paper_id
stringlengths 9
16
| version
stringclasses 26
values | yymm
stringclasses 311
values | created
timestamp[s] | title
stringlengths 6
335
| secondary_subfield
sequencelengths 1
8
| abstract
stringlengths 25
3.93k
| primary_subfield
stringclasses 124
values | field
stringclasses 20
values | fulltext
stringlengths 0
2.84M
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
astro-ph/9512088 | 1 | 9512 | 1995-12-13T16:13:45 | Galaxy formation and evolution: what to expect from hierarchical clustering models | [
"astro-ph"
] | We give a brief review of current theoretical work in galaxy formation. Recent results from N-body and N-body/hydrodynamic simulations, and from semianalytic modelling are discussed. We present updated versions of some figures from Cole et al (1994). In particular, we show the effect of using the revised stellar population synthesis model of Bruzual and Charlot, which results in a much better match to the observed colour distribution of galaxies than before. We also compare the model output with recently available data on the galaxy luminosity function and the redshift distribution of galaxies in the B and K bands. The form of the Tully-Fisher relation at high redshift predicted by our semi-analytic scheme for galaxy formation is given. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Galaxy formation and evolution: what to expect from
hierarchical clustering models
C.S. Frenk, C.M. Baugh and S. Cole
Physics Department, University of Durham, UK
Abstract. We give a brief review of current theoretical work in galaxy
formation. Recent results from N-body and N-body/hydrodynamic sim-
ulations, and from semianalytic modelling are discussed. We present
updated versions of some figures from Cole et al (1994). In particular,
we show the effect of using the revised stellar population synthesis model
of Bruzual and Charlot, which results in a much better match to the
observed colour distribution of galaxies than before. We also compare
the model output with recently available data on the galaxy luminosity
function and the redshift distribution of galaxies in the B and K bands.
The form of the Tully-Fisher relation at high redshift predicted by our
semi-analytic scheme for galaxy formation is given.
1.
Introduction
In hierarchical clustering theories of galaxy formation, galaxies form by gas cool-
ing and condensing into dark matter halos which, in turn, form by a hierarchy
of mergers (White & Rees 1978). The context in which this process takes place
is specified by a cosmological model that determines the spectrum of primordial
density fluctuations and the rate at which they grow by gravitational instability.
The best known example of such a model is the cold dark matter (CDM) model
(see Frenk 1991 for a review), but a number of alternatives (mostly variants of
CDM), have recently become popular in response to new data on large-scale
structure and the COBE detection of anisotropies in the microwave background
radiation. Regardless of the specific cosmological model that one wishes to con-
sider, there are at least six distinct physical processes that need to be included
in any theory of galaxy formation:
• 1. The growth of dark matter halos by accretion and mergers.
• 2. The dynamics of cooling gas.
• 3. Star formation.
• 4. Energy feedback into prestellar gas from the products of stellar evolu-
tion.
• 5. Evolution of the stellar populations that form.
• 6. Galaxy mergers.
1
A number of theoretical tools have been developed over the years to inves-
tigate these processes, both individually and collectively. N-body simulations
have led to significant progress in understanding process (1.), while the recently
developed N-body/hydrodynamic techniques are beginning to address processes
(1-4) and (6). In addition, semianalytic modelling, a relatively new tool, can
treat all six processes together and thus explore the effects of different assump-
tions on the properties of the galaxy population as a whole. In this review, we
will outline some of the areas where progress has been made and highlight some
as yet unresolved issues.
2. Physical processes
2.1. Evolution of dark matter halos
The main features of the formation of dark matter halos by hierarchical cluster-
ing were already established in N-body simulations carried out a decade ago (eg.
Frenk et al. 1985, 1988; Efstathiou et al. 1988). A protohalo perturbation, ini-
tially expanding at a reduced rate, collapses, often into filamentary or sheet-like
structures, which subsequently break up into roughly spherical lumps. These
merge together producing a centrally concentrated and essentially smooth dark
halo. This process is illustrated in Figure 1 which shows the development of a
galactic halo in a flat 'low'-Ω CDM model.
One of the main early results from N-body simulations was the realisation
that the rotation curves of dark galactic halos in the standard CDM model are
approximately flat, suggesting an explanation for the inferred structure of the
halos of spiral galaxies (Frenk et al. 1985, Quinn et al. 1986). These simulations,
however, were limited in particle number and did not resolve the inner regions
of the halos where the visible galaxy actually forms. This issue has recently
been addressed in a series of high-resolution simulations by Navarro, Frenk &
White (1995). The density profiles of galactic halos in the CDM model show
noticeable departures from an r−2 law, gently sloping from r−1 near the centre to
r−3 near the virial radius. When the gravitational effect of a disk is included, the
resulting rotation curves agree well with observations of galaxies, from dwarfs to
bright galaxies, provided the disks fulfill two conditions: (i) their stellar mass-to-
light ratio increases roughly as L1/2 and (ii) the baryon fraction increases with
>200kms−1,
luminosity such that for galaxies with observed circular velocity, Vc∼
there is only a weak of correlation between this velocity and total halo mass. It
is unclear whether the observed disks of spirals satisfy these conditions.
A second important early result concerns the angular momentum of galactic
halos. This is acquired through tidal torques and, in the linear regime grows lin-
early with time (eg White 1995). Tidal effects during merging events efficiently
transfer the angular momentum invested in the orbits of the merging subclumps
into the outer halo and, as a result, the inner parts of merger remnants end up
rotating slowly (Frenk et al. 1985, Barnes & Efstathiou 1987, Cole & Lacey
1995). This non-linear feature has often been invoked as a possible explanation
for the low rotation speeds of elliptical galaxies.
Figure 1.
The formation of a galactic dark matter halo in an N-
body simulation. The left-hand column shows the projected particle
distribution, in comoving coordinates, of a cubical region of present
comoving length 27 Mpc. The right hand column shows, now in phys-
ical coordinates, the growth of the large clump seen in the bottom left
of the region. Each panel on the right hand row has length 3.8 Mpc.
From top to bottom the epochs shown correspond to z = 5, 0.5 and 0.
The parameters of the simulation are: mean density, Ω = 0.3; cosmo-
logical constant, Λ = 0.7; Hubble constant, H0 = 100hkm s−1 Mpc−1,
with h = 0.7; and spectrum normalisation, σ8 = 1.14 (as inferred from
the COBE data). The simulation followed 262144 particles and was
performed the T3D parallel supercomputer at Edinburgh.
2.2. The dynamics of cooling gas
The main ideas here were put forward nearly twenty years ago by Rees & Ostriker
(1977), Silk (1977) and Binney (1977). When a dark matter halo collapses, any
gas admixed with it will also collapse, but whereas the dark matter free streams,
the gas is shock heated. These early papers assumed that shocks would heat up
the gas to the virial temperature of the halo, an assumption verified -- in the
non-radiative limit -- in the N-body/hydrodynamic simulations of Evrard (1990).
These and subsequent simulations (eg. Katz & White 1993, Navarro, Frenk &
White 1995) also showed that, in this limit, the gas acquires a density profile
that closely parallels that of the dark matter. Rees & Ostriker argued that if the
cooling time of virialised gas was shorter than its dynamical time, the gas would
collapse to make a galaxy. White & Rees (1978) recognized, however, that in a
hierarchical model this simple scheme would lead to a cooling catastrophe since
at early times the density is so high that all the gas would cool into subgalactic
lumps where it would presumably turn into stars. This patently did not happen
in the universe - there is still plenty of gas around today. White & Rees solved
this problem by introducing the idea of feedback, whereby the energy released by
supernovae associated with an early generation of stars reheats some of the gas
before it has had a chance to condense into halos at high redshift. (Efstathiou
1992 has argued that photoionisation by a UV background at high redshift would
have a similar effect.)
Testing these simple physical arguments in numerical simulations is difficult
because the propensity of the gas to cool at high density implies that the be-
haviour of the gas is always determined by the resolution limit of the simulation.
This numerical artefact, however, can be turned to advantage if it is loosely in-
terpreted as an effective source of feedback. N-body/hydrodynamic simulations
of representative cosmological volumes in which the gas is allowed to cool are
still at an early stage (eg Katz et al. 1992, Cen & Ostriker 1992, Frenk et al.
1995) and show that the behaviour of the gas is more complex than expected in
the simple analytic picture. Simulations of the formation of individual galaxies
produce disks, often with beautiful spiral arms (e.g. Steinmetz & Muller 1995),
but these disks rotate much too slowly. This is because merger events transfer
angular momentum from gas fragments to the outer dark matter halo in much
the same way as the mergers of collionsless particles do (Navarro, Frenk & White
1995). This angular momentum problem for disks remains a major unresolved
issue in studies of galaxy formation. One possible solution may be, again, to
invoke some form of feedback which might keep the gas hot and allow it to cool
slowly rather to be collected in subclumps.
2.3.
Star formation and feedback
Current understanding of star formation and the attendant feedback, in the
context of galaxy formation, is laughably poor. All that can be done at present
is to try and model these processes in a heuristic fashion. For example, in an
N-body/hydrodynamic simulation one can stipulate a number of conditions for
gas to turn into stars, eg, that it be cool and dense (ie above the Jeans mass)
and that it be inflowing into a halo. Systematic tests of such algorithms are just
beginning (e.g. Navarro & White 1993).
2.4. Galaxy mergers
Simulations of the merging of individual galaxy pairs or small groups have a long
and distinguished history (see for example Barnes (1996)). Such simulations ad-
dress issues such as the structure and rotation properties of merger remnants, or
the gas flows triggered by mergers. From the point of view of galaxy formation
in general, a key issue is the relative timescale for the merging of dark matter
halos and the galaxies they harbour. As a consequence of their higher binding
energy, galaxies take longer to merge than their halos. Furthermore, the simu-
lations show that galaxies (or at any rate the clumps of cool gas identified with
galaxies in the models) merge on a dynamical friction timescale, provided that
the mass that is input into Chandrasekhar's classic formula is the total, gas plus
dark matter, mass of the merging satellite (Navarro, Frenk & White 1995).
3. Semianalytic models
Our understanding of the full range of complex phenomena listed in the Intro-
duction can be approximated by a set of simple rules. These rules can then form
the basis of a semianalytic model for galaxy formation, that follows the collapse
and mergers of dark matter halos and the star formation histories of the galaxies.
Such models (Kauffman et al. 1993, Lacey et al. 1993, Cole et al. 1994) have
been successful in accounting for the general properties of the observed galaxy
distribution, such as the shape of the luminosity function, faint number counts
and colours. However, a number of fundamental problems remain that appear
to suggest that the modelling of the processes (1 - 6) needs to be improved,
rather than altering the choice of cosmology (Heyl et al. 1994).
In the original model of Cole et al. (1994), the model galaxies were not
as red as many observed ellipticals. A study of several stellar population codes
(Charlot et al. 1995) has led to a revision of the Bruzual and Charlot (1993)
models. This has resulted in the model galaxies being typically 0.2 mag redder in
B − K. An updated comparison of the colour distribution of the model galaxies
from Cole et al. with observed colours is given in Figure 2.
The luminosity function of Cole et al. was flatter than that achieved
by other semianalytic models, because of the strong feedback adopted, which
severely restricts star formation in halos of low circular velocity. However, this
model still predicts more faint galaxies than are observed (Loveday et al 1992),
though recent results indicate that the faint end of the luminosity function is still
uncertain (McGaugh 1994, Marzke et al. 1994). A comparison of the luminosity
function predicted by our model with the data of Loveday et al. and Marzke
et al.
is given in Figure 3. The lower panel shows the comparison with the
K-band data of Mobasher et al. (1986) and Glazebrook et al. (1994). Following
Glazebrook et al. , we have corrected the Mobasher et al. magnitudes by +0.22
mag., to compensate for the different k corrections used, and we have applied a
-0.3 correction to Glazebrook et al. 's magnitudes, so that they correspond to
the 40h−1Kpc aperature used by Mobasher et al. .
The Tully-Fisher relation recovered by Cole et al gives a good match to
the observed scatter and slope at zero redshift (see Figure 11 of Cole et al).
However, there is an offset between the observed relation and the prediction of
the model, which suggests that the model galaxies are either too faint by about
Figure 2.
Histograms of B-K colour distributions for various ranges
of B absolute magnitude. The broken lines are data from Mobasher
et al. (1986) and show the observed number of galaxies in the data
set. The model output is shown by the solid lines which have been
normalised to enclose the same area as the data.
The luminosity function of our model (solid line) compared
Figure 3.
with the B-band data of Loveday et al.
(1992) and Marzke et al.
(1994).We have normalised the model to match the knee of the B-band
luminosity function. The lower panel shows the comparison with the
K-band data of Mobasher et al. (1986) and Glazebrook et al. (1994).
Figure 4.
The Tully-Fisher relation predicted by our model as a
function of redshift. The solid line shows the median magnitude in
bins of circular velocity at z = 0; the dashed lines show the 20 and 80th
percentiles. The points show the median and the errorbars show the
location of the percentiles at z = 0.5.
Figure 5.
The redshift distribution of model galaxies compared with
new data for K and B-band selected samples of Glazebrook et al.
1995a,b. The histograms show the observed distributions and the
curves show the model galaxy redshifts. The K band data consists
of 124 redshifts for galaxies with K < 17.3 and is weighted for incom-
pleteness. The B band sample is 70% complete and contains 70 galaxies
with 22.5 < B < 24.
Figure 6.
The median redshift as a function of limiting apparent
magnitude in the B and K bands. The open points show the predictions
of our semi-analytic model.
1.5 mag or are in halos that have a circular velocity that is ∼ 60% too high.
This can be traced back to an overproduction in CDM-like cosmologies of halos
typical of those that contain luminous galaxies.
Both the Tully-Fisher and luminosity function problems could be related
to surface brightness effects. We plan to incorporate a scale length into the
models, allowing us to select only those galaxies above some surface brightness
threshold.
Figure 4 shows the evolution of the Tully-Fisher relation predicted by our
model. The solid line shows the median magnitude in bins of circular velocity
at z = 0. The dashed lines show the location of the 20th and 80th percentiles.
The points show the position of the median magnitude as a function of circular
velocity at redshift z = 0.5; the errorbars here indicate the location of the 20
and 80th percentiles.
We also present an updated version of the redshift distributions predicted
by the model of Cole et al. Figure 5 compares the model predictions with the
recent redshift survey data of Glazebrook et al.
(1995a,b). The model and
observed distributions are in very good agreement. We plot the median redshift
as a function of limiting apparent magnitude in Figure 6. The predictions of our
model agree well with the faint redshift data currently available.
We have extended the model to split the light of each galaxy up into a bulge
and a disk component. Stars are formed in a disk when gas is accreted from the
dark matter halo. Bulges are formed in violent merger events, which destroy
the disks of the progenitors and are accompanied by a burst of star formation.
This allows us to make a broad morphological classification of our galaxies and
make predictions of galaxy properties as a function of bulge to disk luminosity
ratio. We set the parameters that define the strength of a merger event and the
bulge to disk ratios that distinguish between different morphological types by
requiring that our model reproduces the local morphological mix. We are then
able predict the mean colour and scatter in colour for different morphological
classes in different environments, the mix of types in different environments as
a function of redshift and the faint counts for the various galaxy types. We
find good agreement with the faint HST counts of Glazebrook et al. (1995c)
and recover the type of evolution in cluster membership reported by Butcher &
Oemler (1978) (Baugh et al. 1995).
References
Barnes, J., 1996, to appear in the proceedings of IAU 171, "New Light
on Galaxy Evolution" eds., Bender, R., Davies, R.L., (Kluwer)
Barnes, J., Efstathiou, G., 1987, Ap.J, 319, 575
Baugh, C.M., Cole, S., Frenk, C.S., 1995, M.N.R.A.S, submitted
Binney, J.J., 1977, Ap.J, 215, 483
Bruzual, G., Charlot, S., 1993, Ap.J, 405, 538
Butcher, H., Oemler, A., 1978, Ap.J, 219, 18
Cen, R., Ostriker, J.P., 1992, Ap.J, 339, 331
Charlot, S., Worthey, G., Bressan, A., 1995 Ap.J, in press
Cole, S., Lacey, C.G., 1995 M.N.R.A.S, submitted
Cole, S., Aragon-Salamanca, A., Frenk, C.S., Navarro, J., Zepf, S., 1994,
M.N.R.A.S, 271, 781
Colless, M.M., Ellis, R.S., Taylor, K., Hook, R.N., 1990, M.N.R.A.S, 244, 408
Colless, M.M., Ellis, R.S., Broadhurst T., Taylor, K., Peterson, B.A.,
1993, M.N.R.A.S, 261, 19
Efstathiou, G. 1992, M.N.R.A.S, 256, 43p
Efstathiou, G., Frenk, C.S., White, S.D.M., Davis, M., 1988, M.N.R.A.S,
235, 715.
Evrard, A.E. 1990, Ap.J., 363, 349.
Frenk, C.S. 1991, in The Birth and Early Evolution of our Universe, Nobel
Symp. No 79, eds J.S. Nilsson, et al. , World Sci., Physica Scripta, T36, 70.
Frenk, C.S., White, S.D.M., Efstathiou, G., Davis, M., 1985, Nature, 317, 595.
Frenk, C.S., White, S.D.M., Efstathiou, G., Davis, M., 1988, Ap.J., 327, 507.
Glazebrook, K., Peacock, J.A., Collins, C.A., Miller, L., 1994, M.N.R.A.S,
266, 65
Glazebrook, K., Peacock, J.A., Miller, L., Collins, C.A., 1995a, M.N.R.A.S,
275, 169
Glazebrook, K., Ellis, R., Colless, M., Broadhurst, T., Allington-Smith, J.,
Tanvir, N., 1995b, M.N.R.A.S, 273, 157
Glazebrook, K., Ellis, R., Santiago, B., Griffiths, R., 1995c,
M.N.R.A.S, 275, L19
Heyl, J.S., Cole, S., Frenk, C.S., Navarro, J., 1995, M.N.R.A.S, 274, 755
Katz, N., Hernquist, L., Weinberg, D.H., 1992, Ap.J, 399, L109
Katz, N., White, S.D.M., 1993, Ap.J, 412, 455
Kauffmann, G., White, S.D.M., Guiderdoni, B., 1993, M.N.R.A.S, 264, 201
Lacey, C.G., Guiderdoni, B., Rocca-Volmerange, B., Silk, J., 1993, Ap.J,
402,15
Loveday, J., Peterson, B.A., Efstathiou, G., Maddox, S.J., 1992, Ap.J, 390, 338
McGaugh, S., 1994, Nature, 367, 538
Marzke, R.O., Geller, M.J., Huchra, J.P., Corwin, H.G., 1994, A.J., 108, 437
Mobasher, B., Sharples, R.M., Ellis, 1986, M.N.R.A.S, 223, 11
Navarro, J.F., White, S.D.M., 1993, M.N.R.A.S, 265, 271
Navarro, J.F., Frenk, C.S., White, S.D.M., 1995, M.N.R.A.S, in press
Rees, M.J., Ostriker, J.P., 1977, M.N.R.A.S, 179, 541
Silk, J., 1977 Ap.J, 211, 638
Songaila, A., Cowie, L.L., Hu, E.M., Gardner, J.P., 1994,
Ap. J. Suppl., 94, 461
Steinmetz, M., Muller, E., 1995, M.N.R.A.S, 276, 549
Quinn, P.J., Salmon, J.K. and Zurek, W. 1986, Nature, 322, 329.
White, S.D.M., 1995, Les Houches Lecture Notes
White, S.D.M., Rees, M.J. 1978, M.N.R.A.S, 183, 341.
Young, P., Lucey, J.L., 1995, in preparation
|
astro-ph/0511739 | 1 | 0511 | 2005-11-25T22:29:06 | Angular Momentum Transport by Gravity Waves in the Solar Interior | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present self-consistent numerical simulations of the sun's convection zone and radiative interior using a two-dimensional model of its equatorial plane. The background reference state is a one-dimensional solar structure model. Turbulent convection in the outer convection zone continually excites gravity waves which propagate throughout the stable radiative interior and deposit their angular momentum. We find that angular velocity variations in the tachocline are driven by angular momentum transported by overshooting convective plumes rather than the nonlinear interaction of waves. The mean flow in the tachocline is time dependent but not oscillatory in direction. Since the forcing in this shallow region can not be described by simple linear waves, it is unlikely that the interaction of such waves is responsible for the solar cycle or the 1.3 year oscillation. However, in the deep radiative interior, the interaction of low amplitude gravity waves, continually excited by the overshooting plumes, is responsible for the angular velocity deviations observed there. Near the center of the model sun the angular velocity deviation is about two orders of magnitude greater than that in the bulk of the radiative region and reverses its direction (prograde to retrograde or vice versa) in the opposite sense of the angular velocity deviations that occur in the tachocline. Our simulations thus demonstrate how angular velocity variations in the solar core are linked to those in the tachocline, which themselves are driven by convective overshooting. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Angular Momentum Transport by Gravity waves in the Solar
Interior
Tamara M. Rogers
Astronomy and Astrophysics Department, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064
[email protected]
Gary A. Glatzmaier
Earth Sciences Department, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064
ABSTRACT
We present self-consistent numerical simulations of the sun's convection zone
and radiative interior using a two-dimensional model of its equatorial plane. The
background reference state is a one-dimensional solar structure model. Turbulent
convection in the outer convection zone continually excites gravity waves which
propagate throughout the stable radiative interior and deposit their angular mo-
mentum. We find that angular velocity variations in the tachocline are driven by
angular momentum transported by overshooting convective plumes rather than
the nonlinear interaction of waves. The mean flow in the tachocline is time de-
pendent but not oscillatory in direction. Since the forcing in this shallow region
can not be described by simple linear waves, it is unlikely that the interaction of
such waves is responsible for the solar cycle or the 1.3 year oscillation. However,
in the deep radiative interior, the interaction of low amplitude gravity waves,
continually excited by the overshooting plumes, is responsible for the angular
velocity deviations observed there. Near the center of the model sun the angular
velocity deviation is about two orders of magnitude greater than that in the bulk
of the radiative region and reverses its direction (prograde to retrograde or vice
versa) in the opposite sense of the angular velocity deviations that occur in the
tachocline. Our simulations thus demonstrate how angular velocity variations in
the solar core are linked to those in the tachocline, which themselves are driven
by convective overshooting.
Subject headings: convection: overshoot,mixing, internal gravity waves, solar
interior
-- 2 --
1.
Introduction
Internal gravity waves are ubiquitous in nature. Their influence can be observed in
striated cloud structures in our own atmosphere many days of the year.
In addition to
the visual display of these waves in our atmosphere, they have several other more profound
consequences. The interaction of gravity waves with angular velocity shear produces the
quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO), which dominates variability in the equatorial stratosphere
and affects ozone levels.
Gravity waves have been invoked to explain several physical problems in the sun's in-
terior such as: (1) providing the extra mixing required to solve the Li depletion problem
(Garcia-Lopez & Spruit 1991) (2) increasing turbulent mixing and affecting the solar neu-
trino production (Press 1981), (3) maintaining the solid body rotation of the sun's radiative
interior (Schatzman 1993, Kumar & Quataert 1997) (4) and controlling the solar cycle (Ku-
mar, Talon & Zahn 1999). They have also been used to explain the orbital properties of
binary star systems (Terquem et al. 1998). These theories, however, are only as good as the
poorly understood excitation and evolution of gravity waves in stellar interiors. What grav-
ity wave spectra and amplitudes are generated? How effectively do gravity waves transport
angular momentum and mix species?
Some confusion has existed. For example, although gravity waves were postulated to
extract angular momentum from the solar radiative interior and so enforce solid body rotation
(Schatzman 1993, Kumar & Quataert 1997), it was quickly pointed out (Gough & McIntyre
1998, Ringot 1998) that gravity waves tend to enhance local shear rather than smooth it.
Recognizing this anti-diffusive nature of gravity waves in shear flows, several authors
published papers postulating an angular velocity oscillation at the base of the solar convection
zone analogous to the quasi-biennial oscillation (QBO) in the Earth's stratosphere (Baldwin
et al. 2001).
In one paper (Kumar, Talon & Zahn 1999), a spectrum of gravity waves
generated by the overlying convection is prescribed (Goldreich et al. 1994). This spectrum
is then integrated to give a flux of angular momentum that is transferred from the waves
to the mean flow, resulting in a periodic oscillation of angular velocity at the base of the
convection zone with a timescale of about 20 years. In another paper (Kim & MacGregor
2001), a two wave model is assumed: one prograde propagating wave, with a prescribed
angular momentum flux, and one retrograde wave with another (negative) prescribed flux.
In addition, these authors include viscous dissipation in the evolution equation for the mean
flow and find that the nature of the resulting angular velocity oscillation depends sensitively
on the value of the assumed viscous diffusivity. For large viscous diffusivity, a steady solution
is found; whereas for small values a chaotic oscillation is found. A periodic solution is
recovered only for intermediate values of the viscous diffusivity.
-- 3 --
More recently, the Kumar, Talon & Zahn (1999) model has been extended to show that
the oscillating shear layer at the base of the convection zone acts as a filter on the low fre-
quency, short wavelength waves (Talon, Kumar & Zahn 2002, Talon & Charbonnel 2005).
In their theory, the filter preferentially damps prograde waves, allowing predominantly ret-
rograde waves, which carry negative angular momentum, into the deep interior. When these
waves dissipate they transfer their negative angular momentum to the flow and therefore
effectively extract prograde angular momentum from the low-latitude deep solar interior,
leading to solid body rotation in the solar radiative zone.
The major shortcoming of both of these models is twofold. First, neither model self-
consistently calculates the generation of the gravity waves by the solar convection zone. In
Kumar, Talon & Zahn (1999) a spectrum and amplitude of gravity waves is assumed, a
spectrum that is unfortunately, untestable with observations and has not been reproduced
in numerical simulations. In addition, this spectrum neglects the main production of gravity
waves due to overshooting plumes. Second, and perhaps more importantly, neither model
calculates the nonlinear wave-wave interactions which provide this "flux" of angular mo-
mentum. Rather than parameterizing the nonlinear interaction of waves as a prescribed
flux (Kumar, Talon & Zahn 1999 and subsequent papers, Kim & MacGregor 2001), this
interaction should be self-consistently calculated.
Here we present numerical simulations that address both of these issues. Our model
solves the fully nonlinear Navier-Stokes equations in both the convective and radiative re-
gions. Therefore, the gravity waves are self-consistently generated by an overlying convection
zone and the nonlinear terms are retained in the radiation zone to account for the nonlinear
wave interactions which affect the mean flow.
2. Wave - shear flow interactions
In this section we briefly review the hydrodynamic process by which waves can transport
their angular momentum to the flow in which they travel. The natural example of this process
is the QBO. For a more complete discussion of the QBO see, for example, Baldwin et al.
2001, Lindzen (1990) and Holton (1994).
For simplicity consider the Boussinesq equations for a viscous fluid in two dimensional
cartesian (x-z) coordinates, x being the horizontal coordinate and z the vertical coordinate.
After decomposing the horizontal velocity into mean flow (U , a function of z) and fluctu-
ating (u') components and taking the proper horizontal average, the equation for the mean
horizontal velocity becomes:
-- 4 --
∂U
∂t
= −
∂u′w′
∂z
+ ν
∂2U
∂2z
(1)
In (1), u′ represents the fluctuating horizontal velocity and w′ represents the fluctuating
vertical velocity. This equation represents how small scale wave-wave interactions (Reynolds
stresses) influence the mean flow (U). The vertically propagating waves carry horizontal
momentum vertically. Eliassen & Palm (1961) showed that (in this simplified model with
no viscosity) the first term on the right hand side of (1) is zero unless there is some wave
attenuation (such as radiative damping or critical layers). Therefore, in the absence of wave
attenuation, there is no transfer of angular momentum between the mean flow, U , and the
Reynolds stresses. In the sun the proposed mechanism for wave attenuation is via radiative
diffusion, while in the Earth the process is likely wave breaking.
In the presence of differential rotation the picture becomes more complicated.
In a
rotating fluid, waves generated at a particular frequency are doppler shifted away from that
frequency according to the equation:
ω(r) = ωgen + m(Ωgen − Ω(r))
(2)
where m is the horizontal wave number, ωgen is the frequency at which the wave is generated
in the frame rotating at Ωgen and ω(r) is the frequency measured relative to the local rotation
rate, Ω(r).
Where Ω(r) > Ωgen prograde waves (m > 0) are shifted to lower frequencies and retro-
grade waves (m < 0) are shifted to higher frequencies. Since radiative damping is strongly
frequency dependent (damping length ∝ ω4), prograde (lower frequency) waves are damped
in a shorter distance than retrograde (higher frequency) waves. This differential damping
causes prograde waves to deposit their (positive) angular momentum closer to the genera-
tion site than retrograde waves deposit their (negative) angular momentum, thus leading to
a shear layer. As prograde (retrograde) waves continually deposit their positive (negative)
angular momentum, the angular velocity amplitude and gradient continually increase. This
increased angular velocity causes prograde waves to be shifted to ever smaller frequencies
which are damped even closer to the generation site. In this way the peak in the prograde
layer moves toward the source of the waves. When the prograde shear becomes sufficiently
steep, it is broken down by viscous diffusion, leaving behind the retrograde layer. This pro-
cess repeats, with the period of the process inversely proportional to the wave forcing. The
prominent features of this physical process are then twofold: (1) prograde flow lies above
retrograde motion (or vice versa) and (2) this pattern propagates toward the generation site.
This physical picture was proposed initially by Lindzen & Holton (1968) and Holton
& Lindzen (1972) to explain the QBO observed in the Earth's atmosphere. Later, the
-- 5 --
physical theory was tested in the remarkable experiment by Plumb & McEwan 1978 and
the basic physical mechanism was recovered. It has also been suggested that an oscillation
similar to the QBO occurs in Jupiter's atmosphere (Leovy et al. 1991) and is coined the
quasi-quadrennial oscillation (QQO) because of its four year period.
The robustness of this mechanism led astronomers to hypothesize that the same physical
mechanism could be operating in the solar tachocline (Kumar, Talon & Zahn 1999, Kim &
MacGregor 2001, Talon & Charbonnel 2005). This could then provide a handsome explana-
tion for oscillations at the base of the convection zone, whether on 20 year timescales (as in
the dynamo, Kumar, Talon & Zahn 1999) or 1 year timescales (as in the 1.3 year oscillation,
Kim & MacGregor 2001). We have reviewed this mechanism here so comparisons between
this process and the zonal flow oscillations seen in the radiative region of our model can be
clearly made.
3. Numerical Model
The numerical technique and model setup are identical to those in Rogers & Glatzmaier
2005, except here we impose the equatorial rotation profile as a function of radius as inferred
from helioseismology (Ω(r) is specified to be 465nHz in the convection zone, 435nHz in the
stable region and the tachocline is fit to an error function). We solve the Navier-Stokes
equations with rotation in the anelastic approximation in 2D cylindrical geometry (r,φ).
The curl of the momentum equation, i.e., vorticity equation, is:
∂ω
∂t
+ (~v · ~∇)ω = (2Ω(r) + ω)hρvr − 2vr
∂Ω(r)
∂r
−
g
T r
∂T
∂θ
−
1
ρT r
∂T
∂r
∂p
∂θ
+ ν∇2ω
(3)
The heat equation is:
∂T
∂t
+ (~v · ∇)T = −vr(
∂T
∂r
∂T
∂r
− (γ − 1)T hρ) + (γ − 1)T hρvr+
γκ[∇2T + (hρ + hκ)
] + γκ[∇2T + (hρ + hκ)
∂T
∂r
] +
Q
cv
(4)
In these equations, ~v is the velocity, with radial, vr, and longitudinal, vθ, components.
The vorticity is ~ω = ~∇ × ~v and is normal to the equatorial plane in this 2D geometry. The
functions hρ = dlnρ/dr, hκ = dlnκ/dr, g (gravity), T (temperature), ρ (density) and γ
(ratio of specific heats, cp/cv) are radially dependent and taken from the solar model. T is
the temperature perturbation and p is the pressure perturbation, which like ω, are functions
of r, θ and time (t).
-- 6 --
In our model we specify the thermal diffusivity as that given by the solar model, mul-
tiplied by a constant for numerical stability:
κ = kapmult ∗
3
16σT
3ρ2kcp
(5)
here kapmult is generally set to 105, σ is the Stefan-Boltzman constant and k is the opacity.
The viscous diffusivity, ν = µ/ρ, is set so that the dynamic viscosity (µ) is constant.
We calculate the pressure term in (3) using the longitudinal component of the momen-
tum equation:
1
ρr
∂p
∂θ
= −
∂vθ
∂t
− (~v · ~∇~v)θ + ν[(∇2~v)θ −
hρ
3r
∂vr
∂θ
].
(6)
These equations are supplemented by the continuity equation in the anelastic approximation
∇ · ρ~v = 0
(7)
which is satisfied by expressing ρ~v as the curl of a streamfunction. The model extends from
.001R⊙ to 0.93R⊙. The subadiabaticity in the radiative region is given by the solar model
and we specify the superadiabaticity in the convection zone to be 10−7.
These equations are solved using a Fourier spectral transform method in the longitudinal
(θ) direction and a finite difference scheme on a non-uniform grid in the radial (r) direction.
Time advancing is done using the explicit Adams-Bashforth method for the nonlinear terms
and an implicit Crank-Nicolson scheme for the linear terms. The boundaries are impermeable
and stress-free. The inner boundary is isothermal and the outer boundary is held at a
constant heat flux. This code is parallelized using message passing interface (MPI) and the
resolution is 2048 longitudinal zones x 1500 radial zones, with 620 radial zones dedicated to
the radiative region. In the region just below the convection zone the radial resolution is
170km. This model was evolved for 1 simulated year, requiring nearly six million 5 second
timesteps.
4. Convection zone and Tachocline
4.1. Angular Velocity Variations
Helioseismic observations indicate that, in the equatorial plane, the convection zone
spins faster than the radiative interior. The maintenance of differential rotation within the
equatorial plane of the convection zone is a 3D process involving the transport of angular
momentum in both radius and latitude and the Coriolis forces resulting from axisymmetric
-- 7 --
meridional circulation. Since our 2D geometry captures only the transport in radius, we can
not expect to achieve a realistic differential rotation profile with the 2D model. Therefore,
we impose the observed equatorial angular velocity as a function of radius in our model.
As mentioned above, the background angular velocity is set to a constant 465nHz in the
convection zone and to a constant 435nHz in the radiation zone; we prescribe a smooth fit
between these two values through the thin tachocline shear layer. The resulting gravity wave
spectrum and angular momentum transport is then investigated.
The time series of angular velocity, Ω′(r, t), relative to the prescribed background an-
gular velocity, Ω(r), for this model is shown in Figure 1 over one simulated year. As seen
in this figure, angular velocity in the convection zone is initially prograde, relative to the
prescribed Ω(r), in the lower part of the convection zone and retrograde motion in the upper
part. However, after the initial period, angular velocity becomes very time dependent and
is dominantly retrograde in the lower part of the convection zone and prograde in the upper
part. This profile is expected, given the density stratification and rotation of the solar inte-
rior (Glatzmaier et al. 2005). Intermittently prograde motion from the top of the convection
zone will extend to the base of the convection zone and overshoot into the tachocline. The
angular velocity variations produced by these motions vary in amplitude between +/- 15nHz,
slightly larger than the amplitudes of the observed 1.3 year oscillation (Howe et al. 2001).
Figure 1a clearly shows that the angular velocity of the tachocline mimics the behavior in
the lower part of the convection zone; when the lower part is prograde, the tachocline is
prograde and vice versa. This indicates that the behavior of the tachocline is dictated by
convection zone dynamics, rather than by gravity waves (see below).
In the overshoot region fluid motions are strongly nonlinear (Rogers & Glatzmaier
2005b). Figure 2 shows the ratio of the horizontal fluid velocity to the horizontal phase
speed (the Froude number) for a typical frequency and wavenumber (20µHz, l=10); this
provides a measure of the nonlinearity of waves. For linear waves ux/cx << 1. However,
as is clearly seen in the figure this criterion does not hold just below the convection zone.
While only one ratio is shown as a function of radius, this can vary by an order of magnitude
depending on the choice of frequency and wavenumber.1 However, using reasonable values
for frequency and wavenumber, the smallest value of this ratio just below the convection
zone is 0.1, still far from meeting the linearity criterion above. Furthermore, it is clear in
this figure that linearization may not be justified in the solar core either, as suggested by
Press (1981).
1For larger (smaller) values of horizontal wave mode number this ratio is larger (smaller). Similarly, for
larger (smaller) frequencies this ratio is smaller (larger).
-- 8 --
4.2. Reynolds and Viscous Stresses
The mean zonal flow is determined by a balance between viscous and Reynolds stresses
(as seen in equation (1)).
In order to better understand the angular velocity profile in
time (as shown in Figure 1) we examine the sources of that balance. Figure 3 shows the
horizontally averaged convergence of Reynolds stress (first term on the right hand side of
(1), but now in cylindrical coordinates), the viscous stress (second term on the right hand
side of (1), in cylindrical coordinates) and the sum of these (the time rate of change of the
mean zonal flow U ) in both the convection zone and overshoot region over five days.
In the model's convection zone, the Reynolds stresses are much larger than the viscous
stresses. The pattern of Reynolds stress convergence has a semi-periodic behavior with
disturbances propagating up and down from a radius near 1/3dcz (dcz is the convection
zone depth). When positive (i.e., prograde) Reynolds stress convergence moves upward
from this radius a negative value moves downward and vice versa. This process reverses
with a frequency similar to the convective turnover frequency, roughly 10 times the inertial
wave frequency. This oscillatory behavior is observed in our simulations only when we
include a radiative region beneath the convection zone; we do not see it when we impose an
impermeable lower boundary on the convection zone. Note also that this radius of 1/3dcz is
approximately where vθ for the large eddies changes sign and below which smaller, counter-
rotating cells exist. Figure 4 shows a zoomed-in region of the convection zone, displaying
the vorticity within a few convective cells. Beneath the large cells spanning most of the
convection zone is counter-rotating fluid that is driven by the plumes penetrating slightly
into the stable overshoot region. As a plume rebounds it is diverted laterally and counter-
rotating eddies are generated. It remains to be seen how these counter-rotating cells affect
tachocline dynamics in a 3D simulation.
Now consider the overshoot region in our model. Regions with positive (negative)
Reynolds stress convergence in the lower convection zone correspond to the same signed
disturbances in the overshoot region. These disturbances have a slight tendency to prop-
agate downward, i.e., away from their source in the convection zone. When viscous terms
are added (which in the overshoot region have magnitudes similar to the Reynolds stress
terms) disturbances clearly propagate away from the convection zone (Fig. 3). This motion
away from the convection zone 2 is also seen in Figure 1. The semi-periodic oscillations
observed in ∂U /∂t affects only the amplitude of U, but not the direction. That is, the
semi-periodic oscillation seen ∂U /∂t is not realized in U because of a slight asymmetry in
the driving amplitude of prograde and retrograde motions. If, as has been assumed in the
2However, even if diffusion were neglected the disturbances do not move upward as in the QBO.
-- 9 --
past (Kumar, Talon & Zahn 1999, Kim & MacGregor), these motions were produced with
equivalent amplitudes, the semi-periodic oscillation observed in ∂U /∂t would be reproduced
in U, however, that is not the case here.
Given the above results it is clear that overshooting plumes themselves transport angular
momentum in a way which is distinct from the nonlinear interaction of low amplitude waves.
The main properties of a wave driven oscillation (motion in time toward the source, timescales
different than the forcing timescales, and a double peaked layer) are not seen here. Therefore,
given the link between Reynolds stresses in the convection zone and those in the tachocline,
it is clear that the overshooting plumes provide the main transfer of angular momentum to
the tachocline. These plumes are buoyantly braked, radiatively damped and the nonlinearity
allows for mode-mode transfer which affects the damping rate. Furthermore, the momentum
transport by these plumes is time dependent and complex. Their effects need to be included
when considering the dynamics of the tachocline and their influence should not be treated
simply as an increased flux in linear waves. In fact, the linear approximation of waves is not
justified in the overshoot region and tachocline.
5. The Deep Interior and Core
A banded radial differential rotation profile is observed deep within the radiative interior
(Figure 5); however, the amplitude of the angular velocity variation is extremely low (0.02
nHz) relative to what it is in the convection zone. This radial shear grows in time (Figure 6)
due to wave-wave interactions which enforce shear. However, there is some indication that
the growth is slowing and possibly reversing (Figure 6) due to increased viscous diffusion
as angular velocity gradients increase. The banded differential rotation is due to the broad
spectrum of frequencies generated and their continual deposition of angular momentum due
to radiative diffusion as they propagate. Banded differential rotation in the sun's radiative
interior has not been inferred from helioseismology, possibly because the amplitude is too
low, or because these small amplitude disturbances are easily neutralized in 3D. In the core
of our model the amplitude of the angular velocity variation is 2-3 orders of magnitude
higher than in the bulk of the radiative interior. This indicates that angular momentum
transport from waves to zonal flow is more efficient in the core, which could be due to
a number of factors, including: wave breaking, critical layers (where the phase speed of
the wave approaches the mean rotation rate) or inefficient reflection as the wave frequency
approaches the Brunt-Vaisala frequency. Discerning which of these processes is dominant in
this region is extremely difficult when a large spectrum of waves is continually being excited
and is beyond the scope of this paper.
-- 10 --
Maxima in the convergence of Reynolds stress deep within the radiative interior (but
a significant distance below the overshoot region) propagate upward (Figure 7) as expected
from the nonlinear interaction of low amplitude waves. In addition, significant interference
is seen in the lower radiation zone, which likely comes from the interaction of inward prop-
agating and outward reflected waves. While we have not observed a complete reversal of
the angular velocity in the bulk of the radiative region, there is some evidence that one is
underway (Figure 6)3. In the core the mean angular velocity switches from retrograde to
prograde at nearly the same time as the tachocline switches from prograde to retrograde.
This suggests that the angular velocity of the core is linked to the angular velocity of the
tachocline and hence, of the convection zone. The link between tachocline angular velocity
and that of the core due to selective filtering has been elucidated previously in Talon, Kumar
& Zahn 2002. Here we make the link between the tachocline and the convection zone and
propose that a self-consistent study of differential rotation in the sun must not treat the
radiative and convective regions separately.
6. Discussion
Despite some similarity between the convective-radiative interface in the sun and the
Earth's tropopause, there are several obvious differences. In the sun, convection is constantly
driving gravity waves everywhere below the overshoot region; whereas the generation of large-
amplitude gravity waves in the Earth's atmosphere is intermittent in time and space. Solar
gravity waves travel down into a converging region of increasing density (and therefore, have
very little chance of breaking); whereas in the Earth waves travel up into an expanding region
of decreasing density. Furthermore, previous numerical simulations of convective penetration
in a stratified atmosphere demonstrate a remarkable difference between penetration into an
overlying stable region and penetration into an underlying stable region (Hurlburt, Toomre
& Massaguer 1986). Penetration into an underlying stable region is characterized by thin
localized downflows; whereas penetration into an overlying stable region is characterized by
larger scale broad upflows. This asymmetry allows descending plumes to travel farther into
an underlying stable region than ascending motions travel into an overlying stable region.
Therefore, it is likely that penetrative convection plays a more crucial role at the base of
the solar convection zone than it does at the Earth's tropopause. These differences can have
profound effects on the role of overshoot and, hence, on the scale, frequency and amplitude
of the waves generated and, so, on the angular momentum transport by these waves.
3It appears that in the deep interior a QBO-like oscillation is possible
-- 11 --
Numerical simulations (Wedi & Smolarkiewicz 2005) of the Plumb-McEwan laboratory
experiment attempting to reproduce the QBO, have shown that the type and period of an
oscillation in the differential rotation profile depend sensitively on the forcing. In particular,
it is found that random forcing rarely produces a periodic oscillation. Given the turbulent
nature of the sun, it is likely that the forcing is fairly random.
For reasons stated above, it is unlikely that there is a QBO-like oscillation associated
with the solar tachcocline. However, QBO-like oscillations may occur in stars with radiative
envelopes because of the inefficiency of overshoot into an overlying stable region, and because
of more similar geometry.
7. Conclusions
We have presented self-consistent numerical simulations of convective overshoot and
gravity wave generation and the angular momentum transport by these processes in a 2D
model of the dynamics in the solar equatorial plane. We find that angular velocity variations
in the tachocline are driven by angular momentum transported by overshooting plumes rather
than nonlinear interaction of low amplitude waves. These overshooting plumes are strongly
nonlinear disturbances, which can not be accurately represented as an increased flux of linear
waves. We observe a semi-periodic oscillation in amplitude, but not in direction, of the mean
flow in the tachocline because of an asymmetry in the driving of prograde and retrograde
motions. Since we find that linear gravity waves are not dominant in the tachocline it is
unlikely that they are responsible for the 1.3 year oscillation or the 11 year solar cycle. It is
no surprise that overshooting motions play a dominant role in the tachocline and we expect
these results will persist in three-dimensions.
In the deep radiative interior the continual deposition of angular momentum by the
nonlinear interaction of gravity waves produces a radially banded differential rotation. How-
ever, it remains to be seen whether this pattern persists in 3D, considering it's very low
amplitude. In the model's core, the amplitude of the differential rotation (i.e., angular ve-
locity) is larger, about two orders of magnitude larger than that in the bulk of the radiative
region and similar to the magnitude within the convection zone. We observe retrograde
motion in the core reversing to prograde motion in step with the counter-reversal (prograde
to retrograde) at the tachocline. When there is predominantly prograde flow at the base of
the convection zone it selectively filters out prograde propagating gravity waves, allowing
predominantly retrograde waves to propagate to the core where they deposit their (negative)
angular momentum, and vice versa (Talon, Kumar & Zahn 2002). Like previous results our
simulations therefore suggest that the angular velocity variations in the solar core are linked
-- 12 --
to those in the tachocline. However, unlike previous results we show here that the variations
in the tachocline are driven by convective overshooting, therefore, linking core rotation to
convective motions.
We thank K. MacGregor, J. Christensen-Dalsgaard, D. Gough, C. Jones, P. Garaud
and M. Metchnik for helpful discussions and guidance. T.R. would like to thank the NPSC
for a graduate student fellowship and the Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge University for
a travel grant. Support has also been provided by the DOE SciDAC program DE-FC02-
01ER41176, the NASA Solar and Heliospheric Program SHP04-0022-0123 and the UCSC
Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics. Computing resources were provided by NAS
at NASA Ames and by the NSF MRI grant AST-0079757.
Baldwin, M.P., Gray, L.J., Dunkerton, K.Hamilton, Haynes, P.H., Randel, W.J., Holton,
REFERENCES
J.R. et al. 2001, Rev. Geophysics, 39, 179
Eliassen, A. and Palm, E. 1961 Geofysiske Publ., 22, 1
Garcia-Lopez, R.J., Spruit, H. 1991, ApJ, 377, 268
latzmaier, G.A., Evonuk, M. and Rogers, T.M. 2005, Nature, under review
Gough, D.O., McIntyre, M.E. 1998, Nature, 394, 755
Howe, R., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Hill, F., Komm, R.W., Larsen, R.M., Schou, J.,
Thompson, M.J., and Toomre, J. 2001, Science, 287, 2456
Holton, J.R., An Introduction to Dynamic Meteorology, 4th edition, Elsevier Academic Press,
1994
Hurlburt, N.E., Toomre, J. and Massaguer, J.M. 1986, ApJ, 311, 563
Kim, E., MacGregor, K.B. 2001, ApJ556, L117
Kumar, P., Quataert, E. 1997, ApJ, 475, L143
Kumar, P., Talon, S., Zahn, J.P. 1999, ApJ, 520, 859
Leovy,C.B., Friedson, A.J., Orton, G.S. 1991 Nature, 354, 380
Lindzen, R.S., Dynamics in Atmospheric Physics, Cambridge University Press, 1990
-- 13 --
Plumb, R.A., McEwan, A.D. 1978, J. Atmos. Sci, 35, 1827
Press, W.H. 1981, ApJ, 245, 286
Ringot, O. 1998, A&A, 335, L89
Rogers, T.M., Glatzmaier, G.A. 2005, MNRAS, in press
Schatzman, E. 1993 A&A, 279, 431
Talon, S., Kumar, P., Zahn, J.P. 2002, ApJ, 574, 175
Talon, S., Charbonnel, C. 2005, A&A, 440, 981
Wedi, N.P., Smolarkiewicz, P.K., 2005, JAS, submitted
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 14 --
Fig. 1. -- Top: Angular velocity variations, relative to the prescribed solar profile, as a func-
tion of time and radius. Red represents prograde motion, while blue represents retrograde
motion. Black line represents the convective-radiative interface. Variations are shown in
nHz. Bottom: Angular velocity variation as a function of time at the convective-radiative
interface. Dotted line represents zero fluctuation about the mean.
-- 15 --
Fig. 2. -- The ratio of fluid velocities to the phase velocity (for a typical frequency and
wavenumber), also known as the Froude number, a measure of the nonlinearity of the waves.
This figure shows that motions are clearly nonlinear, both in the tachocline and the core.
-- 16 --
Fig. 3. -- Convergence of the Reynolds stress, Viscous stress and the sum, ∂U /∂t, over a
five-day period in both the convection zone (top) and overshoot region (bottom). A semi-
periodic oscillation is seen both in the convection zone and overshoot region. This oscillation
causes an oscillation in the amplitude (but not direction) of the mean zonal flow seen in Fig.
-- 17 --
Fig. 4. -- Zoom in of vorticity in the convection zone. Large cells span the bulk of the con-
vection zone with counter-rotating cells beneath due to the deflection of descending plumes
as they encounter the stiff radiative region.
-- 18 --
Fig. 5. -- Angular Velocity variations in the deep interior. Banded radial differential rotation
is seen. The deviations in the core are 2-3 orders of magnitude larger than those in the bulk
of the radiative interior. There appears to be a link between deviations in the core and those
in the tachocline (see Figure 1).
-- 19 --
Fig. 6. -- Time evolution of angular velocity variations. Some indication of reversal is seen
in the bulk of the radiative interior between 223 days and 348 days. In the core there was
clearly a reversal, which Figure 5 tells us was around 130 days.
-- 20 --
Fig. 7. -- Convergence of the Reynolds stress in the bulk of the radiative interior (blue
represents negative, red positive values). Disturbances move upward in time as expected
from the nonlinear interaction of low amplitude waves. Significant interference is seen at
smaller radii, probably due to the interaction of inward propagating and reflected waves.
|
astro-ph/0311281 | 1 | 0311 | 2003-11-12T15:33:26 | Timing properties and spectral states in Aquila X-1 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We have analyzed five X-ray outbursts of the neutron-star soft X-ray transient Aql X-1 and investigated the timing properties of the source in correlation with its spectral states as defined by different positions in the color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams. The hard color and the source count rate serve as the distinguishing parameters giving rise to three spectral states: a low-intensity hard state, an intermediate state and a high-intensity soft state. These states are respectively identified with the extreme island, island and banana states that characterize the atoll sources. The large amount of data analyzed allowed us to perform for the first time a detailed timing analysis of the extreme island state. Differences in the aperiodic variability between the rise and the decay of the X-ray outbursts are found in this state: at the same place in the color-color diagram, during the rise the source exhibits more power at low frequencies (< 1 Hz), whereas during the decay the source is more variable at high frequencies (> 100 Hz). The very-low frequency noise that characterizes the banana-state power spectra below 1 Hz cannot be described in terms of a single power law but a two-component model is required. In two outbursts a new 6-10 Hz QPO has been discovered and tentatively identified with the normal/flaring branch-like oscillation observed only at the highest inferred mass accretion rates. We have compared the spectral and timing properties of Aql X-1 with those of other atoll and Z sources. Our results argue against a unification scheme for these two types of neutron-star X-ray binaries. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Timing properties and spectral states in Aquila X–1
P. Reig1 , S. van Straaten2 , M. van der Klis2
3
0
0
2
v
o
N
2
1
1
v
1
8
2
1
1
3
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
ABSTRACT
We have analyzed five X-ray outbursts of the neutron-star soft X-ray transient
Aquila X – 1 and investigated the timing properties of the source in correlation with its
spectral states as defined by different positions in the color-color and hardness-intensity
diagrams. The hard color and the source count rate serve as the distinguishing parame-
ters giving rise to three spectral states: a low-intensity hard state, an intermediate state
and a high-intensity soft state. These states are respectively identified with the extreme
island, island and banana states that characterize the atoll sources. The large amount of
data analyzed allowed us to perform for the first time a detailed timing analysis of the
extreme island state. Differences in the aperiodic variability between the rise and the
decay of the X-ray outbursts are found in this state: at the same place in the color-color
diagram, during the rise the source exhibits more power at low frequencies (<
∼ 1 Hz),
whereas during the decay the source is more variable at high frequencies (>∼ 100 Hz).
The very-low frequency noise that characterizes the banana-state power spectra below
1 Hz cannot be described in terms of a single power law but a two-component model
is required. In two outbursts a new 6-10 Hz QPO has been discovered and tentatively
identified with the normal/flaring branch-like oscillation observed only at the highest
inferred mass accretion rates. We have compared the spectral and timing properties
of Aquila X – 1 with those of other atoll and Z sources. Our results argue against a
unification scheme for these two types of neutron-star X-ray binaries.
Subject headings: accretion, accretion disks — stars: neutron — stars:
(Aquila X–1) — X-rays: stars
individual
1G.A.C.E, Instituto de Ciencias de los Materiales, University of Valencia, P.O. Box 22085, E - 46071 Paterna-Valencia, Spain
2Astronomical Institute “Anton Pannekoek”, University of Amsterdam and Center for High-Energy Astrophysics, Kruislaan 403, NL-
1098 SJ Amsterdam, the Netherlands
1
1.
Introduction
Aquila X – 1 belongs to the general group of sys-
tems known as low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXB).
These systems consist of a neutron star or a black
hole orbiting around a late-type star (later than A).
The X rays are the result of the accretion of material
from the companion onto the compact star. Mass
transfer is thought to occur via Roche lobe over-
flow, and hence proceeds via an accretion disk.
In
Aquila X – 1, the compact star is a neutron star and
the mass-donating companion is a V=21.6 K7V star,
located at an estimated distance of 2.5 kpc (Cheva-
lier et al. 1999). An orbital period of 18.95 hours has
been suggested (Chevalier & Ilovaisky 1991; Welsh,
Robinson & Young 2000). The high-energy radiation
is characterized by 1.5–2 month long transient X-ray
outbursts during which the X-ray luminosity can in-
crease by more than three orders of magnitude. They
are thought to be due to thermal instabilities in the
accretion disk (e.g. van Paradijs 1996). Their re-
currence time and duration vary but typical values
are ∼ 200 days and 40–60 days, respectively (Simon
2002). The source also displays Type I bursts (Zhang,
Yu & Zhang 1998) that last a few tens of seconds and
are interpreted as runaway thermonuclear burning of
matter on the surface of the neutron star.
Various schemes have been proposed to categorize
the LMXBs: X-ray spectral behavior as a function of
intensity and the requirement of a low-energy black-
body component in the X-ray spectra (Parsignault &
Grindlay 1978; Naylor & Podsiadlowski 1993), cluster
analysis of a large number of source characteristics
(Ponman 1982), detailed X-ray spectral fits (White
& Mason 1985), X-ray hardness-intensity and color-
color diagrams (Schulz, Hasinger & Trumper 1989),
aperiodic variability at very low frequencies (Reig,
Papadakis & Kylafis 2003). Most relevant for the
purpose of this paper is the classification scheme in
terms of the rapid aperiodic variability and the pat-
terns that these sources display in color-color dia-
grams (Hasinger & van der Klis 1989). In this scheme
LMXBs are divided into two different subclasses, Z
and atoll sources.
The three spectral branches that make up the Z
shape are called horizontal branch, normal branch
and flaring branch and the two structures that occur
in atoll sources are known as the island and the ba-
nana (van der Klis 1989). At the lowest count rates an
extension of the island state is sometimes seen with
a harder spectrum and stronger band-limited noise
than the ”canonical” island state (van Straaten, van
der Klis & M´endez 2003 and references therein). The
term extreme island state has been used to designate
such state (Prins & van der Klis 1997; Reig et al.
2000). The spectral and timing properties of atoll
sources in this state are reminiscent of those seen in
the low/hard state of black hole systems (van der Klis
1994a, 1994b; Berger & van der Klis 1998; Olive et al.
1998; Belloni, Psaltis & van der Klis 2002). Both Z
and atoll sources move through these patterns contin-
uously, that is, without jumping from one branch to
another, although the source motion along the spec-
tral tracks is much slower in atoll sources when they
are in the island state than in the banana state and
in Z sources in all states. The classification of Aquila
X–1 in this scheme was investigated by Reig et al.
(2000) — see also Cui et al. (1998) —, who studied
the correlated X-ray timing and spectral variations of
Aquila X – 1 and presented evidence for its classifi-
cation as an atoll source, exhibiting all classic atoll
source states.
This scheme has been revisited by Muno, Remil-
lard & Chakrabarty (2002) and Gierli´nski & Done
(2002). They reported that three transient atoll
sources which display a wide dynamic range in inten-
sity (Fmax /Fmin >∼ 100; 4U 1608–52, 4U 1705–44 and
Aquila X – 1 trace out three-branch patterns in the
color-color diagram similar to those of Z sources, and
suggested this may be a general feature. Their study
was based on the spectral properties only. However,
as pointed out by Hasinger & van der Klis (1989)
it is difficult to make a clear distinction between Z
and atoll sources on the basis of the motion through
the color-color diagram alone. Analysis of the rapid
aperiodic variability to study the noise components
in different regions of the color-color diagram and the
actual time scales of the motion of the source through
the diagram are important to identify source type and
state.
In this work we have studied the spectral and tim-
ing properties of Aquila X – 1 in order to investigate
whether atoll and Z sources can be unified into one
classification scheme and provide new insights into the
poorly known extreme island states of atoll sources.
We find that although the color-color diagram shows a
branch whose topology is similar to the normal branch
of Z sources, neither the timing properties nor the mo-
tion in the color-color diagram of Aquila X – 1 agree
with those of Z sources.
2
2. Observations
The data were retrieved from the RXTE archive
and comprise all observations of Aquila X – 1 available
from 1997 February to 2002 May. Data taken during
satellite slews and Earth occultation were removed.
Likewise, all Type I bursts were excluded from our
analysis. The observations contain five X-ray out-
bursts. Although the duration and maximum inten-
sity differ, the profile of the outbursts is very similar
and is characterized by a fast rise and a slower decay.
During intensity maximum the light curve is complex
and multi-peaked. The fourth outburst showed two
minor outbursts (the peak intensity was one order
of magnitude lower than the main outburst) 70 days
and 110 days after the main peak, respectively. The
long-term light curve of the observations is shown in
Fig. 1.
3. The color-color diagram
Background subtracted light curves corresponding
to the energy ranges 2.0–3.5 keV, 3.5–6.0 keV, 6.0–
9.7 keV and 9.7–16.0 keV were used to define the soft
and hard colors as SC=3.5–6.0/2.0–3.5 and HC=9.7–
16.0/6.0–9.7, respectively. The color-color diagram
(CD) of Aquila X – 1 was then constructed by plotting
the hard color as function of the soft color (Fig. 2).
During the time spanned by the observations the re-
sponse of the detectors varied due to ageing. In ad-
dition, gain changes are applied occasionally, mak-
ing the channel boundaries for a given energy range
change with time, and also slightly affecting the effec-
tive areas of the detectors. Each gain change is the
start of a new ”gain epoch”. We reduced the effect of
the color shifts that results from these gain changes by
linearly interpolating between the count rates in the
two energy channels straddling the energy boundaries
in each epoch. Each data point of Aquila X – 1 was
normalized with the closest corresponding Crab point
within the same gain epoch in order to mitigate the
response change effects on the colors. The final CD
was obtained by averaging the five (one for each de-
tector) normalized CDs and rebinning into 256-s data
points. We excluded data for which the resulting rel-
ative errors were larger than 5%. The total number
of data points excluded from the analysis was <∼ 10%.
In order to recover the true values of the colors of
Aquila X – 1 the soft color should be multiplied by
2.35 and the hard color by 0.56 (quoted values are av-
erages of the Crab colors during the observations and
3
for all five PCUs). The variation of the Crab colors
computed as the root-mean-square, i.e. (the standard
deviation over the mean color) was 5.3% and 1.7% for
the soft and hard colors, respectively — see also Fig. 1
in van Straaten et al. (2003).
3.1. Spectral states
Aquila X – 1 can be found in two main states:
a low-intensity hard state and a high-intensity soft
state. In addition, a short-lived intermediate or tran-
sition state is found displaying values of the hard color
in between the two main states. The aperiodic vari-
ability as a function of spectral hardness, i.e. position
in the CD of Aquila X – 1 was previously studied by
Reig et al. (2000). With only two of the five out-
bursts analysed in that work, the CD consisted of
a soft branch, the banana branch, and two isolated
groups of points which were called extreme island and
island states. The large amount of data now analyzed
reveals a more structured CD, in which the extreme
island state appears as a more stable and longer-lived
branch than the island state. The high/soft state cor-
responds to the classical banana state and the island
state represents the transition between the two main
states.
Outbursts 1, 4 and 5 (O1, O4 and O5) contain
points in the two main states while outbursts 2 and 3
(O2 and O3) provide points to the banana state only.
Observations of O2 and O3 began and finished when
the source was still at a relatively high level of emis-
sion (> 1200 c/s) and did not experience large ampli-
tude changes (Imax /Imin < 5). In contrast, outburst
1, 4 and 5 extended over a larger dynamic range in
intensity (Imax /Imin > 50). None of the points of the
two minor outbursts which followed O4 (which will be
termed here as O4′) contributed to the banana state.
Outbursts 1, 4, 4′ and 5 include points in the ex-
treme island state. While O4 and O5 include points
both during the rise and during the decay, O1 gives
points during the decay only. The island state oc-
curred only during the decay of O1 and O5. All five
outbursts (except for O4′) have points in the banana
state but only O3 provides banana state points during
the rise.
3.2. Motion in the color-color diagram
Figure 3 displays the motion of Aquila X – 1 in the
CD for outbursts 4 and 5. Data points are ∼1-day
averages. Figure 4 shows the evolution of the colors
with time for those outbursts that include spectral
transitions (O1, O4, O5). The 2–16 keV intensity
just before the transitions is also given. All quoted
intensities in this section are background subtracted
and correspond to 5 PCUs in the energy range 2–16
keV. There is a strong correlation between the po-
sition of the source in the CD and its intensity. At
the onset of the outbursts the data points distribute
in the softest part of the extreme island state. The
count rate is <∼ 100 c/s. As the intensity increases
the source moves toward the right along the extreme
island branch. The hard color (HC) slightly decreases
on average. In about 6 days the count rate increases
by one order of magnitude and the soft color (SC)
increases by ≈+0.3. Then the source seems to jump
to the banana state, recovering the initial values of
the soft color. The hard color decreases by ≈ −0.5.
The 2–16 keV intensity is ∼ 3 or 4 times that of the
extreme island state prior to the spectral transition,
namely 4000–6000 c/s. No intermediate points be-
tween the two states are observed during the rise of
the outbursts. This can be attributed to the fast rise
and the lack of good sampling of the data. Indeed,
the observational gaps between the last point of the
extreme island branch and the first one of the banana
branch were 2.6 and 3.1 days for O4 and O5, respec-
tively.
As the intensity continues to increase the source
becomes harder, i.e., it moves to the right along the
banana, with approximately constant hard color. The
peak of the outburst is characterized by flaring activ-
ity with erratic changes in count rate. The count rate
at the peak is 50–100 times the minimum detected
count rate. Despite this irregular behavior the corre-
lation between the intensity and the colors is main-
tained in the sense that the lower intensity points in
the flares display a lower soft color as it is illustrated
in Fig. 5. In other words, during the flare maxima
the source lies at the right end of the banana branch,
and in between flares it moves to the left. Thus the
flaring variability in the light curve translates into the
CD in a back and forth motion which approximately
extends over the right half part of the banana state.
This motion is quite fast. As an example, in one of the
flares in O5 the soft color changed by 0.08 in about
2.4 hr. In another flare by 0.06 in 0.55 hr. This flar-
ing behavior is seen in all outbursts but O2 shows
it exclusively (Fig. 5). Such behavior stops once the
source gets to half way the decay of the outburst, at
which point the source shifts to lower soft colors (to
the left along the banana branch).
As the outburst declines the source moves back
along the banana branch, abandoning it when the
count rate becomes lower than ∼ 800 c/s. The transi-
tion to the hard state occurs at much lower soft color
than when it entered the banana, although not nece-
sarily at the lowest soft color. The banana state cov-
ers values of the soft color between 0.87 (O5) and 1.16
(O3). The transition to the hard state takes place at
SC ≈ 0.92–0.93 (Fig. 3). The count rate at which the
transition between the two main states takes place is
higher when the source is in the rise of the outburst.
Hard to soft transitions occur when the count rate is
well above ∼ 1000 c/s. Soft to hard transitions when
the count rate is well below ∼ 1000 c/s as it can be
seen in Fig. 4.
Rather than jumping directly to the hard branch
the source remains for a short time (≤ 0.1 days) in an
intermediate state, the island state. Note that such
a short island state episode would usually have been
missed due to data gaps in the rise. The count rate
in the island state is ∼ 200–400 c/s. At even lower
count rates the source finds itself back in the extreme
island branch, moving toward the left as the intensity
decreases, to eventually become too weak to measure
the colors sufficiently well. The source re-enters this
state during the decay when the count rate goes below
∼ 200 c/s. The re-entry point occurs at a lower soft
color (SC ≈ 1.05–1.10) then when the source left the
extreme island state (SC ≈ 1.3). As the speed of mo-
tion along the extreme island state is approximately
constant, the time during which the source can be
found in this state is shorter during the decay of the
outburst than during its rise. A difference in the po-
sition of the source in the CD depending on whether
the source intensity increases or decreases was already
recognized by Reig et al. (2000).
The main result that should be stressed is that
transitions between states do not occur at the same
point of the spectral branches. During the rise of
the X-ray outburst the source occupies the hardest
parts of the extreme island state before the spectral
transition to the banana state. During the decay it
tends to occupy the softest part of the banana branch
before moving into the island state. However, the
points of departure and arrival are different. In the
CD, this translates into some sort of rectangular track
(Fig. 3) along which Aquila X – 1 moves clockwise as
the count rate first increases and then decreases.
In addition to Fig. 4, Tables 1 and 2 also illustrate
4
the time scale for the motion through the diagram.
Table 1 and Table 2 give upper limits on the dura-
tion of the source in each state and the time scales
of the spectral transitions, respectively. Note that
the observational gap for the spectral transitions from
the extreme island state to the banana state is ap-
proximately two times longer than viceversa. Given
the speed of motion of the soft color along the ex-
treme island branch (roughly 0.05 day−1 ) a three-day
gap might imply a change in soft color of about 0.15.
Thus, it is possible that the actual entry point into
the banana branch is at lower values of the soft color.
In this case the motion of Aquila X – 1 in the CD
would be similar to that of 4U 1705-44 (Barret &
Olive 2002), in which both the transition from (to)
the extreme island state to (from) the banana state
occur at the same point of the banana branch. The
motion in the CD then would then resemble an in-
verted triangle rather than a rectangle.
4. Timing analysis
In order to investigate the aperiodic variability of
Aquila X – 1 we obtained power spectra by dividing
the 2–60 keV PCA data of each observation into 256-s
segments and calculated the Fourier power spectrum
of each segment up to a Nyquist frequency of 2048 Hz.
The high-frequency end (1500–2048 Hz) of the power
spectra was used to determine the underlying Pois-
son noise (approximated by a constant power level),
which was subtracted before performing the spectral
fitting. Our aim is to investigate the aperiodic vari-
ability in correlation with the spectral states, which
in turn, correlate with the source count rate. Thus
we divided the color-color plane into various regions
and obtained a mean power spectrum for each region.
The mean power spectrum was the result of averag-
ing all the power spectra corresponding to the points
enclosed in each color region. See Table 3 to find the
average values of the colors, boundaries and intensity
of each region. Prior to this, we investigated whether
power spectra from the same CD region taken at dif-
ferent outbursts were consistent with having the same
properties. We found that while this was true for the
banana state, some differences existed in the extreme
island state depending on whether the source was in
the rise or the decay of the X-ray outburst.
The extreme island state is populated with points
from the rising part of O4 and O5, the decaying part
of O1, O4 and O5 and from the extended extreme is-
land state of O4′ . Consequently, the extreme island
state was first separated into points pertaining to the
rise, to the decay or to O4′ . Then each one of these
groups was further divided into three subgroups ac-
cording to the value of the soft color. Note that in the
case of the rise and decay regions this division implies
a division in count rate as well as in hard color. On
average, the extreme island sates EISrise1 and EISde-
cay2, (see Table 3) have lower intensity and are softer
than EISrise2 and EISdecay1, respectively. In turn,
EISrise2 contains softer points than EISrise3. The is-
land state points (intermediate state) defined another
region. The timing properties of the banana state in
atoll sources have been seen to vary smoothly as the
soft color, or equivalently, the count rate increases,
that is, from the lower (left) to the upper (right) ba-
nana branch. Therefore, the banana branch was split
into five regions (BS1 to BS5) in increasing order of
the soft color. Each region approximately contains
the same amount of data.
There is no unanimity in the literature about the
names of the power spectral noise components nor
about the mathematical functions used to fit those
components. In this work we have followed the ter-
minology of Belloni et al. (2002) and fitted the power
spectra using Lorentzian functions only. Also, for dis-
playing our power spectra we have used the power
times frequency representation ν ×P (ν ) vs ν , in which
the product of the power density in the rms normal-
ization and the Fourier frequency is plotted as a func-
tion of the Fourier frequency (Belloni et al. 1997). As
fit parameters we use the frequency νmax at which the
Lorentzian attains its maximum value in such repre-
sentation, and the Q value, which gives a measure of
the coherence of the Lorentzian. In terms of the half
width at half maximum or ∆, these quanties are re-
lated by νmax = pν 2
0 + ∆2 and Q = ν0/2∆, where ν0
is the central frequency of the Lorentzian. Between
three and five Lorentzians were needed in order to get
a good fit. If during the fitting procedure a Lorentzian
component resulted with negative Q value then we set
it to zero.
It should be noted that the naming scheme of Bel-
loni et al.
(2002) was applied, in the case of low-
luminosity neutron stars, to systems displaying the
island state only. Thus, a complete description of
some power spectra, especially those in the banana
state, in terms of the noise components given in that
work is not always possible and extra or new compo-
nents are needed in order to obtain acceptable fits.
5
The extensions to the Belloni et al. naming scheme
we use are those of van Straaten et al. (2003).
In the terminology of Belloni et al.
(2002), the
band-limited noise of atoll sources in the (extreme)
island state consists of three Lorentzians namely, Lb
that accounts for the power spectrum at low frequen-
cies (<∼1 Hz), Lℓ and Lu that fit its high-frequency
end. Lℓ may show up as a broad bump at frequencies
10–25 Hz (normally in the island state) or as a nar-
row QPO at frequencies >∼ 100 Hz (normally in the
banana state). In fact, at frequencies above >∼ 100 Hz
Lℓ and Lu represent the kHz QPOs seen in low-mass
X-ray binaries. However, note that this identifica-
tion of Lℓ with both a broad peak and the lower kHz
QPO is only tentative and the broad bump at 10-25
Hz might alternatively represent a separate compo-
nent (van Straaten et al. 2002). The intermediate
frequency range (1–100 Hz) is described by one broad
Lorentzian or ”hump”, Lh and one narrow Lorentzian
LLF referred to as the low-frequency QPO. Not de-
tected by Belloni et al.
(2002) but also present in
some atoll sources (van Straaten et al. 2002) is the
so-called hectoHerz QPO, LhH z , a broad feature with
characteristic frequency at ∼ 100 Hz.
4.1. Spectral states: aperiodic variability
Table 4 lists the results of the fits and Fig. 6 de-
picts the power spectra and fit functions for different
regions of the CD (see Table 3 to identify the position
in the CD).
4.1.1. The extreme island state (EIS)
The extreme island state power spectrum contains,
in order of increasing frequency, the low-frequency
band-limited noise, Lb , the broad peak low-frequency
noise Lh , the broad version of Lℓ and one more com-
ponent which could be either the hHz QPO or a kHz
QPO. Based on the rms/frequency correlations of the
noise components seen in other atoll sources, van
Straaten et al. (2002, 2003) favored the upper kHz
interpretation. If Lℓ is also interpreted as the lower
kHz QPO then the intervals EISrise2, EISrise3 and
ISO4′
2 (see Fig.6) would represent the first detection
of the two kHz QPO in Aquila X – 1. Alternatively,
the fourth component could be the hHz QPO. Note
that the narrow ∼1160 Hz peak in EISO4′
2 is not sta-
tistically significant. An F-test reveals that the prob-
ability that the improvement of the fit (in terms of
a lower χ2 ) by the addition of an extra Lorentzian
6
happen by chance is larger than 30%. The character-
istic frequencies of the noise components increase and
their rms values decrease slightly as the count rate
increases, i.e., the source moves toward the right in
the extreme island state.
Figure 7 displays the characteristic frequency of
the Lh and Lℓ components as a function of the band-
limited noise component Lb for Aquila X – 1, the atoll
sources 4U 1608–52 (van Straaten et al. 2003), 4U
1728–34 and 4U 0614+09 (van Straaten et al. 2002)
and the Z source GX5–1 (Jonker et al. 2002).
In
the case of GX5–1 te horizontal branch oscillation is
plotted instead of Lh . Note also that the broad-band
noise in the Z source was not fitted with a Lorentzian
but with a cutoff power law, P (ν ) ∝ ν−α e−ν /νcut . By
differentiating νP (ν ) and equating the resulting func-
tion to zero the maximum frequency of the Z band-
limited noise, νmax = (1 − α)νcut , was derived. Fig-
ure 7 seems to confirm that i) the 1–20 Hz broad fea-
ture Lh observed in atoll sources at low count rates
(island states) has the same origin as the horizon-
tal branch oscillations (HBO) observed in Z sources
(Psaltis, Belloni & van der Klis 1999, van Straaten
et al. 2003), ii) the broad bump at frequencies 10–25
Hz is associated with the lower kHz QPO. The ex-
treme island state data in Aquila X – 1 sample the
lowest characteristic frequencies so far detected.
One interesting result from the timing analysis of
the extreme island state is the differences in the ape-
riodic variability of the source during the rise and
decay of the outbursts. Figure 8 shows three power
spectra of Aquila X – 1 and an enlargement of the
CD displaying the extreme island state. All three
power spectra are associated with the same value of
the colors, i.e, they occupy the same position in the
CD (marked in Fig. 8). However, they correspond to
different parts of the X-ray outburst: rise (diamonds),
decay (stars) and when the source found itself in the
extended island state of O4′ (crosses). During the rise
the power is concentrated at low frequencies whereas
during the decay, the source exhibits more power at
high frequencies During the extended island state of
outburst O4′ there is roughly equal power at all fre-
quencies. The differences in the characteristic fre-
quencies of the noise components are much less pro-
nounced and consistent with one onother whenever
the same component appears.
4.1.2. The banana state
The low-frequency end (<∼ 1 Hz) of the banana
state power spectra is dominated by the very-low fre-
quency noise (VLFN). One single power law is nor-
mally used to fit this component. However, the power
spectrum of Aquila X – 1 below 1 Hz cannot be de-
scribed by one component only.
In order to fit the
VLFN we used two zero-centered Lorentzians that
were called low VLFN (LLV LF N ) and high VLFN
(LHV LF N ) (Schnerr et al. 2003). The characteris-
tic frequencies of these components are found to be
independent of the position of the source in the CD:
νmax ∼ 0.01 Hz and ∼0.03 Hz, respectively. However,
while the fractional rms variability of lower frequency
VLFN roughly remains constant at ∼3.4%, the higher
frequency VLFN becomes stronger — increasing from
∼0.9% in the lower banana to ∼2% in the upper ba-
nana — as the count rate increases.
Above 1 Hz the banana state power spectra contain
one broad Lorentzian, describing the band-limited
noise and one QPO (two in BS1). The character-
istic frequency and width of the broad band-limited
noise component decrease as the count rate increases
(i.e. as the source moves toward the right). This
component has also been seen in 4U 1608–52 (van
Straaten et al. 2003), 4U 0614+09 and 4U 1728–
34 (van Straaten et al. 2002). However, the lack
of data precludes a more detailed comparison. Only
4U 1728–34, with just two measurements, seems to
have the same behavior as Aquila X – 1 i.e., the fre-
quency of this noise component decreases along the
banana. Following van Straaten et al.
(2003) we
will refer to this component as Lb2 . Next to, some-
times on top of, the band-limited noise in the banana
state there is a relatively narrow peak, whose char-
acteristic frequency and width do not correlate with
any other parameter. This narrow QPO has a fre-
quency in between that of the hHz Lorentzian and
Lh . van Straaten et al. (2003) — see also di Salvo
et al. (2001) and van Straaten et al. (2002) — ar-
gued that it is the band-limited noise component Lb
which transforms into a narrow QPO above certain
frequency (∼ 20 Hz in 4U 1608–52). The appearance
of Lb2 and this transformation of Lb occurs coinciden-
tally. In Aquila X – 1, although the narrow version of
Lb appears systematically in all banana-state power
spectra it is always below 3σ .
The detection of a second kHz QPO in Aquila X –
1 is only marginal (van der Klis 2000). Based on
the values of the fitting parameters and the relation
between the QPO frequency and the X-ray colors,
M´endez, van der Klis & Ford (2001) concluded that
whenever a kHz QPO is detected in Aquila X – 1 it
is always the lower kHz QPO. The fractional rms and
characteristic frequency of the second QPO in BS1
are consistent with being the lower kHz QPO (Fig. 1
of M´endez, van der Klis & Ford 2001). Also, the char-
acteristic frequencies of the Lℓ and Lb in BS1 agree
with the correlation of Fig. 7 if an extrapolation to
higher frequencies of the Aquila X – 1 points is done.
4.1.3. The island state (IS)
The analysis of the transition state is hampered
by poor statistics given the relatively low number of
points. One single Lorentzian with peak at ≈ 20 Hz
and Q value of 0.15 accounts for the entire 0.01–
100 Hz frequency band. This noise component is
identified as Lb . A second narrower Lorentzian with
νmax ≈ 710 Hz and Q ≈ 3 fits the noise at higher
frequencies. Its fractional rms, ∼ 17%, is too high to
agree with the lower kHz QPO. In fact, the value of
the frequency and rms are similar to what it is seen in
4U 1608–52 and 4U 1728–34 for the upper kHz QPO
(Fig. 1 of M´endez, van der Klis & Ford 2001). Nev-
ertheless, given the relatively noisy spectrum at high
frequencies such identification should be taken with
care.
4.2. The normal/flaring branch-like oscilla-
tions
A QPO with frequency 7–14 Hz has been found
in at least two atoll sources, XTE J1806–246 (Wi-
jnands & van der Klis 1999; Revnivtsev, Borozdin
& Emelyanov 1999) and 4U 1820–30 (Wijnands et
al. 1999). These QPOs are detected at the high-
est inferred mass accretion rates only, are short-lived
(a few hundreds of seconds) and are localized in a
very narrow region of the CD, namely the tip of the
upper banana. They are reminiscent of those ob-
served in Z sources in the normal and flaring branches,
when the source is accreting near the Eddington limit.
Thus the detection of similar QPO in atoll sources
at significantly lower accretion rates questions the
current models that explain NBO in terms of near-
Eddington accretion (Fortner, Lamb & Miller 1989).
We searched for NBO-like QPO in Aquila X – 1
and tentatively found two of them at ∼ 3σ signifi-
cance, at frequencies 10.3±0.5 Hz in O3 and 5.8±0.2
7
Hz in O5 (Fig. 9). They have similar rms ampli-
tude (≈ 0.7%) and Q-values (≈ 3). The average
values of the colors and intensity associated with
these QPOs are SC=1.11, HC=0.52, IX=5045 count
s−1 and SC=1.06, HC=0.51, IX=6870 count s−1 , re-
spectively. For the sake of comparison with other
sources we also give the value of the X-ray luminosity:
8.5 × 1036 erg s−1 for outburst 3 and 8.1 × 1036 erg
s−1 for outburst 5. As a confirmation that they occur
at the highest count rates, typical luminosities in the
softest parts of the extreme island and banana states
are 3 × 1034 and 2 × 1036 erg s−1 , respectively. The
values of the luminosity are for a distance of 2.5 kpc
and the energy range 2–16 keV. In the other three
outbursts the detection is only marginal. The low
statistical significance of these QPOs (<∼2.5) can be
ascribed to their extremely short life.
5. Discussion
We have analysed all the available RXTE data of
Aquila X – 1 between 1997 February and 2002 May
and investigated its spectral and timing properties in
correlation. This work has been motivated by recent
reports that show that if large data sets are used, the
atoll sources displaying the largest ampitude varia-
tions in intensity show three-branch patterns in the
color-color diagram (CD), reminiscent of Z sources
(Muno, Remillard & Chakrabarty 2002; Gierli´nski &
Done 2002). Consequently, they conclude that the
distinction between atoll and Z sources might be no
longer justified. The extended island state, island
state and banana state of atoll sources would then
correspond to the horizontal branch (HB), normal
branch (NB) and flaring branch (FB), respectively.
The results of these studies were based on the spectral
properties (i.e. color-color diagram) only. In order to
be able to distinguish between the different types of
low-mass X-ray binaries the rapid aperiodic variabil-
ity associated with the various spectral states needs to
be addressed as well (Hasinger & van der Klis 1989),
and that is what we have attempted in this paper.
We first make a comparison of the timing properties
of Aquila X – 1 with those of other atoll sources and
then discuss whether ot not it can be considered as a
Z source.
5.1. Comparison with atoll sources
4U 1608–52 and Aquila X – 1 are the atoll sources
that display the largest dynamic range in X-ray in-
tensity (Imax /Iquiesence > 1000). Thus a comparison
between these two sources is of particular interest. 4U
1608–52 has been extensively studied by van Straaten
et al. (2003). By comparing the shape of the power
spectra (see Fig. 7 in van Straaten et al. 2003 and
our Fig. 6) and the results of the power spectral fits
(their Table 2 and 3 and our Table 4) one can find dis-
tinct similarities between the two sources: the power
spectra of intervals A, B and C in 4U 1608–52 resem-
ble those of the extreme island state of Aquila X – 1,
while interval D of 4U 1608–52 is reminiscent of the
island state in Aquila X – 1. Likewise, the shape and
number of Lorentzians appearing in the power spectra
of the extreme island state of Aquila X – 1 are simi-
lar to those of the three low-luminosity X-ray bursters
studied by Belloni et al. (2002).
It is worth noting the relevant role of the hard
color in connection with the timing properties of the
extreme island state.
In Aquila X – 1 the charac-
teristic frequencies of the timing features in the ex-
treme island state increase from left to right. This
is opposite to what it is seen in 4U 1608-52, where
frequencies increase from right to left. However, in
both sources the increase in frequencies occurs in cor-
relation with an overall decrease in hard color. We
therefore suggest that in the extreme island state it
is the hard color, rather than the intensity, which is
the main determining factor of the timing properties.
We note, that black hole candidates are likewise char-
acterized by power spectral states whose occurrence
seems to primarily depend on spectral hardness and
which are relatively insensitive to intensity, and which
are associated with two-dimensional motion through
the color-intensity plane rather than motion along a
one-dimensional track (Homan et al. 2001). It may
be that in the island and extreme island states, the
states in which atoll sources are most similar to black
holes (e.g., van der Klis 1994a; Belloni, Psaltis & van
der Klis 2002), possibly because in these states the
inner disk radius is furthest from the neutron star
surface, this 2-D picture better describes neutron star
behavior than the 1-D description appropriate to the
banana state and to Z sources.
Leaving aside the kHz QPOs, the overall shape
of the banana-state power spectra of Aquila X – 1
present similarities with those of other atoll sources,
namely, a strong red-noise component, the very-low
frequency noise (VLFN) below ∼ 1 Hz and a broad
and a narrow components describing the band-limited
noise (BLN) in the frequency range 1–100 Hz. Com-
8
pared to 4U 0614+09, 4U 1608-52 and 4U 1728–
34, Aquila X – 1 exbibits the strongest VLFN but
the weakest BLN. While the VLFN is normally de-
scribed by either a power law with index between
1.5-2.0 or a zero centered Lorentzian in the other
atoll sources, it requires the use of two model com-
ponents in Aquila X – 1, similar to the case of GX
13+1 (Schnerr et al. 2003). The broad band-limited
noise component Lb2 in Aquila X – 1 and 4U 1608-
52, or equivalently the zero centred Lorentzian in 4U
1728–34 and 4U 0614+09 have similar rms values. In
contrast, Lb , which is clearly detected in these other
atoll sources, is not significant in Aquila X – 1 in the
banana state.
5.2.
Is Aquila X – 1 a Z source?
Gierli´nski & Done (2002) suggested that the name
atoll source is no longer appropiate as these type of
low-mass X-ray binaries also display a three-branch
pattern in the color-color diagram when large data
sets of observations are used, reminiscent of the Z
pattern for which Z sources are named. This ef-
fect is more pronounced in systems exhibiting large
flux variations (Muno et al. 2002), like Aquila X –
1. The CD of Aquila X – 1 (Fig. 2) does indeed
show a branch (the island state) that can be inter-
preted to connect the two main branches like in a Z
shape. In addition, the correlation between the char-
acteristic frequency of the 1–20 Hz broad Lorentzian
Lh and the band-limited noise component (Fig. 7) at
low count rates, suggesting a common origin with the
horizontal branch oscillations and LFN in Z sources
and the discovery of 7–14 Hz QPO at the highest
X-ray flux (Fig. 9), reminiscent of the Z-source nor-
mal/flaring branch oscillations, strengthen the simi-
larities between Aquila X – 1 and Z sources.
However, there are a number of systematic differ-
ences that clearly puts Aquila X – 1 outside the group
of Z sources. First, there is the motion in the CD. In
the extreme island state as the count rate increases
the soft color increases and the hard color decreases.
Then the source makes a rapid transition to the ba-
nana state and proceeds to harder colors (right) as
the count rate increases further. However, after the
peak of the outburst, when the intensity decreases the
source does not follow exactly the reverse path. As
shown in Fig. 3, Aquila X – 1 enters the banana state
(extreme island state) at a higher (lower) value of the
soft color than when it leaves it. The source moves
clokcwise following a rectangle track.
It should be
9
pointed out that the entrance into the banana state
at such high soft color is not caused by the time reso-
lution used (∼ 1 day) in Fig. 3. A 256-s bin shows the
same effect. However, we cannot rule out an observa-
tional origin since the time gap between the transition
from the extreme island state to the banana state is
≈ 5 days for outburst 5 and ≈ 2.6 for outburst 4
(Table 2). If this is the case and the source entered
the banana state from the left then the pattern that
it would trace out in the CD would be that of an in-
verted triangle, much like 4U 1705–44 (Barret & Olive
2002). In contrast, the re-entrance into the extreme
island state at a low soft color is probably not cause by
the lack of data given the relatively short gap between
the island state and the extreme island state (just 1.6
days in outburst 5). In either case this behavior is not
that of Z sources. In Z sources, the NB is not a fast
transition between the other two branches, and the
source follows the same path whether it is going up
or down along the NB. In this respect, Aquila X – 1
is like the other two atoll sources that display high-
amplitude flux variations. More detailed looks into
the motion of 4U 1608–52 and 4U 1705–44 have re-
vealed different topologies from the classical Z-shaped
track. The motion of 4U 1608–52 resembles the greek
letter ǫ (van Straaten et al. 2003) and 4U 1705–44
describes an inverted triangle (Barret & Olive 2002).
As noted above, these various topologies may sim-
ply be different aspects of 2-D motion through the
color-intensity plane in which it is hard color that de-
termines the timing properties.
Second, the amplitude of the X-ray luminosity
change over the Z track is also different. In Aquila X –
1 the X-ray luminosity throughout the CD, i.e., from
the left of the banana state to the right of the extreme
island state is about three orders of magnitude. In Z
sources, luminosity changes are typically less than a
factor of 2 (di Salvo et al. 2000, 2001, 2002).
Third, another difference is the velocity and time
spent by the source in each spectral state. Jonker
et al.
(2002) calculated that the Z source GX 5–1
spent most of the time in the normal branch. In con-
trast, Aquila X – 1 spends the smallest percentage
of the the total observing time in the transition state
(the analogue to the normal branch would Aquila X –
1 be a Z source). Wijnands et al. (1997) found that
Cyg X–2 moves through the Z most slowly on the
HB, faster on the NB and fastest on the FB. During
a typical X-ray outburst, i.e., when Aquila X – 1 is
X-ray active, it spends most of its time in the banana
five X-ray outbursts covering a period of more than
five years. Three spectral states show up in the color-
color diagram of Aquila X – 1: a low/hard state,
identified with an extreme island state, a high/soft
state corresponding to the classic banana state and
an intermediate state associated with the island state
of atoll sources. We have found that the hard color
plays a crucial role in determining the timing proper-
ties of the extreme island state. Although the overall
distribution of these states in the color-color diagram
may resemble a Z, neither the motion in the CD, nor
the typical time scales through the different branches
of the CD, nor the range of X-ray luminosities, nor
the timing properties at very low count rates (the ex-
istence of the extreme island state) are compatible
with the classical Z-source behavior.
PR is a researcher of the programme Ram´on y
Cajal funded by the University of Valencia and the
Spanish Ministery of Science and Technology. PR
also wants to thank the University of Crete for pro-
viding in part the resources needed to carry out
this work. This research has made use of data ob-
tained through the High Energy Astrophysics Science
Archive Research Center Online Service, provided by
the NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center.
branch (the analogue to the flaring branch).
Finally, the properties of the aperiodic variability
of Aquila X – 1 also differ from those in Z sources,
especially at very low count rates. We can establish
the following differences:
– The very existence of the extreme island state.
Although the characteristic frequencies in Aquila X –
1 increase along the extreme island state as the
count rate increases as Z sources do in the HB,
the latter never reach the low frequencies that
are seen in atoll sources in the extreme island
state, even when at the left end of the HB. Like-
wise, the rms amplitude of the noise compo-
nents in the extreme island state is significantly
higher than in a Z source HB. The total rms
amplitude of those components in Aquila X – 1
amounts to ∼ 30%, while typically in Z sources,
it does not go above ∼ 10%. The extreme
island-state power spectra are typical of atoll
sources.
– The peaked noise components, such as Lh and
the upper kHz QPO are narrow QPOs on the
HB in Z sources, with typical values of the Q
parameter above 3 for the upper kHz QPO,
whereas they are considerably broader peaked
noise components in the extreme island state in
Aquila X – 1(Q < 0.5).
– In Aquila X – 1, the normal/flaring branch-
like oscillation does not occur during the ”nor-
mal/flaring branch”,
the island or the
i.e.
lower banana branches but in the upper banana
branch, just like in other atoll sources.
– The strength of the kHz QPOs decreases as the
Z source moves along the Z track from HB to
NB. Typically, the kHz QPOs become unde-
tectable by the time the source reaches the mid-
dle of the NB. In contrast, Aquila X – 1 presents
kHz QPOs in the island and banana states.
– The time scales of the aperiodic variability tend
to decrease (frequencies increase) as the Z source
moves along the FB, which is the opposite be-
havior to what is is observed in Aquila X – 1 in
the banana branch.
6. Conclusions
We have investigated the timing and spectral prop-
erties of the soft X-ray transient Aquila X – 1 during
10
REFERENCES
Nowak, M.A., 2000, MNRAS, 318, 361
Barret, D, & Olive, J.F., 2002, ApJ, 576, 391
Belloni, T., van der Klis, M., Lewin, W. H. G., van
Paradijs, J., Dotani, T., Mitsuda, K., & Miyamoto,
S., 1997, A&A, 322, 857
Belloni, T., Psaltis, D., van der Klis, M., 2002, ApJ,
572, 392
Berger, M., & van der Klis, M.,1998, A&A, 340, 143
Chevalier, C. & Ilovaisky, S. A. 1991, A&A, 251, L11
Chevalier, C., Ilovaisky, S.A., Leisy, P., Patat, F.,
1999, A&A, 347, L51
Cui, W., Barret, D., Zhang, S.N., Chen, W., Boirin,
L., Swank, J., 1998, ApJ, 502, L49
Di Salvo, T., Stella, L., Robba, N. R., van der Klis,
M., Burderi, L., Israel, G. L., Homan, J., Cam-
pana, S., Frontera, F., Parmar, A. N., 2000, ApJ,
544, L119
di Salvo, T., M´endez, M., van der Klis, M., Ford, E.,
Robba, N. R., 2001, ApJ, 546, 1107
di Salvo, T., Farinelli, R., Burderi, L., Frontera, F.,
Kuulkers, E., Masetti, N., Robba, N. R., Stella, L.,
van der Klis, M., 2002, A&A, 386, 535
Fortner, B., Lamb, F. K., Miller, G. S., 1989, Nature,
342, 775
Gierlinski, M., Done, C., 2002, MNRAS, 331, L47
Hasinger, G. & van der Klis, M. 1989, A&A, 225, 79
Homan, J., Wijnands, R, van der Klis, M. Belloni,
T., van Paradijs, J., Klein-Wolt, M. Fender, R.
M´endez, M., 2001, ApJS, 132, 377
Jonker, P. G., van der Klis, M., Homan, J., M´endez,
M., Lewin, W.H.G., Wijnands, R., Zhang, W.,
2002, MNRAS, 333, 665
M´endez, M. van der Klis, M., Ford, E.C., 2001, ApJ,
561, 1016
Muno, M.P., Remillard, R.A., Chakrabarty, D., 2002,
ApJ, 568, L35
Naylor, T., Podsiadlowski, Ph, 1993, MNRAS, 262,
929
Olive, J. F., Barret, D., Boirin, L., Grindlay, J. E.,
Swank, J. H., & Smale, A. P. 1998, A&A, 333, 942
Parsignault, D.R., Grindlay, J.E., 1978, ApJ, 225, 970
Ponman, T, 1982, MNRAS, 200, 351
Prins, S., van der KLis, M., 1997, A&A, 319, 498
Psaltis, D., Belloni, T., van der Klis, M., 1999, ApJ,
520, 262
Reig, P., M´endez, M., van der Klis, M., Ford, E. C.,
2000, ApJ, 530, 916
Reig, P., Papadakis, I., Kylafis, N., 2003, A&A, 398,
1103
Revnivtsev, M., Borozdin, K., Emelyanov, A., 1999,
A&A, 344, L25
Schnerr, R.S., Reerink, T., van der Klis, M., Homan,
J., M´endez, M., Fender, R.P., & Kuulkers, E.,
astro-ph/0305161
Schulz, N. S., Hasinger, G. & Trumper, J. 1989, A&A,
225, 48
Simon, V., 2002, A&A, 381, 151
van der Klis, M., 1989, ARA&A, 27, 517
van der Klis, M, 1994a, A&A, 283, 469
van der Klis, M, 1994b, ApJS, 92, 511
van der Klis, M., 2000, ARA&A, 38, 717
van Paradijs, J., 1996, ApJ, 464, L139
van Straaten, S., van der Klis, M., di Salvo, T., Bel-
loni, T., 2002, ApJ, 568, 912
van Straaten, S., van der Klis, M., M´endez, M., 2003,
ApJ, in press, astro-ph/0307041
Welsh, W.F., Robinson, E.L., Young, P., 2000, AJ,
120, 943
White, N.E., Mason, K.O., 1985, SSRv, 40, 167
Wijnands, R., van der Klis, M., 1997, ApJ, 482, L65
Wijnands, R., van der Klis, M., 1999, ApJ, 514, 939
Wijnands, R., van der Klis, M., Rijkhorst, E. 1999,
ApJ, 512, L39
11
Zhang, S. N., Yu, W. & Zhang, W., 1998, ApJ, 494,
L71
This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX
macros v4.0.
12
Table 1
Duration and intensity (2–16 keV, 5 PCUs) of the spectral states for each of the five X-ray
outbursts
States
Duration
days
EIS
BS
IS
EIS
BS
IS
EIS
BS
IS
EIS
BS
IS
EIS
BS
IS
EIS
BS
IS
–/0.14
15.1
0.10
–
30.96
–
–
38.95
–
6.02/2.03
18.05
–
63
–
–
6.54/1.33
41.53
0.01
Imin
c/s
Outburst 1
–/56
583
200
Outburst 2
–
1213
–
Outburst 3
–
1227
–
Outburst 4
110/70
368
–
Outburst 4′
77
–
–
Outburst 5
87/128
810
458
Imax
c/s
–/63
3057
220
–
2694
–
–
6175
–
Imean
c/s
–/60
2164
209
–
1778
–
–
4656
–
1295/156
4835
–
650/127
2330
–
530
–
–
340
–
–
1444/255
8555
463
542/203
4925
460
EIS: extreme island, BS: banana, IS: island
The left (right) values correspond to the rise (decay)
of the outburst
Table 2
Duration in days of the spectral transitions. These values should be considered as upper limits
as they include observational gaps
Transition Outburst 1 Outburst 4 Outburst 5
4.94
2.63
–
EIS−→BS
2.64
1.06
4.83
BS−→EIS
0.98
–
1.89
BS−→IS
IS−→EIS
2.84
–
1.64
13
Table 3
Boundaries and properties of the color regions on which the timing analysis was performed
States
(SC, HC )1
(SC, HC )2
(SC, HC )3
EISrise1
EISrise2
EISrise3
EISdecay1
EISdecay2
EISO4′
1
EISO4′
2
IS
BS1
BS2
BS3
BS4
BS5
(0.89,1.08)
(1.14,1.06)
(1.19,1.04)
(1.01,1.02)
(0.92,1.11)
(0.96,1.04)
(1.08,1.04)
(0.97,0.71)
(0.83,0.47)
(0.93,0.41)
(0.99,0.40)
(1.04,0.41)
(1.01,0.42)
(1.12,1.08)
(1.21,1.07)
(1.34,1.05)
(1.11,1.03)
(1.11,1.14)
(1.24,1.06)
(1.07,1.06)
(1.11,0.89)
(0.93,0.41)
(0.99,0.40)
(1.04,0.41)
(1.10,0.42)
(1.18,0.50)
(0.89,1.25)
(1.14,1.15)
(1.23,1.10)
(1.00,1.12)
(0.88,1.43)
(0.96,1.26)
(0.96,1.26)
(0.82,0.97)
(0.89,0.59)
(0.95,0.57)
(1.01,0.57)
(1.02,0.57)
(1.05,0.61)
(SC, HC )4 Mean Mean Mean Count
Ratea (c/s)
SC
HC
185
1.14
1.01
925
1.09
1.18
1063
1.07
1.25
183
1.07
1.05
76
1.24
0.98
1.05
1.15
188
356
1.14
1.14
255
0.90
0.98
1275
0.50
0.91
2086
0.49
0.97
3507
0.49
1.02
5248
0.50
1.07
1.12
0.51
5315
(1.11,1.26)
(1.26,1.14)
(1.29,1.11)
(1.11,1.23)
(1.06,1.45)
(1.10,1.26)
(1.10,1.26)
(0.95,1.05)
(0.95,0.57)
(1.01,0.57)
(1.02,0.57)
(1.05,0.61)
(1.09,0.68)
Number of
power spectra
54
34
23
37
40
152
367
28
313
368
368
381
250
χ2 (dof )
122/92
105/84
95/87
87/92
106/92
106/87
114/84
99/91
193/87
139/89
100/88
89/88
99/88
aBackground subtracted count rate for the five PCU and bandwidth 2–16 keV
14
Table 4
Power spectral parameters. Errors are 1σ (∆χ2 = 1)
Statea
LLV LF N
EISrise1
EISrise2
EISrise3
EISdecay1
EISdecay2
EISO4′
1
EISO4′
2
IS
BS1
BS2
BS3
BS4
BS5
EISrise1
EISrise2
EISrise3
EISdecay1
EISdecay2
EISO4′
1
EISO4′
2
IS
BS1
BS2
BS3
BS4
BS5
EISrise1
EISrise2
EISrise3
EISdecay1
EISdecay2
EISO4′
1
EISO4′
2
IS
BS1
BS2
BS3
BS4
BS5
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.0130±0.0007
0.0144±0.0009
0.0160±0.0009
0.0133±0.0007
0.0103±0.0010
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
3.19±0.06
3.44±0.05
3.49±0.05
3.33±0.06
3.29±0.11
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0b
0b
0b
0b
0b
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.36±0.11
0.20±0.02
0.25±0.01
0.27±0.01
0.25±0.01
LHV LF N
Lb2
Lb
Characteristic frequency νmax (Hz)
-
0.10±0.01
-
0.44±0.02
-
0.61±0.01
2.3±0.3
-
-
0.47±0.05
-
0.130±0.006
-
0.284±0.009
-
20±2
42±2
62±5
73±5
45±5
24±3
76±3
16±1
73±4
65±6
13±1
Integrated fractional rmsc
-
14.8±0.7
13.6±0.3
-
-
11.9±0.4
-
9.5±0.6
-
11.0±0.4
-
16.0±0.4
-
14.9±0.2
15.7±0.5
-
5.0±0.2
<1.3
3.4±0.1
<1.2
2.3±0.1
<1.4
1.79±0.06
<1.1
<1.0
1.55±0.06
Q value
0b
0b
0b
0b
0b
0.14±0.04
0.03±0.02
0.11±0.09
0b
0.16±0.08
0.23±0.09
0.29±0.07
0.41±0.08
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
5b
3.5b
2.9±1.2
2.4±1.1
2.6±1.7
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.89±0.07
1.48±0.04
1.76±0.03
1.97±0.02
2.10±0.02
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0b
0b
0b
0b
0b
Lh
Lℓ
LhH z ,Lu
0.59±0.07
2.62±0.06
5.4±0.2
17±3
-
1.11±0.07
2.17±0.04
-
-
-
-
-
-
16.1±0.6
15.8±0.6
18.2±0.5
13.3±0.7
-
15.9±1.0
14.9±0.5
-
-
-
-
-
-
0b
0.42±0.05
0.16±0.05
0b
-
0.22±0.09
0.33±0.04
-
-
-
-
-
-
12.1±1.0
21.6±0.9
32±2
-
-
10.8±0.8
17.9±0.6
-
861±6
-
-
-
-
19.2±0.5
16.1±0.6
10.0±1.0
-
-
17.9±1.0
17.3±0.6
-
5.4±0.2
-
-
-
-
0b
0.19±0.07
0.49±0.15
-
-
0.15±0.13
0.16±0.06
-
7±1
-
-
-
-
-
233±23
273±24
1160b
880±250
180b
223±17
700±40
-
-
-
-
-
-
11.4±0.4
12.2±0.8
19±2
38.5±0.5
17.8±1.9
14.0±0.8
17±2
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.48±0.15
0.43±0.16
0b
0b
0b
0.25±0.13
1.9±0.9
-
-
-
-
-
aRefers to the regions defined in the color-color diagram (see Table 3)
bFixed
cUpper limits are at 95% confidence level
15
Fig. 1.— Light curve of the entire set of observa-
tions showing the five X-ray outbursts. Different sym-
bols represent different spectral states: extreme island
(circles), island (stars) and banana (dots).
16
Fig. 2.— Color-color diagram of Aquila X – 1. The
soft and hard colors are relative to those of the Crab.
Each point in the color-color diagram represents 256
s. No error bars are given but all the points shown
in this plot have relative errors smaller than 5%. Dif-
ferent symbols represent different outbursts as indi-
cated. The lines separate the banana-state regions
(from BS1 in the left to BS5 in the right).
17
Fig. 3.— Track followed by the source in the color-
color diagram during outbursts 4 and 5. Each data
point is a one day average.
18
Fig. 4.— Evolution of the hard color showing the
transitions between the different spectral states: ex-
treme island (circles),
island (stars) and banana
(dots). Time refers to the onset of each outburst.
19
Fig. 5.— Light curve of the second X-ray outburst
(upper panel) and the corresponding color-color di-
agram. The terms high and low refer to the high-
intensity and low-intensity points of the flares.
20
Fig. 6.— Power spectra and best fits for different positions in the color-color diagram (see Table 3) The lines
represent the different noise components as follows: for the island states, Lb (dashed), Lh (dotted), Lℓ (dot-dashed)
and Lu (dot-dot-dot-dashed); for the banana state LLV LF N (dashed), LHV LF N (dotted), Lb (dot-dashed), Lb 2
(dot-dot-dot-dashed). The second dashed line in BS1 corresond to Lℓ .
21
Fig. 7.— Characteristic frequency of the Lh and Lℓ
noise components of the atoll sources 4U 1608–52,
4U 1728–34 and 4U 0614+09 (dots) and the HBO
of the Z sources GX 5-1 (stars) as a function of the
characteristic frequency of the band-limited noise (Lb
for the atoll sources and HBO for GX5–1). Aquila X –
1 observations have been represented by open circles.
22
Fig. 8.— Comparison of the power spectra for three
different parts of the X-ray outburst. All three power
spectra correspond to the same region of the CD. An
enlarged view of the island state marking the color
region is also plotted.
23
Fig. 9.— N/FBO-like feature in the power spectra of
Aquila X – 1 during the peak of outbursts 3 and 5.
24
|
0709.3175 | 1 | 0709 | 2007-09-20T10:25:17 | A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS observed by the submillimeter array | [
"astro-ph"
] | Circumstellar disks are expected to form early in the process that leads to the formation of a young star, during the collapse of the dense molecular cloud core. It is currently not well understood at what stage of the collapse the disk is formed or how it subsequently evolves. We aim to identify whether an embedded Keplerian protoplanetary disk resides in the L1489 IRS system. Given the amount of envelope material still present, such a disk would respresent a very young example of a protoplanetary disk. Using the Submillimeter Array (SMA) we have observed the HCO$^+$ $J=$ 3--2 line with a resolution of about 1$''$. At this resolution a protoplanetary disk with a radius of a few hundred AUs should be detectable, if present. Radiative transfer tools are used to model the emission from both continuum and line data. We find that these data are consistent with theoretical models of a collapsing envelope and Keplerian circumstellar disk. Models reproducing both the SED and the interferometric continuum observations reveal that the disk is inclined by 40$^\circ$ which is significantly different to the surrounding envelope (74$^\circ$). This misalignment of the angular momentum axes may be caused by a gradient within the angular momentum in the parental cloud or if L1489 IRS is a binary system rather than just a single star. In the latter case, future observations looking for variability at sub-arcsecond scales may be able to constrain these dynamical variations directly. However, if stars form from turbulent cores, the accreting material will not have a constant angular momentum axis (although the average is well defined and conserved) in which case it is more likely to have a misalignment of the angular momentum axes of the disk and the envelope. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. ms
July 16, 2021
c(cid:13) ESO 2021
7
0
0
2
p
e
S
0
2
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
5
7
1
3
.
9
0
7
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around
L1489 IRS observed by the Submillimeter Array
C. Brinch1, A. Crapsi1, J. K. Jørgensen2,3, M. R. Hogerheijde1, and T. Hill1
1 Leiden Observatory, P.O. Box 9513, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands
e-mail: [email protected]
2 Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Mail Stop 42, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
3 Argelander-Institut fur Astromomie, Universitat Bonn, Auf dem Hugel 71, 53121 Bonn, Germany
ABSTRACT
Context. Circumstellar disks are expected to form early in the process that leads to the formation of a young star, during the
collapse of the dense molecular cloud core. It is currently not well understood at what stage of the collapse the disk is formed
or how it subsequently evolves.
Aims. We aim to identify whether an embedded Keplerian protoplanetary disk resides in the L1489 IRS system. Given the
amount of envelope material still present, such a disk would respresent a very young example of a protoplanetary disk.
Methods. Using the Submillimeter Array (SMA) we have observed the HCO+ J = 3 -- 2 line with a resolution of about 1′′. At
this resolution a protoplanetary disk with a radius of a few hundred AUs should be detectable, if present. Radiative transfer
tools are used to model the emission from both continuum and line data.
Results. We find that these data are consistent with theoretical models of a collapsing envelope and Keplerian circumstellar
disk. Models reproducing both the SED and the interferometric continuum observations reveal that the disk is inclined by 40◦
which is significantly different to the surrounding envelope (74◦).
Conclusions. This misalignment of the angular momentum axes may be caused by a gradient within the angular momentum
in the parental cloud or if L1489 IRS is a binary system rather than just a single star. In the latter case, future observations
looking for variability at sub-arcsecond scales may be able to constrain these dynamical variations directly. However, if stars
form from turbulent cores, the accreting material will not have a constant angular momentum axis (although the average is well
defined and conserved) in which case it is more likely to have a misalignment of the angular momentum axes of the disk and
the envelope.
Key words. Stars: formation -- circumstellar matter -- ISM: individual objects: L1489 IRS -- Submillimeter
1. Introduction
Circumstellar disks constitute an integral part in the for-
mation of low-mass protostars, being a direct result of the
collapse of rotating molecular cloud cores and the likely
birthplace of future planetary systems. When a molecu-
lar cloud core collapses to form a low-mass star, its initial
angular momentum causes material to pile up on scales
of ∼ 100 AU in a circumstellar disk (Cassen & Moosman
1981; Terebey et al. 1984; Adams et al. 1987, 1988). Due
to accretion processes as the young stellar object (YSO)
evolves, the disk grows in size while the envelope dissi-
pates (e.g., Basu 1998; Yorke & Bodenheimer 1999). In
the more evolved stages of young stellar objects such disks
can be imaged directly at optical and near-infrared wave-
lengths (e.g., Burrows et al. 1996; Padgett et al. 1999)
and their chemical and dynamical properties can be de-
rived from comparison to submillimeter spectroscopic ob-
servations (e.g., Thi et al. 2001). Still, this latter method
is often not unique, but requires a priori assumptions
about the underlying disk structure. In the earlier em-
bedded stages this method is even more complex, be-
cause the disk is still deeply embedded in cloud ma-
terial so that any signature of rotation in the disk it-
self, for example, is smeared out by emission that orig-
inates in the still collapsing envelope. By going to higher
resolution using interferometric observations, as well as
observing high density gas tracers, more reliable detec-
tions of protoplanetary disks can be made as direct imag-
ing is approached (Rodr´ıguez et al. 1998; Qi et al. 2004;
Jørgensen et al. 2005b). In this paper we present such
high-angular resolution submillimeter wavelength obser-
vations from the Submillimeter Array (SMA) of the em-
bedded YSO L1489 IRS. We show how these observations
place strong constraints on its dynamical structure and
evolutionary status through detailed modeling.
2
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
L1489 IRS (IRAS 04016+2610) is an intriguing pro-
tostar in the Taurus star forming region (d = 140 pc)
classified as a Class I YSO according to the classification
scheme of Lada & Wilking (1984). It is still embedded in
a large amount of envelope material in which a significant
amount of both infall and rotation has been observed on
scales ranging from a few tenths of an AU out to several
thousands of AUs (Hogerheijde 2001; Boogert et al. 2002).
This large degree of rotation makes this source an inter-
esting case study for the evolution of angular momentum
during the formation of low-mass stars, potentially linking
the embedded (Class 0 and I) and revealed (Class II and
III) stages.
In a recent study by Brinch et al. (2007) (referred
to as Paper I), a model of L1489 IRS was presented
based on data from a large single-dish molecular line sur-
vey (Jørgensen et al. 2004). This study was motivated by
the intriguing peculiarities seen in L1489 IRS, such as the
unusual large size and shape of the circumstellar material.
The aim was to constrain the structure of its larger-scale
infalling envelope and to place it in the right context of
the canonical picture of low-mass star formation (see for
example several reviews in Reipurth et al. 2007).
The model presented in Paper I describes a flattened
envelope with an inspiraling velocity field, parameterized
by the stellar mass and the (constant) angle of the field
lines with respect to the azimuthal direction. A spherical
temperature profile was adopted and the model did not
explicitly contain a disk. The mass of the envelope is 0.09
M⊙, adopted from Jørgensen et al. (2002). The use of such
a "global" model is sufficient when working with single-
dish data, where the emission is dominated by the emission
from the large-scale envelope. With this description it was
possible to accurately reproduce all the observed single-
dish lines.
What the study of Paper I could not address,
is
whether a rotationally dominated disk is present on scales
of the order of hundreds of AUs, although the amount of
rotation which is inferred by the single-dish observations
certainly suggests that a disk should have formed. In ad-
dition, two specific puzzles remain about the structure of
L1489 IRS inferred on basis of the model when compared
to other studies in the literature. First, the best fit was ob-
tained with a central mass of 1.35 M⊙, which is a very high
value given that the luminosity of the star has been deter-
mined to be only 3.7 L⊙ (Kenyon et al. 1993). Second, it
was found that the best fit inclination of the system was
74◦. This is in agreement with the result from Hogerheijde
(2001) where they showed that in order to reproduce the
observed aspect ratio the inclination cannot be less than
60◦. However, in a recent study, Eisner et al. (2005), mod-
eled the spectral energy distribution (SED) of L1489 IRS
and demonstrated that this required a significantly differ-
ent systemic inclination of only 36◦.
In this paper, we try to address these issues through
arc second scale interferometric observations of the dense
gas tracer HCO+ J = 3− 2 from the Submillimeter Array.
These observations provide information on the gas dynam-
ics on scales ∼100 AU and reveal an embedded proto-
planetary disk. We show how careful modeling of the full
SED from near-infrared through millimeter wavelengths
can place strong constraints on the geometry of such a
disk.
The outline of this paper is as follows: Sect. 2 describes
the details of the observations and data reduction while
Sect. 3 presents the data. Sect. 4 introduces our model in
which we have now included a disk and we also show how
this model can fit all available observations including our
new SMA data. Finally, in Sect. 5 and 6 we discuss the
implications of our model and summarize our results.
2. Observations and data reduction
Observations were carried out at the Submillimeter Array
(SMA)1 located on Mauna Kea, Hawaii. Our data set
consists of two separate tracks of measurements in dif-
ferent array configurations. The first track was obtained
on December 11, 2005. This track was done in the com-
pact configuration resulting in a spatial resolution of ∼
2.5′′ with projected baselines ranging between 10 and 62
kλ. A second track was obtained on November 28, 2006,
in the extended configuration with the resolution of about
1′′ and baselines between 18 and 200 kλ. The resolution of
the two configurations corresponds to linear sizes of 350
AU and 140 AU respectively. The synthesized beam size
of the combined track using uniform visibility weighting
is 0.9′′× 0.7′′ with a position angle of 78◦.
In both tracks the receiver was tuned to HCO+ J = 3 --
2 at 267.56 GHz. We used a correlator configuration with
high spectral resolution across the line, providing a chan-
nel width of 0.2 kms−1 over 0.104 GHz. The remainder of
the 2 GHz bandwidth of the SMA correlator was used to
measure the continuum. No other lines in this band are
expected to contaminate the continuum. We did not en-
counter any technical problems during observations and
the weather conditions were excellent during both tracks.
For the compact configuration track, τ225 was 0.06 and for
the extended track τ225 was at 0.08.
Mars was used as flux calibrator in the first track, and
Uranus for the second track. The quasars 3c454.3, 3c273,
and 3c279 were used for passband calibration for both
tracks, while the complex gains were calibrated using the
two quasars 3c111 and 3c84 located within 18 degrees from
L1489 IRS. The calibrators were measured every 20 min-
utes throughout both tracks. Their fluxes have been de-
termined to be 3.1 and 2.6 Jy for 3c111 and 3c84 in the
compact track, and 2.3 and 2.2 Jy respectively in the ex-
tended track. For the gain calibration, a time smoothing
scale of 0.7 hours was used which ensures that the large
scale variations in the phase during the track are corrected
for. The data do not show any significant small scale varia-
tions (i.e., rapid fluctuations in the phases or amplitudes).
1 The Submillimeter Array is a joint project between the
Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory and the Academia
Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics and is funded
by the Smithsonian Institution and the Academia Sinica
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
3
Table 1. Summary of the SMA observations.
Source
α, δ(2000)a
Frequency
Integrated line intensity
Peak line intensity
Noise level (rms)
Continuum flux
Noise level (rms)
Synthesized beam size
(Uniform weighting)
L1489 IRS
04:04:42.85, +26:18:56.3
267.55762 GHz (1.12 mm)
41.85 Jy beam−1 km s−1
2.04 K
0.35 Jy beam−1
36.0±2.3 mJy
3.7 mJy beam−1
0.9′′ × 0.7′′
a Coordinates are given at the position where the continuum
emission peaks.
The quasars appear as point sources even at the longest
baselines, which means that phase decorrelation due to
atmospheric turbulence is negligible. The signal-to-noise
of the calibrators is >50 per integration.
The data were reduced using the MIR software pack-
age (Qi 2005)2. Due to the excellent weather conditions,
the data quality is very high and the data reduction proce-
dure went smooth and unproblematic. All post-processing
of the data, including combining the two visibility sets
was done using the MIRIAD package (Sault et al. 1995)3.
Relevant numbers are presented in Table 1.
In this paper we also make use of continuum measure-
ments of L1489 IRS found in the literature ranging from
the near-infrared (Kenyon et al. 1993; Eisner et al. 2005;
Padgett et al. 1999; Park & Kenyon 2002; Whitney et al.
1997; Myers et al.
2005)
to (sub)millimeter wavelengths (Hogerheijde & Sandell
2000; Moriarty-Schieven et al. 1994; Motte & Andr´e 2001;
Hogerheijde et al. 1997; Ohashi et al. 1996; Saito et al.
2001; Lucas et al. 2000).
1987; Kessler-Silacci et al.
3. Results
The two tracks of observations provide us with two sets
of (u, v) -- points which, when combined and Fourier trans-
formed, samples the image (x, y) plane well from scales
of 1 to 30′′ (140 to 4200 AU). Emission on spatial scales
greater than this is filtered out by the interferometer due
to its finite shortest spacing. This filtering is accounted
for when comparing models to the observations.
The measured continuum emission is shown as an im-
age in Fig. 1. Previous attempts to measure the contin-
uum at 1.1 mm with the BIMA interferometer were not
successful (Hogerheijde 2001). The SMA however, reveals
a complex and detailed, slightly elongated, structure.
Two reconstructed images of the HCO+ emission are
shown in Fig. 2 using the natural and uniform weight-
ing schemes, optimizing the signal-to-noise and angular
resolution, respectively. In this figure, the zero moment
map is plotted as solid contour lines and the first moment
2 Available at http://cfa-www.harvard.edu/∼cqi/mircook.html.
3 Available at http://bima.astro.umd.edu/miriad/miriad.html
Fig. 1. Reconstructed image of the continuum emission
at the highest resolution (0.9′′× 0.7′′). The contours are
linearly spaced with 1σ starting at 2σ and dashed lines
are negative contour levels.
is shown as shaded contours. It is clear that both im-
ages reveal an elongated, flat structure. In the uniformly
weighted image there is a large amount of asymmetry in
the structure, which is less prominent in the naturally
weighted image.
The velocity contours in the lower panel of Fig. 2 are
seen to be closed around a point which is offset with
some 3′′ from the peak of the emission. There is also
clearly a gradient in the velocity field along the major
axis of the object. This feature was previously reported
by Hogerheijde (2001) using interferometric observations
of HCO+ J = 1 -- 0, and low S/N HCO+ J = 3 -- 2 obser-
vations, from the BIMA and OVRO arrays. The gradient
in the velocity field coincides almost perfectly with the
long axis of the structure. When compared to the BIMA
HCO+ J = 3 -- 2 observations, the SMA data give 5 -- 10
times better resolution. Furthermore, the BIMA data had
to be self-calibrated using the HCO+ J = 1 -- 0 image as a
model and thus the resulting image was somewhat depen-
dent of the structure of the lower excitation emission. The
image we obtain from the SMA data is of considerably
better quality.
In Fig. 3, the zero moment emission contours have
been superposed on the near-infrared scattered light im-
age taken by the Hubble Space Telescope (Padgett et al.
1999). The figure shows that many of the details in the
SMA image coincide with features seen in the scattered
light image.
The spectral map in Fig. 4 shows single spectra at po-
sitions offset by 2′′ from each other. Each position shown
here is the spectrum contained within one synthesized
beam. The center most spectrum coincides with the peak
of the emission in Fig. 2. Here is seen a very broad, dou-
ble peaked line. Moving outward from the center, the lines
become single peaked and offset in velocity space with re-
4
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
Fig. 3. HCO+ emission (1σ) contours superposed on the
near-infrared scattered light image (Padgett et al. 1999).
)
c
e
s
c
r
a
(
δ
∆
4
2
0
−2
−4
4
2
0
∆α (arcsec)
−2
−4
Fig. 4. Spectral map of L1489 IRS. The spectra are evenly
spaced with 2′′. The bandwidth in each panel is 20 kms−1.
The scale on the y-axis goes from 0 to 2 Jybm−1.
where the protoplanetary disk is expected to be present
(see Section 1). Furthermore, the HCO+ J = 3 -- 2 transi-
tion traces H2 densities of 106 cm−3 or more (Schoier et al.
2005), which are expected in the inner envelope and disk.
The model of Paper I was not explicitly made to mimic
a disk, but rather to describe the morphology of the im-
ages on large scales. Using this model, which works well
on a global scale, we can explore how well it fits the SMA
spectra when extrapolated to scales unconstrained by the
single-dish observations.
Fig. 2. Zero and first moment plots of the HCO+ J = 3 -- 2
emission toward L1489 IRS. Contours are linearly spaced
by 2σ with a clip level of 2σ. σ equals 1.1 and 2.0 Jy bm−1
km s−1 for the natural and uniform weighting schemes
respectively. Negative contours appear as dashed lines.
spect to the systemic velocity. Perpendicular to the long
axis of the structure, the line intensity falls off quickly.
The lines shown in Fig. 4 are reconstructed using the nat-
ural weighting scheme. For the remainder of this paper we
will use the uniformly weighted maps where the resolution
is optimal.
Fig. 5 shows the emission in a position-velocity dia-
gram, where the image cube has been sliced along the
major axis to produce the intensity distribution along the
velocity axis. The PV -- diagram shows almost no emission
in the second and fourth quadrant which is a strong indica-
tor of rotation. The small amount of low velocity emission
seen close to the center in the fourth quadrant may be
accounted for by infalling gas.
4. Analysis
With the resolution provided by the SMA it is possible to
probe the central parts of L1489 IRS on scales of ∼100 AU,
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
5
Fig. 6. This figure shows three spectra from the SMA observations with model spectra superposed. The two off-
positions are chosen in the direction along the long axis of the object. The offsets are chosen to be a resolution
element. Three models are also shown: The dashed line shows the unmodified model from Paper I, the full line is the
model from Paper I, but inclined at 40◦, and the dotted line shows a model where HCO+ is absent on scales smaller
than 200 AU.
To check that this emission does in fact originate from
scales less than 200 AU, a model where HCO+ is com-
pletely absent within a radius of 200 AU is also shown in
Fig. 6 with the dotted line. In this model the wide wings
disappear and only a very narrow line is left. The two off-
positions, which lie outside of the radius of 200 AU, are
not affected minimally introducing this cavity.
Fig. 6 also shows a spectrum which is made from the
Paper I model, but inclined at 40◦ (full line). This is a
considerably better fit than the other two models (again
the two off-positions are little affected). While the obser-
vations of the larger scale structure (Paper I, Hogerheijde
(2001)) demonstrates that the inclination of the flattened,
collapsing envelope is ∼74◦, the SMA observations sug-
gest that a change in the inclination occurs on scales of
100 -- 200 AU, reflecting a dynamically different component
there. On the other hand, since the model of Paper I was
tuned to match the single-dish observation on scales of
∼1000 AU or more and did not explicitly take the disk
into account it is not unexpected that it does not fully
reproduce the SMA observations.
4.1. Introducing a disk model
To reproduce also the interferometric observations we have
modified the model from Paper I on scales corresponding
to the innermost envelope and disk: The improvements
consists largely of two things, namely a different parame-
terization of the density distribution and the explicit in-
clusion of a disk.
The description used in Paper I has a discontinuity
for small values of r and θ: again, this is not a problem
when working with the large scale emission, but becomes
a problem when interfaced with a disk where a contin-
uous transition from envelope to disk is preferred. The
Fig. 5. Position-Velocity (PV) diagram. This plot shows
that the emission on the scales measured by the SMA is
entirely dominated by rotation. The black curves show
the Keplerian velocity, calculated from the dynamic mass
(1.35 M⊙) obtained in Paper I. The curves have been in-
clination corrected with 74◦ for the full lines and 40◦ for
the dashed lines. Contours start at 2σ and increase with
1σ = 0.12 Jy beam−1.
Fig. 6 compares the SMA observations to the predic-
tions of this model (dashed line). For doing this compari-
son, the model is imaged using the (u, v)-spacings from the
observations, so that directly comparable spectra are ob-
tained. While the spectra away from the center are fairly
well reproduced in terms of line width, the center position
is too wide, i.e., the model produces velocities that are too
extreme compared to the measured velocities.
6
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
new parameterization we use for the envelope is adopted
from Ulrich (1976). In this representation the envelope
density is given by,
Rrot(cid:19)−1.5(cid:18)1 +
ρenv(r, θ) = ρ0(cid:18) r
×(cid:18) cos θ
2 cos θ0
cos θ
cos θ0(cid:19)−1/2
cos 2θ0(cid:19)−1
,
+
Rrot
r
(1)
90
30
is
the solution of
where θ0
the parabolic motion
of an infalling particle given by r/Rrot(cos θ0 −
cos θ)/(cos θ0 sin 2θ0) = 1, Rrot = 150 AU is the centrifu-
gal radius of the envelope, and ρ0 is the density on the
equatorial plane and at the centrifugal radius. Since the
outer radius, total mass, aspect ratio, and peak density
are held fixed, the new parameterization is qualitatively
similar to the Plummer-like profile used in Paper I. The
numerical value of Rrot is chosen so that the maximum
deviation in density in the (r, θ)-plane only reaches 20%
in the most dense parts (outside of the disk cavity) and
has an average deviation of less than 5%.
7
0
1
108
109
106
In addition to this envelope, a generic disk is also in-
troduced in the model. The density of the disk is given
by,
Fig. 7. A slice through the model of L1489 IRS: The top
panels show the temperature on different scales and the
bottom panels show the corresponding density profiles.
ρdisk(r, θ) =
Σ0 (r/R0)−1
√2π H0
exp(−
1
2(cid:20) r cos θ
H0 (cid:21)2) ,
(2)
where θ is the angle from the axis of symmetry, R0 is the
disk outer radius and H0 is the scale height of the disk. The
model thus has four free parameters: disk radius, pressure
scale height, mass (taken as a fraction of the total mass
of the circumstellar material), and inclination. In order to
maximize the mid-infrared flux, we use a flat disk, i.e.,
with no increase in scale height with radius and fix the
scale height to 0.25. The outer radius is fixed to 200 AU,
the distance from the center of the emission in Fig. 2 to
the position of the closed velocity contour, thereby effec-
tively reducing the number of free parameters to two. This
outer disk radius is not a strongly constrained parameter
since neither the SED nor the model spectra are influ-
enced much by changes in this value. It is only possible to
rule out the extreme cases, where the disk either gets so
small that it is no longer influencing the SED or where it
gets so big that it holds a significant fraction of the total
mass. We find that the best fit is provided by a disk mass
of Mdisk = 4 × 10−3 M⊙. A cross section of the model is
shown in Fig. 7.
The velocity field in the envelope is similar to the one
used in Paper I, where the velocity field was parameterized
in terms of a central mass and an angle between the ve-
locity vector and the azimuthal direction, so the the ratio
of infall to rotation could be controlled by adjusting this
angle. The best fit parameter values obtained in Paper I of
1.35M⊙ for the central mass and flow lines inclined with
15◦ with respect to the azimuthal direction, are used. No
radial motions are allowed in the disk: only full Keplerian
motion is present in the region of the model occupied by
the disk.
In order to produce synthetic observations which can
be directly compared to the data, we use numerical ra-
diative transfer tools. The 3D continuum radiative trans-
fer code RADMC (Dullemond & Dominik 2004) is used
to calculate the scattering function and the temperature
structure in the analytical axisymmetric density distribu-
tion. In these calculations, the luminosity measurement
by Kenyon et al. (1993) of 3.7 L⊙ is used for the central
source. The solution is then "ray -- traced" using RADICAL
(Dullemond & Turolla 2000) to produce the spectral en-
ergy distribution and the continuum maps at the observed
frequencies. In both RADMC and RADICAL we assume
certain properties of the dust. We use the dust opacities
that give the best fit to extinction measurements in dense
cores (Pontoppidan et al., in prep).
The same density and temperature structure are af-
terward given as input to the excitation and line radia-
tive transfer code RATRAN (Hogerheijde & van der Tak
2000) which is used to calculate the spatial and frequency
dependent HCO+ J = 3 -- 2 emission. The HCO+ mod-
els are post-processed with the MIRIAD tasks uvmodel,
invert, clean, and restore to simulate the actual SMA ob-
servations.
4.2. Modeling the continuum emission
In Fig. 8, we compare our model to the continuum obser-
vations. We calculate (u, v) -- amplitudes at 1.1 mm which
we plot on top of the observed amplitudes. The result is
in good agreement with the data, suggesting that the dust
emission is well-described by our parameterization down
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
7
Fig. 8. The averaged (u, v) -- amplitudes of the contin-
uum at 1 mm in both compact and extended config-
urations. The full
line show our model. The compact
configuration visibilities cover the (u, v) -- distance up to
60 kλ. The black triangle marks the total flux at 1
mm (Moriarty-Schieven et al. 1994). The histogram indi-
cates the zero-signal expectation values.
Fig. 9. The model spectral energy distribution assuming
inclinations of 40◦ (full line) and 50◦ and 74◦ (broken
lines) plotted on top of flux measurements from the liter-
ature (marked by crosses) and the Spitzer/IRS spectrum
from 2 -- 40 microns (red line).
to scales of ∼ 100 AU. This comparison is not very de-
pendent on the inclination, since the continuum emission
is quite compact. For this particular figure, an inclination
of 40◦ is assumed.
Recently, Eisner et al. (2005) modeled the SEDs of a
number of Class I objects in Taurus including L1489 IRS.
The model used in their work is parameterized differently
from ours, but it essentially describes a similar structure.
As pointed out above, Eisner et al. find a best fit inclina-
tion of 36◦ in contrast to the inclination of 74◦ found in
Paper I.
To test the result of Eisner et al. (2005) we calculated
the SED using the described model with only the system
inclination as a free parameter (Fig. 9). The best fit is
found for an inclination of about 40◦, in good agreement
with the result of Eisner et al. (2005). The models with
inclinations of 50◦ and 74◦, are also plotted in Fig. 9 in
order to show how the SED depends on inclination.
Note that the quality of our best fit to the SED is
comparable to the fit presented by Eisner et al. (2005),
whereas the fit becomes rapidly worse with increasing
inclination larger than 40◦, thus bringing about dis-
agreement with the results from (Hogerheijde 2001) and
Paper I. The three different models plotted in Fig. 9 can-
not be distinguished for wavelength above ∼60 µm, which
corresponds to a temperature of about 40 K using Wiens
displacement law. This temperature occurs on radial dis-
tances of approximately 100 AU from the central object
which means that outside of this radius, the SED is no
longer sensitive to the inclination. We interpret this be-
havior as a change in the angular momentum axis on disk
scales, causing the disk to be inclined with respect to the
envelope.
Fig. 10. Three transitions of HCO+ observed by single-
dish telescope (see Paper I for details) with our model
superposed. The quality of the fit is comparable to the fit
in Paper I although a disk model has now been included.
4.3. Modeling the HCO+ emission
In Paper I it was found that the characteristic double peak
feature of the HCO+ J = 4 -- 3 line could not be reproduced
with an inclination below 70◦. On the other hand including
a disk inclined by 40◦ into the model of Paper I does not
alter the fit to the single dish lines (Fig 10): the geometry
and the velocity field of the material at scales smaller than
∼300 AU does not influence the shape of these lines. This
fit is not perfect though as it still overestimates the red-
shifted wing in the J = 3 -- 2 line and the width of the J =
1 -- 0 line slightly, but the quality of the fit is similar to that
presented in Paper I.
We need to test how well this tilted disk model works
with the line observations from the SMA. It was shown in
Sect. 4 that the off-position spectra are weakly dependent
on changes in the inclination and that the same is true
when using the model where the disk is tilted with respect
8
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
Fig. 11. The SMA spectrum towards the center of
L1489 IRS with our model, consisting of a disk which is
inclined with respect to the envelope, superposed. As in
Fig. 6, the model has been imaged with the (u, v)-spacings
from the observations.
Fig. 12. Similar to Fig. 8 but for the HCO+ J = 3 -- 2
measurements. The triangle marks the total flux obtained
from the single dish observations. The amplitudes have
been averaged over ±5 kms−1 relative to the systemic ve-
locity. The histogram indicates the zero-signal expectation
values. The insert is an enlargement of the longest base-
lines.
to the envelope. The central position however, is seen in
Fig. 11 to be very well reproduced in terms of line width
and wing shape by this model. The model spectrum is
slightly more asymmetric than the data, which means that
the infall to rotation ratio is not quite correct on disk
scales. The magnitude of the velocity field projected onto
our line of sight is correct though, since the width of the
line is well fit.
We also compared the averaged (u, v) -- amplitudes to
evaluate the quality of our model similar to the pro-
cedure for the continuum. Fitting the (u, v) -- amplitudes
in this way tests whether the model produces the right
amount of emission at every scale. The best fit is shown
in Fig. 12. The zero-spacing flux has been shown in this
plot as well, marked by the black triangle. This method
has previously been used to study the abundance varia-
tions of given molecules in protostellar envelopes, in par-
ticular imaging directly where significant freeze-out occurs
in protostellar envelopes (Jørgensen 2004; Jørgensen et al.
2005a). The model does a good job reproducing the ob-
served HCO+ brightness distribution on almost all scales
with a constant abundance, except around 20 -- 40 kλ where
it overestimates the amount of observed flux. This corre-
spond to a radius of about 1000 AU, that is well outside
of the disk. On the other hand single-dish observations
of low-mass protostellar envelopes suggest that these are
scales where significant freeze-out in particular of CO may
occur at temperatures . 20 − 30 K, which because of
the gas-phase chemical relation between CO and HCO+
also reflects directly in the observed distribution of HCO+
(e.g., Jørgensen et al. 2004, 2005b). Despite this, the dif-
ference between the model prediction and observations is
small with this constant abundance, suggesting that the
amount of freeze-out is small in L1489 IRS. This is in
agreement with the single-dish studies of Jørgensen et al.
(2002, 2004, 2005b), who generally found little depletion
in the envelopes of L1489 IRS and other Class I sources
in contrast to the more deeply embedded, Class 0, proto-
stars.
The model parameter values obtained in this section
including values from Paper I are summarized in Table 2.
The best fit values that are derived in this paper are tuned
by hand rather than systematically optimized by a χ2 min-
imization method. Therefore we can only give an estimate
on the uncertainties. However, Fig. 9 shows that the SED
fit gets rapidly worse when changing the inclination, and
given the strong dependence of the envelope inclination
on the single-dish lines, we estimate that both angles are
accurate to within 10◦. For the disk mass and radius, the
uncertainties on the parameter values are less well defined
for reasons given in Section 4.1, but we estimate an accu-
racy within a factor of 2 in each of these parameters.
5. Discussion
It seems that depending on the physical size scales that
we probe, the solution favors a different inclination. When
taking all available observations into account we need to
introduce a model where the angular momentum vector
of the disk is misaligned with the angular momentum vec-
tor of the (rotationally flattened) envelope. We adopt a
two component model (illustrated in Fig. 13), disk and
envelope, but in reality, the angular momentum axis may
indeed be a continuous function of radius on the scales
of the disk (. a few hundred AU). The origin of such a
misalignment can actually be explained in a simple way
by considering the initial conditions of the collapse.
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
9
Table 2. Model parameter values
Envelope
Outer radiusa
Envelope massa
Inclinationa,b
HCO+ abundancea
Value
2000 AU
0.093 M⊙
74◦
3.0×10−9
Disk
Radiusb
Disk massb
Inclinationb
Scale heightc
Central massa
Central luminosityc
Distancec
Value
200 AU
4×10−3 M⊙
40◦
z=0.25R
1.35 M⊙
3.7 L⊙
140 pc
a Values from Paper I
b Fitted values
c Values adopted from the literature
ω
envelope
ω
disk
L.O.S.
4000 AU
500 AU
Fig. 13. An (exaggerated) illustration of the proposed
model where the angular momentum axis is changing with
radius. The line of sight is illustrated by the dashed line.
The state of a pre-stellar core before the gravitational
collapse begins is typically described by a static sphere
with a solid body rotation perturbation (Terebey et al.
1984). Due to strict angular momentum conservation, such
a model would be perfectly aligned throughout the col-
lapse and consequently disk formation models are often
described numerically by axisymmetric representations
(e.g., Yorke & Bodenheimer 1999).
However, there is no a priori reason why a pre-stellar
core should rotate as a solid body. Of course the cloud has
an average angular momentum which on a global scale de-
termines the axis of rotation. The cloud does not collapse
instantly to form a disk though, but rather from the in-
side and out as described by Shu (1977), and therefore a
shell of material from deep within the cloud, which may
very well have an average angular momentum that is dif-
ferent from the global average, will collapse and form a
disk before material from further out has had a change to
accrete yet. Actually, if the parental cloud is turbulent,
it is to be expected that the accreting material has ran-
domly oriented angular momentum and a misalignment of
the angular momentum on different scales is more likely
than a perfect alignment. In this way, a system similar to
the model proposed to describe L1489 IRS in this paper
can be formed.
To obtain a gradient in the angular momentum as ini-
tial condition for the collapse, one may consider a cloud
which is not spherically symmetric or one which does not
collapse around its geometrical center but rather around
an over dense clump offset from the center. The former sce-
nario may indeed be true for the case of L1489 IRS which
is seen to be dynamically connected to a neighboring cloud
(which was also modeled in Paper I to explain the excess
of cold emission seen in some of the low-J lines). Actually,
the uniformly weighted moment map (Fig. 2) shows sig-
nificant asymmetry with a secondary emission peak to the
north-east.
It is interesting to note that the HCO+ emission from
the SMA observations agree very well with the near-
infrared image (Fig. 3): the secondary peak, a few arc sec-
onds northeast of the main continuum and HCO+ peaks,
nicely coincides with a bright spot in the scattered light
image and also the shape of the cavity towards the south
follows the contours of the HCO+ emission. The same de-
tails are not revealed in the naturally weighted SMA im-
age, in which shorter baselines are given more weight. We
thus conclude that by going to the extended SMA config-
uration, it is possible to probe structure in YSOs on the
same scales as can be resolved by large near-infrared tele-
scopes such as the Hubble Space Telescope. The structure
seen in both images, however, also emphasizes that for
a fully self-consistent description of L1489 IRS, a global
non-axisymmetric model has to be considered.
Another (non-exclusive) explanation of a misaligned
disk would be that L1489 IRS formed as a triple stellar
system and, that due to gravitational interaction, one of
the stars was ejected. L1489 IRS would thus be a binary
system as suggested by Hogerheijde & Sandell (2000). The
loss of angular momentum due to the ejection would result
in a rearrangement of the remaining binary, which could
"drag" the inner viscous disk along. Such a scenario has
been investigated numerically by Larwood et al. (1996). In
the case of L1489 IRS, it would have to be a very close bi-
nary with a separation of no more than a few AUs since the
near-infrared scattered light image (Padgett et al. 1999)
with a resolution of ∼0.2′′ (30 AU), does not reveal mul-
tiple sources. The ratio of binary separation to disk ra-
dius is therefore significantly lower than the cases investi-
gated by Larwood et al. (1996) and it is therefore not clear
whether similar effects could be present in L1489 IRS.
If indeed the system is binary, it would resolve the
issue that we find a central mass of 1.35 M⊙ while the
luminosity is estimated to be 3.7 L⊙ (Kenyon et al. 1993).
A single young star that massive would require a much
higher luminosity, but two stars of 0.6 -- 0.7 M⊙ would fit
nicely with the estimated luminosity since luminosity is
not a linear function of mass for YSOs.
10
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
To test whether L1489 IRS indeed is a binary and to
constrain the innermost disk geometry on AU scales, mea-
surements of temporal variability in super high resolution
are needed. The timescale for variations of a possible bi-
nary is of the order of years depending on the exact sepa-
ration of the stars (assuming scales of 1 AU). Such obser-
vations would, for example, be feasible with ALMA.
6. Conclusion
In this paper, we have presented high angular resolution
interferometric observations of the low-mass Class I YSO
L1489 IRS. The observations reveal a rotationally dom-
inated, very structured central region with a radius of
about 200 -- 300 AU. We interpret this as a young Keplerian
disk which is still deeply embedded in envelope material.
This conclusion is supported by a convincing fit with a
disk model to the SED.
We conclude further that the inclination of the disk is
not aligned with the inclination of the flattened envelope
structure, due to the possibility that L1489 IRS is a binary
system and/or that the average angular momentum axis
of the cloud is not aligned with the angular momentum
axis of the dense core that originally collapsed to form the
star(s) plus the disk.
We find that a disk with a mass of 4 × 10−3 M⊙, a
radius of 200 AU, and a pressure scale height of z=0.25R
is consistent with both the SED and the HCO+ observa-
tions. Only a small amount of chemical depletion of HCO+
is allowed for, due to a slight over-estimate of the (u, v) --
amplitudes at 20 -- 40 kλ by our model, in agreement with
the results from previous single-dish studies and the na-
ture of L1489 IRS as a Class I YSO.
The combination of a detailed modeling of the SED
with spatially resolved line observations, which contains
information on the gas kinematics, appears to be a very
efficient way of determining the properties of disks, es-
pecially embedded disks which are not directly observable.
Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Kees
Dullemond for making his code available to us. CB is
supported by the European Commission through the
FP6 - Marie Curie Early Stage Researcher Training
programme. JKJ acknowledges support from an SMA
fellowship. AC was supported by a fellowship from
the European Research Training Network "The Origin
of Planetary Systems" (PLANETS, contract number
HPRN-CT-2002-00308). The research of MRH and AC
is supported through a VIDI grant from the Netherlands
Organiztion for Scientific Research.
References
Basu, S. 1998, ApJ, 509, 229
Boogert, A. C. A., Hogerheijde, M. R., & Blake, G. A.
2002, ApJ, 568, 761
Brinch, C., Crapsi, A., Hogerheijde, M. R., & Jørgensen,
J. K. 2007, A&A, 461, 1037
Burrows, C. J., Stapelfeldt, K. R., Watson, A. M., et al.
1996, ApJ, 473, 437
Cassen, P. & Moosman, A. 1981, Icarus, 48, 353
Dullemond, C. P. & Dominik, C. 2004, A&A, 417, 159
Dullemond, C. P. & Turolla, R. 2000, A&A, 360, 1187
Eisner, J. A., Hillenbrand, L. A., Carpenter, J. M., & Wolf,
S. 2005, ApJ, 635, 396
Hogerheijde, M. R. 2001, ApJ, 553, 618
Hogerheijde, M. R. & Sandell, G. 2000, ApJ, 534, 880
Hogerheijde, M. R. & van der Tak, F. F. S. 2000, A&A,
362, 697
Hogerheijde, M. R., van Dishoeck, E. F., Blake, G. A., &
van Langevelde, H. J. 1997, ApJ, 489, 293
Jørgensen, J. K. 2004, A&A, 424, 589
Jørgensen, J. K., Bourke, T. L., Myers, P. C., et al. 2005a,
ApJ, 632, 973
Jørgensen, J. K., Schoier, F. L., & van Dishoeck, E. F.
2002, A&A, 389, 908
Jørgensen, J. K., Schoier, F. L., & van Dishoeck, E. F.
2004, A&A, 416, 603
Jørgensen, J. K., Schoier, F. L., & van Dishoeck, E. F.
2005b, A&A, 435, 177
Kenyon, S. J., Calvet, N., & Hartmann, L. 1993, ApJ, 414,
676
Kessler-Silacci, J. E., Hillenbrand, L. A., Blake, G. A., &
Meyer, M. R. 2005, ApJ, 622, 404
Lada, C. J. & Wilking, B. A. 1984, ApJ, 287, 610
Larwood, J. D., Nelson, R. P., Papaloizou, J. C. B., &
Terquem, C. 1996, MNRAS, 282, 597
Lucas, P. W., Blundell, K. M., & Roche, P. F. 2000,
MNRAS, 318, 526
Moriarty-Schieven, G. H., Wannier, P. G., Keene, J., &
Tamura, M. 1994, ApJ, 436, 800
Motte, F. & Andr´e, P. 2001, A&A, 365, 440
Myers, P. C., Fuller, G. A., Mathieu, R. D., et al. 1987,
ApJ, 319, 340
Ohashi, N., Hayashi, M., Kawabe, R., & Ishiguro, M. 1996,
ApJ, 466, 317
Padgett, D. L., Brandner, W., Stapelfeldt, K. R., et al.
1999, AJ, 117, 1490
Park, S. & Kenyon, S. J. 2002, AJ, 123, 3370
Qi, C. 2005, The MIR Cookbook, The Submillimeter
Array/Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics
Qi, C., Ho, P. T. P., Wilner, D. J., et al. 2004, ApJ, 616,
L11
Reipurth, B., Jewitt, D., & Keil, K., eds. 2007, Protostars
and Planets V (University of Arizona Press)
Rodr´ıguez, L. F., D'Alessio, P., Wilner, D. J., et al. 1998,
Nature, 395, 355
Adams, F. C., Lada, C. J., & Shu, F. H. 1987, ApJ, 312,
Saito, M., Kawabe, R., Kitamura, Y., & Sunada, K. 2001,
788
Adams, F. C., Shu, F. H., & Lada, C. J. 1988, ApJ, 326,
865
ApJ, 547, 840
Sault, R. J., Teuben, P. J., & Wright, M. C. H. 1995,
Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems IV,
C. Brinch et al.: A deeply embedded young protoplanetary disk around L1489 IRS
11
77, 433
Schoier, F. L., van der Tak, F. F. S., van Dishoeck, E. F.,
& Black, J. H. 2005, A&A, 432, 369
Shu, F. H. 1977, ApJ, 214, 488
Terebey, S., Shu, F. H., & Cassen, P. 1984, ApJ, 286, 529
Thi, W. F., van Dishoeck, E. F., Blake, G. A., et al. 2001,
ApJ, 561, 1074
Ulrich, R. K. 1976, ApJ, 210, 377
Whitney, B. A., Kenyon, S. J., & Gomez, M. 1997, ApJ,
485, 703
Yorke, H. W. & Bodenheimer, P. 1999, ApJ, 525, 330
|
astro-ph/0010187 | 1 | 0010 | 2000-10-10T14:28:59 | Lensing in the Hercules Supercluster | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report Keck LRIS observations of an arc-like background galaxy near the center of Abell 2152 (z=0.043), one of the three clusters comprising the Hercules supercluster. The background object has a redshift z=0.1423 and is situated 25 arcsec north of the primary component of the A2152 brightest cluster galaxy (BCG). The object is about 15 arcsec in total length and has a reddening-corrected R-band magnitude of $m_R = 18.55\pm0.03$. Its spectrum shows numerous strong emission lines, as well as absorption features. The strength of the H-alpha emission would imply a star formation rate $\SFR \approx 3h^{-2} \msun $yr$^{-1}$ in the absence of any lensing. However, the curved shaped of this object and its tangential orientation along the major axis of the BCG suggest lensing. We model the A2152 core mass distribution including the two BCG components and the cluster potential. We present velocity and velocity dispersion profile measurements for the two BCG components and use these to help constrain the potential. The lens modeling indicates a likely magnification factor of $\sim1.9$ for the lensed galaxy, making A2152 the nearest cluster in which such significant lensing of a background source has been observed. Finally, we see evidence for a concentration of early-type galaxies at $z=0.13$ near the centroid of the X-ray emission previously attributed to A2152. We suggest that emission from this background concentration is the cause of the offset of the X-ray center from the A2152 BCG. The background concentration and the dispersed mass of the Hercules supercluster could add further to the lensing strength of the A2152 cluster. | astro-ph | astro-ph | To appear in AJ, January 2001
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj
0
0
0
2
t
c
O
0
1
1
v
7
8
1
0
1
0
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
LENSING IN THE HERCULES SUPERCLUSTER1
John P. Blakeslee2,3,4, Mark R. Metzger3, Harald Kuntschner2, and Patrick Cot´e3,5,6
To appear in AJ, January 2001
ABSTRACT
We report Keck LRIS observations of an arc-like background galaxy near the center of Abell 2152
(z = 0.043), one of the three clusters comprising the Hercules supercluster. The background object has
a redshift z = 0.1423 and is situated 25′′ north of the primary component of the A2152 brightest cluster
galaxy (BCG). The object is about 15′′ in total length and has a reddening-corrected R-band magnitude
of mR = 18.55 ± 0.03. Its spectrum shows numerous strong emission lines, as well as absorption features.
The strength of the Hα emission would imply a star formation rate SFR ≈ 3 h−2 M⊙ yr−1 in the absence
of any lensing. However, the curved shaped of this object and its tangential orientation along the major
axis of the BCG suggest lensing. We model the A2152 core mass distribution including the two BCG
components and the cluster potential. We present velocity and velocity dispersion profile measurements
for the two BCG components and use these to help constrain the potential. The lens modeling indicates a
likely magnification factor of ∼ 1.9 for the lensed galaxy, making A2152 the nearest cluster in which such
significant lensing of a background source has been observed. Finally, we see evidence for a concentration
of early-type galaxies at z = 0.13 near the centroid of the X-ray emission previously attributed to A2152.
We suggest that emission from this background concentration is the cause of the offset of the X-ray center
from the A2152 BCG. The background concentration and the dispersed mass of the Hercules supercluster
could add further to the lensing strength of the A2152 cluster.
Subject headings: galaxies: clusters: individual (Abell 2152) -- galaxies: elliptical and lenticular, cD --
gravitational lensing
1.
INTRODUCTION
Strong gravitational lensing of background sources by
clusters of galaxies provides some of the most unambigu-
ous evidence for the presence of large amounts of dark
matter in clusters. Lensing studies suggest that the mass
in clusters is greater and more centrally concentrated than
implied, for instance, by the X-ray properties (e.g., Mel-
lier, Fort, & Kneib 1993; LeF`evre et al. 1994; Waxman
& Miralda-Escude 1995; Smail et al. 1995). Moreover,
the mass appears to clump around the luminous galaxies,
so that consideration of substructure and the effect of the
massive central galaxy are often important for understand-
ing the observations (e.g., Miralda-Escud´e 1995; see also
Tyson, Kochanski, & Dell Antonio 1998). This is partic-
ularly true in more moderate mass clusters with velocity
dispersions σcl ∼< 1000 km s−1, for which the proportion-
ally larger gravitational effects of a massive cD must be
included to properly account for the lensing (Williams,
Navarro, & Bartelmann 1999).
Although there have been great advances in our knowl-
edge of the form of the density distributions of massive
dissipationless particles in simulations of various resolu-
tion (e.g., Dubinski & Carlberg 1991; Navarro, Frenk, &
White 1996, 1997; Moore et al. 1998, 1999b), our knowl-
edge of the central mass distributions of actual galaxy clus-
ters remains fragmentary. Low redshift clusters, because
of their larger angular sizes, can in principle provide a
better opportunity for studying these mass distributions.
Their lensing properties are acutely sensitive to the shape
of the inner cluster potential, although because such clus-
ters tend to be of modest mass (very high-mass clusters
being few and far between), the individual galaxies will
produce relatively larger perturbations on this potential,
complicating the interpretation.
Until recently, moderate- to high-redshift clusters have
been the exclusive purview of strong lensing studies, but
lensing by low-redshift clusters has been gaining increased
attention. For instance, Allen, Fabian, & Kneib (1996)
discovered a redshift z = 0.43 lensed arc in the massive
cooling flow cluster PKS 0745 -- 191 at z = 0.103. Campu-
sano, Kneib, & Hardy (1998) explored lensing models for
a z = 0.073 spiral galaxy located near the central ellip-
tical in the richness class 0 cluster A3408 at z = 0.042;
they obtained an upper limit to the magnification factor
of ∼1.7 from their "maximum mass" model. This object
turned out to be the only viable lensing candidate found
in an imaging survey of 33 southern galaxy clusters with
z ≤ 0.076 by Cypriano et al. (2000), who also presented
an estimate of the expected number of arcs and arclets in
low-redshift clusters. Blakeslee & Metzger (1999) discov-
ered a lensed arc at z = 0.573 in the nearby cD cluster
A2124 at z = 0.066 and found magnification factors near
1Based on observations obtained at the W.M. Keck Observatory, which is jointly operated by the California Institute of Technology, the
University of California, and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
2Department of Physics, University of Durham, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, United Kingdom
3California Institute of Technology, Mail Stop 105-24, Pasadena, CA 91125
4Current address: Department of Physics and Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218
5Sherman M. Fairchild Fellow
6Current address: Department of Physics and Astronomy, Rutger University, 136 Frelinghuysen Road, Piscataway NJ, 08854-8019
1
2
Lensing in Hercules
10 from their best-fitting models of this system.
Despite the recent progress, the lensing properties of
low-redshift clusters remain unclear. For instance, A2124
had by far the lowest redshift in the sample studied by
Williams et al. (1999) of 24 lensing clusters with measured
velocity dispersions, the next nearest being at z = 0.171.
In this paper, we present imaging and spectroscopic obser-
vations and give a lensing analysis of the redshift z = 0.043
cluster Abell 2152 in the Hercules supercluster.
2. CLUSTER PROPERTIES
The Hercules supercluster is a close grouping of three
Abell clusters: the richness class 2 cluster A2151 (the clas-
sical "Hercules cluster") and the two richness 1 clusters
A2147 and A2152, all at z ∼ 0.04. The supercluster was
first identified by Shapley (1934). Although A2151 domi-
nates from the standpoint of the number of galaxies, A2152
is projected closest to the center of the grouping, which is
< 4 h−1 Mpc) in diame-
so tight that a circle of just 2◦ ( ∼
ter easily encompasses all three clusters. Two other Abell
clusters, A2148 and A2107, lie at about the same redshift
and are only ∼ 15 h−1 Mpc away. At lower density en-
hancements, the Hercules supercluster forms part of an ex-
tended, filamentary supercluster that includes A2162 and
A2197/A2199 about 3000 km s−1 in the foreground and
A2052/A2063 about 3000 km s−1 in the background (Abell
1961; Postman, Huchra, & Geller 1992). This extended
ten-cluster supercluster includes more members than any
other supercluster in the Postman et al. (1992) catalogue.
All three members of the Hercules supercluster proper
are classified as Bautz-Morgan type III, Rood-Sastry class
F clusters (Abell et al. 1989; Struble & Rood 1987), in-
dicating morphological irregularity and perhaps dynami-
cal youth. All three have relatively high spiral fractions,
with that of A2151 being near 50% (Tarenghi et al. 1980).
A2151 is also famous for its high degree of internal sub-
clustering (e.g., Bird et al. 1995). A2152, the focus of
this paper, has two bright early-type galaxies at its center
(see Figure 1) that together are designated UGC 10187.
The brighter component (NED 02) was chosen by Post-
man & Lauer (1995) as the A2152 brightest cluster galaxy
(BCG) and has a redshift z = 0.0441. The other compo-
nent (NED 01) is 47′′ to the northwest and about 0.5 mag
fainter; Postman & Lauer classify it as the second ranked
galaxy (SRG). The SRG has a relative velocity of +330
km s−1 with respect to the BCG (see §3.3).
Because A2152 and A2147 are separated by just
1.8 h−1 Mpc, measurements of their velocity dispersions
are problematic. Zabludoff et al. (1993) reported σcl =
1081 km s−1 for A2147 and σcl = 1346 km s−1 for A2152,
the latter being the highest dispersion in their sample of 25
"dense peaks." Recently, Barmby & Huchra (1998) have
carried out a detailed analysis of the Hercules supercluster
kinematics using 414 galaxy velocities. These authors em-
ployed a four-component model, including the three Abell
clusters and a "dispersed supercluster" component. They
derived much lower velocity dispersions of 821+68
−55 km s−1
and 715+81
−61 km s−1 for A2147 and A2152, respectively,
from 93 and 56 galaxy velocities.
Because 122 galaxies in the Barmby & Huchra sample
are assigned to the dispersed component with a high ve-
locity dispersion of 1407 km s−1, rather than to one of
the individual clusters, this approach may tend to bias
the cluster dispersions low. However, it is clearly more
consistent in finding a mean redshift of hzi = 0.0432 for
A2152, much closer to that of the BCG, whereas previous
studies found means 10 -- 15% lower, near the mean values
for A2147 and A2151. Moreover, the lower velocity disper-
sions are more in line with the X-ray properties of these
clusters, e.g., the X-ray gas temperature in A2152 has been
estimated from Einstein data to be kTX = 2.1 keV (White,
Jones, & Forman 1997). We note, however, that the latest
tabulation by Struble & Rood (1999) lists hzi = 0.0398
and σcl = 1338 km s−1 for A2152 from 62 velocities.
The centroid of the X-ray emission associated with
A2152 is not coincident the BCG but is about 2.′1 east. Its
position is within 40′′ of a pair of bright early-type galax-
ies which the Barmby & Huchra redshift catalogue reveals
to be at z = 0.134. Each of these background galaxies is
intrinsically ∼ 70% more luminous than the A2152 BCG
(using a relative K-correction of 0.11 mag for ellipticals).
We return to this point in §5.
3. OBSERVATIONS
A2152 was observed as part of the deep R-band Keck
imaging study by Blakeslee (1999) of the BCG halo regions
in six nearby rich clusters. Clusters were selected to have
velocity dispersions similar to that of the Coma cluster
and to lie in the redshift range cz = 10,000 -- 20,000 km s−1.
These six were then observed because they were reachable
during a single night in the northern spring. Based on
this dataset, Blakeslee & Metzger (1999) reported follow-
up spectroscopy of a magnitude mR = 20.86 lensed arc
located 27′′ from the center of the cD galaxy in Abell
2124. We have visually searched the dataset for other
bright lensing candidates, based on proximity to the BCG,
tangential orientation, and arc-like appearance. The only
obvious bright candidate was an arc-like object in A2152.
We obtained follow-up Keck spectroscopy for this object
and the A2152 BCG/SRG pair.
3.1. Imaging Data
The imaging observations have already been described
in detail by Blakeslee (1999). Here we summarize them
and report new photometric results for the A2152 arclet.
A2152 was imaged with the Low Resolution Imaging Spec-
trograph (LRIS, Oke et al. 1995) on the Keck II tele-
scope under photometric conditions. The image scale was
0.′′211 pix−1, and the total integration was 2000 s in the
R band. Reductions were carried out using the Vista
package. The seeing in the final stacked image was an
exceptional 0.′′53. The photometry was calibrated to the
Cousins R band using Landolt (1992) standard stars; the
photometric zero point is accurate to better than 0.02 mag.
Figure 1 displays the A2152 Keck LRIS image, a smaller
portion of which was shown by Blakeslee (1999). The pos-
sible lensed galaxy (galaxy "A") is located 25.′′2 from the
center of the BCG at a position angle PA = 11.◦4. The ma-
< 15′′, where the
jor axis of the BCG is at 11◦ ± 2◦ at radii ∼
ellipticity (difference of the axis ratio from unity) of the
light distribution is ǫℓ = 0.10. Beyond this radius the BCG
isophotes have significant overlap with those of the SRG
and they are sufficiently round that the angle is difficult
to determine. The isophotes of the SRG show significant
twisting; the PA of its major axis swings from 170◦ at
Blakeslee, Metzger, Kuntschner, & Cot´e
3
r ∼< 5′′ to ∼ 136◦ by r ≈ 25′′, while the ellipticity stays
fairly constant around ǫℓ = 0.32 ± 0.03.
G1/G2 are in the background with redshifts of z = 0.1335
and z = 0.1353, respectively. During our spectroscopic ob-
servation of the BCG/SRG (described in §3.3), the LRIS
slit picked up the magnitude mR = 19.2 galaxy labeled
G3, which turns out to have z = 0.1326. Galaxy "M" is
an A2152 member with a velocity within ∼ 100 km s−1
of the BCG (Barmby & Huchra). The center of the X-ray
emission in this field (Jones & Forman 1999) is 20′′ from
G2 and 50′′ from G1 and is also labeled in Figure 1.
Figure 2 shows an enlarged view of galaxy A along with
an isophotal contour map. The impression is that of a
disk galaxy whose disk has been warped into an arc-like
shape (arguably through lensing, as we discuss in §4). The
object is visible in our image for a length of about 15′′.
The measured full-width at half maximum along the mi-
nor axis is 0.′′67, which would be about FWHM ∼ 0.′′4 in
the absence of atmospheric blurring. This translates to a
< 0.7 h−1 kpc at the redshift of this object (see
metric size ∼
below); apparently it has a very compact nucleus. The to-
tal magnitude of A, corrected for 0.105 mag of R-band
Galactic extinction (Schlegel, Finkbeiner, & Davis 1998),
is mR(arc) = 18.55 ± 0.03. Our main measurement results
are collected in Table 1.
3.2. Spectroscopy of Galaxy A
The simplest and most important test of gravitational
lensing is whether or not the supposed lensed object is
actually in the background. Thus, we obtained one 900 s
spectrum of galaxy A with LRIS on the Keck II telescope
on the night of 25 March 1999 (UT). We used a 300 line
grating and a 1′′ wide slit oriented at PA = 113◦, approx-
imately along the major axis of galaxy A. The seeing was
poor, about 1.′′8, so the slit missed a good fraction of the
light. The dispersion was 2.44 A pix−1, and the effective
resolution was about 10 A (FWHM). Halogen flats and
arc-lamp exposures were taken for calibration. The LRIS
configuration and IRAF reductions were identical to those
of Blakeslee & Metzger (1999), except that no flux stan-
dard spectrum was obtained.
Fig. 2. -- Two views of the possibly lensed galaxy in A2152
(galaxy A). North is up and east is to the left. The top view
shows a 1′ × 1′ region of the R-band LRIS image centered on
the galaxy. The stretch is linear, and a model of the BCG/SRG
halo light has been subtracted. The cross marks the center of
the subtracted BCG, which is 25′′ from A. The lower panel
zooms in by a factor of two, showing an isophotal contour
map of the 30′′ square region around A. The outermost con-
tour is at an extinction-corrected surface brightness of 24.8
mag arcsec−2, corresponding 2.0% of the sky level in the image,
and the other contours are in steps of 1 mag. The curvature
of the object is apparent in both panels.
All galaxies with known redshifts (either from Barmby
& Huchra or the present study) are labeled in Figure 1. It
is somewhat curious that of 7 galaxies (including galaxy A)
in the central ∼ 6′ field of a rich cluster, only 3 turn out to
be cluster members. As mentioned above, the galaxy pair
Figure 3 shows the reduced 1-d spectrum of galaxy A
with the strongest emissions lines labeled at top and some
absorption lines labeled at the bottom. The emission ap-
peared to be confined to the central ∼ 4′′ of the galaxy, so
this is all that was extracted. The spectrum is of very high
signal-to-noise (it was not a priori obvious, in the absence
of spiral structure or any spectral information, that there
whould be such strong features), and we determine the
redshift to be z = 0.1423 ± 0.0001. The object is therefore
about 3.3 times more distant than the intervening A2152
cluster, and the lensing hypothesis remains viable. If un-
lensed, the absolute magnitude of A, with a K-correction
of 0.05 mag, would be MR = −20.57 (for h = 0.7 and
Ω=0; MR = −21.22 for h = 0.5 and Ω=1), or a luminosity
of about 0.48 L∗
R (e.g., Lin et al. 1996).
The Hα emission line has an equivalent width of
EWHα = 117 ± 6 A, corrected for [N II] emission. The
Hβ equivalent width is EWHβ = 28.2 ± 2.0 A. The [O II]
λ3727 and [O III] λ5007 lines have equivalent widths of
83.3 ± 2.3 Aand 54.1 ± 2.0 A, respectively. Thus, the emis-
sion is quite strong, but not too anomalous in compari-
son to many late-type spirals or irregulars (e.g., Kennicutt
1992).
4
Lensing in Hercules
Fig. 3. -- Reduced 1-d spectrum of galaxy A. The redshift is z = 0.1423. Various emission lines are identified above the spectrum
and some absorption features are labeled at bottom, including the Ca II H and K lines, G band, Mg b, and Na D. The atmospheric
A and B absorption bands are also labeled; A-band absorption affects the [Sr II] lines, but not Hα.
Although we do not have a good absolute flux calibra-
tion of the spectrum, we can roughly estimate the star for-
mation rate (SFR) from the Hα equivalent width and the
R-band luminosity. We use the spectrophotometric syn-
thesis results of Fukugita, Shimasaku, & Ichikawa (1995)
to calibrate the absolute flux in Cousins R, which has an
effective wavelength of 6588 A. About 75% of the R-band
light comes from the region of emission within the galaxy,
and from the measured Hα equivalent width we obtain a
flux fHα ≈ 7.38 × 10−15 ergs s−1 cm−2 and a luminosity of
LHα ≈ 1.84 × 1041 h−2 ergs s−1 (Ω = 0). To estimate the
internal extinction, we perform a makeshift relative flux
calibration using the Feige 110 spectrum from Blakeslee &
Metzger (1999) and find an Hα-to-Hβ flux ratio of 4.25;
assuming an unextincted value of 3.0 and the extinction
curve of Cardelli, Clayton & Mathis (1989) gives a cor-
rection at Hα of a factor of 2.15. This is close to the
"canonical" correction of ∼1 mag for spirals (e.g., Kenni-
cutt 1992) but will yield a SFR 16% lower. Finally, using
the updated calibration from Kennicutt (1998), we find
SFR ≈ (3 ± 1) h−2 M⊙ yr−1, or (6 ± 2) M⊙ yr−1 for a typi-
cal H0. Though not qualifying as a "starburst galaxy," the
SFR is quite substantial for a 0.5 L∗ galaxy. The quoted
errorbar is approximate and reflects mainly the ∼ 30%
scatter quoted by Kennicutt. The calibration based on
[O II] equivalent width yields nearly the same SFR for
this galaxy.
3.3. Kinematics of the Central Galaxy
With the intent of improving the constraints on the
A2152 potential for the lensing models, we obtained three
1100 s spectra of the BCG/SRG pair with LRIS on 16 June
1999. We again used a 1′′ wide slit but the 900/5500 grat-
ing, yielding a dispersion of 0.84 A pix−1. The slit was
oriented at PA = 122◦ in order to pass through the cen-
ters of the two galaxies. Again, halogen flats and arc lamps
were taken for calibration, and we also obtained spectra
of the K4 III velocity standard HD 213947. The spectra
were processed, wavelength calibrated, and rectified using
standard IRAF routines.
Figure 4 displays the central 1.′′1 extracted from the re-
duced 2-d spectra. Although the spectra are clearly very
similar, the BCG exhibits a small amount of Hβ emission
that is absent from the SRG. Such optical line emission
is quite common among central cluster galaxies, and may
be associated with cluster "cooling flows" (e.g., Crawford
et al. 1999). This emission may therefore be evidence that
the BCG is indeed at the center of the A2152 cluster po-
tential and that the offset of the Jones & Forman (1999)
X-ray position is due to contamination from a background
X-ray source.
The kinematical analysis of the data was performed
within the MIDAS package. First, the spectra were re-
binned along the slit (spatial direction) in order to achieve
a minimum signal-to-noise (S/N) of 30 per A at all radii.
The S/N of the central pixels is higher. Then the contin-
uum was removed by a fifth order polynomial fit. Finally
we determined the velocity dispersion and rotational ve-
locity as a function of radius with the Fourier Correlation
Quotient (FCQ) method (Bender 1990) allowing only for
a Gaussian stellar velocity distribution. When we allowed
for non-Gaussian distributions and fitted for the higher-
order moments, the results for the rotational velocity and
Blakeslee, Metzger, Kuntschner, & Cot´e
5
dispersion were unchanged within the errors but showed
slightly more scatter at the largest radii. The detailed
FCQ setup, such as continuum fit order, wavelength ex-
traction and error estimation was optimized with Monte
Carlo simulations.
Fig. 4. -- The central 1.′′1 extracted from the 2-d spectra of
the BCG and SRG (observed simultaneously through the slit)
are illustrated. The spectra have been deredshifted for pur-
poses of comparison. Some emission is visible within the Hβ
absorption at λ = 4861 A in the spectrum of the BCG, but not
in the SRG.
Figure 5 shows the measured velocity and velocity dis-
persion profiles for the BCG and SRG. Note that the 122◦
position angle is ∼ 70◦ away from the major axis of the
BCG, and so the profile is more appropriate to the minor
axis. For the SRG, the PA is closer to the major axis. Both
galaxies show significant rotation, and both rotate in the
sense opposite to that of the combined BCG/SRG system.
Although the velocity dispersions decline outward from the
centers of the galaxies, the dispersion profile for the SRG
appears to flatten at a value of σ ∼ 230 km s−1 outside
the central 3′′. Likewise, the BCG's velocity dispersion
> 7′′. As
profile does not show a significant decrease for r ∼
seen in the top panel of Figure 5, the center of rotation
in the BCG is offset by about 0.′′2 (1 LRIS pixel) from
the luminosity center; this is likely due to a slight offset
of the galaxy center within the slit. The mean velocities,
rotational velocities, and central dispersions are tabulated
along with our other results in Table 1.
We have estimated the total (1-sigma) errors on the
mean velocities to be ±25 km s−1, but this is dominated by
zero-point calibration errors (flexure, illumination of slit,
etc.). However, the relative velocity of the BCG/SRG pair
is better determined at ∆v = 331±7 km s−1. This accords
well with previous measurements of ∆v = 327±100 km s−1
from Tarenghi et al. (1979) and ∆v = 341±50 km s−1 from
Wegner et al. (1999); less well with ∆v = 502 ± 21 km s−1
from Davoust & Consid`ere (1995). (The velocities used
by Barmby & Huchra for these two galaxies come from
Tarenghi et al.).
Fig. 5. -- Velocity and dispersion profiles for the BCG and
SRG (labeled). Note that the radial coordinate defined here
increases to the southeast along the slit, i.e., the BCG is in the
direction of positive radius with respect to the SRG. Thus, the
point in the SRG's dispersion profile at (r, σ) = (8.′′6, 291) may
be beginning to show the effects of the BCG halo light.
Central velocity dispersions have been measured previ-
ously for the BCG by Oegerle & Hoessel (1991), who found
σ0 = 295±25 km s−1, and by Wegner et al. (1999), who re-
ported σ0 = 280±26 km s−1; both results are in agreement
with our much more precise value of σ0 = 295 ± 7 km s−1.
For the SRG, we find a central dispersion of σ0 = 271 ± 8
km s−1, while Wegner et al. found σ0 = 313 ± 34 km s−1.
Their significantly higher dispersion is likely due to the
strong rotation in this galaxy, which these authors did not
account for when extracting the spectrum of the central
several arcseconds of the galaxy. Finally, our BCG mean
velocity is ∼ 2.5 σ discrepant with the Wegner et al. value,
which is higher by 95 km s−1, but it agrees within the er-
rors with the values from Tarenghi et al. (1979), Oegerle &
Hoessel (1991), and Davoust & Consid`ere (1995). No pre-
vious measurements of the rotation or dispersion profile in
either galaxy could be found.
Finally, as noted in §3.1, the LRIS slit picked up the
magnitude mR = 19.24 galaxy labeled G3 in Figure 1. We
find it to be in the background with a velocity cz = 39,738
km s−1. This is just ∼ 290 km s−1 less than the velocity
of G1 and ∼ 830 km s−1 less than that of G2.
6
Lensing in Hercules
4. IS IT LENSED?
To model A2152 as a lens, we use a potential of the form
(Blandford & Kochanek 1987)
mary lens (cluster dark matter) can reproduce the char-
acteristics of the arc. These models are degenerate in σ1D
and rc for determining the mass enclosed within the arc
radius. Model 1 fits within this family of models. Fig-
ure 6 shows the predicted magnifications from model 1
with a 10′′ core as a function of observed source position.
The position of galaxy A implies a magnification of ∼ 1.9,
dropping to ∼ 1.8 for a model with a 40′′ soft core. Given
this model, we can ask what the intrinsic source shape
of galaxy A would be; Figure 7 shows contours of the
observed galaxy surface brightness along with the same
contours mapped back to the source plane via the lens
equation. The implied shape is that of a fairly symmetric
galaxy with a disk and dominant bulge, with no indication
of a warp.
While we cannot make quantitative estimates of cluster
mass parameters with a single lensed galaxy, we find that
a simple model constructed from a low-dispersion cluster
centered at the BCG can produce the shear needed to ex-
plain the curved shape of the background galaxy from a
more symmetric source.
Indeed, galaxy A must be dis-
torted in some fashion by the foreground cluster, and we
can rule out two of our other three plausible models based
on the implied lensing geometry. We cannot, however,
rule out a low-dispersion cluster mass centered on the X-
ray center from lensing alone, although this would mean
galaxy A must be intrinsically warped. Another galaxy
with an unusual shape, elongated radially from the BCG
center, is visible about 11′′ to the east of the BCG (see
the upper panel of Fig. 2) and lies near some critical radii
of model 1.
If in the background, this galaxy may pro-
vide much better constraints on the shape of the inner
potential, however the redshift is unknown and we do not
attempt to model it here.
Fig. 6. -- Magnification of a background source at z = 0.142
produced by the simple lens model. The model shown has
σcl = 715 km s−1 with a 10 arcsec soft core, σBCG = 250
km s−1, and σSRG = 240 km s−1. Starting from the outside,
contours indicate magnifications of 1.5, 1.73, 2, 4, and 16. The
critical curve is near the magnification=16 contour, and a sec-
ond critical curve is present close to the center.
ψ(r′) = 4π(cid:16) σ1D
DS
1 +
c (cid:17)2 DLS
1
2
r′2
r2
c !
,
− 1
where σ1D is the line-of-sight velocity dispersion in the
limit r′ ≫ rc for the spherical case, DS and DLS are an-
gular size distances to the source and from the lens to
the source, respectively, and rc defines a softening radius.
An ellipticity parameter ǫp can be introduced through
r′2 = (1−ǫp)x2 + (1+ǫp)y2, where (x, y) are coordinates
aligned with the major and minor axes of the potential.
This represents a softened isothermal sphere for ǫp = 0
and provides a fairly good representation of the dark halo
potentials in the cores of clusters (e.g., Mellier et al. 1993;
Tyson et al. 1998). We use the more limited relation with
a fixed power law because there are too few lensing con-
straints in this system to differentiate various potential
profiles, and we have used only circularly symmetric po-
tentials as there is little constraint on the ellipticity.
We explored four different simple models for the lensing
potential. We included three terms in each of these mod-
els, corresponding to the smooth halo mass in the cluster
and the masses associated with the BCG and SRG. For the
latter two components, we use analytic potentials to ap-
proximate the velocity dispersions measured in §3.3 with
a small core.
In our model 1, the center of the cluster
potential was fixed at the cD center with an asymptotic
dispersion of σcl = 715 km s−1 as measured by Barmby &
Huchra (1998) and a softened core radius of 10′′. Model
2 also fixes the cluster potential at the BCG, but uses the
higher dispersion estimate of 1340 km s−1 (Struble & Rood
1999). Models 3 and 4 are the same as models 1 and 2, but
fix the cluster potential center at the X-ray center (while
of course keeping the BCG and SRG model components
fixed). Within each model, we also explored a range of
core softening radii.
Our primary constraints for the lens models are the ra-
dius, size, and orientation of galaxy A. The modest dis-
tortion and lack of a counterarc suggests a source position
that lies outside the tangential and radial caustics (e.g.,
Grossman & Narayan 1988) and whose image lies out-
side the critical curve. These constraints quickly rule out
model 2 in most forms: with a small core radius, the criti-
cal curve for z = 0.142 lies at around 35 arcsec, well outside
the galaxy radius. This would imply multiple images and
large distortions for galaxy A. Even with a large core ra-
dius, the effective radial magnification becomes large and
can be ruled out by the lens appearance. Model 3 does
not produce significant magnification or distortion for the
galaxy; thus under such a model, the arc-like shape would
need to be intrinsic. Model 4 produces shear and magni-
fication at the position of galaxy A, but the shear direc-
tion is not directed tangential to the BCG, as observed in
galaxy A.
Model 1, however, produces modest magnification and
distortion of a z = 0.142 source with a shear aligned tan-
gentially to the BCG/cluster. A family of models with a
range of core radii and asymptotic dispersions for the pri-
Blakeslee, Metzger, Kuntschner, & Cot´e
7
potential center is taken to coincide with the peak of the
overall X-ray emission. However, if the potential center
is taken to be the A2152 BCG, then the models can re-
produce the observed position and apparent bowed shape
of the galaxy, and the implied magnification is a factor of
about 1.9. Conversely, we can say that if the object is sig-
nificantly lensed, then the 2.′1 offset of the X-ray centroid
from the BCG is due to contamination from another source
of X-ray emission. We note that both the cluster veloc-
ity dispersion and the core softening radius in our lensing
model is degenerate with the source position. However,
the higher values that have been reported for the disper-
sion (see §2), if centered on the BCG, produce lens models
with critical curves that lie outside of the lensed galaxy,
thus multiple images would be expected of any background
galaxy at the position and redshift of A. We can therefore
rule out this case from a lensing argument; even a large
core radius model would produce significantly more dis-
tortion in a z = 0.142 galaxy.
The available redshift data provide evidence for a back-
ground association of early-type galaxies at z ≈ 0.134,
projected near the center of A2152. Two of the galaxies,
which we call G1/G2, have redshifts from the Barmby &
Huchra (1998) catalogue. They are separated by 30′′ and
are each about 70% more luminous than the A2152 BCG.
The third galaxy, called G3, is 35′′ southeast of the A2152
BCG and was picked up by the LRIS slit during our obser-
vations. It is 116′′ from G1 and 132′′ from G2, or metric
distances of 188-215 h−1 kpc. The velocity range for these
three galaxies is ∼ 830 km s−1. While three galaxies do
not a cluster make, the luminosities, velocities, and early-
type morphologies of the galaxies are highly suggestive.
Moreover, there is a strong concentration of small galaxies
of unknown redshift centered near the bright G1/G2 pair.
It is highly likely that some of the X-ray emission, which
is centered just 20′′ from G2, could be due to a grouping
of galaxies associated with G1/G2. Therefore, the cen-
ter of the true A2152 X-ray emission, and the center of
the A2152 cluster potential, might well coincide with the
A2152 BCG, as required by our lensing models. We note
that the centers of the outermost X-ray contours in the
Jones & Forman map of this field drift away from G1/G2
and closer to the A2152 BCG; the optical Hβ emission we
find in the BCG spectrum may be additional circumstan-
tial evidence for central location in the cluster potential.
However, a high-resolution X-ray map is needed to confirm
this hypothesis.
If there is a background cluster, galaxy A may well be
a member, in which case it would be falling away from
us through the cluster with a velocity of ∼ 2500 km s−1.
Simulations show that the tidal effects of clusters on in-
falling galaxies can warp spiral disks into arc-like shapes
(Moore et al. 1999a) and even form giant arcs of tidal de-
bris (Calc´aneo-Rold´an et al. 2000). Thus, tidal interaction
with a local cluster potential, rather than lensing by the
foreground A2152 potential, could be responsible for the
distorted appearance of the galaxy, as well as for the ob-
served strong star formation. Its location and orientation
with respect to the A2152 BCG would then be merely for-
tuitous. However, the galaxy in question would have to
be caught during its initial pass through the cluster, since
gas in cluster galaxies tends to be lost on relatively short
time-scales, truncating the star formation (e.g., Balogh
Fig. 7. -- Contours of the observed galaxy and the inferred
source contours from the simple lens model. The upper image
shows contours of the observed surface brightness of the lensed
galaxy A, spaced by factors of two. The lower image shows the
implied source position and the same surface brightness con-
tours on the source plane, i.e. how the galaxy would appear if
the foreground cluster were absent. The innermost contours,
less than 1′′ in size, are rounded in the observed image from
the seeing; therefore, these contours become artificially elon-
gated in the reconstructed source image. The coordinates are
centered on the BCG.
5. SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION
Deep R-band Keck imaging taken under excellent seeing
conditions has revealed a curved object 25.′′2 (15 h−1 kpc)
from the center of the A2152 BCG, along the major axis.
The reddening-corrected R magnitude of this "arc" is
mR = 18.55 ± 0.03, and follow-up spectroscopy shows that
it lies at a redshift z = 0.1423 ± 0.0001. Its position, ori-
entation, and redshift all suggest a lensing explanation for
the curiously bowed structure. The object has numerous
strong emission lines, and the equivalent width of Hα is
117 ± 6 A, from which we infer a star formation rate of
(3 ± 1) h−2 M⊙ yr−1.
We have presented spatially resolved spectroscopy of the
A2152 BCG and SRG, which are separated by 47′′ and are
together catalogued as UGC 10187. The relative velocity
of the BCG and SRG is 331 ± 7 km s−1, and both galaxies
show significant rotation. The rotational velocities along
the observed position angle are ∼ 50 km s−1 and ∼ 120
km s−1 for the BCG and SRG, respectively. Our velocity
dispersion profile for the BCG extends to a radius of ∼ 16′′
(9.5 h−1 Mpc), about 60% of the way to the radial position
of the lensed galaxy.
We have modeled the lensing potential of A2152 using
constraints from the measured cluster velocity dispersion
of 715 km s−1 and our own stellar velocity dispersion mea-
surements for the BCG and SRG. The models cannot pro-
duce a significant lensing effect on galaxy A if the A2152
8
Lensing in Hercules
et al. 1998; Kodama & Bower 2000). The probability that
galaxy A is a member of a cluster at z = 0.13 depends of
course on the velocity dispersion of the cluster. A deep
redshift survey of this field is needed to discern whether
or not there is a very substantial background cluster (as
suggested by the luminosities of G1/G2 and the position
of the X-ray center in this field), and how likely galaxy
A's membership is. Such a redshift survey would need to
go at least ∼ 2 mag fainter than the Barmby & Huchra
(1998) limit in order to pick up the multitude of small
galaxies that lie between the A2152 BCG/SRG pair and
the G1/G2 background pair.
Although superficially A2152 might have seemed an un-
remarkable low-redshift cluster (leaving aside the unlikely
velocity dispersions in excess 1300 km s−1 found in the lit-
erature), our photometric and spectroscopic observations
of its central field have raised a host of intriguing new
questions about this cluster and the arc-shaped galaxy
projected near its BCG. How much mass is there along
this line of sight and how is it distributed? Is the A2152
BCG actually at the center of the cluster potential and the
observed offset with respect to the X-ray center due to the
superposed emission of a background cluster at z = 0.13?
If so, is the distorted galaxy a member which is being
distorted by the hypothetical background cluster, or is it
a field galaxy being lensed by A2152? Along with high-
resolution X-ray observations and a deep redshift survey, a
weak lensing analysis of this field would help in unraveling
the projected mass distribution and provide insight into
these questions.
We believe that the weight of the evidence favors the
view that the A2152 BCG is at the center of its cluster's
potential and is significantly lensing galaxy A. Further
lensed objects, if present near critical curves, could pro-
vide useful future constraints on the central structure of
rich clusters. For now, however, a complete understand-
ing of this system and definitive answers to the questions
raised by this study must await an infusion of new data.
We thank Michael Balogh, Alastair Edge, Ben Moore,
Ian Smail, and Graham Smith for helpful conversations.
This work made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic
Database (NED), operated by the Jet Propulsion Labora-
tory at Caltech under contract with the National Aeronau-
tics and Space Administration. It also made use of Starlink
computer facilities. We are grateful to the team of scien-
tists and engineers responsible for producing the Low Res-
olution Imaging Spectrograph. J.P.B. and P.C. thank the
Sherman Fairchild Foundation for support while at Cal-
tech. M.R.M's research was supported by Caltech. J.P.B.
and H.K. were supported at the University of Durham by
a PPARC rolling grant in Extragalactic Astronomy and
Cosmology.
Note added in proof -- New multi-color data confirm the
presence of a rich background cluster around the z = 0.13
G1/G2 galaxy pair; analysis of these data will be presented
in a forthcoming paper.
REFERENCES
Abell, G. O. 1961, AJ, 66, 607
Abell, G. O., Corwin H. G. & Olowin, R. P. 1989, ApJS, 70, 1
Allen, S. W., Fabian, A. C. and Kneib, J. P. 1996, MNRAS, 279, 615
Balogh, M. L., Schade, D., Morris, S. L., Yee, H. K. C., Carlberg, R.
G. & Ellingson, E. 1998, ApJ, 504, L75
Barmby, P. & Huchra, J. P. 1998, ApJ, 115, 6
Bender, R. 1990, A&A, 229, 441
Bird, C. M., Davis, D. S., & Beers, T. C. 1995, AJ, 109, 920
Blakeslee, J. P. 1999, AJ, 118, 1506
Blakeslee, J. P. & Metzger, M. R. 1999, ApJ, 513, 592
Blandford, R. D. & Kochanek, C. S. 1987, ApJ, 321, 658
Calc´aneo-Rold´an, C., Moore, B., Bland-Hawthorn, J., Malin, D. &
Sadler, E. M. 2000, MNRAS, 314, 324
Campusano, L. D., Kneib, J.-P., & Hardy, E. 1998, ApJ, 496, L79
Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C. & Mathis, J. S. 1989, ApJ, 345, 245
Crawford, C. S., Allen, S. W., Ebeling, H., Edge, A. C. & Fabian, A.
C. 1999, MNRAS, 306, 857
Cypriano, E. S., Sodr´e, L., Campusano, L. E., Kneib, J.-P.,
Giovanelli, R., Haynes, M. P., Dale, D. A., & Hardy, E. 2000,
AJ, submitted (astro-ph/0005200)
Davoust, E. & Consid`ere, S. 1995, A&AS, 110, 19
Dubinski, J. and Carlberg, R. G. 1991, ApJ, 378, 496
Fukugita, M., Shimasaku, K., & Ichikawa T. 1995, PASP, 107, 945
Grossman, S. A. & Narayan R. 1988, ApJ, 324, L37
Jones, C. & Forman, W. 1999, ApJ, 511, 65
Kennicutt, R. C. 1992, ApJ, 388, 310
Kennicutt, R. C. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 189
Kodama, T. & Bower, R. G. 2000, MNRAS, submitted (astro-
ph/0005397)
Landolt, A. U. 1992, AJ, 104, 340
LeF`evre, O., Hammer, F., Angonin, M. C., Gioia, I. M., & Luppino,
G. A. 1994, ApJ, 422, L5
Lin, H., Kirshner, R. P., Shectman, S. A., Landy, S. D., Oemler, A.,
527, 535
Tucker, D. L., & Schechter, P. L., 1996, ApJ, 464, 60
Mellier, Y., Fort, B., & Kneib, J.-P. 1993, ApJ, 407, 33
Miralda-Escud´e, J. 1995, ApJ, 438, 514
Moore, B., Governato, F., Quinn, T., Stadel, J. & Lake, G. 1998,
ApJ, 499, L5
Moore, B., Lake, G., Quinn, T. & Stadel, J. 1999a, MNRAS, 304,
465
Moore, B., Quinn, T., Governato, F., Stadel, J. & Lake, G. 1999b,
MNRAS, 310, 1147
Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S., & White, S. D. M. 1996, ApJ, 462, 563
Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S. and White, S. D. M. 1997, ApJ, 490, 493
Oegerle, W. R. & Hoessel, J. G. 1991, ApJ, 375, 15
Oke, J. B., Cohen, J. G., Carr, M., Cromer, J., Dingizian, A., Harris,
F. H., Labrecque, S., Lucinio, R., Schaal, W., Epps, H., & Miller,
J. 1995, PASP, 107, 307
Postman, M. Huchra, J. P., & Geller, M. J. 1992, ApJ, 384, 404
Postman, M. & Lauer, T. R. 1995, ApJ, 440, 28
Schlegel, D., Finkbeiner, D., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525
Shapley, H. 1934, MNRAS, 94, 53
Smail, I., Hogg, D. W., Blandford, R., Cohen, J. G., Edge, A. C., &
Djorgovski, S. G. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 1
Struble, M. F. & Rood, H. J. 1987, ApJS, 63, 555
Struble, M. F. & Rood, H. J. 1999, ApJS, 125, 35
Tarenghi, M., Chincarini, G., Rood, H. J., & Thompson, L. A. 1980,
ApJ, 235, 724
Tarenghi, M., Tifft, W. G., Chincarini, G., Rood, H. J. & Thompson,
L. A. 1979, ApJ, 234, 793
Tyson, J. A., Kochanski, G. P., & Dell'Antonio, I. P. 1998 ApJ, 498
L107
Waxman, E. & Miralda-Escude, J. 1995, ApJ, 451, 451
Wegner, G., Colless, M., Saglia, R. P., McMahan, R. K., Davies, R.
L., Burstein, D. & Baggley, G. 1999, MNRAS, 305, 259
White, D. A., Jones, C., & Forman, W. 1997, MNRAS, 292, 419
Williams, L. L. R., Navarro, J. F., & Bartelmann, M. 1999, ApJ,
Zabludoff, A. I., Geller, M. J., Huchra, J. P., & Ramella, M. 1993,
AJ, 106, 1301
Blakeslee, Metzger, Kuntschner, & Cot´e
9
Table 1
Summary of Measurements
Object
quantity
value
Arclet
G3
Arclet
BCG
SRG
BCG
SRG
Arclet
BCG
SRG
G3
BCG
SRG
BCG
SRG
(a)
(a)
mR
mR
fwhm(b)
(c)
(c)
ǫℓ
ǫℓ
PA(d)
PA(d)
cz(e)
cz(e)
cz(e)
cz(e)
(f)
vm
vm
σ0
σ0
(g)
(g)
(f)
18.55
19.24
0.′′42
0.10
0.33
10.◦7
161.◦4
42665
13188
13519
39738
49
117
295
271
±
0.03
0.05
0.′′08
0.01
0.02
0.◦7
2.◦0
40
25
25
25
5
7
7
8
(a)R magnitude, corrected for Galactic extinction
(b)seeing-corrected FWHM along the minor axis of arclet
(c)ellipticity of the light distribution, at r = 10′′
(d)angle of major axis, east from north, at r = 10′′
(e)heliocentric redshift (km s−1)
(f)rotational velocity (km s−1) at r
> 5′′ and PA = 122◦
∼
(g)central velocity dispersion (km s−1)
fig1.gif
Fig. 1. -- An A2152 finding chart. The image was taken with Keck/LRIS through an R filter. The field is 5.′6 × 6.′0 in size,
and the bright galaxy at center is the A2152 BCG. Several other galaxies are labeled: the second-ranked cluster galaxy (SRG);
the arclet at z = 0.142 (A); three early-type galaxies all at z ≈ 0.133 (G1, G2, G3); and the only other galaxy in this field with
a known redshift (M). The redshifts of the BCG, SRG, and galaxy "M" are all z ≈ 0.044. For reference, the arclet is 25′′ from
the center of the BCG, and the BCG/SRG pair are separated by 47′′. The large "X" near the bright pair of background galaxies
G1/G2 marks the location of the centroid of the X-ray emission, normally attributed to A2152 (Jones & Forman 1999).
This figure "fig1.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0010187v1
|
0710.3911 | 1 | 0710 | 2007-10-21T09:06:10 | Helium stars as supernova progenitors | [
"astro-ph"
] | We follow the evolution of helium stars of initial mass $(2.2 - 2.5) M_\odot$, and show that they undergo off-center carbon burning, which leaves behind ${\mathbf \sim 0.01 M_\odot}$ of unburnt carbon in the inner part of the core. When the carbon-oxygen core grows to Chandrasekhar mass, the amount of left-over carbon is sufficient to ignite thermonuclear runaway. At the moment of explosion, the star will possess an envelope of several $0.1 M_{\odot}$, consisting of He, C, and possibly some H, perhaps producing a kind of peculiar SN. Based on the results of Waldman and Barkat (2007) for accreting white dwarfs, we expect to get thermonuclear runaway at a broad range of $\rho_c \approx (1 - 6) \times 10^9 \mathrm{g cm^{-3}}$, depending on the amount of residual carbon. We verified the feasibility of this scenario by showing that in a close binary system with initial masses $(8.5 + 7.7) M_{\odot}$ and initial period of 150 day the primary produces a helium remnant of $2.3 M_{\odot}$ that evolves further like the model we considered. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
**FULL TITLE**
ASP Conference Series, Vol. **VOLUME**, **YEAR OF PUBLICATION**
**NAMES OF EDITORS**
Helium stars as supernova progenitors
Roni Waldman 1, Lev R. Yungelson 2 and Zalman Barkat 1
Abstract. We follow the evolution of helium stars of initial mass (2.2 −
2.5) M⊙, and show that they undergo off-center carbon burning, which leaves
behind ∼0.01 M⊙ of unburnt carbon in the inner part of the core. When the
carbon-oxygen core grows to Chandrasekhar mass, the amount of left-over car-
bon is sufficient to ignite thermonuclear runaway. At the moment of explosion,
the star will possess an envelope of several 0.1 M⊙, consisting of He, C, and
possibly some H, perhaps producing a kind of peculiar SN. Based on the results
of Waldman & Barkat (2007) for accreting white dwarfs, we expect to get ther-
monuclear runaway at a broad range of ρc ≈ (1 − 6) × 109g cm−3, depending
on the amount of residual carbon. We verified the feasibility of this scenario by
showing that in a close binary system with initial masses (8.5 + 7.7) M⊙ and
initial period of 150 day the primary produces a helium remnant of 2.3 M⊙ that
evolves further like the model we considered.
1.
Introduction
Type Ia supernovae (SN Ia) have a relatively small dispersion of luminosity (the
standard deviation in peak blue luminosity is σB ≈ 0.4−0.5 mag., Branch & Miller
(1993)) and are being used as distance indicators ("standard candles"), having
especial significance in the effort of determining the cosmological parameters of
our universe.
The long-standing explanation of the SN Ia phenomenon has been the ex-
plosive burning of degenerate carbon in the core of a carbon-oxygen white dwarf,
which becomes unstable as it grows to Chandrasekhar mass (MCh) either by ac-
cretion from a binary companion or by a merger of two white dwarfs, following
the angular momentum loss from the system by gravitational wave radiation.
However, theoretical models are still far from self-consistently producing an evo-
lutionary path towards the progenitor and reproducing crucial features of the
observational data, such as the composition of the ejecta. For a detailed re-
view of the above see, e.g., Leibundgut (2000); Hillebrandt & Niemeyer (2000);
Filippenko (2005).
As well, SN Ia can not be regarded as perfectly homogeneous class, since
their Hubble diagram exhibits scatter larger than the photometric errors, while
spectroscopic and photometric peculiarities have been noted with increasing fre-
quency in well-observed SN Ia (e.g., Filippenko 2005).
Therefore, there is an obvious need for progenitor scenarios that could ex-
plain the diversity among SN Ia. Several explanations have been suggested, such
1Racah Institute of Physics, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem 91904, Israel
2Institute of Astronomy, Russian Academy of Sciences, 48 Pyatnitskaya Str, Moscow, Russia
1
2
Roni Waldman, Lev R. Yungelson and Zalman Barkat
as variations in the metallicity of the progenitor, in the carbon to oxygen ratio at
its center, or in the central density at the time of ignition (e.g., Timmes et al.
2003; Ropke et al. 2006; Lesaffre et al. 2006). The variation of the latter two
parameters is expected to result from the variation in the initial white dwarf
mass and in the accretion history.
In this work we follow the evolution of helium stars with initial mass ≈
(2.2 − 2.5) M⊙ and show that they might reach thermonuclear explosion and
perhaps account for some of the peculiar SNe.
2. Results
We followed in detail the evolution of a 2.4 M⊙ helium star, starting from a
homogeneous object. We used the TYCHO evolutionary code described in
Young & Arnett (2005). The helium burning convective core has an almost
constant mass of about 0.82 M⊙, and produces a CO core with XC ≈ 0.27.
Subsequently, a radiative helium burning shell develops above the core, and as
the core grows to about 1.1 M⊙ carbon is ignited in the core at about 0.3 M⊙
(Fig. 1, left panel). After the end of core helium burning the center of the star
becomes increasingly degenerate, and neutrino cooling is increasingly compet-
ing with contraction-induced heating. As a result, the maximum temperature
is attained at an off-center point and it keeps growing until carbon ignites there
(Fig. 1, right panel). Following off-center C-ignition, the center expands and
cools, and a series of carbon burning flashes occurs. Eventually burning ceases
when carbon is almost exhausted in the core, however as can be seen in Fig. 2,
the innermost 0.5 M⊙ of the core has a residual XC ≈ 0.02.
After carbon burning ceases, the center continues to heat and contract while
the helium burning shell gradually increases the mass of the core. Similarly to
AGB evolution, the luminosity of the star grows, causing the envelope to ex-
pand and to develop a deepening convective region, which at certain moment
penetrates into the helium burning shell and creates conditions for hot bottom
burning. During this stage the carbon that accumulates below the helium burn-
ing shell quasi-periodically ignites (see Fig. 1, left panel), similarly to the helium
flashes occurring in AGB stars. Since very little is known about the mass loss
rate of stars of the kind we consider, we applied Reimers (1975)-based rate,
which reduced the mass of the star to ≃ 1.8 M⊙ (Fig. 1, left panel).
Finally, the core grows to MCh due to the helium burning shell and carbon
in the center ignites (Fig. 1, right panel). Convection is initiated, supplying
more carbon to the central region, and if the amount of carbon is sufficient to
raise the temperature above the oxygen ignition threshold (≃ 1.5×109 K), which
indeed happens in this case, oxygen will ignite under degenerate conditions and
initiate an explosion similar to the classical SN Ia case.
Models with initial masses (2.2−2.5) M⊙ evolve very similarly to the 2.4 M⊙
case, developing a carbon residue which might ignite thermonuclear runaway. We
did not follow the evolution further through the hot-bottom burning stage. The
2.1 M⊙ model only ignites carbon at a later stage, below the helium burning
shell, similar to the carbon flashes encountered in the 2.4 M⊙ case, however,
since in this case carbon has not been previously depleted in the core, burning
will probably continue until it reaches the center. We have not followed this
Helium stars as supernova progenitors
3
ignition line Xc=0.25
M=2.4 Msun
profile before ignition
profile before ignition
profile at ignition
1010
109
108
107
106
)
3
m
c
/
r
g
(
y
t
i
s
n
e
D
105
0
1
2
4
3
5
Temperature (108 K)
6
7
8
Figure 1.
Evolution of the initially 2.4 M⊙ helium star model. Left: Kip-
penhahn plot after the end of core helium burning. Light (red) filled areas
are convective, dark (blue) line shows maximum thermonuclear energy pro-
duction rate. Right: Evolution of stellar center on temperature vs. density
plane (long dash (green) line); also shown is the ρ − T relation of the inner
part of the model prior (short dashed (dark blue) and dotted (purple) lines)
and immediately after off-center carbon ignition (dot-dashed (light blue) line).
Carbon ignition line for XC = 0.25 is shown as solid (red) line.
Figure 2.
thermonuclear runaway.
Composition of the initially 2.4 M⊙ helium star model before
model further. The models of 2.6 M⊙ and more massive ones ignite carbon very
close to or at the center, so that the carbon residue is either non-existent or
insufficient for thermonuclear runaway.
4
Roni Waldman, Lev R. Yungelson and Zalman Barkat
In an earlier work (Waldman & Barkat 2007) we explored the similar case
of CO white dwarfs undergoing off-center carbon burning followed by mass ac-
cretion. As a function of the amount of residual carbon we got thermonuclear
runaway at a broad range of ρc ≈ (1 − 6) × 109g cm−3. Since the structure of the
CO core in our helium star models is very similar to that of the mass accreting
CO white dwarfs, we expect to get a similar result at runaway.
Supernova which results from thermonuclear runaway in the remnant of
He-star most probably will not differ photometrically from a "normal" SN Ia,
but one may expect presence of strong He-lines in the spectrum, thanks to thick
He-mantle of pre-SN, making this SN Ia "peculiar" (N. Chugai, priv. comm.).
To complete the picture, we tested whether a hydrogen-deficient star very
similar to our initial models could be created as a result of close binary evolution.
We begun with a binary of (8.5 + 7.7) M⊙, with an orbital period of 150 day.
After the stage of Roche lobe overflow, the primary has a total mass of 2.3 M⊙,
a CO core of 1.2 M⊙, and a surface hydrogen mass fraction of 0.14. Later, wind
mass loss and sporadic RLOF reduce the mass to 2.1 M⊙. Further evolution of
the remnant is similar to the above described.
To summarize, we showed that evolution of helium stars with initial mass about
(2.2 − 2.5) M⊙, which might be produced in close binaries, may suggest a SN
scenario in which thermonuclear runaway in MCh-mass cores is initiated by a
very small amount of residual carbon, while the stars still have a several 0.1 M⊙
envelope consisting mostly of helium, carbon and possibly some hydrogen. In
order to give a well justified statement on the observational outcome, our pre-
SN models should be used for detailed simulations of the explosive runaway and
spectra modeling.
Acknowledgments. This research was supported in part by the National
Science Foundation under grant PHY05-51164, Russian Academy of Sciences
Basic Research Program "Origin and Evolution of Stars and Galaxies" and by
Russian Foundation for Basic Research grant 07-02-00454. LRY acknowledges
N.N. Chugai for fruitful discussions and P.P. Eggleton for providing his evolu-
tionary code and advise on its usage. RW acknowledges D. Arnett for providing
his TYCHO evolutionary code for public use.
References
Branch D., Miller D. L., 1993, ApJ 405, L5
Filippenko A. V., 2005, in E. M. Sion, S. Vennes, H. L. Shipman (eds.), White dwarfs:
cosmological and galactic probes, Vol. 332 of Astrophysics and Space Science
Library, 97
Hillebrandt W., Niemeyer J. C., 2000, ARA&A 38, 191
Leibundgut B., 2000, A&A Rev. 10, 179
Lesaffre P., Han Z., Tout C. A., Podsiadlowski P., Martin R. G., 2006, MNRAS 368,
187
Reimers D., 1975, Memoires of the Societe Royale des Sciences de Liege 8, 369
Ropke F. K., Gieseler M., Reinecke M., Travaglio C., Hillebrandt W., 2006, A&A 453,
203
Timmes F. X., Brown E. F., Truran J. W., 2003, ApJ 590, L83
Waldman R., Barkat Z., 2007, ApJ 665, 1235
Young P. A., Arnett D., 2005, ApJ 618, 908
|
astro-ph/0201094 | 1 | 0201 | 2002-01-07T16:49:55 | How is the Reionization Epoch Defined? | [
"astro-ph"
] | We study the effect of a prolonged epoch of reionization on the angular power spectrum of the Cosmic Microwave Background. Typically reionization studies assume a sudden phase transition, with the intergalactic gas moving from a fully neutral to a fully ionized state at a fixed redshift. Such models are at odds, however, with detailed investigations of reionization, which favor a more extended transition. We have modified the code CMBFAST to allow the treatment of more realistic reionization histories and applied it to data obtained from numerical simulations of reionization. We show that the prompt reionization assumed by CMBFAST in its original form heavily contaminates any constraint derived on the reionization redshift. We find, however, that prompt reionization models give a reasonable estimate of the epoch at which the mean cosmic ionization fraction was ~50%, and provide a very good measure of the overall Thomson optical depth. The overall differences in the temperature (polarization) angular power spectra between prompt and extended models with equal optical depths are less than 1% (10%). | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 5 (2001)
Printed 27 October 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
How is the Reionization Epoch Defined ?
Marialuce Bruscoli1, Andrea Ferrara2 & Evan Scannapieco2
1Dipartimento di Astronomia, Universit`a degli studi di Firenze, L.go E. Fermi 2, Firenze, Italy
2Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, L.go E. Fermi 5, Firenze, Italy
27 October 2018
ABSTRACT
We study the effect of a prolonged epoch of reionization on the angular power spec-
trum of the Cosmic Microwave Background. Typically reionization studies assume a
sudden phase transition, with the intergalactic gas moving from a fully neutral to a
fully ionized state at a fixed redshift. Such models are at odds, however, with detailed
investigations of reionization, which favor a more extended transition. We have mod-
ified the code CMBFAST to allow the treatment of more realistic reionization histories
and applied it to data obtained from numerical simulations of reionization. We show
that the prompt reionization assumed by CMBFAST in its original form heavily con-
taminates any constraint derived on the reionization redshift. We find, however, that
prompt reionization models give a reasonable estimate of the epoch at which the mean
cosmic ionization fraction was ≈ 50%, and provide a very good measure of the overall
Thomson optical depth. The overall differences in the temperature (polarization) an-
gular power spectra between prompt and extended models with equal optical depths
are less than 1% (10%).
1
INTRODUCTION
At a redshift of z ≈ 1100 the intergalactic medium (IGM)
recombined and remained neutral until the first sources of
ionizing radiation formed. While the distribution and evo-
lution of these sources are unknown, the overall process of
IGM reionization is fairly well understood, and can be di-
vided into three phases. First, individual HII regions devel-
oped around the sources. Then, these ionized regions grew
in number and size until they overlapped, producing a sud-
den increase of the photon mean free path. Finally, when all
underdense regions and voids were completely ionized, pho-
tons penetrated into overdense clumps and filaments, bring-
ing the reionization process to completion at a "reionization
redshift."
It is clear that the mystery of the nature and evolution
of the ionizing sources is intimately tied with the time scale
over which these phases took place. Thus there is a great
deal of physical information that could be gathered if the
reionization redshift, zi, and its duration, ∆z, can be firmly
established.
Apart from the study of the (HI and HeII) Gunn-
Peterson effect, which has not yet yielded conclusive re-
sults (Becker et al. 2001; Gnedin 2001; Theuns et al. 2001),
measurements of Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB)
anisotropies have the greatest potential for constraining
these important quantities (Griffiths et al. 1999). The scat-
tering of CMB photons by free electrons damps the angu-
lar power spectrum of primary anisotropies by a factor of
e−2τ for large angular multipoles ℓ >
∼ 100 (Tegmark & Zal-
darriaga 2000), where τ is the Thomson optical depth. Us-
c(cid:13) 2001 RAS
ing the currently available data, consistency with the lack
of Gunn-Peterson trough and with the observed peak in
the angular power spectrum at ℓ ≈ 200 (De Bernardis et
al. 2000; Hanany et al. 2000; Padin et al. 2001) is able to
constrain 0.02 ≤ τ ≤ 0.44 (De Bernardis et al. 1997; Grif-
fiths et al. 1999; Tegmark et al. 2001; Griffiths & Liddle
2001), although these results are somewhat dependent on
the cosmological model assumed. Much better constraints
are expected from polarization studies to be carried out by
future satellites such as SPOrt⋆ and PLANCK†.
A second method of quantifying reionization is to ex-
amine zi, and several recent studies have attempted to use
the CMB to derive this redshift directly, using codes that as-
sume a sudden epoch of reionization (e.g, Hu et al. 95; Seljak
& Zaldarriaga 1996). For example, Schmalzing et al. (2000)
use MAXIMA data in combination with cosmological pa-
rameters from independent measurements of Big Bang Nu-
cleosynthesis and X-ray cluster data to constrain zi. By per-
forming a χ2 analysis, they conclude that zi > 15(8) at the
68% (95%) confidence level. Similarly, Naselsky et al. (2001),
in addition to providing support to Schmalzing et al. results,
showed that polarization spectra are very sensitive to the
reionization redshift.
An important caveat is implicit in these applications
however, namely the assumption of prompt reionization.
While taking ∆z = 0 is a reasonable first step, more de-
⋆ http://sport.tesre.bo.cnr.it
† http://astro.estec.esa.nl/SA-general/Projects/Planck
2 M. Bruscoli, A. Ferrara & E. Scannapieco
tailed simulations show that this approach paints a picture
of reionization in only the broadest of strokes. This is par-
ticularly true as the onset of reionization raises the overall
temperature of the IGM, suppressing the further formation
of objects that are too weakly bound gravitationally to over-
come the drastic increase in thermal pressure (Barkana &
Loeb 1999). Thus recent numerical simulations of reioniza-
tion (Ciardi et al. 2000, hereafter CFGJ; Bruscoli et al. 2000;
Gnedin 2000; Benson et al. 2000) have shown that the evolu-
tion of the mean ionization fraction is slow, has a nonlinear
dependence on redshift, and occurs in an extremely patchy
manner. All of these details may considerably affect the de-
termination of zi.
In this paper, we aim to clarify the effects of realistic
reionization scenarios on the observables typically used to
examine the reionization epoch. To this end we have modi-
fied the most heavily relied on theoretical code for comput-
ing CMB fluctuations, CMBFAST (Seljak & Zaldarriaga 1996),
to allow the treatment of such reionization histories, helping
to clarify the best approach in trying to quantify and define
the epoch of reionization.
The structure of this work is as follows. In §2 we dis-
cuss numerical models of reionization and how these have
been incorporated into the CMBFAST code. In §3 we apply
these techniques to study the impact of these models on the
temperature and polarization spectrum of the CMB, and
conclusions are given in §4.
2 REIONIZATION HISTORY FROM
SIMULATIONS
To assess the effects of more physical reionization histories
on the determination of zi, we have modified the Boltzmann
code CMBFAST such that the redshift evolution of the volume-
averaged mean hydrogen ionization fraction, xe(z), can be
specified, reading in data from more detailed simulations of
reionization.‡ Our modified version of CMBFAST is then able
to consider three types of reionization histories: (i) prompt
reionization models in which the total optical depth, τ , is
chosen (ii) prompt models in which the reionization redshift,
zi, is fixed, and (iii) models in which xe(z) is read from an
external file.
As in Bruscoli et al. (2000), we consider a set of reion-
ization simulations studied in CFGJ, which model reioniza-
tion from stellar sources, including Population III objects.
These simulations were developed in a critical density CDM
universe with cosmological parameters h = 0.5, σ8 = 0.6,
and Ωb = 0.06 (where h is the Hubble constant in units of
100 km s−1 Mpc−1, σ8 is the rms variation of density pertur-
bations at the 8h−1 comoving Mpc length scale, and Ωb is
the baryonic density in units of the critical density) but span
a large range of model parameters, and thus are suitable for
drawing conclusions as to the effect of extended reionization
in more general cosmologies.
The spatial distribution of the sources and ionized re-
gions at various cosmic epochs and the overall evolution of
‡ A copy of this version of CMBFAST is publicly available at
http://www.arcetri.astro.it/science/cosmology/CMB
xe(z) are obtained from high-resolution cosmological simula-
tions within a periodic box of comoving length L = 2.55h−1
Mpc. The source properties are calculated taking into ac-
count a self-consistent treatment of both radiative feedback
from ionizing and H2 -- photodissociating photons and stel-
lar feedback regulated by supernovae from massive stars.
There are two main free parameters in the simulations: the
fraction of total baryons converted into stars, fb⋆, and the
escape fraction of ionizing photons from a given galaxy,
fesc. A critical discussion of these parameters is given in
CFGJ, and here we examine four different models, fixing
(fb⋆ = 0.012, fesc = 0.2) in run A, (0.004, 0.2) in run B,
(0.15, 0.2) in run C , and (0.012, 0.1) in run D. As run A, in
which zi ≈ 11, gives the best agreement between the derived
evolution of the cosmic star formation rate and observations
at z <
∼ 4 (Steidel et al. 1998, CFGJ), we choose this as our
fiducial model, and rely on runs B, C, and D to study the
effects of model uncertainties on our conclusions.
3 PROMPT VS. SIMULATED REIONIZATION
Equipped with this more general tool, we now quantitatively
contrast the prompt reionization xe,p(z) with the one de-
rived from the simulations, xe,s(z). As CMBFAST can be run
either by assigning zi or τ , we are able to examine both these
cases separately.
3.1 Assigning the Reionization Redshift
In Fig. 1 we plot the redshift evolution of the hydrogen
ionization fraction and the Thomson optical depth for the
prompt and simulated cases, choosing in the prompt case
the same value of zi = 10.9 as deduced from run A. In this
plot, the smoother, nonlinear increase of xe,s(z) is evident,
with ∆z ≈ 15. Note also that the optical depth for the two
reionization histories are quite different, and that τs = 0.08
for run A and τp = 0.04 for prompt reionization. If we define
the discrepancy between the prompt and simulated visibility
functions g(z) as
∆g
g
=
gs(z) − gp(z)
gs(z)
,
(1)
∼ 1000).
where g(z) is the probability that a photon reaching the
observer last scattered in the redshift range z and z + dz,
then we find that ∆g/g ≈ 5% for a large range of redshifts
between recombination and the beginning of reionization
(25 <
∼ z <
The most important comparison between the prompt
and fiducial cases, however, is made in terms of the dif-
ferent resulting CMB temperature and polarization angular
power spectra, Cℓ and Pℓ, as these are the observable quan-
tities. These are shown in the upper left panel of Fig. 2, in
which differences are particularly evident in the polarization
spectra, which are more sensitive to the reionization history.
Reionization introduces a characteristic bump in the lower
multipoles (ℓ = 5 − 10) that tends to shift to higher ℓ's when
τ is increased. The amplitude of the bump in the Pℓ spec-
trum decreases with τ and therefore the signal is weaker for
the prompt reionization case. In particular the bump am-
plitude in the angular spectrum Pℓ is roughly proportional
c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 5
How is the Reionization Epoch Defined ?
3
Figure 1. H ionization fraction, xe, and Thomson optical depth,
τ , versus redshift for run A (solid lines) and for prompt reioniza-
tion (dotted lines) when CMBFAST is run choosing zi = 10.9. The
dots represent the output from the simulation.
to τ 2 (for τ <
(Zaldarriaga 1997; Fabbri 1999).
∼ 1), while its position scales as ℓpeak ∝ z1/2
i
To highlight these differences, we plot the normalized
discrepancy of temperature and polarization angular spec-
tra [defined analogously to eq. (1)] between the models in
the lower left panel. Here find that ∆Cℓ/Cℓ < 0.07 while,
around ℓ ≈ 10, ∆Pℓ/Pℓ ≈ 1. These results make it clear
that although the prompt and simulated reionization his-
tories share the same value of zi, they produce noticeably
different angular power spectra, and thus correct constraints
on the reionization redshift cannot be obtained by equating
zi in the prompt and simulated runs.
3.2 Assigning the Optical Depth
An alternative approach is to compare our fiducial run with
a prompt model that differs in its zi but has the same Thom-
son optical depth, τ = 0.08. This results in a value for the
prompt reionization redshift of zi,p = 17.1. Note that this
value is much larger than the simulated redshift of reioniza-
tion zi,s = 10.9, and corresponds to the redshift at which
the simulated ionization fraction is only xe,s ≈ 0.5.
Comparing these two runs we find, however, that the
discrepancy between the two visibility functions is only
∆g/g ∼ 10−4. This small change in the visibility function
results in an equally small change in the observed CMB
anisotropies. This can be seen on the top right panel of in
Fig. 2 in which the angular power spectra are almost in-
distinguishable. Indeed, the fractional discrepancy between
<
these runs is only ∆Cℓ/Cℓ
∼ 0.06 as
shown in the bottom right panel in this figure.
<
∼ 0.01 and ∆Pℓ/Pℓ
Thus the two different reionization models produce
comparable angular power spectra if τ is specified rather
than zi. In fact if we try to recover the reionization redshift
from the standard formula zi = 8.9(τ /hΩb)2/3Ω1/3
(Peebles
1993, Tegmark et al. 2000) we get zi = 17.1, again a redshift
at which xe ≈ 0.5. It is clear then that by analyzing CMB
0
c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 5
Figure 2. Top left: temperature (Cℓ) and polarization (Pℓ) an-
gular power spectra versus the multipole ℓ for run A (solid line)
and for prompt reionization (dotted line) when CMBFAST is run
with zi = 10.9. Bottom left: the normalized temperature and po-
larization discrepancy as a function of angular multipole ℓ for this
case. Here the solid and dotted lines refer to Cℓ and Pℓ respec-
tively. Top right: temperature (Cℓ) and polarization (Pℓ) angular
power spectra versus the multipole ℓ for run A (solid line) and
for prompt reionization (dotted line) when CMBFAST is run with
τ = 0.08. Bottom right: the normalized temperature and polariza-
tion discrepancy as a function of angular multipole ℓ for this case.
Here the solid and dotted lines refer to Cℓ and Pℓ respectively.
power spectra using a prompt model, one can draw reason-
able conclusions as to the overall Thomson optical depth,
whereas the reionization redshift is much more uncertain.
3.3 Quantification of Errors & Tests of Our
Approach
In order to quantify the difference between the fiducial
model and the prompt model with the same optical depth
further, we plot in Fig. 3 the quantity
χ2(ℓmax) =
ℓmax
X
2
(2ℓ + 1)
2
(
∆Cℓ
Cℓ
)2fsky
(2)
as a function of the multipole number ℓmax assuming full
sky coverage, fsky = 1. For multipole values greater than
100, χ2 exceeds unity, the value corresponding to the cos-
mic variance error of 2C 2
ℓ /(2ℓ + 1). This means that one can
find a statistically significant difference between the prompt
and fiducial models only by looking at angular multipoles
with ℓ >
∼ 100. However, in Fig. 2 we saw that the largest dif-
ferences between the two histories occur at lower multipole
values (ℓ = 20 − 40). Thus although these reionization his-
4 M. Bruscoli, A. Ferrara & E. Scannapieco
Figure 3. χ2 of Cℓ (solid line) and of Pℓ (dotted line) versus
ℓmax (see eq. 2).
tories are considerably different, it is almost impossible to
discriminate between them observationally.
Finally, we extend our analysis to the runs B, C, and
D of CFGJ, comparing them with prompt runs with equal
values of τs. These results are summarized in Table 1. As in
run A, the values of zi,p found for these models correspond
to times at which xe,s ≈ 0.5, when the IGM was in the midst
of changing from a neutral state to an ionized one.
Is is clear from this table that it is not possible to
put a constraint on the reionization redshift directly from
CMBFAST. In fact, as can be easily seen in Table 1, the differ-
ences between zi,s and zi,p cannot be easily parameterized
because they depend on several effects that influence the du-
ration ∆zs of the reionization process. These effects include
radiative and stellar feedbacks, the star formation efficiency,
the photon escape fraction, the spatial and mass distribu-
tion of the ionizing sources, and even the clumpiness of IGM,
which is beyond the scope of the CFGJ simulations.
We have conducted a number of checks and convergence
tests to assess the robustness of our approach. Our first check
was to examine the overall, numerical value of the optical
depth, which differs slightly from the input value due to the
finite integration time step. Here we found that the output
τ s differ by less than 5 × 10−5 from the specified values.
∼ 10−4, i.e. 30 times smaller
This corresponds to ∆Cℓ/Cℓ
than the actual difference between the simulated and prompt
runs.
<
Next, we carried out a series of convergence tests, to
ascertain the effects of k-mode sampling on our results.
Here we restrict our tests to run A for which we increased
the k resolution by 50%. A comparison between the origi-
nal and resampled simulated runs showed that at most an-
gular scales ∆Cℓ/Cℓ and ∆Pℓ/Pℓ are within 0.1%; larger
differences (up to ∼ 0.7%) are found at higher multipole
numbers (ℓ >
∼ 700). Comparing the resampled run A with a
resampled prompt run with equal input optical depth, we
found ∆Cℓ/Cℓ and ∆Pℓ/Pℓ values that were virtually in-
distinguishable from those obtained with low k resolution
runs.
Finally, we examined the effect of time sampling at both
k resolutions, comparing two prompt runs with equal optical
depth and k resolution, but forcing one of them to the same
time step as in simulated run A. Again, we found ∆Cℓ/Cℓ
∼ 10−4, far smaller than the discrepancies be-
and ∆Pℓ/Pℓ
tween the prompt and simulated runs.
<
4 CONCLUSIONS
One of the first stages of nonlinear structure formation,
reionization marked an important transition from a dark
and relatively simple universe to one filled with a dazzling
array of stars, galaxies, quasars, and other nonlinear ob-
jects. And although one of our best probes of this transition
is through the measurement of CMB fluctuations, the pro-
cess of reionization itself is much more dependent on the
complicated astrophysical issues important at low redshifts
than the linear issues important at z ≈ 1100.
In this work, we have explored this transition, quan-
tifying the impact of realistic scenarios of reionization on
the angular power spectrum of the Comic Microwave Back-
ground. While standard estimates assume prompt reioniza-
tion, we have considered instead a range of simulated mod-
els, each with a prolonged reionization epoch. We find that
equating the redshift of full IGM ionization between these
simulations and models that assume instantaneous reioniza-
tion leads to widely discrepant temperature and polarization
spectra. On the other hand, equating prompt and extended
models with the same overall optical depth leads to differ-
ences in anisotropies that are nearly undetectable. In this
case the redshift of complete ionization is lost in the compli-
cated details of the phase transition, and comparisons yield
zi values corresponding to roughly the point of 50% ioniza-
tion in the simulations, although even this value is model de-
pendent. It is clear then that while zi is useful as schematic
tool, it is the total optical depth that is most accurate in
providing a definition of the reionization epoch.
MB thanks M. Zaldarriaga for discussions and hospi-
tality at IAS, Princeton where part of this work has been
carried out. ES has been supported in part by an NSF MPS-
DRF fellowship.
REFERENCES
Ciardi, B., Ferrara, A. & Abel, T. 2000, ApJ, 533, 594
Ciardi, B., Ferrara, A., Governato, F. & Jenkins, A. 2000, MN-
RAS, 314, 611 (CFGJ)
Barkana, R. & Loeb, A. 1999, ApJ, 523, 54
Becker, R. H. et al. 2001, astro-ph/0108097
De Bernardis, P. et al. 2000, Nature, 404, 955
De Bernardis, P., Balbi, A., De Gasperis, G., Melchiorri, A. &
Vittorio, N. 1997, ApJ, 480, 1
Fabbri, R., 1999, New Astronomy Reviews, 43, 215
Gnedin, N.Y., 2001, astro-ph/0110290
Griffiths, L. M. & Liddle, A. R. 2001, MNRAS, 324, 769
Griffiths, L.M., Barbosa, D. & Liddle, A.R. 1999, MNRAS, 308,
854
Hanany, S. et al. 2000, ApJ, 545, L5
Hu, W. 2000, ApJ, 529, 12
Hu, W., Scott, D., Sugiyama, N. & White, M. 1995, Phys. Rev.
D, 52, 5498
c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 5
How is the Reionization Epoch Defined ?
5
Table 1: Reionization parameters
Run ∆zs
(a)
(b)
zi,s
(c)
τs
(d)
zi,p
xe,s(zi,p)(e)
A
B
C
D
15
17
15
17
10.9
0.080
17.1
8.3
15
8.3
0.059
13.9
0.098
19.8
0.064
14.7
0.46
0.51
0.48
0.47
∆Cℓ
Cℓ
∆Pℓ
Pℓ
<
∼ 0.01
<
∼ 0.06
<
∼ 0.007
<
∼ 0.01
<
∼ 0.008
<
∼ 0.1
<
∼ 0.1
<
∼ 0.1
Table 1. (a)Duration of reionization; (b)Redshift of complete
reionization (simulated); (c)Thomson Optical Depth (simulated);
(d)Redshift of complete reionization (prompt); (e)Hydrogen ion-
ization fraction at zi,p (simulated).
Naselsky, P. et al. 2001, astro-ph/0102378
Padin, S. et al. 2001, ApJ, 549, L1
Peebles, P.J.E. 1993, Principles of Physical Cosmology, Princeton,
Princeton University Press
Tegmark, M., Zaldarriaga, M. & Hamilton, A.J.S. 2001, Phys.
Rev. D, 43007
Tegmark, M. & Zaldarriaga, M. 2000, ApJ, 544, 30
Theuns, T., Zaroubi, S. & Kim, T.S. 2001, astro-ph/0110552
Schmalzing, J., Sommer-Larsen, J. & Goetz, M. 2000, astro-
ph/0010063
Seljak, U. & Zaldarriaga, M. 1996, ApJ, 469, 437
Steidel, C.C. et al. 1999, ApJ, 519, 1
Zaldarriaga, M., 1997, Phys. Rev. D, 55, 1822
c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 5
|
astro-ph/9509120 | 1 | 9509 | 1995-09-21T18:28:30 | Optical Identification of Quasar 0917+7122 in the Direction of an Extreme-Ultraviolet Source | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report the optical identification of an $R=18.3$ mag, $z=2.432$ quasar at the position of a 6 cm radio source and a faint \rosat PSPC X-ray source. The quasar lies within the error circles of unidentified extreme-UV (EUV) detections by the \euve and \rosat WFC all-sky surveys at $\sim 400$ \AA\ and $\sim 150$ \AA, respectively. A 21 cm H I emission measurement in the direction of the quasar with a $21'$-diameter beam yields a total H I column density of $N_{H}=3.3\times 10^{20}$ cm$^{-2}$, two orders of magnitude higher than the maximum allowed for transparency through the Galaxy in the EUV. The source of the EUV flux is therefore probably nearby ($\ltorder 100$ pc), and unrelated to the quasar. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Optical Identi(cid:12)cation of Quasar + in the Direction
of an Extreme-Ultraviolet Source
Dan Maoz, Eran O. Ofek, Amotz Shemi
School of Physics & Astronomy and Wise observatory
Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv , ISRAEL
Aaron J. Barth, Alexei V. Filippenko
Department of Astronomy
University of California, Berkeley, CA , USA
M. S. Brotherton, Beverley J. Wills, D. Wills
McDonald Observatory and Astronomy Department
University of Texas, Austin, TX , USA
Felix J. Lockman
National Radio Astronomy Observatory
P.O. Box , Green Bank, WV - , USA
to appear in Astronomy & Astrophysics (Research Note)
5
9
9
1
p
e
S
1
2
0
2
1
9
0
5
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
Abstract
We report the optical identi(cid:12)cation of an R = : mag, z = : quasar at the
position of a cm radio source and a faint ROSAT PSPC X-ray source. The quasar
lies within the error circles of unidenti(cid:12)ed extreme-UV (EUV) detections by the EUVE
and ROSAT WFC all-sky surveys at (cid:24)
A and (cid:24)
A, respectively. A cm
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
H I emission measurement in the direction of the quasar with a
-diameter beam
yields a total H I column density of N
= : (cid:2)
cm
, two orders of magnitude
H
(cid:0)
higher than the maximum allowed for transparency through the Galaxy in the EUV.
The source of the EUV (cid:13)ux is therefore probably nearby (
pc), and unrelated
<
(cid:24)
to the quasar.
Introduction
The ROSAT Wide Field Camera (WFC) and the Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer (EUVE)
missions carried out all-sky surveys at extreme-ultraviolet (EUV) wavelengths in -
and - , respectively (Pounds et al. ; Malina et al. ; Bowyer et al.
). The EUVE all-sky survey was carried out in four broad bands, centered at
approximately
A,
A,
A, and
A. The ROSAT WFC all-sky survey was
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
conducted in two EUV bands, centered at about
A and
A, and similar to the
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
A and
A bands in the EUVE survey. The two experiments had comparable
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
sensitivities in their common bands.
While the ma jority of the EUV sources detected by the two missions have been
identi(cid:12)ed, mostly with white dwarfs and active late-type stars, about % of the EUV
sources still have no identi(cid:12)ed optical counterparts. As part of an ongoing program
of optical identi(cid:12)cation of EUV sources (Maoz, Ofek, & Shemi ) it was noticed
that the ROSAT source RE + and the EUVE source EUVE J +. are
separated by only
on the sky, each within the positional error circle of the other.
(The typical %-con(cid:12)dence error-circles for EUVE and ROSAT, while sub ject to
some uncertainties, are of order
.) RE + was detected only in the
A
(cid:23)
ROSAT band at the : (cid:27) level, whereas EUVE J +. was detected only in the
A EUVE band at the : (cid:27) level. These sources are not included in the latest
(cid:23)
compilations of EUV sources by the ROSAT and EUVE teams (Pye et al. ;
Lewis et al. ; Bowyer et al. ) because their signi(cid:12)cance is slightly below
the cuto(cid:11) adopted for inclusion. They are, however, likely to be real (J. Pye, private
communication; X. Wu, private communication).
Maoz et al. ( ) obtained B and R CCD images of the (cid:12)eld of these EUV
sources, and noticed a blue (B (cid:0) R = :, R = : mag) ob ject lying between the
positions of the EUV sources, and within their respective error-circles. A database
search showed that the blue ob ject is positionally coincident with a cm radio source
(Gregory & Condon ) and a faint ROSAT PSPC ( .{. keV) X-ray source
(White, Giommi, & Angelini ). A (cid:12)nding chart of the (cid:12)eld is given in Fig.
. The blue ob ject, and the positions and error circles of the various detections,
are marked. A summary of the positions, count-rates, and estimated (cid:13)uxes at all
wavelengths is given in Table .
The positionally-consistent radio through X-ray emission led us to investigate this
(cid:12)eld further.
In particular, we were intrigued by the possibilities that this is an
unknown type of Galactic EUV source, or a quasar detected in the EUV through a
hole in the Galaxy's interstellar medium (ISM). Note that, apart from the detection
of about bright ({ mag) active galactic nuclei, all in the
A bands, no
(cid:23)
extragalactic ob jects have been detected in the EUV (Lewis et al. ; Barber et al.
; Marshall, Fruscione, & Carone ). EUV radiation is very strongly absorbed
by the Galaxy's ISM. We report here optical spectroscopy of the blue ob ject, and a
cm H I emission measurement in its direction.
Optical Spectroscopy
A {
A spectrum of the blue ob ject was obtained on February
(cid:23)
UT with the Large Cassegrain Spectrograph on the .-m telescope at McDonald
Observatory. A Craf-Cassini (cid:2) -pixel CCD detector was used with a
l/mm grating and a
slit at position angle
to give a spectral resolution of less
(cid:14)
than
A. The total integration time was s. The spectrum reveals two broad
(cid:23)
(FWHM { km s
) emission lines at
A and
A (C IV (cid:21) and
(cid:0)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
C III] (cid:21) ), identifying the ob ject as a high-redshift quasar.
Additional CCD spectra were obtained on February UT with the Kast
double spectrograph (Miller & Stone ) at the Cassegrain focus of the -m Shane
re(cid:13)ector at Lick Observatory. The total integration time was s in the range
{
A, plus a short ( s) exposure in the range {
A to verify the
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
reliability of the (cid:13)ux calibration in the dichroic crossover region ((cid:24) {
A).
(cid:23)
The seeing was about
, and thin cirrus may have been present. Although the air
mass was relatively high ((cid:24) :), the e(cid:11)ects of atmospheric dispersion were minimized
by orienting the long slit (of width
) along the parallactic angle; thus, the relative
(cid:13)ux calibration should be accurate. The spectral resolution was (cid:24)
A below
A,
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
and (cid:24) {
A above it.
(cid:23)
Fig. shows the Lick spectrum of the quasar. The Ly(cid:11), C IV, and C III] emission
lines are prominent, and indicate a redshift of z = :. There is a strong unresolved
(FWHM
A) absorption line near the peak of the Ly(cid:11) emission. The spectral slope
(cid:23)
(F
/ (cid:23)
) is (cid:11) (cid:25) (cid:0):, somewhat steeper than that of most quasars (e.g. Richstone &
(cid:23)
(cid:11)
Schmidt ). The absolute (cid:13)uxes of the Lick and McDonald spectra agree to (cid:24) %,
but are about % lower than that implied by the photometric R-band measurement
(obtained months earlier, on July , UT). This is reasonable considering some
seeing losses through the narrow slits, and the possibly non-photometric conditions
of the spectroscopic observations. The equivalent widths in the observer's frame of
the Ly (cid:11) + NV, C IV, and C III lines are, respectively,
A,
A, and
A.
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
Their (cid:13)ux ratios are . : . : .
-cm H I Measurements
The identi(cid:12)cation of the blue ob ject as a quasar raises the possibility that we are
seeing a quasar in the EUV through a hole in the ISM. In the H I maps of Stark
et al. ( ) the quasar (Galactic coordinates l
= :
, b
= :
) lies inside
I I
(cid:14)
I I
(cid:14)
several concentric contours of decreasing H I column density. The lowest contour in
this \dip" is still fairly high, corresponding to about : (cid:2)
cm
, but a deeper
(cid:0)
tunnel may have been smoothed out by the map's resolution (>
). The lowest total
(cid:14)
N
columns that have been measured in the Galaxy are a few
cm
(Lockman,
H
(cid:0)
Jahoda, & McCammon, ), whereas to obtain transparency to light at {
(cid:23)
(cid:0)
A a column density lower than (cid:24) (cid:2)
cm
is required (e.g. Cox & Reynolds
). The total count rate in the ROSAT PSPC detection is about that expected
from an -mag quasar, but there are too few () total counts to determine the N
H
absorbing column by (cid:12)tting the x-ray spectrum. We therefore carried out a cm
measurement of the H I column density in the direction of the quasar.
Observations of Galactic cm H I emission toward + were made with
the m NRAO telescope at Green Bank, WV, which has a half-power beam-width
(cid:0)
of
in the cm line. The H I spectra covered about (cid:6) km s
around zero
velocity relative to the local standard of rest (LSR). They were corrected for stray
cm H I radiation using the technique described by Lockman et al. ( ), although
the actual correction amounted to less than %. The measured Galactic H I column
density toward the quasar is : (cid:2)
cm
for an assumed H I spin temperature of
(cid:0)
K. The estimated (cid:27) uncertainty on the value of N
is < (cid:2)
cm
from all
H
(cid:0)
sources, including the opacity correction. The Galactic H I spectrum in a
(cid:2)
(cid:12)eld
(cid:14)
(cid:14)
around + has two main spectral components, one near zero velocity LSR and
the other near (cid:0) km s
. The total N
across this (cid:12)eld varies systematically from
H
(cid:0)
about (cid:2)
cm
north of the quasar to about (cid:2)
cm
in the south because
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
of a change in the zero velocity line strength. Toward + itself, the zero and
(cid:0) km s
components have widths of and km s
(FWHM), respectively,
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
and the negative velocity component contains (cid:2)
cm
. The uniformly large
(cid:0)
values of N
in the sky around +, the presence of two spectral components,
H
and the fairly large line widths all argue that it is unlikely that there are extreme
(cid:13)uctuations in the total Galactic N
on angular scales smaller than the
beam of
H
the meter telescope in this part of the sky. Thus the present data should give an
accurate value of the Galactic N
toward the quasar.
H
Conclusions
As part of a program to search for optical counterparts to unidenti(cid:12)ed EUV sources,
we have optically identi(cid:12)ed a z = : quasar coincident with a previously detected
radio and X-ray source. Although the quasar lies within the error circles of an EUV
source detected by both EUVE and the ROSAT /WFC, cm H I emission measure-
ments in this direction show a high total H I column density. It is therefore unlikely
that the quasar and the EUV source are associated.
The EUV source is likely to be nearby, within (cid:24) pc (Warwick et al. ),
and only by chance coincidence on the line-of-sight to the quasar. As shown in
more detail by Maoz et al. ( ), all the stars within :
of either of the EUV
detections (i.e. well beyond the error circles shown in Fig.), down to a limit of
R = , B = , have B (cid:0) R colors and magnitudes consistent with late-type dwarfs
at distances of pc or more. At such distances, these stars are unlikely candidate
optical counterparts to the EUV source. This indicates that the EUV source is either
very faint optically, or is an unknown type of nearby Galactic star that mimics the
color and magnitude of a distant late-type dwarf. In the former case, the EUV/optical
(cid:13)ux ratio, (cid:23)F
(
A)=(cid:23)F
(
A) > , i.e. the source is some kind of extremely
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
hot ob ject. A third alternative is that the source emits transiently, and was \turned
o(cid:11) " at the time of the optical observations. Upcoming observations with the Hubble
Space Telescope and EUVE may provide further clues to its nature.
Acknowledgements We thank K. Anderson, N. Craig, A. Laor, H. Netzer, J.
Pye, and X. Wu for helpful discussions and suggestions. Astronomy at the Wise Ob-
servatory is supported by grants from the Ministry of Science and Technology and
from the Israel Academy of Science. The work of A. V. F. and A. J. B. was supported
by the National Science Foundation through grant AST{ . The University of
Texas observations are partially supported by the Space Telescope Science Institute
grant HST GO . -A RQ-Q. STScI is operated by AURA, Inc., under NASA
contract NAS- The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is operated by As-
sociated Universities, Inc., under a cooperative agreement with the National Science
Foundation. This work has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database
(NED), which is operated by JPL, Caltech, under contract with NASA.
References
Barber, C.R., Warwick, R.S., McGale, P.A., & Pye, J.P. , MNRAS, in press
Bowyer, S. et al. , ApJS, ,
Bowyer, S. et al. , ApJS, submitted, CEA preprint No.
Cox., D. P., & Reynolds, R. J. , ARA&A, ,
Gregory, P.C., & Condon, J.J. , ApJS, ,
Lewis, J., Bowyer, S., Lampton, M., Wu, X., Jelinsky, P., Saba, V., Lieu, R., &
Malina, R.F. , BAAS, ,
Lockman, F.J., Jahoda, K., & McCammon, D. , ApJ, ,
Malina, R.F., et al. , AJ, ,
Maoz, D., Ofek, E.O., & Shemi, A. , in preparation
Marshall, H.L., Fruscione, A., & Carone, T.E. , ApJ, in press
Miller, J. S., & Stone, R. P. S. , Lick Obs. Tech. Rep., No.
Pounds, K.A., et al. , MNRAS, ,
Pye, J.P., et al. , MNRAS, in press
Richstone, D.O., & Schmidt, M. , ApJ, ,
Stark, A.S., Gammie, C.F., Wilson, R.W., Bally, J., Linke, R.A., Heiles, C., &
Hurwitz, M. , ApJS, ,
Warwick, R.S., Barber, C.R., Hodgkin, S.T., & Pye, J.P. , MNRAS, ,
White, N.E., Giommi, P., & Angelini L. , IAU Circ. No.
Table : Positions and Fluxes
Band
Instrumental
Flux
R.A. ( ) Dec. ( ) Positional
cm
{
mJy
: : :
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/usr/bin/pdf2txt.py", line 115, in <module>
if __name__ == '__main__': sys.exit(main(sys.argv))
File "/usr/bin/pdf2txt.py", line 109, in main
interpreter.process_page(page)
File "/usr/lib/python2.6/site-packages/pdfminer/pdfinterp.py", line 832, in process_page
self.render_contents(page.resources, page.contents, ctm=ctm)
File "/usr/lib/python2.6/site-packages/pdfminer/pdfinterp.py", line 845, in render_contents
self.execute(list_value(streams))
File "/usr/lib/python2.6/site-packages/pdfminer/pdfinterp.py", line 870, in execute
func(*args)
File "/usr/lib/python2.6/site-packages/pdfminer/pdfinterp.py", line 780, in do_EI
if 'W' in obj and 'H' in obj:
TypeError: argument of type 'PSLiteral' is not iterable
(cid:14)
Count Rate
Error
R
{
. mag
: : :
:
:
(cid:14)
B
{
. mag
: : :
:
:
(cid:14)
EUVE
A
counts ks
:
: : :
(cid:24)
(cid:23)
(cid:0)
y
(cid:14)
ROSAT
A
counts ks
:
: : :
(cid:24)
(cid:23)
(cid:0)
y
(cid:14)
ROSAT .{. keV . counts ks
:
: : :
(cid:0)
y
(cid:14)
y Units of
erg s
cm
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
|
astro-ph/9601110 | 1 | 9601 | 1996-01-22T09:08:40 | Constraining Omega using weak gravitational lensing by clusters | [
"astro-ph"
] | The morphology of galaxy clusters reflects the epoch at which they formed and hence depends on the value of the mean cosmological density, Omega. Recent studies have shown that the distribution of dark matter in clusters can be mapped from analysis of the small distortions in the shapes of background galaxies induced by weak gravitational lensing in the cluster potential. We construct new statistics to quantify the morphology of clusters which are insensitive to limitations in the mass reconstruction procedure. By simulating weak gravitational lensing in artificial clusters grown in numerical simulations of the formation of clusters in three different cosmologies, we obtain distributions of a quadrupole statistic which measures global deviations from spherical symmetry in a cluster. These distributions are very sensitive to the value of Omega_0 and, as a result, lensing observations of a small number of clusters should be sufficient to place broad constraints on Omega_{0} and certainly to distinguish between the extreme values of 0.2 and 1. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (0000)
Printed 18 September 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.3)
Constraining Ω0 using weak gravitational lensing by
clusters
Gillian Wilson1, Shaun Cole2, Carlos S. Frenk3
Department of Physics, University of Durham, Science Laboratories, South Rd, Durham DH1 3LE
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
18 September 2018
ABSTRACT
The morphology of galaxy clusters reflects the epoch at which they formed and hence
depends on the value of the mean cosmological density, Ω0. Recent studies have shown
that the distribution of dark matter in clusters can be mapped from analysis of the
small distortions in the shapes of background galaxies induced by weak gravitational
lensing in the cluster potential. We construct new statistics to quantify the morphology
of clusters which are insensitive to limitations in the mass reconstruction procedure. By
simulating weak gravitational lensing in artificial clusters grown in numerical simula-
tions of the formation of clusters in three different cosmologies, we obtain distributions
of a quadrupole statistic which measures global deviations from spherical symmetry
in a cluster. These distributions are very sensitive to the value of Ω0 and, as a result,
lensing observations of a small number of clusters should be sufficient to place broad
constraints on Ω0 and certainly to distinguish between the extreme values of 0.2 and 1.
Key words: gravitational lensing
1
INTRODUCTION
In a low density universe, density fluctuations cease to grow
after a redshift z ∼ 1
− 1, where Ω0 is the present value of
Ω0
the cosmological density parameter (see e.g. Peebles 1980,
§11 & §13). Introducing a cosmological constant, λ0 (which
we shall express in units of 3H 2
0 , where H0 is the present
value of the Hubble constant) makes this cessation more
abrupt. Hence, in low Ω0 models, both with and without
a cosmological constant, clusters form at moderate redshift
(z = 1 -- 4), and subsequently accrete very little material. In
this period, which can span many dynamical times, the in-
ternal structure of the clusters relaxes to produce smooth,
nearly spherical configurations. In contrast, in Ω0 = 1 mod-
els structure formation occurs continuously, rich galaxy clus-
ters form in abundance only at very low redshift (z = 0.2 --
0.3), and continue to accrete material even at the present
epoch. Hence, if Ω0 = 1, many clusters are expected to show
evidence of recent merger events and to have irregular mor-
phologies.
Over the past few years a number of optical and X-ray
studies have suggested that a significant proportion of clus-
ters, perhaps ∼ 40%, show evidence of substructure (e.g.
Geller & Beers 1982; Dressler & Schectman 1988; West &
Bothun 1990; Forman & Jones 1990; Bird 1994; West, Jones,
& Forman 1995. Motivated by these interesting but contro-
versial observations suggesting recent cluster growth, Evrard
et al. (1994) and Mohr et al. (1995) demonstrated that,
in agreement with analytic predictions (Richstone, Loeb, &
Turner 1992; Lacey & Cole 1993), the internal structure of
clusters is sensitive to the cosmological model. Evrard et al.
(1994) constructed X-ray surface brightness maps from their
hydrodynamic N-body simulations of cluster formation and
compared these to X-ray maps of 65 clusters observed with
the Einstein Imaging Proportional Counter. They concluded
that galaxy clusters with the observed range of X-ray mor-
phologies were more likely to have arisen in a high Ω0 cos-
mology.
In parallel with these developments, it has become clear
that the structure of the dynamically dominant dark matter
in clusters can be reliably mapped by analysing the distor-
tions in the images of background galaxies induced by weak
gravitational lensing in the cluster potential. Our aim in
this paper is to assess whether the surface overdensity maps
revealed by such analyses may be used to quantify cluster
morphology and hence to constrain Ω0. To this end we sim-
ulate the lensing of background galaxies by clusters drawn
from three different cosmological models. These are the same
clusters studied by Evrard et al. (1994). For each cluster we
create a mock CCD frame as described in Wilson, Cole, &
2 G. Wilson, S. Cole, and C. S. Frenk
Frenk (1996) (hereafter WCF) and then use the inversion
technique of Kaiser & Squires (1993) to reconstruct a map
of the projected cluster overdensity.
The remainder of this paper is organised as follows.
The main features of the Kaiser & Squires reconstruction
method are summarized in Section 2.1. Section 2.2 intro-
duces new statistics for measuring cluster shapes, specifi-
cally tailored to be insensitive to uncertainties inherent in
the reconstructed surface overdensity maps. In Section 2.3
we describe the simulated galaxy clusters to be used as lenses
and whose density profiles we examine. Section 2.4 reviews
how we generate the background distribution of galaxies and
create mock CCD frames of the lensed galaxies. Our results
are presented in Section 3 where we compare the reconstruc-
tions to the original clusters and assess how the measured
distribution of cluster shapes depends on the cosmological
model. We conclude in Section 4 with a discussion and sum-
mary of our main results.
2 METHODS
2.1 Lensing Reconstruction
The lensing reconstruction technique employed in this paper
was devised by Kaiser & Squires (1993) (hereafter KS). It
produces a map of the estimated overdensity, σ(~θ), where
σ(~θ) is the deviation of the true cluster surface density, S,
from the mean surface density, ¯S, within the area being
considered, measured in units of the critical surface density
Scrit:
σ(~θ) =
S − ¯S
Scrit
,
(2.1)
where ~θ is the position vector on the plane of the lens. Scrit
is defined as
Scrit =
c2
4πG
Dos
DolDls
,
(2.2)
where D denotes angular-diameter distance and the sub-
scripts refer to the observer, lens and source galaxy. This
critical surface density is the minimum required to produce
multiple images of a source object.
As shown in WCF, the KS technique recovers the mass
distribution in clusters extremely well when the lensing is
weak i.e. when the bending angle varies slowly with po-
sition. Our CCD simulations in that paper demonstrated
that observational complications such as seeing and noise act
to diminish the reconstructed surface density. However, we
showed that it was possible to correct fully for this diminu-
tion and proposed a method to estimate a multiplicative
compensation factor, f.
2.2 Quantifying Shapes
Lensing reconstructions such as that of KS reliably return
relative values of the surface overdensity, σ(~θ) (equation 2.1),
but do not fix its absolute value. Since Scrit depends on the
geometry of the lensing configuration through the angular-
diameter distance relationship, the redshift distribution of
source galaxies must be known before the mean value of
Scrit (equation 2.10 below) and hence the absolute surface
overdensity S − ¯S can be obtained from equation 2.1. In
addition, the KS technique is only sensitive to variations in
surface density from the mean. This is because a uniform
slab of material across the whole lens plane does not distort
the images of galaxies lying behind. Thus, the mean surface
density, ¯S, is also unknown unless the region analysed is suf-
ficiently large to encompass the whole of the lensing material
so that the surface density near the edge of the region can
be taken as the zero-point.
In order to minimise the effects of these uncertainties,
we define dipole and quadrupole statistics which depend not
on the absolute surface overdensity, but only on the values
of σ(~θ) relative to each other. These statistics, therefore,
are explicitly independent of ¯S, Scrit and any compensation
factor f . We define the dipole, D(A), by
[d2
1 + d2
2]
1
2
3
2
A
=
d
3
2
A
D(A) =
where
d1 = Z H(σ − σcon)x dA,
d2 = Z H(σ − σcon)y dA
and
A = Z H(σ − σcon) dA.
(2.3)
(2.4)
(2.5)
(2.6)
Here, σcon is the surface overdensity of the contour level
above which we choose to evaluate the statistic and A is the
area within that contour. H is the Heaviside step function,
H(σ − σcon), which is equal to 0 if σ < σcon and equal to 1
if σ ≥ σcon. The integrals are evaluated over the area within
the contour. Similarly the quadrupole, Q(A), for the same
area A is defined as
[q2
1 + q2
2]
1
2
A2
=
q
A2
Q(A) =
where
q1 = Z H(σ − σcon)(x2 − y2) dA
and
q2 = Z H(σ − σcon)2xy dA.
(2.7)
(2.8)
(2.9)
The x and y coordinates are measured relative to the cluster
centre. (We shall discuss exactly how we define the cluster
centre in Section 3.) In practice, the integrals become sums
over pixels in the reconstructed maps. Note that both these
statistics are dimensionless. If one pictures a reconstructed
surface density map as a contour plot, then these statistics
are independent of the value of σ labelling each contour
because we select the contour by the area A that it encloses
rather than by its level. Thus, once a suitable area A has
been chosen, say 5 arcmin2, the statistics are independent
of :-
(i) Any dilution of the lensing signal due to seeing.
Constraining Ω0 using weak gravitational lensing by clusters
3
(ii) Nonlinearity effects which may result in an underes-
timate of the surface overdensity in regions of high S.
(iii) The (unknown) value of Scrit.
The values of the statistics D(A) and Q(A) will, of course,
depend on the noise level in the reconstructed surface den-
sity maps. It is this effect on these statistics that we aim to
quantify with our simulations of lensing.
2.3 The Cluster Simulations
As our lenses we used a set of eight N-body gasdynamic sim-
ulations of the formation of galaxy clusters, further details
of which may be found in Evrard et al. (1994). The clusters
evolved from the same eight sets of initial density fields but
in three different cosmologies:
(i) A biased Einstein-de Sitter model [ Ω0 = 1, σ8 = 0.59,
where σ8 is the rms fluctuation of mass within spheres of
radius 8h−1Mpc, and h is the present value of the Hubble
constant in units of 100 kms−1Mpc−1].
(ii) An unbiased (σ8 = 1.0) open model with Ω0 = 0.2
and λ0 = 0.
(iii) An unbiased (σ8 = 1.0) low density flat model with
Ω0 = 0.2 and λ0 = 0.8.
In each of four periodic boxes of size L = 15, 20, 25
and 30 h−1 Mpc, Evrard et al. created two constrained
realizations of Gaussian random density fields, with the
standard cold dark matter power spectrum appropriate for
H0 = 50 km s−1 Mpc−1. In each case, using the technique
of Bertschinger (1987), they imposed the constraint that,
when smoothed with a Gaussian of width Rf = 0.2L, there
be a peak at the centre of the box with height 2.5 -- 5 times
the rms density fluctuation on this scale.
Evrard's (1988) P3M/SPH hydrodynamic N-body code
was used to evolve the particle distributions to the present
epoch. Two sets of 323 particles represented the dark mat-
ter and gas respectively. A baryon content of Ωb = 0.1 was
assumed for all the models. Gravity, PdV work and shock
heating were incorporated for the gas but the effects of ra-
diative cooling were ignored. The spatial resolution was ap-
proximately 0.005L, varying from 75 to 150 h−1 kpc depend-
ing on the box length. For our lensing simulations we chose
the output epoch from each cosmology closest to redshift
z = 0.18. This value is fairly typical in observational studies
(Wilson et al. 1996) and corresponds to the value adopted
in our previous simulations (WCF).
In the simulations of Evrard et al. (1994) the mass of
each cluster was approximately proportional to the volume
of the simulation box. Our aim here is to study the morphol-
ogy of clusters detected by gravitational lensing with similar
signal-to-noise ratio in each cosmology. Thus, for our pur-
poses it is more convenient to have a set of clusters all of the
same mass. To achieve this we simply rescaled the mass of
each particle in the smaller clusters so that the total mass
was the same as that in the largest cluster i.e. the one in
the L = 30h−1 Mpc box. This required multiplying each
mass by the factor (30h−1Mpc/L)3. In order to preserve the
correct density, we also multiplied the simulation length by
30h−1Mpc/L.
The typical mass of a rich cluster is known approx-
imately from observations. For a fair intercomparison of
the models, the clusters considered should all have approx-
imately the same mass within a fiducial radius such as the
Abell radius (1.5h−1Mpc). The simulated clusters in the
open and flat Ω0 = 0.2 cosmologies were somewhat less
massive and so we scaled them as in the previous paragraph
to have approximately the same total mass as the average
Ω0 = 1 cluster (∼ 1.36 × 1015h−1M⊙ within an Abell ra-
dius). The maximum scaling required was a factor of 2.4 in
mass.
After this rescaling the initial conditions are no longer
appropriate for a standard CDM model but instead have
power spectra with slopes which differ slightly from the cor-
rect ones. However, analytic arguments show that moderate
changes in the slope of the power spectrum are far less im-
portant in determining the formation history of a cluster
than the actual value of Ω0 (Lacey & Cole 1993). Further-
more, recent high-resolution simulations of the formation of
dark matter halos in an Ω0 = 1 universe by Cole & Lacey
(1995) demonstrate that a statistic similar to the one we use
below to characterize cluster shapes is insensitive to spectral
index and halo mass (cf their Figure 17). Thus, our rescaling
should have a negligible effect on our results.
We tripled the size of our cluster sample by choosing
three perpendicular axes through the centre of each cluster
and treating the projection along each axis as a different
cluster. This resulted in 72 clusters, 24 from each of the
three cosmologies.
2.4 CCD images
To simulate typical observational datasets, we constructed
artificial B-band CCD images of lensed field galaxies, build-
ing them up pixel by pixel, in the manner described in WCF.
We employed the same distributions of galaxy ellipticity,
scalelength, redshift, magnitude, noise and seeing as in that
paper:
• Redshift and magnitude distributions
For the redshift distribution of the model galaxies, we
adopted the mB = 25 distribution predicted by the ana-
lytic model of galaxy formation of Cole et al. (1994). Since
the critical density, Scrit, depends on the source redshifts
through equation (2.2), we sampled this redshift distribu-
tion discretely and produced a set of source planes spanning
a range of redshifts. The net effect on the reconstruction
equations is that Scrit is replaced by the mean value, ¯Scrit,
defined by
crit = Z
¯S−1
1
Scrit(z)
p(z) dz,
(2.10)
where p(z) is the probability that a galaxy lies at red-
shift z. For our adopted redshift distribution, ¯Scrit ≃ 6 ×
1015hM⊙/Mpc2, with the exact value depending on the cos-
mology. The distribution of apparent magnitudes we gen-
erated directly from the B-band source counts of Metcalfe
et al. (1995).
• Scalelength distribution
We assumed that all the background galaxies are disks
with exponential profiles. The scalelength was chosen from a
4 G. Wilson, S. Cole, and C. S. Frenk
a)
b)
Figure 1. Examples of surface overdensity maps for four clusters from each of the three cosmologies. In each group the left-hand column
shows the original surface density maps and the right-hand column the corresponding reconstruction. The greyscales have been adjusted
according to the central surface overdensity in each case. From top to bottom the clusters are from the Ω0 = 1, open Ω0 = 0.2 and flat
Ω0 = 0.2 models with the same initial fluctuation spectrum. The original CCD frame from which the reconstruction was made subtended
an angle of ∼ 10 arcmins but these maps show only the inner 6.7 by 6.7 arcmins. At the cluster redshift, z = 0.18, 1 arcmin is equivalent
to 0.12h−1Mpc for the Ω0 = 1 cosmology. The contour plotted encloses an area of 3.8 arcmin2. A Gaussian smoothing of width θsm =
0.25 arcminutes has been used in the KS reconstruction procedure.
uniform distribution in the range 0.25 arcseconds to 0.65 arc-
seconds, as suggested by the observations of Tyson (1994).
• Ellipticity distribution
Ellipticities for the background galaxies were generated
by randomly sampling the empirical ellipticity distribution
derived from a single frame in 0.7 -- 0.9 arcseconds seeing by
Brainerd, Blandford, & Smail (1995).
We created one CCD frame per cluster projection and
then analysed it using FOCAS (Jarvis & Tyson 1981) as
described in WCF. We assumed moderately good seeing of
1 arcsecond full-width half-maximum.
3 RESULTS
Figures 1a-d show examples of the projected mass distribu-
tion in the central regions of some of our clusters. In each
group, from top to bottom, we illustrate clusters grown from
identical initial conditions in the Ω0 = 1, open Ω0 = 0.2, and
flat Ω0 = 0.2 cosmologies respectively. The left-hand panels
give the original surface density, smoothed with a Gaus-
sian of θsm = 0.25 arcminutes, the same smoothing as we
employed in the KS reconstruction. The right-hand panels
show the corresponding reconstructions. The field of view
in each plot is 6.7 arcmins (equivalent to 0.8h−1 Mpc, for
Ω0 = 1), and the contour on each map encloses an area of
3.8 arcmin2.
The surface overdensities on the left-hand side have
been normalised so that the mean value is zero over the full
Constraining Ω0 using weak gravitational lensing by clusters
5
c)
Figure 1. continued.
d)
CCD frame, reflecting the fact that the mean value from
the KS reconstruction is automatically set to zero. To en-
hance the substructure in the reconstructed maps, we have
used different greyscales in the left- and right-hand panels.
The former appear uniformly black near the centre. Limita-
tions of scale, particularly in the open Ω0 = 0.2 case, con-
ceal the reality that the density distribution is in fact very
highly peaked. The maximum surface density can be critical
or even greater. In contrast, the maximum surface overden-
sity in the right-hand panels is ≃ 0.2 or 0.3 of critical. This
diminution is partly due to observational effects such as see-
ing and noise, and partly due to the effects of nonlinearity -
weak lensing reconstruction techniques generally underesti-
mate σ in regions where the surface overdensity rises above
a few tenths of critical. This failure of the method results
in reconstructed profiles that saturate near the cluster cen-
tre producing a broad plateau which, in the open Ω0 = 0.2
model, extends over many hundreds of pixels with similar
density values.
Figure 1 illustrates how clusters in the Ω0 = 1 cos-
mology are still forming at z = 0.18. In most cases, large
clumps are still infalling and the dominant mass conden-
sation is usually quite elongated. By contrast, clusters in
the open Ω0 = 0.2 cosmology are more centrally concen-
trated and closer to spherical symmetry. Clusters from the
flat Ω0 = 0.2 (λ0 = 0.8) cosmology are similar to these
but they have slightly lower central overdensity and are a
little more elongated. In general, the reconstructed shapes
match the originals rather well. With the exception of a few
noisy pixels, the essential features of the different cluster
morphologies are preserved by the reconstruction.
We now use the dipole and quadrupole statistics, de-
fined in Section 2.2, to quantify the distribution of cluster
shapes in each cosmology. Initially we evaluated the statis-
tics D(A) and Q(A) (equations 2.3 and 2.7) after identifying
the cluster centre with the pixel of maximum surface over-
density. We found that unless the reconstructions have very
high signal-to-noise, this choice of centre results in noisy es-
timates of D(A) and to a lesser extent of Q(A). For clusters
with steep density profiles the reconstructed profiles have
a saturated core and, as a result, the highest density peak
is simply the highest noise peak anywhere in this central
plateau. In light of this we tried a second choice of cluster
centre which is more robust than simply selecting the dens-
6 G. Wilson, S. Cole, and C. S. Frenk
a)
b)
Figure 2. The quadrupole, Q(A), as a function of the area over which it is calculated. Two examples are shown of clusters in each of
the Ω0 = 1 (left panel) and open Ω0 = 0.2 models (right panel).
est pixel. This time we took the centre of coordinates to be
the position at which D(A) = 0 (i.e. the centroid of the area
within the contour). The choice of centre now depends on
the area, A, selected, but is much less sensitive to the pres-
ence of noise. Having chosen the centre such that D(A) = 0
we then use only Q(A) as a measure of the asymmetry of
the cluster.
Figure 2a shows Q(A) as a function of area, A, for two
clusters from the Ω0 = 1 cosmology. For A < 2 arcmin2,
Q(A) tends to be small because of the dominant contribu-
tion from the central relaxed core, although its value fluctu-
ates due to noise. As larger areas (and hence smaller surface
overdensities) are considered, some of the more distant in-
falling clumps are included and Q(A) increases. Q(A) then
varies slowly, gradually falling as an increasing number of
randomly distributed noise peaks enter into the analysis.
Fig. 2b shows Q(A) for two clusters from the open Ω0 = 0.2
cosmology. Q(A) is fairly stable over a wide range of area,
never rising above a value of 0.1. This behaviour reflects
the smooth and nearly spherical mass distribution in these
clusters.
We now examine the distribution of Q(A), at a fixed
area A, for our sample of clusters in each of the 3 cosmolo-
gies. Figure 3 shows cumulative distributions of Q(A) ob-
tained from the 24 clusters in each model (see Section 2).
The three panels are for A = 3.8 arcmin2, 6.3 arcmin2, and
12.6 arcmin2. The two solid lines are for Ω0 = 1, the two dot-
ted lines for the open Ω0 = 0.2 model, and the two dashed
lines for the flat Ω0 = 0.2 cosmology. For each pair, the line
marked by triangles, usually with the smaller quadrupole
value, corresponds to the original, smoothed clusters. The
unmarked line corresponds to the reconstructed clusters.
Examining the original clusters first, it is apparent that an
open Ω0 = 0.2 universe forms clusters with the smallest
quadrupoles, followed by the flat Ω0 = 0.2 model and fi-
nally the Ω0 = 1 case. After reconstruction, the quadrupole
value tends to increase, at least for the Ω0 = 1 and the flat
Ω0 = 0.2 clusters. This is primarily due to the inclusion of
outlying noisy pixels in the analysis.
Figure 3 shows that even with the imperfections of the
weak lensing reconstructions, there remains a strong and
measurable difference in the expected distribution of clus-
ter shapes in high and low Ω0 cosmologies. The dependence
of these distributions on λ0 is very weak and so this statis-
tic cannot be used to constrain the cosmological constant.
This does mean, however, that Ω0 can be constrained in-
dependently of the unknown value of λ0. For example, for
A = 3.8 arcmin2 we see that 75% of clusters in an Ω0 = 1
universe have a Q(A) value in excess of 0.1, whereas less
than 10% of clusters in the two Ω0 = 0.2 universes are so
aspherical. Alternatively, the median value of Q(A) is ap-
proximately 0.2 for both A = 3.8 and 6.3 arcmin2 in the
Ω0 = 1 universe, but less than 0.06 for both the Ω0 = 0.2
universes. These large differences suggest that weak lensing
Constraining Ω0 using weak gravitational lensing by clusters
7
4 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
We have shown how global properties of the dark matter
distribution in clusters, as revealed by weak gravitational
lensing analyses, can be used to measure the cosmologi-
cal density parameter, Ω0. Our approach complements and
extends earlier work by Evrard et al. (1994) who first ap-
plied in practice the well established correlation between
the morphology of clusters and the underlying cosmology to
estimate the value of Ω0. Their analysis exploited the fact
that the distribution of hot X-ray emitting gas in clusters
is expected to reflect the structure of the underlying mass
distribution. By probing this distribution directly, gravita-
tional lensing bypasses the need to assume that the mor-
phology of the gas faithfully mimics the morphology of the
cluster mass. Possible (although unlikely) non-gravitational
processes that may affect this correspondence are therefore
not a concern, nor is there a worry that the test may be
affected by contaminating X-ray signals from, for example,
AGNs. A second advantage of the lensing approach is that it
allows the matter distribution to be probed at larger cluster
radii than the centrally concentrated X-ray emission, that is,
at radii where the distinction between different cosmological
models is particularly strong.
The major disadvantage of the lensing method is its
sensitivity to projection effects. The observed galaxy shear
pattern is a function of the product of the projected sur-
face density along the line-of-sight and the effective cross-
section for lensing (which depends on distance through equa-
tion 2.2). Mass clumps at large distances from the cluster
contribute to the lensing signal and, in principle, to the mea-
sured quadrupole. In practice, this is unlikely to be a strong
effect, particularly when the analysis is restricted to rela-
tively small areas around the cluster centre. Nevertheless
the size of this contamination needs to be assessed using
different simulations from those discussed here. X-ray anal-
yses are much less sensitive to projection effects and so the
two approaches are complementary and should be used in
combination.
In some respects, our detailed results must be regarded
as preliminary. The simulations by Evrard et al. which we
have analyzed have a number of limitations. Firstly, the ini-
tial conditions in all the cosmological models were laid down
with the power spectrum appropriate to an Ω0 = 1 CDM
universe. This inconsistency between the power spectrum
and the cosmology was further exacerbated in our case by
the need to rescale the simulations in order to ensure a lens-
ing signal with comparable signal-to-noise in all cosmolo-
gies. Secondly, the baryon fraction in all the simulations
was fixed to be 10% of the critical density so that in the
Ω0 = 0.2 models, the gas contributes half of the total grav-
itating mass. Finally, the clusters we have analyzed were
chosen to correspond to high peaks in the density field, but
they do not represent a proper statistical sample. Although
we argue that all these approximations are unlikely to affect
our results significantly, it is clearly desirable to repeat our
analysis with purpose-built simulations.
The main result of our work is that the distribution of a
low-order statistic sensitive to global deviations from spher-
ical symmetry in the mass distribution of clusters depends
Figure 3. The cumulative probability distribution of the
quadrupole, Q(A), at a fixed area, A, for A = 3.8 arcmin2 (top),
6.3 arcmin2 (middle), and 12.6 arcmin2 (bottom). The cluster
centre has been chosen as the point about which the dipole van-
ishes. The two solid lines are for the Ω0 = 1 model, the two dotted
lines for the open Ω0 = 0.2 model, and the two dashed lines for
the flat Ω0 = 0.2 model. In each case the curves marked by trian-
gles correspond to the original clusters while the unmarked lines
correspond to the reconstructed clusters.
observations of a small number of clusters, approximately
five or so, can distinguish between these two values of Ω0.
A larger cluster sample is required to place finer constraints
on Ω0.
We stress that the distributions of Q(A) plotted in Fig-
ure 3 are typical of those expected from KS mass reconstruc-
tions using weak lensing data obtained in realistic observing
conditions. However, they are not intended to be definitive
descriptions of Q(A) for these cosmologies. Clearly, the exact
form of the distributions will depend on the observing con-
ditions, the seeing and limiting magnitude, as well as on the
redshifts of the clusters. In practice, simulations that mimic
specific observational datasets will need to be performed for
this test of Ω0 to be reliably applied.
8 G. Wilson, S. Cole, and C. S. Frenk
strongly on Ω0. The distribution of this quadrupole statistic
can be robustly recovered from the shear pattern of galax-
ies weakly lensed by the cluster gravitational potential. We
have shown that under standard observing conditions, lens-
ing data for a handful of clusters should distinguish between
cosmological models with Ω0 = 1 and Ω0 = 0.2.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank Gus Evrard for very kindly supply-
ing us with his cluster simulations. We would also like to
thank Chris Metzler for many useful discussions. SMC ac-
knowledges the support of a PPARC Advanced Fellowship.
REFERENCES
Bertschinger E., 1987, Ap.J.L., 323, L103
Bird C. M., 1994, A.J., 107, 1637
Brainerd T. G., Blandford R. D., Smail I., 1995, preprint
Cole S., Aragon-Salamanca A., Frenk C. S., Navarro J. F., Zepf
S. E., 1994, M.N.R.A.S., 271, 781
Dressler A., Schectman S., 1988, A.J., 95, 284
Evrard A. E., Mohr J. J., Fabricant D. G., Geller M. J., 1994,
Ap.J.L., 419, L9
Forman W. F., Jones C. J., 1990, in Oegerle W. R., Fitchett M. J.,
Danly L., ed, Clusters of Galaxies. Cambridge University
Press, p. 257
Geller M. J., Beers T. C., 1982, P.A.S.P., 94, 421
Jarvis J. F., Tyson J. A., 1981, A.J., 86, 476
Kaiser N., Squires G., 1993, Ap.J., 404, 441
Lacey C., Cole S., 1993, M.N.R.A.S., 262, 627
Metcalfe N., Shanks T., Fong R., Roche N., 1995, preprint
Mohr J. J., Evrard A. E., Fabricant D. G., Geller M. J., 1995,
Ap.J., 447, 8
Peebles P. J. E., 1980, The Large-Scale Structure of the Universe.
Princeton University Press
Richstone D., Loeb A., Turner E. L., 1992, Ap.J., 393, 477
Tyson J. A., 1994, in Schaeffer R., ed, Proc. Les Houches Sum-
mer School, Cosmology and Large Scale Structure. Elsevier
Scientific Publishers
West M. J., Bothun G. D., 1990, Ap.J., 350, 36
West M. J., Jones C., Forman W., 1995
Wilson G., Cole S., Frenk C. S., 1996, M.N.R.A.S., in press
Wilson G., Smail I., Frenk C. S., Ellis R. S., Couch W. J., 1996,
M.N.R.A.S., in preparation
This paper has been produced using the Royal Astronomical
Society/Blackwell Science LATEX style file.
|
astro-ph/0004279 | 1 | 0004 | 2000-04-19T15:18:59 | The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present simulations of dwarf nova outbursts taking into account realistic variations of the mass loss rate from the secondary. The mass transfer variation has been derived from 20 years of visual monitoring and from X-ray observations covering various accretion states of the discless cataclysmic variable AM Herculis. We find that the outburst behaviour of a fictitious dwarf nova with the same system parameters as AM Her is strongly influenced by these variations of the mass loss rate. Depending on the mass loss rate, the disc produces either long outbursts, a cycle of one long outburst followed by two short outbursts, or only short outbursts. The course of the transfer rate dominates the shape of the outbursts because the mass accreted during an outburst cycle roughly equals the mass transferred from the secondary over the outburst interval. Only for less than 10% of the simulated time, when the mass transfer rate is nearly constant, the disc is in a quasi-stationary state during which it periodically repeats the same cycle of outbursts. Consequently, assuming that the secondary stars in non-magnetic CV's do not differ from those in magnetic ones, our simulation indicates that probably all dwarf novae are rarely in a stationary state and are constantly adjusting to the prevailing value of the mass transfer rate from the secondary. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
08(02.01.2;08.02.1;08.09.2 AM Her;08.14.2)
ASTRONOMY
AND
ASTROPHYSICS
0
0
0
2
r
p
A
9
1
1
v
9
7
2
4
0
0
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer
variations
M.R. Schreiber, B.T. Gansicke and F.V. Hessman
Universitats-Sternwarte, Geismarlandstr.11, D-37083 Gottingen, Germany
the date of receipt and acceptance should be inserted later
Abstract We present simulations of dwarf nova out-
bursts taking into account realistic variations of the mass
loss rate from the secondary. The mass transfer variation
has been derived from 20 years of visual monitoring and
from X-ray observations covering various accretion states
of the discless cataclysmic variable AM Herculis. We find
that the outburst behaviour of a fictitious dwarf nova with
the same system parameters as AM Her is strongly influ-
enced by these variations of the mass loss rate. Depending
on the mass loss rate, the disc produces either long out-
bursts, a cycle of one long outburst followed by two short
outbursts, or only short outbursts. The course of the trans-
fer rate dominates the shape of the outbursts because the
mass accreted during an outburst cycle roughly equals the
mass transferred from the secondary over the outburst in-
terval. Only for less than 10% of the simulated time, when
the mass transfer rate is nearly constant, the disc is in a
quasi-stationary state during which it periodically repeats
the same cycle of outbursts. Consequently, assuming that
the secondary stars in non-magnetic CV's do not differ
from those in magnetic ones, our simulation indicates that
probably all dwarf novae are rarely in a stationary state
and are constantly adjusting to the prevailing value of the
mass transfer rate from the secondary.
Key words: accretion, accretion discs - binaries: close -
stars: individual: AM Her - novae, cataclysmic variables.
1. Introduction
Cataclysmic variable systems (CV's), in which a white
dwarf accretes material from a Roche lobe filling sec-
ondary star (see Warner 1995 for an enyclopaedic re-
view) can be broadly divided into three subclasses: in
non-magnetic systems, the white dwarf accretes via an
accretion disc; in the magnetic polars, the infalling mat-
ter couples directly onto the strong magnetic field of the
white dwarf before it can build a disc and is funnelled
to accretion region(s) near the magnetic pole(s) of the
white dwarf; finally, in CV's containing a weekly mag-
netic white dwarf (intermediate polars), a partial disc may
exist, with the mass flowing from the inner edge of the
disrupted disc through magnetically funnelled accretion
curtains onto the white dwarf.
Dwarf novae are non-magnetic cataclysmic variable
stars which show characteristic eruptions with photomet-
ric amplitudes in the range of 2 -- 8 magnitudes 1. These
eruptions typically last a few days to several weeks and
recur quasi-periodically on timescales of weeks up to many
years. They are generally thought to result from thermal
instabilities associated with hydrogen ionization in the ac-
cretion disc (see Cannizzo 1993a for a review and Ludwig
et al. 1994 for a detailed parameter study).
An important boundary condition of the disc-limit-
cycle model is the mass transfer rate from the secondary
to the accretion disc. In most studies of dwarf nova out-
bursts this mass transfer rate is kept constant (Cannizzo
1993b; Ludwig & Meyer 1997; Hameury et al. 1998, 1999).
Duschl and Livio (1989) were the first to examine com-
bined mass transfer and disc outbursts, though within the
framework of the mass transfer instability model where
individual and short-lived mass transfer events are capa-
ble of producing single outbursts. Smak (1991, 1999) dis-
cussed mass transfer variations in the context of the su-
peroutburst phenomenon in dwarf novae of the SU UMa
type and dwarf nova outbursts with enhanced mass trans-
fer during outburst.
King & Cannizzo (1998) and Leach et al. (1999) tested
how the accretion disc in a dwarf nova system behaves if
the mass transfer from the secondary varies abruptly be-
tween different levels. They found that these mass transfer
variations produce only subtle effects on normal dwarf no-
vae, including variations in the outburst shape, and that
the dwarf novae keep on having outbursts even if the trans-
fer rate is reduced close to zero.
In spite of these efforts we are left with the question of
what the real variations of the mass tranfer rates from the
secondaries in dwarf nova systems are and how they can
influence the outburst behaviours of the accretion discs.
Fortunately, nature provides an answer to the first ques-
1 Also intermediate polars are known to show outbursts in
their partial discs; e.g. EX Hya, GK Per
2
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
tion in the form of discless cataclysmic variables, the po-
lars or AM Her systems. In these systems, the mass trans-
fer rate can be estimated directly from the observations
because there is no accretion disc acting as a mass buffer.
Thus, we can use the long-term light curve of an AM Her
system as a measure for the mass transfer variations in a
fictitious but realistic dwarf nova system with the same
system parameters. In the present paper, we present the
results of such a numerical experiment.
In the following section, we briefly review the equa-
tions for the viscous and thermal evolution of the accretion
disc, discuss the numerical methods used in our code, and
compare the results of two standard models with other
fine mesh computations. Thereafter we derive the mass
Mtr(t). Fi-
transfer rate in AM Her as a function of time,
nally, we apply this mass transfer rate to a fictitious dwarf
nova and discuss the effects that can be observed in the
outburst behaviour.
We solve Eqs. (1) and (2) using a combined Finite-
Element / Finite-Difference algorithm (FE for the spatial
part and FD for the time-evolution). Apart from our own
work (Schreiber & Hessman 1998) the method of Finite El-
ements has not been used in this context. As this method
proved to be extremely robust, it warrants a somewhat
more detailed description.
u(x) = Pn
The idea of FE is to divide the region of interest
(the disc radii between Rin and Rout) into n − 1 ele-
ments and to expand the function u(x) which is supposed
to solve the differential equation with suitable functions
i=1 aiϕi(x) for every element. In order to get a
continuous solution over all elements, the functions (ϕ) of
every element have to be transformed to the so-called lo-
cal basis functions Ni and the coefficients to the so-called
nodes (ci) before collected together (Gruber & Rappaz
1985, Schwarz 1991). To solve the differential equation,
the function
2. Finite Element Methods in the context of disc
evolution
The classical equation describing the viscous evolution of
the surface density Σ in a geometrically thin, axisymmet-
ric accretion disc is obtained by combining the vertically
averaged Navier-Stokes and mass-conservation equations:
Mtr(t, R)
1
1
2
∂
=
(R
(1)
3
R
2πR
∂
∂R
∂R(cid:16)R
2 νΣ)(cid:17) +
∂Σ
∂t
where ν = (2/3)αRgT /µΩ is the kinematic viscosity, α
denotes the viscosity parameter, Rg the gas constant and
µ the mean molecular weight. The first term on the right
hand side is the classical disc diffusion term and the sec-
ond term describes the external mass-deposition. For the
purposes of this study, we follow Cannizzo (1993b) and
simply add the mass lost from the secondary Mtr(t) in
a Gaussian distribution at a fixed radius near the outer
edge.
Similarly, one can derive an energy equation (in the
central temperature T :
∂T
∂t
=
2(H − C + J)
cpΣ
−
RgT
µcp
1
R
∂(RvR)
∂R
− vR
∂T
∂R
,
(2)
where cp denotes the specific heat,
vR =
−3ν
R
∂ log(νΣr
∂ log R
1
2 )
is the local radial flow velocity, H = 9
viscous heating, C = σT 4
eff is the radiative cooling and
8 νΩ2Σ represents
J =
3
2
cpν
Σ
R
∂
∂R
(R
∂T
∂R
)
the radial energy flux carried by viscous processes (see
Smak 1984; Mineshige & Osaki 1983; Mineshige 1986;
Ichikawa & Osaki 1992 and Cannizzo 1993b, for discus-
sions).
u(x) =
n
Xk=1
ciNi(x)
(3)
has to meet the requirement formulated by Garlerkin:
the integral of the residuum (which one gets by inserting
Eq. (3) into the differential equation) weighted with the
functions Nj(x)(j = 1, ..., n) has to vanish. This require-
ment, the interchange of integration and summation and
partial integration lead to matrix-equations of the form
B c + Ac = D,
(4)
with A = (aij ), B = bij and D = di (i = 1, .., n; j = 1, .., n
for n nodes).
To solve the differential Eqs. (1) and (2), we have to fill
A, B, D in the sense mentioned above and calculate c from
2 and
Eq. (4). After transforming to the variables X = 2R
S = XΣ we derive for the surface density from Eq. (1):
1
n
X 2
aij =
Xk=1
νk(cid:16)Z 12
+Z 12
X 2 Ni
bij = Z NiNjdX
∂Ni
∂X
Nk
∂Nj
∂X
dX
∂Nk
∂X
∂Nj
∂X
dX(cid:17)
di =
n
Xk=1
Z 2 Mtr,kNk
πX 2 NjdX.
Similarly it is easy to obtain for the central temperature
Eq. (2):
n
k
aij =
Xk=1(cid:16)Z p(1)
+Z p(2)
k Nk
bij = Z NiNjdR
∂Ni
∂R
Nk
∂Nj
∂R
dR
∂Ni
∂R
NjdR +Z p(3)
k NiNkNjdR(cid:17)
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
3
Figure 1. Comparison with Cannizzo (1993b, his Fig.6d).
From top to bottom we used 40, 60, 80, 100 and 200 nodes.
Convergence is obtained for 100 nodes.
Figure 2. Comparison with Ludwig & Meyer (1997).
From top to bottom we again used 40, 60, 80 ,100 and
200 nodes. Our code acurately reproduces the sequence of
one long outburst followed by two short outbursts.
dj =
n
Xk=1
Z p(4)
k NkNjdR.
The coefficients p(i)
k are given by
p(1)
k = 3cpνΣ
3cpνΣ
p(2)
k =
R
Rg
− vR
∂RvR
∂R
p(3)
k =
p(4)
k =
µcpR
9/4νΣΩ2 − σTeff
.
cpΣ
The index k refers to the value of the quantities at node
number k, which is equivalent to the radius Rk. Notice
that we only used linear basis functions in this paper.
As mentioned above, Eq. (4) has to be solved to get
c(t + ∆t) from c(t). Using simple finite differences leads to
c(t + ∆t) = c(t)
1
2
∆t(B−1Ac(t)
+B−1Ac(t + ∆t)(+B−1D)).
(5)
In order to test our code, we carried out two sets of
calculations using the binary parameters and cooling func-
tions from Cannizzo (1993b)
M1 = 1M⊙, αh = 0.1, αc = 0.02,
Rin = 5.0 × 108cm, Rout = 4.0 × 1010cm,
Mtr = 1.5 × 109M⊙/yr
and Ludwig & Meyer (1997)
M1 = 0.63M⊙, αh = 0.2, αc = 0.04,
Rin = 8.4 × 108cm, Rout = 1.7 × 1010cm,
Mtr = 5 × 1015g/s.
The resulting light curves are shown in Figs. 1 and 2. Our
code reproduces the sequence of only relatively long out-
bursts found by Cannizzo (1993b) for the parameter of
SS Cygni as well as the sequence of one long outburst fol-
lowed by two short outbursts found by Ludwig & Meyer
(1997) to describe VW Hydri. The short outbursts arise
when there is not enough mass stored in the disc and there-
fore the heating wave gets reflected before it has reached
the outer edge of the disc.
We find that at least 100 nodes are necessary for long-
term convergence. The outburst and quiescence duration
decreases with an increasing number of nodes because -
with finer zoning - the length of time spent on the viscous
plateau becomes shorter (Cannizzo 1993b). This effect is
smaller in Fig. 2 because the disc is smaller in this system.
We conclude that our FE-code produces results which
are in excellent agreement with those of other fine-mesh
computations.
3. The mass loss rate of the secondary star in
AM Herculis
The strong magnetic field of the white dwarf primary in
polars prevents the formation of an accretion disc. With-
out an accretion disc acting as a buffer for the transferred
mass, the mass loss rate from the secondary equals the
mass accretion rate on the white dwarf at every moment,
Macc = Mtr (the free-fall time is <∼ 1 h). As an obser-
vational consequence, any variation in rate at which the
secondary star loses mass through the L1 point will re-
sult in a quasi-immediate change of the observed accre-
tion luminosity. The brightest polar, AM Her, has been
intensely monitored at optical wavelengths by observers
of the AAVSO for more than 20 years and shows an ir-
regular long-term variability, switching back and forth be-
tween high- and low states of accretion on timescales of
days to months.
The problem of deriving the mass loss history of the
secondary star is then equivalent to that of determining
the accretion luminosity Lacc as a function of time. As the
4
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
Figure 3. The mass transfer rate in AM Her as a function of time.
bulk of the accretion luminosity is emitted in the X-ray
regime, a bolometric correction relating the densly moni-
tored optical magnitude to the total luminosity has to be
derived. This approach has been followed in detail by Hess-
man et al. (A&A, submitted) using X-ray observations ob-
tained at multiple epochs. We summarize only briefly the
results here. The accretion luminosity is computed from
the observed accretion-induced flux Facc as
Lacc(t) = 4πd2Facc(t)
(6)
with d = 90pc (Gansicke et al. 1995). We further use
Facc ≈ FSX + 3 × FHX with FSX and FHX the observed soft
and hard X-ray fluxes respectively. The factor three ac-
counts for the additional cyclotron radiation emitted from
the accretion column and for the thermal reprocession of
bremsstrahlung and cyclotron radiation intercepted by the
white dwarf and emitted in the ultraviolet (Gansicke et al.
1995). The mass loss ( = transfer) rate is then
Mtr(t) =
Lacc(t)Rwd
GMwd
(7)
where G is the gravitational constant and Rwd and Mwd
are the white dwarf radius and mass, respectively. As the
actual properties of the white dwarf in AM Her are still
the subject of controversial discussions (Gansicke et al.
1998, Cropper et al. 1999), we use the parameters of an
average white dwarf, Mwd = 0.6 M⊙ and Rwd = 8.4 ×
Mtr(t) is shown in Fig. 3. The average value of the
108 cm.
mass transfer rate in AM Her is Mav = 7.88 × 1015g s−1 =
1.24 × 10−10M⊙yr−1. The derived mass transfer rates of
AM Her are in general agreement with results published in
the literature. For example, Beuermann & Burwitz (1995)
M⊙yr−1
found transfer rates between 0.8 and 2.0 × 10−10
and Greeley et al. (1999) estimated a mass transfer rate
of 2 × 1016 g s−1 for the high state of AM Her from far
ultraviolet spectra.
4. Results
4.1. The fictitious dwarf nova
We devised a fictitious dwarf nova with a non-magnetic
primary of mass Mwd = 0.6 M⊙ and an orbital period of
P = 3.08 hr, i.e. a non-magnetic twin of AM Her. For these
binary parameters, we obtain Rin ≃ Rwd = 8.4 × 108 cm
for the inner disc radius and Rout = 2.2 × 1010 cm for the
outer edge of the disc. We then used our FE code to follow
the structure of the accretion disc in our fictitious dwarf
nova for 7000 d, applying the variable mass transfer rate
Mtr(t) derived above and standard viscosity parameters
αh = 0.2 and αc = 0.04.
We show 500 day-long samples of our calculations in
Figs. 4 -- 8. In each figure, the top panel show the mass
transfer rate as a function of time (solid line) and the av-
erage mass transfer rate log( Mav[g s−1]) = 15.90 (dotted
line). The panel below displays the disc mass Mdisc nor-
malized with the averaged disc mass M disc = 1.64 × 1023g.
The two lower panels display the light curves calculated
with the varying mass transfer rate and the light curves
calculated with the constant average mass transfer rate
respectively. For the constant average mass transfer rate
the disc goes through a ∼ 60 day-long cycle including one
long outburst followed by two short outbursts. The long
outbursts are those in which the entire disc is transformed
into the hot state while the short outbursts arise when the
outward moving heating wave is reflected as a cooling wave
before it has reached the outer edge of the disc.
Our numerical experiment clearly demonstrates that
the outburst light curve of the fictitious system is strongly
affected by the variations of the mass transfer rate. Even
in the case of relatively small fluctuations effects on the
outburst behaviour (16.0 < log( Mtr[g s−1]) < 16.4) are
clearly present in the light curve. In Fig. 4, the mass trans-
fer rate is always high during the 500 days but the disc
switches between an accretion state with only long out-
bursts and states where one or two short outbursts follow
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
5
Figure 4. From top to bottom as a function of time:
the mass transfer rate (top, solid line), the averaged mass
transfer rate (top, dotted line), the normalized disc mass
and the light curves produced by the fictitious dwarf nova
with the variable transfer rate and the averaged transfer
rate adopted from AM Her.
a long outburst. When the tranfer rate decreases some-
what (∼ day 200), the disc does not save enough mass to
create consecutive long outbursts until the mass transfer
rate increases again (∼ day 350).
In addition to this effect, our experiment shows that a
sharp decrease in the mass transfer rate instantaneously
changes the outburst behaviour of the accretion disc. In
Fig. 5 the disc first behaves as in Fig. 4 but when the trans-
fer rate drops sharply (day 4340), the long outbursts im-
mediately vanish and the duration of the quiescent phase
increases somewhat.
Another remarkable point is that even during rel-
atively long periods of very low transfer rates (Fig. 6,
days 4700 -- 5000) the disc does not stop its outburst ac-
tivity but produces only short outbursts with slowly de-
creasing amplitudes and increasing quiescence intervals.
This confirms the findings of King & Cannizzo (1998).
Fig. 7 shows 500 days of our simulation in which the
adopted mass transfer from the secondary varies strongly
on a timescale of roughly 20 days. This is the most fre-
quent case during our calculation but there are rare peri-
ods of nearly constant mass transfer. Fig. 8 shows the light
curve of the fictitious system during 500 days in which the
mass transfer rate nearly exactly equals its averaged value
(top). As a result the light curves computed with the real
mass transfer rate and the averaged value look equal.
In summary, one can say that the variations of the
mass transfer rate leads the disc to switch between three
states in which only long outbursts occur (log( Mtr) ≥
16.3), one long outburst is followed by one or two short
Figure 5. The same as Fig. 4 but another snapshot of the
simulation. The sharp decline of the mass transfer rate is
immediately reproduced by the accretion disc.
Figure 6. The same as Fig. 4 but another snapshot of
the simulation. Even the long period of low transfer rates
does not stop the outburst activity of the disc.
outbursts (16.3 > log( Mtr) > 15.7), and only short out-
bursts occur (log( Mtr) ≤ 15.7).
In order to understand the described behaviour of the
disc we take into account the viscous timescale tv ∼ R2/ν
which gives an estimate of the timescale for a disc annulus
to move a radial distance R. For the quiescent state tv,c
and the outburst state tv,h and with R = Rout (where the
mass transferred from the secondary is added to the disc)
we obtain for the viscous timescale
tv,c ∼
R2
ν
∼ 2000 d,
tv,h ∼
R2
ν
∼ 15 d.
(8)
(9)
6
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
The mass added to the disc during quiecence is stored in
the disc because it moves inward on the long timescale tv,c
whereas during an outburst even mass from outer regions
can reach the white dwarf within a viscous timescale. This
makes it possible that the mass accreted onto the white
dwarf during a long outburst can be up to roughly one
third of the disc mass (∼ day 4220). Therefore the disc can
relax to equillibrium with the mass transfer rate in only
one outburst in the case of high transfer rates (Fig. 4).
The prompt response of the disc to the sharp decline
in the mass transfer rate (Fig. 5) can be understood in the
same way: due to the short viscous time (tv,h) the disc ac-
cretes a substantial fraction of the disc mass (∼ 1/4Mdisc)
during the last long outburst which immediately prevents
long outbursts when the mass transfer rate becomes low
(∼ day 4340).
Finally, the long period of low transfer rates (Fig. 6) do
not prevent outbursts because the mass accreted during
the short outbursts is only a few percent of the disc mass.
Therefore the disc relaxes to the mass transfer rate on a
longer timescale.
4.2. The mass transfer and mass accretion rates
An important point in understanding the physics of ac-
creting binaries is to know how far the outburst behaviour
and hence the resulting light curves depend on real varia-
tions of the mass tranfer rate.
To answer this question, we compare the averaged
mass accretion rate onto the white dwarf with the mass
transfer rate. Figure 9 shows that the time in which the
disc relaxes to an equilibrium with the mass transfer rate
depends on the occurence of long outbursts: when the
accretion rate is averaged over 20 days (dotted line in
Fig. 9) the mass transfer and the accretion rate correspond
roughly only during periods where only long outbursts
occur (days 40 -- 150, see also Fig. 4) but for the periods
where the disc goes through a cycle of short and long out-
bursts the accretion rate has to be averaged over 60 days
to match the mass transfer rate (days 150 -- 500). If the
mass transfer rate drops steeply and stays in a low -- state
(days 4700 -- 5000 in Fig. 10, see also Fig. 6), the accretion
rate needs more than 60 days to follow this behaviour,
because the disc produces only short outbursts in which
only a small percentage of the disc mass is involved.
In order to make this plausible we give a relaxation
timescale tr as the ratio of the viscous timescale in out-
burst with the relative mass fraction accreted during an
outburst:
tr ∼ tv,h
Mdisc
∆ Mdisc
(10)
For high mass transfer rates this timescale is around
70 days and so the correspondence of the averaged ac-
cretion rate and the mass transfer rate in Fig. 9. is not
surprising. In the case of low transfer rates (Fig. 10, day
Figure 7. The same as Fig. 4 but a snapshot of the sim-
ulation where the transfer rate strongly varies.
Figure 8. The same as Fig. 4 but a snapshot of the sim-
ulation where the transfer rate nearly stays constant.
4700 -- 5000) this timescale is longer (∼ 300 days) because
only roughly 5 percent of the disc mass are accreted during
an outburst.
4.3. Dependence on the primary mass
In the numerical experiment above, we have assumed an
average white dwarf mass for the primary in AM Her. The
literature holds a large spectrum of white dwarf mass es-
timates for AM Her, Mwd = 0.39 M⊙ (Young & Schneider
1981), Mwd = 0.69 M⊙ (Wu et al.1995), Mwd = 0.75 M⊙
(Mukai & Charles 1987), Mwd = 0.91 M⊙ (Mouchet 1993)
and Mwd = 1.22 M⊙ (Cropper et al. 1998). Based on
the observed ultraviolet spectrum of AM Her and on its
well-established distance, Gansicke et al. (1998) estimated
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
7
7000 days of disc evolution with the new Mtr(t), αh =
0.1, αc = 0.02 and Rout = 2.8 × 1010 cm.
In Fig. 11 we show 500 days of our calculation with
Mwd = 1.0 M⊙. The disc produces only short outbursts
and the outburst cycle of four outbursts with decreasing
amplitude is hardly changed even by drastic variations of
the mass transfer rate (day 4700).
The different responses that our fictitious dwarf novae
with 0.6M⊙ and 1.0M⊙ white dwarfs show to the vari-
able mass transfer rate are easy to understand: both the
increased primary mass and the decreased radius of the
white dwarf reduce - as mentioned above - the derived
average mass transfer rate.
In addition, the outer disc radius of the fictitious sys-
tem with Mwd = 1.0M⊙ increases. The disc becomes more
massive, i.e. M disc = 4.59 × 1023g, because of its increased
size.
Due to the reduced mass transfer rate and the in-
creased disc size, the heating waves are able to reach the
outer edge of the disc only during the first outburst of the
outburst cycle and only in cases where the mass transfer
rate is high (log Mtr ≥ 16.1). Even in this rare situation
the disc stays only a few days in the hot state and ac-
cretes only a small fraction of the disc mass (∼ 1/8 Mdisc).
For lower transfer rates (the extremly more frequent case
shown in Fig. 11) the heating front gets reflected before
it has reached the outer edge of the disc. Hence, only a
small percentage of the disc mass is involved in any out-
burst. Therefore, and due to the longer viscous timescale,
the relaxation timescale given in Eq. (10) is always larger
than a few years.
Summing up, the adopted primary mass and the aver-
age accretion rate play an important role on the influence
that the variable mass transfer rate has on the outburst
behaviour.
5. A note on the disc limit-cycle model
A number of new features have been added to the well
known limit-cycle model (Meyer & Meyer-Hofmeister
1981; Smak 1982; Cannizzo, Gosh & Wheeler 1982).
Hameury et al. (1998, 1999, 2000) have shown how the
light curves change if the disc size is allowed to vary and
which effects irradiation has on the outburst behaviour.
Additionally these authors discussed other sources of un-
certainties such as the tidal torque and the evaporation
of the inner parts of the disc (Meyer & Meyer-Hofmeister
1994). They concluded that all these effects must be in-
cluded in order to obtain meaningful physical informa-
tion on e.g. the viscosity from the comparison of pre-
dicted and observed light curves. Another point of im-
portance is the interaction of the accretion stream leav-
ing the secondary star and the accretion disc. Schreiber &
Hessman (1998) tested the influence of stream overflow on
the disc evolution in dwarf novae. They found that signif-
icant stream overflow can lead to reversion of the inward-
Figure 9. The mass transfer rate (solid line) and the
accretion rate onto the white dwarf as function of time.
The accretion rate is averaged over 60 days (dashed line)
and averaged over 20 days (dotted line).
Figure 10. The mass transfer rate (solid line) and the
accretion rate onto the white dwarf as function of time.
The accretion rate is averaged over 60 days (dashed line).
Rwd ≈ 1.1 × 109 cm, and, using the Hamada-Salpeter
(1961) mass-radius relation for carbon cores, 0.35 M⊙ <
Mwd < 0.53 M⊙. As the Hamada-Salpeter mass-radius
relation is valid for cold white dwarfs, the finite temper-
ature ≈ 20 000 K of the white dwarf in AM Her would al-
low also somewhat higher masses, Mwd ≈ 0.65M⊙, which
is very close to the average mass of field white dwarfs,
0.6M⊙, that we used.
Even though we exclude a massive white dwarf based
on the observational evidences, we repeated our simulation
with Mwd = 1.0M⊙ in order to test the sensitivity of our
results.
In a first step, we recompute Mtr(t) from Eq. (7) with
Mwd = 1.0 M⊙ and a corresponding Rwd = 5.4 × 108 cm.
The resulting mean accretion rate is 3.0 × 1015g s−1, a fac-
tor 2.6 lower than before. Then, we simulated once more
8
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
travelling cooling front and create an outward-travelling
heating front. This behaviour would produce small dips in
the light curve during the declining phase.
The model we used here contains neither irradiation
nor allows it the disc radi to vary. The stream mass is
simply deposited in a small Gaussian distribution near
the outer edge of the disc. Therefore we do not attempt
at present a comparison with observed light curves. Nev-
ertheless, all calculated light curves with constant mass
transfer from the secondary relax in a quasi-stationary
outburst cycle (of one or more outbursts) which repeat
periodically. Our model shows in a qualitative way that
real mass transfer variations may have a dominant influ-
ence on the outburst behaviour at least in systems with
relatively small discs and strong mass transfer.
6. Discussion and conclusions
There is no reason to assume that the mass transfer varia-
tions of the secondary observed in AM Her are not present
in non-magnetic systems. Our numerical experiment in-
cluding realistic variations of the mass transfer rate in a
dwarf nova system is, therefore, a significant step towards
a better understanding of dwarf nova light curves, and,
thereby, of the underlying disc limit cycle.
The light curve produced by our fictitious system
switches between three states depending on the actual
mass transfer rate. High transfer rates lead to only long
outbursts where the entire disc is transformed into the
hot state. If the transfer rate is near the average value
the disc goes through a cycle of three outbursts, one long
outburst followed by two short ones. Even long periods of
low transfer rates do not force the disc to stop its outburst
activity: long outbursts are suppressed and the duration
of quiescence increases but the disc always produces short
outbursts. From this follows that the low-states of VY
Sculptoris stars (a subgroup of novalike variables) could
not be caused by low transfer rates alone (see also Leach
et al. 1999).
We find that in our fictitious system the mass accreted
during an outburst cycle is dominated by the course of
the mass transfer rate if the mass transfer rate varies
significantly. The disc always relaxes to equilibrium with
the mass input from the secondary. Thus, our experiment
strongly supports King & Cannizzo's (1998) claim that
dwarf nova accretion discs are probably never in a sta-
tionary state but are constantly adjusting to the prevailing
Mtr. Only during periods where the mass transfer
value of
rate is nearly exactly constant the disc periodically repeat
the quasy stationary outburst cycle. Such periods are rare
but occur in AM Her.
The strong influence of the mass transfer rate on the
outburst behaviour of the fictitious system clearly indi-
cates that probably most (if not all) the deviations from
periodic outburst cycles seen in the light curves of dwarf
novae are caused by variations of the mass transfer rate.
Figure 11. The same as in Fig. 6 but assuming a more
massive primary Mwd = 1.0 M⊙
Acknowledgements. We thank Daisaku Nagami and the referee
for their helpful comments and suggestions. MRS would like to
thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for financial sup-
port (Ma 1545 2-1). BTG thanks for support from the DLR
under grant 50 OR 99 03 6.
References
Beuermann K., Burwitz, 1995, ASP Conf. Ser. 85, Cape Work-
shop on Magnetic Cataclysmic Variables, ed. D.A.H. Buck-
ley and B. Warner (San Francisco:ASP), p.99
Cannizzo J.K., Gosh P., Wheeler J.C. 1982, ApJ 260, L83
Cannizzo J.K., 1993a, in Accretion Discs in Compact Stellar
Systems, ed. J.C. Wheeler (Singapore: World Scientific), 6
Cannizzo J.K., 1993b, ApJ 419, 318
Cropper M., Ramsay G., Wu K., 1998, MNRAS, 293, 222
Cropper M., Wu K., Ramsay G., Kocabiyik A., 1999, MNRAS
306, 684
Duschl W.J. & Livio M., 1989, A&A 209, 183
Gansicke B.T., Beuermann K., de Martino D., 1995, A&A 303,
127
Gansicke B.T., Hoard D.W., Beuermann K., Sion E.M., Szkody
P., 1998, A&A 338, 933
Greeley B.W., Blair W.P., Long K.S., Raymond J.C., 1999,
ApJ 513, 491
Gruber R. Rappaz J., 1985, Finite Element Methods in Linear
Ideal Magnetohydrodynamics (Springer Verlag Heidelberg)
Hamada T., Salpeter E.E., 1961, ApJ 134, 683
Hameury J.-M., Menou K., Dubus G., Lasota J.-P., Hur´e J.-
M., 1998, MNRAS 298, 1048
Hameury J.-M., Lasota J.-P., Dubus G., 1999, MNRAS 303,
39
Hameury J.-M., Menou K., Lasota J.-P., Warner B., 2000,
A&A 353, 244
Hessman F.V., Gansicke B.T., Mattei J., A&A submitted
Ichikawa S., Osaki, Y., 1992, PASJ 44, 14
King A.R., Cannizzo J.K., 1998, ApJ 499, 348
Ludwig K., Meyer F., 1997, A&A 329, 559
Schreiber et al.: The response of a dwarf nova disc to real mass transfer variations
9
Ludwig K., Meyer-Hofmeister E., Ritter H., 1994, A&A 290,
473
Leach R., Hessman F.V., King A.R., Stehle R., Mattei J., 1999,
MNRAS 305, 225
Meyer F., Meyer-Hofmeister E., 1981, A&A 104, L10
Meyer F., Meyer-Hofmeister E., 1994, A&A 288, 175
Mineshige S., Osaki Y., 1983, PASJ 44, 15
Mineshige S., 1986, PASJ 38, 831
Mouchet M., 1993, in White dwarf: Advances in Observation
and Theory, ed Bartsow M., p. 411 (Dodrecht: Kluwer)
Mukai K., Charles P.A., 1987, MNRAS 226, 209
Schreiber M.R., Hessman F.V., 1998, MNRAS 301, 626
Schwarz H.R., 1991, Finite Element Methods (Teubner)
Smak J., 1982, Acta Astron. 32, 199
Smak J., 1984, Acta Astron. 34, 161
Smak J., 1991, Acta Astron. 41, 269
Smak J., 1999, Acta Astron. 49, 383S
Warner B., 1995, Cataclysmic Variables (Cambridge Univ.
Press, Cambridge)
Wu K., Changmugam G., Shaviv G., 1995, ApJ 455, 260
Young P., Schneider D.P., 1981, ApJ 245, 1043
|
astro-ph/0309435 | 2 | 0309 | 2003-11-10T09:55:28 | The entropy distribution in clusters: evidence of feedback? | [
"astro-ph"
] | The entropy of the intracluster medium at large radii has been shown recently to deviate from the self-similar scaling with temperature. Using N-body/hydrodynamic simulations of the LCDM cosmology, we demonstrate that this deviation is evidence that feedback processes are important in generating excess entropy in clusters. While radiative cooling increases the entropy of intracluster gas, resulting in a good match to the data in the centres of clusters, it produces an entropy-temperature relation closer to the self-similar scaling at larger radii. A model that includes feedback from galaxies, however, not only stabilises the cooling rate in the simulation, but is capable of reproducing the observed scaling behaviour both in cluster cores and at large radii. Feedback modifies the entropy distribution in clusters due to its increasing ability at expelling gas from haloes with decreasing mass. The strength of the feedback required, as suggested from our simulations, is consistent with supernova energetics, providing a large fraction of the energy reaches low-density regions and is originally contained within a small mass of gas. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Preprint astro-ph/0309435
The entropy distribution in clusters: evidence of feedback?
Scott T. Kay⋆
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton BN1 9QJ
12 October 2018
ABSTRACT
The entropy of the intracluster medium at large radii has been shown recently to
deviate from the self-similar scaling with temperature. Using N -body/hydrodynamic
simulations of the ΛCDM cosmology, we demonstrate that this deviation is evidence
that feedback processes are important in generating excess entropy in clusters. While
radiative cooling increases the entropy of intracluster gas, resulting in a good match
to the data in the centres of clusters, it produces an entropy-temperature relation
closer to the self-similar scaling at larger radii. A model that includes feedback from
galaxies, however, not only stabilises the cooling rate in the simulation, but is capable
of reproducing the observed scaling behaviour both in cluster cores and at large radii.
Feedback modifies the entropy distribution in clusters due to its increasing ability at
expelling gas from haloes with decreasing mass. The strength of the feedback required,
as suggested from our simulations, is consistent with supernova energetics, providing
a large fraction of the energy reaches low-density regions and is originally contained
within a small mass of gas.
Key words: methods: N -body simulations -- hydrodynamics -- X-rays: galaxies:
clusters -- galaxies: clusters: general
1
INTRODUCTION
Entropy1 has become the standard quantity for describing
the distribution of the intracluster medium. In a self-similar
population of clusters, where entropy originates solely due
to gravitational infall via shock-heating, entropy scales pro-
portional to the system's virial temperature, S ∝ Tvir. Such
a model, however, does not reproduce the observed X-ray
properties of groups and clusters. The most striking example
of this failure is the X-ray luminosity-temperature (LX −TX)
relation: the self-similar scaling, LX ∝ T α
X , where α = 2
(Kaiser 1986) is flatter than the observed relation for clus-
ters, α ∼ 3 (e.g. Edge & Stewart 1991; Mushotzky & Scharf
1997).
This deficit in luminosity, primarily in low-mass sys-
tems, is due to an excess of entropy in cluster cores (Evrard
& Henry 1991; Kaiser 1991), a phenomenon first measured
by Ponman, Cannon & Navarro (1999). Understanding the
origin of this entropy is central to our understanding of clus-
ter physics (Bower 1997; Voit et al. 2002, 2003). Directly
heating the intracluster gas is the most common solution to
this problem, however a variety of theoretical studies con-
clude that the obvious candidates -- supernovae -- are at best
only marginally capable of generating the required excess en-
⋆ E-mail: [email protected]
1 We define entropy as S = kT /nγ−1
the ratio of specific heats for a monatomic ideal gas.
e
keV cm2, where γ = 5/3 is
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
tropy (e.g. Balogh, Babul & Patton 1999; Kravtsov & Yepes
2000; Loewenstein 2000; Wu, Fabian & Nulsen 2000; Bower
et al. 2001; Borgani et al. 2002). More energetic forms of
supernovae (so-called hypernovae) may be important. Al-
ternative sources of energy that are clearly observed to be
interacting with the intracluster medium are Active Galactic
Nuclei (AGN), capable of distributed heating through their
release of bubbles and jets (e.g. Quilis, Bower & Balogh 2001;
Bruggen & Kaiser 2002; Omma et al. 2003).
Recently, attention has also focused on the effects of
radiative cooling, which selectively removes the low-entropy
material to form galaxies, causing higher-entropy material to
flow in to replace it (Knight & Ponman 1997; Pearce et al.
2000; Bryan 2000; Muanwong et al. 2001, 2002; Dav´e, Katz
& Weinberg 2002; Wu & Xue 2002). Cooling is an appealing
mechanism as it involves no free parameters (other than the
metallicity of the gas, which is observable): the observed
level of excess entropy is consistent with the removal of low-
entropy gas with cooling times shorter than the age of the
Universe, scaling as S ∝ T 2/3 (Voit & Bryan 2001). Cooling,
if unchecked however, overproduces the mass in galaxies,
requiring a feedback mechanism in order to regulate itself
(White & Rees 1978; Cole 1991; Balogh et al. 2001), but
as was pointed out by Voit & Bryan (2001), their argument
still holds so long as feedback efficiently transports cold gas
away from cluster cores.
Perhaps the likely source of excess entropy is from a
combination of cooling and heating processes (Kay, Thomas
2
S. T. Kay
& Theuns 2003; Tornatore et al. 2003). For example, Kay et
al. (2003) studied the combined effects of cooling and feed-
back (by reheating cold galactic gas) in simulations of groups
and concluded that feedback, as well as regulating cooling,
could contribute to the excess core entropy in systems with
virial temperatures smaller than the heating temperature.
In larger systems where this temperature inequality was re-
versed, the inability of reheated gas to escape from the halo
reduces the average entropy of the gas, and if the heating
temperature is low enough, will affect the core entropy.
Attention has now shifted to observing the entropy of
intracluster gas at larger radii. In a recent paper, Pon-
man, Sanderson & Finoguenov (2003) measured the entropy-
temperature relation at a significant fraction of the virial
radius (R500) for a sample of 66 galaxies, groups and clus-
ters: the Birmingham-CfA Cluster Scaling Project (see also
Sanderson et al. 2003; Sanderson & Ponman 2003). In their
study, they measured the same deviation from self-similarity
(S ∝ T 2/3) already observed in the core. This scaling be-
haviour was also verified recently by Pratt & Arnaud (2003),
using XMM-Newton observations of Abell 1413 & 1983. In
this paper, we will argue that these observations are evi-
dence that feedback plays a significant role in forming the
entropy distribution in clusters.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec-
tion 2 we describe the simulations used to perform this
study. Our results are presented in Section 3 and summa-
rized in Section 4.
2 METHOD
2.1 Simulation details
We have performed four simulations of the ΛCDM cosmol-
ogy, setting Ωm = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7, Ωb = 0.045, h = 0.7
& σ8 = 0.9, consistent with the WMAP results. Each run
started from the same initial conditions: a regular cubic
mesh of 2,097,152 (1283) particles (each of gas and dark
matter) within a box of comoving length 60 h−1 Mpc. This
set the gas and dark matter particle masses to be mgas ∼
1.3 × 109 and mCDM ∼ 7.3 × 109 h−1 M⊙ respectively. The
runs were started at z = 49 and evolved to z = 0, using a
gravitational softening length equal to 20 h−1 kpc in comov-
ing co-ordinates.
The code used in this study is a parallel (MPI) ver-
sion of gadget (Springel, Yoshida & White 2001), an N -
body/hydrodynamics code that uses a PM-tree to calcu-
late gravitational forces and Smooth Particle Hydrodynam-
ics (SPH, e.g. Monaghan 1992) to calculate gas forces. This
version of gadget uses entropy as the state variable in the
time-integration of the gas (Springel & Hernquist 2002).
Differences between each of the four runs are solely due
to the processes incorporated that are able to change the
entropy of the gas. These details are described below.
2.1.2 Radiative model
Gas in this model could also lose entropy through radia-
tive processes. We implemented the isochoric approxima-
tion described in Thomas & Couchman (1992), using equi-
librium cooling tables from Sutherland & Dopita (1993). We
fixed the metallicity of the gas to Z = 0.3Z⊙. Dense gas
(n > 10−3cm−3, δ > 100) which cooled below T = 1.2×104K
was converted into collisionless 'stars'. This model signif-
icantly overproduces the mass fraction of cooled baryons
(observed to be 5-10 per cent; Cole et al. 2001; Balogh et al.
2001), producing a global cooled fraction of ∼ 34 per cent
at z = 0.
2.1.3 Feedback model
To stabilize the cooling rate, we only allow some of the
cooled gas to form stars and reheat the rest of the cold ma-
terial. Similarly to Kay et al. (2003) we incorporate feedback
effects on a probabilistic basis. (A more sophisticated heat-
ing mechanism is unwarranted for simulations of this reso-
lution, however this method is designed to capture the gross
behaviour of gas being transported out of galaxies.) Rather
than instantaneously convert all cooled particles into stars,
we assign a value, fheat to each cooled gas particle, defined
to be the fractional mass of cooled material that is reheated,
and draw a random number, r, uniformly from the unit in-
terval. If r < fheat then the particle is heated, otherwise
it becomes collisionless. Rather than heating particles to a
fixed temperature, we instead assigned them a fixed entropy,
as it is this quantity that determines how far the gas can rise
buoyantly out of the cluster.
We ran two simulations with feedback, hereafter re-
ferred to as Weak Feedback and Strong Feedback runs. In the
former case we set fheat = 0.5 (i.e. a cooled particle has an
equal chance of forming stars or being reheated) and supply
an entropy Sheat = 100 keV cm2 to each reheated particle.
For the Strong Feedback simulation, we set fheat = 0.1 and
Sheat = 1000 keV cm2. For a cold gas particle at the same
density, both runs require comparable amounts of energy
per mass of collisionless material but in the Strong Feedback
case, the energy is added to one fifth of the mass of gas in
the Weak Feedback case.
Note that an associated temperature depends on the
density of the gas. At n = 10−3cm−3 (where most of the gas
is heated in the simulation) both runs require ∼ 1 keV of en-
ergy per particle, comparable with the energy available from
supernovae. However, cold gas within galaxies (our simula-
tions do not resolve the internal structure of these objects) is
generally at much higher densities, where much higher tem-
peratures would be required to reach Sheat (if the gas flows
out adiabatically). The solution to this problem is either
that a large fraction of energy is transported to low-density
regions in kinetic form (e.g. Strickland & Stevens 2000) or
that more energetic phenomena are at work, for example
hypernovae or AGN or both.
2.1.1 Non-radiative model
2.2 Cluster selection
In this run, gas was only able to increase its entropy through
shocks. This model reproduces self-similar scalings rather
well.
Clusters in each of the simulations were selected using the
method described in detail in Muanwong et al. (2002). A
minimal-spanning tree is first created, of all dark matter
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Entropy distribution in clusters
3
Figure 1. Entropy at fixed overdensity versus temperature for
clusters in the Non-radiative (open symbols) and Radiative (filled
symbols) runs at z = 0. Squares represent entropy values at
0.1R200 and triangles at R500. Solid lines represent least-squares
fits to the simulated data at R500. The data-points are results
from Ponman et al. (2003), with the dashed line illustrating the
self-similar slope (S ∝ T ), normalized to their 8 hottest clusters.
The horizontal dotted line is the entropy floor, S ∼ 124 keV cm2,
from Lloyd-Davies et al. (2000).
particles whose overdensity exceeds the virial value δ ∼
178Ω−0.55(z) (Eke, Navarro & Frenk 1998). The tree is then
pruned using a linking length, l = 0.5δ−1/3 times the mean
interparticle separation. Spheres are then grown around the
position of maximum density in each clump of particles un-
til the enclosed mean density (of all particles) exceeds ∆
times the comoving critical density. In this paper we focus
on results for ∆ = 500 and ∆ = 200. Finally, clusters with
fewer than 500 particles each of baryons and dark matter
are discarded.
3 RESULTS
3.1 Entropy-Temperature relation
We begin by showing results from our Non-radiative and
Radiative simulations. Fig. 1 illustrates entropy at a fixed
density contrast against soft-band X-ray temperature for
clusters in these two runs. The temperatures are calculated
as
TX =
ΣimiρiΛsoft(Ti, Z)Ti
ΣimiρiΛsoft(Ti, Z)
,
(1)
where mi, ρi and Ti are the mass, density and temperature of
hot gas particle i (Ti > 105K) and Z = 0.3Z⊙. We adopt the
soft-band cooling function, Λsoft, from Raymond & Smith
(1977) for an energy range 0.3 -- 1.5 keV. We calculate a mass-
weighted entropy for each cluster by averaging the entropy
of hot gas particles within a shell of width 20 h−1 kpc (our
results are insensitive to changing the size of this shell by a
factor of 2), centred on the radius of interest.
Squares in the figure represent entropy values at
0.1R200, a radius typically chosen to highlight excess entropy
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Figure 2. Entropy at fixed overdensity versus temperature for
clusters in the Weak Feedback (top panel) and Strong Feedback
(bottom panel) runs at z = 0. Squares represent entropy values at
0.1R200 and triangles at R500. Solid lines represent least-squares
fits to the simulated data. The data-points are results from Pon-
man et al. (2003), with the dashed line illustrating the self-similar
slope (S ∝ T ), normalized to their 8 hottest clusters. The hori-
zontal dotted line is the entropy floor, S ∼ 124 keV cm2, from
Lloyd-Davies et al. (2000).
in groups (Ponman et al. 1999). As shown previously (Muan-
wong et al. 2002; Kay et al. 2003), the Non-radiative model
(open symbols) agrees well with the self-similar prediction
(S ∝ T ), apart from at low temperatures where there is
some scatter due to insufficient resolution in the core, while
the Radiative model (filled symbols) is in reasonable agree-
ment with the observations (the error-bars shown here are
from Ponman et al. 2003).
We also show in this figure (triangles) results for a
lower density contrast of 500, corresponding to ∼ 2/3R200.
Again, our Non-radiative results agree well with the self-
similar scaling but (allowing extrapolation) are around 40
per cent higher than the expected result when normalized
to the hottest 8 clusters in the Ponman et al. sample (up-
per dashed line). Note however, that the Radiative results at
R500 are higher than the observational data at all temper-
4
S. T. Kay
atures, but scale almost self-similarly (S ∝ T 0.9
X ). Cooling
increases the entropy in clusters at all radii but in this case,
disagrees with the observed slope. It is therefore apparent
that cooling has been too efficient at generating excess en-
tropy in the most massive clusters.
Fig. 2 illustrates the same relationships for our Weak
Feedback and Strong Feedback runs. In the former case, we
see that this model does a reasonable job at R500, flatter
than the self-similar relation, but the entropy at 0.1R200 is
considerably lower than observed. In this model, the gas is
not receiving enough entropy to escape from the inner (X-
ray dominant) region of the halo, but the feedback is having
a larger effect on the gas in lower-mass systems, even at
R500. (Note that reheated gas can lose some of its entropy
through cooling.)
The Strong Feedback model, however, matches both re-
lations very well. The increase in entropy allows the gas to
escape to larger radii than previously, but the fate of this
gas depends on the system size. In low-temperature systems,
a significant fraction of hot gas gains enough entropy to es-
cape the system entirely (Kay et al. 2003), resulting in an
entropy excess that is shown here to be present even at large
radii. This effect diminishes in higher-temperature systems,
where the entropy level of the gas is sufficiently high that
less material was able to escape.
3.2 Profiles
To illustrate more clearly the effects of cooling and heating
on the entropy distribution of our clusters, we plot in Fig. 3
entropy profiles for two systems with kTX ∼ 1 & 3 keV
respectively. At large radii in both cases, the Non-Radiative
model has an entropy profile in reasonable agreement with
the relation, S ∝ R1.1, as expected from spherical accretion
shocks (Tozzi & Norman 2001). Both profiles flatten within
∼10 per cent of R200.
Cooling increases the entropy of the gas at all radii (by
removing a significant fraction of gas over the age of the uni-
verse) except for in the very centre where the cooling time
is very short, causing the entropy to drop sharply. These
effects are more prominent in the smaller system, reflect-
ing the increasing efficiency of cooling with decreasing halo
mass.
The Weak Feedback profiles are similar to the Radiative
profiles, except that they are lower in normalization. The
feedback in this case is enough to prevent some gas from
cooling but not to move it around in the cluster significantly.
The Strong feedback model on the other hand shows greater
differences. In the 1 keV system the entropy profile is above
the Radiative profile out to ∼ 0.4R200, where they both be-
come comparable. Feedback therefore has increased the core
entropy over and above what is possible from cooling alone,
by moving some of the hot gas (which did not cool in the Ra-
diative model) to larger radii. In the hotter system, however,
the Strong Feedback profile is slightly lower than the Radia-
tive profile out to ∼ 0.2R200, where it decreases further, and
at R500 is only slightly higher than the Non-radiative profile.
In this system, a larger fraction of gas was retained by the
halo due to its deeper gravitational potential well.
We note that the Strong Feedback profiles are a bit flat-
ter than R1.1 at R500 (supported by observations). Gen-
erally, systems above 1 keV have slopes between 0.8-0.9.
Figure 3. Entropy profiles for two haloes (top panel: kTX ∼ 3
keV and bottom panel: kTX ∼ 1 keV) at z = 0, from the Non-
radiative simulation (solid curve), Radiative simulation (dashed
curve), Weak Feedback simulation (dot-dashed curve) and the
Strong Feedback simulation (triple-dot-dashed curve). The ver-
tical dotted line marks the softening radius and the solid vertical
line R500. The solid diagonal line illustrates the predicted slope
from spherical accretion shock models, S ∝ R1.1.
Whether this discrepancy is a problem with this model re-
quires further investigation, but will greatly benefit from
both larger simulations and a larger sample of high-quality
cluster data.
4 SUMMARY
In this paper we used results from N -body/hydrodynamic
simulations of the ΛCDM cosmology with various degrees
of cooling and feedback,
in order to understand the re-
cent observational claim (Ponman et al. 2003; Pratt & Ar-
naud 2003) that the entropy of intracluster gas does not
scale self-similarly with temperature out to at least R500
(∼ 2/3R200). In particular, we compared our results to the
entropy-temperature relation found by Ponman et al. at
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
0.1R200 and at R500, where both are found to be flatter
(S ∝ T ∼2/3) than the self-similar scaling (S ∝ T ). Our re-
sults can be summarized as follows.
clusters
scale
• Non-radiative
self-similarly in the
entropy-temperature plane to good approximation, both at
0.1R200 and at R500. All but the largest clusters are observed
to have an excess of entropy relative to the self-similar model
at both radii.
• Radiative cooling raises the entropy in clusters at all
radii. While this reproduces the entropy-temperature rela-
tion well at 0.1R200, it produces a relation that is too steep
at R500. In this case, the relation is almost self-similar, sug-
gesting that clusters above a few keV have too much entropy
compared to observations. This is due to the hot gas mass
being too low at all radii.
• A feedback model
in which gas receives a sufficient
(1000 keV cm2) amount of entropy results in excellent agree-
ment with the observations at both radii. The reheated gas
has enough entropy to escape the X-ray core but the fraction
of material unable to leave the cluster (particularly at large
radii) increases with system size, flattening the entropy-
temperature relation. In detail, the entropy profiles are a bit
flatter (at R500) than suggested by observations, prompting
future investigation into whether this discrepancy is signifi-
cant.
We conclude that the entropy level required to match
the observations is high, but supernovae are energetically
capable, providing the energy is efficiently transported into
lower density regions and contained within a small mass of
gas. Alternatively, more energetic phenomena (hypernovae
or Active Galactic Nuclei) may play a part.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Peter Thomas for many helpful discussions and
comments on the original manuscript, Trevor Ponman for
providing useful comments and supplying data-points from
the Birmingham-CfA Cluster Scaling Project and Volker
Springel for making his code gadget available to us. The
simulations used in this paper were carried out using the
Cosmology Machine at the Institute for Computational Cos-
mology, Durham as part of the Virgo Consortium pro-
gramme of investigations into the formation of structure in
the Universe. STK is supported by PPARC.
REFERENCES
Balogh M. L., Babul A., Patton D. R., 1999, MNRAS, 307,
463
Entropy distribution in clusters
5
Edge A. C., Stewart G. C., 1991, MNRAS, 252, 414
Eke V. R., Navarro J. F., Frenk C. S., 1998, ApJ, 503, 569
Evrard A. E., Henry J. P., 1991, ApJ, 383, 95
Kaiser N., 1986, MNRAS, 222, 323
Kaiser N., 1991, ApJ, 383, 104
Kay S. T., Thomas P. A., Theuns T., 2003, MNRAS, 343,
608
Knight P. A., Ponman T. J., 1997, MNRAS, 289, 955
Kravtsov A. V., Yepes G., 2000, MNRAS, 318, 227
Lloyd -- Davies E. J., Ponman T. J., Cannon D. B., 2000,
MNRAS, 315, 689
Loewenstein M., 2000, ApJ, 532, 16
Monaghan J.J., 1992, ARA&A, 30, 543
Muanwong O., Thomas P. A., Kay S. T., Pearce F. R.,
Couchman H. M. P., 2001, MNRAS, 552, L27
Muanwong O., Thomas P. A., Kay S. T., Pearce F. R.,
2002, MNRAS, 336, 527
Mushotzky R. F., Scharf C. A., 1997, ApJ, 482, L13
Navarro J. F., Frenk C. S., White S. D. M., 1995, MNRAS,
275, 720
Omma H., Binney J., Bryan G., Slyz A., 2003, MNRAS,
submitted (astro-ph/0307471)
Pearce F. R., Thomas P. A., Couchman H. M. P., Edge
A. C., 2000, MNRAS, 317, 1029
Ponman T. J., Cannon D. B., Navarro J. F., 1999, Nature,
397, 135
Ponman T. J., Sanderson A. J. R., Finoguenov A., 2003,
MNRAS, 343, 331
Pratt G. W., Arnaud M., 2003, A&A, 408, 1
Quilis V., Bower R. G., Balogh M. L., 2001, MNRAS, 328,
1091
Raymond J. C., Smith B. W., 1977, ApJS, 35, 419
Sanderson A. J. R., Ponman T. J., Finoguenov A., Lloyd-
Davies E. J., Markevitch M., 2003, MNRAS, 340, 989
Sanderson A. J. R., Ponman T. J., 2003, MNRAS, accepted
(astro-ph/0307457)
Springel V., Yoshida N., White S. D. M., 2001, New As-
tronomy, 6, 79
Springel V., Hernquist L., 2002, MNRAS, 333, 649
Strickland D. K., Stevens I. R., 2000, MNRAS, 314, 511
Sutherland R. S., Dopita M. A., 1993, ApJS, 88, 253
Tornatore L., Borgani S., Springel V., Matteucci F., Menci
N., Murante G., 2003, MNRAS, 342, 1025
Tozzi P., Norman C., 2001, ApJ, 546, 63
Voit G. M., Bryan G. L., 2001, Nature, 414, 425
Voit G. M., Bryan G. L., Balogh M. L., Bower R. G., 2002,
ApJ, 576, 601
Voit G. M., Balogh M. L., Bower R. G., Lacey C. G., Bryan
G. L., 2003, ApJ, 593, 272
White S. D. M., Rees M. J., 1978, MNRAS, 183, 341
Wu K. K. S., Fabian A. C., Nulsen P. E. J., 2000, MNRAS,
318, 889
Balogh M. L., Pearce F. R., Bower R. G., Kay S. T., 2001,
Wu X.-P., Xue Y.-J., 2002, ApJ, 569, 112
MNRAS, 326, 1228
Bower R. G., 1997, MNRAS, 288, 355
Bower R. G., Benson A. J., Lacey C. G., Baugh C. M.,
Cole S., Frenk C. S., 2001, MNRAS, 325, 497
Bruggen M., Kaiser C. R., 2002, Nature, 418, 301
Bryan G. L., 2000, ApJ, 544, L1
Cole S., 1991, ApJ, 367, 45
Cole S. et al., 2001, MNRAS, 326, 255
Dav´e R., Katz N., Weinberg D. H., 2002, ApJ, 579, 23
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
|
0811.2467 | 2 | 0811 | 2009-01-28T03:35:34 | Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present evidence that the accretion of warm gas onto the Galaxy today is at least as important as cold gas accretion. For more than a decade, the source of the bright H-alpha emission (up to 750 mR) along the Magellanic Stream has remained a mystery. We present a hydrodynamical model that explains the known properties of the H-alpha emission and provides new insights on the lifetime of the Stream clouds. The upstream clouds are gradually disrupted due to their interaction with the hot halo gas. The clouds that follow plough into gas ablated from the upstream clouds, leading to shock ionisation at the leading edges of the downstream clouds. Since the following clouds also experience ablation, and weaker H-alpha (100-200 mR) is quite extensive, a disruptive cascade must be operating along much of the Stream. In order to light up much of the Stream as observed, it must have a small angle of attack (~20 deg) to the halo, and this may already find support in new HI observations. Another prediction is that the Balmer ratio will be substantially enhanced due to the slow shock. We find that the clouds are evolving on timescales of 100-200 Myr, such that the Stream must be replenished by the Magellanic Clouds at a fairly constant rate (>0.1 Msun/yr). The ablated material falls onto the Galaxy as a warm drizzle; diffuse ionized gas at 10^4 K is an important constituent of galactic accretion. We consider the stability of HI clouds falling towards the Galactic disk and show that most of these must break down into smaller fragments that become partially ionized. The Galactic halo is expected to have huge numbers of smaller neutral and ionized fragments. When the ionized component is accounted for, the rate of gas accretion is ~0.4 Msun/yr, roughly twice the rate deduced from HI observations alone. | astro-ph | astro-ph | The Galaxy Disk in Cosmological Context
Proceedings IAU Symposium No. 254, 2008
J. Andersen, J. Bland-Hawthorn & B. Nordstrom, eds.
c(cid:13) 2008 International Astronomical Union
DOI: 00.0000/X000000000000000X
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
J. Bland-Hawthorn
School of Physics, University of Sydney, Australia, NSW 2006
email: [email protected]
9
0
0
2
n
a
J
8
2
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
2
v
7
6
4
2
.
1
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
Abstract. We present evidence that the accretion of warm gas onto the Galaxy today is at
least as important as cold gas accretion. For more than a decade, the source of the bright Hα
emission (up to 750 mR†) along the Magellanic Stream has remained a mystery. We present
a hydrodynamical model that explains the known properties of the Hα emission and provides
new insights on the lifetime of the Stream clouds. The upstream clouds are gradually disrupted
due to their interaction with the hot halo gas. The clouds that follow plough into gas ablated
from the upstream clouds, leading to shock ionisation at the leading edges of the downstream
clouds. Since the following clouds also experience ablation, and weaker Hα (100−200 mR) is
quite extensive, a disruptive cascade must be operating along much of the Stream. In order to
light up much of the Stream as observed, it must have a small angle of attack (≈ 20◦) to the halo,
and this may already find support in new HI observations. Another prediction is that the Balmer
ratio (Hα/Hβ) will be substantially enhanced due to the slow shock; this will soon be tested by
upcoming WHAM observations in Chile. We find that the clouds are evolving on timescales of
100−200 Myr, such that the Stream must be replenished by the Magellanic Clouds at a fairly
constant rate (& 0.1 M⊙ yr−1). The ablated material falls onto the Galaxy as a warm drizzle;
diffuse ionized gas at 104K is an important constituent of galactic accretion. The observed Hα
emission provides a new constraint on the rate of disruption of the Stream and, consequently,
the infall rate of metal-poor gas onto the Galaxy. We consider the stability of HI clouds falling
towards the Galactic disk and show that most of these must break down into smaller fragments
that become partially ionized. The Galactic halo is expected to have huge numbers of smaller
neutral and ionized fragments. When the ionized component of the infalling gas is accounted for,
the rate of gas accretion is ∼0.4 M⊙ yr−1, roughly twice the rate deduced from HI observations
alone.
Keywords. Galaxies: interaction, Magellanic Clouds -- Galaxy: evolution -- ISM: individual
(Smith Cloud) -- shock waves -- instabilities -- hydrodynamics
1. Introduction
It is now well established that the observed baryons over the electromagnetic spectrum account
for only a fraction of the expected baryon content in Lambda Cold Dark Matter cosmology. This
is true on scales of galaxies and, in particular, within the Galaxy where easily observable phases
have been studied in great detail over many years. The expected baryon fraction (ΩB/ΩDM ≈
0.17) of the dark halo mass (1.4 × 1012 M⊙; Smith et al. 2007) leads to an expected baryon
mass of 2.4 × 1011 M⊙ but a detailed inventory reveals only a quarter of this mass (Flynn et al.
2006‡). Moreover, the build-up of stars in the Galaxy requires an accretion rate of 1−3 M⊙ yr−1
(Williams & McKee 1997; Binney et al. 2000), substantially larger than what can be accounted
for from direct observation. We can extend the same argument to M31 where the total baryon
mass is . 1011 M⊙ (Tamm et al. 2007). For the Galaxy, the predicted baryon mass may be a
arcsec−2 at Hα.
† 1 Rayleigh (R) = 106/4π photons cm−2 s−1 sr−1, equivalent to 5.7 × 10−18 erg cm−2 s−1
‡ A decade ago, it was claimed that MACHOs may be important in the halo but these can
only make up a negligible fraction by mass (Tisserand et al. 2007).
1
2
J. Bland-Hawthorn
lower bound if the upward correction in the LMC-SMC orbit motion reflects a larger halo mass
(Kallivayalil et al. 2006; Piatek et al. 2008; cf. Wilkinson & Evans 1999). Taken together, these
statements suggest that most of the baryons on scales of galaxies have yet to be observed.
So how do galaxies accrete their gas? Is the infalling gas confined by dark matter? Does
the gas arrive cold, warm or hot? Does the gas rain out of the halo onto the disk or is it
forced out by the strong disk-halo interaction? These issues have never been resolved, either
through observation or through numerical simulation. HI observations of the nearby universe
suggest that galaxy mergers and collisions are an important aspect of this process (Hibbard &
van Gorkom 1996), but tidal interactions do not guarantee that the gas settles to one or other
galaxy. The most spectacular interaction phenomenon is the Magellanic HI Stream that trails
from the LMC-SMC system (10:1 mass ratio) in orbit about the Galaxy. Since its discovery in the
1970s, there have been repeated attempts to explain the Stream in terms of tidal and/or viscous
forces (q.v. Mastropietro et al. 2005; Connors et al. 2005). Indeed, the Stream has become
a benchmark against which to judge the credibility of N-body+gas codes in explaining gas
processes in galaxies. A fully consistent model of the Stream continues to elude even the most
sophisticated codes.
Here, we demonstrate that Hα detections along the Stream (Fig. 1) are providing new insights
on the present state and evolution of the HI gas. At a distance of D ≈ 55 kpc, the expected
Hα signal excited by the cosmic and Galactic UV backgrounds are about 3 mR and 25 mR
respectively (Bland-Hawthorn & Maloney 1999, 2002), significantly lower than the mean signal
of 100−200 mR, and much lower than the few bright detections in the range 400 − 750 mR
(Weiner, Vogel & Williams 2002). This signal cannot have a stellar origin since repeated attempts
to detect stars along the Stream have failed.
Some of the Stream clouds exhibit compression fronts and head-tail morphologies (Bruns et al.
2005) and this is suggestive of confinement by a tenuous external medium. But the cloud:halo
density ratio (η = ρc/ρh) necessary for confinement can be orders of magnitude larger than that
required to achieve shock-induced Hα emission (e.g. Quilis & Moore 2001). Indeed, the best
estimates of the halo density at the distance of the Stream (ρh ∼ 10−4 cm−3; Bregman 2007)
are far too tenuous to induce strong Hα emission at a cloud face. It is therefore surprising to
discover that the brightest Hα detections lie at the leading edges of HI clouds (Weiner et al.
2002) and thus appear to indicate that shock processes are somehow involved.
We summarize a model, first presented in Bland-Hawthorn et al. (2007), that goes a long
way towards explaining the Hα mystery. The basic premise is that a tenuous external medium
not only confines clouds, but also disrupts them with the passage of time. The growth time for
Kelvin-Helmholtz (KH) instabilities is given by τKH ≈ λη0.5/vh where λ is the wavelength of the
growing mode, and vh is the apparent speed of the halo medium (vh ≈ 350 km s−1; see §2). At
the distance of the Stream, the expected timescale for KH instabilities is less than for Rayleigh-
Taylor (RT) instabilities (see §3). For cloud sizes of order a few kiloparsecs and ξ ≈ 104, the KH
timescale can be much less than an orbital time (τMS ≈ 2πD/vh ≈ 1 Gyr). Once an upstream
cloud becomes disrupted, the fragments are slowed with respect to the LMC-SMC orbital speed
and are subsequently ploughed into by the following clouds.
In §2, the new hydrodynamical models are described and the results are presented; we discuss
the implications of our model and suggest avenues for future research. In §3, we discuss the
stability of HI clouds (high velocity clouds) moving through the corona toward the Galactic disk
and briefly consider the Smith Cloud, arguably the HVC with the best observed kinematic and
photometric parameters.
2. A new hydrodynamical model
There have been many attempts to understand how gas clouds interact with an ambient
medium (Murray, White & Blondin 1993; Klein, McKee & Colella 1994). In order to capture
the evolution of a system involving instabilities with large density gradients correctly, grid
based methods (Liska & Wendroff 1999; Agertz et al. 2007) are favoured over other schemes
(e.g. Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics). We have therefore investigated the dynamics of the
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
3
Magellanic Stream with two independent hydrodynamics codes, Fyris (Sutherland 2008) and
Ramses (Teyssier 2002), that solve the equations of gas dynamics with adaptive mesh refinement.
The results shown here are from the Fyris code because it includes non-equilibrium ionization,
but we get comparable gas evolution from either code†.
The brightest emission is found along the leading edges of clouds MS II, III and IV with
values as high as 750 mR for MS II. The Hα line emission is clearly resolved at 20 − 30 km s−1
FWHM, and shares the same radial velocity as the HI emission within the measurement errors
(Weiner et al. 2002; Madsen et al. 2002). This provides an important constraint on the physical
processes involved in exciting the Balmer emission.
In order to explain the Hα detections along the Stream, we concentrate our efforts on the
disruption of the clouds labelled MS I−IV (Bruns et al. 2005). The Stream is trailing the LMC-
SMC system in a counter-clockwise, near-polar orbit as viewed from the Sun. The gas appears
to extend from the LMC dislodged through tidal disruption although some contribution from
drag must also be operating (Moore & Davis 1994). Recently, the Hubble Space Telescope has
determined an orbital velocity of 378±18 km s−1 for the LMC. While this is higher than earlier
claims, the result has been confirmed by independent researchers (Piatek et al. 2008). Besla
et al. (2007) conclude that the origin of the Stream may no longer be adequately explained
with existing numerical models. The Stream velocity along its orbit must be comparable to the
motion of the LMC; we adopt a value of vMS ≈ 350 km s−1.
400
300
200
100
0
-20
-40
-60
-80
-100
angular distance from LMC along Stream (degrees)
Figure 1. Hα measurements and upper limits along the Stream. The filled circles are from the
WHAM survey by Madsen et al. (2002); the filled triangles are from the TAURUS survey by
Putman et al. (2003). The dashed line model is the Hα emission measure induced by the ionizing
intensity of the Galactic disk (Bland-Hawthorn & Maloney 1999; 2002); this fails to match the
Stream's Hα surface brightness by at least a factor of 3.
2.1. Model parameters
Here we employ a 3D Cartesian grid with dimensions 18 × 9 × 9 kpc [(x, y, z) = (432, 216, 216)
cells] to model a section of the Stream where x is directed along the Stream arc and the z axis
points towards the observer. The grid is initially filled with two gas components. The first is a
hot thin medium representing the halo corona.
Embedded in the hot halo is (initially) cold HI material with a total HI mass of 3 × 107 M⊙.
are provided at
† Further details
and comparative
simulations
http://www.aao.gov.au/astro/MS.
on the
codes
4
J. Bland-Hawthorn
-7.5
-8
-8.5
-9
4
3
2
1
8
6
4
2
0
-1
freefall
drag
disk
halo
present work
Wolfire
500
400
300
200
100
0
4
2
0
40
20
0
1
-1
0
1
0
2
(a) gravitational acceleration due to the disk+halo − all plots are shown as a
Figure 2.
function of vertical height above the disk at the Solar Circle; (b) infall velocity for a point mass
starting from the Magellanic Stream with halo drag (CD = 1 discussed in §3; dashed curve)
and without (solid); (c) coronal gas pressure for our model (solid line) compared to the Wolfire
model (dashed) -- the dot indicates the halo pressure used in our hydrodynamical model; (d)
magnetic field strength for β = 1 (dashed), β = 0.3 (dotted), β = 0.1 (solid); (e) minimum
lengthscale for RT instability (discussed in §3); (e) timescale for RT instability (discussed in
§3).
The cold gas has a fractal distribution and is initially confined to a cylinder with a diameter
of 4 kpc and length 18 kpc (Fig. 5); the mean volume and column densities are 0.02 cm−3
and 2 × 1019 cm−2 respectively. The 3D spatial power spectrum (P (k) ∝ k−5/3) describes a
Kolmogorov turbulent medium with a minimum wavenumber k corresponding to a spatial scale
of 2.25 kpc, comparable to the size of observed clouds along the Stream.
We consider the hot corona to be an isothermal gas in hydrostatic equilibrium with the
gravitational potential, φ(R, z), where R is the Galactocentric radius and z is the vertical scale
height. We adopt a total potential of the form φ = φd + φh for the disk and halo respectively;
for our calculations at the Solar Circle, we ignore the Galactic bulge. The galaxy potential is
defined by
φd(R, z) = −cdv2
φh(R, z) = chv2
circ/(R2 + (ad +qz2 + b2
circ ln((ψ − 1)/(ψ + 1))
d)2)0.5
(2.1)
(2.2)
h + R2 + z2)/r2
h)0.5. The scaling constants are (ad, bd, cd) = (6.5, 0.26, 8.9)
and ψ = (1 + (a2
kpc and (ah, rh) = (12, 210) kpc with ch = 0.33 (e.g. Miyamoto & Nagai 1975; Wolfire et al.
1995). The circular velocity vcirc ≈ 220 km s−1 is now well established through wide-field stellar
surveys (Smith et al. 2007).
We determine the vertical acceleration at the Solar Circle using g = −∂φ(Ro, z)/∂z with
Ro = 8 kpc. The hydrostatic halo pressure follows from
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
∂φ
∂z
= −
1
ρh
∂P
∂z
5
(2.3)
After Ferrara & Field (1994), we adopt a solution of the form Ph(z) = Po exp((φ(Ro, z) −
φ(Ro, 0))/σ2
h) where σh is the isothermal sound speed of the hot corona. To arrive at Po, we
adopt a coronal halo density of ne,h = 10−4 cm−3 at the Stream distance (55 kpc) in order
to explain the Magellanic Stream Hα emission (Bland-Hawthorn et al. 2007), although this is
uncertain to a factor of a few. We choose Th = 2 × 106 K to ensure that OVI is not seen in
the diffuse corona consistent with observation (Sembach et al. 2003); this is consistent with a
rigorously isothermal halo for the Galaxy. Our solution to equation (2.3) is shown in Fig. 2(c)
and it compares favorably with the pressure profile derive by others (e.g. Wolfire et al. 1995;
Sternberg, McKee & Wolfire 2002).
A key parameter of the models is the ratio of the cloud to halo pressure, ξ = Pc/Ph. If the
cloud is to survive the impact of the hot halo, then ξ & 1. A shocked cloud is destroyed in about
the time it takes for the internal cloud shock to cross the cloud, during which time the cool
material mixes and ablates into the gas streaming past. Only massive clouds with dense cores
can survive the powerful shocks. An approximate lifetime† for a spherical cloud of diameter dc
is
τc = 60(dc/2 kpc)(vh/350 kms−1)−1(η/100)0.5 Myr.
(2.4)
For η in the range of 100−1000, this corresponds to 60−180 Myr for individual clouds. With a
view to explaining the Hα observations, we focus our simulations on the lower end of this range.
For low η, the density of the hot medium is nh = 2 × 10−4 cm−3. The simulations are
undertaken in the frame of the cold HI clouds, so the halo gas is given an initial transverse
velocity of 350 km s−1. The observations reveal that the mean Hα emission has a slow trend
along the Stream which requires the Stream to move through the halo at a small angle of attack
(20o) in the plane of the sky (see Fig. 5). Independent evidence for this appears to come from a
wake of low column clouds along the Stream (Westmeier & Koribalski 2008). Thus, the velocity
of the hot gas as seen by the Stream is (vx, vy) = (−330, −141) km s−1. The adiabatic sound
speed of the halo gas is 200 km s−1, such that the drift velocity is mildly supersonic (transsonic),
with a Mach number of 1.75.
A unique feature of the Fyris simulations is that they include non-equilibrium cooling through
time-dependent ionisation calculations (cf. Rosen & Smith 2004). When shocks occur within the
inviscid fluid, the jump shock conditions are solved across the discontinuity. This allows us to
calculate the Balmer emission produced in shocks and additionally from turbulent mixing along
the Stream (e.g. Slavin et al. 1993). We adopt a conservative value for the gas metallicity of
[Fe/H]=-1.0 (cf. Gibson et al. 2000); a higher value accentuates the cooling and results in denser
gas, and therefore stronger Hα emission along the Stream.
Figure 3. The dependence of the evolving fractions of Ho and H+ on column density as the
shock cascade progresses. The timesteps are 70 (red), 120 (magenta), 170 (blue), 220 (green) and
270 Myr (black). The lowest column HI becomes progressively more compressed with time but
the highest column HI is shredded in the cascade process; the fraction of ionized gas increases
with time. The pile-up of electrons at low column densities arises from the x-ray halo.
2.2. Results
The results of the simulations are shown in Figs. 3 − 5; we provide animations of the disrupting
stream at http://www.aao.gov.au/astro/MS. In our model, the fractal Stream experiences a
"hot wind" moving in the opposite direction. The sides of the Stream clouds are subject to gas
ablation via KH instabilities due to the reduced pressure (Bernouilli's theorem). The ablated
gas is slowed dramatically by the hot wind and is transported behind the cloud. As higher order
† Here we correct a typo in equation (1) of Bland-Hawthorn et al. (2007).
6
J. Bland-Hawthorn
modes grow, the fundamental mode associated with the cloud size will eventually fragment it.
The ablated gas now plays the role of a "cool wind" that is swept up by the pursuing clouds
leading to shock ionization and ablation of the downstream clouds. The newly ablated material
continues the trend along the length of the Stream. The pursuing gas cloud transfers momentum
to the ablated upstream gas and accelerates it; this results in Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instabilities,
especially at the stagnation point in the front of the cloud. We rapidly approach a nonlinear
regime where the KH and RT instabilities become strongly entangled, and the internal motions
become highly turbulent. The simulations track the progression of the shock fronts as they
propagate into the cloudlets.
In Fig. 3, we show the predicted conversion of neutral to ionized hydrogen due largely to
cascading shocks along the Stream. The drift of the peak to higher columns is due to the shocks
eroding away the outer layers, thereby progressing into increasingly dense cloud cores. The
ablated gas drives a shock into the HI material with a shock speed of vs measured in the cloud
frame. At the shock interface, once ram-pressure equilibrium is reached, we find vs ≈ vhη−0.5.
In order to produce significant Hα emission, vs & 35 km s−1 such that η . 100. In Fig. 4, we see
the steady rise in Hα emission along the Stream, reaching 100− 200 mR after 120 Myr, and the
most extreme observed values after 170 Myr. The power-law decline to bright emission measures
is a direct consequence of the shock cascade. The shock-induced ionization rate is 1.5 × 1047
phot s−1 kpc−1. The predicted luminosity-weighted line widths of 20 km s−1 FWHM (Fig. 4,
inset) are consistent with the Hα kinematics. In Fig. 5, the Hα emission is superimposed onto
the projected HI emission: much of it lies at the leading edges of clouds, although there are
occasional cloudlets where ionized gas dominates over the neutral column. Some of the brightest
emission peaks appear to be due to limb brightening, while others arise from chance alignments.
The simulations track the degree of turbulent mixing between the hot and cool media brought
on by KH instabilities (e.g. Kahn 1980). The turbulent layer grows as the flow develops, mixing
up hot and cool gas at a characteristic temperature of about 104K. In certain situations, a
sizeable Hα luminosity can be generated (e.g. Canto & Raga 1991) and the expected line widths
are comparable to those observed in the Stream. Indeed, the simulations reveal that the fractal
clouds develop a warm ionized skin along the entire length of the Stream. But the characteristic
Hα emission (denoted by the shifting peak in Fig. 4) is comparable to the fluorescence excited
by the Galactic UV field (Bland-Hawthorn & Maloney 2002). We note with interest that narrow
Balmer lines can arise from pre-cursor shocks (e.g. Heng & McCray 2007), but these require
conditions that are unlikely to be operating along the Stream.
Figure 4. The evolving distribution of projected Hα emission as the shock cascade progresses.
The timesteps are explained in Fig. 3. The extreme emission measures increase with time and
reach the observed mean values after 120 Myr; this trend in brightness arises because denser
material is ablated as the cascade evolves. The mean and peak emission measures along the
Stream are indicated, along with the approximate contributions from the cosmic and Galactic
UV backgrounds. Inset: The evolving Hα line width as the shock cascade progresses; the velocity
scale is with respect to the reference frame of the initial HI gas. The solid lines are flux-weighted
line profiles; the dashed lines are volume-weighted profiles that reveal more extreme kinematics
at the lowest densities.
Figure 5. The initial fractal distribution of HI at 20 Myr, shown in contours, before the wind
action has taken hold. The upper figure is in the x − z frame as seen from above; the lower
figure is the projected distribution on the plane of the sky (x − y plane). Both distributions are
integrated along the third axis. The logged HI contours correspond to 18.5 (dotted), 19.0, 19.5,
20.0, and 20.5 (heavy) cm−2. The greyscale shows weak levels of Hα along the Stream where
black corresponds to 300 mR. The predicted HI (contours) and Hα (greyscale) distributions
after 120 Myr. The angle of attack in the [x,y,z] coordinate frame is indicated. The Hα emission
is largely, but not exclusively, associated with dense HI gas.
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
7
2.3. Discussion
We have seen that the brightest Hα emission along the Stream can be understood in terms of
shock ionization and heating in a transsonic (low Mach number) flow. For the first time, the
Balmer emission (and associated emission lines) provides diagnostic information at any position
along the Stream that is independent of the HI observations. Slow Balmer-dominated shocks of
this kind (e.g. Chevalier & Raymond 1978) produce partially ionized media where a significant
fraction of the Hα emission is due to collisional excitation. This can lead to Balmer decrements
(Hα/Hβ ratio) in excess of 4, i.e. significantly enhanced over the pure recombination ratio of
about 3, that will be fairly straightforward to verify in the brightest regions of the Stream.
The shock models predict a range of low-ionization emission lines (e.g. OI, SII), some of which
will be detectable even though suppressed by the low gas-phase metallicity. There are likely to be
EUV absorption-line diagnostics through the shock interfaces revealing more extreme kinematics
(Fig. 4, inset), but these detections (e.g. OVI) are only possible towards fortuitous background
sources (Sembach et al. 2001; Bregman 2007). The predicted EUV/x-ray emissivity from the
post-shock regions is much too low to be detected in emission.
The characteristic timescale for large changes is roughly 100−200 Myr, and so the Stream
needs to be replenished by the outer disk of the LMC at a fairly constant rate (e.g. Mastropietro
et al. 2005). The timescale can be extended with larger η values (equation (2.4)), but at the
expense of substantially diminished Hα surface brightness. In this respect, we consider η to be
fairly well bounded by observation and theory.
What happens to the gas shedded from the dense clouds? Much of the diffuse gas will become
mixed with the hot halo gas suggesting a warm accretion towards the inner Galactic halo. If
most of the Stream gas enters the Galaxy via this process, the derived gas accretion rate is
∼ 0.4M⊙ yr−1. The higher value compared to HI (e.g. Peek et al. 2008) is due to the gas already
shredded, not seen by radio telescopes now. In our model, the HVCs observed today are unlikely
to have been dislodged from the Stream by the process described here. These may have come
from an earlier stage of the LMC-SMC interaction with the outer disk of the Galaxy.
The "shock cascade" interpretation for the Stream clears up a nagging uncertainty about
the Hα distance scale for high-velocity clouds. Bland-Hawthorn et al. (1998) first showed that
distance limits to HVCs can be determined from their observed Hα strength due to ionization
by the Galactic radiation field, now confirmed by clouds with reliable distance brackets from the
stellar absorption line technique (Putman et al. 2003; Lockman et al. 2008; Wakker et al. 2007).
HVCs have smaller kinetic energies compared to the Stream clouds, and their interactions with
the halo gas are not expected to produce significant shock-induced or mixing layer Hα emission,
thereby supporting the use of Hα as a crude distance indicator.
Here, we have not attempted to reproduce the HI observations of the Stream in detail. This
is left to a subsequent paper where we explore a larger parameter space and include a more
detailed comparison with the HI and Hα power spectrum, inter alia. We introduce additional
physics, in particular, the rotation of the hot halo, a range of Stream orbits through the halo
gas, and so on.
If we are to arrive at a satisfactory understanding of the Stream interaction with the halo,
future deep Hα surveys will be essential. It is plausible that current Hα observations are still
missing a substantial amount of gas, in contrast to the deepest HI observations. We can compare
the particle column density inferred from HI and Hα imaging surveys. The limiting HI column
density is about NH ≈ hnHiL ≈ 1018 cm−2 where hnHi is the mean atomic hydrogen density,
and L is the depth through the slab. By comparison, the Hα surface brightness can be expressed
as an equivalent emission measure, Em ≈ hn2
eiL ≈ hneiNe. Here ne and Ne are the local and
column electron density. The limiting value of Em in Hα imaging is about 100 mR, and therefore
Ne ≈ 1018/hnei cm−2. Whether the ionized and neutral gas are mixed or distinct, we can hide
a lot more ionized gas below the imaging threshold for a fixed L, particularly if the gas is at low
density (hnei ≪ 0.1 cm−3). A small or variable volume filling factor can complicate this picture
but, in general, the ionized gas still wins out because of ionization of low density HI by the
cosmic UV background (Maloney 1993). In summary, even within the constraints of the cosmic
microwave background (see Maloney & Bland-Hawthorn 1999), a substantial fraction of the gas
8
J. Bland-Hawthorn
can be missed if it occupies a large volume in the form of a low density plasma (e.g. Rasmussen
et al. 2003).
3. Direct infall of HI onto the disk
The conditions operating along the Magellanic Stream are unlikely to be representative of all
HI clouds that move through the Galactic corona. A related process is the infall of individual HI
clouds towards the Galactic disk. The Galactic halo is home to many HVCs of unknown origin
(Wakker 2001; Lockman et al. 2008). The survival and stability of these clouds is a problem
that has long been recognized (e.g. Benjamin & Danly 1997) which we now discuss.
It is likely that many or all halo clouds have experienced some deceleration during their
transit through the lower halo. Using equation (2.3), we determine a freefall velocity for a cloud
starting at the distance of the Stream (Fig. 1(b)) that is more than twice what is inferred for
clouds at the Solar Circle (Wakker 2001), although some HVCs clearly have high space motions
(e.g. Lockman et al. 2008). To explain this observation, Benjamin & Danly (1997) investigated
a drag equation for a cloud moving through a stationary medium,
µc vc =
1
2
CDρh(z)v2
c − µcg(z)
(3.1)
where µc is the surface density of the cloud. Equation (3.1) only holds as long as the cloud
stays together. The drag coefficient CD is a measure of the efficiency of momentum transfer
to the cloud. For the high Reynolds numbers typical of astrophysical media, incompressible
objects have CD ≈ 0.4 (e.g. a rough sphere) which indicates that the turbulent wake behind
the plunging object efficiently transfers momentum to the braking medium. The leading face of
a compressible cloud may become flattened, such that the approaching medium is brought to
rest in the reference frame of the cloud; in this instance, CD & 1 may be more appropriate (we
adopt CD = 1 here).
A solution specific to our model is shown in Fig. 2(b) where the freefall velocity is now slowed
by about 35%. In practice, the cloud's projected motion can be considerably less than its 3D
space velocity (e.g. Lockman et al. 2008). In all likelihood, infalling HVCs have experienced
significant deceleration through ram pressure exerted by the corona. But even before the cloud
reaches terminal velocity, the cloud is expected to break up (Murray & Lin 2004).
So how do clouds resist the destructive forces of RT and shock instabilities? In §3.1, we
investigate the stabilizing influence of magnetic fields when a cloud passes through a magnetized
medium. The halo magnetic field is poorly constrained at the present time (e.g. Sun et al. 2008).
We describe the uniform magnetic field in terms of the pressure of the halo medium, or
B2
8π
= βPh
(3.2)
such that B ≈ 1 µG at the distance of the Stream (55 kpc) if the field is in full equipartition
with the corona (see Fig. 1(d)). But there is evidence that the field is weaker than implied here
(β ≈ 0.3; Sun et al. 2008), at least within 5 kpc of the Galactic plane For the warm, denser low-
latitude gas (Reynolds layer), we adopt the new parameter fits of Gaensler et al. (2008) from a
re-analysis of pulsar data. The lower β value finds support from recent magnetohydrodynamic
simulations of the Reynolds layer (Hill et al. 2008).
3.1. Stability limits and growth timescales
We consider the surface of a high velocity cloud as a boundary between two fluids. In practice,
the Galactic ionizing radiation field imparts a multiphase structure to the cloud. At all galactic
latitudes within the Stream distance, HVCs with column densities of order 1020 cm−2 or higher
have partially ionized skins to a column depth of roughly 1019 cm−2 for sub-solar gas due to
the Galactic ionizing field (see Bland-Hawthorn & Maloney 1999; Wolfire et al. 2003). Between
the warm ionized skin and the cool inner regions is a warm neutral medium of twice the skin
thickness; both outer layers have a mean particle temperature of . 104K.
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
9
The cloud is denser than the halo gas. Because of the gravitational field, RT instabilities can
grow on the boundary. Furthermore, KH instabilities may also develop due to the relative motion
of the cloud with respect to an external medium. Recent work has shown that buoyant bubbles
in galaxy clusters are stabilized against RT and KH instabilities by viscosity and surface tension
due to magnetic fields in the boundary (De Young 2003; Kaiser et al. 2005; Jones & De Young
2005). Here we examine whether HVC boundaries are similarly stabilized against disruption in
the Galactic halo.
When there is no surface tension, no viscosity and no relative motion between the two media,
the growth rate of the RT instability for a perturbation with wavenumber k is ω = √gk,
where g is the gravitational acceleration at the fluid boundary. The wavenumber is related to a
perturbation length scale, ℓ = 2π/k. The instability requires a few e-folding timescales to fully
develop; the timescale is given by
tgrow = ω−1 =s ℓ
2πg
.
(3.3)
In the presence of a magnetic field, the transverse component (Btr) provides some surface
tension which can help to suppress RT instabilities below a lengthscale of
ℓmin =
B2
tr
2ρcg
(3.4)
(Chandrasekhar 1961). Here ρc is the mass density of the denser medium, i.e. the cloud, and
Btr is the average value of the transverse magnetic field at the boundary.
In order to illustrate when RT instabilities become important, we assume a flat rotation curve
for the Galaxy (e.g. Binney & Dehnen 1997)
v2
circ
R
g ≈
= 1.6 × 10−8"
vcirc
220 km s−1"2„ R
Ro«−1
cm s−2.
(3.5)
This is only a rough approximation to the form expected from equations (2.1) and (2.2). We
stress that the actual behaviour discussed below, and shown in Figs. 2(e) and (f), solves for the
gravitational potential correctly.
Shortly after the discovery of HVCs, it was thought that they may be self-gravitating. But
this would place them at much greater distances than the Magellanic Stream (e.g. Oort 1966)
which is now known not to be the case (e.g. Putman et al. 2003). Instead, we consider two
cases: (i) HVCs in pressure equilibrium with the coronal gas; (ii) HVCs with parameters fixed
by direct observation. In (i), because the temperature is not strongly dependent on radius, but
the number density decreases rapidly with increasing radius, we expect the increased pressure
to compress the clouds at lower latitudes.
We estimate the impact of RT instabilities using equations (2.3) and (3.3): for a cloud tem-
perature of Tc = 104K (see §2) in pressure equilibrium with the hot halo, the electron density
is given by
ne,c ≈ ne,h
Th
Tc
= 0.02„ R
55 kpc«−2„
Th
2 × 106K«„ Tc
104K«−1
(3.6)
cm−3.
We use equations 3.4, 3.6 and 3.2 to estimate ℓmin as a function of Galactocentric radius.
The minimum length scale for instability is
ℓmin
R ∼
8πβkBTc
mpv2
circ
(3.7)
= 0.004„ Tc
104K«„ β
0.1«"
vcirc
220 km s−1"−2
10
J. Bland-Hawthorn
and its associated growth timescale using equation (3.3)
tgrow ∼s 4βkBTc
mpv2
circ
Ω−1
(3.8)
= 1.1 Myr„ Tc
104K«
1
2 „ β
0.1«
vcirc
Ro«
220 km s−1"−2„ R
1
2 "
where the angular rotation rate is given by Ω = vcirc/R.
Because we have assumed that B2 ∝ ne,h (equipartition) and ne,c ∝ ne,h (pressure equilib-
rium), neither the minimum scale length or its growth timescale depend on the halo density
or temperature. They do depend on the temperature of the clouds and the ionization state. If
the clouds are hotter than 104K, then ne,c is overestimated under the assumption of pressure
equilibrium. This would lead to larger minimum instability lengthscales and growth timescales.
If the Galactic rotation curve drops faster than the flat profile implied by equation (2.3), we
would have underestimated both the minimum instability scale length and its associated growth
timescale at large radii.
Under the assumption of pressure equilibrium, the falling clouds become more compressed as
they approach the disk which can hasten cooling. This effect may help to stabilize against break
up, particularly if a cool shell develops (cf. Sternberg & Soker 2008).
In the absence of gravitational instability, the flow is stable against the KH instability if
(Chandrasekhar 1961)
where U is the relative velocity between the two fluids. When ρc > ρh, this requirement becomes
U 2 <
B2
tr(ρc + ρh)
2πρcρh
(3.9)
mp
U <s 8βkBTh
= 115„ β
0.1«
1
2
1
2 „
Th
2 × 106K«
km s−1
(3.10)
and we have described the magnetic field in terms of the halo pressure using equation 3.2. This
requirement is also independent of the halo density as we have related the magnetic field to
the halo pressure, although it is dependent on the halo temperature. This requirement is nearly
satisfied for HVCs if the magnetic field is near equipartition.
3.2. The Smith Cloud
Arguably, the high-latitude HI cloud that we know most about is the Smith Cloud. Lockman
et al. (2008) have recently published spectacular HI data for this HVC and deduce a remarkable
amount about its past and future properties. The HVC has an estimated distance of 12.4 ± 1.3
kpc, a Galactocentric radius of R ≈ 8 kpc, a vertical height below the plane of -2.9 kpc, a mass
of at least 106 M⊙ in a volume of order 3 kpc3 corresponding to nc ≈ 0.014 cm−3. The cloud
has a prograde orbit that is inclined 30◦ to the plane and appears to have come through the
disk 70 Myr ago at R ≈ 13 kpc moving from above to below the plane.
longer than for the disk. It can be shown that
In order to have punched through the disk, the shock crossing time for the cloud must be
dc
zd
>r nd
nc
(3.11)
where zd is the vertical thickness and nd is the mean density of the HI at the crossing point.
This is essentially a statement that the surface density of the cloud must be higher than the
disk. If we assume the cloud punched through the Galactic hydrogen density profile determined
by Kalberla & Dedes (2008), equation 3.11 indicates that the cloud was substantially thicker
than the disk when it came through and somewhat more massive than what is observed now.
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
11
Consistent with this picture, the observed wake may result from ablation processes induced
by the impact. For cloudlets smaller than 100 pc, thermal conduction due to the halo corona
(McKee & Cowie 1977) and the Galactic radiation field convert the ablated gas to a clumpy
plasma.
The kinetic energy of the Smith Cloud observed today is ∼ 1054 erg -- this is enough to
punch through the disk if sufficiently concentrated. Impulsive shock signatures at UV to x-ray
wavelengths will have largely faded away, and the HI "hole" at the crossing point will have been
substantially stretched by differential shear†.
Figs. 2(e) and (f) show that a cloud of several kpc can survive RT instabilities at these
latitudes, but it is difficult to see how the Smith Cloud, like several other large HVCs, could have
come in from, say, the distance of the Magellanic Stream. Lockman et al. (2008) use essentially
the same Galactic potential as described here to determine the cloud's orbit parameters. We
conjecture that either the cloud has been dislodged from the outer disk by a passing dwarf, or
the cloud has been brought in by a confining dwarf potential. A cloud metallicity of [Fe/H]≈-1
is appropriate in either scenario. Interestingly, the impulse from the Galactic disk can cause the
gas to become dislodged from the confining dark halo or to oscillate within it. The interloper
must be on a prograde orbit which rules out some infalling dwarfs (e.g. ωCen; Bekki & Freeman
2007), but conceivably implicates disrupting dwarfs like Canis Major or Sagittarius, assuming
these were still losing gas in the recent past.
3.3. Discussion
In §2, we presented evidence for a shock cascade along the Magellanic Stream arising from the
disruption of upstream clouds due to their interaction with the Galactic halo. Bland-Hawthorn
et al. (2007) make firm predictions that can be tested in future observations. A possible improve-
ment is to consider the entire Magellanic System, i.e. the influence of the LMC-SMC system
that lies further upstream. Mastropietro et al. (2008) present evidence for a strong interaction
along the leading edge of the LMC; for their quoted model parameters, it seems plausible that
this results in a stand-off bowshock ahead of the galaxy. The cross wind over the face of the
LMC could be confused for a starburst-driven wind from the LMC (cf. Lehner & Howk 2007).
In all likelihood, the LMC-SMC system creates a turbulent wake behind it which may impact
the development of instabilities in the trailing stream.
The issue of cloud survival is highly complex. In §3, we did not consider the role of viscosity
in quenching RT or KH instabilities. Simulations have shown that viscosity does lead to stabi-
lization (Pavlovski et al. 2008) but we have not been able to estimate a lengthscale or a growth
timescale appropriate for our setting. Kaiser et al. (2005) show that when the density ratio
between the two media is large, KH instabilities fail to grow and the growth rate of RT insta-
bilities depends only on the properties of higher density medium, in our case the cloud medium.
However their result, taken in the limit of one density much larger than the other, ρ2 ≫ ρ1, will
not apply if ν1ρ1 ≫ ν2ρ2. Here the subscripts refer to the fluids on either side of the boundary
and ν is the kinematic viscosity. Because diffusivity coefficients are sensitive functions of temper-
ature (∝ T −2.5), they could dampen fluid instabilities. Unfortunately the expected differences
in temperatures between HVCs and the halo gas (corona) suggest that ν1ρ1 ≫ ν2ρ2 and thus
we cannot apply the limit used by Kaiser et al. (2005). A proper treatment is required to cover
the Galactic halo setting.
Other studies have argued that the KH instability leads to a turbulent mixing layer on the
surface and so is less destructive than the RT instability (e.g. De Young 2003). At the present
time, there are no relevant astrophysical codes that are capable of handling mixing in a satis-
factory manner. On the issue of magnetic stability, more sophisticated treatments using MHD
have been attempted, but the main conclusions appear to be contradictory (Konz et al. 2002;
Gregori et al. 1999). We are not aware of MHD codes that are sufficiently capable of answering
this question at the present time.
† It is sometimes claimed, this meeting notwithstanding, that outer disk HI "holes" are evi-
dence of dark matter minihalos passing through the disk, but it can be shown that the gravita-
tional impulse has negligible impact on the gaseous disk.
12
J. Bland-Hawthorn
Without excessive erudition, which is inappropriate for a conference proceeding, it is difficult
to mount a solid case for why hydro processes could ultimately save the day for HVCs. But the
fact of the matter is that fast-moving gas clouds do survive their passage through the Galactic
halo. These may be mostly shortlived entities on the road to destruction, suggesting that there
is a largely hidden plasma component that we have yet to fully comprehend. This will require
more extensive observations at difficult parts of the observational parameter space, matched by
hydro codes that can properly treat instabilities and mixing in a multi-phase gas.
Acknowledgements
JBH is supported by a Federation Fellowship through the Australian Research Council. I
thank Alice Quillen and Ralph Sutherland for their role in the work presented here. I acknowledge
helpful discussions with Bob Benjamin, Chris Flynn, Bryan Gaensler, Greg Madsen and Mary
Putman.
References
Agertz, O., et al. 2007, MNRAS, 380, 963
Bekki, K. & Freeman, K.C. 2003, MNRAS, 346, L11
Benjamin, R. & Danly, L. 1997, ApJ, 481, 764
Besla, G. et al. 2007, ApJ, 668, 949
Binney, J. & Dehnen, W. 1997, MNRAS
Binney, J., Dehnen, W., & Bertelli, G. 2000, MNRAS, 318, 658
Bland-Hawthorn et al. 1998, MNRAS, 299, 611
Bland-Hawthorn, J., & Maloney, P.R. 1999, ApJL, 510, L33
Bland-Hawthorn, J., & Maloney, P.R. 2002, Extragalactic Gas at Low Redshift, 254, 267
Bland-Hawthorn, J., Sutherland, R., Agertz, O., & Moore, B. 2007, ApJ, 670, L109
Bregman, J. N. 2007, ARA&A, 45, 221
Bruns, C., et al. 2005, AAp, 432, 45
Canto, J., & Raga, A.C. 1991, ApJ, 372, 646
Chandrasekhar, S. 1961, Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability, Clarendon, Oxford
Chevalier, R.A., & Raymond, J.C. 1978, ApJL, 225, L27
Connors, T.W., Kawata, D., & Gibson, B.K. 2006, MNRAS, 371, 108
De Young, D. S. 2003, MNRAS, 343, 719
Ferrara, A. & Field, G.B. 1994, ApJ, 423, 665
Flynn, C. et al. 2006, MNRAS, 372, 1149
Gaensler, B. et al. 2008, PASA, submitted
Gibson, B.K. et al. 2000, AJ, 120, 1830
Gregori, G. et al. 1999, ApJ, 527, L113
Heng, K., & McCray, R. 2007, ApJ, 654, 923
Hibbard, J.E., & van Gorkom, J.H. 1996, AJ, 111, 655
Hill, A. et al. 2008, ApJ, 686, 363
Jones, T.W. & De Young, D. 2005, ApJ, 624, 586
Kahn, F.D. 1980, AAp, 83, 303
Kaiser, C. R., Pavlovski, G., Pope, E. D. C., & Fangohr, H. 2005, MNRAS, 359, 493
Kalberla, P. & Dedes, L. 2008, A& A, in press (0804.4831)
Kallivayalil, N., van der Marel, R.P. & Alcock, C., 2006, ApJ, 652, 1213
Keres, D., Katz, N., Weinberg, D. H., & Dave, R. 2005, MNRAS, 363, 2
Klein, R.I., McKee, C.F., & Colella, P. 1994, ApJ, 420, 213
Konz, C., Bruns, C. & Birk, G.T. 2002, A&A, 391, 713
Larson, R. B. 1969, MNRAS, 145, 405
Lehner, N. & Howk, C. 2007, MNRAS, 377, 687
Liska, R., & Wendroff, B. 1999, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids, 30, 461
Lockman, F.J., Benjamin, R.A., Heroux, A.J. &, Langston, G.I. 2008, ApJ, 679, L21
Madsen, G.J., Haffner, L.M. & Reynolds, R.J. 2002, ASPC, 276, 96
Warm gas accretion onto the Galaxy
13
Maloney, P.R., & Bland-Hawthorn, J. 1999, ApJL, 522, L81
Maloney, P. 1993, ApJ, 414, 41
Mastropietro, C., Moore, B., Mayer, L., Wadsley, J., & Stadel, J. 2005, MNRAS, 363, 509
McKee, C.F. & Cowie, L.L. 1977, ApJ, 215, 213
Miyamoto, M. & Nagai, R. 1975, PASJ, 27, 533
Moore, B. & Davis, M. 1994, ApJ, 270, 209
Murray, S.D., White, S.D.M., Blondin, J.M., & Lin, D.N.C. 1993, ApJ, 407, 588
Murray, S.D. & Lin, D.C. 2004, ApJ, 615, 586
Nicastro, F., Mathur, S., & Elvis, M. 2008, Science, 319, 55
Oort, J. 1966, Bull. Astron. Inst. Neth., 18, 421
Pavlovski, G., Kaiser, C., Pope, E. C. D., & Fangohr, H. 2008, MNRAS, 384, 1377
Peek, J.E.G., Putman, M.E., & Sommer-Larsen, J. 2008, ApJ, 674, 227
Piatek, S., Pryor, C. & Olszewski, E.W. 2008, AJ, 135, 1024
Putman, M.E. et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, 948
Quilis, V. & Moore, B. 2001, ApJ, 555, L95
Rasmussen, A., Kahn, S. & Paerels, F. 2003, ASSL, 281, 109
Rosen, A., & Smith, M.D. 2004, MNRAS, 347, 1097
Ruszkowski, M., Enslin, T. A., Bruggen, M., Heinz, S., Pfrommer, C. 2007, MNRAS, 378, 662
Savage, B. D. et al. 2003, ApJS, 146, 125
Sembach, K.R., Howk, J.C., Savage, B.D., Shull, J.M., & Oegerle, W.R. 2001, ApJ, 561, 573
Sembach, K. R., et al. 2003, ApJS, 146, 165
Sembach, K. R. et al. 2004, ApJS, 150, 387
Slavin, J.D., Shull, J.M., & Begelman, M.C. 1993, ApJ, 407, 83
Smith, M. et al. 2007, MNRAS, 379, 755
Sternberg, A., McKee, C.F. & Wolfire, M. 2002, ApJS, 143, 419
Sternberg, A. & Soker, N., 2008, MNRAS, 389, L13
Sun, X. H., Reich, W., Waelkens, A., Enslin, T. A. 2008, A&A, 477, 573
Sutherland, R.S., 2008, ApJ, in preparation
Tamm, A., Tempel, E. & Tenjes, P. 2007, astro-ph/0707.4375
Teyssier, R. 2002, AAp, 385, 337
Thom, C., et al. 2008, astro-ph
Tisserand, P. et al. 2007, A&A, 469, 387
Tripp, T. M., et al. 2003, AJ, 125, 3122
Wakker, B.P. 2001, ApJS, 136, 463
Wakker, B. P et al. 2007, ApJ, 207, 670, L113
Weiner, B.J., & Williams, T.B. 1996, AJ, 111, 1156
Weiner, B.J., Vogel, S.N., & Williams, T.B. 2002, Extragalactic Gas at Low Redshift, 254, 256
Westmeier, T. & Koribalski, B.S. 2008, MNRAS, 388, L29
Wilkinson, M.I. & Evans, N.W. 1999, MNRAS, 310, 645
Williams, J.P. & McKee, C.F. 1997, ApJ, 476, 166
Wolfire, M. et al. 1995, ApJ, 453, 673
Wolfire, M. et al. 2003, ApJ, 587, 278
This figure "Bland-Hawthorn_fig3.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/0811.2467v2
This figure "Bland-Hawthorn_fig4.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/0811.2467v2
This figure "Bland-Hawthorn_fig5a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/0811.2467v2
This figure "Bland-Hawthorn_fig5b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/0811.2467v2
|
astro-ph/9404058 | 1 | 9404 | 1994-04-22T19:13:30 | The Properties of an HI-Selected Galaxy Sample | [
"astro-ph"
] | We analyze the properties of a sample of galaxies identified in a 21-cm, HI-line survey of selected areas in the Perseus-Pisces supercluster and its foreground void. Twelve fields were observed in the supercluster, five of them (target fields) centered on optically bright galaxies, and the other seven (blank fields) selected to contain no bright galaxies. We detected nine previously uncataloged, gas-rich galaxies, six of them in the target fields. We also detected HI from seven previously cataloged galaxies in these fields. Observations in the void covered the same volume as the twelve supercluster fields at the same HI-mass sensitivity, but no objects were detected. Combining our HI data with optical broad-band and H-alpha imaging, we conclude that the properties of HI-selected galaxies do not differ substantially from those of late-type galaxies found in optical surveys. In particular, the galaxies in our sample do not appear to be unusually faint for their HI mass, or for their circular velocity. The previously cataloged, optically bright galaxies in our survey volume dominate the total HI mass density and cross-section; the uncataloged galaxies contribute only 19% of the mass and 12% of the cross-section. Thus, existing estimates of the density and cross-section of neutral hydrogen, most of which are based on optically-selected galaxy samples, are probably accurate. | astro-ph | astro-ph | The Properties of an Hi-Selected Galaxy Sample
Arpad Szomoru
, Puragra Guhathakurta
, Jacqueline H. van Gorkom
,
;
Johan H. Knapen
, David H. Weinberg
, and Andrew S. Fruchter
;
4
9
r
p
A
2
2
8
5
0
4
0
4
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, P.O. Box , NL AV Groningen, The Netherlands
Hubble fellow, Princeton University Obs., Peyton Hall, Princeton, NJ , USA
Current address: STScI, San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD , USA
Department of Astronomy, Columbia University, New York, NY , USA
Instituto de Astrof(cid:19)(cid:16)sica de Canarias, E- La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain
Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton, NJ , USA
Hubble fellow, Astronomy Dept., University of California, Berkeley, CA , USA
Abstract
We analyze the properties of a sample of galaxies identi(cid:12)ed in a -cm, Hi-line survey of
selected areas in the Perseus-Pisces supercluster and its foreground void. Twelve (cid:12)elds
were observed in the supercluster, (cid:12)ve of them (target (cid:12)elds) centered on optically bright
galaxies, and the other seven (blank (cid:12)elds) selected to contain no bright galaxies within
of their centers. We detected nine previously uncataloged, gas-rich galaxies, six of
them in the target (cid:12)elds. We also detected Hi from seven previously cataloged galaxies in
these (cid:12)elds. Observations in the void covered the same volume as the twelve supercluster
(cid:12)elds at the same Hi-mass sensitivity, but no ob jects were detected.
Combining our Hi data with optical broad-band and H(cid:11) imaging, we conclude that
the properties of Hi-selected galaxies do not di(cid:11)er substantially from those of late-type
galaxies found in optical surveys. In particular, the galaxies in our sample do not appear
to be unusually faint for their Hi mass, or for their circular velocity. We (cid:12)nd tentative
evidence for a connection between optical surface brightness and degree of isolation, in
the sense that low surface brightness galaxies tend to be more isolated. The previously
cataloged, optically bright galaxies in our survey volume dominate the total Hi mass
density and cross-section; the uncataloged galaxies contribute only (cid:24) % of the mass
and (cid:24) % of the cross-section. Thus, existing estimates of the density and cross-section
of neutral hydrogen, most of which are based on optically-selected galaxy samples, are
probably accurate. Such estimates can be used to compare the nearby universe to the
high-redshift universe probed by quasar absorption lines.
Introduction
Most investigations of the properties or the spatial distribution of galaxies begin with a
sample selected in the optical, or sometimes in the infrared (based on IRAS [Neugebauer
et al. ] (cid:22)m detections). Even -cm or radio continuum studies usually target a
sample of galaxies taken from optical catalogs, like the Uppsala Galaxy Catalog (UGC;
Nilson ) or the Catalog of Galaxies and Clusters of Galaxies (Zwicky et al. {
). Thus, any population of galaxies or gas clouds with very low optical luminosity or
surface brightness could have largely escaped detection and study.
To circumvent this problem, we have conducted a direct search in the -cm line
of neutral hydrogen, using the D-con(cid:12)guration of the Very Large Array (VLA
; Napier
et al. ), covering (cid:12)elds in the Perseus-Pisces supercluster and in its foreground void
(see Haynes & Giovanelli , hereafter HG). In an earlier paper (Weinberg et al. ,
hereafter Paper I), we summarized the Hi properties of our detected ob jects, and we
discussed the implications of our results for the shape of the Hi mass function and
for the spatial distribution of dwarf galaxies.
In this paper, we describe the -cm
observations and results in greater detail, and we also present the results of follow-up
optical observations, both broad-band and H(cid:11) imaging. These data allow us to compare
directly the properties of our Hi-selected ob jects to those of optically selected galaxies.
For the VLA survey, we observed twelve (cid:12)elds in the Perseus-Pisces supercluster and
thirty (cid:12)elds in the foreground void. The e(cid:11)ective survey volume varies with Hi mass, since
more massive ob jects can be detected farther from the center of the primary beam and at
greater distances from the earth. Paper I discussed the resulting \selection function" of
the survey and compared it to that of previous -cm searches, particularly that of Fisher
& Tully ( ), which at the time was the largest directly comparable survey. We will
not repeat the details herethe salient points are that our survey covered nearly equal
volumes in the void and the supercluster, and that its total e(cid:11)ective volume, roughly
Mpc
for M
> (cid:2)
M
and Mpc
for M
>
M
, was much larger than
HI
(cid:12)
HI
(cid:12)
that of previous surveys for Hi masses in the
{
M
range typical of gas-rich dwarf
(cid:12)
galaxies.
Henning ( ) has recently published results of a much larger -cm survey,
which covers regions that are obscured by the Galactic plane at optical wavelengths. The
sensitivity of these observations varied from one line-of-sight to another because of solar
and man-made interference, dependence on declination and frequency resolution (Henning
); we are therefore unable to make a quantitative comparison of survey volumes. The
survey detected extragalactic ob jects, of them previously cataloged. Follow-up
optical analysis of the sample is still in progress. For a review of other -cm surveys, see
Briggs ( ).
Our survey detected nine previously uncataloged galaxies, along with seven brighter
galaxies that are listed in the UGC or the Zwicky catalog. Our de(cid:12)nition of supercluster
and void (cid:12)elds is based on HG's redshift surveys of optically selected galaxies. This
strategy allows us to address some questions of large-scale structure even with a small
survey volume, but it complicates the interpretation of our results to some extent. In
particular, it is unclear whether the optically cataloged galaxies should be considered
part of our Hi-selected \sample", since they played a role in the choice of survey (cid:12)elds.
Our approach in this paper is to present results for our full sample but to focus on
The VLA of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO) is operated by Associated
Universities, Inc., under a cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Unless stated otherwise, we have adopted a Hubble constant H
= km s
Mpc
in this paper.
the previously uncataloged ob jects as a distinct subset. All of the uncataloged ob jects
are fainter (in B , R, and I ) than all of the previously cataloged galaxies, and for
convenience we will hereafter refer to them as \Hi-dwarfs". However, only three of the
nine have absolute B -magnitudes fainter than (cid:0), which is the boundary often used in
conventional, optical de(cid:12)nitions of dwarf galaxies.
The results of our survey, combined with the follow-up optical data, allow us to
examine both the properties and the spatial distribution of Hi-selected galaxies. We are
limited by small numbers in both cases, but because we are sensitive to ob jects that could
have been entirely missed by earlier studies, even results with large statistical uncertainties
are important; they provide a rough guide to previously unexplored territory. Although we
covered equal volumes in the void and supercluster, all our detections were in supercluster
(cid:12)elds. As discussed in Paper I, this result implies that the Hi-dwarfs trace the structure
outlined by optically bright galaxies, at least qualitatively, though we cannot rule out
a modest \bias" between the Hi-dwarfs and the giants. Our other signi(cid:12)cant (cid:12)nding in
Paper I was that the number of ob jects detected was no more than one would predict
by combining a standard estimate of the optical luminosity function with the Hi-mass-
to-optical-luminosity relation that describes optically selected dwarf galaxies. From this
statistical evidence, we inferred that our -cm search had not turned up a new population
of gas-rich, optically faint ob jects, but that it had rather detected the \normal" population
of irregular galaxies. The optical data in this paper allow us to address this point more
directly.
We describe our observing procedures in the next section, present our results in x,
and discuss their implications in x.
Observations and Data Analysis
. cm Spectral Line
The VLA spectral line observations took place during November . The parameters of
the observations are listed in Table . All antennae were employed in D-con(cid:12)guration
resulting in an angular resolution of about
(full width at half maximum [FWHM]
of the synthesized beam). The bandwidth of the -cm observations was . MHz,
corresponding to a usable velocity range of about km s
. On-line Hannning
(cid:0)
smoothing was used after which every other channel was discarded, resulting in sets of
independent channels and a velocity resolution of (cid:24) km s
. The total observing time,
(cid:0)
including time spent on phase and (cid:13)ux calibration, was hr.
All the VLA pointings were located within the strip
< (cid:11)
<
and
h
m
s
h
m
s
o
o
o
o
< (cid:14)
<
. The pointings are listed in Table . For each (cid:12)eld we made
(cid:2)
images, mapping out the full extent of the primary beam. Twelve (cid:12)elds were observed in
the Perseus-Pisces supercluster at a redshifted velocity of km s
, and (cid:12)elds in the
(cid:0)
foreground void at km s
. The volume surveyed in a single pointing scales as D
,
(cid:0)
where D is the distance corresponding to the mean velocity to which the VLA bandpass
is tuned; the number of supercluster and void (cid:12)elds were chosen so that the total volume
surveyed in each region was roughly the same. The integration times t
were min for
int
each of the void (cid:12)elds and min for each of the supercluster (cid:12)elds, roughly in the ratio
of D
to ensure equal Hi-mass sensitivity in the void and supercluster (M
/ (cid:27)D
and
HI
(cid:0)=
(cid:27) / t
, where (cid:27) is the r.m.s. noise in the -cm data).
int
Five of the supercluster (cid:12)elds were centered on Perseus-Pisces galaxies brighter
than M
= (cid:0): (target (cid:12)elds). These optically bright galaxies were chosen from the
B
redshift catalog of HG. The remaining seven supercluster (cid:12)elds were selected to have no
bright galaxies within
of their pointing centers (blank (cid:12)elds).
The UV data were calibrated and processed into ((cid:11); (cid:14); V ) datacubes using standard
techniques in NRAO's Astronomical Image Processing System. To achieve the best
possible signal-to-noise ratio, natural weighting was applied in making the cubes.
Subsequent analysis of the VLA datacubes was carried out using the Groningen Image
Processing System (GIPSY). We searched for Hi line emission by subtracting the -cm
continuum emission from each cube; preliminary estimates of the continuum map were
obtained by () averaging channels { of the datacube, and () averaging channels {
and {. If line emission was detected, the continuum subtraction was redone using the
average of the line-free channels on the low and high frequency side of the line emission.
In a few cases, the continuum was subtracted by (cid:12)tting a linear baseline to the line-free
channels. Images with Hi emission were CLEANed and restored with a gaussian beam.
The r.m.s. noise (cid:27) = mJy/beam in the (cid:12)nal images of the void (cid:12)elds and . mJy/beam
in the supercluster (cid:12)elds.
Total Hi images were constructed by blanking areas without line emission and
summing the channel maps. Neutral hydrogen masses were calculated using the formula:
M
=M
= : (cid:2)
D
S dV
HI
(cid:12)
Z
where D is the distance in Mpc, and the (cid:13)ux density S (in Jy) is integrated over the
-cm line, with the velocity V expressed in km s
. The mean heliocentric velocity V
hel
(cid:0)
of each galaxy was determined from its global Hi line pro(cid:12)le by averaging the velocities at
which the (cid:13)ux density falls to % and % of the peak value on each side of the -cm
line. We compute the distance to each galaxy by correcting its heliocentric velocity for
the motion of the sun with respect to the velocity centroid of the Local Group: D =
[V
+ sin (l) cos(b)]=H
, where l and b are the Galactic longitude and latitude of the
hel
galaxy, and H
is the Hubble constant.
The observed line widths at % and % of the peak value, W
and W
, are listed
in Table . Also listed is log(W
), which is the logarithm of W
, corrected for instrumental
R
i
broadening following Bottinelli et al. ( ), for turbulent broadening following Tully &
Fouqu(cid:19)e ( ) and corrected to edge-on. The magnitude of the instrumental broadening
correction, which is based on a statistical intercomparison of line pro(cid:12)les measured with
various velocity resolutions, is (cid:0). km s
.
(cid:0)
The ma jority of the uncataloged galaxies is barely resolved in Hi. An estimate
of their angular size was obtained by (cid:12)tting a two-dimensional gaussian to the total
Hi distribution; the sizes quoted for the Hi-dwarfs are the FWHM of these gaussians
with the FWHM of the beam subtracted in quadrature. For the bright galaxies, the Hi
column density contour at (cid:2)
cm
was used to de(cid:12)ne the angular size. It should
(cid:0)
be kept in mind, however, that the size determinations for the smaller galaxies are only
rough indications of the true sizes because of the marginal angular resolution. Intensity-
weighted (cid:12)rst moment maps were used to construct velocity (cid:12)elds for the large galaxies
in which the Hi distribution was well resolved both spatially and in velocity.
. Optical Broad-band
Optical observations of the galaxies detected in Hi were carried out during the second
week of October using the -m Jacobus Kapteyn Telescope (JKT) on the island
of La Palma. The faintest of the galaxies are uncataloged and are barely visible on
the Palomar Optical Sky Survey plates. The camera on the JKT consisted of a GEC
charge-coupled device (CCD) with (cid:2) pixels and a pixel scale of :
. Broad-band
optical images were obtained through B (
A), R (
A), and I (
A) (cid:12)lters.
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
Integration times were (cid:2) s in B ( (cid:2) s for the faintest ob jects), s in R, and
(cid:2) s in I . The seeing ranged from :
to
, and the sky conditions were photometric
during most of the observations. We obtained short exposures of bright standard stars
(Landolt ) at regular intervals throughout the photometric nights, and we used these
to photometrically calibrate the JKT images. All the galaxies were observed close to
transit so that airmass corrections were minimal. The estimated errors in the magnitude
zero points are B = : mag, R = : mag and I = : mag. Twilight sky (cid:13)ats
were used for (cid:13)at (cid:12)elding the CCD images. Sky subtraction was done by (cid:12)tting (cid:12)rst- and
second-order polynomial surfaces to blank regions of sky around the image of each galaxy.
Three of the galaxies, UGC b, PPHI +, and PPHI +, are too faint
to be detected in the JKT B images. These ob jects were reobserved in service time
with the .-m William Herschel Telescope (WHT) in November using the Taurus
instrument in imaging mode. A (cid:2) EEV CCD was employed, with a pixel size of
:
. One s exposure was obtained for each of the three galaxies through a B (cid:12)lter.
Twilight sky (cid:13)ats were used for (cid:13)at (cid:12)elding the CCD frames. An artifact in the sky (cid:13)at
image a(cid:11)ected the (cid:13)at (cid:12)elding of the UGC b image; the (cid:13)ux determination of this
galaxy is therefore uncertain. After sky subtraction, the WHT frames were calibrated by
a bootstrap procedure: the (cid:13)uxes of some bright stars in the WHT images were compared
with the photometrically calibrated (cid:13)uxes of the same stars in the JKT B images.
The total magnitude of each galaxy was calculated by integrating over a circular
aperture of radius
, except for UGC for which an aperture of radius
was used.
In a few cases, images of foreground stars superposed on the galaxy images were removed;
imperfect star subtraction is an additional source of uncertainty in the (cid:13)ux measurement
of these galaxies. Magnitudes were corrected for absorption by dust along the line-of-sight
in the Galaxy following the precepts of Burstein & Heiles ( ). For comparison with
existing samples, we have also applied standard corrections for internal absorption as a
function of wavelength and disk inclination (Tully & Fouqu(cid:19)e ).
In order to derive surface photometry of the galaxies, we (cid:12)tted ellipses to a succession
of isophotes of the I -band light distribution (of decreasing brightness and increasing
radius). Radial brightness pro(cid:12)les in the B , R, and I bands were constructed by
integrating the light in these images within the best-(cid:12)t ellipses. The brightness pro(cid:12)les
of the galaxies are well approximated by exponential laws and these were used to obtain
estimates of the central surface brightness (cid:22)
, the disk scale length h, the diameter D
of the B = mag arcsec
isophote, and the B (cid:0) R and R (cid:0) I color as a function of
(cid:0)
radius. The best-(cid:12)t ellipses also yielded an axis ratio and a position angle for each galaxy.
Disk inclinations were derived from the isophotal axis ratios by accounting for the (cid:12)nite
thickness of stellar disks, assuming an intrinsic axis ratio of . and correcting for the
o
measurement bias (Tully ).
. Narrow-band H(cid:11)
The narrow-band H(cid:11) imaging observations were done on the Shane -m telescope at Lick
Observatory using the UV Schmidt Spectrograph. Due to limited observing time, only
four ob jects were observed in H(cid:11): UGC a, UGC b, UGC b, and UGC a. Line
(cid:13)ux was detected in all four galaxies.
The Cassegrain spectrograph imaging system allowed one to switch between CCD
imaging and spectroscopy through the interposition of a (cid:13)at mirror in the spectroscopic
light path. One could therefore use the spectrograph to directly measure the transmission
function of the imaging (cid:12)lter, although a small uncertainty remains due to possible spectral
dependence of the re(cid:13)ectance of the (cid:13)at mirror. The H(cid:11)+Nii emission of all four galaxies
observed fell within the passbands of two Lick narrow-band (cid:12)lters, which have e(cid:11)ective
wavelengths of
A and
A and FWHM of
A and
A, respectively. Continuum
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(cid:23)
(o(cid:11)-band) images of the galaxies were obtained with a
A-wide (cid:12)lter centered at about
(cid:23)
A. Integration times ranged from s to s for the H(cid:11) exposures, and from
(cid:23)
s to s for the continuum exposures. Very light cirrus was present throughout
the H(cid:11) observations, so that our photometry is no better than { %. As a consequence
of these non-photometric conditions, we had to determine the appropriate scaling for
continuum subtraction on an image-by-image basis by minimizing the residuals of bright
stars. We estimate that this empirical method of continuum subtraction provides H(cid:11)+Nii
(cid:13)uxes to an accuracy of about %.
The measured H(cid:11)+Nii (cid:13)uxes were corrected for Galactic absorption (Burstein &
Heiles ; Rieke & Lebofsky ) and used to estimate star formation rates (SFR)
following Hunter & Gallagher ( ). The H(cid:11) luminosity of a galaxy L
was converted
H(cid:11)
to the total number of ionizing photons, which was then compared to the integrated
number of photons expected from massive stars for a Salpeter ( ) initial mass function.
Extrapolating the Salpeter stellar mass function down to a lower mass limit of : M
,
(cid:12)
the SFR of all stars (with masses in the range .{ M
) is given by:
(cid:12)
_
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
M = : (cid:2)
L
M
yr
;
H(cid:11)
(cid:12)
where L
is in units of erg s
. Based on this SFR, we calculated the distance-
H(cid:11)
(cid:0)
independent quantities
M =L
and the timescale (cid:28) over which the current gas supply
B
_
in a galaxy would last at the current rate of star formation. The gas depletion time (cid:28)
is computed by multiplying the Hi mass by ., to account for the presence of He, and
dividing it by the SFR.
Results
Sixteen galaxies were detected in Hi in our VLA observations of (cid:12)elds in the ridge of
the Perseus-Pisces supercluster region. Of these, Hi detections are located in `target'
(cid:12)elds centered on optically bright galaxies, while the remaining three are in `blank' (cid:12)elds
away from bright galaxies (see x.). Nine of the galaxies detected at cm do not
have counterparts in optical catalogs; we refer to these galaxies as \Hi-dwarfs" regardless
of their optical luminosity. Six of these Hi-dwarfs were found in target (cid:12)elds {, and the
remaining three in blank (cid:12)elds. Two optically faint, but previously cataloged galaxies,
Zw . and Zw . , were detected in Hi in target (cid:12)elds and , respectively. One
of the targets, the S a galaxy UGC , was not detected in Hi, while the (cid:12)fth target
(cid:12)eld contains two bright galaxies (UGC and UGC ). We adopt the following
convention: () uncataloged galaxies near bright galaxies (i.e. in target (cid:12)elds) are denoted
by the UGC number of the bright galaxy with \a" or \b" appended, in order of increasing
right ascension; and () uncataloged galaxies in blank (cid:12)elds are named \PPHI" followed
by their right ascension and declination.
No Hi detections were made in the void (cid:12)eld observations to a (cid:27) (cid:13)ux density limit
of mJy/beam, corresponding to an Hi mass per channel of (cid:24) (cid:2)
M
at the center
(cid:12)
of the primary beam. The noise in our datacubes is somewhat non-gaussian because of
imperfect subtraction of remote continuum sources; the short duration of the VLA void
observations (and the resulting sparse UV coverage) makes it practically impossible to
remove these sources exactly.
The Hi and radio continuum properties of the galaxies detected in the supercluster
are summarized in Table . Their optical magnitudes, colors, and morphological
properties, based on BRI data, are listed in Table . Table contains the results of the
H(cid:11) observations, along with other parameters derived from the various datasets, including
surface brightness, size, Hi-mass-to-light ratio, and gas depletion timescale. Some of the
Hi parameters in Table (e.g. velocity width and total Hi mass) di(cid:11)er slightly from those
given in Paper I. These di(cid:11)erences are a result of redoing a large part of the analysis using
the completely rewritten, UNIX-based version of GIPSY; this allowed us to take advantage
of several convenient features in the new version and corrected a minor software error in
the old package. In nearly every case, the values of the Hi parameters have remained
equal to the previously published value to within the (cid:27) uncertainty. The velocity width
of UGC at % (W
) was listed incorrectly in Table of Paper I, and this has been
corrected in Table of this paper.
We present global Hi pro(cid:12)les in Figure of all galaxies detected at cm: four
galaxies in (cid:12)eld (top left panel), three in (cid:12)eld (top right panel), two in (cid:12)eld (center
left), two in (cid:12)eld (center right), and two in (cid:12)eld (bottom left). The line pro(cid:12)les of
the three Hi-dwarfs detected in blank (cid:12)elds are shown together in the bottom right panel
of Figure . Figure shows the velocity (cid:12)elds of six large galaxies, those in which the
Hi is well resolved in position and velocity. These include the target galaxies of (cid:12)elds ,
, , and (the target galaxy of (cid:12)eld , UGC , was not detected in Hi), along with
UGC (the second bright galaxy in (cid:12)eld ) and Zw . ((cid:12)eld ). Contour plots
of the Hi column density distributions in the supercluster target (cid:12)elds { are shown in
Figures {. Figure (four panels) and Figures { show contour plots of the total Hi
distribution in some of the individual galaxies superposed on gray-scale representations
of their B -band images. The shaded ellipses in Figures { indicate the FWHM of the
VLA synthesized beam.
In the rest of this section, the galaxies detected in each of the supercluster (cid:12)elds are
discussed in turn.
. Field
The central galaxy of this (cid:12)eld is UGC , an SBb galaxy. In addition to UGC , three
companions were detected around this galaxy in our -cm observations, one of which
was found to be a cataloged galaxy, Zw . (Figs. and ). The four galaxies are at
nearly identical redshifts, the largest velocity di(cid:11)erence being about km s
(top left
(cid:0)
panel of Fig. ). The distribution of neutral hydrogen in UGC is symmetric (lower left
panel of Fig. ) and its velocity (cid:12)eld regular (top left panel of Fig. ); its double-peaked
global pro(cid:12)le indicates a disk in di(cid:11)erential rotation. The other three galaxies are barely
resolved in Hi.
Figure shows the Hi and blue light distributions of all four galaxies in (cid:12)eld . The
optical surface brightness pro(cid:12)les of UGC deviate signi(cid:12)cantly from an exponential law
due to the e(cid:11)ects of a central bar and prominent spiral arms (lower left panel of Fig. ).
As a consequence, the extrapolated central surface brightness and the exponential scale
length of the stellar disk are sub ject to systematic error. In the case of Zw . , a
bright foreground star is seen superposed on its disk, and this makes the measurement of
its isophotal axis ratio and position angle uncertain. Spiral arms are discernible in the
optical images of Zw . and, as in the case of UGC , its disk parameters cannot be
determined accurately. The distribution of starlight in the uncataloged galaxy UGC a
has a very small scale length, and the galaxy appears to be featureless in both optical
and Hi. Given its very blue B (cid:0) R color, it could be classi(cid:12)ed as a compact blue dwarf.
The other Hi-dwarf in this (cid:12)eld, UGC b, is slightly asymmetric and has an exponential
stellar disk without a clear bulge component.
The Hi-dwarfs UGC a and UGC b were observed in H(cid:11). The morphology of
the line emission (and hence of the ionized gas) in UGC a is compact and smooth.
By contrast, the H(cid:11) distribution in UGC b is clumpy and extended, indicating that
massive star formation is taking place throughout the disk of this galaxy.
. Field
The VLA observations of this (cid:12)eld were centered on the Sb galaxy UGC . The target
galaxy was detected along with two gas-rich galaxies around it (Fig. ). One of these,
UGC a, is close to UGC and may be interacting with it, while the other, UGC b,
is about
from the target galaxy. The neutral hydrogen distributions of UGC and
UGC a overlap partially, with a hint of an Hi bridge between them and a faint extension
on the opposite side of the larger galaxy (possibly a tidal feature). The velocity (cid:12)elds of
both galaxies are shown in the top right panel of Figure . The iso-velocity contours of the
main galaxy UGC appear to be twisted, suggestive of an interaction. Kinematically,
the companion galaxy UGC a is distinct from UGC , with its ma jor axis at right
angles to the ma jor axis of the latter.
We were unable to derive optical surface photometry of the close companion
UGC a because a bright foreground star happens to lie at the position of the peak of
the Hi emission. The other Hi-dwarf UGC b was studied in BRI and in H(cid:11) (see Fig. ).
Its optical surface brightness pro(cid:12)le is exponential with no sign of a bulge component.
The H(cid:11) emission is smoothly distributed and somewhat extended, with the peak slightly
o(cid:11)set from the optical center of the galaxy.
. Field
The central galaxy of (cid:12)eld , the S a galaxy UGC , was not detected in Hi. Two
gas-rich galaxies were detected in this (cid:12)eld, at large velocities relative to the central
galaxy: V
= km s
and km s
for the Hi-dwarfs UGC a and UGC b,
hel
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
respectively (see Fig. ), compared to km s
for UGC (obtained from RC). The
(cid:0)
distribution of neutral hydrogen in UGC a is practically unresolved, and is somewhat
o(cid:11)set from the optical centroid (Fig. ). The Hi in the other Hi-dwarf UGC b seems
to consist of two components, separated by about
but at the same redshift (Figs. and
). The smaller component of UGC b, though faint, is seen in three independent
velocity channels and is not a noise artifact.
Both Hi-dwarfs in this (cid:12)eld have low central B -band surface brightnesses, UGC b
being the faintest of all the Hi-dwarfs in our sample in this respect. The optical
morphology of UGC a is slightly asymmetrical with a roughly exponential surface
brightness pro(cid:12)le, and it has a smooth, centrally concentrated H(cid:11) distribution. Seen at
optical wavelengths, UGC b shows an irregular structure with no clearly de(cid:12)ned center.
The optical emission coincides with the peak of the larger Hi component. The inclination,
position angle, and radial color pro(cid:12)les of UGC b, derived by (cid:12)tting ellipses to the
optical images, are not very accurate due to the amorphous nature of this galaxy. The
B -band image of UGC b could not be (cid:13)at (cid:12)elded properly; its total blue magnitude
is therefore not well determined.
. Field
The target galaxy of this (cid:12)eld is UGC , an S galaxy. The only other -cm detection
in this (cid:12)eld is a galaxy from the Zwicky catalog, Zw . (Fig. ). The central galaxy
UGC has an Hi disk in di(cid:11)erential rotation, as the double peaked-global Hi pro(cid:12)le
in the center right panel of Figure shows. The asymmetry of the line pro(cid:12)le and the
curving of the kinematical ma jor axis (center left panel of Fig. ) could indicate some
disturbance in UGC . The Hi distribution of Zw . is irregular in appearance
and is slightly o(cid:11)set with respect to the optical image (Fig. ). In spite of this, both
the global pro(cid:12)le (center right panel of Fig. ) and the velocity (cid:12)eld (center right panel
of Fig. ) are regular and symmetrical, with the iso-velocity contours of the gas aligned
with the optical minor axis. The optical image of Zw . shows a normal disk galaxy,
with an exponential light pro(cid:12)le. No H(cid:11) observations were made of the galaxies in this
(cid:12)eld.
. Field
This (cid:12)eld contains two optically bright galaxies, UGC and UGC . The galaxies are
classi(cid:12)ed as Sc and SBa-b, respectively. Despite their proximity to each other in position
and velocity space, both galaxies have regular Hi distributions (Fig. ) and kinematics
(bottom left panel of Fig. ; bottom two panels of Fig. ) and show no obvious signs of
interaction. Solar interference during the VLA observations of this (cid:12)eld made it necessary
to discard a large fraction of the UV data. Consequently, the sensitivity in this (cid:12)eld is
lower than in other (cid:12)elds, with an r.m.s. noise level of . mJy/beam. We did not observe
these two galaxies in H(cid:11).
. Fields , , and
Hi-dwarfs were found in each of these three blank supercluster (cid:12)elds. Two of the detected
Hi-dwarfs, PPHI + ((cid:12)eld ) and PPHI + ((cid:12)eld ), have asymmetrical Hi
distributions that are o(cid:11)set slightly with respect to the optical image (Figs. and ).
The northward extension of the gas in PPHI + is seen in only one channel and may
not be real. Both PPHI + and PPHI + are low surface brightness systems
and have irregular optical morphology. The Hi-dwarf detected in (cid:12)eld , PPHI +, is
somewhat more regular than the other two Hi-dwarfs in both its Hi and light distributions
(Fig. ). Its stellar disk has an exponential brightness pro(cid:12)le. None of the three Hi-dwarfs
in the blank (cid:12)elds were observed in H(cid:11).
Discussion
We discussed the spatial distribution of our Hi-dwarfs at some length in Paper I; we have
little to add here on the sub ject, since we have no new data on the spatial distribution.
We found nine Hi-dwarfs in the supercluster and none in the void, so the basic message is
that Hi-dwarfs trace the structure outlined by optically bright galaxies. The correlation
seems to continue down to small scales within the supercluster, since we found six of our
nine Hi-dwarfs in the (cid:12)elds targeted on bright galaxies despite observing more blank (cid:12)elds
than targeted (cid:12)elds. This is the sort of behavior we might expect based on the galaxy
autocorrelation function, which continues as a power law down to very small scales. With
only nine ob jects, we are unable to rule out a modest bias between the clustering of bright
galaxies and the clustering of Hi-dwarfs (see Paper I for details), but it is clear that the
most likely place to (cid:12)nd a gas-rich Hi-dwarf is near an optically bright giant.
The optical and H(cid:11) data reported in x allow us to compare the properties of our Hi-
selected sample to those of more traditional, optically selected samples. We provide such
a comparison in x. below. We then describe possible environmental e(cid:11)ects within our
sample and discuss the implications of our results for the Hi mass density and cross-section
in the local universe.
. Comparison to Other Samples
.. Luminosities and Star Formation Rates
The distinguishing feature of our sample of Hi-dwarfs is that it is not pre-selected in the
optical, so the most interesting question to ask about it is whether the ob jects detected in
this way are anomalously faint. There are at least two sensible ways to pose this question:
are the Hi-dwarfs unusually faint for their Hi masses, and are they unusually faint for
their circular velocities?
The (cid:12)rst of these questions can be rephrased in terms of the Hi-mass-to-light ratios
M
=L
, which are listed in column of Table . Values for the Hi-dwarfs range from
HI
B
. to ., with a mean of . (we exclude UGC a, for which we did not obtain L
).
B
For their sample of irregular galaxies in the Virgo cluster (excluding (cid:12)ve that were not
detected in Hi), Gallagher & Hunter ( ) (cid:12)nd ratios ranging from . to ., with a
mean of . . In Haynes & Giovanelli's ( ) sample of isolated galaxies, the M
=L
HI
B
ratios for the galaxies of type later than Sc (speci(cid:12)cally, those assigned a numerical
type { in Table I of their paper) range from . to ., with a mean of .. Two
galaxies in the Haynes & Giovanelli sample have M
=L
larger than the extreme value in
HI
B
our sample, that of PPHI +. It appears that the M
=L
ratios of our Hi-selected
HI
B
galaxies are not extraordinarily high relative to those of optically selected samples of late-
type galaxies. Certainly, -cm selection has not turned up any population resembling
star-free gas clouds. There is some evidence for an increase in M
=L
in lower density
HI
B
environments: our supercluster has a higher mean ratio than Gallagher & Hunter's Virgo
cluster sample, Haynes & Giovanelli's sample of isolated galaxies has a still higher mean
ratio, and within our sample, the blank-(cid:12)eld Hi-dwarfs have high M
=L
relative to
HI
B
Hi-dwarfs in target (cid:12)elds.
We can address the second of the questions posed above by plotting our sample of
galaxies on the Tully-Fisher ( ) relation, as shown in Figure . The dashed line in
this Figure represents the relation derived by Pierce & Tully ( , hereafter PT). For
consistency, we have corrected the absolute magnitudes M
listed in column of Table
b;i
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
B
to the Hubble constant H
= km s
Mpc
derived by PT. Linewidths, corrected for
inclination and internal motions, are from column of Table (see x.). The Hi-dwarfs
in our sample follow the Tully-Fisher relation derived from optically selected galaxies fairly
well; they are not unusually faint for their circular velocity. The three Hi-dwarfs detected
in the blank (cid:12)elds all lie somewhat below the PT relation (the possible implications of this
are discussed in x.). An unweighted least-squares (cid:12)t to all of the galaxies in our sample
yields a slope of (cid:0): (cid:6) :, more or less consistent with PT's value of (cid:0): (cid:6) :. This
(cid:12)t is plotted as a dotted line in Figure . The vertical scatter about the best-(cid:12)t relation
is . magnitude. This scatter is higher than that found for optical samples, but it could
arise largely from errors in the linewidths and inclinations of the small systems in our
sample.
Kunth ( ) and Tyson & Scalo ( ) suggest that the ma jority of dwarf galaxies
may be in a quiescent state, not forming young stars, and that they might consequently
be missed by optical selection methods. We have already seen that the Hi-dwarfs in our
sample are not unusually faint, and we can address the star formation issue directly for the
four Hi-dwarfs that we observed in H(cid:11). The H(cid:11) equivalent widths (column of Table )
are similar to those of typical late-type galaxies (Kennicutt & Kent ), and the
M =L
B
_
ratios and the timescales for gas depletion (columns and of Table ) are similar
to the values derived by Gallagher & Hunter ( ) for their sample of Virgo irregulars.
The gas depletion timescales are on the order of a Hubble time, so these Hi-dwarfs do not
seem to be in the midst of star formation bursts.
In Paper I, we argued on the basis of the number of detected ob jects that our Hi-
selection procedure had not turned up a population of optically under-luminous galaxies.
The optical data presented here con(cid:12)rm this conclusion; our Hi-dwarfs appear to be
garden variety late-type galaxies. If there is a large population of optically faint galaxies
lurking in the shadows, they must either have very little gas, or they must store that gas
in ionized or molecular form.
.. Colors and Ages
To our knowledge, no published BRI magnitudes exist for large samples of dwarf
galaxies.
In Table , therefore, we compare the colors of our galaxies to those of the
statistically complete, diameter-limited galaxy sample of de Jong and van der Kruit (in
preparation). They have obtained B V RIHK surface photometry of galaxies, ranging
in morphological type from Sa to Irr. Table lists the mean and dispersion of the B (cid:0) R
and R (cid:0) I colors for their sample (the \control sample") and for a subset of this sample
with morphological types Sd and later. We also list the mean colors and dispersions in
Table for those galaxies in our sample which have BRI photometry: eight of the nine Hi-
dwarfs and three of the eight cataloged galaxies (see Table ). Our sample is somewhat
bluer than the control sample in B (cid:0) R, but the di(cid:11)erence is not large compared to
the dispersion within the control sample. Hunter & Gallagher ( ) (cid:12)nd that optically
selected dwarf galaxies tend to be bluer than bright galaxies, and the same trend seems
to hold for Hi-selected galaxies.
Figure plots the galaxies for which we have BRI photometry in a color-color
diagram, with the Hi-dwarfs as open squares and the cataloged galaxies as (cid:12)lled triangles.
For comparison, the open circles and connecting line show the galaxy evolution model of
Mazzei et al. ( ). The model incorporates stellar evolution, chemical evolution of the
stellar population, and absorption and re-emission of starlight by interstellar dust. The
model does not (cid:12)t the observational data very well, and two colors are in any case not
enough for accurate age determination. However, it does appear that the galaxies in our
sample are fairly young, and that most of the Hi-selected galaxies are younger than the
cataloged galaxies.
. Environmental E(cid:11)ects
In Figure , we plot the central B surface brightness (upper panel) and the logarithm of
the total blue luminosity (lower panel) of all galaxies that were not (cid:12)eld targets against the
logarithm of the pro jected distance to the (cid:12)eld's target galaxy (or, in the case of the blank-
(cid:12)eld Hi-dwarfs, the pro jected distance to the nearest galaxy in HG's redshift catalog).
Cataloged galaxies are shown by triangles, Hi-dwarfs by squares. Surface brightnesses
come from column of Table , and luminosities from column of Table (see x. for
details). In both cases, there appears to be a modest trend, with fainter galaxies having
larger pro jected separations.
We can make this trend a bit more convincing if we distinguish between Hi-dwarfs
that are gravitationally bound to bright galaxies and Hi-dwarfs that are not. We can
reasonably assume that the Hi-dwarfs in blank (cid:12)elds are not bound, but the question is
trickier for Hi-dwarfs in target (cid:12)elds. We will try to make the distinction by computing
dynamical mass-to-light ratios on the assumption that the Hi-dwarfs are bound, then
asking whether the resulting values are \plausible."
We use two di(cid:11)erent techniques to estimate mass-to-light ratios. The (cid:12)rst employs
the \average" mass estimator of Heisler et al. ( ) for galaxy groups:
M
=
(V
(cid:0) V
)
R
:
est
zi
zj
?;ij
f
Av
X
X
GN (N (cid:0) )
i
j<i
Here N is the number of galaxies in the group, V
is the velocity along the line of sight,
zi
R
is the pro jected distance between galaxies i and j , G is the gravitational constant,
?;ij
f
is a scaling factor, and the sums are carried out over all group members. Heisler
Av
et al. ( ) calibrate this and other, similar mass estimators using model groups with
N = and N = . For N = , they (cid:12)nd that % of the mass estimates lie within a
factor
of the correct value. Applying the estimator to the nearby groups cataloged
:
by Huchra & Geller ( ), they (cid:12)nd a median M=L of about
M
=L
for groups
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
:
with three members.
The mass estimates for our (cid:12)ve groups (i.e. our (cid:12)ve target (cid:12)elds) appear in column
of Table . The corresponding mass-to-light ratios appear in column . While four of the
(cid:12)ve groups have what might be called reasonable M=L values, the high value in (cid:12)eld ,
M
=L
, makes it unlikely that the galaxies in this (cid:12)eld form a gravitationally bound
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
group. Even for the bound groups, the mass estimates in Table have large statistical
uncertainties because of the small numbers of group members.
To avoid these large uncertainties, we can take a more conservative approach and
compute the minimum mass that would be required to bind each companion to its bright
target galaxy. We obtain this mass by assuming that the line-of-sight velocity di(cid:11)erence
(cid:1)V and pro jected radial distance (cid:1)R represent the true, three-dimensional values. These
quantities are listed in columns and of Table . The minimum mass follows from the
inequalities
K E (cid:20) (cid:0)P E
=)
((cid:1)V )
(cid:20)
;
M
M
GM
M
(M
+ M
)
(cid:1)R
where M
and M
are the masses of the central galaxy and the companion, respectively.
This inequality implies a minimum value of (M
+ M
):
M
=
((cid:1)V )
(cid:1)R :
min
G
Column of Table lists this minimum pair mass for each companion galaxy (plus
the central galaxy), and column lists the mass-to-light ratio obtained by dividing this
minimum mass by the total blue luminosity of the pair. Again, we conclude that the
galaxies in (cid:12)eld are probably not gravitationally bound, while the remaining galaxies
could plausibly be bound.
This conclusion has an interesting implication for the low surface brightness systems
in our sample. Three of the Hi-dwarfs have very low surface brightness ((cid:22)
> ); two of
these were found in blank (cid:12)elds, the third in (cid:12)eld . This point is illustrated in Figure ,
where we use open symbols to denote \unbound" systems, i.e. blank-(cid:12)eld Hi-dwarfs and
the Hi-dwarfs in (cid:12)eld , and (cid:12)lled symbols to denote bound systems. The average (cid:22)
of the unbound systems is ., with a dispersion of .; for the bound systems, the
average is ., with a dispersion of .. The mean and dispersion in values of log(L
)
B
are : (cid:6) : for the unbound systems and : (cid:6) : for the bound systems.
Although the statistics are poor, there is at least a hint in our data that the presence
of a neighboring bright galaxy in(cid:13)uences surface brightness and luminosity. In particular,
all of our low surface brightness systems are unbound, consistent with the (cid:12)ndings of
Bothun et al. ( ), though not all of our isolated systems have low surface brightness.
. Hi Cross Section and Mean Density in the Local Universe
Our -cm survey provides us with a picture of the distribution of neutral gas in regions of
the nearby universe. This picture can be compared to the distribution of neutral hydrogen
inferred from quasar absorption lines at high redshifts. Most relevant to our survey
are the damped Ly(cid:11) absorbers (Wolfe ; Lanzetta et al. ), which have neutral
hydrogen column densities similar to those of the systems that we detect at cm. The
question of what constitutes the parent population of the damped Ly(cid:11) systems remains a
matter of debate. It has been suggested that the absorption lines could arise in extended
galactic disks (Wolfe ), galactic halos (Bahcall & Spitzer ), dwarf galaxies (York
et al. ; Tyson ), or tidal features around interacting and merging galaxies (Carilli
& van Gorkom ).
By most accounts (cf. Lanzetta et al. ; Rao & Briggs ), the neutral hydrogen
contained in damped Ly(cid:11) systems greatly exceeds that in present-day galaxies, by factors
of (cid:24) { . However, the estimate of the hydrogen content at the current epoch is based on
observations of gas associated with optically cataloged galaxies. By comparing theoretical
models to observations, Tyson & Scalo ( ) conclude that many dwarf galaxies might
escape optical detection. Tyson ( ) argues that this population of faint dwarfs could
produce the observed damped Ly(cid:11) absorption without strong evolution in the neutral gas
fraction.
Arguments like those of Tyson & Scalo ( ) provided much of the motivation
for our -cm survey. However, we found in Paper I that the Tyson & Scalo ( )
model predicted far more dwarfs than we observed, unless we assumed that the ratio of
Hi mass to optical luminosity was much smal ler for \quiescent" dwarfs than for bright
Hi-dwarfs. In a similar vein, we have seen in x. that our Hi-selected galaxies are not
anomalously faint, so estimates of the local neutral gas density based on optically selected
samples, (cid:18)a la Lanzetta et al. ( ) and Rao & Briggs ( ), should be quite safe. Our
survey is not sensitive to Hi masses much below
M
, but other \blind" -cm surveys
(cid:12)
have covered this regime. Although these surveys cover smaller volumes than our survey,
they are probably large enough to rule out a steep rise in the Hi mass function between
M
and (cid:24)
M
(Fisher & Tully ; Ho(cid:11)man et al. ; Briggs ; Ho(cid:11)man
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
et al. ).
We could attempt to estimate the space density and cross-section of neutral hydrogen
in the local universe directly from our sample. Unfortunately, our survey volume is small,
and our (cid:12)elds are not randomly chosen, so such an estimate would have large statistical
uncertainty and a systematic bias that would be di(cid:14)cult to evaluate. However, we can
say that within our survey region, the Hi-dwarfs contribute only % of the Hi mass and
% of the Hi cross-section. Once again, the message is that the Hi content of the nearby
universe is dominated by relatively bright galaxies. Lanzetta ( ) notes the suggestive
coincidence that the mass seen in gas at high redshifts is equal to the luminous mass seen
at z = , and he therefore proposes that the gas observed in the damped Ly(cid:11) systems has
formed into the stars of present-day galaxies. Our results support this inference, albeit
indirectly.
. Summary
Galaxies can \shine" at both optical and -cm wavelengths, and in principle one might
(cid:12)nd rather di(cid:11)erent ob jects in these two regions of the spectrum. However, our Hi survey
of the Perseus-Pisces supercluster and void has not turned up any remarkable population
of unusual ob jects. Most of the neutral hydrogen gas is associated with big, optically
bright galaxies. Sensitive -cm observations reveal a substantial number of smaller
ob jects, but these appear to be normal irregular galaxies, and their spatial distribution
is not radically di(cid:11)erent from that of the optically bright giants. The distribution of Hi
in an individual galaxy or galaxy group may be quite di(cid:11)erent from the distribution of
stars, but in its broad features, the universe seen at cm is a familiar one.
Acknow ledgments. We are grateful to Martha Haynes and Riccardo Giovanelli for helpful
discussions and for allowing us to use their redshift data, in advance of publication, to
select our (cid:12)elds. We also thank Richard McMahon for providing us with APM data
that were used to determine star positions on some of our JKT frames, and Ronald Hes
for excellent support during the early phase of this pro ject. We thank Hy Spinrad and
Dave Cudaback for the loan of narrow-band (cid:12)lters used to make the H(cid:11) measurements.
Finally, we thank the NRAO for generous allocation of observing time. This research
was supported in part by NSF grants AST - and AST - to Columbia
University, under grant no. -- by the Netherlands Foundation for Research
in Astronomy (NFRA), which receives its funds from the Netherlands Organization for
Scienti(cid:12)c Research (NWO). ASF and PG were supported by NASA through grants
HF- . - A and HF- . - A, respectively, from the Space Telescope Science
Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy,
Inc., under NASA contract NAS-. DW acknowledges support from the W.M. Keck
Foundation and from NSF grant PHY -. The Jacobus Kapteyn Telescope (JKT)
and the William Herschel Telescope (WHT) are operated on the island of La Palma by the
Royal Greenwich Observatory in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos
of the Instituto de Astrof(cid:19)(cid:16)sica de Canarias.
References
Bahcall, J.N., and Spitzer, L. Jr. , ApJ, , L.
Bothun, G.D., Schombert, J.M., Impey, C.D., Sprayberry, D., and McGaugh, S.S. ,
AJ, , .
Bottinelli, L., Gouguenheim, L., Fouqu(cid:19)e, P., Paturel, G. , A&AS, , .
Briggs, F.H. , AJ, , .
Burstein, D., and Heiles, C. , ApJS, , .
Carilli, C.L., and van Gorkom, J.H. , ApJ, , .
Fisher, J.R., and Tully, R.B. , ApJ, , L.
Gallagher, J.S. and Hunter, D.A. , AJ , .
Haynes, M.P., and Giovanelli, R. , AJ, , .
Haynes, M.P., and Giovanelli, R. , in Pont. Acad. Sci. Study Week , Large-Scale
Motions in the Universe, ed. V. Rubin and G. Coyne (Rome: Specola Vaticana),
(HG).
Heisler, J., Tremaine, S., and Bahcall, J.N. , ApJ, , .
Henning, P.A. , ApJS, , .
Ho(cid:11)man, G.L, Helou, G., Salpeter, E.E., and Williams, H.L. , ApJS, , .
Ho(cid:11)man, G.L., Lu, N.Y., and Salpeter, E.E. , AJ, , .
Huchra, J.P., and Geller, M.J. , ApJ, , .
Hunter, D.A., and Gallagher, J.S. , PASP, , .
Kennicutt, R.C., and Kent, S.M. , AJ, , .
Kunth, D. ,
in Evolutionary Phenomena in Galaxies, ed.
J.E. Beckman and
B.E.J. Pagel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), .
Landolt, A.U. , AJ, , .
Lanzetta, K.M., Wolfe, A.M., Turnshek, D.A., Lu, L., McMahon, R.G., and Hazard, C.
, ApJS, , .
Lanzetta, K.M. , in The Evolution of Galaxies and Their Environment, Proceedings of
the Third Tetons Summer Astrophysics Conference, ed. J.M. Shull and H.A. Thronson,
Jr. (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers), .
Mazzei, P., Xu, C., and De Zotti, G. , A&A, , .
Napier, P.J., Thompson, A.R., and Ekers, R.D. , Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng., , .
Neugebauer, G. et al. , ApJ, , L.
Nilson, P. , Uppsala General Catalogue of Galaxies, Uppsala: Uppsala Obs. Ann.
(UGC).
Pierce, M.J., and Tully, R.B. , ApJ, , (PT).
Rao, S., and Briggs, F.H. , ApJ, , in press.
Rieke, G.H., and Lebofsky, M.J. , ApJ, , .
Salpeter, E.E. , ApJ, , .
Tyson, N.D. , ApJ, , L.
Tyson, N.D., and Scalo, J.M. , ApJ, , .
Tully, B. , Nearby Galaxies Catalog, Cambridge University Press.
Tully, R.B., and Fisher, J.R. , A&A, , .
Tully, B., and Fouqu(cid:19)e, P. , ApJS, , .
de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H.G. Jr., Buta, R.J., Paturel, G., and
Fouqu(cid:19)e, P. , Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies, New York: Springer-
Verlag (RC).
Weinberg, D.H., Szomoru, A., Guhathakurta, P., and van Gorkom, J.H. , ApJ, ,
L (Paper I).
Wolfe, A.M. , in The Interstellar Medium in Galaxies, Proceedings of the Second
Tetons Summer Astrophysics Conference, ed. H.A. Thronson, Jr. and J.M. Shull
(Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers), .
York, D.G., Dopita, M., Green, R., and Bechtold, J. , ApJ, , .
Zwicky, F., Herzog, E., Wild, P., Karpowicz, M., and Kowal, C.T. { , Catalog of
Galaxies and Clusters of Galaxies, Pasadena: California Inst. of Technology.
Figure captions
Figure . Global Hi pro(cid:12)les of all detected galaxies. The (cid:13)ux densities have been
corrected for primary beam attenuation. All galaxies detected in a given target (cid:12)eld are
plotted together in the same panel ((cid:12)elds { appear in order starting from top left),
as are the three Hi-dwarfs detected in blank (cid:12)elds (bottom right panel). The velocity
resolution is about km s
. The uncertainties in the (cid:13)ux densities per channel range
(cid:0)
from . to . mJy for the Hi-dwarfs, depending on the distance to the (cid:12)eld center, and
from . to . mJy for the bright galaxies.
Figure . Intensity-weighted mean velocity (cid:12)elds of selected galaxies, those in which the
Hi is well resolved, both spatially and kinematically. These include the target galaxies of
(cid:12)elds , , , and (UGC , the target galaxy of (cid:12)eld , was not detected in Hi), along
with Zw . ((cid:12)eld ) and UGC , the second bright galaxy in (cid:12)eld . The spacing
between adjacent iso-velocity contours is km s
, except in the cases of UGC and
(cid:0)
UGC which have a spacing of km s
, and the velocities of a few contours are
(cid:0)
marked in km s
. The FWHM of the synthesized VLA beam is indicated by the shaded
(cid:0)
ellipse in the lower left corner of each panel. In top right panel, the Hi-dwarf UGC a
can be seen as a close companion,
south of the target galaxy UGC . The velocity
(cid:12)eld shows two distinct rotating disks whose pro jected rotation axes are perpendicular.
Figure . Spatial distribution of the total Hi emission in (cid:12)eld , centered on the target
galaxy UGC . The map has not been corrected for primary beam attenuation. The
FWHM of the beam is indicated by the shaded ellipse. The contour levels are (equal
to (cid:27) in the outer parts of UGC ), , , , , and mJy beam
km s
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for (cid:12)eld , centered on UGC . Note that the Hi
distributions of UGC and the Hi-dwarf UGC a overlap. The contour levels are
(equal to (cid:27) in the outer part of UGC ), , , , , , , , ,
and mJy beam
km s
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for (cid:12)eld , centered on the target galaxy UGC . No Hi
is detected in the target galaxy of this (cid:12)eld, UGC ; its position is marked by a cross.
The contour levels are (equal to :(cid:27) in the outer parts of UGC a), , , ,
and mJy beam
km s
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for (cid:12)eld , centered on the target galaxy UGC . The
contour levels are (equal to :(cid:27) in the outer parts of UGC ), , , , ,
, , , and mJy beam
km s
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for (cid:12)eld , centered on the target galaxy UGC . The
contour levels are (equal to :(cid:27) in the outer parts of UGC ), , , , ,
, , and mJy beam
km s
.
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Figure . Contour plots of the total Hi distribution of the galaxies in (cid:12)eld superimposed
on B -band (negative) gray-scale images. The Hi contours have been corrected for primary
beam attenuation. The beam size (FWHM) is indicated by the shaded ellipse in each
panel. The lowest gray level corresponds to B (cid:24) mag arcsec
. The Hi contour levels
(cid:0)
are:
() Zw . : . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., and : (cid:2)
cm
;
(cid:0)
() UGC a: . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., ., and : (cid:2)
cm
;
(cid:0)
() UGC : . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., , ., . and . (cid:2)
cm
; and
(cid:0)
() UGC b: . ((cid:27) ), ., ., ., . , ., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for UGC b, an Hi-dwarf detected in (cid:12)eld . The Hi column
density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), , ., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for UGC a, an Hi-dwarf detected in (cid:12)eld . The Hi
column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for UGC b, an Hi-dwarf detected in (cid:12)eld . The Hi
column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), , ., , ., and (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for Zw . , a previously cataloged galaxy that was
detected in Hi in (cid:12)eld . The Hi column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., ,
., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for PPHI +, an Hi-dwarf detected in blank (cid:12)eld .
The Hi column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., ., ., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for PPHI +, an Hi-dwarf detected in blank (cid:12)eld .
The Hi column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., ., ., ., and
: (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . Same as Figure for PPHI +, an Hi-dwarf detected in blank (cid:12)eld .
The Hi column density contours are . (:(cid:27) ), ., ., ., and : (cid:2)
cm
.
(cid:0)
Figure . The B -magnitude-vs-linewidth (Tully-Fisher) relation. The dashed line
shows the relation derived for optically selected galaxies by Pierce and Tully ( ), the
dotted line an unweighted least-squares (cid:12)t to our data. Triangles represent the previously
cataloged galaxies in our Hi sample, squares the Hi-dwarfs. Absolute magnitudes are
computed assuming H
= km s
Mpc
, for consistency with Pierce and Tully. Our
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Hi-dwarfs lie close to the relation derived for optically selected galaxies, indicating that
they are not anomalously faint for their circular velocities.
Figure . Two-color diagram for galaxies in our sample. Squares represent Hi-
dwarfs; triangles represent the three previously cataloged galaxies for which we have BRI
photometry. The open circles and connecting line show the evolution model of Mazzei et
al. ( ).
Figure . Extrapolated central B -band surface brightness (upper panel) and logarithm
of total blue luminosity (lower panel) plotted against logarithm of the pro jected angular
distance to the nearest bright galaxy. Triangles represent previously cataloged galaxies
(excluding (cid:12)eld target galaxies); we have a blue luminosity but not a central surface
brightness for UGC . Squares represent Hi-dwarfs, which we have divided into bound
((cid:12)lled symbols) and unbound (open symbols) systems as described in x.. There is
weak evidence for an environmental e(cid:11)ectin particular, the three low surface brightness
systems are all unbound.
Table : Parameters of VLA observations.
Con(cid:12)guration
D
Date of observations
November
Number of antennae
Observing mode
IF
Total bandwidth
. MHz
Number of channels
Shortest spacing
. km
Longest spacing
. km
FWHM of synthesized beam
(cid:24)
(cid:2)
FWHM of primary beam
Equivalent T
for mJy/beam
. K
b
Region
Void
Supercluster
Central heliocentric velocity
km s
km s
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Velocity resolution
. km s
. km s
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Velocity coverage
. km s
. km s
(cid:0)
(cid:0)
Number of (cid:12)elds
Integration time per (cid:12)eld
min
min
R.m.s. noise
mJy/beam . mJy/beam
Table : Pointings of VLA observations.
()
()
()
(cid:11)
(cid:14)
Region
(h m s)
(
)
o
.
V+SC
.
V+SC
.
V+SC
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V
.
SC
.
V
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V
.
V
.
V+SC
.
V
Note to table :
Col. : V denotes the void (cid:12)elds,
SC the supercluster (cid:12)elds.
Table . HI and radio continuum parameters
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
( )
( )
()
()
Field
Name
Type
(cid:11)
(cid:14)
V
D
W
W
log W
M
F
hel
HI
cont
R
i
(h m s)
(
)
(km/s)
(Mpc)
(km/s)
(km/s)
(
M
)
(mJy)
(cid:12)
o
Zw .
Sc
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC a
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
SBb
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
UGC b
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
Sb
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
UGC a
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC b
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC a
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
S a
.
.
(cid:3)
UGC b
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
S
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
Zw .
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
Sc
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
UGC
SBa-b
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
PPHI +
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
.
(cid:6)
.
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
.
: (cid:6) :
Col. : Target galaxies are denoted by asterisks. UGC , the target galaxy of (cid:12)eld , was not detected in Hi: all data related to this
Notes to table :
galaxy and all optical data related to the cataloged galaxies which were not reobserved by us were taken from the Third Reference
Catalogue of Bright Galaxies (RC; de Vaucouleurs et al. ).
Col. : Heliocentric velocity, computed by averaging the mean velocities at % and % of the peak emission. The uncertainties are
derived from the uncertainties in the cm (cid:13)uxes per channel, but estimated to be no less than km s
.
(cid:0)
Col. : Adopted distance, calculated from the heliocentric velocity corrected for solar motion with respect to the velocity centroid of the
Local Group.
Col. and : cm line widths at % and % of the peak emission, not corrected for instrumental broadening. The uncertainties are
derived from the uncertainties in the cm (cid:13)uxes per channel, but assumed to be no less than km s
.
(cid:0)
Col. : Logarithm of the cm line width at % of the peak emission, corrected for instrumental broadening according to Bottinelli
et al. ( ), for internal motions according to Tully & Fouqu(cid:19)e ( ) and corrected to edge-on. We do not list this parameter for
UGC as it is face-on.
Col. : Total Hi mass. Errors are derived from the (cid:27) errors in the cm (cid:13)ux per channel and the uncertainties in velocity width and
distance.
Col. : Integrated cm continuum (cid:13)ux at the position of the Hi emission. The errors are the (cid:27) errors in the continuum maps.
Table . Optical parameters
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
( )
( )
()
Field
Name
B
B (cid:0) R
R (cid:0) I
M
(B (cid:0) R)
(R (cid:0) I )
i
P:A:
L
T
B
B
b;i
b;i
b;i
(mag)
(mag)
(mag)
(mag)
(mag)
(mag)
(
)
(
)
(
L
)
B;(cid:12)
o
o
Zw .
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC a
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0) :
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
(cid:6)
(cid:3)
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
(cid:0) :
.
(cid:6)
(cid:3)
UGC a
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC a
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
(cid:0) :
.
(cid:6)
(cid:3)
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
.
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
(cid:0) :
(cid:6)
(cid:3)
Zw .
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
(cid:0) :
.
(cid:6)
UGC
: (cid:6) :
(cid:0) :
.
(cid:6)
(cid:3)
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) : (cid:0):
.
.
: (cid:6) :
(cid:6)
: (cid:6) :
Col. : Target galaxies are denoted by asterisks. UGC , the target galaxy of (cid:12)eld , was not detected in Hi: all data related to this galaxy
Notes to table :
and all optical data related to the cataloged galaxies which were not reobserved by us were taken from the RC catalog.
Col. : Total B -band magnitude. Errors are a combination of the (cid:27) zero-point errors, (cid:13)at-(cid:12)elding errors and the estimated errors due to
imperfect subtraction of adjacent and superposed stars.
Col. and : Uncorrected broadband colors. Errors are derived from the errors in the total magnitudes in the individual bands.
Col. : Absolute B magnitude corrected for Galactic and internal absorption following Burstein & Heiles ( ) and Tully & Fouqu(cid:19)e
( ).
Col. and : Broadband colors corrected for Galactic and internal absorption following Burstein & Heiles ( ) and Tully & Fouqu(cid:19)e
( ).
Col. and : Inclinations and position angles derived by (cid:12)tting ellipses to the I -band images, assuming an intrinsic axis ratio of . and
correcting for the
e(cid:11)ect (Tully ). These quantities are not well determined for Zw . and UGC b. The values for UGC ,
o
UGC , UGC , UGC and UGC are taken from the RC catalog. The errors are the r.m.s. variation of the (cid:12)ts.
Col. : Total blue luminosity, derived from the blue magnitudes listed in column , assuming an absolute solar blue magnitude of ..
Table . H(cid:11) and derived parameters
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
( )
( )
()
()
()
Field
Name
(cid:22)
(cid:22)
h
D
D
M
=L
S
W
M
log (
M =L
)
log ((cid:28) )
;B
HI
HI
B
H(cid:11)
B
eq
b;i
_
_
(cid:0)
(cid:1)
(cid:0)
(cid:1)
;B
mag
mag
erg
(cid:23)
(cid:0)
arcsec
arcsec
cm
s
(
)
(
)
(
)
(M
=L
)
(
)
(
A)
(M
=yr)
(M
=L
=yr)
(yr)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
Zw .
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
UGC a
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
.
.
(cid:0) :
.
UGC
: (cid:6) :
.
(cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
.
.
(cid:0) :
.
UGC
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
UGC a
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
.
.
(cid:0) :
.
UGC a
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
.
.
(cid:0) :
.
UGC
(cid:6) :
(cid:3)
UGC b
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
Zw .
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
UGC
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
(cid:3)
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
PPHI +
: (cid:6) :
.
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
Col. : Target galaxies are denoted by asterisks. UGC , the target galaxy of (cid:12)eld , was not detected in Hi: all data related to this galaxy
Notes to table :
and all optical data related to the cataloged galaxies which were not reobserved by us were taken from the RC catalog.
Col. : Extrapolated B -band central surface brightness, determined by an extrapolation of a linear (cid:12)t to the straight part of the radial luminosity
pro(cid:12)le plotted on a magnitude scale. The errors are the (cid:27) errors in the y-estimate of the regression.
Col. : Extrapolated B -band central surface brightness, corrected for Galactic and internal absorption following Burstein & Heiles ( )
and Tully & Fouqu(cid:19)e ( ) and corrected for line-of-sight integration.
Col. : Scale length in seconds of arc, determined by a linear (cid:12)t to the straight part of the radial luminosity pro(cid:12)le plotted on a magnitude scale.
At Mpc,
corresponds to . kpc. The errors are computed from the (cid:27) errors in the estimate of the x-coe(cid:14)cient of the regression.
Col. : Diameter at B = mag arcsec
, in seconds of arc. This was determined by a linear (cid:12)t to the straight part of the radial luminosity
(cid:0)
pro(cid:12)le plotted on a magnitude scale, except for UGC b, in which case an elliptical (cid:12)t to the B = mag arcsec
isophote was used
(cid:0)
The errors are computed from the (cid:27) errors in the estimates of y and x-coe(cid:14)cients of the regression.
Col. : Hi diameter, obtained by (cid:12)tting gaussians to the Hi distributions and deconvolving these with the beams.
Col. : Total Hi mass divided by the blue luminosity. The errors are computed from the (cid:27) errors in Hi mass and B -band luminosity.
Col. and : The measured H(cid:11) (cid:13)ux and equivalent width, respectively.
Col. : The star formation rate (SFR) derived as described by Hunter & Gallagher ( ). The measured (cid:13)uxes were corrected for Galactic absorption.
Col. : The logarithm of the ratio of the SFR and blue luminosity, both corrected for Galactic absorption only.
Col. : The logarithm of the timescale for gas depletion (cid:28) (in years). This has been computed by dividing the Hi mass, multiplied by .
to account for the presence of He, by the SFR.
a
Table : Average optical colors.
Color
All
Types(cid:21) Sd
All
Hi-dwarfs
Cataloged
Control sample
Our sample
B (cid:0) R
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
R (cid:0) I
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
: (cid:6) :
Table : Group Mass Estimates
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
()
Field
Name
(cid:1)V
(cid:1)R
M
M
M
=L
M
=L
est
min
est
B
min
B
(cid:0)
(km s
)
(kpc)
(
M
)
(
M
)
(M
=L
)
(M
=L
)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
(cid:12)
Zw .
{.
.
.
.
UGC a
.
.
.
.
UGC b
{ .
.
.
.
UGC a
{ .
.
.
.
UGC b
.
.
.
.
UGC a
.
.
.
.
UGC b
.
.
.
.
Zw .
.
.
.
.
UGC
{.
.
.
.
Notes to table :
Cols. and : Line-of-sight velocity di(cid:11)erence and pro jected distance relative to the central
galaxy of the (cid:12)eld.
Col. : Total mass of the group, computed using the average mass estimator of Heisler et
al. ( ).
Col. : Minimum pair mass needed to bind a companion to the central galaxy of the (cid:12)eld.
Col. : Total estimated mass divided by total blue luminosity of the group of galaxies.
Col. : Minimum binding mass of each companion-central galaxy pair divided by the total
blue luminosity of this pair.
|
astro-ph/0012392 | 1 | 0012 | 2000-12-18T16:41:42 | Properties of the Chandra Sources in M81 | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Chandra X-ray Observatory obtained a 50-ks observation of the central region of M81 using the ACIS-S in imaging mode. The global properties of the 97 x-ray sources detected in the inner 8.3x8.3 arcmin field of M81 are examined. Roughly half the sources are concentrated within the central bulge. The remainder are distributed throughout the disk with the brightest disk sources lying preferentially along spiral arms. The average hardness ratios of both bulge and disk sources are consistent with power law spectra of index Gamma~1.6 indicative of a population of x-ray binaries. A group of much softer sources are also present. The background source-subtracted logN-logS distribution of the disk follows a power law of index ~ -0.5 with no change in slope over three decades in flux. The logN-logS distribution of the bulge follows a similar shape but with a steeper slope above ~4.0e+37 ergs/s. There is unresolved x-ray flux from the bulge with a radial profile similar to that of the bulge sources. This unresolved flux is softer than the average of the bulge sources and extrapolating the bulge logN-logS distribution towards weaker sources can only account for 20% of the unresolved flux. No strong time variability was observed for any source with the exception of one bright, soft source. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Submitted to Astrophysical Journal Letters.
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 04/03/99
0
0
0
2
c
e
D
8
1
1
v
2
9
3
2
1
0
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
PROPERTIES OF THE Chandra SOURCES IN M81
Allyn F. Tennant1, Kinwah Wu2, Kajal K. Ghosh3, Jeffery J. Kolodziejczak1, and
Douglas A. Swartz4
Submitted to Astrophysical Journal Letters.
ABSTRACT
The Chandra X-ray Observatory obtained a 50-ks observation of the central region of M81 using the
ACIS-S in imaging mode. The global properties of the 97 x-ray sources detected in the inner 8′.3 × 8′.3
field of M81 are examined. Roughly half the sources are concentrated within the central bulge. The
remainder are distributed throughout the disk with the brightest disk sources lying preferentially along
spiral arms. The average hardness ratios of both bulge and disk sources are consistent with power law
spectra of index Γ∼1.6 indicative of a population of x-ray binaries. A group of much softer sources are
also present. The background source-subtracted logN -logS distribution of the disk follows a power law
of index ∼-0.5 with no change in slope over three decades in flux. The logN -logS distribution of the
bulge follows a similar shape but with a steeper slope above ∼ 4 × 1037 ergs s−1. There is unresolved
x-ray flux from the bulge with a radial profile similar to that of the bulge sources. This unresolved flux is
softer than the average of the bulge sources and extrapolating the bulge logN -logS distribution towards
weaker sources can only account for 20% of the unresolved flux. No strong time variability was observed
for any source with the exception of one bright, soft source.
Subject headings: X rays: galaxies -- galaxies: individual (M81) -- galaxies: luminosity function --
galaxies: structure -- galaxies: fundamental parameters
1.
INTRODUCTION
deferred to a future paper.
Among the best-studied galaxies beyond the Local
Group is the nearby Sab spiral M81 (NGC 3031). With an
inclination of 59◦, a dominant two-armed spiral pattern,
and a well-defined central bulge, M81 is ideal for investi-
gating formation and evolution of galaxies similar to our
own.
Most x-ray studies of M81 have concentrated on the
dominant source in the field, a low-luminosity AGN at its
core. The only extensive examination of the entire M81
field at x-ray energies is that of Fabbiano (1988, hereafter
F88) based on Einstein observations. Einstein detected 9
sources in M81 including the nucleus, all with x-ray lu-
minosities exceeding ∼ 2 × 1038 ergs s−1, with 5 of these
located along spiral arms. We have identified an additional
9 sources within a ∼6′ radius of the nucleus from archival
ROSAT observations.
In this first examination of a Chandra X-ray Observa-
tory observation of M81, we analyze the global properties
of the 97 x-ray sources detected in the inner 8′.3×8′.3 field
to a limiting 0.2-8 keV luminosity of L ∼ 3 × 1036 ergs-
s−1. Details of the observation and the analysis methods
are given in § 2. Section 3 examines the spatial distribu-
tion of sources and identifies those sources spatially coinci-
dent with previously classified objects. The hardness ratio
distribution is presented in § 4 and the logN -logS distribu-
tion in § 5. Section 6 discusses the luminosity evolution of
sources common to the Einstein (c.1980), ROSAT (∼1990)
and present Chandra observations. The results are sum-
marized in § 7. Detailed analysis of individual sources are
2. OBSERVATIONS
A 49926 second observation of a portion of the galaxy
M81 was obtained with the Chandra Advanced CCD
Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS, G. P. Garmire et al.,
in
preparation) on 2000 May 7. The primary target, SN
1993J, was located near the nominal aimpoint on the back-
illuminated CCD S3 of the spectroscopy array (operating
in imaging mode). The nucleus of M81 lies 2.′79 from
SN 1993J towards the center of S3 in this observation.
The observation was taken in faint time exposure mode
at 3.241 s-frame−1. Standard Chandra X-ray Center pro-
cessing has applied aspect corrections and compensated
for spacecraft dither. We selected the standard grade set
and events in pulse invariant (PI) channels corresponding
to ∼ 0.2 to 8.0 keV for analysis.
The majority of sources identified are within the 8′.3 ×
8′.3 field of S3. To avoid difficulties with the intrinsic dif-
ferences between front- and back-illuminated devices we
restrict our analysis to CCD S3. Due to poor cosmic ray
rejection for the central two columns of S3, all events with
CHIPX equal to 512 or 513 were excluded from analy-
sis. Since these columns are dithered across the sky, their
removal results in a slight loss of sensitivity (5%) in the
central 16′′. Pixels with centers less than 1′′.25 from the
readout trail of the nucleus were flagged and excluded from
analysis as were pixels containing less than 50% sky expo-
sure near the edge of the CCD.
Sources were located using a minimum variance estima-
tor that compares the data to the telescope Point Spread
1Space Science Department, NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, SD50, Huntsville, AL, USA
2School of Physics, University of Sydney, 2006, Australia; and MSSL, University College London, Holmbury St. Mary, Surrey, RH5 6NT,
UK
3NAS/NRC Senior Resident Research Associate, NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, SD50, Huntsville, AL, USA
4Universities Space Research Association, NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, SD50, Huntsville, AL, USA
1
2
Function (PSF). This method is most suited to finding
point sources that roughly match the telescope's PSF. The
PSF was approximated by a circular gaussian with the
same width as the measured PSF at the aimpoint and in-
creasing quadratically with distance from the aimpoint to
approximately match the core and off-axis broadening of
the true PSF. We define the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) to
be the estimated source counts divided by the 1σ uncer-
tainity in this number. To set a minimum threshold, we
considered the number of sources found per S/N interval
down to a minimum S/N of 1.0. This distribution shows a
clear gaussian noise peak at low S/N that indicates a sin-
gle false detection (on S3) is to be expected for a minimum
S/N of 3.0 and less than 0.1 false detections at a threshold
of 3.5. We include all sources with S/N>3.0 in our anal-
ysis with the exception of the spectral analysis (§ 4) and
logN -logS analysis (§ 5) for which only S/N>3.5 sources
are considered.
A second pass, designed to mitigate source confusion,
was made through the data. For this purpose, all pixels
within 2σ of each source position were flagged and the
source-finding process repeated. In this way, the variance
in the local background due to nearby sources is greatly
reduced and otherwise confused sources isolated. An ad-
ditional 6 sources, 4 with S/N>3.5, were detected.
The final source list contained 81 sources with S/N≥3.5
with an additional 16 with 3.0≤S/N<3.5. These source
positions are identified in the ACIS data shown in fig-
ure 1a and superimposed on the second generation digital
sky survery (DSS) image in figure 1b.
Small spatial regions centered on each source were then
selected for further analysis. The size of these spatial re-
gions also varies quadratically with off-axis position and
encompasses roughly the 95% encircled energy radii of the
PSF at 1.5 keV. No correction for the low background,
∼0.04 cts-pixel−1, is made. For spectral analysis (§ 4), the
total counts within each source region were binned into soft
(0.2 -- 2.0 keV) and hard (2.0 -- 8.0 keV) bands. Higher res-
olution spectra, at 16 PI channel binning out to ∼10 keV,
were examined for spurious effects such as anomolously
high background. No anomolies were encountered.
Finally, we distinguish between the 'bulge' and 'disk'
defined here as those regions internal and external, respec-
tively, to a 4.′70×2.′35 ellipse centered on the nucleus with
major axis position angle 149◦ (cf. figure 1). This ellipse
corresponds to a circle in the plane of the galaxy of radius
2.′35 (∼2.5 kpc). There is extended, unresolved x-ray flux
in the bulge that is above background and is not due to the
PSF wings of the nucleus nor to other point sources. This
component will be referred to as 'excess bulge emission.'
3. MORPHOLOGY
The bulge contains 41 sources at a surface density of 5.4
sources-arcmin−2 and the disk contains 56 sources (on S3)
at a density of ∼1.0 source-arcmin−2. Among the latter,
21 are located within ±400 pc of spiral arms (as defined
by Matonick & Fesen (1997) by tracing the Hα emission
peak, their figure 31b). The surface density of spiral arm
sources in our sample is slightly less than, but statisti-
cally consistent with, the surface density of disk sources
not associated with spiral arms.
The surface density distribution of bulge sources,
inclination-corrected and centered on the nucleus, can be
described by an exponential radial distribution, σ(r) ∝
e−r/ro, with ro ∼ 0.92 ± 0.26 kpc. After subtracting
the background component and the contribution from the
wings of the PSF of the nucleus, the surface brightness
profile of the excess bulge emission can also be described
by an exponential with scale length ro ∼ 0.83±0.20 kpc for
0.′8 ≤ r ≤ 5.′5. The excess bulge emission is much steeper
at smaller radii though a residual contribution from the
wings of the nuclear PSF cannot be definitively excluded.
Beyond r ∼ 1 kpc, these profiles are roughly consistent
with the V (Georgiev & Getov 1991), g (Frei et al. 1996),
and B and I (Elmegreen & Elmegreen 1984) profiles sug-
gesting the bulge x-ray emission follows the distribution of
starlight.
A search of the literature for known objects spatially
coincident with Chandra sources found no matches within
the bulge, with the exception of the nucleus. Among the
disk sources, 5 are located within 3′′ of supernova rem-
nants (SNR; Matonick & Fesen 1997) including SN 1993J
and the bright Einstein source X-6 (F88). All 5 SNR can-
didates lie on spiral arms as expected for young, massive
star, Type II supernova progenitors. Source X-6 is a point
source located within a 90-pc-diameter SNR (Matonick &
Fesen 1997). The high luminosity and hard spectrum (§ 4)
of X-6 is uncharacteristic of SNRs.
Six x-ray sources, all located within spiral arms, are
within 10′′ of known HII regions, half of which are giant
radio HII regions (Kaufman et al. 1987). One of these x-
ray sources, though weak, has the hardest spectrum of the
entire source sample (§ 4).
No x-ray sources were found to coincide with known
globular clusters, novae, or stars. Roughly 10% of globu-
lar clusters are expected to contain accreting neutron stars
detectable above our threshold and galaxies like M81 typ-
ically contain of order 200 globular clusters (Perelmuter &
Racine 1995). However, there are only 25 confirmed glob-
ular clusters in M81 (Perelmuter, Brodie & Huchra, 1995)
and only 4 within the S3 field.
The nova rate in M81 is probably of order 20 year−1
(A. W. Shafter, private communication). The x-ray sig-
natures and light curves of novae are only sparsely doc-
umented ( Ogelman, Krautte & Beuermann 1987) making
novae difficult to identify in our source sample.
There are two sources, Einstein source X-2 and a
ROSAT-detected object, which are near stars or star
clusters. X-2 is 1.′′8 distant from a star cluster with
a spectrum consistent with G-type stars (Sholukhova et
al. 1998). Zickgraf & Humphreys (1991) list the opti-
cal object as a probable foreground F-type dwarf. The
ROSAT source is coincident with an undocumented ∼18-
magnitude object visible in the Digital Sky Survey image.
Interestingly, both x-ray sources are transient and have
been much brighter in the past (§ 6).
No known background or foreground objects were found
coincident with the S3 Chandra sources. Up to ∼25
background objects are expected in the S3 field above
S/N = 3.5 based upon our analysis of the calibration field
CRSS J0030.5+2618 (see also Brandt et al. 2000). This
estimate ignores any obscurtion by M81. Based on results
of the Einstein stellar survey (Topka et al. 1982), we es-
timate roughly 0.4 F- and G-stars could be detectable in
our field but these should all be extremely soft (Maggio
et al. 1987, Hodgkin & Pye 1994, Schmitt 1997). A soft
spectrum was observed from 3 catalogued stars detected
on CCD S2.
4. HARDNESS RATIO
The total source counts in the hard x-ray band (2.0 -- 8.0
keV) is shown in figure 2 against the soft (0.2 -- 2.0 keV)
band for the subset of sources with S/N≥3.5 excluding the
nucleus. There is no adjustment for pileup which tends to
harden spectra of the brightest sources.
Also shown are the hardness ratios of the sum of all the
bulge sources, and of all the disk sources, the hardness ra-
tio of the excess bulge emission (background and nuclear
PSF subtracted), and of the typical background (scaled to
a 2′ × 2′ area). The nucleus and the bright soft source are
omitted from the summed bulge point, and X-6 is omitted
from the summed disk point as these sources are clearly
spectroscopically atypical.
The line shown corresponds to an absorbed power law
of spectral index Γ = 1.6, typical of x-ray binaries, with
the Galactic absorbing column density of NH = 4 × 1020
cm−2 (Stark et al. 1992). Though indicative and useful to
guide the eye, this canonical spectral shape is not a model
fit result. Most sources fall near this curve. Notable ex-
ceptions are the soft sources at the lower right of figure 2.
The softest bulge sources have no known associations but
the 3 softest disk sources all lie on spiral arms. The softest
source is also time-variable (§ 6) and is the third brightest
source in the entire sample. The hardness ratios for the
summed bulge and summed disk spectra are also typical
of x-ray binaries. The excess bulge emission is softer in-
dicating some of the excess emission is from truly diffuse,
hot, interstellar gas and not entirely from unresolved point
sources.
5. LOGN -LOGS
The number of sources above a limiting brightness,
N (>S), is shown against the 0.2 -- 8.0 keV count rate,
S, in figure 3. The nucleus is excluded as are sources with
S/N<3.5. Background sources were taken from the cali-
bration field CRSS J0030.5+2618 (§ 3), by applying our
same analysis methods, and have been subtracted after
scaling to the fractional areas of the bulge and disk.
The curve shown in figure 3 represents the best power
law fit to the disk distribution, N = 0.43S−0.50, over
the entire range of S. Similarly, N = 0.44S−0.57 for the
bulge source distribution for S<0.004 count-s−1. There is
a break in the slope of the distribution of bulge sources
above this point but no such break in the disk source dis-
tribution. Of the 10 disk sources with S>0.004 count-s−1,
7 are coincident with spiral arms.
The luminosity of each source can be estimated by as-
suming the Γ = 1.6 power law spectral model of § 4 and
a distance of 3.6 Mpc to M81 (Freedman et al. 1994).
For our 50-ks observation, therefore, S = 0.004 count-
s−1 in the 0.2 -- 8.0 keV band corresponds to a luminosity
LX = 3.7 × 1037 ergs s−1 and the faintest source in the
field corresponds to a luminosity of ∼ 3 × 1036 ergs s−1.
Excluding the nucleus, the total bulge luminosity is
LX ∼ 2.4 × 1039 erg s−1 of which 36% is excess (unre-
solved) emission. The total luminosity of the disk sources
is LX ∼ 3.9 × 1039 erg s−1. The luminosity of the nucleus
3
is LX ∼ 4 × 1040 erg s−1 based on spectral fits to the
trailed image. This is within the ASCA-observed range of
luminosities (Ishisaki et al. 1996) and comparable to the
BeppoSAX observed luminosity (Pellegrini et al. 2000).
The nucleus contributes approximately 86% of the total
luminosity in the 8′.3 × 8′.3 S3 field of view.
6. TIME EVOLUTION
A simple test for time variability was made by binning
the light curves of all sources on 1000, 2000, and 4000
second intervals. Applying a χ2 test for the hypothesis
of consistency with a mean value found only one clearly
significant deviation on all three timescales. This source
is also the softest source on S3 and the third brightest.
It is present in at least 3 of 6 ROSAT HRI observations
spanning 1993 - 1998 but is too close to the nucleus to be
identified in any other previous x-ray observation.
M81 has been observed in x-rays at moderate spatial res-
olution by Einstein in 1979 and by ROSAT over the period
1991 -- 1998. There are 6 Einstein sources (F88) within the
S3 field of view and another 4 ROSAT-detected sources
according to our analysis. Chandra resolves six ROSAT
source regions into two or more sources including Einstein
sources X-7 and X-10, and, of course, the nucleus.
Long-term variability has been detected in the Chandra
variable source, the nucleus, X-2 and the ROSAT-detected
source coincident with an undocumented star-like object
(§ 3). Both of the latter sources are moderately weak in
the present observations (∼3 and ∼ 6 × 1037 ergs-s−1, re-
spectively) but have been much brighter in the past.
The location of another Einstein source, X-12, places it
on the eastern edge of S3. There are no Chandra sources
within the portion of the 45′′ error circle of this IPC source
that falls on S3 and it is not detectable in the ROSAT ob-
servations.
7. SUMMARY
The global properties of the Chandra sources identified
in the central 8′.3 × 8′.3 region of M81 have been exam-
ined. There is a high density of sources located in the bulge
of the galaxy. These sources, and the excess bulge x-ray
emission, follow an exponential radial distribution about
the nucleus with an ∼1 kpc scale length. This is similar
to that of optical light and suggests the excess bulge emis-
sion is from unresolved point sources and that the point
sources trace the old stellar bulge population. However,
extrapolating the bulge logN -logS distribution towards
weaker sources predicts ∼0.022 source counts-s−1 from
sources <0.001 counts-s−1-source−1. Thus, weak sources
can only account for 20% of the total excess bulge emis-
sion (∼0.092 counts-s−1). There remains a significant flux
in the bulge unaccounted for by unresolved sources, par-
ticularly at lower energies, indicative of a truly diffuse,
hot interstellar gas. If all the excess bulge emission arises
from a diffuse thermal bremsstrahlung at kT ∼ 0.2 keV,
uniformly distributed throughout the bulge, then there is
∼ 4 × 106 M⊙ of hot gas.
The average hardness ratio of the Chandra sources can
be described by a power law of index Γ = 1.6 with a Galac-
tic absorbing column density of NH = 4 × 1020 cm−2.
This is typical of x-ray binaries. Assuming thie canoni-
cal spectrum applies to all sources, the background source
4
subtracted logN -logS distribution of the disk sources fol-
lows an N ∝ S−0.50 profile extending to the most lumi-
nous sources at LX > 1039 ergs-s−1. The distribution of
bulge sources, however, shows a break at LX ∼ 4 × 1037
ergs-s−1. Thus the bulge sources are predominantly low-
mass x-ray binaries, consistent with an old bulge stellar
population, while the disk has an additional population of
much brighter sources. Seven of the 10 brightest Chandra
disk sources lie within spiral arms, consistent with previ-
ous Einstein observations (F88), but the entire sample of
disk sources, down to the limiting Chandra luminosity of
∼ 3 × 1036 ergs-s−1, are distributed throughout the disk
without preference to spiral arms. Some of these brighter
sources may be black hole candidates with high-mass com-
panions.
We thank Martin Weisskopf for deriving the expression
for the uncertainty in the source flux used in the source-
finding algorithm. The digital sky survey image used in
Figure 1b is from the "Palomar Observatory - Space Tele-
scope Science Institute Digital Sky Survey" of the northern
sky, based on scans of the Second Palomar Sky Survey, and
was produced under NASA Contract NAS5-2555.
REFERENCES
Brandt, W. N., et al. 2000, AJ, 119, 2349
Elmegreen, D. M., & Elmegreen, B. G. 1984, ApJS, 54, 127
Fabbiano, G. 1988, ApJ 325, 544
Freedman, W. L., et al. 1994, ApJ, 427, 628
Frei, Z., Guhathakurta, P., Gunn, J. E., & Tyson, J. A. 1996, AJ,
111, 174
Georgiev, Ts. B., & Getov, R. G. 1991, SvAL, 17, 168
Hodgkin, S. T., & Pye, J. P. 1994, MNRAS, 267, 840
Ishisaki, Y., et al. 1996, PASJ, 48, 237
Kaufman, M., Bash, F. N., Kennicutt, R. C., Jr., & Hodge, P. W.
1987, ApJ, 319, 61
Maggio, A., et al. 1987, ApJ, 315, 687
Matonick, D. M., & Fesen, R. A. 1997, ApJS, 112, 49
Ogelman, H., Krautter, J., & Beuermann, K. 1987, A&A 177, 110
Pellegrini, S., Cappi, M., Bassani, L., Malaguti, G., Palumbo, G. G.
C., & Persic, M. 2000, A&A, 353, 447
Perelmuter, J-. M., Brodie, J. P., & Huchra, J. P. 1995, AJ, 110, 620
Perelmuter, J-. M., & Racine, R. 1995, AJ, 109, 1055
Schmitt, J. H. M. M. 1997, A&A, 318, 215
Sholukhova, O. N., Fabrika, S. N., Vlasyuk, V. V., & Dodonov, S.
N. 1998, AZh, 24, 591
Stark, A. A., Gammie, C. F., Wilson, R. W., Bally, J., Linke, R. A.,
Heiles, C., & Hurwitz, M. 1992, ApJS, 79, 77
Topka, K., Avni, Y., Golub, L., Gorenstein, P., Harnden, F. R.,
Rosner, R., & Vaiana, G. S. 1982, ApJ, 259, 677
Zickgraf, F-. J., & Humphreys, R. M. 1991, AJ, 102, 113
5
FIGURE CAPTION
Fig. 1. -- Left: Chandra ACIS-S image of the inner region of M81 in J2000 coordinates. North is up and east is to the right. Each sky pixel
is 0.492′′. The aimpoint is near SN 1993J. The readout trail, caused by photons from the bright nucleus hitting the detector during readout,
has been removed. Chandra sources are marked as light blue (S/N>3.5) or magenta (3<S/N<3.5) circles. Einstein sources (Fabbiano 1988)
are marked by red circles encompassing the approximate Einstein positional uncertainties. The 4′.7 × 2′.35 ellipse denotes the boundary
between 'bulge' and 'disk' as used in the text. Right: B-band digital sky survey image of M81 with the locations of sources identified as in
left panel.
Fig. 2. -- Hardness ratio of the 80 sources with S/N>3.5, excluding the nucleus, with √N errors. Also included are the sum of all
bulge sources (B) excluding the bright soft source and the nucleus; the sum of all disk sources (D) excluding Einstein source X-6; the excess
(unresolved) bulge emission (⋄); and the average instrument background (∗) over a 2′
× 2′ region. The line denotes the hardness ratio of a
typical x-ray binary; a Galactically-absorbed power law of index Γ = 1.6.
Fig. 3. -- Background-source-subtracted logN -logS for bulge and disk sources. The background logN -logS distribution was taken from
Chandra calibration observation of CRSS J0030.5+2618 (see also Brandt et al. 2000) using the same analysis procedures used in this study
of M81. The line represents the power law fit to the disk distribution, N = 0.43S−0.50.
This figure "fig01.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0012392v1
|
astro-ph/9911212 | 1 | 9911 | 1999-11-11T18:46:27 | Accretion Discs Around Black Holes: Developement of Theory | [
"astro-ph"
] | Standard accretion disk theory is formulated which is based on the local heat balance. The energy produced by a turbulent viscous heating is supposed to be emitted to the sides of the disc. Sources of turbulence in the accretion disc are connected with nonlinear hydrodynamic instability, convection, and magnetic field. In standard theory there are two branches of solution, optically thick, and optically thin. Advection in accretion disks is described by the differential equations what makes the theory nonlocal. Low-luminous optically thin accretion disc model with advection at some suggestions may become advectively dominated, carrying almost all the energy inside the black hole. The proper account of magnetic filed in the process of accretion limits the energy advected into a black hole, efficiency of accretion should exceed $\sim 1/4$ of the standard accretion disk model efficiency. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
ACCRETION DISCS AROUND BLACK HOLES:
DEVELOPEMENT OF THEORY
G.S. Bisnovatyi-Kogan1
1 Space Research Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences
Profsoyuznaya 84/32, Moscow 117810 Russia, [email protected]
ABSTRACT. Standard accretion disk theory is for-
mulated which is based on the local heat balance.
The energy produced by a turbulent viscous heating
is supposed to be emitted to the sides of the disc.
Sources of turbulence in the accretion disc are con-
nected with nonlinear hydrodynamic instability, con-
vection, and magnetic field. In standard theory there
are two branches of solution, optically thick, and opti-
cally thin. Advection in accretion disks is described by
the differential equations what makes the theory nonlo-
cal. Low-luminous optically thin accretion disc model
with advection at some suggestions may become advec-
tively dominated, carrying almost all the energy inside
the black hole. The proper account of magnetic filed
in the process of accretion limits the energy advected
into a black hole, efficiency of accretion should exceed
∼ 1/4 of the standard accretion disk model efficiency.
Key words: Stars: accretion discs; black holes.
1. Introduction
Accretion is a main source of energy in binary X-ray
sources, quasars and active galactic nuclei (AGN). The
intensive development of accretion theory began after
discovery of X-ray sources and quasars. Accretion into
stars is ended by a collision with an inner boundary,
which may be a stellar surface, or outer boundary of a
magnetosphere for strongly magnetized stars. All grav-
itational energy of the falling matter is transformed
into heat and radiated outward.
In black holes matter is falling to the horizon, from
where no radiation arrives. All luminosity is formed on
the way to it. The efficiency of accretion is not known
from the beginning, and depends on angular momen-
tum of the falling matter, and magnetic field embedded
into it. It was first shown by Schwartsman (1971) that
during spherical accretion of nonmagnetized gas the
efficiency may be as small as 10−8 for sufficiently low
mass fluxes. He had shown that presence of magnetic
field in the accreting matter increase the efficiency up
to about 10%, and account of heating of matter due
to magnetic field annihilation rises the efficiency up to
about 30% (Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Ruzmaikin, 1974)
In the case of a thin disc accretion, when matter has
large angular momentum, the efficiency is about 1/2
of the efficiency of accretion into a star with a radius
equal to the radius of the last stable orbit.
In the
case of geometrically thick and optically thin accretion
discs the situation is approaching the case of spherical
symmetry, where presence of a magnetic field plays a
critical role.
Advection dominated accretion flow (ADAF) was
suggested by Narayan and Yu (1995), and used as a
solution for some astrophysical problems. The sugges-
tions underlying ADAF: ignorance of the magnetic field
annihilation in heating of a plasma flow, electron heat-
ing only due to binary collisions with protons (ions)
had been critically analyzed in papers of Bisnovatyi-
Kogan and Lovelace (1997, 1999), Bisnovatyi-Kogan
(1999), Quataert (1997). There are contradictions be-
tween ADAF model and observational data in radioe-
mission of elliptical galaxies (Di Matteo et al., 1999),
and X-ray emission of Seyfert galaxy NGC4258 (Can-
nizzo, 1998). Account of processes connected with a
small-scale magnetic field in accretion flow, strongly
restricts solution. Namely, the efficiency of the accre-
tion flow cannot become less then about 1/4 of the
standard accretion disc value.
2. Development of the standard model
Matter falling into a black hole forms a disc when
its angular momentum is sufficiently high. It happens
when matter comes from the star companion in the
binary, or from a tidal disruption of the star which tra-
jectory approaches close to the black hole. The first
situation is observed in many galactic X-ray sources
(Cherepashchuk, 1996). A tidal disruption happens in
quasars and active galactic nuclei (AGN) in the model
of supermassive black hole surrounded by a dense stel-
lar cluster.
Equations of a standard accretion disk theory had
been first formulated by (Shakura, 1972); some cor-
rections and generalization to general relativity (GR)
1
2
Odessa Astronomical Publications, vol. 12 (1999)
had been done by Novikov and Thorne (1973). Ob-
servational aspects of accretion disks have been ana-
lyzed by Shakura and Sunyaev (1973). Note, that all
authors of the accretion disc theory from USSR were
students (N.I.Shakura) or collaborators (I.D.Novikov
and R.A.Sunyaev) of academician Ya.B.Zeldovich, who
was not among the authors, but whose influence on
them hardly could be overestimated. The main idea of
this theory is to describe a geometrically thin non-self-
gravitating disc of a mass Md, much smaller then the
mass of a black hole M , by hydrodynamic equations
averaged over the disc thickness 2h.
2.1. Equations
locity equals to the keplerian one Ω = ΩK = (cid:0) GM
The small thickness of the disc in comparison with
its radius h ≪ r means small importance of the pres-
sure gradient ∇P in comparison with gravity and in-
ertia forces. Radial equilibrium equation in a disc is a
balance between the last two forces with an angular ve-
.
Note, that just before a last stable orbit around a black
hole this suggestion fails, but in the "standard" accre-
tion disc model this relation is supposed to hold all
over the disc, with an inner boundary at the last sta-
ble orbit. The equilibrium equation in the vertical z-
direction is determined by a balance between the gravi-
tational force and pressure gradient dP
. For
a thin disc this differential equation is substituted by
an algebraic one, determining the half-thickness of the
disc in the form
r3 (cid:1)1/2
dz = −ρ GMz
r3
1
ΩK (cid:18)2
P
ρ (cid:19)1/2
.
h ≈
(1)
The balance of angular momentum, related to the φ
component of the Euler equation has an integral in a
stationary case, written as
M (j − jin) = −2πr2 2htrφ,
trφ = ηr
dΩ
dr
.
(2)
Here j = vφr = Ωr2 is a specific angular momen-
tum, trφ is a component of the viscous stress tensor,
M > 0 is a mass flux per unit time into a black hole,
jin is equal to the specific angular momentum of mat-
ter falling into a black hole. In the standard theory the
value of jin is determined from physical considerations.
For accretion into a black hole it is suggested, that on
the last stable orbit the gradient of the angular veloc-
ity is zero, corresponding to zero viscous momentum
flux. In that case jin = ΩKr2
in, corresponding to the
Keplerian angular momentum of the matter on the last
stable orbit.
at low microscopic (atomic or plasma) viscosity the sta-
tionary accretion disc must be very massive and thick,
and before its formation the matter is collected by disc
leading to a small flux inside. It contradicts to obser-
vations of X-ray binaries, where a considerable matter
flux along the accretion disc may be explained only
when viscosity coefficient is much larger. It was sug-
gested by Shakura (1972), that matter in the disc is
turbulent, what determines a turbulent viscous stress
tensor, parametrized by a pressure
trφ = −αρv2
s = −αP,
(3)
where vs is a sound speed in the matter. This simple
presentation comes out from a relation for a turbulent
viscosity coefficient ηt ≈ ρvtl with an average turbulent
velocity vt and mean free path of the turbulent element
l. It follows from the definition of trφ in (2), when we
take l ≈ h from (1)
trφ = ρvthr
dΩ
dr ≈ ρvtvs = −αρv2
s ,
(4)
where a coefficient α < 1 is connecting the turbulent
and sound speeds vt = αvs. Presentations of trφ in
(3) and (4) are equivalent, and only when the angu-
lar velocity differs considerably from the Keplerian one
the first relation to the right in (4) is more preferable.
That does not appear in the standard theory, but may
happen when advective terms are included.
Development of a turbulence in the accretion disc
cannot be justified simply, because a Keplerian disc
is stable in linear approximation to the development
of perturbations. It was suggested by Ya.B.Zeldovich,
that in presence of very large Reynolds number Re =
ρvl
the amplitude of perturbations at which nonlin-
η
ear effects become important is very low, so a turbu-
lence may be developed due to nonlinear instability
even when the disc is stable in linear approximation.
Viscous stresses may arise from a magnetic field, it was
suggested by (Shakura, 1972), that magnetic stresses
cannot exceed the turbulent ones.
It was shown by
Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Blinnikov (1976), that inner re-
gions of a highly luminous accretion discs where pres-
sure is dominated by radiation, are unstable to vertical
convection. Development of this convection produce a
turbulence, needed for a high viscosity.
With alpha- prescription of viscosity the equation of
angular momentum conservation is written in the plane
of a disc as
M (j − jin) = 4πr2αP0h.
(5)
When angular velocity is far from Keplerian one the
relation (2) is valid with a coefficient of a turbulent
viscosity η = αρ0vs0h, where values with the index
"0" denote the plane of the disc.
The choice of the viscosity coefficient is the most
speculative problem of the theory. In the laminar case
In the standard theory a heat balance is local, all
heat produced by viscosity in the ring between r and
Odessa Astronomical Publications, vol. 12 (1999)
3
r + dr is radiated through the sides of disc at the same
r. The heat production rate Q+ related to the surface
unit of the disc is written as
Q+ = h trφr
dΩ
dr
=
3
8π
M
GM
r3 (cid:18)1 −
jin
j (cid:19) .
(6)
Heat losses by a disc depend on its optical depth. The
standard disc model (Shakura, 1972) considered a ge-
ometrically thin disc as an optically thick in a vertical
direction. That implies energy losses Q− from the disc
due to a radiative conductivity, after a substitution of
the differential equation of a heat transfer by an alge-
braic relation
Q− ≈
4
3
acT 4
κΣ
.
(7)
Here a is a constant of a radiation energy density, c is a
speed of light, T is a temperature in the disc plane, κ is
a matter opacity, and a surface density Σ = 2ρh. Here
and below ρ, T, P without the index "0" are related
to the disc plane. The heat balance equation is repre-
sented by a relation Q+ = Q−. A continuity equation
in the standard model is used for finding of a radial
velocity vr
vr =
M
4πrhρ
=
M
2πrΣ
.
(8)
Completing these equations by an equation of state
P (ρ, T ) and relation for the opacity κ = κ(ρ, T ) we
get a full set of equations for a standard disc model.
For power low equations of state of an ideal gas P =
Pg = ρRT (R is a gas constant), or radiation pressure
P = Pr = aT 4
3 , and opacity in the form of electron
scattering κe, or Karammers formulae κk, the solution
of a standard disc accretion theory is obtained analyti-
cally. Checking the suggestion of a large optical thick-
ness confirms a self-consistency of the model. Note
that solutions for different regions of the disc with dif-
ferent equation of states and opacities are not matched
to each other.
2.2. Optically thin solution
It was found by Shapiro et al.
(1976) that there
is another branch of the solution for a disc structure
M , α which is also
with the same input parameters M,
self-consistent but has a small optical thickness. That
implies another equation of energy losses, determined
by a volume emission Q− ≈ q ρ h. The emissivity of
the unit of a volume q is connected with a Planckian
averaged opacity κp by a relation q ≈ acT 4
0 κp. In the
optically thin limit the pressure is determined by a gas
P = Pg. In the optically thin solution the thickness of
the disc is larger then in the optically thick one, and
density is lower.
While heating by viscosity is determined mainly by
heavy ions, and cooling is determined by electrons, the
rate of the energy exchange between them is important
for a structure of the disc. The energy balance equa-
tions are written separately for ions and electrons. For
small accretion rates and lower matter density the rate
of energy exchange due to binary collisions is so slow,
that in the thermal balance the ions are much hot-
ter then the electrons. That also implies a high disc
thickness. In the highly turbulent plasma the energy
exchange between ions and electrons may be strongly
enhanced due to presence of fluctuating electrical fields,
where electrons and ions gain the same energy. In such
conditions difference of temperatures between ions and
electrons may be negligible. The theory of relaxation
in the turbulent plasma is not completed, but there are
indications to a large enhancement of the relaxation in
presence of plasma turbulence, in comparison with the
binary collisions (Galeev and Sagdeev, 1983; Quataert,
1997).
2.3. Accretion disc structure from equations describ-
ing continuously optically thin and thick regions
Equations of the disc structure smoothly describing
transition between optically thick and optically thin
disc, had been obtained using Eddington approxima-
tion. The expressions had been obtained (Artemova et
al., 1996) for the vertical energy flux from the disk F0,
and radiation pressure in the symmetry plane
F0 =
2acT 4
0
3τ0Φ
, Prad,0 =
aT 4
0
3Φ (cid:18)1 +
4
3τ0(cid:19) ,
(9)
where τα0 = κpρh = 1
1 + 4
3τ0
In the optically thin limit τ∗ ≪ τ0 ≪ 1 we get
2 κpΣ0, τ∗ = (τ0τα0)1/2, Φ =
. At τ0 ≫ τ∗ ≫ 1 we have (7) from (9).
+ 2
3τ 2
∗
F0 = acT 4
0 τα0, Prad,0 =
2
3
acT 4
0 τα0.
(10)
Using F0 instead of Q− and equation of state P =
ρRT + Prad,0, the equations of accretion disc struc-
ture together with equation Q+ = F0, with Q+ from
(6), have been solved numerically by Artemova et al.
(1996). Two solutions, optically thick and thin, exist
separately when luminosity is not very large. They in-
tersect at m = mb and there is no global solution for ac-
cretion disc at m > mb. It was concluded by Artemova
et al. (1996) that in order to obtain a global physically
meaningful solution at m > mb, account of advectiv-
ion is needed. For the calculated case MBH = 108 M⊙,
α = 1.0 at m = mb luminosity of the accretion disk is
less than the critical Eddington one.
3. Accretion discs with advection
4
Odessa Astronomical Publications, vol. 12 (1999)
Standard model gives somewhat nonphysical behav-
ior near the inner edge of the accretion disc around
a black hole, with a zero heat production at the in-
ner edge of the disk. It is clear from physical ground,
that in this case the heat brought by radial motion of
matter along the accretion disc becomes important. In
presence of this advective heating (or cooling) term,
depending on the radial entropy S gradient, written
as Qadv =
dr , the equation of a heat balance is
modified to
M
2πr T dS
Q+ + Qadv = Q−.
(11)
In order to describe self-consistently the structure of
the accretion disc we should also modify the radial disc
equilibrium, including pressure and inertia terms
r(Ω2 − Ω2
K) =
1
ρ
dP
dr − vr
dvr
dr
.
(12)
Appearance of inertia term leads to transonic radial
flow with a singular point. Conditions of a contin-
uous passing of the solution through a critical point
choose a unique value of the integration constant jin.
First approximate solution for the advective disc struc-
ture have been obtained by Paczy´nski and Bisnovatyi-
Kogan (1981). Attempts to find a solution for advec-
tive disc had been done by Abramovicz et al. (1988),
Matsumoto et al.
(1984). For moderate values of
M a unique continuous transonic solution was found,
passing through singular points, and corresponding to
a unique value of jin. The number of critical point
in the radial flow with the gravitational potential φg
(Paczy´nski and Wiita, 1980) φg = GM
rg = 2GM
.
c2
r−rg
may exceed unity. Appearance of two critical points
for a radial flow in this potential was analyzed by
Chakrabarti and Molteni (1993). Using of equations
averaged over a thickness of the disc changes a struc-
ture of hydrodynamic equations, leading to a position
of singular points not coinciding with a unit Mach num-
ber point.
,
Kogan and Ruzmaikin (1974). For a spherical accre-
tion with v = (vr, 0, 0) the equations describing a field
amplification in the ideally conducting plasma reduce
to (Bisnovatyi-Kogan, Ruzmaikin, 1974)
d(r2Br)
dt
= 0,
d(rvrBθ)
dt
= 0,
d(rvrBφ)
dt
= 0, (13)
∂t + vr
where d
dt = ∂
∂
∂r is a full Lagrangian deriva-
tive. Consider a free fall case with vr = −q 2GM
.
The initial condition problem is solved separately for
poloidal and toroidal fields. For initially uniform field
Br0 = B0 cos θ, Bθ0 = −B0 sin θ we get the solution
(Bisnovatyi-Kogan, Ruzmaikin, 1974)
r
Br =
B0 cos θ
r2 Φ4/3
1
, Bθ = −
B0 sin θ
√r
Φ1/3
1
,
(14)
2 t√2GM . The radial component of
where Φ1 = r3/2 + 3
the field is growing most rapidly. It is ∼ r−2 for large
times, ∼ t4/3 at given small radius, and is growing with
time everywhere. For initially dipole magnetic field
Br0 =
B0 cos θ
r3
, Bθ0 = −
B0 sin θ
2r3
we obtain the following solution
Br =
B0 cos θ
r2 Φ−2/3
1
, Bθ = −
B0 sin θ
2√r
Φ−5/3
1
.
(15)
Here the magnetic field is decreasing everywhere with
time, tending to zero. That describes a pressing of
a dipole magnetic field to a stellar surface. The az-
imuthal stellar magnetic field if confined inside the
star. When outer layers of the star are compressing
with a free-fall speed, then for initial field distribution
Bφ0 = B0rnf (θ) the change of Bφ with time is de-
scribed by a relation Bφ = − B0 f (θ)
√r Φn+1/3
1
.
5. Two-temperature advective discs
4. Amplification of the magnetic field at a
spherical accretion
A matter flowing into a black hole is usually mag-
netized. Due to more rapid increase of a magnetic en-
ergy the role of the magnetic field increases when mat-
ter flows inside. It was shown by Schwartsman (1971),
that magnetic energy density EM approaches a density
of a kinetic energy Ek, and he proposed a hypothesis
of equipartition EM ≈ Ek, supported by continuous
annihilation of the magnetic field in a region of the
main energy production. This hypothesis is usually
accepted in the modern picture of accretion (Narayan
and Yu, 1995). Account of the heating of matter by
magnetic field annihilation was done by Bisnovatyi-
In the optically thin accretion discs at low mass
fluxes the density of the matter is low and energy ex-
change between electrons and ions due to binary colli-
sions is slow. In this situation, due to different mech-
anisms of heating and cooling for electrons and ions,
they may have different temperatures. First it was real-
ized by Shapiro et al. (1976), where advection was not
included. It was noticed by Narayan and Yu (1995),
that advection in this case is becoming extremely im-
portant. It may carry the main energy flux into a black
hole, leaving rather low efficiency of the accretion up
to 10−3 − 10−4 (advective dominated accretion flows
- ADAF). This conclusion is valid only when the ef-
fects, connected with heating of matter by magnetic
field annihilation are neglected.
Odessa Astronomical Publications, vol. 12 (1999)
5
In the ADAF solution the ion temperature is about
a virial one kTi ∼ GM mi/r, what means that even
at high initial angular momentum the disc becomes
thick, forming a quasi-spherical accretion flow. When
energy losses by ions are low, some kind of a "thermo-
viscous" instability is developed, because heating in-
creases a viscosity, and viscosity increases a heating.
Development of this instability leads to formation of
ADAF.
A full account of the processes, connected with a
presence of magnetic field in the flow,
is changing
considerably the picture of ADAF. It was shown by
Schwarzman (1971), that in the region of the main en-
ergy production, the condition of equipartition takes
place, and efficiency of a radiation increase enor-
mously from ∼ 10−8 up to ∼ 0.1 due to magneto-
bremstrahlung. To support the condition of equiparti-
tion a continuous magnetic field reconnection and heat-
ing of matter due to Ohmic dissipation takes place.
It was shown by Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Ruzmaikin
(1974), that due to Ohmic heating the efficiency of a
radial accretion into a black hole may become as high
as ∼ 30%. The rate of the Ohmic heating in the con-
dition of equipartition was obtained in the form
T
dS
dr
σE 2
ρvr ≈ −σ
v2
EB2
ρvrc2 = −
= −
B2v2
E
4πραmvrvslt
,
(18)
what coincides with (16) when αm = 4rv2
E
, or lt =
3vr vslt
4rv2
E
3vr vsαm
. Here a local electrical field strength in a
highly conducting plasma is of the order of E ∼ vE B
,
vE ∼ vt ∼ αvs for a radial accretion.
Equations for a radial temperature dependence in
the accretion disc, separately for the ions and electrons
are written as
c
dEi
dt −
dρ
dt
Pi
ρ2
dρ
dt
= Hηi + HBi − Qie ,
(19)
dEe
dt −
Pe
ρ2
= Hηe + HBe + Qie − Cf f − Ccyc , (20)
A rate of a viscous heating of ions Hηi is obtained from
(6) as
Hηi =
2πr
M
Q+ =
3
2
α
vKv2
s
r
, Hηe ≤ r me
mi Hηi. (21)
Combining (1),(8),(5), we get
T
dS
dr
3
2
B2
8πρr
.
= −
(16)
vr = α
r
r
2 = ρGM
8π ≈ ρv2
In the supersonic flow of the radial accretion equipar-
tition was suggested in a form (Schwartsman, 1971)
B2
. For the disc accretion equiparti-
tion between magnetic and turbulent energy was sug-
gested by Shakura (1972), what reduces with account
of "alpha" prescription of viscosity to a relation B2
8π ∼
ρv2
2 ≈ α2
mP , where αm characterizes a magnetic viscos-
t
ity in a way similar to the turbulent α viscosity. It was
suggested by Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Ruzmaikin (1976)
the similarity between viscous and magnetic Reynolds
numbers, or between turbulent and magnetic viscosity
coefficients Re = ρvl
, where the turbu-
lent magnetic viscosity ηm is connected with a turbu-
lent conductivity σ = ρc2
α η, we get
4πηm
a turbulent conductivity
η , Rem = ρvl
. Taking ηm = αm
ηm
σ =
c2
4παmhvs
,
v2
s =
Pg
ρ
(17)
in the optically thin discs. For the radial accretion the
turbulent conductivity may contain mean free path of
a turbulent element lt in (17) instead of h. In ADAF
solutions, where ionic temperature is of the order of the
virial one two above suggestions for magnetic equipar-
tition almost coincide at αm ∼ 1.
The heating of the matter due to an Ohmic dissi-
pation may be obtained from the Ohm's law in radial
accretion
v2
s
vKJ
h = √2
,
vs
vK
r,
ρ =
M
4πα√2
v2
KJ
r2v3
s
,
(22)
where vK = rΩK , J = 1 − jin
j . The rate of the
energy exchange between ions and electrons due to
the binary collisions was obtained by Landau (1937).
Neglecting pair formation for a low density accretion
disc, we may write an exact expression for a pres-
sure Pg = Pi + Pe = nikTe + nekTp = nek(Te + Ti),
and an approximate expression for an energy, con-
taining a smooth interpolation between nonrelativis-
tic and relativistic electrons. The bremstrahlung Cf f
and magneto-bremstrahlung Ccyc cooling of maxwellian
semi-relativistic electrons, with account of free-bound
radiation in nonrelativistic limit, may be written as
interpolation of limiting cases (Bisnovatyi-Kogan and
Ruzmaikin, 1976).
K, v2
B=v2
r , and v2
In the case of a disk accretion there are several char-
acteristic velocities, vK, vr, vs, and vt = αvs, all of
which may be used for determining "equipartition"
magnetic energy, and one characteristic length h. Con-
sider three possible choices of v2
t for
scaling B2 = 4πρv2
B. The expression for an Ohmic
heating in the turbulent accretion disc also may be
written in different ways, using different velocities vE in
the expression for an effective electrical field E = vE B
.
A self-consistency of the model requires, that expres-
sions for a magnetic heating of the matter HB, ob-
tained from the condition of stationarity of the flow
(16), and from the Ohm's law (18), should be iden-
4 . That implies
tical.
It happens at
= 3√2
α
c
v2
E
v2
r
J αm
6
Odessa Astronomical Publications, vol. 12 (1999)
s
< vt.
B2
rρ vr = 1
vK√J ≃ vtvs
vK√J
vE ∼ vr ∼ αv2
In the advec-
tive models J is substituted by a function which is
not zero at the inner edge of the disc. The heating
due to magnetic field reconnection HB in the equa-
tions (19), (20) may be written with account of (21) as
HB = 3
. At vB = vK the ex-
pressions for viscous and magnetic heating are almost
identical. Observations of the magnetic field recon-
nection in the solar flares show (Tsuneta, 1996), that
electronic heating prevails over the ionc one. Transfor-
mation of the magnetic energy into a heat is connected
with the change of the magnetic flux, generation of the
vortex electrical field, accelerating the particles.
vK(cid:17)2
2J Hηi(cid:16) vB
16π
The equations (19),
(20) have been solved by
Bisnovatyi-Kogan and Lovelace (1997) for nonrela-
tivistic electrons, at vB=vK. The combined heat-
ing of the electrons and ions were taken as He =
(2 − g)Hηi, He = gHηi. The results of calculations
for g = 0.5 ÷ 1 show that almost all energy of the
electrons is radiated, so the relative efficiency of the
two-temperature, optically thin disc accretion cannot
become lower then 0.25. Increase of the term Qie due
to plasma turbulence may restore the relative efficiency
to a value, corresponding to the optically thick disc.
6. Discussion
Observational evidences for existence of black holes
inside our Galaxy and in the active galactic nuclei
(Cherepashchuk, 1996; Ho, 1999) make necessary to
revise theoretical models of the disc accretion. The
improvements of a model are connected with account
of advective terms and more accurate treatment of the
magnetic field effects. Account of the effects connected
with magnetic field annihilation does not permit to
make a relative efficiency of the accretion lower then
∼ 0.25 from the standard value. Strong relaxation con-
nected with the plasma turbulence may increase the
efficiency, making it close to unity. For explanation of
underluminous galactic nuclei two possible ways may
be suggested. One is based on a more accurate esti-
mations of the accretion mass flow into the black hole,
which could be overestimated. The second is based on
existence of another mechanisms of the energy losses
in the form of accelerated particles, like in the radio-
pulsars, where these losses exceed strongly a radiation.
This is very probable to happen in a presence of a
large scale magnetic field which may be also respon-
sible for a formation of the observed jets (Bisnovatyi-
Kogan, 1999; Blandford and Begelman, 1999). We may
suggest, that underlumilnous AGN loose main part of
their energy to the formation of jets, like in SS 433.
The search of the correlation between existence of jets
and lack of the luminosity could be very informative.
Acknowledgements. The author is grateful for par-
tial support to RFBR, grant 99-02-18180, and GPNT
"Astronomy", grant 1.2.6.5.
References
Abramovicz M.A.,
Czerny B.,
Lasota
J.P.,
Szuszkiewicz E.: 1988, ApJ, 332, 646.
Artemova I.V., Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S., Bjornsson G.,
Novikov I.D.: 1996, ApJ, 456, 119.
Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S.:
black
evidences
ed. S.Chakrabarti, Kluwer, p.1.
1999,
holes
for
in "Observational
in the universe",
Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S., Blinnikov
S.I.:
1976,
Pisma Astron. Zh., 2, 489.
Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S., Lovelace R.V.L.: 1997, ApJL,
486, L43.
Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S., Lovelace R.V.L.:
1999,
ApJ (accepted), astro-ph/9902344.
Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S., Ruzmaikin A.A.:
1974,
Ap. and Space Sci., 28, 45.
Bisnovatyi-Kogan, G.S., Ruzmaikin, A.A., 1976,
Ap. and Space Sci., 42, 401.
Blandford
R.D.,
Begelman M.C.:
1999,
Month. Not. R.A.S., 303, 1.
Cannizzo J.K. et al.: 1998, AAS Abstracts, 192, 4103C.
Chakrabarti S.K., Molteni D.: 1993, ApJ, 417, 671.
Cherepashchuk A.M.:
1996, Uspekhi Fiz. Nauk.,
166, 809.
Di Matteo T., Fabian A.C., Rees, M.J. et al.: 1999,
Month. Not. R.A.S., 305, 492.
Galeev A.A., Sagdeev R.Z.:
1983, Chap.
Handbook of Plasma Physics, Vol.
Rosenbluth M.N., Sagdeev R.Z.
North-Holland Pub.), Ch. 6.1
6,
in
eds.
(Amsterdam:
1,
Ho L.: 1999, in "Observ. evidences for b. h.
in the
Universe", ed. S.Chakrabarti, Kluwer, p.157.
Landau L.D.: 1937, Zh. Exp. Theor. Phys. 7, 203.
Matsumoto R., Sato Sh., Fukue J., Okazaki A.T.:
1984, Publ. Astron. Soc. Japan, 36, 71.
Narayan R., Yu I.: 1995, ApJ, 452, 710.
Novikov I.D., Thorne K.S.:
in Black Holes
eds. C.DeWitt, B.DeWitt (New York: Gordon &
Breach), p.345
1973,
Paczy´nski B., Bisnovatyi-Kogan G.S.:
1981,
Acta Astron., 31, 283.
Paczy´nski B., Wiita P.J.: 1980, A&A, 88, 23.
Pringle J.E., Rees, M.J.: 1972, A&A, 21, 1.
Quataert E.: 1997, astro-ph/9710127.
Schwartsman V.F.: 1971, Soviet Astron., 15, 377.
Shakura N.I.:
1972, Astron.
Zh., 49,
921;
(1973, Sov. Astron., 16, 756)
Shakura N.I., Sunyaev R.A.: 1973, A&A, 24, 337.
Shapiro S.L., Lightman A.P., Eardley D.M.: 1976,
ApJ, 204, 187.
Tsuneta S.: 1996, ApJ, 456, 840.
|
astro-ph/0409628 | 1 | 0409 | 2004-09-27T11:01:16 | The cosmological significance of Low Surface Brightness galaxies found in a deep blind neutral-hydrogen survey | [
"astro-ph"
] | We have placed limits on the cosmological significance of gas-rich low surface-brightness (LSB) galaxies as a proportion of the total population of gas-rich galaxies by carrying out a very deep survey (HIDEEP) for neutral hydrogen (HI) with the Parkes multibeam system. Such a survey avoids the surface-brightness selection effects that limit the usefulness of optical surveys for finding LSB galaxies. To complement the HIDEEP survey we have digitally stacked eight 1-hour R-band Tech Pan films from the UK Schmidt Telescope covering 36 square degrees of the survey area to reach a very deep isophotal limit of 26.5 R mag/sq. arcsec. At this level, we find that all of the 129 HI sources within this area have optical counterparts and that 107 of them can be identified with individual galaxies. We have used the properties of the galaxies identified as the optical counterparts of the HI sources to estimate the significance of LSB galaxies (defined to be those at least 1.5 magnitudes dimmer in effective surface-brightness than the peak in the observed distribution seen in optical surveys). We calculate the contribution of LSB galaxies to the total number, neutral hydrogen density, luminosity density, baryonic mass density, dynamical mass density and cross-sectional area of gas-rich galaxies. We do not find any `Crouching Giant' LSB galaxies such as Malin 1, nor do we find a population of extremely low surface-brightness galaxies not previously found by optical surveys. Such objects must either be rare, gas-poor or outside the survey detection limits. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (0000)
Printed 14 November 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
The cosmological significance of Low Surface Brightness
galaxies found in a deep blind neutral-hydrogen survey
R. F. Minchin,1⋆ M. J. Disney,1 Q. A. Parker,2 P. J. Boyce,3 W. J. G. de Blok,1
G. D. Banks,1† R. D. Ekers 4 K. C. Freeman,5 D. A. Garcia,1 B. K. Gibson, 6
M. Grossi,1 R. F. Haynes,7 P. M. Knezek,8 R. H. Lang,1 D. F. Malin,9
R. M. Price,10 M. Putman,11 I. M. Stewart,12 A. E. Wright4
1 School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, 5 The Parade, Cardiff, CF24 3YB
2 Department of Physics, Macquarie University, Sydney, NSW 2109, Australia
3 Planning Division, Cardiff University, Park Place, Cardiff, CF10 3UA
4 Australia Telescope National Facility, PO Box 76, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia
5 Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics, Mount Stromlo Observatory, Cotter Road, Weston ACT 2611, Australia
6 Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, PO Box 218, Hawthorn, Victoria 3122, Australia
7 School of Mathematics & Physics, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania 7001, Australia
8 WIYN Consortium Inc., 950 North Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85719, United States
9 Anglo-Australian Observatory, P.O. Box 296, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia
10 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of New Mexico, 800 Yale Boulevard NE, Albuquerque, NM, United States
11 Center for Astrophysics and Space Astronomy, University of Colorado, Campus Box 389, Boulder, CO, United States
12 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester LE1 7RH
14 November 2018
ABSTRACT
We have placed limits on the cosmological significance of gas-rich low surface-
brightness (LSB) galaxies as a proportion of the total population of gas-rich galaxies by
carrying out a very deep survey (HIDEEP; Minchin et al. 2003) for neutral hydrogen
(Hi) with the Parkes multibeam system. Such a survey avoids the surface-brightness
selection effects that limit the usefulness of optical surveys for finding LSB galaxies.
To complement the HIDEEP survey we have digitally stacked eight 1-hour R-band
Tech Pan films from the UK Schmidt Telescope covering 36 square degrees of the sur-
vey area to reach a very deep isophotal limit of 26.5 R mag arcsec−2. At this level, we
find that all of the 129 Hi sources within this area have optical counterparts and that
107 of them can be identified with individual galaxies. We have used the properties
of the galaxies identified as the optical counterparts of the Hi sources to estimate the
significance of LSB galaxies (defined to be those at least 1.5 magnitudes dimmer in
effective surface-brightness than the peak in the observed distribution seen in optical
surveys). Two different methods of correcting for ease-of-detection do not yield signif-
icantly different results: LSB galaxies make up 62 ± 37 per cent of gas-rich galaxies by
number according to our first method (weighting by Hi mass function), which includes
a correction for large scale structure, or 51±20 per cent when calculated by our second
method (1/Vmax correction). We also find that LSB galaxies provide 30 ± 10 per cent
of the contribution of gas-rich galaxies to the neutral hydrogen density of the Universe,
7 ± 3 per cent of their contribution to the luminosity density of the Universe; 9 ± 4 of
their contribution to the baryonic mass density of the Universe, 20 ± 10 per cent of
their contribution to the dynamical mass density of the Universe and 40 ± 20 per cent
of their cross-sectional area. We do not find any 'Crouching Giant' LSB galaxies such
as Malin 1, nor do we find a population of extremely low surface-brightness galaxies
not previously found by optical surveys. Such objects must either be rare, gas-poor or
outside the survey detection limits.
Key words: surveys -- galaxies: luminosity function -- radio lines: galaxies -- galaxies:
fundamental parameters
2
R. F. Minchin et al.
1 INTRODUCTION
Surveys in the optical are known to be affected by strong
selection effects (e.g. Disney 1976; Disney & Phillipps 1983;
McGaugh 1996) which bias our understanding of the local
galaxy population. Corrections for these selection effects can
be made, but these are large and controversial and must be
applied to small numbers of sources, leading to large uncer-
tainties (Impey & Bothun 1997; Disney 1999). Low Surface-
Brightness (LSB) galaxies could make a significant contri-
bution to the Universe that would not be recognised in an
optical survey. They may dominate the luminosity, baryon or
mass density of the galaxies in the Universe (e.g. Fukugita,
Hogan, & Peebles 1998) and could contribute significantly
to QSO absorption line spectra (e.g. Churchill & Le Brun
1998).
Zwaan et al. (2003) derived the Hi mass function for
the 1000 galaxies in the Hi Parkes All Sky Survey (HIPASS)
Bright Galaxy Catalogue (Koribalski et al. 2004) and put a
value of 15 per cent on the contribution of LSB galaxies to
the neutral hydrogen density of the Universe. However, this
number depends crucially on their assumption that optical
catalogues are as (in)complete for LSB galaxies as for high
surface-brightness (HSB) galaxies. This is obviously not the
case as LSB galaxies are much harder to detect than HSB
galaxies. Indeed, most of the new galaxies, outside of the
zone-of-avoidance, found in the HIPASS Bright Galaxy Cat-
alogue are LSB galaxies (Ryan-Weber et al. 2002). Thus the
value of Zwaan et al. should be considered only a lower limit
to the contribution of LSB galaxies to the neutral hydrogen
density.
The idea of searching for galaxies via the 21-cm neutral
hydrogen line has long been considered as an alternative to
optical surveys (e.g. Disney 1976). However, until recent ad-
vances in technology such as multibeam receivers and pow-
erful correlators, such a survey has not been practical.
The HIDEEP survey (Minchin et al. 2003; Paper 1
hereafter) was motivated by the desire to reach previously
inaccessible surface-brightness levels.
If optical surface-
brightness (e.g. luminosity per square arcsec) were to corre-
late with hydrogen column-density (e.g. Hi flux per square
arcsec), then to reach low surface-brightnesses it would be
necessary to reach low column-densities. With an integra-
tion time of 9000 seconds per beam, HIDEEP is significantly
more sensitive to low column-density gas than any previous
survey and thus potentially more sensitive to low surface-
brightness galaxies.
HIDEEP followed the same survey strategy and data-
reduction path as HIPASS (Barnes et al. 1998), but with
twenty times the integration time. The Parkes multibeam
system was actively scanned in declination to cover a 6◦×10◦
region, with full sensitivity being reached over the central
4◦ × 8◦. Scans were interleaved to give Nyquist sampling
and repeated to reach the required depth. The data were
treated in the same way as HIPASS data: they were re-
duced in AIPS++ using the LiveData and Gridzilla pro-
grams and continuum sources were removed by template-
fitting with the Luther program. In order to minimise the
noise, all the observations were carried out at night. The full
sensitivity reached was 3.2 mJy beam−1, which is consistent
with a √t improvement on HIPASS.
To complement the deep Hi data, we obtained eight 1-
hour exposures on Tech Pan films at the UK Schmidt Tele-
scope (UKST). These covered a sky area of 6◦ × 6◦, with
the same centre as the Hi survey data. The films were digi-
tised using the SuperCOSMOS machine at the Royal Ob-
servatory, Edinburgh (Hambly et al. 2001). Digital stacking
of these films brings a √t improvement in signal to noise
(Bland-Hawthorn, Shopbell & Malin 1993), thus gaining us
a little over a magnitude in depth. The use of Tech Pan films
gives a further magnitude improvement over the III-aF R-
band plates previously used at the UKST (Parker & Malin
1999). For galaxies with ordinary colours, our 1σ surface-
brightness limit of 26.5 R mag arcsec−2 is equivalent to
∼ 27.5 B mag arcsec−2.
The bandpass limit of the multibeam system means that
only objects with a heliocentric velocity less than 12,700
km s−1 can be detected (173 Mpc for H0 = 75 km s−1 Mpc−1,
after correction to CMB rest frame velocities), thus the vol-
ume of the 36 square degree optical overlap region is 19,000
Mpc3. Within this volume we find a total of 129 sources, of
which 107 can be identified with individual galaxies.
2 ANALYSIS OF THE OPTICAL DATA
In Paper 1, we identified sources found in the Hi data with
optical counterparts on the Tech Pan films. A comparison
of the offsets of the optical positions from the Hi positions
for the sources with secure identifications (those with cat-
alogued velocities matching the Hi velocity and those con-
firmed by Hi interferometry or optical spectroscopy follow-
up observations) with the offsets for less certain counterparts
(those without catalogued velocities or follow-up observa-
tions) showed no significant difference. Of the 107 galaxies
in this paper, 87 are secure identifications; this includes 18
confirmed with our interferometric follow-up and 2 with our
spectroscopic follow-up. Of the remaining 20, 18 are previ-
ously catalogued galaxies that do not have redshifts in the
literature and two are new detections.
An Hi-selected sample is expected to appear different
from an optically-selected one. In particular low surface-
brightness galaxies -- which are seen over much smaller vol-
umes than high surface-brightness galaxies with the same to-
tal luminosity in optical surveys (Disney & Phillipps 1983) --
are expected to be seen much more easily. However, gas-poor
galaxies, such as ellipticals and dwarf spheroidals, which are
found by optical surveys will be invisible at 21-cm. We find
that this is indeed the case with our sample. As expected,
our surface-brightness distribution (Figure 1) is higher to-
wards lower surface-brightnesses than one finds in optically
selected samples such as the ESO-LV (Lauberts & Valentijn
1989), which is also shown in the figure. A Kolmogorov-
Smirnov test on our observed surface-brightness distribu-
tion and the surface-brightness distribution of the ESO-LV,
which also uses R-band effective surface-brightness, shows
that the hypothesis that both are drawn from the same par-
ent population has a significance of less than 1 per cent, due
to the larger number of LSB galaxies seen in the HIDEEP
sample. This confirms that Hi surveys do, as expected, avoid
some of the surface-brightness selection effects present in op-
tical surveys.
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
3
Figure 1. Number of galaxies found in each surface-brightness
bin. The solid line shows the distribution of observed surface-
brightnesses, the dashed line shows the distribution of surface-
brightnesses after correction for galactic absorption, cosmological
dimming, and inclination. The dotted line shows the observed
surface-brightness distribution of ESO-LV galaxies (right hand
scale).
2.1 Tabulated Optical Properties
Optical photometry of HIDEEP galaxies was carried out us-
ing a combination of sextractor (Bertins & Arnouts 1996)
and the stsdas package in iraf, where the ellipse task was
used to obtain radial surface-brightness profiles. The mea-
sured optical parameters are displayed in Table 1 (a sample
is shown here, the full table is available in the online edi-
tion) where column (1) gives the source name and (2) the
catalogued identification -- if there is one. Column (3) gives
the type of the identification graded into 3 classes: "ID" de-
notes objects where both positions and velocities coincide,
"PCG" (for Previously Catalogued Galaxy) where there is a
positional coincidence with a previously catalogued galaxy
in the NASA Extragalactic Database (NED) and "PUG"
(for Previously Uncatalogued Galaxy) where there is no
possible counterpart in NED, and thus no previous posi-
tional or redshift data. Three further sub-classes, "ID-VLA",
"ID-ATCA", and "ID-Spec" denote where a previously cat-
alogued galaxy without a redshift has been confirmed as
the optical counterpart through our follow-up observations
(by interferometry with the VLA or the ATCA or by spec-
troscopy at the ANU 2.3-m telescope at Siding Spring re-
spectively).
The tabulated optical parameters are as follows: column
(4) gives the apparent magnitude (mR) as measured by the
mag best parameter in sextractor. This takes the form of
either an adaptive aperture magnitude (Kron 1980), where
the size of the aperture is 2.5 times the first-moment radius
of the galaxy, or, for crowded fields, an isophotal magni-
tude (to the 26 R mag arcsec−2 isophote) with a correction
made for the part of the galaxy beyond the isophotal limit
4
R. F. Minchin et al.
Tab e 1: i
a eie f DEE ga axie. Thi i a a e f he
ab e { he f ab e i avai ab e i he ie edii
D
Caa g e
C a
(cid:22)
(cid:15)
A
R
(cid:22)
R
e
e
R
R
e
e
a
e
R(cid:22)
k
R(cid:22)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
DEE 1326 3024
C 4247
D 13.8
16.7
22.4
0.57
0.17
15.0
0.98
22.7
DEE 1326 3209
ES 444 G033
D VA 14.0
23.9
22.4
0.74
0.14
19.5
4.2
23.0
DEE 1327 2713
ES 509 G014
CG 16.5
4.3
22.4
0.40
0.15
16.5
0.72
22.5
DEE 1327 2935
GC 5150
D 12.4
11.7
20.9
0.24
0.15
21.6
3.1
20.8
DEE 1327 3006
UGCA 358
D 14.5
21.7
24.4
0.56
0.16
18.4
3.1
24.7
DEE 1328 2735
ES 509 G026
D 16.5
7.3
24.1
0.32
0.14
16.1
1.0
24.1
DEE 1328 2819
[BZZ2000℄ 132823.03 2811814.7
D 16.6
8.0
24.0
0.34
0.14
16.4
1.3
24.1
DEE 1328 3152
ES 444 G047
D 13.7
12.7
22.1
0.65
0.14
20.8
3.8
22.5
DEE 1329 2714
ES 509 G031
CG 17.3
9.7
25.3
0.10
0.15
16.4
2.4
25.2
DEE 1329 3144
ABE 3558:[G94℄ 2773
D VA 18.1
5.2
24.1
0.20
0.14
16.2
1.6
24.0
DEE 1329 3203
ES 444 G056
D 16.3
7.3
23.4
0.12
0.13
18.0
2.3
23.2
DEE 1330 2755
C 4264
D 14.2
10.7
22.2
0.60
0.14
19.8
2.6
22.5
DEE 1330 2809
GC 5182
D 12.0
30.0
22.0
0.53
0.15
22.5
9.0
22.2
DEE 1330 2936
2ASX 13303473 2934210
D VA 14.6
11.6
23.1
0.52
0.15
19.6
3.1
23.3
DEE 1330 3212
ES 444 G059
CG 16.8
12.1
25.1
0.11
0.14
17.2
3.3
25.0
DEE 1330 3233
ES 444 G061
CG 14.8
10.7
23.2
0.07
0.14
21.5
8.4
22.9
DEE 1330 3259
UG 14.9
26.7
24.8
0.45
0.15
19.1
7.9
24.9
DEE 1331 2804
[ R95℄1325 27 50
D 13.6
8.0
21.4
0.24
0.15
22.4
5.4
21.6
DEE 1331 2944
C 4275
D 13.1
11.4
21.3
0.39
0.15
21.2
3.4
21.3
DEE 1331 3155
ES 444 G066
D 14.9
11.6
23.7
0.09
0.14
19.3
3.6
23.6
DEE 1331 3205
Abe 3558:[G94℄3325
CG 16.9
6.6
23.9
0.35
0.13
15.7
0.90
24.0
DEE 1331 3258
GSC 7269 01680
D 14.4
7.3
22.0
0.34
0.15
19.5
1.8
22.0
DEE 1332 2727
ES 509 G048
D 14.0
9.3
22.5
0.10
0.17
22.3
6.6
22.4
DEE 1332 3141
Abe 3558:[G94℄3535
D 15.7
9.3
23.5
0.09
0.14
20.4
6.6
23.3
DEE 1333 2727
RAS F13304 2714
CG 16.3
4.5
22.9
0.35
0.18
19.9
3.1
22.8
DEE 1333 2743
C 4286
CG 15.0
5.2
21.9
0.11
0.17
20.9
3.4
21.7
DEE 1333 2901
[D99℄ 13300.7 284540
D 15.6
10.7
22.8
0.62
0.15
19.5
4.1
23.0
DEE 1333 3158
ES 444 G070
D 14.0
8.4
21.9
0.20
0.14
22.2
6.2
21.7
DEE 1333 3243
ES 444 G071
D 13.4
15.9
21.6
0.68
0.15
21.1
4.6
22.0
(Maddox et al. 1990), the best algorithm being selected auto-
matically by the program. Simulations by Bertin & Arnouts
(1996) of an R-band CCD image with an isophotal limit of
26 R mag arcsec−2 (i.e. very similar to our image) show that,
to the magnitude level of the faintest galaxy in our survey
(18.6 R mag), the true magnitude is recovered to better than
0.1 mag.
Column (5) gives the effective radius, re -- the radius
enclosing half the R-band light. Column (6) gives the effec-
tive surface-brightness µe -- the R-band surface-brightness at
the effective radius. This gives a model-independent measure
of the surface brightness which can be applied to all types
of galaxies. Column (7) gives the sextractor ellipticity
(ǫ = 1 − b/a) and (8) the estimated R-band absorption at
the position of the object from Schlegel et al. (1998) sup-
plied by NED. Column (9) gives the absolute magnitude
MR, including corrections for galactic absorption, cosmo-
logical dimming and internal absorption (estimated using
Ai,R = 0.95 log(a/b), where a/b is calculated from ǫ). The
k-correction out to the bandpass limit of 12,700 km s−1 is
negligible. We use the distances from Paper 1 except for
galaxies in the Centaurus A group (taken to be those within
1000 km s−1), where we use the distance to the M83 sub-
group of 4.5 Mpc from Thim et al. (2003). Column (10)
gives the physical effective radius Re in kpc. Finally col-
umn (13) gives the surface brightness µe(c) corrected for
(1 + z)4 cosmological dimming, inclination (estimated using
Ci,R = −1.25 log(a/b) from Graham & de Blok (2001)) and
galactic absorption.
Table 2 gives the positions of the optical counterparts
of the PUGs. Where these have been confirmed by interfer-
ometric follow up, this is indicated by a code in column (4)
giving the run in which they were detected. The PUGs that
were not detected in earlier runs were followed up again in
later runs, with the result that there are no galaxies in the
table that have been followed-up but not detected, although
there are two sources which have not been followed-up in-
terferometrically.
3 VOLUMETRIC AND LARGE SCALE
STRUCTURE CORRECTED DATA
No conclusions can be drawn as to the cosmic significance of
the LSB galaxies found in HIDEEP until the raw numbers
have been corrected for ease-of-Hi-detection and for the large
scale structure in the region. The peak flux (Speak) of a
galaxy determines the distance to which it may be seen in
an Hi survey and is related to its Hi mass (MHI) and its
velocity width (∆V ) as MHI ∝ d2∆V Speak. However, the
velocity width is not independent of the mass of a galaxy
-- these are related as ∆V ∝ M 1/3
HI (Briggs & Rao 1993),
thus MHI ∝ d3S3/2
peak. For a fixed limiting peak flux, we
therefore get MHI,lim ∝ d3. While this is an approximate
empirical relationship originally defined using an optically-
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
5
Table 2. Positions of newly-discovered galaxies in the HIDEEP
optical area. For those detected interferometrically, Column (4)
gives the code for the observing run: A1 - ATCA, 11/1999; A2
- ATCA, 01/2000; V - VLA, 01-03/2003; A3 - ATCA, 04/2003.
Those without a code have not been observed with an interfer-
ometer.
HIDEEP ID R.A.
(1)
(2)
Decl.
(3)
Run
(4)
J1330-3259
J1336-2932
J1337-3118
J1338-3035
J1339-3022
J1342-2859
J1342-3021
J1344-3202
J1345-2908
J1345-3041
J1345-3104
J1347-2735
J1347-2810
J1348-2856
13:30:32
13:36:08
13:36:59
13:37:56
13:39:08
13:42:05
13:42:21
13:44:03
13:45:30
13:45:20
13:45:12
13:47:37
13:47:45
13:48:38
-32:57:07 V
-29:34:12 A1
-31:19:05 V
-30:35:12 A2
-30:22:10 V
-29:01:21 A2
-30:23:14 V
-32:02:11
-
-29:06:47 V
-30:43:21
-
-30:56:52 V
-27:35:22 V
-28:11:56 A3
-29:00:22 V
selected sample of galaxies, the general result that higher
Hi-mass galaxies can be seen to greater distances is seen
to hold true in blind Hi surveys (e.g. Zwaan et al. 1997 or
Koribalski et al. 2004). The exact form of this dependence
of limiting Hi mass on distance is not used in our analysis
and is thus unimportant for the purposes of this study.
We find that parameters such as absolute magnitude
and surface brightness are correlated with hydrogen mass
(Figures 2 and 3). Thus more luminous galaxies may be
seen over larger volumes and, in a reversal of the situation
in the optical, low surface-brightness galaxies may be seen
over larger volumes than higher surface-brightness galaxies
of the same luminosity due to the anti-correlation between
surface-brightness and the Hi-mass to light ratio (Figure 4)
seen both in our data and in previous studies using optically-
selected samples (e.g.de Blok, McGaugh & van der Hulst,
1996).
In order to make the volumetric corrections for Hi se-
lection effects, we use two different methods, which are de-
scribed below. We have chosen to remove dwarf galaxies
(MHI < 108M⊙) from this analysis for two main reasons:
that the number of low-mass galaxies in our sample is low
and that the volume in which we can see these galaxies in
dominated by the Cen A group. For these reasons, we fo-
cus solely on the more Hi-massive galaxies (MHI > 108M⊙)
where we have reasonable statistics and probe a variety of
environments.
3.1 1/Vmax Weighting
Weighting detections by 1/Vmax, where Vmax is the total
volume in which they could have been found, is well estab-
lished as a means of correcting for ease-of-detection. We use
this here with a completeness limit of 18 mJy in peak flux
(Paper 1) and a maximum distance, due to the bandpass
limit of the Hi survey, of 173 Mpc. This gives us a complete
sample of 67 galaxies with hV /Vmaxi = 0.49 ± 0.04. Once
the dwarfs are removed, we are left with 62 galaxies with
hV /Vmaxi = 0.52 ± 0.04. While 1/Vmax is well understood,
Figure 2. Relationship between Hi mass and absolute magnitude
Figure 3. Relationship between Hi mass and effective surface-
brightness. Cen A group galaxies are shown by solid circles. The
relationship is weaker than for luminosity, but there is a def-
inite trend for lower Hi mass galaxies to have lower surface-
brightnesses: 14 of the 23 galaxies with MHI < 109M⊙ are LSB
galaxies (µe(R) > 23.3 R mag arcsec−2), while, at the high-
mass end, there is only one LSB galaxy out of the sixteen with
MHI > 1010M⊙. This dependence of surface-brightness on Hi
mass means that corrections must be made for Hi selection effects
before the surface-brightness distribution can be determined.
6
R. F. Minchin et al.
Table 3. Hi Mass Functions used in calculating the weighting
(corrected to H0 = 75 km s−1 Mpc−1).
α
-1.30
-1.53
-1.52
-1.51
-1.2
φ⋆
0.0086
0.005
0.0032
0.006
0.006
HI
log M ⋆
9.79
9.88
10.1
9.7
9.8
Reference
Zwaan et al. 2003 (BGC)
Rosenberg & Schneider 2002
Kilborn 2001
Henning et al. 2000
Zwaan et al. 1997
Figure 4. Correlation of effective surface-brightness with Hi mass
to light ratio. Cen A group galaxies are shown by solid circles. The
correlation between µe and log(MHI /LR), shown as a solid line,
has a slope of 1.51 ± 0.16 and a scatter of 0.9 magnitudes. As
the survey detects galaxies by their Hi content, galaxies with low
Hi mass-to-light ratios may be missed, however this survey goes
deep enough to see galaxies down to MHI /LR ≃ 0.05M⊙/L⊙ so
it is unlikely that this will be a significant effect.
it cannot make any correction for the large scale structure,
which could lead to distortions in the results. However the
value of hV /Vmaxi implies that the overall effect of large
scale structure on the sample is probably not large.
3.2 Hi Mass Function Weighting
Our second method is to use an Hi Mass Function (HIMF)
to correct for both ease-of-detection and large scale struc-
ture, as described in Minchin (1999). This method makes
the assumption that our galaxies are drawn from the same
population as a general HIMF, such as that found for the
HIPASS Bright Galaxy Catalogue (BGC) by Zwaan et al.
(2003). Then the volumetric correction that needs to be ap-
plied in order to match the distribution of Hi masses in
HIDEEP with the HIMF can be calculated and applied to
find other quantities, such as the luminosity function and
the surface-brightness distribution. After dwarf galaxies are
excluded, this gives us a sample of 101 galaxies.
This HIMF-weighting cannot be used to construct an Hi
mass function for the HIDEEP galaxies, as it would clearly
just give the same answer as the input HIMF. However, we
can use it to construct the bivariate brightness distribution,
luminosity function and surface-brightness distribution of
galaxies and to investigate how various parameters (e.g. lu-
minosity density) change with surface-brightness. It would
be possible to make a HIMF from the HIDEEP data using
1/Vmax, however we have chosen to use the HIMF of Zwaan
et al. (2003), based on the 1000 galaxies in the HIPASS
BGC. This contains an order of magnitude more galaxies
Figure 5. The surface-brightness distribution formed by correct-
ing with various different Hi Mass Functions. Solid line: HIPASS
Bright Galaxy Catalogue (BGC; Zwaan et al. 2003) as used else-
where in this paper; dotted line: Rosenberg & Schneider (2002);
short-dashed line: Zwaan et al. (1997); long-dashed line: Kilborn
(2001); dot-dashed line: Henning et al. (2000). Error bars are
given for the distribution formed using the BGC HIMF.
than HIDEEP and thus gives a much more accurate mass
function.
HIMF-weighting contains more sources of error than
1/Vmax. The main sources of additional errors are the width
of the bins used in the HIMF and the numbers of galaxies
in each bin. The resulting formal uncertainties are therefore
normally larger than for 1/Vmax, despite the larger sam-
ple size. However, it should be remembered that HIMF-
weighting includes a correction for the large scale structure
which is not factored into either the values or the errors of
the 1/Vmax weighting.
Systematic errors may be introduced by the choice of
the HIMF. In order to gauge the size of these errors, we
have looked at the contribution of LSB galaxies to the total
number density of gas-rich galaxies when calculated with the
HIMFs of Rosenberg & Schneider (2002), Kilborn (2001),
Henning et al. (2000) and Zwaan et al. (1997) (see Table 3 for
a summary). The resulting surface-brightness distributions
are shown in Figure 5.
It can be seen from Figure 5 that there is little dif-
ference in the overall shape of the Surface Brightness Dis-
tributions derived using the different HIMFs, although the
overall density of gas-rich galaxies is significantly reduced if
the HIMF of Zwaan et al. (1997) is used. The contribution
of LSB galaxies as a proportion of all galaxies is therefore
only weakly dependant on the HIMF chosen, with a slight
rise in the proportion for steeper slopes. Within the range of
HIMFs here the proportion of LSB galaxies varies between
59 and 67 per cent of all gas-rich galaxies, with the BGC
HIMF giving 62 per cent. As the statistical error on this
proportion is 37 per cent, it can be seen that the systematic
error due to the HIMF is comparatively small. These sys-
tematic errors are stated in Table 4 as a second error column
to the percentage LSB contribution.
Masters, Haynes, & Giovanelli (2004) have shown that
if a peculiar velocity field model is used to assign distances
to galaxies in the BGC rather than the pure Hubble law used
by Zwaan et al. (2003) then the faint-end slope of the BGC
HIMF steepens from α = −1.3 to −1.4, which is consistent
with the steeper determinations. The HIMF of Zwaan et al.
(1997) is also inconsistent with the other determinations;
this cannot be explained by the method used for assigning
distances but may be due to problems with correctly deter-
mining the survey sensitivity (Schneider, Spitzak & Rosen-
berg 1998). It is most likely, therefore, that if a systematic
error has been introduced by the use of the HIMF, it is that
the faint-end slope we have used is too shallow. The result
of this would be for this paper to slightly underestimate the
contribution of LSB galaxies.
3.3 The Bivariate Brightness Distribution
As luminosity and surface-brightness appear to be correlated
to some degree, the distributions of luminosity and surface-
brightness on their own are less interesting than the bivari-
ate brightness distribution (BBD) -- the joint distribution
in the (MR,µR
e ) plane. The BBD describes the contribution
of galaxies of different luminosities and surface-brightnesses
to the cosmos but is virtually impossible to obtain accu-
rately from an optically-selected sample (Boyce & Phillipps
1995). For instance the largest sample of galaxies, complete
in both surface brightness and luminosity, that can be as-
sembled from the classical optical catalogues numbers less
than 50 (Disney 1999).
Figure 6 shows the BBDs drawn from the uncor-
rected samples, showing the correlation between luminos-
ity and surface-brightness and illustrating the conventional
emphasis on the overwhelming importance of high-surface-
brightness giant galaxies. However these galaxies tend to
have much larger Hi masses and can be seen over much
greater volumes.
The corrected BBDs, showing the true space-density
of galaxies, are given in Figure 7. The HIMF and 1/Vmax
corrections give very similar results. Over a range of seven
magnitudes in luminosity and five in surface-brightness, the
galaxies appear to lie in an evenly populated strip four mag-
nitudes wide in luminosity and two in surface-brightness
that stretches from high-luminosity, high-surface-brightness
to low-luminosity, low-surface-brightness.
The HIMF-weighted BBD is obviously dependent on
the HIMF used to construct it. However all of the HIMFs in
Table 3 give results fairly similar to those shown here -- if a
steeper HIMF is used then the density at low-luminosity, low
surface-brightness is marginally higher while if the shallower
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
7
Figure 6. Uncorrected bivariate brightness distribution of
HIDEEP galaxies. The upper panel shows the 101 galaxies in
the HIMF-weighted sample, the lower panel the 62 galaxies in
the 1/Vmax-weighted sample. The blank areas around the images
indicate where there is no data.
(and lower-density) HIMF of Zwaan et al. (1997) is used then
the density decreases all round, with the density of low-
luminosity, low surface-brightness galaxies falling slightly
more than that of high-luminosity, high surface-brightness
galaxies.
We define LSB galaxies to be those with effective R-
band surface-brightnesses more than 1.5 magnitudes lower
than the peak in the uncorrected R-band effective surface-
brightness distribution of ESO-LV galaxies, i.e. µe(R) >
23.3 mag arcsec−2. This is slightly dimmer than the defi-
nitions used by Impey & Bothun (1997) (µ0(B) > 23) and
by McGaugh (1996) (µ0(B) > 22.75), which are respectively
1.35 and 1.1 magnitudes dimmer than the peak in the uncor-
rected B-band central surface-brightness found by Freeman
(1970). Using our definition, we can set limits on the popu-
lation of giant LSB galaxies as follows.
There is a clear deficiency of high-luminosity, LSB
'Crouching Giant' galaxies (LSB galaxies with LR >
1010L⊙): of the 47 galaxies with LR > 1010L⊙, not one is
an LSB galaxy. By applying the binomial theorem, we can
calculate that the probability of finding no LSB galaxies in
a sample of 47 is less than 0.05 if LSB galaxies make up
more than 6 per cent of the population. We can therefore
rule out that LSB galaxies make up more than 6 per cent
8
R. F. Minchin et al.
Figure 7. The bivariate brightness distribution (BBD) of Hi-selected galaxies. The panels to the
left show the BBD formed using HIMF-weighting, as described above, while the panels to the
right show the BBD formed using 1/Vmax weighting. The central panels give the best-estimate
of the BBD while the top panels show the BBD + 1σ in each bin and the bottom panels show
the BBD - 1σ in each bin.
of the high-luminosity, gas-rich population with 95 per cent
confidence.
Hi massive galaxies which are LSB galaxies of 26 per cent
at the 95 per cent confidence level.
Of the sixteen Hi-massive (MHI > 1010M⊙) galaxies
found in HIDEEP, one (ESO 383-G059), is an LSB galaxy
with µR
e = 23.8 Rµ -- this galaxy has a high Hi mass despite
not having a high optical (R-band) luminosity. By the same
method as above, we can place a limit on the proportion of
There is little evidence that the unpopulated regions at
high-luminosity, low surface-brightness and low-luminosity,
high surface-brightness are due to the Hi mass limits of the
survey (imposed by the down-turn in the Hi mass function at
high MHI and by small volumes, and the cut at 108M⊙, at
low MHI ). Only one of the galaxies with MHI > 1010M⊙ is
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
9
Figure 8. Weighted luminosity function of HIDEEP galaxies.
Points weighted by the HIMF are shown as open circles (offset
for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer), points weighted by 1/Vmax are
shown as solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag brighter).
The LF of Blanton et al. (2001, α = −1.20 ± 0.03) is shown as a
dashed line.
Figure 9. Corrected surface-brightness distribution of HIDEEP
galaxies. This is consistent with a flat or slowly rising surface-
brightness distribution at lower surface-brightnesses and a down-
turn at the bright end. The HIMF-weighted points are indicated
by open circles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the
1/Vmax-weighted points by solid triangles (offset for clarity by
0.1 mag brighter).
a low surface-brightness galaxy, as previously noted, and the
high-mass galaxies are not spread along the high-luminosity
edge of the populated region as would be expected if this
edge were due to an Hi-mass selection effect. Similarly, only
one of the galaxies in the lowest mass range included in
the sample (108.5M⊙ > MHI > 108M⊙) is a high surface-
brightness galaxy (NGC 5253); these galaxies are not spread
along the low-luminosity edge of the populated region.
The dwarf galaxies that were removed from the sample
(MHI < 108M⊙) fall in the surface-brightness range 22.5
-- 24.5 R mag arcsec−2 and in the R magnitude range -13
-- -18, generally at a lower luminosity than is 'normal' for
their surface-brightness. All but one of these galaxies (all in
the 1/Vmax sample) lie in the Centaurus A group and are
not, therefore, representative of a variety of environments
-- the one dwarf that is not in the Cen A group (HIDEEP
J1337-3118) lies well within the normal range of luminos-
ity for its surface-brightness, while the higher-mass galaxy
NGC 5253, which also lies in the Cen A group, is the galaxy
most under-luminous for its surface-brightness in the sam-
ple. Including these dwarf galaxies in the BBD would not
populate in the low-luminosity, high surface-brightness re-
gion, but would extend the BBD to lower luminosities at
intermediate and low surface-brightnesses.
By collapsing the BBD along the surface-brightness
axis, we can form the optical Luminosity Function (LF)
which is shown in Figure 8. This is compared to the LF
obtained by Blanton et al. (2001) from Sloan Digital Sky
Survey (SDSS) commissioning data. It can be seen that both
the HIMF and 1/Vmax determinations are fairly consistent
with the SDSS luminosity function, although M⋆ appears to
be marginally brighter in our data - this could be due to
uncertainties in the conversion between r⋆, which Blanton
et al. use, and R. The 1/Vmax weighting gives a faint-end
(MR > −21.5) slope of α = −1.40 ± 0.14 and the HIMF-
weighting gives α = −1.27 ± 0.16.
Figure 9 displays the surface-brightness distribution
(SBD), formed by collapsing the BBD along the luminosity
axis. This is consistent with optical determinations such as
Davies (1990) and de Jong (1996a). The effect of large scale
structure on 1/Vmax can be seen in the brightest bin. Both
of the galaxies in this bin lie in the close by Cen A group and
their contribution to the density is therefore over-estimated
by this method. However, in general the 1/Vmax and HIMF-
weighted points are in good agreement, giving confidence
that large scale structure is not overly affecting the 1/Vmax
data.
Overall, it can be seen that optical surveys give very
similar results to this survey. This implies that 21-cm sur-
veys do not uncover any 'hidden' population of extremely
low surface-brightness galaxies that is missed by optical sur-
veys. If such a population does exist in significant numbers,
it must be composed primarily of galaxies with neutral gas
masses lower than 108M⊙.
This is not to say, however, that LSB galaxies do not
make up a significant population. The SBD derived from
weighting by the BGC HIMF implies that LSB galaxies
make up 62 ± 37 per cent of the total population of galaxies
with MHI > 108M⊙, or 51 ± 20 per cent for 1/Vmax weight-
ing. Even with the large errors on these estimates, it is clear
that a large number of galaxies fall into our definition of low
surface-brightness. In the next section we investigate what
contribution these LSB galaxies make to the Universe.
10
R. F. Minchin et al.
Figure 10. Luminosity density -- surface-brightness distribution
for HIDEEP galaxies. The luminosity density can be seen to fall
sharply either side of a peak near the Freeman-law value. The
HIMF-weighted points are indicated by open circles (offset for
clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the 1/Vmax-weighted points by
solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag brighter).
4 THE COSMOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF
LOW SURFACE-BRIGHTNESS GALAXIES
As LSB galaxies have been proposed as repositories for some
of the missing baryons (e.g. Impey & Bothun 1997) and may
also contain large quantities of dark matter, it is important
to make an estimate of how much they actually contribute to
the Universe. It is possible to do this from our data, subject
to the provisos that Hi-poor galaxies would not be found
at 21-cm (e.g. elliptical galaxies) and that we do not detect
sufficient numbers of dwarf galaxies (MHI < 108M⊙) to say
anything about their contribution. We compare the contri-
bution of the LSB galaxies in our sample to the total contri-
bution of Hi-rich galaxies using the weightings described in
Section 3 to correct the numbers in each surface-brightness
bin.
To compare the contribution to the luminosity-density
made by galaxies of different surface-brightnesses we need to
weight the surface-brightness distribution in Figure 9 with
the luminosities of the galaxies. When this is done we obtain
Figure 10 which shows that the luminosity density is sharply
peaked near the Freeman-law value. Gas-rich LSB galaxies
do not appear to emit much light: when analysed with the
HIMF-weighting, they contribute 6.7 ± 2.8 per cent of the
total luminosity-density of all gas-rich galaxies, or 6.5 ± 2.4
per cent according to the 1/Vmax analysis. This is very sim-
ilar to the 7.3 ± 3.6 per cent contribution for LSB galaxies
found by Driver (1999) for local (0.3 < z < 0.5) galaxies
in the Hubble Deep Field. The main source of errors in our
determination is Poisson noise in the surface-brightness bins
but there is also a contribution due to the uncertainty on
the luminosity of the sources and, for the Hi mass function
Figure 11. Neutral hydrogen density -- surface-brightness dis-
tribution for HIDEEP galaxies. It can be seen that this is con-
sistent with a slowly falling distribution towards lower surface-
brightnesses and a much steeper fall-off towards higher surface-
brightnesses, similar in shape to the surface-brightness distribu-
tion. The HIMF-weighted points are indicated by open circles
(offset for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the 1/Vmax-weighted
points by solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag brighter).
weighting, due to the width of the mass bins and the number
of galaxies in each bin.
Similarly the contribution of LSB galaxies to the Hi
content as a whole can be calculated and is shown in Figure
11. This amounts to 32 ± 11 per cent of all Hi with HIMF-
weighting, or 27 ± 7 per cent with 1/Vmax weighting.
This is inconsistent, at the 1σ level, with the determi-
nation of Zwaan et al. (2003) that LSB galaxies contribute
only 15 per cent to the total Hi mass density. That deter-
mination should, however, be treated as a lower limit. The
sample of Zwaan et al., unlike our sample, did not have com-
plete optical data -- surface-brightnesses were only available
for 600 out of the 1000 galaxies. When corrections for this
were made, Zwaan et al. assumed that the incompleteness
in the optical data was unrelated to surface-brightness. It
is far more likely that the LSB galaxies' data were more
incomplete than the HSB galaxies', which could raise the
contribution of LSB galaxies considerably.
The baryonic content of the galaxies was calculated fol-
lowing the method of McGaugh et al. (2000), adding the
mass of the stars and the gas together to get a total bary-
onic mass for the galaxy:
Mbary = 1.4MHI + ΥX
⋆ LX
(1)
where ΥX
⋆ is the stellar mass to light ratio in the band used,
and LX is the luminosity in that band. For our R-band data,
ΥR
⋆ has been estimated, as in McGaugh et al., using the
model of de Jong (1996b) for a 12 Gyr old, solar metallicity
stellar population with a constant star formation rate and
a Salpeter initial mass function, corrected to R-band using
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
11
Figure 12. Baryon density -- surface-brightness distribution for
HIDEEP galaxies. It can be seen that the greatest contribution
to the baryon density is made by Freeman-law galaxies around
µ⋆
e , with the density falling of towards lower and higher surface-
brightnesses. The HIMF-weighted points are indicated by open
circles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the 1/Vmax-
weighted points by solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag
brighter).
Figure 13. Mass density -- surface-brightness distribution for
HIDEEP galaxies. The greatest contribution is made by Freeman-
law galaxies µ⋆
e , however the distribution seems fairly flat towards
lower surface-brightnesses while it falls off towards higher surface-
brightnesses. The HIMF-weighted points are indicated by open
circles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the 1/Vmax-
weighted points by solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag
brighter).
the average colours in that paper (also used by McGaugh
et al. for their correction to H-band). This gives a value of
ΥR
⋆ ≈ 1.4, which we have used in our calculations.
The relative contribution of LSB galaxies to the total
baryon density is then calculated to be 9.3± 3.6 per cent us-
ing HIMF-weighting or 8.7±2.9 per cent using 1/Vmax. This
is only marginally higher than the contribution to the lumi-
nosity, reflecting that the contribution to Hi mass density
is basically flat and so only slightly affects the shape of the
density distribution when the two are added together. LSB
galaxies do have more of their baryons in the form of gas,
as shown in the relationship between MHI /L and surface-
brightness, but this is outweighed by their much lower lumi-
nosities.
If, in the usual way, we estimate the dynamical masses
of HIDEEP galaxies using
Mdyn =
RHI × (∆V0)2
G
(2)
where we follow Paper 1 in assuming rHI ≃ 5re and ∆V0 is
the inclination-corrected velocity width (∆V0 = ∆V / sin i)
then we arrive at the relative contribution of galaxies of var-
ious surface-brightnesses shown in Figure 13. For this calcu-
lation, only those galaxies with reliable inclinations in the
range 45◦ < i < 80◦ were used. This leaves 57 galaxies in
the HIMF-weighted sample and 38 in the 1/Vmax-weighted
sample. The share due to LSB galaxies is, although uncer-
tain, relatively high at 22± 10 per cent for HIMF-weighting
or 21 ± 12 per cent for 1/Vmax-weighting. This is in keeping
with other studies that have shown that LSB galaxies con-
tain proportionally more dark matter than normal galaxies.
Since the cross-sections of large, luminous galaxies can
by no means explain the prevalence of quasar absorption line
systems (QSOALS) it has been suggested that LSB galax-
ies might be responsible (e.g. Phillipps et al. 1993, Linder
1998; 2000) though this has proved controversial (e.g. Chen
et al. 1998). If we assume that the absorption cross-sections
of our galaxies are proportional to their effective areas (e.g.
the area enclosed by the effective radius) then we can make
an estimate of the contribution of LSB galaxies to this cross-
section. Figure 14 shows the cross-sectional area distribution
of our galaxies with surface-brightness (corrected to an in-
clination of 60◦), formed in the same way as the above plots
This gives the contribution of LSB galaxies to the cross-
section to be 39 ± 15 per cent using the HIMF-weighting
and 42 ± 22 per cent using 1/Vmax-weighting.
Their high cross-section suggests that LSB galaxies are
likely to form a significant fraction of the absorbers where
galaxies themselves are responsible for QSOALS, as they
might be in the case of damped Lyman-α systems. This is
born out by recent observations where LSB galaxies, rather
than HSB galaxies with immense halos, appear to be the
more likely absorbers (Turnshek et al. 2001; Bowen, Tripp
& Jenkins 2001).
Table 4 summarises the findings of this section. It can
be seen that LSB galaxies make up over half of all gas-rich
galaxies, yet have less than 10 per cent of the luminosity den-
sity. The relationship between dynamical M/L and surface-
brightness means that luminosity is a biased indicator of
the cosmological significance of LSB galaxies. Similarly, the
higher Hi mass-to-light ratios of LSB galaxies means that
12
R. F. Minchin et al.
Table 4. Summary of the measured contribution of HSB and LSB galaxies to the density of various quantities
in gas-rich galaxies. These are the actual measured densities in the HIDEEP survey, for the SBDs constructed
using weighting by the HIMF of Zwaan et al. (2003) and using 1/Vmax weighting. Possibly systematic errors due
to the selection of the HIMF, calculated by comparing the results of the Zwaan et al. (2003) HIMF with other
published HIMFs as described earlier, are given as a second error to the percentage LSB contribution.
Quantity
Weighting Ngal HSB contribution
LSB contribution
Percentage LSB contribution
HIMF
1/Vmax
Number density
(10−2 galaxies Mpc−3)
Neutral Hydrogen density HIMF
(107M⊙ Mpc−3)
Luminosity density
(107L⊙ Mpc−3)
Baryon density
(107M⊙ Mpc−3)
Mass density
(107M⊙ Mpc−3)
Area density
(10−1 kpc2 Mpc−3)
1/Vmax
HIMF
1/Vmax
HIMF
1/Vmax
HIMF
1/Vmax
HIMF
1/Vmax
101
62
101
62
101
62
101
62
57
38
101
62
1.8 ± 0.7
2.9 ± 1.1
3.7 ± 0.7
5.7 ± 1.2
45 ± 13
57 ± 13
68 ± 17
88 ± 20
280 ± 80
570 ± 170
5.4 ± 1.2
7.4 ± 1.7
3.0 ± 1.5
3.0 ± 0.9
1.8 ± 0.5
2.1 ± 0.5
3.2 ± 1.0
3.9 ± 1.2
6.9 ± 2.1
8 ± 2
77 ± 31
150 ± 78
3.4 ± 1.2
5.4 ± 2.5
62 ± 37 +5
−3
51 ± 20
32 ± 11 +10
−3
27 ± 7
7 ± 3 +1
−1
7 ± 2
9 ± 4 +2
−1
9 ± 3
22 ± 10 +4
−2
21 ± 12
39 ± 15 +8
−3
42 ± 22
than this, while elliptical galaxies are too gas-poor to be de-
tected. Most dwarf galaxies have low surface-brightnesses,
therefore if these were included it is likely that the total
contributions from LSB galaxies would rise. These numbers
should therefore be seen as lower estimates for the total con-
tribution of LSB galaxies.
5 CONCLUSIONS
This survey does not find any LSB 'Crouching Giant' galax-
ies, such as Malin 1. From this, we can rule out LSB galaxies
making up more that 6 per cent of the population of lumi-
nous (LR > 1010L⊙) galaxies. Indeed, there does seem to
be a minimum surface-brightness at every magnitude level
given approximately by µe,min = 45 + MR (Figure 7). To
higher surface-brightnesses, galaxies seem to populate fairly
evenly a band approximately 4 magnitudes wide in luminos-
ity and 2 in surface-brightness. Beyond this, high surface-
brightness, low-luminosity galaxies also appear to be rare
in the gas-rich population. The populated band broadens
slightly towards lower luminosities, giving it an approximate
slope of Σ ∝ L0.7 (where Σ is surface brightness in luminos-
ity per unit area and L is the total luminosity). From this,
it can be calculated that the radius, R, is related to the
surface-brightness as R ∝ Σ0.2, i.e. the radius only changes
very slightly with surface-brightness.
Once volumetric corrections are made, the number
of galaxies per unit volume is flat as we go to lower
surface-brightnesses. Even within the surface-brightness
limit reached by this survey, LSB galaxies contribute over
half of the number density of galaxies. Furthermore, we find
that LSB galaxies contribute approximately 30 per cent
of the neutral-hydrogen density, twice the lower limit set
by Zwaan et al. (2003). LSB galaxies may also contribute
around 20 per cent of the total mass density (again with
large errors), but only 7 per cent of the luminosity-density.
Overall, Hi-rich LSB galaxies do not appear to con-
tribute much to the Universe. However, the cross-section
to QSOALS made by LSB galaxies, which is around 40 per
cent of the total cross-section, is disproportionate to their
luminosity or baryonic content. This implies that LSB galax-
Figure 14. Cross-sectional area density against
surface-
brightness for HIDEEP galaxies. This is fairly flat, with a fall
off towards higher surface-brightnesses (the brightest point of the
1/Vmax distribution is, as noted earlier, affected by large scale
structure). This implies that LSB galaxies will make a significant
contribution to QSO absorption lines in so far as these are caused
by galaxies. The HIMF-weighted points are indicated by open
circles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag dimmer) and the 1/Vmax-
weighted points by solid triangles (offset for clarity by 0.1 mag
brighter).
they have more gas than would be indicated by their light
on a straight extrapolation of MHI /L from Freeman-law
galaxies. The relatively larger sizes of LSB galaxies means
that their contribution to cross-sectional area, around 40
per cent, is much higher than would be expected from their
luminosity or even from their Hi mass.
The totals given here are only for galaxies with MHI >
108M⊙. These are almost entirely spiral galaxies. Dwarf
galaxies, even gas-rich ones, tend to have lower gas masses
ies could contribute substantially to those QSOALS where
galaxies are the absorbers.
Future work in progress will see an order of magnitude
larger sample assembled from the overlap between HIPASS
and the SDSS. This will give not only an increase in the
significance of the results but will also give 5-colour op-
tical data, thus greatly extending our knowledge of Hi-
selected galaxies. A larger sample of Hi-selected samples
from the SDSS may be assembled in the medium term by
the proposed ALFALFA drift-scan survey with the Arecibo
L-band Feed Array or in the longer term by surveys carried
out with the Square Kilometre Array. However, as neither
HIPASS nor ALFALFA reach column-density levels as low
as HIDEEP it is unlikely that they will turn up any sig-
nificant population of extremely LSB galaxies that we have
missed.
This is not to say that extremely LSB galaxies do not
exist, just that if they do make up a significant population
then the amount of Hi they contain must be small. In order
to search for these galaxies, techniques other than Hi sur-
veys will be necessary. The optical channel available to us
on the ground is fundamentally unsuited to looking for LSB
galaxies, but a quite modest switch in wavelengths to either
side of the solar peak, which is possible from space, could
yield dramatic results. O'Connell (1987) has discussed the
idea of using UV wavelengths, while in the H-band at 1.6 µm
the contrast between the Sun's scattered zodiacal spectrum
and the light from red stars in LSB galaxies could be two or-
ders of magnitude higher than the contrast from the ground.
Wide-field near-IR cameras, such as the WFC-3 instrument
currently awaiting shipment to the HST, will be needed to
exploit this window which is, in principle, capable of reveal-
ing galaxies 7 magnitudes lower in surface-brightness than
we can detect from the ground.
The authors would like to thank Lister Staveley-Smith,
Tony Fairall, David Barnes, Jon Davies and Suzanne
Linder for useful discussions. RFM, WJGdeB and PJB
acknowledge the support of PPARC. BGK acknowledges
the support of the Australian Research Council. The
authors would also like to thank the staff of the CSIRO
Parkes and Narrabri observatories, of the NRAO Ar-
ray Operations Center and of the ANU Siding Spring
Observatory for their help with observations. We ac-
knowledge PPARC grant GR/K/28237 to MJD towards
the construction of the multibeam system and PPARC
grants
PPA/G/S/1998/00620,
PPA/G/S/2002/00053 and PPA/G/S/2003/00085 to MJD
towards its operation. We would particularly like to thank
the anonymous referee for an extremely helpful report.
PPA/G/S/1998/00543,
This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Ex-
tragalactic Database (NED) which is operated by the Jet
Propulsion Laboratory, Caltech, under agreement with the
National Aeronautics and Space Administration. This re-
search has also made use of the Digitised Sky Survey, pro-
duced at the Space Telescope Science Institute under US
Government Grant NAG W-2166 and of NASA's Astro-
physics Data System Bibliographic Services
REFERENCES
Bertins E., Arnouts S., 1996, A&AS, 117, 393
Cosmological Significance of LSB galaxies
13
Bland-Hawthorn J., Shopbell P. L., Malin D. F., 1993, AJ, 106,
2154
Blanton M. R. et al. 2001, AJ, 121, 2358
Bowen D. V., Tripp T. M., Jenkins E. B., 2001, AJ, 121, 1456
Boyce P. J., Phillipps S., 1995,A&A, 296, 26
Briggs F. H., Rao S., 1993, ApJ, 417, 494
Chen H.-W., Lanzetta K. M., Webb J. K., Barcons X., 1998, ApJ,
498, 77
Churchill C. W., Le Brun V., 1998, ApJ, 499, 677
Davies J. I., 1990, MNRAS, 244, 8
de Blok W. J. G., McGaugh S. S., van der Hulst J. M., 1996,
MNRAS, 283, 18
de Jong R. S., 1996a, A&A, 313, 45
de Jong R. S., 1996b, A&A, 313, 377
Disney M. J., 1976, Nature, 263, 573
Disney M. J., 1999, in Davies J. I., Impey C., Phillipps S., eds,
ASP Conf. Ser. 170, The Low Surface Brightness Universe,
ASP, San Francisco, p. 9
Disney M. J., Phillipps, S., 1983, MNRAS, 205, 1253
Driver S. P., 1999, ApJ, 576, L69
Freeman K. C., 1970, AJ, 160, 811
Fukugita M., Hogan C. J., Peebles P. J. E., 1998, ApJ, 503, 518
Graham A. W., de Blok W. J. G., 2001, ApJ, 556, 177
Hambly N. C., MacGillivray H. T., Read M. A., Tritton S. B.,
Thomson E. B., Kelly B. D., Morgan D. H., Smith R. E.,
Driver S. P., Williamson J., Parker Q. A., Hawkins M. R. S.,
Williams P. M., Lawrence A., 2001, MNRAS, 326, 1279
Henning P. A., Staveley-Smith L., Ekers R. D., Green A. J.,
Haynes R. F., Juraszek S., Kesteven M. J., Koribalski B.,
Kraan-Korteweg R. C., Price R. M., Sadler E. M., Schroder
A., 2000, AJ, 119, 2686
Impey C. D., Bothun G. D., 1997, ARA&A, 35, 367
Kilborn V. A., 2001, PhD Thesis, University of Melbourne
Koribalski, B. S. et al., 2004, AJ, 128, 16
Kron R. G., 1980, ApJS, 43, 305
Lauberts A., Valentijn E.A., 1989, The Surface Photometry Cat-
alogue of the ESO-Uppsala Galaxies, ESO, Garching
Linder S. M., 1998, ApJ, 495, 637
Linder S. M., 2000, ApJ, 529, 644
McGaugh S. S., 1996, MNRAS, 280, 337
McGaugh S. S., Schombert J. M., Bothun G. D., de Blok W. J.
G., 2000, ApJ, 533, 99
Maddox S. J., Efstathiou G., Sutherland W. J., 1990, MNRAS,
246, 433
Masters K .L., Haynes M. P., Giovanelli, R., 2004, ApJL, accepted
Minchin R. F., 1999, PASA, 16, 12
Minchin R. F. et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 787 (Paper 1)
O'Connell R., 1987, AJ, 94, 867
Parker Q. A., Malin D. F., 1999, PASA, 16, 288
Phillipps S., Disney M. J., Davies J. I. 1993, MNRAS, 260, 453
Rosenberg J. L., Schneider S. E., 2002, ApJ, 567, 247
Schlegel D. J., Finkbeiner D. P., Davis M., 1998, ApJ, 500, 525
Schneider S. E., Spitzak J. G., Rosenberg J. L., 1998, ApJ, 507,
9
Thim F., Tammann G. A., Saha A., Dolphin A., Sandage A.,
Tolstoy E., Labhardt L., 2003, ApJ, 590, 256
Turnshek D. A., Rao S., Nestor D., Lane W., Monier E., Bergeron
J., Smette A., 2001, ApJ, 553, 288
Zwaan M. A., van der Hulst J. M., de Blok W. J. G., McGaugh
S. S., 1995, MNRAS, 273, L35
Zwaan M. A., Briggs F. H., Sprayberry D., Sorar E., 1997, ApJ,
490, 173
Zwaan M. A. et al. 2003, MNRAS, 125, 2842
|
0804.1363 | 2 | 0804 | 2008-07-17T20:23:05 | The Accuracy of Morphological Decomposition of Active Galactic Nucleus Host Galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | In order to assess the accuracy with which we can determine the morphologies of AGN host galaxies, we have simulated more than 50,000 ACS images of galaxies with z < 1.25, using image and noise properties appropriate for the GOODS survey. We test the effect of central point-source brightness on host galaxy parameter recovery with a set of simulated AGN host galaxies made by adding point sources to the centers of normal galaxies. We extend this analysis and also quantify the recovery of intrinsic morphological parameters of AGN host galaxies with a set of fully simulated inactive and AGN host galaxies.
We can reliably separate good from poor fit results using a combination of reasonable error cuts, in the regime where L_{host}:L_{PS} > 1:4. We give quantitative estimates of parameter errors as a function of host-to-point-source ratio. In general, we separate host and point-source magnitudes reliably at all redshifts; point sources are well recovered more than 90% of the time, although spurious detection of central point sources can be as high as 25% for bulge-dominated sources. We find a general correlation between Sersic index and intrinsic bulge-to-total ratio, such that a host galaxy with Sersic n < 1.5 generally has at least 80% of its light from a disk component. Likewise, "bulge-dominated" galaxies with n > 4 typically derive at least 70% of their total host galaxy light from a bulge, but this number can be as low as 55%. Single-component Sersic fits to an AGN host galaxy are statistically very reliable to z < 1.25 (for ACS survey data like ours). In contrast, two-component fits involving separate bulge and disk components tend to over-estimate the bulge fraction by ~10%, with uncertainty of order 50%. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Accepted for publication in Ap. J.
The Accuracy of Morphological Decomposition of AGN Host
Galaxies
B. D. Simmons and C. M. Urry
Astronomy Department, Yale University, New Haven, CT USA
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
In order to assess the accuracy with which we can determine the morpholo-
gies of AGN host galaxies, we have simulated more than 50,000 ACS images
of galaxies with z < 1.25, using image and noise properties appropriate for the
GOODS survey. We test the effect of central point-source brightness on host
galaxy parameter recovery with a set of simulated AGN host galaxies made by
adding point sources to the centers of normal galaxies. We extend this analysis
and also quantify the recovery of intrinsic morphological parameters of AGN host
galaxies with a set of fully simulated inactive and AGN host galaxies.
We can reliably separate good from poor fit results using a combination of
reasonable error cuts, in the regime where (Lhost/LPS) > 1 : 4. We give quan-
titative estimates of parameter errors as a function of host-to-point-source ratio.
In general, we separate host and point-source magnitudes reliably at all redshifts;
point sources are well recovered more than 90% of the time, although spurious
detection of central point sources can be as high as 25% for bulge-dominated
sources. We find a general correlation between S´ersic index and intrinsic bulge-
to-total ratio, such that a host galaxy with S´ersic n < 1.5 generally has at least
80% of its light from a disk component. Likewise, "bulge-dominated" galaxies
with n > 4 typically derive at least 70% of their total host galaxy light from a
bulge, but this number can be as low as 55%. Single-component S´ersic fits to
an AGN host galaxy are statistically very reliable to z < 1.25 (for ACS survey
data like ours). In contrast, two-component fits involving separate bulge and disk
components tend to over-estimate the bulge fraction by ∼ 10%, with uncertainty
of order 50%.
Subject headings: methods: data analysis -- galaxies: active -- galaxies: nuclei
-- galaxies: bulges -- galaxies: fundamental parameters
-- 2 --
1.
Introduction
Morphological analysis of two-dimensional light profiles of galaxies in large data surveys
provides detailed information about galaxy populations and their evolution (e.g., Simard et al.
1999; Ravindranath et al. 2004; Jogee et al. 2004; Sheth et al. 2008). Simulations of both
large and small galaxy samples show that two-dimensional parametric and non-parametric
morphological analysis of normal galaxies is extremely robust (Marleau & Simard 1998;
Graham 2001; Conselice 2003; Trujillo & Aguerri 2004; Haussler et al. 2007).
Studies of active galactic nucleus (AGN) host galaxies give us the opportunity to study
not just the galaxies themselves, but also the well-established connection between galaxies
and central supermassive black holes (Kormendy & Richstone 1995; Magorrian et al. 1998;
Ferrarese & Merritt 2000; Gebhardt et al. 2000; McLure & Dunlop 2002; Marconi & Hunt
2003).
In cases where central black hole masses are independently determined, accurate
decompositions of AGN host galaxies from their central point-source light contributions
allow for the direct study of how galaxy light distribution relates to black hole properties.
Alternatively, when time-intensive observations of black hole mass are not available, we can
use established bulge-black hole relations to determine the black hole masses from bulge
luminosities.
However, two-dimensional morphological fitting of AGN host galaxies is more compli-
cated than that of "normal" (or "inactive") galaxies because of the presence of a central point
source, which is often quite bright. In order to extract host galaxy properties from a source
comprised of a host plus a central AGN, spatial resolution is critical. Thus the Advanced
Camera for Surveys (ACS) on the Hubble Space Telescope (HST ) is the instrument of choice
for many AGN host galaxy studies to date (S´anchez et al. 2004; Alonso-Herrero et al. 2008;
Ballo et al. 2007).
Of the large multi-wavelength surveys currently available, the Great Observatories Ori-
gins Deep Survey (GOODS; Giavalisco et al. 2004) provides some of the deepest multicolor
ACS data. AGN identification is possible because of deep X-ray imaging with Chandra,
as well as ground-based optical and infrared spectroscopic follow up. Spitzer data provide
additional information on total light but insufficient spatial resolution to separate the galaxy
from the active nucleus. We performed detailed morphological analysis on the GOODS ACS
data set using GALFIT (Peng et al. 2002), the results of which are presented in a forthcom-
ing paper (B. D. Simmons et al. 2008, in preparation, hereafter S08). In order to understand
the accuracy of those results -- in particular, to probe the well-known effects of surface bright-
ness dimming and dependence of physical resolution on redshift in the presence of a central
point source whose size does not change with redshift -- extensive simulations of host galaxy
morphology are required.
-- 3 --
Previously, S´anchez et al. (2004) simulated 1880 single-component host galaxies with
point sources fainter than the host galaxy. Here we present a full treatment of over 50,000
simulated AGN host galaxies in the redshift range 0.1 < z < 1.1, with both single-component
and two-component bulge-plus-disk morphologies, and central point sources that are both
brighter and fainter than the host galaxy. Results of these simulations are intended to inform
data analysis of AGN host morphologies, to better infer intrinsic host galaxy shapes from
fitted morphological parameters in the presence of a central point source.
We discuss the data from which we draw our noise properties and simulated sample in
Section 2. The detailed fit procedures and the simulation parameter space are presented in
Section 3, and we assess the ability of our fitting procedure to recover accurate host galaxy
and point-source parameters from GOODS-like images of AGN host galaxies in Section 4.
2. Data
2.1. HST ACS Data
The GOODS fields each cover an area of approximately 10′ × 16′ with a total of 398
HST orbits in both fields. The ACS has a resolution of 0′′.05 pixel−1, and observations were
taken in the F435W, F606W, F775W, and F850LP ACS bands, hereafter referred to as B,
V , I, and z ′, respectively. Data acquisition and reduction are detailed in Giavalisco et al.
(2004) and Koekemoer et al. (2002). Each of the five epochs of data was processed via
the basic ACS pipeline and a further processing task called multidrizzle, which finds an
astrometric solution for all 5 epochs in order to correct for geometric distortion, and at the
same time removes cosmic rays from the image (Koekemoer et al. 2002). The final images
have resolution of 0′′.03 pixel−1, and the magnitude limits for extended sources are B < 28.4
mag, V < 28.4 mag, I < 27.7 mag, and z < 27.3 mag.
From the reduced data, we randomly selected 450 inactive galaxies with stellarity class
less than 0.8 (i.e., objects that are not point sources) and magnitude z ′ < 24.0 mag for
use in those of our simulations that include real data (§3.3). Since the majority of AGN
host galaxies selected for morphological analysis in current surveys using HST have redshifts
such that their I-band data lie in the rest-frame B band (0.575 < z < 0.9), we performed
simulations using the I-band images and noise properties.
-- 4 --
2.2. Noise Properties
For fully simulated galaxies (described in §3.4), noise appropriate to the GOODS-ACS
fields was added. The task of simulating the noise in the GOODS-ACS fields is complicated
by the dithering process, which correlates the noise among nearby pixels. We therefore use
actual noise pixels (i.e., source-free pixels) from the final GOODS-N and GOODS-S images
rather than statistical models. We sampled 150 sub-sections of the GOODS images that
contained no sources, 75 in the North field and 75 in the South, for a total of over 2.5 million
noise pixels. Each of these sub-sections was cut into tiles of size 50 × 50 pixels; this resulted
in 1042 tiles. These were then used to create 500 noise images of the same size as our data
images by arranging random mosaics of the 50 × 50 noise tiles. We have verified that these
new noise mosaics have the same overall noise properties (distribution of pixel intensities)
as the original noise-only subsections of the GOODS images (Figure 1).
We also tested noise mosaics created from 10×10 tiles of background noise but found that
the distribution of pixel intensities was shifted compared to the correlated noise properties
of the dithered ACS images. We thus used only the 50 × 50 pixel noise images to create our
final noise mosaics. The noise value distributions of the 50 × 50 and 10 × 10 noise mosaics
are compared to the actual GOODS noise distribution in Figure 1.
3. Creation and Morphological Fitting of Simulated Samples
We performed two distinct sets of simulations to test the accuracy of derived morpho-
logical parameters. First, we used a sample of 450 real galaxies from the GOODS fields
and added point sources to their centers. This allowed us to test the ability of GALFIT
to extract point sources from the centers of real galaxies.
It also informed our choice of
parameters and galaxy types for the second, more extensive, set of simulations. In the latter
set of simulations, we created a sample of 12,592 completely simulated GOODS galaxies,
in order to additionally test the recovery of a wide range of host galaxy parameters. We
fitted all of our simulated galaxies with our batch-fitting algorithm (described below). We
also simulated the redshifting of these galaxies to quantify redshift-dependent effects, and
we added noise taken directly from real GOODS data.
3.1. Fit Procedure
We performed morphological analysis in two dimensions using GALFIT, which can
simultaneously fit an arbitrary number of components to an image (Peng et al. 2002). The
-- 5 --
Fig. 1. -- Histograms of pixel intensities for GOODS noise (solid), noise mosaics using a
50 × 50-pixel sampling of the GOODS noise (dashed), and using a 10 × 10-pixel sampling
of the GOODS noise (blue, dot-dashed). The histogram for the mosaic using 10 × 10-pixel
tiles is significantly different from the intrinsic noise distribution. The distribution of pixel
intensity of the 50 × 50 noise mosaic is nearly indistinguishable from that of the intrinsic
GOODS noise distribution.
-- 6 --
program uses a χ2 minimization method to determine the best-fit parameters. We used the
S´ersic profile, which models the light distribution of a galaxy as an exponential function
with a variable half-light radius, re, and an exponential parameter, n, called the S´ersic index
(S´ersic 1968). When n is fixed at a value of 1, the S´ersic profile is equivalent to an exponential
disk; when n = 4, the S´ersic profile is equivalent to a de Vaucouleurs bulge. Each of our
simulated galaxies was fitted twice: once using a single S´ersic function with a variable index,
and once with two S´ersic functions with fixed n = 4 and n = 1 (bulge + disk). We also
simultaneously fitted point-source (PS) components using the point-spread function (PSF)
of the data, determination of which is based on GOODS field stars and is described in S08.
We developed a batch-fitting algorithm to fit AGN host galaxies in GALFIT (described
in detail in S08), which we use here on our simulated galaxies. The batch-fitting algorithm
uses a series of initial guesses to execute a first-pass fit of the central region of each AGN host
galaxy, fitting the individual centroid positions of each component (S´ersic plus point source,
or de Vaucouleurs bulge plus exponential disk plus point source). The second fit iteration
zooms out to include the full extended galaxy and fits the central point-source magnitude and
AGN host galaxy parameters (S´ersic index or bulge/disk decomposition, half-light radius,
axial ratio, etc.). Finally, a third iteration is performed where all parameters are allowed to
vary (except n in cases of a bulge + disk fit).
It is important to note that, while these simulations include thousands of AGN host
galaxies, even the largest (current) galaxy surveys using ACS data provide no more than
hundreds of AGN host galaxies that can be reasonably fitted with GALFIT. We can therefore
(as in S08) follow up the batch fits by hand, using the results of the batch-mode fitting as
initial guesses to further constrain the results for each AGN host galaxy. Due to the size of
the simulated galaxy sample in this paper, we did not do this final hand-fitting step. Thus
our conclusions about the fraction of cases for which accurate morphological parameters are
recovered should be considered conservative when compared to a sample of galaxies whose
fits are adjusted and verified individually.
3.2. Determination of Initial Parameter Guesses
For our real host galaxy sample, we use magnitude, flux radius, and position angle from
the GOODS catalogs, which were created using SExtractor (Bertin & Arnouts 1996). Our
simulated galaxies do not have a SExtractor catalog, but we simulated initial parameter
guesses by introducing random errors into the true values.
Specifically, when determining initial guesses for parameters that can be measured from
-- 7 --
a data image, we assume that the guess value is accurate to within the following: ±(2.0, 2.0)
pixels in position, ±0.5 in total magnitude, 10% in re and b/a, and 10◦ in position angle.
We assumed no a priori knowledge of the S´ersic index n of each simulated galaxy, nor of
whether each simulated galaxy was a two-component bulge plus disk system, or a system
with either a pure bulge or disk. Our initial guess for the S´ersic index (or indices) of each
fit is n = 2.5.
In the case of a multi-component fit, we assume that the total magnitude is split evenly
among the components (i.e., that we have no prior knowledge of host:PS contrast ratio or
bulge-to-total ratio), and we additionally assume that the measured position angle and axial
ratio are the average of the actual values for each separate component after adding the
random fluctuation to the sum.
3.3. Real Galaxies with Added Point Sources
In order to test whether we can recover central point sources from galaxies, we selected
450 I-band images of normal galaxies (i.e., not X-ray detected) from the GOODS-North and
GOODS-South fields. The selection was performed so the sample has the same magnitude
distribution as the full sample of galaxies in each of the GOODS fields, but was otherwise
random. We assumed no knowledge of redshifts within the sample.
We fitted each of these galaxies with a single S´ersic profile in order to determine the
baseline set of morphological parameters for each galaxy. These fit parameters (S´ersic n,
magnitude, half-light radius re, etc.) were taken to be the "actual" galaxy parameters.
We then made nine copies of each galaxy, adding one point source to each, centered on
the central pixel of the galaxy. The added point sources ranged in I-band magnitude from
21 to 29, in increments of 1 mag. This gave us a total of 4050 simulated AGN from the
original 450 galaxies, with a large range of host galaxy-to-point-source contrast ratios, from
∼1000:1 to 1:100. These provide a straightforward means of assessing the effect of a central
point source on the recovered parameters of a real galaxy.
Our convergence rate for the fitting routine depends on the magnitude of the added
central point source. Of the models with IP S = 21, 88% converge, whereas 64% of models
with Ips = 29 (significantly below the flux limit of our I-band sample) converged. This is
due to the fitting program being unable to converge to a value for the central point-source
magnitude. Examples of fit results for typical galaxies in our sample are shown in Figure 2.
-- 8 --
Fig. 2. -- Example fit results for two AGN hosts simulated from real galaxies. For each galaxy,
the top row shows the original GOODS galaxy (from left to right: galaxy, fit, residual).
Each row below shows the host+fit+residual for added central point sources of magnitudes
IAB = 22, 24, 26, and 28, with the faintest point source in the bottom row. Note: These
cutouts are zoomed-in to show the galaxies; the actual fitting regions are significantly larger.
-- 9 --
3.4. Simulated Galaxies
The simulated hosts described in §3.3 provide information on how the presence of a
central point source changes the fitted host galaxy parameters, but they do not allow us to
explore redshift effects or quantify the absolute accuracy of the fit parameters. This can
only be accomplished with a set of simulations for which we know the intrinsic properties of
each simulated galaxy.
To that end, we simulated three kinds of galaxies with a range of parameters: pure de
Vaucouleurs bulge (B) galaxies with fixed S´ersic n = 4, pure exponential disk (D) galaxies
with n = 1, and composite galaxies with both bulge and disk (B+D) components in varying
proportions. The galaxy parameters were chosen to be typical of bright, local galaxies
(Binney & Merrifield 1998) and placed at z = 0.125. Redshifted samples were developed
from these, as described below.
For the B and D type galaxies, the component parameters occupy a grid of four values
for each parameter across the ranges 16.9 ≤ IAB ≤ 20.4 and 1.5 ≤ re ≤ 6.0 kpc (for bulges);
4.0 ≤ re ≤ 10.0 kpc (for disks), with axis ratios 0.25 ≤ b/a ≤ 1.0. For the single-component
fits, the position angle was fixed at 45.0◦. This results in 64 B and 64 D galaxies, each
of which is "inactive", i.e., without a central point source. We create simulated AGN host
galaxies by adding point sources to these. We used five values between 16.5 ≤ IAB ≤ 24
for the central point source, resulting in 320 B-type and 320 D-type AGN host galaxies,
with contrast ratios ranging from −1.3 ≤ log (Lhost/LPS) ≤ 2.8. Lastly, in order to ensure
enough galaxies for statistical analysis after binning the fitted single-component sample, we
made four copies of each B and D inactive galaxy and two copies of each B and D AGN host
galaxy. This resulted in a total of 256 B and 256 D inactive single-component galaxies, and
640 B and 640 D AGN host galaxies.
For the B+D type galaxies, the parameter space includes more magnitudes so as to pro-
vide 20 input bulge-to-total ratios with 0.028 ≤ (B/Tot) ≤ 0.97 [plus the single-component
B and D fits, which have (B/Tot) = 1 and 0, respectively]. In addition, the position angles
of the individual components were allowed to vary such that some of the simulated B+D
galaxies have components that are slightly (≤ 15◦) off-axis with respect to each other. The
axis ratios between bulges and disks were also allowed to vary with respect to each other.
These changes significantly increase the total number of double-component galaxies created;
thus the number of radius, b/a, and point-source magnitude parameters used was decreased
in order to keep the total number of galaxies from being prohibitively large from a computa-
tional perspective. This resulted in the creation of 2700 inactive double-component (B+D)
galaxies, and 8100 B+D AGN host galaxies. Table 1 gives the parameter values used to
create the entire local suite of 12,592 simulated single- and double-component galaxies.
-- 10 --
Since we are also interested in distinguishing the effects of redshifting galaxies from the
effects of evolving galaxies, the initial sample was defined to lie at z = 0.125, and three
additional samples were placed at z = 0.413, 0.738, and 1.075, corresponding to the redshifts
at which the centers of each of our GOODS filters (F435W, F606W, F775W, and F850LP)
are in the rest-frame B (F435W) band.
To redshift each galaxy, we used a concordance cosmology with Ωtot = 1, ΩΛ = 0.73,
and H0 = 71 km s−1 Mpc−1 (Spergel et al. 2003) to calculate the cosmological dimming and
loss of resolution corresponding to each redshift. Because the size of the ACS PSF does not
change with redshift, we assume that the size of AGN central point sources will also stay
fixed with redshift, unlike the host galaxy. We therefore created the redshifted AGN by
redshifting the model host galaxy (in flux and size) separately from the central point source
(in flux only) and adding them together before convolving with the ACS PSF and adding
noise to the image. The redshifting of each of the 12,592 galaxies produced another 12,592
galaxies at each final redshift, for a total of 50,368 fully simulated galaxies located at four
different redshifts from 0.125 < z < 1.075.
We fit each using our batch-fitting algorithm. Each galaxy was fit twice: once with a
generalized S´ersic profile plus a point-source component, and once with a combination of
de Vaucouleurs bulge, exponential disk, and point source.
Inactive galaxies were also fit
without point-source components. Examples of fit results for typical galaxies in our sample
are shown in Figure 3.
4. Results And Discussion
4.1. Existing Galaxies with Added Point Sources
We are interested mainly in three properties of these models: how well they recover the
input point-source magnitude, how well they recover the baseline host galaxy parameters,
and how the accuracy of the host galaxy parameters relates to the point-source magnitude
and/or the contrast ratio between central point source and host galaxy.
4.1.1. AGN (Point Source) Recovery
Figure 4 shows the degree of recovery of the central point-source magnitude for input
point sources. As expected, brighter point sources are more accurately recovered. At all
-- 11 --
Fig. 3. -- Example fit results for four fully simulated galaxies at four different redshifts. Each
row shows one galaxy. The first two columns show the image of the galaxy at z = 0.125 and
residual. Each successive pair of columns from left to right shows galaxy and residual for
z = 0.4125, 0.7375, and 1.075, respectively. Note: These cutouts are zoomed-in to show the
galaxies; the actual fitting regions are significantly larger.
-- 12 --
values of input point-source magnitude, the fitted value of the point-source magnitude tends
to either converge to the true input magnitude or remain at the input guess magnitude.
In all cases, we can easily separate these two groups with a simple reduced χ2
ν cut
(χ2
ν < 2.0). After the cut, the number of remaining poor fits is very low, as is the number
of good fits removed by the cut: both are less than 5%, even in the limiting cases of very
high and very low input point-source magnitude. This level of contamination/excess removal
of good fits is not strongly dependent on the value at which we choose to cut χ2, nor is it
strongly dependent on the input point-source magnitude.
The rms uncertainties of the recovered point-source magnitudes for each input point-
source value are shown in Table 2. These values reflect the systematic uncertainties in
the fitted parameters, and should be added to the statistical error in fitted point-source
magnitude returned by GALFIT.
4.1.2. Host Galaxy Parameter Recovery
Figure 5 shows the correlation between the fitted model's host galaxy magnitude and
the actual host magnitude (as determined before the addition of the central point source).
The percent completeness of the low-error sample compared to the full sample varies greatly
across a range of contrast ratios between host galaxy and central point source. For very
faint central point sources, the host galaxy magnitude is very well recovered, whereas for
very bright point sources the fraction of host galaxies with well-recovered parameters is very
low (∼ 15%).
Our simulations show that the reduced χ2
ν parameter is generally not sufficient to dis-
tinguish good from poor host galaxy fits. If we also limit the relative error of the effective
radius parameter, however, the fraction of selected galaxies that recover the true magnitude
of the host galaxy improves significantly. With the combination of χ2
ν and σre/re parameters,
we remove more than 85% of the fits with magnitude differences of 0.5 dex or more from the
actual galaxy magnitudes. The number of well-fitted galaxies that are also removed from
the sample ranges from 5% to 20%, depending primarily on how conservatively we choose
our relative σre cut. Figure 5 reflects a cutoff value of (σre/re) = 0.8, which removes 88% of
poor fits and 12% of the good fits from the IPS = 24 sample.
Figure 6 shows how well we recover the S´ersic index, n. The same error cuts (χ2
ν and
σre/re) efficiently reject the inaccurate fits. The fraction of models whose fitted n values
deviate by more than ∆n = 2 compared to the n values of the unaltered galaxies increases
significantly with increasing point-source flux. That is, a very bright central point source
-- 13 --
Fig. 4. -- Recovery of magnitude of a point source added to real galaxy images, for: input
point-source magnitudes of 22, 24, 26, and 28 mag. The fitting recovers the point-source
magnitude nicely after making a simple χ2
ν < 2.0 cut (black crosses), with a larger spread for
fainter values of the input point source, as expected. Fits with a large value of χ2
ν are shown
as green open circles; Nconv indicates the number of fits (out of 450) that converged automat-
ically for this input point-source magnitude. The dashed horizontal line shows mout = min, so
fits falling on this line perfectly recover the actual point-source magnitude. The dotted line
shows mout = mguess: fits on this line converged to their initial guess point-source magnitude,
and the final fitted magnitude is wrong; nearly all of these fits are removed by the χ2
ν cut.
-- 14 --
Fig. 5. -- Fitted host galaxy magnitude versus actual galaxy magnitude for fits to actual
galaxies with added point sources. Excluding high χ2
ν values and effective radii with large
fractional errors ensures a high fraction of good fits, with moderate uncertainties. Green
open circles indicate fits with high χ2
ν values. Cyan open squares indicate fits with excessive
errors on the effective radius fit parameter (σre ≥ 0.8 × re). Purple open triangles represent
fits with both high χ2
ν and high σre. The dotted line represents equal input and recovered
magnitudes (i.e., perfect recovery). The error cut removes some of the fits that do lie on the
1:1 line, regardless of the precise value for the σre cut.
-- 15 --
can easily be confused with a concentrated (high-n) S´ersic value. For all values of the
added point-source magnitude, however, the same combination of χ2
ν and relative re error is
sufficient to remove 88% of the inaccurate fits from the data, while removing less than 15%
of the well-fitted models.
4.1.3. Dependence of Parameters on Host:AGN Contrast Ratio
Figure 7 shows the relation of fitted host galaxy parameters to the contrast ratio between
the host galaxy and the added central point source, for the 1491 (of 4050) sources that are
not eliminated by the combination of χ2
ν and σre/re cuts. These include galaxies with all
possible values of input point-source magnitude.
The left panel of Figure 7 shows the difference between the fitted host galaxy magnitude
and original galaxy magnitude for the PS-added models. The recovered magnitudes are no
different on average than the correct parameters. For galaxies with contrast ratios of at
least log (Lhost/LPS) < −0.6, the host galaxy magnitude is well recovered, such that a
weighted least-squares fit to those data with contrast ratios (Lhost/LPS) greater than 1:4
has a slope within 1% of zero, indicating no correlation between contrast ratio and recovered
host galaxy magnitude. The scatter in the plot indicates that, while the sample as a whole
is well-recovered, individual galaxies may have large differences in recovered parameters due
to the presence of a point source. We see this result again in the right panel, which shows
the difference between fitted and original S´ersic index as a function of host-to-PS contrast
ratio. The inaccuracy in S´ersic index is larger when the added central point source is more
than 4 times as bright as the host galaxy: the slope of the weighted least-squares fit is 6%
for ∆IAB and 11% for ∆n. With proper error cuts, and for galaxies brighter than 1/4 of
the point-source magnitude, our host galaxy fits are not significantly contaminated by the
central point source. However, the presence of a point source increases the uncertainty in fit
parameters.
Figure 8 shows the median change in fitted parameters with input point-source magni-
tude. For very bright added point sources (IAB = 21, hHost:PSi ≈ 1 : 11), all fit parameters
deviate from their initially-determined values. The median S´ersic index is low by approx-
imately ∆n = 1.75, indicating that on average, galaxies with such bright point sources
could be classified as disk-dominated even if they have more bulge-dominated intrinsic mor-
phologies. The distribution is also very wide in the brightest-point-source bin: for such low
host-to-PS contrast ratios, the S´ersic index is essentially completely uncertain. For fainter
point-source magnitudes, recovery of the S´ersic index is far more reliable, although the un-
certainty (indicated by the width of the distribution in each bin) is considerably larger than
-- 16 --
Fig. 6. -- Change in S´ersic indices of host galaxies after adding point sources with original
host magnitude. Excluding high χ2
ν and σre/re yields the correct S´ersic index (a proxy for
morphological type). The color-coding of the points is the same as in Figure 5: green open
circles for high χ2
ν, cyan open squares for high relative σre, and purple open triangles for
both high χ2
ν and relative σre. The dotted lines at ∆n = 0 indicate perfect recovery of the
S´ersic index. As expected, the bright-point-source fits return mostly unreliable host galaxy
parameters, in contrast to the faint-point-source fits, which return mostly reliable host galaxy
parameters.
-- 17 --
Fig. 7. -- Accuracy of the host galaxy magnitude (left) and S´ersic index (right) as a func-
tion of the ratio of intrinsic galaxy luminosity to the added point-source luminosity.
In
both figures, contour plots are overlaid on the data points. Weighted least-squares fits to
all data points (dashed lines) indicates that the recovery of galaxy magnitude and S´ersic
index is very slightly correlated with host-to-PS contrast ratio. Excluding points with
log (Lhost/LPS) < −0.6, the weighted least-squares fit (solid lines) is consistent with zero
slope (i.e., no correlation between Host-to-PS contrast ratio) for both plots.
-- 18 --
that reported by the fitting routine.
The ratio of host and point-source luminosities is also incorrect at the brightest point-
source magnitudes: in these situations the typical fitted point-source magnitude is very close
to the input value, and the fitted host magnitude is too low (bright) by approximately 1.45
dex. Interestingly, the deviations in magnitude do not add to zero: because bright point-
sources are also slightly too bright, the total magnitude is also underestimated (too bright)
in the presence of a very bright central point source.
For point sources brighter than IAB = 24, the distribution of recovered host galaxy
magnitude is wide, such that the 68% confidence intervals span more than 1 dex in all bins.
For those point sources with magnitudes fainter than 24 (which is approximately equal to
the average magnitude of our initial galaxy sample), on the other hand, the model's host
galaxy magnitude is well recovered.
Since the faintest point-source magnitudes (IAB = 28, 29) are below the 10σ point-
source detection limit of our band, the fitted point-source magnitude for these cases is often
at least 1 mag brighter than the input point-source magnitude, with 68% confidence intervals
larger than 1 mag.
The S´ersic indices for the host galaxies are within ∆n = 0.25 on average for most values
of the added point-source magnitude. Since disks are generally more extended than bulges,
the S´ersic parameter is lower (on average) when the central point source is so bright that the
central portion of the host galaxy is dwarfed by the light in the wings of the central point
source. In all but the brightest cases, however, the median difference between the model
S´ersic index and the no-point-source index is smaller than the size of the morphological bins
discussed for a typical AGN sample (e.g., S´anchez et al. (2004); Ballo et al. (2007), S08), so
it is unlikely that a significant fraction has been mis-classified as disk-like or bulge-like due
to the presence of a central point source.
The rms values of the recovered S´ersic indices and recovered host magnitudes for each
input point-source magnitude are given in Table 2.
4.2. Fully Simulated Galaxies
4.2.1.
Input Parameter Recovery
For our 12,592 fully simulated GOODS galaxies, we apply the error cut determined
above, using a combination of χ2
ν and σre/re to distinguish good fits from poor fits. Within
the single component galaxies, this error cut results in 706 of 896 B type galaxies with "good"
-- 19 --
Fig. 8. -- Median change in S´ersic index n (upper), host magnitude (middle), and point-
source magnitude (lower) versus input point-source magnitude. Each point represents the
median value of all the galaxies with the given input point-source magnitude whose fits pass
the χ2
ν and σre/re cut described in the text. The host S´ersic indices (top panel) are generally
well-recovered for all but the brightest input point sources. The host magnitudes (middle
panel) are also well-recovered in all but the brightest input point-source bin, with the error
bars (representing the width of the distribution encompassing 68% of sources) increasing with
increasing point-source strength. Point-source magnitudes (bottom panel) are recovered well
until the input magnitude is fainter than the published 10σ point-source detection limit of
the data.
-- 20 --
fits and 708 of 896 D type galaxies with "good" fits.
The recovery of the S´ersic index for both of these types of galaxy models is shown for
the z = 0.125 sample in Figure 9.
If we classify galaxies as bulge-dominated when their
fitted n > 2.0 and disk-dominated when their fitted n < 2.0, the level of misclassification
based on these simulations is less than 15% for AGN host disk galaxies and less than 10%
for AGN host bulge galaxies. Fewer than 10% of inactive disks are misclassified as bulges
using the above cut; no inactive bulges are misclassified as disks. For any local sample of
single-component galaxies (the simplest possible case), then, the S´ersic parameter is a very
reliable indicator of morphological type.
The recovery of the z = 0.125 sample of two-component (B+D) galaxies is shown
in Figure 10. The fitted bulge-to-total light ratio, B/Tot = LB/ (LB + LD),
is within
∆ (B/Tot) ≤ 0.15 for 50% of our AGN host sample and 66% of our inactive sample. A
Gaussian fit to the data in Figure 10 gives an estimate of uncertainty in the bulge-to-total
parameter of σB/Tot = 0.04. However, the contamination from very deviant fits (i.e., the
wings of the histogram in Figure 10) is large. Approximately 14% and 13% of host and
inactive galaxies remaining in the sample after our error cut have ∆ (B/Tot) < −0.15, and
36% of host galaxies and 21% of inactive galaxies have ∆ (B/Tot) > 0.15.
Figure 11 shows the ratio of fitted-to-input bulge-to-total flux ratio as a function of the
intrinsic contrast ratio between the host galaxy and the central point source. The median and
1σ error bars (defined here as the values encompassing 68% of the points in each bin) for the
distribution of simulated galaxies without central point sources are plotted for comparison
at a value of Lhost/LP S = 3. In general, the presence of a central point source skews the
fits to slightly high values of the bulge-to-total ratio. For galaxies where the central point
source is very bright, the spread is higher, such that a galaxy may fit to a bulge-to-total ratio
twice the intrinsic value and still be within 1σ of the median value. Based on this, one could
attempt to correct the bulge-to-total ratio for the presence of a central point source, but a
bulge-to-total ratio fitted to a host galaxy could be overestimated by as much as 100%.
This large tail of high fitted bulge-to-total values has several causes. The radius of the
bulge may converge to an unphysically high value; this causes the luminosity bulge-to-total
ratio to skew high. This appears to be slightly more common when the intrinsic luminosity
of the galaxy is disk-dominated, i.e., with (B/Tot) ≤ 0.3. In addition, if the total source
magnitude is not well-conserved during the fit, the bulge-to-total ratio typically deviates
from the input value by at least 10% (high or low). This is more likely to occur when the
bulge and disk components have approximately equal luminosity, or the bulge is slightly
brighter [0.45 ≤ (B/Tot) ≤ 0.7].
-- 21 --
Fig. 9. -- Recovery of S´ersic index n for the single-S´ersic fits to simulated single-component B
and D AGN host galaxies (blue, top) and inactive galaxies (black, bottom). For the bulge-
dominated B galaxies (solid histograms), the average fitted S´ersic index is slightly higher
than the input n = 4 in both AGN and inactive galaxies; however, these are unambiguously
classified as bulge-dominated galaxies, with fewer than 10% of bulge host galaxies mis-
classified as disk-dominated galaxies and no bulge inactive galaxies mis-classified as disks.
For the disk-dominated D galaxies (dot-dash histogram), the recovery of the input n = 1 is
also excellent, with 13% of D host galaxies and 9% of D inactive galaxies having n > 2.0.
The separation between the typical fitted n for B and D galaxies is robust and indicates that
we can use the S´ersic index as a strong indicator of galaxy morphology for single-component
local galaxies with and without central point sources.
-- 22 --
Fig. 10. -- Recovery of input bulge-to-total ratio for the fully-simulated two-component
galaxies. We define ∆ (B/Tot) > 0 to mean the fit was more bulge-like than the input
galaxy. A Gaussian fit to the Host galaxy distribution gives σBT = 0.04, but there is a
large asymmetric tail on each distribution indicating that the samples are skewed toward
more bulge-like fits than the intrinsic distribution. 36% of host galaxies and 21% of inactive
galaxies have ∆ (B/Tot) > 0.15.
-- 23 --
Fig. 11. -- Ratio of fitted-to-input bulge-to-total vs. input host-to-PS contrast ratio. Points
plotted are the median values in each bin, with error bars marking the range of values
containing the central 68% of the points in each bin. The open circle shows simulated
galaxies with no added point source; this bin recovers input bulge-to-total ratio closely, with
a tail of high bulge-to-total values. For simulated host galaxies, the recovered bulge-to-total
ratio is generally high by 10-20%, and the distribution of points in each bin is wider for
galaxies where the central point source is at least as bright as the host galaxy.
-- 24 --
About 18% of the two-component AGN host fits result in either a bulge or disk half-
light radius that is unphysically low given the input sizes of both in our sample. These fits
span the entire range of ∆ (B/Tot) values, and are far more common when the central point
source is intrinsically bright. For the locally-defined sample, 79% of B+D bulge components
and 63% of B+D disk components with fitted re < 5.0 pixels are those with the brightest
central point source; this comprises 26% of all two-component sources with the brightest
central point source. It is worth noting that these fits typically show residuals that clearly
indicate a poor fit, and they can therefore be removed from the well-fitted sample on visual
inspection, or followed up with individual fitting to improve the fit.
The recovery of bulge and disk sizes in our sample is shown in Figure 12. The distribution
of ∆re for single-component galaxies (pure bulges and disks) is sharply peaked at a value of
∆r ≈ 0 (in pixels). A total of 66% of pure bulges and 65% of pure disks recover their input
radii within −1 ≤ ∆re ≤ 12 pixels. The discrete peaks at negative ∆re represent those fits
that converged to unphysically low values (re < 5.0 pixels for the local sample). Less than
5% of single-component fits converged to extremely large radii (∆re > 150 pixels).
The radius parameter converges to extremely high values far more frequently for the
two-component fits, and with higher frequency for the bulge components of two-component
galaxies (20%, B+D bulges) than for the disk components of two-component galaxies (13%,
B+D disks). The high-∆re tail for B+D bulges is a result of confusion with the central point
source of the simulated AGN host. Not only are bulges more compact than disks within
our B+D galaxies (and typically within real galaxies as well), but the slope of their light
profile more closely resembles the light profile of the ACS PSF than does an exponential disk
profile. This can lead to uncertain bulge radii and magnitudes, especially when the intrinsic
luminosity of the bulge is similar to that of the central point source. Disk components of
B+D galaxies are not as readily confused with the central point source: their fit typically
fails when the surface brightness of the disk component is too low compared to the bulge
and point source components.
Figure 13 demonstrates a possible method of separating good from poor two-component
fits. After removing those fits where either the bulge or disk converged to re < 5.0 pixels,
additionally requiring that the total source magnitude be conserved to within ∆mtot < 0.5
(determined by comparing the fitted total source magnitude with a measured, aperture-
corrected magnitude), and/or that the flux-weighted effective radius of the fit be no more
than 90 pixels larger than the measured half-light source radius1 removes 81% of sources
with ∆ (B/Tot) > 0.15 and retains 83% of sources within 0.15 of the input bulge-to-total
1This value was chosen because it is twice the observed radius of the largest source in our sample.
-- 25 --
Fig. 12. -- Histograms of the change in half-light radius for pure bulge (top left), pure disk
(top right), B+D bulge (bottom left) and B+D disk (bottom right) fits to simulated AGN
hosts. The majority of fits converge to a value that is equal to or greater than the input
value of the half-light radius for that source or source component. The small discrete peaks
at negative ∆re values are comprised mostly of fits for which re converged to an unphysical
value for our sample, re < 5 pixels. Single-S´ersic fits typically recover the sizes of pure
bulges and pure disks with about the same level of success. However, the local sample of
two-component galaxies indicates that bulge component radii are more likely to converge
to a value that is at least 50 pixels too high, or at least twice the intrinsic radius. Local
disk components are more likely to be underestimated, with a lower σ for the high-∆re
distribution than for B+D bulges.
-- 26 --
Fig. 13. -- Deviation from input host-to-PS contrast ratio versus deviation in bulge-to-
total ratio. Fits located at (0, 0) perfectly recovered the input bulge-to-total ratio and the
Galaxy-AGN luminosity ratio (Lhost/LPS). Requiring that the difference between the half-
light radii of the host be no more than 90 pixels larger than that observed for the entire
source (∆re ≤ 90), that the total source magnitude luminosity be conserved to better than
∆mtot ≤ 0.5 mag, and that the radii of neither the bulge nor the disk component be less
than 5 pixels (typically indicative of a poor fit) cuts 81% of sources with ∆ (B/Tot) > 0.15,
and retains 83% of sources with ∆ (B/Tot) ≤ 0.15.
-- 27 --
ratio. This also constrains the fitted host-to-PS contrast ratio to within 8% of the input
value for 95% of the remaining "good" sample. However, this selection biases the remaining
sample toward sources with faint central nuclei and preferentially retains bulge-dominated
sources with intrinsic (B/Tot) > 0.7. In general, the result of two-component fits should be
used with caution, even for a local, well-understood sample.
4.2.2. Detection of Central Point Sources
We established in §4.1.1 that central point sources can be recovered on average for a
sample of simulated host galaxies created from the addition of a central point source to a
real GOODS inactive galaxy, although the fraction of recovered point sources varies depend-
ing on the luminosity of the added point source. Using the χ2
ν cut previously determined
from this sample, we now examine the recovery of point sources with redshift and intrinsic
morphological type. Figure 14 shows the fraction of fits in which the central point source
was detected for our entire sample of fully simulated galaxies. In this case, our criteria for
a "detected" point source is simple: the point source is considered undetected only if the
magnitude parameter converged to a value considerably fainter than the detection limit of
our simulated data (mP S = 27.1 for our sample; Giavalisco et al. (2004)). Thus Figure 14
shows the fraction of fits for which any point-source magnitude was recovered, rather than
those fits for which the magnitude is close to the intrinsic magnitude.
Figure 14 indicates that the point source is detected within the fit at least 90% of the
time for all values of input log (Lhost/LPS). The fraction is lowest when the point source
and host galaxy have about equal luminosity. The detection fraction increases to more than
95% at the highest values of input log (Lhost/LPS), even for cases in which the point source
is 100 times fainter than its host galaxy. This is due to the fact that the convergence fraction
is lower for these bins; fits where the central point source may not have been detected are
less likely to converge, driving the detection fraction higher for those fits that did converge.
While we are primarily interested in the recovery of host galaxy parameters and optical
detection of central AGNs, we also want to characterize the fraction of spurious optical
point-source identifications. Thus, Figure 15 shows the results of a S´ersic + PS fit to inactive
galaxies with no intrinsic central point source. We find a significant difference in the number
of false point-source detections between pure disk and pure bulge galaxies. Only ∼ 1% of
pure disk inactive galaxies detect2 a central point source when none are present. However, we
2We define "detected" as having been fit with a magnitude brighter than the published 10σ point-source
detection limit of the GOODS survey (from which we take our noise properties).
-- 28 --
Fig. 14. -- Fraction of point sources recovered for single-component fits to all simulated
AGN host galaxies. The fraction of recovered point sources is slightly lower when the with
input log (Lhost/LPS) is near zero (LP S ≈ Lhost or slightly fainter). However, even in these
cases, the fits detect at least 90% of point sources.
-- 29 --
find a point source nearly one-quarter of the time when the simulated galaxy is a pure bulge.
Because our total sample is composed of equal numbers of pure bulge and pure disk galaxies,
this gives an overall false detection of a central point source in 12% of inactive galaxies.
However, this effect is strongly dependent on morphology: fits to elliptical galaxies are far
more likely to detect a faint point source when none are present than fits to disk galaxies.
Host galaxy studies estimating the uncertainty in the fraction of hosts with detected optical
point sources should therefore consider the morphological composition of their data sample:
if the sample contains mostly elliptical galaxies, the number of false detections could be as
high as 25%.
4.2.3. Redshift Effects on AGN Host Galaxies
At higher redshifts, surface-brightness dimming causes loss of extended components, and
an unresolved central AGN corresponds to a larger fraction of a galaxy's central region at high
redshift for fixed spatial resolution. Because our GOODS data sample (S08), as well as those
of others (S´anchez et al. 2004; Grogin et al. 2005; Ballo et al. 2007; Alonso-Herrero et al.
2008), extends to z ≈ 1, we consider the quantitative effects of redshift on morphological
classification.
After applying data cuts requiring ∆re ≤ 90 pixels and ∆mtot ≤ 0.5 to our results at
all redshifts, we assess the reliability of using the S´ersic index to classify single-component
galaxies at different redshifts in Figure 16. We have "classified" a galaxy as bulge-dominated
if it has n > 2.0 and disk-dominated if it has n < 2.0. Figure 16 then shows the fraction of
correctly classified B- and D-type galaxies at each redshift. In general, the classification of
pure bulges and pure disks is highly reliable for AGN host galaxies and point sources. At all
redshifts, disks and bulges are correctly classified at least 90% of the time using these data
cuts. Without these cuts, the misidentification rate increases to as much as 15%.
The average recovery of input half-light radius for all our simulated galaxies (pure bulges
and disks as well as B+D bulges and disks) is shown in Figure 17. Each point represents the
peak of the distribution of ∆re values for a single galaxy type/component in each redshift bin.
The error bars give the limits of the central 68% of data points; the peak of each distribution
is generally not coincident with the numerical "center" of each bin. Single-component S´ersic
fits to pure bulges and disks recover the radius reliably at all redshifts. Fitted radii to bulge
and disk components in B+D hosts recover the intrinsic radius of the component to within 1
kpc on average; however, the errors are larger and these fits are more uncertain. For example,
the width (containing 68% of sources) of the ∆re distribution of z ≈ 1 pure disks is less than
1 kpc, whereas the width of the z ≈ 1 distribution of ∆re for disk components in B+D hosts
-- 30 --
Fig. 15. -- Distribution of fitted point-source magnitude for simulated inactive galaxies.
Only 1% of pure disk inactive galaxies (blue dashed histogram) recovers point-source mag-
nitudes brighter than the 10σ detection limit (dotted line) for the GOODS survey (from
which our noise properties are taken). When the galaxy is a pure bulge (black histogram),
however, a point source is found above the 10σ threshold in approximately 25% of fits. The
overall percentage of fits where a point-source is found when none exists is 12% (for both
pure bulges and pure disks combined), but this number is strongly dependent on intrinsic
morphology.
-- 31 --
Fig. 16. -- Dependence of galaxy classification on redshift for simulated bulge galaxies
(nin = 4; top, solid lines) and disk galaxies (nin = 1; bottom, dot-dashed lines) with (blue)
and without (black) central point sources. The y-axis is the fraction of galaxies correctly
identified as bulges or disks given a threshold of n > 2.0 for bulge-dominated classification
and n < 2.0 for a galaxy with a significant disk. Although we have here adopted a cutoff
of n = 2.0, the results change by less than 5% when we change the cutoff to values between
1.5 < n < 3.
-- 32 --
Fig. 17. -- Recovery of input radii for pure and B+D bulges (top panel) and disks (bottom
panel). Each point represents the peak of the distribution of single-component (black, solid
lines) and two-component (green, dashed lines) ∆re at each redshift. The numbers next to
each point indicate the percentage of completed fits with re > 5 and ∆re ≤ 90 pixels, so
that the fit converged to a physical value and would not be rejected by eye based on the fit
residuals. While median fitted bulge and disk sizes are generally accurate to within 1 kpc at
all redshifts, the presence of a central point source increases the spread in the distribution
by up to a factor of 3. In addition, the majority of bulge fits within B+D galaxies at z ≈ 1
are not able to converge to a sensible value for the bulge radius.
-- 33 --
is approximately 3 kpc. Although the average recovery of bulge and disk component radii
in B+D galaxies is accurate to within 1 kpc, individual radii are highly uncertain.
The percentage of sources remaining after removing fits with incorrect total magnitudes
and unphysically low or high values of re, as previously discussed, is also shown for each
bin in Figure 17. The number of fits for which the fitted re < 5 pixels remains relatively
constant with redshift, but the number of fits for which the fitted re value diverges increases
with redshift, more dramatically so for bulges than for disks. In the z ≈ 1 sample, fewer
than 40% of bulges within two-component fits have fitted radii within a reasonable physical
range. This is likely due not just to the presence of the additional disk component, but also
to the fact that the bulge is much smaller at higher redshift compared to the size of the
central point source. In these cases, the bulge and the point source can be confused, often
resulting in a divergent bulge fit. This happens less frequently for disks for two reasons:
first, disks are generally more extended than bulges, and second, the radial profile of the
ACS PSF more closely resembles that of a de Vaucouleurs bulge than an exponential disk.
Because different fractions of galaxies are removed from the sample at different redshifts
(and for different bulge sizes), the morphological composition of a galaxy sample may be al-
tered from its intrinsic composition simply by applying a reasonable cut on the morphological
fit parameters, even if this cut is applied evenly (as it is in Figure 17).
Figure 18 thus shows the fitted morphological fraction of bulges with redshift of our
simulated sample of pure bulges and disks for both AGN hosts and inactive galaxies. After
applying the radius and magnitude cuts above (i.e., removing only unphysical fit results
from the sample), we calculate the fraction of galaxies in each redshift bin that would be
classified as bulge-dominated according to an n > 2 cut. For a perfectly-recovered sample,
this fraction would be N(n > 2.0)/Ntot = 0.5 at all redshifts because we simulated equal
numbers of bulges and disks. However, the convergence rate for pure bulge and disk fits
is slightly different at each redshift, and even our set of reasonable and conservative error
cuts removes different fractions of bulge and disk galaxies at each redshift. While this does
affect the morphological composition of the sample at each redshift, its effect is small: the
morphological fraction of n > 2 galaxies for AGN hosts is typically within 2% of the intrinsic
fraction at all redshifts. The inactive galaxy morphological fraction is within 5% of the
intrinsic fraction at all redshifts; both samples are consistent within their uncertainties with
the intrinsic fraction.
For the two-component B+D galaxies, the dependence of fitted S´ersic index on input
bulge-to-total ratio is shown in Figure 19. We see a general dependence of fitted n on the
intrinsic bulge-to-total ratio. The relation changes somewhat as the sample is redshifted,
but at all redshifts the S´ersic index indicates that galaxies may be fitted with a S´ersic index
-- 34 --
Fig. 18. -- Fraction of galaxies classified as bulges with redshift. Blue circles represent
simulated AGN hosts, and black triangles represent simulated inactive galaxies (error bars
determined using Poisson statistics). Because the initial simulation contains equal numbers
of pure bulges and disks, the actual bulge fraction is 0.5 for both samples. At the lowest
redshift bin, these fractions are recovered to within 1% for both samples. The sample of
simulated AGN host galaxies is mis-classified by up to 2% (0.02), and the inactive sample
is mis-classified by up to 5%. Uncertainties are higher for inactive galaxies due to lower
numbers of galaxies in the inactive sample, but in both cases the recovered fractions are
consistent with the correct fraction within the uncertainties.
-- 35 --
Fig. 19. -- Fitted S´ersic index vs. input bulge-to-total ratio, for simulated normal galaxies
(black triangles) and galaxies with added point sources (blue circles). At all redshifts (low
to high, top to bottom) the fit correctly finds disks (n = 1) at (LB/Ltot) = 0 and bulges
(n = 4) at (LB/Ltot) = 1. However, some galaxies fit to S´ersic values of n ≥ 4 despite
having up to 30% of their intrinsic light from a disk. Galaxies with intermediate values of
n (2 < n < 4) likely have bulges that contribute between 20% and 70% of the total galaxy
light. Points plotted are the median of each bin's distribution; error bars mark the widths
of each distribution enclosing the central 68% of sources in the bin.
-- 36 --
indicative of a pure bulge (n = 4) even in cases where a disk is present and contributing up to
45% of the total galaxy light. However, a fitted S´ersic index consistent with an exponential
disk (n = 1) typically indicates very little bulge contribution (< 10%); galaxies fitted with
n < 1.5 have (LB/Ltot) < 0.2. Intermediate values of the S´ersic parameter, 1.5 < n < 3,
generally indicate a galaxy with both bulge and disk, but the bulge-to-total ratio may vary
between 0.2 ≤ (LB/Ltot) ≤ 0.65, indicating that it is impossible to determine with a single-
component fit whether a host galaxy with an intermediate S´ersic index is intrinsically bulge-
or disk-dominated. Given that two-component B+D fits are also uncertain in the presence of
a central point source, we conclude that determination of the bulge-to-total ratio is uncertain
by at least 20% in AGN host galaxies, with a higher uncertainty for hosts with intermediate
S´ersic indices and/or fitted (LB/Ltot).
Figure 20 shows the recovery of detected input point sources, hosts, and host-to-PS
contrast ratios for our simulated galaxies (B, D, and B+D) at all redshifts. Again we see
that for the local sample, the recovery is excellent: not only are point sources detected at
least 95% of the time, but the recovered magnitude is typically within at least 0.1 ± 0.12
dex of the intrinsic magnitude. In fact, point-source recovery is very good at all redshifts:
the recovered magnitude is within 0.5 dex of the input magnitude for all redshifts and input
point-source magnitudes.
The dispersion in recovered values for the host galaxy magnitude is higher than that of
point-source magnitude values for all redshifts. While in the local redshift bin the median
recovered host magnitude is within 0.1 dex of the input magnitude, the central 68% of
values has a larger spread. At higher redshifts, the host galaxy is more likely to converge
to magnitudes that are too bright compared to the input magnitude. This effect is more
pronounced for sources with a brighter input point source, as expected. For sources with a
bright point source compared to the host, the difference is ∆mhost = 0.6 for z > 0.7. For
z ≈ 1, the distribution of ∆mhost has an extended tail to negative (too-bright) values: a
significant fraction of high-redshift sources overestimates the host brightness by up to 1.8
dex regardless of the host-to-PS contrast ratio. For z < 1, this tail also exists for all host-
to-PS values. However, when the input point source is faint compared to the host, the host
magnitude is fitted to within −0.8 < ∆mhost < 0.3 (1σ) for these redshifts.
5. Summary and Conclusions
We simulated 54,418 GOODS ACS galaxy images of inactive and AGN host galaxies
at redshifts 0.125 < z < 1.25, the largest sample of simulated two-dimensional galaxy
morphologies to date.
-- 37 --
Fig. 20. -- Effects of redshift on recovery of input point sources (top), input host magnitudes
(middle), and host-to-PS contrast ratio, shown for all our simulated host galaxies. Each panel
shows the fitted quantity versus the input point-source magnitude. Each line in a panel
represents a different redshift bin: z = 0.125 (blue, circles), z = 0.4125 (green, squares),
z = 0.7375 (orange, triangles), and z = 1.075 (red, stars).
-- 38 --
Using a robust initial guess routine followed by batch-fitting, we performed single-
component and bulge-disk host galaxy fits on these simulated galaxies, while also extracting
the central point-source components of the AGN.
For batch-fit galaxies with central point-source components, typically 60%-70% of the
fits converge successfully and pass our error cuts. This percentage can be significantly
increased by follow-up case-by-case fitting, starting from the results of the batch fitting
routines.
ν cut on the recovered fits. Using a combination χ2
We reliably extract central point-source magnitudes for the simulated AGNs using a
simple χ2
ν < 2 and relative effective radius
error cut of (σre/re) = 0.8 removes 88% of the poor host galaxy fits while excluding 12% of
good host galaxy fits. The accurate extraction of AGN and host galaxy parameters does not
depend on the host:AGN contrast ratio (Lhost/LPS), as long as it is greater than 1:4.
Galaxy size is recovered to within ∆re < 1 kpc for single-component galaxies. For indi-
vidual bulges and disks within two-component bulge + disk host galaxy fits, the distribution
of recovered radii peaks within ∆re < 1 kpc at all redshifts, but the large width of the dis-
tributions indicates that individual fits to bulges and disks within two-component galaxies
are highly uncertain.
The average recovered morphological fraction of our sample is within 5% of the true
fraction, even at z ≈ 1. Of course, this number should be regarded as a lower limit since
actual data samples of two-dimensional AGN host galaxy morphologies are likely to be
significantly smaller than our simulations, and thus suffer from more uncertain statistics.
We recover the correct morphology 99% of the time for inactive galaxies out to z = 1.25.
The average bulge-to-total ratios are within 10% of the true ratio at all redshifts, but
with large scatter (∼ 50%). This means that values for individual hosts are unreliable at
the 50% level, but statistical population averages are more accurate. Thus, uncertainties in
individual black hole masses determined using Lbulge − MBH relations (McLure & Dunlop
2002; Marconi & Hunt 2003; Ferrarese & Ford 2005) are higher when using fitted bulge lu-
minosities of AGN host galaxies than those of inactive galaxies, and may be systematically
overestimated due to the presence of central point sources.
Galaxies with S´ersic n < 1.5 are generally disk-dominated, with at least 80% of their
total light coming from a disky component. Galaxies with intermediate 1.5 < n < 3 have
larger bulge components (occupying from 20% to 65% of the total galaxy light). Galaxies
that appear to be bulge-dominated, i.e., with n ≥ 3, may derive as little as 45% (depending
on redshift) of their total light from a bulge component; for n = 4, typically ∼ 70% of the
galaxy light comes from the bulge.
-- 39 --
In fully simulated AGN host galaxies, the central point source is correctly detected over
90% of the time, with only weak dependence on the intrinsic contrast ratio between the host
galaxy and point source or the host morphology. This indicates that a sample of AGN host
galaxy fits to ACS data with z < 1.25 is at least 90% complete in its detection of central
point sources.
However, we also detect spurious point sources in simulated galaxies where no central
point source is present, for as little as 1% or as high as 25% of the galaxies, depending on
the morphological composition of the sample. Fits to bulge-dominated galaxies are far more
likely to detect a point source when none are present than fits to disk-dominated galaxies.
We have used these simulations to evaluate the robustness of our results for AGN host
galaxies observed with ACS. This is important for assessing the accuracy of recovered host
morphologies, as well as the evolution of AGN host morphology with redshift. All of our
results that can be quantitatively applied to a sample of real AGN host galaxies are also
presented in tabular format (Tables 2, 3, and 4).
We have performed these simulations using the image depths and noise properties of
GOODS, but they may also be used for other ACS surveys such as GEMS (Rix et al. 2004),
COSMOS (Scoville et al. 2007), and AEGIS (Davis et al. 2007). The extent to which these
simulations are directly applicable or provide limits on the accuracy of AGN host galaxy
morphological fits for other ACS data depends on the relative depth of observations in each
survey.
It is important to note that these results apply to redshifts where the ACS bands are
observing rest-frame optical data, e.g. z < 1.25. As we move into the era of newer telescopes
such as the James Webb Space Telescope and observing rest-frame optical wavelengths at
very high resolution becomes possible for higher redshifts, an understanding of the effects
of a central point source on high-redshift morphologies will become crucial. Simulations to
probe these effects have begun on small scales (Dasyra et al. 2008), but more such work is
needed.
The authors wish to thank C. Conselice, L. Moustakas, P. Natarajan, S. Ravindranath,
and the entire GOODS team for helpful discussions that improved this work. Thanks espe-
cially to C. Peng for making GALFIT publicly available and for many enlightening discus-
sions. We acknowledge support from NASA through grants HST-AR-10689.01-A, HST-GO-
09425.13-A and HST-GO-09822.09-A from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is
operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy under NASA contract
NAS 5-26555.
-- 40 --
REFERENCES
Alonso-Herrero, A., P´erez-Gonz´alez, P. G., Rieke, G. H., Alexander, D. M., Rigby, J. R.,
Papovich, C., Donley, J. L., & Rigopoulou, D. 2008, ApJ, 677, 127
Ballo, L., Cristiani, S., Fasano, G., Fontanot, F., Monaco, P., Nonino, M., Pignatelli, E.,
Tozzi, P., Vanzella, E., Fontana, A., Giallongo, E., Grazian, A., & Danese, L. 2007,
ApJ, 667, 97
Bertin, E., & Arnouts, S. 1996, A&AS, 117, 393
Binney, J., & Merrifield, M. 1998, Galactic astronomy (Galactic astronomy / James Binney
and Michael Merrifield. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press, 1998. (Princeton
series in astrophysics) QB857 .B522 1998 ($35.00))
Conselice, C. J. 2003, ApJS, 147, 1
Dasyra, K. M., Yan, L., Helou, G., Surace, J., Sajina, A., & Colbert, J. 2008, ArXiv e-prints,
802
Davis, M., Guhathakurta, P., Konidaris, N. P., Newman, J. A., Ashby, M. L. N., Biggs,
A. D., Barmby, P., Bundy, K., Chapman, S. C., Coil, A. L., Conselice, C. J., Cooper,
M. C., Croton, D. J., Eisenhardt, P. R. M., Ellis, R. S., Faber, S. M., Fang, T., Fazio,
G. G., Georgakakis, A., Gerke, B. F., Goss, W. M., Gwyn, S., Harker, J., Hopkins,
A. M., Huang, J.-S., Ivison, R. J., Kassin, S. A., Kirby, E. N., Koekemoer, A. M.,
Koo, D. C., Laird, E. S., Le Floc'h, E., Lin, L., Lotz, J. M., Marshall, P. J., Martin,
D. C., Metevier, A. J., Moustakas, L. A., Nandra, K., Noeske, K. G., Papovich, C.,
Phillips, A. C., Rich, R. M., Rieke, G. H., Rigopoulou, D., Salim, S., Schiminovich,
D., Simard, L., Smail, I., Small, T. A., Weiner, B. J., Willmer, C. N. A., Willner,
S. P., Wilson, G., Wright, E. L., & Yan, R. 2007, ApJ, 660, L1
Ferrarese, L., & Ford, H. 2005, Space Science Reviews, 116, 523
Ferrarese, L., & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJ, 539, L9
Gebhardt, K., Bender, R., Bower, G., Dressler, A., Faber, S. M., Filippenko, A. V., Green,
R., Grillmair, C., Ho, L. C., Kormendy, J., Lauer, T. R., Magorrian, J., Pinkney, J.,
Richstone, D., & Tremaine, S. 2000, ApJ, 539, L13
Giavalisco, M., Ferguson, H. C., Koekemoer, A. M., Dickinson, M., Alexander, D. M.,
Bauer, F. E., Bergeron, J., Biagetti, C., Brandt, W. N., Casertano, S., Cesarsky, C.,
Chatzichristou, E., Conselice, C., Cristiani, S., Da Costa, L., Dahlen, T., de Mello,
-- 41 --
D., Eisenhardt, P., Erben, T., Fall, S. M., Fassnacht, C., Fosbury, R., Fruchter, A.,
Gardner, J. P., Grogin, N., Hook, R. N., Hornschemeier, A. E., Idzi, R., Jogee, S.,
Kretchmer, C., Laidler, V., Lee, K. S., Livio, M., Lucas, R., Madau, P., Mobasher, B.,
Moustakas, L. A., Nonino, M., Padovani, P., Papovich, C., Park, Y., Ravindranath,
S., Renzini, A., Richardson, M., Riess, A., Rosati, P., Schirmer, M., Schreier, E.,
Somerville, R. S., Spinrad, H., Stern, D., Stiavelli, M., Strolger, L., Urry, C. M.,
Vandame, B., Williams, R., & Wolf, C. 2004, ApJ, 600, L93
Graham, A. W. 2001, AJ, 121, 820
Grogin, N. A., Conselice, C. J., Chatzichristou, E., Alexander, D. M., Bauer, F. E., Horn-
schemeier, A. E., Jogee, S., Koekemoer, A. M., Laidler, V. G., Livio, M., Lucas, R. A.,
Paolillo, M., Ravindranath, S., Schreier, E. J., Simmons, B. D., & Urry, C. M. 2005,
ApJ, 627, L97
Haussler, B., McIntosh, D. H., Barden, M., Bell, E. F., Rix, H.-W., Borch, A., Beckwith,
S. V. W., Caldwell, J. A. R., Heymans, C., Jahnke, K., Jogee, S., Koposov, S. E.,
Meisenheimer, K., S´anchez, S. F., Somerville, R. S., Wisotzki, L., & Wolf, C. 2007,
ApJS, 172, 615
Jogee, S., Barazza, F. D., Rix, H.-W., Shlosman, I., Barden, M., Wolf, C., Davies, J., Heyer,
I., Beckwith, S. V. W., Bell, E. F., Borch, A., Caldwell, J. A. R., Conselice, C. J.,
Dahlen, T., Haussler, B., Heymans, C., Jahnke, K., Knapen, J. H., Laine, S., Lubell,
G. M., Mobasher, B., McIntosh, D. H., Meisenheimer, K., Peng, C. Y., Ravindranath,
S., Sanchez, S. F., Somerville, R. S., & Wisotzki, L. 2004, ApJ, 615, L105
Koekemoer, A. M., Fruchter, A. S., Hook, R. N., & Hack, W. 2002, in The 2002 HST
Calibration Workshop : Hubble after the Installation of the ACS and the NICMOS
Cooling System, Proceedings of a Workshop held at the Space Telescope Science
Institute, Baltimore, Maryland, October 17 and 18, 2002. Edited by Santiago Arribas,
Anton Koekemoer, and Brad Whitmore. Baltimore, MD: Space Telescope Science
Institute, 2002., p.339, 339 -- +
Kormendy, J., & Richstone, D. 1995, ARA&A, 33, 581
Magorrian, J., Tremaine, S., Richstone, D., Bender, R., Bower, G., Dressler, A., Faber,
S. M., Gebhardt, K., Green, R., Grillmair, C., Kormendy, J., & Lauer, T. 1998, AJ,
115, 2285
Marconi, A., & Hunt, L. K. 2003, ApJ, 589, L21
Marleau, F. R., & Simard, L. 1998, ApJ, 507, 585
-- 42 --
McLure, R. J., & Dunlop, J. S. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 795
Peng, C. Y., Ho, L. C., Impey, C. D., & Rix, H.-W. 2002, AJ, 124, 266
Ravindranath, S., Ferguson, H. C., Conselice, C., Giavalisco, M., Dickinson, M., Chatzichris-
tou, E., de Mello, D., Fall, S. M., Gardner, J. P., Grogin, N. A., Hornschemeier, A.,
Jogee, S., Koekemoer, A., Kretchmer, C., Livio, M., Mobasher, B., & Somerville, R.
2004, ApJ, 604, L9
Rix, H.-W., Barden, M., Beckwith, S. V. W., Bell, E. F., Borch, A., Caldwell, J. A. R.,
Haussler, B., Jahnke, K., Jogee, S., McIntosh, D. H., Meisenheimer, K., Peng, C. Y.,
Sanchez, S. F., Somerville, R. S., Wisotzki, L., & Wolf, C. 2004, ApJS, 152, 163
S´anchez, S. F., Jahnke, K., Wisotzki, L., McIntosh, D. H., Bell, E. F., Barden, M., Beckwith,
S. V. W., Borch, A., Caldwell, J. A. R., Haussler, B., Jogee, S., Meisenheimer, K.,
Peng, C. Y., Rix, H.-W., Somerville, R. S., & Wolf, C. 2004, ApJ, 614, 586
Scoville, N., Aussel, H., Brusa, M., Capak, P., Carollo, C. M., Elvis, M., Giavalisco, M.,
Guzzo, L., Hasinger, G., Impey, C., Kneib, J.-P., LeFevre, O., Lilly, S. J., Mobasher,
B., Renzini, A., Rich, R. M., Sanders, D. B., Schinnerer, E., Schminovich, D., Shop-
bell, P., Taniguchi, Y., & Tyson, N. D. 2007, ApJS, 172, 1
S´ersic, J. L. 1968, Atlas de galaxias australes (Cordoba, Argentina: Observatorio Astro-
nomico, 1968)
Sheth, K., Elmegreen, D. M., Elmegreen, B. G., Capak, P., Abraham, R. G., Athanassoula,
E., Ellis, R. S., Mobasher, B., Salvato, M., Schinnerer, E., Scoville, N. Z., Spalsbury,
L., Strubbe, L., Carollo, M., Rich, M., & West, A. A. 2008, ApJ, 675, 1141
Simard, L., Koo, D. C., Faber, S. M., Sarajedini, V. L., Vogt, N. P., Phillips, A. C., Gebhardt,
K., Illingworth, G. D., & Wu, K. L. 1999, ApJ, 519, 563
Spergel, D. N., Verde, L., Peiris, H. V., Komatsu, E., Nolta, M. R., Bennett, C. L., Halpern,
M., Hinshaw, G., Jarosik, N., Kogut, A., Limon, M., Meyer, S. S., Page, L., Tucker,
G. S., Weiland, J. L., Wollack, E., & Wright, E. L. 2003, ApJS, 148, 175
Trujillo, I., & Aguerri, J. A. L. 2004, MNRAS, 355, 82
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 43 --
Pure Bulges Pure Disks
Bulge + Disk
mgal
(IAB, L∗)
re
(pixels, kpc)
16.898, 5.0
18.645, 1.0
19.398, 0.5
20.393, 0.2
16.898, 5.0
18.645, 1.0
19.398, 0.5
20.393, 0.2
13.54, 1.5
27.09, 3.0
40.63, 4.5
54.18, 6.0
36.12, 4.0
54.18, 6.0
72.23, 8.0
90.09, 10.0
Bulge
Disk
16.898, 5.0
18.645, 1.0
19.398, 0.5
20.393, 0.2
20.750, 0.14
27.09, 3.0
40.63, 4.5
54.18, 6.0
16.898, 5.0
18.645, 1.0
19.398, 0.5
20.393, 0.2
20.750, 0.14
54.18, 6.0
72.23, 8.0
90.29, 10.0
b/a
PA
(degrees)
mP S
(IAB)
0.25
0.50
0.75
1.0
45.0
none
16.500
18.375
20.250
22.125
24.000
0.25
0.50
0.75
1.0
45.0
none
16.500
18.375
20.250
22.125
24.000
0.65
1.0
45.0
60.0
0.30
0.65
1.0
45.0
none
16.500
20.250
22.125
Table 1: Grid values for simulated galaxies at z = 0.125. The effective radius re values differ
between the bulge and disk galaxies due to the different physical sizes of these two classes of
galaxies. The parameter space varies slightly between single-component galaxies and double-
component galaxies in order to increase the number of mesh points in the bulge-to-total ratio
without increasing the simulated double-component galaxies to a computationally prohibitive
number. Conversion from magnitude to luminosity and between pixels and physical size uses
a concordance cosmology (Ωtot = 1, ΩΛ = 0.73, and H0 = 71 km/s/Mpc) and a redshift
z = 0.125.
-- 44 --
Source mP S Nconv
σmP S N1
σmhost
σn
σre
N2
(AB)
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
374
389
397
394
382
372
355
315
286
0.33
0.48
0.27
0.15
0.17
0.27
0.47
0.87
1.20
210
273
359
328
328
295
271
228
193
1.09
0.12
0.15
0.20
0.14
0.17
0.12
0.10
0.09
(pixels)
15.6
21.8
11.0
26.7
15.9
8.2
7.9
6.3
1.6
45
85
138
184
223
215
215
192
161
2.10
0.97
0.67
0.54
0.40
0.44
0.27
0.22
0.27
Table 2: RMS values for fit parameters vary with central point-source magnitude. Nconv is
the number of fits which converged (out of 450) for each input point-source magnitude value.
N1 is the number remaining after applying a χ2
ν < 2.0 cut; N2 is the number remaining after
further requiring σre/re < 0.8. The RMS value for the point-source magnitude is calculated
from N1 galaxies, and the values for σmhost, σn, and σr are calculated from N2 objects. Note:
Results for these magnitudes are based on a survey with the GOODS depths (Giavalisco et al.
2004).
Source log (Lhost/LPS)
σmP S
σmhost
σn
σre
-1.5
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.2
1.9
0.26
0.31
0.31
0.36
1.69
1.92
0.69
0.78
0.29
0.31
0.35
0.32
0.23
0.07
(pixels)
7.2
6.2
7.1
5.4
4.4
4.6
3.4
0.70
0.38
0.31
0.27
0.24
0.33
0.20
Table 3: Determined RMS values for fit parameters to sources with different log (Lhost/LPS).
-- 45 --
Fitted S´ersic index Intrinsic bulge-to-total ratio
n ≤ 1.5
1.5 < n < 3
n ≥ 3
n ≥ 4
(B/Tot) < 0.2
0.2 < (B/Tot) < 0.65
(B/Tot) > 0.45
(B/Tot) > 0.55
Table 4: Relationship of a host galaxy's fitted S´ersic index to its intrinsic bulge-to-total light
ratio. Hosts with intermediate S´ersic index may have a wide range of bulge-to-total ratios;
hosts with fitted n = 4, typically classified as pure deVaucouleur bulges, may in fact have
bulge-to-total ratios as low as 55%.
|
astro-ph/0009058 | 1 | 0009 | 2000-09-05T12:19:11 | Search for High Proper Motion White Dwarfs | [
"astro-ph"
] | Recent results of microlensing surveys, show that 10-20% of the dark halo mass of the Milky Way consists of compact objects. The masses of these compact objects range from 0.1 to 1 solar mass. New theoretical cooling models for white dwarfs, and the detection of faint blue high proper motion objects, imply that ancient white dwarfs might make up part of this population. In this pilot project, using data from the C and D patches of the ESO Imaging Survey and data obtained at CTIO, we attempted to find such halo white dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood. With a time baseline of approximately one year between data sets and a limiting I-band magnitude of 23, we can find these high proper motion objects up to distances of 85 parsecs. In the 2.5 square degrees studied so far we have found three high proper motion candidates. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
SEARCH FOR HIGH PROPER MOTION WHITE DWARFS
J.T.A. DE JONG, K.H. KUIJKEN & M.J. NEESER
Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, Postbus 800, 9700 AV Groningen, The Netherlands
Recent results of microlensing surveys, show that 10-20 % of the dark halo mass of the Milky
Way consists of compact objects. The masses of these compact objects range from 0.1 to
1 solar mass. New theoretical cooling models for white dwarfs, and the detection of faint
blue high proper motion objects, imply that ancient white dwarfs might make up part of this
population.
In this pilot project, using data from the C and D patches of the ESO Imaging Survey and data
obtained at CTIO, we attempted to find such halo white dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood.
With a time baseline of approximately one year between data sets and a limiting I-band
magnitude of 23, we can find these high proper motion objects up to distances of 85 parsecs.
In the 2.5 deg2 studied so far we have found three high proper motion candidates.
1
Introduction: dark matter and white dwarfs
It is generally accepted that the Milky Way and most external galaxies contain more mass than
observed directly. What makes up this so-called 'dark mass' is, however, not so clear. This
mass is often assumed to be distributed in an isothermal halo, which means that dark matter
would also be present in the solar neighbourhood. Recent results from galactic microlensing
experiments like MACHO 1 indicate that 10 to 20 % of the dark halo mass of the Milky Way
may be in compact objects.
Recent number counts of faint blue objects2 in the Hubble Deep Fields North and South
and the detection of high proper motion objects3,4, indicate the presence of a population of faint
blueish compact objects in the galaxy. Furthermore, new cooling models for white dwarfs5,6 show
that they are much bluer than was previously believed. The above suggests that the galactic
dark halo might, at least partially, consist of very old white dwarfs.
In the project presented here we try to find faint high proper motion objects in the solar
neighbourhood, which are likely to be dark halo white dwarfs (see the table on the right). For
this purpose we use the C and D patches of the ESO Imaging Survey (EIS) Wide7 and a smaller
survey done with the CTIO 4m telescope. These data serve as a pilot project for a larger survey
for which we plan to observe the complete C and D patches of the EIS Wide survey with a larger
temporal baseline.
2 Data and Method
The data that are being used for the current project consist of two overlapping sets. The first
data set is taken from the C and D patches of the EIS Wide survey7, which are 6 deg2 each.
These data were obtained between July 1997 and March 1998 in the I-band with individual
exposure times of 300 seconds. The second data set was obtained with the 4m telescope at
CTIO. This survey covers almost 2 deg2 of both the EIS C and D patches, making up a total
area of nearly 4 deg2. The CTIO data were taken in the R-band with single pointing exposure
times of 2000 seconds. As this second survey was performed in December 1998, we have a time
baseline of approximately one year for the high proper motion search.
To find high proper motion objects from the data we use a straightforward method. First,
the CTIO data are transformed to the EIS coordinate system. The EIS pixels are smaller than
the CTIO pixels, so in this way we do not lose information. Following this, objects are matched
within a 2 arcsecond radius. Objects that seem to be offset are selected with a magnitude
dependent cutoff. Finally the resulting outliers are visually inspected to filter out close objects,
cosmic rays, extended sources, etc. With the time baseline of ∼ 1 year we are sensitive to proper
motions of 0.5 to 2.0 arcsecond per year.
3 What can we find?
A high proper motion search can be very efficient in finding halo objects because of their large
velocities with respect to the solar standard of rest. While the sun follows the galactic rotation,
the halo does not. Therefore, halo objects have typical velocities of 200 km/s.
In the event that we find an object with a high proper motion, how do we know whether
it's part of the dark halo? In table 1 we compare the chances of finding objects belonging to
the galactic components present in the solar neighbourhood. Our sensitivity to proper motions
of 0.5 to 2.0 arcseconds, together with the typical velocities of the objects w.r.t. the sun, gives
the distance range where we can find these objects. With these densities we can calculate the
average number of objects per square degree. This shows that when we find a high proper
motion object, it is most likely part of the dark halo. According to cooling models by Saumon
& Jacobsen6, white dwarfs as cool as 3000 K have MI ∼ 16; easily detectable in our survey to
distances of 85 pc.
There are, however, some issues that should be mentioned. The two data sets are in different
bands (R and I), and have different noise properties because of the different exposure times.
Other possible explanations for apparent object motion include close (variable star) binaries,
distant supernovae and even Kuiper belt and Oort cloud objects. The motions on the sky of
Table 1: Calculated estimates of the average number of high proper motion objects one will find for different
galactic populations. For these calculations, objects of 0.3 M⊙ are assumed.
Population
v
distances
ρ
pop.II halo
thin disk
thick disk
dark halo
(km/s)
200
30
60
200
(pc)
20-85
3-13
6-25
20-85
(M⊙pc−3)
5 × 10−5
0.05
0.003
0.01
objects
(deg−2)
0.001
0.03
0.01
2
the Kuiper and Oort objects are dominated by parallax, but because our temporal baseline is
∼ 1 year this possibility can not be excluded with our current data. All of these problems can
be solved by doing a third observation run.
4 Results
We have now analyzed 5/8 of the nearly 4 deg2 of data, and have found three promising candi-
dates for dark halo objects. These are shown in the figures 1 to 3. The first two candidates are
located in the C patch of the EIS Wide survey while the third one is in the D patch.
The objects are very faint, which is a further indication that they are not normal stars.
Both candidate 1 and 2 have an apparent I-band magnitude of 22. The third candidate is even
fainter, around mI ∼ 23. It is also striking that the two C patch objects move approximately
in the same direction. This direction is consistent with it being due to the galactic rotation of
the sun. The same is true for the motion of the D patch candidate.
5 Future
The recently discovered population of faint, high proper motion objects which may be part of
the galactic dark halo needs to be studied in detail. For this purpose, a large number of objects
is necessary. Therefore, we see the current project as a pilot project for a larger survey. The
most efficient way of increasing the chances of finding these objects is to increase the field of
view. For the candidates we have so far, further observations need to be done to confirm the
proper motions and to get more color information and/or spectra.
References
1. Alcock, C. et al, 2000, astro-ph/0001272
2. Mendez, R.A. & Minniti, D., 2000, ApJ, 529, 911, astro-ph/9908330
3. Ibata, R.A. et al, 1999, ApJ, 524, L95, astro-ph/9908270
4. Ibata, R.A. et al, 2000, ApJ, 532, L41, astro-ph/0002138
5. Hansen, B.M.S., 1999, ApJ, 520, 680, astro-ph/9903025
6. Saumon, D. & Jacobsen, S.B., 1999, ApJ, 511, L107, astro-ph/9812107
7. Benoist, C. et al, 1999, A&A, 346, 58, astro-ph/9807334
Figure 1: Candidate 1. The two images show the same 16x16 arcsec patch of the sky (located in the EIS Wide
C field). On the left is the EIS I-band image, on the right the CTIO 4m R-band image, which was transformed
to the EIS coordinate system. The apparent shift of the image is ∼ 1 arcsec.
Figure 2: Candidate 2. The shift of this candidate is also ∼ 1 arcsec. This candidate is also located in the EIS
Wide C patch and seems to be moving approximately in the same direction as candidate 1. This direction is
consistent with it being due to the galactic rotation of the sun.
Figure 3: Candidate 3. This candidate has an apparent shift of ∼ 0.5 arcsec and is near our brightness and proper
motion detection limits. The direction of motion of this object is also consistent with it being due to the galactic
rotation of the sun. This candidate is located in the EIS Wide D patch.
|
astro-ph/0210450 | 2 | 0210 | 2003-07-11T07:44:20 | Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field: Constraints on Omega_m and sigma_8 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present measurements of the cosmic shear correlation in the shapes of galaxies in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 deg^2 R_c-band imaging data. As an estimator of the shear correlation originated from the gravitational lensing, we adopt the aperture mass variance. We detect a non-zero E mode variance on scales between 2 and 40arcmin. We also detect a small but non-zero B mode variance on scales larger than 5arcmin. We compare the measured E mode variance to the model predictions in CDM cosmologies using maximum likelihood analysis. A four-dimensional space is explored, which examines sigma_8, Omega_m, Gamma and zs (a mean redshift of galaxies). We include three possible sources of error: statistical noise, the cosmic variance estimated using numerical experiments, and a residual systematic effect estimated from the B mode variance. We derive joint constraints on two parameters by marginalizing over the two remaining parameters. We obtain an upper limit of Gamma<0.5 for zs>0.9 (68% confidence). For a prior Gamma\in[0.1,0.4] and zs\in[0.6,1.4], we find sigma_8=(0.50_{-0.16}^{+0.35})Omega_m^{-0.37} for flat cosmologies and sigma_8=(0.51_{-0.16}^{+0.29})Omega_m^{-0.34}$ for open cosmologies (95% confidence). If we take the currently popular LCDM model, we obtain a one-dimensional confidence interval on sigma_8 for the 95.4% level, 0.62<\sigma_8<1.32 for zs\in[0.6,1.4]. Information on the redshift distribution of galaxies is key to obtaining a correct cosmological constraint. An independent constraint on Gamma from other observations is useful to tighten the constraint. | astro-ph | astro-ph | SUBMITTED TO APJ; DRAFT VERSION NOVEMBER 10, 2018
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 11/12/01
COSMIC SHEAR STATISTICS IN THE SUPRIME-CAM 2.1 SQ DEG FIELD:
CONSTRAINTS ON ΩM AND σ8
1
TAKASHI HAMANA2,3, SATOSHI MIYAZAKI2, KAZUHIRO SHIMASAKU4, HISANORI FURUSAWA2, MAMORU
DOI5, MASARU HAMABE6, KATSUMI IMI6, MASAHIKO KIMURA8, YUTAKA KOMIYAMA2, FUMIAKI
NAKATA2, NORIO OKADA2, SADANORI OKAMURA4, MASAMI OUCHI4, MAKI SEKIGUCHI8, MASAFUMI
YAGI2 AND NAOKI YASUDA2
[email protected]
3
0
0
2
l
u
J
1
1
2
v
0
5
4
0
1
2
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Submitted to ApJ; Draft version November 10, 2018
ABSTRACT
We present measurements of the cosmic shear correlation in the shapes of galaxies in the Suprime-Cam 2.1
deg2 Rc-band imaging data. As an estimator of the shear correlation originated from the gravitational lensing,
we adopt the aperture mass variance, which most naturally decomposes the correlation signal into E and B (non-
gravitational lensing) modes. We detect a non-zero E mode variance on scales between θap = 2′ and 40′. We also
detect a small but non-zero B mode variance on scales larger than θap > 5′. We compare the measured E mode
variance to the model predictions in CDM cosmologies using maximum likelihood analysis. A four-dimensional
space is explored, which examines σ8, Ωm, Γ (the shape parameter of the CDM power spectrum) and ¯zs (a mean
redshift of galaxies). We include three possible sources of error: statistical noise, the cosmic variance estimated
using numerical experiments, and a residual systematic effect estimated from the B mode variance. We derive joint
constraints on two parameters by marginalizing over the two remaining parameters. We obtain an upper limit of
Γ < 0.5 for ¯zs > 0.9 (68% confidence). For a prior Γ ∈ [0.1,0.4] and ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4], we find σ8 = (0.50+0.35
- 0.37
m
for Ωm + ΩΛ = 1 and σ8 = (0.51+0.29
for ΩΛ = 0 (95% confidence). If we take the currently popular ΛCDM
model (Ωm = 0.3, Ωλ = 0.7, Γ = 0.21), we obtain a one-dimensional confidence interval on σ8 for the 95.4% level,
0.62 < σ8 < 1.32 for ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4]. Information on the redshift distribution of galaxies is key to obtaining a
correct cosmological constraint. An independent constraint on Γ from other observations is useful to tighten the
constraint.
Subject headings: cosmology: observations -- cosmological parameters -- dark matter -- gravitational lensing
- 0.16)Ω
- 0.16)Ω
- 0.34
m
1. INTRODUCTION
Cosmic shear, that is coherent distortions in distant galaxy
images resulting from weak gravitational lensing by large-scale
structures, has been recognized as a powerful tool for cosmol-
ogy because it directly probes matter distribution regardless of
any relation between mass and light (for reviews see, Mellier
1999, Bartelmann & Schneider 2001). Since the first reports of
the detection of cosmic shear correlations (Van Waerbeke et al.,
2000; Witteman et al., 2000; Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000;
Kaiser, Wilson & Luppino 2000; Maoli et al. 2001; ), cosmic
shear statistics have become a promising probe of cosmologi-
cal parameters. Indeed, recent measurements of cosmic shear
correlation have put useful constraints on the matter density pa-
rameter Ωm and the matter power spectrum normalization σ8
(Maoli et al. 2001; Bacon et al. 2002; Van Waerbeke et al. 2001;
2002; Hoekstra et al. 2002a; Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders 2002b;
Brown et al. 2003; Jarvis et al. 2003). As the cosmic shear cor-
relation is primarily sensitive to density fluctuation at interme-
diate redshifts (0.2 < z < 0.7) and on scales from quasi-linear
to nonlinear (1 < θ < 50 arcmin corresponding to comoving
scales of 0.38 < r < 19.2h- 1Mpc at z = 0.5 for a cosmological
model with Ωm = 0.3 and ΩΛ = 0.7), it provides cosmological
information that is independent of other observations, such as
galaxy clustering, cluster number counts, and the cosmic mi-
crowave background anisotropies, and thus is complementary
to these techniques.
Cosmic shear measurement is not an easy task; it requires
a rigorous observation strategy, specifically, a deep and wide-
field survey with very high image quality. A large number den-
sity of distant galaxies, ideally ng > 30arcmin- 2, is needed to
suppress random noise due to the intrinsic galaxy ellipticity.
A wide survey area is necessary for suppression of the cos-
mic variance. In addition, good seeing conditions are essential
for precise measurements of a galaxy's shape. Suprime-Cam,
a wide-field camera mounted on the prime focus of the 8.2-m
Subaru telescope, is an almost ideal camera for a weak lensing
survey. It has a field of view of 34′ × 27′ with 0′′.202 pixel- 1.
The median seeing in the Ic band, monitored over a period of
one-and-a-half years, is reported to be ∼ 0.6 arcsec (Miyazaki
et al. 2002b). Subaru's light-gathering power enables a com-
plete magnitude of RC = 25.2 (the turn-around of galaxy counts)
to be obtained by a 30-min exposure, which provides a galaxy
number density of ng ∼ 33arcmin- 2, after object selection (see
§3). These advantages allow a weak lensing survey to be car-
1 Based on data collected at Subaru Telescope, which is operated by the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan.
2 National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan
3 Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, 98bis Boulevard Arago, F 75014 Paris, France
4 Department of Astronomy, University of Tokyo, Bunkyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan
5 Institute of Astronomy, University of Tokyo, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan
6 Department of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Japan Women's University, Bunkyo, Tokyo 112-8681, Japan
7 Communication Network Center (Tsu-den) , Mitsubishi Electric, Amagasaki, Hyogo 661-8661, Japan
8 Institute for Cosmic Ray Research, University of Tokyo, Kashiwa,Chiba 277-8582, Japan
1
1992), the top-hat shear variance (Bernardeau, Van Waerbeke
& Mellier 1997) and the aperture mass variance (Schneider et
al. 1998). For our maximum likelihood analysis, we adopt the
aperture mass variance, which has the very useful property that
it naturally carries out E/B mode decomposition (Schneider et
al. 1998; Crittenden et al. 2002; Pen, Van Waerbeke & Mellier
2002). As gravitational lensing produces only E mode shear,
E/B mode decomposition allows contamination from B mode
shear (which is not caused by gravitational lensing) to be sup-
pressed, and the amplitude of the B mode variance can be used
to estimate the amplitude of the systematic error. The aperture
mass is defined by
Map =Z d2θ U(θ)κ(θ),
where κ(θ) is the lensing convergence field, and U(θ) is the
compensated filter, for which we adopt the following function
proposed by Schneider et al. (1998)
U(θ) =
9
πθ2
ap(cid:18)1 -
θ2
θ2
ap(cid:19)(cid:18) 1
3
θ2
θ2
ap(cid:19) ,
for θ < θap, and 0 otherwise. It should be emphasized that this
filter probes an effective scale of θap/5 not θap. The aperture
mass can be calculated directly from the tangential shear γt (the
tangential component of shear defined in the local frame con-
necting the aperture center to a galaxy), without the need for a
mass reconstruction, by
where Q(θ) is given from U(θ):
Map =Z d2θ Q(θ)γt(θ),
θ2Z dθ′ U(θ′) - U(θ).
2
Q(θ) =
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
2
T. Hamana et al.
ried out efficiently.
In this paper we present the results of our analysis of Rc-
band imaging data from a Suprime-Cam 2.1 deg2 field. This
field is composed of nine pointings in a 3 × 3 mosaic configu-
ration which covers a contiguous 1.64◦ × 1.28◦ area. A great
advantage of these data is their very good and homogeneous
image quality over the whole field, which allows us to obtain
secure weak lensing measurements. These data were also used
for the first halo number counts using the weak lensing tech-
nique (Miyazaki et al., 2002a), which demonstrated that a weak
lensing halo survey is indeed a promising way to study the dis-
tribution and evolution of large-scale structures. In this paper,
we concentrate on the measurement of cosmic shear correla-
tions caused by large-scale structures. We carry out a full max-
imum likelihood analysis of the cosmic shear correlation over
four parameters, Ωm, σ8, Γ (a shape parameter of the Cold Dark
Matter power spectrum) and ¯zs (the mean redshift of the source
galaxy distribution). We derive joint constraints on two param-
eters by marginalizing over the two remaining parameters, and
obtain a constraint on Ωm and σ8. We also obtain an upper
limit on Γ. Confidence intervals on σ8 for the currently popu-
lar ΛCDM model (Ωm = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7 and Γ = 0.21) are also
derived.
The outline of this paper is as follows. In §2 we briefly dis-
cuss the theory of cosmic shear statistics and summarize the
analytical formulas that are used to compute the theoretical pre-
dictions. Details of the observations and data are described in
§3. A galaxy shape analysis is presented in §4. Measurement of
the cosmic shear correlation is presented in §5. The measured
cosmic shear correlation signal is compared with the theoretical
prediction using maximum likelihood analysis in §6. Finally,
§7 presents a summary and discussion. In the Appendix, we
discuss tests of the anisotropic point spread function correction
procedure in some detail.
2. BASICS OF COSMIC SHEAR CORRELATION
In this section, we provide a basic description of the theory of
the cosmic shear correlation (see the reviews by Mellier 1999;
Bartelmann & Schneider 2001 for details).
The observable shear two-point statistics can be related to the
convergence power spectrum defined by
Pκ(l) =
9Ω2
m
c (cid:19)4
4 (cid:18) H0
Z χH
0
a(χ) (cid:21)2
dχ (cid:20)W (χ)
Pδ(cid:20)
l
fK(χ)
; χ(cid:21) ,
(1)
where H0 is the Hubble parameter, χ is the radial comoving
distance, χH corresponds to the horizon, a(χ) is the scale fac-
tor and fK(χ) is the comoving angular diameter distance. Pδ(k)
is the matter power spectrum, for which we adopt the fitting
function of the CDM power spectrum given by Bardeen et
al. (1986), but we treat the shape parameter, Γ, as a free pa-
rameter. To take into account the effect of nonlinear growth of
the density field, which has a significant impact on the shear
correlation function on scales below one degree (Jain & Seljak
1997), we use the fitting function of Peacock & Dodds (1996).
W (χ) is the source weighted distance ratio given by,
W (χ) =Z χH
χ
dχ′ ns(χ′)
,
(2)
fK(χ′ - χ)
fK(χ)
here ns(χ) is the normalized redshift distribution of source
galaxies, which we discuss later (§6.1).
Several real space estimators of the shear correlation have
been proposed, including: the shear two-point correlation func-
tion (Blandford et al. 1991; Miralda-Escude 1991; Kaiser
The aperture mass variance is related to the convergence power
spectrum eq. (1) by
hM2
api(θap) = 2πZ dl l Pκ(l)(cid:20)
12
π(lθap)2 J4(lθap)(cid:21)2
,
(7)
where J4 is a fourth-order Bessel function of the first kind.
We compute the aperture mass variances from the shear cor-
relation functions using relations eqs. (11) and (12). This ap-
proach has some advantages over direct measurement in that (i)
it is the least affected by defects in the data, such as masking by
bright stars, (ii) and it does not depend on the geometry of the
data; (iii) thus it uses all information in the data (Hoekstra et al.
2002b). The two shear two-point correlation functions that are
measured are:
i, j wiw jγt,iγt, j
i, j wiw j
i, j wiw jγr,iγr, j
i, j wiw j
ξtt(θ) = PNs
PNs
ξrr(θ) = PNs
PNs
,
,
(8)
(9)
where θ = xi - xj, Ns is the number of source galaxies, γt and
γr are the tangential and 45◦ rotated shear in the frame con-
necting the pair of galaxies, and w is a weight that expresses
the reliability of the shape measurement for each galaxy (dis-
cussed in §4). For the following discussion, it is useful to de-
fine, ξ+(θ) and ξ- (θ), which are the sum and difference of the
and
-
Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field
3
shear two-point correlation functions defined by eqs. (8) and
(9), respectively
ξ+(θ) = ξtt(θ) + ξrr(θ),
and ξ- (θ) = ξtt(θ) - ξrr(θ).
(10)
The E and B modes' (which we denote by M⊥) aperture mass
variances are derived by integration of these correlation func-
tions with an appropriate window
and
hM2
hM2
0
api(θap) = πZ 2θap
⊥i(θap) = πZ 2θap
0
dθ θhW(θ)ξ+(θ) + W(θ)ξ- (θ)i ,
dθ θhW(θ)ξ+(θ) -
W(θ)ξ- (θ)i ,
(11)
(12)
where W and W are given in Crittenden et al. (2002); useful
analytical expressions were derived by Schneider et al. (2002).
FIG. 1. -- Top panel: the size distribution of objects used for the cosmic
shear measurements. Bottom panel: Average tr(Pγ ) as a function of rg.
FIG. 2. -- Top panel:the solid histogram shows the number counts of objects
used for the cosmic shear measurements, while the dashed histogram is for the
product of the number counts and the average weight. Bottom panel: Average
weight as a function of RC magnitude.
3. DATA
Observations were made with the Suprime-Cam on the Sub-
aru 8.2-m telescope during its commissioning phase. We used a
field size of 2.1 deg2, which was the largest size possible during
that period.
The field that we chose was centered at R.A. = 16h04m43s,
decl. = +43◦12′19′′(J2000.0). We obtained Rc-band images on
the nights of 2001 April 23-25. Suprime-Cam has a field of
view of 34′× 27′with a scale 0′′.202 pixel- 1 (see Miyazaki et
al. 2002 for instrumental details of Suprime-Cam). Nine con-
tiguous fields were observed in a 3×3 mosaic configuration.
Each exposure on a given field was offset by 1 ∼ 2′from the
other exposures to allow the removal of cosmic rays and de-
fects on the CCDs. The total exposure time of each field was
1800 sec (360 sec × 5).
We apply the weak lensing mass reconstruction technique to
these data (Miyazaki et al. 2002a). The number counts of high
peaks (above 5-σ), which represent massive dark halos, in the
reconstructed convergence field is 4.9 ± 2.3, where the Gaus-
sian smoothing radius of the convergence map is 1′. This result
is consistent with predictions thatassume the Press-Schechter
mass function (Press & Schechter 1974; we used the version
modified by Sheth & Tormen 1999) and the universal NFW
halo profile (Navarro, Frenk & White 1996) under the cluster
normalized CDM cosmology. Thus, it is unlikely that this field
is significantly far from the cosmic mean.
The individual images were de-biased and then flattened us-
ing a median of all the object frames taken during the observing
run. Stacking the dithered images is not a trivial procedure be-
cause of the large distortion in the optics, combined with the
alignment error of each CCD with displacement and rotation
from its nominal position. We present here an outline of how
to obtain parameters that transform a CCD coordinate to a stan-
dard celestial coordinate. First, we employ a geometrical model
of the field distortion using a fourth order polynomial function
R - r
r
= ar + br2 + cr3 + dr4,
(13)
where R and r are the distance from the optical axis in units of
pixels on the face of the CCD and in celestial coordinates, re-
spectively. We typically changed the telescope pointing by 1∼2
arcmin between successive exposures to fill the gaps between
the CCDs. The offset and rotation of the telescope pointing
between the exposures are also set as free parameters. All of
these parameters can be determined by minimizing the distance
of the same stars identified on different exposures. To do this,
we adopt a modified version of mosaic f it, which is one of the
functions of the imcat suite.
Once we have obtained these parameters, we use them to
warp each image before stacking. The residual of the distances
between corresponding star images is a measure of the error of
this mosaic-stacking procedure. The RMS value of the resid-
uals is typically about 0.5 pixels. As shown in Miyazaki et
al. (2002b), distortion parameters obtained in this way match
quite well with the residuals predicted by optical ray-tracing
programs, which implies that our solution is satisfactory.
The RMS residual of 0.5 pixels is due to several effects that
are not considered in the simple model, including atmospheric
dispersion and asymmetric aberration of the optics. We note,
however, that the residual vector changes smoothly with posi-
tion and can be well modeled as a third order bi-linear poly-
nomial function of position. This model then gives a fine cor-
rection to our geometrical solution described above. The mea-
4
T. Hamana et al.
surements of the displacement and the warping of the images
are carried out using fitgeometry2 and mosaicmap of imcat, re-
spectively, as described by Kaiser et al. (1999). As a result of
these procedures, the final residual typically decreases down to
0.07 pixel RMS (14 milliarcsec). To derive a better astromet-
ric solution, an external reference star catalog would have to
be used. However, we simply employ each first exposure as a
reference and accept the resulting moderate astrometric accu-
racy, as it does not significantly affect the weak lensing analy-
sis. The individual images are then warped using the solution,
and stacked. The seeing in the resulting image is 0′′.68 FWHM
and the scatter among the fields is quite small at 0′′.04 rms.
To carry out object detection, photometry and shape mea-
surements of objects, we use hfindpeaks, apphot and getshapes
of the imcat suite, which are an implementation of Kaiser et
al. (1995). Catalogs created for the nine fields are registered
using stars in the overlapping regions to generate a final cata-
log whose total field of view is 1.64◦× 1.28◦. Differences in
the photometric zero point among the fields due to variation in
the sky conditions (in turn, due to thin cirrus and differing air
mass) are compensated for at this stage, but the adjustment is
not significant (∼ 0.05 mag).
We adopt slightly different object selection criteria to those
used by Miyazaki et al. (2002a) to optimize our cosmic shear
correlation measurement. Our criteria are (i) 22.5 < Rc < 26.
(ii) The signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio, nu, calculated in imcat, ex-
ceeds 7 (Erben et al. 2001). (iii) The image size is larger than
the PSF size, rg > 1.45 ∼ 1.65, where rg is a measure of the
size of objects (in pixel units) yielded by imcat. The PSF size is
identified from the stellar branch in the size-magnitude (rg-Rc)
plane. The PSF size varies slightly from pointing to pointing
because of changes in the seeing conditions. (iv) Objects with
rh > 10 pixels (where rh is the half light radius) are considered
too large and removed. (v) Highly elliptical objects, where the
observed ellipticity, eobs > 0.5, are removed. (vi) Objects that
have a close companion, with a separation of less than 10 pixels
(≃ 2 arcsec), are removed to avoid the problem of overlapping
isophotes reported by Van Waerbeke et al. (2000). The num-
ber of objects that pass these various selection criteria (i)-(vi) is
249,071 (32.9 arcmin- 2).
Van Waerbeke et al. (2000) reported that regions where data
from different CCDs are stacked together as a result of offsets
between exposures (specifically, the edges of CCDs) can poten-
tially produce discontinuities in the properties of the field and
thus make the PSF correction difficult. This effect could cause a
systematic error in the cosmic shear correlation measurement.
Therefore, we decided to mask such regions. That is, we use
only objects that were observed by the same CCD. About 35%
of the objects are removed by this masking, and the number of
objects in the final catalog is 161,740. The image size distribu-
tion and magnitude distribution of the catalog are shown in the
upper panel of Figure 1 and Figure 2, respectively.
4. GALAXY SHAPE ANALYSIS
The observed ellipticity of galaxies is measured from the
weighted quadrupole moments Ii j of the surface brightness
f (θ):
(14)
where WG(θ) is the Gaussian window function. Estimating
the shear, γ, from the observed ellipticities, eobs, involves two
eobs =(cid:18) I11 -
I22
I11 + I22
,
I12
I11 + I22(cid:19) ,
Ii j =Z d2θ WG(θ)θiθ j f (θ),
steps: First, the point spread function (PSF) anisotropy is cor-
rected using the star images as references,
e = eobs - Psm
P∗
sm
e∗
obs,
(15)
sm)- 1e∗
where Psm is the smear polarisability tensor, which is mostly
obs was calculated for
diagonal (Kaiser et al. 1995). (P∗
stars scattered over the field of view. We use unsaturated stars
selected by the following criteria: (i) 20.6 < Rc < 23.0 (us-
ing fainter stars than this does not change the results, see the
Appendix). Note that the saturation level identified from the
size-magnitude (rg-Rc) plane is Rc = 19.5 ∼ 20.5 which corre-
lates with the seeing (with a fainter saturation level for a better
seeing). (ii) nu > 15. (iii) The image size is within a narrow
range of the seeing size, rg∗ - 0.05 < rg < rg∗ + 0.05, where
rg∗ denotes the central rg value (in pixel units) of the stellar
branch in the rg-Rc plane. rg∗ varies from pointing to pointing
and is rg∗ = 1.27 ∼ 1.52. (iv) Highly elliptical objects, with an
observed ellipticity, e > 0.3, are removed. As a result, the av-
erage number density of the selected stars is about 1/arcmin2,
and there are on average about 60 stars in each chip. How-
ever, the chip-by-chip variation in the number of stars is quite
large; some chips have only ∼20 stars because of the presence
of a large saturated star in the field. We make the first order
obs as a function of posi-
bi-polynomial fit to values of (P∗
tion (a second order fit does not change the results, see the Ap-
pendix). To make this fit, we use the efit command in imcat, and
flux weighting is not applied. This function is used in eq. (15)
to correct the ellipticities of faint galaxies. This correction is
made with the ecorrect command in imcat. Note that each
CCD chip is treated independently in this procedure. We found
that a first order fit corrects the PSF anisotropy well, and fur-
thermore does not introduce a systematic artificial residual due
to the wings of a higher order fit (Van Waerbeke et al. 2002),
provided that overlapped CCD regions are masked. The RMS
value of the ellipticities of the reference stars, he∗2i1/2, is re-
duced from 2.8% to 1.0% as a result of the correction. Note
that the RMS before the correction is already small, because
of the superb image quality of the Subaru telescope. Figure 3
shows the star ellipticities before (left panel) and after (right
panel) the anisotropic PSF correction from one pointing. The
observed ellipticities not only have a large scatter but also show
a systematic effect. After the PSF correction this tendency is
removed and the corrected star ellipticities are distributed sym-
metrically around zero with a small scatter.
sm)- 1e∗
FIG. 3. -- Ellipticities distribution of stars, before (left) and after (right)
the correction for PSF anisotropies is made. The mean and dispersion of the
ellipticites (e) of all the stars are shown inside the frame.
Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field
5
of a certain observable, hAi, is calculated asPN
instead of PN
where α2 is the variance of all the objects in the catalog and
α ≃ 0.4 here. Under the weighting scheme, an averaged value
i=1 wi
i=1 Ai/N. The lower panel of Figure 2 shows the
averaged weight as a function of Rc magnitude. As expected,
less weight is given to fainter objects because the shape mea-
surements of these objects are noisier. The dashed histogram
in the upper panel of Figure 2 plots the product of the num-
ber counts and the average weight and shows that the effective
counts peak at Rc ∼ 24.5.
i=1 wiAi/PN
FIG. 4. -- Components of galaxy ellipticities as a function of the star elliptic-
ity component used for the anisotropic PSF correction. Top and middle panels
show the averaged galaxy ellipticities before and after correction, respectively.
Bottom panels show the ellipticity distribution of galaxies (number per bin)
used for the cosmic shear correlation measurement.
Figure 4 shows the average ellipticity of galaxies as a func-
tion of the value of the star ellipticity used for the anisotropic
PSF correction. The top panels show the observed ellipticities,
and the expected strong correlation is present. Note that for
the majority of galaxies, the PSF anisotropy is very small, as
shown in the bottom panels. The corrected ellipticities plotted
in the middle panels comprise only small values. The averaged
values of the corrected ellipticities are he1i = - 5.0 × 10- 4 and
he2i = 1.8 × 10- 3. Thus, no significant offset is found.
The second step is the isotropic correction, caused by the
window, WG, and the seeing. Luppino & Kaiser (1997) reported
a method to correct the ellipticities for these effects. The pre-
seeing shear γ is described as
FIG. 5. -- Shear correlation functions. Top panel is for ξtt, middle panel for
ξrr, and bottom for the cross correlation ξtr which should vanish if the data are
not contaminated by systematics. The error bars present the statistical error
computed from 100 randomized realizations.
5. COSMIC SHEAR CORRELATIONS
In this section, we present the cosmic shear correlations mea-
sured from the 2.1 deg2 Suprime-Cam data, and discuss their
statistical and possible systematic errors.
The top and middle panels of Figure 5 show the shear cor-
relation functions, ξtt and ξrr, respectively, computed using the
estimator eqs. (8) and (9). The bottom panel presents the cross-
correlation ξtr. The error bars indicate the RMS among 100 ran-
domized realizations, in which the orientations of galaxies are
randomized, and presumably represent the statistical error. In
the following, statistical errors are computed in this manner. As
the two top panels clearly show, we detect non-zero shear corre-
lation signals on scales below 30 arcmin, except for the smallest
two bins. On small scales (θ < 1 arcmin) the number of pairs
corresponding to the separations decreases, and consequently
the signals become noisy and the statistical errors become large.
As the cross-correlation should be zero for a signal due to grav-
itational lensing, it provides a check on systematic effects in
the data. The bottom panel shows that the cross-correlation is
indeed consistent with zero at all scales. This result indicates
γ = P- 1
γ e, Pγ = Psh - P∗
sh
P∗
sm
Psm,
(16)
where Psh is the shear polarisability tensor. The Pγ of individual
galaxies is, however, known to be a noisy estimate, and thus we
adopt the smoothing and weighting method developed by Van
Waerbeke et al.(2000; see also Erben et al. 2001 for a detailed
study of the smoothing scheme). For each object, 20 neigh-
bors are first identified in the rg-Rc plane. A median value of Pγ
among these neighbors is adopted as the smoothed Pγ of the ob-
ject. The averaged tr(Pγ) for all objects is calculated as 0.40 but
Pγ depends on the object size. Figure 1 plots the averaged tr(Pγ)
as a function of rg. This graph shows that the average tr(Pγ) is
almost constant, ∼ 0.65 for rg > 3.5, but becomes smaller for
smaller rg.
As the estimated γ is still noisy, especially for small and faint
objects, it is important to weight the galaxies according to the
uncertainty in the shape measurements. We weight the objects
using the procedure developed by Van Waerbeke et al. (2000;
2002; see also Erben et al. 2001). The variance of raw γ before
the smoothing among the neighbors, σ2
γ, is used to estimate the
weight of each object, w, as
w =
σ2
γ
1
+ α2
(17)
6
T. Hamana et al.
that our PSF corrections perform well and do not introduce a
systematic effect into the data.
galaxies is not sufficient to obtain meaningful statistics. This
possibility should be tested in future studies.
Currently, it is not clear how to correct the E mode vari-
ance, given the observed B mode. We follow Van Waerbeke
et al. (2002b) and add the B mode in quadrature to the uncer-
tainty in the E mode for the maximum likelihood analysis (see
§6).
FIG. 6. -- Upper panel shows the E-mode aperture mass variance hM2
api,
while the lower panel for B-mode aperture mass variance hM2
⊥i. The error
bars present the statistical error computed from 100 randomized realizations.
Let us now turn to the aperture mass variance. We compute
the E and B mode aperture mass variances from the two-point
shear correlation functions via eqs. (11) and (12). We use the
analytic expressions for the window function W and W given in
Schneider et al. (2002). The shear correlation functions defined
by eq. (10) are computed over the range 0.04′ < θ < 90′ on 168
bins equally spaced with a log-interval of ∆log θ = 0.02. The
E and B mode aperture mass variances are plotted in Figure 6.
For the E mode, we detect positive, non-zero signals on scales
larger than θap > 2′. Since, as shown in Figure 5, the two-point
correlation function becomes very noisy on scales smaller than
1 arcmin, and also considering that the aperture mass effec-
tively probes a real scale of ∼ θap/5, we use only the signals on
scales larger than θap = 2 arcmin for our maximum likelihood
analysis in the next section. The amplitude and main features
of the E mode variance are broadly consistent with theoretical
predictions under the cluster normalized CDM cosmology (see
Figure 8).
The B mode aperture mass variance is shown in the lower
panel of Figure 6. Small but non-zero signals are found on
scales larger than 5 arcmin. Currently, the origin of this B mode
variance is not clear. One possibility is incorrect anisotropic
PSF correction. We tested this possibility by repeating the PSF
correction using different procedures, and found no significant
problems (see the Appendix). It is interesting to note that Van
(2002) reported the detection in their data
Waerbeke et al.
⊥i ∼ 3 × 10- 6) on scales
of a non-zero B mode variance (hM2
10′ < θap < 40′, the amplitude of which is very similar to ours.
Note that their survey depth (a limiting magnitude of IAB = 24.5)
was slightly shallower than ours. On the other hand, Hoekstra
et al. (2002b) reported a vanishing B mode variance on scales
larger than 10 arcmin in their shallow data (Rc < 24). These
results suggest that the current procedures for galaxy shape cor-
rections become problematic for fainter objects. Unfortunately,
we cannot test this possibility because the number of brighter
FIG. 7. -- Cross-correlation coefficient r(θ, θ′) for the statistical noise as
a function of scale θ for three scales, θ′ = 2.5 (filled circles with solid line),
6.3 (filled squares with dashed line)and 20 arcmin (filled triangles with long-
dashed line).
6. LIKELIHOOD ANALYSIS
In this section, we compare the measured aperture mass vari-
ance to the model predictions in CDM cosmologies using max-
imum likelihood analysis. We present constraints on cosmo-
logical parameters obtained from the cosmic shear variance ob-
served in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 degree2 field data.
6.1. Source redshift distribution
To compute the theoretical prediction of the aperture mass
variance using eq. (7), we need to fix the redshift distribution of
the source galaxies. However, no redshift information about the
galaxies in our catalog is available. Therefore, we decided to
adopt a parameterized model that provides a good fit to the red-
shift distribution of deep surveys (e.g., Hoekstra et al. 2002b;
Van Waerbeke et al. 2002),
ns(z) =
β
z∗(cid:19)α
z∗Γ(cid:2)(1 + α)/β(cid:3)(cid:18) z
exp"- (cid:18) z
z∗(cid:19)β# ,
(18)
with α = 2 and β = 1.5. The mean redshift relates to z∗ as
¯zs = z∗Γ(cid:2)(2 + α)/β(cid:3)/Γ(cid:2)(1 + α)/β(cid:3) and for these values of α
and β, it gives ¯zs ≃ 1.5z∗. The median redshift is approximately
given by zmed ≃ 1.4z∗. We treat the mean redshift of the distri-
bution as a model parameter in the maximum likelihood analy-
sis.
6.2. Maximum likelihood analysis
In performing the maximum likelihood analysis, we basi-
cally follow the procedure described in Van Waerbeke et al.
(2002; see also Hoekstra et al. 2002b). The theoretical pre-
dictions are computed in a four-dimensional space, but we re-
strict the parameter space to realistic but conservative ranges:
Ωm ∈ [0.1,1] (either ΩΛ = 0 or Ωm + ΩΛ = 1), σ8 ∈ [0.2,2],
Γ ∈ [0.05,0.75] and ¯zs ∈ [0.3,2.5] with a sampling of 19 × 19 ×
11 × 23. In what follows, we refer to this parameter range (Ωm,
σ8, Γ, ¯zs) as the default prior space. The model predictions are
then interpolated with an oversampling fivefold higher in each
dimension.
Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field
7
distribution from the observer (z = 0) to high z (z ∼ 3) is gen-
erated by stacking 10 snapshot outputs from the N-body sim-
ulations. N-body data from the Very Large Simulation (VLS)
which followed 5123 particles in a cubic box of 479h1Mpc on a
side, carried out by the Virgo Consortium (Jenkins et al. 2001;
Yoshida, Sheth & Diaferio 2001) are used. A ΛCDM model
(Ωm = 0.3, Ωλ = 0.7 and h = 0.7) is assumed with the CDM ini-
tial power spectrum computed using CMBFAST (Seljak & Zal-
darriaga 1996). The multiple-lens plane ray-tracing algorithm
is used to follow the light rays (Hamana & Mellier 2001, see
also Jain, Seljak & White 2000 for the basic theory). The lens-
ing convergence and shear is computed for 10242 pixels with
a pixel size of 0.25 arcmin for a single source plane of zs = 1.
We compute the covariance matrix due to the cosmic variance
from 36 random mock observations (but without the intrinsic
ellipticity of galaxy images) generated by the numerical exper-
iment. As the ratio of the non-Gaussian to Gaussian contribu-
tions to cosmic variance does not vary significantly with the
underlying cosmology (Van Waerbeke et al. 2002), the cosmic
variance also does not play an important role at all scales; given
the large residual error from the B mode variance at large scales,
we use the covariance matrix obtained from the ΛCDM numer-
ical experiment regardless of the cosmological model consid-
ered. Figure 8 shows the aperture mass variance with error bars
from the statistical error only (the left error bar on each point)
and a sum of the statistical, systematic and cosmic variance in
quadrature (the right error bar). On small scales, statistical error
dominates [the statistical error (left) is comparable to the total
error (right)], while at large scales the systematic error domi-
nates given the large B mode variance.
FIG. 9. -- The gray-scale shows the ∆χ2 map on Γ and ¯zs obtained after
a marginalization over Ωm ∈ [0.1, 1] and σ8 ∈ [0.2, 2]. A darker gray-scale
indicates a lower ∆χ2 value (thus more likely). Contours indicate 68.3 and
95.4% confidence levels.
6.3. Results and discussion
Here, we present two-parameter space constraints obtained
from marginalizations over the two remaining parameters. Fig-
ure 9 shows the likelihood map on the Γ-¯zs plane where the de-
fault prior is applied for Ωm and σ8. This Figure clearly presents
the correlation between Γ and ¯zs; that is, a flatter (steeper)
power spectrum (a larger (smaller) Γ) prefers a lower (higher)
¯zs, (this was reported previously by Van Waerbeke et al. 2002).
The message here is that, given a relatively narrow range of sig-
nal detection (2′ < θap < 40′) with large error bars (as shown in
Figure 8), the slope of the power spectrum and its normalization
are degenerate. Similar considerations apply to a constraint on
FIG. 8. -- The aperture mass variance. For each measurement point, the
left error bars show statistical error while right error bars present a sum of
the statistical error, a residual systematic error estimated from B mode vari-
ance and the cosmic variance in quadrature. On smaller scales, statistical error
dominates, while on larger scales residual error dominates. Comparing with
them, the cosmic variance does not have a serious impact on the final error on
all scales. The solid curve shows, for an illustrative example, the theoretical
prediction of CDM model with Ωm = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7, Γ = 0.21, σ8 = 0.85 and
¯zs = 1.
For a given theoretical model, we compute the χ2 (log-
likelihood)
χ2 = (di - mi)C- 1(di - mi)T ,
(19)
where di is the measurement at scale θi, and mi is the corre-
sponding theoretical prediction. Confidence values are com-
puted from this χ2 in the standard manner. The covariance ma-
trix consists of three contributions
C(θi, θ j) = Cs(θi, θ j) +Cb(θi, θ j) +Ccv(θi, θ j),
(20)
where Cs, Cb and Ccv are the statistical error, the residual sys-
tematics, and the cosmic variance, respectively, computed by
the procedures described below. The statistical error was com-
puted from the 100 randomized realizations catalog. Figure 7
shows the cross-correlation coefficient for the statistical noise
for three scales, 2.5, 6.3, and 20 arcmin, with other scales.
The non-zero B mode variance could indicate the existence of a
residual systematic, although its origin is not yet clear. It would
be natural to consider that a residual systematic of similar size
also exists in the E mode. However, there is not yet a clear
scheme to deal with this residual systematic. Therefore, we
adopt the simple and conservative procedure described in Van
Waerbeke (2002). We quadratically add the B mode variance to
the error of the signal. As the E and B mode covariance matri-
ces for the statistical noise are identical, the diagonal part of the
matrix Cb is given by the B mode signal and off-diagonal terms
follow the same correlation properties as the E mode.
Estimation of the cosmic variance is more complicated, be-
cause the observed scales are in the quasi-linear to nonlinear
regime and thus random Gaussian theory cannot be applied.
The cosmic variance is estimated using weak lensing numer-
ical experiments, which are performed using a ray-tracing tech-
nique combined with large N-body simulations; the details are
described in Hamana et al. (in preparation; see also Menard et
al. 2003; Takada & Hamana 2003). Briefly, the dark matter
8
T. Hamana et al.
σ8-Γ, as shown in the lower left panel of Figure 10. Although
the constraint on Γ and ¯zs is not as tight, we can see from Figure
9 that for ¯zs > 0.9 (> 0.7) a flatter power spectrum with Γ > 0.5,
would be ruled out at more than the 68% confidence level for
the flat (open) model.
FIG. 10. -- The gray-scale shows the ∆χ2 on two-parameter space obtained
after a marginalization over two remaining parameters for the default prior, a
darker gray-scale for a lower ∆χ2 value (thus more likely). Plots are for σ8-¯zs
(upper left), Ωm-¯zs (upper right), σ8-Γ (lower left) and Ωm-Γ (lower right).
Contours indicate 68.3, 95.4 and 99.73% confidence levels.
FIG. 11. -- Constrains on Ωm and σ8 obtained after a marginalization over
Γ ∈ [0.1, 0.4] and ¯zs ∈ [0.6, 1.4]. Contours indicate 68.3, 95.4 and 99.73%
confidence levels.
Figure 10 shows the degeneracy among the four parameters.
The left panels clearly show the strong degeneracy between σ8
and ¯zs (or Γ). From these plots the following two points be-
come clear: (i) redshift information about the source galaxies is
crucial to obtaining a tight constraint on σ8 (Bernardeau et al.
1997; Jain & Seljak 1997). (ii) A constraint on Γ from other in-
dependent observations (such as galaxy clustering and/or CMB
anisotropies) is very useful to break the degeneracy among the
parameters. The right panels of Figure 10 show the same likeli-
hood maps but for Ωm. The constraints on Ωm are weaker than
those on σ8, because the cosmic shear correlation is less sen-
sitive to Ωm than σ8 (Bernardeau et al. 1997; Jain & Seljak
1997).
In addition to the default prior, we adopt other priors from
information obtained from other observations. We estimate the
mean redshift of our galaxy catalog using redshift distributions
from other deep surveys. The redshift distributions of faint
galaxies in the Hubble Deep Fields North and South have been
estimated using spectroscopic and photometric redshift tech-
niques by several groups (Fernández-Soto et al. 1999; Cohen
et al. 2000; Fontana et al. 1999; 2000; Yahata et al. 2000).
Note that there is a small discrepancy between the two datasets,
which is probably due to field-to-field variation. If we assume
that our galaxy catalog has a similar redshift distribution to
the Hubble Deep Field data, the mean redshift of our catalog
(22.5 < Rc < 26) is estimated to be larger than z = 1. On the
other hand, the redshift distribution of galaxies in the Subaru
deep survey field has been estimated using the photometric red-
shift technique with B V Rc i′ z′ data (Furusawa 2002; Furu-
sawa et al.
in preparation, see also Kashikawa et al. 2003).
They found that the mean redshift of faint galaxies (R > 24) is
systematically lower than the HDF data. Note that the discrep-
ancy is not very significant, given the large error bars due to
small-number statistics. If we take the redshift distribution of
the Subaru deep survey data, the median redshift of our cata-
log can be as low as z = 0.7. The difference between these two
estimates suggests that the field-to-field variation can be quite
large. It is also important to take into account that the weight-
ing of galaxies might change the redshift distribution in a non-
trivial manner. Considering these points, we adopt a conserva-
tive constraint of ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4], and two tighter constraints of
¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.2] and ¯zs ∈ [0.8,1.4] to determine the impact of the
source redshift information. We constrain Γ using the studies
of galaxy clustering by the SDSS (Dodelson et al. 2002; Szalay
et al. 2001) and the APM survey (Eisenstein & Zaldarria 2001).
As there is a wide dispersion in Γ values among these stud-
ies, whereas the statistical error bars in each measurement are
small, we adopt a conservative constraint, Γ ∈ [0.1,0.4], which
covers the 68% confidence intervals of these three studies. We
also take an extreme constraint of Γ = 0.21, where the 68% con-
fidence intervals of the three studies overlap, to determine how
well independent information on Γ improves the constraint on
Ωm and σ8.
Figure 11 shows the constraint on Ωm and σ8 obtained from
marginalization over Γ ∈ [0.1,0.4] and ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4]. As ex-
pected, a strong degeneracy between Ωm and σ8 is found. The
confidence intervals of Ωm and σ8 from various priors are sum-
marized in Table 1.
It is clear from this Table that informa-
tion about the redshift distribution of galaxies and Γ can indeed
give a tighter constraint on Ωm and σ8. Although the current
constraint is not very tight, we may rule out the following two
models.The COBE normalized high density CDM model (Bunn
& White 1997, i.e., Ωm = 1, Ωλ = 0, σ8 = 1.2) is ruled out at
more than the 99.9% confidence level. This model predicts too
high an amplitude at all scales. For the open model, low density
models with Ωm < 0.2 are ruled out at more than the 68% con-
fidence level. As pointed out by Van Waerbeke et al. (2002; see
also Schneider et al. 1998), the incompatibility is because such
low density models predict very large power at small scales.
We obtain the following fitting function for the 95% confidence
contours plotted in Figure 11,
σ8 = (0.50+0.35
- 0.16)Ω
- 0.37
m
,
for Ωm + ΩΛ = 1,
(21)
Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field
9
95.4% ONE-(TWO-)PARAMETER CONFIDENCE INTERVALS OBTAINED FROM THE APERTURE MASS VARIANCE, ∆χ
TABLE 1
2 = 4.00 (6.17), OF Ωm
AND σ8 FOR DIFFERENT PRIORS. (...) INDICATES THAT NO CONSTRAINT IS PLACED WITHIN THE INTERVALS 0.1 < Ωm < 1.0 AND
0.2 < σ8 < 2.0.
Priors
Γ
0.21
hzsi
∈ [0.6,1.4] ∈ [0.05,0.75]
∈ [0.6,1.4] ∈ [0.1,0.4]
∈ [0.6,1.4]
∈ [0.6,1.2] ∈ [0.05,0.75]
∈ [0.6,1.2] ∈ [0.1,0.4]
∈ [0.6,1.2]
∈ [0.8,1.4] ∈ [0.05,0.75]
∈ [0.8,1.4] ∈ [0.1,0.4]
∈ [0.8,1.4]
0.21
0.21
Ωm
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
... (...)
Ωm + ΩΛ = 1
σ8
ΩΛ = 0
Ωm
σ8
> 0.22 (...)
> 0.29 (> 0.26)
0.33 -- 1.92 (> 0.31)
> 0.24 (> 0.21)
> 0.31 (> 0.29)
> 0.37 (> 0.23)
> 0.41 (> 0.26)
> 0.43 (> 0.26)
> 0.36 (> 0.24)
> 0.40 (> 0.25)
> 0.43 (> 0.28)
> 0.36 (> 0.21)
0.28 -- 1.44 (0.25 -- 1.56) > 0.39 (> 0.22)
0.32 -- 1.29 (0.31 -- 1.39) > 0.41 (> 0.23)
0.35 -- 1.92 (> 0.33)
0.21 -- 1.65 (< 1.75)
0.22-0.93 (< 1.03)
0.29 -- 0.79 (0.26 -- 0.86)
0.33 -- 0.70 (0.31 -- 0.76)
0.23-0.93 (0.21 -- 1.03)
0.31 -- 0.79 (0.29 -- 0.87)
0.35 -- 0.70 (0.33 -- 0.76)
0.21 -- 0.76 (< 0.81)
0.27 -- 0.63 (0.25 -- 0.68)
0.32 -- 0.55 (0.31 -- 0.61)
and
σ8 = (0.51+0.20
- 0.16)Ω
- 0.34
m
,
for ΩΛ = 0.
(22)
FIG. 12. -- The one-dimensional likelihood function (∆χ2) for σ8 in the flat
ΛCDM cosmological model with Ωm = 0.3 (ΩΛ = 0.7) and Γ = 0.21 for priors
¯zs ∈ [0.6, 1.2] (the solid line) and ¯zs ∈ [0.8, 1.4] (dashed line). The horizontal
dotted lines indicate, form lower to upper, 68.3, 95.4 and 99.73% confidence
levels.
Figure 12 shows the one-dimensional likelihood function for
σ8 in the currently popular flat ΛCDM cosmological model
with Ωm = 0.3 (ΩΛ = 0.7) and Γ = 0.21. The solid curve
is for the prior ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.2], while the dashed curve is for
¯zs ∈ [0.8,1.4]. Specifically, the one-dimensional confidence
intervals of σ8 for the 95.4% level are: 0.68 < σ8 < 1.33
for ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.2], 0.62 < σ8 < 1.02 for ¯zs ∈ [0.8,1.4], and
0.62 < σ8 < 1.32 for ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4]. A strong degeneracy be-
tween σ8 and ¯z is evident. Especially, the upper bound of the σ8
confidence interval is very sensitive to the choice of the lower
limit of the mean redshift. This is also seen in the upper left
panel of Figure 10. From these results we may say that, for the
flat ΛCDM cosmological model, we obtain a relatively reliable
lower bound of σ8 > 0.62 (95.4% confidence) for a reasonable
choice of ¯zs. However, the upper limit is uncertain; it depends
strongly on the choice of the mean redshift. A conservative
conclusion is σ8 < 1.33 (95.4% confidence), but it is tightened
by σ8 < 1.02 if the mean redshift is as large as ¯zs = 0.8.
Our results are broadly consistent with constraints obtained
from other cosmic shear surveys (Maoli et al. 2001; Bacon et
al. 2002; Van Waerbeke et al. 2002; Hoekstra et al. 2002b; Re-
fregier, Rhodes & Groth 2002; Brown et al. 2003; Jarvis et
al. 2003). This consistency is remarkable, given that the data
have been compiled from different instruments, filters and sur-
vey depths. However, there is a spread of confidence intervals
among the surveys. In fact, Bacon et al.(2002) and Van Waer-
beke et al.
(2002) obtained a slightly higher normalization,
σ8 ∼ 0.95 for the ΛCDM model, which is incompatible with our
68.3% confidence interval for ¯zs ∈ [0.8,1.4]. Note that Bacon et
al.(2002) did not decompose the shear correlation function into
E and B modes. Thus, their correlation function could be biased
on the high side. The source of the small discrepancy among
the cosmic shear surveys is unclear: it could be field-to-field
variance, it could arise from the different analysis schemes, or
it could be due to a mis-choice of the redshift distribution of
galaxies. Hirata & Seljak (2003) investigated biases induced
by the conversion between the observed image shape to shear
distortion in current weak lensing analyses. They found that
the non-Gaussianity of the point spread function has a signifi-
cant effect and can lead to up to a 15% error in σ8 depending on
the method of analysis. A wider field, multi-color survey, and
an analysis scheme calibrated using mock observations (as re-
ported by Erben et al. 2000) are needed to improve the accuracy
of the cosmic shear analysis.
It is interesting to compare our results with the σ8 values
obtained from the number density of rich clusters of galaxies
published by many other groups. It should, however, be em-
phasized that there is a large dispersion in σ8 values among
these studies, whereas the errors in each measurement are quite
small. The σ8 values reported range from σ8 . 0.7 (e.g., Bor-
gani et al. 1999; 2001; Seljak 2002; Vianna, Nichol & Liddle
2002) to σ8 & 0.9 (e.g., Eke, Cole & Frenk, 1996; Kitayama &
Suto 1996; 1997; Bahcall & Fan 1998; Pen 1998; Pierpaoli et
al. 2001) for the standard ΛCDM model.
This spread may reflect mainly the uncertainty in the rela-
tion between the mass and X-ray temperature of clusters.
If
we take the prior of ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4], both values are well within
our 95.4% confidence interval. However, larger σ8 values are
not preferred by the constraint obtained from the high-¯zs prior,
10
T. Hamana et al.
but are well within the 95.4% confidence interval of the low-¯zs
prior. Thus, if the mean redshift of our galaxy catalog is as high
as that estimated from the HDF data (¯zs & 1), our result is more
in accord with the lower σ8 value.
Recently, Spergel et al. (2003) combined CMB measure-
ments from WMAP (Bennet et al. 2003 and references therein),
CBI (Person et al. 2002) and ACBAR (Kuo et al 2002), the
galaxy power spectrum from the 2dF galaxy redshift survey
(Percival et al. 2001; Verde et al. 2002), and the measurements
of the Lyman α power spectrum (Croft et al. 2002; Gnedin &
Hamilton 2002) to find the best fit cosmological model and ob-
tained σ8 = 0.84 ±0.04 (68% confidence). This result is in good
agreement with our cosmic shear constraints.
7. SUMMARY
We analyzed the Suprime-Cam 2.1 deg2 Rc-band data and
measured the cosmic shear correlation. Suprime-Cam has a
wide field of view of 34′ × 27′, and its superb imaging quality
provides a very small RMS value of star ellipticities of 2.8%,
which after PSF corrections is reduced to 1.0%. These advan-
tages combined with the large light gathering power of the 8.2-
m Subaru telescope make Suprime-Cam an almost ideal camera
for a weak lensing survey.
For the cosmic shear correlation measurement we used
galaxies with 22.5 < Rc < 26 and an image size larger than
the seeing size. We detected a non-zero cosmic shear two-point
correlation function of up to 40′. However, this result may be
contaminated by shear that is not caused by gravitational lens-
ing. We thus adopted the aperture mass variance, which nat-
urally decomposes the correlation signal into E and B modes
(the latter arises from shear whose origin is not in gravitational
lensing).
We detected a non-zero E mode variance on scales from
θap = 2′ to 40′. As the aperture mass probes a scale of θap/5,
the signals come from effective scales of 0.5′ < θ < 10′, cor-
responding to the quasi-linear to nonlinear regimes. We also
detected a small but non-zero B mode variance on scales larger
than θap > 5′. Currently, the origin of this B mode variance
is not clear. One possibility is an incorrect anisotropic PSF
correction. To test this possibility, we repeated the anisotropic
PSF correction using different procedures (see the Appendix for
details), namely: (i) a second order bi-polynomial fit to PSF,
(ii) a pointing-by-pointing correction without masking over-
lapped regions and (iii) using fainter stars for modeling the PSF
anisotropy. We did not find significant problems in our PSF
correction procedure.
Interestingly, the amplitude of the B mode variance on larger
scales is similar to that found by Van Waerbeke et al. (2002),
though their survey depth was slightly shallower than ours. On
the other hand, Hoekstra et al. (2002b) found a vanishing B
mode variance on scales larger than 10 arcmin in their shal-
low data (Rc < 24). These results may suggest that the current
procedures for galaxy shape correction become problematic for
fainter objects. Future detailed studies of the origin of the B
mode shear are required to understand and suppress this possi-
ble source of residual systematic error. Also, a calibration of
the analysis scheme using mock data is needed to improve the
accuracy of the cosmic shear analysis.
- 0.34
m
- 0.16)Ω
- 0.16)Ω
We performed a maximum likelihood analysis in a four-
dimensional space of σ8, Ωm, Γ and ¯zs. We included three
possible sources of error: the statistical noise, the cosmic vari-
ance, and the residual systematic estimated from the B mode
variance. We derived joint constraints on two parameters by
marginalizing over the two remaining parameters. We ob-
tained a weak upper limit of Γ < 0.5 for ¯zs > 0.9 (68% con-
fidence). We also showed that independent information on Γ
can reduce the degeneracy among the parameters. For the prior
Γ ∈ [0.1,0.4] and ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4], we found σ8 = (0.50+0.35
- 0.37
m
for Ωm + ΩΛ = 1 and σ8 = (0.51+0.29
for ΩΛ = 0 (95.4%
confidence). Although the current constraint is not very tight,
we can rule out the following two models: the COBE normal-
ized high density CDM model (Ωm = 1, Ωλ = 0, σ8 = 1.2) by
more than a 99.9% confidence level, and low density open mod-
els (Ωm < 0.2) by more than 68% confidence. If we take the
currently popular ΛCDM model (Ωm = 0.3, Ωλ = 0.7, Γ = 0.21),
we obtain a one-dimensional confidence interval on σ8 for the
95.4% level, 0.62 < σ8 < 1.32 for ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.4]. This result is
broadly consistent with constraints from other cosmic shear sur-
veys and from the cluster abundance. However, we found that
the confidence interval is sensitive to the choice of the mean
redshift: 0.68 < σ8 < 1.33 for the prior of ¯zs ∈ [0.6,1.2], while
0.62 < σ8 < 1.02 for ¯zs ∈ [0.8,1.4]. The latter is incompati-
ble with the higher σ8 values obtained from some cluster abun-
dance studies. This result clearly demonstrates that informa-
tion on the redshift distribution of the source galaxies is cru-
cial and can significantly tighten the confidence interval of σ8
and Ωm. The improvement of the constraint on σ8 from the
redshift information can be estimated as follows: the cosmic
shear correlation roughly scales with σ8 and the mean redshift
as ξ ∝ σ2.5
, thus the uncertainly in the median redshift con-
tributes to the error in σ8 as δσ8/σ8 = 0.6δzs/zs. Therefore,
the error in σ8 due to uncertainly in the median redshift can be
reduced to 10% by the current photometric redshift technique
(e.g., Bolzonella, Miralles & Pelló 2000).
8 z1.5
s
We would like to thank Y. Mellier for useful discussions and
comments on the manuscript and L. Van Waerbeke for help-
ful discussions about galaxy shape analysis. We also thank the
anonymous referee for detailed and constructive comments on
an earlier manuscript, which improved the paper. T.H. thanks
K. Umetsu and T. Futamase for useful discussions. T.H. F.N.
and M.O. acknowledge support from Research Fellowships of
the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science.
REFERENCES
Bacon, D. J., Refregier, A. R., & Ellis, R. S. 2000, MNRAS, 318, 625
Bacon, D. J., Massey, R. J., Refregier, A. R., & Ellis, R.S. 2002, submitted to
MNRAS (astro-ph/0203134)
Bahcall, N. A., & Fan, X., 1998, ApJ, 504, 1
Bardeen, J., Bond, J., Kaiser, N., & Szalay, A. S., 1986, ApJ, 304, 15
Bartelmann, M., & Schneider, P., 2001, Phys. Rep., 340, 291
Bennett, C. L., et al., 2003, ApJ, submitted (astro-ph/0302207)
Blandford, R. D., Saust, A. B., Brainerd, T. G., & Villumsen, J. V., MNRAS,
Borgani, S., Rosati, P., Tozzi, P., & Norman, C., 1999, A&A, 363, 476
Borgani, S., et al. 2001, ApJ, 561, 13
Brown, M. L., Taylor, A. N., Bacon, D. J., Gray, M. E., Dey, S., Meisenheimer,
K., Wolf, C., 2003, MNRAS, 341, 100
Bunn, E. F., & White, M., 1997, ApJ, 480, 6
Cohen, J. G., Hogg, D. W., Blandford, R., Cowie, L. L., Hu, E., Songaila, A.,
Shopbell, P., Richberg, K., 2000, ApJ, 538, 29
Crittenden, R. G., Natarajan, P., Pen, U-L., & Theuns, T., 2002, ApJ, 568, 20
Croft, R. A. C., Weinberg, D. H., Bolte, M., Burles, S., Hernquist, L., Katz, N.,
251, 600
Bolzonella, M., Miralles, J.-M., & Pelló, R. 2000, A& 363, 476
Kirkman, D., & Tytler, D. 2002, ApJ, 581, 20
Cosmic shear statistics in the Suprime-Cam 2.1 sq deg field
11
Dodelson, S., et al., (the SDSS collaboration), 2002, ApJ, 572, 140
Eisenstein, D. J., & Zaldarria, M., 2001, ApJ, 546, 2
Eke, V. R., Cole, S., & Frenk, C. S., 1996, MNRAS, 282, 263
Erben, T., van Waerbeke, L., Bertin, E., Mellier, Y. & Schneider, P., 2001, A&A,
366, 717
Fernández-Soto, A., Lanzetta, K. M., & Yahil, A., 1999, ApJ, 513, 34
Fontana, A., D'Odorico, S., Fosbury, R., Giallongo, E., Hook, R., Poli, F.,
Renzini, A., Rosati, P., & Viezzer, R., 1999, A&A, 343, L19
Fontana, A., D'Odorico, S., Poli, F., Giallongo, E., Arnouts, S., Cristiani, S.,
Moorwood, A., & Saracco, P., 2000, AJ, 120, 2206
Furusawa, H., 2002, Ph.D. thesis, Tokyo University
Gnedin, N. Y. & Hamilton, A. J. S. 2002, MNRAS, 334, 107
Hamana, T. & Mellier, Y. 2001, MNRAS, 169, 176
Hirata, C., & Seljak, U., 2003, MNRAS in press (astro-ph/0209489)
Hoekstra, H., Yee, H. K. C., Gladders, M. D., Barrientons, L. F., Hall, P. B., &
Infante, L., 2002a, ApJ, 572, 55
Hoekstra, H., Yee, H. K. C., & Gladders, M. D., 2002b, ApJ, 577, 595
Hu, W., 1999, ApJ, 522, L21
Jain, B., & Seljak, U., 1997, ApJ, 484, 560
Jain, B. Seljak, U. & White, S. D. M. 2000, ApJ, 530, 547
Jarvis, M., Bernstein, G. M., Fischer, P., Smith, D., Jain, B., Tyson, J. A.,
Wittman, D. 2003, AJ, 125, 1014
Jenkins, A., Frenk, C. S., White, S. D. M., Colberg, J. M., Cole, S., Evrard, A.
E., Couchman, H. M. P. & Yoshida, N. 2001, MNRAS, 324, 450
Kaiser, N., 1992, ApJ, 388, 272
Kaiser, N., Squires, G. & Broadhurst, T. 1995, ApJ, 449, 460
Kaiser, N., Wilson, G., Luppino, G., Dahle, H. 1999, PASP, submitted (astro-
ph/9907229)
Kashikawa, N., et al., 2003, AJ, 125, 53
Kitayama, T., & Suto, Y., 1996, ApJ, 469, 480
Kitayama, T., & Suto, Y., 1997, ApJ, 490, 557
Kuo, C. L. et al. 2002, ApJ, submitted (astro-ph/0212289)
Luppino, G.A. & Kaiser, N. 1997, ApJ, 475, L20
Maoli, R., et al., 2001, A&A, 367, 766
Mellier, Y. 1999, ARA&A, 37, 127
Ménard, B., Hamana, T., Bartelmann, M., & Yoshida, N., 2003, A&A, 403, 817
Miralda-Escude, J., 1991, ApJ, 380, 1
Miyazaki, S., Hamana, T., Shimasaku, K., Furusawa, H., Doi, M., Hamabe, M.,
Imi, K., Kimura, M., Komiyama, Y., Nakata, F., Okada, N., Okamura, S.,
Ouchi, M., Sekiguchi, M., Yagi, M., & Yasuda, N., 2002, ApJ, 580, L97
Miyazaki, S., Komiyama, Y., Okada, N., Imi, K., Yagi, M., Yasuda, N.,
Sekiguchi, M., Kimura, M, Doi, M., Hamabe, M., Nakata, F., Shimasaku,
K., Furusawa, H., Ouchi, M. & Okamura, S., 2002, PASJ, 54, 833
Navarro, J., Frenk, C. & White, S. 1996, ApJ, 462, 563
Peacock, J. A., & Dodds, S. J., 1996, MNRAS, 280, L19
Pearson, T. J. et al., ApJ, submitted (astro-ph/0205388)
Pen, U.-L., 1998, ApJ, 504, 601
Pen, U-L., Van Waerbeke, L., Meller, Y., 2002, ApJ, 567, 31
Percival, W. J., et al., 2001, MNRAS, 327, 1297
Pierpaoli, E., Scott, D., White, M., 2001, MNRAS, 327, 1297
Press, W. & Schechter, P. 1974, ApJ, 185, 397
Refregier, A., Rhodes, J., & Groth, E. D., 2002, ApJ, 572, L131
Schneider, P., van Waerbeke, L., Jain, B. & Kruse, G. 1998, MNRAS, 296, 873
Schneider, P., van Waerbeke, L.& Mellier, 2002, A&A, 389, 729
Seljak, U., 2002, MNRAS, 337, 769
Seljak, U. & Zaldarriaga, M. 1996, ApJ, 469, 437
Sheth R. K., Tormen G., 1999, MNRAS, 308, 119
Spergel, D. N., et al. 2003, ApJ, submitted (astro-ph/0302209)
Szalay, A. S., et al.., (the SDSS collaboration), submitteed to ApJ, (astro-
ph/0107419)
Takada, M., & Hamana, T., 2003, submitte to ApJ, (astro-ph/0305381)
Van Waerbeke, L. et al., 2000, A&A, 358, 30
Van Waerbeke, L. et al., 2001, A&A, 374, 769
Van Waerbeke, L. et al., 2002, A&A, 393, 369
Verde, L., et al.. 2002, MNRAS, 335, 432
Vianna, P. T. P., Nichol, R. C., & Liddle, A. R., 2002, ApJ, 569, L75
Wittman, D. M., Tyson, J. A., Kirkman, D., Dell'Antonio, I., & Bernstein, G.,
2000, Nat, 405, 143
Yahata, No., Lanzetta, K. M., Chen, H.-W., Fernández-Soto, A., Pascarelle, S.
M., Yahil, A., & Puetter, R. C., 2000, ApJ, 538, 493
Yoshida, N., Sheth, R. K. & Diaferio, A. 2001, MNRAS, 328, 669
APPENDIX
ANISOTROPIC PSF CORRECTION
In §5, we found a small but non-zero B mode aperture mass variance on scales larger than 5 arcmin. Currently, the origin of this
B mode variance is not clear. One possibility is an incorrect anisotropic PSF correction. To test this possibility, we repeated the
anisotropic PSF correction, but adopting different procedures:
1. use a second order bi-polynomial fit to (P∗
sm)- 1e∗
obs.
2. use the pointing-by-pointing correction without masking the overlapping regions.
3. use fainter stars for modeling the PSF anisotropy.
First, we repeated the anisotropic PSF correction adopting a second order bi-polynomial fit (the primary analysis uses a first order
fit). In this case, we found that both the E and B mode aperture mass variances are almost identical to the results from our primary
data, the differences are 1 × 10- 6 at largest. Further, higher order fits are not feasible, because of the small number of stars in some
chips. Note that Van Waerbeke et al. (2002) reported that a higher order polynomial fit to the PSF (third order in their case) caused a
wing at the edge of fields and produced an artificial B mode signal.
Second, we applied the anisotropic PSF correction not to each chip separately but to each pointing, which is composed of ten chips
(see Miyazaki et al. 2002 for instrumental details of Suprime-Cam). In this case, we did not mask the overlapping regions between
different CCD chips that result from stacking dithering exposures. The second and fifth order bi-polynomial fits were adopted. No
significant differences were found in either the E or B mode variances between the second and fifth order corrections. The E mode
variance is consistent with our primary data (plotted in Figure 6). The amplitude of B mode variance is also similar to the primary
data, but there is a bump at 6′ < θap < 15′. This scale is translated into a real scale of 1′ < θ < 2′, which corresponds to the dithering
angles between exposures. Thus, it is very likely that the bump arises from an inaccurate PSF correction at the overlapping regions
where the PSF anisotropy pattern becomes very irregular9. Because of this result, we decided to mask the overlapping regions. Also,
we decided to adopt the chip-by-chip correction to avoid poor modeling of the anisotropic PSF due to discontinuities between the
chips.
Finally, we repeated the PSF correction but adopted slightly fainter stars to test the possibility of different responses to the PSF
between bright and faint stars. Stars in the magnitude range 21.5 < Rc < 23.5 were used for the PSF correction with the first order fit
(20.6 < Rc < 23.0 for the primary procedure). The number of stars selected is almost the same as the primary selection (∼ 1/arcmin2).
Both the E and B mode variance from these data are consistent with the primary data (specifically the results are within the error bars
of the primary data). A much fainter criterion for star selection gives a poor PSF model because of contamination by small galaxies.
Thus, it gives a very poor PSF correction.
9 A similar B mode excess is found in CFHT data (L. Van Waerbeke & Y. Mellier, private communication).
12
T. Hamana et al.
In conclusion, as far as can be determined from the tests, we did not find a significant problem with our PSF correction procedure.
A future detailed examination of the PSF correction method should be carried out using realistic simulation data, similar to the
exercise performed by Erben et al. (2001). These tests, however, are beyond the scope of this paper and will be reported elsewhere.
|
astro-ph/0312524 | 1 | 0312 | 2003-12-19T12:48:04 | Radiative transfer through the Intergalactic Medium | [
"astro-ph"
] | We use a probabilistic method to compute the propagation of an ionization front corresponding to the re-ionization of the intergalactic medium in a LCDM cosmology, including both hydrogen and helium. The effects of radiative transfer substantially boost the temperature of the ionized gas over the case of uniform re-ionization. The resulting temperature-density relation of the ionized gas is both non-monotonic and multiple-valued, reflecting the non-local character of radiative transfer and suggesting that a single polytropic relation between local gas density and temperatue is a poor description of the thermodynamic state of baryons in the post-reionization universe. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Preprint-03
Radiative transfer through the Intergalactic Medium
James Bolton1, Avery Meiksin2, Martin White3
1Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, The Observatories, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK
2Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK
3Departments of Astronomy and Physics, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
31 October 2018
ABSTRACT
We use a probabilistic method to compute the propagation of an ionization front
corresponding to the re-ionization of the intergalactic medium in a ΛCDM cosmology,
including both hydrogen and helium. The effects of radiative transfer substantially
boost the temperature of the ionized gas over the case of uniform re-ionization. The
resulting temperature-density relation of the ionized gas is both non-monotonic and
multiple-valued, reflecting the non-local character of radiative transfer and suggesting
that a single polytropic relation between local gas density and temperatue is a poor
description of the thermodynamic state of baryons in the post-reionization universe.
Key words: methods: numerical -- intergalactic medium -- quasars: absorption lines
1
INTRODUCTION
Hydrodynamical simulations of structure formation in the
universe have led to fundamental insights into the struc-
ture and evolution of the Intergalactic Medium (IGM) (Cen
et al. 1994; Zhang, Anninos & Norman 1995; Hernquist
et al. 1996; Zhang
et al. 1997; Bond & Wadsley 1997;
Theuns, Leonard & Efstathiou 1998). Comparisons with the
Lyα forest, as measured in high redshift Quasi-Stellar Ob-
ject (QSO) spectra, show that the simulations broadly repro-
duce the statistical properties of the IGM. Precision compar-
isons with the highest spectral resolution measurements re-
cover the cumulative flux distributions and H I column den-
sity distributions to an accuracy of a few percent (Meiksin,
Bryan & Machacek 2001). More problematic are the pre-
dicted widths of the absorption features, which appear
to require additional sources of broadening, perhaps late
He II re-ionization, to match the measured widths (Theuns
et al. 1999; Bryan & Machacek 2000; Meiksin et al. 2001).
Many of the properties of the IGM may be attributed to
the gravitational instability of the dark matter alone, as the
baryon density fluctuations closely follow those of the dark
matter (Zhang et al. 1998). This has led to the development
of pseudo-hydrodynamic simulations based on pure gravity
in which the baryon fluctuations are assumed to exactly fol-
low the dark matter and the temperature to be derived from
an effective equation of state (Petitjean, Mucket & Kates
1995; Croft
et al. 1998; Gnedin & Hui 1998; Meiksin &
White 2001). In recent years, such simulations have been in-
creasingly relied on for predicting the flux power spectrum
of the Lyα forest (Meiksin & White 2001; Zaldarriaga, Hui
& Tegmark 2001; Croft et al. 2002; Meiksin & White 2003b;
Seljak, McDonald & Makarov 2003).
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
The simulations have generally been done assum-
ing sudden early homogeneous H I and He II re-ionization.
While tentative steps have been taken to introduce ra-
diative transfer into the simulations using approximate
schemes (Abel, Norman & Madau 1999; Gnedin & Abel
2001; Nakamoto, Umemura & Susa 2001; Ciardi, Stoehr &
White 2003), these simulations have emphasized the prop-
agation of H I ionization fronts and the predicted mean op-
tical depths. Except for the simulations of Gnedin & Abel,
they have not solved fully self-consistently for the combined
gas dynamics and radiative transfer.
In this Letter, we extend the photon-conserving scheme
of Abel et al. to include the treatment of helium and ex-
plore the thermal effects of radiative transfer in the inhomo-
geneous medium predicted in a ΛCDM cosmology.
2 RADIATIVE TRANSFER
2.1 Simulation data
We use the data from a previously run ΛCDM simula-
tion used to investigate effects of radiative transfer on the
Lyα forest (Meiksin & White 2003b). The simulation was
run using a pure Particle Mesh (PM) dark matter code, and
it was assumed the gas and dark matter have the same spa-
tial distribution. A description of the parallel PM code is
given in Meiksin & White (2003a). The parameters used for
the simulation are ΩM = 0.30, ΩΛ = 0.70, Ωb = 0.045,
h = H0/100 km s−1 Mpc−1 = 0.70, and slope of the pri-
mordial density perturbation power spectrum n = 1.05.
The model is consistent with existing large-scale structure,
Lyα forest flux distribution, cluster abundance and WMAP
constraints (Meiksin & White 2003b). The simulation was
2
J. Bolton, A. Meiksin and M. White
Figure 1. The baryon density fluctuations at z = 6 against co-
moving distance from the ionizing source for the line of sight
considered in our radiative transfer simulations.
run using 5123 particles and a 10243 force mesh, in a cubic
box with (comoving) side length 25 h−1Mpc, adequate for
obtaining converged estimates of the Lyα pixel flux distri-
bution and flux power spectrum (Meiksin & White 2003a,b).
A typical line-of-sight density run at z = 6, used for the ra-
diative transfer calculations here, is shown in Fig. 1.
2.2 Equations of radiative transfer
To consider the effect of radiative transfer when modelling
the propagation of ionization fronts (I-fronts) into the IGM,
we extend the photon-conserving algorithm of Abel et al. to
include helium. The advantage of this scheme is that energy
is conserved independently of numerical resolution, ensuring
that I-fronts propagate at the correct speeds in our simula-
tions. In practice, this means that larger step sizes may be
taken on the simulation space grid without the associated
loss of accuracy which would occur when solving the radia-
tive transfer equation through direct numerical integration.
The probabilities for the absorption of an ionizing pho-
ton by H I , He I and He II , respectively, are
abs = pHIqHeIqHeII (cid:2)1 − exp(cid:0)−τ tot
P HI
abs = qHIpHeIqHeII (cid:2)1 − exp(cid:0)−τ tot
P HeI
= qHIqHeIpHeII (cid:2)1 − exp(cid:0)−τ tot
P HeII
ν (cid:1)(cid:3) /D,
ν (cid:1)(cid:3) /D,
ν (cid:1)(cid:3) /D.
abs
(1)
(2)
(3)
ν = τ HI
ν + τ HeI
ν), qi = exp(−τ i
Here we have defined the auxiliary absorption and transmis-
sion probabilities pi = 1 −exp(−τ i
ν), i denot-
ing the species being referred to, τ tot
ν + τ HeII
,
where τ i
ν is the optical depth for a given species, and
D = pHIqHeIqHeII + qHIpHeIqHeII + qHIqHeIpHeII. These prob-
abilities can be used to calculate the ionization rate for a
given species per unit volume, niΓi, as follows. If in a time
δt, δt N l−1
photons enter grid zone l from zone l −1, then the
number of photons that will be absorbed in zone l by species
i is δt N l−1
abs is the absorption probability for
species i within zone l. The ionization rate of species i in
zone l of volume V l is then
abs, where P i
ν P i
ν
ν
nl
iΓl
i =
1
V l X
g
Nνg P i
abs(νg),
(4)
L and 10ν HI
where we have divided the frequencies into 100 discrete
groups g evenly spaced between ν HI
L . (While we
found this spacing to be adequate, we have made no attempt
to optimize it.) These are used in the following set of cou-
pled equations to solve for the positions of the three I-fronts
over time:
dnHII
= nHIΓHI − nenHIIαHI(T ) − 3
nHII,
a
a
(5)
dt
dnHeII
dt
dnHeIII
dt
= nHeIΓHeI + nenHeIIIαHeII(T ) − nHeIIΓHeII
− nenHeIIαHeI(T ) − 3
a
a
nHeII,
= nHeIIΓHeII − nenHeIIIαHeII(T ) − 3
(6)
a
a
nHeIII,
(7)
where ni denotes number density, Γi (s−1) is the photoion-
ization rate per atom, αi(T ) is the total radiative recombina-
tion coefficient, and a is the cosmological expansion factor.
The time evolution of the gas temperature T is given
by:
dT
dt
=
2(G − L)
3kn
+
T
n
dne
dt
− 3
a
a (cid:16) 2
3
T +
ne
n
T(cid:17) .
(8)
where n = nHI + nHeI + nHII + nHeII + nHeIII + ne, ne =
nHII + nHeII + 2nHeIII, k is the Boltzmann constant, and
G and L (J m−3 s−1) are the atomic heating and cooling
rates, respectively. The last term is the adiabatic cooling
term resulting from cosmological expansion, which will dom-
inate the thermal effects of gas motions at the densities
we consider. While computing the photoionization, we as-
sume the gas over-density (not the density) stays frozen,
which is a good approximation on the scales relevant to the
Lyα forest (Zhang et al. 1998). As in similar previous stud-
ies, we do not include the effects of adiabatic compression
heating as this will only affect the temperature for the rela-
tively rare virialised halos with circular velocities exceeding
∼ 20 km s−1 (Meiksin 1994; Meiksin & White 2003b).
The heating rate Gl in cell l is due to the photoioniza-
tion of H I , He I and He II according to Gl = Gl
HeI +
Gl
i is evaluated in a similar
manner to the ionization rate per unit volume as given in
Eq. (4),
HeII, where for each species i, Gl
HI + Gl
nl
iGl
i =
1
V l X
g
(hνg − χi) Nνg P i
abs(νg),
(9)
where χi is the ionization potential of species i. The atomic
cooling rate L includes radiative recombination cooling to
H I , He I and He II , electron excitation of H I , and Comp-
ton cooling off the Cosmic Microwave Background photons.
The radiative recombination and cooling rates are taken
from Meiksin (1994).
Eqs. (5) -- (8) are solved using explicit forward Euler in-
tegration. Although an implicit numerical scheme such as
backward Euler integration results in a more stable solution
at low numerical resolution (Anninos et al. , 1997), we find
that to obtain the required numerical accuracy as well as to
maintain stability, both methods require similar numerical
resolution. For the sake of speed and simplicity, the forward
method is preferred. The timestep is restricted to being no
more than several times greater that the hydrogen ionization
timescale, Γ−1
HI , for numerical accuracy.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Radiative transfer through the Intergalactic Medium 3
We take the frequency specific luminosity of the ionizing
source in our simulations to be described by a power law
spectrum with index α = 1.5, and a luminosity of LQ
ν =
1023 W Hz−1 at the Lyman edge. This spectrum is typical
of that of QSOs, which are probable candidate sources for
contributing to the re-ionization of the IGM. The assumed
mass fraction of helium in the IGM is Y ≃ 0.235.
We tested the photon-conserving algorithm on the pho-
toionization of gas with uniform density around a point
source. The resulting solutions for the ionization and tem-
perature profiles were accurate to better than 10 per cent
for optical depths at the Lyman edge of up to ∆τν ≃ 20
per cell on the space grid. This results in a significant re-
duction in the computational resources compared with a
radiative transfer scheme in which the ionization rates are
computed by direct numerical integration over the inten-
ν e−τν /[4πr]2) and photoionization cross-sections (eg,
sity (LQ
Madau, Meiksin & Rees 1997). Typically, we find that to
obtain an accuracy comparable to the photon-conserving
scheme at ∆τ HI
ν ≃ 20, a direct integration algorithm re-
quires ∆τ HI
ν ≃ 1/4 in each cell. For the simulation results
presented in this Letter, the original PM grid of 1024 sepa-
rate cells was used over a line of sight 25h−1 comoving Mpc
in length. This provided accurate spatial resolution, as at
most ∆τ HI
ν ≃ 6.8 in each cell at the average baryonic den-
sity assumed for the neutral IGM at z = 6.
3 RESULTS
We set up a problem of a QSO source of luminosity LQ
ν at
z = 6 placed at a comoving distance of 10h−1 Mpc from the
left edge of the density run shown in Fig. 1, and assume the
gas surrounding the QSO up to that point has already been
ionized. Placing the source at this distance avoids having to
impose the restriction that the I-fronts propagate no faster
than the speed of light. We indicate the displaced position of
the source in the figures by starting the (comoving) spatial
axes at R = 10h−1 Mpc.
Two cases were compared: computing the ionization
and temperature profiles by incorporating radiative trans-
fer as discussed in section 2.2 (hereafter the RT simulation),
and a second case neglecting radiative transfer, assuming
instead an instantaneous uniform ionization rate across the
whole line of sight (hereafter the nRT simulation), as is usu-
ally done in simulations of the Lyα forest. Our intention is to
compare the final gas temperatures to determine how large
an effect including radiative transfer may have.
Fig. 2 shows a comparison between the IGM tempera-
tures at z = 5 computed with and without radiative trans-
fer. The inclusion of radiative transfer results in a signifi-
cant boost to the temperature of the ionized IGM, a point
illustrated by Abel & Haehnelt (1999) in the context of a
smooth IGM. The positions of the H II and He II I-fronts at
z = 5 in the RT simulation are 24h−1 comoving Mpc from
the source, while the He III front lags behind at about 19h−1
comoving Mpc; their speeds of propagation are limited by
the reduction in the ionization rate due to the increasing
optical depth through the box. Consequently, the heating of
the IGM, which we find to be dominated by the photoion-
ization of neutral hydrogen at the H II I-front, is also con-
strained to lie behind the H II I-front. All gas beyond 24h−1
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Figure 2. Comparison of the IGM temperature at z = 5 against
comoving distance from the ionizing source. The solid line is com-
puted using radiative transfer, while the dashed line result as-
sumes a uniform ionization field through the entire line of sight.
Figure 3. Comparison of the IGM temperature at z = 3 against
comoving distance from the ionizing source. The line types are as
in Fig. 2.
Mpc is still much cooler. In contrast, the temperature com-
puted by the nRT simulation is much lower and the heating
extends across the whole line of sight. The temperature is
also much less sensitive to variations in the gas density for
the nRT simulation. Fig. 3 compares the results obtained at
z = 3. By this time, both the H II and He II I-fronts have
reached 35h−1 Mpc from the source. The material which has
been ionized early on in the RT simulation is now beginning
to cool to the same temperature as that computed by the
nRT simulation, although the temperature differences re-
main large. In particular, the gas that was photoionized at
z = 5 (R < 24 h−1 Mpc ), remains nearly twice as hot as
the uniformly ionized gas by z = 3. By contrast, the regions
which were ionized more recently are much hotter than for
the nRT simulation. We find that only by z = 1, once the
gas has been in an ionized state for a sufficiently long period
of time, do the temperatures predicted in the two scenarios
converge.
The reason for the temperature boost in the RT sim-
ulation is made clear by considering the energy per ioniza-
tion (E = G/Γ) at the I-front. In Fig. 4, we show that
4
J. Bolton, A. Meiksin and M. White
Figure 4. Plot of the energy per ionization for HI (solid line)
HeI (dashed line) and HeII (dot-dashed line) at z = 5. The bold
lines correspond to the results computed using radiative transfer,
while the lighter (flat) lines correspond to the uniform ionization
field.
the average energy of a photon absorbed by either H I ,
He I or He II increases at the relevant I-front, as proportion-
ally more of the lower energy photons have been absorbed
already -- a consequence of including radiative transfer. This
increase to the heating energy per ionization is responsible
for the temperature boost. The assumption of an instanta-
neous ionization field across the line of sight results in an
underestimate of the IGM temperature at high redshift.
A comparison of the IGM temperature-density rela-
tion computed by the two different simulations is made in
Figs. 5 -- 7. Only data points where He II has been 90 per
cent ionized are plotted, so that gas which is neutral or in
the process of being ionized is not considered. In Fig. 5,
the underdense regions in the line of sight (Fig. 1), are ini-
tially heated to a higher temperature in the RT simulation.
A non-monotonic temperature-density relation results. The
relation actually splits into two trends. To understand the
origin of the split, we divide the data points into two dis-
tinct sets corresponding to two regions in which the average
density fluctuations are slightly higher or lower than the
overall average in the line of sight (see caption to Fig. 5).
The gas in the denser region, which is closer to the source
and thus is ionized sooner, shows the same overall trend as
the gas in the less dense region but is slightly cooler at a
fixed over-density. In contrast, in the nRT simulation the
temperature-density relation is both monotonic and essen-
tially single-valued. By z = 3 (Fig. 6), the ionized gas has
cooled adiabatically, with the overdense regions cooling at
a slower rate than the underdense regions, as the denser re-
gions are better able to maintain thermal balance because
of the shorter cooling (and photoionization heating) times.
The IGM temperatures computed by the two simulations are
now beginning to converge at high density, but at low den-
sity there is still a significant difference between the results.
A third set of data points is also evident, corresponding to
the latest locally underdense region to be ionized.
Finally, by z = 1, the gas temperatures computed by
the RT and nRT simulations have nearly converged. The gra-
dient of the line in the temperature-density plane indicates
that adiabatic cooling due to expansion is largely responsi-
Figure 5. Comparison of the IGM temperature-density relation
at z = 5 for regions with fully ionized helium (nHeIII /nHe >
0.9). The triangles correspond to the uniform ionization case. The
data points for the results incorporating radiative transfer are
split into two sets: + corresponds to gas in the range 10h−1 < R <
14h−1, for which the mean over-density hρ/¯ρi = 1.452, (where ¯ρ
is the global mean gas density); and ∗ designates gas in the range
14h−1 < R < 23.6h−1, with mean over-density 0.519.
Figure 6. Comparison of the IGM temperature-density relation
at z = 3. The symbols are as in Fig. 5. We also add a third point
× designating gas in the range 23.6h−1 < R < 25.8h−1, with
mean over-density 0.671.
ble for cooling the gas. We find the entropy is now nearly
constant throughout the line of sight. The striations in the
RT data points have also disappeared. By z = 1, the results
from the two simulations are in good agreement.
4 CONCLUSIONS
We extend the probabilistic method of radiative transfer de-
scribed for hydrogen by Abel et al. (1999) to include helium
and tested the method on the propagation of an ionization
front through a uniform medium. We compare the method
against direct numerical integration of the exact time-steady
radiative transfer equation. We confirm their conclusion that
the probabilistic method accurately reproduces the position
of the ionization fronts even for large optical depths at the
photoelectric edges. Specifically, we recover the numerically
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Radiative transfer through the Intergalactic Medium 5
is insufficient in itself to account for the broader mea-
sured Lyα absorption systems than predicted by numeri-
cal simulations assuming sudden uniform photoionization.
Meiksin, Bryan & Machacek (2001) find that a boost of
∆T ≈ 1.7×104 K is required at z <
∼ 3.5, larger than the tem-
peratures we find here. Although it may be possible to ob-
tain a larger boost for an alternative re-ionization scenario,
such a large boost may still require invoking late He II re-
ionization. Our principal conclusion here is that for numeri-
cal simulations to accurately predict the temperature of the
IGM, they must include the effects of radiative transfer. We
are currently extending our methods to incorporate radiative
transfer with ray tracing (eg, Abel & Wandelt 2002), into
fully self-consistent simulations to explore this and related
issues, including alternative sources of re-ionization like low
luminosity AGNs and stars.
A.M. thanks the University of Edinburgh Development
Trust for its financial support.
REFERENCES
Abel T., Haehnelt M. G., 1999, ApJ, 520, L13
Abel T., Norman M. L., Madau P., 1999, ApJ, 523, 66
Abel T., Wandelt B. D., 2002, MNRAS, 330, L53
Anninos P., Zhang Y., Abel T., Norman M., 1997, NewA, 2, 209
Bond J. R., Wadsley J. W., 1997, in Petitjean P., Charlot S., eds,
Structure and Evolution of the Intergalactic Medium from
QSO Absorption Line Systems. Editions Fronti`eres, Paris, p.
143
Bryan G. L., Machacek M. E., 2000, ApJ, 534, 57
Cen R., Miralda-Escud´e J., Ostriker J. P., Rauch M., 1994, ApJ,
437, L9
Ciardi B., Stoehr F., White S. D. M., 2003, MNRAS, 343, 1101
Croft R.A.C., Weinberg D. H., Katz N., Hernquist L., 1998, ApJ,
495, 44
Croft R. A. C., et al. , 2002, ApJ, 581, 20
Gnedin N. Y., Abel T., 2001, NewA, 6, 437
Gnedin N. Y., Hui L., 1998, MNRAS, 296, 44
Hernquist L., Katz N., Weinberg D., Miralda-Escud´e J., 1996,
ApJ, 457, L51
Madau P., Meiksin A., Rees M. J., 1997, ApJ, 475, 429
Meiksin A., 1994, ApJ, 431, 109
Meiksin A., Bryan G. L., Machacek M. E., 2001, MNRAS, 327,
296
Meiksin A., White M., 2001, MNRAS, 324, 141
Meiksin A., White M., 2003a, MNRAS, 342, 1205
Meiksin A., White M., 2003b, MNRAS (astro-ph/0307289)
Nakamoto T., Umemura M., Susa H., 2001, MNRAS, 321, 593
Peebles, P.J.E, Principles of Physical Cosmology, 1993, Princeton
University Press
Petitjean P., Mucket J. P., Kates R. E., 1995, A&A, 295, L9
Seljak U., McDonald P., & Makarov A., 2003, MNRAS, 342, L79
Theuns T., Leonard A., Efstathiou G., 1998, MNRAS, 297, L49
Theuns T., Leonard A., Schaye J., Efstathiou G., 1999, MNRAS,
303, L58
Zaldarriaga M., Hui L., Tegmark M., 2001, ApJ, 557, 519
Zhang Y., Anninos P., Norman M. L., 1995, ApJ, 453, L57
Zhang Y., Anninos P., Norman M. L., Meiksin A., 1997, ApJ,
485, 496
Zhang Y., Meiksin A., Anninos P., Norman M. L., 1998, ApJ,
495, 63
Figure 7. Comparison of the IGM temperature-density relation
at z = 1. The symbols are as in Figs. 5 and 6.
integrated converged solutions for the ionization fractions
and temperature to an accuracy of 10 per cent for an incre-
mental optical depth per grid zone at the H I photoelectric
edge as high as 20, while direct numerical integration of the
radiative transfer equations requires an incremental optical
depth less than 1/4 to obtain comparable accuracy.
We use the probabilistic method to compute the prop-
agation of an I-front generated by a QSO source through
the IGM, using the density distribution drawn from a nu-
merical simulation in a ΛCDM universe. Including the ef-
fects of radiative transfer results in a substantial boost in
the post-ionized gas temperature compared with the case of
sudden uniform ionization with no radiative transfer. The
boost is due chiefly to the increased energy per photoioniza-
tion within the ionization fronts, a consequence of the higher
probability for high energy photons to pass through the gas
compared with lower energy photons.
A consequence of the radiative transfer is to alter the de-
pendence of temperature on density from the approximately
polytropic relation found for moderate to low densities as-
suming uniform photoionization (Meiksin 1994; Gnedin &
Hui 1998) to a generally non-monotonic trend. While the dif-
ferences between the temperatures for over-densities above
∼ 5 are small (less than 25 per cent), at lower densities the
two temperatures converge only slowly with time, nearly re-
covering the polytropic relation only by z ≈ 1.
At z > 1, the relation between temperature and den-
sity is not single-valued: multiple temperatures may result
for different gas parcels of the same over-density. Although
this is in part a consequence of the delay in time for gas
at different distances from the source to be photoionized as
the ionization front propagates, an additional contributing
factor is the environment of the gas parcel: if the ionization
front has passed through a region of dense gas, sufficient to
drive the optical depth at the H I photoelectric edge to near
unity, before reaching the parcel, the radiation field will de-
liver a higher energy per photoionization to the parcel. Thus
the determination of the gas temperature is strongly non-
local due to the dependence of the heating rate on the optical
depth to photoionizing photons between the gas parcel and
the source of ionizing radiation.
Although the inclusion of radiative transfer results in
a substantial and persistent boost in gas temperature, it
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
|
0812.1984 | 1 | 0812 | 2008-12-10T17:51:17 | Potential-density pairs for a family of finite disks | [
"astro-ph"
] | Exact analytical solutions are given for the three finite disks with surface density $\Sigma_n=\sigma_0 (1-R^2/\alpha^2)^{n-1/2} \textrm{with} n=0, 1, 2$. Closed-form solutions in cylindrical co-ordinates are given using only elementary functions for the potential and for the gravitational field of each of the disks.
The n=0 disk is the flattened homeoid for which $\Sigma_{hom} = \sigma_0/\sqrt{1-R^2/\alpha^2}$. Improved results are presented for this disk. The n=1 disk is the Maclaurin disk for which $\Sigma_{Mac} = \sigma_0 \sqrt{1-R^2/\alpha^2}$. The Maclaurin disk is a limiting case of the Maclaurin spheroid. The potential of the Maclaurin disk is found here by integrating the potential of the n=0 disk over $\alpha$, exploiting the linearity of Poisson's equation. The n=2 disk has the surface density $\Sigma_{D2}=\sigma_0 (1-R^2/\alpha^2)^{3/2}$. The potential is found by integrating the potential of the n=1 disk. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Potential-density pairs for a family of finite disks
Earl Schulz
60 Mountain Road, North Granby, CT 06060
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
Exact analytical solutions are given for the three finite disks with surface density
Σn = σ0(1 − R2/α2)n−1/2 with n = 0, 1, 2. Closed-form solutions in cylindrical co-
ordinates are given using only elementary functions for the potential and for the gravi-
tational field of each of the disks.
results are presented for this disk. The n=1 disk is the Maclaurin disk for which
The n=0 disk is the flattened homeoid for which Σhom = σ0/p1 − R2/α2. Improved
ΣM ac = σ0p1 − R2/α2. The Maclaurin disk is a limiting case of the Maclaurin spheroid.
surface density ΣD2 = σ0(cid:0)1 − R2/α2(cid:1)3/2
The potential of the Maclaurin disk is found here by integrating the potential of the
n=0 disk over α, exploiting the linearity of Poisson's equation. The n=2 disk has the
. The potential is found by integrating the
potential of the n=1 disk.
Subject headings: gravitation- methods: analytical-celestial mechanics- galaxies: kine-
matics and dynamics - galaxies: individual(NGC 891)
1.
Introduction
Observations of edge-on galaxies now provide detailed structural and kinematic 3-D informa-
tion. However attempts to use this data to generate mass distribution have not been completely
successful. One problem is that it is difficult to calculate the potential and force vectors for finite
disks. There is a need for fully solved finite disks which can be used for theoretical studies, for
benchmarking computer programs, and as basis functions to directly model 3-D observations.
Mass modeling commonly assumes that the disk mass in contained in an infinite disk. These
include the exponential disk (Freeman 1970), the Mestel disk (Mestel 1963), the Kuzmin-Toomre
disk (Toomre 1963; Binney & Tremaine 2008; Evans & de Zeeuw 1992; Conway 2000), and the
Rybicki disk (Evans & Collett 1993).
Only a few finite disks have been solved analytically for all (R, z). Lass & Blitzer (1983) and
Vokrouhlicky & Karas (1998) give a solution for a for all (R, z) for a finite thin disk with constant
density. The gravitational attraction approaches infinity at the edge of this disk. The gravitational
-- 2 --
attraction of the finite Mestel disk (Mestel 1963; Lynden-Bell & Pineault 1978; Hunter et al. 1984)
and the truncated exponential disk (Casertano 1983) are finite at the edge of the disk but these
disks have not been solved in closed form for points off the disk. Hur´e et al. (2008); Hur´e (2005)
describe a method to approximate the potential of a power law disk for points both on and off the
disk.
The family of finite disks with surface density Σn(R; α) =(cid:0)1 − R2/α2(cid:1)n−1/2
are related to the
Maclaurin spheroid which has been studied since the time of Newton. This family has recently
been studied by Gonz´alez & Reina (2006) and Pedraza et al. (2008). Gonz´alez & Reina (2006) use
the method of Hunter (1963) to obtain the general solution as a sum of Legendre polynomials
in elliptical coordinates and give evaluated expressions for the potentials for the disks 1, 2, and
3. Here we derive complete closed form solutions in cylindrical co-ordinates for the potential and
the gravitational fields of the n=0, 1, and 2 disks. We simplify the integration by moving to the
imaginary domain in way which is similar to the complex-shift method introduced by Appell. See
Ciotti & Marinacci (2008); Ciotti & Giampieri (2007) and references therein
The gravitational potential follows Poisson's equation ∇2Φ = 4πGρ. Poissons's equation is
linear so that solutions may be added. That is, if ∇2Φ1 = 4πGρ1 and ∇2Φ2 = 4πGρ2 then
∇2(Φ1 + Φ2) = 4πG(ρ1 + ρ2). Similarly, solutions may be differentiated with respect to a parameter
to obtain a new solution. Toomre (1963) and Lynden-Bell (1989) exploited this linearity to find
a family of velocity-density pairs by differentiating the Kuzmin (1956) model . In the same way,
Satoh (1980) derived new models from the Miyamoto & Nagai (1975) set of potential-density pairs
by differentiating with respect to a parameter. Here we use a similar approach by integrating
a known solution with respect to a parameter.
If the integral is tractable the result is a new
potential-density pair.
Maple 11 was used in this work. Maple was invaluable in simplifying the unwieldy intermediate
results but needed a good deal of coaxing to handle the messier equations. The Maple results were
cross checked in several ways.
A common notation is used throughout. Cylindrical co-ordinates (R, z) are used; Σ is the disk
surface density; σ0 is the surface density at R = 0; and α is the disk radius. Φ is the potential
where Φ is always negative and Φ(∞) = 0; FR and Fz are the gravitational field vectors with the
standard sign convention, ie: F = −∇Φ .
r cos(θ) + I r sin(θ); √z = √r cos(θ/2) + I√r sin(θ/2), valid for −π < θ < π. In this way the
function √z is unambiguous with continuous derivatives except on the negative real axis where it
is discontinuous.
The principal values of elementary functions are used so that, for instance, for z = x + I y =
-- 3 --
2. The n=0 Disk: The Flattened Homeoidal Shell
A homeoid is a shell of uniform density which is bounded by similar spheroids. Newton was
the first to prove that the net force is 0 (i.e., the potential is constant) within these shells. See
Chandrasekhar (1987) for historical background. The infinitely thin homeoidal shell is a differential
element of a spheroid. The homeoidal disk is the limiting case for which the minor axis approaches
0. The collapsed density of the thin homeoid is:
Σhom(R; α) =(σ0/p1 − R2/α2
0
for R < α
for R > α
(1)
Lynden-Bell (1989) gives a formula for the external potential of the thin homeoidal shell.
Taking the limit c = (1 − e2)1/2α → 0 gives a solution for the disk which is valid at all R and z.
Cuddeford (1993) gives an expression for the potential of this disk which is simpler than
previous solutions:
Equation 2 can be further simplified. First make the trivial transformation:
2α
Φhom(R, z; α) = −2πασ0Gsin−1"
pz2 + (R + α)2 +pz2 + (R − α)2#
Φhom(R, z; α) = −2πασ0Gsin−1"pz2 + (R + α)2 −pz2 + (R − α)2
#
2R
Now use the identity A1 to obtain
Φhom(R, z; α) = −πασ0G (cid:20)sin−1(cid:18) α − I z
R (cid:19) + sin−1(cid:18) α + I z
R (cid:19)(cid:21)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Equation 4 can be integrated over α whereas Equation 3 yields an impossible integral. Equation
4 must be real valued on physical grounds. This is easy to prove by noting that sin−1(x) is an odd
function of x and so the odd powers of I z in the series expansion of equation 4 cancel, leaving a
real valued result.
The gravitational field for the collapsed homeoid is obtained from the potential. Equation 4
yields particularly simple expressions for the field vectors FR,hom and Fz,hom:
πασ0G
R "
FR,hom(R, z; α) = −
Fz,hom(R, z; α) = −πασ0G"
α − I z
+
I
pR2 − (α − I z)2
pR2 − (α − I z)2 −
α + I z
pR2 + (α − I z)2#
pR2 − (α + I z)2#
I
(5)
(6)
-- 4 --
These force vectors can be expressed as entirely real functions using identities A8 and A9:
FR,hom(R, z; α) = −
Fz,hom(R, z; α) = −
√2πασ0G
√2πασ0G
α√f1f2 − f3− z √f1f2 + f3
Rf1f2
sgn(z)√f1f2 + f3
f1f2
Where
f1 =pz2 + (R + α)2
f2 =pz2 + (R − α)2
f3 = α2 − R2 − z2
(7)
(8)
(9)
3. The n=1 Disk: The Maclaurin disk
Beginning in the early 18'th century Colin Maclaurin, along with James Ivory and many others,
studied the properties of elliptical bodies. Chandrasekhar (1987) includes a very good historical
summary. See also Binney & Tremaine (2008); Bertin (2000); Schmidt (1956); Mihalas & Routly
(1968); Kalnajs (1971, 1972).
The homogeneous oblate spheroid is the simplest case of a spinning body for which the gravi-
tational attraction balances the centrifugal force. The Maclaurin disk, also known as the Kalnajs
disk (Kalnajs 1972), is a limiting case for which minor axis is 0. The Maclaurin disk is defined by
the surface density:
ΣM ac(R; α) =(σ0p1 − R2/α2
0
for R < α
for R > α
(10)
There are a few solutions for the potential of the Maclaurin disk in the literature. Mihalas & Routly
(1968) gives an expression for the potential of an oblate homogeneous spheroid based on the deriva-
tion in Schmidt (1956). The potential of the Maclaurin disk can be found by letting the eccentricity
e → 1 while holding the mass constant. Hunter (1963) gives the solution for the Maclaurin disk
as a series of Legendre polynomials in elliptical coordinates. Neugebauer & Meinel (1995); Meinel
(2001); Gonz´alez & Reina (2006) give a closed form solution for the potential of the Maclaurin disk
in elliptic coordinates.
The starting point here is the potential-density pair for the n=0 disk, the flattened homeoid
for which Σhom(R; α) = σ0/p1 − R2/α2. The surface mass density of the Maclaurin disk is found
from the transformation:
ΣM ac(R; α) =
1
αZ α
0
Σhom(R; α) dα =
1
αZ α
0
σ0
p1 − R2/α2
dα = σ0p1 − R2/α2
(11)
-- 5 --
The corresponding potential is:
ΦM ac(R, z; α) =
1
αZ α
0
Φhom(R; α) dα = −πσ0G
α
Z α
0
α(cid:20)sin−1(cid:18) α − I z
R (cid:19) + sin−1(cid:18) α + I z
R (cid:19)(cid:21) dα
(12)
Where the expression for Φhom is given by equation 4 above. Use integral 2.813 and 2.833 from
Gradshteyn & Ryzhik (1994) to obtain:
ΦM ac(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
4α (cid:20)(2α2 − R2 + 2z2)(cid:18)sin−1(cid:18) α + I z
+ α(cid:16)pR2 − (α − I z)2 +pR2 − (α + I z)2(cid:17)
− 3 z(cid:16)IpR2 − (α − I z)2 − IpR2 − (α + I z)2(cid:17)(cid:21)
R (cid:19) + sin−1(cid:18) α − I z
R (cid:19)(cid:19)
Equation 13 can be converted to an entirely real expression by using the identities A1, A6 and
(13)
(14)
A7:
ΦM ac(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
4α (cid:20)2(2α2 − R2 + 2z2)sin−1(cid:18) f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
+ √2αpf1f2 − f3 − 3√2 z pf1f2 + f3(cid:21)
where f1, f2, f3 are given by equation 9 above.
The gravitational field of the Maclaurin disk is found from the potential using Φ as given
by equation 13. The resulting expressions were expressed as entirely real functions by using the
identities A1, A8, and A9 :
FR,M ac(R, z; α) = −
Fz,M ac(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
2Rα "2R2sin−1(cid:18) f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
√f1f2 − f3
+ √2α(α2 − R2 + z2)
√2 z (α2 + R2 + z2)
−
α " − 2zsin−1(cid:18)f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
πσ0G
f1f2
f1f2
√f1f2 + f3
√f1f2 − f3
+ 2√2αz
+ √2 sgn(z) (α2 − R2 − z2)
f1f2
√f1f2 + f3
f1f2
#
#
(15)
(16)
-- 6 --
where f1, f2, f3 are given by equation 9 above.
The potential on the z axis and on the z = 0 plane can be found by by taking limits of equation
14:
ΦM ac(0, z; α) = −
ΦM ac(R, 0; α) =
πσ0G
α (cid:20)(cid:0)α2 + z2(cid:1) sin−1(cid:18)
− π2σ0G
4α (cid:0)2α2 − R2(cid:1)
2α h(2α2 − R2)sin−1( α
− πσ0G
α
√α2 + z2(cid:19) − α z (cid:21)
R ) + α√R2 − α2i
forR ≤ α
forR ≥ α
(17)
(18)
The radial force vector in the z = 0 plane is found by taking the limit of equation 15 or by
differentiating equation 18 with respect to R.
FR,M ac(R, 0; α) =
2α
− π2Rσ0 G
α hRsin−1(α/R) − αp1 − α2/R2i
− πσ0G
forR ≤ α
forR ≥ α
(19)
The axial force vector on the z axis is found by taking the limit of equation 15 or differentiating
equation 17 with respect to z.
Fz,M ac(0, z; α) = −
2πσ0G
α
(cid:20)zsin−1(cid:18)
α
√α2 + z2(cid:19) − α sgn(z)(cid:21)
(20)
4. The n=2 Disk
Gonz´alez & Reina (2006) give a closed form solution for the potential of the n=2 disk in elliptic
coordinates.
The disk surface density of the n=2 disk is
ΣD2(R; α) =(σ0(1 − R2/α2)3/2
0
for R < α
for R > α
(21)
This mass distribution can be obtained from equation 10, the disk surface density of the n=1
disk, with the transformation:
ΣD2(R; α) =
The corresponding potential is:
ΦD2(R, z; α) =
3
α3 Z α
0
3
α3 Z α
0
α2ΣM ac(R; α)dα
α2ΦM ac(R, z; α) dα
(22)
(23)
-- 7 --
Where the expression for ΦM ac is given by equation 13 above. Equation 23 contains terms which
using Gradshteyn & Ryzhik (1994) 2.262, 2.813, and 2.833. After collecting terms, the result is
reasonably compact:
after change of variable have with the form R xnsin−1(x)dx and R xn√1 ± x2dx and can be solved
R (cid:19) + sin−1(cid:18) α − I z
64α3 "3(8α4 − 8α2R2 + 16α2z 2 + 3R4 − 24R2z 2 + 8z 4)(cid:18)sin−1(cid:18) α + I z
ΦD2(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
R (cid:19)(cid:19)
+ α(18α2 − 9R2 + 26z 2)(cid:16)pR2 − (α + I z)2 +pR2 − (α − I z)2(cid:17)
− z(58α2 − 55R2 + 50z 2)(cid:16)IpR2 − (α + I z)2 − IpR2 − (α − I z)2(cid:17)(cid:21)
(24)
Equation 24 can be converted to an entirely real expression by using the identities A1, A6 and
A7:
ΦD2(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
64α3 "6(8α4 − 8α2R2 + 16α2z2 + 3R4 − 24R2z2 + 8z4)sin−1(cid:18) f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
+ √2α(18α2 − 9R2 + 26z2)pf1f2 − f3
√2 z (58α2 − 55R2 + 50z2)pf1f2 + f3#
−
(25)
where f1, f2, f3 are given by equation 9 above.
The gravitational field of the n=2 disk is the gradient of the potential using Φ as given by
equation 24. The resulting expressions were expressed as entirely real functions by using the
identities by using identities A1, A8, and A9 :
FR,D2(R, z; α) = −
3πσ0G
16Rα3"2R2(4α2R2 − 3R4 + 12R2z 2)sin−1(cid:18) f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
√f1f2 − f3
+ √2α(2α4 − 5α2R2 + 4α2z 2 + 3R4 − 25R2z 2 + 2z 4)
+ √2 z (2α4 + 9α2R2 + 4α2z 2 − 13R4 − 11R2z 2 + 2z 4)
f1f2
f1f2
√f1f2 + f3
Fz,D2(R, z; α) = −
πσ0G
4α3 " − 6z(2α2 − 3R2 + 2z 2)sin−1(cid:18) f1 − f2
2R (cid:19)
+ √2αz(13α2 − 13R2 + 17z 2)
+ √2 sgn(z)((4α4 − 8α2R2 − 3α2z 2 + 4R4 − 7R2z 2 − 11z 4)
f1f2
√f1f2 − f3
where f1, f2, f3 are given by equation 9 above.
√f1f2 + f3
f1f2
#
#
(26)
(27)
-- 8 --
The potential on the z axis and on the z = 0 plane can be found by by taking the limit of
equation 25:
ΦD2(0, z; α) = −
πσ0G
4α3 (cid:20)3(cid:0)α4 + 2α2z2 + z4(cid:1) sin−1(cid:18)
α
√α2 + z2(cid:19) − α z (5α2 + 3z2) (cid:21)
(28)
ΦD2(R, 0; α) =
− 3π2σ0G
64α3 (cid:0)8α4 − 8α2R2 + 3R4(cid:1)
32α h(8α4 − 8α2R2 + 3R4)sin−1( α
− 3πσ0G
R ) + 3α(2α2 − R2)√R2 − α2i
forR ≤ α
forR ≥ α
(29)
The radial force vector in the z = 0 plane is found by taking the limit of equation 26 or
differentiating equation 29 with respect to R.
FR,D2(R, 0; α) =
16α3
(4α2 − 3R2)
− 3π2Rσ0 G
8α3 hR(4α2 − 3R2)sin−1(α/R) − α(2α2 − 3R2)p1 − α2/R2i
− 3πσ0G
forR ≤ α
forR ≥ α
(30)
The axial force vector on the z axis is found by taking the limit of equation 27 or differentiating
equation 28 with respect to z.
Fz,D2(0, z; α) = −
πσ0G
2α3(α2 + z2)(cid:20) − 6(α2 + z2)2zsin−1(cid:18)
α
√α2 + z2(cid:19)
+ αz2(13α2 + 17z2) + α sgn(z)(4α4 − 3α2z2 − 11z4)(cid:21)
(31)
4.1. Comparison of the Maclaurin disk and the n=2 disk
Table 1 compares important properties of the two disks. Figure 1a compares the surface mass
density and potential. Figure 1b compares rotational velocity in the disks. The n=2 disk is more
centrally concentrated than the Maclaurin disk. The rotational velocity increases more quickly in
the inner disk and begins to fall before reaching the edge of the disk. As is apparent from figure
1b, the derivative of the circular velocity of the Maclaurin disk is discontinuous at the edge of the
disk whereas the n=2 disk is better behaved.
-- 9 --
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
y
t
i
c
o
l
e
v
r
a
l
u
c
r
i
C
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Radial distance
0.8
1.0
Maclaurin disk
n=2 Disk
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
Maclaurin disk
Radial distance
n=2 Disk
Point Mass
y
t
i
s
n
e
D
s
s
a
M
e
c
a
f
r
u
S
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
Fig. 1. -- Compare the surface mass density and circular velocity, Vc = p(−V FR(R, z), for the
Maclaurin disk and the n=2 disk. Reduced units are used so that the masses of both disks and the
point mass are 1.0
Table 1 comparison of the Maclaurin and the n=2 disks
Property
Maclaurin disk
n=2 Disk
Surface density
Total mass
Σ(R) = σ0p1 − R2/α2
M = 2
Circular velocity
V 2
c (R, 0) =
=
Disk edge velocity
V 2
c (α, 0) =
=
3 πα2σ0
π2R2σ0G
2α
3πR2M G
4α3
π2ασ0G
2
3πM G
4α
= σ0(1 − R2/α2)3/2
= 2
5 πα2σ0
3π2R2σ0G(4α2 − 3R2)
15πR2M G(4α2 − 3R2)
3π2ασ0G
16α3
32α3
=
=
=
=
16
15πM G
32α
5. Example: The force field of a simple galaxy model
Three-dimensional problems such as that of the structure and kinematics of the extra-planar
gas will benefit from the use of the new density-potential pairs. A simple galaxy model was
constructed for illustration. The model consists of a an n=2 disk and a core/bulge region modeled
as a point mass. This model is defined by three parameters: the mass of the disk, the mass of
-- 10 --
250
200
150
100
50
1
-
s
m
k
y
t
i
c
o
l
e
v
r
a
l
u
c
r
i
C
0
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
z=0
Radial distance kpc
z=2.6 kpc
z=3.9 kpc
Fig. 2. -- Circular velocity, Vc = p(−V FR(R, z), of a simple galaxy model at z=0, z=2.6 kpc,
and z=3.9 kpc above the disk. The model consists of an n=2 disk and a point mass to represent
the core + bulge. The masses of the two components are Mdisk = 3.5 × 1010M⊙ and MP ointM ass =
4 × 1010M⊙. The radius of the disk is α = 19 kpc.
the core/bulge region, and the diameter of the disk. As shown in figure 2, the circular velocity,
calculated as Vc = p(−V FR(R, z), is nearly constant over much of the disk. Also, the derivative
of the circular velocity with z is nearly linear over a wide range of both R and z.
Figure 2 agrees surprisingly well with figure 5 of Fraternali et al. (2005) which shows that the
measured velocity of HI for NGC891 decreases linearly with the height above the disk. See also Rand
(1997); Swaters et al. (1997); Kamphuis et al. (2007); Oosterloo et al. (2007); Fraternali & Binney
(2006); Barnabe et al. (2006). Further work is planned on this topic.
6. Summary and conclusion
We have presented new solutions for a family of finite disks. Closed form expressions in
cylindrical coordinates using elementary functions are given for the potential and gravitational
force for the disks with surface density Σn = σ0(1 − R2/α2)n−1/2 with n = 0, 1, 2. Expressions are
also given for the limiting cases of R = 0 and z = 0.
These solutions fill a need and should make it easier to model 3-D gravitational phenomenon
involving disk galaxies. This is particularly important due to the recent availability of detailed
kinematic data above the plane of the disk.
-- 11 --
I am grateful to the anonymous referee for useful suggestions and comments which improved
the presentation.
-- 12 --
A. Some simple identities
A number of identities are gathered here. In all cases x, y ∈ ℜ The ranges of validity must
avoid the discontinuity of the principal value of the square root function on the negative real axis.
Equation A1 can be proved by taking the sin of both sides; reducing the terms using the
identities sin(a + b) = sin(a) cos(b) + cos(a) sin(b) and sin(2a) = 2 sin(a) cos(b); and substituting
cos =p1 − sin2. The other identities can be found by substituting into the relation
√x + I y = qpx2 + y2 + x + sgn(y)Iqpx2 + y2 − x
√2
and into the expression found by taking the reciprocal of both sides.
2p(x − 1)2 + y2i
sin−1(x − I y) + sin−1 (x + I y) = 2sin−1h 1
2p(x + 1)2 + y2 − 1
√x − I y + √x + I y = √2qpx2 + y2 + x
I√x − I y − I√x + I y = sgn(y)√2qpx2 + y2 − x
= √2qpx2 + y2 + x
px2 + y2
= sgn(y)√2qpx2 + y2 − x
px2 + y2
√x − I y
√x − I y
√x + I y −
√x + I y
+
1
I
1
I
q1 − (x + I y)2 +q1 − (x − I y)2 = √2qp1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4 + 1 − x2 + y2
Iq1 − (x + I y)2 − Iq1 − (x − I y)2 = sgn(xy)√2qp1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4 − 1 + x2 − y2
(A1)
(A2)
(A3)
(A4)
(A5)
(A6)
(A7)
(A8)
1
+
q1 − (x − I y)2
q1 − (x − I y)2 −
I
1
q1 − (x + I y)2
q1 − (x + I y)2
I
= √2qp1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4 + 1 − x2 + y2
= sgn(xy)√2qp1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4 − 1 + x2 − y2
p1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4
p1 − 2x2 + 2y2 + x4 + 2x2y2 + y4
(A9)
-- 13 --
REFERENCES
Barnabe, M., Ciotti, L., Fraternali, F., & Sancisi, R. 2006, A&A, 446, 61
Bertin, G. 2000, Dynamics of galaxies (Cambridge University Press)
Binney, J. & Tremaine, S. 2008, Galactic Dynamics: Second Edition (Princeton University Press,
Princeton, NJ.)
Casertano, S. 1983, MNRAS, 203, 735
Chandrasekhar, S. 1987, Ellipsoidal figures of equilibrium (New York : Dover, 1987)
Ciotti, L. & Giampieri, G. 2007, MNRAS, 376, 1162
Ciotti, L. & Marinacci, F. 2008, MNRAS, 387, 1117
Conway, J. T. 2000, MNRAS, 316, 540
Cuddeford, P. 1993, MNRAS, 262, 1076
Evans, N. W. & Collett, J. L. 1993, MNRAS, 264, 353
Evans, N. W. & de Zeeuw, P. T. 1992, MNRAS, 257, 152
Fraternali, F. & Binney, J. J. 2006, MNRAS, 366, 449
Fraternali, F., Oosterloo, T. A., Sancisi, R., & Swaters, R. 2005, in ASP Conf. Ser. 331: Extra-
Planar Gas, 239 -- +
Freeman, K. C. 1970, ApJ, 160, 811
Gonz´alez, G. A. & Reina, J. I. 2006, MNRAS, 371, 1873
Gradshteyn, I. S. & Ryzhik, I. M. 1994, Table of integrals, series and products (Academic Press,
5th ed. Edited by Jeffrey, A)
Hunter, C. 1963, MNRAS, 126, 299
Hunter, J. H., Ball, R., & Gottesman, S. T. 1984, MNRAS, 208, 1
Hur´e, J.-M., Hersant, F., Carreau, C., & Busset, J.-P. 2008, A&A, 490, 477
Hur´e, J.-M. 2005, A&A, 434, 1
Kalnajs, A. J. 1971, ApJ, 166, 275
-- . 1972, ApJ, 175, 63
Kamphuis, P., Peletier, R. F., Dettmar, R.-J., van der Hulst, J. M., van der Kruit, P. C., & Allen,
-- 14 --
R. J. 2007, A&A, 468, 951
Kuzmin, G. G. 1956, Astr.Zh., 33, 27
Lass, H. & Blitzer, L. 1983, Celestial Mechanics, 30, 225
Lynden-Bell, D. & Pineault, S. 1978, MNRAS, 185, 679
Lynden-Bell, D. 1989, MNRAS, 237, 1099
Meinel, R. 2001, in Exact Solutions and Scalar Fields in Gravity: Recent Developments (Edited by
A Macias, J Cervantes-Cota, and C Lammerzahl; Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York),
69 -- 75
Mestel, L. 1963, MNRAS, 126, 553
Mihalas, D. & Routly, P. M. 1968, Galactic astronomy (W.H. Freeman and Company)
Miyamoto, M. & Nagai, R. 1975, PASJ, 27, 533
Neugebauer, G. & Meinel, R. 1995, Physical Review Letters, 75, 3046
Oosterloo, T., Fraternali, F., & Sancisi, R. 2007, AJ, 134, 1019
Pedraza, J. F., Ramos-Caro, J., & Gonzalez, G. A. 2008, MNRAS, 390, 1587
Rand, R. J. 1997, ApJ, 474, 129
Satoh, C. 1980, PASJ, 32, 41
Schmidt, M. 1956, Bull. Astron. Inst. Netherlands, 13, 15
Swaters, R. A., Sancisi, R., & van der Hulst, J. M. 1997, ApJ, 491, 140
Toomre, A. 1963, ApJ, 138, 385
Vokrouhlicky, D. & Karas, V. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 53
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
|
astro-ph/0002235 | 1 | 0002 | 2000-02-10T19:04:45 | Problems encountered in the Hipparcos variable stars analysis | [
"astro-ph"
] | Among the 17 volumes of results from the Hipparcos space mission, two are dedicated to variable stars. These two volumes arose from the work of two groups, one at the Geneva Observatory and one at RGO (Royal Greenwich Observatory), on the 13 million photometric measurements produced by the satellite for 118204 stars.
The analysis of photometric time series permitted us to identify several instrumental and mathematical problems: overestimation of the precision, offsets in the zero-points depending on the field of view, mispointing effects, image superpositions, trends in the magnitudes, binarity effects (spurious periods and amplitudes) and time-sampling effects. In this article we summarize some of the problems encountered by the Geneva group. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Delta Scuti and Related Stars
ASP Conference Series, Vol. N , 2000
M. Breger & M.H. Montgomery, eds.
Problems encountered in the Hipparcos variable stars
analysis
Laurent Eyer
Instituut voor Sterrenkunde, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven,
Celestijnenlaan 200 B, B-3001 Leuven, Belgie
Michel Grenon
Observatoire de Gen`eve, CH-1290 Sauverny, Suisse
Abstract. Among the 17 volumes of results from the Hipparcos space
mission, two are dedicated to variable stars. These two volumes arose
from the work of two groups, one at the Geneva Observatory and one
at RGO (Royal Greenwich Observatory), on the 13 million photometric
measurements produced by the satellite for 118 204 stars.
The analysis of photometric time series permitted us to identify sev-
eral instrumental and mathematical problems: overestimation of the pre-
cision, offsets in the zero-points depending on the field of view, mispoint-
ing effects, image superpositions, trends in the magnitudes, binarity ef-
fects (spurious periods and amplitudes) and time-sampling effects. In this
article we summarize some of the problems encountered by the Geneva
group.
1.
Introduction
The variable star analysis of the Hipparcos photometric data was an iterative
process in interaction with the FAST and NDAC data reduction consortia. We
started with data extracts from FAST, then from NDAC and finally worked on
the whole merged data set, that is on the 118 204 time series.
The result of variable star analysis is a beautiful by-product of the mission
and it was clear that it had to be published at the same time as the astrometric
results (ESA 1997). The time available for the photometric analysis was then
short in order to match the deadlines. The teams were put under strong pressure.
The approach was then to produce a robust analysis restricting the analysis to
statistically well-confirmed variables, leaving suspected variables and ambiguous
cases for further analysis.
Because several instrumental problems were identified and solved, the vari-
able star study definitely improved the overall quality of the Hipparcos photom-
etry available now on the CD-ROMs.
147
148
Eyer & Grenon
HIP 96647. Left: magnitudes before the data merging,
Figure 1.
open squares are for the following FOV, crosses for the preceding FOV.
Right: the corrected final solution.
2. Hipparcos main-mission photometry
Although the telescope diameter is small (29 cm), Hipparcos achieved a high pho-
tometric precision in the wide Hp band (335 to 895 nm), thanks to the chosen
time allocation strategy and to the frequent on-orbit photometric calibrations,
making use of a large set of standard stars. The time allocated for a star ob-
servation was adapted to its magnitude in order to homogenize the astrometric
precision. The photometric reduction was made in time slices of 10 hours, called
reduced great circles (RGC). During that time interval, the satellite scanned a
closed strip in the sky, measuring about 2600 stars, among them 600 standard
stars.
The FAST and NDAC consortia independently reduced the photometry.
They had to map the time evolution of the spatial and chromatic response of the
detection chains for both fields of view (FOV), the preceding and the following.
In Fig. 1, a zero-point problem between FOV magnitude scales is shown, before
and after its correction.
The light of the star was modulated by a grid for astrometric purposes. The
transmitted signal was modeled by a Fourier series of 5 parameters. From this
model two estimates of the intensity were done: one, measuring the integrated
signal, the "DC mode", was robust to the duplicity but more dependent on the
background, and the second, measuring the amplitude of the modulation, the
"AC mode", was sensitive to the duplicity but not to the background (cf. van
Leeuwen et al. 1997). These two estimates and their accuracies are given in the
Epoch Photometry Annex (CD-ROM 2) and in the Epoch Photometry Annex
Extension (CD-ROM 3).
Problems encountered in the Hipparcos variable stars analysis
149
3. Noise and magnitude
The precision of the magnitude is a function of the magnitude itself. In addition,
for a star of constant magnitude, the errors may be variable. The data are then
heteroscedastic. The correlation between the error and the magnitude, may
generate some problems. For instance, the weighted mean cannot be used to
estimate the central value of the magnitude distribution, if the amplitude is
large as for the Miras. The global loss of precision as the satellite ages (Eyer &
Grenon 2000) also needs to be considered. The usual period search algorithms
are also sensitive to the inhomogeneity of the data.
3.1. Quoted transit errors
During a single transit, a star was measured 9 times on average, the transit error
σHp was derived in a first approximation from the spread of these measurements.
However, the estimation did not include offsets which might have affected a
whole transit, e.g., due to a mispointing or to a superposition of a star from the
other FOV. In our first analysis, an empirical law was determined to correct the
transit error underestimation, otherwise the number of candidate variable stars
did not appear credible.
During the phase of data merging, ad-hoc corrections were computed (Evans
1995). The errors were studied with different methods, comparing first the
"average" error estimated from the σHp with the dispersion of the measurements
on Hp. Another study by Eyer & Genton (1999) was made on the quoted
errors using variograms; it showed a good general agreement with the Evans
results, with some mild underestimations for faint magnitudes and some mild
overestimations for the bright magnitudes in Evans' approach.
3.2. Time sampling
The time sampling was determined by the satellite rotation speed and by the
scanning law which were optimized to reach the most uniform astrometric pre-
cision over the whole celestial sphere. The total number of transits per star is a
function mainly of the ecliptic latitude. The time intervals between successive
transits are 20-108-20-etc. . . minutes. The transits form groups which are sepa-
rated by about one month, but the number of consecutive measurements as well
as the time separation between groups of transits can vary strongly from one
star to another.
3.3. Chromatic aging
The irradiation by cosmic particles reduced the optical transmission with time.
This aging was chromatic; it was worse than expected because the satellite had
to cross the two van Allen Belts twice per orbit. Furthermore, the satellite was
operational during a maximum of solar activity. For instance, the magnitude
loss over 3.3 years was 0.8 mag for the bluest stars and only 0.15 mag for the
reddest.
The aging of the image dissector tubes were not uniform and distinct for
both FOVs, therefore the aging corrections had to be calibrated as functions of
the star location on the grid for each FOV.
150
Eyer & Grenon
Figure 2.
HIP 29862, an example of trend induced by aging
Magnitude trends: An odd effect of the chromatic aging was the production
of magnitude trends in the Hp time series. As the transmission loss was colour
dependent, the magnitude correction had to be a function of the star colour. A
colour index, monotonically growing with the effective wavelength of Hp band,
had to be evaluated from heterogeneous sources. The precision of the equivalent
V − I was highly variable. For stars with "bad" V − I colour, the magnitude
correction was erroneous and produced a trend. A colour bluer than true gener-
ates a spurious increase of the luminosity with the time. An example of a trend
is given in Fig. 2.
Stars like Be stars may also show quasi-linear trends over
Selection of trends:
the mission duration. The identification of spurious trends was iterative. LPVs,
showing Gaussian residuals when modeled with a trend on top of their semi-
periodic light-curve, were sorted first. But there was much more diversity in the
data showing trends, true or spurious. So we used an Abbe test (Eyer & Grenon
2000) for a global detection. Stars with an Abbe test close to 1, or with a large
trend or with very long periods, were flagged. Stars with possible envelopes were
not retained. After visual inspection of the time series by Grenon, the number
of stars selected by these different procedures was 2412.
Correction of the star colour: The amplitude of the magnitude drift was used
to correct the star colour. Indeed, if a time series shows a trend α which may be
imputed to an incorrect initial colour, there is a possibility to recover the true
star colour by the relation:
(V − I)new = (V − I)old − 14290 α
where α is expressed in magnitude per day.
Problems encountered in the Hipparcos variable stars analysis
151
Two examples of series with outlying values. Left:
Figure 3.
HIP 35527 the case of a light pollution from the other FOV, where Sir-
ius is the perturbing star (this case is not flagged); Right: HIP 57437 an
example of mispointing effect with low values correctly flagged (open
circles).
Every selected case was investigated to decide whether the trend could be
a consequence of an incorrect colour; 965 V − I indices were corrected this way
with certainty and the origin of the errors on the colours was traced back.
4. Outlying values
When studying variable stars, outlying values and anomalous data distributions
are of great interest. Namely, it is important to distinguish outliers of instru-
mental origin from those due to stellar physical phenomena. Some stars show
luminosity changes on very short time scales. For Algol eclipsing binaries, the
duration of the eclipse is short with respect to their period. With non-continuous
time sampling, eclipses may appear as low luminosity points. UV Ceti stars show
strong bursts in the U band on very short time scales. However, because of the
width of the Hp band, the photospheric flux in the redder part of the band
largely dominates that of the burst, with the result that no burst was detected
with certainty in the M dwarfs.
In Fig. 3 we present two cases of outlying values of instrumental origin.
4.1.
Instrumental outliers: Mispointing effect
The pointing precision of the satellite was normally better than 1 arcsec. How-
ever after Earth or Moon eclipses and especially near the end of the mission when
most gyroscopes were faulty, the problems of mispointing were more acute. The
radius of the photocathode was 15 arcsec, with a lower sensitivity towards the
152
Eyer & Grenon
edge. An inaccurate pointing was inducing a loss of counted photons, leading to
dimmer points in the time series.
The problems with extended objects were even worse, depending on their
sizes. A similar situation happened with visual double systems when the sepa-
ration was around 10 arcsec. In this case the target was either the primary or
the photocenter of the system. From time to time the companion was on the
edge or out of the FOV, diminishing the amount of collected light. Even when
the two components were measured alternatively, the not-measured star might
have sometimes entered in the FOV producing a luminosity excess mimicking a
burst.
4.2.
Instrumental outliers: Light pollution
A neighbour star could contaminate the observed star, although most of the
identified cases were rejected during the Input Catalogue compilation. The
perturbing star was possibly a real neighbour or, more often, a star belonging
to the other FOV. Several configurations are possible:
• A star from the other FOV was added to the measured star. That is
called a superposition effect. Stars in the Galactic plane were more often
perturbed because of the higher star density.
• The perturbing star was very bright and caused scattered light in the
detection chain. This veiling glare could be felt even if the disturbing star
was further than 15 arcsec.
• When the separation was greater that 15 arcsec, the two effects of pollution
and mispointing could produce high values of fluxes of the dim component.
Fig. 4 shows the correlation between the asymmetry of the time series for
double systems and the angular separation ρ. The asymmetry is positive for
dimmer outlying values, and negative for pollution by the primary (bright out-
lying values).
4.3. Selection of outliers
The problems caused by the outliers were very acute at the beginning of the
analysis; we had then to take drastic measures before searching for periods and
amplitudes. We removed:
• all measurements with a non-null flag.
• the end of the mission, if the dispersion of the data was smaller than 0.3
before the day 8883. (the data for large amplitude variables were kept up
to the end of the mission).
• high luminosity values if there was a magnitude jump in consecutive tran-
sits.
• bad-quality measurements with transit errors higher than ǫ(DC) = 0.0005∗
100.167 HpDC + 0.0014.
Problems encountered in the Hipparcos variable stars analysis
153
Figure 4.
a function of the angular separation ρ.
Light pollution and mispointing effects for double stars as
• temporarily one or two outliers to check their impact on the result of an
analysis based on truncated time series.
This removal represents a reduction by 6% of the number of measurements with
non-zero flag.
Suspect transits from the analysis of outliers were transmitted to the re-
duction consortia, who flagged them according to the origin of the disturbance.
5. Alias and spurious periods
The spectral window produces spurious periods when it is convoluted with the
true spectrum. As a result, spurious periods around 0.09 d were frequently found
for long periods or irregular variables as well as for stars showing magnitude
trends. Periods of about 5 d for SR variables turned out to be nearly all spurious.
With the Hipparcos time sampling the spectral window changes from one star
to another and the alias effect had to be studied on a per star basis.
A 58 day periodicity was found in many time series when applying the
period search algorithm. This period corresponds to the time interval between
consecutive measurements of double systems under the same angle with respect
to the modulating grid (the modulated signal is higher when the components
are parallel to the grid).
154
Eyer & Grenon
6. Advice about the use of the data
We want to stress that caution should be taken in handling the epoch photom-
etry, especially when the signal to noise ratio or when the number of retained
measurements are small. The effects of multiperiodicity are generally very tricky.
The spectral window should be investigated in detail and periods near sampling
frequencies should be taken with care, in particular in the range 5 to 20 d where
the Hipparcos photometry has the weakest detection capability.
The selection of photometric data can be made according to their flags, the
estimates of the transit errors and the background intensities. In case of doubt
about outlying data, a look to the magnitude difference AC − DC will reveal
problems related to duplicity and image superpositions since the amplitude of the
modulated signal is reduced in the case of misaligned sources with respect to the
grid orientation. The contents of the opposite FOV can be investigated thanks
to their published positions. It is suggested to correct rather than to eliminate
data since a loss of information might twist statistics. For an example of a
successful selection procedure applied to the data of HIP 115510, see Lampens
et al. (1999).
7. Conclusion
Performing accuracy photometry in space is not free from problems. The same
is true for the data analysis. Once the origin of the encountered problems is
identified, it is possible to cope with them and determine precisely the domains
of validity of the algorithms for search of periods and amplitudes. Globally the
ratio quantity-quality generated by this mission for the study of variability has
no equivalent up to now.
References
ESA 1997, The Hipparcos and Tycho catalogues, ESA SP-1200
Evans, D.W. 1995, Hipparcos Photometry Merging Report, RGO/NDAC 95.01
Eyer, L., and Genton, M.G. 1999, A&AS 136, 421
Eyer, L. and Grenon, M., 2000, in preparation
Lampens, P., van Camp, M., Sinachopoulos, D. 1999 A&A, accepted
van Leeuwen, F., Evans, D.W., Grenon, M., Grossmann, V., Mignard, F., Per-
ryman, M.A.C. 1997, A&A323, L61
|
astro-ph/0210680 | 1 | 0210 | 2002-10-31T12:56:09 | Interstellar extinction in the open clusters towards galactic longitude around 130 degrees | [
"astro-ph"
] | In this paper we present a detailed study of the intra-cluster reddening material in the young open clusters located around $l \sim 130^o$ using colour-excess diagrams and two-colour diagrams. The study supports the universality of the extinction curves for $\lambda \geq \lambda_J$, whereas for shorter wavelengths the curve depends upon the value of the $R_{cluster}$ (total-to-selective absorption in the cluster region). The value of $R_{cluster}$ in the case of NGC 654, NGC 869 and NGC 884 is found to be normal, whereas the value of $R_{cluster}$ in the cluster regions NGC 1502 and IC 1805 indicates an anomalous reddening law in these regions. It is also found that the extinction process in the $U$ band in the case of NGC 663 seems to be less efficient, whereas in the case of NGC 869 the process is more efficient. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. MS2516
(DOI: will be inserted by hand later)
November 3, 2018
2
0
0
2
t
c
O
1
3
1
v
0
8
6
0
1
2
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Interstellar extinction in the open clusters towards galactic
longitude around 130o
A. K. Pandey1, K. Upadhyay1, Y. Nakada2, K. Ogura3,
1 State Observatory, Manora Peak, Naini Tal, 263 129, Uttaranchal, India
2 Kiso Observatory, School of Science, University of Tokyo, Mitake-mura, Kiso-gun, Nagano 397-0101, Japan
3 Kokugakuin University, Higashi, Shibuya-ku, Tokyo 150-8440, Japan
Received XXXX, 2002; accepted XXXX,
In this paper we present a detailed study of the intra-cluster reddening material in the young open
Abstract.
clusters located around l ∼ 130o using colour-excess diagrams and two-colour diagrams. The study supports the
universality of the extinction curves for λ ≥ λJ , whereas for shorter wavelengths the curve depends upon the
value of the Rcluster (total-to-selective absorption in the cluster region). The value of Rcluster in the case of NGC
654, NGC 869 and NGC 884 is found to be normal, whereas the value of Rcluster in the cluster regions NGC 1502
and IC 1805 indicates an anomalous reddening law in these regions. In the case of NGC 1502 the value of Rcluster
is found to be lower (2.57 ± 0.27) whereas in the case of IC 1805 it is higher (3.56 ± 0.29) than the normal value
of 3.1. Although the intra-cluster material indicates a higher value of Rcluster in the NGC 663 region, the error
in the estimation of Rcluster is too large to conclude anything. It is also found that the extinction process in the
U band in the case of NGC 663 seems to be less efficient, whereas in the case of NGC 869 the process is more
efficient.
Key words. ISM: dust, extinction -- ISM: general -- open clusters and associations: general
1. Introduction
Photometric studies are one of the most valuable and effi-
cient tools for determining the physical properties of open
clusters (e.g. distance, age, etc) and the interstellar matter
(ISM) within the cluster as well as along the line of sight
of the cluster. The accurate determination of the distance
of star clusters is crucial for a wide range of astronomical
studies. The interstellar extinction and the ratio of the
total-to-selective extinction R = AV /E(B − V ) towards
the cluster are important quantities that must be accu-
rately known to determine the distances photometrically.
Observations of star clusters in the near-infrared
bands, especially of young clusters which are still embed-
ded in remnants of their parental clouds, are very use-
ful to study the extinction behaviour in these clusters.
Observations of interstellar extinction due to the intra-
cluster matter yield fundamental information on the op-
tical properties of the particles responsible for extinction.
The analysis of extinction curves in 20 OB stellar associ-
ations indicates that big complexes are obscured by the
same type of interstellar matter (Kiszkurno et al. 1984).
On the other hand Kre lowski and Strobel (1983) com-
pared the extinction law in two rich stellar aggregates,
Send offprint requests to: A.K. Pandey ([email protected])
namely Per OB1 and Sco OB2, situated in different parts
of the galactic disk. They found that the average extinc-
tion curves of the two aggregates seem to differ substan-
tially. The differences are large in the far-UV, which leads
to the conclusion that an average extinction law cannot be
applied to all associations. In an analysis of two different
complexes of young stars (Sco-Ori region and Perseus re-
gion) Kre lowski and Strobel (1987) found different shapes
of extinction curves, supporting the assumption that the
obscuring material in these two young star complexes have
different physical properties. Consequently, in the case of
young open clusters, the average extinction curve should
not be used to correct spectral or photometric data for
interstellar extinction.
There is much evidence in the literature that indicates
significant variations in the properties of the interstellar
extinction and these refer mainly to high values of the
total-to-selective extinction ratio R as compared to the
normal value, 3.1, for the galactic diffuse medium (see e.g.
Pandey et al. 2000 and references therein). Whittet (1977)
reported that the value of R in the galactic plane can
be represented by a sinusoidal function of the form R =
3.08+0.17 Sin(l +175o), which indicates a minimum value
of R at l ≈ 95o. However, Tapia et al. (1991) found a value
of R = 2.42 ± 0.09 for the cluster NGC 1502 (l = 143.7o),
2
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
Table 1. The details of the clusters used in the study
Cluster
l
b
Distance
(pc)
Log age E(B-V) Available
(Yr)
photometric data
IC 1590
Be 62
NGC 436
NGC 457
NGC 581
Tr 1
NGC 637
NGC 654
NGC 663
Be 7
NGC 869
IC 1805
NGC 884
NGC 1502
123.13
123.99
126.07
126.56
128.02
128.22
128.55
129.09
129.46
130.13
134.63
134.74
135.08
143.65
-06.24
01.10
-03.91
-04.35
-01.76
-01.14
01.70
-00.35
-00.94
00.37
-03.72
00.92
-03.60
07.62
2940
2513
2942
2796
2241
2520
2372
2422
2284
2570
2115
2195
2487
900
6.54
7.22
7.78
7.15
7.13
7.43
6.96
7.08
7.13
6.60
7.10
6.67
7.15
7.03
0.32
0.85
0.48
0.48
0.44
0.63
0.70
0.85
0.82
0.80
0.58
0.80
0.58
0.74
which is significantly lower than the average galactic value
of 3.1.
The above discussions indicate that the interstellar ex-
tinction shows a large range of variability from one line
of sight to another. A precise knowledge of the spatial
variability of interstellar extinction is important for the
following reasons;
(i) Since the extinction depends on the optical proper-
ties of the dust grains, it can reveal information about
the composition and size distribution of the grains.
Consequently, variation of the extinction from one direc-
tion to other may reveal the degree and nature of dust
grain processing in the ISM (Fitzpatrick 1999).
(ii) Since astronomical objects are viewed through in-
terstellar dust, the wavelength dependence of extinction
is required to remove the effects of dust obscuration from
observed energy distributions.
Uncertainties of extinction estimates limit the accu-
racy of dereddened energy distributions. Such uncertain-
ties might be acceptably small for very lightly reddened
objects but can become important for modestly reddened
objects. The intra-cluster extinction due to the remains of
the star-forming molecular cloud decreases systematically
with the age of the cluster (cf. Pandey et al. 1990).
While analysing the U BV Ic data of NGC 663 we found
that the V /(U − B) colour-magnitude diagram (CMD) for
NGC 663 cannot be explained by a normal value of the
extinction ratio E(U − B)/E(B − V ) = 0.72 (see Sect. 3).
Some clusters in the direction of NGC 663 also appear to
show abnormal extinction properties. This motivated us
to study the interstellar extinction in detail towards the
direction of the cluster NGC 663.
U BV IcJHK
U BV
U BV Ic
U BV Ic
U BV Ic
U BV
U BV
U BV RcIc
U BV IcJHK
U BV
U BV RcIcJHK
U BV RcIcJHK
U BV RcIcJHK
U BV IcJHK
2. Data
online
available
database
at
The
http://obswww.unige.ch/webda/
by Mermilliod
(1995) provides an excellent compilation of the data on
open clusters. We selected a range of 1200 < l < 1500 to
study the intra-cluster extinction in open clusters. The
online database lists 103 clusters in this longitude range.
The parameters, such as distance, E(B − V ), age etc, are
available for only 54 clusters. Seventeen clusters in this
direction are quite young (log age < 7.5) and are suitable
to study the behaviour of intra-cluster ISM. U BV CCD
photometry for nine young clusters of the above sample
is given by Phelps and Janes (1994). A casual look at the
(U − B)/(B − V ) two-colour diagrams (TCDs) given by
Phelps and Janes (1994, hereafter PJ94) indicates that
the photometric data of 3 clusters, namely Be 62, NGC
637 and NGC 663, do not satisfy the main-sequence (MS)
curve, where apparent U V excess can be seen for stars
having spectral type later than A. PJ1994 concluded
that this may be due to U V excess of pre-main-sequence
(PMS) stars and this part of the (U − B)/(B − V ) TCD
is not suitable for reddening estimation. We will discuss
(U − B)/(B − V ) TCDs in ensuing sections. The present
analysis has been carried out using photometric data of
14 clusters and details are given Table 1.
3. Extinction
One of the main characterstics of the diffuse interstellar
matter in the Galaxy is its irregular structure. This makes
it difficult to map the extinction as a function of galac-
tic longitude and distance. Young open clusters also show
differential reddening due to the remains of the associated
parental clouds. The differential reddening decreases with
the age of the clusters (cf. Pandey et al. 1990). However,
it does not show any correlation with the location of the
cluster in the galactic disk.
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
3
Thus the extinction in star clusters arises due to two
distinct sources; (i) The general interstellar medium (ISM)
in the foreground of the cluster, and (ii) the localized cloud
associated with the cluster. While for the former compo-
nent a value of R = 3.1 is well accepted (Wegner 1993,
Lida et al. 1995, Winkler 1997), for the intra-cluster re-
gions the value of R varies from 2.42 (Tapia et al. 1991)
to 4.9 (Pandey et al. 2000 and references therein) or even
higher depending upon the conditions occurring in the re-
gion.
3.1. Extinction Curve
Extinction has often been analyzed using a two-colour nor-
malizations of the form E(λ−V )/E(B −V ). In the present
work the following methods are used to derive the ratio of
E(λ − V )/E(B − V ).
a) Colour excess diagrams (CEDs); method 'A'
The colour excesses of the stars in the cluster region
can be obtained by comparing the observed colours of
the stars with their intrinsic colours derived from the
MKK bi-dimensional spectral classification. For this pur-
pose we used the data available in the online catalogue by
Mermilliod (1995). When multiple data points are avail-
able for a star, we used those selected by Mermilliod and
given as MKS in the online catalogue. The colour excess
in a colour index (λ − V ) is obtained from the relation
E(λ − V ) = (λ − V ) − (λ − V )0, where (λ − V )0 is the
intrinsic colour index and λ represents the magnitude in
the U BV RIJHK pass bands. Intrinsic colours are ob-
tained from the MKK spectral type-luminosity class rela-
tion given by Schmidt-Kaler (1982) for U BV , by Johnson
(1966) for V RI converted to the Cousin's system using the
relation given by Bessel (1979), and by Koornneef (1983)
for V JHK.
The colour excesses E(U − V ), E(I − V ), E(J −
V ), E(H − V ) and E(K − V ) are shown as a function
of E(B − V ) in Figs. 1, 2, 3 and 4. The stars having Hα
emission features and stars apparently lying away from
the general distribution are not included in the analysis.
A least-squares fit to the data is shown by a straight line
which gives the ratio of E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) for the stars
in the cluster region. The slope of the line representing the
ratio E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) along with the error is given in
Table 2. In general, the least-square errors are quite large.
The reason for the large errors is mainly the small sam-
ple and the small range in the E(B − V ). For comparison
the colour excess ratios for the normal reddening law (cf.
Johnson 1968, Dean et al. 1978) are also given in Table 2.
b) Two colour diagrams (TCDs); method 'B'
In most of the cases the MKK spectral classification is
available only for a few stars of the cluster, which make
the CEDs quite noisy (see e.g. the CEDs of NGC 654,
NGC 663, NGC 869 and NGC 884). The TCDs of the
form of (λ − V ) vs (B − V ), where λ is one of the wave-
length of the broad band filters (R, I, J, H, K, L), provide
1.0
1.5
2.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.5
0.8
1.0
0.8
1.0
1.2
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
0.0
0.4
0.8
1.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Fig. 1. E(U − V ) vs E(B − V ) colour-excess diagrams.
Straight line shows a least-square fit to the data.
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-0.4
-0.5
-0.6
-0.7
-0.8
0.0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Fig. 2. E(I − V ) vs E(B − V ) colour-excess diagrams.
an effective method for separating the influence of the nor-
mal extinction produced by the diffuse interstellar medium
from that of the abnormal extinction arising within re-
gions having a peculiar distribution of dust sizes (cf. Chini
and Wargau 1990, Pandey et al. 2000). On these diagrams
the unreddened MS and the normal reddening vector are
practically parallel. This makes these diagrams useless for
determining the amount of reddening, but instead, very
useful for detecting anomalies in the reddening law. Chini
and Wargau (1990) and Pandey et al. (2000) used TCDs
to study the anomalous extinction law in the clusters M16
and NGC 3603 respectively. Figs. 5, 6, 7 and 8 show TCDs
for the central region of the clusters. We used the data of
the central region of the clusters to reduce the contami-
nation due to field stars. The stars apparently lying away
from the general distribution are not included in the anal-
4
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
Table 2. The colour excess ratios E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) obtained from the CEDs.
Cluster
E(U −V )
E(B−V )
E(I−V )
E(B−V )
E(J −V )
E(B−V )
E(H−V )
E(B−V )
E(K−V )
E(B−V )
NGC 654
NGC 663
NGC 869
NGC 1502
IC 1805
IC 1590
Normal
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-4.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-4.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-4.0
−2.20 ± 0.26 −2.47 ± 0.26 −2.71 ± 0.27
−2.28 ± 0.25 −2.79 ± 0.30 −2.99 ± 0.30
2.12 ± 0.32
−1.20 ± 0.46 −1.75 ± 0.48 −1.59 ± 0.50
1.90 ± 0.13
−1.87 ± 0.16 −2.04 ± 0.23 −2.17 ± 0.22
1.74 ± 0.18
1.76 ± 0.08 −1.34 ± 0.04 −2.74 ± 0.30 −3.30 ± 0.37 −3.66 ± 0.38
1.56 ± 0.30 −1.33 ± 0.17
1.72
−2.58
−2.30
−1.25
−2.78
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-0.8
-1.2
-1.6
-0.8
-1.2
-1.6
-0.8
-1.2
-1.6
-0.8
-1.6
-2.4
-0.8
-1.6
-2.4
-0.8
-1.6
-2.4
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
0.6
0.8
1.0
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.4
0.8
1.2
Fig. 3. E(J −V ), E(H −V ), E(K −V ) vs E(B−V ) colour-
excess diagrams for the clusters IC 1805, NGC 1502 and
NGC 663.
Fig. 4. Same as Fig. 3 but for the clusters NGC 869, NGC
884 and NGC 654.
ysis. The slopes of the distribution, mcluster, are given in
in Table 3. The slopes of the theoretical MS, mnormal, on
the TCDs, obtained for the stellar models by Bertelli et
al. (1994) are also given in Table 3. The errors associated
with the slopes are significantly smaller than the errors
obtained in the CEDs. The values of the (λ − V )/(B − V )
can be converted to the ratio E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) using
the following approximate relation;
E(λ−V )
E(B−V ) = mcluster
mnormal
× [ E(λ−V )
E(B−V ) ]normal.
c) (U − B)/(B − V ) two-colour diagram and colour-
magnitude diagrams; method 'C'
In absence of spectroscopic observations, the (U −
B)/(B−V ) TCD and colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs)
are important tools to study the interstellar reddening to-
wards the cluster as well as intra-cluster reddening.
In the case of (U − B)/(B − V ) TCD a MS curve (e.g.
given by Schmidt-Kaler 1982) is shifted along a reddening
vector given by the ratio of E(U − B)/E(B − V ) ≡ X
until a match between the MS and stellar distribution is
found. In this method the reddening vector X plays an im-
portant role. Over the years the observational as well as
theoretical studies have used ( or 'misused', according to
Turner 1994) a universal form for the mean galactic red-
dening law. However, theoretical as well as observational
estimates for the reddening vector X show a range from
0.62 to 0.80 (cf. Turner 1994). Recently DeGioia Eastwood
et al. (2001) also preferred a value of X=0.64 in the case
of Tr 14. The variability of X indicates the variations in
the properties of the dust grains responsible for the extinc-
tion. High values of X imply a dominance by dust grains of
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
5
Table 3. The slopes of the distribution of stars obtained from the (λ − V )/(B − V ) TCDs.
Cluster
(R−V )
(B−V )
(I−V )
(B−V )
(J −V )
(B−V )
(H−V )
(B−V )
(K−V )
(B−V )
NGC 654
NGC 663
NGC 869
NGC 884
NGC 1502
IC 1590
IC 1805
Normal
−0.61 ± 0.02 −1.20 ± 0.04 −2.16 ± 0.25 −2.39 ± 0.23 −2.50 ± 0.25
−0.50 ± 0.02 −1.13 ± 0.03 −2.33 ± 0.30 −2.73 ± 0.35 −3.07 ± 0.43
−0.60 ± 0.02 −1.12 ± 0.02 −1.90 ± 0.10 −2.41 ± 0.10 −2.53 ± 0.11
−0.62 ± 0.02 −1.06 ± 0.02 −1.96 ± 0.08 −2.44 ± 0.08 −2.59 ± 0.10
−1.92 ± 0.24 −2.04 ± 0.24 −2.08 ± 0.24
−1.36 ± 0.09
−0.98 ± 0.04 −2.12 ± 0.15 −2.58 ± 0.17 −2.73 ± 0.18
−1.1
−2.42
−2.60
−0.55
−1.96
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
0.0
-1.0
-2.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
0.3
0.6
0.9
0.3
0.6
0.9
0.7
1.4
2.1
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
0.0
0.2
0.5
1.0
2.0
3.0
Fig. 5.
(R − V ) vs (B − V ) two-colour diagram. The
data point shown by open circles is not included in the
least-squares fit (see text).
Fig. 6. (I − V ) vs (B − V ) two-colour diagram.
small cross sections while the small values of X indicate a
dominance of dust grains of larger cross section (cf. Turner
1994). Turner (1994) raised a question about the so called
reddening-free parameter Q [= (U − B) − 0.72(B − V )];
how can Q be reddening-free when the reddening vector
X is different from 0.72?
As we have mentioned earlier, the distribution of stars
in the V /(U − B) CMD of NGC 663 cannot be explained
by a normal value of X (i.e. 0.72). The (U − B)/(B − V )
TCD and the V /(B − V ), V /(U − B) CMDs for the cen-
tral region of the cluster NGC 663 are shown in Figs. 9
and 10 respectively. The data have been taken using the
105 cm Schmidt telescope of the Kiso Observatory, Japan
(for details see Pandey et al. 2002). In Fig. 9, where the
dashed curve shows the intrinsic MS by Schmidt-Kaler
(1982) shifted along X = 0.72, we find a disagreement be-
tween the observations and the MS at (B − V ) ∼ 0.90.
PJ94 explained the disagreement due to the presence of
pre-main-sequence (PMS) stars having U V excess. In Fig.
9 stars with V ≤ 16 are shown by filled circles. The appar-
ent distance modulus for NGC 663 is (m − MV )=14.4 (cf.
Pandey et al. 2002); the stars with V = 16 (i.e. MV =1.6)
will have mass ∼ 2.5M⊙. Since the cluster has an age
of ∼ 107 yr, the stars of ∼ 2.5M⊙ should have reached
the MS and no longer be PMS stars. The TCD for these
stars also does not support a normal value of X. We find
that the MS shifted along a reddening vector of 0.60 and
E(B − V )=0.68 explains the observations satisfactorily.
The value of X in the NGC 663 cluster region can
further be checked by comparing the theoretical zero-age-
main-sequence (ZAMS) with the observed stellar distri-
bution in the V /(B − V ) and V /(U − B) CMDs. Once
the reddening is known from the (U − B)/(B − V ) CCD,
the ZAMS is shifted to match the blue envelope of the ob-
served stellar distribution in the V /(B −V ) and V /(U −B)
CMDs. The ZAMS fitting for E(B − V )=0.68 and appar-
ent distance modulus (m−MV )=14.4 is shown in Fig. 10a.
Figure 10b shows V /(U − B) CMD where ZAMS, shifted
for E(U − B)=0.49 (corresponding to the normal redden-
ing vector X = 0.72) and (m − MV )=14.4, is shown by
6
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
0.3
0.6
0.9
Fig. 7. (J − V ), (H − V ), (K − V ) vs (B − V ) two-colour
diagrams for the clusters IC 1805, NGC 1502 and NGC
663. The data point shown by open circles are not included
in the least-squares fit (see text).
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
-6.0
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
-6.0
0.0
-2.0
-4.0
-6.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
0.0
0.5
1.0
Fig. 8. Same as Fig. 7 but for the clusters NGC 869, NGC
884 and NGC 654.
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
Fig. 9. (U −B)/(B−V ) two-colour diagram for the cluster
NGC 663 . The continuous curve represents the MS shifted
along E(U − B)/E(B − V ) = 0.60, whereas dashed curve
shows the MS shifted along a normal reddening vector.
Star having V ≤ 16.0 are shown by filled circles.
a dashed line, which clearly shows disagreement with the
distribution of the stars. The ZAMS for E(U − B)=0.40
(corresponding to X = 0.60 and E(B − V ) = 0.68) nicely
fits the blue envelope of the distribution. This supports
an anomalous value X=0.60 for the slope in the NGC 663
cluster region.
(U − B)/(B − V ) TCDs and V /(B − V ) CMDs were
used to find out the value of X in all of the 14 clusters ex-
amined in the present study. The (U − B)/(B − V ) TCD
for 3 clusters namely Be 62, NGC 436 and NGC 637 is
shown in Fig. 11. The values of the reddening vector X
obtained from the TCD/CMDs are given in Table 4. The
uncertainty in the estimated value of X arises due to un-
certainties in the intrinsic colours (i.e. ZAMS), uncertain-
ties associated with the observations and also uncertain-
ties associated with the visual fit of the ZAMS to the ob-
servations. The typical total uncertainty in the reported
values of X is estimated to be ∼ 0.05.
4. The Value of R
Table 4 indicates that the clusters Be 62, NGC 637 and
NGC 663 show a smaller value whereas the clusters NGC
869 and NGC 436 show a higher value for X. The remain-
ing 8 clusters show a normal value for X. The data given
in Tables 2,3 and 4 are used to estimate the weighted
(according to associated errors) mean value of the colour
excess ratios E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) and the ratios are given
in Table 5.
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
7
U band to K band are available,r is plotted as a function
of λ−1 in Fig. 12.
Fig. 12 indicates that the extinction in most of the
cluster regions seems to be normal at λ > λI , except
for the clusters NGC 1502 (where the colour excess ra-
tios for λ > λI are less than the normal one) and NGC
1805 (where the colour excess ratio at λ ≥ λJ are higher
than the normal one). Recent studies support a universal-
ity of the extinction curves for λ > λI (see e.g. Cardelli
et al. 1989, He et al. 1995). It is suggested that the nor-
malization should be done using the E(V − K) instead
of E(B − V ) (Tapia et al. 1991) because the E(V − K)
does not depend on properties like chemical composition,
shape, structure, degree of alignment of interstellar dust
(cf. Mathis 1990 and references therein).
Cardelli et al. (1989) found that the mean R dependent
extinction law can be represented by the following relation
Aλ
AV
= aλ + bλ
R
(1)
where aλ and bλ can be obtained from the relations given
by Cardelli et al. (1989). The above relation can be writ-
ten, in terms of E(λ−V )
E(B−V ) , as
E(λ−V )
E(B−V ) = R(aλ − 1) + bλ
(2)
The ratio of total-to-selective extinction towards the
cluster direction 'Rcluster' is derived using the eqn. (2).
The value of E(λ−V )
E(B−V ) (λ ≥ λJ ) given in Table 5 is used to
estimate the value of Rcluster and the results estimate for
Rcluster are given Table 6. The clusters that have a broad
spectrum of data are discussed below.
NGC 654
Sagar and Yu (1989) concluded that at wavelengths
greater than 5500 A, the extinction is normal. The pres-
ence of unusually well aligned interstellar grains indicated
by the polarization measurements seems to increase the
extinction in the U and B bands slightly (Sagar and Yu
1989). In the present work we find a rather normal extinc-
tion law.The value of Rcluster is ∼ 2.97 ± 0.30(σ) which,
within the error, is close to the normal value of 3.1.
NGC 663
Using the colour excesses E(V − K) and E(B − V )
Tapia et al. (1991) found weak evidence for an anomalous
reddening law with a value of Rcluster = 2.73±0.20, which
is marginally lower than the normal value of 3.1. However,
they felt that the scatter in their data is too large to con-
clude about the value of Rcluster. Yadav and Sagar (2001)
reported values for E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) ((λ ≥ λJ )) which
are significantly smaller than the normal ones.
The (weighted) mean value of Rcluster = 3.50±0.40(σ)
suggests a marginally anomalous reddening law in the
NGC 663 cluster region but in the opposite sense to that
reported by Tapia et al. (1991) and Yadav and Sagar
(2001). More near-IR data is needed to determine the
-1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
Fig. 10. V /B − V (the left panel), V /U − B (the right
panel) CMDs for the cluster NGC 663. Star having V ≤
16.0 are shown by filled circles. The continuous curve in
left panel represents the ZAMS fitting for E(B − V )=0.68
and apparent distance modulus (m − MV )=14.4. The con-
tinuous and dashed curves in right panel shows ZAMS
shifted for E(U − B)=0.40 and E(U − B)=0.49 respec-
tively. For details see text.
Table 4. The value of the reddening vector X =
E(U − B)/E(B − V ) obtained from the TCD/CMDs
Cluster
X
IC 1590
Be 62
NGC 436
NGC 457
NGC 581
Tr 1
NGC 637
NGC 654
NGC 663
Be 7
NGC 869
IC 1805
NGC 884
NGC 1502
0.72
0.60
0.84
0.72
0.72
0.72
0.53
0.72
0.60
0.72
0.95
0.72
0.72
0.76
We define a parameter r which is the ratio of [E(λ −
V )/E(B − V )]cluster (the ratio of colour excesses in the
cluster region) and [E(λ−V )/E(B−V )]normal (the ratio of
colour excesses for the normal reddening law). The values
of E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) given in Table 5 are used to obtain
the ratio r for the cluster region and resultant value of r
is given in Table 6. For the clusters where the data from
8
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
Table 5. Weighted mean value of the colour excess ratios E(λ − V )/E(B − V ).
Cluster
E(U −V )
E(B−V )
E(R−V )
E(B−V )
E(I−V )
E(B−V )
E(J −V )
E(B−V )
E(H−V )
E(B−V )
E(K−V )
E(B−V )
NGC 654
NGC 663
NGC 869
NGC 884
NGC 1502
IC 1805
Normal
0.0
1.0
2.0
1.72 ± 0.07 −0.65 ± 0.03 −1.35 ± 0.07 −2.18 ± 0.25 −2.42 ± 0.24 −2.60 ± 0.26
1.60 ± 0.07 −0.55 ± 0.02 −1.28 ± 0.04 −2.43 ± 0.29 −2.84 ± 0.33 −3.08 ± 0.36
1.95 ± 0.07 −0.64 ± 0.03 −1.28 ± 0.02 −2.16 ± 0.16 −2.54 ± 0.15 −2.65 ± 0.17
1.72 ± 0.07 −0.66 ± 0.03 −1.21 ± 0.02 −2.29 ± 0.09 −2.61 ± 0.09 −2.77 ± 0.11
1.76 ± 0.07
−1.97 ± 0.19 −2.14 ± 0.24 −2.20 ± 0.24
−1.25 ± 0.05 −2.55 ± 0.22 −2.86 ± 0.23 −3.07 ± 0.24
1.72 ± 0.07
1.72
−1.25
−2.58
−0.60
−2.30
−2.78
0.0
1.0
2.0
2.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
2.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Fig. 11. CCDs for the clusters Be 62, NGC 436 and NGC 637. The continuous curve represents the MS shifted along
the reddening vector given in Table 4 and dashed curve shows the MS shifted along a normal reddening vector.
Table 6. Mean value of the ratio r as a function of wavelength.
λ−1(µm−1)
Cluster
NGC 654
NGC 663
NGC 869
NGC 884
NGC 1502
IC 1805
2.90
U
1.56
RC
1.25
IC
0.80
J
0.61
H
0.45
K
Rcluster
1.00 ± 0.04
0.93 ± 0.04
1.19 ± 0.02
1.00 ± 0.04
1.02 ± 0.03
1.00 ± 0.03
1.08 ± 0.05
0.92 ± 0.04
1.07 ± 0.05
1.02 ± 0.05
1.08 ± 0.06
1.02 ± 0.03
1.02 ± 0.02
0.97 ± 0.02
1.00 ± 0.02
1.07 ± 0.14
1.07 ± 0.11
0.98 ± 0.05
0.97 ± 0.03
0.85 ± 0.05
1.12 ± 0.09
0.98 ± 0.09
1.09 ± 0.11
1.02 ± 0.05
0.99 ± 0.02
0.83 ± 0.05
1.14 ± 0.08
0.95 ± 0.03
1.10 ± 0.11
1.00 ± 0.04
0.98 ± 0.03
0.81 ± 0.04
1.16 ± 0.07
2.97 ± 0.30
3.50 ± 0.40
3.04 ± 0.20
3.19 ± 0.12
2.57 ± 0.27
3.56 ± 0.29
Rcluster in the NGC 663 cluster region. Here it is interest-
ing to mention that the behaviour of the extinction curve
towards UV also deviates from the normal one. Fig. 12
indicates a lower value for the E(U − V )/E(B − V ) ra-
tio, whereas Yadav and Sagar (2001) reported a normal
value for this ratio. They supplemented their data with
the photometric spectral types which are based on the Q
method, where they adopted E(U − B)/E(B − V )=0.72.
Presumably a dominance of photometric spectral determi-
nation forced the ratio of E(U − B)/E(B − V ) to a normal
value.
NGC 869 and 884 (h and χ Persei)
From the extinction curve analysis Johnson (1965)
found a value of Rcluster = 3.0 in the NGC 869 and NGC
884 cluster region. Tapia et al. (1984) also reported a nor-
mal reddening law in the cluster region. Recently Yadav
and Sagar (2001) found that the E(λ−V )/E(B −V ) ratios
for λ ≥ λJ are smaller than the normal ones.
The colour excess diagrams (method 'A') of NGC
869 indicates somewhat lower values for the ratios
E(J − V )/E(B − V ) and E(K − V )/E(B − V ) but the
errors are large, whereas in the case of NGC 884 the er-
rors in the estimation of colour excess ratios are too large.
The reason for the large errors is a small range in the
E(B − V )(∼ 0.3 mag). Because of the large errors we
have not used the colour excess ratios obtained from the
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
9
Various studies have been carried out to estimate the
value of R in the cluster region of IC 1805, but the re-
sults are not conclusive. Johnson (1968), Ishida (1969)
and Kwon and Lee (1983) reported an anomalous red-
dening law in the cluster region with values of Rcluster
∼ 5.7, ∼ 3.8 and ∼ 3.44 respectively. Kwon and Lee also
reported a regional variation in the value of Rcluster, with
a maximum value of Rcluster = 3.82 ± 0.15 for stars lo-
cated in the outer region and the minimum of 3.06 ± 0.05
for stars located in the central region. Sagar and Yu (1990)
found that the interstellar extinction law in the direction
of most of the cluster members is normal. The colour ex-
cess ratios E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) for λ ≥ λJ obtained in
the present work indicate an anomalous reddening law in
the cluster region of IC 1805. The value of Rcluster is es-
timated as 3.56 ± 0.29, which also indicates an anomalous
reddening behaviour in the cluster region.
5. The Aλ/AV curve
Extinction has normally been analyzed using a two-colour
normalization of the form E(λ − V )/E(B − V ). However,
the true nature of the variability of observed extinction
may be hidden by the choice of normalization. The quan-
tity Aλ/AV reflects a more fundamental extinction be-
haviour than the E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) (cf. Cardelli et al.
1989). The average colour excess ratios given in Table 5
can be used to estimate the quantity Aλ/AV in the fol-
lowing manner,
Aλ/AV = [E(λ − V )/E(B − V )Rcluster] + 1
where Rcluster is taken from Table 6. In Fig 13a the nor-
malized extinction in the form Aλ/AV is plotted against
λ−1 for the clusters NGC 654, NGC 663, NGC 869
and NGC 884 alongwith the average extinction law for
Rcluster = 3.1 given by Cardelli et al. (1989). Fig 13a in-
dicates that the agreement between observations and the
extinction law by Cardelli et al. (1989) is good barring the
AU /AV values for NGC 869 and NGC 663. In the case of
NGC 869 the ratio AU /AV is higher than the normal one
whereas in the case of NGC 663 it is lower than the normal
one. The value of AU /AV = 1.46 in the case of NGC 663
supports Rcluster ∼ 3.5. Whereas in the case of NGC 869
the colour excess ratios indicate a perfectly normal red-
dening law. It seems somewhat strange that in the case
of these two clusters the ISM behaves at λU in a different
way.
The extinction law in the direction of two clusters IC
1502 and IC 1805 is found to be anomalous. The nor-
malized extinction Aλ/AV for these two clusters along
with the ρ Oph dark cloud (data taken from Martin and
Whittet 1990) is plotted in Fig 13b. The effect of vary-
ing Rcluster on the shape of the extinction curves is quite
apparent at the shorter wavelengths for different environ-
ments of the star forming regions.
As we have discussed the extinction in the direction
of star clusters arises due to the general ISM in the fore-
Fig. 12. The ratio r as a function of λ−1.
CEDs of NGC 869 in the further analysis. The TCDs
(method 'B') indicate that the ratio of colour excesses
E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) in both the clusters for λ ≥ λI are
perfectly normal. It is interesting to note that the CED for
NGC 869 yields E(U − V )/E(B − V ) = 1.90 ± 0.13. The
V /(B −V ) and V /(U −B) CMDs also seem to support the
ratio of E(U −V )/E(B −V ) = 1.9. In a recent study Keller
et al. (2001) have adopted E(U − B)/E(B − V ) = 0.72 to
fit the ZAMS to the stellar distribution on the V /(U − B)
CMD of the stars in the NGC 869 and NGC 884 clus-
ter region. We find that only in the case of NGC 884 the
V /(U − B) CMD supports a normal value for the redden-
ing vector X in the cluster region.
NGC 1502
Tapia et al. (1991) found the ratio E(V − K)/E(B −
V ) = 2.20 corresponding to Rcluster = 2.42 ± 0.09, which
is significantly lower than the reddening value. Yadav
and Sagar (2001) also found that the colour excess ratios
E(λ − V )/E(B − V ) for λ ≥ λJ are significantly smaller
than the normal ones. The colour excess ratios for λ ≥ λJ
obtained in the present study are in good agreement with
those reported by Tapia et al. (1991) and Yadav and Sagar
(2001). The value of Rcluster is estimated as 2.57 ± 0.27
which is in good agreement with that obtained by Tapia
et al. (1991).
IC 1805
10
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
ground of the cluster and also due to the cloud associ-
ated with the cluster. Various studies using OB type sin-
gle stars support a value of R ∼ 3.1 for the general ISM
(Wegner 1993, Lida et al. 1995, Winkler 1997). The min-
imum reddening, E(B − V )min, towards the direction of
the cluster is representative of reddening due to the fore-
ground dust. The slopes of the distribution of stars having
E(B − V ) ≤ E(B − V )min on the TCDs can give infor-
mation about the foreground reddening law. In the case
of IC 1805 (and NGC 654), where E(B − V )min is 0.65
(0.77), we used stars having E(B − V ) ≤ 0.80 (0.85) to
estimate the foreground reddening presuming that star
having 0.65(0.77) ≤ E(B − V ) ≤ 0.80(0.85) are not much
affected by the anomalous reddening law in the cluster re-
gion. The colour excess ratios E(J − V )/E(B − V ), E(H −
V )/E(B − V ), and E(K − V )/E(B − V ) obtained are
−2.00 ± 0.32(−1.98 ± 0.28), −2.58 ± 0.35(−2.47 ± 0.27)
and −2.80 ± 0.39(−2.82 ± 0.36) respectively, which sup-
port a normal reddening law in front of the cluster IC
1805. We further combined data of all the clusters hav-
ing stars with reddening E(B − V ) ≤ 0.50. We feel that
the limit of E(B − V ) ≤ 0.50 safely excludes the redden-
ing due to intra-cluster matter as the smallest E(B − V )
for the NGC 869 and NGC 884 is ≈ 0.50 ( e.g. Uribe
et al. 2002). A least-squares fit to 8 data points having
0.01 ≤ E(B − V ) ≤ 0.50 gives the colour excess ratio
E(J −V )/E(B −V ) = −2.23±0.32, E(H −V )/E(B −V ) =
−2.62 ± 0.22, and E(K − V )/E(B − V = −2.79 ± 0.26.
These colour excess ratios also indicate a normal fore-
ground reddening law towards the direction of the clusters
used in the present study.
Several studies have pointed to the apparent concen-
tration of stars with high R-values in the vicinity of star
forming regions. This effect has, for example, in the η
Carina nebula (Forte 1978, Th´e and Groot 1983), M 16
(Chini and Wargau 1990) and M 17 (Chini et al. 1980,
Chini and Wargau 1998) and it may be presumed to be
characterstic of many more HII regions ( Winkler 1997).
Winkler (1997) compared the value of R obtained for
hottest stars in the Galaxy (spectral type O8 or earlier),
which can be considered as indicators of regions with re-
cent star formation, and he confirms that in the majority
of the cases the stars with large R indeed seems to be in
the vicinity of star forming regions.
On the basis of the above discussions we presume that
the anomalous extinction law in the direction of cluster
IC 1805 is due to the intra-cluster material.
6. Conclusions
In the present work we have carried out a detailed study of
the intra-cluster material inside the young open clusters
within a range of galactic longitude 1230 < l < 1440.
We used three methods (cf. Sect. 3.1) to derive E(λ −
V )/E(B−V ) and the results agree with each other in a few
percent. It is found that the behaviour of extinction varies
from cluster to cluster. The main results are as follows;
2
1
0
0
1
2
3
4
Fig. 13. The normalized extinction curves Aλ/AV . The
values written along the curves represent the value of
Rcluster
.
1. The extinction curves at shorter wavelengths depend
upon the Rcluster while they converge for λ ≥ λJ .
2. The extinction behaviour in the case of NGC 654, NGC
869 and NGC 884 is found normal, whereas in the case
of NGC 663 there is some tendency for a higher value
of Rcluster. It is interesting to mention that in the case
of NGC 663 and NGC 869 the extinction at λU is found
different from the normal one. In the case of NGC 663
the extinction process in the U band seems to be less
efficient, whereas in the case of NGC 869 the process
is more efficient.
3. The cluster regions of IC 1502 and IC 1805 show
anomalous reddening laws. In the case of IC 1502 the
Rcluster ∼ 2.57 ± 0.16 which is in agreement with the
value (∼ 2.49 ± 0.09) obtained by Tapia et al. (1991),
whereas in the case of IC 1805 the present study yields
Rcluster ∼ 3.53 ± 0.25 which is in agreement with the
value (∼ 3.44) given by Kwon and Lee (1983).
More near-IR data is needed for the clusters NGC 663,
NGC 1502 and IC 1805, where an anomalous value of
Rcluster is found, to study the reddening law in detail
in the these clusters.
Acknowledgements. This work is partly supported by the DST
(India) and the JSPS (Japan). AKP is thankful to the staff of
KISO observatory for their help during his stay there. Authors
are grateful to Prof. Ram Sagar for useful discussions. Thanks
are also due to Dr. John Mathis for his comments which im-
proved the contents of the paper.
Pandey et al.: interstellar extinction in open clusters
11
References
Bessel, M. S. 1979, PASP, 91, 589
Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., & Mathis, J. S. 1989, ApJ, 345,
245
Chini, R., Elsasser, H., & Neckel, T. 1980, A&A, 91,186
Chini, R.,& Wargau, W.F. 1990, A&A, 227, 213
Chini, R.,& Wargau, W.F. 1998, A&A, 329, 161
DeGioia Eastwood, K., Throop, H., Walker, G., & Cudworth,
K. M. 2001, ApJ, 549, 578
Elmegreen, B. G., & Lada, C. J. 1977, ApJ, 214, 725
Fitzpatrick, E. L. PASP, 1999, 111, 63
Forte, J. C. 1978, AJ, 83, 1199
He, L., Whittet, D. C. B., Kilkenny, D., & Spencer Jones J. H.
1995, ApJS, 101, 335
Johnson, H. L. 1965, ApJ, 141, 923
Johnson H. L. 1966, ARA&A, 4, 193
Johnson, H. L., 1968, in Nebulae and Interstellar Matter, ed.
B. M. Middlehurst, & L. M. Aller (University fo chicago
press), chap 5
Ishida, K. 1969, MNRAS, 144, 55
Kiszkurno, E., Ko los, R., Kre lowski, J., & Strobel, A. 1984,
A&A, 135, 337
Koornneef, J. 1983, A&A, 128, 84
Kre lowaski, J., & Strobel, A. 1983, A&A 127, 271
Kre lowaski, J., & Strobel, A. 1987, A&A 175, 186
Kwon, S. M.,& Lee, S. W. 1983, JKAS, 16, 7
Lida, H., Whittet, D. C. B., Kilkenny, D., & Spencer Jones, J.
H. 1995, ApJS, 101, 335
Mathis, J. S. 1990, ARA&A 28, 37
Martin, P. G., & Whittet, D. C. B. 1990 ApJ, 357, 113
Mermilliod, J. C. 1995,
in Information & On-line Data in
Astronomy, ed. D. Egret, & M. A. Abrecht (Kluwar
Academic Press), 227
Pandey, A. K., Mahra, H. S., & Sagar, R. 1990, AJ, 99, 617
Pandey, A. K., Ogura, K., & Sekiguchi, K. 2000, PASJ, 52, 847
Pandey, A. K., Upadhyay, K., & Ogura, K., et. al. 2002 (In
preparation)
Phelps R. L., & Janes K. A. 1994, ApJS, 90, 31
Sagar, R., & Yu, Q. Z. 1989, MNRAS, 240, 551
Schmidt-Kaler Th. 1982,
in Landolt-Bornstein, Neue Serie
Gr.VI, Vol 2b (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York) 19
Tapia, M., Roth, M., Costero, R., & Navarro, S. 1984, Rev Mex
A&A 9, 65
Tapia, M., Costero, R., Echevarria, J., & Roth M. 1991,
MNRAS, 253, 649
Th´e, P. S., & Groot, M. 1983, A&A, 125, 75
Turner, D. G. 1994, Rev. Mex. A&A 29, 163
Uribe, A., Garc´ia-Varela, J., Sabogal-Mart´inez, B., et al. 2002,
PASP, 114, 233
Wegner, W. 1993, AcA, 43, 209
Winkler, H. 1997, MNRAS, 287, 481
Whittet, D. C. B. 1977, MNRAS, 180, 29
Yadav, R.K.S., & Sagar, R. 2001, MNRAS, 328, 370
|
astro-ph/9502102 | 1 | 9502 | 1995-02-27T17:19:31 | AGAPE, an experiment to detect MACHO's in the direction of the Andromeda galaxy | [
"astro-ph"
] | The status of the Agape experiment to detect Machos in the direction of the andromeda galaxy is presented. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
AGAPE, an experiment to detect MACHO's in the
direction of the Andromeda galaxy
R. Ansaria, M. Auri`ereb, P. Baillonc, A. Bouquetd, G. Coupinotb,
C. Couturese, C. Ghesqui`eref , Y. Giraud-H´eraudf , P. Gondolod, J. Hecquetb,
J. Kapland, A.L. Melchiord, M. Monieza, J.P. Picatb and G. Soucailb
a LAL, Universit´e Paris Sud, Orsay, France,
b Observatoire Midi-Pyr´en´ees Bagn`eres de Bigorre et Toulouse, France,
c CERN, Gen`eve, Switzerland, d LPTHE, Universit´es Paris 6 et 7, France,
e DAPNIA, CEN Saclay, France, f LPC Coll`ege de France, Paris, France.
Presented at the 17th Texas Symposium on Relativistic Astrophysics, Munchen germany,
December 94, by J. Kaplan.
PAR-LPTHE 95-07
The M31 galaxy in Andromeda is the nearest large galaxy after the Small and Large
Magellanic Clouds. It is a giant galaxy, roughly 2 times as large as our Milky Way, and has
its own halo. As pointed by A. Crotts[1] and independantly by some of us[2] M31 provides a
rich field of stars to search for MACHO's in galactic halos by gravitational microlensing[3].
M31 is a target complementary to the Large Magellanic Cloud and the galactic bulge wich
are used by the three current experiments[4, 5, 6]. It is complementary in that it allows to
probe the halo of our galaxy in a direction very different from that of the LMC. Moreover,
the fact that M31 has its own halo and is tilted with respect to the line of sight provides a
very interesting signature : assuming an approximately spherical halo for M31, the far side
of the disk lies behind a larger amount of M31 dark matter, therefore more microlensing
events are expected on the far side of the disk. Such an asymmetry could not be faked by
variable stars[1].
In other words, M31 seems very appropriate to detect brown dwarfs through microlens-
ing. However, as very few stars of M31 are resolved, we had to develop an approach to look
for microlensing by monitoring the pixels of a CCD, rather than individual stars[2]. The
AGAPE collaboration has set out to implement this idea.
MONITORING PIXELS
In the case of a crowded field such as M31, the light flux Fpixel on a pixel comes from
the many stars in and around it, plus the sky background. The light flux of an individual
star, Fstar, is spread among all pixels of the seeing spot and only a fraction of this light,
Fpixel = {seeing fraction} × Fstar, reaches the central pixel.
If the star luminosity is
amplified by a factor A, the pixel flux increases by :
∆Fpixel = (A − 1) {seeing fraction} Fstar
(1)
The amplification of the star luminosity allows an event to be detected if the flux on the
brightest pixel rises sufficiently high above its rms fluctuation σpixel :
Typically, in our simulations, we require Q to be larger than 3 during 3 consecutive expo-
sures and larger than 5 for at least one of them.
∆Fpixel > Q σpixel
(2)
1
EXPECTED STATISTICS.
We have performed numerical simulations using the above detection criterium. As an-
ticipated, the number of events we expect to be able to detect depends strongly both on the
stability of the pixel and on the average seeing. The numbers in Table 1 below assume a
two meter telescope, a field of view of 60 by 20 arcminutes (planed for a second generation
experiment) centered on the center of M31, 1 arcsecond pixels, 30 minutes exposures, and
120 consecutive nights. The brown dwarf mass is taken to be 0.08 M⊙, and we assume a
standard halo (see reference[2] for instance) with a local dark matter density of 0.3 GeV/cm3
(0.0075 M⊙/pc3) and a core radius of 5 kpc.
Table 1: Expected number of events under various observing conditions
seeing
σpixel/Fpixel
1"
2"
2%
1%
0.5%
2%
1%
0.5%
number of
galactic events
9
15
27
3
7
11
number of
M31 events
15
29
50
4
10
21
total
24
44
77
7
17
32
These numbers have to be compared with the 2 events per year expected by the EROS
collaboration for brown dwarfs with masses of order 0.1 M⊙.
It is clear from Table 1 that the number of detectable events depends crucially on the rel-
ative flux fluctuation on the pixel, σpixel/Fpixel. To study the feasibility of the experiment,
we have analyzed these pixel fluctuations in three series of real data (Table 2) :
• 1) 82 images of the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) taken by the EROS collaboration
• 2) 26 images of M31 taken with the one meter telescope at Pic du Midi, in collaboration
with F. Colas (Bureau des longitudes, Paris) and J. Lecacheux (DESPA, Meudon)
Table 2: The mean relative fluctuation obtained for the three series of images listed above.
The numbers in the first column refer to the numbers in the list.
Images
relative fluctuation
LMC EROS (• 1)
M31 Pic (• 2)
M31 Pic (• 3)
M31 Pic (• 3)
mirror size
(meter)
0.4
1
2
2
pixel size
(arcsec)
1.15
0.7
0.25
1 ("superpixels")
3%
1%
0.7%
0.23%
• 3) 4 images of M31 taken by E. Davoust (OMP, Toulouse) with the 2 m telescope at
Pic du Midi. In this case, the angular size of the pixels is very small (0.23"), and we have
also considered a rearrangement in 4×4 "superpixels".
The results given in Table 2 clearly show that the required photometric stability of pixels
can be reached. Moreover, the analysis of the third series of data shows that pixels small
compared to the seeing allow an efficient matching between images, whereas, once images
are matched, superpixels are more appropriate for a stable photometry.
DISCRIMINATING AGAINST VARIABLE STARS AND OTHER VARI-
ABILITIES
Variable stars should be the main background. The usual tools to discriminate against
this background are available (symmetry, unicity, achromaticity of the light curve). Still,
some points particular to our approach are discussed below.
2
Achromaticity. At first sight, one would think that there is no achromaticity as a
star rising above a background of a different color will cause a color variation of the pixels
involved. However, it is easy to show that when a star rises above the background in two
color bands (say red and blue) then the ratio
(Fpixel − hFpixeli)red
(Fpixel − hFpixeli)blue
=
Fstarred
Fstarblue
(3)
is constant in time during a microlensing event.
High amplifications. To rise above the background an unresolved star needs a rather
high amplification (hAi ∼ 6), which will exclude most variable stars.
On the other hand small secondary maxima indicating unstable stars with occasional
strong flares will not be discriminated. Further study is required in this respect.
THE FIRST RUN OF AGAPE
We were given 57 half nights of observation on the 2 meter telescope "Bernard Lyot" at
Observatoire du Pic du Midi in the French Pyr´en´ees, from September 29 to November 24
1994. The field was 8′ × 8′ only, covered by 4 exposures on a 800 × 800 thin Tektronix CCD
camera with pixels 0.3" wide.
The data of this prototype run are currently under treatment. A key step of this treat-
ment is the alignement of successive images both in position and in photometry. The
photometric alignement is performed by linearly transforming the light flux of one image
in such a way that the mean flux and the variance of the transformed image matches those
of some reference image. The result of this alignement between images is illustrated in
figure 1. After alignement the dispersion of the relative difference between the two images
is 1.6%. This preliminary result is very encouraging as our alignement procedures are not
yet optimized.
AKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank The EROS collaboration, and E. Davoust who
allowed us to use their data, as well as F. Colas, and J. Lecacheux with whom we took data
on the 1 meter telescope at Pic du Midi. The help of F. Colas during our first observation
run has been particularly appreciated.
References
[1] Crotts A. P. S. 1992. ApJ. 399; L43.
[2] Baillon P. Bouquet A. Giraud-H´eraud Y. & Kaplan J. 1993. A&A 277; 1.
[3] Paczy´nski B. 1986. ApJ. 304; 1.
[4] Alcock et al., 1993. Nature 365; 621, and these proceedings.
[5] Aubourg E. et al. 1993. Nature 365; 623.
[6] Udalski A. et al. 1993. Acta Astronomica 43; 289.
3
a
b
c
Figure 1: photometric alignement of two different images of the same field. Histogramms of
pixel flux of two images, a: before treatment, b: after photometric aligement. c: Histogram
of the difference of pixel fluxes between the two images, after photometric alignement.
4
|
astro-ph/9908238 | 3 | 9908 | 1999-09-06T17:05:05 | An HST Snapshot Survey of Proto-Planetary Nebulae Candidates: Two Types of Axisymmetric Reflection Nebulosities | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report the results from an optical imaging survey of proto-planetary nebula candidates using the HST. We exploited the high resolving power and wide dynamic range of HST and detected nebulosities in 21 of 27 sources. All detected reflection nebulosities show elongation, and the nebula morphology bifurcates depending on the degree of the central star obscuration. The Star-Obvious Low-level-Elongated (SOLE) nebulae show a bright central star embedded in a faint, extended nebulosity, whereas the DUst-Prominent Longitudinally-EXtended (DUPLEX) nebulae have remarkable bipolar structure with a completely or partially obscured central star. The intrinsic axisymmetry of these proto-planetary nebula reflection nebulosities demonstrates that the axisymmetry frequently found in planetary nebulae predates the proto-planetary nebula phase, confirming previous independent results. We suggest that axisymmetry in proto-planetary nebulae is created by an equatorially enhanced superwind at the end of the asymptotic giant branch phase. We discuss that the apparent morphological dichotomy is caused by a difference in the optical thickness of the circumstellar dust/gas shell with a differing equator-to-pole density contrast. Moreover, we show that SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae are physically distinct types of proto-planetary nebulae, with a suggestion that higher mass progenitor AGB stars are more likely to become DUPLEX proto-planetary nebulae. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
An HST Snapshot Survey of Proto-Planetary Nebulae Candidates: Two Types
of Axisymmetric Reflection Nebulosities
Toshiya Ueta and Margaret Meixner
Department of Astronomy, MC-221, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801,
[email protected], [email protected]
Matthew Bobrowsky
Orbital Sciences Corporation, 7500 Greenway Center Drive, #700, Greenbelt, MD 20770,
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We report the results from an optical imaging survey of proto-planetary nebula candidates
using the Hubble Space Telescope (HST). The goals of the survey were to image low surface
brightness optical reflection nebulosities around proto-planetary nebulae and to investigate
the distribution of the circumstellar dust, which scatters the star light from the central
post-asymptotic giant branch star and creates the optical reflection nebulosities. We exploited
the high resolving power and wide dynamic range of HST and detected nebulosities in 21
of 27 sources. The reduced and deconvolved images are presented along with photometric
and geometric measurements. All detected reflection nebulosities show elongation, and the
nebula morphology bifurcates depending on the degree of the central star obscuration. The
Star-Obvious Low-level-Elongated (SOLE) nebulae show a bright central star embedded in a
faint, extended nebulosity, whereas the DUst-Prominent Longitudinally-EXtended (DUPLEX)
nebulae have remarkable bipolar structure with a completely or partially obscured central star.
The intrinsic axisymmetry of these proto-planetary nebula reflection nebulosities demonstrates
that the axisymmetry frequently found in planetary nebulae predates the proto-planetary nebula
phase, confirming previous independent results. We suggest that axisymmetry in proto-planetary
nebulae is created by an equatorially enhanced superwind at the end of the asymptotic giant
branch phase. We discuss that the apparent morphological dichotomy is caused by a difference
in the optical thickness of the circumstellar dust/gas shell with a differing equator-to-pole
density contrast. Moreover, we show that SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae are physically distinct
types of proto-planetary nebulae, with a suggestion that higher mass progenitor AGB stars are
more likely to become DUPLEX proto-planetary nebulae.
Subject headings: stars: AGB and post-AGB -- stars: mass loss -- planetary nebulae: general
-- reflection nebulae
1.
Introduction
Intermediate mass stars (initial main sequence mass of 0.8 − 8.0M⊙) evolve through a transitional
proto-planetary nebula (PPN) phase between the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) and planetary nebula
(PN) phases (Iben & Renzini 1983). A PPN consists of a cool (Teff <∼ 104 K) post-AGB stellar core and an
extensive circumstellar shell of gas and dust, which is the former stellar envelope ejected through wind mass
-- 2 --
loss1. In the PPN phase, AGB mass loss is assumed to have ceased but photoionization of circumstellar
matter is considered not to have been initiated (cf. Kwok 1993). The PPN phase is still poorly studied
because PPNe are statistically rare objects in the sky due to (1) their characteristically short time scale
of evolution (∼ 103 years) with respect to a typical AGB evolutionary time scale (∼ 106 years) and (2)
technological constraints imposed by PPNe's small angular scale and the presence of dust grains. Despite
this rarity, approximately 100 PPN candidates have been identified from optical and infrared studies (e.g.,
Hrivnak, Kwok, & Volk 1989, Oudmaijer et al. 1992).
One of the most significant changes that occurs to stars during the transition is the emergence of
axisymmetry. It is observationally established that most OH/IR stars, whose stellar cores are AGB stars
(Goldreich & Scoville 1976), show a high degree of spherical symmetry (cf. Habing & Blommaert 1993),
while most (80%) planetary nebulae display either bipolar or elliptical symmetry2 (Zuckerman & Aller
1986). Therefore, the departure from spherical symmetry must take place somewhere along the evolutionary
sequence between the two phases. The aspherical shaping of PNe has been qualitatively explained by the
interacting stellar winds (ISW) model. In this framework, the fast wind (>∼ 103 km/s) is expected to "snow
plow" slowly coasting (>∼ 10 km/s) circumstellar material which was ejected from the stellar envelope during
the previous mass loss epoch (Kwok 1982). Then, axisymmetry can be imposed by introducing the notion of
the equatorial density enhancement in the mass loss ejecta (Kahn & West 1985) and distinct morphological
groups can be created by varying the degree of equatorial enhancement in red giant or AGB ejecta (e.g.,
Balick 1987, Habing et al. 1989, Mellema & Frank 1995). Although there has been a number of suggestions
for the source of equatorial density enhancement (which includes magnetic fields and binary companions to
name a few; e.g., Soker 1998, Mastrodemos & Morris 1999), there is no definite solution to the problem.
Whichever the true scenario may be, a significant portion of the entire mass loss history is imprinted on
the PPN circumstellar shell of gas and dust: the innermost edge defines the termination of mass loss and
the mass loss history can be traced back in time as one probes outer regions of the circumstellar shell.
Therefore, one can investigate when and how geometry of mass loss departs from spherical symmetry by
sampling dust/gas distribution at various radial locations in a PPN circumstellar shell. One must, however,
employ techniques that are sensitive to neutral gas (molecular line emission in radio) and dust (thermal
emission in infrared and scattering of star light in visible) since no photoionization has taken place in the
PPN circumstellar shell.
In order to sample the most recent mass loss history one needs to probe the innermost regions of
a PPN circumstellar shell. Previous ground-based investigations of PPN circumstellar shells include
mid-infrared imaging of the thermal emission from warm (∼ 100K) dust grains (e.g., Meixner et al. 1999),
optical imaging of the reflection nebulosity (e.g., Hrivnak et al. 1999b), and spectropolarimetry of the
dust-scattered star light (Schmidt & Cohen 1981, Johnson & Jones 1991; Trammell, Dinerstein, & Goodrich
1994, hereafter TDG94). All of these studies have shown the axisymmetric nature of the innermost regions
of PPN circumstellar shells. Recent work on HST imaging of PPNe (Egg Nebula, Sahai et al. 1998; IRAS
17150−3224, Kwok, Su, & Hrivnak 1998; IRAS 17441−2411, Su et al. 1998) have displayed spectacular
images of bipolar reflection nebulosity but concentrated on a few PPNe that are associated with mostly or
entirely obscured central stars. Our HST survey of PPNe covers a larger number of targets than any of the
previous studies and, more importantly, includes PPNe candidates that are associated with bright central
1We reserve the word "shell" to refer to the circumstellar material that is physically detached from the central star to avoid
confusion with the word "envelope," with which we refer to the mantle of a star.
2We consider bipolar and elliptical morphologies form mutually exclusive sets (see discussions below).
-- 3 --
stars.
Our main goal in this survey is to detect small and faint reflection nebulosities around PPN candidates
at various evolutionary stages and to investigate if there exists any coherent morphological trend that will
bridge gaps between the circumstellar shell morphologies in the AGB and PN phases. In this paper, we
report results of our survey of optical reflection nebulosities around 27 PPN candidates, in which the high
resolving power and wide dynamic range of HST are both exploited to the fullest extent. In the following
sections, procedures of observations and data reduction are summarized (§2), results are presented (§3), and
the physical nature of morphological groups that we find and the subsequent implications in the context of
the PPN evolution are discussed (§4) with conclusions (§5).
2. Observations
2.1. Modes of Observation
The 27 PPN candidates were observed with the Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2)
on-board HST between 1996 April and 1997 August (Program IDs 6364 and 6737) and were all acquired in
the Planetary Camera (PC) chip (f/28.3, 0′′.0455 pixel−1). Observed coordinates for each object are listed
in Tables 1, 2, and 3.
To obtain high resolution images, each source was observed with a two- or three-point linear dithering
pattern (the telescope is linearly shifted with a non-integer multiple of pixels). The dithering technique
is now widely used in WFPC2 observations to fully exploit the high resolving power of HST from
undersampled WFPC2 images. In conjunction with the dithering, the objects were observed with a set of
different exposure times to cover the wide dynamic range that we required in our images. To image faint
nebulosities with a sufficiently high signal-to-noise ratio, observations were made with intentionally long
exposure times. For example, IRAS 22272+5435 was observed with 0.11, 1.2, 16, and 120 sec exposures. As
a consequence, pixels in the vicinity of the central star were often saturated or contaminated by anomalies
(e.g., bleeding, ghosts). The short exposure frames, which would be free of saturated pixels, were used to
recover the loss of information in such pixels. In order to maximize the coverage of the dynamic range, we
used a gain of 15 electrons per Data Number (DN) in our observations.
We typically used two wide band filters, F555W and F814W (WFPC2 equivalent of the Johnson-Cousins
bands, VJ and IC; e.g. Holtzman et al. 1995), for each source. However, F450W (Wide B) filter was
used when a source had previously been observed with F555W. For extremely bright sources, we used
medium and narrow band filters, F410M (Stromgren v), F547M (Stromgren y), and F469N (He II), to avoid
saturation in the shortest exposure frames. In total, approximately a dozen raw images were obtained for
each source and filter.
2.2. Data Reduction
We used IRAF/STSDAS routines in data reduction. A standard HST pipeline calibration was
performed with the latest reference files available at the time of data reduction. Duplicate frames of
dithered images were combined into a single image by applying the variable-pixel linear reconstruction
algorithm ("drizzle" package v1.2, Fruchter & Hook 1997), which would interlace each pixel in multi-point
dithered frames according to the statistical significance of each pixel. The drizzled images were subpixelized
-- 4 --
(0′′.0228 pixel−1) during the process and thus the high spatial resolution was recovered. Cosmic-rays were
removed by the drizzling algorithm in the three-point dithered frames, while they were eliminated manually
by replacing the contaminated pixels with a median of the neighboring pixels in the two-point dithered
frames.
In order to create non-saturated final source images, the saturated and unsaturated frames were
combined by replacing saturated pixels with unsaturated ones from the shorter exposures, scaled by the
exposure times. We have thus successfully obtained high dynamic range images of reflection nebulosities
whose outer perimeters often seem to be sky-limited. Figures 1, 2, and 3 show the reduced images. The
resulting nebular signal-to-noise ratio ranges from <∼ 2 for a faint nebula to > 100 for a bright nebula, while
the star-to-nebula ratio, which quantifies the emission contrast between the central star and nebulosity as a
measure of the dynamic range, ranges from 18 for a compact nebula up to 1.8 × 105 for an extended nebula.
Some faint nebulae are barely distinguishable from the background sky, while some others are almost buried
under the point spread function (PSF) of the central star itself.
2.3.
Image Enhancements
The reduced images, particularly those with a bright central star, were affected by the WFPC2
diffraction patterns that consist of linear spikes and circular wings. We employed image enhancement
techniques to remove unwanted effects of the WFPC2 point spread function (PSF) so that the reflection
nebulae would be more clearly seen. One could remove the effects of the WFPC2 PSF by either (1)
subtracting a stellar PSF from a source image or (2) deconvolving a source image with a stellar PSF.
A PSF subtraction can be done with either an observed PSF or a synthesized PSF. Although observed
PSFs were often preferred (Krist et al. 1997), we used synthesized PSFs because there existed no PSF with
a high enough dynamic range in proper filters for our observations. Model WFPC2 PSFs were generated
by the code Tiny Tim (v4.4, Krist & Hook 1997) for a given mode of observation, but the PSF had to be
scaled to account for the drizzling.
Alternatively, a deconvolution technique can be used to eliminate the PSF effects in the reduced
source images. We used the Richardson-Lucy (RL) algorithm and maximum entropy method and the
former generally yielded better results than the latter. This suggests that the most significant noise in our
images was due to photon shot noise because iterative solutions yielded by the RL algorithm are known
to converge into the maximum likelihood solution in Poisson statistics (Shepp & Vardi 1982). In general,
the contrast between the nebula and sky emission at the outer perimeter of a nebula was increased by a
factor of >∼ 2; however, there seemed to be little improvement in a few very extended nebulosities where the
nebula emission was comparable to the sky emission. Unlike the case of PSF subtraction, a deconvolution
technique could be applied to all our images. One shortcoming in RL deconvolution is that the algorithm
is known to amplify uncertainties and generate false depressions around pixels with unusually high DNs,
and such "holes" indeed appeared in the deconvolved images. Therefore, we have to keep in mind that any
interior structure in the deconvolved images should be regarded as suspect.
Overall, we found that the RL deconvolved images provided the best removal of the PSF effects among
all the methods we tried. Thus, we present only the RL deconvolved images alongside the original reduced
images in Figures 1, 2, and 3.
-- 5 --
2.4. Measurements
Photometric and geometric quantities were measured from the reduced source images. To give the total
specific flux density (Fλ in ergs cm−2 s−1 A−1), the reduced images were flux calibrated by adopting the
HST photometric calibration of SYNPHOT (v4.0, Simon 1997). First, we defined a photometric aperture
that was large enough to encircle the entire source as well as the diffraction features. The total DN of
a source was then determined by summing all DNs within the aperture. The background emission per
pixel was estimated by calculating the averaged sky DN inside a 10-pixel-wide annulus that encloses the
aperture but was separated from the aperture by a buffer zone. The background DN, which is the averaged
sky DN multiplied by the number of pixels in the aperture, was subtracted from the total DN only when
the averaged sky DN per pixel was greater than the root mean square of the sky DNs in the background
annulus because otherwise the background subtraction would introduce an additional 1σ uncertainty to the
results. We expect that an uncertainty due to the background subtraction is rather insignificant because
considerably larger DNs in the emission core will dominate the total emission of the source and thus
photon shot noise will dominate. The total source DN was then converted into Fλ and the WFPC2 system
magnitude (STMAG).
The extent of the nebulosities was estimated from the images by defining the "edge" of a nebula to be
the outermost recognizable structure, in which the emission level turned out to be 1σ up to about 7σ of the
sky depending on the quality of the image. The major and minor axes of the nebula were measured and the
ellipticity of a nebula was derived by e = 1 − b/a (a and b are respectively major and minor axis lengths).
With the edge of a nebula being defined, we can also measure the surface intensity (ergs cm−2 s−1 A−1
sr−1) at the peak and edge of the nebula, from which we can obtain the star-to-nebula surface intensity
ratio as a measure of the width of the dynamic range covered by the image. When the central star is visible,
the peak coincides with the location of the central star, but, when the central star is totally obscured, the
peak is simply the local maximum in the emission region. All derived quantities are summarized in Tables
1, 2, and 3.
3. Results
3.1.
Images of Reflection Nebulosity
Of 27 PPN candidates, 21 were found with fascinating reflection nebulosities around the central stars
and six did not seem to be associated with any nebulosity. By inspection, one immediately realizes the
following: (1) all 21 nebulae show asphericity with varying degrees and (2) there clearly exist two types
of axisymmetry among those aspherical nebulosities. One type of nebulosity is characterized by its very
low surface brightness and multi-axis elongations which surround extremely bright central stars. The other
type, however, is distinguished by the limb-brightened bipolar lobes with their partially or completely
invisible central stars somewhere in the nebulae. Because this apparent bifurcation is so astonishing in
the morphology of reflection nebulosity, we categorize the two types according to the traits in appearance
described above and refer to the former type as the Star-Obvious Low-level-Elongated (SOLE) nebulae
while the latter type as the DUst-Prominent Longitudinally-EXtended (DUPLEX) nebulae. Among 21
nebulosities, 11 and 10 are respectively found to be SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae in this classification.
One of the key differences between SOLE and DUPLEX sources is the star-to-nebula surface intensity
ratio (Table 1 and 2), which is a useful quantity to estimate the size of the dynamic range required to
-- 6 --
observe SOLE nebulae. For sources with the visible central star (all SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae with the
partially visible central star), the dynamic range varies from 18 (for the most compact SOLE source, IRAS
07430+1115) to 1.8 × 105 (for the most extended SOLE source, IRAS 19114+0002) with the average value
of 1.3 × 104. On the other hand, for sources with the obscured central star (bipolar DUPLEX nebulae),
the dynamic range is at most 330 (IRAS 20028+3910, whose northern lobe is barely detected) with the
average value of 55. In recent subarcsecond optical imaging of PPNe by ground-based telescopes, four
of our sources (IRAS 18095+2704, IRAS 19374+2359, IRAS 20028+3910, and IRAS 22574+6609) were
observed to determine their morphology (Hrivnak et al. 1999b). However, they were unable to determine
if IRAS 18095+2704 (the only SOLE source among the four) is extended partly due to the brightness of
the star (V = 10.3) despite the suggestion of its extension from the FWHM of their V image. Because
of the wide dynamic range we achieved (∼ 1000), our IRAS 18095+2704 images clearly show that it is
indeed an extended source. Therefore, to detect and image faint, extended reflection nebulosities around a
bright central star, i.e., the SOLE nebula, a very wide dynamic range must be used. Even the six orders of
magnitude coverage barely detects the outermost structure in images of IRAS 19114+0002 and there may
be even fainter, more extended nebulosity.
Although we classify the objects mainly on morphological grounds, spectral energy distribution (SED)
and two-color diagrams provide supplemental information to determine the morphological class of an object.
The sources that are not considered to be associated with any nebulosities are referred to as stellar sources
(see discussions below). We adopt these terms to address each morphological type hereafter and will discuss
the morphological dichotomy in detail in the following subsections. Figures 1(a) to 1(c), 2(a) to 2(c), and 3
show SOLE, DUPLEX, and stellar sources, respectively3.
3.1.1. SOLE Nebulae
The SOLE nebulae show the very bright central star embedded in a very low surface brightness
nebulosity (Fig. 1). This type of reflection nebulae has been imaged for the first time by this survey: the
central star is so bright that the object would always appear as a point source unless the observations are
done with the high enough resolution (available with HST) and/or wide enough dynamic range (available
with our method of multiple exposure times). The very eye-catching trident-like structures emanating
from the central star are WFPC2 linear diffraction spikes and are not to be construed as real structure.
The reader is encouraged to compare the images of the SOLE nebulae (Fig. 1) with those of the stellar
sources (Fig. 3) to help the eye differentiate real structures from remnants of the PSF artifacts such as the
diffraction spikes and circular halos. The morphology of the SOLE nebulae can be further subdivided into
groups: a simple ellipse, multiple ellipses (more than one ellipse superposed onto one another with differing
orientations of the major axes), an ellipse with embedded bipolar structure, and an ellipse with concentric
shells.
IRAS 07134+1005, IRAS 17436+5003, and IRAS 20462+3416 all have large (<∼ 4′′) and faint
nebulosities. The size of the optical reflection nebulosity in IRAS 07134+1005 is the largest among the
21µm feature sources (e.g. Hrivnak & Kwok 1991a) and is comparable to mid-infrared images (Meixner et
al. 1997). The extended nature of IRAS 17436+5003 was suspected from wings of 12CO (J=2-1) and 13CO
(J=2-1) line profiles (Bujarrabal, Alcolea & Planesas 1992). IRAS 20462+3416, a young PN which has
3All fully reduced and deconvolved images are also available in FITS format on the World Wide Web's NCSA Astronomy
Digital Image Library (ADIL, at http://imagelib.ncsa.uiuc.edu/document/99.TU.01/).
-- 7 --
already started showing low extinction characteristics (Parthasarathy 1993, Smith & Lambert 1994), was
observed to have experienced a brief period of an enhanced mass loss between 1993 and 1995 (Garc´ıa-Lario
et al. 1997b). IRAS 02229+6208 and IRAS 07430+1115 have smaller (2′′ and 1′′) nebulae. Both of these
sources, along with IRAS 05341+0852, have recently been observed by Hrivnak & Kwok (1999), but
they were unable to determine if the sources are extended due to poor seeing. IRAS 04296+3429, IRAS
05341+0852, and IRAS 22272+5435 have two axes of elongation that are not perpendicular to each other.
Despite a circular nebula prediction because of its shape of the SED (Hrivnak & Kwok 1991a, Hrivnak et
al. 1999b), IRAS 04296+3429 shows a complex double-elongation structure: the secondary E-W elongation
of IRAS 04296+3429 is close to but not aligned with a diffraction spike and is likely to be real. This is,
however, consistent with a suggestion that the source is associated with axisymmetrically distributed,
optically thin dust (TDG94). IRAS 05341+0852 shows a diffuse elongation in the NE-SW direction and
there seems to be a secondary elongation inside of and tilted about 20◦ counter-clockwise from the primary
one. IRAS 22272+5435, whose axisymmetric nature was already seen by spectropolarimetry (TDG94), has
a bright, large core with the four elliptical tips which create an almost amoeba-like appearance for the
nebula. The northern and southern elliptical tips are of equal brightness, but the western tip is 2.6 times
fainter than the eastern tip, which is approximately 1.6 times brighter than the northern and southern
tips: this suggests that the E-W elongation is tilted (with the eastern lobe being closer to us) but the N-S
elongation is not tilted.
IRAS 06530−0213 and IRAS 18095+2704 have rather peculiar structures.
In addition to the
well-defined elongation, both sources display an inner structure, which seems to be a limb-brightened
bipolar lobes. IRAS 18095+2704 shows a similar spectropolarimetric trend as seen in IRAS 04296+3429
(TDG94), which may be related to a secondary jet-like structure that extends in the NE-SW direction.
However, its very bright central star (VWFPC2 = 10.30) and poor seeing prevented Hrivnak et al. (1999)
from resolving its extension. IRAS 19114+0002 shows rich structure: there are at least four inner concentric
shells (11′′, 7′′, 4′′, and 3′′) with some protuberance and one very sharp elongation (8′′.5) about 15◦ East
from North. The 12CO (J=2-1) map shows very extended structure, which seems to have been shifting its
direction: 10% contour points to 72◦ East from North (37′′), while 50% contour points to 45◦ East from
North (18′′). The protuberance seen in our images may have emanated from the same rotating point of
origin. The axisymmetric nature has also been seen in polarimetric observations (TDG94). Although the
sharp elongation suggests a rather large inclination angle, IRAS 19114+0002 is believed to be close to a
pole-on orientation, which is evidenced by a hollow shell structure seen in both mid-infrared (Hawkins et
al. 1995) and near-infrared polarimetric (Kastner & Weintraub 1995) imaging studies.
3.1.2. DUPLEX Nebulae
The DUPLEX nebulae are recognized either by their magnificent bipolar nebulosities or by rather
well-defined limb-brightened bipolar lobes (Fig. 2). They are usually outlined by a lower surface brightness
halo. These nebulae differ from the SOLE nebulae in appearance primarily because their central stars are
partially or completely obscured. The diffraction spikes are not usually an issue in the images of DUPLEX
nebulae as the central stars are obscured from the direct view. The DUPLEX nebulae can also be further
subdivided into two groups depending on the presence or absence of the central star.
IRAS 16342−3814, IRAS 17150−3224, IRAS 17441−2411, IRAS 20028+3910, and IRAS 22574+6609
show multiple emission peaks without clear indications of the central star's whereabouts. Among those,
IRAS 17150−3224 and IRAS 17441−2411 are found with comparable lobes both in size and brightness
-- 8 --
and their lobes possess some inner structure that seems to be point symmetric. There are also thin
concentric arcs extending beyond the perimeters of the lobes. The arcs appear to be created independently
of the lobes because the arcs maintain the same emission level both in and out of the lobes and hence
seem to be unaffected by the presence of the lobes. The intervals between arcs have been estimated to
be too short to be caused by the consecutive AGB thermal pulses (Paczy´nski 1975). Our B and I band
images of IRAS 17150−3224 and IRAS 17441−2411 confirm the findings by previous HST wide V band
observations (Kwok, Su, & Hrivnak 1998, Su et al. 1998). Weintraub et al. (1998) obtained H2 emission
profiles from these sources and confirmed their orientations suggested from the HST optical images. They
even also found evidence of an expanding torus in IRAS 17150−3224, which was shown in a V -- I image
constructed from ground-based observations (Kwok et al. 1996). IRAS 16342−3814 and IRAS 20028+3910
have unequal lobes in which some inner structure is recognized in the primary lobe. The bipolar nature
of IRAS 16342−3814, an extreme AGB star, was revealed in H2O and OH maser observations (Likkel &
Morris 1988), and recent VLA observations of OH maser determined its inclination angle to be about 40◦
(Sahai et al. 1999). IRAS 20028+3910 has recently been reported to be extended (2′′.2 × 2′′.0, Hrivnak et
al. 1999b), but this only corresponds to the S lobe (which is about 25 times brighter than the N lobe) of
this bi-lobal object. Interestingly, the deconvolved images of IRAS 20028+3910 show multiple-peaks within
the S lobe. IRAS 22574+6609 is optically resolved for the first time and the images indicate the presence
of more than two emission peaks, confirming an earlier suggestion of elongation (Hrivnak & Kwok 1999a).
The emission level of the suspected third emission peak (0′′.2 north of the second peak) is almost the same
as that of the background sky and thus its presence is inconclusive. This "third" peak may simply be a
part of a clumpy second peak, in which case the overall appearance of the source resembles that of IRAS
17441−2411. Our V band photometry (VWFPC2 = 21.24) differs from that of Hrivnak & Kwok (1991a;
VJ = 24). This difference is significant enough to mention, even though we are comparing magnitudes in
slightly different systems. Their lower magnitude suggests that it may have been affected by the unusually
poor seeing (Hrivnak & Kwok 1991a), or this star may have been experiencing a significant brightening.
IRAS 08005−2356, IRAS 17423−1755, and IRAS 19374+2359 have the partially visible central star
with limb-brightened bipolar lobes which appear as a pair of horseshoe structures facing each other along
the bipolar axis. Slijkhuis et al. (1991) observed an unusually broad Hα line profile in IRAS 08005−2356
and attributed it to a fairly extended emission region. This interpretation is independently supported by
spectropolarimetry, which shows an abrupt position angle shift suggesting an optically thick dust torus and
optically thin reflection lobes (TDG94). Both of the above views are confirmed by the bipolar shape clearly
seen in our images. Its SE lobe is approximately 3 times brighter than the NW lobe, which suggests that
the SE lobe is tilted towards us so that the central star becomes partially visible within the conical opening
angle of the lobe. IRAS 17423−1755 displays fascinating point symmetric jet-like structures extending 17′′
in the whole stretch. The NW lobe is more prominent (8 times brighter) than the SE lobe, whose presence
can be traced with the help of the slightly visible, outer part of the limb. This suggests that the NW lobe is
inclined towards us, again explaining the partial view of the central star. The way the SE lobe is obscured
strongly suggests the presence of a dust torus between the lobes. This interpretation agrees with a model
in an earlier multi-wavelengths study, in which fast, collimated jets punctured a detached shell causing a
torus-like shell structure (Bobrowsky et al. 1995). Although less prominent, there are at least three knots
in each of the point symmetric jets as seen previously (Bobrowsky et al. 1995, Riera et al. 1995, Borkowski,
Blondin, & Harrington 1997). A hydrodynamic simulation shows a diverging outflow being focused into a
narrow jet and the point symmetric structure can be explained by wobbling jets (Borkowski, Blondin, &
Harrington 1997). IRAS 19374+2359 was observed by Hrivnak et al. (1999b) and a round extension (2′′.6)
is seen. This corresponds to the outer halo in our images. Although our images of IRAS 19374+2359 have
-- 9 --
smaller signal-to-noise ratio compared with other images, one can discern the star from the nebula in the
northern lobe, which is 3 times brighter than the southern counterpart, suggesting that the northern lobe is
pointing towards us.
The two remaining DUPLEX sources, IRAS 09452+1330 (IRC+10216) and IRAS 23321+6545, do not
neatly fit into either of the above subdivisions. IRAS 09452+1330 is the best studied C-rich AGB star in the
Galaxy. The I band image was previously published (Skinner, Meixner, & Bobrowsky 1998) and is included
in this survey for the sake of completeness. The aspherical appearance of IRAS 09452+1330 has been
interpreted as a bipolar nebula whose southern lobe is pointed towards us, being separated from smaller
northern lobes by a dust lane, and the bright point-like source in the southern lobe may be the central star
(Skinner, Meixner, & Bobrowsky 1998). Thus, we classify IRAS 09452+1330 as a DUPLEX source because
its reflection nebulosity appears quite similar to that of DUPLEX PPNe. We also observed the source with
the wide B filter but did not detect anything. The optical counterpart to IRAS 23321+6545 is imaged for
the first time. Its very small spatial extent suggests that this object is located relatively far away. However,
the fact that this distant source appears extended alternatively indicates that the nebulosity has rather
high surface brightness compared to the central star, which is a typical characteristic of DUPLEX nebulae.
If IRAS 23321+6545 were a SOLE nebula, the PSF of the bright central star would have masked any
structure of the fainter, compact nebula and the source would have appeared as a point source. Therefore,
IRAS 23321+6545 must possess DUPLEX structure, possibly the one with the partially visible central star.
3.1.3. Stellar Sources
Figure 3 shows the sources lacking clear indications of the presence of a nebulosity. IRAS 04386+5722,
IRAS 20043+2653, and IRAS 22142+5206 only have the diffraction features and no evidence of extended
emission regions. There is no deconvolved image displayed for both IRAS 20043+2653 and IRAS
22142+5206 because all of the frames were saturated and reconstruction of the non-saturated peaks was
not possible. Ghosts appear in the images of IRAS 04386+5722 as the "double dots" about 2′′ east of the
star: they are double because each ghost appeared at different chip locations in the dithered frames. IRAS
05113+1347 does not seem to have any extended nebula, however, the deconvolved images leave rather
high residual DNs within 0′′.4 of the central star where a Tiny Tim PSF is able to simulate PSF effects
rather well (Krist et al. 1997). Because of its small angular extent, it is inconclusive whether this is real or
not. IRAS 10158−2844 and IRAS 15465+2818 are considered to have had little recent mass loss but are
associated with very diffuse, extended circumstellar dust shells (Gillett at al. 1986, Waters et al. 1989). Our
images are consistent with this picture of little mass loss by showing no apparent nebulosity. Because these
stars are very bright (hence the use of a narrow band filter), the diffraction features are more prominent in
these images than in other images.
3.2. Measured Quantities and Binary Companions
Tables 1, 2, and 3 summarize the measured quantities for SOLE, DUPLEX, and stellar sources,
respectively. The quantities are the total specific flux densities (Fλ in ergs s−1 cm−2 A−1), WFPC2 system
magnitudes (STMAG), peak intensities, star-to-nebula intensity ratios, sizes, and ellipticity. Table 2 is
subdivided into two sections according to the visibility of the central star: the peak intensity represents the
intensity of the star when the location of the central star in the nebula is certain (top 4 objects) whereas
-- 10 --
it represents the local intensity maximum in the emission region when the central star is completely or
partially obscured (the rest). For images that show clear bipolar structure with halo, the size and ellipticity
are measured for the entire halo as well as for each lobe. We only list photometric quantities for stellar
sources (Table3).
All VWFPC2 are generally in good agreement with the previously published VJ in the literature
(δV ≈ 0.18 mag) where the STMAG closely resembles the Johnson system, except for two sources (IRAS
16342−3814 and IRAS 22574+6609). Comparison between IWFPC2 and available IC in the literature
suggests that IWFPC2 is generally ∼ 1.3 dimmer than IC. This offset is due to the definition of STMAG
system and the amount of offset is about equal to what is expected by definition in SYNPHOT (Simon
1997). Similarly, magnitudes obtained with other filters deviate from the values in the literature due to the
definition of the STMAG system.
Our VWFPC2 of IRAS 16342−3814 (15.64) agrees with another measurement independently made by
Sahai et al. (1999) from the same image (15.7). However, these values are significantly dimmer than the
value reported in a PPN photometric survey (13.65; Van der Veen, Habing & Geballe 1989, hereafter
VHG89). A large photometric aperture used by them is suspected to have included nearby bright stars
(Sahai et al. 1999). On the other hand, their near-infrared photometric values (J=12.17, H=10.75, K=9.61,
done in 1986; VHG89) are significantly dimmer than those of yet another PPN photometric survey (J=9.29,
H=8.32, K=7.71, done in 1993; Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1997a). Because Garc´ıa-Lario et al. (1997) do not
discuss their sources individually or give the observed coordinates, we are unable to assess the cause of
the discrepancy. It is very unlikely that the central star of a PPN becomes dimmer in V and brighter in
near-infrared. IRAS 22272+5435 is suspected to be a variable star with an almost 1 mag variation (Hrivnak
& Kwok 1991b). Our measurement (VWFPC2 = 8.63) is consistent with its brightest magnitude. There
seems to be no sign of any other unreported variability in our sources.
The size of SOLE nebulae is the major and minor axis lengths of the elliptical elongation whereas the
size of DUPLEX nebulae is the extent of the halo. Some SOLE nebulae have two axes of elongation. In
such cases, we only list major axis lengths of the two elongations but not the minor axis lengths, though the
ellipticity are given for each. The averaged ellipticity is rather high for both SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae
(0.45 and 0.43, respectively). Here, the ellipticity is even larger for SOLE nebulae. This quantitatively
confirms what we have seen in the images: reflection nebulosities are unquestionably elongated in their
apparent shapes.
We can also search for signs of binary companions in the vicinity of the sources, and there are several
possible cases. IRAS 10158−2844 is seen with a star (WFPC2 He II mag = 13.70) which is about 2′′ east of
the source. Although IRAS 10158−2844 is known to form a binary system of an orbital period of near 434
days with either a low-mass main sequence star or a white dwarf (Waelkens et al. 1991), this nearby star
does not seem to be the companion of the binary system because the separation is too large (≈ 1500AU).
Whether or not this nearby star is related to IRAS 10158−2844 is also not certain. IRAS 19114+0002 has
a nearby star seen about 4.5′′ north of the source at the edge of the faintest nebulosity along one of the
saturation spikes. However, the stars do not seem to be related due to rather large distance between the
two. IRAS 19374+2359 has a nearby star (VWFPC2 = 20.39) inside the south lobe about 1′′ away from
the central star, but it is likely to be a foreground or background star because of the low galactic latitude
of the source (1◦). IRAS 22142+5206 also has a star (VWFPC2 = 20.36) about 2′′ east of the source, but
the nature of the nearby star is not certain. IRAS 22142+5206 is now classified as a young stellar object
embedded in a massive molecular cloud (∼ 7300M⊙; Dobashi et al. 1998). Their observations indicate that
the source is associated with the most massive CO outflow (∼ 33M⊙) reported so far, and this may be
because of the binarity of the source.
-- 11 --
4. Discussions
4.1. Axisymmetry: an Intrinsic Nature of PPNe
We have detected optical reflection nebulosities in 21 sources out of 27 PPN candidates (78%) and all of
these 21 PPN reflection nebulosities exhibit some type of axisymmetry with the averaged ellipticity of 0.44.
Our direct imaging of reflection nebulosities confirms previously published results in a spectropolarimetric
survey of post-AGB stars, which has indirectly shown that 24 of 31 sources (77%) are aspherical (TDG94).
As we have discussed in the introduction, previous work in the literature has revealed that most PPN
candidates possess axisymmetric nebulosities, and therefore, we conclude that the axisymmetry is an
intrinsic trait of the PPN reflection nebulosities. Below, we discuss when this axisymmetry arises along the
evolutionary track between the AGB and PN phases and how the two different types of PPN may arise.
It is now generally accepted that the AGB phase is associated with two types of mass loss: an AGB
wind (∼ 10 km/s) mass loss phase followed by a briefer but supposedly more violent superwind (∼ 20
km/s) mass loss phase (Renzini 1981). Because the termination of a superwind is considered to be the
end of the AGB phase and no significant stellar wind is expected until the initiation of a fast wind (Kwok
1982), the PPN axisymmetry must arise just before the end of the AGB phase. This interpretation is
also supported by the fact that mass loss is spherically symmetric in the beginning of the AGB phase
(Habing & Blommaert 1993) and that some extreme AGB stars have already departed from spherically
symmetric structure (e.g., IRAS 16342−3814). It is, therefore, very likely that a superwind is intrinsically
axisymmetric and that the onset of a superwind initiates the morphological shift from spherical to axial
symmetry in a PPN circumstellar dust/gas shell.
Based on the results of our PPN survey with the above inference, we propose the following evolutionary
scenario. In the AGB wind phase, an AGB star loses its mass through a dust-driven AGB wind (Salpeter
1974, Kwok 1975, Netzer & Elitzur 1993) in a largely spherically symmetric manner, creating a spherically
symmetric circumstellar AGB wind shell. Towards the end of the AGB phase, some physical mechanism,
albeit still unknown, comes to play and starts generating an equatorially density enhanced dust-driven
wind, which we call an axisymmetric superwind. The axisymmetric superwind dumps the envelope material
of the central AGB star preferentially on the equatorial plane, and a superwind shell with a torus-like
density enhancement develops deep within the spherically symmetric AGB wind shell. The equatorial
density enhancement in the superwind shell is further strengthened as the star evolves. At the end of the
AGB phase, the superwind ceases and defines the inner boundary of a detached circumstellar dust/gas shell,
which manifests itself as a mid- to far-infrared excess in the double-peaked SED of a PPN (Kwok 1993).
This two-phased AGB mass loss scenario can be employed to explain an apparent "dust lane" obscuring
the central star. In one-dimensional radiation transfer simulations, the superwind shell may be treated
as a somewhat ad hoc addition to an otherwise spherically symmetric dust shell (e.g., Su et al. 1998).
Meixner et al. (1997) have incorporated the two-phased mass loss in fully two-dimensional radiation transfer
calculations and their synthesized mid-infrared images and SEDs agree with observations. However, the
scenario used in these calculations is still a first order approximation: the transition from a spherically
symmetric AGB wind to an axisymmetric superwind is assumed to take place abruptly. Instead, the
transition is more likely to occur gradually because mass loss is essentially governed as a function of the
fundamental stellar parameters, which do change gradually as the central star evolves if integrated over the
-- 12 --
course of the entire AGB phase (e.g., Blocker 1995).
Given that the details of the two-phased mass loss probably depend on the fundamental stellar
parameters, the degree of equatorial density enhancement in a superwind may also be dependent upon
them, and the physical environment will probably be distinct in each superwind shell. Figure 4 schematically
describes how this can affect the structure of PPN circumstellar shells and may cause the morphological
bifurcation of PPN reflection nebulosities. In a SOLE PPN (top), a marginal equatorial enhancement in
the superwind shell can yield a dust torus that is optically thin (gray zone), and stellar photons can escape
virtually in all directions (arrows). Hence an observer is able to see the bright central star embedded in
an elliptically elongated nebula (dashed perimeter). In a DUPLEX PPN (bottom), on the other hand, a
stronger equatorial enhancement in the superwind shell can result in a optically thick dust torus (black
zone), and most photons are scattered off towards the biconical openings of the torus along its axis of
symmetry (arrows), thereby generating a bipolar, dumbbell-like nebulosity (dashed perimeter). When the
equatorial enhancement is exceptionally strong, the dust torus can be so flattened that it assumes the form
of a thin disk. Therefore, we consider a disk to be an extremely equatorially enhanced torus.
4.2. SOLE vs. DUPLEX: Physically Distinct Nebulae
The distinct appearances between SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae are characterized by the presence or
absence of the central star and by the undisturbed elliptical or dumbbell-like outline of the nebulosity. We
now discuss how the evident morphological dichotomy of the PPN reflection nebulosities can be caused by
a physical difference in the circumstellar dust/gas shell and not by an inclination angle effect alone. More
specifically, we propose that the optical morphology of PPN candidates bifurcates because the opacity
in the circumstellar dust/gas shells varies due to differing degrees of equatorial density enhancement.
Spectropolarimetric survey results of TDG94 show that there are two types of polarization position angle
shift (a gradual shift in IRAS 04296+3429, a SOLE source and an abrupt shift in IRAS 08005−2356, a
DUPLEX source) and that the presence of the optically thick and thin, two-component obscuring agent
is suspected in PPNe with an abrupt position angle shift. This is consistent with the assumption of
DUPLEX nebulae being associated with optically thick dust grains. In the following, we will present three
additional pieces of evidence suggesting that the morphological dichotomy indeed corresponds to physically
distinct nature of the circumstellar dust shell in PPN nebulae: the mid-infrared morphologies, SEDs, and
IRAS/near-infrared colors.
4.2.1. Mid-Infrared Morphology of PPN Dust Shells
Meixner et al. (1999) have recently observed 66 PPNe at mid-infrared wavelengths and directly imaged
thermal dust emission regions in the circumstellar dust shell. The major discovery in the mid-infrared
survey is the morphological bifurcation of dust emission regions: "core/elliptical" types have an extended
low emission region surrounding a compact unresolved core, which is attributed to an optically thick
equatorial density enhancement, while "toroidal" types show two emission peaks, which are interpreted as
limb-brightened peaks of an optically thin, equatorial density enhancement. If we compare the mid-infrared
and optical morphologies of PPNe, there is a one-to-one correspondence between the two morphologies
-- 13 --
as is shown in Table 44. It appears that toroidals and core/ellipticals are strongly correlated with SOLE
and DUPLEX nebulae, respectively. This correlation is consistent with the picture in which a dust optical
thickness difference causes the PPN morphological bifurcation. That is, PPN candidates that are optically
thin at visible wavelengths (SOLE nebulae) are also optically thin at mid-infrared wavelengths (toroidals),
while PPN candidates that are optically thick at visible wavelengths (DUPLEX nebulae) are also optically
thick at mid-infrared wavelengths (core/ellipticals).
The ways in which the mid-infrared and optical images are spatially related in SOLE and DUPLEX
nebulae differ, and hence, they also suggest a difference in dust shell optical thickness. By direct comparison
between the mid-infrared and optical images of SOLE sources, the optical and mid-infrared nebulae are
found to be spatially coincident and that the optical nebulosity is elongated perpendicularly with respect
to the equatorial plane of the suspected dust torus, whose orientation is indicated by the two mid-infrared
emission peaks. In Figure 5, for example, a resolved, deconvolved 11.8µm image of IRAS 07134+1005 shows
limb-brightened dust emission peaks which are oriented in the east-west direction (Meixner et al. 1997),
while its optical (Stromgren v) nebula is extended in the north-south direction (top left). A similar trend
is seen in the composite image of IRAS 17436+5003 (top right; Skinner et al. 1994) as well. On the other
hand, the mid-infrared and optical images of DUPLEX sources show elongation in the same direction, and
the mid-infrared emission region is often completely embedded within the optical nebulosity. In Figure 5,
for example, an I band image of IRAS 17150−3224 clearly displays the dust lane, which completely obscures
the central star, between the two lobes and there is a very compact, unresolved mid-infrared emission core
over the location of the dust lane (bottom left), and the unresolved dust emission core of IRAS 16342−3814
in 9.8µm is very compact with respect to the whole extent of the I band reflection nebulosity (bottom right).
4.2.2. Spectral Energy Distribution of PPNe
One of the well-established characteristics of PPNe is that their SEDs have a "double-peaked" structure
(cf. Kwok 1993). The shortward and longward peaks in the wavelength spectrum respectively correspond
to the stellar and dust emission components. The morphological bifurcation between the SOLE and
DUPLEX nebulae also manifest itself as a distinction between the SED shapes of these sources. A number
of post-AGB stars have been classified into four classes based on the shape of the SED (VHG89):
I. Flat spectrum between 4 and 25µm and a steep fall-off to shorter wavelengths,
II. Maximum around 25µm and a gradual fall-off to shorter wavelengths,
III. Maximum around 25µm and a steep fall-off to a plateau roughly between 1 and 4µm with a steep
fall-off at shorter wavelengths,
IV. Two distinct maxima; one around 25µm and a second between 1 and 2µm (IVa) or one around 25µm
and a second < 1µm (IVb).
Here, we adopt the VHG classification scheme for the SEDs of our sources. Because only five of our sources
were studied in VHG89 with a partial coverage of the stellar component (i.e., > 1µm), we compiled new
4We included four other PPN candidates (one SOLE source, IRAS 21282+5050, and three DUPLEX sources, IRAS
04395+3601, Red Rectangle (IRAS 06176−1036), and Egg Nebula) whose mid-infrared and optical morphologies have been
identified.
-- 14 --
SEDs of our sources by adding our photometric measurements at optical wavelengths to the latest published
data in the literature. Figures 6, 7, and 8 show updated SEDs for SOLE, DUPLEX, and stellar sources,
respectively, with VHG class assignments indicated in each frame. The SED shapes of SOLE and DUPLEX
nebulae are indeed very distinct from each other, but are very similar within each morphological type of
the nebulosity. Stellar sources are of a mix of classes and are discussed in §4.2.5. Table 4 (column 5)
summarizes a clear correlation between the morphological and SED classes.
All SOLE nebulae have a double-peaked, class IV SED. The prominent central stars in SOLE nebulae
appear in their SED as the well-defined, unobscured optical/near-infrared peak and the thermal emission
from the circumstellar dust appears as an almost equal flux peak. There is a subdivision of the SED
class among SOLE nebulae depending on the location of the optical/near-infrared peak. The difference
stems from the degree of reddening of the central star due to its circumstellar dust/gas shell. Class IVb
PPNe tend to have physically larger circumstellar shells and hence their column densities are lower, less
dereddening the central star. Interestingly, mid-infrared images are resolved for those of class IVb (IRAS
07134+1005, IRAS 17436+5003, and IRAS 19114+0002), and this coincidence is consistent with the picture
of more extended, optically thin dust shells of SOLE nebulae. IRAS 21282+5050 is a very young PN that
we classify as a SOLE source based on morphology (Kwok, Hrivnak, & Langill 1993, Meixner et al. 1997),
but its SED class appears to be III because the shorter wavelengths light from its hot central star (Of7,
Cohen & Jones 1987) is more reddened by the dust than the star light from a typical PPN central star.
DUPLEX SEDs are of class II (e.g., IRAS 19374+2359) or of class III (e.g., IRAS 17150−3224). Both
classes II and III are characterized by a prominent far-infrared peak (30 to 50µm) with an optical/near-
infrared excess that represents the central star or its associated reflection nebulosity. The difference between
class II and III SEDs is the presence of a rather large near-infrared excess in class II, which is commonly
attributed to either an ongoing mass loss episode or the presence of very compact circumstellar dust shell
(VHG89). Interestingly, this SED class difference among DUPLEX sources corresponds to the visibility of
the central star. That is, the SED will be of class II when the central star is partially visible whereas it will
be of class III when the central star is completely obscured from the view. IRAS 09452+1330 is of class I
but has a flat peak at <∼ 10µm caused by its lower Teff (∼ 2000K), which is consistent with its AGB stellar
nature. Its very sharp drop into the shortward wavelengths resulted in non-detection in our B band image
(Table 2). We classify IRAS 08005−2356 of class II because of its gradual fall-off in shorter wavelengths due
to rather large optical/near-infrared flux. Our classification of IRAS 08005−2356 and IRAS 17423−1755
being DUPLEX sources is well supported by the resemblance in the shapes of the two SED classes.
The differences in the SED shapes between SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae can be explained in the
context of our hypothesis. In the case of a SOLE nebula, the circumstellar dust is optically thin and
permits a clear, albeit reddened, view of the central star with a modest amount of dust emission, which is
proportional to the column density of dust. Hence, we see two distinct, comparable peaks of stellar and
dust emission in its SED. In the case of a DUPLEX nebula, on the other hand, the circumstellar dust is
optically so thick that almost all of the star light is absorbed by the dust and is reradiated at mid- to
far-infrared wavelengths; only a few optical photons escape through the biconical openings of the dust shell.
Therefore, we see a prominent dust emission peak accompanied by an optical/near-infrared plateau in its
SED. In the framework of our hypothesis, an inclination angle effect among DUPLEX sources manifests
itself as the difference in their SED shapes.
-- 15 --
4.2.3.
IRAS/Near-Infrared Two-Color Diagrams
To demonstrate the differences between SOLE and DUPLEX sources, we use the J -- K vs. K -- [25]
diagram, an IRAS/near-infrared two-color diagram (Fig. 9). Here, [25] is IRAS flux at 25µm in magnitude
converted by [25] = −2.5 log(Fν /6.73) (IRAS Explanatory Suppliment 1988). Because K -- [25] color relates
the heights of stellar and dust peaks whereas J -- K color describes the shape of the stellar component,
the J -- K vs. K -- [25] diagram introduces characteristics of detached dust shells and incorporated the SED
dichotomy into a diagram. The robustness of the J -- K vs. K -- [25] diagram is evident in the clear bifurcation
between morphological groups. In J -- K color, SOLE sources are bluer (<∼ 1.45) than DUPLEX sources.
This bluer color is consistent with the presence of an optically thinner circumstellar shell along the line
of sight to the central star. In K -- [25] color, DUPLEX sources are spatially separated according to the
visibility of the central star: DUPLEX sources with invisible central stars are redder than SOLE sources
while those with partially visible central stars (IRAS 08005−2356 and IRAS 17423−1755) are bluer than
SOLE sources. This bifurcation among DUPLEX sources follows the split of the SEDs into classes II and
III: very high near-infrared excess in the class II DUPLEX sources makes their K -- [25] colors bluer than
the class III DUPLEX sources and even bluer than SOLE sources. The diagram thus not only signifies the
difference between SOLE and DUPLEX sources but also differentiates the partial/total obscuration of the
central star in DUPLEX nebulae, and should be a very useful tool in identifying the nature of dust shell by
near- to mid-infrared colors.
With new all-sky near-infrared surveys becoming available (e.g. 2MASS and DENIS), near-infrared
two-color diagrams will also be a valuable tool in discriminating a particular type of sources from a large
data set. Whitelock (1985) presented near-infrared (JHK) photometry for 80 PNe and classified them into
several types in terms of the visibility of the central star due to dust obscuration and of the location in
the near-infrared two-color J -- H vs. H -- K diagram. Since the apparent morphological bifurcation is also
partly based on the visibility of the central star, we adopt the classification scheme of Whitelock (1985)
and make use of such two-color diagrams. Figure 10 is the J -- H vs. H -- K diagram with our sources that
have published near-infrared photometric data. Also shown in the diagram are the regions according to
the object classification for PN candidates: Nebula+Star, Nebula, Nebula+Dust, Star+Dust, and Miras
(Whitelock 1985). Because of the dusty nature of PPNe, all of our sources are distributed over a linear
diagonal region that corresponds to the regions of Miras and Star+Dust objects. There is a parallelism
between the distributions of our targets and planetary nebulae in the diagram: SOLE nebulae correspond
to PNe with prominently visible central nuclei (Nebula+Star), whereas DUPLEX nebulae correspond to
dust enshrouded PNe (Nebula+Dust). There also seems to be a border that separates the region of SOLE
sources from that of DUPLEX sources on the region of Miras (dashed line in Fig. 10). All SOLE nebulae are
found on or blueward of the border and all DUPLEX nebulae are found on or redward of the border. The
fact that DUPLEX sources are redder than SOLE sources suggests that DUPLEX nebulae are associated
with a larger amount of obscuring dusts than SOLE nebulae are and this corroborates our hypothesis of the
morphological bifurcation being induced by the differing optical thickness in the two types of sources.
4.2.4. The Inclination Angle Effect
The inclination angle between the axis of symmetry with the line of sight can change the morphological
appearance of an object. We have seriously considered if the inclination angle effect alone could explain all
the observed differences between SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae with questions such as if SOLE nebulae are
-- 16 --
nearly pole-on DUPLEX nebulae or not. In the following, we discuss that the evidence suggests otherwise.
Suppose that the dust shell structure of all existing PPNe are of DUPLEX type, i.e., all dust shells
have the same geometry of optically thick tori. When sources are oriented edge-on (90◦ inclination angle),
most of the star light is blocked by the dust torus and we observe optical reflection nebulosities in the
form of more or less well-balanced bipolar lobes with a dust lane (e.g. IRAS 17150−3224 and IRAS
17441−2411). However, in other cases when the inclination is in some intermediary angle, sources should
appear as imbalanced nebulae either with a dust lane (with larger intermediate inclination angle) or
without a dust lane (with smaller intermediate inclination angle), whose central stars are seen off center in
the nebulosities when visible. The imbalance in the structure of nebulosities occurs because the far side
of the nebulosity (which is pointing away from us) will be at least partially obscured by the near side of
the optically thick dust torus, as we see in the images of IRAS 08005−2356 and IRAS 17423−1755, for
example. This imbalance of brightness was also shown in simulated images of IRAS 17441−2411 with 4
different inclination angles presented by Su et al. (1998, their Fig. 5). According to their simulation, the
central star is seen evidently off-centered even at 30◦ inclination angle.
As we have seen in our images of SOLE nebulae, 11 of 21 nebulae appear as well-balanced, smooth,
and symmetric low surface brightness nebulosities with their central stars located at centers of the nebulae.
Following the discussion above, this is possible only when all 11 sources are oriented exactly pole-on or
extremely close to pole-on. Thus, if this is the case one has to explain why nearly half the objects are
oriented at zero or near-zero inclination angles with respect to us. For instance, IRAS 07134+1005 would
be a prime example of a PPN viewed nearly exactly pole-on because it shows an extended, almost circular
reflection nebulosity of uniform brightness with its central star at the center of the nebulosity. Nevertheless,
the mid-infrared images of IRAS 07134+1005 clearly show a two-peaked, limb-brightened dust torus which
suggests a non-zero inclination angle and radiative transfer calculations support a model of an equatorially
enhanced dust torus viewed at an inclination angle of ∼ 45◦ (Meixner et al. 1997). If IRAS 07134+1005
were really a DUPLEX source viewed at a 45◦ inclination angle, it should have appeared as either an
imbalanced nebula with the central star located off center or a bipolar nebula with one of the lobes partially
obscured. However, that is not the case and thus the inclination angle effect can not simply explain the
data. The most reasonable interpretation of the data is that the optical thickness along the line of sight
is too low to cause any detectable difference, which is also supported by radiation transfer calculations
(edge-on τ9.7µm ∼ 0.03, Meixner et al. 1997).
As we have seen in the previous section, the distinction between SOLE and DUPLEX sources is obvious
and the subdivision among DUPLEX sources is remarkable in the J -- K vs. K -- [25] diagram (Fig.10). One of
the most peculiar aspects of the IRAS/near-infrared diagram is that the sources are not distributed linearly
as in the J -- K vs. H -- K diagram. If the inclination angle effect were the main cause for the distinction
between SOLE and DUPLEX sources, the sources would have been distributed linearly with the region
of DUPLEX sources with obscured central stars being located between the regions of SOLE sources and
DUPLEX sources without central stars. Alternatively, the absence of subdivision among SOLE sources
corroborates our view of SOLE sources being associated with optically thin dust tori: no matter what the
inclination angle is there is no partial obscuration in the SOLE sources and they cluster as a single group
in the J -- K vs. K -- [25] diagram.
It is of course possible that we come across a source whose orientation is exactly or very close to pole-on.
In such cases, how the reflection nebulosities appear is not trivial. No matter to which morphological
type a source belongs, it is incredibly difficult to detect reflection nebulosity when the source is viewed
pole-on because the central star appears extremely prominent and the prominent PSF spikes are likely to
-- 17 --
severely obscure the nebulosity. The appearance of IRAS 07430+1115, a SOLE PPN, does not fall into the
morphological type of the DUPLEX nebulae, but the source still looks different from other SOLE nebulae.
Although SED and two-color diagrams also suggest that this object is a SOLE source, it is possible that this
is a DUPLEX source oriented at or very close to pole-on. However, we tentatively classify the source as a
SOLE nebula and will not delve into the issue in this study. The pole-on cases must be further investigated
with at least two-dimensional calculations. Radiative transfer calculations with fully axisymmetric models
would clarify these inclination angle effects with more certainty and such calculations will be the focus of
our future work.
4.2.5. Non-Association with Nebulosities
There are six sources we tentatively classify as stellar sources because no reflection nebulosities are
detected. Neither PSF subtraction nor deconvolution achieves the perfect removal of the WFPC2 diffraction
features, and thus, there are always some residual diffraction artifacts which can mask a low surface
brightness reflection nebula. In particular, our observations are insensitive to circular nebulosities with
extremely low surface brightness, which can be easily confused with the WFPC2 circular diffraction wings.
When viewed pole-on, SOLE sources would appear more or less like stellar sources due to a combined
effect of the high star-to-nebula contrast and a confusion with the WFPC2 PSF artifact. For example,
IRAS 04386+5722 and IRAS 05113+1347 may be such cases. The images of these sources barely show
nebulosities and the deconvolved images are almost nebula-free for IRAS 04386+5722 whereas suggestive of
a compact nebula for IRAS 05113+1347. However, their SEDs are of class IVa (Fig. 8) and their locations
in two-color diagrams are within the region of SOLE sources (an asterisk and a filled star in Figures 9 and
10). The slight offset of IRAS 04386+5722 towards blue in K -- [25] color in the J -- K vs. K -- [25] diagram
can be explained considering the pole-on inclination angle effect: the source is of SOLE type and hence the
stellar emission peak is present in the SED irrespective of the angle of inclination and hence its J -- K color
would not be very different from other SOLE sources, while its K -- [25] color can be bluer than other SOLE
sources because the stellar emission would be more prominent than other SOLE sources with respect to the
dust emission. IRAS 05113+1347 is located among other SOLE sources.
IRAS 10158−2844 and IRAS 15465+2818 have very bright central stars, but the amount of far-infrared
excess is smaller (Fig. 8). The lack of far-infrared excess in these sources makes the SED classification
scheme of VHG89 inapplicable and also makes both have much bluer K -- [25] color than other sources
(K -- [25] = 3.48 and 3.12, respectively). This is consistent with the evolutionary status of these R Coronae
Borealis stars, in which they have had little recent mass loss but are associated with very diffuse, extended
circumstellar dust shells (Gillett at al. 1986, Waters et al. 1989). However, if we consider the stellar
component peaks alone (which peak at < 1µm) these objects will be found among DUPLEX sources (Fig.
10; filled stars in the region of DUPLEX sources) suggesting the presence of circumstellar dust rather close
to the central star, on-going mass loss, or pole-on inclination angle effects. The nature of variability of
IRAS 10158−2844 is suspected to be due to variable obscuration by circumstellar material along the line
of sight and the inclination angle of this source is expected to be >∼ 50◦ (Waelkens et al. 1991). In fact,
both of these sources show indications of a very recent mass loss (Clayton et al. 1997, Meixner et al. 1999).
Hence, a possible explanation for the non-detection of any nebulosities is that the column density of dust
near the star in these sources is much lower than in SOLE sources.
IRAS 20043+2653 is classified as an OH/IR source (cf. Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1997a), and hence, the
-- 18 --
central star is likely be in the AGB or extreme AGB phase. This interpretation fits well with the SED
shape and its very red H -- K color (both of which resemble to those of IRAS 09452+1330, an extreme AGB
star). Therefore, the absence of any reflection nebulosity seems to suggest that IRAS 20043+2653 has
not yet developed one. IRAS 22142+5206 is classified as a young stellar object embedded in a massive
CO molecular cloud of ∼ 7300M⊙ (Dobashi et al. 1998). Its SED shows significant far-infrared excess
without a stellar component (Fig. 8), which is a signature of a class I young stellar object (e.g., Wilking,
Lada, & Young 1989). Its location in two-color diagrams is also consistent with the young stellar object
interpretation.
4.3. Origins of the PPN Morphological Bifurcation
The origin of axisymmetry in many astrophysical systems is always of a great importance and there
have been numerous possible mechanisms for the creation of nebular morphologies (cf. Livio 1997).
Instead of reviewing every possible means, we will focus on the origins of the differing equatorial density
enhancement in the SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae.
4.3.1. Galactic Height and Progenitor AGB Stellar Mass
One of the strongest pieces of circumstantial evidence that is related to the morphological bifurcation is
probably that bipolar nebulae are preferentially found close to the plane of the Galaxy. With a large sample
of PNe, Corradi & Schwartz (1995) found that bipolar PNe were distributed closer to the Galactic plane
(scale height zh = 130 pc with z <∼ 850 pc) than elliptical PNe (zh = 325 pc with z <∼ 1300 pc). Following
this finding, they suggested that bipolar PNe have evolved from more massive progenitors than elliptical
PNe, adopting a lower limit of 1.5M⊙ for the bipolar PN progenitors. This correlation is also suggested by
the galactic latitudes and the z values of our sources (Table 4). DUPLEX sources, having a mean height
of 220 pc with a range of z <∼ 520, are more confined to the Galactic plane than the SOLE sources, which
have a mean height of 470 pc with a range of z <∼ 2100. Although a direct comparison between our values
(mean Galactic heights) to the values obtained by Corradi & Schwartz (1995; Galactic scale heights) is not
possible, there certainly exists a parallelism in the ways these two types of PPNe and two types of PNe are
distributed in the Galaxy. To test if the Galactic height distributions of the SOLE and DUPLEX sources
are not exactly equal, we calculated the Kolmogorov -- Smirnov (K -- S) statistic (0.417) and its significance
level (0.186). This means that there is 18.6% chance that the K -- S statistic, the greatest difference between
the two cumulative distribution functions of the Galactic heights, will be smaller than 0.417, if both types
of objects are from the same Galactic height distribution. Considering the fact that some SOLE sources do
exist close to the Galactic plane where DUPLEX sources are populated, the outcome of the K -- S test is
suggestive that SOLE and DUPLEX sources are not distributed in the exactly same manner. Therefore, it
is likely that more massive progenitor AGB stars lead to DUPLEX PPNe and that bipolar PNe are the
direct descendants of DUPLEX PPNe and elliptical PNe are the SOLE PPN offspring. In fact, this is a
very reasonable result in the context of stellar evolution. The majority of AGB stars become white dwarfs
of roughly 0.6 M⊙ (Schonberner 1981); the more massive the progenitor, the more material the star has to
dump into the circumstellar environment. Therefore, PPNe from more massive progenitor AGB stars are
likely to have more obscuring material in the circumstellar shell, which could completely block the central
star from the observer's view as in DUPLEX nebulae. This is well demonstrated in Figure 10 as DUPLEX
sources being redder than SOLE sources. Also consistent with the division of PPN into two classes is that
-- 19 --
the degree of equatorial enhancement and the subsequent evolution depend on the fundamental parameters
of the central star, especially, the stellar mass.
4.3.2. Circumstellar Chemistry
Because PPNe can be put into two groups in terms of photospheric and/or circumstellar chemistry (C-
or O-rich), we looked for a correlation between the circumstellar chemistry and morphological bifurcation.
When referring to the chemical type of a PPN, one needs to be cautious because a PPN can have both C-
and O-rich characteristics in the circumstellar environment above the photosphere (e.g., IRAS 08005−2356
and Red Rectangle). The circumstellar chemistry can be determined mainly by the presence of a certain
molecular species (e.g., OH in an O-rich shell, Hu et al. 1994; HCN in a C-rich shell, Loup et al. 1993)
or some infrared spectral feature (e.g., 9.7µm feature in an O-rich shell; 21µm feature in a C-rich shell,
Kwok, Volk, & Hrivnak 1989). On the other hand, the photospheric chemistry can be determined by direct
abundance measurements (e.g., IRAS 02229+6208, IRAS 07430+1115, Reddy, Bakker & Hrivnak 1999;
IRAS 04296+3429, Decin et al. 1998; IRAS 05341+0852, Reddy et al. 1997; IRAS 06530−0213, Reddy
1999; IRAS 18095+2704, Klochkova 1995; IRAS 19114+0002, Reddy & Hrivnak 1999; IRAS 20462+3416,
Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1997a) or the presence of optical photospheric features of C2 or C3 molecules (e.g.,
Hrivnak 1995). Comparison between the PPN morphology and photospheric/circumstellar chemistry
does not seem to yield any apparent correlation between the two. Table 4 (column 7) summarizes the
non-correlation between morphology and chemistry.
4.3.3. Stellar Ages
It may be possible to attribute the differing optical thickness in SOLE and DUPLEX PPNe to their
ages. PPN dust shells expand with time and older shells tend to have smaller optical depth, and therefore,
DUPLEX PPNe are expected to be younger than SOLE PPNe. If one insists on a single evolutionary
channel, DUPLEX PPNe may be forerunners of SOLE PPNe. However, bifurcating PPNe into SOLE and
DUPLEX types by their ages does not appear to be possible because of the spectral types of these stars.
If DUPLEX PPNe were indeed younger than SOLE PPNe, DUPLEX PPNe would have had the latest
spectral types possible (G to M types) and SOLE PPNe would have had the earliest spectral types (A to
F types). However, SOLE PPNe include a number G types (e.g. IRAS 04296+3429) and DUPLEX PPNe
include F types (e.g. IRAS 08005−2356 and Egg Nebula). Given the horizontal evolutionary track in the
HR diagram during the PPN phase and its surpassingly short evolutionary time scale, it is not possible to
conclude one type of PPNe is younger than the other.
4.4. From the Dual PPN Morphology to the PN Morphology
During the PPN phase, the two-layered PPN shell keeps expanding around the central post-AGB star
while the surface temperature of the star continues to rise. A fast wind initiates somewhere along the
PPN phase and pushes the inner boundary of the PPN shell out to typical PN dimensions, while shaping
the boundary geometry and increasing the boundary density (Kwok 1982). The central post-AGB star
finally becomes hot enough to emit photoionizing photons, which illuminate the inner boundary of the
circumstellar gas shell as a PN. Because we observe dust-scattered light in PPNe and ionized gas emission
-- 20 --
in PNe, we can not trivially link the PPN and PN morphologies via a mere resemblance in the images. We
can, nevertheless, interpolate the PPN and PN morphologies considering the circumstellar distribution of
matter and see the PN morphological structures (round, elliptical, and butterfly classes; Balick 1987) in the
dual PPN morphology. The bipolar shapes of DUPLEX PPNe (e.g., IRAS 08005−2356, IRAS 17150−3224)
may be forerunners to the bipolar PNe (e.g., Hourglass Nebula, Sahai & Trauger 1995). The simply
elongated SOLE nebulae (e.g., IRAS 17436+5003, IRAS 20462+3416) may be precursors of elliptical PNe
(e.g., NGC 3132 (HST Heritage Team 1998), IC 3568 (Bond & Ciardullo 1997)). The multi-lobed SOLE
nebulae (e.g., IRAS 22272+5435, IRAS 06530−0213) may be progenitors of complex PNe (e.g., Stingray
Nebula (Bobrowsky et al. 1998), Cat's Eye Nebula (Harrington & Borkowski 1995)). We thus see that the
development of the PPN axisymmetry in the superwind phase probably sets the stage for the emergence
of axisymmetry in PNe. Jet-like structures, however, are rather rare in PPNe (e.g., IRAS 17423−1755,
which is a young PN) and this may suggest that the formation of jet-like structures seen in PNe (e.g., NGC
5307, Bond & Ciardullo 1997) does not share the same generating mechanism as the PPN axisymmetric
structures.
5. Conclusions
After observing 27 PPN candidates with HST , we have found elongated low surface brightness reflection
nebulosities around 21 sources. We have also found that an optical reflection nebulosity can manifest itself
in the form of a faint, elliptically elongated shell in addition to the bipolar form. The PPN circumstellar
shell seems to be intrinsically axisymmetric (ellipticity ∼ 0.44) and we argue that the axisymmetry emerges
in the superwind phase, the latter of the two-phased AGB mass loss epoch. A morphological bifurcation
exists among the PPN nebulosities: of 21 extended nebulae, 11 are SOLE nebulae (e.g., IRAS 07134+1005)
and 10 are DUPLEX nebulae (e.g., IRAS 17150−3224). We discuss how the morphological dichotomy is
caused by the difference in optical thickness of the PPN circumstellar dust shells: SOLE shells are optically
thin whereas a DUPLEX shells are optically thick. The distinctness between SOLE and DUPLEX nebulae
in terms of optical thickness of the dust shells is evidenced by the correlation between the mid-infrared
morphology of dust emission regions and optical morphology of reflection nebulosities, the characteristic
shapes of the SEDs, and the near- and IRAS/near-infrared two-color diagrams. We also discuss that the
inclination alone may not be able to explain the well-balanced shape of reflection nebulosities with their
central stars seen at the center. Although we find no correlation between the circumstellar chemistry and
morphology, we do find that DUPLEX sources tend to be found closer to the Galactic plane than SOLE
sources. This suggests that DUPLEX PPNe probably originate from higher mass AGB progenitor stars than
SOLE PPNe. The origins of the apparent morphological bifurcation -- the equatorial density enhancement
in the superwind -- remain inconclusive. In addition to optical imaging of reflection nebulosities, direct,
high-resolution imaging of dust emission regions in mid-infrared wavelengths will be extremely important
in studies of PPNe because optical images of reflection nebulosities alone are not sufficient to decipher the
orientation of these objects. Similarly, future investigation will have to require at least two-dimensional,
radiative transfer model calculations.
This research is based on observations with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope, obtained at the
Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI), which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research
in Astronomy, Inc. under NASA contract No. NAS5-26555. Data reduction was done with routines
provided in the Space Telescope Science Data Analysis System (STSDAS), which is a software package for
-- 21 --
calibrating and analyzing data from HST . STSDAS includes the same calibration routines as are used
in the routine data processing pipeline, as well as general-purpose tools and enhancements to the Image
Analysis and Reduction Facility (IRAF) distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories,
which are operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative
agreement with the National Science Foundation. This research also made use of the SIMBAD database,
operated at CDS, Strasburg, France. Ueta and Meixner are supported by NASA Grants GO-06737.01-95A
and GO-06364.02-95A and NSF Career Award Grant AST 97-33697. Bobrowsky is supported by STScI
Grants GO-06364.01-94A and GO-006737.02-95A. We are thankful for the help that Chris Skinner gave
us in setting up these observations. Chris J. Skinner, who died suddenly in October 1997, was a valued
colleague and friend. We would also like to thank the STScI support staff for their guidance in setting up
these observations and helping with the reduction of the data.
Bakker, E. J., van Dishoeck, E. F., Waters, L. B. F. M., & Schoenmaker, T. 1997, A&A, 323, 469.
REFERENCES
Balick, B. 1987, AJ, 94, 671.
Blocker, T. 1995, A&A, 297, 727.
Blommaert, J. A. D. L., van der Veen, W. E. C. J., & Habing, H. J. 1993, A&A, 267, 39.
Bobrowsky, M., Sahu, K. C., Parthasarathy, M., & Garc´ıa-Lario, P. 1998, Nature, 392, 469.
Bobrowsky, M., Zijlstra, A. A., Grebel, E. K., Tinny, C. G., te Lintel Hekkert, P., Van de Steene, G. C.,
Likkel, L., & Bedding, T. R. 1995, ApJ, 446, L89.
Bond, H. & Ciardullo, R. 1997, STScI-PRC, 97-38b.
Borkowski, K. J., Blondin, J. M., & Harrington, J. P. 1997, ApJ, 482, L97.
Bujarrabal, V., Alcolea, J., & Planesas, P. 1992, A&A,, 257, 701.
Campbell, M. P., Elias, J. H., Gezari, D. Y., Harvey, P. M., Hoffmann, W. F., Hudson, H. S., Neugebauer,
G., Soifer, B. T., Werner, M. W., & Westbrook, W. E. 1976, ApJ, 208, 396.
Clayton, G. C., Bjorkman, K. S., Nordsieck, K. H., Zellner, N. E. B., & Schulte-Ladbeck, R. E. 1997, ApJ,
476, 870.
Cohen, M., Anderson, C. M., Cowley, A., Coyne, G. V., Fawley, W., Gull, T. R., Harlan, E. A., Herbig,
G. H., Holden, F., Hudson, H. S., Jakoubek, R. O., Johnson, H. M., Merrill, K. M., Schiffer, F. H.,
Soifer, B. T., & Zuckerman, B. 1975, ApJ, 196, 179.
Cohen, M. & Jones, B.F. 1987, ApJ, 321, L151.
Corradi, R. L. M. & Schwartz, H. E. 1995, A&A, 293, 871.
Decin, L., Van Winckel, H., Waelkens, C., & Bakker, E. J. 1998, A&A, 332, 928.
Dobashi, K., Yonekura, Y., Hayashi, Y., Sato, F., & Ogawa, H. 1998, ApJ, 115, 777.
Feast, M. W., Carter, B. S., Roberts, G., Marang, F., & Catchpole, R. M. 1997, MNRAS, 285, 317.
-- 22 --
Fruchter, A. S., Hook, R. N., Busko, I. C., & Mutchler, M. 1997, in 1997 HST Calibration Workshop, eds.
S. Casertano, R. Jedrzejewski, C. D. Keyes, & M. Stevens (Baltimore: STScI), p.518.
Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Manchado, A., Pottasch, S. R., Suso, J., & Olling, R. 1990, A&AS, 82, 497.
Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Manchado, A., Pych, W., & Pottasch, S. R. 1997a, A&AS, 126, 479.
Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Parthasarathy, M., de Martino, D., Sanz Fern´andez de C´ordoba, L., Monier, R., Manchado,
A., & Pottasch, S. R. 1997b, A&A, 326, 1103.
Geballe, T. R., Tielens, A. G. G. M., Kwok, S., & Hrivnak, B. J. 1992, ApJ, 387, L89.
Geballe, T. R. & van der Veen, W. E. C. J. 1990, A&A, 235, L9.
Gillett, F. C., Backman, D. E., Beichman, C., & Neugebauer, G. 1986, ApJ, 310, 842.
Goldreich, P. & Scoville, N. 1976, ApJ, 205, 144.
Gutler, J., Kompe, C., & Henning, Th. 1996, A&A, 305, 878.
Habing, H., te Lintel Hekkert, P., & van der Veen, W. E. C. J. 1989, in IAU Symposium 131: Planetary
Nebulae, ed. S. Torres-Peimbert (Dordrecht: Kluwer), p.359
Habing, H. & Blommaert, J. A. D. L. 1993, in IAU Symposium 155: Planetary Nebulae, eds. R. Weinberger
& A. Acker (Dordrecht: Kluwer), p.243
Harrington, J. P. & Borkowski, K. J. 1995, 185th AAS meeting (Tucson, AZ).
Hawkins, G. W., Skinner, C. J., Meixner, M., Jernigan, J. G., Arens, J. F., Keto, E., & Graham, J. R.
1995, ApJ, 452, 314.
Holtzman, J. A., Burrows, C. J., Casertano, S, Hester, J. J., Trauger, J. T., Watson, A. M., Worthey, G.
1995, PASP, 107, 1065.
Hrivnak, B. J. 1995, ApJ, 438, 341.
Hrivnak, B. J. & Kwok, S. 1991a, ApJ, 368, 564.
Hrivnak, B. J. & Kwok, S. 1991b, ApJ, 371, 631.
Hrivnak, B. J. & Kwok, S. 1999a, ApJ, 513, 869.
Hrivnak, B. J., Kwok, S., & Geballe, T. R. 1994, ApJ, 420, 783.
Hrivnak, B. J., Kwok, S., & Volk, K. 1988, ApJ, 331, 832.
Hrivnak, B. J., Kwok, S., & Volk, K. 1989, ApJ, 346, 265.
Hrivnak, B. J., Langill, P. P., Su, K. L., & Kwok, S. 1999b, ApJ, 513, 421.
HST Heritage Team 1998, STScI-PRC, 98-39.
Hu, J. Y., Slijkhuis, S., de Jong, T., & Jiang, B. W. 1993a, A&AS, 100, 413.
Hu, J. Y., Slijkhuis, S., Nguyen-Q-Rieu, & de Jong, T. 1993b, A&A, 273, 185.
Hu, J. Y., te Lintel Hekkert, P., Slijkhuis, S., Baas, F., Sahai, R., & Wood, P. 1994, A&AS, 103, 301.
-- 23 --
Humphreys, R. M. & Ney, E. P. 1974, ApJ, 190, 339.
Iben, I. & Renzini, A. 1983, ARA&A, 21, 271.
Iyengar, K. V. K. & Parthasarathy, M. 1997, A&AS, 121, 45.
Johnson, J. J. & Jones, T. J. 1991, AJ, 101, 1735.
Joint IRAS Science Working Group 1988, Infrared Astronomical Satellite Catalogs and Atlases, Version 2.
Explanatory Suppliment, eds. C. A. Beichmen, G. Neugebauer, H. J. Habing, P. E. Clegg, & T. J.
Chester. (Washington: NASA Reference Publication).
Kahn, F. D. & West, K. A. 1985, MNRAS, 212, 837.
Kastner, J. H. & Weintraub, D. A. 1995, ApJ, 452, 833.
Klochkova, V. G. 1995, MNRAS, 272, 710.
Krist, J. E., Burrows, C. J., Stapelfeldt, K. R., Ballester, G. E., Clarke, J. T., Crisp, D., Evans, R. W.,
Gallagher, J. S. III, Griffiths, R. E., Hester, J. J., Holtzman, J. A., Hoessel, J. G., Mould, J. R.,
Scowen, P. A., Trauger, J. T., Watson, A. M., & Westphal, J. A. 1997, ApJ, 481, 447.
Krist, J. E., & Hook, R. N. 1997, The Tiny Tim User's Guide v4.4 (Baltimore: STScI).
Kwok, S. 1975, ApJ, 198, 583.
Kwok, S. 1982, ApJ, 258, 280.
Kwok, S. 1993, ARA&A, 31, 63.
Kwok, S., Hrivnak, B. J., & Boreiko, R. T. 1987, ApJ, 312, 303.
Kwok, S., Hrivnak, B. J., & Geballe, T. R. 1990, ApJ, 360, L23.
Kwok, S., Hrivnak, B. J., & Geballe, T. R. 1995, ApJ, 454, 394.
Kwok, S., Hrivnak, B. J., & Langill, P. P. 1993, ApJ, 408, 586.
Kwok, S., Hrivnak, B. J., Zhang, C. Y., & Langill, P. L. 1996, ApJ, 472, 287.
Kwok, S., Su, K. Y. L., & Hrivnak, B. J. 1998, ApJ, 501, L117.
Kwok, S., Volk, K., & Hrivnak, B. J. 1989, ApJ, 345, L51.
Lawrence, G., Jones, T. J., & Gehrz, R. D. 1990, AJ, 99, 1232.
Le Bertre, T. 1988, 203, 85.
Likkel, L. & Morris, M. 1988, ApJ, 329, 914.
Likkel, L., Morris, M., Omont, A., & Forveille, T. 1987, A&A, 173, L11.
Livio, M. 1997, Sp. Sci. Reviews, 82, 389.
Loup, C., Forveille, T., Omont, A. & Paul, J. F. 1993, A&AS, 99, 291.
-- 24 --
Luck, R. E., Bond, H. E., & Lambert, D. L. 1990, ApJ, 357, 188.
Manchado, A. Pottasch, S. R., Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Esteban, C., & Mampaso, A. 1989, A&A, 214, 139.
Mastrodemos, N. & Morris, M. 1999, ApJ, in press.
Meixner, M., Skinner, C. J., Graham, J. R., Keto, E., Jernigan, J. G. & Arens, J. F. 1997, ApJ, 482, 897.
Meixner, M., Ueta, T., Dayal, A., Hora, J. L., Fazio, G., Hrivnak, B. J., Skinner, C. J., Hoffmann, W. F.,
& Deutsch, L. K. 1999, ApJS, 122, 221.
Mellema, G & Frank, A. 1995, MNRAS, 273, 401.
Netzer, N. & Elitzur, M. 1993, ApJ, 410, 701.
Oudmaijer, R. D., van der Veen, W. E. C. J., Waters, L. B. F. M., Trams, N. R., Waelkens, C., &
Engelsman, E. 1992, A&AS, 96, 625.
Paczy´nski, B. 1975, ApJ, 202, 558.
Parthasarathy, M. 1993, ApJ, 414, L109.
Reddy, B. E. 1999, private communication
Reddy, B. E. & Hrivnak, B. J. 1999a, AJ, 117, 1834.
Reddy, B. E., Bakker, E. J. & Hrivnak, B. J. 1999b, submitted to ApJ.
Reddy, B. E., Parathasarathy, M., Gonzalez, G., & Bakker, E. J. 1997, A&A, 328, 331.
Reddy, B. E. & Parathasarathy, M. 1996, AJ, 1112, 2053.
Renzini, A. 1981, in Physical Processes in Red Giants, ed. I. Iben & A. Renzini (Dordrecht: Reidel), p.431.
Riera, A., Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Manchado, A., Pottasch, S. R., & Raga, A. C. 1995, A&A, 302, 137.
Sahai, R., te Lintel Hekkert, P., Morris, M., Zijstra, A., & Likkel, L. 1999, ApJ, 514, L115.
Sahai, R. & Trauger, J. T. 1996, STScI-PRC, 96-07.
Sahai, R., Trauger, J. T., Watson, A. M., Stapelfeldt, K. R., Hester, J. J., Burrows, C. J., Ballister, G.
E., Clarke, J. T., Crisp, D., Evans, R. W., Gallagher, J. S., III, Griffiths, R. E., Hoessel, J. G.,
Holtzman, J. A., Mould, J. R., Scowen, P. A., & Westphal, J. A. 1998, ApJ, 493, 301.
Salpeter, E. E. 1974, ApJ, 193, 585.
Schmidt, G. D. & Cohen, M. 1981, ApJ, 246, 444.
Schonberner, D. 1981, A&A, 103, 119.
Shepp, L. A. & Vardi, Y. 1982, IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging, MI-1, 113.
Simon, B. 1997, Synphot User's Guide v4.0 (Baltimore: STScI).
Skinner, C. J., Meixner, M., Bobrowsky, M. 1998, MNRAS, 300, L29.
-- 25 --
Skinner, C. J., Meixner, M., Barlow, M. J., Collison, A. J., Justtanont, K., Blanco, P., Pina, R., Ball, J. R.,
Keto, E., Arens, J. F., & Jernigan, J. G. 1997, A&A, 328, 290.
Skinner, C. J., Meixner, M., Hawkins, G. W., Keto, E., Jernigan, J. G., & Arens, J. F. 1994, ApJ, 423,
L135.
Slijkhuis, S., Hu, J. Y., & de Jong, T. 1991, A&A, 248, 547.
Smith, V. V. & Lambert, D. L. 1994, ApJ, 424, L123.
Soker, N. 1998, MNRAS, 299, 1242.
Su, K. Y. L., Volk, K., Kwok, S., & Hrivnak, B. J. 1998, ApJ, 508, 744.
te Lintel Hekkert, P. 1991, A&A, 248, 209.
Trammell, S. R., Dinerstein, H. L., & Goodrich R. W. 1994, AJ, 108, 984 (TDG94).
Van der Veen, W. E. C. J., Habing, H. J., & Geballe, T. R. 1989, A&A, 226, 108 (VHG89).
Waelkens, C., Lamers, H. J. G. L. M., Waters, L. B. F. M., Rufener, F., Trams, N. R., Le Bertre, T., Ferlet,
R., Vidal-Madjae, A. 1991, A&A, 242, 433.
Waters, L. B. F. M., Lamers, H. J. G. L. M., Snow, T. P., Mathlener, E., Trams, N. R., van Hoof, P. A. M.,
Waelkens, C., Seab, C. G., & Stanga, R. 1989, A&A, 221, 208.
Waters, L. B. F. M., Waelkens, C., van Winckel, H., Molster, F. J., Tielens, A. G. G. M., van Loon, J. Th.,
Morris, P. W., Cami, J., Bouwman, J., de Koter, A., de Jong, T., & de Graauw, Th. 1998, Nature,
391, 868.
Weintraub, D. A., Huard, T., Kastner, J. H., & Gatley, I. 1998, ApJ, 509, 728.
Westbrook, W.E., Becklin, E.E., Merrill, K.M., Neugebauer, G., Schmidt, M., Willner, S.P., &
Wynn-Williams, C.G. 1975, ApJ, 202, 407.
Whitelock, P. A. 1985, MNRAS, 213, 59.
Whitmore, B. C. 1997, in 1997 HST Calibration Workshop, eds. S. Casertano et al (Baltimore: STScI),
p.317.
Wilking, B. J., Lada, C. J., & Young, E. T. 1989, ApJ, 340, 823.
Zacs, L., Klochkova, V. G., & Panchuk, V. E. 1995, MNRAS, 275, 764.
Zuckerman, B. & Aller, L. H. 1986, ApJ, 301, 772.
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
-- 26 --
Fig. 1. -- (a) -- (c): Images of SOLE nebulae in the increasing order of their right ascension (north is up and
east is left): the left-most frame shows the IRAS ID and scale of the object. The tick marks show relative
offsets in arcseconds. The filter types are shown at the bottom of each frame with "+ RL" indicating
Richardson-Lucy deconvolution. Wedges show the ranges of log-scaled flux density to help readers visually
illustrate the emission contrast. See Table 1 for the star-to-nebula surface intensity ratio.
Fig. 2. -- (a) -- (c): Images of DUPLEX nebulae. The displaying scheme follows Figure 1. See Table 2 for the
star-to-nebula surface intensity ratio.
Fig. 3. -- Selected Images of stellar sources. These images exemplify how PSF artifacts appear in both
reduced and deconvolved images. The basic displaying scheme follows Figure 1.
Fig. 4. -- A schematic diagram illustrating the essential difference between SOLE and DUPLEX sources.
[Top] In the SOLE sources, the superwind mass loss creates marginally equatorially enhanced dust shell (gray
area near the central star) within a spherically symmetric the AGB wind shell. Because the axisymmetric
dust shell is optically thin, it permits star light to leak out in all directions (arrows), creating an elliptically
elongated nebula (dashed line) with the bright central star. [Bottom] In the DUPLEX sources, the superwind
mass creates highly equatorially enhanced dust shell (black area near the central star) within a spherically
symmetric the AGB wind shell. Because the axisymmetric dust shell is optically thick, it permits starlight
to leak out only along the biconical openings of the dust torus (arrows), creating a bipolar, dumbbell-
like nebulosity (dashed perimeter) with the partially or completely obscured central star. Relative sizes of
components are not to scale.
Fig. 5. -- Composites of optical and mid-infrared images of four PPN candidates. Mid-infrared contours
are overlaid onto an optical grayscale image. The top row shows examples of the SOLE-toroidal correlation
(IRAS 07134+1005: F410M and 11.8µm and IRAS 17436+5003: F410M and 12.5µm) and the bottom row
shows examples of the DUPLEX-core/elliptical correlation (IRAS 17150−3224: F814W and 12.5µm and
IRAS 16342−3814: F814W and 9.8µm). Tickmarks show relative offsets from the center.
Fig. 6. -- Spectral energy distributions of SOLE sources in λFλ (ergs s−1 cm−2) vs. λ (µm). The name of
the source and its SED class assignment (Van der Veen, Habing & Geballe 1989; see text) are given in each
frame. Photometric data are taken from our measurements and references listed in Table 4.
Fig. 7. -- Spectral energy distributions of DUPLEX sources in λFλ (ergs s−1 cm−2) vs. λ (µm). Conventions
follow those of Fig. 6.
Fig. 8. -- Spectral energy distributions of stellar sources in λFλ (ergs s−1 cm−2) vs. λ (µm). Conventions
follow those of Fig. 6.
Fig. 9. -- IRAS/Near-infrared two-color (J -- K vs. K -- [25]) diagram for our sources. Circles, triangles, and
stars are respectively SOLE, DUPLEX, and stellar sources. The asterisk is IRAS 04386+5722, a stellar source
whose chemistry is undetermined. The numbers associated with symbols refer to the source numbers given
in Table 4 (column 1). Two stellar sources, IRAS 10158−2844 and IRAS 15465+2818, and one DUPLEX
source, IRAS 09452+1330, are located off the diagram: (K -- [25], J -- K) = (3.48, 1.59), (3.12, 2.11), and
(10.21, 6.54), respectively. This diagram displays the color of the star vs. the ratio of the dust peak to the
stellar peak in the SED. Sources are more clearly clustered into three groups: SOLE and DUPLEX sources
with a totally obscured central star (w/o Star), and DUPLEX sources with a visible central star (w/ Star).
Each subdivision is labeled in the diagram. The dashed line indicates a fiducial division between SOLE and
DUPLEX sources. All sources above the line are of DUPLEX type and below the line are of SOLE type.
-- 27 --
Fig. 10. -- Near-infrared two-color (J -- H vs. H -- K) diagram for our sources. Conventions follow those of
Fig. 9. Two AGB stars, IRAS 09452+1330 (C-rich) and IRAS 20043+2653 (O-rich) are located off the
diagram: (H -- K, J -- H) = (3.03, 3.51) and (2.79, 0.30), respectively. Whitelock's classification of planetary
nebula (1985) is also shown in the diagram: the regions of Nebula+Star, Nebula+Dust, Star+Dust, Nebula,
and Miras. Sources are clustered diagonally in the diagram, which indicates the black-body temperature
decreasing to the upper right. The dashed line indicates a fiducial division between SOLE and DUPLEX
sources. All sources on the right of the line are of DUPLEX type and on the left of the line are of SOLE
type.
9
9
9
1
IRAS ID
02229+6208
04296+3429
05341+0852
06530−0213
07134+1005
(HD56126)
07430+1115
p
e
S
6
3
v
8
3
2
8
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
17436+5003
(HD161796)
18095+2704
(OH53.8+20.2)
19114+0002
(HD179821)
20462+3416
22272+5435
(HD235858)
Observed and Derived Properties of SOLE Nebulae
TABLE 1
Obs. Coord. (J2000) WFPC2
1
Fλ
RA
DEC
Filter
HST
Mag2
Surface Intensity3
Peak3a Ratio3b
Size
(′′ × ′′ (σ))
Ellipticity4
(e = 1 − b/a)
02:26:41.9 +62:21:22
04:32:57.0 +34:36:13
05:36:55.0 +08:54:08
06:55:31.8 −02:17:29
07:16:10.3 +09:59:48
07:45:51.4 +11:08:20
17:44:55.4 +50:02:40
18:11:30.8 +27:05:15
19:13:58.6 +00:07:32
20:48:16.6 +34:27:25
22:29:10.4 +54:51:07
F555W 6.36 e−14
F814W 3.51 e−13
F555W 7.68 e−15
F814W 2.54 e−14
F555W 1.43 e−14
F814W 3.16 e−14
F555W 8.83 e−15
F814W 3.14 e−14
F410M 1.03 e−12
F547M 1.71 e−12
F555W 3.90 e−14
F814W 7.45 e−14
F410M 8.07 e−12
F547M 5.82 e−12
F555W 2.74 e−13
F814W 3.70 e−13
F410M 7.11 e−13
F547M 1.70 e−12
F555W 1.45 e−13
F814W 6.05 e−14
F555W 1.28 e−12
F814W 2.26 e−12
11.89
10.04
14.19
12.89
13.51
12.65
14.03
12.66
8.87
8.32
12.42
11.72
6.63
6.99
10.30
9.98
9.27
8.32
10.99
11.95
8.63
8.01
9.2 e−2
5.1 e−1
2.0 e−3
1.4 e−2
1.9 e−2
4.8 e−2
8.3 e−3
3.4 e−2
1.5 e+0
4.0 e+0
1.9 e−2
5.4 e−2
1.4 e+1
1.0 e+1
2.9 e−1
4.8 e−1
2.0 e+0
3.0 e+0
4.4 e−1
1.4 e−1
1.7 e+0
2.6 e+0
1000
1200
65
220
220
440
390
860
5300
11000
18
50
9400
7100
960
1100
180000
110000
17000
16000
3500
3700
2.09 × 1.42 (2.2)
2.14 × 1.52 (2.5)
1.88 × 1.57 (2.9)
1.69 × 1.59 (3.0)
1.12 × 0.81 (5)
1.14 × 0.78 (5)
2.36 × 1.11 (2.5)
2.33 × 0.92 (2.2)
4.73 × 4.15 (5.3)
4.70 × 3.71 (4.0)
1.01 × 0.90 (6)
0.98 × 0.86 (7)
4.34 × 2.46 (4.9)
4.49 × 2.53 (3.6)
1.89 × 1.27 (2.2)
1.82 × 1.04 (6)
10.69 × 8.30 (∼1)
10.82 × 8.52 (2)
4.10 × 3.23 (2.2)
3.99 × 2.94 (2.5)
3.53 × 3.47 (5.6)
3.47 × 3.37 (4.0)
0.32
0.29
0.61, 0.67
0.61, 0.66
0.72, 0.33
0.70, 0.31
0.53
0.61
0.12
0.21
0.11
0.12
0.43
0.44
0.80, 0.54
0.69, 0.60
0.22
0.21
0.21
0.26
0.43, 0.61
0.41, 0.62
1In units of ergs/s/cm2/A.
2HST WFPC2 system magnitudes (STMAG).
3In units of ergs/s/cm2/A/sr: 3a-peak intensity of the central source, 3b-star-to-nebula intensity ratio.
4a and b are respectively major and minor axis lengths.
Observed and Derived Properties of DUPLEX Sources
TABLE 2
IRAS ID
Obs. Coord. (J2000) WFPC2
1
Fλ
RA
DEC
Filter
HST
Mag2
Surface Intensity3
Peak3a Ratio3b
Size
(′′ × ′′ (σ))
Ellipticity4
(e = 1 − b/a)
9
9
9
1
p
e
S
6
3
v
8
3
2
8
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
08005−2356
08:02:40.8 −24:04:44
09452+1330
(IRC+10216)
17423−1755
(Hen3-1475)
19374+2359
09:47:57.4 +13:16:43
17:45:14.2 −17:56:47
19:39:35.6 +24:06:28
16342−3814
16:37:39.9 −38:20:17
Eastern Lobe
Western Lobe
Eastern Lobe
Western Lobe
17150−3224
17:18:19.7 −32:27:21
Southeastern Lobe
Northwestern Lobe
Southeastern Lobe
Northwestern Lobe
17441−2411
17:47:13.5 −24:12:50
Northern Lobe
Southern Lobe
Northern Lobe
Southern Lobe
20028+3910
20:04:35.9 +39:18:45
Northern Lobe
Southern Lobe
Northern Lobe
Southern Lobe
22574+6609
22:59:18.3 +66:25:47
23321+6545
23:34:23.1 +66:01:51
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
F555W 1.01 e−13
F814W 1.91 e−13
F450W
. . .
F814W 5.37 e−15
F555W 2.59 e−14
F814W 3.78 e−14
F555W 2.39 e−16
F814W 1.89 e−15
F555W 2.02 e−15
1.22 e−16
1.74 e−15
F814W 5.99 e−15
8.81 e−17
5.12 e−15
F450W 3.26 e−15
9.51 e−16
2.44 e−15
F814W 1.24 e−14
9.23 e−15
1.11 e−14
F450W 1.04 e−15
6.11 e−16
3.29 e−16
F814W 6.98 e−15
5.18 e−15
3.50 e−15
F555W 3.60 e−16
1.26 e−17
3.52 e−16
F814W 1.19 e−15
4.25 e−17
1.18 e−15
F555W 1.16 e−17
F814W 1.16 e−16
F555W 3.15 e−18
F814W 1.06 e−17
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
11.38
10.70
. . .
14.54
12.87
12.46
17.96
15.71
15.64
18.68
15.80
14.46
19.04
14.63
15.12
16.45
15.43
13.07
13.99
13.78
16.35
16.93
17.61
14.29
14.61
15.04
17.51
21.15
17.53
16.21
19.83
16.22
21.24
18.74
22.65
21.34
1.1 e−1
2.5 e−1
. . .
2.0 e−3
5.8 e−3
2.2 e−2
2.4 e−5
3.5 e−4
. . .
7.1 e−5
9.2 e−4
. . .
2.7 e−4
1.3 e−3
. . .
1.6 e−5
4.9 e−5
. . .
1.9 e−4
2.3 e−4
. . .
4.2 e−5
1.7 e−5
. . .
3.0 e−4
1.2 e−4
. . .
2.0 e−7
6.7 e−5
. . .
2.4 e−6
1.7 e−4
6.3 e−6
3.5 e−5
1.3 e−5
3.1 e−5
990
1200
. . .
250
1900
10000
32
130
9
120
8
50
10
32
170
210
5
2
28
11
1
330
1
70
6
12
9
12
2.68 × 1.42 (2.3)
2.58 × 1.13 (1.6)
. . .
3.12 × 3.00 (∼1)
3.75 × 1.98 (5)i
3.70 × 2.19 (3)i
3.29 × 1.63 (2.6)
3.07 × 1.57 (4)
2.55 × 0.71 (3)
0.52 × 0.39 (3)
1.27 × 0.71 (3)
2.71 × 0.82 (3)
0.76 × 0.56 (2)
1.29 × 0.82 (2)
12.59 × 6.12 (5)
2.70 × 1.22 (10)
2.57 × 1.37 (10)
8.96 × 4.72 (3)
2.51 × 1.61 (5)
2.50 × 1.39 (5)
4.43 × 1.76 (2)
1.61 × 0.90 (3)
1.43 × 0.57 (3)
6.47 × 3.77 (5)
1.28 × 0.80 (10)
1.46 × 0.44 (10)
3.48 × 2.11 (3)
0.74 × 0.70 (∼ 1)ii
1.71 × 1.27 (7)
4.42 × 3.13 (3)
1.69 × 1.11 (5)ii
0.14 × 0.48 (5)
0.82 × 0.50 (4.7)
0.73 × 0.48 (2)
0.26 × 0.16 (8)
0.40 × 0.35 (5)
0.47
0.44
. . .
0.04
0.47
0.41
0 50
0.49
0.72
0.25
0.44
0.70
0.26
0.36
0.51
0.55
0.47
0.47
0.36
0.44
0.60
0.44
0.60
0.42
0.38
0.70
0.39
0.05
0.26
0.29
0.34
0.71
0.39
0.34
0.38
0.13
1In units of ergs/s/cm2/A.
2HST WFPC2 system magnitudes (STMAG).
3In units of ergs/s/cm2/A/sr: 3a-peak intensity of the central star or lobe, 3b-star- or peak-to-nebula intensity ratio.
4a and b are respectively major and minor axis lengths.
iAssociated with point symmetric jets which extend 16′′.70 in V and 16′′.92 in I.
iiThe northern lobe appears to have an oblate shape.
9
9
9
1
p
e
S
6
3
v
8
3
2
8
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Observed and Derived Properties of Stellar Sources
TABLE 3
IRAS ID
Obs. Coord. (J2000) WFPC2
1
Fλ
RA
DEC
Filter
HST
Mag2
Surface Peak
Intensity3
04386+5722
04:42:49.0 +57:27:47
05113+1347
05:14:07.8 +13:50:28
10:18:07.6 −28:59:32
F555W
F814W
F555W
F814W
F469N
1.63 e−14
2.09 e−13
3.68 e−14
9.15 e−14
2.44 e−11
13.37
10.60
12.49
11.50
5.43
5.1 e−2
4.2 e−1
4.8 e−2
1.3 e−1
6.7 e+1
10158−2844
(HR4049)
15465+2818
(RCrB)
20043+2653
15:48:34.4 +28:09:25
F469N
1.56 e−12
8.42
5.4 e+0
20:06:22.7 +27:02:32
22142+5206
22:16:10.1 +52:21:13
F555W > 7.39 e−16 < 16.73
F814W > 8.36 e−16 < 16.59
F555W > 1.83 e−15 < 15.74
F814W > 1.52 e−15 < 15.95
> 8.6 e−4
> 4.8 e−4
> 7.7 e−4
> 7.4 e−4
1In units of ergs/s/cm2/A.
2HST WFPC2 system magnitudes (STMAG).
3In units of ergs/s/cm2/A/sr.
Optical vs. Mid-Infrared Morphologies and Other Properties of PPN Candidates
TABLE 4
#
IRAS ID
Object
Type
Mid-IR
Morph.i
SED
Type
Spectral
Class
Chemii
(*/CS)
biii
(deg)
z iii
(pc)
Referencesiv
SOLE SOURCES
1
2
5
6
9
7
9
8
9
16
1
18
p
19
e
S
23
25
6
02229+6208
04296+3429
05341+0852
06530−0213
07134+1005
07430+1115
17436+5003
18095+2704
19114+0002
20462+3416
22272+5435
21282+5050
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN?
PN
PPN
PN
DUPLEX SOURCES
3
v
9
8
10
3
13
2
14
8
0
15
9
17
9
20
/
h
21
p
26
-
27
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
3
X
4
r
a
11
12
22
24
08005−2356
09452+1330
16342−3814
17150−3224
17423−1755
17441−2411
19374+2359
20028+3910
22574+6609
23321+6545
04395+3601
06176−1036
AFGL 2688
PPN
AGB
AGB
PPN
PN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PPN
PN
PPN
PPN
STELLAR SOURCES
PPN
PPN
RCrB
RCrB
AGB
YSO
04386+5722
05113+1347
10158−2844
15465+2818
20043+2653
22142+5206
unknown
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
toroidal
unresolved
toroidal
unresolved
toroidal
. . .
toroidal
toroidal
unresolved
. . .
core/elliptical
core/elliptical
. . .
unknown
core/elliptical
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
core/elliptical
core/elliptical
core/elliptical
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
unresolved
IVa
IVa
IVa
IVa
IVb
IVa
IVb
IVa
IVb
IVb
IVa
III
II
I
III
III
II
III
II
II/III
II
II/III
III
III
III
IVa
IVa
..
..
I
II
G8-K0Ia
G0Ia
G20-Ia
F0Iab
F5Iab
G50-Ia
F3Ib
F3Ib
G5Ia
B1Ia
G2Ia
..
F5e
C9.5
M
G2
..
..
..
..
..
..
B0
B8V
F5Iae
M
G8Ia
B9.5Ib-II
F0-F8pe
..
..
C/C
C/C
C/C
C/C?
C/C
C/C
O/O
O/O
O/O
O/..
C/C
C/C
C/O
C/..
../O
../O
../O
../C?
../O
../C
C/C
../C
C/C
C/O
C/C
../..
C/C
C/..
C/..
O/..
C/..
1.5
-9.1
-12.2
-0.1
10.0
17.1
30.9
20.2
-5.0
-5.8
-2.5
-0.1
3.6
45.1
5.8
3.0
5.8
2.2
1.0
4.1
6.0
4.3
-6.5
-11.8
-6.5
7.5
-14.3
22.9
51.0
-2.7
-3.6
60
650
2100
4
520
90
620
660
350
290
130
6
250
140
220
130
510
110
90
240
520
..
190
70
140
..
1200
270
1500
..
280
22,48,52
1,8,12,19,20,23,31,37,44,46,47,53,62
1,12,15,22,46,48,53,54
12,28,29,48,50,53
1,5,23,25,33,35,36,37,44,46,47,62
12,22,23,31,48,52
1,5,11,23,25,30,43,44,45,48,56,62
5,12,23,24,26,33,34,40,44,48,62,63
5,18,23,25,32,44,51,62,63
12,13,49,59
1,12,14,19,21,23,37,44,46,47,62,63,67
47,69,70
11,19,29,31,58,62
1,6,40,44,57,62
12,17,42,48,55,63
12,17,27,28,29,38,39,44,48,53,63,66
12,61
3,4,12,28,29,38,44,48,53,60,63,66
26,29,34,40,48,63
26,29,44,48
20,26,29,48
29,44,48
20,74
68,73
71,72
22,48,52
1,9,11,12,19,23,36,48
1,48,62,64,65
7,10,48,62
46
9,46,48
iMarginally resolved sources have an inconclusive "unknown" morphology classification (Meixner et al. 1999).
iiChemistry: * -- Photosphere, CS -- Circumstellar shell
iiiGalactic latitude, b, is used with the averaged distance in the literature to estimate the Galactic height, z.
ivReferences: Photometric data are obtained from references in boldface; 1.Bakker et al. 1997, 2.Blommaert et al. 1993, 3.Bobrowsky
et al. 1995, 4.Borkowski et al. 1997, 5.Bujarrabal et al. 1992, 6.Campbell et al. 1976, 7.Clayton et al. 1997, 8.Decin et al. 1998, 9.Dobashi
et al. 1999, 10.Feast et al. 1997, 11.Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1990, 12.Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1997a, 13.Garc´ıa-Lario et al. 1997b, 14.Geballe et
al. 1992, 15.Geballe et al. 1990, 16.Gillett et al. 1986, 17.Gutler et al. 1996, 18.Hawkins et al. 1995, 19.Hrivnak 1995, 20.Hrivnak et
al. 1991a, 21.Hrivnak et al. 1991b, 22.Hrivnak et al. 1999a, 23.Hrivnak et al. 1994, 24.Hrivnak et al. 1988, 25.Hrivnak et al. 1989,
26.Hrivnak et al. 1999b, 27.Hu et al. 1993a, 28.Hu et al. 1993b, 29.Hu et al. 1994, 30.Humphreys et al. 1974, 31.Iyengar et al. 1997,
32.Kastner et al. 1995, 33.Klochkova 1995, 34.Kwok et al. 1987, 35.Kwok et al. 1990, 36.Kwok et al. 1995, 37.Kwok et al. 1989, 38.Kwok
et al. 1996, 39.Kwok et al. 1998, 40.Lawrence et al. 1990, 40.Le Bertre 1988, 42.Likkel et al. 1988, 43.Likkel et al. 1987, 44.Loup et al.
1993, 45.Luck et al. 1991, 46.Manchado et al. 1989 47.Meixner et al. 1997, 48.Meixner et al. 1999, 49.Parthasarathy 1993, 50.Reddy
1999, 51.Reddy et al. 1999a, 52.Reddy et al. 1999b, 53.Reddy et al. 1996, 54.Reddy et al. 1997, 55.Sahai et al. 1999, 56.Skinner et
al. 1994, 57.Skinner et al. 1998, 58.Slijkhuis et al. 1991, 59.Smith et al. 1994, 60.Su et al. 1998, 61.te Lintel Hekkert 1991, 62.TDG94,
63.VHG89, 64.Waelkens et al. 1991, 65.Waters et al. 1989, 66.Weintraub et al. 1998, 67.Zacs et al. 1995, 68.Cohen et al. 1975, 69.Cohen
et al. 1987, 70.Kwok et al. 1993, 71.Sahai et al. 1998, 72.Skinner et al. 1997, 73.Waters et al. 1998, 74.Westbrook et al. 1975
|
astro-ph/9902070 | 1 | 9902 | 1999-02-04T14:33:53 | The zabs=zem Absorption Line Systems Toward QSO J2233-606 in the Hubble Deep Field South: NeVIII770,780 absorption and partial coverage | [
"astro-ph"
] | Results of a careful analysis of the highly ionized absorption systems, observed over the redshift range 2.198--2.2215 in the zem=2.24 HDFS-QSO J2233-606, are presented. Strong OVI and NeVIII absorptions are detected. Most of the lines show signature of partial coverage which varies from species to species. This can be understood if the clouds cover the continuum emission region completely and only a fraction of the broad emission line region. Using photo-ionization models we analyze in more detail the component at zabs = 2.198. Absolute abundances are close to solar but the [N/C] abundance ratio is larger than solar. This result, which is consistent with the analysis of high-z QSO broad emission-lines, confirms the physical association of the absorbing gas with the AGN. The observed column densities of NIV, NV and NeVIII favor a two-zone model for the absorbing region where NeVIII is predominantly produced in the highly ionized zone. It is most likely that in QSO J2233-606, the region producing the NeVIII absorption can not be a warm absorber. One of the Lyalpha absorption lines at zabs = 2.2215 has a flat bottom typical of saturated lines and non-zero residual intensity in the core, consistent with partial coverage. There is no metal-line from this Lyalpha cloud detectable in the spectrum which suggests either large chemical inhomogeneities in the gas or that the gas is very highly ionized. If the latter is true the cloud could have a total hydrogen column density consistent with that of X-ray absorbers. It is therefore of first importance to check whether or not there is an X-ray warm-absorber in front of this QSO. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
11.17.1;11.17.4 J2233-606
ASTRONOMY
AND
ASTROPHYSICS
15.10.2018
9
9
9
1
b
e
F
4
1
v
0
7
0
2
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
The zabs ∼ zem absorption line systems toward QSO J2233-
606 in the Hubble Deep Field South: Ne viiiλλ770,780
absorption and partial coverage ⋆
Patrick Petitjean1,2 and R. Srianand3
1Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris -- CNRS, 98bis Boulevard Arago, F-75014 Paris, France
2UA CNRS 173 -- DAEC, Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, F-92195 Meudon Cedex, France
3IUCAA, Post Bag 4, Ganesh Khind, Pune 411 007, India
Abstract. Results of a careful analysis of the highly ion-
ized absorption systems, observed over the redshift range
2.198 -- 2.2215 in the zem = 2.24 HDFS-QSO J2233-606,
are presented. The strength and covering factor of the
O vi and Ne viii absorption lines suggest that the gas is
closely associated with the AGN. In addition, most of the
lines show signature of partial coverage and the covering
factor varies from species to species. This can be under-
stood if the clouds cover the continuum emission region
completely and only a fraction of the broad emission line
region.
Using photo-ionization models we analyze in more de-
tail the component at zabs= 2.198, for which we can derive
reliable estimates of column densities for H i and other
species. Absolute abundances are close to solar but the
[N/C] abundance ratio is larger than solar. This result,
which is consistent with the analysis of high-z QSO broad
emission-lines, confirms the physical association of the ab-
sorbing gas with the AGN. The observed column densities
of N iv, N v and Ne viii favor a two-zone model for the
absorbing region where Ne viii is predominantly produced
in the highly ionized zone. It is most likely that in QSO
J2233-606, the region producing the Ne viii absorption
can not be a warm absorber.
One of the Lyα absorption lines at zabs = 2.2215 has a
flat bottom typical of saturated lines and non-zero resid-
ual intensity in the core, consistent with partial coverage.
There is no metal-line from this Lyα cloud detectable in
the spectrum which suggests either large chemical inhomo-
geneities in the gas or that the gas is very highly ionized.
Send offprint requests to: Patrick Petitjean
⋆ Based in part on observations obtained with the
NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope by the Space Telescope
Science Institute, which is operated by AURA, Inc., under
NASA contract NAS 5 -- 26555; observations collected at the
European Southern Observatory, La Silla, Chile; and observa-
tions collected at the Anglo-Australian Observatory.
If the latter is true the cloud could have a total hydrogen
column density consistent with that of X-ray absorbers.
It is therefore of first importance to check whether or not
there is an X-ray warm-absorber in front of this QSO.
Key words: quasars: absorption lines, quasars: individ-
ual: J2233-606
1. Introduction
The QSO J2233-606 (zem = 2.24) has been given tremen-
dous interest as it is located in the middle of the STIS
Hubble deep field south making this field an ideal target
for studying the connection between the diffuse gaseous
component of the universe and galaxies (Ferguson 1998).
The spectrum of this QSO shows several associated sys-
tems, (i.e. systems with zabs ≃ zem ), at zabs ∼ 2.2 with
broad C iv and N v absorption lines (Sealey et al. 1998,
Savaglio 1998, Outram et al. 1998). HST STIS spectra,
together with the available ground-based data, provide
different pieces of information about these systems over
the rest-wavelength range 375-2800 A.
Associated systems have been intensively studied in
the past few years because they are believed to be inti-
mately related to the central engines of AGNs as: (i) they
frequently show absorption due to high-ionization lines;
(ii) they have been convincingly shown to have metallic-
ities of the order of or above solar (Petitjean et al. 1994,
Savaglio et al. 1994, Hamann 1997); (iii) the absorbing
gas does not cover the background emitting region com-
pletely (Petitjean et al. 1994, Hamann et al. 1997b, Barlow
& Sargent 1997). In a few cases it has been shown that
the optical depth of the high-ionization lines varies with
time on scales of a year (Hamann et al. 1997b) as is the
case for some broad absorption line systems (e.g. Barlow
2
et al. 1992). This requires a recombination time-scale of
less than a year and hence high particle density in the
absorbing gas if the observed variability is caused by the
change in the ionizing conditions.
Soft X-ray spectra of an appreciable fraction of Seyfert-
I galaxies show K-shell absorption edges of ionized oxygen
(O vii and O viii; Reynolds 1997, George et al. 1998).
Rapid variability of these absorption edges suggest that
the absorbing gas is very close to the central engine.
Moreover, there is a one-to-one correspondence between
the presence of associated absorption systems and X-ray
"warm absorbers" in Seyfert galaxies (Crenshaw et al.
1998). The case for a unified model for X-ray and UV
absorbers, although attractive, is not completely convinc-
ing yet however. Eventhough Mathur et al. (1994) showed
that the X-ray and UV absorptions seen in 3C351 can be
reproduced by a single-cloud model, there are cases where
two different ionized zones are needed even to produce
the optical depth ratios of O vii and O viii (see Reynolds
1997).
Some Seyfert-I galaxies show signatures of the exis-
tence of optically thin emitting clouds in the BLR. Shield,
Ferland & Peterson (1995) have shown that the properties
of the optically thin clouds in the inner BLR are consis-
tent with that of warm absorbers (see also Porquet et al.
1998). Analysis of the broad Ne viiiλ774 emission line in
QSOs shows that the Ne viii-emitting regions have ioniza-
tion parameters in the range 5 -- 30, total hydrogen column
densities of the order of 1022.5 cm−2 and average covering
factors >30% for solar abundances and a nominal QSO
spectrum (Hamann et al. 1997b). The ionization condi-
tions in these emitting clouds are similar to those of warm
absorbers.
In order to investigate in more detail the nature of as-
sociated systems and their possible connection to warm
absorbers, absorptions from species with a wide range
of excitation should be studied. Morevover column den-
sities should be determined taking into account the ef-
fect of partial coverage. In this prospect, absorption from
Ne viii, if present, is crucial as its ionization potential,
207 eV, is much higher than the ionization potential of
other easily observable species. To our knowledge the
Ne viiiλλ770,780 absorption doublet has been detected
in only two associated systems, in the line of sight to
HS1700+6416 at zabs = 2.7126 (Petitjean et al. 1996; see
the HST spectrum in Vogel & Reimers 1995) and in the
line of sight to UM675 (Hamann et al. 1995, see the spec-
trum in Hamann et al. 1997a) at zabs = 2.1340. Analysis
of the latter system leads the authors to conclude that, al-
though the detection of Ne viii provides strong evidence
for a link between the associated system and the warm ab-
sorber, the total hydrogen column density in the Ne viii
phase is too small to produce the warm absorber phe-
nomenon. Recently Telfer et al. (1998) have done a similar
study (including detection of Ne viii) of the broad absorp-
tion line system present in QSO SBS 1542+531. Note that
in all previous studies Ne viii absorption is investigated
with low dispersion FOS spectra.
In the following we discuss in detail the associated sys-
tems in the line of sight to QSO J2233-606 and especially
the unambiguous detection of strong Ne viii absorption.
We briefly present the method to derive column densi-
ties in case of partial coverage in Section 2; describe the
data in Section 3 and the individual absorption systems in
Section 4, discuss the physical consequences of the obser-
vations in Section 5 and draw our conclusions in Section 6.
2. Partial coverage
When an absorbing cloud does not cover the background
source completely, the observed residual intensity in the
normalized spectrum, Rλ, can be written as,
Rλ = (1 − fc) + fc × exp(−τλ),
(1)
where, τλ and fc are the optical depth and covering factor
respectively. The latter is the ratio of the number of pho-
tons produced by the region of the background source that
is occulted by the absorbing cloud to the total number of
photons (Srianand & Shankaranarayanan 1999). If two ab-
sorption lines with rest-wavelengths λ1 and λ2 originate
from the same ion (usually it will be doublets or multi-
plets), their residual intensities, R1 and R2, at any veloc-
ity v with respect to the centroid of the lines are related
by,
R2(v) = 1 − fc2 + fc2 ×(cid:18) R1(v) − 1 + fc1
fc1
(cid:19)γ
(2)
where fc1 and fc2 are the covering factors calculated for
the two lines and,
γ = (cid:18) f2λ2
f1λ1(cid:19)
with f1 and f2 the oscillator strengths (see e.g. Petitjean
1999). The value of γ is close to 2 for doublets.
Though our intuition says that fc1 = fc2 it need not be
true in general (Srianand & Shankaranarayanan 1999). In-
deed due the complex velocity structure in the BLR, pho-
tons that could be absorbed by lines 1 and 2 (even in the
case of doublets) originate from spatially distinct regions
in the BLR. A cloud can thus be black in line 1 (covering
the BLR region emitting at the corresponding wavelength
λ1), but not in line 2 if it does not cover at the same time
the region emitting photons with wavelength λ2. Also, the
interpretation of the relative covering factors for various
ions is not straightforward. Indeed, the covering factor
of absorption lines seen over the wavelength range of the
QSO spectrum that is dominated by the continuum may
be larger than the covering factor of lines present on top
of the QSO emission lines as the extension of the BLR is
larger than that of the continuum emission region.
Table 1. Spectroscopic data
Coverage
Inst./Tel.
R
S/N
Ref.
(A)
per pixel
30000
E230M-STIS/HST 2275-3118
1126-1721 ∼1100
G140L-STIS/HST
G230L-STIS/HST
1585-3173
∼550
G430M-STIS/HST 3025-3565 ∼6000
35000
UCLES/AAT
EMMI/NTT
21000
3530-4390
4386-8270
1.5 - 4
10 - 18
20 - 45
5 - 15
5 - 30
8 - 10
a
a
a
a
b
c
a Ferguson (1998), b Outram et al. (1998), c Savaglio (1998)
3. Data
In the following analysis we use spectra of QSO J2233-
606 obtained with different instruments and telescopes.
Table 1 gives the instrumentation, wavelength coverage,
spectral resolution, typical signal-to-noise ratio and refer-
ence for the data available. Ultra-violet and optical spec-
tra were taken by the HST HDF-S STIS Team (Ferguson
1998) with the STIS E230M, G140L, G230L and G430M
gratings on board of the Hubble Space Telescope. Optical
data was obtained at the AAT and ESO/NTT by Outram
et al. (1998) and Savaglio (1998) respectively. We have cor-
rected the data for fluctuations in the zero-level by fitting
low order polynomials to the bottom of the strong sat-
urated Lyα lines. The echelle data have been smoothed
using a gaussian filter of width 3 pixels. The continuum
was fit with low-order polynomials and the spectrum was
normalized.
4. Description of the associated system
4.1. Overview
The absorption profiles produced by the associated ab-
sorbers are shown for the most important transitions on a
velocity scale in Fig. 1. Complementary identifications in
the G230L spectrum of lower quality because of the pres-
ence of the LLS break at ∼2700 A are given in Fig. 2. The
two spectra obtained in 1997 (end of october) and 1998
(beginning of october) are superimposed on Fig. 2 to look
for variability. It can be seen that the modest signal-to-
noize ratio prevents any firm conclusion about the vari-
ability of the Ne viii absorption lines. There are absorp-
tion features near the expected position of Mg xλλ609,624
but, due to poor spectral resolution, this cannot be as-
certained. On the contrary, O v and probably N iii are
present. The maximum column density of He i found in
the models discussed below is ∼1011 cm−2. We thus do
not believe that the possible line at ∼1875 A seen in only
one of the spectra can be He iλ584.
The emission redshift of QSO J2233-606, derived from
the high-ionization emission lines C iv, C iii] + Al iii,
zem = 2.237, is smaller than the redshift derived from
Mg ii, zem = 2.252, by about 1390 km s−1 (Sealey et al.
3
1998). Considering the Mg ii redshift as more represen-
tative of the intrinsic redshift (Carswell et al. 1991), the
associated absorptions, seen over the redshift range 2.198 --
2.2215, have outflow velocities relative to the quasar of
2800 -- 5000 km s−1 which is modest compared to usual as-
sociated or BAL outflows.
-1000
-1000
0
0
1000
1000
2000
2000
-1000
0
1000
2000
Fig. 1. Absorption profiles of different transitions in the asso-
ciated systems observed along the line of sight to J2233-606.
The zero velocity is taken at z = 2.20. The vertical dashed lines
mark redshifts 2.1982, 2.2052, 2.2075 and 2.2215 from the left
to the right. Note the component at +950 km s−1 (zabs = 2.21)
with O vi and Ne viii but no detectable H i absorptions.
4.2. zabs= 2.2215
There is a Lyα line at this redshift with flat bottom, con-
sitent with line saturation, but with non-zero residual in-
4
1800
1900
2000
2100
2200
0
2200
2300
2400
2500
Observed Wavelength
2600
2700
Fig. 2. Possible identifications of lines from the associated sys-
tem in the G230L spectrum. The vertical dashed lines mark the
redshift range 2.198 -- 2.210. The two spectra obtained in 1997
(end of october) and 1998 (beginning of october) are superim-
posed to look for variability. It can be seen that the modest
S/N ratio prevents any firm conclusion about the variability of
the Ne viii absorption lines.
tensity. From the latter, it can be seen on Fig. 3 that the
minimum covering factor for this line is fc ∼ 0.7. However
before drawing any conclusions it is important to show
that the feature is not due to blending of a few weaker
lines. In Fig. 3 we plot the line profiles of the other de-
tected Lyman series lines from this system. It can be seen
that the Lyβ line is very strong. Moreover the residual
intensity in the Lyβ line is smaller than the residual in-
tensity in the Lyα line, consistent with saturation of the
Lyα line.
We first assume that the covering factor is the same for
Lyα and Lyβ . In the middle panel we plot the observed
Lyβ profile together with the predicted Lyβ profiles com-
puted from the Lyα profile for three values of the covering
factor: dotted, short -- dashed and long -- dashed lines are for
covering factors 1, 0.8, 0.70 respectively.
The predicted Lyβ profiles are inconsistent with the ob-
served Lyβ profile and the latter seems too strong even for
the minimum covering factor acceptable for the Lyα line
(fc ∼ 0.7). The numerous saturated lines present in this
part of the spectrum assures that the error in the zero level
determination cannot explain the discrepancy. Although
we cannot reject the presence of weak Lyα absorption lines
superimposed with the Lyβ absorption, especially in the
blue-wing, the good wavelength coincidence between Lyβ
and Lyα seems to indicate that the contamination cannot
be large. One way to explain the apparent strength of the
Lyβ line is to assume that the covering factor for Lyβ is
larger than for Lyα . Note that this is consitent with the
QSO Lyα emission line to be stronger than the Lyβ emis-
sion line. If true, then we can expect that the covering
factor of the Lyγ line be even larger.
In the top panel we plot the observed wavelength range
of the Lyγ line and the predicted profile using the Lyβ
profile for covering factors 1 (dotted line) and 0.9 (dashed
lines). The best match is obtained for complete coverage
though this does not reproduce the Lyγ very well. Smaller
values of the covering factor predict too strong a Lyγ line.
We conclude that, in order to understand the residual in-
tensities in the different Lyman series absorption lines, it
must be assumed that the covering factor increases from
Lyα to Lyγ. It is thus likely that the absorbing cloud at
zabs = 2.2215 completely covers the continuum source and
partially covers the BLR.
This system does not show absorption due to any de-
tectable heavy element transitions either in the optical
data (Outram et al 1998; Savaglio, 1998) or in the HST
data. If partial coverage is a signature of physical associ-
ation between the absorbing gas and the AGN, then the
lack of metal lines in this system could suggest that there
are large inhomogeneities in the chemical enrichment of
the gas physically associated with central engines of QSOs.
However, on the contrary, if we presume that the gas as-
sociated with the central regions of the quasar is more or
less uniformly enriched, then this system could correspond
to very highly ionized gas. The ionization state should be
such that all observable metal transitions are weak and
undetectable. This condition demands log H i/H to be
smaller than -8 (e.g. Hamann 1997) and log N (H)>22.
Note that such a cloud could be related to the warm ab-
sorbers.
Another possibility is that the gas is extremely metal-
poor and is produced by an intervening cloud with sizes
less than the BLR (i.e. few pc). Not only this is much
smaller than the dimensions derived for intervening Lyα
clouds using adjacent lines of sight (e.g. Petitjean et al.
1998) but also these clouds would have been detected by
previous surveys far away from the QSO.
4.3. zabs= 2.207
The C iv , N v and Lyα absorption lines produced by this
system are shallow and broad (∼500 km s−1) like a minia-
turised Broad Absorption Line system (BALs). Outram
1.2
1.2
1.2
1
1
1
0.8
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.2
1.20
0
0
1.2
1.2
1.2
1
1
1
1
0.8
0.8
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
1.20
0
0
0
1.2
1
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
0
0
-200
0
200
Fig. 3. Analysis of partial coverage in the zabs= 2.2215 system.
The observed Lyα profile is plotted in the bottom panel. The
middle panel shows the observed Lyβ profile (solid) together
with the predicted profiles computed from Lyα assuming cov-
ering factors fc = 1, 0.8 and 0.70 for the dotted, short-dashed
and long-dashed lines respectively. The top panel shows the ob-
served Lyγ profile with the predicted profiles computed from
Lyβ assuming covering factors fc = 1 and 0.9 for the dotted
and dashed lines respectively.
et al. (1998) discuss the N v and Lyα absorptions from
this system. They could not fit the N v doublet when as-
suming 100% coverage. However, they managed to obtain
a consistent fit after correcting the continuum by sub-
tracting a Gaussian centered at 3938 A with FWHM =
670 km s−1 and maximum depth 19 percent of the origi-
nal continuum level. They used a three-component model
with large velocity dispersions. Savaglio (1998) observed
the C iv absorption doublet from this system. She could
fit the doublet with six components. The O vi and Ne viii
doublets are detected in the G430M and E230M spec-
tra respectively. Note that the O vi doublet is observed
at slightly lower resolution than N v and C iv and the
Ne viii doublet is found in a low S/N region blueward
the Lyman limit of the moderately thick system at zabs=
1.87. Finally, strong O vλ629 is seen at ∼2020 A as ex-
pected and possibly Mg xλ624 at λ2000 A.
The stronger line of the C iv , N v , O vi and Ne viii
doublets, together with the Lyα line, are plotted on Fig. 4
on a velocity scale. The dotted and dashed lines are the
predicted velocity profiles computed from the profile of the
second transition of the doublets for different values of the
covering factor. Here again we assume identical covering
5
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-200
0
200
Fig. 4. Analysis of partial coverage in the zabs= 2.207 system.
The observed Lyα profile is plotted in the bottom panel. The
solid curves in the other panels are the observed profiles of the
stronger line of the doublets. The dotted and short-dashed lines
are the predicted velocity profiles computed from the profile of
the second transition of the doublet and assuming covering
factors fc = 0.35 (dotted line) and 0.50 (dashed line).
factors for both transitions. It can be seen that in order
to reproduce the residual intensities of N v we need a cov-
ering factor of the order of 0.35 at v ∼ +150 km s−1 and
0.50 at v ∼ -- 100 km s−1. The difference between the two
models with fc = 0.35 and 0.50, is, at these places, of the
order or larger than 0.1 (10% of the normalized contin-
uum; see Fig. 4) when the rms deviation in the spectrum
is ∼0.04.
The O vi profiles are consistent with a covering factor
∼ 0.7 that cannot be reconciled with the values found for
N v . Note that the O vi profiles could be affected by the
relatively poor spectral resolution and the derived cov-
ering factors should be considered as lower limits. The
maximum error in the covering factor for the O vi lines
is about 0.1, computed from the error in the residual in-
tensity. The S/N ratio over the C iv doublet is not good
enough and consistent residual intensities are obtained for
a wide range of covering factors. The covering factor re-
quired for the Ne viii lines is in the range 0.8-1.0 with
6
an error per pixel of 0.15. The covering factor derived
from the Ne viii lines is therefore significantly larger than
the one derived from the N v doublet. There seems to be
an anti -- correlation between the covering factor and the
ionization state or the wavelength. This again is consis-
tent with clouds partially covering the BLR while covering
most of the continuum emission region.
Another interesting observation concerns the doubly-
ionized species. It can be seen on Fig. 1 that O iiiλ832 is
certainly blended with other lines; that there may be a
shallow absorption at the expected position of C iiiλ977
although most of it should be Lyγ; and that there is a
strong absorption at the expected position of N iiiλ989.
This line cannot be Lyβ at zabs = 2.093 as there is no
corresponding Lyα line. We cannot reject the hypoth-
esis that this is an intervening Lyα line as the Lyβ
range is of very poor S/N ratio. Interestingly enough,
there is an absorption feature at the expected position of
N iiiλλ684,685 (see Fig. 2). Although such a strong N iii
absorption would be very surprizing (see next Section and
Fig. 6), the presence of doubly-ionized species cannot be
ruled out. The corresponding absorptions from triply ion-
ized species, although weak and noisy, could be present
(see in particular O ivλ787 and N ivλ765). If true, this
would imply that the medium has two phases of low and
high-ionization (see next Section).
Since the possible strong N iiiλ989 line goes to zero,
suggesting complete coverage; we note that there is a ten-
dency for the absorption lines redshifted on top of the
emission lines (here C iv and N v ) to have covering fac-
tors smaller than lines redshifted in parts of the spectrum
free from emission-lines (Ne viii and N iii). This further
supports the conclusion that the gas covers the continuum
emitting region but only part of the BLR.
4.4. zabs= 2.198
Lyα and N v absorptions produced by this system are de-
tected by Outram et al. (1998) who already noted the
incomplete coverage of the background source. They con-
jectured that the absorbing cloud is larger than the contin-
uum emitting region and smaller than the BLR. Savaglio
(1998) has noted that single as well as two component
fits to the C iv doublet result in a very poor fit, again
suggesting partial coverage. O vi and Ne viii doublets are
detected in the HST spectra. The stronger lines of the dou-
blets together with Lyα are plotted on Fig. 5 on a velocity
scale. The dotted and dashed lines are the predicted veloc-
ity profiles computed from the second transition of dou-
blets assuming different values of the covering factor (dot-
ted, short-dashed and long-dashed lines are for fc = 0.7,
0.8 and 0.9 respectively). Here again we assume identical
covering factors for both transitions. The N vλ1242 line
of this system is blended with N vλ1238 of the system
at 2.208. We have subtracted the contribution due to the
N vλ1238 line before doing the analysis. The covering fac-
1
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0
0
0
0
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-200
-100
0
100
200
Fig. 5. Analysis of partial coverage in the zabs= 2.198 system.
The observed Lyα profile is plotted in the lowest panel. The
solid curves in other panels are the observed profiles of the
strongest transition of the doublet. The dotted, short-dashed
and long-dashed lines are the predicted velocity profiles com-
puted using the profile of the weakest member of the doublets
and assuming covering factor of fc = 0.7, 0.8 and 0.9 respec-
tively.
tor required to fit the N v doublet is ∼ 0.7±0.04. However
the O vi profiles require values larger than 0.85±0.04. It
is quite likely that the Ne viiiλ780 is blended with some
other line in the blue wing. Also the Ne viiiλ770 profile is
very noisy and is consistent with a wide range of covering
factors. It is interesting to note that inspite of the poor
signal to noise ratio, the C iv profiles clearly suggest that
the covering factor is less than 0.7 and we have obtained
a consistent fit for fc = 0.5. Thus like the zabs= 2.207 sys-
tem, this system also shows different covering factor for
different transitions; the covering factor beeing lower for
C iv than for N v .
5. Physical conditions in the zabs = 2.198 system
In this section we study the physical conditions in the
zabs= 2.198 system in greater detail. The column density
per unit velocity interval at any velocity, v, with respect
to the centroid of the line is given by,
N (v) =
(mec/πe2)
f λ
τ (v),
and from Eq. (1) the optical depth τ (v) is given by,
τ (v) = − ln (cid:18) R(v) − 1 + fc
fc
(cid:19).
(3)
(4)
Assuming equal covering factor for the two absorption
lines of a doublet, fc1 = fc2 = fc, we obtain fc(v) for each
doublet using Eq. (2). We then derive the column density
per unit velocity interval from Eqs. (3) and (4). The total
column density, N , is obtained by integrating N (v) over
the velocity interval covered by the absorption line pro-
file. For various species we give in Table 2 the absorption
parameters (N and b) obtained from Voigt profile fitting
(column #3 and #4 respectively) and the column density
obtained by integration of the column density per unit ve-
locity interval over the velocity profile (column #7). The
velocity range (column #5), and the mean covering factor
estimated over this range (column #6) are also given. In
the case of single lines we use a conservative lower limit of
0.7 for the covering factor. Note that the column density
obtained with the Voigt profile fits are lower limits as cor-
rections are not incorporated to take into account partial
coverage.
Lyβ from this system is weak and we could not derive
any bound on the covering factor from the Lyα line only.
C iiiλ977 is not detected and we derive a two sigma upper
limit from the continuum rms at the expected position of
the line. Voigt profile fits to the C iv lines are taken from
Savaglio (1998). As the estimated covering factor is low,
the column density derived by fitting the profile is less by
a factor of 5 compared to the estimated column density
using the column density per unit velocity interval. N iii
and Si iii are not detected whereas a line is present at the
expected position of N ivλ765. This line clearly shows two
components and the blue component is clearly absent in
the N v profile. The further absence of N iii suggests that
this component is not real. Thus we have fitted the N iv
blue component as an intervening Lyα line and used only
the column density obtained from the red component in
our analysis. Although the resolution of the spectrum is
not very high (∼ 50 km s−1), we have fitted the O vi lines
using three components. There is a line at the expected
position of O ivλ787. However this line could possibly be
Lyγ from the system at zabs= 2.5907. By carefully fitting
the Lyα , Lyβ and Lyδ lines in this system, we removed the
contribution of the Lyγ and fit the residual as O ivλ787.
As discussed before, the estimate of column densities can
be somewhat uncertain due to limited S/N ratio (espe-
cially for the Ne viii lines) and possible contamination by
intervening lines.
The derived column densities for H i, C iv , N v and
O vi are characteristic of associated systems (Hamann
7
Ne VIII
C IV
N V
MF87
O VI
O IV
N IV
C III
-0.5
0
0.5
1
O VI
N IV
O IV
C III
O III
0.5
N III
0
O VI
O IV
Ne VIII
C IV
N V
1
Ne VIII
C IV
N V
0
log U
0.5
1
-0.5
N III
-0.5
N IV
C III
O III
16
15
14
13
12
11
16
14
12
16
15
14
13
12
11
Fig. 6. The logarithm of column densities for species indicated
next to each curve is given versus the logarithm of the ioniza-
tion parameter for ionizing spectra as given by Mathews &
Ferland (1987; top panel); or power-laws with index α = -1.5
(middle panel) and -1 (bottom panel).
1997). We run photo-ionization models using Cloudy
(Ferland 1996) to study the ionization structure of a
plane parallel cloud with neutral hydrogen column density
1014 cm−2, solar metallicities, and illuminated by ionizing
radiation fields with different spectra. Although a one-
zone model is questionable in such medium, we believe
that this is a reasonable representation of the absorbing
cloud producing at least C iv, N v and H i (see below for
O vi and Ne viii) because the kinematics of the lines are
very similar (see Figs. 1 and 5) and the partial coverages
discussed in the previous sections indicate small sizes for
the cloud.
Results for a typical AGN spectrum given by Mathews
& Ferland (1987) and two power-law spectra are given in
Fig. 6. In the framework of these models, it is apparent
8
Table 2. Parameters for the associated system at zabs=2.198
Ion
fc
v
b
z
log N
cm−2
(km s−1)
(km s−1)
log N
cm−2
2.1982
13.74±0.01
43.99±1.01
-47, 53
H i
C iii
C iv
N iv
N v
O iv
O vi
Ne viii
.....
2.1982
2.1980
2.1972
2.1982
2.1979
2.1987
2.1976
2.1981
2.1987
2.1976
2.1981
2.1987
.....
13.77±0.05
13.73±0.04
13.12±0.05
14.57±0.03
14.43±0.06
13.94±0.08
14.39±0.16
14.87±0.24
14.63±0.14
14.63±0.27
14.79±0.10
14.68±0.09
.....
19.80±2.40
30.43±1.35
32.51±4.06
31.46±0.58
49.33±2.74
37.70±4.53
a
a
a
39.11±9.70
25.39±3.85
32.33±3.20
.....
-27, 50
>0.7 <13.95
..... <13.40
14.48
∼0.5
>0.7 <14.34
-27, 53
∼0.7
14.55
-47, 53
>0.7 <14.62
-46, 100 ∼0.8
15.38
-27, 53
∼0.7
15.10
a Same as for Ne viii
that the column densities are reproduced easily. The α = -
1 power-law ionizing spectrum is favored as it minimizes
the N (C iv)/N (O vi) ratio. Although metallicities can-
not be much less than solar (because of C iv and N v ),
it would be difficult to argue for metallicities much larger
than solar (especially for oxygen). However, contrary to
what is observed, the predicted C iv column density is al-
ways larger than that of N v . This suggests that nitrogen
is over-abundant compared to carbon. It is interesting to
note that the N v lines of the zabs= 2.207 system is also
stronger than the lines of C iv suggesting a similar abun-
dance pattern. Indeed, using N v /C iv emission line ra-
tios, Hamann & Ferland (1992) have shown that nitrogen
is over-abundant by a factor of ∼ 2 − 9 in high-redshift
QSOs (z ≥ 2.0). They suggested rapid star-formation
models to boost the nitrogen abundance through en-
hanced secondary production in massive stars. Korista
et al. (1996) have also noticed overabundance of nitro-
gen with respect to carbon and oxygen in the well-studied
BAL system in Q 0226-1024. They could obtain a much
better fit of the lines after taking into account the abun-
dance pattern due to rapid star-formation. The overabun-
dance of nitrogen with respect to oxygen and/or carbon,
does not seem to be seen in every associated system how-
ever. Indeed, we have good data for the associated systems
in Q 0207 -- 003 and Q 0138 -- 381 showing partial coverage.
Although solar metallicities are needed to explain the line
ratios, there is no indication of enhanced nitrogen abun-
dance.
From the observed N v to N iv column density ra-
tio,
it can be seen that log U < -- 0.5 (the ionization
parameter U is the ratio of the ionizing photons den-
sity to the total hydrogen density). However such a value
for the ionization parameter implies that the gas pro-
ducing N v and N iv can not account for the observed
value of the Ne viii column density without an unreal-
istically large neon abundance. Another and more likely
explanation is that there are two distinct regions with
different ionization parameters and that Ne viii predom-
inantly originates from the more highly ionized region.
This is supported by the fact that the Ne viii absorption
is spread over a larger velocity range than the N v and
O vi absorptions. We can check that, even in that case,
C iiiλ977 would not be detectable. Indeed, the expected
C iii column density is of the order of 1013 cm−2 (see
Fig. 6), thus wobs(C iiiλ977) ∼ 0.2 A which is about twice
below the detection limit at λ ∼ 3100 A.
Since the low-ionization region by itself can account
for the observed H i and O vi column densities, the high-
ionization region should have N (Ne viii) much larger than
N (O vi ) which means log U larger than 0.5 and most
probably 1.
If we suppose that this component is similar to warm
absorbers detected by O vii and O viii edges in the X-
rays, then the condition that the optical depth of these
edges are larger than 0.1 implies log N (O vii) > 17.55
and log N (O viii) > 18.00. Photoionization models with
solar abundances, fail to produce such high O vii and
O viii column densities for H i column densities in the
range 1013 to 1014 cm−2. Indeed, the ratios NeVIII/Ne,
OVII/O and OVIII/O are all maximized over the range
of ionization parameters U ∼ 10 -- 100 (see Hamann et al.
1995) where log HI/H ∼ -- 6. For log N (H i) = 14, this cor-
responds to log N (H) ∼ 20 and, assuming solar abun-
dances, implies that log N (O vii) and log N (O viii) are
less than 17. Thus, it is most likely that in QSO J2233-
606, the region producing the Ne viii absorption can not
be a warm absorber. It is thus of first importance to study
the intrinsic spectral energy distribution of J2233-606 es-
pecially in the X-rays.
9
Ferland, G. J. 1996, "HAZY a Brief Introduction to Cloudy",
Univ. Kentucky, Dept. Physics & Astron.. Internal rep.
George I.M., Turner T.J., Netzer H., et al., 1998, ApJS 114, 73
Korista, K., Hamann, F., Ferguson, J. & Ferland, G. 1996,
ApJ, 461,641
Hamann F., 1997, ApJS 109, 279
Hamann F., Barlow T.A., Beaver E.A., 1995, ApJ 443, 606
Hamann F., Barlow T.A., Cohen R.D., Junkkarinen V., Bur-
bidge E.M., 1997a, astro-ph/9704235
Hamann F., Barlow T.A., Junkkarinen V., Burbidge E.M.,
1997b, ApJ 478, 80
Hamann F., Cohen R.D., Shields J.C., et al., 1998, ApJ 496,
761
Hamann F., Ferland G. J. 1992, ApJ, 391, L53
Mathews W.G., Ferland G.J., 1987, ApJ 323, 456
Mathur S., Wilkes B., Elvis M., Fiore F., 1994, ApJ 434, 493
Outram P. J., Boyle B. J., Carswell R. F., et al., 1998, MNRAS
in press (astro-ph/9809404)
Petitjean P., 1999, Proceedings of the Les Houches school "For-
mation and Evolution of Galaxies"; O. Le Fevre and S.
Charlot (eds.), Springer-Verlag, astro-ph/9810418
Petitjean P., Rauch M., Carswell R.F., 1994, A&A 291, 29
Petitjean P., Riediger R., Rauch M., 1996, A&A 307, 417
Petitjean P., Surdej J., Smette A., et al., 1998, A&A 334, L45
Porquet D., Dumont A.-M., Collin S., Mouchet M., 1999, astro-
ph/9810333v2
Reynolds C.S., 1997, MNRAS 286, 513
Savaglio S., 1998, AJ 116, 1055
Savaglio S., D'Odorico S., Møoller P., 1994, A&A 281, 331
Shield et al. 1995, ApJ, 441, 507
Sealey M. K., Drinkwater J. M., Webb J. K., 1998, ApJL 499,
135
Srianand & Shankaranarayanan, 1999, astro-ph/9901091
Telfer R.C., Kriss G.A., Zheng W., Davidsen A.F., Green R.,
1998, ApJ 509, 132
Vogel S., Reimers D., 1995, A&A 294, 377
6. Conclusion
We have studied the associated absorption systems
(zabs ∼ zem) in QSO J2233-606, seen over the redshift
range 2.198 -- 2.2215, corresponding to outflow velocities
relative to the quasar emission redshift (zem = 2.252 from
Mg ii) of 2800 -- 5000 km s−1 which is modest compared to
usual associated or BAL outflows.
We have shown that the Lyα line at zabs= 2.2215 is
saturated but has non-zero residual intensity. The cover-
ing factor of the gas is of the order of 0.7. This absorption
system is unusual in the sense that there is no detectable
metal lines. This could reveal chemical inhomogeneities in
the gas or, and more likely, this absorption could corre-
spond to very highly ionized gas from which no absorption
due to heavier element can be detected. If the latter is
true, the ionization factor log HI/H could be smaller than
-- 8 and the total column density in the cloud larger than
log N (H) = 22. Such a cloud could be related to the warm
absorbers.
Over
the redshift
range 2.198 -- 2.21, conspicuous
Ne viii, O vi, C iv and N v absorptions are seen whereas
the H i absorption is weak. From analysing these ab-
sorptions we conclude that (i) a two-phase medium of
low and high-ionization respectively is required to ex-
plain the complete set of column densities; (ii) the
abundances are close to the solar value but nitrogen
is enhanced with respect to carbon; (iii) although dif-
ficult to ascertain there is a tendency for the absorp-
tion lines redshifted on top of the emission lines to have
covering factors smaller than lines redshifted in parts
of the spectrum free from emission-lines; this suggests
that the gas covers the continuum emitting region but
only part of the BLR. The component at zabs = 2.21
(+950 km s−1 on Fig. 1) is remarkable as, though conspic-
uous in Ne viii and O vi, it is undetected in H i, C iv and
N v . The column densities derived for this subcomponent
by Voigt-profile fitting are log N (Ne viii) = 14.57±0.10;
log N (O vi) = 14.05±0.06 and log N (H i) < 13.30, con-
sistent with what is expected from a high-ionization zone.
Acknowledgements. We would like to thank all astronomers
who have provided the data for this project and especially the
HST HDF-S STIS team lead by H. Ferguson. We thank the
referee, Fred Hamann, for a careful reading of the manuscript.
References
Barlow T.A., Junkkarinen V.T., Burbidge E.M., et al., 1992,
ApJ 397, 81
Barlow T.A., Sargent W.L.W., 1997, AJ 113, 136
Carswell R.F., Mountain C.M., Robertson D.J., et al., 1991,
ApJ 381, L5
Crenshaw D.M., Kraemer S.B., Boggess A., et al., 1998, astro-
ph/9812265
Ferguson H.C., 1998, Space Telescope Science Institute
Newsletter, Vol. 15, No. 3, 6
This article was processed by the author using Springer-Verlag
LaTEX A&A style file L-AA version 3.
|
astro-ph/0507331 | 1 | 0507 | 2005-07-13T18:14:02 | Anisotropy Studies Around the Galactic Center at EeV Energies with Auger Data | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Pierre Auger Observatory data have been analyzed to search for excesses of events near the direction of the galactic center in several energy ranges around EeV energies. In this region the statistics accumulated by the Observatory are already larger than that of any previous experiment. Using both the data sets from the surface detector and our hybrid data sets (events detected simultaneously by the surface detector and the fluorescence detector) we do not find any significant excess. At our present level of undestanding of the performance and properties of our detector, our results do not support the excesses reported by AGASA and SUGAR experiments. We set an upper bound on the flux of cosmic rays arriving within a few degrees from the galactic center in the energy range from 0.8-3.2 EeV. We also have searched for correlations of cosmic ray arrival directions with the galactic plane and with the super-galactic plane at energies in the range 1-5 EeV and above 5 EeV and have found no significant excess. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
29th International Cosmic Ray Conference Pune (2005) 00, 101 -- 106
Anisotropy Studies Around the Galactic Center at EeV Energies with
Auger Data
The Pierre Auger Collaboration
Presenter: A. Letessier-Selvon (Antoine.Letessier-Selvon@@in2p3.fr),fra-letessier-selvon-A-abs1-he14-oral
The Pierre Auger Observatory data have been analyzed to search for excesses of events near the direction of
the galactic center in several energy ranges around EeV energies. In this region the statistics accumulated
by the Observatory are already larger than that of any previous experiment. Using both the data sets from
the surface detector and our hybrid data sets (events detected simultaneously by the surface detector and the
fluorescence detector) we do not find any significant excess. At our present level of undestanding of the
performance and properties of our detector, our results do not support the excesses reported by AGASA and
SUGAR experiments. We set an upper bound on the flux of cosmic rays arriving within a few degrees from
the galactic center in the energy range from 0.8-3.2 EeV. We also have searched for correlations of cosmic ray
arrival directions with the galactic plane and with the super-galactic plane at energies in the range 1-5 EeV and
above 5 EeV and have found no significant excess.
1.
Introduction
The galactic centre (GC) region provides an attractive target for anisotropy studies with the Pierre Auger
Observatory. On the one hand, there have been in the past observations by the AGASA experiment indicating
a 4.5σ excess of cosmic rays (CRs) with energies in the range 1-2.5 EeV in a 20◦ radius region centered at
(δ, α) ≃ (−17◦, 280◦) [1]. A later search near this region with a reanalysis of SUGAR data [2], though with
smaller statistics, failed to corroborate these findings, but reported a 2.9σ excess flux of CRs with energies 0.8
<E<3.2 EeV in a region of 5.5◦ radius centered at (δ, α) = (−22◦, 274◦).
On the other hand, since the GC harbors a very massive black hole, it provides a natural candidate for CR
accelerator to very high energies. Following the recent high significance observation by HESS [3] of a TeV
γ ray source near the location of Sagittarius A∗, predictions for neutron fluxes at Auger energies have been
published [4]. Since neutrons emitted by such a source would go undeflected by galactic magnetic fields, they
should appear as a point-like source, just spread by the angular resolution of the experiment (the neutron decay
length becomes comparable to the distance to the GC at EeV energies).
2. Data Selection
In this work we use Auger data from 1st January 2004 until 6th June 2005. We use the events from the surface
detector (SD) [5] that passed the 3-fold or the 4-fold data acquisition triggers and satisfying our high level
physics trigger (T4) and our quality trigger (T5) [6]. The T5 selection is independent of energy and ensures a
better quality for the event reconstruction. This data set has an angular resolution better than 2.2◦ for all of the
3-fold events (regardless of the zenith angle considered) and better than 1.7◦ for all events with multiplicities
> 3 SD stations [7]. In all our analyses we use a zenith angle cut at 60◦ like AGASA while SUGAR used all
zenith angles.
One concern about the use of Auger data at 1 EeV given the 1.5 km spacing of our SD stations could be the
trigger efficiency. Various studies (using Monte Carlo simulation, our Hybrid data set, or the extrapolation of
the spectral shape) have shown that our 3-fold trigger efficiency is better than 30% for proton induced showers
2
Pierre Auger Collaboration
Data Set >0.1 EeV [0.8-3.2] EeV [1.0 - 5.0]EeV >5.0 EeV >10.0 EeV
SD
122636
41792
Table 1. Events statistics
29773
1359
387
and better than 50% for Iron induced shower above 0.8 EeV. The 4-fold trigger reaches the same efficiency at
about 2 EeV [8]. The efficiency ratio between Iron and proton is always below 1.6 above 0.8 EeV and this
difference can be taken into account when setting upper limits on point sources.
Regarding the hybrid events (i.e.
those with both Fluorescence Detectors (FD) and SD signal) [9], despite
the lower duty cycle of the fluorescence telescopes and consequently smaller statistics, they offer an excellent
angular resolution of 0.4◦ [7] over the whole energy range and a much lower trigger threshold of 0.1 EeV.
In Table 1 we show the statistics for the SD data-set in the various energy ranges we have used for our studies.
This is the first search in the southern hemisphere since the SUGAR analysis and we have over 10 times more
statistics.
3. AGASA and SUGAR Excesses
To estimate the coverage map, needed to construct excess and excess probability maps, we tested two different
techniques. The so-called "shuffling" technique where one uses the data to construct randomized isotropic
data sets and, alternatively for the SD sample, a semi-analytical method described in [10]. Both techniques are
equivalent for studying sources because the Poisson noise in our search window dominates over the uncertainty
of our coverage map. This report is based on the shuffling technique. For the hybrid sample, we have defined
24 epochs each corresponding to a given telescope configuration. For the SD sample we have randomized,
within 5 bands of zenith angle, the UTC hours and Julian days of the events and drawn the azimuth from a
uniform distribution. We present in Fig. 1A the coverage map obtained from our SD sample in a region around
the GC. Since we are well within the field of view of Auger there are no strong variation within this region.
In Fig.1B,C,D we present the chance probability distributions (mapped to positive Gaussian significance for
excesses and negative for deficits) in the same region for various filtering and energy cuts corresponding to our
various searches. In these map the filtering is choosen as to maximize the appearance of eventual structures at
a certain scale. 1.5◦ corresponds to our 2.2◦ angular resolution and therefore to point sources, 3.7◦ is similar
to a 5◦ top-hat window and also corresponds to the SUGAR excess size, 13.3◦ is similar to a 20◦ top-hat and
to the size of the excess reported by AGASA. In these maps the chance probability distributions are consistent
with those expected as a result of statistical fluctuations from an isotropic sky.
Regarding the region where the AGASA excess was reported, the results from the Auger Observatory are 1155
events observed, and 1160.7 expected (ratio 1.00±0.03) for the energy range [1.0-2.5] EeV. This is almost 3
times the event number of AGASA in this region due to the fact that the GC lies well within the field of view of
Auger while it lies outside the one of AGASA. These results do not support the excess observed by AGASA,
and in particular not at a level of 22% like the one they reported which would translate into a 7.5σ excess.
In a worst case scenario where the source would be protons and the background much heavier (e.g. Iron),
the difference in detection efficiency of the Auger trigger at 1 EeV would reduce the sensitivity to a source
excess. However, using the Fe/proton efficiency ratio at 1 EeV (70%/50% = 1.44, an upper bound in the
range [1-2.5] EeV) we would still expect to see a 5.2σ event excess in our data set.
There may be systematic differences between the energy calibrations of the two experiments, so we have
scanned the region maintaining the high/low energy ratio and moving the interval center by ±40%. We have
also enlarged the interval to [0.8 -- 3.2] EeV. We found no significant excess in any of those cases. Regarding the
Galactic Center Studies
3
Figure 1. Lambert projections of the galactic centre region, GC (cross), galactic plane (solid line), regions of excess of
AGASA and SUGAR (circles), AGASA f.o.v. limit (dashed line). A) coverage map (same color scale as the significance
maps, but in a range [0-1.0]). B) significance map in the range [0.8-3.2] EeV smoothed using the individual pointing
resolution of the events and a 1.5◦ filter (Auger like excess), C) same smoothed at 3.7◦ (SUGAR like excess), D) in the
range [1.0-2.5] EeV smoothed at 13.3◦ (AGASA like excess).
excess claimed by SUGAR, we find in their angular/energy window 144 events observed, and 150.9 expected
(ratio 0.95±0.08) , and hence with over an order of magnitude more statistics we are not able to confirm this
claim.
4. Galactic Center
We then searched for signals of a point-like source in the direction of the GC. Using a 1.5◦ Gaussian filter
corresponding to the angular resolution of the SD [7]. In the energy range [0.8 -- 3.2] EeV, we obtain 24.3 events
observed and, 23.9 expected (ratio 1.0±0.1). A 95% CL upper bound on the number of events coming from a
point source in that window is ns(95%) = 6.3. This bound can be translated into a flux upper limit if we know
how many events (ns) are expected for a given flux (Φs) integrated in this energy range. Since the detector
efficiency is energy (and primary composition) dependent at EeV energies, the ratio Φs/ns will depend on the
spectral shape and nature of the source. In the simplest case in which the source has a spectrum similar to the
one of the overall CR spectrum (dN/dE ∝ E−3), we can relate the two with Φs = nsΦCR4πσ2/nexp where
σ is the size of the Gaussian filter used. Using ΦCR(E) = 1.5 ξ(E/EeV )−3 × 10−12 (EeV−1 m−2 s−1 sr−1)
where ξ ∈ [1, 2.5] denotes our uncertainty on the CR flux (ξ is around unity for Auger and 2.5 for AGASA),
introducing ε the Iron/proton detection efficiency ratio (1 < ε < 1.6 for E ∈ [0.8, 3.2] EeV) and, integrating
in that energy range we obtain :
Φs < 2.5 ξ ε × 10−15 m−2s−1 @ 95% CL.
Since the detector efficiency grows with energy, a harder source flux would lead to a stronger flux bound. In a
worst case scenario, where both ξ and ε take their maximum value, the bound is Φs = 10.0 × 10−15 m−2s−1,
and still excludes the neutron source scenario suggested in [1, 11] to account for the AGASA excess, or in [4]
in connection with the HESS measurements.
4
Pierre Auger Collaboration
Figure 2. Left, the GC region seen by the hybrid detector, the excess map is built using the individual pointing resolution
of the events. Right, significance map from the SD data in galactic coordinates for events with 1 EeV < E < 5 EeV (top),
in super-galactic coordinates for events with E>5 EeV (middle), idem for events with E>10 EeV (bottom).
Using the better angular resolution of the hybrid reconstruction, we can set a point-like flux limit inside a 1◦
radius cone around the direction of the galactic center. Due to the limited statistics, all hybrid events with
energies above 0.1 EeV (10589) are used in this analysis, we find in this window 4 events observed and, 3.4
expected , showing no significant excess. At 95% CL an upper limit for a neutron source at the GC above
0.1 EeV is:
Φs < 1.2 ξ × 10−13m−2s−1 @ 95% CL.
5. Galactic/Super-Galactic Plane Studies
It is expected that the origin of cosmic rays changes from galactic to extra galactic in the 1-10 EeV range. We
have looked for an excess of events inside a ±10◦ band along the Galactic Plane in the energy range from
1 EeV to 5 EeV and along the Super Galactic Planes above 5 and 10 EeV. We observed 5077, 229, and 68
events respectively for expectations of 5083.3, 235.6, and 67.4 (ratios 1.00±0.01, 0.97±0.07, and 1.0±0.1)
showing no significant deviations. On Fig. 3 we show our corresponding probability maps smoothed on a 10◦
scale. Again all chance probabilities are consistent with isotropy.
References
[1] N. Hayashida et al. (AGASA Collaboration) ICRC 1999, Salt Lake City, OG.1.3.04, [astro-ph/9906056].
[2] J. A. Bellido et al., Astropart. Phys. 15, 167 (2001) [astro-ph/0009039].
[3] F. Aharonian et al. (HESS Collaboration), [astro-ph/0408145].
[4] F.Aharonian and A.Neronov [astro-ph/0408303]
[5] Auger Collaboration, "Performances of the Pierre Auger Observatory Surface Array," these proceedings.
[6] Auger Collaboration, "Triggers of the Pierre Auger Observatory Surface Array," these proceedings.
[7] Auger Collaboration, "Angular Resolution of the Pierre Auger Observatory ," these proceedings.
[8] Auger Collaboration, "Acceptance of the Pierre Auger Observatory Surface Array," these proceedings.
[9] Auger Collaboration, "The Hybrid Performance of the Pierre Auger Observatory," these proceedings.
[10] Auger Collaboration, "Coverage and large scale anisotropies estimation methods...," these proceedings.
[11] M. Bossa et al., J. Phys G 29 (2003) 1409.
|
astro-ph/9509001 | 1 | 9509 | 1995-09-01T10:02:06 | Colour Gradients in the Optical and Near-IR | [
"astro-ph"
] | For many years broadband colours have been used to obtain insight into the contents of galaxies, in particular to estimate stellar and dust content. Broadband colours are easy to obtain for large samples of objects, making them ideal for statistical studies. In this paper I use the radial distribution of the colours in galaxies, which gives more insight into the local processes driving the global colour differences than integrated colours. Almost all galaxies in my sample of 86 face-on galaxies become systematically bluer with increasing radius. The radial photometry is compared to new dust extinction models and stellar population synthesis models. This comparison shows that the colour gradients in face-on galaxies are best explained by age and metallicity gradients in the stellar populations and that dust reddening plays a minor role. The colour gradients imply $M/L$ gradients, making the `missing light' problem as derived from rotation curve fitting even worse. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Colour Gradients in the Optical and Near-IR
5
9
9
1
p
e
S
1
1
v
1
0
0
9
0
5
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Roelof S. de Jong12
1 Univ. of Durham, Dept. of Physics, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK
2 Kapteyn Institute, P.O.box 800, 9700 AV Groningen, The Netherlands
Abstract. For many years broadband colours have been used to obtain insight into
the contents of galaxies, in particular to estimate stellar and dust content. Broad-
band colours are easy to obtain for large samples of objects, making them ideal
for statistical studies. In this paper I use the radial distribution of the colours in
galaxies, which gives more insight into the local processes driving the global colour
differences than integrated colours. Almost all galaxies in my sample of 86 face-on
galaxies become systematically bluer with increasing radius. The radial photometry
is compared to new dust extinction models and stellar population synthesis mod-
els. This comparison shows that the colour gradients in face-on galaxies are best
explained by age and metallicity gradients in the stellar populations and that dust
reddening plays a minor role. The colour gradients imply M/L gradients, making
the 'missing light' problem as derived from rotation curve fitting even worse.
1 The colour gradients
A sample of 86 spiral galaxies was imaged in the B, V , R, I, H and K
passbands to study light and colour distributions as a function of radius.
Full details of sample selection and data reduction are described in de Jong
& van der Kruit (1994). The galaxies were selected to be face-on and to
have a diameter of at least 2′. The sample is statistically complete and can
be corrected for selection effects. It can therefore be used to analyze the
nature of the Freeman law (Freeman 1970) and this analysis has been reported
elsewhere (de Jong 1995a, 1995b).
The luminosity profiles were determined in the usual way by measuring
the average surface brightness on annuli of increasing radius. Radial colour
profiles were created by combining profiles in different passbands. The run
of colour as function of radius is put on a common scale for all galaxies in
Fig. 1, where the average B -- K colour at each radius is plotted as function
of the average R surface brightness at this radius.
2 Roelof S. de Jong
Fig. 1. The average B -- K colour at each radius as function of the average R surface
brightness at this radius. The galaxies are divided into 4 morphological RC3 T-type
bins. The dashed lines are provided to have a common reference among the bins.
Two observations can readily be made from this diagram. Firstly, all
galaxies become bluer going radially outward, correlating strongly with the
average surface brightness at each radius. Secondly, even at the same sur-
face brightness, late type spiral galaxies are bluer than earlier types (use the
dashed lines to guide the eye). Furthermore it should be noted that there is
a smooth transition in colour from the bulge to the disk region. The colours
of bulges are nearly identical to the colours of inner disk regions (see also
Peletier, these proceedings).
2 The dust and stellar population synthesis models
A possible explanation for the colour gradients is reddening due to dust
extinction. As galaxies are intricate mixtures of stars and dust, we cannot
describe the reddening by a simple extinction law, but have to calculate the
separate contributions of absorption and scattering. To predict reddening
profiles due to absorption and scattering full 3D Monte Carlo simulations
were made (de Jong 1995a) of galaxies with smooth exponential dust and
stellar distributions in both radial and vertical directions. The main free
parameters are the dust to stellar scaleheight (zd/zs) and scalelength (hd/hs)
ratios, the central optical depth (τ0,V ) and the properties of the dust particles.
The (poorly determined) Galactic dust properties were assumed, since extra-
galactic albedo and phase scattering functions have never been measured.
Colour Gradients in the Optical and Near-IR 3
Fig. 2. The radial colour-colour reddening profiles resulting from the Monte Carlo
simulations of stars and dust in exponential disks for different zd/zs and τ0,V values.
The arbitrary unreddened colours are indicated with filled circles for each model,
the galaxy centres indicated by open circles.
Figure 2 shows a number of model colour-colour reddening profiles for
different zd/zs and τ0,V values. The positions of the models in the diagram
are arbitrary (depending on the colours of the underlying population), but
the shape of the reddening profiles are determined by the distribution and
the properties of the dust. Note that all reddening profiles point in about the
same direction, independent of the dust configuration, and that this direction
is different from the standard screen model extinction vector (arrow).
I have used two sets of stellar population synthesis models in the com-
parison with the data. The Solar metallicity models of Bruzual & Charlot
(1993) are used to study the colour changes of populations due to different
star formation histories. Two extreme cases are considered, a single star burst
model and a constant star formation model. The colours of these populations
are inspected after 8 and 17 Gyr. The models of Worthey (1994) are used to
study the effects that age and metallicity have on the colours of a population.
3 The comparison between models and data
Figure 3 shows the colour-colour diagrams of the models and the galaxies,
again divided into four T-type bins. Note that the same model should fit the
data in all colour combinations, thus in both Figs. 3a & 3b. The thin lines
represent the galaxy data; the central galaxy colours are indicated by the open
circles, the lines show the run of colours as function of radius. All galaxies
with type T<6 are confined to a small region in these diagrams, only the
later types show a considerable larger spread.
4 Roelof S. de Jong
Fig. 3a. The run of B -- V versus R -- K colour as function of radius for the galaxies
(thin lines, centre indicated by open circle). Dust models in the top left corner,
Bruzual & Charlot (1993) models after 8 and 17 Gyr thick dashed lines, Worthey
(1994) models for indicated metallicities thick solid lines in the two bottom panels.
Some dust model profiles are indicated in the top-left corner of the panels.
As mentioned in Sect. 2, these profiles can be placed anywhere in the diagrams
and their direction depends mainly on the dust properties, not on the relative
distribution of dust and stars. Clearly, the colour gradients cannot be caused
by reddening alone, assuming that the dust properties used are correct.
In the 5≤T<6 panels the colours predicted by Worthey's models after
12 Gyr are shown for a range of indicated metallicities. The metallicity-colour
trend runs in the same direction for other ages and apparently, a metallicity
gradient alone cannot explain the observed colour gradients.
The effects of different star formation histories are indicated by the two
dashed lines in the centre of the panels. The red ends of these lines indicate
the colours of a single burst population, the blue end of a population of
constant star formation rate. Both the position and the direction of these solar
metallicity models seem to agree reasonably well with the data, and the most
simple explanation for the colour gradients would be age gradients across the
disks of spiral galaxies. Still this cannot be the whole story, as galaxies still
have star formation in their central regions, which means that a single burst
is a bad approximation. Furthermore it is known from measurement of HII
regions that spiral galaxies have metallicity gradients in their gas content,
Colour Gradients in the Optical and Near-IR 5
Fig. 3b. As Fig. 3a, but for B -- I versus V -- K.
which most likely is partly reflected in the stellar component. So the most
consistent picture is one where colour gradients are caused by both age and
metallicity gradients, with the central regions of galaxies being on average
quite old and having a range of metallicities, whereas the outer parts are
young and have low metallicities.
The large spread in colours of the late type galaxies can be explained by
stellar population changes as well. The single-burst age evolution is indicated
by the thick, solid lines in the 6≤T≤10 panels, for the metallicities indicated
in the 5≤T<6 panels. The colours indicate that the stellar population in some
of these galaxies are on average very young and have a low metallicity.
The colour gradients imply large M/L gradients for the optical passbands,
making the 'missing light' problem as derived from rotation curve fitting even
worse, irrespective whether they are caused by dust or population changes.
References
Bruzual G.A., Charlot S. 1993, ApJ 405, 538
de Jong R.S. 1995a, Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Groningen, The Netherlands
de Jong R.S. 1995b, A&A, submitted
de Jong R.S., van der Kruit P.C. 1994, A&AS 106, 451
Freeman K.C. 1970, ApJ 160, 811
Worthey G. 1994, ApJS 95, 107
|
astro-ph/9906373 | 1 | 9906 | 1999-06-24T06:47:19 | High-Energy Gamma-Ray Observations of Two Young, Energetic Radio Pulsars | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present results of Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory EGRET observations of the unidentified high-energy gamma-ray sources 2EG J1049-5847 (GEV J1047-5840, 3EG J1048-5840) and 2EG J1103-6106 (3EG J1102-6103). These sources are spatially coincident with the young, energetic radio pulsars PSRs B1046-58 and J1105-6107, respectively. We find evidence for an association between PSR B1046-58 and 2EG J1049-5847. The gamma-ray pulse profile, obtained by folding time-tagged photons having energies above 400 MeV using contemporaneous radio ephemerides, has probability of arising by chance of 1.2E-4 according to the binning-independent H-test. A spatial analysis of the on-pulse photons reveals a point source of equivalent significance 10.2 sigma. Off-pulse, the significance drops to 5.8 sigma. Archival ASCA data show that the only hard X-ray point source in the 95% confidence error box of the gamma-ray source is spatially coincident with the pulsar within the 1' uncertainty (Pivovaroff, Kaspi & Gotthelf 1999). The double peaked gamma-ray pulse morphology and leading radio pulse are similar to those seen for other gamma-ray pulsars and are well-explained in models in which the gamma-ray emission is produced in charge-depleted gaps in the outer magnetosphere. The inferred pulsed gamma-ray flux above 400 MeV, (2.5 +/- 0.6) x 10E-10 erg/cm^2/s, represents 0.011 +/- 0.003 of the pulsar's spin-down luminosity, for a distance of 3 kpc and 1 sr beaming. For PSR J1105-6107, light curves obtained by folding EGRET photons using contemporaneous radio ephemerides show no significant features. We conclude that this pulsar converts less than 0.014 of its spin-down luminosity into E > 100 MeV gamma-rays beaming in our direction (99% confidence), assuming a distance of 7 kpc, 1 sr beaming and a duty cycle of 0.5. | astro-ph | astro-ph | High-Energy Gamma-Ray Observations of Two Young, Energetic
Radio Pulsars
V. M. Kaspi1 and J. R. Lackey2
Department of Physics and Center for Space Research, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, 70 Vassar St., Cambridge, MA 02139
Astronomy Department, Boston University, 725 Commonwealth Ave., Boston, MA 02215
J. Mattox3
Australia Telescope National Facility, Epping, NSW, 2121 Australia
R. N. Manchester4
Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, Mail 31, PO Box
M. Bailes5
218, Hawthorn, Victoria, 3122 Australia
R. Pace6
Physics Department, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia
ABSTRACT
results
We present
of Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory/EGRET
observations of the unidentified high-energy γ-ray sources 2EG J1049−5847 (GEV
J1047−5840, 3EG J1048−5840) and 2EG J1103−6106 (3EG J1102−6103). These
sources are spatially coincident with the young, energetic radio pulsars PSRs
B1046−58 and J1105−6107, respectively. We find evidence for an association
between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847. The γ-ray pulse profile, obtained
by folding time-tagged photons having energies above 400 MeV using contem-
poraneous radio ephemerides, has probability of arising by chance of 1.2 × 10−4
according to the binning-independent H-test. A spatial analysis of the on-pulse
9
9
9
1
n
u
J
4
2
1
v
3
7
3
6
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1Alfred P. Sloan Research Fellow; [email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
– 2 –
photons reveals a point source of equivalent significance 10.2σ. Off-pulse, the sig-
nificance drops to 5.8σ. Archival ASCA data show that the only hard X-ray point
source in the 95% confidence error box of the γ-ray source is spatially coincident
with the pulsar within the 1′ uncertainty (Pivovaroff, Kaspi, & Gotthelf 1999).
The double peaked γ-ray pulse morphology and leading radio pulse are similar to
those seen for other γ-ray pulsars and are well-explained in models in which the
γ-ray emission is produced in charge-depleted gaps in the outer magnetosphere.
The inferred pulsed γ-ray flux above 400 MeV, (2.5 ± 0.6) × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1,
represents 0.011±0.003 of the pulsar's spin-down luminosity, for a distance of
3 kpc and 1 sr beaming. For PSR J1105−6107, light curves obtained by folding
EGRET photons using contemporaneous radio ephemerides show no significant
features. We conclude that this pulsar converts less than 0.014 of its spin-down
luminosity into E > 100 MeV γ-rays beaming in our direction (99% confidence),
assuming a distance of 7 kpc, 1 sr beaming and a duty cycle of 0.5.
Subject headings: gamma rays: observations - pulsars: general - pulsars: in-
dividual: PSR B1046−58, PSR J1105−6107
1.
Introduction
An outstanding unknown in γ-ray astronomy is the nature of a population of high-energy
γ-ray sources at low Galactic latitude which were first identified using the COS-B satellite
(Swanenburg et al. 1981). More recently, these sources were studied in greater detail by the
Energetic Gamma Ray Experiment Telescope (EGRET) aboard the Compton Gamma-Ray
Observatory (Kanbach et al. 1996). In contrast to the high-energy γ-ray sources at high
latitudes, which are typically associated with active galaxies, several dozen apparent point
sources of high-energy γ-rays at latitudes b <
∼ 10◦ have as yet not been identified with
astronomical objects. However, a handful of low-latitude sources has been identified with
young, energetic radio pulsars (see Thompson 1996 for a review). This suggests that many
of the unidentified sources are also young pulsars. This hypothesis has been considered in
various studies, many of which suggest that the majority, if not all, of the unidentified sources
are pulsars (Yadigaroglu & Romani 1995, Kaaret & Cottam 1996, Yadigaroglu & Romani
1997, Cheng & Zhang 1998). Sturner & Dermer (1995) suggested that many of the sources are
not pulsars but rather are a result of cosmic ray interactions with gas in supernova remnants.
With the EGRET spatial resolution generally limited to tens of arcminutes, identification
of discrete high-energy γ-ray sources is difficult using spatial coincidence alone, explaining
why this problem has remained open so long.
– 3 –
Rotation-powered pulsars permit a straightforward determination of the nature of a γ-
ray source using the signature pulsed emission. Indeed the Crab and Vela pulsars are long-
known to be strong sources of pulsed γ-rays. EGRET has provided unambiguous and/or
strong evidence for pulsations from five other rotation-powered pulsars (see Table 1). Five
E/d2, where the spin-down
of the six pulsars having the highest values of the parameter
luminosity E ≡ 4π2I P /P 3 (P is the pulse period and P its rate of increase) and d is the
distance to the source, are established sources of high-energy γ-ray pulsations. Finding
rotation-powered pulsars at γ-ray energies is important because those detected thus far have
their maximum luminosities in this energy range. Thus γ-rays may hold the key to the poorly
understood pulsar energy budget and emission mechanism, in which mechanical energy of
rotation is efficiently converted into non-thermal high-energy radiation. The origin of the
γ-rays – whether at the neutron star polar cap (e.g. Daugherty & Harding 1996) or in the
outer magnetosphere (e.g. Romani & Yadigaroglu 1995) – is still debated. In this paper we
examine high-energy γ-ray data from the direction of two young, energetic pulsars which are
good candidates for observable γ-ray pulsations.
PSR B1046−58 is a 124 ms radio pulsar having characteristic age 20 kyr and spin-down
luminosity E = 2.0 × 1036 erg s−1. It was discovered in a survey of the Galactic plane for
radio pulsars (Johnston et al. 1992), and has an unremarkable radio average pulse profile,
characterized by a single narrow peak having width ∼8 ms at 1.4 GHz (Figure 1).
Its
pulsed radio emission is highly linearly polarized and shows a slow position angle variation
across the pulse, suggestive of conal emission (Qiao et al. 1995). The dispersion measure
of 129.01±0.01 pc cm−3 toward this pulsar implies a distance of 2.98±0.35 kpc (Taylor &
Cordes 1993). In the rank-ordered E/d2 list, PSR B1046−58 falls ninth, with six of the eight
above it known γ-ray pulsars, five of those six being high-energy γ-ray sources (see Table 1).
The pulsar's position lies near the 95% confidence contour for the Second EGRET catalog
source 2EG J1049−5847 (Thompson et al. 1995). Thompson et al. (1994) reported a pulsed
flux 99.9% confidence upper limit for energies above 100 MeV of 4.5×10−7 photons cm−2 s−1
for a 50% duty cycle pulse. They noted, however, a "hint" of a pulsation for PSR B1046−58
above 1 GeV, having probability of chance occurrence of 14%. As reported in a companion
paper, Pivovaroff, Kaspi & Gotthelf (1999) have detected X-rays from the direction of the
pulsar; that emission is not pulsed and is probably due to a synchrotron nebula.
PSR J1105−6107 is a 63 ms pulsar having characteristic age 63 kyr and E = 2.5 ×
1036 erg s−1 (Kaspi et al. 1997).
It exhibits a narrow double peaked radio pulse profile
having width 3.4 ms at 1.6 GHz. Its radio emission is highly linearly polarized, showing a slow
positional angle variation suggestive of conal emission (Crawford et al. 1999). The pulsar's
dispersion measure of 270.55±0.14 pc cm−3 implies a distance of 7.1±0.9 kpc (Taylor &
Cordes 1993). Ranking by E/d2, it is 23rd, well above the known γ-ray pulsar PSR B1055−52
– 4 –
(whose distance may well be overestimated; see Thompson et al. 1999 and references therein)
though well below several sources which have not been detected by EGRET (Thompson et
al. 1994). PSR J1105−6107 is spatially coincident with the unidentified EGRET source 2EG
J1103−6106 (Thompson et al. 1995, Kaspi et al. 1997). This γ-ray source has pulsar-like
properties: it has a hard spectrum and is not time variable. However the Second EGRET
catalog noted marginal evidence for the source being extended. PSR J1105−6107 has been
detected as an unpulsed X-ray source (Gotthelf & Kaspi 1998, Steinberger, Kaspi, & Gotthelf
1999); this emission is best explained as being due to nebular synchrotron emission powered
by the pulsar wind.
Given the importance of identifying γ-ray pulsations in radio pulsars as well as es-
tablishing the nature of the unidentified EGRET sources, additional EGRET exposure of
the Eta Carina region was obtained. We report here on an analysis of EGRET data for
PSR B1046−58 obtained between 1991 May and 1997 October, and for PSR J1105−6107
between 1993 July and 1997 October. In §2 we summarize the EGRET observations used
in our analysis. In §3 we report our findings, showing evidence for γ-ray pulsations from
PSR B1046−58, but none from PSR J1105−6107. We discuss our results and their implica-
tions in §4.
2. Observations and Analysis
The Energetic Gamma Ray Experiment Telescope (EGRET) aboard the Compton Gamma
Ray Observatory is sensitive to photons in the energy range from approximately 30 MeV to
30 GeV, using a multi-level spark chamber system to detect electron-positron pairs resulting
from γ-rays. A NaI calorimeter provides energy resolution of 20-25%, and a plastic scintil-
lator anti-coincidence dome prevents triggering on events not associated with high-energy
photons. The detector thus has negligible background. The detector is described in more
detail in Thompson et al. (1993) and references therein. The data sets used in this analysis
consist of archival data, as well as PI data for Cycles 5 and 6. Data sets included event UTC
arrival times accurate to 100 µs, energy, measured direction of origin, satellite location, and
other information. A summary of the observations of PSRs B1046−58 and J1105−6107 is
presented in Tables 2 and 3.
– 5 –
2.1. Timing Analysis
The timing analysis was done using the interactive software PULSAR which has been
described elsewhere (e.g. Fierro 1995) and is based on the TEMPO software package (e.g.
Taylor & Weisberg 1989). Event arrival times are first reduced to the solar system barycenter
and then folded using a contemporaneous ephemeris derived from radio monitoring.
Young pulsars are notorious for displaying timing irregularities, namely glitches and
long-term timing "noise" (see Lyne 1996 for a review). The pulsars in question are no
exception (Johnston et al. 1995, Kaspi et al. 1997). Timing noise alone can result in phase
deviations as large as a full cycle over a year or two, while glitches can result in so large
a phase deviation that only unusually dense observations can permit unambiguous phase
determination. Such deviations cannot be tolerated when searching for γ-ray pulsations over
many years, particularly when expecting weak pulsations, as even small deviations could
broaden the signal beyond detectability.
For this reason, we have used contemporaneous radio ephemerides determined by timing
observations made at the 64-m radio telescope at Parkes, Australia. Most radio observations
were done at a central frequency near 1500 MHz, with some at 430 and 660 MHz. Prior to
1995, all data were obtained using filter-bank timing systems (2 × 64 × 5 MHz at 1520 MHz
and 2 × 256 × 0.125 MHz at 430 and 660 MHz) that have been described elsewhere (e.g.
Bailes et al. 1994). Most data from after 1995 were obtained using the Caltech correlator-
based pulsar timing machine (Navarro 1994), which has 2× 128 lags across 128 MHz in each
of two separate frequency bands. Typically, correlator observations were made at central fre-
quencies of 1420 and 1650 MHz simultaneously. Filter-bank data were recorded on tape and
folded off-line; correlator data were folded on-line. Resulting folded profiles were convolved
with high signal-to-noise templates to yield topocentric pulse arrival times. Resulting arrival
times were analyzed using the standard TEMPO pulsar timing software package6 together with
the JPL DE200 ephemeris (Standish 1982). Ephemerides for folding the γ-ray data were de-
termined piecewise using a minimum of some two dozen arrival times per valid interval, with
RMS residuals well under the γ-ray binning resolution in all cases. The ephemerides used
are provided for each EGRET viewing period in publicly accessible machine-readable format
at http://www.atnf.csiro.au/research/pulsar/psr/archive/.
Since the range of radio frequencies observed at each epoch was not generally sufficiently
large to determine dispersion measures with high precision, we assume that the dispersion
measures do not vary significantly. Substantial variations would result in changes in the
6http://pulsar.princeton.edu/tempo
– 6 –
pulse phase extrapolated from the radio ephemeris to the effectively infinite γ-ray frequency
according to the cold plasma dispersion law. This could cause smearing of the pulse profile.
We can test the plausibility of our assumption of a constant dispersion measure (DM) using
the results of Backer et al. (1993) who empirically characterized variations in DM for sev-
eral pulsars. As neither pulsar considered here lies within a detectable supernova remnant
(Johnston et al. 1995, Kaspi et al. 1996, Gotthelf & Kaspi 1998, Pivovaroff, Kaspi, & Got-
thelf 1999), the very large DM variations observed for the Crab and Vela pulsars, usually
attributed to their unusual environments, are unlikely to be present. From the empirical
findings of Backer et al. (1993), for PSR B1046−58, the maximum DM variation per year
expected is ∼0.01 pc cm−3. Over the ∼8 yr duration of the experiment described here, this
amounts to a variation in pulse phase of ∼1.2×10−3, a factor of ∼40 smaller than our binning
resolution. For PSR J1105−6107, the DM variation could be an order of magnitude larger,
however the experiment in this case spans only ∼4 yr. The phase variation then could be
as large as ∼1.1×10−2, smaller, but only by a factor of ∼4, than our binning resolution.
We conclude that DM variations are certainly negligible for PSR B1046−58, and probably
negligible for PSR J1105−6107.
2.2. Spatial Analysis
The energy dependence of the point-spread function of the EGRET detector can be
characterized by the function
θ67(E) = 5◦.85 × (E/100)−0.534,
(1)
where θ67 is the half-angle of the cone encircling the actual source direction and which con-
tains 67% of the events having energy E in MeV (Thompson et al. 1993). In our timing
analysis, we used all events within θ67. The source directions are (J2000) RA 10h 48m 12s.6(3),
DEC −58◦ 32′ 03′′.75(1) for PSR B1046−58 (Stappers et al.
1999), and (J2000) RA
11h 05m 26s.07(7), DEC −61◦ 07′ 52′′.1(4) for PSR J1105−6107 (Kaspi et al. 1997), where
the numbers in brackets are 1σ uncertainties. The total number of counts folded is given for
each viewing period in Tables 2 and 3 for PSRs B1046−58 and J1105−6107, respectively.
Spatial analysis of γ-ray data is done using the likelihood ratio test (Mattox et al.
1996). The significance of a point source is found using a test statistic Ts that compares
the likelihood of the distribution of counts (which is governed by Poisson statistics) having
occurred under the null hypothesis of no point source, with that with a point source present,
given the instrumental point-spread function (PSF). Mattox et al. have shown that a point-
– 7 –
source significance in units of the standard deviation is given by √Ts where
Ts ≡ 2(ln L1 − ln L0),
(2)
where L1 is the likelihood under the assumption of a point source and L0 is that under the
null hypothesis. The likelihood itself is given by
L = Y
ij
θnij
ij e−θij
nij!
,
(3)
where the product is over pixel ij that contains nij counts, and the model prediction is θij.
3. Results
3.1. PSR B1046−58
3.1.1. Timing Analysis
In Figure 1, we present the folded light curve for PSR B1046−58 for energies above
400 MeV. The significance of the apparent modulation can only be established using ap-
propriate statistical tests. The optimal test is the H-test (de Jager 1994), which provides a
figure of merit for a folded light curve that is independent of the number of bins or of the
phase of the putative signal. For this reason, the H-test is superior to the standard χ2 test
(e.g. Leahy et al. 1983). Further, the H statistic has been shown to be optimal when con-
sidering a light curve having unknown pulse morphology. In this sense, it is superior to the
Z 2
N test (Buccheri et al. 1983) which can be done for specified numbers of harmonics only.
For the light curve in Figure 1, the H statistic is 22.5, which has a probability of 1.2 × 10−4
of having occurred by random chance, with 5 harmonics indicated. This corresponds to an
equivalent normal distribution deviation of 3.9σ from the null hypothesis of no pulsations.
For reference, χ2 = 26.3 for 10 bins (9 degrees of freedom); the probability of this value
or higher having occurred by chance is 1.8 × 10−3 (3.1σ). The Z 2
4 statistic has value 33.8;
the probability of this value or higher having occurred by chance is 4.3 × 10−5 (4.1σ). Note
that there is effectively only a single trial folding period. Since we considered two pulsars,
these probabilities should be multiplied by a factor of two. Although we did not search
independent energy bands, the choice of 400 MeV lower energy cutoff was made to optimize
the significance; we discuss this further below.
We have checked the robustness of our result in several ways. First, we divided the total
data set into two halves of approximately equal size and verified that the signal is seen in
– 8 –
both, albeit at reduced significance, as expected. For the first half data set (MJDs 48386–
49361), we find H=16.7, which has probability 1.3 × 10−3, while for the second half data set
(MJDs 49361–50728) we found H=15.0, having probability 2.4 × 10−3. These statistics are
for E > 400 MeV. Second, we verified that the signal persisted when the energy-dependent
cone opening angle (Eq. 1) was increased to include 99% of the counts from the known source
direction; in this case we found H=12.5, which has probability 6.8 × 10−3.
Note that zero is suppressed in the light curve shown in Figure 1. The observed pulsed
fraction for E > 400 MeV is 0.12±0.02. The off-pulse γ-rays may originate as diffuse Galactic
emission - the pulsar is located in the complicated Eta Carina region, tangent to the Carina
spiral arm, which is known to contain significant diffuse emission and many discrete sources.
In §3.1.2 we describe a spatial analysis that
(Bertsch et al. 1993, Hunter et al. 1997).
indicates that a small fraction of the off-pulse could be emission from PSR B1046−58 itself.
One way to check for the presence of contaminating diffuse emission is to utilize the
different expected spectra of diffuse and pulsed signals. In Figure 2 we show, in the lower
panel, results of three statistical tests as a function of lower cutoff energy. The probability
shown is that of finding the value of the statistical test, or higher, for a profile consisting
of folded photons having energies above the cutoff. The upper panel shows the number of
photons included in the analysis, here done for counts within θ67. Qualitatively, the behavior
is as expected: the diffuse emission has a softer spectrum than those of the known γ-ray
pulsars, so as the lower energy bound is increased, the significance of the pulse should increase
until the pulsar signal is too photon-starved to be detected. Furthermore, the EGRET PSF
narrows with increasing energy (Eq. 1), so diffuse emission and nearby confusing point sources
are preferentially removed as the lower energy bound is increased given advance knowledge
of the pulsar position (Lamb & Macomb 1997). However, the sudden decrease in significance
when the lower energy cut changes from 400 to 600 MeV is unexpected, given the smooth
decrease in the number of counts. This could indicate a spectral cutoff in the pulsed emission,
or could simply be a result of the poor statistics for the pulse profile; it could also suggest
the apparently significant modulation is a statistical fluctuation.
The detection of pulsed high-energy γ-ray emission from PSR B1951+32 by Ramana-
murthy et al. (1995) was done by considering events selected from a cone of fixed angle
with respect to the pulsar position, as a compromise between maximizing signal from the
source and minimizing background contamination. We have carried out the same analysis
for PSR B1046−58, using a fixed cone of 2◦ half-angle. We chose this size cone as it resulted
in a comparable total number of events as for the energy-dependent cone. For the fixed cone,
we find H= 23.9, corresponding to a probability of 6.9 × 10−5 (4.0σ), an improvement over
the energy-dependent-cone results. This supports the reality of the pulsations. However,
– 9 –
not all the profile statistics improve for the fixed cone; for example, the χ2 statistic drops
to 25.3, corresponding to a probability of 2.7 × 10−3 (3.0σ), still statistically significant, but
less so than with the energy-dependent cone.
Ramanamurthy et al.
(1996) reported high-energy γ-ray pulsations from the radio
pulsar PSR B0656+14 using photons that had been "weighted" according to their energy
and direction, and the known telescope response. We have employed a similar algorithm to
theirs in considering the apparent modulation seen in the unweighted data. Each event is
assigned a weight which is equal to the probability that a specific γ-ray originated from the
point source (rather than as diffuse Galactic emission),
w =
PSF(r, E)
PSF(r, E) + B
S (E)
,
(4)
where PSF(r, E) is the energy-dependent EGRET point spread function, the probability per
steradian for a photon of energy E to be detected at a measured angle r from the source.
B/S is the ratio of diffuse Galactic counts per steradian to source counts at energy E. As the
combinations of weights within phase bins are, unlike the unweighted data, not described by
Poisson statistics, the same statistical tests do not apply. Instead, we considered the simple
statistical standard deviation of the binned values, xi, PN
i=1(xi−x)2/(N−1). We used Monte
Carlo simulations of profiles to determine the probability of chance occurrence of a profile
having this statistic. Simulated profiles of weighted data were made by randomly varying the
phases. In this way, for E > 400 MeV, we found that the probability of obtaining a profile
having the same modified χ2 statistic or higher for the folded, weighted data was 0.026.
Thus the significance of the detection decreases using the weights. This was not expected.
However, given the evidence below in favor of the association, it does not eliminate the
possibility that pulsed flux is being detected from PSR B1046−58; the decrease in significance
could be due to the poorly known pulsed γ-ray spectrum (which was assumed to be a power
law of index 1.97±0.07 – see §4.1.2) or to a statistical fluctuation.
3.1.2. Spatial Analysis
We have conducted a likelihood analysis (Mattox et al. 1996) of the EGRET data for
PSR B1046−58 (see §2.2) for E > 400 MeV events.
In the analysis, the model for the
diffuse Galactic flux of Hunter et al. (1997) was used, and the flux of nearby sources in the
Second EGRET catalog (Thompson et al. 1995) was estimated simultaneously with that
from the position of PSR B1046−58. A point source at the pulsar position was detected
with a significance of √Ts = 10.8σ. We estimate 347±40 γ-ray events from this point
source, corresponding to a flux of (1.6 ± 0.2)×10−7 photons cm−2s−1 (E > 400 MeV). The
– 10 –
distribution of EGRET events is consistent with the EGRET PSF; we find a reduced χ2 of
1.3 for the sum of all events for Cycles 1–6 of the EGRET mission.
A similar analysis was done for different rotational phases. Phase-resolved event maps
for E > 400 MeV were made for peak 1 (phases 0.300–0.475), interpeak 1 (0.475–0.675),
peak 2 (0.675–0.825), and interpeak 2 (0.825–0.300). The peak 1 and peak 2 maps were
combined to form an "on-pulse" map. The interpeak 1 and interpeak 2 maps were combined
to form an "off-pulse" map.
For the on-pulse map, a point source at the position of PSR B1046−58 was detected
with a significance of √Ts = 10.2σ, corresponding to an estimated 203±25 γ-ray events.
For the off-pulse map, a point source at the position of PSR B1046−58 was detected with a
significance of √Ts = 5.8σ corresponding to an estimated 144±29 γ-ray events. The distri-
bution of EGRET events was consistent with the PSF for both the on- and off-pulse phase
selections. The EGRET position estimate was also consistent with that of PSR B1046−58
for both the on- and off-pulse phase selections. Thus, significant flux is detected during both
the on- and off-pulse phases, and it appears that both the pulsar and diffuse Galactic γ-ray
emission contribute to the emission represented by the suppressed zero in Figure 1.
We also subdivided the on-pulse map into two, by making separate maps for peak 1 and
peak 2 data. Both peak 1 and peak 2 show a point source at the position of the pulsar, with
significances of 6.0σ and 8.4σ, respectively.
Maps of "residual" flux were also made for both the on- and off-pulse phase selections by
subtracting the counts distribution for nearby sources, counts corresponding to an isotropic
flux of 0.295 × 10−5 photons cm−2 s−1 sr−1, and counts corresponding to diffuse Galactic
flux (with an empirically determined scaling factor of 0.242 for the model of Hunter et al.
1997 for E > 100 MeV flux). The residual counts map was then converted to a residual
flux map by dividing by the exposure. The difference between the residual fluxes for the
on- and off-pulse maps shows the expected distribution for the EGRET PSF with a source
coincident with PSR B1046−58.
3.2. PSR J1105−6107
3.2.1. Timing Analysis
In Figure 3, we show the folded light curve for PSR J1105−6107 for energies above
400 MeV. The H statistic is 3.6, which has a probability of 0.24 of having occurred by chance.
We thus find no evidence for γ-ray pulsations from PSR J1105−6107. We also tried folding
– 11 –
photons from within a cone encircling the source direction that contains 99% of the events;
again no evidence for pulsations was found. We also searched for pulsations in different
energy ranges to take advantage of the expected increased pulsed fraction with increasing
low energy cutoff, but found no significant signals. Finally, we considered data weighted
according to the algorithm described in §3.1, but again found no significant pulsations.
The 99% confidence level upper limit on the pulsed fraction of 2EG J1103−6106 at the
PSR J1105−6107 spin period for E > 400 MeV, using the H test and assuming a duty cycle
of 0.5 is 0.33. For a duty cycle of 0.1, it is 0.13. For E > 100 MeV photons, the analogous
limits are 0.09 and 0.04 for duty cycles 0.5 and 0.1, respectively.
4. Discussion
4.1. PSR B1046−58
The folded γ-ray profile for PSR B1046−58 and the spatial analysis of the γ-ray data
provide evidence for the association between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847. However
additional support for this conclusion is desirable, because of the difficulty in interpreting the
pulse significance as a function of energy and the drop in significance when photon weighting
is used. We consider here evidence that provides additional support for the association
between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847.
4.1.1. ASCA X-Ray Observations of the 2EG J1049−5847 Field
Additional evidence in favor of associating PSR B1046−58 with 2EG J1049−5847 are
the results of ASCA X-ray observations of the 2EG J1049−5847 field, which are described
in a companion paper (Pivovaroff, Kaspi, & Gotthelf 1999). There, archival ASCA ob-
servations are presented that cover the full 95% confidence error circle of the counterpart
(1999) in the recently published
to 2EG J1049−5847 as determined by Hartman et al.
show,
3EG catalog (where the source name is 3EG J1048−5840). As Pivovaroff et al.
the only X-ray source within the 95% confidence contour of the γ-ray source is coincident
with PSR B1046−58 within the < 1′ X-ray positional uncertainty. The source is unpulsed
and is likely to be a synchrotron nebula. However, there is an additional nearby hard-
spectrum X-ray source outside the 95% confidence contour (but within the 99% contour)
that could also be the counterpart, a possibility we cannot rule out without an improved
γ-ray source position. Nevertheless, the most likely counterpart from the X-ray observations
is PSR B1046−58.
– 12 –
4.1.2. Spectrum and Energetics
Merck et al.
(1996) found that 2EG J1049−5847 had a spectral index of 2.0±0.1,
and noted that the γ-ray source had properties consistent with the known γ-ray pulsar
population, as well as the positional coincidence with PSR B1046−58. Bertsch et al. (in
preparation) find a spectral index of 1.97±0.09 for the 3EG counterpart of 2EG J1049−5847,
3EG J1048−5840, and an integrated flux for E > 100 MeV of (62±7)×10−8 photon cm−2 s−1
(R. Hartman, personal communication). We have done an independent pulse-phase-resolved
spectral analysis by considering the fluxes and spectra for peaks 1 and 2 separately, using
γ-rays arriving during the off-peak 2 interval as a background estimate. We find spectra for
both peaks that are consistent with that reported above as well as with each other.
Using the results of the on-pulse spatial analysis (§3.1.2) together with the reported
3EG point source flux (Hartman et al. 1999) and spectrum (Bertsch et al. 1999), we derive
a pulsed flux for E > 400 MeV of (2.5 ± 0.6) × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1, which corresponds to
an efficiency for conversion of spin-down luminosity into pulsed E > 400 MeV γ-rays of
0.011±0.03 for 1 sr beaming, assuming d = 3 kpc. Using the derived total pulsed fraction
(§3.1.1), the total number of counts and the exposure yields consistent results. The observed
flux is consistent with previously published upper limits (Thompson et al. 1994).
4.1.3. Absence of Variability
McLaughlin et al. (1996) quantified the variability of EGRET sources and showed that
known γ-ray pulsars are not variable, in contrast to all known γ-ray-loud active galaxies for
which accurate γ-ray flux measurements have been made. They further analyzed the variabil-
ity of the unidentified EGRET sources and concluded that 2EG J1049−5847 is non-variable,
consistent with its identification as an energetic rotation-powered pulsar. An analysis of the
larger data set used to produce the 3EG catalog reveals no evidence for variability from the
source, consistent with its identification as a rotation-powered pulsar (Hartman et al. 1999).
4.1.4. Pulse Profile Morphology and Relative Radio Phase
The morphology of the γ-ray profile shown in Figure 1 lends some support to its in-
terpretation as pulsations from PSR B1046−58. Note that in the profile, the difference in
height between the two peaks is not statistically significant, and the bin resolution is op-
timal. The two peaks, having separation 0.36±0.13 in pulse phase, is reminiscent of the
γ-ray profile of the Vela pulsar (e.g. Kanbach et al. 1994), which has comparable spin-down
– 13 –
parameters. Similar γ-ray pulse profiles are also observed for the Crab pulsar, Geminga,
and PSR B1951+32 (Thompson 1996 and references therein). Hard X-ray observations of
the Vela pulsar reveal a pulse profile that is similar to that at γ-ray energies (Strickman &
Harding 1998); this suggests that hard X-ray observations of PSR B1046−58 could confirm
its identification as a source of pulsed γ-rays. It must be kept in mind, however, that the
profile of other well-established high-energy γ-ray pulsars is not as clearly double peaked.
For example, PSR B1706−44, whose spin-down parameters most closely resemble those of
PSR B1046−58, has a γ-ray profile whose morphology could be interpreted, within the
limited statistics, as either single or double peaked with small peak separation. Therefore
the double peaked profile in Figure 1 does not lend unambiguous support to the proposed
association.
The γ-ray pulse's offset from the single radio pulse (Fig. 1) is similar to those seen
in the known high-energy γ-ray pulsars. The offset in time between the peak of the radio
pulse and the approximate centroid of the first of the two γ-ray peaks shown in Figure 1
is 0.19±0.12 in pulse phase, with the uncertainty dominated by the poor profile statistics.
The phase offset to the approximate midpoint between the two apparent pulses is 0.37±0.13.
The uncertainty in these numbers due to the uncertainty of 0.01 pc cm−3 in the single-epoch
DM measurement (§1) is negligible. This offset is similar to those of the other γ-ray pulsars
having similar γ-ray pulse morphologies, namely the Crab (considering the radio precursor
as the analog of the PSR B1046−58 radio pulse), Vela, and PSR B1951+32 (Thompson 1996
and references therein). These show an approximate empirical trend of radio–γ-ray phase
offset that increases with characteristic age (e.g. Thompson 1996). The observed radio/γ-
ray offset for PSR B1046−58 is in agreement with this trend, which predicts an offset in the
approximate range 0.32–0.38.
4.1.5. Previous Discussion of the PSR B1046−58 / 2EG J1049−5847 Association
In addition to Thompson et al. (1994) noting a hint of a γ-ray pulsation from PSR B1046−58,
Fierro (1995) discussed a possible association between the pulsar and 2EG J1049−5847 in
detail. He noted the positional coincidence as well as the plausibility of the implied spectral
and energy properties of the putative γ-ray pulsar. He also noted the absence of variabil-
ity in the source. Yadigaroglu & Romani (1997) used a statistical test that quantifies the
probability for positional coincidence of unidentified EGRET sources with nearby young
objects. They identified the PSR B1046−58 / 2EG J1049−5847 association using this anal-
ysis. Zhang & Cheng (1998) argued that the PSR B1046−58 / 2EG J1049−5847 association
was plausible on the basis of predictions from a version of the outer gap model of γ-ray
– 14 –
production in pulsar magnetospheres.
4.1.6.
Implications
If the association between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847 is correct, then this is
only the eighth pulsar to show evidence for high-energy γ-ray pulsations. The poor statistics
in the folded profile and the presence of significant off-pulse emission preclude detailed anal-
ysis of the γ-ray emission properties. Nevertheless, the pulsar's apparent γ-ray properties
resemble those of other known γ-ray pulsars, particularly the Crab and Vela pulsars and
PSR B1951+32 (radio and γ-ray pulse morphologies and phase offset). PSR B1046−58 fur-
ther shares a property common to all other known "older" γ-ray pulsars (that is, excluding
the Crab and PSR B1509−58), namely that its maximum luminosity appears to be in the
high-energy γ-ray range. By contrast, Pivovaroff et al. (1999) show that PSR B1046−58's
efficiency for conversion of
E into X-rays in the ASCA range is only ∼ 1 × 10−4.
We now consider what the implications of the possible γ-ray pulsations from PSR B1046−58
are for models of γ-ray emission from rotation-powered pulsars. If the pulsations are real, the
observed phase offset of the radio pulse is difficult to understand in the context of models in
which the γ-rays are produced by particles which are accelerated along open field lines near
the neutron star by electric fields (e.g. Dougherty & Harding 1982, Dermer & Sturner 1994).
In these models, the radio emission is thought to arise in the same polar cap region, so the
radio pulse should be observed between the γ-ray peaks, which result from emission from a
hollow cone. The conal geometry results from the smaller radius of curvature of magnetic
field lines near the polar cap rim (see Harding 1996 for a review). This radio/γ-ray phase
problem has been noted for other γ-ray pulsars as well, e.g. Vela (Daugherty & Harding
1996); the results reported here argue that the problem is general. Also, emission beams in
the polar cap model tend to be narrow and aligned with the magnetic and spin axes (e.g.
Sturner & Dermer 1994, Harding & Muslimov 1998); this can pose a problem for the pulsar
birth rate. However, the radio phase offset problem, as argued by Harding & Muslimov
(1998), seems general to both the polar cap γ-ray emission model as well as to geometric
models of thermal X-ray pulsations, while the relative phases of the latter two are consistent.
Polar cap models therefore make a testable prediction regarding the phase of the peak of
any thermal X-ray emission that may one day be detected from PSR B1046−58.
The observed γ-ray pulse morphology and radio phase offset for PSR B1046−58 are, by
contrast, well explained in the outer gap model. In this model, the γ-ray emission is produced
in the charge-depleted region between the closed magnetic field lines and the velocity of light
cylinder (e.g. Cheng, Ho, & Ruderman 1986, Chiang & Romani 1994, Romani & Yadigaroglu
– 15 –
1995, Zhang & Cheng 1998). The double peaked γ-ray pulse morphology in this model arises
from a single pole's outer gap that has uniform emissivity along its field lines but in which
the radiation is subject to significant relativistic aberration and time-of-flight delays through
the magnetosphere; the expected pulse morphology for most viewing geometries is double
peaked, as long as the magnetic inclination is not small. The morphology and phase are also
consistent with the geometry proposed by Manchester (1996) in which the radio emission is
produced in the outer gap as well. The outer gap model predicts bridge emission between the
two γ-ray peaks, whose outer edges should be sharp; this could be tested with an improved
γ-ray pulse profile. This model results in large beaming fractions that are consistent with
the pulsar birth rate; this implies that most, if not all, of the unidentified EGRET low-
latitude sources that have constant fluxes are young rotation-powered pulsars (Yadigaroglu
& Romani 1997), although most of them will not be detectable in radio waves from Earth
because of smaller radio beaming fractions. We note, however, that recently reported very
tentative evidence for γ-ray emission from the millisecond pulsar PSR J0218+4232 (Kuiper
et al. 1998) could pose a problem for the outer gap model, which predicts that millisecond
pulsars should not be detectable in high-energy γ-rays (Romani & Yadigaroglu 1995).
4.1.7. Unpulsed γ-ray Emission from PSR B1046−58?
The spatial analysis of the EGRET data presented in §3.1.2 showed evidence for off-
pulse emission consistent with coming from a point source coincident with the pulsar. For
E > 400 MeV, this emission has flux (1.9 ± 0.6) × 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1, which corresponds
E, for isotropic emission. The poor spatial resolution of EGRET obviously
to ∼ 10% of
precludes a firm association between the pulsar and this unpulsed emission, although we
note that off-pulse γ-ray emission has been seen for the Crab, Vela and Geminga pulsars,
with that of the Crab possibly originating in the surrounding nebula (Fierro et al. 1998).
4.2. PSR J1105−6107
Since we find no evidence for γ-ray pulsations for PSR J1105−6107, we set an upper
E that is converted into high-energy γ-rays beaming in our direction.
limit on the fraction of
The counterpart to 2EG J1103−6106 in the 3EG catalog, 3EG J1102−6103, has flux (32.5±
6.2)×10−8 photons cm−2 s−1 for E > 100 MeV, and photon index 2.47±0.21 (Hartman et al.
1999). Using these numbers, we infer with 99% confidence that PSR J1105−6107 converts
less than 8 × 10−11 erg cm−2 s−1 and 3 × 10−11 erg cm−2 s−1 for duty cycles of 0.5 and 0.1,
respectively. These limits correspond to efficiencies for conversion of spin-down luminosity of
– 16 –
less than 0.014 and 0.006 for 1 sr beaming and assuming a distance of 7 kpc, for duty cycles
0.5 and 0.1, respectively. These limits are not constraining on models of γ-ray emission.
5. Conclusions
We have found evidence for γ-ray emission from the young, energetic radio pulsar
PSR B1046−58, which, if correct, establishes a counterpart for the previously unidenti-
fied high-energy γ-ray source 2EG J1049−5847 (GEV J1046−5840, 3EG J1048−5840). The
evidence can be summarized as follows. (i) PSR B1046−58 has the ninth highest value of
E/d2 of the known radio pulsars, with six of the eight higher slots occupied by known γ-ray
pulsars. This suggests that PSR B1046−58 is likely to be detectable in γ-rays. (ii) The radio
pulsar is spatially coincident with the unidentified EGRET source 2EG J1049−5847. (iii)
The folded light curve for E > 400 MeV, obtained using contemporaneous radio ephemerides,
is characterized by an H-test statistic 22.5; the chance probability of this value or higher
having occurred is 1.2 × 10−4. This number should be multiplied by a factor of two for the
two pulsars we searched. (iv) A spatial likelihood analysis of on- and off-pulse data reveals a
point source coincident with the radio pulsar position whose significance is much greater on-
pulse than off (10.2σ versus 5.8σ). (v) The only hard X-ray point source detected in the 95%
EGRET error box is spatially coincident with the pulsar (Pivovaroff et al. 1999). (vi) The
γ-ray light curve morphology resembles those of other the known γ-ray pulsars (the Crab and
Vela pulsars, Geminga, and PSR B1951+32), namely, two narrow peaks separated by ∼0.4
in pulse phase. (vii) The inferred radio/γ-ray phase offset is consistent with trends seen for
other pulsars. The implied efficiency for conversion of spin-down energy into E > 400 MeV
γ-rays, 0.011±0.003 for d = 3 kpc and 1 sr beaming, is consistent with those seen for other
pulsars. We also found evidence for spatially unresolved unpulsed γ-ray emission from the
pulsar position, as has been reported for the Crab, Vela and Geminga pulsars.
If the association between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847 emission exists, it
should be confirmed by GLAST, the planned Gamma-ray Large Area Space Telescope, which
will provide significantly higher angular resolution and more detector area than EGRET. It
may be possible to confirm the γ-ray pulsations by detecting magnetospheric X-ray pulsa-
tions from PSR B1046−58 at hard X-ray energies. The similarity of this pulsar's rotational
parameters and high-energy γ-ray efficiency to those of PSR B1706−44 suggest TeV emission
might be detectable. Thermal emission from the initial cooling of this young neutron star
may also be detectable.
If the association between PSR B1046−58 and 2EG J1049−5847 holds, that seven of
the top nine pulsars ranked by E/d2 are γ-ray pulsars (with one of the two remainders not
– 17 –
having been studied at γ-ray energies – see Table 1) implies at the very least that the radio
and γ-ray beams are aligned closely, or that γ-ray beams are wide. In fact, the morphology
of the observed γ-ray pulse and the phase offset of the radio pulse provide support for the
outer gap model of γ-ray emission (Romani & Yadigaroglu 1995 and references therein). This
model predicts that an improved γ-ray profile should find bridge emission between the pulses
whose outer edges should be sharp. In this model, most or all of the unidentified EGRET
sources that have constant fluxes are young rotation-powered pulsars like PSR B1046−58,
though most radio beams will not be detectable from Earth due to small radio beaming
fractions.
Our analysis of EGRET data from the direction of PSR J1105−6107 finds no evidence
for γ-ray pulsations. This pulsar converts at most 0.014 (99% confidence) of its spin-down
power to E > 100 MeV γ-rays beamed in our direction, assuming 1 sr beaming, a duty cycle
of 0.5, and a distance to the source of 7 kpc. This limit is not constraining on models.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Dave Thompson for many helpful conversations, and Robert Hartman
for communication of Third EGRET Catalog numbers prior to publication. We also thank
Russell Pace for help with the Parkes observations. This research has made use of data
obtained through the High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Center Online
Service, provided by the NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center. This work was supported by
NASA grants NAG 5-3178 and NAG 5-3683 to VMK, and NASA LTSA grant NAG 5-3384
to JRM. We thank Joe Fierro for inspiration and assistance in the initial undertaking of this
project.
– 18 –
REFERENCES
Backer, D. C., Hama, S., Van Hook, S., & Foster, R. S. 1993, ApJ, 404, 636
Bailes, M. et al. 1994, ApJ, 425, L41
Bertsch, D. L., Dame, T. M., Fichtel, C. E., Hunter, S. D., Sreekumar, P., Stacy, J. G., &
Thaddeus, P. 1993, ApJ, 416, 587
Buccheri, R. et al. 1983, A&A, 128, 245
Caraveo, P. A., Bignami, G. F., Mignani, R., & Taff, L. G. 1996, ApJ, 461, 91
Cheng, K. S., Ho, C., & Ruderman, M. 1986, ApJ, 300, 500
Cheng, K. S. & Zhang, L. 1998, ApJ, 498, 327
Chiang, J. & Romani, R. W. 1994, ApJ, 436, 754
Crawford, F., Kaspi, V. M., Manchester, R. N., & Lyne, A. G. 1999, in preparation
Daugherty, J. K. & Harding, A. K. 1996, ApJ, 458, 278
de Jager, O. C. 1994, ApJ, 436, 239
Dermer, C. D. & Sturner, S. J. 1994, ApJ, 420, L75
Dougherty, J. K. & Harding, A. K. 1982, ApJ, 252, 337
Esposito, J. A., Hunter, S. D., Kanbach, G., & Sreekumar, P. 1996, ApJ, 461, 820
Fierro, J. M. 1995. PhD thesis, Stanford University
Fierro, j. M., Michelson, P. F., Nolan, P. L., & Thompson, D. J. 1998, ApJ, 494, 734
Gotthelf, E. V. & Kaspi, V. M. 1998, ApJ, 497, L29
Harding, A. K. 1996, in Pulsars: Problems and Progress, IAU Colloquium 160, eds. S.
Johnston, M. A. Walker, & M. Bailes, San Francisco, Astronomical Society of the
Pacific, 315
Harding, A. K. & Muslimov, A. G. 1998, ApJ, 500, 862
Hartman, R. C. et al. 1999, ApJ. in press
Hunter, S. D. et al. 1997, ApJ, 481, 205
– 19 –
Johnston, S., Lyne, A. G., Manchester, R. N., Kniffen, D. A., D'Amico, N., Lim, J., &
Ashworth, M. 1992, MNRAS, 255, 401
Johnston, S., Manchester, R. N., Lyne, A. G., Kaspi, V. M., & D'Amico, N. 1995, A&A,
293, 795
Kaaret, P. & Cottam, J. 1996, ApJ, 462, L35
Kanbach, G. et al. 1994, A&A, 289, 855
Kanbach, G. et al. 1996, A&AS, 120, 461
Kaspi, V. M., Bailes, M., Manchester, R. N., Stappers, B. W., & Bell, J. F. 1996, Nature,
381, 584
Kaspi, V. M., Bailes, M., Manchester, R. N., Stappers, B. W., Sandhu, J. S., Navarro, J., &
D'Amico, N. 1997, ApJ, 485, 820
Kaspi, V. M., Crawford, F., Manchester, R. N., Lyne, A. G., Camilo, F., D'Amico, N., &
Gaensler, B. M. 1998, ApJ, 503, L161
Kuiper, L., Hermsen, W., Verbunt, F., Belloni, T., & Lyne, A. 1998, in Proceedings of the
3rd INTEGRAL Workshop: The Extreme Universe, http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-
ph/9812408
Lamb, R. C. & Macomb, D. J. 1997, ApJ, 488, 872
Leahy, D. A., Darbro, W., Elsner, R. F., Weisskopf, M. C., Sutherland, P. G., Kahn, S., &
Grindlay, J. E. 1983, ApJ, 266, 160
Lyne, A. G. 1996, in Pulsars: Problems and Progress, IAU Colloquium 160, eds. S. Johnston,
M. A. Walker, & M. Bailes, San Francisco, Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 73
Manchester, R. N. 1996, in Pulsars: Problems and Progress, IAU Colloquium 160, eds.
S. Johnston, M. A. Walker, & M. Bailes, San Francisco, Astronomical Society of the
Pacific, 193
Marshall, F. E., Gotthelf, E. V., Zhang, W., Middleditch, J., & Wang, Q. D. 1998, ApJ,
499, L179
Mattox, J. R. et al. 1996, ApJ, 461, 396
McLaughlin, M. A., Mattox, J. R., Cordes, J. M., & Thompson, D. J. 1996, ApJ, 473, 763
– 20 –
Merck, M. et al. 1996, A&AS, 120, 465
Navarro, J. 1994. PhD thesis, California Institute of Technology
Pivovaroff, M., Kaspi, V. M., & Gotthelf, E. V. 1999, ApJ, submitted
Qiao, G. J., Manchester, R. N., Lyne, A. G., & Gould, D. M. 1995, MNRAS, 274, 572
Ramanamurthy, P. V. et al. 1995, ApJ, 447, L109
Ramanamurthy, P. V., Fichtel, C. E., Kniffen, D. A., Sreekumar, P., & Thompson, D. J.
1996, ApJ, 458, 755
Romani, R. W. & Yadigaroglu, I.-A. 1995, ApJ, 438, 314
Standish, E. M. 1982, A&A, 114, 297
Stappers, B. W., Gaensler, B. M., Johnston, S., & Frail, D. A. 1999. in preparation
Steinberger, J., Kaspi, V. M., & Gotthelf, E. V. 1999, in Proceedings of the Elba Work-
shop: Neutron Stars and Supernova Remnants, Memorie della Societa' Astronomica
Italiana, in press
Strickman, M. S. & Harding, A. K. 1998, BAAS, 192, 74.04
Sturner, S. J. & Dermer, C. D. 1994, ApJ, 420, L79
Sturner, S. J. & Dermer, C. D. 1995, A&A, 293, L17
Swanenburg, B. N. et al. 1981, ApJ, 243, L69
Taylor, J. H. & Cordes, J. M. 1993, ApJ, 411, 674
Taylor, J. H. & Weisberg, J. M. 1989, ApJ, 345, 434
Thompson, D. J. et al. 1993, ApJS, 86, 629
Thompson, D. J. et al. 1994, ApJ, 436, 229
Thompson, D. J. et al. 1995, ApJS, 101, 259
Thompson, D. J. 1996, in Pulsars: Problems and Progress, IAU Colloquium 160, eds. S.
Johnston, M. A. Walker, & M. Bailes, San Francisco, Astronomical Society of the
Pacific, 307
Thompson, D. J. et al. 1999, ApJ, in press
– 21 –
Torii, K. et al. 1998, ApJ, 494, L207
Ulmer, M. P. et al. 1993, ApJ, 417, 738
Yadigaroglu, I.-A. & Romani, R. W. 1995, ApJ, 449, 211
Yadigaroglu, I. A. & Romani, R. W. 1997, ApJ, 476, 347
Zhang, L. & Cheng, K. S. 1998, A&A, 335, 234
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
– 22 –
Fig. 1.- Bottom panel: folded EGRET light curve for PSR B1046−58 for E > 400 MeV.
Top panel: radio profile at 20 cm from the Parkes observatory.
– 23 –
Fig. 2.- Upper panel: number of events within θ67 for PSR B1046−58 as a function of lower
energy cutoff in MeV. Lower panel: results of three statistical tests applied to folded profiles
for PSR B1046−58 as a function of lower energy cutoff in MeV. The probabilities represent
the chance of the measured value of the statistical test or higher having been obtained by
chance. The three tests are the H test, the χ2 test for 10 bins (9 degrees of freedom), and
the Z 2
4 test.
– 24 –
Fig. 3.- Folded EGRET light curve for PSR J1105−6107 for E > 400 MeV.
– 25 –
Table 1. Summary of Known High-Energy γ-ray Pulsars and PSRs B1046−58 and
J1105−6107, ordered by τ .
Pulsara
Crab
Vela
B1706−44
B1046−58
J1105−6107
B1951+32
B0656+14
Geminga
B1055−52
P
ms
33
89
102
124
63
39
385
237
197
log τ b
log Bc
log Ed
yr
3.1
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.8
5.0
5.0
5.5
5.7
G
erg s−1 cm−2
12.6
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.0
11.7
12.7
12.2
12.0
38.7
36.8
36.5
36.3
36.4
36.6
34.6
34.5
34.5
de
kpc
2.0
0.5
1.8
3.0
7.1
2.4
0.8
0.157+0.059
−0.034
1.5
E/d2 f
rank
g
ηγ
%
1
2
4
9
23
6
20
3
39
0.013±0.006
0.18±0.07
0.72±0.47
1.1±0.3
< 1.4
0.26±0.17
∼0.1
1.61+0.22
−0.08
6–13
aPulsars in bold are the subject of this paper.
bτ ≡ P/2 P
cB ≡ 3.2 × 1019(P P )1/2 G
d E ≡ 4π2I P /P 3
eDistances from Taylor & Cordes (1993) except for Geminga which is from Caraveo et al.
(1996).
fRanked 5th is PSR B1509−58, detected in low-energy γ-rays (Ulmer et al. 1993); 7th is
the millisecond pulsar PSR J0437−4715; 8th is PSR J1617−5055, which was only recently
discovered (Torii et al. 1998, Kaspi et al. 1998).
gFor E > 100 MeV and 1 sr beaming, except for PSR B1046−58 which is for E > 400 MeV.
Uncertainties include nominal distance uncertainties. Numbers are from Fierro (1995) except
for Geminga, for which we have used the updated distance, PSR B0656+14, which is from
Ramanamurthy et al. (1996), and PSR B1055−52, which is from Thompson et al. (1999).
For PSR J1105−6107, the 3σ upper limit for duty cycle 0.5 is quoted.
– 26 –
Table 2. Summary of EGRET Observations for PSR B1046−58.
VPa
0007
0060
0080
0120
0140
0170
0230
0320
2080
2150
2170
2300
2305
3010
3140
3150
3160
3385
4020
4025
4150
4240
5220
5310
6270
6300
MJD Range
48386–48392
48463–48476
48490–48504
48546–48560
48574–48588
48617–48631
48700–48714
48798–48805
49020–49027
49078–49083
49089–49097
49195–49198
49198–49202
49216–49223
49355–49368
49368–49375
49375–49384
49595–49615
49643–49650
49650–49657
49818–49832
49908–49923
50245–50248
50359–50371
50693–50700
50714–50728
∆θb
◦
21.1
31.2
25.2
31.3
2.7
32.4
34.8
22.5
28.1
32.4
32.4
11.1
8.7
24.1
16.8
16.8
28.7
24.1
23.5
19.8
27.1
30.9
2.7
3.7
1.6
1.6
N(θ67)
Exposure
614
279
1032
235
3252
140
30
289
163
52
34
335
416
361
775
381
157
649
156
195
261
65
136
366
234
437
0.52
0.54
1.01
0.49
3.08
0.45
0.14
0.40
0.18
0.08
0.12
0.45
0.60
0.40
1.09
0.60
0.24
0.87
0.24
0.40
0.36
0.24
0.33
1.16
1.01
1.89
aEGRET Viewing Period.
bAngular offset of pulsar from center of EGRET field of view.
– 27 –
Table 3. Summary of EGRET Observations of PSR J1105−6107.
VPa
2300
2305
3010
3140
3150
3160
3385
4020
4025
4150
4240
5220
5310
6270
6300
MJD Range
49195–49198
49198–49202
49216–49223
49355–49368
49368–49375
49375–49384
49595–49615
49643–49650
49650–49657
49818–49832
49908–49923
50245–50248
50359–50371
50693–50700
50714–50728
∆θb
◦
14.0
11.8
27.0
13.7
13.7
26.9
27.0
20.4
16.7
28.0
28.9
5.0
6.7
3.6
3.6
N(θ67)
Exposure
293
412
245
826
420
213
430
201
226
213
114
128
304
205
419
0.38
0.52
0.30
1.32
0.71
0.27
0.67
0.32
0.31
0.35
0.28
0.32
0.99
0.96
1.81
aEGRET Viewing Period.
bAngular offset of pulsar from center of EGRET field of view.
|
astro-ph/0703630 | 2 | 0703 | 2007-06-09T06:57:31 | Statefinder diagnostic for the modified polytropic Cardassian universe | [
"astro-ph"
] | We apply the Statefinder diagnostic to the Modified Polytropic Cardassian Universe in this work. We find that the Statefinder diagnostic is quite effective to distinguish Cardassian models from a series of other cosmological models. The $s-r$ plane is used to classify the Modified Polytropic Cardassian models into six cases. The evolutionary trajectories in the $s-r$ plane for the cases with different $n$ and $\beta$ reveal different evolutionary properties of the universe. In addition, we combine the observational $H(z)$ data, the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data and the Baryonic Acoustic Oscillation (BAO) data to make a joint analysis. We find that \textbf{Case 2} can be excluded at the 68.3% confidence level and any case is consistent with the observations at the 95.4% confidence level. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Statefinder diagnostic for the modified polytropic Cardassian universe
Department of Astronomy, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, 100875, P.R.China
Ze-Long Yi and Tong-Jie Zhang∗
We apply the statefinder diagnostic to the modified polytropic Cardassian universe in this work.
We find that the statefinder diagnostic is quite effective to distinguish Cardassian models from a
series of other cosmological models. The s − r plane is used to classify the modified polytropic
Cardassian models into six cases. The evolutionary trajectories in the s − r plane for the cases with
different n and β reveal different evolutionary properties of the universe. In addition, we combine
the observational H(z) data, the cosmic microwave background data and the baryonic acoustic
oscillation data to make a joint analysis. We find that Case 2 can be excluded at the 68.3%
confidence level and any case is consistent with the observations at the 95.4% confidence level.
PACS numbers: 98.80.Es,95.35.+d,98.80.Jk
I.
INTRODUCTION
Recent type Ia Supernova observations, along with
other observations such as cosmic microwave background
(CMB) and galaxy power spectra, support the fact that
the present expansion of our universe is accelerating
[1, 2]. In order to explain the accelerated expansion of
the universe, cosmologists have tried to explore many
cosmological models. A negative pressure term called
dark energy is always taken into account, such as the cos-
mological constant model with equation of state ωDE =
pDE/ρDE = −1 where pDE and ρDE are pressure and den-
sity of the dark energy, respectively [3], the quiessence
whose equation of state ωQ is a constant between -1 and
-1/3 [4], and the quintessence which is described in terms
of a scalar field φ [5, 6]. Some other candidates are con-
structed in different ways, such as the braneworld models
which explain the acceleration through the fact that the
general relativity is formulated in 5 dimensions instead
of the usual 4 [7], and the Cardassian models which in-
vestigate the acceleration of the universe by a modifica-
tion to the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) equa-
tion [8].
In these cases, the dark energy component is
not involved, but the accelerated expansion can still be
obtained. The quantity ωeff is usually described as an
effective equation of state for these models, and can be
expressed by the Hubble parameter H and its derivatives
with respect to redshift z [4].
As so many cosmological models have been developed,
a discrimination between these contenders becomes nec-
essary. In order to achieve this aim, Sahni et al. proposed
a new geometrical diagnostic named the statefinder pair
{r, s}, where r is generated from the scalar factor a and
its derivatives with respect to the cosmic time t, just as
the Hubble parameter H and the deceleration parame-
ter q, and s is a simple combination of r and q [9]. The
statefinder pair has been used to discriminate a series of
cosmological models, including the LCDM universe with
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
a cosmological constant Λ and a cold dark matter term
(CDM), the Chaplygin gas, the holographic dark energy
models, the quintessence, the braneworld models and so
on. Clear differences for the evolutionary trajectories in
the s − r plane have been found.
In this paper, we apply the statefinder diagnostic to
the modified polytropic Cardassian universe. The origi-
nal Cardassian model based on two parameters Ωm0 and
n was first suggested by Freese & Lewis [8]. It was gen-
erated from a modification to the Friedmann equation.
Such a universe is spatially flat and accelerating today.
But it involves no dark energy term and is dominated
by merely matter and radiation. These Cardassian mod-
els predict the same distance-redshift relation as generic
quintessence models, although they generate from com-
pletely different physical principles. A generalized Car-
dassian model -- the modified polytropic Cardassian uni-
verse can be obtained by introducing an additional pa-
rameter β into this model [10, 11, 12], which reduces to
the original model if β = 1. The distance-redshift re-
lation predictions of generalized Cardassian models can
be very different from generic quintessence models, and
can be differentiated with data from surveys of Type
Ia Supernovae such as SuperNova/Acceleration Probe
(SNAP). In all, the modified polytropic Cardassian uni-
verse can predict more fresh physical information than
the original Cardassian.
It is worthy of more detailed
discussions.
In this work, we successfully classify the modified poly-
tropic Cardassian models into six cases by the statefinder
diagnostic. The cases with different n and β correspond
to different evolutionary trajectories in the s − r plane.
The fact that LCDM corresponds to a fixed point (0,
1) in the s − r plane plays a significant role for our
classification. Also, it is very important to find where
the evolutionary trajectories start and end. Another key
standpoint is whether the evolutionary trajectory has a
crossing with LCDM. We also study the relation between
(n, β) and the crossing redshift zC, at which the modified
polytropic Cardassian universe intersects with LCDM in
the s − r plane. We find that the modified polytropic
Cardassian models can be distinguished from other inde-
pendent cosmological models by the statefinder diagnos-
tic.
In addition, we use the observational H(z) data de-
rived from ages of the passively evolving galaxies [13], the
newly measured value of the CMB shift parameter R [14]
and the A-parameter which describes the baryonic acous-
tic oscillation (BAO) peak [15] to make a combinational
constraint. We assume a prior of H0 = 72 ± 8 suggested
by the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Key Project [16].
From the confidence regions, we find that Case 2 is not
consistent with the observations at the 68.3% confidence
level and all the six cases do not conflict with the obser-
vations at the 95.4% confidence level.
This paper is organized as follows: In Sec.2, we briefly
review the modified polytropic Cardassian universe. In
Sec.3, we introduce the statefinder pair {r, s}. In Sec.4,
we apply the statefinder diagnostic to various Cardassian
models.
In Sec.5, we make a combinational constraint
on the parameters of the modified polytropic Cardassian
universe. In Sec.6, the discussions and the conclusions
are given.
II. THE MODIFIED POLYTROPIC
CARDASSIAN UNIVERSE
Measurements of CMB suggest a flat geometry for our
If we consider a spatially flat FRW
universe [17, 18].
universe, the basic equation can be written as
H 2 =
8πG
3
ρ,
(1)
where G is Newton's universal gravitation constant and ρ
is the density of summation of both matter and vacuum
energy. Freese & Lewis [8] proposed a model called the
Cardassian universe by adding a term on the right side
of Eq.(1),
H 2 =
8πG
3
ρm + Bρn
m,
(2)
where n is assumed to satisfy n < 2/3 and ρm is always
taken as a contribution of only the matter (in this paper
we do not plan to consider radiation).
If n = 0, it is
identical to the cosmological constant universe. If B = 0,
it reduces to the usual FRW equation, but with density
of only matter. Thus, it is easy to get a new expression
of H from Eq.(2),
H 2 = H 2
0 [Ωm0(1 + z)3 + (1 − Ωm0)(1 + z)3n],
(3)
by using
ρm = ρm0(1 + z)3 = Ωm0ρc(1 + z)3,
(4)
where ρm0 is current value of ρm and ρc = 3H 2
0 /8πG
is the critical density of the universe. Clearly, this
model predict the same distance-redshift relation as the
quiessence with ωQ = n−1. But we notice that they have
completely different essentials. The quiessence requires a
dark energy component while the Cardassian does not.
2
In the earlier time, the universe is dominated by the
first term in Eq.(3) and the ordinary FRW behavior
works. The additional term which consists of only matter
gradually becomes a dominant driver afterwards. This
transition was found to occur at z ∼ O(1) [8]. Then the
universe is caused to accelerate. The period of accelera-
tion for this model is usually called the Cardassian era.
The Cardassian model is attractive because the universe
is flat and accelerating today but no vacuum energy is in-
volved. And it has been demonstrated compatible with
a series of observational tests, including the CMB data,
the age of the universe, the structure formation and the
cluster baryon fraction [8].
The modified polytropic Cardassian universe can be
obtained by introducing an additional parameter β into
the above model [10, 11, 12],
H 2 = H 2
0 [Ωm0(1 + z)3 + (1 − Ωm0)fX(z)],
(5)
where
fX(z) =
Ωm0
Ω−β
m0 − 1
1 − Ωm0
(1 + z)3[(1 +
(1 + z)3(1−n)β )1/β − 1].
(6)
The two parameters (n, β) are usually taken as n < 2/3
and β > 0. If β = 1, the model reduces to the original
one characterized by Eq.(3) while if fX(z) = 1, the model
just corresponds to LCDM.
Similar to Wang et al., we also take Ωm0 = 0.3 as a
prior in subsequent discussions.
In the work of Wang
et al., this model was compared with current supernova
data and CMB data.
It was proved that the existing
data can be well fit for several chosen values of n and
β. Also, the simulated data were constructed to make
a discrimination between the modified polytropic Car-
dassian universe and LCDM as well as the quintessence.
Once Ωm0 is known with an accuracy of 10%, SNAP
can determine the sign of the time dependence of dark
energy density which provides a first discrimination be-
tween various cosmological models [12]. In this work, we
use a geometrical tool-the statefinder diagnostic to make
a classification and a discrimination about the modified
polytropic Cardassian models.
III. A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE
STATEFINDER DIAGNOSTIC
The Hubble parameter H = a/a and the deceleration
parameter q = −a/aH 2 are two traditional geometrical
diagnostics. They only depend on the scalar factor a and
its derivatives with respect to t, i.e., a and a. Through
a = 1/(1 + z), the deceleration parameter q can be ex-
pressed as
q(z) =
H ′
H
(1 + z) − 1,
(7)
where H ′ is the derivative of H with respect to redshift
z. The deceleration parameter q is a good choice to de-
scribe the expansion state of our universe, but it is not
3
perfect enough to characterize the cosmological models
uniquely. This shortage can be easily seen from the fact
that many models may correspond to the same current
value of q. And this difficulty can be overcome by an-
other geometrical diagnostic -- the statefinder pair {r, s}.
This approach has been used to distinguish a series of
cosmological models successfully.
For a spatially flat universe, the statefinder r is defined
as follows [9]
the statefinder diagnostic in several literatures [4, 9]. In
the s − r plane, a vertical line with s = n and r changing
monotonically from 1 to 1 + 9n(n − 1)/2 represents the
evolutionary trajectory of the universe.
For cases with β 6= 1, we first pay our attention to
the epoches in the far past (a → 0) and the far future
(a → +∞).
It is clear that z → +∞ represents the
former case and z → −1 stands for the latter. From
Eq.(12), it is easy to find the limit condition
r =
···
a
aH 3 ,
(8)
lim
z→+∞
r(z) = 1,
(14)
···
a is the third derivative of a with respect to t. s
where
is just a combination of r and q,
s =
r − 1
3(q − 1/2)
.
(9)
The statefinder pair was first introduced to analyze a flat
universe with a cold matter and a dark energy term. For
these contenders, r is given by
r = 1 +
9
2
ωDE(1 + ωDE)ΩDE −
3
2
ωDE
H
ΩDE.
(10)
where ΩDE = ρDE/ρc and ωDE is the derivative of ωDE
with respect to t. And the other diagnostic,
s = 1 + ωDE −
1
3
ωDE
ωDEH
.
(11)
From the two equations above it is easy to realize that
LCDM corresponds to a fixed point (0, 1) in the s − r
plane and the standard cold dark matter (SCDM) uni-
verse with no dark energy term locates at (1, 1) forever.
For this particularity, the current values of {r, s} pro-
vide a considerable way to measure the distance from a
specific model to LCDM.
More generally, r and s can be given in terms of the
Hubble parameter H and its first and second derivatives
H ′ and H ′′ with respect to redshift z,
which means that the value of r in the far past is inde-
pendent on n and β. However, we can not derive the
similar properties for the value of s from Eq.(13). It is
related to both of n and β. For the limit of z → −1, from
Eq.(12), we get
lim
z→−1
r(z) = 1 +
9
2
n(n − 1).
(15)
And from Eq.(13), we have
lim
z→−1
s(z) = n.
(16)
The values of both s and r are independent on β.
Generally, some models have a crossing with LCDM in
the s − r plane. By substituting the Hubble parameter,
Eq.(5), in the expressions of r and s, Eq.(12) and Eq.(13),
we find that the crossing with LCDM happens at the
redshift
zC = [(Ω−β
m0 − 1)
−n
1 − β + nβ
1
3(1−n)β − 1.
]
(17)
And we notice that the crossing can happen only if the
following inequality is satisfied,
(Ω−β
m0 − 1)
−n
1 − β + nβ
≥ 0.
(18)
r(z) = 1 − 2
H ′
H
(1 + z) +
H ′′
H
+ (
H ′
H
)2,
(12)
Due to the prior Ωm0 = 0.3 and β > 0, Ω−β
m0 − 1 > 0 is
naturally satisfied. Thus we may describe the condition
in Eq.(18) equivalently as
s(z) =
−2H ′(1 + z)/H + H ′′/H + (H ′/H)2
3(H ′(1 + z)/H − 3/2)
.
(13)
Thus we can use the new tool to describe the evolutionary
trajectories of the modified polytropic Cardassian uni-
verse.
IV. THE s − r PLANE FOR MODIFIED
POLYTROPIC CARDASSIAN UNIVERSE
For the original Cardassian model with β = 1, it cor-
responds to a compatible expression with the quiessence
with ωQ = n − 1. The quiessence has been studied using
n
1 − β + nβ
≤ 0.
(19)
In order to understand the relation among n, β and
zC clearly, we draw a β − zC plane for several fixed n in
Fig.1. For n > 0, the crossing takes place at zC > 0 for
any β, and zC changes little for larger values of β. For
n < 0, whether zC > 0 or zC < 0 depends on the values
of β. And zC is nearly equal to -1 if β is small enough.
For the particular case which satisfies 1 − β + nβ = 0, the
expected crossing happens at zC → ∞. Clearly, n = 0
and β = 1/(1 − n) are the two critical conditions.
Now we use Eq.(19) to classify the modified polytropic
Cardassian universe. We draw an n − β plane in Fig.2
n=−0.5
n=−1.0
n=−1.5
n=−2.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
β
0.4
0.5
0.6
r
n=0.2
n=0.3
n=0.4
n=0.5
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
4
LCDM
SCDM
1.5
2
2.5
β
3
3.5
0
−1
−0.5
0
s
0.5
1
C
z
2
1
0
−1
0
C
z
4
3
2
1
0
FIG. 1: β − zC planes for n=-0.5, -1.0, -1.5 and -2.0 (the top
panel) as well as n=0.2, 0.3, 0.4 and 0.5 (the bottom panel).
3
2.5
2
β
1.5
1
0.5
0
−1
Case2
n<0 & β>1/(1−n)
Case4
0<n<2/3 & β >1/(1−n)
Case3 n=0
Case6
β=1/(1−n)
Case1
n<0 & 0<β<1/(1−n)
Case5
0<n<2/3 & 0<β<1/(1−n)
−0.8
−0.6
−0.4
−0.2
n
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
FIG. 2: n − β plane based on n and β. The vertical solid
line represents n = 0 (Case 3), and the declined solid curve
stands for β = 1/(1 − n) (Case 6).
and divide it into different regions by the critical curves
n = 0 and β = 1/(1 − n):
Case 1 n < 0 and 0 < β < 1/(1 − n);
Case 2 n < 0 and β > 1/(1 − n);
Case 3 n = 0;
Case 4 0 < n < 2/3 and β > 1/(1 − n);
Case 5 0 < n < 2/3 and 0 < β < 1/(1 − n);
Case 6 β = 1/(1 − n).
(20)
Case 1 (n < 0 and 0 < β < 1/(1 − n)): n=-0.5,
β=0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4 and 0.5 are taken for a qualitative
analysis. We plot the s − r plane in Fig.3. Although
the original Cardassian model with β = 1 is not involved
in this case, we still draw this curve for a comparison.
FIG. 3: s − r plane for Case 1. The star (0, 1) corresponds
to LCDM, the star (1, 1) SCDM and other dots the current
values of the Statefinder pair, i.e., (s0, r0) (also for subsequent
cases). And the solid curves from bottom to top correspond
to the evolutionary trajectories of n=-0.5, β=0.1, 0.2, 0.3,
0.4 and 0.5 respectively. The dot-dash curves represent the
critical case β = 2/3. For a comparison, the vertical dashed
line stands for the case of β = 1.
All the curves start at r = 1 and 0 < s < 1 on the
horizontal line, i.e., on the right of LCDM. After passing
by LCDM, they arrive at their common end (−0.5, 4.38)
in far future. And the crossing with LCDM happens at
zC=-0.999, -0.84, -0.50, -0.13 and 0.25 for β=0.1, 0.2, 0.3,
0.4 and 0.5 respectively. Particularly, the fixed point (0,
1) for LCDM just is the beginning point for the critical
case of β = 1/(1 − n) = 2/3.
Case 2 (n < 0 and β > 1/(1 − n)): To be consistent
with Case 1, we consider n = −0.5 again, but β=0.8,
1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 respectively. The s − r plane is plotted
in Fig.4. The crossing with LCDM never occurs for this
case. The vertical line s = n for the evolutionary trajec-
tory of β = 1 divides the whole plane into two parts. The
left part with n < s < 0 stands for 1/(1 − n) < β < 1 and
the right part with s < n corresponds to β > 1. And all
the evolutionary trajectories commence at one point with
r = 1. The same as Case 1, they arrive at (−0.5, 4.38)
in the end.
Case 3 (n = 0): We plot the s − r plane for β=0.3,
0.7, 1, 2, 3 and 4 in Fig.5 . One point with r = 1 acts as
the beginning point, and (0, 1) the common end. This
diagram is divided into two segments by the LCDM fixed
point, or equivalently the modified polytropic Cardassian
model with n = 0 and β = 1. The segment with r > 1
corresponds to β > 1 while the other segment with r < 1
corresponds to β < 1.
Case 4 (0 < n < 2/3 and β > 1/(1 − n)): The
s − r plane for n = 0.2, β=2, 3, 4 and 5 is plotted in
Fig.6. Clearly, all the curves start with r = 1 and s < 0,
and then pass by LCDM after an arc route. All the lat-
5
LCDM
SCDM
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
r
−6
−5
−4
−3
s
LCDMSCDM
−2
−1
0
1
0
−3
−2.5
−2
−1.5
−1
s
−0.5
0
0.5
1
r
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
FIG. 4: s − r plane for Case 2. The solid curves from right
to left correspond to the evolutionary trajectories of n=-0.5,
β=0.8, 2, 3, 4 and 5 respectively. And the vertical dashed
line stands for the case of β = 1. Same as Fig.3, the dot-dash
curve represents the critical case β = 2/3.
FIG. 6: s − r plane for Case 4. The solid curves from right to
left stand for the evolutionary trajectories of n = 0.2, β=2,
3, 4 and 5 respectively. The dot-dash curve represents the
critical case β = 5/4. For a comparison, the vertical dashed
line stands for the case of β = 1.
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
r
LCDM
SCDM
0
−3
−2.5
−2
−1.5
−1
s
−0.5
0
0.5
1
LCDM
1
SCDM
0.8
0.6
r
0.4
0.2
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
s
FIG. 5: s − r plane for Case 3. The solid curves from bottom
to top stand for β=0.3, 0.7, 2, 3 and 4 respectively. The case
of β = 1 just corresponds to the fixed point for LCDM, i.e.,
(0, 1).
FIG. 7: s − r plane for Case 5. The solid curves from right
to left correspond to the evolutionary trajectories of n=0.2,
β=0.3, 0.6, 0.9 and 1.1 respectively. And the vertical dashed
line stands for the case of β = 1. Same as Fig.6, the dot-dash
curve represents the critical case β = 5/4.
ter evolutionary parts of the trajectories nearly overlap
with each other. They are insensitive to β. The point
(0.2, 0.28) is the common end. The crossing redshifts
are not too far from each other for different values of β,
i.e., zC ≃ 0.3. It is interesting that the fixed point (0,
1) for LCDM is just the beginning point for the critical
case of β = 1/(1 − n) = 5/4. And the Cardassian mod-
els for this case can satisfy the weak energy condition
ω = pX/(ρm + ρX) > −1 although the effective equation
of state satisfies ωeff = pX/ρX < −1. weff < −1 is con-
sistent with many observations such as CMB and large
scale structure data [19, 20].
Case 5 (0 < n < 2/3 and 0 < β < 1/(1 − n)): Same
as Case 4, n = 0.2 is considered, but β=0.3, 0.6, 0.9,
1.0 and 1.1. We plot the s − r plane in Fig.7. All the
evolutionary trajectories start with r = 1 and s > 0.
They arrive at (0.2, 0.28) in the end, and never pass by
LCDM. The whole plane is divided into two parts by the
vertical line s = n (corresponding to the case of β = 1).
The left part satisfies 1 < β < 5/4 and β < 1 is satisfied
for the right.
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
r
LCDM
SCDM
−0.8
−0.6
−0.4
−0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
s
FIG. 8: s − r plane for Case 6. The point (0, 1) stands for
n = 0. Then n increases by a interval of 0.1 until 0.6 for
cases on the right of (0, 1) and n decreases by a interval of
0.1 until -0.5 for cases on the left of (0, 1). The other vertical
dashed lines stand for the evolutionary trajectories of cases
with β = 1 and different values of n.
Case 6 (β = 1/(1 − n)): This is another critical case
besides Case 3. n=-0.5, -0.4, -0.3, -0.2, -0.1, 0, 0.1,
0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5, and 0.6 are considered. For this case,
crossing with LCDM happens at zC → ∞. We plot the
s − r plane in Fig.8. All the evolutionary trajectories
start at LCDM in the past and end at (−1 + 3n/2, 1 +
9n(n − 1)/2) in the future.
We have successfully given a qualitative analysis to
the modified polytropic Cardassian universe from the
statefinder viewpoint and it has been classified into six
cases. A prior Ωm0 = 0.3 is adopted in this work. We also
take some other values of Ωm0 for comparison and notice
that Ωm0 is not a sensitive parameter for our analysis in
this work. And it has been clear that the s − r plane is
effective enough to discriminate the modified polytropic
Cardassian models. The fact that LCDM corresponds
to a fixed point (0, 1) in the s − r plane plays a signifi-
cant role for our classification. Whether the evolutionary
trajectory has a crossing with LCDM is our basic stand-
point. Also, the beginning points and the ending points
are both key factors for shapes of the evolutionary tra-
jectories.
V. DATA ANALYSIS FROM OBSERVATIONAL
H(z) DATA, CMB AND BAO
In order to understand the six cases above more clearly,
we use the observational H(z) data derived from the
passively evolving galaxies, the cosmic microwave back-
ground (CMB) shift parameter R and the A-parameter
which describes the baryonic acoustic oscillation (BAO)
peak to make a joint analysis.
6
The Hubble parameter H(z) depends on the differen-
tial age of the universe in this form
H(z) = −
1
1 + z
dz
dt
,
(21)
which provides a direct measurement for H(z) through a
determination of dz/dt. By using the differential ages of
passively evolving galaxies determined from the Gemini
Deep Deep Survey [21] and archival data [22, 23, 24, 25],
Simon et al. determined a set of observational H(z) data
in the range 0 . z . 1.8 and used them to constrain the
dark energy potential and its redshift dependence [13].
Yi & Zhang first first used them to analyze the holo-
graphic dark energy models and got a consistent result
with others [26].
The model-independent shift parameter R can be de-
rived from CMB data. It is defined as [14]
R = pΩm0Z zr
0
dz
E(z)
,
(22)
where E(z) = H(z)/H0 and zr = 1089 is the redshift
of recombination. From the three-year result of WMAP
[27], Wang & Mukherjee estimated R = 1.70 ± 0.03 [28].
Using a large spectroscopic sample of 46748 lumi-
nous red galaxies covering 3816 square degrees out to
z = 0.47 from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, Eisen-
stein et al. [15] successfully found the acoustic peaks in
the CMB anisotropy power spectrum, described by the
model-independent A-parameter,
A = pΩm0[
1
z1E1/2(z1) Z z1
0
dz
E(z)
]2/3,
(23)
where z1 = 0.35 is the redshift at which the acoustic scale
has been measured. Eisenstein et al. [15] suggested the
measured value of the A-parameter as A = 0.469 ± 0.017.
The best-fit parameters of the modified polytropic Car-
dassian universe can be determined by minimizing
[Hth(zi) − Hob(zi)]2
(R − 1.70)2
(A − 0.469)2
+
+
,
χ2 = Xi
σ2
i
0.032
0.0172
(24)
where Hth(zi) is the theoretical Hubble parameter at zi,
Hob(zi) is the observational Hubble parameter at zi and
σi is the corresponding 1σ error. We get the best-fit val-
ues n = −1.85 and β = 0.23, with χ2
min = 10.12. The
best-fit results correspond to Case 1. And the cross-
ing with LCDM in the s − r plane occurs at zC=0.32.
The current values of the diagnostics are s0=-0.19 and
r0=1.59. The confidence regions in the n − β plane are
plotted in Fig.9, from which we find that Case 2 can
be excluded at the 68.3% confidence level and all the six
cases are consistent with the observational data at the
95.4% confidence level.
VI. DISCUSSIONS AND CONCLUSIONS
The statefinder diagnostic is powerful to discriminate
various cosmological models. Differences of the evolu-
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
β
0
−1
−0.8
−0.6
−0.4
−0.2
n
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
FIG. 9: Confidence regions in the n − β plane for the joint
analysis (the regions from inner to outer stand for confidence
levels at 68.3%, 95.4% and 99.7% respectively). The vertical
solid line represents n = 0 (Case 3), and the declined solid
curve stands for β = 1/(1 − n) (Case 6).
tionary trajectories in the s − r plane among a series
of cosmological models have been found. For example,
LCDM corresponds to a fixed point (0, 1) and the point
(1, 1) represents SCDM. For the holographic dark energy
model with c = 1 [29], the curve in the s − r plane com-
mences at (2/3, 1) in the past and ends at LCDM in the
future, with s monotonically decreasing from 2/3 to 0 and
r first decreasing from 1 to a minimum value and then
rising to 1 [30]. Both the quintessence tracker models
(with tracker potentials V = V0/φα) and the Chaplygin
gas models have arc evolutionary trajectories, but in dif-
ferent regions [4, 31, 32]. The conditions −1 ≤ s ≤ 0
and r ≤ 1 are satisfied for the former cosmological model
while 0 ≤ s ≤ 1 and r ≥ 1 for the latter. The evo-
lutionary trajectories of the coupled quintessence models
have more complicated evolutionary properties [33]. And
quintessence models with other potentials were studied
by Evans et al.[31], also along with a generalization of
{r, s} to a non-flat universe.
Also, the q − r plane has been widely used for discus-
sion on the evolutionary property of the universe. For
example, the point (0.5, 1) corresponds to SCDM in the
q − r plane and the horizontal straight line from (0.5,
1) to (-1, 1) stands for LCDM. The braneworld models
have been studied too, including Disappearing Dark En-
ergy (DDE) as the simplest case [4]. LCDM separates the
first braneworld model (named BRANE1 in [4] and the
effective equation of state satisfies ωeff ≤ −1) from the
second braneworld model (named BRANE2 in [4] and the
effective equation of state satisfies ωeff ≥ −1) and DDE
models. DDE both begins and ends at SCDM, forming
a loop. However, although both BRANE1 and BRANE2
commence their evolutions at (0.5, 1) and end at (-1, 1),
the diagnostic r satisfies r ≥ 1 for BRANE1 while r ≤ 1
7
for BRANE2.
As the s − r plane has been found robust for our clas-
sification for the modified polytropic Cardassian models,
we do not intend to make use of the q − r plane. For
the modified polytropic Cardassian universe, the evolu-
tionary trajectories can be picked out easily with help
of the s − r plane if β 6= 1.
In fact, the original Car-
dassian model with β=1 can not be discarded from the
quiessence with ωQ = n − 1 because they correspond to
identical expressions for both r and s. Such a consistence
has also been mentioned by Freese & Lewis, as well as
how to distinguish the two models [8].
Distinct differences in the s − r plane have been real-
ized for the cases with different n and β for the modified
polytropic Cardassian universe. For Case 1 and Case 4,
the crossing with LCDM happens at some zC, while the
same state never occurs for Case 2 and Case 5. And
Case 3 and Case 6 just are two critical cases. Also, the
beginning points and the ending points are tightly related
to the shapes of the evolutionary trajectories. They se-
riously depend on n and β, especially n. As n and β
are found to be sensitive to the modified polytropic Car-
dassian models, constraining the two parameters exactly
becomes a valuable task. We use the observational H(z)
data, the CMB data and the BAO data to make a com-
binational constraint. We find that Case 2 can be ex-
cluded at the 68.3% confidence level and all the six cases
are consistent with the observational data at the 95.4%
confidence level. Recent other constraints suggest some
results far from consistent with each other. For example,
in the work of Wang et al., the choices of n = 0.2, β = 1;
n = 0.2, β = 2 and n = 0.2, β = 3 are all consistent
with SN Ia and CMB observations [12]. The first case
corresponds to the quiessence with the equation of state
ωQ = −0.8, and this case is consistent with Case 5. The
latter two cases with the crossing at zC=0.29 and 0.26
respectively are in agreement with Case 4. And the cur-
rent values of the diagnostics are s0=0.13, r0=0.58 and
s0=0.16, r0=0.45 for n = 0.2, β=2 and n = 0.2, β=3
respectively. Nesseris & Perivolaropoulos [34] suggested
another result n = −23+8
−0.010 with a super-
nova data set consisting of 194 SN Ia [35, 36]. Both Case
1 and Case 2 may be included within the given error-
bar. The best fitting values lie in Case 1 and the cross-
ing with LCDM happens at zC=0.37. Meanwhile, the
present quantities are s0=-0.29 and r0=1.94. Evans et
al. provided a best fitting result n = −0.94 and β = 0.06
with a simulated data set [31]. This result is in agreement
with Case 1. The crossing happens in the far future,
i.e., at zC=-0.999. And the current values s0=0.76 and
r0=0.54 indicate a large distance from LCDM. As con-
straints still remain weak, we expect for data with higher
precision to provide more consistent fitting results in fu-
ture. We also hope theses statefinder parameters can be
determined more exactly and shed light on the nature of
the cosmological models.
−9, β = 0.025+0.008
VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are very grateful to the anonymous referee for
his valuable comments that greatly improve this paper.
And we are also grateful to Xin Zhang for his helpful
suggestions. Z. L. Yi would like to thank Qiang Yuan
and Jie Zhou for their kind help. This work was sup-
ported by the National Science Foundation of China
(Grants No.10473002 and 10273003), the Scientific Re-
search Foundation for the Returned Overseas Chinese
Scholars.
8
[1] A. G. Riess, A. V. Filippenko, P. Challis, A. Clocchiattia,
A. Diercks, P. M. Garnavich, R. L. Gilliland, C. J. Hogan,
S. Jha, K. R. Kirshner, B. Leibundgut, M. M. Phillips,
D. Reiss, B. P. Schmidt, R. A. Schommer, R. C. Smith,
J. Spyromilio, C. Stubbs, N. B. Suntzeff and J. Tonry,
Astron. J. 116, 1009 (1998).
[2] S. Perlmutter, G. Aldering, G. Goldhaber, R. A. Knop,
P. Nugent, P. G. Castro, S. Deustua, S. Fabbro, A. Goo-
bar, D. E. Groom, I. M. Hook, A. G. Kim, M. Y. Kim,
J. C. Lee, N. J. Nunes, R. Pain, C. R. Pennypacker, R.
Quimby, C. Lidman, R. S. Ellis, M. Irwin, R. G. McMa-
hon, P. Ruiz-Lapuente, N. Walton, B. Schaefer, B. J.
Boyle, A. V. Filippenko, T. Matheson, A. S. Fruchter, N.
Panagia, H. J. M. Newberg and W. J. Couch, Astrophys.
J. 517, 565 (1999).
[3] S. M. Carroll, W. H. Press and E. L. Turner, Annu. Rev.
Astron. Astrophys. 30, 499 (1992).
[4] U. Alam, V. Sahni, T. D. Saini and A. A. Starobinsky,
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 344, 1057 (2003).
Stetson, Astrophys. J. 553, 47 (2001).
[17] N. W. Halverson, E. M. Leitch, C. Pryke, J. Kovac,
J. E. Carlstrom, W. L. Holzapfel, M. Dragovan, J. K.
Cartwright, B. S. Mason, S. Padin, T. J. Pearson, M. C.
Shepherd and A. C. S. Readhead, Astrophys. J. 568, 38
(2002).
[18] C. B. Netterfield, P. A. R. Ade, J. J. Bock, J. R. Bond,
J. Borrill, A. Boscaleri, K. Coble, C. R. Contaldi, B.
P. Crill, P. de Bernardis, P. Farese, K. Ganga, M. Gia-
cometti, E. Hivon, V. V. Hristov, A. Iacoangeli, A. H.
Jaffe, W. C. Jones, A. E. Lange, L. Martinis, S. Masi,
P. Mason, P. D. Mauskopf, A. Melchiorri, T. Montroy,
E. Pascale, F. Piacentini, D. Pogosyan, F. Pongetti, S.
Prunet, G. Romeo, J. E. Ruhl and F. Scaramuzzi, Astro-
phys. J. 571, 604 (2002).
[19] P. Schuecker, R. R. Caldwell, H. Bohringer, C. A. Collins,
L. Guzzo, N. N. Weinberg, Astron. Astrophys. 402, 53
(2003).
[20] A. Melchiorri, L. Mersini, C. J. Odman and M. Trodden,
[5] R. R. Caldwell, R. Dave and R. J. Steinhardt, Phys. Rev.
Phys. Rev. D 68, 043509 (2003).
Lett. 80, 1582 (1998).
[6] V. Sahni and L. M. Wang, Phys. Rev. D 62, 103517
(2000).
[7] C. Csaki, M. Graesser, L. Randall and J. Terning, Phys.
Rev. D 62, 045015 (2000).
[8] K. Freese and M. Lewis, Phys. Lett. B 540, 1 (2002).
[9] V. Sahni, T. D. Saini, A. A. Starobinsky and U. Alam,
JETP Lett. 77, 201 (2003).
[21] R. G. Abraham, K. Glazebrook, P. J. McCarthy, D.
Crampton, R. Murowinski, I. Jorgensen, K. Roth, I. M.
Hook, S. Savaglio, H. W. Chen, R. O. Marzke and R. G.
Carlberg, Astron. J. 127, 2455 (2004).
[22] T. Treu, P. Mφller, M. Stiavelli, S. Casertano and G.
Bertin, Astrophys. J. Lett. 564, L13 (2002).
[23] T. Treu, M. Stiavelli, P. Mφller, S. Casertano and G.
Bertin, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 326, 221 (2001).
[10] P. Gondolo and K. Freese, Phys. Rev. D 68, 063509
[24] L. A. Nolan, J. S. Dunlop, R. Jimenez and A. F. Heavens,
(2003).
[11] P. Gondolo and K. Freese, Phys. D hep-ph/0211397.
[12] Y. Wang, K. Freese, P. Gondolo and M. Lewis, Astro-
phys. J. 594, 25 (2003).
Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 341, 464 (2003).
[25] P. L. Nolan, W. F. Tompkins, I. A. Grenier and P. F.
Michelson, Astrophys. J. 597, 615 (2003).
[26] Z. L. Yi and T. J. Zhang, Mod. Phys. Lett. A. 22, 41
[13] J. Simon, L. Verde and R. Jimenez, Phys. Rev. D 71,
(2007).
123001 (2005).
[14] C. J. Odman, A. Melchiorri, M. P. Hobson and A. N.
Lasenby, Phys. Rev. D 67, 083511 (2003).
[15] D. J. Eisenstein, I. Zehavi, D. W. Hogg, R. Scoccimarro,
M. R. Blanton, R. C. Nichol, R. Scranton, H. Seo, M.
Tegmark, Z. Zheng, S. Anderson, J. Annis, N. Bahcall,
J. Brinkmann, S. Burles, F. J. Castander, A. Connolly,
I. Csabai, M. Doi, M. Fukugita, J. A. Frieman, K. Glaze-
brook, J. E. Gunn, J. S. Hendry, G. Hennessy, Z. Ivezic,
S. Kent, G. R. Knapp, H. Lin, Y . Loh, R. H. Lupton, B.
Margon, T. McKay, A. Meiksin, J. A. Munn, A. Pope,
M. Richmond, D. Schlegel, D. Schneider, K. Shimasaku,
C. Stoughton, M. Strauss, M. SubbaRao, A. S. Szalay, I.
Szapudi, D. Tucker, B. Yanny and D. York, Astrophys.
J. 633, 560 (2005).
[16] W. L. Freedmann, B. F. Madore, B. K. Gibson, L. Fer-
rarese, D. D. Kelson, S. Sakai, J. R. Mould, R. C. Ken-
nicutt, Jr., H. C. Ford, J. A. Graham, J. P. Huchra, S.
M. G. Hughes, G. D. Illingworth, L. M. Macri and P. B.
[27] D. N. Spergel, R. Bean, O. Dore, M. R. Nolta, C. L.
Bennett, G. Hinshaw, N. Jarosik, E. Komatsu, L. Page,
H. V. Peiris, L. Verde, C. Barnes, M. Halpern, R. S.
Hill, A. Kogut, M. Limon, S. S. Meyer, N. Odegard, G.
S. Tucker, J. L. Weiland, E. Wollack and E. L. Wright.
astro-ph/0603449.
[28] Y. Wang and P. Mukherjee, Astrophys. J. 650, 1 (2006).
[29] A. G. Cohen, D. B. Kaplan and A. E. Nelson, Phys. Rev.
Lett. 82, 4971 (1999).
[30] X. Zhang, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 14, 1597 (2005).
[31] A. K. D. Evans, I. K. Wehus, O. Gron and O. Elgaroy,
Astron. Astrophys. 430, 399 (2005).
[32] V. Gorini, A. Kamenshchik and U. Moschella, Phys. Rev.
D 67, 063509 (2003).
[33] X. Zhang, Phys. Lett. B 611, 1 (2005).
[34] S. Nesseris and L. Perivolaropoulos, Phys. Rev. D 70,
043531 (2004).
[35] J. L. Tonry, B. P. Schmidt, B. Barris, P. Candia, P. Chal-
lis, A. Clocchiatti, A. L. Coil, A. V. Filippenko, P. Gar-
navich, C. Hogan, S. T. Holland, S. Jha, R. P. Kirshner,
K. Krisciunas, B. Leibundgut, W. D. Li, T. Matheson,
M. M. Phillips, A. G. Riess, R. Schommer, R. C. Smith,
J. Sollerman, J. Spyromilio, C. W. Stubbs and N. B.
Suntzeff, Astrophys. J. 594, 1 (2003).
[36] B. J. Barris, J. Tonry, S. Blondin, P. Challis, R.
Chornock, A. Clocchiatti, A. Filippenko, P. Garnavich,
S. Holland, S. Jha, R. Kirshner, K. Krisciunas, B. Lei-
9
bundgut, W. D. Li, T. Matheson, G. Miknaitis, A. Riess,
B. Schmidt, R. C. Smith, J. Sollerman, J. Spyromilio,
C. Stubbs, N. Suntzeff, H. Aussel, K. C. Chambers, M.
S. Connelley, D. Donovan, J. P. Henry, N. Kaiser, M.
C. Liu, E. L. Martin and R. J. Wainscoat, Astrophys. J.
602, 571 (2004).
|
astro-ph/9808019 | 1 | 9808 | 1998-08-03T21:47:23 | Magnetic field estimation in Cyg X-3's jet | [
"astro-ph"
] | Multi-wavelength photometric observations of Cygnus X-3 were carried out at 18 cm through to 450 um, complemented by X-ray (2-10 keV) observations. The system was mildly active with cm fluxes at 150 -- 250 mJy. We find the spectrum to be flat with a spectral index of zero. Using a modified Wolf-Rayet wind model, and assuming emission is generated in synchrotron emitting jets from the source, we find an upper-limit to the magentic field of 20 G at a distance of $5 \times 10^{12}$ cm is required. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Magnetic field estimation in Cyg X-3's jet
R.N. Ogleya, S.J. Bell Burnella, R.P. Fenderb, G.G. Pooleyc,
E.B. Waltmand, M. van der Klisb
aDepartment of Physics, The Open University, Walton Hall, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, UK
bAstronomical Institute 'Anton Pannekoek', University of Amsterdam, 1098 SJ Amsterdam, The Netherlands
cMRAO, Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, CB3 0HE, UK
dRemote Sensing Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Code 7210, Washington, DC 20375-5351, USA
Abstract
Multi-wavelength photometric observations of Cygnus X-3 were carried out at 18 cm through to 450 µm,
complemented by X-ray (2-10 keV) observations. The system was mildly active with cm fluxes at 150 -- 250
mJy. We find the spectrum to be flat with a spectral index of zero. Using a modified Wolf-Rayet wind model,
and assuming emission is generated in synchrotron emitting jets from the source, we find an upper-limit to the
magnetic field of 20 G at a distance 5 × 1012 cm is required.
1. Introduction / History
Cygnus X-3 is an unusual binary: a neutron star (or black hole) and Wolf-Rayet-like secondary in a
4.8 hr period. This system flares at sporadic intervals, with various flux increases, but generally returns
to a quiescent level of ∼100 mJy. The system has bipolar jets, and it is generally assumed these jets
are composed of synchrotron-emitting electrons. Because of the wind, the synchrotron emission, which
is by far the dominant emission at radio wavelengths, becomes optically thin at increasing distance with
increasing wavelength. The sub-mm emission is relatively unexplored; Fender et al. [1995] first detected
the emission, and found excessively high fluxes compared with an extrapolation from the radio. The cm
wavelength data has been analysed by Waltman et al. [1996]. Behaviour at these wavelengths is due to
synchrotron emission in a modified Wolf-Rayet wind. We use these previous observations as a starting
point for our models.
2. Observations
All data were taken during 1997 September 27, MJD 50717, and observations were arranged in order
to observe the source as close in time as possible.
Fig. 1 shows the long-term variation of Cyg X-3 from the Green Bank Interferometer (GBI) programme,
from MJD 50400 to MJD 50860 (1996 November -- 1998 February), with an insert showing the variability
of the source around the time of our SCUBA observations. One can see that, although a couple of
major flares occurred (MJD 50485, 50610), these have no effect on our data. The system seems to have
undergone a minor flare event around MJD 50700, and was experiencing a state of unrest during our
observations, as it returned to quiescence.
Fig. 2 shows the cm variability around the time of the SCUBA observations. The top panel is from
the Ryle telescope at 2.0 cm and the bottom panel is from the GBI at 3.6 cm and 13 cm. The time of
1
Fig. 1. Flux history of Cyg X-3 from 1996 November to 1998 February at 13 cm. An insert from MJD 50700
to MJD 50770 is shown; our data was taken on MJD 50717. Although no major flares immediately precede the
observations, the system appears to be relaxing after a minor flare -- leading to small-scale variations.
the SCUBA observations is shown by the arrow in both plots. Fig. 3 shows the sub-mm variability from
SCUBA. The top panel (a) is 850 µm, the bottom panel (b) is 2.0 mm. The 450 µm datum is not shown
because poor weather prevented a reliable detection (our formal mean for the 120 minutes of integration
at this wavelength is 80 ± 77 mJy).
Because of the variability inherent in the source, the spectrum is not apparent. We use the mean flux
densities over the whole of the observing times shown in figures 2 and 3 to produce an average spectrum,
detailed in table 1 and Fig. 4. Errors are 1σ deviations from the mean. The datum at 450 µm is included
for reference.
Table 1
Time-averaged flux densities
Telescope
Wavelength
Flux (mJy)
Green Bank Interferometer
13 cm
120 ± 10
3.6 cm
200 ± 40
Ryle
2.0 cm
186 ± 32
JCMT SCUBA
2.0 mm
144 ± 18
850 µm
150 ± 46
450 µm
80 ± 77
2
Fig. 2. Cyg X-3 photometry at radio wavelengths.
The top panel is Ryle telescope data at 2.0 cm. The
bottom panel is from the GBI, square points are at
3.6 cm and triangles are at 13 cm. The observations
by SCUBA are shown by the arrow.
Fig. 3. Photometry at mm and sub-mm wavelengths.
The top panel is at 850 µm, and the bottom panel is
at 2.0 mm.
The best fit including all the data is shown by a solid line and has a zero spectral index (within errors).
We favour a model in which the electrons in the jet are emitting synchrotron radiation, and in which the
wind becomes optically thin to the longer wavelengths at larger distances from the central source. Using
a stellar wind model with the parameters given in Waltman et al.
[1996], the radii at which emission
becomes optically thin are 1.5 × 1014, 6 × 1013, 4 × 1013 and 5 × 1012 cm for 13, 3.6, 2.0 cm and 850 µm
respectively. We assume material in the jet is observed at these, and increasing, distances from the core
as the surrounding material becomes optically thin. Electrons emitting at 850µm would take 2000 s to
travel a distance of 5 × 1012 cm (assuming a jet velocity of 0.3 c), and this places a lower-limit to their
age. Since no spectral change occurs at this wavelength, we conclude that the high energy electrons have
not aged in this time, placing an upper-limit on the magnetic field of ≤ 20 G at that distance. A higher
magnetic field would create a spectral change at the shorter wavelengths.
3
Fig. 4. Spectrum from the time averaged data. The solid line is the best fit to all the wavelengths.
References
Waltman, E.B., Foster, R.S., Pooley, G.G., Fender, R.P., Ghigo, F.D., 1996, AJ, 112, 2690
Fender R.P., Bell Burnell, S.J., Garrington, S.J., Spencer, R.E., Pooley, G.G., 1995, MNRAS, 290, L65
4
|
astro-ph/0101137 | 1 | 0101 | 2001-01-09T18:14:37 | Millimeter observations of radio-loud active galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | In order to study the nature of the far-infrared emission observed in radio-loud active galaxies, we have obtained 1.2 mm observations with the IRAM 30 m telescope for a sample of eight radio-loud active galaxies. In all objects we find that the 1.2 mm emission is dominated by non-thermal emission. An extrapolation of the non-thermal radio spectrum indicates that the contribution of synchrotron emission to the far-infrared is less than 10% in quasars, and negligible in the radio galaxies. The quasars in the sample show signs of relativistic beaming at millimeter wavelengths, and the quasar 3C334 shows evidence for strong variability. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
ASTRONOMY
AND
ASTROPHYSICS
Millimeter observations of radio-loud active galaxies
Ilse M. van Bemmel1,2 and Frank Bertoldi3
1 European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschildstr. 2, D -- 85748 Garching bei Munchen
2 Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, P.O. Box 800, NL -- 9700 AV Groningen
3 Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hugel 69, D-53121 Bonn
1
0
0
2
n
a
J
9
1
v
7
3
1
1
0
1
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Received date; accepted date
Abstract. In order to study the nature of the far-infrared
emission observed in radio-loud active galaxies, we have
obtained 1.2 mm observations with the IRAM 30 m tele-
scope for a sample of eight radio-loud active galaxies. In
all objects we find that the 1.2 mm emission is dominated
by non-thermal emission. An extrapolation of the non-
thermal radio spectrum indicates that the contribution
of synchrotron emission to the far-infrared is less than
10% in quasars, and negligible in the radio galaxies. The
quasars in the sample show signs of relativistic beaming
at millimeter wavelengths, and the quasar 3C 334 shows
evidence for strong variability.
Key words: galaxies: active -- galaxies:photometry --
quasars: general -- infrared: general -- infrared: galaxies
-- radio continuum: galaxies
1. Introduction
Photometry from radio to infrared wavelengths has shown
that double-lobed radio-loud quasars show deep minima
in their spectral energy distributions at millimeter wave-
lengths (Antonucci et al. 1990), which indicates that the
radio emission arises from components which cannot be
related to the infrared emission. However, the nature of
the far-infrared emission observed in double-lobed radio
sources remains unclear. Most evidence (Haas et al. 1998,
Polletta et al. 2000, and references therein) points at a
thermal nature of the infrared emission, although a possi-
ble contribution from relativistically beamed, non-thermal
emission has not yet been carefully determined. Relativis-
tic beaming can play an important role in the infrared
emission of quasars, in which the relativistic jet is oriented
closer to the line of sight (Barthel 1989). In radio-galaxies
however, beaming is thought to have a negligible effect
(Hoekstra et al. 1997).
The significance of beaming may be estimated by ex-
trapolating the radio core spectra to infrared wavelengths.
offprint
Send
[email protected])
requests
to:
Ilse
van Bemmel
(bem-
The non-thermal emission from the radio lobes can be
safely neglected, as these have no bulk relativistic motions
and thus show no beaming. However, the exact shape of
the core spectrum is unknown at high frequencies.
In order to improve the quality of the extrapolation
of the non-thermal spectrum, we measured 1.2 mm con-
tinuum fluxes for eight 3CR objects, of which seven have
been observed with ISOPHOT on board ISO (Lemke et al.
1996; Kessler et al. 1996) and with the NRAO Very Large
Array (VLA) (van Bemmel et al. 2000). We here compare
the 1.2 mm fluxes with the integrated radio and infrared
data, and for the quasars in the sample, with their radio
core spectra.
The general properties of our objects are listed in Ta-
ble 1. The sample consists of three radio-loud quasars
(QSR), two broad-line radio galaxies (BLRG), one narrow-
line radio galaxy (NLRG) and the radio structure 3C 59.
The latter was previously misidentified with the Seyfert 1
galaxy RBS 0281. The maps of Meurs & Unger (1991)
show three components: a north-western source (the origi-
nal 3C 59), a central source associated with RBS 0281, and
a south-eastern source. 3C 59 has no optical counterpart,
so it is either a lobe of RBS 0281, or a background core-
dominated quasar. With ISOPHOT only RBS 0281 was
observed. We shall refer to the Seyfert galaxy as RBS 0281,
and to the north-eastern hotspot/background object as
3C 59.
2. Observations and data reduction
2.1. IRAM 30 m
Continuum observations at 1.2 mm (250 GHz) were ob-
tained between 12 and 15 December 1999 with the Max-
Planck Millimeter Bolometer (MAMBO; Kreysa et al.
1998) at the IRAM 30 m telescope on Pico Veleta, Spain
(Baars et al. 1987). MAMBO is a 37-element bolometer
array, sensitive between 190 and 315 GHz. The half peak
sensitivity range is 210 -- 290 GHz, with an effective band-
pass center, somewhat dependent on the spectral slope of
the observed emission, at 250 GHz. The beam for the feed
horn of each bolometer is matched to the telescope beam
of 10.6′′, and the bolometers are arranged in a hexagonal
2
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
Name
3C 33.1
3C 59
RBS 0281
3C 67
3C 277.1
3C 323.1
3C 334
3C 460
IAU
B1950
0106+729
0204+293
0204+293
0221+276
1250+568
1545+210
1618+177
2318+235
z
type
L178
[W/Hz]
0.181 BLRG
--
?
0.110
Sey1
0.310 BLRG
QSR
0.321
0.264
QSR
0.555
QSR
0.268 NLRG
26.89
24.01
--
27.28
27.24
27.13
27.88
27.08
size
[′′]
227
∼ 4
∼ 1
2.5
1.7
69
58
8
Table 1. Basic properties of the observed objects. Types
are: NLRG = narrow-line radio galaxy, BLRG = broad
line radio galaxy, QSR = radio quasar, Sey1 = Seyfert
1, ? = unknown. We adopt the most common classifica-
tion in the literature. L178 assumes H0 = 75 km s−1 Mpc−1,
∝ ν−1. The last column lists the size of the
q0 = 0.5 and Fν
radio structure associated with the object, only the central
component size is given for RBS 0281.
pattern with a beam separation of 22′′. Observations were
made in standard on-off mode, with 2 Hz chopping of the
secondary reflector by 32′′. The pointing accuracy is typi-
cally 2′′. The target was centered on the central bolometer
of the array, and after each 10 seconds of integration, the
telescope was nodded so that the previous "off" beam be-
comes the "on" beam. Each scan of twelve 10 second sub-
scans lasts 3 minutes, of which 1 minute integration falls
on the sources, 1 minute off source, and 1 minute is used
to move the telescope and start the integration. Typically
15 to 20 of such scans were performed for each object.
Gain calibration was performed using observations of
Mars, Uranus, and Ceres, resulting in a flux calibration
factor of 12500 counts per Jansky, which we estimate to
be accurate to 15%. A sky opacity correction factor was
measured every 2 hours through total power sky dips.
The data were analyzed using the MOPSI software
package (Zylka 1998). For each bolometer the temporally
correlated variation of the sky signal (sky-noise) was com-
puted using the signals of neighbouring bolometers. The
correlated noise is iteratively determined for each channel
and subtracted.
Due to unintentional mispointing,
for 3C 59 and
RBS 0281 the targeted positions differ from the radio po-
sitions in the maps of Meurs & Unger (1991, see also Ta-
ble 2). A signal is measured at the targeted position to-
ward RBS 0281, which however is 10′′ off the radio peak,
so that the millimeter flux from the peak radio position
could well be higher than observed. Toward 3C 59, a 7 mJy
signal was picked up by an off-center channel, closely cor-
responding to the position of component D in the Meurs
& Under radio map. Since the chances of observing a
background source are very small, we assume that the off-
center channel detects 3C 59, but also here the peak flux
Object
3C 59
Position of
RA (2000) DEC (2000)
MAMBO target
radio peak
detection
RBS 0281 MAMBO target
radio peak
02 07 09.6
02 07 10.1
02 07 09.7
02 07 02.3
02 07 02.2
29 31 24
29 31 45.1
29 31 44
29 30 55.1
29 30 46.8
Table 2. Observed positions for 3C 59 and RBS 0281: cen-
tral channel position and the peak flux positions in the
Meurs & Unger (1991) maps are given. For 3C 59 we also
list the position at which the signal is detected.
could be higher than the observed flux. Since the MAMBO
fluxes toward RBS 0281 and 3C 59 are uncertain, we will
not make use of them in the analysis. They will be re-
measured in a future observing campaign.
2.2. Radio and infrared data
We collected radio fluxes for our objects from the
NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED). Where
available, we adopt those given at 178 MHz, 1.4 GHz,
2.7 GHz, and 4.9 GHz. For the three quasars additional
fluxes from the unresolved core are available at 4.9, 15,
25 and 43 GHz from a previous programme (van Bemmel
et al. 2000, hereafter BBG). For RBS 0281 only one radio
point was found.
The infrared data were obtained with ISOPHOT, using
the P1, P2, C100 and C200 detectors in raster-mapping
mode. A detailed description of the data reduction is given
in BBG, including a list of the resulting flux densities.
ISOPHOT data are available at 60, 90 and 160 µm for all
objects except 3C 59. For 3C 33.1 and RBS 0281 we have
additional ISOPHOT data at 12 and 25 µm. For 3C 323.1
an upper limit at 10 µm was obtained by Rieke & Low
(1972).
3. Results
Table 3 lists the radio and millimeter flux densities. The
radio fluxes are integrated fluxes, which include the lobes
and other extended structures. The millimeter fluxes only
include the part of the object within the IRAM 30 m tele-
scope beam. The resulting spectral energy distributions
(SED) are plotted in Fig. 1, along with the radio flux den-
sities of the unresolved core emission for the quasars.
The 1.2 mm flux densities are always lower than the
infrared and the integrated radio flux densities, consistent
with observations by Antonucci et al. (1990). They found
that quasars show a minimum in their SEDs at millimeter
wavelengths. We obtained similar results for radio galax-
ies. The millimeter flux densities are even lower than the
fluxes expected from an extrapolation of the integrated ra-
dio spectra, which we show as dashed lines in Fig. 1. For
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
3
Name
178 MHz
1.4 GHz
2.7 GHz
3C 33.1
3C 59
RBS 0281
3C 67
3C 277.1
3C 323.1
3C 334
3C 460
(Jy)
11.4±0.9
5.3±1.0
--
9.0±1.1
8.9±0.9
10.0±1.3
10.9±0.8
8.1±1.0
(Jy)
--
1.60±0.03
0.026±0.002
3.10±0.09
2.50±0.09
2.45±0.12
2.20±0.11
1.60±0.08
(Jy)
--
--
--
--
1.56±0.06
1.50±0.08
1.00±0.05
0.90±0.05
4.9 GHz
(mJy)
820±62
670±87
--
860±113
880±90
840±112
500±76
440±59
250 GHz
(mJy)
6±2
(7±1)
(> 3)
10.3±0.7
20.6±1.5
13.5±0.9
<4
4.3±1.2
Table 3. NED archive radio fluxes Sν and newly obtained MAMBO 250 GHz fluxes for our sample. Additional data
can be found in van Bemmel et al. (2000). Brackets indicate an off-center detection.
this extrapolation we fitted a power law to the radio data
with ν > 1 GHz. In cases where a flux was available at
only one frequency, we use the average slope of the other
objects, excluding 3C 59 and RBS 0281 though.
Half of the objects in our sample have radio sizes
larger than the 10.6′′ beam of the IRAM 30 m telescope at
1.2 mm. In these cases a direct comparison with the radio
data may not be meaningful, unless we assume that the ra-
dio lobes are not contributing to the millimeter emission
(see section 4.3). For the quasars, core radio fluxes are
available at even higher resolution (1 -- 2′′). The core radio
SED shows no obvious relation to the millimeter fluxes,
except maybe for 3C 323.1, where the core and millimeter
fluxes show a typical self-absorbed synchrotron spectrum.
To test whether the millimeter flux could arise from a
cold, thermal component that also gives rise to the 160 µm
emission, we fit an optically thin grey-body spectrum to
the far-infrared flux, using a dust emissivity index β = 1.6.
This value is an average of observed values in nearby active
and normal galaxies. To be conservative, we adopted dust
temperatures of 20 K, which is even colder than the coldest
dust found in active galaxies with ISO (e.g. Siebenmorgen
et al. 1999). The temperature is typical for dust in Galac-
tic clouds and cirrus. The dust masses implied by such a
cold component range from a few 107 to several 108 M⊙.
From the extrapolated grey-body spectra it appears that
the millimeter flux is dominated by non-thermal emission.
In 3C 460, e.g., the 1.2 mm flux could be dominated by
thermal dust emission if β < 1.4 or T < 16, but then the
implied dust mass would be larger than 5 × 108 M⊙. Such
a large dust mass is hard to reconcile with 3C 460 being
an elliptical galaxy. There is only circumstantial evidence
for a very cold dust component (T < 15 K) in galaxies.
Starbursts and active galaxies do not show very cold dust
emission at millimeter wavelengths.
3C 334 is probably a variable millimeter source. Previ-
ous observations with the Owens Valley Radio Observa-
tory found a 3 mm flux density of 37 ±2 mJy (van Bemmel
∝ ν−1, a 1.2 mm flux of 15 mJy
et al. 1998). Assuming Fν
would be expected, much higher than our upper limit of
Name
3C 33.1
3C 59
RBS 0281
3C 67
3C 277.1
3C 323.1
3C 334
3C 460
QSR average
RG average
log L250
α178
1.4
α1.4
4.9
23.61
--
(>22.86)
24.33
24.67
24.30
<24.46
23.82
24.49
23.92
--
--
-0.61
-0.64
--
-0.52
-0.62
-0.68
-0.78
-0.79
-0.69
-0.65
--
-1.02
-0.83
-0.85
-1.18
-1.03
-0.96
-1.03
α4.9
250
-1.28
(-1.18)
(>-0.42)∗
-1.15
-0.97
-1.07
<-1.25
-1.2
-1.02
-1.21
Table 4. Monochromatic 250 GHz luminosities
(in
W Hz−1) and radio spectral indices. Brackets indicate an
off-center detection. (∗) for RBS 0281 α1.4
250 is given instead
of α4.9
250.
3 mJy. 3C 334 is known to be variable at 4.85 GHz, with
variations of order 10% over a few decades (van Bemmel
et al. 1998). Variability tends to increase at higher fre-
quencies, but one would not expect a dramatic change in
flux such as implied by the OVRO and MAMBO measure-
ments.
3.1. Luminosities and spectral indices
Adopting H0 = 75, q0 = 0.5, and kΛ = 0, we computed lu-
minosity densities in order to compare the millimeter lu-
minosities of quasars and radio galaxies (Table 4). 3C 59
is excluded, because its redshift has not yet been deter-
mined. Although we find that the infrared luminosities are
comparable between the classes, there is evidence that the
quasars are brighter at 1.2 mm than the radio galaxies. At
178 MHz the quasars are only marginally brighter.
The sample is too small to draw firm conclusions,
but it appears that the stronger millimeter emission from
quasars may be due to a beamed component. When com-
paring the integrated flux at 178 MHz and 1.4 GHz, the
quasars are a factor 1.5 brighter than the radio galaxies.
4
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
Fig. 1. Rest frame spectral energy distributions of the objects observed with MAMBO. For 3C 59 we assume z = 0.
Filled circles show the total integrated radio fluxes, open circles show the unresolved core radio fluxes, the filled
diamond the MAMBO 1.2 mm fluxes, and open diamonds are ISOPHOT fluxes. The solid lines represent grey-body
T = 20 K spectra, matching the 160 µm fluxes. The dashed lines are power law fits to > 1 GHz integrated radio data.
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
5
In case of isotropic synchrotron emission over the whole
radio spectrum, this factor should be constant. However, it
appears to increase toward higher frequencies; at 250 GHz
the quasars are about three times brighter than the ra-
dio galaxies. This indicates that we observe an additional
component, which is unlikely to be due to dust emission,
since that would be optically thin and therefore also vis-
ible in the radio galaxies. For synchrotron emission, the
excess can only be beamed emission, which causes a natu-
ral anisotropy. It would be desirable to confirm this trend
with a larger sample.
There is clear evidence of spectral steepening of the
radio spectrum towards millimeter wavelengths. The av-
erage spectral index for the entire sample ranges from −0.7
at the lowest frequency to −1.2 at millimeter wavelengths
(Table 4). Spectral steepening occurs in most objects in
our sample, irrespective of their size or the resolution of
the observations.
4. Discussion
4.1. Nature of the millimeter and far-infrared emission
We find that the 1.2 mm flux densities are well below those
expected from an extrapolation of the total radio flux den-
sities. If cold dust gives rise to the millimeter emission,
then the millimeter flux densities are expected to lie above
the extrapolated radio spectra, and the grey-body extra-
polation should fit the observed flux. In our data the oppo-
site is true, and therefore the millimeter emission is proba-
bly dominated by synchrotron emission, except maybe for
3C 460, where this case is not so clear.
Since the far-infrared fluxes are more than an order
of magnitude higher than the millimeter fluxes, the far-
infrared emission is likely to arise from dust. The clear
minimum of the SED at millimeter wavelengths excludes
that the far-infrared emission is the continuation of the
radio synchrotron spectrum of the radio lobes or the core.
If the far-infrared emission were due to synchrotron
radiation, it would have to arise from a very young elec-
tron population. The younger the electrons, the closer they
must be to the core, so that their emission would be even
more strongly beamed than synchrotron emission at mil-
limeter wavelengths. As a consequence, the quasars should
be brighter than radio galaxies at infrared wavelengths,
for which there is no evidence in our data. Instead we
find that in the infrared the quasars and radio galaxies
are comparably bright, while at 1.2 mm the quasars are
clearly brighter than the radio galaxies.
The possible contribution of relativistically beamed
synchrotron emission to the far-infrared emission is es-
timated by extrapolating the radio SED. This yields on
average a less than 10% contribution in quasars, and a
less than 1% contribution in radio galaxies. Although in
3C 323.1 the core radio spectrum would extrapolate well
to the observed far-infrared fluxes, the 1.2 mm emission
falls below this extrapolation, indicating a turnover in the
core spectrum, which excludes a significant contribution
of non-thermal emission to the far-infrared.
An earlier study of the infrared emission from radio-
loud active galaxies indicated that quasars are signifi-
cantly brighter at 60 µm than radio galaxies (Heckman
et al. 1992). This does not contradict what we find from
our sample. The objects in the Heckman sample have an
average redshift ∼ 0.5 − 0.9, thus in their rest frame the
emission emerges at ∼ 30 − 40 µm. If the infrared emission
arises from a circumnuclear torus, the dust is likely to be
optically thick up to 60 µm (Pier & Krolik 1992, Granato
& Danese 1994), and the emerging flux depends on the ori-
entation of the torus. According to these models, the ob-
served flux could vary by orders of magnitude, depending
on the torus' optical depth. However, ISOPHOT studies
(BBG) show no conclusive evidence that quasars are in-
trinsically brighter in the far-infrared than radio galaxies,
when they are matched in radio power and redshift.
4.2. Relativistic beaming in quasars
Unified models for radio-loud AGN (Urry & Padovani
1995, Barthel 1989) suggest that quasars are oriented with
their jets closer to the line of sight than radio galaxies.
This implies that any beamed component is more evi-
dent in quasars, but also that isotropic emission, such
as optically thin dust emission, should not differ among
the types. Our observations confirm this picture, showing
that quasars are more luminous at millimeter wavelengths,
where we expect relativistic beaming, whereas they do
not differ in their far-infrared luminosity, which is due
to isotropic cold dust emission, and therefore unaffected
by beaming. The luminosity ratio QSR/RG increases with
frequency, which can only naturally be explained by beam-
ing.
If this trend is confirmed in larger samples, millimeter
observations in combination with radio observations could
provide a direct measure of the orientation of a source. E.g.
for a quasar and a radio galaxy of comparable 178 MHz
power, the radio galaxy provides the unbeamed radio SED
that can be subtracted from the quasar SED. The remain-
ing emission is then due to beaming, and the strength of
this beamed component depends directly on the viewing
angle of the source.
4.3. Hotspot and lobe emission
For three of our objects, the radio structures are larger
than the beam size of the IRAM 30 m telescope, so that
the hotspots fall outside the central bolometer channel.
We made no attempt to observe the hotspots separately.
The radio fluxes for all objects are integrated fluxes,
including the lobe emission. The MAMBO fluxes are also
integrated fluxes for the small objects, but core fluxes for
the objects with larger radio sizes than the IRAM beam. If
6
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
the millimeter emission would be dominated by the lobe
emission in all objects, there should be a clear turnover
in the SEDs of the large objects, where the lobes are not
observed with MAMBO. On the other hand, if the core
dominates the millimeter emission in all objects, the SEDs
should be comparable, irrespective of object radio size. We
observe no clear difference between the radio -- millimeter
SED of large and small objects, which seems to indicate
that the core is dominating the millimeter emission. This
does not imply that the lobes do not emit any millimeter
emission, e.g. in Cygnus A the hotspots have been clearly
detected with SCUBA at 850 µm (Robson et al. 1998).
However, there might be a relation between the lumi-
nosity density of the lobes at 1.2 mm and the size of the
radio structure. Small radio sources are known to have
much flatter spectra (Murgia et al. 1999) and thus can
have much stronger lobes. In our MAMBO observations,
all small sources are unresolved and thus we cannot tell
which component is dominating. If the lobes dominate in
small objects and the core dominates in larger ones, the
expected difference in spectral indices will not be visible.
We always observe the dominating regions, i.e. the lobes
in the small radio sources and only the core in the larger
ones. Judging from the radio core fluxes in 3C 277.1, the
core is not the dominant 1.2 mm source here. The same
can be true for 3C 67 and 3C 460, which are also small
radio sources. The lobe emission will dilute the amount of
beaming observed in small objects, thus for a proper es-
timate of the amount of beaming the objects should have
comparable radio sizes and be larger than the IRAM 30m
telescope beam.
4.4. Variability
We find evidence for variability in 3C 334. Since we have
only one observation for each object, variability cannot be
ruled out for the other objects. Previous SCUBA observa-
tions of the other quasars (BBG) are consistent with the
MAMBO detections, confirming the spectral steepening
and the thermal nature of the infrared emission. For the
radio galaxies there is remarkably little dispersion in the
observed spectral slopes. Thus, variability must be small
in all other objects.
-- An extrapolation of the non-thermal radio spectrum to
far-infrared wavelengths shows that the contribution of
non-thermal emission at 160 µm is less than 10%.
-- There is evidence that at 1.2 mm the quasar emission
is stronger, and therefore possibly more beamed, than
that from radio galaxies.
-- The far-infrared luminosity on the other hand, does
not differ between quasars and radio galaxies. Most
likely because it arises from optically thin thermal
emission, but optical thickness effects can play a role
up to 100 µm in the rest frame of the objects.
-- Radio and millimeter observations provide an inter-
esting test for unification models of radio-loud active
galaxies, in that they can provide a measure of the
amount of beamed emission. Millimeter observations,
in combination with radio observations, of a larger
sample of radio-loud active galaxies are needed to ver-
ify this.
Acknowledgements. Thanks to Bob Fosbury and Peter Barthel
for their motivation and help on the manuscript. Thanks to
Alessandra Bertarini for assisting with the observations, and
to the referee, Neal Jackson, for comments which greatly im-
proved the manuscript. Special thanks to the MPIfR bolometer
team for providing MAMBO and support, and to R. Zylka for
writing the MOPSI data reduction package.
NED is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Cal-
ifornia Institute of Technology, under contract with the Na-
tional Aeronautics and Space Administration. ISO is an ESA
project with instruments funded by ESA Member States (es-
pecially the PI countries: France, Germany, the Netherlands
and the United Kingdom) and with the participation of ISAS
and NASA.
References
Antonucci R., Barvainis R., Alloin D., 1990, ApJ 353, 416
Baars J.W.M., Hooghoudt B.G., Mezger P.G., de Jonge M.J.,
1987, A&A 175, 319
Barthel P.D., 1989, ApJ 336, 606
Granato G.L., Danese L., 1994, MNRAS 268, 235
Heckman T.M., Chambers K.C., Postman M., 1992, ApJ 391,
39
Hoekstra H., Barthel P.D., Hes R., 1997, A&A 319, 757
Kessler M.F., Steinz J.A., Anderegg M.E., et al., 1996, A&A
315, L27
Kreysa E., Gemuend H.-P., Gromke J., et al., 1998, SPIE 3357,
5. Conclusions
319
The main conclusions, drawn from our continuum obser-
vations at 1.2 mm of eight radio-loud active galaxies, can
be summarized as follows.
-- The millimeter emission is dominated by non-thermal
processes, whereas the far-infrared emission must be
thermal.
-- Any thermal contribution to the millimeter emission
arising from cold dust is estimated to be less than 15%,
except for 3C 460, where the case is not clear.
Lemke D., Klaas U., Abolins J., et al., 1996, A&A 315, L64
Meurs E.J.A., Unger S.W., 1991, A&A 252, 63
Murgia M., Fanti C., Fanti R., et al., 1999, A&A 345, 769
Pier E.A., Krolik J.H., 1992, ApJ 401, 99
Polletta M., Courvoisier T.J.-L., Hooper E.J., Wilkes B.J.,
2000, A&A in press, astro-ph 0006315
Rieke G.H., Low F.J., 1972, ApJ 176, L95
Robson E.I., Leeuw L.L., Stevens J.A., Holland W.S., 1998,
MNRAS 301, 935
Siebenmorgen R., Krugel E., Chini R., 1999, A&A 351, 495
Urry C.M., Padovani P., 1995, PASP 107, 803
van Bemmel & Bertoldi: Millimeter observations of radio-loud AGN
7
van Bemmel I.M., Barthel P.D., Yun M.S., 1998, A&A 334,
799
van Bemmel I.M., Barthel P.D., de Graauw T., (BBG), 2000,
A&A 359, 523
Zylka R., 1998, Pocket Cookbook for MOSPI Software,
http://www.iram.es/Telescope/manuals/Datared/pockroo.ps
|
astro-ph/0606309 | 1 | 0606 | 2006-06-13T12:08:23 | VLT/ISAAC Spectra of the H-beta Region in Intermediate-Redshift Quasars II. Black Hole Mass and Eddington Ratio | [
"astro-ph"
] | We derive black hole masses for a sample of about 300 AGNs in the redshift range 0 < z < 2.5. We use the same virial velocity measure (FWHM Hbeta broad component) for all sources which represents a significant improvement over previous studies. We review methods and caveats for determining AGN black hole masses via the virial assumption for motions in the gas producing low ionization broad emission lines. We derive a corrected FWHM measure for the broad component of H-beta that better estimates the virialized line emitting component by comparing our FWHM measures with a sample of reverberated sources with H-beta radial velocity dispersion measures. We also consider the FWHM of the FeII 4570 blend as a potential alternative velocity estimator. We find a range of black hole mass between log M ~ 6 - 10, where the black hole mass M is in solar masses. Estimates using corrected FWHM, as well as FWHM(Fe II) measures, reduce the number of sources with log M > 9.5 and suggest that extremely large M values (log M >~ 10) may not be realistic. Derived Eddington ratio values values show no evidence for a significant population of super-Eddington radiators especially after correction is made for sources with extreme orientation to our line of sight. Sources with FWHM(Hbeta broad component) <~ 4000 km/s show systematically higher Eddington ratio and lower M values than broader lined AGNs (including almost all radio-loud sources). | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. sulenticetalsubmission3rdprint
(DOI: will be inserted by hand later)
April 25, 2018
VLT/ISAAC Spectra of the Hβ Region in Intermediate-Redshift
II. Black Hole Mass and Eddington Ratio⋆
Quasars
J. W. Sulentic1, P. Repetto2,3, G. M. Stirpe4, P. Marziani2, D. Dultzin-Hacyan3, and M. Calvani2
1 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
2 Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, INAF, Vicolo dell' Osservatorio 5, 35122 Padova, Italy
e-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]
3 Instituto de Astronom´ıa, UNAM, Aptdo. Postal 70-264, M´exico, D. F. 04510, M´exico e-mail:
[email protected],[email protected]
4 Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna, INAF, Via Ranzani 1, 40127 Bologna, Italy
e-mail: [email protected]
Received / Accepted
Abstract. We derive black hole masses for a sample of about 300 AGNs in the redshift range 0 < z < 2.5. We use
the same virial velocity measure (FWHM HβBC) for all sources which represents a significant improvement over
previous studies. We review methods and caveats for determining AGN black hole masses via the virial assumption
for motions in the gas producing low ionization broad emission lines. We derive a corrected FWHM(HβBC) measure
for the broad component of Hβ that better estimates the virialized line emitting component by comparing our
FWHM measures with a sample of reverberated sources with Hβ radial velocity dispersion measures. We also
consider the FWHM of the Feiiλ4570 blend as a potential alternative velocity estimator. We find a range of black
hole mass between logMBH ∼ 6.0 -- 10.0, where MBH is in solar masses. Estimates using corrected FWHM(Hβ),
as well as FWHM(Feii) measures, reduce the number of sources with log MBH > 9.5 and suggest that extremely
large MBH values (log MBH>∼ 10) may not be realistic. Derived L/LEdd values show no evidence for a significant
population of super-Eddington radiators especially after correction is made for sources with extreme orientation
to our line of sight. Sources with FWHM(HβBC) <∼ 4000 km s−1 show systematically higher L/LEdd and lower
MBH values than broader lined AGNs (including almost all radio-loud sources).
Key words. quasars: emission lines -- quasars: general -- line: profiles -- black hole physics
6
0
0
2
n
u
J
3
1
1
v
9
0
3
6
0
6
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1. Introduction
Gravitational accretion onto supermassive black holes is
generally accepted as the ultimate energy source of Active
Galactic Nuclei (AGNs). The last decade has seen a major
effort to derive reasonable estimates of black hole masses
(MBH) by assuming virialized motions in the broad line
emitting gas:
MBH =
v2rBLR
G
(1)
the full width half maximum measured for a suit-
able emission line. The factor f depends on the ge-
ometry and details of the kinematics (Krolik, 2001;
McLure & Dunlop, 2001; Onken et al., 2004). The use-
fulness of the virial assumption for MBH determina-
tion is best exploited using reverberation-mapping stud-
ies, especially for the Balmer lines (Koratkar & Gaskell,
1991; Peterson & Wandel, 1999; Wandel et al., 1999;
Kaspi et al., 2000; Peterson et al., 2004). Kaspi et al.
(2000, 2005) derive a relation between Broad Line Region
(BLR) distance rBLR and continuum luminosity
where v is the velocity dispersion of the emit-
ting gas at distance rBLR. The velocity dispersion
can be written as v = f FWHM where FWHM is
rBLR ∝ (λLλ)α
(2)
Send offprint requests to: J. W. Sulentic
⋆ Based on observations collected at the European Southern
Observatory, Chile. Proposal ref.: ESO 072.B-0338(A)
where the exponent α is constrained between 0.5 and 1.0,
and is most likely ≈ 0.6 -- 0.7 for broad Hβ (HβBC) and
optical continuum luminosity.
2
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
There are caveats associated with this method. The
virial assumption is not likely to be generally valid for the
emission line gas in AGNs. It has been known for sev-
eral decades that different emission lines in a source can
show different width and profile shape (e.g., de Robertis,
1985; Sulentic, 1989). The virial assumption implies that
the velocity dispersion will steadily decrease with dis-
tance from the central black hole ∝ r− 1
2 . The time lag
between continuum fluctuations and corresponding emis-
sion line responses will therefore anti-correlate with line
width. This trend has been confirmed in a few objects
(Peterson & Wandel, 2000).
Observations however show that profile width and
shape depend on the ionization potential. The strongest
high-ionization lines (HILs; e.g. Civλ1549) often display
blueward asymmetric profiles, or even centroid blueshifts
(up to several 1000 km s−1) with respect to the best esti-
mates of the rest frame of the source (e.g., Gaskell, 1982;
Marziani et al., 1996; Richards et al., 2002; Bachev et al.,
2004). Blueshifts like those observed for Civλ1549 are in-
dicative of obscuration and radial motions which invali-
date the virial assumption.
Low ionization lines (LILs) like Hβ are the best can-
didates for emission arising from a virialized medium. All
or much of the Balmer (and Feii) line emission is thought
to arise from an accretion disk or a flattened cloud dis-
tribution near the disk (e.g., Collin-Souffrin et al., 1988;
Marziani et al., 1996). A major caveat, especially for the
Balmer lines, involves the possibility that: (1) there are
two or more emission components in a line, and (2) only
one of them may arise in a region where the virial assump-
tion holds. The Balmer lines do not usually show very
large line shifts (i.e., shift ≤ FWHM) although profiles can
be very asymmetric. Both red and blue asymmetries are
observed for HβBC which is the most studied line because
it is relatively unblended and is observable with optical
spectrometers up to z ≈ 1 (Osterbrock & Shuder, 1982;
Sulentic, 1989; Stirpe, 1990; Sulentic et al., 1990; Corbin,
1991; Corbin & Francis, 1994).
The most ambiguous sources from the point of view of
MBH determination show FWHM(HβBC) >∼ 4000 km s−1
(Population B, following Sulentic et al., 2000b) and red-
shifted profiles and/or red asymmetries. Not all parts of
the Hβ profile respond to continuum changes in the same
way implying that some of the line emitting gas may be
optically thin or, less likely, is not exposed to the variable
Hi ionizing radiation (we will return to this issue in §5.2).
The broad line profile in Pop. B sources may be due to two
distinct emitting regions: (1) an optically thick classical
BLR and (2) a broader and redshifted very broad com-
ponent that may be optically thin or marginally optically
thick to the Lyman continuum, originating in a distinct
Very Broad Line Region (VBLR) (Marziani & Sulentic,
1993; Shields et al., 1995; Sulentic et al., 2000c). The red-
shift of the VBLR component raises doubts that it arises
from virialized gas. A strong BLR response to continuum
fluctuations, coupled with a weak or absent response of the
VBLR component, can lead to an overestimate of FWHM
for the virialized BLR component resulting in an overes-
timate of MBH (Wandel et al., 1999; Kaspi et al., 2000;
Vestergaard, 2002).
Sources with FWHM(HβBC) <∼ 4000 km s−1
(Population A, Sulentic et al., 2000b) should provide more
reliable MBH estimates. The HβBC profile is usually well
fit with a symmetric function (V´eron-Cetty et al. , 2001;
Sulentic et al., 2002) and the BLR emission is thought
to arise from a Keplerian disk. The most unreliable
Pop. A sources, in a disk emission scenario, should be
those observed near face-on where the rotational (i.e.
virial) contribution to FWHM(HβBC) is minimal. At least
some of the face-on sources may be identified as the so-
called "blue outliers" which show a weak and significantly
blueshifted [Oiii]λλ4959,5007 lines (Zamanov et al., 2002;
Marziani et al., 2003b; Aoki et al., 2005; Boroson, 2005).
The inferences in this, and the preceding paragraph
have emerged from the Eigenvector 1 (E1) scenario that
we have pursued for the past 5+ years (Sulentic et al.,
2000a,b, following Boroson & Green (1992)). The results
reported in this paper appear to confirm them.
There are additional caveats connected with us-
ing FWHM(HβBC) for MBH derivations. Line asym-
metries can affect MBH estimates for both Pop. A
and B sources. The vr displacement of the line cen-
troid at fractional intensities (at half maximum, c( 1
2 ))
can give useful
information about the uncertainty of
FWHM(HβBC) measurements. The average displacement
value is a few hundred km s−1 with median c( 1
2 ) ≈
400 km s−1 (Marziani et al., 2003a). This implies that
deviations from a symmetric profile can affect MBH
estimates by ≈ 40 %. Uncertainties are also intro-
duced by: (1) contamination from overlapping/nearby
lines such as Feii, Heiiλ4686,
and [Oiii]λλ4959,5007
(Osterbrock & Shuder, 1982; de Robertis, 1985; Joly,
1988; Jackson et al., 1991), (2) FWHM measures based
on single-epoch observations, (3) low S/N spectra and (4)
spectra without Hβ narrow component (HβNC) subtrac-
tion. The rBLR - Lλ relation is also not free from un-
certainties. Reverberation mapping-based MBH determi-
nations are certainly affected by the non-negligible radial
extent of the optically thick BLR. The derived rBLR is
not a very well defined quantity and α is also somewhat
uncertain because of the intrinsic scatter in the correla-
tion. Finally, reverberation data does not exist for high
luminosity/redshift quasars requiring an extrapolation of
the rBLR - Lλ relation in order to estimate MBH for these
sources.
Uncertainties for MBH derivations using single profile
observation of HβBC are estimated to be a factor of 2 -- 3
(at a 1 σ confidence level), but may be as low as 30% if
the velocity dispersion of the variable part of HβBC profile
is employed as a virial estimator (Peterson et al., 2004).
MBH estimates based on the virial relation retain a statis-
tical validity considering that AGNs span a 5dex range in
MBH (105 M⊙<∼ MBH <∼ 1010 M⊙) and that the relation
has now been applied to large samples of objects (∼ 103;
McLure & Dunlop, 2004).
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
3
With these considerations in mind, and supported by
previous results, we use the virial relation to compute
MBH for ≈ 280 AGNs in our E1 sample of low red-
shift (0 <∼ z <∼ 1) sources (Marziani et al., 2003b) sup-
plemented with 25 intermediate redshift/high luminosity
(1 <∼ z <∼ 2.5) quasars. We derive MBH and L/LEdd values
in several ways. New VLT-ISAAC data are presented for 9
sources (§2) which supplement data already published for
sixteen quasars (Sulentic et al., 2004). Line measures are
presented in §4. We use HβBC and Feiiλ4570 line widths
in a consistent way over the redshift range 0 <∼ z <∼ 2.5 (a
range of 105 in luminosity). We compute black hole mass
MBH, Eddington ratio L/LEdd (§5) and we discuss how
mass determinations might be improved (§5.2) so that the
evolution of MBH and L/LEdd with redshift can be con-
sidered (§5.3 and §6).
2. Observations and Data Reduction
New intermediate redshift data were obtained between
10/2003-03/2004 in service mode with the infrared spec-
trometer ISAAC mounted on VLT1 (ANTU) at the
European Southern Observatory. Each spectrum corre-
sponds to a wavelength range (IR windows sZ, J, sH) that
covers the region of redshifted HβBC and Feiiλ4570 or
Feiiλ5130 at least in part. Reduction of quasar spectra
and standard stars followed exactly the same procedures
described in Sulentic et al. (2004). Wavelength calibration
yielded rms residuals of 0.4, 0.6 and 0.9 A in the sZ, J and
sH windows, respectively. Absolute flux scales of the spec-
tra will be inaccurate because atmospheric seeing almost
always exceeded the slit width (≈ 0".6) resulting in sig-
nificant light loss.
Table 1 summarizes the new observations and the ba-
sic format is given below the table. All sources come from
the Hamburg-ESO (HE) quasar survey, which is a flux
limited (with limiting mB ≈ 17.5), color-selected survey
(Wisotzki et al., 2000 ). Column 2 of Table 1 lists the
blue apparent magnitudes from the HE survey papers
(Reimers et al., 1996; Wisotzki et al., 2000 ) while Col. 3
lists the source redshift z computed as described in section
3. The brightest sources of the HE at intermediate red-
shift were preferentially selected. Col. 4 indicates whether
[Oiii]λ5007 was used to compute z as indicative of the
source rest frame. The absolute magnitude MB reported in
Col. 5 was computed by assuming H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1,
and relative energy density ΩM = 0.3 and ΩΛ = 0.7. The
k correction was computed for a spectral index a = 0.6
(S ∝ ν−a). Col. 6 gives the ratio of log specific fluxes at 6
cm and 4400 A (log Rk). In most cases only NRAO VLA
Sky Survey (NVSS) upper limits are available. Columns
7-12 give details of the observations explained in the foot-
notes. The continuum S/N estimate given in Col. 12 was
measured using a small region of the spectrum that was
as flat and free of line emission as possible.
3. Data Analysis
3.1. Redshift Determination and Rest Frame
Corrections
Small offsets are present in the wavelength calibration,
because the arc lamp frames were obtained in daytime,
and therefore usually after grism movement. A correc-
tion for these shifts was obtained by measuring the cen-
troids of 2 -- 3 OH sky lines against the arc calibration
and calculating the average difference, which reached at
most 6.5 A or 2.5 pixels in either direction. Rest frame
determination for the 9 new sources was usually esti-
mated from the Hβ peak redshift (assumed rest frame λ =
4861.33 A). [Oiii]λ5007 (assumed rest frame λ = 5006.85
A) yielded a consistent measurement in only two sources
(where the results were averaged. Two sources show no
clear detection of [Oiii]λλ4959,5007 while the remaining
five show a significant disagreement between [Oiii]λ5007
and HβNC. In these sources (we call the extreme exam-
ples of them "blue outliers") it is not advisable to use
[Oiii]λ5007 for redshift determination (Zamanov et al.,
2002; Marziani et al., 2003b; Aoki et al., 2005; Boroson,
2005). The adopted estimate was used to deredshift the
spectra while the dopcor IRAF task applied a (1+z)3 cor-
rection to convert observed specific fluxes into rest frame
values. Fig. 1 shows the deredshifted spectra.
3.2. Continuum and Feii subtraction
Our spectral analysis made use of standard IRAF tasks
with the first step involving continuum modelling and sub-
traction. Using Chebyshev polynomials of 3rd or 2nd or-
der, a reasonably smooth continuum subtraction was ob-
tained for all sources. To estimate errors in the continuum
assessment introduced by noise, we also defined a mini-
mum and a maximum continuum. Continuum fluxes were
chosen at about -- 3σ (minimum) and +3σ (maximum),
where σ is the noise standard deviation from the most
likely continuum choice. Errors in continuum placement
defined by difference between the extreme continua and
the most probable one were then propagated according
to standard error theory. The results of this procedure
are consistent with continuum fits employing very simple
models (Malkan & Sargent, 1982; Shang et al., 2004). We
assumed that the continuum underlying the Hβ spectral
regions is due to two components: either a blackbody of
temperature 25000◦ K or a power law of slope b = 0.7
(fν ∝ ν−b; assumed to be valid only locally around Hβ).
In 5 sources the sole black body component produces a
good fit; in 2 the blackbody component is dominant, and
only in the remaining 2 cases the power-law alone can pro-
vide a good fit. This method has some limitations due to
the small spectral bandwidth covered by our spectra, to
the relative strength of Feii and to internal reddening ef-
fects. Since we did not attempt to change the blackbody
temperature nor the slope of the power-law, we adopt the
empirical continuum which is visually more accurate.
4
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
The emission blends of Feii were subtracted using
the template method based upon the spectrum of I Zw
1 (Boroson & Green, 1992; Marziani et al., 2003a). The
strongest Feii blends fall in the wavelenghth ranges 4450 --
4600 A (blue blend: Feiiλ4570) and 5200 -- 5600 A (red
blend: Feiiλ5130). The method includes the following
steps: (1) the template intensity is scaled to roughly match
the observed spectrum, (2) a Gaussian broadening factor
is estimated from FWHM HβBC (3) a careful estimate
of minimum and maximum plausible broadening factor
is made to set a reliable ±3σ uncertainty and (4) the
template intensity is adjusted as necessary after broad-
ening. The resultant template was subtracted from the
continuum-subtracted spectra. The blue side of the spec-
trum including Feiiλ4570 is missing, or not fully covered,
in several sources (HE 0946 -- 0500, HE 1003+0149, HE
1017 -- 0009, HE 1249 -- 0648 and HE 1258 -- 0823). In these
cases the best template fit was achieved for the red blend
and a fixed ratio between the red and blue blends was as-
sumed to reproduce Feiiλ4570. Fig. 2 shows the estimated
Feii emission (green lines). Feii was subtracted before con-
tinuum fitting in sources with strong Feii emission.
The [Oiii]λλ4959,5007 lines were measured after Feii
subtraction and taking into account the following con-
siderations: (1) the flux ratio between [Oiii]λ5007 and
[Oiii]λ4959 should be ≈3, (2) both lines should show
identical profiles and (3) any HβBC emission underlying
[Oiii]λλ4959,5007 is expected to have a smooth shape.
Sources HE 1249 -- 0648 and HE 1258 -- 0823 see (Fig. 2)
show a small bump at λ ≈ 5016 A which is either an Feii
subtraction residual or emission from Heiλ5016 (weak red-
shifted [Oiii]λ5007 would be almost unprecedented). After
subtraction of HβNC (following Marziani et al., 2003a),
the HβBC profile was fit with a high order spline function
(IRAF task SFIT). This procedure does not yield a model
fit but only an empirical fit that smooths the noise and
reproduces the main features and inflections in HβBC.
4. Immediate Results
4.1. Line Measurements and Uncertainties
Line Fluxes and Equivalent Widths Table 3 gives line mea-
surements for the new VLT spectra with the basic for-
mat given in the footnote. Cols. 3 and 4 give equivalent
width (EW) measures for HβBC and Feiiλ4570 respec-
tively. We evaluated uncertainties associated with the con-
tinuum level (derived from the minimum and maximum
reasonable continuum estimates) and line flux errors es-
timated from the S/N . These estimates were combined
quadratically to obtain uncertainties for EW measures. A
similar procedure was applied to obtain uncertainty esti-
mates for HβNC and [Oiii]λλ4959,5007. The EW uncer-
tainty for HβNC was derived from the estimated maxi-
mum and minimum possible HβNC component in the Hβ
line. The relative error of the HβNC flux can be large (see
Table 3) and in some cases an HβNC component may not
be present.
Fe iiopt width Feii emission is heavily blended so that
widths of individual
lines must be obtained from the
best broadening parameter that was used for the tem-
plate fit. This requires that we assume a constant width
for all Feii
lines which so far appears to be reason-
able. FWHM(Feiiλ4570) values derived from the tem-
plate broadening factor are reported in Col. 5 of Table
3. Uncertainty estimates for FWHM(Feiiλ4570) were ob-
tained by increasing/decreasing the broadening factor un-
til we could detect significant changes in the best fit.
Simulated data reveal that it is possible to estimate the
Feiiλ4570 width up to FWHM(Feiiλ4570) ≈ 6000 km s−1.
Due to the very large uncertainty of Feiiλ4570 width de-
termination for individual sources, MBH estimates based
on FWHM(Feiiλ4570) measures are used mainly for con-
firmatory purposes of statistical trends detected with Hβ.
HβBC Line Profiles Measurements of FWHM(Hβ) to-
gether with other important line parameters like asymme-
try index, kurtosis and line centroid at various fractional
intensities were derived using a FORTRAN program devel-
oped for that purpose. These parameters are the same as
defined in several previous papers (Marziani et al., 1996,
2003a; Sulentic et al., 2004) and are given in Table 3. Each
line measure is followed in the next Col. by its appropri-
ate uncertainty. Cols. 2 and 4 give the Full Width at Zero
Intensity (FWZI) and FWHM. Col. 6 gives the asymme-
try index (AI) as defined in Sulentic et al. (2004). Col. 8
lists kurtosis values while the remaining part of Table 3
lists measures of the HβBC centroid at various fractional
intensities. (in km s−1). All uncertainties represent the 2σ
confidence level.
The dichotomy in HβBC profile shape (and many other
properties) between Population A and B (Sulentic et al.,
2002) is seen in the new source measures and in the
rest of our higher redshift sample (Sulentic et al., 2004).
Redward asymmetries (A.I. >∼ 0.2) are most often found
in Pop. B sources. They also show HβBC profiles that
are best fit with Gaussian functions, and some profile ap-
pear composite. A few sources appear to deviate from the
trend found in previous work that FWHM of HβBC and
the Feii lines are very similar (Marziani et al., 2003a,c).
HE 1249-0648 and HE 1258−0823 show FWHM(HβBC)
≫ FWHM(Feiiλ4570). While FWHM(Feiiλ4570) is sub-
ject to large uncertainty, the difference is confirmed by
careful reinspection of these spectra. This condition is
seen in only 2/215 sources in the Marziani et al. (2003a)
sample. Both (IRAS 07598+6508 and Mkn 235) are BAL
QSOs which are also FIR ultra-luminous (Sulentic et al.,
2006). In addition to a Civλ1549 BAL with high ter-
minal velocity, these objects have a strong, blueshifted
Civλ1549 emission line component. Blueshifted Balmer
emission is probably associated with the high-ionization
gas emitting Civλ1549. The absence of any detectable
[Oiii]λλ4959,5007 emission, along with a possible Hei fea-
ture at λ5016 A support the possibility that HE 1249-0648
and HE 1258−0823 could be BAL QSOs similar to IRAS
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
5
07598+6508 and Mkn 235. Further support comes from
an inspection of the HE survey spectra of both objects
which indeed show blueshifted broad absorption in the
Mgiiλ2800 line.
reported in Table 2. All sources with z >∼ 0.8 are from
the VLT sample. We do not show MBH values derived
from MB as in Marziani et al. (2003b) for clarity, since
they basically confirm the same trends obtained from the
specific fluxes.
5. Black Hole Mass and Eddington Ratio
5.1. Basic Equations
One can write the velocity dispersion v in Eq. 1 as v ≈
√3/2 FWHM(HβBC) in the case of randomly oriented ve-
locities projected along the line-of-sight. The expression
for black hole mass is then:
MBH ≈
3
4
rBLRFWHM(HβBC)2
G
(3)
In the absence of reverberation data one must rely on
the correlation between reverberation radius and source
luminosity rBLR ∝ (L5100)α, where L5100 is the specific
luminosity at λ ≈ 5100 A (Kaspi et al., 2000, 2005). This
formula relates BLR distance from the central continuum
source and specific luminosity (ergs s−1A−1) near 5100 A.
Following Kaspi et al. (2005) one can write:
rBLR ≈ 0.697 · 1017 ·" λLλ(cid:0)5100A(cid:1)
1044 erg s−1 #0.67
cm
(4)
We can make two estimates of MBH using these rela-
tionships assuming two different values for λLλ. The first
method derives MB from tabulated values of V or B ap-
parent magnitudes:
λLλ(cid:0)5100A(cid:1) ≈ 3.14 · 1035−0.4(MB) ergs s−1
A second possibility involves estimating the specific
luminosity near 5100 A directly from flux measures using
the adopted continuum fits for our spectra. More explicitly
λLλ is computed as follows:
(5)
λLλ(cid:0)5100A(cid:1) = 4πd2
Pλfλ(5100A) ergs s−1,
(6)
where dP is the redshift derived distance and fλ is the
specific flux in the rest frame at 5100 A (after correction
for Galactic extinction AB at the observed wavelength).
The second choice has the advantage that the continuum
fλ and FWHM(HβBC) are measured from the same spec-
trum. Expected light losses are estimated to be ≈ 35 %
of the quasar flux with average Paranal seeing (0."6). We
apply this average correction to the observed flux before
computing MBH.
Substituting the expression for rBLR in the mass for-
mula one obtains the following relation:
MBH ≈ 5.48·106" λLλ(cid:0)5100A(cid:1)
1044 erg s−1 #0.67
1000km s−1 (cid:19)2
(cid:18) FWHM(HβBC)
(7)
where MBH is in solar mass units (M⊙).
Fig. 3 shows the distribution of MBH as a function of z.
MBH estimates are based on the FWHM(HβBC) measures
5.2. Improved MBH Estimators?
As briefly summarized in §1, there is some evidence sug-
gesting that the virial assumption is reasonable for LILs
in a significant fraction of quasars (Population A; about
50-60% of low z quasars). Our VLT spectra confirm that
any dependence of FWHM(HβBC) on source luminosity
is weak (Sulentic et al., 2004). Table 3 suggests that low
redshift trends for asymmetries and line shifts are pre-
served in the intermediate z sample. It is therefore not
certain that FWHM(HβBC) is a valid estimator of the
virial velocity for all sources even after proper HβNC,
[Oiii]λλ4959,5007, Feii subtraction.
A more physical approach to MBH estimation uses
the FWHM of the variable part of the HβBC profile
(Peterson et al., 2004). Fig. 4 plots FWHMrms values
from Peterson et al. (2004) versus our FWHM(HβBC)
measures (Marziani et al., 2003a) for all sources in com-
mon. Sources with FWHM <∼ 4000 km s−1 show a
with FWHM>∼ 4000 km s−1. We recall
correlation while the situation is less clear for sources
this
value indicates the nominal population A-B bound-
ary (Sulentic et al., 2000b) that emerged in our E1
studies. A least-square best fit analysis yields a "cor-
rected" FWHM(HβBC) estimate: FWHMcorr(HβBC)≈
−710(±800) + 1.13(±0.28) FWHM(HβBC) for FWHM
<∼ 4000 km s−1 and FWHMcorr(HβBC)≈ 650(±1000) +
0.79(±0.14) FWHM(HβBC) for FWHM >∼ 4000 km s−1.
that
The slope depends somewhat on the fitting method (a ro-
bust fit yields 0.94 and 0.72) but is always less steep for
FWHM >∼ 4000 km s−1. An immediate implication is that
optically thick BLR gas responding to continuum changes
shows a velocity dispersion correlated with -- but slightly
lower than that of the integrated profile at all FWHM.
A break in the linear fit at 4000 km s−1 is consis-
tent with several previous findings: (a) mean and pos-
sibly systematic HβBC profile differences between Pop.
A and B sources (Sulentic et al., 2002); (b) the lack of
strong profile changes in Pop. A sources (Giveon et al.,
1999); (c) profile asymmetries frequently observed in Pop.
B sources. They might represent a distinct redshifted emis-
sion component (Sulentic et al., 2002)which may arise in
less optically thick gas than the rest of the HβBC pro-
file (Sulentic et al., 2000c). If the redshifted component is
emitted in an innermost VBLR, the FWHM of the whole
HβBC profile is obviously increased over the value due to
the line component that is actually responding, and that
is most likely located farther away from the central con-
tinuum source. Even if the virial assumption holds for the
VBLR (but the frequent asymmetries warn us that this
might not be the case), the use of the FWHM from the
6
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
whole HβBC profile and of rBLR from the reverberating
part, yields an MBH overestimate. This interpretation of
the correlations in Fig. 4 is advanced with caution because
of the small sample size and especially because of the poor
statistics for sources with FWHM >∼ 4000 km s−1. It is
also possible to produce a meaningful fit with a second-
order polynomial. We apply a tentative correction to the
FWHM measures FWHMcorr(HβBC) and therefore to re-
sultant MBH estimates using the second-order fit shown
in Fig. 4 which approximates very well the linear trends.
If an optically thin/nonvirialized component is present
in the HβBC profile of many sources then we might
use as a virial estimator the FWHM of a line, or lines,
arising in BLR gas but not likely to be present in the
VBLR region. FWHM(Feiiλ4570) is an obvious alter-
native because there is no evidence for a VBLR emis-
sion component in the broad Feii blends. It is not
strictly correct to use it because the rBLR- Lλ rela-
tion was deduced for Hβ. The most serious difficulty
lies in obtaining a reliable FWHM(Feiiλ4570) estimate
from the heavily blended Feii emission. Considering the
EW and FWHM limits for detection of Fe iiopt emis-
sion (Marziani et al., 2003a) we conclude that a reason-
able FWHM measurement is possible for ≈120 sources
in our low z spectral atlas. Measurement uncertainties
for FWHM(Feii) will be larger than for FWHM(HβBC)
and are estimated to lie between 20 -- 50%. The best
fit of FWHM(Feiiλ4570) vs. FWHM(HβBC) (km s−1)
is consistent with FWHM(Feiiλ4570) ≈ FWHM(HβBC)
for FWHM(HβBC) <
is
FWHM(Feiiλ4570) ≈ 0.67 · FWHM(HβBC) + 820 km s−1
if FWHM(HβBC) >
The relationship between FWHM(HβBC) and FWHM
(Feii) confirms that individual Feii lines show approxi-
mately the same width as HβBC and as the rms HβBC
component implying a common kinematic environment if
∼ 4000 km s−1, while
it
∼ 4000 km s−1.
FWHM(HβBC) <∼ 4000 km s−1. If FWHM(HβBC) >∼ 4000
km s−1, FWHM(Feii) follows a trend closer to that of the
rms HβBC component. Therefore if the rms HβBC compo-
nent arises from gas in virialized motion, the same can be
reasonably assumed for the whole Feiiλ4570 emission.
5.3. MBH and L/LEdd Dependence on Redshift
MBH,9⊙ = 3.85 · 106h−2(cid:18) L
·(cid:2)1.5(cid:0)1 − e− z
LEdd(cid:19)−1
6.107(cid:1) +(cid:0)1 − e− z
· 10−0.4mB ·
1.266(cid:1)(cid:3)2
· (1 + z)(1−a).
Appendix B details how Eqn. 8 was derived. If we
adopt a limiting magnitude mB ≈ 17.5 (appropriate
for the Hamburg-ESO survey) and consider a maximum
Eddington ratio L/LEdd≈ 1 we obtain the minimum MBH
detectable as a function of z. Limiting MBH curves are
shown in Fig. 3, Fig. 5, and Fig. 6.
All sources show MBH >∼ 106 M⊙. In the range 1 <∼
z <∼ 2.5 we begin to find a significant black hole popu-
lation in the range ∼ 109.5 M⊙ <∼ MBH <∼ 1010 M⊙. If
we consider MBH values derived from Feiiλ4570 as well as
from FWHMcorr(HβBC) (Fig. 5, open and filled symbols
respectively) we get a somewhat different picture. Almost
all sources lie below ≈ 5· 109 M⊙ (all sources with z <∼ 1);
only three sources whose MBH has been computed with
from FWHMcorr(HβBC) lie significantly above this limit.
Our sample of intermediate z quasars with compatible
quality data is still small so caution is needed. It should
corr is self-consistent,
be pointed out that the use of HβBC
since no Hβ surrogate line was used.
The upper panel of Fig. 6 identifies sources on the ba-
sis of radio-loudness where open and solid symbols denote
radio-loud (RL; see definition in Sulentic et al., 2003) and
radio-quiet (RQ) sources respectively. At low z RQ sources
are distributed across the full range of MBH up to MBH>∼
109 M⊙, although RL sources tend to have larger MBH
(Metcalf & Magliocchetti, 2006; Marziani et al., 2003b,
and references therein). The same consideration apply to
Pop. A and Pop. B sources (lower panel of Fig. 6), and
this is not surprising since most Pop. A sources are RQ.
At intermediate z, selection effects limit the detectable
black holes to MBH>∼ 109 M⊙, so that only the high end
of the quasar MBH distribution can be traced. It is too
early to decide whether systematic differences in the MBH
distribution of RQ and RL sources may still exist at in-
termediate z, at least from the present data.
5.3.1. MBH
5.3.2. L/LEdd
Fig. 3 shows the distribution with z of MBH esti-
mates derived using uncorrected FWHM(HβBC) mea-
sures. This can be compared with Fig. 5 where we
show corresponding distributions of MBH derived us-
ing corrected FWHMcorr(HβBC) measures and using
FWHM(Feiiλ4570). FWHMcorr(HβBC) values were de-
rived from the second-order relation in Fig. 4.
The distribution of data points in the log MBH vs. z
plane reflects selection effects intrinsic to any flux limited
sample. If we consider AGNs that are radiating at a given
L/LEdd we easily obtain MBH for a given apparent mag-
nitude:
Fig. 7 shows the distribution of L/LEdd estimates as a
function of z. A preliminary analysis in terms of L/LEdd,
and including discussion of bolometric luminosity estima-
tion, was presented in Marziani et al. (2003b).
The existence of apparently super-Eddington radia-
tors in the low-z part of Fig. 7 involves the most extreme
NLSy1 sources. One caveat about interpreting any of them
as super-Eddington involves the significant uncertainties
associated with these estimates. If we assume a typical un-
certainty of ±50% for the bolometric correction (neglect-
ing beaming or lensing) and ±10% for the virial estimator
(basically the uncertainty in the FWHM measurement) we
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
7
find a ∆ logL/LEdd≈ 0.13 (neglecting the scatter in Eqn.
2). A serious source of uncertainty ignored until now in-
volves source orientation with respect to the line-of-sight.
The virial velocity dispersion that HβBC is assumed to
measure is now widely assumed to involve Keplerian ro-
tation in an accretion disk or in a flattened distribution
near the disk. If our candidate super-Eddington sources
are mostly viewed with (face-on disk and/or pole-on jet)
then MBH can be significantly underestimated. An orien-
tation correction applied to extreme NLSy1 sources (we
call them Pop. A "blue outliers") interpreted as face-on,
will move them below L/LEdd ≈ 1 (Marziani et al., 2003b,
see arrows in their Figure 12). At high z we so far find
no strong evidence for any super-Eddington sources. The
thick solid line in Fig. 7 shows the expected L/LEdd de-
tection limit deduced from Eqn. 8 for a flux-limited survey
(mB ≈ 17.5) and a quasar with MBH ≈ 4 · 109 M⊙. All
quasars in our sample fall above the minimum detectable
L/LEdd, suggesting that masses larger than ≈ 4 · 109M⊙
are not strictly necessary from our data (see §6.1 for fur-
ther discussion).
A physical basis for the dichotomy between Pop. A
and Pop. B (Sulentic et al., 2000b; Marziani et al., 2001,
2003b) is supported by this analysis in the sense that Fig.
4 shows evidence for a change at about FWHM(HβBC) ≈
4000 km s−1. Fig. 7 identifies Pop. A and B sources as
filled and open symbols respectively. Here we apply the
luminosity-dependent definition of the Pop. A-B bound-
ary as defined in Fig. 6 of Sulentic et al. (2004). It shows
that the Eddington ratio of Pop. A sources is systemat-
ically larger than that of Pop. B, and that the apparent
boundary between the two populations may increase with
redshift. If we focus on the intermediate z quasars then
Pop. A sources show an average L/LEdd ≈ 0.78 compared
to 0.27 for 10 Pop. B sources. Even these small samples of
Pop. A and B sources show significantly different L/LEdd
distributions according to a Kolmogorov-Smirnov (K-S)
test. RL AGNs are systematically low L/LEdd radiators
since they are almost entirely Pop. B sources.
It is interesting to note that with: (1) a limiting magni-
<
tude mB ≈ 16.5, (2) L/LEdd<∼ 1 and (3) MBH
∼ 4·109 M⊙
we should detect fewer sources beyond z ≈ 2 (no source
below the dot-dashed curve of Fig. 7). If our assumptions
about the quasar bolometric correction are valid up to
that redshift, selection effects may influence the relative
frequency of Pop. A and B sources (the two Populations
have different L/LEdd distributions) rather than the in-
trinsic properties of LILs. In this case selection effects on
L/LEdd should strongly influence the so-called "Baldwin
effect" involving Civλ1549 and other HILs (Bachev et al.,
2004, and references therein) because Civλ1549 is more
prominent in Pop. B, and Pop. B sources are more easily
lost at high z.
6. Discussion
The present paper provides MBH estimates that have three
advantages: (1) a consistent data analysis procedure is em-
ployed over the entire redshift range 0.0 <∼ z <∼ 2.5 by
using the same MBH tracer, HβBC; (2) S/N and resolu-
tion of the spectroscopic data sample are high enough to
permit a careful study of the HβBC profile, and (3) the
data quality allows reasonable estimates of FWHM Feii
in many of the sources.
6.1. What are the largest black hole masses?
Netzer (2003) discussed several problems with MBH >∼
1010 M⊙. If the black hole mass vs. bulge mass (Mbulge)
relation (Ferrarese & Merritt, 2000) is valid at high z then
MBH ∼ 1010 M⊙ would imply stellar velocity dispersion
σ⋆ ≈ 700 km s−1 (following Gebhardt et al., 2000) and
resultant bulge masses Mbulge >∼ 1013M⊙ which are not
observed at low-z (McLure & Jarvis, 2004; Netzer, 2003;
Wang, 2003). Recent results for the fundamental plane
of elliptical galaxies, and the most massive spheroids at
z <
∼ 0.3 from Sloan Digital Sky Survey measures, confirm
∼ 500 km s−1 (SDSS, Bernardi et al., 2003, 2005,
that σ⋆
∼ 500 km s−1 are likely due to chance
all galaxies with σ >
superposition).
<
There are several proposed interpretations of this prob-
lem: (1) the MBH -- Mbulge relationship may not strictly
hold for all hosts, (2) the virial assumption is not appli-
cable, (3) results are plagued by such large uncertainties
-- including the one of the luminosity index α -- that very
large mass estimates are not real (Vestergaard, 2002), and
(4) some systematic effects may not have been considered.
6.1.1. The MBH -- Mbulge Relationship
Nuclei with MBH >∼ 5 · 109 M⊙ are not observed in galax-
ies of the local Universe if a direct black hole mass de-
termination is possible from circum-nuclear kinematics
(Marconi & Hunt, 2003). They are expected to be rare
and difficult to find, considering also that they should be
in a dormant or nearly dormant stage at the present epoch.
Integrating the quasar luminosity function at z ≈ 1.5
(Boyle et al., 2000), we find a comoving density of quasars
above the HE limiting magnitude (which corresponds to
MB≈ −27.1 for a k−correction a = 0.6) ∼ 3 · 10−8
Mpc−3. This indicates that the present-day density of
the most massive black holes that were once luminous
quasars should be very low, ∼ 2 · 10−9 Mpc−3. Even so,
they should be much more frequent than the very mas-
sive spheroids that would host them if the MBH -- Mbulge
relationship is valid. To estimate the density of spheroids
with σ⋆
bution function provided by Sheth et al. (2003) to unob-
served domains in σ. Integrating the Sheth et al. (2003)
∼ 500 km s−1, one obtains that the co-
function for σ⋆
moving density of all local spheroids is three orders of
magnitude lower (∼ 6 · 10−13 Mpc−3) than that of the
most massive black holes. A possible implication is that
the MBH -- Mbulge relation is not linear or of universal
validity, i.e. some galaxies host larger black hole masses
∼ 500 km s−1, one must extrapolate the σ distri-
>
>
8
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
than expected. This conclusion should remain valid also
at intermediate redshifts. A constant MBH/Mbulge ratio
cannot hold forever if bulge mass grows by secular evolu-
tionary processes. Evolution goes in the sense that the
spheroids may increase their masses at a later cosmic
age (z <∼ 2; Treu et al., 2004; Peng et al., 2005) signifi-
cantly more than their central black hole: the most mas-
sive black hole should be already "brightly shining" at
z ≈ 2 (McLure et al., 2005, and references therein). A
nonlinear MBH -- Mbulge relation has been proposed (Laor,
2001) for local hosts, with MBH accounting for only 0.05
% of the bulge mass in low-luminosity galaxies and 0.5 %
in giant ellipticals. In this case, MBH∼ 1010 M⊙ would
imply Mbulge∼ 1012 M⊙, which is at the upper end of
the spheroid masses measured locally (Marconi & Hunt,
2003).
The problem can be made to disappear if MBH<∼ 3 ·
109 M⊙. Bernardi et al. (2005) find a maximum σ⋆ ≈ 500
km s−1. These local galaxies (with expected MBH ≈ 3·109
M⊙) may have been the hosts of the luminous quasars
∼ z <
at 1 <
∼ 2 since the number density of spheroids with
∼ 350 km s−1 is ∼ 4·10−7 Mpc−3, still somewhat larger
σ⋆
than the present-day density of supermassive black holes
>
that were radiating at MB <∼ −25 (∼ 10−7 Mpc−3).
The curves in Fig. 7, where MBH∼ 4 · 109 M⊙ has
been assumed, suggest that there is no need for MBH >∼
1010 M⊙ at z <
∼ 2.5. Similarly the brightest HE sources in
the redshift range 1 <
∼ 2 (mB ≈ 15.0 at z ≈ 1.7) are
consistent with L/LEdd≈ 1 if MBH∼ 4 · 109 M⊙. In other
words, if MBH∼ 1010 M⊙, then a source at L/LEdd≈ 1
would be brighter than the brightest quasars observed in
the range 1 <
∼ 2 (if H0 is close to the value assumed
in this paper).
∼ z <
∼ z <
6.1.3. Statistical Errors
It is interesting to consider in more detail the sources
that show MBH ∼ 1010 M⊙ in our sample. HE 0248 -- 3628
with the largest estimated MBH is also one of the highest
L/LEdd radiators with L/LEdd∼ 1. It shows an anoma-
lously large (by a factor ∼10) flux with respect to our other
VLT sources which makes it an extremely luminous quasar
(MB<∼ −30; see Sulentic et al., 2004). It falls near the Pop.
A -- B boundary in Eigenvector 1 space and is a borderline
radio-loud source by our definition (Sulentic et al., 2003).
It disappears as an outlier if the MBH estimated from the
tabulated MB is adopted. HE 2355 -- 4621 is a second source
with MBH∼ 1010 M⊙. It behaves like a normal radio-quiet
Pop. B source. The HβBC profile shows a prominent red-
ward asymmetry, which is strongly affecting the width at
half maximum. It is also interesting to consider HE 1104 --
1805, which is the most luminous source in our new sam-
ple with (MB≈ -29.5). It behaves like an ordinary Pop. A
source and shows MBH≈ 5 · 109 M⊙ which may be over-
estimated if the continuum is lens brightened (Appendix
A).
∼ z <
The high-mass wing of the MBH distribution in the
redshift range 1 <
∼ 2 is consistent with the wing of a
Gaussian peaked at ≈ 3 ·109 M⊙ and dispersion ∆ log
MBH ≈ 0.3 if MBH is computed from FWHMcorr(HβBC)
(4 ·109 M⊙ if no correction to HβBC is applied). The
Gaussian dispersion is consistent with the estimated er-
rors of individual measurements. K − S tests do not favor
significantly different peak masses or a much different dis-
persion. This suggests that sources with MBH >∼ 3 ·109
M⊙ of our data might be mostly due to random errors
associated to the uncertainty in individual MBH measure-
ments.
6.1.2. Could A Non-virial Component Yield a Huge
6.1.4. Systematic Effects
MBH?
One might envision a non-virial component that increases
with source luminosity and systematically broadens the
HβBC profile. In our so-called Pop. A sources, the high
ionization wind that can dominate Civλ1549 emission
might reasonably be expected to produce Balmer line
emission as well. Such an additional (blueshifted) com-
ponent on the HβBC profile would increase FWHM mea-
sures (Sulentic et al., 2006, HE 1249 -- 0648 and HE 1258 --
0823 may show this effect). One intriguing possibility is
that high-luminosity sources are extreme Pop. A sources
which is supported by models invoking a radiation pres-
sure driven wind. Such an effect would make the correc-
tion (∼ 500 km s−1) deduced for low-z Pop. A sources
inadequate. At the other extreme, strong redward asym-
metries observed in Pop. B sources indicate that the in-
tegrated profile may be affected by gravitational redshift
and non-virial motions (Marziani et al., 2003b). A quanti-
tative analysis of these suggestions needs careful analysis
beyond the scope of this paper, but in both cases any cor-
rection would lower MBH.
A first systematic effect considers the uncertainty in the
index α. Our MBH estimates show the onset of MBH>∼
3·109 M⊙ at z ∼0.8; at z >∼0.8 we observe some of the most
luminous HE quasars. The high luminosity range of the
Kaspi et al. (2005) relationship remains poorly sampled:
there are just 2-3 sources in the range 45 <∼ log λLλ <∼
46 (to which most of our intermediate z sources belong),
creating a sample bias and making the correlation analysis
intrinsically unstable. In addition, a recent reanalysis of
the rBLR -- λLλ correlation suggests a value of α as low as
0.5 (Vestergaard & Peterson, 2006). If α is overestimated
by ∆α ≈ 0.17 over a luminosity range of ∼ 10, MBH may
be overestimated by ∆ log MBH≈ 0.2 in our intermediate
z sources.
Pop. A sources show good evidence that LILs are emit-
ted in a strongly flattened system, probably an accretion
disk or gas co-planar with the disk. Civλ1549 in these
sources seems to be dominated by a wind component
(Bachev et al., 2004). If these considerations apply also
to Pop. B sources (but it is by no means clear, given the
large FWHM(HβBC) of sources believed to be observed
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
9
7. Conclusions
Nine intermediate z VLT/ISAAC spectra with high res-
olution and S/N supplement an earlier sample of 17
sources. Emission line measurements on HβBC and Feii
presented in this paper strengthen the conclusion of
Sulentic et al. (2004) that luminosity effects are weak or
absent in the low-ionization lines of AGNs. Results on the
HβBC profile are consistent with the population A-B hy-
pothesis and Eigenvector 1 parameter space concept de-
veloped for low z AGNs. We computed virial masses and
Eddington ratios for the 25 intermediate-z objects plus
about 280 lower z sources, using the same emission line
over the entire redshift range for the first time.
We also have how the distributions of MBH and
L/LEdd vs. z are shaped by selection effects intrinsic to
any flux-limited survey at the low MBH end. At the high
MBH end, masses exceeding a few 109 M⊙ may be rare
if corrections for non-virial broadening and statistical er-
rors are taken into account. This suggestion is based on
just 25 objects distributed over the entire redshift range
0.9 <∼ z <∼ 2.5. Confirmation from a larger sample of
intermediate-z observations is needed.
<
pole-on) and if the maximum angle between disk axis and
line-of-sight is ≈ 45◦, a correction could imply a factor
∼ 2 systematic increase in MBH. However, these consider-
ation of orientation effects may not even reopen the prob-
lem of very large MBH values: if our suggestion of a maxi-
mum MBH≈ 3·109 M⊙ is appropriate, taking into account
the systematic orientation effects would yield a maximum
MBH≈ 6 · 109 M⊙ which is still plausible. The result that
L/LEdd<∼ 1 at z >∼ 0.8 would be reinforced by systematic
orientation effects.
Summing up, our data suggest that very large masses
∼ 1010 M⊙ may be not be real, and may be predominantly
due to statistical errors and emission line profile broaden-
ing that is in part non-virial. The data presented in this
paper are consistent with MBH not exceeding 3·109 M⊙ for
our sources if the correction to FWHM(HβBC) described
earlier is applied.
6.2. The Best MBH Estimators
LILs like Mgiiλ2800 and Feii may yield more reliable re-
sults than HβBC. Hi Balmer line emission can be substan-
tial from gas in a variety of physical conditions. In Pop. B
sources, a very broad component may increase the FWHM
of the integrated HβBC profile (also mimicked by low S/N
data; McIntosh et al., 1999; Shemmer et al., 2004). This
very broad component may be optically thin to the ion-
izing continuum, and therefore non-responsive to contin-
uum changes. The HβBC profile of Pop. A sources may
be affected by a high-ionization component mentioned
earlier. Feii is thought to be emitted in a region very
optically thick to Lyman continuum which is probably
photoionized (Vestergaard & Peterson, 2005; Wang et al.,
2005), as the part of HβBC responding to continuum
changes should be. It is not surprising that the rever-
berating part of HβBC and Feii provides width estimates
which are consistent, since they are expected to mea-
sure the width of a similar sub-region within the BLR.
Similar considerations apply to Mgiiλ2800 (Wills et al.,
1985) since Mgiiλ2800 should be mainly emitted in the
same zone as Feii. McLure & Dunlop (2004) present virial
MBH estimates for ≈13000 quasars in the redshift inter-
val 0.1 <∼ z <∼ 2.1 based on spectra from the SDSS first
data release. The mean MBH increases with increasing red-
shift basically as shown in Fig. 3. The mass values found
by them are also consistent with a limiting MBH around
3 · 109 M⊙, with large scatter. They use FWHM(HβBC)
or FWHM(Mgiiλ2800) and find a consistency between the
most massive at z ≈ 2 and those at z ≈ 0. Given measure-
ment difficulties, and doubts about the virial assumption
for most other lines, corrected measures for HβBC, Feii,
and Mgiiλ2800 may offer the best hope for reliable MBH
and L/LEdd estimates out to z ≈ 2.5.
10
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Acknowledgements. We thank a referee for many useful sug-
gestions and the tenacity to ensure that they were taken into
account. We also thank Lutz Wisotzki for providing us with
the HE optical spectra. D. D-H, and JS acknowledge financial
support from grant IN100703 from PAPIIT, DGAPA, UNAM.
Appendix A: Notes on Individual Sources
A.1. HE0512-3329
HE 0512 -- 3329 was discovered as a probable gravitation-
ally lensed quasar with the Space Telescope Imaging
Spectrograph (STIS). It is a doubly imaged QSO with
a source redshift of z = 1.58 and an image separation
of 0".644. The flux ratio A
B of the lensed images shows a
strong dependence on wavelength. In the R and I bands,
A is brighter than B by about 0.45 mag while the two
are almost equal in the band B. For smaller wavelengths,
especially close to the limit near 2000 A, B becomes
much brighter than A by about 1.3 mag. A natural ex-
planation for this effect is differential reddening caused
by different extinction effects in the two lines of sight
(Gregg et al., 2000). Microlensing by stars and other com-
pact object in the lensing galaxy also plays a role in this
source (Wucknitz et al., 2003). Unfortunately, the small
separation does not allow to us to distinguish component
A and B on the ISAAC spectrum. The HE 0512 -- 3329 ac-
quisition image is compatible with an unresolved source.
Considering the flux ratios in the R and I band, it is rea-
sonable to assume that our spectrum is dominated by the
A component.
A.2. HE1104-1805
HE 1104-1805 is a double-image lensed quasar discov-
ered by Wisotzki et al. (1993). The image separation is
∆θ = 3′′.19, the source redshift is zs = 2.319, and the
lens redshift is zl = 0.729. Wisotzki et al. (1995 ) reported
that the continuum flux in both images is highly variable
but that the line fluxes do not change, as expected if mi-
crolensing is operating. On the acquisition image of HE
1104 there is a second source at 3.5" but it is completely
off-slit.
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
11
Table 1. Basic Properties of Sources and Log of Observations
Object name
(1)
HE0507−3236
HE0512−3329
HE0926−0201
HE0946−0500
HE1003+0149
HE1017−0009
HE1104−1805
HE1249−0648
HE1258−0823
ma
B
(2)
17.36
17.03
16.23
16.24
16.45
16.69
16.45
16.72
16.26
zb
(3)
Linec M d
B
(5)
(4)
log Re
K
(6)
Datef
(7)
Bandg DITh Ni
exp Airmassj
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
1.5770 (7)
1.5873 (7)
1.6824 (7)
1.1013 (7)
1.0809 (7)
1.1295 (7)
2.3192 (7)
1.1940 (7)
1.1632 (7)
1
1
1
1
1,2
1
1,2
1
1
−27.6 <∼ 0.51
−28.0 <∼ 0.38
−29.0 <∼ -0.33
−28.0 <∼ 0.03
−27.7
−27.6
−29.6 <∼ 0.19
−27.7 <∼ 0.23
−28.1 <∼ 0.04
0.20
0.87
2003-10-22
2003-10-22
2004-02-11
2004-02-11
2004-02-13
2004-02-28
2004-02-11
2004-02-05
2004-03-29
J
J
J
sZ
sZ
sZ
sH
sZ
sZ
180
180
180
180
180
180
180
180
180
18
16
12
12
12
12
20
16
17
1.23-1.09
1.07-1.02
1.11-1.17
1.17-1.27
1.19-1.14
1.97-1.62
1.14-1.35
1.04-1.06
1.06-1.16
S/Nk
(12)
25 -- 20
20 -- 15
30 -- 10
30
20
20 -- 10
20
30 -- 15
30
a Apparent B magnitude corrected because of Galactic absorption.
b Redshift, with uncertainty in parenthesis.
c Lines used for redshift calculations: 1: Hβ, 2: [Oiii]λ5007.
d Absolute B magnitude, computed for H0=70 km s−1Mpc−1, ΩM = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7, and k-correction spectral index a=0.6.
e Decimal logarithm of the specific flux ratio at 6cm and 4400 A (effective wavelength of the B band). Upper limits are from
the NVSS (≈ 2.5 mJy), and would place all undetected sources in the RQ domain.
f Date refers to time at start of exposure.
g Photometric band.
h Detector Integration Time (DIT) of ISAAC, in seconds.
i Number of exposures with single exposure time equal to DIT.
j Airmass at start and end of exposure.
k S/N at continuum level in the proximity of Hβ. Two values are reported in case of different S/N on the blue and red side
of Hβ (blue side first). The S/N value is with N estimated at a 2σ confidence level i.e., 2 times the rms.
Table 2. Measurements of Fluxes, Equivalent Widths and FWHM of Strongest Lines
Object name
F(HβBC)a W(HβBC)b W(Feiiλ4570)c
FWHM(Feiiλ4570)d
(1)
(2)
HE0507−3236
HE0512−3329
HE0926−0201
HE0946−0500
HE1003+0149
HE1017−0009
HE1104−1805
HE1249−0648
HE1258−0823
12.5 ± 3.0
20.0 +5.0
−3.0
26.0 ± 4.0
17.0 +3.0
−2.0
7.0 ± 1.0
10.5 ± 1.0
20.0 ± 4.0
15.5 ± 2.0
24.0 ± 3.0
(3)
62 ±20
75 +30
−10
72 ± 15
59 +20
−10
48 ± 10
60 +15
−10
72 ± 15
63 ± 15
44 ± 10
(4)
17 ± 3
47 ± 10
20 ± 2
19 +5
−3
67 ± 12
11 +5
−3
39 +7
−5
31 +5
−2
20 ± 4
(5)
4100 +1600
−900
2400 +1300
−500
3400 ± 1200
2900 ± 1000
2100 ± 1400
3600 +2100
−1300
4100 ± 1700
1400 +1000
1400 +1000
−400
−0
Appendix B: Minimum MBH and L/LEdd as a
Function of z
The absolute B magnitude MB can be related to the spe-
cific luminosity at 5100 A assuming an average spectral
shape between 4400 (effective wavelength of B band) and
5100 A. If the spectral shape is described by a power-law
(fν ∝ ν−b) with b = 0.3 (Marziani et al., 2003b):
log[λLλ(λ = 5100A)] = −0.4MB + 35.497.
(B.1)
If we further assume that L = 10λ · Lλ, with λ=5100
A i.e., a bolometric correction factor 10, we can write:
log[λLλ(λ = 5100A)] =
L
10 · LEdd · 1.3 · 1047MBH,9⊙ (B.2)
where the black hole mass MBH has been written in
units of 109 M⊙. The absolute magnitude MB is:
MB = mB + 5 − 5 log dL − 2.5(a − 1) log(1 + z)
(B.3)
where the luminosity distance dL is in parsec, and the
last term is the K(z) correction.
the co-moving distance:
Assuming ΩM 6= 0, ΩΛ 6= 0, and Ωk = 0, we have for
H0 Z z
(B.4)
dC =
dz ′
c
0
pΩM(1 + z)3 + ΩΛ
This integral can be approximated with residuals less
c
than 3% at all z (maximum error for z → 0).
6.107(cid:1) + 0.996(cid:0)1 − e−
dC ≈
H0 (cid:2)(1.500)(cid:0)1 − e−
z
z
1.266(cid:1)(cid:3) (B.5)
12
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Object name
F(HβNC)e W(HβNC)f W([Oiii]λ4959)f W([Oiii]λ5007)f
(6)
HE0507−3236
HE0512−3329
HE0926−0201
HE0946−0500
HE1003+0149
HE1017−0009
HE1104−1805
HE1249−0648
HE1258−0823
(7)
7:
3:
28:
14 +9
−5
15 +18
−5
15 +10
−5
60 ± 18
18 ± 5
9:
(8)
0.3:
0.1:
0.8:
0.9
1.0
0.8
2.0 ± 0.5
0.7 ± 0.3
0.8 ± 0.3
(9)
2.7 ± 0.5
2.5 ± 0.5
5.6 ± 0.5
1.1 ± 0.5
0.6 ± 0.5
1.4 ± 0.5
3.9 ± 0.5
...
...
(10)
8.4 ± 0.6
6.5 ± 1.0
15.2 ± 1.0
3.4 ± 0.6
1.7 ± 0.5
3.8 ± 0.6
11.4 ± 0.5
...
...
a Rest frame flux of HβBC in units of 10−13 ergs s−1 cm−2 and ±2σ confidence level uncertainty.
b Rest frame equivalent width of HβBC in A ±2σ confidence level uncertainty.
c Rest frame equivalent width of the Feiiλ4570 blend in A ±2σ confidence level uncertainty.
d FWHM of lines in the Feiiλ4570 blend and uncertainty at 2σ, in km s−1. See text for details.
e Rest frame flux of HβNC in units of 10−16 ergs s−1 cm−2 and ±2σ confidence level uncertainty. Colons indicate highly
uncertain values.
f Rest frame equivalent width of HβNC, [Oiii] l4959, and [Oiii]λ5007 in A, with uncertainty at 2σ. Colons indicate highly
uncertain values.
Table 3. HβBC Line Profile Measurements
Source
(1)
FWZIa ∆a,b
(3)
(2)
FWHMa ∆a,b
(5)
(4)
A.I.c
(6)
HE0507−3236
HE0512−3329
HE0926−0201
HE0946−0500
HE1003+0149
HE1017−0009
HE1104−1805
HE1249−0648
HE1258−0823
16000
16000
17000
20000
9000
16000
15000
21000
17000
2100
3700
1400
2800
2100
3800
1500
1000
2600
3500
3100
5100
3600
2900
6200
4300
4900
4400
300 −0.15
300 −0.16
500
0.21
250 −0.06
280 −0.06
290 −0.04
260
0.11
500
0.13
500 −0.08
∆b
(7)
0.10
0.07
+0.07
−0.19
0.09
+0.07
−0.11
+0.08
−0.05
0.09
+0.11
−0.07
+0.20
−0.08
Kurt.d ∆b
(9)
(8)
c(0/4) ∆a,b
(11)
(10)
0.31
0.31
0.27
0.37
0.33
0.41
0.38
0.31
0.23
0.06
0.04
0.06
0.05
0.05
0.04
0.05
0.05
0.06
−500
−100
1200
−600
−400
200
900
1400
−700
1100
1900
700
1400
1000
1900
800
500
1300
The luminosity distance is:
References
dL = dC(1 + z)
(B.6)
and we can use the new relationship to derive a working
relationship for MBH:
MBH,9⊙ = 3.85 · 106h−2(cid:18) L
z
LEdd(cid:19)−1
6.107(cid:1) +(cid:0)1 − e−
· 10−0.4mB ·
1.266(cid:1)(cid:3)2
z
·(cid:2)1.5(cid:0)1 − e−
assume a = 0.6. Differences for 0.3 <
where h = H0/75. Curves shown in Figs. 3, 5, 6, 7
∼ 0.6 are minor.
∼ a <
Aoki, K., Kawaguchi, T., & Ohta, K. 2005, ApJ, 618, 601
Bachev, R., Marziani, P., Sulentic J. W., Dultzin-Hacyan
D., Calvani M., ApJ, in press
Baldwin, J. A., et al. 1996, ApJ, 461, 664
Bernardi, M., et al. 2003, AJ, 125, 1866
Bernardi, M., et al. 2005, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints,
arXiv:astro-ph/0510696
(1 + z)(1−a),
Boroson, T. A. 2003, ApJ, 585, 647
Boroson, T.
2005, ArXiv Astrophysics
e-prints,
arXiv:astro-ph/0505127
Boroson, T. A., & Green, R. F. 1992, ApJS, 80, 109
Boyle, B. J., Shanks, T., Croom, S. M., Smith, R. J.,
Miller, L., Loaring, N., & Heymans, C. 2000, MNRAS,
317, 1014
Brotherton, M. S., Wills, B. J., Steidel, C. C., & Sargent,
W. L. W. 1994, ApJ, 423, 131
Brotherton, M. S. 1996, ApJS, 102, 1
Collin-Souffrin, S., Dyson, J. E., McDowell, J. C., & Perry,
J. J. 1988, MNRAS, 232, 539
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
13
Source
(12)
c(1/4) ∆a,b
(13)
(14)
c(1/2)a ∆a,b
(16)
(15)
c(3/4)a ∆a,b
(18)
(17)
c(0.9)a ∆a,b
(20)
(19)
HE0507−3236
HE0512−3329
HE0926−0201
HE0946−0500
HE1003+0149
HE1017−0009
HE1104−1805
HE1249−0648
HE1258−0823
−300
−500
800
−300
−100
−900
200
400
−400
300
200
+400
−1100
200
200
300
300
400
+700
−300
50
−180
−150
−320
−50
−610
−180
−70
−330
150
150
250
120
130
130
130
240
220
100
−80
−160
−160
−20
−350
−190
−60
−30
90
80
130
100
70
140
120
130
110
90
−30
−110
−70
10
−360
−190
−110
−40
50
50
80
70
50
120
80
80
50
a In units of km s−1.
b 2σ confidence level uncertainty.
c Asymmetry index defined as in Marziani et al. (1996).
d Kurtosis parameter as in Marziani et al. (1996).
Corbin, M. R. 1991, ApJ, 375, 503
Corbin, M. R., & Francis, P. J. 1994, AJ, 108, 2016
de Robertis, M. 1985, ApJ, 289, 67
Ferrarese, L., & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJL, 539, L9
Gaskell, C. M. 1982, ApJ, 263, 79
Gebhardt, K., et al. 2000, ApJL, 539, L13
Giveon, U. et al. 1999, MNRAS, 306, 637
Gregg, M. D., Wisotzki, L., Becker, R. H., Maza, J.,
Schechter, P. L., White, R. L., Brotherton, M. S., &
Winn, J. N. 2000, AJ, 119, 2535
Grupe, D., Beuermann, K., Mannheim, K., & Thomas,
H.-C. 1999, A&A, 350, 805
Marziani P., Zamanov R., Sulentic J. W., Calvani M.,
2003c, MNRAS, 345, 1133 S. 2000, MNRAS, 314, L17
Mathur, S., Kuraszkiewicz, J., & Czerny, B. 2001, New
Astronomy, 6, 321
McIntosh, D. H., Rieke, M. J., Rix, H.-W., Foltz, C. B.,
& Weymann, R. J. 1999, ApJ, 514, 40
McLure, R. J., & Dunlop, J. S. 2001, MNRAS, 327, 199
McLure, R. J., & Dunlop, J. S. 2004, MNRAS, 352, 1390
McLure, R. J., & Jarvis, M. J. 2004, MNRAS, 353, L45
McLure, R. J., Jarvis, M. J., Targett, T. A., Dunlop,
J. S., & Best, P. N. 2005, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints,
arXiv:astro-ph/0510121
Jackson, N., Perez, E.,& Penston, M. V. 1991, MNRAS,
Metcalf, R. B., & Magliocchetti, M. 2006, MNRAS, 365,
249, 577
101
Joly, M. 1988, AAp, 192, 87
Kaspi S., Smith P.S., Netzer H., et al. 2000, ApJ, 533, 631
Kaspi, S., Maoz, D., Netzer, H., Peterson, B. M.,
Vestergaard, M., & Jannuzi, B. T. 2005, ArXiv
Astrophysics e-prints, arXiv:astro-ph/0504484
Koratkar, A. P., & Gaskell, C. M. 1991, ApJL, 370, L61
Krolik, J. H. 2001, ApJ, 551, 72
Kuraszkiewicz, J. K., Green, P. J., Crenshaw, D. M.,
Dunn, J., Forster, K., Vestergaard, M., & Aldcroft, T. L.
2004, ApJS, 150, 165
Laor, A. 2001, ApJ, 553, 677
Malkan, M. A., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1982, ApJ, 254, 22
Marconi, A., & Hunt, L. K. 2003, ApJ, 589, L21
Marziani, P., & Sulentic, J. W. 1993, ApJ, 409, 612
Marziani P., Sulentic J.W., Dultzin-Hacyan D., Calvani
M., Moles M., 1996, ApJS 104, 37
Netzer, H. 2003, ApJ, 583, L5
Onken, C. A., Ferrarese, L., Merritt, D., Peterson, B. M.,
Pogge, R. W., Vestergaard, M., & Wandel, A. 2004,
ApJ, 615, 645
Osterbrock, D. E., & Shuder, J. M. 1982, ApJS, 49, 149
Peng, C. Y., Impey, C. D., Ho, L. C., Barton, E. J.,
& Rix, H.-W. 2005, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints,
arXiv:astro-ph/0509155
Peterson, B. M., & Wandel, A. 1999, ApJL, 521, L95
Peterson, B. M., & Wandel, A. 2000, ApJ, 540, L13
Peterson, B. M., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 682
Reimers, D., Koehler, T., & Wisotzki, L. 1996, AApS, 115,
235
Richards, G. T., Vanden Berk, D. E., Reichard, T. A.,
Hall, P. B., Schneider, D. P., SubbaRao, M., Thakar,
A. R., & York, D. G. 2002, AJ, 124, 1
Marziani P., Sulentic J.W., Zwitter T., Dultzin-Hacyan
Rokaki, E., Lawrence, A., Economou, F., & Mastichiadis,
D., Calvani M., 2001, ApJ, 558, 553 (M01)
A. 2003, MNRAS, 340, 1298
Marziani P., Sulentic J. W., Zamanov R., Calvani M.,
Dultzin-Hacyan D., Bachev R., Zwitter T., 2003a,
ApJS, 145, 199 (M03)
Marziani, P., Zamanov, R., Sulentic, J. W., Dultzin-
Hacyan, D., Bongardo, C., & Calvani, M. 2003b, ASP
Conf. Ser. 290: Active Galactic Nuclei: From Central
Engine to Host Galaxy, 229
Shang, Z., et al. 2004, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints,
astro-ph/0409697
Sheth, R. K., et al. 2003, ApJ, 594, 225
Shemmer, O., Netzer, H., Maiolino, R., Oliva, E., Croom,
S., Corbett, E., & di Fabrizio, L. 2004, ApJ, 614, 547
Shields, J. C., Ferland, G. J., & Peterson, B. M. 1995,
ApJ, 441, 507
14
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Stirpe, G. M. 1990, A&AS, 85, 1049
Sulentic, J. W. 1989, ApJ, 343, 54
Sulentic, J. W., Zheng, W., Calvani, M., & Marziani, P.
1990, ApJ, 355, L15
Sulentic, J. W., Marziani, P., & Dultzin-Hacyan, D. 2000a,
ARA&A, 38, 521
Sulentic, J. W., Marziani, P., Zwitter, T., Dultzin-Hacyan,
D., & Calvani, M. 2000b, ApJ, 536, L5
Sulentic, J. W., Marziani, P., Zwitter, T., Dultzin-Hacyan,
D., & Calvani, M. 2000c, ApJL, 545, L15
Sulentic, J. W., Marziani, P., Zamanov, R., Bachev, R.,
Calvani, M., & Dultzin-Hacyan, D. 2002, ApJ, 566, L71
Sulentic J. W., Zamfir S., Marziani P., Bachev R., Calvani
M., Dultzin-Hacyan D., 2003, ApJ, 597, L17
Sulentic, J. W., Stirpe, G. M., Marziani, P., Zamanov, R.,
Calvani, M., & Braito, V. 2004, AAp, 423, 121 (Paper
I)
Sulentic, J. W., Dultzin-Hacyan, D.., Marziani, P.,
Bongardo, C., Braito V., Zamanov, R., Calvani, M.
2006, RevMexAAp, accepted
Treu, T., Malkan, M. A., & Blandford, R. D. 2004, ApJ,
615, L97
V´eron-Cetty, M.-P., V´eron, P., & Gon¸calves, A. C. 2001,
A&A, 372, 730
Vestergaard, M. 2002, ApJ, 571, 733
Vestergaard, M., & Peterson, B. M. 2005, ApJ, 625, 688
Vestergaard, M., & Peterson,
2006,
B. M.
astro-ph/0601303
Wandel, A., Peterson, B. M., & Malkan, M. A. 1999, ApJ,
526, 579
Wanders, I., et al. 1995, ApJL, 453, L87
Wang, J. 2003, AJ, 125, 2859
Wang, J., Wei, J. Y., & He, X. T. 2005, A&A, 436, 417
Wills, B. J., Netzer, H., & Wills, D. 1985, ApJ, 288, 94
Wisotzki, L., Koehler, T., Ikonomou, M., & Reimers, D.
1995, A&A, 297, L59
Wisotzki, L., Koehler, T., Kayser, R., & Reimers, D. 1993,
A&A, 278, L15
Wisotzki, L., Christlieb, N., Bade, N., Beckmann, V.,
Kohler, T., Vanelle, C., & Reimers, D. 2000, A&A, 358,
77
Wu, X.-B., Wang, R., Kong, M. Z., Liu, F. K., & Han,
J. L. 2004, AAp, 424, 793
Wucknitz, O., Wisotzki, L., Lopez, S., & Gregg, M. D.
2003, A&A, 405, 445
Zamanov, R., Marziani, P., Sulentic, J. W., Calvani, M.,
Dultzin-Hacyan, D., & Bachev, R. 2002, ApJ, 576, L9
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
15
Fig. 1. Calibrated VLT-ISAAC spectra for 9 new intermediate-redshift quasars. Abscissae are rest-frame wavelength
in A, ordinates the rest-frame specific flux in units of 10−15 ergs s−1 cm−1 A−1.
16
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Fig. 2. Spectral Atlas for the new intermediate-redshift quasars. Left-hand panels show the continuum-subtracted
Hβ spectral region. Axes are the same as Fig. 1. The best-fit Feii emission model is traced as a thin (green) line.
Right-hand panels show the enlarged Hβ profiles after continuum and Feii subtraction. The (blue and red) thick line
shows a spline fit of the short and long wavelength sides of the HβBC profile, respectively.
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
17
Fig. 3. Distribution of MBH estimates as a function of z using uncorrected FWHM(HβBC) values. Intermediate z
sources observed with ISAAC are at z >∼ 0.8. The solid curve estimates the minimum detectable MBH for our sample
-- see text.
18
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Fig. 4. FWHM measured from the variable part of the HβBC profile for low-z sources with reverberation data
(Peterson et al., 2004) versus FWHM(HβBC) (km s−1) measures from Marziani et al. (2003c). Solid straight lines
show best fits for FWHM(HβBC)≤ 4000 km s−1(Pop. A) and for sources with broader lines(Pop. B). The solid curve
shows a weighted least-square fit of all data with a second order polynomial. The diagonal dot-dashed line indicates
the location of equal ordinate and abscissa values.
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
19
Fig. 5. MBH computed from corrected FWHMcorr(HβBC) as a function of z (filled circles). MBH estimates computed
from FWHM(Feiiλ4570) measures are shown as open symbols. Symbol types and solid curve are as described for Fig.
3.
20
Sulentic et al.: Hβ in Intermediate z Quasars: MBH and L/LEdd
Fig. 6. MBH computations using same samples as Fig. 3, where RQ and RL sources are indicated by filled and open
symbols respectively (upper panel). Triangles indicate sources for which radio data are insufficient to compute a
meaningful RK. The lower panel distinguishes MBH for Pop. A (filled symbols) and Pop. B (open symbols). The solid
curve is as described for Fig. 3.
Fig. 7. Distribution of L/LEdd with z following Fig. 3 with λLλ values derived from the 5100 A rest-frame flux and
with α = 0.67. E1 Populations A and B are indicated by filled and open symbols respectively. The solid line traces
the minimum L/LEdd for a fixed mass value of 4· 109 M⊙ to observe a quasar above the limiting magnitude of the HE
quasar survey mB ≈ 17.5. The dot-dashed lines indicate the same limit but assuming limiting magnitude mB ≈ 16.5.
|
astro-ph/9710033 | 1 | 9710 | 1997-10-02T21:58:44 | Long-Term Flux Monitoring of LSI +61 303 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz | [
"astro-ph"
] | LSI +61 303 is an exotic binary system consisting of a ~10 Msun B star and a compact object which is probably a neutron star. The system is associated with the interesting radio source GT0236+610 that exhibits bright radio outbursts with a period of 26.5 days. We report the results of continuous daily radio interferometric observations of GT0236+610 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz from 1994 January to 1996 February. The observations cover 25 complete (and 3 partial) cycles with multiple observations each day. We detect substantial cycle-to-cycle variability of the radio emission characterized by a rapid onset of the radio flares followed by a more gradual decrease of the emission. We detect a systematic change of the radio spectral index alpha which typically becomes larger than zero at the onset of the radio outbursts. This behavior is suggestive of expansion of material initially optically thick to radio frequencies, indicating either that synchrotron or inverse Compton cooling are important or that the free-free optical depth to the source is rapidly changing. After two years of observations, we see only weak evidence for the proposed 4-year periodic modulation in the peak flux of the outbursts. We observe a secular trend in the outburst phases according the the best published ephemeris. This trend indicates either orbital period evolution, or a drift in outburst orbital phase in response to some other change in the system. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Long-Term Flux Monitoring of LSI +61◦ 303 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz
7
9
9
1
t
c
O
2
1
v
3
3
0
0
1
7
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
P. S. Ray1, R. S. Foster2, E. B. Waltman3
Code 7210
Remote Sensing Division
Naval Research Laboratory
Washington, DC 20375
M. Tavani4
Columbia Astrophysics Laboratory
Columbia University
New York, NY 10027
F. D. Ghigo5
National Radio Astronomy Observatory
P.O. Box 2
Green Bank, WV 24944
Received
;
accepted
1E-mail: [email protected], NRC Research Associate
2E-mail: [email protected]
3E-mail: [email protected]
4E-mail: [email protected]
5E-mail: [email protected]
-- 2 --
ABSTRACT
LSI +61◦ 303 is an exotic binary system consisting of a ∼ 10 M⊙ B star and a
compact object which is probably a neutron star. The system is associated with
the interesting radio source GT 0236+610 that exhibits bright radio outbursts
with a period of 26.5 days. We report the results of continuous daily radio
interferometric observations of GT 0236+610 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz from 1994
January to 1996 February. The observations cover 25 complete (and 3 partial)
cycles with multiple observations each day. We detect substantial cycle-to-cycle
variability of the radio emission characterized by a rapid onset of the radio flares
followed by a more gradual decrease of the emission. We detect a systematic
change of the radio spectral index α (defined as Sν ∝ να) which typically
becomes larger than zero at the onset of the radio outbursts. This behavior is
suggestive of expansion of material initially optically thick to radio frequencies,
indicating either that synchrotron or inverse Compton cooling are important
or that the free-free optical depth to the source is rapidly changing. After two
years of observations, we see only weak evidence for the proposed 4-year periodic
modulation in the peak flux of the outbursts. We observe a secular trend in
the outburst phases according the the best published ephemeris. This trend
indicates either orbital period evolution, or a drift in outburst orbital phase in
response to some other change in the system.
Subject headings: radio continuum: stars -- stars: individual (LSI +61◦ 303) --
stars: binaries -- X-rays: binaries
-- 3 --
1.
Introduction
The exotic binary system LSI +61◦ 303 (= V615 Cas = GT 0236+610) is one of a
remarkable class of X-ray and radio emitting binaries which includes the well-known sources
Cir X-1, Cyg X-3 and SS433 (e.g. Hjellming & Johnston 1988). LSI +61◦ 303 is a ∼ 10 M⊙
B0 star at a distance of ∼ 2 kpc (Frail & Hjellming 1991) whose spectrum shows evidence
for rapid rotation and a high-velocity equatorial wind (Hutchings & Crampton 1981). The
B star is in a binary system with a compact companion, most likely a neutron star. This
source is particularly interesting among high-mass binaries because of its strongly variable
emission at wavelengths from radio to X-rays and probably γ-rays. Although this source has
been the target of a great many observations, the energy source and emission mechanisms
responsible for its peculiar behavior remain a mystery.
GT 0236+610 is a highly variable radio source which exhibits periodic radio outbursts
with a period of 26.496 ± 0.008 d (Taylor & Gregory 1984). However, these outbursts are
not stable in phase. Outburst maxima have been seen from phase 0.45 to 0.95, but bright
maxima seem to occur near 0.6 (Paredes, Estalella, & Rius 1990). Phase zero is arbitrarily
defined to be at JD 2443366.775 (Taylor & Gregory 1982). A ∼ 4 year periodic modulation
has been proposed in the amplitude of the radio maxima (Gregory et al. 1989), possibly
due to precession of a relativistic jet, or variable accretion from the B star. The modulation
has been fit with a sinusoidal function with a period of 1476 ± 7 d (Paredes, Estalella, &
Rius 1990) or 1605 ± 24 d (Mart´ı 1993). VLBI observations near maxima show a 2 mas
double source implying source size of about 5.5 × 1013 cm (3.7 AU) and an equipartition
value of 0.7 G for the magnetic field (Massi et al. 1993). The source shows evidence for
rapid expansion ( >∼ 400 km/s), but not for relativistic bulk motions such as those seen in
GRS 1915+105, GRO J1655−40, SS433 and Cyg X-3 (see Mirabel & Rodriguez (1994) for
a review).
-- 4 --
In addition, LSI +61◦ 303 is associated with a weak, variable X-ray source which
has been observed with Einstein, ROSAT, and ASCA (Bignami et al. 1981, Goldoni &
Mereghetti 1995, Taylor et al. 1996, Leahy, Harrison, & Yoshida 1997). The X-ray source
(in the one well-sampled cycle) is brightest (∼ 1.5 × 1033 erg/s, 0.07-2.48 keV, assuming
a distance of 2.0 kpc and without correcting for absorption) during the radio quiet phase,
although the relationship is poorly determined because of very sparsely sampled X-ray
data. The X-ray spectrum is an absorbed power-law with photon index ∼ −1.7 with no
evidence for an Iron line (Leahy, Harrison, & Yoshida 1997).
LSI +61◦ 303 is exceptional among X-ray binaries in that it is the most probable
counterpart to the COS-B and EGRET γ-ray source 2CG 135+01 (Hermsen et al.
1977, Fichtel et al. 1994, Tavani et al. 1996) with an implied luminosity of ∼ 8 × 1034 erg/s
above 100 MeV (for a distance of 2.0 kpc). The radio position is between the 68% and
95% confidence level contours of the best γ-ray position determination (Thompson et al.
1995, Kniffen et al. 1997) by EGRET. Both COMPTEL and OSSE have observed emission
from this region (van Dijk et al. 1996, ) but have not been able to exclude the nearby
QSO0241+622 as the source.
In 1994 January, we began dual-frequency radio monitoring observations of LSI +61◦ 303
to follow the radio flux density and spectral index of the source during ASCA X-ray
observations (Leahy, Harrison, & Yoshida 1997, Ray et al. 1996). These observations
were continued through 1996 February and supported Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory
observations (Tavani et al. 1996). Multi-frequency observations are a good way to probe
the physical conditions of the source. Because of the large cycle-to-cycle variations, it is
imperative to track the state of the radio emission during high-energy observations. This
paper summarizes the radio observations (§2) and discusses implications for models (§3) of
this unique system.
-- 5 --
2. Observations
The observations reported here were made several times per day (with a few gaps)
from 1994 January 27 to 1996 February 23. The monitoring was performed with the
National Radio Astronomy Observatory Green Bank Interferometer (GBI) in Green
Bank, West Virginia. The GBI consists of two 26 m antennas on a 2.4 km baseline
each of which has a pair of cooled receivers to simultaneously receive signals at 2.25
and 8.3 GHz. The correlators process 35 MHz of bandwidth at each frequency. After
being shut down due to lack of funding from 1996 April through November, the GBI is
currently being operated by NRAO and NASA primarily for radio monitoring of X-ray
sources. All data taken is made available to the public immediately via the WWW
(http://www.gb.nrao.edu/gbint/GBINT.html).
Ten minute scans on LSI +61◦ 303 were performed 1 -- 10 times per day within ±5 hours
of source transit. Each scan consists of a vector sum of the correlator amplitude and phase
from 30 s integrations. Measured correlator amplitudes are converted to flux densities by
comparison to standard, regularly observed calibrators. The resulting data set consists of
6628 flux density measurements of the source at two frequencies over 2.07 yr. Twenty-five
outbursts have nearly complete coverage and three more have partial coverage (due to
hardware or scheduling problems). The receivers have a system temperature of ∼ 40 K, and
individual flux density measurements have errors of:
σ2.25GHz = h(0.006)2 + (0.014S2.25GHz)2i1/2
σ8.3GHz = h(0.009)2 + (0.049S8.3GHz)2i1/2
Jy,
Jy.
(1)
(2)
Note that the constant term has been significantly lowered since 1989 (Fiedler et al. 1987)
by the installation of new cooled HEMT receivers. A fraction of this error estimate is due
to a difficult to calibrate systematic gain variation in the system as a function of hour angle.
The gain variations are likely due to a combination of changing aperture efficiency due to
-- 6 --
deformations of the antenna surface, and weather-dependent phase coherence problems. We
have attempted to correct for the gain variations by fitting the hour-angle dependent effect
observed in a constant source with a second order polynomial. This was used to correct the
observed fluxes for LSI +61◦ 303. The magnitude of the effect at ±5h is about 7% and 20%
for 2.25 and 8.3 GHz, respectively.
The daily average flux density of LSI +61◦ 303 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz as well as the
calculated spectral index are shown in Figure 1 and 2. The error bars on this and other
figures are ±1σ. There is considerable variation from outburst to outburst, but inspection
of the light curves reveals that the higher frequency tends to peak earlier and fade more
quickly than the lower frequency. By cross correlating the light curves at each frequency,
we measure a mean time delay between the 8.3 GHz outburst and the 2.25 GHz outburst of
0.4 days with a large RMS scatter of 0.5 days. In addition, many of the outbursts show two
or more peaks during the decline of the main outburst.
2.1. Spectral evolution
An important feature of this monitoring program is the simultaneous dual-frequency
observations. This allows accurate measurements of the spectral index as a function of time
(orbital phase) in this highly variable source. From two frequency data, we cannot tell
anything about the shape of the spectrum, but we can infer a spectral index (α) assuming
that Sν ∝ να. During typical outbursts we observe the spectral index to rise to a peak with
α between 0 and 0.5 then decay back to the quiescent value of α ∼ −0.4. Our mean light
curves with derived two-frequency spectral index between 2.25 and 8.3 GHz are shown in
Figure 3. Note, however, that the actual radio light curve and spectral index behavior
may substantially change from cycle to cycle. The changing spectral index is a result of
the typical outburst profile decaying more slowly at 2.25 GHz than at 8.3 GHz. By fitting
-- 7 --
Gaussian profiles to the outbursts, we find that the characteristic widths of the 2.25 GHz
profiles are 28% larger than that of the 8.3 GHz profiles.
The only previous measurements of the spectral index evolution during an outburst are
the statistical results of Taylor & Gregory (1982) and one outburst observed by Taylor &
Gregory (1984). Both of these results reported two-frequency spectral indices between 5 and
10 GHz. Realistic models for the radio spectrum of this source are not simple power laws
(Mart´ı 1993), and free-free absorption will be much more important at 2.3 GHz than at 5
GHz, so direct comparison of our results to previous ones is somewhat difficult. However, in
the one outburst with two-frequency measurements, the spectral index is slightly negative
at the peak and the decay phase of the outburst is consistent with a constant spectral
index. Also, their statistical results show a strong peak in spectral index of nearly α = 2 at
around phase 0.4. We see no evidence for positive spectral indices except at the peak of the
outbursts.
There are several energy loss mechanisms which may be important in an expanding
cloud of relativistic electrons including adiabatic expansion, synchrotron emission, and
inverse Compton scattering (Pacholczyk 1970). Each of these affects the shape of the
electron energy distribution function and thus the observed spectral index in different ways.
Inverse Compton scattering and synchrotron losses both have dE/dt ∝ E 2 which result
in a spectral index changing toward more negative values during the decay phase of the
outburst. Adiabatic expansion implies dE/dt ∝ E which results in a constant spectral
index, which is not seen in the decay phase of the outbursts. The multiple peaks in the light
curves of the outbursts indicate continuing particle injection. It is clear that the production
of energetic particles in this source cannot be modeled as a simple delta function of time.
The observed spectral index evolution may also be (at least partially) the result of the
source being embedded in a high-optical-depth envelope such as the ionized stellar wind
-- 8 --
of the B star. In this case, the emitted radio emission will be modified by the free-free
opacity of the wind. This envelope may be completely opaque near periastron and the
optical depth may remain greater than unity for 6 -- 22 days (Massi et al. 1993). Thus, the
observed outburst onset may occur well after the initial acceleration event. Since the wind
opacity is a strong function of frequency (the optical depth τ = T −1.5
e
ν −2.1EM, where the
emission measure EM = R n2
to brighten first if this is an important effect, as is observed.
eds; Pacholczyk 1970), one would expect the higher frequency
2.2. Long-term periodicity
The proposed long-term periodicity has previously been fitted with rather sparse data:
14 peak flux measurements covering only 2 -- 3 periods of the modulation (Mart´ı 1993).
Possible explanations include: variable beaming from a precessing relativistic jet (Gregory
et al. 1989), variable wind velocity from the B star resulting in a variable accretion rate
onto the neutron star (Mart´ı & Paredes 1995), or precession of the B star in the neutron
star magnetic field (Lipunov & Nazin 1994).
The peak fluxes (at 8.3 GHz) of the 18 outbursts observed by the GBI are shown
in Figure 4 along with the previous observed outburst maxima (observed at 5, 8, or 10
GHz) used to fit the sinusoidal model by Paredes, Estalella, & Rius (1990) and Mart´ı
(1993). An expanded view of only the new data is shown in Figure 5. Both figures include
the previously published models for the modulation. Our data rule out the four-year
modulation model of Paredes, Estalella, & Rius (1990), but are marginally consistent with
the model of Mart´ı (1993) in which
Smax = A cos [
2π
P
(t − t0)] + B,
(3)
where A = 114 ± 8 mJy, t0 = JD 2443464 ± 100, A = 114 ± 9 mJy, and P = 1605 ± 24 d.
-- 9 --
However, no evidence for any secular trend in the peak flux data at 2.25 GHz (shown in
Figure 6) is observed.
2.3. Ephemeris
Figure 7 shows the phase of the outburst maxima as a function of date. These
phases were determined by cross correlating the observed fluxes with a template. Due to
incomplete sampling of the fluxes, and occasional high points which may be due to radio
interference, fitting outburst phases by cross correlation is more robust than simply taking
the time of the measurement with the highest flux. The offset between the two frequencies
may be partially due to a different template with a different fiducial point being used for
each frequency.
A secular trend in the outburst phases is evident. To characterize this effect, we have
fit the outburst times of the 8.3 GHz data to a linear model
tn = t0 + n × P,
(4)
where tn is the peak time of the nth outburst. Fitting for t0 and P using 26 measured
outburst times yields t0 = JD2449393.5 ± 0.4, and P = 26.69 ± 0.02 days. With these
parameters, equation 4 provides a good ephemeris for recent outburst maxima. The RMS
difference between the model and the actual outburst times is 1.1 days. Since the differences
of the measured outburst times from a linear model could have contributions from many
sources including intrinsic variability, cross correlation errors due to shape variations from
outburst to outburst, and normal measurement errors, the standard deviations used in the
fitting process were calculated from the RMS residuals after fitting a linear model to the
data.
We note that our best estimate of the period is significantly different (> 9σ) from the
-- 10 --
best previously published value of 26.496 ± 0.008 days (Taylor & Gregory 1984). There
are several possible explanations for this result. Either there has been real orbital period
evolution in the 10 -- 12 years since the previous result was published, or the outburst peaks
tend to move around in orbital phase in response to some other parameter in the system,
such as the B star mass-loss rate, or a precession period. This other parameter may
also be related to the possible modulation in the outburst maxima discussed above. The
required orbital period derivative to explain currently observed period is (3.5 ± 0.03) × 10−5,
consistent with the upper limit of 1.6 × 10−4 from Taylor & Gregory (1984). The timescale
implied by P/ P is 2 × 103 yr, two orders of magnitude less than that observed in the two
HMXB systems (Cen X-3 and SMC X-1) with measured orbital period derivatives. Thus
the interpretation as true orbital period change seems unlikely. These two models predict
rather different behavior over the next several years. Real orbital period evolution will
result in a continued gradual lengthening of the period while a drift in the outburst orbital
phase predicts that the phase should recover back to 0.6, possibly in response to the 4-year
modulation. A complete analysis of all published data over the 20 years since the source
was discovered is in progress (M. Peracaula, personal communication) which may resolve
this question.
3. Discussion
Most models of this source share the feature that the radio emission is due to
synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons moving in a magnetic field. However,
there is no consensus as to the means of production of these particles, or their relation
to the high-energy emission. Several mechanisms for creating the required relativistic
electron population which have been proposed for LSI +61◦ 303 are summarized below to
demonstrate the wide variety of possible mechanisms.
-- 11 --
Maraschi & Treves (1981) (see also Tavani 1995) proposed that the relativistic electrons
are from a young pulsar wind, and that the X-ray and γ-ray emission comes from Compton
scattering of optical photons from the primary B star at a shock boundary between the
pulsar wind and the stellar wind. Taylor & Gregory (1984) proposed that super-Eddington
accretion onto the neutron star near periastron results in luminosity-driven shocks which
may account for the particle production. Paredes et al. (1991) proposed an adiabatically
expanding synchrotron source with prolonged injection of relativistic particles. Lipunov &
Nazin (1994) proposed that relativistic electrons from a pulsar wind are captured by the
magnetosphere of the B star and cooled by synchrotron losses. Recent work (e.g. Campana
et al. 1995) has focused on the accretion regimes of rapidly rotating magnetized neutron
stars in eccentric binaries. Similarly, Zamanov (1995) proposed that the outbursts occur at
the transition of a magnetized neutron star from a propeller phase to an ejector phase as
the mass transfer rate changes in an eccentric orbit.
It is likely that LSI +61◦ 303 is a close relative of the two recently discovered radio
pulsars in B-star binaries (PSR J0045−7319 and PSR B1259−63) and the 69-ms X-ray
pulsar A 0535−668. All three systems contain a rapidly rotating, highly magnetized neutron
star orbiting a massive main-sequence companion. The primary differences between these
systems are the mass-loss rate of the OB star, the geometry of the orbit, and the energy
flux of the pulsar wind. These three factors determine which accretion regime the system
is in. For J0045−7319,
M < 10−10 M⊙ yr−1 (Kaspi, Tauris, & Manchester 1996) and for
B1259−63, 100 < (v/10 km s−1)( M /10−8 M⊙ yr−1) < 104 (Tavani & Arons 1997). Thus,
these two systems have fairly weak stellar winds, active pulsars producing strong outflows,
and B1259−63 does not get very close to the companion at periastron, allowing both
to remain in the radio pulsar regime since matter is unable to accrete onto the pulsar
magnetosphere. On the other hand, A 0535−668, may have a weaker pulsar wind, and
might encounter the thick equatorial disk of the Be star near periastron. This allows
-- 12 --
accretion at about the Eddington rate to occur and produces a powerful X-ray pulsar.
For LSI +61◦ 303, a reasonably good estimate for the mass loss rate from the companion
is
M ∼ 10−7 M⊙ yr−1 (Waters et al. 1988). Campana et al. (1995) suggest that while in
LSI +61◦ 303 the stellar wind ram pressure may be sufficient to overcome the pulsar wind
pressure and accrete onto the magnetosphere, the angular velocity might be super-Keplerian
resulting in the matter being ejected by the propeller mechanism. Alternately, a relatively
young pulsar may power the high energy emission from LSI +61◦ 303 (Maraschi & Treves
1981, Tavani 1995) by a shock mechanism which can be shown to be in agreement with
the intensity and spectral ranges observed for LSI +61◦ 303 in the X-ray range and for
2CG 135+01 in the gamma-ray range (Tavani et al. 1996).
We note that the long-timescale monitoring at 2.25 GHz adds significant new
information compared to previous observations of LSI +61◦ 303 that were made a much
higher frequency. This can be immediately realized by considering the relevance of Figure 3
giving the mean spectral index. The flattening of the spectrum at phases coincident with
the peak radio fluxes is evident. Free-free absorption along the line-of-sight or synchrotron
self-absorption may be responsible for the spectral flattening near phase 0.6. If we assume
a critical absorption frequency at, say, 5 GHz, and a gas temperature of 104 K, we obtain a
free-free optical depth larger than unity for an emission measure EM ≥ 2 · 1025 (cgs units).
We can also estimate the source size L if the spectral flattening is caused by synchrotron
self-absorption. For an estimated radio luminosity of ∼ 2 × 1030 erg s−1, a local magnetic
field of ∼ 1 G, we deduce L ∼ 7 × 1012 cm. We notice that the estimated value of L is
not dissimilar from the source size adopted in the adiabatic/synchrotron cooling model by
Paredes et al. 1991. The integration time of 10 minutes prevents us from placing a strong
limit on the source size from rapid variability, but we do find that the source varies by
more than a factor of two within 15 minutes. This is fully consistent with the timescale
L/c ∼ 4 min.
-- 13 --
4. Summary
After 20 months of continuous radio observations of GT 0236+610 we find only weak
evidence for long-term modulation of peak flare amplitudes on a four year time scale. We
observe spectral index variability during the outbursts which implies that either adiabatic
expansion is not the dominant energy loss mechanism in the expanding plasmon or that
the optical depth due to free-free opacity is changing during the outburst. We also observe
an apparent lengthening of the period between outbursts which is fit with a period of
26.69 ± 0.02 days. This may be due to an orbital period derivative of (3.5 ± 0.03) × 10−5
or due to the outburt phases being modulated in response to some other parameter of the
system.
A single self-consistent model for LSI +61◦ 303 remains elusive. Critical questions
include: Are the X-rays and γ-rays produced by the same population of relativistic
electrons? Is the compact object a young pulsar? What is the orbital eccentricity?
A critical diagnostic for distinguishing between the various models is the time
dependence and correlation between the radio, X-ray and γ-ray emission. Multiwavelength
observations with GRO, XTE, and SAX will be important. A collection of resources
to facilitate multifrequency observations of this source is available on the WWW at
http://www.srl.caltech.edu/personnel/paulr/lsi.html. Radio observations at more
than two frequencies will also be useful to separate the effects of free-free absorption,
synchrotron and inverse Compton losses in the evolution of the source spectrum. Finally, a
more accurate determination of the Keplerian orbital parameters is badly needed.
During this work, the Green Bank Interferometer was operated by the National Radio
-- 14 --
Astronomy Observatory for the Naval Research Laboratory and was supported by the
Office of Naval Research. Partial support for the observations and analysis of this source
were supported by a National Aeronautics and Space Administration interagency fund
transfer. Basic research in precision pulsar astrophysics at the Naval Research Laboratory
is supported by the Office of Naval Research. A portion of this work was performed while
one of the authors (PSR) held a National Research Council-NRL Research Associateship.
This research made use of the Simbad database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France.
-- 15 --
REFERENCES
Bignami, G. F., Caraveo, P. A., Lamb, R. C., Markert, T. H., & Paul, J. A. 1981, ApJ, 247,
L85
Campana, S., Stella, L., Mereghetti, S., & Colpi, M. 1995, A&A, 297, 385
Fichtel, C. E. et al. 1994, ApJS, 94(2), 551
Fiedler, R. L. et al. 1987, ApJS, 65, 319
Frail, D. A. & Hjellming, R. M. 1991, AJ, 101, 2126
Goldoni, P. & Mereghetti, S. 1995, A&A, 299, 751
Gregory, P. C., Xu, H.-J., Backhouse, C. J., & Reid, A. 1989, ApJ, 339, 1054
Hermsen, W. et al. 1977, Nature, 269, 494
Hjellming, R. M. & Johnston, K. J. 1988, ApJ, 328, 600
Hutchings, J. B. & Crampton, D. 1981, PASP, 93, 486
Kaspi, V. M., Tauris, T. M., & Manchester, R. N. 1996, ApJ, 459, L717
Kniffen, D. A. et al. 1997, ApJ, 486, 126
Leahy, D. A., Harrison, F. A., & Yoshida, A. 1997, ApJ, 475, 823
Lipunov, V. M. & Nazin, S. N. 1994, A&A, 289, 822
Maraschi, L. & Treves, A. 1981, MNRAS, 194, 1P
Mart´ı, J. 1993. PhD thesis, Universitat de Barcelona
Mart´ı, J. & Paredes, J. M. 1995, A&A, 298, 151
-- 16 --
Massi, M., Paredes, J. M., Estalella, R., & Felli, M. 1993, A&A, 269, 249
Mirabel, I. F. & Rodriguez, L. F. 1994, in Proceedings of the 17th Texas Symposium on
Relativistic Astrophysics, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
Pacholczyk, A. G. 1970, Radio Astrophysics, (San Francisco: Freeman)
Paredes, J. M., Estalella, R., & Rius, A. 1990, A&A, 232, 377
Paredes, J. M., Mart´ı, J., Estalella, R., & Sarrate, J. 1991, A&A, 248, 124
Ray, P. S., Foster, R. S., Waltman, E. B., Ghigo, F. D., & Johnston, K. J. 1996, in Radio
Emission from Stars and the Sun, ed. A. R. Taylor & J. M. Parades, volume 93 of
ASP Conference Series, 249
Strickman, M. S., Tavani, M., Coe, M. J., Steele, I. A., Fabregat, J., Mart´i, J., Paredes,
J. M., & Ray, P. S. 1998, ApJ. submitted
Tavani, M. 1995, in The Gamma-Ray Sky with GRO and SIGMA, ed. M. Signore, P. Salati,
& G. Vedrenne, (Dordrecht: Kluwer), 181
Tavani, M. & Arons, J. 1997, ApJ, 477, 439
Tavani, M. et al. 1996, A&AS, 120, 243
Taylor, A. R. & Gregory, P. C. 1982, ApJ, 255, 210
Taylor, A. R. & Gregory, P. C. 1984, ApJ, 283, 273
Taylor, A. R., Young, G., Peracaula, M., Kenny, H. T., & Gregory, P. C. 1996, A&A, 305,
817
Thompson, D. J. et al. 1995, ApJS, 101, 259
van Dijk, R. et al. 1996, A&A, 315, 485
-- 17 --
Waters, L. B. F. M., Taylor, A. R., van den Heuvel, E. P. J., Habets, G. M. H. J., & Persi,
P. 1988, A&A, 198, 200
Zamanov, R. K. 1995, MNRAS, 272, 308
This manuscript was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
-- 18 --
Fig. 1. -- Flux history of LSI +61◦ 303 at 2.25 and 8.3 GHz from 27 January 1994 to 8 March
1995. The arrows mark phase 0.6 of the published radio ephemeris (Taylor & Gregory 1984).
The triangles mark the outburst phase as determined by cross-correlating with a template
(see Figure 7). The triangles are missing where there was insufficient data to get a good
peak.
-- 19 --
Fig. 2. -- Continuation of Figure1 from 8 March 1995 to 26 February 1996.
-- 20 --
Fig. 3. -- Phase averaged fluxes and spectral index of LSI +61◦ 303.
-- 21 --
Fig. 4. -- Peak outburst flux of LSI +61◦ 303. The dotted line is the best-fit model of Paredes,
Estalella, & Rius (1990). The dashed line is the more recent model of Mart´ı (1993). Stars
and upward pointing arrows (lower limits) are the previously published data on which the
model was based. All data beyond day 9000 are from this work.
-- 22 --
Fig. 5. -- Expanded version. The dotted line is the best-fit model of Paredes, Estalella, &
Rius (1990). The dashed line is the more recent model of Mart´ı (1993).
-- 23 --
Fig. 6. -- Same as Figure 5 except using the 2.25 GHz data.
-- 24 --
Fig. 7. -- Outburst phase determined by cross-correlating with a template.
|
0804.0410 | 1 | 0804 | 2008-04-02T18:28:24 | The Galactic gamma-ray club | [
"astro-ph"
] | The exclusive Galactic gamma-ray club has opened up to new members. Supernova remnants, pulsar wind nebulae, and massive binary systems hosting a compact object have recently joined the young pulsars as firmly established sources of gamma rays in the Milky Way. Massive young stellar clusters are on the waiting list to join the club. Only the fine imaging recently obtained at TeV energies could resolve specific sources. The samples are sparse, but raise exciting questions. The jet or pulsar-wind origin of the emission in binaries has been hotly debated, but it seems that both types of systems have been recently detected. The nature of the radiation in shock accelerators is still questioned: do nuclei contribute a lot, a little, or not to the gamma rays and what energy do they carry away from the shock budget? The acceleration process and the structural evolution of the pulsar winds are still uncertain. The magnetic field distribution in all these systems is a key, but poorly constrained, ingredient to model the multi-wavelength data, particle transport and electron ageing. It must, however, be determined in order to efficiently probe particle distributions and the acceleration mechanisms. The source samples soon to be expected from GLAST and the Cherenkov telescopes should bring new valuable test cases and they will, for the first time, shed statistical light on the collective behaviour of these different types of accelerators. | astro-ph | astro-ph | 30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE
The Galactic Gamma-Ray Club
ISABELLE GRENIER
Laboratoire AIM, CEA/DSM-CNRS-Université Paris Diderot, Service d’Astrophysique, CEA Saclay, 91191 Gif/
Yvette, France
[email protected]
Abstract: The exclusive Galactic γ-ray club has opened up to new members. Supernova remnants,
pulsar wind nebulae, and massive binary systems hosting a compact object have recently joined the
young pulsars as firmly established sources of γ rays in the Milky Way. Massive young stellar clusters
are on the waiting list to join the club. Only the fine imaging recently obtained at TeV energies could
resolve specific sources. The samples are sparse, but raise exciting questions. The jet or pulsar-wind
origin of the emission in binaries has been hotly debated, but it seems that both types of systems have
been recently detected. The nature of the radiation in shock accelerators is still questioned: do nuclei
contribute a lot, a little, or not to the γ rays and what energy do they carry away from the shock
budget? The acceleration process and the structural evolution of the pulsar winds are still uncertain.
The magnetic field distribution in all these systems is a key, but poorly constrained, ingredient to
model the multi-wavelength data, particle transport and electron ageing. It must, however, be deter-
mined in order to efficiently probe particle distributions and the acceleration mechanisms. The source
samples soon to be expected from GLAST and the Cherenkov telescopes should bring new valuable
test cases and they will, for the first time, shed statistical light on the collective behaviour of these
different types of accelerators.
GeV and TeV gamma-ray sources
Major advances in our understanding of the universe
have often come from improving angular resolution at
all wavelengths. The prowess of achieving several arc-
minute resolution at TeV energies with the Cherenkov
telescopes, and soon at GeV energies with GLAST,
indeed opens a new era in γ-ray astronomy. The very
secluded club of identified γ-ray sources, which has
only accepted young pulsars and blazars for decades,
has recently expanded to supernova remnants, pulsar
wind nebulae, and γ-ray binaries. The high-energy
facets of these objects of course raise new and exciting
questions that I will try to briefly review. Yet, such a
resolution does not compare with the imaging capabili-
ties at lower wavelengths and deciding between true
source identification and mere spatial coincidence in
the crowded environments along the Milky Way will
still be a key issue for years to come.
Source detection at GeV energies, unlike at TeV ener-
gies, has to fight against the intense and highly struc-
tured interstellar background that results from cosmic-
ray interactions in the interstellar gas and soft radiation
field. This background is of particular interest to the
ICRC scientists because it probes the cosmic-ray den-
sity through the Galaxy, yet, with respect to point
sources, its imperfect modelling induces systematic
errors in source significance, flux, location, and spatial
extension. Figure 1a illustrates the difference between
the 3rd EGRET (3EG) catalogue [1] and the revised
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
Figure 1: Distribution in Galactic coordinates of (a) the
revised EGRET point sources detected at energies
above 100 MeV on top of an improved interstellar
emission model and using 9 years of EGRET data.
Blue dots, open circles, and black dots respectively
mark the confirmed 3EG sources, the unconfirmed
ones and new sources; (b) the sources currently de-
tected at TeV energies by the Cherenkov telescopes
(courtesy of Robert Wagner).
one presented at the conference [2]. The use of nine
years of EGRET data instead of four at the time of the
3EG catalogue has allowed detection of 31 new
sources, but the fact that as many as 107 former sources
have not been confirmed in the new analysis is primar-
ily due to the improved background that includes new
CO clouds at medium latitudes, new HI maps corrected
for stray radiation, and new maps for the dark gas
phase in the nearby clouds. The latter is dark in the
sense that it is not properly traced by HI and CO emis-
sion. This gas phase has been found in the nearby
Gould Belt clouds [3]. It appears as an excess of both
dust emission and diffuse γ radiation over what the HI
and CO data should yield. Both excesses are strongly
correlated and form spatially coherent structures. So,
both dust and cosmic rays trace some 'dark' gas that
forms an extended layer at the transition between the
dense CO cores and the outer HI envelope of the
clouds. The dark gas column-densities compare with
that measured in HI and CO, so it provides both γ-ray
intensity and structure that were not accounted for in
the earlier background models. Because source detec-
tion methods in γ rays search for significant and point-
like photon excesses above the predicted background,
an ensemble of point sources with the wide EGRET
PSF would compensate for the missing cloud structures
and yield an excellent fit to the data. These 3EG
sources have not been confirmed in the new analysis;
they consist of only six sources with a likely AGN
counterpart and 101 unidentified sources, in particular
the faint and persistent ones that have long been spa-
tially associated with the Gould Belt [4, 5, 6]. The im-
proved GLAST resolution [7] will soon provide much
more accurate maps of the diffuse interstellar emission,
but the same uncertainties in gas tracers and in the
cosmic-ray flux pervading the distant clouds will still
impact source detection and localization near the detec-
tion threshold. At TeV energies, the interstellar inten-
sity falls off more rapidly than most source spectra.
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
This is why we presently detect more TeV than GeV
sources at low latitude, as illustrated in Figure 1b. The
concentration of sources at l < 60° is due to the cover-
age of the HESS survey.
Irradiated clouds
It is, however, striking that the vast majority of TeV
sources have radial extensions of several arc minutes
that correspond to diameters of 20 or 30 parsecs in the
inner spiral arms and molecular ring of the Milky Way.
Pulsar wind nebulae have been seen as extended
sources of TeV radiation and will be reviewed below,
yet an exciting alternative is that some of these sources
trace where the cosmic-ray sources dwell, in other
words that they are due to pockets of enhanced cosmic-
ray flux diffusing away from their source(s) and irradi-
ating the gas on their way. The HESS J1800-240 A and
B sources may serve as useful examples [8]. They cor-
relate well with the integrated CO intensity map of
massive (0.5-1.5 105 M⊙) clouds at a distance of 2 and
4 kpc in the Sagitttarius and Scutum-Crux arms. The
TeV flux requires 10 to 30 times the local cosmic-ray
density if it is due to neutral pion decay. This is much
more than the modest increase in cosmic-ray density
expected in the inner Galaxy from large-scale studies
of the interstellar GeV emission [9]. The increase with
respect to the flux at the solar circle does not exceed a
factor of 1.5 or 2. Another source in this direction,
HESS J1801-233, correlates with CO intensity. It coin-
cides with the rim of the W 28 supernova remnant, but
may not be related to it. The shock wave from W 28 is
known to run into 2000 solar masses of molecular gas
which could be heavily irradiated if acceleration at the
shock manages to remain active in the dense medium
or if particles accelerated earlier and trapped down-
stream still leak out of the remnant. Yet, the HESS
source spatially overlaps with only half of the shocked
gas. The other half exhibits almost as much mass, but is
not detected. It is not obvious that the small mass defi-
cit compared to the TeV-bright side can explain the lack
of emission. The TeV source correlates with a fore-
ground or background CO complex of about 2 104 M⊙
which may or may not be spatially related to the
shocked clouds. It is difficult to tell in this crowded
direction. Again, 10 to 30 times the local cosmic-ray
density is needed to explain the flux in terms of pion
decay in this cloud. It could be provided by W 28 or by
other sources embedded in the cloud.
The three HESS sources associated with CO exhibit
equivalent spectra, with soft photon indices of 2.5-2.7
typical of interstellar emission. When protons of energy
Ep diffuse for a time τ away from their source, with an
interstellar diffusion coefficient D ≈ 1024 (Ep/10
GeV)0.6 m2 s-1, the pion-decay spectrum breaks at an
energy Eγ ≈ 0.17 Ep that shifts with distance L from the
source as L2 ≈ 6 D(Ep).τ [10]. Lower energy particles
cannot reach that far in the same amount of time, so the
spectrum drops at lower energies. The spectrum above
the broad peak falls as E-2.6 for an E-2 source injection
spectrum. The flux also peaks around this characteristic
timescale τ(L, E) since spherical expansion dilutes the
flux on longer time scales (in the same energy band).
The clouds of 104 to 105 solar masses that we are dis-
cussing have typical sizes of 20 to 60 pc, respectively,
near virial equilibrium. The soft E-2.7-2.5 spectra seen by
HESS require a peak proton energy of 600 GeV or less,
that can be seen out to 50 pc after a thousand years of
diffusion. The flux estimates derived by Aharonian &
Atoyan [10] agree reasonably well with the observed
ones. More distant clouds would exhibit too hard spec-
tra and undetectable fluxes at TeV energies. The same
50 pc cloud complex would yield a flux detectable by
GLAST after 50 kyr, with a flat energy spectrum near
the peak that would allow separation from the bulk of
the diffuse interstellar emission. It should be noted,
however, that the diffusion properties in the interstellar
medium are not well characterized, especially in dense
environments where lower diffusion coefficients may
prevail. For a 10 times lower coefficient, one would
have to wait for 10 kyr for the higher energy particles
to diffuse out to get a soft enough TeV spectrum in the
50 pc large cloud, but not too long because the flux
drops by an order of magnitude after 50 kyr [11]. Es-
tablishing several examples of ‘over-irradiated’ clouds
at GeV and TeV energies would therefore prove very
useful to explore the diffusion properties as well as to
locate where the cosmic-ray sources live.
Another example of cloud irradiation has been pro-
posed toward the Galactic centre [12] where the corre-
lation between the molecular gas distribution (as traced
by CS) and the TeV intensity profile may suggest an
overabundance of freshly accelerated cosmic rays.
Given the turmoil in the inner 150 pc of the Milky Way,
it is unfortunately one of the most difficult places to
interpret spatial distributions. Given the tortured struc-
ture of the magnetic field and its possible strength of
100 nT to account for the bright radio arcs, one cannot
use the local value of the diffusion coefficient. The
latter should also largely differ in and out of the plane.
One may ask how the particles can efficiently cross the
radio arc region and numerous other magnetic threads
that stretch perpendicular to the plane between the
central TeV source assumed by the authors and the
peaks detected at l = ± 0.6°. An estimate of the fraction
of particles that escape out vertically would be useful.
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
A second problem is that the secondary electron-
positron flux produced in the hadronic interactions fails
by nearly a factor 100 to mach the radio emission
found in Sgr B2. It does not explain either the unusu-
ally high ionization level measured in the cloud (∼ 4
10-16 s-1) [13]. A pure inverse Compton origin of the
TeV data is difficult to reconcile with the X-ray and
radio fluxes in the cloud and the required magnetic field
is too low [13]. On the other hand, the distribution of
the TeV emission in the whole region follows that of
the fluorescent 6.4 keV line from neutral iron which is
probably excited in the clouds by very low energy
cosmic rays [14]. So these clouds, unlike others at l >
1°, appear to harbour an excess of long-lived, low-
energy cosmic rays as well as fresh high-energy ones.
A passing wave of particles produced by Sgr A East or
another central supernova remnant of the past millennia
is not the end of the story.
Gamma-ray champagne bubbles?
Alternatively, the TeV intensity around Sgr A* corre-
lates with the position of the very young and incredibly
active star-forming regions of the Arches, Quintuplet,
and Sgr B2 clusters,
as well as the less
prominent, but still
very active, Sgr B1
and C regions. TeV
radiation has also
been detected toward
two other young and
massive stellar clus-
ters: by HESS
to-
ward Westerlund 2 in
the giant RCW49
HII region [15], and
by Milagro
and
MAGIC on the edge
of Cygnus OB2 [16,
17]. These sources,
J1023-575
HESS
a n d
T e V
J2032+4130,
have
not been
identified
with other likely γ-
ray emitters such as
supernova remnants,
pulsars or their wind nebulae. They do not coincide
with EGRET sources. These spatial coincidences raise
the interesting possibility of efficient particle accelera-
tion in these young environments.
Coincidences between COS-B sub-GeV sources and
OB associations,
together with anomalies
in the
cosmic-ray composition, had prompted the idea of
SNOBs [18] in which ions would be first injected and
accelerated by the supersonic winds of massive stars
and then by the shock wave of a nearby supernova
remnant. The recent measurements by ACE of isotopic
ratios in the local cosmic rays point to an acceleration
site inside OB associations to explain the presence of
about 20 % Wolf-Rayet material in the composition
[19]. The lack of 59Ni also suggests a period of at least
105 years between nucleosynthesis and acceleration
[20], supporting the two-step scenario of SNOBs. The
cloud complex that has given birth to the cluster pro-
vides targets for hadronic interactions to shine in γ
rays. The power released by OB associations in the
combined form of stellar winds and supernova shocks
is large enough to sustain the required γ-ray luminosi-
ties for standard mechanical-to-cosmic-ray energy con-
version efficiencies of
a
few
percent.
EGRET,
however,
has seen only few
sources toward OB
associations (in the
Cygnus region, Car
OB 1b and 2, Sco
OB2d, and Gem
OB1) and they may
only be chance co-
incidences in these
crowded directions.
associa-
Potential
tions with TeV
sources appear to be
more promising, but
different
because
the related OB clus-
ters
rather
are
unique
in
stellar
content and youth
[21, 22, 23, 24].
Figure 2: significance contours of the HESS J1023-575
source (7 and 9 σ as dashed and solid curves, respec-
tively) overlaid on the Spizter and Chandra images of
Westerlund 2 and its HII region RCW 49. The PAH
infrared emission (in grey) outlines the cloud highly
perturbed response to the ionization fronts and winds
from the very massive stars. The X rays (in colour)
reveal the compact and massive stellar cluster that
powers the intense activity in this highly obscured re-
gion.
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
Figure 3: location and extent of the TeV J2032+4130
source (red dot, as seen by MAGIC [17]) with respect
to the massive Cyg OB2 cluster (white circle, [23])
breaking out in a CO shell (green ellipse). The parent
cloud and ionized gas are shown as CO contours (red)
overlaid on the 1420 MHz intensity map [25]). The
EGRET source EGR J2033+41 is centred within the
yellow error circle, but any extended source within the
dashed yellow circle would not be resolved by
EGRET.
They are referred to as ‘super star clusters’. They result
from extraordinary bursts of star formation that have
converted 103.7 to 104.6 solar masses of gas in stars
heavier than the Sun. They are extremely rich in mas-
sive stars (e.g. 150 O stars in the Arches, 120 ± 20 O
stars in Cyg OB2, down to > 12 0 stars in the more
modest Westerlund 2 cluster). The huge ionizing pho-
ton fluxes of 1050.8 to 1051.6 s-1 have carved out wide
HII regions around them. These photons can efficiently
produce pairs on the TeV γ rays, but one can easily
check that, given the cluster sizes, the photon densities
are not lethal to γ rays except within light minutes of
one of the massive members [26]. The inverse Comp-
ton scattering of all the starlight can double the amount
of interstellar GeV γ rays in the cluster vicinity. In the
case of Cyg OB2, it would form a 1° wide source of γ
rays with a flux near the threshold of the GLAST tele-
scope [27]. All these clusters have manufactured giant
stars of 85 M⊙ in Westerlund 2 and over 100 M⊙ in
the Arches and Quintuplet. The large number of LBV
and WR members that are still alive attests of their
youth (5% of all known Galactic WR in the Arches, >
17 in the Quintuplet, 3 in Cyg OB2, and 2 in Wester-
lund 2). Ages of 2.5 ± 0.5, 2, and 2-3 Myr have been
derived for the Arches, Cyg OB2, and Westerlund 2,
respectively [22, 28, 29]. Little is known from Sgr B2
since the stars still hide in their parent cloud, but the
presence of 50 compact HII regions strongly suggests it
is another Arches cluster in the making. The Quintuplet
is slightly more evolved, with an age of 4 ± 1 Myr.
If these systems turn out to be responsible for the TeV
emission, their extreme youth calls for another scenario
than the more evolved case of SNOBs because of the
lack of supernovae. Even if remnants could easily hide
in the intense free-free radio emission, the clusters are
too young to have produced several supernovae. Me-
chanically, these young systems are almost as powerful
as SNOBs. Cesarsky & Montmerle [30] have estimated
that stellar winds from WR and O stars dominate the
cluster power during the first few million years, espe-
cially in the case of massive associations with stars
heavier than 30 M⊙ as observed in the super-star clus-
ters. The power exceeds 1031 W if the cluster hosts 40
stars with mass-losses > 10-5 M⊙ yr-1 and terminal
velocities of order 2500 km/s. Supernovae hardly take
over the overall budget when the cluster is 5 or 6 mil-
lion years old. Whereas Fermi acceleration by multiple
random shocks from supernova remnants in more
evolved OB associations has been studied to account
for cosmic-ray energies and composition near or be-
yond the knee [31], the shock sizes, velocities, and
separation in space and time do not apply to the denser,
more turbulent case of the colliding winds from tens of
massive stars in the compact configuration of the super
clusters. Losses in the dense bubble shells also limit the
acceleration. Figure 2 shows how intensively the stars
have ionized and sculpted the gas around them in
Westerlund 2. A ridge of radio emission follows the rim
of the bubble centred on the main cluster and along its
interface with the bubble blown by WR 20b, but it is
dominated by free-free emission. Particle acceleration
has been observed as synchrotron radio emission in the
colliding winds of massive stars within binary systems.
It should yield detectable fluxes of γ rays, if not at TeV
energies because of the heavy toll of pair absorption on
the intense stellar radiation field, at least to tens of GeV
energies [32]. However, the large spatial extent of
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
HESS J1023-575 toward Westerlund 2 (25 pc in radius
at 8 kpc) is not compatible with an origin of the emis-
sion in the colliding winds of the WR 20a binary. The
whole Westerlund 2 cluster is also too compact to ex-
plain the large TeV source. A more diffuse cause, per-
haps in the collective action of separate winds, is
needed. This is also true for the more compact case of
the TeV J2032+4130 source (4.4 pc in size at 1.5 kpc)
which is seen toward a sub-group of 10 or more O stars
of the Cyg OB2 cluster. The position of the EGRET
EGR
J2033+41
source
(consistent with 3EG
J2033+4118) is well centred on the dense core of the
cluster and it could encompass emission from the entire
system because of the wide EGRET point-spread-
function. The massive eclipsing binary V729 Cyg in
Cyg OB2 cannot account for the observed luminosity
[33].
Interestingly, the γ-ray sources toward Westerlund 2
and Cyg OB2 are found where the hot bubble of the
main HII region breaks free into the low density me-
dium, blowing away the ambient gas in a champagne
flow that sweeps the magnetic field lines away with it
in a mushroom-like configuration. Adiabatic losses in
the expanding flow must be severe, but particles can
stream along the field lines and flow back to the edge of
the cloud, or they can diffuse along the edge of the
champagne flow to produce γ rays [34]. The problem is
to accelerate cosmic rays from the bubbling inside the
champagne bottle, within the HII bubble, to begin with.
This γ-ray champagne bubble scenario, as well as the
possible connection between young massive clusters
and γ-ray sources has yet to be verified observationally
in other examples, taking advantage of the upcoming
surveys of the Galactic plane by GLAST and the Cher-
enkov telescopes and combining their data to constrain
the high-energy spectrum. Having missed until recently
the importance of Cyg OB2 at a mere distance of 1.5
kpc reminds us that super star clusters may have es-
caped radio searches in the Galaxy.
Cosmic-ray acceleration in supernova
remnants
Collisionless shocks in supernova remnants are thought
to produce the bulk of the cosmic rays up to the knee.
They are numerous and powerful enough to sustain the
total cosmic-ray power in the Galaxy. Synchrotron X
rays also indicate that the forward shock effectively
accelerates electrons to tens of TeV (see below). Yet,
the accelerated ions are very elusive and they have not
been firmly observed so far. Strong, but indirect, evi-
dence of their presence has come from several impor-
tant clues in the X-ray images. The thinness of the syn-
chrotron filaments observed behind the forward shock
of young remnants (such as Cas A, Kepler, Tycho, and
SN 1006) imply very severe losses from large magnetic
field strengths, well in excess of the compressed inter-
stellar field ([35] and references therein). The electrons
rapidly cool down and their radiation shifts to UV en-
ergies, below the spectral window of the X-ray tele-
scope. It has been proposed that the magnetic amplifi-
cation is due to cosmic-ray streaming upstream [36,
37]. Another clue comes from the X-ray morphology of
these remnants. All models of diffusive shock accelera-
tion predict that ions receive far more energy than elec-
trons. When this energy drain becomes significant, the
gas hydrodynamics and shock profile are modified. The
shocked gas becomes more compressible and it piles up
in a much thinner shell outside the contact discontinu-
ity. Instead of the classical compression ratio r = 4,
average values of 6 ≤ r ≤ 8 are predicted after several
centuries of acceleration activity. The post-shock tem-
perature thus drops by an order of magnitude or more
compared to the classical case [38]. Several observa-
tions support this possibility. A modified shock can
reconcile the unusually low electron temperature meas-
ured in the young 1E0102.2-7219 remnant with its
large shock velocity [39]. Detailed spectro-imaging of
Tycho and Kepler also shows that the forward shock is
twice closer to the contact discontinuity than one would
expect when the shock is not disturbed by accelerated
ions [40]. These are strong indications of efficient ac-
celeration. The case of Cas A is less conclusive. A wide
shell is seen between the shock and the ejecta. It may
be due to inefficient acceleration, despite the large
magnetic amplification implied by thin X-ray filaments,
or to the remnant expansion in the wind of its progeni-
tor [40].
Three remnants, G347.3-0.5, Vela Jr, and RCW 86,
have now been imaged at TeV energies [41, 42, 43].
G347.3-0.5 and RCW 86 may be the remnants of the
historical supernovae SN 393 and SN 185. The three
objects share many common traits. Their large size (11
pc at 1.3 kpc, 17 pc at 1 kpc, and 18 pc at 2.8 kpc, re-
spectively), their large ratio of synchrotron to thermal
X-ray flux, together with their weak radio emission
suggest that they have expanded at high speed in a low-
density medium, possibly a stellar wind bubble or an
OB cavity. So, they would be near the end of the free
expansion phase or in early Sedov stage. Part of their
shells has reached a denser environment a few centu-
ries ago (to the west and southwest of G347.3-0.5 [44]
and southwest of RCW 86 [45]). Their non-thermal X-
ray filaments are quite broader than those of the
younger remnants quoted above, thus implying a lower
degree of magnetic amplification. The TeV flux appears
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
well correlated with the X-ray synchrotron one. Syn-
chrotron losses dominate over inverse Compton ones in
their spectral energy distributions (SEDs), even if the
TeV emission is entirely electronic. It is my purpose
here to grossly constrain the range of shock velocities
(vsh), post-shock magnetic fields (Bd), and diffusion
coefficients at high energy that are consistent with the
observed energies and flux ratios of the SED peaks, and
with the observed width of the synchrotron and γ-ray
profiles. It is also my purpose to convey that both pos-
sible origins for the γ rays (pion-decay from in-situ
ions or electrons up-scattering the cosmological mi-
crowave background (CMB) radiation and dust infrared
emission) still face serious difficulties.
Following the formalism of Parizot et al. [35], I will
assume that both the upstream and downstream diffu-
sion coefficients D(E) scale as k0 times the Bohm limit,
so D(E) = k0E/3eB for an electron or proton of energy
E in a B field. The most efficient acceleration takes
place when k0 = 1. I also assume a mean compression
ratio r = 7 and a ratio of downstream to upstream mag-
netic field strength Bd/Bu = 0.83 × r in the case of iso-
tropic magnetic turbulence [46]. The synchrotron peak
energy and filament width provides two constraints.
Equating the 1st order Fermi acceleration timescale and
the synchrotron loss timescale upstream and down-
stream yields an estimate of the maximum electron
energy Eemax ∝ Bd-1/2 k0-1/2 vsh. The synchrotron cut-off
energy therefore scales as hνsyn-cut ∝ vsh2 k0-1 and pro-
vides a first constraint between the shock velocity and
k0. It is displayed in the left plots of Figure 4 for the
three remnants. Because of diffusion, advection, and
synchrotron losses, the high-energy electron distribu-
tion falls off exponentially downstream and the syn-
chrotron profile at a given X-ray frequency, hνX, has a
projected full width at half maximum Δθsyn that fol-
lows equation 24 in [35]. The ratio Bd3/2/vsh is thus
constrained by the three observables hνsyn-cut, hνX, and
Δθsyn. This relation is plotted as the blue line in the
right plots of Figure 4. The cut-off energies being
poorly constrained in the current SEDs, an uncertainty
within a decade is quite plausible. It implies an equiva-
lent uncertainty in k0. Its impact is shown in Figure 4 as
the blue shaded area. For the input parameters of the
three remnants, one finds that the downstream field
roughly scales with hνsyn-cut-1/3.Δθsyn-2/3. This is why the
constraint on Bd, displayed again as the blue shaded
area, is more robust.
The γ rays provide other constraints. The peak inverse
Compton (IC) flux cannot exceed the peak γ-ray flux
observed in the SED, so the magnetic energy density
has a lower limit set by this flux ratio and the energy
density of the ambient soft radiation field. This lower
limit is met if one assumes the TeV data to arise from
pure IC emission. The lower limit appears as the lower
horizontal red line in Figure 4. I have used 0.26 MeV
m-3 for the cosmological background and 0.27 MeV m-3
for the local density of of thermal emission from cold
(24 K) dust for Vela Jr and G347.3-0.5 [47]. RCW 86
resides in the much brighter inner Galaxy, but in the
quieter
interarm region between
the Carina and
Scutum-Crux arms, so the ambient inrared density may
be twice larger than the local value. If IC emission
dominates over pion decay, the peak γ-ray energy,
hνγcut, provides another relation between the down-
stream field, hνsyn-cut, hνγcut, and the soft photon ener-
gies (Esoft = 0.66 and 5.8 meV for the CMB and cold
dust photons, respectively). It appears as the grey
shaded area in Figure 4. In the same IC framework, the
width of the TeV profile should not exceed the ob-
served one. This provides another lower limit in the
(Bd, vsh) phase space that depends on Esoft, hνsyn-cut and
the intrinsic width ΔRγ of the γ-ray shell as inferred
from the observations at the energy hνγ. This lower
limit appears as the two broken red lines in Figure 4
(solid and dotted for the CMB and IR target photons,
distance (kpc)
angular radius
projected FWHM of the X-ray filaments
intrinsic fractional width dR/R of the shell at 1 TeV
synchrotron peak energy (keV)
synchrotron peak energy flux (eV cm-2 s-1)
inverse Compton peak energy (TeV)
inverse Compton peak energy flux (eV cm-2 s-1)
G 347.3-0.5
1.3
30’
40” at 2 keV
45 %
∼ 1
∼ 190
∼ 5
∼ 19
Vela Jr
0.2 or 1.0
60’
50” at 5 keV
22.5 %
∼ 0.9
∼ 100
∼ 4
∼ 20
RCW 86
2.8
22’
100” at 2 keV
50 %
∼ 0.15
∼ 8
∼ 1
∼ 4
Table 2: supernova remnant characteristics used to constrain the downstream magnetic field and shock velocity.
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
respectively). The blue lines and broken red lines
change by only 25% when using the classical r = 4
compression ratio instead of r = 7. The observational
constraints summarized in Table 1 were taken from the
data in [35, 41, 42, 43, 45, and references therein]. In
the absence of velocity measurements, one expects the
shock speed to vary with the remnant radius R and age
τage as vsh = 2R/3τage during the free expansion phase.
The velocity can be derived for G347.3-0.5 and RCW
86 if they are related to the historical supernovae. It is
plotted as the vertical dashed line in Figure 4. On the
other hand, we can set a maximum velocity by rea-
sonably requiring the age of the three objects to be
older than 1000 years. The upper limit is plotted as the
solid vertical line in Figure 4.
The results for G347.3-0.5, Vela Jr at 1 kpc, and RCW
86 show that their current shock speed should exceed
3800, 3600, and 1500 km/s, respectively, to accelerate
electrons to the observed cut-off energies in X rays
with the maximum efficiency (k0 = 1, Bohm limit).
Large field strengths, of order 10 nT, are also required
to explain the thinness of the X-ray synchrotron fila-
ments. These values are less subject to the uncertainty
in the synchrotron cut-off energy. As expected, they are
slightly lower than the fields strengths of 20 to 30 nT
derived for the younger historical remnants [35].
Let us first examine the case of dominant IC emission
at high energy. The large magnetic fields required by
the X-ray filaments are consistent with the peak energy
observed by HESS. The energetic electrons preferably
up-scatter soft, CMB-like, photons which correspond to
the lower end of the grey shaded region. The large
magnetic fields are also consistent with the thickness of
the TeV shell. IC emission also provides a natural ex-
planation for the tight spatial correlation between the
X-ray and TeV fluxes. Yet, the necessary large mag-
netic fields are not consistent with a dominant IC origin
of the γ-ray flux. A ‘pure’ electronic origin requires the
low fields of 1.5, 1.0, and 0.8 nT inferred from the
peak-flux ratio between the X-ray and γ-ray compo-
nents for the 3 remnants. Similar values have been
found for G347.3-0.5 and Vela Jr by modelling the
observed SEDs with a power-law distribution of elec-
trons [41, 42]. These fields are, however, too low to
explain the sharp synchrotron filaments and are only
marginally consistent with the TeV shell thickness. One
would need to increase the sub-mm part of the dust
emission by two orders of magnitude to reconcile the
dominant IC scenario and high magnetic fields. This
option is unlikely. Another possibility is to suppose that
the large magnetic fields are confined to sharp filaments
at the shock and that they rapidly drop inward [48]. If
so, the filaments would trace the magnetic radial profile
rather than fast synchrotron cooling and the field
Figure 4: constraints on the diffusion coefficient (k0
times the Bohm limit) and on the downstream mag-
netic field as a function of shock velocity for the three
supernova remnants, G347.3-0.5, Vela Jr at 1 kpc, and
RCW 86, resolved at TeV energies (see text for the
explanation of the different lines and regions).
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
strength Bd would not be constrained by the blue areas
in Figure 4. This option requires a careful modelling of
the diffusion, advection, and radiation cooling to be
tested against the observations because of the impor-
tance of the projection effects. Electron spectral hard-
ening with energy, as expected from modified shocks,
should also be taken into account. A convincing IC
scenario would also need to explain why the synchro-
tron spectral index varies from 1.8 to 2.6 along the
shell of G347.3-0.5, whereas the γ-ray index remains
uniformly close to 2.0 [41, 44]. The large magnetic
field helps in this matter since it implies X-ray elec-
trons that have a few times more energy than the γ-ray
emitting ones. So, the latter are closer to the cut-off
energy (thus harder) than the X-ray ones that belong to
the exponential cut-off part of the spectrum.
The nearby distance of 200 pc for Vela Jr does not yield
a convincing case. The minimum shock velocity neces-
sary to sustain the X-ray synchrotron properties is 1.6
times larger than the maximum value set by an age
older than 1 kyr and the required field is very large (Bd
> 25 nT). It would completely rule out an IC scenario,
as noted by the HESS group [42].
Following the constraints in Figure 4 and adopting
downstream field strengths of 8, 8, and 6 nT as possible
values for G347.3-0.5, Vela Jr (1 kpc), and RCW 86,
respectively, we can infer maximum electron energies
of 26, 24, and 11 TeV and synchrotron lifetimes of 100,
110, and 380 yr. The maximum proton energy is de-
rived by equating the acceleration timescale and the
remnant age. Choosing ages of 1620 and 1820 years
from the historical supernovae and a comparable age of
2300 years for Vela Jr at 1 kpc that corresponds to a
current speed of 5000 km/s in Figure 4, we find that
protons can be accelerated to 400 TeV in G347.3-0.5,
500 TeV in Vela Jr, and 50 TeV in RCW 86. These
values fall well below the knee energy despite the large
magnetic amplification. The region explored by these
high-energy protons in their random walk is found to
be smaller than the observed TeV shell thickness.
The large magnetic amplification favours the interpre-
tation of the γ-ray flux in terms of pion decay, but this
scenario also faces important difficulties. Large gas
densities between 1 and 2 cm-3 are required to match
the TeV flux. Yet, the absence of thermal emission in
G347.3-0.5 sets an upper limit of 0.02 cm-3 at 1 kpc
[44]. This limit can be further lowered for an increased
gas compressibility in a modified shock. A low density
of 0.03 ff-1/2 cm-3 (for a filling factor ff) has also been
found for Vela Jr at 1 kpc [49]. These values cannot be
increased to meet the γ-ray requirement. Large densi-
ties (300 cm-3) exist on the southwestern side of
G347.3-0.5 where the clear correlation between the
synchrotron flux and absorbing column-density indi-
cates that the shock runs into dense clouds seen in CO.
If protons are accelerated as well as electrons, having
more high-energy protons and more targets to produce
pions, one would expect the pion-decay flux to scale
more or less quadratically with the ambient density.
Yet, the γ-ray profile linearly follows the X-ray one,
both radially and azimuthally. It does not exhibit an
enhanced γ-ray to X-ray flux ratio toward the CO
clouds [41]. The same difficulty is seen in RCW 86.
The TeV map presented at the conference carefully
avoids the southwestern region where the shock is
known to have slowed down to 800 km/s inside a dense
cloud and where ample thermal emission is detected
[45]. In addition, the pion-decay modelling of the TeV
emission in Vela Jr requires an unsually low electron to
proton ratio (< 10-4). Furthermore, the maximum pro-
ton energies derived from the amplified magnetic fields
chosen above correspond to cut-off energies in the γ-
ray spectrum of 70 TeV for G347.3-0.5 and 90 TeV for
Vela Jr, at odds with the spectral break detected be-
tween 3.7 ± 1.0 TeV and 17.9 ± 3.3 TeV in G347.3-0.5
[41] and possibly several TeV for Vela Jr [42]. One
would need to decrease the downstream field by an
order of magnitude to explain these breaks from
proton-proton collisions. It would then conflict with the
observed synchrotron properties and IC emission
would become dominant. The spectral break near 9
TeV inferred for RCW 86 would be consistent with the
possible 5 TeV break reported at the conference. Fi-
nally, it has often been said that a flat spectrum below 1
TeV would sign pion-decay against IC emission, but
the reader should be warned that the flattening at high
energy of the electron spectra emerging from modified
shocks, as well as various dosages of infrared photon
targets can easily broaden the IC spectra and increase
the overall IC flux for a given magnetic amplitude.
Flattened spectra will certainly help to better fit the
radio and X-ray data simultaneously, but they will pro-
vide less room for pion-decay emission.
In conclusion, whereas indirect evidence of ion accel-
eration exists in X rays from the modified shock ther-
modynamics, no clear picture has emerged yet from the
beautiful γ-ray images of shell supernova remnants.
Pulsar wind nebulae
The case of the HESS J1813-178 source brings forth
the problem of separating emission from the supernova
remnant and pulsar activities when the telescope reso-
lution is limited. The source coincides with the radio
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
shell of the G12.82-0.02 remnant and with a non-
thermal X-ray nebula that probably traces the wind of a
young and energetic pulsar inside the remnant, al-
though searches for radio pulsations have failed so far
[50]. Since the 1990s, when the GeV to TeV emission
from the Crab nebula was successfully interpreted as
synchro-self-Compton emission in the pulsar wind
downstream of its terminal shock inside the remnant
[51], and when several of us drew attention to the fact
that a number of hard X-ray nebulae were seen inside
the error boxes of unidentified, possibly variable,
EGRET sources (e. g. [52, 53]), pulsar wind nebulae
have been firmly established as sources of TeV emis-
sion. The identification is based on the correlation be-
tween the X-ray and γ-ray images of the diffuse emis-
sion. In several cases, the TeV image extends further
away from the pulsar, as around PSR B1823-13 (HESS
J1825-137, [54]), in the long Vela X tail [55], or along
the jet of PSR B1509-58 [56]. For more compact
sources, unresolved by HESS, such as in G21.5-0.9,
G0.9+0.1, and Kes 75, the proposed identification is
based on the lack of non-thermal X-ray emission from
the shell or on the weakness of the magnetic field re-
quired to explain the TeV flux from electrons acceler-
ated at the shell [57, 58].
The number of pulsar wind nebulae emitting synchro-
tron X rays has grown rapidly in the past few years.
Thanks to the high-resolution images provided by
XMM-Newton and Chandra, many have been resolved
into a large variety of shapes. The innermost regions of
the wind are dominated by polar jets and a toroidal
wind that results from the winding of the neutron star
magnetic field. A rather complex standing shock forms
as the wind decelerates to match the boundary condi-
tion imposed by the external medium (the pressure of
the supernova ejecta or the ram pressure of the ambient
medium if the pulsar motion has become supersonic
inside or outside the remnant). The downstream equa-
torial flow expands laterally and turns back against the
external medium to fill intermediate latitudes and form
an elongated bubble, stretched along the pulsar spin
axis and jets [59]. The synchrotron emitting part of the
wind is confined between the termination shock and the
bubble outer boundary since it is assumed that the up-
stream charges flow along with the frozen-in field and
do not radiate. Doppler boosting of the synchrotron
intensity is important for the innermost part of the
wind, as in the Crab wisps, but not for the rest of the
nebula [59]. The wind electrons can efficiently upscat-
ter soft photons to produce TeV γ rays. In the Crab
nebula, the average synchrotron infrared and optical
energy density in the bubble exceeds the other ambient
radiation fields and the modelling of the multi-
wavelength spectrum indeed finds that synchro-self-
Compton emission dominates in γ rays [51, 60]. The
situation appears to be different for the other nebulae
seen in γ rays. The second most luminous one after the
Crab is in G21.5-0.9. Assuming that the sub-eV syn-
chrotron energy flux is comparable to the observed X-
ray one (for a flat SED), and considering the size of the
synchrotron bubble (0.65’, [61]), one finds an average
energy density 7 times lower than that of the cosmo-
logical background or of the dust radiation at the solar
circle. The latter can easily increase by a factor of a few
in the inner Galaxy, so synchro-self-Compton should
not dominate in G21.5-0.9. The third most luminous
case is found in the left wing of the Kookaburra,
around PSR J1420-6048. It is fainter, but more com-
pact. Following the same assumptions, the soft syn-
chrotron energy density falls 25 times below the inter-
stellar or cosmological fields, so we can consider that
most of the TeV wind nebulae should mainly upscatter
the cosmological background and interstellar radiation.
Starlight and warm dust radiation may play a signifi-
cant role below 1 TeV if the nebula resides near bright
star clusters as in G0.9+0.1 [57] and G12.82-0.02
(HESS J1813-178, [50]). In any case, the GLAST sen-
sitivity should prove very useful to constrain the peak
of the inverse Compton emission, therefore the particle
ageing.
Thanks to the X-ray imaging capabilities, one can often
separate the diffuse nebular emission from pulsar DC
Figure 5: evolution of the 2-10 keV luminosity of pul-
sar wind nebulae as a function of the spindown power.
The squares mark the observed values, highlighted in
blue when the nebula also shines at TeV energies, and
the open diamonds give the toy model predictions if
1% of the spindown power is given to the wind.
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
Figure 6: evolution of the ratio of the 0.5-10 TeV to the
2-10 keV luminosities of pulsar wind nebulae. The
filled squares give the observed values and the open
diamonds the prediction from the toy model. The three
blue squares with a ratio < 0.1 are the youngest, most
compact, wind nebulae in the sample (Crab, Kes 75,
and G21.5-0.9). The fourth blue square marks the jet-
like nebula from PSR B1509-58.
Figure 7: distributions of the photon spectral indices of
the pulsar wind nebulae in X rays and at TeV energies,
for the whole sample of objects displayed in Figure 5
(upper histogram) and the sub-group of TeV emitting
objects (right histogram and scatter plot).
emission or the innermost part of the wind. Several
authors have noted that the nebular luminosity scales
with the pulsar spindown power as LX ∝ Ė psr1.4 ± 0.2 [62,
and references therein]. Updating their list for the
newly found nebulae and for results found in the litera-
ture on more detailed morphological studies of several
Figure 8: evolution of the size ratio between the TeV
and X-ray emission regions of pulsar wind nebulae as a
function of spindown power.
nebulae they had listed (details will be given in a forth-
coming paper), I have plotted in Figure 5 the evolution
of the 2-10 keV luminosity with Ėpsr and I have high-
lighted the sources that have been detected at TeV en-
ergies. The latter span a small range of ages from a
thousand years in the Crab and Kes 75 to 50 kyr in PSR
J1809-1917. Their X-ray luminosity is not particularly
bright compared to the general scaling relation. The
luminosities recorded between 0.5 and 10 TeV show a
much narrower dynamical range. Except for Vela X and
G21.5-0.9, which have luminosities of 8 1025 W and 6
1026 W, respectively, all other sources gather in the
(0.3-1.4) 1028 W range and show little dependence on
the pulsar spindown power, if any, and a large disper-
sion. This is illustrated in Figure 6 where the ratio of
the TeV to X-ray luminosity scales as LTeV/LX ∝ Ė psr-1.9.
In fact, most of the apparent evolution is due to the
change in X-ray emission. This trend is nicely inde-
pendent of distance.
Since the TeV emitting electrons have lower energies
than the X-ray ones, the evolution of the LTeV/LX ratio
with Ėpsr (alias youth) traces how the particles age in
the nebula. Particle ageing is also illustrated by the
spectral softening of the TeV emitting electrons with
respect to the X-ray emitting ones. Figure 7 shows that
the γ-ray spectra are often softer than the X-ray ones.
Particle ageing is also reflected in the larger extent of
the TeV nebula when the source is resolved in both
energy bands. Figure 8 shows that the size ratio, meas-
ured in terms of radius or length depending on the
source morphology, indeed increases with age (i. e.
decreasing spindown power) as RTeV/RX ∝ Ė psr-2.0, but it
presents a large dispersion. The spectral softening with
distance from the pulsar strongly supports an electronic
origin of the γ radiation since synchrotron and inverse
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
Compton losses result in a longer lifetime at lower
energy. One would expect harder spectra in γ rays than
in X rays at large distance in the case of ion emission.
The higher energy electrons illuminating the X-ray
synchrotron nebula give a more instantaneous image of
the wind than the longer-lived electrons shining in γ
rays which integrate a fair fraction of the pulsar wind
history. Both the evolution of the wind power and of its
magnetic field near the shock are linked to the history
of the pulsar spindown power. To explore their impact
on the recorded luminosities in Figures 5 and 6, I have
developed a toy model based on a small set of assump-
tions. Given the young age (< 600 kyr) of the X-ray
nebulae plotted in Figure 5, one can reasonably assume
that the neutron star magnetic field has not decayed,
therefore that the product P(n-2).(dP/dt) of the rotational
period and its time derivative remains remains constant
from birth to now. n notes the pulsar braking index (n =
3 for a magnetic dipole). This implies that the spin-
down power evolves as Ėpsr(t) = Ė0 (1 + t/τ0)(n+1)/(n-1).
The characteristic timescale τ0 can be retrieved from
the present timing measurements and the pulsar period
at birth: τ0 = P0(n-1) P(2-n) / (n-1) / dP/dt. A birth period
P0 = 15 ms has been adopted to account for the fastest
pulsars in the sample. In the absence of pulsar timing
data for the HESS J1813-178, Rabbit, and HESS
J1640-465 nebulae, a spindown power of 1030 W and
ages of 2, 16, and 20 kyr have been chosen respec-
tively, following [50, 63, 64]. The pulsar powering the
bow shock nebula G189.22+2.90 in IC 443 is probably
older (30 kyr) and less energetic (1029 W) [65]. A con-
stant fraction of the spindown power Ėpsr(t) is poured
into the wind at the terminal shock. It is distributed
over the electron spectrum. A constant E-2.1 spectrum
has been assumed for the injected electrons above 1
GeV. I have not attempted to reproduce the trend be-
tween the X-ray photon index and the spindown power
(αX ∝ Ė psr-1/2) that has been observed [66]. The maxi-
mum electron energy has been set to the full electrical
potential drop eΦopen across the open magnetosphere
today. The latter evolves slowly as Ėpsr1/2 and has not
changed much over the short lifetime of the X-ray
emitting electrons, so it has been kept constant in the
calculation. The particles have been traced in time,
loosing energy primarily by synchrotron radiation. This
should be revised in view of the large LTeV/LX ratios
found for middle-aged objects. Adding inverse Comp-
ton losses will remove even more particles from the γ-
ray window. The magnetic energy density of the wind
injected at the shock may scale as Ėpsr(t), so B(t) ∝
Ėpsr(t)1/2. Other scaling laws have been explored (B ∝
Ėpsr, ...), but do not appreciably modify the results given
in Figure 5 and 6. The minimum magnetic strength in
the wind at birth is set to the maximum value between
30 nT and the value required so that the electrons cur-
rently injected with half the maximum energy eΦopen
shine at 10 keV which is the upper limit of the X-ray
window. This applies only to the older pulsars that have
a reduced voltage. The inverse Compton luminosity
was calculated for an energy density of 0.53 MeV m-3
of photons with an energy of 2 meV representative of
the cosmological background and cold dust radiation.
The most drastic assumption is that the injected parti-
cles and field remain frozen. In other words, there is no
spatial evolution of the wind density or field strength in
the toy model and the particles loose energy in the
same initial field all their life. This is why the compari-
son between the predictions of the toy model and the
data allows to guess what is due to the pulsar evolution
and what must be due to the wind expansion and struc-
tural evolution in the data.
The results are presented for each nebula as open dia-
monds in Figures 5 and 6. The evolution of the pre-
dicted synchrotron luminosity in the 2-10 keV band
follows reasonably well the observations given the
simplicity of the toy model. The wind power has been
set to 1% of the spindown power as a good match to
the data. Most of the observed X-ray evolution is
driven by the decrease in wind power with time be-
cause the short lifetime of the X-ray emitting electrons.
They have been injected in the recent past, typically
over the last 10% or 20% of the pulsar lifetime in most
cases. The situation is quite different in γ rays since the
emission integrates the wind history over a large frac-
tion of the pulsar age, often more than half its age. The
evolution of the predicted inverse Compton emission is
much shallower than the data. The modelled LTeV/LX
ratio is independent of the power fraction attributed to
the wind. The predicted slope in Figure 6 is rather in-
sensitive to the initial strength as well as the evolution
of the magnetic field B(t). The rapid increase of the
TeV to X-ray luminosity ratio with age indicates that
synchrotron losses must strongly decrease as the parti-
cles move out to keep enough of them shining in γ
rays. The four nebulae in the sample for which we ex-
pect a minimal influence of the spatial evolution have
been highlighted. They consist of the three very young
and compact Crab, Kes 75, and G21.5-0.9 nebulae
where most of the synchrotron power comes from the
inner region where the magnetic pressure has built up
to the equipartition value because of the wind slowing
down [67]. The jet-like emission from PSR B1509-58
has also been highlighted because the comparison of
the tail lengths recorded from 0.5 to 100 keV by RO-
SAT, Beppo-SAX, and INTEGRAL was compatible
with synchrotron ageing in a uniform magnetic field
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
over 20 or 30 pc [56]. The toy model predictions are
indeed closest to the data for these cases, especially
when keeping in mind that an additional SSC compo-
nent for the Crab would move the model prediction up
by a factor of 3 or 4. For the others objects, the syn-
chrotron burn-off is obviously too strong to account for
the TeV flux. Adding inverse Compton losses will in-
crease the discrepancy at old age. The model strongly
under-predicts the TeV flux and it is unlikely that the
ambient interstellar radiation field can be increased to
match the data. So, the trend observed in Figure 6 bears
valuable information on the spatial structure of the
nebulae as they evolve.
The fact that the Cherenkov telescopes have detected
wind nebulae at different stages of their evolution is of
great interest. The three youngest objects quoted above
illustrate the early development of the wind when con-
fined by the supernova ejecta. HESS J1640-465 may
bring another example when its age is known. The
elongated nebular shapes in HESS J1813-178 and
around PSR B1823-13, well inside their supernova
remnant, and the long Vela X tail that expands almost
at right angle from the pulsar spin axis give potential
examples of winds crushed back by an irregular reverse
shock. This may happen when the forward supernova
shock slows down at different rates in azimuth because
of different mass loading in a non-uniform medium
[68]. Later in the evolution, when the pulsar has moved
near the edge of the supernova remnant or when it has
left it, its supersonic motion confines the wind inside a
bow shock. The ram pressure strongly compresses the
wind upfront and lets it stretch at the back. It forms a
cometary tail trailing behind the pulsar. The particles
injected at the front and back regions of the termination
shock suffer very different losses before joining in the
tail. Modelling the spatial distribution of the particle
density and magnetic field strength in the crushed and
bow shock configurations is difficult and being able to
probe particle ageing in these situations with GeV to
TeV γ rays will prove very useful to constrain the mod-
els. The nebulae of PSR J1809-1917 and B1800-21
may illustrate this stage when the identification is con-
firmed. So will the Rabbit wind when its age is known.
Understanding why the X-ray wakes of the relatively
young pulsars in IC 443 and in CTB 80 (PSR
B1951+32) have not been detected above 100 GeV by
MAGIC also needs further investigations [69, 70], as
does the case of PSR B1853+01 in W44.
Other promising candidates have been reported at GeV
energies from EGRET sources and need confirmation
by GLAST. The 10-kyr old, 2.2 1030 W pulsar PSR
J2229+6114 is a compelling identification for the stable
3EG J2227+6122 source that is confirmed in the re-
vised catalogue [71]. It also coincides with a COMP-
TEL source in the 0.75-3 MeV band. The compact X-
ray nebula, with a possible 14” jet, belongs to an in-
complete non-thermal radio shell. CTA 1 should also
bring an interesting case. The brightest unidentified
EGRET
source off
the Galactic plane, 3EG
J1835+5918, and its X-ray counterpart have long been
proposed as a second Geminga [72, 73] because of its
hard and stable spectrum cutting off at 2 GeV and be-
cause of the lack of radio and optical counterparts
down to very low magnitudes. The 1.7 1029 W compact
keV nebula can be powered by a 20 kyr radio-quiet
pulsar. Another promising case corresponds to the wind
of PSR B1046-58. Likely γ-ray pulsations have been
found in the signal from 3EGJ1048-5840, but 40 % of
the emission above 400 MeV is not pulsed and a faint
X-ray nebula has recently been found for this 20-kyr
old, 2 1029 W pulsar [74, 75]. The fraction of radio-
quiet Geminga pulsars among the Galactic sources may
be rather large if the pulsed γ-ray beams are produced
at high altitude inside the magnetosphere [76]. Search-
ing for wind nebulae with GLAST will therefore need
to concentrate at energies above several GeV to benefit
from the sharp cut-off expected in the pulsed emission
from 10-100 kyr old neutron stars.
Gamma-ray binaries
The detection of a pulsar wind nebula in a binary sys-
tem has opened the possibility of probing the wind
structure as a function of compression near periastron
[77]. PSR B1259-63 indeed follows an eccentric 3.5-yr
long orbit around its massive Be companion and the
ram and radiation pressures build up when it crosses
the equatorial outflow from the star. A variety of situa-
tions have been explored at the interface between the
two winds: whether the pulsar wind is still supersonic
and bounded by a termination shock at the point of
pressure balance with the stellar outflow or not, or
whether the Compton drag from the intense stellar
radiation can slow down the unshocked wind or not.
Inverse Compton components and lightcurves have
been estimated [78, and references therein]. Another
source of γ rays has been proposed using the termina-
tion shock of the stellar outflow against the pulsar wind
to accelerate ions and electrons and letting them shine
in γ rays by π0 decay, bremsstrahlung, and inverse
Compton processes [79]. The TeV detection of two
other eccentric and massive binaries, LS 5039 [80] and
LSI +61°303 [81], has started a debate between a pul-
sar wind or a microquasar jet origin of the emission.
The nature of the compact object in LS 5039 and LSI
+61°303 was not firmly identified and both types of
THE GALACTIC GAMMA-RAY CLUB
systems could present striking similarities when seen
from Earth. Because of the stellar brightness, a strong
orbital modulation is expected in both systems from
two-photon pair production [26]. It is essential to
model this absorption to be able to explore the intrinsic
source variability that may result from a change in
accretion rate in the microquasar case or a change in
wind compression in the pulsar case, and from the in-
crease in inverse Compton emissivity near periastron in
both systems. The energy distribution recorded for the
three binaries were quite alike and, morphologically,
comparable images could be computed from an ex-
tended jet and from a cometary wind [82]. Very high
resolution radio images of LSI +61°303 showed a tail
pointing away from the star along the orbit [83] which
strongly suggested the presence of a bow-shock pulsar
wind. So, the situation appeared confused until the
detection, at the 4σ level, of the canonical black-hole
binary Cygnus X-1. It was seen by MAGIC above 100
GeV for a short hour [84]. It has strengthened the case
for a genuine high-energy activity from microquasars.
Confirming another γ-ray flare will establish high-mass
microquasars as γ-ray emitters as well as pulsar wind
nebulae. Summarizing the numerous models that pre-
dict γ radiation from microquasar jets and how they
should vary with aspect angle, precession, accretion
rate, and companion type is beyond the scope of this
review. The studies of LS 5039 [85, 86] illustrate the
various processes at work in massive systems where
inverse Compton scattering of the copious stellar pho-
tons clearly dominates in the GeV to TeV band. This is
probably why only massive binary systems have been
detected so far. Above 1 TeV, synchro-self-Compton
emission contributes a significant fraction to the overall
flux. This process is the only hope of detecting low-
mass binaries with current telescopes [87], unless the
intensity is magnified by Doppler boosting at small
viewing angles from the jet axis. We would then hap-
pily discover the long-sought microblazars.
In conclusion, with both rotation-powered and accre-
tion powered massive binaries, isolated pulsars and the
many facets of their magnetospheric and wind activi-
ties, champagne bubbles from superstar clusters and
SNOBs, shock acceleration in supernova remnants,
bubbles and stellar wind collisions, a wealth of GeV
and TeV sources still awaiting identification, and higher
performance telescopes soon to come, the future of the
Galactic γ-ray club looks very bright. Let me thank the
organizers for having run such a festive and lively con-
ference where many ideas were forged and debated to
make this future even brighter.
References
[1] Hartman, R. C., et al., 1999, ApJS, 123, 79.
[2] Casandjian, J. M., & Grenier, I. A., these pro-
ceedings.
[3] Grenier, I. A., & Casandjian, J. M., Terrier, R.
2005, Science, 307, 1292.
[4] Grenier, I. A., 1995, AdSpR, 15, 73.
[5] Grenier, I. A., 2000, A&A, 364, L93.
[6] Gehrels, N., et al., 2000, Nature, 404, 363.
[7] http://www-glast.slac.stanford.edu/software/
IS/glast_lat_performance.htm
[8] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2008, A&A, in press,
arXiv:astro-ph/0801.3555v3
[9] Strong, A. W., & Mattox, J. R., 1996, 308,
L21.
[10] Aharonian, F. A., & Atoyan, A. M., 1996,
A&A, 309, 917.
[11] Gabici, S., & Aharonian, F. A., 2007, ApJ,
665, L131
[12] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, Nature, 439,
695.
[13] Crocker, R. M., et al., 2007, ApJ, 666, 934
[14] Sakano, M., Warwick, R. S., Decourchelle,
A., 2006, JPhCS, 54, 133.
[15] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, A&A, 467,
1075.
[16] Abdo, A. A., et al., 2007, ApJ, 658, L33.
[17]
2008,
al.,
et
J.,
Albert,
arXiv:astro-ph/0801.2391v2
[18] Montmerle, T., 1979, ApJ, 231, 95.
[19] Binns, W. R., et al., 2007, SSRv, 130, 439.
[20] Binns, W. R., et al. 2005, ApJ, 634, 351.
[21] Figer, F. D., McLean, I. S., Morris, M., 1999,
ApJ, 514, 202.
[22] Figer, F. D., et al., 2002, ApJ, 581, 258.
[23] Knödlseder, J., et al., 2000, A&A, 360, 539.
[24] Churchwell, E., Whitney, B. A., Babler, B.
L., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 322
[25] Butt, Y. M., et al., 2003, ApJ, 597, 494.
[26] Dubus, G., 2006, A&A, 451, 9.
[27] Orlando, E., Strong, A. W., 2007, these pro-
ceedings.
[28] Hanson, M. M., 2003, ApJ, 597, 957.
[29] Piatti, A. E., Bica, E., & Claria, J. J. 1998,
A&AS, 127, 423
[30] Cesarsky, C. J., Montmerle, T., 1983, SSRv,
36, 173.
30TH INTERNATIONAL COSMIC RAY CONFERENCE 2007
[31] Bykov, A. M., Toptygin, I. N., 2001, AstL,
27, 625.
[32] Reimer, A., Pohl, M., Reimer, O., 2006,
ApJ, 644, 1118
[33] Benaglia, P., Romero, G. E., Stevens, I. R.,
Torres, D. F., 2001, A&A, 366, 605.
[34] Völk, H. J., 1983, SSRv, 36, 3.
[35] Parizot, E., Marcowith, A., Ballet, J., & Gal-
lant, Y. A., 2006, A&A, 453, 387.
[36] Bell, A. R., & Lucek, S. G., 2001, MNRAS,
321, 433.
[37] Ptuskin, V. S., & Zirakashvili, V. N., 2003,
A&A, 403, 1.
[38] Ellison, D. C., Decourchelle, A., Ballet, J.,
2004, A&A 413, 189.
[39] Hughes, J. P., Rakowski, C. E., De-
courchelle, A., 2000, ApJ, 543, L61.
[40] Decourchelle, A, 2005, Proc. of the X-Ray
and Radio Connections, Santa Fe, USA, 2004,
http://www.aoc.nrao.edu/events/xraydio
[41] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, A&A, 449, 223
[42] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2007, ApJ, 661, 236.
[43] Hoppe et al., 2007, these proceedings.
[44] Cassam-Chenaï, G., et al., 2004, A&A, 427,
199.
[45] Vink, J., et al., 2006, ApJ, 648, L33.
[46] Berezhko, E. G., Ksenofontov, L. T., Völk,
H. J., 2002, A&A, 395, 943.
[47] Moskalenko, I. V., Porter, T. A., Strong, A.
W., 2006, ApJ 640, L155.
[48] Pohl, M., Yan, H., & Lazarian, A, 2005, ApJ,
626, L101.
[49] Slane, P., et al., 2001, ApJ, 548, 814.
[50] Helfand, D. J., et al., 2007, ApJ, 665, 1297.
[51] de Jager, O. C., et al., 1996, ApJ, 457, 253.
[52] Roberts, M. S. E., Romani, R. W., Johnston,
S., Green, A. J, 1999, ApJ, 515, 712.
[53] Grenier, I. A., 1999, ICRC, 3, 476.
[54] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, A&A, 460, 365
[55] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, A&A, 448,
L47.
[56] Forot, M., et al., 2006, ApJ, 651, L45.
[57] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2006, A&A, 432,
L25.
[58] Djannati-Ataï, A., et al., 2007, these proceed-
ings.
V. ,
2 0 0 6 ,
[59] Komissarov, S. S., Lyubarsky, Y. E., 2004,
MNRAS, 349, 779.
[60] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2004, ApJ, 614, 897.
[61] Camilo, F., et al., 2006, ApJ, 637, 456.
[62] Li, X.-H., Lu, F.-J., Li, Z., 2007,
arXiv:astro-ph/0707.4279v1
[63] Ng, C.-Y., Roberts, M. S. E., & Romani, R.
W, 2005, ApJ, 627, 904.
[64] Funk, S., et al., 2007, ApJ, 662, 517.
[65] Gaensler, B. M., et al., 2006, ApJ, 648,
1037.
[ 6 6 ]
E .
G o t t h e l f ,
arXiv:astro-ph/0610376v1.
[67] Kennel, C. F., Coroniti, F. V., 1984, ApJ,
283, 694.
[68] Blondin, J.~M., Chevalier, R. A., Frierson,
D. M, 2001, ApJ, 563, 806.
[69] Albert, J., et al., 2007, ApJ, 664, L87.
[70] Albert, J., et al., 2008, ApJ, 669, 1143.
[71] Halpern, J. P., et al., 2001, ApJ, 552, L125.
[72] Mirabal, N., & Halpern, J.~P, 2001, ApJ,
547, L137.
[73] Reimer, O., et al., 2001, MNRAS, 324, 772.
[74] Kaspi, V.~M., et al., 2000, ApJ, 528, 445.
[75]
Gonzales, M.,
et
al.,
2006,
arXiv:astro-ph/0610523v2.
[76] Harding, A. K., Grenier, I. A., & Gonthier, P.
L, 2007, Ap&SS, 309, 221.
[77] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2005, A&A, 442, 1.
[78] Ball, L., & Dodd, J, 2001, PASA, 18, 98.
[79] Kawachi, A., et al., 2004, ApJ, 607, 949.
[80] Aharonian, F. A., et al., 2005, Science, 309,
746.
[81] Albert, J., et al., 2006, Science, 312, 1771.
[82] Dubus, G., 2006, A&A, 456, 801.
[83] Dhawan, V., Mioduszewski, A., Rupen, M,
2006, VI Microquasar Workshop: Microquasars
and Beyond.
[84] Albert, J., et al., 2007, ApJ, 665, L51.
[85] Paredes, J. M., Bosch-Ramon, V., Romero,
G. E, 2006, A&A, 451, 259.
[86] Dermer, C.~D., Böttcher, M, 2006, ApJ,
643, 1081.
[87] Grenier, I. A., Kaufman Bernadò, M. M., &
Romero, G. E, 2005, Ap&SS, 297, 109.
|
astro-ph/0411548 | 1 | 0411 | 2004-11-18T19:01:35 | Intrinsically faint quasars: evidence for meV axion dark matter in the Universe | [
"astro-ph",
"hep-ph"
] | Growing amount of observations indicate presence of intrinsically faint quasar subgroup (a few % of known quasars) with noncosmological quantized redshift. Here we find an analytical solution of Einstein equations describing bubbles made from axions with periodic interaction potential. Such particles are currently considered as one of the leading dark matter candidate. The bubble interior possesses equal gravitational redshift which can have any value between zero and infinity. Quantum pressure supports the bubble against collapse and yields states stable on the scale more then hundreds million years. Our results explain the observed quantization of quasar redshift and suggest that intrinsically faint point-like quasars associated with nearby galaxies are axionic bubbles with masses 10^8-10^9M_{Sun} and radii 10^3-10^4R_{Sun}. They are born in active galaxies and ejected into surrounding space. Properties of such quasars unambiguously indicate presence of axion dark matter in the Universe and yield the axion mass \approx 1 meV, which fits in the open axion mass window constrained by astrophysical and cosmological arguments. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Intrinsically faint quasars: evidence for meV axion dark matter in the Universe
Anatoly A. Svidzinsky
Department of Physics, Institute for Quantum Studies, Texas A&M University, TX 77843-4242
(Dated: January 25, 2019)
Growing amount of observations indicate presence of intrinsically faint quasar subgroup (a few %
of known quasars) with noncosmological quantized redshift. Here we find an analytical solution of
Einstein equations describing bubbles made from axions with periodic interaction potential. Such
particles are currently considered as one of the leading dark matter candidate. The bubble interior
possesses equal gravitational redshift which can have any value between zero and infinity. Quantum
pressure supports the bubble against collapse and yields states stable on the scale more then hun-
dreds million years. Our results explain the observed quantization of quasar redshift and suggest
that intrinsically faint point-like quasars associated with nearby galaxies are axionic bubbles with
masses 108-109M⊙ and radii 103-104R⊙. They are born in active galaxies and ejected into sur-
rounding space. Properties of such quasars unambiguously indicate presence of axion dark matter
in the Universe and yield the axion mass m ≈ 1 meV, which fits in the open axion mass window
constrained by astrophysical and cosmological arguments.
∼ 50−100
Based on observations, Karlsson [1] has noted division
of quasars (QSOs) into two groups with different red-
shift properties and concluded the following. If we select
QSOs associated with most nearby (distance d <
Mpc), galaxies then their redshift is close to certain val-
ues (quantized), as shown in Fig. 3 below. Meanwhile,
in QSO samples associated with distant galaxies no pe-
riodicity in intrinsic redshift is observed. Such a division
is supported by later studies of QSOs associated with
most nearby galaxies where the quantization was con-
firmed [2, 3] and distant (0.01 < zgal < 0.3) galaxies for
which absence of any periodicity was claimed [4]. The
observations suggest existence of intrinsically faint (op-
tical luminosity L = 105 − 107L⊙) QSO subgroup with
quantized noncosmological redshift. Being intrinsically
faint, such objects are not detected from large distances
(which yields disappearance of redshift quantization in
distant QSO samples) and constitute only a few % of the
known QSO population. Observations indicate that such
quasars are ejected from nearby active galaxies or in the
process of ejection from the galactic nucleus [5, 6].
Here we show that bubbles of dark matter with pe-
riodic interaction potential, masses about 108 − 109M⊙
and radii 103 − 104R⊙ can explain the intrinsically faint
quasars. The bubble is supported against collapse by
quantum pressure and decays on a time scale more than
hundreds million years. Hypothetical axions, one of the
leading dark matter candidate, fit well into this picture
and can account for the redshift quantization. Usual
baryonic matter falls into the bubble interior, heated
by the release of the gravitational energy and produce
electromagnetic radiation that freely propagate into sur-
rounding space.
In this Letter we study massive real scalar field ϕ with
periodic interaction potential
V (ϕ) = V0[1 − cos(ϕ/f )],
(1)
where V0 > 0. This potential is quite general and de-
rived in quantum filed theory in connection with pseudo
Nambu-Goldstone bosons (PNGBs) [7]. In all such mod-
els, the key ingredients are the scales of global symme-
try breaking f and explicit symmetry breaking (V0)1/4.
One of the examples of a light hypothetical PNGB is
the axion which possess extraordinarily feeble couplings
to matter and radiation and is well-motivated dark mat-
ter candidate [8]. If the axion exists, astrophysical and
cosmological arguments constrain its mass to be in the
range of m = 10−6 − 3 × 10−3 eV and the global
symmetry-breaking scale to lie in a window f ≈ 107 GeV
×0.62/m(eV) = 2 × 109 − 6 × 1012 GeV [8].
We consider spherically symmetric system with metric
ds2 = −N 2dt2 + g2dr2 + r2dΩ2,
(2)
where g, the radial metric, and N , the lapse, are functions
of t and r with r being the circumferential radius. We
introduce dimensionless coordinates and define the unit
of distance, time and ϕ as
r0 =
¯h
mc
,
t0 =
¯h
mc2 , ϕ0 =
1
√4πG
,
(3)
where c is the speed of light, G is the gravitational con-
stant, m = √V0/f is the particle mass. In dimensionless
units the static Klein-Gordon and Einstein equations de-
scribing the self-gravitating field ϕ and the metric are
[9]
ϕ′
g2 (cid:18) g2 + 1
r − 2rg2V(cid:19) +
ϕ′′
g2 −
∂V
∂ϕ
= 0,
(4)
N
N ′ =
g′ =
2 (cid:20) g2 − 1
r
g
2 (cid:20) 1 − g2
r
+ r(cid:0)ϕ′2 − 2g2V(cid:1)(cid:21) ,
+ r(cid:0)ϕ′2 + 2g2V(cid:1)(cid:21) ,
(5)
(6)
with boundary conditions
g(0) = g(∞) = N (∞) = 1,
g′(0) = N ′(0) = ϕ′(0) = 0, V (ϕ(∞)) = 0,
where prime denotes ∂/∂r,
V =
1
α2 [1 − cos(αϕ)], α =
1
√4πGf
=
mpl√4πf
(7)
is the dimensionless potential and the coupling parame-
ter respectively, mpl = p¯hc/G = 1.2 × 1019 GeV is the
Planck mass. The interaction potential has degenerate
minima at ϕ = 2πn/α, where n is an integer number.
Here we show that in the limit of strong nonlinearity,
(4)-(6) have an approximate static solu-
α ≫ 1, Eqs.
tion that describes a spherical bubble with surface width
much smaller then its radius R. The bubble surface is
an interface between two degenerate vacuum states with
ϕ = 2πn/α (r < R) and ϕ = 0 (r > R).
Outside the bubble Eqs.
(4)-(6) lead to the known
Schwazschild solution
g2 =
1
1 − 2M/r
, N 2 = 1 −
2M
r
,
(8)
where M is the bubble mass in units of m2
pl/m.
Let us assume that R ≫ α ≫ 1. Then, near the surface
one can omit terms with 1/r in Eqs. (4)-(6) and take
r ≈ R, we obtain
− 2Rϕ′V +
ϕ′′
g2 −
∂V
∂ϕ
= 0,
N ′ =
N R
2 (cid:0)ϕ′2 − 2g2V(cid:1) ,
g′ =
gR
2 (cid:0)ϕ′2 + 2g2V(cid:1) .
(9)
(10)
(11)
Eqs. (9)-(11) can be solved analytically. Their first inte-
gral is
N = const, ϕ′2 = 2g2V,
g′ = Rgϕ′2.
(12)
We assume ϕ(0) = 2πn/α, where n = 1, 2, 3, . . . is the
number of kinks at the bubble surface, and ϕ(r) mono-
tonically decreases with r. Eqs. (12) yield
1
g
= 1 − RZ ϕ(0)
ϕ
√2V dϕ, ϕ′ = −
√2V
1 − RR ϕ(0)
ϕ
.
√2V dϕ
(13)
For V (ϕ) given by Eq. (7) the final solution is
4R
α2 ln sin(αϕ/2)+(cid:20)1 −
4R
α2 (2m − 1)(cid:21) arctanh[cos(αϕ/2)]
2
FIG. 1: Scalar field ϕ as a function of distance r to the bubble
center for bubbles with equal radius and different quantum
numbers n = 1, 2, 3. The unit of length is ¯h/mc. Note,
we plot the field ϕ only in the vicinity of the bubble surface
where it undergoes variation.
where Rm is a position of the mth kink, m = 1, 2, . . . , n.
When the coordinate r passes through the point Rm
the scalar field ϕ(r) changes from 2π(n − m + 1)/α to
2π(n − m)/α (see Fig. 1). Eq. (13) yields the following
expression for g as a function of ϕ inside the bubble:
1
g
= 1 −
4R
α2 [2m − 1 + cos(αϕ/2)].
(15)
Outside the bubble ϕ = 0, m = n and 1/g = 1 −
8nR/α2. The solution is valid if 1/g > 0, that is
R < Rmax = α2/8n. Match of the inner solution (13)
with the Schwazschild solution (8) determines the mass-
radius relation
M = 4πnuR2 − 8π2n2u2R3,
(16)
cosine potential (7) u = 2/πα2.
where u is the surface energy density given by an integral
over one potential period u = R √2V dϕ/4π. For the
Redshift of the bubble interior z = 1/N − 1 can be
found by matching the inner N = const and the outer
(8) solutions:
1
1
1 − 4πnuR − 1.
(17)
z =
p1 − 2M/R − 1 =
The internal redshift monotonically increases from zero
to infinity when the bubble radius R changes from zero to
Rmax. Fig. 2 shows the redshift of space as a function of
the distance r to the bubble center. The redshift is con-
stant in the bubble interior and monotonically decreases
outside the bubble.
= sign[sin(αϕ/2)](r − Rm),
ϕ ∈ [2π(n − m + 1)/α, 2π(n − m)/α],
(14)
Let us make rescaling M → M/4πu, R → R/4πu, then
Eqs. (16), (17) yield
M = nR2 − n2R3/2,
z =
1
1 − nR − 1.
(18)
3
n R, in α2¯h/mc
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
0.0329
0.0241
0.0204
0.0182
0.0168
0.0159
0.0153
0.0151
z
0.357
0.629
0.96
1.40
2.06
3.24
6.11
26.6
TABLE I: Redshift of the bubble interior z and its radius R
for M = 0.00752α2 m2
pl/m and different kink numbers n.
FIG. 2: Redshift z of space as a function of distance r to the
bubble center for bubbles shown in Fig. 1.
For a given M the redshift depends on the integer number
n, which implies the redshift is quantized.
In early samples of QSOs associated with nearby spiral
galaxies, Karlsson showed that the redshift distribution
has a periodicity log(1 + zn+1) − log(1 + zn) = 0.089,
where n = 0, 1, 2, . . . and z0 = 0.061 [10]. It has been
later confirmed by other groups [2, 11]. In a recent pa-
per, Burbidge and Napier [3] tested for the occurrence of
this periodicity in new QSO samples and found it to be
present at a high confidence level. The peaks were found
at z ≈ 0.30, 0.60, 0.96, 1.41 and 1.96 in agreement with
Karlsson's empirical formula. The formula also includes
the peak at z0 = 0.061, however, this peak does not occur
for quasars, but for morphologically related objects.
The redshift periodicity is observed only in QSO sam-
ples satisfying certain selection criteria, in particular, the
galaxies which are assumed to be paired to the QSOs
must be most nearby spirals [1, 12]. This implies that
redshift quantization is a property of intrinsically faint
QSOs which are not detected from large distances.
It is naturally to assume that QSOs born in the same
type of galaxies have approximately equal masses because
their formation mechanism must be similar. Such phe-
nomenon is well known for type Ia supernovae or neu-
tron stars: practically all measured neutron star masses
cluster around the value of 1.4M⊙ with only a few per-
cent deviation [13]. If dark matter bubbles are born with
equal masses then, according to Eqs.
(18), their red-
shift must be quantized. For M = 0.0601 (in dimension
units M = 0.00752α2m2
pl/m) Eqs. (18) have solutions for
n = 1, 2, . . . , 8, they are given in Table 1.
In Fig. 3 we plot the most recent histogram of the
redshift distribution from Ref.
[12] in which five peaks
are clearly seen. The solid lines show the redshifts from
our Table 1, they match well the observed peaks. The
agreement is remarkable because the theory has only one
free parameter, the bubble mass M . Such coincidence
strongly suggests that the point-like quasars associated
FIG. 3: Histogram of the redshift distribution of QSOs close
to bright nearby active spiral galaxies or multiple QSOs with
small angular separation from Ref. [12]. The solid lines rep-
resent position of the peaks from Table 1.
with nearby galaxies are dark matter bubbles composed
of scalar particles with periodic interaction potential.
One should mention an alternative possibility of quasar
evolution. Bubbles can be originally born with the same
mass and number of kinks n = 5 that corresponds to
the 5th peak. During evolution the kinks tunnel to the
bubble center and quasars sequentially decay into states
with smaller n but the same mass.
For axions with m = 0.1 − 3 meV and f = 2 × 109 −
6 × 1010 GeV Eq. (7) yields α = 5.6 × 107 − 1.7 × 109.
Hence, an axion bubble with the internal redshift z =
0.36 and n = 1 would have the mass M = 3 × 107 −
109M⊙ and the radius R = 3× 102− 104R⊙. Such radius
range agrees with the size of the emission region expected
for the intrinsically faint QSOs.
Indeed, for Seyfert 1
galaxies the size of the broad-line region is R ∼ 10 − 100
light days. The luminosity L of the QSOs is 5-6 orders
smaller. Based on the empirical relation for Seyfert 1
galaxies R ∝ L1/2 [14], we obtain for the quasars R ∼
104R⊙.
Now we discuss the bubble life time. Under the in-
fluence of surface tension and gravitational attraction an
initially static bubble starts to collapse. In the thin-wall
approximation the initial acceleration is given by [15]
R = −
2N 3
R −
N 2M
(1 + N )R2 ,
(19)
where N = p1 − 2M/R. For one kink thin-wall con-
tracting bubble the conserved mass is [15]
energy mc2 by a moving bubble surface is governed by the
Boltzmann factor exp(−mc2/Teff ), where Teff = a/c is
the effective temperature and a is the acceleration of the
surface [19]. For the bubble a ≈ c2/R(t) and the Boltz-
mann factor reduces to exp(−R(t)/l) where l = ¯h/mc is
the surface width. Hence, emission of scalar particles is
exponentially suppressed apart from small regions where
R(t) <
∼ l. As a result, during one period of oscillation,
tc ∼ R/c, the energy loss is ∆E ∼ (l/R)E, which yields
the bubble life time
4
M =
4πuR2
p1 − (dR/dτ )2 − 8π2u2R3,
(20)
where τ is the interior coordinate time. Based on Eqs.
(19), (20) one can expect a continuous contraction of the
bubble to the origin on an astronomically short time scale
R/c ≪ 1yr. However, so far we treated the scalar field
as classical. Quantum corrections suppress the collapse
and result in appearance of long-lived bubbles, stable on
a scale more then hundreds million years. To include
quantum effects it has been suggested that the expres-
sion (20) be interpreted as the canonical hamiltonian of
the bubble at the quantum level [16, 17, 18]. The bub-
ble wave function Ψ(R) satisfies the following stationary
quantum mechanical equation in one dimension (¯h = 1)
[18]:
(cid:20)(cid:0)E + 8π2u2R3(cid:1)2
+
∂2
∂R2 − 16π2u2R4(cid:21) Ψ(R) = 0. (21)
This equation possesses stationary solutions that are not
possible in the classical model. Bubbles of non-negligible
redshift correspond to highly excited stationary states
for which the energy spectrum can be treated as quasi-
continuous. At the quantum level the collapse is pre-
vented by quantum pressure that balances the surface
tension and gravitational attraction producing station-
ary configurations.
Let us estimate the decay time of an excited station-
ary state of the quantum bubble. The decay occurs by
means of scalar particle emission. We estimate the de-
cay time using the Bohr correspondence principle as the
time of energy loss by the classical bubble with the ra-
dius R(t) oscillating between the turning points R(t) = R
and R(t) = 0, where R is determined by Eq. (16). In
the quantum picture, however, there are no such oscil-
lations. The probability of creation a particle with the
R
l
R2
cl
.
t ∼
(22)
For an axionic bubble with R > 102R⊙ and l < 0.7 cm
Eq. (22) yields t > 108 yrs which is the time we need to
account for the phenomenon of quasars.
tc =
Properties of the intrinsically faint point-like QSOs,
combined with equations for the bubble mass M =
0.00752α2m2
pl/m = 2.94m(eV) × 1011M⊙ and the radius
R = 0.0329α2¯h/mc = 2.73m(eV) × 106R⊙, allow us to
determine the axion mass m. The quasar luminosity sug-
gests that the bubble radius is larger then 103R⊙ which
yields m > 0.4 meV and M > 108M⊙. From the other
hand, the quasar ejection from active galaxies implies
that the bubble mass M must be much smaller then the
galactic mass. It is reasonable to constrain M < 109M⊙
which leads to m < 3 meV and R < 104R⊙. We con-
clude, the axion mass is m = 0.4− 3 meV. This value fits
in the open window for the axion mass constrained by as-
trophysical and cosmological arguments [8], which unam-
biguously points towards the axionic nature of dark mat-
ter composing the intrinsically faint point-like quasars.
Current cavity search experiments in Livermore [20] and
Kyoto University [8] are looking for the axion in the mass
range 1 − 10 µeV which deviates by two orders of mag-
nitude from our result. Probably now, when the axion
mass is established from quasar observations, the axion
has a better chance to be discovered.
We mention that data on central "black hole" masses
in small companion galaxies allow us to determine the
axion mass more accurately and yield m = 1.0 − 1.9
meV. We will discuss this elsewhere. Moreover, observa-
tions show that apart from the intrinsically faint point-
like objects considered here there is a subgroup of bright
quasars which probably also possess noncosmological red-
shift. Tachyons, another dark matter candidate, can ex-
plain their nature. We discuss this in a detail paper [21].
[1] K.G. Karlsson, A&A 239, 50 (1990).
[2] H. Arp et al., A&A 239, 33 (1990).
[3] G. Burbidge and W.M. Napier, AJ 121, 21 (2001).
[4] E. Hawkins, S.J. Maddox and M.R. Merrifield, MNRAS
336, L13 (2002).
[5] G.R. Burbidge et al., ApJS 74, 675 (1990); E.M. Bur-
bidge et al., ApJ 591, 690 (2003); H. Arp et al., A&A
391, 833 (2002); A&A 418, 877 (2004).
[6] H. Arp, Quasars, redshifts and controversies, Interstellar
Media, Berkeley, 1987; Seeing red: redshifts, cosmology
and academic science, Apeiron, Montreal, 1998.
[7] C.T. Hill and G.G. Ross, Nucl. Phys. B311, 253 (1988).
[8] R. Bradley et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 777 (2003).
[9] E. Seidel and W. M. Suen, Phys. Rev. D 42, 384 (1990).
[10] K.G. Karlsson, A&A 13, 333 (1971); 58, 237 (1977).
[11] J.M. Barnothy and M.F. Barnothy, PASP 88, 837 (1976).
[12] W.M. Napier and G. Burbidge, MNRAS 342, 601 (2003).
[13] N.K. Glendenning, "Compact Stars: Nuclear Physics,
Particle Physics, and General Relativity", Springer Ver-
lag; New York, 2nd edition, (2000).
[14] T.G. Wang and X.G. Zhang, MNRAS 340, 793 (2003).
[15] S. K. Blau et al., Phys. Rev. D 35, 1747 (1987).
[16] V.A. Berezin et al., Phys. Lett. B 212, 415 (1988).
[17] A. Aurilia and E. Spallucci, Phys. Lett. B 251, 39 (1990).
[18] A. Aurilia et al., Phys. Lett. B 262, 222 (1991).
[19] A. Gorsky and K. Selivanov, Phys. Rev. D 62, 071702
(2000).
[20] S.J. Asztalos et al., Phys. Rev. D 69, 011101(R) (2004).
[21] A.A. Svidzinsky, astro-ph/0409064.
5
|
astro-ph/0508083 | 2 | 0508 | 2005-11-21T21:39:29 | Definitive Identification of the Transition between Small- to Large-Scale Clustering for Lyman Break Galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report angular correlation function (ACF) of Lyman Break Galaxies (LBGs) with unprecedented statistical quality on the basis of 16,920 LBGs at z=4 detected in the 1 deg^2 sky of the Subaru/XMM-Newton Deep Field. The ACF significantly departs from a power law, and shows an excess on small scale. Particularly, the ACF of LBGs with i'<27.5 have a clear break between the small and large-scale regimes at the angular separation of ~7'' whose projected length corresponds to the virial radius of dark halos with a mass of 10^11-12 Mo, indicating multiple LBGs residing in a single dark halo. Both on small (2''<theta<3'') and large (40''<theta<400'') scales, clustering amplitudes monotonically increase with luminosity for the magnitude range of i'=24.5-27.5, and the small-scale clustering shows a stronger luminosity dependence than the large-scale clustering. The small-scale bias reaches b~10-50, and the outskirts of small-scale excess extend to a larger angular separation for brighter LBGs. The ACF and number density of LBGs can be explained by the cold dark matter model. | astro-ph | astro-ph | To Appear in the Astrophysical Journal Letters
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 6/22/04
5
0
0
2
v
o
N
1
2
2
v
3
8
0
8
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
DEFINITIVE IDENTIFICATION OF THE TRANSITION BETWEEN
SMALL- TO LARGE-SCALE CLUSTERING FOR LYMAN BREAK GALAXIES1
Masami Ouchi 2,3, Takashi Hamana 4, Kazuhiro Shimasaku 5, Toru Yamada 4,
Masayuki Akiyama 6, Nobunari Kashikawa 4, Makiko Yoshida 5, Kentaro Aoki 6,
Masanori Iye 4, Tomoki Saito 5, Toshiyuki Sasaki 6,
Chris Simpson 7, and Michitoshi Yoshida 8
To Appear in the Astrophysical Journal Letters
ABSTRACT
We report angular correlation function (ACF) of Lyman Break Galaxies (LBGs) with unprecedented
statistical quality on the basis of 16,920 LBGs at z = 4 detected in the 1 deg2 sky of the Subaru/XMM-
Newton Deep Field. The ACF significantly departs from a power law, and shows an excess on small
scale. Particularly, the ACF of LBGs with i′ < 27.5 have a clear break between the small and
large-scale regimes at the angular separation of ≃ 7′′ whose projected length corresponds to the virial
radius of dark halos with a mass of 1011−12M⊙, indicating multiple LBGs residing in a single dark halo.
Both on small (2′′ < θ < 3′′) and large (40′′ < θ < 400′′) scales, clustering amplitudes monotonically
increase with luminosity for the magnitude range of i′ = 24.5 − 27.5, and the small-scale clustering
shows a stronger luminosity dependence than the large-scale clustering. The small-scale bias reaches
b ≃ 10 − 50, and the outskirts of small-scale excess extend to a larger angular separation for brighter
LBGs. The ACF and number density of LBGs can be explained by the cold dark matter model.
Subject headings:
large-scale structure of universe -- galaxies: formation -- galaxies: high-redshift
1. INTRODUCTION
Recent observational studies have been found strong
clustering in two-point angular correlation function
(ACF) of Lyman break galaxies (LBGs) at z = 3−5, (e.g.
Giavalisco & Dickinson 2001; Ouchi et al. 2001; Foucaud
et al. 2003; Adelberger et al. 2003; Ouchi et al. 2004b;
Hildebrandt et al. 2004; Allen et al. 2005), red galaxies
at z = 3 (Daddi et al. 2003), and Lyα emitters (LAEs;
Ouchi et al. 2003; Shimasaku et al. 2004) at z = 5. Even
at z = 6, there is a piece of evidence for filamentary
large (100 Mpc)-scale structures of LAEs (Ouchi et al.
2005). The distribution of high-z galaxies is fairly inho-
mogeneous and highly biased against matter distribution
predicted by the cold dark matter (CDM) model. The
estimated bias is b ≃ 2−8, depending on luminosity/type
and redshift of galaxies. However, the shape of the ACF
for high-z galaxies is not well constrained. Ouchi et al.
(2001) report a 3σ excess of the ACF at θ < 5′′ for z ∼ 4
LBGs, while Porciani & Giavalisco (2002) found a pos-
sible deficit of the ACF at 10′′ . θ . 30′′ for bright
LBGs which they interpret as the halo exclusion effect
on hosting halos with a mass of 1012M⊙.
In the local universe, the correlation function shows a
departure from a power law (e.g. Hawkins et al. 2003;
Zehavi et al. 2004). The departure is reproduced in the
1 Based on data collected at Subaru Telescope, which is oper-
ated by the National Astronomical Observatory of Japan.
2 Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Bal-
timore, MD 21218, USA; [email protected].
3 Hubble Fellow
4 National Astronomical Observatory, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan
5 Department of Astronomy, School of Science, University of
Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan
6 Subaru Telescope, National Astronomical Observatory, 650
N.A'ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720, USA
7 Department of Physics, University of Durham, South Road,
Durham DH1 3LE, UK
8 Okayama Astrophysical Observatory, National Astronomical
Observatory, Kamogata, Okayama 719-0232, Japan
framework of the halo occupation distribution (HOD)
and the related halo models in the CDM cosmology (van
den Bosch et al. 2003; Magliocchetti & Porciani 2003; Ze-
havi et al. 2004; Benson et al. 2001; Berlind et al. 2003),
and is explained by two sources contributing to the corre-
lation function; one for galaxy pairs residing in the same
halo (1-halo term) and the other for galaxies hosted by
different halos (2-halo term; see, e.g., Zehavi et al. 2004).
The HOD has been also applied to clustering of galaxies
at high-z (Bullock et al. 2002; Moustakas & Somerville
2002; Hamana et al. 2004). However, parameters of the
models have not been constrained with similar accuracy
as at low-z because of the small sample (100−2000 galax-
ies) and surveyed area (0.01 − 0.1deg2).
In this paper, we present ACF of z = 4 LBGs with
unprecedented statistical quality, on the basis of 16,920
LBGs obtained in the 1 deg2 sky of Subaru/XMM-
Newton Deep Field (SXDF; Sekiguchi et al. 2004).
Throughout this paper, magnitudes are in the AB sys-
tem, and we adopt H0 = 70h70km s−1 Mpc−1 and
[Ωm, ΩΛ, n, σ8] = [0.3, 0.7, 1.0, 0.9]. To facilitate compar-
ison with previous results, we express r0 using h100, the
Hubble constant in units of 100 km s−1 Mpc−1.
2. DATA AND SAMPLE
We carried out deep optical broad-band imaging with
Subaru/Suprime-Cam in the 1 deg2 sky of the SXDF.
Our broad-band images reach B ≃ 28.3, V ≃ 27.3,
R ≃ 27.6, i′ ≃ 27.5, and z′ ≃ 26.5 with a 2′′-diameter cir-
cular aperture at the 3σ level (Furusawa et al. in prepa-
ration). Typical seeing sizes (FWHM) of these images
are 0′′.8. We use the i′-band selected source catalog of
the SXDS V er1.0 produced with SExtractor (Bertin &
Arnouts 1996), which is composed of 0.7 million objects
with i′ < 27.5. We select LBGs at z = 4.0 ± 0.5 on the
basis of the color criteria of Ouchi et al. (2004a), i.e.,
B − R > 1.2, R − i′ < 0.7, and B − R > 1.6(R − i′) + 1.9,
2
Ouchi et al.
Fig. 1. -- The distribution of LBGs at z = 4.0 ± 0.5 in the
SXDF. The red, blue, and black points denote the positions of
the LBGs with i′ < 24.5 (bright), 24.5 ≤ i′ < 26.0 (interme-
diate), and 26.0 ≤ i′ < 27.5 (faint), respectively. The gray ar-
eas present masked regions where we did not use for our analy-
sis. The scale on the map is marked in both degrees and (co-
moving) megaparsecs for projected distance at z = 4.0. This
figure is degraded. This paper with the original figure
can be downloaded from http : //www − int.stsci.edu/ ∼
ouchi/work/astroph/sxds z4LBG/ouchi highres.pdf
which were determined with the results of spectroscopy
and Monte-Carlo simulations. We visually inspect all
the candidates and mask areas contaminated with halos
of bright stars and CCD blooming. Our final catalog in-
cludes 16,920 LBGs in a 1.00 deg2 area (Table 1). Figure
1 shows the sky distribution of our LBGs. Our spec-
troscopic follow-up observations show that 60 out of 63
identified candidates are real LBGs at z = 3.5 − 4.5;
i.e., 17 out of 17 and 43 out of 46 are LBGs in the
SXDF (Akiyama M. in preparation) and in the Subaru
Deep Field, respectively, where the latter LBG sample
is made with the same color criteria as ours (Yoshida
2005). Thus, the contamination rate of our LBG sample
is estimated to be (63 − 60)/63 = 5%.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1. Definitive Identification of Clustering Transition
We derive the ACF, ω(θ), by the formula of Landy &
Szalay (1993) with random samples composed of 200,000
sources, and estimate bootstrap errors (Ling et al. 1986).
Since clustering properties of our 5% contaminants are
not clear, we do not apply a correction for contaminants
with the assumption of random distribution (c.f. Ouchi
et al. 2004b). However, this correction changes ω(θ) and
bias only by 10% or less. Figure 2 presents the ACF of
LBGs (top panel), residuals of a power-law fit (middle
panel), and galaxy-dark matter bias (bottom panel) de-
fined as b(θ) ≡ pω(θ)/ωdm(θ), where ωdm(θ) is the ACF
predicted by the non-linear model of Peacock & Dodds
(1996).
In the top and middle panels of Figure 2 the
ACF of LBGs shows a significant excess on small scale,
and indicates that a power law, Aωθ−β, does not fit the
Fig. 2. -- T op : The ACF, ω(θ), of LBGs. The filled and open
squares indicate the ACF with 1 σ bootstrap errors, while the
open squares mean for ACF on very small scale which may include
additional errors in source deblending and confusion. The solid
line is the best-fit power law (Aωθ−β ) for 2′′ − 1000′′. The open
circles are the ACF with IC correction under the assumption of
the conventional power-law approximation, and the dashed lines
are the best-fit power law for these open circles. The dotted curve
is the ACF of dark matter predicted by the non-linear model of
Peacock & Dodds (1996). The scale on the top axis denotes the
projected distance in comoving megaparsecs at z = 4.0. The ticks
labeled with R(1E10), R(1E11), R(1E12), R(1E13), and R(1E14)
correspond to the predicted virial radii of dark halos, r200, with a
mass of 1 × 1010, 1011, 1012, 1013, and 1014 h−1
70 M⊙, respectively.
M iddle : The ratios of the ACF to the best-fit power law for our
LBGs (squares), together with those for local galaxies (crosses;
Zehavi et al. 2004). Bottom : The galaxy-dark matter bias, b,
of LBGs as a function of separation. The dashed curve presents
bias of local galaxies (Zehavi et al. 2004). The ticks with b(1E11),
b(1E12), and b(1E13) show linear biases of dark halos with a mass
of 1 × 1011, 1012, and 1013 h−1
70 M⊙, respectively, predicted by the
CDM model of Sheth & Tormen (1999).
data. This is the definitive identification of the depar-
ture from a power law for the ACF of LBGs at z = 4.
With a visual inspection, we confirm that all close-pairs
of LBGs are not false detections. We also plot histogram
of galaxy sizes for LBG pairs. We find that most of our
LBGs have FWHM≃ 1′′ for pairs with any separations
down to, at least, ≃ 2′′, and that extended LBGs do not
boost small-scale ACF by producing false pairs. Uncer-
tainties in source deblending and photometry can hardly
account for the small-scale excess at & 2′′.
In fact, a
similar small-scale excess of ACF for z = 4 − 5 LBGs is
also found by a recent study on high-resolution (∼ 0′′.1)
HST images (Lee et al. 2005).
Comparing our ACF with the one of dark matter, we
find that the small-scale excess extends up to ≃ 7′′, i.e.
0.24h−1
70 Mpc, which is comparable to virial radius, r200,
of dark halos with a mass of 1011−12M⊙ (see the ticks in
the top panel of Figure 2), where r200 is a sphere of radius
within which the mean enclosed density is 200 times the
Transition of Clustering for LBGs
3
Fig. 3. -- The ACFs of magnitude-limited subsamples of LBGs
at z = 4.0. In the top to third-top panels, the filled symbols are
the ACFs of our LBGs with the limiting magnitude indicated in
the legend. Each of these panels shows the ACF of i′ < 27.5
LBGs with open squares. The dotted curves are the ACF of dark
matter predicted by the non-linear model of Peacock & Dodds
(1996). The thick solid and dashed lines indicate the best-fit ACFs
of the halo model and the breakdown of 1-halo and 2-halo terms
for each subsample, while the thin lines are for i′ < 27.5 LBGs. In
the bottom panels, biases of LBGs for the each magnitude-limited
subsample are presented with the symbols which correspond to
those marks found in the top to third-top panels. The plots of
large-scale biases are magnified in the inserted boxes.
mean cosmic value (Mo & White 2002). Interestingly, the
large-scale average bias at 40′′ < θ < 400′′ is estimated to
be 2.9±0.2 which is also comparable to linear bias of dark
halos with a mass of 1011−12M⊙ (b = 2.2 − 3.5) predicted
by the CDM (Sheth & Tormen 1999; see the ticks in the
bottom panel of Figure 2). This coincidence of the dark-
halo mass strongly supports that typical z = 4 LBGs
reside in dark halos with a mass of 1011−12M⊙. More-
over, these pieces of evidence suggest that multiple LBGs
occupy a single dark halo. The middle panel of Figure
2 also plots residuals of a power-law fit for local galax-
ies (Zehavi et al. 2004), which is comparable to those of
z = 4 LBGs on large scale, but significantly larger than
LBGs on intermediate scale (0.2 − 1.0 Mpc) correspond-
ing to the radius of 1012−14M⊙ dark halos. According to
the halo mass function (Sheth & Tormen 1999), the ratio
of galaxy-sized halos (1010−12M⊙) to group/cluster-sized
halos (1012−14M⊙) is about 10 times higher in number
density at z = 4 than at z = 0. This relative deficit of
group/cluster-sized halos at high-z would be the cause
of the clearer break between small and large-scale ACFs
at z = 4 than z = 0. Although multiple occupation of
LBGs explains very consistently both the angular scale
of transition and the amplitude of large-scale bias, there
remains the possibility that the small-scale excess is en-
hanced or produced by brightening of pair galaxies due
to interactions.
Fig. 4. -- Bias and slope of z = 4 LBGs as a function of limiting-
absolute magnitude calculated from i′ − M1500 = 46.0. Top and
middle panels present bias of small-scale (2′′ < θ < 3′′) and large-
scale (40′′ < θ < 400′′) clustering. Filled circles plot for our LBGs,
whose bias is directly measured from the ACFs. Open pentagons,
squares, triangles, and diamonds present the large-scale (≃ 8h−1
100)
bias estimated from the conventional power-law fit by Allen et al.
(2005); Ouchi et al. (2004b, 2001); Arnouts et al. (2002). In the
middle panel, the right-hand vertical scale means mass of dark
halos corresponding to the linear bias (Sheth & Tormen 1999). The
upper abscissa axis ticks number densities of our LBGs. Bottom
panel shows the slope of a power law for the ACFs. Filled and
open circles indicate the slopes for large-scale (40′′ < θ < 400′′)
with no IC correction (βL), and for all scales (2′′ < θ < 1000′′)
with IC correction (β; see Table 1), respectively.
3.2. Luminosity Dependence of Clustering
We calculate ω(θ) and b for six subsamples with lim-
iting magnitudes of i′ < 24.5, 25.0, 25.5, 26.0, 26.5, and
27.0 (Figure 3). We define the large- and small-scale bi-
ases as the biases in the range 40′′ < θ < 400′′ (1−10h−1
100
Mpc) and 2′′ < θ < 3′′ (0.05 − 0.07h−1
100 Mpc), respec-
tively, and show the biases in Figure 4. Although the
angular range for the small-scale bias is somewhat arbi-
trary, the range defined here is beyond the internal struc-
tures of galaxies and below the radii of dark halos with
1011M⊙, and thus is sensitive to a multiplicity of LBGs in
a halo. Luminosity segregation of large-scale clustering
is reported for z = 4 LBGs (Ouchi et al. 2004b; Allen et
al. 2005; Lee et al. 2005). In Figures 3 and 4, we find that
ACFs and biases monotonically decrease from i′ < 24.5
to 27.5 on small scale as well as large scale. Interestingly,
Figure 4 shows that the small-scale bias has a stronger
dependence on luminosity (b ≃ 10 − 50) than the large-
scale bias (b ≃ 3 − 4), and the bottom panels of Figure
4
Ouchi et al.
3 indicate that outskirts of small-scale excess extend to
θ ∼ 10′′ for bright (i′ < 24.5 − 25.5) LBGs. All the fea-
tures of luminosity dependence suggest that bright LBGs
reside in more massive dark halos, since massive dark ha-
los have not only a high large-scale bias, but also a high
small-scale bias (i.e. high probability of pair galaxies in
a massive halo) and an extended outskirt of bias due to
a large halo size.
Although the ACFs depart from a power law, we ap-
proximate the ACFs with a power law, in order to com-
pare our results with previous results. We fit the ACF
over 2−1000′′ with ω(θ) = Aω(θ−β −IC/Aω), where IC is
the integral constraint (Groth & Peebles 1977). The bot-
tom panel of Figure 4 presents the best-fit slopes, β, as a
function of magnitude. The slopes, β, become flatter at
faint magnitudes (see also Kashikawa et al. 2005). This
luminosity dependence of β is explained by the strong
luminosity dependence of small-scale clustering as dis-
cussed above. Then we calculate the Limber equation
with the redshift distribution function of Ouchi et al.
(2004b), and estimate the correlation lengths, r0, of spa-
tial two-point correlation function, ξ = (r/r0)−γ, where
γ = β + 1. Table 1 presents the best-fit parameters,
Aω and β, together with r0. These r0 are consistent
with those obtained by Ouchi et al. (2004b) as well as by
Hildebrandt et al. (2004) and Kashikawa et al. (2005).
However, our results are not consistent with those of
small-sky surveys in HDF, if we assume that ACF does
not significantly evolve between z = 3 and 4. For exam-
ples, Giavalisco & Dickinson (2001) find a small corre-
lation length of r0 = 1.0+0.8
100 Mpc for z = 3 LBGs,
while we find a larger value, r0 = 3.8+0.2
100 Mpc, for
our i′ < 27.5 LBGs whose number density is comparable
to that of Giavalisco & Dickinson (2001). We restrict our
power-law fitting to the same narrow range as Giavalisco
& Dickinson (2001) (1′′ . θ . 20′′), and then we obtain
the consistent results within errors, i.e. r0 = 1.3±0.3h−1
100
−0.7h−1
−0.2h−1
Mpc and β = 1.9 ± 0.2, due to the fitting only to the
small-scale excess of the ACF (see Kravtsov et al. 2004).
Similarly, the correlation length of red galaxies in HDF-S
(r0 = 8h−1
100 Mpc; Daddi et al. 2003) is probably overes-
timated by the extrapolation from a bump of small-scale
ACF with a relatively flat slope of β = 0.8, which is also
claimed by the model of Zheng (2004).
3.3. Comparison with a Halo Model
We fit the halo model of Hamana et al. (2004) to the
observed ω(θ) and number density, n, simultaneously.
This model predicts the ω(θ) and n of galaxies con-
tributed by a combination of the 1-halo and 2-halo terms
in the framework of the CDM model. The best-fit mod-
els are shown in Figure 3 and Table 1. These models
account for the overall shape of our ACFs, i.e., the small-
scale excess as well as the large-scale clustering (see also
Lee et al. 2005), although there remain large residuals 9
(e.g. χ2/dof = 3.0 for i′ < 27.5 LBGs). Reducing these
residuals results in a decrease in the combined likelihood
(ω(θ) + n) from the best-fit value. The large residuals
imply that we need a more precise model for our LBGs.
For implications of the model fitting, Table 1 summarizes
the average number of LBGs in a halo, hNgi, and the av-
erage masses of the halo, hMhi, (Hamana et al. 2004) for
the best-fit models. The average mass of hosting halos
monotonically decreases from 2 × 1012h−1
70 M⊙ (i′ < 24.5)
to 6 × 1011h−1
70 M⊙ (i′ < 27.5). The average number of
LBGs in a halo is less than unity, hNgi ≃ 0.2 − 0.7, while
the model ACF in Figure 3 shows a significant 1-halo
term produced by multiple LBGs in one halo. This im-
plies that majority of halos with an average mass have no
LBG and only some halos host one or multiple LBG(s).
We thank M. Fall, M. Giavalisco, K. Lee, S. Okamura,
and Z. Zheng for helpful comments and discussion.
9 Note that bootstrap errors of the ACF are assumed to be
independent.
REFERENCES
Adelberger, K. L., Steidel, C. C., Shapley, A. E., & Pettini, M.
2003, ApJ, 584, 45
Allen, P. D., Moustakas, L. A., Dalton, G., MacDonald, E., Blake,
C., Clewley, L., Heymans, C., & Wegner, G. 2005, MNRAS, 523
Arnouts, S., et al. 2002, MNRAS, 329, 355
Bullock, J. S., Wechsler, R. H., & Somerville, R. S. 2002, MNRAS,
Landy, S. D., & Szalay, A. S. 1993, ApJ, 412, 64
Lee, K. et al. 2005, submitted to ApJ
Ling, E. N., Barrow, J. D., & Frenk, C. S. 1986, MNRAS, 223, 21P
Magliocchetti, M., & Porciani, C. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 186
Mo, H. J. & White, S. D. M. 2002, MNRAS, 336, 112
Moustakas, L. A., & Somerville, R. S. 2002, ApJ, 577, 1 2002,
329, 246
Benson, A. J., Frenk, C. S., Baugh, C. M., Cole, S., & Lacey, C. G.
2001, MNRAS, 327, 1041
Berlind, A. A., et al. 2003, ApJ, 593, 1
Bertin, E. & Arnouts, S. 1996, A&AS, 117, 393 al. 2002, ApJ, 579,
42
Daddi, E., et al. 2003, ApJ, 588, 50
Foucaud, S., McCracken, H. J., Le F`evre, O., Arnouts, S., Brodwin,
M., Lilly, S. J., Crampton, D., & Mellier, Y. 2003, A&A, 409,
835
Giavalisco, M. & Dickinson, M. 2001, ApJ, 550, 177
Giavalisco, M. 2005, "Wide-Field Imaging from Space", Eds. T.
McKay, A. Fruchter, and E. Linder. Elsevier, in press
Groth, E. J. & Peebles, P. J. E. 1977, ApJ, 217, 385
Hamana, T., Ouchi, M., Shimasaku, K., Kayo, I., & Suto, Y. 2004,
MNRAS, 347, 813
Hawkins, E., et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 78
Hildebrandt, H., et al. 2004, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints,
arXiv:astro-ph/0412375
Kashikawa, N. et al. 2005, submitted to ApJ
Kravtsov, A. V., Berlind, A. A., Wechsler, R. H., Klypin, A. A.,
Gottlober, S., Allgood, B., & Primack, J. R. 2004, ApJ, 609, 35
MNRAS, 332, 827
Ouchi, M. et al. 2001, ApJ, 558, L83
Ouchi, M. et al. 2003, ApJ, 582, 60
Ouchi, M., et al. 2004a, ApJ, 611, 660
Ouchi, M., et al. 2004b, ApJ, 611, 685
Ouchi, M., et al. 2005, ApJ, 620, L1
Peacock, J. A., & Dodds, S. J. 1996, MNRAS, 280, L19
Porciani, C., & Giavalisco, M. 2002, ApJ, 565, 24
Sekiguchi, K. et al. 2004, Astrophysics and Space Science Library,
301, 169
Sheth, R. K. & Tormen, G. 1999, MNRAS, 308, 119
Shimasaku, K., et al. 2004, ApJ, 605, L93
van den Bosch, F. C., Yang, X., & Mo, H. J. 2003, MNRAS, 340,
771
Yoshida, M. 2005, Master Thesis, University of Tokyo
Zehavi, I., et al. 2004, ApJ, 608, 16
Zheng, Z. 2004, ApJ, 610, 61
Transition of Clustering for LBGs
5
Summary of Clustering Properties
TABLE 1
Conventional Power-Law Approx.
Modele
i′
AB
(mag)
N (< i′)a
n(< i′)b
70 Mpc−3)
(h3
24.5
25.0
25.5
26.0
26.5
27.0
27.5
239
808
2231
4891
8639
12921
16920
9.8 ± 1.6 × 10−5
2.8 ± 0.3 × 10−4
6.4 ± 0.6 × 10−4
1.3 ± 0.1 × 10−3
2.2 ± 0.3 × 10−3
3.7 ± 0.7 × 10−3
5.8 ± 1.4 × 10−3
c
Aω
(arcsecβ )
10.5 ± 8.2
5.0 ± 9.1
3.1 ± 1.6
2.6 ± 0.6
0.6 ± 0.1
0.8 ± 0.1
0.5 ± 0.1
βc
c
r0
d
βL
hN gi
(h−1
100 Mpc)
4.9+4.3
−4.1
5.5+1.7
−2.1
5.0+0.7
−0.8
5.0+0.4
−0.4
4.8+0.2
−0.3
4.4+0.1
−0.2
3.8+0.2
−0.2
1.1 ± 0.4
0.9 ± 0.3
0.8 ± 0.1
0.8 ± 0.1
0.5 ± 0.1
0.6 ± 0.1
0.5 ± 0.1
≃ 1.6
0.9 ± 0.6
0.8 ± 0.4
1.0 ± 0.2
0.7 ± 0.2
0.7 ± 0.1
0.6 ± 0.1
0.2+0.2
−0.2
0.3+0.4
−0.3
0.6+0.1
−0.5
0.6+0.1
−0.1
0.6+0.1
−0.1
0.6+0.1
−0.2
0.7+0.2
−0.1
log hMhi
(h−1
70 M⊙)
12.3+0.1
−0.6
12.3+0.1
−0.2
12.1+0.1
−0.1
12.0+0.1
−0.1
11.9+0.05
−0.05
11.8+0.07
−0.04
11.8+0.02
−0.05
aCumulative numbers. Differential surface densities are 0.002 ± 0.001, 0.014 ± 0.002, 0.049 ± 0.004, 0.158 ± 0.007,
0.395 ± 0.011, 0.739 ± 0.014, 1.041 ± 0.017, 1.189 ± 0.018, and 1.111 ± 0.018 arcmin−2 (0.5mag)−1 for i′ = 23.25, 23.75,
24.25, 24.75, 25.25, 25.75, 26.25, 26.75, and 27.25, respectively, which are consistent with previous measurements (e.g.
Ouchi et al. 2004a).
bCumulative number density calculated from luminosity function of Giavalisco (2005).
cResults from the conventional power-law approximation, i.e. ω(θ) = Aω(θ−β − IC/Aω), over 2′′ − 1000′′. For integral
constraints, IC, we apply IC/Aω = [3, 14, 21, 28, 364, 154, 293] × 10−4 for i′ = [24.5, 25.0, 25.5, 26.0, 26.5, 27.0, 27.5].
dPower-law slope for the fit of ω = AωLθ−βL over 40′′ − 400′′ with no IC correction.
e χ2/dof = [0.7, 0.4, 2.5, 6.9, 8.3, 7.1, 3.0] for i′ = [24.5, 25.0, 25.5, 26.0, 26.5, 27.0, 27.5].
|
astro-ph/0211575 | 1 | 0211 | 2002-11-26T16:02:27 | Rayleigh - Taylor Gravity Waves and Quasiperiodic Oscillation Phenomenon in X-ray Binaries | [
"astro-ph"
] | Accretion onto compact objects in X-ray binaries [black hole, neutron star (NS), white dwarf] is characterized by non-uniform flow density profiles. Such an effect of heterogeneity in presence of gravitational forces and pressure gradients exhibits Raylegh-Taylor gravity waves (RTGW). They should be seen as quasioperiodic wave oscillations (QPO). In this paper I show that the main QPO frequency, which is very close to the Keplerian frequency, is split into separate frequencies (hybrid and low branch) under the influence of the gravitational forces in the rotational frame of reference. The observed low and high QPO frequencies are an intrinsic signature of the RTGW. I elaborate the conditions for the density profile when the RTGW oscillations are stable. A comparison of the inferred QPO frequencies with QPO observations is presented. I find that hectohertz frequencies detected from NS binaries can be identified as the RTGW low branch frequencies. I also predict that an observer can see the double NS spin frequency during the NS long (super) burst events when the pressure gradients and buoyant forces are suppressed. The Coriolis force is the only force which acts in the rotational frame of reference and its presence causes perfect coherent pulsations with a frequency twice of the NS spin. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Rayleigh - Taylor Gravity Waves and Quasiperiodic Oscillation
Phenomenon in X-ray Binaries
Lev Titarchuk 1,2
ABSTRACT
Accretion onto compact objects in X-ray binaries (black hole, neutron star
(NS), white dwarf) is characterized by non-uniform flow density profiles. Such
an effect of heterogeneity in presence of gravitational forces and pressure gra-
dients exhibits Raylegh-Taylor gravity waves (RTGW). They should be seen as
quasioperiodic wave oscillations (QPO) of the accretion flow in the transition
(boundary) layer between the Keplerian disk and the central object. In this pa-
per I show that the main QPO frequency, which is very close to the Keplerian
frequency, is split into separate frequencies (hybrid and low branch) under the
influence of the gravitational forces in the rotational frame of reference. The
RTGWs must be present and the related QPOs should be detected in any sys-
tem where the gravity, buoynancy and Coriolis force effects cannot be excluded
(even in the Earth and solar environments). The observed low and high QPO
frequencies are an intrinsic signature of the RTGW. I elaborate the conditions
for the density profile when the RTGW oscillations are stable. A comparison of
the inferred QPO frequencies with QPO observations is presented. I find that
hectohertz frequencies detected from NS binaries can be identified as the RTGW
low branch frequencies. I also predict that an observer can see the double NS spin
frequency during the NS long (super) burst events when the pressure gradients
and buoyant forces are suppressed. The Coriolis force is the only force which
acts in the rotational frame of reference and its presence causes perfect coherent
pulsations with a frequency twice of the NS spin. The QPO observations of neu-
tron binaries have established that the high QPO frequencies do not go beyond
of the certain upper limit. I explain this observational effect as a result of the
density profile inversions. Also I demonstrate that a particular problem of the
gravity waves in the rotational frame of reference in the approximation of very
small pressure gradients is reduced to the problem of the classical oscillator in
1George Mason University/CEOSR/NRL; [email protected]
2NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, code 661, Laboratory for High Energy Astrophysics, Greenbelt
MD 20771; [email protected]
-- 2 --
the rotational frame of reference which was previously introduced and applied
for the interpretation of kHZ QPO observation by Osherovich & Titarchuk.
Subject headings: Accretion, accretion disks -- (magnetohydrodynamics:) MHD --
stars:oscillations (including pulsations) -- stars: neutron -- X-ray:binaries
1.
Introduction
The theory of oscillations of rotating fluids of variable density [Rayleigh- Taylor (R-T)
effect] was developed in detail by Chandrasekhar (1961), hereafter C61. A large variety of
the magnitohydrodynamic (MHD) problems, including the stability of inviscid and viscous
fluids in the case of two uniform layers separated by a horizontal boundary with and without
rotation as well as the magnetic field effects were analyzed using perturbation technique.
The simplest case of a one-dimensional gravitational force was studied. A similar analysis
was also implemented for the case of an exponentially varying density. It follows from C61
that the quasiperiodic oscillations (QPO) with the twin "kilohertz" frequencies represent
the main frequencies of the stable gravity waves in the rotational frame of reference.
It
also as follows from C61 that the twin "kilohertz" frequencies should be on the order of the
Keplerian frequency.
In this Paper I present the results of the study of the R-T effect for a particular case of
fluid oscillations in an accretion flow under influence of a central gravitational force. This
particular R-T analysis is important in view of the high and low frequency detection by the
Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE) in a number of low mass X-ray binaries (Strohmayer
et al. 1996, van der Klis et al. 1996), black hole candidate sources (Morgan, Remillard &
Greiner 1997; Strohmayer 2001a,b; Remillard 2002) and by Extreme Ultraviolet Explorer,
Chandra X-ray observatory and optical observations in white dwarfs (Mauche 2002 and
Woudt & Warner 2002). The presence of two observed peaks with frequencies ν1 and ν2
in the upper part of the power spectrum became a natural starting point in modeling the
phenomena.
In NS binaries, for example Sco X-1, the lower frequency part of the power
spectrum, contains two horizontal branch oscillation (HBO) frequencies νHBO ∼ 45 Hz and
ν2HBO ∼ 90 Hz (probably the second harmonic of νHBO) which slowly increase with the
increase of ν1 and ν2 (van der Klis et al. 2000). Any plausible model faces the challenging
task of describing the dependences of the peak separation ∆ν = ν2 − ν1 on ν1 and ν2 .
Attempts have been made to relate ν1 and ν2 and the peak separation ∆ν = ν2 − ν1 with
In the sonic point beat frequency model by Miller, Lamb &
the neutron star (NS) spin.
Psaltis (1998) the kHz peak separation ∆ν is considered to be close to the NS spin frequency
and thus ∆ν is predicted to be constant. However observations of kHz QPOs in a number
-- 3 --
of binaries (Sco X-1, 4U 1728-34, 4U 1608-52, 4U 1702-429 and etc) show that the peak
separation decreases systematically when the high [kilohertz (kHz)] frequencies increase (for
a recent review see van der Klis 2000, hereafter VDK). For Sco X-1 VDK found that the
peak separation of kHz QPO frequencies changes from 320 Hz to 220 Hz when the lower kHz
peak ν1 changes from 500 Hz to 850 Hz.
The correlation between high frequency (lower kHz frequency) and low frequency (broad
noise component) QPOs previously found by Psaltis, Belloni & van der Klis (1999) for
black hole (BH) and neutron star (NS) systems has been recently extended over two orders
of magnitude by Mauche (2002) to white dwarf (WD) binaries. Accepting the reasonable
assumption that the same mechanism produces the QPO in WD, NS and BH binaries, one
can argue that the data exclude relativistic models and, beat frequency models as well as any
model requiring either the presence or absence of a stellar surface or a strong magnetic field.
The transition layer model (TLM) was introduced by Titarchuk, Lapidus & Muslimov
(1998), hereafter TLM98, to explain the dynamical adjustment of a Keplerian disk to the
innermost sub-Keplerian boundary conditions (it is at the star surface for NSs and WDs).
TLM98 argued that a shock should occur where the Keplerian disk adjusts to the sub-
Keplerian flow. Thus the transition layer bounded between the sub-Keplerian boundary and
the adjustment radius can undergo various type of oscillations under the influence of the
gas, radiation, magnetic pressure and gravitational force. Osherovich & Titarchuk (1999),
hereafter OT99, suggested that the phenomological model of a one-dimensional classical
oscillator in the rotational frame of reference could explain the observed correlations between
twin kHz frequencies ν1, ν2 and the HBO frequencies. They further suggested that the
oscillations of the fluid element that bounced from the disk shock region (at the adjustment
radius) would be seen as two independent oscillations parallel and perpendicular to the disk
plane respectively. This is due to the presence of a Coriolis force in the magnetospheric
rotational frame of reference.
In this paper I show that when the pressure gradients can
be neglected, the problem of the Rayleigh-Taylor wave oscillations (buoynancy effect) in
the rotational frame of reference is reduced to the OT99 formulation (see §3). This result
provides a solid basis for application of the OT99 model for interpretation of the QPO
phenomena observed in X-ray binaries.
The main goal of this Paper is to demonstrate that there is an inevitable effect of
the gravity wave oscillations in the heterogeneous fluid of the accretion flow near compact
objects.
In §2, I formulate the problem of the gravity wave propagation in the bounded
medium in the rotational frame of reference. In §3 I present analysis and solutions of this
problem using a perturbation method in the context of three dimensional periodic waves
with assigned wave numbers. Applications of the gravity modes and their relations with the
-- 4 --
QPO observations is presented in §4. Summary and conclusions are drawn in §5.
2. The Problem of Gravity Wave Propagation in a Bounded Medium
Lord Rayleigh (1883) has treated the non-rotating inviscid case of the present problem.
He developed a general theory for any density configuration ρ0(z) (the z axis being the
upward drawn vertical). Rayleigh's treatment of inviscid superposed fluids was extended
by Bjerkness et al. (1933) to include the influence of rotation. With an assumption of the
gravitational force directed vertically, Hide (1956) developed the theory for any density ρ0(z)
and viscosity µ0(z) profiles and any δ (where δ is an angle between the rotational axis and
the vertical). In this study we consider a case of an inviscid and incompressible fluid.
The equation of relative motion appropriate to the problem is
ρ
∂ui
∂t
+ ρui
∂
∂xj
ui − 2ρΩǫijkujsk = −
∂p
∂xj − gρei,
(1)
where the fluid is supposed to rotate uniformly about an axis whose direction is specified by
the unit vector s = Ω/Ω. The tensor notation follows the summation convention and the
unit vector e in the radial direction is introduced. In equation (1) ρ denotes the density, Ω
the angular velocity of rotation, ui the ith component of the (Eulerian) velocity vector, p is
the pressure and g is the acceleration due to gravity. This term g can represent the effective
gravity which includes the centrifugal and radiation pressure forces. For an incompressible
fluid the continuity equation is
∂ui
∂xi
= 0.
(2)
Because (similar to C61)diffusion effects are ignored in this analysis, an individual fluid
element retains the same density throughout its motion. Hence it is required that
Dρ
Dt
=
∂ρ
∂t
+ uj
∂ρ
∂xj
= 0.
(3)
Because the equilibrium situation in the comoving frame is a static one it is characterized
by ui = 0. We now assume the equilibrium situation to be slightly disturbed, so that ui 6= 0.
So we shall write
ρ = ρ0(r, z) + δρ(x, y, z),
p = p0(z) + δp(x, y, z, t).
(4)
and treat ui, δρ, and δp as quantities of the first order of smallness so that products of such
quantities can be ignored.
-- 5 --
We are interested in the study of the gravity wave oscillations in the disk transition layer
where the accretion flow is sub-Keplerian and the temperature of the flow is of order 5 keV
or more (see cartoon diagram of the system in Titarchuk, Osherovich & Kuznetsov 1999,
hereafter TOK, Fig. 1). These temperatures of order of 5 keV are a representative values
for plasma temperatures inferred from X-ray spectra during kHz QPO events (see more in
Titarchuk, Bradshaw & Wood 2001 and Titarchuk & Wood 2002).
At this stage we introduce the Cartesian coordinate system. We take the z axis to be in
the direction of the (upward) vertical and the x axis to be such that the (x, z) plane contains
the angular velocity vector Ω which then has components (Ωx, 0, Ωz). In the general case
the gravitational force has components g(x/R, y/R, z/R) where R = (x2 + y2 + z2)1/2.
If (u, v, w) are the components of the velocity u, then on substituting in equations (1),
(2) and (3) we find
ρ0
∂u
∂t − 2ρ0Ωzv = −
∂v
∂t − 2ρ0Ωxw + 2ρ0Ωzu = −
ρ0
δp
δx − gxδρ,
δp
δy − gyδρ,
δp
δz − gzδρ,
+ 2ρ0Ωxv = −
∂v
= 0,
+
∂y
∂u
∂x
+
ρ0
∂w
∂t
∂δρ
∂t
+ u
∂ρ0
∂x
+ v
∂ρ0
∂y
+ w
= 0.
∂w
∂z
∂ρ0
∂z
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
One can see that the variation of ρ is ignored in all terms except for the ones representing
the buoyancy force (see C61 for details).
3. Analysis of various types of the solutions of the problem
In order to illustrate the buoyancy (R-T) effect we consider the simplest solutions of
the problem including those which already exist in the literature.
Case A
In the case when we allow the vector Ω to rotate around the z axis at angle δ, we
introduce the cylindrical coordinate system, namely taking the z axis in the direction of the
(upward) vertical, the x axis as the radial axis and the y axis as the azimuthal axis in the
horizontal plane. Then the vector Ω has components (Ω sin δ, 0, Ω cos δ) and gravitational
force vector has components g(r/R, 0, z/R) where r = (x2 + y2)1/2.
-- 6 --
(I) With assumptions that ρ0 is only a function of R the scale height of ρ0 is order of
R we obtain that δρ = [(dρ/dx)dx + (dρ/dz)dz) ∼ ρ0/R[(r/R)χ + (z/R)ζ] where χ = dx,
ζ = dz are the radial and vertical components of displacement respectively and conse-
quently the radial and vertical components of the perturbation velocity are u = dχ/dt,
w = dζ/dt. Thus the vector G = δρ(gx, 0, gz) is transformed into G = ρ0(g/R)[(r/R)(rχ/R +
zζ/R), 0, (z/R)(rχ/R + zζ/R].
Furthermore if we neglect the effects of pressure gradients, the set of equations (5-7)
can be reduced to the system where the right hand side consists of only the vector G. Then,
for radial, azimuthal and vertical displacements χ, Υ, ζ this system takes the form:
χ − 2Ω cos δ Υ = −(g/R)(r/R)(rχ/R + zζ/R),
Υ + 2Ω cos δ χ − 2Ω sin δ ζ = 0,
ζ + 2Ω sin δ Υ = −(g/R)(z/R)(rχ/R + zζ/R).
(10)
(11)
(12)
OT99 have already analyzed the solution of Eqs. (10-12) (see Eqs. 2-4, in OT99) in the
case of z/R ≪ 0 and δ ≪ 1. They found that in the rotational frame of reference, the
radial oscillation with the main frequency ωK = (g/R)1/2 is split to the oscillations taking
K + 4Ω2)1/2
place near the horizontal (disk) plane (χΥ) with the hybrid frequency ωh = (ω2
and to oscillations taking place near the vertical plane (Υζ) with the low branch frequency
ωL = 2Ω(ωK/ωh) sin δ.
For z ∼ r the dispersion equation for the frequency ω
ω2[ω4 − 2(ω2
∗ + 2ω2)ω2 + ω4
∗ + 4Ω2ω2
∗ + 2Ω2ω2
∗ sin 2δ] = 0
(13)
besides the nonoscillatory mode (ω = 0), describes two oscillatory eigenmodes. For δ ≪ 1
they are ω1 = ω∗ = (g/2R)1/2 = ωK/√2 and ω2 = (ω2
∗ + 4Ω2)1/2 = (ω2
K/2 + 4Ω2)1/2.
The relation of the model eigenfrequencies νL = ωL/2π, νK = ωK/2π and νh = ωh/2π
with the QPO observed frequencies: horizontal branch oscillation freqiencies νHBO, kHz
frequencies were studied by OT99; TOK, Kuznetsov & Titarchuk (2002); and Titarchuk
(2002), hereafter T02. It is worth noting that the relation between νK, Ω, νh and νL predicts
the existence of the invariant quantity δ. (e.g. Titarchuk & Osherovich 2001). T02 calculated
δ and its uncertainty of δ finding that the inferred δ−values are consistent with being constant
at least for four Z sources, Sco X-1, GX 340+0, GX 5-1, GX 17+2 (see more on this issue
in section §4).
(II). With assumptions that g∆ρ ≪ 1 and ∇p ≪ 1 the set of equations for χ, Υ, ζ is similar
to Eqs (10-12) where the right hand side vector is the zero vector, 0 = (0, 0, 0). In this case
the dispersion equation for ω ( for small δ << 1)
ω2(ω2 − 4Ω2) = 0
(14)
-- 7 --
has the only one nontrivial root ω = 2Ω which is related to the eigenmode oscillations taking
place parallel to the disk (χΥ)-plane. We discuss the application of this solution to the
observation in section §4.
Case B
If we do not neglect the pressure gradient and assume the vertical gravitational force
and the vector Ω directed along the vertical (δ = 00), then the entire problem (Eqs. 5-9) is
reduced to set of equations which have already been analyzed by Chandrasekhar in C61. He
studied two cases: (1) In the case of two uniform fluids separated by a horizontal boundary
he showed that for two adjacent, hydrostatic, inviscid fluids, the low fluid having density ρ1
and the upper layer having density ρ2 the eigenfrequency νR−T was
νR−T = [2(Ω/2π)2 + (4(Ω/2π)4 + ν 4
0 )1/2]1/2
(15)
where ν0 is the frequency in the absence of rotation. The frequency ν0 is of order of νK =
(g/R)1/2 if the k-wave number (ν0 depends on k and density difference ∆ρ = ρ2 − ρ1) of
order R−1 and ∆ρ/(ρ1 + ρ2) ∼ (0.5 − 1).
For a stratified medium of density ρ = C0 exp(βz), where 1/β is the scale height, the
R-T instability occurs for positive β, whereas stable gravity waves occur for negative β. The
0 + 4(Ω/2π)2]1/2 if one assumes that the wave number k is
R-T frequency νR−T = νh = [ν 2
of order of d−1 ∼ H −1 (where d is a layer size). It is worthwhile to emphasize that even
in the simplest case of the vertical gravitational force (C61) the hybrid frequency νh is an
eigenfrequency (which is also true for the case with no pressure gradient effects, see above).
Formula (10) for νR−T can also be reduced to νh if one assumes that ν0 ∼ 2(Ω/2π).
Case C
Now we consider the case when the vector Ω rotates uniformly around the vertical at
angle δ, then the gravitational vector G = δρ(gr/R, 0, zg/R), also taking into account the
pressure effects. The general case of G = δρ(gx, gy, gz) can be analyzed in a similar way and
it will be presented elsewhere. Following the usual practice in problems of this kind, we seek
solutions of equations (5-9) which are of form (see e.g. C61)
u, v, w, δρ. δp = constant × exp(ikxx + ikyy + ikzz + nt),
(16)
where kx, ky and kz are the horizontal and vertical wave numbers of the harmonic perturba-
tions respectively. We also assume that ρ0 = f (x)ϕ(z) is a function of x (or r) and z which
the scale heights are 1/γ and 1/β for radial and vertical density profiles respectively, r ≈ R.
Upon substituting for u, v, w, δρ, δp in the form (16) equations (5) to (8) become
nu − 2Ωzv = −ikx(δp/ρ0) + guγ/n + gwβ/n,
(17)
-- 8 --
nv − 2Ωxw + 2Ωzu = −iky(δp/ρ0),
nw − 2Ωxv = −ikz(δp/ρ0) + (zg/R)uγ/n + (zg/R)wβ/n,
kxu + kyv + kzw = 0.
(18)
(19)
(20)
We also use the relation nδρ + (γu + βw)ρ0 = 0 which follows from Eqs. (9) and (16) in
order to express δρ through ρ0, u and w. The set of equation (17-20) assumes a nontrivial
solution only if the determinant of the system D = 0. This equation provides the dispersion
relation for the determination of n:
P (n) = a4n4 + a2n2 + a1n + a0 = 0,
(21)
where a0 = k2
a2 = 4(Ωxkx + Ωzkz)2 − gβ[−(γ/β)k2
k2 = k2
y + k2
z .
yg2γ 2(kz/kx − z/R)(β/γ − kz/kx), a1 = −βkyg(2Ωxkx + 2Ωzkz)(1 − γz/βR),
y(γ/β + z/R)], a4 =
x(β/γ − kz/kx)(kz/kx − z/R) + k2
x + k2
3.1. Stable gravity modes
The specific wave values kx, ky, kz are determined by the conditions imposed on the
oscillatory domain boundary. Thus for a given set of boundary conditions the analysis of the
R-T instability is reduced to the analysis of the roots of of fourth order algebraic equation
(21), which depends on the main parameters of the atmosphere, β, γ and ratio of the wave
numbers kz/kx. We assume that z/R < 1 and kx, ky ∝ 1/R, kz ∝ 1/z is the case of interest.
Figure 1 illustrates the specific behavior of the polynomial P(n) which should help one
to understand the presence (or absence) of its roots for given coefficient a0, a1, a2 (a4 > 0,
a3 = 0). For example, if a0 < 0, a1 < 0 and a2 > 0 (see case i below) then P (n) has two
complex conjugate roots n1,2 = ζ ± iη and two real roots n3, n4 (in fact, d2P/dn2 > 0).
Because a1 < 0, the absolute value of the positive root n4 is larger than that of the negative
one n3. But a3 is a sum of the polynomial (real and complex conjugate) roots, and because of
a3 = n1+n2+n3+n4 = 0 one can come to conclusion that 2ζ = −(n3+n4) < 0. Therefore (in
this case) the stable oscillatory mode exists and n1,2 are related to these damped oscillations.
Below we present all cases with the oscillatory stable solutions:
Case i: β, β/γ > 0, β/γ − kz/kx < 0 and a2 > 0 (see Fig. 1, curve i). For such
conditions a0 < 0 and a1 < 0. Then equation (21) has two real roots which relate to the
unstable (growing) and stable (decaying) modes with one pair of complex conjugate roots
corresponding to the stable oscillatory mode:
n1,2 ≈ a1/2d ± iωh,
(22)
-- 9 --
2 − 4a4a0)1/2. These roots of equation (21) are
where ωh = [(a2 + d)/2a4]1/2 and d = (a2
found using the sequential approximation method: first we solve equation (21) with a1 = 0,
n and then in the next stage we look for roots of equation (21) as n = n + α.
Case ia: β, β/γ > 0, β/γ − kz/kx < 0 and a2 < 0. For such conditions a0 < 0 and
a1 < 0. Equation (21) has just one pair of the complex conjugate roots and two real roots
which relate to the unstable (growing) and stable (decaying) modes (see Fig. 1, curve ia).
The oscillatory mode n1,2 is stable for which we have
n1,2 ≈ a1/2d ± iωL,
(23)
where ωL = [(−a2 + d)/2a4]1/2.
Case ib: β > 0, β/γ < 0, β/γ − kz/kx < 0. For such conditions a0 < 0 and a1 < 0
and a2 > 0. This case is similar to case i (see Fig 1, curve i) when equation (21) has two
real roots which relate to the unstable (growing) and stable (decaying) modes and complex
conjugate roots which correspond to the stable oscillatory mode:
n1,2 ≈ a1/2d ± iωh.
(24)
Case ii: β > 0, β/γ − kz/kx > 0. For such conditions a0 > 0 and a1 < 0 and a2 > 0.
Equation (21) has a pair of complex conjugate roots (see Fig. 1, curve ii) and one of them
n1,2 is related to the stable oscillatory mode:
n1,2 ≈ a1/2d ± iωh.
(25)
Case iii: β < 0, β/γ − kz/kx > 0, and a2, d > 0. For such conditions a0 > 0 and a1 > 0.
Equation (21) has a pair of complex conjugate roots (see Fig. 1, curve iii) and one of them
n3,4 is related to the stable oscillatory mode:
n1,2 ≈ −a1/2d ± iωL,
(26)
where ωL = [(a2 − d)/2a4]1/2.
Finally, we single out the case when the effective gravitational force goes to zero. This
can happen during a burst event, when the gravitational forces are compensated by the
radiation pressure forces (e.g. Titarchuk 1994). For such conditions, a0, a1 → 0 and a2/a4 =
4[(kx/k)Ωx/k + (kz/k)Ωz]2. Equation (21) has zero roots n = 0 and conjugate complex roots
n1.2 = ±i(a2/a4)1/2 = ±2i[(kx/k)Ωx + (kz/k)Ωz]
(27)
which are related to a pure harmonic mode. In fact, this result also follows from treatments
detailed in C61 and OT99. The hybrid frequency then becomes simply νh = 2(Ω/2π) for
-- 10 --
g = 0. This case of the perfect coherent oscillations would also occur if the density profile
is quasi-uniform i.e. when β, γ → 0 but β/γ = O(1). These two conditions (on either the
effective gravity force or the density profile) can be realized during the burst event.
In this section the main goal is to reveal all cases when stable gravity modes exist
and when the stability breaks down. This analysis is particularly important in a view of the
transient nature of QPO features (see e.g. Zhang et al. 1998). With an increase of bolometric
luminosity (presumably in mass accretion rate) the kHz QPO frequency increases and then
entirely disappears! At low rates it appears once again! The stability analysis presented
here leads to conditions for the existence and the destruction of gravity modes in terms of
density profiles scale heights β −1, γ −1 and boundary conditions (kx, ky kz). In fact, the
strong dependence of the gravity wave stability on the density profile was a central point of
Chandrasekhar's analysis (C61). For the accretion disk cases, we can give an example where
stable gravity modes are followed by instabilities (the gravity mode destruction). In case
(ib) we have a stable mode with ωh as a QPO frequency. When the density profile changes,
over z−coordinate from γ < 0 to γ > 0 then the stable g-mode with ωh can still be sustaned
[see case (ia)], But if the density profile over z coordinate is stabilized (β < 0) and that over
r coordinate is inverted (i.e. from γ < 0 to γ > 0) then the QPO oscillations are no longer
stable.
4. Gravity modes and their relation to QPO phenomenon
As we have seen in the previous section, there are two stable oscillatory gravity modes:
one is associated with the hybrid frequency ωh (see cases i, ib, ii) and another with the low
branch frequency ωL (cases ia and iii). We also estimate the decay rate for oscillations as
λ = a1/d and the QPO quality value Q = ω/2λ. The presence and absence of these modes
depend on the atmospheric structure (scale height inverses β and γ) and on the imposed
boundary conditions (wave numbers kx, ky and kz). Furthermore, it is possible to restore the
related boundary conditions if one compares the observed QPO features with the calculated
mode frequencies and Q-values. The analysis made in section 3 is also necessary in order to
control an accuracy of numerical calculations of the set of hydrodynamical equations (5-9).
To illustrate the results obtained in §3 we should specify the orders of the introduced
quantities kx, ky, kz, β, γ. Namely we assume that kx ∼ 1/R, ky ∼ 1/R, kz ∼ 1/z, γ ∼ q/R
(where q < 1) and z/R < 1. If we also assume that β/γ−kz/kx ∼ R/z then β ∼ 2q/z. With
these assumptions expressions for the polynomial coefficients aj (see Eq. 21) are significantly
K(zΩx/R + Ωz), a2/a4 ∼ 4(zΩx/R + Ωz)2 + qω2
simplified: a0/a4 ∼ q2ω4
K.
K, a1/a4 ∼ −2qω2
-- 11 --
Because q < 1 and ωK < ωh we can calculate ωL as
and
ωL ≈ q(ωK/ωh)ωK
QL = ωL/2(a1/2d) ≈ ωh/2Ω ≥ 1/2.
(28)
(29)
TOK introduced the classification scheme for the QPO features and related the observed
high and low kHz frequencies to the hybrid and Keplerian frequencies, νh = ωh/2π and
νK = ωK/2π respectively. They also attributed the hectohertz frequencies detected in the
atoll source 4U 1728-34 (Ford & van der Klis 1999) to the low branch. The angle δ was found
to be almost twice that found in Sco X-1 (see also T02 for details of δ− determination). The
low frequencies in atoll sources (as a rule) are three times higher than those in the Z-sources.
The hectohertz frequencies have been identified in several other neutron star LMXBs (4U
0614+09; van Straaten et al. 2000, 2002; SAX J1808.4-3658, 4U 1705-44; Wijnands & van der
Klis 1998). They weakly depend on the kHz frequencies, their ratio to low kHz frequency
being about (4-5) (van Straaten et al. 2002, hereafter S02). The hectohertz frequency
Lorentzian profile are very broad with Q-values around 1 or even less. We suggest that these
observed frequencies can be identified as the low branch frequencies (see formulas 28-29).
Taking into account resonance effects (T02), we correct the error bars of the hectohertz
frequencies presented in S02. In Figure 2 the best fit to the data (S02) is presented using
formula (28) which includes one fit parameter q. The best-fit value of q = 0.3 for which
χ2
∼ 1/2 are also in agreement with the observed values of Q (S02,
red = 0.76. The estimated Q >
Table 2).
The harmonic modes ωhm = 2(kxΩx + kzΩz) can be related to a coherent oscillation
frequency of 582 Hz which is observed in 4U 1636-53 during the superburst (Strohmayer &
Markwardt 2002). If kz/kx ≫ 1 (which is our case) ωhm is a double frequency of the NS spin
frequency. Furthermore, we have already found the same eigenmode with the frequency 2Ω in
case (AII) when effects of the buoynant forces and pressure gradients are neglected (see §3).
In fact, Miller (1999) has reported the detection of the coherent pulsations of frequency ∼ 291
Hz during the burst development in 4U 1636-53. Thus the NS spin frequency Ω/2π = 291
Hz and the double NS spin frequency 2Ω/2π = 582 Hz have probably been detected in 4U
1636-53.
It is also worth noting that the RXTE observations of neutron binaries establish that
the kHz QPO frequencies do not seem to exceed beyond a certain upper limit (Zhang et al.
1998). This observational effect may be a result of the density profile. Our stability analysis
presented in §3 clearly indicates such a possibility (see also C61).
-- 12 --
5. Conclusions
I have presented a detailed study of the Rayleigh-Taylor (R-T) instability in the accre-
tion flow. To summarize I have :(1) put forth arguments to explain the QPO phenomena, as
a result of the R-T effect in the rotational frame of reference. (2) formulated and solved the
mathematical problem of the gravity wave propagation (R-T effect) in the accretion flow.
(3) concluded that the stable gravity modes in the rotational frame of reference are related
to the hybrid and low branch frequencies. (4) demonstrated that the particular problem of
the gravity waves in the rotational frame of reference, in the approximation of very small
pressure gradients, is reduced to the problem of the classical oscillator in the rotational frame
of reference which was previously introduced and applied for the interpretation of kHz QPO
observation by OT99.
I demonstrate that these frequencies are intrinsic features of the R-T effect. They ap-
pear in various configurations of the accretion flow depending on assumptions regarding the
density profiles, the boundary conditions and the effects of the pressure forces. It is not by
chance the high and low frequencies phenomenon has common observational appearances for
a wide range of objects classes from black hole sources down to white dwarfs (Mauche 2002).
(5) Investigated the conditions for the density profile and the wave numbers (boundary con-
ditions) when the gravity modes are stable. (6) Identified the observed QPO frequencies
seen in the power density spectra of NS LMXBs using the inferred gravity mode frequencies.
In particular, I found that the inferred low branch frequencies and their Q-values are consis-
tent with the QPO hectohertz frequencies observed in the atoll sources 4U 1728-34 and 4U
0614+19. (7) During the NS long (super) burst event, I find that the observer should see
oscillations at double NS spin frequency. The Coriolis force is the only force which acts in
the rotational frame of references and its presence causes perfect coherent pulsations with a
frequency twice of the NS spin frequency.
Finally one can conclude that the R-T gravity wave oscullations must be present and the
related QPOs should be detected in any system where the gravity, buoynancy and Coriolis
force effects cannot be excluded (even in the Earth and solar environments).
L.T. acknowledges fruitful discussions with Chris Shrader and Kent Wood. I also ap-
preciate the fruitful discussions with the referee and his/her constructive evaluation of the
manuscript.
-- 13 --
REFERENCES
Bjerkness, V. Bjerkness, J., Solberberg, H. & Bergron, T. 1933, Physikalish Hydrodynamik,
Berlin: Springer
Chandrasekhar, S. 1961, Hydrodynamics and Hydromagnetic Stability, Oxford: Oxford at
the Caredon Press (C61)
Ford, E., & van der Klis, M. 1998, ApJ, 506, L39
Hide, R. 1956, Quart. J. Math. Appl. Math. 9, 35
Kuznetsov, S.I. & Titarchuk, L.G. 2002, ApJ, 571, L137
Mauche, C. W. 2002, ApJ in press (astro-ph/0207508)
Miller, M. C. 1999, ApJ, 554, L77
Miller, M.C., Lamb, F.K., Psaltis, D. 1998, ApJ 508, 791
Morgan, E.H., Remillard, R.A., & Greiner, J. 1997, ApJ. 482, 993
Osherovich, V., & Titarchuk, L. 1999, ApJ, 522, L113 (OT99)
Psaltis, D., Belloni, & van der Klis, M. 1999, ApJ, 520, 262
Rayleigh, L. 1883, Proc. London Math. Soc. 14, 170
Remillard, R. 2002, astro-ph/0202305
Strohmayer, T.E. & Markwardt, C. B. 2002, ApJ, 577, 337
Strohmayer, T.E. 2001a, ApJ, 552, L49
Strohmayer, T.E. 2001b, ApJ, 554, L169
Strohmayer, T.E., et al. 1996, ApJ, 469, L9
Titarchuk, L.G. 2002, ApJ, 578, L71 (T02)
Titarchuk, L., & Wood, K. 2002, ApJ, 577, L23
Titarchuk, L., Bradshaw, C.F. & Wood, K. 2001, ApJ, 560, L55
Titarchuk, L.G., Lapidus, I.I. & Muslimov, A. 1998, ApJ, 499, 315 (TLM98)
Titarchuk, L., & Osherovich, V. 2001, ApJ, 555, L55
-- 14 --
Titarchuk, L., Osherovich, V., & Kuznetsov, S.I. 1999, ApJ, 525, L129 (TOK)
van der Klis, M. 2000, ARA&A, 38, 717 (VDK)
van der Klis, et al. 1996, ApJ, 469, L1
van Straaten, S., Ford, E., van der Klis, M. & Belloni, T. 2002, ApJ, 568, 912
van Straaten, S., Ford, E., van der Klis, M., Mendez, M. & Kaaret, Ph. 2000, ApJ, 540, 1049
Wijnands, R., & van der Klis, M. 1998, ApJ, 507, L63
Woudt, P.A. & Warner, B. 2002, MNRAS, 2002, 333, 411
Zhang, W., Smale, A.P., Strohmayer, T.E., & Swank, J.H. 1998, ApJ, 500, L171
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0.
-- 15 --
Fig. 1. -- Behavior of the dispersion polynomial P(n) for stable gravity modes (see text).
-- 16 --
Fig. 2. -- Correlation between the lower kHz frequency and hectohertz frequency for 4U
1728-34 (star), 4U 0614+09 (triangles) (van Straaten et al. 2002) and the best-fit curve of
low branch frequency vs Keplerian frequency (solid line). χ2
red = 0.76 for q = 0.3.
|
astro-ph/0408418 | 2 | 0408 | 2005-03-14T18:27:26 | Non-parametric inversion of strong lensing systems | [
"astro-ph"
] | We revisit the issue of non-parametric gravitational lens reconstruction and present a new method to obtain the cluster mass distribution using strong lensing data without using any prior information on the underlying mass. The method relies on the decomposition of the lens plane into individual cells. We show how the problem in this approximation can be expressed as a system of linear equations for which a solution can be found. Moreover, we propose to include information about the null space. That is, make use of the pixels where we know there are no arcs above the sky noise. The only prior information is an estimation of the physical size of the sources. No priors on the luminosity of the cluster or shape of the halos are needed thus making the results very robust. In order to test the accuracy and bias of the method we make use of simulated strong lensing data. We find that the method reproduces accurately both the lens mass and source positions and provide error estimates. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 16 (0000)
Printed 16 November 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
Non-parametric inversion of strong lensing systems.
J.M. Diego1, P. Protopapas2, H.B. Sandvik3, M. Tegmark4.
University of Pennsylvania. 209S, 33rd St, Department of Physics & Astronomy, Philadelphia PA 19104, USA.
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
Draft version 16 November 2018
ABSTRACT
We revisit the issue of non-parametric gravitational lens reconstruction and present a
new method to obtain the cluster mass distribution using strong lensing data without
using any prior information on the underlying mass. The method relies on the de-
composition of the lens plane into individual cells. We show how the problem in this
approximation can be expressed as a system of linear equations for which a solution
can be found. Moreover, we propose to include information about the null space. That
is, make use of the pixels where we know there are no arcs above the sky noise. The
only prior information is an estimation of the physical size of the sources. No priors
on the luminosity of the cluster or shape of the halos are needed thus making the
results very robust. In order to test the accuracy and bias of the method we make use
of simulated strong lensing data. We find that the method reproduces accurately both
the lens mass and source positions and provide error estimates.
Key words: galaxies:clusters:general; methods:data analysis; dark matter
1
INTRODUCTION
Analysis of strong lensing images in galaxy clusters is one
of the more subjective and intuitive fields of modern astron-
omy (see Blandford & Narayan 1992, Schneider, Ehlers &
Falco 1993, Wambsganss 1998, Narayan & Bartelmann 1999,
Kneib 2002, for comprehensive reviews on gravitational lens-
ing). The common use of parametric models means making
educated choices about the cluster mass distribution, for
instance that the dark matter haloes follow the luminous
matter in the cluster or that galaxy profiles posses certain
symmetries. Once these choices are made, one can only hope
they are the right ones. The recent improvement in strong
lensing data however, is impressive and should increasingly
allow us to extract information using fewer assumptions. For
instance, it should allow us to relax assumptions about the
mass distributions of the cluster and instead enable us to
test this. The approach of testing rather than assuming the
underlying physics has now been used in other branches of
astrophysics and cosmology (e.g. Tegmark 2002) but has so
far been largely absent in strong lensing analyses.
There are two relatively different fields within the area
of strong lensing, namely lensing by galaxies and galaxy
clusters. These are different both in appearance as well as
in abundance. Galaxy-cluster systems are few and far be-
tween, only the most abnormally dense clusters have surface
densities greater than the critical density for lensing. How-
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
ever, they are much more spectacular than their galaxy lens
counterparts. The most massive clusters are able to create
multiple images of extended objects such as distant galax-
ies with image separations of up to ∼ 1 arcminute. Arguably
the most impressive system, A1689 (Broadhurst et al. 2005),
boasts more than 100 multiple images of some 30+ sources.
Galaxy lens systems are of course on a much smaller scale
with image separations of a few arcseconds. They are far
more abundant, but less impressive. The lensed objects that
we are able to observe are typically high redshift quasars
due to their high luminosity and point like structure, al-
though galaxy-galaxy lensing has been observed ( Brainerd,
Blandford & Smail 1996, Hudson et al. 1998, Guzik & Seljak
2002).
The classification of strong lensing systems into these
two groups is not merely a matter of scale. The baryons in
galaxies have had time to cool and form the visible galaxy,
thereby giving a cuspy profile, suitable for lensing. The cool-
ing time for galaxy clusters exceed the Hubble time and the
density profile is therefore far less cuspy, making them less
ideal lenses. Although cluster lens systems are scarce, the im-
pressive number of lensed images in each system, mean they
still contain a lot of information, particularly regarding clus-
ter mass profiles. The information is harder to extract due
to the relatively complicated gravitational potentials, but if
this challenge can be overcome they could be highly useful
probes, certainly of cluster physics and potentially also for
2 Diego et al.
cosmology (Yamamoto & Futamase 2001, Yamamoto et al.
2001, Chiba & Takahashi 2002, Golse et al. 2002, Sereno
2002, Meneghetti et al 2005) The intention of this paper is
to improve our methods for extracting this information.
Although alternative approaches have been suggested to
recover the density field in both the weak and strong lensing
regime, (see for instance Kaiser & Squires 1993, Broadhurst
et al. 1995, Kaiser 1995, Schneider 1995, Schneider & Seitz
1995, Seitz & Schneider 1995, Bartelmann et al. 1996, Taylor
et al. 1998, Tyson et al. 1998, Bridle et al. 1998, Marshall et
al. 1998), the standard approach to modeling strong cluster
lenses is using parametric methods. This is motivated by the
fact that the data usually do not contain more than a few
arcs. This is not enough to constrain the mass distribution
without the help of a parametrization. Parametric methods
rely heavily on assumptions or priors on the mass distribu-
tion (Kochanek & Blandford 1991, Kneib et al. 1993, 1995,
1996, 2003, Colley et al. 1996, Tyson et al. 1998, Broad-
hurst et al. 2000, 2005, Sand et al. 2002). A common prior
is the assumption that there is a smooth dark matter com-
ponent which is correlated spatially with the centroid of the
luminous matter in the cluster. The mass is then ususally
modeled by a large smooth dark matter halo placed on top
of the central galaxy or the centroid of the luminous matter,
as well as smaller dark matter haloes located in the positions
of the other luminous galaxies. The parameters of each halo
are then adjusted to best reproduce the observations.
There is plenty of subjectivity involved in this process,
particularly in the addition of the dominant dark matter
component to the cluster. The assumption that the dark
matter follows the luminosity is necessary but remains the
Achilles heel of parametric lens modelling. For large clus-
ters the number of parameters in the parametric lens model
quickly becomes large but there is still no guarantee that the
parametric model used, is in fact capable of reproducing well
the mass distribution. It is not hard to envisage complica-
tions like dark matter substructure, asymmetric galaxy pro-
files, interactions between individual galaxies and the cluster
or even dark matter haloes without significant luminosity all
of which would not be well represented by the typical para-
metric methods. In these cases, where the number of pa-
rameters is large, we may want to consider alternative non-
parametric methods where all the previous problems do not
have any effect on any of the assumptions. Also is in these
situations where the number of parameters in both para-
metric and non-parametric methods is comparable. When
the number of parameters is comparable in both cases, it is
interesing to explore non-parametric methods since they do
not rely on the same assumptions.
This paper does not pretend to be an attack to paramet-
ric methods but a defense of non-parametric alternatives.
Parametric methods are usually the best way to obtain in-
formation about the gravitational potential (few multiple
images, simple lens) and are not affeted by resolution prob-
lems, specially in the center of the lens which can play a
key role in reproducing the radial arcs. They however suffer
of some potential problems, some of which have been out-
lined above. These problems combined with the impressive
quality of recent and upcoming data lead us in this paper
to explore the potential to constrain the mass distribution
without imposing priors on it. In other words we want to
know what strong gravitational lensing images can tell us
about cluster mass profiles whilst pretending we know noth-
ing about the luminosity. Upcoming images of strong lens-
ing in galaxy clusters will contain of the order of a hundred
arcs and should make this a manageable task (Diego et al.
2004). A non-parametric approach will provide an impor-
tant consistency check, since concurring results would lend
strength to the parametric approach, whereas any resulting
differences would need to be addressed.
Accepting this challenge we present in this paper a new
method which makes use of all the available information in
super-high quality strong lensing systems. The method has
also been thoroughly tested with simulated lensing data with
very good results. We thus address the crucial issue of how
well we can reproduce both the cluster mass profile and the
positions and shapes of the background galaxies.
We want to stress that ours is by no means the first work
proposing use of non-parametric methods in strong lensing.
Among the non-parametric methods already available, are
the pixellization methods of Saha et al. (1997, 2000), Ab-
delsalam et al. (1998a, 1998b), Williams et al. (2001), who
first established many of the ideas revisited in this work, as
and also the multi-pole approach of Kochanek & Blandford
(1991), Trotter et al. (2000).
Naturally, our work shares many similarities with this
former work, but there are also important and interesting
differences. Firstly, in Saha et al. (1997) (and subsequent
papers), the authors divide the lens plane into a grid similar
to the method presented here, but with the important dif-
ference that their grid is fixed while our grid is dynamical.
Our grid adapts to the new estimated mass at each step.
This has important implications for the solution since high
density regions will be sampled more heavily. These dense
regions play a key role, particularly in the positions of the
radial arcs. Not sampling these regions properly will neces-
sarily lead to a biased mass distribution.
Another important difference with Saha et al (1997) is
that they make use of a prior on the mass distribution, pe-
nalizing deviations from the distribution of luminous matter.
They claim this prior does not play an important role but
we find this questionable. It is hard to quantify the effect
since the method apparently was not tested on simulated
lensing data. In contrast, as mentioned above, our method
is thoroughly tested with simulations to quantify how well
the mass distribution is recovered. We do not use any prior
other than a physical prior on the sizes of the sources. This
prior is proved to be weak provided it is chosen with a min-
imum of wisdom.
A third important difference between the work pre-
sented in this paper and others is that we show how to speed
up the algorithm significantly by adopting techniques com-
monly used in optimization problems.
Moreover as an added novelty, our algorithm also in-
cludes for the first time information about the null space.
Rather than using only the information in the lensed arcs,
we use information which has hitherto been overlooked; the
areas in the sky where no arcs are observed.
The paper is laid out as follows. In the next section
we present the lens inversion problem, and provide a linear
approximation. We then in section 3 present the simulated
lensing data used to test the method, before we go on to
present the adaptive gridification of the lens-plane, section
4. In section 5 we describe the various inversion algorithms
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
and finally, in section 6 we introduce the use of the comple-
mentary (null) space.
2 THE PROBLEM FORMULATED IN ITS
BASIC LINEAR FORM
The fundamental problem in lens modelling is the following:
Given the positions of lensed images, ~θ, what are the po-
sitions of the corresponding background galaxies ~β and the
mass distribution of the lens, M (~θ). Mathematically this en-
tails inverting the lens equation
~β = ~θ − ~α(~θ, M (~θ))
(1)
where ~α(~θ) is the deflection angle created by the lens which
depends on the observed positions, ~θ. From now on we will
omit the vector notation unless otherwise noted. The data
points of our problem, ~θ, are given by the x and y positions
of each of the pixels forming the observed arcs.
The deflection angle, α, at the position θ, is found by
integrating the contributions from the whole mass distribu-
tion.
α(θ) =
4G
c2
Dls
DsDl Z M (θ′)
θ − θ′
θ − θ′2 dθ′
(2)
where Dls, Dl, and Ds are the angular distances from the
lens to the source galaxy, the distance from the observer to
the lens and the distance from the observer to the source
galaxy respectively. In equation 2 we have made the usual
thin lens approximation so the mass M (θ′) is the projected
mass along the line of sight θ′. Due to the (non-linear) de-
pendency of the deflection angle, α on the position in the
sky, θ, this problem is usually regarded as a typical exam-
ple of a non-linear problem. We will see that this is only
partially true.
The next approximation we make is to split the lens
plane in Nc small regions (hereafter cells) over which the
projected mass is more or less constant. We can then rewrite
equation (2) as;
α(θ) =
4G
c2
Dls
DsDl XNc
mi
θ − θi
θ − θi2
(3)
The first point we want to make here is that the deflection
angle α may be thought of as the net contribution of many
small masses mi in the positions θi, each one pulling the
deflection in the direction of (θ − θi) and with a magnitude
which is proportional to mi/(θ − θi). If we divide the lens
plane in a grid with Nc cells, the masses mi can be consid-
ered as the mass contained in the cell i (i = 1, ..., Nc). If the
cells are sufficiently small then the above pixellization of the
mass plane will give a good approximation to the real mass
distribution.
Our second point is that the problem is non-linear in one
direction but linear in the other. That is, given a position
in the sky θ (and given a lens) there is only one β which
satisfy equation 1 but given a position of the background
galaxy β, there may be more than one position in the sky
(θ) satisfying equation 1 or equivalently, the source galaxy
may appear lensed in more than one position in the sky. The
linear nature of the problem is evident when one realizes
that the only non-linear variable, namely the θ positions,
are fixed by the observation and that the problem depends
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Inverting the lens
3
Figure 1. Original simulated mass profile. The total projected
mass is 1.119 × 1015 h−1 M⊙ in the field of view (0.1 degrees
across) and the cluster is at z = 0.18. The units of the grey scale
map are 1015h−1M⊙/pixel where each pixel is 0.494 arcsec2. Also
shown are the radial (small) and tangential (large) critical curves
for a source at redshift z = 3.
linearly on the unknowns (β positions and masses, mi, in
the cells).
Let us now assume that we have a data set consist-
ing of a system of radial and tangential strong lensing arcs
which are spread over Nθ pixels in the image. We will also
assume that we know which arcs originate from the same
sources. Since both the data and the mass distribution has
been discretized we can rewrite equation (1) as a simple
matrix equation:
β = θ − ΥM
(4)
where θ and β are now 2Nθ element vectors containing x and
y values of the observed positions and the (unknown) source
positions respectively. M is the mass vector containing all
Nc mass cells, and Υ is the (2Nθ × Nc) matrix casting the
mass vector into a vector of displacement angles. A more
technical account of the make-up of the Υ matrix can be
found in the appendix. Equation 4 clearly demonstrates
the linear nature of the problem when formulated in this
manner. The problem has now been reduced to a set of 2Nθ
linear equations with 2Nθ + Nc unknowns (lens masses and
source galaxy positions). Notice that when the problem is
formulated in this form, there are more unknowns than equa-
tions which means it is an underdetermined system with an
infinite number of solutions. In order to identify a suitable
solution for such a system, we need to add extra information
or impose constraints.
One way of doing this is by reducing the number of un-
knowns, for instance by removing the source positions from
the unknown category. This can be achieved by minimizing
the dispersion in the source plane, i.e. demanding that the
pixels in the source plane be as concentrated as possible for
each source. In this case we are left with only Nc unknowns.
4 Diego et al.
allows for a complete, linear solution to a problem usually
considered non-linear.
3 SIMULATIONS
Before proceeding to invert the system of linear equations
(5), it is instructive to take a closer look at the simulations
which are going to be used to test the inversion algorithms.
Given that most methods rely on the luminous mass dis-
tribution, this is particularly important should the galaxies
not accurately trace the dark matter.
Our simulations consist of three elements. The first el-
ement of the simulation is the projected mass distribution
(M ) in the lens plane. We simulate a generic mass distribu-
tion of a cluster with a total projected mass of 1.119 × 1015
h−1 M⊙ in the field of view located at redshift z = 0.18. The
field of view of our simulation is 0.1 degrees The mass profile
is built from a superposition of 20 NFW profiles with added
ellipticity. The halos' masses vary from 0.25 × 1015 h−1 M⊙
to 2 × 1012 h−1 M⊙. In the context of lensing, NFW halos
seem to reproduce well the shear profile of massive clus-
ters up to several Mpc (Dahle et al. 2003, Kneib et al. 2003,
Broadhurst et al. 2005). The final mass distribution is shown
in figure 1. Also in the same figure we show the two critical
curves. The interior one is the radial critical curve and the
exterior one the tangential critical curve. Both curves have
been calculated assuming the source is at redshift z = 3.
The tangential critical curve is usually associated with the
Einstein radius. Its large size (radius ≈ 2 arcmin) is due to
the unusually high projected mass of our cluster plus its rel-
atively low redshift (z = 0.18). Although the deduced Ein-
stein radius is larger than the one observed in clusters, the
simulation presented here will serve the purpose of testing
the different methods discussed here. More realistic simula-
tions with proper mass distribution and source density will
be presented in a future paper.
The second element in our simulation are the sources
(β), for which we extract 13 sources from the HUDF (Hubble
Ultra Deep Field, Beckwith et al. 2003). We assign them a
redshift (z ∈ [1, 6]) and size and place them in different
positions behind the cluster plane.
The third element are the lensed images (θ) which are
calculated from the first two elements (M and β). This is
done through a simple ray-tracing procedure. For each posi-
tion θ in the image, we calculate the deflection angle, α, and
then the corresponding source plane position,β, according to
the lens equation (equation 1). If the calculated β coincides
with one of the original sources, we assign to the lensed im-
age the value (colour) of that source. Otherwise that point
in the lensed image is left dark (value 0 ). We repeat the op-
eration for all the pixels (θs) to produce a complete image.
Also, since the sources are small compared with our pixel
size and to avoid missing some sources, we oversample our
θ pixels by subdividing them and checking each pixel at dif-
ferent locations (θ + ∆θ with ∆θ < 1 and θ ∈ [1, 512]) The
original sources are plotted in figure 2 and the corresponding
θs in the left panel of figure 3.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Figure 2. The 13 sources at redshift z ∈ (1, 6). The field of
view is 0.1 degrees across and is centered in the same point as
figure 1. The solid line marcs the position of the caustics at z = 3
correponding to the radial (dotted line) and tangential (solid line)
critical curves.
Another way of constraining the system is by assum-
ing the Ns sources are well approximated by point sources,
which reduces the number of unknowns to Nc + 2Ns. This
means effectively demanding that all observed θs for arcs
corresponding to the same source, can be traced back
through the lens to Ns single points. With this assumption
we can rewrite the lens equation in the compact form of
θ = ΓX.
(5)
Γ is now a matrix of dimension 2Nθ × (Nc + 2Ns) and X
is the vector of dimension (Nc + 2Ns) containing all the
unknowns in our problem (see appendix A), the mass ele-
ments and the 2Ns central (x- and y) coordinates of the Ns
sources. Now the system is matematically overdetermined
(more data points that unknowns) and has a unique point
source solution. This unique solution can be found by nu-
merical methods as we will see later.
The linearization of the problem means that it is in
principle solvable by both matrix inversion and simple lin-
ear programming routines. In practice, the problem quickly
becomes ill-conditioned and too large for direct matrix in-
version, and approximate numerical methods are more suit-
able. The main problem with the linearization is that we do
not know if the obtained linearized solution creates artifi-
cial tangential or radial arcs. Checking this requires forward
solving of the lens equation which is non-linear due to the
complicated dependence of the deflection angle on θ.
We suggest a novel approach to this problem, by using
all the available information in the images, i.e. the informa-
tion inherent in the dark areas (pixels containing no arcs)
as well as the observed arcs. By pixellization the dark areas,
tracing these pixels back through the lens and imposing that
they fall outside the sources it is possible to find the true
solution without over-predicting arcs. This use of the null
space is to our knowledge unprecedented, and in principle
Inverting the lens
5
Figure 3. The sources lensed by the mass distribution of figure 1. The right image is the lensed image using 325 cells in the dynamical
grid (see text). The left image is the exact solution using no griding. Note the differences in the radial arcs.
4 GRIDIFYING THE MASS DISTRIBUTION
4.1 The Υ matrix
As laid out in section 2 the basis of our non-parametric
reconstruction method is the assumption that the real mass
can be well approximated by a pixelized mass distribution.
The Υ matrix is then the matrix which casts the mass vector
into the vector of deflection angles
αi = ΥijMj
(6)
For convenience rather than taking the mass distribu-
tion in each cell to be constant we assume it follows a Gaus-
sian distribution centred in the centre of the cell with some
dispersion. This allows us to calculate analytically the lens-
ing contribution from each mass cell, saving valuable com-
puter time. We use a dispersion of 2a where a is the size of
the cell, and we have confirmed with simulations that the
lensed image generated with this choice agrees well with the
true lensed image using a relatively small number of cells.
The detailed structure of the Υ matrix will be explained in
appendix A.
4.2 Multi resolution mass-grid
Rather than taking a uniform grid, it is better to construct
a dynamical- or multi-resolution grid. By sampling dense re-
gions more heavily, it is possible to reduce drastically the
number of cells needed to accurately reproduce the lens-
ing properties of the cluster. In other words we choose an
adaptive grid which samples the dense cluster centre better
than the outer regions. Since we do not actually know the
density profile of the cluster, this multi-resolution grid must
be obtained through an iterative procedure. An example of
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
this process can be found on the SLAP⋆ (Strong Lensing
Analysis Package) webpage.
Given a mass estimate (a first mass estimate can be ob-
tained with a coarse regular grid), we split a given cell into
four sub-cells if the mass in the cell exceeds some threshold
value. The lower this threshold, the higher the number of
divisions and consequently the higher the final number of
cells. The obtained grid can then be used for the next mass
estimate, and the process can be repeated as necessary. Typ-
ically the mass estimate will improve with each iterative step
as this dynamical grid allows for the relevant regions of the
cluster to become resolved.
In figure 4 we show an example of a gridded version of
the true mass in figure 1 for a threshold of Mthr = 8.0×1012
h−1 M⊙. This grid has 325 cells. The corresponding (true)
mass in the grid is shown in figure 5. The parameter Mthr
or equivalently the number of cells, Nc, can be viewed as a
free parameter but also as a prior. Fixing it means we are
fixing the minimum scale or mass we are sensitive too. In a
paralell paper (Diego et al. 2004) we explored the role of Nc
and found that it can have a negative effect on the results
if it takes very large values. A natural upper limit for Nc is
2 times the number of pixels in the θ vector minus 2 times
the number of sources (the factor 2 accounts for the x and
y positions). Our simulations show that a good election for
Nc is normally 1/4 of this upper limit.
For the shake of clarity it is useful to give some practical
numbers. The image on the left of figure 3 has 5122 pixels
from which 2156 pixels are part of one of the ≈ 35 arcs so
Nθ = 2156. These arcs are coming from 13 sources (Ns = 13)
and the lens plane is tipically divided in a few hundred cells
(Nc ∼ 300).
⋆ see http://darwin.cfa.harvard.edu/SLAP/
6 Diego et al.
Figure 4. Dynamical grid for the mass in figure 1. This case
corresponds to Mthr = 8.0 × 1012 h−1 M⊙.
Figure 5. Masses in the cells of the dynamical grid of figure 4.
5
INVERSION METHODS
In this section we will describe some inversion methods
which can be applied to solve the problem. Most of these
methods can be found in popular books like Numerical
Recipes (Press et al. 1997). All these algorithms are be-
ing implemented in the package SLAP⋆ which will be made
available soon.
Once we have the problem formulated in its linear form
with all the unknowns on one side it is tempting to try a
direct inversion of equation 5. Although the Γ matrix is not
square, one can find its inverse, Γ−1, by decomposing Γ into
orthogonal matrices. This is similar to finding the eigenval-
ues and eigenvectors of Γ. This approximation has its ad-
vantages as well as its drawbacks and we will explore this
possibility later. However, we anticipate that degeneracies
between neighboring pixels in the arcs as well as neighboring
cells in the lens plane (not to mention the compact nature
of the sources) will result in a system of linear equations
which is not well behaved. The rank of the matrix Γ will
be normally smaller than its smaller dimension. Calculating
the inverse in this situation is not a trivial task.
A second approach is rotating our system of linear equa-
tions using a transformation which is just ΓT . This trans-
forms Γ into a square, symmetric and positive definite ma-
trix of dimension (2Ns + Nc) × (2Ns + Nc), A = ΓT Γ which
is better behaved than the original Γ matrix. However, the
rank of A is in generally smaller than its dimension and its
inverse does not exist. The hope in this case must therefore
be to find an approximate rather than exact solution to the
system.
The third approach is the simplest and will be explored
first. We assume we know nothing about the sources other
than their redshift and that they are much smaller than the
strong lensing arcs. This is the same as saying that the lens
has to be such that it focuses the arcs into compact sources
at the desired (known) redshift. This simple argument alone
will turn out to be powerful enough to get a quick but good
first estimate of the mass distribution in the lens plane.
We explore all these approaches below in reverse order.
5.1 A first approach: Minimizing dispersion in the
source plane
In this subsection we will discuss the simplest (although ef-
fective) method to get a fast estimation of the mass using
no prior information on the lens nor the sources. The prob-
lem then contains two sets of unknowns: The mass vector we
want to determine, M , and the β positions of the sources. In
general, for a finite number of observed arcs, there are sev-
eral combinations of β and M which can reproduce the ob-
servations. The most obvious unphysical solution is the null
solution, where the mass is zero and the sources identical to
the observed arcs. The easiest way to avoid such unphysical
solutions is to minimize the variance of the β positions. This
is equivalent to imposing that the vector M really acts as a
true lens: We require big arcs with large magnifications and
multiple images separated by arcsec or even arc-min to focus
into a rather compact region in the source plane. This min-
imization process assumes that we are able to associate the
multiple lensed images with a particular source. This can be
achieved with either spectroscopy or with morphology and
the multicolor imaging of the arcs.
To minimize the variance in the source plane it is illus-
trative to follow the steepest descent path although other
more effective minimization algorithms can be used (see be-
low). Given an initial guess for the mass vector, one can
calculate the derivative of the variance in the source plane
as a function of the mass and minimize in the direction of
the derivative. Once a minimum is found, we calculate the
derivative in the new mass position and minimize again in
an iterative procedure.
The quantity to be minimized is :
f (M ) = Xs
σ2
s
(7)
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Inverting the lens
7
Figure 7. Recovered sources after minimizing the variance. The
real positions of the sources are shown as crosses. Note that the
recovered sources are farther away than the real ones. This com-
pensates for the fact that the recovered mass is lower than the
the true value.
the sources. In fact, since the source positions can be esti-
mated from equation 4, the minimization of the variance also
provides us with an initial guess for these. The drawback is
the slow convergence of the algorithm. A typical minimiza-
tion may take several hours on a 1 GHz processor. In the
next sub-section we will go a step further and we will include
the β positions in the minimization as well as speed up the
convergence by orders of magnitude.
5.2 Biconjugate Gradient
Inversion of linear systems where the matrix dimensions are
of order 103, is a numerically trivial problem for today's
computers provided the matrix is well behaved. If the ma-
trix has null or negative eigenvalues, a direct inversion is not
feasible and one has to aim to solve for some approximated
solution. Our system of linear equations is a good example
of an ill-conditioned one. Direct inversion of the matrix is
not possible due to negative eigenvalues. However there is
another important reason why we do not want to solve ex-
actly (or invert) the system of equations. An exact solution
means that we will recover a mass distribution which puts
the arcs into delta function sources. As we will see later, this
solution will be unphysical. Instead, we are interested in an
approximated solution which does not solve exactly the sys-
tem of equations and which has a residual. This residual will
have the physical meaning of the extension of the sources or
the difference between the point-like sources and the real,
extended ones. The biconjugate gradient (Press et al. 1997)
will be a useful way to regularize our problem.
The biconjugate gradient algorithm is one of the fastest
and most powerful algorithms to solve for systems of linear
equations. It is also extremely useful for finding approximate
solutions for systems where no exact solutions exist or where
Figure 6. Smooth version of the recovered mass after minimizing
the variance. The total recovered mass is 1.01 × 1015 h−1 M⊙.
Compare this mass with the original one in figure 1.
where the sum is over the number of identified sources and
σ2
s is the variance of the source s in the source plane. That
is;
σ2
s =< β2 >s − < β >2
(8)
s
where the β's are calculated from equation 4 and the aver-
age is over the β's corresponding to source s. By combining
equations 4 and 8 is easy to compute the derivative of σ2
s
with respect to M .
∂σ2
s
∂Mj
= 2 < β >s< Υj >s −2 < βΥj >s
(9)
x + σ2
where Υj is the column j of the Υ matrix and the average is
made only on the elements associated with the source s. We
should note that all equations involving the vectors β, θ or
α = ΥM have two components, x and y so there will be in
fact two equations like equation 9. One for the x component
of β and the other one for the y component. At the end,
the quantity we aim to minimize is σ2 = σ2
y. As we
already mentioned, the minimization can be done following
the path of steepest descent given by equation 9. This path
will end in a minimum at the new mass M j . The process
can be repeated by evaluating the new path at the new mass
position until the variance is smaller than certain ǫ. A good
choice for ǫ is to take a few times the expected variance for
a population of Ns galaxies at the measured Ns redshifts.
specific values for ǫ will be discussed later.
In practical
terms the minimization is done through a series of iterations,
gradually improving the dynamical grid as laid out in section
4.2. For each iteration the ability of the mass distribution
to focus the βs into compact sources is improved.
Equation 8 can be improved by weighting it with the
amplification of the different images, assuming the errors
in the image plane are similar from images to images. This
point will not be explored here. The minimization of the
variance is a powerful and robust method for finding a first
guess for the mass vector without making assumptions about
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
8 Diego et al.
the exact solution is not the one we are interested in. The
latter will be our case. Given a system of linear equations;
Ax = b
(10)
a solution of this system can be found by minimizing the
following function,
f (x) = c − bx +
1
2
xtAx
(11)
where c is a constant. When the function f (x) is minimized,
its gradient is zero.
∇f (x) = Ax − b = 0
(12)
That is, at the position of the minimum of the function f (x)
we find the solution of equation (10). In most cases, finding
the minimum of equation 11 is much easier than finding
the solution of the system in 10 especially when no exact
solution exists for 10 or A does not have an inverse.
The biconjugate gradient finds the minimum of equa-
tion 11 (or equivalently, the solution of equation 10) by fol-
lowing an iterative process which minimizes the function
f (x) in a series of steps no longer than the dimension of the
problem. The beauty of the algorithm is that the successive
minimizations are carried out on a series of orthogonal con-
jugate directions , pk, with respect to the metric A. That
is,
piApj = 0
j < i
(13)
This condition is useful when minimizing in a multidimen-
sional space since it guarantees that successive minimiza-
tions do not spoil the minimizations in previous steps.
Let us now turn to the system we want to solve, namely
equation 5. The biconjugate gradient method assumes that
the matrix Γ ( matrix A in equation 10) is square. For our
case this does not hold since we typically have Nθ >> (Nc +
Ns). Instead we build a new quantity, called the square of
the residual,R2:
Figure 8. Recovered mass after minimizing R2 using the bicon-
jugate gradient algorithm. The mass has been smoothed with a
Gaussian filter. The total recovered mass is 1.17 × 1015 h−1 M⊙.
R2 = (θ − ΓX)T (θ − ΓX)
1
2
θT θ − ΓT θX +
= 2(
1
2
X T ΓT ΓX)
(14)
(15)
By comparing equations 15 and 11 is easy to identify the
2 θT θ, b = ΓT θ and A = ΓT Γ. Minimizing the
terms, c = 1
quantity R2 is equivalent to solving equation 5. To see this
we only have to realize that
b − AX = ΓT (θ − ΓX) = ΓT R
(16)
If an exact solution for equation 5 does not exist, the min-
imum of R2 will give the better approximated solution to
the system. The minimum can be now found easily with the
biconjugate gradient (Press et al. 1997). For the case of sym-
metric matrices A, the algorithm constructs two sequences
of vectors rk and pk and two constants, αk and βk;
αk =
rT
k rk
pT
k Apk
rk+1 = rk − αkApk
βk =
rT
k+1rk+1
rT
k rk
pk+1 = rk+1 + βkpk
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
Figure 9. Recovered β's after minimizing R2. Again, crosses rep-
resent the true position of the sources. The recovered βo falls in
the middle of its corresponding cloud β points.
At every iteration, an improved estimate of the solution is
found by;
Xk+1 = Xk + αkpk
(21)
The algorithm starts with an initial guess for the solution,
X1, and chooses the residual and search direction in the first
iteration to be;
r1 = p1 = b − AX1
(22)
Note that p1 is nothing but ∇R2. Thus the algorithm
chooses as a first minimization direction the gradient of the
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
function to be minimized at the position of the first guess.
Then it minimizes in directions which are conjugate to the
previous ones until it reaches the minimum or the square of
the residual R2 is smaller than certain value ǫ.
The method has one potential pathological behavior
when applied to our problem. One can not choose ǫ to be
arbitrarily small. If one chooses a very small ǫ the algorithm
will try to find a solution which focuses the arcs in Ns sources
which are delta functions. This is not surprising as we are
assuming that all the 2Nθ unknown βs are reduced to just
2Ns βs, i.e the point source solution (see figures 10 and 11
) . The mass distribution which accomplishes this is usu-
ally very much biased compared to the right one. It shows a
lot of substructure and it has large fluctuations in the lens
plane. One therefore has to choose ǫ with a wise criteria.
Since the algorithm will stop when R2 < ǫ we should choose
ǫ to be an estimate of the expected dispersion of the sources
at the specified redshifts. This is the only prior which has to
be given to the method. However, we will see later how the
specific value of ǫ is not very critical as long as it is within
a factor of a few of the right source dispersion (see figure
18 below). Instead of defining ǫ in terms of R2 is better
to define it in terms of the residual of the conjugate gradi-
ent algorithm, r2
k. This will speed the minimization process
significantly since we do not need to calculate the real dis-
persion at each step but to use the already estimated rk.
Both residuals are connected by the relation,
rk = ΓT R
(23)
Imposing a prior on the sizes of the sources means that we
expect the residual of the lens equation, R, to take typical
values of the order of the expected dispersion of the sources
at the measured redshifts. Hence we can define an Rprior of
the form;
Inverting the lens
9
focuses the arcs into sources which are larger than the real
sources. We should take this into account when fixing σi.
The reader can argue that a more clever way of includ-
ing this prior information in the algorithm is by perturbing
the β elements in equation 5 (or similarly, equation 5 in Ap-
pendix A). This is done by adding some noise to the 1s in the
two 1 matrices in equation 37 (see Appendix A). One could
for instance add Gaussian noise with a dispersion similar
to the expected dispersion of the source at redshift z. The
reality however is that the quadratic nature of R2 cancels
out any symmetric perturbation added to the elements of
Γ. Thus, the result is similar if we perturb Γ or not and we
still have to include the prior and fix ǫ to be large enough
so we do not recover the point source solution. This also
tell us that this method is not very promising if one wants
to include parity information in the recovery of the mass
and sources. In the next subsection we will show a different
approach which can include this parity information.
5.3 Singular Value Decomposition
The Singular Value Decomposition (hereafter SVD) algo-
rithm allows for decomposition of a generic m × n (with
m >= n) matrix A into the product of 3 matrices, two or-
thogonal and one diagonal (e.g Press et al. 1997).
A = U W V T
(26)
where U is an m × n orthogonal matrix, W is an n × n diag-
onal matrix whose elements in the diagonal are the singular
values and V T is the transpose of an n × n orthogonal ma-
trix. When A is symmetric, the SVD reduces to finding the
eigenvectors and eigenvalues of A.
The advantage of this decomposition is that the inverse
of A is given by ;
Ri
prior = σi ∗ RN D
(24)
A−1 = V W −1U T
(27)
where the index i runs from 1 to Nθ and σi is the disper-
sion (prior) assumed for the source associated to pixel i and
RN D is a random number uniformly distributed over -1 and
1. Then, we can estimate ǫ as;
ǫ = rT
k rk = RT
priorΓΓT Rprior
(25)
When calculating ǫ is is better to consider only the first Nc
columns of Γ and discard the last 2Ns. This is recommended
to avoid that the 1s in this part of the Γ matrix do not cancel
out when multiplied by the random number and dominate
the much smaller Γij elements corresponding to the mass
components. The last Nc columns of Γ should give 0 con-
tribution when multiplied by the random Ri
prior vector. If
we chose as a prior that the sources are Gaussians with a
σ = 30h−1 kpc located at the measured redshift, this ren-
ders ǫ ≈ 2 × 10−10. The reader will note that the chosen σ is
a few times larger than the one we would assign to a typical
galaxy. We will discuss this point later. The final result is
shown in figures 8 and 9.
One has to be careful in not choosing the σi very small.
In fact, they should be larger than the real dispersion of the
source. Only when the number of grid points, Nc, is large
enough, can the gridded version of the true mass focus the
arcs into sources which are similar in size to the real ones. If
Nc is not large enough, the gridded version of the true mass
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
where W −1 is another diagonal matrix whose elements are
just the inverse of the elements of W , that is W −1
jj =
1.0/Wjj . The proof A−1A = I follows from the property
that U and V T are orthogonal (U T U = V V T = I).
In our case, we can use SVD to calculate the inverse of
the Γ matrix and find the solution, X, directly by inverting
equation (5)
X = Γ−1θ = V W −1U T θ
(28)
Although the SVD allows us to invert the problem by calcu-
lating Γ−1, its full power lies in its ability to solve a system
approximately. The level of approximation can be controlled
by setting a threshold in the matrix W −1. In our problem,
there will be many equations which are strongly correlated
in the sense that most of the θ positions in a single arc will
come from the same source (that is, they will have almost
the same β). Also we have to keep in mind that we are us-
ing all the pixels in our data. This means that two equations
corresponding to two neighboring pixels will look almost ex-
actly the same. When one computes the SVD of the matrix
Γ, these two facts translate into a matrix W with elements
in the diagonal which are 0 or close to 0. The inverse of W
would be dominated by these small numbers and the solu-
tion will look very noisy. The good news about using SVD is
that the most relevant information in the Γ matrix is packed
10 Diego et al.
Figure 10. Recovered mass after minimizing R2 using the bicon-
jugate gradient algorithm and with a very small ǫ (point source
solution). The total recovered mass is 2.43 × 1015 h−1 M⊙ but
there are also regions with negative masses.
Figure 11. Recovered β's after minimizing R2 for the point
source solution. The real source positions are shown as crosses.
into the first few values (the largest values in W ) while the
small single values in W will contain little information or
the redundant information coming from neighboring pixels.
One can just approximate W by another matrix W ′ where
all the elements in its diagonal smaller than certain thresh-
old are set to 0. Also, in the inverse of W ′, these elements
are set to 0. The magic of this trick is that the solution
found with this approximation will contain the main trend
or main components of the mass distribution.
Figure 12. Recovered mass after SVD (no prior). The total re-
covered mass is 1.01 × 1015 h−1 M⊙.
The degree of accuracy is controlled by setting the thresh-
old in the singular values of the matrix W . Those elements
in W below the threshold are set to 0 and the same in its
inverse. The threshold is usually set after looking at the sin-
gular values. The first ones will normally stay in some kind
of plateau and after then the singular values will decrease
rapidly. The threshold should be normally set immediately
after the plateau. In figures 12 and 13 we show the result af-
ter decomposing Γ in its SVD decomposition and calculating
its inverse with (27).
Like the two previous algorithms, the SVD has its own
pathologies. Using standard subroutines to find the SVD of
Γ usually return a no convergence error. This error comes
from the nearly degenerate nature of Γ. One has then to in-
crease the number of maximum iterations on these subrou-
tines or use a coarse version of Γ where only a small fraction
of the θ positions (or equivalently, Γ rows) are considered.
Another solution is inverting the preconditioned system of
equations where we previously multiply for ΓT . This allows
to use all the θ pixels and find the SVD of ΓT Γ in a small
number of iterations. However, using the SVD of Γ instead
of ΓT Γ has a very interesting feature. It allows to introduce
parity information in an effective way.
Contrary to the quadratic cases of minimization of the
variance or the square of the residual R2, the SVD allows us
to include parity information in the Γ matrix which will not
disappear when we look for the best solution. Since no ΓT θ
or ΓT Γ operations are involved, parity information will not
cancel out. SVD could be an interesting way of fine tuning
the solution by including the extra information coming from
the parity of the arcs.
6 INCORPORATING THE NULL SPACE
Another advantage of using the SVD algorithm is that
in this case no prior on the extension of the sources is needed.
So far we have made use of the information contained in the
observed strong lensing arcs. This gives us a solution which
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Inverting the lens
11
predicting β falling near the β positions which minimize R2.
As a penalizing function we will choose an asymptotically
divergent Gaussian
g(fk) =
1
efk − µ
with,
fk =
( β(k)x − βo
x)2 + ( β(k)y − βo
y)2
σ2
k
(31)
(32)
Where β(k)x is the x component of β for the pixel k in the
null space. βo
x is our estimated value of β (x component) and
similarly for the y component. There are as many constraints
of the form fk as there are pixels, θ, in the null space.
The parameter µ controls the degree of divergence of
the Gaussian function. When µ = 0 we recover the classi-
cal Gaussian but as µ approaches 1 the Gaussian becomes
more and more sharply without increasing its dispersion. For
µ = 1 the Gaussian is infinite at fk = 0 (see figure 14. By
minimizing the function φ(X) with increasing values of µ we
will find that in the limit µ → 1 the solution will push away
those β which originally were falling in the region defined
by the set of β.
Ideally we want to include all the dark or empty pixels
in the θ space but this is, in general, found to be a waste
of memory and computing time. The fact is that only the θ
pixels which are hitting (or close to hit) one of the Ns esti-
mated β positions of the sources will have some impact on
the solution. Most of the θ pixels in the null space already
satisfy all the constraints for the actual solution X. For this
reason we will include only those θ for which the solution X
predicts their corresponding β are close to hitting (or actu-
ally hitting) a source. The θ space will include the observed
θ's as a subspace. We have to exclude this subspace from β
before minimizing equation 30. This is, again, just an opti-
mization process. In practice, one can include all the pixels
in the image (excluding those containing part of an arc) in
the null space.
After the minimization process is finished, the new so-
lution will have the arcs falling in compact regions around
β0 while the extra-arcs produced by the previous solution
will fall in regions outside areas around the βo.
¿From our simulation we have seen that addition of the
null space induces small changes in the mass plane and it
tends to stabilize the solution in the sense that it makes the
recovered mass profile independent of the threshold ǫ. This
is in fact an interesting bonus which comes with the addition
of the null space. The new function to be minimized, φ, can
be minimized until the true minimum is found. In this case,
there is no equivalent of a point source solution. Since some
of the θ are in fact very close to the observed θ, the solution
which minimizes φ will focus those θ and θ in neighboring
regions in the source plane. When minimizing φ there will be
two competing effects. One will tend to increase the mass
so it minimizes R2 (point source solution). The other will
tend to reduce the mass so the β will be pushed away from
the β positions. The outcome will be a balanced situation
between the β trying to collapse into compact sources and
the β trying to escape the wells in the beta positions.
To accurately quantify the effect more simulations are
needed. This will be done in a future paper but as an illustra-
tion we show in figure 15 the recovered mass after imposing
Figure 13. Recovered sources after SVD (no prior). The real
positions of the sources are shown as crosses
explains the data in the sense that it predicts arcs in the
right positions but it could well happen that the solution
over-predicts arcs. An example of this can bee seen by com-
paring the reproduced arcs in fig. (16) with the true arcs in
fig. (3). Some of the reproduced arcs are slightly larger and
span a larger area than the true ones, although the sources
are perfectly reproduced in their true positions and the re-
covered mass is very close to the true mass distribution.
To avoid this we propose for the first time to include
information from the null space, θ. That is, the part of the
image which does not contain any arc. This space tell us
where an arc should not appear but it does not tell us where
the hypothetical β should be. The only fair thing we can do
is to impose that none of the pixels in the null space fall into
the estimated β of our solution. By achieving this we will
have a solution which predicts the right arcs while not over-
predicting arcs. The solution will be then fully consistent
with the observed data.
The null space is connected to the solution X by;
β = θ − ΥM
(29)
It is evident that we want the new solution X (M and βo) to
be such that the new β do not fall within a circle of radius
p(k) centered in each one of the βo where p(k) is the prior
with information on how extended are the sources. The null
space will perturb the solution X in such a way that the
new solution, X ′ = X + ∆ X is an approximated solution of
equation 5 and satisfies all the constraints of the form β ∋ β.
The way we incorporate the constraints is by adopt-
ing an approach commonly used in penalized quadratic pro-
gramming. We will minimize the new function
φ(X) = R2 + λXk
g(fk)
(30)
where the λ is a constant which guarantees that in the first
iterations, the second term in equation 30 does not dominate
the first and gk is a function which will penalize those models
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
12 Diego et al.
Figure 14. Penalizing function showing values of µ =
0.8, 0.9, 0.95, 0.97, and 0.98 and σ = 1. Note that the width of
the curve does not change when increasing µ.
Figure 15. Recovered mass (smoothed) after minimizing φ. The
crosses show the position of the three main halos in the cluster.
The size of the cross is proportional to the mass of the halo. The
total recovered mass is 1.1055 × 1015h−1M⊙.
the constraints in the θ space. The total mass is now only
1.2 % lower than the true mass. The new mass also contains
more structure and starts showing the internal distribution
of the main components of the cluster.
In figure 16 we show the predicted position for the arcs
after combining the best mass together with the best esti-
mate for the position of the sources. To compute the arcs
we have assumed that each source is a circle with a radius
15h−1kpc centred in the estimated best source positions and
at the measured redshifts. By comparing figures 16 and fig-
ure 3 (left) we see that the predicted arcs matches very well
the observed (simulated) data with the exception of some of
the arcs near the center of the image.
Figure 16. The plot shows the predicted arcs according to the
best mass and source solution. We have assumed that the sources
are circles with radius 15h−1kpc centred in the source position
and at the measured redshifts. This result should be compared
with the true arcs seen in figure 3. The match is almost perfect.
7 DISCUSSION
In this paper we have presented several approaches to non-
parametric lens modelling. Using no information about lu-
minosity distributions whatsoever, these methods perform
remarkably well on simulated strong lensing data. One of
the main conclusions of this work is simply that it works; It
is possible to recover information about the mass distribu-
tion without using prior information on the same if one has
a sufficiently large number of arcs. This can be seen in fig-
ure 17 where we show the recovered mass profiles compared
with the original one. The recovered mass traces the real
mass distribution up to furthest data point in the simulated
image. Beyond this point, the recovered profile is insensitive
to the data. When the minimization stops, the cells in the
outer regions stay with a mass close to the one they had in
the first step of the minimization. This point is discussed in
more detail in Diego et al. (2004).
We are optimistic about the performance of these meth-
ods when used on future data, but we would also like to
emphasize the potential pathologies. We will now discuss
the major issues. As we have seen in section (2) the inver-
sion algorithms rely on a linearization of the lens equation.
We achieve that by decomposing the lens plane into small
mass-cells and assuming that the gridded mass is a fair rep-
resentation of the true underlying mass. This is true when
the number of cells in the grid is large enough, but for a uni-
form grid this may mean using several thousand mass-cells,
making the problem ill conditioned and underdetermined.
By inverting the lens equation in a series of iterations we
introduce an adaptive grid which optimizes the number of
cells by sampling dense regions more heavily and using larger
cells for underdense regions. This allows for good sampling of
the lens without a huge number of cells. However, the grid-
ded mass plane is still an approximation to the true mass
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Inverting the lens
13
Introducing such a prior begs the question: How sensi-
tive is the solution to the specific guess of prior? The answer
is that it depends on exactly "how bad" that choice is. As
long as we assume a source size significantly larger than the
true sizes the actual solution does not change much and re-
sembles well the true mass distribution. However, when try-
ing to approach the true source size, the solutions changes
rapidly away from the realistic model. The situation is shown
in fig. (18). As shown in section 5.2 a given physical size cor-
responds to a given threshold, ǫ, and as long as this threshold
is sufficiently large, ≥ 10−10, (corresponding to a physical
size of ≥ 30h−1 kpc) the total mass is well behaved. If we
instead demand that the physical size of the reconstructed
sources be more realistic, say ∼ 12h−1 kpc, we get a thresh-
old of ∼ 10−11 for which the mass distribution is already
starting to diverge away from the true mass. We therefore
want the recovered sources to be larger than the true ones.
In other words we want to recover a short-sighted cluster! In
previous sections we have demonstrated non-parametric lens
modelling using several different algorithms with promising
results. However we have not yet addressed the question of
uniqueness. Is there a unique solution, and if not, how dif-
ferent are the possible solutions?
The good news is that minimizing quadratic functions
like the variance or the square of the residual guarantees that
there is only one absolute minimum. This absolute minimum
corresponds to the point source solution. The bad news is
that this is not the solution we are looking for. As shown
above, trying to focus the sources too much introduces arti-
facts in the mass distribution, so we need to stop the mini-
mization at some step before the absolute minimum. In two
dimensions it is easy to visualize that the quadratic func-
tion will have the shape of a valley, and stopping the min-
imization at some point before the actual minimum means
choosing an ellipse on which all solutions are equally good.
In many dimensions this is harder to visualize but we expect
our obtainable solutions to lie on an N-dimensional ellipsoid
around the minimum.
To get a quantitative grasp on how much these solutions
differ in mass and source positions, we solve the equations
for a range of random initial conditions. This is a manage-
able task since our minimization algorithm is extremely fast,
taking only about ∼ 1 second on a 1GHz processor. Also for
speed purposes, we fix the grid to the one corresponding to
the solution shown in figure 8. Fixing the grid speeds the
process significantly since the ΓT Γ matrix and the ΓT θ vec-
tor do not need to be recalculated in each minimization.
In Diego et al. (2004) a similar process is followed carrying
multiple minimizations but this time the grid is changed dy-
namically based on the solution found in the previous step.
The authors found on that paper that the dispersion of the
solutions increases due to the extra variability of the grid.
The result is shown in figure 19. The minimization pro-
cess described in section 5.2 will stop at a different point in
the N-dimensional ellipsoid for each set of different initial
conditions. If the total mass of the initial mass distribution
is very low the minimization will stop at solutions with mass
below the true mass and β positions further away from the
center of the cluster than the real ones (dots). If instead
we start with a total mass much larger than the true value,
the minimization process returns higher masses and β po-
sitions closer to the center of the potential (crosses). The
Figure 17. Original profile (solid line) compared with the re-
covered ones. Dashed line is the biconjugate gradient case, dot-
dashed the SVD case, dotted the case is when include the null
space. The minimum of the variance is similar but with less mass
in the tails. All profiles have been normalized by the critical sur-
face density for a source at redshift, zs = 3.
Figure 18. Total mass as a function of the threshold ǫ used in
the biconjugate gradient minimization. The true mass is 1.119 ×
1015h−1M⊙.
plane so we expect the solution to be an approximation to
the true solution as well. Since a solution comprises not only
the masses but the positions and extents of the sources as
well, this means that we should expect these to also be ap-
proximations to the true ones. This has already been iden-
tified as one of the potential pathologies of the algorithm.
Namely, if we try to focus the sources into very compact
regions, with sizes comparable to the typical galaxy sizes at
the relevant redshifts, the obtained mass is in general differ-
ent to the true mass. In fact the best results are obtained
when the mass plane focuses the arcs into regions which are
a few times larger than the extent of the true sources. As we
pointed out before, this reconstructed mass corresponds to a
short-sighted version of the lens. This problem can be over-
come by requiring the minimization algorithms stop once
the recovered sources are a few times larger than the true
sources. The extent of the true sources can be guessed from
the redshift.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
14 Diego et al.
situation improves when we impose that the total mass of
the initial distribution have a reasonable value. In this case,
the minimization stops in a region close to both the right
mass and the right βs. This argument motivates an iterative
minimization where successive estimations for the mass are
obtained at each step and used in the next.
Among the three algorithms presented in this work, the
minimization of the variance is the less powerfull due to its
low convergence. It is however interesting from a pedagog-
ical point of view since it shows the existing degeneracies
between the total mass of the cluster and the positions of
the sources. The biconjugate gradient is orders of magnitude
faster and is capable of finding the point source solution in a
few seconds. The point source solution is however unphysical
and a prior associated to the size of the sources is needed in
order to stop the minimization process at the proper place.
The good news are that the algorithm shows a weak sen-
sitivity to this prior provided it is chosen with a minimum
of wisdom. Since the point where the minimization stops
depends on where the minimization starts, this also allows
to study the range of possible models consistent with the
data by minimizing many times while changing the initial
conditions. This feature makes the biconjugate gradient very
attractive for studying the space of solutions. This space can
be reduced by including the extra-information contained in
the null space, that is, the areas in the sky with no observed
arcs. We have seen how this information can be naturally in-
cluded in the minimization process by introducing a penalty
function.
Finally, the SVD has the interesting feature that it al-
lows to add extra information regarding the parity or re-
solved features in the arcs. This possibility has not been
studied in detail in this paper but is definitely worth ex-
ploring since it would allow to recover smaller details in the
mass distribution. The main drawbacks of the SVD is that
the decomposition fails to converge when all the informa-
tion is used and one has to use a coarse version of the data
instead. The second drawback is that some of the singular
values in the matrix W are very small. These values will
dominate the inverse if they are not masked by a threshold
in the matrix W . Choosing the value for this threshold is
not very critical as long as its amplitude is large enough to
mask the small singular values in W .
The accuracy of the methods presented in this paper al-
low for high precision non-parametric mass reconstructions
and direct mapping of the dark matter distribution of clus-
ters. Previous works have suggested some discrepancy be-
tween mass estimates derived from different data (Wu &
Fang 1997). Accuracy, combined with the speed of the algo-
rithm opens the door to cosmological studies. Strong lens-
ing analyses were predicted to yield interesting cosmologi-
cal constraints, but due to the uncertainties in our under-
standing of galaxy clusters they have yet to live up to these
predictions. A fast, per-cent level determination of cluster
masses from lensing observations, could allow for sufficient
statistical sampling to provide information about cosmolog-
ical parameters. An interesting follow up to this work would
be to establish what number of strong lensing systems, and
what quality of data is necessary in order to make interesting
constraints using our methods.
However the methods presented here should not be
applied indiscriminately. For instance, if the reconstructed
Figure 19. Dispersion in the solutions for three different sets
of initial conditions. Upper left (dots), we start with a random
realization of small masses. Asterisks in the center, starting from
a random realization but with a total mass of M ≈ 1.06. Crosses
(bottom right), starting with high random masses. In all cases, the
threshold was set to ǫ = 2 × 10−10 and the starting β positions
where chosen as random in a box of 100 × 100 centered in the
center of the image.
mass is systematically biased toward recovering less cuspy
central regions this reduces the possibility of making con-
clusions about mechanisms for dark matter annihilation
(Spergel & Steinhardt 2000, Wyithe et al. 2001, Boehm et
al. 2004). If one is interested in using our methods to discuss
this, that bias must be quantified. Due to lens resolution is-
sues we anticipate that our reconstruction algorithms indeed
have a bias in this direction and it is likely that other algo-
rithms may suffer from similar problems. These and other
poetential systematic errors shall be investigated in future
works.
7.1 Future work
This paper is not intended to be an exhaustive exploration of
the accuracy of non-parametric mass reconstruction meth-
ods but rather to help re-ignite debate and competition in
the field, and demonstrate the feasibility and power of such
methods in the face of new data. Specific issues such as mag-
nitudes of the mass profile bias, source morphologies, sur-
face brightness of the arcs, parity, projection effects as well
as other relevant issues discussed above should be explored
in order to improve the results. Special emphasis should be
paid to the effects the grididification of the lens plane has on
the results. An attempt to study this issue has been made on
a second paper (Diego et al 2004) where the authors have
shown that the grid may play an important role. In this
paper we have presented the results using a very specific
simulation. Although the algorithm has been tested with
different simulations with positive results, it would be de-
sirable to make a more detailed study of how the result is
affected by issues like the structure of the lens, its symme-
try or the number of sources and accuracy in their redshifts.
Such a study would be even more interesting if a compara-
tive study between parametric and non-parametric methods
is done using the same simulations. Also interesting is to
explore the effects of adding constraints in the mass of the
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
type Mi > 0 which may help to stabilize the solution even
in the absence of a prior on the source sizes. This can be
accomplished by adopting the techniques used in quadratic
programming. All theses issues, although very interesting,
are beyond the scope of this paper and will be studied in
subsequent papers.
Although not discussed in this paper, a very interesting
piece of work would be about the potentiality of an accu-
rate strong lensing analysis as a cosmological tool (e.g Link
& Pierce 1998, Yamamoto et al. 2001, Golse et al. 2002,
Soucail et al. 2004). Previous works (Yamamoto et al. 2001,
Chiba & Takahashi 2002, Sereno 2002, Dalal et al. 2004)
suggest that the lensing observables are primarily dependent
on the lens model while the dependency in the cosmologi-
cal parameters is minor. Constraining the lens model with
accuracy can open the window to do cosmology with strong
lensing images. Is easy to imagine that a single image of a
cluster with dozens of arcs coming from sources at differ-
ent redshifts will constrain the lens model rather accurately
and then, it will have something to say about the cosmology
given the large number of distances involved in the analysis.
All these issues are of great interest and they are intended
to be studied in subsequent papers.
8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This work was supported by NSF CAREER grant AST-
0134999, NASA grant NAG5-11099, the David and Lucile
Packard Foundation and the Cottrell Foundation. The work
was also partially supported by B. Jain through lousy poker
playing. We thank D. Rusin and G. Bernstein for helpful dis-
cussions. We would like also to thank J.P Kneib for helpful
suggestions.
REFERENCES
Abdelsalam H.M., Saha P. & Williams, L.L.R., 1998, MNRAS,
294, 734.
Inverting the lens
15
Guzik J., Seljak U., 2002, MNRAS, 335, 311.
Hudson M.J., Gwyn S.D.J., Dahle H., Kaiser N., 1998, ApJ, 503,
531.
Kaiser N. & Squires 1993, ApJ, 404, 441.
Kaiser N. 1995, ApJ, 439, L1.
Kneib J.-P., Mellier Y., Fort B., Mathez G., 1993,A&A, 273, 367.
Kneib J.-P., Mellier Y., Pello R., Miralda-Escud´e J., Le Borgne
J.-F.,Boehringer H., & Picat J.-P. 1995, A&A, 303, 27.
Kneib J.-P., Ellis R.S., Smail I.R., Couch W., & Sharples R. 1996,
ApJ, 471, 643.
Kneib J.-P., 2002, The shapes of galaxies and their dark halos,
Proceedings of the Yale Cosmology Workshop "The Shapes
of Galaxies and Their Dark Matter Halos", New Haven,
Connecticut, USA, 28-30 May 2001. Edited by Priyam-
vada Natarajan. Singapore: World Scientific, 2002, ISBN
9810248482, p.50
Kneib J.-P., Hudelot P., Ellis R.S., Treu T., Smith G.P., Marshall
P., Czoske O., Smail I.R., Natarajan P., 2003, ApJ, 598, 804.
Kochanek C.S. & Blandford R.D., 1991, ApJ, 375, 492.
Link R. & Pierce M.J., 1998, ApJ, 502, 63.
Marshall P.J., Hobson M.P., Gull S.F., Bridle S.L, 2002, MNRAS,
335, 1037.
Meneghetti M., Jain B., Bartelmann M., Dolag K., 2004, astro-
ph/0409030.
Narayan R. & Bartelmann M., Formation of Structure in the
Universe, Proceedings of the 1995 Jerusalem Winter School.
Edited by A. Dekel and J.P. Ostriker; Cambridge University
Press 1999. p. 360.
Press W.H., Teukolsky S.A., Vetterling W.T., Flannery B.P.,
1997, Numerical Recipes in Fortran 77. Cambrdige Univer-
sity Press.
Saha, P., Williams, L.L.R., 1997, MNRAS, 292, 148.
Saha P. 2000, AJ, 120, 1654.
Sand D.J., Treu T. Ellis R.S. 2002, ApJ, 574, 129.
Schneider P., Ehlers J., Falco E.E., 1993, Book Review: Gravita-
tional lenses. Springer-Verlag, 1993.
Schneider P., 1995, A&A...302..639S.
Schneider P., & Seitz C. 1995, A&A, 294, 411.
Seitz C., & Schneider P. 1995, A&A, 297, 287.
Sereno M., 2002, A&A, 393, 757.
Soucail G., Kneib J.-P., Golse G. 2004, A&A, 417, L33.
Spergel D.N. & Steinhardt P.J., 2000, PhRvL, 84, 3760.
Taylor A.N., Dye S., Broadhurst T.J., Benitez N., van Kampen
Abdelsalam H.M, Saha P. & Williams, L.L.R., 1998, AJ, 116,
E. 1998, ApJ, 501, 539.
1541.
Tyson J.A., Kochanski G.P., Dell'Antonio I., 1998, ApJL, 498,
Bartelmann M., Narayan R., Seitz S. Schneider P., 1996, ApJ,
107.
464, L115.
Beckwith S.V.W. et al. 2003, AAS, 202,1705
Blandford R.D., Narayan R. 1992, ARA&A, 30, 311.
Boehm C., Hooper D., Silk J., Casse M., Paul J., 2004, PhRvL,
92, 1301.
Brainerd T.G, Blandford R.D, Smail I, 1996, ApJ, 466, 623.
Bridle S.L, Hobson M.P., Lasenby A.N., Saunders R., 1998, MN-
RAS, 299, 895.
Broadhurst T.J., Taylor A.N., Peacock J.A., 1995, ApJ, 438, 49.
Broadhurst T.J., Huang X., Frye B., Ellis R., 2000, ApJL, 534,
15.
Broadhurst T.J. et.al. 2005, ApJ, 621, 53.
Chiba T., Takahashi R. 2002, Progress of Theoretical Physics,
107, 625.
Colley W.N., W.N, Tyson J.A., Turner E.L., 1996, ApJL, 461,
83.
Dahle H., Hannestad S.; Sommer-Larsen J. 2003, ApJ, 588, 73
Dalal N., Holder G., Hennawi, J.F. 2004, ApJ, 609, 50.
Diego J.M., Sandvik H.B., Protopapas P., Tegmark M., Ben-
itez N., Broadhurst T., 2004, submitted to MNRAS, preprint
astro-ph/0412191
Golse G., Kneib J.-P., Soucail G., 2002, A&A, 387, 788.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
Tegmark M., 2002, PhRvD, 66, 3507.
Trotter C.S., Winn J.N., Hewitt J. N., 2000, ApJ, 535, 671.
Wambsganss J., 1998, Living Reviews in Relativity, 1, 12.
Wyithe J.S.B., Turner E.L., Spergel D.N. 2001, ApJ, 555, 504.
Wu X.-P., & Fang L.-Z. 1997, ApJ, 483, 62.
Yamamoto K., & Futamase T., 2001, Progress of Theoretical
Physics, 105, 5.
Yamamoto K., Kadoya Y., Murata T., Futamase T., 2001,
Progress of Theoretical Physics, 106, 917.
APPENDIX A: THE Υ AND Γ MATRICIES
The Υ matrix contains the information of how each
mass element j affects the ith deflection angle. That
is
αi = ΥijMj.
(33)
Precisely how the matrix is constructed is a matter of
convenience. Our specific choice is to put both x and y
components of all the arc pixels into vectors with 2Nθ
elements. The resulting Υ is then a 2Nθ × Ncells matrix.
16 Diego et al.
In fact the structure of the Υ matrix and the vec-
tors are irrelevant as long as they combine to correctly
represent the lens equation as
βi = θi − ΥijMj.
(34)
Each element in the Υ matrix is computed as fol-
lows.
Υx(i, j) = λ[1 − exp(−δ/2σ2)]
δx
δ2
where
λ = 1015M⊙
4G
c2
Dls
DlDs
(35)
(36)
positions of the Ns sources. Similarly, ~βy
the central y positions.
o will contain
This paper has been produced using the Royal Astronomical
Society/Blackwell Science LATEX style file.
y(j) and δ = qδ2
The index i runs over the Nθ observed θ pixels, in-
dex j runs over the Nc elements in the mass vector,
M . The factor δx in equation (35) is just the differ-
ence (in radians) between the x position in the arc (or
x of pixel θi) and the x position of the cell j in the
mass grid (δx = θx(i) − θ′
x(j)). Similarly we can define
δy = θy(i) − θ′
y. Also, for Υy we
only have to change δx by δy. Since we include the fac-
tor 1015M⊙ in λ (see equation 36), the mass vector M
in equation 4 will be given in 1015 h−1 M⊙ units. The
h−1 dependency comes from the fact that in λ we have
the ratio Dls/(DlDs) which goes as h. Also we calcu-
late Υx and Υy separately, the final Υ matrix entering
in equation 4 contains both, Υx and Υy (the same holds
for the vectors β and θ). One can rearrange the x and
y components in any order.
x + δ2
The structure of the Γ matrix is identical to the
matrix Υ but with the difference that it has 2Ns ad-
ditional columns (the location of the extra-columns is
irrelevant as long as it is consistent with the location of
the 2Ns βo unknowns in the X vector). Is easy to see
that each one of these extra columns (with dimension
2 ∗ Nθ) corresponds to one of the Ns sources. Since the
Γ matrix has to contain both the x and y component,
the first/second half of each one of the extra columns
will be all 0's depending on if it corresponds to the y/x
component of Bo. The other half will be full of 0's and
1's, the 1's being in the positions associated with that
particular source, the 0's elsewhere. That is, the lens
equation can be written explicitly as (a denotes matrix
and ~a denotes vector);
(cid:18) ~θx
~θy (cid:19) = (cid:18) Υx 1 0
Υy 0 1 (cid:19)
~M
~βx
o
~βy
o
(37)
Where again, ~θx and ~θy are two Nθ dimensional vectors
containing the x and y positions, respectively, of the
pixels in the observed arcs. The two (Nθ × Nc matrices
Υx and Υy contain the x and y lensing effect of the cell
j on the θ pixel i. The Nθ × Ns dimensional matrices
1 and 0 are full of 0's (the 0 matrix) or contain 1's
(the 1 matrix) in the i positions (i ∈ [1, Nθ]) where
the ith θ pixel comes from the j source (j ∈ [1, Ns])
and 0 elsewhere. The vector ~M contains the Nc gridded
masses we want to estimate. ~βx
o contains the central x
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 16
|
astro-ph/0507396 | 1 | 0507 | 2005-07-18T04:30:26 | GALEX Observations of an Energetic Ultraviolet Flare on the dM4e Star GJ 3685A | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Galaxy Evolution Explorer (GALEX) satellite has obtained high time resolution ultraviolet photometry during a large flare on the M4 dwarf star GJ 3685A. Simultaneous NUV (1750 - 2800A) and FUV (1350 - 1750A) time-tagged photometry with time resolution better than 0.1 s shows that the overall brightness in the FUV band increased by a factor of 1000 in 200 s. Under the assumption that the NUV emission is mostly due to a stellar continuum, and that the FUV flux is shared equally between emission lines and continuum, then there is evidence for two distinct flare components for this event. The first flare type is characterized by an exponential increase in flux with little or no increase in temperature. The other involves rapid increases in both temperature and flux. While the decay time for the first flare component may be several hours, the second flare event decayed over less than 1 minute, suggesting that there was little or no confinement of the heated plasma. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astrophysical Journal accepted, 2005 July 11
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 6/22/04
GALEX OBSERVATIONS OF AN ENERGETIC ULTRAVIOLET FLARE ON THE DM4E STAR GJ 3685A
Richard D. Robinson,1 Jonathan M. Wheatley,2 Barry Y. Welsh,2 Karl Forster,3 Patrick Morrissey,3 Mark
Seibert,3 R. Michael Rich,4 Samir Salim,4 Tom A. Barlow,3 Luciana Bianchi,5 Yong-Ik Byun,6 Jose Donas,7
Peter G. Friedman,3 Timothy M. Heckman,5 Patrick N. Jelinsky,2 Young-Wook Lee,6 Barry F. Madore,8
Roger F. Malina,7 D. Christopher Martin,3 Bruno Milliard,7 Susan G. Neff,9 David Schiminovich,3 Oswald H.
W. Siegmund,2 Todd Small,3 Alex S. Szalay,5 and Ted K. Wyder3
5
0
0
2
l
u
J
8
1
1
v
6
9
3
7
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Astrophysical Journal accepted, 2005 July 11
ABSTRACT
The Galaxy Evolution Explorer (GALEX ) satellite has obtained high time resolution ultraviolet
photometry during a large flare on the M4 dwarf star GJ 3685A. Simultaneous NUV (1750 - 2800 A)
and FUV (1350 - 1750 A) time-tagged photometry with time resolution better than 0.1 s shows that
the overall brightness in the FUV band increased by a factor of 1000 in 200 s. Under the assumption
that the NUV emission is mostly due to a stellar continuum, and that the FUV flux is shared equally
between emission lines and continuum, then there is evidence for two distinct flare components for
this event. The first flare type is characterized by an exponential increase in flux with little or no
increase in temperature. The other involves rapid increases in both temperature and flux. While the
decay time for the first flare component may be several hours, the second flare event decayed over less
than 1 minute, suggesting that there was little or no confinement of the heated plasma.
Subject headings: stars: flare -- stars: late-type -- stars: individual (GJ 3685A) -- stars: variables:
other (UV Ceti) -- ultraviolet: stars
1. INTRODUCTION
UV Ceti stars exhibit many of the activity phenom-
ena observed on the Sun, such as flares, dark spots
and variable emission from the chromosphere and corona
(Thomas & Weiss 2004). Such surface activity is linked
to their magnetic field strength and surface coverage,
which can be several times larger than that found on
the Sun. When quiescent, UV Ceti flare stars are low
luminosity (MV > 8),
low temperature (T = 2500 -
4000 K) M-type dwarfs. During outbursts, these stars
brighten dramatically over timescales of a few sec-
onds to hours at all wavelengths from X-ray to radio
(Haisch, Strong, & Rodono 1991).
The vast majority of stellar flare observations involve
photometric monitoring using the Johnson UBV filters
(Lacy et al. 1976). Normally this involves high speed
sampling using a single transmission filter. Occasionally,
however, observations are obtained in multiple filters by
sequencing using time steps of a few seconds to about 1
minute. This technique has the advantage of obtaining
1 Institute for Astrophysics and Computational Sciences,
Catholic University of America, 200 Hannan Hall, Washington,
DC 20064; [email protected]
2 Experimental Astrophysics Group, Space Sciences Labora-
tory, University of California, 7 Gauss Way, Berkeley, CA 94720;
[email protected], [email protected]
3 California Institute of Technology, MC 405-47, 1200 East Cal-
ifornia Boulevard, Pasadena, CA 91125
4 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Califor-
nia, Los Angeles, CA 90095
5 Center for Astrophysical Sciences, The Johns Hopkins Univer-
sity, 3400 N. Charles St., Baltimore, MD 21218
6 Center for Space Astrophysics, Yonsei University, Seoul 120-
749, Korea
7 Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Marseille, BP 8, Traverse du
Siphon, 13376 Marseille Cedex 12, France
8 Observatories of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, 813
Santa Barbara St., Pasadena, CA 91101
9 Laboratory for Astronomy and Solar Physics, NASA Goddard
Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD 20771
flare colors, allowing estimates of temperatures and sizes,
and is reasonably valid during the long duration decay
phase of the events. However, during the impulsive phase
the fluxes can change on time scales of seconds, so the
color data becomes highly uncertain. A second limitation
is that the flare energy distribution peaks at wavelengths
shorter than 4000A (van den Oord et al. 1996), so that
the Johnson photometry only samples the wing of this
distribution, which is contaminated by the stellar photo-
sphere.
The GALEX satellite (Martin et al. 2005) provides the
opportunity for obtaining vastly improved photometric
measurements of stellar flares. Using a dichroic beam
splitter and two photon counting detectors, this telescope
is able to simultaneously monitor a 1.25o field of view
in the FUV (1350 - 1750 A) and NUV (1750 - 2800A)
regions with 5 arcsec and 6.5 arcsec angular resolution
respectively. This allows the accurate determination of
UV fluxes and colors at a time resolution which is lim-
ited only by the count rate and the required S/N values.
In this paper we describe a serendipitous observation of
a large flare seen by the GALEX telescope on the dM4e
star GJ 3685A. Some of the physical properties of this
event are discussed and we develop a schematic model
which is compared with models developed from other
flare observations.
2. OBSERVATIONS AND DATA REDUCTION
The flare event on GJ 3685A was detected on 2004
April 20 during a simultaneous FUV and NUV ob-
servation of the Medium Imaging Survey (MIS) field
MISDR1 13062 0283. The exposure began at 19:42:06
UT and lasted for 1244s. At present, the standard
GALEX Data Analysis Pipeline is only designed to pro-
duce a calibrated image of the field and thus does not
retain timing information. To construct a photometric
time sequence, we began with the original time-tagged
2
ROBINSON, et al.
photon lists and integrated all photons within a 1.8 ar-
cmin aperture centered on the source. The background
count rate was measured within an annulus extending
from 1.8 to 2.4 arcmin around the star, during the first
500 s of the observation, in order to avoid contamination
by scattered light when the flare was at its brightest. The
FUV and NUV background rates are 3.2 cts s−1 and 38.5
cts s−1, respectively.
The GALEX microchannel plate detectors exhibit a lo-
cal non-linearity of 10% affecting point sources with in-
put count rates of 90 cts s−1 in FUV and 470 cts s−1 in
NUV (Morrissey et al. 2005). In this paper, we use Mor-
rissey's published local non-linearity corrections, which
have been calibrated with white dwarf standard stars up
to 3300 cts s−1 in FUV and 8400 cts s−1 in NUV. The GJ
3685A flare exceeded this calibrated range in the FUV
for a few seconds during the brightest parts of the flare:
we have omitted these data from the analysis because
the uncertainty in the true count rate is unknown in this
high count-rate regime.
The results of the analysis are given in Figure 1, which
shows both the flux variations and the ratio of the FUV
to NUV fluxes. In these plots the photon count rates have
been converted to fluxes (in erg cm−2 s−1 A−1) using
the conversion factors of 1.4 × 10−15 and 2.6 × 10−16 for
the FUV and NUV, respectively (Morrissey et al. 2005).
Initially, the star showed a 'quiescent' flux of ∼ 10−15 erg
cm−2 s−1 A−1 and a flux ratio (or color) of 1. The start
of the stellar flare is lost in the noise of the background.
A reasonable estimate seems to put the start somewhere
between 450 and 500 s and it is definitely underway in
both the NUV and FUV bands by 500 s. Between 500 s
and 630 s the flux in both bands increases exponentially,
with an e-folding time of ∼60 s. During this time the
average color remains constant, at a value of near 0.8.
At 650 s the rate of flux increase jumps dramatically,
with e-folding times of 23 s in the NUV and 12 s in the
FUV, and the FUV/NUV ratio increases from < 1 to
more than 6. Both temperature and FUV/NUV ratio
reach a peak at 700 s. During this peak period, we have
omitted the data because the FUV non-linearity correc-
tion is uncertain.
After the peak, which only lasts for about 20 s, the
flux and FUV/NUV ratio rapidly decrease. Note that
the time variations of both the color and the flux for the
100 s centered at the flare peak are symmetrical about
the peak, i.e. the rise times and decay times are about
the same. By 750 s the color ratio is again near 1 and
the flux settles into a slow decline which is interrupted
at 865 s by a second flux enhancement. This second en-
hancement is somewhat more complicated than the first,
but follows the same basic trend of rapid flux increase ac-
companied by a rapid increase in FUV/NUV, this time
to values in excess of 10. The decay phase for the second
enhancement is slower and more complex than was the
case for the first enhancement. By the end of the obser-
vation the flux and color had returned to the levels seen
prior to the second enhancement, though the flux is still
well above the 'quiescent' level.
3. ANALYSIS
3.1. Pre-flare Activity
On 2004 March 2 GALEX obtained a 110 sec 'qui-
escent' observation of GJ 3685A which showed a flux of
1.7 ± 0.5 × 10−16 erg cm−2 s−1 A−1 in the FUV and
3.0 ± 0.3 × 10−16 erg cm−2 s−1 A−1 in the NUV, giv-
ing a color ratio of 0.57 ± 0.19. On 20 April, before
the onset of the flare event the average 'quiescent' flux
was 1.54 × 10−15 erg cm−2 s−1 A−1 in the NUV and
1.52 × 10−15 erg cm−2 s−1 A−1 in the FUV band, result-
ing in a flux ratio of 1. Since the FUV/NUV flux ratio
is directly related to the effective emission temperature
(see section 3.2) we see that preceding the flare the stel-
lar emission had not only increased in flux by a factor of
5 in the NUV, but also increased in temperature.
One possible explanation is that the pre-flare enhance-
ment results from an increased level of microflaring ac-
tivity. To test this notion, we performed an analysis on
the first 400 s of the data set using the binning tech-
nique described by Robinson et al. (1995, 1999).
Indi-
vidual microflares can be detected by binning the time
sequence and searching for times when the counts per bin
are significantly higher than those expected from random
chance. The maximum visibility occurs when the binning
factor is near the lifetime of the event.
A distribution of small events which are not individ-
ually time resolvable can be determined by comparing
the distribution of count rates with a reference distribu-
tion from a non-variable source, as described in Robinson
(1999). This method reveals that when the binning fac-
tor is much smaller than the flare lifetime, then event
noise will dominate and both distributions will be Pois-
son. However, as the binning factor approaches the flare
lifetime, the microflares show up as an enhancement of
the high count rate tail of the distribution.
Examining the time sequences for binning factors rang-
ing from 1 s to 20 s for the GJ 3685A flare data shows
no strong evidence for either individual or unresolved
flare events, while a regression analysis showed that the
level of activity remained statistically constant prior to
flare onset. A problem, however, is that the background
levels are large compared to the stellar signal. For ex-
ample, in the NUV the estimated background is 38.5
counts s−1, while the stellar signal was only 7.5 counts
s−1. Thus, noise from the background would swamp all
but the largest microflare events.
3.2. Empirical Modeling
Since we have no spectroscopic information about
this flare it is not possible to perform any type of
detailed modeling or radiative transfer calculations on
these UV data. However, some good qualitative and
semi-quantitative insights can be obtained by assuming
black-body emission. The reader should be aware that
this assumed model is only one of several possible flare
model scenarios. However, this simple theoretical ap-
proach has been widely used in the interpretation of op-
tical photometry of flare events and yielded some impor-
tant insights into flare phenomena (Kahler et al. 1982;
van den Oord et al. 1996; Hawley et al. 2003). We have
a definite advantage in these UV observations since the
photospheric emission from the star is so small that it
can be neglected.
The first step in our simplified analysis is to determine
the relation between the black body temperature and
the measured FUV/NUV flux ratio. We have calculated
the black body spectrum for a number of different tem-
peratures, multiplied by the effective area curves for the
GALEX Ultraviolet Flare
3
GALEX FUV and NUV filters and then divided by the
total effective area for each filter. This gives the expected
flux for a black body, which can be directly related to the
average flux deduced from the measured count rates. The
relation between temperature and flux ratio is shown in
Figure 2. Note that the flux ratio increases dramatically
between 4000 and 19000 K (when the peak of the black
body distribution falls within the FUV bandpass) and
then increases much more slowly toward high tempera-
tures. The ratio eventually reaches a value of just over
3 at temperatures of 50,000 K. This immediately shows
that our black-body assumption is not totally valid, since
we measured ratios during the flare peaks in excess of 6.
This is not a surprise, since the FUV wavelength region
has numerous strong emission lines (e.g. C II, C IV, Si II,
Si IV, etc) which can dominate the continuum, especially
during 'quiescent' periods outside of major flare events
(van den Oord et al. 1996).
Assessing the relative contributions from continuum
and/or emission lines at near UV wavelengths is still an
open problem for flare research (Hawley & Fisher 1992).
We note that the GALEX NUV channel is not signifi-
cantly contaminated by the (expected) strong MgII emis-
sion lines at 2800A due to the low transmission of the
GALEX NUV instrument at this wavelength. However,
previous flares have shown an (albeit far less) increase
in the NUV emission from the FeII line multiplet at
2600A (Haisch et al. 1987), whereas Butler et al. (1981)
have observed a significant rise in the near UV contin-
uum during a flare on the star Gl 867A. For the present
case of the flare on GJ 3685A, it is difficult to imagine
how line emission could be the sole major contributor
to the more than 5 UV magnitude increase in NUV flux
observed during the flare. Thus, in determining the effec-
tive temperature from the FUV/NUV flux ratio, we ar-
bitrarily assume that approximately half of the FUV flux
was from emission lines and the other half from black-
body emission. This is consistent with the time-resolved
spectroscopy of Hawley et al. (2003), where the FUV
line-to-continuum flux ratio is 0.8, during the brightest
flare on AD Leo reported in that paper. Furthermore,
Hawley & Fisher (1992) also provide support for the no-
tion that the GALEX NUV band is dominated by the
star's continuum.
A black body of given temperature has a well de-
fined emission. Thus, having determined a temper-
ature we can define the effective stellar surface cov-
erage required to produce the observed NUV flux at
the earth, assuming a distance to the star of 14.6 pc
(Astronomisches Rechen-Institut 1998). The results of
the calculations are presented in Figure 3, where we have
converted the flare surface area to an effective source ra-
dius. The calculated temperature in the pre-flare phase
was about 12,000 K with a deduced scale of about 3500
km. The exact values are uncertain because this phase is
dominated by the emission lines in the FUV and the ac-
tual structure is most likely composed of small elements
spread over a large area. When the flare starts the ef-
fective temperature drops to about 10,000 K and the
radius increases linearly from 3,500 km at 500 s to about
25,000 km at 650 s, suggesting an initial expansion ve-
locity of at least 140 km s−1. The deduced temperature
increases dramatically at 660 s, becomes undefined near
the flare peak and then rapidly decreases back to a value
of about 10,000 K. During this time the deduced radius
decreases to 7,000 km and then increases back to 25,000-
28,000 km, about the same value as that seen before the
large temperature increase. The temperature and area
then remain relatively constant until the start of the sec-
ond temperature enhancement at 880 s, where the area
again dramatically decreases and then slowly recovers to
a value of about 32,000 km.
Having estimated a temperature and area for the flare
it is possible to determine the total optical and UV en-
ergy by integrating under the appropriate black body
curve. The result of this calculation is shown in the Fig-
ure 4. The overall appearance of this event is two short
duration bursts at 670-730 s and 880-970 s superimposed
on a more slowly varying event which started at 450 s and
which was slowly decaying at the end of the observation.
The flare is obviously very energetic, with luminosities
reaching more than 1032 erg s−1 and a total integrated
energy in excess of 1034 erg. This is comparable to the
largest recorded M-dwarf flare outbursts, such as the
1985 flare on the star AD Leonis (Hawley & Petterson
1991). Another way to put this into perspective is to
note that the total (optical plus UV) luminosity emit-
ted from the photosphere of a M4 star is on the order
of 2.0 × 1031 erg s−1. Thus, at the peak the flare would
outshine the star by more than a factor of 10.
4. DISCUSSION
Assuming that our black body emission model dis-
cussed in Section 3.2 provides a reasonable description
of the flare event on GJ 3685A (and given the caveat
that there may be other models that can provide an al-
ternate interpretation of the data that we have chosen
not to explore due to the lack of spectroscopic informa-
tion on this flare), we can now postulate a schematic
model for the event which satisfies all of the observa-
tions and is consistent with observations of flares seen
on other stars. The flare itself appears to be composed
of two distinct types of events, which we will refer to
as type A and type B. The flare begins with a type
A event, which is characterized by a FUV/NUV flux
ratio that is nearly the same as that seen in the pre-
flare activity (plage) and remains constant as the flux
increases. We conclude that the spectrum has a very
plage-like appearance and that the source structure, and
possibly the heating processes, are also very plage-like.
We postulate that this phase was initiated by a mag-
netic reconnection somewhere within a highly stressed
active region. This initial energy release triggers recon-
nection events in adjacent magnetic structures, leading
to an avalanche (Lu & Hamilton 1991; Carbonneau et al.
2001) which propagates throughout the region at a veloc-
ity of at least 140 km s−1, which probably represents the
local Alfven velocity. The increase in flux is then simply
the result of expanding area coverage.
At about 670 s (roughly 3 minutes after the start
of the flare) the disturbance which is responsible for
flare A intersects a highly unstable magnetic structure
and triggers an explosive release of energy, resulting in
the first type B flare (B1), which occurs between 670
s and about 730 s. The rapid increase in temperature
and flux is compatible with a chromospheric evapora-
tion model (Haisch, Strong, & Rodono 1991), in which a
4
ROBINSON, et al.
large amount of energy (probably in the form of energetic
particles) is suddenly released near the top of a magnetic
loop complex and propagates down towards the photo-
sphere. When it strikes the denser atmospheric layers
it impulsively heats the material, which then expands
back into the loop. Normally, this type of event will
have a long lasting decay as the heated material cools
through conduction and radiation. In this case, however,
the short duration of the decay suggests that the energy
release was sufficient to cause a disruption of the confin-
ing loops (Reale, Bocchino, & Peres 2002). The source
size for flare B1 is also significantly smaller than that
of flare A, since the deduced flare area decreases rapidly
when the emission from B1 dominates that from flare A.
The structure responsible for flare B1 is probably near
the edge of the active region associated with flare A, since
the expansion of flare A ends during flare B1. Appar-
ently, all of the available structures which can support
flare A emission have been activated by that time.
It
is possible that the disturbance responsible for flare A
could continue into regions outside of the initial active
region. More likely, the energy release initiating flare B1
also generated an Alfvenic shock, similar to the Morton
waves seen on the Sun (Athay & Morton 1961). This dis-
turbance propagates to an unstable magnetic structure
in a nearby active region and triggers a second B type
flare (flare B2) which starts at around 880 s. This flare
is both stronger and more complex than B1, indicating
more complex field configuration. It also shows a better
developed thermal decay, implying that at least some of
the hot plasma is confined in the loops. Note also that
this is an isolated event, without an accompanying type
A event, since there was no increase in source size prior
to the onset of the temperature enhancement.
By the end of the observation it appears that flare B2
has completely faded and flare A is again visible. Un-
fortunately, we do not have much information about the
decay phase of flare A. However, from the fact that the
integrated flux at the end of the observation at 1250 s is
very similar to that at 800 s, after the decay of flare B1,
suggests that it may take an hour or more for flare A to
decay to pre-flare levels.
5. CONCLUSIONS
We report on a large flare from the dM4e star
GJ 3685A which was simultaneously observed in the
NUV and FUV by the GALEX satellite. Under the as-
sumption of a blackbody emission model in which half
of the FUV flux arises from line emission and half from
continuum, and that the NUV flux arises solely from an
increase in the continuum, there is strong evidence for
two distinct classes of flares during this event. The first
(type A) is characterized by an exponential increase in
flux with little of no change in emission temperature, as
measured from the FUV/NUV flux ratio. This behavior
is compatible with an avalanche model. The fact that
the flux ratio during this phase was very similar to that
seen in the pre-flare plage emission also supports the idea
that plages are heated by microflares, as first proposed
by (Parker 1988).
The second class (type B) is characterized by an impul-
sive increase in both flux and temperature. This class is
consistent with a classical explosive event and may be re-
lated to the solar two ribbon flare. Two flares of this type
were seen during the event. The first (flare B1) probably
originated in the same active region as the type A flare.
The lack of a well developed decay phase suggests that
the confining magnetic structure was disrupted. The sec-
ond flare (B2) may have originated outside of that region,
being triggered by a disturbance formed during the flare
B1 energy release.
The 2004 April 20 flare began when GJ 3685A was al-
ready in a state of enhanced activity in which both the
flux and temperature are substantially higher than in a
previous GALEX observation on 2004 March 2. It is un-
clear whether this enhancement is the result of coronal
variations, or arises from the rotation of an intense active
region onto the visible surface of the star, or if it comes
from some pre-flare energy release.
In order to obtain
better models of future dMe star flare events we recom-
mend using the low-resolution spectroscopic grism mode
of GALEX, instead of the imaging photometric mode.
Such future observations would provide better insights
into the relative contributions from the UV continuum
and/or line emission during these large releases of stellar
energy.
GALEX is a NASA Small Explorer, launched in 2003
April. We gratefully acknowledge NASA's support for
construction, operation, and science analysis for the
GALEX mission. Financial support for this research was
provided by NASA grant NAS5-98034.
REFERENCES
Astronomisches Rechen-Institut 1998, ARI Database for Nearby
Stars. http://www.ari.uni-heidelberg.de/aricns
Athay, R.G., & Morton, G.E. 1961, 133, 935
Butler, C.J., et al. 1981, MNRAS, 197, 815
Carbonneau, P., McIntosh, S.W., Liu, H-L, & Bogdan, T.J. 2001,
Solar Physics, 203, 321
Gliese, W., & Jahreiss, H. 1991, Preliminary Version of the Third
Catalogue of Nearby Stars. Greenbelt, MD: Goddard Space
Flight Center
Haisch, B., et al. 1987, A&A, 181, 96
Haisch, B., Strong, K., & Rodono, M. 1991, ARA&A, 29, 275
Hawley, S.L., & Fisher, G.H. 1992, ApJS, 78, 565
Hawley, S.L., & Petterson, B.R. 1991, ApJ, 378, 725
Hawley, S.L., et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, 535
Kahler, S., et al., ApJ, 252, 239
Lacy, C.H., Moffett, T.J., & Evans, D.S. 1976, ApJS, 30, 85
Lu, E.T., & Hamilton, R. 1991, ApJ, 380, L89
Martin, D.C., et al. 2005, ApJ, 619, L1
Morrissey, P., et al. 2005, ApJ, 619, L7
Nakajima, H., Dennis, B.R., Hoyng, P., Nelson, G., Kosugi, T., &
Kai, K. 1986, ApJ, 288, 806
Parker, E.N. 1988, ApJ, 330, 474
Reale, E., Bocchino, F., & Peres, G. 2002, A&A,383, 952
Robinson, R.D., Carpenter, K.G., Percival, J.W., & Bookbinder,
J.A. 1995, ApJ, 451, 795
Robinson, R.D., Carpenter, K.G., & Percival, J.W., 1999, ApJ,
516, 916
Thomas, J.H., & Weiss, N.O. 2004, ARA&A, 42, 517
van den Oord, G.H.J., et al. 1996, A&A, 310, 908
GALEX Ultraviolet Flare
5
Fig. 1. -- (Top) Ratio of FUV to NUV fluxes. In this and all other figures, data are omitted during the time intervals in which the
FUV count rate exceeds the maximum calibrated count rate of 3300 cts s−1. (Bottom) Calibrated fluxes from the GALEX FUV (solid)
and NUV (dashed) channels for the entire observation of 2004 April 20. Data have been binned into 25 s intervals for 0-450 s, 5 s intervals
between 450 and 630 s and 1 s intervals for times greater than 630 s.
6
ROBINSON, et al.
Fig. 2. -- Relation between black body temperature and the FUV/NUV flux ratio determined by convolving the appropriate black body
distribution with the GALEX FUV and NUV filter effective area curves.
GALEX Ultraviolet Flare
7
Fig. 3. -- (a) Effective black body temperatures derived from the measured FUV/NUV flux ratio using the calibration presented in
Figure 2. Preflare activity has been estimated using an integration over the first 400 s. Data between 400 s and 630 s is deduced using 5 s
bins, while later data uses 1 s bins. (b) Effective radius of the source deduced from the observed flux, as described in the text. Data for
the first 630 s has been binned into 5 s intervals, later data has been binned into 1 s increments. (c) Measured FUV flux, binning as in (b).
8
ROBINSON, et al.
Fig. 4. -- Estimated luminosity, assuming black body emission at the temperature and source size presented in Figure 3.
|
astro-ph/0302521 | 1 | 0302 | 2003-02-25T15:38:33 | Angular momentum redistribution and the evolution and morphology of bars | [
"astro-ph"
] | Angular momentum exchange is a driving process for the evolution of barred galaxies. Material at resonance in the bar region loses angular momentum which is taken by material at resonance in the outer disc and/or the halo. By losing angular momentum, the bar grows stronger and slows down. This evolution scenario is backed by both analytical calculations and by $N$-body simulations. The morphology of the bar also depends on the amount of angular momentum exchanged. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Angular momentum redistribution and the
evolution and morphology of bars
E. Athanassoula1
Observatoire de Marseille, 2 Place Le Verrier, 13248 Marseille cedex 04, France
Abstract. Angular momentum exchange is a driving process for the evolution of
barred galaxies. Material at resonance in the bar region loses angular momentum which
is taken by material at resonance in the outer disc and/or the halo. By losing angular
momentum, the bar grows stronger and slows down. This evolution scenario is backed
by both analytical calculations and by N -body simulations. The morphology of the bar
also depends on the amount of angular momentum exchanged.
1
Introduction
Bars are common features of disc galaxies. De Vaucouleurs ([11]), using a classi-
fication based on images at optical wavelengths, found that roughly one third of
all disc galaxies are barred (family SB), while yet another third have small bars
or ovals (family SAB). Observations in the near infrared have shown that galax-
ies that had been classified as non-barred from images at optical wavelengths
may have a clear bar component when observed in the near infrared. Thus Es-
kridge et al. ([17]) classified more than 70% of all disc galaxies as barred, while
Grosbøl, Pompei & Patsis ([18]) found that only ∼ 5% of all disc galaxies are
definitely non barred.
Bars come in a large variety of strengths, lengths, masses, axial ratios and
shapes. Great efforts have been made in order to obtain some systematics on bar
structure and important advances have been made. Elmegreen & Elmegreen ([16])
have shown that earlier type bars are relatively longer (i.e. relative to the disc
diameter) on average than bars in later type galaxies. They also find that early
type bars have flat intensity profiles along the bar major axis, while late type
bars have exponential-like profiles. A correlation has been found ([5], [27]) be-
tween the length of bars and the size of bulges. This is in good agreement with
the trend found in [16], since earlier type galaxies have larger bulges than late
types. Important differences between early and late type bars are also found with
the Fourier decomposition of the surface density. Indeed the relative m = 2 and
4 components are much stronger in early than in late type bars. Moreover, the
higher order components (m = 6 and 8), which for the late type bars are negligi-
ble, are still important for early types. Finally, the shape of the bar isodensities
differ and Athanassoula et al. ([7]), using a sample of strongly barred early type
galaxies, showed that their bar isophotes are rectangular-like, particularly in the
region near the end of the bar.
The first trials of N -body simulations (e.g. [28]) show that bars grow sponta-
neously and are long-lived. Yet it is only recently that simulations have achieved
2
E. Athanassoula
sufficient quality to provide information on the morphology of N -body bars and
on the mechanisms that govern bar formation and bar evolution. I will here dis-
cuss some of the latest results of N -body simulations. I will argue that it is the
exchange of angular momentum within the galaxy that will determine the bar
strength and the rate at which the pattern speed decreases after the bar has
formed, as well as the bar morphology.
2 Angular momentum exchange and bar evolution
Exchange of energy and angular momentum between stars at resonance with
a spiral density wave has been first discussed by Lynden-Bell & Kalnajs ([26]).
Using linear perturbation theory, these authors showed that, for a steady forcing,
stars emit, or absorb, angular momentum only if they are at resonance. Stars
at the inner Lindblad resonance (hereafter ILR) lose angular momentum, while
stars at the outer Lindblad resonance (hereafter OLR) gain it. This ground-
braking work has to be extended in order to be applied to bars in general and
N -body bars in particular. HI observations, basically starting with [10], have
now established that, if Newton's law of gravity is valid, then disc galaxies are
embedded in a dark matter component, called the halo, whose mass exceeds that
of the disc. This component should now be taken into account as an extra partner
in the angular momentum exchange process. Furthermore, bars are strongly
non-linear features, since they contain a large fraction of the mass in the inner
parts of the disc and a considerable part of the total disc mass. Thus any linear
theory should be thought of as a guiding line, to be supplemented by and tested
against adequate N -body simulations. It is obvious that such simulations should
be fully self-consistent, since rigid components can not exchange energy and
angular momentum.
In [4] I extended the analytical work of [26] to include spheroidal components,
like a halo and/or a bulge, and also supplemented it with fully self-consistent
N -body simulations. In the analytical part I showed that, if the distribution
function of the spheroidal component is a function only of the energy, then at
all resonances the halo and bulge particles can only gain angular momentum.
Also, since the bar is a strongly nonlinear feature, higher multiplicity resonances
should be taken into account. Thus angular momentum is emitted by particles
(stars) at the resonances in the inner disc, mainly the ILR, but also the inner
-1:m resonances nearer to corotation (hereafter CR). It is absorbed by disc par-
ticles (stars) at the OLR, or the outer 1:m resonances, outside corotation, or by
the resonant particles in the halo and/or bulge components. Since the bar is a
negative angular momentum perturbation ([26]), by losing angular momentum
it will grow. This clearly outlines a scenario for the evolution of barred galaxies.
3 The effect of the halo on bar evolution
As the bar loses angular momentum, it grows stronger. This, however, can only
happen if there are absorbers that can absorb the angular momentum that the
Evolution and morphology of bars
3
Fig. 1. Basic information on simulations LH (time t = 600) and RH (time t = 900).
The two upper rows give the circular velocity curves at time 0 and t. The dashed and
dotted lines give the contributions of the disc and halo respectively, while the thick full
lines give the total circular velocity curves. The third row of panels gives the isocontours
of the density of the disc particles projected face-on and the fourth and fifth row give
the side-on and end-on edge-on views, respectively. The side of the box for the face-on
views is 10 length units and the height of the box for the edge-on views is 3.33. The
isodensities in the third row of panels have been chosen so as to show best the features
in the bar and in the inner disc. No isodensities for the outer disc have been included,
although the disc extends beyond the area shown in the figure. The sixth row of panels
gives the m = 2, 4, 6, and 8 Fourier components of the mass.
bar region emits. Thus the existence of a massive halo component, whose res-
onances can absorb considerable amounts of angular momentum, will help the
bar grow. At first sight this may be thought to go against old claims that haloes
stabilise bars. In fact, a more precise wording is necessary. Indeed, the halo
slows down the bar growth in the initial stages of the evolution. At later stages,
however, the situation can be reversed, since the halo may absorb the angular
4
E. Athanassoula
momentum emitted by the bar, and thus it may allow the latter to grow further.
Thus bars that grow in halo-dominated discs can be stronger than bars that
grow in disc-dominated surroundings. This effect was not seen till recently, since
the older studies were either 2D (e.g. [33], [8]), or 3D but with few particles (e.g.
[31]), or had rigid haloes. In all these cases the halo was denied from the onset
its destabilising influence. Its effect becomes clear in fully self-consistent N -body
simulations, with an adequate particle number and resolution. Thus [6] showed
that stronger bars can grow in cases with more important halo components.
The influence of the halo is also illustrated in Fig. 1, where I compare the
results of two N -body simulations. Initially their disc is exponential, with unit
mass and scale-length (Md = 1, Rd = 1) and its Q parameter ([32]) is independent
of radius and equal to 1.2. Since G = 1, taking the mass of the disc equal to 5 ×
1010 M⊙, and its scale-length equal to 3.5 kpc implies that the unit of velocity is
248 km/sec and the unit of time is 1.4 × 107 yrs. This calibration is reasonable,
but is not unique, so in the following I will give all quantities in computer
units. The reader can then convert the values to astronomical units according to
his/her needs. The halo component is spherical, non-rotating and has an isotropic
velocity distribution. It follows a pseudo-isothermal radial density profile ([19])
and has a total mass Mh = 5, a core radius γ = 0.5 and a cutoff radius of rc = 10.
Its density is truncated at 15 disc scale-lengths, i.e. at a radius containing more
than 96% of its mass. In building the initial conditions I loosely followed [19]
and [6], and the simulations were run on the Marseille GRAPE-5 systems (for a
description of the GRAPE-5 boards see [22]). The only difference between the
initial conditions of the two simulations is that for simulation LH, illustrated in
the left panels, the halo is live and represented by roughly 106 particles, while for
simulation RH, illustrated in the right panels, it is rigid, i.e. represented by an
analytical potential and thus can neither emit nor absorb angular momentum.
Although their initial conditions are so similar, the two simulations evolve in
a very different way. After some initial multi-spiral episodes, LH forms a bar
which grows stronger with time. Its morphology at t = 700 is shown in the left
panels. The bar is long and strong and has ansae-type features near the end of
its major axis. It is surrounded by a ring, which can be compared to the inner
rings often observed in barred galaxies. The bar formation entails considerable
redistribution of the disc matter, both radially and azimuthally. On the other
hand the disc in simulation RH stays close to axisymmetric, except for some
multi-armed spirals which die out with time. Only at the latest stages of the
evolution does it form an oval distortion, and even that is weak and short and is
confined to the innermost parts of the disc, as can be seen for t = 900 in the right
panels of Fig. 1. I show this simulation at a later time than that for simulation
LH because at earlier times there is very little structure visible.
Seen edge-on with the bar seen side-on (i.e. with the line of sight along the
bar minor axis), simulation LH exhibits a very strong peanut, which is totally
absent from simulation RH (fourth row of panels). Seen edge-on with the bar
seen end-on (i.e. with the line of sight along the bar major axis), the peanut
in LH resembles a bulge (left panel on fifth row). This underlines the hazards
Evolution and morphology of bars
5
involved in classifying edge-on galaxies, since the classifier may in such cases
easily misinterpret the bar for a bulge.
A useful way of quantifying the bar strength is with the help of the Fourier
components of the mass, or density. These can be defined as
Fm(r) = pA2
m(r) + B 2
m(r)/A0(r),
m = 0, 1, 2, .....
(1)
Am(r) =
1
π Z 2π
0
Σ(r, θ)cos(mθ)dθ,
m = 0, 1, 2, .....
(2)
where
and
Bm(r) =
1
π Z 2π
0
Σ(r, θ)sin(mθ)dθ,
m = 1, 2, .....
(3)
For runs LH and RH, these components for m = 2, 4, 6 and 8 are shown in
the lower panels of Fig. 1. For run LH all four components are important, due
to the strength of the bar. Their amplitude decreases with increasing m, while
the location of the maximum shifts outwards. On the other hand, for model RH
only the m = 2 component stands out from the noise, but its amplitude is rather
small, smaller than e.g. that of the m = 8 for model LH.
Since the only difference between the initial conditions of models LH and
RH is that the halo of the one is responsive, while that of the other is rigid, we
can conclude that the halo response is crucial for determining the evolution of
barred galaxies.
4 Bar slow-down
Fig. 2. Bar pattern speed of simulation LH as a function of time.
I ran a large number of simulations similar to those described in the previous
sections. I noted that, as it loses angular momentum, the bar grows longer,
6
E. Athanassoula
and more massive, thus stronger. Angular momentum loss, however, is not only
linked to an increase in the bar strength. It is also linked to a slow-down, i.e. to
a decrease of the bar pattern speed Ωp with time. Such a slow-down has indeed
been seen in a number of simulations and has also been predicted analytically
([34], [36], [24], [25], [20], [1], [12], [13]). It can also be seen in Fig. 2, which shows
the run of the bar pattern speed with time for simulation LH, whose morphology
at time t = 700 is shown in the left panels of Fig. 1. Note that the bar slows
down considerably with time.
5 Resonances
In order for haloes to be able to absorb angular momentum, they need to have
a considerable fraction of their mass at resonance. This was shown to be true
in ([2]). I will illustrate it here for model LH. The procedure is the same as
that followed in [2]. I calculate the potential from the mass distribution in the
disc and halo component at time t = 800, by freezing all motion except for the
bar, to which I assign bulk rotation with a pattern speed equal to that found in
the simulation at that time. I then pick at random 100 000 disc and 100 000 halo
particles and, using their positions and velocities as initial conditions, I calculate
their orbits for 40 bar rotations. Using spectral analysis ([9], [23]), I then find
the principal frequencies of these orbits, i.e. the angular velocity Ω, the epicyclic
frequency κ and the vertical frequency κz. An orbit is resonant if there are three
integers l, m and n, such that
Orbits on planar resonances fulfill
lκ + mΩ + nκz = −ωR = mΩp
lκ + mΩ = −ωR = mΩp
(4)
(5)
The ILR corresponds to l = –1 and m = 2, CR to l = 0, and OLR to l = 1 and
m = 2.
The upper panels of Fig. 3 show, for time t = 800, the mass per unit frequency
ratio MR of particles having a given value of the frequency ratio (Ω − Ωp)/κ
as a function of this frequency ratio1. The distribution is not uniform, but has
clear peaks at the location of the main resonances, as was already shown in [2]
and [4]. The highest peak for the disc component is at the ILR, followed by
(−1, 6) and CR. In all simulations with strong bars the ILR peak is strong. The
existence of peaks at other resonances as well as their importance varies from
one run to another and also during the evolution of a given run. For example
the CR peak is, in many other simulations, much stronger than in the example
shown here. For the spheroidal component the highest peak is at CR, followed
by peaks at the ILR, OLR and (−1, 4).
The lower panels show the angular momentum exchanged. For this I calcu-
lated the angular momentum of each particle at time 800 and at time 500, as
1 See [4] for more information on MR and on how it is derived.
Evolution and morphology of bars
7
Fig. 3. The upper panels give, for time t = 800, the mass per unit frequency ratio, MR,
as a function of that ratio. The lower panels give ∆J, the angular momentum gained or
lost by the particles between times 800 and 500, plotted as a function of their frequency
ratio (Ω − Ωp)/κ, calculated at time t = 800. The left panels correspond to the disc
component and the right ones to the halo. The component and the time are written in
the upper left corner of each panel. The vertical dot-dashed lines give the positions of
the main resonances.
described in [4], and plotted the difference as a function of the frequency ratio
of the particle at time 800. It is clear from the figure that disc particles at ILR
and at the (−1, 6) resonance lose angular momentum, while those at CR gain it.
There is a also a general, albeit small, loss of angular momentum from particles
with frequencies between CR and ILR. This could be partly due to particles
trapped around secondary resonances, and partly due to angular momentum
8
E. Athanassoula
taken from particles which are neither resonant, nor near-resonant, but can still
lose a small amount of angular momentum because the bar is growing. The cor-
responding panel for the spheroid is, as expected, more noisy, but shows that
particles at all resonances gain angular momentum. Thus this plot, and similar
ones which I did for other simulations, confirm the analytical results of [4], and
show that the linear results concerning the angular momentum gain or loss by
resonant particles, qualitatively at least, carry over to the strongly nonlinear
regime.
6 What determines the strength of bars and their
slow-down rate?
I have shown in the previous sections that the halo can take angular momentum
from the bar, thus making it stronger and slower. However, for this effect to be
important, the amount of angular momentum exchanged must be considerable.
For the latter to happen the halo must
• be sufficiently massive in the regions containing the principal resonances.
• not be too hot, i.e. not have too high velocity dispersion. Indeed, hot haloes
can not absorb much angular momentum, even if they are massive (e.g. [4]).
Thus the length and the slow-down rate of bars are naturally limited by the
mass and velocity distribution of the halo. Examples of this can be found in [4].
7 Trends and correlations
In [4] I found trends and correlations between the angular momentum absorbed
by the spheroid (i.e. the halo plus, whenever existent, the bulge), the bar strength
and the bar pattern speed. They are based on a set of simulations analogous to
those described in the previous sections. Such plots are given also in Fig. 4, based
on a somewhat larger sample of simulations. About three quarters of them were
run with the Marseille GRAPE-5 systems, and roughly one quarter was run on
PCs using Dehnen's treecode ([14], [15]). Each point represents one simulation
and the trends are the same as those found in [4]. The upper panels show the
results for the whole sample, the middle panels contain only simulations where
the halo has a small core radius (γ < 2), Mh = 5 and does not extended beyond
15 disc scale-lengths, and the lower ones contain only simulations where the halo
has a large core radius (γ > 2), Mh = 5 and again does not extended beyond 15
disc scale-lengths.
The right panel shows that there is a correlation between the angular mo-
mentum of the spheroid and the bar strength. This correlation holds also when I
restrict myself to simulations with large (or small) core radii as seen in the second
and third row. A trend also exists between the spheroid angular momentum and
the bar pattern speed. In this case, however, simulations with large core radii be-
have differently from those with small radii. Indeed, for simulations with a small
Evolution and morphology of bars
9
Fig. 4. Relations between the bar strength and the pattern speed (left panels), the
spheroid angular momentum and the pattern speed (middle panels) and the spheroid
angular momentum and the bar strength (right panels), at times t = 800. The spheroid
angular momentum is normalised by the initial disc angular momentum (Lz,d). The
simulations under consideration in each panel are marked with a filled circle and the
rest by a dot. The upper row includes all simulations, the middle and the lower ones
subsamples, as described in the text. In the middle panel simulations with a bulge are
marked with a ⊕, simulations with γ = 0.01 with a filled star, simulations with 2 > γ ≥
1 with a filled triangle and simulations with Qinit ≥ 2 with an open square. In the
lower panel simulations with Qinit ≥ 1.4 and z0 ≥ 0.2 are marked with an ⊕.
core radius (i.e. centrally concentrated halos) I find a very strong correlation
between the spheroid angular momentum and the pattern speed, particularly if
I restrict myself to one value of γ. In such simulations the angular momentum is
exchanged primarily between the bar region and the spheroid, thus accounting
10
E. Athanassoula
for the very tight correlation. Simulations with large cores behave differently
(lower middle panel). They show only a rough trend, except for simulations with
a hot disc, which show a tight correlation. This is easily explained in the sce-
nario of evolution via angular momentum exchange. The outer parts of hot discs
absorb only little angular momentum, so that the exchange is basically between
the bar region and the spheroid, thus accounting for the tight correlation. On
the other hand, if the outer disc is cold, then it can participate more actively in
the exchange. Since the angular momentum absorbed by the spheroid (plotted
in Fig. 4) is not the total angular momentum exchanged, but only a fraction of
it, I find only a trend.
8 Comparing the morphology of N -body and of real bars
The correlations discussed in section 7 show clearly that models that have ex-
changed more angular momentum have stronger bars than models that have
exchanged little. By examining the results of the individual simulations, I could
see that, in cases where large amounts of angular momentum have been ex-
changed, the bars are long, relatively thin and have rectangular-like isodensities,
particularly in their outer parts. A typical example of such a case is given in
the left panels of Fig. 5 (see also [6]). Note also the existence of ansae at the
ends of the bar, a feature sometimes observed in early type barred galaxies. On
the other hand, models that have exchanged little angular momentum have less
homogeneous properties. For example they can have either ovals, or short bars.
Typical examples of such cases are given in the middle and right panels of Fig. 5,
respectively. The model in the left panel has exchanged about 15 percent of the
disc angular momentum by the time shown in Fig. 5, while the other two models
only of the order of a percent.
The edge-on morphology also is strongly influenced by the amount of angu-
lar momentum exchanged. The strong bar, when seen edge-on, displays a clear
peanut morphology, as often observed. On the other hand the oval has a boxy
edge-on appearance, while the small bar has not changed significantly the edge-
on morphology of the galaxy.
The difference in bar strength is also illustrated in the lower panels of Fig. 5,
which show the relative Fourier components of the density for m = 2, 4, 6 and
8 for the three simulations. The simulation that exchanged a lot of angular
momentum has a very strong m = 2 component, with a secondary maximum
roughly at the position of the ansae. The remaining components, even the m = 6
and 8 ones, are also important. The location of their maximum moves outwards
with increasing m. The oval has much lower Fourier components, and only the
m = 2 stands out from the noise. For small radii all components are nearly zero,
which means that the oval must be nearly axisymmetric in its innermost parts.
On the other hand, the m = 2 amplitude drops slowly with radius in the outer
parts, thus extending to large radii. The small bar has Fourier components which
drop rapidly with radius, i.e. they are noticeable only in the central region, as
Evolution and morphology of bars
11
Fig. 5. Comparison of a simulation forming a strong bar (left panels), one forming an
oval (middle panels) and one forming a short bar (right panels). The layout is as for
Fig. 1.
expected since the bar is confined there. Only the m = 2 and 4 components
stand out from the noise.
The radial rearrangement of the disc material due to the bar can be inferred
by comparing the initial with the current circular velocity curves, given in the
12
E. Athanassoula
Fig. 6. The upper panels show the run of the ellipticity 1 - b/a as a function of the
semi-major axis a. The lower panels show the run of the shape parameter c, also as a
function of a. The left panels corresponds to a model with a strong bar, the middle ones
to model with an oval and the right ones to a model with a short bar. To improve the
signal-to-noise ratio for the model with the oval I took an average over a time interval,
namely [620-700]. The dispersion during that time is indicated by the error bars. The
times are given in the upper right corner of the upper panels.
first and second rows of panels. The strong bar has entailed a substantial radial
rearrangement, the final disc mass distribution being considerably more cen-
trally concentrated than the initial one. On the other hand, in the other two
simulations, and particularly in the one producing the oval, there is very little
radial rearrangement of the disc material. Since there is also hardly any radial
rearangement of the halo material ([6], [3], [35]), this means that the disc-to-halo
mass ratio changes most in the simulations where more angular momentum has
been exchanged.
Quantitative comparison of the bar form of the three models is given in Fig. 6.
The values of the bar semi-major and semi-minor axes (a and b, respectively)
and of the shape parameter (c) were obtained by fitting generalised ellipses of
the form
(x/a)c + (y/b)c = 1,
(6)
to the bar isodensities. The shape parameter c is 2 for ellipses, larger than 2 for
rectangular-like generalised ellipses, and smaller than 2 for diamond-like ones.
From this figure one can note that both the strong and the short bar are thin,
and in general see how their axial ratios vary with the semi-major axis. The
shape parameter is given in the lower panels. We see that both the strong and
the short bar have rectangular-like isodensities in the outer regions of the bar,
while the oval has a shape very close to elliptical. In fact the strong bar has axial
Evolution and morphology of bars
13
ratios and shapes very similar to those found in [7] by applying the same type
of analysis to a sample of early type barred galaxies.
Plotting the run of the density along the bar major axis ([6]) I find for the
strong bar a profile which is rather flat within the bar region, similar to what
was found in [16] for early type bars.
It is thus clear that the amount of angular momentum exchanged influences
the morphology of the bar. In my first example, where a lot of angular momentum
was transferred from the bar to the outer halo (mainly), the result is a long,
strong bar, with some rectangular-like isophotes and ansae at its ends. The
examples where little angular momentum was exchanged have a very different
morphology, one forming an oval and the other a short bar. What determines
which one of the two it will be? In the examples shown here, and in a rather large
sample of similar cases, the oval was formed in an initially hot disc, while the
short bar grew in a hot halo. The existing theoretical framework, however, gives
no predictions on this point and work is in progress to elucidate this further.
9 Summary
In this paper I reviewed evidence that shows that angular momentum is ex-
changed between the bar region in the one hand, and the outer disc and the
spheroid on the other. This exchange determines the slow-down rate of the bar,
as well as its strength and its overall morphology.
Acknowledgments. I thank the organisers for inviting me to this interesting
conference. I thank M. Tagger, A. Bosma, W. Dehnen, A. Misiriotis, C. Heller,
I. Shlosman, F. Masset, J. Sellwood, O. Valenzuela, A. Klypin and P. Teuben
for many stimulating discussions. I thank J. C. Lambert for his help with the
GRAPE software and with the administration of the simulations and W. Dehnen
for making available to me his tree code and related programs. I also thank
the INSU/CNRS, the University of Aix-Marseille I, the Region PACA and the
IGRAP for funds to develop the GRAPE and Beowulf computing facilities used
for the simulations discussed in this paper and for their analysis.
References
1. E. Athanassoula: 'Evolution of bars in isolated and in interacting disk galaxies'. In
Barred Galaxies, eds. R. Buta, D. Crocker and B. Elmegreen (Astron. Soc. of the
Pacific Conference series, 91), pp. 309–321 (1996)
2. E. Athanassoula: Astrophys. J. 569, L83 (2002)
3. E. Athanassoula: 'Formation and Evolution of Bars in Disc Galaxies'. In Disks
of Galaxies: Kinematics, Dynamics and Perturbations, eds. E. Athanassoula, A.
Bosma, R. Mujica (Astron. Soc. of the Pacific Conference Series, 275) pp. 141–152
(2002)
4. E. Athanassoula: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., in press (2003)
5. E. Athanassoula, L. Martinet: Astron. Astrophys. 87, L10 (1980)
6. E. Athanassoula, A. Misiriotis: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 330, 35 (2002)
14
E. Athanassoula
7. E. Athanassoula, S. Morin, H. Wozniak, et al.: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 245, 130
(1990)
8. E. Athanassoula, J. A. Sellwood: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 221, 213 (1986)
9. J. Binney, D. Spergel: Astrophys. J. 252, 308 (1982)
10. A. Bosma: Astron. J., 86, 1825 (1981)
11. G. de Vaucouleurs: Astrophys. J. Suppl. 8, 31 (1963)
12. V. P. Debattista, J. A. Sellwood: Astrophys. J. 493, L5 (1988)
13. V. P. Debattista, J. A. Sellwood: Astrophys. J. 543, 704 (2000)
14. W. Dehnen: Astrophys. J. 536, L39 (2000)
15. W. Dehnen: J. Comp. Phys. 179, 27 (2002)
16. B. G. Elmegreen, D. M. Elmegreen: Astrophys. J. 288, 438 (1985)
17. P. B. Eskridge, J. A. Frogel, R. W. Pogge, et al.: Astron. J., 119, 536 (2000)
18. P. Grosbøl, E. Pompei, P. Patsis: 'Spiral Structure Observed in Near-Infrared'. In
Disks of Galaxies: Kinematics, Dynamics and Perturbations, eds. E. Athanassoula,
A. Bosma, R. Mujica (Astron. Soc. of the Pacific Conference Series, 275) pp. 305–
310 (2002)
19. L. Hernquist: Astrophys. J. Suppl. 86, 389 (1993)
20. L. Hernquist, M. D. Weinberg: Astrophys. J. 400, 80 (1992)
21. F. Hohl: Astrophys. J. 168, 343 (1971)
22. A. Kawai, T. Fukushige, J. Makino, M. Taiji: Pub. Astron. Soc. Japan 152, 659
(2000)
23. J. Laskar: Icarus, 88, 266 (1990)
24. B. Little, R. G. Carlberg: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 250, 161 (1991a)
25. B. Little, R. G. Carlberg: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 251, 227 (1991b)
26. D. Lynden-Bell, A. J. Kalnajs: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 250, 161 (1972)
27. P. Martin: Astron. J. 109, 2428 (1995)
28. R. H. Miller, K. H. Prendergast, W. J. Quirk: Astrophys. J. 161, 903 (1979)
29. K. Ohta: 'Global Photometric Properties of Barred Galaxies'. In Barred Galaxies,
eds. R. Buta, D. A. Crocker, B. G. Elmegreen (Astron. Soc. of the Pacific Conference
Series, 91) pp. 37–43, (1996)
30. K. Ohta, M. Hamabe, K. Wakamatsu: Astrophys. J. 357, 71 (1990)
31. J. P. Ostriker, P. J. E. Peebles: Astrophys. J. 186, 467 (1973)
32. A. Toomre: Astrophys. J. 139, 1217 (1964)
33. A. Toomre: 'What amplifies the spirals' In: The Structure and Evolution of Normal
Galaxies, ed. S. M. Fall, D. Lynden-Bell (Cambridge University Press) pp. 111–136
(1981)
34. S. Tremaine, M. D. Weinberg: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 209, 729 (1984)
35. O. Valenzuela, A. Klypin: in preparation (2003)
36. M. D. Weinberg: Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 213, 451 (1985)
|
astro-ph/0203033 | 1 | 0203 | 2002-03-04T06:52:55 | Maximum mass and radius of strange stars in the linear approximation of the EOS | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Chandrasekhar limit for strange stars described by a linear equation of state (describing quark matter with density-dependent quark masses) is evaluated. The maximum mass and radius of the star depend on the fundamental constants and on the energy density of the quark matter at zero pressure. By comparing the expression for the mass of the star with the limiting mass formula for a relativistic degenerate stellar configuration one can obtain an estimate of the mass of the strange quark. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
missing; you have not inserted them
Maximum mass and radius of strange stars
in the linear approximation of the EOS
T. Harko and K. S. Cheng
Department of Physics, The University of Hong Kong, Pok Fu Lam Road, Hong Kong, P. R.
China
Received 9 August 2001/Accepted 4 February 2002
Abstract. The Chandrasekhar limit for strange stars described by a linear equation of
state (describing quark matter with density-dependent quark masses) is evaluated. The
maximum mass and radius of the star depend on the fundamental constants and on the
energy density of the quark matter at zero pressure. By comparing the expression for
the mass of the star with the limiting mass formula for a relativistic degenerate stellar
configuration one can obtain an estimate of the mass of the strange quark.
Key words: dense matter-equation of state-stars: fundamental parameters
1. Introduction
One of the most important characteristics of compact relativistic astrophysical objects
is their maximum allowed mass. The maximum mass is crucial for distinguishing be-
tween neutron stars and black holes in compact binaries and in determining the outcome
of many astrophysical processes, including supernova collapse and the merger of binary
neutron stars. The theoretical value of the maximum mass for white dwarfs and neutron
2
0
0
2
r
a
M
4
1
v
3
3
0
3
0
2
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
stars was found by Chandrasekhar and Landau and is given by Mmax ∼ (cid:16) ¯hc
(Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983), where mB is the mass of the baryons (in the case of white
G m−4/3
B
(cid:17)3/2
dwarfs, even pressure comes from electrons; most of the mass is in baryons). Thus, with
the exception of composition-dependent numerical factors, the maximum mass of a de-
generate star depends only on fundamental physical constants. The radius Rmax of the
degenerate star obeys the condition Rmax ≤ ¯h
either electron (white dwarfs) or neutron (neutron stars) (Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983).
, with m being the mass of
mc(cid:16) ¯hc
B(cid:17)1/2
Gm2
White dwarfs are supported against of gravitational collapse by the degeneracy pressure
of electrons whereas for neutron stars this pressure comes mainly from the nuclear force
between nucleons (Shapiro & Teukolsky 1983). For non-rotating neutron stars with the
2
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
central pressure at their center tending to the limiting value ρcc2, an upper bound of
around 3M⊙ has been found (Rhoades & Ruffini 1974).
The quark structure of the nucleons, suggested by quantum cromodynamics, opens
the possibility of a hadron-quark phase transition at high densities and/or temper-
atures, as suggested by Witten (Witten 1984). In the theories of strong interaction,
quark bag models suppose that breaking of physical vacuum takes place inside hadrons.
As a result, vacuum energy densities inside and outside a hadron become essen-
tially different and the vacuum pressure on the bag wall equilibrates the pressure of
quarks, thus stabilizing the system. If the hypothesis of the quark matter is true,
then some neutron stars could actually be strange stars, built entirely of strange mat-
ter (Alcock, Farhi & Olinto 1986, Haensel, Zdunik & Schaeffer 1986). For a review of
strange star properties, see (Cheng, Dai & Lu 1998).
Most of the investigations of quark star properties have been done within the frame-
work of the so-called MIT bag model. Assuming that interactions of quarks and gluons
are sufficiently small, neglecting quark masses and supposing that quarks are confined
to the bag volume (in the case of a bare strange star, the boundary of the bag coincides
with the stellar surface), the energy density ρc2 and pressure p of a quark-gluon plasma
at temperature T and chemical potential µf (the subscript f denotes the various quark
flavors u, d, s etc.) are related, in the MIT bag model, by the equation of state (EOS)
(Cheng, Dai & Lu 1998)
p =
(ρ − 4B)c2
3
,
(1)
where B is the difference between the energy density of the perturbative and non-
perturbative QCD vacuum (the bag constant). Equation (1) is essentially the equation
of state of a gas of massless particles with corrections due to the QCD trace anomaly
and perturbative interactions. These corrections are always negative, reducing the energy
density at given temperature by about a factor of two (Farhi & Jaffe 1984). For quark
stars obeying the bag model equation of state (1) the Chandrasekhar limit has been
evaluated, from simple energy balance relations, in (Bannerjee, Ghosh & Raha 2000). In
addition to fundamental constants, the maximum mass also depends on the bag constant.
More sophisticated investigations of quark-gluon interactions have shown that Eq.
(1) represents a limiting case of more general equations of state. For example, MIT bag
models with massive strange quarks and lowest- order QCD interactions lead to some
corrections terms in the equation of state of quark matter. Models incorporating restora-
tion of chiral quark masses at high densities and giving absolutely stable strange matter
can no longer be accurately described by using Eq. (1). On the other hand, in models in
which quark interaction is described by an interquark potential originating from gluon
exchange and by a density-dependent scalar potential which restores the chiral symmetry
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
3
at high densities (Dey et al. 1998), the equation of state P = P (ρ) can be well approx-
imated by a linear function in the energy density ρ (Gondek-Rosinska et al. 2000). It is
interesting to note that Frieman and Olinto (Frieman & Olinto 1989) and Haensel and
Zdunik (Haensel & Zdunik 1989) have already mentioned the approximation of the EOS
by a linear function (see also Prakash et al. (Prakash, Baron & Prakash 1990), Lattimer
et al (Lattimer et al. 1990). Recently Zdunik (Zdunik 2000) has studied the linear ap-
proximation of the equation of state, obtaining all parameters of the EOS as polynomial
functions of strange quark mass, the QCD coupling constant and bag constant. The scal-
ing relations have been applied to the determination of the maximum frequency of a
particle in a stable circular orbit around strange stars.
It is the purpose of this paper to obtain, by using a simple phenomenological ap-
proach (which is thermodynamical in its essence), the maximum mass and radius (the
Chandrasekhar limits) for strange stars obeying a linear equation of state. Of course the
maximum mass of compact astrophysical objects is a consequence of General Relativity
and not of the character of motion of matter constituents. However, the formulae for
maximum mass and radius, due to their simple analytical form, give a better insight
into the underlying physics of quark stars, also allowing us to obtain some results which
cannot be obtained by numerical methods. For example, from the obtained relations one
can find the scaling relations for the maximum mass and radius of strange stars in a
natural way.
The present paper is organized as follows. The maximum mass and radius of quark
stars with a general linear equation of state is obtained in Section 2. In Section 3 we
discuss our results conclude the paper.
2. Maximum mass and radius for strange stars in the linear approximation
of the EOS
We assume that the strange star obeys an equation of state that can be obtained by
interpolation with a linear function of density in the form:
p = a (ρ − ρ0) c2,
where a and ρ0 are non-negative constants. ρ0 is the energy density at zero pressure.
(2)
Such an equation of state has been proposed mainly to describe the strange matter
built of u, d and s quarks (Gondek-Rosinska et al. 2000, Zdunik 2000). The physical
consistency of the model requires ρ0 > 0.
The particle number density and the chemical potential corresponding to EOS (2)
are given respectively by (Zdunik 2000)
n (p) = n0(cid:18)1 +
a + 1
a
p
ρ0c2(cid:19)1/(a+1)
,
(3)
4
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
µ (p) = µ0(cid:18)1 +
a + 1
a
p
ρ0c2(cid:19)a/(a+1)
,
(4)
where n0 is the particle number density at zero pressure and µ0 = ρ0c2/n0.
The parameters a and ρ0 can be calculated, for realistic equations of state, by using a
least squares fit method (Gondek-Rosinska et al. 2000, Zdunik 2000). For the equations
of state incorporating restoration of chiral quark masses at high densities proposed in Dey
et al. (Dey et al. 1998) one obtains the values a = 0.463, ρ0 = 1.15 × 1015g/cm3 and a =
0.455, ρ0 = 1.33 × 1015g/cm3, respectively (Gondek-Rosinska et al. 2000). The standard
bag model corresponds to a = 0.333 and ρ0 = 4 × 1014g/cm3 (Cheng, Dai & Lu 1998).
From Eqs. (3)-(4) it follows that the particle number and chemical potential are
related by the equation
µ =
ρ0c2
na+1
0
na.
(5)
From the numerical studies of strange star models we know that the density profile
of this type of astrophysical object is quite uniform (Glendenning 1996). Therefore we
can approximate n ≈ N/V , which leads to
µ
µ0
R−3a,
=(cid:18) 4π
3 (cid:19)−a(cid:18) N
n0(cid:19)a
(6)
where N is the total number of particles in a star of radius R and volume V .
With the use of Eqs. (2)-(6) one obtains the energy density of the star in the form
ρ0
ρ =
a
ρ0.
a + 1
R−3(a+1) +
n0(cid:19)a+1
3 (cid:19)−a−1(cid:18) N
a + 1(cid:18) 4π
The total mass M of the star is defined according to M = 4πR R
a + 1(cid:18) 4π
3 (cid:19)−a(cid:18) N
n0(cid:19)a+1
R−3a +
ρ0R3,
4π
3
a + 1
a
is given by
ρ0
M =
0 ρr2dr ≈ 4π
3 ρR3 and
(7)
(8)
where we assumed that the energy density is approximately constant inside the star.
Extremizing the mass with respect to the radius R by means of ∂M/∂R = 0 gives
the relation
ρ0
a + 1(cid:18) 4π
3 (cid:19)−a(cid:18) N
n0(cid:19)a+1
R−3a =
4π
3
1
a + 1
ρ0R3.
(9)
Substituting Eq. (9) into Eq. (8) we obtain the maximum mass of the strange star in
the linear approximation of the EOS:
M =
4π
3
ρ0R3.
(10)
This expression is very similar to the expression for the maximum mass of the quark
star obtained assuming that the star is composed of three-flavour masslesss quarks,
confined in a large bag (Bannerjee, Ghosh & Raha 2000, Cheng & Harko 2000). From
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
5
a physical point of view, Eq. (10) describes a uniform density zero pressure stellar type
configuration.
The maximum equilibrium radius corresponds to a minimum total energy of the star
(including the gravitational one), for any radius. For ordinary compact stars, the mass
is entirely due to baryons, and the corresponding (Newtonian) gravitational potential
energy is of the order EG ∼ −αGM 2/R (α = −3/5 for constant density Newtonian stars).
For quark stars, assumed to be formed of massless quarks, the total mass can be calculated
from the total (thermodynamic as well as confinment) energy in the star. One possibility
for the estimation of the gravitational energy per fermion is to define an effective quark
mass incorporating all the energy contributions (Bannerjee, Ghosh & Raha 2000).
The gravitational energy per particle (the strange star is assumed to be formed from
fermions) is
EG = −
GM mef f
R
,
(11)
where mef f is the effective mass of the particles inside the star, incorporating also
effects such as quark confinment. For a star with N particles one can write M =
N mef f = ρ0V , or mef f = ρ0/n. On the other hand one can assume µ = ρ0/2n
(Bannerjee, Ghosh & Raha 2000), leading to mef f = 2µ/c2. Hence, with the use of Eqs.
(6), (9) and (10) we can express the gravitational energy per particle as
3 (cid:19)2
EG = −2(cid:18) 4π
G
ρ2
0
N
R5.
(12)
The energy density per particle of the fermions follows from Eq. (7) and is given by:
EF =
4π
3
1
a + 1
ρ0
N
R3.
The total energy E per particle is
E =
4π
3
1
a + 1
ρ0
N
3 (cid:19)2
R3 − 2(cid:18) 4π
G
ρ2
0
N
R5.
(13)
(14)
Extremizing the total energy with respect to the radius (with the total particle number
kept constant),(cid:0) ∂E
configuration in the linear approximation of the EOS is given by:
∂R(cid:1)N =const. = 0, it follows that the maximum radius of the equilibrium
Rmax = R0
pπ (a + 1) Gρ0
The maximum mass of the star can be calculated from Eq. (10) and is:
c
.
Mmax =
4
3
R3
0
(a + 1)3/2
c3
G
1
√πGρ0
.
(15)
(16)
In Eqs. (15) and (16) R0 is a numerical factor of the order R0 ≈ 0.474.
The maximum radius of the quark star given by Eq. (15) is the radius corresponding
to the maximum mass. On the other hand for the existing models of strange stars,
6
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
the configuration with maximum mass has a radius which is lower than the maximum
radius. For example, for strange stars described by the bag model equation of state, the
maximum radius is 11.40km, while the radius corresponding to the maximum mass is
10.93km, which is 4% lower than the maximum radius. This difference is neglected in
Eq. (15).
The maximum mass and radius of the star are strongly dependent on the numerical
value of the coefficient R0 and estimations based on other physical models could lead to
different numerical estimates of the limiting values of the basic parameters of the static
strange stars.
3. Discussions and final remarks
In the present paper we have shown that there is a maximum mass and radius (the
Chandrasekhar limits) for quark stars whose equation of state can be approximated by
a linear function of the density. We have also obtained the explicit expressions for Mmax
and Rmax.
With respect to the scaling of the parameter ρ0 of the form ρ0 → kρ0, the maximum
mass and radius have the following scaling behaviors:
Rmax → k−1/2Rmax, Mmax → k−1/2Mmax.
(17)
For the maximum mass of the strange stars this scaling relation has also been found
from the numerical study of the structure equations in the framework of the bag model
(Witten 1984, Haensel, Zdunik & Schaeffer 1986).
A rescaling of the parameter a of the form a + 1 → K (a + 1), with ρ0 unscaled, leads
to a transformation of the radius and mass of the form
Rmax → K −1/2Rmax, Mmax → K −3/2Mmax.
(18)
A simultaneous rescaling of both a and ρ0, with a + 1 → K (a + 1) , ρ0 → kρ0 gives
(19)
Rmax → k−1/2K −1/2Rmax, Mmax → k−1/2K −3/2Mmax.
The maximum mass and radius of strange stars with linear EOS is strongly dependent
on the numerical value of ρ0, the mass decreasing with increasing ρ0. For ρ0 = 4B, with
the bag constant B = 1014g/cm3 (56M eV f m−3) we obtain Mmax = 1.83M⊙, a value
that must be compared to the value Mmax = 2M⊙ obtained by numerical methods
(Witten 1984, Haensel, Zdunik & Schaeffer 1986). The difference between the numerical
and theoretical predictions is around 10%. For ρ0 = 1.33 × 1015gcm−3 the maximum
mass of the star is about 1M⊙.
Generally our formulae (15) and (16) underestimate the maximum values of the mass
and radius because we have assumed that the density inside the star is uniform. It
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
7
is obvious that near the surface the density is much lower than at the center of the
compact object. Due to the approximations and simplifications used to derive the basic
expressions, reflected mainly in the uncertainties in the exact value of the coefficient R0,
Eqs. (15) and (16) cannot provide high precison numerical values of the maximum mass
and radius for linear EOS stars, which must be obtained by numerically integrating the
gravitational field equations.
For the the linear EOS, Mmax and Rmax depend mainly on the fundamental constants
c and G and on the zero pressure density ρ0 (the bag constant). The Chandrasekhar
expressions for the same physical parameters involve two more fundamental constants, ¯h
and the mass of the electron or neutron.
For quark stars, usually one assume they are composed of a three-flavour system of
massless quarks, confined in a large bag. Hence the mass of the quark cannot play any
role in the mass formula. But the linear EOS with arbitrary a can describe quark matter
with non-zero quark masses (the mass of the strange quark ms ≈ 200M eV ), forming a
degenerate Fermi gas (Gondek-Rosinska et al. 2000, Zdunik 2000). Therefore this system
should also be described by the same formulae as white dwarfs or neutron stars, not only
by Eqs. (15) - (16). Generally ρ0 is a function of the mass of the strange quark, so this
mass implicitly appears in the expression of the maximum mass and radius. But on the
other hand we can assume that the Chandrasekhar limit also applies to quark stars with
the baryon mass substituted by an effective quark mass mqef f , representing the minimum
mass of the quark bubbles composing the star. Hence we must have
(cid:18) ¯hc
G
m−4/3
qef f(cid:19)3/2
c3
G
∼
1
√πGρ0
.
(20)
Eq. (20) leads to the following expression of the effective mass of the "elementary"
quark bubble:
mqef f ∼ ¯hρ1/3
c !3/4
0
.
(21)
The effective quark mass is determined only by elementary particle physics constants
and is independent of G. From its construction mqef f should be relevant when the system
is quantum mechanical and involves high velocities and energies. With respect to a scaling
of the zero pressure density of the form ρ0 → kρ0, the effective quark mass has the
scaling behavior mqef f → mqef f k1/4, similar to the scaling of the strange quark mass
(Zdunik 2000).
For ρ0 = 4 × 1014gcm−3 we obtain mqef f ∼ 3.63 × 10−25g ≈ 204M eV . For ρ0 =
1.33 × 1015gcm−3 Eq. (21) gives mqef f ∼ 4.9 × 10−25g ≈ 275M eV . The mass given
by Eq. (21) can be considered as the minimum mass of the stable quark bubble. It is
of the same order of magnitude as the mass ms of the strange quark. Therefore the
8
Harko & Cheng: Maximum Mass and Radius for Linear EOS
Chandrasekhar limit applies also for quark stars if we take mqef f for the mass of the
elementary constituent of the star .
In the present paper we have considered the maximum mass and radius of strange
stars in the linear approximation of the equation of state and the dependence of these
quantities on the parameter a has been found. We have also pointed out the existence of
scaling relations for the maximum radius of strange stars, an aspect that has not been
mentioned in previous investigations (Witten 1984, Haensel, Zdunik & Schaeffer 1986,
Bannerjee, Ghosh & Raha 2000, Zdunik 2000). Our formulae also lead to the transfor-
mation relations for the maximum mass and radius of strange stars with respect to
separate and simultaneous scaling of the parameters a and ρ0. On the other hand the
possibility of estimation of the mass of the strange quark from general astrophysical
considerations can perhaps give a better understanding of the deep connection between
micro- and macro-physics.
Acknowledgements. This work is partially supported by a RGC grant of Hong Kong
Government and T.H. is supported by a studentship of the University of Hong Kong. The
authors are very grateful to the anonymous referee whose comments helped to improve
an earlier version of the manuscript.
References
Alcock C., Farhi E. & Olinto A. 1986, Astrophys. J., 310, 261
Bannerjee S., Ghosh S. K. & Raha S. 2000, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys., 26, L1
Cheng K. S., Dai Z. G. & Lu T. 1998, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D, 7, 139
Cheng K. S. & Harko T. 2000, Phys. Rev. D, 62, 083001
Dey M., Bombacci I., Dey J., Ray S. & Samanta B. C. 1998, Phys. Lett. B, 438, 123
Farhi E. & Jaffe R. L. 1984, Phys. Rev. D, 30, 2379
Frieman J. A. & Olinto A. 1989, Nature, 341, 633
Glendenning N. K. 1996, Compact stars: nuclear physics, particle physics and general relativity,
Springer, New York
Gondek-Rosinska D., Bulik T., Zdunik L., Gourgoulhon E., Ray S., Dey J. & Dey M. 2000,
Astron. Astrophys., 363, 1005
Haensel P., Zdunik J. L. & Schaeffer R. 1986, Astron. Astrophys., 160, 121
Haensel P. & Zdunik J. L. 1989, Nature, 340, 617
Lattimer J. M., Prakash M., Masaak D. & Yahil A. 1990, Astrophys. J., 355, 241
Prakash M., Baron E. & Prakash M. 1990, Phys. Lett. B, 243, 175
Rhoades C. E. & Ruffini R. 1974, Phys. Rev. Lett., 32, 324
Shapiro S. L. & Teukolsky S. A. 1983, Black Holes, White Dwarfs, and Neutron Stars, John
Wiley & Sons, New York
Witten E. 1984, Phys. Rev. D, 30, 272
Zdunik J. L. 2000, Astron. Astrophys., 359, 311
|
0806.1754 | 1 | 0806 | 2008-06-10T21:16:48 | Identifying the Low Luminosity Population of Embedded Protostars in the c2d Observations of Clouds and Cores | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a search for all embedded protostars with internal luminosities < 1 solar luminosity in the sample of nearby, low-mass star-forming regions surveyed by the Spitzer Space Telescope c2d Legacy Project. The internal luminosity (Lint) of a source is the luminosity of the central source and excludes luminosity arising from external heating. On average, the c2d data are sensitive to embedded protostars with Lint > 4E-3 (d/140 pc)^2 solar luminosities, a factor of 25 better than the sensitivity of IRAS to such objects. We present selection criteria used to identify candidates from the Spitzer data and examine complementary data to decide whether each candidate is truly an embedded protostar. We find a tight correlation between the 70 micron flux and internal luminosity of a protostar, an empirical result based on observations and two-dimensional radiative transfer models of protostars. We identify 50 embedded protostars with Lint < 1 solar luminosities; 15 have Lint < 0.1 solar luminosities. The intrinsic distribution of source luminosities increases to lower luminosities. While we find sources down to the above sensitivity limit, indicating that the distribution may extend to luminosities lower than probed by these observations, we are able to rule out a continued rise in the distribution below 0.1 solar luminosities. Between 75-85% of cores classified as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer remain starless to our luminosity sensitivity; the remaining 15-25% harbor low-luminosity, embedded protostars. We compile complete Spectral Energy Distributions for all 50 objects and calculate standard evolutionary signatures, and argue that these objects are inconsistent with the simplest picture of star formation wherein mass accretes from the core onto the protostar at a constant rate. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Accepted for publication in ApJS
Identifying the Low Luminosity Population of Embedded
Protostars in the c2d Observations of Clouds and Cores
Michael M. Dunham1,2, Antonio Crapsi3,4, Neal J. Evans II1, Tyler L. Bourke5, Tracy L.
Huard5, Philip C. Myers5, and Jens Kauffmann6,5
ABSTRACT
We present the results of a search for all embedded protostars with internal
luminosities ≤ 1.0 L⊙ in the full sample of nearby, low-mass star-forming regions
surveyed by the Spitzer Space Telescope Legacy Project "From Molecular Cores
to Planet Forming Disks" (c2d). The internal luminosity of a source, Lint, is the
luminosity of the central source and excludes luminosity arising from external
heating. On average, the Spitzer c2d data are sensitive to embedded protostars
with Lint ≥ 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙, a factor of 25 better than the sensitivity of
the Infrared Astronomical Satellite (IRAS) to such objects. We present a set of
selection criteria used to identify candidates from the Spitzer data and examine
complementary data to decide whether each candidate is truly an embedded pro-
tostar. We find a tight correlation between the 70 µm flux and internal luminosity
of a protostar, an empirical result based on both observations and detailed two-
dimensional radiative transfer models of protostars. We identify 50 embedded
protostars with Lint ≤ 1.0 L⊙; 15 have Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙. The intrinsic distribu-
tion of source luminosities increases to lower luminosities. While we find sources
down to the above sensitivity limit, indicating that the distribution may extend
to luminosities lower than probed by these observations, we are able to rule out a
continued rise in the distribution below Lint = 0.1 L⊙. Between 75 −85% of cores
1Department of Astronomy, The University of Texas at Austin, 1 University Station, C1400, Austin,
Texas 78712–0259
2E-mail: [email protected]
3Sterrewacht Leiden, Leiden University, P.O. Box 9513, 2300 RA Leiden, the Netherlands
4Observatorio Astron´omico Nacional (IGN), Alfonso XII, 3, E-28014 Madrid, Spain
5Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138
6Initiative in Innovative Computing at Harvard, 60 Oxford Street, Cambridge, MA 02138
– 2 –
classified as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer remain starless to our lu-
minosity sensitivity; the remaining 15 − 25% harbor low-luminosity, embedded
protostars. We compile complete Spectral Energy Distributions for all 50 ob-
jects and calculate standard evolutionary signatures (Lbol, Tbol, and Lbol/Lsmm),
and argue that these objects are inconsistent with the simplest picture of star
formation wherein mass accretes from the core onto the protostar at a constant
rate.
Subject headings: stars: formation - stars: low-mass, brown dwarfs
1.
Introduction
Recently, the Spitzer Space Telescope Legacy Project "From Molecular Cores to Planet
Forming Disks" (c2d; Evans et al. 2003) completed an extensive 3.6−160 µm imaging survey
of nearby, low-mass star-forming regions. One of the results to come out of this survey is
the discovery of very low luminosity objects (VeLLOs; Young et al. 2004). If the internal
luminosity of a source, Lint, is the total luminosity of the central protostar and circumstellar
disk (if present), a VeLLO is defined to be an object embedded within a dense core with
Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙ (Di Francesco et al. 2007). The bolometric luminosity of an embedded
protostar, an observable quantity that can be calculated by integrating over the full Spectral
Energy Distribution (SED), is composed of both internal and external luminosity (Lbol =
Lint +Lext). The external luminosity is usually that arising from heating of the circumstellar
envelope by the Interstellar Radiation Field (ISRF), and will add, on average, a few tenths of
a solar luminosity to Lbol (e.g., Evans et al. 2001). Thus, the distinction between Lbol and Lint
is most relevant for embedded protostars with Lint . 1.0 L⊙, where the external luminosity
can be a significant fraction of the observed Lbol. For VeLLOs, the external luminosity can
dominate the observed Lbol. Radiative transfer modeling of the SEDs of embedded protostars,
including both the emission from the envelope at submillimeter and millimeter wavelengths
and the emission from the central source itself at infrared wavelengths, is required to decouple
internal and external luminosities (e.g., Shirley et al. 2002; Young et al. 2004; Dunham et
al. 2006).
Several VeLLOs have been discovered in cores that were previously classified as starless
prior to being observed by Spitzer.
In fact, the very first starless core observed by c2d,
L1014, was found to harbor a VeLLO with Lint ∼ 0.09 L⊙ (Young et al. 2004). This
discovery reinforces that the known sample of embedded protostars is not complete. This
sample has been assembled primarily by two methods: (1) searching for IRAS sources that
are associated with dense cores and have colors consistent with those expected for embedded
– 3 –
protostars (e.g., Myers et al. 1987), and (2) identifying molecular outflows and radio point
sources associated with dense cores indicating the presence of protostars too deeply embedded
to detect with IRAS (e.g., Andr´e et al. 1993). Myers et al. (1987) found that the IRAS
data could detect protostars with Lint & 0.1 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙, where d is the distance to the
protostar, although this does not include the younger, more deeply embedded protostars that
were only identified on a case-by-case basis by the second method. The regions surveyed by
c2d with Spitzer are located at distances ranging from 125 − 500 pc. Even in the closest of
these regions VeLLOs are likely to fall below the IRAS sensitivity limit. In the more distant
regions, no protostars with Lint . 1 L⊙ would be detected. While some of these protostars
might have been identified on a case-by-case basis as described above, the full sample of
embedded protostars with Lint ≤ 1 L⊙ is clearly incomplete.
Constructing a complete sample of embedded protostars with Lint ≤ 1 L⊙ is important
for studies of low-mass star formation. Despite substantial progress in recent decades, the
details of the physical processes regulating mass accretion from the envelope to the proto-
star remain poorly understood (see McKee & Ostriker [2007] for a recent review). Several
authors have attempted to constrain evolutionary models of the formation of low-mass stars
by determining the observational signatures of these models and comparing them to the
properties of known protostars (e.g., Myers et al. 1998; Young & Evans 2005). A result
common to all such studies is a substantial population of protostars with luminosities below
model predictions. An idea proposed to explain this discrepancy is that the mass accretion is
episodic in nature and the protostars with the lowest luminosities are those observed in qui-
escent accretion states (e.g., Kenyon & Hartmann 1995; Young & Evans 2005; Enoch 2007;
Enoch et al. 2008a, in preparation). Theoretical studies have provided several mechanisms
by which such a process may occur, such as material piling up in a circumstellar disk until
gravitational instabilities drive angular momentum outward and mass inward in short-lived
bursts (Vorobyov & Basu 2005, 2006). Alternatively, quasi-periodic magnetically driven out-
flows in the envelope can cause mass accretion onto the protostar to occur in magnetically
controlled bursts (Tassis & Mouschovias 2005). Indeed, the evidence for non-steady mass
accretion in young protostellar systems still in the embedded phase is steadily growing (e.g.,
Hartmann & Kenyon 1985; Dunham et al. 2006; Acosta-Pulido et al. 2007; K´osp´al et al.
2007; Fedele et al. 2007). However, as the sample of embedded, low luminosity protostars
is incomplete, the true nature of the discrepancy between evolutionary models and obser-
vations of protostars is unknown. Future work devoted to assessing the validity of various
models by comparing their predictions to the properties of known protostars depends on the
existence of a sample that is as complete and unbiased as possible.
The VeLLOs are a particularly interesting subset of embedded, low-luminosity proto-
stars; in essence, they are an extreme case of the problem discussed above. To date, only
– 4 –
three VeLLOs have been studied in detail: L1014-IRS (Lint ∼ 0.09 L⊙; Young et al. 2004),
L1521F-IRS (Lint ∼ 0.06 L⊙; Bourke et al. 2006), and IRAM 04191-IRS (Lint ∼ 0.08 L⊙;
Dunham et al. 2006). Despite the fact that all three have similar internal luminosities,
they differ greatly in envelope and outflow properties, as discussed by Bourke et al. (2006).
IRAM 04191 drives a large, bipolar molecular outflow, features bright molecular line and
dust continuum emission, and shows evidence for infall, depletion, and deuteration (Andr´e et
al. 1999; Belloche et al. 2002). L1521F is also bright in molecular line and dust continuum
emission and also shows evidence for infall, depletion, and deuteration (Crapsi et al. 2004),
but the envelope is not as centrally condensed as IRAM 04191 and the presence of an outflow
is uncertain (Crapsi et al. 2004; Bourke et al. 2006). L1014 does not show significant evi-
dence for infall, depletion, or deuteration (Crapsi et al. 2005a), but it does drive a compact,
weak molecular outflow detected only in interferometer observations (Bourke et al. 2005;
Crapsi et al. 2005a). A systematic search for all VeLLOs in the regions surveyed by c2d
will allow their properties to be examined in detail both on a case-by-case basis and as a
class of objects. Identifying the complete sample of VeLLOs will also allow us to determine
how many cores classified as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer truly are starless, a
question with important implications for estimates of the lifetime of starless cores (e.g., Kirk
et al. 2005).
In this paper, we present the results of a search for all embedded protostars with Lint ≤
1.0 L⊙ in the full c2d imaging dataset. Depending on the distance to each individual source,
some will already have been detected by IRAS, while others will be new sources. We consider
this work to be complementary to several related studies: A search by Kirk et al. (2007) for
embedded protostars in 22 cores classified as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer ; a
search by Jørgensen et al. (2007; 2008, in preparation) for all embedded protostars in Perseus
and Ophiuchus, regardless of luminosity, conducted by combining Spitzer and SCUBA 850
µm dust continuum emission data; and a search by Enoch (2007) and Enoch et al. (2008a,
in preparation) for all embedded objects in the Perseus, Ophiuchus, and Serpens molecular
clouds, regardless of luminosity, conducted by combining Spitzer and Bolocam 1.1 mm dust
continuum emission data.
The key difference between the work presented here and the searches for embedded
protostars listed above is that we do not start by identifying dense cores from their millimeter
dust continuum emission and then look for associated Spitzer sources embedded within
them. Instead, we develop a set of criteria to identify candidate embedded, low-luminosity
protostars based on the 3.6 − 70 µm Spitzer data. This way, we are able to identify all of
the candidates in the full c2d dataset, regardless of the availability and quality of millimeter
wavelength observations for each region. Only after we identify all candidates based on
Spitzer data alone do we turn to other observations to distinguish the objects of interest
– 5 –
from various contaminants masquerading in our sample. Our method identifies candidates
for further examination once large-scale surveys of nearby star-forming regions are completed
with SCUBA-2 (Ward-Thompson et al. 2007) and Herschel, and the method can easily be
extended to search for embedded, low-luminosity protostars in the additional nearby, low-
mass star-forming regions being surveyed by the Spitzer Gould Belt Legacy Project (L. Allen
et al. 2008, in preparation).
The organization of this paper is as follows: In §2, we provide a brief description of the
c2d observations and data reduction, emphasizing those aspects relevant to this work. The
criteria for identifying candidate embedded, low-luminosity protostars from the 3.6 − 70 µm
Spitzer data are discussed in §3, along with the possibilities for estimating source internal
luminosities directly from observable quantities. A general proof-of-concept demonstrating
the validity of these criteria is given in §4. In §5, we discuss the contamination expected in
the list of candidates, both from background extra-galactic sources and from more evolved
Young Stellar Objects (YSOs) no longer embedded within their dense cores. We discuss the
necessary requirements to prove that a candidate is truly an embedded protostar in §5.1,
we apply these requirements to our candidate list in §5.2, and we discuss the difficulties in
including regions lacking good quality 70 µm data in §5.3. We discuss several general results
of this work in §6. Finally, we present our conclusions in §7.
2. Observations and Data Reduction
The Spitzer c2d data have been published in several papers focusing on individual
regions in the survey. We summarize here the observation strategy and data reduction
method used by c2d; greater detail on individual regions can be found in the references
given below.
2.1. Observations
2.1.1. Molecular Clouds
The c2d project obtained complete 3.6 − 160 µm Spitzer maps of five nearby, large
molecular clouds. The clouds (and approximate areas) surveyed include 1 deg.2 of Serpens
(Harvey et al. 2006; 2007a; 2007b), 2.5 deg.2 total of the Lupus I, Lupus III, and Lupus
– 6 –
IV clouds1 (Chapman et al. 2007; Mer´ın et al. 2008), 1 deg.2 of Chamaeleon II (Young
et al. 2005; Porras et al. 2006; Alcal´a et al. 2008), 7 deg.2 of Ophiuchus (Padgett et al.
2007), and 4 deg.2 of Perseus (Jørgensen et al. 2006; Rebull et al. 2007). These clouds were
chosen to span a wide range of low-mass star-forming environments (Evans et al. 2003). We
adopt distances of 260 ± 10, 150 ± 20, 200 ± 20, 150 ± 20, 178 ± 18, 125 ± 25, and 250 ± 50
pc for Serpens, Lupus I, Lupus III, Lupus IV, Chamaeleon II, Ophiuchus, and Perseus,
respectively (see discussion of distances in the references listed above). The observations
of Serpens, Lupus, Chamaeleon II, Ophiuchus, and Perseus were obtained in Program IDs
(PIDs) 174, 175, 176, 177, and 178, respectively.
Observations at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 µm were obtained with the Infrared Array Cam-
era (IRAC; Fazio et al. 2004). Each region was observed in two epochs to allow for the
detection and removal of asteroids, and each region was observed twice per epoch with small
dithers between the observations. The integration time per pointing was selected to be 12 s,
providing an effective integration time per pixel of 10.4 s. This strategy results in four total
observations per region (2 epochs of 2 dithers each), resulting in a total integration time
of ∼ 42 s per pixel. All observations were obtained in the "High Dynamic Range" mode,
which provides an additional short (0.6 s) exposure to enable photometry of bright sources
saturated in the longer exposures.
Observations at 24, 70, and 160 µm were obtained with the Multiband Imaging Pho-
tometer for Spitzer (MIPS; Rieke et al. 2004). The observations consist of two epochs of
fast scan maps with a spacing between adjacent scan legs of 240′′. The second epoch was
offset by 125′′ from the first in the cross-scan direction to fill in the 70 µm sky coverage
that would have otherwise been missed due to detector problems, and by 80′′ in the scan
direction to minimize missing 160 µm data. These mapping parameters result in two epochs
of observations at 24 µm and one epoch at 70 and 160 µm, with total integration times per
pixel of 30, 15, and 3 s, respectively. Small gaps of missing coverage remain in the 160 µm
maps.
For technical reasons relating to the fact that the length of a MIPS scan map leg must
be chosen from a fixed list, the regions observed by MIPS are often significantly larger than
those observed by IRAC in order to ensure full coverage. The approximate areas quoted
above are for the IRAC+MIPS overlap regions; in general, the areas observed by MIPS are
a factor of 2 − 3 larger.
1For simplicity, we refer to the ensemble of these three portions of the Lupus Molecular Cloud Complex
as simply "Lupus".
– 7 –
2.1.2. Small Dense Cores
In addition to the five large molecular clouds, c2d also obtained small maps of 82 regions
containing 95 small, dense cores. These cores are selected on the basis of being nearby (within
500 pc), relatively small (generally less than 5′, which corresponds to ∼0.7 pc at a distance
of 500 pc), relatively isolated, and showing evidence for dense gas and dust (Evans et al.
2003). The list of all 82 regions is given in Evans et al. (2007). A discussion of the overall
results of the Spitzer observations of these cores and estimates of the distance to each core
are presented in T. Huard et al. (2008, in preparation). Although "relative isolation" was
one of the criteria used to select these cores, we note here that many are not truly isolated
in the sense that they are often loosely associated (both in projection on the sky and in
velocity) with larger complexes. Approximately 70% of these cores were classified as starless
prior to the launch of Spitzer, based primarily on showing no association with IRAS sources
(Evans et al. 2003 and references therein).
Observations at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 µm were obtained with IRAC in PID 139 in a
manner nearly identical to the clouds. The main differences are that the maps are much
smaller (often only a single 5 × 5′ frame or a small map < 30′ on a side), the number of
epochs observed (one or two) depends on the location of each core relative to the ecliptic, and
short-exposure HDR images were only obtained for cores expected to contain bright sources
based on previous surveys. Cores observed in only one epoch featured 4 dithers instead of 2
so that all cores featured a total integration time per pixel identical to the clouds.
Observations at 24 and 70 µm were obtained with MIPS in PID 139; 160 µm observa-
tions were not obtained. Unlike the clouds, the MIPS observations of the core regions were
obtained in the pointed photometry mode. The exposure time per pointing was 3 seconds at
24 µm and either 3 or 10 seconds at 70 µm, and small raster maps were obtained to match
the IRAC maps. As a result, the core regions, unlike the clouds, do not feature significantly
larger areas observed with MIPS than with IRAC. The exact integration time per pixel varies
from region to region due to the differences in field and map size, but is generally 30 − 60 s
at 24 µm and 50 − 100 s at 70 µm.
2.2. Data Reduction
The IRAC and MIPS images were processed by the Spitzer Science Center (SSC), using
their standard pipeline, version S13, to produce Basic Calibrated Data (BCD) images. These
images were then improved by the c2d Legacy Project to correct for artifacts remaining in
the BCD images. A complete description of the improvements made, as well as the source
– 8 –
extraction and band-merging process summarized below, is given in Evans et al. (2007).
After correcting for artifacts, mosaics were produced using the MOPEX software pro-
vided by the SSC. Photometry at 3.6 − 24 µm was obtained using c2dphot, a modified
version of DOPHOT (Schechter et al. 1993) that utilizes a digitized rather than analytic
point source profile to better match the real Spitzer data, as well as incorporating several
other changes (a complete description of which are given in Harvey et al. 2006). Sources
that were not detected in all 5 bands from 3.6 − 24 µm were band-filled, a process whereby
the c2dphot source extractor was forced to obtain fluxes at the source position (known from
the band(s) in which it was detected) in the bands for which the source was not detected in
the original source extraction (see Evans et al. (2007) for details). Finally, photometry at
3.6 − 24 µm were band-merged into a final source catalog.
Photometry at 70 µm was obtained using the SSC's MOPEX point-source fitting package
on filtered BCD data for faint sources (. 2 Jy) and unfiltered BCD data for bright sources
(& 2 Jy). Sources extracted at 70 µm were band-merged into the 3.6 − 24 µm catalogs
described above, although this process is imperfect due to the significantly worse resolution
at 70 µm (∼18′′) compared to 24 µm (∼6′′) and 3.6 − 8.0 µm (∼2′′) (see Evans et al. 2007
and §5.3).
All of the above reduction and source extraction is part of the standard c2d pipeline.
However, this pipeline does not include source extraction at 160 µm due to problems with
diffuse emission and low spatial resolution. Thus, photometry at 160 µm for the five large
clouds was obtained using the SSC's MOPEX point-source fitting package. The source
extraction lists were then inspected and sources that appeared to be extended dust "clumps"
with little or no central condensation were removed (T. Brooke, private communication). As
a redundancy check, we also visually inspected all of the 160 µm images at the positions of
the candidates identified in this work and performed aperture photometry on those that have
associated 160 µm sources. The aperture sizes and sky annuli were chosen to allow us to use
one of the standard aperture corrections for 160 µm point sources determined by the SSC.
In general, we find very good agreement between the PSF and aperture photometry. The
ratio of PSF to aperture flux for sources extracted by both methods has a mean and median
of 1.07 and 1.02, respectively, with a standard deviation of 0.2. We thus add an overall 20%
systematic uncertainty into our photometry at 160 µm. Both methods assume all 160 µm
sources are point sources; fluxes of extended sources may thus be under-estimated.
– 9 –
3.
Identification of Candidate Embedded, Low-Luminosity Protostars
Generally speaking, we identify candidate embedded, low-luminosity protostars from the
Spitzer observations by selecting sources with rising fluxes from shorter to longer wavelengths
and infrared luminosities LIR, calculated over the 2MASS and Spitzer bands (1.25 − 70 µm),
indicating Lint ≤ 1 L⊙ (see below). Throughout this paper we denote flux as Fν (Fν = νSν).
When we refer to the shape of the Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) of an object, it is
always evaluated in terms of flux (Fν) rather than flux density (Sν).
At this stage, we emphasize completeness over reliability; many objects identified as
candidates are likely either more evolved Young Stellar Objects (YSOs) no longer embedded
in their dense cores, or background galaxies. Separating these from the true embedded
protostars is addressed in §5. We have assembled a set of seven criteria that must be
met for a source to be identified as a candidate. We list these criteria below, followed by
an explanation of each one individually in §3.1. We provide a detailed discussion of the
motivation for the third criterion in §3.2, and investigate the results of relaxing the first
criterion in §3.3. Finally, we discuss the need to visually inspect each candidate in §3.4 and
present a general proof-of-concept in §4.
The seven criteria that must be met are:
1. Detected at 24 µm with a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) ≥ 3.
2. Located at a position observed by a minimum of two Spitzer photometric bands be-
tween 3.6 and 70 µm.
3. Detected at 70 µm, unless confused or not observed at this wavelength.
4. Rising (or flat) SED between the longest IRAC wavelength at which the source is
detected and 24 µm.
5. Rising (or flat) SED between 24 and 70 µm, unless confused or not observed at 70 µm.
6. Observed luminosity calculated using all detections ranging from 1.25 − 70 µm of LIR
≤ 0.5 L⊙.
7. Not classified as a candidate galaxy in the classification method of Harvey et al. (2007b)
unless Log(Pgal) ≤ −1.25, where Pgal is the un-normalized probability of being a galaxy.
– 10 –
3.1. Selection Criteria
We impose the first criterion simply because 24 µm observations are convenient for
determining whether or not a source features a rising SED in the wavelength region covered
by our Spitzer observations (3.6 − 70 µm). First of all, 24 µm is located approximately
halfway between 3.6 and 70 µm in log space, making it useful for determining the general
shape of the SED over the wavelengths observed by Spitzer. Additionally, the diffraction
limited resolution of Spitzer, θ = 1.2 λ
D , is a factor of 2.92 better at 24 µm than 70 µm. Thus,
sources clustered close together (at least in projection on the sky) can often be resolved into
individual sources at 24 µm even when they are confused at 70 µm, providing reliable flux
information at a wavelength beyond the 3.6 − 8.0 µm region covered by IRAC and better
enabling us to evaluate the shape of the SED. We discuss the effects of relaxing this criterion
in §3.3.
The second criterion ensures that we have flux information available at a minimum
of one other Spitzer wavelength besides 24 µm. The MIPS observations of the five large
clouds were obtained in the scan map observing mode and often cover significantly larger
areas than the IRAC observations of the same regions for technical reasons. Furthermore,
there are minor differences between the exact areas observed at 24 and 70 µm, resulting
in small regions that are observed at 24 µm but not at any other wavelength. Since it is
impossible to determine the shape of the SED of any source observed at only one wavelength,
all sources in these "MIPS-24 only" regions are removed from consideration. This issue is
not as significant in the regions with dense cores, where the MIPS data were obtained in the
pointed observations mode and often cover very similar areas to the IRAC observations.
The third criterion is imposed because 70 µm is a crucial wavelength for determining
Lint of embedded, low-luminosity protostars. We will return to this point in greater detail
below.
The fourth and fifth criteria select sources with rising or flat SEDs from shorter to
longer wavelengths. Simple, 1-D models of protostars still embedded within their cores show
that they should essentially always feature rising SEDs both between the IRAC wavelength
regime (3.6 − 8.0 µm) and 24 µm and between 24 and 70 µm (e.g., Young et al. 2005). Two-
dimensional models that include the effects of outflow cavities show that the exact shape of
the 3.6 − 70 µm SED depends on the inclination of the source (e.g., Whitney et al. 2003a;
Whitney et al. 2003b; Robitaille et al. 2006). In particular, embedded protostars observed
at nearly pole-on inclinations exhibit much flatter SEDs over these wavelengths since more of
the protostellar emission can escape through the outflow cavities instead of being reprocessed
to longer-wavelength emission by the envelope. While this flattening of the SED can be very
significant, even at the most extreme inclinations the models predict essentially flat rather
– 11 –
than falling SEDs at these wavelengths. We return to this point in §4.2.
We thus require each source to have an increasing or constant flux between the longest
IRAC wavelength at which the source is detected and 24 µm, and between 24 and 70 µm. If
a source is not detected at any IRAC wavelength, it is considered to pass the fourth criterion.
We take the photometric uncertainties into account; a source may actually have a decreasing
flux between the two wavelengths considered as long as it is consistent with being at least
flat given the uncertainties. Not all sources have 70 µm detections; we will return to these
sources at the end of this section, but for now, we keep any source that meets the first rising
criterion but has no flux information at 70 µm. We do not place any rising requirements on
the IRAC fluxes themselves since the effects of geometry (Whitney et al. 2003a; Whitney et
al. 2003b), solid-state ice features (Boogert et al. 2004), and shocked emission from outflows
(e.g., Noriega-Crespo et al. 2004) greatly complicate the exact shape of the 3.6 − 8.0 µm
SED.
The sixth criterion separates out the low-luminosity sources, those of interest to this
study, from the more luminous sources. As described in §1, the internal luminosity of an
embedded, low-luminosity protostar is not an observable quantity and is usually derived from
radiative transfer modeling. Here we investigate whether or not we can estimate Lint without
the need to construct detailed models of each source. We have identified 11 embedded
protostars from the literature that have been observed with Spitzer by c2d and have accurate
internal luminosity determinations from radiative transfer models. We list these 11 objects
in Table 1, along with LIR calculated from the observations and Lbol and Lint derived from
the published models.
Figure 1a plots Lint vs. LIR in log-log space for these 11 objects; a linear correlation is
clearly observed. The solid line shows the results of a linear least-squares fit; it has a slope
of 0.88 and a y-intercept of 0.32. However, any linear correlation in a luminosity-luminosity
plot is suspect since it may simply arise from plotting the square of the distance to the object
versus itself. Thus, Figure 1b plots the ratio of Lint/LIR, a quantity that is independent of
distance, vs. the log of LIR. An approximately constant ratio is observed over several orders
of magnitude of LIR, as would be expected if a true linear correlation exists between these
quantities. The solid line shows the average ratio of 1.7, weighted by the uncertainties in Lint.
Inverting this quantity, we find that the luminosity calculated between 1.25 − 70 µm gives
a result that is approximately half the true value of the internal luminosity. Thus, to select
sources with Lint . 1.0 L⊙, we impose the requirement that LIR ≤ 0.5 L⊙. We emphasize
that this relationship between Lint and LIR is only an approximation; Figure 1b clearly
shows there is some variation from source to source. In fact, the lowest-luminosity sources
may have a larger ratio of Lint/LIR than more luminous sources, although the uncertainties
– 12 –
are large. However, even if the ratio of Lint/LIR does increase for lower-luminosity sources,
they will have LIR far below the cut of 0.5 L⊙ and will thus be included in our sample.
The seventh criterion is related to the fact that background galaxies are difficult to
separate from YSOs when analyzing Spitzer data of star-forming regions. A number of
authors have recently shown that such galaxies often exhibit similar mid-infrared colors and
SEDs to YSOs (e.g., Harvey et al. 2006; Jørgensen et al. 2006). In an effort to accurately
separate out background galaxies from YSOs, Harvey et al. (2007b) developed a classification
method that assigns to each object that can not be fitted by an extincted stellar photosphere
an un-normalized "probability" of being a galaxy, Pgal. The probabilities are assigned based
on the position of each source in various color-color and color-magnitude diagrams, along
with information about the nature of the source (point-like vs. extended) given by the c2d
source extraction software (see §2 and references therein). Based on its value of Pgal, Harvey
et al. classified each source as a candidate YSO or candidate Galaxy.
Figure 2 shows a histogram of Pgal for all 851 sources assigned a probability in the
ensemble of 82 regions with dense cores observed by c2d. The dotted line shows Log(Pgal) =
−1.47 while the dashed line shows Log(Pgal) = −1.25. This figure is similar to Figure 4
of Harvey et al.
(2007b), which plots the distribution of Pgal for all sources assigned a
probability in the c2d observations of the Serpens Molecular Cloud. As noted by Harvey et
al., there are two distinct peaks in probability space: one at Log(Pgal) = −5.00 and one at
Log(Pgal) ∼ −0.4, with a tail connecting the two. In a similar analysis on a Spitzer dataset
of extragalactic objects, Harvey et al. found only the peak at Log(Pgal) ∼ −0.4 and not the
other peak or the tail connecting the two. Based on this, they set the boundary between
candidate YSO and candidate galaxy at Log(Pgal) = −1.47, such that objects in the peak
at Log(Pgal) = −5.00 and the tail between the two peaks are considered candidate YSOs
while objects in the peak at Log(Pgal) ∼ −0.4 are considered candidate Galaxies. However,
as is evident both from Figure 2 of this paper and Figure 4 of Harvey et. al, there is likely
some overlap in probability space between the tail of objects considered candidate YSOs and
the peak of objects considered candidate galaxies. Some of the objects near the boundary
of Log(Pgal) = −1.47, but slightly into the regime of galaxies, may in fact still be YSOs.
Furthermore, there was no galaxy in the Spitzer dataset of extragalactic objects considered
by Harvey et al. with Log(Pgal) ≤ −1.25. Thus, for all the objects that pass the first
six criteria, we reject all those classified as candidate galaxies based on this classification
method except for those with −1.47 ≤ Log(Pgal) ≤ −1.25. Many of these intermediate
objects are likely to be galaxies, but we include them as candidates at this stage for the sake
of completeness. Separating out these false candidates is the subject of §5.
– 13 –
3.2.
Importance of 70 µm Data
We now return to the issue of detection at 70 µm. This is a crucial wavelength for
determining Lint for embedded, low-luminosity protostars. Radiative transfer models of
these objects are strongly constrained by this wavelength since the flux at 70 µm, F70,
is mostly unaffected by the details of the source geometry and presence or absence of a
circumstellar disk that significantly affect the 3.6 − 24 µm SED. F70 is also quite unaffected
by the amount of external heating from the ISRF that is important at wavelengths & 100
µm (e.g., Dunham et al. 2006). To examine this more fully, we again use the sources listed in
Table 1 observed with Spitzer by c2d and possessing accurate determinations of Lint through
radiative transfer models. Figure 3 plots Fν, normalized to 140 pc, for all six wavelengths
observed by Spitzer vs. Lint for these 11 sources, along with the results of linear least-squares
fits to the data in log-log space. These fits show that a correlation exists between the flux at
each wavelength and Lint; in general terms, more luminous sources emit more energy at all
wavelengths. However, the correlation is clearly strongest at 70 µm, weaker at 24 µm, and
very poor at 3.6 − 8.0 µm. To quantify this, at each wavelength we calculate χ2
r, a reduced
chi-squared for the fit:
χ2
r =
1
n − p
n
Xi=0
(yi − mxi − b)2
σ2
i
,
(1)
where n is the number of datapoints (n = 11), p is the number of free parameters
(p = 2), yi and xi are the log of the x and y values for each datapoint, σi is the size of the
uncertainty in log space, and m and b are the slope and y-intercept, respectively, derived
from the fit in log-log space. The values for m and b, along with their statistical uncertainties
from the fit and the results of the χ2
r calculations, are presented in Table 2. We find χ2
r = 3
at 70 µm, χ2
r = 85 at 24 µm, and χ2
r > 100 for all four IRAC wavelengths, in agreement with
the qualitative conclusions from above.
These results suggest that a direct correlation exists between F70 and Lint. However,
this analysis is based on only 11 data points, and furthermore, many of the radiative transfer
model determinations of Lint listed in Table 1 are based on the same simple, 1-D modeling
setup that, among other things, uses a very simple method of including a disk in a 1-D
model (Butner et al. 1994). We do not expect this to be significant, as previous work has
concluded that even these simple, 1-D models accurately constrain Lint (e.g., Dunham et al.
2006), but to test the validity of these results, we attempt to reproduce them by running a
grid of two-dimensional models that are more physically realistic than those on which many
of the values of Lint in Table 1 are based.
– 14 –
We used the two-dimensional, axisymmetric, Monte Carlo dust radiative transfer code
RADMC (Dullemond & Dominik 2004) to compute the radiative transfer and calculate the
emergent SEDs of embedded, low-luminosity protostars and look for correlations between
Lint and Fν in the Spitzer bands. The density structure assumed for the models consists of a
protostellar disk and a rotationally flattened, infalling envelope with an outflow cavity, and
is described in greater detail in Crapsi et al. (2008). The details of the models are nearly
identical to those of Crapsi et al.; we do not describe them here except to note that they
have been tuned to their specific purpose within this work in the following ways:
• The protostar has a fixed temperature of 3000 K and a random luminosity in the range
of 0.03 − 10 L⊙.
• The disk has a fixed size of 100 AU, variable mass between 10−3 and 10−5 M⊙, and fixed
flaring parameters (a scale height H of 20 AU at the outer radius and then decreasing
as H ∝ r9/7, corresponding to the self-irradiated passive disk of Chiang & Goldreich
[1997]).
• The envelope has a fixed radius of 14,000 AU, a variable mass in the range of 1 − 10
M⊙, and a variable centrifugal radius in the range of 100 − 900 AU.
• The envelope is externally heated by the ISRF, for which we adopt that of Black (1994),
modified at the ultraviolet wavelengths to reproduce the ISRF of Draine (1978). This
Black-Draine ISRF is then attenuated by dust with properties given by Draine & Lee
(1984) to simulate being embedded in a parent cloud and multiplied by a scale factor
to account for the fact that the ISRF is not uniform everywhere, where the number of
magnitudes of visual extinction and scale factor are chosen randomly.
The observed SED was obtained by raytracing the density, temperature, and scattering
structures calculated by RADMC at five different inclinations: 20, 35, 50, 65, and 80◦ from
the axis of symmetry. Fluxes were integrated inside apertures comparable to the resolution
of Spitzer : 2′′ for wavelengths shorter than 10 µm, 6′′ for wavelengths in the range of 10 − 40
µm, and 20′′ in the wavelength range of 40 − 100 µm.
Following this description, a grid of 292 models were run and 1460 SEDs were obtained
(one at each inclination). The results are shown in Figure 4 and, qualitatively, appear to
confirm the correlation between F70 and Lint. The parameters derived from linear least-
squares fits in log-log space for Fν vs. Lint for the models are given in Table 2. It is clear
from these models that there is in fact a tight correlation between F70 and Lint (most of the
scatter seen in the MIPS2 panel of Figure 4 is due to inclination effects). In fact, not only do
– 15 –
the observations and models both show this correlation, but they also agree remarkably well
on the quantitative relationship (within 3% for the slope and within 1% for the y-intercept)
considering that, to date, only 11 sources have been modeled by us and are thus available
to examine this from an observational standpoint. Since F70 is an observable quantity, the
correlation we find between F70 and Lint can be used to estimate Lint for sources which either
lack sufficient data to constrain radiative transfer models or have such data but have not yet
been modeled. Using the results of the linear least-square fit to the modeled F70 vs. Lint in
log-log space, we derive this estimate to be
Lint = 3.3 × 108 F70
0.94 L⊙ ,
(2)
where F70 is in cgs units (erg cm−2 s−1) and is normalized to 140 pc.
Since a detection at 70 µm is crucial for constraining radiative transfer model determi-
nations of Lint and gives an immediate, direct estimate of Lint, we require each source to
be detected at 70 µm unless it is not observed at this wavelength or is located too close to
another source detected at 70 µm to be resolved into a separate source (see §5.3). Thus, with
these two exceptions, we effectively require candidates to be above the detection threshold
at 70 µm. This requirement sets the fundamental limit for our luminosity sensitivity. Fig-
ure 5 plots a histogram showing the 70 µm 3σ point source sensitivity for each of the 82
regions with dense cores observed by c2d. This sensitivity was derived by first calculating
the standard deviation of the background intensity for each region, σsky, in the image units
of MJy sr−1. Approximating the 70 µm Spitzer PSF as a Gaussian with θFWHM equal to
the diffraction limited resolution of ∼ 18′′, this background intensity is then converted into
units of mJy beam −1 as follows:
σsky (mJy beam)−1 = 1 × 109 (cid:18) π θ2
FWHM
4 ln2 (cid:19) σsky (MJy sr)−1
(3)
This gives the 3σ point source sensitivity for each region, since the total flux density of a
point source is equivalent to its flux density per beam.
This 70 µm point source sensitivity can be directly translated into a luminosity sensi-
tivity using Equation 2. From this relationship, the mean 70 µm 3σ point source sensitivity
of 38.6 mJy translates into a luminosity sensitivity of ∼ 4 × 10−3 L⊙ at 140 pc. Figure 6
plots the luminosity sensitivity limit for each of the 82 regions vs. the distance to the region,
calculated by translating the 70 µm 3σ point source sensitivity into a luminosity sensitivity
using Equation 2 and then scaling from 140 pc to the distance to the region. The solid
line shows the relation Lint = 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙. There is some scatter between the
line and the actual data, caused by the variation in 70 µm point-source sensitivity from one
region to the next, but this relation clearly provides an accurate estimate of the luminosity
– 16 –
sensitivity. On average, the c2d observations of regions with dense cores are sensitive to
embedded protostars with internal luminosities Lint ≥ 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙. This same
argument holds true for the c2d observations of the clouds, as the 70 µm cloud maps reach
similar depths as the cores. This is a factor of 25 better than the sensitivity of IRAS quoted
in §1.
Applying these criteria results in the identification of 673 candidate embedded, low-
luminosity protostars: 106 in the ensemble of dense core regions, 196 in Perseus, 112 in
Chamaeleon II, 153 in Lupus, 57 in Ophiuchus, and 49 in Serpens.
3.3. Relaxing the First Criterion
The first of the seven criteria described above for selecting candidates from the Spitzer
c2d observations is a detection at 24 µm. As discussed in §3.1, this is an important wavelength
for determining whether or not a source features a rising (or flat) SED from 3.6 − 70 µm.
However, it is possible that a source of interest has no detection at 24 µm. For example,
it might simply not be covered at 24 µm if it is located close to the edge of an observed
region where the coverage between bands is not uniform, or it might be so deeply embedded
that it is only detected at 70 µm. The latter could be particularly interesting sources, either
very young, deeply embedded protostars or perhaps even first hydrostatic cores, which are
short-lived, hydrostatic objects in a phase between the initial collapse of a dense core and
the formation of a Class 0 protostar predicted by theory but not yet found by observations
(e.g., Boss & Yorke 1995).
Thus, to make sure no sources are missed by imposing this first criteron, we search for
any source not detected at 24 µm but detected at 70 µm. We then apply the sixth criterion,
LIR ≤ 0.5 L⊙, to select the low luminosity sources that are the focus of this work. This
gives an additional 53 candidates: 13 in the ensemble of dense core regions, 7 in Perseus,
17 in Chamaeleon II, 10 in Lupus, 2 in Ophiuchus, and 4 in Serpens. We add these to
the candidates identified above for a total of 726 candidates. However, only 4 of these
53 additional candidates survive the visual inspection described in §3.4, and none of these
surviving 4 are particularly strong candidates (see §3.4).
3.4. Visual Inspection
The final step in the identification of candidates is visual inspection. For each of the
726 sources identified above, we examined the images at the six wavelengths observed by
– 17 –
Spitzer and the source SED. Throughout the course of this inspection, we found five reasons
to reject candidates: (1) The source is obviously a resolved galaxy; (2) The 70 µm detection
is not real; (3) The source SED is not consistent with that of an embedded protostar; (4)
The source is located in a region of nebulosity that produces a false infrared excess at the
longer wavelengths; and (5) There is no real source.
The first reason is due to the fact that a source must meet certain requirements to be
classified as a candidate YSO or candidate galaxy in the method of Harvey et al. (2007b).
Specifically a source must be detected in both epochs of observations (or in the single epoch
if only one epoch was observed) with SNR ≥ 3 in all 4 IRAC bands and the 24 µm MIPS
band. Any source outside the area of overlap between all 5 bands, or simply not detected
in any one of these bands, does not get evaluated by the method of Harvey et al. and thus
can not be classified as a candidate YSO or galaxy. This results in many galaxies making
the candidate list. Visual inspection removes those large and/or close enough to be resolved
by IRAC; all others remain candidates at this stage.
The second reason relates to the fact that the exact sensitivity of the 70 µm c2d ob-
servations is a complicated function of the position within the scan map (clouds) or pointed
observation (core regions), since the exact number of frames at a given position depends
on the technical details of how Spitzer executes observations. In regions with fewer frames,
often near the edges of maps, noise spikes are sometimes falsely identified as sources; we
remove these from consideration. Of the 53 candidates identified by searching for sources
detected at 70 µm but not at 24 µm, 49 were removed for this reason, and the 4 that remain
are all sources with questionable 70 µm detections that simply weren't obvious enough false
detections to remove.
The third reason relates to the details of how rising sources were selected. Figure 7
shows the SED of SSTc2d J032856.64+311835.6, a source in Perseus representative of those
removed for this reason. It is detected at all 6 Spitzer wavelengths, features a rising flux
between 8 and 24 µm, features a flat, but slightly rising, flux between 24 and 70 µm, has
LIR = 0.37 L⊙, and is classified as a candidate YSO by the classification method of Harvey
et al. (2007b). Thus, it fulfills all the criteria for selecting candidates discussed in §3.1.
However, it clearly emits more energy in the near-infrared (1.25 − 2.17 µm) than at 24 and
70 µm. Comparison with 2-D models of sources (e.g., Whitney et al. 2003a; Whitney et al.
2003b; Robitaille et al. 2006) shows that, even at the most extreme pole-on inclinations, the
effects of outflow cavities are unlikely to result in an observed SED more luminous in the
near-infrared than at 24 and 70 µm. A more likely explanation for objects featuring such
SEDs is that they are more evolved YSOs surrounded by circumstellar disks but no longer
– 18 –
embedded within dense cores. Indeed, a search of the SIMBAD2 database shows that this
is SSS 108, which Aspin et al. (1994) and Aspin (2003) conclude is a pre-main sequence
star with a small thermal excess at 2 µm (i.e., from a disk). The nature of these objects
with large infrared excesses at 24 and 70 µm compared to 3.6 − 8.0 µm could potentially
be very interesting; indeed, these SEDs appear similar to those of a sample of YSOs with
disks featuring large inner holes presented by Brown et al. (2007). Sources that meet our
selection criteria but are more luminous in the near-infrared than at 24 and 70 µm may be
interesting objects, but they are not relevant to this study and are thus removed from our
sample.
The final two reasons for rejecting sources upon visual inspection both relate to the
bandfilling process described in §2. The first reason is that stars are often detected only in
the first two IRAC bands, due both to the decreasing Spitzer sensitivity at longer wavelengths
and the fact that Spitzer observes the Rayleigh-Jeans portion of stellar SEDs. Some stars
detected only in these two bands are located, at least in projection, in regions of nebulosity.
For these objects, the bandfilling process can assign source fluxes in bands beyond IRAC2
that are contaminated by this extended nebulosity, creating false excesses and thus falsely
rising SEDs. These are obvious in that there is no real point-source in the longer wavelength
images. The second reason is that Spitzer images of star-forming regions often exhibit copious
amounts of nebulous, diffuse emission due to scattered light, shocked emisison from outflows,
thermal emission from hot dust, PAH emission, etc. In regions where this diffuse emission
becomes clumpy, the source extraction may falsely detect a point-source at one wavelength
that then gets band-filled at all other wavelengths. Some of these fake sources may pass all
7 criteria for selection, but they are obvious upon visual inspection in that there is no point
source present in the images. Both types of sources are removed from consideration.
After removing sources for the reasons described above, we are left with 218 candidates:
49 in the ensemble of dense core regions, 70 in Perseus, 16 in Chamaeleon II, 42 in Lupus,
22 in Ophiuchus, and 19 in Serpens. The source number from this work, group number
indicating likelihood of being an embedded object (see §5), Spitzer source name, position,
LIR, and distance to and name of the nearest source in the IRAS point-source catalog are
given for each candidate in Tables 3 − 8. For the candidates in the dense cores, Table 3
also list the name of the core region in which each candidate is located and the assumed
distance to this region; these distances have been derived by reddening or association with
regions with known distances (T. Bourke, private communication). The full list of distances
to core regions will be presented by T. Huard et al. (2008, in preparation). We emphasize
2Available at: http://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/
– 19 –
here that these objects are only candidates. We have chosen to emphasize completeness over
reliability, with the result being that many of these 218 candidates are in fact galaxies or
more evolved YSOs no longer embedded in their dense cores. Separating the wheat from the
chaff is the focus of §5.
4. Proof of Concept
In §3.1, we presented a set of criteria to select embedded, low-luminosity protostars from
Spitzer c2d observations. We imposed certain restrictions on the shape of the 3.6 − 70 µm
SED in order to pick out the embedded objects (the fourth and fifth criteria), and justified
their validity by comparing to both 1-D and 2-D models of embedded sources. Here we
further examine the ability of these criteria to identify embedded protostars.
4.1. Comparison to Known Class 0 Objects
Class 0 objects were added to the original infrared spectral slope classification system
of Lada (1987) by Andr´e et al. (1993) as objects younger and more deeply embedded than
Class I objects and thus not detected in the infrared. However, with the advent of sensitive
infrared facilities such as Spitzer, both Class 0 and I objects are detected in the infrared and
are often indistinguishable from one another based on their infrared spectral slope α (e.g.,
Enoch 2007; Enoch et al. 2008a, in preparation; Kauffmann et al. 2008). Robitaille et al.
(2006) discussed the distinction between SED "class" and physical "stage". Physically, the
distinction between a Stage 0 and Stage I object is that a Stage 0 object still has more than
half of its total mass in the circumstellar envelope (Andr´e et al. 1993). Various evolutionary
indicators can be used to separate embedded objects into Class 0 and Class I objects, which
should correlate with the true physical stage (see §6.2.2).
Froebrich (2005) searched the literature and compiled a database of photometry of all
known Class 0 objects. This database is available online3 and is updated as new Class 0
objects are discovered and new photometry is published. If we remove our sixth criterion,
which selects only those embedded protostars with Lint . 1 L⊙, our criteria should select all
of the objects in this database with available photometry between 3.6 − 70 µm.
Since both IRAS and the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) obtained photometry at 25
and 60 µm, there are many objects in this database with photometry at these two wavelengths
3Available at http://astro.kent.ac.uk/protostars/index.html
– 20 –
but not at 24 and 70 µm (in other words, observed with IRAS and/or ISO, but not with
Spitzer ). Thus, we first selected all sources in the database that had a detection at 60 or
70 µm; 80 of the 135 sources in the database meet this criterion. We then imposed the
same criteria as described in §3.1 and 3.3, omitting the sixth criterion as described above,
repacing 24 and 70 µm with 25 and 60 µm, respectively, when necessary, and omitting the
second, third, and seventh criteria because these require information not available from the
database.
Of the 80 objects evaluated, 79 pass our criteria and are selected as embedded objects.
The one source that does not is IRAS 12500−7658, located in the Chamaeleon II molecular
cloud. According to the Class 0 database, this source has F24 = 8.58 × 10−11 ± 0.05 × 10−11
erg s−1 cm−2 and F70 = 6.98 × 10−11 ± 0.43 × 10−11 erg s−1 cm−2, and thus does not have
a rising (or flat) flux between 24 or 70 µm, even when the uncertainties are taken into ac-
count. This source was observed by c2d, and in fact these values are taken from Young
et al. (2005), who presented MIPS data on the Chamaeleon II cloud using a preliminary
version of the c2d pipeline.
In the final c2d source catalog for Chamaeleon II, which in-
cludes, among other things, improved source photometry and more accurate photometric
uncertainties (Evans et al. 2007), this source has F24 = 7.64 × 10−11 ± 0.71 × 10−11 erg s−1
cm−2 and F70 = 6.60 × 10−11 ± 0.64 × 10−11 erg s−1 cm−2. Using these new, more accurate
values, IRAS 12500−7658 does indeed have a rising (or flat) SED between 24 or 70 µm when
the uncertainties are taken into account. Thus, all 80 sources are recovered; we identify all
of the Class 0 objects.
4.2. Comparison to Embedded Objects in Perseus, Serpens, and Ophiuchus
The above exercise demonstrates that our criteria successfully identify the youngest,
most heavily embedded protostars. However, we are interested in the full population of
embedded objects, not just the Class 0 objects. To test our method for Class I objects, and
to verify the above results, we compare our objects to those identified by Enoch (2007) and
Enoch et al. (2008a, in preparation). They searched for Spitzer sources associated with
dense cores identified by large-scale, uniform 1.1 mm Bolocam dust continuum emission
surveys of Perseus, Serpens, and Ophiuchus. They did not restrict themselves to the low-
luminosity population, and since they had good-quality millimeter data available for all three
clouds, they started by searching for sources associated with known dense cores. Our work
is complementary in that all sources identified here should be identified by Enoch et al., but
we can extend our analysis to regions lacking such millimeter data.
Comparing the results of both searches shows, in general, good agreement. Enoch et al.
– 21 –
separated their objects into Class 0 and Class I objects based on the bolometric temperature
of each source (see §6.2). After removing sources with LIR ≥ 0.5 L⊙ from their sample, we
identify all of their Class 0 sources. This confirms the above result that we identify all Class
0 objects. We also identify most of their Class I sources, but find a population of objects
in their sample not identified as candidates in our work. Inspection of this population of
objects shows that they are not selected by our criteria because they do not have rising
fluxes from 24 to 70 µm. Out of the 37 Class I objects with LIR ≤ 0.5 L⊙ in the Enoch
(2007) and Enoch et al. (2008a) sample, 15 (40%) are not selected by our criteria for this
reason. These 15 objects range in luminosities from 0.03 ≤ LIR ≤ 0.4 L⊙. Figure 8 shows
the average SEDs, weighted by 1/Lbol so that the average is not dominated by the most
luminous sources, for all sources identified by Enoch (2007) and Enoch et al. (2008a, in
preparation), divided into four bins: Class 0, Class I with rising (or flat) fluxes from 24 to
70 µm, Class I with decreasing fluxes from 24 to 70 µm, and Class II.
Following Whitney et al. (2003b), Enoch et al. (2008a, in preparation) use the bolo-
metric temperature of each object to go beyond the simple Class 0/I division and divide
their sources into Early Class 0, Late Class 0, Early Class I, and Late Class I objects. They
present the average SED for each of these four classes of objects; it is the Late Class I ob-
jects (300 K ≤ Tbol ≤ 650 K) that feature decreasing fluxes between 24 and 70 µm. Thus,
a possible conclusion is that our selection criteria miss the older Class I objects nearing the
end of the embedded phase.
However, as described in §3.1, we developed our selection criteria based on comparison
to models of protostars still embedded within their dense cores. This includes both Class 0
and Class I protostars. Two-dimensional models featuring outflow cavities predict rising or
flat fluxes from 24 to 70 µm at even the most extreme pole-on inclinations, (e.g., Whitney
et al. 2003a; Whitney et al. 2003b; Robitaille et al. 2006). Indeed, Enoch et al. (2008a,
in preparation) compare their average SEDs for Early and Late Class 0 and I objects to
the two-dimensional models of each type of object presented by Whitney et al. (2003b) and
note that their Late Class I objects differ from the models in that, among other things, they
decrease in flux from 24 to 70 µm.
The nature of these objects is uncertain. The overall similarities between the average
SEDs of the Class I objects rising and falling between 24 and 70 µm (see Figure 8) and the
fact that these objects are associated with dense cores suggests they truly are embedded
objects. On the other hand, no published models of embedded protostars predict fluxes that
decrease between these two wavelengths. Robitaille et al. (2006) noted that the SED class
and physical stage of an object do not always agree. For example, a Stage II object located
behind a large amount of material (such as a dense core) could feature a Class I SED. It is
– 22 –
possible that these objects with decreasing fluxes from 24 to 70 µm are not truly embedded
protostars but heavily extincted Stage II objects located behind dense cores. A future,
detailed study of these objects is needed, but at present, their true physical stage remains
unknown. Our criteria will identify the majority of embedded, low-luminosity objects (100%
of the Class 0 objects; ≥ 60% of the Class I objects). Even if the objects with decreasing
fluxes from 24 to 70 µm are in fact embedded objects, including them in our sample would
not significantly change any of our results.
5. Confirming the Candidates
Many of the 218 candidates identified in §3 are not truly embedded protostars. The
visual inspection described above removed a large number of false candidates, cutting our
list down from 726 candidates to 218. However, we only removed sources from consideration
if it was obvious that they fell into one of the five types of false candidates discussed in §3.4.
Candidates for which there was any ambiguity were kept, and at least some of these are
expected to be false candidates. Furthermore, as discussed above, a source is only evaluated
by the classification method of Harvey et al. (2007b) for identifying candidate YSOs and
candidate galaxies if it is detected in both epochs of observations (or in the single epoch
if only one epoch was observed) with SNR ≥ 3 in all 4 IRAC bands and the 24 µm MIPS
band. Any source not covered by all 5 of these bands is ineligible for classification as either
candidate galaxy or candidate YSO, and instead receives one of several general source types
based on the shape of the SED (Evans et al. 2007). Many galaxies thus slip into our
candidate list because they pass criterion 7 of §3.1, whereas they would have been classified
as candidate galaxies and rejected according to this criterion if they had been observed in all
5 bands. Only those that are large and/or close enough to resolve are removed by the visual
inspection described in §3.4. This is particularly relevant for the five large clouds, since the
MIPS coverage is substantially larger than the IRAC coverage.
To demonstrate the extent of extra-galactic contamination expected, we note that 148
of the 218 candidates have LIR ≤ 0.05 L⊙, which roughly corresponds to Lint . 0.1 L⊙ using
the relation between the two derived in §3.1. This suggests a very large number of VeLLOs
exist; however, out of these 148 sources, 114 are not considered by the Harvey et al. (2007b)
classification method because they do not meet the requirement of SNR ≥ 3 detections in
all 5 bands. As Figure 9 demonstrates, the majority of these low-luminosity sources are
expected to be galaxies. Out of 851 sources in the 82 regions with dense cores observed by
c2d that are classified as either candidate YSOs or candidate galaxies, 604 have LIR ≤ 0.05
L⊙, and 518 of these 604 (∼ 86%) are classified as candidate galaxies. Thus, as many as
– 23 –
98 of the 114 candidates not considered by the Harvey et al. (2007b) classification method
because they do not meet the requirement of SNR ≥ 3 detections in all 5 bands may be
extra-galactic in nature. Clearly, further effort is required in order to determine which of the
218 candidates are in fact embedded, low-luminosity protostars.
5.1. How to Prove a Source is Embedded
We examined both the Spitzer data and complementary data for each of the 218 can-
didates to search for evidence proving they are truly embedded objects. We divide this
evidence into two "levels of certainty":
1. Evidence exists proving that a source is associated, in projection on the sky, with a
region of high volume density.
2. Evidence exists proving that this soure is actually embedded within the dense region
(to remove the possibility of chance alignment).
As discussed below, data on molecular line and dust continuum emission, molecular outflows,
extinction, and infrared nebulosity are used to evaluate these conditions. We note here that
it is much easier to prove the first level than the second.
5.1.1. Evaluating the First Level
The first level is evaluated by observing the region in a tracer of dense material. Such
tracers include millimeter dust continuum emission, which typically traces regions with vol-
ume densities of n & 104 cm−3 (e.g., Enoch et al. 2007), inversion transition lines of NH3,
which also trace regions with volume densities of n & 104 cm−3 (e.g., Ho & Townes 1983;
Benson & Myers 1989), and rotational transition lines of N2H+, which trace similar material
as the NH3 lines (Caselli et al. 2002). We thus looked for associations with millimeter dust
continuum, NH3, or N2H+ sources using a number of different surveys of the regions covered
by c2d in these tracers, some of which were specifically designed as complementary surveys
to c2d; we list these surveys below.
In addition, we searched the SIMBAD database for
other such observations besides those listed below. In all cases, a candidate is said to be
associated (in projection) with a millimeter dust continuum, NH3, or N2H+ source if it is
located within one beam of the peak position of the source.
– 24 –
The surveys we used for the candidates in the 82 regions with dense cores are as follows:
An on-going 350 µm dust continuum survey of cores with the Submillimeter High Angular
Resolution Camera II (SHARC-II) at the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory (CSO; Wu
et al. 2007; M. Dunham et al. 2008, in preparation), a 450 and 850 µm dust continuum
survey of 38 cores with the Submillimeter Common-User Bolometer Array (SCUBA) at the
James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT; Young et al. 2006a), a 1.2 mm dust continuum
survey of 37 cores with the Max Planck Millimeter Bolometer (MAMBO) at the IRAM 30
m telescope (Kauffmann et al. 2008), a 1.2 mm dust continuum survey of 151 southern
cores with the SEST Imaging Bolometer Array (SIMBA) at the Swedish ESO Submillimeter
Telescope (SEST; K. Brede et al. 2008, in preparation), an N2H+ (1-0) survey of 38 cores
observed with the Five College Radio Astronomy Observatory (FCRAO; C. De Vries et al.
2008, in preparation), an N2H+ (1-0) survey of 59 cores also observed with the FCRAO
(Caselli et al. 2002), and observations of the (J, K) = (1, 1) and (2, 2) lines of NH3 for 264
cores compiled from the literature by Jijina et al. (1999).
The surveys used for Perseus are a 1.1 mm dust continuum survey of 7.5 deg2 with
Bolocam at the CSO (Enoch et al. 2006), an 850 µm dust continuum survey of 3.5 deg2
with SCUBA at the JCMT (Kirk et al. 2006), a 450 and 850 µm dust continuum survey of
3.0 deg2 with SCUBA at the JCMT (Hatchell et al. 2005; Hatchell et al. 2007a), and the
SHARC-II survey described above, which includes several cores in Perseus. For Chamaeleon
II, we used a 1.3 mm dust continuum survey of 36 YSOs in Chamaeleon I and II with the 3He-
cooled bolometer system at the SEST (Henning et al. 1993), and the SIMBA survey of 151
southern cores described above, which includes several cores in Chamaeleon II. For Lupus,
a 1.2 mm dust continuum survey of ∼625 arcmin2 with SIMBA at the SEST (Tachihara et
al. 2007) was used. For Ophiuchus, we used a 1.1 mm dust continuum survey of 10.8 deg2
with Bolocam at the CSO (Young et al. 2006b), a 1.2 mm dust continuum survey of 1.0
deg2 with SIMBA at the SEST (Stanke et al. 2006), and an 850 µm dust continuum survey
of 700 arcmin2 with SCUBA at the JCMT (Johnstone et al. 2000). Finally, for Serpens we
used a 1.1 mm dust continuum survey of 1.5 deg2 with Bolocam at the CSO (Enoch et al.
2007), a 450 and 850 µm dust continuum map of 120 arcmin2 with SCUBA at the JCMT
(Davis et al. 1999), and a 1.2 mm dust continuum map of ∼150 arcmin2 with MAMBO at
the IRAM 30 m telescope (Djupvik et al. 2006).
Observations tracing dense material are not always available at the positions of the
candidates. This is especially true for candidates in the southern clouds and cores. As an
alternative, observations indicating high column density can be used to evaluate the first
level. A positive result does not guarantee this level is satisfied, as high column densities do
not necessarily indicate high volume densities, but it does increase the likelihood that the
source is an embedded object.
– 25 –
We utilize two indicators of high column density: extinction maps and absorption against
the mid-infrared background. For the extinction maps, we used the maps created by the
c2d team. We give a brief description of them here; a more complete description can be
found in Evans et al. (2007). A line-of-sight extinction estimate is produced by the c2d
pipeline for each source with a 1.25 − 24 µm SED consistent with that of an extincted stellar
photosphere, and these line-of-sight estimates were then convolved with uniformly spaced
Gaussian beams. Maps of different resolution were produced by using Gaussian beams with
different FWHM. We used the highest resolution maps available for each cloud (180′′ for
Perseus, 120′′ for Chamaeleon, 120′′ for Lupus I, 90′′ for Lupus III, 90′′ for Lupus IV, 240′′
for Ophiuchus, and 90′′ for Serpens); extinction maps are not yet available for the cores. We
did not attempt to derive quantitative estimates of the column density from the extinction
maps; instead, we examined the maps at the positions of the candidates and identified any
candidate located in a localized region of higher extinction as showing evidence for high
column density.
For the absorption against the mid-infrared background, we looked for "dark cores"
or "shadows" in the 8 and 24 µm images. We examined both the images themselves and
radial profiles of the background intensity. Figure 10 shows an example of a dark core at
the position of the candidate in L673-7 (source 031). While a quantitative analysis of the
extinction profile and column density through the core is possible (e.g., Stutz et al. 2007), it
is beyond the scope of this paper. Here we simply identified any candidates that appeared
to be located within such a dark core as showing evidence for high column density. An
important note is that, in both techniques, negative results do not rule out the possibility
of high column density. Very small, localized column density enhancements may not be
seen in the extinction maps due to beam dilution, and variations in the strength of both
the background and foreground emission will have a significant impact on the presence or
absence of absorption against the mid-infrared background. As a result, we consider cases
where data are available to evaluate the existence of regions of high column density but
return a negative result to be equivalent to cases where no such data are available.
5.1.2. Evaluating the Second Level
The second level is primarily evaluated by searching the region around a source for a
molecular outflow that is centered both spatially on the source and kinematically at the
velocity of the dense core with which the source is associated. Large-scale surveys of 12CO,
the primary tracer of molecular outflows, with the necessary sensitivity, spatial resolution,
and velocity resolution to detect molecular outflows are not as common as surveys of dust
– 26 –
continuum. In fact, the only such survey for the regions observed by c2d was a search for
outflows in Perseus by Hatchell et al. (2007b), and even this was not an unbiased survey
as they targeted known cores from a previous 850 µm dust continuum survey (Hatchell et
al. 2005). Thus, we searched the literature for each of the 218 candidates to find those
with known molecular outflows. Many candidates had no published 12CO observations,
including several candidates in Perseus that were not part of the Hatchell et al. (2007b)
survey. Some of these were observed at the CSO as part of a search for molecular outflows,
resulting in detections of outflows by us in L673-7 and L1251 (Sources 031, 044, and 045 from
this work; M. Dunham et al. 2008, in preparation; J.-E. Lee et al. 2008, in preparation).
While a positive result will prove a source is embedded in a dense core, a negative result
will not disprove this since the answer can depend on the available data. As an example,
L1014 (Source 038 from this work) showed no signs of driving an outflow from single-dish
molecular line observations (Crapsi et al. 2005a), but a compact, low-velocity 12CO (2-
1) outflow was discovered by Bourke et al. (2005) with the Submillimeter Array. Thus, in
evaluating whether each source shows evidence for being an embedded protostar, we consider
cases where observations tracing molecular outflows exist but no outflow is detected to be
equivalent to cases where no such observations exist.
We also use a 350 µm SHARC-II detection to satisfy the second level. As with all
submillimeter and millimeter observations of dust continuum emission, a detection with
SHARC-II indicates high volume density. However, unlike other observations of the dust
continuum, Wu et al. (2007) concluded that, through a combination of temperature and
instrumental effects, a SHARC-II 350 µm detection effectively always indicates that a core
has a protostar embedded within it.
Many of the 218 candidates have not been observed either in 12CO or with SHARC-
II at 350 µm. Both a search for molecular outflows and an extension of the SHARC-II
survey of dense cores presented by Wu et al. (2007) are on-going at the CSO (M. Dunham
et al. 2008, in preparation), but in the meantime, this leaves us unable to evaluate the
second level for many candidates. Thus, we also examine the IRAC 2 (4.5 µm) image for
each candidate to look for extended nebulosity or jets, suggesting the presence of molecular
outflows and outflow cavities. We specifically focus on 4.5 µm for two reasons: the wavelength
is short enough for scattered light off the edges of outflow cavities to often be visible, and the
photometric band overlaps with emission lines of molecular hydrogen shocked by outflows
(e.g., Noriega-Crespo et al. 2004). Examples of this are shown for Sources 001 and 004
from this work in Dunham et al. (2006) and Bourke et al. (2006), respectively. We do
not separately identify "extended nebulosity" and "jets"; instead we consider evidence for
either to be the same thing. While this is not strictly correct, it avoids the ambiguity
sometimes inherent in assigning extended structure one label or the other. Furthermore,
– 27 –
both are likely indicators of outflow activity, the actual source property of relevance for this
study. A positive result does not guarantee that the second level is satisfied, but it does add
to the likelihood that the source is an embedded object. Once again, however, a negative
result does not prove that the source is not embedded. To again use L1014 (Source 038) as
an example, it does not show any extended nebulosity or jet features in the 4.5 µm image
(or any other Spitzer image); only in deep near-infrared images is scattered light from an
outflow cavity seen (Huard et al. 2006). Thus, as above, we consider cases where 4.5 µm
Spitzer images are available but show no extended nebulosity and/or jets to be equivalent
to cases where no such images are available.
5.2. Assessing the Likelihood of Being Embedded
Based on the results of evaluating the two levels of certainty described above, we divide
the candidates into 6 groups of descending likelihood of being embedded protostars. We list
the groups in Table 9 and describe them below:
1. Group 1 consists of candidates that are confirmed as embedded, low-luminosity pro-
tostars. Existing observations confirm that sources in this group are embedded within
regions of high volume density.
2. Group 2 consists of candidates that have a very high likelihood of being embedded,
low-luminosity protostars. Sources in this group are associated with regions of high
volume density. They show extended nebulosity and/or jets in 4.5 µm Spitzer images,
but they are not confirmed to be embedded within the high-density regions, either
because no observations are available to evaluate this condition or such observations
are available but give a negative result.
3. Group 3 consists of candidates that have a high likelihood of being embedded, low-
luminosity protostars, although not as high as group 2 candidates. Similar to group
2, group 3 candidates are associated with regions of high volume density but are not
confirmed to be embedded within these regions. Unlike group 2, however, group 3
candidates are not associated with extended nebulosity and/or jets at 4.5 µm, either
because no such extended structure is detected or because 4.5 µm images are not
available.
4. Group 4 consists of candidates that show evidence for being embedded, low-luminosity
protostars but lack confirmation that either level of certainty is fulfilled. Sources in this
group have no available observations to evaluate whether or not they are associated
– 28 –
with regions of high volume density and either no available observations or observations
giving a negative result on whether or not they are embedded within regions of high
volume density. These sources either are associated with regions of high column density
and show extended nebulosity and/or jets in 4.5 µm Spitzer images (group 4a), are
only associated with regions of high column density (group 4b), or only show extended
nebulosity and/or jets in 4.5 µm Spitzer images (group 4c).
5. Group 5 consists of candidates that might be embedded, low-luminosity protostars,
but show no sign of being such objects in their limited available data. Sources in this
group have no available observations to evaluate whether or not they are associated
with regions of high volume density and either no available observations or observations
returning a negative result for proving they are embedded within dense regions, evalu-
ating their association with regions of high column density, and identifying nebulosity
or jets at 4.5 µm.
6. Group 6 consists of candidates that are most likely not embedded, low-luminosity
protostars. Observations show that sources in this group are not associated with regions
of high volume density, with the important caveat that most dust continuum emission
surveys used to search for regions of high volume density are only complete to cores
with masses ≥ 0.1 − 1.0 M⊙ (e.g., Enoch et al. 2007).
The last column of Table 9 lists the total number of the 218 candidates in each of the
groups. Table 10 lists, for all 218 candidates, sorted by group, the source number, cloud
or core region in which the source is located, LIR, the status of 160 µm observations for
this source, and the SIMBAD name of the source, where applicable. If a candidate is not
associated with an infrared or radio point source in SIMBAD, we give the name of the
nearest extended dense core within a search radius of 1′. Note that this does not guarantee
the candidate is embedded within this core.
We find that 149 of the 218 candidates are in either group 5 or group 6 and thus show no
evidence for being embedded, low-luminosity protostars. A fraction of these 149 candidates
are likely real embedded sources that simply lack complementary data of sufficient quality
to prove this; these sources should be re-evaluated as additional surveys of these regions
become available. Most, however, are likely either galaxies or more evolved sources no
longer embedded within dense cores, consistent with our earlier claim that as many as 98 of
the candidates may be extra-galactic in nature (§5). This leaves 69/218 candidates that, at
minimum, show some evidence for being embedded objects. We are able to obtain complete
SEDs for 50 of these 69 candidates; these SEDs are listed in Table 11. We consider only
these 50 sources in the rest of the paper. Of the 19 remaining candidates, 16 are located
– 29 –
close enough to other sources that they cannot be separated into individual sources at 70
µm; these are discussed below. Two sources, 027 and 202, are not covered by the 70 µm
c2d observations and have no obvious association with IRAS 60 µm sources. As 70 µm is
an essential wavelength for this study (see below), we do not list these objects in Table 11.
The last remaining source is Source 132, which is identical to Source 017 as it was observed
by both IRAC and MIPS in the map of the dense core DC303.8−14.2 and by MIPS in the
map of Chamaeleon II. We thus remove Source 132 from consideration to avoid duplication.
5.3. Effects of Confused 70 µm Data
Good quality 70 µm data are essential to this study. Photometry at this wavelength is
important for distinguishing between SEDs of embedded protostars and more evolved YSOs
no longer embedded in dense cores (§3.1; §4.2), and for deriving accurate protostellar internal
luminosities (§3.2). However, the MIPS 70 µm PSF is ∼ 18′′, compared to 6′′ at 24 µm and
2′′ at 3.6 − 8.0 µm. Embedded protostars spaced by more than 6′′ but less than 18′′ will
be resolved into individual sources at 24 µm and thus identified by our selection criteria,
but confused at 70 µm. Various methods exist for dividing the total 70 µm flux among the
confused sources, such as by the ratio of 24 µm fluxes of each source (e.g., Lee et al. 2006),
but all such methods introduce large uncertainties.
Of the 69 candidates that show at least some evidence for being embedded objects, 16
are located too close to other objects to resolve into individual sources at 70 µm4. Many
likely have Lint ≥ 1.0 L⊙ and are thus not relevant to this study, since most have values of
LIR, integrated only to 24 µm, greater than 0.1 L⊙. However, a few might be embedded,
low-luminosity protostars. We do not list any of these 16 candidates in Table 11 and do
not consider them in the analysis discussed below. Higher-resolution far-infrared data (e.g.,
Herschel) will be necessary to evaluate the nature of these objects.
6. Discussion
6.1. Estimating Internal Luminosities and the Luminosity Distribution
The internal luminosity is a key parameter in understanding the evolution of an object
from dense core to star, but for low-luminosity, embedded protostars, it is not a directly
4The source numbers are 002, 006, 027, 048, 049, 055, 056, 073, 208, 210, 213, 214, 215, 108, 211, 212.
– 30 –
observable quantity since a significant component of the bolometric luminosity will arise
from external heating by the ISRF. In §3, we presented two methods of estimating Lint based
on observable quantities. The first estimate is based on the result that an approximately
constant ratio exists between Lint and LIR, where LIR is an observable quantity. We call
this estimate of the internal luminosity LIR
int. The second estimate is based on the tight
correlation observed between the 70 µm flux, scaled to the value it would have if the source
were located at 140 pc, and the internal luminosity. This estimate, which we call L70
int, is
given by Equation 2.
int vs. L70
Figure 11, which plots LIR
int, demonstrates that the two estimates agree to within
a factor of two of each other for nearly all of the sources. We consider L70
int to be a more
accurate estimate of Lint, both because nearly identical relationships between Lint and 70
µm flux normalized to 140 pc were derived separately from observations of protostars and a
large grid of models and because LIR
int is based on a relationship between Lint and LIR that
shows some variation from source to source. Throughout the rest of this paper we use L70
int
when we refer to internal luminosities. Detailed radiative transfer modeling of each source
is necessary to obtain more accurate internal luminosities.
Figure 12 shows the distribution of Log(Lint) for the 50 objects listed in Table 11. The
decrease in the number of protostars near Lint ∼ 1 L⊙ is an artifact introduced by requiring
that all sources have LIR ≤ 0.5 L⊙, which is roughly equivalent, but not identical, to requiring
that all sources have Lint ≤ 1.0 L⊙ given that the ratio of Lint/LIR has a weighted average
of 1.7 but varies from source to source. The full distribution of protostellar luminosities will
be examined in a future paper (Evans et al. 2008, in preparation) that combines this work
with other, complementary searches for embedded protostars in the c2d sample (e.g., Enoch
2007; Enoch et al. 2008a, in preparation; Jørgensen et al. 2007; Jørgensen et al. 2008, in
preparation). Here we only focus on the low end of the distribution.
We find that 15/50 (30%) of the objects identified here have Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙ and are thus
classified as VeLLOs. Qualitatively speaking, this indicates that there are more embedded
protostars at lower luminosities than at higher luminosities (if they were distributed evenly
in luminosity, only 10% would have Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙). To quantify this, Figure 13 shows the
distribution of source internal luminosities, cut off at Lint = 0.5 L⊙ since our sample is likely
incomplete near 1 L⊙. A visual inspection of this figure suggests that the distribution is not
uniform but increases with decreasing luminosity. Applying a K-S test, we find that there is
a 94.2% probability that these sources are not drawn from a uniform luminosity distribution.
The implications of this increase in number of protostars with decreasing luminosity will be
explored in §6.4.
Six VeLLOs have internal luminosities lower than our sensitivity limit for the most
– 31 –
distant regions (∼ 5 × 10−2 L⊙), raising the question of how many such sources we miss in
the more distant regions of our sample. A discussion of correction for completeness due to
the non-uniform distances to observed regions is presented in Appendix A. Based on this
discussion, we conclude that only ∼ 2 sources with luminosities between our sensitivity limit
for the closest regions (Lint = 2.5×10−3 L⊙) and the most distant regions (Lint = 5×10−2 L⊙)
are missed. Also based on Appendix A, we conclude that the intrinsic luminosity distribution
does not continue to increase below Lint = 0.1 L⊙, although there are sources present all the
way down to the sensitivity limit. Finally, we note that we can not draw any conclusions
about the possible presence of objects with extremely low luminosities below ∼ 10−3 L⊙.
Future infrared facilities with sensitivities much greater than that of Spitzer will be required
to search for such objects and determine the true lower limit to the intrinsic luminosity
distribution.
The above conclusions are based on the analysis presented in Appendix A. This analysis
assumes that all sources with luminosities above our sensitivity limit of Lint = 4 × 10−3
(d/140 pc)2 L⊙ are in fact identified. To verify that this is indeed the case, we re-examine
the criteria described in §3. The only criterion that could potentially filter out sources with
very low luminosities is the requirement that a source not be classified as a candidate galaxy
in the classification method of Harvey et al. (2007b) unless Log(Pgal) ≤ −1.25, since several
of the steps in this classification method are based on the general fact that galaxies are faint
(see Harvey et al. for details).
Using Perseus as an example, we re-applied our selection criteria, leaving out the step
that filters out candidate galaxies with Log(Pgal) ≥ −1.25. This results in only an additional
36 sources, since most of the additional sources that would otherwise be selected are rejected
because they are not detected at 70 µm. We visually inspected these sources and rejected
14 based on either showing obvious galaxy morpologies or not being real sources (see §3.4
for details). This left us with 22 sources. The positions of all 22 sources were covered by at
least one of the three submillimeter/millimeter dust continuum emission surveys of Perseus
listed in §5.1.1, but none were associated with dense cores. All 22 sources would thus be
placed into group 6 in the terminology of §5.2. We conclude that we do indeed identify all
sources above our sensitivity limit.
6.2. Evolutionary Indicators
For the 50 objects with complete SEDs listed in Table 11, we calculate the following
quantities: the bolometric luminosity (Lbol), the ratio of bolometric to submillimeter lumi-
nosity (Lbol/Lsmm), and the bolometric temperature (Tbol). Lbol is calculated by intergrating
– 32 –
over the full observed SED,
Lbol = 4πd2Z ∞
0
Sνdν
,
(4)
while the submillimeter luminosity is calculated by integrating over the observed SED for λ
≥ 350 µm,
Lsmm = 4πd2Z ν=c/350 µm
0
Sνdν
.
(5)
The bolometric temperature is defined to be the temperature of a blackbody with the same
flux-weighted mean frequency as the source (Myers & Ladd 1993). Following Myers & Ladd,
Tbol is calculated as
Tbol = 1.25 × 10−11 R ∞
R ∞
0 νSνdν
0 Sνdν
K
.
(6)
We list Lbol, Lbol/Lsmm, and Tbol for these 50 objects in the last column of Table 11. The
stated uncertainties reflect only those arising from measurement error. Since we are inte-
grating over finitely sampled SEDs, the values calculated for all three quantities will depend
on how well each SED is sampled. We discuss the errors introduced by incomplete sampling
in Appendix B.
6.2.1. Bolometric Luminosity-Temperature (BLT) Diagram
Figure 14 places the 50 objects listed in Table 11 on Figure 19 from Young & Evans
(2005), which plots Lbol vs. Tbol. As discussed by Myers et al. (1998), who refer to this
as a Bolometric Luminosity-Temperature (BLT) diagram, this is effectively a Hertzsprung-
Russell diagram for protostars. The lines show the evolutionary tracks followed by various
models from Young & Evans (2005) and Myers et al. (1998). In general, models predict
that protostars form at low values of Lbol and Tbol and move up and to the left (increasing
Lbol, increasing Tbol) as the protostar grows. Whether or not Lbol steadily increases or
begins to decrease depends on the details of the mass accretion process. Young & Evans
considered the collapse of a singular isothermal sphere in the "standard model" of star
formation (Shu, Adams, & Lizano 1987), which features a constant mass accretion rate over
the entire protostellar phase. Myers et al.
(1998), on the other hand, assume that the
accretion rate decreases exponentially with time and mass is lost from the system (from
outflows, winds, etc.), explaining the different trends shown by their evolutionary tracks.
The colors/symbols of the points in Figure 14 for the 50 objects from this work reflect
how well the source SED is sampled. All four colors/symbols have SEDs that are sampled
at 1.25 − 70 µm by 2MASS and Spitzer and at millimeter wavelengths. Black circles are also
– 33 –
sampled at, at minimum, one wavelength in both the 100−200 and 350−450 µm wavelength
ranges (category 1 SEDs in the notation of Appendix B). Blue triangles are sampled between
350−450 µm but not 100−200 µm (category 2 SEDs). Green diamonds are sampled between
100−200 µm but not 350−450 µm (category 3 SEDs). Red squares are not sampled in either
wavelength range (category 4 SEDs). A detailed analysis of the errors introduced by the
incomplete sampling in these various categories is presented in Appendix B; here we simply
note that, depending on the category, the error in Lbol and Tbol is between approximately
20 − 60%.
There are many Class I sources (Tbol ≥ 70 K; Chen et al.
[1995]) with Lbol below
any evolutionary track by up to an order of magnitude. The most extreme cases are all
sources with category 4 SEDs, where Lbol is underestimated by ∼ 50%, on average. However,
even accounting for this, many are still substantially below any of the evolutionary tracks.
A similar result was found by Enoch (2007) and Enoch et al.
(2008a, in preparation),
who suggest episodic accretion as a potential solution. Another potential explanation for
this discrepancy is that the sources with the lowest Lbol are simply those with envelope
masses below those considered in the models. However, this is ruled out by Enoch et al.,
who find good agreement between observations and models when comparing envelope mass
vs. bolometric temperature despite the scatter seen in BLT diagrams, as well as several
individual studies of VeLLOs that conclude at least some of the lowest-luminosity protostars
are embedded in envelopes with masses similar to those of more luminous protostars (a few
M⊙; Young et al. 2004; Bourke et al. 2006; Dunham et al. 2006).
A similar population of Class 0 objects with luminosities below model predictions is
not as apparent from Figure 14, and is also not seen by Enoch et al. However, on average,
external heating from the ISRF will add a larger contribution to Lbol for objects with more
massive envelopes, thus such heating is likely to be more significant for Class 0 objects than
Class I objects and can add up to several tenths of a solar luminosity to Lbol (e.g., Evans et
al. 2001). Since, as described in §1, this distinction between Lbol and Lint is most relevant for
very low-luminosity sources where external heating from the ISRF can dominate the total
observed Lbol, a similar population of Class 0 objects with very low luminosities may be
present but not readily apparent when examining a plot of Lbol vs. Tbol. We return to this
point in §6.4.
6.2.2. Comparison of two Indicators of Evolutionary Status
Both Tbol and Lbol/Lsmm are indicators of the evolutionary status of a protostar. As
the envelope mass decreases through a combination of accretion and dissipation processes,
– 34 –
both quantities should increase. Eventually, once the star has fully formed, Tbol will become
equal to Tef f and Lbol/Lsmm will become very large. We show a plot of Lbol/Lsmm vs. Tbol
for the objects considered here in Figure 15. The division between Class 0/I objects in Tbol
is from Chen et al. (1995), while the division between Class 0/I and Class I/II objects in
Lbol/Lsmm is from Young & Evans (2005). The colors/symbols of the data points hold the
same meaning as in Figure 14.
As stated in §4.1, the distinction between a Stage 0 and Stage I object is that a Stage 0
object still has more than half of the total mass of the system in the envelope, whereas less
than half the total mass remains in the envelope of a Stage I object. Both Tbol and Lbol/Lsmm
are used to separate embedded objects into Class 0 and Class I objects; in principle, these
observational classes should correspond to Stage 0 and Stage I objects. Young & Evans
(2005) concluded that Lbol/Lsmm is a better measure of physical stage than Tbol, since their
evolutionary models of different initial mass cores featured similar values of Lbol/Lsmm but
different values of Tbol when they reached the point at which half of the total mass had
accreted onto the protostar. They also found that embedded objects cross the Class 0/I
boundary in Tbol (Tbol = 70K; Chen et al. 1995) when they are still Stage 0 objects. We
see a similar trend in Figure 15 in that several objects are Class I objects according to Tbol
but Class 0 objects according to Lbol/Lsmm. However, we caution that the details of where
the observed SED is sampled affect the calculated value of Lbol/Lsmm significantly more
than the calculated value of Tbol; this explains the objects seen in Figure 15 with extremely
high values of Lbol/Lsmm (see Appendix B). Great care must be taken to consider the errors
introduced by incomplete sampling before using Lbol/Lsmm as an evolutionary indicator for
any particular object.
6.3. Fraction of Starless Cores that Remain Starless
Out of the 95 individual dense cores observed by c2d5, 67 (∼70%) were classified as
starless prior to being observed by Spitzer. The very first starless core observed, L1014, was
found to actually harbor a very low-luminosity, embedded protostar (Lint ∼ 0.09 L⊙; Young
et al. 2004; Bourke et al. 2005; Huard et al. 2005). This naturally gives rise to the question
of how many cores classified as starless prior to the launch of Spitzer remain so after being
5Evans et al. (2007) list the 82 core regions surveyed by c2d. Those regions that covered multiple cores are
as follows (see also Evans et al. 2003 and references therein): CB130-3 (CB130-1, CB130-2, and CB130-3),
CG30-31 (CG30, CG31A, CG31B, CG31C), IRAM04191+1522 (IRAM04191+1522 and IRAS04191+1523),
L1251 (L1251A, L1251C, and L1251E), L43 (L43-East and L43-RNO91), L673 (L673-SMM1 and L673-
SMM2), and TMC1 (TMC1-1, TMC1-2, TMC1-1C-1, and TMC1-1C-2).
– 35 –
observed with Spitzer ? A substantial number of protostellar cores misclassified as starless
cores would result in an incorrect estimate of the lifetime of the starless core phase6, as such
estimates are derived by comparing the numbers of starless and protostellar cores (e.g., Kirk
et al. 2005; Enoch et al. 2008b). Kirk et al. (2007) present the results of a search for
embedded, low-luminosity protostars in Spitzer observations of 22 starless cores previously
studied using submillimeter data (Kirk et al. 2005); they find only one such source, L1521F-
IRS (Bourke et al. 2006). This suggests that ∼95% of starless cores remain starless, leading
them to conclude that the errors in starless core lifetime estimates introduced by previously
undetected, low-luminosity protostars are smaller than the uncertainties in such estimates.
Our sample of 67 starless cores allows us to test these conclusions with a dataset approx-
imately three times larger than that of Kirk et al. (2007). Searching all 95 cores considered
here, we have identified a total of 49 candidate embedded, low-luminosity protostars in 33
different cores (Table 3). Seventeen of these cores were classified as starless prior to being
observed by Spitzer. If we restrict ourselves only to those sources in Groups 1 − 4, those
that, at minimum, show some additional evidence of being embedded protostars besides the
shapes of their SEDs, we identify 29 candidates in 21 different cores, 9 of which were classified
as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer. Thus, between 9 and 17 out of the 67 starless
cores actually harbor embedded, low-luminosity protostars. Approximately 75−85% of star-
less cores remain starless down to our luminosity sensitivity of Lint ≥ 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2.
Most starless cores do indeed remain starless after being observed by Spitzer, in agreement
with Kirk et al. (2007), although the fraction is smaller than they found with their smaller
sample.
6.4. Non-Steady Mass Accretion
In this work, we have identified a sample of 50 embedded protostars with Lint ≤ 1.0
L⊙; 15 of these objects have Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙ and are thus classified as VeLLOs. Assuming
spherical mass accretion at the rate predicted by the standard model ( Macc ∼ 2 × 10−6
M⊙ yr−1; Shu, Adams, & Lizano 1987) onto an object with a typical protostellar radius of
R ∼ 3 R⊙, a protostar located on the stellar/substellar boundary (M = 0.08 M⊙) would
have an accretion luminosity, Lacc = GM Macc
, of L ∼ 1.6 L⊙. The objects identified here
are difficult to understand in the context of the standard model of star formation. VeLLOs,
with luminosities more than an order of magnitude lower than the above calculation, are
R
6In actuality, this is an estimate of the lifetime of the portion of the starless core phase detectable by
(sub)millimeter observations. This is often referred to as the pre-stellar core phase (Kirk et al. 2005).
– 36 –
an extreme example of this problem. If the objects identified here were observed edge-on
through circumstellar disks their luminosities could possibly be underestimated, but, for at
least some of them, this possibility can be eliminated (e.g., IRAM04191, Dunham et al.
2006). Thus, they must either feature mass accretion rates far below that predicted by the
standard model, masses far below the stellar/substellar boundary, or some combination of
the two. Several authors have invoked episodic accretion to explain the existence of these
low-luminosity objects (e.g., Kenyon & Hartmann 1995; Young & Evans 2005; Enoch 2007;
Enoch et al. 2008a, in preparation).
Strong evidence for non-steady mass accretion exists for the VeLLO IRAM 04191-IRS.
This object drives a well-defined, bipolar molecular outflow (Andr´e et al. 1999). Taking the
average mass accretion rate implied by the outflow and the dynamical time of this outflow
(h Macci ∼ 5 × 10−6 M⊙ yr−1 and td ∼ 104 years), Andr´e et al.
(1999) calculate that a
protostellar mass of 0.05 M⊙ will have accreted over the lifetime of the outflow. Accretion at
this rate onto an object with a mass of 0.05 M⊙ and a radius of 3 R⊙ would give rise to an
accretion luminosity of Lacc ∼ 2 L⊙. This is clearly inconsistent with the internal luminosity
of Lint ∼ 0.08 L⊙ derived by Dunham et al. (2006). Dunham et al. suggested non-steady
mass accretion to resolve this inconsistency: the current mass accretion rate must be much
lower than the average rate over the lifetime of the outflow.
We show the location of the 15 VeLLOs in our sample on the BLT diagram in Figure
16. Most are located at Tbol < 70 K and Lbol > 0.1 L⊙ and are thus Class 0 objects with very
low internal luminosities but bolometric luminosities that generally appear consistent with
evolutionary tracks. If there is a population of Class 0 objects with luminosities lower than
predicted by evolutionary tracks, as is the case for Class I objects (see §6.2.1), the inconsis-
tency between the luminosities of these Class 0 objects and the predictions of evolutionary
tracks will likely be masked on a BLT diagram since, as described in §6.2.1, the contribution
to Lbol from external heating will be larger for younger objects with more massive envelopes.
In addition to Lbol and Tbol, considering time as a third dimension relevant to protostellar
evolution can help illuminate whether or not these Class 0 objects with Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙ but
Lbol > 0.1 L⊙ are truly as consistent with constant mass-accretion evolutionary tracks as
they appear to be on a BLT diagram.
Assuming a constant rate of mass accretion, the protostellar mass M will grow linearly
with time.
If we assume the protostellar radius remains fixed, Lacc ∝ M and thus also
grows linearly with time. Adding in the assumption that star formation has been occuring
continuously over a time much longer than the lifetime of the embedded phase, the number
of protostars as a function of luminosity should be constant. However, as discussed in §6.1,
the intrinsic luminosity distribution is not uniform and instead increases with decreasing
– 37 –
luminosity. Even though many of the lowest luminosity objects appear consistent with the
location of evolutionary tracks calculated assuming constant mass accretion, there are too
many relative to higher luminosity sources to explain by constant mass accretion.
We have presented evidence for non-steady mass accretion in low-mass protostars, both
from the above statistical argument and from a detailed study of one individual source (Dun-
ham et al. 2006). While we note here that non-steady mass accretion does not necessarily
imply episodic mass accretion, these results, combined with other studies that find clear evi-
dence for episodicity in outflow activity (e.g., HH211; Lee et al. 2007), strongly suggest that
protostellar mass accretion is episodic in nature. Future work is needed on both observational
and theoretical fronts to better understand the implications of the objects identified in this
study on the mass accretion process in low-mass star formation. On the observational front,
the detailed study of the outflow driven by IRAM04191 must be repeated for other sources
known to drive outflows, and dedicated outflow searches are needed towards objects lacking
such data. Additionally, detailed chemical and physical studies of the objects identified in
this work are needed to explore the nature of these sources beyond the simple evolutionary
indicators calculated here. Such studies are of particular relevance to understanding the
evolution of starless cores and identifying those cores on the verge of collapse since VeLLOs
have been discovered in cores that were classified as starless prior to Spitzer observations
but were not always those cores believed to be the most evolved and nearest to the onset
of collapse (Crapsi et al. 2005b; Bourke et al. 2006). Chemical studies can also be used
to distinguish between low-luminosity protostars that have featured higher past luminosities
(presumably through higher past mass accretion rates) and those that have always featured
such low luminosities (e.g., Lee 2008). Candidates identified in this study that show no evi-
dence for being embedded in dense cores should be re-examined as additional data on each
source becomes available (e.g., through large-scale surveys with Herschel, SCUBA-2, etc.)
to ensure as complete a sample as possible. Finally, the full sample of embedded, low-mass
protostars must be assembled from this work and the various other searches for such objects
outlined in §1.
On the theoretical front, evolutionary models predicting the observational signatures of
dense cores forming stars must be revisited. These models must be able to explain both the
existence of embedded protostars with luminosities much lower than predicted by current
models and the very large scatter in Lbol observed at each value of Tbol in Figure 14. Models
that incorporate episodic mass accretion and the effects of source geometry may provide
such explanations, but will require higher dimensions than the 1-D models considered by us
to date.
– 38 –
7. Conclusions
We have conducted a search for all embedded protostars with Lint ≤ 1.0 L⊙ in the
c2d dataset of nearby, low-mass star-forming regions. We identify 218 candidates from the
Spitzer data alone; examining all available complementary data for each candidate results
in a sample of 50 objects that show at least some evidence that they are indeed embedded
within dense cores. A summary of our major results is as follows:
• On average, the Spitzer c2d data are sensitive to embedded protostars with Lint ≥
4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙, a factor of 25 better than the sensitivity of the Infrared
Astronomical Satellite (IRAS) to such objects.
• The 70 µm flux and internal luminosity of a protostar are tightly correlated. As the
former is a directly observable quantity but the latter is not, this correlation gives a
powerful method for estimating protostellar internal luminosities when detailed radia-
tive transfer models for each source are lacking.
• Of the 50 objects in our sample, 15 (30%) have Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙ and are thus classified as
VeLLOs. The distribution of source luminosities is not uniform and instead increases
with decreasing luminosity. Accounting for incompleteness arising from non-uniform
distances to the observed regions, we find sources down to the above sensitivity limit,
indicating that the intrinsic luminosity distribution may extend to lower luminosities
than probed by these observations. Despite this, we are able to rule out a continued
rise in the distribution below Lint = 0.1 L⊙.
• Between 75 − 85% of cores classified as starless prior to being observed by Spitzer
remain starless down to the above luminosity sensitivity; the remaining 15 − 25%
harbor low-luminosity, embedded protostars. This is in general agreement with Kirk
et al. (2007), who examined archival Spitzer data of 22 starless cores and found only
one to be harboring a low-luminosity protostar. However, with our larger sample size,
we are able to better constrain the fraction of cores previously classified as starless that
in fact harbor such objects. We confirm that recent estimates of starless core lifetimes
(e.g., Kirk et al. 2005; Enoch et al. 2008b) do not feature large errors introduced by
previously undetected, low-luminosity protostars.
• The observed luminosity distribution for embedded objects with Lint ≤ 1.0 L⊙ is incon-
sistent with the simplest picture of star formation wherein mass accretes from the core
onto the protostar at a constant rate. Combining this result with other studies that
find clear indications of episodic outflow activity strongly suggests that protostellar
mass accretion is episodic in nature.
– 39 –
We have outlined several avenues of future work that must be pursued now that rela-
tively complete and unbiased samples of embedded, low-mass protostars are being compiled.
Only with such future studies can we begin to build a coherent picture of low-mass star
formation consistent with the growing observational database provided by systematic, large-
scale surveys of low-mass star forming regions.
The authors thank M. Enoch for providing the data used in Figure 8, as well as for
several helpful discussions that have improved the quality of this paper. We express our
gratitude to the anonymous referee for several comments that have improved the quality of
this publication. We thank Jes Jørgensen and Paul Harvey for providing helpfuul comments,
and we also thank Jes Jørgensen for his IDL scripts to display three-color images. This work
is based primarily on observations obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope, operated by the
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology. We thank the Lorentz Center
in Leiden for hosting several meetings that contributed to this paper. This publication makes
use of the Protostars Webpage hosted by the University of Kent, as well as data products from
the Two Micron All Sky Survey, which is a joint project of the University of Massachusetts
and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center/California Institute of Technology, funded
by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and the National Science Foundation.
These data were provided by the NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive, which is operated
by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with
NASA. This research has made use of NASA's Astrophysics Data System (ADS) Abstract
Service and of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France. Support for
this work, part of the Spitzer Legacy Science Program, was provided by NASA through
contracts 1224608 and 1288658 issued by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute
of Technology, under NASA contract 1407. Support was also provided by NASA Origins
grants NNG04GG24G, NNX07AJ72G, and NAG5-13050.
A.
Internal Luminosity Completeness and the Intrinsic Luminosity
Distribution
The regions observed by c2d are located at distances ranging from 125 − 500 pc. Using
the result from §3.1 that our observations are sensitive to embedded protostars with Lint
≥ 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙, the effect of these non-uniform distances is that our sensitivity to
embedded protostars varies between 2.5 × 10−3 and 5 × 10−2 L⊙. Two important questions
thus arise: (1) How many objects are lost because of these non-uniform sensitivities (stated
another way, how many additional objects would we expect to identify if all observed regions
were located at the distance of the closest regions)?, and (2) What conclusions can be drawn
– 40 –
about the intrinsic luminosity distribution? The latter is of particular significance to future
work aimed at explaining the observed distribution of sources in Lbol-Tbol space through
evolutionary modeling.
A.1.
Internal Luminosity Completeness
The regions observed consist of both targeted observations of 82 regions with 95 dense
cores and unbiased surveys of 5 large, molecular clouds (§2). Thus, an analysis of complete-
ness that uses the area observed at different distances is incorrect since the sample consists
both of observations biased towards dense cores and observations with no such bias. Instead,
we start from the total number of dense cores observed at different distances since all em-
bedded protostars are, by definition, within these cores. The sample consists of 122 cores in
Perseus (Enoch et al. 2006), 35 cores in Serpens (Enoch et al. 2007), and 48 cores in Ophi-
uchus (Young et al. 2006b), along with the targeted observations of 95 cores. This yields
a total of 300 cores; the distribution of the sensitivity to protostars embedded within these
cores is shown in Figure 17. We have no information on the number of dense cores in the
Lupus and Chamaeleon II clouds; any such cores have comparable luminosity sensitivities
to the rest of the sample (Figure 17).
To start with a simple analysis, we ask what percentage of the cores are located at
distances close enough such that sources in each of the lowest three bins of Figure 12 could
be detected. Statistically, this should be equal to the percentage of sources in that bin we
are able to detect. All of the cores are located at distances such that sources in the bin -1.2
≤ Log(Lint/L⊙) ≤ -0.9 could be detected, thus we are complete to sources in this bin. 96%
of the cores are located at distances such that sources in the bin -1.5 ≤ Log(Lint/L⊙) ≤
-1.2 could be detected; correcting for completeness raises the total number of sources in
this bin from 5 to 5.2. 90% of the cores are located at distances such that sources in the
bin -1.8 ≤ Log(Lint/L⊙) ≤ -1.5 could be detected; correcting for completeness raises the
total number of sources in this bin from 4 to 4.4. We conclude that we miss, at most, 1
source in the range -1.8 ≤ Log(Lint/L⊙) ≤ -0.9; this is actually a strong upper limit since
the percentage of cores with distances close enough to detect sources in these bins would
increase if the dense cores in the Lupus and Chamaeleon II clouds were included. However,
this says nothing about the bins that are above our sensitivity limit for the nearest regions
(2.5 × 10−3 L⊙) in which we detect no sources. To examine the completeness in these bins,
and confirm the above results, we turn to a Monte Carlo simulation.
For the Monte Carlo simulation, we create a sample of 10,000 embedded protostars. We
assign an internal luminosity to each protostar from a distribution specified at the start; in
– 41 –
all cases, this distribution has a maximum of Lint = 0.1 L⊙. We then randomly place each of
the 10,000 sources in one of the 300 dense cores. If a source has Lint less than the sensitivity
limit for the core in which it is placed, it is considered "missed" by our observations and
rejected; otherwise, the source is kept. We run the simulation 1000 times, average the results,
and compare the observed distribution of Lint for the 15 VeLLOs with the average simulated
observed distribution.
Figure 18 shows the results of a simulation where the 10,000 sources have internal
luminosities evenly distributed (in linear space) between 10−5 and 10−1 L⊙. The normalized
observed distributions of Lint for the 15 VeLLOs identified by this work and for the simulated
sources agree given the uncertainties due to small number statistics. Furthermore, since we
detect no sources with Log(Lint) ≤ −1.8, we can set an upper limit of ≤ 1/15 sources (or
≤ 7% of all sources detected) have such luminosities. Out of all the sources detected in the
Monte Carlo simulation, 6.1% have such luminosities, consistent with the observed upper
limit of 7%.
Out of the 10,000 sources considered by this simulation, 1158 (12%) have luminosities
below the sensitivity limit of the core in which they are placed and are thus "missed" by our
observations. This means that the 15 VeLLOs identified are only 88% of the total number of
objects, indicating that approximately 2 sources are missed. The exact details of the input
luminosity distribution do not affect these results, as long as the simulation is consistent
with the upper limit on the number of detected sources with Log(Lint) ≤ −1.8 described
above. Input luminosity distributions that have a much larger fraction of sources at lower
luminosities, such as a distribution flat in log space, would lead to an increase in the number
of sources missed. However, such distributions are inconsistent with the above upper limit
(for example, a simulation with an input luminosity distribution flat in log space between
10−3 and 10−1 L⊙ results in 24% of the total sources detected having Log(Lint) ≤ −1.8,
clearly inconsistent with the observed upper limit of 7%). Thus, we conclude that ∼ 2
sources are missed due to the non-uniform distances of the observed regions.
A.2.
Intrinsic Luminosity Distribution
We now consider what constraints we can place on the low end of the intrinsic luminosity
distribution. Additional constraints will be provided by a future paper aimed at analyzing
the shape of the full luminosity distribution, including higher luminosity sources (Evans et
al. 2008, in preparation). These constraints will serve as guides to future work aimed at
explaining the full distribution of sources in Lbol-Tbol space.
– 42 –
As stated in §6.1, the intrinsic luminosity distribution for the objects identified here
increases to lower luminosities. To examine whether or not this increase continues to our
sensitivity limit, Figure 19 shows the distribution of internal luminosities, in linear bins
of 0.01 L⊙, for the 15 objects with Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙. Considering the small sample size,
this distribution appears uniform down to Lint = 0.02 L⊙. From the discussion above,
approximately two sources are missing from this figure because of incompleteness arising
from the non-uniform distances to the observed regions. Additionally, a strong upper limit
of 1 source is lost due to incompleteness for Lint ≥ 10−1.8 L⊙ (denoted by the dashed line
in Figure 19), suggesting that the sources missing due to incompleteness likely fall in the
lowest two bins. Taking into account the small sample size, adding ∼ 2 sources to these two
bins results in a distribution that appears approximately uniform all the way down to the
sensitivity limit (denoted by the dotted line in Figure 19). This suggests that the intrinsic
luminosity distribution may extend to lower luminosities than probed by these observations.
However, even if all missed sources fall in the lowest bin of Figure 19, this portion of the
intrinsic luminosity distribution (Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙) would appear to be uniform rather than
increasing to lower luminosities. We thus conclude that the instrinsic luminosity distribution
does not continue to increase to our sensitivity limit, although K-S tests should be used to
quantitatively confirm this result once a larger sample becomes available.
This result provides an important constraint for future attempts at understanding these
very low luminosity objects. However, we caution that we can draw no conclusions about
the possible presence of objects with luminosities below ∼ 10−3 L⊙. To illustrate this with
an example, Figure 20 shows the results of a Monte Carlo simulation where half of the 10,000
sources have luminosities evenly distributed between 10−4 and 10−3 L⊙, while the other half
have luminosities evenly distributed between 10−3 and 10−1 L⊙. The simulated observed
distribution matches the observed distribution quite well; the population of objects with
Lint between 10−4 and 10−3 L⊙ have no effect on the final result since none of them are
detected. A large population of embedded objects with such low luminosities would be very
difficult to explain physically (see discussion of VeLLOs in §6.4), but we cannot rule out the
presence of such objects based on these observations.
B. Errors in Evolutionary Indicators From Incomplete, Finitely Sampled
Spectral Energy Distributions
The integrals defined in Equations 4 − 6 are evaluated using the trapezoid rule to
integrate over the finitely sampled source SEDs. The contribution δi to the total integral
– 43 –
from measurements yi and yi+1, measured at xi and xi+1, is
δi = (xi+1 − xi) (cid:18)yi+1 + yi
2
(cid:19)
.
(B1)
The total value of the integral is then the sum of each individual δi.
Clearly, the result will depend on how well the source SED is sampled, especially near
the peak. Most of the material in the envelope of embedded objects is cold (10 − 15 K;
e.g., Evans et al. 2001; Shirley et al. 2002). The emission peaks from blackbodies with
temperatures of 10 and 20 K are located at approximately 500 and 250 µm, respectively,
overlapping with the ∼ 50 − 300 µm far-infrared regime that cannot be observed from the
ground.
Incomplete sampling near the peak may thus introduce significant errors in the
calculations of Lbol, Tbol, and Lbol/Lsmm.
To quantify these errors, we consider the 13 group 1 candidates in Perseus. Most of these
sources have well-sampled SEDs, with 2MASS and Spitzer detections from 1.25 − 70 µm,
Spitzer detections at 160 µm and possibly IRAS detections at 100 µm, SHARC-II detections
at 350 µm, SCUBA detections at 450 and 850 µm, and Bolocam detections at 1.1 mm. We
construct four SEDs for each source:
1. We include all detections. These "category 1" SEDs are those that are the most
completely sampled.
2. We only include detections in the wavelength ranges 1.25 ≤ λ ≤ 70 µm and λ ≥ 350
µm. These "category 2" SEDs are meant to simulate sources for which 2MASS and
Spitzer 1 − 70 µm data, 350 or 450 µm submillimeter data, and millimeter wavelength
data are available, but neither Spitzer 160 µm nor IRAS 100 µm data are available.
3. We only include detections in the wavelength ranges 1.25 ≤ λ ≤ 160 µm and λ ≥ 850
µm. These "category 3" SEDs are meant to simulate sources for which 2MASS and
Spitzer 1.25 − 70 µm data, Spitzer 160 µm or IRAS 100 µm data, and millimeter
wavelength data are available, but no 350 or 450 µm submillimeter data are available.
4. We only include detections in the wavelength ranges 1.25 ≤ λ ≤ 70 µm and λ ≥ 850
µm. These "category 4" SEDs are meant to simulate sources for which only 2MASS
and Spitzer 1.25 − 70 µm and millimeter wavelength data are available.
For each of the 13 sources, we calculate Lbol, Tbol, and Lbol/Lsmm for each of the four
versions of the SED. Comparing the results will give an estimate of the errors introduced by
incompletely sampling the source SED.
– 44 –
B.1. Bolometric Luminosity
The three panels of figure 21 shows the percent error for each source between Lbol
calculated from the SEDs in categories 2 − 4 and Lbol calculated from the SED in category
1. For category n, where n = 2, 3, 4, this percent error (P E) is defined as
P E = 100 ×
Lbol,n − Lbol,1
Lbol,1
(B2)
For all three cateogories, the calculated Lbol is an underestimate of the Lbol calculated
from the more completely sampled Category 1 SEDs. The average of the absolute values
of P E, ignoring values of 0 which simply indicate that the complete SED for the source
is not a Category 1 SED, are 31%, 25%, and 54% for categories 2, 3, and 4, respectively.
As expected, including detections either between 100 − 160 or 350 − 450 µm significantly
improves the accuracy of Lbol; adding detections in both ranges improves it further.
B.2. Bolometric Temperature
The results of the same analysis for Tbol as that performed above for Lbol are shown in
Figure 22. For category 3 and category 4 SEDs, the calculated Tbol is always higher than
that calculated from a well-sampled SED. This is expected since both categories leave out
detections near the peak of the SED. For category 2, however, the direction of the error in
Tbol depends on the true value of Tbol. Category 2 SEDs of the coldest sources (Tbol . 50
K) will lead to underestimates of Tbol, whereas they will lead to overestimates for warmer
sources (Tbol & 50 K).
We calculate the percent error in Tbol in the same manner as above for Lbol. The average
of the absolute values of these percent errors are 21%, 23%, and 64% for categories 2, 3, and
4, respectively. As for Lbol, category 2 and 3 SEDs yield significantly more accurate values
of Tbol than category 4 SEDs, but are not as accurate as Category 1 SEDs.
We note here that our results are in good agreement with Enoch (2007), who found that
overall uncertainties for measured Lbol and Tbol values are approximately 20−50%, depending
on whether or not 160 µm data are available. We also note that distance uncertainties will
add additional uncertainties to Lbol beyond those considered here.
– 45 –
B.3. Bolometric to Submillimeter Luminosity
We performed a similar anaysis for Lbol/Lsmm as above for Lbol and Tbol. The average
values of the percent errors are 31%, 1282%, and 605% for categories 2, 3, and 4, respectively,
significantly larger than the errors in Lbol and Tbol. The value of Lbol/Lsmm calculated for
category 4 SEDs overestimates the actual value; both Lbol and Lsmm are underestimated by
not sampling the SED at all between 70 and 850 µm, but Lbol is underestimated less than
Lsmm. The same is true for category 3 SEDs, except the error is even larger because the
calculation of Lbol is now less of an underestimate (see above), but the calculation of Lsmm
remains the same. On the other hand, Lbol/Lsmm calculated from category 2 SEDs underes-
timates the actual value, since Lbol is underestimated but Lsmm is accurately calculated. The
errors here are more than an order of magnitude smaller than Categories 3 and 4. Clearly,
great care must be taken to obtain the most well-sampled SEDs before attempting to draw
conclusions from the value of Lbol/Lsmm for a given source.
REFERENCES
Acosta-Pulido, J. A., et al. 2007, AJ, 133, 2020
Alcal´a, J.M., et al. 2008, ApJ, 676, 427
Andr´e, P., Ward-Thompson, D., & Barsony, M. 1993, ApJ, 406, 122
Andr´e, P. & Montmerle, T. 1994, ApJ, 420, 837
Andr´e, P., Motte, F., & Bacmann, A. 1999. ApJ, 513, L57
Aspin, C., Sandell, G., & Russell, A.P.G. 1994, A&AS, 106, 165
Aspin, C. 2003, AJ, 125, 1480
Belloche, A., Andr´e, P., Despois, D., & Blinder, S. 2002, A&A, 393, 927
Benson, P.J., & Myers, P.C. 1989, ApJS, 71, 89
Black, J.H. 1994, ASP Conf. Ser. 58, The First Symposium on the Infrared Cirrus and
Diffuse Enterstellar Clouds, ed. R.M. Cutri & W.B. Latter (San Francisco: ASP),
355
Boogert, A.C.A., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 359
Boss, A.P. & Yorke, H.W. 1995, ApJ, 439, L55
Bourke, T.L., Crapsi, A., Myers, P.C., Evans, N.J. II, Wilner, D.J., Huard, T.L., Jørgensen,
J.K., & Young, C.H. 2005, ApJ, 633, L129
Bourke, T.L., et al. 2006, ApJ, 649, L37
– 46 –
Brown, J.M., et al. 2007, ApJ, 664, L107
Butner, H.M., Natta, A., & Evans, N.J. II 1994, ApJ, 420, 326
Caselli, P., Benson, P.J., Myers, P.C., & Tafalla, M. 2002, ApJ, 572, 238
Chapman, N., et al. 2007, ApJ, 667, 288
Chen, H., Myers, P.C., Ladd, E.F., & Wood, D.O.S. 1995, ApJ, 445, 377
Chiang, E.I. & Goldreich, P. 1997, ApJ, 490, 368
Clark, F. O. 1991, ApJS, 75, 611
Crapsi, A., Caselli, P., Walmsley, C.M., Tafalla, M., Lee, C.W., Bourke, T.L., & Myers, P.C.
2004, A&A, 420, 957
Crapsi, A., et al. 2005a, A&A, 439, 1023
Crapsi, A., et al. 2005b, ApJ, 619, 379
Crapsi, A., et al. 2008, A&A, in press
Davis, C.J., Matthews, H.E., Ray, T.P., Dent, W.R.F, & Richer, J.S. 1999, MNRAS, 309,
141
Di Francesco, J., Evans. N.J., II, Caselli, P., Myers, P.C., Shirley, Y., Aikawa, Y., & Tafalla,
M. 2007, in Protostars and Planets V, ed. B. Reipurth, D. Jewitt, & K. Keil (Tucson:
Univ. Arizona Press)
Djupvik, A.A., Andr´e, P., Bontemps, S., Motte, F., Olofsson, G., G alfalk, M., & Flor´en,
H.-G. 2006, A&A, 458, 789
Draine, B.T. 1978, ApJS, 36, 595
Draine, B.T. & Lee, H.M. 1984, ApJ, 285, 89
Dullemond, C.P., & Dominik, C. 2004, A&A, 417, 159
Dunham, M.M., et al. 2006, ApJ, 651, 945
Enoch, M.L., et al. 2006, ApJ, 638, 293
Enoch, M.L, Glenn, J., Evans, N.J. II, Sargent, A.I., Young, K.E., & Huard, T.L. 2007, ApJ,
666, 982
Enoch, M.L. 2007, Ph.D. thesis, California Institute of Technology
Enoch, M.L., et al. 2008a, in preparation
Enoch, M.L., Evans, N.J. II, Sargent, A.I., Glenn, J., Rosolowsky, E., & Myers, P. 2008b,
ApJ, in press
Evans, N.J. II, Rawlings, J.M.C., Shirley, Y.L., & Mundy, L.G. 2001, ApJ, 557, 193
– 47 –
Evans, N.J. II., et al. 2003, PASP, 115, 965
Evans, N.J. II, et al. 2007, Final Delivery of Data from the c2d Legacy Project: IRAC and
MIPS (Pasadena: SSC), http://ssc.spitzer.caltech.edu/legacy/all.html
Fazio, G.G., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 10
Fedele, D., van den Ancker, M.E., Petr-Gotzens, M.G., & Rafanelli, P. 2007, A&A, 472, 207
Froebrich, D. 2005, ApJS, 156, 169
Harvey, P.M., et al. 2006, ApJ, 644, 307
Harvey, P.M., et al. 2007, ApJ, 663, 1139
Harvey, P.M., Merin, B., Huard, T.L., Rebull, L.M., Chapman, N., Evans, N.J. II, & Myers,
P.C. 2007b, ApJ, 663, 1149
Hatchell, J., Richer, J.S., Fuller, G.A., Qualtrough, C.J., Ladd, E.F., & Chandler, C.J. 2005,
A&A, 440, 151
Hatchell, J., Fuller, G.A., Richer, J.S., Harries, T.J., & Ladd, E.F. 2007a, A&A, 468, 1009
Hatchell, J., Fuller, G.A., & Richer, J.S. 2007b, A&A, 472, 187
Hartmann, L., & Kenyon, S.J. 1985, ApJ, 299, 462
Henning, T., Pfau, W., Zinnecker, H., & Prusti, T. 1993, A&A, 276, 129
Ho, P.T.P., & Townes, C.H. 1983, ARA&A, 21, 239
Hodapp, K.W., Bally, J., Eisloffel, J., & Davis, C.J. 2005, AJ, 129, 1580
Huard, T.L., et al. 2006, ApJ, 640, 391
Jijina, J., Myers, P.C., & Adams, F.C. 1999, ApJS, 125, 161
Johnstone, D., Wilson, C.D., Moriarty-Schieven, G., Joncas, G., Smith, G., Gregersen, E.,
& Fich, M. 2000, ApJ, 545, 327
Jørgensen, J.K., et al. 2006, ApJ, 645, 1246
Jørgensen, J.K., Johnstone, D., Kirk, H., & Myers, P.C. 2007, ApJ, 656, 293
Kauffmann, J.,Bertoldi, F., Evans, N.J., & the c2d Collaboration 2005, Astron. Nachr., 326,
878
Kauffmann, J., Bertoldi, F., Bourke, T.L., Evans, N.J. II., & Lee, C.W. 2008, A&A, sub-
mitted
Kenyon, S.J., & Hartmann, L. 1995, ApJS, 101, 117
Kirk, J.M., Ward-Thompson, D., & Andr´e, P. 2005, MNRAS, 360, 1506
Kirk, H., Johnstone, D., & Di Francesco, J. 2006, ApJ, 646, 1009
– 48 –
Kirk, J.M., Ward-Thompson, D., & Andr´e, P. 2007, MNRAS, 375, 843
K´osp´al, ´A, ´Abrah´am, P., Prusti, T., Acosta-Pulido, J., Hony, S., Mo´or, A., & Siebenmorgen,
R. 2007, A&A, 470, 211
Kun, M. 1998, ApJS, 115, 59
Lada, C.J. 1987, Star Forming Regions, M. Peimbert & J. Jugaku (eds.), IAU, 1
Lee, C.-F., Ho, P.T.P., Palau, A., Hirano, N., Bourke, T.L., Shang, H., & Zhang, Q. 2007,
ApJ, 670, 1188
Lee, J.-E., et al. 2006, ApJ, 648, 491
Lee, J.-E. 2008, JKAS, in press, arXiv:0712.1866
Lehtinen, K., Mattila, K., & Lemke, D. 2005, A&A, 437, 159
McKee, C.F. & Ostriker, E.C. 2007, ARA&A, in press
Mer´ın, B., et al. 2008, ApJ, in press
Motte, F., & Andr´e P. 2001, A&A, 365, 440
Myers, P.C., Fuller, G.A., Mathieu, R.D., Beichman, C.A., Benson, P.J., Schild, R.E., &
Emerson, J.P. 1987, ApJ, 319, 340
Myers, P.C. & Ladd, E.F. 1993, ApJ, 413, 47
Myers, P.C., Adams, F.C., Chen, H., & Schaff, E. 1998, ApJ, 492, 703
Noriega-Crespo, A., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 352
Padgett, D., et al. 2008, ApJ, 672, 1013
Porras, A., et al. 2007, ApJ, 656, 493
Rebull, L.M., et al. 2007, ApJS, 171, 447
Rieke, G.H., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 25
Robitaille, T.P., Whitney, B.A., Indebetouw, R., Wood, K., & Denzmore, P. 2006, ApJS,
167, 256
Schechter, P.S., Mateo, M., & Saha, A. 1993, PASP, 105, 1342
Shirley, Y.L., Evans, N.J. II, & Rawlings, J.M.C. 2002, ApJ, 575, 337
Shu, F.H., Adams, F.C., & Lizano, S. 1987, ARA&A, 25, 23
Stanke, T., Smith, M.D., Gredel, R., & Khanzadyan, T. 2006, A&A, 447, 609
Stutz, A.M., et al. 2007, ApJ, 665, 466
Tachihara, K, et al. 2007, ApJ, 659, 1382
– 49 –
Tassis, K., & Mouschovias, T.C. 2005, ApJ, 618, 783
Vorobyov, E.I., & Basu, S. 2005, ApJ, 633, L137
Vorobyov, E.I., & Basu, S. 2006, ApJ, 650, 956
Ward-Thompson, D., et al. 2007, PASP, 119, 855
Whitney, B.A., Wood, K., Bjorkman, J.E., & Wolff, M.J. 2003a, ApJ, 591, 1049
Whitney, B.A., Wood, K., Bjorkman, J.E., & Cohen, M. 2003b, ApJ, 598, 1079
Wu, J., Dunham, M.M., Evans, N.J. II, Bourke, T.L., & Young, C.H. 2007, AJ, 133, 1560
Young, C.H., Shirley, Y.L., & Evans, N.J. 2003, ApJS, 145, 111
Young, C.H., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 396
Young, C.H., & Evans, N.J. 2005, ApJ, 627, 293
Young, C.H., et al. 2006a, AJ, 132, 1998
Young, K.E., et al. 2005, ApJ, 628, 283
Young, K.E., et al. 2006b, ApJ, 644, 326
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
– 50 –
Table 1. Embedded Protostars Observed by Spitzer with Published Models
Protostar
LIR
(L⊙)
Lint
(L⊙)
Lbol
(L⊙)
Referencea
CB130-3-IRS
IRAM 04191+1522
IRAS 04191+1523
IRAS 18148−0440
IRAS 19156+1906
L1014-IRS
L1148-IRS
L1221-IRS1
L1221-IRS3
L1521F-IRS
L673-7-IRS
0.05
0.02
0.25
8.19
1.13
0.06
0.08
1.12
0.36
0.01
0.02
0.15 ± 0.05
0.08 ± 0.04
0.4 ± 0.1
13.0 ± 0.5
2.6 ± 0.5
0.09 ± 0.03
0.1 ± 0.05
2.5 ± 0.25
1.0 ± 0.15
0.05 ± 0.02
0.04 ± 0.02
0.96
0.28
0.64
12.9
3.4
0.3
0.15
2.7
1.9
0.36
0.13
1
2
3
4
4
5
6
7
7
8
3
aReference for the radiative transfer model and determination of
Lint and Lbol:
(1) H.J. Kim et al. (2008, in preparation); (2) Dunham et al. (2006);
(3) M. Dunham et al.
in preparation); (4) Shirley et al.
(2002); (5) Young et al. (2004); (6) Kauffmann et al. (2005); (7) C.
Young et al. (2008, in preparation); (8) Bourke et al. (2006.).
(2008,
Table 2. Linear Least-Squares Fits to Plots of Log Fν vs. Log Lint.
Wavelength
(µm)
Observations
m
b
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
0.57 ± 0.42 −11.07 ± 0.32
0.88 ± 0.26 −10.54 ± 0.20
0.97 ± 0.29 −10.54 ± 0.22
0.83 ± 0.27 −10.72 ± 0.22
0.87 ± 0.20 −10.05 ± 0.17
−9.26 ± 0.06
1.06 ± 0.06
m
Models
b
0.86 ± 0.05 −11.87 ± 0.03
0.94 ± 0.04 −11.63 ± 0.03
0.99 ± 0.04 −11.43 ± 0.03
1.02 ± 0.04 −11.38 ± 0.03
1.38 ± 0.02 −10.12 ± 0.01
−9.02 ± 0.01
1.06 ± 0.01
χ2
r
296
148
179
160
85
3
χ2
r
3309
2846
2305
2044
433
15
Table 3. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in the Cores
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Core Regionc
Spitzer
c2d
Dist.
(pc)
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
LIR
(L⊙)
d DIRAS
001
002
003
004
005
006
007
008
009
010
011
012
013
014
015
016
017
018
019
020
021
022
023
024
025
026
027
028
029
030
031
032
033
034
1
1
1
1
1
1
6
5
5
5
3
5
5
6
5
2
1
3
5
5
1
6
3
1
1
6
1
5
1
3
1
3
6
6
IRAM04191+1522
IRAM04191+1522
IRAM04191+1522
L1521F
TMC1
B35A
B35A
BHR22
BHR16
CG30−31
J042156.88+152946.0
J042200.07+153024.8
J042200.41+153021.2
J042838.90+265135.6
J044112.65+254635.4
J054429.26+090856.8
J054443.94+090307.2
J071357.60−482711.9
J080533.05−390924.8
J080850.47−360652.2
J081705.26−395415.8 DC2573−25
J081706.34−394635.8 DC2573−25
J081710.92−395244.4 DC2573−25
J092851.50−513558.6 DC2742−04
J123040.90−710007.6 Mu8
J124539.96−552522.4 DC302.1+7.4
J130736.89−770009.7 DC303.8−14.2
J154216.99−524802.2 DC3272+18
J155856.14−373354.0 DC3391+117−2
J163705.11−353219.7 DC3460+78
J165719.63−160923.4
J171111.83−272655.0
J171122.18−272602.0
J181616.39−023237.7
J181659.47−180230.5
J191744.28+191523.7
J192025.32+112217.4
J192025.92+112221.0
J192026.16+111949.1
J192026.54+112025.4
J192134.82+112123.4
J204056.66+672304.9
J204105.95+671820.9
J204355.51+673850.3
CB68
B59
B59
CB130−3
L328
L723
L673
L673
L673
L673
L673−7
L1148
L1148
L1155E
140 ± 10
140 ± 10
140 ± 10
140 ± 10
140 ± 10
400 ± 40
400 ± 40
450 ± 50
440 ± 100
450 ± 50
440 ± 100
440 ± 100
440 ± 100
130 ± 10
150 ± 30
300 ± 50
178 ± 18
250 ± 50
150 ± 20
150 ± 20
125 ± 25
125 ± 25
125 ± 25
270 ± 50
270 ± 50
300 ± 100
300 ± 100
300 ± 100
300 ± 100
300 ± 100
300 ± 100
325 ± 25
325 ± 25
325 ± 25
04 21 56.88 +15 29 46.0
04 22 00.07 +15 30 24.8
04 22 00.41 +15 30 21.2
04 28 38.90 +26 51 35.6
04 41 12.65 +25 46 35.4
05 44 29.26 +09 08 56.8
05 44 43.94 +09 03 07.2
07 13 57.60 −48 27 11.9
08 05 33.05 −39 09 24.8
08 08 50.47 −36 06 52.2
08 17 05.26 −39 54 15.8
08 17 06.34 −39 46 35.8
08 17 10.92 −39 52 44.4
09 28 51.50 −51 35 58.6
12 30 40.90 −71 00 07.6
12 45 39.96 −55 25 22.4
13 07 36.89 −77 00 09.7
15 42 16.99 −52 48 02.2
15 58 56.14 −37 33 54.0
16 37 05.11 −35 32 19.7
16 57 19.63 −16 09 23.4
17 11 11.83 −27 26 55.0
17 11 22.18 −27 26 02.0
18 16 16.39 −02 32 37.7
18 16 59.47 −18 02 30.5
19 17 44.28 +19 15 23.7
19 20 25.32 +11 22 17.4
19 20 25.92 +11 22 21.0
19 20 26.16 +11 19 49.1
19 20 26.54 +11 20 25.4
19 21 34.82 +11 21 23.4
20 40 56.66 +67 23 04.9
20 41 05.95 +67 18 20.9
20 43 55.51 +67 38 50.3
0.023
0.033
0.250
0.015
0.383
0.141
0.006
0.006
0.081
0.064
0.193
0.013
0.018
0.005
0.001
0.232
0.387
0.034
0.005
0.003
0.299
0.024
0.343
0.054
0.065
0.048
0.201
0.168
0.037
0.138
0.017
0.081
0.003
0.004
(′′)
43.6
17.4
20.8
380.9
15.7
8.1
405.4
170.7
241.9
525.5
51.1
194.3
161.0
712.4
413.5
44.5
5.7
337.1
331.8
221.3
2.0
125.9
86.3
905.7
445.0
225.4
42.9
52.5
5.3
35.4
427.6
222.3
250.9
642.1
Nearest IRAS
Source
IRAS 04191+1523
IRAS 04191+1523
IRAS 04191+1523
IRAS 04260+2642
IRAS 04381+2540
IRAS 05417+0907
IRAS 05417+0907
IRAS 07128−4820
IRAS 08036−3904
IRAS 08076−3556
IRAS 08152−3945
IRAS 08151−3934
IRAS 08152−3945
IRAS 09274−5134
IRAS 12288−7047
IRAS 12427−5508
IRAS 13036−7644
IRAS 15387−5233
IRAS 15552−3727
IRAS 16335−3528
IRAS 16544−1604
IRAS 17082−2724
IRAS 17081−2721
IRAS 18144−0242
IRAS 18145−1801
IRAS 19156+1906
IRAS 19180+1116
IRAS 19180+1116
IRAS 19180+1114
IRAS 19180+1114
IRAS 19189+1109
IRAS 20410+6710
IRAS 20410+6710
IRAS 20423+6736
–
5
1
–
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Core Regionc
Spitzer
c2d
Dist.
(pc)
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
Table 3-Continued
d DIRAS
LIR
(L⊙)
035
036
037
038
039
040
041
042
043
044
045
046
047
048
049
6
6
6
1
6
6
1
6
3
1
1
6
6
1
1
J204427.17+673835.9
J205706.72+773656.2
J205707.85+773659.8
J212407.58+495908.9
J220633.22+590232.6
J220637.27+590315.8
J222807.42+690038.9
J222933.39+751316.0
J222959.52+751403.1
J223031.94+751408.9
J223105.59+751337.2
J223514.06+751502.5
J223731.13+751041.5
J223846.15+751132.3
J223846.44+751128.0
L1155E
L1228
L1228
L1014
L1165
L1165
L1221
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
325 ± 25
200 ± 50
200 ± 50
250 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
250 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
300 ± 50
20 44 27.17 +67 38 35.9
20 57 06.72 +77 36 56.2
20 57 07.85 +77 36 59.8
21 24 07.58 +49 59 08.9
22 06 33.22 +59 02 32.6
22 06 37.27 +59 03 15.8
22 28 07.42 +69 00 38.9
22 29 33.39 +75 13 16.0
22 29 59.52 +75 14 03.1
22 30 31.94 +75 14 08.9
22 31 05.59 +75 13 37.2
22 35 14.06 +75 15 02.5
22 37 31.13 +75 10 41.5
22 38 46.15 +75 11 32.3
22 38 46.44 +75 11 28.0
0.004
0.199
0.038
0.087
0.030
0.008
0.404
0.066
0.272
0.156
0.077
0.030
0.004
0.274
0.081
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
cName of the core region from Evans et al. (2007) in which this source is located.
(′′)
768.6
72.7
75.4
246.8
135.6
107.5
41.9
119.7
13.1
120.5
252.0
129.3
295.5
5.2
2.7
Nearest IRAS
Source
IRAS 20423+6736
IRAS 20582+7724
IRAS 20582+7724
IRAS 21220+4944
IRAS 22051+5848
IRAS 22051+5848
IRAS 22266+6845
IRAS 22290+7458
IRAS 22290+7458
IRAS 22290+7458
IRAS 22290+7458
IRAS 22343+7501
IRAS 22376+7455
IRAS 22376+7455
IRAS 22376+7455
–
5
2
–
dIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics denote that the calculation only
extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
– 53 –
Table 4. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in Perseus
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Spitzer
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
050
051
052
053
054
055
056
057
058
059
060
061
062
063
064
065
066
067
068
069
070
071
072
073
074
075
076
077
078
079
080
081
082
083
084
085
086
087
088
089
090
091
092
093
094
5
5
5
5
5
1
1
6
5
5
3
5
5
1
1
1
6
5
1
6
6
1
6
1
2
2
6
6
2
5
3
1
6
6
1
6
6
5
1
5
1
6
1
1
5
J032353.74+310244.5
J032430.79+310651.8
J032433.14+311433.0
J032503.14+310322.7
J032515.26+312511.3
J032536.22+304515.8
J032539.12+304358.1
J032621.65+305726.3
J032627.62+293002.2
J032629.33+312154.4
J032637.46+301528.1
J032655.27+312831.4
J032705.62+294601.9
J032738.26+301358.8
J032832.57+311105.3
J032839.10+310601.8
J032843.58+311736.2
J032843.70+291050.2
J032845.29+310542.0
J032856.33+312227.8
J032856.59+310736.8
J032900.55+311200.7
J032906.05+303039.2
J032912.07+311301.6
J032913.54+311358.1
J032917.16+312746.4
J032919.75+311256.9
J032920.35+311250.4
J032923.47+313329.5
J032950.42+300328.8
J032951.82+313906.1
J033032.69+302626.5
J033047.81+313906.8
J033116.90+302958.2
J033120.98+304530.2
J033146.63+302440.0
J033147.33+302438.5
J033149.90+295423.8
J033217.95+304947.6
J033225.70+300631.3
J033229.18+310240.9
J033257.84+310608.3
J033314.38+310710.9
J033316.44+310652.6
J033357.17+314330.0
03 23 53.74 +31 02 44.5
03 24 30.79 +31 06 51.8
03 24 33.14 +31 14 33.0
03 25 03.14 +31 03 22.7
03 25 15.26 +31 25 11.3
03 25 36.22 +30 45 15.8
03 25 39.12 +30 43 58.1
03 26 21.65 +30 57 26.3
03 26 27.62 +29 30 02.2
03 26 29.33 +31 21 54.4
03 26 37.46 +30 15 28.1
03 26 55.27 +31 28 31.4
03 27 05.62 +29 46 01.9
03 27 38.26 +30 13 58.8
03 28 32.57 +31 11 05.3
03 28 39.10 +31 06 01.8
03 28 43.58 +31 17 36.2
03 28 43.70 +29 10 50.2
03 28 45.29 +31 05 42.0
03 28 56.33 +31 22 27.8
03 28 56.59 +31 07 36.8
03 29 00.55 +31 12 00.7
03 29 06.05 +30 30 39.2
03 29 12.07 +31 13 01.6
03 29 13.54 +31 13 58.1
03 29 17.16 +31 27 46.4
03 29 19.75 +31 12 56.9
03 29 20.35 +31 12 50.4
03 29 23.47 +31 33 29.5
03 29 50.42 +30 03 28.8
03 29 51.82 +31 39 06.1
03 30 32.69 +30 26 26.5
03 30 47.81 +31 39 06.8
03 31 16.90 +30 29 58.2
03 31 20.98 +30 45 30.2
03 31 46.63 +30 24 40.0
03 31 47.33 +30 24 38.5
03 31 49.90 +29 54 23.8
03 32 17.95 +30 49 47.6
03 32 25.70 +30 06 31.3
03 32 29.18 +31 02 40.9
03 32 57.84 +31 06 08.3
03 33 14.38 +31 07 10.9
03 33 16.44 +31 06 52.6
03 33 57.17 +31 43 30.0
c
LIR
(L⊙)
0.010
0.017
0.008
0.015
0.008
0.061
0.432
0.006
0.016
0.018
0.462
0.008
0.008
0.347
0.036
0.015
0.414
0.010
0.185
0.119
0.014
0.105
0.019
0.018
0.305
0.183
0.002
0.020
0.149
0.010
0.166
0.033
0.009
0.004
0.299
0.015
0.002
0.014
0.135
0.007
0.180
0.012
0.098
0.144
0.050
DIRAS
(′′)
Nearest IRAS
Source
440.4
419.3
407.6
178.7
689.4
4.3
90.4
281.5
932.8
434.6
5.8
227.9
133.6
60.0
163.6
72.7
15.8
757.9
10.5
182.5
194.6
170.3
212.5
217.2
183.8
184.3
283.7
293.9
9.3
922.0
3.3
147.0
402.2
383.7
9.6
209.2
211.3
642.7
6.2
409.5
18.4
258.9
47.3
58.4
461.0
IRAS 03203+3048
IRAS 03219+3056
IRAS 03219+3103
IRAS 03222+3053
IRAS 03219+3103
IRAS 03225+3034
IRAS 03225+3034
IRAS 03232+3051
IRAS 03239+2905
IRAS 03235+3118
IRAS 03235+3004
IRAS 03235+3118
IRAS 03239+2933
IRAS 03245+3002
IRAS 03255+3103
IRAS 03256+3055
IRAS 03256+3107
IRAS 03253+2848
IRAS 03256+3055
IRAS 03260+3111
IRAS 03256+3055
IRAS 03258+3104
IRAS 03258+3023
IRAS 03259+3105
IRAS 03259+3105
IRAS 03262+3114
IRAS 03259+3105
IRAS 03259+3105
IRAS 03262+3123
IRAS 03279+2950
IRAS 03267+3128
IRAS 03273+3018
IRAS 03279+3123
IRAS 03286+3017
IRAS 03282+3035
IRAS 03286+3017
IRAS 03286+3017
IRAS 03295+2947
IRAS 03292+3039
IRAS 03297+2951
IRAS 03293+3052
IRAS 03301+3057
IRAS 03301+3057
IRAS 03301+3057
IRAS 03302+3131
– 54 –
Table 4-Continued
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Spitzer
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
095
096
097
098
099
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
5
6
6
6
6
6
5
5
5
3
1
1
3
3
3
6
6
6
5
6
5
6
6
5
6
J033544.18+302357.5
J033554.41+304501.1
J033626.54+313634.9
J033745.17+305445.7
J033812.17+314020.6
J033925.54+321708.2
J034010.20+304446.7
J034015.79+305504.8
J034227.67+310145.1
J034351.02+320307.9
J034356.52+320052.9
J034356.83+320304.7
J034402.40+320204.9
J034402.64+320159.5
J034421.36+315932.6
J034511.57+322753.3
J034513.82+321210.1
J034527.98+323635.6
J034530.41+324801.8
J034632.45+313443.7
J034635.38+330746.6
J034656.74+325248.4
J034734.34+324640.1
J034754.26+331512.2
J034910.08+323249.2
03 35 44.18 +30 23 57.5
03 35 54.41 +30 45 01.1
03 36 26.54 +31 36 34.9
03 37 45.17 +30 54 45.7
03 38 12.17 +31 40 20.6
03 39 25.54 +32 17 08.2
03 40 10.20 +30 44 46.7
03 40 15.79 +30 55 04.8
03 42 27.67 +31 01 45.1
03 43 51.02 +32 03 07.9
03 43 56.52 +32 00 52.9
03 43 56.83 +32 03 04.7
03 44 02.40 +32 02 04.9
03 44 02.64 +32 01 59.5
03 44 21.36 +31 59 32.6
03 45 11.57 +32 27 53.3
03 45 13.82 +32 12 10.1
03 45 27.98 +32 36 35.6
03 45 30.41 +32 48 01.8
03 46 32.45 +31 34 43.7
03 46 35.38 +33 07 46.6
03 46 56.74 +32 52 48.4
03 47 34.34 +32 46 40.1
03 47 54.26 +33 15 12.2
03 49 10.08 +32 32 49.2
c
LIR
(L⊙)
0.057
0.067
0.026
0.029
0.019
0.292
0.008
0.013
0.019
0.172
0.310
0.253
0.101
0.021
0.200
0.026
0.051
0.011
0.010
0.018
0.012
0.015
0.006
0.013
0.010
DIRAS
(′′)
Nearest IRAS
Source
432.3
13.1
381.9
694.5
683.5
28.8
652.3
326.0
641.4
99.9
59.0
105.2
124.0
122.0
171.1
512.3
311.9
185.7
247.3
223.8
198.8
549.0
314.5
229.8
594.5
IRAS 03324+3020
IRAS 03328+3035
IRAS 03335+3120
IRAS 03337+3043
IRAS 03356+3121
IRAS 03363+3207
IRAS 03375+3043
IRAS 03375+3043
IRAS 03399+3059
IRAS 03407+3152
IRAS 03407+3152
IRAS 03407+3152
IRAS 03407+3152
IRAS 03410+3152
IRAS 03410+3152
IRAS 03426+3214
IRAS 03424+3203
IRAS 03421+3229
IRAS 03424+3234
IRAS 03436+3123
IRAS 03436+3300
IRAS 03434+3235
IRAS 03445+3242
IRAS 03448+3302
IRAS 03454+3230
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
cIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics
denote that the calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
– 55 –
Table 5. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in Chamaeleon II
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Spitzer
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
LIR
(L⊙)
c DIRAS
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
5
5
5
5
3
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
1
5
5
5
J124657.72−771916.0
J124816.42−781511.5
J124940.03−775657.1
J125254.34−780913.7
J125342.86−771511.5
J125507.66−765755.4
J125701.58−764834.9
J130100.05−770453.0
J130242.22−764402.0
J130326.59−764502.9
J130509.53−770716.3
J130515.96−771115.7
J130737.22−770009.4
J130832.38−773226.2
J131031.92−772423.8
J131331.97−773438.3
12 46 57.72 −77 19 16.0
12 48 16.42 −78 15 11.5
12 49 40.03 −77 56 57.1
12 52 54.34 −78 09 13.7
12 53 42.86 −77 15 11.5
12 55 07.66 −76 57 55.4
12 57 01.58 −76 48 34.9
13 01 00.05 −77 04 53.0
13 02 42.22 −76 44 02.0
13 03 26.59 −76 45 02.9
13 05 09.53 −77 07 16.3
13 05 15.96 −77 11 15.7
13 07 37.22 −77 00 09.4
13 08 32.38 −77 32 26.2
13 10 31.92 −77 24 23.8
13 13 31.97 −77 34 38.3
0.004
0.012
0.006
0.010
0.184
0.006
0.050
0.003
0.003
0.020
0.005
0.003
0.361
0.003
0.008
0.018
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
(′′)
372.4
896.9
897.8
483.2
5.7
182.1
10.5
347.6
396.9
355.1
203.0
336.8
6.2
308.5
694.4
1271.6
Nearest IRAS
Source
IRAS 12416−7703
IRAS 12440−7813
IRAS 12504−7745
IRAS 12504−7745
IRAS 12500−7658
IRAS 12522−7640
IRAS 12533−7632
IRAS 12571−7654
IRAS 12584−7621
IRAS 13005−7633
IRAS 13022−7650
IRAS 13022−7650
IRAS 13036−7644
IRAS 13031−7714
IRAS 13030−7707
IRAS 13031−7714
cIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics
denote that the calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
– 56 –
Table 6. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in Lupus
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Regionc
Spitzer
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
LIR
(L⊙)
d DIRAS
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
4c
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
4a
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
6
1
5
5
6
5
5
5
5
J153706.36−334102.4
J153751.12−335806.6
J153800.05−340524.4
J153826.95−325628.7
J153833.84−334030.0
J153834.66−344819.4
J153914.59−341105.3
J153953.90−334821.6
J154017.64−324649.4
J154051.62−342104.7
J154125.92−344445.6
J154126.95−325204.1
J154138.54−325005.3
J154141.93−324025.7
J154148.05−333536.6
J154302.28−344406.4
J154339.98−335554.8
J154421.91−332303.8
J154507.97−334254.7
J154513.15−335524.2
J154548.24−340510.7
J154601.18−335816.7
J154612.58−340250.3
J160003.79−421024.2
J160020.16−410333.8
J160115.55−415235.4
J160132.74−423628.4
J160709.79−392817.0
J160727.19−383842.0
J160729.66−391634.0
J160740.42−384602.3
J160741.50−383614.0
J160754.74−391544.6
J160851.43−390530.5
J160918.07−390453.4
J160934.85−384654.1
J160950.09−380756.3
J160954.82−391122.6
J161002.52−383025.9
J161022.30−373618.4
J161110.30−372008.9
J161316.27−384827.7
15 37 06.36 −33 41 02.4
Lupus I
15 37 51.12 −33 58 06.6
Lupus I
15 38 00.05 −34 05 24.4
Lupus I
15 38 26.95 −32 56 28.7
Lupus I
15 38 33.84 −33 40 30.0
Lupus I
15 38 34.66 −34 48 19.4
Lupus I
15 39 14.59 −34 11 05.3
Lupus I
15 39 53.90 −33 48 21.6
Lupus I
15 40 17.64 −32 46 49.4
Lupus I
15 40 51.62 −34 21 04.7
Lupus I
15 41 25.92 −34 44 45.6
Lupus I
15 41 26.95 −32 52 04.1
Lupus I
15 41 38.54 −32 50 05.3
Lupus I
15 41 41.93 −32 40 25.7
Lupus I
15 41 48.05 −33 35 36.6
Lupus I
15 43 02.28 −34 44 06.4
Lupus I
15 43 39.98 −33 55 54.8
Lupus I
15 44 21.91 −33 23 03.8
Lupus I
15 45 07.97 −33 42 54.7
Lupus I
15 45 13.15 −33 55 24.2
Lupus I
15 45 48.24 −34 05 10.7
Lupus I
15 46 01.18 −33 58 16.7
Lupus I
Lupus I
15 46 12.58 −34 02 50.3
Lupus IV 16 00 03.79 −42 10 24.2
Lupus IV 16 00 20.16 −41 03 33.8
Lupus IV 16 01 15.55 −41 52 35.4
Lupus IV 16 01 32.74 −42 36 28.4
16 07 09.79 −39 28 17.0
Lupus III
Lupus III
16 07 27.19 −38 38 42.0
16 07 29.66 −39 16 34.0
Lupus III
16 07 40.42 −38 46 02.3
Lupus III
16 07 41.50 −38 36 14.0
Lupus III
16 07 54.74 −39 15 44.6
Lupus III
Lupus III
16 08 51.43 −39 05 30.5
16 09 18.07 −39 04 53.4
Lupus III
16 09 34.85 −38 46 54.1
Lupus III
16 09 50.09 −38 07 56.3
Lupus III
16 09 54.82 −39 11 22.6
Lupus III
Lupus III
16 10 02.52 −38 30 25.9
16 10 22.30 −37 36 18.4
Lupus III
16 11 10.30 −37 20 08.9
Lupus III
Lupus III
16 13 16.27 −38 48 27.7
0.004
0.004
0.004
0.003
0.004
0.003
0.003
0.005
0.006
0.011
0.001
0.004
0.005
0.008
0.003
0.007
0.003
0.008
0.006
0.006
0.006
0.007
0.004
0.006
0.003
0.049
0.006
0.008
0.015
0.009
0.009
0.018
0.012
0.035
0.134
0.004
0.014
0.009
0.021
0.009
0.008
0.006
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
cName of the Lupus region (I, III, or IV) in which this source is located.
(′′)
682.1
680.6
709.8
178.5
511.7
486.1
532.3
186.7
926.8
11.8
659.8
845.4
733.6
192.0
203.4
559.0
603.3
196.2
375.2
1110.8
862.0
1302.4
1152.9
487.1
225.4
390.2
637.5
894.9
960.9
401.1
1081.8
737.8
411.1
52.1
19.3
715.3
312.3
63.2
679.7
611.7
897.5
531.3
Nearest IRAS
Source
IRAS 15334−3340
IRAS 15337−3350
IRAS 15349−3407
IRAS 15350−3246
IRAS 15349−3337
IRAS 15358−3444
IRAS 15367−3405
IRAS 15364−3339
IRAS 15364−3250
IRAS 15376−3411
IRAS 15379−3445
IRAS 15375−3253
IRAS 15387−3228
IRAS 15387−3228
IRAS 15384−3327
IRAS 15399−3425
IRAS 15397−3350
IRAS 15409−3312
IRAS 15417−3327
IRAS 15417−3327
IRAS 15420−3408
IRAS 15420−3408
IRAS 15420−3408
IRAS 15570−4155
IRAS 15571−4052
IRAS 15573−4147
IRAS 15571−4230
IRAS 16043−3933
IRAS 16051−3820
IRAS 16042−3901
IRAS 16036−3854
IRAS 16051−3820
IRAS 16042−3901
IRAS 16054−3857
IRAS 16059−3857
IRAS 16059−3850
IRAS 16063−3755
IRAS 16064−3903
IRAS 16069−3811
IRAS 16072−3738
IRAS 16084−3725
IRAS 16106−3842
– 57 –
dIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics denote that the
calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
– 58 –
Table 7. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in Ophiuchus
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
Spitzer
RA
(J2000)
Dec
(J2000)
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
5
5
5
3
1
3
3
1
5
5
6
6
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
J162135.57−224351.6
J162145.12−234231.7
J162458.99−252119.1
J162648.48−242838.6
J162705.23−243629.5
J162715.89−243843.1
J162717.57−242856.3
J162821.60−243623.4
J162843.68−231918.1
J163122.87−231655.2
J163131.25−242628.0
J163136.77−240419.9
J163307.27−225041.6
J163502.45−235100.7
J164001.80−244429.0
J164114.35−243758.1
J164147.64−243030.2
J164206.74−233859.3
J164301.87−245420.9
J164305.88−242357.5
J164433.26−233348.2
J164512.50−233848.1
16 21 35.57 −22 43 51.6
16 21 45.12 −23 42 31.7
16 24 58.99 −25 21 19.1
16 26 48.48 −24 28 38.6
16 27 05.23 −24 36 29.5
16 27 15.89 −24 38 43.1
16 27 17.57 −24 28 56.3
16 28 21.60 −24 36 23.4
16 28 43.68 −23 19 18.1
16 31 22.87 −23 16 55.2
16 31 31.25 −24 26 28.0
16 31 36.77 −24 04 19.9
16 33 07.27 −22 50 41.6
16 35 02.45 −23 51 00.7
16 40 01.80 −24 44 29.0
16 41 14.35 −24 37 58.1
16 41 47.64 −24 30 30.2
16 42 06.74 −23 38 59.3
16 43 01.87 −24 54 20.9
16 43 05.88 −24 23 57.5
16 44 33.26 −23 33 48.2
16 45 12.50 −23 38 48.1
c
LIR
(L⊙)
0.004
0.033
0.012
0.103
0.107
0.440
0.374
0.046
0.000
0.003
0.013
0.036
0.034
0.006
0.004
0.007
0.005
0.005
0.002
0.005
0.005
0.016
DIRAS
(′′)
Nearest IRAS
Source
1467.3
246.9
6.6
366.6
55.0
163.5
10.4
11.6
516.2
1354.8
70.9
51.1
15.0
1074.3
447.9
539.7
591.5
538.5
295.6
345.0
329.6
375.3
IRAS 16200−2251
IRAS 16187−2339
IRAS 16219−2514
IRAS 16235−2416
IRAS 16240−2430
IRAS 16240−2430
IRAS 16242−2422
IRAS 16253−2429
IRAS 16262−2317
IRAS 16275−2251
IRAS 16285−2421
IRAS 16285−2358
IRAS 16301−2244
IRAS 16318−2402
IRAS 16375−2439
IRAS 16377−2426
IRAS 16381−2419
IRAS 16384−2334
IRAS 16403−2447
IRAS 16396−2419
IRAS 16411−2329
IRAS 16420−2327
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
cIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics
denote that the calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
– 59 –
Table 8. Candidate Low-Luminosity Embedded Objects in Serpens
Source
Number
Groupa
Source Nameb
colhead(J2000)
(J2000)
Spitzer
RA
Dec
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
6
6
3
6
6
6
6
6
1
6
2
3
3
2
2
2
6
6
6
J182841.86−000321.2
J182844.02+005338.0
J182844.78+005125.9
J182844.95+005203.4
J182854.91+001832.8
J182902.11+003120.6
J182902.83+003009.7
J182902.95+003008.3
J182909.05+003127.8
J182923.18+013454.8
J182949.63+011522.0
J182951.98+011538.2
J182952.51+003611.9
J182953.04+003606.8
J182954.31+003601.4
J182957.67+011304.4
J183000.55+010304.0
J183004.03+003424.2
J183005.26+004104.6
18 28 41.86
18 28 44.02
18 28 44.78
18 28 44.95
18 28 54.91
18 29 02.11
18 29 02.83
18 29 02.95
18 29 09.05
18 29 23.18
18 29 49.63
18 29 51.98
18 29 52.51
18 29 53.04
18 29 54.31
18 29 57.67
18 30 00.55
18 30 04.03
18 30 05.26
−00 03 21.2
+00 53 38.0
+00 51 25.9
+00 52 03.4
+00 18 32.8
+00 31 20.6
+00 30 09.7
+00 30 08.3
+00 31 27.8
+01 34 54.8
+01 15 22.0
+01 15 38.2
+00 36 11.9
+00 36 06.8
+00 36 01.4
+01 13 04.4
+01 03 04.0
+00 34 24.2
+00 41 04.6
c
LIR
(L⊙)
0.153
0.146
0.016
0.209
0.033
0.032
0.134
0.035
0.009
0.040
0.395
0.028
0.198
0.169
0.119
0.166
0.025
0.151
0.056
DIRAS
(′′)
Nearest IRAS
Source
240.0
99.1
40.9
14.2
321.8
70.9
52.0
51.3
70.9
891.6
11.3
31.2
18.8
10.0
10.0
64.9
157.8
144.5
92.5
IRAS 18261−0009
IRAS 18262+0050
IRAS 18262+0050
IRAS 18262+0050
IRAS 18267+0016
IRAS 18265+0028
IRAS 18265+0028
IRAS 18265+0028
IRAS 18265+0028
IRAS 18276+0124
IRAS 18273+0113
IRAS 18273+0113
IRAS 18273+0034
IRAS 18273+0034
IRAS 18273+0034
IRAS 18274+0112
IRAS 18273+0059
IRAS 18273+0030
IRAS 18275+0040
aGroup indicating likelihood of being an embedded protostar (see §5.2).
bAll source names are preceded by the prefix "SSTc2d ".
cIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 (2MASS J-band) and 70 µm. Entries in italics denote
that the calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70 µm.
Table 9. Groups Showing Likelihood Each Candidate is an Embedded Protostar
Associated with
Region of High
Volume Densitya Volume Densitya Column Densitya
Associated with
Region of High
Embedded in
Region of High
4.5 µm
Number
Jets/Nebulositya
of Candidatesb
Yes
Yes
Yes
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
No
Yes
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Yes
Yes
No/Unknown
No/Unknown
N/A
N/A
Yes
No/Unknown
Yes
No/Unknown
Yes
No/Unknown
N/A
40
8
19
1
0
1
95
54
Group
1
2
3
4a
4b
4c
5
6
a"Yes" indicates data exists and satisfies this condition. "No" indicates data exists and shows that this
condition is not satisfied. "Unknown" indicates no data exists to evaluate this condition. As discussed in the
text, "No" and "Unknown" are considered equivalent for all but "Associated with Region of High Volume
Density" since negative results do not prove a source is not an embedded protostar.
bTotal number of the 218 candidates in this group.
– 60 –
Table 10. Candidates Divided Into Groups
Core/Cloud
IRAM04191+1522
IRAM04191+1522
IRAM04191+1522
L1521F
TMC1
B35A
DC303.8−14.2
CB68
CB130−3
L328
L673
L673
L673−7
L1014
L1221
L1251
L1251
L1251
L1251
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Chamaeleon II
Lupus III
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Serpens
DC302.1+7.4
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Serpens
a
LIR
(L⊙) MIPS3b
SIMBAD
0.023
0.033
0.250
0.015
0.383
0.141
0.387
0.299
0.054
0.065
0.201
0.037
0.017
0.087
0.404
0.156
0.077
0.274
0.081
0.061
0.432
0.347
0.036
0.015
0.185
0.105
0.018
0.033
0.299
0.135
0.180
0.098
0.144
0.310
0.253
0.361
0.134
0.107
0.046
0.009
0.232
0.305
0.183
0.149
0.395
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
C/S
C/S
Y
Y
Y
Y
C/S
C/S
Y
Y
Y
Y
C/S
Y
C/S
C/S
Y
Y
C/S
Y
C/S
N/A
C/S
C/S
Y
C/S
NAME IRAM 04191−IRS
IRAS F04191+1523
IRAS F04191+1523
NAME LDN 1521F−IRS
IRAS F04381+2540
Barnard 35A
BHR 86
[CB88] 68
[CB88] 130
[VRC2001] L328 SMM 1
[VRC2001] L673 SMM 1
[VRC2001] L673 SMM 2
NAME LDN 673 7
NAME LDN 1014−IRS
[LH2005] MM 2
LDN 1251A
[KP93] 3−6
LDN 1251B
LDN 1251B
[BC86b] LDN 1448 IRS 3B
NAME LDN 1448*
2MASS J03273825+3013585
[JJK2007] 9
[JJK2007] 12
IRAS 03256+3055
[JCC87] IRAS 4B1
[JCC87] IRAS 4B
SSTc2d J033032.7+302626
[WBK2005] SMM J033135+30455
IRAS 03292+3039
IRAS 03293+3052
[WBK2005] SMM J033328+31078
[JJK2007] 35
HH 211
NAME IC 348 MMS
BHR 86
NAME LUPUS 3 MMS
CRBR 2403.7−2948
[SSG2006] MMS126
[DAB2006] VLA−7
CG 19
[JCC87] IRAS 4B2
[JJK2007] 27
IRAS 03262+3123
[SB86] S68 1b
Group
Source
Number
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
001
002
003
004
005
006
017
021
024
025
027
029
031
038
041
044
045
048
049
055
056
063
064
065
068
071
073
081
084
088
090
092
093
105
106
132c
170
182
185
208
016
074
075
078
210
– 61 –
Table 10-Continued
Core/Cloud
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
DC2573−25
DC3272+18
B59
L673
L1148
L1251
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Chamaeleon II
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Lupus IV
Lupus I
BHR22
BHR16
CG30−31
DC2573−25
DC2573−25
Mu8
DC3391+117−2
DC3460+78
L673
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
a
LIR
(L⊙) MIPS3b
SIMBAD
0.169
0.119
0.166
0.193
0.034
0.343
0.138
0.081
0.272
0.462
0.166
0.172
0.101
0.021
0.200
0.184
0.103
0.440
0.374
0.016
0.028
0.198
0.049
0.011
0.006
0.081
0.064
0.013
0.018
0.001
0.005
0.003
0.168
0.010
0.017
0.008
0.015
0.008
0.016
0.018
0.008
0.008
0.010
0.010
0.014
C/S
Y
C/S
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Y
Y
C/S
C/S
C/S
C/S
Y
C/S
C/S
C/S
N
C/S
C/S
Y
Y
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
U
N
N
IRAS 18273+0034
IRAS 18273+0034
GCNM 104
NAME DCLD 257.3−2.5 1
[LM99] 135
[BHB2007] 10
[VRC2001] L673 SMM 2
IRAS F20404+6712
IRAS 22290+7458
[JJK2007] 4
IRAS 03267+3218
[JJK2007] 42
[JJK2007] 47
Cl* IC 348 LRL 54460
Cl* IC 348 LRL 1889
DENIS−P J125338.9−771553
BBRCG 7
NAME WL 20W
BBRCG 36
None
NAME Serpens SMM 10 IR
IRAS 18273+0034
2MASS J16011549-4152351
IRAS 15376−3411
None
None
None
None
Dcld 257.3−02.5
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
Group
Source
Number
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
4a
4c
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
213
214
215
011
018
023
030
032
043
060
080
104
107
108
109
124
181
183
184
202
211
212
161
145
008
009
010
012
013
015
019
020
028
050
051
052
053
054
058
059
061
062
067
079
087
– 62 –
Table 10-Continued
Core/Cloud
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Chamaeleon II
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus I
Lupus IV
a
LIR
(L⊙) MIPS3b
SIMBAD
0.007
0.050
0.057
0.008
0.013
0.019
0.010
0.012
0.013
0.004
0.012
0.006
0.010
0.006
0.050
0.003
0.020
0.005
0.003
0.003
0.008
0.018
0.004
0.004
0.004
0.003
0.004
0.003
0.003
0.005
0.006
0.001
0.004
0.005
0.008
0.003
0.007
0.003
0.008
0.006
0.006
0.006
0.007
0.004
0.006
N
N
U
U
N
U
N
N
N
U
U
U
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
U
N
N
U
U
N
N
N
U
U
U
N
N
N
N
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
IRAS 12533−7632
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
Group
Source
Number
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
089
094
095
101
102
103
113
115
118
120
121
122
123
125
126
128
129
130
131
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
– 63 –
Table 10-Continued
Core/Cloud
Lupus IV
Lupus IV
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Lupus III
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
B35A
DC2742−04
B59
L723
L1148
L1155E
L1155E
L1228
L1228
L1165
L1165
L1251
L1251
L1251
Perseus
Perseus
a
LIR
(L⊙) MIPS3b
SIMBAD
0.003
0.006
0.008
0.015
0.009
0.009
0.018
0.012
0.004
0.014
0.021
0.009
0.008
0.006
0.004
0.033
0.012
0.000
0.003
0.034
0.006
0.004
0.007
0.005
0.005
0.002
0.005
0.005
0.016
0.006
0.005
0.024
0.048
0.003
0.004
0.004
0.199
0.038
0.030
0.008
0.066
0.030
0.004
0.006
0.414
U
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Y
N
N
N
N
N
N
U
N
Y
N
N
N
Y
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N
Y
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
2MASS J16075475−3915446
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
[L89] R7
IRAS Z16219−2514
None
None
IRAS 16301−2244
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
2MASS J17111182−2726547
None
None
None
None
2MASX J20570656+7736557
None
None
None
None
None
None
None
HBC 341
Group
Source
Number
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
160
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
171
172
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
186
187
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
007
014
022
026
033
034
035
036
037
039
040
042
046
047
057
066
– 64 –
Table 10-Continued
Core/Cloud
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Perseus
Chamaeleon II
Lupus III
Lupus III
Ophiuchus
Ophiuchus
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
Serpens
a
LIR
(L⊙) MIPS3b
SIMBAD
0.119
0.014
0.019
0.002
0.020
0.009
0.004
0.015
0.002
0.012
0.067
0.026
0.029
0.019
0.292
0.026
0.051
0.011
0.018
0.015
0.006
0.010
0.003
0.035
0.009
0.013
0.036
0.153
0.146
0.209
0.033
0.032
0.134
0.035
0.040
0.025
0.151
0.056
C/S
N
N
C/S
C/S
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Y
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
C/S
N
N
Y
N
N
Y
Y
C/S
C/S
C/S
N
C/S
N
N
2MASS J03285630+3122279
None
None
None
HH5
None
None
None
None
None
IRAS 03328+3035
None
None
None
None
None
Cl* IC 348 LRL 904
None
None
None
None
None
None
V* V1192 Sco
None
None
None
None
None
IRAS 18262+0050
None
SSTc2d J192902.1+003120
2MASS J18290283+0030092
None
None
None
None
None
Group
Source
Number
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
069
070
072
076
077
082
083
085
086
091
096
097
098
099
100
110
111
112
114
116
117
119
127
169
173
188
189
200
201
203
204
205
206
207
209
216
217
218
aIntegrated luminosity using all available detections between 1.25 and 70 µm.
Italics
denote that the calculation only extends to 24 µm due to no flux information available at 70
µm.
bIndicates whether each candidate is associated with a 160 µm source. Y: Yes; N: No; U:
Unknown - located off the edge of the 160 µm map; C/S: Unknown - located in a region that
is confused and/or saturated at 160 µm; N/A: Not applicable for the dense cores.
cSource 132 is the same as Source 017.
– 65 –
Source
Number
001
003
004
005
Table 11. SEDs of Groups 1-3
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
90
160
200
350
450
850
1300
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
100
450
850
1300
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
450
850
1200
1.25
1.65
2.17
4.5
8.0
12
0.22
0.78
0.94
0.63
16.4
500
875
800
6000
10000
5000
10000
2500
650
0.3
1.7
8.3
48.5
93.0
135
179
985
1300
5910
4320
14400
1400
600
400
0.42
0.24
0.35
0.62
24.0
509
8900
7000
1500
600
0.22
2.27
16.1
139
346
396
0.02
0.06
0.08
0.06
1.73
100
120
160
1200
2000
800
2000
500
65
0.03
0.2
0.9
3.42
6.60
9.36
12.5
105
117
591
591
1730
800
100
...
0.06
0.03
0.05
0.06
2.52
86.5
1400
1800
500
150
0.05
0.17
0.88
10.3
24.7
32
...
...
...
...
...
60
...
60
60
60
40
60
60
60
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
40
60
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
40
40
40
...
...
...
...
...
...
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
2
2
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
5
5
1
5
6
6
7
8
1
1
1
1
1
9
10
6
11
4
4
4
1
1
5
LIR
L70
int = 0.04 L⊙
int = 0.05 L⊙
Lbol = 0.12 ± 0.02 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 5 ± 1
Tbol = 27 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.42 L⊙
int = 0.23 L⊙
Lbol = 0.50 ± 0.06 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 197 ± 23
Tbol = 149 ± 8 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.03 L⊙
int = 0.03 L⊙
Lbol = 0.13 ± 0.02 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 7 ± 1
Tbol = 20 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.64 L⊙
int = 0.36 L⊙
Lbol = 0.73 ± 0.07 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 89 ± 9
Tbol = 165 ± 10 K
– 66 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
017
021
024
025
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
24
25
60
70
100
450
850
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
100
200
1200
1300
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
100
350
450
850
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
450
850
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
1720
2520
9810
6740
12600
6410
1350
353
0.98
12.8
40.1
82.7
995
1050
4100
5450
8100
29000
1260
225
0.36
1.38
1.90
1.12
659
1480
19500
13100
33700
19100
27800
9400
1.44
4.23
5.85
6.76
54.1
312
2800
1100
1480
1.55
3.79
3.34
1.75
182
151
490
919
1260
2800
110
71
0.07
0.89
2.76
5.75
105
83.9
200
574
1100
3400
140
49.0
0.03
0.12
0.15
0.09
69.3
133
1950
1780
8080
2900
14900
2300
0.11
0.30
0.41
0.47
5.68
35.0
700
400
296
0.14
0.30
0.28
0.27
(′′)
...
...
...
...
...
120
120
40
...
...
...
...
...
...
43.5
...
43.5
89.4
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
40
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
40
120
...
...
...
...
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
1
5
5
1
5
12
12
11
1
1
1
1
1
5
13
1
13
13
14
15
1
1
1
1
1
5
5
1
5
3
6
6
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
3
16
1
1
1
1
LIR
L70
int = 0.65 L⊙
int = 0.46 L⊙
Lbol = 0.91 ± 0.09 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 2502 ± 257
Tbol = 69 ± 5 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.50 L⊙
int = 0.54 L⊙
Lbol = 0.94 ± 0.16 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 16 ± 3
Tbol = 52 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.09 L⊙
int = 0.07 L⊙
Lbol = 0.20 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 9 ± 2
Tbol = 55 ± 10 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.11 L⊙
int = 0.07 L⊙
Lbol = 0.18 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 9 ± 2
– 67 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
24
70
350
4.5
24
70
450
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
450
850
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
450
850
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
1200
1.25
1.65
87.0
337
2000
0.11
1.94
148
1100
358
4.02
12.2
21.2
26.2
89.5
503
3200
21500
1800
630
0.57
3.10
4.96
3.84
47.5
5080
6400
11300
7900
0.13
0.42
0.32
0.16
4.97
1400
9400
1010
0.43
1.07
0.75
0.37
1.90
688
7500
906
0.24
7.99
9.14
109
500
0.01
0.28
23.8
400
72
0.34
0.91
1.53
1.85
9.39
70.4
500
16100
400
126
0.04
0.24
0.25
0.35
5.00
691
1000
6100
1900
0.02
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.54
192
1400
202
0.04
0.10
0.06
0.04
0.23
94.5
1100
181
0.05
0.32
...
...
20
...
...
...
40
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
120
120
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
40
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
80
...
...
1
1
3
1
1
1
3
11
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
17
17
17
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
6
6
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
11
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
11
4
4
Tbol = 62 ± 9 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.03 L⊙
int = 0.04 L⊙
Lbol = 0.09 ± 0.03 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 10 ± 3
Tbol = 24 ± 6 K
LIR
int = 0.15 L⊙
L70
int = 0.09 L⊙
Lbol = 0.34 ± 0.11 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 3 ± 1
Tbol = 66 ± 21 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.67 L⊙
int = 0.81 L⊙
Lbol = 0.93 ± 0.16 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 8 ± 1
Tbol = 42 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.26 L⊙
int = 0.34 L⊙
Lbol = 0.78 ± 0.11 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 8 ± 1
Tbol = 24 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.13 L⊙
int = 0.17 L⊙
Lbol = 0.55 ± 0.08 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 7 ± 1
Tbol = 21 ± 2 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.58 L⊙
int = 0.20 L⊙
031
038
041
044
045
063
– 68 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
160
350
450
850
850
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
160
350
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
160
350
850
850
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
12
36.4
62.5
72.0
79.1
93.1
343
1120
16200
9800
1600
720
260
270
0.17
0.69
1.07
1.01
2.28
2.57
4.01
55.3
179
3340
3100
240
210
0.13
0.27
0.43
0.94
24.4
94.0
4930
1900
750
830
290
0.06
0.46
0.72
1.22
2.73
2.67
2.69
20
0.84
4.43
5.13
5.46
6.57
36.2
160
4600
1500
...
...
...
30
0.01
0.03
0.11
0.09
0.17
0.18
0.28
5.83
26.5
996
500
...
70
0.01
0.02
0.04
0.07
2.58
14.5
1420
300
...
...
20
0.01
0.02
0.10
0.09
0.19
0.19
0.19
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
T
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Lbol = 1.1 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 36 ± 7
Tbol = 199 ± 33 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.06 L⊙
int = 0.03 L⊙
Lbol = 0.20 ± 0.05 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 12 ± 3
Tbol = 65 ± 12 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.03 L⊙
int = 0.02 L⊙
Lbol = 0.22 ± 0.06 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 15 ± 4
Tbol = 29 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.31 L⊙
int = 0.26 L⊙
Lbol = 0.45 ± 0.09 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 193 ± 38
Tbol = 64 ± 8 K
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
3
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
9
18, 19
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
9
18, 19
20
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
22, 23
064
065
068
– 69 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
24
25
60
70
100
160
450
850
4.5
5.8
24
70
450
850
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
160
350
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
100
160
350
450
850
850
1100
3.6
4.5
8.0
24
60
70
213
150
1430
1520
6000
4960
552
102
0.09
0.11
15.4
1320
2100
720
130
370
0.06
0.20
0.19
0.16
30.5
310
2560
3200
800
0.13
0.85
0.83
0.62
14.7
2332
3880
13900
16400
12300
3300
2260
910
760
0.39
0.42
1.29
13.0
1590
1720
22.6
...
129
214
...
1620
140
12
0.01
0.03
1.63
183
...
...
...
50
0.01
0.01
0.04
0.03
3.21
43.1
865
500
70
0.01
0.07
0.07
0.06
1.55
210
533
1520
5680
2100
...
...
...
30
0.08
0.14
0.11
1.38
127
183
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
...
...
...
...
T
T
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
1
22, 23
5
1
22, 23
1
23
23
1
1
1
1
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
9
21
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
5
1
3
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
5
1
LIR
L70
int = 0.18 L⊙
int = 0.23 L⊙
Lbol = 0.24 ± 0.09 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 24 ± 4
Tbol = 41 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.06 L⊙
int = 0.06 L⊙
Lbol = 0.18 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 7 ± 2
Tbol = 33 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.50 L⊙
int = 0.63 L⊙
Lbol = 1.1 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 22 ± 4
Tbol = 35 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.23 L⊙
int = 0.29 L⊙
Lbol = 1.2 ± 0.3 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 7 ± 2
Tbol = 28 ± 2 K
071
081
084
088
– 70 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
090
092
093
105
100
160
350
450
850
850
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
160
350
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
350
1100
4.5
5.8
24
70
160
350
450
850
850
1100
3.6
5.8
24
70
350
450
850
9087
24200
17500
21500
5600
2130
2310
0.71
2.69
5.81
11.1
17.2
23.3
32.8
181
1350
1130
8250
2900
290
0.16
0.94
2.05
4.21
111
809
3700
1840
0.26
0.44
19.5
1820
13600
13300
50400
5370
4960
1840
0.06
0.28
2.20
4080
25200
83300
8190
1270
8380
2800
...
...
...
60
0.06
0.16
0.21
0.86
1.25
1.62
2.28
19.0
122
157
2380
400
50
0.01
0.07
0.15
0.30
11.8
116
600
40
0.04
0.05
2.08
256
3930
500
...
...
...
40
0.02
0.06
0.34
565
4100
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
T
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
20
T
...
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
T
T
...
...
...
...
40
T
T
1
1
3
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
1
3
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
9
21
1
1
1
1
1
9
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
3
18, 19
18, 19
LIR
L70
int = 0.30 L⊙
int = 0.20 L⊙
Lbol = 0.57 ± 0.11 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 30 ± 6
Tbol = 114 ± 17 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.16 L⊙
int = 0.14 L⊙
Lbol = 0.29 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 8 ± 1
Tbol = 47 ± 5 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.24 L⊙
int = 0.31 L⊙
Lbol = 1.1 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 4 ± 1
Tbol = 24 ± 2 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.52 L⊙
int = 0.66 L⊙
Lbol = 1.8 ± 0.3 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 4 ± 1
Tbol = 21 ± 3 K
– 71 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
450
850
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
160
1200
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
850
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
100
160
350
1100
1200
3.6
3140
2070
0.05
0.20
0.52
0.60
10.8
3280
17600
3590
2270
1420
0.26
1.00
0.99
0.55
32.4
1670
2610
8710
990
0.06
0.28
1.11
6.11
10.7
16.6
29.6
459
3490
440
433
0.59
2.55
4.49
3.13
90.1
2911
2000
16300
18700
45400
1140
411
0.13
...
50
0.01
0.06
0.06
0.12
1.17
454
...
...
...
30
0.03
0.08
0.09
0.06
3.44
217
363
2510
130
0.01
0.01
0.09
0.46
0.80
0.82
1.17
48.3
526
...
...
0.05
0.20
0.37
0.22
9.47
378
281
2780
5560
6800
100
...
0.01
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
56
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
120
T
...
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
1
24
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
25
26
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
5
1
9
27
26
1
LIR
L70
int = 0.42 L⊙
int = 0.54 L⊙
Lbol = 1.1 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 15 ± 3
Tbol = 25 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.22 L⊙
int = 0.29 L⊙
Lbol = 0.37 ± 0.08 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 275 ± 62
Tbol = 39 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.18 L⊙
int = 0.15 L⊙
Lbol = 0.15 ± 0.02 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 335 ± 46
Tbol = 105 ± 2 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.08 L⊙
int = 0.09 L⊙
Lbol = 0.45 ± 0.08 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 7 ± 1
Tbol = 30 ± 2 K
LIR
int = 0.39 L⊙
106
170
182
185
016
– 72 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
1200
3.6
5.8
24
70
450
850
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
450
850
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
160
850
850
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
1200
3.6
4.5
1.10
2.04
2.39
87.7
1750
370
0.03
0.25
28.4
3910
20900
2920
0.42
1.22
1.24
0.82
111
1950
2500
1420
470
550
0.76
2.26
2.47
3.03
191
1070
1150
4380
1560
390
510
0.75
1.87
2.42
2.17
2.12
1.81
2.43
56.4
492
100
0.47
2.03
0.08
0.15
0.16
9.20
240
50
0.01
0.04
3.00
538
...
...
0.04
0.12
0.10
0.11
11.7
292
...
...
...
50
0.08
0.17
0.24
0.21
20.1
96.3
159
1270
...
...
40
0.07
0.14
0.14
0.15
0.15
0.13
0.17
5.92
69.5
20
0.04
0.16
...
...
...
...
...
120
...
...
...
...
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
...
...
1
1
1
1
1
14
1
1
1
1
18, 19
18, 19
1
1
1
1
1
1
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
1
18, 19
20
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
14
1
1
L70
int = 0.42 L⊙
Lbol = 0.37 ± 0.05 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 321 ± 43
Tbol = 66 ± 1 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.51 L⊙
int = 0.63 L⊙
Lbol = 1.3 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 16 ± 3
Tbol = 26 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.31 L⊙
int = 0.33 L⊙
Lbol = 0.37 ± 0.06 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 25 ± 4
Tbol = 53 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.25 L⊙
int = 0.20 L⊙
Lbol = 0.38 ± 0.07 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 134 ± 26
Tbol = 59 ± 7 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.32 L⊙
int = 0.26 L⊙
Lbol = 0.28 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 416 ± 54
Tbol = 206 ± 5 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.06 L⊙
int = 0.04 L⊙
074
075
078
011
018
– 73 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
023
030
032
043
060
5.8
8.0
24
70
1200
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
3.6
4.5
5.8
24
70
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
1200
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
1200
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
4.16
4.94
42.9
219
290
3.18
11.9
22.1
42.2
1870
10200
0.11
0.48
0.51
7.61
1230
0.09
0.59
0.87
1.21
1.39
0.88
1.25
70.5
126
321
306
170
0.33
1.76
6.43
15.8
21.8
25.2
27.3
272
375
734
848
705
0.18
0.50
1.19
3.62
9.27
0.30
0.43
4.50
32.9
40
0.23
0.84
1.53
2.91
199
1390
0.03
0.05
0.07
0.85
170
0.01
0.03
0.08
0.09
0.10
0.07
0.09
7.41
15.1
48.2
41.8
35
0.02
0.13
0.23
1.22
1.64
1.82
1.93
28.5
48.8
58.7
117
141
0.01
0.03
0.08
0.29
0.65
...
...
...
...
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
80
...
...
...
...
...
1
1
1
1
14
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
5, 28
5, 28
1
11
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
5
5
1
11
4
4
4
1
1
Lbol = 0.06 ± 0.01 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 90 ± 12
Tbol = 105 ± 3 K
LIR
int = 0.57 L⊙
L70
int = 0.42 L⊙
Lbol ≥ 0.34 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = ...
Tbol ≤ 106 K
LIR
int = 0.23 L⊙
L70
int = 0.30 L⊙
Lbol ≥ 0.14 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = ...
Tbol ≤ 60 K
int = 0.14 L⊙
int = 0.09 L⊙
Lbol = 0.13 ± 0.02 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 207 ± 28
Tbol = 145 ± 1 K
LIR
L70
LIR
L70
int = 0.45 L⊙
int = 0.21 L⊙
Lbol = 0.38 ± 0.04 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 173 ± 19
Tbol = 236 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.77 L⊙
int = 0.69 L⊙
Lbol = 1.1 ± 0.2 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 27 ± 4
Tbol = 64 ± 6 K
– 74 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
100
160
450
850
850
1100
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
160
450
850
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
850
1100
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
850
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
11.1
12.0
396
545
4180
4300
6970
8970
12100
860
170
400
0.02
0.10
0.37
48.9
1880
1990
5960
11900
4900
410
520
6.81
3.99
12.8
2.15
45.4
1960
1460
1410
0.73
1.93
3.82
6.41
107
847
940
500
0.33
1.17
6.63
31.0
50.4
61.7
0.77
0.82
41.7
76.3
376
591
697
2550
...
...
...
60
0.005
0.03
0.04
5.15
151
276
1730
6400
1200
...
40
0.59
0.63
0.93
0.18
4.82
276
...
40
0.05
0.15
0.27
0.45
11.7
124
...
20
0.02
0.09
0.18
2.14
3.45
4.21
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
T
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
40
120
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
80
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
1
1
1
5
5
1
5
1
18, 19
18, 19
20
21
1
1
1
1
5
1
1
6
6
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
20
21
1
1
1
1
1
1
20
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
LIR
L70
int = 0.28 L⊙
int = 0.34 L⊙
Lbol = 0.64 ± 0.18 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 11 ± 3
Tbol = 34 ± 7 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.29 L⊙
int = 0.33 L⊙
Lbol = 0.32 ± 0.05 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 56 ± 8
Tbol = 63 ± 3 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.17 L⊙
int = 0.15 L⊙
Lbol = 0.18 ± 0.03 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 77 ± 11
Tbol = 76 ± 4 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.33 L⊙
int = 0.11 L⊙
Lbol = 0.26 ± 0.03 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 195 ± 20
Tbol = 345 ± 4 K
080
104
107
109
– 75 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
124
181
183
184
8.0
24
70
1100
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
25
60
70
160
1300
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
1300
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
850
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70.9
228
600
560
0.87
3.56
9.19
17.9
25.4
33.5
51.2
612
1010
2720
1540
3420
59.7
0.09
2.74
21.8
79.2
111
128
148
446
1100
50
4.41
32.0
97.3
127
143
140
99.0
816
15700
80
0.21
1.75
15.5
127
206
286
268
780
4.86
24.1
85.8
70
0.06
0.14
0.22
1.25
1.75
2.31
3.53
64.3
90.9
407
215
995
15.0
0.01
0.11
0.54
5.61
7.75
9.10
10.3
47.3
219
...
0.23
2.09
3.40
9.36
11.2
11.4
12.2
287
2160
...
0.01
0.16
0.57
8.96
14.9
20.5
19.9
84.1
...
...
...
120
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
12
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
1
1
1
21
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
5
5
1
1
15
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
29
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
25
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
LIR
L70
int = 0.31 L⊙
int = 0.14 L⊙
Lbol = 0.34 ± 0.05 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 6000 ± 900
Tbol = 167 ± 6 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.17 L⊙
int = 0.05 L⊙
Lbol = 0.12 ± 0.01 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 5000 ± 600
Tbol = 430 ± 19 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.73 L⊙
int = 0.64 L⊙
Lbol = 0.62 ± 0.09 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 10000 ± 1500
Tbol = 225 ± 13 K
LIR
L70
int = 0.62 L⊙
int = 0.50 L⊙
Lbol = 0.76 ± 0.12 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = 3750 ± 600
Tbol = 157 ± 7 K
– 76 –
Table 11-Continued
Source
Number
Wavelength
Flux Density
σ
Aperturea
(µm)
(mJy)
(mJy)
(′′)
Referenceb
Evolutionary
Indicators
161
145
25
70
100
1200
1.25
1.65
2.17
3.6
4.5
5.8
8.0
24
70
160
5.8
8.0
24
60
70
160
6560
12200
22000
375
0.42
1.67
4.83
8.36
9.92
8.98
7.70
75.9
1220
5390
0.28
0.70
8.78
468
372
705
1120
1720
4840
...
0.06
0.10
0.20
0.61
0.70
0.63
0.53
7.99
173
1560
0.09
0.19
1.00
42.1
54.9
225
...
...
...
T
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
5
1
5
26
4
4
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
5
1
1
LIR
int = 0.08 L⊙
L70
int = 0.08 L⊙
Lbol ≥ 0.11 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = ...
Tbol ≤ 126 K
LIR
int = 0.02 L⊙
L70
int = 0.03 L⊙
Lbol ≥ 0.02 L⊙
Lbol/Lsmm = ...
Tbol ≤ 57 K
aDiameter of the aperture used for photometry at λ > 100 µm, where the sources are likely to be
extended, when specified. A "T" indicates the photometry is an attempt to derive the total source
flux density rather than the flux density in a fixed aperture; see individual references for descriptions
of the methods used to derive this quantity.
bReferences.− (1) Spitzer observations from this work; (2) Andr´e et al. (1999); (3) Wu et al.
(2007); (4) 2MASS; (5) IRAS ; (6) Young et al. (2006a); (7) Motte & Andr´e (2001); (8) Bourke et
al. (2006); (9) M. Dunham et al. (2008), in preparation; (10) Kirk et al. (2005); (11) Kauffmann
et al. (2008); (12) Young et al. (2003); (13) Lehtinen et al. (2005); (14) K. Brede et al. (2008), in
preparation; (15) Henning et al. (1993); (16) H.J. Kim et al. (2008, in preparation); (17) Young et al.
(2004); (18) Hatchell et al. (2005); (19) Hatchell et al. (2007a); (20) Kirk et al. (2006); (21) Enoch et
al. (2006); (22) Clark (1991); (23) Hodapp et al. (2005); (24) Tachihara et al. (2007); (25) Johnstone
et al. (2000); (26) Stanke et al. (2006); (27) Young et al. (2006b); (28) Kun (1998); (29) Andr´e &
Montmerle (1994).
– 77 –
Fig. 1.- (a): Log Lint vs. Log LIR for the objects listed in Table 1. The solid line shows the
results of a linear least-squares fit in log-log space; it has a slope of 0.88 and a y-intercept
of 0.32. (b): Lint/LIR vs. Log LIR for the same objects. The solid line shows the average
ratio of 1.7, weighted by the uncertainties in Lint.
– 78 –
Fig. 2.- Histogram of the un-normalized "probability" of being a galaxy, Pgal, using the
method of Harvey et al.
(2007b) for the 851 sources assigned such a probability in the
ensemble of 82 regions with dense cores observed by c2d. The dotted line shows Log(Pgal) =
−1.47 while the dashed line shows Log(Pgal) = −1.25.
– 79 –
Fig. 3.- Fν (normalized to 140 pc) vs. Lint for the 11 embedded protostars listed in Table
1. From left-to-right, top-to-bottom: IRAC1 (3.6 µm), IRAC2 (4.5 µm), IRAC3 (5.8 µm),
IRAC4 (8.0 µm), MIPS1 (24 µm), and MIPS2 (70 µm). The lines represent the results of
linear least-squares fits at each wavelength. The parameters of the fits are given in Table 2.
– 80 –
Fig. 4.- Same as Figure 3, except for the 1460 model SEDs calculated from the grid of 2-D
radiative transfer models rather than the 11 embedded protostars listed in Table 1.
– 81 –
Fig. 5.- Histogram of the 70 µm 3σ point source sensitivity for the 82 regions with dense
cores observed by c2d. The distribution has a mean and median of 38.6 mJy and 31.9 mJy,
respectively.
– 82 –
Fig. 6.- Log of the luminosity sensitivity limit for embedded protostars in the 82 regions
with dense cores observed by c2d (L) vs.
the distance to each core (d), calculated by
translating the 70 µm 3σ point source sensitivity for each core into a luminosity sensitivity
using the correlation found between F70 and Lint and then scaling from 140 pc to the distance
to the core. The solid line shows the relation Lint = 4 × 10−3 (d/140 pc)2 L⊙.
– 83 –
Fig. 7.- SED of SSTc2d J032856.64+311835.6, a source in Perseus that is representative of
candidates that pass all 7 selection criteria described in §3.1 but feature SEDs inconsistent
with being embedded sources. This particular source is SSS 108, a previously known pre-
main sequence object with a 2 µm excess indicative of a circumstellar disk. Objects with
these types of SEDs are rejected (see §3.4 for further information).
– 84 –
Fig. 8.- Average SEDs, weighted by 1/Lbol, for the embedded protostars identified by
Enoch (2007) and Enoch et al. (2008, in preparation) in Perseus, Serpens, and Ophiuchus
based on a comparison between 1.1 mm Bolocam dust continuum emission maps and the
Spitzer c2d maps. The average Class 0 SED is shown in black, the average SED for Class I
sources with rising (or flat) fluxes from 24 to 70 µm is shown in blue, the average SED for
Class I sources with decreasing fluxes from 24 to 70 µm is shown in green, and the average
SED for the Class II objects identified by Enoch et al. is shown in red.
– 85 –
Fig. 9.- Distribution of luminosities for the 851 objects in the 82 regions with dense cores
observed by c2d classified as either candidate YSOs or candidate galaxies by the classification
method of Harvey et al.
(2007b). The solid line shows the distribution for the sources
classified as candidate YSOs while the dashed line shows the same for the sources classified
as candidate galaxies. Of the 604 out of 851 sources with LIR ≤ 0.05 L⊙, 518 (∼ 86%) are
classified as candidate galaxies.
– 86 –
Fig. 10.- Top Left: Three-color image of L673-7 comprised of IRAC 1 (3.6 µm; blue),
IRAC 2 (4.5 µm; green), and IRAC 4 (8.0 µm; red ). The white cross marks the position of
Source 031 from this work, which is not detected by IRAC; it is clearly seen to fall within
a dark core at 8.0 µm. Top Right: Same as top left, except the red now shows the MIPS1
(24 µm) image. A very red source is seen at the position of Source 031. Bottom: Radial
profiles of the background intensity at 8 and 24 µm, centered at the position of Source 031.
The background intensities are calculated in concentric annuli, each with a radius of 2′′. The
radius on the x-axis is the mid-point of the annulus (for example, at a radius of 10′′ the
background intensity was calculated in an annulus with its inner edge located 9′′ from the
source and its outer edge located 11′′ from the source). The calculations start at radii of 5
and 7′′ respectively, for 8.0 and 24 µm.
– 87 –
Fig. 11.- LIR
int, the internal luminosity estimated from the calculated value of LIR, vs. L70
int,
the internal luminosity estimated from the 70 µm flux scaled to its value at 140 pc, for the
50 objects listed in Table 11. The dashed line shows the 1:1 line, while the dotted lines show
the 2:1 and 1:2 lines.
– 88 –
Fig. 12.- Distribution of internal luminosities of the 50 embedded, low-luminosity protostars
listed in Table 11. The internal luminosity of each protostar was estimated from the observed
70 µm flux and the correlation between the two derived in §3. The dashed lines shows
our sensitivity limit to embedded protostars for the closest regions observed by c2d (Lint
= 2.5 × 10−3 L⊙) and the most distant regions observed by c2d (Lint = 5 × 10−2 L⊙).
– 89 –
Fig. 13.- Distribution of internal luminosities, in linear bins with a size of 0.1 L⊙, for all
sources listed in Table 11 with Lint ≤ 0.5 L⊙.
– 90 –
Fig. 14.- Figure 19 from Young & Evans (2005), a Lbol vs. Tbol BLT, with the 50 objects
listed in Table 11 overlaid as large, colored points. The meaning of the colors and symbols
are described in the text. The uncertainties in Lbol and Tbol, which are not shown on this
plot, are dominated by the 20-60% errors introduced by incomplete, finite sampling of the
source SEDs (see Appendix 2). The thick lines show the evolutionary tracks for the three
models considered by Young & Evans (2005), which differ in their initial envelope mass. The
thin lines show the evolutionary tracks for three models considered by Myers et al. (1998),
which also differ in their initial envelope mass. The small circles are observations from the
literature compiled by Young & Evans (2005). The vertical dashed lines show the Class 0/I
and Class I/II Tbol boundaries from Chen et al. (1995).
– 91 –
Fig. 15.- Lbol/Lsmm vs. Tbol for the 50 objects listed in Table 11. The meaning of the
colors/symbols are the same as for Figure 14. The Class divisions in Tbol are from Chen et
al. (1995), while the Class divisions in Lbol/Lsmm are from Young & Evans (2005).
– 92 –
Fig. 16.- Same as Figure 14, except only showing the 15 VeLLOs (objects with Lint ≤ 0.1
L⊙).
– 93 –
Fig. 17.- Distribution of the sensitivity to protostars embedded within the 300 dense cores
in Perseus, Serpens, Ophiuchus, and the sample of 82 regions with dense cores targeted for
observations. The dashed lines show, from left to right, the sensitivity for cores in Lupus I
and IV, Chamaeleon II, and Lupus III.
– 94 –
Fig. 18.- Monte Carlo simulation of the observation of 10,000 embedded protostars with
internal luminosities distributed evenly between 10−5 and 10−1 L⊙ and randomly placed in
one of the 300 dense cores. Top: Normalized distribution of Lint for the 10,000 sources.
Bottom: Results of the simulation. The solid line shows the observed distribution of Lint
(normalized) for the 15 VeLLOs identified by this work, while the dashed line shows the
simulated observed distribution of Lint (normalized) of the simulated sources.
– 95 –
Fig. 19.- Distribution of internal luminosities, in linear bins of 0.01 L⊙, for the 15 embedded
protostars with Lint ≤ 0.1 L⊙. The vertical dashed line shows Lint = 10−1.8 L⊙ ≈ 0.016 L⊙.
The vertical dotted line shows Lint = 0.0025 L⊙.
– 96 –
Fig. 20.- Same as Figure 18, except with the internal luminosities of 5,000 of the 10,000
sources evenly distributed between 10−4 and 10−3 L⊙ and the internal luminosities of the
other 5,000 sources evenly distributed between 10−3 and 10−1 L⊙.
– 97 –
Fig. 21.- Percent errors between Lbol calculated from the category 2 (left; category 3,
middle; category 4, right) SED and the category 1 SED, as defined in the text. The dashed
line shows the average value of this error for each category.
Fig. 22.- Same as Figure 21, except for Tbol rather than Lbol.
|
astro-ph/0105015 | 1 | 0105 | 2001-05-01T23:10:36 | Optical spectroscopy of X-MEGA targets I. CPD -59 2635: A New Double-Lined O type Binary in the Carina Nebula | [
"astro-ph"
] | Optical spectroscopy of CPD -59 2635, one of the O-type stars in the open cluster Trumpler 16 in the Carina Nebula, reveals this star to be a double-lined binary system. We have obtained the first radial velocity orbit for this system, consisting of a circular solution with a period of 2.2999 days and semi amplitudes of 208 and 273 km/s. This results in minimum masses of 15 and 11 Msol for the binary components of CPD -59 2635, which we classified as O8V and O9.5V, though spectral type variations of the order of 1 subclass, that we identify as the Struve-Sahade effect, seem to be present in both components.
From ROSAT HRI observations of CPD -59 2635 we determine a luminosity ratio log(L_x/L_bol)~ -7, which is similar to that observed for other O-type stars in the Carina Nebula region. No evidence of light variations is present in the available optical or X-rays data sets. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000–000 (0000)
Printed 16 March 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
Optical spectroscopy of X-MEGA targets
I. CPD -59◦ 2635: A New Double-Lined O type Binary in
the Carina Nebula
J.F. Albacete Colombo1⋆ †, N.I. Morrell1⋆ ‡ §, V.S. Niemela1⋆ ¶ and M.F. Corcoran2,3
1 Facultad de Ciencias Astron´omicas y Geof´ısicas, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, Paseo del Bosque S/N, 1900 La Plata, Argentina
2 Universities Space Research Association, 7501 Forbes Blvd, Ste 206, Seabrook, MD 20706, USA
3 Laboratory for High Energy Astrophysics, Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt MD 20771, USA
16 March 2018
ABSTRACT
Optical spectroscopy of CPD -59◦ 2635, one of the O-type stars in the open cluster
Trumpler 16 in the Carina Nebula, reveals this star to be a double-lined binary system.
We have obtained the first radial velocity orbit for this system, consisting of a circular
solution with a period of 2.2999 days and semi amplitudes of 208 and 273 km s−1.
This results in minimum masses of 15 and 11 M⊙ for the binary components of CPD -
59◦ 2635, which we classified as O8V and O9.5V, though spectral type variations of
the order of 1 subclass, that we identify as the Struve-Sahade effect, seem to be present
in both components. From ROSAT HRI observations of CPD -59◦ 2635 we determine
a luminosity ratio log(Lx/Lbol) ≈ −7, which is similar to that observed for other O-
type stars in the Carina Nebula region. No evidence of light variations is present in
the available optical or X-rays data sets.
Key words: open clusters and associations: individual (Trumpler 16) – stars: binaries
– early-type – stars: individual (CPD -59◦ 2635) – X-rays: stars
1
INTRODUCTION
The very young Carina Nebula region contains several open
clusters with a rich population of O-type stars. Among them,
Trumpler 16 is one of the most conspicuous. One of its mem-
bers, CPD -59◦ 2635 (V=9.27, α2000=10◦ 45′ 12.78′′, δ2000=-
59◦ 44′ 46.6′′; Massey & Johnson, 1993) has been observed
in the context of the international X-Mega campaign, which
involves optical spectroscopy of OB stars showing X-ray
emission on ROSAT-HRI images (Corcoran 1999) k CPD -
59◦ 2635 is one of the OB stars in the neighborhood of η Car-
⋆ Visiting Astronomer, CASLEO, operated under agreement be-
tween CONICET and National Universities of La Plata, C´ordoba
and San Juan, Argentina.
† Fellow of CIC, Prov. de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
‡ Visiting Astronomer, CTIO, NOAO, operated by AURA Inc.,
for NSF.
§ Member of Carrera del Investigador Cient´ıfico, CONICET,
Argentina.
¶ Member of Carrera del Investigador Cient´ıfico, CIC, Prov. de
Buenos Aires, Argentina.
k (See http://lheawww.gsfc.nasa.gov/users/corcoran/xmega/ for
a more comprehensive description of the XMega campaign).
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
inae also detected as a bright X-ray source. Figure 1 shows
an X-ray image centered on CPD -59◦2635 obtained through
combination of 3 deep ROSAT HRI pointings (see below)
along with the optical field from the Digitized Sky Survey.
Because a massive binary system could influence its
emergent X-ray flux as a result of colliding stellar winds
(e.g. Chlebowski & Garmany, 1991), it is important to ver-
ify the frequency of close multiple systems among the Carina
OB stars which are detected as X-ray sources. We wonder,
for example, if wind collision might be the physical reason
that makes CPD -59◦ 2635 brighter in X-rays than its close
neighbor HD 93343 very similar in both visual brightness
and spectral type (see Fig. 1).
CPD -59◦ 2635 has received different designations in the
literature. The IDS catalogue (Jeffers et al. 1963) refers to it
as IDS 10452 S 5946 as possibly forming a visual binary with
HD 93343, of similar V magnitude, about 14" to the South.
Stephenson & Sanduleak (1971) gave to CPD -59◦ 2635 the
number 1872 in their catalogue of "Luminous Stars in the
Southern Milky Way" (LSS), but misleadingly providing the
cross-identification as "HD 93343?". Feinstein et al. (1973)
assigned to CPD -59◦ 2635 the number 34, among the prob-
able members of the open cluster Trumpler 16.
Figure 1. Optical field around CPD −59◦ 2635 (left) from digitized sky survey and ROSAT HRI image (right). The fields of view are
6′ × 6′.
2 OBSERVATIONS
Our observations consist of optical spectrograms of CPD
-59◦ 2635, obtained during 1984 at Cerro Tololo Interameri-
can Observatory (CTIO), Chile, and between 1997 and 2000
at Complejo Astron´omico El Leoncito (CASLEO).
The first set of 11 observations was obtained in March
1984 at CTIO using the Carnegie Image Tube Spectrograph
(CTIS) attached to the 1-m Yale telescope. These spectro-
grams, covering a wavelength range from 3900 to 4900 A at
a reciprocal dispersion of 43 A mm−1 were widened to 1 mm
and secured on Kodak IIIa-J baked emulsion. A He-A lamp
was used as a comparison source. These photographic spec-
trograms were digitized with a Grant micro-densitometer
at La Plata Observatory, and subsequently analyzed with
IRAF ⋆⋆ routines.
Spectral CCD images of CPD -59◦ 2635 were obtained
at CASLEO observatory, between January 1997 and June
2000 with the 2.15-m Jorge Sahade telescope, mainly as
part of the observations for the XMega campaign. We used
a REOSC echelle Cassegrain spectrograph and a Tek 1024
× 1024 pixels CCD as detector to obtain 27 spectra in the
wavelength range from 3500 to 6000 A at a reciprocal dis-
persion of 0.17 A px−1 at 4500 A. The S/N of these data is
∼ 110 (although it changes, of course, with position within
each echelle order).
Four additional observations were obtained at CASLEO
with a Boller & Chivens (B&C) spectrograph attached to
the 2.15m telescope, using a PM 516 × 516 pixels CCD as
detector, and a 600 l mm−1 diffraction grating, yielding a
reciprocal dispersion of 2.5 A px−1. These spectra cover the
spectral range from ∼ 3800 to 4900 A , and their S/N is
∼300. One more spectrum of CPD -59◦ 2635 was obtained
⋆⋆ Image Reduction and Analysis Facility, distributed by NOAO,
operated by AURA, Inc., under agreement with NSF.
at CASLEO with the REOSC spectrograph in its simple dis-
persion mode, using a 600 l mm−1 grating and the Tek 1024
× 1024 CCD as detector, at a resulting reciprocal dispersion
of 1.8 A px−1. The central wavelength of this observation is
4700 A and the corresponding S/N is ∼ 300.
The usual series of bias, flat field and dark exposures
were also secured during each observing night for every CCD
data set. The CCD images were processed and analyzed with
IRAF routines at La Plata Observatory.
3 RESULTS AND THEIR DISCUSSION
3.1 Radial Velocity orbit of CPD -59◦ 2635
A first inspection of our high resolution echelle spectrograms
revealed double lines present in some of them, indicating
that CPD -59◦ 2635 was probably a double-lined spectro-
scopic binary. Figure 2 shows the behavior of He ii 4686 A
line in echelle spectra of CPD -59◦ 2635, obtained at different
observing dates.
Radial velocities were determined from our spectra of
CPD -59◦ 2635, fitting Gaussian profiles to the absorption
lines.
We used for radial velocity determination several lines
of Hei along with Heii 4686 A which appear as the least
affected by pair blending. The Pickering (4-n) series of Heii
absorptions of the two binary components are not well re-
solved in our spectra, these lines being broader than other
Heii and Hei absorptions. We interpret this fact as indica-
tive of higher pressure broadening acting in the region where
these lines form, which must be deeper in the atmosphere
than the formation region of Hei lines. As a consequence,
these (4-n) series lines are more seriously blended than the
other absorptions in the spectrum of CPD -59◦ 2635 and we
decided not to include them in the average radial velocities
presented in Table 1. We also derived radial velocities from
Table 1. Radial-velocity measurements for CPD -59◦ 2635.
HJD
2400000+
phase
φ
Primary
km s−1
s.d.
km s−1
Secondary
km s−1
s.d.
km s−1
45776.826†
45777.783†
45778.731†
45779.715†
45780.748†
45781.644†
45782.730†
45783.677†
45784.682†
45785.634†
45786.623†
50495.835
50498.826
50506.834
50841.793
50842.769
50843.727
50844.718
50845.723
50846.828
50847.649
50848.779
50850.724
50851.655
50852.828
50859.789‡
50861.781‡
50862.762‡
50868.714‡
51208.709
51209.714
51210.727
51211.715
51215.682
51216.653
51217.673
51218.632
51712.448
51712.478
51715.463
51716.483
51716.521
51718.555‡
0.86
0.27
0.63
0.11
0.56
0.95
0.42
0.84
0.27
0.62
0.12
0.64
0.92
0.43
0.07
0.49
0.91
0.34
0.77
0.26
0.61
0.10
0.95
0.35
0.89
0.61
0.76
0.18
0.77
0.61
0.04
0.47
0.90
0.63
0.05
0.49
0.91
0.62
0.63
0.93
0.37
0.39
0.27
193
-214
+179
-138
+27
+37
-116
+175
-204
+181
-135
+163
+108
-68
-86
+3
+132
-168
+205
-202
+150
-133
+86
-162
+177
+112
+189
-192
+188
+134
-49
-36
+118
+137
-82
-12
+109
+136
+179
+84
-165
-131
-220
34
56
22
25
25
28
46
25
47
27
28
23
10
19
27
9
18
10
11
27
10
12
17
17
19
21
24
18
22
17
27
18
6
17
20
21
32
20
56
16
33
16
59
-132
+256
-210
+160
-
-
+98
-223
+219
-210
+180
-225
-131
+132
+152
-
-143
+236
-271
+270
-184
+189
-101
+231
-191
-
-248
+243
-
-214
-
-
-179
-197
+80
-
-149
-193
-
-120
184
160
220
56
41
28
10
-
-
28
61
68
30
34
18
18
13
28
-
16
29
37
21
35
24
18
24
18
-
25
33
-
21
-
-
24
17
12
-
37
30
-
10
19
23
31
NOTE: Orbital phases have been calculated with ephemeris of ta-
ble 2. † indicates the lower resolution observations obtained with
the CITS , and ‡ those obtained either with the B&C spectro-
graph or the REOSC spectrograph in simple dispersion mode.
3.2 Spectral classification of the binary
components of CPD -59◦ 2635.
CPD -59◦ 2635 has been previously classified by Walborn
(1982) as O7Vnn; and by Levato & Malaroda (1982) as
O8/9:V "+ companion ?", already pointing out its probable
binary nature. Massey & Johnson (1993) classified CPD -
59◦ 2635 as O8.5V. The spectrum of CPD -59◦ 2635 (identi-
fied as star number 516), shown in the last mentioned paper
displays indeed double lines, apparently not noticed by the
authors.
Two spectra of CPD -59◦ 2635 from our lower resolu-
Figure 2. Heii 4686 A absorption in the spectrum of CPD -
59◦ 2635 at different observing dates, showing the doubling of
spectral lines.
our lower resolution, but higher S/N CCD spectra and from
our digitized photographic plates. The radial velocities were
computed as unweighted mean values of individual velocities
determined for each spectral line.
The journal of our radial velocity observations is pre-
sented in Table 1. In successive columns, we quote the Helio-
centric Julian Date (HJD), the corresponding orbital phase
(as explained below), the measured average radial velocities
for the primary and secondary components, and their stan-
dard deviations (s.d.). We identified the primary component
as the one having deeper absorptions of Heii lines.
From the radial velocities listed in Table 1, it was al-
ready apparent that the orbital period of CPD -59◦ 2635
was of the order of a few days. A period search routine
based on the modified Lafler & Kinman (1965) method
(Cincotta, M´endez & Nunez 1995) applied to all the radial
velocity observations of the primary component of CPD -
59◦ 2635 as listed in Table 1, yielded as the most probable
period P = 2.29995 ± 0.00002 days. Initial orbital elements
were estimated, leaving also the period as a free parame-
ter, resulting in an orbital solution of negligible eccentric-
ity (e = 0.005 ± 0.008) with no significative change in the
orbital period. We therefore considered the orbit to be cir-
cular, and the above mentioned value of the period to be
the most probable, and proceeded to find the best fit for the
remaining orbital parameters. In order to avoid as much as
possible pair blending effects, we computed the orbital ele-
ments of CPD -59◦ 2635 using only radial velocities derived
from our high resolution observations of both binary com-
ponents, obtained at the orbital phase intervals 0.1 to 0.4
and 0.6 to 0.9, of the binary period. The resulting orbital
elements are listed in Table 2.
Figure 3 represents the complete set of observed radial
velocities as a function of the adopted orbital period, along
with the circular orbital solution from Table 2.
Figure 3. Radial velocity orbit for CPD -59◦ 2635. The meaning of the symbols is as follows: filled and open symbols refer to the primary
and secondary stars, respectively. Circles represent REOSC-echelle spectra (bigger symbols refer to data used in the calculation of the
orbital solution); squares stand for B&C and REOSC-DS spectra and triangles, for CITS spectra. Typical error bars for each data-set
are also indicated.
Table 2. Circular orbital elements of CPD −59◦ 2635.
P [days]
K1 [km s−1]
K2 [km s−1]
γ [km s−1]
Tmax [HJD]
a1.sini [R⊙]
a2.sini [R⊙]
M1 sin3i [M⊙]
M2 sin3i [M⊙]
q(M2/M1)
2.29995 ± 2 ×10−5
208 ± 2
273 ± 2
0 ± 1
2450845.664 ± 0.01
9.4 ± 0.1
12.4 ± 0.1
15.0 ± 0.5
11.4 ± 0.5
0.76 ± 0.01
NOTE: Tmax represents the time of maximum radial velocity of
the primary component.
tion CCD images, corresponding to nearly opposite binary
phases, are illustrated in Figure 4, where a difference in the
relative intensities of Hei 4471A and Heii 4542A is evident.
In the upper spectrum shown in Figure 4, obtained at bi-
nary phase 0.76P, Hei and Heii absorptions appear similar
indicating a spectral type O7; while in the lower spectrum,
obtained at the binary phase 0.18P, Hei absorption is clearly
stronger than that of Heii, corresponding to a spectral type
O8-9. Such spectral variations might explain the slightly dif-
ferent classifications given to this star by different authors.
Keeping in mind the known difficulties in classifying
spectra of close binaries, and the above illustrated spectral
variations, we have nevertheless tried to estimate the spec-
tral types of the binary components of CPD -59◦ 2635.
An inspection of our high and intermediate resolution
observations showed that both stars present absorption-line
ratios of Hei/Heii ≥ 1, indicating spectral types probably
later than O7. From the spectra with maximum separation
of the lines of the binary components, and using the classi-
fication criteria described by Walborn & Fitzpatrick (1990),
we derived spectral types of O8:V and O9.5:V for the pri-
mary and secondary components, respectively.
In order to provide an additional estimate for the spec-
tral types of the binary components of CPD -59◦ 2635,
we considered the Hei(4922)/Heii(5411) ratio, following the
classification criteria proposed by Kerton et al. (1999). The
equivalent widths (W ) of the 5411 A and 4922 A lines were
measured in normalized spectra, by means of a Gaussian
fit to the absorption profiles, though Heii 5411 A looks
somewhat blended even at phases of maximum radial ve-
locity separation (as above discussed) which causes less con-
fident W determinations. We found equivalent width ratios
R(W4922/W5411) of 0.54 ± 0.03 and 1.18 ± 0.04 for the pri-
mary and secondary components, respectively, correspond-
ing to spectral types of O8V and O9.5V, with some varia-
tions depending probably on binary phase.
Figure 5 shows the spectral region comprising Hei 4922
A and Heii 5411 A lines on echelle spectrograms of CPD -
59◦ 2635 near the phases of maximum separation of the com-
ponents.
By inspection of the Hei and Heii spectral lines observed
during different phases of the binary motion, we found line
depth variations that can be appreciated in Figures 2 and
5. We identify this phenomenon as the Struve-Sahade ef-
fect (cf. Gies et al. 1997 and references therein) observed in
Figure 4. Spectra of CPD -59◦ 2635 obtained at CASLEO with the B&C spectrograph. Spectral features marked are: H Balmer lines,
Hei(+ii) 4026 A, Hei 4143 A, Heii 4200 A, Hei 4388 A, Hei 4471 A, Heii 4541 A, Ciii + Oii 4650 A blend, Heii 4686 A, Hei 4713 A, and
Hei 4921 A. Note the difference in relative intensities of Hei 4471A and Heii 4541A between both spectra.
Kerton et al. (1999) we found variations around one sub-
class in spectral types for both binary components, going
from O7 to O8 for the primary and O8.5 to O9.5 for the
secondary star. However, the errors involved in the EW
measurements (especially those affecting the Heii 5411 A
line) are also considerable and, as a consequence, we cannot
address any conclusive statement about the phase depen-
dence of these variations until higher resolution and S/N
observations are available.
As the binary components of CPD -59◦ 2635 are prob-
ably in synchronous rotation with the orbital period, we
believe that the later spectral types (i.e. O8V and O9.5V
respectively) are more realistic in describing each star in
this binary system, being the earlier ones probably produced
by photo-spheric heating on each star from its companion
and/or the colliding wind region between the stars.
3.3 Physical Parameters
In what follows we will estimate the physical parameters of
the binary components of CPD -59◦ 2635. We adopt for this
star the visual magnitude and distance modulus of Trum-
pler 16 published by Massey & Johnson (1993), namely V
= 9.27 and Mv − V0 = 12.55 ± 0.08, close to the value
of Mv − V0 = 12.6 obtained by Feinstein et al. (1973). Also
from Massey & Johnson (1993), we take, for CPD -59◦ 2635,
EB−V = 0.54, R = 3.2 and thus V0 = 7.54. In order to ob-
tain individual absolute magnitudes, we need an estimate of
the luminosity ratio of the binary components. We applied
the corrected integrated-absorption method of Petrie (1940)
in the way described by Niemela & Morrison (1988). We used
equivalent widths measured for Hei 4387 and 4471 and Heii
Figure 5. Hei 4922 A and Heii 5411 A lines in the spectrum of
CPD -59◦ 2635 at phases 0.26 and 0.77
massive close binaries, which consists in the deepening of
the spectral lines of the secondary star when it approaches
to the observer. In our spectra, variable line depths seem
to be present in both binary components although stronger
variations are observed in the secondary star.
Applying again the classification criteria proposed by
4686 A absorptions in spectra where those features are bet-
ter resolved. We corrected for continuum overlapping using
equivalent widths of the same lines measured for individ-
ual stars of similar spectral types, taken from Mathys, 1988.
Then we calculated for each selected spectral line the quo-
tient (L2/L1=< (B.Ka)/(A.Kb) >), where A is the equiv-
alent width of the line measured in the spectrum of the
most intense component, B is the equivalent width of the
same line as observed in the weaker component, and Ka,b
are the equivalent widths measured for single stars of spec-
tral types O8 V and O9 V, respectively. Performing these
measurements in several spectra of CPD -59◦ 2635 observed
near phases of maximum separation of the components we
obtained an average value of L2/L1 = 0.45 ± 0.14, which we
have used in the following calculations. With this luminosity
ratio and the adopted distance modulus, we obtained indi-
vidual absolute magnitudes of MV = -4.61 ± 0.1 and -3.74 ±
0.1 for the primary and secondary components, respectively.
Our classification of the components of CPD -59◦ 2635
as O8 V and O9.5 V corresponds to Teff = 38450 K and
BC = -3.68 for the primary, and Teff = 34620 K and
BC = -3.36 for the secondary, according to the calibration
of effective temperatures (Teff) and bolometric corrections
(BC) proposed by Vacca, Garmany & Shull (1996, here-
after VGS). However, according to Schmidt-Kaler (1982),
the corresponding effective temperatures and bolometric co-
rrections would be Teff = 35800 K and BC = -3.54 for the
primary, and Teff = 31500 K and BC = -3.25 for the sec-
ondary. Therefore, depending on which calibration we adopt,
we would find somewhat different values for the bolometric
magnitudes, and thus, luminosities of each binary compo-
nent.
Knowing the luminosities and effective temperatures,
we can derive the radii of the stars, that we want to com-
pare with the radii of the critical Roche lobes. Those were
estimated using the expression given by Paczynski (1971):
r1 sin i = a sin i(0.38 + 0.2 log(M1/M2))
for a "mean" Roche radius of r1 and separation a. We ob-
tained individual Roche radii of r1 sin i = 8.8 R⊙ and r2 sin i
= 7.8 R⊙. We need to know something about the inclination
of the orbital plane in order to compare these critical Roche
radii with the Stefan-Boltzmann radii of the stars.
The physical parameters derived for the binary compo-
nents are summarized in Table 3.
Under the assumption that the system is in synchronous
rotation (which seems reasonable in a massive binary of
short period) we derived probable rotational velocities for
its components (quoted in Table 3 which are higher than
the observed rotational velocities of single stars of similar
spectral types (e.g. Slettebak et al., 1975 ; Conti & Ebbets,
1977).
We tried to estimate the projected rotational velocities
(V sin i) comparing the observed absorption profiles of Hei
4388 A and 4471 A with flux profiles from non-LTE model
atmospheres by Auer & Mihalas (1972). We chose models
corresponding to Teff of 40000, 35000 and 30000 K and log g
= 4 to represent the binary components. The model pro-
files were convolved with different rotational velocity pro-
files, finding satisfactory agreement with observations for
V sin i values of 180 ± 25 km s−1 and 140 ± 30 km s−1 for
the primary and secondary components, respectively. Com-
Table 4. Three deep ROSAT HRI pointings which include CPD
−59◦ 2635.
Sequence Identification
Begin Date
End Date
Exposure
RH900385N00
RH900385A03
RH202331N00
1992-07-31
1994-07-21
1997-12-23
1992-08-02
1994-07-29
1998-02-10
11527
40555
47095
paring these results with the calculated rotational velocities,
we obtain, for the inclination of the orbital plane, values of
64◦ and 79◦, for the primary and secondary, respectively,
using the radii derived through the calibration by VGS, or
56◦ and 59◦, for primary and secondary, respectively, using
the calibration by Schmidt-Kaler (1982). However, the er-
rors involved in the V sin i determination give room for a
large range of inclinations.
Assuming the mass-spectral type relation for normal
O-type stars by VGS (1996), we can expect masses near 25
and 21 M⊙ for the individual binary components of CPD -
59◦ 2635. These values are similar to (or slightly larger than)
those obtained from the observation of eclipsing binary sys-
tems with O8V and O9V components (e.g. EM Car, Ander-
sen & Clausen, 1989; Y Cyg, Burkholder, Massey & Mor-
rell, 1997; CQ Cep, Kartascheva & Svechnikov, 1989). This
also points to an orbital inclination inclination of 56◦ ±
6◦, similar to the values estimated from the line widths.
If these estimates are correct, the system is not likely to
present eclipses. However, some kind of light variations may
occur due to tidal deformation, considering that both com-
ponents are hot luminous stars in a close binary system.
Also, if our guess for the inclination is as supposed, the sys-
tem would be detached, with both components within their
critical Roche lobes, as we would expect for a young binary
with non evolved components.
4 X-RAY EMISSION
CPD −59◦ 2635 was detected as a serendipitous X-ray
source during numerous pointing in the Carina Nebula by
the ROSAT X-ray satellite observatory with both the Posi-
tion Sensitive Proportional Counter (PSPC) and the High
Resolution Imager (HRI). In the PSPC images the star is
unresolved from other nearby X-ray sources (notably the O
stars HD 93343 and Tr 16 #182) due to the rather coarse
spatial resolution of the PSPC (∼ 1′). The HRI has finer
spatial resolution (∼ 10′′) and so can better resolve CPD
−59◦ 2635 from surrounding sources, providing a more ac-
curate measure of the uncontaminated X-ray emission from
the star. Table 4 lists 3 deep ROSAT HRI pointing which
include CPD −59◦ 2635.
The source lies about 4.2′ off axis, and at this position
the 50% encircled energy radius is about 3′′. We extracted
source counts from these 3 HRI sequences in an 8′′ re-
gion centered on CPD −59◦ 2635. We extracted background
counts from a region of blank sky centered at α2000 = 10h
45m 19.6s, δ2000 = −59◦ 44′ 43.2′′ using an extraction radius
of 40′′ to reduce the statistical uncertainty in the net rate.
Figure 6 shows the extracted net light curve for the
Table 3. Physical Parameters of CPD -59◦ 2635.
Primary component
VGS
38450
Calibration
Teff [K]
Mbol
L [L⊙]
RS−B [R⊙]
RS−B/RRoche−lobe
Vrot [km.s−1]
Schmidt-Kaler
Secondary component
VGS
Schmidt-Kaler
35800
34620
31500
-8.3 ± 0.15
-8.1 ± 0.15
-7.1 ± 0.15
-7.0 ± 0.15
162000 ± 20000
143000 ± 20000
54000 ± 11000
49000 ± 11000
9.1 ± 0.4
0.8 ± 0.1
200 ± 10
9.8 ± 0.4
0.9 ± 0.1
215 ± 10
6.5 ± 0.5
0.7 ± 0.1
142 ± 15
7.4 ± 0.5
0.8 ± 0.1
164 ± 15
Notes: a) RS−B means Stefan-Boltzmann radii.
b) Theoretical Roche-lobe radii were desafected by the sin i factor using a probable average value for the inclination of the
orbital plane, namely 60◦ .
0.004
0.003
s
/
c
t
e
N
I
R
H
0.002
0.001
0.000
48500
49000
49500
50000
50500
51000
JD - 2,400,000
Figure 6. HRI X-ray light curve of CPD −59◦ 2635.
source. There is no evidence for variability. Because the HRI
has no spectral resolution, we could not determine X-ray lu-
minosity by direct spectral fitting. Rather, to determine the
X-ray luminosity we converted the total net count rate to
luminosity by assuming a Raymond-Smith thermal source
spectrum with a temperature kT = 0.5 keV and an ab-
sorbing column NH = 2 × 1021 cm−2, which should reason-
ably approximate the X-ray emission from OB type stars in
the Carina nebula. At 4′ off-axis, the HRI vignetting cor-
rection is 1.01 (David, et al., 1997); the total net count
rate, corrected for vignetting, is 1.35 ± 0.14 × 10−3 HRI
counts s−1. With our assumed spectral parameters, this cor-
responds to an X-ray luminosity Lx = 3.8 × 1031 ergs s−1 in
the ROSAT band (0.2 − 2.4 keV), uncorrected for absorp-
tion, using Mv − V0 = 12.55. After correcting for absorp-
tion, the X-ray luminosity at the source is approximately
Lx,unabs = 9 × 1031 ergs s−1 in the ROSAT band. With
a total bolometric luminosity Ltot ∼ 200000L⊙ the ratio
of the unabsorbed X-ray luminosity to the total luminosity
is log Lx/Ltot ∼ −7, similar to the canonical value of this
ratio in the ROSAT band (Berghoffer et al. 1997). Accord-
ing to this, CPD -59◦ 2635 does not show excess in its X-ray
flux compared to other O-type stars, and the question about
why it looks brighter than its neighbour HD 93343 in the
ROSAT HRI image of Figure 1 remains to be clarified when
more observations of both stars are available.
5 CONCLUSIONS
In the present study we demonstrate that CPD -59◦ 2635 is a
close binary system in a circular orbit. Both binary compo-
nents are O-type stars, and the short period of binary motion
suggests strong interactions between the stellar winds.
Variations of the order of one subclass in the spectral
types of both components are observed, probably related to
the phenomenon known as Struve-Sahade effect. A possible
explanation for the Struve-Sahade effect, analyzed by Gies et
al. (1997), is that it is present in systems expected to contain
colliding winds with X-ray generation from the bow shock
between the stars. However, the observed X-ray light curve
does not show any significant variations, and moreover, the
ratio Lx/Lbol seems to be similar to that observed for other
O-type stars.
This star is a massive close binary, with hot, luminous
components (O8V + O9.5V) and thus a good candidate for
further exploration of colliding wind effects.
With the estimated inclination ∼ 60◦, we can conclude
that the stellar radii are smaller than the corresponding
Roche lobes, the system being detached, as one would ex-
pect from the evolutionary status of a member in a cluster
still containing unevolved O3 stars.
Though the system is not expected to present eclipses,
future photometric studies could reveal the presence of phase
locked light variations produced by tidal deformation of the
binary components. This would provide the opportunity of
making a better estimate of the inclination of the orbital
plane, and consequently lead to the derivation of absolute
individual masses for the components of CPD -59◦ 2635.
No need to recall that this is of fundamental astrophysical
interest concerning O-type stars.
6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank the director and staff of CASLEO for techni-
cal support and kind hospitality during the observing runs.
N.I.M. is indebted to the director and staff of CTIO for the
use of their facilities. We acknowledge use at CASLEO of
the CCD and data acquisition system supported under U.S.
NSF grant AST-90-15827 to R. M. Rich.
The Digitized Sky Survey in the southern hemisphere is
based on photographic data obtained using The UK Schmidt
Telescope. The UK Schmidt Telescope was operated by the
Royal Observatory Edinburgh, with funding from the UK
Science and Engineering Research Council, until 1988 June,
and thereafter by the Anglo-Australian Observatory. Orig-
inal plate material is copyright the Royal Observatory Ed-
inburgh and the Anglo-Australian Observatory. The plates
were processed into the present compressed digital form with
their permission. The Digitized Sky Survey was produced at
the Space Telescope Science institute under US Government
grant NAG W-2166. This research has made use of NASA's
Astrophysics Data System Abstract Service. This research
has made use of data obtained from the High Energy As-
trophysics Science Archive Research Center (HEASARC),
provided by NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center.
Useful discussions with R. Barb´a are very much appreciated.
REFERENCES
Andersen J., & Clausen J.V., 1989, A&A, 213, 183
Auer L. H., & Mihalas D. 1972, Ap.J.S., 24, 193.
Berghoffer, T., Schmitt, J. H. M. M., Danner, R., and Cassinelli,
J., 1997, A&A, 322, 167.
Burkholder V., Massey P. & Morrell, N.I., 1997, ApJ, 490, 328
Chlebowski, T., 1989, 342, 1091.
Chlebowski T., & Garmany C. D. 1991, AJ, 368, 241.
Chlebowski, T., Harnden, Jr., F. R., & Sciortino, S. 199, ApJ, 341,
427. David, L., et al., 1997, ROSAT High Resolution Imager
Calibration Report, RSDC/SAO.
Conti P. S., & Burnichon M. L. 1975, A&A, 38, 467.
Conti P. S., & Ebbets, D. 1977, ApJ, 213, 438.
Corcoran M. F. 1999, Rev Mex AASC, 8, in press
David P., Goldwurm A., Murakami T.,Paul J., Laurent P.,
Goldoni P. 1997, A&A., 322, 229D.
Feinstein A., Marraco H. G., & Muzzio J. C. 1973, A&AS., 12,
331.
Gies D. R., Bagnuolo W. G. Jr., & Penny L. R. 1997, AJ, 479,
408.
Jeffers H. M., van den Bos W.H., Greeby F. M. 1963, Index Ca-
talogue of Visual Double Stars, Univ. California, Publ Lick
Obs., Vol XXI.
Kartascheva T.A. & Svechnikov M.A., 1989, Astrofiz. Issled. Izv.
SAO, 28, 3
Kerton C. R., Ballantyne D. R., & Martin P. G. 1999, AJ, 117,
2493.
Lafler J., & Kinman T. D. 1965, ApJS, 11, 199.
Levato H., & Malaroda S. 1982, PASP, 94, 807.
Massey P., & Johnson J. 1993, AJ, 1053, 980.
Mathys, G. 1988, A&AS, 76, 427.
Niemela, V. S., & Morrsion, N. D. 1988, PASP, 100, 1436.
Packzynski B. 1971, Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrphys. , 9, 183.
Petrie, R.M. 1940, Publ. Dom. Astroph. Obs. Victoria, 7, 205.
Schmidt & Kaler 1982, in "Landolt-Bornstein, NS", Vol. 2, p. 455.
Slettebak A., Collins G. W., Boyce P. B., White N. M., & Parkin-
son T. D. 1975, Ap,J.S. 29, 137.
Stephenson C. B., & Sanduleak N. 1971, Publ. Warner & Swasey
Obs., 1, 1.
Stevens, I. R., Blondin, J. M., & Pollock, A.M.T., 1992, ApJ, 386,
265.
Usov, V. V., 1992, ApJ, 389, 635.
Vacca W. D., Garmany C. D. & Shull J. M. 1996, ApJ, 460, 914
(VGS)
Walborn N. 1982, AJ, 87, 1300.
Walborn N., & Fitzpatrick E. 1990, PASP, 102, 379.
This figure "figure1.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0105015v1
|
astro-ph/9704059 | 2 | 9704 | 1997-10-14T08:28:52 | Deconvolution with correct sampling | [
"astro-ph"
] | A new method for improving the resolution of astronomical images is presented. It is based on the principle that sampled data cannot be fully deconvolved without violating the sampling theorem. Thus, the sampled image should not be deconvolved by the total Point Spread Function, but by a narrower function chosen so that the resolution of the deconvolved image is compatible with the adopted sampling. Our deconvolution method gives results which are, in at least some cases, superior to those of other commonly used techniques: in particular, it does not produce ringing around point sources superimposed on a smooth background. Moreover, it allows to perform accurate astrometry and photometry of crowded fields. These improvements are a consequence of both the correct treatment of sampling and the recognition that the most probable astronomical image is not a flat one. The method is also well adapted to the optimal combination of different images of the same object, as can be obtained, e.g., from infrared observations or via adaptive optics techniques. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Deconvolution with correct sampling
P. Magain1
Institut d'Astrophysique, Universit´e de Li`ege,
5, avenue de Cointe,
B -- 4000 Li`ege Belgium
email: [email protected]
F. Courbin
Institut d'Astrophysique, Universit´e de Li`ege,
5, avenue de Cointe,
B -- 4000 Li`ege Belgium
email: [email protected]
URA 173 CNRS-DAEC, Observatoire de Paris,
F-92195 Meudon Principal CEDEX, France
S. Sohy
Institut d'Astrophysique, Universit´e de Li`ege,
5, avenue de Cointe,
B -- 4000 Li`ege Belgium
email: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
A new method for improving the resolution of astronomical images is presented.
It is based on the principle that sampled data cannot be fully deconvolved without
violating the sampling theorem. Thus, the sampled image should not be deconvolved
by the total Point Spread Function, but by a narrower function chosen so that the
resolution of the deconvolved image is compatible with the adopted sampling.
Our deconvolution method gives results which are, in at least some cases, superior
to those of other commonly used techniques : in particular, it does not produce ringing
around point sources superimposed on a smooth background. Moreover, it allows to
perform accurate astrometry and photometry of crowded fields. These improvements
are a consequence of both the correct treatment of sampling and the recognition that
the most probable astronomical image is not a flat one.
The method is also well adapted to the optimal combination of different images of
the same object, as can be obtained, e.g., from infrared observations or via adaptive
optics techniques.
Subject headings: Methods: Numerical - Observational - Data analysis
1Maıtre de Recherches au Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique (Belgium)
-- 2 --
1. Deconvolution
Any recorded image is blurred whenever the instrument used to obtain it has a finite resolving
power : for example, the image of a point source seen through a telescope has an angular size which
is inversely proportional to the diameter of the primary mirror. If the instrument is ground-based,
the image is additionally degraded by the turbulent motions in the earth's atmosphere.
Much effort is presently devoted to the improvement of the spatial resolution of astronomical
images, either via the introduction of new observing techniques (e.g. interferometry or adaptive
optics, see L´ena 1996, Enard et al. 1996) or via a subsequent numerical processing of the image
(deconvolution). It is, in fact, of major interest to combine both methods to reach an even better
resolution.
An observed image may usually be mathematically expressed as a convolution of the original
light distribution with the "total instrumental profile" -- the latter being the image of a point
source obtained with the instrument considered, including the atmospheric perturbation (seeing)
if relevant. The total blurring function is called the Point Spread Function (PSF) of the image.
Thus, the imaging equation may be written :
d(~x) = t(~x) ∗ f (~x) + n(~x)
(1)
where f (~x) and d(~x) are the original and observed light distributions, t(~x) is the total PSF and
n(~x) the measurement errors (noise) affecting the data.
In addition, on all modern light detectors (e.g. CCDs whose pixels have finite dimensions), the
observed light distribution is sampled, i.e. known only at regularly spaced sampling points. The
imaging equation for a sampled light distribution then becomes :
di =
N
Xj=1
tij fj + ni
(2)
where N is the number of sampling points, dj, fj, nj are vector components giving the sampled
values of d(~x), f (~x), n(~x) and tij is the value at point j of the PSF centered on point i.
The aim of deconvolution may be stated in the following way : given the observed image d(~x) and
the PSF t(~x), recover the original light distribution f (~x). Being an inverse problem, deconvolution
is also an ill-posed problem, and no unique solution can be found, especially in the presence of
noise. This is due to the fact that many light distributions are, after convolution with the PSF,
compatible within the error bars with the observed image. Therefore, regularization techniques
have to be used in order to select a plausible solution amongst the family of possible ones and a
large variety of deconvolution methods have been proposed, depending on the way this particular
solution is chosen.
A typical method is to minimize the χ2 of the differences between the data and the convolved
model, with an additional constraint imposing smoothness of the solution. fj is then the light
distribution which minimizes the function :
S1 =
N
Xi=1
1
σ2
N
i
Xj=1
2
tijfj − di
+ λ H(f1, · · · , fN )
(3)
-- 3 --
where the first term in the sum is the χ2 with σi the standard deviation of the image intensity
measured at the ith sampling point, H is a smoothing function and λ a Lagrange parameter which
is determined so that the reconstructed model is statistically compatible with the data (χ2 ≃ N ).
j=1 fj, one
If H(f1, · · · , fN ) = PN
obtains the so-called maximum entropy method for image deconvolution (Narayan and Nityananda
1986, Skilling and Bryan 1984).
i=1 pi ln pi, with pi the normalized flux at point i, pi = fi/PN
In order to choose the correct answer in the family of possible solutions to this inverse problem,
it is also very useful to consider any available prior knowledge. One such prior knowledge is the
positivity of the light distribution : no negative light flux can be recorded, so that all solutions with
negative values may be rejected. The maximum entropy method automatically ensures positivity
of the solution. This is also the case, under certain conditions, for other popular methods, such as
the Richardson-Lucy iterative algorithm (Richardson 1972, Lucy 1974).
Most of the known deconvolution algorithms suffer from a number of weak points which strongly
limit their usefulness. The two most important problems in this respect are the following : (1)
traditional deconvolution methods tend to produce artefacts in some instances (e.g. oscillations
in the vicinity of image discontinuities, or around point sources superimposed on a smooth
background) ; (2) the relative intensities of different parts of the image (e.g. different stars) are
not conserved, thus precluding any photometric measurements. In the next sections, we identify a
plausible cause of these problems and show how to circumvent it.
2. Sampling
The sampling theorem (Shannon 1949, Press et al. 1989) determines the maximal sampling
interval allowed so that an entire function can be reconstructed from sampled data. It states that
a function whose Fourier transform is zero at frequencies larger than a cutoff frequency ν0 is fully
specified by values spaced at equal intervals not exceeding (2 ν0)−1. In practice, for functions
whose Fourier transform does not present such a cutoff frequency, ν0 may be taken as the highest
frequency at which the Fourier transform emerges from the noise.
The imaging instruments are generally designed so that the sampling theorem is approximately
fulfilled in average observing conditions. A typical sampling encountered is ∼ 2 sampling intervals
per Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM) of the PSF (this does certainly not ensure good
sampling for high signal-to-noise (S/N) images, but is roughly sufficient at low S/N).
The main problem with classical deconvolution algorithms is the following : if the observed data
are sampled so that they just obey the sampling theorem, the deconvolved data will generally violate
that same theorem. Indeed, increasing the resolution means recovering highest Fourier frequencies,
thus increasing the cutoff frequency, so that the correct sampling becomes denser.
One might object that some deconvolution algorithms, which allow a different sampling in the
deconvolved image, could overcome this problem : it would be possible to keep a correct sampling
by shortening the sampling interval. This is however an illusory solution, since the only limit on
the frequency components present in an arbitrary image comes from the PSF of the instrument
-- 4 --
used to record it. Removing the effect of the PSF would allow the presence of arbitrary high
frequency components, and thus an infinitely small sampling interval would have to be used.
This is particularly true if the image contains point sources, which is generally the case for
astronomical images. Indeed, the angular diameters of most stars (≪ 0.001 arcsec) are so small
compared to the sampling interval (∼ 0.1 arcsec) that they may be considered as point sources
("δ-functions"). In such an instance, it would be hopeless to reduce the sampling interval in an
attempt to obtain a good sampling of such "δ-functions".
This is one of the sources of some of the artefacts present in the deconvolved images and, in
particular, of the "ringing" around point sources superimposed on a diffuse background. The
origin of this "ringing" may be understood in the following way.
Let us assume that we have a continuous (i.e. not sampled) noise-free image of a field containing
point sources, and observed with an instrument having a known PSF. For simplicity, we restrict
our considerations to one-dimensional images. If we can perfectly deconvolve this image, we shall
obtain a solution f (x) in which each point source is represented by a Dirac δ-function.
Now, let us assume that we have the same image, but sampled on N points, with a sampling step
∆x. The Fourier transform of its deconvolution may be obtained from the Fourier transform F (ν)
of the continuous deconvolution in the following way : repeat periodically F (ν) with the Nyquist
frequency νN y = (2∆x)−1, take the sum of all these periodical replicas at each frequency point,
isolate one period and sample it on N equally spaced frequency points.
Isolating one period means multiplying the Fourier transform by a rectangular ("box") function
which equals 1 in an interval of length νN y and 0 outside. Now, a convolution in the image domain
translates into a simple product in the Fourier domain, and vice-versa. This multiplication by a
box function in the Fourier domain is thus equivalent, in the image domain, to a convolution by
the Fourier transform of the box function, which is a function of the form sin x/x. The solution
of the deconvolution problem for a sampled image with point sources is thus the (sampled)
convolution of the exact solution f (x) with a function of the form sin x/x. Each δ-function is thus
replaced by an oscillatory sin x/x function, which explains the ringing.
Another, more intuitive, explanation of the same effect is the following. If a point source is located
between two sampling points (as will generally be the case), in order to correctly reproduce its
position, the deconvolution algorithm will have to distribute its intensity over several sampling
points. But, then, the width of the source will be too large and ringing will appear as the
algorithm attempts to decrease the intensity on the edges of the reconstructed source, in order to
keep the convolved model as close as possible to the observed data.
In fact, it is not possible to correctly reproduce both the position and the width of a sampled point
source. To reproduce the zero width, the full signal must be concentrated on a single sampling
point. On the other hand, to reproduce the position with a precision which is better than the
sampling interval, the signal has to be distributed over several points.
-- 5 --
3. Solution
The correct approach to this sampling problem is thus not to deconvolve with the total PSF t(~x),
but rather with a narrower function s(~x) chosen so that the deconvolved image has its own PSF
r(~x) compatible with the adopted sampling. These three functions are simply related by :
t(~x) = r(~x) ∗ s(~x)
(4)
Note that a similar decomposition was proposed, in a completely different context (reduction
of artefacts in maximum-likelihood reconstructions for emission tomography), by Snyder et al.
(1987).
The shape and width of r(~x) can be chosen by the user. The only constraint is that Eq. (4)
admits a solution s(~x). The function s(~x) by which the observed image has to be deconvolved is
thus obtained as the deconvolution of the total PSF t(~x) by the final PSF r(~x). Of course, the
sampling interval of the deconvolved image does not need to be equal to the sampling interval of
the original image, so that r(~x) may be much narrower than t(~x), even if the original sampling
would not allow it. Choosing a sufficiently narrow r(~x) effectively insures that Eq. (4) will admit a
solution s(~x). Note also that, contrary to other traditional methods (the success of which depends
crucially on the effectiveness of the positivity constraint), we have no positivity constraint on the
PSFs r(~x) and s(~x).
Thus, the deconvolution algorithm should not attempt to determine the light distribution as if it
were obtained with an ideal instrument (e.g. a space telescope with a primary mirror of infinite
size). This is forbidden as long as the data are sampled. Rather, the aim of deconvolution should
be to determine the light distribution as if it were observed with a better instrument (e.g. a 10 m
space telescope).
Deconvolution by s(~x) ensures that the solution will not violate the sampling theorem. It also
has a very important additional advantage : if the image contains point sources, their shape in
the deconvolved image is now precisely known :
it is simply r(~x). This is a very strong prior
knowledge, and it may be used to constrain the solution f (~x), which can now be written :
f (~x) = h(~x) +
ak r(~x − ~ck)
M
Xk=1
(5)
where M is the number of point sources, for which ak and ~ck are free parameters corresponding to
their intensities and positions, and h(~x) is the extended component of the solution, i.e. generally a
rather smooth background.
We can use another prior knowledge to constrain the solution : we know that the background h(~x)
can also be written as the convolution of some function h′(~x) with the PSF of the solution r(~x) :
h(~x) = r(~x) ∗ h′(~x)
(6)
However, we cannot use that decomposition directly and determine h′(~x) instead of h(~x) because
h′(~x) might violate the sampling theorem, even if it does not contain point sources. Rather, we
may use this knowledge to impose smoothness of h(~x) on the scale length of r(~x).
-- 6 --
So, instead of regularizing the solution by a global function such as the entropy, we use a function
imposing local smoothness of h(~x) on the known scale length. We thus choose the solution which
minimizes the function :
S2 =
N
Xi=1
1
σ2
N
i
Xj=1
sij hj +
M
Xk=1
ak r(~xj −~ck)! − di
2
+ λ
N
Xi=1
hi −
N
Xj=1
2
rij hj
(7)
with respect to the unknowns hi (i = 1, . . . , N ), ak and ~ck (k = 1, . . . , M ).
Although the smoothing term in the right-hand side of Eq. (7) will not force h(~x) to exactly obey
Eq. (6), it essentially contains the Fourier components with frequencies higher than those of the
deconvolved PSF r(~x). Minimizing this term will force the background component to contain only
the frequencies compatible with r(~x) and, thus, with the adopted sampling.
One additional improvement may be introduced. In general, the Lagrange multiplier λ is chosen
so that χ2 ≃ N . This ensures that the fit is statistically correct globally. However, some regions of
the image may be overfitted, and others may be underfitted. In practice, this will generally be the
case : although the residuals will be correct on the average, they will systematically be too small
in some parts of the image and too large in other parts.
To avoid this problem, one may replace the smoothing function by :
H(f1, · · · , fN ) =
N
Xi=1
2
λi
hi −
N
Xj=1
rij hj
(8)
where λi is the value at the ith sampling point of a function λ(~x) which is chosen so that the
residuals of the fit are correct locally, i.e. that they are statistically distributed with the correct
standard deviation in any sub-part of the image.
In practice, an image of the square of the normalized residuals (observed data minus convolved
model, divided by sigma) is computed and then smoothed with an appropriate function, so that
any value is replaced by a weighted mean on a neighborhood containing a few dozens of pixels.
The parameter λ is then adjusted until this image is close to one everywhere.
4. Examples
Our deconvolution program implements the ideas exposed in the preceding section. The light
distribution aimed at is written as the sum of a smooth background plus a number of point
sources. The sampling step of the deconvolved image is chosen, as well as the final PSF r(~x),
compatible with this sampling (in general, we adopt a gaussian function, with a few pixels
FWHM). Approximate values of the unknowns are chosen and the function S2 is computed,
together with its derivatives with respect to all variables. The minimum of S2 is then searched for,
using an algorithm derived from the classical conjugate gradient method (Press et al. 1989). The
fit's residuals are then computed and a check of their statistical correctness is performed. If this
test is not satisfied, the Lagrange multiplier λ is replaced by a variable λ(~x) which is varied until
the residuals conform to the statistical expectations.
-- 7 --
The present version of the program runs on PCs and workstations and can handle images of
reasonable size (e.g., 256 × 256 pixels) containing up to several hundreds of stars. The main
weakness of the present implementation is related to the conjugate gradient algorithm, which is
not always able to find the global minimum of the function, especially when the number of point
sources is large. We are presently working on a new optimization technique which would allow our
method to be applied to the photometry of crowded fields with thousands of stars.
It may not seem obvious at first sight to select the correct number of point sources to be included
in the solution. However, the algorithm allows to constrain this number in a very efficient way :
if too few point sources are entered, it will generally be impossible to obtain statistically correct
residuals locally, in all sub-parts of the image. On the other hand, if too many point sources are
considered, the algorithm will either attribute essentially the same position or negligible intensities
to several of them. Our methodology is thus to model the data with the minimum number of
point sources necessary to yield statistically correct residuals locally in all sub-parts of the image,
in the sense described at the end of the preceding section.
Figure 1 compares the results of our new deconvolution algorithm to those of three classical
methods in the case of a simulated star cluster partly superimposed on a smooth background
(e.g. a distant elliptical galaxy). The input point sources were selected from the observed image
alone, without any prior knowledge of the exact solution. It is clear that our result is free from
the artefacts present in the other methods and that it allows an accurate reconstruction of the
original light distribution. Another important property of our technique is that it allows, contrary
to the other ones, an accurate measurement of the positions and intensities of the point sources.
This point will be discussed more extensively in the next section.
An application to real astronomical data is shown on Fig. 2, which displays a mediocre resolution
image of the "Cloverleaf", a gravitationally lensed quasar (Magain et al. 1988), together with the
deconvolved version, using a sampling interval twice as short. The four lensed images, which were
unresolved in the original data, are completely separated after deconvolution. The deduced fluxes
are fully compatible with those measured on higher resolution images and, although the original
resolution is 1.3 arcsec only and the pixel size is 0.35 arcsec, the deduced image positions are
accurate to 0.01 arcsec.
Figure 3 illustrates the deconvolution of an image of the compact star cluster Sk 157 in the Small
Magellanic Cloud (Heydari-Malayeri et al. 1989). The original image was obtained with the
ESO/MPI 2.2m telescope at La Silla, in average seeing conditions (1.1 arcsec FWHM). While the
original maximum entropy deconvolution (Heydari-Malayeri et al. 1989) allowed to resolve the
cluster into 12 components, our new algorithm detects, from the same input data, more than 40
stars in the corresponding area.
Another important application of our algorithm is the simultaneous deconvolution of different
images of the same field. These images may be obtained with the same instrument or with different
ones. The solution is then a light distribution which is compatible with all the images considered.
Our technique even allows to let, e.g., the intensities of the point sources converge to different
values in the different images, so that variable objects may be considered. This technique should
be very useful for the photometric monitoring of variable objects in crowded fields or overimposed
-- 8 --
on a diffuse background (e.g. Cepheids in distant galaxies, gravitationally lensed QSOs,...).
Figure 4 illustrates this simultaneous deconvolution on simulated images, the first of which has a
good resolution but a poor S/N (as might be obtained with a space telescope) and the second one
a low resolution and a high S/N (a typical image from a large ground-based telescope). Contrary
to Lucy's method (Hook and Lucy 1992) which is very sensitive to the noise present in one of the
images, our technique allows to reliably recover both the high resolution of the space image and
the hidden information content of the ground-based one.
In the same spirit, our algorithm is well adapted to the processing of images obtained with
infrared or adaptive optics techniques. In the latter, numerous short exposures of the same
field are usually obtained, the shape of the mirror being continuously adapted to correct for
atmospheric distortions. So, the observations consist in a number of images of the same field,
each of them having its own PSF. Performing a simple sum results in an image whose spatial
resolution is typical of the average observing conditions, while a simultaneous deconvolution not
only allows to take count of the best conditions, but even results in an improved resolution by
optimally combining the information content of the different images. A simple illustration of
these considerations is provided by Fig. 5, which shows the simultaneous deconvolution of four
adaptive-optics-like images of the same field, where the PSF as well as the image centering vary
from one observation to the other. Of course, the PSF needs to be known for each individual
observation, but only with an accuracy comparable to that of the observation itself.
5. Astrometric and photometric accuracy
Traditional deconvolution methods are notoriously unable to give photometrically accurate results.
Two main reasons for that are readily identified.
First, as we have already mentioned, these methods generally produce rings when point sources are
overimposed on a diffuse background. In fact, these rings tend to appear as soon as the positivity
constraint is inefficient to inhibit them, that is, as soon as some flux is distributed around the
point sources. This is most clearly seen when this flux is in the form of a smooth background,
but the effect is also present if the flux is distributed among, e.g., a number of fainter stars. In
this case, the rings around the star considered will interfere with the intensity in the neighbouring
sources, and the photometry of the latter ones will be affected.
A second photometric bias comes from the fact that, among the family of possible solutions to
the inverse problem, most classical algorithms select, in one way or another, the smoothest one
according to some criterion. These algorithms thus produce images where the peaks corresponding
to point sources deviate as little as possible with respect to the background -- provided, of course,
that the model fits the data. This implies a systematic underestimate of the intensity peaks, and
thus, a photometric bias.
An example of these effects is illustrated by the deconvolution of an image of two point sources
with varying separation. A simple image was constructed, with two point sources having an
intensity ratio of 0.1, and convolved with a Gaussian PSF of 7 pixels FWHM, plus some gaussian
-- 9 --
noise so that the peak S/N ratio reaches 100. Figure 6 shows the deduced intensity ratio as
a function of the source separation, as derived after deconvolution with the maximum entropy
method. It clearly shows that the photometry is not preserved, even when the two stars are
separated by nearly two FWHMs. For more details on the photometric accuracy of deconvolution
algorithms (in the special case of HST images), see Busko (1994).
Our algorithm naturally avoids these two biases. Indeed, the fact that the sampling theorem is
obeyed in the deconvolved image, combined with the fact that no smoothing of the point sources
is attempted, naturally ensure that no ringing is present around the star peaks, and that no
bias will appear as a consequence of smoothing. This is illustrated in Fig. 7, which shows the
results of a photometric test applied to a synthetic field containing 200 stars in a 128× 128 pixels
image. The positions and central intensities were selected at random, and nearly all the stars are
blended to varying degrees (197 stars out of 200 have the nearest neighbour within 2 FWHMs).
Moreover, these stars are superimposed on a variable background. Figure 7 clearly shows that no
systematic error is present, and that the intensities of all but the most severely blended objects
are reproduced with errors compatible with the photon noise.
Figure 8 illustrates the astrometric accuracy of our algorithm. For the brightest stars, the
positional accuracy is generally better than 0.1 pixel, even in very severe blends. The positions of
stars with a blend between 1 and 2 FWHM is generally accurate within 0.02 pixel at high S/N,
and within 0.1 pixel otherwise.
There exits another deconvolution algorithm which claims to achieve a high photometric quality,
namely the so-called two-channel Lucy method (Lucy 1994, Hook and Lucy 1994). As our
algorithm, the two-channel Lucy method is based on a decomposition of the deconvolved model
into point sources and background.
The main problem with that method is that, contrary to ours, the total PSF is used in the
deconvolution, so that the sampling problem is avoided only if each point source is exactly centered
on a pixel. To increase the accuracy, the model can use a finer pixel grid than the data. However,
in high S/N cases, the model pixels will generally need to be very small if high accuracy is aimed
at (which is normally the case in high S/N observations...). As an example, let us recall that the
positions derived from our new algorithm for the different images of the Cloverleaf gravitational
lens (Fig. 2) are accurate to 0.01 arcsec, which is 1/35 of a data pixel. To achieve the same
accuracy with the two channel Lucy algorithm would require each original pixel to be devided in
∼ 35 × 35 ∼ 1000 finer pixels. This would rapidly result in huge data frames and computationally
intractable problems.
Another weakness of the two-channel Lucy method is that the point source positions have to
be supplied by the user, and cannot be adjusted by the algorithm. So, no astrometry can be
performed and, moreover, in the case of high S/N data with many point sources, it might require
an unreasonably large number of trials for the user to find a fairly good estimate of the source
positions.
Finally, let us note that the user has to choose arbitrarily not only the number of iterations of the
algorithm, but also a scale length for the smoothing of the background component. These choices
are generally made by looking at the results. This approach can obviously give nice-looking
-- 10 --
results, but their scientific soundness may be questioned. On the contrary, the scale length for
the smoothing of the background in our method is unambiguously fixed by the PSF r(~x) of the
deconvolved image.
A comparison of the two-channel Lucy method with our algorithm is illustrated below by an
example which is not meant to provide a general comparison between the two methods, but only
to illustrate some of the points in the preceding discussion.
Figure 9 shows the deconvolution of simulated data containing three point sources superimposed
on a background which varies rather fast. The peak S/N of 170 is quite reasonable for modern
CCD detectors. In order to obtain a satisfactory result with the two-channel Lucy method, each
original pixel was divided into 16 model pixels and the positions were adjusted iteratively by the
user. In contrast, when running our algorithm, we kept the same pixel size as in the data (this is
why the results of the two-channel method seem smoother in Fig. 9). The deduced background
light distributions are compared in Fig. 10, which also shows the difference between these deduced
backgrounds and the known solution, reconvolved to the same resolution of 2 pixels FWHM. It is
immediately seen that the residuals are much less important in the case of our method (largest
residual : 4.8 σ as compared to 14 σ with the Lucy method, mean variance : 1.8 σ2 instead of
15 σ2). The photometry of the point sources is also more accurate with our method : the mean
deviation is 1%, as compared to 7% with the two-channel method.
6. Discussion
We summarize here some of the reasons why classical deconvolution algorithms generally give
rather disappointing results, and why our method allows to improve the situation.
A major advantage of our method over traditional ones comes from the fact that the deconvolved
image never violates the sampling theorem, so that the fastest image variations may be correctly
represented, without the introduction of spurious rings, or Gibbs oscillations.
An additional drawback of most traditional deconvolution algorithms lies in their smoothing
recipe. For example, in the maximum entropy method, one assumes that the most probable image
is a perfectly flat one. However, the most probable astronomical image is certainly not a flat one.
It would rather look like a dark background with a number of sharp sources. Trying to smooth
the sharp sources is undesirable, and results in poor performance.
The smoothing function used in the classical maximum entropy method and most of its derivatives
is, moreover, a global function, i.e., a function linking the value of the intensity in a particular
pixel to the values in all other pixels, even very remote ones. Thus, the flux distribution in one
part of the image will depend on what is happening in other remote parts (in astronomical images,
this often corresponds to quite different parts of the Universe). This link is obviously not based
on physical grounds, and is totally avoided by our smoothing function, which is purely local and
linked to the PSF of the deconvolved image.
Another weakness of the most popular of the classical methods (e.g. maximum entropy or
Richardson-Lucy) is that the solution depends on the zero point level of the image : this is due
-- 11 --
to the fact that the positivity constraint is essential for their success. Indeed, this positivity
constraint is the main inhibitor of the ringing around point sources: by forbidding the negative
lobes, it automatically reduces the positive ones since the mean level must be compatible with
the observed data. Adding a constant to the image data results in a strong degradation of the
performance of these algorithms (which then depend, e.g., on a precise subtraction of the sky
level). On the contrary, our technique is completely independent of an additive constant, and it
is reliable enough that the positivity constraint, although it can be used, is not necessary in most
cases (it has not been used in any of the examples shown in this paper).
As can be seen from the above examples and from the discussion, our new deconvolution technique
is well adapted to the processing of astronomical images. It is however not restricted to that field
of imaging and, in fact, should be useful in several other areas where an enhancement of the image
resolution is desirable, or where different images of the same object could be optimally combined.
References
Busko, I.C., in The Restoration of HST Images and Spectra-II, R.J. Hanisch and R.L. White, eds.,
p. 279 (1994)
Enard, D., Mar´echal, A. & Espiard, J. Rep. Prog. Phys. 59, 601 (1996)
Heydari-Malayeri, M., Magain, P. & Remy, M. Astron. Astrophys. 222, 41 (1989)
Hook, R.N. & Lucy, L., ST-ECF Newsletter 17, 10 (1992)
Hook, R.N. & Lucy, L., in The Restoration of HST Images and Spectra-II, R.J. Hanisch and R.L.
White, eds., p. 86 (1994)
L´ena, P. Astrophysique. M´ethodes physiques de l'observation, 2nd edition, CNRS Editions, Paris,
1996 (english translation of the first edition : Observational Astrophysics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin,
1988)
Lucy, L. Astron. J. 79, 745 (1974)
Lucy, L. ST-ECF Newsletter 16, 6 (1991)
Lucy, L., in The Restoration of HST Images and Spectra-II, R.J. Hanisch and R.L. White, eds.,
p. 79 (1994)
Magain, P., Surdej, J., Swings, J.-P. et al. Nature 334, 325 (1988)
Narayan, R. & Nityananda, R. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 24, 127 (1986)
Press, W. H., Flannery, B. P., Teukolsky, S. A. & Vetterling, W. T. Numerical Recipes (Cambridge
University Press, 1989)
Richardson, W. H. J. Opt. Soc. America 62, 55 (1972)
Shannon, C. J. Proc. I. R. E. 37, 10 (1949)
-- 12 --
Skilling, J. & Bryan, R. K. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 211, 111 (1984)
Snyder, D. L., Miller, M. I., Thomas, L. J., & Politte, D. G. IEEE Transactions on Medical
Imaging MI-6, 228 (1987)
Acknowledgements
This work has been supported by contracts ARC 94/99-178 "Action de Recherche Concert´ee de la
Communaut´e Fran¸caise de Belgique", SC 005 "Service Center and Research Networks" and Pole
d'Attraction Interuniversitaire P4/05 (SSTC, Belgium).
-- 13 --
Fig. 1. -- Deconvolution of a simulated image of a star cluster partly superimposed on a background
galaxy. Top left : true light distribution with 2 pixels FWHM resolution ; bottom left : observed
image with 6 pixels FWHM and noise ; top middle : Wiener filter deconvolution of the observed
image ; bottom middle : 50 iterations of the accelerated Richardson-Lucy algorithm ; top right :
maximum entropy deconvolution ; bottom right : deconvolution with our new algorithm.
Fig. 2. -- Deconvolution of a pre-discovery image of the Cloverleaf gravitational mirage obtained
with the ESO/MPI 2.2m telescope at La Silla (Chile). Left : observed image with a FWHM
resolution of 1.3 arcsec ; right : our deconvolution with improved sampling and a FWHM resolution
of 0.5 arcsec.
Fig. 3. -- Deconvolution of an image of the compact star cluster Sk 157 in the Small Magellanic
Cloud. Left : image obtained with the ESO/MPI 2.2m telescope at La Silla (1.1 arcsec FWHM);
right : deconvolution with our algorithm (0.26 arcsec FWHM).
Fig. 4. -- Simultaneous deconvolution of simulated images. Top left : true light distribution with
2 pixels FWHM resolution ; top middle : image obtained with a space telescope ; top right : image
obtained with a large ground-based telescope ; bottom left : sum of the two images ; bottom middle :
simultaneous deconvolution with Lucy's algorithm ; bottom right : simultaneous deconvolution with
our new algorithm.
Fig. 5. -- Simultaneous deconvolution of 4 simulated adaptive-optics-like images. Top left : true light
distribution with 2 pixels FWHM resolution ; middle and right : 4 images obtained with the same
instrument but in varying atmospheric conditions ; bottom left : simultaneous deconvolution with
our new algorithm.
Fig. 6. -- Intensity ratio derived after deconvolution with the maximum entropy method for a pair
of point sources with variable separation. The true intensity ratio is 0.1, the peak S/N ratio is 100
and the original resolution is 7 pixels FWHM.
-- 14 --
Fig. 7. -- Photometric test performed on a synthetic field containing 200 stars with random positions
and intensities, nearly all blended to various degrees (see text). The relative errors are plotted
against the total intensity (the latter being on an arbitrary scale, corresponding to an integrated
S/N varying from 10 to 400). Open symbols represent heavily blended stars (the distance to the
nearest neighbour is smaller than the FWHM), filled symbols correspond to less blended objects.
The dashed curves are the theoretical 3σ errors for isolated stars, taking into account the photon
noise alone.
Fig. 8. -- Astrometric test performed on the same crowded field as in Fig. 7. The total error in
position (expressed in fractions of a pixel) is plotted versus the total intensity. Open symbols
represent heavily blended stars (the distance to the nearest neighbour is smaller than the FWHM),
filled symbols correspond to less blended objects.
Fig. 9. -- Deconvolution of an image containing 3 points sources superimposed on a variable
background. Top left : observed image; top right : deconvolution with 50 iterations of the accelerated
Richardson-Lucy algorithm; bottom left : deconvolution with 1000 iterations of the two-channel
Lucy method; bottom right : deconvolution with our algorithm.
Fig. 10. -- Comparison of the background light distributions deduced from the deconvolution of the
image in Fig. 9, using the two-channel Lucy method (top left) and our method (top right). The
bottom panels show the square of the difference between the deduced background (reconvolved to
the same 2 pixels resolution when necessary) and the exact solution, with the two-channel Lucy
method (left) and with our algorithm (right).
This figure "fig1.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig2.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig3.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig4.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig5.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig9.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
This figure "fig10.jpg" is available in "jpg"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9704059v2
|
astro-ph/0609188 | 2 | 0609 | 2006-12-19T17:36:43 | Can extragalactic foregrounds explain the large-angle CMB anomalies? | [
"astro-ph"
] | We address the effect of an extended local foreground on the low-l anomalies found in the CMB. Recent X-ray catalogues point us to the existence of very massive superstructures at the 100 h^(-1) Mpc scale that contribute significantly to the dipole velocity profile. Being highly non-linear, these structures provide us a natural candidate to leave an imprint on the CMB sky via a local Rees-Sciama effect. We show that the Rees-Sciama effect of local foregrounds can induce CMB anisotropy of DeltaT/T ~ 10^(-5) and we analyse its impact on multipole power as well as the induced phase pattern on largest angular scales. | astro-ph | astro-ph | October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
6
0
0
2
c
e
D
9
1
2
v
8
8
1
9
0
6
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
CAN EXTRAGALACTIC FOREGROUNDS EXPLAIN THE
LARGE -- ANGLE CMB ANOMALIES?
Aleksandar Raki´c 1, Syksy Rasanen2 and Dominik J. Schwarz1
1 Fakultat fur Physik, Universitat Bielefeld, Postfach 100131, D-33501 Bielefeld Germany
2 CERN Physics Department Theory Unit, CH -- 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland
email: rakic at physik dot uni -- bielefeld dot de, syksy dot rasanen at iki dot fi,
dschwarz at physik dot uni -- bielefeld dot de
We address the effect of an extended local foreground on the low -- ℓ anomalies found in the
CMB. Recent X -- ray catalogues point us to the existence of very massive superstructures
at the 100 h−1Mpc scale that contribute significantly to the dipole velocity profile. Being
highly non -- linear, these structures provide us a natural candidate to leave an imprint
on the CMB sky via a local Rees -- Sciama effect. We show that the Rees -- Sciama effect
of local foregrounds can induce CMB anisotropy of ∆T /T ∼ 10−5 and we analyse its
impact on multipole power as well as the induced phase pattern on largest angular scales.
1. Motivation and Overview
At largest angular scales which correspond to small multipole moments ℓ there exist
puzzling features in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). The near vanishing
of the two -- point angular correlation function in all wavebands for angular scales
between 60◦ and 170◦ is one of the longest known anomalies, already detected in
the data of the Cosmic Background Explorer's Differential Radiometer (COBE --
DMR). It has been confirmed and persists in the three -- year Wilkinson Microwave
Anisotropy Probe data [WMAP(3yr)].1,2 Among the two -- point angular correlation
functions it has been shown that none of the almost vanishing cut -- sky wavebands
matches the full sky and again neither one of these is in accordance with the best
fit Λ cold dark matter (ΛCDM) model.3 The disagreement turned out to be even
more distinctive in the WMAP(3yr) data than in WMAP(1yr) and is unexpected
at 99.97% C.L. for the updated Internal Linear Combination map [ILC(3yr)].3
Besides the lack of power, there are a number of remarkable anomalies regarding
the phase relationships of the quadrupole and octopole within the WMAP data.4 -- 6
In order to be able to make distinct statements with respect to a phase analysis of
multipoles we make use of the multipole vectors formalism.7 Looking at quadrupole
plus octopole vectors from WMAP(3yr) the alignment with the equinox (EQX) and
with the ecliptic is found to be unlikely at 99.8% C.L. and 96% C.L. respectively.3
The correlation with the dipole direction and with the galactic plane is found to
be odd at 99.7% C.L. and 99% C.L. respectively. Moreover from the combined full
sky map of ℓ = 2 + 3 one infers that the octopole is quite planar and that the
ecliptic strongly follows a zero line of the map, leaving the two strongest extrema
in the southern hemisphere and the two weakest in the northern hemisphere. Some
of these effects are statistically dependent, e.g. given the observed quadrupole --
octopole alignment, the significance of alignment with the galactic plane is reduced
to unremarkable 88% C.L.
These findings support the conclusion that either the Universe as seen by WMAP
1
October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
2
is not statistically isotropic on largest scales, or that the observed features are due to
unexpected foregrounds, hidden systematics or new physics challenging the standard
cosmological model. Diverse attempts for explanation can be found in the litera-
ture: considering anisotropic or inhomogeneous models [Bianchi family, Lemaıtre --
Tolman -- Bondi (LTB) models],8 -- 13 Solar system foreground,14 lensing of the CMB15
and moving foregrounds,16 Sunyaev -- Zel'dovich (SZ) effect17,18 and Rees-Sciama
(RS) effect,12,19 considering a non -- trivial topology of the Universe,20,21 considering
modifications and refinements of the standard simplest scenario of inflation,22 -- 28
considering possible phenomenology of loop quantum gravity.29,30 In this talk we
update and expand our previous work12 in the light of the WMAP(3yr) data release.
2. Local Structures and Rees-Sciama Effect
Recent X-ray catalogues of our neighborhood show that a major contribution to
the dipole velocity profile originates from the Shapley Supercluster (SSC) and other
density concentrations at a distance of of around 130 -- 180 h−1 Mpc.31 -- 34 The SSC is
a massive concentration centered around the object A3558 with a density contrast
of δ ≃ 5 over the inner 30 h−1Mpc region.35
We will show that the CMB displays correlations between the dipole and higher
multipoles after passing through non -- linear structures, due to the RS effect.36 The
physics of the RS effect is that in the non -- linear regime of structure formation, the
gravitational potential changes with time, so photons climb out of a slightly different
potential well than the one they fell into. Following ref.37 the CMB anisotropy pro-
duced by a spherical superstructure is estimated by the integral of the gravitational
potential perturbation φ ≃ δM/d along the path of the photon: ∆T (θ, ϕ)/T ≃ φ vc ,
where d is the physical size of the structure and δM is the mass excess. Here we
assumed a structure collapsing at velocity vc and let the evolution time of the
structure tc be the matter crossing time d/vc (using c ≡ 1 ≡ G). We estimate
the typical collapse velocity from the energy balance condition v2
c ≃ φ and get:
∆T (θ, ϕ)/T ∼ φ3/2 ∼ (δM/d)3/2. We model the non -- linear structure by a spher-
ically symmetric LTB model embedded in a flat (Ω = 1) Friedmann -- Robertson --
Walker Universe. Substituting the expression for the mass excess within this model
we arrive at:37
∆T (θ, ϕ)
T
∼(cid:18) δρ
ρ (cid:19)3/2(cid:18) d
t(cid:19)3
,
(1)
where t is the cosmic time at which the CMB photons crossed the structure.
Inserting the characteristics of the SSC it follows that a CMB anisotropy of 10−5
due to a local RS effect is reasonable. For simplicity we picture the local Universe
as a spherically symmetric density distribution, with the Local Group (LG) falling
towards the core of the overdensity at the centre. The line between our location and
the centre defines a preferred direction z, which in the present case corresponds
to the direction of the dipole. This setup exhibits rotational symmetry w.r.t. the
axis z (neglecting transverse components of our motion). Consequently, only zonal
October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
axial= 0 µK [WMAP(1yr) best-fit ΛCDM]
a20
20 µK
40 µK
70 µK
WMAP(1yr)
WMAP(3yr)
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
d
o
o
h
i
l
e
k
L
i
0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
C2 in [0.1 mK]2
0.2
0.25
0.3
d
o
o
h
i
l
e
k
L
i
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
3
axial=
a30
0 µK [WMAP(1yr) best-fit ΛCDM]
20 µK
40 µK
70 µK
WMAP(1yr)
WMAP(3yr)
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
C3 in [0.1 mK]2
0.2
0.25
0.3
Fig. 1. Likelihood of quadrupole and octopole power for increased axial contributions. Vertical
lines denote experimental data: WMAP(1yr) cut -- sky and WMAP(3yr) maximum likelihood es-
timate. Considering the quadrupole adding any multipole power was excluded at > 99% C.L.
w.r.t WMAP(1yr) but it is possible to add up to 60µK within the same exclusion level w.r.t. the
WMAP(3yr) value. The octopole is more resistant against axial contaminations as it is possible
to add a whole 100µK before reaching the same exclusion level w.r.t the updated WMAP data.
harmonics (m = 0 in the z-frame) are generated. Note that any other effect with
axial symmetry would also induce anisotropy only in the zonal harmonics.
3. Multipole Analysis
We study how maps of the CMB are affected by the anisotropy induced by additional
axisymmetric contributions aaxial
added to the quadrupole and octopole by using
Monte Carlo (MC) methods. As predicted by the simplest inflationary models, we
assume that the aℓm are fully characterised only by angular power, for which we
use the values from the best fit ΛCDM temperature spectrum to the WMAP data.2
We produced 105 MC realisations of ℓ = 2 and ℓ = 3 for the statistical analysis.
ℓ0
The angular power spectrum is estimated by Cℓ = 1/(2ℓ + 1)Pm aℓm2. In fig.
1 we show how the histograms for the quadrupole and octopole power compare with
the measured values from WMAP(1yr,3yr). Considering the WMAP(1yr) cut -- sky,
adding any power to the quadrupole was already excluded at > 99% C.L. whereas
the WMAP(3yr) data allows for adding up to aaxial
20 = 60µK in order to reach the
same exclusion level. The octopole is quite robust against axial contaminations as
it lies better on the fit: in order to reach the same exclusion level of > 99% C.L.
it is necessary to add aaxial
30 = 80µK w.r.t. the WMAP(1yr) cut -- sky and a whole
aaxial
30 = 100µK w.r.t. the WMAP(3yr) value. Considering only the WMAP(3yr)
maximum likelihood estimate and increasing the effect of local structures up to
aaxial
ℓ0 = 70µK leads to an exclusion of 99.5% C.L. for C2 and 92.9% C.L. for C3.
ℓ0
The next question is what kind of phase pattern the contribution aaxial
will
induce on the CMB sky. Using the multipole vector formalism7 a (temperature)
multipole on a sphere can be alternatively decomposed as:
Tℓ =
ℓ
Xm=−ℓ
aℓmYℓm(θ, ϕ) = A(ℓ)" ℓ
Yi=1(cid:16)v
(ℓ,i) · e(θ, ϕ)(cid:17) − Lℓ(θ, ϕ)# ,
(2)
October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
4
where e(θ, ϕ) = (sin θ cos ϕ, sin θ sin ϕ, cos θ) is a radial unit vector. With the de-
composition (2) it is possible to obtain an unique factorisation of a multipole into a
(ℓ,i) that contain
scalar part A(ℓ) which measures its total power and ℓ unit vectors v
all the directional information. The signs of the multipole vectors can be absorbed
into the scalar quantity A(ℓ), and are thus unphysical.
Introducing the ℓ(ℓ − 1)/2 oriented areas n(ℓ;i,j) ≡ v
(ℓ,j)
we are ready to define a statistic in order to probe alignment of the normals n(ℓ;i,j)
with a given physical direction x:
(ℓ,i) × v
(ℓ,i) × v
(ℓ,j)/v
Snx ≡
.
(3)
1
4 Xℓ=2,3Xi<j(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
n
(ℓ;i,j) · x(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
We test for alignment with three natural directions x: the north ecliptic pole
(NEP), EQX and the north galactic pole (NGP). The results of the correlation
analysis are shown in fig. 2: in the first row the preferred direction z coincides with
the direction of local motion, the dipole.38 Here the anomaly becomes worse when
increasing the amplitude of the axial contribution. But for x = NEP the exclusion
becomes somewhat milder; e.g. aaxial
ℓ0 = 40µK leads to an exclusion of 99.2% C.L.
for ILC(1yr) but only 98.2% C.L. for the updated ILC map. Finding an alignment
with the EQX though is strongly excluded at > 99.2%C.L. even with a vanishing
axial contribution for both one -- and three -- year data.
In the second row of fig. 2 we let the preferred direction point to the NEP as
a complementary test. Here the probability to find an ecliptic alignment becomes
dramatically increased: with a aaxial
ℓ0 = 70µK it is 17% and 10% for the ILC(3yr)
and ILC(1yr) values respectively. Regarding the three -- year data the probability
for finding an EQX alignment increases from 1% to 3% for aaxial
ℓ0 = 70µK. The
alignment with the NGP remains quite stable for both tested directions of z.
4. Conclusion
Recent astrophysical data cataloguing our neighborhood in the X -- ray band point
us to the existence of massive non -- linear structures like the SSC at distances
∼ 100 h−1Mpc. Besides its significant contribution to the dipole velocity profile
such a structure is able to induce anisotropies ∼ 10−5 via its RS effect. Regarding
CMB modes, the spherical symmetry (LTB) which we use to approximate the local
superstructure reduces to an axial symmetry along the line connecting our position
and the centre of the superstructure where we locate the SSC. We produced statisti-
cally isotropic and gaussian MC maps of the CMB and computed their S -- statistics
(3) for alignment with generic astrophysical directions like the NEP, EQX and NGP.
The additional zonal harmonics have been added with increasing strength (see ref.39
for full -- sky maps). When gauging the preferred axis to the direction of local mo-
tion (WMAP dipole) the consistency of the data with theory becomes even worse,
albeit with less significance w.r.t. WMAP(3yr). On the other hand an orthogonally
directed (Solar system) effect would be more consistent with the three -- year data.
October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
5
Considering extended local foregrounds Abramo et al.17 recently proposed that
a cold spot in the direction of the local Supercluster could account for the cross
alignments of quadrupole and octopole. The cold spot would be realised by the SZ
effect of CMB photons scattering of the hot intracluster gas. On the other hand
Inoue and Silk19 suggest a certain geometrical pattern of two identical voids to
account for the cross alignment as well as for the octopole planarity via the RS
effect. Each of the latter approaches alone is not fully satisfactory. Nevertheless a
combined approach enfolding the RS effect as well as the SZ effect from extended
foregrounds seems promising for the future. Moreover, since the local RS effect can
contribute up to 10−5 to the temperature anisotropies on large angular scales, a
detailed study is important for cross -- correlating CMB data (including upcoming
Planck data) with astrophysical observations on the local large -- scale structure.
Acknowledgment
It is a pleasure to thank the organisers of the 11th Marcel Grossmann meeting for their
effort and the opportunity to speak. We acknowledge the use of the Legacy Archive for
Microwave Background Data Analysis (LAMBDA) provided by the NASA Office of Space
Science. The work of AR is supported by the DFG grant GRK 881.
References
1. G. Hinshaw et al., astro-ph/0603451.
2. WMAP data products at http://lambda.gsfc.nasa.gov/
3. C. Copi, D. Huterer, D. J. Schwarz and G. Starkman, astro-ph/0605135.
4. D. J. Schwarz, G. D. Starkman, D. Huterer and C. J. Copi, PRL 93, 221301 (2004).
d
o
o
h
i
l
e
k
L
i
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
axis in direction of WMAP dipole
axial=
al0
0 µK
40 µK
70 µK
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
axial= 0 µK
al0
40 µK
70 µK
axis in direction of WMAP dipole
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
axis in direction of WMAP dipole
axial=
al0
0 µK
40 µK
70 µK
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0
0.2
0.4
SnNEP
0.6
0.8
1
0
0
0.2
0.4
SnEQX
0.6
0.8
1
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
SnNGP
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
d
o
o
h
i
l
e
k
L
i
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
axis in direction of north ecliptic pole
axial=
al0
0 µK
40 µK
70 µK
axis in direction of north ecliptic pole
axial=
al0
0 µK
40 µK
70 µK
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
axis in direction of north ecliptic pole
axial=
al0
0 µK
40 µK
70 µK
)
r
y
3
(
C
L
I
)
r
y
1
(
C
L
I
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
0
0.2
0.4
SnNEP
0.6
0.8
1
0
0
0.2
0.4
SnEQX
0.6
0.8
1
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
SnNGP
Fig. 2. WMAP one- and three -- year ILC maps compared to the alignment (3) of quadrupole
and octopole normals with physical directions (NEP, EQX, NGP in columns) for two orthogonal
realisations of the preferred direction z (WMAP dipole, NEP in rows). The bold histograms
represent statistically isotropic and gaussian skies. Increasing the axial contribution makes the
anomalies worse for z = WMAP dipole, but with the exclusions being less significant for the
ILC(3yr) than for the ILC(1yr). At the same time a Solar system effect is preferred by the data.
October 18, 2018 18:20
WSPC - Proceedings Trim Size: 9.75in x 6.5in main
6
5. H. K. Eriksen, F. K. Hansen, A. J. Banday, K. M. G´orski and P. B. Lilje, ApJ 605,
14 (2004); (Erratum) 609, 1198 (2004).
6. A. de Oliveira -- Costa, M. Tegmark, M. Zaldarriaga and M. Hamilton, Phys. Rev. D
69, 063516 (2004);A. de Oliveira -- Costa and M. Tegmark, astro-ph/0603369.
7. C. J. Copi, D. Huterer and G. D. Starkman, Phys. Rev. D 70, 043515 (2004).
8. T. Ghosh, A. Hajian and T. Souradeep, astro-ph/0604279.
9. T. R. Jaffe, A. J. Banday, H. K. Eriksen, K. M. Gorski and F. K. Hansen,
astro-ph/0606046 and references therein.
10. H. Alnes and M. Amarzguioui, astro-ph/0607334.
11. J. W. Moffat JCAP 0510, 012 (2005).
12. A. Raki´c, S. Rasanen and D. J. Schwarz, MNRAS 369, L27 (2006).
13. K. Tomita Phys. Rev. D 72, 043526 (2005), Phys. Rev. D 72 103506; (Erratum) D
73 029901.
14. P. C. Frisch, ApJ 632, L143 (2005).
15. C. Vale, astro-ph/0509039.
16. A. Cooray and N. Seto, JCAP 0512, 004 (2005).
17. L. R. Abramo and L. Sodr´e Jr., astro-ph/0312124;
L. R. Abramo, L. Sodr´e Jr. and C. A. Wuensche, astro-ph/0605269.
18. F. K. Hansen, E. Branchini, P. Mazzotta, P. Cabella and K. Dolag, MNRAS 361, 753
(2005).
19. K. T. Inoue and J. Silk, ApJ 648, 23 (2006); K. T. Inoue and J. Silk, astro-ph/0612347.
20. A. Riazuelo, J. Weeks, J. P. Uzan, R. Lehoucq and J. P. Luminet, Phys. Rev. D 69,
103518 (2004); J. P. Luminet, J. Weeks, A. Riazuelo, R. Lehoucq and J. P. Uzan,
Nature 425, 593 (2003).
21. J. Shapiro Key, N. J. Cornish, D. N. Spergel and G. D. Starkman, astro-ph/0604616;
N. J. Cornish, D. N. Spergel, G. D. Starkman and E. Komatsu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92,
201302 (2004).
22. D. Boyanovsky, H. J. de Vega and N. G. Sanchez, astro-ph/0607508; astro-ph/0607487.
23. L. Campanelli, P. Cea and L. Tedesco, astro-ph/0606266.
24. C. R. Contaldi, M. Peloso, L. Kofman and A. Linde, JCAP 0307, 002 (2003).
25. F. Ferrer, S. Rasanen and J. Valiviita, JCAP 0410, 010 (2004).
26. C. Gordon and W. Hu, Phys. Rev. D 70, 083003 (2004).
27. A. E. Gumruk¸cuoglu, C. R. Contaldi and M. Peloso, astro-ph/0608405.
28. C. -- H. Wu, K. -- W. Ng, W. Lee, D. -- S. Lee and Y. -- Y. Charng, astro-ph/0604292.
29. S. Hofmann and O. Winkler, gr-qc/0411124.
30. S. Tsujikawa, P. Singh and R. Maartens, CQG 21, 5767 (2004).
31. D. D. Kocevski, C. R. Mullis, H. Ebeling, ApJ 608, 721 (2004).
32. D. D. Kocevski, H. Ebeling, ApJ 645, 1043 (2006).
33. M. J. Hudson, R. J. Smith, J. R. Lucey, E. Branchini, MNRAS 352, 61 (2004).
34. J. Lucey, D. Radburn -- Smith, M. Hudson, astro-ph/0412329.
35. D. Proust et al., A&A 447, 133 (2006).
36. M. J. Rees, D. W. Sciama, Nature 217, 511 (1968).
37. M. Panek, ApJ 388, 225 (1992).
38. C. L. Bennett et al., ApJS 148, 1 (2003).
39. Full -- sky maps at http://www.physik.uni-bielefeld.de/cosmology/rs.html
|
astro-ph/0503044 | 2 | 0503 | 2006-02-08T17:06:38 | Effect of entrainment on stress and pulsar glitches in neutron star crust | [
"astro-ph"
] | The build up of the stress whose relaxation is presumed to account for pulsar frequency glitches can be attributed to various mechanisms, of which the most efficient involve differential rotation of the neutron superfluid in the inner layers of the (magnetically braked) solid crust of a rotating neutron star. In such a case it is usually supposed that the stress is attributable to pinning of superfluid vortices to crust nuclei, but it has been suggested that, even if the pinning effect is too weak, a comparably large stress might still arise just from the deficit of centrifugal buoyancy in the slowed down crust. The present work is a re-examination that investigates the way such processes may be affected by considerations that were overlooked in the previous work -- notably uncertainties about the ``effective'' masses that have to be attributed to the ``free'' superfluid neutrons to allow for their entrainment by the ionic crust material. Though restricted to a Newtonian formulation, this analysis distinguishes more carefully than has been usual between true velocities, which are contravariantly vectorial, and so called ``superfluid velocities'' that are proportional to momenta, which are essentially covectorial, a technicality that is important when more than one independent current is involved. The results include a Proudman type theorem to the effect that the superfluid angular velocity must be constant on slightly deformed Taylor cylinders in the force free case, and it is shown how to construct a pair of integral constants of the motion that determine the solution for the pinned case assuming beta equilibrium. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Effect of entrainment on stress and pulsar glitches
in stratified neutron star crust
Nicolas Chamel⋆ †, Brandon Carter⋆
⋆ LuTh, Observatoire de Paris, 92195 Meudon, France
† Centrum Astronomiczne im M. Kopernika, Warszawa, Polska
Extended version, 10 December 2005
Abstract
1
Introduction
The build up of the stress whose relaxation is presumed
to account for pulsar frequency glitches can be attributed
to various mechanisms, of which the most efficient involve
differential rotation of the neutron superfluid in the inner
layers of the (magnetically braked) solid crust of a rotat-
ing neutron star.
In such a case it is usually supposed
that the stress is attributable to pinning of superfluid vor-
tices to crust nuclei, but it has been suggested that, even
if the pinning effect is too weak, a comparably large stress
might still arise just from the deficit of centrifugal buoy-
ancy in the slowed down crust. The present work is a
re-examination that investigates the way such processes
may be affected by considerations that were overlooked in
the previous work -- notably uncertainties about the "effec-
tive" masses that have to be attributed to the "free" super-
fluid neutrons to allow for their entrainment by the ionic
crust material. Though restricted to a Newtonian formu-
lation, this analysis distinguishes more carefully than has
been usual between true velocities, which are contravari-
antly vectorial, and so called "superfluid velocities" that
are proportional to momenta, which are essentially cov-
ectorial, a technicality that is important when more than
one independent current is involved. The results include a
Proudman type theorem to the effect that the superfluid
angular velocity must be constant on slightly deformed
Taylor cylinders in the force free case, and it is shown how
to construct a pair of integral constants of the motion that
determine the solution for the pinned case assuming beta
equilibrium.
1
This work is intended as a comparison of the qualitative
mathematical consequences of hypotheses of various alter-
native kinds (particularly concerning vortex pinning and
chemical equilibrium) that have been invoked in the con-
struction of differentially rotating neutron star models of
the type developed to acccount for phenomena observed
in pulsars.
It is hoped that this qualitative study will be helpful
for the preparation of quantitative models designed to im-
prove on those of the simple kind constructed by Prix et
al [39], for which (as for the analogously constructed mod-
els [40] in a relativistic framework) separately conserved
proton and superfluid neutron currents were able to de-
viate from Proudman - Taylor type corotation illustrated
on figure 1, without giving rise to the (glitch producing)
stresses that are actually anticipated. In earlier work [38]
such stresses were obtained by including allowance for the
effect of vortex pinning, but it has since been remarked [16]
that deviations from corotation would give rise to stresses
in any case (with or without pinning) when allowance is
made for the consideration that the proton and neutron
numbers will not be separately conserved but will undergo
transfusion (by beta processes) so as to achieve chemical
equilibrium.
The work of Prix [38] and of Carter et al [16] used a
simplified treatment that neglected the mechanism of rel-
ative entrainment between the differentially rotating con-
stituents, an effect which had already been considered in
earlier work (both in a Newtonian framework [34] and also
[30] in a relativistic treatment) but which had been consid-
ered to be only of secondary relevance as a minor quan-
titative correction. The effect of entrainment (but not
transfusion) in the liquid core was allowed for in the more
recent work of Comer & Andersson [18] and of Prix et al.
[39], and it has since been recognised [17] to be particu-
larly important in the crust layers that are the primary
concern of the present analysis, which will consider the
(glitch producing) stresses that can be expected to arise
from the combined effect of entrainment, pinning, trans-
fusion, and also nuclear stratification.
Explanations of the glitches of the pulsar period P =
2π/Ω observed in rotating neutron stars may be broadly
classified into two main categories. In what may be de-
scribed as the "deformation" category, the discontinuous
spin up δΩ is attributed to a sudden change of the geomet-
ric configuration of the matter distribution [23], whereby
the relevant moment of inertia is decreased so that -- for
a given angular momentum -- the angular velocity Ω must
increase. While conceivably sufficient to account for cases
such as the glitches of order δΩ/Ω ≃ 10−8 observed in the
Crab pulsar, such a deformation mechanism is inadequate
for explaining the frequent occurrence of the larger gliches
δΩ/Ω ≃ 10−6 observed in Vela like pulsars, not to mention
the enormous glitch δΩ/Ω ≃ 1.6 × 10−5 recently observed
in PSR J1806-2125 by Hobbs et al. [24].
To account for the frequent occurence of such large
glitches, it has long been generally recognised [8] to be
necessary to invoke a mechanism belonging to what may
be referred to as the "transfer" category, involving inter-
action between two dynamically distinct constituents of
the star. In such a case the discontinuous increase in the
observed angular velocity Ω is attributed to transfer of
angular momentum from a more rapidly rotating internal
constituent to a more slowly rotating constituent that is
directly coupled to the outer magnetosphere whose pulsa-
tions are directly observed. However it is not so clear what
actually happens during the discontinous process involved.
It has been suggested [42] that the stress due to pinning of
neutron superfluid vortices to the ionic crust material may
build up elastic stress to the point where the solid stuc-
ture itself breaks down (as in a terrestrial earthquake). In
another much studied scenario [2, 37] it is postulated that
before this can happen there will be a crisis of a different
kind whereby a threshold is reached at which the vortices
in the crust become collectively unpinned (whereas in the
fluid core it is expected that vortices in the core will be
subject to a strong dissipative drag, which will simulates
pinning but will not be limited by any threshold). Another
possibility [27, 26, 21, 22] is that pinning in the crust may
be too weak to be effective, but it has been pointed out
[16] that differential rotation might in principle by itself
engender sufficient elastic stress to cause a breakdown of
the solid structure even in the absence of pinning.
The main purpose of the present work is not to draw any
specific conclusions about the relative plausibility of these
various postulates in particular cases, but to consider, gen-
erally, how such alternatives will affect the predicted out-
come, and how estimates of relevant quantities such as
subcomponent moments inertia and stresses may need to
be modified to take account of some effects that tended to
be neglected in preceding discussions, including stratifica-
tion and particularly the entrainment between the ionic
crust material and the "free" superfluid neutrons, which
thereby aquire "effective masses" that can be defined in
various ways, but that in any case are likely[13, 14, 15] to
be large enough to make an important difference.
In order to carry out such a revision, and as a secondary
purpose in its own right, this work employs and develops a
Newtonian formulation of the covariant kind [11, 12] whose
use would be taken for granted in a relativistic treatment,
in which care is taken to distinguish between true veloc-
ities, which are contravariantly vectorial, and so called
"superfluid velocities" that are proportional to momenta,
which are essentially covectorial.
Although deeply rooted in the well known principles of
Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, the fundamental
distinction between velocities and their canonical conju-
gates, namely momenta, has commonly been obscured in
the context of superfluidity as traditionally formulated [34]
in a Newtonian framework, for which it has long been cus-
tomary to use the term "velocity" indiscriminately for any-
thing having the physical dimensions thereoff, regardless
of its actual mathematical role. The distinction is rela-
tively unimportant for a single constituent perfect fluid or
superfluid such as that of ordinary Helium at zero temper-
ature, or even for a two contituent fluid in which entrain-
ment is absent [16], but it becomes important when there
are two or more independently moving fluids with entrain-
ment, which means that the momenta need no longer be
aligned with their conjugate velocities.
As well as simplifying the algebra in the work presented
below, the introduction of the canonically covariant for-
mulation also has the advantage of providing a helpful
step towards the development of a fully General relativis-
tic treatment, such as will ultimately be necessary for ac-
curacy. Relativistic effects will be particularly important
for the core, in which however, compared with the crust,
the effect of entrainment is expected to be much more
moderate [44, 19] at least in the outer part for which the
basic physics is reasonably well understood, unlike the in-
ner core for which many exotic possibilities have been en-
visages, such that of hyperon crystallisation [36], or of a
LOFF phase in a color superconducting quark condensate
[1].
2
would appear that corrections from general relativity will
be much less important (at most a few tens of per cent)
than those due to the entrainment. A recent program of
work [13, 14, 15] (using a microphysical analysis combin-
ing methods from nuclear and solid state physics) on the
relative motion of unbound neutrons in the inner crust lay-
ers (between the neutron drip density about 1011 g/cm3
and nuclear saturation density about 1014 g/cm3) has pro-
vided results [17] indicating that the effect of entrainment
is likely to be very much stronger than had previously been
supposed.
As in the preceding work [16], we shall therefore pro-
ceed here within a non relativistic Newtonian treatment,
but instead of using a decoupled perfect fluid description
we shall now include allowance for the effect of entrain-
ment, using a non-dissipative two constituent description
of the generic kind already developed for use in the liquid
core [34, 18, 39] where the entrainment corrections are rel-
atively moderate, though still potentially important as a
cause for two-stream instability [6] if the relative velocity
becomes too large.
For the reasons outlined in the introduction, it is both
instructive and convenient (even though our treatment is
non-relativistic) to use a canonical formalism of the 4-
dimensionally covariant kind recently developed [11, 12]
for the purpose of facilitating the exploitation of the varia-
tional formulation that is applicable to the non-dissipative
limit. In this limit there is no resistance to relative mo-
tion, so that the only direct coupling between the two
constituents is via the entrainment effect [7], whose micro-
scopic origin is the Bragg scattering of dripped neutrons by
crustal nuclei [13] which is the analog in the nuclear con-
text of conduction electron scattering in ordinary solids.
It is also convenient to use a chemical constituent label X
that runs over two values, namely X = f for the superfluid
constituent and X = c for the crust constituent. Each
constituent will have a baryon current density 4-vector
having the form
n ν
X = nX u ν
X
(1)
in which the scalars nX are the respective number densities
of free baryons (only neutrons) and of baryons that are
effectively confined within the atomic nuclei (namely all
the protons, together with a roughly equal but somewhat
larger number of confined neutrons, whose precise specifi-
cation needs further clarification as discussed below) while
the vectors u ν
X are the corresponding 4-velocities, whose
components are labelled by a Greek index ν running over
the values 0, 1, 2, 3. The conservation of the total baryon
number current
n ν
B = n ν
f + n ν
c ,
(2)
is concisely expressible in this 4-dimensional notation as
∇νn ν
B = 0 .
(3)
Figure 1: Intersection of rotating neutron star model with
a Taylor cylinder, over which the superfluid angular veloc-
ity must be uniform when the conditions for the Proudman
theorem are applicable.
2 Two fluid model for stratified
neutron star crust
2.1 The Lagrangian master function
f and n ν
The previous treatment referred to above [16] used a non
relativistic Newtonian description in terms of free neutron
and confined baryon 4-currents n ν
c respectively
representing a neutron superfluid, and a normal crust com-
ponent consisting of ionic nuclei characterised by a con-
fined baryon number Ac and a positive charge number Z
(in a degenerate electron background) that were treated
as decoupled but interpenetrating barotropic perfect fluids
interacting only via vortex pinning and long range gravita-
tional forces, with the solid rigidity of the crust component
taken into account by the inclusion of an extra stress force
density.
One of the improvements introduced here is to drop the
barotropy restriction for the ionic constituent by allowing
its behavior to depend on the nuclear mass number Ac
(which will tend to be larger in the deeper layers) thus
allowing for the possibility of a stratification effect that
may be important for stabilisation.
Another improvement that would be needed for a more
accurate analysis is of course the use of a general rela-
tivistic treatment, of the kind that has long been com-
monly used with a simple perfect fluid description, and
that has recently been developed for use with a two con-
stituent fluid description of the kind needed fore treating
the stellar core [30, 5]. However for the semilocal modeli-
sation needed for the treatment of differential rotation in
the crust layers with which we shall be concerned here, it
3
X = v i
X = 1, u i
In Aristotelian coordinates (representing the usual kind
of 3+1 space time decomposition with respect to the rest
frame of the star) the 4-velocity components will have the
form u 0
X are ordinary 3-velocity
components, using a Latin index i = 1, 2, 3. This means
that time component of the current density is simply equal
X = nX ,
to the corresponding particle number density n0
while the space components are the those of the current
density 3-vector ni
X where the v i
X .
c and n i
In addition to the six independent vectorial components
provided by the space vectors n i
f and the pair of
scalars provided by the "confined" and "free" baryon num-
ber densities nc and nf , our model will contain a nineth
independent variable, namely the scalar provided by the
nuclear mass number Ac, or equivalently by the number
density nI of nuclei, whose number current will be given
by
I = nIu ν
n ν
c ,
nI = nc/Ac .
(4)
We shall take the mass per baryon to be the same (con-
sidering the electron mass and the proton neutron mass
difference to be negligible compared with the ordinary
proton mass) with fixed value mc = mf = m, so that
the corresponding mass density contributions will simply
be given by ρX = m nX . The total mass density, as given
explicitly by
ρ = m nB = ρf + ρc ,
(5)
will be important as the Poissonian source of the Newto-
nian gravitational potential scalar, φ. Within this New-
tonian background field, the total force balance equation
will take the form
∇µT µ
ν = f ν − ρ∇νφ ,
(6)
in which f ν is the non gravitational external 4-force den-
sity -- if any -- that may be acting on the system, and T µ
ν is
the stress momentum energy density tensor as constructed
in terms of the 4-dimensional formalism recapitulated be-
low.
The dynamics of system will be governed -- in the man-
ner described in our preceding work [11, 12] -- by a La-
grangian master function
Λ = Λmat − φ ρ ,
Λmat = Λkin + Λint
(7)
in which Λkin is the ordinary Galilean frame dependent
kinetic energy density, namely
Λkin = 1
2 (cid:0)ρf v 2
f + ρcv 2
c(cid:1) ,
(8)
and Λint is some appropriately specified internal action
density contribution that must be Galilean frame indepen-
dent, which means that it can depend only on the scalar
4
number densities nI, nf , nc, and on the velocity difference
[vi] = v i
f − v i
c
(9)
so that in terms of an "entrainment density" function ¯ρfc
and a set of chemical potentials χf , χc, χI its generic vari-
ation will take the form
δ Λint = ¯ρfc[vi] δ[vi] − χf δnf − χcδnc − χIδnI ,
(10)
which gives the corresponding formula
δΛmat = nf µf
iδv i
f +ncµc
iδv i
c − µf δnf − µcδnc − µIδnI , (11)
in which the (Galilean frame dependent) material energy
coefficients are given in terms of the corresponding (frame
independent) chemical potentials by
µf = χf − 1
2 m v 2
f ,
µc = χc − 1
2 m v 2
c ,
µI = χI , (12)
and the associated space momenta are given by
µf
i = m vf i +
¯ρfc
nf
[vi] ,
µc
i = m vc i −
¯ρfc
nc
[vi] .
(13)
In the low relative velocity regimes that are relevant it
will always be possible to take the internal energy contri-
bution to have the quadratic form
Λint = 1
2 ¯ρfc[v]2 − U ins ,
(14)
with ¯ρfc and the static contribution U ins specified by ap-
propriate equations of state as functions only of the scalar
densities nI, nc, nf . It is to be remarked that to translate
our notation to that used by Prix et al.
[39] we would
need to make the conversions χf
7→ µf , χc 7→ µc and
Λint 7→ −E where E is what these authors have referred
to rather loosely as "internal energy" density, although it
is something that should not be confused with the true
internal energy density U int, which will actually be given
by
U int = 1
2 ¯ρfc[v]2 + U ins = ¯ρfc[v]2 − Λint .
(15)
2.2 Currents and their conjugate mo-
menta in 4 dimensions
Instead of treating quantities such as energy and momen-
tum separately, as has traditionally been done in a New-
tonian framework,
it has been found to be technically
advantageous, as remarked above, to unify them in a 4-
dimensional treatment [11, 12] (which was originally in-
spired by the corresponding relativistic theory [30]). The
first step in this 4 dimensional treatment is to rewrite the
generic variation (11) in tems of 4-current variations in
the form
dΛmat = µf
ν dn ν
f + µc
ν dn ν
c − µI dnI ,
(16)
which provides a direct specification of the material 4-
momentum covectors µf
ν that play a crucial role in
the concise canonical formalism to be described below. In
terms of the quantities introduced above their time com-
ponents will be given by
ν and µc
µf
0 = −(µf + µf
iv i
f ) ,
µc
0 = −(µc + µc
iv i
c ) ,
(17)
These material 4-momenta, µf
while their space components will simply be given by (13).
ν , give rise to cor-
responding complete "free" and "confined" baryon mo-
menta, πf
ν, whose time components include al-
lowance for gravitational energy according to the specifi-
cations
ν and πc
ν and µc
πf
0 = µf
0 − mφ ,
πc
0 = µc
0 − mφ ,
while their space components are given simply by
πf
i = µf
i ,
πc
i = µc
i .
(18)
(19)
It is also useful to introduce the total ionic momentum
ν , which is defined so as to include allowance
covector πI
for nuclear energy by
πI
0 = Acπc
0 − µI ,
πI
i = Acπc
i .
(20)
This enables us to express the complete stress energy ten-
sor of the system in the very concise form
T µ
ν = n µ
f πf
ν + n µ
I πI
ν + Ψ δµ
ν ,
in which the material pressure function is given by
Ψ = Λmat − n ν
f µf
ν − n ν
c µc
ν + nI µI .
(21)
(22)
It follows that the force balance equation (6) can be rewrit-
ten in the form
f f
ν + f I
ν = f ν ,
(23)
2.3 Equations of state and effective mass
To complete the specification of the variables introduced
in the previous section it is evidently necessary to pre-
scribe the particular form of the material action density
Λmat, which is -- for this purpose -- most conveniently de-
composible in the form
Λmat = U dyn − U ins ,
(28)
wherein U ins is the static internal energy contribution in-
troduced in (14), which is specified by an appropriate "pri-
mary" equation of state as a function of the three relevant
number densities nf , nc nI, while the remaining dynamical
energy contribution is given [15] in terms of the "normal"
(crust) velocity 3 vector vi
c and the relative current 3 vec-
tor
ni = nf [vi] ,
by the formula
U dyn = ρ vc iv i
c /2 + m niv i
c + nini/2K ,
(29)
(30)
in which the K is the "mobility coefficient". This quantity
K is given by a "secondary" equation of state as a function
of the relevant number densities nI, nc, and nf .
In the analysis that follows a particularly important role
will be played by the "free" neutron 3-momentum covector
µf
i for which, on a local "mesoscopic" scale (small com-
pared with the intervortex separation) the superfluidity
property entails the irrotationality condition ∇[iµf
j] = 0.
It follows from (30) that the contravariant version (as ob-
tained by contracting with the ordinary Euclidean space
metric γij ) of this (superfluid) momentum will be given
by an expression of the form
in which the 4-force density f f
trons is specified in terms of their vorticity tensor f
ν acing on the"free" neu-
µν by
µf i = m⋆v i
f + (m − m⋆)v i
c
f f
ν = nµ
f f
µν + πf
ν∇µn µ
f
,
f
µν = 2∇[µπf
ν] ,
in terms of an effective mass variable,
(24)
m⋆ = nf /K ,
(31)
(32)
while the combined 4-force density acting on the ions and
their "confined" baryons will be specified by the formula
f I
I πc
This can be decomposed in the form
ν = 2nµ
I ∇[µ πI
ν] + nµ
µ∇νAc .
f I
ν = f c
ν + nI∇ν µI − δ 0
ν ∇µ(µIn µ
I ) ,
whose difference from the ordinary baryon mass m is pro-
portional to the "entrainment density"
(25)
¯ρfc = ρf (m⋆ − m)/m ,
(33)
(26)
which -- in much of the inner crust -- now seems likely [17]
to be much larger than had previously been supposed.
in which the last term contributes only to the time com-
ponent, while the only part that remains in the absence
of stratification is the contribution of first term, which is
given by an expression of the standard form
f c
ν = 2nµ
c ∇[µπc
ν] + πc
ν∇µn µ
c .
(27)
5
The reason why it is convenient for the formulation of
the equations of state to start with the specification of
K rather than the effective mass m⋆ or the corresponding
"entrainment density" ¯ρfc in the decomposition (14) is that
-- unlike m⋆ and ¯ρfc -- the "mobility coefficient" K has the
advantage of being physically well defined in a manner
that does not depend on the choice of the chemical basis
that will be discussed in Section 2.6.
Another kind of decomposition that is also independent
of the choice of chemical basis, and that is instructive for
the purpose of comparison with the notation used in re-
lated work, including the seminal article of [7], is to intro-
duce the concept of the so called "superfluid 3-velocity"
i , which in stricter terminology should be referered to
V S
as "superfluid momentum per unit mass", as defined by
setting
µf
i = m V S
i
V Si = v i
c +
m⋆
m
[vi] .
(34)
This enables the dynamical energy density (30) to be
rewritten (without a cross term) in the seductively sim-
ple form
magnetic braking of pulsar rotation. However the main
reason for introducing the external force contribution f ν
in the present analysis is to take account of the presence,
due to the solidity of the crust, of additional stresses that
we wish to estimate but for which a complete treatment
would be beyond the scope of the purely fluid model used
here.
I , n ν
f , n ν
In conjunction with (3), strict application of the varia-
tion principle would entail as consequence that each of the
three currents n ν
c should be separately conserved.
This would no doubt be a very good approximation for
the purpose of treating high frequency oscillation modes.
However, in the medium to long timescale processes we
wish to consider here, whereas it will still be reasonable
to postulate conservation of the number of ionic nuclei,
meaning that we we shall have
(35)
∇νn ν
I = 0 ,
(37)
U dyn =
m
2 (cid:0)nS V S
i V Si + nN vc iv i
c(cid:1) ,
in which the so called "superfluid particle number den-
sity" nS and the corresponding"normal particle number
density" nN are defined by
nS = mK = ρf /m⋆
nN = nB − nS .
(36)
2.4 Dynamical Equations
Even after the primary (3 variable) equation of state func-
tion U ins{nI, nc, nf } and the secondary (2 variable) equa-
tion of state function K{nI, nc} have been specified, the
formulae given so far will merely provide a coherent set
of definitions, but -- except for the total baryon conser-
vation law (3) -- they contain no dynamical information.
To govern the evolution of the nine independent variables
(namely nI and the components of the 4-vectors n ν
f and
n ν
c ) of the system we still need eight more conditions,
which can be provided by specification of the values of
the 4-forces f f
ν and f c
ν .
ν = 0.
ν and f c
In the absence of an external force f ν in (23) the sum
of the contributions f f
ν would have to vanish, a
condition that will automatically be satisfied if these con-
tributions are specified just by the variational principle,
according to which they should each vanish separately,
f f
ν = f c
In a dissipative model o the kind recently developed by
[12] (such as might be needed to allow for the mutual re-
sistivity that would be present if the temperature were too
high for superconductivity) the contributions f f
ν and f c
ν
could still add up to zero even though they would no longer
vanish separately. However we wish to consider more gen-
eral situations in which a non-vanishing total force density
f ν may be present for two reasons. One reason is to al-
low for the "secular" (very long timescale) effect of weak
on the other hand it may be realistic to allow for the
possibility that -- due to beta processes whereby neutrons
are transformed into neutrons or vice versa -- the "free"
and "confined" baryon currents may not be separately
conserved, but will evolve in such a way as to diminish
the magnitude of the relevant chemical affinity[12], A say,
meaning the chemical potential difference between the two
constituents, as measured in the relevant "normal" (non
superfluid) rest frame, namely that of the ionic lattice with
unit velocity 4-vector u ν
c , so that it will be given by
A = u ν
c [µν] ,
[µν] = µf
ν − µc
ν .
(38)
As discussed in the treatment of the analogous relativis-
tic model [30] (with nI and µI respectively replaced by
entropy density and temperature) a non-dissipative model
that is self contained -- so that total force f ν vanishes -- will
be obtainable in a manner that is compatible either with
the short term conservation conditions ∇νn ν
c = 0,
or alternatively with the long term equilibrium condition
A = 0 that is more relevant here, provided the three force
acting on the superfluid neutron current is specified in
such a way that
f = ∇ν n ν
n µ
f f
µν n ν
c = 0 .
(39)
2.5 Superfluidity condition
On a mesoscopic scale (large compared with the ionic spac-
ing but small compared with the distance between quan-
tised vortices) the superfluidity property of the "free" neu-
trons entails that their momentum covector πf
ν must be
locally proportional to the gradient of a quantum phase
scalar, and hence that their vorticity 2-form must vanish,
f
µν = 0 , which automatically ensures that the condition
(39) will be satisfied.
6
The supposition that the vortices will be "pinned" in
the sense of being transported with the ionic lattice is
evidently expressible by adopting a dynamic equation of
the form (42) with
u µ
w = u µ
c
(43)
which still automatically ensures that the condition (39)
will be satisfied, but which will generically entail the in-
volvement of a non-vanishing force density that will be
attributable to the Magnus effect as discussed in the ap-
pendix. This condition (39) particularly plausible as a
description of evolution on very long timescales, for which
the beta equilibrium condition,
A = 0 ,
(44)
will also be appropriate.
For evolution on the more moderate timescales that will
be relevant for many astrophysical processes the situation
is not so clear. An obvious -- though not necessarily re-
alistic -- alternative way of satisfying (39) is to apply the
strict variation principle to the effect that f f
ν should van-
ish, which instead of (43) as well as the separate "free"
neutron conservation condition ∇ν n ν
f = 0 also provides a
dynamical equation of the form (42) but with
w = u µ
u µ
f
,
(45)
and which instead of (44) provides a separate conservation
law
∇νn ν
f = 0 .
(46)
However the realism of such an alternative is question-
able on the basis of microphysical considerations which
suggest that both the vortex slipping implied by (45) and
the beta disequilibrium entailed by (46) would in prac-
tise give rise to dissipative processes that would require
a more elaborate treatment. This issue is hinted at, on
a purely macroscopic level, by the consideration that the
actual physical meaning of the simple set of non dissipa-
tive evolution equations provided by (45) and (46) is open
to question, due to its gauge dependence in the sense dis-
cussed in the next section.
2.6 Chemical basis dependence
A problem with the force free postulate, namely the use
of (45) in conjunction with (46) is that (unlike the use of
(43) in conjunction with (44) which will be appropriate for
longer timescale processes) its physical meaning depends
on how many of the neutrons are considered to be "free".
To be more explicit, it depends on the choice of the dimen-
sionless parameter ac in the chemical base transformation
n ν
c = ac np
ν
n ν
f = n ν
n + (1 − ac)np
ν ,
(47)
Figure 2: Sketch of the 2-surface swept out by a quantised
vortex line.
What we are concerned with here however is the macro-
scopic level -- meaning lengthscales large compared with
the intervortex separation -- at which there will be a non-
vanishing vorticity 2-form, and a corresponding spacelike
vorticity vector
wλ = 1
2 ελµν f
µν ,
(40)
whose components in Aristotelian coordinates are simply
w0 = 0 and wi = εijk∇jvf k, representing the mean density
of circulation around the quantised vortices. The superflu-
idity property does however entail an algebraic restriction
to the effect that we must have
wµf
µν = 0 ,
(41)
a condition need not be satisfied for a more general fluid
motion (such as would be possible for the free neutrons in
a very young neutron star that has not yet dropped below
the temperature of the BCS pairing transition). This re-
striction expresses the requirement that, instead of having
matrix rank 4 as in the normal case, the antisymmetric (so
necessarily even ranked) vorticity tensor f
µν should have
its rank reduced to 2 in the superfluid case, a condition
that is mathematically necessary for it to be tangential
to a set of 2-surfaces which in this instance are swept out
by the quantised vortex lines as illustrated on figure 2.
This implies the existence of vorticity transport 4-vector
field u ν
w subject to the usual time normalisation condition
u 0
w = 1 characterised by the defining property
w f
u µ
µν = 0
(42)
which does not fix it completely but evidently allows a
freedom of adjustment by addition of a spacelike vector
field aligned with the direction of the vortex lines as given
by wν .
7
whereby the "confined" and "free" baryon currents are
specified in terms of the more obviously well defined chem-
ν and the
ical basis constituted by the proton current np
total ("confined" plus "free") neutron current n ν
n .
Obvious simple possibilities for the choice of such a
"chemical gauge" include the "comprehensive" gauge, ac
in which all the neutrons are counted as "free", the "pair-
ing gauge" ac = 2 in which the most strongly bound neu-
tron states, namely those paired with proton states, are
counted as "confined", but all the others are considered to
be free. A more intuitively "natural" -- but more fuzzily
defined -- possibility would be to reserve the qualification
"free" for neutrons that are actually located outside the --
somewhat blurred -- boundaries of the nuclei that contain
the protons. However what really matters is not location
in ordinary space but in phase space: the "operational"
criterion for a neutron state to be effectively "free" is that
it should have sufficient energy to overcome the barriers
separating the ionic potential wells either classically or by
quantum tunnelling within the relevant timescale.
On this "operational" basis it is clear that all the neu-
trons will be effectively "free" in the fluid core and that
none of them will be effectively "free" in the outer crust
below the "drip" density threshold, while at densities just
above this threshold there will be a clear cut critical energy
above which the neutrons will be able to travel over ionic
separation distances on a microscopically short timescale
and below which their wave functions will be exponentially
suppressed outside the ionic wells so that they will be able
to tunnell only on cosmologically long timescales. How-
ever in the deeper and denser layers of the crust (which
are likely to be particularly important for glitch processes)
this "operational" distinction will no longer be so clear cut,
because the ionic wells will get too close for the exponential
suppression outside to be fully effective, so that there will
be marginally bound states with intermediate penetration
timescales that are macroscopically long but cosmologi-
caly short. This means that the most appropriate way of
precisely defining an "operational" basis will depend on
the timescales involved in the astrophysical context under
consideration.
In view of the debatability of this question about which
basis may be most appropriate, it is important to observe
that the counting convention used to define the chemical
gauge parameter ac in (47) makes no difference at all to
the specification of the "normal" velocity v i
c and the rel-
ative current ni defined by (29) and hence that it has no
effect on any of the terms in the original specification (30)
for the dynamical energy density. It is no less important
to observe that uncertainties about the appropriate choice
for ac make no difference to the specification of the "free"
momentum covector µf
ν, nor in consequence, to the vortic-
ity form f
i ,
µν and the so called "superfluid 3-velocity" V S
which means that the quantities appearing in the rewrit-
ten formula (35) will also be unaffected.
The rule chosen for the specification of ac and hence of
nf will evidently affect the individual terms in the formula
(21) for the stress energy tensor, but it can be seen that
the total, T µ
ν , will be unaffected by the value of ac so long
as it is held fixed, and even (though this is less obvious) if
it is allowed to vary, so long as this ratio,
ac = nc/np = AcnI/np ,
(48)
is postulated to depend only on the nuclear charge number
Z, which is itself definable as the ratio
Z = np/nI .
(49)
It thus follows from (6) that provided ac (or equivalently
Ac) is chosen as some function just of the single variable Z,
although the choice of this function will indeed affect the
specification of the separate force density contributions f f
ν
and f c
ν , nevertheless it will not have any effect on their to-
tal (23). This means that it will not have any effect on the
complete set of evolution equations given by specifying the
total external force f ν (e.g. by postulating that it should
vanish) in conjunction with the ionic number conserva-
tion law (37) together with the (long timescale) pinning
and beta equilibrium conditions (43) and (44). However if
(44) is replaced by (46), then the physical specification of
the system would depend on the ansatz for the function
ac{Z}, which for very short timescales could realistically
be taken to be simply the "comprehensive" value ac = 1,
corresponding just to separate conservation of protons and
neutrons. Similarly if (43) is replaced by (45) the result
would again depend on the ansatz for ac{Z}, but in this
case the appropriate choice is a question needing further
investigation at a microscopic level.
The strategy of the following work is not to adopt any
particular choice of gauge but to see how far it is possible
to draw general conclusions that will be valid whatever the
choice of the function ac{Z} and whatever the postulate
adopted for the specification of the vortex drift velocity
u µ
w in (42).
3 Axisymmetric configurations
3.1 Angular momentum convection and
the lag formula
As in the preceding work [16] on this problem, we now
restrict our attention to configurations that are axisym-
metric in the sense of being invariant with respect to the
action of a rotation symmetry generator ν of the usual
kind, meaning one that is spacelike, 0 = 0, with space
8
We are concerned here with configurations that differ
only very slightly from a state of circularity, meaning a
state in which the 3-velocities are all aligned with the ax-
isymmetry generator i, so that we can write
vi
X = ΩX i + v i
X⊥ ,
i v i
X⊥ = 0 ,
(54)
where ΩX is the relevant angular velocity, and the residual
non circular velocity contribution v i
X⊥ is supposed to be
very small except perhaps in very brief intervals during a
glitch. The non circular part, if any, will evidently make no
contribution to the superfluid angular momentum scalar,
which, according to (64) will be given simply by
ℓ = 2(cid:16)m⋆Ωf + (m − m⋆)Ωc(cid:17) .
(55)
Since the axisymmetry evidently implies i∇iℓ = 0, the
conservation law (53) can be rewritten in terms of the vor-
tex drift 3-velocity v i
w as a slow variation rule of the form
ℓ = −v i
w⊥∇iℓ ,
(56)
with the usual convention that a dot denotes partial dif-
ferentiation with respect to time at a fixed space position.
In the rotating neutron star configurations under con-
sideration it will be justifiable to use a small perturbation
approximation, not just for the non-circular velocity con-
tributions, but also for deviations of the circular part from
rigid rotation with a uniform fixed angular velocity value,
¯Ω say. This means that for each constituent we can write
ΩX = ¯Ω + ∆ΩX
(57)
where, like v i
w⊥ the deviation ∆ΩX is to be considered as
relatively small. It follows that to first perturbative order
we can rewrite the slow variation law (56) as
Figure 3: Axisymmetry generator i, whose magnitude is
equal to the cylindrical radius and the unit vector νi
directed along the rotation axis.
components i given in terms of the unit vector νi along
the relevant symetry axis, with respect to Cartesian co-
ordinates ri centered on the axis, by an expression of the
form i = εijkνjrk as shown on figure 3. This means that
this symmetry generator will have a scalar magnitude
that can be interpreted as a cylindrical radial coordinate
(such as was denoted by in the preceding work by Carter
et al. [16]) so that it will be given in terms of the relevant
angle of latitude θ by = r cos θ.
Invariance of a field with respect to such an action is
expressible in any (Cartesian or other) coordinate sys-
tem as the vanishing of its Lie derivative with respect to
the generator. In the particular case of the superfluid 4-
momentum covector πf
ν the axisymmetry condition will
therefore be expressible as
ν∇νπf
µ + πf
ν ∇µν = 0 .
(50)
ℓ = −m ¯Ω v i
w⊥∇i2 .
(58)
In terms of the angular momentum per free (superfluid)
particle, as defined (independently of any choice of the
chemical gauge parameter ac) by
ℓ = νπf
ν ,
(51)
(so that on a microscopic scale ℓ will be quantised as a
half integer multiple of the Dirac-Planck constant ) the
axisymmetry condition (50) can evidently be rewritten as
∇µℓ = f
µν ν .
(52)
We can use this in conjunction with (42) to obtain a gen-
eralised Bernoulli type [12] conservation law to the effect
that this superfluid angular momentum scalar ℓ will be
convected by (in the sense of remaining constant along)
the vortex flux trajectories:
Using square brackets for differences between the con-
stituents according to the convention
[Ω] = Ωf − Ωc ,
[ Ω] = Ωf − Ωc ,
(59)
we can write (58) more explicitly as
2m¯Ω
m⋆[ Ω] + m Ωc = −
v i
w⊥∇i .
(60)
It follows that, after a finite time interval during which the
vortices have undergone a small cylindrical radial displace-
ment, ∆ say, the ensuing (local) change in the angular
frequency lag will be given in terms of the correspond-
ing (uniform) change ∆Ω in the observable rotation fre-
quency, namely that of the solid constituent Ω = Ωc by
the remarkably simple formula
u ν
w∇νℓ = 0 .
∆[Ω]
Ω
= −
(53)
9
m
m⋆ (cid:18) ∆Ω
Ω
+ 2
∆
(cid:19) .
(61)
In the idealised case of pinning to an absolutely rigid
solid the displacement ∆ would of course vanish, so that
∆[Ω] would be approximately determined as a function
just of the spherical radial coordinate r by a proportion-
ality relation of the form ∆[Ω] ∝ m/m⋆, but in practice,
even for perfect pinning, there will be deviations from this
as the crustal rigidity modulus is expected [42] to be rather
low (the solid structure will be effectively "squashy"). On
the other hand if it is supposed that pinning is entirely in-
effective (since the vortices may drift by either thermal [3]
or quantum fluctuations [32]) then the generalised Proud-
man theorem derived below in Subsection 4.2 tels us that
the angular velocity difference [Ω] -- and hence also its
variation ∆[Ω] -- will be a function not of r but of the
cylindrical coordinate = r cos θ, so in that case (to al-
low for non-uniformity of m⋆) the contribution from the
displacement term in (61) would have to be relatively sig-
nificant.
3.2 Simplified global model
For the purpose of drawing conclusions from available em-
pirical data such as that of Lyne et al.
[33], rather than
with the locally well defined but observationally inacces-
sible quantities involved in a formula such as (61) it can
be more instructive in practice to work with corresponding
crudely defined averages, using a total angular momentum
decomposition of the form
J = J f + J c
(62)
in terms of "free" and "confined" contributions of the form
J X = Z nX µX
i i d3r ,
(63)
with the "free" bayon momentum µf
i given by (31) and
with the "confined" baryon momentum given by tha anal-
ogous formula
µc i = mv i
c − mc
⋆ [vi] ,
,
(64)
in which the effective mass function mc
⋆ for the "con-
fined" baryons is determined by its "free" baryon ana-
logue,analogue mf
⋆ = m⋆, via the symmetric relation
nc(mc
⋆ − m) = nf (m⋆ − m) .
(65)
Using an approximation in which Ωf is taken to be roughly
uniform, as Ωc(= Ω) must be in any case, these contribu-
tions will be given roughly by
J f ≃ I ff Ωf + I cf Ωc ,
J c ≃ I ccΩc + I cf Ωf ,
(66)
in terms of coefficients that combine to give the respective
moments of inertia of the confined and free parts in the
form
I f = I ff + I cf ,
I c = I cc + I cf .
(67)
In accordance with (64) the separate coefficients will be
given, in terms of the cylindrical radius h, as the volume
integrals
I cc = Z mc
⋆ nc 2 d3r ,
I ff = Z m⋆ nf 2 d3r , (68)
while, in view of the equivalence (65) , the entrainment
coefficient will be given by
I cf = Z (m − mc
⋆) nc 2 d3r = Z (m − m⋆) nf 2 d3r , (69)
so the subtotals will be given by expressions of the familiar
form
I c = mZ nc 2 d3r ,
I f = mZ nf 2 d3r ,
(70)
which combine to give the complete stellar moment of in-
ertia as
I = I c + I f = Z ρ 2 d3r .
(71)
In a simplified treatment it may be supposed that these
moment of inertia coefficients remain constant (i.e. that
the effects of a conceivable radial displacement ∆ in (61)
can be ignored) and that the superfluid contribution to
the angular momentum is conserved during the interglitch
period, ∆J f ≃ 0, which by (66) evidently implies
∆Ωf ≃ −
Icf
I ff ∆Ω .
(72)
It may also be supposed that the total angular momentum
variation is negligible, δJ = 0 during the very short time
interval in which the star undergoes a discontinuous glitch
transformation involving an angular momentum transfer
given by δJ f ≃ −δJ c so that the corresponding angular
velocity discontinuities will be related by
δΩf ≃ −
I c
I f δΩ .
(73)
To avoid a long term build up of too large a deviation
of the superfluid angular velocity Ωf from the externally
observable value, Ωc = Ω, the averages over many glitches
of their total (continuous plus discontinuous) change per
glitch should be the same,
h∆Ωf + δΩf i ≃ h∆Ω + δΩi ,
(74)
a condition that is equivalently expessible using the nota-
tion of (59) as
hδ[Ω]i ≃ −h∆[Ω]i .
(75)
The immediately preceding relations can be used to
rewrite this condition in the form
hδΩi
h∆Ωi
≃ −
(I f )2
I ff I
,
(76)
10
in which the left hand side contains only quantities that
are directly observable, with values that have been typ-
ically found [33] to be given in order of magnitude by
hδΩi/h∆Ωi ≈ −10−2 in the case of Vela type pulsars.
This magnitude has commonly been used as a basis for
estimating the ratio I f /I of the moment of inertia of the
superfluid component involved to that of the whole star,
on the basis of the usual supposition that there is no need
to distinguish between the coefficients I f and I ff . However
it can be seen from (68) that the relation between these co-
efficients will actually be expressible in terms of a suitably
weighted mean value ¯m⋆ of m⋆ by the formula
I ff ≃
¯m⋆
m
I f ,
(77)
in which, according to the recent work [17] referred to
above, the ratio ¯m⋆/m is likely to be substantially larger
than unity, which leads to a correspondingly augmented
estimate,
in such a stationary configuration will satisfy the rigidity
condition, meaning that Ωc is uniform with the externally
observed angular velocity Ω,
∇i Ωc = 0 ,
Ωc = Ω ,
(80)
it can be seen that the space parts of the force density
formulae (24) and (26) will be expressible simply as
f f
i = nf (∇i Cf + ℓ ∇i Ωf ) ,
f I
i = nc∇i Cc + nI∇i µI ,
(81)
(82)
using the notation of Prix et al.
[39] for the comoving
particle energies, which are concisely specifiable for the
respective "free" and "confined" constituents as the cor-
responding diagonal components
C f = E f
f ,
Cc = E c
c ,
(83)
I f
I
≃ −
¯m⋆
m
hδΩi
h∆Ωi
,
(78)
of the (non-symmetric) energy matrix defined by the for-
mula
for the relative value of the moment of inertia I f of the
relevant superfluid component as compared with the total
moment of inertia I of the neutron star.
4 Stationary circularly symmetric
configurations.
4.1 Total stress force in the general case
We now investigate the equilibrium conditions that need to
be satisfied in the short and medium term when we neglect
the slow secular evolution effects considered in the preced-
ing section and consider the system to to be in a state that
is exactly stationary, and with flow that is strictly circular
in the sense that convective velocity contributions v i
X⊥ in
(54) are absent, so that we simply have
v i
f = Ωf i ,
v i
c = Ωf i .
(79)
For a single-fluid model in such a non convective state the
well known Proudman theorem tells us that the angular
velocity must be uniform over each "Taylor cylinder" (as
characterised by a fixed value of ) for the case of a perfect
fluid that is barotropic, meaning that there is no stratifi-
cation. It will be shown in the present section how this
result can be generalised to the two-fluid context under
consideration here.
Using the circularity conditions (79) in conjunction with
the axisymmetry conditions exemplified by (50), and as-
suming that the solidity property of the crust will ensure
that the "normal" flow velocity of the "confined" current
E X
Y = −πX
νu ν
Y .
(84)
This is another example of a formula that becomes more
complicated and less heuristically meaningful when in-
stead of using 4 dimensional notation it is written out
using the traditional 3 dimensional notation, in which for
example the comoving particle energy for the "free" con-
stituent will be given by the formula
Cf = mφ + χf − 1
2 m v 2
f ,
(85)
in which, by (10) and (14), the relevant chemical potential
will be given by
χf = ∂ U ins/∂nf − 1
2 [v]2∂¯ρfc/∂nf ,
(86)
with ∂¯ρfc/∂nf = nf ∂m⋆/∂nf + m⋆ − m.
Without going into such details, it can be seen that
the gravitational contributions to these comoving particle
energies will cancel out in their difference, which will be
given in terms of the chemical affinity (38) and the angular
velocity difference [Ω] = Ωf − Ω by
Cc − Cf = A + ℓ [Ω] .
(87)
If the crust were purely fluid, the force density f c
i would
just have to be equal in magnitude and opposite in sign
to the force density acting on the superfluid, namely −f f
i.
Detailed evaluation of the effects of solidity would require
the use of a more elaborate model incorporating elastic
rigidity, but as in the preceding work by Carter et al. [16]
we can allow for the effect of finite rigidity by introducing
a non vanishing stress force density f i representing the
11
discrepancy according to the definition (23), which can be
rewritten in the form
1
nc (cid:18)f i −
ρ
ρf
f f
i(cid:19) =
f I
i
nc
−
f f
i
nf
,
(88)
in order to obtain a difference on the right hand side that
is particularly amenable to simplification using (87).
In
terms of the chemical disequilibrium force density term
defined by
f χ
i = nc∇i A + nI∇i µI ,
(89)
it can be seen that the formulae (81) and (82) lead to an
expression of the remarkably simple form
f I
i
nc
−
f f
i
nf
=
f χ
i
nc
+ [Ω]∇iℓ .
(90)
in the direction of ∇iℓ which is approximately that of ∇i.
Consequently the condition (95) can be seen to provide us
with a Proudman type theorem telling us that the energy
parameter C f and the angular velocity difference [Ω] must
both be uniform over each of the deformed Tayor cylinders
characterised by a fixed value of the angular momentum
per "free" particle, ℓ. Provided the difference [Ω] is small
compared with the uniform crust angular velocity Ω it
can be seen from (96) that these modified Taylor cylinders
will differ only by a small deformation from the ordinary
Taylor cylinders that are characterised by fixed values of
the cylindrical radial coordinate .
It is interesting to consider what would happen if the
force given by (82) were also supposed to vanish, so that
there would be no net force at all:
We thus obtain an expression of the same form
i = 0 ⇒ Ac∇i Cc + ∇i µI = 0 ,
f c
(97)
f i =
ρ
ρf
f f
i + f χ
i + f b
i ,
(91)
as that previously derived by Carter et al. [16] in a sim-
plified treatment in which the effects of entrainment and
stratification were not included, with the force density
attributable to centrifugal buoyancy deficit given by the
same formula as previously, namely
f b
i = nc[Ω]∇iℓ .
(92)
4.2 Generalised Proudman theorem for
force-free superfluid case
Leaving aside the pinned case for treatment in the next
subsection, let us restrict our attention in the remainder
of the present subsection to the case in which the neutron
superfluid flow is postulated to be force-free, which means
that we have
f f
i = 0 .
(93)
In this case the chemical and buoyancy contributions on
the right of (91) will be the only sources for the stress force,
which in this case will be given simply by
f i = f χ
i + f b
i .
Under these circumstances (81) reduces to the form
∇i Cf + ℓ ∇i [Ω] = 0 ,
in which by (55) we have
ℓ = 2(cid:16)m Ω + m⋆[Ω](cid:17) .
(94)
(95)
(96)
Taking the exterior derivative of equation (95) implies
that εijk(∇iℓ)∇j [Ω] must vanish so that ∇i [Ω] has to lie
where Ac is the nuclear mass number as introduced in (4).
This would provide an analogue of the Proudman theorem,
to the effect that the confined particle energy parameter
Cc and the nuclear potential function µI should both be
uniform over surfaces characterised by a fixed value of Ac.
A noteworthy special case of the application of the fore-
going theorems is to the scenario considered by Prix et
al [39] in which there is no stratification, meaning that
∇i µI = 0 and for which the differential rotation is also
postulated to be uniform so that one has ∇i [Ω] = 0, in
which case it follows that in the absence of any (pinning
or external stress) force both Cc and Cf would be uniform,
as first integral constants of the motion, in the sense that
their gradients too would vanish, ∇i C c = ∇i Cf = 0.
Assuming that (as well as the gravitational background
φ that may have been provided by a Cowling type ap-
proximation) the distributions of the angular velocities (or
the corresponding angular momenta) and in our case also
of the nuclear number density nI (or the corresponding
stratification potential µI) have been specified in advance
to have values resulting from the previous history of the
system, then the specification of two more independent
quantities such as Cc and Cf will suffice to determine the
system completely, as remarked by Prix et al.
[39], who
observed that their values as first integral constants could
be fixed by the specification of the globally integrated to-
tals of free and confined baryons.
A force free configuration with separate conservation of
the free and confined constituents is not however what is
most realistic in a system that is stationary over a secu-
lar timescale. The assumption of separate conservation of
neutrons and protons is appropriate in the context of high
frequency dynamical processes [18, 5] such as may give rise
to a two stream instability [6]. However in an effectively
stationary context it is to be expected that transfusion
12
(by beta processes) would be able to establish the chemi-
cal equilibrium condition (44) to the effect that the affinity
A should vanish, which by (87) means that one will have
Cc = Cf + ℓ [Ω] .
(98)
In the special case for which [Ω] and hence (by the gen-
eralised Proudman theorem) also Cf are uniform it fol-
lows, since the distribution of ℓ will be highly non-uniform
(roughly proportional to the squared cylindrical radius 2)
that Cc will also be highly non-uniform. We thus obtain a
scenario in which unlike that considered by Prix et al.[39]
requires only a single constant of integration. This can be
taken to be the globally integrated total baryon number,
which suffices to determine the uniform value of Cf , from
which Cc will be obtainable unambiguously (without any
need to specify any other arbitrary parameter) as the non-
uniform field provided by substituting the relevant fixed
values of [Ω] and Cf . A scenario of this mathematically
well defined type differs from the kind envisaged by Prix
et al. [39] in that, despite the fact that no vortex pinning
is involved, it requires that the solid structure of the crust
should provide a stress force density that according to (94)
will be given as a sum of stratification and buoyancy deficit
forces by
f i = nI∇iµI + nc[Ω]∇iℓ .
(99)
c ∇i µI were equal in magni-
This could only vanish if A−1
tude and opposite in sign to [Ω]∇iℓ which is mathemati-
cally conceivable but physically implausible (except near
the stellar equator) because ℓ will depend mainly on the
cylindrical coordinate , whereas one would expect that
the other quantities involved would depend mainly on the
spherical radial coordinate r.
4.3 Constants of integration for pinned
superfluid case
To deal with the case when the superfluid vortices are
pinned to the "normal" constituent it is convenient to fo-
cus attention not so much on the comoving diagonal ele-
ment Cf in the energy matrix (84) but on the cross term
C = E f
c = Cf + [vi] µf
i ,
(100)
which is interpretable as the energy per particle of the
"free" (superfluid) neutrons with respect to the"normal"
rest frame of the "confined" baryons. Unlike the diagonal
elements Cf = −πf
c (and the other
off-diagonal element) this particular off-diagonal element
C = −πf
c has the property of being invariant with re-
spect to the changes of chemical basis that were discussed
in Subsection 2.6.
f and Cc = −πc
νu ν
ν u ν
ν u ν
The usual supposition that, instead of moving freely, as
was supposed in the preceding subsection, the vortices will
satisfy the pinning condition expressed by (42) and (43)
can be seen to be equivalent to the requirement that the
"free" neutron current should be subject to a force density
of the form
f f
i = −f J
i
(101)
where f J
i is the Magnus force density reacting on the solid
structure of the confined constituent, as given in accor-
dance with the usual Joukowsky formula (see appendix)
by
f J
i = nf f
ij [vj] ,
(102)
which works out in this stationary circularly symmetric
case as
f J
i = nf [Ω]∇iℓ .
(103)
It is to be noticed that, unlike the buoyancy deficit force
density (92) to which it is proportional, this Magnus force
density is invariant with respect to changes of chemical
basis. When substituted in the general formula (91) for the
total force acting on the system it provides an expression
of the simple form
f i = f χ
i − f J
i .
(104)
By substituting the Joukowsky formula in (81) it can
be seen that in terms of the crossed particle energy (100)
the vortex pinning condition can be rewritten simply as
∇i C = 0 ,
(105)
which means that for any pinned configuration C will be a
uniform integral constant, whose value can be fixed by the
total globally integrated baryon number. In terms of this
constant C the comoving energy per particle of the "free"
constituent will be obtainable from (100) as the variable
function of position given by
C f = C − [Ω] ℓ .
(106)
It can be seen from (98) that the tranfusive equilibrium
condition (44) will be expressible simply as
Cc = C ,
(107)
which means that, when the specification of the system is
completed by the imposition of this chemical equilibrium
condition, then C c will also have a uniform constant value.
The constancy of these quantities is interpretable as a
modified Bernouilli theorem of a kind that is rather ro-
bust:
it is to be emphasised that whereas the constancy
deduced by Prix et al. [39] for Cc and Cc in the unpinned
case was dependent on very restrictive assumptions about
the uniformity of [Ω] and the negligibility of stratification,
no such restrictions are involved in the derivation of con-
stancy for Cf and Cc in the pinned case.
13
In this pinned equilibrium case, the analogue of the for-
mula (99) for the stress force density that needs to be
provided by the solidity of the crust will be given, as a
difference between stratification and Magnus-Joukowsky
contributions by the expression
f i = nI∇i µI − nf [Ω]∇iℓ ,
(108)
which, unlike (99), has the noteworthy property of being
chemically invariant.
The work in this section has used no approximations
apart from the postulates of exact stationarity and ax-
isymmetry, but if we make the realistic supposition that
the configurations under consideration differ only slightly
from a rigidly rotating reference state with fixed angular
velocity ¯Ω then, to lowest order, we shall obtain the ex-
pressions
ℓ = m ¯Ω 2 ,
∇iℓ = 2m ¯Ω ∇i .
(109)
This dependence of the angular momentum (per superfluid
particle) ℓ on the cylindrical radial coodinate contrasts
with the dependence mainly on the spherical radial coor-
dinate r that one would expect for the number densities
nI and nf , as well as for the angular velocity difference [Ω]
(which, in view of (61), might be expected to be roughly
proportional to the depth dependent ratio m/m⋆). This
is why, as in the case of (99), it is physically implausible
that the gradient of the stratification potential µI could
be adjusted so as to cancel the terms in (108) except near
the stellar equator.
5 Conclusions
The foregoing work shows how it is possible to construct
an extensive range of simple, explicitly integrable, axisym-
metric stratified two-fluid neutron star models in which a
small differential angular velocity [Ω] can be chosen in ad-
vance as an arbitrary (implicitly history dependent) func-
tion of the spherical coordinates r and θ in the pinned
case, and as an arbitrary function just of the cylindrical
coordinate = r cos θ in the unpinned case to which the
generalised Proudman theorem applies.
This idealised category of non-dissipative models in-
cludes, as extreme case, the kind of force-free model con-
structed by Prix et al.
[39] on the basis of the postulate
of separate conservation of protons and neutrons. Except
in this special case it is shown that the equilibrium of the
two-fluid model necessitates the presence of a balancing
force (given by (99) for unpinned configurations and by
(108) for pinned configurations) that must presumably be
provided by stress in the solid structure of the crust (whose
detailed treatment is beyond the scope of the purely fluid
description used here) which can build up only to a certain
point at which the breakdown responsible for the glitch
phenomenon will occur.
The exceptional case in which the presence of such
(glitch producing) stress was avoided [39] depended on
the postulate of separate conservation of protons and neu-
trons, a condition that would be realistic in the short
timescale context of dynamic perturbations but not in
the long timescale context of stationary configurations, for
which the postulate of chemical equilibrium is advocated
here as a more plausible idealisation.
It is to be understood that the force density given ei-
ther by (99) or more likely by (108) will have to be bal-
anced by a solid stress gradient, meaning that it will sat-
isfy a relation of the form f i = ∇jhSij
i in which hSij
i
is a shear stress tensor that is the trace-free part of an
elastic stress tensor Sj
i of the kind recently described in
the framework of an elastic solid model that is already
available [10] for the description of the outer crust, of
which an appropriate neutron conducting generalisation
will soon be ready [9] for application to the inner crust
(with density above the neutron drip threshold) under con-
sideration here. The idea is that this shear stress tensor
hSiij will be proportional to a trace-free shear strain ten-
sor that can not excede a critical magnitude beyond which
the solid structure will breakdown, and that a glitch will
occur either when this critical value is reached or else, in
the pinned case (108), at what may be an earlier stage
when the Joukowski-Magnus force density (103) reaches a
vortex slippage limit at which unpinning occurs.
For the study of processes occurring on intermediate
timescales it will of course be necessary to include al-
lowance for the dissipative processes that have been ne-
glected in the idealised models considered here. As well
as the controversial question of vortex slippage, [27, 26,
20, 21, 22] a particularly important issue concerns the
timescales [41, 47, 45] of the weak interaction processes
leading to chemical equilibrium.
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful to Silvano Bonazzola, Loic Villain
and Pawel Haensel for discussions concerning stratification
and deviations from chemical equilibrium in neutron stars.
Nicolas Chamel acknowledges support from the Lavoisier
program of the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
14
References
[1] M. Alford, J. Bowers, K. Rajagopal, "Crystalline
color superconductivity", Phys. Rev. D63 (2001),
074016.
[2] M.A. Alpar, H.F. Chau, K.S. Cheng, D. Pines, "Post-
glitch relaxation of the VELA pulsar after its first
eight large glitches - A reevaluation with the vortex
creep model", Ap. J. 409 (1993) 345-359.
[3] M.A. lpar, D. Pines, P. .W Anderson, J. Shaham,
"Vortex creep and the internal temperature of neu-
tron stars. I - General theory", Ap. J.276 (1984) 325-
334.
[4] M.A. Alpar, J.A. Sauls, "On the dynamical coupling
between the superfluid interior and the crust of a neu-
tron star" Ap. J. 327 (1988) 723-725.
[5] N. Andersson, G.L. Comer, D. Langlois, "Oscillations
of general relativistic superfluid neutron stars", Phys.
Rev. D66 (2002) 104002.
[6] N. Andersson, G.L. Comer, R.Prix, "The super-
fluid two-stream instability and pulsar glitches",
M.N.R.A.S. 354 (2004) 101-110.
[7] A. F. Andreev, E. P. Bashkin, "Three velocity hy-
drodynamics of superfluid solutions", Sov. Phys.
J.E.T.P. 42 (1976) 164-167.
[8] G. Baym, C. Pethick, D. Pines, M. Ruderman, "Spin
up in neutron stars: the future of the Vela pulsar",
Nature 224 (1969) 872.
[9] B. Carter, E. Chachoua, "Newtonian mechanics
of neutron superfluid in elastic star crust", ArXiv
preprint astro-ph/0601658.
[10] B. Carter, E. Chachoua, N. Chamel, "Covariant New-
tonian and Relativistic dynamics of (magneto)-elastic
solid model for neutron star crust." Gen. Rel. Grav.
38 (2006) 83-119.
[11] B. Carter, N. Chamel, "Covariant analysis of New-
tonian multifluid models for neutron stars: I Milne-
Cartan structure and variational formulation", Int. J.
Mod. Phys. D 13 (2004) 291-325.
[12] B. Carter, N. Chamel, "Covariant analysis of Newto-
nian multifluid models for neutron stars: II Stress -
energy tensors and virial theorems; III Transvective,
viscous and superfluid drag dissipation", Int. J. Mod.
Phys. D 14 (2005) 717-774.
[13] B. Carter, N. Chamel, P. Haensel, "Entrainment co-
efficient and effective mass for conduction neutrons
in neutron star crust: Simple nuclear models", Nucl.
Phys. A 748 (2005) 675-697.
[14] B. Carter, N. Chamel, P. Haensel, "Effect of BCS
pairing on entrainment in neutron superfluid current
in neutron star crust", Nucl. Phys. A 759 (2005) 441-
464.
[15] B. Carter, N. Chamel, P. Haensel, "Entrainment coef-
ficient and effective mass for conduction neutrons in
neutron star crust: Macroscopic treatment", ArXiv
preprint astro-ph/0408083.
[16] B. Carter, D. Sedrakian, D. Langlois, "Centrifugal
buoyancy as a mechanism for neutron star glitches",
A&A. 361 (2000) 795 - 802.
[17] N. Chamel, "Band structure effects for dripped neu-
trons in neutron star crust", Nucl. Phys. A 747
(2005) 109-128.
[18] G.L. Comer, N. Andersson, "On the dynamics of su-
perfluid neutron star cores", M.N.R.A.S. 328 (2001)
1129-1143.
[19] G.L. Comer, R. Joint, "A relativistic mean field
model for entrainment in general relativity", Phys.
Rev. D68 (2003) 023002.
[20] D. Dall'Osso, G.L. Israel, L. Stella, A. Possenti, E.
Perozzi, "The Glitches of the Anomalous X-Ray Pul-
sar 1RXS J170849.0-400910", ApJ.599 (2003) 485-
497.
[21] P. Donati, P.M. Pizzochero, "Is there Nuclear Pinning
of Vortices in Superfluid Pulsars?", Phys. Rev. Lett.
90 (2003), 211101
[22] P. Donati, P. M. Pizzochero, "Fully consistent semi-
classical treatment of vortex-nucleus interaction in
rotating neutron stars", Nucl. Phys. A 742 (2004),
363-379.
[23] L. M. Franco, B. Link, R. I. Epstein, "Quaking neu-
tron stars" Ap. J. 543 (2000) 987-994.
[24] G. Hobbs, A. G. Lyne, B. C. Joshi, M. Kramer, I.H.
Stairs, F. Camilo, R. N. Manchester, N. D'Amico, A.
Possenti, V. M. Kaspi, "A very large glitch in PSR
J1806-2125", M.N.R.A.S. 333 (2002) L7-L10.
[25] K. Iida & K. Sato, "Spin-down of Neutron Stars and
Compositional Transitions in the Cold Crustal Mat-
ter", Ap. J. 477 (1997) 294-312.
15
[26] D. I. Jones & N. Andersson, "Freely precessing neu-
tron stars: model and observations", M.N.R.A.S. 324
(2001) 811-824.
[40] R. Prix, J. Novak, G.L. Comer, "Relativistic numer-
ical models for stationary superflid neutron stars"
Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 043005.
[27] P. B. Jones, "The origin of pulsar glitches",
M.N.R.A.S. 296 (1998) 217-224.
[28] V. M. Kaspi, J. R. Lackey, D. Chakrabarty, "A Glitch
in an Anomalous X-Ray Pulsar", Ap. J. 537 (2000)
L31-L34.
[29] V. M. Kaspi, F. P. Gavriil, "A Second Glitch from
the "Anomalous" X-Ray Pulsar 1RXS J 170849.0-
4000910", Ap. J. 596 (2003) L71-L74.
[30] D. Langlois, D. Sedrakian, B. Carter, "Differential
rotation of relativistic superfluid in neutron stars",
MNRAS 297 (1998) 1198-1201.
[41] A. Reisenegger, "Constraining Dense Matter Super-
fluidity through Thermal Emission f Ap. J. 485
(1997) 313-318.
[42] M. Ruderman, "Neutron star crustal plate tectonics.
I. Magnetic dipole evolution in lillisecond pulsars and
low-mass X-ray binaries", Ap. J. 366 (1991) 261-269.
[43] M. Ruderman, T. Zhou, K. Chen, "Neutron star mag-
netic field evolution, crust movement and glitches",
Ap. J. 492 (1998), 267-280.
[44] J.A. Sauls, in Timing Neutron Stars ed. H. Ogelman,
E.D.P. Van den Heuvel (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1989)
457-490.
[31] B. Link, "Constraining Hadronic Superfluidity with
Neutron Star Precession", Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 (2003)
101101.
[45] L. Villain & P. Haensel, "Non equilibrium beta
processes in superfluid neutron star cores", ArXiv
preprint astro-ph/0504572.
[32] B. Link, R. I. Epstein, G. Baym, "Superfluid vortex
creep and the rotational dynamics of neutron stars",
ApJ.403 (1993) 285-302.
[46] N. Wang, R.N. Manchester, R.T. Pace, M. Bailes,
V.M. Kaspi, B. W. Stappers, A. G. Lyne, "Glitches in
southern pulsars", M.N.R.A.S. 317 (1998) 843-860.
[33] A.G. Lyne, S. L. Shemar, F. G. Smith, "Statistical
studies of pulsar glitches", M.N.R.A.S. 315 (2000)
534-542.
[47] D. G. Yakovlev, A.D. Kaminker, O. Y. Gnedin, P.
Haensel, "Neutrino emission from neutron stars",
Phys. Rep. 354 (2001) 1-155.
[34] G. Mendell, "Superfluid hydrodynamics in rotating
neutron stars. I Nondissipative equations", Ap. J.
380 (1991) 515-529.
6 Appendix
[35] M. Morii, N. Kawai, N. Shibazaki, "Pulse Profile
Change Possibly Associated with a Glitch in an
Anomalous X-Ray Pulsar 4U 0142+61", Ap. J. 622
(2005) 544-548.
[36] M.A. Perez-Garcia, N. Corte, L. Mornas, J.P. Suares-
Curieses, J. Diaz-Alonso, "Formation of an ordered
phase in nuclear matter" Nucl. Phys. A 699 (2002)
939.
[37] P.M. Pizzochero, L. Viverit, R.A. Broglia, "Vortex
nucleon interaction and pinning forces in neutron
stars" Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 3347-3350.
[38] R. Prix, "Slowly rotating two-fluid neutron star
model" A&A. 352 (2000) 623 - 631.
[39] R. Prix, G.L. Comer, N. Andersson, "Slowly rotat-
ing superfluid neutron star model with entrainment",
A&A. 381 (2002) 178-196.
6.1 Joukowsky formula for Magnus force
The purpose of this appendix is to derive the formula used
above for the force exerted on the fluid in the pinned case
and to verify that it does indeed balance the collective
effect of the Magnus forces exerted on the individual vor-
tices. We shall start by evaluating the latter, using the
generalised Joukowski formula that has recently been de-
rived [12] for the force exerted on an isolated vortex by a
mixture of irrotational perfect fluids.
The present application is to the case of a vortex that
is fixed with respect to the crust rest frame characterised
by the flow 4 vector u µ
c of the "normal" constituent, and
that is oriented in the direction specified by a spacelike
unit 4-vector νµ say, for which the force per unit length
will be given by
F ν = Cf nµεµνρσνρu σ
c
(110)
where nµ is the (chemical gauge invariant) relative flow
current vector of the superfluid and C is its (chemical
16
gauge invariant) circulation as given by
6.2 Effect of entrainment on vortex den-
Cf = I πf
µdxµ ,
(111)
in which the integral is carried out along any closed path
surrounding the vortex.
Since the effect of many such vortices in closely spaced
parallel array will be represented by a vorticity vector
wµ = w νµ
(112)
of the type introduced in (40), whose magnitude w is the
value of the total circulation per unit area, it follows that
the corresponding force density (obtained as force per unit
length per unit area) will be given by
f J
ν =
w
Cf F ν
so we end up with the formula
f J
ν = nµεµνρσwρu σ
c
(113)
(114)
in which it is to be observed that the value of the cir-
culation Cf round an individual vortex has cancelled out.
(Thus it is not necessary to know that it will actually be
given in terms of the Dirac-Planck constant by the formula
Cf = π in which the usual factor 2 is missing because of
the pairing due the fermionic nature of the neutrons.)
To obtain the force density on the fluid we start from
the formula (24) in which, since we are considering a sta-
tionary axisymmetric situation, the divergence term will
automatically drop out leaving the expression
f f
µ = nν
f f
νµ .
(115)
which would be equivalent just to the ordinary Euler equa-
tion if the force term vanished. It is evident that the pin-
ning condition
c f
uν
νµ = 0,
can be used to rewrite (115) in the form
f f
µ = nf (u ν
f − u ν
c )f
νµ = nνf
νµ .
(116)
(117)
sity
It is of interest to consider the effect of entrainment on
the vorticity magnitude w which is the circulation per unit
area round an infinitesimal circuit orthogonal to the local
axis of rotation. Remarking that the circulation Cf is sim-
ply given by 2πℓ, where ℓ is the angular momentum per
free particle, it can be seen from (55), by considering the
circulation between nearby circuits with crylindrical ra-
dius values and +δ, that the local vorticity magnitude
will be expressible in terms of the angular velocity differ-
ence [Ω] = Ωf − Ωc and the mass increment mf
c = m⋆ − m
as
w =
δCf
2πδ
= 2mΩf + 2mf
c[Ω] +
δ(m⋆[Ω])
δ
.
(120)
Knowing that the circulation round an individual quan-
tised vortex line in the fermionic superfluid condensate will
be given by Cf = π we see that the corresponding surface
number density of quantised vortex lines will simply be
given by w/Cf = w/(π). The first term in equation (120)
can be recognised as the well-known formula for a single
superfluid.
In practice, the extra terms proportional to [Ω] and its
gradient will be negligible for the astrophysical applica-
tions under consideration, in which we shall generally have
[Ω] ≪ Ω, provided we are using an "operational" gauge in
which magnitude of the effective mass m⋆ will remain com-
parable with the ordinary baryonic mass m. If the evalua-
tion were carried out in a "comprehensive" gauge, meaning
a chemical basis in which all the neutrons are deemed to
be "free", the relevant value of the effective mass would
become extremely large near the "neutron drip" transi-
tion, but the value of the (gauge dependent) difference
[Ω] would correspondingly become even smaller, since the
product m⋆[Ω] is chemically invariant, so that the same
value would ultimately be obtained for the vorticity mag-
nitude w itself.
It can also be seen to follow from (116) that, in terms of
the vector introduced in (40), the vorticity form will be
expressible as
f
νµ = εµνρσwρu σ
c ,
so that (114) can be rewritten in the form
f J
µ = −nνf
νµ ,
which evidently does indeed exactly balance (117).
(118)
(119)
17
|
astro-ph/0212467 | 2 | 0212 | 2003-06-12T09:59:56 | Discs in early-type lensing galaxies: effects on magnification ratios and measurements of $H_0$ | [
"astro-ph"
] | Observations of early-type galaxies, both in the local universe and in clusters at medium redshifts, suggest that these galaxies often contain discs or disc-like structures. Using the results of Kelson et al. (2000) for the incidence of disc-components among the galaxies in the redshift z=0.33 cluster CL 1358+62, we investigate the effect of disc structures on the lensing properties of early-type galaxies. Statistical properties, like magnification cross sections and the expected number of quad (four-image) lens systems, are not affected greatly by the inclusion of discs that contain less than about 10 per cent of the total stellar mass. However, the properties of individual lens systems are affected. We estimate that 10-30 per cent of all quad lens systems, with early-type deflector galaxies, would be affected measurably by the presence of disc components. Intriguingly, the image magnification ratios are altered significantly. The amplitude of the predicted change is sufficient to explain the observed magnification ratios in systems like B1422+231 without requiring compact substructure. Furthermore, time delays between images also change; fitting a bulge-only model to early-type lenses that in fact contain a disc would yield a value of the Hubble constant H_0 that is systematically too low by about 25 per cent. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (0000)
Printed 13 June 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
Discs in early-type lensing galaxies: effects on
magnification ratios and measurements of H0
Ole Moller1, Paul Hewett2 and A. W. Blain3
1Kapteyn Institute, PO Box 800, 9700 AV Groningen, the Netherlands.
2Institute of Astronomy, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HE, UK.
3Department of Astronomy, California Institute of Technology, CA91125, Pasadena, USA
13 June 2018
ABSTRACT
Observations of early-type galaxies, both in the local universe and in clusters at
medium redshifts, suggest that these galaxies often contain discs or disc-like struc-
tures. Using the results of Kelson et al. (2000) for the incidence of disc-components
among the galaxies in the redshift z = 0.33 cluster CL 1358+62, we investigate the
effect of disc structures on the lensing properties of early-type galaxies. Statistical
properties, like magnification cross sections and the expected number of quad (four-
image) lens systems, are not affected greatly by the inclusion of discs that contain less
than ∼ 10 per cent of the total stellar mass. However, the properties of individual lens
systems are affected. We estimate that 10 − 30 per cent of all quad lens systems, with
early-type deflector galaxies, would be affected measurably by the presence of disc
components. Intriguingly, the image magnification ratios are altered significantly. The
amplitude of the predicted change is sufficient to explain the observed magnification
ratios in systems like B1422+231 without requiring compact substructure. Further-
more, time delays between images also change; fitting a bulge-only model to early-type
lenses that in fact contain a disc would yield a value of the Hubble constant H0 that
is systematically too low by ∼ 25 per cent.
gravitational lensing -- galaxies: elliptical and lenticular -- galaxies:
Key words:
formation -- cosmology: dark matter -- cosmology: distance scale -- method: numerical
1
INTRODUCTION
In current models of hierarchical galaxy formation the mor-
phological type of a galaxy is determined to a large extent by
its merger history (Abraham & van den Bergh 2001): late-
type galaxies have not undergone a recent massive merger,
so that stable, prominent discs formed, whereas early-type
galaxies have been prevented from forming a prominent disc
by a major merger that either consumes all the available
gas for star formation, or redistributes angular momentum
via large scale winds (Somerville & Primack 1999). This be-
haviour has also been recovered in hydrodynamical simu-
lations of galaxy formation (Steinmetz & Muller 1995). So
far, there is no evidence for any evolution in the luminos-
ity and size of discs in late-type galaxies up to redshifts
of about 1 (Simard et al. 1999; Ferguson & Clarke 2001).
This suggests that if mergers occur after that time, they
are either not massive enough to significantly affect the disc
structures or they destroy visible disc structures, producing
elliptical systems. It is not known on what time scales disc
structures form. Simulations and some observations suggest
that disc structures form slowly between redshifts 0.1 and
1 (Mo, Mao & White 1998) but there is also evidence that
some large discs are already present at higher redshifts (van
Dokkum & Stanford 2001). Most likely, discs in early-type
galaxies are the result of remaining gas settling after ma-
jor merging events between two late-type galaxies (Naab &
Burkert 2001). Another possible formation scenario for discs
involves slow accretion from many minor merging events.
Debris from minor mergers, or high velocity clouds in the
halo of the galaxy, could rain down onto the disc (Benjamin
& Danly 1997; Putman et al. 2002). However, such a scenario
would lead to thicker, less pronounced disc structures. Since
late-type galaxies exhibit clear disc structures, this process
is unlikely to be very important in the formation of typical
spiral structures.
In all these scenarios, the obvious question arises as to
whether disc structures are exclusively found in late-type
galaxies. Observationally, that is clearly not the case. S0
galaxies in the local universe possess disc components, and
even local ellipticals show evidence of disc structures and
dust lanes when studied in detail (Rest et al. 2001; Tran
et al. 2001). The isophotes of ellipticals are usually classified
2 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
into "boxy" and "discy", types. Pointed, discy isophotes may
well be caused by the presence of discs. Even in the case
when the isophotes are nearly round and show no sign of
"discyness", kinematic studies suggest that it is still possible
to hide a disc in such galaxies (Romanowsky & Kochanek
1997).
There is also some observational evidence for discs in el-
lipticals at cosmological redshifts; Kelson et al. (2000) found
that many early-type galaxies in CL 1358+62 at z = 0.33
possess evidence for the presence of exponential discs, sug-
gesting discs are present in a large fraction of early-type
galaxies, at least in clusters. Since there is no clear under-
standing yet on how these discs form, and no systematic ob-
servational investigation into the abundance and properties
of discs in early-type field galaxies has been carried out, it is
difficult to make precise statements about the abundance of
discs in field ellipticals. However, some recent observations
using the Hubble Space Telescope (HST ) show that a frac-
tion of at least ∼ 50 per cent of field ellipticals contain discs
of sizes spanning a range of at least an order of magnitude,
from small nuclear discs to large discs extending beyond the
bulge (Rest et al. 2001). In addition, kinematic studies using
the SAURON integral field spectrograph, also suggest that
a high fraction of ∼ 50 per cent of field ellipticals contain
discs of various sizes (de Zeeuw et al. 2002).
Most lens galaxies known to date are early-type galax-
ies. The main reason for this is that early-type galaxies tend
to be the most massive and hence have a larger cross sec-
tion for gravitational lensing. However, as shown by Blain,
Moller & Maller (1999) spiral galaxy lenses are also pre-
dicted to contribute significantly to the total lensing cross
section. This is mainly due to the high surface mass density
of the thin disc component when viewed edge on (Maller,
Flores & Primack, 1997; Moller & Blain, 1998). As shown
in those papers, the disc components of late-type lenses can
make important contributions to the lensing potential and
change the generic properties of the lens systems. The dis-
covery of spiral lens systems in the CLASS lensing survey,
e.g. B1600+434 (Koopmans, de Bruyn & Jackson 1998),
confirm that this is the case. However, early-type lensing
galaxies have so far nearly always been modelled with a sim-
ple one-component model, possibly including external shear
(Keeton, Kochanek & Seljak, 1997; Leh´ar et al., 2000).
In this paper we determine the lensing properties of
early-type galaxies that contain realistic discs with stellar
masses of up to ∼ 10 per cent of that of the bulge. We
will determine the lensing properties of early-type lenses and
show how discs in ellipticals could explain some properties
of observed lens systems that have not yet been modelled
successfully. We concentrate on three main questions:
(i) statistical lensing properties: how do disc structures
in early-type lensing galaxies affect the statistical proper-
ties of a sample of early-type lenses? We calculate magni-
fication cross sections and the expected ratio of quad: two-
image systems. In particular, we investigate whether discs in
early-type lenses may explain the high ratio of quad image
systems, which is still an unsolved enigma in gravitational
lensing (Rusin & Tegmark, 2001, but see Chae, 2002).
(ii) magnification ratios: can disc structures explain some
or all of the unusual magnification ratios observed in some
early-type lens systems? To date, these deviant magnifica-
tion ratios have been interpreted as providing strong evi-
dence in favour of the presence of compact halo substructure
as predicted by current cold dark matter (CDM) simulations
(e.g. Metcalf & Madau 2001).
(iii) time delays: how would disc structures affect the
measured time delays in early-type lens systems? Currently
there seems to be a strong disagreement between the value
of H0 as found in the HST Key Project (Freedman et al.
2001) and measurements of H0 from gravitational lensing
(Kochanek 2003). Some local estimates of H0 (e.g.Saha et al
2001) also favour lower values. We investigate whether disc
structures in gravitational lens systems may reduce this dis-
crepancy.
We start in §2 by discussing the appearance of the model lens
galaxies and show that the manifestations of the presence
of a disc are similar to those observed in some ellipticals.
In §3 we present the parametric lens models used in this
paper. In §4 we describe some general and statistical lensing
properties of early-type galaxies that include disc structures.
In §5 we show how discs in ellipticals could explain some of
the observed magnification ratios and in §6 we calculate how
the presence of discs in ellipticals would affect estimates of
H0 from lensing. We conclude with a summary in §7.
Throughout
this paper we assume a Friedmann-
Robertson-Walker Universe with ΩM = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7 and
H0 = 50 km s−1 Mpc−1. The choice for this value of H0 is
motivated due to limitations of the original lensing code.
Subsequently, the code has been extended to allow for any
value of H0, as necessary for the calculations in §6, but we
did not recalculate the results of §3-5, as these calculations
are very time-consuming and a change in H0 has little effect
on the results. A value of H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1, is prob-
ably more in line with current observational constraints, as
given for example by the HST Key Project (Freedman et al.
2001) and the WMAP results (Bennett et al. 2003).
2 SURFACE BRIGHTNESS PROFILES
The existence of disc components with large scale-lengths
in luminous elliptical galaxies has been known for some
time (Bender et al. 1989; Rix & White 1990; Rix 1991).
Recent theoretical work (Naab & Burkert 2001; Barnes
2002) has begun to address the origin of such components
in bulge-dominated galaxies. However, the ability to reli-
ably determine the prevalence of discs in strongly bulge-
dominated systems has only been possible following the de-
velopment of full two-dimensional decomposition techniques
(Byun & Freeman 1995). Given data of adequate signal-to-
noise ratio and angular resolution, two-dimensional decom-
position methods are capable of identifying discs in systems
with bulge fractions (B/T) as high as B/T=0.95. A signif-
icant quantity of HST imaging, obtained using the Wide
Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2), of luminous bulge-
dominated galaxies in intermediate redshift clusters is well-
suited to such decompositions but little work appears to
have been undertaken. Exceptions are the investigations of
the z = 0.33 cluster CL1358+62 by Kelson et al. (2000) and
Tran et al. (2003). Fig. 4 of Kelson et al. provides a partic-
ularly striking demonstration of the presence of discs, even
among galaxies with conventional 'E' morphological classi-
fications.
In order to parameterize the light profile of ellipticals,
a commonly used set of parameters are the half-light radius
rh and the surface brightness at the half light radius Ih.
The surface brightness of a de-Vaucouleurs bulge can then
be written as (Binney & Tremaine 1987),
I(r) = Ih exp(cid:8)−7.67[(r/rh)(1/4) − 1](cid:9).
The parameterization of the surface brightness distribution
for an exponential disc, in terms of the central surface bright-
ness, Id, and scale -- length, rd, can be written
(1)
I(r) = Id exp −(r/rd).
(2)
The bulge fraction, B/T, for a galaxy parameterized by
such bulge and disc components is then
B
T
=
Ihr2
h
Ihr2
h + 0.28Idr2
d
(3)
where Ih and rh, Id and rd are as defined above.
Table 2 in Kelson et al. gives surface brightnesses and
half-light-radii
for bulge-only and bulge-plus-disc fits to
galaxies in CL1358+62. Note that Kelson et al. specify the
properties of the disc component in terms of half-light radius
of the disc, rhd = 1.688rd, and the mean surface brightness
within the half-light radius, < Ihd >. Using this parameter-
ization the B/T ratio may be calculated by replacing the
term 0.28Idr2
d by < Ihd > r2
hd.
For the investigation of the general and statistical lens-
ing properties of discy ellipticals, we use the full sample
of galaxy models in Kelson's catalogue. However, our main
results, as presented in § 5 and § 6 involve time-consuming
calculations and are therefore based on the parameters de-
scribing a single model galaxy. The presence of many galax-
ies with bulge and disc components with comparable scale-
lengths in CL1358+62 is clear from the form of the residuals
shown in Figure 4 of Kelson et al. It is worth stressing that
the presence of even highly inclined (almost edge-on) discs,
with scale-lengths similar to those identified by Kelson et al.,
making up less than ∼ 10 per cent of the total light are hard
to discern directly in images. Plots showing the residuals ob-
tained by fitting a bulge-only model are, however, far more
revealing. The presence of face-on discs is revealed by char-
acteristic donut-like residuals, while edge-on discs appear as
often quite prominent inclined structures. Notwithstanding
the evidence provided by Kelson et al. in support of the ac-
curacy of their bulge-disc compositions we have chosen to
be conservative by reducing the disc contribution to each
galaxy in the Kelson et al. catalogue by half. Thus, our in-
vestigation of the statistical lensing properties is based on
the properties of the galaxies listed in Table 2 of Kelson et
al. but with a reduction in the disc contribution of a factor 2.
For the individual model galaxy used in our calculations we
have chosen galaxy no. 242 (Table 1). Adopting our rescal-
ing of the disc contribution, galaxy no. 242 has B/T=0.95,
c.f., B/T=0.91 in Kelson et al. Galaxy no. 242 has a total
mass, B/T ratio and bulge scale-length close to the average
value for the 'E' galaxies in Kelson et al's catalogue. In our
simulations the ellipticity of the bulge is set to e = 0.4 and
the inclination of the disc is i = 75 deg.
Fig. 1 shows images based on our adopted parameteri-
zation of galaxy no. 242 with B/T=0.95. Fig. 1a is an image
based on the bulge-only model surface-brightness profile fit
(parameters from Cols: 3 & 4 in Table 1), Fig. 1b shows a
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
3
realization of the bulge-plus-disc surface-brightness profile
(parameters from Cols: 7 & 8 (bulge) and Cols: 10 & 11
(disc) in Table 1). The disc is at high inclination, i = 70 deg
to the line of sight (i = 90 deg corresponding to edge-on)
and oriented at an angle of 45 deg with respect to the x-
axis. The presence of the disc is barely discernible. Fig. 1c
shows the residual image derived from subtracting Fig. 1a
from Fig. 1b (both normalized to possess the same total
counts). The images may be compared to those in Figs 1
and 4 of Kelson et al.. In Kelson et al., galaxy no. 242 shows
the donut-like residual characteristic of the presence of a
close to face-on disc. By contrast, in Fig. 1c, the disc ap-
pears prominently because of the high inclination angle of
i = 70 deg to the line-of-sight.
Following submission of the original version of this pa-
per an analysis of the photometric properties of galaxies in
CL 1358+62 undertaken by Tran et al. (2003) appeared.
Comparison of both the B/T values and the scale-lengths
of the light distributions for the bulge-dominated galaxies
in common between Kelson et al. and Tran et al. show a
good correlation over the full range of B/T. However, for
large values of B/T the contribution of the disc components
are much larger in the Tran et al. analysis. Less satisfac-
tory still is the comparison between the scale-lengths of the
disc components found among the bulge-dominated galaxies.
The disc scale-lengths found by Tran et al. are significantly
larger, explaining, at least in part, the systematically smaller
B/T ratios found for the bulge-dominated systems. Tran et
al. present the results of a large number of Monte-Carlo sim-
ulations designed to quantify the accuracy of the decompo-
sitions into bulge and disc components. No reference is made
to the strong systematic disagreement between the statistics
of the disc scale-lengths found in the two studies. Tran et al.
are confident that their simulations demonstrate the ability
of the software employed to obtain accurate bulge-disc de-
compositions. However, the parameter ranges employed in
the simulations appear to be determined from the results of
the actual decompositions applied to the real data. Tran et
al. find no discs with scale-lengths comparable to or smaller
than those of the bulge components of the galaxies. Thus, it
is not clear that the ability of Tran et al.'s analysis to cor-
rectly parameterize combinations of bulge and disc profiles
with parameters found by Kelson et al. has been adequately
tested. In the circumstances we have decided to retain the
very conservative distribution of B/T ratios, with associated
values of component scale-lengths, based on the distribution
advocated by Kelson et al.
3 THE LENS MODELS
In order to study the lensing properties of early-type galax-
ies including discs, a working model of the mass distribution
is needed. Unfortunately, little is known about the detailed
properties of early-type galaxy discs and how they depend on
morphology and environment. From past studies it is clear
that discs in ellipticals are abundant and that the disc sizes
and magnitudes cover the whole range from compact and
luminous to extended and faint (Rest et al. 2001; Scorza &
Bender 1995; Scorza et al. 1998). Most of the available infor-
mation is based on observations of individual galaxies; there
has not yet been a systematic high-resolution study of the
4 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
Figure 1. Simulated images of a typical model galaxy at redshift z = 0.33. The galaxy model parameters correspond to our modified
representation of galaxy no. 242 in Kelson's catalogue (Table 1). Panel (a) shows the image derived using a bulge-only model. Panel (b)
shows the bulge-plus-disc model, normalized to have the same total counts as the bulge -- only model. The disc component of the model is
inclined at 70 deg to the line of sight and oriented at an angle of 45 deg, to the x axis. Panel (c) shows the residual following subtraction
of the bulge-only image from the bulge-plus-disc image. The pixel scale, 0.1 arcsec per pixel, and point spread function have been chosen
to approximate images obtained using the WFPC2 on HST. The signal-to-noise ratio of the synthetic images is significantly higher than
that typical of HST imaging data of the type analysed by Kelson et al. (2000).
morphologies of a complete, unbiased sample of early-type
galaxies. In order to make meaningful predictions about the
lensing properties of early-type lensing galaxies including
disc components, we base our models on the light profiles
obtained in Kelson et al. (2000). All galaxies in Kelson's
sample are at a redshift of z = 0.33, which corresponds
roughly to the redshift at which lensing is most efficient;
few lenses are expected with redshifts less than z < 0.1.
then rh = 7.6764rb and Ih = Γ−1Σb exp (−7.676) for the
bulge component and Id = Γ−1Σd for the disc component.
We will refer to rh and rhd = 1.688rd as the 'effective ra-
dius' or 'half-light radius' of bulge and disc, respectively.
Assuming randomly oriented discs, the average inclination
is about 70 deg. Unless otherwise stated, the discs in our
bulge-plus-disc models have this inclination.
3.1 Parameterization of early-type lenses with
3.2 Possible caveats of the model
discs
the
We model
lensing galaxies with two-
components: an elliptical bulge with a de-Vaucouleurs r1/4
profile and an exponential thin disc.
elliptical
Under the usual assumption of a thin lens, the lensing
properties depend solely on the surface mass density profile.
For the bulge component this is given by
Σb(r) = Σb exp (−r′/rb)1/4,
(4)
where Σb is the central surface mass density of the bulge,
rb is the bulge scale-length, and
r′ = px2 + y2(1 − e)2.
Here r = px2 + y2, and e is the ellipticity of the bulge.
The disc, inclined at an angle i to the line of sight, can be
parameterized in a similar way, to give
(5)
Σd(r) = Σd exp (−r′/rd),
(6)
where Σd is the central surface mass density of the disc, rd
is the scale-length of the disc and
r′ = px2 + y2[1 − cos (i)]2.
We convert the light profiles as given in equations (1) &
(2) to models of the mass distribution assuming a constant
mass-to-light ratio, Γ. The relation between the parameters
in equations (1) & (2) and those in equations (4) & (6), is
(7)
The photometric profile decompositions of galaxies in CL
1358+62 provide an observational motivation for mod-
elling early-type galaxies including disc structures. However,
galaxies in cluster environments might exhibit more pro-
nounced discs than corresponding galaxies in the field. If
this is indeed the case, and simulations of Naab & Burk-
ert (2001) suggest otherwise, the discs in our model lensing
galaxies could be too pronounced compared to those ex-
pected in observed early-type lens systems, many of which
are in lower-density field environments. A comparison of the
disc sizes obtained from a sample of mostly field ellipticals
by Scorza & Bender (1995) with the sizes of discs in E's
and S0's found in Kelson et al. (2000) shows that the discs
from both samples are similar and range in disc half-light
radii from 0.1 kpc to 1 kpc. This could indicate that the en-
vironment may influence the relative number of galaxies as
a function of morphology, but has little effect on the prop-
erties of discs in galaxies of a given morphological type. In
any case, we are not concerned here with accurate modelling
of the statistical incidence of discs, but rather aim to show
how discs with sizes and masses consistent with current ob-
servations influence the gravitational lensing properties of
early-type lens systems.
There is a second possible caveat with the mass model
we use here: we assume that mass follows light and do not
include a dark matter halo. As we will discuss in more de-
tail below, the main effect of inclined, thin disc components
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
5
Figure 2. Radial surface mass density profiles for representative
models of the galaxies in the cluster CL 1358+62. The different
lines show the surface mass density as a function of radius for dif-
ferent model parameters that are representative for the majority
of all galaxies in the sample. All curves are normalized so that
the total mass is 1011M⊙. The ellipticity of the bulge is e = 0.4
and the inclination angle of the disc is i = 70 deg. The surface
mass density differs by less than 10 per cent between models that
include a disc with Md = 0.1Mb and models without a disc. At
small radii, discs increase the surface mass density, due to their
smaller scale lengths. At the cluster redshift of z = 0.33, 1 arcsec
corresponds to 6.6 kpc for the cosmology we adopt in this paper.
on the lensing properties of galaxies arises from the strong
asymmetry that is introduced in the central regions of the
galaxies due to the disc. We therefore expect that the pre-
cise form of the spherical or nearly-spherical components in
which the disc is embedded, that is, the bulge and halo, will
not change the effect of the added disc component drasti-
cally. We have checked this explicitly for the mass model
used to derive the results in §5 and §6, by adding a dark
matter halo that contains 2/3 of the total mass and scaling
the mass of the bulge and disc so that the Einstein radius
is the same as for the model without a dark-matter halo.
Estimates of the mass-to-light ratio of early type galaxies
range from M/L ∼ 2 in the K-band (e.g. Moriondo, Gio-
vanardi & Hunt 1998) to about M/L ∼ 10 in the V-band
(Natarajan et al. 1998). Many lens systems are consistent
with lower mass-to-light ratios within an Einstein radius of
about M/L ∼ 2 in V (Koopmans & Treu 2003), motivating
our choice of a dark halo containing 2/3 of the total mass.
When including such a spherical dark halo we find that the
inner caustic shrinks in size, and so quad images become less
likely, but that the magnification ratios and time delays of
images of sources that are quadruply imaged do not change
substantially.
3.3 Surface density and mass profiles of lens
models
We show the radial surface mass density profiles for some
typical cases in Fig. 2. The solid lines show the density pro-
files of three bulge-only models with effective radii of 0.2, 1.0
and 2.0 arcsec. At the cluster redshift of z = 0.33 these val-
ues correspond to 1.3, 6.6 and 13.3 kpc respectively. These
values cover the range of half-light radii of the bulge-only fits
Figure 3. Radial mass profiles for a number of galaxy models.
The different lines show the enclosed mass as a function of radius
for different model parameters. The curves are normalized so that
limR→∞ M (R) = 1011M⊙. The effective radii for bulge and disc
are rhd = rh = 0.2 arcsec, which corresponds to 1.3 kpc at the
cluster redshift of z = 0.33. The ellipticity of the bulge is e =
0.4 and the inclination angle of the disc is 75 deg. The enclosed
mass at distances of ∼ 1 arcsec differs by less than 10% between
models that include a disc containing 10% of the mass and models
without a disc. Note that, as in the previous figure, the most
significant contribution of the disc is in the inner regions.
to the light profiles of the galaxies in CL 1358+62, which
lie between 0.2 and 4.9 arcsec with only two galaxies hav-
ing half-light radii larger than 1.6 arcsec. The dashed lines
in Fig. 2 show the surface mass densities for discs of effec-
tive radii of 0.05, 0.2 and 0.3 arcsec. The discs are assumed
to be inclined at 70 deg to the line of sight. Most of the
bulge-plus-disc fits to the light profile of the elliptical galax-
ies in the sample have discs with effective radii less than
0.3 arcsec, corresponding to 2 kpc at z = 0.33. The disc com-
ponents of the later type galaxies are usually larger, with
effective radii of up to 1 arcsec. Comparison of the relative
bulge and disc contributions shows that the disc components
contribute significantly to the surface mass density within
about 0.5 arcsec, or 3.3 kpc. The dotted lines show the to-
tal surface mass density for a typical bulge-plus-disc fit, but
with different B/T mass ratios. It is clear that the radial
profiles for models that include a disc of less than ∼ 5 per
cent of the total mass are very similar to bulge-only mod-
els. For B/T mass ratios of 0.9 or less, that is for most of
the S0/Sa or later type galaxies in Kelson et al., the surface
mass density in the inner 0.2 arcsec differs by more than
10 per cent.
Gravitational lensing measures directly the projected
mass Menc contained inside a circular region of radius R.
In Fig. 3 we show Menc as a function of radius R. All the
models shown are normalized to the same total mass, but
the B/T mass ratio varies. The effective radius of disc and
bulge, ellipticity of bulge and inclination angle of disc are
rhd = 0.2 arcsec, rh = 0.2 arcsec, e = 0.4 and i = 75 deg
respectively and are the same for all models. These values
correspond to the typical values for an elliptical galaxy in CL
1358+62. At distances of R ∼ 1 arcsec the enclosed mass for
typical bulge-plus-disc models with B/T> 0.9 is only a few
percent larger than the enclosed mass for bulge-only models.
6 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
None of the discs in the light profile fits to the early-type
galaxies in CL 1358+62 contain more than ∼ 10 per cent of
the light (cf. Table A1), and so, if the mass-to-light ratio
is constant, then disc structures are expected to contain at
most 10 per cent of the mass. The effect of the disc on the
maximum image separations or the radius of the Einstein
ring will be small in those cases. More massive discs with a
mass of Md ∼ 0.3Mb, contribute significantly to the mass
in the inner region of the galaxy and influence the mass
contained within the expected Einstein radius more strongly.
The properties of all the elliptical galaxies from the Kel-
son et al. (2000) catalogue with the reduced disc contribu-
tion adopted for our simulations are summarized in Table 1.
The table lists both the values for the best fitting bulge-only
models and the values for the best bulge-plus-disc fits. The
two parameters fe and ft give the B/T mass ratio as mea-
sured at the Einstein radius RE and at R → ∞ respectively.
The Einstein radius is calculated taking account of the ellip-
ticity of the bulge and the inclination of the disc. Note that
the Einstein radius does not depend strongly on whether a
disc is included or not: there is no systematic dependence of
the Einstein radius on the presence of a disc.
4 LENSING PROPERTIES
The lensing properties of discs in spiral galaxies have been
studied by Maller, Flores & Primack (1997), Moller & Blain
(1998) and Blain, Moller, & Maller (1999). In those studies
it was found that thin exponential discs can influence the
statistical lensing properties even if they only contain 10 per
cent of the total mass provided that they are inclined by
more than about 70 deg to the line of sight. In particular, the
cross section for image geometries with 4 or more magnified
images, and the cross section for high magnifications of 10
or more is increased considerably. These results are generic
and hold qualitatively for discs in early-type galaxies. How-
ever, the scale lengths and masses of the disc components in
early-type galaxies are likely to be smaller, relative to the
bulge component, and so the effect of the disc on their statis-
tical lensing properties is expected to be less. In this section,
we describe the general and statistical lensing properties of
discy early-type galaxies.
4.1 General lensing properties
The gravitational potential of a mass distribution between
an observer at z = 0 and a source at z = zs deflects the light
of the source, at position ~β on the source plane, so that an
image is observed at position ~θ on the lens plane, where
~θ = ~β +
DLS
DOS
~α.
(8)
The deflection angle of a light ray α that passes the lens at
an angular position ~θ relative to the lens centre, is given by
~α(~θ) =
DOS
πDLS Z κ(~θ′)
2 d2θ′.
~θ − ~θ′
~θ − ~θ′(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:12)(cid:12)
(9)
where DOS and DLS are the angular diameter distances from
observer to source and lens to source respectively. The di-
mensionless quantity κ is defined as κ = Σ/Σc where
Σc =
c2DOS
4πGDOLDLS
(10)
is the critical surface mass density. These equations show
explicitly why thin disc components may be important, even
if they contain only a small fraction of the total mass: it is
the projected surface mass density that enters equation (9)
and this can be very high for thin edge-on discs.
The numerical ray-tracing routines that we used to ob-
tain the results in this paper are described in detail in Moller
& Blain (1998, 2001). The routines were used to generate
magnification maps on the source plane and determine the
cross sections for high magnifications and multiple imaging.
To illustrate the possible effect of disc components in a
lens system, Fig. 4 shows the images of a background point
source at a redshift of zs = 1.0 that is lensed by a fore-
ground elliptical galaxy at redshift zl = 0.3. The images
are shown for the bulge-plus-disc and pure-bulge model dis-
cussed in § 2. The source position is adjusted slightly, by
less than 0.01 arcsec, so that both the total magnification of
the source and the image geometries are very similar. Note
the change in the relative fluxes of the images. The insets
show the magnification maps on the source plane, µ(~θ) for
both cases; the disc increases the area enclosed by the caus-
tic only slightly. Comparing the magnification maps on the
source plane as shown in the insets of Fig. 4 with those of
disc lenses shown in Fig. 3 in Moller & Blain (1998), makes
clear that the effect of a disc component in early-type lensing
galaxies is much less pronounced. However, there are differ-
ences in the magnification ratios which we will investigate
more in §5.
The importance of discs can also be seen when the rel-
ative shifts of the image positions for a source at a fixed
position is considered. The shift gives some indication of
how significant a given modification of a lens model is. We
show the image geometries for small, extended sources for a
number of our lens models in Fig. 5. There is a small, but
measurable change in the image shapes and positions for
E/S0 lenses of the order of 0.05 arcsec. In the case of later-
type lenses, there is a much more pronounced change; even
Sa lens galaxies significantly change the image geometries.
Note that there is also a change in the overall scale set by the
Einstein radius, of 5−10 per cent. This is consistent with the
change of mass projected within the Einstein radius shown
in Fig. 3. However, this change of scale only affects the mass
normalization and does not reflect an observable effect of
the disc component.
4.2 Statistical lensing properties
First we determine cross sections for multiple images and
high magnifications for ellipticals that include an inclined,
thin, exponential disc.
In Fig. 6 we show the cross section ratios for bulge and
bulge-plus-disc models as a function of magnification, aver-
aged over all the galaxies of a certain morphological classifi-
cation in the sample. Except for late-type (Sa, Sab and Sb)
galaxies, there is no significant increase in the cross sections
for magnifications of up to 100. Even though a few early-
type galaxies show a clear signature of an enhancement by
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
7
Table 1. Elliptical galaxies in CL 1358+62. The values for < Ih >, rh and < Ihd > are taken directly from Kelson et al. (2000). The disc
scale length rd is related to the half-light radius as given in Kelson et al. by rd = 1.688rhd. In a cosmology with ΩΛ = 0.7, ΩM = 0.3 and
H0 = 50 km s−1 Mpc−1, 1 arcsec corresponds to 6.6 kpc at the cluster redshift of z = 0.33. A larger table that includes all the galaxies
in CL 1358+62 investigated by Kelson et al. (2000), is given in the Appendix.
←−
Bulge only
−→ ←−
Bulge and disc
No. Type < Ih >
rh
Σb
Re
< Ih >
rh
Σh < Ihd >
rd
Σd
Re
fe
212
242
256
303
360
375
409
412
531
534
536
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
20.780
21.920
20.880
20.590
20.220
22.860
21.270
21.390
21.260
21.210
21.180
0.683
1.529
1.380
0.638
0.341
4.979
0.498
0.767
1.549
0.620
1.266
0.488
0.171
0.445
0.581
0.817
0.072
0.310
0.278
0.313
0.328
0.337
1.220
1.360
2.330
1.270
2.176
2.650
2.176
2.176
2.090
0.860
1.790
21.170
22.420
21.200
21.110
21.660
23.010
21.490
22.320
21.710
22.170
21.520
0.781
1.825
1.551
0.774
0.594
5.267
0.542
1.091
1.830
0.878
1.433
0.340
0.108
0.331
0.360
0.217
0.063
0.254
0.118
0.207
0.136
0.247
18.030
20.720
18.000
18.890
17.620
19.220
22.600
17.660
19.300
16.680
18.570
0.031
0.156
0.053
0.054
0.030
0.096
0.132
0.033
0.108
0.019
0.057
6.138
0.515
6.310
2.780
8.954
2.051
0.091
8.630
1.905
1.281
3.733
1.160
1.270
2.260
1.210
1.000
2.870
0.660
0.870
1.980
0.770
1.720
0.808
0.806
0.836
0.787
0.565
0.800
0.959
0.502
0.772
0.489
0.807
−→
ft
0.960
0.950
0.967
0.947
0.867
0.984
0.969
0.908
0.954
0.901
0.965
the disc component in the magnification map on the source
plane, the average effect is small.
Rusin & Tegmark (2001) showed that the fraction of 4
image systems found in the CLASS survey is inconsistent
with the predictions from standard lens models. They found
that under the assumption of dark matter halos that are
not significantly more flattened than the visible mass, about
25 per cent of all CLASS lenses should be quads. However,
the observed fraction is about 60 per cent. We now investi-
gate whether disc structures in the early-type lensing galax-
ies could explain this discrepancy. Fig. 7 shows the expected
fraction of quad systems as a function of the total magni-
fication threshold A for the different morphological types.
There is no significant increase in the cross section for the
formation of a quad lens for the subset of early-type galaxies;
this cross section increases significantly only for the late-type
galaxies. Many observed quad lens systems are very symmet-
rical. This suggests that the sources do not lie very close to
a cusp (B1422+231 is an exception), and so that the sources
of the majority of known quad lens systems are likely to be
magnified by only moderate amounts µ ∼ 10 − 20. Hence,
discs in ellipticals cannot explain the discrepancy between
the predicted and observed quad fraction. However, our cal-
culations are conservative, as they do not take into account
the proper statistical range of lens parameters, source lu-
minosity function, the selection function of the survey and
the magnification bias. Rusin & Tegmark (2001) show that
such factors can increase the predicted fraction of quads at
modest magnifications by up to a factor of ∼ 2.
Statistical lensing constraints obtained from CLASS by
Chae (2002) suggest that the observed fraction of quad
lenses is consistent with an average lens ellipticity e ∼ 0.4,
and thus that many S0 and later lenses must be present to
match this ellipticity. Our results in Fig. 7 suggest that if
the majority of lens galaxies are indeed later than S0, then
the predicted fraction of quads is consistent with the obser-
vations.
In summary, these results indicate that the presence of
discs with constant mass-to-light ratio in ellipticals, is un-
likely to affect the population statistics of strong lens sys-
tems. However, inspecting the magnification maps on the
source plane shows that discs might have a significant effect
for individual lenses (Fig. 5). To investigate this further we
determined how much the magnification ratios of individual
lens systems are affected when a disc component is included
in the lens model.
5 MAGNIFICATION RATIOS
Attempts to model a number of known quad lens systems,
like B1422+231 and PG1115+080 have shown that smooth
power-law ellipsoidal models cannot fit both the observed
image positions and magnification ratios. This has been
generally interpreted as evidence for substructure in their
CDM haloes (Metcalf & Madau 2001; Bradac et al. 2002;
Chiba 2002; Dalal & Kochanek 2002; Metcalf & Zhao 2002).
The observational detection of substructure in dark matter
haloes would be of great importance for the standard model
of structure formation, which predicts such CDM substruc-
ture on galactic and sub-galactic scales (Moore et al. 1999).
If the presence of CDM halo substructure provides the only
possible explanation for the observed magnification ratios,
this would provide strong observational evidence in support
of the current CDM model. We now investigate whether
discs in early-type lens galaxies provide an alternative ex-
planation.
5.1 Causes for unusual magnification ratios
As pointed out by Mao & Schneider (1998), for point sources
that are highly magnified and split into 4 magnified images,
A, B, C and D, with B the brightest and D the faintest
image (cf. Fig. 4 in the previous section; note that we differ
here from the more conventional labelling, where images are
labelled A,B,C and D in order of decreasing brightness), the
individual image magnifications obey the relation
µAC/B ≡
µA + µC
µB
= 1,
(11)
in the limit of µtot → ∞. The loci of source positions at
which µtot is infinite form the caustic line, and so equa-
tion (11) holds for sources lying exactly on the caustic. What
is not known, however, is how well equation (11) holds for
8 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
Figure 4. Lensing of a point source by an elliptical galaxy with
and without a disc. The contours show the images of a point
source at zs = 1 that lies behind a lens galaxy with the same
properties as galaxy no. 242 in Table 1, convolved with a Gaus-
sian beam of 0.1 arcsec FWHM. The contour levels are 0.5, 3, 10,
20, and 30 in arbitrary flux units. The top panel shows the re-
sulting images for a bulge-only model. The bottom panel shows
the images for a bulge-plus-disc model, where the disc is inclined
at i = 75 deg to the line of sight. The major axis of both bulge
and disc is at 45 deg to the x-axis. The insets show the respective
0.2 arcsec × 0.2 arcsec magnification maps on the source plane.
The grey-scale is logarithmic and ranges from µ ∼ 2 (white) to
µ ∼ 200 (black). The source position is marked by a star in the
inset, and is slightly different in the two panels, to keep the image
geometry very similar and the total source magnification roughly
the same in both cases.
sources that lie close to the caustic, or, for sources of small
but finite size. In addition, it is not clear how the details of
the lensing potential will affect this behaviour close to the
caustics. The observed magnification ratios in systems like
B1422+231 grossly violate equation (11). This discrepancy is
the main reason why the observed magnification ratios are
generally regarded as strong evidence for CDM-halo sub-
structures with masses of the order of 106 − 107 M⊙, which
can strongly affect the flux of individual images if located
Figure 5. Lensing of an extended source by galaxies with and
without discs. The grey-scale shows the images of a small ex-
tended source of size ∼ 0.1 arcsec at zs = 1 that lies behind lens
galaxies with the properties of the labelled galaxies in Table A1.
The models in the right panels include a disc at an inclination
angle of i = 75 deg: the bulge and disc components are oriented
at 45 deg with respect to the x-axis in all cases. The left panels
show the corresponding images for bulge-only models.
close to the images. However, there are several other expla-
nations:
(i) microlensing. In many strong lens systems, microlens-
ing variability has been detected and it is difficult to exclude
the possibility of microlensing in the observed systems with
certainty.
(ii) differential extinction. There is a possibility that op-
tical flux ratios of the images are affected by different dust
columns along the lines of sight through the lensing galaxy.
(iii) the source is extended. Extended radio sources may
lead to very different magnification ratios in the observed im-
ages, depending on the size and relative brightness of the dif-
ferent source components. Recent simulations by Moustakas
& Metcalf (2003) suggest that even for extended sources
there is no change in the continuum magnification ratios
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
9
5.2 Known lens systems with unusual
magnification ratios
There have been two recent studies of lens systems with
unusual magnification ratios. In the comprehensive study
by Metcalf & Zhao (2002) 4 systems are listed where
the magnification ratios deviate by ∼ 0.1 mag or more
from the expected values assuming a one component
smooth ellipsoidal
lens with external shear; B1422+231,
PG1115+080, H1413+117 and Q2237+030. The first three
systems are quasars lensed by early-type galaxies while the
lens in Q2237+030 is a barred spiral. Of the four systems,
H1413+117 lies close to a cluster of galaxies which may cru-
cially affect the lensing potential (Kneib et al. 1998; Chae &
Turnshek 1999). Q2237+030 is lensed by a galaxy at a very
low redshift of z = 0.04 and microlensing affects the flux ra-
tios by up to a factor of two (Irwin et al. 1989; Wo´zniak et al.
2000). PG1115+080 and B1422+231 are affected only very
moderately if at all by microlensing (Vanderriest et al. 1986;
Yee & Bechtold 1996), but both reside very close to, or even
within, a galaxy group (Tonry 1998; Kundi´c et al. 1997a,b).
As shown by Moller et al. (2002), the presence of the group
can significantly alter the lensing behaviour and it is doubt-
ful whether a simple power-law-plus-shear model, as used
for example by Keeton, Kochanek & Seljak (1997) reflects
the true lensing potential adequately. For B1422+231 the
predicted and observed magnification ratios differ by up to
0.3 mag, as compared to only 0.1 mag for PG1115+080, and
so it is less likely that the discrepancy in B1422+231 is a re-
sult of the details of the group mass distribution surrounding
the lens. This points out B1422+231 as the strongest candi-
date for dark substructures: it is studied in great detail by
Bradac et al. (2002).
A recent theoretical study (Keeton, Gaudi & Petters
2002) investigated the magnification ratios of four caustic
lens systems in more detail, using an analysis similar to that
presented here but with a simple one-component lens model:
B2045+265, B0712+472, RX J0911+0551 and B1422+231
(Keeton, Gaudi & Petters 2002). RX J0911+0551 has only
optical and near-infrared flux measurements, and so the
extinction corrections for this source are highly uncertain.
B0712+472 is possibly affected by a foreground group (Fass-
nacht & Lubin 2002). Keck spectra of B2045+265 indicate
that it is likely to be a late-type lens (Fassnacht et al. 1999),
and so it is unlikely that a simple one-component model is
viable: a disc is almost certainly present. Note that only
B1422+231 was included in the study of Metcalf & Zhao
(2002).
The number of lens systems that are claimed to have
magnification ratios that can only be explained using com-
pact CDM substructure is rather large. In some cases, mi-
crolensing variability or differential extinction could be a
viable alternative explanation, but not for all.
We summarise the properties of all these lens systems
in Table 2. Together with the image fluxes, we list the mag-
nification ratios µAC/B and µABC/D ≡ (µA + µB + µC)/µD.
5.3 Magnification ratios for bulge-plus-disc
models of early-type lens galaxies
Figure 6. The ratio of the magnification cross sections. The
curves show the ratio of the cross sections, σb+d(µ > A)/σb(µ >
A), for total magnifications µ > A of a point source at zs = 1 as
a function of the threshold magnification, A. The different curves
are calculated by averaging over all the galaxies in Table A1 that
have the same morphological type. When a disc is included, the
inclination angle i = 75 deg in all cases.
Figure 7. The fraction of four-image lens systems as a function of
minimum magnification for different lens models. For each mor-
phological class of galaxies listed in Table A1 the average cross
section ratio σN=4/σtot is shown, where σN=4 is the cross section
for the formation of 4 images and σtot is the total cross section
for multiple imaging. The left panel shows the results for earlier
types, the right panel for later types. In all bulge-plus-disc mod-
els, a disc with the parameters as listed in Table A1 is included,
with an inclination angle i = 75 deg.
for smooth lens models; only the relative contributions from
broad and narrow lines is affected.
(iv) off-caustic sources. If the source does not lie exactly
on the caustic but is still magnified strongly, then the mag-
nification ratios will not necessarily obey equation (11).
We now investigate the validity of the last explanation in
the context of discs in early-type lensing galaxies.
To answer the question whether discs in early-type lenses
could explain some or all of the observed magnification ra-
10 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
Table 2. Summary of observed quad systems with unusual magnification ratios. 1 Christian, Crabtree & Waddell 1987. The fluxes are
normalized to image D. 2 Jackson et al. 1998. The listed values are for the Merlin 1996 5 GHz data. 3 Fassnacht et al. 1999. The listed
values correspond to the VLA 8.5GHz data. 4Patnaik et al. 1999. The listed values correspond to the VLA 8.5GHz data. 5 Chae &
Turnshek 1999. All images have been relabelled to correspond to the convention adopted in other systems. 6 Falco et al. 1996. All images
have been relabelled to correspond to the convention adopted in other systems. 7 Burud et al. 1998. The fluxes are normalized to image
A.
System
PG1115+0801
B0712+4722
B2045+2653
B1422+2314
H1413+1175
Q2237+0306
RX J0911+05517
FA
FB
FC
FD
µAC/B
µABC/D
2.49±0.03
10.5±0.1mJy
18.4±0.3mJy
152±2
1.65±0.16
78±14 µJy
1.0
3.22±0.03
8.5±0.1mJy
9.42±0.3mJy
164±2
1.62±0.16
60±14 µJy
0.965±0.013
0.64±0.03
4.7±0.1mJy
14.8±0.3mJy
81±1
1.0
85±14 µJy
0.544±0.025
1.0
0.9±0.1mJy
2.41±0.3 mJy
5±0.5
0.67±0.1
43±14 µJy
0.458±0.004
0.98±0.1
1.78±0.03
3.5±0.1
1.42±0.03
1.63±0.16
2.7±0.8
1.60±0.08
6.35±0.1
26.3±2.1
17.7±2.1
79.4±7.9
6.1±0.6
5.2±2.4
5.48±0.28
tios, we computed all the image multiplicities, position and
magnifications for all sources on a 400 × 400 pixel grid for
our particular representative model galaxy (galaxy no. 242).
We performed the calculations both on a low-resolution grid
that contained the whole caustic structure and on a smaller,
higher resolution grid, that contained one of the cusps along
the major axis of the lens galaxy. For both grids, we se-
lected all sources with quad images, yielding a total sample
of about 40000 simulated image systems.
Fig. 8 shows a scatter plot of the ratio of the sum of
the magnifications of the outer two images to the central
image µAC/B, versus the ratio of the total magnification of
the brightest three images, A-C to the magnification of the
faintest image D, µABC/D. The points in the upper panel are
for the pure-bulge model, whereas the points in the lower
panel are for the bulge-plus-disc model. For large magnifica-
tion ratios there is a significant difference. All the images of
sources with high total magnifications, corresponding to a
high µABC/D ratio, scatter around µAC/B ∼ 1 for the bulge-
only models. For large µ the scatter of a few per cent equals
that expected from numerical uncertainties in the simula-
tions, due to small deviations in the deflection angle that
lead to large deviations in the source position and images
occasionally being missed or associated with a wrong source
position. Note that there are two distinct and well defined
'populations' of images, corresponding to images in the two
different types of cusp regions (see Fig. 9). The two panels
of Fig. 9 show quantitatively how much the image magni-
fication ratios deviate from equation (11) as a function of
source position, both for the bulge-plus-disc model (upper
panel) and the bulge-only model (lower panel). These maps
are similar overall, but differ significantly in the two cusps
that are aligned with the disc: when a disc is present, im-
ages of sources that lie very close to these cusps have mag-
nification ratios that are inconsistent with the predictions
of equation (11). The images that are produced by sources
that lie close to these two cusps form the second population
of images in the bottom panel of Fig. 8.
As an example, Fig. 4 illustrates the behaviour for
sources in the lower-left cusp of our model. By comparing
the relative fluxes of the images in the top and bottom pan-
els of Fig. 4, one can see by eye that the sum of the fluxes
of the images A and C is roughly equal to the flux of image
B in the bulge only model, but not in the bulge-plus-disc
model. The relative positions and flux ratios of the images
Figure 8. Scatter diagrams of magnification ratios for quad im-
ages of point sources lensed by a model galaxy with parameters
matching galaxy no. 242 in Table 1. The markers in the upper
panel show the magnification ratios between images produced by
the bulge-only model, whereas the markers in the bottom panel
show the results for the bulge-plus-disc model. For total magnifi-
cations below 20 only 10 per cent of all simulated image systems
are shown. Note that the images in the bulge-plus-disc case fall
into two regions, whereas all the images produced by pure-bulge
models obey equation (11) in the limit of µABC/D → 1. The large
markers indicate the magnification ratios for the observed systems
with the 1σ error, as listed in Table 2. A small scatter of about
10 per cent is introduced at high µ due to numerical uncertainties.
A,B and C in the lower panel of that figure are very close
to those observed in B1422+231.
Figs 8 and 9 show the difference between the bulge and
bulge-plus-disc models. In the bulge-plus-disc model a set of
sources exists with an image magnification ratio µAC/B very
different from one, even for high magnifications of µABC/D ∼
50. All these sources lie inside one of the two cusps along the
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
11
Figure 10. Scatter diagrams of magnification ratios for quad
images of point sources lensed by a model galaxy with parameters
as in the Fig. 9, but with a heavier disc that has twice the size.
The symbols are in the previous plot.
lensed by a spiral galaxy, and so our early-type lens model
with a very modest disc would not be expected to provide a
good fit.
In Fig. 10 we show magnification ratios for about 40000
simulated image systems (without using a second higher-
resolution grid) for a bulge-plus-disc model with a disc that
has a scale-length twice that of the previous bulge-plus-disc
model. All the other parameters are unchanged and corre-
spond to galaxy no. 242. The effect of increasing the disc
mass is to substantially increase the µAC/B ratio for image
systems with magnifications µABC/D ∼ 20. The magnifica-
tion ratio of B2045+265 is now consistent with the predicted
value.
We conclude that the presence of an inclined disc com-
ponent containing of order 5 per cent of the total mass can
describe all of the known early-type lens systems with un-
usual magnification ratios without requiring compact sub-
structure in the lens halo.
5.4 Effect of disc size, disc inclination, bulge
ellipticity and a dark halo
We have used a particular model galaxy (§ 2) as a lens. In
order to make sure that our results apply in general to bulge-
plus-disc models of early-type galaxies and are not specific to
our particular choice of parameters we investigated a range
of other models. The full parameter space for bulge-plus-disc
models is large and a detailed study is beyond the scope of
this paper. We investigated the dependence on several pa-
rameters qualitatively. We find that, qualitatively, any disc
that on its own produces a caustic of similar or larger size
than that produced by the bulge is effective at modifying
the image properties. In practice that means any disc that
is inclined by more than 60 deg with a scale-length of the
order of the size of the caustic of the corresponding bulge-
only model. For nearly spherical bulges, discs with smaller
scale-lengths are also effective, and naturally produce mag-
Figure 9. Maps of the magnification ratio [(µA + µC)/µB − 1]−1
as a function of source position. The upper panel is for the bulge-
only model, the lower panel for the bulge-plus-disc model. Large
values (dark shades) indicate that the magnification ratios of the
images of a source at that position obey equation (11). Small val-
ues (light shades) indicate that the image magnification ratios
deviate from that relation. Note that Fig. 4 shows an example
configuration for sources lying in the bottom left cusp.
major axis. Note that for all those images, the faintest image
D lies at a large distance of ∼ 1.2 arcsec from the centre of
the lensing galaxy and is not demagnified. This reflects the
high total magnification of a source which lies close to the
caustic line.
Some unusual observed magnification ratios of some ob-
served lens systems are indicated by the large symbols in
Fig. 8. Error bars indicate the 1-σ flux measurement errors
(Table 2). Only H1413+117 and RXJ0911+0551 lie in re-
gions of the diagram that are consistent with a bulge-only
model.
However, the bulge-plus-disc model is clearly consistent
with the magnification ratios for PG1115+080, H1413+117,
RX J0911+0551, B0712+472, Q2237+030 and B1422+231.
B2045+265 is the only system for which our model cannot
reproduce the observed magnification ratios. This source is
12 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
nification ratios similar to those observed for B1422+231.
For disc sizes below 0.2 arcsec, the disc inclination must be
increased beyond i = 80 deg to obtain magnification ratios
consistent with B1422+231. Even an edge-on disc smaller
than 0.1 arcsec cannot reproduce the magnification ratios of
B1422+231. There is also the possibility of misalignment
between the positions of the disc and the bulge/halo. Such
misalignments are to be expected as a result of recent merger
events and may lead to complicated and unusual lensing con-
figurations and provide more extreme changes in the magni-
fication ratios, as discussed by Quadri, Moller & Natarajan
(2002).
We have also investigated models with a CDM halo.
Adding a singular CDM halo, containing 2/3 of the total
mass within an Einstein radius, and adjusting the mass nor-
malization of the bulge and disc so as to keep the Einstein
radius constant, does not significantly alter the effect of the
disc. It is purely the presence of a thin disc structure in
combination with a more spherical mass component that
produces the change in magnification ratios.
5.5 Expected number of affected systems
Moller & Blain (1998) have shown that discs in spiral galax-
ies are important for the statistical effects on lensing cross
sections only at inclination angles of ≥ 60 deg. Assuming
that a fraction of 50 − 100 per cent of all early-type lens
galaxies do contain discs, 15 − 35 per cent will contain discs
with inclination angles of ≥ 60 deg. A conservative estimate
of the fraction of early-type lens systems in which discs may
be important is thus ∼ 10 − 30 per cent. This fraction is
consistent with the number of CLASS quad lens systems
with deviant magnification ratios: of the 7 CLASS quad
lenses, at least two early-type lens system (B1422+231 and
B0712+472) exhibit magnification ratios inconsistent with
simple power-law plus external-shear models.
An additional factor to consider is magnification bias.
Depending on the bulge-to-disc ratio, the disc may lead to
higher cross sections for strong magnifications, as shown in
Fig. 6. This could bias a flux-limited sample towards lens
galaxies that contain discs. However, as shown in Fig. 6, the
cross section is not increased significantly for E/S0/Sa galax-
ies, and so the magnification bias is likely to be small.
5.6 Distinguishing the effect of discs and CDM
substructure
The results described in this section demonstrate that discs
in early-type lensing galaxies may explain some of the ob-
served magnification ratios that have hitherto only been ex-
plained assuming CDM substructure. There are some key
observational differences between these two scenarios.
First, discs in early-type lens galaxies are, in principle,
detectable by bulge-plus-disc light profile decompositions as
discussed in § 2. However, the light of the background quasar
makes accurate photometry of lens galaxies extremely dif-
ficult in practice. Treu & Koopmans (2002) obtained kine-
matic information of a lensing galaxy from spectroscopic ob-
servations, and demonstrated that it is thus possible to ob-
tain additional constraints on its mass distribution. It might
be possible to constrain possible disc structures in lensing
galaxies in this way.
Secondly, disc structures significantly affect only the
magnification ratios of sources that lie within one of the two
cusps along the discs. Assuming that discs are oriented along
the major axis of the bulge ellipticity, this means that disc
structures provide an explanation of discrepant magnifica-
tion ratios only for quad image systems with three strongly
magnified images along a line perpendicular to the major
axis of the lens galaxy, whereas CDM substructure could
modify any image configuration. Note that this is not true
for late-type lenses with extended inclined discs, in which
the caustic structures are completely dominated by the disc,
and the disc strongly affects the magnification ratios of quad
systems produced by sources in any one of the four cusps.
We stress that these results do not prove the existence
of discs in early-type lensing galaxies, nor do we propose
that such disc structures provide the only explanation for
all the observed magnification ratios. For all systems, the
observed magnification ratios could be caused by CDM sub-
structures. We have not carried out detailed modelling of any
of the observed systems, and our analysis does not include
joint fitting to both magnification ratios and image posi-
tions. However, in contrast to Keeton et al. (2002) we find
that magnification ratios alone do not provide conclusive ev-
idence for the presence of CDM halo substructure: realistic
disc structures can explain the observed magnification ra-
tios equally well. Detailed case-by-case lens modelling using
bulge-plus-disc models is now needed to verify that early-
type galaxies with disc structures are indeed viable models
for all or at least some of the observed lens systems. The fact
that discs affect image positions very slightly, even for a fixed
source position, indicate that detailed bulge-plus-disc mod-
els are likely to be successful in fitting magnification ratios
and image positions.
6 EFFECT ON HUBBLE PARAMETER
ESTIMATION
Strong gravitational lensing of variable background quasars
provides a unique method to determine the Hubble constant.
Brightness fluctuations are observed at different times at
each image as the path lengths and gravitational time delays
to each image depend on its relative position and the local
lensing potential. If the image positions and lensing poten-
tial are known, then H0 can be determined, as ∆t ∝ 1/H0.
Gravitational and geometric time delays are often of roughly
equal magnitude, and so an accurate knowledge of the lens-
ing potential is crucial to deduce an accurate value of H0.
Lens systems with measured time delays are nearly
always associated with early-type lens galaxies, although
B1600+434 (Koopmans et al. 2000) and B0218+357 (Wuck-
nitz, priv. comm.) are notable exceptions. These systems
have been modelled using bulge-only models, with a con-
stant external shear in some cases.
We now investigate how a disc component is likely to
affect time delays for the bulge and bulge-plus-disc model
of galaxy no. 242. The time delay between two images at ~θ1
and ~θ2 of a source at ~β is
∆t =
DOSDOL
cDLS
(1+zl)(cid:20) (~β − ~θ1)2 − (~β − ~θ2)2
2
− ∆ψb + ∆ψd(cid:21) ,(12)
where DOL is the angular diameter distances between ob-
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
13
Figure 12. Histogram of time delays. This plot shows the ex-
pected relative fraction of systems as a function of timedelay be-
tween images B and D. The left panel shows the statistics for
the regions marked I in Fig. 11 and the right panel the statis-
tics for the regions marked II. The histograms are shown for our
bulge-plus-disc and bulge-only lens galaxy model (see § 2). Note
that the time delay is smaller for bulge-only systems, due to the
shallower potential.
Figure 13. Histogram of the separations of images. This plot
shows the expected relative fraction of systems as a function of
separation. Note that the separation is larger for bulge-only sys-
tems, due to the higher mass in the central region.
to unity. Comparing the histograms in the right panel of
Fig. 12, there is no significant difference between the bulge-
plus-disc and bulge-only model time-delay statistics in the
cusps away from the disc (the regions marked II on Fig. 11).
However, the histograms in the left panel of Fig. 12 show
that the time delays in the cusps lying along the disc are in-
creased by ∼ 20 per cent for the bulge-plus-disc model with
respect to the bulge-only model. The overall distribution for
the bulge only model is shifted towards shorter time delays
with respect to the bulge-plus-disc models. Assuming that
an elliptical lens galaxy that contains a disc is modelled us-
ing a bulge-only model, this suggests that the Hubble con-
stant will be underestimated systematically.
In Fig. 13 we show explicitly that disc components al-
ter the individual image positions only very slightly for our
model galaxy no. 242. The figure shows the distribution of
Figure 11. Time delay as function of source position. The two
maps show the time delays between images B and D (cf. Fig. 4)
for all quad geometries for model galaxy no.242. The left panel
shows the results for the bulge-only model and the right panel the
results for the bulge-plus-disc model. The boxes in the left panel
mark the different cusp regions, as discussed in the text.
server and lens. The distances and thus ∆t are proportional
to H −1
0 . The lens redshift is zl and the potentials due to
bulge and disc components are ψb and ψd respectively. In
§ 4 we pointed out that the shift in image positions between
bulge-plus-disc and bulge-only models for E and E/S0 type
lensing galaxies is expected to be very small.
We are concerned here with the effects of modelling an
early-type lens that contains a disc with a bulge-only model.
Since the lens models are obtained from fits to the image
positions, the image positions remain the same irrespective
of the model used. Therefore, the geometrical time delay of
a given pair of images is not affected by a disc component;
any change in the time delay is due to the change in the
potential at the image positions.
Note that compact CDM substructure does not affect
time-delays measurably.
6.1 Four-image/quad systems
About half of the known lens systems with measured time
delays are quad systems. Since the quad caustic structure is
the region in the source plane that is most strongly affected
by the presence of a disc, the greatest effect of a disc on
time delays is expected in these systems. In most cases a
single time delay is measured, usually between the image
pair with the largest separation. Using our ray-tracing code
in combination with equation (12) we calculated the time
delays between images B and D for all quad systems of the
model galaxy described in § 2. Fig. 11 shows the time delays
as a function of source position for bulge-plus-disc and bulge-
only models. The difference is on the order of a few tens of
per cent, and is largest in the cusps lying along the disc (the
regions marked I). Especially in the cusp regions close to
the caustic, where the image magnification is greatest, the
time delays for the bulge-plus-disc model are 20−30 per cent
larger than for the bulge-only model.
The time-delay statistics for regions I and II are shown
in Fig. 12. For each region in Fig. 11 the time delays are
divided into 50 bins and the histograms are normalized
14 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
Figure 14. Histogram of time delays for 2-image systems. This
plot shows the expected relative fraction of systems as a function
of time-delay between the two images in 2-image lens systems.
The histograms are shown for our bulge-plus-disc and bulge-only
lens galaxy model as described in § 2.
image separations for both models. The images are system-
atically further apart in the bulge-only models, suggesting a
larger mass inside the Einstein radius and thus a larger pre-
dicted time delay, if the radial profile of the potential is unaf-
fected. In observed lens systems, the lens would be modelled
to fit the image configurations, and so a bulge-only model
fitted to the observed image separations would contain less
mass within the Einstein radius than the bulge-only model
with the time delay distribution shown in Fig. 12. This would
shift the time-delay distributions shown in Fig. 12 for the
bulge-only model to even lower time delays. The only pos-
sibility both to fit the image separations and obtain similar
distribution of time delays is by changing the gradient of
the potential between the images. For point sources, the
only other lensing property that is sensitive to the shape
of the potential is the magnification ratio between the im-
ages. Thus, if magnification ratios are not used to constrain
lens models, then bulge-only models might fit the image po-
sitions of a lens that actually consists of a bulge-plus-disc
lens, yielding an incorrect mass model and an H0 value that
is systematically too low by up to 25 per cent.
6.2 Two-image systems
Quad lens systems are generally regarded as being more
useful than 2-image systems for H0 determinations because
more constraints on the lensing potential are available. How-
ever, many 2-image lens systems have been used for time de-
lay measurements. In these cases, the source lies outside the
diamond-shaped caustic, where magnifications µ ∼ 2 − 10.
These images are expected to be affected only weakly by a
disc component.
We have calculated the time delays for 2-image systems
and show the corresponding statistics in Fig. 14. Comparison
with Fig. 12 shows that the effect of a disc component on the
time delay is much smaller for 2-image systems than for quad
systems. A number of 2-image systems with measured time
delays, like B0218+357 (Biggs et al. 1999) have possible disc
structures, but even if these are present, our results indicate
that the the effect on estimates of H0 is small. Note that
recent observations (Wucknitz, private comm.) indicate that
the lens in B0218+357 is a spiral galaxy. Massive discs, as
expected in spiral lenses, may affect the time delays much
more strongly.
6.3 Parameter dependence
The results in this and the preceding section show that any
inclined discs within elliptical lens galaxies affect sources
in the cusps lying along the disc most strongly, whereas the
effect on the cusps lying away from the disc is small. We have
not checked the dependence of the time-delay statistics on
the disc parameters in detail, but the dependence is similar
to that discussed in § 5.4 since magnification ratios and time
delays are both sensitive on changes in the cusps. The results
we obtained in that section also hold for the time delays.
Disc structures are important if they are inclined at i >
60 deg to the line of sight and are massive/extended enough
to produce a caustic of a size that is of the order of the
caustic produced by the bulge. That is typically the case
for discs larger than rhd > 0.6kpc and with masses of at
least ∼ 5 per cent of the bulge, for which time delays will
be increased by a few tens of per cent relative to bulge-only
models.
6.4 The effect on estimates on H0
Our approach here only gives a rough indication of how de-
terminations of H0 are affected by disc structures. To be
any more quantitative about the uncertainties that arise it
is necessary to perform detailed modelling of known systems
using bulge and bulge-plus-disc models, which is difficult and
time-consuming. However, our results offer a possible reso-
lution as to why there is a significant discrepancy between
determinations of H0 from CMB data (Lewis & Bridle 2002),
the HST Key-project (Freedman et al. 2001) and gravita-
tional lensing (Kochanek 2003).
The effect of disc structures on time-delays is much
more significant for quad systems than for 2-image sys-
tems. In addition, we expect that there will be a correla-
tion between low-H0 results and unusual magnification ra-
tios if discs are present. This seems to be the case: Biggs
et al. (1999) derive H0 = 69+13
−19 km s−1 Mpc−1 for the 2-
image system B0218+357, whereas Impey et al. (1998) ob-
tain H0 = 44±4 km s−1 Mpc−1 for PG1115+080, a quad sys-
tem with unusual magnification ratios. The errors on the H0
estimate by Biggs et al. (1999) have recently been disputed
by Lehar et al.(2000) and Wucknitz, Biggs & Browne (MN-
RAS, submitted). More recent single-component models of
PG1115+080 by Treu & Koopmans (2002) give a higher
value of H0 = 59+12
−7 ± 3 km s−1 Mpc−1. The larger errors are
statistical, and the smaller error of ±3 is an estimate of the
systematic error. No other quad systems with measured time
delays have unusual magnification ratios, and the values of
H0 determined from these systems are generally higher.
7 CONCLUSIONS
Gravitational lensing plays a role of ever increasing impor-
tance in determining cosmological parameters, notably H0,
and constraining the dark matter distribution on a variety of
scales. More than 50 strong gravitational lens systems are
known. Generally, it is not possible to constrain the mass
distribution of the lensing galaxy uniquely, due to the de-
generacies present. Whether this uncertainty in models has
serious implications for cosmological parameter estimation
from strong lensing is still unclear.
The majority of all lensing galaxies have been classified
as massive early-type galaxies. Reliable photometric deter-
mination of the presence of a disc component is difficult due
to the usually very bright lensed quasar images. Therefore,
discs similar to those discussed in this paper would not gen-
erally have been identified in existing images. However, ob-
servations of early-type galaxies in the local universe and in
the moderate-redshift cluster CL 1358+62 suggest strongly
that a large fraction of early-type galaxies contain disc-like
structures.
We have investigated how the lensing properties of
early-type galaxies would change if a thin disc component
that contains about 5 per cent of the mass is included:
(i) If early-type galaxies contain disc components, the sta-
tistical lensing properties of early-type lensing galaxies are
affected by less than about 5 per cent. Only if the major-
ity of lensing galaxies are of S0/Sa or later types would the
expected relative number of quad to 2-image lens systems
increase by a factor of 2 or more.
(ii) A disc component in early-type lensing galaxies af-
fects significantly the expected magnification ratios of highly
magnified quad systems. If a disc component is present in
the lens and inclined at more than ∼ 70 deg to the line of
sight, the resulting image configurations and magnification
ratios can resemble that of systems like B1422+231.
(iii) Time delays may be affected significantly by the pres-
ence of a disc component in individual early-type lens galax-
ies. Bulge-only lens models used to fit bulge-plus-disc lenses
fit lensed image positions well, but would yield a value for
H0 that is systematically low by about 25 per cent.
The presence of inclined exponential discs in early-type
lensing galaxies affect the lensing properties of quad lens sys-
tems significantly. Assuming that the majority of all early-
type lens galaxies contain discs, then both the time delays
and magnification ratios are expected to be affected by disc
components in 10 − 30 per cent of all quad lens systems. One
or two of the quad lenses identified by CLASS is expected to
be affected (consistent with the properties of B1422+231).
Bulge-plus-disc models provide an alternative explanation
to the observed magnification ratios and lead to systemat-
ically longer time-delays. In order to obtain more stringent
constraints on the presence of CDM substructure in the lens
and on the effect of discs on H0 measurements, detailed lens
modelling of known lens systems will be necessary. Fitting
models that include exponential discs to real lens systems is
much more computationally intensive than the calculations
performed here, but may be possible.
We have discussed the first order effect of discs in early-
type galaxies on observed lensing properties. Once a large
number of lens systems is known, it might also be possible to
use lensing to constrain the masses and parameters of those
systems. Determining the abundance and properties of discs
in ellipticals in more detail, and at different redshifts, using
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
15
gravitational lensing would shed new light on the details of
the formation of discs in early-type galaxies.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
OM acknowledges financial support from a European Com-
munity Marie Curie Fellowship. We thank Konrad Kuijken
and the referee for helpful comments on the manuscript.
REFERENCES
Abraham R. G., van den Bergh S., 2001, Science, 293, 1273
Barnes J. E., 2002, MNRAS, 333, 481
Bender R., Surma P., Doebereiner S., Moellenhoff C., Madejsky
R., 1989, A&A, 217, 35
Bennett C. L., et al., 2003, ApJ, submitted, astro-ph/0302207.
Benjamin R. A., Danly L., 1997, ApJ, 481, 764
Biggs A. D., Browne I. W. A., Helbig P., Koopmans L. V. E.,
Wilkinson P. N., Perley R. A., 1999, MNRAS, 304, 349
Binney J., Tremaine S., 1987, "Galactic dynamics". Princeton,
NJ, Princeton University Press, 1987, p747
Blain A. W., Moller O., Maller A. H., 1999, MNRAS, 303, 423
Bradac M., Schneider P., Steinmetz M., Lombardi M., King L. J.,
Porcas R., 2002, A&A, 388, 373
Burud I., Courbin F., Lidman C., Jaunsen A. O., Hjorth J., Os-
tensen R., Andersen M. I., Clasen J. W., et al., 1998, ApJ,
501, L5
Byun Y. I., Freeman K. C., 1995, ApJ, 448, 563
Chae K., Turnshek D. A., 1999, ApJ, 514, 587
Chae K.-H., 2002, MNRAS, submitted (astro-ph/0211244)
Chiba M., 2002, ApJ, 565, 17
Christian C. A., Crabtree D., Waddell P., 1987, ApJ, 312, 45
Dalal N., Kochanek C. S., 2002, ApJ, 572, 25
de Zeeuw P. T., Bureau M., Emsellem E., Bacon R., Marcella
Carollo C., Copin Y., Davies R. L., Kuntschner H., et al.,
2002, MNRAS, 329, 513
Falco E. E., Lehar J., Perley R. A., Wambsganss J., Gorenstein
M. V., 1996, AJ, 112, 897
Fassnacht C. D., et al., 1999, AJ, 117, 658
Fassnacht C. D., Lubin L. M., 2002, AJ, 123, 627
Ferguson A. M. N., Clarke C. J., 2001, MNRAS, 325, 781
Freedman W. L., et al., 2001, ApJ, 553, 47
Impey C. D., Falco E. E., Kochanek C. S., Leh´ar J., McLeod
B. A., Rix H.-W., Peng C. Y., Keeton C. R., 1998, ApJ, 509,
551
Irwin M. J., Webster R. L., Hewett P. C., Corrigan R. T., Jedrze-
jewski R. I., 1989, AJ, 98, 1989
Jackson N., et al., 1998, MNRAS, 296, 483
Keeton C. R., Kochanek C. S., Seljak U., 1997, ApJ, 482, 604
Keeton C. S., Gaudi B. S., Petters A. O., 2002, ApJ, submitted
(astro-ph/0210318)
Kelson D. D., Illingworth G. D., van Dokkum P. G., Franx M.,
2000, ApJ, 531, 137
Kneib J. P., Alloin D., Mellier Y., Guilloteau S., Barvainis R.,
Antonucci R., 1998, A&A, 329, 827
Kochanek C. S., 2003, ApJ, 583, 49
Koopmans L. V. E., de Bruyn A. G., Jackson N., 1998, MNRAS,
295, 534
Koopmans L. V. E., de Bruyn A. G., Xanthopoulos E., Fassnacht
C. D., 2000, A&A, 356, 391
Koopmans L. V. E., Treu T., 2003, ApJ, 583, 606
Kundi´c T., Hogg D. W., Blandford R. D., Cohen J. G., Lubin
L. M., Larkin J. E., 1997a, AJ, 114, 2276
16 Ole Moller, P. Hewett & A.W. Blain
Kundi'c T., Turner E. L., Colley W. N., Gott J. R. I., Rhoads
J. E., Wang Y., Bergeron L. E., Gloria K. A., et al., 1997b,
ApJ, 482, 75
Lewis A., Bridle S. L., 2002, Phys. Rev. D, 66, 10
Leh´ar J., Falco E. E., Kochanek C. S., McLeod B. A., Munoz
J. A., Impey C. D., Rix H.- W., Keeton C. R., et al., 2000,
ApJ, 536, 584
Maller A. H., Flores R. A., Primack J. R., 1997, ApJ, 486, 681
Mao S., Mo H. J., White S. D. M., 1998, MNRAS, 297, L71
Mao S., Schneider P., 1998, MNRAS, 295, 587
Metcalf R. B., Madau P., 2001, ApJ, 563, 9
Metcalf R. B., Zhao H., 2002, ApJ, 567, L5
Mo H. J., Mao S., White S. D. M., 1998, MNRAS, 295, 319
Moller O., Blain A. W., 1998, MNRAS, 299, 845
Moller O., Blain A. W., 2001, MNRAS, 327, 339
Moller O., Natarajan P., Kneib J., Blain A. W., 2002, ApJ, 573,
562
Moriondo G., Giovanardi C., Hunt L. K., 1998, A&A, 319, 409
Moore B., Ghigna S., Governato F., Lake G., Quinn T., Stadel
J., Tozzi P., 1999, ApJ, 524, L19
Moustakas L. A., Metcalf R. B., 2003, MNRAS, 339, 607
Naab T., Burkert A., 2001, ApJ, 555, L91
Natarajan P., Kneib J.-P., Smail I., Ellis R. S., 1998, ApJ, 499,
600
Patnaik A. R., Kemball A. J., Porcas R. W., Garrett M. A., 1999,
MNRAS, 307, L1
Putman M. E., et al., 2002, AJ, 123, 873
Quadri R., Moller O., Natarajan P., 2002, ApJ, submitted
Rest A., van den Bosch F. C., Jaffe W., Tran H., Tsvetanov Z.,
Ford H. C., Davies J., Schafer J., 2001, AJ, 121, 2431
Rix H.-W., White S. D. M., 1990, ApJ, 362, 52
Rix H.-W., 1991, Ph.D. Thesis
Romanowsky A. J., Kochanek C. S., 1997, MNRAS, 287, 35
Rusin D., Tegmark M., 2001, ApJ, 553, 709
Saha A., Sandage A., Tammann G. A., Dolphin A. E., Christenses
J., Panagia N., Macchetto F. D., 2001, ApJ, 562, 314
Scorza C., Bender R., 1995, A&A, 293, 20
Scorza C., Bender R., Winkelmann C., Capaccioli M., Macchetto
D. F., 1998, A&A Supp, 131, 265
Simard L., Koo D. C., Faber S. M., Sarajedini V. L., Vogt N. P.,
Phillips A. C., Gebhardt K., Illingworth G. D., et al., 1999,
ApJ, 519, 563
Somerville R. S., Primack J. R., 1999, MNRAS, 310, 1087
Steinmetz M., Muller E., 1995, MNRAS, 276, 549
Tonry J. L., 1998, AJ, 115, 1
Tran H. D., Tsvetanov Z., Ford H. C., Davies J., Jaffe W., van
den Bosch F. C., Rest A., 2001, AJ, 121, 2928
Tran K.-V., Simard L., Illingworth G., Franx M., 2003, ApJ, in
press, astro-ph/0302292
Treu T., Koopmans L. V. E., 2002, MNRAS, 337, 6
van Dokkum P. G., Stanford S. A., 2001, ApJ, 562, L35
Vanderriest C., Wlerick G., Lelievre G., Schneider J., Sol H.,
Horville D., Renard L., Servan B., 1986, A&A, 158, L5
Wo´zniak P. R., Alard C., Udalski A., Szyma´nski M., Kubiak M.,
Pietrzy´nski G., Zebru´n K., 2000, ApJ, 529, 88
Yee H. K. C., Bechtold J., 1996, AJ, 111, 1007
APPENDIX A: GALAXIES IN CL 1358+62
All the galaxies for which Kelson et al. (2000) provides sur-
face brightness profile information are employed in our cal-
culation of certain statistical properties, like the high magni-
fication cross sections in §4.2. For completeness, we present
here the surface brightness profile parameters for all the
galaxies.
Discs in early-type lens galaxies
17
←−
Bulge only
−→ ←−
Bulge and disc
No. Type < Ih >
rh
Σb
Re
< Ih >
rh
Σb < Ihd >
rd
Σd
Re
fe
212
242
256
303
360
375
409
412
531
534
536
233
269
309
353
381
493
095
135
182
211
215
236
298
300
343
359
408
410
463
481
110
129
142
164
292
335
366
369
397
423
440
454
523
209
328
356
368
371
372
465
549
234
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E/S0
E/S0
E/S0
E/S0
E/S0
E/S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
S0/a
Sa
Sa
Sa
Sab
Sa
Sa
Sa
Sab
Sb
20.780
21.920
20.880
20.590
20.220
22.860
21.270
21.390
21.260
21.210
21.180
20.400
20.390
20.020
21.050
20.340
19.980
20.940
20.450
20.460
20.120
20.660
21.100
19.690
19.840
20.540
20.260
19.820
20.670
20.430
20.250
19.450
19.930
21.400
22.620
20.320
20.860
20.790
21.860
20.500
21.610
22.450
20.420
21.640
20.650
20.720
20.200
21.100
21.040
21.920
21.010
21.920
21.860
0.683
1.529
1.380
0.638
0.341
4.979
0.498
0.767
1.549
0.620
1.266
0.784
0.962
0.502
1.120
0.512
0.193
0.704
0.418
0.355
0.448
0.457
0.776
0.554
0.453
0.404
0.574
0.382
0.488
0.639
0.260
0.350
0.489
0.834
2.251
0.486
0.539
0.630
1.036
0.409
1.021
1.108
0.595
1.044
0.625
0.666
0.604
0.542
0.956
1.435
0.609
0.866
0.996
0.488
0.171
0.445
0.581
0.817
0.072
0.310
0.278
0.313
0.328
0.337
0.692
0.698
0.982
0.380
0.731
1.019
0.421
0.661
0.655
0.895
0.545
0.363
1.330
1.159
0.608
0.787
1.180
0.540
0.673
0.794
1.660
1.067
0.275
0.090
0.745
0.453
0.483
0.180
0.631
0.227
0.105
0.679
0.221
0.550
0.515
0.832
0.363
0.384
0.171
0.394
0.171
0.180
1.220
1.360
2.330
1.270
2.176
2.650
2.176
2.176
2.090
0.860
1.790
1.740
2.150
1.370
1.710
2.176
0.540
1.150
0.900
0.760
1.160
2.176
1.150
1.810
2.176
0.830
1.380
1.160
0.930
2.176
2.176
1.300
1.400
1.030
1.250
1.130
0.920
1.120
0.960
0.860
1.110
0.690
1.310
1.110
1.200
1.230
1.500
2.176
1.470
1.280
0.950
0.770
0.920
21.170
22.420
21.200
21.110
21.660
23.010
21.490
22.320
21.710
22.170
21.520
20.940
20.620
20.210
21.240
20.500
21.660
21.840
20.870
20.770
20.410
21.770
21.630
20.840
20.530
21.100
21.050
20.660
21.130
20.740
20.760
18.360
20.950
20.470
22.920
20.390
20.900
21.160
21.980
18.960
22.460
22.980
22.270
21.960
22.060
21.530
19.780
22.390
20.640
22.720
21.220
19.900
17.800
0.781
1.825
1.551
0.774
0.594
5.267
0.542
1.091
1.830
0.878
1.433
0.952
1.045
0.540
1.205
0.550
0.374
0.986
0.490
0.392
0.458
0.700
0.944
0.835
0.584
0.492
0.769
0.523
0.575
0.714
0.157
0.102
0.726
0.318
2.541
0.297
0.541
0.718
1.085
0.111
1.397
1.328
0.990
1.171
0.960
0.862
0.392
0.627
0.468
1.905
0.660
0.142
0.035
0.340
0.108
0.331
0.360
0.217
0.063
0.254
0.118
0.207
0.136
0.247
0.421
0.565
0.824
0.319
0.631
0.217
0.184
0.449
0.492
0.685
0.196
0.223
0.461
0.614
0.363
0.380
0.545
0.353
0.506
0.497
4.529
0.417
0.649
0.068
0.698
0.437
0.344
0.161
2.606
0.104
0.064
0.124
0.164
0.150
0.244
1.225
0.111
0.555
0.082
0.325
1.096
7.586
18.030
20.720
18.000
18.890
17.620
19.220
22.600
17.660
19.300
16.680
18.570
18.740
18.710
18.910
19.970
20.020
18.740
17.750
18.010
21.910
21.680
16.950
17.870
19.530
18.660
20.930
19.050
18.860
20.840
21.180
20.650
20.120
16.680
22.440
17.770
21.100
20.610
20.460
20.280
21.450
17.950
18.800
20.610
21.080
20.930
21.300
22.070
21.560
21.920
21.990
21.100
22.500
22.030
0.031
0.156
0.053
0.054
0.030
0.096
0.132
0.033
0.108
0.019
0.057
0.067
0.055
0.036
0.079
0.052
0.035
0.038
0.023
0.130
0.256
0.022
0.033
0.142
0.055
0.098
0.072
0.057
0.093
0.136
0.166
0.248
0.028
0.648
0.036
0.332
0.035
0.083
0.047
0.320
0.043
0.036
0.273
0.117
0.253
0.232
0.533
0.305
0.693
0.351
0.079
0.609
0.621
6.138
0.515
6.310
2.780
8.954
2.051
0.091
8.630
1.905
21.281
3.733
3.192
3.281
2.729
1.028
0.982
3.192
7.943
6.252
0.172
0.213
6.596
7.112
1.542
3.436
0.425
2.399
2.858
0.461
0.337
0.550
0.895
21.281
0.106
7.798
0.363
0.570
0.655
0.773
0.263
6.607
3.020
0.570
0.370
0.425
0.302
0.149
0.238
0.171
0.160
0.363
0.100
0.154
1.160
1.270
2.260
1.210
1.000
2.870
0.660
0.870
1.980
0.770
1.720
1.640
2.100
1.000
1.680
1.000
0.480
1.040
0.870
0.740
1.120
0.790
1.080
1.630
1.280
0.780
1.270
1.080
0.880
1.350
1.000
1.000
1.300
0.870
1.230
1.000
0.910
1.070
0.950
1.000
1.000
0.640
1.100
1.070
1.040
1.130
1.420
1.000
1.260
1.150
1.000
0.560
0.520
0.808
0.806
0.836
0.787
0.565
0.800
0.959
0.502
0.772
0.489
0.807
0.796
0.905
0.913
0.902
0.924
0.549
0.583
0.817
0.941
0.921
0.524
0.711
0.735
0.789
0.879
0.748
0.755
0.886
0.926
0.521
0.722
0.647
0.934
0.616
0.803
0.963
0.882
0.903
0.841
0.515
0.572
0.646
0.882
0.755
0.862
0.939
0.713
0.890
0.877
0.925
0.938
0.903
−→
ft
0.960
0.950
0.967
0.947
0.867
0.984
0.969
0.908
0.954
0.901
0.965
0.947
0.976
0.979
0.979
0.979
0.838
0.912
0.956
0.945
0.873
0.889
0.946
0.873
0.932
0.935
0.923
0.915
0.951
0.965
0.351
0.363
0.899
0.496
0.966
0.506
0.992
0.963
0.987
0.443
0.918
0.950
0.655
0.968
0.772
0.881
0.749
0.568
0.497
0.909
0.977
0.284
0.094
Table A1. Galaxies in CL 1358+62. The values for < Ib >, rb and < Ihd > are taken directly from Kelson et al. (2000). The disc scale
length rd is related to the half-light radius as given in Kelson et al. by rd = 1.688rhd. In a cosmology with ΩΛ = 0.7, ΩM = 0.3 and
H0 = 50 km s−1 Mpc−1, 1 arcsec corresponds to 6.6 kpc at a redshift of z = 0.33.
|
0802.2070 | 1 | 0802 | 2008-02-14T18:12:22 | Ages and metallicities of circumnuclear star formation regions from Gemini IFU observations | [
"astro-ph"
] | Aims: We derive the age and metallicity of circumnuclear star formation regions (CNSFRs) located in the spiral galaxies NGC6951 and NGC1097, and investigate the cause of the very low equivalent widths of emission lines found for these regions.
Methods: We used optical two-dimensional spectroscopic data obtained with Gemini GMOS-IFUs and a grid of photoionization models to derive the the metallicities and ages of CNSFRs.
Results: We find star formation rates in the range 0.002-0.14 Msun/yr and oxygen abundance of 12+log(O/H)~8.8 dex, similar to those of most metal-rich nebulae located in the inner region of galactic disks.
Conclusions: We conclude that the very low emission-line equivalent widths observed in CNSFRs are caused by the ``contamination'' of the continuum by (1) contribution of the underlying bulge continuum combined with (2) contribution from previous episodes of star formation at the CNSFRs. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. dors
December 5, 2018
c(cid:13) ESO 2018
8
0
0
2
b
e
F
4
1
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
0
7
0
2
.
2
0
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
Ages and metallicities of circumnuclear star formation regions
from Gemini IFU observations
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, IF, CP 15051, Porto Alegre 91501-970, RS, Brazil.
Received 29 octubre 2007 / Accepted 28 january 2008
ABSTRACT
Aims. We derive the age and metallicity of circumnuclear star formation regions (CNSFRs) located in the spiral galaxies NGC 6951 and
NGC 1097, and investigate the cause of the very low equivalent widths of emission lines found for these regions.
Methods. We used optical two-dimensional spectroscopic data obtained with Gemini GMOS-IFUs and a grid of photoionization models to
derive the the metallicities and ages of CNSFRs.
Results.We find star formation rates in the range 0.002-0.14 M⊙ yr−1 and oxygen abundance of 12+log(O/H)≈8.8 dex, similar to those of most
metal-rich nebulae located in the inner region of galactic disks.
Conclusions. We conclude that the very low emission-line equivalent widths observed in CNSFRs are caused by the "contamination" of the
continuum by (1) contribution of the underlying bulge continuum combined with (2) contribution from previous episodes of star formation at
the CNSFRs.
Key words. Galaxy: abundances -- Galaxies: individual: NGC 6951, NGC 1097 -- ISM: abundances -- ISM: HII regions
1. Introduction
The pioneer works by Morgan (1958) and S´ersic & Pastoriza
(1967) have shown that many spiral galaxies host circumnu-
clear star formation regions (CNSFRs) and several works have
studied these regions. In one of the most recent works, Knapen
(2005) uses Hα images of a sample of spiral galaxies to study
CNSFRs, as well as nuclear star formation regions. They found
that CNSFRs are present in about 20% of spiral galaxies and al-
most always occur within a barred host. In this paper we adopt
the definition of Knapen (2005) to distinguish CNSFRs from
nuclear star formation regions: CNSFRs are the ones observed
within circular areas with diameters of a few kpc around the
galactic nucleus, while nuclear star formation regions are ob-
served in more internal areas a few hundred parsec across. In
particular, the formation of CNSFRs in barred galaxies seems
to be due to the radial inflow of gas along bars to the galac-
tic center (Roberts et al. 1979; Friedli & Benz 1995; Sakamoto
et al. 1999; Sheth et al. 2005; Jogge et al 2005). This gas is
accumulated in a ring structure between two inner Lindblad
resonances (Knapen et al. 1995).
Gas inflow is also necessary to feed the nuclear massive
black hole in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) and surround-
ing nuclear star formation regions, probably yielding the so-
called AGN-starburst connection (Norman & Scoville 1988;
Send offprint requests to: Oli L. Dors Jr.,
e-mail: [email protected]
Terlevich et al. 1990; Heckman et al. 1997; Gonz´alez Delgado
et al. 1998; Ferrarese & Merritt 2000; Cid Fernandes et al.
2001; Storchi-Bergmann 2001; Heckman 2004). Recent obser-
vational studies have shown evidence of gas inflow: Storchi-
Bergmann et al. (2007) and Fathi et al. (2006) report the dis-
covery of gas streaming motions along spiral arms towards
the LINER nuclei of the galaxies NGC 6951 and NGC 1097,
while Fathi et al. (2007) found gas inflow to the nuclear star
formation region of the galaxy M 83. Moreover, several works
have found star formation around active nuclei (e.g. Riffel et al.
2007; Kauffmann et al. 2003)
In CNSFRs,
the line ratio [O iii]λ5007/Hβ (hereafter
[O iii]/Hβ) is usually weak or not observable and the emis-
sion lines have lower equivalent widths than those of disk H ii
regions (e.g. Diaz et al. 2007; Bresolin et al. 1999; Bresolin
& Kennicutt 1997; Kennicutt et al. 1989). The low value of
[O iii]/Hβ has been attributed to over-solar abundances (e.g.
Boer & Schulz 1993). At their location in the innermost parts
of galactic disks, these objects are expected to be the most
metal-rich star-forming regions. In fact, D´ıaz et al. (2007) ob-
tained long-slit observations for 12 CNSFRs and, using a semi-
empirical method to derivate of oxygen abundances, found that
some of them have 12+log(O/H)=8.85, a value consistent with
the maximum oxygen abundance value derived for central parts
of spiral galaxies (Pilyugin et al. 2007).
Regarding the equivalent width of emission lines,
Kennicutt et al. (1989) found that the equivalent widths of Hα
2
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
96 pc for the former and 68 pc for the latter galaxy. The reader
is referred to the papers above for a full description of the data.
Figure 1 shows spectra of CNSFRs identified by the let-
ters F and J in Figs. 2 and 3 located in the circumnuclear rings
of NGC 6951 and NGC 1097, respectively. Using the observed
spectra we built maps for flux distributions in the Hα emis-
sion line and for the line ratios [N ii]λ6583/Hα, ([S ii]λ6717 +
λ6731)/Hα, as well as for the EW(Hα). These maps are shown
in Figs. 2 and 3. Throughout the paper we identify the line ra-
tios above as [N ii]/Hα and [S ii]/Hα. For NGC 6951 the ob-
served field completely covers the circumnuclear ring. The data
of the ring were separated from those of the inner region by fit-
ting two ellipses to the Hα image of NGC 6951: one to the inner
border of the ring and the other to the outer border (see Storchi-
Bergmann et al. 2007). In the NGC 6951 Hα map, we clearly
see several regions of star formation. We have identified nine of
them as indicated in Fig. 2. Since for NGC 1097 the observa-
tion field covered only part of the ring, we could only identify
two regions in this galaxy (see Fig. 3).
For these measurements, we assumed that each star forma-
tion region has a circular symmetry, whose center corresponds
to the peak in the Hα intensity and the radius defined as the one
where the flux reaches 50 % of the peak value. Nevertheless, we
can see from Fig. 2 that the CNSFRs have irregular morpholo-
gies and the assumption above can result in some uncertainties
in the Hα flux and in line ratio measurements. To estimate how
much flux we may be missing, for NGC 6951, we compared
the sum of the Hα flux of all regions (obtained from photom-
etry within circular apertures) with the flux integrated over the
whole ring. We found that the diffuse gas contribution (from
regions not covered by the circles) is about 12 %. A similar re-
sult was found for individual H ii regions by Oey & Kennicutt
(1997). In relation to line ratios, we measured the median val-
ues considering different values for the radius of each region
and differences no greater than 10% were found. We thus es-
timate that uncertainties in both fluxes and line ratios due to
uncertainties in the geometry of the CNSFRs are about 10%.
In Table 1 we show the adopted area of each region, the lumi-
nosity of Hα, and the median values of EW(Hα), [N ii]/Hα, and
[S ii]/Hα.
3. Photoionization models
To derive the metallicity, ionization parameter, and the age
of
the CNSFRs, we employed the photoionization code
Cloudy/95.03 (Ferland 2002) to build a grid of models cov-
ering a large space of nebular parameters. The models were
built as in Dors & Copetti (2006), with metallicities Z=1.1, 1.0,
0.7, 0.6 Z⊙, and ionization parameter logarithm (log U) of −2.0,
−2.5, and −3.0 dex. In each model a stellar cluster was assumed
as the ionizing source with the stellar energy distributions ob-
tained from the synthesis code S T ARBURS T 99 (Leitherer et
al. 1999). We built models with stellar clusters formed by in-
stantaneous and continuous bursts with stellar upper mass lim-
its of Mup = 20, 30 and 100 M⊙, Z= 1.0 and 0.4 Z⊙, and ages
ranging from 0.01 to 10 Myr with a step of 0.5 Myr. Clusters
older than about 10 Myr and formed instantaneously have no
more O stars (Leitherer & Heckman 1995), so were not consid-
Fig. 1. Sample spectra: star-forming regions F in NGC 6951
(top) and J in NGC 1097 (bottom).
EW(Hα) in CNSFRs are about 7 times lower than the ones
in disk H ii regions. They proposed several scenarios to ex-
plain this behavior, such as (i) deficiency of high-mass stars
in the initial mass function (IMF), (ii) a long timescale for
star formation, and (iii) high dust abundance. However, nei-
ther of these mechanisms turned out to be the dominant effect.
Unfortunately, spectroscopic data and abundance estimates are
only available for a small number of CNSFRs.
With the goal of increasing the number of CNSFRs with
determined gas abundances and star formation rates, we have
combined two-dimensional integral field unit (IFU) data of
CNSFRs located in the galaxies NGC 1097 and NGC 6951 with
a grid of photoionization models to derive their nebular gas
properties. Using high-quality two-dimensional data, we could
also investigate the cause of lower equivalent widths of emis-
sion lines observed in CNSFRs with respect to those of inner
disk HII regions. In Section 2 we give details about the obser-
vational data we used, in Section 3 we present a description of
the methodology used to derive the physical parameters, while
in Section 4 we present our results. The discussion of the out-
come and our final conclusions are given in Sections 5 and 6,
respectively.
2. Observational data
The observational spectroscopic data on NGC 1097 and
NGC 6951 were drawn from the works of Fathi et al. (2006)
and Storchi-Bergmann et al. (2007). Basically these data were
obtained with IFUs of the Gemini Multi-Object Spectrographs
(GMOS-IFU) on the Gemini South (for NGC 1097) and North
(for NGC 6951) telescopes using the R400-G5325 grating and
r-G0326 filter, covering the spectral range 5600-7000 Å with
a resolution of R ≈ 2300. Three IFU fields were observed in
each galaxy, covering an angular field of 15′′× 7′′. The reduc-
tion procedure resulted in 50 × 70 spectra for each IFU field,
each corresponding to an angular coverage of 0.1′′× 0.1′′. We
adopted distances for NGC 6951 and NGC 1097 of 24 Mpc and
17 Mpc (Tully 1988), respectively, such that 1′′corresponds to
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
3
Fig. 2. Star-forming ring in NGC 6951. From left to right: map of the Hα integrated flux (ergs cm−2 per pixel); line ratio maps
[N ii]/Hα [S ii]/Hα and EW(Hα). The circles and the letters identify each region as defined in Section 2.
ered in our models. The metallicity of the nebula was matched
to the closest available metallicity of the stellar cluster. The so-
lar composition refers to Asplund et al. (2005) and corresponds
to log(O/H) = −3.30.
4. Results
Since the observational data for NGC 6951 and NGC 1097 cov-
ers a restricted wavelength range, few emission line ratios can
be used in our analysis. Storchi-Bergmann et al. (1994) and
Raimann et al. (2000) showed that [N ii]/Hα can be used to ob-
tain the oxygen abundance of star-forming galaxies. However,
this line ratio also dependents on the ionization parameter U
(Kewley & Dopita 2002), thus the combination with other line
ratios is desirable in order to decrease the uncertainties in the
O/H estimates. Thus we used our photoionization model grid
to build an [N ii]/Hα vs. [S ii]/ Hα diagram to derive Z and U
of the CNSFRs located in NGC 6951 and NGC 1097. Recently,
Viironen et al. (2007) have shown that diagnostic diagrams us-
ing [N ii]/Hα and [S ii]/ Hα are a powerful tool for estimating
Z and U of star-forming regions. Moreover, these line ratios
are not dependent on the Mup and age assumed in the models
(see Fig. 5). We point out that a cautionary note has been put
forth by Mazzuca et al. (2006) regarding the use of diagnostic
diagrams including the line ratio [N ii]/Hα: they can yield de-
generate values for the metallicity, as star-forming regions with
low Z and U have [N ii]/Hα values similar to regions with high
Z and U. However, CNSFRs are known to have high abun-
dances (near solar) (see Sect. 5.1), ruling out the possibility
of low abundances. This is confirmed by the work of Storchi-
Bergmann et al. (1996), which shows an increasing gas abun-
dance towards the nucleus, including a few regions in circum-
nuclear rings.
The results of our models compared to observational data
for NGC 6951 and NGC 1097 are shown in Fig. 4, in which
we considered an instantaneous burst with age of 2.5 Myr and
Mup = 100 M⊙. We can see that the observational data are
well represented by models having metallicities Z ≈ Z⊙ and
log U ≈ −2.3, with uncertainties of about 0.03 and 0.1 dex, due
to the uncertainties in the line ratios discussed above. In Table 1
we show the Z and log U values for each region, obtained by
linear interpolation from the model grid. In this table we also
present the values of electron density Ne computed from the
observed line ratio [S ii]λ6717/λ6731 and adopting Te = 104
K (Osterbrock 1989). The Ne values cover the range 50-600
cm−3, which is typical of H ii regions (Copetti et al. 2000).
To obtain the ages of the CNSFRs, we used the observed
values of equivalent widths and [O iii]/Hβ, which decrease al-
most monotonically as a function of time (Magris et al. 2003,
Copetti et al. 1986). In Fig. 5 we plot the values predicted by the
models for EW(Brγ), EW(Hβ), EW(Hα), as well as [N ii]/Hα,
[S ii]/Hα and [O iii]/Hβ versus age. We considered instanta-
neous and continuous star formation bursts with Mup = 20, 30
and 100 M⊙, log U = −2.5 and Z = Z⊙. The values of the line
ratios [N ii]/Hα and [S ii]/Hα were found to be approximately
constant for the range of ages considered. However, [O iii]/Hβ
shows a chaotic behavior between 2 and 6 Myr, mainly for
Mup=100 M⊙ and instantaneous burst. This happens due to the
increase in the number of ionizing photons by the presence of
Wolf Rayet stars in this phase (Leitherer & Heckman 1995).
This behavior was also noted by Dopita et al. (2006). As no
feature of Wolf Rayet stars was observed in our data and be-
cause [O iii]/Hβ is very dependent on many nebular parame-
ters, it will not be considered as an age tracer in this paper. The
use of the equivalent width of emission lines seems to be more
reliable for deriving ages of star-forming regions, since they
basically depend on Mup and on the slope of the IMF (Copetti
et al. 1986).
Using the EW(Hα) values shown in Table 1, the CNSFR
ages predicted by instantaneous and continuous models are
around 7 Myr and over 10 Myr, respectively, independent of
the Mup assumed. Table 1 also presents the values for the star
formation rate (SFR) computed using the luminosity of the re-
4
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
Fig. 3. Left: map of the Hα-integrated flux (ergs cm−2 per pixel) showing the field covered by the IFU in NGC 1097, which
includes the nucleus and part of the ring (at the bottom). Right: line ratio maps [N ii]/Hα [S ii]/Hα and EW(Hα) for the partial
ring. The circles and the letters identify each region defined in Section 2.
Fig. 4. Diagnostic diagram [N ii]/Hα vs. [S ii]/Hα showing the
grid of photoionization models for an ionizing cluster with age
2.5 Myr and Mup = 100 M⊙. Solid lines connect curves of iso-
Z, while dotted lines connect curves of iso-U. The values of
log U and Z are indicated. Squares are the median values mea-
sured for the CNSFRs in NGC 6951 and triangles are those for
NGC 1097.
Fig. 5. Evolution of the EW(Brγ), EW(Hβ), EW(Hα), and rel-
evant line ratios as predicted by our photoionization models
considering different Mup values and star formation regimes as
indicated, for Z = Z⊙ and log U = −2.5.
gions obtained in this paper and the relation SFR(M⊙ year−1)=
7.9 × L(Hα) (ergs s−1) given by Kennicutt (1998).
Acording to our models,
the CNSFRs of NGC 6951 and
NGC 1097 have solar or slightly higher solar metallicities.
5. Discussion
5.1. Metallicities
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
5
Table 1. Physical properties of the CNSFRs in NGC 6951 and NGC 1097
Region
A (arcsec2)
LHα (1038 erg s−1)
[N II]/Hα
[S II]/Hα
SFR (M⊙ yr−1)
EW(Hα)
Z/Z⊙
log U Ne(cm−3)
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
3.0
1.5
1.4
0.6
1.4
2.9
0.9
0.8
3.0
8.9
1.8
121
68.2
23.1
25.0
59.7
94.5
16.5
12.2
47.6
45.8
2.06
0.32±0.03
0.35±0.03
0.35±0.03
0.31±0.02
0.32±0.02
0.29±0.01
0.31±0.01
0.34±0.02
0.34±0.02
0.38±0.02
0.40±0.03
0.15±0.01
0.16±0.01
0.18±0.01
0.15±0.01
0.13±0.01
0.11±0.02
--
0.22±0.02
0.20±0.01
0.16±0.01
0.18±0.01
0.09
0.05
0.02
0.02
0.05
0.07
0.01
0.01
0.04
0.03
0.002
28
31
16
39
45
26
32
31
38
12
7
1.04
1.05
1.04
1.03
1.05
1.04
--
0.94
0.99
1.08
1.09
−2.3
−2.2
−2.4
−2.3
−2.1
−2.0
--
−2.6
−2.6
−2.1
−2.2
208±59
287±151
297±134
525±103
354±24
148±40
273±36
68±10
138±29
292±45
223±149
Considering an uncertainty on the order of 0.1 dex due to the
method used to estimate abundances (see Evans 1986, Dors &
Copetti 2005, 2006), our abundance values are comparable to
the maximum oxygen abundance derived for central parts of
spiral galaxies of 12+log(O/H) ≈ 8.87 (Pilyugin et al. 2007).
Similarly, Mazzuca et al. (2006) present an emission-line diag-
nostic analysis of the nuclear starburst ring of NGC 7742 and
find roughly solar abundances.
Recently, Sarzi et al. (2007) presented a study of CNSFRs
located in eight galaxies which include the regions B, E and F
of our sample. They also used empirical methods to derive the
metallicities of these regions and find abundances similar to
the ones derived in this paper. D´ıaz et al. (2007) use a semi-
empirical abundance calibration to find that the CNSFRs in
NGC 2903, NGC 3351, and NGC 3504 have metallicities com-
parable to the ones derived in this paper. Until now, only a
case of very low abundance on the order of 0.2-0.4 Z⊙ in the
CNSFRs located in NGC 3310 was reported by Pastoriza et al.
(1993). This low abundance can be understood as due to the
fact that this galaxy has an interaction history (Elmegreen et al.
2002), through which neutral gas may have been accreted to
the ring.
Due to the fact that CNSFRs have very low excitation, with
[O iii]/Hβ < 1 (e.g. Hagale et al. 2007, P´erez et al. 2000)
and to their central location in the galactic disk, it is expected
that these objects have somewhat higher abundance than is de-
rived for inner disk H ii regions. To check this, we have plot-
ted the [N ii]/Hα in Fig. 6 (lower panel) against oxygen abun-
dance for some disk H ii regions located in 13 spiral galax-
ies. This sample includes the most metal-rich nebulae in which
temperature sensitive emission lines have been detected. The
data were taken from Bresolin (2007), Bresolin et al. (2005,
2004), Kennicutt et al. (2003), Castellanos et al. (2002), and
Skillman et al. (1996). With the exception of the oxygen abun-
dances from Skillman et al. (1996), which were recalculated
by us using the P-method (Pilyugin 2001), all O/H values were
obtained using direct derivation of the electron temperature.
Also included in Fig. 6 are the data of our sample. We can
see that the CNSFRs show the highest oxygen abundances, to-
gether with some disk nebulae, a result also obtained by D´ıaz
et al. (2007). Since abundance determinations via photoioniza-
tion models are overestimated by a factor of 0.1-0.4 dex when
compared to direct determinations (Dors & Copetti 2005), our
abundance estimates should be interpreted as upper limits. If
CNSFRs are included in the computation of abundance gra-
dients in spirals, we would expect therefore a plateau at very
small galactocentric distances.
5.2. Starformationhistory
The Hα luminosity values found for the CNSFRs in this paper
are in the range 2 × 1038 − 1.2 × 1040 erg s−1, compatible with
values of regions in circumnuclear rings of other spiral galaxies
(e.g. D´ıaz et al. 2007). These luminosity values yield star for-
mation rates of 0.002-0.1 M⊙ yr−1, characterizing a moderate
star-forming regime. Averaging the SFR values in Table 1, we
find 0.04 M⊙ yr−1, a similar value to the one found by Ho et
al. (1997) for a sample of nuclear star-forming regions and by
Shi et al. (2006), who studied a sample of 385 circumnuclear
star-forming regions in galaxies with different Hubble types.
We cannot conclude from our data alone whether the star
formation has been continuous or instantaneous in the rings,
although the former scenario has not been favored by previous
studies. For example, Sarzi et al. (2007) use absorption-line in-
dex diagrams to show that the hypothesis of a constant star for-
mation in their sample can be ruled out. Allard et al. (2006) find
that the star formation in the ring of M 100 have occurred in a
series of short bursts for the past 500 Myr or so. These results
can be understood within the following scenario. Once mas-
sive stars are formed, they cause turbulence and heating in the
molecular cloud, inhibiting further star formation (Hartmann et
al. 2001, Blitz & Shu 1980). Since no systematic age sequence
is observed along the NGC 6951 ring, the star formation mode
seems to be as predicted by the popcorn model (Boker et al.
2008), in which the entire ring begins to form stars at about the
same time or at random times. A similar result was also derived
by Mazzuca et al. (2008), who used photometric Hα imaging
of 22 nuclear rings to find that only a very small fraction of
them show age sequences along the ring.
5.3. Ageestimates
Our modeling gives ages of about 7.0 Myr for an instanta-
neous burst and more than 10 Myr for a continuous burst, with
6
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
the CNSFRs in NGC 1097 slightly older than in NGC 6951.
To compare our age estimates with those of other CNSFRs,
we collected equivalent widths of more CNSFRs from the
literature and estimated their ages using Fig. 5. The data
were extracted from D´ıaz et al. (2007) for NGC 2903 and
NGC 3505, Hagele et al. (2007) for NGC 3351, Allard et
al. (2006) for M 100, Reunanen et al. (2000) for NGC 7771,
and Wakamatsu & Nishida (1980) for NGC 4314, which give
EW(Hβ), EW(Hα), and EW(Brγ) in the range 1-17, 10-40, and
5-60 Å, respectively. The predicted ages for these EW values
are of 5-8 Myr and more than 10 Myr for instantaneous and
continuous bursts, respectively, thus similar to the ones we de-
rived for the CNSFRs in the present paper. Somewhat higher
EW values have been obtained by Mazzuca et al. (2008) for
HII regions in nuclear rings of more than 20 galaxies. On the
other hand, studies also utilizing photoionization models give
ages of 1.5-3 Myr for H ii regions located in galactic disks and
for H II galaxies (Dors & Copetti 2006; Stasinska & Izotov
2003; Bresolin et al. 1999; Copetti et al. 1985). We have also
compared the ages of our sample with those of disk nebulae
of similar metallicity. In Fig. 6 we show log(EW(Hβ)) and
12+log(O/H) plotted against log([N ii]/Hα) for these disk H ii
regions, together with our data for the CNSFRs. We converted
the EW(Hα) values shown in Table 1 in EW(Hβ) using the re-
lation EW(Hβ)≈ 0.15 EW(Hα) obtained from our models. We
can see that the EW(Hβ) of the CNSFRs are lower by a factor
of about 30 than those of their counterpart disk H ii regions.
Assuming a EW(Hβ)= 100 Å for the innermost disk regions
and using Fig. 5, we find that these regions are about 3 Myr
younger than the CNSFRs.
5.4. ThelowEWvalues
The age differences found above may not be real, since the very
low equivalent widths in CNSFRs stem from other effects than
the age. Kennicutt et al. (1989) pointed out possible mecha-
nisms such as (i) deficiency of high-mass stars in the initial
mass function, (ii) very high dust abundance, (iii) contamina-
tion of the continuum by contribution from the bulge or other
underlying stellar populations, and (iv) continuous star forma-
tion. These hypotheses are discussed below.
Regarding the hypothesis of the deficiency of high-mass
stars, since Mup of an ionizing cluster is dependent on the
metallicity (Larson & Starrfield 1971; Kahn 1974; Shields &
Tinsley 1976; Stasi´nska 1980; Vilchez & Pagel 1988; Campbell
1988; Bresolin et al. 1999; Dors & Copetti 2003, 2005, 2006),
CNSFRs and innermost disk nebulae should have about same
Mup. It is unlikely that the discrepancy in EWs is only due to
variation in Mup. Even assuming that the ionizing cluster of
disk nebulae have Mup = 100 M⊙ and the ones of CNSFRs
have Mup = 20 M⊙, the age difference remains. Also a varia-
tion in the IMF can be discarded, since stellar clusters appear to
form with a universal IMF slope (Kroupa 2007, 2002, Chabrier
2003).
The hypothesis of very high dust abundance in CNSFRs is
not favored because they have similar Balmer decrements to
those observed for disk H ii regions, suggesting that this is not
the main source of the low EWs in CNSFRs (Kennicutt et al.
1989).
Concerning the contamination of the continuum, several
works have found the presence of underlying stellar popula-
tions from previous generations of stars in CNSFRs, which can
decrease the equivalent widths and yield no real age estimates
from Fig. 5. For example, Buta et al. (2000) found a spread in
ages of about 5 to 200 Myr for clusters in the circumnuclear
ring of NGC 1326, with the largest number of clusters younger
than 20 Myr. In the case of NGC 6951 and with measurements
of the equivalent width of calcium triplet at ≈8500 Å, P´erez
et al. (2000) found evidence of a population of red supergiant
stars with ages of 10 to 20 Myr in the ring.
An underlying stellar population can contribute in two ways
to the low EWs by causing a Balmer absorption and yielding
an extra contribution to the continuum. To estimate the effect
of an underlying Balmer absortion, we constructed models of
stellar populations (using the Padova 1994 tracks) with ages in
the range 10-1000 Myr. We normalized the continuum of each
model to the observed one and subtracted them from the ob-
served spectra of the CNSFRs of NGC 6951. For all cases, the
increase in the EW values due to subtracting of an underlying
absorption was at most 10%, much less than needed to com-
pensate for the low observed EW in CNSFRs.
Determining of the continuum contribution from underly-
ing stellar populations is not an easy task, since two types of
stellar populations can be contributing: the stellar population
from the bulge and stars formed in previous episodes of star
formation in the ring. To evaluate the contribution of the un-
derlying bulge, we performed aperture photometry on the con-
tinuum images (not shown) measuring both the CNSFR con-
tinuum and that of the bulge in the surrounding regions. We
concluded that the bulge contributes with ≈ 75 % of the total
flux in the case of NGC 6951 and with 50 % in NGC 1097. The
corresponding corrections are an increase by a factor of 2 and 4
in EW(Hα) for NGC 1097 and NGC 6951, respectively. These
factors increase the EW(Hα) in NGC 6951 from average values
of ≈30 Å to ≈120 Å and from ≈10 Å to ≈20 Å in NGC 1097.
The corresponding changes in age are from ≈7 Myr to ≈6 Myr
in NGC 6951 and no change for NGC 1097 (≈7 Myr). Thus the
contribution from the bulge to the continuum also does not ex-
plain the low EW's in CNSFRs. Stauffer (1981) also studied
the bulge contamination using aperture photometry of galaxy
nuclei to measure the background contribution to the contin-
uum flux, and Kennicutt et al. (1989) used those results to find
a correction factor similar to the one found by us.
Several generations of stars may coexist in CNSFRs be-
cause the tidal effects are not strong enough to disrupt the clus-
ter at the radius of the ring, allowing several generations of stars
to coexist (Buta et al. 2000). Thus the continuum may have a
contribution from previous bursts of star formation in the rings.
To investigate the effect of this continuum, we built photoion-
ization models to represent a scenario where three bursts of star
formation have occurred, with ages of 0.01, 10, and 20 Myr for
two values of Mup: 100 and 30 M⊙. This is illustrated in Fig. 7,
which shows the evolution of EW(Hβ) as a function of time.
It can be seen that the EW values decrease considerably when
compared with those of a single burst (Fig. 5). If we consider a
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
7
Fig. 6. Oxygen abundance vs. [N ii]/Hα (lower panel) and
EW(Hβ) vs. [N ii]/Hα (upper panel). The squares represent data
collected from the literature, while the circles represent the data
of the CNSFRs analyzed in this paper.
Fig. 7. Evolution of the EW(Hβ) as predicted by photoioniza-
tion models considering three episodes of star formation as in-
dicated. The ages correspond to the youngest burst.
typical EW(Hβ) for CNSFRs of 10 Å (not corrected for the un-
derlying bulge contribution) and compute the age from Fig. 7,
we find ages of 6-7 Myr, similar to the values derived above.
We conclude that none of the mechanisms discussed above
alone yield the low EW values (and resulting larger age)
observed in CNSFRs when compared to disk H ii regions.
However, it could be that a combination of more than one
mechanism can explain the lower EWs in CNSFRs. For exam-
ple, we can consider the effects of both the dilution by the bulge
and by previous bursts of star formation. A typical EW(Hβ)=
10 Å in NGC 6951 will increase to 40 Å if we correct for con-
tamination by the bulge. Then, we can consider the effect of
previous generation of stars in the ring using Fig. 7 instead of
Fig. 5 to obtain the age. We obtain an age of 3-4 Myr, a value in
consonance with ages of the innermost disk regions. In this way
we eliminate the apparent difference in age between CNSFRs
and inner-disk H ii regions.
6. Conclusions
We have used optical IFU spectroscopic data of CNSFRs in
NGC 6951 and NGC 1097, which compared to a grid of pho-
toionization models, in order to obtain physical parameters of
these regions. We find that the star formation rates are in the
range 0.002-0.14 M⊙ yr−1, thus covering a range from very low
to moderate star-forming regime. We also find that the CNSFRs
have oxygen abundances of 12+log(O/H)≈8.8, similar to those
of the most metal-rich nebulae located in inner parts the disks
of spiral galaxies.
We investigated the cause of the very low equivalent width
of emission lines found in CNSFRs, which suggests an older
age for these objects than for disk H ii regions. Among the sev-
eral scenarios invoked to explain this fact, we have concluded
that the contamination of the continua of CNSFRs by under-
lying contributions from both old bulge stars and stars formed
in the ring in previous episodes of star formation (10-20 Myr)
yield the observed low equivalent widths. Correcting for these
contributions, there are not any more significant differences in
ages between the CNSFRs and inner disk H ii regions.
Acknowledgements. We thank the anonymous referee for valuable
suggestions which helped to improve the paper. This work was based
on observations obtained at the Gemini Observatory, which is oper-
ated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy,
Inc., under a cooperative agreement with the NSF on behalf of the
Gemini partnership: the National Science Foundation (United States),
the Science and Technology Facilities Council (United Kingdom),
the National Research Council (Canada), CONICYT (Chile), the
Australian Research Council (Australia), CNPq (Brazil) and SECYT
(Argentina)
References
Allard, E. L., Knapen, J. H., Peletier, R. F., Sarzi, M. 2006, MNRAS,
371, 1087
Asplund, M., Grevesse, N., Sauval, A. J. 2005, Cosmic Abundances
as Records of Stellar Evolution and Nucleosynthesis, Vol. 336 of
Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, The Solar
Chemical Composition. pp. 25
Boer, B., & Schulz, H. 1993, A&A, 277, 397
Boker, T., Falc´on-Barroso, Schinnerer, E., Knapen, J. H., Ryder, S.
2008, AJ, 135, 479
Blitz, L., Shu, F. H. 1980, ApJ, 238, 148
Bresolin, F. 2007, ApJ, 656, 186
Bresolin, F., Schaerer, D., Gonz´alez Delgado, R. M., Stas´ınska, G.
2005, A&A, 441, 981
Bresolin, F., Garnett, D. R., Kennicutt, R. C. 2004, ApJ, 615, 228
Bresolin, F., Kennicutt, R. C., Garnett, D. R. 1999, ApJ, 510, 104
Bresolin, F., Kennicutt, R. C 1997, AJ, 113, 3
Buta, R., Treuthardt, P. M., Byrd, G. G., Crocker, D. A. 2000, AJ, 120,
1289
Campbell, A. 1988, ApJ, 335, 644
Castellanos, M., D´ıaz, A. I., Terlevich, E. 2002, MNRAS, 329, 315
Chabrier, G. 2003, PASP, 115, 763
8
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
Copetti, M. V. F., Mallmann, J., Schmidt, A. A., Castaneda, H. O.
2000, A&A, 357, 621
Copetti, M. V. F., Pastoriza, M. G., Dottori, H. A. 1986, A&A, 156,
111
P´erez, E., M´arquez, I. M., Durret, F. et al. 2000, A&A, 353, 893
Pilyugin, L. S., Thuan, T. X., V´ılchez, J. M. 2007, MNRAS, 376, 353
Pilyugin, L. S. 2001, A&A, 369, 594
Terlevich, E., Diaz, A. I., Terlevich, R. 1990, MNRAS, 242, 271
Copetti, M. V. F., Pastoriza, M. G., Dottori, H. A. 1985, A&A, 152,
0707.0651
427
Cid Fernandes, R., Heckman, T, Schimitt, H., Gonz´ales Delgado, R.,
Storchi-Bergmann, T. 2001, MNRAS, 558, 81
D´ıaz, A. I., Terlevich, E., Castellanos, M., Hagele, G. 2007, MNRAS,
382, 251
Dors, O. L., & Copetti, M. V. F. 2006, A&A, 452, 437
Dors, O. L., & Copetti, M. V. F. 2005, A&A, 437, 837
Dors, O. L., & Copetti, M. V. F. 2003, A&A, 404, 969
Dopita, M. A., Fischera, J., Sutherland, R. S. et al. 2006, ApJS, 167,
177
Elmegreen, D. M., Chromey, F., McGrath, E., Ostenson, J. 2002, AJ,
123, 1388
Evans, I. N. 1986, ApJ, 309, 544
Hagele, G. F., D´ıaz, A. I., Cardaci, M. C., Terlevich, E., Terlevich, R.
2007, MNRAS, 378, 163
Hartmann, L., Ballesteros-Paredes, J.; Bergin, E. A. 2001, ApJ, 562,
852
Heckman, T. M. 2004, cbhg.symp, 358
Heckman, T. M., Gonz´alez Delgado, R. M., Leitherer, C. et al. 1997,
ApJ, 482, 114
Ho, L. C., Filippenko, A. V.; Sargent, W. L. W. 1997, 487, 591
Fathi, K., Beckman, J. E., Lundgren, A. A. et al. 2007, [arXiv:astro-
ph/0712.0793]
Fathi, K., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Riffel, R. A. et al. 2006, ApJ, 641,
L25
Ferland, G. J. 2002, Hazy, a brief introduction to Cloudy 96.03, Univ.
Kentucky, Dept. Phys., Astron. internal report
Ferrarese, L., & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJ, 539, L9
Friedli, D., & Benz 1995, A&A, 301, 649
Gonz´alez Delgado, R. M., Heckman, T., Leitherer, C. et al. 1998, ApJ,
505,174
Jogge, S., Scoville, N., Kenney, J. D. P. 2005, ApJ, 630, 837
Kahn, F. D. 1974, A&A, 37, 149
Kauffmann, G., Heckman, T. M., Tremonti, C. et al. 2003, MNRAS,
346, 1055
Kennicutt, R. C., Bresolin, F., Garnett, D. R. 2003, ApJ, 591,
Kennicutt, R. C. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 189
Kennicutt, R. C. Keel, W., Blaha, C. A. 1989, ApJ, 97, 1022
Kewley, L. J., & Dopita, M. A. 2002, ApJSS,142, 35
Knapen, J. H., Beckman, J. E., Heller, C. H., Shlosman, I., de Jong,
R. S. 1995, ApJ, 454, 623
Knapen, J. H., 2005, A&A, 429, 141
Kroupa, P. 2007, [arXiv:astro-ph/0703282]
Kroupa, P. 2002, Science, 295, 82
Larson, R. B., Starrfield, S. 1971, A&A, 13, 190L
Leitherer, C., Schaerer, D., Goldader, J. D. et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 3
Leitherer, C., Heckman, T. M. 1995, ApJS, 96, 9
Magris C. G., Binette, L., Bruzual A. G. 2003, ApJS, 149, 313
Mazzuca, L. M., Knapen, J. H., Veilleux, S., Regan, M. W. 2008,
ApJS, 174, 337
Mazzuca, L. M., Sarzi, M., Knapen, J. H., Veilleux, S., Swaters, R.
2006, ApJ, 649, L79
Morgan, W. W. 1958, PASP, 70, 364
Norman, C., & Scoville, N. 1988, ApJ, 332, 124
Oey, M. S., & Kennicutt, R. C. 1997, MNRAS, 291, 827
Osterbrock, D. E. 1989, Astrophysics of Gaseous Nebulae and Active
Galactic Nuclei, (Mill Valley: Univ. Science Books)
Pastoriza, M. G., Dottori, H. A., Terlevich, E., Terlevich, R. 1993,
MNRAS, 260, 177
Tully, R. B. 1988, Nearby Catalogue, Cambridge University Press
Raimann, D., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Bica, E., Melnick, J. Schmitt, H.
2000, MNRAS, 316, 559
Reunanen, J., Kotilainen, J. K., Laine, S., Ryder, S. D. 2000, ApJ, 529,
853
Riffel, R., Pastoriza, G., Rodr´ıgues-Ardila, A., Maraston, C. 2007,
ApJ, 659, L103
Roberts, W. W., Huntley, J. M., van Albada, G. D. 1979, ApJ, 233, 67
Riffel, R. A., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Winge, C., Barbosa, F. K. 2006,
MNRAS, 373, 2
Sakamoto, K., Okumura, S. K., Ishizuki, S., Scoville, N. Z. 1999, ApJ,
525, 691
Sarzi, M., Allard, E. L., Knapen, J. H., Mazzuca, L. M. 2007,
MNRAS, 380, 949
Stauffer, J. P. 1981, Ph.D thesis, University of California, Berkeley
Stasi´nska, G. 1980, A&A, 84, 320
S´ersic, J. L., Pastoriza, M. 1967, PASP, 79, 427
Sheth, K., Vogel, S. N., Regan, M. W., et al. 2005, ApJ, 632, 217
Shields, G. A., Tinsley, B. M. 1976, ApJ, 203, 66
Shi, L., Gu, Q. S., Peng, Z. X. 2006, A&A, 450. 15
Skillman E. D., Kennicutt, R. C., Shields, G. A., Zaritsky, D. 1996,
ApJ, 462, 147
Stasi´nska, G., Izotov, I. 2003, A&A, 397, 71
Storchi-Bergmann, T., Dors, O. L., Riffel, R. A. et al. 2007, ApJ, 670,
959
Storchi-Bergmann, T., Gonz´alez Delgado, R. M. et al. 2001, ApJ,
559,147
Storchi-Bergmann, T., Rodriguez-Ardila, A., Schmitt, H. R., Wilson,
A. S., Baldwin, J. A. 1996, ApJ, 472, 83
Storchi-Bergmann, T., Calzetti, D., Kinney, A. 1994, ApJ, 572, 581
Viironen, K., Delgado-Inglada, G., Mampaso, A., Magrini, L.,
Corradi, R. L. M. 2007, MNRAS, 381, 1719
Vilchez, J. M., & Pagel, B. E. J. 1988, MNRAS, 231, 257
Wakamatsu, K., & Nishida, M. T. 1980, PASJ, 32, 389
List of Objects
'NGC 6951' on page 1
'NGC 1097' on page 1
'NGC 6951' on page 1
'NGC 1097' on page 1
'NGC 6951' on page 1
'NGC 1097' on page 1
'M 83' on page 1
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
O. L. Dors Jr., T. Storchi-Bergmann, Rogemar A. Riffel, A. A Schimdt: Circumnuclear star formation regions
9
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 1097' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 2
'NGC 6951' on page 3
'NGC 1097' on page 3
'NGC 6951' on page 3
'NGC 1097' on page 3
'NGC 6951' on page 3
'NGC 1097' on page 3
'NGC 6951' on page 4
'NGC 1097' on page 4
'NGC 6951' on page 4
'NGC 1097' on page 4
'NGC 6951' on page 4
'NGC 1097' on page 4
'NGC 7742' on page 4
'NGC 6951' on page 5
'NGC 1097' on page 5
'NGC 2903' on page 5
'NGC 3351' on page 5
'NGC 3504' on page 5
'NGC 3310' on page 5
'M 100' on page 5
'NGC 6951' on page 5
'NGC 1097' on page 5
'NGC 6951' on page 5
'NGC 2903' on page 5
'NGC 3505' on page 5
'NGC 3351' on page 5
'M 100' on page 5
'NGC 7771' on page 5
'NGC 4314' on page 5
'NGC 1326' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 1097' on page 6
'NGC 1097' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 1097' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 6
'NGC 1097' on page 6
'NGC 6951' on page 7
'NGC 6951' on page 7
'NGC 1097' on page 7
|
astro-ph/0412693 | 1 | 0412 | 2004-12-30T11:31:30 | IVS Products for Precise Global Reference Frames | [
"astro-ph"
] | VLBI plays a unique and fundamental role in the maintenance of global reference frames which are required for precise positioning in many research areas related e.g to the understanding and monitoring of global changes, to geodesy, to space missions etc. The International VLBI Service for Geodesy and Astrometry coordinates internationally the VLBI components and resources and is tasked by IAG and IAU for the provision of products describing the Celestial Reference Frame through positions of quasars and their changes with time and also for products describing the rotation of the Earth in space. This paper summarises today's status of the products, achieved over the last years by evolving the observing programs. It points out the activities to improve further on the product quality to meet future service requirements, which will come up with the need for highly precise global reference frames. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Proceedings of the 7th European VLBI Network Symposium
Bachiller, R. Colomer, F., Desmurs, J.F., de Vicente, P. (eds.)
October 12th-15th 2004, Toledo, Spain
IVS Products for Precise Global Reference Frames
Wolfgang Schluter1 and Nancy Vandenberg2
1 Bundesamt fur Kartographie und Geodaesie, Fundamentalstation Wettzell, D 93444 Kotzting, Germany
2 NVI, Inc./ Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, USA
Abstract. VLBI plays a unique and fundamental role in the maintenance of global reference frames which are required for
precise positioning in many research areas related e.g to the understanding and monitoring of global changes, to geodesy, to space
missions etc. The International VLBI Service for Geodesy and Astrometry coordinates internationally the VLBI components and
resources and is tasked by IAG and IAU for the provision of products describing the Celestial Reference Frame through positions
of quasars and their changes with time and also for products describing the rotation of the Earth in space. This paper summarises
today's status of the products, achieved over the last years by evolving the observing programs. It points out the activities to
improve further on the product quality to meet future service requirements, which will come up with the need for highly precise
global reference frames.
1. Introduction
2. Products and improvements
The International VLBI Service for Geodesy and Astrometry
(IVS) is a service of the International Association of Geodesy
(IAG), the International Astronomical Union (IAU) and the
Federation of Astronomical and Geophysical Data Analysis
Services (FAGS). The main task of the IVS is the coordina-
tion of VLBI components in order to guarantee the provision of
the products and parameters to realize the Celestial Reference
Frame (CRF), the Terrestrial Reference Frame (TRF) and the
Earth Rotation with its orientation of the rotation axis in both
reference frames and its angular velocity through the Earth
Orientation Parameter (EOP). The EOP enables the transfor-
mation between TRF and CRF. VLBI is fundamental and
unique for the realization of the CRF through a catalogue of
quasar positions. The IAU tasked IVS to maintain the CRF
and released a resolution in August 2001, during the General
Assembly in Birmingham. VLBI contributes strongly to the
TRF by the determination of station positions, in particular
of baseline lengths between the stations. Due to the long in-
tercontinental baselines VLBI is strongly supporting the scale
of the TRF. Time series of station positions give informa-
tion about their movements (plate motions). As VLBI pro-
vides the complete set of EOP and uniquely the UT1-UTC
(DUT1) parameter and the CRF, VLBI is the key technique
for the monitoring of global reference frames. The interna-
tional collaboration is based on a Call for Participation in
1998 with respect to the IVS Terms of Reference (ToR).
Proposals were made to operate more than 73 permanent com-
ponents by 37 institutions in 17 countries. IVS has more
than 250 Associate Members. Annual Reports and Meeting
Proceedings are published (Vandenberg 1999, Vandenberg,
Baver 2001, Vandenberg, Baver 2002 , Vandenberg, Baver
2003 , Vandenberg, Baver 2004 , Vandenberg, Baver 2000,
Vandenberg, Baver 2002b , Vandenberg, Baver 2004b).
When IVS started in March 1999, the demand for continuity in
maintaining the reference frames forced us to employ the exist-
ing observing programs set up by the US Naval Observatory as
NEOS, or by NASA as CORE. In 2001 a working group (IVS
WG2) was established to review the products and the existing
observing programs. The WG2 report was the basis for improv-
ing products and evolving observing programs to meet service
requirements. The IVS products can be defined in terms of their
accuracy, reliability, frequency of observing sessions, tempo-
ral resolution of the estimated parameters, time delay from ob-
serving to final product, and frequency of solutions. The situ-
ation before 2002 and the goals for the follow on years with
IVS products are described in detailed tables in the WG2 re-
port (Schuh et al. 2002). The main IVS products, their current
accuracies and the goals are summarized in table 1. The VLBI
technique allow us to provide additional products and IVS in-
tends to set up the extended products summarized in table 2.
As of late 2001, IVS products were generated from 3
days/week observing with 6-station networks. The time delay
ranged from several days up to 4 months, with an overall av-
erage value of 60 days. Over the next years, the goals of IVS
with respect to its products were the following (specific goals
for each product are listed in the WG2 report tables):
-- improve the accuracies of all EOP and TRF products by a
factor of 2 to 4 and improve the sky distribution of the CRF,
-- decrease the average time delay from 60 to 30 days, and
designate 2 days per week as rapid turnaround sessions
with a maximum delay of 3-4 days,
-- increase the frequency of observing sessions from 3 to 7
days per week,
-- deliver all products on a regular, timely schedule.
310
Wolfgang Schluter and Nancy Vandenberg: IVS Products for Precise Global Reference Frames
Fig. 1. Overview of IVS components
3. Evolving observing programs
To meet its product goals, beginning with the 2002 observ-
ing year, IVS designed an observing program coordinated with
the international community. The 2002 observing program in-
cluded the following sessions:
-- EOP: Two rapid turnaround sessions each week (IVS R1
and IVS R2), initially with 6 stations, increasing to 8. These
networks were designed with the goal of having compara-
ble xp and yp results. One-baseline 1-hr INTENSIVE ses-
sions four times per week, with at least one parallel session.
-- TRF: Monthly TRF sessions with 8 stations including a
core network of 4 to 5 stations and using all other stations
three to four times per year.
-- CRF: Bi-monthly RDV sessions using the Very Long
Baseline Array (VLBA) and 10 geodetic stations, plus
quarterly astrometric sessions to observe mostly southern
sky sources.
-- Monthly R&D sessions to investigate instrumental effects,
research the network offset problem, and study ways for
technique and product improvement.
-- Annual, or semi-annual if resources are available, 14-day
continuous sessions to demonstrate the best results that
VLBI can offer, aiming for the highest sustained accuracy.
Although certain sessions have primary goals, such as CRF,
all sessions are scheduled so that they contribute to all geodetic
and astrometric products. Sessions in the observing program
that are recorded and correlated using S2 or K4 technology
will have the same accuracy and timeliness goals as those us-
ing Mark 4/Mark 5. The new IVS observing program began
in January 2002. The observing program and product delivery
was accomplished by making some changes and improvements
in IVS observing program resources (station days, correlator
time, and magnetic media), by improving and strengthening
analysis procedures, and by a vigorous technology develop-
ment program.
4. Status and experiences of the new IVS Program
two year after its implementation
The number of station observing days increased by about
10compared to 2001, with an additional 12campaign. Not
counting CONT02, the number of observing days increased
Wolfgang Schluter and Nancy Vandenberg: IVS Products for Precise Global Reference Frames
311
Table 1. Summary of IVS main products, status and goal specifications
Products
Specifications
Status
UT1 - UTC
DUT1
Celestial Pole
dǫ, δψ
Polar Motion
xp, yp
accuracy
latency
resolution
frequency of solution
accuracy
latency
resolution
accuracy
latency
resolution
frequency of solution
accuracy
accurary
frequency of solution
latency
1 improved distribution
TRF(x,y,z)
CRF
(α; δ)
xp 100µas, yp 200µas
1 -- 4 weeks . . . 4 months
1 day
+3 days/week
5µs . . . 20µs
1 week
1 day
100µas . . . 400µas
1 -- 4 weeks . . . 4 months
1 day
3 days/week
5 mm -- 20 mm
0.2µas -- 3mas
1 year
3 -- 6 months
xp, yp: 50µas
4 -- 3 days
1 day . . . 1 h
Goals (2002 -- 2005)
. . . 25µas
. . . 1 day
. . . 10 min
. . . 7 days/week
3µs . . . 2µs
4 -- 3 days
1 day
50µas
4 -- 3 days
1 day
5mm
0.25µas1
1 year
3 months
. . . 1 day
. . . 10 min
. . . 25µas
. . . 1 day
. . . 7 days/week
. . . 2 mm
. . . 1 month
Table 2. Extended products derived by VLBI and provided or intended to be provided by IVS
Earth Orientation Parameter additions
Terrestrial Reference Frame (TRF)
Celestial Reference Frame (CRF)
Geodynamical Parameter
Physical Parameter
• dUT1/dt (length of day)
• dxp/dt; dyp/dt (pole rates)
• x-, y-, z- time series
• Episodic events
• Annual solutions
• Non linear changes
• Source structure
• Flux density
• Solid Earth tides (Love numbers h,l)
• Ocean Loading (amplitudes and phases Ai, Φi)
• Atmospheric loading (site-dependent coefficients)
• Tropospheric parameters
• Ionospheric mapping
• Light deflection parameter γ
by another 12will continuously increase such that by 2005 the
top dozen geodetic stations will need to be observing up to 4
days per week - an ambitious goal. Increased station reliabil-
ity and unattended operations can improve temporal coverage
by VLBI and also allow substantial savings in operating costs.
Higher data rate sessions can yield more accurate results, and
therefore nearly all geodetic stations were upgraded to Mark 5
and K5 technology. A deployment plan for the Mark 5 system
was proposed. As of the end of 2003 the correlator and most
of the observing stations were equipped with Mark 5 digital
recording systems. All correlators were committed to handling
the IVS data with priority processing for meeting timely prod-
uct delivery requirements. High capacity disks were purchased
and organized in a common pool to replace magnetic tapes and
to obtain additional recording media capacity. The progress in
communication technologies supported the breakthrough for e-
VLBI. Several tests have been conducted on national, continen-
tal and global levels. Some station are already connected to fast
internet links and regular applications for e-VLBI (real time or
near real time) will be established. The 1-hr INTENSIVE ob-
servation sessions are routinely transferred electronically to a
correlator and will soon be operational. The increased amount
of VLBI data to be produced under the new observing program
required Analysis Centers to handle a larger load. Partially au-
tomated analysis procedures helped to improve the timeliness
of product delivery. As the official IVS product, a complete
set of Earth Orientation Parameter is regularly submitted to
the International Earth Rotation Service (IERS). The set is ob-
tained as a combination of the individual solutions of the six
IVS Analysis Centers (Nothnagel, Steinforth 2002). Up to the
end of the year 2001, the parameters were derived from the
NEOS observations, while since January 2002 the IVS R1 and
IVS R4 were used. It should be noted that up to the end of 2001
NEOS was the rapid turn around program which since January
2002 now includes the IVS R1 and R4 sessions. The objective
of the rapid turn around observation sessions was to minimize
the delay between the observations and the availability of the
results. For the NEOS the delay was approximately 2 weeks,
which has not changed by its transition to the IVS R4 as all
the routine procedures were already established. For the IVS
R4, as new stations were added the data shipping procedures
needed to be set up to be routine. Initially this caused unex-
pected delays, which were overcome with time. For the IVS R1
processing, experience needed to be gained at the correlators at
312
Wolfgang Schluter and Nancy Vandenberg: IVS Products for Precise Global Reference Frames
Nothnagel, A., Ch. Steinforth 2002, IVS Analysis Coordination, IAG
CSTG Bulletin no.17, Progress Report 2001
Schuh H., Boehm, J. 2002, IVS- Zenith Wet path delay , 2002 General
Meeting Proceedings, NASA/CP-2002- 210002, Greenbelt, MD
Bonn, Haystack and Washington during the first months. The
delay between the observation to the results is approximately
two weeks since April 2002. This should be regarded as signif-
icant and real progress, even though the WG2 goal of only 4
days has not been achieved. Improvements for data transmis-
sion and a higher throughput at the correlator were achieved,
after the implementation of the newly developed Mark 5 digi-
tal data recording system, which has e-VLBI capabilities, al-
lowing data transmission via high speed Internet links. The
determination of DUT1 from the near-daily 1-hour observa-
tions known as "Intensives" have been carried out since 1983
via the baseline Wettzell-Westford, since 1994 via the baseline
Wettzell-Green Bank and since 2000 via the baseline Wettzell-
Kokee Park. These baselines now employ Mark 5 systems . In
the year 2002 a time series observed on the baseline Wettzell-
Tsukba/Japan with the Japanese K4 system was set up. The
regular application of fast Internet links for the INTENSIVE's
will start soon, which will allow rapid availability of DUT1.
The VLBI observations from the IVS R1 and R4 allow determi-
nation of tropospheric parameters, in particular the wet zenith
path delay. Since July 2003 the zenith wet path delay is an of-
ficial IVS product. The University of Vienna is combining the
solutions of five Analysis Centers (Schuh, Boehm 2002).
5. Plans
A "Vision Paper 2010" for geodetic VLBI is under develop-
ment by IVS. Considering our increasing requirements (e.g. the
IGGOS project, the increase in radio frequency interference,
our aging antennas) general refinements and upgrades of VLBI
technology are needed in the future. A Working Group, WG3,
was established with the objective to develop future visions.
Goals include unattended observation, improved global cover-
age of the network, employment of the new data transmission
technologies and provision of near real time correlation and
products. In collaboration with radio astronomers some guide-
lines for future developments will be derived.
References
Vandenberg, N.R. (editor) 1999, Annual Report 1999, NASA/TP-
1999-209243, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2001, Annual Report 2000,
NASA/TP-2001-209979, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2002, Annual Report 2001,
NASA/TP-2002-210001, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2003, Annual Report 2002,
NASA/TP-2003-211619, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2004, Annual Report 2003,
NASA/TP-2004-212254, Greenbelt, MD;
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2000, 2000 General Meeting
Proceedings, NASA/CP-2000-209893, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2002b, 2002 General Meeting
Proceedings, NASA/CP-2002-210002, Greenbelt, MD
Vandenberg, N. R., Baver K. D.(editors) 2004b, 2004 General Meeting
Proceedings, NASA/CP-200-212255, Greenbelt, MD
Schuh, H. et al. 2002, IVS Working Group 2 for Product Specification
and Observing programs, Final Report, Annual Report 2001, page
13 - 45, NASA/TP-2002-210001, Greenbelt, MD
|
astro-ph/9808315 | 1 | 9808 | 1998-08-27T18:49:36 | Spectroscopy of Outlying H II Regions in Spiral Galaxies: Abundances and Radial Gradients | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present the results of low dispersion optical spectroscopy of 186 H II regions spanning a range of radius in 13 spiral galaxies. Abundances for several elements (oxygen, nitrogen, neon, sulfur, and argon) were determined for 185 of the H II regions. As expected, low metallicities were found for the outlying H II regions of these spiral galaxies. Radial abundance gradients were derived for the 11 primary galaxies; similar to results for other spiral galaxies, the derived abundance gradients are typically -0.04 to -0.07 dex/kpc. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Accepted: Astronomical Journal
Spectroscopy of Outlying H II Regions in Spiral Galaxies:
Abundances and Radial Gradients
National Radio Astronomy Observatory,2 PO Box 0, Socorro, NM 87801
Liese van Zee1
[email protected]
John J. Salzer3
Astronomy Department, Wesleyan University, Middletown, CT 06459 -- 0123
[email protected]
Martha P. Haynes
Center for Radiophysics and Space Research and
National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center4
Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853
[email protected]
Physics Department, St. Lawrence University, Canton, NY 13617
Aileen A. O'Donoghue
[email protected]
Thomas J. Balonek
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Colgate University
13 Oak Drive, Hamilton, NY 13346
[email protected]
8
9
9
1
g
u
A
7
2
1
v
5
1
3
8
0
8
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1Jansky Fellow
2The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the National Science Foundation, operated under a
cooperative agreement by Associated Universities Inc.
3NSF Presidential Faculty Fellow
4The National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center is operated by Cornell University under a cooperative agreement
with the National Science Foundation.
-- 2 --
ABSTRACT
We present the results of low dispersion optical spectroscopy of 186 H II regions
spanning a range of radius in 13 spiral galaxies. Abundances for several elements
(oxygen, nitrogen, neon, sulfur, and argon) were determined for 185 of the H II regions.
As expected, low metallicities were found for the outlying H II regions of these spiral
galaxies. Radial abundance gradients were derived for the 11 primary galaxies; similar
to results for other spiral galaxies, the derived abundance gradients are typically -- 0.04
to -- 0.07 dex kpc−1.
Subject headings: galaxies: abundances -- galaxies: ISM -- galaxies: spiral
1.
Introduction
Radial abundance gradients, in the sense that the inner H II regions have higher abundances
than the outer ones, are found in almost all large spiral galaxies. For instance, a gradient of
approximately -- 0.07 dex kpc−1 is observed in both the stellar and gaseous components of the
Milky Way (Shaver et al. 1983; Smartt & Rolleston 1997). The physical basis for the presence of
an abundance gradient is still a matter of debate; successful chemical evolution models typically
include a combination of (1) a radial dependence on the star formation activity, generally taking
the form of a Schmidt law (e.g., Phillipps & Edmunds 1991); (2) radial gas flows (e.g., Edmunds
1990; Gotz & Koppen 1992); and (3) a radial dependence on stellar yields due to IMF variations
(e.g., Gusten & Mezger 1982). The relative importance of these processes can be constrained
by investigating the observed gradients for a large sample of galaxies which span a range of
morphological type (e.g., Vila -- Costas & Edmunds 1992) or environment (e.g., Skillman et al.
1996).
Extensive studies of individual galaxies either via spectroscopy (e.g., NGC 5457, Kennicutt
& Garnett 1996; NGC 2403, Garnett et al. 1997) or spectrophotometric imaging (e.g., NGC 628,
NGC 6946, Belley & Roy 1992; NGC 925, NGC 1073, Martin & Roy 1994; NGC 2366, NGC
4395, Roy et al. 1996; NGC 1313, Walsh & Roy 1997) indicate that large numbers of H II region
abundances are necessary to determine accurate abundance gradients. While spectrophotometric
imaging observations have the advantage that large samples are easily obtained, they are not
as accurate as spectroscopic studies for individual objects. Recently, several large spectroscopic
surveys and literature compilations have appeared (e.g., McCall et al. 1985; Vila -- Costas &
Edmunds 1992; Zaritsky et al. 1994). These studies indicate that the oxygen abundance gradients
may be a function of Hubble type (e.g., Vila -- Costas & Edmunds 1992). Furthermore, the
mass surface density appears to play a critical role in supporting an abundance gradient (e.g.,
Vila -- Costas & Edmunds 1992; Garnett et al. 1997).
-- 3 --
If the abundance gradients are constant across the full radial extent of the galaxy, the
outermost H II regions in spiral galaxies should have low abundances, similar to those found
in low luminosity dwarf galaxies. Thus, the outlying H II regions of spiral galaxies provide a
new environment in which to investigate metallicity effects on elemental yields (particularly of
nitrogen) and other aspects of the star formation process.
In this paper, we present the results of new spectroscopic observations of a large number
of outlying H II regions in 11 spiral galaxies. In the few instances where the target galaxies
did not have previous abundance measurements reported in the literature, spectra of inner H II
regions were obtained as well. The observations presented in this paper complement previous
spectroscopic observations by extending the radial coverage. In a previous paper (van Zee et
al. 1998, hereafter Paper I), these H II region abundances were used to investigate the origin of
nitrogen in low metallicity environments. Here, we present the complete data set and discuss the
derived radial abundance gradients. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the galaxy
sample is defined and the imaging and spectroscopic observations are described. The observed H
II region line strengths and diagnostics are presented in Section 3. The abundance derivations are
described in Section 4; the radial abundance gradients for all 11 spiral galaxies are discussed in
Section 5. The conclusions are summarized in Section 6.
2. Observations
2.1. Sample Selection
To facilitate identification of outlying H II regions and to minimize internal extinction,
a sample of 11 nearly face -- on spiral galaxies were selected for imaging and spectroscopic
observations. In addition, two galaxies from the NGC 2805 group (NGC 2820 and IC 2458) were
also observed; NGC 2820 is a nearly edge -- on spiral and IC 2458 is a dwarf galaxy. Table 6 lists
the physical properties of the sample galaxies. The morphological type, inclination, position angle,
and isophotal radius (at the 25 mag arcsec−2 surface brightness isophote) for each system have
been taken from the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991). The inclination was derived by assuming
an intrinsic axial ratio, q, of 0.2. With the exception of NGC 1068 and NGC 2903, all of the
primary targets are classified as late -- type (Sc or Sd) spirals. Furthermore, all the galaxies in the
sample have low inclination angles and subtend a large angular size.
The distances listed in Table 6 were derived either from Cepheid variables (NGC 2403,
Freedman & Madore 1988; NGC 925, Silbermann et al. 1996; NGC 5457, Kelson et al. 1996), or
were estimated from the recessional velocity based on a Virgocentric infall model and an assumed
H0 of 75 km s−1 Mpc−1 (NGC 628, NGC 1068, NGC 2903, NGC 3184: Zaritsky et al. 1994; NGC
4395: Wevers et al. 1986; NGC 1232, NGC 1637, NGC 2805, NGC 2820, IC 2458: this paper).
Absolute magnitudes were computed from the apparent magnitudes listed in the RC3, corrected
for internal and Galactic extinction, and the adopted distances. All of the primary targets have
-- 4 --
B -- band apparent magnitudes brighter than 11.2, corresponding to absolute magnitudes ranging
between -- 17.7 and -- 21.3.
Of the 11 primary targets, three (NGC 1232, NGC 1637, and NGC 2805) had no previous
abundance measurements reported in the literature. The other 8 were known to have moderate
to steep abundance gradients (e.g., Zaritsky et al. 1994), but lacked abundance measurements of
the outermost H II regions. The total number of new H II region abundances for each galaxy
are tabulated in Table 6. Multiple H II regions were observed in all galaxies except for NGC
1068, where the outlying H II regions were discovered to be too faint for the planned abundance
measurements.
2.2. Optical Imaging
In preparation for the spectroscopic observations, wide field images of the selected galaxies
were obtained with the Burrell Schmidt telescope at KPNO5 in 1995 April and October and 1996
January. The S2KA CCD had a read noise of 3 e− and a pixel scale of 2.028′′ pix−1. A gain of
2.5 DN/e− was selected for the 1995 April observing run; a gain of 3.7 DN/e− was selected for
all subsequent observing runs. While the typical seeing was less than 2′′, the spatial resolution
of these images is dominated by the large pixel size. R -- band and Hα narrow band images were
obtained for all program galaxies. During the 1995 April run, three to four 450 second observations
of each program galaxy were obtained with the R -- band filter; during the subsequent observing
runs, one 600 second exposure was obtained for each galaxy. During all the observing runs, the
Hα imaging consisted of several sets of ON -- OFF -- ON observations with individual exposure times
of 600 seconds each. A total of three to five Hα sets were obtained for each program galaxy
(corresponding to total on -- line integration times of 3600 to 6000 seconds). The Hα filter (KP
1468) had a central wavelength of 6571 A and a width of 84 A; the OFF images were obtained
through a matched off -- line filter (KP 808) centered at 6411 A, with a width of 88A.
Data reduction was performed within the IRAF6 package and followed standard practice.
After bias subtraction and flat fielding, images with multiple exposures were aligned and the sky
background was subtracted. The images were then scaled to the level of the "most photometric"
(either the frame with the lowest airmass or the one taken under the best weather conditions) and
combined with a median filter. At the same time, the off -- line Hα images were scaled to the level
of the on -- line images, based on the observed counts for at least six to ten stars in each frame.
Because the majority of these images were taken under non -- photometric conditions, they
were used primarily as finding charts for the outlying (faint) H II regions. The relevant R -- band
5Observations made with the Burrell Schmidt of the Warner and Swasey Observatory, Case Western Reserve
University.
6IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories.
-- 5 --
and continuum subtracted Hα images are presented in Figure 1. The images are oriented with
north to the top and east to the left. The 2′ slits on the Hα images indicate the spatial scale of
each pair of images.
Optical scale lengths (Rd), tabulated in Table 6, were derived from the R -- band images. The
IRAF task ELLIPSE was used to fit ellipses of constant surface brightness. We note that several
of the galaxies in the present sample are asymmetric, making such fits difficult to interpret. In
particular, satisfactory fits were obtained only for NGC 628, NGC 925, NGC 1232, NGC 2403,
and NGC 2903. The scale length tabulated in Table 6 for NGC 1068 was derived from a fit to
only the outer isophotes, those with r > 50′′. By far the worst fit was obtained for the severely
asymmetric spiral NGC 1637; the scale length presented here should only be taken as a rough
estimate. The derived scaled lengths for the remaining galaxies, NGC 2805, NGC 3184, NGC
4395, and NGC 5457, are reasonable, although we caution that the ellipse fitting was not ideal
due to their modest asymmetries.
2.3. Optical Spectroscopy
Low resolution optical spectra of the selected H II regions were obtained with the Double
Spectrograph on the 5m Palomar7 telescope during observing runs in 1996 May and November
and 1997 January. The long slit (2′) was set at a 2′′ aperture during all observing runs; the seeing
was generally better than 2′′. During all observing runs, a 5500 A dichroic was used to split the
light to the two sides (blue and red), providing complete spectral coverage from 3500 -- 7600 A. The
blue spectra were acquired with the 300 lines/mm diffraction grating (blazed at 3990 A). The red
spectra were acquired with the 316 lines/mm diffraction grating (blazed at 7500 A). A thinned
800×800 TI CCD with a read noise of 8 e−, a gain of 1.5, and 9.2 A effective resolution (2.19
A/pix) was used on the blue side; a thinned 1024×1024 TEK CCD with a read noise of 7.5, gain
of 2.0, and an effective resolution of 7.8A (2.46 A/pix) was used on the red side. The spatial scale
of the long slit was 0.8 arcsec/pix on the blue and 0.49 arcsec/pix on the red. The CCD on the
blue side had moderate focussing problems across the full wavelength range. During all observing
runs, the focus was optimized for Hδ and [O III] λ4363.
The observations were conducted via blind offsets from nearby stars. Stellar and H II region
coordinates were derived from the Schmidt narrow band Hα images. Astrometric plate solutions
were calculated using the coordinates of the bright stars in the HST Guide Star Catalog, yielding
positions accurate to within 1′′. The telescope pointing was verified each run by using the same
offsetting technique to move between several stars in a field. Offsets between stars and H II regions
were typically less than 20′. Previous observations (e.g., van Zee et al. 1997) indicated that the
7Observations at the Palomar Observatory were made as part of a continuing cooperative agreement between
Cornell University and the California Institute of Technology.
-- 6 --
5m telescope could point and track accurately; nonetheless, the newly commissioned offset guider
was used to improve the tracking during long exposures.
To reduce light losses due to atmospheric refraction, the slit position angle was set close to
the parallactic angle during the observations. The slit positions are illustrated on the Hα images
in Figure 1 and tabulated in Table 6. The slit numbers listed in Table 6 are ordered in increasing
Right Ascension for each galaxy and each slit is labelled by the offset (arcseconds east -- west
and north -- south) from the galaxy center (tabulated in Table 6). The offsets do not necessarily
correspond to the location of an H II region since the telescope was often pointed between two (or
more) H II regions in order to maximize the number of H II regions observed. The astrometric
pointing centers are also given in Table 6 along with the position angle (PA) of the slit. Finally,
the observing run and the total integration times are listed. Most observations consisted of two or
three 1200 second exposures; in a few instances, primarily due to time constraints, the integration
time was only 300 seconds.
Flux calibration was obtained by observations of at least 5 standards per night (Stone
1977; Oke & Gunn 1983; Massey et al. 1988), interspersed with the H II region observations.
Wavelength calibration was obtained by observations of arc lamps taken before and after each H
II region observation. A Hollow Cathode (Fe and Ar) lamp was used to calibrate the blue spectra;
a combination of He, Ne, and Ar lamps were used to calibrate the red spectra.
The spectra were reduced and analyzed with the IRAF package. The spectral reduction
included bias subtraction, scattered light corrections, and flat fielding with both twilight and dome
flats. The 2 -- dimensional images were rectified based on the arc lamp observations and the trace of
stars at different positions along the slit. The sky background was removed from the 2-dimensional
images by fitting a low order polynomial along each row of the spectra. One dimensional spectra
of each H II region were then extracted from the rectified images. Throughout this paper, the
H II region nomenclature is based on east -- west and north -- south offsets from the galaxy center.
These offsets were derived either from the pointing center (if only one H II region was in the slit),
or were computed for each H II region from the pointing center, the slit position angle, and the
spatial scale of the image. These offsets, therefore, are generally only accurate to 1 -- 2′′.
The 1D spectra were corrected for atmospheric extinction and flux calibrated. Since the
night -- to -- night variation in the calculated sensitivity function was small, the sensitivity function
for each run was created using the standard stars from all nights. As a final step, the individual
20 minute exposures were combined. In general, there was excellent agreement in the continuum
level of the final blue and red spectra for each H II region, indicating that the flux calibration and
extraction regions were well matched.
A few representative spectra are shown in Figure 2. The three H II regions in Figure 2 are
ordered in increasing distance from the center of NGC 1232. Figure 2(a) illustrates a typical
spectrum from the inner galaxy; absorption features are present and the low ionization lines, such
as [O II] and [N II], are strong while the high ionization lines, such as [O III], are extremely weak
-- 7 --
or absent. Figure 2(b) illustrates a typical spectrum from the outer galaxy; the emission lines
dominate the spectrum, with both the low and high ionization lines at moderate strength. Finally,
Figure 2(c) illustrates the low abundance nature of the outermost H II regions. Here, the [O III]
lines are very strong while [N II] and [S II] are weak, indicating that this is a high temperature
(low abundance) H II region. Furthermore, [O III] λ4363 is clearly detected in this spectrum,
permitting an accurate temperature estimate (see Section 4.3).
3. Line Ratios and Diagnostic Diagrams
3.1. Extinction
The reddening along the line of sight to each H II region was computed from the observed
strengths of the Balmer emission lines. The intrinsic line ratios of Hα/Hβ and Hγ/Hβ were
interpolated from the values of Hummer & Storey (1987) for case B recombination, assuming that
Ne = 100 cm−3 and Te = 10000 K. For the few H II regions where the [O III] λ4363 line was
detected, the electron temperature as derived from the [O III] lines (see Section 4.3) was used
instead of the nominal 10000 K. The reddening function, f (λ), normalized at Hβ from the galactic
reddening law of Seaton (1979) as parameterized by Howarth (1983), was used, assuming a value
of R = AV /EB−V = 3.1. When necessary to bring the two Balmer line ratios into agreement,
an underlying Balmer absorption with an equivalent width of 2 A was assumed. The reddening
coefficients, cHβ, derived for each H II region are listed in Table 6 and are shown as a function
of radius in Figure 3. While there is a fair amount of scatter in the reddening plots, the general
trend is for the outer H II regions to have lower extinction than the inner ones. Similar extinction
gradients have been seen in photometric studies of the dust content in spiral galaxies (e.g., Peletier
et al. 1995).
3.2. Line Intensities
The reddening corrected line intensities relative to Hβ are given in Table 6. In this and
subsequent tables, each H II region is identified by its east -- west and north -- south offsets from
the galaxy center (in arcsec, north and east are positive) and by its slit number (Table 6).
Furthermore, the H II regions for each galaxy are ordered by increasing radial distance. The error
associated with each relative line intensity was determined by taking into account the Poisson
noise in the line, the error associated with the sensitivity function, the contributions of the Poisson
noise in the continuum, read noise, sky noise, and flat fielding or flux calibration errors, the error
in setting the continuum level (assumed to be 10% of the continuum level), and the error in the
reddening coefficient. For a few of the high abundance H II regions, the [O III] lines were so weak
that [O III] λ4959 was not detected. In those instances, the tabulated [O III] line intensities were
derived by assuming that the [O III] λ5007 line intensity was 2.88 times the intensity of [O III]
λ4959.
-- 8 --
3.3. Diagnostic Diagrams
Since the majority of the H II regions in this sample are from the outer regions of spiral
galaxies, they should form well defined H II region sequences in diagnostic diagrams (e.g.,
Osterbrock 1989). A few galactic nuclei (NGC 925+002 -- 002, NGC 1637 -- 001 -- 000, and NGC
4395 -- 003 -- 003) were also observed, however, so it is worthwhile to examine such plots to determine
if these are stellar photoionized emission regions or AGN. Several of the line ratios commonly used
as H II region diagnostics are tabulated in Table 6 and are graphically shown in Figures 4 and 5. In
these and subsequent Figures, the H II regions in each galaxy are coded by common symbols. The
well defined H II region sequence formed by the [N II]/Hα and [O III]/Hβ line ratios is illustrated
in Figure 4. A theoretical curve from the H II region model of Baldwin et al. (1981) is superposed
on the data in Figure 4(a), illustrating that the majority are indeed H II regions. Panel (b) shows
the same diagnostic, but with the sum of [O II]/Hβ and [O III]/Hβ (R23) on one axis instead of
[O III]/Hβ (after McCall et al. 1985). In both of these plots, NGC 4395 -- 003 -- 003 (marked by
an arrow) deviates from the overall H II region sequence. This supports the suggestion by Ho et
al. (1995) that the nucleus of NGC 4395 harbors a dwarf Seyfert. Similarly, while the diagnostic
diagrams from [S II]/Hα are less definitive, the nucleus of NGC 4395 again falls outside of the H
II region sequence in Figure 5. Due to the unknown ionization source for NGC4395 -- 003 -- 003, it
has been excluded from the following abundance analysis.
4. Abundance Determinations
Several assumptions are required to convert observed line ratios into nebular abundances. In
sections 4.1 -- 4.3, we describe the methodology used to obtain the electron density and electron
temperature for each H II region. In section 4.4, we describe the ionization correction factors
which were used to convert the derived ionic abundances to nebular abundances. Finally, in
sections 4.5 and 4.6 we discuss the derived oxygen abundances and the relative enrichments of
nitrogen, neon, sulfur, and argon.
4.1. Electron Density
The density sensitive line ratio [S II] λ6717/6731 is tabulated for each H II region in Table 6
and graphically illustrated in Figure 6. The maximum value of this line ratio in the low density
limit is marked on Figure 6. The majority of the H II regions are within the low density limit
(I(λ6717)/I(λ6731) > 1.35). In the following abundance analysis, an electron density of 100 cm−3
was assumed for the majority of the H II regions; in the few instances where the [S II] line ratios
-- 9 --
were below the low density limit, a version of the FIVEL program of De Robertis et al. (1987)
was used to calculate the electron density from the observed [S II] line ratios.
4.2. Semi -- Empirical Oxygen Abundances
The optical oxygen lines ([O II] λ3727 and [O III] λλ4959, 5007) are sensitive to both the
oxygen abundance and electron temperature. At low metallicities, the dominant coolant is the
collisionally excited Lyman series, and thus the total oxygen line intensity (R23 ≡ ([O II]+[O
III])/Hβ) increases as the abundance increases. As the metallicity increases, however, the infrared
fine structure lines, such as the 52µ and 88µ oxygen lines and the C+ 158µ transition, begin to
dominate the cooling. At an oxygen abundance of approximately 1/3 solar, the intensity of the
optical oxygen lines reaches a maximum and then declines as the oxygen abundance increases.
The behavior of the optical oxygen line intensities as a function of oxygen abundance has been
examined via semi -- empirical methods (e.g., Searle 1971; Pagel et al. 1979; Alloin et al. 1979;
Edmunds & Pagel 1984; Dopita & Evans 1986; Skillman 1989) and derived from H II region
ionization models (e.g., McGaugh 1991; Olofsson 1997). The theoretical models of McGaugh
(1991) are shown in Figure 7. The surface is double valued due to the ambiguity between high
and low abundances. Furthermore, the geometry of the H II region (represented by the average
ionization parameter, ¯U, the ratio of ionizing photon density to particle density) introduces a
further spread in the estimated abundance for a given R23. In addition, aging of the H II regions
can also introduce further scatter as both the ionization parameter and the shape of the ionizing
spectrum evolve (e.g., Stasi´nska & Leitherer 1996; Olofsson 1997); we do not include such effects
in the present analysis.
The observed line strengths for the H II regions are plotted in Figure 7. The lowest values of
R23 occur for the innermost H II regions observed, and therefore presumably populate the high
abundance side of the R23 surface (see below). At these high oxygen abundances, the ionization
parameter ( ¯U) is approximately 0.001 for all of the H II regions. In contrast, the H II regions with
low oxygen abundances span a wide range of ¯U, indicating that it is important to include such
ionization effects when using the strong line method to estimate oxygen abundances.
The process of determining empirical oxygen abundances from the strong line ratios requires
several steps. First, abundances for both the high and low abundance side of the surface were
determined. Further information is required, however, to resolve the ambiguity between these
two values. The degeneracy can be broken by looking at the line strengths of other species. For
instance, the [N II]/[O II] line ratio forms a single parameter sequence from high to low abundance
(Figure 8). In general, H II regions with log ([N II]/[O II]) < -- 1.0 are believed to have low oxygen
abundances, while those with log ([N II]/[O II]) greater than -- 1.0 are on the high abundance side.
For those H II regions where the [N II]/[O II] diagnostic was conclusive (those with log ([N II]/[O
II]) > -- 0.8 or log ([N II]/[O II]) < -- 1.05), the abundance from the appropriate side of the surface
was assigned.
-- 10 --
A large fraction of the H II regions in this sample fall in the ambiguous region of the R23
relation (the turnover region) where the [N II]/[O II] diagnostic is inconclusive. Thus, it was
necessary to identify an alternative means of determining the oxygen abundance for these H II
regions. Like the [N II]/[O II] diagnostic, the [N II]/Hα ratio increases with increasing oxygen
abundance (Figure 9). The relation between the [N II]/Hα line ratio and the oxygen abundance
was determined by a weighted least squares fit to the low abundance H II regions from van Zee
et al. (1997) and the high abundance H II regions (8.8 < 12 + log (O/H) < 9.1) in the present
sample:
12 + log(O/H) = 1.02 log([NII]/Hα) + 9.36.
(1)
Note that the [N II]/Hα line ratio is only valid as a metallicity estimator for 12 + log (O/H) < 9.1
and in the absence of shock excitation. Furthermore, with typical errors of 0.2 dex or more, it is
not a particularly accurate abundance estimator. However, it does provide an additional method
to break the ambiguity of the R23 abundances.
For those H II regions where the oxygen abundance could not be resolved based on the [N
II]/[O II] line ratio, the [N II]/Hα relation was used to calculated an empirical oxygen abundance.
This empirical oxygen abundance was then compared with the two (high and low abundance)
estimates from the R23 relation. Whichever R23 abundance was closest to the empirical abundance
was then assigned, unless both the R23 abundances were significantly different from the empirical
abundance. In the instances where neither the upper nor the lower branch R23 abundances were
within 0.2 dex of the empirical abundance, the empirical abundance was assigned. This primarily
occurred when the empirical abundance estimate was between 8.2 and 8.5, corresponding to the
turnover region of the R23 relation, a region where typical errors are several tenths of a dex.
4.3. Electron Temperature
The preferred method of obtaining an estimate of the electron temperature of the ionized gas
is to derive it from the corrected line strengths of the [O III] lines. For the 16 H II regions where
[O III] λ4363 was detected (9% of the sample), the [O III] ratio λλ4959, 5007/λ4363 is tabulated
in Table 6. A version of the FIVEL program of De Robertis et al. (1987) was used to compute Te
from this reddening -- corrected line ratio. Not unexpectedly, the H II regions with detectable [O
III] λ4363 correspond to those with high Te; the electron temperatures were typically in the range
of 9000 to 14000 K, with errors of 300 to 600 K.
In most cases, however, [O III] λ4363 was not detected, or was contaminated by the nearby
In these instances, the electron temperature was estimated from
Hg λ4358 night sky line.
ionization models. Because oxygen is one of the dominant coolants, the electron temperature
depends strongly on the oxygen abundance. Thus, if the oxygen abundance is known, the electron
temperature can be estimated. The anticorrelation between oxygen abundance and electron
temperature (Pagel et al. 1979; Shaver et al. 1983) was used in a self -- consistent manner to
-- 11 --
estimate Te. The errors in the derived temperatures are quite large. For the H II regions where
the electron temperature was derived from the assumed oxygen abundance, the error in the
electron temperature was set to yield the appropriate error (as determined by the calibration
process) in the computed oxygen abundance. For the abundances estimated from R23 (71% of
the sample), this corresponds to 0.1 dex, or ∼500 K for a Te of 5000 to 7000 K. For the oxygen
abundances estimated from the [N II]/Hα relation (20% of the sample), errors of 0.2 dex in the
oxygen abundance were adopted, corresponding to temperature uncertainties of ∼ 2000 K for a
Te of 10000 K. As a check of self -- consistency, the same method was used to estimate the electron
temperatures for those H II regions where [O III] λ4363 was detected; in general, the two methods
yielded similar results, with absolute differences less than the estimated errors for the empirical
method. The electron temperatures adopted for the subsequent abundance analysis are tabulated
in Table 6.
Numerical models of H II regions have shown that, particularly at low abundances, there are
significant differences between the temperatures in the high -- and low -- ionization zones (Stasi´nska
1980). This difference must be taken into account to derive accurate abundances. We therefore
adopt the approach taken by Pagel et al. (1992), who use the H II region models of Stasi´nska
(1990) to derive an approximation for the electron temperature of the O+ zone:
Te(O+) = 2[T −1
e
(O++) + 0.8]−1,
(2)
where Te is the electron temperature in units of 104 K.
4.4.
Ionization Correction Factors
For all atoms other than oxygen, the derivation of atomic abundances requires the use of
ionization correction factors (ICFs) to account for the fraction of each atomic species which is in
an unobserved ionization state. To estimate the nitrogen abundance, we have assumed that N/O
= N+/O+ (Peimbert & Costero 1969). To estimate the neon abundance, we have assumed that
Ne/O = Ne++/O++ (Peimbert & Costero 1969). To determine the sulfur and argon abundances,
we are forced to adopt an ICF from published H II region models to correct for the unobserved
S+3 and Ar+3 states. We have adopted analytical forms of the ICFs as given by Thuan et al.
(1995). In H II regions where S++ λ6312 was not detected, an ICF was assumed based on the
average value of the ICF in all other H II regions. The use of an "average" ICF assumes that
the ionization characteristics of the H II regions with non -- detections of the S++ λ6312 line are
similar to those where λ6312 was detected. This is not necessarily the case, but it appears to work
reasonably well. We have assumed an error of 50% in this "average" ICF of 5.8±2.9.
-- 12 --
4.5. Oxygen Abundances
The oxygen abundances tabulated in Table 6 were derived from the observed line strengths
(Table 6) and the relevant emissivity coefficients (based on the electron temperature (Table 6)
and electron density) as calculated by a version of the FIVEL program of De Robertis et al.
(1987). The errors in the derived abundances are dominated by the errors inherent in the electron
temperature estimates.
As expected, the outermost H II regions in the spiral galaxies have low oxygen abundances.
The new observations confirm the low abundance nature of H681 (+010+885) in NGC 5457
(Garnett & Kennicutt 1994), which has the lowest oxygen abundance (12 + log (O/H) = 7.92 ±
0.03) of all the spiral galaxy H II regions in this sample (the H II regions in the dwarf galaxy IC
2458 also have similarly low oxygen abundances). The highest oxygen abundances are found in
the asymmetric spiral NGC 1637, with typical abundances of 1.5 to 2 times the solar value.
The majority of the oxygen abundances were ultimately derived from the strong line method
(either from the McGaugh (1991) R23 calibration or the modified version of this R23 relation as
described in Section 4.2). Other calibrations of the R23 relation yield slightly different results. In
particular, the R23 calibration of Zaritsky et al. (1994) (ZKH) will yield very similar abundances
for H II regions with 12 + log (O/H) > 8.5 (Table 6). Note, however, that since the ZKH
analytical form does not explicitly take into account the turnover in the R23 relation, it can
result in artificially high abundances for the outlying H II regions. A comparison of the derived
abundances from the modified McGaugh calibration (this paper) with those derived from the
Zaritsky et al. (1994) analytical formula is shown in Figure 10. Also shown in Figure 10 and
tabulated in Table 6 are the R23 abundance estimates from the calibration of Edmunds & Pagel
(1984). It is clear from this plot that the EP84 calibration will yield steeper abundance gradients
than either the ZKH or the modified McGaugh calibrations used here.
4.6. Nitrogen, Neon, Sulfur, and Argon Abundances
The abundances of nitrogen, neon, sulfur, and argon were computed from the observed line
strengths (Table 6), the emissivity coefficients, and the ionization correction factors described in
Section 4.4. Their abundances relative to oxygen are tabulated in Table 6. The original purpose of
the observations described here was to investigate the N/O ratio in the outlying, low abundance, H
II regions of spiral galaxies. Detailed analysis of the derived N/O ratios is presented in a separate
paper (van Zee et al. 1998, Paper I). Briefly, as seen in other high metallicity H II regions, the
N/O ratio increases linearly with the oxygen abundance at high abundance. However, the N/O
ratio plateaus for H II regions with metallicities less than 1/3 solar, indicating that there is a
primary origin for nitrogen in low metallicity environments.
The relative abundances of the α elements (Ne, S, and Ar) are expected to be constant with
-- 13 --
increasing oxygen abundance. Their abundances relative to oxygen are shown in Figure 11. Also
shown in Figure 11 are the solar values (Anders & Grevesse 1989). As expected for primary
elements, the relative abundance ratios are essentially constant: the mean log (Ne/O) is -- 0.65 ±
0.18; the mean log (S/O) is -- 1.55 ± 0.15; and the mean log (Ar/O) is -- 2.28 ± 0.11. These mean
ratios are similar to those derived for low metallicity H II regions in dwarf galaxies (e.g., Thuan et
al. 1995; van Zee et al. 1997).
5. Radial Abundance Gradients
The oxygen abundances presented in this paper increase the total number of H II regions
observed in these spiral galaxies. Furthermore, a large fraction of the H II regions in this sample
are located at radii greater than half of the isophotal radius. These outlying H II regions provide
a significant lever -- arm for the computation of radial abundance gradients (see also Ferguson et al.
1998). The spiral galaxy abundance gradients are illustrated in Figure 12. All deprojected radii
have been computed from the H II region offsets and the assumed inclination and position angles
(Table 6); the deprojected radii are tabulated (in arcsec) in Table 6. In Figure 12, the deprojected
radii have been normalized by the isophotal radius (R25), as listed in the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et
al. 1991) and tabulated in Table 6. The filled symbols in Figure 12 represent H II regions from
the present study. The open circles represent data from the literature: NGC 628 (McCall et al.
1985), NGC 925 (Zaritsky et al. 1994), NGC 1068 (Evans & Dopita 1987; Oey & Kennicutt 1993),
NGC 2403 (McCall et al. 1985; Fierro et al. 1986; Garnett et al. 1997), NGC 2903 (McCall et al.
1985; Zaritsky et al. 1994), NGC 3184 (Zaritsky et al. 1994), NGC 4395 (McCall et al. 1985), and
NGC 5457 (Kennicutt & Garnett 1996). To place the literature abundances on a common scale
with the abundances derived in this paper, the analytical form of the R23 calibration presented by
Zaritsky et al. (1994) was used to compute the oxygen abundances. As illustrated in Table 6 and
Figure 10, this analytical form of the R23 calibration yields similar abundance estimates for high
abundance H II regions. The only exceptions to this recalibration of the literature data were the
few instances where abundances were derived from an electron temperature which was directly
measured, either through the [O III] or [O II] line ratios (e.g., NGC 5457, Garnett & Kennicutt
1994; NGC 2403, Garnett et al. 1997).
The oxygen abundance gradients obtained from weighted least -- squares fits to both the
literature and new data points are tabulated in Table 6. For those galaxies with previous
abundance gradients reported in the literature, the newly derived abundance gradients are
generally in agreement with older results (see, e.g., the compilations by Zaritsky et al. 1994;
Garnett et al. 1997). The few exceptions are NGC 925, NGC 1068, and NGC 4395. For NGC
1068, the one additional H II region in the present study is at such a large radius compared to the
previous observations that it determines the gradient. Further observations of the other outlying H
II regions in NGC 1068 will be necessary to confirm the derived gradient. For NGC 925 and NGC
4395, the new observations also result in steeper abundance gradients than previously reported
-- 14 --
in the literature. The majority of the H II regions in both of these galaxies are at, or near, the
R23 turnover, so the derived abundances have large errors. The previous spectroscopic studies of
NGC 925 (Zaritsky et al. 1994) and NGC 4395 (McCall et al. 1986) were limited by the small
number of H II regions observed; in these studies, the abundance gradients were swamped by the
intrinsic errors of the abundance measurements. Spectrophotometric imaging observations of a
large number of H II regions in NGC 925 (Martin & Roy 1994) suggested that a steeper abundance
gradient existed; the newly derived abundance gradient from the spectroscopic observations is
in good agreement with the spectrophotometric imaging results. Spectrophotometric imaging
observations of NGC 4395 indicated that the abundance gradient was flat (or nonexistent) in this
low luminosity galaxy (Roy et al. 1996); the new spectroscopic results suggest that a shallow
gradient exists, but the errors in the derived slope are quite large.
A large scatter in the oxygen abundance for a given radius can indicate azimuthal variations
of the abundance gradient An apparent branching of the abundance gradient of NGC 5457 at
radii between R/R25 ∼0.2 -- 0.5 was noticed by Kennicutt & Garnett (1996). The two branches
are spatially separate, with the higher abundance H II regions lying on the northwest half of
the galaxy and the lower abundance H II regions lying on the southeast side (near NGC 5461).
As discussed by Kennicutt & Garnett (1996), these abundance variations could arise from the
inherent asymmetry of the galaxy, from tidal interactions with its companions NGC 5474 and/or
NGC 5477, or from accretion of high -- velocity gas. Other galaxies, such as NGC 925 and NGC
2403, also show large variations in the abundance at a given radius. The H II regions in both of
these galaxies lie near the turnover region of the R23 relation, however. Thus, the large scatter in
oxygen abundance is probably due to the intrinsic errors in the abundance measurements. New
observations with solid detections of the temperature sensitive lines will be necessary to address
the validity of these abundance variations.
Observations of the Milky Way suggest that the abundance gradient may flatten in the
outer disk (e.g., V´ılchez & Esteban 1996). The outermost points of NGC 5457 suggest that the
abundance gradient may flatten in this galaxy as well. However, previous claims of flattening in the
inner regions of NGC 5457 (e.g. Zaritsky 1992; Scowen et al. 1992; Vila -- Costas & Edmunds 1992)
have not been substantiated (Henry & Howard 1995; Kennicutt & Garnett 1996). To determine
if flattening of the abundance gradient is a common phenomena of the outer disk, observations of
H II regions at even larger radii will be necessary. Such observations are challenging due to the
faintness of the outermost H II regions, but not impossible (e.g., Ferguson et al. 1998).
6. Conclusions
We have presented the results of high signal -- to -- noise spectroscopy of 186 H II regions
spanning a range of radius in 13 spiral galaxies. Abundances for several elements (oxygen,
nitrogen, neon, sulfur, and argon) were derived for all except the nucleus of NGC 4395. Below, we
summarize the main conclusions.
-- 15 --
(1) The H II region diagnostic diagrams indicate that the nucleus of NGC 4395 harbors a
dwarf Seyfert. The remaining 185 H II regions form a well defined H II region sequence in the
Osterbrock diagnostic diagrams. Furthermore, the majority of the H II regions are low density,
with an assumed Ne of 100 cm−3.
(2) A modified version of the R23 calibration of McGaugh (1991) was used to derive the
majority of the oxygen abundances. In this method, the [N II]/Hα line ratios are used to break
the degeneracy between the upper and lower branches; furthermore, this line ratio is used to
estimate the oxygen abundance for H II regions which fall in the R23 turnover region (8.2 < 12 +
log (O/H) < 8.5).
(3) The enrichment of the α elements (neon, sulfur, and argon) relative to oxygen is constant
for all H II regions in this sample. The mean α -- to -- oxygen ratios are consistent with those
derived for low metallicity H II regions (e.g., Thuan et al. 1995; van Zee et al. 1997). The mean
abundance ratios are: -- 0.65 ± 0.18, -- 1.55 ± 0.15, and -- 2.28 ± 0.11 for log (Ne/O), log (S/O), and
log (Ar/O), respectively.
(4) The outlying H II regions presented here extend the radial range of H II region abundances
measured in spiral galaxies. For those galaxies with previous abundance measurements, the newly
derived radial gradients are generally consistent with those previously reported. For the three
galaxies which had no abundance measurements reported in the literature (NGC 1232, NGC 1637,
and NGC 2805), each now has abundances measured in at least 15 H II regions.
(5) As expected, the outermost H II regions in the spiral galaxies have abundances similar to
those of low luminosity dwarf galaxies. These outlying H II regions provide a new environment in
which to investigate metallicity effects on stellar yields and the star formation process (see, e.g.,
van Zee et al. 1998).
We thank Elizabeth Barrett for processing several of the Hα images and Stacy McGaugh for
providing us with the ionization models. We thank the anonymous referee for comments which
improved the presentation of this paper. We thank Scott Lacey, Stacey Davis, Jennifer Heldmann,
Lai Man Lee, Alison Schirmer, and Matt Pickard for their assistance in the observations at the
Burrell Schmidt. They and TJB acknowledge travel support from the W.K. Keck Foundation
for their support of astronomy through the Keck Northeast Astronomy Consortium. AOD
acknowledges travel support by the Judge Francis Bergen Career Development Award in
Astrophysics, from the Dudley Observatory, Schenectady, New York. We acknowledge the financial
support by NSF grants AST95 -- 53020 to JJS and AST90 -- 23450 and AST95-28860 to MPH. This
research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED) which is operated by the
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National
Aeronautics and Space Administration.
-- 16 --
REFERENCES
Alloin, D., Collin -- Soufrin, S., Joly, M., & Vigroux, L. 1979, A&A, 78, 200
Anders, E., & Grevesse, N. 1989, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 53, 197
Baldwin, J. A., Phillips, M. M., & Terlevich, R. 1981, PASP, 93, 5
Belley, J., & Roy, J. -- R. 1992, ApJS, 78, 61
De Robertis, M. M., Dufour, R. J., & Hunt, R. W. 1987, JRASC, 81, 195
de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H. G., Buta, R., Paturel, G., & Fouqu´e, P. 1991,
Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies (Springer, New York) (RC3)
Dopita, M. A., & Evans, I. N. 1986, ApJ, 307, 431
Edmunds, M. G. 1990, MNRAS, 246, 678
Edmunds, M. G., & Pagel, B. E. J. 1984, MNRAS, 211, 507 (EP84)
Evans, I. N., & Dopita, M. A., 1987, ApJ, 319, 662
Ferguson, A. M. N., Gallagher, J. S., & Wyse, R. F. G. 1998, AJ, in press
Fierro, J., Torres -- Peimbert, S., & Peimbert, M. 1986, PASP, 98, 1032
Freedman, W. L., & Madore, B. F. 1988, ApJ, 332, L63
Garnett, D. R., & Kennicutt, R. C. 1994, 426, 123
Garnett, D. R., Shields, G. A., Skillman, E. D., Sagan, S. P., & Dufour, R. J. 1997, ApJ, 489, 63
Gotz, M., & Koppen, J. 1992, A&A, 262, 455
Gusten, R., & Mezger, P. G. 1982, Vistas, Astro., 26, 159
Henry, R. B. C., & Howard, J. W. 1995, ApJ, 438, 170
Ho, L. C., Filippenko, A. V., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1995, ApJS, 98, 477
Kelson, D. D., Illingworth, G. D., Freedman, W. F., Graham, J. A., Hill, R., Madore, B. F., Saha,
A., Stetson, P. B., Kennicutt, R. C., Mould, J. R., Hughes, S. M., Ferrarese, L., Phelps, R.,
Turner, A., Cook, K. H., Ford, H., Hoessel, J. G., & Huchra, J. 1996, ApJ, 463, 26
Kennicutt, R. C., & Garnett, D. R. 1996, ApJ, 456, 504
Kobulnicky, H. A., & Skillman, E. D. 1996, 471, 211
Kobulnicky, H. A., & Skillman, E. D. 1997, 489, 636
Martin, P., & Roy, J. -- R. 1994, ApJ, 424, 599
McCall, M. L., Rybski, P. M., & Shields, G. A. 1985, ApJS, 57, 1 (MRS)
McGaugh, S. S. 1991, ApJ, 380, 140
Oey, M. S., & Kennicutt, R. C. 1993, ApJ, 411, 137
Olofsson, K. 1997, A&A, 321, 29
-- 17 --
Osterbrock, D. E. 1989, Astrophysics of Gaseous Nebulae and Active Galactic Nuclei (University
Science Books, Mill Valley)
Pagel, B. E. J., Edmunds, M. G., Blackwell, D. E., Chun, M. S., & Smith, G. 1979, MNRAS, 189,
95
Pagel, B. E. J., Simonson, E. A., Terlevich, R. J., & Edmunds, M. G. 1992, MNRAS, 255, 325
Peimbert, M., & Costero, R. 1969, Bol. Obs. Tonantzintla y Tacubaya, 5, 3
Peletier, R. F., Valentijn, E. A., Moorwood, A. F. M., Freudling, W., Knapen, J. H., & Beckman,
J. E. 1995, A&A, 300, L1
Phillipps, S., & Edmunds, M. G. 1991, MNRAS, 251, 84
Roy, J. -- R., Belley, J., Dutil, Y., & Martin, P. 1996, ApJ, 460, 284
Scowen, P. A., Dufour, R. J., & Hester, J. J. 1992, AJ, 104, 92
Searle, L. 1971, ApJ, 168, 327
Shaver, P. A., McGee, R. X., Newton, L. M., Danks, A. C., Pottasch, S. R. 1983, MNRAS, 204, 53
Silbermann, N. A., Harding, P., Madore, B. F., Kennicutt, R. C., Saha, A., Stetson, P. B.,
Freedman, W. L., Mould, J. R., Graham, J. A., Hill, R. J., Turner, A., Bresolin, R.,
Ferrarese, L., Ford, H., Hoessel, J. G., Han, M., Huchra, J., Hughes, S. M. G., Illingworth,
G. D., Phelps, R., & Sakai, S. 1996, ApJ, 470, 1
Skillman, E. D. 1989, ApJ, 347, 883
Skillman, E. D., & Kennicutt, R. C. 1993, ApJ, 411, 655
Skillman, E. D., Kennicutt, R. C., & Shields, G. A., & Zaritsky, D. 1996, ApJ, 462, 147
Smartt, S. J. & Rolleston, W. R. J. 1997, ApJ, 481, L47
Stasi´nska, G. 1980, A&A, 84, 320
Stasi´nska, G. 1990, A&AS, 83, 501
Stasi´nska, G., & Leitherer, C. 1996, ApJS, 107, 661
Thuan, T. X., Izotov, Y. I., & Lipovetsky, V. A. 1995, ApJ, 445, 108
van Zee, L., Haynes, M. P., & Salzer, J. J. 1997, AJ, 114, 2479
van Zee, L., Salzer, J. J., & Haynes, M. P. 1998, ApJ, 497, L1 (Paper I)
Vila -- Costas, M. B., & Edmunds, M. G. 1992, MNRAS, 259, 121
V´ılchez, J. M. & Esteban, C. 1996, MNRAS, 280, 720
Walsh, J. R., & Roy, J. -- R. 1997, MNRAS, 288, 715
Wevers, B. M. H. R., van der Kruit, P. C., & Allen, R. J. 1986, A&AS, 66, 505
Zaritsky, D. 1992, ApJ, 390, L73
-- 18 --
Zaritsky, D., Kennicutt, R. C., & Huchra, J. P. 1994, ApJ, 420, 87 (ZKH)
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
-- 19 --
Table 1. Galaxy Properties
Galaxy
NGC 0628
NGC 0925
NGC 1068
NGC 1232
NGC 1637
NGC 2403
NGC 2805
IC 2458
NGC 2820
NGC 2903
NGC 3184
NGC 4395
NGC 5457
RA
(2000)
Dec
(2000)
Morph.a Distanceb
Type
[Mpc]
c
MB
ia
p.a.a
[arcsec]
[arcsec]
a
R25
Rd
No. HII
Regions
01:36:41.6
02:27:16.8
02:42:40.6
03:09:45.3
04:41:28.0
07:36:51.0
09:20:20.3
09:21:30.0
09:21:45.4
09:32:10.0
10:18:16.8
12:25:48.9
14:03:12.5
15:47:03
33:34:46
.SAS5..
.SXS7..
-- 00:00:46 RSAT3..
.SXT5..
-- 20:34:41
-- 02:51:27
.SXT5..
.SXS6..
65:36:04
.SXT7..
64:06:11
.I.0.P*
64:14:20
64:15:25
.SBS5P/
.SXT4..
21:30:18
.SXT6..
41:25:28
.SAS9..
33:32:52
54:20:55
.SXT6..
9.7
9.29
14.4
21.5
8.6
3.25
23.5
23.5
23.5
6.3
8.7
4.5
7.4
-- 20.1
-- 19.8
-- 21.3
-- 21.2
-- 18.5
-- 19.1
-- 20.7
-- 16.9
-- 20.1
-- 19.9
-- 19.3
-- 17.7
-- 21.2
25
58
32
30
36
60
42
· · ·
· · ·
64
21
18
18
25
102
70
90
15
126
125
· · ·
· · ·
17
135
147
37
314.
314.
212.
222.
120.
656.
189.
· · ·
· · ·
378.
222.
395.
865.
71.8
86.2
111.4
60.2
20.6
117.3
74.8
· · ·
· · ·
85.9
55.8
149.9
152.9
19
44
1
16
15
17
17
3
4
9
17
11
13
aMorphological type, inclination, position angle, and isophotal radius from de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 (RC3).
bDistance references: NGC 628, NGC 1068, NGC 2903, NGC 3184 -- Zaritsky et al. 1994; NGC 925 -- Silbermann et
al. 1996; NGC 1232, NGC 1637, NGC 2805, IC 2458, NGC 2820 -- Virgocentric infall model; NGC 2403 -- Freedman &
Madore 1988; NGC 4395 -- Wevers et al. 1986; NGC 5457 -- Kelson et al. 1996.
cAbsolute magnitude calculated from the apparent magnitude listed in the RC3 and the adopted distance to the
system.
-- 20 --
Table . Spectroscopy Observing Log
Slit
RA
Dec
PA
T
int
No.
Name
( )
( )
[deg]
Run
[sec]
NGC
{ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
NGC
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
{
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
{
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
{ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+ +
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
{ .
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
-- 21 --
Table . (continued)
Slit
RA
Dec
PA
T
int
No.
Name
( )
( )
[deg]
Run
[sec]
NGC
{ +
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
IC
{
{
.
.
Nov
(cid:2)
NGC
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
NGC
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
Jan
(cid:2)
NGC
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
NGC
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
{
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+ +
.
.
May
(cid:2)
+
{
.
.
May
(cid:2)
Table . HII Region Line Strengths
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
NGC
+ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
--
2
2
--
+ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
NGC
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
NGC
NGC
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
--
2
3
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
a
NGC
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
a
NGC
--
2
4
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
NGC
{ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
--
2
5
--
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
IC
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
NGC
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
NGC
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
NGC
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
a
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
a
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
a
{ {
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
NGC
--
2
6
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
Slit
[OII]
[NeIII]
[OIII]
[OI]
[SIII]
H(cid:11)
[NII]
[SII]
[ArIII]
EW
E-W N-S No. +
+
+
+
c
(H(cid:12) )
H (cid:12)
{ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
a
NGC
{ +
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ {
.(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
--
2
7
--
{ {
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ {
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
{ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
+ +
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) .
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) . . (cid:6) . .(cid:6) .
a
Only (cid:21) detected{ sum derived assuming (cid:21) /(cid:21) = .
Table . HII Region Ratios
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
NGC
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
NGC
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:6)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
--
2
8
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
NGC
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
--
2
9
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:6)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
--
3
0
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
NGC
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
IC
+
{
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
--
3
1
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
{
{
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:6)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
NGC
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
NGC
--
3
2
--
Table . (continued)
O(cid:11)sets
r
Slit
[OIII]
[SII]
Log
Log
Log
Log
Log
E-W N-S
[arcsec] No.
ratio
ratio
([OII]+[OIII])
([OIII]/[OII])
([NII]/H(cid:11))
([NII]/[OII])
([SII]/[OII])
{
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
NGC
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
--
3
3
--
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{
{
.
(cid:6)
. (cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
. (cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:6)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{. (cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
+ +
.
(cid:1) (cid:1) (cid:1)
.(cid:6) .
.(cid:6) .
{ .(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{.(cid:6) .
{ . (cid:6) .
-- 34 --
Table 5. HII Region Abundances
T(O++)
(O/H) (O/H)
12+Log(O/H) Log(N/O) Log(Ne/O) Log(S/O) Log(Ar/O) ZKH EP84
NGC 0628
Offsets
Slit
E-W N-S [arcsec] No.
r0
+081 -- 140
+062 -- 158
+047 -- 172
+044 -- 175
+180 -- 008
+178 -- 052
-- 086 +186
-- 075 +200
+203 -- 041
-- 073 +203
-- 069 +208
+254 -- 043
+256 -- 041
-- 232 +112
+262 -- 041
+264 -- 037
+265 -- 041
-- 227 +148
+292 -- 020
+002 -- 002
-- 005 +000
-- 008 +000
+010 -- 004
+015 -- 005
+030 -- 008
+036 -- 010
+042 -- 011
+087 -- 031
-- 012 -- 066
-- 047 -- 058
+135 -- 016
-- 109 +062
+137 +011
-- 137 +056
-- 145 -- 006
-- 080 +087
-- 114 +087
+161 +015
+174 +018
+182 +019
-- 187 -- 017
-- 192 -- 018
-- 192 -- 018
-- 198 -- 013
+209 -- 006
-- 200 -- 020
+217 -- 006
+156 -- 114
172.6
178.8
185.9
187.7
195.5
203.3
216.9
224.6
226.4
226.5
229.6
281.3
283.0
283.0
289.4
290.7
292.6
297.2
318.0
3.6
5.2
8.4
11.1
16.0
31.1
37.5
43.5
94.1
120.5
124.2
137.2
137.6
149.4
153.1
154.8
156.3
170.2
177.0
192.5
201.5
205.3
211.1
211.1
214.1
216.5
220.8
224.9
226.4
5700 ± 500
4800 ± 500
5500 ± 500
6200 ± 500
5100 ± 500
5300 ± 500
6400 ± 500
6700 ± 500
6000 ± 500
6200 ± 500
6900 ± 500
7000 ± 700
8500 ± 800
6400 ± 500
7500 ± 500
7400 ± 500
8300 ± 500
7400 ± 500
3
3
3
3
4
4
2
2
5
2
2
6
5
1
5
6
5
1
6 12000 ± 1500
5100 ± 500
5100 ± 500
5500 ± 500
5500 ± 500
5100 ± 500
5400 ± 500
5800 ± 500
5800 ± 500
6900 ± 500
8890 ± 520
7400 ± 500
7900 ± 500
7900 ± 1500
8900 ± 2000
7000 ± 500
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
12
9
9
12
6
13
6
5 10300 ± 2000
8300 ± 800
7
8500 ± 800
7
8700 ± 2000
13
8900 ± 1000
13
13 12500 ± 1500
7800 ± 500
8300 ± 800
8500 ± 800
5
3
5
3 10000 ± 2000
8600 ± 1600
7500 ± 500
15
5
15 11200 ± 1500
14
7700 ± 600
8.88±0.12
8.95±0.19
8.90±0.12
8.82±0.10
8.94±0.14
8.95±0.14
8.79±0.10
8.69±0.10
8.85±0.11
8.80±0.10
8.73±0.10
8.69±0.11
8.48±0.10
8.70±0.10
8.60±0.10
8.65±0.10
8.55±0.10
8.64±0.10
8.10±0.10
8.98±0.15
8.94±0.14
8.89±0.12
8.87±0.12
8.96±0.15
8.86±0.13
8.82±0.11
8.84±0.11
8.71±0.10
8.48±0.05
8.60±0.10
8.58±0.10
8.48±0.23
8.38±0.25
8.68±0.10
8.23±0.17
8.48±0.10
8.51±0.10
8.38±0.24
8.28±0.11
8.01±0.10
8.61±0.10
8.56±0.10
8.53±0.10
8.35±0.18
8.39±0.19
8.65±0.10
8.19±0.10
8.59±0.10
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.15±0.17 -- 0.68±0.34 -- 1.83±0.26 -- 2.16±0.21
-- 1.52±0.30
-- 1.14±0.24
-- 1.65±0.26 -- 2.22±0.22
-- 1.17±0.18
-- 1.81±0.25 -- 2.11±0.18
-- 1.12±0.15
-- 1.15±0.21
-- 1.61±0.27 -- 2.13±0.25
-- 1.14±0.20 -- 0.60±0.40 -- 1.80±0.27 -- 2.16±0.24
-- 1.19±0.14 -- 0.81±0.26 -- 1.26±0.25 -- 2.20±0.17
-- 1.23±0.13
-- 1.63±0.24 -- 2.18±0.16
-- 1.61±0.25 -- 2.03±0.19
-- 0.97±0.16
-- 1.18±0.15
-- 1.67±0.24 -- 2.20±0.17
-- 1.15±0.12 -- 0.73±0.23 -- 1.51±0.21 -- 2.20±0.15
-- 1.16±0.16
-- 1.50±0.25 -- 2.31±0.20
-- 1.38±0.24 -- 2.20±0.16
-- 1.20±0.13
-- 1.56±0.25
-- 1.47±0.14
-- 1.43±0.23 -- 2.14±0.14
-- 1.18±0.11
-- 1.55±0.24 -- 2.24±0.14
-- 1.26±0.11
-- 1.22±0.14
-- 1.62±0.24 -- 2.28±0.18
-- 1.39±0.11
-- 1.80±0.24 -- 2.37±0.14
-- 1.39±0.13 -- 0.70±0.25 -- 1.87±0.24 -- 2.29±0.16
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
NGC 0925
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.63±0.28 -- 2.09±0.26
-- 1.09±0.21
-- 1.45±0.27 -- 2.25±0.25
-- 1.14±0.21
-- 1.49±0.26 -- 2.23±0.22
-- 1.18±0.18
-- 1.44±0.26 -- 2.24±0.22
-- 1.16±0.18
-- 1.52±0.28 -- 2.09±0.26
-- 1.03±0.21
-- 1.45±0.26 -- 2.14±0.23
-- 1.19±0.19
-- 1.49±0.25 -- 2.13±0.20
-- 1.23±0.17
-- 1.18±0.17
-- 1.56±0.25 -- 2.23±0.20
-- 1.30±0.13 -- 0.28±0.23 -- 1.61±0.24 -- 2.18±0.15
-- 1.34±0.08 -- 0.61±0.13 -- 1.62±0.12 -- 2.11±0.10
-- 1.37±0.11 -- 0.25±0.20 -- 1.42±0.24 -- 2.27±0.13
-- 1.42±0.13 -- 0.25±0.25 -- 1.56±0.24 -- 2.30±0.16
-- 1.25±0.30 -- 0.50±0.69 -- 1.72±0.34 -- 2.14±0.37
-- 1.43±0.35 -- 2.41±0.43
-- 1.37±0.33
-- 1.35±0.12
-- 1.79±0.24 -- 2.27±0.15
-- 1.28±0.23 -- 0.70±0.52 -- 1.60±0.43 -- 2.17±0.29
-- 1.42±0.14 -- 0.43±0.26 -- 1.53±0.22 -- 2.26±0.17
-- 1.44±0.24 -- 2.35±0.16
-- 1.45±0.13
-- 1.55±0.36 -- 2.36±0.43
-- 1.46±0.35
-- 1.64±0.16
-- 1.39±0.25
-- 1.43±0.12 -- 0.89±0.23 -- 1.74±0.19 -- 2.22±0.16
-- 1.41±0.10 -- 0.67±0.18 -- 1.66±0.23 -- 2.34±0.12
-- 1.49±0.14 -- 0.68±0.26 -- 1.72±0.24 -- 2.36±0.17
-- 1.44±0.13 -- 0.68±0.25 -- 1.51±0.21 -- 2.37±0.16
-- 1.40±0.25 -- 0.72±0.56 -- 1.67±0.42 -- 2.32±0.31
-- 1.52±0.26
-- 1.55±0.30 -- 2.18±0.33
-- 1.34±0.11 -- 0.49±0.19 -- 1.68±0.23 -- 2.28±0.13
-- 1.48±0.15 -- 0.48±0.29 -- 1.52±0.25 -- 2.45±0.19
-- 1.46±0.12
-- 1.38±0.20 -- 2.33±0.14
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8.94
9.06
8.95
8.84
9.02
9.02
8.78
8.72
8.87
8.82
8.71
8.67
8.52
8.77
8.62
8.62
8.50
8.63
8.45
9.05
9.01
8.93
8.93
9.07
8.94
8.87
8.89
8.70
8.47
8.65
8.57
8.74
8.60
8.68
8.57
8.57
8.49
8.67
8.70
8.54
8.58
8.50
8.51
8.44
8.63
8.60
8.43
8.60
8.80
9.01
8.81
8.66
8.94
8.93
8.60
8.54
8.70
8.64
8.53
8.49
8.36
8.59
8.44
8.44
8.35
8.45
7.81
9.00
8.92
8.78
8.79
9.03
8.79
8.70
8.73
8.51
8.32
8.47
8.40
8.56
8.43
8.50
7.70
8.40
8.34
8.48
8.51
7.72
8.41
8.34
8.35
7.81
8.45
8.42
7.82
8.42
-- 35 --
Table 5 -- Continued
T(O++)
(O/H) (O/H)
12+Log(O/H) Log(N/O) Log(Ne/O) Log(S/O) Log(Ar/O) ZKH EP84
Offsets
Slit
E-W N-S [arcsec] No.
r0
-- 220 +004
+221 -- 006
+052 +130
-- 250 +019
+206 -- 114
+019 +143
-- 174 +140
-- 262 +011
-- 272 +016
-- 274 +010
-- 285 +023
-- 159 +162
-- 308 +035
-- 149 +177
-- 022 +227
228.7
229.0
249.1
255.6
256.8
258.7
269.3
270.2
279.2
283.1
291.1
294.3
313.2
314.0
396.8
3
7100 ± 500
15 11200 ± 1500
11 11000 ± 1500
9300 ± 2000
7400 ± 500
2
14
11 10000 ± 1000
4 11000 ± 1500
9800 ± 1000
1
1
9700 ± 1000
2 10300 ± 2000
9700 ± 1000
1
7800 ± 700
4
8100 ± 800
1
8600 ± 1600
4
8
9440 ± 1380
8.67±0.10
8.27±0.11
8.20±0.10
8.31±0.23
8.65±0.10
8.39±0.10
8.19±0.10
8.30±0.10
8.29±0.10
8.29±0.16
8.30±0.10
8.49±0.10
8.50±0.10
8.38±0.18
8.39±0.09
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.50±0.12 -- 0.71±0.22 -- 1.41±0.20 -- 2.33±0.14
-- 1.27±0.15
-- 1.58±0.25 -- 2.35±0.19
-- 1.57±0.15 -- 0.68±0.30 -- 1.68±0.25 -- 2.21±0.19
-- 1.27±0.29 -- 0.77±0.70 -- 1.31±0.62 -- 2.15±0.38
-- 1.45±0.11
-- 1.62±0.24 -- 2.29±0.14
-- 1.47±0.12 -- 0.52±0.23 -- 1.71±0.21 -- 2.32±0.15
-- 1.43±0.15 -- 0.65±0.30 -- 1.62±0.24 -- 2.31±0.19
-- 1.45±0.24
-- 1.52±0.14
-- 1.55±0.15
-- 1.34±0.24 -- 2.44±0.18
-- 1.41±0.23 -- 0.36±0.51 -- 1.50±0.40 -- 2.40±0.29
-- 1.58±0.15 -- 0.51±0.25 -- 1.25±0.23 -- 2.39±0.17
-- 1.28±0.24
-- 1.51±0.14
-- 1.43±0.14
-- 1.34±0.24 -- 2.10±0.17
-- 1.51±0.26 -- 0.63±0.40 -- 1.60±0.47 -- 2.40±0.32
-- 1.53±0.13 -- 0.87±0.24 -- 1.93±0.24 -- 2.23±0.16
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
8.67
8.31
8.44
8.66
8.62
8.32
8.51
8.50
8.56
8.48
8.56
8.63
8.61
8.69
8.46
8.49
7.91
7.81
8.48
8.45
7.90
7.76
7.76
7.71
7.78
7.70
8.45
8.43
8.50
7.79
+111 -- 088
159.5
1
4700 ± 300
9.04±0.13
-- 0.82±0.15
· · ·
-- 1.56±0.26
· · ·
9.11
9.13
NGC 1232
NGC 1068
+062 +004
+075 -- 001
+075 -- 012
+059 +058
-- 103 -- 021
-- 103 +022
+021 +091
+004 -- 101
+057 +098
+056 +106
+147 -- 030
+117 -- 084
+099 -- 101
+093 -- 110
+147 -- 065
+135 +114
-- 001 -- 000
+016 -- 001
-- 019 -- 009
-- 020 -- 000
-- 001 +026
+009 -- 026
+022 +018
+026 +018
-- 017 -- 031
+051 +012
-- 055 -- 011
+047 -- 031
+047 +046
-- 055 -- 032
+058 -- 054
62.2
75.0
76.2
88.9
105.8
106.0
106.5
115.9
126.0
133.9
151.0
151.6
152.4
156.7
164.8
187.9
1.2
19.5
23.9
24.2
26.6
29.6
30.7
34.8
35.8
61.7
66.3
67.7
69.9
71.0
93.3
4200 ± 200
4
4900 ± 300
5
5200 ± 300
5
4300 ± 200
4
5100 ± 400
1
5900 ± 400
1
5800 ± 400
3
5900 ± 400
2
7000 ± 700
4
6600 ± 500
4
5800 ± 500
8
6500 ± 500
7
6700 ± 500
6
7300 ± 800
6
6400 ± 500
8
7 10670 ± 650
3
4
2
2
3
4
4
5
2
7
1
6
7
1
8
4000 ± 200
4900 ± 300
5200 ± 300
3300 ± 200
4300 ± 200
4100 ± 200
3900 ± 200
4100 ± 200
3500 ± 200
3550 ± 200
4900 ± 300
3900 ± 200
4000 ± 200
4500 ± 200
6200 ± 400
9.07±0.10
8.94±0.11
8.87±0.10
9.08±0.10
8.94±0.14
8.83±0.10
8.85±0.10
8.80±0.10
8.67±0.10
8.74±0.10
8.85±0.10
8.77±0.10
8.71±0.10
8.64±0.11
8.75±0.10
8.20±0.05
9.18±0.11
8.91±0.13
8.94±0.11
9.30±0.21
9.10±0.10
9.10±0.10
9.12±0.11
9.11±0.11
9.26±0.16
9.24±0.17
8.95±0.11
9.12±0.10
9.12±0.10
9.04±0.10
8.74±0.10
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.49±0.24
-- 0.95±0.13
-- 1.45±0.25
-- 1.07±0.14
-- 1.42±0.24
-- 1.00±0.13
-- 0.93±0.30 -- 2.38±0.14
-- 0.88±0.12
-- 1.55±0.27 -- 2.34±0.22
-- 1.00±0.26
-- 1.61±0.24 -- 2.45±0.18
-- 1.07±0.13
-- 1.19±0.24 -- 2.24±0.16
-- 1.02±0.14
-- 1.20±0.23 -- 2.27±0.16
-- 1.03±0.13
-- 1.13±0.31 -- 2.30±0.20
-- 1.12±0.16
-- 1.61±0.24
-- 1.21±0.14
-- 1.56±0.25 -- 2.40±0.19
-- 1.05±0.17
-- 1.68±0.24 -- 2.44±0.16
-- 1.18±0.14
-- 1.71±0.24 -- 2.30±0.16
-- 1.16±0.13
-- 1.56±0.25 -- 2.39±0.21
-- 1.16±0.17
-- 1.58±0.24 -- 2.43±0.19
-- 1.22±0.14
-- 1.09±0.08 -- 0.96±0.11 -- 1.74±0.11 -- 2.23±0.10
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
NGC 1637
-- 0.55±0.14
-- 0.97±0.16
-- 0.82±0.15
-- 0.61±0.20
-- 0.79±0.12
-- 0.90±0.13
-- 0.96±0.14
-- 0.92±0.13
-- 0.79±0.17
-- 0.63±0.17
-- 0.89±0.14
-- 0.88±0.14
-- 0.88±0.14
-- 0.78±0.12
-- 1.14±0.12
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.40±0.25
-- 1.42±0.26
-- 1.61±0.26
-- 1.46±0.31
-- 1.53±0.24
-- 1.46±0.25
-- 1.50±0.25
-- 1.48±0.25
-- 1.52±0.28
-- 1.42±0.28
-- 1.51±0.25
-- 1.56±0.24 -- 2.16±0.17
-- 1.52±0.25
-- 1.44±0.24
-- 1.50±0.24 -- 2.06±0.15
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
9.18
9.02
8.98
9.16
9.03
8.88
8.91
8.88
8.70
8.76
8.90
8.80
8.74
8.66
8.78
8.53
9.23
9.01
9.01
9.35
9.18
9.18
9.20
9.18
9.30
9.31
9.06
9.22
9.18
9.15
8.82
9.25
8.92
8.87
9.23
8.95
8.72
8.77
8.72
8.52
8.57
8.74
8.61
8.55
8.48
8.60
7.73
9.34
8.92
8.92
9.52
9.25
9.25
9.29
9.25
9.44
9.46
9.01
9.32
9.26
9.21
8.64
-- 36 --
Table 5 -- Continued
T(O++)
(O/H) (O/H)
12+Log(O/H) Log(N/O) Log(Ne/O) Log(S/O) Log(Ar/O) ZKH EP84
NGC 2403
Offsets
Slit
E-W N-S [arcsec] No.
r0
+186 -- 177
+178 -- 203
+176 -- 211
+166 -- 229
+356 -- 195
+360 -- 190
+377 -- 163
+376 -- 106
-- 377 +104
-- 105 -- 218
-- 105 -- 224
-- 381 +082
+383 -- 056
-- 104 -- 256
-- 425 -- 002
-- 423 -- 010
-- 421 -- 017
-- 051 -- 009
+055 -- 026
+058 -- 022
-- 021 -- 045
+032 -- 056
-- 001 -- 079
-- 005 -- 080
-- 041 -- 090
+037 -- 115
+078 -- 107
-- 068 -- 079
+080 -- 110
+017 -- 119
+089 -- 107
+116 -- 098
-- 145 +104
-- 151 +102
+002 -- 006
-- 028 -- 007
-- 033 -- 007
+001 +001
-- 018 -- 009
+021 +011
-- 025 -- 013
262.4
286.4
295.2
315.9
414.2
417.5
435.2
446.8
448.9
452.0
461.5
464.5
482.7
511.2
585.8
590.3
594.1
60.8
61.5
63.4
65.3
68.8
97.2
99.8
130.0
136.4
137.6
137.7
141.3
142.3
142.8
152.3
178.4
182.2
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 062 -- 085
-- 065 -- 073
-- 067 -- 061
-- 060 -- 100
123.2
123.7
124.9
127.8
7600 ± 1400
4
8200 ± 1500
4
6200 ± 500
4
7100 ± 500
4
9100 ± 1000
5
8000 ± 1500
5
5
8500 ± 1500
6 10300 ± 2000
2
8000 ± 1500
7800 ± 1500
3
7400 ± 1400
3
8600 ± 1600
2
9100 ± 2000
6
3
8500 ± 1500
8900 ± 2000
1
9300 ± 2000
1
1
9000 ± 1000
5900 ± 400
2
7300 ± 800
6
6500 ± 500
6
6200 ± 500
3
7300 ± 800
6
6800 ± 500
4
7300 ± 800
4
8000 ± 800
4
9710 ± 490
5
5
7900 ± 500
3 11480 ± 840
6 10000 ± 1000
9700 ± 2000
5
6
9180 ± 2670
6 10970 ± 270
1
9300 ± 1000
1 12000 ± 1500
8.74±0.24
8.40±0.21
8.72±0.11
8.66±0.10
8.44±0.10
8.44±0.18
8.42±0.18
8.23±0.17
8.46±0.20
8.33±0.22
8.44±0.23
8.43±0.19
8.35±0.23
8.34±0.18
8.33±0.24
8.26±0.21
8.21±0.11
8.84±0.10
8.64±0.11
8.75±0.10
8.79±0.10
8.62±0.11
8.75±0.10
8.65±0.11
8.56±0.10
8.33±0.04
8.61±0.10
8.19±0.05
8.38±0.10
8.28±0.20
8.49±0.13
8.22±0.03
8.40±0.10
8.16±0.10
1 13120 ± 460
1 13100 ± 1500
1 13210 ± 1110
8.06±0.03
7.87±0.10
7.98±0.05
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
6000 ± 1000
6900 ± 500
6000 ± 400
8000 ± 800
8.95±0.25
8.69±0.10
8.83±0.10
8.60±0.10
6200 ± 500
5500 ± 500
5800 ± 500
5600 ± 500
8.78±0.10
8.79±0.16
8.81±0.11
8.79±0.14
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.16±0.30 -- 0.50±0.69 -- 1.50±0.34 -- 2.26±0.38
-- 1.23±0.27 -- 0.81±0.62 -- 1.87±0.32 -- 2.12±0.35
-- 1.31±0.25 -- 2.27±0.22
-- 1.28±0.15
-- 1.38±0.12
-- 1.52±0.24 -- 2.40±0.14
-- 1.35±0.14 -- 0.80±0.28 -- 1.54±0.25 -- 2.27±0.17
-- 1.36±0.28 -- 0.20±0.67 -- 1.32±0.30 -- 2.39±0.34
-- 1.39±0.25 -- 1.04±0.56 -- 1.69±0.30 -- 2.22±0.31
-- 1.53±0.23 -- 0.72±0.52 -- 1.70±0.46 -- 2.31±0.29
-- 1.40±0.28 -- 0.63±0.67 -- 1.69±0.32 -- 2.22±0.35
-- 1.48±0.31
-- 1.48±0.32
-- 1.47±0.26
-- 1.56±0.31
-- 1.58±0.25
-- 1.58±0.32
-- 1.56±0.29
-- 1.55±0.15
-- 1.70±0.33
-- 1.62±0.33
-- 1.69±0.30 -- 2.24±0.33
-- 1.94±0.34 -- 2.37±0.39
-- 1.68±0.30 -- 2.36±0.31
-- 1.61±0.34 -- 2.35±0.41
-- 1.71±0.32 -- 2.45±0.37
-- 1.49±0.25 -- 2.12±0.19
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
NGC 2805
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.14±0.13 -- 0.62±0.25 -- 1.21±0.24 -- 2.33±0.16
-- 1.27±0.17 -- 0.50±0.35 -- 1.62±0.25 -- 2.36±0.21
-- 1.25±0.14 -- 0.47±0.26 -- 1.56±0.24 -- 2.31±0.16
-- 1.18±0.15
-- 1.69±0.24 -- 2.23±0.18
-- 1.32±0.17
-- 1.57±0.26 -- 2.51±0.22
-- 1.28±0.13 -- 0.65±0.24 -- 1.31±0.22 -- 2.28±0.15
-- 1.29±0.17
-- 1.47±0.29 -- 2.43±0.20
-- 1.35±0.15 -- 0.43±0.28 -- 1.49±0.24 -- 2.43±0.17
-- 1.34±0.08 -- 0.70±0.11 -- 1.57±0.10 -- 2.32±0.09
-- 1.37±0.13 -- 0.76±0.25 -- 1.61±0.25 -- 2.37±0.17
-- 1.31±0.08 -- 0.62±0.13 -- 1.67±0.11 -- 2.35±0.10
-- 1.38±0.13
-- 1.42±0.24 -- 2.48±0.16
-- 1.30±0.27 -- 0.96±0.62 -- 1.60±0.31 -- 2.24±0.34
-- 1.53±0.19
-- 1.64±0.30 -- 2.42±0.22
-- 1.37±0.06 -- 0.62±0.07 -- 1.64±0.07 -- 2.35±0.08
-- 1.42±0.14
-- 1.32±0.13 -- 0.75±0.25 -- 1.72±0.22 -- 2.32±0.17
IC 2458
-- 1.43±0.07 -- 0.68±0.08 -- 1.68±0.08 -- 2.28±0.08
-- 1.68±0.14
-- 1.48±0.09 -- 0.95±0.13 -- 1.63±0.13 -- 2.39±0.11
-- 1.37±0.24
-- 1.45±0.24
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
NGC 2820
-- 1.30±0.34
-- 1.22±0.14
-- 1.08±0.13
-- 1.25±0.15
NGC 2903
-- 0.96±0.15
-- 1.16±0.19
-- 1.09±0.17
-- 1.12±0.18
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.54±0.36
-- 1.49±0.24
-- 1.66±0.24 -- 2.31±0.16
-- 1.56±0.25
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.47±0.25
-- 1.31±0.28
-- 1.50±0.25 -- 2.40±0.24
-- 1.34±0.27
· · ·
· · ·
8.41
8.79
8.81
8.66
8.44
8.78
8.65
8.55
8.71
8.93
8.85
8.60
8.61
8.72
8.68
8.70
8.79
8.93
8.65
8.77
8.85
8.64
8.73
8.65
8.56
8.53
8.56
8.41
8.37
8.61
8.36
8.45
8.44
8.32
8.32
8.70
8.48
8.61
8.90
8.69
8.53
8.81
8.90
8.88
8.89
8.28
8.60
8.63
8.48
8.30
8.59
8.47
8.39
8.52
8.78
8.67
8.43
8.44
8.53
8.49
8.52
8.61
8.78
8.47
8.58
8.67
8.46
8.54
8.46
8.40
8.37
8.39
7.84
8.26
8.44
8.25
7.80
8.30
7.91
7.90
7.56
7.78
8.43
8.74
8.50
8.37
8.63
8.75
8.72
8.73
-- 37 --
Table 5 -- Continued
(O/H) (O/H)
12+Log(O/H) Log(N/O) Log(Ne/O) Log(S/O) Log(Ar/O) ZKH EP84
8.71±0.10
8.78±0.10
8.70±0.11
8.74±0.12
8.79±0.12
9.27±0.15
9.23±0.15
9.19±0.11
9.18±0.10
9.24±0.14
9.12±0.10
9.11±0.11
9.09±0.10
9.10±0.19
9.05±0.10
9.05±0.10
9.01±0.22
8.97±0.11
8.71±0.10
8.90±0.13
8.87±0.12
8.82±0.10
8.48±0.21
8.57±0.10
8.29±0.20
8.39±0.23
8.41±0.17
8.33±0.17
8.39±0.17
8.31±0.17
8.38±0.22
8.06±0.10
8.33±0.05
9.23±0.17
9.13±0.12
8.41±0.03
8.22±0.04
8.49±0.21
8.30±0.19
8.38±0.24
8.28±0.23
8.01±0.03
8.44±0.19
8.09±0.10
7.92±0.03
7.95±0.10
-- 1.19±0.13
-- 1.19±0.14
-- 1.26±0.14
-- 1.25±0.16
-- 1.24±0.17
NGC 3184
-- 0.70±0.18
-- 0.67±0.16
-- 0.74±0.15
-- 0.78±0.14
-- 0.81±0.16
-- 0.89±0.14
-- 0.79±0.12
-- 0.99±0.13
-- 1.08±0.28
-- 1.06±0.13
-- 0.97±0.12
-- 1.21±0.28
-- 1.07±0.15
-- 1.02±0.16
-- 1.05±0.18
-- 1.06±0.18
-- 1.09±0.15
NGC 4395
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.72±0.24 -- 2.17±0.16
-- 1.79±0.24 -- 2.17±0.17
-- 1.42±0.25 -- 2.02±0.20
-- 1.45±0.26
-- 1.57±0.26 -- 2.02±0.22
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.55±0.27
-- 1.55±0.27 -- 2.16±0.23
-- 1.61±0.25
-- 1.52±0.25
-- 1.52±0.25
-- 1.48±0.24 -- 2.25±0.19
-- 1.46±0.25
-- 1.40±0.24 -- 2.18±0.16
-- 1.70±0.31 -- 2.26±0.33
-- 1.46±0.25
-- 1.56±0.24
-- 1.62±0.33
-- 1.49±0.25 -- 2.24±0.25
-- 1.62±0.25 -- 2.19±0.20
-- 1.84±0.26 -- 2.12±0.22
-- 1.71±0.26 -- 2.23±0.23
-- 1.60±0.25 -- 2.27±0.18
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.51±0.32 -- 2.28±0.37
-- 1.48±0.35
-- 1.50±0.31
-- 1.29±0.25
-- 1.44±0.27 -- 0.84±0.62 -- 1.46±0.56 -- 2.16±0.34
-- 1.60±0.32 -- 0.69±0.80 -- 1.47±0.34 -- 2.40±0.41
-- 1.44±0.27 -- 0.57±0.47 -- 1.61±0.30 -- 2.25±0.31
-- 1.59±0.23 -- 0.58±0.52 -- 1.54±0.29 -- 2.26±0.30
-- 1.41±0.25 -- 0.91±0.56 -- 1.22±0.52 -- 2.19±0.31
-- 1.66±0.25
-- 1.82±0.44 -- 2.32±0.31
-- 1.48±0.31 -- 0.71±0.74 -- 1.59±0.33 -- 2.21±0.39
-- 1.46±0.13 -- 0.83±0.25 -- 1.69±0.24 -- 2.17±0.16
-- 1.55±0.09 -- 0.75±0.14 -- 1.65±0.14 -- 2.28±0.11
· · ·
NGC 5457
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
-- 1.53±0.28
-- 1.63±0.25
-- 0.57±0.17
-- 0.80±0.15
-- 1.17±0.06 -- 0.69±0.07 -- 1.38±0.20 -- 2.03±0.07
-- 1.39±0.07 -- 0.68±0.10 -- 1.65±0.21 -- 2.32±0.09
-- 1.49±0.30
-- 1.43±0.63 -- 2.28±0.36
-- 1.47±0.26 -- 0.60±0.40 -- 1.46±0.30 -- 2.36±0.33
-- 1.54±0.33
-- 1.70±0.34 -- 2.54±0.42
-- 1.48±0.31 -- 0.74±0.74 -- 1.58±0.33 -- 2.42±0.39
-- 1.44±0.06 -- 0.77±0.07 -- 1.66±0.07 -- 2.30±0.07
-- 1.55±0.27 -- 0.67±0.60 -- 1.56±0.30 -- 2.44±0.33
-- 1.43±0.14 -- 0.23±0.27 -- 1.47±0.24 -- 2.24±0.17
-- 1.45±0.06 -- 0.75±0.07 -- 1.69±0.39 -- 2.46±0.08
-- 1.51±0.13 -- 0.51±0.24 -- 1.53±0.24 -- 2.44±0.16
8.74
8.79
8.80
8.85
8.89
9.35
9.29
9.28
9.24
9.28
9.21
9.20
9.16
8.94
9.16
9.13
8.78
9.07
8.72
8.96
8.95
8.84
8.71
8.51
8.58
8.57
8.58
8.32
8.71
8.48
8.55
8.52
8.42
9.33
9.21
8.32
8.55
8.74
8.76
8.61
8.72
8.50
8.64
8.56
8.55
8.73
8.55
8.60
8.61
8.68
8.72
9.51
9.43
9.41
9.34
9.42
9.30
9.28
9.22
8.80
9.22
9.18
8.60
9.03
8.53
8.82
8.82
8.66
8.53
8.36
8.41
8.40
8.41
7.90
8.52
8.33
8.39
7.74
8.29
9.48
9.30
8.23
8.38
8.56
8.57
8.43
8.54
7.76
8.46
7.70
7.72
7.53
Offsets
Slit
E-W N-S [arcsec] No.
r0
+171 +196
+171 +226
+171 +232
+171 +236
+171 +243
-- 058 -- 007
-- 064 -- 006
-- 080 -- 005
+085 -- 004
+079 +035
+059 -- 079
+074 +064
+092 -- 093
+005 +135
-- 002 +136
-- 017 +137
+111 -- 102
-- 119 -- 121
-- 113 -- 127
-- 101 -- 137
-- 110 -- 130
-- 095 -- 142
+061 -- 029
+099 -- 029
+002 -- 127
-- 075 -- 117
+088 -- 119
-- 167 -- 093
+118 +206
+195 -- 159
+200 +141
-- 226 +237
-- 272 +186
-- 075 +028
-- 106 +028
-- 347 +276
-- 459 -- 053
+271 -- 393
-- 276 -- 417
-- 037 -- 532
-- 250 +484
-- 398 -- 436
-- 291 +489
-- 499 +300
+010 +885
+005 +887
326.6
336.3
338.7
340.3
343.3
60.9
66.9
83.3
87.8
91.5
98.7
104.5
130.8
140.1
140.6
141.7
150.8
181.3
181.5
181.5
181.8
182.0
68.5
105.3
128.8
144.7
148.0
200.5
246.7
252.8
256.7
328.0
332.0
84.7
114.3
465.2
474.1
498.6
500.2
541.2
566.6
590.6
593.1
610.6
900.6
902.8
T(O++)
6700 ± 500
6400 ± 500
6400 ± 500
6000 ± 500
5700 ± 500
3400 ± 200
3700 ± 200
3800 ± 200
3900 ± 200
3600 ± 200
4000 ± 200
4300 ± 200
4100 ± 200
5000 ± 600
4200 ± 200
4400 ± 200
5400 ± 300
4700 ± 300
6000 ± 500
5500 ± 500
5500 ± 500
6200 ± 500
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
4
5
4
5
3
3
3
5
1
1
1
1
1
7800 ± 500
8
8100 ± 800
8
9700 ± 2000
7
8900 ± 2000
4
8930 ±5790
9
1200
3 10300 ± 2000
10
8500 ± 1500
11 10000 ± 2000
12
9100 ± 2000
2 12000 ± 1500
1 10050 ± 770
3600 ± 200
7
4250 ± 250
7
4
9880 ± 170
2 10450 ± 480
7600 ± 1400
11
8600 ± 1600
6
8900 ± 2000
8
5
9100 ± 2000
3 12750 ± 320
5
8300 ± 1500
1 10300 ± 1200
10 13630 ± 440
10 12200 ± 1500
-- 38 --
Table 6. Radial Oxygen Abundance Gradients
No. of
Central
Galaxy
HII Regions
12+log(O/H)
[dex/r25]
NGC 0628
NGC 0925
NGC 1068
NGC 1232
NGC 1637
NGC 2403
NGC 2805
NGC 2903
NGC 3184
NGC 4395
NGC 5457
26
53
13
16
15
40
17
36
32
14
53
9.46 ± 0.11
8.79 ± 0.06
9.26 ± 0.02
9.49 ± 0.12
9.18 ± 0.07
8.70 ± 0.07
9.11 ± 0.12
9.22 ± 0.06
9.50 ± 0.04
8.48 ± 0.13
9.29 ± 0.05
-- 0.99 ± 0.14
-- 0.45 ± 0.08
-- 0.30 ± 0.07
-- 1.31 ± 0.20
-- 0.34 ± 0.15
-- 0.77 ± 0.14
-- 1.05 ± 0.17
-- 0.56 ± 0.09
-- 0.78 ± 0.07
-- 0.32 ± 0.19
-- 1.52 ± 0.09
Gradients
[dex/rd]
-- 0.23 ± 0.03
-- 0.12 ± 0.02
-- 0.16 ± 0.04
-- 0.36 ± 0.05
-- 0.06 ± 0.02
-- 0.14 ± 0.02
-- 0.42 ± 0.07
-- 0.13 ± 0.02
-- 0.20 ± 0.02
-- 0.13 ± 0.07
-- 0.27 ± 0.02
[dex/kpc]
-- 0.067 ± 0.009
-- 0.032 ± 0.006
-- 0.020 ± 0.004
-- 0.056 ± 0.009
-- 0.068 ± 0.028
-- 0.074 ± 0.013
-- 0.049 ± 0.008
-- 0.048 ± 0.008
-- 0.083 ± 0.007
-- 0.037 ± 0.022
-- 0.049 ± 0.003
-- 39 --
Fig. 1. -- R -- band and continuum subtracted Hα images of the galaxies in the sample. The
positions of the 2′ slits are illustrated on the Hα images. The images are oriented with north to
the top and east to the left.
-- 40 --
Fig. 1 continued
-- 41 --
Fig. 1 continued
-- 42 --
Fig. 1 continued
-- 43 --
Fig. 2. -- Representative spectra of H II regions in NGC 1232. The inner H II regions (a) and (b)
are clearly high abundance, with strong [N II] and [S II] and weak [O III] lines. The outermost H
II region (c) is low abundance, with weak [N II] and strong [O III] lines.
-- 44 --
Fig. 3. -- Reddening as a function of radius for each galaxy. In each panel the radius has been
normalized by the isophotal radius of that galaxy.
-- 45 --
Fig. 4. -- Emission -- line diagnostic diagram for [N II]. In this and subsequent figures, H II regions
from NGC 628 are denoted by upright triangles, NGC 925 by squares, NGC 1068 by crosses, NGC
1232 by downward triangles, NGC 1637 by diamonds, NGC 2403 by upward indented triangles,
NGC 2805 by pentagons, IC 2458 by six pointed stars, NGC 2820 by five pointed stars, NGC 2903
by indented crosses, NGC 3184 by hexagons, NGC 4395 by four pointed open stars, and NGC 5457
by five pointed open stars. (a) The H II region sequence formed by [N II] and [O III] normalized
by Balmer lines. A theoretical curve from Baldwin et al. (1981) is superposed. (b) The H II region
sequence formed by R23 vs. [N II]/Hα. In both panels, NGC 4395 -- 003 -- 003 is marked by an arrow.
-- 46 --
Fig. 5. -- Emission -- line diagnostic diagrams for [S II]. The symbols are the same as in Figure 4.
(a) The H II region sequence formed by [S II] and [O III] normalized by the Balmer lines. (b) The
H II region sequence formed by R23 vs. [S II]/Hα. In both panels, NGC 4395 -- 003 -- 003 is marked
by an arrow.
-- 47 --
Fig. 6. -- The density sensitive line ratio [S II] λ6717/6731 as a function of R23. The symbols are
the same as in Figure 4. The dashed line indicates the maximum value of the [S II] ratio in the low
density limit. The majority of the H II regions fall within the low density limit.
-- 48 --
2
1
0
0.1
0.01
-1
0.001
0.0001
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
Fig. 7. -- The model grid of the R23 relation from McGaugh (1991). The locations of the H II
regions are marked; the symbols are the same as in Figure 4. The ambiguity between the high and
low abundance sides of the surface can be resolved based on the strength of the [N II] lines.
-- 49 --
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
Fig. 8. -- The [N II]/[O II] diagnostic diagram. The symbols are the same as in Figure 4. The
one outlying point is NGC 4395 -- 003 -- 003. Low values of [N II]/[O II] and high values of [O II]+[O
III]/Hβ are found for the outermost H II regions in NGC 925, NGC 2403, NGC 2805, NGC 4395,
and NGC 5457, indicating that these are low abundance H II regions.
9.5
9
8.5
8
7.5
7
-- 50 --
-2
-1
0
Fig. 9. -- A semi -- empirical technique for determining oxygen abundances. The line shows the least
squares fit to the low (12 + log (O/H) < 8.2) and high (8.8 < 12 + log (O/H) < 9.1) abundance
H II regions and HII regions from a dwarf galaxy sample (van Zee et al. 1997). Also plotted are
data points for H II regions in NGC 4214 (Kobulnicky & Skillman 1996), NGC 1569 (Kobulnicky
& Skillman 1997), and I Zw 18 (Skillman & Kennicutt 1993).
-- 51 --
Fig. 10. -- Comparison between R23 calibrations. The large scatter for 12 + log (O/H) < 8.5 is due
to the turnover in the R23 relation which has not been accounted for in the ZKH (Zaritsky et al.
1994) calibration. The six high abundance points which are offset from both the EP84 (Edmunds
& Pagel 1984) and ZKH calibrations are from H II regions where the [N II]/Hα calibration was
used instead of the pure R23 relation. Two of these points are from the edge -- on spiral NGC 2820,
where the combination of uncertain extinction corrections and the superpositions of multiple H
II regions make the empirical calibration highly uncertain. While there are systematic differences
between the calibrations, at high abundances the ZKH calibration is very similar to the calibration
used here. In contrast, the calibration of EP84 would result in much steeper abundance gradients.
-- 52 --
Fig. 11. -- The relative enrichment of the α elements. In all three panels, the mean value is denoted
by a solid line. The solar value (Anders & Grevesse 1989) is represented by an open circle, where
the symbol size is indicative of the errors. (a) Log (Ne/O) as a function of oxygen abundance. (b)
Log (S/O) as a function of oxygen abundance. (c) Log (Ar/O) as a function of oxygen abundance.
-- 53 --
Fig. 12. -- The observed oxygen abundance gradients in all 11 spiral galaxies. The filled symbols
represent H II regions from the present study. The open circles represent data from the literature:
NGC 628 -- McCall et al. (1985); NGC 925 -- Zaritsky et al. (1994); NGC 1068 -- Evans & Dopita
(1987), Oey & Kennicutt (1993); NGC 2403 -- McCall et al. (1985), Fierro et al. (1986), Garnett
et al. (1997); NGC 2903 -- McCall et al. (1985), Zaritsky et al. (1994); NGC 3184 -- Zaritsky et al.
(1994); NGC 4395 -- McCall et al. (1985); NGC 5457 -- Kennicutt & Garnett (1996). The solid lines
illustrate the derived oxygen abundance gradients.
|
astro-ph/0012527 | 1 | 0012 | 2000-12-29T05:18:10 | On the source of QPO of the black hole candidate GRS1915+105: some new observations and their interpretation | [
"astro-ph"
] | A few classes of the light curve of the black hole candidate GRS 1915+105 have been analyzed in detail. We discover that unlike the previous findings, QPOs occasionally occur even in the so-called `On' or softer states. Such findings may require a revision of the accretion/wind scenario of the black hole candidates. We conjecture that considerable winds which is produced in `Off' states, cool down due to Comptonization, and falls back to the disk and creating an excess accretion rate to produce the so-called `On' state. After the drainage of the excess matter, the disk goes back to the `Off' state. Our findings strengthen the shock oscillation model for QPOs. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (2000)
Printed 27 October 2018
On the source of QPO of the black hole candidate
GRS1915+105: some new observations and their
interpretation.
Anuj Nandi1, Sivakumar G. Manickam1, A.R. Rao2 and Sandip K. Chakrabarti1,3
1 S.N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences,
JD-Block, Sector III, Salt Lake, Calcutta 700098, India;
2 Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Road, Colaba, Mumbai 400005
3 Centre for Space Physics, 114/v/1A Raja S.C. Mullick Rd., Calcutta 700047, India
[email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
Accepted . Received ; in original form
ABSTRACT
A few classes of the light curve of the black hole candidate GRS 1915+105 have
been analyzed in detail. We discover that unlike the previous findings, QPOs occa-
sionally occur even in the so-called 'On' or softer states. Such findings may require a
revision of the accretion/wind scenario of the black hole candidates. We conjecture that
considerable winds which is produced in 'Off' states, cool down due to Comptonization,
and falls back to the disk and creating an excess accretion rate to produce the so-called
'On' state. After the drainage of the excess matter, the disk goes back to the 'Off' state.
Our findings strengthen the shock oscillation model for QPOs.
Key words: Black Hole Physics -- Accretion Disks -- Outflows -- Stars:individual
(GRS1915+105)
MNRAS (to appear)
1
INTRODUCTION
The black hole candidate GRS1915+105 continues to excite
astrophysicists by having one of the most, if not the most
mysterious light curves. In a matter of days, the light curve
changes its character, and within each day, photon counts
show variations of a factor of two to five or more (Morgan,
Remillard & Greiner, 1997; Belloni et al, 1997; Paul et al.
1998; Manickam & Chakrabarti 1999). The power density
spectra shows clear evidence of quasi-periodic oscillations
(QPOs) with frequency ranging from ∼ 0.001Hz to 67Hz
(see, e.g., Morgan, Remillard & Greiner, 1997; Chakrabarti
& Manickam 2000, hereafter CM00, and references therein).
The origin of the quasi-periodic oscillations cannot be
a complete mystery since there are very clear evidence that
sub-Keplerian flows, which must occur in a black hole accre-
tion, exhibit very wild time-dependent behaviour including
large amplitude shock oscillations. This is true, especially
when the infall time matches with the cooling time (Molteni,
Sponholz & Chakrabarti, 1996; Ryu, Chakrabarti & Molteni
1997; Paul et al, 1998; Remillard et al, 1999ab; Muno, Mor-
gan & Remillard, 1999). This became more evident when
it was observed that the QPOs are absent in low energy
photons but is very strong at high energies, supporting the
view that the photons participating in QPOs originate at
hot post-shock flow (CM00, Rao et al. 2000). It has also
been observed that QPOs are seen mostly when the photon
counts are low ('Off' states) and QPO is very weak or absent
in the On states when the photon counts are about two to
five times larger. In the present Letter, by On and Off states,
we would mean the high and low count states of the light
curves. This nomenclature is not related to spectral states.
Because of the presence of the On and the Off states
in the light curves, explanation of QPOs using radial os-
cillation of the centrifugal pressure supported shocks alone
(which produce the right amplitude and frequency for the
QPOs) cannot be the complete story. The very fact that
the Off states terminate and the On states emerge in almost
regular basis (but not exactly regular) gives rise to another
time scale which must, at the same time, be dependent on
disk/jet parameters. This is because Belloni et al. (2000)
found that at least twelve types of light curves are seen, and
within each type, the duration and behaviour of the On and
the Off (if both exist) states were not at all fixed. For in-
stance, ρ class exhibits extremely regular light curves (Taam,
Chen & Swank, 1997; Vilhu & Nevalainen, 1998) with broad
Off- or low-count states and very narrow, spiky, high-count
or On-states (see, Fig. 2b below). Light curves in the ν class
2
Anuj Nandi, Sivakumar G. Manickam, A.R. Rao and Sandip K. Chakrabarti
is similar to those of ρ, but are highly irregular (see, Fig.
2a below). In λ class, both Off and On states are of longer
time duration (Belloni et al. 1997) while in κ class these
durations are relatively shorter (see, Fig. 5 below). Nandi,
Manickam and Chakrabarti (2000) using a completely differ-
ent procedure divided the light curves into four fundamental
types (Hard, Soft, Semi-soft and Intermediate). The Inter-
mediate class shows On/Off transitions. Chakrabarti (1999)
and Chakrabarti & Manickam (2000) showed that outflow
rates from the centrifugal barrier must play a major role in
deciding the duration, as the wind matter at least up to the
sonic sphere can be Comptonized and cooled down. Most of
this cold matter (below the sonic surface of the cooler wind)
can fall back on the immediate vicinity of the disk increasing
its accretion rate temporarily while the rest must separate
out at a supersonic speed. As this excess matter drains out,
the Off state together with the QPO start appearing again.
In this Letter, we analyze light curves in detail and find
that QPOs may be observed at very unlikely times in the
light curves. For instance, we find that very often, there is a
sharp peak ('first hiccup') at the onset of the On state and
there is a sharp peak ('last hiccup') just prior to going to
the Off state. The first peak, though in the On state, very
often shows QPOs while the last peak, though the radiation
is much harder, does not show a QPO. We also note that the
radiation progressively hardens in the On state. In several
cases, using data from both the RXTE and Indian X-ray
Astronomical Experiment (IXAE), ρ class curves (mostly
mini-ρ type) are seen to be peeled off from a κ class. In κ
and λ, the On state duration is long and just before going to
the Off state, the light curve becomes noisy and oscillating
in nature, and the features indicate as though the light curve
is made up of 'sums' of ρ types. Only the lower half of the
oscillations (local Off states of mini-ρ states) exhibit QPO!
We believe that these observations definitely point to the
drainage of extra matter in the disk which was accumulated
from the wind.
One of the problems in analyzing data of one of the
most complex objects, such as GRS1915+105 is that one
has to ask the right questions and as many of them as pos-
sible. Once a paradigm is kept in the back of the mind, ask-
ing questions become easier. We therefore concentrate on
models which required sub-Keplerian and Keplerian flows
simultaneously and where winds are also produced self-
consistently. In the next Section, we present some of the
'subtle' observational results which have not been reported
by workers before (despite the fact that GRS 1915+105 is
probably the most studied object in recent years). In §3,
we interpret this observations in terms of the advective disk
paradigm. In §4, we draw our conclusions.
2 OBSERVATIONS
2.1 Properties of two peaks in the On state
GRS 1915+105 exhibits both broad and narrow On states
(Paul et al. 1998; Yadav et al, 1999; Belloni et al. 2000;
CM00). When the On state is narrow or spiky, i.e., the du-
ration with high photon counts is very small, and very often,
just after transition from On to Off state, a second peak is
observed. This has also been cursorily reported by Paul et
al. (1998). Figure 1 shows details of a narrow section of the
Fig. 1: Subdivisions of a quasi-repetitive structure of the light
curve of Oct. 15th, 1996 (ID:10408-01-41-00). Relatively hard ra-
diations are emitted in the region marked Off with relatively lower
count rates. There are typically two major peaks, P1 followed by
P2.
all-channel light curve corresponding to the RXTE obser-
vation of 15th of Oct. 1996 (The observation ID number is
10408-01-41-00.). We denote the peak appearing first as the
primary peak (P1 for short) and the peak following P1 as
the secondary peak (P2 for short) respectively. The words
Off, 'P1' and 'P2' are marked. The entire light curve is al-
most a repetition of this section. Figure 2a presents the light
curves of this data clearly showing two peaks P1 and P2 in
the On state. The time lag between the two peaks is roughly
constant on a given day (in this case about 10 seconds) and
we do not find any correlation between this lag and the du-
ration of the Off state. The light curve is shown in four
panels: the panels are drawn for channel energies (from top
to bottom) 0 − 5.07keV, 5.43 − 6.88keV, 7.24 − 9.43keV,
and 9.79 − 13.09keV respectively (corresponding channels
are 0 − 13, 14 − 18, 19 − 25, 26 − 35 respectively). Note that
while in low energies, photon counts in P1 is much larger
compared to P2, in higher energies they are roughly equal,
suggesting that the spectrum of P2 is harder. Taam, Chen
and Swank (1997) also noted the existence of these peaks
and that P2 is harder compared to P1. A similar light curve
is shown in Fig. 2b, for the RXTE observation of 22nd of
June, 1997 (see also Vilhu & Nevalainen (1998) and Yadav
et al (1999) for displaying this light curve.). The correspond-
ing observation ID is 20402-01-34-01. In this case, the time
lag is about 4 seconds but other features are similar to those
of Fig. 2a. The channel energies are marked on each panel
(corresponding channels numbers are 0−13, 14−19, 20−25,
26 − 35 respectively).
Figures 3(a-c) show the power density spectra (PDS) of
the three regions marked in Fig. 1. While selecting photons
from 'P1' and 'P2' regions we took special care that they
are not contaminated by the photons from the Off states.
Also, to improve statistics, we added data from many peaks
over the entire duration of the observation on that day. Note
that in the Off state there is a distinct QPO of frequency
νqpo = 7.4Hz. Photons in 'P1' also exhibit QPO though it is
weaker (νqpo ∼ 5.7Hz). QPO is completely absent from 'P2'.
On the source of QPO of the black hole candidate GRS1915+105: some new observations and their interpretation.
Fig. 2a: Four panels showing light curves of a part of the observa-
tion on Oct. 15th, 1996 (ID: 10408-01-41-00) at different channels
(energies are marked). Note that ratio of photon counts in P1 and
P2 tends to become unity at higher energies.
Fig. 3(a-c): Power Density Spectrum (PDS) of three regions
marked in Fig. 1 of the observation dated Oct. 15th, 1996. Several
data segments have been added to improve statistics. Note the
absence of QPO in P2.
Fig. 2b : Four panels showing light curves of a part of the ob-
servation on June 22nd, 1997 (ID: 20402-01-34-01) at different
channels (energies are marked).
We examined the RXTE data of 22nd June, 1997 also, the
PDS of which is shown in Fig. 4(a-c). The result is generally
the same. The QPO frequency in the Off-state is given by
νqpo = 6.3Hz and in P1 peak νqpo = 6.8Hz. We therefore
believe that the observed features may be generic.
Fig. 4(a-c): Power Density Spectrum (PDS) of three regions
marked in Fig. 1 of the observation dated June 22nd, 1997. Several
data segments have been added to improve statistics. Note the
absence of QPO in P2.
2.2 Properties of On++ state
It is generally observed that whenever the duration of On or
the high count state is large, light curves become very noisy
and count rates start oscillating wildly as the Off state is
approached. The later half may be termed as 'On++' state
and Manickam & Chakrabarti (1999) showed that this re-
gion exhibits a weak QPO. In fact, similar to Fig. 2(a-b)
above, where the photons in P2 are harder compared to
P1, one finds that On++ state is harder compared to the
first half of the On state. This is demonstrated in Fig. 5,
4
Anuj Nandi, Sivakumar G. Manickam, A.R. Rao and Sandip K. Chakrabarti
frequency and when the shock is fully developed, the Off
state begins with a QPO at 3.09Hz.
An easily missed phenomenon in all these light curves is
that most of the On states begin with a 'hiccup' or a small
peak, which may be likened with 'P1' of ρ or ν class and
also end with another 'hiccup' which may be likened with
'P2'.
3 POSSIBLE INTERPRETATIONS OF THESE
OBSERVATIONS
3.1 The Paradigm
While there is as yet no fully self-consistent model which
includes disks, winds and radiative transfer simultaneously,
one can collect bits and pieces of the solutions and con-
struct a viable model for the system. Chakrabarti (1996)
and more recently Chakrabarti (2000a) have discussed such
solutions in detail. Fig. 7 shows a cartoon diagram of an
accretion/wind system of GRS 1915+105. Generally, it is
assumed the the accretion is advective in nature and has a
centrifugal barrier dominated region which may or may not
have become a fully developed shock (at r = rs) throughout
the period of observation. Chakrabarti (1999) showed that
the centrifugal barrier dominated boundary layer (CENBOL
for short) is not only responsible for the Comptonized ra-
diation, but also responsible for the wind/jet formation. A
very simple analysis which envisages an isothermal wind at
least up to the sonic surface (at r = rc) shows that winds
should not be emitted in soft states, and very hard states
should have very little winds. If the shock is of intermediate
strength, outflow rate is very much high.
If the outflow rate is high enough, it can fill the sonic
sphere (of size rc ∼ 2 − 3rs; sub-sonic region up to the
sonic surface) rapidly till the optical depth due to Compton
scattering become larger than unity. Comptonization cools
down this region rapidly. CM00 suggests that the duration
of the Off state is the time in which this region achieves this
threshold of cooling. Since the specific energy and angular
momentum of the flow decide shock location and its strength
(Chakrabarti 1989), a small variation of the overall viscosity
would change the shock location, and therefore cause the
variation of the duration and the QPO frequency from one
Off state to another. The correlation between duration and
frequency based on this consideration has been discussed in
CM00. An important bye-product of all these is that as the
disk loses matter (and pressure) from the post-shock region
in the form of outflows, the shock, as well as the inner edge of
the Keplerian disk moves inwards, gradually increasing the
QPO frequency. This has been demonstrated by the dynamic
power density spectra (e.g., Muno et al., 2000; Trudolyubov
et al. 2000).
A part of the wind which does not reach escape veloc-
ity must return back to the disk and the accretion rate of
the disk is temporarily modulated. This has been demon-
strated by two dimensional simulations of advective disks
(Molteni, Lanzafame & Chakrabarti, 1994; Molteni, Ryu
and Chakrabarti, 1996 and Ryu, Chakrabarti & Molteni,
1997). This feedback mechanism becomes more complex in
presence of radiative cooling of the outflow. After the wind is
cooled down, the sound speed is reduced, and location of the
sonic surface comes closer to the black hole, very abruptly.
Fig. 5: A part of the light curve from the so-called κ-state is
shown. The energy ranges are marked in each panel. Upper four
panels are from RXTE and the lower two panels are from IXAE
data. Note that in On++ states light curves are more noisy and
oscillatory, more so for photons at higher energy. A small arrow
indicates a ρ type burst. Presence of mini-ρ bursts within a κ
type On states indicates that ρ may be the fundamental type of
all burst.
where a part of the light curve from the so-called κ-state is
shown. The energy ranges are marked in each panel. Upper
four channels are from RXTE and the lower two channels
are from the Indian X-ray Astronomy Experiment (IXAE)
data. The observation ID for RXTE is 20186-03-01-02. In
both the cases one second bin-size is chosen.
First note that RXTE and IXAE show very similar be-
haviours throughout the period of overlap of observations.
Second, towards the end of each of the On states (which we
term as On++ state for brevity), the light curves are noisy
and generally oscillatory in nature. Third, in both the ex-
periments, the relative oscillations are increased with the
increasing photon energy in On++ state. Fourth, though
generally the light curve may be called that of a κ-class
(Belloni et al. 2000), several pieces of ρ class is evident. In
fact, mini-ρ type light curves are also evident in the On++
states giving clear evidence that the light curve in the ρ-class
is more primitive. In the next Section we discuss possible in-
terpretations of this important observation.
In Fig. 6, we show a part of the light curve on the same
day, and draw two boxes (in dotted curves) at the On++
state. The photons from the upper box show no sign of QPO,
while the photons from the lower box shows clear evidence
of QPO. Since lower box contains photons which are from
mini-Off states of the mini-ρ class mentioned above, it is not
surprising that this show QPOs. Indeed, while the Off state
on this day shows QPO of frequency 3.09Hz, these mini-Off
states show QPOs of frequency 6.25Hz. This indicates that
towards the end, the shock again starts developing much
closer to the black hole giving rise to a higher oscillation
On the source of QPO of the black hole candidate GRS1915+105: some new observations and their interpretation.
Fig. 6: A part of the light curve from the so-called κ-state is
shown. In On++ states, two dotted boxes are drawn and below
the PDS of each box is plotted. Note the presence of QPO in
lower box, which are nothing but mini-Off states corresponding
to mini-ρ bursts.
Part of the originally subsonic outflowing matter still re-
mains below the new sonic surface and falls back since it
loses drive to escape. The rest becomes supersonic (because
of reduced sound speed) and separates in the form of blobs.
Thus, blobs are produced at the end of the off-states. This
conjecture has been tested by multiwavelength observations
(Dhawan et al. 2000).
During the On states, the shock and the CENBOL are
non-existent and hence the QPOs are generally absent. To-
wards the end of the On state, in the so-called On++ state,
the shocks start forming close to the black hole because of
heat generated by excess accretion. The shock then rapidly
recedes to a distance consistent with the steady state so-
lution as soon as the excess matter is drained out of the
disk. This causes the onset of the Off state. This process of
receding are regularly seen in numerical simulation of sub-
Keplerian flows (Chakrabarti & Molteni, 1993; MLC94).
3.2 Origin of hiccups or P1 and P2 peaks
It is clear that since these peaks are separated by a few sec-
onds, and generally one has a QPO while the other does
not, their origins cannot be the same. From the paradigm
described above, one may imagine that P1 forms when catas-
trophic cooling of the CENBOL-sonic sphere system takes
place. Since P1 is a continuation of the Off state, QPO is
thus expected unless the shock is hidden under the cooler
wind. P2 is due to the steepening of last bits of excess
matter on the disk which is delayed by the viscous time-
scale. The viscous time which a ring of matter takes after
it leaves the Keplerian disk from a transition radius (rtr,
where the flow deviates from a Keplerian disk (Chakrabarti
& Titarchuk, 1995), and enters the post-shock region is given
100 )1/2s where α
by tvisc ∼ 1
is the Shakura-Sunyaev viscosity parameter, h(r) ∼ csr3/2
= 10( 0.01
α )( 0.1
cs
α ( h
r )−2
r
vKep
)2( rtr
Fig. 7: Cartoon diagram showing possible physical processes close
to a black hole during an average time of the (a) Off and (b) On
states. Centrifugal barrier or CENBOL produces winds. Subsonic
region is cooled and falls back on the disk while supersonic region
separates out as blobs. Excess accretion inner part causes higher
counts in On states.
is the dimensionless instantaneous height of the disk (in
vertical equilibrium) at a radius r (measured in units of
Rg = 2GM/c2, the Schwarzschild radius), vKep is the ro-
tational velocity of the Keplerian orbit, and cs is the speed
of sound in units of velocity of light. As this ring of matter
propagates through this region, it is illuminated by soft pho-
tons coming out of the Keplerian disk, but since it is outside
the shock, its radiations do not participate in the oscillation.
On the other hand, since rising side of P1 is in Off state, it
shows QPO. Due to Compton cooling the spectrum of P1 is
softer. However P2 occurs when the excess matter is almost
entirely drained out from the disk. Hence its spectrum is
harder.
It is to be noted that whether or not shocks would form
depend on viscosity. It has been shown (Chakrabarti, 1990;
Chakrabarti & Molteni, 1995; Chakrabarti 1996) that there
is a critical viscosity parameter αc below which shocks can
form and this parameter is about αc ∼ 0.015. Beyond this
chosks disappear and Keplerian flows directly enter into the
black hole. Out choice of α = 0.01 to explain the time scale
is thus consistent with the presence of shocks.
In general, as excess matter drains out of the CENBOL,
6
Anuj Nandi, Sivakumar G. Manickam, A.R. Rao and Sandip K. Chakrabarti
This work is partly supported by Indian Space Research
Organization (ISRO) through a project entitled Quasi Peri-
odic Oscillations in Black Holes. AN's work is supported by
a DST project entitled Analytical and Numerical Studies of
Astrophysical Flows Around Compact Objects. We grate-
fully acknowledge using RXTE data from public archive of
GSFC/NASA.
REFERENCES
Belloni, T, M´endez, King, A.R., Van der Klis, M. & Van Paradijs,
J. 1997, APJ 488, L109
Belloni, T., Klein, Wolt, M., M´endez, M., van Der Klis, M. and
van Paradijs, J. 2000, A & A, 355, 271
Chakrabarti, S.K. 1989, ApJ 347, 365
Chakrabarti, S.K. 1990, M.N.R.A.S. 243, 610
Chakrabarti, S.K. & Molteni, D., 1995, M.N.R.A.S. 272, 80
Chakrabarti, S.K. 1996, Phys. Rep., 266, 229
Chakrabarti, S.K. 1999a, Ind. J. Phys. 73B(6), 931
Chakrabarti, S.K. 1999b, A&A 351, 185, (C99)
Chakrabarti, S.K. 2000a, Il Nouvo Cimento (In press).
Chakrabarti, S.K. et al. 2000b, Proceedings of 9th Marcel Gross-
man meeting (Ed.) R. Ruffini
Chakrabarti, S.K. & Molteni, D. 1993, ApJ 417 671
Chakrabarti, S.K. & Manickam, S.G. 2000, ApJL 531, L41
(CM00)
Chakrabarti, S.K. & Titarchuk, L.G. 1995, ApJ 455, 623
Dhawan, V., Mirabel, I. F. & Rodriguez, L. F. 2000, ApJ, sub-
mitted.
Manickam, S.G. & Chakrabarti, S.K. 1999 in Proceedings of
Young Astrophysicists of Today's India, Ind. J. Phys. 73(6),
967
Molteni, D., Lanzafame, G. & Chakrabarti, S.K. 1994, ApJ 425,
161
Molteni, D., Sponholz, H. & Chakrabarti, S.K. 1996, ApJ 457,
805
Molteni, D., Ryu, D. & Chakrabarti, S.K. 1996, ApJ 470, 460
Morgan, E. H., Remillard, R. A. & Greiner, J. 1997, ApJ 482, 993
Muno, M.P., Morgan, E.H. & Remillard, R.A. 1999 ApJ 527, 321
Muno M.P., Morgan E.H., Remillard, R. A. 1999, 527, 321.
Nandi, A., Manickam, S. & Chakrabarti, S.K., 2000, Ind. J. Phys.,
74B(5), 3312
Paul, B., et al. 1998, ApJ 492, L63
Rao, A.R, Naik, S.,Vadawale, S.V. And Chakrabarti, S.K. 2000,
A&A, 360, L25
Remillard, R.A. et al., 1999a ApJL 517, L127
Remillard, R. A., Morgan, E.H., McClintock, J.E., Bailyn, C. D.,
Orosz, J.A. 1999b, ApJ 522, 397
Ryu, D., Chakrabarti & Molteni, D. 1997, ApJ 474, 378
Taam, R., Chen, X.-M. & Swank, J. 1997, ApJ, 485, 83
Trudolyubov S., Churazov E., Gilfanov, M. 1999, A & A 25, 718
Vilhu, O. & Nevalainen, J. 1998, ApJ, 508, L85
Yadav, et al., 1999, ApJ, 517, 935
its optical depth decreases and the spectrum gets harder in
the On++ state. This is observed in both RXTE and IXAE
data.
3.3 Origin of ρ type light curve
One of the reasons we plotted Fig. 5 using the particular re-
gion of κ class observations is that it may hold the key of un-
derstanding the general light curves. The Figure clearly in-
dicates that ρ type regions are peeled off gradually in On++
states of κ class light curve. Arrows in Fig. 5 indicate that
the forms of rise and fall are qualitatively similar, but quan-
titatively one is a miniature version of a fully developed ρ
type of bursts. Details of the modeling is being discussed
elsewhere (Chakrabarti et al. 2000b).
Briefly, when the entire CENBOL behaves like a single
blob, it's light curve is of ρ type: count rate going up in
Comptonization time scale and rapidly drops in infall time-
scale. However, in presence of strong winds, and subsequent
return of matter on the disk, turbulence are generated and
one may imagine that each of the turbulent cells after being
steepened into small shocks, producing mini-ρ light curves,
depending on the shapes and sizes of the turbulent cells.
Each mini-shock produces a mini-ρ curve after filing smaller
sonic surface.
4 CONCLUDING REMARKS
In this Paper, we have pointed out some new and interesting
behaviour of the light-curve of the black hole candidate GRS
1915+105. We showed that very often the On states of ρ and
ν types of light curves produce more than one peak which
behave differently. For instance, the first peak may show
QPOs whereas the second peak shows no QPO. The second
peak also has a harder spectrum. In the κ and λ classes
when the On state duration is longer, the On state shows
very noisy and oscillatory behaviour towards the end, which
we term as On++ state. What is more, photons from upper-
half of these light curves do not show QPOs while those from
the lower-half do.
Though these observations are related to very small re-
gions of the overall light curves, they help us understand the
behaviour of matter close to a black hole. If one assumes that
the duration of the Off states are determined by the time in
which the optical depth of the sonic sphere becomes unity,
as CM00 suggested, then many puzzles are resolved. In this
picture, part of the cooler matter of the outflowing wind
falls back on the CENBOL and the pre-shock disk and its
drainage time gives rise to the On states. It is possible that
the first catastrophic cooling gives rise to the first hiccup
in the On state and the last significant density perturba-
tion due to the fallen matter may cause the final hiccup.
This can explain why P1 often shows QPO, but P2 does
not. Duration of On states in between may vary, depend-
ing on drainage time, giving rise to various classes of light
curves. Also, towards the end of the drainage period, i.e., in
On++ states, the excess matter is depleted and the signs of
QPO starts appearing. What is most interesting, mini-Off
states show QPO, while mini-On states do not, indicating
that states with broader On are possibly made of ρ type
bursts.
|
astro-ph/0207385 | 2 | 0207 | 2002-07-19T05:01:37 | Thermal Emission as a Test for Hidden Nuclei in Nearby Radio Galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | The clear sign of a hidden quasar inside a radio galaxy is the appearance of quasar spectral features in its polarized (scattered) light. However that observational test requires suitably placed scattering material to act as a mirror, allowing us to see the nuclear light. A rather robust and more general test for a hidden quasar is to look for the predicted high mid-IR luminosity from the nuclear obscuring matter. The nuclear waste heat is detected and well isolated in the nearest narrow line radio galaxy, Cen A. This confirms other indications that Cen A does contain a modest quasar-like nucleus. However we show here that M87 does not: at high spatial resolution, the mid-IR nucleus is seen to be very weak, and consistent with simple synchrotron emission from the base of the radio jet. This fairly robustly establishes that there are "real" narrow line radio galaxies, without the putative accretion power, and with essentially all the luminosity in kinetic form. Next we show the intriguing mid-IR morphology of Cygnus A, reported previously by us and later discussed in detail by Radomski et al. (2002). All of this mid-IR emission is consistent with reprocessing by a hidden quasar, known to exist from spectropolarimetry by Ogle et al. (1997) and other evidence. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Thermal Emission as a Test for Hidden Nuclei in Nearby Radio
Galaxies
D. Whysong and R. Antonucci
Physics Department, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106
ABSTRACT
It is widely believed that the optical/UV continuum of quasars (the "Big Blue
Bump") represents optically thick thermal emission from accretion onto a black
hole. Narrow line radio galaxies don't show such a component directly, and were
historically thought for that reason to be rotation-powered, with large kinetic
luminosity in the radio jets but very little accretion or optical radiation. When
the Unified Model came along, identifying at least some narrow line radio galaxies
as hidden quasars, the compelling observational motivation for this radio galaxy
scenario lost some of its force. However, it is far from clear that all narrow line
radio galaxies contain hidden quasar nuclei.
The clear sign of a hidden quasar inside a radio galaxy is the appearance
of quasar spectral features in its polarized (scattered) light. However that ob-
servational test requires suitably placed scattering material to act as a mirror,
allowing us to see the nuclear light. A rather robust and more general test for
a hidden quasar is to look for the predicted high mid-IR luminosity from the
nuclear obscuring matter.
The nuclear waste heat is detected and well isolated in the nearest narrow line
radio galaxy, Cen A. This confirms other indications that Cen A does contain a
modest quasar-like nucleus. However we show here that M87 does not: at high
spatial resolution, the mid-IR nucleus is seen to be very weak, and consistent with
simple synchrotron emission from the base of the radio jet. This fairly robustly
establishes that there are "real" narrow line radio galaxies, without the putative
accretion power, and with essentially all the luminosity in kinetic form.
Next we show the intriguing mid-IR morphology of Cygnus A, reported pre-
viously by us and later discussed in detail by Radomski et al. (2002). All of this
mid-IR emission is consistent with reprocessing by a hidden quasar, known to
exist from spectropolarimetry by Ogle et al. (1997) and other evidence.
Subject headings: galaxies: active -- galaxies:
individual (M87, Cen A, 3C 405, 3C
273) -- infrared: galaxies
-- 2 --
1.
Introduction
Now that the existence of supermassive black holes in AGN seems fairly secure, perhaps
the next most fundamental questions are the sources of energy and the nature of the accretion
flow in the various classes of objects. Historically (see Begelman, Blandford and Rees 1984
for an early review) it was thought that the optical/UV continuum (or "Big Blue Bump")
in quasars (hereafter: and broad line radio galaxies) represents thermal radiation from some
sort of cool optically thick accretion flow. Radio galaxies didn't show this component, so
were posited to be "nonthermal AGN" with hot radiatively inefficient accretion, at a very
low rate; in these cases the the jet power would derive from the hole rotation rather than
release of gravitational potential energy from accretion.
These arguments took a surprising turn when it was realized that many radio galaxies
do have the quasar-like nuclei∗ that are invisible from our line of sight. One Fanaroff-
Riley II (edge-brightened, very luminous) radio galaxy, 3C234, was shown in 1982 to have
quasar features (broad permitted emission lines and Big Blue Bump) in polarized light
(Antonucci 1982, 1984; Antonucci 1993 for a review). Thus 3C234 does have the "thermal"
optical/UV emission, which is only visible via scattering. Many other examples have been
shown subsequently (e.g. Hines and Wills 1993; Young et al. 1996). Some invocations of
the Unified Model postulated that this was generally true of the FR II (powerful, edge-
brightened) class (e.g. Barthel 1989).
3C234 has powerful high-ionization narrow lines, consistent with its being a hidden
quasar. However it is still contentious how those FR IIs with weak and/or low ionization
narrow emission lines fit in (Singal 1993; Laing 1994; Gopal-Krishna et al. 1996; Antonucci
2001). The situation is even less clear for the FR I galaxies, almost all of which have
undetectable or low-ionization emission lines.
For radio galaxies with no observable high-ionization narrow emission line region present,
there is no a priori evidence for the presence of a quasar. These could still have a quasar
nucleus, but any narrow line region would need to be mostly obscured as well. In fact there
is some evidence that the high ionization narrow emission lines are partially obscured in
many 3C radio galaxies (Hes et al. 1993). In NGC 4945 and many other ordinary looking
galaxies, the only present evidence for a hidden AGN is in the hard X-ray (e.g. Madejski et
al. 2002).
To summarize, many FR II radio galaxies fall into the apparently weak, low-ionization
emission line category. Most of the FR I radio galaxies do as well. These spectra have been
described as "optically dull." Quite recently, Chiaberge et al. (1999, 2000) have shown that
among these optically dull sources of both FR types, a majority show optical point sources in
-- 3 --
HST images, and of course more might do so with better imaging data. Note that their result
seems surprising at first: one might have guessed that those with stronger high-ionization
spectra would have the point sources, but the opposite is true.
Chiaberge et al. argue that those with detectable optical point sources cannot in general
have thick obscuring tori on. The reason is, if the point sources are truly nuclear, then we
can see to the very center in most of these objects. These radio galaxies are effectively
selected by an isotropic emission property - the radio lobe flux - so the source orientations
should have an isotropic distribution. That is, the radio axes should be randomly oriented
with respect to our line of sight. Since we can see optical point sources in most optically
dull objects, most lines of sight to their nuclei must be unobscured in general. Recall that in
the Chiaberge et al. picture, the HST optical point sources are the bases of the synchrotron
jets which emit in the radio. As they point out, one caveat must be given with their line of
argument. It is possible that obscuring tori exist below the HST resolution, and hide the
nucleus and the very innermost region of the conical jet. For example, their optical point
sources may really be jet emission on ∼ 1 pc scales, and optical Big Blue Bump sources are
much smaller. A torus might be large enough to obscure the latter while still allowing the
pc scale jet emission to be seen over the top.
In the Chiaberge et al. scenario the optical point sources represent synchrotron emission
from the bases of the jets. In support of this idea, those authors show that the optical fluxes
correlate roughly with the core radio fluxes at 6 cm. It should be easy to check this: the
relationship should tighten up substantially using millimeter fluxes instead of those at 6 cm.
It is very important to remember that some narrow line radio galaxies of both FR types
do have strong high ionization emission lines, and in some cases definitive spectropolarimetric
evidence for a hidden "thermal" nucleus. In general such objects have no detectable optical
point source. They behave instead like Seyfert 2 nuclei, with just spatially resolved scattered
light and the extended narrow line region directly visible.
Our goal is to determine robustly which if any radio galaxies lack a hidden "thermal"
(optical/UV continuum) nucleus. This is crucial for AGN theory since it would prove the
existence of an accretion mode different from that in quasars. In particular, current wisdom
would posit a very low accretion rate and a very low radiative efficiency, that is, some
variant of the advection dominated accretion flow for those radio galaxies. Then by default
the enormous kinetic luminosity of the radio jets would be attributed to black hole rotational
energy.
How can we tell whether or not a hidden nucleus is present? One method is via the hard
X-rays. Many hidden AGN that are not Compton-thick have been discovered with X-ray
-- 4 --
observations. Some references to penetrating X-rays in optically dull sources are gathered
in Antonucci 2001; NGC4945 is a spectacular example (e.g. Madejski et al. 2000).
Our approach here is to look instead for reradiation of the absorbed light from any hidden
quasar-like nucleus by the dusty obscuring matter (torus). Modulo factors of order unity, the
various models of the obscuring tori predict that the "waste heat" from the obscuring matter
will emerge in the mid-IR, and that this emission is roughly isotropic in all but the highest
inclination cases. (Note that this assumption is the weakest point of our project, but that
the various torus models predict it is true to within a factor of a few: Pier and Krolik 1992,
1993; Granato et al. 1997; Efstathiou and Rowan-Robinson 1995; a related model in Konigl
and Kartje 1994 should also be consulted; Cen A is discussed specifically in Alexander et
al 1999). We are making this test for hidden quasars using the Keck I telescope's mid-IR
instrument (the "LWS"). This is the only way to isolate the nucleus well, and to achieve
the required sensitivity. Here we show the power of the technique, and demonstrate the
existence of at least one "nonthermal" AGN†.
2. Observations
2.1.
3C 405 (Cygnus A)
in Figure 1 we present a diffraction limited mid-IR image of the nuclear source in 3C 405
(Cyg A), obtained with the Long Wavelength Spectrometer (LWS) instrument at the Keck I
telescope‡. All data were taken with the 11.7µm filter, which has an ∼ 1 µm bandpass from
11.2 to 12.2 µm. The image was shown previously in Whysong and Antonucci (2001).
The nucleus of 3C 405 was imaged at 11.7µm with Keck I/LWS on 1999 September
30. The chop/nod throw was set to 10" in order to allow imaging of larger scale extended
structure; this places the chop beam off the chip, which has a 10" field. We do not report on
structures larger than the 10" chop distance. The images were dithered in a 5 position box
pattern, 2" to a side, with 53.1 seconds on-source for the positive image per dither position.
The entire 5-position exposure was repeated three times, for a total on-source time of 796.6
seconds.
Data were processed by subtracting all background chop/nod frames, shifting each
dithered image to the correct position, and coadding all dither images. Morphology is ex-
tended, with structure to the east and southeast of the nucleus (Fig. 1). The standard star
was alpha Ari§, with a FWHM of 0.27".
Our 11.7µm image and a partial spectral energy distribution are shown in Figs. 1 and
5. For comparison, the IRAS (large aperture) data for Cygnus A are listed in Table 3.
-- 5 --
2.2. Cen A
The high resolution mid-IR data on Cen A also come from the Keck I telescope. Data
were obtained on our behalf by Randy Campbell on 28 June 2002. Three filters were used:
the 11.7 µm filter with 1 µm bandpass, a wider "SiC" filter centered at 11.7 µm but with a
2.4 µm bandwidth, and the 17.75 µm filter with a ∼ 1 µm bandwidth. The standard star was
Sigma Sco, a multiple star which was partially resolved so that it was necessary to increase
the synthetic aperture to 2.24 arcsec in order to include all components. No photometric
data are available for Sigma Sco at wavelengths longer than M, so we extrapolated to longer
wavelengths using the Rayleigh-Jeans approximation.
The Cen A images show only an unresolved source in all filters. Photometric calibration
results are F(11.7µm)= 1.6 Jy, F(SiC)= 1.8 Jy with ≈ 0.3 arcsec FWHM resolution, and
F(17.75 µm)= 2.3 Jy with ≈ 0.5 arcsec FWHM resolution.
Since Cen A is so close, there are published data for relatively small physical apertures.
A small physical aperture is key, because for both Cen A and M87, the large-aperture
(e.g. IRAS, ISO) fluxes are much larger than that from the nucleus. But the much higher
resolution Keck data isolate a nuclear point source with size ≈ 5 pc at 11.7µm and ≈ 7.8 pc
at 17.75µm given a distance of 3.1 Mpc.
We will assume that this is mostly dust emission heated by the nucleus. This is consistent
with the 10-20 micron nuclear spectrum taken by ISOCAM CVF in a ∼ 4" aperture (Mirabel
et al. 1999, reproduced here as Fig. 3). In fact, our 11.7 µm flux is in good agreement with
that of the spectrum, suggesting that Fig. 3 is in fact the nuclear spectrum.
For comparison, the published, larger aperture mid-IR fluxes are much higher. The Cen
A central region flux has been measured in the mid-IR by Grasdelen and Joyce (1976). Their
3.5" aperture has the same flux as the 5.2" aperture, so there is a compact source surrounded
by a region of low or zero flux. The 3.5" aperture corresponds to 50 pc, and the enclosed
flux is given as ∼ 2.6 Jy at 11 microns, and 4.3 Jy at 12.6 microns. The IRAS 12.6µm flux
measurement is even higher at 13.3 Jy.
-- 6 --
2.3. M87
Here a new high-resolution Keck I image is also crucial. We obtained this data for
M87 on 2000 January 18. The observation was made in chop-nod mode using a small 3.5"
amplitude so as to keep both the object and chop beams on the CCD chip. The 11.7 µm
filter was used, with a 1µm bandpass.
Integration time was 96 seconds per dither each for positive and negative (background).
Unfortunately, due to a loss of guiding, the positive nucleus image was only fully imaged
in one dither frame. However, we are still left with two independent images, both strong
pointlike detections. Our measurement was taken from the better placed of the two.
Beta And and Mu UMa were used as standards for photometric calibration, yielding a
flux scale of 0.0874 and 0.0931 mJy/(ADU/s) and FWHM of 0.33" and 0.31" respectively.
This calibration for the unresolved nuclear component in M87 results in a flux of 13 +/- 2
mJy. The uncertainty is dominated by systematic errors in the background subtraction; we
adopt a value of 13 mJy. A synthetic aperture of 0.96 arcsec was used, but the source is
unresolved so the flux is insensitive to the aperture.
Again we note that the large aperture fluxes are much higher. In particular the IRAS
fluxes (Moshir et al. 1990) are 231+/−37 mJy at 12µm, <241 mJy at 25µm, and 393+/−51
mJy at 60µm.
3. Discussion
3.1. Cen A
Fig 1 shows the SED for Cen A, combining all the ∼ 1" measurements. For AGN which
show the quasar-like optical nucleus in scattered light only, the mid-IR emission is typically
two orders of magnitude greater than the (scattered) optical light. For Cen A the situation
is similar, but with a slight modification (Bailey et al. 1996; Hough et al. 1987; Antonucci
and Barvainis 1990; Alexander et al. 1999). The ratio is inflated by absorption of the pc
scale scattered optical light by the kpc dust lane famous from photographs.
At 2u, a highly polarized point source indicates detection of a ∼ pc scale reflection
region. The near-IR reflected light from pc scales penetrates the kpc scale dust lane which
has only moderate optical depth. This situation was deduced for 3C323.1 and Cen A by
Antonucci and Barvainis (1990). The pc scale dust screen can be consistently identified with
the cold absorber seen in the X-ray spectrum, which has column density ∼ 3 × 1023 cm−2.
-- 7 --
Additional optical and near-IR scattered light on kpc scales has been mapped and disucssed
by Capetti et al 2000 and Marconi et al 2000.
The case of Cen A shows that even radio galaxies with weak or low-ionization lines (the
"optically dull" ones) can have hidden Type 1 nuclei. Others can be found in e.g. Ekers and
Simkin 1983 and Sambruna et al. 2000.
To show the level of the reflected light in the nuclear region, we have plotted the value
at 2 microns rather than that in the optical (which is highly absorbed). The K-band nuclear
flux with starlight subtracted (Marconi et al. 2000) is F(K) ∼ 3 mJy, and νLν ∼ 6 × 1039
ergs/sec for a distance of 3 Mpc. The SED in Figure 2 shows that the mid-IR luminosity
of the nucleus is much larger than the optical/near-IR value, as expeted. This is consistent
with all other reflected-light objects.
The value of the mid-IR flux quoted above is ∼3.5 Jy at 11.7 microns, interpolated from
measurements at two nearby wavelengths. The corresponding νLν is 1.2 × 1042 erg/sec. As-
suming a normal quasar SED (e.g. Sanders et al 1989; Barvainis et al. 1990), that translates
to a bolometric luminosity of 2 × 1043 ergs/sec for the hidden AGN.
The nature of the mid-IR emission is important. The SED has been fit to a synchrotron
self-Compton model (Chiaberge et al. 2001) which would lead to a classification for Cen A
as a "misaligned BL Lac". However, the fit was to the mid-IR continuum slope instead of
the different ISO bands because the latter were heavily affected by absorption and emission
features (M. Chiaberge 2001, private communication). Small aperture mid-IR spectra show
PAH and Si features (Figure 3), and the SED in ≤ 4" apertures is consistent with predom-
inantly dust rather than synchrotron (Alexander et al. 1999; note also that the ISOCAM
CVF flux from the Mirabel et al. 1999 spectrum is consistent with our 11.7 µm measure-
ment, suggesting that the spectrum is representative of our smaller aperture). These features
indicate that most of the mid-IR flux is thermal emission as expected for the torus model.
3.2. M87
This radio galaxy is on the FR I-II borderline, both in morphology and in radio power
(Owen et al. 2000). It is one of the majority of FR I radio galaxies with an optical/UV point
source (Chiaberge et al. 1999, 2000). The optical point source is tentatively ascribed to
synchrotron radiation associated with the radio core (see Ford & Tsvetanov 1999, as well as
the Chiaberge et al. papers). However it's not known whether this light is highly polarized,
or whether broad emission lines are strong in either total or polarized optical/UV flux.
-- 8 --
Our small ∼ 0.3 arcsec FWHM beam isolates the innermost ∼ 25pc in M87. The
enclosed 11.7µm flux in an 0.6" synthetic aperture is 15 mJy; this aperture matches that
used for Cen A in physical size. The flux measured in this way is much lower than the large
aperture measurements in the literature. Published large-aperture data leave plenty of room
for waste heat from a hidden AGN, but our data do not (Fig. 1). The mid-IR luminosity νLν
is only of order that in the optical rather than much greater as for the hidden AGN sources.
In fact, much or all of the mid-IR flux could simply be synchrotron radiation associated with
the innermost part of the jet, so the measured flux is an upper limit to the dust luminosity.
Note that this outcome for M87 is just what Chiaberge et al. implicitly predicted.
Unless the nuclear dust is too obscured to emit in the mid-IR, this rules out a powerful
hidden nucleus. The observed 11.7µm flux corresponds to νLν = 1.0 × 1041 erg/sec, for a
distance of 15 Mpc. Suppose the mid-IR core is in fact all dust emission. For the SED for
the PG quasar composite of Sanders et al. 1989, a bolometric luminosity of ∼ 1.6 × 1042
ergs/sec is expected. For comparison, a lower limit to the jet kinetic luminosity in M87 is
∼ 5 × 1044 erg/sec (Owen et al. 2000), so the jet is by far the dominant channel for energy
release.k If correct, this suggests that M87 is the true "misaligned BL Lac."
Published ADAF models (Reynolds et al. 1996) predict very low IR-optical-UV lumi-
nosities compared with those in the radio and X-ray. Our 11.7µm point is about equal to the
optical value, but certainly our 11.7µm point may be partially or completely jet emission∗∗.
3.3. Cygnus A
This is a very powerful FR II radio galaxy at a redshift of 0.056. It has strong high-
ionization narrow lines, suggestive of a hidden AGN. A broad Mg II 2800 emission line is
detectable in total flux (Antonucci et al. 1994). That line may or may not be highly polarized,
and thus scattered from a hidden nucleus. Several detailed papers report spectroscopic
and spectropolarimatric data (Goodrich and Miller 1989; Tadhunter et al. 1994; Shaw and
Tadhunter 1994; Vestergaard and Barthel 1993; Stockton et al. 1994; see also Tadhunter et
al. 2000 and Thornton et al. 1999 - and there are several others), culminating in Ogle et al.
1997, which shows an extremely broad H-alpha line in polarized flux. It is virtually invisible
in total flux because its great width makes it hard to distinguish from continuum emission.
A nuclear point source in the near-IR was noted by Djorgovski et al. (1991), but they
don't seem to have considered hot dust emission for this excess over the extrapolation from
the optical light, as we believe.
A powerful hidden nucleus should manifest a mid-IR dust luminosity much larger than
-- 9 --
the observed optical luminosity. However for this object and M87 (and virtually all others!)
the only IR data available were taken with very large beam sizes. We (and Radomski et al.
2002)†† isolate the core much better with the ∼ 0.3 arcsec (∼ 1.1 kpc) resolution provided by
the Keck I telescope, and find a nuclear flux of ∼ 60mJy. An uncertainty here derives from
the extended emission, but flux as a function of aperture size does flatten out for apertures
larger than the seeing disk, so the 0.96" measurement should be approximately correct (see
Table 2). However, we can't be sure from this observation alone that the emission is on pc
scales. Since the emission is powerful and at the relatively short wavelength of 11.7µm, it is
very likely that this comes from nuclear dust rather than a starburst.
It is entirely possible that the extended emission is thermal dust even at radii up to 1
kpc. The temperature of nuclear-heated dust can be estimated according to Barvainis 1988.
Adopting a Hubble constant of 75 km/s Mpc, the νLν luminosity at 11.7µm is 9.2 × 1043
erg/sec. If the intrinsic SED is similar to those of PG quasars (Sanders et al. 1989), the
11.7µm value implies a bolometric luminosity of 16.5 νLν (11.7µm) ∼ 1.5 × 1045 erg/sec.
An optical luminosity of ≈ 1045 erg/s produces a dust temperature of ≈ 120 K at a 500pc
radius. A similar calculation of the dust temperature was done by (Radomski et al. 2002),
yielding a slightly higher results (150 K) due to a higher estimate of the optical luminosity.
Among the uncertainties are the nuclear UV luminosity and the possiblility of single photon
heating.
The IRAS (large aperture, see Table 3) dust spectrum is quite cool, suggesting a large
starburst contribution. Extended emission is seen in our image at 11.7µm. The core can't be
exactly separated from the extensions (see Table 2), but we can estimate around 60 mJy for
the nuclear dust. Fig. 1 shows the Cyg A 11.7µm image, and Fig. 5 shows a partial spectral
energy distribution. The nuclear luminosity νLν at 11.7µm is 10 times higher than that at
0.5µm. The latter wavelength needs two roughly canceling corrections: subtraction of optical
light from the host galaxy, and dereddening (Ogle et al. 1997). The starbust contribution
to the nuclear 11.7µm emission is expected to be small, but this should be checked with a
spectral slope measurement.
The conclusion is simple and expected from prior evidence: Cyg A has a moderately
powerful hidden nucleus.
As noted above, the estimated bolometric luminosity is 1.5 ×1045 erg/s. For comparison
the jet power is estimated several different ways (Carilli and Barthel 1996; Sikora 2001;
Punsly 2001). The values are rough, but generally lie in the >∼ 1045 ergs/sec range. This is
consistent with the finding that jet power and optical/UV luminosity are often comparable
in double radio quasars (e.g., Falcke 1995).
-- 10 --
Thus this is a moderate luminosity broad line radio galaxy with a very high luminosity
radio source.
It has in fact been inferred already that Cygnus A is an over-achiever in
the radio (Carilli and Barthel 1996; Barthel and Arnaud 1996). This is well explained
qualitatively by the fact that it is the only known FR II radio source in a rich X-ray-emitting
cluster.
3.4. Blazars
A goal of this paper is to detect thermal IR bumps, often in the presence of a synchrotron
In general the SED sampling is limited for our targets. Even in cases with
continuum.
convincing dust emission, the dust component is not very well isolated in the infrared SED.
Thus we thought it would be helpful to show a well observed object which clearly isolates a
nonthermal infrared bump from a broadband nonthermal component.
Blazar radio sources are typically dominated over most of their SED by variable syn-
chrotron emission (and/or inverse Compton bump in the X-ray - γ-ray region). This means
that in powerful cases, relatively few continuum components of emission are important for
the SED. For example, starlight and dust warmed to tens of K by stars are relatively weak.
Thus the infrared consists almost entirely of the broadband nonthermal and the (relatively)
narrow band thermal components. The SED, shown in Fig. 4, is that of 3C 273 (data from
Robson et al. 1993). It can be referred to while assessing the other SEDs in this paper.
4. Relation to other Radio Galaxies and Conclusion
Radio lobe emission is fairly isotropic, so it's easy to make lists of double radio sources
that are nearly unbiased with respect to orientation. The visibility of optical point sources
in most of the optically dull (weak or low ionization emission line) galaxies show that there
are no >∼ parsec scale tori present which are able to obscure the unresolved optical sources
in those cases (Chiaberge et al. 1999, 2000). Whatever the nature of the M87 optical point
source, we know it's small from the variability on year timescales. The same would apply to
the other optically dull nuclei if they vary as M87 does. This would strengthen the Chiaberge
et al. argument that we have unobscured sightlines nearly all the way to the central engines.
Since the M87 optical/UV flux is quite variable (e.g., Tsvetanov et al. 1998) jet syn-
chrotron emission is a possibility. By correlating the radio synchrotron core fluxes and the
optical point source fluxes in FR I radio galaxies generally, Chiaberge et al. (1999) infer that
the latter are in fact likely to be beamed synchrotron sources. Crucial tests of the nature of
-- 11 --
the optical point sources can be made with spectroscopy and polarimetry. We hope to do
this with adaptive optics, excluding most of the starlight that dominates in arcsec apertures.
However, a large minority of low ionization FR I and FR II radio galaxies show no point
source, and are similar in this way to AGN with hidden nuclei. In fact the closest FR I,
Cen A, does have a big molecular torus (see Fig. 2 of Rydbeck et al. 1993!), and substantial
evidence for a hidden nucleus as well (see references cited earlier). As a working hypothesis
we might suppose that the same is true for all those without detectable optical pointlike
nuclei. (Of course sensitivity of the optical/UV observations also enters in.)
Thus the FR I family is heterogeneous: some contain hidden optical/UV nuclei and
some do not. It's been difficult to find FR I objects with strong evidence for hidden AGN,
but in fact at least a few are known to be quasar-like from direct spectroscopy (3C120 is
well known; see also Lara et al. 1999 and Sarazin et al. 1999). The infrared peaks in some
blazars such as 3C 66A are clearly distinct from the radio synchrotron, providing further
evidence for FR I objects with hidden thermal emission. Therefore the "nonthermal" model
does not apply to all optically dull or low ionization radio galaxies, or to all FR I galaxies.
The FR class has no apparent direct relation to the mode of energy production, consistent
with much recent evidence that FR Is behave very much like FR IIs at VLBI scales. We will
understand this better after the completion of our mid-IR program.
Finally we reiterate an assumption in our program: we assume that any mid-IR dust
emission is isotropic to within a factor of a few.
-- 12 --
5. Acknowledgements
We wish to thank M. Chiaberge, P. Ogle, B. Wills, and R. Barvainis for good advice.
A thousand huzzas to Randy Campbell at Keck for obtaining the Cen A data.
Alexander, D. M., Efstathiou, A., Hough, J. H., Aitken, D. K., Lutz, D., Roche, P. F., &
REFERENCES
Sturm, E. 1999, MNRAS, 310, 78
Antonucci, R 1982 Nature 299, 605
Antonucci, R 1993 Ann Rev Astron Astrophys 31, 473
Antonucci, R 1984 ApJ 278, 499
Antonucci, R 2001 preprint (astro-ph/0103048)
Antonucci, R, Hurt, T, and Kinney, A 1994 Nature 371, 313
∗We will use the terms "thermal AGN" and "hidden AGN" to refer to the optical/UV continuum and
broad emission lines which characterize the spectra of quiescent quasars, broad line radio galaxies, and
Seyfert galaxies in this spectral region.
†Preliminary reports of this work were published in Anotnucci 2001 and Whysong and Antonucci 2001
(astro-ph 0106381); shortly thereafter, Gemini mid-IR images were published and analyzed by Perlman et
al. 2001. Their measurements and conclusions were similar to ours. Since their images were very deep, they
were also able to detect extended jet emission.
‡Instrument reference is available at: http://www2.keck.hawaii.edu:3636/realpublic/inst/lws/lws.html.
§A table of photometric standards is available at: http://www2.keck.hawaii.edu:3636/realpublic/inst/lws/IRTF Standards.html.
kWe can also make the empirical test of the ratio of the mid-IR flux to that of the radio lobes. We
measured 15mJy at 11.7µm, and NED shows ∼ 220Jy at 1.4GHz. The ratio is 6.8 × 10−5, much lower than
the ratio for the objects with hidden AGN, such as Cen A.
∗∗It is unclear to us why the radio points, which fit the ADAF model, are taken as measurements while the
(non-fitting) optical fluxes were not. Also, the Reynolds et al. figure apparently uses 3C273 as a "thermal"
quasar-like template, but that object definitely has a large jet contribution in the radio and infrared (Robson
et al. 1993).
††Our Keck I image appeared publicly before that of Radomski et al. 2002, but we did relatively little
analysis.
-- 13 --
Barth, A J, Hien, H D, Brotherton, M S, Filippenko, A V, Ho, L C, van Breugel, W,
Antonucci, R, and Goodrich, R 1999 A J 118, 1609
Barthel, P 1989 ApJ 336, 606
Barthel, P D, and Arnaud, K A 1996 MNRAS 283, L45
Barvainis, R E 1987 ApJ 320, 537
Barvainis, R E 1990 ApJ 353, 419
Begelman, M, Blandford, R, and Rees, M 1984 Rev Mod Phys 56, 255
Blandford, R and Znajek, R 1977 MNRAS 179, 433
Carilli, C L, and Barthel, P D 1996 A&AR 7, 1
Capetti, A et al. 2000 ApJ 544, 269
Chiaberge, M, Capetti, A, and Celotti, A 1999 Astron Astrophys 349, 77
Chiaberge, M, Capetti, A, and Celotti, A 2000 Astron Astrophys 355, 873
Chiaberge, M, Capetti, A, and Celotti, A 2001, MNRAS, 324, 33
Clarke, D, Burns, J, and Norman, M 1992 ApJ, 395, 444
Cohen, M H, Ogle, P M, Tran, H D, Goodrich, R W, and Miller, J S, 1999 AJ 188, 1963.
Djorgovski, S, Weir, N, Matthews, K, and Graham, J R 1991 ApJL 372, 67
Miller, J S 1999 Astron J 118, 1963
Efstathiou, A. & Rowan-Robinson, M. 1995, MNRAS, 273, 649
Ekers, R D, and Simkin, S M 1983 ApJ 265, 85
Falcke, H, Malkan, M A, Biermann, P L 1995 A&A 298, 375
Ford, H, and Tsvetanov, Z 1999, in "The Radio Galaxy M87: proceedings of a workshop
held at Ringberg Castle" (NY:Springer), Roser and Meisenheimer, eds., p.∼278
Goodrich, R W, and Miller, J S 1989 ApJ 346, L21.
Gopal-Krishna, Kulkarni, V K, and Wiita, P J 1996 ApJ 463, L1
Granato, G. L., Danese, L., & Franceschini, A. 1997, ApJ, 486, 147
-- 14 --
Grasdalen, G L, and Joyce, R R 1976 ApJ 208, 317
Hes, R., Barthel, P. D., and Fosbury, R. A. E., 1993 Nature 362, 326
Hines, D C, and Wills, B J 1993 ApJ 415, 82
Impey, C D and Neugebauer, G 1988, Astronom. J, 95, 307
Konigl, A. & Kartje, J. F. 1994, ApJ, 434, 446
Kishimoto, M, Antonucci, R, Cimatti, A, Hurt, T, Dey, A, and van Breugel, W 2001, ApJ,
in press; also astro-ph 0010001
Laing, R 1994 Physics of Active Galaxies, ASP Conf Series #54, eds. Bicknell et al.
Lara, L, Marquez, I, Cotton, W D, Feretti, L, Giovannini, G, Marcade, J M, and Venturi,
,T 1999 New Astr Reviews 43, 643
Marconi, A, Schreier, E J, Koekemoer, A, Capetti, A, Axon, D, Macchetto, D, and Caon, N
2000 ApJ 528, 276
Moshir, M. et al. Infrared Astronomical Satellite Catalogs, 1990, The Faint Source Catalog,
version 2.0
Ogle, P M, Cohen, M H, Miller, J S, Tran, H D, Fosbury, R A E, and Goodrich, R W 1997
ApJ 482, L37
Owen, F W, Eilek, J A, and Kassim, N E 2000 ApJ 543, 611
Perlman, E S, Sparks, W B, Radomski, J, Packham, C, Biretta, J, and Fisher, R S, 2001
ApJ 561, 51L
Punsly, B 2001, Black Hole Gravitohydromagnetics (Berlin: Springer)
Radomski, J T, Pina, R K, Packham, C, Telesco, C M, Tadhunter, C 2002 ApJ 566, 675.
Reynolds, C S et al. 1996 MNRAS 283, L111
Robson, E I et al. 1993 MNRAS 262, 249
Robson, E I, Leeuw, L L, Stevens, J A, Holland, W S 1998 MNRAS 301, 935
Rydbeck, G, Wiklind, T, Wild, W, Eckart, A, Genzel, R, and Rothermel, H 1993 A&A 270,
L13
-- 15 --
Sambruna, R M, Chartas, G, Eracleus, M, Mushotzky, R F, and Nousek, J A 2000 ApJ 532,
L91
Sanders, D B, Phinney, E S, Neugebauer, G, Soifer, B T, and Matthews, K 1989 ApJ 347,
29
Sarazin, C L, Koekemoer, A M, Baum, S A, O'dea, C P, Owen, F N, and Wise, M W 1999
ApJ 510, 90
Singal, A 1993 MNRAS 262, L27
Shaw,, M and Tadhunter, C 1994 MNRAS 267, 589
Sikora, M 2001 ASP Conference Series: Blazar Demographics and Physics (in press); also
astro-ph 01011381
Stockton, A Ridgway, S E, and Lilly, S J 1994 AJ 108, 414
Thornton, R J, Stockton, A, and Ridgway, S 1999 AJ 118, 146
Tadhunter, C N, Metz, S, and Robinson, A 1994 MNRAS 268, 989
Tadhunter, C, et al. 2000 MNRAS 313, L52
Tsvetanov, Z et al. 1998 ApJ 493, L83
Vestergaard, M, and Barthel, P D Ap&SS 205, 135
Young, S, Hough, J H, Efstathiou, A, Wills, B J, Axon, D J, Bailey, J A, and Ward, M J
1996 MNRAS 281, 1206
Whysong, D and Antonucci, R, preprint (astro-ph/0106381)
Wilkes, B J, Schmidt, G D, Smith, P S, Mathur, S, and McLoed, K K 1995 ApJ 455, L13
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0.
-- 16 --
Fig. 1. -- Keck I/LWS 11.7µm image of Cygnus A. The arrow indicates north and is 1 arcsec
long.
-- 17 --
Fig. 2. -- Spectral energy distribution for Cen A (triangles, rectangles, and thin lines,
adopted from Chiaberge et al. 2001), and M87 (open circles), with ADAF models for three
different accretion rates (Reynolds et al. 1996). Additional M87 points are from the IRAS
faint source catalog (Moshir et al. 1990) (solid circles) and Keck I/LWS (cross). The Cen A
points have been shifted up two decades for clarity.
-- 18 --
Fig. 3. -- ISOCAM CVF spectrum of Centaurus A (from Mirabel et al. 1999).
-- 19 --
Fig. 4. -- Spectral energy distribution for 3C 273. Data were obtained from Robson et al.
1993.
-- 20 --
Fig. 5. -- Partial core SED for Cygnus A. Data are from IRAS (squares, Impey and Neuge-
bauer 1988), Keck/LWS (triangle), and Palomar 200 inch (circles, Djorgovski et al. 1991).
Errors for the Keck/LWS point represent uncertainty in nuclear emission due to the extended
structure. Other data are plotted with 10% error bars. While measurement errors were much
smaller than this, we include these larger uncertainties due to the different apertures.
-- 21 --
Table 1: Flux Ratios
Mid-IR results are from our Keck I survey.
1.4 GHz (mJy)
3800
4000
8000
5400
5100
10600
11.7µm (mJy)
10
9.7
7.0
186
27.5
22
Name
3C 47
3C 216
3C 219
3C 234
3C 382
3C 452
Ratio
2.6E-3
2.4E-3
8.8E-4
3.4E-2
5.4E-3
2.1E-3
Table 2: LWS photometry results for Cygnus A:
aperture diameter
(arcsec)
0.64
0.96
1.28
1.60
1.92
2.56
3.20
flux (mJy)
44
71
93
111
122
139
152
Table 3: IRAS photometry for Cygnus A (Impey and Neugebauer 1988):
12 µm
25 µm
60 µm
S = 144 +/- 5 mJy
S = 870 +/- 5 mJy
S = 2908 +/- 13 mJy
|
astro-ph/0309096 | 1 | 0309 | 2003-09-03T11:25:10 | The Ionized Gas and Nuclear Environment in NGC 3783. IV. Variability and Modeling of the 900 ks CHANDRA Spectrum | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a detailed spectral analysis of the data obtained from NGC 3783 during the period 2000-2001 using Chandra. This analysis leads us to the following results. 1) NGC 3783 fluctuated in luminosity by a factor ~1.5 during individual observations (~170 ks duration). These fluctuations were not associated with significant spectral variations. 2) On a longer time scale (20-120 days), we found the source to exhibit two very different spectral shapes. The main difference between these can be well-described by the appearance and disappearance of a spectral component that dominates the underlying continuum at the longest wavelengths. The spectral variations are not related to the brightening or the fading of the continuum at short wavelengths in any simple way. 3) The appearance of the soft continuum component is consistent with being the only spectral variation, and there is no need to invoke changes in the opacity of the absorbers. 4) Photoionization modeling indicates that a combination of three ionized absorbers, each split into two kinematic components, can explain the strengths of almost all the absorption lines and bound-free edges. All three components are thermally stable and seem to have the same gas pressure. 5) The only real discrepancy between our model and the observations concerns the range of wavelengths absorbed by the iron M-shell UTA feature. This most likely arises as the result of our underestimation of the poorly-known dielectronic recombination rates appropriate for these ions. 6) The lower limit on the distance of the absorbing gas in NGC 3783 is between 0.2 and 3.2 pc. The assumption of pressure equilibrium imposes an upper limit of about 25 pc on the distance of the least-ionized component from the central source. (abridged) | astro-ph | astro-ph |
THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, ASTRO-PH/0309096
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 7/15/03
THE IONIZED GAS AND NUCLEAR ENVIRONMENT IN NGC 3783.
IV. VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF THE 900 KS CHANDRA SPECTRUM
HAGAI NETZER,1 SHAI KASPI,1 EHUD BEHAR,2 W. N. BRANDT,3 DORON CHELOUCHE,1 IAN M. GEORGE,4,5 D. MICHAEL
CRENSHAW,6 JACK R. GABEL,7 FREDERICK W. HAMANN,8 STEVEN B. KRAEMER,7 GERARD A. KRISS,9,10 KIRPAL NANDRA,11
BRADLEY M. PETERSON,12 JOSEPH C. SHIELDS,13 AND T. J. TURNER,4,5
Received 2003 July 7; accepted 2003 September 1
ABSTRACT
We present a detailed spectral analysis of the data obtained from NGC 3783 during the period 2000 -- 2001 using
Chandra. The data were split in various ways to look for time- and luminosity-dependent spectral variations.
This analysis, along with the measured equivalent widths of a large number of X-ray lines and photoionization
calculations, lead us to the following results and conclusions. 1) NGC 3783 fluctuated in luminosity by a
factor ∼ 1.5 during individual observations (most of which were of 170 ks duration). These fluctuations were
not associated with significant spectral variations. 2) On a longer time scale (20 -- 120 days), we found the
source to exhibit two very different spectral shapes. The main difference between these can be well-described
by the appearance (in the "high state") and disappearance (in the "low state") of a spectral component that
dominates the underlying continuum at the longest wavelengths. Contrary to the case in other objects, the
spectral variations are not related to the brightening or the fading of the continuum at short wavelengths in any
simple way. NGC 3783 seems to be the first AGN to show this unusual behavior. 3) The appearance of the
soft continuum component is consistent with being the only spectral variation, and there is no need to invoke
changes in the opacity of the absorbers lying along the line of sight. Indeed, we find all the absorption lines
which can be reliably measured have the same equivalent widths (within the observational uncertainties) during
high- and low-states. 4) Photoionization modeling indicates that a combination of three ionized absorbers, each
split into two kinematic components, can explain the strengths of almost all the absorption lines and bound-
free edges. These three components span a large range of ionization, and have total column of about 4×1022
cm−2. Moreover, all three components are thermally stable and seem to have the same gas pressure. Thus
all three may co-exist in the same volume of space. This is the first detection of such a multi-component,
equilibrium gas in an AGN. 5) The only real discrepancy between our model and the observations concerns the
range of wavelengths absorbed by the iron M-shell UTA feature. This most likely arises as the result of our
underestimation of the poorly-known dielectronic recombination rates appropriate for these ions. We also note
a small discrepancy in the calculated column density of O VI and discuss its possible origin. 6) The lower limit
on the distance of the absorbing gas in NGC 3783 is between 0.2 and 3.2 pc, depending on the component of
ionized gas considered. The assumption of pressure equilibrium imposes an upper limit of about 25 pc on the
distance of the least-ionized component from the central source.
Subject headings: galaxies: active -- galaxies: individual (NGC 3783) -- galaxies: nuclei -- galaxies: Seyfert
-- techniques: spectroscopic -- X-rays: galaxies
1 School of Physics and Astronomy, Raymond and Beverly Sackler Fac-
ulty of Exact Sciences, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv 69978, Israel.
2 Physics Department, Technion, Haifa 32000, Israel
3 Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 525 Davey Laboratory, The
Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802.
4 Laboratory for High Energy Astrophysics, NASA/Goddard Space Flight
Center, Code 662, Greenbelt, MD 20771.
5 Joint Center for Astrophysics, Physics Department, University of Mary-
land, Baltimore County, 1000 Hilltop Circle, Baltimore, MD 21250.
6 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Georgia State University, At-
MD 21218
11 Astrophysics Group, Imperial College London, iBlackett Laboratory,
Prince Consort Rd., London SW7 2AZ, UK
12 Department of Astronomy, Ohio State University, 140 West 18th Av-
enue, Columbus, OH 43210-1106.
13 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Clippinger Research Labs 251B,
Ohio University, Athens, OH 45701-2979.
lanta, GA 30303.
MD 20771.
7 Catholic University of America, NASA/GSFC, Code 681, Greenbelt,
8 Department of Astronomy, University of Florida, 211 Bryant Space Sci-
ence Center, Gainesville, FL 32611-2055.
9 Center for Astrophysical Sciences, Department of Physics and Astron-
omy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218-2686.
10 Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore,
1. INTRODUCTION
The barred-spiral galaxy NGC 3783 (V ≃ 13.5 mag., z =
0.0097) hosts a well-studied, type-I active galactic nucleus
(AGN) with prominent broad emission lines and strong X-
ray absorption features. The object has been observed ex-
tensively with almost all X-ray instruments, most recently by
Chandra (Kaspi et al. 2002, hereafter Paper I) and XMM-
Newton (Blustin et al 2002). The 2 -- 10 keV flux of NGC 3783
varies in the range ∼ (4 -- 9) × 10−11 ergs cm−2 s−1, and its
mean 2 -- 10 keV luminosity is ∼ 1.5 × 1043 erg s−1 (for H0 =
70 km s−1 Mpc−1 and q0 = 0.5). Paper I gives an extensive
list of references and a comprehensive summary of historical
observations, including ground-based and UV (HST) observa-
tions. It also discusses the unique Chandra data set obtained
in 2000 -- 2001. These observations consist of a relatively short
observation performed in 2000 January, and five longer ob-
servations performed in 2001 February -- June, separated by
various intervals from 2 to 120 days (see §2). Paper I con-
tains numerous illustrations of the mean spectrum, absorption
line profiles and detailed measurements of many absorption
and emission lines. Two other papers (Gabel et al. 2003a,b)
2
NETZER ET AL.
discuss the HST and FUSE data obtained as part of this multi-
waveband campaign.
There have been several previous attempts to model the
characteristics of the X-ray absorbing gas along the line of
sight to NGC 3738. Here we comment only on the more de-
tailed works. A very detailed work Kaspi et al (2001) at-
tempted to fit the spectrum obtained with Chandra in 2000.
The Kaspi et al. most successful model consists of two ab-
sorbing shells, both outflowing from the central source with
a velocity of ∼ 600 km s−1. The gas in both shells was as-
sumed to be turbulent with internal turbulent motion of ∼ 250
km s−1. The two shells had similar column densities, but dif-
ferent ionization parameters. The model is consistent with
the intensity and equivalent width (EW) of many (but not all)
emission and absorption lines observed in the spectrum. A
major limitation of the Kaspi et al. (2001) work was the lim-
ited signal-to-noise (S/N) of the spectrum, which results in
large uncertainties on the model parameters. In addition, the
limited duration of the only observation then available did not
allow a meaningful analysis of any time-dependence. A new
paper, by Krongold et al. (2003, hereafter K03), discussing
the full Chandra data set, was accepted for publication after
the submission of our paper. Some results of that work are
relevant to our study and are discussed in the various sections
below.
This paper discusses the complete spectroscopic Chandra
data of NGC 3783. We present our modeling of this material,
with emphasis on the properties of the absorber(s) along the
line of sight. In §2 we describe the two X-ray spectral states
discovered using the new observations. In §3 we explain the
various ways we measured and modeled the spectrum. §4 con-
tains a discussion of the new findings, and §5 summarizes our
new results.
2. THE TWO-STATE X-RAY SPECTRUM OF NGC 3783
A full description of the Chandra data considered here is
given in Paper I. In brief, there were 5 observations (each of
∼170 ks duration) obtained over the period 2001 February --
June, and a shorter observation (of ∼56 ks duration) obtained
in 2000 January (and also discussed in Kaspi et al. 2001). All
six observations were performed with the High-Energy Trans-
mission Grating Spectrometer (HETGS) in place, and consist
of a total exposure of 888.7 ks. All measurements in Paper
I refer to a time-averaged spectrum, produced by combining
the first-order spectra from both grating arms, using 0.01 A
wide bins. Third-order data from the medium-energy grat-
ing (MEG) were also used to compare the profiles of several
short-wavelength lines with the first-order profiles obtained
for several lines at longer wavelength. It was found that most
of the resolved absorption lines (e.g. O VII, Ne IX and Si XIV
lines) consist of at least two kinematic components, outflow-
ing at −500 ± 100 km s−1 and −1000 ± 200 km s−1 (respec-
tively). The overall absorption profiles in NGC 3783 covers
the velocity range of 0 to -1600 km s−1 (e.g. see Figs. 5 & 10
in Paper I).
A major goal of the present work is to investigate subsets
of the Chandra data. We subdivided the data in various ways
to search for spectral variations as a function of source lumi-
nosity and/or time. This was done for both short (i.e. within
the individual 170 ks observations) as well as for long (be-
tween observations i.e. 20 -- 90 days) time scales. The short
time-scale behavior of NGC 3783 is illustrated in Fig.1 which
shows the short wavelength (2 -- 10 A) flux as a function of time
for all observations binned in intervals of 3170 sec in the left
panels. The right panels shows the "softness" ratio, defined
as the flux in the 15 -- 25 A band divided by that in the 2 -- 10 A
band, to illustrate now the different variability characteristics
exhibited by the source above and below ∼1 keV.
From Fig. 1 it can be seen that the 2 -- 10 A flux varied
by about 50% over the 170 ks duration of each of the ob-
servations. However, inspection of the corresponding soft-
ness light curves shows that the spectral variations are much
smaller and almost insignificant. Thus, the data show very
little cahnges of the spectral energy distribution (SED) over
time scales .4 days ("obsids" 2090 and 2091 are consecutive
with total duration of about 4 days). To further test this find-
ing, we have also extracted various spectra when the source
was in different intensity states, but did not find any signifi-
cant spectral variations during this period. We also note that
Behar et al. (2003) did not find any spectral variations dur-
ing a three-day observation of NGC 3783 in 2001 December
using XMM-Newton.
Contrary to the above, there is a very significant change of
SED on longer time scales.
In particular, there is a major
change in the softness ratio between obsids 2092 and 2093
(separated by 20 days) and obsids 2093 and 2094 (separated
by 90 days). As shown in Fig. 1, obsid 2093 shows a higher
mean count rate but exhibits a much softer spectrum. Direct
comparison of the time-averaged spectra obtained during ob-
sid 2093 with that obtained during obsid 2094 reveals the low
energy part (l > 15 A) decreased in flux by a factor of ∼ 4,
but that the shorter wavelength continuum exhibited a much
smaller decrease (factor ∼ 1.5) The opposite change occured
between obsids 2092 and 2093. Most importantly, the soft-
ness ratio variations are not simple luminosity-related effects.
For example, the 2 -- 10 A count rate in the middle of obsid
2093 (Fig. 1) is a little lower than the 2 -- 10 A flux toward
the end of obsid 2094, yet the softness ratios are significantly
different. A similar effect is seen in obsid 2093, during which
the 2 -- 10 A count rate varied by about 50% yet the softness
ratio remaining approximately constant.
In light of these results, we have divided the entire data set
into groups with high and low softness ratios. We find four
observations (2090, 2091, 2092 and 2094) with low softness
ratio and two (0373 and 2093) with high softness ratio. Here-
after we refer to these as the "low-" and "high-state" observa-
tions, respectively. We find no significant differences between
the mean spectra of the four individual low-state observations
(except for a small intensity variations). Similarly we find no
significant differences between the mean spectral shapes of
the two high-state observations.
Fig. 2 is a more detailed example of this phenomenon. It
shows the softness ratio as a function of the 2 -- 10 A flux for
all the data using 3170s bins. A separation into two groups
is apparent, and a standard KS statistical test confirms its sig-
nificance. We have also investigated possible linear correla-
tions of the softness ratio with the 2 -- 10 A flux within each
of the states. For the low-state observations, we find a sig-
nificant (> 99%) linear correlation between softness ratio and
flux. However, as can be seen from Fig.2, clearly this line
does not connect the low- and high-state data. No significant
correlation of softness ratio with flux was found for the high-
state data. We conclude that the X-ray spectrum of NGC 3783
fluctuates between two states of different softness ratio. The
combined spectra of the two are shown in Fig. 3 and much of
the rest of this paper is devoted to the analysis of this unusual
behavior of NGC 3783.
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
3
obsid=2094
2001 Jun 26
2087
2087.5
2088
2088.5
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
2001 Jun 26
2087
2087.5
2088
2088.5
obsid=2093
2001 Mar 31
2000
2000.5
2001
2001.5
obsid=2092
2001 Mar 10
1979
1979.5
1980
1980.5
obsid=2091
2001 Feb 27
2001 Mar 31
2000
2000.5
2001
2001.5
2001 Mar 10
1979
1979.5
1980
1980.5
2001 Feb 27
8
7
6
5
4
3
8
7
6
5
4
3
1999.5
8
7
6
5
4
3
1978.5
8
7
6
5
4
3
]
1
-
Å
1
-
s
2
-
m
c
s
g
r
e
1
1
-
0
1
[
r
e
d
r
o
t
s
r
i
f
G
E
M
Å
0
1
-
2
x
u
l
F
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
1999.5
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
1978.5
r
e
d
r
o
t
s
r
i
f
G
E
M
)
x
u
l
f
Å
0
1
-
2
(
/
)
x
u
l
f
Å
5
2
-
5
1
(
[
o
i
t
a
r
s
s
e
n
t
f
o
S
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
1968
1968.5
1969
1969.5
obsid=2090
2001 Feb 24
1965.5
1966
1966.5
1967
obsid=0373
2000 Jan 21
8
7
6
5
4
3
8
7
6
5
4
3
1564.5
1565
1565.5
1566
1566.5
JD - 2450000
1968
1968.5
1969
1969.5
2001 Feb 24
1965.5
1966
1966.5
1967
0.24
0.2
0.16
0.12
0.08
0.04
1564.5
2000 Jan 21
1565
1565.5
1566
1566.5
JD - 2450000
FIG. 1. -- MEG 2 -- 10 A flux light curves (left) and softness ratios (ratio of the 2 -- 10 and the 15 -- 25 A count rates, right) for all Chandra observations of
NGC 3783. The dashed lines across observations no. 2093 and 2094 represent constant flux (4.8) and softness ratio (0.15). They illustrate the fact that similar
2 -- 10 A fluxes (middle part of obs. 2093 and last part of obs. 2094) can be associated with very different softness ratios.
4
]
)
x
u
l
f
Å
0
1
-
2
(
/
)
x
u
l
f
Å
5
2
-
5
1
(
[
o
i
t
a
r
s
s
e
n
t
f
o
S
0.24
0.21
0.18
0.15
0.12
0.09
0.06
Obsn. 2090
Obsn. 2091
Obsn. 2092
Obsn. 2094
Obsn. 0373
Obsn. 2093
3
3.5
4.5
4
2-10 Å Flux [10-11 ergs cm-2 s-1 Å-1]
5.5
5
6
NETZER ET AL.
TABLE 1. EQUIVALENT WIDTHSa
Ion & Line
low state
high state Kaspi et al. (2002)
Si XIV l 6.182
Si XIII l 6.648
Si XII l 6.718 b
Si XI l 6.778
Si X l 6.859
Si IX l 6.931
Si VIII l 6.999
S XVI l 4.729
S XV l 5.039
20.4 ± 1.2
16.0 ± 1.3
2.9 ± 0.5
4.8 ± 0.8
10.6 ± 1.1
7.2 ± 1.0
4.3 ± 1.0
11.5 ± 1.6
8.7 ± 1.7
22.6 ± 1.7
14.6 ± 1.3
3.8 ± 0.7
5.9 ± 1.2
9.4 ± 1.4
7.7 ± 1.6
4.4 ± 1.4
11.6 ± 2.5
9.1 ± 2.5
20.5 ± 0.8
14.9 ± 0.7
3.0 ± 0.4
4.8 ± 0.6
10.9 ± 0.8
7.1 ± 0.7
4.3 ± 0.8
10.7 ± 1.2
9.2 ± 1.2
aEquivalent widths were measured as described in Paper I and are given in
m A.
bThis line is blended with Mg XII l 6.738 with 1:1 ratio. Tabulated values
are only for the Si XII l 6.718 line.
6.5
7
7.5
A
/
2
m
c
/
c
e
s
/
n
o
o
h
p
4
−
0
1
t
FIG. 2. -- Softness ratio vs. 2 -- 10 A flux for the data in Fig. 1. The low
and high-state observations are shown as filled and open symbols, respec-
tively, and the various observations are denoted with different colors. The
solid straight line is the linear regression fit to the low-state observations. No
significant correlation of softness ratio vs. flux was found for the high state
observations.
25
20
15
10
5
0
5
10
15
rest wavelength (A)
20
FIG. 3. -- High-state (red, observations 0373 and 2093 combined) and low-
state (blue, all other observations combined) spectra of NGC 3783 binned to
0.04 A. The solid lines are the two chosen intrinsic continua (see §3.2.5). The
lower continuum is a single power-law with G = 1.6. The high continuum is
made out of two power-laws with slopes G = 1.6 and G = 3.2 and relative
normalization of 1:0.4 at 1 keV. These power-laws are discussed in §3.2.5.
3. SPECTRAL ANALYSIS AND MODELING
3.1. Spectral differences between the high and the low states
We have investigated the unusual variations observed in the
spectrum of NGC 3783 in an attempt to understand their na-
ture and their origin. In particular, we have attempted to an-
swer the question of whether they are due to the response of
the absorbing gas to the variations observed in the continuum.
There are two ways to answer the above question -- by a
direct and detailed spectral comparison, and by modeling the
two spectra trying to establish the origin of the differences.
Fig. 4 is an example of the first approach. The diagrams
shows a comparison of the low- and high-state spectra after
applying a simple scaling factor to the former such that the
(local) continua have the same intensity. As the scaling factor
is wavelength dependent, we divided the two spectra into sev-
eral bands and applied different factors in each case. The two
examples shown in Fig. 4 (and all others we have examined)
illustrate that, except for a luminosity scaling, the two absorp-
tion line spectra are indistinguishable within the uncertainties
(∼10% for the low-state spectrum and about twice that for the
high-state spectrum). The somewhat weaker looking lines of
low ionization species in the high-state spectrum (e.g. around
7 A) are well within the noise. Table 1 lists the EWs measured
for several key absorption lines (see §3.2.3) in both the high-
and low-state spectra. Again, the small differences between
the two spectra are well within the measurement errors. We
proceed under the assumption that there are no variations in
the line EWs between the two states. We comment on the
implications of this in §4.1.
3.2. Spectral modeling
The second and complementary approach for investigat-
ing the spectral changes is by detailed modeling of the ab-
sorbing and emitting gas. The underlying idea is that the
gas is photoionized by the central X-ray source, and that the
observed spectra represent its physical state during the two
states. The principles and the ingredients of such modeling
were outlined in Netzer (1996) and previous applications to
the case of NGC 3783 were discussed by Kaspi et al. (2001).
A very recent analysis is provided by K03 who describe a
detailed model composed of two absorbers that are different
from those suggested by Kaspi et al. (2001). Below we com-
ment on the similarity and differences between our work and
the new K03 paper. Here we summarize our basic method and
explain its application to the high and the low-state spectra of
NGC 3783.
3.2.1. General method and model ingredients
The X-ray gas is assumed to be photoionized by a central
source, and in photoionization and thermal equilibrium (see
§4 for discussion of the last point). Modeling was performed
using ION2003, the 2003 version of the code ION (Netzer
1996). The code includes all relevant atomic processes, and
computes the ionization and thermal structure of the gas along
with the intensities and EWs for more than 2000 X-ray lines.
The code is able to consider various geometries, from a sin-
gle cloud to a multi-component, expanding atmosphere. The
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
5
A
/
2
m
c
/
c
e
s
/
/
n
o
t
o
h
p
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
n
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
high vs. 1.5xlow
6.2
6.4
6.6
6.8
7
7.2
rest wavelength [A]
A
/
2
m
c
/
c
e
s
/
n
o
t
o
h
p
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
n
6
4
2
0
high vs. 3xlow
16
16.5
17
rest wavelength [A]
17.5
FIG. 4. -- Left: High-state (red) vs. low-state (blue) 6 -- 7 A spectra of NGC 3783 showing the great similarity in absorption line EWs (cf. table 1). The low-state
spectrum was multiplied by 1.5 to match the flux of the high-state continuum. For clarity, error bars are only plotted for the low state spectrum. Right: Same for
the 15.6 -- 18 A range except for the different scaling of the low-state continuum.
TABLE 2. ASSUMED COMPOSITION
Element Relative abundance
H
He
C
N
O
Ne
Mg
Al
Si
S
Ar
Ca
Fe
1.0
0.1
3.7 × 10−4
1.1 × 10−4
5.0 × 10−4
1.0 × 10−4
3.7 × 10−5
3.0 × 10−6
3.5 × 10−5
1.6 × 10−5
3.3 × 10−6
2.3 × 10−6
4.0 × 10−5
basic parameters of the model are the gas density (assumed
to be in the range 102−6 cm−3 - see justification in §4), the
hydrogen column density (N, in units of cm−2), the covering
factor, the gas composition, turbulent motion (§3.2.2) and the
oxygen ionization parameter (UOX ) defined over the energy
range 0.54 -- 10 keV. As explained by Netzer (1996), and dis-
cussed further in George et al. (1998), this choice of ioniza-
tion parameter (compared with, for example, UX defined over
the 0.1 -- 10 keV range) gives the most meaningful definition of
the ionization field of X-ray photons for AGN. Regarding the
covering factor, we distinguish between the emission covering
factor (W /4p ) applicable to the emission line gas, and the ab-
sorption (line of sight) covering factor which can be different.
The "solar composition" used throughout this work is given in
Table 2 (note the reduced oxygen abundance compared with
older estimates).
The incident continuum is taken to be the broken power-
law defined in Kaspi et al. (2001, Table 4). The only changes
we have experimented with are related to the slope of the 0.1 --
50 keV continuum. As discussed below, the UV part of the
spectrum can be different from the one assumed here with
important implications for the UV absorption lines. This will
be investigated in a forthcoming paper. The effects of the UV
continuum on the strongest features seen in the X-ray band
are of far less importance. Thus we consider this SED to be
adequate for the present analysis.
The models calculated here are entirely self-consistent and
are not simple attempts to fit the observed spectra by measur-
ing line EWs and deducing column densities for the differ-
ent ions. We have searched for the combination of physical
components that can be produced in nature in an environment
where low density gas is exposed to a typical AGN contin-
uum. These components were then combined in a realistic
manner, taking into account screening, attenuation of the ra-
diation field, etc.
3.2.2. Multi-component models
We have examined the hypothesis that the spectral changes
observed arise purely as a result of variations in the opacity
of the absorbing gas which are caused solely by changes in
the intensity of the ionizing continuum. Thus, for this experi-
ment, we assume the shape of the SEDs is the same for both
the low- and high-states and only differ in total luminosity.
We start by calculating a variety of models in order to mimic
the low-state spectrum. Each model is made of several emis-
sion and absorption components. The absorbers are specified
by UOX , N and the absorption (i.e. line of sight) covering fac-
tor. The latter is assumed to be the same for all absorbers (but
see also §4). The absorbers are assumed to be aligned such
that the observed spectrum is the result of the intrinsic contin-
uum passing through them all. The emission components are
specified by their UOX and N (that are not necessarily the same
as those of the absorbers), their covering factor and whether
or not they are occulted by the absorbing gas.
The dynamics and kinematics of the absorbing gas are im-
portant factors in comparing the data with the model. Fol-
lowing numerous UV observations, and our analysis in Pa-
6
NETZER ET AL.
TABLE 3. COLUMN DENSITIESa
per I, we assumed internal motion in the gas which is much
larger than the thermal motion. This "turbulent velocity" is
assumed to have a Doppler profile and the velocity quoted
is the Doppler b parameter. Paper I showed that all absorp-
tion lines with good S/N and sufficient resolution (the lines
of O VII, Ne X, Mg XII and Si XIV) can be characterized by
two kinematic components. The central velocities of these are
between -400 and -600 km s−1 and between -1000 and -1300
km s−1, relative to the systemic velocity. A good represen-
tation of the observations can be obtained with two Doppler
profiles each with b ≃ 250 km s−1.
The relative EW and covering factor of the two velocity
components are critical to our modeling of the source. The
observations show that the EW ratio of the velocity compo-
nents is about 1:0.7 (lower:higher) in all lines with sufficient
S/N (see below). Since this ratio is seen in several saturated
lines, it can be interpreted as the result of different absorp-
tion covering factors for each component. In this case, the
lower-velocity component has a covering factor of 0.8 -- 1.0
and the larger-velocity component a covering factor of 0.6 --
0.8. However, the composite profiles also include unsaturated
lines that seem to have similar shapes. In this case, the dif-
ferent EWs are due to different column densities. We cannot
distinguish between the two possibilities since we do not have
high-quality, high-resolution profiles for many weak lines.
Given these uncertainties, we investigated two cases where
the relative column densities for the two velocity components
are in the ratio of 1:0.7. In one case the covering factor of all
absorbers is unity and in the other case it is of order 0.8.
In summary, each ionization component of the models pre-
sented in this paper is made of two kinematic components.
For the outflow velocities we chose -500 and -1000 km s−1,
and assumed a turbulent velocity of 250 km s−1 for all com-
ponents. This implies that the total derived column density
of a certain ionization component is the sum of the column
densities in the two kinematic components, even for saturated
lines (since there is very little velocity overlap between the
two). For brevity, in the rest of this paper we just quote the
total column densities. Given these assumptions, we used the
EWs measured in Paper I, combined with a few new mea-
surements, to obtain the various column densities and optical
depths. The more important lines that were used to constrain
our models, and their adopted column densities, are listed in
Table 3.
3.2.3. The silicon and sulphur line method
A major clue for the conditions in the absorbing gas is ob-
tained from EW measurements of various lines in the 5 -- 7.1 A
band. This wavelength range contains lines from Si VII to
Si XIV as well as the strongest lines of S XV and S XVI. Most
of these lines are not blended. The range of ionization and ex-
citation is very large and represents the ionization of almost
all line-producing ions in the Chandra spectrum. The column
densities deduced from these EWs, assuming the two compo-
nent profiles, are given in Tables 1 & 3. The atomic data for
the lines are known either from standard calculations (f-values
for the H-like and He-like transitions) or from the recent work
of Behar and Netzer (2002) discussing the inner-shell lines of
silicon, sulphur and other elements.
We have developed a simple algorithm to compare the mea-
sured optical depths of all the observed silicon and sulphur
lines with the results of the photoionization calculations. We
first compute a large grid of models with calculated optical
depths for a large range of ionization parameters and column
Ion & Line
Si XIV l 6.182
Si XIV l 5.217
Si XIV l 4.947
Si XIV adopted value
Si XIII l 6.648
Si XIII l 5.681
Si XIII l 5.405
Si XIII l 5.286
Si XIII adopted value
Si XII l 6.718
Si XI l 6.778
Si X l 6.859
Si IX l 6.931
Si VIII l 6.999
Si VII l 7.063
S XVI l 4.729
S XVI l 3.991
S XVI adopted value
S XV l 5.039
S XV l 4.299
S XV adopted value
Mg VIII l 9.506
Mg IX l 9.378
O VIII l 14.821
O VIII l 14.634
O VIII adopted value
O VII l 17.396
O VII l 17.200
O VII adopted value
O VI l 21.01
O VI l 19.341
O VI adopted value
O V l 22.334
O V l 19.924
O V adopted value
measuredb
> 17.50c
17.94 ± 0.10
17.83 ± 0.20
17.90 ± 0.20
> 16.87c
> 17.23c
17.57 ± 0.20
17.71 ± 0.25
17.65 ± 0.20
16.10 ± 0.06
16.29 ± 0.06
16.83 ± 0.05
16.66 ± 0.06
16.66 ± 0.08
16.26 ± 0.20
> 17.29c
17.58 ± 0.13
17.58 ± 0.13
16.87 ± 0.09
17.08 ± 0.25
17.00 ± 0.20
16.58 ± 0.05
16.39 ± 0.06
18.67 ± 0.25
18.59 ± 0.14
18.63 ± 0.25
18.03 ± 0.20
18.04 ± 0.20
18.04 ± 0.20
> 16.42c
> 17.00c
> 17.00
> 16.34c
model log(Uox)
−2.4 −1.2 −0.6
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
12.50
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
14.68
15.57
16.43
16.90
17.04
16.81
16.13
· · ·
· · ·
10.13
· · ·
· · ·
12.70
16.77
17.06
· · ·
· · ·
17.65
· · ·
· · ·
18.39
· · ·
· · ·
17.96
· · ·
· · ·
17.54
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
17.00
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
17.31
16.55
16.15
15.88
15.27
14.26
12.71
· · ·
· · ·
16.23
· · ·
· · ·
16.90
14.46
15.13
· · ·
· · ·
18.05
· · ·
· · ·
16.84
· · ·
· · ·
14.34
· · ·
· · ·
12.59
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
17.48
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
16.94
15.41
14.11
13.10
11.68
9.93
7.80
· · ·
· · ·
17.16
· · ·
· · ·
17.00
11.13
12.61
· · ·
· · ·
17.55
· · ·
· · ·
15.49
· · ·
· · ·
12.23
· · ·
· · ·
9.3
total
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
17.60
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
· · ·
17.46
16.62
16.61
16.94
17.05
16.81
16.13
· · ·
· · ·
17.21
· · ·
· · ·
17.25
16.77
17.07
· · ·
· · ·
18.28
· · ·
· · ·
18.40
· · ·
· · ·
17.96
· · ·
· · ·
17.54
17.07 ± 0.40
17.07 ± 0.40
aLog of column density in units of cm−2.
bColumn densities and uncertainties derived from the EWs in Paper I. The
EW was divided in the ratio 1:0.7, then the column density corresponding to
the 1/1.7 part was computed assuming a Doppler width of 250 km s−1. The
derived column density was multiplied by 1.7 to result with the total column
density listed here. Uncertainties were calculated from the EWs uncertanties.
See text for details.
cSaturated line, lower limit only.
densities. We then pick up to four models at a time and com-
pare the combined optical depth for the chosen set of lines
with the values deduced from the observations for the larger
column density (lower outflow velocity) kinematic compo-
nent. The best combination of models is obtained by mini-
mizing the differences between the observed and the calcu-
lated optical depths in all 10 lines (the 9 silicon and sulphur
lines listed in Table 1 plus a line of Si VII). The result is a list
of up to four models, with various column density and UOX ,
whose combination gives the best match to the observed col-
umn densities. Using this procedure we find that at least three
ionization components (i.e. six kinematic components) are re-
quired to fit the data to within the observational accuracy. The
reason is the very large difference in ionization between the
lowest (e.g. Si VII and Si VIII) and the highest (e.g. S XVI)
ionization lines. This requires at least one component to fit the
EWs of the lowest ionization lines, one to fit the intermediate
ionization lines and one for the highest ionization lines.
Experimenting with various modifications of the method
suggests that there are several combinations of three or four
ionization components that give similar quality fits to the ob-
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
7
Log(Uox)=−0.6 Log(N)=22.3
Log(Uox)=−1.2 Log(N)=22
Log(Uox)=−2.4 Log(N)=21.9
Log(UOX)=−0.6 Log(N)=22.3
Log(UOX)=−1.2 Log(N)=22.0
Log(UOX)=−2.4 Log(N)=21.9
A
/
2
m
c
/
n
o
t
o
h
p
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
n
1
.5
0
1
.5
x
u
l
f
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
n
S
Si
5
10
15
20
wavelength
25
30
35
0
4.5
5
5.5
6
wavelength [A]
6.5
7
FIG. 5. -- The three generic components that were used to model the low-
state spectrum of NGC 3783. All components are shown on the same nor-
malized scale where 1 is the incident continuum level.
FIG. 6. -- A blown up version of Fig. 5 showing the 4.5 -- 7 A region used
to constrain the model parameters (see text). Note that all three models are
required to explain the large range of ionization (from Si VII to S XVI.)
this column gives rises to an uncertainty on the slope.
served optical depths of the silicon and sulphur lines. All
combinations share the same general properties -- they all
require at least three very different sets of physical condi-
tions (i.e.
ionization parameters) and three similar column
densities. A generic model with the required properties is
the following three-component model (all column densities
refer to the total column of the two kinematic components):
a low ionization component with log(UOX ) = −2.4 ± 0.1 and
log(N) = 21.9 ± 0.1, a medium ionization component with
log(UOX ) = −1.2 ± 0.2 and log(N) = 22.0 ± 0.15, and a
high ionization component with log(UOX ) = −0.6 ± 0.2 and
log(N) = 22.3 ± 0.2. The uncertainties on UOX and N in the
case of the low ionization component arise primarily from the
uncertainty on the slope of the ionizing continuum. Relax-
ing this constraint allows a somewhat smaller column density
(see §3.2.4). The larger uncertainties on the parameters of the
higher ionization components are due to the fact that gas with
such properties produce similar EWs for medium (e.g. Si XI)
and high (e.g. Si XIV) ionization lines over a larger range of
ionization parameters and column densities. The three the-
oretical ionization components are plotted over a large wave-
length range in Fig. 5, and a more detailed view of the 4.5 -- 7 A
range is shown in Fig. 6.
3.2.4. Intrinsic continuum and global model properties
The next step is to test the combination of components that
fit the optical depths of the 5 -- 7.1 A silicon and sulphur ions
best over other wavelength bands. This requires the shape of
the underlying ionizing continuum to be defined more pre-
cisely. The slope of the short wavelength continuum can
be measured directly if bound-free absorption is negligible.
However, Fig. 5 clearly shows that two of the generic ab-
sorbers are characterized by large opacity at wavelengths as
short as 4 -- 5 A. Thus a unique determination of the 2 -- 5 A con-
tinuum slope (the part available for the grating observations)
is not trivial. More specifically, the exact O VII column den-
sity in the lowest-ionization component strongly influences
the short wavelength continuum shape, and the uncertainty on
Given the above constraints on the model properties, and
the observed 2 -- 5 A continuum, we have experimented with
various power-law continua with the requirement that both
the short wavelength continuum and the measured EWs of
the silicon and sulphur lines, are within the observational un-
certainties. All fits were performed on the low-state spec-
trum. We found that a single power-law (where the number
of photons per unit energy, E, is proportional to E −G ) with
G = 1.65 ± 0.15 is a good overall representation of the low-
state spectrum. We note that the limited data quality cannot
exclude the possibility of some steepening of the intrinsic con-
tinuum at long (l > 20 A) wavelengths.
We note in passing the different continuum slope adopted
by K03 in their recent modeling of the source. These authors
did not consider the two spectral states found here and fitted
the full Chandra data set. As a result, the SED they adopted
is based on the combined (high- and low- state) spectrum, and
hence is different from ours. This is also the reason why their
powerlaw slope is flatter than the one adopted by Kaspi et al.
(2001), who fitted the high state only. K03 also include in
their SED a low-energy blackbody component.
Another uncertainty on the intrinsic SED arises from the
fact that some of the high energy photons are likely to be
produced far away from the source, due to Compton scatter-
ing and reflection of the central continuum radiation. This
can be very noticeable in faint sources, like NGC 3516 dur-
ing 2000 (see Netzer et al. 2002). Scattering by gas in a
low state of ionization is strongly wavelength dependent, and
for NGC 3783 can amount to a change of ∼ 0.1 in the de-
rived value of G
. As a result, we might have overestimated
the column density of the lowest ionization component (the
only component with significant influence on the slope of the
short wavelength continuum) which would results in overesti-
mating the column densities of low ionization species such as
O V and O VI. §4.1 contains some discussion about the low-
ering of the column density in our low UOX component and a
more detailed examination of this effect is deferred to a sepa-
8
NETZER ET AL.
rate paper (George et al. 2003, in preparation).
Finally, a broad, relativistic iron Ka
line can also be impor-
tant in affecting the short wavelength continuum slope. The
presence or absence of such a feature is an open question.
Kaspi et al.
(2001) see no evidence for this feature in the
2000 Chandra observation. Given the uncertainties discussed
above, and the large amount of absorption at almost all wave-
lengths, we cannot resolve this issue even with our much im-
proved data.
Given the chosen continuum and the three ionization com-
ponents, we have calculated a combined multi-component
model that covers the entire wavelength range. As stated
above, the model includes two kinematic components for ev-
ery ionization component. The theoretical spectrum is com-
pared with the observed low-state spectrum in Fig. 7. The re-
sults are very good. In fact, we could not find another combi-
nation of models (three or more absorbers) that is significantly
superior. Not only does the model provide a good overall fit
to many lines of all elements, but it also predicts the strengths
of the deep bound-free edges correctly. Thus, the constraints
on the 5 -- 7.1 A silicon and sulphur lines are enough to com-
pletely specify a model for the entire spectrum.
3.2.5. Deficiencies in the Modeling
As demonstrated above, the low-state absorption spectrum
of NGC 3783 can be satisfactorily explained by our combina-
tion of line-of-sight absorbers. The agreement with the ob-
servations is very good for all lines with l < 15 A. However,
there is a noticeable discrepancy at around 16 A. At this wave-
length range there are two main sources of opacity -- the O VII
bound-free continuum (edge at 16.7 A), and the iron M-shell
UTA feature (Behar, Sako & Kahn 2001). Our photoioniza-
tion calculations suggest a disagreement between the two in
the sense that the strongest iron lines observed are due to ions
indicative of a lower level of ionization than that indicated by
the strongest oxygen lines observed. Specifically, the peak
UTA absorption corresponds to Fe VIII -- Fe X. For such a level
of ionization, our models predict most of the oxygen being
in the form of O III -- O VI. However, the observations indicate
that most of the oxygen bound-free absorption is due to O VII.
The possible origin of this discrepancy is discussed in §4.
Regarding the spectrum beyond 19 A, the comparison be-
tween the model and the observations is limited by the poorer
S/N. While the model shown in Fig. 7 is consistent with the
data, the predicted depths of several absorption lines in this
range (in particular those due to O V and O VI) seem to be
stronger than actually observed. This may be a real short-
coming of the model (see comments in §3.2.4 and in §4).
It may also be the result of the assumed absorption cover-
ing factor. As already mentioned, line-profile analysis sug-
gest a mean (over the line profile) covering factor of 0.7 -- 1.0,
and all models considered so far assumed the extreme case
of an absorption covering factor of unity. The "leakage" of
the incident continuum makes little difference at short wave-
lengths except for a need to somewhat decrease the assumed
. However, leakage can influence the comparison at long
wavelengths much more. This is illustrated in Fig. 8 which
shows a model with G = 1.5 and a line-of-sight covering factor
of 0.85. Indeed, the agreement at long wavelengths is much
better. The differences between the two assumed slopes and
covering factors are well within the model uncertainties.
We have attempted to model the high-state spectrum by as-
suming the same ionization components and by changing the
luminosity and the ionization parameter by the factor inferred
from the observed increased luminosity in the short wave-
length continuum (∼ 1.5). The result is a very poor fit to
the long wavelength continuum luminosity and to the inten-
sities of many lines. The reason is that such a small lumi-
nosity change results in an opacity change which is too small
to account for the very large difference (factor ∼ 4) between
the low and the high state spectra at long wavelengths. This
means that the high and the low state spectra are inconsistent
with the assumption of a simple response of the gas to contin-
uum luminosity variations.
There is a simple and satisfactory solution for the high-state
spectrum that involves the appearance of an additional con-
tinuum component. This second, long wavelength component
(sometimes referred to as a "soft excess") appears only during
high state. We have therefore modeled the high-state contin-
uum by two powerlaws: the low-state power law (G = 1.6) and
a steeper component with G = 3.2 which dominates at long
wavelengths. We find a satisfactory solution for the high-state
spectrum when the G = 3.2 component emits 40% of the flux
of the G = 1.6 component at 12.398 A (1 keV). (We note that
this is not a unique combination, and fits of similar quality
can be obtained for other combinations of slope and normal-
ization.) The two continua are shown in Fig. 3, along with the
high and the low state spectra. Given the two component con-
tinuum, we find a very good agreement for the high-state line
and continuum spectrum by assuming no opacity variations.
The quality of the fit is similar to the low-state fits shown in
Figs. 7 & 8.
To further illustrate this point in Fig. 9 we show the high-
state spectrum divided by the low-state spectrum (binned to
reduce the noise) along with the ratio of the two assumed con-
tinua. The diagram shows that any remaining spectral features
are entirely consistent with the noise. The S/N in this diagram
is not high enough to completely rule out some opacity-like
variations at long wavelengths. In particular, there is some ex-
cess emission near the O VII and O VIII recombination edges
that may hint to extra emission in the high-state spectrum
(note that we do not expect the emission features to disap-
pear by this division). However, such opacity variations must
contribute very little to the spectral variations observed at long
wavelengths.
Finally, the emission-line spectrum of NGC 3783 can be ex-
plained by assuming X-ray emitters with the same properties
found for the ionized absorbers. The emitted line photons are
probably observed through the absorber, as indicated by the
combined emission-absorption profiles of several resonance
lines. The model is problematic at around 21.8 A, where it
fails to reproduce the O VII intercombination emission line.
The emission covering factor required is about 0.1 (see §4.1)
consistent with the value of approximately 0.05 -- 0.15 obtained
by Behar et al. (2003).
4. DISCUSSION
This section discusses the main results of the new analysis
of all the Chandra observations of NGC 3783 performed to
date. The reader is referred also to an appendix where we
give a detailed comparison with the recent work of Krongold
et al. (2003).
The main new findings of our work are the large increase
in flux between the low- and high-states, which is not accom-
panied by any significant changes in the properties of the ab-
sorption. The central source in NGC 3783 fluctuates between
two such flux states on a 20 -- 120 days time scale, and the best
G
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
9
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
8
6
4
2
0
8
6
4
2
0
8
6
4
2
0
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
9.5
10
10.5
11
11.5
12
12.5
13
13.5
14
14.5
15
15.5
16
16.5
17
17.5
18
18.5
19
19.5
20
20.5
21
Rest Wavelength [Å]
21.5
22
]
1
-
Å
1
-
s
2
-
m
c
s
n
o
t
o
h
p
4
-
0
1
[
x
u
l
F
FIG. 7. -- A comparison of the low state spectrum with the six component model (three ionization components each split into two kinematic components). Note
that most of the apparent discrepancy at around 5 -- 6 A is due to a known calibration problem (H. Marshall, private communication).
description of the observed variations is the appearance and
disappearance of a "soft excess", low energy continuum com-
ponent. These lead to important conclusions regarding the
nature of the continuum source. Other important conclusions
are the multi-component nature of the absorber and the large
range of ionization. Below we discuss some interpretations.
4.1. Physical properties of the absorbing gas
We found that three ionization components with different
properties and a large range of ionization, are required to fit
10
]
1
-
Å
1
-
s
2
-
m
c
s
n
o
t
o
h
p
4
-
0
1
[
x
u
l
F
NETZER ET AL.
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
19
19.5
20
20.5
21
Rest Wavelength [Å]
21.5
22
FIG. 8. -- Model vs. observation for the long wavelength spectrum assuming G = 1.5 and a line-of-sight covering factor of 0.85 for all absorbers.
w
o
l
/
h
g
h
i
6
4
2
0
5
10
15
rest wavelength [A]
20
25
FIG. 9. -- A ratio spectrum of NGC 3783: Points with error bars are the
result of dividing the high-state spectrum by the low-state spectrum. The
binning is 0.04 A for l < 11 A and 0.1 A at longer wavelengths. The smooth
line is the same division applied to the two continua shown in Fig. 3.
the spectrum of NGC 3783. Each of those components is
split into two kinematic components, as implied by the ob-
served line profiles reported in Paper 1. The three "generic ab-
sorbers" of our model are listed in Table 4 and shown in Figs.
5 & 6. As explained above, the number of real components
and the exact values of UOX and N are not very meaningful
since several somewhat different combinations of ionization
components give equally good fits. Rather, the values chosen
here are representative, "average" ionization parameters, and
the total column densities required. Our modeling of the low-
TABLE 4. PARAMETERS OF THE THREE GENERIC MODELS
Model
log(UOX )
log(N)
Low ionization
Intermidiate ionization
High ionization
-2.4
-1.2
-0.6
21.9
22.0
22.3
state spectrum assumes the underlying X-ray continuum is a
single power-law. However, the S/N of the long wavelength
spectrum is not high enough to completely rule out the pres-
ence of an additional softer continuum component, similar to
the one seen during the high states but of much lower lumi-
nosity. We also note that there is little (if any) response of
the absorbing gas to the short (∼ 2 days) time scale contin-
uum variations. Thus our measurements are models represent
some time-averaged spectral properties.
The main difference between the present model and the
one given by Kaspi et al. (2001) is the presence of the low-
est ionization component. Only the first Chandra observa-
tion (obtained in 2000 January) was available to Kaspi et al.,
and hence was insufficient to reveal the two spectral states.
Furthermore, this relatively short observation resulted in the
S/N at l > 18 A which was insufficient to reveal the true
shape of the continuum. Hence Kaspi et al. naturally (but
incorrectly) assumed the underlying continuum was a single
power-law for this high-state spectrum. As a result, their
preferred model contained a component with a strong O VII
bound-free edge, but very little absorption at longer wave-
lengths (i.e. at l > 18 A the underlying continuum was "re-
covered"). Our new observations do not show such a recovery.
In fact, the absorption in the long wavelength region is dom-
inated by features of K-shell carbon and nitrogen and L-shell
nitrogen and oxygen.
The presence of a lower ionization component is also a key
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
11
point in the K03 work. In their study they assume two ab-
sorbers with log(UOX ) = −2.77 (i.e. a factor of about two
lower than our lowest ionization component) and log(UOX ) =
−1.23 (very similar to our imtermediate ionization compo-
nent). Their fit does not require a third, very ionized com-
ponent. Our reason for suggesting this higest-ionization
(log(UOX ) = −0.6) component is based on the fit to the lines
of Si XIV, S XV and S XVI. When this component is not in-
cluded, the discrepancy in column densities of these ions is
a factor 2 -- 3. Several of the lines of these ions are in fact
missing from the K03 analysis. Moreover, some of the high-
est -ionization lines are badly saturated, (e.g. Si XIVl 6.18 A).
Thus a comparison of the observed and the calculated EWs of
those lines, as performed by K03, is not sufficient for evaluat-
ing the ionic column densities.
Perhaps the largest observed discrepancy between model
and observation is due to absorption by the iron M-shell UTA.
This feature has been observed in several other AGN (Steen-
brugge et al. 2003 and references therein) with similar shape
and central wavelength. Its smooth shape is due to the large
number of absorption lines of many iron ions and the wave-
length of largest absorption is ionization dependent. Our mod-
eling of this spectral region includes all the lines in the Behar
et al. (2001) calculations (i.e. not only the shorter published
list of lines). The central observed wavelength of the fea-
ture in NGC 3783 is at around 16.4 A suggesting that most
of the contribution is due to Fe VIII -- Fe X. For the assumed
SED, this corresponds to gas whose dominant oxygen ions
are O III -- O VI. In our modeling, most long wavelength ab-
sorption is due to the component with log(UOX ) = −2.4 (Fig.
5). The dominant ions in this components are O VI -- O VII and
Fe X -- Fe XII. This corresponds to peak UTA opacity at around
16.1 A. As shown in Fig. 7, the model fits the observed oxy-
gen lines and continua reasonably well but badly misses the
position of the UTA absorption.
We have experimented with various other models to try to
eliminate this discrepancy. For example, an overabundance
of iron relative to oxygen may decrease the level of ioniza-
tion of iron due to the increased iron opacity. Experiment-
ing with iron abundance which is three times larger resulted
with changes that are not large enough to explain the observed
discrepancy. We have also experimented with models that in-
clude several low ionization components, instead of the single
low UOX component shown here. This, again, gave very lit-
tle improvement. It seems that the apparent conflict between
the oxygen and iron ionization cannot be resolved by these
models and we suggest two alternative explanations.
1. The absorbing gas in NGC 3783 may not be in ioniza-
tion equilibrium due to its low density and the rapid
flux variations on time scales that are shorter than the
recombination and ionization time scales. This is prob-
ably not very important for the short wavelength flux
since its variability time scale is short and the ampli-
tude not very large. The gas responding to this con-
tinuum is probably at some mean level of ionization.
This however is not the case for the soft excess con-
tinuum which varies on a much longer time scale with
a much larger amplitude. This can contribute, signifi-
cantly, to the ionization of the lower ionization species.
Different ions react on different time scales and the gas
may never reach an equilibrium. Since all our mod-
els assume steady state gas, they may not be adequate
to describe the absorbing gas properties. In particular,
the iron and oxygen recombination times may be dif-
ferent enough to result in gas where iron is less ionized
or oxygen is more ionized compared to the equilibrium
situation. The complicated issue of time dependent ion-
ization is beyond the scope of this paper.
2. The ionization balance of iron depends critically on low
temperature dielectronic recombination (DR) rates that
are not well known for the iron M-shell ions. Experi-
ence with L-shell iron ions, whose DR rates have been
measured and computed recently (Savin et al. 2002 and
references therein), shows that in almost all cases the
previous low temperature DR rates were consistently
smaller than the newly calculated values. Assuming a
similar effect in the M-shell ions, we can envisage a sit-
uation where, in the absence of realistic DR rate, the en-
tire ionization balance of iron is shifted toward higher
ionization. Thus, more realistic low temperature DR
rates may bring models to better agreement with the ob-
servations. We note that low temperature DR rates are
also not available for the magnesium and silicon ions
that we have modeled. For some of these ions (Mg VIII
and Mg IX) these are probably not very important and
for others (the relevant silicon ions) the situation is less
clear (D. Savin, private communication but see also Gu
2003). Nevertheless, since we do obtain good agree-
ment between the calculated EWs of these lines and the
EWs of other lines observed in the spectrum, we did not
consider changing those rates in the calculations.
It is interesting to note that the K03 model assumes a lower
level of ionization for all elements, including iron, and hence
provides a better fit to the UTA. However, their lower ion-
ization component fails to fit the Si X and Si XI lines around
6.8 A. Our model was designed to give a very good fit over the
5 -- 7 A wavelength range and hence produces a lower quality
fit to the UTA feature. Thus, there seem to be no satisfac-
tory solution based on a single low-ionization component that
explains all these features.
An interesting and somewhat problematic issue is the abun-
dance of O VI, which can also be clearly observed in the
far UV (Gabel et al. 2003a; Gabel et al., 2003b). Paper I
found even the Ka
line of O VI undetectable with the cur-
rent S/N. However, revisiting this measurement more care-
fully, and with more accurate atomic data, we can now detect
several O VI lines. From two such lines, both of which are
probably saturated, we have obtained a lower limit of 1017.0
cm−2 on the column density of O VI. This is much higher than
the value (1016.0±0.3 cm−2) obtained from the XMM-Newton
RGS spectrum (Behar et al. 2003). Moreover, the values pre-
dicted from our model (1017.96 cm−2) is even larger. Such a
large value is problematic for several reasons. It may be in
contradiction with the UV observations of the source (see be-
low), it is much larger than the values obtained from the RGS
observations, and it results in a prediction of a strong absorp-
tion line at around 21.87 A which is not seen in the spectrum
(Fig. 7, the absorption line underneath the O VII intercombi-
nation line).
An explanation of the discrepancy between the values for
the O VI column density measured by Chandra and XMM-
Newton is the crowded region of the spectrum where O VI
Ka
resides. In particular, the lower spectral resolution of the
XMM-Newton RGS makes it extremely difficult to resolve the
weak O VI absorption line at 22.01 A in the presence of the
12
.8
.6
.4
.2
0
n
o
i
t
i
a
z
n
o
i
l
a
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
oxygen
silicon
magnesium
VII
VIII
VIII
IX
V
VII
VII
VI
IX
−3.2
−3
−2.8
−2.6
−2.4
−2.2
−2
−1.8
Log UOX
FIG. 10. -- The fractional ionization of oxygen, magnesium and silicon
ions in a low density gas of our chosen composition exposed to the NGC 3783
low-state continuum. The curves show the mean ionization of various ions
averaged over a column density of 1021.5 cm−2. Note the great similarity in
the ionization of O VI, Mg VIII and Si VIII (all plotted with dotted lines).
bright O VII forbidden emission line (22.10 A). We also wish
to note that with the lack of laboratory measurements for the
O VI wavelengths, high-resolution astrophysical spectra such
as the present one constitute the best determination of these
wavelengths currently available. The Chandra data, along
with the assumption that O VI is outflowing at the same ve-
locity as O VII, places the O VI Ka
line at a rest-wavelength
of 22.01 ± 0.01 A. This value is in agreement with our model
wavelength of 22.005 A, calculated with the HULLAC atomic
code, as well as with the value measured in NGC 5548 (Steen-
brugge et al., 2003), but is somewhat different from the value
of 22.05 A calculated by Pradhan (2000) using the R-matrix
method. For more information see Behar and Kahn (2002).
A O VI column density less than 1017 cm−2 is also incon-
sistent with theoretical predictions based on modelling the
abundances of Mg VIII, Si VIII and O VI. This is illustrated in
Fig. 10 where we show calculations for the fractional abun-
dance of oxygen, silicon and magnesium ions as a function of
UOX assuming an incident continuum similar to the one used
here. The diagram shows the very similar fractional abun-
dance of O VI, Mg VIII and Si VIII as a function of ioniza-
tion parameter. Using the measured EW of the Si VIIIl 6.998
line, which is an unblended, easy-to-measure feature, we can
use Fig. 10, and the assumed silicon-to-oxygen abundance
ratio, to derive an estimate for the column density of O VI.
This number is very close to the model prediction. The sit-
uation is more complicated regarding magnesium since sev-
eral of the relevant lines (around 9.4 A) are blended with neon
lines. However, we could obtain an estimate of the EW of the
Mg VIII l 9.506,9.378 lines that are good enough to constrain
the Mg VIII column density. The O VI column density based
on this measurement is, again, much larger than 1017 cm−2
and in good agreement with the model prediction.
A comparison with the K03 work shows a disagreement by
a factor of two in the total (hydrogen) column density of the
lowest-ionization absorber. One reason for the difference is
NETZER ET AL.
that K03 analyse the combined (high- and low-state) spec-
trum, which is then interpreted in terms of a different amount
of bound-free absorption. Another reason is the somewhat
larger oxygen abundance assumed by K03 (the oxygen col-
umn densities of the low-ionization components in the two
papers actually differ only by a factor 1.35). We also note that
the inner-shell O VI lines that we have used to determine the
limit on the column density of this ion are missing from the
K03 model. This makes a noticeable difference in the spectral
fitting at around 21 A.
Finally, we have looked for the lowest O VI column density
allowed by the observations if we remove the constraint im-
posed by the short wavelength continuum slope (§3.2.4) and
keep the ionization parameter unchanged. This means find-
ing the lowest column density for the log(UOX)=-2.4 compo-
nent which is still consistent with the measured EWs of the
5 -- 7.1 A silicon and sulphur lines. We found this limit to be
log(N) & 21.7 for the low-state spectrum, and log(N) & 21.6
for the high-state spectrum. These lower limits on the column
densities are consistent with the uncertainties given in Table
1. Under these assumptions, the column density of O VI in
the low-state spectrum can be as low as 1017.76 cm−2. This
column is large enough to produce saturated O VI lines at
21.01 and 21.87 A. It also requires a much harder continuum
(G = 1.4).
4.2. Outflow velocity and covering factor
Some of the parameters our model are based on measured
profiles of several absorption lines that were shown in Paper I
to include at least two components with different ouflow ve-
locities. The measurements in Paper I also show that the rela-
tive EWs of the two components seems to be ionization inde-
pendent and that most of the lines used for the profile analysis
were heavily saturated. This suggests that the apparent opti-
cal depths of those lines are determined by the covering fac-
tor rather than the line opacity, and hence similar to the case
seen in many UV absorption systems in AGN (e.g. Barlow,
Hamann & Sargent 1997;Arav et al. 1999). The covering fac-
tor of the lower-velocity components of the O VII, Ne X and
Si XIV lines is in the range 0.8 -- 1.0. The covering factor of the
larger-velocity component of the same lines, assuming satu-
rated profiles, is 0.6 -- 0.8. We also note that the large number
of iron lines near the UTA center gives an independent esti-
mate of the covering factor which is at least 0.85.
Fig. 8 shows that models with a covering factor less than
unity provide fits to the data of similar quality. Using the sil-
icon and sulphur lines (as in §3.2.3), we find three ionization
components are again required, each with parameters similar
to those listed in Table 4. The only difference is the need
to assume a somewhat harder ionizing continuum. The fit
to the long wavelength lines is in fact somewhat better than
that produced by the full covering models. However given
the low S/N at those wavelengths, this is not a strong con-
clusion. Thus, the data-model comparison cannot constrain
covering factor beyond the actual observations. The most im-
portant conclusion is that the covering factor is similar in low
(e.g. O VII and the iron UTA) and in high (e.g. Si XIV, Ne X)
ionization lines.
4.3. Density, location and thermal stability of the absorbing
gas
Our measurements and analysis are consistent with no vari-
ations in the absorbers' properties on time scales of 1 -- 4 days.
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
13
There are also indications for no spectral changes over much
longer periods, perhaps a few months. For instance we find no
evidence for any significant, narrow (< 1 A) spectral features
in the high- to low-state spectral ratio shown in Fig.9. The
reason we cannot constrain the variability of the absorbers
on short time-scales are the fast, relatively-small amplitude
fluctuations in the luminosity of the central source (maximum
amplitude of about a factor 2). As a result of these variability
characteristics of the illuminating continuum, the lack of sig-
nificant spectral variations may be due to the ionization level
of the gas reflecting the time averaged ionizing luminosity,
rather than very long ionization or recombination times. This
conclusion therefore depends primarily on the direct compar-
ison between the low and the high state spectra, and thus on
the S/N in the lower-quality spectrum used for the comparison
(the high state spectrum).
To further examine this point, we have calculated the theo-
retical spectrum appropriate for the high state continuum un-
der the assumption that the absorbing gas responds instantly
to changes in the ionizing continuum. This would be the case
if the gas along the line-of-sight gas were of very high den-
sity. The initial conditions are those assumed for the low-state
continuum, and the change in the SED as described earlier: a
two component X-ray continuum, where the long-wavelength
component is assumed to extrapolate down to 40 eV. The in-
crease in flux between the low- and high states was assumed
to be a factor 1.5 at 4 A (see Fig. 3). Fig. 11 shows two the-
oretical spectra: the low-state spectrum (in blue) is the same
model shown in Fig. 7, the high state spectrum (in red) is the
result of these new calculations. The two are clearly differ-
ent. In particular the Si VII, Si VIII and Si IX lines are are
much weaker for the high-state model. This is due to the
large increase in flux at longest wavelengths, with the largest
consequences for the lowest ionization component (UOX has
increased by a factor close to 2 and UX by a factor of 6.6).
The variations predicted by this theoretical exercise are much
larger than those observed (Table 1 and Fig. 4). This illus-
trates the gas did not simply react to the differences in the
illuminating continuum between the low- and high-states. An
even stronger conclusion is obtained from the fact that at long
wavelengths the differences observed between the two states
are much larger than can be explained by simple variations in
opacity.
Given the above findings, we can place limits on the elec-
tron density (ne) and the distance from the central source (D)
for each absorption component. We used the temperatures
derived from the models, average recombination times for
the dominant oxygen and silicon ions, and assuming there is
no response to continuum variations on a time scale of 10
days. We find ne < 5 × 104 cm−3 and D > 3.2 pc for the
log(UOX ) = −2.4 component, ne < 105 cm−3 and D > 0.63
pc for the log(UOX ) = −1.2 component , and ne < 2.5 × 105
cm−3 and D > 0.18 pc for the log(UOX ) = −0.6 compo-
nent. The corresponding masses are 8.1 × 103Cf , 390Cf and
64Cf solar masses, respectively, where Cf is the absorption
(4p ) covering factor. The mass outflow rate is dominated
by the lowest ionization component and is approximately
75Cf e voutflow/(500 km s−1) solar masses per year, where e
is the radial filling factor of the flow. The very large num-
ber suggests a short duration outburst rather than continuous
ejection. We also note that the covering factor can be small, of
order 0.1. The above distances are in agreement with the find-
ings of Behar et al. (2003), who have suggested the outflow is
x
u
l
f
d
e
z
i
l
a
m
r
o
n
15
10
5
0
low state
high state
6.2
6.4
6.6
6.8
7
7.2
wavelength [A]
FIG. 11. -- Low state and high state theoretical spectra assuming the ob-
served variable NGC 3783 continuum and line of sight gas that responds in-
stantly to continuum variations. The low state model (in blue) is the one
described earlier and shown in Fig. 7. The high state spectrum (in red) as-
sumed the high state SED discussed in the text. Such a continuum results in
much weaker Si VIII and Si IX lines.
located at a distance of a few pc and is extended beyond 10 pc
based on a comparison between the soft X-ray emission and
absorption characteristics of the XMM-Newton data.
A significant new aspect of our model is that the product
ne × T is similar (within a factor .2) for all three absorp-
tion components. This raises the interesting possibility that
all the components are in pressure equilibrium (assuming gas
pressure dominates the total pressure, i.e. radiation pressure
and turbulent pressure are not important), and they all occupy
the same volume of space. To test this idea, we have calcu-
lated thermal stability curves (log(T ) vs. log(UOX /T ) for the
low-state continuum and our assumed composition (Table 2)
under various assumptions. We have kept the UV SED un-
changed and varied G (0.1 -- 50 keV) over a wide range. We
have also investigated the possibility of a line-of-sight atten-
uation by the absorbing gas. This can be relevant for the sit-
uation under study since, even in the simplest geometry, two
of the absorbers do not have a clear view of the central radi-
ation source. Screening by the lowest-ionization component
(log(UOX ) = −2.4) is the most important since this gas mod-
ifies the transmitted spectrum much more than the other com-
ponents (see Fig. 5). Three such stability curves are shown in
Fig. 12, along with the location of the three ionization com-
ponents. The exact location depends on the details of the as-
sumed SED, the gas metallicity and opacity.
The interesting feature of the stability diagram is that all ra-
diation fields considered here result in extended, almost verti-
cal parts between T ≃ 3 ×104 K and T ≃ 2 ×106 K. The curve
for G = 1.6 has a more extended vertical part since the higher
mean energy of the radiation field results in a Compton tem-
perature. Screening by the lowest-ionization component in
NGC 3783 is indeed important, but does not change the main
result that, given the uncertainties on the SED and compo-
sition, all three ionization components lie on the stable part
of the curve. We also note that, while here we only consid-
ered gas with a single composition, the details of the stability
14
7
6
5
4
)
T
(
g
o
l
G =1.6
G =1.8
−8
−7.5
−7
−6.5
log(UOX/T)
−6
−5.5
−5
FIG. 12. -- Thermal stability curves for a low density gas exposed to the
low-state continuum of NGC 3783. The two curves marked by G
are for a
bare continuum with a 0.1 -- 50 keV slope as marked. The dotted line is the
stability curve for a gas exposed to the G = 1.8 continuum seen through the
log(UOX ) = −2.4 absorber. Thick sections mark the locations of the three
absorbers considered in this work with the corresponding uncertainties on
the ionization parameters. All ionization components considered in this work
are situated on thermally stable parts and they all have roughly the same gas
pressure.
curve are abundance dependent. Needless to say, very differ-
ent curves will be obtained for significantly different SEDs.
We note that K03 reach similar conclusions regarding the
pressure equilibrium of their two ionization components.
However, in our model all components are situated on stable
branches of the thermal stability curve (Fig. 12) while accord-
ing to K03, their high-ionization component is situated on the
unstable branch (their Fig. 16). We suspect that the difference
is in part due to the different SED and metalicity assumed by
K03, and in part due to the method they used to calculate the
curve.
The existence of an additional stable-region along the curve
of thermal-equilibrium (intermediate between the cold and the
hot branches) where "warm" ( f ew × 105 K) can survive is not
a new idea. It has been discussed by Marshall et al. (1993)
in their study of the multi-phase medium in NGC 1068, and
later by many others. Reynolds & Fabian (1995) discussed
the stability criteria and noted the narrow range of ionization
parameter allowed for warm absorbers. Hess et al (1997) dis-
cussed the various parameters governing the stability curve
(metallicity and more). Komossa and collaborators (e.g. Ko-
mossa & Fink, 1997; Komossa & Meerschweichen 2001) cal-
culated many such curves, for different SEDs and metallici-
ties, and discussed the location of warm absorbers as well as
the possible link between the NLR and the X-ray gas. Kro-
lik & Kriss (2001) considered multi-phase, warm-absorber
winds and noted the various locations of stable, over-heated
and over-cooled gas. Kinkhabwala et al.
(2002) re-visited
the thermal stability issue in NGC 1068 and showed that a
wide range of UOX is needed to account for the observed X-
ray emission lines. Chelouche & Netzer (2003) investigated
the changes in the stability criteria for clouds with large inter-
nal line radiation pressure.
NETZER ET AL.
Most of these earlier works focused either on the allowed
parts of the curve from general stability conditions, or on the
location of a certain absorber observed in a certain source.
Our work shows that three very different aborbers in a source
can all occupy extended, stable parts of the curve where the
gas pressure is roughly the same. This means there may well
be more than three absorbers spread over the vertical branch
of the curves in Fig. 12. The three ionization parameters con-
sidered here may therefore represent some volume-averaged
properties of the entire cloud ensemble. The column densi-
ties are therefore the total column densities of a large num-
ber of such clouds. Moreover, the most-ionized component
may provide the confining medium for the two other ioniza-
tion components. Needless to say, real confined outflowing
clouds are characterised by a more complicated density and
pressure structure than with the simplified, constant density
clouds considered here (e.g. see Chelouche & Netzer 2001).
The pressure equilibrium between all three absorbers in
NGC 3783 suggest they occupy the same general location.
This allows additional constraints to be placed on their density
and location. Specifically, we require that the distance of this
region is at least 3.2 pc (the minimum distance of the lowest
ionization component). However, this zone cannot be much
further away because of total size and volume considerations.
Under the assumed conditions, the highest-ionization param-
eter component has the lowest density, and hence the largest
dimension. However, its radial extent cannot exceed about
500 pc (the approximate radius of the narrow-line region),
and thus its mean density cannot fall below about 10 cm−3.
Pressure equilibrium then dictates the density of the lowest-
ionization component, and a maximum distance of about 25
pc. This limitation is only imposed on discrete clouds -- i.e.
on the mean properties of the gas. Real absorbers may not be
"clouds", they can cover a large range of distances, and can
have properties which depend on location. The detailed in-
vestigation of such models is beyond the scope of the present
paper.
4.4. The emission lines
There is no indication for flux variation in any of the ob-
served emission lines. However the measurement uncertainty
on these line is rather large since the strongest lines are ob-
served at the long wavelengths where the S/N is poor. We
obtain satisfactory fits for most lines by assuming that the
emission -- line gas has the same column density and ionization
parameter as the absorbing gas. The covering factors required
for the emitting gas are 0.2 -- 0.3 for the log(UOX ) = −2.4 com-
ponent, 0.1 -- 0.2 for the log(UOX ) = −1.2 component, and
∼ 0.1 for the log(UOX ) = −0.6 component. The large range
is due to the uncertainties in the continuum placement and in
estimating the fraction of the O VII and O VIII emission lines
that are being absorbed by the line-of-sight gas (the model
shown in Figs. 7 and 8 assumes that all the emitted photons
are seen through the absorbers).
A clear shortcoming of the model is the fitting of the in-
tercombination O VII line. The intensity predicted for this
line is too small by a large factor (2-4). A large part of the
discrepancy is due to the O VI l 21.87 A absorption line sit-
uated close to this emission (Fig. 7). This may be related to
the O VI problem discussed earlier. Alternatively it may be a
consequence of our assumption that all emission-line photons
are seen through the absorbers. Indeed, a model that assumes
no absorption of the emitted photons by the line-of-sight gas
(not shown here) would give a much better agreement to the
VARIABILITY AND MODELING OF NGC 3783
15
O VII absorption complex. This would also required a smaller
emission covering factor. Obviously we cannot determine the
exact geometry using current observations, and the real case
may well be intermediate between those two extremes.
We also note on the difference between the absorption cov-
ering factor (0.8 -- 1.0) and the emission covering factor (0.1 --
0.3). Given the uncertain geometry and the fact that the first
is a line-of-sight covering factor and the secong a globel (4p )
property, the two are perhaps consistent with each other. We
did not investigate all possibilities and cannot comment in de-
tail on special cases like biconical flows or a torus geometry
(e.g. Krolik & Kriss 2001).
Finally, comparing our method with that of K03 we note
that those authors do not calculate the emission line flux and
profile in a self-consistent way. Instaed, they add Gaussian
shaped emission profiles to their calculated absorption pro-
files (e.g. their Fig. 6). This can result in significant differ-
ences regarding the line flux and EW. For example, our default
approach assumes that all emission lines are seen through the
absorber. In such a case, the entire "blue" wing of many emis-
sion lines is absorbed. Clearly this affects the EW of the emis-
sion lines, but has almost no effect on the EW of the absorp-
tion features. In contrast, the approach adopted in K03 always
results in a decrease of the EW of the absorption lines.
4.5. UV absorbers in NGC 3783
NGC 3783 contains time-variable absorbers in the UV that
have been described in various earlier publications (Gabel et
al. 2003a and references therein). Our analysis clearly indi-
cates that at least one X-ray component contains gas which is
of sufficiently low ionization so as to produce strong absorp-
tion lines of C IV, N V and O VI in the UV.
The predicted EWs of these UV lines depend on two fac-
tors that have been given little attention in this work: the ex-
act shape of the UV continuum, and covering factor appro-
priate for the UV absorbers. A UV continuum which is softer
than that assumed here can result in higher levels of ionization
for carbon, nitrogen and oxygen, with little effect on most X-
ray lines. This is very important for the C IVl 1549 A and
N Vl 1240 A lines, but less so for the UV lines of O VI that
are directly linked to the O VI column density discussed here.
As for the covering factors, the size of the UV continuum
source is likely to be much larger than the size of the central
X-ray source. Thus the covering factor appropriate in the UV
can be different to that appropriate in the X-ray. This will re-
sult in saturated UV absorption lines whose EWs are smaller
than the ones indicated by the column densities derived here.
However, our upper limit on the density of the low-ionization
component, combined with its column density, suggest a very
large line-of-sight dimension (> 1017 cm). Assuming lateral
dimension of the same size or large, we conclude that the
physical dimension of this component is much larger than the
expected dimension of any likely UV source (e.g. the surface
of a thin accretion disk). A combined analysis of the UV and
X-ray results, taking these such points into consideration, is
in progress
UV absorbers are also UV emitters, and the low-ionization
component can also contribute to the observed UV emission
lines. Our photoionization calculations show that this con-
tribution is very small. For example, an emission covering
factor of 0.1, similar to the one deduced from the X-ray emis-
sion lines, will produce O VIl 1035 line with emission EW of
about 1 A.
4.6. The long wavelength component
Perhaps the most interesting result of this study is the ap-
pearance and disappearance of the soft excess component.
This broad-band continuum source was seen in two of the
six observations. On average, these are the two observations
with the highest luminosity. An increase in softness ratio with
increasing source luminosity is well known and well docu-
mented in a number of AGN (e.g. Magdziarz et al., 1998;
Chiang et al., 2000; Markowitz & Edelson 2001). However
we are not aware of a softness ratio increase that is not corre-
lated with a short wavelength flux increase. NGC 3783 seems
to be the first AGN to show this phenomenon, but we suspect
that careful spectroscopic monitoring will reveal the same or
a similar behavior in other sources. This has important conse-
quences to the continuum production mechanism, as well as
for the modeling of the warm X-ray gas around the center.
We do not know the origin of the soft continuum source.
In particular, we do not have information on its flux at wave-
lengths l > 30 A (the source was not in a high-state in any
of the published XMM-Newton observations). It may be re-
lated to a broad-band phenomenon (e.g. due a flaring accre-
tion disk), or a component covering a narrower band (e.g. a
single temperature black body). Simple global energy consid-
eration show that this phenomenon is unrelated to the appear-
ance of broad emission features like those claimed to be seen
in at least two sources and interpreted as due to relativistic
disk lines (Branduardi et al 2001; Mason et al. 2002; but see
also Lee et al. 2002).
Finally, we must comment on the possibility of a more com-
plex behavior. Our analysis is based on the fitting of a single
powerlaw continuum at low-state and the addition of a soft
X-ray component during the high-state. However, an equiv-
alent analysis could be carried out in the reverse order -- i.e.
starting from a pure powerlaw for the high-state and subtract-
ing a continuum component to explain the low-state spectrum.
However, as argued earlier, the observed spectral changes at
long wavelengths are too large to be explained by pure opacity
variations and it is not at all clear what other mechanism could
explain an AGN continuum with flux deficit at long wave-
lengths.
5. CONCLUSIONS
Our detailed measurements and analysis of the 900 ks data
set of NGC 3783 lead to the following results:
1. The source fluctuates in luminosity, by a factor ∼ 1.5,
during individual 170 ks observations. The fluctuations
are not associated with significant spectral variations.
2. On time scales of 20 -- 120 days, the source exhibits two
very different spectral shapes denoted here as the high-
and low-states. The two are associated with different
softness ratios that seem unrelated to the total X-ray lu-
minosity. The observed changes in the underlying con-
tinuum can be described as due to the appearance (in
the high-state) and disappearance (in the low-state) of
a soft excess component. The origin of this continuum
component is not clear. To the best of our knowledge,
NGC 3783 is the first AGN to show such a behavior.
3. The appearance of the soft continuum component can
explain all spectral variations observed within the mea-
surement uncertainties. There is no need to invoke
opacity changes between the high- and low-states. This
16
NETZER ET AL.
conclusion depends mostly on the S/N in the high state
spectrum.
4. A combination of three ionization components, each
split into two kinematic components, provides a good
description of the intensity of almost all the absorption
lines and bound-free edges observed. The components
span a large range of ionization, and have a total col-
umn of about 4×1022 cm−2. The only real discrep-
ancy between the observed and theoretical spectra are
for the iron M-shell UTA feature at 16 -- 16.5 A. This is
most likely due to inadequate dielectronic recombina-
tion rates currently available to use in our calculations.
The largest other uncertainty is in the column density
of O VI.
5. The three generic absorbers discussed in this work have
very similar values of ne × T . We speculate that the
absorbers may be in pressure equilibrium with each
other, occupying the same volume in the nucleus. This
is the first confirmation of the location of several X-
ray absorbers on the vertical part of the log(T ) vs.
log(UOX /T ) stability curve of AGN.
6. We have obtained thee lower limits on the gas distance
from the center, corresponding to our three generic ab-
sorbers. The limits are 3.2 pc, 0.6 pc and about 0.2
for the low ionization, intermediate ionization and high
ionization absorbers, respectively. The pressure equi-
librium assumption implies distances in the range 3 --
25 pc.
This work is supported by the Israel Science Foundation
grant 545/00, H.N. thanks S. Kahn and the astrophysics group
at Columbia university for hospitality and support during a
summer visit in 2002. E.B. was supported by the Yigal-Alon
Fellowship and by the GIF Foundation under grant #2028-
1093.7/2001. We gratefully acknowledge the financial sup-
port of CXC grant GO1-2103 (S. K., W. N. B., I. M. G.),
NASA LTSA grant NAG 5-13035 (W. N. B.) and the Alfred
P. Sloan Foundation (W. N. B.),
REFERENCES
Arav, N., Becker, R. H., Laurent-Muehleisen, S. A., Gregg, M. D., White,
R. L., Brotherton, M. S., & de Kool, M. 1999, ApJ, 524, 566
Arav, N., Korista, K. T., & de Kool, M. 2002, ApJ, 566, 699
Barlow, T. A. & Sargent, W. L. W. 1997, AJ, 113, 136
Barlow, T. A., Hamann, F., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1997, ASP Conf. Ser. 128:
Mass Ejection from Active Galactic Nuclei, 13
Behar, E., & Netzer, H. 2002, ApJ, 570, 165
Behar, E., Sako, M., & Kahn, S. M. 2001, ApJ, 563, 497
Behar, E. & Kahn, S. M. 2002, NASA Laboratory Astrophysics Workshop,
Ed. Farid Salama (astro-ph/0210280)
Behar et al., 2003 (astro-ph/0307467)
Blustin, A. J., Branduardi-Raymont, G., Behar, E., Kaastra, J. S., Kahn, S. M.,
Page, M. J., Sako, M., & Steenbrugge, K. C. 2002, A&A, 392, 453
Branduardi-Raymont, G., Sako, M., Kahn, S. M., Brinkman, A. C., Kaastra,
J. S., & Page, M. J. 2001, A&A, 365, L140
Chelouche, D. & Netzer, H. 2001, MNRAS, 326, 916
Chelouche, D. & Netzer, H. 2003, MNRAS, (in press)
Chiang, J., Reynolds, C. S., Blaes, O. M., Nowak, M. A., Murray, N.,
Madejski, G., Marshall, H. L., & Magdziarz, P. 2000, ApJ, 528, 292
Gabel, J. R. et al. 2003a, ApJ, 583, 178
Gabel, J. R. et al. 2003b, ApJ, (in press)
George, I. M., Turner, T. J., Mushotzky, R., Nandra, K., & Netzer, H. 1998,
ApJ, 503, 174
Gu, M. F. 2003, ApJ, 589, 1085
Hess, C. J., Kahn, S. M., & Paerels, F. B. S. 1997, ApJ, 478, 94
Kaspi, S., Brandt, W. N., Netzer, H., Sambruna, R., Chartas, G., Garmire, G.
P., & Nousek, J. A. 2000a, ApJ, 535, L17
Kaspi, S. et al. 2001, ApJ, 554, 216
Kaspi, S., et al. 2002, ApJ, 574, 643 (Paper I)
Kinkhabwala, A. et al. 2002, ApJ, 575, 732
Komossa, S. & Fink, H. 1997, A&A, 322, 719
Komossa, S. & Meerschweinchen, J. 2000, A&A, 354, 411
Kraemer, S. B., Crenshaw, D. M., & Gabel, J. R. 2001, ApJ, 557, 30
Krolik, J. H., & Kriss, G. A. 2001, ApJ, 561, 684
Krongold, Y., Nicastro, F., Brickouse, N.S., Elvis, M., Liedahl, D.A., &
Mathur, S., 2003, ApJ preprint doi:10.1086/378639 (K03)
Lee, J. C., Ogle, P. M., Canizares, C. R., Marshall, H. L., Schulz, N. S.,
Morales, R., Fabian, A. C., & Iwasawa, K. 2001, ApJ, 554, L13
Magdziarz, P., Blaes, O. M., Zdziarski, A. A., Johnson, W. N., & Smith, D. A.
1998, MNRAS, 301, 179
Markowitz, A. & Edelson, R. 2001, ApJ, 547, 684
Marshall, F. E. et al. 1993, ApJ, 405, 168
Mason, K. O. et al. 2003, ApJ, 582, 95
Mathur, S., Elvis, M., & Wilkes, B. 1995, ApJ, 452, 230
Netzer, H. 1996, ApJ, 473, 781
Netzer, H., Chelouche, D., George, I. M., Turner, T. J., Crenshaw, D. M.,
Kraemer, S. B., & Nandra, K. 2002, ApJ, 571, 256
Pradhan, A. K. 2000, ApJ, 545, L165
Reynolds, C. S. & Fabian, A. C. 1995, MNRAS, 273, 1167
Savin, D. W. et al. 2002, ApJ, 576, 1098
Steenbrugge, K.C. et al. 2003, A&A, 402, 477
|
astro-ph/9604095 | 2 | 9604 | 1996-10-07T16:47:07 | Halo White Dwarfs and the Hot Intergalactic Medium | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a schematic model for the formation of baryonic galactic halos and hot gas in the Local Group and the intergalactic medium. We follow the dynamics, chemical evolution, heat flow and gas flows of a hierarchy of scales, including: protogalactic clouds, galactic halos, and the Local Group itself. Within this hierarchy, the Galaxy is built via mergers of protogalactic fragments. We find that early bursts of star formation lead to a large population of remnants (mostly white dwarfs), which would reside presently in the halo and contribute to the dark component observed in the microlensing experiments. The hot, metal-rich gas from early starbursts and merging evaporates from the clouds and is eventually incorporated into the intergalactic medium. The model thus suggests that most microlensing objects could be white dwarfs ($m \sim 0.5 \msol$), which comprise a significant fraction of the halo mass. Furthermore, the Local Group could have a component of metal-rich hot gas similar to, although less than, that observed in larger clusters. We discuss the known constraints on such a scenario and show that all local observations can be satisfied with present data in this model. The best-fit model has a halo that is 40% baryonic, with an upper limit of 77%. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
HALO WHITE DWARFS AND THE HOT INTERGALACTIC
MEDIUM
Brian D. Fields and Grant J. Mathews
Department of Physics, University of Notre Dame
Notre Dame, IN 46635
[email protected]
[email protected]
and
David N. Schramm
University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, and
NASA/Fermilab Astrophysics Center, FNAL, Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We present a schematic model for the formation of baryonic galactic halos and hot
gas in the Local Group and the intergalactic medium. We follow the dynamics, chemical
evolution, heat flow and gas flows of a hierarchy of scales, including: protogalactic clouds,
galactic halos, and the Local Group itself. Within this hierarchy, the Galaxy is built via
mergers of protogalactic fragments. Hot and cold gas components are distinguished, with
star formation occurring in cold molecular cloud cores, while stellar winds, supernovae,
and mergers convert cold gas into a hot intercloud medium. We find that early bursts
of star formation lead to a large population of remnants (mostly white dwarfs), which
would reside presently in the halo and contribute to the dark component observed in the
microlensing experiments. The hot, metal-rich gas from early starbursts and merging
evaporates from the clouds and is eventually incorporated into the intergalactic medium.
The model thus suggests that most microlensing objects could be white dwarfs (m ∼
0.5M⊙), which comprise a significant fraction of the halo mass. Furthermore, the Local
Group could have a component of metal-rich hot gas similar to, although less than,
that observed in larger clusters. We discuss the known constraints on such a scenario
and show that all local observations can be satisfied with present data in this model.
The most stringent constraint comes from the metallicity distribution in the halo. The
best-fit model has a halo that is 40% baryonic, with an upper limit of 77%. Our model
predicts that the hot intragroup gas has a total luminosity 1.5 × 1040 erg s−1, and a
temperature of 0.26 keV, just at the margin of detectability. Improved X-ray data could
provide a key constraint on any remnant component in the halo.
Subject headings: dark matter -- galaxies: evolution -- galaxies: interactions -- nuclear
reactions, nucleosynthesis: abundances cosmology -- dark matter, galactic evolution
1
1.
Introduction
Recently there has been renewed interest in the
nature of the dark matter in galaxy halos, motivated
by the results of microlensing experiments. Observa-
tions toward the Magellanic clouds (e.g., Alcock et al.
1995; Aubourg et al. 1993) and toward the Galactic
bulge (e.g., Udalski et al. 1993) have detected gravita-
tional microlensing and inferred the presence of dark,
massive compact halo objects (MACHOs). Further-
more, a recent binary detection in the direction of the
LMC, along with average event durations of about 2.5
months, may imply masses of order ∼ 0.5M⊙, sugges-
tive of white dwarfs.
At the same time, X-ray observations of clusters
(Mushotzky 1993) and groups (e.g., Mulchaey, Davis,
Mushotzky, & Burstein 1996, 1993; Pildis, Breg-
man, & Evrard 1995; Ponman, Bourner, Ebeling, &
Bohringer 1996) have discovered a large amount of
hot, metal-rich gas. Where it is observed, this gas is
a substantial fraction of the baryonic mass -- it is the
dominant baryonic component of clusters, and is com-
parable to the galactic component in groups. Indeed,
it appears that most baryons in the universe are in
the for of this hot X-ray emitting gas.
The relatively high metallicity (Z ∼ 0.3Z⊙ for clus-
ters, Z ∼ 0.1Z⊙ for groups) of this gas is impressive
and demands that the material has undergone a sig-
nificant amount of stellar processing during an ear-
lier epoch of star formation. Such an epoch would
also produce remnants, mostly white dwarfs. If this
epoch is a general consequence of the formation of the
bulge and halo of spirals like the Milky Way, as well
as the ellipticals of rich clusters, it could account for
the observed microlensing objects.
Although white dwarfs are attractive MACHO
candidates, there are important constraints on such
objects and their formation (Ryu, Olive, & Silk 1990).
These include background light from the early evolu-
tion, the present luminosity of the halo, and the metal
and helium content of the disk and halo stars. While
these place important constraints on model parame-
ters, they do not rule out a significant white dwarf
halo population, as we shall show.
In modeling these galaxy aggregates and their hot
gas components, one must account for the dependence
of these systems on the morphology of the constituent
galaxies. On the one hand, the hot gas in clusters and
groups appears correlated with the luminosity of el-
liptical and S0 galaxies (Arnauld et al. 1992). This
suggests that the hot gas arises from the violent merg-
ing associated with these morphological types. On the
other hand, it also seems well established (e.g., Rich
1990) that the morphology of the bulge and halo of
spiral galaxies is quite similar to that of ellipticals
and S0's. This suggests that the bulge and halo of
spirals may have experienced a similar epoch of star
formation and outflow during their formation. The
difference in the morphologies may relate to the larger
angular momentum or shallower gravitational poten-
tial of spirals (Zurek et al. 1988), such that some gas
survives halo formation, and settles afterwards into
spiral arms.
With this background in mind, we find that a likely,
and perhaps inevitable, consequence of the forma-
tion of the bulge and halo is the formation of a large
remnant population in the Galactic halo, along with
hot X-ray emitting gas in the Local Group and inter-
galactic (i.e., extragroup) medium. While our model
should be widely applicable, in this paper we concen-
trate on the Local Group.
Given the detection of dark microlensing objects,
as well as the need for significant amounts of dark
baryonic matter somewhere (Copi, Schramm, & Turner
1995; Fields, Kainulainen, Olive, & Thomas 1996)
halo white dwarfs are a very conservative candi-
date (e.g., Larson 1987; Ryu, Olive, & Silk 1990;
Silk 1993). This is particularly so since red and
brown dwarfs are apparently excluded as halo can-
didates (Bahcall, Flynn, Gould, & Kirhakos 1994;
Graff & Freese 1996). Here we make a specific though
schematic model, and assess the plausibility of the
white dwarf hypothesis.1 As we will see, the model
can be made to work but not without some assump-
tions (e.g., one must alter the halo initial mass func-
tion). In any case, the model is eminently testable,
and perhaps has already been tested by X-ray ob-
servations in other groups. Indeed, should one find
this model and the halo white dwarf hypothesis un-
tenable, then it follows that the dark baryons and the
MACHOs must take an even more exotic form.
2. Local Group Properties
We take the Local Group to have a mass ∼ (3 −
5) × 1012M⊙ (Fich & Tremaine 1991). Its luminous
component is dominated by two galaxies, one of which
1Others have suggested that the microlensing objects might
be remnants from an early Population III; see Fujimoto,
Sugiyama, Iben, & Hollowell (1995).
2
(the Galaxy) has a visible mass ∼ 7 × 1010M⊙. The
total mass of the Galaxy is uncertain and depends on
the radius, i.e., Mtot ∼ 5 × 1011M⊙(Rhalo/50 kpc).
This implies that the dark halo has a mass within
50 kpc of ∼ 4 × 1011M⊙, some or all of which will
be in the form of microlensing objects and other dark
baryons. We consider models with up to 90% the total
mass in nonbaryonic dark matter, at the group scale.
The baryonic fraction at the halo scale, however, can
be much less.
In many galaxy groups, hot intergalactic gas is
found (e.g., Mulchaey et al. 1993, 1996; Pildis, Breg-
man, & Evrard 1995; Ponman, Bourner, Ebeling, &
Bohringer 1996). This gas is a significant and some-
times dominant component of the baryonic mass. The
hot gas-to-galaxy mass ratio ranges from 0.3− 3. The
gas also contains metals, with Z ∼ (0.1 − 0.2)Z⊙.
While the ROSAT metallicity determinations are un-
certain (Davis, Mulchaey, Mushotzky, & Burstein
1996), recent measurements with ASCA (Fukazawa et
al. 1996) suggest that the gas metallicities in groups
could have a larger spread than those of clusters. In
any case, the metallicity is clearly not primordial, in-
dicting that a significant fraction of material has been
processed in stars before they are incorporated into
the intragroup medium.
If the gas is in hydrostatic equilibrium with the
gravitational potential of the group, then the tem-
perature distribution determines the total mass. Fur-
thermore, the observed temperatures tend to tightly
cluster around T = 1 keV for most groups observed
thus far (Mulchaey et al. 1996). This implies that the
total masses are similar, with most observed group
masses lying in the range (1.5 − 2.5) × 1013M⊙. This
is a tighter range than the span of luminous mass in
galaxies and gas.
However, it is not clear that all optically identified
groups evidence hot gas. Several analyses of ROSAT
observations have found that the presence of de-
tectable gas is strongly correlated with the morpholo-
gies of the constituent galaxies (e.g., Pildis, Bregman,
& Evrard 1995). The trend is very similar to that
found in galaxy clusters: the hot gas mass is cor-
related with the presence of early-type (E and S0)
Indeed, Mulchaey et al. (1996) emphasize
galaxies.
that there is at least one bright (LB >∼ 5 × 1010L⊙)
elliptical galaxy in every group for which hot gas has
been detected.
On the other hand, Ponman, Bourner, Ebeling, &
Bohringer (1996), also using ROSAT data, have re-
3
cently claimed the positive detection of hot gas in
spiral-dominated Hickson compact groups. They find
that the gas in these groups has a lower tempera-
ture (∼ 0.3 keV), and thus, a lower surface brightness
than that in groups with early-type galaxies. The dis-
crepancies between these results and those of previous
groups attests to the difficulty in trying to measure
or put limits on such a relatively dim diffuse com-
ponent. Ponman et al. (1996) note that differences
between their results and others trace to details of
the analysis, e.g., subtraction of galactic and back-
ground emission. As Davis, Mulchaey, Mushotzky,
& Burstein (1996) point out, these are not always
straightforward issues. Hence, we regard the issue of
hot gas in spiral-dominated galaxies as presently am-
biguous.
In the Local Group specifically, there has not been
direct observation of hot intergalactic gas. However,
Suto et al. (1996) have argued that such a component
is allowed within current direct limits. Indeed, they
suggest that this is a source of the excess low-energy
component in the diffuse X-ray background. Suto et
al. (1996) model a gas distribution that could lead to
the excess radiation; their distribution implies a total
mass in hot intergalactic gas of about ∼ 3.5×1011M⊙.
Of course, the existence of hot gas in spiral-dominated
groups is a central premise in this scenario. Pildis &
McGaugh (1996) show that the observational limits
on such gas (if it is similar to other spiral-rich groups)
require any Local Group gas to have too low a mass
to provide the soft X-ray background.
3. Hierarchical Collapse Model
Motivated by hierarchical clustering scenarios for
structure formation, we compute the evolution of a
hierarchy of self-similar mass scales. The three scales
are (1) protogalactic clouds, all of which reside in (2)
galaxy halos, themselves moving within the (3) group.
Within a spiral protogalaxy, the clouds merge to be-
come ultimately the disk and bulge. However, we do
not distinguish the disk and bulge. Their formation
does not significantly affect the halo or group evolu-
tion once the last merging has occurred and the star
formation (and gas outflow) in the halo has dimin-
ished.
The dynamics of the three components are de-
scribed (Mathews & Schramm 1993) as the radial evo-
lution R(t) of a spherical overdensity, from its initial
expansion (starting at t = 108 yr) through the de-
parture from Hubble flow and collapse to a fixed final
radius. The halo collapse is halted at 50 kpc.
For each component in the structure hierarchy, we
follow the evolution of matter in the form of gas, stars
and remnants, and possibly also non-baryonic dark
matter. We also compute the helium and metal evo-
lution, and follow the temperature of the hot gas. Our
model is schematic but contains the necessary features
for testing and constraining our basic hypotheses. Its
structure (summarized pictorially in figure 1) is as
follows.
3.1. Level 1: Protogalactic Clouds
In this simple model we assemble galaxies from
a distribution of protogalactic fragments within ex-
panding and contracting galactic halos. At the level
of the protogalactic clouds, we consider the system to
be composed of three components: cold star-forming
molecular clouds; heated ejecta from the clouds; and
stars and remnants. We assume that non-baryonic
dark matter (if there is any) is unimportant at this
scale.
Let us first consider the cold star-forming gas and
hot gas components. These components are most
dramatically affected by star formation and merg-
ing. Stars form from the cold gas and return a frac-
tion of their material as hot ejecta. This hot stellar
ejecta further mixes with and heats the local cold gas
mass into the hot component. In addition, material
is heated during mergers (e.g., White et al. 1993) as
the relative kinetic energy of the merging clouds is
converted into internal energy of the merged system.
Also, cooling of the hot gas component returns mate-
rial back to cold star forming regions.
We write the coupled equations for the evolution
of the cold and hot gas components for an average
cloud experiencing all of these processes as:
mcold
g1
= −(1 + Rηmix)ψ(t)
+λmergemcold
g1
+λcoolmhot
g1
,
mhot
g1 = R(1 + ηmix)ψ(t)
(1)
(2)
+λmergemhot
g1
−λcoolmhot
+ min1 − mhot
g1
out1 .
The first term on the right hand side of equations (1)
and (2) describes the formation of stars and ejecta.
R is the usual (e.g., Tinsley 1980) returned fraction
of material from stars in the instantaneous recycling
approximation. It depends on the initial mass func-
tion. The hot ejecta is assumed to sweep up and mix
with the cold cloud material; the resulting mixture
contributes to the hot gas component. We therefore
include an additional factor of ηmix describes the num-
ber of equal masses of local interstellar material that
is heated into the hot component along with the stel-
lar ejecta. The rate of incorporation of cold gas into
new stars is ψ(t).
The second term on the right hand side in equa-
tions (1) and (2) describes the effects of mergers.
Here, λmerge is the merger rate per cloud. On average,
during each merger, the cloud mass will double. The
third term describes the cooling from hot to cold gas,
with the cooling rate per particle given by λcool. The
last terms in Eq. (2) accounts for infall and outflow of
gas. The infall term min gives the rate at which hot
halo gas is incorporated int to the hot gas component
of the clouds. The outflow rate mhot
out1 we attribute to
the evaporation of hot gas. The physics behind each
of these terms is discussed in §3.4.
to be truly cold gas with T <∼ 100 K. The hot gas com-
For our purposes, we take the cold star forming gas
ponent is approximated by assuming that all gas at
higher temperatures is isothermal and homogeneous
within each of the levels of structure.
If we combine equations (1) and (2) we can recover
the familiar instantaneous recycling equation for one
gas component;
mcold
g1 + mhot
g1 = −(1 − R)ψ(t) + meff
in − mout
,
(3)
meff
in = (mcold
where the effective infall rate, due to mergers as
well as the influx of halo gas, is
g1 +
mhot
g1 )λmerge + min1. The outflow rate is just mout =
mhot
out1.
As in MS93 we assume that protogalactic mergers
disperse the stars and remnants into the halo. The
evolution equation for the mass mr1 in stars and rem-
nants remaining in a cloud becomes:
mr1 = (1 − R)ψ(t) + (1 − κ)λmergemr1 .
(4)
Here κ is a measure of the efficiency for the mergers to
disperse stars and remnants. Specifically, the average
fraction f of stars and remnants born at time t0 which
survive merging up to time t is
f = e
−κR t
t0
dt′λmerge
(5)
4
We will take κ = 1.
Since stars return all of their ejecta into the hot
component, the metallicity in the cold star forming
gas is only indirectly enriched by cooling from the
hot component. Thus, from Eq. (1) we write for the
evolution of the total mass in metals in the cold star
forming gas (Z cold
1 mcold
g1 ):2
1 mcold
g1 )
d(Z cold
dt
= Z hot
1 λcoolmhot
g1
(cid:20)(1 + Rηmix)ψ(t)
1
−Z cold
+mcold
g1 λmerge(cid:21) .
(6)
This reduces to a simple evolution equation for the
metallicity of the cold gas,
Z cold
1 = (cid:0)Z hot
1 − Z cold
1
mhot
g1
mcold
g1
(cid:1) λcool
.
(7)
Clearly, the equilibrium metallicity of the cold star-
forming component is equal to the hot component
metallicity. This equilibrium is, however, only achieved
after a time given by the cooling time scale, λcool
times the ratio of cold to hot gas masses.
−1
By an analogous process to the derivation of Eq.
(7), the evolution of metallicity in the hot gas com-
ponent can be written
Z hot
1
= (cid:2)yZ + (1 + ηmix)R(Z cold
1 − Z hot
1
+(Z hot
g2 − Z hot
g1 )
min1
mhot
g1
ψ(t)
mhot
g1
)(cid:3)
(8)
mhot
out
mhot
g1
−(cid:0)ǫout
1 − ǫ1(cid:1)
+ (ǫ2 − ǫ1)
min1
mhot
g1
R1
R1
−2
ǫ1 ,
where ǫSN in the average energy per unit mass in
all stellar ejecta averaged over an appropriate initial
mass function. This term is dominated by supernovae
whose energy release is Eej ∼ 1051 erg per supernova.
Averaging over the initial mass function φ(m) then
gives
ǫSN = R dm φ(m) Eej(m)
R dm φ(m) mej
(10)
The quantity ǫout
which is independent of the normalization convention
of φ. For a typical initial mass function, this gives
values of order ǫSN ∼ 1049 erg M−1
⊙ .
is the average energy per unit
mass for the material exiting the cloud. For an ideal
gas, the temperature is simply related to ǫ1 by, T1 =
(2ǫ1µ/3kNA), where µ is the mean molecular weight
of the gas and NA is Avagadro's number.
1
The last term in Eq. (9) accounts for the p dV
work done as the cloud expands or contracts; the ra-
dial dependence is given by the collapse of a spherical
overdensity. The cloud radius R1 is the average tidal
radius
R1 = (cid:18) m1
m2(cid:19)1/3
R2 ,
(11)
where m1 is the total average cloud mass
m1 = mcold
g1 + mhot
g1 + mr1 ,
(12)
where yZ is the mass fraction of newly synthesized
material in the ejecta. As usual, yZ depends on both
the initial mass function, and on the stellar nucleosyn-
thesis yields as a function of mass (and metallicity).
By a similar derivation, the temperature of hot
gas in the halo is determined from an energy bal-
ance equation. This leads to an evolution of internal
energy per unit mass ǫ1 in the hot gas,
ǫ1 = (cid:20)ǫSN − ǫ1(1 + ηmix)(cid:21)Rψ(t)
mhot
g1
(9)
+λmergeǫmerge
and m2 is the average halo mass defined below (Eq.
13). We assume that the relative momentum of the
merger goes into heating the cloud gas. Thus, we have
ǫmerge = Emerge/Mmerge = v2
rel/2.
3.2. Level 2: Galactic Halos
For our purposes, galactic halos are treated as a ho-
mogeneous assembly of protogalactic clouds and hot
gas, possibly having a component of nonbaryonic dark
matter. The total mass of the galactic halo is then
m2 = ncm1 + mg2 + mr2 + mNB
2
,
(13)
2We explicitly show only the metal evolution here and below,
but from this the expressions for the helium evolution follows
trivially.
where nc is the number of protogalactic clouds, mg2
is the mass of hot gas which has exited the clouds to
5
reside in the halo, and mr2 is the mass of stars and
remnants which have been dispersed from clouds into
the halo. The mass of the nonbaryonic component, if
present, is mNB
2 .
The equation describing the evolution of the (hot)
gas component in the halo is:
mg2 = nc ( mout1 − min1)
− mout2 + min2 ,
(14)
where mout2 is the rate at which the hot gas is ejected
from the halos as described below and min3 is the
possible inflow of gas from the intragroup medium.
The rate at which stars and remnants are injected
into the halo from mergers can be inferred from Eq.
(4),
mr2 = κncmr1λmerge
.
(15)
The equation governing the evolution of metallicity
in the halos will be
Z2 = (Z hot
1 − Z2)
+(Z3 − Z2)
nc mout1
mg2
min2
mg2
,
(16)
where nc is the number of cold protogalactic clouds in
the halo. Similarly the internal energy per unit mass,
ǫ2, of gas in the halo is determined from an energy
balance equation:
ǫ2 = (ǫout
(17)
nc mhot
out1
mg2
1 − ǫ2)
2 − ǫ2(cid:19) mout2
−(cid:18)ǫout
+ (ǫ3 − ǫ2)
mg2
−λcoolǫ2 − 2
ǫ2 .
min2
mg2
R2
R2
The number of clouds decreases exponentially with
the number of mergers:
nc = −λmergenc
.
(18)
3.3. Level 3: Hot Intra-Group Medium
The equations governing the evolution of the intra-
group medium are analogous to those for the galactic
halos, but at the level of the group nonbaryonic dark
6
matter may be a dominant contributor. Thus, for the
total group mass we write,
m3 = nhm2 + mg3 + mNB
3
,
(19)
where nh is the number of galactic halos in the group,
mg3 is the mass of the hot X-ray intragroup medium,
and mNB
is the contribution from nonbaryonic dark
3
matter.
The evolution equation for the intragroup medium
is then,
mg3 = nh( m2out − min2) − m3out
,
(20)
and m3out is the rate at which the gas is lost from the
group.
The equation governing the evolution of metallicity
in the intragroup medium is then
Z3 = (Z2 − Z3)
nh m2out
mg3
,
and the energy balance equation is
ǫ3 = (ǫout
nh mout2
mg3
mout3
mg3
2 − ǫ3)
−(cid:0)ǫout
3 − ǫ3(cid:1)
R3
−λcoolǫ3 − 2
R3
ǫ3 ,
(21)
(22)
from which temperature of the intragroup medium
can be inferred.
3.4. Cooling, Star Formation, Mergers, and
Mass Loss
The evolution is given by equations (1 -- 22). What
remains is to specify the various input quantities, i.e.,
the rates for cooling, star formation, merging, and
mass loss.
The metallicity-dependent cooling rate λcool is de-
rived from the calculations of Bohringer & Hensler
(1989). For the temperatures appropriate for the
hot gas, the cooling is dominated by brehmsstrahlung
emission from electrons. These losses are written in
terms of the cooling function Λ, which gives the en-
ergy loss rate per unit density. Given the number
density at a given scale ni, one may then compute
Ei = niΛ, and then
the energy loss rate per particle:
the cooling rate λcool ≡ E/E.
We allow star formation to be induced both by
mergers and intrinsic star formation processes within
the clouds (MS93).
In MS93 it was shown that in-
trinsic star formation is more important during the
subsequent evolution as material settles into a disk.
To describe the merger-induced star formation for all
of the merging substructures within a collapsing halo,
MS93 proposed a schematic model of colliding viri-
alized protogalactic clouds within an expanding and
contracting halo. We adopt that formulation here.
Specifically, we presume that the fragments virial-
ize as they form. The collision rate per cloud within
this virialized velocity distribution can be written,
λmerge = (nc − 1)σv/V ,
(23)
where n is the number of protogalactic clouds within a
volume V , σ is an average collision cross section, and v
is the virial velocity (v ∼ [0.4GMh/Rh]1/2), where Mh
is the total gravitational mass of a galactic halo, and
Rh is the radius of the galactic halos, approximated as
a collapsing spherical overdensities. We define halos
as those regions which evolve to become independent
gravitationally bound ensembles of gas and stars at
the present time. All halos themselves are viewed
as the result of merging internal structure. Hence
we only describe merging within the halos and not
merging between halos. This is largely a matter of
semantics.
The number of protogalactic clouds decreases ex-
ponentially with the integral of the merger rate (Eq.
18),
nc(t) = nc(0) e−R t
0
λmergedt′
,
(24)
where the initial number of clouds, nc(0), is given by
the ratio of the total initial halo baryonic mass to
the initial cloud mass. Thus, nc(0) ∼ 106 for this
schematic model. For the merger cross section σ we
use σ = πR2
t , with a tidal radius Rt = 2R1 to include
gravitational effects (Binney & Tremaine 1987).
Near the end of the collapse of the halos, the com-
bined effects of conservation of angular momentum
and heating will dissipate the radial motion. In our
schematic model, we approximate these effects by
halting the halo collapse at a size of a typical present
dark-matter halo, (R2 ∼ 50 kpc). The cloud radii are
fixed by Eq. (11), and the group collapse is halted
when the radius reaches the present size of the Local
Group, R3 ∼ 700 kpc.
The merger-induced stellar birth rate thus is taken
as proportional to the mass of gas mass participating
in mergers per unit time. The intrinsic, quiescent
star formation rate is taken as ∝ ρn
gas1, where
coldmcold
n = 1/2 in our case. The total star formation rate is
the sum of the two terms:
ψ(t) = (cid:16)αmrgλmerge + βQρ1/2
cold(cid:17) mcold
g1
,
(25)
Note that we have parameterized the strength of
merger-induced star formations in terms of the di-
mensionless efficiency αmrg. Typical numbers for
αmrg are ∼ 1% (MS93). The coefficient of the qui-
escent piece is taken as βQ = βqΛ0, where Λ0 =
1.7 × 10−4/(M⊙ kpc−3)−1/2 Gyr−1. Typical values
of the dimensionless scaling βq are 1 − 5 (MS93).
Finally, we must specify the rate at which hot gas
is ejected from, or falls into, the clouds, halos, and
the group. We first calculate the outflow due to evap-
orative mass loss. We assume that the hot gas is dis-
tributed homogeneously within an object. The rate
of loss of hot gas is then just given by the fraction of a
Maxwellian thermal distribution of velocities in excess
of the escape velocity at the surface of the structures
at all three levels. Thus, we write,
gi = 3ζloss hv(> ve)i
mhot
Ri
mhot
gi
≡ λoutmhot
gi
(26)
Where, i denotes clouds, halos, or the group, and
ζloss ≤ 1 is a dimensionless scale factor depending
on the geometry of the cloud; ζloss = 1 for a sphere.
The factor hv(> vesc)i is the average velocity of all
particles above the escape velocity v2
esc = 2GMi/Ri:
hv(> vesc)i = R ∞
dv v3 fMB(v)
vesc
R ∞
0 dv v2 fMB(v)
1
4√π
(1 + xi)e−xi vT
=
(27)
where fMB is the Maxwellian distribution. The aver-
age thermal velocity is v2
T = 2kTi/µmp, and µmp is
the average mass of a gas particle. xi = GMi/RikTi
is the ratio of gravitational binding energy to thermal
energy, and is small typically.
Similarly, the average energy loss per unit ejected
mass of material is
ǫout
i
= hǫv(> vesc)i
hv(> vesc)i
1 + xi + x2
i /2
=
1 + xi
2kTi
µmp
(28)
which for small xi gives ǫout
i ≃ 2kTi/µmp = 4ǫi/3.
7
Using similar derivations, we have computed in-
flow of halo (group) gas into the clouds (halos). We
note that this inflow has two components. First, some
material is accreted simply due to the motion of the
halo or cloud through the surrounding medium -- the
finite size of these substructures will lead to the cap-
ture gas that falls within their geometric cross section
σ = πR2
i . Second, the hot gas particles surround-
ing the substructures will accrete due to their ran-
dom thermal motion. We assume that these particles
quickly equilibrate with the ambient gas. Together
these two effects lead to an infall term of the form
mhot
ini =
4
3
ζloss (cid:18) Ri
Ri+1(cid:19) mhot
gi+1(cid:0)vT
i+1 + vc(cid:1)
Ri+1
, (29)
with v2
locity.
c ≡ Gmi+1/Ri+1 the cloud (halo) circular ve-
3.5.
Initial Mass Function and Stellar Yields
The initial mass function (IMF) is important for
our scenario in several respects. As we have noted,
it affects the parameters of our model, namely the
returned fraction R, yields yY and yZ, and specific
energy injection ǫSN. Moreover, the crucial impact of
the IMF for our scenario is that it determines the ratio
of low mass stars to high mass stars in the halo. Low
mass stars (m <∼ 0.9M⊙ for halo metallicities) will
still be burning today. While these stars are faint,
they would be detectable, and heavily favored by an
IMF similar to that of present disk stars. As a re-
sult, such stars would today outnumber by far the
halo remnants, and their net contribution to the halo
luminosity would be large (Ryu, Olive, & Silk 1990).
Thus, remnants cannot be a significant component of
the halo if the halo IMF is similar to that inferred
for disk stars. To allow for a significant population
of halo white dwarfs, they must have been formed
from an IMF which strongly favored the formation of
intermediate- to high-mass stars over low-mass stars
(Ryu, Olive, & Silk 1990).
Given the different physical conditions during the
formation of the halo (e.g., frequent mergers, higher
temperatures, lower metallicities), it is at least plau-
sible that the star forming process then was different
than that of disk stars. Indeed, there are arguments
for an early IMF that is skewed towards higher masses
(see Silk 1993; Bond, Arnett, & Carr 1984; Adams &
Fatuzzo 1996).
Therefore, we have chosen the simple log-normal
IMF parameterization, as suggested by both obser-
8
vational (Miller & Scalo 1979) and theoretical ar-
guments (Adams & Fatuzzo 1996 and refs therein):
ln φ(ln m) = ln φ0 − [ln2(m/mc)/2σ2]. We investigate
the effect of variations of the centroid mass mc and the
dimensionless width σ. We take the IMF bounds to be
(0.1,100)M⊙, with a black hole cutoff at 18M⊙(Brown
& Bethe 1995). In fact, our results for metal yields
are insensitive to these limits. With these parameters,
we obtain a returned fraction R = 0.375.
The stellar yields are taken from Maeder (1992).
We follow both helium and metallicity Z. These
abundances are particularly powerful constraints when
used together. The helium yields are mainly from in-
termediate mass stars (m <∼ 8M⊙), while the metal
yields come primarily from high mass stars. Thus,
the IMF must strike a balance between the two mass
ranges to avoid an inappropriate ratio of helium to
metals. With our IMF, we find yY = 0.0139 and
yZ = 0.0354.
4. Results
In this hierarchical merging picture we take the
clouds to be the initial building blocks of all structure.
Thus, while we assume the clouds to be comprised
initially of hot and cold gas, we assume baryons in
the halos and the Group to be initially within clouds
only. Thus, by definition the initial gas in the halos
and group is zero. The initial metallicity is zero, while
we take a primordial helium abundance of Y = 0.235.
We have run the model for plausible ranges of the
input parameters. The two models we present here
are: (1) a "best-fit" model which has appropriate fi-
nal masses and metallicities, while also optimally sat-
isfying other constraints (§§4.4 -- 4.6); and (2) a "max-
imum remnant" model which has the highest possible
halo remnant mass without violating the constraints.
Parameters of these models are summarized in Table
1. Unless otherwise noted, numerical results will be
given for the best-fit model.
For all models, the qualitative results are as fol-
lows. There is generally a high initial merger rate,
which lasts for <∼ 1 Gyr. This reduces the number
of protogalactic clouds from 106 to about 100 while
producing a burst of star (and hot gas) formation.
The star formation rate and cloud number evolution
appear in Figure 2. Some of the stars are ejected into
the halo by the mergers, and on a longer timescale,
a wind is ejected -- first from clouds, then from halo,
and ultimately from the Group. When the halo col-
lapses, after 5 Gyr (Mathews & Schramm 1993), there
is an additional burst of merging and star formation.
The remaining clouds coalesce into what will eventu-
ally become the galactic bulge and spiral arms. With
the collapse there is also heating and a reinvigorated
wind. Subsequently, all remaining (hot, metal-rich)
halo gas is ejected into the intergalactic medium. The
evolution of halo and group masses is given in Figure
3.
4.1. Disk and Bulge Formation
The clouds begin with the Jeans mass at recom-
bination, 106M⊙. They merge to form the proto-
disk+bulge, with a mass 8.1×1010M⊙. It is encourag-
ing that, at the end of the halo collapse, most material
in the proto-disk is in cold gas which will form disk
stars. The evolution of metallicities is given in Figure
4. As seen in the figure, the metallicities grow rapidly
in the initial burst, then remain fairly constant un-
til the halo collapse at 5 Gyr. Then the metals rise
again as the halo collapses and the disk and bulge are
formed. Hence, the halo evolution provides an initial
metallicity for the gas of the protodisk. This corre-
sponds to an "initial enrichment" of the disk material,
and so avoids overproduction of metal poor disk stars
(i.e., the disk G-dwarf problem).
4.2. Halo Formation
In the best-fit model, portrayed in Fig. 3a, the
galaxy (=clouds+halo) begins with a mass of 1.35 ×
1012M⊙, of which 1.1 × 1012M⊙ is baryonic (all
in the clouds). Even higher fractions are allowed,
as discussed below (§5). The final galaxy mass is
5.0×1011M⊙, of which 2.5×1011M⊙ is baryonic; thus
50% of the total Galactic mass is in baryons. Some of
these baryons constitute the disk+bulge, as described
above. The baryonic mass of the halo remnants alone
(excluding the disk+bulge) is 1.7 × 1011M⊙, and the
halo nonbaryonic mass accounts for 2.5 × 1011M⊙.
Hence, 40% of the dark halo is in remnants, consis-
tent with the microlensing observations.
When combined with mass loss from the other
galaxy in the Local Group, there is a total loss of
1.7 × 1012M⊙ of gas from both halos into the intra-
group medium. The galactic wind is thus very ef-
ficient, as it must be to remove the ejecta that ac-
companies the remnant production. The remnants
themselves are mostly white dwarfs, with 12% neu-
tron stars.
9
4.3. Group Evolution
In the best-fit model, the Local Group begins (Fig.
3b)with a mass of 5.6× 1012M⊙, and a baryonic mass
of 2.2 × 1012M⊙. At the end of the simulation the
group has a total mass 4.3× 1012M⊙, 17% of which is
baryonic. Of the baryonic group mass, 2.9 × 1011M⊙
resides in hot gas. The intragroup gas temperature
is 0.26 keV, just at the limit of ROSAT sensitivity.
The group as a whole loses 1.4 × 1012M⊙ of gas to
the intergalactic medium; thus about 64% of the ini-
tial baryonic mass in the group is ejected later into
intergalactic space.
It is remarkable that the remnants in the halos,
turn out to represent a small fraction of the initial
baryonic matter. The galactic winds required to re-
move the stellar ejecta co-produced with the white
dwarfs prove strong enough to remove most gas from
the group itself. This amount of hot (ionized) ma-
terial is consistent with Gunn-Peterson limits on the
intergalactic medium if it does not cool further (§5.1).
Thus, in the best-fit model we find the dark halo
to be 40% microlensing objects. These take the form
of stellar remnants, 88% of which are white dwarfs,
and the rest neutron stars (and perhaps black holes).
In this model the copious production of hot intra-
group and intergalactic gas is a natural consequence of
white dwarf-dominated halos. We produce a present
mass of intragroup gas of 2.9 × 1011M⊙. This cor-
responds to about 37% of the baryonic mass of the
Local Group. This mass is encouragingly near the
value (3.5×1011M⊙) implied by the Suto et al. (1996)
model for the excess diffuse X-ray background (§2).
(But recall the observational controversy §2.)
The X-ray luminosity of the halo is 1.5×1040 erg s−1.
Let us assume for simplicity that the earth is at the
center of this emission, and that the gas extends ho-
mogeneously to the edge of the Local group (R3 = 700
kpc in this model). This leads to a total diffuse back-
ground of about 4× 10−2 erg s−1 cm−2 sr−1. This is,
at its peak energy, about 3 orders of magnitude be-
low the observed diffuse soft X-ray background. We
therefore find the diffuse Local Group radiation to be
negligible. The contribution is thus much lower than
that suggested by Suto et al. (1996), who postulate a
similar (but larger) intragroup gas mass, but posit a
temperature of 1 keV as opposed to 0.26 keV in this
model.
4.4. Mass budget
The most basic constraint on our model is the re-
quirement that it reproduce the observed mass and
metal budget of the Local Group. The final masses
determine the initial masses, but the metallicity val-
ues constrain how to get these. Consider the to-
tal metal mass production in our model. The to-
tal initial baryonic mass is 2.2 × 1012. Of this, the
mass processed into stars and remnants is Mrem =
4.95 × 1011M⊙. The total mass into ejecta is just
R/(1 − R)/Mrem = 3.0 × 1011M⊙. The total metal
mass produced is yZ Mej = 1.1 × 1010M⊙, and the
total new helium mass is yY Mej = 2.8 × 1010M⊙.
Now, the average new metals from a given star rep-
resents a high fraction of that star's ejecta: yZ =
0.014 ∼ 2/3 Z⊙. However, this metal-rich ejecta is
diluted in several ways. First, it is mixed with η
times its mass as it leaves the cold star-forming re-
gions. Then it is mixed into the hot cloud gas, which
quickly evaporates into the halo and on to the intra-
group medium. Much gas is even evaporated from the
Local Group itself, becoming part of an intergalactic
(extragroup) medium. Thus, the final mean metallic-
ity must be averaged over all of the baryons (including
the ejecta from the Local Groups). One finds that the
global average mass fraction is just 0.0049 ≃ 0.25Z⊙,
an acceptably small value.
The key point here is that star formation does not
occur in all regions containing gas (as is often as-
sumed in simple chemical evolution models) but only
cold molecular cloud cores. Consequently, the stars
represent a small fraction of the total baryonic mass.
Furthermore, whereas the stars remain in the galax-
ies, the gas is dispersed at all levels. The halo can
thus contain many remnants but not a large amount
of metals.
4.5. Nucleosynthesis
Nucleosynthesis provides an important additional
constraint on this scenario (Ryu, Olive, & Silk 1990;
Charlot & Silk 1995; Hegyi & Olive 1986). The burst
of star formation which produces the white dwarfs
must not overproduce metals and helium. As noted
above, the metallicities at the different scales are rea-
sonable. Furthermore, we may test not only the aver-
age metallicities, but also the halo metallicity distri-
bution. Figure 5 compares our calculated halo stel-
lar metallicity distribution with the observed globu-
lar cluster distribution. The agreement is good for
the most metal-poor ([Z] < −1), and thus the oldest,
portion of the population.
The halo metallicity distribution strongly constrains
the total halo remnant mass in our model. The posi-
tion of the peak constrains the net star formation rate
amplitude. If the star formation rate is too large, the
peak is shifted too high. Thus, the need to reproduce
the peak at [Z] ∼ −1.5 limits the mass processed
into stars, and so leaves fewer stars available for the
halo. From the χ2 of a fit to the halo metallicity
distribution we estimate a 2σ upper limit of a 77%
remnant contribution to the halo. Consequently, it
seems likely that the halo contains at least some non-
baryonic dark matter. In addition, the shape of the
distribution is largely sensitive to the relative star for-
mation rate, and to the degree of mixing between the
stellar ejecta with the cold gas.
The IMF shape is of course important in deter-
mining the metallicities. However, contrary to Ryu,
Olive, & Silk, we find no significant constraint on the
IMF upper limit, essentially because the ejection of
gas removes some of the metals produced by high-
mass stars. This is even more so if there is a cutoff
for black hole formation as low as 18 M⊙ (Bethe &
Brown 1995). This is
4.6. Halo Luminosity
Several sources of luminosity also provide impor-
tant constraints.
(1) Low mass stars in the halo are long lived and
can lead to an unacceptably high halo mass-to-light
ratio (Ryu, Olive & Silk 1990; Richstone, Gould,
Guhathakurta, & Flynn 1992); however, in our model,
the mass to light ratio is comfortably above these au-
thors limit M/LB > 500 for Rhalo = 50 kpc. We
determine the luminosity contributed by all stars still
burning in the halo by integration of stellar luminosi-
ties, the past star formation rate, and initial mass
function, without the instantaneous recycling approx-
imation. We find a mass to total luminosity ratio of
M/Ltot = 760, M/LV = 1300, and M/LB = 3500.
(2) Light from the bursts of star formation can
lead to a large diffuse background (Charlot & Silk
1995; Zepf & Silk 1996). Using a population synthe-
sis model we have preliminarily computed this back-
ground assuming the starlight to be unscattered after
its emission. These will be discussed in Mathews et al.
(1996), but results are consistent with observed con-
straints. We exceed the Charlot & Silk (1995) limit
10
of a 10% remnant halo because most of the elements
are formed at very large redshift (z ∼ 10).
(3) The halo white dwarfs will contribute to the
white dwarf luminosity function (e.g., Adams & Laugh-
lin 1996; Chabrier, Segretain, & M´era 1996). There
is a new constraint from Flynn, Gould, & Bahcall
(1996), which requires halo white dwarfs to have an
luminosity MV >∼ 18.4. for V − I > 1.8.
The white dwarf luminosity function in our model
is given in Figure 6. The two peaks corresponding to
the two bursts of star formation. The strongest con-
straint comes from the more recent peak produced at
the epoch of halo collapse. These white dwarfs have
cooled to present luminosities of ∼ 10−5.5L⊙. This
would correspond to a bolometric magnitude of 18.4.
However, the bolometric correction (Liebert, Dahn,
& Monet 1988), would probably reduce the visible lu-
minosity to MV > 20, well below the Flynn, Gould,
& Bahcall limit (similar to the findings of Kawaler
1996). The low luminosity of the white dwarfs de-
rives in part from their very old age, but also because
the population comes from a shifted IMF. Since the
progenitors are more massive stars, they died sooner
and so the remnants have had longer to cool. Indeed,
our adopted IMF centroid of 2.3M⊙ is that of Adams
& Laughlin (1996), who chose it specifically to obey
the luminosity function constraints in the disk.
4.7. Parameter Sensitivity
Our results depend sensitively on several of the
model parameters. Parameter values for our best-fit
model are summarized in column 3 of Table 1. Among
the most important parameters are those that deter-
mine the shape of the IMF. We find a good fit for a
centroid (c.f. §3.5) mc = 2.3M⊙, and a width σ = 1.
Note that this centroid is that of Adams & McLaugh-
lin (1996). However, they advocated a tighter width
to avoid metallicity problems which we do not require
in our model because metals are efficiently ejected in
the hot wind. Indeed, the width we use is essentially
the present value (Miller & Scalo 1979).
Other IMF parameters are allowed, but to obey the
observational constraints, these must be near the ones
we have adopted. As discussed above (§3.5), the cen-
troid must be >∼ 1M⊙ to avoid significant production
of long lived, low mass stars still burning in the halo.
However, the centroid must not be too high to avoid
untenably large metal yields. The width must also be
not so large that it allows too many low mass stars,
but not so narrow that metal yields are too small and
helium yields too large. Thus, the need for a dark
halo, and for a reasonable nucleosynthesis, drive the
IMF parameters to the range of those we have chosen.
The other important parameters involve star for-
mation and ejecta. The star formation parameters
(eq. 25 and Table 1) are reasonable and consistent
with previous results (MS93), derived from requiring
consistency among various comoschronometers. The
quiescent term dominates, controlling the mass bud-
get, but the merger term is also important. The ratio
of the merger to quiescent contribution controls the
position of the peak in the halo metallicity distribu-
tion (Fig. 5).
For the ejecta, the most important parameter is the
degree of mixing ηmix. A higher value leads to more
dilution of the ejecta, which leads to lower metallicity
and temperature in the hot gas. The observed lower
temperatures and metallicity of the hot gas in groups
demands that ηmix > 1.
5. The Remnant Contribution to the Dark
Halo Mass
Given that (1) there is good evidence for dark mat-
ter in the Galactic halo, and that (2) microlensing ob-
jects are the first positively detected dark matter in
the halo, a key question arises: how much of the dark
halo is in MACHOs? In this context it is important to
note that our best model does not give an all-remnant
halo. Such a model is attractive for its simplicity,
but we find that our best fit prefers only ∼ 40% of
the dark halo mass in remnants, with the balance
in non-baryonic material. The strongest constraint
on the white dwarf halo fraction is the halo metal-
licity distribution.
Increasing the white dwarf frac-
tion requires increasing the star formation rate; this
leads to halo metallicities whose distribution peaks
too high (§4.7). The "maximum remnant" model is
that having the 2σ upper limit for the halo fraction
(as set by the halo globular cluster metallicity distri-
bution). It's parameters are summarized in Table 1;
in it the halo remnant mass fraction is 77%. This up-
per limit can be raised somewhat if we increase the
stellar merger dispersal efficiency κ (see §3.2). While
it is difficult to increase the halo remnant fraction, it
is easy to decrease it. If the winds are less efficient
(e.g., if ζloss < 1), then more material is recycled in
the clouds. Thus a lower star formation amplitude is
required and fewer stars are available to eject at early
11
Table 1: Model Parameters Adopted
Model Feature
Parameter Best-Fit Max Remnant
IMF
Star Formation
Ejecta
mc
σ
αmrg
βq
ηmix
ζloss
2.3 M⊙
1.6
0.007
1
8
1
same
same
0.002
2.5
8
1
times. We find a minimum halo remnant fraction, for
ζloss <∼ 0.08, of ∼ 1%.
Our findings are to be compared to recent analysis
of the MACHO data (Alcock et al. 1996). The mi-
crolensing results are still very model-dependent, but
it is provocative that they find a best fit for ∼ 50%
of the halo being made up of 0.5+0.3
−0.2M⊙ objects. The
question of whether one can put stronger constraints
on the MACHO halo fraction in our model leads to
the issues raised in the next section.
5.1. X-ray Groups: a Key Constraint
As indicated in §2, there is currently large uncer-
tainty regarding X-ray observations of spiral domi-
nated groups. However, while the observations are
ambiguous, what seems more clear is that spiral-rich
groups do not contain hot gas with T ∼ 1 keV. That
is, these systems do not evidence the same kind of
diffuse emission as groups with early-type galaxies. If
hot gas exists in these groups, it must have either low
mass (<∼ (1−3)×1010M⊙), or a low temperature, near
or below the ROSAT threshold Tth <∼ 0.3 keV. Indeed,
gest that these systems do have cool (T <∼ 0.3 keV)
Mulchaey, Mushotzky, Burstein, & Davis (1996) sug-
gas, and argue that this may have been detected as
high-ionization quasar absorption lines. Furthermore,
given the morphological similarity of the bulge and
halo with early-type galaxies, it would be surprising
if no hot gas were found in these systems.
At any rate, the observations seem to rule out that
the gas is both massive and hot in spiral-rich groups.
However, in our model the temperature and the gas
mass are related, as follows.
After the processing of one stellar generation, the
ejecta to remnant ratio is R/(1 − R). Mixing with
unprocessed cold material gives a total hot gas to
remnant ratio (1 + ηmix)R/(1 − R).
In our model,
R = 0.38, so Mgas > Mrem for ηmix > 1.7 (which
holds in our case). This already means that the mass
12
of ejected gas must be larger than the halo baryon
mass (assuming that most hot gas escapes). Con-
sequently,
if the limits on gas in spiral-dominated
groups apply -- i.e., if the gas were to have T >∼ 0.3
keV -- then the mass in halo white dwarfs must be less
than the X-ray limits on the gas mass, ∼ 1010M⊙.
This would be only a small component of the halo.
To allow for a significant gas mass, therefore, one
must demand that it avoid the ROSAT limits because
it is cool: T <∼ 0.3 keV. However, the gas temperature
is related to the gas-to-remnant ratio, as we now show.
The total energy in the ejecta is RǫSNMrem. This
implies that the energy per unit mass of ejected gas
is ǫgas = RǫSNMrem/Mgas = ǫSN(1 − R)/(1 + ηmix).
Finally, using the scaling TSN = (2/3) µmpǫSN = 2
keV, we have Tgas = 2 keV(1 − R)/(1 + ηmix). That
is, the gas temperature diminishes with ηmix. But we
already have seen that having a significant fraction of
the halo in remnants, we need the concomitant halo
gas to be cool. Using the Ponman et al. (1996) value
Tgas ≃ 0.3 keV, and with R = 0.39, one finds ηmix ≃
3. In our detailed model which includes reprocessing,
we find a larger value, η = 8. Thus, cooler gas results
if ηmix > 1, but only if the bulk of the baryons are in
the gas.
5.2. Cosmological Baryon Fraction
In the preceding section we see that our best-fit
model finds that a large fraction of baryons, initially
in the group, are ejected as an intergalactic medium.
This can be reconciled with the total cosmological
baryonic budget, as follows. In our scenario, the cos-
mic baryonic inventory is ΩB = Ωdisk+bulge + Ωrem
halo +
Ωgas
IGM (writing the uni-
versal density in component i in units of the critical
density: Ωi ≡ ρi/ρcrit, where ρcrit = 3H 2
0 /8πG). If
most baryons reside in the intragroup and intergalac-
tic diffuse gas, we therefore require Ωgas
IGM ≃
ΩB ≫ Ωrem
halo.
IGM ≃ Ωrem
LG + Ωgas
LG + Ωgas
halo + Ωgas
LG + Ωgas
Observationally, galactic rotation curves imply that
galaxy halos have Ωhalo ∼ 0.02h(Rhalo/50 kpc), where
Rhalo is the (unknown) radius of the dark halo (e.g.,
Peebles 1993). On the other hand, primordial nucle-
osynthesis calculations give ΩB = (0.015 ± 0.005)h−2
(Copi, Schramm, & Turner 1995; Fields et al. 1996).
Taking the ratio, we have Ωhalo/ΩB ∼ 1.3h3. Conse-
quently, for h <∼ 0.9, Ωhalo < ΩB; that is, for reason-
able values of h, some baryons are likely to be non-
galactic. Indeed, for a low Hubble constant (h = 0.5),
the bulk of the baryons are nongalactic. Furthermore,
these relations assume that the halos are entirely
baryonic (not the case in our best model). Any non-
baryonic component in galaxy halos only strengthens
the argument.
Thus, we see that the X-ray observations of groups
can provide strong constraints on remnants in the
halo. Of course, this assumes that the Local Group is
like other poor groups. If so, and if the X-ray data is
reliable, then these data may provide a key constraint.
As we have noted, if there is only a small X-ray gas
mass in the Local Group, then there can be few rem-
nants in the halo. Taking the more optimistic view, if
the Ponman et al. (1996) result is correct, then there
could be a large amount of (as yet unobserved) hot
gas in the Local Group, as required in our model.
6. Conclusions
We have shown that, without violating constraints
posed by luminosity and nucleosynthesis considera-
tions, one may construct a plausible model in which
the dark halo of the Galaxy contains a significant
fraction of white dwarfs. These may have already
been detected in halo microlensing events towards the
LMC, and might also be detected via their luminos-
ity function. The same bursts of star formation which
produced the white dwarfs also led to hot, metal-rich
intergalactic gas, some of which may still reside in the
Local Group. This hot gas could be detectable via its
X-rays, and by distortions in the cosmic microwave
background radiation (Suto et al. 1996).
Thus, the predictions of the model are testable. If
the halo is comprised of white dwarfs then there must
be a background of hot, X-ray emitting gas in the
Local Group. Conversely, if there is metal-rich hot
gas in the Local Group, then a significant fraction of
the halo mass must be in remnants. Clearly, further
searches for both of these are warranted.
Furthermore, if our galaxy formation scheme is in-
deed universal, then hot gas production and ejection
should be a ubiquitous aspect of halo formation. Con-
sequently, X-ray observations of other systems could
provide a key constraint on our model.
In partic-
ular, our model can be directly tested by observa-
tions which can unambiguously confirm or deny the
presence of hot gas in other spiral-dominated groups.
Also, if white dwarfs are ubiquitous in galactic ha-
los, then they may lead to detectable infrared pro-
files in edge-on galaxies, which may already have
been observed (Barnaby & Thronson 1994; Sackett,
Morrison, Harding, & Boroson 1994; Lequeux, Fort,
Dantel-Fort, Cuillandre, & Mellier 1996; Lehnert &
Heckman 1996). Finally, even if our scenario turns
out not to be applicable to spiral-dominated groups,
it remains that ellipticals must eject gas in strong
winds. Thus, our model may still be valid for clusters,
which are elliptical-dominated. This will be explored
in a subsequent work.
We note as well that in our scenario, just as there is
typically a large outflow from the halo, there is also a
strong evaporative wind that ejects material from the
Local Group. As a result, most baryons eventually
reside in hot, intergalactic (as opposed to intragroup)
gas.
If this gas stays hot, it could perhaps be the
ionized intergalactic (as suggested by Gunn-Peterson
limits on the neutral intergalactic medium). If it does
cool, it presents serious problems, as it would lead to
prodigious but unobserved absorption of extragalactic
radiation.
Finally, we reiterate that stellar remnants and their
associated hot ejecta are conservative candidates for
both the halo microlensing objects and for the bary-
onic dark matter. If these can be ruled out, then we
are forced to conclude that the microlensing objects
and the dark baryons are something stranger still.
We are pleased to acknowledge useful discussions
with C. Alcock, D. Bennett, E. Gates, K. Jedamzik,
S. Shore, and M. Turner. We are grateful to R.
Mushotzky and J. Mulchaey for may useful discus-
sions of X-ray observations, and we especially thank
R. Pildis for pointing out the limits on spiral-dominated
groups. Finally, we are particularly indebted to
St´ephane Charlot for advice and assistance on an
early version of this work. Work at Notre Dame is
supported by DoE Nuclear Theory grant number DE-
FG02-95ER40934. Work at the University of Chicago
is supported by NSF grant AST 90-22629, DOE grant
DEF02-91-ER40606, and NASA grant 1231, and by
13
NASA through grant NAGW 2381 at Fermilab.
Graff, D.S., & Freese, K.1996, ApJ, submitted (astro-
REFERENCES
Adams, F.C., & Fatuzzo, M. 1996, ApJ, 464, 256
Adams, F.C., & Laughlin, G. 1996, ApJ, submitted
(astro-ph/9502006)
ph/9602051)
Hegyi, D.J. & Olive, K.A., 1986, ApJ, 303, 56
Kawaler, S. 1996, ApJ, in press (astro-ph/9606094)
Larson, R.B. 1987, Co. Ap., 11, 273
Alcock, C. et al. 1995, ApJ, 461, 84
Lehnert, M.D., & Heckman, T.M. 1996, ApJ, 462, 651
Alcock, C. et al. 1995, ApJ submitted (astro-
ph/9606165)
Arnauld, M., Rothenflug, R., Boulade, O., Vigroux,
L., & Vangioni-Flam, E. 1992, A&A, 254, 49
Aubourg, E. et al. 1993, Nature, 365 623
Bahcall, J.N., Flynn, C., Gould, A., Kirhakos, S.
1994, ApJ, 435, L51
Barnaby D., & Thronson, H.A. 1994, AJ, 107, 1717
Bethe, H.A., & Brown, G.E. 1995, ApJ,445, L129
Binney, J., & Tremaine, S. 1987, Galactic Dynamics,
(Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press), 580
Bohringer, H. & Hensler, G. 1988, A&A, 215, 147
Bond, J.R., Arnett, W.D., & Carr, B.J. 1984, ApJ,
280, 825
Lequeux, J., Fort, B., Dantel-Fort, M., Cuillandre,
J.C., & Mellier, Y. 1996, A&A, in press (astro-
ph/9606172)
Liebert, J., Dahn, C.C., & Monet, D.G. 1988, ApJ,
332, 891
Maeder, A. 1992, A&A, 264, 105
Mathews, G.J., Fields, B.D., Charlot, S., & Schramm,
D.N. 1996, to be submitted
Mathews, G.J., & Schramm, D.N. 1993, ApJ, 404,
468
Miller, G.E., & Scalo, J.M. 1979, ApJS, 41, 513
Mulchaey, J.S., Davis, D.S., Mushotzky, R.J., &
Burstein, D. 1993, ApJ, 404, L9
Mulchaey, J.S., Davis, D.S., Mushotzky, R.J., &
Burstein, D. 1996, ApJ, 456, 80
Chabrier, G., Segretain, L., & M´era, D., 1996, ApJ,
submitted (astro-ph/9606083)
Mulchaey, J.S., Mushotzky, R.J., Burstein, D. 1996,
& Davis, D.S. ApJ, 456, L8
Charlot, S., & Silk, J. 1995, ApJ, 445, 124
Copi, C.J., Schramm, D.N., & Turner, M.S. 1995,
Science, 267, 192
Davis, D.S., Mulchaey, J.S., Mushotzky, R.J., &
Burstein, D. 1996, ApJ, 460, 601
Fich, M., & Tremaine, S. 1991, ARAA, 409
Fields, B.D., Kainulainen, K., Olive, K.A., &
Thomas, D. 1996, New Astron., in press
R.J.
1993,
Mushotzky,
of
Texas/PASCOS 1993, ed. M. Sredniki (New York:
Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.)
Proceedings
Pagel, B.E.J. 1988, in Evolutionary Phenomena in
Galaxies, eds. J. Beckman & B.E.J. Pagel (Cam-
bridge: Cambridge University Press)
Peebles, P.J.E., 1993, Principles of Physical Cosmol-
ogy, (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press)
Pildis, R., Bregman, J.N., & Evrard, A.E. 1995, ApJ,
Flynn, C., Gould, A., & Bahcall, J.N. 1996, ApJ, 466,
443, 514
L55 (astro-ph/9503035)
Pildis, R.A., & McGaugh, S.S. 1996, ApJ, submitted
Fujimoto, M.Y., Sugiyama, K., Iben, I., Hollowell, D.
(astro-ph/9608038)
1995, ApJ, 444, 175
Fukazawa, Y., et al. 1996, Pub. Astr. Soc. Japan, 48,
395
Ponman, T.J., Bourner, P.D.J., Ebeling, H., &
in press (astro-
Bohringer, H. 1996, MNRAS,
ph/9607114)
14
Rich, R.M. 1990, ApJ, 362, 604
FIGURE CAPTIONS
Richstone, D., Gould, A., Guhathakurta, P, & Flynn,
C. 1992, ApJ, 38, 354
Ryu, D., Olive, K.A., & Silk, J. 1990, ApJ, 353, 81
Sackett, P.D., Morrison, H.L., Harding, P., & Boro-
son, T.A. 1994, Nature, 370, 441
Silk, J. 1993, Phys Reports, 227, 143
1. Schematic diagram of model features.
2. The total galactic star formation rate ψ =
ncψcloud (solid curve) and number of clouds
nc (dashed curve) as a function of time. Two
bursts of star formation are evident, one shortly
after decoupling when the density is high, and
one during halo collapse (5 Gyr).
Suto, Y., Makishima, K., Ishisaki, Y., & Ogasaka, Y.
3. Mass evolution for (a) the halo, (b) the local
1996, ApJ, 461, L33 (astro-ph/9602061)
Group.
Tinsley, B. 1980, Fund. Cosmic Phys., 5, 287
4. Metallicity evolution for the halo and Local
Udalski, A. et al. 1994, Acta Astronomica, 44 165
White, S.D.M., Navarro, J.F.,Evrard, A.E., Frenk,
C.S. 1993, Nature, 366, 429
Zepf, S.E. & Silk, J. 1996, ApJ, 466, 114 (astro-
ph/9501166)
Zurek, W.H., Quinn, P.J. & Salmon, J.K. 1988, ApJ,
330. 519
Group.
5. Halo metallicity distribution. The points are
for globular clusters (Pagel 1988); only the low
metallicity members ([Z] < −1) are included in
the analysis. The theory (histogram) is binned
in the same way as the data, and normalized to
minimize χ2.
6. The halo white dwarf luminosity function, with
L in units of L⊙. Only results for halo white
dwarfs are shown. The two peaks correspond
to the two bursts of star formation; the more
luminous peak is the more recent burst at t = 5
Gyr. This second peak has MV >∼ 20, well below
current observational limits.
This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX
macros v4.0.
15
Hot
Intergalactic
Medium
Group wind
X-ray emitting
intra-group medium
Local
Group
Galactic infall
Galactic wind
Hot intercloud medium
cloud
wind
infall
Hot gas
cooling
ejecta
Star-forming cold
molecular gas
Protogalactic Clouds
Galactic
Halo
Halo stars
and remnants
Cloud
mergers
Survive
merging?
yes
Disk+Bulge
106
105
104
103
102
101
100
10-1
ψ (solar mass yr-1)
ncloud
0
5
10
15
t (Gyr)
1013
)
s
e
s
s
a
m
r
a
l
o
s
(
M
1012
1011
1010
109
0
total mass
gas mass
remnant mass
5
10
15
t (Gyr)
1014
)
s
e
s
s
a
m
l
r
a
o
s
(
M
1013
1012
1011
0
total mass
baryonic mass
gas mass
5
10
15
t (Gyr)
10-2
i
Z
10-3
10-4
cold gas
hot gas
halo
cluster
cloud stars
halo stars
0
5
10
15
t (Gyr)
15
10
5
]
Z
[
∆
/
N
∆
0
-3
-2
-1
0
[Z]
)
L
d
/
D
W
m
d
(
g
o
l
11.0
10.5
10.0
9.5
9.0
8.5
8.0
0
-1
-2
-3
-4
log (L)
-5
-6
-7
|
astro-ph/0307212 | 1 | 0307 | 2003-07-10T14:50:06 | Weak Gravitational Lensing by Large-Scale Structure | [
"astro-ph"
] | Weak gravitational lensing provides a unique method to map directly the distribution of dark matter in the universe and to measure cosmological parameters. This cosmic-shear technique is based on the measurement of the weak distortions that lensing induces in the shape of background galaxies as photons travel through large-scale structures. This technique is now widely used to measure the mass distribution of galaxy clusters and has recently been detected in random regions of the sky. In this review, we present the theory and observational status of cosmic shear. We describe the principles of weak lensing and the predictions for the shear statistics in favored cosmological models. Next, we review the current measurements of cosmic shear and show how they constrain cosmological parameters. We then describe the prospects offered by upcoming and future cosmic-shear surveys as well as the technical challenges that have to be met for the promises of cosmic shear to be fully realized. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Annual Reviews of Astronomy and Astrophysics 2003 – 41: 645–668
Copyright c(cid:13) 2003 by Annual Reviews (in press)
Weak Gravitational Lensing by
Large-Scale Structure
Alexandre Refregier
Service d’Astrophysique, CEA/Saclay, 91191 Gif sur Yvette, France;
email: [email protected]
KEYWORDS: Cosmology, Dark Matter, Cosmic Shear, Structure Formation, Statistics
ABSTRACT: Weak gravitational lensing provides a unique method to map directly the dis-
tribution of dark matter in the universe and to measure cosmological parameters. This cosmic-
shear technique is based on the measurement of the weak distortions that lensing induces in the
shape of background galaxies as photons travel through large-scale structures. This technique
is now widely used to measure the mass distribution of galaxy clusters and has recently been
detected in random regions of the sky. In this review, we present the theory and observational
status of cosmic shear. We describe the principles of weak lensing and the predictions for the
shear statistics in favored cosmological models. Next, we review the current measurements
of cosmic shear and show how they constrain cosmological parameters. We then describe the
prospects offered by upcoming and future cosmic-shear surveys as well as the technical challenges
that have to be met for the promises of cosmic shear to be fully realized.
1 INTRODUCTION
Gravitational lensing provides a unique method to directly map the distribution
of dark matter in the universe. It relies on the measurement of the distortions
that lensing induces in the images of background galaxies (for reviews, see Bartel-
mann & Schneider 1999, Bernardeau 1999, Kaiser 1999, Mellier 1999, Narayan &
Bartelmann 1996, Schneider 1995, Wittman 2002). This method is now widely
used to map the mass of clusters of galaxies (see Fort & Mellier 1994 for a review)
and has been extended to the study of superclusters (Gray et al. 2002, Kaiser et
al. 1998) and groups (Hoekstra et al. 2001). Recently, weak lensing was statisti-
cally detected for the first time in random patches of the sky (Brown et al. 2003;
Bacon et al. 2002; Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000; Hamana et al. 2003; Hammerle
et al. 2002; Hoekstra et al. 2002a; Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders 2002a; Jarvis et
al. 2002; Kaiser, Wilson & Luppino 2000; Maoli et al. 2001; Refregier, Rhodes,
& Groth 2002; Rhodes, Refregier & Groth 2001; van Waerbeke et al. 2000; van
Waerbeke et al. 2001a; van Waerbeke et al. 2002; Wittman et al. 2000). These
cosmic shear surveys provide direct measurements of large-scale structure in the
universe and, therefore, of the distribution of dark matter. Unlike other meth-
ods that probe the distribution of light, weak lensing measures the mass and
can thus be directly compared to reliable theoretical models of structure forma-
tion. Cosmic shear can therefore be used to measure cosmological parameters
in the context of these models, thereby opening wide prospects for cosmology
(Bernardeau, van Waerbeke & Mellier 1997; Hu & Tegmark 1999; Jain & Seljak
1
2
Refregier
Figure 1: Illustration of the effect of weak lensing by large-scale structure. The
photon tra jectories from distant galaxies (right) to the observer (left) are deflected
by intervening large-scale structure (center). This results in coherent distortions
in the observed shapes of the galaxies. These distortions, or shears, are on the
order of a few percent in amplitude and can be measured to yield a direct map
of the distribution of mass in the universe.
1997; Kaiser 1998).
In the present review, we describe the theoretical and observational status of
cosmic shear. Earlier reviews of this fast-evolving field can be found in Hoekstra
et al.
(2002b), Mellier et al.
(2001), van Waerbeke et al.
(2002), Wittman
(2002). Here, we first describe the principles of weak lensing (Section 2). We then
summarize the different statistics used to measure cosmic shear and describe how
they are used to constrain cosmological parameters (Section 3). In Section 4, we
survey the different methods used to derive the lensing shear from the shapes
of background galaxies. We present, in Section 5, the current observations and
their cosmological significance. Future cosmic-shear surveys and the prospects
they offer for cosmology are described in Section 6. In Section 7, we outline how
systematic effects present challenges that must be met for the potential of these
future surveys to be fully realized. We summarize our conclusions in Section 8.
2 THEORY
The idea of cosmic shear can be traced back to a lecture given by Richard Feyn-
man at Caltech in 1964 (J.E. Gunn, personal communication). Several theo-
rists (e.g., Gunn 1967, Jaroszy´nsky et al. 1990, Kristian & Sachs 1966, Lee &
Paczy´nsky 1990, Schneider & Weiss 1988) then studied the propagation of light
in an inhomogeneous universe. Predictions for the statistics of the weak-lensing
distortions were then computed in a modern cosmological context by several
groups (Babul & Lee 1991, Blandford et al. 1991, Kaiser 1992, Miralda-Escud´e
1991, Villumsen 1996). More recently, the power of cosmic shear to measure
cosmological parameters was the ob ject of many theoretical studies (Bernardeau,
van Waerbeke & Mellier 1997; Jain & Seljak 1997; Hu & Tegmark 1999; Kaiser
1998; Kamionkowski et al. 1997; van Waerbeke, Bernardeau & Mellier 1999). In
this section, we briefly describe the principles of weak lensing and show how this
technique can be used to map the dark matter in the universe.
As they travel from a background galaxy to the observer, photons get deflected
Weak Gravitational Lensing
3
γ 2
ε
2
ε
1
γ1
Figure 2:
Illustration of the geometrical meaning of the shear γi and of the
ellipticity ǫi . A positive (negative) shear component γ1 corresponds to an elon-
gation (compression) along the x-axis. A positive (negative) value of the shear
component γ2 corresponds to an elongation (compression) along the x = y axis.
The ellipticity of an ob ject is defined to vanish if the ob ject is circular (center).
The ellipticity components ǫ1 and ǫ2 correspond to compression and elongations
similar to those for the shear components.
by mass fluctuations along the line of sight (see Figure 1). As a result, the appar-
ent images of background galaxies are sub ject to a distortion that is characterized
by the distortion matrix:
Ψij ≡
∂ (δθi )
∂ θj
≡ (cid:18) κ + γ1
κ − γ1 (cid:19) ,
γ2
γ2
where δθi (θ) is the deflection vector produced by lensing on the sky. The conver-
gence κ is proportional to the pro jected mass along the line of sight and describes
overall dilations and contractions. The shear γ1 (γ2 ) describes stretches and com-
pressions along (at 45◦ from) the x-axis. Figure 2 illustrates the geometrical
meaning of the two shear components.
The distortion matrix is directly related to the matter density fluctuations
along the line of sight by
Ψij = Z χh
0
where Φ is the Newtonian potential, χ is the comoving distance, χh is the co-
moving distance to the horizon, and ∂i is the comoving derivative perpendicular
to the line of sight. The radial weight function g(χ) is given by
g(χ) = 2 Z χh
χ
where r = a−1DA , and DA is the angular-diameter distance. The function n(χ)
is the distribution of the galaxies as a function of the comoving distance χ from
the observer and is assumed to be normalized as R dχn(χ) = 1.
As we discuss in Section 4, galaxy shapes can be averaged over a patch of the sky
to measure the shear, which is thus an observable. The shear pattern expected in
r(χ)r(χ′ − χ)
r(χ′ )
dχ g(χ)∂i ∂j Φ,
dχ′ n(χ′ )
,
(1)
(2)
(3)
4
Refregier
Figure 3: Shear map derived by ray-tracing simulations by Jain, Seljak & White
(2000). The size and direction of each line gives the amplitude and position angle
of the shear at this location on the sky. The displayed region is 1◦ × 1◦ for an
SCDM (Einstein-De Sitter) model. Tangential patterns about the overdensities
corresponding to clusters and groups of galaxies are apparent. A more complex
network of patterns is also visible outside of these structures. The root-mean-
square shear is approximately 2% in this map. (From Jain et al. 2000)
a standard Cold Dark Matter (SCDM) model is shown in Figure 3 for a 1 × 1 deg2
region. Jain, Seljak, & White (2000) derived this map from ray tracing through
N-body simulations. Tangential patterns around the overdensities corresponding
to clusters and groups of galaxies, along with a more complicated network of shear
fluctuations, are apparent. By inverting the lensing equation (Equation 2), the
shear map can be converted into a map of the pro jected mass κ and, therefore,
of the dark matter distribution.
3 COSMIC-SHEAR STATISTICS AND COSMOLOGY
The statistical characteristics of the cosmic-shear field can be quantified using a
variety of measures, which can then be used to constrain cosmological models.
First, we consider the most basic two-point statistic of the shear field, namely the
two-dimensional power spectrum (Jain & Seljak 1997, Kaiser 1998, Kamionkowski
et al. 1997, Schneider et al. 1998a). The shear power spectrum Cl is defined as a
function of multipole moment l (or inverse angular scale) by P2
i=1 h eγi (l) eγi (l′ )i =
(2π)2 δ(l − l′ )Cl , where tildes denote Fourier transforms (with the conventions of
Bacon, Refregier, & Ellis 2000), δ is the two-dimensional Dirac-delta function, and
Weak Gravitational Lensing
5
Figure 4: Shear power spectrum for different cosmological models and for source
galaxies at zs = 1. The SCDM model is COBE normalized and thus has a higher
amplitude than the three cluster-normalized models ΛCDM, OCDM, and τ CDM.
The thin dashed line shows the ΛCDM spectrum for linear evolution of structures.
Notice that for l > 1000 (corresponding approximately to angular scales θ < 10′ )
the lensing power spectrum is dominated by nonlinear structures.
(4)
Cl =
the brackets denote an ensemble average. Applying Limber’s equation in Fourier
space (e.g., Kaiser 1998) to Equation 2 and using the Poisson equation, one can
easily express the shear power spectrum Cl in terms of the three-dimensional
power spectrum P (k , χ) of the mass fluctuations δρ/ρ and obtain
dχ (cid:20) g(χ)
, χ(cid:19) ,
ar(χ) (cid:21)2
16 (cid:18) H0
c (cid:19)4
P (cid:18) l
m Z χh
9
Ω2
r
0
where a is the expansion parameter, and H0 and Ωm are the present value of
the Hubble constant and matter density parameter, respectively. The lensing
power spectra for four CDM models are shown in Figure 4 (see color insert)
(see Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000 for the exact cosmological parameter values
of each model). They were derived using the fitting formula for the nonlinear
matter power spectrum P (k , χ) of Peacock & Dodds (1996).
In Figure 4, the
galaxies were assumed to lie on a sheet at a redshift zs = 1. A more realistic
redshift distribution n(z ) would require corrections of only approximately 10%
on these power spectra, as long as the median redshift of the galaxies were kept
at zs = 1.
The three cluster-normalized models (ΛCDM, OCDM and τ CDM) yield power
spectra of similar amplitudes but with different shapes. The COBE-normalized
SCDM model has more power on a small scale and thus yields a larger normal-
ization. For the ΛCDM model, the power spectrum corresponding to a linear
evolution of structures is also shown in Figure 4 for comparison. For l >
∼ 1000
6
Refregier
(corresponding to angular scales smaller than approximately 10’), nonlinear cor-
rections dominate the power spectrum (Jain & Seljak 1997), making cosmic-shear
sensitive to gravitational instability processes.
The measurement of the lensing power spectrum can thus be used to measure
cosmological parameters, such as Ωm , ΩΛ , σ8 , and Γ. (Bernardeau, van Waerbeke
& Mellier 1997; Hu & Tegmark 1999; Jain & Seljak 1997; Kaiser 1998; van Waer-
beke, Bernardeau & Mellier 1999). A full-sky cosmic-shear survey would yield
a precision of these parameters comparable to that for future cosmic microwave
background (CMB) missions. More realistically for the short term, a precision
on the order of 10% can be achieved with surveys of approximately 10 square
degrees. Such cosmic-shear surveys can also be combined with CMB anisotropy
measurements to break degeneracies present when the CMB is considered alone
(Hu & Tegmark 1999; Contaldi, Hoekstra & Lewis 2003). This would yield im-
provements in the precision of cosmological parameters by approximately one
order of magnitude. In addition, the use of photometric redshifts can provide
a tomographic measurement of matter fluctuations and improve the precision of
cosmological parameters by up to an order of magnitude (Hu 1999, Hu & Keeton
2002, Taylor 2001).
In practice, it often is more convenient to measure other two-point statistics.
γ ≡ hγ 2 i in randomly placed cells is
In particular, the variance of the shear σ2
widely used. It is related to the shear power spectrum by
2π Z ∞
dl lCl (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)fWl (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
1
2
σ2
,
(5)
γ =
0
where fWl is the Fourier transform of the cell aperture. The shear two-point cor-
relation functions (eg. Kaiser 1998) are Fourier transforms of the power spectra
and have also been measured by various groups (eg. Bacon et al. 2002; van
Waerbeke et al. 2001a; Hoekstra et al. 2002a). The Map statistics (Schneider et
al. 1998a) is another convenient statistic based on the average of the shear within
a compensated filter. Its advantages are that its window function in l-space is
narrow, that adjacent cells are effectively uncorrelated, and that it can be easily
related to the statistics of the pro jected mass κ.
In analogy with electromagnetism, a tensor field like the shear field γi can
be decomposed into an electric (E, or gradient) component and a magnetic (B,
or curl) component (Crittenden et al. 2001b, Kaiser 1992, Kamionkowski et al.
1997, Stebbins 1996). Because the distortions it induces arise from a scalar field
(the gravitational potential), weak lensing only produces E-type fluctuations. On
the other hand, systematic effects and intrinsic galaxy alignments are likely to
produce both E-type and B-type fluctuations (See Heavens 2001 for a review;
also see Section 7.6). The presence of B-modes can thus be used as a measure of
contaminants to the cosmic-shear signal. In practice, this decomposition can be
performed using the Map statistic (Schneider et al. 1998a, van Waerbeke et al.
2001a) or the power spectrum (Hu & White 2000, Padmanabhan, Seljak & Pen
2002, Pen et al. 2001).
As is apparent in Figure 3, the shear field is not Gaussian but, instead, has
apparent coherent structures. Bernardeau, van Waerbeke, & Mellier (1997) have
shown that the skewness
hκ3 i
hκ2 i2
of the convergence field κ can be used to break the degeneracy between σ8 and
S3 =
(6)
Weak Gravitational Lensing
7
Ωm , which is present when the shear variance alone is considered. The measure-
ment of higher-point statistics is thus of great cosmological interest, but their
computation is made difficult by the fact that the angular scales accessible to
∼ 10′ ) are in the nonlinear regime. Predictions for higher-point cor-
obervation (θ <
relation functions have been calculated using perturbation theory, the hierarchi-
cal ansatz, (Bernardeau & Valageas 2000; Bernardeau, van Waerbeke & Mellier
1997; Hui 1999; Munshi & Coles 2000; Munshi & Jain 2001; van Waerbeke et
al. 2001b) and halo models (Cooray & Hu 2001a; Cooray, Hu, & Miralda-Escud´e
2000). These techniques have also been used to compute the full probability dis-
tribution function of the convergence field (Bernardeau & Valageas 2000, Munshi
& Jain 2000, Valageas 2000) and the errors in two-point statistics (Cooray & Hu
2001b; Munshi & Coles 2002; Schneider et al. 2002).
Another possible way to compute the full nonlinear field is to use ray tracing
through N-body simulations (Blandford et al. 1991; Hamana, Colombi & Mellier
2000; Jain, Seljak & White 2000; Premadi et al. 2001; Wambsganss, Cen, &
Ostriker 1998; White & Hu 2000) to produce simulated shear maps such as those
by Jain, Seljak & White (2000) (shown in Figure 3). These can be used to
compute and study other proposed measures of non-Gaussianity such as peak
statistics (Jain & van Waerbeke 2000), a generalized maximum likelihood (Taylor
& Watts 2000), and cluster counts (Bartelmann, King & Schneider 2001).
In
practice, the complex geometry of surveys makes it difficult to infer a convergence
κ map from the observed shear γi . For this reason, a number of researchers have
recently proposed the use of high-order statistics of the shear field rather than
the skewness S3 of the convergence (Bernardeau, van Waerbeke, & Mellier 2003;
Schneider & Lombardi 2002; Takada & Jain 2002; Zaldarriaga & Scoccimarro
2002).
4 SHEAR MEASUREMENT METHODS
Because the sought-after lensing signal is of only a few percent in amplitude, the
data acquisition and analysis must be performed carefully, and systematic effects
must be tightly controlled. All the current measurements of cosmic shear were
derived from deep optical images taken with charged-coupled devices (CCD). It
is advantageous for the exposures to be homogeneous in depth and for the ground
to be sub ject to as small a seeing as possible. The fields are generally chosen to
lie far away from each other to ensure that they are statistically independent and
to minimize cosmic variance.
The first step in the data analysis is image processing. After flat fielding,
the different exposures are co-added to produce the final reduced images.
If
necessary, any instrumental distortion induced by the telescope optics is corrected
for at this stage. This can be done very accurately by measuring the astrometric
offsets from several dithered exposures. For a detailed description of the different
image-processing steps, see Kaiser et al. (1999). An example of a processed deep
image from the cosmic-shear survey of Bacon, Refregier & Ellis (2000) is shown
in Figure 5.
The next step consists of deriving an estimator for the shear from the shapes
of the galaxies in the co-added images. The point-spread function (PSF), which
smears the images of galaxies and is generally not circular, complicates this task.
In general, the PSF varies spatially and in time, and it must be measured and
8
Refregier
Figure 5: Example of an deep image in the cosmic-shear survey by Bacon, Re-
fregier & Ellis (2000). This corresponds to a 1 h exposure with the EEV camera
on the William Herschel Telescope (WHT). The field of view is 8′ × 16′ and
achieves a magnitude depth of R ≃ 26 (5σ detection). The bright ob jects are
saturated stars. The faint ob jects comprise approximately 200 stars and approxi-
mately 2000 galaxies that are usable for the weak-lensing analysis. (From Bacon,
Refregier & Ellis 2000)
Weak Gravitational Lensing
9
modelled for each image individually. This can be done by measuring the shape
of the stars in the field, whose number can be optimized by tuning the galactic
latitudes of the observations. Figure 6 shows the ellipticity pattern of the PSF
from one of the William Hershel telescope (WHT) fields of Bacon, Refregier &
Ellis 2000.
Several methods have been developed to tackle this difficult and crucial task.
The more rigorous method of Kaiser, Squires & Broadhurst (KSB; 1995), further
developed by Luppino & Kaiser (1997) and Hoekstra et al. (1998), replaced the
earlier method by Bonnet & Mellier (1995). The KSB method is now widely used
for cluster studies, and it has been used by the ma jority of the groups involved in
measuring cosmic shear (see Bartelmann & Schneider 1999 for a detailed review
of the KSB method). It is based on the measurement of the quadrupole moment
of the galaxy surface brightness I (x),
Qij ≡ Z d2xxixj w(x)I (x),
where w(x) is a weight function conveniently taken to be Gaussian. These mo-
ments capture the lowest-order shape information of the galaxy and can be com-
bined to form the ellipticity of the galaxy
(7)
ǫ1 =
Q11 − Q22
Q11 + Q22
,
ǫ2 =
2Q12
Q11 + Q22
.
(8)
The first (second) component of the ellipticity describes compressions and elon-
gations along (at 45◦ from) the x and y axes (see Figure 2 for an illustration).
The ellipticity vanishes for circular galaxies.
The first step in the KSB method is to correct the observed galaxy ellipticity
ǫg ′
for the anisotropy of the PSF. The corrected galaxy ellipticity ǫg is given by
i
ǫg = ǫg ′ − P g
sm )−1 ǫ∗ ,
sm (P ∗
(9)
where ǫ∗ is the PSF ellipticity derived from the stars, and P g
sm and P ∗
sm are the
smear susceptibility tensors for the galaxy and star, respectively, and can be
derived from higher moments of the images. The shear in a patch of the sky can
then be measured by averaging over the (corrected) ellipticities in the patch of
the sky using
γ = (Pγ )−1 hǫg i,
(10)
where the tensor Pγ quantifies the susceptibility to shear acting before isotropic
PSF smearing and is given by
Pγ = P g
sm )−1P g
sh (P ∗
sh − P ∗
sm ,
(11)
where the shear susceptibility tensors P g
sh and P ∗
sh for the galaxies and the stars
can also be measured from higher moments of their respective light distribution.
The KSB method was thoroughly tested using realistic simulated images by
Erben et al. (2001) and Bacon et al. (2001a). These studies showed that it is
accurate to within a few tenths of percent in reconstructing an input shear and
is thus sufficient for the current cosmic-shear surveys (see Section 5). However,
this accuracy is insufficient for future, more sensitive surveys (see Section 6).
Moreover, Kuijken (1999) and Kaiser (2000) have shown that the KSB method
is ill-defined mathematically and unstable for PSF’s found in practice.
10
Refregier
Figure 6: PSF ellipticity pattern measured in WHT field shown in the Figure 5:
(a) PSF ellipticities measured from the stars in Figure 5. (b) Ellipticity residuals
for those stars after the KSB corrections. In this survey, the root-mean-square
stellar ellipticity is found to be approximately 7% before the corrections and
negligible after the correction. (From Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000)
.
This inadequacy has led a number of researchers to develop alternative meth-
ods. Rhodes, Refregier & Groth (2000) have modified the KSB method to be
better suited for HST images. Kuijken (1999) considered a different approach
that consisted of fitting the observed galaxy shape with a smeared and sheared
circular model. Kaiser (2000) introduced a new method based on a finite resolu-
tion shear operator. Refregier & Bacon (2003) and, independently, Bernstein &
Jarvis (2001) developed a new method based on the decomposition of the galaxies
into shape components or “shapelets”. The gauss-hermite orthogonal basis func-
tions used in this approach allow shears and PSF convolutions to be described as
simple matrix operations, using the formalism developped for the quantum har-
monic oscillator (Refregier 2003). These new methods are promising but require
extensive testing to establish whether they will achieve the required precision.
5 OBSERVATIONS
Because the expected distortions are only of a few percent, the measurement
of cosmic shear requires large survey areas and excellent image quality. Early
searches for cosmic shear signals with photographic plates were unsuccesful (Kris-
tian 1967; Valdes, Jarvis & Tyson 1983). Mould et al. (1994), performed the
first attempt to detect a cosmic-shear signal with CCDs, but only derived an
upper limit. Using the same data, Villumsen (1995) reported a 4.5σ detection.
Schneider et al. (1998b) then reported a detection of cosmic shear in one of three
QSO fields, an area too small to draw any constraints on cosmology.
Within a few weeks, four independent groups (Bacon, Refregier & Ellis 2000;
Weak Gravitational Lensing
11
Kaiser, Wilson & Luppino 2000; van Waerbeke et al. 2000; Wittman et al. 2000)
reported the first firm statistical detections of cosmic shear using three different
4m-class telescopes: the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO), the
Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT), and the William Herschel Telescope
(WHT). These were later confirmed by more precise measurements of the cosmic-
shear amplitude from the ground (Bacon et al. 2002; Brown et al. 2003; Maoli et
al. 2001; Hamana et al. 2003; Hoekstra et al. 2002a; Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders
2002a; Jarvis et al. 2002; van Waerbeke et al. 2001; van Waerbeke et al. 2002a)
using 2-m – (MPG/ESO), 4-m– (WHT, CFHT, CTIO) and 8-m– (Very Large
Telescope, Keck, Subaru) class ground-based telescopes. Meanwhile, cosmic shear
was also detected (Hammerle et al. 2002; Rhodes, Refregier & Groth 2001) and
measured (Refregier, Rhodes & Groth 2002) from space using HST. Space-based
surveys are currently limited by the small field of view of HST, but they are deeper
and less prone to systematics thanks to the absence of atmospheric seeing.
Table 1 summarizes the existing cosmic-shear surveys and highlights the wide
range of telescopes, survey areas, and depths. The shear variance σ2
γ (Equation 5)
measured recently by several groups is shown in Figure 7 (see color insert) as a
function of the radius a circular cell. The results by Hammerle et al.
(2002)
and Hamana et al. (2002a) are not displayed. Note that, for the shear variance,
the data points at different angular scales are not independent. For comparison,
the shear variance predicted for a ΛCDM model with σ8 = 1 is also shown in
Figure 7. The model is displayed for median galaxy redshifts of zm from 0.8 to
1.0, corresponding approximately to the range of depths of the top five surveys
displayed (van Waerbeke et al. 2002a; Brown et al. 2003; Bacon et al. 2002,
WHT and Keck; Refregier et al. 2002). These observations are approximately
consistent with each other and with the ΛCDM model on angular scales from 0.7
to 20 arcmins. This is compelling given that these were performed with different
telescopes (and therefore different instrumental systematics) and independent
data-analysis pipelines.
The bottom two surveys (Hoekstra et al. 2002b; Jarvis et al. 2002) have a
median redshift in the range zm ≃ 0.6–0.7 and yield lower shear variances. As
indicated by the theoretical curves in figure 7, this redshift dependence is expected
in CDM models and thus confirms the detection of a cosmic shear signal.
Although the shear variance was displayed for the purpose of Figure 7, some
of the groups have used instead the shear correlation function or Map statistic
to quantify their lensing signal. Recently, several groups used the latter statistic
to separate their signal into E and B components (see Section 3) and thus to
estimate and subtract systematic effects (Jarvis et al. 2002; Hamana et al. 2003;
Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders 2002; van Waerbeke et al. 2001, 2002a). Pen, van
Waerbeke & Mellier (2001) and Brown et al. (2003) chose instead to measure
directly the shear power spectrum for each E and B mode. Figure 8a shows
the measurement of the E and B signals using the Map statistic by Hoekstra,
Yee & Gladders (2002a), for several Rc -magnitude ranges in the Red-Sequence
Cluster (RCS) survey. They measure a clear lensing signal apparent as E modes.
However, the significant B modes reveals the presence of residual systematics
∼ 10′ ), especially for bright galaxies.
on small scales (θ <
In their analysis, these
authors use the amplitude of the B modes as a measure systematic uncertainties.
Existing cosmic-shear measurements already yield interesting constraints on
the amplitude of the matter power spectrum σ8 on which the lensing signal
strongly depends. For instance, Figure 8b shows cosmological constraints for
12
Refregier
Figure 7: Shear variance σ2
γ as a function of the radius θ of a circular cell. The
data points correspond to recent results from different groups: van Waerbeke et
al. (2002a), Brown et al. (2003), Bacon et al. (2002, WHT and Keck), Refregier
et al. (2002), Hoekstra et al. (2002b), Jarvis et al. (2002). When relevant, the
inner error bars correspond to noise only, whereas the outer error bars correspond
to the total error (noise + cosmic variance). The measurements by Hammerle
et al.
(2003) are not displayed. The solid curves
(2002) and Hamana et al.
show the predictions for a ΛCDM model with Ωm = 0.3, σ8 = 1, and Γ = 0.21.
The galaxy median redshift was taken to be zm = 1.0, 0.9, and 0.8, from top to
bottom, respectively, corresponding approximately to the range of depth of the
top five surveys. The bottom two surveys (Hoekstra et al. 2002b; Jarvis et al.
2002) have a median redshift in the range zm ≃ 0.6–0.7 and, as expected, yield
lower shear variances.
Weak Gravitational Lensing
13
Figure 8: Cosmic shear measurement by Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders (2002a) from
the RCS survey. (a): measurement of the E (top panels) and B (bottom panels)
modes of the Map statistics variance as a function of aperture scale θ . Several
ranges of the Rc -magnitude are considered. The errors correspond to 1σ sta-
tistical uncertainties. The presence of significant B Modes reveal the presence
of residual systematics on small scales (θ ≤ 10′ ). (b): Cosmological constraints
derived from their measurement of the E -mode Map statistics for 22 < Rc < 24
after accounting for the residual B -modes. The joint constraints are shown for
Ωm and σ8 in the ΛCDM model. Priors from CMB and galaxy surveys were used
to marginalize over Ωtot , Γ, and the source redshift zs . The contours indicate
68.3%, 95.4%, and 99.9% confidence levels.
(From Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders
2002a)
14
Refregier
Table 1: current cosmic-shear surveys
Area (deg2 ) Mag. limit
Telescope
Reference
R <
CTIO
1.0
∼ 26
Wittman et al. 2000
1.7
CFHT
van Waerbeke et al. 2000
0.96
CFHT
Kaiser et al. 2000
0.5
WHT
Bacon et al. 2000
VLT
0.65
Maoli et al. 2001
0.05
Rhodes et al. 2001
HST/WFPC2
6.5
van Waerbeke et al. 2001a CFHT
Hammerle et al. 2002
HST/STIS
0.02
Hoekstra et al. 2002a
CFHT, CTIO 24
8.5
van Waerbeke et al. 2002a CFHT
0.36
HST/WFPC2
Refregier et al. 2002
WHT, Keck
Bacon et al. 2002
1.6
Hoekstra et al. 2002b
CFHT, CTIO 53
1.25
MPG/ESO
Brown et al. 2003
2.1
Subaru
Hamana et al. 2003
Jarvis et al. 2002
CTIO
75
R <
∼ 24
I <
∼ 24.5
hI i ≃ 23.5
R <
∼ 26
R <
∼ 24
R <
∼ 25
R <
∼ 26
R <
∼ 23
I <
∼ 24, V <
∼ 25
R <
∼ 26
I <
∼ 24.5
I <
∼ 26
I <
∼ 24.5
a
σ8
1.50+0.50
−0.50
1.03+0.03
−0.03
0.91+0.25
−0.30
0.88+0.02
−0.02
b
c
0.81+0.07
−0.09
0.98+0.06
−0.06
0.94+0.14
−0.14
0.97+0.13
−0.13
0.86+0.04
−0.05
0.72+0.09
−0.09
0.69+0.18
−0.13
0.71+0.06
−0.08
a for ΛCDM model with Ωm = 0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7; Γ is marginalised over or set to 0.21 when possible;
errors correspond to 68%CL
b for combination of Maoli et al. (2001), van Waerbeke et al. (2000), Bacon et al. (2000), and
Wittman et al. (2000); cosmic variance not included.
c cosmic variance not included.
a ΛCDM model derived by Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders (2002a) from the measure-
ment of the Map statistic for their 22 < Rc < 24 galaxy sample. The degeneracy
between σ8 and Ωm apparent in the figure is typical of cosmic-shear measurements
involving only two-point statistics. Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders (2002a) found that
m = 0.46+0.05
the constraints are well described by σ8Ω0.52
−0.07 (95% CL), where priors
from CMB and galaxy survey data have been used to marginalize over Γ and ΩΛ .
Other surveys find constraints of the same form with similar exponents for Ωm .
Table 1 lists the values of σ8 found by the different groups. The errors have
been converted to 68% confidence level (CL) when necessary, and values of Ωm =
0.3, ΩΛ = 0.7, and Γ = 0.21 have been assumed, when possible. The most
recent values are displayed in Figure 9 (see color insert), along with their average
σ8 ≃ 0.83 ± 0.04 (1σ). The values derived by the different cosmic shear groups
are in the range σ8 ≃ 0.7–1.0, with the most recent measurements (Brown et al.
2003; Hamana et al. 2003; Jarvis et al. 2002) yielding lower values. The 2–3σ
mutual inconsistencies between some of the measurements may be symptomatic of
a small level of residual systematics. In particular, calibration errors in the shear
measurement method would not be detected via the E -B decomposition and are
a likely explanation (see Hirata & Seljak 2003). Another source of discrepancy
arises from the different fitting functions for the non-linear evolution of the power
spectrum (see section 2). Apart from Brown et al. (2003; see also Contaldi et al.
2003) who used the more accurate results of Smith et al. (2003), the other groups
used the Peacock & Dodds (1997) fitting function which yields an underprediction
of σ8 by roughly 5–10%. The impact of these systematics will be discussed further
in section 7.
Weak Gravitational Lensing
15
Figure 9: Comparison of the determination of σ8 by different groups and methods.
The errors have all been converted to 1σ , and a ΛCDM model with Ωm = 0.3 and
Γ = 0.21 was assumed when possible. The vertical dotted lines show the average
σ8 ≃ 0.83 ± 0.04 of the seven cosmic-shear measurements and associated 1σ error.
The normalization from cluster abundance (e.g., Pierpaoli et al. 2002) as well as
that derived from CMB anisotropies and local large-scale structure (galaxy and
Lyman α surveys; Spergel et al. 2003) are also shown.
Interestingly, an independent measurement of σ8 is provided by the abun-
dance of X-ray clusters and can be directly compared to this value. Initially, this
method yielded normalisations of σ8 ∼ 0.9 (Eke et al. 1998; Pierpaoli, Scott &
White 2001; Viana & Liddle 1999), in agreement with the early cosmic shear re-
sults (see table 1 and figure 9). This value was subsequently revised downward to
σ8 ∼ 0.7–0.8 by the use of the observed, rather than simulated, mass-temperature
relation in clusters (Borgani et al. 2001; Reiprich & Bohringer 2001; Seljak 2001;
Viana, Nichol & Liddle 2001; Pierpaoli, Scott & White 2002). Recently, Spergel
et al. (2003) derived a value of σ8 = 0.84 ± 0.04 (68%CL) from a joint analy-
sis of CMB anisotropy measurements from the Wilkinson Microwave Anistropy
Probe (WMAP) and other experiments, galaxy clustering and the Lyman α for-
est. For comparison, these results along with a representative value of the revised
cluster-abundance normalization (Pierpaoli, Scott & White 2002) are also shown
in figure 9. The average of the cosmic shear results is formally in good agreement
with the determination of σ8 using the other techniques. Future surveys are how-
ever needed to confirm this, by resolving the discrepancies between the current
cosmic shear measurements. Also, a full likelihood analysis would be required
to establish the significance of the agreement between the different techniques
(see Contaldi et al. 2003). This comparison is important as it provides a strong
test of the ΛCDM model, the gravitational instability paradigm, the physics of
clusters, and of the biased formation of galaxies.
As discussed in Section 3, the degeneracy between σ8 and Ωm can be broken
by measuring higher-order correlation functions of the lensing field. Bernardeau,
16
Refregier
Mellier, & van Waerbeke (2002) recently reported the first detection of a non-
Gaussian shear signal using the 3-point shear correlation function formalism of
Bernardeau, van Waerbeke & Mellier (2003). Another measure of non-gaussianity
was recently performed by Miyazaki et al. (2002) using peak statistics in their
Subaru survey. Although these results are consistent with that expected from
structure formation models, larger survey areas are needed to infer cosmological
constraints.
Another approach to probe the dark matter is to measure the bias between
the mass and galaxies by cross-correlating the shear map with that of the light
from foreground galaxies in the same region of the sky (Cooray 2002, Schneider
1998, van Waerbeke 1998). Hoekstra, Yee & Gladders (2001a), Hoekstra et al.
(2002b), and Wilson, Kaiser & Luppino (2001) have recently measured this cross-
correlation on large scales.
6 FUTURE SURVEYS AND PROSPECTS
The existing measurements described above are primarily limited by statistics.
They will therefore be improved upon by ongoing surveys on existing telescopes,
such as the Legacy Survey on CFHT (CFHTLS; Mellier et al. 2000), the Deep
Lens Survey (Wittman et al. 2002), surveys with the Subaru telescope (Hiroyasu
et al. 2001) and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Stebbins, McKay & Frieman 1995).
Future instruments dedicated to surveys and for which cosmic shear is a primary
science driver are being planned, such as Megacam on CFHT (Boulade et al.
2000), the Visible and Infrared Survey Telescope for Astronomy (VISTA; Taylor
et al. 2003), the Large aperture Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST; Tyson et al.
2002a,b), or the novel Panoramic Survey Telescope and Rapid Response System
(Pan-STARRS; Kaiser, Tonry & Luppino 2000). From space, the new Advanced
Camera for Surveys (ACS) on HST and, much more ambitiously, the future
Supernova Acceleration Probe satellite (SNAP; Perlmutter et al. 2003; Rhodes
et al. 2003; Massey et al. 2003; Refregier et al. 2003) also offer exciting prospects.
Table 2 lists the characteristics of some of these future surveys. Broadly speaking,
ground-based measurements will cover large areas, whereas space-based surveys
will yield higher-resolution maps and reduced systematics thanks to the absence
of atmospheric seeing.
Radio surveys offer another interesting prospect. Ongoing efforts are aimed at
detecting cosmic shear with the FIRST radio survey (Chang & Refregier 2002,
Kamionkowski et al. 1997, Refregier et al. 1998). The future radio telescopes
LOFAR (Low Frequency Array) and SKA (Square Kilometer Array) will yield
cosmic-shear measurements of comparable sensitivity to the most ambitious op-
tical surveys (Schneider 1999). The advantages of radio surveys are that they
cover large solid angles, that the bright radio sources are at a higher redshift,
and that the PSF is fully predictable and reproducible.
These future surveys will provide very accurate measurements of cosmolog-
ical parameters through the measurement of the lensing power spectrum and
higher-order statistics. Figure 10 (see color insert) shows, for instance, the ex-
cellent accuracy with which the lensing power spectrum will be measured with
the SNAP wide survey. They will also allow us to test some of the foundations
of the standard cosmological model. For example, the measurement of the power
spectrum on nonlinear scales at different redshift slices, and of the hierarchy of
Weak Gravitational Lensing
17
Table 2: Future cosmic-shear surveys
Area
Telescope/Survey Ground/Space Diameter FOV
(deg2 )
(deg2 )
(m)
28
2 × 0.3
2 × 4
ground
DLS
172
1
3.6
ground
CFHTLS
x100d
1
2.6
ground
VST
VISTAe
4
2
10000
ground
31000
4 × 4
4 × 1.8
ground
Pan-STARRS
30000
7
8.4
ground
LSST
SNAP
2
0.7
300
space
a planned start date of the cosmic shear surveys
b references: 1: Wittman et al. 2002; 2: Mellier et al. 2000; 3: Kuijken et al. 2002; 4: Taylor et al.
2003; 5: Kaiser et al. 2000; 6: Tyson et al. 2002a,b; 7: Perlmutter et al. 2003, Rhodes et al. 2003,
Massey et al. 2003, Refregier et al. 2003
c the survey will be complete in 2003
d a survey of several 100 deg2 is planned
e assuming the availability of the optical camera
1999c
2003
2004
2007
2008
2012
2011
Starta Ref.b
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
high-order correlation functions, will yield a direct test of the gravitational in-
stability paradigm. The lensing power spectrum can also be used to measure
the equation of the state of the dark energy w and thus complement supernovae
measurements in the constraining of quintessence models (Benabed & Bernardeau
2001; Hui 1999; Huterer 2001; Hu 2001, 2002; Munshi & Wang 2002; Weinberg
& Kamionkowski 2002). Figure 10 shows, for instance, that a change of 40% in
w can easily be measured by SNAP (see Refregier et al. 2003). Cosmic-shear
measurements can also be used to test general relativity (Uzan & Bernardeau
2001).
Another promising approach to measure weak lensing is to use the fluctuations
of the CMB temperature as the background sources (Bernardeau 1997, 1998;
Cooray & Kesden 2002; Hirata & Seljak 2002; Hu 2000; Seljak 1996; Seljak &
Zaldarriaga 1999; Zaldarriaga & Seljak 1998). Because these fluctuations are
produced at a redshift of approximately 1100, CMB lensing provides a probe of
the evolution of mass fluctuations at redshifts larger than those probed by optical
galaxies. Lensing indeed produces distinct non-Gaussian signatures that can be
used to reconstruct the foreground mass distribution and probe the growth of
structures. This approach will become feasible with the advent of future CMB
missions such as Planck Surveyor or ground-based instruments with high angular
resolutions.
7 CHALLENGE: SYSTEMATIC EFFECTS
For the future surveys described above to yield their full potential, a number of
challenges must be met. Indeed, these surveys require the measurement of shears
on the order of 1% with an accuracy better than 0.1%; thus, they require a very
tight control of systematic effects. In the following, we review the main sources
of systematics.
18
Refregier
Figure 10: Prospects for the measurement of the weak-lensing power spectrum
with future weak-lensing surveys. The solid line represents the lensing power
spectrum of a ΛCDM model with Ωm = 0.3 (and an equation of state w = −1).
The boxes correspond to the band-averaged 1σ errors for the SNAP wide survey
(300 deg2 , 100 galaxies per arcmin2 with a root-mean-square intrinsic ellipticity
dispersion of σǫ = 0.31). The precision is highest in the nonlinear region [see
the linear ΛCDM power spectrum (dotted line)] and will thus provide a test of
the gravitational instability paradigm. This model can easily be distinguished
from models that differ from it by a 17% change in Ωm (dashed line) or by a 40%
change in the dark-energy equation of state w (dot-dashed line).
Weak Gravitational Lensing
7.1 PSF Anisotropy
19
The most serious systematic for ground-based surveys is that produced by the
rather large PSF ellipticities (∼ 10%) observed by the different groups. The
KSB method (see Section 4) provides a correction of the PSF anisotropy by, at
most, a factor of approximately 10, which is insufficient for a precision of 0.1%
in shear. Although new shear measurement methods may improve upon this (see
Section 4 and below), the correction is fundamentally limited by the finite surface
density and signal-to-noise ratio of the stars used to measure the PSF shape. It
is, therefore, necessary for the PSF ellipticity to be reduced in hardware as well
as in software. This can be done by using tighter constraints in the tracking and
optical systems of the new telescopes and instruments as well as with interactions
between telescope designers, engineers, and scientists.
7.2 Shear Measurement Method
Even if the PSF ellipticity were guaranteed to be isotropic, future measurements
will be limited by the precision of the shear measurement methods. The KSB
method is accurate to measure shears of approximately 1% with only a 10%
accuracy (Bacon et al. 2001, Erben et al. 2001). This will soon become an
important limiting factor (see Hirata & Seljak 2003). Although new methods
(see Section 4) promise to improve upon this, more extensive simulations are
required to establish that the same accuracy can be reached for shears of 0.1%.
7.3 Redshift Distribution
To convert cosmic-shear measurements into constraints on cosmological param-
eters, the redshift distribution of the background galaxies must be known (see
Section 4). The uncertainty in the median galaxy redshift is already one of the
dominant contributions to the uncertainty in the amplitude of the matter power
spectrum from cosmic shear. The determination of the galaxy redshift distribu-
tion is made difficult by the depth of the cosmic-shear surveys. In addition, the
sample of galaxies is not simply magnitude limited, but it is sub ject to complex
selection cuts throughout the shear measurement pipeline. Dedicated spectro-
scopic surveys and photometric redshift studies (such as that by Brown et al.
2003) are thus required to overcome this limitation.
7.4 CCD Nonlinearities
All the shear measurement methods rely on the assumption that the instrumental
response is linear. It is therefore important to test whether CCD cameras do not
have subtle pixel-to-pixel nonlinearities that would induce biases in the shear
measurements. The mean shear offset and the shear gradient across the chip
found by van Waerbeke et al. (2001) could be due to this effect.
7.5 Overlapping Isophotes
Two neighboring galaxies in an image yield ”peanut-shaped” isophotal contours
and thus appear to have aligned ellipticities. This overlapping-ellipticities effect
may produce a spurious ellipticity correlation signal on small scales. van Waer-
beke et al. (2000) suggested that this effect may explain the excess shear signal,
20
Refregier
which they measured on small scale and which disappeared when close pairs were
discarded. Evidence for this effect was also found in the image simulation by Ba-
con et al. (2001). More extensive and detailed simulations would need to be
performed to ascertain and calibrate this effect.
7.6 Intrinsic Correlations
The measurement of the lensing shear relies on the assumptions that, in the ab-
sence of lensing, the ellipticities of the galaxies are uncorrelated. However, an
intrinsic correlation of galaxy shapes could exist owing to the coupling of the
galaxy angular momentum or shape to the tidal field or to galaxy interactions
(see Heavens 2001 for a review). Theoretical estimation of the size of this effect
has been performed using numerical simulations (Croft & Metzler 2000; Heav-
ens, Refregier & Heymans 2000; Jing 2002) and analytical methods (Catalan,
Kamionkowski & Blandford 2001; Crittenden et al. 2001a,b; Lee & Pen 2001;
Mackey, White & Kamionkowski 2001). Measurements of intrinsic correlations
have also been performed (Brown et al. 2000; Pen, Lee & Seljak 2000). Although
considerable uncertainty remains regarding the amplitude of this effect, a consen-
sus is arising that intrinsic correlations are likely to be small for the deep current
<
surveys with zm ∼ 1, but may be dominant for shallower surveys with zm
∼ 0.2
(see however the conflicting results of Jing 2002). Although lensing distortions
are coherent over a large redshift range, intrinsic alignments are only significant
for small physical separations. Photometric redshifts can thus be used to separate
and reduce intrinsic correlations from cosmic-shear signals (Heymans & Heavens
2002; King & Schneider 2002a,b). Another approach is to search for the B -type
correlation signal produced by intrinsic correlations (Crittenden et al. 2001b).
7.7 Theoretical Uncertainties
∼ 10′ ) and
Most of the signal in cosmic-shear surveys arises from small scales (θ <
thus from nonlinear structures (Jain & Seljak 1997). The existing prescriptions
for computing the nonlinear corrections (Peacock & Dodds 1997; Ma 1998) to
the matter power spectrum are only accurate to approximately 10% and disagree
at that level with one another (see discussion in Huterer 2001). This theoretical
uncertainty will soon become one of the dominating errors in the determination of
cosmological parameters from cosmic-shear surveys (see discussion in van Waer-
beke et al. 2002). New prescriptions based on more recent N-body simulations
such as those by Smith et al. (2003) will help improve the accuracy of the pre-
dictions. The problem of the prediction of higher-order statistics is even more
difficult, but it is not as pressing given the large uncertainties in the the measure-
ments within current surveys (see Bernardeau, Mellier, van Waerbeke 2002). The
inclusion of second-order terms in the weak-lensing approximation will eventually
also be required (Cooray 2002, Cooray & Hu 2002).
These systematic effects must be controlled to match the statistical accuracy
of future surveys. Along with the studies suggested above, further measurements
with different colors and comparison of various surveys in overlapping regions
would help to control systematics and to test data analysis pipelines. On the
theoretical side, larger simulations coupled with advanced analytical techniques
will be required.
Weak Gravitational Lensing
8 CONCLUSIONS
21
Cosmic shear has emerged as a powerful method to measure the large-scale struc-
ture in the universe. It can be thought of as the measurement of background
fluctuations in the space-time metric. Although other methods rely on assump-
tions relating the distribution of light to that of the mass, weak lensing is based
on “clean” physics and can be directly compared to theory. The past three years
have yielded impressive observational progress, as the first statistical detections
and measurements of cosmic shear have been achieved.
In analogy with the
CMB, cosmic shear has moved from the COBE era to that of the first generation
of anisotropy experiments. However, the measurement of cosmic shear differs
from that of CMB anisotropies in several respects. First, the fluctuations are
on the order of 10−2 as opposed to 10−5 , making them easier to measure while
retaining the validity of linear calculations. Second, the cosmic-shear field is
non-Gaussian and therefore contains more information than that quantified by
the power spectrum.
Existing cosmic-shear measurements have started to yield significant constraints
on cosmological parameters. The measurement of the amplitude of the matter
power spectrum σ8Ω0.5
m from cosmic shear should soon replace that derived from
the local abundance of clusters. This latter technique is indeed limited by the
finite number of bright clusters and by systematic uncertainties in the physics of
clusters. With better statistics, the angular and redshift dependence of the shear
signal as well as with higher-order moments of the convergence field will break
the degeneracy between σ8 and Ωm and yield constraints on further parameters
such as ΩΛ and Γ.
The current measurements of cosmic shear are now primarily limited by statis-
tics. They will therefore be improved upon by a number of upcoming and future
instruments such as Megacam, VST, VISTA, LSST, and Pan-STARRS from the
ground, and HST/ACS and SNAP in space. For several of these instruments, a
weak-lensing survey has been listed as one of the primary science drivers. These
surveys will potentially yield measurements of cosmological parameters that are
comparable in precision and complementary to those derived from the CMB.
They will also be able to address more far-reaching questions in cosmology by
measuring parameters beyond the standard model. For instance, they can be
used to provide a test of the gravitational instability paradigm, a measure of the
equation of state of the dark energy, and a test of general relativity.
For these instruments to yield the full promise of cosmic shear, a number of
challenges have to be met. First, observationally, systematic effects, such as the
PSF anisotropy and CCD nonlinearities, must be controlled and corrected for.
From the theoretical point of view, calculations of the nonlinear power spectrum,
of high-order statistics, and of the associated errors must be improved to meet the
precision of future measurements. The observational and theoretical efforts re-
quired to overcome these difficulties are worthwhile given the remarkable promise
that cosmic shear offers to cosmology.
Acknowledgments The author thanks his collaborators David Bacon, Richard
Massey, Tzu-Ching Chang, Jason Rhodes, and Richard Ellis for numerous fruitful
discussions. The author thanks Bhuvnesh Jain, David Bacon, and Henk Hoekstra
for their permission to reproduce their figure. He also thanks Tony Tyson, Herv´e
Aussel and Andy Taylor for precisions regarding the parameters of future cosmic
shear surveys. He is also grateful to Richard Ellis, Henk Hoekstra, Gary Bern-
22
Refregier
stein, Yannick Mellier, Richard Massey, and Ivan Valtchanov for useful comments
on the manuscript.
The Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics is online at
http://astro.annualreviews.org
Literature Cited
Babul, A Lee MH. 1991. MNRAS 250:407
Bartelmann M, King LJ, Schneider P. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 378:361
Bartelmann M, Schneider P. 1999. astro-ph/9912508
Bacon DJ, Refregier A, Clowe D, Ellis R. 2001. MNRAS 325:1065
Bacon DJ, Refregier A, Ellis R. 2000. MNRAS 318:625
Bacon DJ, Massey R, Refregier A, Ellis R. 2002. astro-ph/0203134
Benabed K, Bernardeau F. 2001. Phys. Rev. D 64:083501
Bennet DP, Rhie SH. 2000. GEST Home Page.
http://bustard.phys.nd.edu/GEST. astro-ph/0011466
Bernardeau F. 1997. Astron. Astrophys. 324:15
Bernardeau F. 1998. Astron. Astrophys. 338:767
Bernardeau F. 1999. Theoretical and Observational Cosmology. Proc. Cargese Summer Sch.,
Cargese, France, ed. M Lachieze-Rey. astro-ph/9901117
Bernardeau F, Mellier Y, van Waerbeke L. 2002. Astron. Astrophys. 389:L28
Bernardeau F, Valageas P. 2000. Astron. Astrophys. 364:1
Bernardeau F, van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y. 1997. Astron. Astrophys. 322:1
Bernardeau F, van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y. 2003. Astron. Astrophys. 397:405
Berstein GM, Jarvis M. 2001. astro-ph/0107431
Blandford RD, Saust AB, Brainerd TG, Villumsen JV. 1991. MNRAS 241:600
Bonnet H, Mellier Y. 1995. Astron. Astrophys. 303:331
Borgani S, Rosati P, Tozzi P, Stanford SA, Eisenhardt PR, et al. 2001. Ap. J. 561:13
Boulade O, Charlot X, Abbon P, Aune S. Borgeaud P. et al. 2000. Proc. SPIE 4008:657 Megacam
Home Page.
http://www-dapnia.cea.fr/Phys/Sap/Activites/Projets/Megacam/page.shtml
Brown M, Taylor AN, Hambly N, Dye S. 2000. astro-ph/0009499
Brown M, Taylor AN, Bacon, D.J., Gray, M.E., Dye S., Meisenheimer, K., Wolf, C. 2003.
MNRAS 341:100
Catalan P, Kamionkowksi M, Blandford R. 2001. MNRAS 320:7
Chang T-C, Refregier A. 2002. Ap. J. 570:447
Contaldi, C, Hoekstra, H., Lewis, A. 2003. submitted to Phys. Rev. Letters. astro-ph/0302435
Cooray A. 2002. astro-ph/0206068
Cooray A, Hu W. 2001a. Ap. J. 548:7
Cooray A, Hu W. 2001b. Ap. J. 554:56
Cooray A, Hu W. 2002. Ap. J. 574:19
Cooray A, Hu W, Miralda-Escud´e J. 2000. Ap. J. 535:9
Cooray A, Kesden M. 2002. astro-ph/0204068
Crittenden R, Natara jan P, Pen U, Theuns, T. 2001a. Ap. J. 559:552
Crittenden R, Natara jan P, Pen U, Theuns T. 2001b. astro-ph/0012336
Croft RAC, Metzler CA. 2000. Ap. J. 545:561
Eke V, Cole S, Frenk C, Patrick Henry J. 1998. MNRAS 298:1145
Erben T, van Waerbeke L, Bertin E, Mellier Y, Schneider P. 2001. Astron. Astrophys. 3667:17
Fort B, Mellier Y. 1994. Astron. Astrophys. Rev. 5:239
Gray ME, Taylor AN, Meisenheimer K, Dye S, Wolf C, Thommes E. 2002. Ap. J. 568:141
Gunn JE. 1967. Ap. J. 150:737
Hamana T, Colombi S, Mellier Y. 2000. Cosmological Physics with Gravitational Lensing. Proc.
XXth Moriond Astrophys. Meet., Les Arcs, France, ed. J-P Kneib, Y Mellier, M Mon, J Tran
Thanh Van. astro-ph/0009459
Hamana T, Miyazaki S, Shimasaku K, Furusawa H, Doi M, et al. 2002, submitted to Ap. J.,
preprint astro-ph/0210450
Weak Gravitational Lensing
23
Hammerle H, Miralles JM, Schneider P, Erben T, Fosbury RA. 2002. Astron. Astrophys. 385:743
Heavens AF. 2001. Intrinsic Galaxy Alignments and Weak Gravitational Lensing. Yale Worksh.
Shapes Galaxies Haloes, May. astro-ph/0109063
Heavens A, Refregier A, Heymans C. 2000. MNRAS 319:649
Heymans C, Heavens A. 2002. astro-ph/0208220
Hirata C, Seljak U. 2002. astro-ph/0209489
Hirata C, Seljak U. 2003. to appear in MNRAS. astro-ph/0301054
Hiroyasu A, et al. 2001. Subaru Home Page. http://www.subaru.naoj.org/
Hoekstra H, Franx M, Kuijken K, Squires G. 1998. Ap. J. 504:636
Hoekstra H, Franx M, Kuijken K, Carlberg RG, Yee HKC, et al. 2001. Ap. J. 548:5
Hoekstra H, Yee HKC, Gladders, M. 2001. Ap. J. 558:11
Hoekstra H, Yee HKC, Gladders M. 2002a. Ap. J. 577:595
Hoekstra H, Yee HKC, Gladders M. 2002b. astro-ph/0205205
Hoekstra H, Yee HKC, Gladders M, Felipe Barrientos L, Hall PB, Infante L. 2002a. Ap. J.
572:55
Hoekstra H, van Waerbeke L, Gladders MD, Mellier Y, Yee HKC. 2002b. Ap. J. 577:604
Hu W. 1999. Ap. J. 522L:21
Hu W. 2000. Phys. Rev. D 63:3504
Hu W. 2001. astro-ph/010890
Hu W. 2002. astro-ph/0208093
Hu W, Keeton CR. 2002. astro-ph/0205412
Hu W, Tegmark M. 1999. Ap. J. 514L:65
Hu W, White M. 2000. Ap. J. 554:67
Hui L. 1999. Ap. J. 519:9
Huterer D. 2001. astro-ph/0106399
Jain B, Seljak U. 1997 Ap. J. 484:560.
Jain B, Seljak U, White S. 2000. Ap. J. 530:547
Jain B, van Waerbeke L. 2000. Ap. J. 530:L1
Jaroszy´nsky M, Park C, Paczy´nsky B, Gott JR. 1990. Ap. J. 365:22
Jarvis, M., Bernstein, G.M., fisher, P., Smith, D., Jain, B., Tyson, J.A., Wittman, D. 2002,Ap.
J. 125:1014
Jing YP. 2002. MNRAS 335:L89
Kaiser N. 1992. Ap. J. 388:272.
Kaiser N. 1998. Ap. J. 498:26.
Kaiser N. 1999. Weak Lensing by Galaxy Clusters. Boston Lensing Meet. astro-ph/9912569
Kaiser N. 2000. Ap. J. 537:555
Kaiser N, Squires G, Broadhurst T. 1995. Ap. J. 449:460
Kaiser N, Tonry JL, Luppino GA. 2000. PASP 112:768. Pan-STARRS homepage
http://pan-starrs.ifa.hawaii.edu/
Kaiser N, Wilson G, Luppino GA. 2000. astro-ph/0003338
Kaiser N, Wilson G, Luppino GA, Dahle H. 1999. astro-ph/99077229
Kaiser N, Wilson G, Luppino G, Kofman L, Gioia I, et al. 1998. astro-ph/9809268
Kamionkoski M, Babul A, Cress CM, Refregier A. 1997. MNRAS 301:1064. astro-ph/9712030
King L, Schneider P. 2002a. astro-ph/0208256
King L, Schneider P. 2002b. astro-ph/0209474
Kristian J, Sachs RK. 1966. Ap. J. 143:379
Kristian J. 1967. Ap. J. 147:864
Kuijken K. 1999. Astron. Astrophys. 352:355
Kuijken K, Bender R, Cappellaro E, Muschielok B, Baruffolo A et al. 2002. ESO Messenger
110: 15; VST homepage http://www.na.astro.it/vst/
Lee MH, Paczy´nsky B. 1990. Ap. J. 357:32
Lee J, Pen U. 2001. Ap. J. 532:5
Luppino GA, Kaiser N. 1997. Ap. J. 475:20
Ma C-P. 1998. Ap. J. 508:5
Mackey J, White M, Kamionkowksi M. 2001. astro-ph/0106364
Massey R., Rhodes J., Refregier A., Albert J., Bacon D. et al. 2003. astro-ph/0304418
Maoli R, van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y, Schneider P, Jain B, et al. 2001. Astron. Astrophys.,
368:766
Mellier Y. 1999. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 37:127
24
Refregier
Mellier Y, van Waerbeke L, Bertin E, Tereno I, Bernardeau F. 2002. astro-ph/0210091
Mellier Y, van Waerbeke L, Maoli R, Schneider P, Jain B, et al. 2001. Cosmic shear surveys.
Deep Fields, Proc. Eur. South. Obs., Oct., Garching, Ger. astro-ph/0101130
Mellier Y, van Waerbeke L, Radovich M, Bertin E, Dantel-Fort M. 2000. ESO Proceedings,
Mining the Sky, Garching, July 2000, A.J. Banday et al eds. astro-ph/0012059. CFHTLS
homepage http://cdsweb.u-strasbg.fr:2001/Science/CFHLS/
Mould J, Blandford R, Villumsen J, Brainerd T, Smail I. 1994. MNRAS 271:31
Miyazaki S, Hamana T, Shimasaku K, Furusawa H, Doi M, et al. 2002. Ap. J. 580:97
Munshi D, Coles P. 2000. astro-ph/0003354
Munshi D, Coles P. 2002. astro-ph/0003481
Munshi D, Jain B. 2000. MNRAS 318:109
Munshi D. Jain B. 2001. MNRAS 322:107
Munshi D, Wang Y. 2002. astro-ph/0206483
Narayan R, Bartelmann M. 1999. In Formation of Structure in the Universe, ed. A Dekel, JP
Ostriker, p. 360. astro-ph/9606001
Padmanabhan N, Seljak U, Pen UL. 2002. New Astronomy 8:581
Peacock J, Dodds SJ. 1997. MNRAS 280:L19
Pen U, Lee J, Seljak U. 2000. Ap. J. 543:L107
Pen U, van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y. 2001. astro-ph/0109182
Perlmutter, et al. 2003. SNAP Home Page. http://snap.lbl.gov
Pierpaoli E, Scott D, White M. 2001. MNRAS 325:77
Pierpaoli E, Scott D, White M. 2002. submitted to MNRAS. astro-ph/0210567
Premadi P, Martel H, Matzner R, Futamase T. 2001. Ap. J. Suppl. 135:7
Refregier A. 2003. MNRAS 338:35
Refregier A, Bacon DJ. 2003. MNRAS 338:48
Refregier A, Rhodes J, Groth E. 2002. Ap. J. 572:L131
Refregier A, Brown ST, Kamionkowski M, Helfand DJ, Cress CM, et al. 1998. Wide Field Surveys
in Cosmology. Proc. XIVth IAP Meet., ed. Y Mellier, S Colombi. Paris. astro-ph/9810025
Refregier A, Massey M, Rhodes J, Ellis R, Albert J, et al. 2003. astro-ph/0304419
Reiprich TH, Bohringer H. 2001. astro-ph/0111285
Rhodes J, Refregier A. Groth E. 2000. Ap. J. 536:79
Rhodes J, Refregier A, Groth E. 2001. Ap. J. 552:L85
Rhodes J., Refregier A., Massey R., Albert, J., Bacon D., et al. 2003, astro-ph/0304417
Schneider P. 1995. Proc. Laredo Adv. Summer Sch., Sept. astro-ph/9512047
Schneider P. 1998. Ap. J. 498:43
Schneider P. 1999. Proc. Perspec. Radio Astron., April, Amsterdam. astro-ph/9907146
Schneider P, Lombardi M. 2002. astro-ph/0207454
Schneider P, van Waerbeke L, Jain B, Kruse G. 1998a. MNRAS 296:873
Schneider P, van Waerbeke L, Kilbinger M, Mellier Y. 2002. Astron. Astrophys 396:1
Schneider P, Weiss A. 1988. Ap. J. 327:526
Schneider P, van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y, Jain B, Seitz S, Fort B. 1998b. Astron. Astrophys.
333:767
Seljak U. 1996. Ap. J. 463:1
Seljak U. 2001. astro-ph/0111362
Seljak U, Zaldarriaga M. 1999. Phys. Rev. D 60:43504
Smith RE, Peacock JA, Jenkins A, White SDM, Frenk CS, et al. 2003. MNRAS 341:1311
Spergel, D., Verde, L., Peiris, H.V., Komatsu, E., Nolta, M.R., et al. 2003, submitted to Ap. J..
astro-ph/0302209
Stebbins A. 1996. astro-ph/9609149
Stebbins A, McKay T, Frieman JA. 1995. Proc. IAU Symposium 173. astro-ph/9510012
Takada M. Jain B. 2002. astro-ph/0205055
Taylor A. 2001. astro-ph/0111605
Taylor A, Watts P. 2000. astro-ph/0010014
Taylor A, et al. 2003. in preparation VISTA Home Page. http://www.vista.ac.uk
Tyson JA, Wittman D, Hennawi JF, Spergel DN. 2002a. Proc. 5th Int. UCLA Symp. Sources
Detect. Dark Matter, Feb., Marina del Rey, ed. D Cline. astro-ph/0209632
Tyson JA, & the LSST collaboration 2002b. Proc. SPIE Int.Soc.Opt.Eng. 4836, 10-20. astro-
ph/0302102. LSST Home Page http://lsst.org
Uzan J-P, Bernardeau F. 2001. Phys. Rev. D 64:083004
Weak Gravitational Lensing
25
Valageas P. 2000. Astron. Astrophys. 356:771
Valdes F, Jarvis JF, Tyson JA. 1983. Ap. J. 271:431
van Waerbeke L. 1998. Astron. Astrophys. 334:1
van Waerbeke L, Bernardeau F, Mellier Y. 1999. Astron. Astrophys. 342:15
van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y., Erben T., Cuillandre JC, Bernardeau F, et al. 2000. Astron. As-
trophys. 358:30
van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y., Radovich M., Bertin E., Dantel-Fort M. et al. 2001a. Astron.
Astrophys. 374:757
van Waerbeke L, Hamana T, Scoccimarro R, Colombi S, Bernardeau F. 2001b. MNRAS 322:918
van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y, Pell´o R, Pen U-L, McCracken HJ, Jain B. 2002. Astron. Astrophys.
393:369
Viana P, Liddle A. 1999. MNRAS 303:535
Viana P, Nichol RC, Liddle A. 2001. astro-ph/0111394
Villumsen J. 1995. astro-ph/9507007
Villumsen J. 1996. MNRAS 281:369
van Waerbeke L, Mellier Y, Tereno I. 2002. astro-ph/0206245
Wambsganss J, Cen R, Ostriker JP. 1998. Ap. J. 494:29
Weinberg NN, Kamionkowski M. 2002. astro-ph/0210134
White M, Hu W. 2000. Ap. J. 537:1
Wilson G, Kaiser N, Luppino GA. 2001. Ap. J. 556:601
Wittman DM, Tyson J, Kirkman D, Dell’Antonio I, Bernstein G. 2000. Nature 405:143
Wittman DM. 2002. Dark Matter and Gravitational Lensing, LNP Top. Vol., ed. F Courbin, D
Minniti. Springer-Verlag. astro-ph/0208063
Wittman DM, Tyson JA, Dell’Antonio IP, Becker AC, Margoniner VE, et al. 2002. Proc. SPIE
4836 v.2. astro-ph/0210118. Deep Lens Survey web page http://dls.bell-labs.com/
Zaldarriaga M, Scoccimarro R. 2002. astro-ph/0208075
Zaldarriaga M, Seljak U. 1998. astro-ph/9810257
|
astro-ph/0501413 | 2 | 0501 | 2005-01-25T15:49:16 | Ultraviolet Dust Grain Properties in Starburst Galaxies: Evidence from Radiative Transfer Modeling and Local Group Extinction Curves | [
"astro-ph"
] | This paper summarizes the evidence of the ultraviolet properties of dust grains found in starburst galaxies. Observations of starburst galaxies clearly show that the 2175 A feature is weak or absent. This can be the result of radiative transfer effects (mixing the dust and stars) or due to dust grains which do not have this feature. Spherical DIRTY radiative transfer models imply that it is not radiative transfer effects, but other radiative transfer models with disk/bulge geometries have found cases where it could be radiative transfer effects. Recent work on the extinction curves in the Magellanic Clouds and Milky Way has revealed that the traditional explanation of low metallicity for the absence of the 2175 A feature in the Small Magellanic Cloud is likely incorrect. The SMC has one sightline with a 2175 A feature and the Milky Way has sightlines without this feature. In addition, where the 2175 A feature is found to be weak or absent in both Magellanic Clouds and the Milky Way, there is evidence for recent star formation. Taking the sum of the radiative transfer modeling of starburst galaxies and the behavior of Local Group extinction curves, it is likely that the dust grains in starburst galaxies intrinsically lack the 2175 A feature. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Ultraviolet Dust Grain Properties in Starburst
Galaxies: Evidence from Radiative Transfer
Modeling and Local Group Extinction Curves
Karl D. Gordon
Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA
email: [email protected]
Abstract. This paper summarizes the evidence of the ultraviolet properties of dust grains found in
starburst galaxies. Observations of starburst galaxies clearly show that the 2175 Å feature is weak
or absent. This can be the result of radiative transfer effects (mixing the dust and stars) or due to
dust grains which do not have this feature. Spherical DIRTY radiative transfer models imply that it
is not radiative transfer effects, but other radiative transfer models with disk/bulge geometries have
found cases where it could be radiative transfer effects. Recent work on the extinction curves in the
Magellanic Clouds and Milky Way has revealed that the traditional explanation of low metallicity
for the absence of the 2175 Å feature in the Small Magellanic Cloud is likely incorrect. The SMC
has one sightline with a 2175 Å feature and the Milky Way has sightlines without this feature. In
addition, where the 2175 Å feature is found to be weak or absent in both Magellanic Clouds and
the Milky Way, there is evidence for recent star formation. Taking the sum of the radiative transfer
modeling of starburst galaxies and the behavior of Local Group extinction curves, it is likely that
the dust grains in starburst galaxies intrinsically lack the 2175 Å feature.
INTRODUCTION
There are two main reasons to study the dust in galaxies where single stars are unresolv-
able with current telescopes.
1) To directly study the dust itself as galaxies provide a much wider range of envi-
ronments than found in the Local Group. These different environments can be charac-
terized by more extreme values of radiation field density, radiative field hardness, shock
frequency, and initial conditions (eg., metallicity). Such different environments can sig-
nificantly impact the formation and destruction of dust grains.
2) To more accurately account for the effects of dust on observations of the stars and
gas present in galaxies. This accounting allows for the study of stars and gas in galaxies
to be carried out more accurately.
In order to study dust in such galaxies, a model of how the mixing of dust with stars
and gas affects to the observations of a galaxy is required. One such model is the DIRTY
dust radiative transfer model [1, 2] which uses Monte Carlo techniques to compute the
radiative transfer of photons through dust and self-consistently accounts for the dust
re-emission in the infrared including equilibrium and non-equilibrium emission.
This paper concentrates on the ultraviolet dust grain properties in starburst galaxies
determined using the DIRTY model and implied from extinction curves measured in
the Local Group. The study of dust in galaxies is much larger than this, especially
in light of the wealth of information available in the infrared where the dust grain
emission dominated the spectral energy distribution of a galaxy. The connection between
ultraviolet and infrared dust grain properties is not direct, but determined using dust
grain models [3, 4, 5] which have their own problems. For example, I have found that
using empirically determined dust scattering properties in the ultraviolet [6] is crucial to
reproducing the ultraviolet colors of starburst galaxies.
STARBURST GALAXIES
Starburst galaxies provide ideal environments to probe dust grain properties in extreme
environments as they are intrinsically bright in the ultraviolet where dust grain properties
show large variation [7, 8, 9]. The environments probed by starbursts range from very
metal poor (eg., I Zw 18) to very metal rich and most starbursts are likely characterized
by high and hard radiation fields and elevated shock frequencies. Starbursts probe the
more active environments of those possible in galaxies in general.
The study of the type of dust found in starburst galaxies really got going with the
work of Calzetti et al. [10] and Calzetti [11]. In these studies, a variant of the standard
pair method was used to derive an empirical attenuation curve appropriate for ultraviolet
bright starburst galaxies. This empirical curve clearly lacked the strong 2175 Å absorp-
tion feature seen in almost all known dust extinction curves. In addition, this curve was
grayer than most dust extinction curves. The question was then: Is the lack of this 2175 Å
feature and the grayer curve due to different dust grain properties or radiative transfer
effects? At the time, only a small number of sightlines in the Small Magellanic Cloud
(SMC) were known to lack this feature [12]. This lack was attributed to the low metal-
licity of the SMC with the higher metallicities of the Large Magellanic Cloud and the
Milky Way resulting in the ubiquity of the 2175 Å feature in their dust [7, 8]. But, the
starburst galaxies studied by Calzetti et al. [10] had metallicities spanning the known
range from lower than the SMC to higher than the Milky Way. Radiative transfer effects
were seen as the probable cause of the lack of the 2175 Å feature. The complicated mix-
ing of the dust, gas, and many stars in unresolved observations of galaxies implies that
radiative transfer effects are important. Such mixing means that the stars in the observ-
ing beam have different dust columns and significant scattered flux is included in any
measurement. As a result, the attenuation curve for a galaxy is not dependent only on
dust grain properties, like that for the extinction curve towards a single resolved star in
the Local Group, but is also dependent on the geometry of the dust, gas, and stars.
Motivated by the starburst results and improvements in the DIRTY dust radiative
transfer model to include nonhomogeneous dust distributions [13], Gordon et al. [14]
investigated the importance of radiative transfer effects on determining the shape of the
empirical starburst attenuation curve. After investigating a number of dust/star geome-
tries, they found that the lack of the 2175 Å feature could not be explained by radiative
transfer effects. The only way to remove the 2175 Å feature from the attenuation curve
was for the dust grains themselves to lack the feature. This result coupled with the large
range in metallicities in the starburst galaxies implied that it was the starburst environ-
ment which was responsible for the lack of the 2175 Å feature. The dust grains were
either newly formed without the feature or this feature was destroyed by the hard radia-
tion field and elevated shock frequency in starbursts. Using the same or similar analysis,
this result was extended to higher redshifts (z ≈ 3) by Gordon et al. [15] and Vijh et al.
[16] where it was also found that most high-redshift (and likely starburst) galaxies lack
a 2175 Å bump. A detailed analysis of the Calzetti [11] attenuation curve by Witt and
Gordon [17] found that a clumpy SHELL geometry with SMC dust, t V ∼ 1.5 DIRTY
model best fit both the grayness of the curve and the lack of the 2175 Å feature.
Since the work utilizing simple spherical DIRTY models, other studies have found
ways to produce attenuation curves with weak or nearly absent 2175 Å features while
using dust grains with Milky Way-like dust (i.e., a strong 2175 Å feature). Using
the GRASIL code, Granato et al. [18] found that differentially embedding sources of
different spectral types (basically by stellar lifetime) in molecular clouds in a disk/bulge
geometry with clumpy structure and Milky Way-like dust resulted in attenuation curves
with weak or absent 2175 Å features. Fischera et al. [19] studied the attenuation curves
produced by a foreground screen with a log-normal density distribution of Milky Way-
like dust and was able to reproduce the grayness of the Calzetti [11] curve, but was only
able to reduce the strength of the 2175 Å feature. Finally, Pierini et al. [20] used DIRTY
models of disk/bulge galaxies and found that for highly inclined, weak bulge galaxies
the 2175 Å feature was very weak in the global attenuation curves.
As a result of these studies [18, 19, 20], it is clear that there are dust/star geometries
which can reproduce most, if not all, of the characteristics of the Calzetti [11] starburst
curve. But it is not clear that the necessary geometries (disk/bulge or foreground screen)
are appropriate for the starburst galaxies which are usually seen as nuclear dominated or
have highly irregular morphologies.
LOCAL GROUP EXTINCTION CURVES
An important part of the type of dust we expect to find in galaxies is driven by our
detailed knowledge of dust in the Local Group. One of the most powerful ways to
study the properties of dust is to determine ultraviolet through near-infrared extinction
curves towards single stars. As the dust measured by observing a star is distributed in a
foreground screen, the derived extinction curve is only dependent on the properties of
the dust grains (size, composition, and shape). With current telescopes and instruments,
this work is limited to Local Group galaxies.
Prior to the work on starburst galaxies, it was thought that most galaxies would have
dust with a 2175 Å feature because all known sightlines in the Milky Way [7, 8] and
the Large Magellanic Cloud [21, 22] had this feature. Only in the Small Magellanic
Cloud was the 2175 Å feature absent [12] and this was understood to be due to the
low metallicity of this galaxy. The lack of the 2175 Å feature in starburst galaxies with
metallicities like those found in the Milky Way and LMC questioned the explanation for
the SMC lacking the 2175 Å feature. In fact, the variation in the LMC extinction curves
between those near and far from the 30 Dor star forming region pointed to a different
explanation [22]. It was found that the extinction curves near 30 Dor had weaker 2175 Å
features and somewhat steeper far-ultraviolet extinctions than those found in the rest of
the LMC.
The existence of two explanations (low metallicity versus nearby active star forma-
tion) for the weakness or lack of a 2175 Å feature motivated new work on extinction
curves in the Local Group.
In the SMC, Gordon and Clayton [23] searched the IUE archives and found it was
possible to generate accurate extinction curves for only four sightlines. Three of the
four curves were basically linear with 1/l and had no detectable 2175 Å feature. The
fourth curve was much more like that found in the Milky Way with a 2175 Å feature and
weaker far-ultraviolet extinction compared to the rest of the SMC curves. This Milky
Way-like curve was first published in Lequeux et al. [24] but dismissed by Prevot et al.
[12] as anomalous. Gordon and Clayton [23] found that this Milky Way-like curve was
located in a more quiescent region than the other three curves which were located in
the star forming bar of the SMC. One additional sightline was added to the sample of
SMC extinction curves by Gordon et al. [9] using new HST/STIS observations. This
new sightline was in the star forming bar and was very similar to the previously known
extinction curves in this same region. Thus, the spatial variations in the five known
extinction curves in the SMC are consistent with the explanation that the lack of the
2175 Å feature is due to nearby active star formation.
In the LMC, Misselt et al. [25] searched the IUE archives and was able to construct
19 accurate extinction curves from the available data. Like previous studies, this work
found significant differences between those sightlines near 30 Dor and those in the rest
of the LMC. Misselt et al. [25] found that this difference was caused by the sightlines
associated with the supergiant shell LMC 2 near 30 Dor, not 30 Dor itself. Thus, they
found very significant differences (especially in their 2175 Å feature strengths) when the
19 sightlines were grouped between those associated with the LMC 2 shell and those in
the rest of the LMC. Like the SMC, the spatial variation of the LMC extinction curves
is consistent with active star formation being the cause.
In the Milky Way, the most comprehensive extinction curve study to date has been
the recent work of Valencic et al. [26]. Like the studies in the SMC and LMC [23,
25], the IUE archive was searched and a total of 417 extinction curves created. The
overwhelming majority of these curves (93%) were well characterized by the Cardelli
et al. [7] RV dependent relationship with only 4 curves showing systematic deviation
from this relationship. HD 204827 is one of these 4 curves and a detailed study of
this sightline [27] found that after subtracting a well measured foreground component,
the remaining extinction curve was equivalent within the uncertainties to the extinction
curves found in the SMC star forming bar (i.e., linear with 1/l and lacking a 2175 Å
bump). The local environment of HD 204827 has evidence for a recent supernova shock.
In a study of 30 low reddening, long sightlines in the Milky Way, Clayton et al. [28]
found that a subsample which had extinction curves like that found in the LMC 2
shell sample [25]. This subsample were all in the same region of the Milky Way and
displayed N(Ca II)/N(Na I) ratios and velocities indicating recent dust destruction. Like
the work in Magellanic Clouds, new studies in the Milky Way have revealed evidence
that processing of dust can cause the weakening or disappearance of the 2175 Å feature
and strengthening of the far-ultraviolet extinction.
Examining the sum of work on extinction curves in the Milky Way and Magellanic
Clouds, it is clear that there is a continuum of dust extinction curves extending from
those represented by the Cardelli et al. [7] relationship with strong 2175 Å features
to those like those found in the SMC bar with no detectable 2175 Å feature [9]. This
implies that it is more accurate to describe the Cardelli et al. [7] relationship as referring
to dust in quiescent environments and SMC bar extinction curves as referring to dust in
much more active environments. But even this picture of dust ultraviolet extinction curve
variations is incomplete as dust in molecular clouds has not been well measured. Only
the Taurus molecular cloud has been probed in the ultraviolet through the HD 29647 and
HD 283809 sightlines [29]. By subtracting a foreground extinction curve measurement
from these two sightlines, Whittet et al. [30] found that the 2175 Å bump disappeared.
This is like the dust found in the SMC bar, but the far-ultraviolet extinction in this dust
was much weaker. This is good evidence that the true range of dust extinction curves
likely includes another extreme, that found in molecular clouds.
DISCUSSION
In this paper, I have attempted to summarize work I have been involved in relating to
the dust found in starburst galaxies and Local Group extinction curve work motivated
in part by the starburst galaxy results. Combining the results for radiative transfer in
starburst galaxies for what we now know is a more varied story of dust extinction
curves in the Milky Way and Magellanic Clouds, it is most probable that the dust
grains in starburst galaxies are truly lacking the 2175 Å feature and possesses strong
far-ultraviolet extinctions. It is very important to clearly state that this conclusion only
applies to the dust found in or near the starburst regions. This is the dust which is
probed by the ultraviolet photons from the starburst regions. Given our knowledge of
Local Group dust extinction curves, it is very likely that dust far from sites of active star
formation in starburst galaxies would be characterized by Milky Way-like or quiescent
dust (i.e., Cardelli et al. [7] relationship).
The measurements of starburst galaxies in the ultraviolet necessarily probe only the
active regions of these galaxies; there are other measurements which probe the type of
dust found in more quiescent regions of galaxies. Studies of the colors of gravitational
lens systems [31, 32] have found Cardelli et al. [7] type dust curves. As gravitational
lenses probe random sightlines in galaxies, this is evidence that quiescent dust is like that
seen in our Galaxy. These gravitational lens difference curves are not direct measures
of dust extinction as they probe the difference in two dust extinction curves of unknown
dust columns [33, 34], but they can be used to determine the presence of the 2175 Å
feature. Finally, measurements of Mg II absorbers also probe random sightlines in
galaxies and show evidence for the 2175 Å feature [35, 36].
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would like thank the organizers of this conference for inviting me to give a talk on my
work. The work described in the paper encompasses a large body of work, which would
not have been possible but for the contributions of many of my collaborators. I would
like to especially thank Adolf Witt who was my Monte Carlo radiative transfer mentor
and Geoff Clayton who was my extinction curve mentor.
REFERENCES
1. Gordon, K. D., Misselt, K. A., Witt, A. N., and Clayton, G. C., ApJ, 551, 269 (2001).
2. Misselt, K. A., Gordon, K. D., Clayton, G. C., and Wolff, M. J., ApJ, 551, 277 (2001).
3. Weingartner, J. C., and Draine, B. T., ApJ, 548, 296 (2001).
4. Clayton, G. C., Wolff, M. J., Sofia, U. J., Gordon, K. D., and Misselt, K. A., ApJ, 588, 871 (2003).
5.
6. Gordon, K. D., "Interstellar Dust Scattering Properties," in ASP Conf. Ser. 309: Astrophysics of Dust,
Zubko, V., Dwek, E., and Arendt, R. G., ApJS, 152, 211 (2004).
Fitzpatrick, E. L., and Massa, D., ApJS, 72, 163 (1990).
7. Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., and Mathis, J. S., ApJ, 345, 245 (1989).
8.
9. Gordon, K. D., Clayton, G. C., Misselt, K. A., Landolt, A. U., and Wolff, M. J., ApJ, 594, 279 (2003).
10. Calzetti, D., Kinney, A. L., and Storchi-Bergmann, T., ApJ, 429, 582 (1994).
11. Calzetti, D., AJ, 113, 162 (1997).
12. Prevot, M. L., Lequeux, J., Prevot, L., Maurice, E., and Rocca-Volmerange, B., A&A, 132, 389
2004, p. 77.
(1984).
13. Witt, A. N., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 463, 681 (1996).
14. Gordon, K. D., Calzetti, D., and Witt, A. N., ApJ, 487, 625 (1997).
15. Gordon, K. D., Smith, T. L., and Clayton, G. C., "Dust in High Redshift Starburst Galaxies," in ASP
Conf. Ser. 193: The Hy-Redshift Universe: Galaxy Formation and Evolution at High Redshift, 1999,
p. 517.
16. Vijh, U. P., Witt, A. N., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 587, 533 (2003).
17. Witt, A. N., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 528, 799 (2000).
18. Granato, G. L., Silva, L., Bressan, A., Lacey, C. G., Baugh, C. M., Cole, S., and Frenk, C. S.,
Astrophysics and Space Science Supplement, 277, 79 (2001).
19. Fischera, J., Dopita, M. A., and Sutherland, R. S., ApJL, 599, L21 (2003).
20. Pierini, D., Gordon, K. D., Witt, A. N., and Madsen, G. J., ApJ, in press (2004).
21. Clayton, G. C., and Martin, P. G., ApJ, 288, 558 (1985).
22. Fitzpatrick, E. L., AJ, 92, 1068 (1986).
23. Gordon, K. D., and Clayton, G. C., ApJ, 500, 816 (1998).
24. Lequeux, J., Maurice, E., Prevot-Burnichon, M.-L., Prevot, L., and Rocca-Volmerange, B., A&A,
113, L15 (1982).
25. Misselt, K. A., Clayton, G. C., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 515, 128 (1999).
26. Valencic, L. A., Clayton, G. C., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 616, 912 (2004).
27. Valencic, L. A., Clayton, G. C., Gordon, K. D., and Smith, T. L., ApJ, 598, 369 (2003).
28. Clayton, G. C., Gordon, K. D., and Wolff, M. J., ApJS, 129, 147 (2000).
29. Clayton, G. C., Gordon, K. D., Salama, F., Allamandola, L. J., Martin, P. G., Snow, T. P., Whittet,
D. C. B., Witt, A. N., and Wolff, M. J., ApJ, 592, 947 (2003).
30. Whittet, D. C. B., Shenoy, S. S., Clayton, G. C., and Gordon, K. D., ApJ, 602, 291 (2004).
31. Nadeau, D., Yee, H. K. C., Forrest, W. J., Garnett, J. D., Ninkov, Z., and Pipher, J. L., ApJ, 376, 430
(1991).
32. Falco, E. E., Impey, C. D., Kochanek, C. S., Lehár, J., McLeod, B. A., Rix, H.-W., Keeton, C. R.,
Muñoz, J. A., and Peng, C. Y., ApJ, 523, 617 (1999).
33. Wucknitz, O., Wisotzki, L., Lopez, S., and Gregg, M. D., A&A, 405, 445 (2003).
34. McGough, C., Clayton, G. C., Gordon, K. D., and Wolff, M. J., ApJ, in press (2005).
35. Malhotra, S., ApJL, 488, L101 (1997).
36. Wang, J., Hall, P. B., Ge, J., Li, A., and Schneider, D. P., ApJ, 609, 589 (2004).
|
astro-ph/9307005 | 1 | 9307 | 1993-07-05T11:34:00 | The Environment of Lyman a Absorbers in the Sightline toward 3C273 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present new ground-based data following up on the HST discovery of low-redshift Lya absorption in the sight-line to the quasar 3C273. Narrow-band filter observations show that there are no H II regions within a 12 kpc radius of the line-of-sight to the quasar, at the velocities of three of the absorbers. Broad-band imaging shows that there are no dwarf galaxies at Virgo distances with absolute magnitude above MB~-13.5 and within a radius of 40 kpc. We present fiber spectroscopy of galaxies within a radius of 1 deg, down to an apparent magnitude of B~19. We show that the absorbers are definitely not distributed at random with respect to the galaxies, but also that the absorber-galaxy correlation function is not as strong as the galaxy-galaxy correlation function on large scales. Our data are consistent with the hypothesis that all galaxies more luminous than 1/10 L* have effective cross-sections (for association with absorbers with Log(NH)>13.0), of between 0.5 and 1 Mpc. We also show a clear case of a Lya absorber which has no galaxy brighter than MB=-18 within a projected distance of 4.8 Mpc, and discuss the possibility that Lya absorbers are destroyed in a rich galaxy environment. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
The Environment of Lyman α Absorbers
in the Sightline towards 3C273
S. L. Morris1, R. J. Weymann
Alan Dressler and P. J. McCarthy
The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution of Washington,
813 Santa Barbara St., Pasadena, CA 91101
Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI 96822
B. A. Smith
R. J. Terrile
Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA 91109
Department of Astronomy and National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center2, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY
R. Giovanelli
14853
and
M. Irwin
Royal Greenwich Observatory, Madingley Rd, Cambridge CB3 0EZ, UK
ABSTRACT
We present new ground-based data following up on the HST discovery of low-redshift
Lyman α absorption in the sight-line to the quasar 3C273. Our goal is to investigate
the relationship between the low-column-density absorbers and higher column-density
objects such as galaxies or H II regions. Narrow-band filter observations with a corono-
graph show that there are no H II regions or other strong Hα line-emitting gas within a
12 kpc radius of the line-of-sight to the quasar, at the velocities of three of the absorbers.
Broad-band imaging in Gunn r shows that there are no dwarf galaxies at Virgo distances
with absolute magnitude above MB ≈-13.5 and within a radius of 40 kpc from the line-
of-sight to the quasar. Finally, we present fiber spectroscopy of a complete sample of
galaxies within a radius of 1◦, down to an apparent magnitude of B≈19. Analysis of this
sample, combined with galaxies within 10 Mpc of the quasar line-of-sight taken from
1Present Address: Institute of Astronomy, Madingley Rd., Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK
2The National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center is operated by Cornell University under a cooperative agreement with the U.S. National
Science Foundation
1
the literature, shows that the absorbers are definitely not distributed at random with
respect to the galaxies, but also that the absorber-galaxy correlation function is not as
strong as the galaxy-galaxy correlation function on large scales. We show that our data
are consistent with the hypothesis that all galaxies more luminous than 1/10 L∗ have
effective cross-sections (for association with absorbers whose neutral-hydrogen column-
density (Log(NH)) is >13.0), of between 0.5 and 1 Mpc. We also show a clear case
of a Lyman α absorber which has no galaxy brighter than MB=-18 within a projected
distance of 4.8 Mpc, and discuss the possibility that Lyman α absorbers are destroyed
in a rich galaxy environment.
Subject headings: cosmology -- interstellar:matter -- galaxies:redshifts
2
1.
Introduction
Understanding the origin and evolution of struc-
ture in the universe remains one of the most funda-
mental and active challenges of current astrophysical
research. As the evidence in favor of a cosmologi-
cal origin for the narrow, displaced absorption lines
in QSO spectra became overwhelming, it also became
clear that both the metal-line systems and the Lyman
α systems are invaluable tools for the study of some
aspects of this problem. Since ground-based Lyman α
studies refer only to redshifts ∼>1.6, they complement
studies of galaxy clustering properties, the majority
of which involve redshifts much less than this. How-
ever, precisely because the redshift regimes have been
so different and because it has not been at all clear
what relation exists between the typical low-column-
density Lyman α absorbers and galaxies, these two
approaches have remained disjoint. It was somewhat
unexpected, but pleasing, that low-redshift Lyman α
absorbers were found in sufficient numbers to enable
meaningful studies of the evolution of the Lyman α
absorbers and their relation to galaxies (Morris et al.
1991, Bahcall et al. 1991b). This has presented as-
tronomers with the opportunity to join these two lines
of investigation.
There are two levels at which such such attempts
can be carried out: 1) Purely statistical investiga-
tions aimed at comparing the clustering properties
of galaxies and Lyman α absorbers, and 2) Investi-
gation of individual cases in which the possibility of
establishing the presence (or absence) of a clear link
between a Lyman α absorption line and something
we could call a "galaxy" presents itself. Preliminary
discussions along these lines may be found in papers
by Bahcall et al. 1992a, Bahcall et al. 1992b and
by Salzer 1992. The present paper is a first attempt
to pursue both these approaches along the sightline
to 3C273. The remainder of this paper is organized
as follows: In § 2. we describe the different sets of
observations we have assembled to investigate the en-
vironment of the Lyman α absorbers along the 3C273
sightline. In § 3. we analyze them for possible associ-
ations or lack of associations of individual Lyman α
absorbers with galaxies, and also give some statisti-
cal analysis of the clustering properties of the Lyman
α absorbers with galaxies. In § 4. we discuss these
results in light of current models for the Lyman α ab-
sorbers and provide a brief summary and suggestions
for further work.
3
Throughout this paper H0 is taken to be 80 km/s/Mpc,
the distance to the Virgo cluster is taken to be 16.0
Mpc (a distance modulus of (m-M)Virgo=31.02) (Ja-
coby et al. 1992), and q0 is taken to be 0.
2. Observations and Reduction
It has long been realized that imaging of the gas
directly responsible for the low-column-density Ly-
man α absorbers is well beyond the reach of current
technology. Specifically, the neutral-hydrogen column
densities of order 1013 − 1014 cm−2 that GHRS de-
tected toward 3C273 are about 4 or 5 orders of mag-
nitude below what can be imaged in 21 cm emission,
even without taking into account the powerful radio
background contributed by 3C273 itself. The Hα re-
combination surface brightness associated with these
neutral-hydrogen column-densities is also several or-
ders of magnitude below what is feasible to detect,
unless the incident flux of ionizing photons is several
orders of magnitude higher than that expected from
the integrated background radiation.
However, it has frequently be suggested that the
Lyman α absorbers are intimately connected with, or
are actual extensions of, entities which can be imaged
either by means of Hα emission, starlight, or 21 cm
emission - e.g. dwarf galaxies (Fransson and Epstein
1982) or shells of expanding gas (Chernomordic and
Ozernoy 1983) or the outer regions of galactic disks
(Maloney 1992). In the case of dwarf irregulars, for
example, a very small episode of recent star formation
might betray the presence of a dwarf irregular whose
outer envelope produces the Lyman α absorbers. Al-
ternatively, expanding shells of gas might produce Hα
emission via collisional ionization at a shock front.
In addition, of course, possible association of indi-
vidual Lyman α absorbers with specific galaxies, as
well as statistical studies of absorber-galaxy correla-
tion can be carried out with a sample of redshifts for
galaxies in the field surrounding 3C273.
In this section we describe three such new sets of
observations of a region centered on 3C273. These
are: § 2.1. Coronagraph observations with narrow-
band filters of a 5′ diameter region, § 2.2. Deep broad-
band imaging of a 17′ diameter region, and § 2.3.
Fiber spectroscopy of a 2.2×1.6◦ region down to a
limiting magnitude of B=19. We describe the analysis
of these three sets of observations in § 3.
2.1. Coronagraph Observations with Narrow
Band Filters
Observations of a 5.′3×5.′3 region (radius ≈12 kpc
at Virgo) around 3C273 were obtained during 1992
February 3-7, with the University of Hawaii Corona-
graph (Vilas and Smith 1987) on the Las Campanas
2.5m duPont Telescope. A thinned 1024×1024 Tek-
tronics CCD was used, binned 2×2, giving a scale of
1.23′′/pixel. The coronagraph blocking mask had a
diameter of 5′′. Data were obtained with a Gunn r fil-
ter, and also 5 specially acquired filters, 3 with width
13.5A, centered at 6586.2A, 6598.0A and 6756.0A
(hereafter referred to as VN1, VN2 and HN), and 2
with width 25A, centered at 6643.2A and 6718.9A
(hereafter referred to as VB and HB). (The above
widths and central wavelengths are quoted for an f7.5
beam and a temperature of 15◦ C). The narrow-band
wavelengths were chosen to match the redshifted po-
sition of Hα at the velocities of the 2 Lyman α ab-
sorbers listed in Morris et al. 1991 at velocities corre-
sponding to the Virgo cluster (Bingelli, Sandage and
Tammann 1985), and one absorber at 1251A. This is
the lowest redshift, strong Lyman α system beyond
the Virgo cluster. The observing procedure involved
cycling through the 6 different filters, with exposure
times of 10 mins for the r and 25A filters, and 20
mins for the 13.5A filters. Seven such cycles were
completed over the 5 night run. During the observing
run, it was discovered that the narrow-band filter HN
had slightly non-parallel faces, resulting in detectable
'ghost' images offset from bright stars and also 3C273.
In an attempt to minimise the effect of these, this fil-
ter was rotated though 90◦ between each night.
For calibration purposes, observations were also
obtained of Mkn 49 (an emission line galaxy in the
Virgo cluster with radial velocity 1524 km/s, and
hence with Hα line-emission within 2A of the peak
of VN2) and M87, and also a number of bright stan-
dard stars.
The images were reduced using IRAF3. The reduc-
tion steps were: bias subtraction, division by a flat
field taken on the same night as the observations, ro-
tation and shifting of the images to match a reference
image, sky subtraction and averaging together of im-
ages taken with the same filter. It was found after the
run that refocusing the coronagraph between taking
the flat fields and the data meant that the flat field di-
3IRAF is distributed by NOAO, which is operated by AURA
Inc. under contract to the NSF
vision left significant features in the data, both at the
edges of the coronagraph field and also throughout
the data at the location of what are presumed to be
dust particles on the coronagraph optics or CCD win-
dow. This problem was particularly noticeable for the
data taken on the last night of the run. However, the
residuals are greatly reduced in the combined data.
Continuum sources were removed from the narrow-
band images by subtracting off a scaled version of
the two 25A filter observations. We investigated scal-
ing methods, including measuring stars or galaxies in
the images, but found that the scaling derived was
consistent with simply subtracting off the average of
the 25A filters from each 13.5A observation. That
is, there was no evidence for a significant continuum
slope or calibration difference across the 150A region
of interest, and the factor 2 shorter broad-band expo-
sure fairly accurately balanced the higher throughput
of the 25A filters. This apparent consistency may
be fortuitous: due to the small field (small number of
galaxies), and the errors in measuring the flux of faint
galaxies. Figure 1 shows the sum of the 25A data, and
the continuum subtracted 13.5A data for 3C273. As
can be seen, the PSF is a function of angle off-axis,
and becomes quite broad and asymmetric at the edge
of the field, due to aberrations in the coronagraph
optics.
2.2. Wide Field Imaging with COSMIC
A mosaic of Gunn r band images of the field around
3C273 was obtained on 1992 February 23, at the
Palomar 5m, with the prime focus COSMIC sys-
tem. This recently commissioned camera contains
a thinned 2048×2048 Tektronics CCD. Due to poor
seeing, this was read out with 2×2 binning giving a
scale of 0.56′′/pixel. Exposures were taken roughly
centered on 4 positions offset from 3C273 by 5.′4 NE,
NW, SE and SW. Four exposures of 5 minutes each
were obtained at each position. During the observa-
tions, the moon rose, and so the background level of
the images varies by almost a factor 2.
The data were reduced using IRAF. After bias
subtraction, the data were flat fielded using images
of the dome. This left significant large scale struc-
ture in the images, and so a 'skyflat' was constructed
from the combined data images. This flat was me-
dian smoothed to remove any small scale structure.
Because of a region of very low sensitivity near the
center of the CCD, and also the location of a very
bright star coincidentally at the same place in one set
4
of images, the flat fielded data still shows a weak neg-
ative feature near the center of each image. The sky
background was determined for each image separately
and subtracted. The offsets between the images were
determined by measuring the positions of the QSO
and 2 bright nearby stars, which were common to all
images and the data were then mosaiced together,
giving a combined image with diameter 17.′2 centered
on 3C273. The resulting image is show as figure 2.
2.3. Fiber Spectroscopy
During 1992 February 8-10, spectra of objects in a
2.2×1.6◦ rectangle surrounding 3C273 were obtained
with the Fiber Spectrograph at the Las Campanas
2.5m duPont Telescope. (Shectman 1992). This sys-
tem has 128 fibers which are manually plugged into
an aluminum plate over a 1.5×1.5◦ field. The fibers
have a projected diameter of 3.′′5. They feed the slit
of a floor-mounted spectrograph. A 600 l/mm grating
was used, with the 2D-Frutti photon-counting detec-
tor, giving a resolution of 8.6A FWHM. Three fields
were observed for about 6000 seconds each, offset EW
from each other.
Objects observed were chosen from a database pro-
duced by scanning an UKST IIIaJ plate of the region
with the APM scanning machine at Cambridge. The
APM produces a catalog of all the objects on a plate,
with estimates of isophotal magnitudes, size and a
'sigma' parameter that measures how much the image
parameters differ from those of stars with compara-
ble magnitude. We chose objects to observe from this
catalog with 'sigma'>3.0. This includes many fairly
compact objects, and resulted in a rather high con-
tamination by stars, but also means that we found
a number of compact galaxies that would otherwise
have been missed. For each 1.5×1.5◦ fiber field, a
magnitude sorted list of candidate galaxies was pro-
duced. Due to restrictions on the minimum fiber sep-
aration, 330 out of a possible 336 object fibers were
used, with 16 fibers per field set on blank sky.
The fiber spectra were extracted and reduced using
the IRAF apextract package. The spectra were first
traced and extracted. Then fiber-to-fiber throughput
differences were corrected with a flat field image, and
the fibers were wavelength calibrated and rebinned to
a common linear wavelength scale. The wavelength
calibration used an arc spectrum to determine the
non-linear relationship between wavelength and pixel
number, after which a zero point shift was measured
for each fiber using the strong sky lines in the data.
5
Finally, the sky emission was subtracted from each
fiber using an unscaled template constructed from the
16 sky fibers in each frame.
Classification and radial velocity measurements for
each spectrum were done in two ways. First each
spectrum was inspected by eye, and classified as ei-
ther a star, galaxy or unknown. Then a radial veloc-
ity was determined by measuring either the position
of the 4000A break, or that of the [OII] λ3727.6 fea-
ture (actually a doublet, but unresolved in our data).
A subjective assessment was also made of the reli-
ability of the resulting radial velocity, dividing the
sample into 'possible' and 'definite'. All the spectra
were also analysed using the fxcor routine in IRAF.
Each object was cross-correlated with three different
templates: (a) a template made up from the 27 best
S/N stars in the data, (b) a template made up from 3
high S/N late-type stars, and (c) a template made up
from 16 emission line galaxies (all shifted to their rest
frames) in the data. For each spectrum, the correla-
tion with the highest peak was then selected. A re-
assuringly close match was found between the by-eye
classification and velocities and the results from fxcor.
The resulting histogram of velocities was inspected.
Apart from 4 low S/N or hot stars (for which a good
template was not constructed), the stellar velocities
found by fxcor had a distribution well represented by
a gaussian with zero mean and an approximate dis-
persion (σ) of 85 km/s. We take this to be a reason-
able estimate for our radial velocity uncertainties. It
was also found that the subjective 'possible' category
in the by-eye radial velocity measurements matched
rather well to a cross-correlation peak height less than
0.3 returned by fxcor. Apart from one outlier, the
difference between the fxcor velocity and that mea-
sured by eye for the galaxy identifications with cross-
correlation peak heights above 0.3 also was fairly well
fit by a gaussian with σ of 85 km/s.
In the end we obtained 129 definite galaxies, 43
possible galaxies, 86 definite stars, 4 possible stars,
10 fibers that had to be unplugged due to over-
illumination (which were hence almost certainly stars),
37 fibers which showed no flux (either very low surface
brightness galaxies or positional errors) and 21 spec-
tra which showed flux but which were unclassifiable
either as stars or galaxies (based on very low cross-
correlation peak heights from fxcor and visual inspec-
tion). We should reiterate that a much higher 'suc-
cess' rate in finding galaxies could have been achieved
by raising the cutoff 'sigma' value used in choosing
galaxies from the APM scans, at the cost of missing
some compact galaxies.
We present in table 1 the resulting galaxy red-
shifts. For each object, the table lists the RA and
Dec, an approximate B magnitude and the heliocen-
tric radial velocity. The magnitudes were calculated
using the APM isophotal magnitudes measured from
the plates, crudely calibrated using the B magnitudes
listed by Stockton 1980 and Salzer 1992 for objects
in the scanned region. They could be in error by as
much as 0.5.
A number of the brightest galaxies in the field were
not included in the fiber survey. Those with known
redshifts within the survey region were added to the
sample (4 objects taken from the May 5 1990 version
of the CfA Redshift Catalog, Huchra 1990). This
gives a total sample of 176 galaxies with redshifts
within the survey region which is roughly complete
to a B magnitude of 19.0.
We plot the results of the survey in a number of
projections. Figure 3 shows a redshift histogram of
the galaxies, figure 4 shows the distribution of galax-
ies on the sky, while figure 5 shows the pie-diagrams
obtained.
3. Analysis
In this section we go through each of the three
observations described in § 2. in turn, deriving con-
straints on the absorbers. In § 3.1. we derive limits on
Hα line emission at the velocities of the narrow-band
filters and in § 3.2. we calculate the maximum abso-
lute magnitude a dwarf galaxy could have and remain
undetected in our broad-band imaging. A long de-
scription of the correlation analysis between the Lyα
absorbers and the galaxies found in the fiber survey is
given in § 3.3., in which the various available absorber
and galaxy sub-samples are discussed, and two al-
ternative extreme hypotheses for the absorber-galaxy
correlation function are tested. Finally in § 3.4. we
discuss some particular aspects of the absorber-galaxy
distribution found in the 3C273 sightline.
3.1. Flux Limits for Hα Line Emission
The final continuum-subtracted coronagraph im-
ages have a measured rms dispersion (away from
residuals due to bright stars) of 0.0018 DN/pixel/s.
From calibration observations of HD84937, this is
equivalent to a 1σ flux limit of 2.10−18 ergs/cm2/s/⊓⊔′′,
equivalent to an emission measure of approximately
6
2.8 pc cm−6. By blinking the images, it can be seen
that none of the objects visible in the broad-band
images have emission line fluxes > 3σ. For compari-
son, the VN2 image of Mkn49 showed a peak Hα line
flux of 3.10−14 ergs/cm2/s/⊓⊔′′, i.e. 5,000 times higher
than our 3σ detection limit. One can also perform the
following thought experiment. What would the Orion
nebula look like if placed at the distance of the Virgo
cluster? As discussed in Kennicutt 1984, the Orion
nebula is actually a relatively low luminosity H II re-
gion, with an Hα luminosity of only 1037 ergs/s. Nev-
ertheless, if placed at a distance of 16 Mpc, it would
still have a flux of 1.3 10−15 ergs/cm2/s (and would
be unresolved - the nebula has a diameter of 5 pc,
while at Virgo, 1′′ corresponds to approximately 80
pc). Thus it would be a factor 220 brighter than our
3σ limit. One can also calculate that the Stromgren
sphere around a single main sequence star of spec-
tral class ∼B1/⊓⊔′′ would be detectable at the 3σ level
(Allen 1973).
Unfortunately, the expected surface brightness of
an optically thick slab of hydrogen, simply bathed
in the local UV background would not be detectable.
Taking the limit on the UV background from Songaila,
Bryant and Cowie 1989, and using the formulae from
Osterbrock 1989, one finds a surface brightness of
≤ 3.10−19 ergs/cm2/s/⊓⊔′′, about a factor 20 below
our 3σ limit.
Higher spectral and spatial resolution data have
been taken by T. Williams (private communication)
using the Rutgers Fabry-Perot system at the CTIO
4m telescope. This data has not been fully analysed,
but should produce even lower surface brightness lim-
its (or detection) than our data.
3.2. Limiting Magnitude for detection of Low
Surface Brightness Dwarf Galaxies
The main motivation for taking the COSMIC im-
ages was to determine whether there were any dwarf
galaxies within a 40 kpc radius from the line of sight
to 3C273 which are too faint to be visible on the POSS
sky survey plates. Examples of low surface brightness
dwarfs in the Virgo cluster can be seen in Sandage
and Bingelli 1984. In order to determine how faint
a dwarf galaxy, which had morphological properties
typical of those found in the Virgo cluster, would be
detectable in our image, we used the IRAF artdata
package to insert artificial dwarf galaxies into the data
array. The magnitude scale was derived by assuming
that the sky background in the Gunn r band (before
the moon rose) was 21.5 (Massey 1990). B absolute
magnitudes were converted to Gunn r assuming a B-R
color of 1.0 (B-V of 0.7), and a conversion from R to
Gunn r of r=R+0.43+0.15(B-V) (Kent 1985). Thus a
dwarf galaxy with MB=-15.5 was taken to have Mr=-
16.0. The Virgo distance modulus was taken to be
31.02. Dwarf galaxy properties were taken from Bin-
gelli, Sandage and Tammann 1985. In particular, typ-
ical exponential scale lengths4 for Virgo dwarfs were
taken to be 2-4 kpc. Figure 6 shows the same data as
figure 2, but with three dwarf galaxies added. One to
the NE with MB=-14.5 and scale length 4.4 kpc, one
to the NW with MB=-13.5 and scale length 2.2 kpc,
and one to the SW with MB=-13.5 and scale length
4.4 kpc. These experiments demonstrated that we
would be able to detect dwarf galaxies as faint as -13.5
at the distance of Virgo, having morphological prop-
erties similar to those found near the cluster center.
For comparison, the dwarf galaxy illustrated in figure
2, panel 4, labelled '15◦47' of Sandage and Bingelli
1984 has an absolute B magnitude of -14.8.
A complementary approach is to search for H I
21 cm emission from Virgo dwarf galaxies. Re-
cently, van Gorkom and her collaborators have set
extremely low limits with the VLA over a 40×40
arcmin field centered on 3C273 and over a velocity
range of about 1000 km/s centered on 1300 km/s to
a 1 sigma column-density limit of approximately 1019
cm−2 (van Gorkom 1993, van Gorkom et al. 1993).
3.3. Correlations between Lyman α Absorbers
and Galaxies
We have shown there are no H II regions, or other
strong Hα line-emitting gas, or dwarf galaxies near
the Virgo absorbers. Having determined the redshift
distribution of galaxies near the sightline to 3C273,
(§ 2.3.) we would now like to address the statisti-
cal question of the degree to which the Lyman α ab-
sorbers are correlated with luminous galaxies. If they
are correlated, is the Lyman α absorber-galaxy cor-
relation the same as the galaxy-galaxy correlation?
A cursory inspection of figure 5 is enough to show
that there will not be a simple answer to this ques-
tion. While there do seem to be Lyman α absorbers
associated with clumps of galaxies (e.g.
the Virgo
absorbers, or the set of absorbers around z=0.02-
0.03), there are also absorbers in conspicuous 'voids'
(at z=0.06-0.07), and there are no absorbers associ-
4Scale Length=R0, with Intensity ∝ exp(−1.6783 × R/R0)
7
ated with the prominent excess of galaxies at z=0.078.
We consider statistical tests for various assumptions
about the correlation between the Lyman α absorbers
and the galaxies near the sightline towards 3C273 for
which we have redshift information. Ultimately, the
goal should be a quantitative and complete statistical
description of the clustering properties of the Lyman
α absorbers themselves and their correlation with var-
ious types of galaxies, clusters, voids etc. Given both
our rather meagre understanding of this problem and
the small data set, we shall concentrate on testing
the following two extreme null hypotheses about the
Lyman α absorber clustering properties:
1. The Lyman α absorbers are uncorrelated with
galaxies and are randomly distributed.
(The
second part of this assumption necessarily im-
plies the first, but the converse is not necessarily
true: The absorbers could be correlated among
themselves but be uncorrelated with galaxies)
2. The Lyman α absorbers are correlated with
galaxies in the same way that galaxies are corre-
lated. More precise formulations of this hypoth-
esis depend upon the particular test applied, as
described below.
In carrying out most of the tests described below,
it is necessary to compute the 3-dimensional distance
between every absorber-galaxy or every galaxy-galaxy
pair. The question arises as to how to compute the
component along the line of sight, since departures
from a perfectly smooth Hubble flow distort the map-
ping of redshift onto radial distance. With no infor-
mation other than the angular coordinates and red-
shifts for the objects, we cannot uniquely determine
the separation along the line of sight for any individ-
ual pair of objects. For purposes of statistical tests
we therefore make two different assumptions about
this component; the degree to which we do or do not
derive similar results will provide some indication of
the sensitivity of the test to the uncertainty in the
estimation of this component:
1. We simply ignore any departures from Hubble
flow
2. We adopt the formalism of Davis and Peebles
1983 to estimate this component. These au-
thors show how, knowing the two-point correla-
tion function for the projected distance between
pairs, in principal one can invert the integral
equation relating the projected distance corre-
lation function to the three-dimensional spatial
correlation function. However, for our limited
and rather noisy sample, this is not a very sat-
isfactory procedure. Moreover, we would like
statistical estimates for the 3-dimensional sepa-
ration for each pair for the purposes of carrying
out other types of tests (e.g. nearest neighbor
tests). We therefore use the Davis-Peebles for-
malism as follows: Adopting the assumptions
described in their paper, the integrand in their
equation (22) represents the probability that a
pair with projected separation rp Mpc and ve-
locity difference π km/s has a separation in the
radial direction of y Mpc. We further assume
their functional form for h(r) in their equation
(23), with the parameter F = 1, and adopt their
functional form for f(V), the probability of the
relative velocity difference, as well as their ex-
pression for σ, the dispersion in f(V), i.e. their
equation (32). For rp >> ro or π >> Ho × ro,
where ro is the characteristic correlation length,
the probability is strongly peaked at y ∼ Ho ×π,
i.e., the pair separation is very likely to be that
given by assuming a pure Hubble flow. How-
ever, as both of these inequalities fail to be sat-
isfied, a second maximum in the probability dis-
tribution arises at y ≈ 0 whose height depends
upon the strength of the correlation - i.e., a pair
with a moderate velocity separation and small
projected separation may be separated by their
Hubble flow distance, but if the correlation be-
tween such pairs is strong, this moderate ve-
locity separation is more likely to arise from a
pair at about the same distance from us, with
strong gravitational interaction between them.
As noted at the outset of this discussion there
is no way to unambiguously determine the rel-
ative separation of any pair along the line of
sight, but since we are interested in statistical
applications we adopt the expectation value of
this probability distribution as our second alter-
native algorithm.
A problem with this second approach is that evalu-
ating the probability distribution for the radial sep-
aration of the pair requires that we know in advance
the two-point correlation function between the pair.
Ideally, we could have dealt with this problem by
using an iterative approach:
for both the absorber-
8
galaxy and galaxy-galaxy pairs separately, we start
with some "fiducial estimates" for the two-point cor-
relation (e.g. ro = 5.4h−1 Mpc and γ = 1.77 ; c.f.
equation 19 in Davis and Peebles) to compute the ex-
pectation value of the radial separation for each pair,
and thus compute the two-point correlation functions.
With these new, separate best-fit values of γ and ro
for the correlation functions for the galaxy-absorber
pairs and the galaxy-galaxy pairs, we could then re-
peat the process until the parameters for the two-
point correlation functions have converged. In fact,
since the results of our statistical tests do not appear
to be very sensitive to departures from a pure Hubble
flow, we have not carried out this iteration, but have
simply used the single set of parameters (ro = 5.4h−1
Mpc and γ = 1.77) in calculating the expectation val-
ues for both sets of pairs.
In the following, we refer to these two algorithms
for estimating the radial separations as the "pure
Hubble flow" and "perturbed Hubble flow" cases.
When listing object separations in the following sec-
tions we will give the separations found from the ex-
pectation value of the perturbed Hubble flow model
in brackets following the value for the pure Hubble
flow model.
Before carrying out any statistical tests we define
the two samples and discuss appropriate corrections
for completeness.
3.3.1. The Lyman α Sample
A carefully defined list of Lyman α absorption lines
is essential to a proper statistical discussion of the cor-
relation properties of Lyman α absorbers with galax-
ies. The preferred list would obviously be drawn from
a homogenous set of observations with the smallest
detectable equivalent width covering all or most of
the relevant redshift range.
Several
line lists for the 3C273 sight line have
been published (Morris et al. 1991, Bahcall et al.
1991a, Bahcall et al. 1991b, Brandt et al. 1993, Bah-
call et al. 1993). These line lists are compared in
table 2. However, not only are these lists based upon
3 different HST spectrograph configurations (GHRS
G160M, GHRS G140L, FOS G130) but they have
also been produced by different reduction procedures
and line-finding and measuring algorithms and with
differing acceptance criteria for what constitutes a
"real" line. To investigate the importance of this lat-
ter source of inhomogeneity we have run the same
continuum fitting, absorption line-finding and line-
measuring software, "JASON", used for the FOS line
list, which is described in detail by Schneider et al.
19935 on the data sets of Morris et al. 1991 and
Brandt et al. 1993. The JASON software was de-
signed to run on FOS data with an approximately
gaussian point spread function (PSF). Unfortunately
this is not a good representation for the GHRS large
aperture PSF, and also in general the lines were re-
solved - meaning that the observed line profiles had
neither the instrumental PSF nor a gaussian shape.
The current version of JASON does not perform such
convolutions, and so we have run the search routines
assuming a fixed PSF with the correct (non-gaussian)
shape for the GHRS, but with no account taken for
resolved lines. This means that the EWs output by
the JASON software are not accurate, but the detec-
tion significance levels are approximately correct (see
Schneider et al. 1993). The data set used is that
described by Brandt et al. 1993. We tabulate the sig-
nificance levels from JASON for the Lyman α lines in
column 5 of table 2, after the positions and EWs pub-
lished in Brandt et al. 1993. It can be seen that all
of the 'reliable' lines listed by Morris et al. 1991 are
confirmed by the JASON software, with the notable
exception of the line at λ1276.54, which was also not
found by Brandt et al. 1993. We checked this line
by running the JASON software on the original data
used by Morris et al. 1991, obtaining a significance
level of 4.5 for the line. The line finding and fitting
software used in Morris et al. 1991 was developed by
R. Carswell and J. Webb, and is described in that
paper. It used the GHRS PSF convolved with a Voit
profile with variable width.
Two other entries in table 2 require special com-
ment: The line at λ=1317.08 is identified as Lyman α
in the list of Bahcall et al. 1991b whereas in the list
of Morris et al. 1991 it is identified as Ni II. This is-
sue has been discussed in detail in Brandt et al. 1993
who give reasons for preferring the Ni II identifica-
tion which we adopt. The second case involves the
line at λ=1393.86. As discussed in detail by Savage
et al. 1993 this line appears to be a blend of one of
the members of the galactic Si IV doublet and an-
other strong line, whose only plausible indentification
is Lyman α. The procedure used by Morris et al.
1991 in estimating the strength of this line (which in-
5We thank D. Schneider for kindly making available the most
recent version of JASON and for instruction in its use.
volves a detailed comparison of the line profiles of the
Si IV doublet) is not incorporated into the JASON
formalism. For this reason we cannot assign a formal
uncertainty in the line strength. However the resid-
uals from an unblended fit to the Si IV doublet are
highly significant.
As a result of the above considerations, we have
decided to adopt the following samples of absorbers
for our statistical tests: (1) For the Lyman α ab-
sorber "full sample" we adopt the list of 16 Lyman
α absorbers (and their redshifts) given in Morris et
al. 1991 along with the additional low-redshift line
(λ1224.52) given by Bahcall et al. 1991a; as noted in
table 2, this last line is visible in the GHRS G140L
spectra but was below the significance threshold of
Morris et al. 1991. This "full sample" is inhomoge-
nous and/or biased in three senses: i) The high resolu-
tion GHRS data covers only redshifts above z∼0.016;
below this, only the FOS data of Bahcall et al. 1991b
and the GHRS G140L low resolution data are avail-
able. (Observations with the GHRS G160M grating
in the redshift regime from 0.0 to 0.016 are sched-
uled for HST Cycle 3). Thus, the full sample may
be biased against weak low-redshift lines in this red-
shift range that may be detected by these Cycle 3
observations. ii) The line of sight toward 3C273 may
be somewhat atypical in that it passes through the
southern extension of the Virgo cluster. iii) Some of
the weakest lines listed as "possible" in the Morris
et al. 1991 list may not be real. Accordingly, along
with the full sample of 17 lines, we shall also con-
sider two subsamples: (2) A "homogeneous sample"
made of the set of 14 lines found only with the GHRS
G160M observations using the original Carswell and
Webb software (i.e. all but the first 3 lines in column
1 of table 2). (As it happens, this is also equivalent
to deleting the 3 low-redshift (z∼<0.016) lines possi-
bly associated with the Virgo cluster). (3) A "strong
sample" composed of the set of 10 lines from Morris
et al. 1991 with -log(P)>7.5 (but including the line
at z=0.14658 for which a formal probability estimate
was not possible due to blending - i.e. the above sam-
ple with the lines marked 'd' in the comments column
of table 2 removed). We have listed the sample mem-
bership in the final column of table 2. Note that in
contrast to the galaxy sample discussed below there is
no intrinsic observational selection against the higher
redshift absorbers.
One could, of course, define further samples.
In
particular, at the request of the referee, we have also
9
run our statistical tests of the complete set of 5 lines
listed in Bahcall et al. 1993 (i.e. the line list in col-
umn 8 of table 2). Unfortunately, the number of
lines in this list is so small that neither of the two
null hypotheses considered below in connection with
cloud-galaxy association can be rejected with any sig-
nificance. For this reason, and in order to keep the
various combinations of absorption line and galaxy
samples to managable proportions, we limit our ta-
bles of statistical results to consideration of the three
samples defined above.
3.3.2. The Galaxy Sample
An appropriate sample of galaxies with which to
carry out the correlation analysis would be one which
is complete to some limiting absolute magnitude through-
out a cylindrical volume centered on the 3C273 sight-
line (i.e. out to a constant impact parameter) with a
radius large enough to sample most of the expected
power in the correlation function and length over (and
beyond) the full redshift range covered by the Ly-
man α line sample. The observed sample described
in § 2.3. fails this requirement in two obvious respects:
i) It detects only the more luminous galaxies at the
higher redshifts, ii) It contains no galaxies with large
impact parameters at low-redshifts. For some tests
these deficiencies are probably not important but for
others they are. Accordingly, we will consider two
galaxy samples. The first is the sample described in
§ 2.3., which we will refer to as the 'cone' sample. The
second is the cone sample together with all galaxies
from the May 5 1990 version of the CfA Redshift Cat-
alog, (Huchra 1990) within 10 Mpc of the 3C273 line-
of-sight. This gives a heterogeneous sample with an
unknown selection function, but is closer to the ideal
'filled cylinder' than the cone sample. It contains 1498
galaxies, the vast majority being at Virgo distances,
and will be referred to as the 'cylinder' sample.
Thus for each hypothesis tested below there are 6
galaxy-absorber sample combinations, and 2 possible
estimates for the distance between every pair of ob-
jects giving a total of 12 data sets for each statistical
test.
3.3.3. Tests of the 1st Null Hypothesis: The Lyman
α absorbers are uncorrelated with galaxies
It is obvious that this hypothesis cannot literally be
true - every sightline that passes close to any galaxy,
except those utterly devoid of gas, will surely pro-
10
duce a detectable Lyman α line, and indeed examples
of this are already known (Bahcall et al. 1992a, Bah-
call et al. 1992b). Nevertheless, in light of the fact
that the high-redshift Lyman α absorbers show al-
most no power in their two-point correlation function
(c.f. Rauch et al. 1992 and references therein) it is of
interest to see if the present data set does or does not
exclude this hypothesis, and if it does, how strongly.
Having formulated this null hypothesis we consider
two statistics as measures of correlation (or lack of it):
1. The average over all the Lyman α absorbers of
the distance between a given Lyman α absorber
and the N nearest galaxies in the sample, with
N=1,3 and 5.
2. The total number of absorber-galaxy pairs within
a fixed radius R, with R=500 kpc and 10 Mpc.
In order to see whether the values of these observed
statistics are such that the null hypothesis can be re-
jected, we must find the distribution of these same
statistics for many realizations of the null hypothesis.
To do this, we carry out 1000 Monte Carlo simula-
tions in which the same number of absorbers as that
of the particular Lyman α sample under considera-
tion are laid down randomly (but follow the "global"
distribution dN/dz ∼ (1+z)0.3 as determined by Bah-
call et al. 1993). Redshift limits for the random ab-
sorbers were 0.03<z<0.151 for the total sample, and
0.016<z<0.151 for the homogeneous and strong sam-
ples.
The results for the nearest-neighbour tests are
summarised in table 3. We show results for the single
nearest neighbour galaxy, the mean of the 3 near-
est and the mean of the 5 nearest. For each case,
the three columns list the observed mean nearest-
neighbour(s) distance, the average of the mean nearest-
neighbour(s) distances produced by the Monte Carlo
simulations, and the number of the 1000 Monte Carlo
simulations that had a mean nearest-neighbour dis-
tance less than the observed one. Thus this last col-
umn, divided by 1000, can be taken as the probability
that the observed value could arise from a sample of
absorbers distributed at random with respect to the
galaxies.
The most striking result is that there is a less than
0.1% probability that the average nearest-neighbour
distance to the single closest galaxy could arise from
a randomly distributed set of absorbers. This is true
for all sample combinations, and for either pure or
perturbed Hubble flow. For all samples, as one in-
cludes more galaxies in the nearest-neighbour aver-
age, the significance drops. After seeing this result,
we wanted to test whether all the significance came
from the nearest galaxy, and so ran tests on the sec-
ond nearest galaxy only (also given in table 3). One
can see that the observed mean distance is still signif-
icantly lower than that expected for a randomly dis-
tributed set of absorbers, but this could be explained
by a combination of the highly significant correlation
with the nearest galaxy and the strong galaxy-galaxy
two-point correlation. This point is discussed in some
detail by Phillips, Disney and Davies 1993 in the con-
text of bright galaxies found near quasar MgII ab-
sorbers.
We also give in table 4 the RA, Dec and redshift
of the nearest galaxy in the 'cylinder' sample to each
Lyα absorbers of the 'total' sample (assuming pure
Hubble flow). The final column in this table is the
minimum absolute magnitude that could have been
detected in the fiber survey. This shows that for one
absorber there is no known galaxy with absolute mag-
nitude above -17.8 within nearly 10 Mpc, (the same
distance for the perturbed Hubble flow model) and
that even the nearest absorber-galaxy pair in our sam-
ple are separated by 350 kpc (240 kpc). We will return
to this in § 3.4.
The results for the number of galaxies within a
fixed radius of each absorber are given in table 5.
These tests are essentially a comparison of the in-
tegrated two-point correlation function out to the
given radius (see Mo et al.
1992 for a discussion
of this point). The numbers given in the table are
the observed number of absorber-galaxy pairs within
the given radius, the average of the number of pairs
found in 1000 Monte Carlo simulations with randomly
distributed absorbers, and the number of the Monte
Carlo simulations with a larger number of pairs than
that observed. Thus the final column divided by 1000
is the probability that the observed numbers of pairs
or more would arise from a random distribution of
absorbers.
Table 5 shows that there is no significant excess
of galaxies within volumes of radius 10 Mpc centered
on the absorbers compared to a random distribution,
apart from the cylinder/total subsample. For this
combination there are a large number of pairs between
the Virgo absorbers and the many Virgo galaxies in
the CfA catalog. This result may be interpreted as
saying that it is surprising to find 3 out of 17 absorbers
below z=0.008 (although see § 3.4.3.). There is a
marginally significant excess of absorber-galaxy pairs
within 500 kpc, over that expected for a random dis-
tribution of absorbers, although the inclusion of the
Virgo velocity range removes the significance of this
result. In summary, these tests seem to be consistent
with the nearest-neighbour distance results, showing
that there is an excess of close pairs of absorbers and
galaxies, but that this result vanishes if the averaging
is done over several galaxies or large radii.
3.3.4. Tests of the 2nd Null Hypothesis:
Identi-
cal Lyman α absorber-Galaxy, Galaxy-Galaxy
Correlations
In order to test this hypothesis, one would like to
use the same tests as were used in § 3.3.3. A diffi-
culty arises though in generating a large number of
Monte Carlo samples. We are loathe to compare the
observed distributions with simulations involving any-
thing other than the actual observed galaxy distribu-
tion since differences between the observations and
simulations (based, for example on n-body or other
galaxy clustering models) may result simply from in-
adequacies of such models, and it is not clear how to
create simulations of (fake) absorber-(real) galaxy dis-
tributions having cross correlation properties which
are the same as the observed galaxy-galaxy correla-
tion properties.
One way to deal with this difficulty is to use a test
which does not require the generation of Monte Carlo
samples: If the absorbers are distributed in the same
way as the galaxies, then, given the pencil-beam na-
ture of the galaxy sample, the redshift distributions
of the absorbers and the galaxies should be identical,
after correction for differing selection effects in the
two samples. Table 6 shows the Kolmogorov-Smirnov
D-values and probabilities that the absorber redshift
distribution is the same as that of the galaxies, after
the galaxy distribution is corrected using the selec-
tion function shown in figure 3. This selection func-
tion was derived by assuming a Schechter luminos-
ity function with M∗=-19.5 and α=-0.97 (Loveday et
al. 1992). Because this test requires a known selec-
tion function, it can only be run for the 'cone' galaxy
sample. Also, as it directly compares the redshifts, it
does not require any assumptions about pure or per-
turbed Hubble flow. It can be seen from table 6 that
when all the absorption lines are included there is a
highly significant difference in the redshift distribu-
tions. This significance level becomes marginal when
11
the Virgo absorbers are removed, and vanishes when
only strong absorbers beyond Virgo are considered.
Our other test of the hypothesis that the absorbers
and galaxies have identical correlation functions uses
the observed galaxy sample to generate our Monte
Carlo 'absorber' sample. For each realization a num-
ber of the actual galaxy redshifts were selected at
random, and were treated as absorbers on the 3C273
sightline. The actual algorithm involved selecting at
random a number of the observed galaxy redshifts
equal to the number in the absorber sample (making
no correction for the galaxy selection function, and
with no restriction on how close together the chosen
galaxies were), and treating these redshifts as if they
were measured absorber redshifts on the 3C273 line
of sight. The galaxies which provided these redshifts
were removed from the galaxy sample for each test,
to avoid an excess of 'spurious' pairs6. The number
of absorber-galaxy pairs within a given radius were
determined for both the real and 1000 Monte Carlo
samples, in an identical manner to the second test in
§ 3.3.3. above. This procedure should be valid as long
as the radius within which the pair counts are being
made is significantly larger than the typical distance
between a galaxy and the 3C273 line-of-sight. Be-
cause of this, tests were not run for a 500 kpc radius.
The results from these tests are given in table 7. The
columns are the same as for table 5, except that the
final column lists the number of Monte Carlo runs
with fewer absorber-galaxy pairs than the real sam-
ple. Thus this number divided by 1000 is the prob-
ability that the absorbers could have a correlation
function as strong as that between galaxies. As can
be seen, the absorber-galaxy correlation function av-
eraged over 10 Mpc is significantly weaker than that
between galaxies.
In summary, the two tests above seem to show
that the absorber-galaxy correlation function is sig-
nificantly weaker than the galaxy-galaxy correlation
function over large scales (10 Mpc). Even though
there is clear evidence for galaxy-absorber clustering,
there is a significant difference between the strength
with which the galaxies are clustered with respect to
each other and the strength with which the Lyman α
6In fact leaving in the galaxies would allow one to model a situ-
ation where the absorbers were actually part of the halo of one
of the observed galaxies, although some maximum halo size
would also have to be imposed to make the simulation realis-
tic. We are investigating this point in more detail, and a paper
is in preparation (Mo, Morris and Weymann 1993)
absorbers are associated with galaxies.
Some of the results of the two preceding sections
can be inferred directly by inspection of the actual
two-point correlation functions themselves. A log-
arithmically binned version of the correlation func-
tions for pure and perturbed Hubble flows are shown
in figure 7. The absorber-galaxy correlation function
was generated using the total Lyman α sample and
the cone galaxy sample. The correlation functions
were normalised in the usual way using random sam-
ples with the selection function shown in figure 3.
The error bars were estimated using the formulae in
Mo, Jing and Borner 1992. As expected, the pure
and perturbed Hubble flow models agree fairly well
for separations larger than one or two Mpc; the per-
turbed Hubble flow model produces more very close
pairs, since even small velocity differences wipe out
small separations for the pure Hubble flow model. In
both cases, the absorber-galaxy correlation is clearly
weaker than the galaxy-galaxy correlation on scales
from about 1-10 Mpc. However, although visual in-
spection of the absorber-galaxy correlation function
may suggest that the correlation is significant out to
about 10 Mpc, in fact the pair tests summarized in
table 5 and the nearest neighbor tests summarized in
table 3 both indicate that a statistically significant
absorber-galaxy correlations can be detected in our
data sets only over volumes which are smaller than
this.
3.4. Some Particular Cases of Interest
3.4.1. The Closest Absorber-Galaxy Associations
Actual associations between individual observed
galaxies and absorbers in the 3C273 sight line are dif-
ficult to prove for a number of reasons: (1) The small-
est projected distance to the 3C273 line-of-sight of all
the galaxies in our sample is still 160 kpc. (2) Galaxy
rotation or velocity dispersions could produce veloc-
ity differences as large as 200 km/s between the mean
galaxy velocity and an actually associated absorber
(also comparable to the 3σ error in our fiber data
velocity measurements) (3) In regions of high galaxy
density along the line-of-sight, peculiar motions of the
galaxies and the absorbers in cluster potential wells
may make the velocity-distance relationship complex.
This is especially true of the Virgo region, and for
the z=0.0034 and 0.0053 absorbers (which also lie on
the steep portion of the damping wings of the galactic
Lyman α, and have only been observed at low resolu-
12
tion). With these caveats, it can be seen from table 4
that the closest absorber-galaxy pair has a separa-
tion of 350 kpc (240 kpc). Outside of the Virgo re-
gion (where the velocity-distance relationship may be
less complex, but also where our galaxy sample goes
to much less faint absolute magnitudes), the smallest
separation is 410 kpc (350 kpc).
The best published example of an association be-
tween a Lyman α absorber and a galaxy is given in
Bahcall et al. 1992a, where they find a galaxy within
90 kpc of the sightline to H1821+643 which has a
strong Lyman α absorber (EW 950 mA) within 400
km/s. There are no galaxies in our sample this close
to the line of sight (or indeed any absorption systems
this strong).
One can (somewhat arbitrarily) break the absorbers
in our sample into two groups: (1) those with a galaxy
within 1 Mpc of the line-of sight, and with a velocity
difference of less than 400 km/s (all of the Virgo sys-
tems and 6 of the higher-redshift systems. Despite its
entry in table 4, the absorber at z=0.02622 actually
has 2 galaxies within 400 km/s and 1 Mpc projected
separation. They do not appear in the table, as their
large velocity differences (>250 km/s) make their sep-
aration large, assuming pure Hubble flow), and (2) the
rest (8 systems). There is no significant difference in
the EW distribution of these two samples.
Our data can also be used to consider the ques-
tion: What is the average galaxy diameter within
which one would see a neutral-hydrogen column den-
sity of at least 1013 cm−2? In practice this is rather
a naive question, as the cross-section almost certainly
depends on galaxy luminosity and probably also mor-
phology. One might also expect a patchy distribu-
tion of neutral-hydrogen in the outer parts of galaxies
leading to a covering factor not equal to one. Never-
theless, ignoring these complications, and excluding
the Virgo velocity range due to (a) the possibility of
large peculiar velocities (b) a wish to avoid the large
range of intrinsic galaxy luminosities in the sample
and (c) because our absorber EW limit is higher in
this region, we find that of the 12 galaxies with pro-
jected separation to the line-of-sight less than 1 Mpc,
8 show Lyman absorption systems within 400 km/s.
A velocity difference of up to about 400 km/s could
possibly be attributed to internal motions within a
large galaxy, coupled with our measuring error, or al-
ternatively to a small group. Having 8 or more such
matches would occur 0.6% of the time if the absorbers
were randomly distributed in velocity space. How-
13
ever, of these 8 galaxies, two are associated with the
absorber at z=0.02622, and three with the absorber
at z=0.2933. Clearly several distinct galaxies can not
be producing the same absorber, and so in fact only 5
of the 12 systems within 1 Mpc of the line-of-sight to
the quasar can be legitimately associated with indi-
vidual absorbers. Reducing the projected separation
to 500 kpc, one finds 3 galaxies, with velocity sep-
arations of 20, 120 and 0 km/s (see table 3). This
may be interpreted as saying that the cross-section of
galaxies with luminosities greater than 1/10 of L∗ for
log(NH)> 1013 is between 0.5 and 1 Mpc, although
by "cross-section" we do not mean that the absorbers
are neccesarily associated with the actual galaxy in
question.
Because of the 3 Virgo absorbers, all of the Virgo
galaxies have an absorber within 400 km/s. However,
it is clearly unreasonable to suggest that more than
one galaxy is associated with a given absorber. Thus
of the 19 Virgo galaxies within 500 kpc of the line-
of-sight, 16 must not be producing absorption. Of
these 19, 2 have absolute magnitudes brighter than
1/10 L∗, and so are consistent with the above state-
ment, despite the higher absorber EW limit, as long
as only one of the galaxies with luminosity <1/10 L∗
is producing observed absorption.
3.4.2. The Most Isolated Lyman α Absorbers
One of the stronger lines in our absorber sample
is also the most isolated. Any galaxy brighter than
-18 would be in our sample at the redshift of the iso-
lated z=0.06655 absorber. However, the nearest such
galaxy has a projected separation of 4.75 Mpc and
a velocity difference of 710 km/s, which corresponds
to a spatial separation of 10 Mpc for both pure and
perturbed Hubble flow models. Indeed studying the
galaxy distribution in figure 5, the three absorbers
with 0.060<z<0.07 seem to lie in a 'void' in the galaxy
distribution. While it is certainly possible that these
absorbers are associated with galaxies below our ab-
solute magnitude limit, these isolated absorbers are a
clear demonstration that one can not associate ALL
low-redshift Lyman α absorbers with luminous (L∗)
galaxies.
3.4.3. The Absence of Lyman α Absorbers in the z
∼ 0.078 Galaxy Concentration
The most striking feature of the observed galaxy
redshift distribution is a concentration of galaxies cen-
tered at a redshift of z ∼ 0.078. This excess is almost
certainly associated with a structure which includes
the galaxy cluster Abell 1564. This cluster has a tab-
ulated center at 12:32:25 +02:07:11 (1950), giving it
an offset of 89′ SW of the 3C273 sightline. This angle
corresponds to a separation of 7.3 Mpc at the clus-
ter distance. Abell 1564 is the closest Abell cluster
to the 3C273 sightline, but is only richness class 0.
Redshifts for two member galaxies are given in Met-
calfe et al. 1989, giving an average cluster redshift of
0.0793. Selecting all galaxies in our fiber sample with
redshifts between 0.07 and 0.085 (54 galaxies), one
derives a mean redshift of 0.0781 with rms of 0.0021
(630 km/s). For comparison, selecting galaxies be-
tween redshifts of 0.15 and 0.17 (the cluster around
3C273, see figure 3), one gets 24 galaxies with mean
redshift 0.1581 and rms 0.0024 (720 km/s).
Despite the location of Abell 1564 to the SW, the
galaxies in the redshift slice 0.07-0.085 show a weak
concentration to the NE of the fiber field, although
there are galaxies in all parts of the fiber area sur-
veyed. If they are really part of a structure includ-
ing A1564, the structure must have a size of at least
8 Mpc. However, the nearest Lyman α absorber is
0.0095 from the peak in redshift space (or 2850 km/s,
which is 4.5 times the rms from the mean of the con-
centration) and is at a distance of 36 Mpc from the
center of the concentration.
It thus seems unlikely
that there are any observed Lyman α absorbers in
our line of sight which are physically associated with
this concentration.
We can test a slightly different form of the hypoth-
esis considered in § 3.3.4., (though we grant its appli-
cation to the z ∼ 0.078 galaxy concentration involves
post facto statistics), namely: What is the probabil-
ity that, if the Lyman α absorbers are distributed in
space "in the same way" as the galaxies in our sam-
ple, we should find the observed number of Lyman α
absorbers (none, in our case). By "in the same way"
we mean that:
(cid:18) ρLyα(~r)
ρLyα (cid:19) = (cid:18) ρgalaxy(~r)
ρgalaxy (cid:19)
and by "in the vicinity of" we shall mean within
±2.5 × rms of the redshift peak of the concentration.
We consider that our selection function can be mean-
ingfully applied over the redshift range from about
z= 0.016 out to our adopted "proximity cutoff" at
z= 0.151. Carrying out the integration of our sam-
ple (i.e. the galaxy numbers weighted by the selection
14
function) between ±2.5×rms of the peak of the galaxy
concentration and over the redshift range from 0.016
to 0.151 we find that after correction for the selection
function, about 0.33 of an absolute-magnitude-limited
cylindrical sample of galaxies should be found within
2.5σ of the velocity peak of this structure. Since the
Lyman α absorbers are not subject to such a selec-
tion function, we can apply this equation to all the
volume elements along the line of sight and, assuming
further that the effective cross-section of the Lyman
α absorbers (σ) is constant over the redshift range
0.016-0.151, one can write:
n × σ × [(zpeak + 2.5 × rms) − (zpeak − 2.5 × rms)]
= 0.33 × n × σ × [0.151 − 0.016]
This equation represents the number of Lyman α ab-
sorbers in the vicinity of the peak that we should ex-
pect to see if our hypothesis is correct. Over the red-
shift interval 0.016-0.151 we have observed up to 14
Lyman α absorbers so that we expect 0.33 × 14 ≈ 4.7
absorbers, and we observe none. The probability of
this occuring is thus exp(−4.7) ≈ 0.01. This is not a
strong result due to the rather small number of ab-
sorbers expected, and the post facto nature of the
test as we acknowledged above, but is additional sug-
gestive evidence that the Lyman α absorbers do not
follow the galaxy distribution and in particular that
they may avoid strong concentrations of galaxies. It
could be strengthened, of course, by observing addi-
tional lines of sight through dense concentrations.
It would be nice to repeat the above calculation
for the case of the three absorbers found in the Virgo
velocity region. However, there are a number of rea-
sons why any estimate of the probability of finding
three absorbers in this region with an apparent over-
density of galaxies is highly uncertain. Firstly, our
absorber sample is incomplete in this velocity range,
as described in § 3.3.1. Secondly, the area of sky sur-
veyed is so small that the selection function correc-
tion for this velocity range is very large. Taking our
selection function at face value, the 8 galaxies actu-
ally in our survey at Virgo velocities imply that 60%
of an absolute-magnitude-limited cylindrical galaxy
sample from z=0 to 0.151 would be found in that
velocity range. Our hypothesis above would then
predict that (neglecting the incompleteness of the
absorber sample) one would expect 0.6×17≈10 ab-
sorbers, when we only see 3. Unfortunately, it is not
possible to place a meaningful uncertainty on this ap-
parent under-density of absorbers in the Virgo region,
for the reasons listed above.
In summary, there is marginal evidence, both from
a clump of galaxies at z=0.078 and also from the
Virgo velocity range, that Lyman α absorbers are less
common in regions of high galaxy density.
4. Summary and Discussion
We have assembled several types of observations in
an attempt to find objects with which the Lyman α
absorbers along the line of sight to 3C273 might be
associated, and in order to carry out statistical tests
of galaxy-Lyman α absorber association. In particu-
lar, we obtained narrow-band images centered on and
off the expected position of any Hα emission which
might be associated with three of the low redshift Ly-
man α absorbers, and obtained deep broad-band im-
ages of a 17′×17′ field centered on 3C273. Both these
searches were negative. Our failure to identify any
broad-band or Hα emission from plausible "galaxy-
like" objects a few tens of kpc from the 3C273 sight
line at the approximate distance of the Virgo clus-
ter will be checked by more sensitive and extensive
searches for Hα by T. Williams (private communica-
tion) and 21 cm emission by van Gorkom 1993 and
van Gorkom et al. 1993.
We have also obtained redshifts for a large num-
ber of galaxies in the vicinity of the 3C273 sightline.
Again, we find no unambiguous instance of associa-
tion of any of the Lyman α absorbers with individual
galaxies. We define a number of samples for both the
Lyman α absorbers and the galaxies and estimate the
3-dimensional separation between each galaxy-galaxy
pair and each Lyman α absorber-galaxy pair based
upon two models for converting the observed redshift
difference between any pair into a radial separation,
viz.
i) the assumption of a pure Hubble flow and ii)
a statistical model of "perturbed" Hubble flow based
upon work of Davis and Peebles 1983. The result-
ing data base is used to carry out statistical tests to
confirm or reject two null hypotheses about the asso-
ciation of galaxies and Lyman α absorbers, namely:
i) The Lyman α absorbers show no tendency to clus-
ter around galaxies ii) The Lyman α absorbers cluster
around galaxies exactly as the galaxies cluster about
each other. While neither of these two hypotheses
can be unambiguously rejected in the sense that ev-
ery combination of samples and flow hypotheses reject
both of them at significant levels, the evidence from
these tests, and from the galaxy-galaxy and Lyman
α absorber-galaxy two-point correlations themselves,
points quite strongly to the conclusion that both hy-
potheses are false.
In particular, over length scales from about 1 to 10
Mpc there seems little doubt that the Lyman α ab-
sorbers cluster around galaxies less strongly than the
galaxies themselves cluster. This is born out by an
examination of a redshift interval centered at about
z=0.078 at which a strong concentration of galaxies
occurs but in the neighborhood of which there are
no Lyman α absorbers. Additionally, we find at least
one Lyman α absorber for which no galaxy with abso-
lute magnitude brighter than about -18 can be found
closer than about 5 Mpc. Taken together, all this ev-
idence suggests that the most significant conclusion
we have reached is that the majority of low-redshift
Lyman α absorbers are not intimately associated with
normal luminous galaxies.
In view of the fact that it has long been realized
that at high redshifts there is an absence of power in
the Lyman α absorber two-point correlation function
in redshift space, except possibly at the very smallest
velocity separations, this conclusion is not too sur-
prising. On the other hand, it is also fairly clear that
there is some tendency for the Lyman α absorbers to
cluster around galaxies, and even weak evidence that
this clustering becomes strong at very small separa-
tions. Also Bahcall et al. 1992a have investigated
the auto-correlation function of the low-redshift ab-
sorbers seen in the line-of-sight to H1821+643, and
show that there is only a 4% probability that the ob-
served 'clumping' arose from a randomly distributed
sample.
None of the foregoing points unambiguously, in our
estimation, to a particular model for the formation
and evolution of the Lyman α absorbers. As have oth-
ers, we simply offer the following speculations which
appear to be compatible with the facts as they are
presently understood:
At high redshifts, the Lyman α absorbers consist
primarily of entities which are only very loosely asso-
ciated with larger mass objects (e.g. proto galaxies),
and which are evolving fairly rapidly. Possibly this
dominant population consists of absorbers in which
gravitational binding (eg by dark matter) plays no
significant role.
In addition to this group, there is
a smaller population of absorbers which are evolving
less rapidly, possibly stabilized by dark matter and
which are clustered more strongly about galaxies. At
15
new Palomar Sky-survey plates, Alan Sandage for al-
lowing us to inspect one of his older IIIaJ plates, Mark
Davis and Margaret Geller for advice on generating
Monte Carlo samples with known correlation func-
tions, Don Schneider for help with the JASON soft-
ware and Xavier Barcons, Donald Lynden-Bell, Mario
Mateo, Houjon Mo, Michael Rauch, John Webb, Jeff
Willick and Dennis Zaritzky for useful conversations.
We would also like to thank the referee, J. N. Bah-
call, for his helpful and constructive comments which
improved the content and presentation of the paper.
SLM and RJW acknowledge support through NASA
contract NAS5-30101 and NSF grant AST-9005117.
very low redshifts, this latter population is beginning
to constitute a large enough fraction of the absorbers
that power in the two-point correlation function is
detectable. Thus, the present mix of Lyman α ab-
sorbers appears to have clustering properties inter-
mediate between present-epoch normal galaxies and a
random non-clustered population. This property also
appears to be shared by the low-luminosity moderate
redshift "blue galaxies" (Pritchet and Infante 1992),
leading to the plausible conjecture that the Lyman α
absorbers are more closely related to low mass, low lu-
minosity galaxies than they are to L∗ galaxies, though
the relation is clearly not one-to-one.
We have no good way at present of estimating the
characteristic scale or masses of the low-redshift Ly-
man α absorbers. A guess at a diameter of 30 kpc
is as plausible as any. In particular, consider a pan-
cake whose diameter is 30 kpc and whose thickness is
10 kpc. In this case, at the present epoch, a hydro-
gen column-density of 1013-1014 cm−2 normal to the
face of the absorber, coupled with estimates for the
present-epoch energy-density of ionizating radiation
leads to a total gas mass of order 107 M⊙, but a mass
of only a few hundred solar masses of neutral hydro-
gen. It is of interest that the mass function of neutral-
hydrogen gas clouds appears to be truncated below
about 108 M⊙ (Weinberg et al. 1991). As Maloney
(1992,1993) has shown, the gas in a flaring galaxy
with decreasing column-density will undergo a rather
sudden transition along its face from being mostly
neutral to mostly ionized, with the consequence that
few if any contours with neutral-hydrogen column-
density of order 1018 cm−2 are known. Similarly, it is
conceivable that, given the appropriate run of length
scale with mass, a sequence of masses would have
the property of making a sudden transition in the
mass function of neutral-hydrogen starting at about
108 M⊙, leading to a dearth of objects with total HI
masses for several orders of magnitude below this.
If these speculations have any connection with re-
ality then one might expect to see some similarity in
the clustering properties of the Lyman α absorbers
and low mass galaxies. We are currently attempt-
ing to obtain redshifts of galaxies of lower luminosity
along the 3C273 sightline in order to investigate this
possibility.
We would like to thank Greg Aldring and Steve
Shectman for help and advice in using the LCO fiber
system, Neil Reid for giving us access to one of the
16
Table 1: Definite Galaxy redshifts in 3C273 Field
17
18
19
Table 2: Comparison of 3C273 Extragalactic Absorption Line Lists
20
Table 3: Nearest Neighbour Monte-Carlo tests
Table 4: Nearest Galaxies to 3C273 Lyman α absorbers
21
Table 5: Pair Count Monte-Carlo tests using random absorbers
Table 6: KS comparison of z-distribution
22
Table 7: Pair Count Monte-Carlo tests using the galaxy distribution
23
REFERENCES
Maloney, P., 1992, ApJ, 389, L89
Allen, C. W. 1973, "Astrophysical Quantities 3rd Edi-
Maloney, P., 1993, ApJ, In Press
tion", Athlone Press, London, Pg 267
Bahcall, J. N., Jannuzi, B. T., Schneider, D. P., Har-
tig, G. F., Bohlin, R. and Junkkarinen, V., 1991a,
in "The First Year of HST Observations", ed A. L.
Kinney and J. C. Blades, Pg 46
Bahcall, J. N., Jannuzi, B. T., Schneider, D. P., Har-
tig, G. F., Bohlin, R. and Junkkarinen, V., 1991b,
ApJ, 377, L5
Bahcall, J. N., Jannuzi, B. T., Schneider, D. P., Har-
tig, G. F. and Green, R. F., 1992a, ApJ, 397, 68
Bahcall, J. N., Jannuzi, B. T., Schneider, D. P., Har-
tig, G. F. and Jenkins, E. B., 1992b, ApJ, 398,
495
Bahcall, J. N., Bergeron, J., Boksenberg, A., Hartig,
G. F., Jannuzi, B. T., Kirhakos, S., Sargent, W.
L. W., Savage, B. D., Schneider, D. P., Turnshek,
D. A., Weymann, R. J. and Wolfe, A. M., 1993,
ApJS, In Press
Binggeli, B., Sandage, A. and Tammann, G. A., 1985,
AJ, 90, 1681
Brandt, J. C. et al., 1993, AJ, 105, 831
Chernomordic, V. V. and Ozernoy, L. L., 1983, Na-
ture, 303, 153
Davis, M. and Peebles, P. J. E. 1983, ApJ, 267, 465
Fransson, C. and Epstein, R., 1982, MNRAS, 198,
1127
Haynes, M.P. and Giovanelli, R. 1984, AJ, 89, 758
Huchra, J. P. 1990 May 5 1990 version of the CfA Red-
shift Catalog, obtained through the Astronomical
Data Center.
Jacoby, G. H., Branch, D., Ciardullo, R., Davies, R.
L., Harris, W. E., Pierce, M. J., Pritchet, C. T.,
Tonry, J. L. and Welch, D. L., 1992, PASP, 104,
599
Kennicutt, R. C., 1984, ApJ, 287, 116
Kent, S. M., 1985, PASP, 97, 165
Loveday, J., Peterson, B. A., Efstathiou, G. and Mad-
dox, S. J., 1992, ApJ, 390, 338
Massey, P., 1990, NOAO Newsletter # 21, March
1990
Mo, H. J., Jing, Y. P. and Borner, G., 1992, ApJ, 392,
452
Mo, H. J., Einasto, M., Xia, X. Y. and Deng, Z. G.,
1992, MNRAS, 255, 382
Mo, H. J., Morris, S. L. and Weymann, R. J., In
Preparation
Metcalfe, N., Fong, R., Shanks, T. and Kilkenny, D.
1989, MNRAS, 236, 207
Morris, S. L., Weymann, R. J., Savage, B. D. and
Gilliland, R. L., 1991, ApJ, 377, L21
Osterbrock, D. E., "Astrophysics of Gaseous Nebu-
lae and Active Galactic Nuclei", 1989, University
Science Books, CA
Phillips, S., Disney, M. J. and Davies, J. I., 1993,
MNRAS, 260, 453
Pritchet, C. J. and Infante, L., 1992, ApJ, 399, L35
Rauch, M, Carswell, R. F., Chaffee, F. H., Foltz, C.
B., Webb, J. K., Weymann, R. J., Bechtold, J. and
Green, R. F., 1992, ApJ, 390, 387
Salzer, J. J. 1992, AJ, 103, 385
Sandage, A. and Bingelli, B., 1984, AJ, 89, 919
Savage, B. D., Lu, L., Weymann, R. J, Morris, S. L.
and Gilliland, R. L., 1993, ApJ, 404, 124
Schneider, D. P., Hartig, G. F., Jannuzi, B. T.,
Kirhakos, S., Saxe, D. H., Weymann, R. J., Bah-
call, J. N., Bergeron, J., Boksenberg, A., Sargent,
W. L. W., Savage, B. D., Turnshek, D. A. and
Wolfe, A. M., 1993, ApJS, In Press
Shectman, S. A., 1992, in "Fiber Optics in Astronomy
II", ed P. M. Gray, ASP Volume 37, Pg 26
Songaila, A., Bryant, W. and Cowie, L. L., 1989, ApJ,
345, L71
Stockton, A. 1980, In IAU symposium 92, "Objects
of High Redshift", ed G. O. Abell and P. J. E.
Peebles, Pg 87
24
van Gorkom, J., H., 1993, Teton Conference Proceed-
ings, In Press, Ed M. Shull and H. Thronson
van Gorkom, J., H., Bahcall, J.N., Jannuzi, B., and
Schneider.D. 1993, AJ, In Press
Vilas, F. and Smith, B. A., 1987, Appl.Optics, 26, 4
Weinberg, D. H., Szomoru, A., Guhathakurta, P. and
van Gorkom, J. H., 1991, ApJ, 372, L13
This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX
macros v3.0.
25
Fig. 1. -- Coronagraph Data of 3C273 field. (a) Sum
of 25A Filters, the horizontal bar in the lower left is 1
armin long, (b) Continuum Subtracted VN1, (c) Con-
tinuum Subtracted VN2, (d) Continuum Subtracted
HN. See text in § 2.1.
Fig. 2. -- Mosaic of COSMIC Images in Gunn r of
3C273 field. See text in § 2.2. Region shown in figure 1
is circled.
Fig. 3. -- Histogram of redshifts for Galaxies found in
the 3C273 sightline. Also plotted are the locations of
Lyman α absorbers from table 3 (where 'strong' refers
to lines with EW≥55 mA, and 'weak' refers to the
remainder), and the (arbitrarily normalised) galaxy
selection function for the fiber survey. See text in
§ 2.3.
Fig. 4. -- Locations on the sky of the galaxies with
redshifts in the field of 3C273. See text in § 2.3.
Fig. 5. -- Pie-diagrams for the Galaxies observed with
the LCO fiber system. Angles have been exagerated
by a factor 15 to prevent overcrowding of the symbols.
Please note that this results in a highly distorted plot
with initially spherical structures (such as the 3C273
cluster of galaxies) appearing elongated transverse to
the line of sight. Note also that the star marking the
position of 3C273, while readily visible in the pro-
jection in RA, is partially obscured by a clump of
galaxies in the projection in Dec
Fig. 6. -- Mosaic of COSMIC Images in Gunn r of
3C273 field, with 3 artificial dwarf galaxies added.
NE with MB=-14.5 and scale length 15kpc, NW with
MB=-13.5 and scale length 7.5kpc, and SW with
MB=-13.5 and scale length 15kpc. See text in § 3.2.
Fig. 7. -- Two point correlation functions for galaxy-
galaxy and absorber-galaxy (a) assuming pure Hubble
flow (b) assuming perturbed Hubble flow. See text in
§ 3.3.4.
26
This figure "fig1-1.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-2.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-3.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-4.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-5.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-6.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
This figure "fig1-7.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9307005v1
|
0710.4094 | 1 | 0710 | 2007-10-22T16:30:02 | Deep Optical Imaging of Starbursting "Transition" Dwarf Galaxies | [
"astro-ph"
] | A subgroup of dwarf galaxies have characteristics of a possible evolutionary transition between star-forming systems and dwarf ellipticals. These systems host significant starbursts in combination with smooth, elliptical outer envelopes and small HI content; they are low on gas and unlikely to sustain high star formation rates over significant cosmic time spans. We explore possible origins of such starburst "transition" dwarfs using moderately deep optical images. While galaxy-galaxy interactions could produce these galaxies, no optical evidence exists for tidal debris or other outer disturbances, and they also lack nearby giant neighbors which could supply recent perturbations. Colors of the outer regions indicate that star formation ceased > 1 Gyr in the past, a longer time span than can be reasonably associated with the current starbursts. We consider mechanisms where the starbursts are tied either to interactions with other dwarfs or to the state of the interstellar medium, and discuss the possibility of episodic star formation events associated with gas heating and cooling in low specific angular momentum galaxies. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Deep Optical Imaging of Starbursting "Transition" Dwarf
Galaxies
Kate E. Dellenbusch1
Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin, 475 N. Charter Street, Madison, WI
53706
[email protected]
John S. Gallagher, III
Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin, 475 N. Charter Street, Madison, WI
53706
[email protected]
Patricia M. Knezek
WIYN Consortium Inc., PO Box 26732, Tucson, AZ 85726
[email protected]
Allison G. Noble2
Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin, 475 N. Charter Street, Madison, WI
53706
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
A subgroup of dwarf galaxies have characteristics of a possible evolutionary
transition between star-forming systems and dwarf ellipticals. These systems
host significant starbursts in combination with smooth, elliptical outer envelopes
1Visiting Astronomer, The 0.9m telescope is operated by WIYN Inc. on behalf of a Consortium of
ten partner Universities and Organizations (see http://www.noao.edu/0.9m/partners.html). WIYN is a
joint partnership of the University of Wisconsin at Madison, Indiana University, Yale University, and the
National Optical Astronomical Observatory.
2Now at McGill University, 3600 rue University, Montreal, QC, Canada; [email protected]
-- 2 --
and small HI content; they are low on gas and unlikely to sustain high star for-
mation rates over significant cosmic time spans. We explore possible origins of
such starburst "transition" dwarfs using moderately deep optical images. While
galaxy-galaxy interactions could produce these galaxies, no optical evidence ex-
ists for tidal debris or other outer disturbances, and they also lack nearby giant
neighbors which could supply recent perturbations. Colors of the outer regions
indicate that star formation ceased >1 Gyr in the past, a longer time span than
can be reasonably associated with the current starbursts. We consider mecha-
nisms where the starbursts are tied either to interactions with other dwarfs or to
the state of the interstellar medium, and discuss the possibility of episodic star
formation events associated with gas heating and cooling in low specific angular
momentum galaxies.
Subject headings: galaxies: dwarf -- galaxies: starburst -- galaxies: evolution
-- galaxies: structure
1.
Introduction
The formation and evolution of dwarf galaxies remains poorly understood. How these
processes produce both rotationally supported (dIrr) as well as dynamically warm (dE/dS0s)
dwarf systems remain puzzles, despite considerable effort. An outstanding question in dwarf
galaxy evolution is whether there is an evolutionary connection between the various mor-
phological classes of dwarf galaxies (e.g. van den Bergh 1977, van Zee et al. 1998, van Zee
et al. 2001, Lisker et al. 2007). Specifically, can dwarfs of one morphological type evolve by
some process into a different type? For example, do some dIrrs evolve into dE/dS0s or did
the dE/dS0s we see in the Universe originally form as that type? These questions regarding
the formation and evolution of dwarf galaxies are of particular importance in light of hier-
archical cold dark matter (CDM) galaxy formation models which predict large numbers of
dwarf galaxies and suggests that larger galaxies are built up from the accretion of many low
mass halos (e.g. White & Frenk, 1991).
A related issue concerns the impact of star formation on dwarf galaxy evolution and
particularly the role of episodic star formation (e.g. Searle, Sargent & Bagnuollo 1973, Lee
et al. 2002). How does star formation relate to morphology in low mass galaxies? For
example, where do blue compact dwarfs (BCDs) fit in the dwarf galaxy zoo as starbursting
objects and are they related to either dIrrs or dE/dS0s (e.g. Sung et al. 1998, Gil de Paz &
Madore 2005, Noeske et al. 2005)? In particular, it has been suggested that BCD galaxies
may evolve into dE/dS0 galaxies after they lose their gas, either through supernovae-driven
-- 3 --
winds during episodes of intense star formation (Marlowe et al. 1999, Tajiri & Kamaya
2002), or through stripping processes induced by galaxy-galaxy interactions (Drinkwater &
Hardy 1991). Or, are some of these objects dEs where star formation has been renewed
through gas capture as suggested by Silk, Wyse, & Shields (1987)? Previous studies, which
have concentrated mainly on optical morphological differences between dwarf galaxies and
to some extent on their neutral gas content, have not firmly established a direct evolutionary
connection between dIs and dEs in galaxy groups and other low density environments (e.g.
van Zee, Salzer & Skillman 2001, Noeske et al. 2005).
Even in the Local Group the situation is unclear. Many Local Group dwarfs have
complex star formation histories and kinematic peculiarities, and at least five of the faint
dwarfs possess optical morphologies which place them in a "transition" or "mixed-type"
structural category between dI and dE/dS0 (e.g. Mateo 1998, Grebel, Gallagher, & Harbeck
2003). While nearby dE galaxies, such as NGC 185 and NGC 205 in the local group,
support star formation, the rates are extremely low and consistent with these objects' small
gas supplies.
More distant galaxy samples also contain dwarfs with early-type structures that also
host HI gas and often also some young stars. As in the Local Group, these transition
dwarfs frequently are small, low luminosity objects containing . 106 M⊙ of HI and having
correspondingly low star formation rates (e.g. Bouchard et al. 2005). On the other hand,
the Virgo Cluster of galaxies appears to contain a complete sequence of more luminous
dwarfs with declining and increasingly concentrated star formation, extending from typical
BCDs through to blue core dEs (Gallagher & Hunter 1989, Lisker et al. 2006,2007). While
moderate luminosity galaxies with early-type outer structures and young stellar populations
in their centers also exist in less dense environments (e.g. NGC 404, del Rio et al. 2004;
NGC 5102; Deharveng et al. 1997), they are sufficiently rare that it is difficult to determine
if evolutionary sequences exist.
In this paper we explore possible histories for a sample of actively star forming luminous
dwarf galaxies with transitional properties between BCDs and dEs residing in loose group
environments. These systems are fairly isolated and show little indication of a recent inter-
action or merger. They have an intriguing combination of characteristics which do not allow
them to easily be categorized as either dI/BCD or dE systems, but rather show a mixture
of the two. The key properties which indicate these low luminosity galaxies may be in the
midst of an evolutionary transition from dI/BCD to dE include:
• They are actively forming stars with star formation rates between 0.1 and 1 M⊙/yr.
• The star formation is currently centrally concentrated, with the outer regions composed
-- 4 --
of an older stellar population.
• Although actively forming stars, the starburst is fueled by very little HI gas, with
MHI/LB . 0.1. This compares with MHI/LB > 0.2 for typical dIs (Roberts & Haynes
1994) and BCDs (Pustilnik et al. 2002) and MHI/LB < 0.1 for dEs. Star formation
can continue in our sample galaxies only for about another 109 years at their current
rate, based on their HI content; in a few cases, including molecular gas will at most
double this time (e.g. Jackson et al. 1989, Gordon 1991).
• Unlike many other star forming dwarf galaxies including BCDs they have high oxygen
abundance ratios, with 12 + log(O/H) > 8.4 as we found in Dellenbusch et al. (2007).
• Their outer optical colors are similar to those of typical BCDs with (B-R)0 of order 1
(Gil de Paz et al. 2005), but bluer than the (B-R)0 ≈ 1.3 - 1.4 expected for slightly
fainter dEs (Conselice et al. 2003). In this regard our sample resembles the Gil de Paz
et al. "E-type" BCDs.
• These objects have smooth outer isophotes which are much more indicative of early-
rather than late-type galaxy structures.
Table 1 quantifies several of these properties.
In this paper we examine the significance of these final two characteristics. In §2 we
discuss the observations and data reduction. In §3 we describe our analysis and modeling
processes used to examine the data for evidence of tidal debris and fine structures. In this
section we also describe the results of this analysis. We discuss two possible evolutionary
pictures to explain the galaxies' star formation histories as a means of transition in §4. §5
contains a brief summary and our conclusions.
2. Observations and Data Reduction
For this study, we obtained imaging data with the WIYN 0.9-m telescope on Kitt Peak
in Arizona. We used the S2KB CCD camera to obtain deep R-band imaging of five transition
dwarf galaxies. The S2KB camera provides a 20' × 20' field of view with a plate scale of 0.′′6.
The data were taken on 24-26 and 28-29 April 2006; conditions were not photometric. We
obtained total exposure times of 50 to 62 minutes for each galaxy by combining 4 or 5 750
second exposures. The data were reduced using standard methods in IRAF1. Data reduction
1IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories, which are operated by the As-
sociation of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative agreement with the National
-- 5 --
included subtraction of combined bias frames and flat fielding using combined dome flats.
The multiple dithered frames were aligned and combined.
We also use short B- and R-band imaging observations made at Michigan-Dartmouth-
MIT (MDM) Observatory on the 1.3 m McGraw-Hill telescope during 10-12 April 1996.
Typical integration times were 20-39 minutes in B, and 10-15 minutes in R under generally
photometric conditions. Details of the data reduction performed on these images can be
found in Knezek, Sembach, & Gallagher, 1999).
The sample of transition galaxies studied here, consisting of NGC 3265, NGC 3353,
NGC 3773, NGC 3928, and IC 745, was selected to have a mixture of early- and late-type
dwarf galaxy characteristics. That is, an underlying dE or dS0 with a high rate of current
star formation. They thus were chosen in the spirit of Sandage & Hoffman (1991) and
were initially observed as transition dwarf candidates with MDM along with NGC 3377A,
NGC 4286, and IC 3475, which were discussed in Knezek, Sembach, & Gallagher (1999).
3. Results and analysis
3.1. Elliptical Modeling and Residual images
In order to study the morphology and fine structure of our galaxies, we produced residual
images, in other words the difference of the original images minus galaxy models. This allows
weak features which are otherwise dominated by the overall smooth and symmetric light
distribution to be more easily discernable.
These residual images are created using several routines in the IRAF package ISOPHOTE.
First, elliptical isophotes are fit to the galaxies using the ELLIPSE routine. The results from
such a model of a galaxy's surface brightness distribution is then input into the BMODEL
task to create a two-dimensional model of the galaxy (e.g. Forebes & Thomson 1992, Lisker
et al. 2006), representing the smooth elliptical structure of each system. Because of intense
star formation in the very centers of these galaxies, ELLIPSE does a poor job of fitting
isophotes at small radii. Ellipses were fit starting in the outer galaxy and proceeding in-
wards. These fits were stopped inside the 5 arcsecond isophote. By allowing the ellipticity
and position angle of the model-fit to vary, any large-scale structure such as a bar, are in-
cluded in the model. When the model is then subtracted from the original galaxy image,
the residual more clearly reveals any fine structure (e.g. dust, tidal tails, shells) which had
Science Foundation.
been hidden beneath the dominant elliptical light distribution.
-- 6 --
3.2. Dwarf Galaxy Fine Structure Features
The procedure described above was used to examine the deep R-band images for ev-
idence of tidal interaction and clues to their evolutionary histories. We do not find tidal
tails or extended tidal debris in any of the galaxies studied. The residual images do however
reveal interesting fine structures near the galaxy centers where we find the light distribution
is not smooth. Several of them have clear dust lanes, in particular NGC 3773 and IC 745
(See Figure 1). The residual images in Figure 1 are presented as negative images. The
dust features therefore appear as lighter regions. These dust features are also visible in the
original images. In addition, most of the objects do not show significantly boxy or disky
isophotes as derived from a4 coefficients of the ellipse fits. NGC 3353 does show evidence of
being boxy with -0.07 . a4/a . 0 out to a radius of 30 arcsec, while NGC 3265 is weakly
disky with 0 . a4/a . 0.02 inside of 10 arcseconds. IC 745, NGC 3928, and NGC 3773 are
not predominantly boxy or disky with a4/a not trending toward positive or negative values
on average (See Figure 2). Thus, the conservative result is that the outer isophotes are quite
close to ellipses.
It is important to note however, that these trends are likely influenced
by the prominent dust features present in the inner parts of these objects. In addition to
dust features, several of the galaxies have complex fine structures in their inner regions (See
Figure 1), indicating the light distribution is not smooth in the inner parts of these galaxies.
Galaxies that have not experienced mergers in the past several Gyr generally have
symmetric stellar bodies. In systems where mergers or stellar mass transfer events are more
recent, distinctive features can be seen, including tidal tails. As these systems age, structural
features associated with past events become increasingly subtle, passing from stellar shells
and ripples to possibly tidal bars (Miwa & Noguchi 1998) or boxy isophotes (see Barnes &
Hernquist 1992). If the galaxies we observe as starbursting transition dwarfs formed via near
equal mass mergers, then these events were in the distant past or involved a companion with
very few stars.
The fine structure features as described above, are apparently associated with gas and
are similar to those others have found in larger isolated elliptical galaxies. For example, Reda
et al. (2004) studied a sample of nearby isolated early-type galaxies and found a variety of
fine structure features in several of them such as dust lanes and shells as well as both disky
and boxy isophotes. For several of the E's studied, Reda et al. suggest they are the remnant
of a galaxy merger, as their light distributions deviate from perfect ellipticity. Thus the
structure of the ISM in our sample allows for the possibility of past galaxy mergers; however
-- 7 --
if these events occurred, they took place many outer-galaxy dynamical time scales in the
past.
4. Discussion
The galaxies discussed in this paper exhibit a puzzling combination of properties. Al-
though these types of galaxies are not ubiquitous in the local universe, they may represent
an important snapshot in dwarf galaxy evolution. It is therefore useful to understand their
possible evolutionary histories and likely future states. Two potential scenarios are explored
here; an internal ISM instability leading to multiple starburst episodes and a past interaction
or dwarf-dwarf merger event.
4.1.
Internal Chemo-Dynamical Star Formation Regulation
The pattern of star formation in these galaxies indicates that producing a concentration
of low angular momentum gas in the central regions plays an important role in their evolution.
In this regard the problem is similar to that generally seen in BCD galaxies with high star
formation rates: how is the central region of a starbursting dwarf fueled with gas (e.g. Taylor
et al. 1993, van Zee et al. 2001)?
In galaxies with low specific angular momenta, random motions and thermal energy
could play important roles in supporting a spatially extended ISM. In the extreme situation
where these are the only factors, numerical simulations suggest that the system can become
unstable against bursts of star formation. This idea was first explored by Loose et al. (1982)
who modeled the Galactic center. Stars energize the ISM which then expands, shutting
off star formation, leading to collapse and another round of star formation; a cycle that
resembles a kind of cosmic diesel engine. This type of galactic "star formation dieseling"
also is seen in some of the more sophisticated 1-dimensional simulations of non-rotating dE
galaxies by Hensler et al. (2004; see also Pelupessy et al. 2004). The basic principle is again
the ability of mechanical energy from stars to expand the radial extent of a low mass ISM
to the point where star formation declines, leading to a collapse on a gas dissipational time
scale and another round of star formation, or gas exhaustion
It is not clear whether the kinds of star formation rate oscillations found in these models
occur in galaxies. A connection between mechanical power and the overall radial structure of
the ISM is one key feature. For example, Tajiri & Kamaya (2002) estimate conditions under
which BCD HI envelopes could be blown away, and the galaxies in this sample sit near their
-- 8 --
boundary SFR for retaining their HI. Thus we expect the envelopes may be influenced by
the current starbursts. A full assessment, however, requires knowledge of the gravitational
potentials and structural form of the system. Unfortunately the stellar kinematics of the
galaxies in our sample are not known and thus more detailed modeling is not yet warranted.
Studies of HI in galaxies like those in our sample (central starburst, moderate luminosity,
low MHI /L), however, show that some of the gas is in a rotating disk surrounding the central
gas concentration (Lake et al. 1987, Sadler et al. 2000, van Zee et al. 2001). In some cases the
gas kinematics are not regular; e.g. Lake et al. note the HI in the outer parts of NGC 3265
has confused kinematics, which they summarize as "infall, outflow, no-flow". Lake et al. and
Sadler et al. consider that some of the HI could have been recently accreted, but this now
seems unlikely given the high gas phase chemical abundances that we find in Dellenbusch et
al. (2007).
The possibility of an internal instability that leads to an episodic central concentration
of gas is consistent with the chemical abundances and therefore merits closer examination.
An alternative internal model for feeding gas into the centers of low mass galaxies via
viscosity of gas in their disks has been developed by Noguchi (2001). In this picture low
density gas disks in small galaxies fail to efficiently form stars, thereby allowing gas to
accrete into the centers of the systems. This model, however, produces long-lived central
star forming zones and thus it is not clear if it can be applied to the low HI content, high
SFR objects studied here.
4.2. Old Interaction/Merger Event
An alternative mechanism to explain the evolution of these galaxies is a past interaction
with another galaxy or possibly a dwarf-dwarf merger.
The amorphous dwarf galaxy NGC 5253 is a well studied nearby starburst galaxy which
is similar in several ways to the galaxies discussed in this paper. It has been suggested that
the central starburst in NGC 5253 may have been triggered by an interaction with M83 (e.g.
van den Bergh 1980). NGC 5253 is an amorphous dwarf galaxy with an underlying elliptical
structure and bright HII regions in the core. Like the transition dwarfs in this study, it has a
low neutral gas mass-to-light ratio of MHI/LB = 0.04 and an Hα derived star formation rate
of 0.12 M⊙/yr (Ott et al. 2005). It does however have a somewhat lower oxygen abundance
with 12+log(O/H) = 8.23 (Martin 1997).
Kobulnicky & Skillman (1995) have suggested the current star formation activity of NGC
-- 9 --
5253 may be due to the accretion of a gas-rich companion or the result of an interaction
with nearby M83 about 109 years ago. M83 and NGC 5253 are separated by only 0.15 Mpc
thus making an interaction between them ∼ 1 Gyr ago possible. This is supported by the
galaxy's unusual gas dynamics (Kobulnicky & Skillman 1995) and an elliptical young halo
stellar population with ages of 108 - 109 yrs (Caldwell & Phillips 1989).
Could similar interactions be responsible for triggering the star formation we see in our
transition dwarf sample? First, are there any galaxies nearby with which the transition
dwarfs could have interacted? To examine this we must first estimate when stars last formed
in the outer regions of these galaxies. We currently only have one color, (B-R), from short
exposures obtained with the 1.3 m McGraw-Hill telescope at Michigan-Dartmouth-MIT Ob-
servatory in addition to the deep R-band data presented here. Although more colors would
be beneficial, we can roughly estimate the minimum time since stars formed in the red outer
regions of the galaxies using these data and spectral evolutionary synthesis models.
An estimate of the minimum time passed since the population of stars in the outer
disk formed was made using models from the Gottingen Galaxy Evolution (GALEV) Group
courtesy of Dr. Uta Fritze-v. Alvensleben. These are spectral evolutionary synthesis models
for several metallicities and include gaseous emission (Schulz et al. 2002, Anders & Fritze-v.
Alvensleben 2003). We use data from these models to plot the variation of (B-R) color with
time for a galaxy which has experienced a burst of star formation. An estimate of the time
since stars last formed in the outer galaxy envelope can then be made based on the time
elapsed since the model burst for the color of the simulated galaxy to fade to the observed
outer region color. This was done using GALEV models with a metallicity of z=0.008 for
the underlying galaxy and a burst of solar metallicity (z=0.02). Constant and exponential
star formation rates were explored for the underlying galaxy model. In both cases a burst
with a simple stellar population was placed on top of the underlying galaxy population. In
addition, models for different burst strengths were also examined.
We find the model post-burst colors to be too blue for the case of constant star formation
rate. Observed integrated (B-R)0 colors for our galaxies range from 0.84 to 1.2 (see Table 1),
while the model post-burst B-R color only gets as red as B-R=0.7 by 6 Gyr after the burst.
Modeling the underlying galaxy with an exponential star formation rate of the form (SF R ∝
e−t/1Gyr) produces post-burst colors which are a much better fit to our outer colors data.
Changing the strength of the burst however, does not significantly affect our age estimate.
As a result of these models, we find that at least between 2 and 6 Gyr have passed since
star formation ceased in the outer regions of the galaxies studied here. An example of one of
our models is shown in Figure 3 with (B-R) indicated for the envelope of NGC 3353. These
results are consistent with ages found for the underlying stellar population of NGC 3353 by
-- 10 --
Cair´os et al. (2007).
Although these galaxies have no obvious close companions with which they are clearly
interacting, they are not completely isolated. The galaxy which visually appears near IC 745
in Figure 1 is actually a background object. Assuming a relative velocity of 200 km/s
between galaxies in the loose group environments in which the transition dwarfs reside, in
the estimated time elapsed since the outer regions last experienced star formation, they could
now be separated by about ∼0.5 Mpc. Several other galaxies can be found within 1 Mpc of
each of our sample galaxies, and smaller gas-rich companions may be relatively common but
difficult to locate in optical data (Taylor et al. 1995, 1996, Hogg et al. 1998, Noeske et al.
2001, Pustilnik et al. 2001).
Any proposed mechanism for producing these dwarfs must be able to explain the ob-
served low gas content and centrally concentrated star formation as well as envelope structure
and colors. A likely scenario therefore is a mechanism through which some gas can be re-
moved from the galaxy and much of the remaining gas falls into the center. An interaction
could be a way to achieve this. For example, Bushouse (1987) found that the majority of
interaction induced star formation is concentrated near the nuclei of disk galaxies and that
gas depletion times are lower than for isolated spirals.
For the gas to be moved toward the center, it must lose angular momentum and dissi-
pate energy. Numerical simulations of spiral arms and bars tidally induced in disk galaxies
(e.g. Noguchi & Ishibashi 1986, Noguchi 1987) and Noguchi (1988) showed that the gas is
also affected, whereby the stellar bar induces the infall of gas toward the galactic nucleus.
However, most of the transition dwarfs examined here do not appear to have such features,
although it is uncertain what the bar lifetime might be for such objects. An exception to
this is NGC 3353, which has star formation occurring in an elongated arc, as seen in Hα
imaging (Dellenbusch et al. 2007 in prep.), that is not as centrally concentrated as in the
other sample galaxies. This may be a bar-like structure. In addition, van Zee et al. (2001)
found the HI in many BCDs, which have characteristics in common with transition dwarfs,
to have intrinsically low angular momenta.
Another related scenario to explain the evolution of transition galaxies is a dwarf-dwarf
merger. Although dwarf galaxy mergers with larger systems have been modeled (e.g. Hern-
quist 1989, Mihos & Hernquist 1994), the results of which can also describe a dwarf galaxy
accreting a cloud for example, there is little discussion of dwarf-dwarf merger simulations in
the literature. This is no doubt at least in part because they occur much less frequently than
other types of merger events. However, there is evidence that they take place. One example
is II Zw 40, a BCD which is thought to be an on-going merger of two gas-rich dwarf galaxies.
Optically, II Zw 40 is dominated by a starburst with two faint tails extending outward (Sar-
-- 11 --
gent & Searle 1970, Baldwin, Spinrad, & Terlevich 1982). It's HI extends several times the
optical diameter with distinct tidal tails extending even further. As van Zee, Skillman, &
Salzer (1998) note, the morphology of the system, a strong color gradient indicating the low
surface brightness optical tidal tails are from an older stellar population, and no evidence
for a second optical galaxy along the HI tidal tails indicate II Zw 40 is likely a merger rather
than just a tidal interaction.
Tidal interactions have often been invoked as a mechanism by which star formation can
be triggered in a galaxy as well as an explanation for the high star formation rates found
in BCD's (e.g Brinks & Klein 1988). Another possible dwarf-dwarf merger is the galaxy
He 2-10 which is a Wolf-Rayet galaxy with a primarily elliptical appearance and two bright
star clusters. It also exhibits a tail-like feature in both HI and CO. Kobulnicky et al. (1995)
suggest, based on HI and CO kinematics, that He 2-10 is an advanced merger of two dwarf
galaxies. A third well known example of two dwarfs interacting are the Small and Large
Magellanic Clouds. Could the transition dwarfs which we are studying be a more evolved
version of a dwarf-dwarf merger where it is no longer morphologically apparent a merger has
taken place?
Although dwarf-dwarf mergers occur in nature and may provide an explanation for at
least some transition dwarfs, they are rare. This is to be expected because dwarfs have small
interaction cross-sections. Also, for a merger to actually take place, the two interactors must
have very low relative velocities. As galaxies with transition dwarf characteristics also seem
to be rare, it is possible we are seeing an uncommon form of dwarf-dwarf merger in isolated
environments with energy dissipation playing an important role in the subsequent evolution
of these systems.
Although the transition galaxies discussed here do not appear very disturbed and have
regular outer isophotes, we cannot rule out an interaction or merger as playing an important
role in their evolutionary and star formation histories. Several dynamical crossing times have
passed since star formation occurred in the outer envelope, and it is therefore reasonable for
minimal evidence of tidal interaction to remain today. On the other hand, the very long
time scales that we find seem to be at odds with the intrinsically short time scales expected
for starburst development in small galaxies (e.g. Recchi et al. 2002).
5. Summary & Conclusions
In summary, we have presented results of deep R-band imaging for five starbursting
transition dwarf galaxies. Our observational results show:
-- 12 --
1. All five galaxies exhibit smooth elliptical outer isophotes.
2. We find no evidence of extended tidal debris or other indications of a recent major
interaction (e.g. tails, shells or ripples).
3. Fine structure exists in the central regions that are associated with the ISM and star
formation, with dust structures and HII regions being prominent in several of the
galaxies.
4. Outer envelope colors are consistent with having no star formation in the outer regions
for the past several Gyr. This timescale could be longer if star formation slowly declined
rather than stopping suddenly.
We consider two possible classes of evolutionary histories which could be consistent
with the observed properties and locations of transition dwarf galaxies: an internal ISM
instability and a past interaction or merger event. The interaction or dwarf-dwarf merger
scenario remains a possibility, although we find no strong evidence to support it. After
several billion years it is not clear if we should still find evidence of tidal debris in the outer
regions of the galaxies. However, long term products of dwarf interactions and dwarf-dwarf
mergers in particular have not been well modeled (e.g.
the effects of large dark matter
contents on merger products).
The other possibility of an unstable ISM seems promising to explain the central star
formation in these objects. In this case the eventual evolution to an inactive state will be
slower, possibly requiring several starburst cycles. Observationally the model can be tested
by looking for the young stellar populations in fading starburst phases in dE-like dwarfs.
A remaining question, which is particularly puzzling,
If
these objects last experienced significant star formation in their outer regions & 1 Gyr ago,
why are they currently undergoing bursts of centrally concentrated star formation? What
mechanisms control the structure of the ISM such that these galaxies now support rapid star
formation, and will these circumstances lead to galaxies with little or no star formation, i.e.
objects resembling dEs, within the next ∼ 1 Gyr?
is the issue of timescales.
We would like to thank P. Mucciarelli for assisting with the observations. In addition we
wish to thank H. Schweiker and J. Davies for their assistance and dedication to the WIYN
0.9m telescope. We also thank U. Fritze-von Alvensleben for the use of the GALEV models
and helpful discussions regarding them. This research is supported in part by the University
of Wisconsin-Madison Graduate School.
-- 13 --
REFERENCES
Anders, P. & Fritze-v. Alvensleben, U. 2003, A&A, 401, 1063
Baldwin, J. A., Spinrad, H., & Terlevich, R. 1982, MNRAS, 198, 535
Barnes, J. E. & Hernquist, L. 1992, ARA&A, 30, 705
Bouchard, A., Jerjen, H., Da Costa, G. S., Ott, J. 2005, AJ, 130, 2058
Brinks, E. & Klein, U. 1988, MNRAS, 231, 63
Burstein, D, Krumm, N., & Salpeter, E. E. 1987, AJ, 94, 883
Bushouse, H. A. 1987, ApJ, 320, 49
Cairos, L. M., Caon, N., Garcia Lorenzo, B., Monreal-Ibero, A., Amorin, R., Weilbacher, P.,
Papaderos, P., 2007, ApJ, in press.
Caldwell, N. & Phillips, M. M. 1989, ApJ, 338, 789
Conselice, C. J., Gallagher, J. S., Wyse, R. F. G. 2003, AJ, 125, 66
Deharveng, J.-M., Jedrzejewski, R., Crane, P., Disney, M. J., Rocca-Volmerange, B. 1997,
A&A, 326, 528
Dellenbusch, K. E., Gallagher, III, J. S., & Knezek, P. M. 2007, ApJ, 655, L29
del Rio, M. S., Brinks, E., Cepa, J. 2004, AJ, 128, 89
Drinkwater, M. & Hardy, E. 1991, AJ, 101, 94
Forbes, D. A. & Thomson, R. C. 1992, MNRAS, 249, 779
Gallagher, J. S. & Hunter, D. A. 1989, AJ, 98, 806
Gil de Paz, A. & Madore, B. F. 2005, ApJS, 156, 345
Gordon, M. A. 1991, ApJ, 371, 563
Gordon, D. & Gottesman, S.T. 1981, AJ, 86, 161
Grebel, E. K., Gallagher, III, J. S., & Harbeck, D. 2003, AJ, 125, 1926
Hensler, G., Theis, C., Gallagher, III, J. S. 2004, A&A, 426, 25
Hernquist, L. 1989, Nature, 340, 687
-- 14 --
Hogg, D. E., Roberts, M. S., & Knezek, P. M. 1998, AJ, 115, 502
Knezek, P. M., Sembach, K. R., & Gallagher, III, J. S. 1999, ApJ, 514, 119
Kobulnicky, H.A., Dickey, J.M, Sargent, A.I., Hogg, D.E., & Conti, P.S. 1995, AJ, 110, 116
Kobulnicky, H. A. & Skillman, E. D. 1995, ApJ, 454, L121
Jackson, J., Snell, R. L., Ho, P. T. P., & Barrett, A. H. 1989, ApJ, 337, 680
Lake, G. & Schommer, R. A. 1984, ApJ, 280, 107
Lee, J. C., Salzer, J. J., Impey, C., Thuan, T. X., & Gronwall, C. 2002, AJ, 124, 3088
Li, J. G., Seaquist, E. R., Wang, Z., Sage, J. J. 1994, AJ, 107, 90
Lisker, T., Grebel, E. K., & Binggeli, B. 2006, AJ, 132, 497
Lisker, T., Grebel, E. K., Binggeli, B., & Glatt, K. 2007, ApJ, 660, 1186
Loose, H. H., Krugel, E., Tututkov. A. V. 1982, A&A, 105, 342
Marlowe, A. T., Meurer, G. R., & Heckman, T. M. 1999, ApJ, 522, 183
Martin, C. L. 1997, ApJ, 491, 561
Martin, M. 1998, A&AS, 131, 77
Mateo, M. L. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 435
Mihos, J. C. & Hernquist, L. 1994, ApJ, 425, L13
Miwa, T. & Noguchi, M. 1998, ApJ, 499, 149
Noeske, K. G., Iglesias-P´aamo, J., V´ıchez, J. M., Papaderos, P. & Fricke, K. J. 2001, A&A.
371, 806
Noeske, K. G., Papaderos, P., Cair´os, L. M., & Fricke, K. J. 2005, A&A, 429, 115
Noguchi, M. 1987, MNRAS, 228, 635
Noguchi, M. 1988, A&A, 203, 259
Noguchi, M. 2001, ApJ, 555, 289
Noguchi, M. & Ishibashi, S. 1986, MNRAS, 219, 305
-- 15 --
Ott, J., Walter, F., & Brinks, E. 2005, MNRAS, 358, 1453
Pelupessy, F. I., van der Werf, P. P., & Icke, V. 2004, A&A, 422, 55
Pustilnik, S. A., Kniazev, A. Y., Lipovetsky, V. A., & Ugryumov, A. V. 2001, A&A, 373, 24
Pustilnik, S. A., Martin, J.-M., Huchtmeier, W. K., Brosch, N, Lipovetsky, V. A., Richter,
G. M. 2002, A&A, 389, 405
Recchi, S., Matteucci, F., D'Ercole, A., & Tosi, M. 2002, A&A, 384, 799
Reda, F. M., Forbes, D. A., Beasley, M. A., O'Sullivan, E. J., & Goudfrooij, P. 2004,
MNRAS, 354, 851
Roberts, M. S. & Haynes, M. P. 1994, ARA&A, 32, 115
Sadler, E. M., Oosterloo, T. A., Morganti, R., Karalas, A. 2000, AJ, 119, 1180
Sandage, A. & Hoffman, G. L. 1991, ApJ, 379, L45
Sargent, W.L.W. & Searle, L. 1970, ApJ, 162, 155
Schulz, J., Fritze-v. Alvensleben, U., & Fricke, K. J. 2002, A&A, 392, 1
Searle, L., Sargent, W. L. W., & Bagnuollo, W. 1973, ApJ, 179, 427
Silk, J., Wyse, R. F. G., & Shields, G. A. 1987, ApJ, 322, L59
Sung, E.-C., Han, C., Ryden, B. S., Chun, M.-S., & Kim, H.-I. 1998, ApJ, 499, 140
Tajiri, Y. Y. & Kamaya, H. 2002, A&A, 389, 367
Taylor, C. L., Brinks, E., & Skillman, E. D. 1993, AJ, 105, 128
Taylor, C. L., Brinks, E., Grashuis, R. M. & Skillman, E. D. 1995, ApJS, 99, 427.
Taylor, C. L., Thomas, D. L., Brinks, E. & Skillman, E. D. 1996, ApJS, 107, 143
van den Bergh, S. 1977, Evolution of Galaxies and Stellar Populations, Proceeding of a
Conference at Yale University, 19
van den Bergh, S. 1980, PASP, 92, 122
van Zee, L., Salzer, J. J., Skillman, E. 2001, AJ, 122, 121
van Zee, L., Skillman, E.D., & Salzer, J.J. 1998, AJ, 116, 1186
-- 16 --
White, S. D. M. & Frenk, C. S. 1991, ApJ, 379, 52
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 17 --
Table 1. Galaxy Properties
Galaxy
D(Mpc)† SFR (M⊙yr−1)
LB ( x 108L⊙) MHI /LB
12 + log(O/H)
(B-R)0
‡
IC 745
NGC 3265
NGC 3353
NGC 3928
NGC 3773
15.3
17.6
12.6
13.2
13.2
0.2
0.1
0.8
0.1
0.1
4.9
7.8
7.8
3.6
6.5
0.05a
0.10b
0.30c
0.33d
0.08e
9.0
9.2
8.4
9.1
8.8
0.92
1.19
0.84
1.19
0.88
†A value of H0 = 75 km/s/Mpc is used to calculate distances
‡Outer region color; integrated colors will be bluer
aMartin 1998
bLake & Schommer 1984
cGordon & Gottesman 1981
dLi et al. 1994
eBurstein, Krumm, & Salpeter 1987
-- 18 --
Fig. 1. -- Residual negative images in R-band of galaxies: A) IC 745, B) NGC 3265, C)
NGC 3353, D) NGC 3928, and E) NGC 3773. Dust features appear as lighter regions in
these negative images. Because of the intense star formation there, the inner ∼ 5 arcseconds
of each galaxy were not included in the model and therefore appear as dark regions.
-- 19 --
Fig. 2. -- Deviation from perfect ellipticity, described by the Fourier a4 parameter, as a
function of distance along the semi-major axis for galaxies A) IC 745, B) NGC 3265, C)
NGC 3353, D) NGC 3928, and E) NGC 3773. a4 > 0 describe disky isophotal shapes while
a4 < 0 describe boxy isophotes. Although our images are moderately deep, S/N becomes
low at outer isophotes and therefore we terminate the plot at ∼ 30 arcseconds for the two
smaller galaxies.
-- 20 --
Fig. 3. -- Illustrative spectral evolution synthesis model including an underlying elliptical
galaxy model having an exponential star formation rate with a simple stellar population
starburst occurring after 9 Gyr (Solid Curve). Horizontal dashed line indicates B-R color of
the quiescent outer envelope of NGC 3353. The model indicates that for the color to have
faded to B-R=0.84, after an instantaneous burst of star formation, 2.5 Gyrs have passed
(Vertical Dashed Line).
|
astro-ph/0408248 | 1 | 0408 | 2004-08-13T01:50:38 | The Anatomy of Star Formation in NGC 300 | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Spitzer Space Telescope was used to study the mid-infrared to far-infrared properties of NGC 300, and to compare dust emission to Halpha to elucidate the heating of the ISM and the star formation cycle at scales < 100 pc. The new data allow us to discern clear differences in the spatial distribution of 8 micron dust emission with respect to 24 micron dust and to HII regions traced by the Halpha light. The 8 micron emission highlights the rims of HII regions, and the 24 micron emission is more strongly peaked in star forming regions than at 8 microns. We confirm the existence and approximate amplitude of interstellar dust emission at 4.5 microns, detected statistically in Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) data, and conclude it arises in star forming regions. When averaging over regions larger than ~ 1 kpc, the ratio of Halpha to Aromatic Feature emission in NGC 300 is consistent with the values observed in disks of spiral galaxies. The mid-to-far-infrared spectral energy distribution of dust emission is generally consistent with pre-Spitzer models. | astro-ph | astro-ph | The Anatomy of Star Formation in NGC 300
G. Helou,1 H. Roussel,2
P. Appleton,1 D. Frayer,1 S. Stolovy,1 L. Storrie-Lombardi,1 R. Hurt,1 P. Lowrance,1
D. Makovoz,1 F. Masci,1 J. Surace,1 K.D. Gordon,3 A. Alonso-Herrero,3 C.W. Engelbracht,3
K. Misselt,3 G. Rieke,3 M. Rieke,3 S.P. Willner,4 M. Pahre,4 M.L.N. Ashby,4
G.G. Fazio,4 H.A. Smith4
ABSTRACT
The Spitzer Space Telescope was used to study the mid-infrared to far-infrared
properties of NGC 300, and to compare dust emission to Hα to elucidate the
heating of the ISM and the star formation cycle at scales < 100 pc. The new
data allow us to discern clear differences in the spatial distribution of 8 µm dust
emission with respect to 24 µm dust and to H II regions traced by the Hα light.
The 8 µm emission highlights the rims of H II regions, and the 24 µm emission
is more strongly peaked in star forming regions than 8 µm. We confirm the
existence and approximate amplitude of interstellar dust emission at 4.5 µm,
detected statistically in Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) data, and conclude it
arises in star forming regions. When averaging over regions larger than ∼ 1 kpc,
the ratio of Hα to Aromatic Feature emission in NGC 300 is consistent with the
values observed in disks of spiral galaxies. The mid-to-far-infrared spectral energy
distribution of dust emission is generally consistent with pre-Spitzer models.
Subject headings: galaxies:
(NGC 300)
ISM - infrared: galaxies - individual: galaxy
4
0
0
2
g
u
A
3
1
1
v
8
4
2
8
0
4
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
1.
Introduction
NGC 300 is a SA(s)d galaxy in the Sculptor Group of galaxies, at a distance of about
2.1 Mpc (Freedman et al. 1992), viewed at an inclination of about 50◦ (Puche et al. 1990).
1
2
3
4
SIRTF Science Center, California Institute of Technology, M.S. 220-6, Pasadena, CA 91125
California Institute of Technology, M.S. 320-47, Pasadena, CA 91125
Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721
Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden St., Cambridge, MA 02138
– 2 –
Its total luminosities in the blue band (3855–4985A) and in the far-infrared (42.5–122.5 µm,
estimated from Spitzer data) are ∼ 3.3 × 108 L⊙ bol and 2.2 × 108 L⊙ bol respectively.
Its
LFIR/LB ratio is thus very close to the average ratio for the blue magnitude-limited sample
studied by Thuan & Sauvage (1992). Due to its large angular extent and low surface bright-
ness, no reliable total radio continuum flux measurement exists (only discrete sources are
detected). NGC 300 has a striking appearance in the visible and in Hα due to several H II
regions with nearly circular shapes and various degrees of filling-in (Deharveng et al. 1988;
Hoopes et al. 1996; see Figure 1). Its large HI envelope (Puche et al. 1990) extends well
beyond the visible image. Pannuti et al. (2000) reported a total of 44 SNR candidates, evi-
dence that the current star formation activity manifested as H II regions has been on-going
for tens of millions of years (see also Butler et al. 2004). Because of its proximity, NGC 300
allows the Spitzer Space Telescope (Werner et al. 2004) to compare dust emission to other
ISM components and discern the interplay between the ISM and the star formation cycle at
scales < 100 pc.
2. Observations and Data Reduction
The IRAC (Fazio et al. 2004) observations of NGC 300 are 12-second frames and map
the galaxy in approximately half array spacings, yielding a total time per sky position of 48 s.
They were reduced with the standard Spitzer Science Center data reduction pipeline (version
9.5). Due to the readout of bright point sources, the signal was reduced (pulled-down) in some
columns of the array1; a correction measured from the map was applied. Persistent images
left by bright sources were found by median-combining all the dithered positions together
and identifying any remaining sources. These objects were removed from individual frames.
The data were then combined into a mosaic using a cosmic ray rejection and a background
matching applied between overlapping fields of view. The relative photometric uncertainty
is of the order of 5%, and the absolute uncertainty is 10%; uncertainty tied to the angular
sizes of source and measuring aperture contributes up to 15%.
Images of NGC 300 at 24, 70, and 160 µm were obtained with the MIPS Instrument
(Rieke et al. 2004) in the scan-map mode. The final mosaics have a total exposure time
of approximately 160, 80, and 16 s per point at 24, 70, and 160 µm. The MIPS images
were reduced using the MIPS Instrument Team Data Analysis Tool (Gordon et al. 2004) as
described by Engelbracht et al. (2004). The uncertainties on the final absolute calibrations
are estimated at 10%, 20%, and 20% for the 24, 70, and 160 µm data, respectively. The
1see the Spitzer Observer's Manual at http://ssc.spitzer.caltech.edu/documents/som/.
– 3 –
70 and 160 µm images exhibit linear streaks along the scan direction which are residual
instrumental artifacts due to the time dependent responsivity of the Ge detectors, and affect
the photometry in large apertures.
The Hα (6563A) + [N II] (6583 and 6548A) map was derived from images posted in
NED by Larsen & Richtler (1999). The narrowband image containing Hα emission and the
R-band image were aligned, and rescaled to subtract the stellar continuum, deriving the
scaling factor from aperture photometry on 32 bright stars. Residuals from saturated or
improperly subtracted stars were masked out, and the final image was regridded and rotated
to match the IRAC reference frame.
The Spitzer and Hα+[N II] images are shown in Figure 1. The images contain three
very bright Milky Way stars directly superposed on the disk. We masked them out in IRAC
and 24 µm images, as well as additional point sources as described in Section 3.1 below
(Figure 4b). Foreground stars will be removed more rigorously in a later paper. Fainter,
indistinguishable stars are unlikely to affect significantly the results presented here.
3. Physical Content in Mid-Infrared Images
Whereas at λ ≥ 24 µm the emission is dominated by interstellar dust, the mid-infrared
marks the transition from stellar to interstellar emission. The appearance of the galaxy shifts
from resembling the stellar disk in the 3.6 µm image to an ISM-like appearance at 8 µm. We
assume conservatively the 3.6 µm emission is all due to stars, and extrapolate this component
to longer wavelengths using stellar population modeling from Starburst99 (Leitherer et al.
1999); the stellar Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) longward of 2 µm depends very little on
star formation history or metallicity, as illustrated in Figure 2. The decomposition amounts
to scaling the 3.6 µm map by 0.596, 0.399, 0.232 and 0.032 respectively for 4.5, 5.8, 8 and
24 µm, and subtracting these from the observed maps pixel by pixel to yield what we will
refer to as the "dust maps" shown in Figure 1. Based on this decomposition, the 24 µm map
is probably ≥ 98% interstellar emission globally, and ≥ 93% interstellar in the inner arcmin,
where the stellar contribution is the greatest. The 8 µm map is ≥ 81% interstellar emission.
This method potentially overestimates the dust component by underestimating the red-
der SED of very low mass stars. However the model reproduces adequately the 4.5 µm/3.6 µm
color of the nuclear stellar cluster, of the emission averaged in the inner arcmin (Figure 2),
and of the diffuse emission outside several disk H II regions.
On the other hand, the method probably underestimates the dust component by as-
suming that the 3.6 µm map contains only photospheric emission, ignoring evidence that the
– 4 –
hot dust component stretches down to λ < 3 µm (Bernard et al. 1994; Lu et al. 2003; Hunt
et al. 2002). From the ISO data in Figure 6 of Lu et al. (2003), this underestimate may
reach a factor of up to 2.6, 10–20% and 3–4%, respectively at 4.5, 5.8 and 8 µm. In view of
these opposing potential biases, our conservative approach should be reliable qualitatively
for NGC 300, in spite of localized departures due to variations in stellar population colors
or dust extinction.
3.1.
Interstellar Dust Emission
In order to constrain the origin of the 4.5µm non-stellar emission, we identified pix-
els where the excess is above the 3σ significance threshold in the 4.5µm "dust map", and
examined their colors and locations.
In scatter plots of these pixel values vs. Hα or vs.
8 µm dust emission, a correlation branch is evident in both cases with moderate slopes in
fν(4.5 µm)/fν(8 µm) and fν(4.5 µm)/Hα (Figure 3), as well as a branch with very steep, al-
most vertical slopes. The pixels in the latter branch are strongly associated with the 3.6 µm
emission, including the brightest foreground star and a large number of point sources spread
almost uniformly accross the whole map. We use this excess map as a mask to efficiently
remove foreground stars, with additional hand masking of residues around very bright stars.
On the other hand, the branches with moderate 4.5 µm/8 µm and 4.5 µm/Hα ratios
map into bright star formation regions, as might be expected (Figure 4a). The global ratio
νfν(4.5 µm)/νfν(8 µm) for the selected dust emission amounts to ∼ 4%. However, summing
the pixels in star forming regions with large 4.5 µm excess, dust alone accounts for 17%
of the total 4.5 µm emission, probably more if dust contribution to the 3.6 µm emission
were accounted for. Two uncertainties remain which will be addressed in future papers:
Whether redder SEDs of young stars affect significantly the results in star forming regions;
and whether the 4.5µm dust associates more closely with ionized regions or with Photo-
Dissociation Regions (PDR).
The dust maps at 5.8 and 8 µm should be dominated by the Aromatic Features in
Emission (AFE) proposed by Puget & L´eger (1989)) to explain IRAS data, and well studied
with ISO (Boulanger et al. 1998; Helou et al. 2000; Lu et al. 2003). The value and variability
of the ratios between these bands are of considerable interest in constraining the physical
state of the emitters (e.g. de Frees et al. 1993). Lu et al. (2003) found the AFE profiles
among galaxies constant to within measurement uncertainty of 15 to 25% in the range 5 to
12µm; the Spitzer images can extend this finding to much greater accuracy, and could point
to variations within disks on a variety of scales.
– 5 –
We find that νfν(5.8 µm)/νfν(8 µm) for dust emission alone is constant to within the
uncertainties, with a value of 0.50± 0.09 (3σ) over most of the area where surface brightness
is above the 6σ level in each of the 5.8 µm and 8 µm dust maps.
3.2. Comparison to Hα
Figure 4c shows a comparison between Hα and 8 µm maps at a resolution of 2×FWHM ∼
5.15′′ ∼ 50 pc. In the outer disk, several H II regions as well as more complex structures are
visible in the Hα map, with the corresponding 8 µm profile flatter and sometimes significantly
offset from the Hα peak. In spite of the complex structure, Figure 4c-d clearly shows the 8 µm
emission highlighting the rims of H II regions. The ratio 8 µm/Hα goes up by a factor five
to ten from inside to just outside the H II region. This ratio may increase by another factor
of 2–4 in diffuse regions, but this is uncertain because of limited sensitivity and inaccurate
continuum subtraction in the Hα map. While this behavior is not a complete surprise, the
Spitzer data are the first to show it so clearly in a nearby galaxy. Boulanger et al. (1990),
Sellgren et al. (1990), Giard et al. (1994) and others have reported sharp boundaries to the
AFE, with peaks on molecular cloud surfaces outside ionized regions, and related this to a
combination of UV excitation and photo-processing of the AFE carriers. Helou et al. (2001)
also speculated that AFE arise primarily in PDRs based on physical arguments rather than
direct observations. Inside the H II regions, the Aromatics are depressed probably because
of destruction by the ionizing UV (Boulanger et al. 1990).
The sharp contrasts near H II regions between 8 µm and Hα are only a small-scale
property. Summing over scales larger than about 1 kpc, the ratio between the two tracers is
constant to about 40%. The global ratio of 8 µm to unextincted Hα is roughly 30% smaller
than the average measured in disks of spiral galaxies by Roussel et al. (2001a), which had
itself a dispersion of 50% among disks. For this comparison, the total Hα+[N II] flux from
Hoopes et al. (1996) was corrected for an extinction A(Hα) = 0.37 and an Hα/(Hα+[N II])
ratio of 0.91, averaged from values of individual H II regions in Webster & Smith (1983).
The 8 µm IRAC flux was converted to 7 µm flux in the ISO filter LW2 assuming the same
spectral shape as in the disk of M 83 (Roussel et al. 2001b), which was verified to reproduce
accurately the 5.8 µm/8 µm dust ratio of NGC 300.
The star formation rate in the disk of NGC 300 is 0.08–0.11 M⊙ yr−1 from the 8 µm
emission (as calibrated for solar-metallicity spiral disks by Roussel et al. 2001a), and ∼
0.14 M⊙ yr−1 from Hα (as calibrated by Kennicutt 1998). The agreement points to 8 µm
under these conditions as a viable proxy for ionizing flux, and therefore for on-going massive
star formation rate. Since the association between 8 µm and Hα is not at the atomic process
– 6 –
level however, it will be subject to geometric and other effects, and the use of 8 µm as such
a proxy is unlikely to be valid under all conditions.
Figure 4e-f also shows the 24 µm emission is more peaked than 8 µm in star forming
regions. The spatial resolution is insufficient to distinguish whether PDRs or ionized regions
are more closely associated with the 24 µm peaks. This confirms earlier suggestions based
on global SED analysis that 24 µm traces heating by the youngest and most massive stars
in a galaxy (Helou 2000).
4. Mid-IR to Far-IR SED
In order to study the SED at λ ≥ 8 µm, we identified nineteen emission regions in
the dust maps, most centered on a local peak (Figure 5l). After smoothing all maps to
the resolution of 160 µm, we measured the emission of each region in a circular aperture
2.5 × FWHM(160 µm) = 95′′ ∼ 1 kpc in diameter. The resulting photometry is plotted
in Figure 5 as various color ratios against fν(8 µm)/fν(24 µm), and compared to the ratios
expected from pre-Spitzer model SEDs of galaxies (Dale & Helou 2002). These are single-
parameter models of dust emission integrated over whole galaxies, and incorporate a power-
law distribution of dust over heating intensities. The data and model agree in the trends,
though there are systematic offsets in the values. These offsets are most simply understood
as a systematic discrepancy of ∼ 30% at 160 µm and ∼ 15% at 70 µm between model and
measurement, assuming reliable photometry at 8 and 24 µm. In view of the simplicity of the
models, photometric uncertainties (especially non-linearity effects) and source extent, the
agreement between model and data is quite satisfactory, and suggests that beyond a certain
scale portions of galaxies may approach full galaxies in their behavior.
The 160 µm and less so the 70 µm maps display a striking large halo which echoes several
features of the HI envelope. It is unclear at this point whether this reflects unusually cold
material in the outer disk, or whether the larger 160 µm beam is simply more sensitive to
low surface brightness features.
5. Summary
The Spitzer Space Telescope data allow us more clearly than ever to dissect the inter-
stellar dust emission components in NGC 300 and to relate them to star formation. The
8 µm AFE highlights the rims of the H II regions defined by Hα, confirming it is more closely
associated with PDRs than with ionized regions. When averaging over regions larger than
– 7 –
∼ 1 kpc, the ratio of Hα to AFE emission in NGC 300 is consistent with the disk value
observed in other galaxies. This confirms AFE as a convenient massive star formation rate
estimator in disks of galaxies. The mid-IR spectral signature of the AFE is invariant as
measured by the ratio fν(5.8 µm)/fν(8 µm), which is essentially constant at ∼ 50 pc reso-
lution at the ∼ 20% (3σ) measurement accuracy over most of the disk of NGC 300. The
24 µm emission is more strongly peaked than 8 µm in star forming regions. Interstellar dust
emission at 4.5 µm is confirmed at about the expected amplitude; for the first time, its spa-
tial distribution associates it clearly with star forming regions. The data cannot distinguish
between PDRs and H II regions as the primary origin for either 4.5 or 24 µm dust emission.
The SED models of (Dale & Helou 2002) apply to ∼kpc-sized portions in the disk to within
the current photometry and calibration uncertainties of 20–30%.
The Spitzer Space Telescope is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California
Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Adminis-
tration. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database which is
operated by JPL/Caltech, under contract with NASA.
REFERENCES
Bernard, J.P., Boulanger, F., D´esert, F.X., Giard, M., Helou, G., & Puget, J.L. 1994, A&A,
291, L5
Boulanger, F., Boissel, P., Cesarsky, D., & Ryter, C. 1998, A&A, 339, 194
Boulanger, F., Falgarone, E., Puget. J.-L., & Helou, G. 1990, ApJ, 346, 136
Butler, D.J., Martinez-Delgado, D. & Brandner, W. 2004, AJ127, 1472
Dale, D.A., Helou, G., Contursi, A., Silbermann, N., & Kolhatkar, S. 2001, ApJ, 549, 215
Dale, D.A., & Helou, G. 2002, ApJ, 159, 576
de Frees, D.J., Miller, M.D., Talbi, D., et al. 1993, ApJ, 408, 530
Deharveng, L., Caplan, J., Lequeux, J., et al. 1988, A&AS, 73, 407
Engelbracht, C.W. et al. 2004, ApJS, this volume
Fazio, G. et al. 2004, ApJS, this volume
Freedman, W.L., Madore, B.F., Hawley, S.L., et al. 1992, ApJ, 396, 80
– 8 –
Giard, M., Bernard, J. P., Lacombe, F., Normand, P., & Rouan, D. 1994, A&A, 291, 239
Gordon, K.D. et al. 2004, PASP, submitted
Helou, G. 2000, in "Infrared Astronomy: Today and Tomorrow", ed. F. Casoli, J. Lequeux
& F. David (Springer Verlag: Les Ulis) p. 337
Helou, G., Lu, N.Y., Werner, M.W., Malhotra, S., & Silbermann, N.A. 2000, ApJ, 532, L21
Helou G., Malhotra S., Hollenbach D.J., Dale D.A. & Contursi A. 2001, ApJ, 548, L73
Hoopes, C.G., Walterbos, R.A., & Greenawalt, B.E. 1996, AJ, 112, 1429
Hunt, L.K., Giovanardi, C., & Helou, G. 2002, A&A, 394, 873
Kennicutt, R.C. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 189
Larsen, S.S., & Richtler, T. 1999, A&A, 345, 59
Leitherer, C., Schaerer, D., Goldader, J.D., et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 3
Lu, N., Helou, G., Werner, M.W., et al. 2003 ApJ, 588, 199
Pannuti, T.G., Duric, N., Lacey, C., et al. 2000, ApJ, 544, 780
Puche, D., & Carignan, C., & Bosma, A. 1990, AJ, 100, 1468
Puget, J.L. & L´eger, A. 1989, ARA&A, 27, 161
Rieke, G. H. et al. 2004, ApJS, this volume
Roussel, H., Sauvage, M., Vigroux, L., & Bosma, A. 2001a, A&A, 372, 427
Roussel, H., Vigroux, L., & Bosma, A., et al. 2001b, A&A, 369, 473
Sellgren, K., Tokunaga, A.T., & Nakada, Y. 1990, ApJ, 349, 120
Thuan, T.X., & Sauvage, M. 1992, A&AS, 92, 749
Webster, B.L., & Smith, M.G. 1983, MNRAS, 204, 743
Werner, M. W. et al. 2004, ApJS, this volume
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
– 9 –
Fig. 1.- Images of NGC 300 obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope and other sources.
The left-most column shows observed maps at (a) 3.6 µm, (b) 4.5 µm, (c) 5.8 µm, (d) 8 µm.
The center column shows (e) BVRHα composite image (credit MPG/ESO), where B is
coded in blue, V in green, R and Hα in red; (f) Hα map described in Section 2; (g) dust
map at 5.8 µm; (h) dust map at 8 µm. The right-most column shows (i) H I map from Puche
et al. (1990); and observed maps at (j) 24 µm; (k) 70 µm; (l) 160 µm, with photometric
apertures used in Figure 5 superposed. Each frame contains the peak surface brightness
in the background-subtracted image; all images are in logarithmic scale, except the 160 µm
image which is linear. North is about 40◦ clockwise from vertical up, and each frame is
approximately 20′ on a side.
– 10 –
Fig. 2.- SED decomposition: The SEDs of NGC 300 in three different apertures are shown,
with all fluxes normalized to 3.6 µm: the nuclear stellar cluster (clearly contaminated by
dust emission judging from morphology in the IRAC maps), the inner arcmin, where dust
contribution is relatively small, and the whole galaxy. The thick dashed lines trace model
photospheric SEDs from 2 to 24 µm, derived from Starburst99 for a range of star formation
histories and two metallicities, and transformed to IRAC filter fluxes. The horizontal error
bars represent the filter widths at half maximum transmission. The Ks fluxes are lower
limits, because the 2MASS map is not sensitive to the diffuse emission.
Fig. 3.- Scatter plot of excess fν(4.5 µm) versus dust-only fν(8 µm), normalized by the
noise in the original maps. Individual pixels are plotted, after convolution of all maps to a
common angular resolution. The correlation branch was isolated by selecting pixels below
the solid line (corresponding to Figure 4a). The uncorrelated emission, extending to much
higher brightnesses, was cut here for clarity. The scatter plot versus Hα, not included, shows
a similar correlation branch, most pixels of which map into the 8 µm correlation branch.
– 11 –
Fig. 4.- Top: Distribution of excess 4.5 µm emission, f e
ν (4.5 µm), in units of the noise in
the initial 4.5 µm map, σ4.5. (a): Part of f e
ν (4.5 µm) which is correlated with 8 µm and Hα
(950 pixels ∈ [3; 19] σ4.5. (b): Part of f e
ν (4.5 µm) which is not correlated with 8 µm nor Hα,
in logarithmic scale (4583 pixels ∈ [3; 8150] σ4.5). The contours are Hα isophotes (a) and
the 4σ isophote of the 8 µm dust map (b). Bottom: Comparison of Hα and dust emission:
(c) log(fν(8 µm) / Hα) (95% of pixels span 1.2 dex), showing low ratios inside prominent
H II regions; (e) log(fν(8 µm) / fν(24 µm)) (95% of pixels span the linear range [0.6; 2.2]),
showing again the distinctly low color ratios of H II regions; (d) 8 µm (red) and Hα (green)
composite image; (f) 8 µm (red) and 24 µm (green) composite image.
– 12 –
100.00
10.00
)
8
/
0
7
(
R
,
)
0
7
/
,
)
4
2
/
0
7
(
R
,
)
8
/
0
6
1
(
R
,
)
4
2
/
0
6
1
(
R
0
6
1
(
R
1.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
R(24/8)=fnu(24um)/fnu(8um)
Fig. 5.- Color-color plot for all Spitzer bands at λ ≥ 8 µm, for the regions measured with an
aperture corresponding to ∼ 1 kpc in the plane of NGC 300, with the Dale & Helou (2002)
model predictions superposed as curves. Each curve has one symbol at x=2.28 to indicate
the corresponding color ratio. We corrected the 8 µm fluxes by a factor of √0.69 since the
aperture is intermediate in size between the nominal point-source aperture and infinitely
extended scales. The one point with error bars illustrates the uncertainties of 25% on the x-
axis and 35% on the y-axis. Squares are for 160 µm/8 µm; X signs are for 160 µm/24 µm; plus
signs are for 70 µm/8 µm; triangles are for 70 µm/24 µm; and circles are for 160 µm/70 µm.
The systematic offset at the longer wavelength bands is discussed in the text.
|
astro-ph/0604492 | 2 | 0604 | 2007-09-19T08:08:07 | Einstein and Jordan frames reconciled: a frame-invariant approach to scalar-tensor cosmology | [
"astro-ph",
"gr-qc",
"hep-ph",
"hep-th"
] | Scalar-Tensor theories of gravity can be formulated in different frames, most notably, the Einstein and the Jordan one. While some debate still persists in the literature on the physical status of the different frames, a frame transformation in Scalar-Tensor theories amounts to a local redefinition of the metric, and then should not affect physical results. We analyze the issue in a cosmological context. In particular, we define all the relevant observables (redshift, distances, cross-sections, ...) in terms of frame-independent quantities. Then, we give a frame-independent formulation of the Boltzmann equation, and outline its use in relevant examples such as particle freeze-out and the evolution of the CMB photon distribution function. Finally, we derive the gravitational equations for the frame-independent quantities at first order in perturbation theory. From a practical point of view, the present approach allows the simultaneous implementation of the good aspects of the two frames in a clear and straightforward way. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Einstein and Jordan frames reconciled: a frame-invariant approach to scalar-tensor
DESY 06 -- 076
cosmology
Riccardo Catena
Deutsches Elektronen-Syncrotron DESY, 22603 Hamburg, Germany
INFN, Sezione di Padova, via Marzolo 8, I-35131, Padova, Italy
Massimo Pietroni
Luca Scarabello
Dipartimento di Fisica Universit`a di Padova and INFN,
Sezione di Padova, via Marzolo 8, I-35131, Padova, Italy
Scalar-Tensor theories of gravity can be formulated in different frames, most notably, the Einstein
and the Jordan one. While some debate still persists in the literature on the physical status of the
different frames, a frame transformation in Scalar-Tensor theories amounts to a local redefinition
of the metric, and then should not affect physical results. We analyze the issue in a cosmological
context. In particular, we define all the relevant observables (redshift, distances, cross-sections, ...)
in terms of frame-independent quantities. Then, we give a frame-independent formulation of the
Boltzmann equation, and outline its use in relevant examples such as particle freeze-out and the
evolution of the CMB photon distribution function. Finally, we derive the gravitational equations
for the frame-independent quantities at first order in perturbation theory. From a practical point of
view, the present approach allows the simultaneous implementation of the good aspects of the two
frames in a clear and straightforward way.
I.
INTRODUCTION
The evidence for Dark Energy has revived the interest in modifications to General Relativity (GR). Among these
theories, Scalar-Tensor gravity (ST) [1] represents a good benchmark to accommodate new ultra-light degrees of
freedom possibly responsible for the accelerated expansion of the universe.
From a phenomenological point of view, it respects local Lorentz invariance and the universality of free fall of test
bodies. Moreover, the post-Newtonian parameters γ − 1 and β − 1, parameterizing the deviations from GR, are
expressed in terms of a single function, thus allowing a straightforward confrontation of the theory with solar system
tests of gravity [2, 3, 4].
From a theoretical point of view, this class of theories is large enough to accommodate a vast range of possible
extensions of GR in which new scalar fields are present in the gravitational sector; from extra-dimensional radions and
string theory moduli, to f (R) theories of gravity. Moreover, in a ST context, ultralight scalar fields are technically
natural. Indeed, general covariance implies that the contribution of radiative corrections from the (visible and dark)
matter sector to the scalar field mass is at most of order Λ4/M 2
p , Λ being the cosmological constant. Thus, the
lightness of the scalar field is just a manifestation of the smallness of the cosmological constant, or of the curvature
of the universe [5].
Finally, in a cosmological setting, it has been pointed out that an intriguing attraction mechanism towards GR [6]
could be operative under very generic conditions, including the case of a runaway potential suitable for DE [7, 8, 9].
Therefore, these theories may differ considerably from GR at high redshifts and at the same time fulfill the stringent
bounds coming from solar system tests [4] today.
ST theories can be formulated in different guises. In the so-called 'Jordan frame', the Einstein-Hilbert action of
GR is modified by the introduction of a scalar field1 with a non-canonical kinetic term and a potential. This field
replaces the Planck mass, which becomes a dynamical quantity. On the other hand, the matter part of the action is
just the standard one.
By Weyl-rescaling the metric, one can express the ST action in the so called 'Einstein Frame'.
In these new
variables, the gravitational action is just the Einstein-Hilbert one plus a scalar field with canonically normalized
kinetic terms and an effective potential. On the other hand, in the matter action the scalar field appears, through the
rescaling factor multiplying the metric tensor everywhere. As a consequence, the matter energy-momentum tensor is
1 ST theory can be generalized with the introduction of many scalar fields [1]. In order not to overload the notation, in this paper we will
consider a single field, but our results are easily generalizable to the multi-field case.
2
not covariantly conserved, and particle physics parameters, like masses and dimensionful coupling constants appearing
in the lagrangian are space-time dependent.
It is a general fact that physics is invariant under a local redefinition of field variables -- in this case, the Weyl-
rescaled metric. Nevertheless, this invariance is not fully exploited in the literature, where some confusion also exists
about the physical status of the different frames. Most authors prefer to work in the Jordan frame, which is also
referred to as the 'physical' one. The advantage of this frame is that all the particle physics' properties, i.e masses,
coupling constants, decay rates, cross sections, etc. can be computed straightforwardly, since the matter action is just
the standard one. On the other hand, the gravitational equations are more involved than in GR, since the scalar is
non-trivially mixed to the metric tensor.
Working in the Einstein frame is easier for what concerns the gravitational equations, but the connection with
particle physics is not so direct as in the Jordan frame, since, for instance, the electron mass appearing in the
lagrangian is space-time dependent. So, many authors use the Einstein frame as a mathematical tool to solve the field
equations, and then translate back the results in the Jordan frame to compare with observations. For some recent
applications along these lines, see, for instance [8, 10, 11, 12]. Non-linear approaches have also been discussed [13, 14].
While both these procedures are correct, a general discussion of the frame-invariance of physics in the ST theories
in a cosmological setting is still missing. In particular, while it is quite straightforward to go back and forth from
one frame to the other when the barotropic fluid approximation for matter holds, it is not so clear how to do it
when Boltzmann equations have to be employed. For instance, the epoch of decoupling of some interaction in the
expanding universe, expressed in conformal time, should be derived independently on the frame. But the standard
rule of thumb, that is,
Γ <∼ H/a ,
(1)
with Γ the reaction rate and H the Hubble parameter, is not a frame-invariant relation.
The purpose of this paper is to formulate a frame-invariant approach to discuss ST cosmology. Following Dicke
[15, 24], we will start by the observation that the physical observables are dimensionless ratios between physical
quantities and the appropriate units of measure2. These numbers are frame-invariant, and should therefore be
expressible in terms of frame-invariant quantities. We will discuss the main observables in cosmology (redshift,
distances, CMB temperature perturbations, . . . ) and particle physics (masses, cross sections, rates, . . . ) and express
them in terms of frame-invariant combinations of the theory parameters and variables, and the units. We will discuss
metric perturbations and define a frame-invariant phase space and distribution function. This will enable us to write
down a frame-invariant Boltzmann equation to discuss processes relevant for cosmology, like particles freeze-out, the
Sachs-Wolfe effect, and matter-radiation decoupling. Finally, we will derive the equations of motion for the frame
invariant quantities at first order in metric perturbations.
The plan of the paper is as follows.
In sect. II we will introduce frame-transformations.
In sect. III we will
discuss how frame-invariant results can be obtained for rates, cross sections, and so on. The cosmological background
observables, that is redshift and (angular and luminosity) distance will be discussed in sect. IV. Then, we will consider
scalar perturbations in the Newtonian gauge. We will see that a frame transformation amounts to a change of gauge,
and will therefore define frame-invariant scalar metric perturbations. This will enable us to define a frame-invariant
phase space and energy-momentum tensor (sect. V). The Boltzmann equation will be introduced in sect. VI, where
its application to particles' freeze-out and CMB photons will be outlined. Finally, in sect. VII, we will discuss the
ST dynamics. We will write down the ST action in terms of frame-invariant quantities only, and write down the
corresponding equations of motion at first order. In the appendix, the case of the synchronous gauge and of a generic
gauge will be discussed.
II. FRAME TRANSFORMATIONS
In general, a frame transformation is a rescaling of the metric gµν, of the form
with f = f (xµ) and real, and the space-time coordinates xµ (µ = 0, . . . , 3) are kept fixed. The diffeomorphism-
invariant space-time interval then gets transformed as
ds2 = gµνdxµdxν = e−2f gµνdxµdxν = e−2f ds2 .
(3)
gµν = e−2f gµν ,
(2)
2 Strictly speaking, this argument applies only to local physical quantities independent of metric derivatives.
3
Considering time-like and space-like intervals, we see that proper times, dt0 = ds(timelike), and proper lengths,
dl0 = ds(spacelike), transform as
dt0 = e−f dt0
dl0 = e−f dl0 .
(4)
The above transformations can be seen as the relations between the clocks and rods in two different systems of units
[15, 16]. Notice that the above transformation laws are, in general, space-time dependent, since so is the function
f (xµ). Such transformations are not common in GR and in standard physics in general, where they are of no practical
use. However, in ST the situation changes dramatically. For instance, one could consider two different units of length,
say, the size of an atom and the radius of a small Schwarzschild black hole. The ratio between these two physical
lengths, which is constant in GR, is in general space-time dependent in ST. Therefore, in this kind of theories, the
operational definition of units implies local transformations.
Since ds2 = 0 is a frame-invariant condition, the speed of light is also invariant under the transformation (4).
Moreover, we will impose that the Planck constant ¯h is also invariant. This amounts to transforming units of mass
(and energy) as
M = ef M ,
(5)
and in leaving actions invariant (but, in general not covariant!). It should be emphasized that this is by no means a
unique choice. One could for instance consider frame transformations in which ¯h varies and the Newton constant is
kept fixed. However, our prescription is the one realized in ST theories, which are the main focus of this work.
Since -- in the particular class of local transformations we are considering -- units of time, length, and inverse
masses transform in the same way, we will consider a single dimensionful unit, length. The generic unit length will
be indicated by lR. It transforms according to the space-time dependent relation of eq. (4)
lR = e−f lR .
(6)
Then, a generic local physical quantity, Q, having the dimensions [Mass]a [Length]b, and [Time]c, will transform
according to
Q = ef (a−b−c) Q .
(7)
The scaling above holds as long as the quantity Q does not depend on derivatives of the metric. The choice of the
unit length is dictated, as usual, by practical convenience. For instance, one could use a reference atomic wavelength,
the inverse physical mass of some particle, or the Planck length.
Physics does not depend on which particular clock or rod one adopts.
In the following, we will discuss this
independence in the framework of Friedmann-Robertson-Walker cosmology, but of course this is a general property
[15].
III. FRAME-INVARIANT PARTICLE PHYSICS
The particle physics action (the underlying theory being the Standard Model, or any of its extensions) has the form
Z d4x√−g L =Z d4x
√−g
l4
R
l4
R L .
(8)
Since both the action and the combination √−g/l4
construct a lagrangian L such that
R are frame-invariant, so is the product l4
R L. It is convenient to
l4
R
L = l4
R L + ··· ,
(9)
where the dots represents terms containing space-time derivatives of lR and lR. This is achieved transforming the
parameters and fields in L as follows:
R λn = ln
ln
R
Aµ = Aµ ,
(10)
where λn is a generic coupling of canonical dimension n (e.g. m2 φ2 ≡ λ2 φ2, h φ4 ≡ λ4 φ4, and so on), φ, ψ, and Aµ
are scalar, spinor and vector fields, respectively, and γµ are the Dirac gamma matrices.
lR γµ = lR γµ ,
lR φ = lR φ ,
l3/2
R ψ = l3/2
R
ψ ,
λn ,
4
In particular, the mass parameters appearing in the lagrangian can be constant in one frame and space-time
dependent in all the other ones, as m = lR/lR m = ef m. In ST gravity masses and couplings are constant in the
Jordan frame and space-time dependent in the Einstein one.
In general, the space and time scales of variation of the function f = log(lR/lR) depend on the model and can
be determined by solving the full set of equations of motion. We will make the assumption that these scales are of
cosmological -- or at least astrophysical -- size, and in any case much larger than particle physics interaction times and
effective ranges [13, 14]. So, in computing transition amplitudes, decay rates and cross sections, the particle physics
parameters adiabatically adjust their relations in eq. (10) to the local values of the functions f , lR and lR, up to
corrections of O(λP P /L), λP P being a typical particle physics interaction range and L the typical scale of variation
of f . Then, one can compute all the relevant observables in a frame-independent way, following the usual rules of
quantum field theory and using the frame-invariant combinations of eq. (10). The results are frame-independent decay
rates, cross sections, etc., given by
The above quantities are the true observables, that is, in any frame, the dimensionless combinations between the Γ's,
σ's, ..., and the appropriate powers of the standard rod length.
lR Γ = lR Γ ,
R σ = l−2
l−2
R σ ,
··· .
(11)
IV. FRAME-INVARIANT FRW COSMOLOGY: BACKGROUND OBSERVABLES
We will consider the background FRW metric
where τ = x0 is the conformal time, δij is the delta-function, and latin indices run from 1 to 3. We will assume that
the function f defining the frame transformation (2) can be expanded as
ds2 = −a2(τ )(dτ 2 − δijdxidxj) ,
(12)
f (τ, xi) = ¯f (τ ) + δf (τ, xi) ,
(13)
where δf can be treated as a perturbation of the same order as the metric perturbations. Then, the scale factor in
the other frame is given by
a(τ ) = e− ¯f(τ )a(τ ) .
(14)
A. Redshift and temperature
One of the basic cosmological observables is the redshift of photon wavelengths. Using the metric (12) one gets the
standard result that a photon traveling through the cosmos, which, at time τi had wavelength λ(τi), at a later time
τf would have a wavelength
λ(τf ) = λ(τi)
a(τf )
a(τi)
.
(15)
Looking at the transformation (14) we see that the ratio λ(τf )/λ(τi), which is usually defined as the cosmological
redshift, is not a frame-invariant quantity. This should be no surprise, since this ratio is not what is actually measured.
Instead, the physical quantity is the dimensionless ratio between the wavelength of the -- emitted or absorbed -- photon
and some reference length, measured in the laboratory. Then, the frame-invariant redshift can be defined using a
frame-invariant combination such as
λ(τ0)
¯lR(τ0)
¯lR(τ )
λ(τ )
=
a(τ0)
a(τ )
¯lR(τ )
¯lR(τ0)
,
(16)
where the bar denotes the spatial average. In order to give an operative definition of redshift, the unit lR has to be
specified. In practice, a reference atomic wavelength is chosen, which we will indicate with lR = lat. In principle,
different reference wavelengths could have different space-time dependences, thus leading each to a different definition
of redshift. However, in ST theories this is not the case, as they all have constant ratios one another. Therefore, in
these theories, the redshift can be defined unambiguously as
1 + z(τ ) ≡
a(τ0)
a(τ )
¯lat(τ )
¯lat(τ0)
.
(17)
5
The standard relation between the redshift and the scale factor, i.e. 1 + z = a(τ0)/a(τ ) is recovered only in that
frame in which the reference wavelength lat is constant in time and space.
In ST theories this is the case of the
Jordan frame, whereas, in terms of the scale factor of any other frame one has 1 + z = a(τ0)/a(τ ) exp( ¯f (τ ) − ¯f (τ0)),
f being the function connecting the frame under consideration with the Jordan one, according to eq. (2). It should
be stressed that the reason for the Jordan frame to be singled out from all the possible ones, is a matter of practical
utility, namely, the choice of lat in the definition of eq. (17), but has nothing to do with it having a better physical
status than the others. In principle, a physicist could decide to measure the wavelength of cosmological photons in
Planck units. In this case, his definition of redshift would have the standard relation to the scale factor of the Einstein
frame, not the Jordan one.
Since the comoving coordinate volume is frame-invariant, the total entropy per comoving coordinate volume is a
frame-invariant quantity. In the perfect fluid approximation it is given by the standard expression
where r is the comoving radius, ρ and p the energy density and the pressure, and T is the temperature. Recalling the
definition of the energy-momentum tensor for matter,
S =
(ra)3(ρ + p)
T
,
(18)
with SM the matter action, we get the transformation laws,
T µ
ν = e4f T µ
ν .
Tµν = −
2
√−g
δSM
δgµν ,
(19)
(20)
It should be noted that the above relation is valid as long as the matter action SM does not depend on derivatives
of the metric, as is the case in ST theories. In the case of barotropic fluids with background energy ρ = −T 0
0 and
pressure p δi
j = −T i
j , we have
From the frame-invariance of the comoving entropy and using eqs. (14) and (21), we get that the dimensionless
combination T lR is frame invariant, and that, choosing again lR = lat, the temperature-redshift relation is
ρ = e4 ¯f ρ ,
p = e4 ¯f p .
(21)
Notice that T ∼ 1/a, in any frame.
T (τ )¯lat(τ )
T (τ0)¯lat(τ0)
= 1 + z(τ ) .
B. Distances
(22)
The basic quantity entering the definition of the different distance indicators used in cosmology is the comoving
distance traveled by a light ray emitted at redshift z, r(z). This is obtained using the (frame-invariant) condition for
photon geodesics, i.e. ds2 = 0, that is, using eqs. (12) and (17),
r(z) =Z r
0
dr =Z a0
a
da
a
=Z z
0
dz
1 + z a
a −
¯lat
¯lat!−1
,
(23)
where the overdot indicates a derivative with respect to the conformal time τ .
The redshift-dependence of the frame-invariant combination a/a − ¯lat/¯lat appearing at the denominator can be
computed in any frame. In ST gravity, the ¯lat/¯lat term vanishes in the Jordan Frame and one needs to solve the
Friedmann equations for the scale factor in that frame. On the other hand, in the Einstein frame, one needs also the
time-dependence of the field ¯f relating the two frames, since ¯lat/¯lat = ¯f in this frame. For practical purposes it may
be convenient to work in the Einstein frame, since its equations are simpler.
The angular distance of an object of proper diameter D at coordinate r, which emitted light at time τ (and redshift
z(τ )) is given by
dA ≡
D
δ
¯l0
R
¯lR(z)
= a0 r(z)(1 + z)−1 ,
(24)
R ≡ ¯lR(τ0) and a0 ≡ a(τ0). In the definition
where δ is the observed angular diameter today, and we have defined ¯l0
above, we had to keep track of the possibility that the length of the standard rod lR evolves in time in the frame
under consideration. Since a0/¯l0
R, z, and r(z) are all frame invariant, so is also the measure of dA expressed in terms
of the present value of the unit length ¯l0
R, that is, the ratio dA/¯l0
R.
Analogously, the luminosity distance can be defined in a frame-invariant way as
6
d2
L
l0
R
2 ≡ L ¯lR(z)2
4π F l0
R
4 ,
(25)
where L is the luminosity (energy per unit time) of the object at redshift z and F is the energy flux measured today.
One can verify that the angular and luminosity distances defined above satisfy the standard relation
dL(z) = (1 + z)2dA(z) .
(26)
Finally, the number counts of objects (galaxies, clusters, . . . ) as a function of redshift measure the frame-invariant
observable
dN
dz
= nc(z) r(z)2 a
a −
¯lat
¯lat!−1
dz
1 + z
dΩ ,
(27)
where nc(z) is the comoving number density.
V. FRAME-INVARIANT PERTURBATIONS
Now we include first order perturbations of the metric and of the function f , eq. (13). We will work in Newtonian
gauge, leaving to the Appendix the extension to the synchronous gauge and to a generic gauge.
The line element in a generic frame is given by
with Ψ and Φ two scalar functions of space-time. Considering also the fluctuation of lR, lR = ¯lR + δlR, we can write
down the frame-invariant line element as
ds2 = a2(τ )(cid:2)−(1 + 2 Ψ)dτ 2 + (1 − 2 Φ)δijdxidxj(cid:3) ,
(28)
(29)
ds2/l2
R = a2(τ )/¯l2
R(cid:20)−(cid:18)1 + 2 Ψ − 2
δlR
lR (cid:19) dτ 2
+(cid:18)1 − 2 Φ − 2
δlR
lR (cid:19) δijdxidxj(cid:21) ,
which still has the form of an invariant line element in a Newtonian gauge, with frame-invariant scale factor and
potentials
¯a ≡ a/¯lR ,
¯Ψ ≡ Ψ −
δlR
lR
,
¯Φ ≡ Φ +
δlR
lR
.
(30)
All the physical observables, up to first order, must depend on the above quantities. In the previous section we have
seen already how it works at zeroth order. In the following we will extend the program to first-order.
A. Frame invariant geodesics
It is convenient to work with comoving coordinates, since they are frame-invariant. Then, besides space-time
coordinates x0 = τ and xi, we will also consider the conjugate momenta. For a particle of mass m they are given by
where ds ≡ √−ds2.
As we have seen in sect. III, the lagrangian mass of a particle is not a frame-invariant quantity, m = lR/lR = ef m,
independent of whether the particle is a scalar, spinor or a vector.
Pµ = m gµν
dxν
ds
,
(31)
7
Taking into account the frame dependence of the mass, one can verify that the canonical momenta (31) with low
indices are frame-invariant.
The geodesic equation for a particle with space-time dependent mass is
Using the metric (28) we arrive at the equation for the frame-invariant momentum Pi,
P 0 dP µ
dτ
+ Γµ
λσ P λ P σ = −m ∂σ m gσµ .
dPi
dτ − P0 ∂i(Ψ + log m) = 0 ,
(32)
(33)
which is manifestly frame-invariant since ∂i(Ψ + log m) = ∂i( ¯Ψ + log ¯m), where ¯m = lR m.
In some applications, such as the Boltzmann equation entering the computation of the CMB spectra, see sect. VI,
it is convenient to eliminate the perturbations from the definition of the momenta by going to new variables qi and ǫ
[17], which can be defined in a frame-invariant way as
Pi = (1 − ¯Φ) qi ,
P0 = −(1 + ¯Ψ) ǫ .
Writing qi = q ni, with ninjδij = 1, one can verify the relation ǫ = [q2 + ¯a2 ¯m2]1/2. The geodesic equation in these
variables have the standard form
which is valid also in the massless case ǫ = q.
Photon trajectories are given by the frame-invariant equation ds2 = 0. As a consequence, the expressions for the
deflection angles due to weak lensing depend on the frame-invariant combination Ψ + Φ = ¯Ψ + ¯Φ [18].
q = q
∂
∂τ
¯Φ − ǫ ni
∂
∂xi
¯Ψ ,
(35)
B. The energy-momentum tensor
One can define a frame-invariant distribution function F (xi, Pj, τ ), giving the number of particles in a (frame-
invariant) differential volume in phase space,
(34)
(36)
(37)
(38)
From F one can define the comoving number density,
F (xi, Pj , τ ) dx1dx2dx3dP1dP2dP3 = dN .
and the energy-momentum tensor,
nc(xi, τ ) = gsZ d3P
(2π)3 F (xi, Pj, τ ) ,
Tµν = gsZ d3P
(2π)3 (−g)−1/2 PµPν
P 0 F (xi, Pj, τ ) ,
where d3P = dP1dP2dP3 and gs counts the spin degrees of freedom. One can verify that the above definition fulfills
the transformation rule of eq. (20). The distribution function for bosons (-) and fermions (+) in equilibrium is the
standard one [17],
F 0(ǫ) =(cid:16)eǫ/T0 ± 1(cid:17)−1
.
(39)
Using the variables qi, ǫ defined in eq. (34), the components of the energy momentum tensor are explicitly given,
at first order, by
¯T 0
0 = l4
R T 0
¯T 0
i = l4
R T 0
d3q
δ ¯ρ
0 = −gs¯a−4Z
i = gs¯a−4Z
j = gs¯a−4Z
¯ρ (cid:19) ,
(2π)3 ǫf = − ¯ρ(cid:18)1 +
d3q
(2π)3 qnif = ¯ρ(1 + w) vi ,
d3q
ninjf = ¯ρ(cid:20)w + c2
(2π)3
q2
ǫ
¯ρ (cid:21) δi
where f (xi, q, nj, τ ) = F (xi, Pj, τ ), vi ≡ dxi/dτ , w is the equation of state, and c2
¯T i
j = l4
R T i
δ ¯ρ
s
j + Σi
j ,
s = ∂ ¯P /∂ ¯ρ.
(40)
VI. THE BOLTZMANN EQUATION
8
From what we have discussed in the previous session, it is now clear that, using the frame-invariant coordinates xi,
Pj, and τ , it is possible to study departures from thermal equilibrium in a frame-invariant way. The tool is, as usual,
the Boltzmann equation. The evolution of the phase space density of a particle ψ, Fψ(xi
j , τ ) is given by
ψ, P ψ
∂F ψ
∂τ
+
dxi
ψ
dτ
∂F ψ
∂xi
ψ
dP ψ
j
dτ
+
∂F ψ
∂P ψ
j
=(cid:20) dF ψ
dτ (cid:21)C
.
(41)
The frame-invariance of the LHS is trivially checked. One can cast it in a more useful form by using dxi
and eq. (33).
ψ/dτ = P i
ψ/P 0
ψ
The collisional term for a generic process ψ + a + b + ··· ↔ i + j + ··· reads
0 Z dΠadΠb ··· dΠidΠj ···
1
2P ψ
(xi
ψ, P ψ
j , τ ) =
(cid:20) dFψ
dτ (cid:21)C
×(2π)4δ4(P ψ + P a + P b ··· − P i − P j ···)
×(cid:2)M2
−M2
ψ+a+b+···→i+j+···FψFaFb ··· (1 ± Fi)(1 ± Fj)···
i+j+···→ψ+a+b+···FiFj ··· (1 ± Fψ)(1 ± Fa)(1 ± Fb)···(cid:3) ,
where the ′′+′′ applies to bosons and the ′′−′′ to fermions, and dΠ is the frame-invariant quantity
dΠ ≡ l2
R
= l2
R
d4P
(2π)3 (−g)−1/2 δ(P 2 + m2)Θ(P 0)
d3P
(2π)3
(−g)−1/2
¯l2
R a−2
(2π)3
2P 0 =
d3q
2ǫ
,
(42)
(43)
with d4P = dP0 d3P . The delta-function in eq. (42) depends on momenta with low indices.
A. Freeze out
As a first example, we consider the case of a heavy particle decaying into two lighter ones, which are assumed to
equilibrate rapidly. Following the standard procedure (see for instance ref. [19]) the (conformal) time dependence of
the comoving number density is given by
nψ
c = gsZ d3P
(2π)3 M2
=Z d3P Ψ
2P ψ
0
dτ (cid:21)C
(2π)3 (cid:20) dFψ
dΠadΠb(2π)4δ(4)(P ψ − P a − P b)(Fψ − F 0
a F 0
b ) ,
where we have approximated 1 ± F ≃ 1.Using energy conservation we can write, as usual,
a F 0
F 0
b = F 0
ψ ,
and then
nψ
c = −(nψ
c − nψ
c
0
)Z dΠadΠb(2π)4δ(4)(P ψ − P a − P b) M2
2mψa
,
(44)
(45)
(46)
where for the non-relativistic particle Ψ we have used P ψ
0 ≃ −mψa. Recognizing the integral as the decay rate per unit
conformal time, Γ a, where Γ is the decay probability per unit physical time, and turning to the variable x = mψ/T ,
we get the frame-invariant equation
d nψ
c
d log x
= −
Γ a
H(1 + m′
ψ/mψ)
(nψ
c − nψ
c
0
) ,
(47)
where primes denote derivatives with respect to log a and we have used the relation T /T = −H. From the above
equation one can see that the usual rule of thumb for a particle interaction to be efficient in the expanding Universe,
that is Γ a >∼ H, now generalizes to the frame-invariant relation
Γ a >∼ H(1 + m′
ψ/mψ) .
(48)
9
We stress again that the frame independence of the above equation is a consequence of the frame-independence of
the product Γa, and then, ultimately, of that of the matrix element M2.
Analogously, in the case of a 2 ↔ 2 scattering process one gets the result
0!2
nψ
Γ a
H(1 + m′
d nψ
c
d log x
= −
c
nψ
c
1
nψ
c
0
ψ/mψ)
,
− 1
(49)
where Γ = nψ
c
0
a−3hσvi, with hσvi the thermally averaged cross section.
From these examples one can appreciate the utility of the frame-invariant Boltzmann equations. In practice, it
turns out that rates, cross sections, and all the particle physics related quantities are more conveniently computed in
a frame different from that in which the Einstein equations are simpler. For instance, in scalar-tensor theories, particle
physics is conveniently computed in the Jordan frame, whereas gravitational equations are simpler in the Einstein
frame. Since frame-invariant combinations -- such as Γa -- appear in the equations above, one can first compute rates
and cross sections in the more convenient frame and then translate them in the other one using the relations of
eq. (11).
Using the 0-0 component of the energy-momentum tensor, eq. (40) one can define (space and direction-dependent)
temperature fluctuations for a gas of photons (ǫ = q, gs = 2) as
B. Sachs-Wolfe effect
From the collisionless Boltzmann equation for the function f ,
Θ(xi, nj, τ ) ≡
∆T
T
(xi, nj, τ ) =
1
4π2 ¯ρ¯a4 Z dqq3f − 1 .
∂f
∂τ
+ xi ∂f
∂xi + q
∂f
∂q
+ nj
∂f
∂nj
= 0 ,
using the geodesic equation (35) and the relation ni = qi/q = xi(1 − ¯Φ − ¯Ψ)ǫ/q, one gets
(Θ + ¯Ψ) = ¯Ψ + ¯Φ ,
d
dτ
(50)
(51)
(52)
where use has been made of the fact that potentials and δlR do not depend on the angle explicitly, and ( ) ≡ ∂ /∂τ . If
the potential are static, the quantity Θ + ¯Ψ is conserved, which is the frame-invariant expression for the Sachs-Wolfe
effect [20].
C. Phase space evolution for CMB photons
The evolution of the CMB photon distribution function is described by the Boltzmann equations discussed, for
instance, in [17, 21, 22]. To reduce the number of variables, one integrates out the q dependence and expands the
angular dependence in Legendre polynomials, Pl. Going to Fourier space, one defines
F (~k, n, τ ) ≡ R f 1(~k, ~q, τ )q3dq
R f 0(q)q3dq ≡
(−i)l(2l + 1)Fl(~k, τ )Pl(k · n) ,
Xl=0
≡
∞
G(~k, n, τ ) ≡ R Q1(~k, ~q, τ )q3dq
R Q0(q)q3dq ≡
(−i)l(2l + 1)Gl(~k, τ )Pl(k · n) ,
Xl=0
≡
∞
10
(53)
(54)
where ~k = kk is the wavevector and n the direction of the photons 3-momentum ~q. f 0 is the zeroth order (equilibrium)
distribution function and f 1 the first order deviation from it, while Q0 and Q1 are the zeroth and first order Stokes
parameter, respectively.
The Boltzmann equations for F and G take the form
∂F
∂τ
∂τ (cid:19)C
+ ikµF − 4( ¯Φ − ikµ ¯Ψ) =(cid:18) ∂F
∂τ (cid:19)C
+ ikµG =(cid:18) ∂G
∂G
∂τ
,
,
with µ ≡ k · n. Again, the LHS are manifestly frame-invariant. The collisional terms are given by [17]
(cid:18) ∂F
∂τ (cid:19)C
= a−2ne
∂τ (cid:19)C
(cid:18) ∂G
c σT (cid:20)−F + F0 + 4n · ~ve −
= a−2ne
c σT (cid:20)−G +
1
2
1
2
(F2 + G0 + G2) P2(cid:21) ,
(F2 + G0 + G2) (1 − P2)(cid:21) ,
(55)
(56)
c are respectively the proper velocity and comoving density of the electrons, and σT the Thomson
c σT = ¯a−2ne
c ¯σT is frame-invariant, and so is the proper velocity, the frame-invariance of the collisional
where ~ve and ne
cross section.
Since a−2ne
terms is also manifest.
VII. EQUATIONS OF MOTION FOR SCALAR-TENSOR THEORIES
It is convenient to define the frame-invariant metric
hµν ≡ l−2
P l gµν ,
(57)
where the unit length lP l will be later identified with the Planck length. If gµν is a FRW metric in Newtonian gauge,
so is hµν, with scale factor ¯a and potentials ¯Ψ, ¯Φ as defined in eq. (30) with lR = lP l. Notice that hµν and ¯a2 have
dimension of (mass)2.
Scalar-tensor theories can be defined in terms of frame-independent quantities by the action
S = SG[hµν , ϕ] + SM [hµνe−2b[ϕ], ¯φ , ¯ψ , . . . ; ¯λn] ,
(58)
where the frame-independent fields ¯φ , ¯ψ , . . ., and coupling constants ¯λn's, appearing in the matter action SM are
given by the combinations in eq. (10) with lR = lP l.
The gravity action is given by
SG = κZ d4x√
−h(cid:2)R(h) − 2 hµν∂µϕ ∂ν ϕ − 4 ¯V (ϕ)(cid:3) .
(59)
The only feature differentiating the action in eq. (58) from that of standard GR is the function b[ϕ(x)]. In the
b = 0 limit, the scalar-tensor theory reduces to GR with an extra scalar field, ϕ, which in this limit can be seen as
an extra matter component minimally coupled to gravity. In this case, a constant lP l can be univocally taken as the
most convenient choice to measure all the dimensional quantities in the theory. In this units, both the Planck mass
and particle masses, as well as atomic wavelengths, are constant.
On the other hand, when b 6= 0, the scalar field ϕ(x) is non-minimally coupled to gravity and one has a genuine
scalar-tensor theory. In the literature, these theories are usually discussed in two frames, the Einstein and the Jordan
ones. In our language, choosing a frame corresponds to fixing the function lP l(x) appropriately.
11
The first possible choice is to take a constant lP l, which corresponds to the Einstein frame. The gravity action
takes the usual Einstein-Hilbert form
SG = κ l−2
P l Z d4x√−g [R(g) − 2 gµν∂µϕ ∂ν ϕ − 4V (ϕ)] ,
(60)
¯V . The combination in front of the integral fixes the Einstein-frame Planck mass, κ l−2
with V = l−2
∗ /2 =
P l
(16πG∗)−2.
In other words, in this frame, dimensional units are set by the Planck scale. The matter action is
obtained from the one of quantum field theory by substituting the Minkowsky metric ηµν with gµνe−2b. Since in this
frame the matter energy-momentum tensor is not conserved (see eq. (66)), particle physics quantities, like masses and
wavelengths are not constant.
P l = M 2
The other choice corresponds to the Jordan frame, which is obtained by making the Planck length space-time
dependent such as to reabsorb b[ϕ(x)] in SM . This is accomplished if one choses lP l = lP l e−b, where lP l is the
previously defined Planck length in the Einstein frame. With this choice the matter action takes the standard form
of quantum field theory (with ηµν → gµν ), whereas the gravity action is
SG =
where V = l−2
P l
¯V and
M 2
∗
2 Z d4xp−g e2bhR(g) − 2 gµν∂µϕ ∂νϕ (1 − 3 α2) − 4 V (ϕ)i ,
db
dϕ
.
α ≡
(61)
(62)
Notice that, in this frame, the role of the Planck mass is played by the space-time dependent quantity M∗eb. Since
b[ϕ(x)] disappears from the matter action, the energy-momentum tensor is now covariantly conserved.
Of course, any other choice for lP l is possible in principle and leads to the same physical consequences. However, for
practical purposes, only the Einstein and Jordan frames are employed. The discussion of the previous sections shows
how one can exploit the good aspects of the two. One can compute cross sections, decay rates, etc., in the Jordan frame,
where masses and couplings are constant and the usual rules of quantum field theory apply straightforwardly. Then,
one constructs frame-invariant combinations out of these, such as Γa, and insert them into the frame-independent
Boltzmann equations like eqs. (47, 49). On the other hand, the gravity part, like the combination H(1 + m′/m)
can be computed in the Einstein frame. Equivalently, both the particle physics part and the gravity part can be
computed frame-invariantly from the beginning, using the particle physics parameters defined in eq. (10) and solving
the equations of motion obtained from the action in eq. (58), that we are going to write down explicitly up to first
order.
Before doing that, we give the expression of the redshift (17) in terms of the frame-invariant scale factor ¯a = a/lP l,
that is
where ¯b(τ ) ≡ b[ ¯ϕ(τ )].
1 + z =
¯a(τ0)
¯a(τ )
¯b(τ )−¯b(τ0) ,
e
A. Background equations
The background equations for the scale factor ¯a are
The energy-momentum tensor ¯T µ
2
3(cid:18) 1
2
¯a
¯a
ϕ2 + ¯a2 ¯V(cid:19) =
¯a(cid:19)2
(cid:18) ¯a
−
3(cid:0) ϕ2 − 4¯a2 ¯V(cid:1) = −
ν is not conserved,
ν; µ = −α ϕν ¯T µ
¯T µ
µ ,
12κ
1
1
+
1
6κ
¯ρ¯a2 ,
¯ρ¯a2(1 − 3w) .
which, at zeroth-order implies
¯ρ + 3 ¯ρ (1 + w) ¯a/¯a = −α ϕ ¯ρ (1 − 3w) .
(63)
(64)
(65)
(66)
(67)
One can verify that, with the Jordan frame choice, i.e. lP l ∼ e−b, the covariant conservation of the energy-momentum
tensor is recovered.
The equation of motion for the field ϕ is
12
which, at zeroth-order, gives
hµν ¯Dνϕµ −
δ ¯V
δϕ
=
α
4κ
¯T µ
µ ,
ϕ + 2
¯a
¯a
ϕ + ¯a2 ∂ ¯V
∂ϕ
=
α
4k
¯a2 ¯ρ (1 − 3w) .
B. First-order equations
Here we give the set of first order equations:
δϕ = −
1
4κ
δ ¯ρ¯a2 ,
k2 ¯Φ + 3
k2(cid:18) ¯Φ +
¯Φ +
¯a
¯a
¯ρ¯a2(1 + w)θ ,
¯a
¯a
¯Ψ(cid:19) − ( ϕδ ϕ − ϕ2 ¯Ψ) + 2¯a2 δ ¯V
δϕ
¯a
¯a
¯a
1
4κ
¯a(cid:18) ¯Φ +
¯Ψ(cid:19) − ϕk2δϕ =
¯a(cid:19)2# ¯Ψ −
¯a −(cid:18) ¯a
+ ¯Ψ ϕ2 − ϕδ ϕ +
( ¯Ψ + 2 ¯Φ) +"2
¯a
1
k2( ¯Ψ − ¯Φ) +
3
δ ¯V
1
δϕ
4κ
δϕ =
c2
sδ ¯ρ¯a2 ,
k2( ¯Φ − ¯Ψ) =
3
4κ
¯ρ¯a2(1 + w)σ ,
where θ ≡ ikjvj and ¯ρ(1 + w)σ ≡ −( ki kj − δij /3)Σi
j, with ki = ki/k.
At first order, the continuity equation for the matter energy-momentum tensor, eq. (66), yields
∂α
∂ϕ
δϕ(cid:19) −
∂w
∂ ¯ρ
¯δ = −(1 + w)(θ − 3 ¯Φ) − (1 − 3w)(cid:18)αδ ϕ + ϕ
¯ρ¯δ(cid:18) ¯a
− 3
θ = −(1 − 3w)(cid:18) ¯a
+ k2( ¯ψ − σ) −
¯a − α ϕ(cid:19) ,
¯a − α ϕ(cid:19) θ −
(1 − 3w)
(1 + w)
k2αδϕ ,
1 + w
w
∂ ¯ρ ¯ρ(cid:17)
θ + (cid:16)w + ∂w
1 + w
k2¯δ
where ¯δ ≡ δ ¯ρ/ ¯ρ.
The equation of motion for the scalar field fluctuation δϕ, from eq. (68) is
δ ϕ + 2
¯a
¯a
δ ϕ − ∇2δϕ − ¯ψ ϕ − 3 ϕ ¯Φ + 2 ¯ψ¯a2 ∂ ¯V
∂ϕ −
∂ϕ2 δϕ =
4k (cid:20)¯ρ(1 − 3w)
δϕ +(cid:18)1 − 3w − 3
¯ρ¯a2(1 − 3w) ¯ψ +
¯ρ(cid:19) αδ ¯ρ(cid:21) .
∂w
∂ ¯ρ
∂α
∂ϕ
α
2k
¯a2
+ ¯a2 ∂2 ¯V
(68)
(69)
(70)
(71)
(72)
(73)
(74)
(75)
(76)
A particular ST theory is identified by two functions: b(ϕ) and the effective potential ¯V (ϕ), see eqs. (58) and
(59). Therefore, the physical deviations from GR should be parameterized in terms of these two functions alone,
VIII. CONCLUSION
13
irrespectively of the frame one choses to solve the equations of motion [2, 3]. Actually, as we have shown, fixing a
frame is not necessary, provided one carefully expresses all the observables in terms of frame-invariant quantities.
From a practical point of view, the formulation of ST gravity presented in this paper allows a straightforward
modification of the available codes based on Boltzmann equations for the study of Nucleosynthesis, CMB, or the
calculation of the Dark Matter relic abundances in the context of GR. It is enough to redefine the redshift as in
eq. (63) and add the scalar field ϕ to the GR equations of motion, as in sects. VII A and VII B. Then, the code will
work in the standard way, the only difference being given by the two extra inputs b and ¯V . The implementation of
this procedure to the publicly available CMBFAST [23] code is under way.
We will show how the results obtained in the text in the Newtonian gauge can be extended to the synchronous
gauge and to a generic gauge.
IX. APPENDIX
The synchronous gauge is defined by
A. The synchronous gauge
ds2 = a2(cid:2)−dτ 2 + (δij + hij) dxidxj(cid:3) .
After a frame transformation ds2 → ds2 = e−2f ds2 the metric of eq. (77) transforms in
ds2 = a2e−2fB(cid:2)−(1 − 2δf )dτ 2 + (δij + hij − 2δf δij) dxidxj(cid:3) ,
(77)
(78)
Unlike for the Newtonian gauge, a frame transformation doesn't preserve the synchronous gauge. However it is
possible to give a frame-independent description of all the physical phenomena also when the metric perturbations are
described in the basis (hij, δf ). In fact, as we will see, the geodesic motion depends only from the frame-independent
combination ¯hij = hij − 2(δlR/lR)δij .
To show this in a simple way let's define a synchronous gauge as in the following
In this way at least the spatial components of the metric are frame-independent.
dh2 = ¯a2(cid:2)−dτ 2 +(cid:0)δij + ¯hij(cid:1) dxidxj(cid:3) .
As for the Newtonian gauge we now relate the 4-momentum Pµ to the frame-independent variables qi and ǫ
P0 = −ǫ ,
Pi = (cid:18)δij +
1
2
¯hij(cid:19) qj .
With this definitions the relation ǫ =pq2 + ¯m¯a2 is preserved.
Using eqs. (80) and the metric of eq. (79) the geodesics equation at first order yields
q = −
1
2
qninj ¯hij .
Also if the metric of eq. (79) is not frame-invariant, eq. (81) is not affected by a frame transformation.
Let's consider now the metric
B. The case of a generic gauge
(79)
(80)
(81)
ds2 = a2{−(1 + 2ψ)dτ 2 + 2∂iBdτ dxi + [(1 − 2Φ)δij + DijE] dxidxj}
(82)
where Dij =(cid:0)∂i∂j − 1
After a frame transformation ds2 → ds2 = e−2f ds2 eq. (82) transforms in
3 δij∇2(cid:1).
ds2 = a2e−2fB{−(1 + 2ψ − 2δf )dτ 2 + 2∂iBdτ dxi +
+ [(1 − 2Φ − 2δf )δij + DijE] dxidxj}
14
(83)
The transformation properties of the metric in eq. (82) suggest to define the following frame-invariant line element
where the frame-invariant quantities ¯a, ¯ψ and ¯Φ are given in eq. (30). We also wrote ¯B = B and ¯E = E to underline
dh2 = ¯a2{−(1 + 2 ¯ψ)dτ 2 + 2∂i ¯Bdτ dxi +(cid:2)(1 − 2 ¯Φ)δij + Dij ¯E(cid:3) dxidxj} ,
(84)
that such a quantities do not transform under frame transformations.
The 4-momentum is now related to the frame invariant variables qi and ǫ by the following relations
P0 = −(cid:2)qi∂i ¯B + ǫ(1 + ¯ψ)(cid:3) ,
Dij ¯E(cid:21) qj ,
Pi = (cid:20)(1 − ¯Φ)δij +
1
2
with ǫ =pq2 + ¯m¯a2.
Using now eqs. (85) and the metric of eq. (84) at first order the geodesic equation yields
q = q ¯Φ − ǫni∂i ¯ψ + 2ǫni(cid:18) ¯a
¯a
∂i ¯B + ∂i
¯B(cid:19) − qninj(cid:18)∂i∂j ¯B +
1
2
Dij
¯E(cid:19)
(85)
(86)
If in eq. (86) we impose ¯B = ¯E = 0 we recover eq. (33). Choosing instead ¯B = ¯ψ = 0 and −2 ¯Φδij + Dij ¯E = ¯hij
eq. (86) reduces to eq. (81).
R. Catena acknowledges a Research Grant funded by the VIPAC Institute.
Acknowledgments
[1] P. Jordan, Schwerkaft und Weltall (Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1955); Nature (London), 164, 637 (1956); M. Fierz, Helv. Phys.
Acta 29, 128 (1956); C. Brans and R.H. Dicke, Phys. Rev. 124, 925 (1961).
[2] C.Will, Theory and experiments in gravitational physics, Cambridge University ress, 1990), pp. 313.
[3] T. Damour, gr-qc/9606079, lectures given at Les Houches 1992, SUSY95 and Corf´u 1995.
[4] B. Bertotti, L. Iess and P. Tortora, Nature 425, 374 (2003).
[5] K. Choi, hep-ph/9912218; M. Pietroni, Phys. Rev. D 72, 043535 (2005).
[6] T. Damour and K. Nordtvedt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 2217 (1993); Phys. Rev. D 48, 3436 (1993);T. Damour and
A. M. Polyakov, Nucl. Phys. B 423, 532 (1994).
[7] N. Bartolo and M. Pietroni, Phys. Rev. D 61, 023518 (2000).
[8] R. Catena, N. Fornengo, A. Masiero, M. Pietroni and F. Rosati, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 063519; R. Catena, M. Pietroni
and L. Scarabello, Phys. Rev. D 70, 103526 (2004).
[9] G. Esposito-Farese and D. Polarski, Phys. Rev. D 63, 063504 (2001).
[10] A. Coc, K. A. Olive, J. P. Uzan and E. Vangioni, [arXiv:astro-ph/0601299].
[11] C. Schimd, J. P. Uzan and A. Riazuelo, Phys. Rev. D 71, 083512 (2005).
[12] J. Martin, C. Schimd and J. P. Uzan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 061303 (2006).
[13] F. Perrotta, S. Matarrese, M. Pietroni and C. Schimd, Phys. Rev. D 69, 084004 (2004).
[14] S. Matarrese, M. Pietroni and C. Schimd, JCAP 0308, 005 (2003).
[15] R. H. Dicke, Phys. Rev. 125, 2163 (1962).
[16] C. Armendariz-Picon, Phys. Rev. D 66, 064008 (2002); E. E. Flanagan, Class. Quant. Grav. 21, 3817 (2004).
[17] C. P. Ma and E. Bertschinger, Astrophys. J. 455, 7 (1995).
[18] N. Kaiser Astrophys.J. 498 (1998) 26; V. Acquaviva, C. Baccigalupi and F. Perrotta, Phys. Rev. D 70, 023515 (2004).
[19] E. W. Kolb and M. S. Turner, "The Early Universe", 1990, Redwood City, USA, Addison-Wesley, 547 pp.
[20] R. K. Sachs and A. M. Wolfe, Astrophys. J. 147, 73 (1967).
[21] J. R. Bond and G. Efstathiou, Astrophys. J. 285, L45 (1984); Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 226, 655 (1987).
[22] A. Kosowsky, Annals Phys. 246, 49 (1996).
[23] U. Seljak and M. Zaldarriaga, Astrophys. J. 469, 437 (1996).
[24] R. Catena, M. Pietroni and L. Scarabello, J. Phys. A 40, 6883 (2007).
15
|
astro-ph/0208331 | 1 | 0208 | 2002-08-17T19:35:20 | NGC 3576 IRS 1 in the Mid Infrared | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present the results of high-resolution mid-infrared observations of the source NGC 3576 IRS 1. Near diffraction-limited images were taken at the Gemini South Observatory through OSCIR's filters N, 7.9, 9.8, 12.5 and IHW18. The source IRS 1 was resolved into 3 sources for the first time at mid-infrared wavelengths. For each source we constructed the SED from 1.25 to 18 microns, as well the color temperature and the spatial distribution of the dust in the region. The optical depth of the silicate absorption feature at 9.8 microns is presented also. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
**TITLE**
ASP Conference Series, Vol. **VOLUME***, **YEAR OF PUBLICATION**
**NAMES OF EDITORS**
NGC 3576 IRS 1 in the Mid Infrared
C´assio Leandro D. R. Barbosa
IAG-USP, R.do Matao 1226, 05508-900, Sao Paulo, Brazil
[email protected]
Augusto Damineli
IAG-USP, R.do Matao 1226, 05508-900, Sao Paulo, Brazil
[email protected]
Robert D. Blum
Cerro Tololo Interamerican Observatory, Casilla 603, La Serena, Chile
[email protected]
Peter S. Conti
JILA, University of Colorado, Campus Box 440, Boulder, CO, 80309
[email protected]
Abstract. We present the results of high-resolution mid-infrared ob-
servations of the source NGC3576 IRS 1. Near diffraction-limited images
were taken at the Gemini South Observatory1 through OSCIR's2 filters
N (10.8 µm), 7.9, 9.8, 12.5 and IHW18 (18.2 µm). The source IRS1 was
resolved into 3 sources for the first time at mid-infrared wavelengths. For
each source we constructed the SED from 1.25 to 18 µm, as well the color
temperature and the spatial distribution of the dust in the region. The
optical depth of the silicate absorption feature at 9.8 µm is presented
also.
1.
Introduction
The formation mechanism of massive stars is essentially unknown. This is mostly
due to observational difficulties in finding and establishing an evolutionary se-
1Based on observations obtained at the Gemini Observatory, which is operated by the Associ-
ation of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under a cooperative agreement with the
NSF on behalf of the Gemini partnership: the National Science Foundation (United States),
the Particle Physics and Astronomy Research Council (United Kingdom), the National Re-
search Council (Canada), CONICYT (Chile), the Australian Research Council (Australia),
CNPq (Brazil) and CONICET (Argentina).
2This paper is based on observations obtained with the mid-infrared camera OSCIR, developed
by the University of Florida with support from the National Aeronautics and Space Admin-
istration, and operated jointly by Gemini and the University of Florida Infrared Astrophysics
Group.
1
2
C´assio Barbosa et al.
quence for young stellar objects (YSOs). It is believed that during the accretion
phase, YSOs remain heavily enshrouded in dusty cocoons, behind hundreds
of magnitudes of extinction at visual wavelengths (even at near-infrared wave-
lengths for the earliest phases).
A very interesting group of YSOs has been identified in the Galactic gi-
ant HII regions (GHII) M17 (Hanson, Horwarth & Conti 1997), W43 (Blum,
Damineli & Conti 1999), W42 (Blum, Conti & Damineli 2000), W31 (Blum,
Damineli & Conti 2001) and NGC 3576 (Figueredo et al. 2002). These are lu-
minous YSOs with excess emission in the K band and have color indexes H-K>2.
J, H and K spectra of these objects typically show a featureless continuum. In
some cases the CO 2.3 µm bandhead is seen in emission or absorption, and in
others FeII and/or H2 are seen in emission.
Figueredo et al. (2002) identified two massive YSO candidates in the posi-
tion of IRS 1 in NGC 3576. This source was discovered by Lacy, Beck & Geballe
(1982) and it was recently observed at 10 µm by Walsh et al. (2001), but none
of their images have enough spatial resolution to resolve the source.
2. Observations
Observations were obtained at the Gemini South Observatory 8-m telescope on
December 4th, 2001. OSCIR is based on a Rockwell 128×128 pixel Si:As BIB
detector, with a 0.089 arcsec/pixel plate scale at Gemini. The total field of view
of the camera is 11×11 arcsec and the spatial resolution (FWHM of the PSF
star) is ∼0.5 arcsec. The images were taken through the wide N-band filter
(10.8µm) and IHW18 (18.2 µm) and the 7.9, 9.8 and 12.5 µm narrow filters.
Flux calibration was performed by taking the flux densities of the mid-infrared
standard star α CMa observed during the night as part of the baseline calibration
program. The uncertainty of these procedures is estimated to be ∼10%, which
is good enough for our purposes.
All images presented have on-source exposure time of 46 seconds, except
the N-band image which has 40 seconds. Background and sky subtraction was
done via the standard chop and nod technique.
3. Results
The field of NGC 3576 IRS 1 is shown in the Figure 1, for the N and IHW18
bands.
IRS 1 has been resolved into 3 sources embedded in extended emis-
sion. All images were smoothed by convolving each image by the corresponding
normalized PSF star fitted from the standard star using a Fourier transform.
Figure 2 shows the spectral energy distribution (SED) of each source. The
JHK fluxes are from Figueredo et al. (2002), the L-band flux is from Moneti
(1992). The NIR-to-MIR SEDs are very similar to the results found for a group
of less massive AeBe stars by Hillenbrand et al.
(1992). The stars of this
group (called group II) have SEDs with infrared excess and are supposed to be
young stars with intermediate masses (M∼< 10 M⊙, average spectral type A5)
still accreting. The infrared excess is attributed to a dense dusty accretion disk
surrounding the young stars.
NGC 3576 in the Mid Infrared
3
Left:The N-band image of IRS-1. The contours are at 0.01
Figure 1.
0.025, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, ..., 0.5 Jy/ ✷". Right: The 18µm image of IRS-1.
The contours are at 0.044, 0.088, 0.13, 0.17, 0.2, 0.27, 0.35, 0.4 Jy/ ✷".
North is up, East is left for both images. Each image is 11×11 arcsec.
NIR/MIR NGC 3576 IRS-1 SED
J
H
K
L
N
#48
#50
#60
-7.5
-8
-8.5
-9
-9.5
-10
-10.5
-11
14.5
14.25
14
13.75
logν (Hz)
13.5
13.25
)
y
J
(
x
u
F
g
o
l
l
2
1
0
-1
-2
NGC 3576 IRS-1 SED
#50
#60
#48
f-f
8
10
12
Wavelength (µm)
14
16
18
20
)
2
m
c
/
s
/
g
r
e
(
ν
F
ν
g
o
l
Left:NIR-to-MIR SED for each source identified in the IRS
Figure 2.
1 position. Right: The SED constructed from the fluxes measured at
mid infrared.The dashed line is the projected free-free emission of the
gas from De Pree, Nysewander & Goss (1999), assuming Sν ∝ ν −1.
4
C´assio Barbosa et al.
Figure 3.
Left: The map of the silicate absorption at IRS-1 position.
The darker is the region, the strongest is the absorption. The contour
at the source #60 position indicates where the absorption turns into
emission. Right: The dust color temperature map of IRS-1. The con-
tour levels are represent temperatures of 160, 180, 200, ..., 280 K. Both
images are 5.8×5.8 arcsec.
Figure 3 shows the spatial distribution of the dust, as well as, its color
temperature map. The map at the left was obtained dividing the calibrated
image taken at 9.8 µm by the 7.9 µm image. From this map, we have calculated
the optical depth of the silicate absorption feature and we found τ9.8=3.7. The
right panel is the dust color temperature map which was calculated from the
ratio of the 7.9/18 µm images. From this map we can see the dust tempera-
ture associated with each source: T∼280K (#50), T∼210K (#48) and T<160K
(#60).
4. Summary
We presented high-resolution mid-infrared images of NGC 3576 IRS 1, that has
been resolved into 3 sources for the first time at mid-infrared wavelengths. The
SEDs of each source were constructed from 1.25 to 18 µm with data taken from
literature. Each SED shows increasing fluxes toward to longer wavelengths. Hil-
lenbrand et al. (1992) found similar SEDs for a group of less massive young
stars in process of accreting mass via an accretion disk embedded in a dusty
cocoon. This similarity suggests the same interpretation for our results. Finally
we presented maps of dust distribution, temperature and optical depth as well.
We thank Chris De Pree for kindly providing the FITS file of the 3.4 cm map
of NGC 3576.
CLB and AD acknowledge the financial support from PROAP, PRONEX and
NGC 3576 in the Mid Infrared
5
FAPESP.
PC appreciates continuing support from the National Science Foundation.
References
Blum, R. D., Damineli, A. & Conti, P. S. 1999, AJ, 117, 1392
Blum, R. D., Conti, P. S. & Damineli, A. 2000, AJ, 119, 1860
Blum, R. D., Damineli, A. & Conti, P. S. 2001, AJ, 121, 3149
De Pree, C. G., Nysewander, Melissa C. & Goss, W. N. 1999, AJ, 117, 2902
Figueredo E., Blum, R. D., Damineli, A. & Conti, P. S. 2002, AJ, accepted
Hanson, M., M., Horwarth, I. D. & Conti, P. S. 1997, ApJ, 489, 698
Hillenbrand, L. A., Strom, S. E., Vrba, F. J., Keene, J. 1992 ApJ, 397, 613
Lacy, J., Beck, S. & Geballe, T. 1982, ApJ, 255, 510
Moneti, A. 1992, A&A, 259, 627
Walsh, A. J., Bertoldi, F., Burton, M. G. & Nikola, T. 2001, MNRAS, 326, 36
|
0809.3265 | 1 | 0809 | 2008-09-18T22:17:46 | HI and CO in the circumstellar environment of the oxygen-rich AGB star RX Lep | [
"astro-ph"
] | Circumstellar shells around AGB stars are built over long periods of time that may reach several million years. They may therefore be extended over large sizes (~1 pc, possibly more), and different complementary tracers are needed to describe their global properties. In the present work, we combined 21-cm HI and CO rotational line data obtained on an oxygen-rich semi-regular variable, RX Lep, to describe the global properties of its circumstellar environment. With the SEST, we detected the CO(2-1) rotational line from RX Lep. The line profile is parabolic and implies an expansion velocity of ~4.2 km/s and a mass-loss rate ~1.7 10^-7 Msun/yr (d = 137 pc). The HI line at 21 cm was detected with the Nancay Radiotelescope on the star position and at several offset positions. The linear shell size is relatively small, ~0.1 pc, but we detect a trail extending southward to ~0.5 pc. The line profiles are approximately Gaussian with an FWHM ~3.8 km/s and interpreted with a model developed for the detached shell around the carbon-rich AGB star Y CVn. Our HI spectra are well-reproduced by assuming a constant outflow (Mloss = 1.65 10^-7 Msun/yr) of ~4 10^4 years duration, which has been slowed down by the external medium. The spatial offset of the HI source is consistent with the northward direction of the proper motion, lending support to the presence of a trail resulting from the motion of the source through the ISM, as already suggested for Mira, RS Cnc, and other sources detected in HI. The source was also observed in SiO (3 mm) and OH (18 cm), but not detected. The properties of the external parts of circumstellar shells around AGB stars should be dominated by the interaction between stellar outflows and external matter for oxygen-rich, as well as for carbon-rich, sources, and the 21-cm HI line provides a very useful tracer of these regions. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. 0089
November 1, 2018
c(cid:13) ESO 2018
H i and CO in the circumstellar environment of the
oxygen-rich AGB star RX Lep
Y. Libert1, T. Le Bertre1, E. G´erard2, and J.M. Winters3
8
0
0
2
p
e
S
8
1
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
5
6
2
3
.
9
0
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
1 LERMA, UMR 8112, Observatoire de Paris, 61 Av. de l'Observatoire, 75014 Paris, France
e-mail: [email protected]
2 GEPI, UMR 8111, Observatoire de Paris, 5 Place J. Janssen, 92195 Meudon Cedex, France
3 IRAM, 300 rue de la Piscine, 38406 St. Martin d'H`eres, France
Received: 29/04/2008; accepted: 25/08/2008
ABSTRACT
Context.Circumstellar shells around AGB stars are built over long periods of time that may reach
several million years. They may therefore be extended over large sizes (∼ 1 pc, possibly more),
and different complementary tracers are needed to describe their global properties.
Aims.We set up a program to explore the properties of matter in the external parts of circumstel-
lar shells around AGB stars and to relate them to those of the central sources (inner shells and
stellar atmospheres).
Methods.In the present work, we combined 21-cm H i and CO rotational line data obtained on an
oxygen-rich semi-regular variable, RX Lep, to describe the global properties of its circumstellar
environment.
Results. With the SEST, we detected the CO(2-1) rotational line from RX Lep. The line
profile is parabolic and implies an expansion velocity of ∼ 4.2 km s−1 and a mass-loss rate
∼ 1.7 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1 (d = 137 pc). The H i line at 21 cm was detected with the Nanc¸ay
Radiotelescope on the star position and at several offset positions. The linear shell size is rel-
atively small, ∼ 0.1 pc, but we detect a trail extending southward to ∼ 0.5 pc. The line profiles are
approximately Gaussian with an FWHM ∼ 3.8 km s−1 and interpreted with a model developed for
the detached shell around the carbon-rich AGB star Y CVn. Our H i spectra are well-reproduced
by assuming a constant outflow ( M = 1.65 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1) of ∼ 4 × 104 years duration, which
has been slowed down by the external medium. The spatial offset of the H i source is consistent
with the northward direction of the proper motion measured by Hipparcos, lending support to the
presence of a trail resulting from the motion of the source through the ISM, as already suggested
for Mira, RS Cnc, and other sources detected in H i . The source was also observed in SiO (3 mm)
and OH (18 cm), but not detected.
Conclusions. A detached shell, similar to the one around Y CVn, was discovered in H i around
RX Lep. We also found evidence of an extension in the direction opposite to the star proper
motion. The properties of the external parts of circumstellar shells around AGB stars should be
dominated by the interaction between stellar outflows and external matter for oxygen-rich, as well
as for carbon-rich, sources, and the 21-cm H i line provides a very useful tracer of these regions.
Key words. stars: individual: RX Lep -- stars: mass-loss -- stars: AGB and post-AGB -- stars:
winds, outflows -- radio lines: stars -- circumstellar matter
2
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
1. Introduction
Evolved stars on the asymptotic giant branch (AGB) are often surrounded by circumstellar shells.
The material in these shells is flowing outwards with velocities from a few km s−1 up to 40 km s−1
(Nyman et al. 1992). The observed mass-loss rates range from ∼ 10−8 to a few 10−4 M⊙ yr−1 (e.g.
Knapp & Morris 1985; Olofsson et al. 2002), the lower limit being probably set by detectability. In
this phase of the stellar life, the evolution is dominated by mass loss rather than nuclear processes
(Olofsson 1999). The history of mass loss over the full AGB is complex and the details of this
process are currently not well known (e.g., Lafon & Berruyer 1991; Habing 1996; Leao et al.
2006). A general picture, however, has arisen from both theoretical and observational findings that
- on average - the mass-loss rate increases towards the end of the AGB phase, leading in some cases
to the formation of a planetary nebula (e.g., Renzini 1981; Hrivnak & Bieging 2005).
The validity of this simple picture may depend on the parameters of the star, e.g., on its initial
mass. Schroder et al. (1999) combine mass-loss rates derived from consistent wind models with
stellar evolution calculations and find that the mass-loss rate should increase along the AGB for
stars with initial masses greater than 1.3 M⊙. Stars with lower initial mass would experience a single
short-lived (∼ 1000 yr) episode of high mass loss only, which would leave behind a very narrow
detached shell as observed in the case of, e.g., TT Cyg (Olofsson et al. 2000). On the other hand,
the mass-loss phenomenon appears to be highly variable on even shorter time scales as indicated
e.g. by concentric arcs observed in scattered light around the prototype carbon Mira IRC +10216
(Mauron & Huggins 2000) and around some proto-planetary nebulae (e.g., Hrivnak et al. 2001).
The time scale of these mass-loss variations would be around a few 102 yr. The physical mechanism
responsible for these variations still needs to be identified, although different possibilities have
already been proposed: e.g., interaction between gas and dust within stellar outflows (Simis et al.
2001), or solar-like magnetic cycle (Soker 2002). In contrast to these later phases of AGB mass loss
at rather high rates (∼ 10−5M⊙ yr−1), information about the mass-loss process on the early AGB, is
even scarcer.
To unravel the processes involved in the mass-loss phenomenon, we have to find suitable trac-
ers. One of the most studied among these tracers is the CO molecule, because so far it has been
considered to provide the best estimate of the mass-loss rate for AGB stars (Ramstedt et al. 2008).
Not only can it be used to estimate this mass-loss rate, but it also yields important parameters of
the AGB wind (e.g.: expansion velocity, central star velocity, etc.). Since CO is photodissociated
by UV radiation from the interstellar radiation field (ISRF), it can only probe the inner parts (r ≤
10−3 - 10−1 pc, Mamon et al. 1988) of circumstellar shells (CSs). Therefore, the CO emission is
only related to "recent" (i.e. a few 103 - 104 years) mass-loss episodes.
On the other hand, H i is in general protected from photoionization by the surrounding inter-
stellar medium (ISM). As a result, H i can be used to probe the external parts of circumstellar shells
and can give indications on the mass-loss on longer timescales (a few 105 years: Libert et al. 2007).
Hence, CO and H i complement each other nicely to describe the history of the mass-loss rate of an
AGB star.
The drawbacks of H i circumstellar observations are that hydrogen is ubiquitous in the Galaxy
and that the genuine stellar H i must be separated from the ambient H i. Ideal cases would be
bright H i sources, with relatively high velocity with respect to the local standard of rest (LSR) and
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
3
reasonably far above the Galactic plane. For the other sources, the interstellar H i should be studied
with care. In the present paper, we analyze this confusion with a new approach that consists in a
3D-mapping using H i spectra.
The mass-loss phenomenon is different from one AGB star to another and may vary highly with
time. Nevertheless, observing in H i provides a global view of the CS behavior and, on timescales
of about 105 years, small variations in the mass-loss rate may be flattened out. Thus, we have
developed a model of the circumstellar gas, based on a scenario already proposed by Young et
al. (1993), in which CSs are the result of a constant outflow eventually slowed down by the sur-
rounding medium. This deceleration produces a snowplough effect around the source, resulting in
a detached shell of compressed matter originating from the star and the external medium (Lamers
& Cassinelli 1999, Chap. 12).
A schematic view of this model can be pictured as follows: a wind is flowing outward from the
star, in free expansion with a constant velocity (Vexp) and a constant rate. It encounters a shock at a
radius r1 (termination shock), due to the slowing down by the surrounding matter. Between r1 and
rf (contact discontinuity), the stellar matter is compressed. Between rf and until a second shock
at r2 (bow shock), the interstellar matter has been swept up by the wind of the AGB star. Finally,
beyond r2, the external matter is considered to be at rest.
Recently, we successfully applied this model to a carbon-rich star: Y CVn (Libert et al. 2007).
In H i at 21 cm, this star exhibits a composite profile, made of a broad, rectangular component and
a narrow, Gaussian-shaped one. In our description, the broad component is the signature of the
freely expanding wind, whereas the narrow component is produced by the H i compressed in the
snowplough between r1 and r2. Our model provides a simple explanation for some of the so-called
"detached dust shells" observed in the far infrared (Izumiura et al. 1996). If this approach is correct,
then it should also apply to detached shells around oxygen-rich AGB stars. In this paper we present
H i and CO data that we obtained on an oxygen-rich AGB star, RX Lep, and interpret them with
the model that we developed for Y CVn. The H i interstellar confusion in the direction of RX Lep
is moderate and we illustrate, in that case, our new approach to extract a genuine H i spectrum.
In this simplified description we assume spherical symmetry. However, recent H i, far-infrared
and UV data (G´erard & Le Bertre 2006; Matthews & Reid 2007; Ueta et al. 2006; Martin et al.
2007) have shown that the AGB star motion with respect to the ISM may lead to a distortion, and
eventually a disruption, of the circumstellar environment. Previous, and more recent, numerical
modelings (Villaver et al. 2003; Wareing et al. 2007) are in line with this interpretation. The cir-
cumstellar environment of RX Lep might provide a new illustration of this phenomenon, and we
will discuss this possibility.
2. RX Lep
RX Lep has been classified as an irregular variable, Lb star (General Catalogue of Variable Stars,
GCVS 3rd ed., Kukarkin et al. 1971). A photometric monitoring over 8 years shows variations of
about ± 1 magnitude in the V band (Cristian et al. 1995). The periodogram analysis gives a main
period in the range 80-100 days and a possible secondary period around 60 days. Recently, the
star has been re-assigned to the type SRb (GCVS 4.2, Samus et al. 2004), because it may exhibit a
periodic variability of a few tenths of a magnitude.
4
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
The Hipparcos parallax (7.30±0.71 mas) places the star at 137+15
−12 pc from the Sun and at
∼ 65 pc away from the Galactic plane (bII=-27.51◦). The proper motion, also given by Hipparcos,
is 31.76±0.58 mas yr−1 in right ascension (RA) and 56.93±0.50 mas yr−1 in declination (Dec.). At
137 pc, it translates into a motion in the plane of the sky of 44 km s−1 (corrected for solar motion,
as determined by Dehnen & Binney 1998) in the northeast direction (PA ∼ 31◦).
Fouqu´e et al. (1992) have obtained near-infrared photometry data and, using the bolometric
correction of Le Bertre et al. (2001), we derived a luminosity of 4500 L⊙. This luminosity con-
firms that RX Lep is on the AGB. The effective temperature is ∼ 3300 K (Dumm & Schild 1998).
This means that hydrogen is expected to already be mostly in atomic form in the atmosphere and
throughout the CS (Glassgold & Huggins 1983). Technetium lines (99Tc) were searched for in the
4200-4300 Å region and not detected (Lebzelter & Hron 1999), confirming an older result from
Little et al. (1987). This tends to indicate that RX Lep has not gone through a thermal pulse and
that it is still in the early phase of the AGB (E-AGB). This is in good agreement with the results of
Mennessier et al. (2001) who, using astrometric and kinematic data, place RX Lep among E-AGB
stars that belong to the Galactic disk population with initial masses in the range 2.5-4 M⊙.
Paschenko et al. (1971) did not detect the source in the OH satellite line at 1612 MHz. As this
is the only OH observation reported in the literature, we observed RX Lep again at 18 cm on Jan.
12, 2006 and July 14, 2006 with the NRT. No emission was detected at a level of 0.015 Jy in any
of the 4 OH lines (1612, 1665, 1667, and 1720 MHz).
RX Lep might be associated with an IRAS extended source (X0509-119, IRAS Science Team
1988) at 60 (diameter ∼ 1.1′) and 100 µm (diameter ∼ 6.0′). However, X0509-119 is centered at
about 2.5′ east from RX Lep, and that association might only be fortuitous. We present a re-analysis
of the IRAS results farther down (Sect. 6).
Kerschbaum & Olofsson (1999) report a CO (1-0) and CO (2-1) detection, but their radial ve-
locity is doubtful: vhel ∼ 29 km s−1 (as compared to vhel ∼ 46 km s−1 cited in the General Catalogue
of Stellar Radial Velocities, GCRV, Wilson 1953). Our new results (Sect. 3) now suggest there has
likely been a confusion between the heliocentric and LSR reference frames.
3. Molecular line observations
RX Lep was part of a CO observing program dedicated to the Valinhos 'b' class stars (Epchtein et
al. 1987). This class of sources is defined by a weak near-IR excess as compared with the IRAS
fluxes (0.2 < K-L' < 0.7 and 0.8 < L'-[12] < 2). The central stars are generally identified with
late-M giants surrounded by tenuous circumstellar shells. Those stars were suspected by Winters
et al. (2000) to show preferentially low expansion velocity winds. Most of the data from this pro-
gram have been published in Winters et al. (2003). Subsequently, RX Lep's CO (2-1) emission
at 230 GHz and SiO (v=1, J=2-1) maser transition at 86 GHz have been searched using the 15-m
Swedish-ESO Submillimetre Telescope, SEST (Booth et al. 1989) on January 30, 2003. At 1.3 mm,
the FWHM of the SEST beam is 23′′. We used the position-switch mode with a beam throw of
11.5′. The spectra were recorded on the high-resolution spectrometer (HRS) giving a resolution of
80 kHz, for a channel separation of 43 kHz and a bandwidth of 86 MHz.
The CO (2-1) transition was clearly detected (Fig. 1). The resulting profile was fitted with
a parabolic curve, and we derived an LSR velocity of Vlsr = 28.9 ± 0.1 km s−1, an expansion
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
5
Fig. 1. CO (2-1) emission of RX Lep. The solid line represents a parabolic fit (Sect. 3).
velocity of Vexp = 4.2 ± 0.1 km s−1, and an amplitude of Tmb = 0.45 K ± 0.13 K. By using the
same method as Winters et al. (2003, Sect. 4.3), we estimated both RX Lep mass-loss rate and CO
photo-dissociation radius using the results of the line fitting. We find M ∼ 1.7 × 10 −7 M⊙ yr−1 and
rCO ∼ 0.8 × 10−2 pc (≡ 12.5′′). On the other hand, the SiO maser was not detected at a level of
0.2 Jy.
Our CO measurement of the LSR radial velocity (28.9 km s−1) is consistent with the heliocen-
tric velocity quoted in the GCRV. Combining this result with the Hipparcos determination of the
velocity in the plane of the sky (44 km s−1), we get a 3-D space velocity of 53 km s−1.
4. H i observations
RX Lep has been observed during a total of 141 hours between February 2005 and February 2008
with the Nanc¸ay Radiotelescope (NRT). The NRT is a meridian telescope with a rectangular aper-
ture of effective dimensions 160×30 m. At 21 cm and at the declination of RX Lep, the FWHM
of the beam is 4′ in RA and 22′ in declination. We used the position-switch technique with two
off-positions in the east-west direction, every 2′, and up to 24′ from the source. Thus, the total
time spent on-source was 47 hours. To fully describe the environment of RX Lep, we sampled
our map every half beam in RA and in Dec. (hereafter, the position-switch spectra will be referred
to as C ± n × 4′ EW, n being the number of beams for the off positions). At 21 cm, the spectra
have a bandwidth of 165 km s−1 and a channel width of 0.08 km s−1. For convenient analysis, we
smoothed the data with a Hanning filter so that the spectral resolution was 0.16 km s−1. The data
are processed with the CLASS software, part of the GILDAS1 package developed at IRAM (Pety
2005).
The different steps of the data processing can be described as follows. First of all, we determine
the spatial extent of the source by comparing the C ± n × 4′ EW spectra. When the maximum inten-
sity of the peak is reached (n = nmax), the source does not contribute to the flux of the offset spectra
anymore. For example, according to Fig. 2 (upper panel), RX Lep does not extend farther than 6′ in
the E-W direction. Once the maximum extent is estimated, the average of the C ± n × 4′ EW spec-
tra with n > nmax gives the central spectrum (Fig. 2, lower panel). Simple arithmetic then allows to
extract the spectra at the offset positions, using the central spectrum.
We present a new visualization of the H i spectra to better separate the genuine stellar H i from
the contamination due to interstellar hydrogen. The operation can be described as a stacking of the
1 http://www.iram.fr/IRAMFR/GILDAS
6
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
Fig. 2. Upper panel: Spectra obtained in position-switch mode with the NRT. The positions are
expressed in number of beams (4′). The maximum intensity is reached at C±1.5 × 4′ EW. For clar-
ity, the individual spectra have been displayed with vertical offsets of 0.4 Jy. Lower panel: average
spectrum computed with C ± n × 4′ EW, n > 1.5. Dotted line: baseline subtracted f-switch spectrum.
The horizontal line shows the width of the CO signal.
Fig. 3. Left panel: 3D velocity-position representation of the H i flux density; east is to the left. The
arrow points to the expected position of the source. Right panel: the same data set represented in
2D; west is to the right. The dashed circle surrounds the expected position of RX Lep.
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
7
Fig. 4. H i map of RX Lep. The steps are 2′ in RA and 11′ in Dec. The positions are indicated with
respect to the stellar position. The abscissae and ordinates are LSR radial velocities (km s−1) and
flux densities (Jy) as indicated on the lower left corner.
NRT spectra, processed as above, in the east-west direction, for a given declination (Fig. 3). In this
view, velocity is given as a function of right ascension, and intensity is represented using a colored
scale. This aims at visualizing, and thus separating, the H i emission coming from the source and
that from the Galaxy. Indeed, on the resulting image, the stellar H i should be nearly centered in
RA and close to the LSR velocity given by CO observations. While this process emphasizes the
difficulties coming from the contamination due to the Galactic hydrogen emission, it also allows
an evaluation of the possible problems when processing the data and a design of the best strategy
for extracting the intrinsic source emission.
According to Fig. 3, RX Lep is definitely a suitable candidate for H i observation, as it is clearly
separated from the interstellar emission spectrally and spatially, although the confusion increases
for velocities lower than 29 km s−1. Indeed, the image shows 2 potential sources of contamination:
one around 4′W from the source and at ∼ 20 km s−1, the other increasing (negatively) at 16′E and
around 24 km s−1. This information is crucial to safely extracting the intrinsic emission of RX Lep.
Thus, to build the map of the source, we fitted polynomial baselines (in some cases of degree up
to 3 when the confusion reaches its highest level) to a portion of the spectrum between 21 and
54 km s−1. The resulting map of RX Lep is shown in Fig. 4.
We independently confirmed these results by observing the source using the frequency-switch
mode (Fig. 2, lower panel). We spent 5 hours on source and detected it at the same velocity and
with the same flux density as shown on the map for the central position.
From our observations, we can readily derive some important properties of the CS. The map
of RX Lep in Fig. 4 reveals that the H i line profile, at the central position, shows a quasi-
8
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
Gaussian shape of central velocity 28.84±0.03 km s−1, FWHM 3.8±0.1 km s−1, and flux density
0.22±0.03 Jy. The shape of this line differs from that of the parabolic CO line. It clearly indicates a
slowing down of the wind within the outer parts of the CS (Le Bertre & G´erard 2004). Moreover,
assuming that the broadening of the H i emission line is dominated by the thermal Doppler effect,
the FWHM of the spectrum allows us to estimate an upper limit to the average temperature in the
shell (Libert et al. 2007, Eq. 1). It gives us Tmean < 312 K.
Evidence of a composite line profile such as that of Y CVn (Sect. 1) is difficult to see, given
the fairly low intensity of the signal and the narrow width of the expected pedestal (2 × Vexp).
Nevertheless, from the central spectrum, we can set an upper limit to the amplitude of a possible
pedestal. We estimate this limit at 20 mJy by assuming it has the same width as the CO profile
(Fig. 5).
The map of RX Lep (Fig. 4) shows that the H i brightness distribution of the envelope is offset
from the stellar position both in RA and Dec. There is a slight westward RA offset < 1′ (since the
flux density at 2′ west is larger than at 2′ east but smaller than at the center). There is a southward
Dec. offset close to 5.5′ (since the flux density at 11′ south is nearly equal to the central flux). It
is useful to give quantitative estimates, not only of the offsets but also of the spatial extents for
the model calculations that will be discussed in Sect. 5. If one assumes that the H i brightness
distribution is Gaussian in RA (and Dec.) and offset, the convolution by a Gaussian beam also
produces a Gaussian distribution and one can retrieve from the data both the offset and half power
width (HPW) in RA (and Dec.). The RA offset and HPW are respectively −0.4′ (± 0.2′) and
2.3′ (± 0.5′). The Dec. offset and HPW are respectively −4.4′ (± 0.6′) and 15′ (± 3′). Thus the
H i envelope is elongated southwards and offset from the stellar position by 4.4′ at PA 185◦ (i.e.
also nearly southward). This suggests an HI envelope trailing south.
The integrated flux throughout the map gives 1.22 Jy×km s−1, which translates into a hydrogen
mass of ∼ 5.42 × 10−3 M⊙ (assuming no hydrogen in H2; cf. Sect. 2). Adopting a mean molecular
weight of 1.3, it translates into a total mass of the gas in the shell of ∼ 7.05 × 10−3 M⊙. If we
consider the mass-loss rate to be constant and adopt the estimate given by CO, then the age of the
CS is ∼ 42700 years, about one order of magnitude less than the age we estimated for Y CVn.
Fig. 5. Average of the spectra C ± n × 4′ EW and 11′S ± n × 4′ EW with n > 1. The horizontal
line represents the width of the CO line.
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
9
5. Model
The high-quality H i spectral profiles that we have obtained in the direction of RX Lep are similar to
those of Y CVn (Libert et al. 2007). This type of profile is indicative of a slowing-down of stellar
outflows in the external parts of CSs (Le Bertre & G´erard 2004). In the following we apply the
model that we developed for the carbon-rich star Y CVn in order to evaluate the physical conditions
within the shell of RX Lep. Of course, as this model assumes sphericity, it cannot reproduce the
more complex geometry suggested by the map presented in the previous section. In the east-west
direction the map is fairly symmetric, so the model could apply. However, there is also a clear
north-south extension that would require a 2-D model, as well as a spatial resolution better than
22′ (the NRT beam).
A 1D-hydrodynamic code provides the density distribution within the detached shell based on
the hypothesis of a slowing down of the stellar gas by the surrounding local material. The mass-loss
rate is constant, and the gas expanding outward from the atmosphere is in free expansion with a
constant velocity Vexp. Then, the outflow encounters a shock (r1). Its velocity decreases by a factor
of about 4 and the matter keeps on decelerating until it reaches the external medium (at rf). The
external matter that has been swept up and compressed by the expansion of the stellar envelope lies
outside rf. Finally, beyond r2, the gas is at rest.
The expansion velocity and the LSR velocity of the source are based on the results from our
CO observations. But RX Lep has not been studied much, so we lack some spatial information
such as estimates of r1 and r2 that could have been obtained, for example, with dust continuum
observations. Nevertheless, the NRT map indicates that the object is fairly small in the east/west
direction (∼ 2.3′ i.e. ∼ 9 × 10−2 pc at 137 pc).
One of the results of our model is that detached shells are flagged by a composite H i spectrum.
The first component (Comp. 1) is narrow, with a quasi-Gaussian shape and it arises from the matter
slowed down by the local medium. The second component (Comp. 2) is broad with a rectangular
shape, as it probes the inner part of the shell where the gas is in free expansion. In Sect. 4, we set an
upper limit of Comp. 2 of ∼ 20 mJy. For a constant mass-loss rate, we can derive a relation (Eq. 1)
to estimate r1:
r1 ≈ 2.17 × 10−9 ×
d V2
exp FComp. 2
M
(1)
where r1 is expressed in arcmin, d is the distance in pc, Vexp is in km s−1, FComp.2 is the intensity
of the pedestal in Jy, and M is in M⊙ yr−1. With Vexp = 4.2 km s−1 and M = 1.65 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1
(Sect. 3), we estimate an upper limit for r1 of 0.64′. We set r2 at 1.15′, in agreement with the
H i observations in the east-west direction (HPW/2, Sect. 4).
As our model assumes spherical symmetry, we performed a fitting on a symmetrized map, i.e.
a map in which the offset positions have been averaged (Fig. 6, upper panel). In the model, the total
flux is forced to be equal to that measured in the map (i.e. 1.22 Jy × km s−1). We set the central
velocity at 28.8 km s−1. The results are summarized in Table 1. In this simulation, the temperature
and the velocity are constant inside r1 (resp. 20 K and 4.2 km s−1). The shock at r1 decreases the
velocity (increases the density) by a factor of 3.9 and the temperature rises to 530 K (Figs. 7 &
8). Then, inside the region of compressed matter (between r1 and rf), the temperature decreases to
∼ 175 K. The physical conditions between rf and r2 are in fact not constrained either by our model
10
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
Fig. 6. H i observations vs model (dashed line): the upper panel shows the model discussed in
Sect. 5 and compared to a symmetrized H i map of RX Lep. The lower panel presents the same
model shifted by 4.4′S and 0.4′W and compared to the H i map of RX Lep (as in Fig. 4).
or by the data at 21 cm, and in Table 1 they are only extrapolated (for more details, see Libert et al.
2007).
The model assumes that the H i emission is optically thin (τ ≪ 1). This can be verified using the
output column density profile (Fig. 8, right panel) and the expression τ = 5.50 × 10−19 NH
T ∆V (Eq. 12,
Libert et al., 2007) where NH is in cm−2 and ∆V, the line width, in km s−1. With T > 175 K and ∆V
∼ 3.8 km s−1, the optical depth stays below 0.5 at all impact parameters > 0.1′ from the central star.
In general, the model provides a satisfactory fit to the symmetrized H i spectra that we have
obtained on RX Lep. However, it predicts a flux above the observations on the central position and
below at 22′ in declination. This can be understood as a consequence of the 4.4′ offset to the south
noted in Sect. 4. By moving the model 4.4′ south and 0.4′ west with respect to the central star,
we can improve the fit to the observed data (Fig. 6, lower panel). This gives support to the offset
values that we have determined by Gaussian-fitting in Sect. 4. Yet, the spectrum on the position at
22′ south is not well reproduced, suggesting that the source is more extended along the north-south
direction than along the east-west one, as suspected in Sect. 4.
In the past (Y CVn, Libert et al. 2007), we already attempted to better fit the data by a shift in
position to take into account the deformation of the envelope by the ISM. However, this approach is
Table 1. Model parameters (d = 137 pc), with notations the same as in Libert et al. (2007)
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
11
M (in hydrogen)
1 ), T+
1
µ
t1
tDS
r1
r f
r2
T0(≡ T−
T f (= T2)
v0(≡ v−
v f
v2
n−
1 , n+
1
n−
f , n+
f
n2
Mr<r1 (in hydrogen)
MDT,CS (in hydrogen)
MDT,EX (in hydrogen)
1 ), v+
1
1.27 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1
1.3
5 927 years
36 800 years
2.55 × 10−2 pc (0.64 ′)
3.67 × 10−2 pc (0.92 ′)
4.58 × 10−2 pc (1.15 ′)
20 K, 528 K
175 K
4.2 km s−1, 1.07 km s−1
0.16 km s−1
1.2 km s−1
148 H cm−3, 578 H cm−3
2.1 × 103 H cm−3, 2.5 H cm−3
1.3 H cm−3
0.75 10−3 M⊙
4.67 10−3 M⊙
0.010 10−3 M⊙
Fig. 7. Upper panel: velocity profile. The dashed line represents the isothermal sound velocity.
Lower panel: temperature profile adopted for the model.
artificial because we used a spherical model that is not centered on the star position. It is only meant
to illustrate the need for an H i mapping of this interesting source with a better spatial resolution
and the need to develop a true non-spherical modeling of detached shells.
12
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
Fig. 8. Left panel: atomic hydrogen density profile. Center panel: atomic hydrogen mass-flow pro-
file. Right panel: atomic hydrogen column density calculated by the model. The vertical dotted
lines show the radii, r1, rf and r2, used in the model.
6. Discussion
RX Lep shows evidence of a circumstellar envelope of ∼ 0.01 M⊙ that may be the result of its
stellar wind decelerated by the external medium. This star is an oxygen-rich, semi-regular variable
on the E-AGB (no evidence of Tc, cf. Sect. 2). It is in the same evolutionary stage as EP Aqr
and X Her, which have also been detected in H i and for which the emission at 21 cm shows
evidence of significant circumstellar envelopes (Le Bertre & G´erard 2004; Gardan et al. 2006). We
note that these 3 stars share the same variability properties and have about the same luminosity
(∼ 4500 L⊙) and the same effective temperature (∼ 3200 K). It suggests that mass loss can already
occur efficiently for this type of star on the E-AGB.
Our model strongly relies on the mass-loss rate estimated from CO observations. It is note-
worthy that this estimate is consistent with Reimers' relation (Reimers 1978). Indeed, by adopting
M ∼ 3 M⊙, L ∼ 4500 L⊙ and Teff ∼ 3300 K (Sect. 2), this relation gives M ∼ 2 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1.
However, the luminosity was probably lower in the past, as was the mass-loss rate. This suggests
that the age (42 700 years) is underestimated.
The model and our observations together put constraints on the physical conditions within the
CS between the termination shock (r1) and the interface (rf). Directly from the observations, the
mean temperature should be . 300 K. Based on the assumption of an adiabatic shock at r1, it implies
an increase in temperature to ∼ 500 K. Thus, the gas must be cooled down in the CS. Estimating the
cooling rate is difficult at such low temperatures. Nevertheless, the H i line-profiles put constraints
on the behavior of the temperature because it is coupled to the kinematics (Libert et al. 2007). The
temperature profile shown in Fig. 7 (lower panel) yields the best fit to the shape of the H i spectra.
Between rf and r2, our model has only been extrapolated. This region is probably dominated by
interstellar material flowing at ∼ 50 km s−1 through the bow shock. The material should be denser
than assumed in our model; indeed, this region is fed by the interstellar medium that has been swept
up through the relative motion of RX Lep circumstellar shell, at ∼ 50 km s−1, rather than by the
expansion of the shell during the same period of 4 104 years. Also it is expected to be ionized, and
therefore might not contribute significantly to the H i emission that we detected.
The H i data indicate that RX Lep's CS is offset about 4′ to the south and 0.5′ to the west. This
agrees within 25◦ with the direction of the proper motion given by Hipparcos (PA ∼ 31◦). In addi-
tion, the model hints that the shell is not completely spherical, and that RX Lep is slightly elongated
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
13
Fig. 9. Reprocessed IRAS images (IRIS) at 60 µm (upper panels) and 100 µm (lower panels). To
enhance the suspected extended emission to the south, we present a non-saturated version (left) and
a saturated one (right) for both wavelengths. The field is ∼ 65′ × 39′ and the green reticles mark
the position of RX Lep (north is to the top and east to the left).
mostly in the N/S direction. This suggests that the elongated shape observed in H i is connected to
the motion of RX Lep through the local ISM. Villaver et al (2003) have made numerical simula-
tions of the evolution of a low-mass star moving supersonically through the ISM and find that, due
to the ram-pressure stripping, most of the mass ejected during the AGB phase is left downstream.
The left panel in their Fig. 1 shows that CSs are progressively distorted and become elongated in
the direction of the motion with respect to their surrounding ISM. The 25◦ difference between the
space motion of the star and the elongation of the shell could then be due to the intrinsic velocity
of the ISM local to RX Lep relative to the LSR. Such intrinsic motions are currently found in the
local solar neighborhood (Redfield & Linsky, 2008, Fig. 16 and references therein). A significant
fraction of the velocity of the local ISM is a reflection of the solar motion; nevertheless, the velocity
of the Sun with respect to the LSR (13.4 km s−1, according to Dehnen & Binney, 1998) is 25◦ away
from the direction of the velocity of the average local ISM with respect to the Sun (26.7 km s−1).
It is also worth noting that for RX Lep there is no significant difference between the H i and CO
central velocities, as if the interaction only occurs in the plane of the sky.
We have examined the IRAS maps that have been reprocessed recently by Miville-Deschenes &
Lagache (2005; IRIS: Improved Reprocessing of the IRAS Survey). The 60 µm and 100 µm images
(Fig. 9) suggest a small extended source (φ ∼ 6′ - 8′). The source at 100 µm might be shifted by
∼ 2′ to the south. There is also an extension (∼ 12′) to the south; however, it might be an artifact
due to the satellite scanning in the north-south direction. In these images, we cannot confirm the
X0509-119 offset with respect to RX Lep (cf Sect. 2). New data with a better spatial resolution,
e.g. from the Far Infrared All-Sky Survey of Akari, may help to clarify this situation.
In their H i survey of evolved stars, G´erard & Le Bertre (2006) found that the line-profiles
are Gaussian-shaped and often offset with respect to the stellar velocity by ∼ 1-3 km s−1 towards
0 km s−1 LSR. Several H i sources were also noted to be spatially offset from the central star.
They suggest that these effects could be related to a non-isotropic interaction with the local ISM.
Matthews & Reid (2007) have imaged the H i emission around RS Cnc with the VLA. They find
that it is elongated with a peak on the stellar position and a filament extending ∼ 6′ to the northwest,
14
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
in a direction opposite to that given by the proper motion. Recently, Matthews et al. (2008) have
imaged the H i emission of Mira with the VLA. As for RS Cnc, they find a "head-tail" morphology
oriented along the star proper motion and consistent, on large scales, with the far-ultraviolet emis-
sion discovered by GALEX (Martin et al. 2007). Furthermore, the high spectral resolution H i data
obtained with the NRT along the 2-degree GALEX trail reveal a deceleration of the gas caused
by interaction with the local ISM. Finally, using Spitzer MIPS data obtained on R Hya at 70 µm,
Ueta et al. (2006) discovered a bow-shock structure ahead of the star in the direction of its motion.
The excess emission that delineates this bow shock is seen at 70 µm, but not at 160 µm; it may
partly come from the [O i] cooling line at 63 µm. Although we have presently no direct evidence in
H i of a bow-shock, both structures, bow-shock and H i trail, should be causally related (Wareing
et al. 2006). In fact, as the velocity of these sources with respect to the ISM is often high (see e.g.
Nyman et al. 1992, or Mennessier et al. 2001), the interstellar material is probably ionized through
the bow shock, so that we may never detect directly such a bow-shock structure in H i at 21 cm.
Better tracers would likely be line emission in the UV/optical/IR ranges (Hα, [Fe ii], [O i], etc.).
We therefore have a convergent set of results that shows that AGB stars are associated with
large-scale circumstellar shells distorted by the motion of these evolved objects through the ISM
(Villaver et al. 2003). We suggest that RX Lep is one more source in such a case. That the source is
elongated in the same direction as its offset and nearly opposite to the direction of motion, argues
in favor of a head-tail morphology.
7. Conclusions
We detected CO(2-1) and H i line emissions from the semi-regular oxygen-rich E-AGB star,
RX Lep. These emissions indicate a stellar outflow at a velocity ∼ 4.2 km s−1 and a rate
∼ 1.7 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1, with a duration of 4 × 104 years. The H i source has a size of ∼ 2′ (≈ 0.08 pc)
in the east-west direction and possibly 15′ (≈ 0.6 pc) in the north-south direction.
The modeling of the H i line profiles obtained at different positions suggests that the outflow
is slowed down by the interaction with the ambient ISM, and that the external part of RX Lep
circumstellar shell is made of compressed material, at ∼ 200 K, as in the well-known detached
shell around Y CVn.
The elongated shape of the RX Lep H i source is compatible with the direction of its proper
motion, as in the cases of Mira and RS Cnc, which have already been studied at high angular
resolution with the VLA.
Acknowledgements. The Nanc¸ay Radio Observatory is the Unit´e scientifique de Nanc¸ay of the Observatoire de Paris,
associated as Unit´e de Service et de Recherche (USR) No. B704 to the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
(CNRS). The Nanc¸ay Observatory also gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the Conseil R´egional de la R´egion
Centre in France. This research made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at the CDS, Strasbourg, France, and of the
NASA's Astrophysics Data System. We thank the referee, Dr T. Ueta, and Dr L. Matthews for helpful suggestions.
References
Booth, R.S., Delgado, G., Hagstrom, M., et al., 1989, A&A, 216, 315
Cristian, V.-C., Donahue, R. A., Soon, W. H., Baliunas, S. L., & Henry, G. W., 1995, PASP, 107, 411
Dehnen, W., & Binney, J.J., 1998, MNRAS, 298, 387
Dumm, T., & Schild, H., 1998, New Astron., 3, 137
Libert et al.: H i & CO in RX Lep.
15
Epchtein, N., Le Bertre, T., L´epine, J.R.D., et al., 1987, A&AS, 71, 39
Fouqu´e, P., Le Bertre, T., Epchtein, N., Guglielmo, F., & Kerschbaum, F., 1992, A&AS, 93, 151
Gardan, E., G´erard, E., & Le Bertre, T., 2006, MNRAS, 365, 245
G´erard, E., & Le Bertre, T., 2006, AJ, 132, 2566
Glassgold, A. E., & Huggins, P. J., 1983, MNRAS, 203, 517
Habing, H., 1996, A&AR, 7, 97
Hrivnak, B.J., & Bieging, J.H., 2005, ApJ, 624, 331
Hrivnak, B.J., Kwok, S., & Su, K.Y.L., 2001, AJ, 121, 2775
IRAS Science Team, 1988, IRAS Catalogs and Atlases, NASA RP-1190, vol. 7
Izumiura, H., Hashimoto, O., Kawara, K., Yamamura, I., & Waters, L. B. F. M., 1996, A&A, 315, L221
Kerschbaum, F., & Olofsson, H., 1999, A&AS, 138, 299
Knapp, G. R., & Morris, M., 1985, ApJ, 292, 640
Kukarkin, B. V., Kholopov, P. N., Pskovsky, Y. P., et al., 1971, General Catalogue of Variable Stars, 3rd ed.
Lafon, J.-P.J., & Berruyer, N., 1991, A&AR, 2, 249
Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., & Cassinelli, J.P., 1999, "Introduction to Stellar Winds", Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Leao, I.C., de Laverny, P., M´ekarnia, D., De Medeiros, J.R., & Vandame, B., 2006, A&A, 455, 187
Le Bertre, T., & G´erard, E., 2004, A&A, 419, 549
Le Bertre, T., Matsuura, M., Winters, J. M., et al., 2001, A&A, 376, 997
Lebzelter, Th., & Hron, J., 1999, A&A, 351, 533
Libert, Y., G´erard, E., & Le Bertre, T., 2007, MNRAS, 380, 1161
Little, S. J., Little-Marenin, I. R., & Bauer, W. H., 1987, AJ, 94, 981
Mamon, G.A., Glassgold, A.E., & Huggins, P.J., 1988, ApJ, 328, 797
Martin, D.C., Seibert, M., Neill, J.D., et al., 2007, Nature, 448, 780
Matthews, L.D., Libert, Y., G´erard, E., Le Bertre, T., & Reid, M.J., 2008, ApJ, 684, 603
Matthews, L.D., & Reid, M.J., 2007, AJ, 133, 2291
Mauron, N., & Huggins, P. J., 2000, A&A, 359, 707
Mennessier, M. O., Mowlavi, N., Alvarez, R., & Luri, X., 2001, A&A, 374, 968
Miville-Deschenes, M.-A., & Lagache, G., 2005, ApJS, 157, 302
Nyman, L.-Å., Booth, R. S., Carlstrom, U., et al., 1992, A&AS, 93, 121
Olofsson, H., 1999, Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars, IAU Symposium ♯191, ed. T. Le Bertre, A. L`ebre, & C. Waelkens, p. 3
Olofsson, H., Bergman, P., Lucas, R., et al., 2000, A&A, 353, 583
Olofsson, H., Gonz´alez Delgado, D., Kerschbaum, F., & Schoier, F.L., 2002, A&A, 391, 1053
Paschenko, M., Slysh, V., Strukov, I., et al., 1971, A&A, 11, 482
Pety, J., 2005, in SF2A-2005: Semaine de l'Astrophysique Franc¸aise, ed. F. Casoli, T. Contini, J. M. Hameury, & L. Pagani,
721
Ramstedt, S., Schoıer, F.L., Olofsson, H., & Lundgren, A.A., 2008, A&A, 487, 645
Redfield, S., & Linsky, J.L., 2008, ApJ, 673, 283
Reimers, D., 1978, A&A, 67, 161
Renzini, A., 1981, in Physical processes in Red giants, Iben Jr., I. & Renzini, A. (Eds.), D. Reidel, p.431
Samus, N. N., Durlevich, O. V., et al., 2004, Combined General Catalog of Variable Stars (ed. 4.2; Moscow: Sternberg
Astron. Inst.)
Schroder, K.-P., Winters, J.M., & Sedlmayr, E., 1999, A&A, 349, 898
Simis, Y.J.W., Icke, V., & Dominik, C., 2001, A&A 371, 205
Soker, N., 2002, ApJ, 570, 369
Ueta, T., Speck, A. K., Stencel, R. E., et al., 2006, ApJ, 648, L39
Villaver, E., Garc´ıa-Segura, G., & Manchado, A., 2003, ApJ, 585, L49
Wareing, C.J., Zijlstra, A.A., & O'Brien, T.J., 2007, MNRAS, 382, 1233
Wareing, C.J., Zijlstra, A.A., Speck, A.K., et al., 2006, MNRAS, 372, L63
Wilson, R. E., 1953, General Catalogue of Stellar Radial Velocities, Carnegie Inst. Washington D. C. Publ. 601
Winters, J. M., Le Bertre, T., Jeong, K. S., Helling, Ch., & Sedlmayr, E., 2000, A&A, 361, 641
Winters, J. M., Le Bertre, T., Jeong, K. S., Nyman, L.-Å., & Epchtein, N., 2003, A&A, 409, 715
Young, K., Phillips, T. G., & Knapp, G. R., 1993, ApJ, 409, 725
|
astro-ph/0701430 | 2 | 0701 | 2007-02-23T08:34:06 | "Late prompt" emission in Gamma Ray Bursts? | [
"astro-ph"
] | The flat decay phase in the first 1e2-1e4 seconds of the X-ray light curve of Gamma Ray Bursts (GRBs) has not yet found a convincing explanation. The fact that the optical and X-ray lightcurves are often different, with breaks at different times, makes contrived any explanation based on the same origin for both the X-ray and optical fluxes. We here assume that the central engine can be active for a long time, producing shells of decreasing bulk Lorentz factors Gamma. We also assume that the internal dissipation of these late shells produces a continuous and smooth emission (power-law in time), usually dominant in X-rays and sometimes in the optical. When Gamma of the late shells is larger than 1/theta_j, where theta_j is the jet opening angle, we see only a portion of the emitting surface. Eventually, Gamma becomes smaller than 1/theta_j, and the entire emitting surface is visible. Thus there is a break in the light curve when Gamma=1/theta_j, which we associate to the time at which the plateau ends. After the steeply decaying phase which follows the early prompt, we see the sum of two emission components: the "late-prompt" emission (due to late internal dissipation), and the "real afterglow" emission (due to external shocks). A variety of different optical and X-ray light curves are then possible, explaining why the X-ray and the optical light curves often do not track each other (but sometimes do), and often they do not have simultaneous breaks. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Draft version July 4, 2019
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj
7
0
0
2
b
e
F
3
2
2
v
0
3
4
1
0
7
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
"LATE PROMPT" EMISSION IN GAMMA RAY BURSTS?
G. Ghisellini, G. Ghirlanda, L. Nava1, C. Firmani2
INAF -- Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, via Bianchi 46, I -- 23807 Merate, Italy
Draft version July 4, 2019
ABSTRACT
The flat decay phase in the first 102 -- 104 seconds of the X -- ray light curve of Gamma Ray Bursts
(GRBs) has not yet found a convincing explanation. The fact that the optical and X -- ray lightcurves are
often different, with breaks at different times, makes contrived any explanation based on the same origin
for both the X -- ray and optical fluxes. We here assume that the central engine can be active for a long
time, producing shells of decreasing bulk Lorentz factors Γ. We also assume that the internal dissipation
of these late shells produces a continuous and smooth emission (power -- law in time), usually dominant
in X -- rays and sometimes in the optical. When Γ of the late shells is larger than 1/θj, where θj is the
jet opening angle, we see only a portion of the emitting surface. Eventually, Γ becomes smaller than
1/θj, and the entire emitting surface is visible. Thus there is a break in the light curve when Γ = 1/θj,
which we associate to the time at which the plateau ends. After the steeply decaying phase which follows
the early prompt, we see the sum of two emission components: the "late -- prompt" emission (due to late
internal dissipation), and the "real afterglow" emission (due to external shocks). A variety of different
optical and X -- ray light curves are then possible, explaining why the X -- ray and the optical light curves
often do not track each other (but sometimes do), and often they do not have simultaneous breaks.
Subject headings: gamma rays: bursts -- X-rays: general -- radiation mechanisms: general
1.
INTRODUCTION
One of the puzzling results of the Swift satellite (Gehrels
et al., 2004) is the discovery that the [0.3 -- 10 keV] X -- ray
light curve of Gamma Ray Bursts (GRBs) is much more
complex than thought in the pre -- Swift era. After a steep
decline of the flux [F (t) ∝ t−α1 , with α1 ∼ 3 -- 5; Taglia-
ferri et al. 2005], which is most commonly interpreted as
off axis radiation of a switching -- off fireball (see e.g. Ku-
mar & Panaitescu 2000), the flux decay becomes shallow
[F (t) ∝ t−α2, with α2 ∼ 0.2 -- 0.8], up to a break time of
103 -- 104 s (Willingale et al. 2007, hereafter W07), after
which the flux decays "normally" [F (t) ∝ t−α3 with α3 ∼
in a similar way as ob-
1 -- 1.5; Nousek et al. 2005], i.e.
served in the pre -- Swift era.
In addition, several bursts
show flares superposed to this power law evolution (Bur-
rows et al. 2005), leading Fan & Wei (2005) and Lazzati
& Perna (2006) to suggest a long lasting central engine.
Unpredicted beforehand, the complex structure of the X --
ray light curve, characterized by a steep -- flat -- steep behav-
ior, has been interpreted in several ways (for reviews, see
e.g. Panaitescu 2007; Granot 2007; Zhang 2007) none of
which seems conclusive. The three main possibilities al-
ready proposed (but there are more, see the review by
Zhang 2007), are: i) energization of the forward shock by
the arrival of shells being produced late (with large Γs),
or just after the prompt phase (with small Γs); ii) chang-
ing microphysical parameters, assuming that the efficiency
of the forward shock to produce radiation increases with
time: iii) off -- axis jets, whose prompt and early afterglow
radiation is not fully beamed towards the observer. Note
that the spectral slope does not change across the tem-
poral break from the shallow decay phase to the normal
decay phase, ruling out the crossing of a spectral break
across the band. This favors instead an hydrodynamical
or geometrical nature of the break. All these ideas do not
obviously distinguish between X -- ray and optical radiation,
which should have the same origin. As a consequence, the
light curves in both bands should be similar, contrary to
what observed in several cases (see e.g. Panaitescu et al.
2006; Panaitescu 2007).
These difficulties recently led Uhm & Beloborodov
(2007) and Grenet, Daigne & Mochkovitch (2007) to con-
sider the possibility that the X -- ray plateau emission is not
due to the forward, but to the reverse shock running into
ejecta of relatively small Lorentz factors. This however
requires an appropriate Γ -- distribution of the ejecta, and
also the suppression of the X -- ray flux produced by the
forward shock.
Here we make the alternative proposal that the plateau
phase of the X -- ray emission (and sometimes even of the
optical) is due to a "late -- prompt" mechanism: after the
early prompt (the prompt which we are used to) there may
be a tail of activity of the central engine, producing for a
long time (i.e. days) shells of progressively lower power
and bulk Lorentz factor. The dissipation process during
this and the early phases can occur at similar radii. The to-
tal energetics involved in this late activity phase is smaller
than (and at most comparable to) the energetics of the
early phase, but diluted on a much longer time. The rea-
son for the shallow decay phase, and for the break ending
it, is that the Γ -- factor is decreasing, allowing to see an
increasing portion of the emitting surface, until all of it is
visible.
2. LATE PROMPT EMISSION?
1Univ. dell'Insubria, V. Valleggio, 11, I -- 22100, Como, Italy
2Instituto de Astronom´ıa, U.N.A.M., A.P. 70-264, 04510, M´exico, D.F., M´exico
1
2
Assume that the central engine, after having emitted
most of the power in the usual duration of what we call
"prompt" emission, continues to create shells of much
smaller power, but for a much longer time. For simplic-
ity, let us call "early prompt" and "late prompt" the two
phases of activity. By contrast, we call "real afterglow"
the emission produced in the forward shock created by
the interaction of the shells with the circumburst medium.
The early prompt emission is due to internal dissipa-
tion of shells of large Γ -- factors (changing erratically) and
energy, due to e.g.
internal shocks (Rees & Meszaros,
1994) or interactions with the funnel of the progenitor star
(Thompson 2006; Thompson Meszaros & Rees 2006), or
some form of magnetic reconnection (e.g. Spruit, Daigne
& Drenkhahn 2001).
We suggest that the late prompt emission can be due
to the same dissipation processes, but by shells created at
late times with smaller Γ and much lower power. The ra-
diation can then be produced at distances relatively close
to the central engine (even less than 1013 -- 1014 cm), in a
different region where the shells, produced during the early
prompt, interacts with the circumburst medium produc-
ing the real afterglow. Note that a smaller Γ implies less
Doppler time contraction, and therefore a less pronounced
variability during the late prompt. Furthermore, if Γ is
decreasing with time, a new effect appears. In fact, when
Γ > 1/θj, the emission surface seen by the observer is of
the order of (R/Γ)2 (here R is the distance from the black
hole where dissipation takes place, and θj is the jet open-
ing angle), and becomes (θjR)2 when Γ ≤ 1/θj.
In the
same way as in the afterglow case, we should then see a
steepening of the light curve when the central engine pro-
duces shells with Γ ∼ 1/θj. This should occur at the time
ta, in a similar way as the jet break time tj for the after-
glow. According to this scenario, there is a link between ta
and tj: both are times at which Γ = 1/θj, but they refer
to two different processes.
The plateau phase of the X -- ray emission is characterized
by a power law decay L(t) ∝ t−α2, followed by a steeper
decay L(t) ∝ t−α3 . The end of the plateau phase occurs
at ta, and the transition is smooth. If j ′ is the bolometric
emissivity in the comoving frame, we have
Γ(cid:19)2
L(t < ta) ∼ π(cid:18) R
L(t ≥ ta) ∼ π (θjR)2 ∆R′Γ2j ′(t) ∝ t−α3 , Γ ≤ 1/θj(1)
∆R′Γ2j ′(t) ∝ t−α2 , Γ > 1/θj
Assuming that j ′(t) is with constant slope before and after
ta, we have t−α3 ∝ Γ2t−α2. Therefore we find Γ ∝ t−∆α/2,
with ∆α ≡ α3 − α2. This behavior should be appropri-
ate after the time t∗ characterizing the start of the late
prompt phase of emission. Finally we have:
Γ = Γ∗(cid:18) t
t∗(cid:19)−∆α/2
(2)
Since hα2i = 0.6 ± 0.3 and hα3i = 1.25 ± 0.25 (Panaitescu
2006), ∆α/2 is of the order of 0.33 ± 0.2. This means
that the bulk Lorentz factor, at the beginning of the late
3We use the notation Qx = 10xQ, in cgs units.
prompt phase (t∗), is of the order of3
Γ∗ = θ−1
j (cid:18) ta
t∗(cid:19)∆α/2
∼
46
θj,−1 (cid:18) ta,4
t∗.2(cid:19)1/3
(3)
which is smaller than what is usually assumed for the
early prompt emission. The barion loading of the late
shells can be estimated assuming a given efficiency η for
the dissipation process leading to the radiation produced
in the plateau phase. After ta, when we see the entire
emitting surface, the jet kinetic power per unit solid angle
Lkin = Γ M c2 ∼ 2LX/(θ2
j η) and then
M =
2L(t > ta)
j Γc2 ∝ t−(α2+α3)/2
ηθ2
(4)
M ∝ t−1, with a large dis-
which approximately gives
persion (the dependence is the same also for the plateau
phase). The total mass in the late ejecta is relatively small,
again at most comparable with what can be estimated for
the ejecta of the early prompt. This is because, although
the Γ -- factors are smaller, the total energetics of the late
prompt shells is smaller than the one of the early prompt.
This agrees with the findings of W07 that the total radi-
ated energy of the late shells (which is called X -- ray af-
terglow in that paper) is on average a factor ∼10 smaller
than the early prompt. Therefore, if η of the early and
late shells is similar, we do not expect a big effect from
the possible refreshed shocks. We also expect that the
late shells reach the front forward shock at very different
times. This is due both because the late shells are pro-
duced at later and later times, and also because the later
the shell is produced, the smaller its bulk Lorentz factor,
and the longer the time needed to reach the shock front
which is decelerating by the interaction with the circum-
burst medium. The refreshing effect is long lasting, but
diluted. For the same reasons, we expect that the reverse
shock is also long lasting, but diluted, and therefore not
contributing much to the total flux. To see this, assume for
illustration a circumburst density with a wind -- like profile.
Calling ti the time (after the trigger) at which a late shell
is created, and td the deceleration time, we have that at
the observed time t the front shock and the i-th late shell
are at the distances Rs and Ri, respectively, given by:
Rs = ctΓ2 = ctΓ2
0(cid:18) t
td(cid:19)−1/2
= cΓ2
0(ttd)1/2
(5)
Ri = c(t − ti)Γ2
i
(6)
where Γ0 is the initial Lorentz factor of the early shells.
Late shells are assumed not to decelerate until they catch
up the front shock. Equating the two above radii we have
that the ith shell reaches the front shock at the time tc:
tc ∼
Γ4
0
Γ4
i
td;
if
tc ≫ ti
(7)
For td = 100 s, tc ranges from 1600 s (Γ0/Γi = 2) to
tc = 106 (Γ0/Γi = 10). Since the decrease of the bulk
Lorentz factor is associated with a decrease of the kinetic
power, we have some effects only for the first refreshed
shocks, at times of the order of thousands of seconds, but
not later.
2.1. The real afterglow
In the pre -- Swift era, it was generally believed that the
real afterglow should contain at least a comparable amount
of energy (in the emitted radiation) of the prompt, that
it should start a few tens -- hundreds of seconds after the
trigger, and that the energy band containing most of the
emission is the X -- ray band (since its energy spectrum
F (ν) ∝ ν−1 indicates that the peak in νF (ν) is within
or close the X -- ray band).
The prediction of the start time of the afterglow seems
well confirmed in two cases: GRB 060418 and GRB
060607, as shown in Molinari et al.
(2007), thanks to
ground based near IR observation by the REM telescope.
Quite remarkably, the X -- ray light curve in these two cases
does not track the near IR, confirming that, although the
afterglow theory can correctly explain what seen in the
optical, we need another component to explain the X -- ray
i) the real afterglow X -- ray
flux. We also conclude that:
component is much weaker than thought before:
ii) the
X -- ray band is likely not the band where most of the af-
terglow energy is, and iii) the total energetics of the real
afterglow is much smaller than thought before.
A weak afterglow can result if the microphysical param-
eters ǫe, ǫB, at least for the first afterglow phases, are
much smaller than commonly thought. Alternatively, the
fireball can have a small kinetic energy, as a result of a
very efficient prompt phase, that was able to convert a
large fraction of the fireball energy into radiation. Further-
more, the radiation produced by the real afterglow should
be mostly in the IR -- optical, not in the X -- ray band.
There is a spectral transition between the varying and
generally hard slope of the hard X -- ray emission and a more
stable and generally softer slope of the later X -- ray emis-
sion. In W07, the distributions of the spectral index βx of
the prompt and the plateau phase are broad, but a slight
narrowing around a value βx ∼ 1 for the plateau is visible.
We propose that this is not due to the prompt/afterglow
transition, but it is instead associated to the transition
between the early prompt phase, characterized by large
Γ -- factors changing erratically, and the late prompt phase
characterized by smaller Γ decreasing monotonically.
Note also that the pre -- Swift observations of the X -- ray
"afterglow" should be re -- interpreted: in many cases, what
observed even days after the trigger time should be late
prompt, not real afterglow, emission.
2.2. Flares
The flares occurring mainly in X -- ray (Burrows et al.
2007) but sometimes also in the optical light curve have
been associated to internal dissipation (internal shocks)
either by late shells, or by shells produced within the first
early prompt phase, but moving with a small Lorentz fac-
tor. In our framework, the most likely possibility is that a
flare is produced by a late shell, moving with a somewhat
larger Lorentz factor than the shells created just earlier.
Thus there will be a chain of interactions between this
(faster -- than -- average) shell and the slower previous ones,
and this mechanism can be efficient in converting the ki-
netic energy of the shell into radiation. Due to the differ-
ent time Doppler contraction, late flares should also last
longer than early ones. Alternatively, the flares could flag
periods of enhanced activity of the central engine, able for
3
some time (i.e. tens or hundreds of seconds) to produce
shells (or a continuous flow) of higher energy.
3. DISCUSSION
The scenario here proposed allows to explain some GRB
properties which are puzzling and mysterious.
In general, the X -- ray flux can receive contributions from
the steep part of the early prompt phase, the late prompt
emission, and from the decelerating early shells which are
producing the real afterglow emission. The late prompt
emission,
in the optical -- UV bands, may be reduced if
the main radiation process is multiple Comptonization of
UV/soft X -- ray seed photons, or by self -- absorption if it
is synchrotron radiation. The real afterglow emission, in-
stead, should produce synchrotron (and self -- Compton) ra-
diation both in the X -- ray and in the optical bands. Fo-
cusing to the plateau and later phases, we may have a
complex behavior:
1. the X -- ray flux is dominated by late prompt emission,
while the optical is dominated by the real afterglow.
In this case the light curves in the two bands are
independent, and show no simultaneous break.
In
particular, the jet break time is possibly seen in the
optical, but not in the X -- rays.
2. Both the X -- ray and the optical fluxes are domi-
nated by late prompt emission. In this case the two
light curves are similar, they may have simultane-
ous breaks (at the time ta) and the jet break time
(due to real afterglow emission) can be masked. The
dominance of the late prompt emission may however
end after some time, beyond which the real afterglow
can become visible.
3. Both the X -- ray and the optical fluxes are dominated
by real afterglow emission. This is the case foreseen
before Swift. The light -- curves should have an achro-
matic jet -- break, should track one another, and they
should not show the break at ta.
The first case is sketched in Fig. 1. While the other two
cases can also occur, the case of a late prompt emission
dominating in the optical but not in the X -- rays seems
contrived.
In terms of total energetics, the scenario proposed here
may be the least demanding for explaining what observed.
In fact, in the refreshed shock scenario, the plateau phase
is flat because the shock running into the circumburst
medium is energized by the arrival of shells with kinetic en-
ergies which largely overtake the energy of the first shells,
which have contributed to the early prompt emission. Al-
ternatively, in the increasing ǫe, ǫB scenario, the radia-
tion produced during the plateau phase is a very tiny frac-
tion of the carried kinetic energy. Instead, interpreting the
plateau phase as late prompt emission, we need that the
extra energy created by the central engine in the late phase
is less than (or at most comparable to) the total energetics
of the shells responsible for the early prompt emission. If
the radiative efficiency of the early prompt is large, we can
also explain the weakness of the real afterglow emission,
since the kinetic energy of the fireball, remaining after the
early prompt phase, may be relatively small.
4
Our scenario is not based on a detailed model on how
the central engine works. The following ideas should then
be considered as speculations to be studied in future work.
After the black hole formation following the core collapse
of the progenitor star, the equatorial core material which
failed to form the black hole in the first place can form
a very dense accreting torus, which can sustain a strong
magnetic field, which in turn extracts the rotational energy
of the black hole. This accretion phase could correspond
to the early prompt phase of the burst. After this phase,
some fall -- back material may also be accreted. This phase
of "late accretion" can last for a longer time, with a density
of the accreting matter smaller than in the early phases.
If so, the magnetic field that this matter can sustain is
weaker than before, with a corresponding smaller power
extracted from the black hole spin. This may well corre-
spond to production of shells of smaller Γ -- factors. These
shells can dissipate part of their energy with the same
mechanism of the early ones. Occasionally, the central en-
gine produces a faster than average shell, originating the
late flares often observed in the Swift/XRT light curves.
Our suggestion may be not the unique solution of the
puzzle concerning the unpredicted behavior of the X -- ray
and the optical light curves. Indeed, Uhm & Beloborodov
(2007) and Grenet, Daigne & Mochkovitch (2007) recently
proposed that the X -- ray flux may be dominated by the re-
verse shock emission in slow shells. These and our propos-
als share the common view that the X -- ray flux can be due
to a component different from what produces the optical.
The difference is that in our model the late prompt and
real afterglow emissions are completely decoupled, while
in the reverse shock scenario the two emission processes
are linked. Furthermore, in the reverse shock scenario,
one has to assume a somewhat ad hoc time profile of the
Γ -- factor to explain the flat -- steep X -- ray transition, (Uhm
and Beloborodov 2007), which is not a simple (unbroken)
power law as in our case.
Finally, there are some features that our model can pre-
dict. Observationally, we should have the three cases men-
tioned above: both the optical and the X -- rays are late
prompt emission; both are real afterglow emission; X -- rays
and optical are "decoupled", with the X -- ray due to late
prompt and the optical due to real afterglow emission, re-
spectively. One obvious way to check these possibilities
is through the construction of the simultaneous spectral
energy distribution (SED), which can confirm or not if the
X -- ray and the IR -- optical fluxes belong to the same com-
ponent. The unknown extinction due to the host galaxy
material may complicate this test, but having enough pho-
tometric data, especially in the infrared, may result in a
good determination of the extinction, and thus a good esti-
mate of the extrapolation of the IR -- optical spectrum into
the X -- ray range. The SED so obtained may clearly show
that the IR -- optical and X -- ray emission belong (or not) to
two different components.
Another test concerns the total kinetic energy of the
fireball after its radiative phase, using the radio data, as
done e.g.
for GRB 970508 by Frail, Waxman & Kulka-
rni (2000). Should the derived energetics be smaller than
what required by the refreshed shock scenario, one could
exclude this possibility, and instead favor our scenario.
In cases in which the late prompt emission ends, the
underlying real afterglow emission can be revealed. In the
light curve, this should appear as a steep -- flat transition at
late times (not to be confused with the usual steep -- flat --
steep X -- ray decay). This can also be confirmed by the
corresponding SEDs.
We thank the anonymous referee for helpful comments,
F. Tavecchio for discussion and a 2005 PRIN -- INAF grant
for funding.
REFERENCES
Burrows, D.N., Romano, P., Falcone, A., et al., 2005, Science, 309,
Burrows, D.N., Falcone, A., Chincarini, G., et al., 2007, preprint
(astro -- ph/0701046)
Campana, S., Mangano, V., Blustin, A.J., et al., Nature, 2006, 442,
1833
1008
Fan, Y.Z. & Wei, D.M., 2005, MNRAS, 364, L42
Frail, D.A., Waxman, E. & Kulkarni, S.R., 2000, ApJ, 537, 191
Gehrels, N., Chincarini, G., Giommi, P., et al., 2004, ApJ, 611, 1005
Granot, J., 2007, Il Nuovo Cimento, in press (astro -- ph/0612516)
Grenet, F., Daigne, F. & Mochkovitch, R., 2007, subm. to MNRAS
(astro -- ph/0701204)
Kumar, P. & Panaitescu, A., 2000, ApJ, 647, 1213
Lazzati, D. & Perna, R., 2007, MNRAS, 375, L46
Liang, E. & Zhang, B., 2005, ApJ, 633, L611
Molinari, E., Vergani, S., Malesani, D., et al., 2007, subm to Science
(astro -- ph/0612607)
Nousek, J.A., Kouveliotou, C., Grupe, D., et al., 2005, ApJ, 642, 389
Panaitescu, A., Meszaros, P., Burrows, D., Nousek, N., O'Brien, P.
& Willingale R., 2006, MNRAS, 369, 2059
Panaitescu, A., 2007, Il Nuovo Cimento, in press (astro -- ph/0607396)
Rees, M.J. & Meszaros, P., 1994, ApJ, 430, L93
Spruit, H.C., Daigne, F. & Drenkhahn, G., 2001, A&A, 369, 694
Tagliaferri, G., Goad, M., Chincarini, G., et al., 2005, Nature, 436,
985
Thompson, C., 2006, ApJ, 651, 333
Thompson, C., Meszaros, P. & Rees, M.J., 2007, subm to ApJ,
(astro -- ph/0608282)
Uhm, L.Z. & Beloborodov, A.M.,
2007,
subm to ApJ,
(astr -- ph/0701205)
Willingale, R., O'Brien, P.T., Osborne, J.P., et al., 2007, subm to
ApJ (W07) (astro -- ph/0612031)
Zhang, B.,
(astro -- ph/0611774)
2007, Advances
in Space Research,
in press
5
Fig. 1. -- Schematic illustration of the different components contributing to the X -- ray and optical light curves, as labelled.
Scales are arbitrary. The case illustrated here is only one (likely the most common) possible case (see text), when the
X -- ray flux is dominated by late prompt emission (solid line, the dotted line corresponds to an extrapolation at very late
times), while the optical flux is dominated by the real afterglow (dashed). ΓLP and ΓF S indicate the Γ of the late shells
and the forward shocks, respectively.
|
astro-ph/0507456 | 2 | 0507 | 2005-08-04T21:46:48 | The Type Ia Supernova Rate | [
"astro-ph"
] | We explore the idea that the Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) rate consists of two components: a prompt piece that is proportional to the star formation rate (SFR) and an extended piece that is proportional to the total stellar mass. We fit the parameters of this model to the local observations of Mannucci and collaborators and then study its impact on three important problems. On cosmic scales, the model reproduces the observed SNe Ia rate density below z=1, and predicts that it will track the measured SFR density at higher redshift, reaching a value of 1-3.5 X 10^-4 per yr per Mpc^3 at z=2. In galaxy clusters, a large prompt contribution helps explain the iron content of the intracluster medium. Within the Galaxy, the model reproduces the observed stellar [O/Fe] abundance ratios if we allow a short (approximately 0.7 Gyr) delay in the prompt component. Ongoing medium-redshift SN surveys will yield more accurate parameters for our model | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 6/22/04
THE TYPE IA SUPERNOVA RATE
Evan Scannapieco & Lars Bildsten
Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics, Kohn Hall, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106;
[email protected], [email protected]
ABSTRACT
We explore the idea that the Type Ia supernovae (SN Ia) rate consists of two components: a prompt
piece that is proportional to the star formation rate (SFR) and an extended piece that is proportional
to the total stellar mass. We fit the parameters of this model to the local observations by Mannucci
and collaborators and then study its impact on three important problems. On cosmic scales, the
model reproduces the observed SN Ia rate density below z = 1, and predicts that it will track the
measured SFR density at higher redshift, reaching a value of 1-3.5 × 10−4 yr−1 Mpc−3 at z = 2. In
galaxy clusters, a large prompt contribution helps explain the Fe content of the intracluster medium.
Within the Galaxy, the model reproduces the observed stellar [O/Fe] abundance ratios if we allow a
short (≈ 0.7 Gyr) delay in the prompt component. Ongoing medium-redshift SN surveys will yield
more accurate parameters for our model.
Subject headings: supernovae: general -- galaxies:evolution -- galaxies: clusters: general -- stars: abun-
dances
1. INTRODUCTION
2004).
Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) play a pivotal role in as-
trophysics. On cosmological scales they serve as unparal-
leled distance indicators, providing direct evidence that
the low-redshift universe is accelerating (Riess et al. 1998;
Perlmutter et al. 1999). On galactic scales, they act as
the primary source of iron, producing ≈ 0.7 M⊙ per event
(Tsujimoto et al. 1995), roughly an order of magnitude
more than in core-collapse SNe (Hamuy 2005). On stellar
scales, they represent an excellent example of explosive
nuclear burning, resulting in radioactively-powered light
curves (e.g., Nomoto et al. 1984; Woosley 1990).
Nevertheless, many mysteries remain. While the peak
magnitude and the decay time of SN Ia light curves are
tightly correlated (Pskovskii 1977; Phillips 1993; Hamuy
et al. 1995), the origin of this relation is poorly under-
stood (see discussion in Pinto & Eastman 2000; Mazzali
et al 2001). Similarly, while there is a consensus that
SNe Ia originate from thermonuclear ignition and burn-
ing of a C/O white dwarf in a binary system, it is un-
certain whether they are triggered by accretion from a
hydrogen-rich companion or from a merger with another
white dwarf (see Branch et al. 1995). This uncertainty
in the progenitor makes it difficult to predict the Ia rate
in galaxies of varying masses, ages, and star formation
rates.
Consequently, a wide range of models of this rate have
been developed (e.g., Matteucci & Recchi 2001; Greggio
2005). These are commonly parameterized by a delay
function, whose convolution with the star formation rate
(SFR) yields the SN Ia rate. In principle, this is a com-
pletely general approach, as the SN Ia rate must depend
on the mass and age of the underlying stars.
In prac-
tice, most of this generality is lost to the assumption of
a single "delay time" (e.g., Madau et al. 1998; Dahl´en
& Fransson 1999; Gal-Yam & Maoz 2004; Strolger et al.
2004). These fits are used to draw conclusions about SN
Ia progenitors, the most recent example of which is the
claim that there must be a 2-4 Gyr delay in all SNe Ia
relative to the burst of star formation (Strolger et al.
However, this approach neglects the possibility that
multiple evolutionary paths lead to SNe Ia.
Indeed,
there is direct observational evidence that this is the case.
The brightest events (such as 1991T) only occur in ac-
tively star-forming galaxies, while substantially under-
luminous events (such as 1991bg) are most prevalent in
E/S0 galaxies (Hamuy et al. 1996; Howell 2001; van den
Bergh et al. 2005). This is an important clue that SNe
Ia have at least two evolutionary channels with different
characteristic times: one "prompt," basically tracking
the current SFR, and another so delayed that it simply
scales with the stellar mass (much as is seen in accreting
binaries with low-mass companions, such as Cataclysmic
Variables [Townsley and Bildsten 2005] or low-mass X-
ray binaries in E/S0s [Gilfanov 2004]). We show here,
that in addition to explaining the SN Ia rates seen in
nearby galaxies as described by Mannucci et al. (2005,
hereafter M05), such a simple two-component model also
resolves a wide range of outstanding issues.
We begin in §2 by presenting the model, fitting the con-
stants to observations of SNe Ia in nearby galaxies, and
stating a few of the immediate repercussions. In §3 we
study the implications of this model in three important
contexts: the iron content of galaxy clusters, the evolu-
tion of the average cosmic SN Ia rate density, and the
[O/Fe] abundance ratios of Galactic stars. In §4 we con-
trast this approach with other models, and we conclude
in §5.
2. THE TWO-COMPONENT MODEL
Following M05, we assume that there are two avenues
for SNe Ia. Specifically, we adopt a model in which the
SN Ia rate is the sum of two components: a term propor-
tional to the total stellar mass, M⋆(t) (regardless of its
age) and a term proportional to the instantaneous SFR,
M⋆(t),
SN RIa(t)
(100 yr)−1 = A(cid:20) M⋆(t)
1010M⊙(cid:21) + B"
M⋆(t)
1010M⊙ Gyr−1# , (1)
2
where A and B are dimensionless constants that we fix
with observations (see also M05, eq. [2]). The first of
these terms is dominant in old stellar populations (and
contains underluminous 1991bg-like SNe), while the sec-
ond term is most important in starbursts (and contains
the brightest 1991T-like SNe). To measure A, we use
the recent observations from M05, who utilized detailed
K-band data to update the analysis presented by Cappel-
laro et al. (1999). As there were 21 Type Ia SNe observed
in E/S0 galaxies in this sample, and no instances of core-
collapse supernovae, we consider the SFR term to be neg-
ligible in this population. This gives A = 4.4+1.6
−1.4 × 10−2.
M05 showed that the SN Ia rate was 0.35 ± 0.08
of the core collapse rate in young stellar populations.
Since they arise from massive, short-lived stars, the core-
collapse SN rate should directly trace the SFR, and
thus can be used to determine B. Presently, the pri-
mary uncertainty in this measurement comes from re-
lating the core-collapse rate to the SFR. We take two
approaches to determining B, fully aware that ongoing
SN surveys will soon reduce these uncertainties. First
we use the z ≤ 1.0 core-collapse SN rate density as mea-
sured by Dahl´en et al. (2004), comparing it against the
SFR density as measured by Giavalisco et al. (2004), and
considering only the statistical error bars. This gives
SN Rcc/ M⋆ = (7.5 ± 2.5) × 10−3 M⊙
−1 and corresponds
to a B value for SNe Ia of 2.6 ± 1.1, which we adopt
throughout this Letter.
An alternative approach is to use the blue (B − K ≤
2.6) population observed by M05, in which the measured
SN Ia rate is 0.86+0.45
−0.35 per 100 yr per 1010 M⊙ of stars.
The colors of these starbursting galaxies are consistent
with a 0.7 Gyr population (M05), as computed from
the population synthesis models of Bruzual & Charlot
(2003). Within the errors, this gives B = 1.2+0.7
−0.6, con-
sistent with our first estimate.
Our values of A and B directly yield the relative contri-
butions of these two components. For example, 10 Gyrs
after a starburst, only 20% of all SNe Ia will have come
from the extended piece. Hence, in our model, most
of the SNe Ia over any galaxy's lifetime come from the
prompt contribution as originally suggested by Oemler
& Tinsley (1979).
Our model also allows for a comparison between SN
types, as illustrated in Figure 1.
In our model, by
construction, the rate of core-collapse SNe is approxi-
mately 3 times the SN Ia rate in starbursting galaxies,
while only SNe Ia are found in galaxies without star
formation. For a galaxy with a total stellar mass of
1010 M⊙ the transition between these two regimes oc-
M⋆ ≈ 0.1 M⊙ yr−1, which corresponds to a Scalo
curs at
parameter b ≡ M⋆(t)/D M⋆(t)E = M⋆(t)t/M⋆(t) ≈ 0.08
or an age of 7 Gyrs if we assume a star formation rate
∝ e−t/2Gyr as in M05.
Finally, since 0.74 M⊙ of Fe is expelled in a typical SN
Ia (Tsujimoto et al. 1995) while 0.062 M⊙ is expelled in
a typical core-collapse SN (Hamuy 2003), in any given
starburst the overall SN Ia contribution to Fe produc-
tion as compared with core-collapse SNe in our model is
approximately 3 to 1.
3.
IMPLICATIONS AND PREDICTIONS
Fig. 1. -- The supernova rate in a galaxy with a final stellar
mass of 1010M⊙. The solid line gives our model predictions for the
Type-Ia SN rate (bracketed by 1 sigma errors), which is made up of
the prompt (dotted) and extended (dot-dashed) components. The
dashed line gives the core-collapse SN rate. In all cases we assume a
star formation rate ∝ e−t/2Gyr. Choosing a different characteristic
star-formation decay time would rescale the time axis, while leaving
the Scalo b values unchanged.
We now apply this simple model to three important
issues. In this section and below we adopt a Hubble con-
stant of 70 km s−1 Mpc−1 and total matter and vacuum
energy densities of Ωm = 0.3 and ΩΛ = 0.7 in units of
the critical density (e.g., Spergel et al. 2003). First we
consider the intracluster medium (ICM) in galaxy clus-
ters, which is measured to have an Fe content ≈ 0.3Z⊙
(Baumgartner et al. 2003). Although clusters are dom-
inated by elliptical galaxies, models that combine the
observed SN Ia rate in ellipticals with the total cluster
stellar mass result in Fe estimates that are roughly an
order of magnitude too small (e.g., Renzini et al. 1993;
Renzini 2004). While Maoz & Gal-Yam (2004) were able
to provide a single-component resolution to this prob-
lem, they were not able to reconcile this fit with SN Ia
measurements in field galaxies. In fact, even ICM models
that appeal to Fe production by pair-instability SNe from
very massive primordial stars (e.g., Lowenstein 2001) fall
far short of the observed metallicity (Scannapieco et al.
2003).
Our two-component model, however, addresses this is-
sue from a different perspective. The dominant source of
Fe is not the late-time SN Ia contribution, as observed
in ellipticals, but rather the prompt contribution, which
took place at high redshifts. In the upper panel of Figure
2, we plot the ICM metallicity as a function of redshift,
assuming a star formation redshift of 3, and an ICM to
stellar mass ratio of MICM/M⋆ = 10 ± 3, as appropri-
ate for 7 keV clusters (Lin et al. 2003). Again, we take
the core-collapse SN rate to directly trace the SFR. This
results in [Fe/H] values broadly consistent with obser-
vations and an order of magnitude higher than previous
estimates (Renzini 2004). Our model also naturally pre-
dicts the recently observed lack of [Fe/H] evolution with
redshift (Tozzi et al. 2003), a feature that does not ap-
3
Fig. 2. -- Top:
[Fe/H] of the intracluster medium in kT ≥ 5
keV galaxy clusters as a function of redshift. The solid line shows
the results of our two-component model, with the one-sigma errors
defining the shaded region. The low redshift point (open triangle)
is an average from the Baumgartner et al. (2003) sample, while the
higher redshift points (solid circles) are from Tozzi et al. (2003).
Bottom: Type Ia SNR density as a function of redshift (solid) which
is the sum of the prompt (dotted) and extended (dot-dashed) com-
ponents. Again the solid line corresponds to our two-component
model, with the one-sigma errors given by the shaded region. The
lower redshift measurements (open triangles) are taken (in order
of increasing redshift) from Cappellaro et al. (1999), Hardin et al.
(2000), Blanc et al. (2004), Reiss (2000), Pain et al. (1996), Tonry
et al. (2003), and Pain et al. (2002). The higher redshift measure-
ments (solid circles) are from Dahl´en et al. (2004).
Fig. 3. -- Top: Evolution of the Fe content in a closed-box system
as a function of the age of the stellar population, assuming an SFR
∝ e−t/2Gyr. Here the (thin) upper solid line corresponds to our
fiducial two-component model (bracketed by the 1-sigma errors),
while the dashed line gives the iron provided by core-collapse SNe.
Finally, the (thick) lower sold line is the result of our delayed two-
component model. Bottom: Variation of the [O/Fe] abundance
ratio as a function of metallicity, in a simple closed box model. The
(thin) lower line gives the results of our fiducial model, while the
upper (thick) line corresponds to the two-component model with
a 0.7 Gyr delay in the prompt component. The data points are
taken from observations of Galactic disk and halo stars compiled
in McWilliam (1997), following the symbol convention used in his
Figure 3.
pear in models dominated by late-time SNe Ia.
Next we turn to the cosmic SN Ia rate density, or
the number of Type Ia SNe per year per comoving
Mpc3. We adopt a cosmic star formation rate density
of log10[SFR/( M⊙ yr−1 Mpc−3)] = −2.2 + 3.9 log10(1 +
z) − 3.0[log10(1 + z)]2, which is a simple fit to the most
recent measurements (Giavalisco et al. 2004; Bouwens et
al. 2004). The resulting SN Ia rate density is compared
with observations in the lower panel of Figure 2, provid-
ing an excellent match, except for the highest-redshift
point from Dahl´en et al. (2004). This is because at z ≈ 1
our model is dominated by the prompt piece, and no cor-
responding dip is seen in the SFR density at this redshift.
Furthermore, requiring agreement with this point is the
source of the 2 − 4 Gyr delay-time derived by Strolger et
al. (2004). Thus a strong prediction of our model is that
future observations will revise the z ≈ 1.5 measurement
upward. In fact, more detailed analyses of the SN Ia rate
density at z > 1 represent the single best way to falsify
(or confirm) our approach.
Finally we turn to the measured abundance ratios
of Galactic stars, which probe the relationship between
Type Ia and core-collapse SNe at short times. In particu-
lar we compare iron with oxygen, an alpha-element that
is synthesized primarily in core-collapse SNe. We take
0.14 M⊙ of oxygen per SN Ia (Tsujimoto et al. 1995),
1.2 M⊙ oxygen per core-collapse SN (a Salpeter inital
mass function average computed in Scannapieco et al.
2003), and a closed-box model. Following M05 we adopt
M⋆ = Mgas exp[−t/2Gyr]/2Gyr,
a star formation rate
which results in the [Fe/H] and [O/Fe] values shown in
Figure 3.
As the overall Ia Fe contribution as compared with
core-collapse SNe in our model is nearly 3 to 1, [O/Fe]
should drop by a factor of 3, as observed. The value
of [Fe/H] where this drop occurs, however, depends on
the star formation model, and requires a short delay in
the prompt component. Assuming that both the core-
collapse and the prompt Type Ia contributions exactly
trace the SFR would fix the [O/Fe] values to a constant,
in conflict with measurements of metal-poor halo stars.
On the other hand, delaying the prompt component by
0.7 Gyr allows core-collapse SNe to briefly dominate the
initial gas enrichment, but has no impact on the SN Ia
distribution on the timescales probed by other measure-
ments. The timescale of this delay is proportional to the
assumed SFR decay time, and a model with an SFR de-
cay time of 1.0 Gyr and a prompt SN Ia delay of 0.35 Gyr
would give equivalent [O/Fe] values. In any case, this de-
lay is so short on cosmic times that we will continue to
refer to this component as "prompt."
4. COMPARISON WITH OTHER WORK
4
We now compare our approach with other single-
In particular we consider three pos-
component fits.
sible SN Ia delay functions: an exponential model in
which Φ(∆t) = C exp(−∆t/τ )/τ (Tutukov & Yun-
gelson 1994; Madau et al. 1998; Gal-Yam & Maoz
2004), and two Gaussian models in which Φ(∆t) =
C(2πσ2)−1/2 exp[(∆t − τ )2/(2σ2)] and σ is either "nar-
row" (σ = 0.2τ ) or "wide" (σ = 0.5τ ) (Dahl´en & Frans-
son 1999; Strolger et al. 2004). Each of these functions
has two free parameters: a delay time τ and a normal-
ization C; which we fit to the number of SNe Ia in the
youngest (B − K < 2.6) and most evolved (B − K > 4.1)
galaxies measured by M05. As in that study, we model
both galaxy types with M⋆ ∝ exp(−t/2Gyr) with an
age of 0.75 ± 0.25 Gyrs in the B − K < 2.6 population
and 10.5 ± 1.5 Gyrs in the B − K > 4.1 population, as
is consistent with their observed colors and core-collapse
SNe rates. Note that these SFRs are averages over entire
populations, rather than histories of individual galaxies.
Within the one-σ errors, we find τ values of 0.5 − 1.6,
0.6 − 1.0, and 0.5 − 1.3 Gyr, for the exponential, narrow
Gaussian, and wide Gaussian models, respectively.
Applying these fits to the full range of galaxy popula-
tions measured by M05 indicates that the proper number
of SNe Ia in old galaxies and starbursting galaxies is ob-
tained only at the expense of a large number of SNe Ia
in galaxies of intermediate age. For example in a t = 5
Gyr population, all three models predict ≥ 2 SNe Ia per
100 yr per 1010 M⊙, while the measured value is 0.19+0.08
−0.07
(M05). Furthermore the ratio of Type Ia to core-collapse
SNe at 5 Gyr is ≥ 4, while the measured ratios are ≤ 1/3.
On the other hand, our two-component model, shown as
the solid line in Figure 1, falls within the range of ob-
served values at all ages.
5. CONCLUSIONS
Our two-component model is motivated by the ob-
served dichotomy between the environments of the
brightest (1991T-like) and the faintest (1991bg-like) SNe
Ia. Yet in some sense it is simply an application of the
delay function formalism, in which the SN Ia rate is de-
scribed as a convolution of an unknown function with
the overall star formation history. Other models were
limited by the assumption of a single "delay time" and
had difficulties in reconciling the Fe content in clusters
with the ratio of core-collapse to Type Ia SNe as a func-
tion of galaxy age (e.g., Maoz & Gal-Yam 2004). Our
model solves this problem because it is dominated by
a prompt component, but allows significant numbers of
SNe Ia to occur at late times. In addition, it produces
the observed cosmic SN Ia rate to z ≤ 1, while also fitting
observations of E/S0s. The strongest test of this model
is the measurement of the SN Ia rate at z > 1, which we
predict to be in the range 1 − 3.5 × 10−4 yr−1 Mpc−3 at
z = 2.
M⋆/D M⋆E & 0.1. An example
Of course, star formation does occur in some ellipti-
cal galaxies, and as shown in Figure 1, our simple model
predicts that prompt SNe Ia will be the dominant com-
ponent in such objects if
of such a case is the slow-declining Type Ia SN 1998es,
which occurred in the early-type galaxy NGC632. While
this galaxy is fairly red (B-K > 3), spectral observations
uncover significant star formation (Gallagher et al. 2005).
Conversely, underluminous SNe Ia should occasionally
be found in star forming galaxies, such as the rapidly-
declining SN 1999by. While the host galaxy of this SN
Ia is an Sb galaxy, imaging shows that it took place in
the old population of halo stars (Gallagher et al. 2005).
SNe Ia play a pivotal role in astrophysics, and thus our
two-component model has many implications. It allows
for an updated assessment of Clayton & Silk's (1969) hy-
pothesis that the γ-rays from radioactive decays explain
the extragalactic MeV background (see Watanabe et al.
1999; Ruiz-Lapuente et al. 2001; Ahn et al. 2005).
It
highlights the usefulness of measurements that constrain
Type Ia evolution at short time scales, such as studies of
the distribution of SNe Ia relative to spiral arms (Maza
& van den Bergh 1976; Bartunov et al. 1994; McMil-
lan & Ciardullo 1996; Petrosian et al. 2005) and the Fe
content of high-redshift quasars (Barth et al. 2003; Di-
etrich et al. 2003).
It stresses the importance of early
SNe Ia in ICM enrichment and exposes the limitations
of one-component fits.
More generally, our model implies that over a Hubble
time, ≈ 80% of the SNe Ia from any galaxy will occur
within a Gyr of the initial starburst. The remaining 20%
occur in a delayed fashion, clearly extending to times
>
∼ 10 Gyrs. This alludes to multiple progenitor scenar-
ios: one that occurs "promptly," within a Gyr, and an-
other that can occur a Hubble time after star formation.
Perhaps this is not surprising given the openly-debated
range of possibilities (e.g., Branch et al. 1995; Greggio
2005) and the evidence for dominance (or absence) of
some extreme SNe Ia in certain galaxy types. Deeper
physical insights into how the age or metallicity of the
accreting white dwarf might naturally cause this large
range of diversity awaits theoretical work.
We thank Avishay Gal-Yam and the anonymous ref-
eree for comments. This work was supported by the NSF
under grants PHY99-07949 and AST02-05956.
REFERENCES
Ahn, K., Komatsu, E. & Hoflich, P. 2005, PRD,
in press
Branch, D., Livio, M., Yungelson, L. R., Boffi, F. R., & Baron, E.
(astro-ph/0506126)
Barth, A. J., Martini, P., Nelson, C. H., & Ho, L. C 2003, ApJ,
593, L95
Bartunov, O. S., Tsvetkov, D. Yu., Filimonova, I. V. 1994, PASP,
106, 1276
Baumgartner, W. H., Loewenstein, M., Honer, D. J., & Mushotzky,
R. F. 2005, ApJ, 620, 680
Blanc, G. et al. 2004, A&A, 423, 881
Bouwens, R. et al. 2004, ApJ, 616, L79
1995, PASP, 107, 1019
Bruzual, G. & Charlot. S. 2003, MNRAS, 344, 1000
Cappellaro, E., Evans, R., & Turatto, M. 1999, A&A, 351, 459
Clayton, D. D. & Silk, J. 1969, ApJ, 158, L43
Dahl´en, T., & Fransson C. 1999, A&A, 351, 459
Dahl´en, T. et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 189
Dietrich, M., Hamann, F., Appenzeller, I., & Vestergaard, M. 2003,
ApJ, 596, 817
Gal-Yam, A., & Maoz, D. 2004, MNRAS, 347, 942
Gallagher, J. S., Garnavich, P. M., Berlind, P., Challis, P., Jha, S.,
& Kirshner, R. P. 2005, ApJ, in press
Giavalisco, M. 2004, ApJ, 600, L103
Gilfanov, M. 2004, MNRAS, 349, 146
Greggio, L 2005, A&A submitted, (astro-ph/0504376)
Hamuy, M., Phillips, M. M., Maza, J., Suntzeff, N. B., Schommerr,
R. A., & Aviles, R. 1995, AJ, 109, 1
Hamuy, M., Phillips, M. M., Suntzeff, N. B., Schommerr, R. A.
Maza, J., & Aviles, R. 1996, AJ, 112, 23910
Hamuy, M. 2005 in Core Collapse of Massive Stars, ed. C. L. Fryer
(Kluwer: Dordrecht), in press (astro-ph/0301006)
Hardin, D., et al. 2000, A&A, 362, 419
Howell, D. A. 2001, ApJ, 554, L193
Lin, Y.-T., Mohr, J. J., & Stanford, S. A. 2003, ApJ, 591, 749
Lowenstein, M. 2001, ApJ, 557, 573
Mannucci, F. et al. 2005, A& A, 433, 807 (M05)
Madau, P., della Valle, M., & Nino, P. 1998, MNRAS, 297, L17
Maoz, D. & Gal-Yam, A. 2004, MNRAS, 347, 951
Matteucci, F., & Recchi, S. 2001, ApJ, 558, 351
Maza, J., & van den Bergh, S. 1976, ApJ, 204, 519
Mazzali, P. A., Nomoto, K., Cappellaro, E., Nakamura, T., Umeda,
H., & Iwamoto, K. 2001, ApJ, 547, 988
McMillan, R. J., & Ciardullo, R. 1996 ApJ, 473, 707
McWilliam, A 1997, 35, 503
Nomoto, K., Thielemann, F.-K., Yokoi, K. 1984, ApJ, 286, 664
Oemler, A. & Tinsley, B. M. 1979, AJ, 84, 985
Pain, R., et al. 1996, ApJ, 473, 356
Pain, R, et al. 2002, ApJ, 577, 120
Perlmutter, S. et al. 1999, ApJ, 517, 565
Petrosian, A. et al. 2005, 129, 1369
Phillips, M. M. 1993, ApJ, 413, L105
5
Pinto, P. A., & Eastman, R.G. 2000, ApJ, 530, 744
Pskovskii, Y. P. 1977, Soviet Astron., 21, 675
Reiss, D. J. 2000, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Washington
Renzini, A, Ciotti, L., D'Ercole, A., & Pellegrini, S. 1993, ApJ,
419, 52
Renzini, A. 2004, in in Carnegie Obs. Astrophys. Ser., 3, Clusters
of Galaxies: Probes of Cosmological Structure and Galaxy
Evolution, ed. J. S. Mulcaey, A. Dressler, & A. Oemler
(Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press)
Riess, A. G. et al. 1998, AJ, 116, 1009
Ruiz-Lapuente, P., Casse, M. & Vangioni-Flam, E. 2001, ApJ, 549,
483
Scannapieco, E., Schneider, R., & Ferrara, A. 2003, ApJ, 589, 35
Spergel, D. N. et al. 2003, ApJS, 14, 175
Strolger, L.-G. et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 200
Tonry, J. L., et al. 2003, ApJ, 594, 1
Townsley, D. M., & Bildsten, L. 2005, ApJ, 628, 395
Tozzi, P., Rosati, P., Ettori, S., Borgaini, S., Mainieri, V., &
Norman, C. 2003, ApJ, 593. 705
Tsujimoto, T., Nomoto, K., Yoshii, Y., Hashimoto, M., Yanagida,
S., & Thielemann, F.-K. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 945
Tutukov, A. V. & Yungelson, L. R. 2004, MNRAS, 268, 871
van den Bergh, S., Li, W., & Filippenko, A. V. 2005, PASP, in
press (astro-ph/0504668)
Watanabe, K., Hartmann, D. H., Leising, M. D., & The, L.-S.,
1999, ApJ, 516, 285
Woosley, S. E. 1990, in Supernovae, ed. A. G. Petscheck (New York:
Springer-Verlag), 182
|
astro-ph/0211643 | 1 | 0211 | 2002-11-29T07:58:39 | The CYDER Survey: First Results | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present the Calan-Yale Deep Extragalactic Research (CYDER) Survey. The broad goals of the survey are the study of stellar populations, the star formation history of the universe and the formation and evolution of galaxies. The fields studied include Chandra deep pointings in order to characterize the X-ray faint populations. Here we present the results on the first fields studied. We find that the redshift distribution is consistent with that found in the Chandra Deep Field North. The distribution of hardness ratios is, however, softer in our sample. We find a high redshift quasar, CXOCY J125304.0-090737 at z=4.179, which suggests that the abundance of low luminosity high redshift quasars may be larger than what would be expected from reasonable extrapolations from the quasar optical luminosity function. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astron. Nachr./AN 32X (200X) X, XXX -- XXX
The CYDER Survey: First Results
2
0
0
2
v
o
N
9
2
1
v
3
4
6
1
1
2
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
FRANCISCO J. CASTANDER1
COPPI3, THOMAS J. MACCARONE4 , STEPHEN E. ZEPF5, RAFAEL GUZM ´AN6, MAR´IA
TERESA RUIZ2
3 , EZEQUIEL TREISTER2
3 , JOS ´E MAZA2, PAOLO S.
,
2
,
,
1 Institut d'Estudis Espacials de Catalunya/CSIC, Gran Capit`a 2-4, 0834 Barcelona, Spain
2 Departamento de Astronom´ıa, Universidad de Chile, Casilla 36-D, Santiago, Chile
3 Astronomy Department, Yale University, P.O. Box 208101, New Haven, CT06520, USA
4 SISSA, via Beirut 2-4, 34014 Trieste, Italy
5 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA
6 Department of Astronomy, University of Florida, P.O. Box 112055, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA
Received date will be inserted by the editor; accepted date will be inserted by the editor
Abstract. We present the Cal´an-Yale Deep Extragalactic Research (CYDER) Survey. The broad goals of the survey are the
study of stellar populations, the star formation history of the universe and the formation and evolution of galaxies. The fields
studied include Chandra deep pointings in order to characterize the X-ray faint populations. Here we present the results on the
first fields studied. We find that the redshift distribution is consistent with that found in the Chandra Deep Field North. The
distribution of hardness ratios is, however, softer in our sample. We find a high redshift quasar, CXOCY J125304.0-090737
at z = 4.179, which suggests that the abundance of low luminosity high redshift quasars may be larger than what would be
expected from reasonable extrapolations from the quasar optical luminosity function.
Key words: surveys -- quasars: general -- galaxies: active -- X-rays -- galaxies: evolution
1. Introduction: the CYDER Survey
The Cal´an-Yale Deep Extragalactic Research (CYDER) Sur-
vey is a collaborative effort between the Universidad de Chile
and Yale University to study in detail faint stellar and ex-
tragalactic populations in survey mode. The broad scientific
goals are directed towards the core observing goals of the
new generation of large optical and millimeter facilities. The
program takes full advantage of these facilities by combining
deep optical and near-IR photometric and spectroscopic ob-
servations on wide field cameras and spectrographs using a
wide variety of 4-m and 8-m class telescopes.
The CYDER survey original design goal was to cover 1
square degree down to limiting magnitudes U ∼ 26, B ∼
26.5, V ∼ 26, R ∼ 25.5, I ∼ 25, z ∼ 24, J ∼ 22 and
K ∼ 20 at S/N ∼ 10. So far, the optical coverage is larger
than 1 square degree in some filters while there is no area
coverage in others. In the near infrared only 1/2 of a square
degree has been imaged. Optical spectroscopy is underway
in a few selected fields, while near infrared spectroscopy has
not started yet.
1.1. Strategy
2. Observations
Fields were selected at high galactic latitude to minimize the
effects of extinction. They were also spread out in right as-
cension to allow flexibility in the allocation of telescope time.
Amongst our fields, we selected fields observed by the Chan-
dra X-ray Observatory satellite with exposure times longer
than 50 ks.
Correspondence to: [email protected]
The first fields studied were three of the earliest deep Chan-
dra pointings to become publicly available. One of these field
is in the Northern hemisphere. It is the Chandra pointing to-
wards the blazar 1156+295. The X-ray exposure time was
75ks. The other two fields are in the South. They were point-
ing to the Hickson compact group HCG62 (exposure time
50ks) and the blazar Q1127-145 (30ks). These two Southern
fields will be the ones discussed in this paper.
A.N. Author: Title
2.1. X-ray data
Both the HCG62 and Q1127-145 fields were observed with
the Chandra ACIS-S instrument. We retrieved these images
from the archive and analyzed them using standard tech-
niques with the CIAO package. In the HCG62 field we de-
tect 34 X-ray sources in the s3 ACIS CCD and 16 sources in
the s4. In Chandra pointing towards Q1127-145, the s3 CCD
was the only CCD read. It was read in subraster mode and
therefore only 5 X-ray sources are detected in that field.
2.2. Optical and Infrared Imaging
We have observed both X-ray fields with the CTIO 4m
MOSAIC-II camera. The total
integration time for the
HCG62 field is 200 minutes in U, 36min in B, 80min in V
and 25 min in I under 1.0-1.5" conditions. In the Q1127-145
field the integration times are 80, 75 and 25 minutes in V, R
and I respectively. Images were reduced using standard tech-
niques with the IRAF/MSCRED package.
In the near infrared we have observed both fields at Las
Campanas Observatory with the DuPont 2.5m telescope us-
ing the Wide Field InfraRed Camera during 60 minutes in
J and 120 minutes in Ks under typical 0.6-0.7" seeing con-
ditions. We have reduced the data with the IRAF DIMSUM
package following standard procedures.
2.3. Optical Spectroscopy
Follow up spectroscopy of these fields was obtained at the
ESO Cerro Paranal Observatory with the UT4/Yepun tele-
scope using the FORS2/MXU instrument and at the Las Cam-
panas Observatory with the LDSS-2 instrument at the Magel-
lan Baade telescope. Several masks were designed which in-
cluded slits for most, but not all, of the X-ray sources in these
fields. Masks were observed for approximately two hours.
The instrument configuration used resulted in a spectral res-
olution of R ∼ 520 at VLT and R ∼ 350 at Magellan. The
spectra were reduced using standard techniques with IRAF
and calibrated in wavelength using He-Ar comparison lamps
exposures and the night sky lines.
3. First Results
In our first two Southern fields we have spectroscopically
identified 25 X-ray sources which corresponds to approxi-
mately half of the total X-ray sources detected. Table 1 sum-
marizes the percentages of the different type of objects in
our sample. For comparison we also present the results for
the Chandra Deep Field North (CDF-N; Brandt et al 2001,
Barger et al 2002) and the Chandra Multiwavelength Project
(ChaMP; Green et al 2003). We have grouped the different
object types in broad classes and have translated the source
types of Barger et al (2002) into these types. The CDF-N, CY-
DER and ChaMP surveys reach different X-ray flux limits;
the CDF-N survey reaching the faintest, the ChaMP survey,
the brightest. Table 1 demonstrates how the source compo-
sition changes with flux limit in an X-ray survey, although
1
Fig. 1. I magnitude plotted against full band (0.5-8.0 keV) X-
ray flux. Blue crosses represent the CDF-N sources and red
circles, the CYDER sources. The black solid line represents
the line of constant X-ray-to-optical flux ratio, that is, objects
with fI /fx = 1, where fI is the flux in the I optical band and
fx the X-ray flux. The two dashed lines correspond to objects
with log(fI /fx) = ±1, enclosing the region populated by
normal AGN/QSOs
the identification incompleteness may hide or enhance cer-
tain trends. At bright flux limits, the broad line active galactic
nuclei/quasars dominate the extragalactic sources. Their per-
centage contribution diminishes as the flux limit lowers due
to the appearence of a new population of X-ray fainter narrow
emission lines AGN/QSOs and normal galaxies.
Table 1. Approximate percentages of different
type of
sources in the CDF-N (Barger et al 2002), the CYDER and
ChaMP (Green et al 2003) surveys
CDFN CYDER ChaMP
Stars
Broad line AGN/QSO
Narrow line AGN/QSO
Galaxies
Total Number of Identified Sources
Total Number of Detected Sources
5%
25%
50%
20%
170
370
5%
40%
40%
15%
25
55
10%
65%
15%
10%
∼200
-
Figure 1 shows the I band and total X-ray flux of our
Chandra sources. For comparison we also plot the CDF-N
sources. In our sample we find that approximately 30% of our
sources do not show an optical counterpart down to I ∼ 24.
In the case of the CDF-N 16% are undetected down to I ∼ 26
and 35% down to I ∼ 24. Overall, the distribution of our
sources in the I .vs. X-ray flux plane occupy the same param-
eter space as the CDF-N sources cut at our same X-ray flux
limit.
2
Astron. Nachr./AN XXX (200X) X
Fig. 2. Cumulative redshift distribution of CYDER (solid red)
and CDF-N (dashed blue) sources.
We compare the CYDER and CDF-N source redshift
distributions in Figure 2. A Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test
shows that both distribution are compatible with having been
drawn from the same parent population and are therefore sta-
tistically indistinguishable. Given that the CDF-N sources are
typically fainter, we have cut their sample at the effective X-
ray flux limit of our sample. If we compare the redshift distri-
bution in this case, they remain to be statistically compatible.
It is worth noting that in our sample there are 5 QSOs at a
redshift z ∼ 1.2 in the same field. This large scale structure
feature is noticeable in our redshift distribution and stresses
the need to study sufficient sources and fields as to not be
biased by such structures.
We have also compared the X-ray properties of our sam-
ple to the CDF-N sources. We find that our sources are in gen-
eral softer than those in the CDF-N (see Treister & Castander
2003). A KS test indicates that the hardness ratio distributions
are incompatible with being drawn from the same parent pop-
ulation. This results may be expected as the CDF-N sources
are typically fainter and fainter sources are in general harder
(e.g., Giacconi et al 2001; Tozzi et al 2001; Brandt et al 2001;
Stern 2002). However, if we impose our effective flux limit to
the CDF-N sample we still find that our sources are signifi-
cantly softer than the reduced brighter CDF-N subsample.
We also investigate what the optical properties of our
sample are. Figure 3 is a colour-colour plot including our
X-ray sources counterparts (see the figure caption for an
explanation of the symbols). Two sources lie on the stel-
lar locus. One is spectroscopically identified as a star, while
the other has not been observed spectroscopically. The rest
of the sources populate the region of colour-colour space
of extragalactic sources. Some of our broad emission line
AGN/QSOs are close to the expected location of typical
quasars. Others, on the other hand, deviate from their ex-
Fig. 3. J − K .vs. V − I colour-colour plot including the
CYDER X-ray sources. The small dots represent the colours
of the objects in a reduced area of our optical and near in-
frared coverage of our Chandra fields. The main sequence
stars (band of objects from J − K ∼ 0.3 and V − I ∼ 0.6
to J − K ∼ 0.8 and V − I ∼ 3.5) nicely separate from the
rest of the extragalactic sources. The grey symbols indicate
the X-ray sources (circles: sources in the HCG62 field; trian-
gles: Q1127-145 field). The size of the circles and triangles is
proportional to the X-ray flux. The grey intensity of the sym-
bols shows the hardness ratio. The softest sources (HR=-1)
are represented in dark grey and the hardest sources (HR=1)
in light grey. The black line indicates the expected location
of a QSO at different redshifts. The small dots in the line in-
dicate separations of 0.5 units in redshift. The track starts at
z = 0 at J − K ∼ 1.9 and V − I ∼ 1.1, then moves blue-
wards in V − I at approximately constant J − K up to z ∼ 2,
then moves blue-wards in J − K at approximately constant
V − I up to z ∼ 3 − 3.5 and finally quickly moves red-wards
in V −I at approximately constant J −K. The grey (coloured
in electronic version) tracks represent the expected evolution-
ary path of different galaxy types. The dark grey curve most
to the right (red) is a 1 Gyr burst of star formation occurring
15 Gyr ago that evolves passively since. The other evolution-
ary tracks are computed with star formation prescriptions that
broadly reproduce the observed photometric properties of E,
S0, Sa, Sb, Sbc, Sc, Sd and irregular galaxies (from right to
left run from earlier types to later types). The points at the
bluest J − K colour in each track represent those galaxies at
z = 0. Small dots on the tracks are then spaced in 0.5 units
in redshift.
pected position indicating that they are probably reddened.
The majority (although not all) of our soft sources lie close to
the expected locus of early-type galaxies. The hardest sources
populate the regions of mildly active galaxies at redshifts
z ∼ 0.5 − 1.0. They may be at such locations because they
are indeed this type of galaxies or because they have been
reddened to that part of colour-colour space.
We compare the photometric and X-ray properties of our
sources. We find that the hardest sources are preferentially
redder than the rest of the objects. However, we also find
soft sources that are red, implying that while blue sources
A.N. Author: Title
3
Fig. 4. Optical spectrum of CXOCY J125241.0-091622 ob-
tained at UT4/Yepun VLT.
are preferentially soft, red sources can be either X-ray hard
or soft. Given the reduced number of sources in our sample,
this effect could simply be a statistical fluctuation.
The spectra of our sources reveal a diverse variety of type
of objects. We find typical examples of broad and narrow
emission line AGN/QSOs. We find typical old stellar pop-
ulation spectral energy distributions. There are also examples
of poststarburst galaxies and objects whose spectral classifi-
cation is difficult as they have broad emission lines typical of
quasars and spectral characteristics of old stellar population
with some moderate on-going star formation. Some of our
objects show obvious signs of strong absorption.
Here we comment on two of our X-ray sources. CXOCY
J125241.0-091622 is a quasar at redshift z = 2.282 (Fig-
ure 4) with a harder than usual X-ray spectrum Γ ∼ 1.3.
In the optical its V − K color is 4.0 which is one magni-
tude redder than the expected colour of a prototype quasar
at this redshift (Figure 3). Both X-ray and optical data thus
indicate that this is an obscured object. Such objects are pre-
dicted in models as contributors to the X-ray Background at
faint fluxes.
CXOCY J125304.0-090737 is an optically faint quasar
(MB = −23.69+5 ×log(h65)) with a typical QSO spectrum
(figure 5). In X-rays, CXOCY J125304.0-090737 is also X-
ray faint (fX = 1.7 ± 0.4 × 10−15 ergs s−1 cm−2 in the [0.5-
2.0] keV band) with a somewhat harder spectrum (Γ ∼ 1.7 or
HR ∼ −0.35) than typical low redshift or high redshift op-
tically selected quasars. We speculate that a reflection com-
ponent can slightly harden the spectrum but by no means is
this the only mechanism. CXOCY J125304.0-090737 X-ray-
to-optical emission is X-ray strong (αox ∼ −1.35) compared
to high redshift optically selected quasars (see Castander et
al 2002 for further details).
Fig. 5. Optical spectrum of CXOCY J125304.0-090737 ob-
tained at UT4/Yepun VLT. For comparison, we also show the
error weighted average of the SDSS Early Data Release QSO
spectra at z > 4. This composite spectrum have arbitrary zero
point and scaling offsets for display purposes and it is shown
above the spectrum of CXOCY J125304.0-090737. The most
common QSO emission lines are indicated as dotted lines.
The emission lines in CXOCY J125304.0-090737 are nar-
rower than the typical SDSS spectrum.
CXOCY J125304.0-090737 is the only quasar above z =
4 found so far in the CYDER survey. However, the space den-
sity implied by its discovery is higher than reasonable extrap-
olations of the quasar optical luminosity function to fainter
luminosities at high redshifts (Fan et al 2001) . Although this
object by itself does not constrain the faint end of the lumi-
nosity function at high redshift, it demonstrates the possibili-
ties that X-ray surveys have to achieve this goal.
4. Summary
We have briefly presented the CYDER survey, which is cur-
rently underway. We have focused in the first fields studied
that were chosen to coincide with moderately deep Chandra
X-ray pointings. We have investigated the nature of the X-ray
sources in these fields. We find that the broad X-ray and op-
tical properties of our sources are similar to the ones studied
in the CDF-N. The only difference is that our sources appear
to be softer. We also stress the fact that our X-ray sources
are of diverse optical spectral types and have highlighted the
discovery of a high redshift X-ray selected quasar.
The current X-ray surveys (most of which are presented
in this volume) that have flourished with the launch of the
new X-ray observatories promise to be key to our understand-
ing of the faint X-ray populations. The CYDER survey will
be one of the surveys contributing to pin down the evolution
of accretion material on to black holes which seems to be
closely related to the star formation history of the universe.
Acknowledgements. We acknowledge the financial support received
from the Fundaci´on Andes that has enabled the collaboration be-
tween the Universidad de Chile and Yale University and therefore
has made the CYDER survey possible.
Astron. Nachr./AN XXX (200X) X
4
References
Barger, A. J. et al.: 2002, AJ, 124, 1839
Brandt, W. N. et al.: 2001, AJ, 122, 2810
Castander, F. J. et al.: 2002, AJ, submitted
Giacconi, R. et al.: 2001, ApJ, 551, 624
Green, P.J. et al: 2003: AN, this volume
Fan, X. et al: 2001, AJ, 121, 31
Stern, D. et al.: 2002, AJ, 123, 2223
Tozzi, P. et al.: 2001, ApJ, 562, 42
Treister, E. & Castander, F. J.: 2003, AN, this volume
|
astro-ph/0505322 | 1 | 0505 | 2005-05-16T15:59:14 | An Artificial Neural Network Approach to the Solution of Molecular Chemical Equilibrium | [
"astro-ph"
] | A novel approach is presented for the solution of instantaneous chemical equilibrium problems. The chemical equilibrium can be considered, due to its intrinsically local character, as a mapping of the three-dimensional parameter space spanned by the temperature, hydrogen density and electron density into many one-dimensional spaces representing the number density of each species. We take advantage of the ability of artificial neural networks to approximate non-linear functions and construct neural networks for the fast and efficient solution of the chemical equilibrium problem in typical stellar atmosphere physical conditions. The neural network approach has the advantage of providing an analytic function, which can be rapidly evaluated. The networks are trained with a learning set (that covers the entire parameter space) until a relative error below 1% is reached. It has been verified that the networks are not overtrained by using an additional verification set. The networks are then applied to a snapshot of realistic three-dimensional convection simulations of the solar atmosphere showing good generalization properties. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. 2865
(DOI: will be inserted by hand later)
October 24, 2018
5
0
0
2
y
a
M
6
1
1
v
2
2
3
5
0
5
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
An Artificial Neural Network Approach to the Solution of
Molecular Chemical Equilibrium
A. Asensio Ramos1 and H. Socas-Navarro2
1 Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF) Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, Largo Enrico Fermi 5, 50125
Florence, Italy
2 High Altitude Observatory, NCAR⋆, 3450 Mitchell Ln, Boulder CO 80307-3000, USA
Received ¡date¿ / Accepted ¡date¿
Abstract. A novel approach is presented for the solution of instantaneous chemical equilibrium problems. The
chemical equilibrium can be considered, due to its intrinsically local character, as a mapping of the three-
dimensional parameter space spanned by the temperature, hydrogen density and electron density into many
one-dimensional spaces representing the number density of each species. We take advantage of the ability of arti-
ficial neural networks to approximate non-linear functions and construct neural networks for the fast and efficient
solution of the chemical equilibrium problem in typical stellar atmosphere physical conditions. The neural network
approach has the advantage of providing an analytic function, which can be rapidly evaluated. The networks are
trained with a learning set (that covers the entire parameter space) until a relative error below 1% is reached. It
has been verified that the networks are not overtrained by using an additional verification set. The networks are
then applied to a snapshot of realistic three-dimensional convection simulations of the solar atmosphere showing
good generalization properties.
Key words. Molecular processes -- Astrochemistry -- Methods: numerical
1. Introduction
Molecules are usually found in highly dynamic systems
(e.g., the solar atmosphere, winds of AGB stars, ...) and
their formation is influenced by the time variation of
the physical conditions in the medium. In many situa-
tions the dynamical timescales are much slower than the
timescales of molecular formation, and the approximation
of Instantaneous Chemical Equilibrium (ICE) can be used
with extremely good results (Russell 1934; Tsuji 1964,
1973; McCabe et al. 1979, etc.). Under the ICE approxi-
mation, molecules and ions are assumed to form instan-
taneously and their abundances depend only upon the
local temperature and density. Another consequence of
this assumption is that the specific reaction mechanisms
that create and destroy a given molecule are irrelevant
and only the molecule and its constituents are impor-
tant. Concerning the solar atmosphere, it has been re-
cently shown with the comparison between ICE calcula-
tions and detailed chemical evolution calculations that the
formation of the strong CO lines around 4.7 µm can be
well described using the ICE approximation for heights be-
low ∼700 km (Asensio Ramos et al. 2003). On the other
hand, chemical evolution effects in regions of the atmo-
sphere above this height are of importance in setting the
CO abundance.
In order to calculate the atomic and molecular number
densities using the ICE approximation one needs to solve
a non-linear system of equations (see below). Although
efficient numerical methods exist for solving this kind of
systems, the computing time when the ICE problem has
to be solved in a large amount of points (e.g., dense grids,
multi-dimensional geometries, iterative inversions, etc) be-
comes prohibitive. It is then very important to develop a
numerical method for the rapid solution of chemical equi-
librium problems.
Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) have proven to be
a powerful approach to a broad variety of problems (see,
e.g., Bishop 1996). In the solar community, they have been
recently applied to the problem of inferring the magnetic
field from observations of the polarization profiles of se-
lected atomic lines (Carroll & Staude 2001; Socas-Navarro
2003, 2005). In this paper, we make use of the ability of
ANNs with one hidden layer to approximate any non-
linear continuous function (e.g., Jones 1990; Blum & Li
1991) to solve the ICE problem.
⋆ The National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) is
sponsored by the National Science Foundation
The structure of the paper is as follows. Section 2 de-
scribes the ICE approximation and its standard solution.
2
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
Section 3 describes our approach to the ICE problem us-
ing ANNs, discussing how it can be trained to associate
a combination of physical parameters with the number
density of each species included in the problem. Section
4 details how the trained network can be applied to solve
the ICE problem in realistic convection simulations of the
solar atmosphere. In section 5 we show the dependence
of the outputs of the ANN on the physical parameters,
which can be easily done because of the intrinsic analytic
character of the mapping generated by the ANN. Finally,
the most relevant conclusions are summarized in Section
6.
2. Instantaneous chemical equilibrium
2.1. Basic equations
Consider three elements A, B and C that stick together
to form a molecule AaBbCc, in which a, b and c are the
stoichiometric coefficients indicating the number of times
an element is present in the molecule. Because the explicit
reactions which form the molecule are irrelevant under the
ICE approximation, one needs only to consider the follow-
ing dissociative process for the formation of the molecule
AaBbCc:
AaBbCc ⇔ aA + bB + cC.
(1)
This reaction is characterized by its dissociative reaction
constant or equilibrium constant. It is given by the ratio
between the product of the partial pressures of the indi-
vidual elements and the partial pressure of the molecule:
We now define the fictitious pressure P (i) as the pressure
exerted by element i if all the gas were in the neutral
form of the atomic species i. It is customary to specify
the partial pressures of all the atomic species in terms of
the fictitious pressure of hydrogen P (H). The coefficient
relating one and the other is the abundance of each ele-
ment with respect to hydrogen, A(i), so P (i) = A(i)P (H).
The abundance of each atomic species depends on the
metallicity of the star we are considering. For the solar
case, we have used the standard solar abundances given
by Grevesse (1984).
Under ICE conditions, the number of atoms and
molecules are obtained by solving the conservation of mass
and the chemical equilibrium conditions given by Eq. (2).
The conservation of mass establishes that the sum of
the partial pressures of all the species containing a given
atomic element (taking into account the stoichiometry)
equals the fictitious pressure of the given element:
P (i) = Pi + Pi+ + Pi− +Xk
ωi
kPk,
(7)
where Pi, Pi+ and Pi− are the partial pressure of the neu-
tral element i, and the ionized elements i+ and i−, respec-
tively, while Pk is the partial pressure of molecule k which
has species i in its composition. ωi
k is the stoichiometric
coefficient which indicates the number of times element i
appears in molecule k. The sum is extended over all the
molecules in which the element i takes part. The previous
equation can be rewritten with the aid of Eqs. (2) and (6):
Kp(T ) =
BP c
P a
AP b
C
PABC
,
(2)
P (i) = Pi +Ki+
Pi
Pe−
+Ki−PiPe− +Xk
ωi
k
ωj
P ωi
i P
k
j
k
· · · P ωl
k
l
K (k)
p (T )
,
where Kp(T ) is a function of the temperature and Pi the
partial pressure of the species i. For example, the equi-
librium constants for the dissociation of CO and H2 are
given by
K CO
p
(T ) =
PC PO
PCO
,
K H2
p (T ) =
P 2
H
PH2
.
(3)
The partial pressure is usually related to the number den-
sity ni of a given species by the ideal gas equation:
Pi = nikT,
(4)
where k is the Boltzmann constant and T the local tem-
perature. This partial pressure is the pressure of the gas if
no other species were present. The sum of all the partial
pressures is the total pressure in the medium.
Following the same line of reasoning, one can consider
the ionization equilibria for the atomic species:
A ⇔ A+ + e−
A + e− ⇔ A−,
with their corresponding equilibrium constants:
KA+(T ) =
PA+ Pe−
PA
KA−(T ) =
PA−
PAPe−
.
. . . ,
k + ωj
(8)
l are the atomic species composing
where i, j,
k + . . . + ωl
molecule k, ωi
k = nk is the number of
atoms of molecule k and K (k)
p (T ) is its equilibrium con-
stant. Charged molecules can be easily included by taking
into account their dissociation and the ionization equilib-
rium, simultaneously. Consider the dissociation equilib-
rium of an ionized diatomic molecule. One only needs to
take into account that when a charged molecule dissoci-
ates, the atomic element which remains ionized is the one
with the lowest ionization potential:
AB+ ⇔ A+ + B,
(9)
with D0(A) < D0(B). Therefore, using Eq. (2) and Eq.
(6) we can calculate the partial pressure of the ionized
molecule:
Kp(T ) =
PA+ PB
PAB+
=
KA+(T )
Pe−
PAPB
PAB+
,
(10)
(5)
(6)
We can write an equation like Eq. (8) for each of the
Ns atomic species included in the calculation. In our case
we have selected the 21 species which are shown in Table
1. Therefore, once the molecular and ionization equilib-
rium constants are known, we have a set of Ns non-linear
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
3
algebraic equations which depend on the local tempera-
ture and density. The ICE approximation is intrinsically
local since it depends only on the local values of the tem-
perature and density. Therefore, to calculate the molecu-
lar number densities in a model atmosphere, we have to
solve the algebraic non-linear system of equations at each
point in the atmosphere. This system is solved using a
standard Newton-Raphson iterative method (Press et al.
1986). Once the partial pressures for all the atomic species
are known, we can calculate the ensuing atomic number
densities by using Eq. (4). The molecular number densi-
ties are calculated by solving for their partial pressures
in Eq. (2), using the equilibrium constant appropriate for
each molecule.
2.2. Equilibrium constants
As we discussed above, the problem of obtaining the
atomic and molecular number densities is completely de-
fined once the temperature and the total density (or pres-
sure) is known. However, we also need to know the value
of the equilibrium constant for each temperature. It is
known from considerations of statistical mechanics that
the value of the equilibrium constant can be obtained
with the aid of the partition function of the molecule
and of the individual atomic components, their respec-
tive masses and the dissociation energy D0 (see, e.g.,
Tejero Ordonez & Cernicharo 1991, for detailed informa-
tion on how the equilibrium constants can be calculated).
The expression is given by (Tejero Ordonez & Cernicharo
1991, and references therein):
Kp(T ) = (kT )N A−1(cid:18) 2πkT
h2 (cid:19)3(N A−1)/2(cid:18) ma
Amb
Bmc
mABC (cid:19)
C
3/2
Aφb
×(cid:18) φa
Bφc
φABC (cid:19) e−D0/kT ,
C
(11)
where mi is the mass of atomic or molecular species i,
N A = a + b + c is the number of atoms present in the
molecule, φi is the partition function of species i. h and
k stand for the Planck and Boltzmann constants, respec-
tively. The partition functions can be obtained by per-
forming the summation
φ = Xj
gje−Ej /kT ,
(12)
where gj is the degeneracy of level j and Ej
its en-
ergy. Ideally, the sum has to be extended over all
the energy levels of the species. However, due to the
difficulty of accounting for all the energy levels, the
most complete available set of energy levels must be
used. For molecules, the partition function has to in-
clude the contribution from the electronic, vibrational
and rotational
levels. It is not practical to compute
this
every ICE calculations. As a
workaround, some authors have tabulated polynomial
fits to the partition functions (Russell 1934; Tsuji 1971;
Sauval & Tatum 1984; Tejero Ordonez & Cernicharo
summation for
1991). In this work, we make use of the results obtained
by Tejero Ordonez & Cernicharo (1991).
It represents
one of the most complete compilations of molecular
equilibrium constants for more than 240 diatomic and
polyatomic molecules. These equilibrium constants were
obtained by calculating the partition function with the
most up-to-date molecular constants at the time of
the work and their dependence with the temperature
are given, as in previous works, as polynomial fits.
One of the advantages of selecting this database is its
self-consistency.
3. Neural network
3.1. Description of the network
The ICE problem consists on obtaining the partial pres-
sures of the atomic species (or the atomic species number
densities) which are consistent with Eq. (8) once the lo-
cal temperature, local hydrogen density and local electron
density are given. One could also take a different point
of view and see the ICE problem as a mapping between
the three-dimensional space given by (T, nH , ne) onto sev-
eral one-dimensional spaces, one for each atomic species
included in the problem. The functional form of the func-
tions f : R3 → R is not known.
The Artificial Neural Network (ANN) with one hidden
layer is a universal approximant to any non-linear con-
tinuous function (e.g., Jones 1990; Blum & Li 1991). The
schematic structure of such a network is shown in Fig.
1. We have constructed an ANN with an input layer of
three neurons where the temperature, hydrogen density
and electron density are introduced. The neurons of the
input layer have a linear activation function. The hidden
layer consists on Nh neurons with a non-linear activation
function σ(x). Each hidden neuron is connected to all the
neurons of the input layer by a certain weight (indicated
by arrows in the figure). The value obtained at each hidden
neuron is a linear combination of the values at the neurons
of the input layer multiplied by the weights. These values
are then applied the non-linear function σ(x), multiplied
by another set of weights and summed to give the final
output of the neural network. The output of the network
can be written as:
j T + wH
j n(H) + we
j n(e) + uj(cid:3) ,
N (T, n(H), n(e), m) =
Nh
Xj
vjσ(cid:2)wT
(13)
where the activation function is usually given by the sig-
moid or the hyperbolic-tangent function. In this case, we
have selected σ(x) = tanh(x). In the previous expression,
m formally represents the whole set of 5 × Nh weights
which define the neural network.
The use of a neural network approach for the solu-
tion of the ICE problem is very appealing for several rea-
sons. Firstly, we obtain an analytic function which is in-
finitely differentiable and which could be easily used in any
subsequent calculation. This way, we can investigate with
4
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
T
n(H)
n(e )-
gives a good coverage of the parameter space, consider-
ing that they are randomly selected. The temperature is
varied in the range from 3500 K and 14000 K, which is
representative of the physical conditions in typical stel-
lar atmospheres. Concerning the hydrogen and electronic
abundances, we decided to use a logarithmic scaling. The
hydrogen density is varied from 1012 cm−3 to 1018 cm−3
while the electronic density is varied from 108 cm−3 to
1017 cm−3. Again, these values are a reasonable represen-
tation of realistic conditions.
Once the learning set is selected, the training of the
network for each species i reduces to a minimization of
the following error function:
Pi
Fig. 1. Schematic structure of the neural network model
used for approximating the ICE results. The input layer
and the output layer are linear, while the hidden layer
is assumed to be non-linear, with an hyperbolic-tangent
activation function. The input layer consists of three neu-
rons for the temperature, hydrogen number density and
electronic number density. The output neuron gives the
partial pressure of element i for the physical conditions in
the input layer.
great detail the dependence of the atomic and/or molec-
ular abundances with temperature, hydrogen density and
electron density. Secondly, the powerful approximation ca-
pabilities of ANNs make them very suitable for multi-
dimensional interpolation problems. Even more striking is
the ability of ANNs to extrapolate data outside the range
of parameters used in the learning process. A direct con-
sequence of these properties is that the number of points
that need to be used for the learning process can be very
small compared to the case of standard interpolation tech-
niques. Furthermore, the number of parameters needed for
performing the interpolation is also small. Essentially, one
transforms the problem from storing in memory the whole
set of N points which relates T , n(H) and n(e) with the
partial pressures Pi for every species to storing only the
5 × Nh m weights present in Eq. (13) for each species.
This reduction is proportional to the ratio N/Nh, which
can be very large for large, as we will see below. Finally, it
is also important to note that the neural network can be
straightforwardly implemented in parallel architectures.
3.2. Learning process
In order to obtain a neural network which is able to ap-
proximate the abundance of each species included in the
chemical equilibrium calculation, we randomly select Nl
sets of temperature, hydrogen density and electronic den-
sity. For each one of these combinations, we solve the
ICE equations and calculate the abundances of all the
atomic species. We have verified that taking Nl = 1000
Ei =
Nl
Xl=1 (cid:2)P l
i − N (Tl, nl(H), nl(e), m)(cid:3)2
,
(14)
so that the optimum values of the parameters m are ob-
tained. P l
i is the partial pressure (or number density) of
species i obtained for the combination of physical condi-
tions l. Since almost every minimization algorithm makes
use of the derivatives of the error function with respect to
the parameters, it is of interest to notice that they can be
obtained analytically:
∂E
∂mk
= −2
Nl
Xl=1
[Pi − N (Tl, nl(H), nl(e), m)]
∂N
∂mk
,
(15)
where the partial derivatives of the neural network with
respect to the parameters are obtained in a straightfor-
ward manner by using Eq. (13). In order to obtain the set
of parameters m which minimize the error function, we
have used a quasi-Newton BFGS method (Fletcher 1987)
implemented in the Merlin package (Papageorgiou et al.
1998) which presents a very good convergence rate.
It is interesting to note that the usual approach of
training the neural network with a learning set obtained
from the original problem can be circumvented here. We
do not need to rely on the precision given by the Newton-
Raphson solution and the neural network can be made
as precise as desired. This is a consequence of the fact
that the equations describing the ICE approximations are
known. One can see that the equations of ICE can be for-
mally written as f (T, n(H), n(e), {Pi}) = 0, where {Pi} is
the set of Ns partial pressures (or atomic number densi-
ties) which satisfy the equations. Therefore, we can build
as many neural networks as species included in the ICE
problem and train the network by minimizing the follow-
ing error function:
Nl
E =
[f (Tl, nl(H), nl(e), {Ni(Tl, nl(H), nl(e), m)})]2 .
Xl=1
(16)
The solution to the problem is transformed into finding the
set of parameters m for all the networks which minimizes
the previous error function. The summation is extended
over the Nl elements of the learning set. Several issues are
noteworthy in this case. On the one hand, the derivatives
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
5
Fig. 2. Relative error obtained after the training of the neural network for hydrogen, oxygen, carbon and iron. The
distribution of relative errors are shown for the learning set and for a verification set, which aids at detecting over-
training. We indicate the value of the standard deviation σ of the distribution and the number of points below 1σ, 2σ
and 3σ. We also indicate these values in the plots as horizontal lines.
of the error function with respect to the parameters m
are not as straightforward as those found in Eq. (15) since
the function f (T, n(H), n(e), {Pi}) = 0 is non-linear. On
the other hand, the minimization process has to be carried
out simultaneously for the Ns neural networks, so that the
problem of finding the minimum might be more difficult
to solve. The dimension of the hypersurface in which we
have to find the minimum is 5×Nh×Ns, instead of finding
Ns minima in hypersurfaces of dimension 5 × Nh.
A critical parameter in the training ability of a neural
network is the number of hidden neurons Nh. It is impor-
tant to build networks with sufficient number of hidden
networks to accurately approximate the non-linear func-
tion we are interested in. However, since the number of
learning points is not infinite, the number of hidden neu-
rons one can use is practically limited by the overtraining
phenomenon (in principle, the number of training points
should be much larger than the number of hidden neu-
rons). If Nh is very large, the network is capable of cor-
rectly approximating all the points in the learning set but
its interpolation capacity is lost, producing large oscilla-
tions between the points of the learning set. This is a di-
rect consequence of the increase in the degrees of freedom
of the network when the number of hidden neurons is in-
creased. One way to avoid this overtraining is to use two
different data sets: one for learning purposes and the other
for testing. When the training process takes places, the er-
ror given by expression (14) is evaluated for the training
set and for the test set. When the network is training cor-
rectly, both errors are reduced. When the network starts to
be overtrained, the error of the test set starts to increase.
We have followed this scheme in order to stop the train-
ing process before overtraining. In our case, we have used
two different values for the number of hidden neurons. We
have verified that Nh = 20 gives sufficiently accurate re-
sults for 13 of the 21 atomic species included in the ICE
calculations, while we were forced to increase this num-
ber to Nh = 30 for the rest of species. Table 1 lists the
number of hidden neurons for each species. We did not
investigate the dependence of the minimum error on the
number of hidden neurons so that the increase to Nh = 30
was somewhat arbitrary.
The training of the neural networks was stopped when
the standard deviation of the relative error between the
output of the neural network and the values obtained from
the solution of the ICE equations for both the learning and
the test sets was 1% or below. Obviously, the relative er-
ror was always larger for the test set than for the learning
6
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
Fig. 3. Histograms of relative errors for the 2.55×105 points of the three-dimensional convection simulation of
Asplund et al. (2000). We indicate the position of 1σ, 2σ and 3σ of the distribution. Note that they are similar
to those obtained for the verification set during the training of the networks.
Table 1. Number of hidden neurons used for each ANN.
Species
Number of hidden neurons
He, Na, Mg, Al, P, K, Ca
Ti, Cr, Mn, Fe, Ni, Cu
H, C, N, O, F, Si, S, Cl
20
30
set, but the training always reached the limit of 1% and
was stopped before any indication of overtraining was ob-
served. In Fig. 2 we present the relative error obtained for
the 1000 training points for the abundances of H, C, O and
Fe. The behavior of the relative error for the rest of species
follows the same behavior, except for He, which presents a
much smaller dispersion. Since He cannot form molecules,
it is always in its atomic form and the non-linear mapping
that the neural network has to learn is strongly simplified.
We have indicated in each plot the value of the stan-
dard deviation and the percentage of points which are con-
tained within 1σ, 2σ and 3σ. This is an indication of the
precision obtained with the neural network. It is common
in all the networks that more than ∼ 95% of the points are
inside 3σ, which translates into a relative error of ∼ 3%
(since σ is always of the order or below 1%). However,
we note that it is common to all the networks that more
than 75% of the points are below 1σ. Along with the plots
of the results obtained for the learning set, we have in-
cluded the results for the verification set. It is interesting
to note that, although the standard deviation of the dis-
tribution of relative errors is larger than that obtained for
the learning set, typically more than ∼ 80% of the points
are below this limit. In the case of the network for the
carbon abundance, we have a relatively high value for σ,
but more than 90% of the points are below this limit.
4. Comparison of results
Once the neural networks were trained to the desired pre-
cision, as shown in Fig. 2, we have applied them to realistic
situations in order to compare their performance with the
complete ICE calculations. To this end, we make use of a
three-dimensional snapshot of the convection simulation
of the solar atmosphere of Asplund et al. (2000). We con-
sider this simulation to be an adequate representation of
the physical conditions in the solar atmosphere since sev-
eral investigations are reporting good agreements between
the synthetic line profiles and the observed ones (e.g.,
Shchukina & Trujillo Bueno 2001; Asplund et al. 2004,
2003). The snapshot box size is 50x50x102, so that the
number of points is 2.55×105. We have solved the ICE
problem in each point and confronted the results with
those obtained from the neural networks.
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
7
Fig. 4. Number density of carbon and oxygen obtained with the simplified model and with the neural network for two
different combinations of hydrogen and electron densities and for different values of the temperature. Note that this
kind of investigation is greatly simplified due to the analytical character of the neural network.
The normalized error histograms are shown in Fig. 3
for H, C, O and Fe, with vertical dashed lines indicating
the position of 1σ, 2σ and 3σ of the distribution. Note
that the histograms are decreasing functions of the rela-
tive error, so that the number of points with large rela-
tive error is much smaller than the number of points with
small relative errors. It is verified that the value of the
standard deviation of the distribution of relative errors
is quite similar to those obtained for the verification set.
This reinforces our confidence that the learning set and
the verification set provide sufficient coverage of the three-
dimensional parameter space (T, n(H), n(e)). The shapes
of the histograms turn out to be fairly linear in this log-
linear scale, so that we can consider, as a first approxima-
tion, that the number of points Np with a certain relative
error r is given by Np ∝ r−α. For example, we find that
α ≃ 5 for hydrogen, α ≃ 3.7 for carbon and α ≃ 7 for oxy-
gen. There is an exception for iron, for which the distri-
bution of points with relative errors below ∼ 2.3% seems
to be constant, while the number of points with errors
larger than ∼ 2.3% is three order of magnitude smaller.
The behavior of the histograms for the rest of species is
very similar to those shown in Fig. 3 for the selected ones,
maintaining the properties obtained for the verification
sets.
5. T , n(H) and N (e) dependence
Since the neural network approach leads to analytic for-
mulae for the solution of ICE problems, we now take ad-
vantage of them and compare the results for abundant
species with simplified models. Our aim is to investigate
the variation with temperature, hydrogen density and
electronic density of the number density of carbon and
oxygen. We have selected these two species because they
are the constituents of the highly abundant CO diatomic
molecule. This way, we can safely obtain an approximation
to the carbon and oxygen abundances by taking only into
account the formation of CO in the ICE equations and ne-
glecting the rest of molecular species. Note that this sim-
plification is only valid for species like C and O and not for
species which form less abundant molecules and/or form
several high abundance molecules. Specializing Eq. (8) to
oxygen and carbon, we obtain:
P (C) = PC +
P (O) = PO +
PC PO
KCO(T )
PC PO
KCO(T )
+ KC +
+ KO+
PC
Pe−
PO
Pe−
+ KC−PC Pe−
+ KO−POPe− . (17)
This system of equations can be solved analytically for
PC and PO and transformed into number densities by us-
ing the ideal gas equation Eq. (4). Their dependence with
temperature for two different combinations of hydrogen
and electronic densities are shown in Fig. 4. The output
of the neural network is also shown in the plots with solid
lines. Note the accurate results obtained with this simpli-
fied model in this high abundance case. This behavior can
be better understood if we plot separately the contribu-
tion to the total pressure of each element of each term in
Eq. (17). The results are shown in Fig. 5 for the two sets
of physical conditions. The fictitious pressure of carbon
and oxygen (essentially the abundance of carbon and/or
oxygen times the hydrogen density) is shown by solid line,
the partial pressure of the neutral element by dashed line,
the partial pressure of the carbon monoxide molecule by
dash-dotted line and the partial pressure of the ionized
element by long dashes. All the quantities shown in the
plots have been obtained using the neural network ap-
proach. Although the neural network takes into account
the formation of other molecules which contain carbon
and oxygen (i.e., it gives the solution to the complete ICE
problem), we see that accounting only for CO appears to
be enough since the addition of all the contribution closely
approximates the value of the fictitious pressure.
Note that the CO molecule is efficiently formed when
the temperature is below ∼5000 K in both situations. The
neutral species are mainly situated at intermediate tem-
peratures, typical from photospheric regions, while the
8
A. Asensio Ramos and H. Socas-Navarro: Neural Network approach to ICE
Fig. 5. Contribution to the total pressure of carbon and oxygen in two different cases. The curves have been obtained
using the neural networks. The addition of all the contribution closely matches the fictitious pressure of carbon and
oxygen. This is the reason why the very simplified model for C and O works very well.
ionized species tend to dominate for high temperatures,
above 6000 − 7000 K.
6. Conclusion
We have successfully trained 21 neural networks which
approximate the solution to the Instantaneous Chemical
Equilibrium problem. We have generated a learning set
which is representative of the physical conditions in stel-
lar atmospheres and have verified that the coverage of
the three-dimensional parameter space is sufficiently good
with only 1000 points. We have trained the neural net-
works so that the standard deviation of the relative er-
ror were below or of the order of 1%. In order to avoid
overtraining, we have employed an independent verifica-
tion set. The standard deviation of the relative error in
this verification set is larger than that for the learning
set but also of the order of 1%. We apply the neural net-
works obtained to the ICE problem in a three dimensional
convection simulation, representative of the physical con-
ditions in the solar atmosphere. The histograms of rela-
tive errors built with all the points in the simulation show
that the neural networks are capable of solving the ICE
problem with relative errors similar to those obtained for
the verification set. The advantage of the neural network
approach is their intrinsic analytical character, the possi-
bility of parallelization and the very fast evaluation. The
development of a fast approach to ICE is of importance
for, among others, recent multi-dimensional simulations
of stellar atmospheres which include very dense grids and
iterative inversions of observed spectra.
Acknowledgements. This research has been partly funded
by the Ministerio de Educaci´on y Ciencia through project
AYA2004-05792 and by the European Solar Magnetism
Network (contract HPRN-CT-2002-00313).
References
Asensio Ramos, A., Trujillo Bueno, J., Carlsson, M., &
Cernicharo, J. 2003, ApJ, 588, L61
Asplund, M., Carlsson, M., & Botnen, A. V. 2003, A&A,
399, 31
Asplund, M., Grevesse, N., Sauval, A. J., Allende Prieto,
C., & Kiselman, D. 2004, A&A, 417, 751
Asplund, M., Ludwig, H. G., Nordlund, A., & Stein, R. F.
2000, A&A, 359, 669
Bishop, C. M. 1996, Neural networks for pattern recogni-
tion (Oxford University Press)
Blum, E. K. & Li, L. K. 1991, Neural Networks, 4, 511
Carroll, T. A. & Staude, J. 2001, A&A, 378, 316
Fletcher, R. 1987, Practical Methods of Optimization, 2nd
ed. (New York: Wiley)
Grevesse, N. 1984, Phys. Scr, 8, 49
Jones, L. K. 1990, in Proceedings of the IEEE, 78, 1585
McCabe, E. M., Connon Smith, R., & Clegg, R. E. S. 1979,
Nature, 281, 263
Papageorgiou, D. G., Demetropoulos, I. N., & Lagaris,
I. R. 1998, Comput. Phys. Commun., 109, 227
Press, W. H., Teukolsky, S. A., Vetterling, W. T., &
Flannery, B. P. 1986, Numerical Recipes (Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press)
Russell, H. N. 1934, ApJ, 79, 281
Sauval, A. J. & Tatum, J. B. 1984, ApJS, 56, 193
Shchukina, N. & Trujillo Bueno, J. 2001, ApJ, 550, 970
Socas-Navarro, H. 2003, Neural Networks, 16, 355
Socas-Navarro, H. 2005, ApJ, 620, 517
Tejero Ordonez, J. & Cernicharo, J. 1991, Modelos
de Equilibrio Termodin´amico Aplicados a Envolturas
Circunestelares de Estrellas Evolucionadas (Madrid:
IGN)
Tsuji, T. 1964, Ann. Tokio. Astron. Obs., 2nd ser. 9, 1
Tsuji, T. 1971, Ann. Tokio Astron. Obs. 2nd ser., 9, 1
Tsuji, T. 1973, A&A, 23, 411
|
astro-ph/0205121 | 1 | 0205 | 2002-05-08T15:00:31 | The X-ray emission from Nova V382 Velorum: II. The super-soft component observed with BeppoSAX | [
"astro-ph"
] | Nova Velorum 1999 (V382 Vel) was observed by BeppoSAX 6 months after optical maximum and was detected as a bright X-ray supersoft source, with a count rate 3.454+-0.002 cts/s in the LECS. It was the softest and most luminous supersoft source observed with this instrument. The flux in the 0.1-0.7 keV range was not constant during the observation. It dropped by a factor of 2 in less than 1.5 hour and then was faint for at least 15 minutes, without significant spectral changes.
The observed spectrum is not well fit with atmospheric models of a hot, hydrogen burning white dwarf. This is due mainly to a supersoft excess in the range 0.1-0.2 keV, but the fit can be significantly improved at higher energy if at least one emission feature is superimposed. We suggest that a ``pseudocontinuum'' was detected, consisting of emission lines in the supersoft X-ray range superimposed on the thermal continuum of a white dwarf atmosphere. As a result, an accurate determination of the effective temperature and gravity of the white dwarf at this post-outburst stage is not possible. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- ?? (1994)
Printed 24 October 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
The X-ray emission from Nova V382 Velorum:
II. The super-soft component observed with BeppoSAX
M. Orio1,2, A. N. Parmar3, J. Greiner,4 H. Ogelman5, S. Starrfield6, E. Trussoni1
1 Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF), Osservatorio Astronomico di Torino, Strada Osservatorio, 20, I-10025 Pino Torinese (TO), Italy
2 Department of Astronomy, 475 N. Charter Str., University of Wisconsin, Madison WI 53706, USA
3 Astrophysics Division, Space Science Dept. of ESA, ESTEC, Postbus 299, 2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands
4 Astrophysical Institut, 14882 Potsdam, An der Sternwarte 16, FRG
5 Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, 1500 University Ave., Madison WI 53706, USA
5 Dept of Physics and Astronomy, P.O. Box 87150, Arizona State University, Tempe AZ 85287-1504, USA
Received; Accepted
ABSTRACT
Nova Velorum 1999 (V382 Vel) was observed by BeppoSAX 6 months after optical
maximum and was detected as a bright X-ray supersoft source, with a count rate
3.454±0.002 cts s−1 in the LECS. It was the softest and most luminous supersoft
source observed with this instrument. The flux in the 0.1 -- 0.7 keV range was not
constant during the observation. It dropped by a factor of 2 in less than 1.5 hour
and then was faint for at least 15 minutes, without significant spectral changes. The
observed spectrum is not well fit with atmospheric models of a hot, hydrogen burning
white dwarf. This is due mainly to a supersoft excess in the range 0.1-0.2 keV, but
the fit can be significantly improved at higher energy if at least one emission feature
is superimposed. We suggest that a "pseudocontinuum" was detected, consisting of
emission lines in the supersoft X-ray range superimposed on the thermal continuum
of a white dwarf atmosphere. As a result, an accurate determination of the effective
temperature and gravity of the white dwarf at this post-outburst stage is not possible.
Key words: Stars: individual: V382 Vel, novae, cataclysmic variables -- Sources as
function of wavelength: X-rays: stars
1
INTRODUCTION
Nova Velorum 1999 (V382 Vel) was the second brightest
nova of the last 50 years (V=2.6) (Seargent & Pearce, 1999).
It was a "fast " O -- Ne -- Mg nova, with v≃4000 km s−1, t2=
6 d, t3=10 d (Della Valle et al. 1999, Shore et al. 1999). The
nova was immediately declared a Target of Opportunity by
the BeppoSAX Mission Scientist.
BeppoSAX carries instruments that cover the energy
range 0.1-300 keV. The instruments used are the coalined
Low-Energy Concentrator Spectrometer (LECS; 0.1 -- 10 keV;
Parmar et al. 1997), the Medium-Energy Concentrator Spec-
trometer (MECS; 1.8 -- 10 keV; Boella et al. 1997), and the
Phoswich Detection System (PDS; 15 -- 300 keV; Frontera et
al. 1991). The LECS and MECS, used in this work, consist
of grazing incidence telescopes with imaging gas scintillation
proportional counters in their focal planes.
Novae in outburst have been observed to emit X-rays
due to thermal emission of shocked ejecta (see Orio et al.
2001a, and references therein). The outburst is normally due
to a radiation pressure driven wind and not to a shock wave,
however shocks can be produced in interacting winds, or in-
teraction between the ejecta and the circumstellar medium.
c(cid:13) 1994 RAS
After a few months, luminous "supersoft" X-ray emission
(luminosity of the order 1037−38 erg s−1) has also been
observed. The previous detections have been attributed to
residual hydrogen burning in a shell on the white dwarf rem-
nant (e.g. Ogelman et al. 1993, Krautter et al. 1996, Orio
& Greiner 1999). We expect to detect in this case an at-
mospheric continuum at Teff =20-80 eV and the absorption
edges of the white dwarf (or even emission edges if the ef-
fective temperature is extremely high).
V382 Vel was observed with BeppoSAX, with ASCA
and RossiXTE two weeks after the outburst (Orio et al.
1999a, Orio et al. 2001b, Mukai & Ishida 1999, 2001) as a
hard X-ray source (with plasma temperature kT≃7 keV).
It cooled rapidly in the first two months after outburst to
kT≃2.4 keV (Mukai & Ishida 2001). In a recent paper (Orio
et al. 2001b; hereafter, Paper I) we attributed the initial X-
ray emission to shocks in the nebula. Since the initially very
large intrinsic absorption of the ejected nebula was thinning
out, the equivalent N(H) decreased rapidly (Mukai & Ishida
2001). Thus, in the second BeppoSAX observation we hoped
to detect the super-soft X-ray emission with the LECS and
derive useful information on the nature of the white dwarf.
2 M. Orio et al.
The peak temperature of the hot white dwarf remnant, and
the absorption edges that indicate the underlying chemical
composition, are extremely important in order to constrain
the physical models. In addition to this, the length of the
constant bolometric luminosity phase is an essential parame-
ter in order to understand whether the nova retains accreted
mass after the outburst and is therefore a candidate type Ia
supernova (or, even, a candidate neutron star formed by ac-
cretion induced collapse).
2 THE SUPERSOFT X-RAY SOURCE
In the second BeppoSAX observation on 1999 November
23, the actual length of the LECS exposure was 12.4 ksec,
over about a total 16 hours in 11 time intervals, lasting for
t≤1200 sec each. The MECS exposure time was 25.9 ksec
during the same 16 hours. The count rate measured with
the LECS was extremely high, 3.4540±0.0021 cts s−1 in the
0.1-4.0 keV range, due to the emergence of supersoft X-ray
emission (Orio et al. 1999b). This high count rate was not
unexpected, and it would be equivalent (assuming for sim-
plicity a blackbody at 40 eV and N(H)=2 × 1021 cm−2)
to ≈50 cts s−1 with the ROSAT PSPC. A count rate of
75 cts s−1 was measured for V1974 Cyg at maximum with
the PSPC (Krautter et al. 1996). In the 0.8-10.0 keV range
the count rate was only 0.1030±0.0038, consistent with the
MECS count rate 0.0454±0.0015 cts s−1 (more than a fac-
tor of 3 lower than in June of 1999). There was no PDS
detection with a 2σ upper limit of 0.080 cts s−1 in the 15-50
keV range. We have already discussed the evolution of the
hard X-ray emission (Paper I). We found that more than one
component was necessary to fit the LECS spectrum, how-
ever we also concluded that there was no component with
a higher plasma temperature than ≃1 keV, that N(H) was
consistent with the interstellar value and that the supersoft
portion of the flux was dominant.
Remarkably, the supersoft X-ray flux (0.1-0.7 keV) was
variable. No significant variability was detected at higher en-
ergy. Overall, there was irregular flickering with time scales
of minutes, and as Fig. 1 shows, in the 9th observation (af-
ter ≈13 hours from the beginning of the exposures) the
background-subtracted count rate decreased dramatically,
by approximately a factor of 2. This low state lasted during
the whole LECS coverage of 15 minutes, spaced about 5000
seconds from two observation in which the average count
rate was twice higher. Close to the end of the ≈16 hours of
intermittent observations, the count rate decreased again in
the few minutes (see bottom panel of Fig. 1). If we missed
other episodes of this type, they must have been shorter
than the 4000 -- 5000 seconds that elapsed between the obser-
vations. One possible explanation for the sudden decrease in
count rate is of course that a dense clump intervened along
the line of sight. However, the spectrum was definitely super-
soft during the whole observation and became slightly softer
during the dip. Instead, the additional absorption of a thick
clump would absorb the softer portion of the spectrum more
and produce an apparently "harder" spectrum.
Is this phenomenon linked with orbital variability?
Given the observed periodicity at optical wavelengths (Bos
et al. 2001) the orbital period of V382 Vel is likely to be 3.5
hours. The time that elapsed between minima in the last
observation span was a little over 3 hours. We folded the
LECS lightcurve with the optical modulation period and
even if ≈70% of the phase was covered, we could not detect
any modulation in supersoft X-ray flux. We also note that
the semi-amplitude of the optical modulation is only 0.02
mag, while the X-ray count rate has a large variation.
The time scale of the phenomenon does not give very
significant upper limits on the size of the obscuring region:
the upper limit on the size of an obscuring clump in the
nebula, assumed to be moving at v=4000 km s−1 for 5000
seconds, is 2 ×1012 cm (a small fraction of the nova shell
radius at this epoch). Assuming instead some other type of
phenomenon, connected with the possible orbital period, an
upper limit on the size is obtained assuming the speed of
light for the obscuring source: 1.5 ×1014 cm.
This variability is a truly puzzling phenomenon which
we do not fully understand. We note that also V1494 Aql (N
Aql 1999 no.2), which was observed with Chandra and also
detected as a supersoft X-ray source, showed time variability
in supersoft X-rays: a flare (with increase of flux by a factor
6) that lasted for about 15 minutes and pulsations every
42 minutes (Starrfield et al. 2001). Even for this nova, the
supersoft X-ray variability time scale was very short.
3 SPECTRAL ANALYSIS AND
INTERPRETATION
In Paper I we made the working hypothesis that the super-
soft flux observed in November 1999 was entirely due to the
central hot white dwarf remnant. Neglecting the LECS flux
below 0.8 keV we simultaneously fitted the LECS and MECS
spectra with a mekal model of thermal plasma (included in
the software package XSPEC, see Arnaud et al. 1986) with
parameters: N(H)≃ 2 × 1021 cm−2, kT≃700 eV, and un-
absorbed flux ≃ 10−12 erg cm−2 s−1 (the reduced χ
2 was
≈1.2). In this work we analyse instead the properties of the
supersoft X ray flux. The spectral distribution observed for
V382 Vel, shown in Fig.2 in the range 0.1-1.1 keV, is strik-
ingly different from the one observed with the BeppoSAX
LECS for three non-nova supersoft X-ray sources: Cal 87
(Parmar et al. 1997), Cal 88 (Parmar et al. 1987) and RX
J0925.7-4758 (Hartmann et al. 1999). The LECS spectra are
shown in Fig. 7 of Hartmann et al. (1999) and Fig. 3 of Par-
mar et al. (1997). V382 Vel is much more luminous than the
other observed sources, it appears to have additional, harder
spectral components and above all it is very luminous also
in the very soft range, 0.1-0.2 keV. It is the only object of
this kind ever studied with the LECS.
We tried to fit the whole LECS and MECS spectra in
the 0.1-10 keV range adding the mekal model used for the
hard flux to a) a blackbody, b) a blackbody with absorption
edges (included in XSPEC), and c) more detailed model at-
mospheres (see Hartmann & Heise 1997, Hartmann et al.
1999). The latter models were used to fit the non-nova su-
persoft X-ray sources and very reasonable results were ob-
tained. We expected that the blackbody would not give a
perfect fit (since white dwarf atmospheres resemble black-
bodies only in first approximation) but we thought that it
would provide an approximate estimate of the luminosity,
of the range of effective temperatures, and indicate whether
absorption edges must be included. Adding absorption edges
c(cid:13) 1994 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- ??
The X-ray emission from Nova V382 Velorum:II. The super-soft component observed with BeppoSAX
3
Table 1. Spectral fit parameters obtained applying two NLTE models with log(g)=8.5 and different abundances (25% the cosmic value,
NLTE-1, and LMC-like depleted, NLTE-2), plus MEKAL and lines, to the BeppoSAX LECS and MECS spectra of Nova Vel observed
in 1999 November. The absorption, N(H), is in units of 1022 atom cm−2. Teff is the WD atmospheric temperature, kT the MEKAL
2, dof the number of
plasma temperature (of the ejecta), Fa is the absorbed flux and Fx the unabsorbed flux, χ
degrees of freedom.
2/dof is the reduced χ
Model
N(H) Teff (×105 K)
kT (keV)
Fa
Fx
2/dof
χ
A: NLTE-1+MEKAL
B: NLTE-1+MEKAL+L(0.449 keV)
C: NLTE-1+MEKAL+L(0.243 keV+0.449 keV
+6.4 keV)
D: NLTE-2+MEKAL
E: NLTE-2+MEKAL+L(0.453 keV)
F: NLTE-2+MEKAL+L(0.491 keV+6.52 keV)
G: NLTE/CNO+MEKAL
H: NLTE/NeOMg+MEKAL
1.38
2.03
2.07
1.56
1.98
1.98
1.68
1.69
5.6
4.0
4.0
5.3
5.2
5.2
4.8
5.0
0.896
0.801
0.836
0.069
0.826
0.813
0.063
0.068
1.6 × 10−9
6.1× 10−6
1.6 × 10−9
1.2 × 10−6
4.53
1.70
1.67
12.66
1.57
1.62
15.81
10.73
dof
105
102
96
122
117
112
106
105
to the black-body (the most likely seemed C vi at 0.49 eV,
but we also tried N vi at 0.55 keV and 0.67 keV, O viii at
0.87 keV) did not improve the fit.
We also found that a reasonable fit to the supersoft por-
tion of the spectrum could not be obtained with any of the
atmospheric models we tested, in Local Thermodynamical
Equilibrium (hereafter, LTE), and in NON-LTE (hereafter,
NLTE), developed by Heise et al. (1994), Hartmann & Heise
(1997) and Hartmann et al. (1999). For the NLTE case, we
tested four small grids of models with log(g) between 8 and
9, with four different set of abundances. The first set had cos-
mic abundances (developed primarily for galactic sources,
hereafter NLTE-1 models), in the second set of abundances
the abundances were depleted to 0.25 the solar value (de-
veloped for LMC sources, here after called NLTE-2 mod-
els), and in the third and fourth group of models the abun-
dances were enhanced in C, N and O and in Ne, O and Mg,
respectively. These models include line opacities. The two
grids with enhanced abundances are still unpublished (Hart-
mann 2002, private communication). With either models in
LTE and NLTE we could not obtain a good fit by, for in-
stance, decreasing log(g) and "tuning" the MEKAL compo-
nent accordingly. In Table 1 we give the best fit parameters
the NON-LTE model atmospheres with log(g)=8.5 and a
MEKAL bremsstrahlung component. The value log(g)=8.5
2, but it is smaller
does not give an acceptable value of χ
than for other values of log(g). The only reason for testing
also the NLTE-2 LMC-type models was that we could not
obtain a reasonable fit with the other available models and
wanted to experiment with all the available grids. We con-
cluded that no model is acceptable: with the best NLTE-1
2=4.5 for 105 de-
model, model A in the Table, we obtain χ
grees of freedom. The fit to the data, shown in the upper
part of Fig. 3, predicts counts at energies higher than 200
eV that differ from those observed by more than 5%, which
is the likely uncertainty in the knowledge of the LECS spec-
tral response. Apart from what can be interpreted as an iron
line at ≈6.5 keV, at low energies (<0.2 keV) the predicted
counts exceed those observed by at least 100% (see Fig.2).
However, the uncertainty in the low-energy LECS response
in this range is estimated not to exceed ≃20% (Parmar et
al. 1997).
In a Chandra HRC-S+LETG observation of V382 Vel
done in 2000 March by one of us, S. Starrfield, the HRC-
c(cid:13) 1994 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- ??
S+LETG spectrum, to be described in detail in a forthcom-
ing paper (Starrfield et al. 2002) is very different from an-
other nova which also appeared as a supersoft X-ray source,
V1494 Aql (N Aql 1999 no.2, see Starrfield et al. 2001).
The main difference is the lack of conspicuous continuum
for V382 Vel in March 2000: it was instead an emission line
spectrum, with many high ionization emission lines in the
supersoft range. These lines presumably have an origin in
the ejected nebula. The BeppoSAX instruments would have
detected a blend of such lines as a featureless "pseudocontin-
uum". Emission lines in the supersoft range may well have
existed even at the earlier epoch of our BeppoSAX obser-
vations. These lines may have been due to shock ionization
in the ejecta, rather than to photoionization by the central
source.
Even if the spectral resolution of the BeppoSAX LECS
and MECS is not sufficient to detect lines, we tried to de-
termine which emission lines may explain the observed X-
ray spectrum and what constraints we could derive on the
level of the continuum. In model C of Table 1 we added not
only the bremsstrahlung continuum at the harder energy
(kT=0.84 keV) and a line at ≈6.5 keV (which is necessary
but is not in the range where the bulk of the flux is emitted),
but also one or more "softer" spectral features in emission.
2=1.6 -- 1.7
As an experiment, we obtained best fits with χ
adding such lines to both NLTE-1 and NLTE-2 models with
log(g)=8.5 (see Table 1). For the NLTE-1 model, in the best
fit the added gaussian feature has to be at 449 keV. It could
probably be C vi (perhaps a blend of the C vi triplet at 27-
28 A). We tried to add additional lines and improved the fit
only marginally, although another emission line at 243 eV
may be present (probably the Fe xv line at 50.5 A), and a
narrow iron line at ≈6.4 keV is needed to explain the excess
at this energy (Model C). This fit is shown in Fig. 3 (lower
panel).
With the NLTE-2 model we obtained model F with
2=1.62 adding a line (perhaps N vi) at ≈490 keV, and
χ
again an iron line for the excess at ≈6.5 keV. The total un-
absorbed flux in the lines in these two models is a negligible
fraction of the total bolometric flux, less than 1%. However,
the flux in the line at ≈450 or 490 keV would be about
30% of the absorbed flux in the BeppoSAX LECS range. In
model C, the bolometric luminosity at a distance of 2 kpc
(Della Valle et al. 1999) is 6.8 × 1038 erg s−1. This value is
4 M. Orio et al.
higher, but not much in excess of the model predictions for
a ≈ 1 M⊙ WD emitting at Eddington luminosity.
The main problem in determining the white dwarf pa-
rameters accurately is the excess at low energy (kT<200
eV), which cannot be fit with one or more narrow lines.
Around 150 eV several transition exist due to Fe, Si, Mg,
and Ni, that could produce an intricate pattern, must be
heavily absorbed, and cannot be resolved with the spec-
tral resolution of the BeppoSAX LECS. By the time this
nova was observed with the Chandra LETG, it had be-
come much less luminous and the spectral structure had def-
initely changed. We only remark that a complicated multi-
temperature structure most likely existed in the ejecta, and
that continuum and emission lines with different origins
(white dwarf for the first and nebular for the latter) can
explain the complicated spectrum we detected with the Bep-
poSAX LECS and MECS. We rule out that our determina-
tion of effective temperature and gravity of the white dwarf
can be accurate if nebular lines overlap with the white dwarf
continuum. It is only clear that at this stage the atmosphere
of the central source was still the dominating component of
the X-ray flux.
4 CONCLUSIONS
The observation of V383 Vel 6 months after the outburst
revealed a very luminous supersoft X-ray source, compara-
ble in luminosity only with V1974 Cyg at maximum. The
details of this observation raise new, unexpected and very
interesting, questions. We observed irregular variability on
a time scale of minutes in the supersoft flux of V382 Vel.
The lack of energy dependence of the variability measured
below 0.7 keV seems to rule out the ejection of an obscur-
ing clump, yet other considerations seems to rule out orbital
variability as well.
Moreover, the BeppoSAX spectrum of V382 Vel
in
November 1999 appears much more complex than the ex-
pected thermal continuum of a hot white dwarf plus a resid-
ual thermal component from the nebula. We cannot justify
this spectrum without invoking emission lines in the super-
soft range (which were indeed observed shortly after this
observation with Chandra), so we suggest that the observed
"supersoft X-ray source" in V382 Vel is characterized by
unresolved narrow emission lines superimposed on the at-
mospheric continuum. We found that even a contribution of
the lines of less than 1% to the total bolometric flux can
significantly change the shape of the stellar continuum, and
make the task of determining white dwarf temperature and
effective gravity impossible with the resolution of the Bep-
poSAX instruments.
However, we conclude that the bulk of the X-ray flux
was still due to the atmospheric continuum and not to lines
at this epoch, unlike in the later observation performed with
the Chandra LETG (Starrfield et al. 2002).
Emission from classical novae in outburst can be quite
complex and different from one nova to another. The X-ray
spectra of N LMC 1995 (Orio & Greiner 1999) and of the
recurrent nova U Sco (Kahabka et al. 1999) could be fit well
with model atmospheres, although U Sco required also a
nebular component at higher energy. We caution however,
that the spectral structure may be as complex as the one
s
/
t
n
u
o
C
s
/
s
t
n
u
o
C
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
46100
46200
46300
46400
46500
46600
46700
46800
46900
47000
Time (seconds from begining of observations)
5
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
57650
57700
57750
57800
57850
57900
Time (seconds from begining of observations)
Figure 1. The LECS lightcurve in the range 0.1-0.7 keV with
time bins of 100 s (top) and the 16 s binned lightcurve during the
third before last (second plot from the top) and the last (bottom)
of the observations done during the 16 hours from beginning to
end of LECS exposure.
observed for Cal 83 by Paerels et al. (2001), when observed
with higher resolution.
The situation was more complex for V1974 Cyg, where
a model atmosphere and a hotter, thermal component were
necessary to fit the spectrum. The relative importance of
the two components seemed to vary in each observation (see
Balman et al. 1998) and the interplay between them was
rather complicated, also due to the lower energy resolution
of the PSPC compared to the LECS (a factor 2.4 less) and
limited energy range of the PSPC (which could not cover
the harder component well, at least at the beginning). We
wonder whether the spectrum of V1974 Cyg also had super-
imposed nebular emission lines that made it appear hotter
than it was, because a lower effective temperature (≤ 20
eV) of the post-nova white dwarf atmosphere may explain
a puzzling fact. An ionization nebula was detected only in
c(cid:13) 1994 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- ??
The X-ray emission from Nova V382 Velorum:II. The super-soft component observed with BeppoSAX
5
different velocity colliding into the initial radiation driven
wind? The nova theory must become more detailed and re-
fined once the X-ray spectrum is known in detail for a sta-
tistically meaningful sample of objects. The gratings in the
new X-ray observatories are opening new and exciting pos-
sibilities for nova studies.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank L. Piro, BeppoSAX Mission Scientist, for support
and W. Hartmann for providing the atmospheric models he
developed. M. Orio is grateful also to another colleague, C.
Markwardt, for computer support and useful advice. Finally,
we thank the referee, Koji Mukai. This research has been
supported by the Italian Space Agency (ASI) and by the
UW College of Letters & Sciences. S. Starrfield gratefully
acknowledges NSF and Chandra support to ASU.
REFERENCES
Arnaud K.A., 1996, In: Astronomical Data Analysis Software Sys-
tems V. ASP Conf. Series 101, G. Jacoby, J Barnes editors,
17
Balman S., Krautter J., Ogelman H., 1998, ApJ, 499, 395
Bearda H., Hartmann W., et al., 2002, preprint, astroph0202333
Boella G., et al., 1997, A&AS, 122, 327
Bos M., Retter A., McCormick J., Velthuis F., 2001, IAU Circ.
7610
Casalegno R. Orio M., et al., 2000, A&A, 361, 725
Della Valle M., Pasquini L., Williams R., 1999, IAU Circ. 7193
Frontera F., et al., 1991, Advances in Space Research, 11, 281
Hartmann H.W., Heise J., 1997, A&A, 322, 591
Hartmann H.W., Heise J., Kahabka P., Motch C., Parmar A.N.,
1999, A&A 125, L346
Heise J., van Teeseling A., Kahabka P., 1994, A&A, 288, L45
Kahabka P., Hartmann H.W., Parmar A.N., Neguerela I., 1999,
A&A, 347, 43
Krautter J., et al., 1996, ApJ, 456, 788
Mukai K., Ishida M., 1999, IAU Circ. 7205
Mukai K., Ishida M., 2001, ApJ, 551, 1024
Ogelman H., Orio M., Krautter J., Starrfield S., 1993, Nature,
361, 331
Orio M., Covington J., Ogelman H., 2001a, A&A, 373, 542
Orio M., Parmar A., Benjamin R., Amati L., Frontera F., Greiner
J., Ogelman H., Mineo T., Starrfield S., Trussoni E., 2001b,
MNRAS, 326, L13O
Orio M., Greiner J. 1999, A&A, 344, L1
Orio M., Parmar A.N., Capalbi M., 1999b, IAU Circ. 7325
Orio M., Torroni V., Ricci R., 1999a, IAU Circ. 7196
Paerels F., et al., 2001, A&A, 365, L308
Parmar A.N., et al., 1997, A&AS, 122, 309
Platais I., et al., 2000, PASP, 112, 224
Seargent D.A.J., Pearce A., 1999, IAU Circ. 7177
Shore S.N., et al., 1999, IAU Circ. 7261
Starrfield S., et al., 2001, AAS, 198, 11.09
Starrfield S., et al., 2002, in preparation
Figure 2. Spectra observed in the 0.1-8 keV range with the
BeppoSAX LECS and MECS in November 1999 and (above)
best fit with model A (MEKAL + NLTE model atmosphere for
log(g)=8.5 and cosmic abundances) and (below) with model C,
which includes also three superimposed emission lines, at 0.243
keV, 0.449 keV and 6.4 keV). The first fit is not acceptable, and
this is due to in a large portion to structured residuals in the range
0.1-0.2 keV. The second fit is overall much better, but the resid-
uals in the soft range are still large. The lower panel in each plot
shows the residuals, as ratio of observed over predicted counts per
energy bin.
Hα for N Cyg 1992 (Casalegno et al. 2000) while other ion-
ization lines (indicating a higher ionization potential) were
not present in the nebula. We speculate therefore that in
V1974 Cyg the white dwarf (Krautter et al. 1996, Balman
et al. 1998) might have been cooler than it appeared by fit-
ting the ROSAT PSPC spectrum with just a two component
model.
We note that even the spectrum of a non-nova super-
soft X-ray source,
the Galactic MR Vel, shows non-
atmospheric emission lines, attributed to a wind from the
source (Bearda et al. 2002). Instead, in classical novae in
outburst emission lines in the soft X-ray range could be pro-
duced by shock ionization within the nebula. Shocked, X-ray
emitting material seems to be present since the beginning
of the outburst (Krautter et al. 1996, Orio et al. 2001b).
The BeppoSAX LECS and the ROSAT PSPC do not re-
solve narrow emission lines. For novae, prominent nebular
emission lines in the supersoft X-ray energy range indicate
interesting possibilities, specially if they should be observed
with Chandra or XMM-Newton in the future. We face new
questions. Are these lines at times due to collisional excita-
tion, do shocks occurs in the nova wind even many months
after the outburst? Should we consider a line driven wind at
c(cid:13) 1994 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- ??
|
0709.1111 | 1 | 0709 | 2007-09-07T17:33:54 | On the oscillations in Mercury's obliquity | [
"astro-ph"
] | One major objective of MESSENGER and BepiColombo spatial missions is to accurately measure Mercury's rotation and its obliquity in order to obtain constraints on internal structure of the planet. Which is the obliquity's dynamical behavior deriving from a complete spin-orbit motion of Mercury simultaneously integrated with planetary interactions? We have used our SONYR model integrating the spin-orbit N-body problem applied to the solar System (Sun and planets). For lack of current accurate observations or ephemerides of Mercury's rotation, and therefore for lack of valid initial conditions for a numerical integration, we have built an original method for finding the libration center of the spin-orbit system and, as a consequence, for avoiding arbitrary amplitudes in librations of the spin-orbit motion as well as in Mercury's obliquity. The method has been carried out in two cases: (1) the spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the 2-body problem case (Sun-Mercury) where an uniform precession of the Keplerian orbital plane is kinematically added at a fixed inclination (S2K case), (2) the spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the N-body problem case (Sun and planets) (Sn case). We find that the remaining amplitude of the oscillations in the Sn case is one order of magnitude larger than in the S2K case, namely 4 versus 0.4 arcseconds (peak-to-peak). The mean obliquity is also larger, namely 1.98 versus 1.80 arcminutes, for a difference of 10.8 arcseconds. These theoretical results are in a good agreement with recent radar observations but it is not excluded that it should be possible to push farther the convergence process by drawing nearer still more precisely to the libration center. | astro-ph | astro-ph | On the oscillations in Mercury's obliquity
E. Bois a and N. Rambaux b,c
aObservatoire de la Cote d'Azur, UMR CNRS Cassiop´ee, B.P. 4229, F-06304
Nice Cedex 4, France
bRoyal Observatory of Belgium, 3 Avenue Circulaire, B-1180 Brussels, Belgium
cDepart. of Mathematics, Facult´es Univ. N.D. de la Paix, 8 Rempart de la Vierge,
B-5000 Namur, Belgium
Email address : [email protected]
Email address : [email protected]
Telephone Number : + 33 [0]4 92 00 30 20 (E. Bois)
Telephone Number : +32 [0]2 373 67 33 (N. Rambaux)
Number of manuscript pages: 30
Number of manuscript tables: 3
Number of manuscript figures: 8
7
0
0
2
p
e
S
7
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
1
1
1
1
.
9
0
7
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
Preprint submitted to Elsevier Science
31 May 2018
Eric Bois
Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur,
UMR CNRS Cassiop´ee,
B.P. 4229, F-06304 Nice Cedex 4, France
Telephone Number : + 33 [0]4 92 00 30 20
Fax Number : + 33 [0]4 92 00 31 18
Email address : [email protected]
Running title: Librations in Mercury's obliquity
2
Abstract
Mercury's capture into the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance can be explained as a result of its
chaotic orbital dynamics. One major objective of MESSENGER and BepiColombo
spatial missions is to accurately measure Mercury's rotation and its obliquity in
order to obtain constraints on internal structure of the planet. Analytical approaches
at the first order level using the Cassini state assumptions give the obliquity constant
or quasi-constant. Which is the obliquity's dynamical behavior deriving from a
complete spin-orbit motion of Mercury simultaneously integrated with planetary
interactions? We have used our SONYR model (acronym of Spin-Orbit N -bodY
Relativistic model) integrating the spin-orbit N -body problem applied to the solar
System (Sun and planets). For lack of current accurate observations or ephemerides
of Mercury's rotation, and therefore for lack of valid initial conditions for a numerical
integration, we have built an original method for finding the libration center of
the spin-orbit system and, as a consequence, for avoiding arbitrary amplitudes in
librations of the spin-orbit motion as well as in Mercury's obliquity. The method has
been carried out in two cases: (1) the spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the 2-body
problem case (Sun-Mercury) where an uniform precession of the Keplerian orbital
plane is kinematically added at a fixed inclination (S2K case), (2) the spin-orbit
motion of Mercury in the N -body problem case (Sun and planets) (Sn case).
We find that the remaining amplitude of the oscillations in the Sn case is one order
of magnitude larger than in the S2K case, namely 4 versus 0.4 arcseconds (peak-to-
peak). The mean obliquity is also larger, namely 1.98 versus 1.80 arcminutes, for
a difference of 10.8 arcseconds. These theoretical results are in a good agreement
with recent radar observations but it is not excluded that it should be possible to
push farther the convergence process by drawing nearer still more precisely to the
libration center. We note that the dynamically driven spin precession, which occurs
when the planetary interactions are included, is more complex than the purely
kinematic case. Nevertheless, in such a N -body problem, we find that the 3:2 spin-
orbit resonance is really combined to a synchronism where the spin and orbit poles
on average precess at the same rate while the orbit inclination and the spin axis
orientation on average decrease at the same rate. As a consequence and whether it
would turn out that there exists an irreducible minimum of the oscillation amplitude,
quasi-periodic oscillations found in Mercury's obliquity should be to geometrically
understood as librations related to these synchronisms that both follow a Cassini
state. Whatever the open question on the minimal amplitude in the obliquity's
oscillations and in spite of the planetary interactions indirectly acting by the solar
torque on Mercury's rotation, Mercury remains therefore in a stable equilibrium
state that proceeds from a 2-body Cassini state.
Key words: Mercury, rotational dynamics, spin-orbit resonance, celestial
mechanics
Email addresses: [email protected] (E. Bois), [email protected] (N.
3
1
Introduction
From radar measurements of the rotation of Mercury obtained by Pettengill
& Dyce (1965), Colombo (1965) showed the non-synchronous rotation of Mer-
cury and its 3:2 spin-orbit state (the rotational and orbital periods are 56.646
and 87.969 days respectively). The stability of the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance de-
pends on a significant orbital eccentricity and the fact that the averaged tidal
torque trying to slow the planet further is considerably less than the maxi-
mum averaged torque acting on the permanent axial asymmetry that causes
the planet spin to librate about the resonant 3:2 value. Moreover, Correia &
Laskar (2004) have shown more recently that Mercury's capture into the 3:2
resonance can be explained as a result of its chaotic orbital dynamics.
The upcoming missions, MESSENGER (Solomon et al. 2001) and BepiCo-
lombo, with onboard instrumentations capable of measuring the rotational
parameters of Mercury (see e.g. Milani et al. 2001), stimulate the objective to
achieve a very accurate theory of Mercury's rotation. One aim of these missions
is to determine the existence or not of a liquid core by measuring accurately
both the rotation and the gravity field of Mercury. The current method for
obtaining constraints on the state and structure of Mercury's core is based
on the assumptions introduced by Peale in 1972 and revisited in 2002 (Peale
et al. 2002). By measuring the amplitude of the 88-day libration in longitude,
called ϕ hereafter, the obliquity ¯η (a constant derived from the Cassini state
assumption for Mercury's rotation and playing the role of a mean obliquity),
and the degree-two gravitational coefficients (2¸0 and 2. 2), it is possible to
determine the radius of the expected fluid core.
Let A, B, and C be the principal moments of inertia of Mercury, Cm the
mantle's moment of inertia, M the mass of Mercury, and R its equatorial
radius. The information on the core size is inferred from the following relation
(Peale et al. 2002) :
(cid:18) Cm
B − A(cid:19)(cid:18)B − A
MR2 (cid:19) MR2
C ! =
Cm
C
≤ 1
(1)
where a ratio of Cm/C equal to 1 should indicate a core firmly coupled to the
mantle and most likely solid. In the other hand, if the interior of Mercury is
partly fluid, the ratio is smaller than 1.
The objective of the rotation parameter measurements consists in restraining
each factor of the expression (1). The first factor is inversely proportional to
the ϕ rotation angle (Peale et al. 2002). The second factor in (1) is equal to
42. 2 while the third factor is related to ¯η by the following relation (Wu et al.
1995) :
MR2
C
=
µ
n
sin (I + ¯η)
sin ¯η [(1 + cos ¯η) G201C22 − (cos ¯η) G210C20]
(2)
Rambaux).
4
2e − 123
where n is the mean orbital motion of Mercury and µ a constant of uniform
precession of the orbit pole. G201 and G210 are the eccentricity functions of
Kaula (Kaula, 1966). G201 = 7
16 e3 represent the first two terms in a series
expansion where e is the eccentricity while G210 = (1 − e2)−
2 . The formula (2)
expresses the Cassini state of Mercury (Colombo 1966; Peale 1969) where I is
the inclination of the orbit pole of Mercury relative to the Laplace plane pole
around which the orbit pole precesses at an uniform rate. Let us recall that in
a Cassini state, the orbital and rotational parameters are indeed matched in
such a way that the spin pole, the orbit pole, and the Laplacian pole remain
coplanar while the spin and orbital poles on average precess at the same rate.
3
Table 1 is here
The rotational motion of Mercury is mainly characterized by a 3:2 spin-orbit
resonance and a spin-orbit synchronism where axes of precession cones, spin
and orbital, on average precess at the same rate. In the 2-body problem (Sun
and Mercury), by using the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance and a few corollary ap-
proximations in the classic Euler equations of the 3-D rotational motion of
Mercury disturbed by the solar torque, one may get two characteristic fre-
quencies, namely the one in longitude Φ, which is solution of the third Eule-
rian equation and the other in latitude of the body Ψ, which is solution of the
two first Eulerian equations. A Hamiltonian approach of the rotational mo-
tion of Mercury has been expanded by D'Hoedt & Lemaıtre (2004). The two
resulting frequencies Φ and Ψ, usually called proper frequencies, calculated by
this analytical approach and those obtained with our SONYR model are in a
good agreement (see Table 1). By the present paper, we have also improved
the internal accuracy of our values (see Table 1).
Table 2 is here
Let us call η the instantaneous obliquity of Mercury, defined as the angle bet-
ween Mercury's Oz spin axis and the normal to its orbital plane; let < η >
be its mean value. Until the Radar observations recently obtained by Margot
et al. (2006), 1 the value of Mercury's mean obliquity was not truly constrai-
ned by measurements; many values were available in literature from zero to 7
arcminutes (amin hereafter). On the one hand, from the formula (2) computed
with realistic Mercury's parameters, ¯η can not be equal to zero. On the other
hand, 7 amin given by Wu et al. (1995) seemed too high for Mercury. In our
previous paper (Rambaux & Bois 2004), using (2) we have estimated a range
of ¯η from 1.33 to 2.65 amin (for I ∈ [5, 10] deg, e ∈ [0.11, 0.24], with µ = 2π/Π
and n = 2π/Pλ where values of the Π orbital precession period and the Pλ
orbital period are given in Table 2). However by using our SONYR model
including the full spin-orbit motion of Mercury, for the plausible values of
1 published at the very time when we are finishing the revised paper.
5
parameters we had chosen, the mean value of η is close to 1.66 amin. In the
present paper, by improving our method, we give a more relevant value for
< η > that proves to be in a very good agreement with the observations.
We obtain the dynamical behavior of the hermean obliquity by the way of the
following relation :
cos η = cos i cos θ + sin i sin θ cos(Ω − ψ)
(3)
where the spin-orbit variables are computed with SONYR. i and Ω are respec-
tively the inclination and the longitude of the ascending node of Mercury's
orbital plane relative to the ecliptic plane. The angles ψ and θ are the preces-
sion and nutation angles of the Eulerian sequence 3-1-3, while the third angle
ϕ is called the proper rotation. This angular sequence is used to describe the
evolution of the body-fixed axis system Oxyz (centered on the Mercury's cen-
ter of mass) relative to a local reference system, dynamically non-rotating but
locally transported with the translational motion of the body. Let OX1Y1Z1 be
the local reference system for the Mercury's rotation (see complete definitions
of reference systems in Section 3).
In our previous work as well as in the present one, using our SONYR model,
we have numerically integrated the complete equations of the N -body problem
(8 planets and the Sun) including the full spin-orbit motion of Mercury. More
precisely, in our previous paper (Rambaux & Bois 2004), we presented (i) an
accurate theory of Mercury's spin-orbit motion, (ii) the proper frequencies
related to the spin-orbit resonance, (iii) an analysis of main librations, and
(iv) a first attempt for characterizing the dynamical behavior of Mercury's
obliquity. The present paper is wholly devoted to stress and highlight the
fourth point.
For lack of current accurate observations or ephemerides of Mercury's rotation,
and therefore for lack of valid initial conditions for a numerical integration, we
have built an original method for finding the libration center of the spin-orbit
system and as a consequence for avoiding arbitrary amplitudes in librations of
the spin-orbit motion as well as in Mercury's obliquity. Initial conditions of the
rotational and orbital modes have indeed to be consistent between themselves
with respect to a same spin-orbit reference system. As a consequence, using
the SONYR model, the method requires in a first step to build mean initial
conditions verifying geometrical conditions of a Cassini state for Mercury,
that is to say a spin-orbit equilibrium state. In a second step, these mean
initial conditions are fitted in order to place the spin-orbit system at its center
of libration. The method has been carried out in two cases: (1) the spin-
orbit motion of Mercury in the 2-body problem case (Sun-Mercury) where an
uniform precession of the Keplerian orbital plane is kinematically added at a
fixed inclination, (2) the spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the N-body problem
(Sun and planets). With the spin-orbit system located at its center of libration
in both cases above, the reference system of the first case is put at the average
of perturbations of the second case. As a consequence, we make not only in
6
evidence the strict dynamical behavior of Mercury's obliquity in both cases
but may compare the respective oscillations.
Our theoretical results are in a good agreement with recent radar observa-
tions. However, it is not excluded that it should be possible to push farther the
convergence process by drawing nearer still better to the libration center. In
the present framework, we note that the dynamically driven spin precession,
which occurs when the planetary interactions are included, is geometrically
more complex than the purely kinematic case. In particular, we highlight that
in the full spin-orbit motion of Mercury, the asynchronous rotation of the
planet is really combined with a synchronism in precession variables as well
as a second one between secular changes of the orbit inclination and the spin
axis orientation. As a consequence and supposing that it could exist an irre-
ducible minimum of the oscillation amplitude, we show how the quasi-periodic
oscillations found in Mercury's obliquity could be geometrically understood.
We discuss briefly the question to know whether the minimal amplitude has
to theoretically be of zero value or not. In the meantime of such a forthcoming
work, we describe Mercury's rotation and the resulting equilibrium state that
proceeds from a 2-body Cassini state.
2 The Spin-Orbit N -bodY Relativistic model
For obtaining the real motion of Mercury, we have used our model of solar
System integration including the coupled spin-orbit motion of the Moon. This
model (built by Bois, Journet, & Vokrouhlick´y and called BJV), expanded
in a relativistic framework, had been previously built in accordance with the
requirements of the Lunar Laser Ranging observational accuracy (Bois 2000;
Bois & Vokrouhlick´y 1995). We extended the BJV model by generalizing the
Moon's spin-orbit coupling to the other terrestrial planets (Mercury, Venus,
the Earth, and Mars). The model is at present called SONYR (acronym of
Spin-Orbit N -BodY Relativistic model). As a consequence, the SONYR model
gives an accurate simultaneous integration of the spin-orbit motion of Mer-
cury. The approach of the BJV and SONYR models consists in integrating the
N -body problem (including translational and rotational motions) on the basis
of the gravitation description given by the general relativity. The equations
have been developed in the DSX formalism presented in a series of papers by
Damour, Soffel, & Xu (1991, 1992, 1993). For purposes of celestial mechanics,
to our knowledge, it is the most suitable formulation of the post-Newtonian
(PN) theory of motion for a system of N arbitrary extended, weakly self-
gravitating, rotating and deformable bodies in mutual interactions. The DSX
formalism, derived from the first PN approximation level, includes then the
translational motions of the bodies as well as their rotational motions with
respect to locally transported frames with the bodies. To each body is then
associated a local reference system, centered on its center of mass and dynam-
ically non-rotating. These local reference systems are freely falling in the local
7
gravity field (the Sun) and are referred to a global reference system O′X ′Y ′Z ′
for the complete N-body problem.
A description of the SONYR model is given in our previous paper (Rambaux
& Bois 2004). The principle of the model allows the analysis of Mercury's spin-
orbit motion and the identification of internal mechanisms such as the direct
and indirect planetary interactions. In addition, it gives also the interrelations
between the parameters involved in Mercury's dynamical figure and the planet
librations.
3 Reference systems and their relations
O′X ′Y ′Z ′ is centered on the Solar System barycenter, the O′X ′Y ′ plane is
parallel to the J2000 ecliptic plane. The X ′-axis is oriented to the equinox
J2000. Let OXY be the mean orbital plane of Mercury and OZ the mean
orbital pole. Let us call P the instantaneous orbital plane of Mercury. The
rotational motion of Mercury is evaluated from a body-fixed coordinate axis
system Oxyz centered on Mercury's center of mass relative to a local dy-
namically non-rotating reference system, OX1Y1Z1. The Ox, Oy, Oz axes are
defined by the three principal axes of inertia a, b, and c of the planet according
to the best fitting ellipsoid such as a > b > c. The corresponding principal
moments of inertia are then ordered as follows : A < B < C. We used the
Euler angles ψ, θ, ϕ related to the 3-1-3 angular sequence (3 represents a ro-
tation around a Z-axis and 1, around an X-axis) to describe the evolution of
the body-fixed axes Oxyz with respect to axes of the local reference system
OX1Y1Z1. These angles are defined as follows : ψ is the precession angle of the
Oz polar axis around the OZ1 reference axis, θ is the nutation angle represent-
ing the inclination of Oz with respect to OZ1, and ϕ is the rotation around
Oz and conventionally understood as the rotation of the largest rotational
energy. This angle is generally called the proper rotation. The Oz principal
axis around which is applied the proper rotation is called the axis of figure
and defines the North pole of the rotation (Bois 1995). The proper rotation ϕ
is around the smallest axis of inertia; it is called hereafter the spin angle and
Oz the spin axis.
Figure 1 is here
In SONYR, building up the reference frames from the reference systems is re-
lated to the choice of the reference frames transported by the initial conditions
(IC hereafter). This is of practical use when we have valid IC (for instance
coming from ephemerides or derived from observations). In such conditions,
the local reference frame for the rotation of a planet may be the one of the
ephemeris. It is not actually the case for Mercury. True IC of Mercury's ro-
tation are unknown (with respect to any reference system). Moreover, ad hoc
attempts for determining instantaneous IC of the rotation produce a shift with
8
those of the orbit and therefore a shift of the libration center of the spin-orbit
resonance. Inconsistency between rotation's and orbit's IC drives necessarily
to arbitrary amplitudes and phases in the spin-orbit librations. As a conse-
quence, we have built (in Section 4) mean initial conditions (MIC hereafter)
coming from geometrical conditions of the mean spin-orbit motion of Mercury.
The latter is related to (i) the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance in cyclic variables (ϕ
and λ such as < dϕ/dt > = (3n/2) + < dω/dt >), (ii) the synchronism in
precession variables (ψ and Ω), and (iii) a second synchronism in nutation
and inclination variables (θ and i) (see Rambaux & Bois 2004). In a second
step of the method (Section 5), the MIC are accurately corrected by taking
into account a fit between the central axis of the precession cone described by
the spin pole and the theoretical axis of reference. For these final MIC, the
spin-orbit system is at its center of libration (Γ hereafter) without arbitrary
amplitudes. Moreover, we consider two cases :
(1) The spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the 2-body problem framework (Sun-
Mercury) where a uniform precession, which we denote by Π, of the Keplerian
orbital plane is kinematically added at a fixed inclination IK with respect to
OX ′Y ′. Let us call S2K this construction bearing the geometrical Cassini state.
Let us call PK the associated orbital plane (a Keplerian plane in this case),
and LK the fixed plane of reference OX ′Y ′ (LK plays the role of a Laplace
plane for PK) (see Fig. 1).
(2) The spin-orbit motion of Mercury in the N-body problem framework (Sun
and planets). Let us call Sn this case. Let us call Pn the associated mean orbital
plane of Mercury. The instantaneous orbital plane P has an instantaneous
inclination i relative to OX ′Y ′ while the inclination of Pn is < i >. Let us
include the S2K construction into Sn by putting PK on Pn. As a consequence,
IK = < i >. Over short periods, Pn remains equivalent to PK. The associated
Laplace plane Ln is an instantaneous plane which follows the oscillations of P
so that i remains quasi-constant relative to Ln. LK coıncides with the average
of the oscillations of Ln, i.e. < Ln > ≡ LK (see Fig. 1).
Our construction of reference systems verifies in the end the three following
relations :
Pn ≡ PK < i > ≡ IK < Ln > ≡ LK
(4)
which permit to accurately evaluate the obliquity's oscillations (i) not only
with respect to the center of libration of the full spin-orbit motion of Mer-
cury, but (ii) with respect to the included Cassini state. In other words, our
construction is such as the mean Cassini state of the full spin-orbit motion
of Mercury, on a given interval of time, coıncides with an exact Cassini state
derived from the 2-body problem.
Let us add that local dynamically non-rotating frames show in general relativ-
ity a slow (de Sitter) rotation with respect to the kinematically non-rotating
frames. As a consequence, the OX1Y1Z1 local reference frame for Mercury's
rotation is affected by a slow precession of its axes transported with the trans-
lational motion of Mercury. In the Earth's case, the de Sitter secular preces-
9
sion of the Earth reference frame is close to 1.9"/cy (see Fukushima 1991;
Bizouard et al. 1992; Bois & Vokrouhlick´y 1995). Consequently, the real rota-
tion of Mercury has not to be expressed in an inertial system fixed in space,
but in a local dynamically non-rotating frame fallen down in the gravitational
field of the Sun. However, in the framework of the present paper where only
Newtonian-like terms of SONYR are activated, OX1Y1Z1 remains parallel to
OX ′Y ′Z ′.
4 Building the mean initial conditions
For lack of accurate observations or ephemerides of Mercury's rotation, and
therefore for lack of valid IC for a numerical integration of the full spin-orbit
motion of Mercury, a method is required for: (i) fitting the different parameters
or constants involved in the spin-orbit of Mercury so that the SONYR model
be self-consistent; (ii) removing arbitrary amplitudes in librations of Mercury's
spin-orbit motion and therefore in its obliquity. In this section, we present the
construction of MIC related to the spin-orbit coupling of Mercury.
(1) We start from the geometry of the spin-orbit coupling problem defined in
Goldreich & Peale (1966): the spin axis of Mercury is considered normal to
its orbital plane and the orbit is assumed to be fixed and unvarying. At this
level, for expressing these assumptions, as well as that the long axis is pointed
toward the Sun at a perihelion position t0, analytical relations giving the
corresponding set of initial conditions, namely C0, can be written as follows :
(C0)
ψ0 = Ω0
θ0 = I
ϕ0 = ω0 + 3
2M0
dt!0
dψ
= 0 dθ
dt!0
= 0
dϕ
dt!0
=
3
2
n
where ω0 is the mean argument of periastron, and M0 the mean anomaly with
Ω0 = ω0 = M0 = 0 at t = t0. For such a Mercury's spin-orbit coupling based
on a 2-body problem (with the asphericity factor α = q3(B − A)/C = 0.0187
and the eccentricity e = 0.206), we have plotted a Poincar´e section in Rambaux
& Bois (2004, Fig. 2), making in evidence the quasi-periodic librations around
the 3:2 rotation state.
(2) In the S2K framework, the condition of the precession synchronism drives
to the geometrical property < dψ/dt > = 2π/Π where Π is the constant of
uniform precession. The principle of our method requires to obtain the value of
Π from the Sn case such as 2π/Π = < dΩ/dt >. In the same way, the value of
I = IK is obtained from the Sn case such as IK = < i >, and as a consequence
the value of I is taken equal to < i > since the S2K case. The mean initial
10
conditions C2K for the S2K case are then written as follows :
(C2K)
ψ0 = Ω0
θ0 = I = IK
ϕ0 = ω0 + 3
2M0
dψ
dt !0
=
2π
Π
dθ
dt!0
= 0
dϕ
dt!0
=
3
2
n
with Ω0, ω0, and M0 equal to zero at t = t0.
(3) In the Sn framework, the orbit precession of the rotating body is dy-
namically generated by the planetary interactions but its rate is nonuniform.
However, 2π/Π has been rightly defined as < dΩ/dt >. Moreover, the 3:2 spin-
orbit resonance in the Sn case involves the condition dϕ/dt = (2π/Λ) + (3n/2)
where Λ is obtained such as 2π/Λ = < dω/dt >. In addition, as shown further,
θ and i on average change at the same rate. This expresses a proximity to a
Cassini state, which involves a third geometrical condition for building MIC,
namely < dθ/dt > = < di/dt > = 2π/Θ. The mean initial conditions Cn for
the Sn case are then written as follows :
(Cn)
ψ0 = Ω0
θ0 = < i >
ϕ0 = ω0 + 3
2M0
dt !0
dψ
=
2π
Π
dθ
dt!0
=
2π
Θ
dϕ
dt!0
=
2π
Λ
+
3
2
n
with Ω0, ω0, and M0 equal to zero at t = t0.
The dynamical behaviors of θ and i have the same slopes (see Fig. 2, top
panel). As a consequence, secular parts of θ and i decrease at the same rate
equal to Θ. Although it is a question of a N-body problem, the spin keeps its
proximity to a Cassini state during the slow change in i. But with this signature
of the proximity to the Cassini state made in evidence in the Sn framework,
< dθ/dt > = < di/dt > may be understood as a second synchronism between
the respective inclinations of the orbit and the spin axis relative to a same
reference system (OX ′Y ′Z ′). As a matter of fact we find that ξ = θ −i librates
and rightly according to the Ψ proper frequency in latitude (see Fig. 2, bottom
panel).
Figure 2 is here
5 Fitting the mean initial conditions
Let us call hereafter SONYR(Si, Ci) the integration of SONYR in the mode
Si with the initial conditions Ci. Let us note that under the assumptions of
the present paper, SONYR(Si, Ci) is a conservative dynamical system. Let S
be the Oz spin pole of Mercury. S describes a large cone with oscillations
of polhodie; the projection of the cone in the OX ′Y ′ reference plane gives a
11
large quasi-circle of center A (with oscillations). Due to slightly heterogeneous
initial spin-orbit positions, A does not exactly coıncide with the projection of
OZ ′. By setting the latter in A, the system is placed at its Γ libration center.
This can be achieved by slightly moving OX ′Y ′Z ′ or in SONYR by fitting a
little bit the MIC. But because of large periods of precession, building and
fitting the large circles is a very heavy computational process. Nevertheless,
the reference frame that satisfies the whole system in Γ is the one where all
librations (related to small and large cones of precession) are at their respective
right centers of libration. As a consequence, we have determined equations
expressing the departure from Γ within smaller circles of libration. Let us note
SX " and SY " the coordinates of S projected onto a reference plane OX"Y "
rotating with the uniform motions Π and Θ; they are written as follows :
SX " = sin [ψ − ( 2π
SY " = − cos [ψ − ( 2π
Π )t] sin [θ − ( 2π
Θ )t]
Π )t] sin [θ − ( 2π
Θ )t]
(5)
where 2π/Θ = 0 in the S2K case. For each mode of SONYR (S2K and Sn),
S describes a small precession cone. Figure 3 gives the motion of S in the
mode SONYR(S2K, C2K). Let us call Oζ the central axis of the small cone of
precession whose coordinates are (ζ1, ζ2) in OX"Y ".
Figure 3 is here
The fitting equations are then written as follows :
SX " = ζ1
SY " = ζ2
After substitutions in orbital elements alone, the system (6) becomes :
(6)
(7)
IK + δIK = arcsin (qζ 2
Ω0 + δΩ0 = arctan (−ζ1/ζ2)
1 + ζ 2
2 )
where one gets δIK and δΩ0 as functions of IK, Ω0, ζ1, and ζ2. In the mode
SONYR(S2K, C2K), we obtain then the two following fitted initial conditions :
ψ0 = Ω0 + δΩ0
θ0 = IK + δIK
(8)
C2K becomes C ′
2K and one gets on the same graphic frame as previously a
little circle (like a point at this scale, see Fig. 4). The little circle expresses
a considerable decreasing of the degree of opening of the cone by the above
process.
Figure 4 is here
12
The same principle is applied to the Sn case with an analogous result. Taking
into account in Cn (becoming C ′
n) the two fitted initial conditions ψ0 and θ0
coming from (8) according to the same process, Figure 5 shows the significant
decreasing of the degree of opening of the precession cone.
Figure 5 is here
Table 3 is here
6 The resulting obliquities
In the S2K mode, computations of η give resulting obliquities before and after
fitting the MIC at the libration center Γ, as shown in Figure 6a. Figure 6b
shows a zoom of the obliquity purged of arbitrary amplitudes after the fit-
ting process. However, η appears not constant but quasi-constant. In the S2K
mode indeed, i.e. without planetary interactions, due to the gravitational so-
lar torque acting on the dynamical figure of Mercury with three unequal axes
of inertia, the equations of the rotational motion solely form a non-integrable
system whose regular solutions are quasi-periodic librations. As a consequence,
the η obliquity that depends on θ and ψ (see formula (3) while i = IK and
Ω = Ω0 + (2π/Π)t where IK, Ω0 and Π are constant values) follows in part
this behavior. Nevertheless, with such faint amplitudes (peak-to-peak 0.4 arc-
seconds, 'as' hereafter), the obliquity may be reported quasi-constant in the
S2K case, which is usually characteristic of a Cassini state derived from the
2-body problem (see Fig. 6b). After removing the amplitude of the high fre-
quency fluctuations (a modulation of a beat frequency with a period of 295
years whose peak-to-peak amplitude varies between a maximum near 0.28 as
and a minimum near 0.14 as), the peak-to-peak amplitude of the resulting
long period modulation of 1066.4 years is only 0.12 as.
Figure 6 is here
In the same way, in the Sn mode, computations of η give resulting obliquities,
before and after the fitting process, as shown in Figure 7a. Figure 7b shows
a zoom of the obliquity after the fitting process and then purged of arbitrary
amplitudes. In both modes, S2K and Sn, the period of the main oscillation is
Ψ, namely the second proper frequency of the resonance. A frequency analysis
gives 1066.81 years in the Sn case and 1066.44 years in the S2K one, let be a
difference lesser than 0.4 years. In the Sn case, after removing the amplitude
of the high frequency fluctuations (about 0.6 as), the peak-to-peak amplitude
of the resulting long period modulation of 1066.8 years is 3.4 as.
Figure 7 is here
13
Both sets of results, from S2K and Sn cases are globally consistent with those
of Peale (2006) and implicitly with those of Yseboodt & Margot (2006). We
note that the dynamically driven spin precession, which occurs when the plan-
etary interactions are included, is geometrically more complex than the purely
kinematic case. We find that the 3:2 spin-orbit resonance is not only combined
with a first synchronism where the spin and orbit poles on average precess at
the same rate but also with a second one where the rotational nutation desi-
gnated by θ and the i orbit inclination on average decrease at the same rate
(see Fig. 2 where is shown the libration of ξ = θ − i within the Ψ period).
These two synchronisms reflect the proximity to the Cassini state and their
signatures express its conserving in the N-body problem case. Besides, the
conceptual question to know whether the ultimate minimal amplitude could
be of zero value or not is discussed further. However, regardless of that, inside
the present numerical process, the amplitudes in the Sn case are related to
a spin-orbit coupling. As shown below with the equation (9), it is about an
indirect effect due to the solar torque, bearing the planetary interactions, and
acting on the planet's rotation.
Reference frames of the S2K and Sn cases being linked by the conditions (4)
(see Fig. 1) and values of the free constants required for SONYR(S2K, C2K)
being determined from SONYR(Sn, Cn), SONYR(S2K, C2K) has been built
at the heart of SONYR(Sn, Cn) in such a way the quasi-periodic solution
of SONYR(Sn, Cn) surrounds the vicinity of the quasi-periodic solution of
SONYR(S2K, C2K). Arbitrary amplitudes are not only avoided in the oscilla-
tions of η, but a direct comparison of η coming from Sn with η coming from S2K
is possible, which makes in evidence the effect of the planetary interactions.
In the Sn mode indeed, the gravitational solar torque, bearing the planetary
interactions and acting on the dynamical figure of Mercury, induces more size-
able librations related to the disturbed Euler angles as well as the variables
i and Ω. At this phase of analysis, the obliquity can be no longer said quasi-
constant. The oscillation amplitude of period Ψ is indeed equal to 4 as (total
peak-to-peak amplitude), let be one order of magnitude larger than in the
S2K case (or 28 times larger when comparing the peak-to-peak amplitudes
of the strict Ψ modulation without high frequency fluctuations) (see Fig. 6b
and Fig. 7b). The comparison of the S2K and Sn modes, respectively derived
from the 2-body and N-body problems, both computed and plotted at their
respective libration centers Γ, shows how Mercury's obliquity and its dynami-
cal behavior are modified when the planetary interactions are fully introduced
(see Fig. 8). The mean obliquity is larger as well as the oscillation amplitude.
< η > = 1.98 amin in the Sn case while < η > = 1.80 amin in the S2K case.
This spin-orbit mechanism is rightly an indirect effect due to the solar torque,
bearing the orbital planetary interactions and acting on Mercury's rotation,
as shown by the classic general equation of the rotational motion of a solid
celestial body (Bois 1995) :
14
∂[(I)ωωω]
∂t
+ ωωω × [(I)ωωω] = (cid:18)3Gm
r(cid:19)3
a3 (cid:19)(cid:18)a
uuu × (I) uuu
(9)
where ωωω is the instantaneous rotational vector of Mercury and (I) its tensor
of inertia. The right hand side of the equation represents the second degree
torque exerted by a point mass m (the Sun) of position ruuu with respect to
the body (Mercury) when it is reduced to three oblateness coefficients. a is
the mean distance between the two bodies while r is the instantaneous one.
ruuu is solution of the N-body problem in SONYR(Sn). Let us note that the
direct planetary torques are about two orders of magnitude smaller than the
indirect effects acting by the solar torque.
Figure 8 is here
Due to the planetary interactions, Mercury's orbit is no longer Keplerian and
rate of precession of Mercury's orbital plane is no longer uniform. As a conse-
quence, the obliquity's dynamical behavior is no longer quasi-constant. More
generally, it is not possible for the obliquities to be constant since the orbit
precession occurs at non-uniform rates (Bills 2005). In the case of Mercury,
according to Bills & Comstock (2005), if the orbit pole precession rate were
uniform, dissipation would have driven Mercury into a Cassini state, in which
the spin pole and orbit pole remain coplanar with the Laplace pole, as the
spin pole precesses about the moving orbit pole. However, according to these
authors and in accordance with our results, due to the nonuniform orbit pre-
cession rate with several distinct modes of oscillation, this simple coplanar
configuration is no longer globally maintained.
7 Discussion
We have significantly reduced amplitudes of the oscillations in Mercury's obli-
quity, which were exposed to discussion since a previous paper (Rambaux &
Bois 2004). For doing that, we have built an original method for finding the
libration center of the spin-orbit system and as a consequence for avoiding ar-
bitrary amplitudes in librations of the spin-orbit motion as well as in Mercury's
obliquity. We have converged and the amplitudes are in very good agreement
with most recent observations (Radar observations by Margot et al. 2006).
This validates not only our theoretical SONYR model applied to Mercury but
also our method of convergence.
Our centering method has converged but it is not excluded that it may re-
main a residual amplitude of arbitrary oscillations. It ought to be possible to
push farther the convergence process by drawing nearer yet more precisely
to the libration center (in the framework of the paper, i.e. in a conservative
dynamical system). Since our amplitudes are compatible with current observa-
tions, we have concluded that this question could wait for MESSENGER and
15
BepiColombo data in order to directly fit the SONYR model to observations.
Nevertheless, apart from values of residual amplitudes, it remains a conceptual
question. Does there exist a theoretical possibility to reach a pure point of
equilibrium where the oscillation amplitude would be absolutely of zero value
or, on the contrary, does there exist an irreducible minimum, even very small
but of non-zero value? In the Sn case, existence of distant resonances of high
orders that would excite the 3:2 resonance is not excluded a priori. None
mathematical theorem does deny it but the demonstration of this would take
us along to a purely mathematical ground. Consequently, we will say that the
question remains open (both in conservative and dissipative cases). However,
we plane some further works in this connection. The occurrence of a perfect or
rigid equilibrium without oscillations seems to us unlikely for natural systems.
8 Conclusion
Using our SONYR model of the solar System including the spin-orbit cou-
plings of Earth-like planets, and setting the system at its libration center in
order to eliminate arbitrary amplitudes (at the internal accuracy level of the
model), we have obtained the complete obliquity for the full spin-orbit mo-
tion of Mercury. Our construction of reference systems permits to accurately
evaluate the obliquity's oscillations (i) not only with respect to the libration
center of the full spin-orbit motion of Mercury (Sn), (ii) but also with respect
to a Cassini state derived from the 2-body problem (S2K). The construction
is such as the exact Cassini state derived from S2K coıncides with the mean
Cassini state of Sn on a given interval of time. We have obtained (1) a mean
value of Mercury's obliquity that is in a very good agreement with very recent
observations (Radar observations by Margot et al. 2006), namely 1.98 amin
with SONYR for 2.1 ± 0.1 amin by observations, (2) amplitudes of oscillations
in Mercury's obliquity of the order of 2 as, which is compatible with the results
of these observations where the deviation with respect to the 2-body Cassini
state is constrained lesser than 6 as. These observational data validate not
only our theoretical prediction with the SONYR model applied to Mercury
but also our method of convergence for finding a libration center in a complex
spin-orbit system.
Being dependent on the question of existence of an irreducible minimum in the
oscillation amplitude, we find that the equilibrium state of Mercury computed
in the framework of a conservative N-body system squares to a quasi-periodic
oscillation without secular drifts. In other words, in spite of the planetary
interactions indirectly acting by the solar torque on Mercury's rotation, Mer-
cury remains in a stable equilibrium state that proceeds from a 2-body Cassini
state.
Besides, by the way of our method, we have made in evidence the richness of a
dynamical precession related to planetary interactions (N-body problem) rel-
ative to a purely kinematical orbit precession added to a 2-body problem (Sun
16
and Mercury). Whatever the open question on the minimal amplitude in the
obliquity's oscillations, the approach of the 2-body Cassini state is necessarily
limited to reach a constant or quasi-constant behavior of Mercury's obliquity
(where moreover < η > = 1.80 amin versus 1.98 amin, for a difference of
10.8 as). The planetary interactions generate a forced dynamical precession
of Mercury's orbital plane with a nonuniform rate. This precession is kine-
matically taken into account in the conventional construction of a Mercury's
Cassini state as well as in our S2K case. But in the Sn case, due to the first
synchronism where the spin and orbit poles on average precess at the same
rate (as well as the second one where the spin axis orientation, namely the
θ nutation, and the orbit inclination i on average change at the same rate),
the difference angle between these two poles, i.e. η, (and θ − i as well) li-
brates necessarily. As a consequence and whether it would turn out that there
exists an irreducible minimum of the oscillation amplitude, so these resulting
quasi-periodic oscillations in the obliquity ought to be understood as librations
related to these two synchronisms where the (ψ − Ω) and (θ − i) respective
differences librate (according to the Ψ proper frequency in latitude). In the
same way, in multi-planet systems, when the longitudes of periapse on average
precess at the same rate, the difference angle between the two apsidal lines
librates (see e.g. Lee & Peale 2003 or Bois et al. 2003). Under this assumption
and according to the obtained dynamical behavior, the obliquity of Mercury
should be characterized by a quasi-periodic oscillation according to the period
Ψ, with an amplitude Aη and a mean obliquity < η >, in such a way that
Mercury's obliquity η could be written as follows (in first approximation) :
η = < η > +Aη cos(cid:18) 2π
Ψ
t + α(cid:19)
(10)
where α is a phase factor.
In the end, for lack of current and accurate observations or ephemerides of
n) set up at the libration center
Mercury's rotation, but with SONYR(Sn, C ′
of Mercury's spin-orbit motion, we may conclude that our method is relevant
to link physical causes and their respective effects. As a consequence, with
accurate observations of Mercury's rotational motion, that should be being
achieved by MESSENGER and BepiColombo, SONYR(Sn, C ′
n), and not a 2-
2K), ought to be fitted to these
body Cassini state model as SONYR(S2K, C ′
observations.
Acknowledgments The authors thank the anonymous referee and Bruce Bills
for their constructive requirements. NR acknowledges the ROB and FUNDP
for their fellowship supports.
References
[1] Bills, B.G., 2005, Free and forced obliquities of the Galilean satellites of Jupiter,
Icarus 175, 233
17
[2] Bills, B.G. & Comstock, R.L., 2005, Forced obliquity variations of Mercury,
Journal of Geophysical research 110, 1
[3] Bizouard, C., Schastok, J., Soffel, M., Souchay, J., 1992, in : N. Capitaine (ed.),
Journ´ees 1992 : Syst`emes de r´ef´erence spatio-temporels, Observatoire de Paris, 76
[4] Bois, E., 1995, Proposed Terminology for a General Classification of Rotational
Swing Motions of the Celestial Solid Bodies, A&A 296, 850
[5] Bois, E., 2000, Knowledge of the lunar librations at the Lunar Laser Ranging
experiment epoch, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, t. 1, S´erie IV, 809
[6] Bois, E., & Vokrouhlick´y, D., 1995, Relativistic spin effects in the Earth-Moon
system, A&A 300, 559
[7] Bois, E., Kiseleva-Eggleton, L., Rambaux, N., & Pilat-Lohinger, E., 2003,
Conditions of Dynamical Stability for the HD 160691 Planetary System,
Astrophysical Journal 598, 1312
[8] Lee, M.H., & Peale, S., 2003, Secular Evolution of Hierarchical Planetary
Systems., 2003, Astrophysical Journal 592, 1201
[9] Colombo, G., 1965, Rotational period of the planet Mercury, Nature 208, 575
[10] Colombo, G., 1966, Cassini's second and third laws, AJ 71, 891
[11] Correia, A., & Laskar, J., 2004, Mercury's capture into the 3/2 spin-orbit
resonance as a result of its chaotic dynamics, Nature 429, 848
[12] Damour, T., Soffel, M., & Xu, Ch. 1991, General-relativistic celestial mechanics.
I. Method and definition of reference systems, Phys. Rev. D 43, N. 10, 3273
[13] Damour, T., Soffel, M., & Xu, Ch. 1992, General-relativistic celestial mechanics.
II. Translational equations of motion, Phys. Rev. D 45, N. 4, 1017
[14] Damour, T., Soffel, M., & Xu, Ch. 1993, General-relativistic celestial mechanics.
III. Rotational equations of motion, Phys. Rev. D 47, N. 8, 3124
[15] D'Hoedt, S., & Lemaıtre, A., 2004, The spin-orbit resonant rotation of Mercury:
a two degree of freedom Hamiltonian model, Celest. Mech. and Dyn. Astron. 89,
267
[16] Fukushima, T., 1991, Geodesic nutation, A&A 244, L11
[17] Goldreich, P., & Peale, S., 1966, Spin-orbit coupling in the solar system, AJ 71,
N. 6, 425
[18] Kaula, W.M., 1966, Theory of Satellite Geodesy; Applications of Satellites to
Geodesy, Blaisdell, Waltham, MA
[19] Laskar, J., & Robutel, P., 1993, The chaotic obliquity of the planets, Nature
361, 608
18
[20] Margot, J.-L., Peale, S.J., Slade, M.A., Jurgens, R.F., & Holin, I., 2006,
Obervational proof that Mercury occupies a Cassini state, AAS, DPS Meeting
#38, #49.05
[21] Milani, A., Vokrouhlick´y, D., & Bonanno, C., 2001, Gravity field and rotation
state of Mercury from the BepiColombo Radio Science Experiments, Planet. Space
Sci. 49, 1579
[22] Moons, M., 1982, Analytical theory of the libration of the moon, Moon and
the Planets 27, 257
[23] Peale, S.J., 1969, Generalized cassini's laws, AJ 74, 483
[24] Peale, S.J., 1972, Determination of parameters related to the interior of
Mercury, Icarus 17, 168
[25] Peale, S.J., 2006, The proximity of Mercury's spin to Cassini state 1 from
adiabatic invariance, Icarus 181, 338
[26] Peale, S.J., Phillips, R.J., Solomon, S.C., Smith, D.E., & Zuber, M.T., 2002, A
procedure for determining the nature of Mercury's core, Meteo. and Planet. Sci.
37, 1269
[27] Pettengill, G.H., & Dyce R.B., 1965, A Radar determination of the rotation of
the planet Mercury, Nature 206, 1240
[28] Rambaux, N., & Bois, E., 2004, Theory of the Mercury's spin-orbit motion and
analysis of its main librations, A&A 413, 381
[29] Solomon, S.C., 20 colleagues, 2001, The MESSENGER mission to Mercury:
scientific objectives and implementation, Planet. Space Sci. 49, 1445
[30] Wu, X., Bender, P.L., & Rosborough, G.W., 1995, Probing the interior structure
of Mercury from an orbiter plus single lander, Planet. Space Sci. 45, 15
[31] Yseboodt, M., & Margot, J.L., 2006, Evolution of Mercury's obliquity, Icarus
181, 327
19
Proper Frequencies
Φ (years)
Ψ (years)
Rambaux & Bois 2004
D'Hoedt & Lemaıtre 2004
15.847
15.857
1066
1066.68
This paper
15.824 ± 0.024
1066.8 ± 0.4
Table 1
Proper frequencies related to the spin-orbit motion of Mercury (in longitude: Φ, in
latitude: Ψ). Comparaison of results.
20
Basic periods
Pϕ (rotation period)
Pλ (orbital period)
=
=
58.646 days
87.969 days
Π (orbital precession) = 279 000 years
Table 2
Basic periods of the spin-orbit motion of Mercury (Rambaux & Bois 2004)
21
S2K
Sn
δΩ0 (amin)
0.0
-6.564
δIK (amin)
-1.806
-1.823
Table 3
Numerical values of δΩ0 and δIK in the S2K and Sn cases.
22
Fig. 1. Planes of reference of the S2K and Sn cases linked by the conditions (4) (see
Section 3).
23
)
g
e
d
(
i
,
θ
)
n
i
m
a
(
ξ
7.04
7
6.96
6.92
6.88
1.84
1.82
1.8
1.78
1.76
1.74
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
Fig. 2. Second synchronism of the spin-orbit motion of Mercury. θ and i are plotted
in the top panel over 1600 years. The difference ξ = θ − i plotted on the bottom
panel librates within the proper frequency in latitude, namely Ψ = 1066.8 years.
Degrees (top panel) and arcminutes (bottom panel) are on the respective vertical
axes. Years are on both horizontal axes.
24
"
Y
S
-0.122
-0.1222
-0.1224
-0.1226
-0.1228
-0.123
-0.0006 -0.0004 -0.0002
0.0002 0.0004 0.0006
0
SX"
Fig. 3. Projection of Mercury's spin pole S in mode SONYR(S2K , C2K ) on the
OX"Y " plane (i.e. rotating with Π).
25
(1)
(2)
"
Y
S
-0.122
-0.1222
-0.1224
-0.1226
-0.1228
-0.123
-0.0006 -0.0004 -0.0002
0.0002 0.0004 0.0006
0
SX"
Fig. 4. Projection of Mercury's spin pole S on the OX"Y " plane. The large
circle (1) obtained in mode SONYR(S2K , C2K ) is the one of Fig. 3. In mode
SONYR(S2K , C ′
2K ), it is a broadly reduced circle (2).
26
-0.1218
-0.122
-0.1222
-0.1224
-0.1226
-0.1228
-0.123
"
Y
S
(1)
(2)
-0.1232
-0.001 -0.0008 -0.0006 -0.0004 -0.0002
0
0.0002 0.0004
SX"
Fig. 5. Projection of Mercury's spin pole S on the OX"Y " plane. The large circle
(1) is obtained in mode SONYR(Sn, Cn) whereas the broadly reduced circle (2) in
mode SONYR(Sn, C ′
n).
27
)
n
i
m
a
(
η
)
n
i
m
a
(
η
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
(a)
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
1.808
1.807
1.806
1.805
1.804
1.803
1.802
1.801
T (years)
(b)
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
Fig. 6. (a) Resulting obliquities by SONYR(S2K, C2K ) and SONYR(S2K, C ′
2K ).
(b) Zoom of η in the SONYR(S2K, C ′
2K) case, i.e. without arbitrary amplitudes. η
is characterized by a main oscillation according to the second proper frequency Ψ
within a peak-to-peak amplitude lesser than 0.4 as. In both panels, arcminutes are
on the vertical axes and years on the horizontal ones.
28
)
n
i
m
a
(
η
)
n
i
m
a
(
η
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
2.01
2
1.99
1.98
1.97
1.96
1.95
1.94
1.93
(a)
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
(b)
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
Fig. 7. (a) Resulting obliquities by SONYR(Sn, Cn) and SONYR(Sn, C ′
n). (b) Zoom
of η in the SONYR(Sn, C ′
n) case, i.e. without arbitrary amplitudes. η is charac-
terized by a clear oscillation according to the second proper frequency Ψ while the
peak-to-peak amplitude is near 4 as. Arcminutes are on the vertical axes and years
on the horizontal ones.
29
)
n
i
m
a
(
η
2.05
2
1.95
1.9
1.85
1.8
0
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
T (years)
Fig. 8. Comparison of the obliquity's dynamical behavior in SONYR(Sn, C ′
n) and
SONYR(S2K, C ′
2K ) modes, i.e. with and without planetary interactions, both com-
puted and plotted at their respective libration center Γ. < η > = 1.98 amin in the
Sn case while < η > = 1.80 amin in the S2K case.
30
|
0811.2902 | 1 | 0811 | 2008-11-18T14:03:32 | Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center | [
"astro-ph"
] | We use the Spitzer IRAC catalogue of the Galactic Center (GC) point sources (Ramirez et al. 2008) and combine it with new isochrones (Marigo et al. 2008) to derive extinctions based on photometry of red giants and asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars. This new extinction map extends to much higher values of Av than previoulsy available. Our new extinction map of the GC region covers 2.0 x 1.4 degree (280 x 200 pc at a distance of 8 kpc). We apply it to deredden the LPVs found by Glass et al. (2001) near the GC. We make period-magnitude diagrams and compare them to those from other regions of different metallicity.
The Glass-LPVs follow well-defined period-luminosity relations (PL) in the IRAC filter bands at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 micron. The period-luminosity relations are similar to those in the Large Magellanic Cloud, suggesting that the PL relation in the IRAC bands is universal. We use ISOGAL data to derive mass-loss rates and find for the Glass-LPV sample some correlation between mass-loss and pulsation period, as expected theoretically.The GC has an excess of high luminosity and long period LPVs compared to the Bulge, which supports previous suggestions that it contains a younger stellar population. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. paperastroph
August 10, 2018
c(cid:13) ESO 2018
Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the
Galactic Center
M. Schultheis1,2, K. Sellgren3, S. Ram´ırez4, S. Stolovy5, S. Ganesh6, I.S. Glass7, and L. Girardi8
8
0
0
2
v
o
N
8
1
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
2
0
9
2
.
1
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
1 Observatoire de Besanc¸on, 41bis, avenue de l'Observatoire, F-25000 Besanc¸on, France
2 Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, CNRS, 98bis Bd Arago, F-75014 Paris, France
e-mail: [email protected]
3 Astronomy Department, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
4 IPAC, Caltech, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
5 Spitzer Science Center, Caltech, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
e-mail: [email protected]
6 Physical Research Laboratory, Astronomy & Astrophysics Division, Ahmedabad, India
e-mail: [email protected]
7 South African Astronomical Observatory, PO Box 9, Observatory 7935, South Africa
8 Osservatorio di Padua, Italy
received:??; accepted ??
ABSTRACT
Aims. To derive a new map of the interstellar extinction near the Galactic Center (GC) extending to much higher values of AV than
previously available. To use the results obtained to better characterise the long-period variable star population of the region.
Methods. We take the Spitzer IRAC catalogue of GC point sources (Ram´ırez et al. 2008) and combine it with new isochrones (Marigo
et al. 2008) to derive extinctions based on photometry of red giants and asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars. We apply it to deredden
the LPVs found by Glass et al. (2001) (Glass-LPVs) near the GC. We make period-magnitude diagrams and compare them to those
from other regions of different metallicity.
Results. Our new extinction map of the GC region covers 2.0 o × 1.4 o (280 × 200 pc at a distance of 8 kpc). The Glass-LPVs follow
well-defined period-luminosity relations (PL) in the IRAC filter bands at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 µm. The period-luminosity relations are
similar to those in the Large Magellanic Cloud, suggesting that the PL relation in the IRAC bands is universal. We use ISOGAL data
to derive mass-loss rates and find for the Glass-LPV sample some correlation between mass-loss and pulsation period, as expected
theoretically. Theoretical isochrones for a grid of different metallicities and ages are able to reproduce this relation. The GC has
an excess of high luminosity and long period LPVs compared to the Bulge, which supports previous suggestions that it contains a
younger stellar population.
Key words. ISM: dust, extinction -- Galaxy: stellar content -- Infrared: stars
1. Introduction
The variable stars of the Galactic Center (GC) region are of
great interest, both as population and distance indicators. Long-
period, large-amplitude variables situated on the asymptotic gi-
ant branch (AGB), comprising Miras and OH/IR stars, are the
easiest objects to detect thanks to their high luminosities. Thus,
they are one of the few stellar populations that can be observed
in their entirety towards the GC. As is well-known, in the inner-
most parts of the Galaxy, surveys are hampered by high inter-
stellar extinction (e.g. Frogel et al. 1999; Schultheis et al. 1999);
observations must therefore be carried out in the infrared where
Aλ can be as low as 0.04 AV for 4µm < λ < 8µm (Indebetouw
et al 2005). Sensitive surveys at the latter wavelengths have only
recently become possible thanks to the Spitzer satellite.
For these reasons, Glass et al. (2001) conducted a K-band
(2.2 µm) survey for variable stars covering 24 × 24 arcmin2 (56
× 56 pc at a distance of 8 kpc) and centered on the GC in a
study spanning 4 years. The majority of the variable sources they
Send offprint requests to: M. Schultheis
found were, as expected, Miras and OH/IR stars with periods
ranging from 150 d to about 800 d. Uncertainty as to the fore-
ground extinction unfortunately precluded any detailed compar-
ison of their luminosities with similar populations in other well-
studied areas, such as the the solar neighbourhood, the Baade's
Windows and the Magellanic Clouds, where period-luminosity
relations have been determined.
The inner Galaxy has also been searched intensively in the
radio region for OH sources (see e.g. Lindqvist et al. 1992,
Sjouwerman et al. 1996, Wood et al. 1998, Blommaert et al.
1998, Vanhollebeke et al. 2006). From these surveys, it is clear
that a number of the large amplitude variables remained unde-
tected in the Near-infrared, owing to the extremely high extinc-
tion in some regions. Nevertheless, from OH and SiO observa-
tions, (see e.g. Messineo 2004 and Deguchi et al. 2008) radial
velocities are available for many of these sources, making them
extremely valuable for studies of stellar kinematics near the GC.
Because the large-amplitude variables have very high mass-
loss rates they also play an important role in the chemical evo-
2
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
lution of the Galaxy. It is therefore desirable that they should be
characterised as fully as possible.
Previous studies in the near-IR using 2MASS or DENIS data
have yielded extinction maps with a typical resolution of several
arcmin (see e.g. Schultheis et al. 1999, Marshall et al. 2006).
These maps, however, were limited by the sensitivities of the
near-IR surveys and are only realistic in regions where AV is
less than 25 magnitudes. Unfortunately, this limit is generally
exceeded towards the GC.
In this paper we show that an improved map of the inter-
stellar extinction around the GC can be made by fitting mid-
IR data on AGB/RGB stars obtained by the IRAC camera on
Spitzer to isochrones (see also Ganesh et al., in preparation).
Extinctions have been determined for much more heavily ob-
scured areas than was possible previously, especially towards
the GC itself. We apply the new extinction values to a discus-
sion of the long-period variables in the region, concentrating on
the period-magnitude relations that they obey in the IRAC bands
and their mass-loss rates.
2. The data set
2.1. The Spitzer IRAC Point Source Catalog of the Galactic
Center (GALCEN)
The central 2.0 o × 1.4 o of the GC have been mapped with
Spitzer/IRAC between 3.6 and 8.0 µm (Stolovy et al. 2006 and
Stolovy et al. 2008, in preparation). Ram´ırez et al. (2008) per-
formed point-source extraction on the IRAC data and published
a confusion-limited catalogue of point sources that also included
photometry from 2MASS. The IRAC magnitudes are referred
to as [3.6], [4.5], [5.8] and [8.0], corresponding to their central
wavelengths. The average confusion limits are 12.4, 12.1, 11.7
and 11.2 magnitudes, respectively, but can vary by 2 or 3 mag-
nitudes within the survey. The whole catalogue (referred to here
as GALCEN, see Ram´ırez et al. 2008 for more details) consists
in total of about one million sources. Most of these show the
characteristics of red giants or AGB stars, but there are several
hundreds of extremely red sources which may be massive Young
Stellar Objects (YSOs). A major problem that must be faced
in the study of the LPV component is the bright-star limit of
the IRAC camera. According to the Spitzer Observer's Manual
(Version 7.1), saturation starts at 7.9, 7.4, 4.8 and 4.8 magni-
tudes respectively. Saturated sources are however retained in the
GALCEN catalogue but if a flux is greater than the limit it is
flagged with the number '3' (see Ram´ırez et al. 2008 for a more
detailed discussion). We have excluded photometry with flux
flag values of 3 from our analysis.
IRAC
by
the
processed
reduction and source
2.2. GALCEN vs GLIMPSE-II
GALCEN
Recently,
observations
have
been
independently
the GLIMPSE-II
http://www.astro.wisc.edu/sirtf/docs.html).
team
(see
Different data
extraction proce-
dures from those of the GALCEN survey were used (see
http://www.astro.wisc.edu/glimpse and Benjamin et al. 2003).
These data were kindly made available to us in advance of pub-
lication by the GLIMPSE-II team. As discussed in the online
document, they found systematic offsets between the GALCEN
and GLIMPSE-II photometry that was larger than the combined
uncertainty in both observations, at the bright and faint ends of
the observed range. To look for any possible systematic effects
on our work we have also calculated the extinction maps that
we discuss in Sect. 3 using the GLIMPSE-II results. We find
that the differences in the values of the extinctions derived
from GALCEN and from GLIMPSE-II are smaller than the
uncertainties in the determinations.
The locations of the LPVs in the IRAC colour-colour dia-
grams, the IRAC colour-magnitude diagrams, and the period-
luminosity relations (see Sections 4 -- 5) also differ slightly
between the GALCEN and GLIMPSE-II photometry. The
GALCEN and GLIMPSE-II photometry differ by ∼0.05 mag
in the mean, with a standard deviation of 0.12 mag, over the
brightness range of the LPVs. We find no statistically signifi-
cant dependence of the difference between the GALCEN and
GLIMPSE-II photometry on magnitude, or on the periods of the
LPVs (which can be regarded as a proxy for their de-reddened
magnitudes). The scatter in this difference, however, is large and
we conservatively place a limit of 0.2 mag on any possible varia-
tion in its value over the brightness range occupied by the LPVs.
Our conclusions in this paper are, however, unaffected by photo-
metric uncertainties at this level.
2.3. Long-Period Variables
The Glass et al. (2001) survey covered an area of 24 × 24
arcmin2 around the GC, as mentioned, and found about 400 pe-
riodic variables with Mira-like amplitudes and an average pe-
riod of 427 d. (Among these are 64 OH/IR stars included in the
Wood et al. 1998 sample). We refer to the survey list hereafter as
the Glass-LPV catalogue. Compared to the well-explored SgrI
Baade's window of low extinction which lies at l = −1.4◦ and
b = −2.6◦, the GC field contains more than ten times the number
of variables per arcmin2. The average period in the SgrI field is
much lower, at 333 d. Due to the limited photometric precision
of the Glass et al. (2001) survey, small amplitude variables such
as semi-regulars were not detected.
2.4. ISOGAL observations
The details of the ISOGAL observational procedure with
ISOCAM (Cesarsky et al. 1996) and the general processing of
the data are described in Schuller et al. (2003). In this paper we
will discuss only the ISOGAL FC−00027 − 00006 field (here-
after called FC−027), centered at (l, b) = (−0.27◦,−0.06◦). It
was observed with the narrow filters LW5 (6.5 -- 7.1 µm) and LW9
(13.9 -- 15.9 µm), using 3(cid:48)(cid:48) × 3(cid:48)(cid:48) pixels, in order to avoid sat-
uration. More specific details about this field can be found in
Schuller et al. (2006). The parts of the region closest to the GC
itself could not be observed by ISOGAL due to saturation prob-
lems even when the narrow-band filters were used. Nevertheless,
25% of the Glass-LPV area is overlapped by the ISOGAL survey
at 7 and 15 µm, mainly towards the south-western corner.
2.5. Cross-identifications
Cross-identification of stellar catalogues in these extremely
crowded regions, which are often confusion limited, is a very
difficult issue. In order to minimize spurious associations we
used the following method when comparing the different cata-
logues mentioned above. We first calculated the offsets of the
400 brightest sources between a given pair of catalogues and
determined the second-order distortion matrix. Following appli-
cation of the offset and distortion corrections, we made the sub-
sequent cross-identifications using a search radius of 2 arcsec:
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
3
Fig. 1. Upper panel: Interstellar extinction map of the central 280 × 200 pc of the Galactic Center with spatial resolution 2(cid:48), derived
using 2MASS J − Ks data. Lower panel: As above, except using the [3.6]−[5.8] colour-magnitude data for point sources from the
Ram´ırez et al. (2008) GC catalogue.
-- First, we cross-identified the LPVs of Glass et al. (2001)
with the GALCEN catalogue. By limiting the GALCEN cat-
alogue to the area covered by the Glass-LPV survey, it was
reduced to a total of 46314 sources. Of the 421 LPVs, 410
were found in the GALCEN list (97%). Many of them are,
however, saturated, especially at [3.6] and [4.5]. (From the
Glass-LPV sample there were 162, 178, 36, and 58 saturated
sources at [3.6], [4.5], [5.8], and [8.0], respectively).
-- Second, we cross-identified the Glass-LPV catalogue with
ISOGAL. We found 183 matches, despite the small overlap.
010203040501.0000.5000.000359.500359.0000.8000.6000.4000.2000.000-0.200-0.400-0.600-0.800-1.000Galactic longitudeGalactic latitudeAv(2MASS)010203040501.0000.5000.000359.500359.0001.0000.8000.6000.4000.2000.000-0.200-0.400-0.600-0.800Galactic longitudeGalactic latitudeAv(IRAC) 4
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
3. Interstellar extinction
3.1. Derivation of the extinction values
As stated, interstellar extinction remains a serious obstacle to the
interpretation of stellar populations in the GC region.
The present work follows the method of Ganesh et al. (in
preparation) who recently mapped the extinction towards the
inner Bulge with a spatial resolution of 2(cid:48). GLIMPSE-II and
2MASS data are compared to the latest isochrones for evolved
stars (Marigo et al. 2008) in order to derive AV. Several studies
of this type, using only the 2MASS data, have been undertaken
before (e.g. Schultheis et al. 1999, Marshall et al. 2006).
In the method of Ganesh et al, colour-magnitude diagrams
are constructed within sampling boxes of 2(cid:48) square and the
amount by which each individual data point has to be de-
reddened for it to fall on the isochrone is determined. The ex-
tinction values for AV > 20 are derived using the [3.6]−[5.8]
colour, while 2MASS J and Ks data are used for AV < 20.
With the large number of filter combinations available (three
from 2MASS and four from GLIMPSE-II) several possible com-
binations had to be considered. The [5.8] vs. [3.6]−[5.8] colour-
magnitude diagram was selected since it was found to yield the
smallest dispersion, i.e. the [3.6]−[5.8] colour excess was found
to be the most suitable one for determining the interstellar ex-
tinction (see e.g. Indebetouw et al. 2005). This pair of filters has,
in fact, the advantage of simultaneous observations (the other
two IRAC colours were observed at different times) and also has
better completeness (more stars detected through high extinc-
tion). Further, at 3.6 µm and 5.8 µm, the observed flux is dom-
inated by stellar photospheric emission while at 8.0 µm inter-
stellar PAH emission becomes prominent. The models indicate
that metallicity effects are negligible in the [3.6]−[5.8] colour, in
contrast to J − Ks, where the RGB/AGB branch of a metal-rich
stellar population shifts to redder J − Ks colours (Schultheis et
al. 2004). For more detailed information see Ganesh et al. (in
preparation).
In the following, we took the GALCEN catalogue of
Ram´ırez et al. (2008) and limited ourselves to stars with [3.6]
< 12.5 and [5.8] < 12. We have also excluded sources with
[3.6] -- [4.5] > 0.8 and [5.8] -- [8.0] > 0.5 from our extinction cal-
culation, because sources with these colors are typical of YSOs
(see Allen et al. 2004) and the inclusion of their extreme col-
ors would bias the results. We again chose a sampling box of
2(cid:48) square in order to get a sufficient numbers of stars for the
isochrone fitting. For each sampling box the average extinction
value was taken.
The values of Aλ/AV that we use to make the extinction maps
were derived by using the infrared colour-colour diagram J − Ks
vs. Ks−[IRAC] as proposed by Jiang et al. (2003), Indebetouw
et al. (2005) and Ganesh et al. (2008). We used the J − Ks vs.
Ks−[3.6] and the J−Ks vs. Ks−[5.8] diagrams to determine A[3.6]
and A[5.8]. We assumed that most of the sources are luminous
RGB stars or AGB stars with moderate mass-loss and similar in-
trinsic colours. We further adopted the values AJ = 0.256 × AV
= 0.089× AV as used by Schultheis et al. (1999). Fitting
and AKS
straight lines in these diagrams gives us the following values:
A[3.6]/AV = 0.0498 ± 0.0015 and A[5.8]/AV = 0.0308 ± 0.0015.
These values were determined using the whole GALCEN cat-
alog. Ganesh et al. (2008) will discuss more in detail how the
extinction coefficients vary with different line of sights using the
whole GLIMPSE-II dat set. Our A[3.6]/AV value agrees within
the errors with those from Indebetouw et al. (2005), Lutz (1999),
Flaherty et al. (2007) and Rom´an-Z´uniga et al. 2007, while our
derived A[5.8]/AV is a litte bit lower, but still lies inside the errors
of the quoted authors.
Lutz et al. (1996) and Lutz (1999) measured a flat mid-IR
extinction curve towards the GC. However Flaherty et al. (2007)
and Rom´an-Z´uniga et al. 2007 have shown that extinction coeffi-
cents may vary somewhat depending in which line of sight one is
looking (e.g. especially towards star forming regions). Recently,
Chapman et al. (2008) have also studied the mid-infrared extinc-
tion law in three molecular clouds and found that as the over-
all extinction increases, the curve flattens out. The coefficients
evidently vary according to whether the dust is located in the
general ISM or in dense molecular clouds.
Figure 1 shows the AV map derived from the 2MASS filters
(upper panel) and that from the IRAC [3.6] and [5.8] filters of
GALCEN (lower panel). There is a great similarity in the overall
distribution of the two extinction maps. Where 2MASS gives
lower limits for the extinction or is unable to probe the extinction
due to lack of sources, the GALCEN extinction map exhibits
high values for the extinction (AV > 40). Within Figure 1 there
are regions of low extinction according to the 2MASS data but
which are seen to have very high extinction when looked at by
IRAC (e.g. the region around l = 0.2 o and b = −0.5 o). These
areas are mostly associated with infrared dark clouds. 2MASS
gives artificially low values of extinction in such cases because it
detects only those stars located in front of the dark cloud whereas
IRAC penetrates to much greater depth.
Fig. 2. Extinction values derived from 2MASS compared to
those derived from IRAC colours. The straight line gives the
identity relation. The dotted line indicates the maximum value
of AV to which 2MASS is sensitive.
Since the [3.6] -- [5.8] colour is less than J -- KS , for a given
amount of reddening the precision it yields in AV is not as high.
The loss of accuracy at low AV can, however, be avoided by us-
ing the near-infrared derived values for mapping when they are
available. At larger AV, the results from the [3.6] and [5.8] map
are, of course, to be preferred.
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
5
Fig. 3. [5.8] vs. [3.6]−[5.8] colour-magnitude diagrams towards regions of low (left panel), intermediate (middle panel) and high
(right panel) extinction (see text) in the GALCEN survey. The corresponding isochrones are displayed. The horizontal dotted line
indicates the approximate confusion limit. The corresponding fields (from left to right) are α = 265.93596 o, δ = -28.44771 o; α =
266.16275 o, δ = -28.44771 o; and α = 267.027222 o, δ = -28.967888 o. The size of each field is 2(cid:48). The region with AV = 70m is
located at α =267.027222 o and δ = -28.967888 o and is associated with the infrared dark cloud IRDN3 of Dutra & Bica (2001) who
list it as an opaque region at Ks with an angular diameter of 3(cid:48).
Different ages or metallicities for the Bulge population do
not significantly affect the mid-infrared colours of RGB stars,
as will be seen. The sequences in the sampling fields are well
defined in the case of low extinction while there is some scat-
ter when it is high. This scatter arises from variable extinction
on small scales within the Bulge and along the line of sight.
Towards regions with very high extinction (AV > 60), the num-
ber densities in the CMD can drop significantly due to the loss
of the fainter stars. Such points have relatively large errors.
Figure 2 compares the extinction values derived from J and
Ks 2MASS data and those derived from the [3.6] − [5.8] IRAC
colours. There is a tendency towards a linear relation between
AV(2MASS) and AV(IRAC) up to AV = 20 with a dispersion of
AV (cid:39) 3. For higher AV values, 2MASS can no longer detect the
most reddened stars at the GC and is biased towards less red-
dened foreground stars. For those regions where 2MASS gives
low AV values and IRAC high ones, different optical depths are
obtained. The values of AV derived from J − Ks are representa-
tive of the foreground population rather than the regions hidden
by high extinction, while the IRAC bands relate to stars that are
deeper within the clouds.
Figure 3 shows the CMDs towards three regions of different
extinction in the GALCEN survey. While for the low extinction
field (left panel) the red giant branch is well defined and the dis-
persion is low, the CMD is more scattered in the high extinction
regions. Despite the high extinction, however, we get a sufficient
number of sources to determine AV.
3.2. The combined extinction map
Figure 4 shows the combined extinction (2MASS and IRAC)
map as well as an intrinsic uncertainty map derived from the
isochrone fitting. As explained before, for AV(IRAC) < 20 the
2MASS J − Ks colour was used, while for AV(IRAC) > 20 the
IRAC [3.6]−[5.8] colour was used. The highest AV values we
can detect correspond to about AV (cid:39) 90. These are mostly asso-
ciated with clouds that are dark even in the infrared.
We will provide in electronic form (at CDS) the three extinc-
tion maps as well as the error map in the form of individual FITS
files.
3.3. The uncertainty map
The intrinsic uncertainty map corresponding to the combined
interstellar extinction map is shown in Fig. 4 (lower panel).
The uncertainty map is calculated as the standard deviation of
the AV distribution. For AV < 20 the intrinsic uncertainty is
about 2-3 mag while for AV > 20 it can go up to 6-7 mag.
Figure 5 shows the comparison between our AV determinations
based on GALCEN and on the GLIMPSE-II catalogue (see also
Sect. 2.2). Despite the differences found in the photometry be-
tween these two pipelines, no systematic offset is found between
AV derived from GALCEN and AV derived from GLIMPSE-
II. The typical r.m.s standard deviation between GALCEN and
GLIMPSE-II is 6 mag in AV which is the overall uncertainty in
the derived extinction map. For very high AV (AV > 40), the
differences between GALCEN and GLIMPSE become larger.
Howver, for those regions the CMD is less well defined and the
intrinsic uncertainty increases (see Fig. 4).
It should be noted that Nishiyama et al. (2006) found that
the behaviour of near-IR extinction varies slightly though signif-
icantly from one direction to another near the GC so that there is
no universally valid extinction law for the region. These results
were confirmed by Bandyopadhyay et al. (2008). Variations with
direction of Aλ/AV in the IRAC bands do not appear to be sig-
nificant at the accuracy that is currently available, at least in the
6
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
Fig. 4. Upper panel: Combined interstellar extinction map of the central 280 × 200 pc of the Galactic Center. For AV(IRAC) < 20
the 2MASS J − Ks colour was used, while for AV(IRAC) > 20 the IRAC [3.6]−[5.8] colour was used. Lower panel: Intrinsic error
map of the combined interstellar extinction map. The error is the sigma of the AV distribution.
fields studied by Indebetouw et al (2005) and Ganesh et al. (in
prepration).
Gosling et al. (2006) found complex small-scale structure in
the infrared extinction towards the GC, with a typical size of 5 --
15(cid:48)(cid:48), corresponding to 0.2 -- 0.6 pc. They demonstrated that sig-
nificant granularity appears to be present in high and variable
extinction fields, indicating that extinction at J and H may have
significantly higher values on smaller scales than those previ-
ously derived for the GC as a whole.
4. The Long Period Variables near the Galactic
Center
In the remainder of this work we discuss the long-period vari-
ables of the Galactic Center region. Figure 7 shows the 2MASS
image of the GC region at KS . The known LPVs of Glass et
al. (2001) are superimposed and are bright in KS . We note that
patchy and filamentary dark clouds (appearing white in Fig. 7)
often vary on size scales smaller than the 2(cid:48)sampling boxes used
010203040501.0000.5000.000359.500359.0001.0000.8000.6000.4000.2000.000-0.200-0.400-0.600-0.800Galactic longitudeGalactic latitudeAv(Combined)01234561.0000.5000.000359.500359.0001.0000.8000.6000.4000.2000.000-0.200-0.400-0.600-0.800Galactic longitudeGalactic latitudeError(IRAC) Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
7
Fig. 5. Extinction values derived from GALCEN compared to
those derived from GLIMPSE-II. The straight line gives the
identity relation.
here to calculate the extinction. This can contribute to the pho-
tometric errors in the extinction correction towards individual
sources.
4.1. Stellar isochrones
The newest set of isochrones for the RGB/AGB phase include
an improved treatment of the thermally pulsing asymptotic giant
branch (TP-AGB) phase (Marigo et al. 2008). These isochrones
predict realistic tracks for the TP-AGB, taking into account
mass-loss and pulsation. The whole of TP-AGB evolution is now
treated in a realistic way, especially the crucial effects of the third
dredge-up, hot bottom burning and variable molecular opacities.
The dust models incorporated in these isochrones are an ex-
tension of the work by Groenewegen (2006). They have been
calculated with a 1-dimensional dust radiative transfer code that
solves the radiative transfer equation and the thermal balance
equation in a self-consistent way.
The main physical inputs to the model are the luminosity,
distance, photospheric spectrum, mass-loss rate, dust-to-gas ra-
tio, expansion velocity, dust condensation temperature and com-
position of the dust. For oxygen-rich stars two main species of
dust are considered: aluminium oxide (Al2O3) and silicate dust.
Blommaert et al. (2006) studied the CVF ISOCAM spectra of a
sample of AGB stars with low mass-loss in the Galactic bulge
and found that the dust content is dominated by Al2O3 grains.
Isochrones for different metallicities, Z=0.008, Z=0.019 and
Z=0.038, and ages between 0.5 and 10 Gyr, have been calculated
for the Spitzer IRAC filters. In the present work, we consider the
isochrones placed at the distance to the GC (8.0 kpc, Reid 1993).
Fig. 6. ([3.6] − [8.0])0 vs ([3.6] − [5.8])0 diagram. Open circles
indicate the GC LPVs of Glass et al. (2001). Filled red circles
denote oxygen-rich LPVs in the LMC (see text). The straight
lines are models computed by Groenewegen (2006) using realis-
tic stellar atmosphere models. The dashed green line is a model
with 100% aluminium oxide dust, the dotted blue line is 60%
aluminium oxide and 40% silicate, and the solid magenta line
is 100% silicate dust. The extinction vector of AV = 20 is indi-
cated.
4.2. LPVs in the Spitzer colour-magnitude and colour-colour
diagrams
Figure 8 (left panel) shows the [3.6]−[8.0] vs [8.0] diagram.
Indicated are also the approximate saturation limits at [3.6] and
[8.0]. In total, only 248 known LPVs have reliable (unsaturated)
IRAC photometry. On the right panel of Fig. 8, the dereddened
[3.6]−[8.0] vs [8.0] diagram, derived using the extinctions given
in Fig. 4, shows clearly that the locus of the known AGB stars is
above the RGB tip ([8]0 (cid:39) 7.3). As can be seen, the isochrones of
Marigo et al. (2008) are a good fit to the dereddened CMD. This
agreement confirms the correctness of the derived extinctions.
The locations of the isochrones change only marginally with age
and/or metallicity (e.g. from 1 to 10 Gyr and 0.008 < Z < 0.03
in these bands. The AGB stars show a large scatter in this dia-
gram due to strong variability (we only have single-epoch mea-
surements) and also to the infrared excesses arising from heavy
mass-loss (see Sect. 6). A similar diagram can be drawn for
LPVs at [4.5] where we find only 84 AGB variables to be un-
saturated.
4.2.1. Comparison with Spitzer observations of LMC LPVs
Cioni et al. (2001) examined a field of about 0.5 square de-
grees around the optical center of the Large Magellanic Cloud.
8
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
Fig. 7. 2MASS image (reversed grayscale) of the Galactic Center region at KS . The known LPVs from Glass et al. (2001) are
superimposed with red circles.
Fig. 8. Left panel: [3.6]−[8.0] vs [8.0] colour-magnitude diagram of the GALCEN field, with the known LPVs (red crosses) and
OH/IR stars (blue open circles) superimposed. The extinction vector for AV =20 is indicated. The dotted horizontal line indicates the
saturation limit at [8.0] while the dotted diagonal line shows the saturation limit at [3.6]. Right panel: Same diagram but dereddened
(see text). Superimposed is the isochrone for 10 Gyr and Z=0.02 put at a distance of 8 kpc.
Light curves in the EROS V and R bands were obtained for 334
variables, most of which are of long period (including Miras
and semiregulars). In addition they obtained spectroscopy of
about 100 AGB variables whose visible spectra were classi-
fied as carbon- or oxygen-rich. We used their sample of known
AGB stars and cross-identified their catalogue with the SAGE
(Surveying the Agents of a Galaxy's Evolution) MIPS and IRAC
imaging survey (Meixner et al. 2006). In the latter work, a field
of 7 sq degrees of the LMC was surveyed between 3.6 and 160
µm. In total, 331 objects were found in the SAGE catalogue. For
further discussion, we will refer to this as the LMC-AGB sam-
ple.
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
9
Figure 6 shows the dereddened [3.6]−[8.0] vs [3.6]−[5.8]
colour-colour diagram for both the Galactic Center and the LMC
AGB LPVs. We have superimposed for comparison theoretical
dust models by Groenewegen (2006). These utilise several types
of dust for the O-rich AGB stars: 100% aluminium oxide, a com-
bination of 60% aluminium oxide and 40% silicate, and pure
silicate dust (see Groenewegen 2006 for a discussion). All three
models fail to match the observed colours and a significant offset
is clearly visible.
Our comparison is restricted to oxygen-rich AGB stars (283
stars). It should be noted that we split the LMC-AGB sample
into oxygen-rich and carbon-rich AGB stars using only the J− K
colour. Though Cioni et al. (2001) showed that carbon stars can
in general be eliminated by avoiding colours in the range 1.4 <
J − Ks < 2.0, they warn (see their Fig. 3) that stars selected in
this way will contain a certain fraction of carbon stars.
Figure 6 shows that
the GALCEN variables and LMC
oxygen-rich variables only partly overlap in the colour-colour
diagram. The GALCEN LPVs show much redder colours in
[3.6]−[8.0] and [3.6]−[5.8] than the LMC sample. These stars
also have a higher proportion of long periods (Groenewegen &
Blommaert 2005) relative to the LMC and the remainder of the
Galactic Bulge. The redder colours in the IRAC bands may in-
dicate that mass-loss rates of AGB stars in the GC are higher in
general than in the LMC. However, the differing circumstellar
dust-to-gas ratios between the LMC and GC makes direct com-
parison difficult. The differences can also be a manifestation of
the strong relation between period and mass-loss (see Sect. 6).
5. The Period-magnitude relations
AGB variable stars in the Galactic Bulge follow a well-defined
period-magnitude relation in the near infrared. Glass et al.
(2001) showed that the mean K magnitude for the Glass-LPVs,
measured over a complete cycle, showed some tendency to fol-
low a log P vs. K relation in spite of a very high dispersion due to
the large and unknown variations in AV. Some of the scatter may
also have arisen because of crowding effects or insufficient ob-
servations having led to incorrect periods, especially at the long
(log P > 2.8) and short ends (log P < 2.3) of the range. The
Glass et al. (2001) sample contains a higher fraction of long pe-
riods than e.g. the SgrI field. Thus, circumstellar reddening due
to heavy mass-loss affects the log P vs. K relation by depressing
the emergent fluxes at longer wavelengths.
Figure 9 shows the IRAC magnitude vs. log P relations
for the Glass-LPVs, after correction of the photometry for
interstellar extinction. We find following relations for the
Glass-LPV sample:
[3.6] = log P × -5.21 +18.94
[4.5] = log P × -5.71 +19.98
[5.8] = log P × -6.10 +20.70
[8.0] = log P × -6.73 +21.96
The typical r.m.s deviation for the four [IRAC] bands are
0.71 , 0.62, 0.60 and 0.61 mag in the period range between
2.2 < log P < 2.8. This is smaller than at K0 where the r.m.s
is 0.95 mag (corrected according to the extinctions determined
in this work) as the IRAC bands are less affected by any residual
errors in the extinction. Even within the IRAC bands, the disper-
sions at the longer wavelengths are less than that at 3.6 µm. The
Glass-LPVs with periods greater than 900 days do not follow the
log P vs. [IRAC] relations. Their periods could be incorrect as
these only have a few observations (see Glass et al. 2001) and in
addition these stars suffer heavy mass-loss which depress their
[IRAC] fluxes.
Superimposed on Fig. 9 is the LMC-AGB star sample.
Again, we have chosen only oxygen-rich Mira variables in or-
der to make direct comparisons with the Glass-LPV sample. We
have put the LMC LPVs at the distance of the GC using a dis-
tance modulus difference of ∆m = 4.0 mag. Within the errors,
the Glass-LPVs do follow the LMC relation.
As mentioned, the scatter in the period-magnitude relations
for the Glass-LPVs is much higher than in the LMC-AGB sam-
ple. This is due to the uncertainties in the extinction determina-
tion. No attempt has been made to compensate for the triaxial
distribution of stars in the Bulge. Recent studies of the central
region of our Galaxy suggest a smaller bar-like structure within
the main bar (see e.g. Alard 2001, Nishiyama et al. 2005) which
might be partly responsible for the observed scatter. However,
the parameters of the central bar (such as its angle, length and
orientation) are still poorly known.
In contrast to the light curves obtained by Glass et al. (2001),
we have only single epoch measurements in the IRAC bands.
The K amplitude distribution of the Glass-LPVs peaks around
0.8 mag, going up to 1.5 mag for the OH/IR stars. In order to es-
timate the expected amplitude of LPVs in the IRAC filter bands,
we used the calculated colours of Galactic oxygen-rich AGB
stars by Marengo et al. (2006). Several such objects were ob-
served by ISO at different epochs. Mira variables, such as Z Cyg,
can show variations up to 1 mag in each IRAC channel, while in
the most extreme cases, such as the dust-enshrouded OH/IR star
V1300 Aql, variations of 1.4 mag may occur in each filter.
Up to now, period-magnitude relations have been mainly
studied in the intermediate Bulge (such as Baade's Window)
and the LMC, where the log P vs KS relations seem to be in-
dependent of the galactic environment (see e.g. Schultheis et al.
2004, Glass & van Leeuwen 2007). Groenewegen & Blommaert
(2005), by using OGLE data, also compared the period-
magnitude relations in the Galactic bulge and the Magellanic
Clouds and concluded that there is no difference in their slopes.
Rejkuba (2004) found that even Miras in Cen A follow a similar
relation.
The Galactic Center, however, has up to now been excluded
from this comparison. In asking whether substantially different
behaviour should be expected we first summarize recent abun-
dance studies in order to place the GC in context with the Bulge
([Fe/H] (cid:39) −0.1; alpha-enhanced) and the LMC ([Fe/H] (cid:39) −0.4;
no alpha-enhancement). Studies have shown that in the GC the
mean [Fe/H] is nearly solar; [Fe/H] (cid:39) 0.1 (Ram´ırez et al. 2000;
Najarro et al. 2004, 2008; Cunha et al. 2007). On the other hand,
Ram´ırez et al. (2000) found that the distribution in metallicity is
significantly narrower than in the Bulge, emphasizing the differ-
ence between its stellar population and that of the GC.
Figure 9 shows clearly that
the slopes of the period-
magnitude relations at the IRAC wavelengths for the Glass-
LPVs are similar to those of the LMC. This suggests that any
dependence of the log P vs. IRAC relations on abundance, if
present at all, must be small. Within the uncertainties, there
is no evidence for a significant difference between the period-
magnitude relations in the LMC and in the GC. This is in agree-
ment with Whitelock et al. (2008) who found, after reanalyz-
ing published lightcurves of AGB variables in the LMC, similar
zero points in the period-MK relations for systems with differ-
ent metallicities. They did not, however, include in their analysis
the variables towards the GC, which is thought to be the most
metal-rich environment. Thus, our analysis shows that the appar-
ent universality of the PL relations extends to the IRAC bands.
10
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
Fig. 9. Dereddened IRAC magnitudes (using the extinction map as described in Sect. 3) vs. log P for LPVs in the Glass et al. (2001)
GC field (Glass-LPVs; black dots), where P is the period. Open magenta squares are LMC-AGB stars (oxygen-rich Mira variables).
The straight red line is a least-squares fit to the LMC-AGB data set.
6. Mass-loss
AGB stars contribute more than 70% towards the enrichment of
the dust component of the interstellar medium (ISM) in the so-
lar neighbourhood (Sedlmayr 1994) and hence it is important
to study their mass-loss in other parts of the Galaxy. One of
the most promising tools for determining mass-loss rates is the
combination of near-IR and mid-IR colours such as the IRAS
K0 − [12] or the ISOGAL K0 − [15] colours (see e.g. Whitelock
et al. 1994; Habing 1996; Le Bertre & Winters 1998; Omont et
al. 1999; Jeong et al. 2002, Ojha et al. 2003, 2007).
We used the dust radiative transfer code for oxygen-rich
AGB stars from Groenewegen (2006) to derive theoretical mass-
loss rates. The procedures described by Ojha et al. (2007) to de-
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
11
rive observed mass-loss rates based on the (KS − [15])0 colour
(see Equ. 1).
log M = −8.6171 + 0.85562 x −0.064143 x2 + 0.0018083x 3(1)
where x = (K − [15])0
As in Ojha et al. (2007) we are considering an AGB star
model with Teff = 2500 K and 100% silicate composition. Note
that the empirical values determined by Groenewegen (2006) are
for mass-loss rates smaller than 2 × 10−5 M(cid:12) yr−1. For the high
mass-loss end we extrapolate the empirical relation.
The distribution of mass-loss rates is displayed in Fig. 10.
The derived values of M range from 10−8 to 10−5 M(cid:12) yr−1. The
distribution, however, is definitely incomplete for M < 1 × 10−7
M(cid:12) yr−1. We emphasize that the determination of these rates is
very uncertain as discussed by Schultheis et al. (2003). The un-
certainties could easily reach a factor of 3.
Fig. 11. Histogram of luminosities of the GC Glass-LPV sample
(solid line). The luminosities for an inner Bulge sample (Ojha
et al. 2007) is shown for comparison (dotted lines). The vertical
lines mark the tip of the RGB (at fainter Mbol) and the tip of the
AGB (at brighter Mbol).
We used an approximate relation between BCK and (K -- [15])0
derived by Ojha et al. (2003) for AGB stars, using data from
Frogel & Whitford (1987). We refer here to Ojha et al. (2003) for
a more detailed description of the method. These authors con-
clude that the rms uncertainty in the luminosities of the Bulge
sources that they observed with ISO is about 0.5 mag.
Fig. 11 shows the luminosity function of the Glass-LPVs.
These include high luminosity stars, with Mbol < −6, which are
not observed in the inner Bulge AGB stars (Ojha et al. 2007).
However, one should note that the sample of Ojha et al. (2007)
excludes the GC region and are only single-epoch measure-
ments. The luminosity distribution of the Glass-LPVs, compared
to that of the inner Bulge AGB stars (Ojha et al. 2007), is also
broader and less strongly peaked. Due to the variability of our
sources, the luminosity distribution will be widened. Thus, com-
pared to the Bulge sample of Ojha et al., we find an excess in the
GC of luminous stars.
Such an excess of luminous stars in the GC, compared to
Bulge fields such as Baade's Window, has previously been found
in the infrared stellar luminosity function by Blum et al. (1996),
Narayanan et al. (1996), Launhardt et al. (2002), Genzel et al.
(2003), Van Loon et al. (2003), and Figer et al. (2004). In ad-
dition, Blommaert et al. (1998) and Wood et al. (1998) found a
similar excess of high luminosity OH/IR stars in the GC com-
pared to the Bulge. All these authors conclude that this is gen-
erally evidence for recent star formation in the GC. Blum et al.
(1996), Figer et al. (2004), and Maness et al. (2007), among oth-
ers, have derived detailed star formation histories for the GC by
fitting models to the observations. Their studies suggest that star
formation has occurred within the last 10 Myr within the cen-
Fig. 10. Distribution of mass-loss rates for the GC Glass-
LPV sample. The mass-loss rates are inferred from models
(Groenewegen 2006) using the dereddened K−[15] colour.
There is some correlation between mass-loss rates and
period, in the sense that longer periods show higher rates.
Theoretical isochrones by Marigo et al. (2008) which include
mass-loss and pulsation periods predict that there should be such
a correlation; however there is still some disagreement with the
observational data indicating that self-consistent dust models of
oxygen-rich AGB stars are in need of further improvement.
7. Luminosities
We have derived a bolometric magnitude (Mbol) for each Glass-
LPV from its de-reddened K magnitude, an assumed bolometric
correction (BCK), and a distance modulus of 14.5 for the GC.
12
Schultheis et al.: Interstellar Extinction and Long-Period Variables in the Galactic Center
tral 30 pc, and that it has been more or less continuous over the
Hubble time.
Groenewegen & Blommaert (2005) studied the Mira period
distribution of six fields at similar longitudes but spanning lat-
itudes −5.8 < b < −1.2 o. They found for all these fields a
similar period distribution, consistent with the average period
in Baade's Window of ∼333 d (Glass et al. 1995). By comparing
their fields with the LPVs of Glass et al. (2001) they found that
there is a significant overabundance of LPVs with periods >∼500
d in the GC compared to Bulge fields at higher latitudes. This
excess of LPVs with long periods in the GC is not surprising,
considering the excess of luminous sources in the GC generally
(see Fig. 11), when combined with the period-luminosity rela-
tion. Groenewegen & Blommaert (2005) explain this difference
in the period distribution as due to a younger population in the
GC with a higher initial mass in the range of 2.5 -- 3 M(cid:12) compared
to 1 -- 2 M(cid:12) for higher latitude Bulge fields.
We conclude that the GALCEN-LPVs show an excess of lu-
minous, young stars compared to the galactic Bulge. It is un-
fortunate that the isochrones in the [IRAC] bands are not very
sensitive to metallicity and/or age; thus no estimation of initial
masses or metallicities in this wavelength range can be made.
8. Conclusions
We have presented a high resolution interstellar extinction map
of the Galactic Center (GC), derived from the Spitzer IRAC
catalogue of GC point sources (Ram´ırez et al. 2008). It com-
bines observations of the RGB/AGB population with the newest
isochrones (Marigo et al. 2008). We have improved on previ-
ous near-IR extinction maps by using extinctions derived from
mid-IR colours to resolve all regions of high AV. The maximum
value we found is AV (cid:39) 90. By using this extinction map, we
have studied the Spitzer (IRAC) properties of the long-period
variables (LPVs) of in the GC. They follow well-defined period-
magnitude relations in the IRAC bands and are similar to those
observed in the LMC, lending support to the suggestion that the
log P vs. [IRAC] relations are universal, independent of metal-
licity. Further, mass-loss rates for the Glass-LPVs have been de-
termined by using additional data from ISOGAL. These LPVs
show some correlation between mass-loss and pulsation pe-
riod as predicted by theoretical isochrones (Marigo et al. 2008).
Finally, the long periods of the Glass-LPVs as well as their lu-
minosity function agree with the suggestion of Groenewegen &
Blommaert (2005) that one is dealing with a young and more
massive population in the GC.
Acknowledgements. We want to thank the referee J. Blommaert for his very
fruitful comments. We are thankful to M. Marengo for making the colours of
AGB stars in the IRAC bands available to us, and to the GLIMPSE team for
sharing data in advance of publication. We would like to thank M. Groenewegen
for the fruitful discussion and his comments on the paper This work is based
on observations made with the Spitzer Space Telescope, which is operated by
the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), California Institute of Technology under
NASA contract 1407. K.S., R.S., and S.S. are grateful for financial support from
NASA through an award issued by JPL/Caltech. ISG acknowledges receipt of
a travel grant under the CNRS-NRF bilateral agreement. M.S. and L.G. ac-
knowledge support by the University of Padova (Progetto di Ricerca di Ateneo
CPDA052212). SG's visit to the Observatoire de Besancon was supported by
an EARA-Marie Curie fellowship. Work at the Physical Research Laboratory is
supported by the Department of Space, Govt of India.
This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive,
which is operated by JPL, California Institute of Technology, under contract with
the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. This publication makes use
of data products from the Two Micron All Sky Survey, which is a joint project
of the University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis
Center/California Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics
and Space Administration and the National Science Foundation.
References
Allen L.E., Calvet N., Alessio P., et al., 2004, ApJS 154, 363
Alard C., 2001, A&A 379, L44
Bandyopadhyay R.M., Eikenberry S.S., Curtis D., 2008, astro-ph/0803.2721
Benjamin R.A., Churchwell E., Babler B.L. et al., 2003, PASP 115, 953
Blommaert J.A.D.L., van der Veen W.E.C.J., van Langevelde H.J. et al., 1998,
A&A 329, 991
Blommaert J.A.D.L.L, Groenewegen M.A.T., Okumura K., 2006, A&A 460, 555
Blum R.D., Sellgren K., DePoy D.L. 1996, ApJ 470, 864
Cesarsky C.J., Abergel A., Agnese P., et al., 1996, A&A 315, L32
Chapman N.L., Mundy L.G., Shih-Ping L., 2008, astro-ph/0809.1106
Cioni M.R., Marquette J.B., Loup C., et al., 2001, A&A 377, 945
Cunha K., Sellgren K., Smith V.V., et al., 2007, ApJ 669, 1011
Deguchi S., Fuji T., Ita Y., et al., 2008, in "Mapping the Galaxy and Nearby
Galalxies", Astrophysics and Space Science Proceedings, Springer, p33
Dutra C.M., Bica E., 2001, A&A 376, 434
Figer D.F., Rich R.M., Kim S.S., et al. 2004, ApJ 601, 319
Flaherty K.M., Pipher J.L., Megeath S.T., et al., 2007, ApJ 663, 1069
Frogel, J. A., Tiede, G. P., & Kuchinski, L. E. 1999, AJ, 117, 2296
Frogel J.A., Whitford A.E., 1987, ApJ 320, 199
Ganesh S., Omont A., Baliyan K.S., et al., 2008, astro-ph/0809.1741
Genzel R., Schodel R., Ott T., et al. 2003, ApJ 594, 812
Glass I.S., Whitelock P.A., Catchpole R.M., et al., 1995, MNRAS 273, 383
Glass I.S., Matsumoto S., Carter B. S., Sekiguchi K., 2001, MNRAS 321, 77
Glass I.S., van Leeuwen F., 2007, MNRAS 378, 1543
Gosling A., Blundell K.M., Bandyopadhyay R., 2006, AJ, 640, L171
Groenewegen M.A.T., 2006, A&A 448, 181
Groenewegen M.A.T., Blommaert J.A.D.L., 2005, A&A 443, 143
Habing, H. J. 1996, A&AR 7, 97
Indebetouw R., Mathis J.S., Babler B.L., et al., 2005, ApJ 619, 931
Jeong, K. S., Winters, J. M., Le Bertre, T., et al. 2002, in Mass-losing Pulsating
stars and their Circumstellar Matter, ed. Y. Nakasa, M. Honma, & M. Seki
Jiang B.W., Omont A., Ganesh S., et al., 2003, A&A 400, 903
Launhardt R., Zylka R., Mezger P.G., 2002, A&A 384, 112
Le Bertre, T., & Winters, J. M. 1998, A&A, 334, 173
Le Bertre T., Tanaka M., Yamamura I., et al., 2003, A&A, 403, 943
Lindqvist M., Winnberg A., Habing H.J., et al., 1992, A&AS 92, 43
Lutz D., Feuchtgruber H., Genzel R., et al., 1996, A&A 315, L269
Lutz D., 1999, in "The Universe as Seen by ISO", ESA-SP 427, p.623
Maness H., Martins F., Trippe S., et al. 2007, ApJ 669, 1024
Marengo M., Hora J.L., Barmby P., astro-ph/0611346
Marigo P., Girardi L., Bessan A., et al., 2008, A&A 482, 883
Marshall D.J., Robin A.C., Reyl´e C., 2006, A&A 453, 635
Meixner M., Gordon K.D., Indebetouw R., et al., 2006, AJ 132, 2268
Messineo M., "Late-type Giants in the Inner Galaxy", PhD thesis, Leiden
Najarro F., Figer D.F., Hillier D.J., et al., 2004, ApJ 611, L105
Najarro F., Figer D.F., Hillier D.J., et al., 2008, astro-ph/0809.3185
Narayanan V., Gould A., DePoy D.L. 1996, ApJ 472, 183
Nishiyama S., Nagata T., Baba D., et al., 2005, ApJ 621, L105
Nishiyama S., Nagata T., Matsunaga N., 2006, ApJ 638, 839
Ojha D. K., Omont A., Schuller F., et al. 2003, A&A, 403, 141
Ojha D.K., Tej A., Schultheis M., et al., 2007, MNRAS 381, 1219
Omont A., Ganesh S., Alard C., et al. 1999, A&A, 348, 755
Ram´ırez S.V., Sellgren K., Carr J.S., et al., 2000, ApJ 537, 205
Ram´ırez S.V., Arendt R.G., Sellgren K., et al., 2008, ApJS 175, 147
Reid M.J., 1993, ARA&A 31, 345
Rejkuba M., 2004, A&A 413, 903
Rom´an-Z´uniga C.G., Lada C.J., Muench A., 2007, ApJ 664, 357
Schuller F., Ganesh S., Messineo M.., et al., 2003, A&A 403, 955
Schuller F., Omont A., Glass I.S., et al., 2006, A&A 453, 535
Schultheis M., Ganesh S., Glass I.S., et al., 1999, A&A 349, L69
Schultheis M., Lanc¸on A., Omont A., et al., 2003, A&A 405, 531
Schultheis M., Glass I.S., Cioni M.R., 2004, A&A 427, 945
Sedlmayr, E. 1994, in Molecules in the Stellar Environment, ed. U. G. Jorgensen
(Berlin: Springer), 163
Sjouwerman L., van Langevelde H.J., Winnberg A., 1996, A&AS 128, 35
Stolovy S., Ram´ırez S.V., Arendt R.G et al., 2006, Journal of Physics:
Conference Series, Volume 54, 176
Stolovy S., et al., 2008, in preparation
Vanhollebeke E., Blommaert J.A.D.L, Schultheis M., et al., 2006, A&A 455, 645
van Loon, J., Gilmore G., Omont A., et al., 2003, MNRAS 338, 857
Whitelock P.A., Menzies J.W., Feast M.W., et al., 1994, MNRAS 267, 711
Whitelock P.A., Feast M.W., van Leeuwen F., 2008, MNRAS 386, 313
Wood P.R., Habing H.H., McGregor P.J., 1998, A&A 336, 925
|
astro-ph/0604099 | 2 | 0604 | 2006-07-13T15:14:02 | Unexpected Dynamical Instabilities In Differentially Rotating Neutron Stars | [
"astro-ph"
] | A one-armed spiral instability has been found to develop in differentially rotating stellar models that have a relatively stiff, $n=1$ polytropic equation of state and a wide range of rotational energies. This suggests that such instabilities can arise in neutron stars that are differentially, although not necessarily rapidly, rotating. The instability seems to be directly triggered by the presence of a corotation resonance inside the star. Our analysis also suggests that a resonant cavity resulting from a local minimum in the radial vortensity profile of the star plays an important role in amplifying the unstable mode. Hence, it appears as through this instability is closely related to the so-called ``Rossby wave instability'' \citep{LLCN99} that has been found to arise in accretion disks. In addition to the one-armed ($m=1$) spiral mode, we have found that higher-order ($m = 2$ and $m=3$) nonaxisymmetric modes also can become unstable if corotation points that resonate with the eigenfrequencies of these higher-order modes also appear inside the star. The growth rate of each mode seems to depend on the location of its corotation radius with respect to the vortensity profile (or on the depth of its corotation radius inside the vortensity well). The existence of such instabilities makes the stability criterion for differentially rotating neutron stars non-unique. Also, the gravitational-waves emitted from such unstable systems generally will not have a monochromatic frequency spectrum. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Unexpected Dynamical Instabilities In Differentially Rotating
Neutron Stars
Shangli Ou and Joel E. Tohline
Department of Physics & Astronomy, Center for Computation & Technology,
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803
ABSTRACT
A one-armed spiral instability has been found to develop in differentially ro-
tating stellar models that have a relatively stiff, n = 1 polytropic equation of
state and a wide range of rotational energies. This suggests that such instabil-
ities can arise in neutron stars that are differentially, although not necessarily
rapidly, rotating. The instability seems to be directly triggered by the presence
of a corotation resonance inside the star. Our analysis also suggests that a reso-
nant cavity resulting from a local minimum in the radial vortensity profile of the
star plays an important role in amplifying the unstable mode. Hence, it appears
as through this instability is closely related to the so-called "Rossby wave insta-
bility" (Lovelace et al. 1999) that has been found to arise in accretion disks. In
addition to the one-armed (m = 1) spiral mode, we have found that higher-order
(m = 2 and m = 3) nonaxisymmetric modes also can become unstable if corota-
tion points that resonate with the eigenfrequencies of these higher-order modes
also appear inside the star. The growth rate of each mode seems to depend on the
location of its corotation radius with respect to the vortensity profile (or on the
depth of its corotation radius inside the vortensity well). The existence of such
instabilities makes the stability criterion for differentially rotating neutron stars
non-unique. Also, the gravitational-waves emitted from such unstable systems
generally will not have a monochromatic frequency spectrum.
Subject headings: neutron stars -- one-armed instabilities -- corotation -- dif-
ferential rotation -- vortensity -- Rossby wave instability -- gravitational waves
1.
Introduction
Rotating stars are subject to a variety of nonaxisymmetric instabilities (Chandrasekhar
1969; Tassoul 1978; Andersson 2003). If a star rotates sufficiently fast -- to a point where the
-- 2 --
ratio of its rotational to gravitational potential energy T /W & 0.27 -- it will encounter a
dynamical bar-mode instability that will result in the deformation of the star into a rapidly
spinning, bar-like structure. This instability has been verified by a number of numerical
hydrodynamics investigations (Tohline, Durisen, & McCollough 1985; Durisen et al. 1986;
Williams & Tohline 1988; Cazes & Tohline 2000; New, Centrella & Tohline 2000; Brown 2000;
Liu 2002). At a slower rotation rate, T /W & 0.14, a star may also encounter a secular
bar-mode instability that can promote deformation into a bar-like shape, but only if the star
is subjected to a dissipative process capable of redistributing angular momentum within its
structure, such as viscosity or gravitational radiation reaction (GRR) forces (Chandrasekhar
1970; Friedman & Schutz 1978; Ipser & Lindblom 1990, 1991; Lai & Shapiro 1995).
In
reality, viscosity and GRR forces tend to compete with each other and can drive the secularly
unstable star along a variety of different evolutionary paths. Recently, Shibata & Karino
(2004) and Ou, Tohline & Lindblom (2004) used numerical hydrodynamic techniques to
study the nonlinear evolution of the GRR-driven secular bar-mode instability in rotating,
"polytropic" neutron stars in the absence of any competing dissipation. The above studies
have shown that the critical limits of both the secular and dynamical bar-mode instabilities
do not depend sensitively on the degree of compressibility of the equation of state (EOS) or
on the differential rotation law of a star.
Surprisingly, several recent numerical studies have found that dynamical instabilities
that excite m = 1 as well as m = 2 azimuthal Fourier modes can arise in self-gravitating
structures having T /W < 0.27, that is, having a rotational energy below the threshold tra-
ditionally expected for dynamical nonaxisymmetirc instabilities. Tohline & Hachisu (1990)
found an m = 2 instability in self-gravitating rings and tori having uniform specific angular
momentum and T /W & 0.16. Centrella et al. (2001) found a one-armed (m = 1) spiral
instability in stellar models with a polytropic index n = 3.33, strong differential rotation
and T /W ∼ 0.14. Shibata et al. (2002, 2003) found an m = 2 instability in extremely
differentially rotating stellar models having T /W on the order of 10−2! Saijo et al. (2003)
concluded that one-armed (m = 1) modes only appear in structures with a very soft equation
of state (n & 2.5), and that a necessary condition for this instability to arise is the presence
of an off-center density maximum, that is, a toroidal-like structure. Ott et al. (2005a) showed
that a one-armed spiral instability may arise in the context of a pre-supernova core collapse.
The linear analysis of Watts et al. (2004) has suggested that these low T /W instabilities
are triggered because corotation points of the unstable modes fall within the differentially
rotating structure of the examined models. Saijo & Yoshida (2005) also have carried out a
linear stability analysis that shows a connection between the one-armed, m = 1 instability
and corotation points in differentially rotating stars.
Many earlier studies of disks and tori have also noted an association between the onset
-- 3 --
of dynamical instabilities and the existence of corotation points. For example, a number
of groups (Papaloizou & Pringle 1984; Goldreich, Goodman, & Narayan 1986; Narayan,
Goldreich, & Goodman 1987; Frank & Robertson 1988) have used both linear analyses and
nonlinear simulations to study the so-called Papaloizou-Pringle instability, which is triggered
by corotation resonances. But the existence of a corotation point within a model is not
sufficient to ensure significant growth of an unstable mode. It appears as though a resonant
cavity is also required to drive these modes to very large amplitude.
In the case of the
Papaloizou-Pringle instability, the inner and outer edges of the disk or torus form a resonant
cavity in which waves are reflected back and forth; the unstable mode is greatly amplified
through multiple passages across the corotation radius. However, it is not obvious how such
a resonant cavity can exist in stellar models that have no inner edges.
Lovelace & Hohlfeld (1978) and Papaloizou & Lin (1989) have discussed how the radial
distribution of vortensity or potential vorticity, which is defined as the ratio between vorticity
and surface density, is important in determining the stability of homentropic, self-gravitating
rings and disks. Lovelace et al. (1999) and Li et al. (2000) extended this discussion to non-
homentropic disks. According to their analysis of the so-called "Rossby-Wave Instability",
local minima in the radial vortensity profile of homentropic configurations tend to trap
radially propagating waves and, hence, can serve as resonant cavities that will help drive
corotation instabilities to large amplitude. This removes the necessity of having disk edges
to serve as reflecting boundaries. In their subsequent nonlinear simulations, Li et al. (2001)
found that this mechanism can aid in the excitation of nonaxisymmetric instabilities (m = 1,
3, 5) and vortex formation in accretion disks. It is interesting to note that when the initial
perturbations in these nonlinear simulations contained the pure eigenfunctions for a given
azimuthal mode (for example, m = 3 or 5), the corresponding mode developed; but, when
a white noise initial perturbation was used, an m = 1 spiral mode became dominant in the
final stage.
It is conceivable that a similar resonant cavity mechanism may work to amplify corota-
tion resonances in stellar models. This would seem to be especially likely for rapidly rotating
models that have toroidal-like structures because the associated off-center density maximum
will inevitably result in a dip in the radial vortensity profile of the star. This profile could
then act as a resonant cavity to trap radially propagating waves. Alternatively, a maximum
in the star's radial entropy profile can also produce such a cavity (Lovelace et al. 1999),
but in keeping with most previous studies of the low T /W instabilities we will confine our
analysis to homentropic configurations where a dip in the vortensity profile will be required
to create a resonant cavity.
In this paper, we report the unexpected discovery of an m = 1 spiral-mode instability in
-- 4 --
rotating stars with a relatively stiff (n = 1) polytropic EOS that was designed to represent
differentially rotating neutron stars. We also show evidence that this instability is directly
triggered by the existence inside the star of a corotation radius for the eigenmode. This one-
armed spiral instability develops on a timescale that is somewhat longer than the growth
time observed in previous studies of configurations with a softer EOS, but the instability
appears to be dynamical nevertheless. All of our unstable models exhibit a local minimum
in their radial vortensity profile and this seems likely to be the resonant cavity that traps the
wave and permits it to amplify. (We have found that such a minimum can exist in config-
urations with centrally condensed, rather than toroidal, density structures when the degree
of differential rotation is sufficiently strong.) Our results suggest that it is the combination
of corotation points and resonant cavities formed by vortensity minima that is responsible
for the excitation of low T /W instabilities found in stellar models.
Perhaps our most striking discovery is that, in addition to the m = 1 mode, m=2 and
3 modes also come into play as long as their corotation points exist within the structure of
the star. Therefore, if the rotational profile of the star is steep enough to contain corotation
points of multiple modes, these unstable modes may all arise within one single star. The
entire picture of rotational instabilities that might arise in differentially rotating neutron
stars becomes more complicated due to the co-existence of these corotation instabilities. The
corresponding gravitational-wave signals may exhibit different characteristic frequencies at
different or overlapping times, since various unstable modes may set in simultaneously.
2.
Initial Models and Numerical Methods
2.1.
Initial Axisymmetric Models
Using the Hachisu self-consistent-field technique (Hachisu 1986), four simplified axisym-
metric neutron star models (models J250, J133, J127, and J068 ) were constructed on a
cylindrical grid with resolution 66 × 82 × 128 in the radial, vertical and azimuthal direc-
tions, respectively. For each model, we have adopted a dimensionless unit system in which
the gravitational constant G, the maximum density ρmax, and the radius of the entire grid
Rgrid are set to 1. For comparison purposes, equatorial radii Req were all set to 0.673. All
the models were constructed using Newtonian gravity and a polytropic equation of state,
p = Kρ1+1/n, where p is the gas pressure, K is a polytropic constant, and the polytropic
index n was in all cases chosen to be 1. The angular velocity profiles were specified by the
so-called j-constant-like law as,
Ω(R) =
ωcA2
R2 + A2 ,
(1)
-- 5 --
where R = px2 + y2 is the cylindrical radius, A is a constant, and ωc is the angular velocity
at the rotation axis (the Z-axis). The specific parameter values of each model are given in
Table 1, where ¯ρ is the mean density of the star, ρc is the central density (which will be less
than ρmax if the model exhibits an off-center density maximum), and Rp is the polar radius.
2.2. Analysis Method
We used a three-dimensional (3D), Newtonian hydrodynamics code essentially the same
as the one employed by Ou, Tohline & Lindblom (2004, hereafter Paper I) to study the evo-
lution of our differentially rotating, neutron stars models. The details of the hydrodynamics
code can be found in Motl, Tohline, & Frank (2002). In paper I, an artificially enhanced
gravitational-radiation-reaction (GRR) potential was introduced into the code to mimic the
GRR effect, which will induce the secular bar-mode instability when the T /W value of the
star exceeds the critical limit 0.14.
In order to monitor the growth of nonaxisymmetric modes, we measured the Fourier
amplitude of each mode with azimuthal quantum number m in the following fashion: At
any point in time during an evolution, the azimuthal density distribution in a ring of fixed
R and z can be decomposed into a series of azimuthal Fourier components via the relation,
ρ(R, z, φ) =
+∞
Xm=−∞
Cm(R, z)eimφ ,
where the complex amplitudes Cm are defined by the expression,
Cm(R, z) =
1
2π Z 2π
0
ρ(R, z, φ)e−imφdφ .
(2)
(3)
In our simulations, the time-dependent behavior of the magnitude of this coefficient, Cm, is
then monitored to measure the growth-rate of various unstable modes. At any point in time,
the ratio between the imaginary and real parts of Cm(R, z) gives us a spatially dependent
phase angle φm(R, z) from which we also are able to determine the azimuthal structure of
each unstable mode m, if it exists. (In particular, the radial dependence of φm tells us, for
example, whether an m = 1 mode has a spiral character or an m = 2 mode has a bar-like
structure; see Figures 14 and 15, below.) In general, φm(R, z) is a function of time, but
an eigenmode of the system becomes identifiable when the spatial structure of the phase
angle φm(R, z) appears to be coherent/aligned throughout the star and time-independent,
apart from a spatially independent azimuthal eigenfrequency ωm ≡ ∂φm/∂t of the mode.
Another way to look at this is that the oscillation period of mode m, Tm ≡ 2π/ωm, is
-- 6 --
equivalent to the time it takes the real or imaginary parts of Cm to complete a full cycle
from a positive value to a negative value, then back to a positive value. In our nonlinear
hydrodynamic simulations, the measurement of ωm is accurate only when the corresponding
mode dominates the evolution.
By definition, the corotation radius Rcor of mode m is the radial location in the star
where the angular velocity of the fluid resonates with the eigenfrequency of the unstable
mode, that is, where ω(Rcor) = ωm/m. In our analysis, we also will find it useful to refer
to each model's central spin period, Tc = 2π/ωc, and characteristic dynamical time scale,
T0 ≡ 2π/ω0, where ω0 ≡ √πG¯ρ.
3. Simulation Results
In this section, we show results from a number of independent 3D hydrodynamic evo-
lutions. Because our initial goal was to study the secular bar-mode instability induced by
GRR forces, rather than the development of a one-armed spiral instability, the initially ax-
isymmetric density structure of all models was perturbed with an m = 2 perturbation with
different amplitude as they were introduced into the hydrodynamics code. In the discussion
that follows, the evolution time of individual simulations has been normalized to the spin
period at the rotation axis of each star Tc, which varies significantly for different models,
but in terms of the characteristic dynamical time, T0, they were evolved for roughly the
same times, except for model J127. Table 2 summarizes all the relevant frequencies and
time scales for each of our models. In addition to the time scales and frequencies defined
earlier, τm is the measured e-folding (growth) time for a given mode m, and ωs is the angular
frequency at the equatorial surface. We note that, for a given model, the eigenfrequencies
quoted in Table 2 have been measured at different evolutionary times. Each ωm is measured
at a time when the corresponding mode m is dominant, and the corresponding corotation
radius is determined from the system's equatorial plane rotational profile at that same time.
3.1. Evolution of model J250
This investigation began as an extension of Paper I (where uniformly rotating neutron
stars were studied) and our initial aim was to study the secular bar-mode instability in
differentially rotating neutron stars. The first model we evolved was model J250, which
was expected to be secularly unstable but dynamically stable to the high T /W bar-mode
instability. Because the model had a relatively large value of the parameter A, it also
-- 7 --
Table 1. Parameters of Initial Models
Model
n
A/Req Rp/Req Mtot
ρc/ρmax
¯ρ
ωc
J250
J133
J127
J068
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
0.94
0.94
0.59
0.44
0.302
0.558
0.558
0.721
0.204
0.257
0.335
0.384
0.976
0.999
0.999
1.000
0.384
0.309
0.363
0.343
1.44
1.19
1.75
1.80
T /W
0.250
0.133
0.127
0.068
unstable modes
m=1
-
m=1,2,3
m=1,2
Note. -- n is polytropic index, A is a parameter that determines the degree of differential
rotation, Req is the equatorial radius, Rp is the polar radius, Mtot is the total mass, ρc is the
central density, ρmax is the maximum density, ¯ρ is the mean density, ωc is the angular frequency
at the center, T is the rotational energy, W is the gravitational energy.
Table 2. Relevant Frequencies of All Models
Model
ωc
ωs
ω0 = √πG¯ρ
ω1
ω2/2
ω3/3
τ1/T0
τ2/T0
τ3/T0
J250
J133
J127
J068
1.44
1.19
1.75
1.80
0.66
0.54
0.44
0.29
1.10
0.98
1.07
1.04
1.2
-
1.3
1.3
-
-
0.9
0.9
-
-
1.0
-
9.4
-
29.4
8.4
-
-
7.8
4.4
-
-
4.2
-
Note. -- ωc is the angular frequency at the center, ωs is the angular frequency
at the equatorial surface, ¯ρ is the mean density, ωm is the eigenfrequency of the
azimuthal mode m, τm is the e-folding time of the azimuthal mode m, T0 = 2π/ω0.
As illustrated in Figure 9, for a given model, the eigenfrequencies ωm have been
measured at different evolutionary times, when each mode dominates.
-- 8 --
was expected to be stable to the low T /W dynamical bar-mode instability identified by
Shibata et al. (2002). Model J250 was evolved for many dynamical times with an artificially
enhanced GRR potential, in a manner similar to the evolutions described in Paper I.
The top panel of Figure 1 shows the time-evolution of the amplitudes of different modes
(averaged over the whole volume) throughout this evolution. In the beginning, the m = 2
bar-mode grows exponentially on a timescale governed by the artificially enhanced GRR
potential; but it saturates after only a moderately deformed bar structure has formed. This is
consistent with the results reported by Shibata & Karino (2004). However, on a considerably
longer time scale, an unexpected m = 1 mode arises and becomes the dominant mode. The
density contour plots in the bottom right-hand panel of Figure 1 suggest that the m = 1
mode has a one-armed spiral structure similar to the one discovered by Centrella et al. (2001).
We note that, late in the evolution, the amplitude of the m = 2 mode increases when the
m = 1 mode reaches the nonlinear regime. (This feature is common to all of our models
that are unstable to the m = 1 mode.) Measurements of ωm for various modes at the time
when the m = 1 mode is dominant confirms that, for example, ω2 ≈ 2ω1 ≈ 2.6 and suggests
that, at late times, the m = 2 mode is a harmonic of the m = 1 mode.
This discovery is unexpected in the sense that the one-armed, m = 1 instability had
previously appeared only in models with a softer EOS (n & 2.5) and with a high degree of
differential rotation, i.e., ωc/ωs ≈ 10 (Centrella et al. 2001; Saijo et al. 2003; Saijo & Yoshida
2005), where ωs is the angular frequency at the equatorial surface. In contrast, our model
J250 has an n = 1 polytropic EOS and has only a moderate degree of differential rotational
with ωc/ωs ≈ 2.
In order to test whether or not this instability was caused by the artificially enhanced
GRR forces, a second evolution was performed on model J250 with GRR turned off. Figure
2 shows the time-evolution of the amplitudes of different modes for this second evolution.
As expected, the m = 2 bar-mode was not unstable in the absence of GRR forces, but
surprisingly the m = 1 mode remained unstable, becoming the dominant Fourier component
at time & 100 Tc. Compared to models that had a softer EOS (Centrella et al. 2001; Saijo
et al. 2003) in which the m = 1 mode grew on a time scale of a few tens of Tc, the growth
time here is much longer but nevertheless still dynamical. (We note that the growth time
in this pure hydrodynamical evolution is also longer than that from the previous run, in
which GRR was turned on. This is probably because GRR tends to increase the degree of
differential rotation, hence influence the growth rate of the m = 1 mode.) The top panel of
Figure 3 shows the radial eigenfunction of the m = 1 mode obtained by subtracting the initial
axisymmetric background density (bottom panel of Figure 3). Its behavior is qualitatively
similar to that derived from a linear stability analysis by Saijo & Yoshida (2005) (see their
-- 9 --
Figure 9).
The appearance of the one-armed spiral instability in our models with a stiff EOS
seems to suggest that its stability criterion is independent of compressibility. Now the
question is what mechanism is responsible for its growth? According to Watts et al. (2004),
Saijo & Yoshida (2005), and related studies of disks and tori (Papaloizou & Pringle 1984;
Goldreich, Goodman, & Narayan 1986; Narayan, Goldreich, & Goodman 1987), corotation
points may be responsible for the amplification of some unstable modes. But this mechanism
of amplification can only operate if there is at least one radial location in the model where
the angular frequency of orbiting fluid elements resonates with the eigenfrequency of the
identified special mode. A straightforward check of the radial rotational profiles Ω(R) of
model J250 (see Figure 4) shows that a corotation radius is present at R ≈ 0.32 for the
unstable m = 1 Fourier mode with an eigenfrequency ω1 ≈ 1.2. (This measurement of the
eigenfrequency was done for the pure hydrodynamical simulation, in which GRR was turned
off.)
However, the result from one model is not sufficient for us to draw a definite conclu-
sion. To further clarify the relationship between the instability and corotation points, we
performed a number of simulations on different polytropic neutron star models.
In these
additional simulations, we will concentrate only on hydrodynamic simulations with GRR
turned off, because GRR-related instabilities generally would set in on a much longer time
scale and therefore are irrelevant here.
3.2. Evolution of model J133
So far we have identified a corotation point associated with the one-armed spiral insta-
bility in model J250. It would be interesting to find out if the instability disappears when
there is no such corotation point. In order to test this, we chose to evolve model J133. This
model is rotating slowly enough so that the central angular frequency is well below the eigen-
frequency of the m = 1 mode that arose in model J250. By removing the corotation points
of the m = 1 mode inside model J133, it was hoped that the one-armed instability would
not show up in this evolution. To eliminate the possible influence of the degree of differential
rotation, we kept the value of the parameter A the same as in model J250, but increased
the polar radius Rp to slow down the rotation of the star. Note that the eigenfrequency of
the m = 1 mode for this model is actually unknown1, but we estimate it would not change
1Our studies do not include a method for performing a complete eigenmode analysis of our selected,
initially axisymmetric models. Only modes that are unstable and that grow on a timescale short compared
-- 10 --
dramatically compared to that of model J250. (In fact, as shown by later simulations, ω1
in model J250 and J127 are very close to each other; see Table 2.)
As shown in the top panel of Figure 5, the m = 1 Fourier amplitude C1 does not grow
into the nonlinear regime in this case. It develops somewhat, but only hangs on at a very
small amplitude. On the other hand, the m = 2 mode seems to gain some strength in the
beginning of the evolution, but it quickly saturates at a very low amplitude and never enters
into the nonlinear regime. The density contours shown in the bottom panels of Figure 5 also
display no indication of nonaxisymmetric structure. The lack of development of the m = 1
spiral mode in this simulation supports our conjecture that corotation points are directly
responsible for the excitation of the mode.
3.3. Evolution of model J127
Although the evolution of model J133 makes our argument about corotation points
plausible, the fact that its T /W value is significantly lower than model J250 raised the
following question:
is it the low T /W value that suppressed the instability? To answer
this question and as a further check of our conjecture, model J127 was evolved in the same
fashion as model J133. This model has a T /W value that is similar to that of model J133,
but its degree of differential rotation was made very high by reducing the value of A. With
this steep rotational profile, we hoped that a corotation point for the m = 1 mode would
exist within the star and, hence, trigger the instability.
The final outcome of this evolution is perhaps the most striking and interesting one. As
shown in the top panel of Figure 6, the evolution can be divided into three stages: (1) In the
first ∼ 50 Tc, an m = 2 mode grows exponentially, but it saturates very quickly; (2) ∼ 30 Tc
later, an unexpected m = 3 mode comes into play, and becomes dominant for quite a long
time. The pear-shaped m = 3 density distortion is visible in the bottom left-hand panel of
Figure 6; (3) after ≈ 300Tc, the originally expected m = 1 mode catches up and wins over.
Given previous studies of the low T /W bar-mode instability (Shibata et al. 2002), the
appearance of the m = 2 mode here is not surprising. However, the appearance of an m = 3
mode in axisymmetric equilibrium stellar models with intermediate T /W values is totally
unexpected. A plot of the rotational profile of model J127 is shown in Figure 7 and reveals
the existence of corotation radii for all three of these unstable modes. These results are fully
consistent with the linear analysis presented by Watts et al. (2004): Corotation instabilities
to our evolution times can be identified using our present nonlinear hydrodynamic tools.
-- 11 --
in stellar models are not limited to m = 1 and m = 2 modes. Other modes may become
unstable as long as their corotation points exist inside the star. In this simulation, we also
analyzed the behavior of the m = 4 (5) Fourier component of the density distribution. It
appears to follow the behavior of the m = 2 (3) mode, but it saturates at an amplitude that
is two orders of magnitude lower. This suggests that the m = 4 (5) "mode" is actually a
harmonic of m = 2 (3). There is no indication of the independent development of either an
m = 4 or 5 mode. We suspect that the reason for the lack of independent m=4 and 5 modes
is that their corotation radii fall outside the star.
Because instabilities associated with different modes may arise in stars with strong
differential rotation, the gravitational-wave signals from such an event would exhibit multiple
characteristics. Figure 8 shows the computed quadrupole gravitational-wave strain as viewed
by an observer located along the +Z axis and assuming the neutron star has a mass of 1.4 M⊙
and an equatorial radius of 12.5 km. The peak signal strength is actually stronger than the
bounce signal expected from the axisymmetric core collapse of massive stars, which has been
shown to produce signals with rh+ ≈ 300 cm at a frequency f ≈ 400 Hz (Ott et al. 2004).
The signal also has some distinct features. There is more than one localized burst, arising
from different modes peaking at different times and in different frequency bands: the first,
centered at t/Tc ∼ 65, corresponds to rh+ ∼ 500 cm at a frequency f ≈ 1800 Hz emitted
by the m = 2 mode; the second, centered at t/Tc ∼ 100, corresponds to rh+ ∼ 600 cm at a
frequency f ≈ 1900 Hz associated with the m = 3 mode; the third, centered at t/Tc ∼ 375,
corresponds to a rh+ ∼ 900 cm at frequency f ≈ 2600 Hz emitted by the m = 2 harmonic
of the m = 1 spiral mode.
Figure 9 shows the pattern frequencies of all the dominating unstable modes as a function
of time. To make the graph clean, the frequencies of the m = 1 and 2 modes are only shown
in the time intervals when they dominate, and all the data at times t < 40Tc have been
omitted because they appear to be noisy due to the lack of coherent modes. It is observed
that the pattern frequencies of all three modes -- ω1, ω2/2, and ω3/3 -- are fairly constant
throughout their peroid of dominance and the uncertainty in these measurements is . 10%.
Hence, the relative location of the corotation radii Rcor for these various modes does not
vary with time, unless a change in the rotational profile of the star causes Rcor to migrate.
Based upon the above hydrodynamic simulations, we can now draw the following con-
clusions: (1) The m = 1 instability can be turned on or off by controlling the rotational
profile of the star to allow or remove the existence of a corotation point. (2) The instability
is not limited to the m = 1 mode; other modes may also arise, as long as their corotation
points exist inside the star.
-- 12 --
3.4. Evolution of model J068
According to Shibata et al. (2002, 2003), models with very small values of the rotation-
profile parameter A are subject to a low T /W dynamical bar-mode instability. Since the
rotational profiles for these types of models are quite steep, it occurred to us that they may
also allow corotation points for various modes within their structure. It also seemed likely
that even one individual stellar model might be subject to instabilities associated not only
with the m = 2 bar-mode, but also other modes. In order to test this idea, we evolved model
J068 with A/Req = 0.44 (ωc/ωs ≈ 6), which falls in the instability region where the low
T /W dynamical bar-mode instability would be expected to set in.
The results of this simulation support our suspicion that an individual model with a
very steep rotational profile may be subject to multiple instabilities associated with differ-
ent azimuthal modes. As shown in the top panel of Figure 10, at the beginning of this
simulation the m = 2 bar-mode grew very quickly, became nonlinear, and dominated the
evolution for quite a while, which is consistent with the results presented by Shibata et al.
(2002). In addition, however, we found that the underlying m = 1 and 3 modes also grew
simultaneously. These odd-numbered modes had growth rates rather slower than the m = 2
mode, but this did not keep the m = 1 mode from finally winning over all the other modes,
including the bar-mode, and manifesting itself as the dominant mode, just as it did in our
earlier simulations. Notice that, again, the amplitude of the m = 2 mode increases when
the m = 1 mode becomes dominant at late times, which suggests that the m = 2 mode is a
harmonic of the m = 1 mode during this period.
The rotational profile of model J068, shown in Figure 11, reveals corotation points for
both m = 1 and 2 modes.
(We could not accurately measure the eigenfrequency of the
m = 3 mode because it never became the dominant mode in the evolution time followed by
our simulation.)
4. Summary and Discussion
We have found that a one-armed spiral instability arises in rotating n = 1 "polytropic"
neutron stars with moderate and high degrees of differential rotation. This is in contrast to
the work of Saijo et al. (2003), which has suggested that such instabilities can arise only in
stars with a softer EOS. As has been suggested by Saijo & Yoshida (2005), the instability
seems to be associated with the existence of a corotation point of the m = 1 mode that lies
inside the star. Given previous results for models with a softer EOS, we conclude that the
compressibility and T /W value of the star are not directly responsible for triggering the
-- 13 --
instability.
We have discovered that, in addition to the m = 1 mode, other higher-order modes
also are allowed to come into play within a single model as long as corotation points for
these modes also exist within the star. This can happen as long as the rotational profile
is sufficiently steep. In our n = 1 polytropic neutron star models, these modes grow rela-
tively slowly compared to previous results for softer EOSs (Centrella et al. 2001; Saijo et al.
2003), but nevertheless they appear to be dynamically unstable. Such modes are likely
to develop in newly born neutron stars because young neutron stars are expected to have
strong differential rotation (Ott et al. 2005b; Akiyama & Wheeler 2005). Also, because they
develop in low T /W configurations on a dynamical time scale, these modes are likely to
be more important than the often-discussed secular bar-mode instability. This will have
important consequences for the detection of gravitational-waves by the Laser Interferome-
ter Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO), because gravitational-waves generated in such
systems would not be monochromatic; our simulations indicate that signals with different
characteristic frequencies are likely to peak at different times.
We suspect that these corotation-related instabilities have not been identified in previous
studies of models that have a stiff EOS because earlier studies have been focused on a search
for, or the analysis of, instabilities that develop on a very short time scale. Most previous
simulations have been followed through only a few tens of Tc, which is not a long enough time
to permit significant amplification of many of the modes we have identified in this study.
Only in this study -- which was initially aimed at examining the secular bar-mode instability
in stars with differential rotation -- have models been evolved long enough to reveal the
corotation instabilities that grow on a longer time scale for this stiff EOS case.
Based on theoretical analyses of differentially rotating configurations that have been
presented by others, we suspect that, in addition to the existence of corotation points, a
resonant cavity is required in order to drive corotation instabilities to very large amplitude.
In particular, Lovelace et al. (1999) have suggested that a local minimum in the radial
vortensity profile can serve as a resonant cavity to trap waves and, hence, trigger a "Rossby
wave" instability. Figures 12 and 13 display the radial vortensity profiles of our models J068
and J127 at different times. (The vortensity plotted here is the ratio between vorticity and
volume density, but the same radial profile is preserved even if we define vortensity as the ratio
between vorticity and surface density.) As these figures show, a fairly wide dip encompasses
the corotation radii of all of the modes that we have found to be unstable in these models.
We note that such a dip in the radial vortensity profile is a common feature for all of our
unstable models. We suspect that waves are trapped inside these vortensity cavities and
are continously amplified through multiple passages across their respective corotation radii.
-- 14 --
Because an off-axis density maximum alone will generate a vortensity minimum and hence
form a resonant cavity that can trap waves inside, it is perhaps not surprising that toroidal
structures frequently have been found to be unstable to a one-armed, spiral instability (Saijo
et al. 2003). However, our new results show that a toroidal structure is not necessary to
generate a vortensity minimum; strong differential rotation alone can create a vortensity
minimum, as indicated for example by our model J068 which does not have a toroidal
structure.
We have also noticed that an unstable mode whose corotation radius falls at a position
that is deeper in the vortensity well has a higher growth rate in any given simulation. Figures
12 and 13, in conjunction with the data provided in Table 2, reveal this correlation between
the growth rate of each mode and the depth of its corotation radius inside the vortensity
well. This correlation is consistent with the results reported by Li et al. (2000) from a study
of the Rossby-wave instability in differentially rotating thin disks. They discovered that
the growth rate of the Rossby-wave instability was proportional to the amplitude of density
bumps/jumps that were introduced into their models, in other words, proportional to the
depth of the vortensity wells that were created by such density jumps.
According to Li et al. (2000), requiring a minimum to be present in a star's radial
vortensity profile before the star can become susceptible to a corotation instability is a gen-
eralization of the Rayleigh inflexion point theorem, which states that a necessary condition
for an instability of this type to develop is that there be an inflection point in the velocity
profile (Drazin & Reid 1981). Given the j-constant-like rotation law (Eq. 1) adopted in our
(as well as previous) studies, the condition ∂2vφ/∂2R = 0 can be evaluated analytically to
show that a velocity inflection point arises at R = A/√3. Hence, for a sufficiently shallow
rotational profile having A > √3Req, the required inflection point does not exist inside the
star. This may also explain why low T /W instabilities only show up in stars with strong
differential rotation (smaller values of A).
Finally, in an effort to draw a further connection between our results and previous anal-
yses, we have examined the azimuthal structure of the unstable eigenmodes in our models.
Figure 14 displays the phase angle of the m = 1 mode as a function of R in the equatorial
plane of model J250. The pattern shows a slightly trailing segment in the innermost re-
gion, then transforms itself into a leading wave outside the density maximum, and finally
a loosely wound, trailing segment appears again outside the corotation radius. This par-
ticular characteristic is reminiscent of the m = 1 structure that was observed in an earlier
study of Papaloizou-Pringle modes by Woodward et. al. (1994), and it is quite similar to
the azimuthal structure of the one-armed spiral mode discussed by Saijo & Yoshida (2005).
In contrast, Figure 15 shows the phase-angle plot of the m = 2 mode for model J068. No
-- 15 --
spiral structure is observed for the m = 2 mode; instead, the phase angles at different radii
are roughly aligned along a straight line indicating a purely bar-like deformation. The radial
eigenfunction of the m = 1 mode shown in Fig. 3 is not monotonic and has a node between
the center and the surface; we suspect it belongs to the family of Papaloizou-Pringle modes
that arises in pressure-supported tori and thick accretion disks. The nodeless feature of the
radial eigenfunctions for m = 2, 3 modes suggests that they might be f-mode oscillations
(this interpretation is consistent with the unstable mode structure presented by Shibata et
al. (2003)); but their structures are different in details: the eigenfunction of the m = 2 mode
(seen in J068) starts from zero at the center, monotonically increases outward, and reaches
a maximum amplitude near the surface; in contrast, the eigenfunction of the m = 3 mode
(seen in J127) has a maximum between the center and the surface.
We would like to thank Hui Li for insightful and useful discussions at the 47th Meeting
of the Division of Plasma Physics of the American Physical Society. We also thank Juhan
Frank, Patrick Motl, Shin Yoshida, and Christian Ott for helpful comments and suggestions.
It is a pleasure to thank Anna Watts for useful conversations at the Eighth Divisional
Meeting of High Energy Astrophysics Division of the American Astronomical Society. We
thank an anonymous referee for helpful suggestions. This work was partially supported
by NSF grants AST-0407070 and PHY-0326311. The computations were performed on the
Supermike cluster and the Superhelix cluster at LSU, and on the Tungsten cluster at National
Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA).
REFERENCES
Akiyama, S., & Wheeler, J. C., 2005, ApJ, 629, 414
Andersson, N. 2003, Class. Quant. Grav., 20, 105
Brown, J. D. 2000, Phys. Rev. D, 62, 084024
Cazes, J. E., & Tohline, J. E. 2000, ApJ, 532, 1051
Centrella, J. M., New, K.C.B., Lowe, L., Brown, J.D. 2001, ApJ, 550, L193
Chandrasekhar, S. 1969, Equilibrium Figures of Equilibrium, New Haven, CT: Yale Univ.
Press
Chandrasekhar, S. 1970, ApJ, 161, 561
Drazin, P. G., & Reid, W. H., Hydrodynamic Stability (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press)
-- 16 --
Durisen, R. H., Gingold, R. A., Tohline, J. E., & Boss, A. P. 1986, ApJ, 305, 281
Frank, J., & Robertson, J.A., 1988, MNRAS, 232, 1
Friedman, J., & Schutz, B. F. 1978, ApJ, 222, 281
Goldreich, P., Goodman, J., & Narayan, R., 1986, MNRAS, 221, 339
Hachisu, I. 1986, ApJS, 61, 479
Ipser, J. R., & Lindblom, L. 1990, ApJ, 355, 226
Ipser, J. R., & Lindblom, L. 1991, ApJ, 373, 213
Lai, D., & Shapiro, S. L. 1995, ApJ, 442, 259
Li, H., Finn, J. M., Lovelace, R. V. E., & Colgate, S. A., 2000, ApJ, 533, 1023
Li, H., Colgate, S. A., Wendroff, B., Liska, R., 2001, ApJ, 551, 874
Liu, Y. T., 2002, Phys. Rev. D, 65, 124003
Lovelace, R. V. E., Hohlfeld, R. G., 1978, ApJ, 221, 51
Lovelace, R. V. E., Li, H., Colgate, S. A., Nelson, A. F., 1999, ApJ, 513, 805
Motl, P. M., Tohline, J. E., & Frank, J. 2002, ApJS, 138, 121
Narayan, R., Goldreich, P., & Goodman, J., 1987, MNRAS, 228, 1
New, K. C. B., Centrella, J. M., & Tohline, J. E. 2000, Phys. Rev. D, 62, 064019
Ott, C. D., Burrows, A., Livne, E., & Walder, R. 2004, ApJ, 600, 834
Ott, C.D., Ou, S., Tohline, J.E., Burrows, A., 2005a, ApJ, 625, L119
Ott, C. D., Burrows, A., Thompson, T. A., Livne, E., & Walder, R. 2005b, astro-ph/0508462
Ou, S., ,Tohline, J.E, Lindblom, L. 2004, ApJ, 617, 490
Papaloizou, J.C.B., Pringle, J.E., 1984, MNRAS, 208, 721
Papaloizou, J.C.B., Lin, D. N. C., 1989, ApJ, 344, 645
Saijo, M., Baumgarte, T. W., & Shapiro, S. L. 2003, ApJ, 595, 352
Saijo, M., & Yoshida, S., 2005, astro-ph/0505543
-- 17 --
Shibata, M., & Karino, S. 2004, Phys. Rev. D, in press (astro-ph/0408016)
Shibata, M., Karino, S., & Eriguchi, Y. 2002, MNRAS, 334,L27
Shibata, M., Karino, S., & Eriguchi, Y. 2003, MNRAS, 343, 619
Tassoul, J.-L. 1978, Theory of Rotating Stars, Princeton: Princeton University Press
Tohline, J. E., Durisen, R. H., & McCollough, M. 1985, ApJ, 298, 220
Tohline, J. E., Hachisu, I., 1990, ApJ, 361, 394
Watts, A. L., Andersson, N., & Jones, D. I. 2005, ApJ, 618, L37
Williams, H. A., & Tohline, J. E. 1988, ApJ, 334, 449
Woodward, J. W., Tohline, J. E., & Hachisu, I., 1988 ApJ, 420, 247
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 18 --
Fig. 1. -- The top panel shows m = 1, 2, and 3 Fourier amplitudes as a function of time t in
the equatorial plane of model J250 when GRR was turned on; t is normalized to the central
spin period Tc of the differentially rotating star. The bottom panels show equatorial-plane
isodensity contours at two different evolutionary times, with inertial-frame velocity vectors
superposed; contour levels are (from the innermost, outward) ρ/ρmax = 0.9, 0.5, 0.1, and
0.01.
-- 19 --
Fig. 2. -- Same as Figure 1, but for model J250 when GRR forces are turned off.
-- 20 --
Fig. 3. -- The top and bottom panels show, respectively, δρ(R) and ρ(R) for model J250 in
the equatorial plane when the m = 1 mode is dominant.
-- 21 --
Fig. 4. -- The rotational profile Ω(R) of model J250 is shown at three different evolutionary
times. The dash-dotted horizontal line identifies the measured eigenfrequency ω1 of the
unstable m=1 mode.
-- 22 --
Fig. 5. -- Same as Fig. 1, but for model J133 when GRR forces are turned off.
-- 23 --
Fig. 6. -- The same as Figure 1, but for model J127 with GRR turned off.
-- 24 --
Fig. 7. -- The angular velocity profile Ω(R) is shown for model J127 at three different
evolutionary times. Dash-dotted horizontal lines denote the measured eigenfrequencies ω1, ω2
and ω3 of various unstable modes. ω2/2 is measured at ∼ 50 Tc, ω3/3 is measured at ∼ 80
Tc, and ω1 is measured at ∼ 400 Tc. To determine a corotation radius, we used a rotational
profile that is around at the same time when each frequency is measured.
-- 25 --
Fig. 8. -- The quadrupole gravitational-wave strain that would be radiated from model J127
as viewed by an observer looking down the Z (rotation) axis.
-- 26 --
Fig. 9. -- The pattern frequencies of different modes is displayed as a function of time for
model J127. The frequency ω2/2 is measured between 40 and 130 Tc, ω3/3 is measured
between 50 and 430 Tc, and ω1 is measured between 220 and 430 Tc.
-- 27 --
Fig. 10. -- Same as Figure 1, but for model J068 when GRR is turned off.
-- 28 --
Fig. 11. -- The angular velocity profile Ω(R) of model J068 is plotted at two different
times during its evolution. Dashed horizontal lines identify measured eigenfrequencies of the
unstable m = 1 and m = 2 modes.
-- 29 --
Fig. 12. -- The radial vortensity profile is shown for model J068 initially (solid line) and
at a time t = 53Tc (dotted line) during its evolution. The horizontal axis is the cylindrical
radius, the vertical axis is the vortensity normalized to the value on the Z axis. The two
vertical dashed lines locate the corotation radii for m = 1 (left) and m = 2 (right) modes.
There seems to be a correlation between the growth rate and the location of corotation radii
inside the vortensity well: the m = 2 mode with a "deeper" corotation radius in the initial
vortensity well was the first unstable mode to arise in the simulation, whereas the m = 1
mode whose corotation radius lies at a "shallower" location in the initial vortensity well
developed later in the evolution.
-- 30 --
Fig. 13. -- The radial vortensity profile is shown for model J127 initially (solid line) and at
a time t = 240Tc (dotted line) during its evolution. The horizontal axis is the cylindrical
radius, the vertical axis is the vortensity normalized to the value on the Z axis. The three
vertical dashed lines locate the corotation radii for m = 1 (left), m = 2 (middle), and m = 3
(right) modes.
-- 31 --
Fig. 14. -- The dotted curve displays the azimuthal structure φ1(R) of the m = 1 eigenfunc-
tion in the equatorial plane of model J250 at t = 95.4Tc when GRR was turned on. The
solid circle denotes the corotation radius; the dashed circle denotes the location of density
maximum.
-- 32 --
Fig. 15. -- Same as Figure 14 but for the m = 2 mode of model J068 when t = 70Tc; there
is no dashed circle because the density maximum lies at the center of the star.
|
0709.2019 | 1 | 0709 | 2007-09-13T08:32:49 | Drift Wave Model of Rotating Radio Transients | [
"astro-ph"
] | During the last few years there were discovered and deeply examined several transient neutron stars (Rotating Radio Transients). It is already well accepted that these objects are rotating neutron stars. But their extraordinary features (burst-like behavior) made necessary revision of well accepted models of pulsar interior structure. Nowadays most popular model for RRATs is precessing pulsar model, which is the subject of big discussion. We assume that these objects are pulsars with specific spin parameters. An important feature of our model, naturally explaining most of the properties of these neutron stars, is presence of very low frequency, nearly transverse drift waves propagating across the magnetic field and encircling the open field lines region of the pulsar magnetosphere. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Drift Wave Model of Rotating Radio
Transients
D.Lomiashvili a,∗ G.Machabeli b I.Malov c
aPurdue University, 525 Northwestern Avenue, West Lafayette, IN, USA
bTbilisi state university, 3 Chavchavadze Ave., 0128, Tbilisi, Georgia
cPushchino Radio Astronomy Observatory, P.N.Lebedev Institute of Physics,
142290, Pushchino, Moscow Region, Russia
Abstract
During the last few years there were discovered and deeply examined several tran-
sient neutron stars (Rotating Radio Transients). It is already well accepted that
these objects are rotating neutron stars. But their extraordinary features (burst-like
behavior) made necessary revision of well accepted models of pulsar interior struc-
ture. Nowadays most popular model for RRATs is precessing pulsar model, which
is the subject of big discussion. We assume that these objects are pulsars with spe-
cific spin parameters. An important feature of our model, naturally explaining most
of the properties of these neutron stars, is presence of very low frequency, nearly
transverse drift waves propagating across the magnetic field and encircling the open
field lines region of the pulsar magnetosphere.
Key words: (stars:) pulsars: individual PSR J1819-1458, PSR J1752+2359, PSRs
J1649+2533, stars: magnetic fields, radiation mechanisms: non-thermal
PACS: 97.60.Gb, 94.20.Bb
1
Introduction
Recently, McLaughlin et al. (2005) reported the discovery of a new class of ra-
dio transients from the Parkes Multibeam Pulsar Survey. The current sample
includes 11 objects characterized by single, dispersed bursts of radio emission
with the durations ranging from 2 to 30 milliseconds. Long-term monitoring
∗ Corresponding author.
Email addresses: [email protected] (D.Lomiashvili),
g [email protected] (G.Machabeli), [email protected] (I.Malov).
Preprint submitted to New Astronomy
30 October 2018
of these objects led to identification of their spin periods (P), ranging from
0.4 to 7 seconds. As McLaughlin et al. (2005) concluded, these objects rep-
resent a previously unknown population of rotation-powered neutron stars,
which were named as Rotating RAdio Transients (RRATs). Another interest-
ing case between normal pulsars and RRATs have been reported earlier (PSRs
J1649+2533 and J1752+2359) by Lewandowski et al. (2004). Understanding
the physical origin of these objects as well as their relationship with normal
pulsars is desirable. There exist few models for this phenomenon: 1) The pre-
cession model; 2) The model suggesting that these objects are pulsars located
slightly below the radio emission death line, and become active occasionally
when the conditions for pair production and coherent emission are satisfied;
3) The third model invoking a radio emission direction reversal in normal pul-
sars. In this picture, our line of sight misses the main radio emission beam
of RRATs but happens to sweep the emission beam when the radio emission
direction is reversed. Last two ideas were suggested by Zhang et al. (2006).
Here we propose another model of RRATs proving once again that they are
normal pulsars with special values of certain parameters.
The paper is organized as follows. Pulsar radio emission mechanism is pre-
sented in Section 2. The generation of the drift waves and their influence on
the curvature of magnetic field lines are discussed in Section 3. Our proposed
model is presented in Section 4. The conclusions are summarized in Section 5.
2 Emission mechanism
As it is known the pulsar magnetosphere is filled by a dense relativistic
electron-positron plasma. The (e+e−) pairs are generated as a consequence
of the avalanche process (first described by Sturrock (1971)) and flow along
the open magnetic field lines. The plasma is multi-component, with a one-
dimensional distribution function ( see Fig.1 from Arons (1981)) and consists
of the following components: the bulk of plasma with an average Lorentz-factor
γp ≃ 10; a tail on the distribution function with γt ≃ 104 and the primary
beam with γb ≃ 106. The main mechanism of wave generation in plasmas of
the pulsar magnetosphere is the cyclotron instability. Generation of waves is
possible if the condition of the cyclotron resonance if fulfilled (Kazbegi et al.,
1991a):
ω − kϕVϕ − kxux +
ωB
γr
= 0,
(1)
where Vϕ is the particle velocity along the magnetic field, γr is the Lorentz-
factor for the resonant particles and ux = cVϕγr/ρωB is the drift velocity of
the particles due to curvature of the field lines (ρ is the radius of curvature of
2
the field lines and ωB = eB/mc is the cyclotron frequency). Here cylindrical
coordinate system is chosen, with the x-axis directed transversely to the plane
of field line, when r and ϕ are the radial and azimuthal coordinates. Generated
waves leave the magnetosphere propagating at very small angles to the pulsar
local magnetic field lines and reach an observer as pulsar radio emission. These
processes take place near the light cylinder where the cyclotron instability
occurs (Lyutikov et al. , 1999).
3 Change of field line curvature and emission direction by drift
waves
It has been shown by Kazbegi et al. (1991b, 1996) that, in addition to the
radio waves, very low frequency, nearly transverse drift waves can be excited
in the same region. The period of the drift waves Pdr can be written as:
Pdr =
e
BP 2
4π2mc
γ
(2)
Where P is the pulsar spin period, B = Bs(R0/R)3 is the magnetic field in the
wave excitement region and γ is the relativistic Lorentz factor of the particles.
It appears that the period of the drift wave can vary in a broad range. The
magnetic field of drift wave adds with pulsar magnetic field as r component
and causes changing of field line curvature ρc. Here and below the cylindrical
coordinate system (x, r, ϕ) is chosen, with the x-axis directed transversely to
the plane of field line, while r and ϕ are the radial and azimuthal coordinates,
respectively.
Even a small change of Br causes significant change of ρc. Variation of the
field line curvature can be estimated as
∆ρ
ρ
≈ kϕr
∆Br
Bϕ
(3)
Here kϕ is a longitudinal component of wave vector and r is distance to the
center of pulsar. It follows that even the drift wave with a modest amplitude
Br ∼ ∆Br ∼ 0.01Bϕ alters the field line curvature substantially, ∆ρ/ρ ∼ 0.1
Since radio waves propagates along the local magnetic field lines, curvature
variation causes change of emission direction.
3
Fig. 1. Geometry of Ω - rotation, K - emission and A - observers axes. Angles δ
and ϑ are constants, while β and α are oscillating with time.
4 The model
There is unequivocal correspondence between the observable intensity and α
(angle between observers line and emission direction (see fig. 1)). Maximum of
intensity corresponds to minimum of α. The period of pulsar is time interval
between neighboring maxima of observable intensity i.e. minima of α (see fig.
2). According to this fact, we can say that the observable period depends on
time behavior of α and as it will appear below it might differ from the spin
period of pulsar.
cos α = A · K
(4)
A and K are unit guide vectors of observers and emission axes respectively.
In the spherical coordinate system (r, ϕ, θ), combined with plane of pulsar
rotation, these vectors can be expressed as:
A = (1, 0, δ)
K = (1, Ωt, β)
4
(5)
(6)
where Ω = 2π/P is the angular velocity of the pulsar. δ is the angle between
rotation and observers axis, and β is the angle between rotation and emission
axis (see fig. 1). From equations (4),(5) and (6) follows that:
α = arccos (sin δ sin β cos Ωt + cos δ cos β)
(7)
In the absence of the drift wave β = β0 = const and consequently the period
of α equals to 2π/Ω, while in the case of existence of drift wave β is oscillating
with time (Lomiashvili et al. , 2006).
Considering that for wavelengths of order of the transverse scale of magneto-
sphere, the treatment of the drift waves as plane waves becomes inappropriate
the geometry of magnetosphere must be taken into account. A treatment in
terms of spherical harmonic eigenmodes with specific l, m is then appropriate
(Gogoberidze et al., 2005). Therefore in general case the amplitude ∆β must
be defined as follows
∆β = X ∆βn sin (ωn
drt + ϕn)
(8)
Here n is number of eigenmode. According to equations (7) and (8) we obtain
α = arccos[sin δ sin(cid:16)β0 + X ∆βn sin (ωn
+ cos δ cos(cid:16)β0 + X ∆βn sin (ωn
drt + ϕn)(cid:17) cos Ωt
drt + ϕn)(cid:17)]
(β0 − δ) + ∆β sin(cid:18)2πk
αk
min = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
ωdr
Ω
+ ϕ(cid:19)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(9)
(10)
Where αk
min is the minimum of α after k revolutions of the pulsar, after time
reckoning 1 . The parameters of the pulse profile (e.g. width, height etc.) sig-
nificantly depend on what the minimal angle would be between emission axis
and observers axis when the first one passes the other (during one revolution).
If the emission cone does not cross the observers line of sight entirely (i.e.
minimal angle between them is more then cone angle ϑ, see inequality (11))
then pulsar emission is unobservable for us. On the other hand, inequality (12)
defines condition that is necessary for emission detection.
αk
min > ϑ
αk
min < ϑ
(11)
(12)
1 as zero point of time reckoning is taken detection moment of any pulse.
5
Fig. 2. The oscillating behavior of α with time for β0 = 1.35, δ = 1.0, ∆β = 0.35,
ωdr = 2π(1/4.26 + 1/204.4)(s−1), Ω = 2π/4.26(s−1), ϕ = 1.5 and Simulated
lightcurve of PSR J1819-1458
(below)
Hence for some values of parameters Ω, ωdr, β, ∆β, δ, ϕ and ϑ (Set A) it is
possible to accomplish following regime: Once condition (12) becomes fulfilled
it stays along k revolutions, therefore pulsar is observable during k periods.
While over the the other m − k revolutions condition (11) accomplishes, con-
sequently pulsar appears "switched off" (see Fig. 2). It means that burst-like
emission occurs.
PSR J1752+2359 has been selected for its unusually long nulling periods. It
had been observed on several occasions between 2000 and 2002 by Lewandowski et al.
6
Fig. 3. Simulated lightcurve of PSR J1752+2359
(2004). The pulsar spends 70- 80% of the time in a quasi-null state. The on-
states occur once every 400-600 periods and last, on average, for ∼ 100 peri-
ods. A more detailed inspection of the on-states reveals that these burst-like
emissions are quite similar in shape and duration and they decay into a null
state in a manner that is quite reasonably described by a te−t/τ function with
τ ∼ 45 seconds. PSR J1752+2359 switches off gradually, rather than suddenly.
Simulated lightcurve of J1752+2359 is presented in Fig. 3.
If we consider these pulsars in the framework of our model their parameters
(spin, angular etc.) will get values shown in Table 1. Simulated lightcurve of
PSR J1819-1458 (RRAT J1819-1458) is presented in Fig. 2.
5 Conclusions
To sum up, drift wave driven model is very convenient since it allows to
explain almost every extraordinary feature of known pulsars such as: ex-
tremely long periods (Lomiashvili et al. , 2006), cyclic variations of radia-
tion intensity (RRATs) and rotational parameters (in prep.), subpulse drift
(Gogoberidze et al., 2005), nullings (Kazbegi et al., 1996), etc. Moreover it
has potentiality to unfold future discoveries in this field.
In long period radio pulsars (Lomiashvili et al. , 2006) relation between peri-
ods of pulsar and drift wave along with pulsar geometry satisfy much precise
7
Table 1
The values of pulsar parameters
PSR
P
∆β
J1752+2359
0.41
0.2
β0
1.2
J1819-1458
4.26
0.35
1.35
δ
1
1
ϑ
0.03
0.03
condition than in RRATs. Therefore total number of RRATs should be much
more than long period radio pulsars.
The precession model is very similar to ours although it has number of dis-
advantages. First of all, it is necessary to take large value of wobble angle to
interpret observational data of some RRATs. In the case of neutron stars this
is hard to explain because of their superfluid interior structure. However, there
is a need of distinguishable sign to elucidate which model is true. Zhang et al.
(2006) reported that one of the such tests would be search of X-ray counter-
part from RRATs. Particularly, presence of a hot-spot thermal component in
the possible X-ray spectra will mean that the emission direction reversal and a
preferred viewing geometry are likely the agents to make a RRAT. While ab-
sence of X-ray radiation indicates that considering pulsars are "not-quite-dead
pulsars before disappearing in the graveyard."
We suggest to investigate the power spectrum of the single-pulse observational
data thoroughly. In our opinion, the power spectrum should be composition of
few slightly broadened areas (ranges with peaks) instead of thin lines. Find-
ing this kind of signature in the power spectra of RRATs will help to asses
wether the origin of the transient nature of these objects is indeed plasmic, as
suggested by our model.
Acknowledgments
This work was partially supported by by Georgian NSF Grant ST06/4-096,
Russian Foundation for the Basic Research (project 06-02-16888) and NSF
(project 00-98685).
References
Arons J., 1981a, Plasma Astrophys., 273
Gogoberidze, G., Machabeli, G.Z., Melrose, D.B., & Luo, Q. 2005, MNRAS,
360, 669
Kazbegi A. Z., Machabeli G. Z., Melikidze G. I., Smirnova T. V., 1991a, Afz,
34, 433
8
Kazbegi A. Z., Machabeli G. Z., Melikidze G. I., 1991b, MNRAS, 253, 377
Kazbegi A. Z., Machabeli G. Z., Melikidze G. I., Shukre C., 1996, A&A, 309,
515
Lewandowski W., Wolszczan A., Feiler G., Konacki M., & Soltysinski T., 2004,
ApJ, 600, 905
Lomiashvili D., Machabeli G., & Malov I., 2006, ApJ, 637, 1010
Lyutikov M, Blandford R., Machabeli G., 1999, MNRAS, 305, 338L
McLaughlin M. A., Lyne A. G., Lorimer D. R., Kramer M., Faulkner A. J.,
Manchester R. N., Cordes J. M., Camilo F., Possenti A., Stairs I. H., Hobbs
G., DAmico N., Burgay M., & OBrien J. T., 2005, (astro-ph/0511587)
Sturrock P. A., 1971, ApJ, 164, 529
Zhang B., Gil J., & Dyks J., 2006, (astro-ph/0601063)
9
|
0704.1114 | 1 | 0704 | 2007-04-09T20:13:36 | Identification of Absorption Features in an Extrasolar Planet Atmosphere | [
"astro-ph"
] | Water absorption is identified in the atmosphere of HD209458b by comparing models for the planet's transmitted spectrum to recent, multi-wavelength, eclipse-depth measurements (from 0.3 to 1 microns) published by Knutson et al. (2007). A cloud-free model which includes solar abundances, rainout of condensates, and photoionization of sodium and potassium is in good agreement with the entire set of eclipse-depth measurements from the ultraviolet to near-infrared. Constraints are placed on condensate removal by gravitational settling, the bulk metallicity, and the redistribution of absorbed stellar flux. Comparisons are also made to the Charbonneau et al. (2002) sodium measurements. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Draft version June 15, 2018
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 7/15/03
7
0
0
2
r
p
A
9
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
4
1
1
1
.
4
0
7
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
IDENTIFICATION OF ABSORPTION FEATURES IN AN EXTRASOLAR PLANET ATMOSPHERE
Lowell Observatory, 1400 W. Mars Hill Rd., Flagstaff, AZ 86001, [email protected]
T. Barman
Draft version June 15, 2018
ABSTRACT
Water absorption is identified in the atmosphere of HD209458b by comparing models for the planet's
transmitted spectrum to recent, multi-wavelength, eclipse-depth measurements (from 0.3 to 1 µm)
published by Knutson et al. (2007). A cloud-free model which includes solar abundances, rainout
of condensates, and photoionization of sodium and potassium is in good agreement with the entire
set of eclipse-depth measurements from the ultraviolet to near-infrared. Constraints are placed on
condensate removal by gravitational settling, the bulk metallicity, and the redistribution of absorbed
stellar flux. Comparisons are also made to the Charbonneau et al. (2002) sodium measurements.
Subject headings: planetary atmospheres - extrasolar planets
1. INTRODUCTION
The discovery of transiting extrasolar planets has
opened the door to direct detections and characteriza-
tion of their atmospheres. Observations using the STIS
instrument on HST provided the first glimpse of what
the photospheric composition is like for a nearby EGP.
Charbonneau et al. (2002) measured the relative change
in eclipse depth for HD209458b across a sodium doublet
(5893A) resulting in the first detection of atomic absorp-
tion in an EGP atmosphere. Following the Na detec-
tion, Vidal-Madjar et al. (2003) discovered an extended
hydrogen-rich atmosphere surrounding HD209458b using
a similar technique as Charbonneau et al., but in the UV.
At Lyman-α wavelengths, HD209458b is ∼ 3 times larger
than in the optical. These detections were made using a
technique called transit spectroscopy as the planet passes
in front of its star. Transit spectroscopy uses the fact that
the wavelength-dependent opacities in the planet's atmo-
sphere obscure stellar light at different planet radii lead-
ing to a wavelength-dependent depth of the light-curve
during primary eclipse. Consequently, searching for rela-
tive changes in eclipse depth as a function of wavelength
directly probes the absorption properties of the planet's
atmosphere with the potential to reveal the presence (or
absence) of specific chemical species.
In this paper, recent measurements of HD209458b's
radius are combined in a multi-wavelength comparison to
model atmosphere predictions. Atmospheric molecular
and atomic absorption are identified and constraints are
placed on the basic atmospheric properties.
2. THE LIMB MODEL
Transit spectroscopy probes the limb of a planet which
is the transition region between the day and night sides.
One would, therefore, expect that, in the presence of
a horizontal temperature gradient between the heated
and non-heated hemispheres, the temperatures across
the limb would be cooler than the average dayside tem-
peratures (Barman et al. 2005; Iro et al. 2005). Re-
cent Spitzer observations of both transiting and non-
transiting hot-Jupiters showing large flux variations with
phase have provided strong evidence supporting such a
day-to-night temperature gradient (Charbonneau et al.
2005; Deming et al. 2005b, 2006; Harrington et al. 2006).
Describing the limb ultimately requires a multi-
dimensional model atmosphere solution; however, as is
common practice, a simpler one-dimensional model is
used here to represent the average properties of the limb,
in both a longitudinal and latitudinal sense. To explore
a variety of limb temperature structures, the incident
stellar flux has been scaled by a parameter α. A model
with α = 0.25 represents an average description of the
entire planet in the presence of very efficient horizontal
energy transport (Barman et al. 2005). Increasing α to
0.5 increases the heating of the model atmosphere mak-
ing it more appropriate for just the dayside which, in this
work, will represent an upper limit to the plausible mean
temperatures at the limb.
The basic chemistry across the limb is modeled assum-
ing chemical equilibrium, determined by minimizing the
free energy while including grain formation. To under-
stand the effects of gravitational settling of grains on the
chemistry and the transmission spectrum, the removal
of grains from the atmosphere is included via two simple
approximations that represent opposite extremes. The
first is the "cond" approximation used by Barman et al.
(2001) and Allard et al. (2001) which simply ignores the
grain opacity without altering the chemistry or abun-
dances. The second is the "rainout" approximation
which iteratively reduces, at each layer, the elemental
abundances (by the appropriate stoichiometric ratios)
involved in grain formation and recomputes the chem-
ical equilibrium with each new set of stratified elemen-
tal abundances. This approach is similar to other rain-
out models (Fegley & Lodders 1996; Burrows & Sharp
1999), except that the depletion of elements is contin-
ued until grains are no longer present.
The transmission of stellar fluxes through the limb of
HD209458b is determined by solving the spherically sym-
metric radiative transfer equation while fully accounting
for scattering and absorption of both intrinsic and ex-
trinsic radiation (Hauschildt 1992; Barman et al. 2001,
2002). Spherical, instead of the more traditional plane-
parallel geometry, naturally accounts for the curvature of
the atmospheric layers and changes in chemistry along
the slant paths through the upper atmosphere. The
planet radius at a given wavelength (Rλ) is obtained by
determining the radial depth at which the transmitted
2
Fig. 1.- Monochromatic transit radii over the STIS spectral range for the baseline rainout model with (red) and without (blue)
photoionization of Na and K. The solid and dotted red lines are the same, except H2O line opacity is excluded in the latter. Horizontal
bars correspond to mean radii across bins with λ-ranges indicated by the width of each bar. STIS measurements by Knutson et al. (2007)
are shown in green with 1 σ error bars. Vertical dashed lines mark the narrow λ-range used by Charbonneau et al. (2002).
flux is equal to e−1 times the incident starlight along
that same path.
3. RESULTS
A cloud-free atmosphere with rainout, α = 0.25, and
solar abundances is adopted as the baseline model. This
model, along with others, is compared to the relative
Rλ measurements of Knutson et al. (2007) which have
a reported precision high enough to constrain many of
the basic atmospheric properties. Since a comparison is
being made to relative Rλ values, the model results were
uniformly scaled to match the observations in the 4580
to 5120A wavelength bin; this scaling was always less
than 0.005RJ up. Overall, the baseline model (red solid
line in Fig. 1) reproduces the observed rise in Rλ toward
shorter wavelengths, the increase across the Na doublet,
and the increase at the far red wavelengths. The baseline
model comparison to the data has a χ2 that is 3 times
smaller than a constant Rλ.
3.1. Water Absorption
Water is predicted to be one of the most abundant
species in an EGP atmosphere and, given its broad ab-
sorption features in the infrared, plays a crucial role in
regulating the temperature-pressure (T-P) profile. The
first major H2O absorption band appears between 0.8
and 1 µm, a region covered by the last two wavelength
bins of Knutson et al. (2007). As illustrated in Fig. 1,
there is excellent agreement between the baseline model
and the observations in this part of the spectrum espe-
cially across the longest wavelength bin that sits on top
of the H2O band. Qualitatively similar water features are
seen in the models of Brown (2001) and Hubbard et al.
(2001); however these models fall many σ below the ob-
servations. The baseline model also predicts mean Rλ-
peaks equal to 1.330, 1.343, and 1.341 RJ up for the next
three water bands (at λ ∼ 1.15, 1.4, and 1.9 µm).
A model that excludes H2O line opacity is also shown
in Fig. 1 and is greater than 10 σ below both the observa-
tions and the baseline model prediction. Removing H2O
opacity also produces a significant drop in Rλ near 0.9
µm that further increases the discrepancy between the
model and overall red/near-IR observations. No other
opacity source could be responsible for the observed rise
in Rλ across this part of the spectrum.
3.2. Photoionization
After the reported sodium detection in the atmosphere
of HD209458b (Charbonneau et al. 2002), there were
several attempts to explain why the strength of this fea-
ture was much lower than expected based on earlier mod-
els (e.g., by Seager & Sasselov, 2000). Barman et al.
(2002) explored departures from local thermodynamic
equilibrium (LTE) which are capable of producing an in-
version in the cores of the Na doublet line profiles. How-
ever, the earlier models of Barman et al. (2001, 2002)
were constructed under the cond approximation and,
consequently, contained a larger number of free met-
als along with TiO and VO molecular absorption com-
pared to a rainout model. These additional sources of
optical/UV opacity lead to a hotter upper atmosphere
and a very shallow photoionization depth for Na (only
a 5% reduction of Na across the region probed by tran-
sit spectroscopy). Fortney et al. (2003) also explored Na
photoionization and found that their atmosphere model
(which included rainout) could be brought into reason-
able agreement with the Na observations. The models
presented here account for the angular dependence of
ionziation on the limb's dayside, but not on the night
side. However, Fortney et al. (2003) have shown that Na
ionization is still present at ∼ 5◦ past the terminator for
pressures relevant to the transit spectrum modeled here.
Figure 1 compares cloud-free solar abundance rainout
models with and without photoionization of Na and K.
While these models include photoionization, the LTE ap-
proximation on the atomic level populations and line
source function is maintained.
Ionization (radially) at
the limb reaches 50% at P ∼ 0.1 and 1.2 mbar for Na
and K, respectively, and stops at P ∼ 2 and 7 mbar, re-
spectively, resulting in a reduction of the Rλ-peaks across
3
The rainout model used here reduces the individual
metal abundances with depth iteratively until clouds do
not form, thus mimicking efficient gravitational settling.
However, the removal of metals is not 100% efficient,
leaving behind a variety of atoms (in addition to Na and
K) to contribute to the line opacity. The impact of rain-
out on the planet's atmosphere is made apparent by com-
paring rainout and cond models (Fig. 3). In the cond
model grain opacities are simply ignored in the transfer
equation while the chemistry remains that of a pure equi-
librium model without any actual removal of refractory
elements. Thus, the cond model represents the minimum
impact of grain formation on the stratified abundances
and leaves behind a considerable amount of free metals
along with molecules like TiO and VO. This leads to
much stronger atomic lines, including Na and K along
with TiO and VO bands.
Apart from a very minor contribution from molecules,
the Rλ features at λ < 0.8µm are all due to atomic line
opacity 1. These narrow features are due to blended lines
from metals like Ca, Al, Fe, Ni, Mn, and Cr. Note that,
while Rayleigh scattering does contribute to the opacity
in the blue/UV, a removal of atomic line opacity would
drop Rλ by ∼ 0.02RJ up for λ < 0.45µm. The top panel of
Fig. 3 compares the solar abundance rainout model with
photoionization (shown in Fig. 1) to a rainout model
with 10× solar abundances. Since the metal abundances
were uniformly scaled, the grain formation and corre-
sponding removal of refractory elements were also uni-
formly enhanced. The additional opacity altered the T-P
profile as well as the total atmospheric extension. These
factors contribute to a similar Rλ pattern in the opti-
cal but enhanced molecular absorption features in the
red/near-IR. The increase in metals increases the H2O
absorption feature along with the wings of the Na and
K doublets (which form deeper in the atmosphere where
photoionization is less important). Also, FeH and CrH
absorption is larger in the metal-rich atmosphere leading
to an increase in Rλ on both sides of the K doublet. The
metal-enhanced Rλ spectrum is in good agreement with
the observations near 0.9µm, but is noticeably too high
across both the K doublet and the H2O band.
Transit spectroscopy can also help constrain the tem-
peratures across the limb. The lower panel of Fig. 3
compares an α = 0.5 model (i.e. a model with a hotter
dayside-like T-P profile) to the cooler α = 0.25 base-
line model. In the hotter model, grain formation is less
pronounced resulting in a greater concentration of most
free metals and, thus, stronger UV/blue absorption lines
than in the α = 0.25 model. Higher temperatures at
depth also result in equilibrium concentrations of Na
and K that are several times lower than found at the
cooler temperatures of the α = 0.25 model. The net re-
sults are two distinctively different Rλ spectra with the
α = 0.25 model being more consistent with the Knutson
et al. measurements.
4. SUMMARY
1 Ballester et al. (2007) claim the Rλ rise in the blue/UV is due
to the Blamer edge of hot hydrogen in an extended atmosphere.
While the present model does not support this explanation, if ver-
ified, it could indicate that rainout is more efficient than predicted
here.
Fig. 2.- Relative flux differences (with time from center of
eclipse) between a wavelength band centered on the Na doublet and
the mean of two wavelength bands on either side of the Na doublet.
The total wavelength range is indicated by vertical lines in Fig. 1.
Each model is cloud-free with solar abundances and α = 0.25. See
Figure legend and text for the distinguishing characteristics of each
model. Symbols are the observations of Charbonneau et al. (2002)
with 1 σ error bars.
the Na and K lines. For K, this reduction extends out to
the line-wings resulting in a significantly smaller mean
Rλ, bringing the model into ∼ 3σ agreement with the
Knutson et al. measurement. The impact of Na pho-
toionization is mostly confined to the core of the doublet
leading to only a small reduction of the mean Rλ, but suf-
ficient to bring the model into ∼ 1σ agreement with the
observations at these wavelengths. Though not included
here, ionization past the terminator onto the night side
should further improve the agreement across the Na and
K doublets. The two narrow features on the red wing
of the K doublet are due to Rb, which should also be
affected by photoionization due to its very low first ion-
ization potential. Photoionization of Rb resulted in a
near complete removal of these features, but reduced the
mean Rλ for this bin by less than 0.002 RJ up.
The broad wavelength bins allowed Knutson et al. to
obtain very precise relative Rλ measurements; however,
as illustrated by the Na doublet, such broad bins lim-
its the constraints that can be placed on atomic absorp-
tion features.
In contrast, the narrow range analyzed
by Charbonneau et al. (2002) resulted in much larger
Rλ error-bars, but still precise enough to easily distin-
guish between the various models shown in Fig. 1. The
flux differences across the Na doublet as a function of
time (measured from the transit center) were computed
for each model using the same narrow wavelength bins
as Charbonneau et al. (2002),
indicated in Fig. 1 by
vertical dashed lines. Fig. 2 compares model transit
curves to the 2002 Na measurements and shows a large
discrepancy between the observations and solar abun-
dance models with pure equilibrium chemistry (cond or
rainout). Including photoionization brings the baseline
rainout model into rough agreement with the observa-
tions. Note the cond model shown in Fig. 2 does not
include photoionization (similar to the LTE model from
Barman et al. (2002)) and illustrates how far off the pre-
dicted Rλ can be across the Na doublet under simplified
assumptions.
3.3. Rainout, Metallicity, and Temperature
4
Fig. 3.- Monochromatic transit radii over the STIS spectral range. Top panel: solar abundance models, cond (black) and rainout(red),
are compared to a model with 10× solar metal abundances including rainout (blue). Lower panel: solar abundances baseline rainout model
with α = 0.25 (red) compared to a similar model with α = 0.5 (blue). Horizontal bars have the same meaning as in Fig. 1.
Photoionziation plays an important role for both Na
and K, and potentially many other species. No evidence
is found to support a large metal enhancement (e.g., 10×
solar), though smaller Jupiter-like enhancements are not
ruled out. Furthermore, the agreement between model
and observations demonstrated here alleviates the need
for substantial cloud coverage along the limb between
0.05 and 0.001 bars, which would otherwise truncate and
flatten the Rλ spectrum (Brown 2001). In the baseline
model, the predicted location of clouds (e.g., MgSiO3)
lies just below the minimum Rλ(∼ 1.315RJ up) across the
STIS wavelength range, consequently deep clouds (and
also very high clouds) remain a possibility.
The models presented here also predict Rλ variations
(∼ 0.02 RJ up) across the 2-0 R-branch of CO in the K-
band. This is inconsistent (at 2.5σ) with a non-detection
of CO based on Keck-NIRSPEC transit spectra taken
in 2002 (Deming et al. 2005a). It is likely that using a
single T-P profile to represent the horizontal and pole-
to-pole variations across the limb averages out too much
of the upper atmospheric structure; this simplification
might explain the K-band discrepancy. High clouds may
also be involved. In addition, the Keck and HST obser-
vations were taken between 1 and 2 years apart and time-
dependent atmospheric variations along the limb cannot
be ruled out (Menou et al. 2003).
While Knutson et al. (2007) did not attribute their
measured Rλ variations to any absorption features (this
was not the focus of their paper), the models presented
above clearly show that these measurements are consis-
tent with strong water absorption near 1 µm. A detection
of water in the limb of HD209458b is nominally at odds
with a recent Spitzer IRS spectrum that shows no H2O
features for this planet(Richardson et al. 2007). These
data were taken during secondary eclipse and directly
probe the planet's dayside with negligible contribution
from the limb. It is possible that the dayside atmosphere
is nearly isothermal (Fortney et al. 2006) which would re-
sult in a spectrum with no detectable water absorption
features, despite a copious water supply. The transmis-
sion spectrum, however, would contain absorption fea-
tures independent of an isothermal dayside or limb.
The author thanks B. Hansen and the referees for their
comments. This research was supported by NASA Ori-
gins and Spitzer Theory Grants and made use of NASA's
Project Columbia computer system.
REFERENCES
Allard, F., Hauschildt, P. H., Alexander, D. R., Tamanai, A., &
Deming, D., Harrington, J., Seager, S., & Richardson, L. J. 2006,
Schweitzer, A. 2001, ApJ, 556, 357
ApJ, 644, 560
Ballester, G. E., Sing, D. K., & Herbert, F. 2007, Nature, 445, 511
Barman, T. S., Hauschildt, P. H., & Allard, F. 2001, ApJ, 556, 885
-. 2005, ApJ, 632, 1132
Barman, T. S., Hauschildt, P. H., Schweitzer, A., Stancil, P. C.,
Baron, E., & Allard, F. 2002, ApJ, 569, L51
Brown, T. M. 2001, ApJ, 553, 1006
Burrows, A. & Sharp, C. M. 1999, ApJ, 512, 843
Charbonneau, D., Allen, L. E., Megeath, S. T., Torres, G., Alonso,
R., Brown, T. M., Gilliland, R. L., Latham, D. W., Mandushev,
G., O'Donovan, F. T., & Sozzetti, A. 2005, ApJ, 626, 523
Charbonneau, D., Brown, T. M., Noyes, R. W., & Gilliland, R. L.
2002, ApJ, 568, 377
Deming, D., Seager, S., Richardson, L. J., & Harrington, J. 2005b,
Nature, 434, 740
Fegley, B. J. & Lodders, K. 1996, ApJ, 472, L37+
Fortney, J. J., Cooper, C. S., Showman, A. P., Marley, M. S., &
Freedman, R. S. 2006, ApJ, 652, 746
Fortney, J. J., Sudarsky, D., Hubeny, I., Cooper, C. S., Hubbard,
W. B., Burrows, A., & Lunine, J. I. 2003, ApJ, 589, 615
Harrington, J., Hansen, B. M., Luszcz, S. H., Seager, S., Deming,
D., Menou, K., Cho, J. Y.-K., & Richardson, L. J. 2006, Science,
314, 623
Hauschildt, P. H. 1992, JQSRT, 47, 433
Hubbard, W. B., Fortney, J. J., Lunine, J. I., Burrows, A.,
Deming, D., Brown, T. M., Charbonneau, D., Harrington, J., &
Sudarsky, D., & Pinto, P. 2001, ApJ, 560, 413
Richardson, L. J. 2005a, ApJ, 622, 1149
Iro, N., B´ezard, B., & Guillot, T. 2005, A&A, 436, 719
Knutson, H. A., Charbonneau, D., Noyes, R. W., Brown, T. M., &
Gilliland, R. L. 2007, ApJ, 655, 564
Menou, K., Cho, J. Y.-K., Seager, S., & Hansen, B. M. S. 2003,
ApJ, 587, L113
Richardson, L. J., Deming, D., Horning, K., Seager, S., &
Harrington, J. 2007, ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints
Seager, S. & Sasselov, D. D. 2000, ApJ, 537, 916
Vidal-Madjar, A., Lecavelier des Etangs, A., D´esert, J.-M.,
Ballester, G. E., Ferlet, R., H´ebrard, G., & Mayor, M. 2003,
Nature, 422, 143
5
|
astro-ph/0405369 | 1 | 0405 | 2004-05-19T15:48:29 | The type IIn supernova 1994W: evidence for the explosive ejection of a circumstellar envelope | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained between 18 and 203 days after explosion. During the luminous phase (first 100 d) the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P-Cygni lines with the absorption minima at -700 km/s; (ii) broad emission lines with BVZI ~4000 km/s; and (iii) broad, smooth wings, most apparent in H-alpha. These components are identified with an expanding circumstellar (CS) envelope, shocked cool gas in the forward post-shock region, and multiple Thomson scattering in the CS envelope, respectively. The absence of broad P-Cygni lines from the supernova is the result of the formation of an optically thick, cool, dense shell at the interface of the ejecta and the CS envelope. We model the supernova deceleration and Thomson scattering wings to recover the density, radial extent and Thomson optical depth of the CS envelope during the first month. We reproduce the light curve with a hydrodynamical model and find it to be powered by a combination of internal energy leakage after the explosion of an extended pre-supernova (~10^15 cm) and luminosity from circumstellar interaction. We recover the pre-explosion kinematics of the CS envelope: it is close to homologous expansion with outer velocity ~1100 km/s and a kinematic age of ~1.5 yr. The CS envelope's high mass and kinetic energy, combined with its small age, strongly suggest that the CS envelope was explosively ejected about 1.5 yr before the supernova explosion. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 22 (2004)
Printed 25 November 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
The type IIn supernova 1994W: evidence for the explosive
ejection of a circumstellar envelope
Nikolai N. Chugai1⋆, Sergei I. Blinnikov2, Robert J. Cumming3, Peter Lundqvist3,
Angela Bragaglia4, Alexei V. Filippenko5, Douglas C. Leonard6, Thomas Matheson5,7,
Jesper Sollerman3
1Institute of Astronomy, RAS, Pyatnitskaya 48, 109017 Moscow, Russia
2Institute for Theoretical and Experimental Physics, 117218 Moscow, Russia
3Stockholm Observatory, Department of Astronomy, Stockholm University, AlbaNova University Center, SE-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden
4Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna, via Ranzani 1, 40127 Bologna, Italy
5Department of Astronomy, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-3411 USA
6Five College Astronomy Department, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003-9305 USA
7Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA
Accepted 12 May 2004. Received 11 May 2004; in original form 29 March 2004.
ABSTRACT
We present and analyse spectra of the Type IIn supernova 1994W obtained be-
tween 18 and 203 days after explosion. During the luminous phase (first 100 days)
the line profiles are composed of three major components: (i) narrow P-Cygni lines
with the absorption minima at −700 km s−1; (ii) broad emission lines with blue ve-
locity at zero intensity ∼ 4000 km s−1; and (iii) broad, smooth wings extending out
to at least ∼ 5000 km s−1, most apparent in Hα. These components are identified
with an expanding circumstellar (CS) envelope, shocked cool gas in the forward post-
shock region, and multiple Thomson scattering in the CS envelope, respectively. The
absence of broad P-Cygni lines from the supernova (SN) is the result of the forma-
tion of an optically thick, cool, dense shell at the interface of the ejecta and the CS
envelope. Models of the SN deceleration and Thomson scattering wings are used to
recover the density (n ≈ 109 cm−3), radial extent [∼ (4 − 5) × 1015 cm] and Thomson
optical depth (τT >
∼ 2.5) of the CS envelope during the first month. The plateau-like
SN light curve is reproduced by a hydrodynamical model and is found to be powered
by a combination of internal energy leakage after the explosion of an extended pre-
supernova (∼ 1015 cm) and subsequent luminosity from circumstellar interaction. The
pre-explosion kinematics of the CS envelope is recovered, and is close to homologous
expansion with outer velocity ∼ 1100 km s−1 and a kinematic age of ∼ 1.5 yr. The
high mass (∼ 0.4 M⊙) and kinetic energy (∼ 2 × 1048 erg) of the CS envelope, com-
bined with small age, strongly suggest that the CS envelope was explosively ejected
∼ 1.5 yr prior to the SN explosion.
Key words: supernovae -- circumstellar matter -- stars: supernovae: individual (SN
1994W)
1
INTRODUCTION
Recent studies of supernovae (SNe) have made considerable
progress in our knowledge of what makes a star explode.
From observations of light curves and spectra, theories of
pre-supernova evolution are now better constrained than
ever. Conventional wisdom says that Type II SNe (SNe II)
are caused by core collapse in massive, usually red super-
giant stars. In general, theory has no trouble accounting for
the main features of the spectra and light curves of these ob-
jects. However, some SNe II are remarkably different, and
many of their observational properties are not yet under-
stood.
⋆ E-mail: [email protected] (NNC);
(RJC); [email protected] (PL)
[email protected]
These events, sometimes known as narrow-line Type
II SNe or SNe IIn (Schlegel 1990; Filippenko 1997), show
2
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
1987F (Filippenko
1988Z
(Filippenko
in early spectra the presence of strong, narrow Balmer
emission lines on top of broad emission lines. Exam-
ples of prominent SNe IIn include 1978K (Ryder et al.
1993), SNe 1983K (Niemela, Ruiz & Phillips 1985), 1984E
(Dopita et al. 1984), 1986J (Rupen et al. 1987; Leibundgut
1989; Wegner & Swanson
1991),
1994),
1991;
Stathakis & Sadler
1991; Turatto et al. 1993; Benetti et al. 1998), 1994W
(Cumming, Lundqvist & Meikle 1994; Meikle et al. 1994;
Sollerman, Cumming & Lundqvist 1998, hereafter SCL98),
1995G (Pastorello et al. 2002) and 1995N (Fransson et al.
2002). More recent examples of SNe II with narrow lines
are SNe 1997cy (Germany et al. 1994; Turatto et al. 2000),
1998S (Filippenko & Moran 1998; Bowen et al.
2000;
Leonard et al. 2000; Fassia et al. 2001; Chugai et al. 2002;
Fransson et al. 2004), 1999E (Filippenko 2000; Rigon et al.
2003) and, most remarkably, SN 2002ic, which has been
identified as a likely SN Ia in a dense circumstellar (CS)
envelope (Hamuy et al. 2003), are more recent examples of
SNe with narrow lines.
The general wisdom is
that the narrow lines of
SNe IIn originate from the ionized, dense circumstellar gas
(Henry & Branch 1987; Filippenko 1991). The interaction
of SN ejecta with the dense CS gas modifies the SN op-
tical spectrum and may fully power the SN IIn luminos-
ity (Chugai 1990, 1992). Interaction with the dense CS gas
is indicated also by strong radio and X-ray flux detected
in some SNe IIn. SNe IIn are diverse (Filippenko 1997),
probably reflecting variations in CS gas density and struc-
ture (smooth vs. clumpy) and SN ejecta parameters (mass
and energy). On top of this there is also the possibility of
asymmetry of both the ejecta and CS gas. Nevertheless,
the primary factors responsible for the diversity (mass of
main-sequence star, explosion mechanism, structure of pre-
supernova, mass-loss mechanism and history, and progenitor
binarity) are still unknown. All these uncertainties, along
with the possibility of using them to probe pre-supernova
behaviour prior to core collapse, add to the interest in these
phenomena.
SN 1994W, discovered on 1994 July 29 (UT dates
are used throughout this paper) at the pre-maximum
phase (Cortini & Villi 1994), is among the brightest known
SNe IIn. Its proximity (25±4 Mpc; SCL98) and early dis-
covery made it an ideal case for detailed study. Preliminary
interpretation of the spectra showed that SN 1994W ex-
ploded in the dense CS envelope with a characteristic ra-
dius of ∼ 1015 cm, while the amount of ejected 56Ni was low
(< 0.015 M⊙; SCL98).
Here we further advance our understanding of both the
CS envelope properties and the phenomenon of SN 1994W as
a whole by analysing the spectra and photometry discussed
by SCL98 as well as other, hitherto unpublished, spectra. In
our study we take two different approaches to modelling the
data. The first is the simulation of the Hα profile, which pro-
vides an efficient and straightforward probe of the Thomson
optical depth and density of the CS envelope. The second ap-
proach is a hydrodynamical simulation of the SN explosion
and the light curve based upon the upgraded version of the
code stella (Blinnikov et al. 1998, 2000). An early version
of this code proved effective in computing the hydrodynam-
ics and light curve for interaction with a dense CS envelope
in the case of SN 1979C (Blinnikov & Bartunov 1993).
This paper has the following structure. We start with
a description of the data (Sections 2 and 3) and the gen-
eral picture which arises from a qualitative analysis (Section
4). Next we quantify parameters of the CS envelope using
a thin-shell deceleration model and a line-profile simulation
(Section 5). We then use the gross parameters of the recov-
ered density distribution as input for detailed hydrodynam-
ical modelling (Section 6). Our findings are summarized and
discussed in Section 7.
2 OBSERVATIONS
2.1 Photometry
The photometric data were compiled and described in
SCL98. In our light-curve models in Section 3 we use the
photometry up to day 197, assuming SN 1994W exploded
on 1994 July 14.0 (SCL98). For a discussion of the explosion
date, see Section 3.
2.2 Spectroscopy
The spectroscopic observations are described in Table 1.
Some of these, taken from La Palma, were presented in Ta-
ble 2 of SCL98. We supplement them with spectra taken at
the Lick, Keck, and Bologna Observatories. The data cover
epochs 18 -- 203 days after explosion. We now describe these
spectra in detail.
The La Palma spectra were reduced using the figaro
(Shortridge 1990) and NOAO iraf1 packages. The CCD
frames were bias-subtracted, flat-fielded, and corrected for
distortion and cosmic rays. Wavelength calibration was car-
ried out using arc spectra of copper-neon and copper-argon
lamps, and should be accurate to better than 0.1 A for the
high-resolution WHT and INT spectra, 0.5 A for the low-
resolution WHT and INT spectra, and 1 A for the NOT
spectrum.
The Bologna spectrum was obtained with the Bologna
Astronomical Observatory 1.5-m telescope with the spec-
trograph BFOSC on 1994 July 31.9 and reported by
Bragaglia et al. (1994).
Spectra were also obtained at the Shane 3 m reflec-
tor at Lick Observatory on days 21, 49, 57, 79 and 89, and
at the W. M. Keck II 10 m telescope on day 197. The
Lick observations were made with the Kast double spec-
trograph (Miller & Stone 1993). The Keck spectrum was
obtained using the Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer
(LRIS; (Oke et al. 1993)) with a 1200 lines mm−1 grating.
For details, see Table 1.
For the Lick data, all one-dimensional sky-subtracted
spectra were extracted in the usual manner, and each spec-
trum was then wavelength and flux calibrated, as well as
corrected for continuum atmospheric extinction and tel-
luric absorption bands (Wade & Horne 1988; Bessell 1999;
Matheson et al. 2000).
1 IRAF (Image Reduction and Analysis Facility) is distributed by
the National Optical Astronomy Observatories, which are oper-
ated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy,
Inc., under cooperative agreement with the US National Science
Foundation.
Table 1. Log of spectroscopic observations
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 3
Phase(a)
Telescope/
spectrograph
Spectral
res. (A)
Flux
standard
Seeing Wavelength
coverage (A)
(arcsec)
Observers
BD+25◦3941
--
BD+17◦4708
SP1337+705
BD+28◦4211,
BD+26◦2606
Grw+70◦5824
Grw+70◦5824
BD+28◦4211,
BD+26◦2606,
BD+17◦4711
Feige 110,
BD+26◦2606
Feige 110,
BD+26◦2606
--
HD 19445
Feige 34
1.6
2.6 -- 3.0
2.5
1.1 -- 1.7
4+
0.9 -- 2.9
1.0 -- 1.5
3 -- 5
2 -- 3
3 -- 4
1.6
1.2
0.9
4600-7800
6507 -- 6675
4250 -- 7020
4290 -- 8005
3120 -- 10400
3300 -- 9360
4255 -- 5060,
6345 -- 7150
3140 -- 9920
AB
EZ
AJB, AF, CP
MB
AJB, AF, TM
RR
RR
AJB, AF, TM
3130 -- 8040
AF, LH, TM
3160 -- 8020
AF, TM
5485-7370
5628 -- 6939
5000-10000
RR, NO
AF, LH
JS, RC
11
2.7
4
4
4
6
6
12
Date
(UT)
1994 07 31.9
1994 07 31.9
1994 08 04
1994 08 13.9
1994 09 01
1994 09 08.9
1994 09 08.9
17.9
17.9
21.5
30.9
49.5
56.9
56.9
BAO/BFOSC 13
INT/IDS
Lick/Kast
WHT/ISIS
Lick/Kast
0.25
7
2.7
5
WHT/ISIS
WHT/ISIS
1994 09 09
57.5
Lick/Kast
1994 10 01
79.5
Lick/Kast
1994 10 11
89.5
Lick/Kast
1994 11 12.3
1995 01 26.6
1995 02 01.9
121.3
196.6
202.9
INT/IDS
Keck/LRIS
NOT/LDS
Note: (a) Days after 1994 July 14.0. (b) Observers: AB -- A. Bragaglia; AF -- A. Filippenko; AJB -- A. J. Barth; CP -- C. Peng; EZ -- E.
Zuiderwijk; JS -- J. Sollerman; LH -- L. Ho; MB -- M. Breare; NO -- N. O'Mahony; TM -- T. Matheson; RC -- R. Cumming; RR -- R.
Rutten.
The spectra were flux-calibrated by comparison with
the standard stars listed in Table 1. The sky position of
SN 1994W in late 1994 meant that the observations were
made when the supernova was at rather low altitude, and
correspondingly high airmass. We corrected for the differ-
ence in atmospheric extinction brought about by the differ-
ing zenith distances of the supernova and the standard star.
Airmasses at different zenith distances were taken from the
relation given by Murray (1983), and we used the tables of
extinction coefficient versus wavelength for La Palma given
by King (1985).
With two exceptions, all our spectra were taken at the
parallactic angle (Filippenko 1982), minimising slit losses
due to atmospheric dispersion. The first exception was the
day 18 Bologna spectrum of SN 1994W, which shows con-
siderable loss of flux in the blue. We corrected the slope of
the spectrum to match the B and V photometry from the
same night reported by Bragaglia et al. (1994) using filter
functions from Gualandi & Merighi (2001).
The second exception was the standard-star observation
for the day 31 La Palma spectrum. While the SN 1994W
spectrum was taken at the parallactic angle, the standard-
star spectrum was taken at an airmass of 1.6, with the slit at
position angle 33◦ when the parallactic angle was 119◦. No
contemporary filter photometry is available for correcting
the supernova spectrum. The effect on the day 31 supernova
spectrum depends on how the standard star was positioned
in the slit, which in turn depends on the combination of the
spectral response of the acquisition camera at the telescope.
The acquisition camera at the WHT in 1994 August was
a Westinghouse ETV-1625 whose response curve peaked at
4400 A, with half-power points at 3400 A and 6200 A (C.
Jackman & D. Lennon, 2004, private communication). The
standard star, Grw +70◦5824, is a DA3 white dwarf with
a blue spectrum. It therefore seems likely that the slit was
positioned so that maximum transmission was at around
4400 A, at the blue end of the spectrum.
We have estimated the amount of flux that would be
lost with wavelength, and find that the losses would largely
have been at the red end of the standard spectrum -- as
much as 80 per cent of the flux at 8000 A. The effect on
the calibrated supernova spectrum was thus to make it ap-
pear redder than it really was. Since the day 31 spectrum is
already remarkably blue (Section 3.1.3), we have made no
further correction to the spectrum; the calibration can be
regarded as a conservative estimate of the already extreme
continuum slope.
No observations of flux standards were available for the
INT spectra taken on days 18 and 121. A very rough flux-
calibration of the day 18 INT spectrum was made by assum-
ing that the flux in the wings of the Hα line (at the red and
blue edges of the spectrum) declined at the same rate as the
visual magnitude estimates between days 18 and 31, i.e., by
a factor of about 1.6 in fλ. A similarly rough calibration
of the day 121 spectrum was made by comparing with our
R-band photometry from day 123 (SCL98).
The spectrum taken on day 197 was scaled so that the
flux in the narrow Hα feature matched that in the day 203
spectrum. The continua then match well in the overlap re-
gion.
Spectra from days 18, 57, 121 and 203 were displayed in
SCL98 (their Figs. 2 and 3). They also showed the portion
of the spectrum on day 31 covering Hα.
As a final correction, we noted that all the spectra cover
the entire V band, and we scaled each spectrum to match
contemporary V -band photometry. The procedure was as
follows. We assumed that the day 57 La Palma spectrum was
correct. Next, we interpolated the V magnitudes in the light
4
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Figure 1. Spectra of SN 1994W: days 18 -- 203. The spectra have been shifted vertically for clarity. No heliocentric correction has been
applied to the wavelength scale. The ticks on the right-hand side mark the zero level for each spectrum. The spectra from day 79 and
later have been multiplied by a constant, noted in parentheses. The La Palma spectra from days days 18 and 57 and the day 197 Keck
spectrum are not shown. Telluric absorption lines in the day 31 spectrum are marked.
curve presented by SCL98. This gave us relative fluxes in V
for all the epochs. We then integrated all the plateau spec-
tra (days 21 -- 89), multiplying them by a standard V filter
function (Allen 1973) with transmission values interpolated
between points at 100-A intervals. The whole spectrum was
then scaled linearly in flux so that the integrated V magni-
tude corresponded to the V -band photometry in SCL98.
the spectral development for each epoch in turn, and then
concentrate on the individual features and ionic species.
In this section, quoted line fluxes (see Table 3) were
measured by interpolating the neighbouring continuum
across the line in question. The line fluxes are net fluxes
and do not correct for the narrow P-Cygni absorption com-
ponents.
3 RESULTS
3.1 Spectral evolution
3.1.1 Day 18
During the period of our observations, the spectrum of SN
1994W (Figs. 1 and 2) was dominated by narrow Balmer
emission lines, initially with P-Cygni absorption features,
and accompanied by a wide variety of weaker lines show-
ing broad emission and/or narrow P-Cygni profiles (cf.
Filippenko & Barth 1994). Line identifications are presented
in Table 2 and in Fig. 3. In the following sections, we examine
The low-resolution Bologna spectrum showed a blue contin-
uum with prominent lines of Hα and Hβ, which are nar-
row with broad wings. The latter have been interpreted as
an effect of multiple Thomson scattering of line photons in
the CS envelope (Chugai 2001). Our high-resolution spec-
trum for this epoch (Fig. 3 in SCL98) covers only the Hα
line, but shows a narrow P-Cygni absorption at about −800
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 5
Figure 2. Spectra of SN 1994W: days 18 -- 121. Same as Fig. 1, but with the ordinate stretched to show the weaker features more clearly.
The day 197 and 203 spectra are omitted. Telluric absorption lines in the day 31 spectrum are marked.
km s−1 not visible in the low-resolution spectrum. The emis-
sion peak is close to the velocity of nearby H ii emission,
measured at 1249±3 km s−1, which we adopt as our best es-
timate of the heliocentric velocity of the supernova. The in-
terstellar Na i D lines give a somewhat lower value, 1185±15
km s−1, measured from the day 31 spectrum.
3.1.2 Day 21
The rapid brightening of the supernova at this epoch
(SCL98) was reflected in increasingly strong Balmer lines.
The spectrum showed a strong blue continuum, and promi-
nent lines of Hα, Hβ and Hγ, all exhibiting narrow P-
Cygni profiles with broad emission wings. The Balmer decre-
ment was remarkably shallow, with flux ratio Hα:Hβ:Hγ
= 1.1:1:0.5 (dereddened assuming EB−V = 0.17 mag from
SCL98 and the reddening law of Cardelli, Clayton & Mathis
1989). The Balmer lines were accompanied by an asymmet-
ric triangular broad emission feature corresponding to He i
λ5876, possibly blended with the Na i D doublet, and many
narrow P-Cygni lines of Fe ii.
3.1.3 Day 31
By day 31, the blue continuum appeared to have steepened.
The calibration of the spectrum is uncertain, as noted in
Section 2 above, but the evidence suggests that the spec-
trum really was as remarkably blue as it appears to be. The
Balmer lines still show a flat decrement, as on day 21, with
measured ratios 1.2:1:0.6. The blue wings in Hβ and Hγ ap-
pear to be stronger relative to the red wings, compared to
day 21 (Fig. 5, right-hand panel).
Broad, triangular He i emission lines with full-width at
half-maximum velocity width (vFWHM) around 2500 km s−1
were stronger than on day 21 (Figs. 2 and 5). He i λ5876
was accompanied by strong He i λ7065. Broad He i λ6678
appeared to fill out the red wing of Hα, and the triplet
line at λ4471 is present as broad emission which underlies
neighbouring Fe ii lines. All but He i λ7065 also showed
6
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Figure 3. Line identifications for days 49 (upper spectrum) and 79. The spectra have been continuum-subtracted and shifted for clarity.
Each line is indicated by a broken vertical bar marking heliocentric velocities −700 km s−1 and 0 km s−1. Horizontal bars longward of
6700 A mark regions where telluric absorption has been removed.
weak, narrow P-Cygni features with minima around −700
km s−1.
A similarly triangular emission feature is seen at 7890 A,
which we identify with the Mg ii triplet at 7877 -- 7896 A (see
Section 3.3.4).
Stronger narrow P-Cygni lines with absorptions around
−600 km s−1 are seen in O i λ7773, Si ii λλ6347, 6371, and
a large number of Fe ii lines. The O i and Si ii lines are dom-
inated by absorption, while in Fe ii the equivalent widths of
the absorption and emission components are comparable.
3.1.5 Day 57
Eight days later, the Balmer decrement showed no signifi-
cant change at 1.5:1:0.6. The spectrum showed ever stronger
Fe ii lines. No unambiguous trace of He i remained (Fig. 2),
suggesting that the emission feature at ∼6000 A was now
only due to Na i D. The emission in this feature broadened
and flattened out, extending from −4000 km s−1 to +6000
km s−1 (Figs. 2 and 5). The Mg ii λ7877 -- 7896 feature was
still present, but appeared more flat-topped than on day
49. P-Cygni lines of O i λ8446 and the Ca ii near-infrared
triplet, also weakly present on day 49, were clearly detected
in the red.
3.1.4 Day 49
The day 49 spectrum (Figs. 1, 2 and 3) shows a redder con-
tinuum. The Balmer decrement steepened to 1.5:1:0.6. The
He i λ5876 and Na i D blend was again asymmetric as on
day 21, and appeared to have a broader blue wing. The only
other remaining He i line, λ7065, is no longer as prominent
as on day 31. The Mg ii λ7877 -- 7896 feature was still clearly
visible. Similar broad features were detected at ∼8230 A and
∼9220 A, lending support to the identification with Mg ii.
Many new Fe ii lines are apparent, plus Ca ii H & K
and possibly the Ti ii multiplet at around 3500 A. The wider
wavelength coverage picked up a large number of overlapping
narrow P-Cygni lines in the blue; most of the identified ones
are H i and Fe ii.
3.1.6 Day 79
The continuum appeared again to have reddened (Fig. 1).
The Balmer lines decreased in strength relative to the now
very numerous Fe ii P-Cygni lines (Figs. 2 and 3). The
Hα/Hβ ratio was now 2.7±0.3, close to Case B. Narrow over-
lapping absorption and P-Cygni features completely domi-
nated in the blue. In the red, the feature at 7890 A had
disappeared, but O i λ8446 and the Ca ii triplet had in-
creased in strength. The narrow absorption in Na i D had
increased markedly in strength since day 57, and broad Na i
emission was no longer apparent.
Narrow P-Cygni profiles of O i λ7002 and Sc ii ap-
peared, the latter possibly accompanied by a broad emission
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 7
Table 2. Line identifications for days 18 -- 121. Symbols are as follows: a -- line seen in absorption only; b -- broad emission, e --
emission; p -- P-Cygni profile; -- (dash) -- no feature detected, : (colon) -- uncertain identification. The Fe ii lines were identified with
the help of the line lists of Fuhr, Martin & Wiese (1988) and Sigut & Pradhan (2003). Wavelengths in A are from these references and
from van Hoof (1999).
Identification
18
21
31
49
57
79
89
121
Identification
18
21
31
49
57
79
89
121
Fe ii 3764.11
+H11 3770.63
H10 3797.90
H9 3835.38
Mg ii 3849.3
H8 3889.05
Fe ii 3914.51
Ca ii 3933.66
Ca ii 3968.47
+ Hǫ 3970.07
Hδ 4101.73
Fe ii 4233.12
Fe ii 4296.57
+Fe ii 4303.17
Hγ 4340.46
Fe ii 4351.76
Fe ii 4385.38
Fe ii 4416.83
He i 4471.5
Mg ii 4481.2
Fe ii 4520.21
Fe ii 4549.46
+Fe ii 4555.88
Fe ii 4576.34
+Fe ii 4582.83
Fe ii 4629.34
Hβ 4861.32
Fe ii 4923.94
Fe ii 5018.44
Fe ii 5169.05
Fe ii 5197.59
Fe ii 5234.63
+Sc ii 5239.81
Fe ii 5264-84
Fe ii 5316.62
+Fe ii 5325.54
Fe ii 5362.85
Fe ii 5425.26
Fe ii 5477.66
Sc ii 5526.79
p
p
p
p
p
--
p
pb
pb
p
--
pb
--
p
p
--
p
p
p
p
p
p
p
--
p
pb
pb
p
p
pb
p
p
p
--
p
p
--
p
p
--
p
p
p
pb
pb
p
p
pb
p
--
p
--
--
--
--
--
--
pb
--
--
--
--
p
--
--
pb
--
--
--
ba
p
--
p
p
p
p
p
p
p
pb
pb
pb
p
p
--
p
p
--
--
--
--
p
--
pb
pb
pb
p
--
--
p
--
--
--
--
p
p
pb
pb
pb
p
p
--
p
p
--
--
--
--
p
p
pb
pb
pb
p
p
p
p
p
p
pe
--
pb
p
p
pb
pb
pb
p
p
p
p
p
p
pe
p
pb
--
p
p
--
p
p
p
pb
pb
p
p
pb
p
--
p
--
--
p
p
p
pb
pb
pb
p
p
p
p
p
p
pe
p
pb
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
pb
p:
p:
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
p:
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
pb
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
p
Sc ii 5657.90
+Sc ii 5658.36
He i 5875.61
Na i 5889.95
+Na i 5895.92
Fe ii] 5990.60
+Fe ii] 5991.38
Fe ii] 6150.10
Sc ii 6245.63
+Fe ii 6247.58
Si ii 6347.11
Si ii 6371.37
Fe ii 6416.91
Fe ii 6456.38
Fe ii 6517.02
Hα 6562.80
He i 6678.15
O i 7002.20
He i 7065.22
[Fe ii] 7214.71
Ca ii] 7291.47
Fe ii 7308.07
+Fe ii 7310.22
Ca ii] 7323.89
Fe ii 7449.34
Fe ii 7462.41
Fe ii 7711.72
O i 7773.8
Mg ii 7877-96
Mg ii 8213.98
+Mg ii 8234.64
O i 8446.36
Ca ii 8498.03
Ca ii 8542.09
Ca ii 8662.14
Mg ii 9218.25
+Pa9 9229.01
+Mg ii 9244.26
Paǫ 9545.97
Paδ 10049.4
+Mg ii 10092.1
--
b
--
pb
--
b:
--
b:
b:
b:
ba:
ba:
--
p
pb
p
p
p
p
p
pb
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
p
p
b
b:
p
--
p
p
--
--
--
p
p
--
--
--
pb
p:
--
--
--
--
p
p
--
--
--
pb
pb
--
b
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
p
b
--
--
pb
p
p
--
--
--
pb
--
--
b
--
--
--
--
--
--
p
p
b
b:
p
--
p
--
b
pb:
b:
--
ep:
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
e
--
--
--
--
e
--
e
a
--
p
ep
p
pb
p
p
p
p
p
pb
--
p
--
p
--
p
--
p
p
p
p
--
a
--
p
ep
p
pb
p
p
p
p
p
pb
--
p
--
p
--
p
--
p
p
p
p
--
--
p
p
p
p
b
pb:
b
pb:
component. Semi-forbidden lines of Fe ii] λλ5991, 6150 were
clearly detected for the first time.
3.1.7 Day 89
The spectrum on day 89 was essentially the same as on day
79, but was weaker and showed a redder continuum. The
Hα/Hβ ratio increased to 5.2±1.3, and Hγ was now blended
with Fe ii lines. Both Na i D and O i λ7002 continued to
increase in strength.
3.1.8 Day 121
Our spectrum for day 121 (Figs. 1 and 2) has smaller wave-
length coverage and rather poor signal-to-noise ratio, but it
is obvious that a dramatic change had occurred since day
89, paralleling the supernova's precipitous fading after day
∼110 (SCL98).
As reported by SCL98, three narrow emission lines are
unambiguously detected: Hα with a vFWHM of 780 km s−1,
plus much fainter Na i D (vFWHM = 775 km s−1) with a P-
Cygni absorption component, and Ca ii] λ7291 (vFWHM =
475km s−1) close to the red edge of the spectrum. The emis-
sion peak of Hα had moved farther to the red than on day
89, at about +70±100 km s−1. The Sc ii P-Cygni feature at
5530 A appears also to have survived since day 89, showing
a sharp absorption feature at −800 ± 100 km s−1.
Underlying the narrow features is what appears to be
a low, undulating continuum. SCL98 argued that the sharp
drop to zero flux at 5620 A was evidence that the contin-
8
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Axelrod 1980). These similarities suggest that SN 1994W
had reached its nebular phase at this epoch.
3.1.9 Day 197
Our spectrum, not shown in Figs. 1 and 2, detected only
Hα, which was perhaps just resolved. Its velocity width was
vFWHM ≈ 625 km s−1, consistent with no change since day
121. Na i emission at the same strength relative to Hα as
on day 121 would not have been detected, given the low
signal-to-noise ratio of the spectrum.
3.1.10 Day 203
The day 203 spectrum (Fig. 1) confirms that narrow, un-
resolved Hα is the only detectable feature from the su-
pernova. The galaxy background probably dominates the
remaining, noisy continuum, though photometry indicates
that the supernova can account for up to 50 per cent of the
flux (SCL98). SCL98 put limits on the flux in broad lines of
width ∼4500 km s−1.
Figure 4. Luminosity evolution of various lines. Line fluxes are
detailed in Table 3. A distance of 25.4 Mpc and an extinction of
EB−V = 0.17 mag were adopted.
3.2 General spectral appearance
3.2.1 Line profiles
The spectra reveal two major types of line profile-forming
components (SCL98; Fig. 5): narrow P Cygni profiles and
broad lines. However, careful inspection reveals that while
the blue velocity at zero intensity (BVZI) of the broad lines
does not exceed −5000 km s−1, Hα at the luminous stage
shows a red wing extending at least up to +7000 km s−1.
This wing is clearly detectable in Hα on days 31, 49 and
57 (Figs. 2 and 5). We believe that this wing is caused by a
Thomson scattering effect in the expanding CS envelope (see
also Section 4). Since the intensity of the Thomson scatter-
ing wing is proportional to the line intensity, the wing may
be present but not obvious in other, weaker lines.
The intrinsically broad lines typically have a triangular
profile. On day 31 they show an apparent skewing toward
the blue, possibly due to an occultation effect. The Na i
doublet on day 57 shows a flat-topped profile with BVZI≈
4000 km s−1. No other line shows such a flat-topped profile,
nor does Na i doublet at other epochs, though the feature
is dominated by He i λ5876 earlier than this. This suggests
that the material emitting Na i has a narrower distribution
of velocity than the other broad lines (see Section 4.2).
3.2.2 Line strengths
Assuming a distance of 25.4 Mpc to NGC 4041 and EB−V =
0.17 mag (SCL98), we have plotted the luminosity evolution
of the strongest emission lines in Fig. 4. Note the quasi-
exponential decline of the Hα luminosity with exponential
lifetime ∼ 21 days. This fast decline is in dramatic con-
trast to other SNe IIn, for example SN 1995G, whose nar-
row Hα luminosity dropped by only a factor of three during
the first 600 days (Pastorello et al. 2002). The fast decay
of the Hα luminosity is consistent with a small amount of
56Ni in SN 1994W (SCL98) and also indicates the absence
of dense CS gas at large distances from the pre-supernova
(see Section 7).
Figure 5. Selected line profiles; day numbers are indicated. The
left-hand panel shows examples of narrow P-Cygni profiles, the
middle panel shows broad lines (note the extended wings in Na i
on day 57), and the right-hand panel shows the wings of the H i
lines on day 31. The dotted vertical lines mark velocities of 0 and
−700 km s−1.
uum was rather composed of broad, overlapping emission
lines. The steepness of the drop at 5620 A indicates that the
velocity widths of such lines can be no greater than ∼5000
km s−1. Similar features have been seen in late-time spectra
of the SN IIn 1997cy (Germany et al. 1994; Turatto et al.
2000). A sharp drop at this wavelength is in fact also typ-
ical of SNe Ia and some SNe Ib/Ic at late times, when
the emission is dominated by lines of Fe ii and [Fe ii] (see
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 9
Table 3. Flux measurements of emission lines, in units of 10−14 erg s−1 cm−2.
Line
Hγ 4340.46
Hβ 4861.32
Fe ii 5018.44
He i 5875.62
+Na i(a) 5889-95
Na i(b) 5889-95
Hα 6562.80
He i 7065.22
Mg ii(a) 7877-7896
Mg ii 9218-44
18
--
30(10)
--
--
--
25(5)
<2
--
--
21
30(2)
61(3)
31
47(4)
91(5)
49
34(1.5)
60(5)
1.7(0.1)
0.7(0.1)
2.1(0.5)
13.6(2)
--
82(3)
--
--
--
14(4)
--
130(6)
9.7(3)
10(2.5)
--
12(1)
--
110(2)
2.9(0.7)
5.2(0.5)
--
Notes: (a) blend, (b) emission component only.
Error estimates are 1σ. Upper limits are 3σ.
Day
57
24.5(2)
47(2)
2.7(0.7)
79
--
10(1)
89
--
4(1)
2.0(0.7)
1.6(0.2)
5(1)
<1
<1
121
203
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
0.14(0.05)
0.2(0.02)
0.6(0.1)
0.11(0.03)
<0.03
84(2)
<0.7
5.0(0.3)
6.3(1)
32(3)
<0.5
<0.6
21(1)
<0.2
<0.6
7.5(0.8)
1.0(0.3)
2.2(0.2)
0.1(0.025)
--
--
--
--
--
--
3.2.3 Continuum
We carried out black-body fits to the continuum. We obtain
colour temperatures of 13000±2000 K on day 21, 15000 K on
day 31, 10000 K on days 49 and 57, 7200 K on day 79 and
7200 K on day 89. We find that the black-body fits work
best for EB−V = 0.15 mag, consistent with our estimate
from Na i absorption (0.17 ± 0.06 mag; SCL98).
3.3 Elements identified
3.3.1 Hydrogen
We detect the Balmer series from Hα to at least H11, and
possibly also members of the Paschen series from Paδ to
Pa11 (Fig. 3). The profiles seem to be a combination of
∼ 4000 km s−1 and a narrow
broad emission line with BVZI >
P-Cygni absorption component (∼ 1000 km s−1). The ra-
tio of narrow-to-broad emission component decreases from
Hα toward the higher Balmer lines. This indicates a nearly
normal Balmer decrement for the narrow component and
a flat or possibly inverse Balmer decrement for the broad
component (Fig. 5).
A flat or inverted decrement suggests strong deviation
from the recombination case, related to collisions and ra-
diative transitions in the field of the photospheric radia-
tion. The observed line ratios suggest an excitation tem-
perature for hydrogen's excited levels of around 15000 K.
Two different thermalization mechanisms for hydrogen lev-
els may operate in this situation: the level populations may
be controlled by radiative transitions in the field of the
external black-body photospheric radiation, or thermaliza-
tion may be primarily collisional. Both mechanisms have
been exploited to account for flat or inverted Balmer decre-
ments observed in cataclysmic variables (Elitzur et al. 1983;
Williams & Shipman 1988). Both thermalization mecha-
nisms are plausible in SN 1994W as well.
3.3.2 Helium
We observe broad He i lines with triangular emission profiles
and narrow P-Cygni features. The He i lines disappear after
day 49 (Figs. 2 and 4; Table 2). He i λ5876 and λ7065 appear
only in emission. He i λ4471 and λ6678 show weak absorp-
tion features. A high ratio I(7065)/I(5876) ≈ 0.5 indicates a
large contribution of collisional and/or radiative excitation
compared to the purely recombination case. Unfortunately,
this fact cannot be used as a straightforward indicator of
electron concentration in the line-emitting region. Computa-
tions for an extended parameter set (Almog & Netzer 1989)
show that this particular ratio may be reached in a wide
range of concentrations (ne ≈ 104 − 1014 cm−3), with pro-
nounced dependence on the optical depth in He i λ3889.
3.3.3 Oxygen
O i λ7773 is present with an absorption-dominated P-Cygni
profile from as early as day 18 to day 89. From day 79,
we tentatively identify O i λ7002 with a P-Cygni profile.
This line has not to our knowledge been seen in a supernova
spectrum before, but was identified in the proto-planetary
nebula Henize 401 (Garc´ıa-Lario, Riera & Manchado 1999),
whose low-ionization spectrum bears some similarity to that
of SN 1994W at these phases.
3.3.4 Other metals
Ca ii H & K were strong in absorption at all epochs when
we covered them. The near-infrared triplet lines were weak
on day 49, but strengthened dramatically by day 79 (Fig. 3).
This may reflect an increase in the Ca ii/Ca iii ratio with
the drop in radiation temperature at late epochs.
The Na i D doublet's development is remarkable (Figs.
1, 2 and 5), even taking into account blending with inter-
stellar absorption and in the earlier spectra with He i λ5876.
Up to day 49, a flat-topped profile emerged as He i faded.
From day 57 on, the strength of the circumstellar P-Cygni
absorption increased, presumably as a result of increasing
Na i ionization fraction.
Magnesium lines appear both in absorption and emis-
sion. Narrow absorption with weak P-Cygni emission is
seen in Mg ii λ4481 from day 21 to day 57. We iden-
tify Mg ii λ7877 -- 7896 as the source of the broad feature
around 7890 A. As an alternative interpretation, we consid-
ered [Fe xi] λ7892. Strong [Fe xi] might be expected to be
accompanied by emission in [Fe x] λ6374, and there may
10
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
indeed be a broad feature underlying the Si ii absorption
lines to the blue of Hα. However, this feature does not per-
sist to later epochs as the 7890 A feature does, nor are any
other high-ionization lines identified at any epoch. In addi-
tion, emission lines with similar widths to the 7890 A feature
are seen at wavelengths corresponding to Mg ii transitions
around 9230 A, and possibly at 8200 A and 10900 A. Never-
theless, we find it somewhat surprising that the broad emis-
sion in Mg ii λλ7877 -- 7896 is not accompanied by similar
emission in O i λ7773.
The doublet of Si ii λλ6347, 6371 is present from days 21
to 89, showing absorption-dominated P-Cygni profiles. The
lines weakened relative to other features on days 79 and 89.
Si ii λ6240 therefore seems to be an unlikely contributor to
the feature at 6260 A (see below), which increases on these
dates.
Sc ii emission lines at around 5530 A and 6250 A were
identified by Pastorello et al. (2002) in the spectrum of the
Type IIn SN 1995G. We identify both Sc ii λ5527 and λ6246
in our spectra, and Sc ii may contribute to the feature at
6260 A. In particular, λ5527 shows some evidence of a broad
emission component (Figs. 2 and 3). Its narrow P-Cygni core
apparently persisted until day 121.
We identify a host of Fe ii lines (Fig. 3; Table 2), all of
which show narrow P-Cygni profiles. They may also be ac-
companied by broad emission as in the case of other species,
since the spectra show hints of underlying broad emission
in regions of the spectrum where there are many Fe ii lines
(Fig. 1). By days 79 and 89, a few lines of forbidden and
semi-forbidden Fe ii are identified. These have emission-
dominated P-Cygni profiles (Fig. 3).
4 GENERAL PICTURE
The previous discussion of spectroscopic and photometric
data on SN 1994W (SCL98) led to the conclusion that the
narrow lines originate in a dense CS envelope. However, at
present, the spectroscopic and photometric results cannot
readily be incorporated into any existing model of a SN II
interacting with a CS environment. We therefore present
first our qualitative view of what we observe in the case of
SN 1994W. We emphasize some basic elements of the physi-
cal picture that, in our opinion, are crucial for understanding
the phenomenon.
4.1 The opaque cool dense shell
The smooth continuum of SN 1994W and its lack of broad
absorption lines is typical of most SNe IIn at an early phase.
It is also reminiscent of the early spectrum of SN 1998S
(Leonard et al. 2000). For SN 1998S, the smooth contin-
uum and the absence of broad absorption lines was ex-
plained as an effect of an opaque cool dense shell (CDS)
which formed at the interface of the SN with its circum-
stellar medium (Chugai 2001). In this situation, an opaque
CDS is physically equivalent to an expanding photosphere
with a sharp boundary and without an external, extended
SN atmosphere. In comparison, the CDS formed in super-
nova remnants during the radiative stage (Pikelner 1954)
and in SNe interacting with a moderately dense CS wind
(Chevalier & Fransson 1985) are optically thin in the con-
tinuum.
The large optical depth of the CDS requires a rela-
tively large swept-up mass. This may be a natural conse-
quence of shock break-out in SNe II with extended stel-
lar envelopes (Grasberg et al. 1971; Falk & Arnett 1977;
Blinnikov & Bartunov 1993) and/or with extended CS en-
velopes of unusually high density. In the model of a pre-
supernova with initial radius ∼ 1015 cm (Falk & Arnett
1977), a CDS with a mass of ∼ 2 M⊙ forms and re-
mains opaque for about 70 days. We propose that a similar
opaque CDS formed in SN 1994W. This suggestion finds
support in the exceptionally bright peak of the light curve,
MV ≈ −19.5 mag (SCL98, their Fig. 5). According to the
theory of SN II light curves, a broad luminous maximum
with M ≈ −(19−20) mag requires the explosion of a very ex-
tended pre-supernova with an envelope radius of R0 ≈ 1015
cm (Grasberg et al. 1971; Falk & Arnett 1977).
4.2 The broad-line region
The deceleration of the CDS in the extended pre-supernova
envelope and in the dense CS environment is accompa-
nied by the Rayleigh-Taylor (RT) instability (Falk & Arnett
1977; Chevalier 1982). The growth and subsequent fragmen-
tation of RT spikes in the dense CDS material results in the
formation of a narrow layer (∆R/R ≈ 0.1 − 0.15) composed
of dense filaments, sheets and knots embedded in the rar-
efied hot gas behind the forward shock (Chevalier & Blondin
1995; Blondin & Ellison 2001). This mixed layer on top of
the CDS is likely responsible for the broad emission lines ob-
served in SN 1994W. If this is the case, then the expansion
velocity of the CDS (vs) should be the same as the velocity
of the broad line-emitting gas, i.e., vs ≈ 4000 km s−1.
A drawback of this picture of the broad-line formation is
that the velocity distribution of the line-emitting gas peaks
at the CDS expansion velocity vs, which means the expected
line profile should be boxy. With the exception of the Na i
profile on day 57, the broad lines are instead triangular.
A triangular profile can be produced, however, if the
spherically symmetric velocity distribution of the line-
emitting matter is close to dM/dv ∝ v. Actually, given
this mass-velocity spectrum and constant emissivity per unit
mass, and assuming that the velocity field is spherically sym-
metric, the luminosity distribution over the radial velocity
u (in units of vs) is
dL
du
∝ Z 1
u
1
v
dM
dv
dv ∝ (1 − u) ,
(1)
which is indeed triangular.
The broad velocity spectrum of the dense gas in the
mixed layer may naturally arise in two plausible scenarios.
In the first scenario the CS gas is clumpy. In this case, an
ensemble of dense CS clouds engulfed by the forward post-
shock gas could provide a broad velocity spectrum of radia-
tive cloud shocks and cloud fragments (Chugai 1997) in the
range of 1000 -- 4000 km s−1, where the lower limit is the CS
velocity. This model may be characterized as low-velocity
clouds in a high-velocity flow.
Alternatively, dense high-velocity clumps interacting
with the low-velocity CS gas could produce a similar spec-
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 11
trum of fragments. This could occur if the forward shock is
radiative, forming a thin post-shock layer with ∆R/R < 0.1.
In this situation, dense RT spikes, formed at the previous
stage of RT instability of the CDS, can penetrate into the
pre-shock zone. The interaction of these protrusions with
the CS gas in the pre-shock zone leads to further fragmen-
tation and deceleration of fragments down to the velocity of
the CS gas. As a result, a broad velocity spectrum of dense
cool fragments emerges in the velocity range of 1000 -- 4000
km s−1.
For this second possibility to hold, a high CS density
n is needed to maintain the narrow width of the post-shock
cooling region,
lc =
mpv3
s
32nΛ
,
(2)
where mp is the proton mass, and Λ is the cooling function in
the post-shock zone. To reach the required ratio lc/R ≈ 0.1
at radius R = 1015 cm, one needs a CS density of n ≈
1.7 × 109 cm−3 assuming Λ = 2 × 10−23 erg s−1 cm6 and
vs = 4000 km s−1.
Both scenarios for the velocity spectrum leave open the
question of why the velocity distribution of the line-emitting
gas in the mixed layer is close to dM/dv ∝ v. The following
naive model seems to provide a hint.
Let us consider the interaction of a high-velocity frag-
ment with the CS gas. In the rest frame of the initial frag-
ment, the fragmentation process in the rarefied CS flow
with the velocity ≈ vs may be thought of as a stripping
flow with accelerating velocity v1 and in which the "ra-
dius" a of fragments progressively decreases as the velocity
v1 increases (Klein, McKee & Colella 1994). Assuming mass
conservation of fragments in velocity space, Q = dM/dt =
(dM/dv)(dv/dt) = constant, the mass-velocity spectrum of
fragments may be expressed as
dM
dv1
= Q(cid:16) dv1
dt (cid:17)−1
,
(3)
which is essentially determined by the acceleration dv1/dt.
The latter can be approximately described as acceleration
due to the drag force
m
dv1
dt
= πa2ρ(1 − v1)2 ,
(4)
where the velocity is in units of vs, m = (4π/3)a3ρf is the
mass of fragment of the density ρf , and ρ is the density in
the rarefied ambient flow. To determine the acceleration we
must specify the relation between fragment size and velocity
v = 1 − v1 relative to the CS gas. We assume that the
fragment size for each new generation of cloudlets is tuned to
the Kolmogorov turbulent cascade with spectrum v ∝ a1/3.
With this relation, equation (4) leads to dv1/dt ∝ 1/v. The
latter combined with equation (3) leads to a mass-velocity
spectrum dM/dv ∝ v.
A similar analysis carried out for the case of a CS cloud
in the SN flow produces a quite different mass-velocity spec-
trum, dM/dv ∝ (1−v). This spectrum also results in a broad
line but with zero slope at u = 1 and a narrow logarithmic
peak: dL/du ∝ (u − 1 − ln u). While this profile resembles
the observed Hα profile, it is at odds with the triangular
profile of He i lines. Below (Section 5.4) we argue against a
large contribution of CS clouds in the formation of Hα.
Figure 6. Circumstellar lines on day 79. Overplotted on the ob-
servational data (dotted line) are the models for homologous ex-
pansion (thick line) and the constant-velocity case (thin line).
4.3 The circumstellar envelope
4.3.1 Expansion kinematics
The radial velocities of narrow absorption features in SN
1994W are strikingly persistent between days 18 and 89.
This implies that the expansion velocity of the CS envelope
(∼ 1000 km s−1) has a pre-explosion origin. An alternative
possibility -- acceleration of a slow wind by SN radiation
(see also SCL98) -- seems unlikely, since it would require un-
realistic fine tuning between the time-dependent luminosity
and absorption (scattering) coefficient to arrange the persis-
tence of the velocity of accelerated gas.
Two extreme options are conceivable for the CS enve-
lope's pre-explosion kinematics: constant-velocity flow and
homologous expansion (u ∝ r). The former might be the
result of either continuous wind outflow or a succession of
ejection events with similar ejecta velocities. Homologous
expansion, on the other hand, might be produced by a sin-
gle explosive ejection. The latter mechanism, though exotic,
was in fact proposed by Grasberg & Nadyozhin (1986) to
account for the narrow CS lines in SN 1983K.
4.3.2 Envelope size
The light curve of SN 1994W is characterized by a broad
maximum around day 30 and a subsequent plateau, ter-
minated by a sudden drop in luminosity at td ≈ 110 d
(SCL98, their Fig. 5). Assuming a CDS expansion velocity of
vs = 4000 km s−1, we find that during this period the CDS
sweeps up the CS gas within the radius Rd = vstd ≈ 4×1015
cm. Although this estimate refers to t = 110 d, we adopt it
as a rough estimate for earlier epochs as well.
We now argue that this radius should coincide with the
outer radius of the dense CS envelope, Rcs ≈ Rd. If in-
stead Rcs > Rd, then the light curve of SN 1994W should
not have shown such a steep drop, since the CS interaction
12
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
would have augmented the luminosity at the luminosity de-
cay phase. Equally, if Rcs < Rd, the narrow lines would have
disappeared at epoch t < td, which was not observed. These
arguments, therefore, provide strong evidence that the ex-
tent of the dense CS envelope is Rcs ≈ Rd ≈ 4×1015 cm. Be-
yond this radius, the CS density presumably drops steeply,
as indicated both by the broad-band light drop after day
100 and the fast decline of the Hα luminosity (Fig. 4). At
larger radii, X-ray observations suggest that other density
enhancements may be present (Section 7; Schlegel 1999).
4.3.3 Electron-scattering wings and circumstellar density
We attribute the extended smooth wings observed in Hα and
Hβ between days 18 and 89 to the effect of Thomson scatter-
ing on thermal electrons participating in the bulk expansion
of the CS envelope (Chugai 2001). Based on previous com-
putations of Thomson scattering effects in SN 1998S, and
the strength of the Hα wings in SN 1994W on day 57 (when
blending with He i λ6678 was negligible), we believe that
the optical depth of the CS envelope to Thomson scattering
(τT) at this stage must have been close to unity.
Adopting a photospheric radius Rp ≈ vst = 2 × 1015 cm
on day 57 (where vs ≈ 4000 km s−1) and an outer radius of
the CS envelope Rcs = 4 × 1015 cm, we obtain an estimate
of the average electron concentration in the CS envelope
assuming τT ≈ 1:
ne ≈
τT
σT(Rcs − Rp)
≈ 109 cm−3.
(5)
This value, taken together with the forward shock-wave ve-
locity (vsh ≈ 3000 km s−1), after correction for the CS ve-
locity, provides an estimate of the density of the CDS mate-
rial in the broad-line region (ncds). The pressure equilibrium
condition, with sound speed in the CDS matter of cs ≈ 15
km s−1, results in ncds ≈ n(vsh/cs)2 ≈ 4 × 1013 cm−3. This
tremendous density provides a natural reason for the strong
collisional thermalization of the broad component indicated
by the observed inverse Balmer decrement (Section 3.3.1).
4.3.4 Circumstellar density from narrow lines
The strength of narrow subordinate lines indicates a high
density in the CS envelope, as noted by SCL98. The sim-
plest density estimate may be taken from the condition that
the optical depth in a line of Fe ii, for example λ5018, is on
the order of unity. This follows from the relative intensity
of the absorption component of this line (∼ 0.5). Assuming
that level populations of Fe ii obey the Boltzmann distribu-
tion for T = 104 K, one obtains for solar Fe/H a hydrogen
concentration of n ≈ 3 × 107v8r−1
cm−3. Here r15 is the
linear scale of the line-forming zone in units of 1015 cm, v8
is the velocity dispersion in units of 108 cm s−1, and f2 is
the ionization fraction of Fe ii. Given the scale of the CS en-
velope (∼ 4 × 1015 cm), we thus have a lower limit n > 107
cm−3. This lower limit should be considered as a revised
version of the estimate reported in SCL98.
15 f −1
2
A somewhat more elaborate estimate of the density
may be obtained using several different lines and assuming
a quasi-local thermodynamic equilibrium (quasi-LTE) ap-
proximation, i.e., the Saha-Boltzmann equations corrected
for both geometrical dilution W and dilution of the pho-
tospheric brightness ξ. The latter defines the photospheric
brightness through the black-body brightness Iν = ξBν (T ).
We adopt a simple density distribution in the CS envelope:
a plateau with a steep outer drop
n = n0/[1 + (r/Rk)12] ,
(6)
where the cutoff radius Rk ≈ Rcs = 4 × 1015 cm. We
consider two cases for the CS kinematics: free expansion
(v = hr), with outer velocity at r = 6 × 1015 cm equal to
vb = 1100 km s−1, and constant-velocity flow with v = 1100
km s−1. The photospheric radius on day 79 is estimated as
Rp ≈ vst ≈ 2.7 × 1015 cm, where vs = 4000 km s−1, while
the temperature is taken to be Tp = 7200 K according to
the value found from the black-body fit to the continuum
(Section 3.2.3). The parameter ξ in this case is found to be
0.26.
In Fig. 6 we show calculated profiles of Fe ii λ5018, Si ii
λ6148, the Na i D1,2 doublet and the O i 7773 A triplet, for
solar abundance and hydrogen concentration n0 = 1.5 × 109
cm−3. In the case of Na i we have for the sake of simplicity
ignored the doublet structure, which explains why our model
line is narrower than the observed one. This density seems
to be the optimal one: a factor of 1.5 lower density results in
too weak O i and Na i lines, while a factor 1.5 higher density
makes all the lines too strong.
Although neither kinematic model produces an excel-
lent fit, it is clear that free expansion kinematics better pre-
dicts the positions of the absorption minima and, therefore,
is preferred compared to the constant-velocity case. The dif-
ferences between the modelled and observed line profiles in
the free-expansion case may be related to the omission of
Thomson scattering and the simplicity of our quasi-LTE
model.
4.4 Overview of the qualitative model
We summarize the main results of the qualitative analysis
in a cartoon (Fig. 7). It shows the basic structural elements
of SN 1994W which we believe are responsible for the for-
mation of the optical spectrum when the supernova's lumi-
nosity is high. The ejecta expand with a velocity of ∼ 4000
km s−1 into an extended (∼ 4 × 1014 cm) CS envelope. The
characteristic density of the CS envelope is ∼ 109 cm−3. The
SN ejecta are enshrouded by the opaque CDS within which
the photosphere resides during most of the luminous phase.
The opaque CDS precludes the formation of absorption lines
from the ejecta. The CDS presumably forms primarily dur-
ing shock break-out and is subsequently maintained by both
CS material swept up by the radiative forward shock and SN
material swept up by the reverse shock. These shocks are not
shown in Fig. 7 but they are presumably located at the dis-
tances ∆R < 0.1R away from the outer and inner edges of
the CDS.
Attached to the CDS is a layer populated by dense
(n ≈ 4 × 1013 cm−3) fragments supplied by the RT insta-
bility of the dense CDS and, possibly, by radiative shocks
in CS clouds. This inhomogeneous layer of dense material is
the primary site of the broad emission lines with the charac-
teristic velocity of the line-emitting gas, 4000 km s−1 (e.g.,
in He i).
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 13
the SN ejecta begin to interact with the extended stellar
envelope. The density of the extended stellar envelope is ad-
justed in our model by the requirement that a strong initial
deceleration of the swept-up thin shell must result in an
expansion velocity of ∼ 4000 km s−1 on day 30 when the
photospheric radius reaches ∼ 1015 cm. The CS envelope is
attached to the stellar envelope at r ≈ 1015 cm. A constant
pre-shock velocity (1000 km s−1) is assumed for the CS gas.
This is a reasonable approximation for the homologous ex-
pansion, bearing in mind additional radiative acceleration.
For the SN mass and energy we adopt M = 8 M⊙ and
E = 1051 erg -- both values are close to the parameters
of the light-curve models B and C of Falk & Arnett (1977).
We find that the dynamical model is nearly the same for SN
mass in the range 7−9 M⊙. The evolution of the CDS radius
and velocity is shown in Fig. 8 for the density profile which is
also consistent with the Hα model. In fact, the optimal den-
sity is a compromise between the requirements imposed by
the Hα profile evolution, the CDS velocity, and the bolomet-
ric luminosity at the final stage of the light-curve plateau.
The density of the CS envelope is nearly flat (ρ ∝ r−0.4) in
the range 1015 < r < 4 × 1015 cm.
The ionization of the CS envelope is produced by both
X-ray emission from the radiative forward shock wave and
by photospheric radiation. The latter primarily operates via
hydrogen photoionization from the second level. The X-ray
luminosity of the forward shock wave is calculated as
Lx = 2πr2ρ(vs − ups)3,
(7)
where ρ is the pre-shock density, while the pre-shock ve-
locity ups is the superposition of the pre-explosion velocity
and the accelerated velocity term. Half of this luminosity is
directed toward the CDS where it is reprocessed into con-
tinuum radiation. This component is not treated explicitly
in the model. The other half of the X-ray luminosity of
the forward shock is emitted outward and is partially ab-
sorbed by the CS gas. The X-ray spectrum of the forward
shock is approximated as FE = CE−q exp (−E/Ts), where
Ts is the temperature of the forward shock defined by the
shock velocity vs − ups. The spectral power index q = 0.5
roughly describes both the Gaunt factor and the contribu-
tion of X-ray lines in the low-energy band (Terlevich et al.
1992). The soft X-rays from the reverse shock at the epoch
under consideration are fully absorbed by the CDS (cf. Fig.
9 of Fransson, Lundqvist & Chevalier 1996) and by the SN
ejecta, and are reprocessed into the optical.
The energy of the X-rays absorbed in the CS envelope
is shared between heating, ionization and excitation. Ex-
citation and ionization by the photospheric radiation are
also taken into account. The electron temperature Te in the
CS envelope is determined from the energy balance between
heating from ionization by X-rays and photospheric radi-
ation and cooling due to hydrogen. This approximation is
quite reasonable in the temperature range of (1 − 2) × 104
K. The hydrogen atom is treated in the two-level-plus-
continuum approximation. The degree of ionization we ob-
tain for hydrogen in the CS envelope lies typically in the
range 0.8 − 0.95. The Hα emissivity is due to recombination
(Case B) and collisional excitation. Collisional de-excitation
of Hα is included in the computation of the net emissivity.
To allow for uncertainties in the flux, model, distance and
reddening we use a fitting parameter Cn for narrow Hα. This
(photosphere)
Figure 7. A sketch of SN 1994W at the epoch around day 30. We
show the principal structural elements involved in the formation
of the spectrum. The SN ejecta are bounded by an opaque cool
dense shell (CDS), which is responsible for the continuum radi-
ation. The broad-line region is a narrow mixing layer attached
to the CDS, composed of Rayleigh-Taylor fragments of the CDS
matter and possibly of shocked CS clouds. The SN ejecta expand
into a dense CS envelope with Thomson optical depth on the or-
der of unity. The CS envelope is responsible for both narrow lines
and the extended Thomson wings seen in Hα.
The CS envelope, which in turn expands with a veloc-
ity of ∼ 1000 km s−1, is responsible for the narrow lines.
Thomson scattering in the CS envelope results in the emer-
gence of broad emission-line wings, which are most apparent
in the strong lines such as Hα and Hβ. Because of the large
expansion velocity, the red wing is stronger than the blue
wing.
5 A MODEL FOR Hα
In order to confirm and refine the above qualitative picture
of the formation of the SN 1994W spectrum, we have mod-
elled the Hα line profile. In many respects our approach
repeats the analysis of SN 1998S by Chugai (2001), which
involved calculations of the CDS dynamics and Monte Carlo
computations of the emergent lines formed outside the CDS.
Here we use an updated version of this model, which now in-
cludes calculations of CS hydrogen ionization, electron tem-
perature and Hα emissivity. In the previous model both of
the latter were set rather arbitrarily.
5.1 The model
The CDS dynamics are calculated numerically in the thin-
shell approximation (Chevalier 1982). We assume that the
SN initially expands homologously (v ∝ r) with density dis-
tribution ρ = ρ0/[1 + (v/vk)9], where the parameters of the
distribution are defined by the ejecta mass M and kinetic en-
ergy E. At radius R0 = 1000 R⊙ (a rather arbitrary value)
14
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Figure 9. A typical model of Hα on day 31 (thick line), showing
the contribution of the narrow component (thin line).
Figure 8. The CS density (top panel) and evolution of the radius
and velocity of the cool dense shell (lower panels).
parameter is a multiplicative factor in the Hα emissivity in
the CS envelope.
The broad-line region (Fig. 7) is described by an (on
average) homogeneous layer, Rs < r < R1, where R1/Rs =
1.15 and the distribution of the line luminosity dL/dv ∝ v
for v1 < v < vs, where v1 is the minimal velocity adopted to
be equal to the pre-shock CS gas velocity. We express the
average emissivity of the broad component in terms of the
pre-shock emissivity, multiplied by a fitting factor Cb, which
is restricted by the requirement that the Hα intensity from
the broad-line region cannot exceed the black-body value for
the local electron temperature of the CS gas in the pre-shock
zone.
We assume free expansion pre-explosion kinematics
(u = hr), though we have also explored the constant-velocity
case. The acceleration by the SN radiation is described as
an additional CS velocity term ua = u0(Rs/r)2, where u0 is
a free parameter.
5.2 Thomson scattering and the broad component
In the Hα line profile, the broad emission component and
electron-scattering wings overlap and at first sight cannot
be disentangled unambiguously. Nevertheless, we found that
there is not much freedom in the decomposition procedure.
In Fig. 9 we show a model narrow-line component on day 31,
with the broad component turned off. To emphasize the dif-
ferent behaviours of the broad component and the electron-
scattering wings, we show in Fig. 10 models with different
Thomson optical depth (0, 1 and 2.8) but with otherwise
similar parameters. For optical depth zero, the modelled
broad component is strongly skewed toward the blue be-
cause of occultation by the photosphere. This asymmetry
decreases as τT increases and Thomson scattering of the
Figure 10. The same model as in Fig. 9 but for different Thom-
son optical depths. Lines with increasing thickness show cases
τT = 0, 1 and 2.8, respectively.
line emission in the expanding CS envelope produces an in-
creasingly strong red wing. These different behaviours of the
broad line and electron-scattering wings permit us to disen-
tangle the contribution of the two line components in Hα.
In passing, we note that the continuum level also depends
on τT, since the Thomson optical depth affects the escape
probability of photons emitted by the photosphere.
5.3 Hα and the expansion law
The sensitivity of the model line profile to the kinematics
of the CS envelope is demonstrated in Fig. 11. The plot
shows Hα profiles on day 31 computed for similar model
parameters -- all that differs is the velocity distribution.
For τT = 2.8, homologous expansion without post-explosion
radiative acceleration fits the observations quite well. The
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 15
Figure 11. Hα profile on day 31 for different velocity distri-
butions (shown in the inset in each panel). Overplotted on each
observed profile (thin line) are models for CS envelope kinematics
displayed in insets.
constant-velocity case is much less successful: it produces
an emission component which is too broad, and absorption
which is too shallow (Fig. 11). This result, taken together
with the results of the narrow CS line modelling (Fig. 6), ar-
gues against the constant-velocity case. We checked a model
with constant velocity and pre-shock acceleration and found,
unsurprisingly, that this gives even worse agreement. The
homologous model, on the other hand, works just as well
when combined with post-explosion acceleration. In the bot-
tom panel of Fig. 11 we show such a model profile char-
acterized by an amplitude of accelerated velocity term of
ua = 400 km s−1.
Although homologous expansion kinematics is certainly
preferred, this model shows a rather deep absorption compo-
nent. This contradiction is not related to the finite resolution
since we have smoothed the model profile by a Gaussian with
appropriate width. An explanation for the large absorption
strength in the model might be hidden in a possible devi-
ation of the kinematics from homologous expansion, some
clumpiness of the CS envelope, or lower hydrogen excita-
tion in the outer layers of the CS envelope than the model
predicts.
5.4 Modelling the Hα evolution
We have calculated Hα for three epochs (31, 57 and 89 days
past explosion) using the density distribution of the CS en-
velope (r > 1015 cm), and the CDS radius and velocity
as shown in Fig. 8. The density parameter w = 4πr2ρ at
r = 1015 cm on day 31 is w = 7.5 × 1016 g cm−1. Free ex-
pansion kinematics is assumed with a boundary velocity of
1100 km s−1 at r = 5.4 × 1015 cm on day 31. This implies
an age for the CS envelope of tcs = 1.5 yr when the SN
Figure 12. Hα at different epochs. Model profiles (thick line) are
overlaid on the observations (thin line).
explodes. For other values of tcs counted from the moment
of envelope ejection, we rescale according to r ∝ tcs and
ρ ∝ 1/t3
cs.
The computed profiles are shown in Fig. 12. In Table 4
we list the corresponding parameters: photospheric (CDS)
radius, photospheric temperature, brightness dilution, CDS
velocity, post-explosion velocity increase, and emissivity fit-
ting factors for narrow and broad components. The last col-
umn displays the calculated Thomson optical depth outside
the CDS. On days 31 and 57 we use the approximation of an
opaque photosphere. On day 89 we found, however, that this
approximation predicts too weak a red part of the profile.
The model agrees better with the observations if we suggest
that at this late phase the CDS is semi-transparent. To de-
scribe this effect in a simple way we allow a photon striking
the photosphere to cross it and escape into the CS medium
with a finite probability, which we found should be close to
p = 0.3. This assumption is qualitatively consistent with the
fact that the photospheric brightness on day 89 is diluted
(ξ = 0.2) for the optimal continuum temperature. The mod-
els for all three epochs demonstrate satisfactory fits to the
data. On day 31, the model is consistent with the presence
of broad He i λ6678 in the red wing of Hα, while on day 57
the model fit in the red wing does not leave any room for the
He i line. This behaviour is consistent with the weakening
of other He i lines at this time.
We calculated the Hα component from the CS envelope
in a unified way with a minimum number of free parameters.
For this reason, the fact that the tuning parameter of the
narrow-line intensity (Cn) is close to unity (Table 4) means
that within the uncertainties (∼ 20 per cent) the electron
distribution in the CS envelope recovered from the Thomson
scattering effects is also consistent with the luminosity of the
narrow Hα component. Because the line luminosity depends
on the filling factor as L ∝ 1/f while the Thomson optical
depth does not, we conclude that the filling factor in the CS
16
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
envelope is close to unity in at least most of the line-forming
zone.
This last observation is of crucial importance for distin-
guishing between the two scenarios for the formation of the
broad-line region (Section 4.2), and indicates that CS clouds
do not play a significant role in this process.
We have studied cases with different density power-law
indices s (defined via ρ ∝ rs) in the flat part of the CS
envelope. In the case s = 0, the tuning parameter (Cn) must
systematically decrease by a factor of 1.25 to fit the profile.
For s = −1, Cn should systematically increase with time by
a similar factor. Bearing in mind the uncertainties in the
modelling and fluxing, we do not rule out that the density
gradient lies in the range −1 6 s 6 0.
5.5 Implications for the origin of the
circumstellar envelope
The model for the Hα evolution presented above for the
CS envelope outside r ≈ 1015 cm argues for a total mass
of Mcs ≈ 0.4 M⊙ and kinetic energy of Ecs ≈ 2 × 1048
erg. Combined with the derived kinematic age of the CS
envelope tcs ≈ 1.5 yr, the average kinetic luminosity of the
mass-loss mechanism responsible for the ejection of the CS
envelope then becomes L ≈ Ecs/tcs ≈ 4 × 1040 erg s−1, and
the average mass-loss rate is ∼ 0.3 M⊙ yr−1.
The kinetic luminosity we derive here is enormous com-
pared to stellar values. It exceeds by two orders of mag-
nitude the radiative luminosity of a pre-supernova with a
main-sequence mass of 6 20 M⊙. This certainly rules out
a superwind as the mass-loss mechanism responsible for the
CS envelope around SN 1994W. The CS envelope around
SN 1994W must have been born as a result of a rather vio-
lent mass ejection initiated by some energetic explosive event
in the stellar interior (E > 2 × 1048 erg) at ∼ 1.5 yr prior to
the SN outburst.
6 LIGHT-CURVE MODELLING
To model the broad-band photometric light curves, we
use the multi-energy group radiation hydrodynamics code
stella (Blinnikov et al. 1998, 2000). In the current work,
stella solves time-dependent equations for the angular mo-
ments of intensity averaged over fixed frequency bands, us-
ing 200 zones for the Lagrangian coordinate and up to 100
frequency bins with variable Eddington factors. The transfer
of gamma rays from radioactive decay is calculated using a
one-group approximation for the non-local deposition of the
energy of radioactive nuclei. Except for the latest phases,
the gamma-ray deposition is not important for SN 1994W.
In the equation of state, LTE ionizations and recombina-
tions are taken into account, but radiation is not assumed
to be in equilibrium with matter. The effect of line opac-
ity is treated as an expansion opacity according to the pre-
scription of Eastman & Pinto (1993). In comparison with
previous work with stella, here we use an extended spec-
tral line list, the same as in the discussion of SN 1998S by
Chugai et al. (2002).
Figure 13. Composition as a function of interior mass, Mr, for
the most abundant elements in the pre-supernova model sn94w58.
The mass cut is at Mc = 1.41 M⊙.
6.1 Pre-supernova models
SCL98 used analytical fits (Litvinova & Nadyozhin 1983,
1985; Popov 1993) to estimate the pre-SN radius, mass and
explosion energy in SN 1994W. However, those fits are only
valid for typical SNe II-P, and from the discussion above we
know that SN 1994W was instead dominated by circumstel-
lar interaction. To determine the pre-supernova parameters
for such an unusual event, we therefore need to do detailed
numerical modelling. This can be done only for a subset of
the pre-supernova parameters, so we used a cut-and-trial ap-
proach, guessing the initial conditions and computing light
curves in order to meet the constraints posed by the photom-
etry and the spectral analysis of Section 5. In the absence
of an evolutionary model, we built a sequence of several
dozens of non-evolutionary models, converging finally on a
reasonably good fit to observations. Our initial models are
constructed in hydrostatic equilibrium for the bulk mass,
while the outer layers mimic the structure of the circumstel-
lar envelope.
For a given mass M and radius R0, we obtain a model in
mechanical equilibrium assuming a power-law dependence
of temperature on density (Nadyozhin & Razinkova 1986;
Blinnikov & Bartunov 1993):
T ∝ ρα .
(8)
The hydrostatic configuration thus obtained would be close
to a polytrope of index 1/α if it were chemically homoge-
neous and fully ionized. The difference from a polytropic
model arises due to recombination of ions in the outermost
layers and non-uniform composition (Fig. 13).
In the centre of this configuration, at the mass cut of the
collapsing core, we assume a "point-like" gravitating hard
core (with numerical radius Rc = 0.1R⊙ -- much larger
than a real core, but much smaller than the radii of mesh
zones involved in our hydrodynamic simulations). The den-
Table 4. Parameters of the Hα evolution models
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 17
Day
Rp
(1015 cm)
T
(K)
ξ
vs
ua
(km s−1)
(km s−1)
Cb
Cn
τT
31
57
89
1.2
2.2
3.3
16000
7760
7000
1
1
0.2
4220
4160
3920
400
400
170
35
1
0.5
1.15
1
1.15
2.8
2.0
0.54
Figure 14. Density as a function of the radius r in the pre-
supernova models sn94w43 and sn94w58.
Figure 15. Density as a function of the interior mass (Mr) in the
pre-supernova models sn94w43 and sn94w58. The mass cut is at
Mc = 1.41 M⊙.
sity structure found in this way is shown in Figs. 14 and
15.
The parameters of the models are given in Table 6.1.
The first column is the model label, which is followed by the
mass of SN ejecta, pre-supernova stellar radius, 56Ni mass,
power-law index α, density of the CS envelope (ρ15) at the
radius r = 1015 cm, power-law index (p) of the CS envelope
density distribution ρ ∝ r−p, the outer radius of the CS
envelope, and the kinetic energy at infinity in units of foe
(1 foe = 1051 erg).
Each model was exploded by the deposition of heat en-
ergy in a layer of mass ∼ 0.06 M⊙ outside of 1.41 M⊙. Since
stella does not include nuclear burning, preservation of the
same mixed composition in the ejecta is assured.
We explored parameter space for the mass (M ) and en-
ergy (E) of the SN ejecta and found acceptable fits to the
data for masses in the range 6 -- 15 M⊙ and with the en-
ergy given by the ratio E/M ≈ 0.15 -- 0.2 foe M −1
⊙ . In the
following sections and in Table 6.1, we present three rep-
resentative models which allow us to demonstrate different
aspects of the formation of the light curve. Of these three,
model sn94w58 provides our best fit to SN 1994W, model
sn94w43 shows that a normal SN II-P light curve is not
appropriate for SN 1994W, and model sn94w68 illustrates
what the supernova light curve might have looked like with-
out CS interaction. All three models have E = 1.5 × 1051
ergs. This energy is typical for good light-curve models. The
asymptotic kinetic energy of the ejecta is somewhat lower
and is given in the Table 6.1.
6.2 Hydrodynamics and shock propagation
The modelled light curves are dominated by the diffusion
of the trapped radiation generated during the shock wave's
propagation in the extended stellar atmosphere and sub-
sequent emission of a radiative shock propagating in the
dense circumstellar medium. A dense shell is formed which
is found in non-equilibrium radiation hydrodynamic mod-
elling but often missed in equilibrium diffusion modelling.
We identify this dense shell as the CDS discussed in Sec-
tion 4.1. The Lagrangian code stella does a good job of
resolving the very fine structure of the opaque shell, which
contains approximately one solar mass of the material (Fig.
16).
6.3 Light curves
In Figs. 17 and 18 we show the changes in the colour tem-
perature, Tc, of the best black-body fit to the flux. We
compare this to the effective temperature, Teff , defined by
the luminosity and the radius of last scattering R through
L = 4πσT 4
eff R2 (see Blinnikov et al. 1998 for details of find-
ing R and from that Teff ). Our multi-group radiative trans-
18
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Table 5. Parameters of hydrodynamical models
Model
a
Mej
(M⊙)
R0
(104 R⊙)
sn94w43
sn94w58
sn94w64
12
7
7
8
2
2
MNi
(M⊙)
0.015
0.015
0.015
α
ρ15
(10−15 g cm−3)
0.319
0.31
0.31
5
12
0
p
2
1
-
Rw
(104 R⊙)
12
6.6
-
a pre-supernova mass = Mej + 1.41 M⊙
b kinetic energy at infinity
b
Ekin
(1051 erg)
1.07
1.25
1.33
Figure 16. Density as a function of radius (r) in two models with
different amounts of artificial smearing at day 30. The height of
the density spike with small smearing (solid line) reaches the
theoretical estimate for an isothermal shock wave.
fer with hydrodynamics obtains this temperature in a self-
consistent way, and no additional estimates of the thermal-
ization depth are needed (in contrast to the one-group model
of Ensman & Burrows 1993, for example). The large differ-
ence between colour and effective temperatures is partly due
to a geometric effect (the radius of last scattering is greater
than the effective radius of photon creation) and partly due
to the blanketing effect of scattering (the average energy of
the photons is higher than that corresponding to the value of
Teff ; Schuster 1905). The modelled Tc changes in a way sim-
ilar to the values derived from black-body fits to the spectra
(Section 3.2.3).
The light curves are shown in Figs. 19, 20 and 21. The
model sn94w43 produces a bright light curve, but the sec-
ond half of its plateau is dominated by diffusion, not by the
shock, so the behaviour of colours is similar to that of a
typical SN II-P.
The density of the more powerful wind in the model
sn94w58 follows the law ρ ∝ r−1. This model produces a
much better fit to the colours at the late plateau phase. The
flat CS density distribution is consistent with the modelling
Figure 17. Colour and effective temperatures for the model
sn94w43. Realistic, scattering-dominated opacity has been as-
sumed. The solid line shows the temperature of the best black-
body fit to the flux (colour temperature). The dashed line shows
the effective temperature defined by the luminosity and the radius
of last scattering.
of Hα evolution (Section 5.4). Model sn94w64, which is ex-
actly the same as model sn94w58 in the bulk mass, but does
not have the powerful wind, is much less luminous at the late
plateau phase. This shows the importance of CS interaction
for the luminosity.
The time-dependence of the radius Rs and velocity Vs
of the cool dense shell in model sn94w58 is shown in Fig.
22. The two nearly indistinguishable lines in the Vs plot are
obtained by taking Vs = dRs/dt numerically, and by taking
the mass-averaged speed of matter inside the shell. A com-
parison with Fig. 8 shows good agreement with the spectral
model, although Vs is somewhat higher in the hydrodynam-
ical model. The difference is at most ∼ 10 per cent.
To summarize, the hydrodynamical modelling of the
light curve of SN 1994W suggests that the optimal light
curve is produced in a model which contains a dense CS en-
velope at r >
∼ 1015 cm with a relatively flat density distribu-
tion and an outer radius of ∼ 4.5 × 1015 cm. This conclusion
is fully consistent with the Hα modelling.
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 19
Figure 18. Colour and effective temperatures for the model
sn94w58.
Figure 20. Same as in Fig. 19, but for model sn94w58.
Figure 19. Light curves for the model sn94w43. The photometric
points are taken from SCL98 and references therein.
7 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
We have presented and analysed spectra and light curves of
SN 1994W, one of the best-observed SNe IIn. During the
first three months the spectrum clearly shows the presence
of three line components: (i) narrow P-Cygni lines, (ii) in-
trinsically broad lines and (iii) extended smooth wings in Hα
and Hβ. We attribute these components, respectively, to (i)
a dense CS envelope, (ii) shocked, cool, dense gas confined
in a narrow layer on top of the photosphere, and (iii) the
effects of Thomson scattering in the CS envelope.
Our line profile analysis and hydrodynamical
light-
curve modelling have led us to a coherent picture. SN 1994W
Figure 21. Same as in Fig. 19, but for model sn94w64.
appears to have been the result of explosion of an extended
pre-supernova (∼ 1015 cm) embedded in an extended CS
envelope [∼ (4 − 5) × 1015 cm] with Thomson optical depth
∼ 2.8 one month after the explosion.
Although we do not rule out the presence of a wind from
a normal red supergiant pre-supernova outside the dense CS
envelope, such a wind component cannot have been very
dense, considering the low luminosity of Hα on day 203
(L ≈ 1038 erg s−1). This luminosity is two orders of mag-
nitude lower than for SN 1979C (∼ 1040 erg s−1) at ∼ 1
yr (Chevalier & Fransson 1985). Attributing this difference
to the difference in the interaction luminosity (L ∝ 4πρv3
s ),
we can estimate the density parameter of the outer wind in
SN 1994W. The expansion velocity of the CDS in SN 1994W,
∼ 4000 km s−1, is half that of SN 1979C (∼ 8000 km s−1).
20
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
∼ 11 M⊙ star may produce strong Ne flashes several years
prior to the SN explosion and that the strongest flash could
eject most of the hydrogen envelope with velocities of ∼ 100
km s−1. Although such flashes do not occur in more recent
models with finer zoning (Woosley, Heger & Weaver 2002),
we believe that the effect warrants further investigation, es-
pecially given the highly complicated nuclear burning regime
and hydrodynamics of degenerate O/Ne/Mg cores.
Remarkably, the low 56Ni mass (< 0.015 M⊙) estimated
from the tail R-band luminosity of SN 1994W (SCL98)
seems to be in accord with the suggested mass of such a
progenitor, if at the lower end of our estimated mass range.
Such stars are expected to eject only small amounts of 56Ni
(Mayle & Wilson 1988). Our models are, however, not very
sensitive to the zero-age main-sequence mass of the progen-
itor, and, as SCL98 point out, the low nickel content could
indicate either a low-mass progenitor which may have lost a
few solar masses in shell and wind ejections, or a more mas-
sive star that lost several solar masses prior to the ejection of
the CS shell. Deep X-ray searches for more extended CS ma-
terial could help solve this problem, as should more detailed
models for stellar evolution just prior to core collapse.
How common are events like SN 1994W? Of the SNe IIn
that have been observed so far, it is possible that a close
counterpart has been seen but not recognised as such due
to sparser temporal coverage or greater distance. Never-
theless, several objects have shown narrow hydrogen and
Fe ii absorption lines with velocities of about 1000 km
s−1. This family includes SNe 1987B (Schlegel et al. 1996),
1994aj (Benetti et al. 1998), 1994ak (Filippenko 1997),
1995G (Pastorello et al. 2002), 1996L (Benetti et al. 1999)
and 1999el (Di Carlo et al. 2002). We suggest that in at least
some of these SNe, a CS envelope was ejected in a violent,
explosive manner, as we believe was the case for SN 1994W,
and as Chugai & Danziger (2003) have suggested for SN
1995G. Further data and analyses are needed, however, be-
fore it can be demonstrated that the energy of the ejected
CS envelope is comparable for these events.
In any case, we suggest that at least part of the variety
of SNe IIn has been accounted for. Some, like SN 1988Z and
SN 1998S, have a dense, slow CS envelope formed by a slow
superwind. Others, like SN 1994W, seem to have ejected a
CS envelope in a violent event a few years before the SN
explosion.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Aaron J. Barth, Mike Breare, Ren´e Rutten, Luis
C. Ho, Neil O'Mahony, Chien Y. Peng and Ed Zuiderwijk for
helping take observations for us, and Clive Jackman, Danny
Lennon and Marco Azzaro for help assessing the day 31
spectrum calibration. We also thank Itziar Aretxaga, Eddie
Baron, Claes Fransson, Seppo Mattila, Peter Meikle, Miguel
P´erez Torres, and Luca Zampieri for discussions.
This paper is based on observations made with the Isaac
Newton Telescope (INT), the William Herschel Telescope
(WHT), and the Nordic Optical Telescope (NOT). The INT
and WHT are operated on the island of La Palma by the
Isaac Newton Group in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque
de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrof´ısica de Canarias.
The NOT is operated on the island of La Palma jointly
Figure 22. The evolution of the radius and velocity of the cool
dense shell in hydrodynamical model sn94w58. Compare with
Fig. 8.
Given the SN 1979C wind parameter, w ≈ 1016 g cm−1,
the outer wind in SN 1994W should have w ≈ 1015 g cm−1
to account for the difference in the Hα luminosity. This is
at least ten times lower than in SN 1979C, and a factor of
two lower than in SN 1980K (e.g., Lundqvist & Fransson
1988). In this respect, the detection by Schlegel (1999) of
X-rays from SN 1994W at t = 1180 days with luminosity
L ≈ 8 × 1039 erg s−1 appears odd when compared with the
expected X-ray luminosity ( <
∼ 1038 erg s−1) at that epoch
for a case of SN/wind interaction with w ≈ 1015 g cm−1.
To resolve this problem, one would need the wind density
to be at least of factor of ten higher at ∼ 4 × 1016 cm, i.e.,
exceeding that of SN 1979C. This could argue for a possible
multi-shell ejection scenario prior to the explosion.
The recovered kinematics, density and linear scale of the
CS matter around SN 1994W imply a kinematic age for the
CS envelope of tcs ≈ 1.5 yr, mass Mcs ≈ 0.4 M⊙ and kinetic
energy Ecs ≈ 2 × 1048 erg. The enormous average mass-loss
rate (Mcs/tcs ≈ 0.3 M⊙ yr−1) and equally enormous kinetic
luminosity (Ecs/tcs ≈ 4 × 1040 erg s−1) of the mass-ejection
mechanism strongly suggest that the CS envelope has been
lost as a result of an explosive event which occurred ∼ 1.5
yr prior to the SN outburst.
In their model
for the narrow lines in SN 1983K,
Grasberg & Nadyozhin (1986) invoked the violent ejection
of the hydrogen envelope 1 -- 2 months before the SN explo-
sion with a velocity on the order of ∼ 2500 km s−1 and an
energy (1−2)×1049 erg. Dramatically high mass loss shortly
before explosion has also been derived for the SN IIn 1995G
by Chugai & Danziger (2003), on the basis of an analysis
similar to the one we have presented here.
The mechanism behind such violent ejections might
be associated with a nuclear flash in the degenerate core
of the pre-supernova. This conjecture, also presented by
Chugai & Danziger (2003), is prompted by the prediction
of Weaver & Woosley (1979) that the O/Ne/Mg core of an
Circumstellar envelope ejection in SN 1994W 21
by Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Sweden, in the
Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the
Instituto de Astrof´ısica de Canarias. Some of the data pre-
sented herein were obtained at the W.M. Keck Observatory,
which is operated as a scientific partnership among the Cal-
ifornia Institute of Technology, the University of California
and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.
The Observatory was made possible by the generous finan-
cial support of the W.M. Keck Foundation.
This project was supported by the Royal Swedish
Academy of Sciences. S.I.B. was supported partly by RFBR
02-02-16500, the Wenner-Gren Science Foundation, MPA
Garching and ILE Osaka guest programs. The research of
P.L. is sponsored by the Royal Swedish Academy and the
Swedish Research Council, and he is a Research Fellow at
the Royal Swedish Academy supported by a grant from the
Wallenberg Foundation. A.V.F.'s research is supported by
National Science Foundation grant AST-0307894.
REFERENCES
Allen, C. W., 1973, Astrophysical Quantities. University of
London, Athlone Press, London
Aretxaga, I., Benetti, S., Terlevich, R. J., Fabian, A. C.,
Cappellaro, E., Turatto, M., Della Valle, M., 1999, MN-
RAS, 309, 343
Axelrod, T., 1980, Ph.D. thesis, California Univ., Santa
Cruz
Cumming, R. J., Lundqvist, P., Meikle, W. P. S., 1994,
IAU Circ., No. 6057
Di Carlo, E., et al., 2002, ApJ, 573, 144
Dopita, M. A., Evans, R., Cohen, M., Schwarz, R. D., 1984,
ApJ, 287, L69
Eastman, R. G., Pinto, P. A., 1993, ApJ, 412, 731
Elitzur, M., Ferland, G. J., Mathews, S. G., Shields, G. A.,
1983, ApJ, 272, L55
Ensman, L., Burrows, A., 1992, ApJ, 393, 742
Fassia, A., et al., 2001, MNRAS, 325, 907
Falk, S. W., Arnett W. D., 1977, ApJS, 13, 515
Filippenko, A. V., 1982, PASP, 94, 715
Filippenko, A. V., 1989, AJ, 97, 726
Filippenko, A. V., 1991, in Danziger, I. J., Kjar, K., eds,
Supernova 1987A and Other Supernovae ESO, Garching,
p. 343
Filippenko, A. V., 1997, ARA&A, 35, 309
Filippenko, A. V., 2000, in Holt, S. S., Zhang, W. W., eds,
Cosmic Explosions, AIP, New York, p. 123
Filippenko, A. V., Barth, A. J., 1994, IAU Circ., No. 6046
Filippenko, A. V., Moran, E. C., 1998, IAU Circ., No. 6830
Fransson, C., 1982, A&A, 111, 140
Fransson, C., 1984, A&A, 133, 264
Fransson, C., Lundqvist, P., Chevalier, R. A., 1996, ApJ,
461, 993
Fransson, C., et al., 2002, ApJ, 572, 350
Fransson, C., et al., 2004, ApJ, submitted
Fuhr, J. R., Martin, G. A., Wiese, W. L., 1988, J. Phys.
Chem. Ref. Data 17, Suppl. 4
Almog, Y., Netzer, H., 1989, ApJ, 238, 57
Benetti, S., Cappellaro, E., Danziger, I. J., Turatto, M.,
Gaskell, C. M., 1994, IAU Circ., No. 6048
Garc´ıa-Lario, P., Riera, A., Manchado, A., 1999, ApJ, 526,
Patat, F., Della Valle, M., 1998, MNRAS, 294, 448
854
Benetti, S., Turatto, M., Cappellaro, E., Danziger, I. J.,
Germany, L., Reiss, D. J., Sadler, E. M., Schmidt, B. P.,
Mazzali, P. A., 1999, MNRAS, 305, 811
Stubbs, C. W., 2000, ApJ, 533, 320
Bessell, M. S., 1999, PASP, 111, 1426
Blinnikov, S. I., Bartunov, O. S., 1993, A&A, 273, 106
Blinnikov, S. I., Eastman, R., Bartunov, O. S., Popolitov,
Grasberg, E. K., Imshennik, V. S., Nadyozhin, D. K., 1971,
Ap&SS, 10, 28
Grasberg, E. K., Nadyozhin, D. K., 1986, Sov. Astr. Lett.,
V. A., Woosley, S. E., 1998, ApJ, 496, 454
12, 68
Blinnikov, S., Lundqvist, P., Bartunov, O., Nomoto, K.,
Iwamoto, K., 2000, ApJ, 532, 1132
Blondin, J. M., Ellison, D. C., 2001, ApJ, 560, 244
Bowen, D. V., Roth, K. C., Meyer, D. M., Blades, J. C.,
2000, ApJ, 536, 225
Bragaglia, A., Munari, U., Barbon, R., 1994, IAU Circ.,
No. 6044
Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., Mathis, J. S., 1989, ApJ,
345, 245
Chevalier R.A., 1982, ApJ, 258, 790
Chevalier R.A., Blondin J.M., 1995, ApJ, 444, 312
Chevalier R. A., Fransson C., 1985, in Bartel N., ed., Su-
pernovae as Distance Indicators, Springer-Verlag, Berlin,
p. 123
Chevalier, R. A., Fransson, C., 1992, ApJ, 395, 540
Chevalier, R. A., Fransson, C., 1994, ApJ, 420, 268
Chugai, N. N., 1990, Sov. Astr. Lett., 16, 457
Chugai, N. N., 1992, SvA, 36, 63
Chugai, N. N., 1997, Ap&SS, 252, 225
Chugai, N. N., 2001, MNRAS, 326, 1448
Chugai N. N., Blinnikov, S. I., Fassia, A., Lundqvist, P.,
Meikle, W. P. S., Sorokina, E. I., 2002, MNRAS, 330, 473.
Chugai, N. N., Danziger, I. J., 2003, Astr. Lett., 29, 732
Cortini, G., Villi, M., 1994, IAU Circ., No. 6042
Gualandi, R., Merighi, R., 2001, BFOSC (Bologna Faint
Object Spectrograph & Camera) Manuale Utente, version
2.0. Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna, Bologna
Hamuy, M. et al., 2003, Nat, 424, 651
Henry, R. B. C., Branch, D., 1987, PASP, 99, 112
King, D. L., 1985, ING Technical Note, 31
Klein, R. I., McKee, C. F., Colella, P., 1994, ApJ, 420, 213
Leibundgut, B. et al., 1991, ApJ, 372, 531
Leonard, D. C., Filippenko, A. V., Barth, A. J., Matheson,
T., 2000, ApJ, 536, 239
Lewis, J. R., et al., 1994, MNRAS, 266, L27
Litvinova, I. Yu., Nadyozhin, D. K., 1983, Astrophys. Sp.
Sci. 89, 89
Litvinova, I. Yu., Nadyozhin, D. K., 1985, Pis'ma Astron.
Zh. 11, 351 (Sov. Astron. Lett. 11, 145)
Lundqvist, P., Fransson, C., 1988, A&A, 192, 221
Matheson, T., Filippenko, A. V., Ho, L. C., Barth, A. J.,
Leonard, D. C., 2000, AJ, 120, 1499
Meikle, W. P. S., Catchpole, R. M., Cumming, R. J.,
Geballe, T. R., Lewis, J. R., Martin, R., Walton, N. A.,
1994, Spectrum, 4, 7
Mayle, R., Wilson, J. R., 1988, ApJ, 334, 909
Miller, J. S., Stone, R. P. S., 1993, Lick Obs. Tech. Rep.,
No. 66
22
Nikolai N. Chugai, Sergei I. Blinnikov, Robert J. Cumming et al.
Murray, C. A., 1983, Vectorial Astrometry. Adam Hilger,
Bristol
Nadyozhin, D. K., Razinkova, T. L., 1986, Nauchnye infor-
matsii, 61, 29
Niemela, V. S., Ruiz, M. T., Phillips, M. M., 1985, ApJ,
289, 52
Oke, J. B., et al., 1995, PASP, 107, 375
Pastorello, A., Turatto, M., Benetti, S., Cappellaro, E.,
Danziger, I. J., Mazzali, P. A., Patat, F., Filippenko, A.
V., Schlegel, D. J., Matheson, T., 2002, MNRAS, 333, 27
Pikelner, S. B., 1954, Izv. Krymsk. Astroph. Obs. 12, 93
Popov, D. V., 1993, ApJ, 414, 712
Pozzo, M., Meikle, W. P. S., Fassia, A., Geballe, T.,
Lundqvist, P., Chugai N. N., Sollerman, J., 2004, MN-
RAS, in press (astro-ph/0404533)
Rigon, L., Turatto, M., Benetti, S., Pastorello, A., Cappel-
laro, E., Aretxaga, I., Vega, O., Chavushyan, V., Patat,
F., Danziger, I. J., Salvo, M., 2003, MNRAS, 340, 191
Rupen, M. P., et al., 1987, AJ, 94, 61
Ryder, S., Staveley-Smith, L., Dopita, M., Petre, R., Col-
bert, E., Malin, D., Schlegel, E., 1993, ApJ, 416, 167
Schlegel, E. M., 1990, MNRAS, 244, 269
Schlegel, E. M., Kirshner, R. P., Huchra, J. P., Schild, R.
E., 1996, AJ, 111, 2038
Schlegel, E. M., 1999, ApJ, 527, 85
Schuster, A., 1905, ApJ, 21, 1
Shortridge, K., 1990, Starlink User Note, 86, Rutherford
Appleton Laboratory
Sigut, T. A. A., Pradhan, A. K., 2003, ApJS, 145, 15
Sollerman, J., Cumming, R. J., Lundqvist, P., 1998, ApJ,
493, 933
Stathakis, R. A., & Sadler, E. M., 1991, MNRAS, 250, 786
Terlevich, R. J., Tenorio-Tagle, G., Franco, J., Melnick, J.,
1992, MNRAS, 255, 713
Turatto, M., Cappellaro, E., Danziger, I. J., Benetti, S.,
Gouiffes, C., Della Valle, M., 1993, MNRAS 262, 128
Turatto, M., Suzuki, T., Mazzali, P. A., Benetti, S., Cap-
pellaro, E., Danziger, I. J., Nomoto, K., Nakamura, T.,
Young, T. R., Patat, F., 2000, ApJ, 534, L57
van Hoof, P.,
1999, Atomic
Line List
v2.04,
http://www.pa.uky.edu/∼peter/atomic/
Wade, R. A., Horne, K., 1988, ApJ, 324, 411
Weaver, T. A., Woosley, S. E., 1979, BAAS, 11, 724
Wegner, G., Swanson, S. R., 1996, MNRAS, 278, 22
Williams, G. A., Shipman, H. L., 1988, ApJ, 326, 738
Woosley, S. E., Heger, A., Weaver, T. A., 2002, RvMP, 74,
1015
Woosley, S. E., 1986, in Hauck B., Maeder, A., Meynet,
G., eds, Nucleosynthesis and Stellar Evolution, Saas-Fee
Advanced Course 16, Geneva Observatory, Sauverny, p. 1
This paper has been typeset from a TEX/ LATEX file prepared
by the author.
|
astro-ph/9904030 | 2 | 9904 | 1999-07-18T02:00:34 | Luminosity Profiles of Merger Remnants | [
"astro-ph"
] | Using published luminosity and molecular gas profiles of the late-stage mergers NGC 3921, NGC 7252 and Arp 220, we examine the expected luminosity profiles of the evolved merger remnants, especially in light of the massive CO complexes that are observed in their nuclei. For NGC 3921 and NGC 7252 we predict that the resulting luminosity profiles will be characterized by an r^{1/4} law. In view of previous optical work on these systems, it seems likely that they will evolve into normal ellipticals as regards their optical properties. Due to a much higher central molecular column density, Arp 220 might not evolve such a ``seamless'' light profile. We conclude that ultraluminous infrared mergers such as Arp 220 either evolve into ellipticals with anomalous luminosity profiles, or do not produce many low-mass stars out of their molecular gas complexes. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Draft version September 24, 2018
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj
9
9
9
1
l
u
J
8
1
2
v
0
3
0
4
0
9
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
LUMINOSITY PROFILES OF MERGER REMNANTS
National Radio Astronomy Observatory1, 520 Edgemont Road, Charlottesville, VA 22903-2475
J. E. Hibbard
([email protected])
and
Min. S. Yun
National Radio Astronomy Observatory1, P.O. Box 0, Soccoro, NM 87801-0387 ([email protected])
Draft version September 24, 2018
ABSTRACT
Using published luminosity and molecular gas profiles of the late-stage mergers NGC 3921, NGC 7252
and Arp 220, we examine the expected luminosity profiles of the evolved merger remnants, especially in
light of the massive CO complexes that are observed in their nuclei. For NGC 3921 and NGC 7252 we
predict that the resulting luminosity profiles will be characterized by an r1/4 law. In view of previous
optical work on these systems, it seems likely that they will evolve into normal ellipticals as regards their
optical properties. Due to a much higher central molecular column density, Arp 220 might not evolve
such a "seamless" light profile. We conclude that ultraluminous infrared mergers such as Arp 220 either
evolve into ellipticals with anomalous luminosity profiles, or do not produce many low-mass stars out of
their molecular gas complexes.
Subject headings: galaxies: individual (NGC 3921, NGC 7252, Arp 220) -- galaxies: interactions --
galaxies: evolution -- ISM: molecules -- infrared: galaxies
1.
INTRODUCTION
The merger hypothesis for elliptical galaxy formation,
as put forth by Toomre & Toomre (1972; see also Toomre
1977), posits that two spiral galaxies can fall together un-
der their mutual gravitational attraction, eventually evolv-
ing into an elliptical-like remnant. An early objection to
this hypothesis was that the cores of ellipticals are too
dense to result from the dissipationless merging of two
spirals (Carlberg 1986, Gunn 1987, Hernquist, Spergel &
Heyl 1993). An obvious solution to this objection is to
include a dissipative (gaseous) component in the progeni-
tors (for other solutions, see e.g. Veeraraghavan & White
1985, Barnes 1988, Lake 1989). Numerical experiments in-
cluding such a component readily showed that gaseous dis-
sipation can efficiently drive large amounts of material into
the central regions (Negroponte & White 1983, Noguchi
& Ishibashi 1986, Barnes & Hernquist 1991). Indeed, it
was considered a great success for early hydrodynamical
work to be able to reproduce dense knots of gas within
the central regions of simulated merger remnants, similar
to the gas concentrations observed in IR luminous mergers
(Barnes & Hernquist 1991, Sanders et al. 1988b). Since
the inferred central gas mass densities in the observed gas
knots are comparable to the stellar mass density seen in the
cores of normal ellipticals (∼ 102M⊙ pc−3), it seems natu-
ral that they could be the seed of a high surface brightness
remnant (Kormendy & Sanders 1992).
Subsequent numerical work by Mihos & Hernquist
(1994; hereafter MH94) finds that the dissipative response
of the simulated gas component is so efficient that the
resulting mass profiles of the simulated remnants are un-
like those seen in normal ellipticals. In particular, ensu-
ing starformation leaves behind a dense stellar core whose
surface density profile does not join smoothly onto the
de Vaucoleurs r1/4 profile of the pre-existing stellar pop-
ulation.
Instead, the profiles exhibit a "spike" at small
radii, with a suggested increase in surface brightness by
factors ∼100. While the predicted break in the mass den-
sity profile occurs at spatial scales comparable to the grav-
itational softening length of the simulations, making the
precise slope somewhat questionable, the conclusion that
the profiles should exhibit a clear break was considered
firm (MH94). This prediction, if confirmed, offers a means
to constrain the frequency of highly dissipative mergers in
the past by searching for their fossil remnants in the cores
of nearby ellipticals. However, the numerical formalisms
used in MH94 to model gaseous dissipation, star forma-
tion, and energy injection back into the ISM from mas-
sive stars and SNe ("feedback") are necessarily ad hoc in
nature. As such, these predictions should be viewed as
preliminary (as Mihos & Hernquist themselves note).
We investigate this question observationally by convert-
ing the observed gas column densities of on-going or late-
stage mergers into optical surface brightness by assuming a
stellar mass-to-light ratio appropriate for an evolved pop-
ulation. This light is added to the observed luminosity
profile after allowing it to age passively. The resulting lu-
minosity profile is examined for anomalous features such
as the sharp break predicted by MH94.
We conduct this experiment with the late-stage mergers
NGC 3921 and NGC 7252 and with the ultraluminous in-
frared (ULIR) merger Arp 220. These systems were chosen
because they have been observed in the CO(1-0) molecu-
lar line transition with resolutions (full width at half max-
1The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the National Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement by
Associated Universities, Inc.
1
2
Luminosity Profiles of Merger Remnants
imum) of 2′′
− 2.5′′ (Yun & Hibbard 1999a, Wang et al.
1992, Scoville et al. 1997). The resulting spatial radial
resolution (300 -- 400 pc; Ho= 75 km s−1 Mpc−1) is similar
to the hydrodynamical smoothing length used in MH94 (∼
350 pc)2, indicating that the molecular line observations
have sufficient resolution to resolve the types of mass con-
centrations found in the simulations. The molecular gas
surface densities of each of these systems are plotted in
Figure 1, converted from CO fluxes by adopting a con-
version factor of NH2 /ICO = 3 × 1020 cm−2 (K km s−1)−1
(Young & Scoville 1991). Detailed studies on each of these
systems, which fully discuss their status as late stage merg-
ers, can be found in Schweizer (1996) and Hibbard & van
Gorkom (1996) for NGC 3921; Schweizer (1982) and Hib-
bard et al. (1994) for NGC 7252; and Scoville et al. (1997)
for Arp 220.
2. RESULTS
2.1. NGC 3921 & NGC 7252
For these moderately evolved merger remnants (ages of
∼ 0.5 -- 1 Gyr since their tidal tails were launched, Hibbard
et al. 1994, Hibbard & van Gorkom 1996), the observed
gas and luminosity profiles are used to predict the expected
luminosity profile of a 2 Gyr old remnant. We assume that
all of the molecular gas is turned into stars at the same
radii, adopting an exponentially declining starformation
history. The present luminosity profile is allowed to fade
due to passive aging effects, and the final luminosity pro-
file is the sum of these two populations. The molecular gas
profiles plotted in Fig. 1 are converted into gas mass den-
sities by multiplying by a factor of 1.36 to take into con-
sideration the expected contribution of Helium. Optical
luminosity profiles have been obtained by Schweizer (1982,
1996), Whitmore et al. (1993), and Hibbard et al. (1994),
showing them to be well fitted by an r1/4 profile over all
radii, with no apparent luminosity spikes.
The gas surface densities (Σgas in M⊙ pc−2) are con-
verted to optical surface brightnesses (µB) by dividing
by the stellar mass-to-light ratio (M∗/LB) expected for
a 2 Gyr old population. We adopt the stellar mass-to-
light ratios given by de Jong (1995, Table 1 of ch. 4),
which were derived from the population synthesis mod-
els of Bruzual & Charlot (1993) for an exponentially de-
clining star formation history, a Salpeter IMF, and Solar
metallicity (M∗/LB = 0.82 M⊙L−1
⊙ at 2 Gyr). Noting
that 1 L⊙ pc−2 corresponds to µB = 27.06 mag arcsec−2
(adopting MB,⊙ = +5.48), the conversion from gas surface
density to optical surface brightness is given by µB(r) =
27.06 mag arcsec−2 − 2.5 × log[Σgas(r)/(M∗/LB)].
The luminosity profiles of the evolved remnants are
estimated from the observed B-band profiles (Schweizer
1996, Hibbard et al. 1994), allowing for a fading of +1 mag
arcsec−2 in the B-band over the next 2 Gyr (Bruzual &
Charlot 1993, Schweizer 1996), and adding in the expected
contribution of the population formed from the molecular
gas, calculated as above. We emphasize that this should
favor the production of a luminous post-merger popula-
tion, since it assumes the that none of the molecular gas
is lost to stellar winds or SNe and the adopted IMF favors
the production of many long-lived low-mass stars.
The results of this exercise are plotted in Figure 2. This
2Assuming scaling parameters appropriate for a MilkyWay-like progenitor.
plot shows that the observed gas densities in NGC 3921
and NGC 7252, although high, are not high enough to
significantly affect the present luminosity profiles. The
profile of NGC 3921 is basically indistinguishable from an
r1/4 profile. The profile of NGC 7252 does show a slight
rise at small radii, but not the clear break predicted by
MH94. Therefore the resulting luminosity profiles of these
remnants are now and should remain fairly typical of nor-
mal elliptical galaxies, and the conclusions of MH94 are
not applicable to all mergers of gas-rich galaxies. Since
both of these systems also obey the Faber-Jackson rela-
tionship (Lake & Dressler 1986) and NGC 7252 falls upon
the fundamental plane defined by normal ellipticals (Hib-
bard et al. 1994, Hibbard 1995), we conclude that at least
some mergers of gas-rich systems can evolve into normal
elliptical galaxies as far as their optical properties are con-
cerned.
2.2. Arp 220
Since Arp 220 is an extremely dusty object, its opti-
cal luminosity profile is poorly suited for a similar analy-
sis. Instead, we use a luminosity profile measured in the
near-infrared, where the dust obscuration is an order of
magnitude less severe. Arp 220 was recently observed
with camera 2 of NICMOS aboard the HST (Scoville et
al. 1998), and we use the resulting K −band luminosity
profile, kindly made available by N. Scoville. Since Arp
220 is presently undergoing a massive starburst, the fading
factor is much less certain than for the already evolved sys-
tems treated above, and depends sensitively on what frac-
tion of the current light is contributed by recently formed
stars. We adopt a situation biased towards the production
of a discrepant luminosity profile by assuming that the en-
tire population was pre-existing, converting the observed
K −band profile to an evolved B−band profile by adopting
a B −K color of 4, appropriate for a 10 Gyr old population
(de Jong 1995). The contribution due to the population
formed from the molecular disk is calculated exactly as
before. The resulting profile is shown in Figure 2.
This figure shows that Arp 220 is predicted to evolve
a luminosity profile with a noticeable rise at small radii.
This is due to the peak in the molecular gas surface den-
sity at radii less than 0.5 kpc (Fig. 1). We conclude that
Arp 220 has the potential to evolve a similar feature in its
luminosity profile, if indeed all of the current molecular gas
is converted into stars. However, the expected rise of ∼2
mag arcsec2 in surface brightness (a factor of ∼6) is con-
siderably lower than the two orders of magnitude increase
predicted by the simulations (see Fig. 1 of MH94).
3. DISCUSSION
From the above exercise, we conclude that neither NGC
3921 nor NGC 7252 are expected to show a significant de-
viation in their luminosity profiles, and that the maximum
rise expected for Arp 220 is considerably lower than the
two orders of magnitude increase predicted by the simula-
tions of MH94. We conclude that the numerical formalisms
adopted in the simulations to treat the gas and star forma-
tion are incomplete. Mihos & Hernquist enumerate var-
ious possible shortcomings of their code. For example,
their star-formation criterion is extrapolated from studies
Hibbard & Yun
3
of quiescent disk galaxies, and may not apply to violent
starbursts. Perhaps most importantly, their simulations
fail to reproduce the gas outflows seen in ULIR galaxies
("superwinds" e.g. Heckman, Armus & Miley 1990, Heck-
man, Lehnert & Armus 1993), suggesting that the numer-
ical treatment of feedback is inadequate.
In spite of these results, it is still interesting that under
some conditions there might be an observational signature
of a past merging event in the light profile of the remnant.
The question is for which mergers might this be the case?
Since ΣH2 is tightly correlated with IR luminosity (Yun
& Hibbard 1999b), we infer that only the ultraluminous
IR galaxies retain the possibility to evolve into ellipticals
with a central rise in their luminosity profiles. While such
profiles are not typical of ellipticals in general, they are
not unheard of. For example, ∼ 10% of the the Nuker
sample profiles presented by Byun et al. (1996) show such
anomalous cores (e.g., NGC 1331, NGC 4239). It is there-
fore possible that such systems evolve from ultraluminous
IR galaxies. This can be tested by careful "galactic ar-
chaeology" in such systems to search for signatures of a
past merger event (e.g., Schweizer & Seitzer 1992, Malin
& Hadley 1997).
However, it is not a foregone conclusion that systems
like Arp 220 will evolve anomalous profiles. This system
presently hosts a very powerful expanding "superwind"
(Heckman et al. 1996), which may be able to eject a signif-
icant fraction of the cold gas in a "mass-loaded flow" (e.g.
Heckman et al. 1999). Such winds are common in ULIR
galaxies (Heckman, Armus & Miley 1990, Heckman, Lehn-
ert & Armus 1993). Another related possibility is that
the IMF may be biased towards massive stars (i.e. "top
heavy", Young et al. 1986, Scoville & Soifer 1991). Such
mass functions will leave far fewer stellar remnants than
the IMF adopted here. A third possibility is that the stan-
dard Galactic CO-to-H2 conversion factor is inappropriate
for ULIR galaxies, and that the high gas surface densities
derived from CO observations (and thus the resulting stel-
lar luminosity profile) may be over-estimated (see Downes
et al. 1993, Bryant & Scoville 1996).
Some support for the idea that central gas cores may
be depleted by the starburst is given by a population syn-
thesis model of NGC 7252, which suggests that it expe-
rienced an IR luminous phase (Fritze-von Alvensleben &
Gerhard 1994). While the current radial distribution of
molecular gas in NGC 7252 is flat and lacks the central
core seen in Arp 220, it appears to connect smoothly with
that of Arp 220 in Fig. 1. Therefore one may speculate
that NGC 7252 did indeed have a radial gas density pro-
file much like Arp 220 but has since lost the high density
gas core as a result of prodigious massive star formation
and/or superwind blowout. However, the burst parame-
ters are not strongly constrained by the available obser-
vations, and a weaker burst spread over a longer period
may also be allowed (Fritze-von Alvensleben & Gerhard
1994). Further insight into this question could be obtained
by constraining the past star formation history in other
evolved merger remnants.
In conclusion, a comparison of the peak molecu-
lar column densities and optical surface brightnesses in
NGC 3921 and NGC 7252 suggests that some mergers
between gas-rich disks will evolve into elliptical-like rem-
nants with typical luminosity profiles, even considering
their present central gas supply. For ULIR galaxies like
Arp 220 the case is less clear. Such systems will either
produce an excess of light at small radii, as seen in a small
number of ellipticals, or require some process such as mass-
loaded galactic winds or a top-heavy IMF to deplete the
central gas supply without leaving too many evolved stars.
If the latter possibility can be excluded, then the frequency
of such profiles may be used to constrain the number of
early type systems formed via ULIR mergers.3
4. SUMMARY
• Even under assumptions that favor the production of
a luminous post-merger population, the dense molec-
ular gas complexes found in the centers of NGC 3291
and NGC 7252 should not significantly alter their
luminosity profiles, which are already typical of el-
liptical galaxies (Schweizer 1982, Schweizer 1996).
Since these systems also obey the Faber-Jackson re-
lationship (Lake & Dressler 1986) and NGC 7252
falls upon the fundamental plane defined by normal
ellipticals (Hibbard et al. 1994, Hibbard 1995), it
appears that at least some mergers of gas-rich sys-
tems can evolve into normal elliptical galaxies as far
as their optical properties are concerned.
• The dense molecular gas complex found in the cen-
ter of Arp 220 may result in a moderate rise in the
remnants' luminosity profile at small radii. Since the
molecular gas column density is a tight function of
IR luminosity (Yun & Hibbard 1999b), we conclude
that this condition may apply to all of the ultra-
luminous infrared galaxies. However, this does not
preclude a merger origin for elliptical galaxies since
(1) About 10% of the Nuker sample ellipticals (Byun
et al. 1996) show such rises in their radial light pro-
files, and (2) it is possible that much of the gas in
such systems is blown into intergalactic space by the
mass-loaded superwinds found emanating from such
objects (Heckman et al. 1999, Heckman, Lehnert &
Armus 1993).
• The maximum expected rise in the luminosity pro-
files are considerably lower than the orders of magni-
tude increase predicted by the simulations (MH94).
We therefore suggest that the numerical formalisms
adopted in the simulations to treat the gas and star
formation are incomplete.
The authors thank N. Scoville for kindly providing the
NICMOS K-band profile for Arp 220. We thank F.
Schweizer and J. van Gorkom for comments on an earlier
version of this paper, and R. Bender and C. Mihos for use-
ful discussions, and the referee, J. Barnes, for a thorough
report.
3We note that any subsequent dissipationless merging of these cores with other stellar system will tend to smooth out these profiles.
4
Luminosity Profiles of Merger Remnants
REFERENCES
Barnes, J. E. 1988, ApJ, 331, 699
Barnes, J.E., & Hernquist, L. 1991, ApJ, 370, L65
Bryant, P.M. & Scoville, N.Z. 1996, ApJ, 457, 678
Bruzual, G. & Charlot, S. 1993, ApJ, 405, 538
Byun, Y.-L., Grillmair, C. J., Faber, S. M., Ajhar, E. A., Dressler,
A., Kormendy, J., Lauer, T. R., Richstone, D., & Tremaine, S.
1996, AJ, 111, 1889
Carlberg, R. G. 1986, ApJ, 310, 593
Downes, D., Solomon, P. M., & Radford, S. J. E. 1993, ApJ, 414, 13
Fritze-von Alvensleben, U., Gerhard, O. E. 1994, A&A, 285, 751 &
775
Gunn, J. E. 1987, in "Nearly Normal Galaxies: From the Planck
Time to the Present", edited by S. M. Faber (Springer, New York),
p. 455
Heckman, T. M., Dahlem, M., Eales, S. A., Fabbiano, G., & Weaver,
K. 1996, ApJ, 457, 616
Heckman, T. M., Armus, L., Weaver, K. & Wang, J. 1999, ApJ, 517,
130
Heckman, T. M., Armus, L. & Miley, G. K. 1990, ApJS, 74, 833
Heckman, T. M., Lehnert, M. & Armus, L. 1993, in "The Evolution
of Galaxies and their Environment", edited by H. A. Thronson
and J. M. Shull (Kluwer, Dordrecht), p. 455
Hernquist, L., Spergel, D. N. & Heyl, J. S. 1993, ApJ, 416, 415
Hibbard, J.E. 1995, PhD Thesis, Columbia University
Hibbard, J.E., Guhathakurta, P., van Gorkom, J.H., & Schweizer, F.
1994, AJ, 107, 67
Hibbard, J.E., & van Gorkom, J.H. 1996, AJ, 111, 655
de Jong, R. S. 1995, PhD Thesis, University of Groningen
Kormendy, J., & Sanders, D.B. 1992, ApJ, 390, L53
Lake, G. 1989, AJ, 97, 1312
Lake, G., & Dressler, A. 1986, ApJ, 310, 605
Malin, D. F. & Hadley, B. 1997, PASA, 14, 52
Mihos, J.C., & Hernquist, L. 1996, ApJ, 437, L47 (MH94)
Negroponte, J., White, S.D.M. 1983, MNRAS, 205, 1009
Noguchi, M., & Ishibashi, S. 1986, MNRAS, 219, 305
Sanders, D.B., Scoville, N.Z., Sargent, A.I., Soifer, B.T. 1988b, ApJ,
324, L55
Schweizer, 1982, ApJ, 252, 455
Schweizer, F. 1996, AJ, 111, 109
Schweizer, F., & Seitzer, P. 1992, AJ, 104, 3
Scoville, N.Z., & Soifer, B.T. 1991, in Massive Stars in Starbursts,
eds. C. Leitherer, N.R. Walborn, T.M. Heckman, & C.A. Norman
(Cambridge Univ. Press: New York), p 233.
Scoville, N.Z., Yun, M.S., & Bryant, P.M. 1997, ApJ, 484, 702
Scoville, N.Z., Evans, A.S., Dinshaw, N., Thompson, R., Rieke, M.,
Schneider, G., Low, F.J., Hines, D., Stobie, B. & Epps, H. 1998,
ApJ, 492, L107
Toomre, A. 1977,
in "The Evolution of Galaxies and Stellar
Populations", edited by B. M. Tinsley and R. B. Larson (Yale
University Press, New Haven), p. 401
Toomre, A., & Toomre, J. 1972, ApJ, 178, 623
Veeraraghavan, S. & White, S. D. M. 1985, ApJ, 296, 336
Wang, Z., Schweizer, F., & Scoville, N.Z. 1992, ApJ, 396, 510
Whitmore, B.C., Schweizer, F., Leitherer, C., Borne, K., & Robert,
C. 1993, AJ, 106, 1354
Young, J. S., Schloerb, F. P., Kenney, J. D., & Lord, S. D. 1986,
ApJ, 304, 443
Young, J.S., & Scoville, N.Z. 1991, ARA&A, 29, 581
Yun, M.S., & Hibbard, J. E. 1999a, ApJ, submitted
Yun, M. S., & Hibbard, J. E., 1999b, submitted
Hibbard & Yun
5
Fig. 1. -- Radial surface molecular gas mass density profiles (in M⊙ pc−2) derived from the integrated CO flux maps are plotted as a function
of radius. The CO fluxes have been turned into mass densities by adopting a conversion factor of NH2 /ICO = 3 × 1020 cm−2 (K km s−1)−1.
The data are from Yun & Hibbard (1999a) for NGC 3921 (dotted line); from Wang et al. (1991) for NGC 7252 (solid line); and from Scoville
et al. (1997) for Arp 220 (dashed line).
6
Luminosity Profiles of Merger Remnants
Fig. 2. -- Predicted luminosity profiles as a function of the fourth-root of the radius for the aged remnants of NGC 3921, NGC 7252,
and Arp 220. Dotted lines: expected contribution to the B−band profile by the present stellar component, after aging by 2 Gyr. For NGC
3921 and NGC 7252 this is calculated from the presently observed B−band luminosity profiles (taken from the data in Schweizer 1996 and
Hibbard et al. 1994) and fading by 1 mag arcsec−2. For Arp 220 we use the observed K −band luminosity profile (from Scoville et al. 1998)
adopting B − K = 4 for a 10 Gyr old population. Dashed lines: expected contribution to the B−band profile from the expected post-merger
population if all the molecular gas is turned into stars. Solid lines: the expected B−band luminosity profiles after adding in the aged stellar
and post-merger populations. No significant deviation from a pure r1/4 law expected for NGC 3921 or NGC 7252. Arp 220 does not show
such a seamless profile, exhibiting a slight rise in at small radii.
|
astro-ph/0207488 | 1 | 0207 | 2002-07-23T09:24:14 | The status of Galactic field lambda Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era | [
"astro-ph"
] | The lambda Bootis stars are Population I, late B to early F-type stars, with moderate to extreme (up to a factor 100) surface underabundances of most Fe-peak elements and solar abundances of lighter elements (C, N, O, and S). To put constraints on the various existing theories that try to explain these peculiar stars, we investigate the observational properties of lambda Bootis stars compared to a reference sample of normal stars. Using various photometric systems and Hipparcos data, we analyze the validity of standard photometric calibrations, elemental abundances, and Galactic space motions. There crystallizes a clear picture of a homogeneous group of Population I objects found at all stages of their main-sequence evolution, with a peak at about 1 Gyr. No correlation of astrophysical parameters such as the projected rotational velocities or elemental abundances with age is found, suggesting that the a-priori unknown mechanism, which creates lambda Bootis stars, works continuously for late B to early F-type stars in all stages of main-sequence evolution. Surprisingly, the sodium abundances seem to indicate an interaction between the stars and their local environment. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 ()
Printed 2 November 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the
post-Hipparcos era
E. Paunzen1,2, I.Kh. Iliev3, I. Kamp4, I.S. Barzova3
1-Institut fur Astronomie der Universitat Wien, Turkenschanzstr. 17, 1180 Wien, Austria
2-Zentraler Informatikdienst der Universitat Wien, Universitatsstr. 7, 1010 Wien, Austria
3-Institute of Astronomy, National Astronomical Observatory, P.O. Box 136, 4700 Smolyan, Bulgaria
4-Leiden Observatory, Niels Bohrweg 2, PO Box 9513, 2330 RA Leiden, The Netherlands
2 November 2018
ABSTRACT
The λ Bootis stars are Population I, late B to early F-type stars, with moderate to
extreme (up to a factor 100) surface underabundances of most Fe-peak elements and
solar abundances of lighter elements (C, N, O, and S). To put constraints on the
various existing theories that try to explain these peculiar stars, we investigate the
observational properties of λ Bootis stars compared to a reference sample of normal
stars. Using various photometric systems and Hipparcos data, we analyze the valid-
ity of standard photometric calibrations, elemental abundances, and Galactic space
motions.
There crystallizes a clear picture of a homogeneous group of Population I objects
found at all stages of their main-sequence evolution, with a peak at about 1 Gyr.
No correlation of astrophysical parameters such as the projected rotational velocities
or elemental abundances with age is found, suggesting that the a-priori unknown
mechanism, which creates λ Bootis stars, works continuously for late B to early F-type
stars in all stages of main-sequence evolution. Surprisingly, the sodium abundances
seem to indicate an interaction between the stars and their local environment.
Key words: Stars: λ Bootis -- Stars: chemically peculiar -- Stars: early-type
1
INTRODUCTION
Knowledge of the evolutionary status of the members of the
λ Bootis group is essential to put tight constraints on the as-
trophysical processes behind this phenomenon. We have cho-
sen the following working definition as group characteristics:
late B- to early F-type, Population I stars with apparently
solar abundances of the light elements (C, N, O and S) and
moderate to strong underabundances of Fe-peak elements
(see Faraggiana & Gerbaldi 1998 for a critical summary of
the various definitions). Only a maximum of about 2% of all
objects in the relevant spectral domain are believed to be
λ Bootis -type stars (Paunzen 2001). That already suggests
either that the mechanism responsible for the phenomenon
works on a very short time-scale (106 yrs) or else the general
conditions for the development are very strict.
We know already of a few λ Bootis stars in the Orion
OB1 association and one candidate in NGC 2264 (Paun-
zen 2001), for both of which log t ≈ 7.0. The evolutionary
status for two λ Bootis -type spectroscopic-binary systems
(HD 84948 and HD 171948) has been determined as very
close to the Zero Age Main Sequence (ZAMS hereafter) for
HD 171948 and to the Terminal Age Main Sequence (TAMS
hereafter) for HD 84948 (Iliev et al. 2002). The results for
the other Galactic field stars are not clear.
In 1995, Iliev & Barzova summarized the evolution-
ary status of 20 λ Bootis stars (and Vega) using Stromgren
uvbyβ photometric data. They concluded that most of the
stars studied are in the middle of their main-sequence evo-
lution, with only a few objects near the ZAMS.
Paunzen (1997) investigated the parallaxes measured by
the Hipparcos satellite for a sample of λ Bootis -type stars
in order to derive luminosities, masses and ages for 18 ob-
jects in common with Iliev & Barzova (1995). He found no
systematic influence of the distance, effective temperature,
metallicity and rotational velocity on the difference between
photometrically calibrated absolute magnitudes and those
derived from Hipparcos parallaxes. Six objects were found
to be very close to the ZAMS and a hypothesis was pro-
posed that all other stars are in their Pre-Main-Sequence
(PMS hereafter) phase.
Later on, Bohlender, Gonzalez & Matthews (1999) and
Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) challenged that hypothesis
with plausible arguments such as the unusually vigorous
star-forming activity that it implied in the solar neighbour-
hood and a statistical analysis of normal-type stars.
2
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
Already Gray & Corbally (1998) stated that the
λ Bootis phenomenon can be found from very early stages
to well into the main-sequence life of A-type stars. That con-
clusion was based on the incidence of λ Bootis stars among
very young A-type stars, which is not very different from
the incidence among Galactic field stars.
In this paper we present a much more extensive in-
vestigation, including the data of the Hipparcos satellite.
With the help of photometric data of the Johnson UBV,
Stromgren uvbyβ and Geneva 7-colour systems, different cal-
ibrations of the absolute magnitude, effective temperature
and surface gravity are applied and compared.
From evolutionary models (Claret 1995), masses and
ages are estimated. They are compared with those derived
by Iliev & Barzova (1995) and Paunzen (1997).
As a further step, the proper motions of λ Bootis stars
are used to calculate space velocities. That very important
information should help further to sharpen the group prop-
erties and to sort out probably misclassified stars.
Another point
investigated is
the question as to
whether there exists a typical abundance pattern for the
λ Bootis group. Heiter (2002) and Heiter et al. (2002) tried
to shed more light on the abundance pattern in the context
of the proposed theories. We have searched for correlations
of the individual abundances with, especially, mass and age.
However, we will not comment on our results in the
context of the developed theories and models, because they
still depend on too many free parameters. The aim of this
paper is not to promote one of the suggested theories but
rather to find strict observational constraints which should
be incorporated into future theoretical investigations.
2 PROGRAM STARS AND THEIR
ASTROPHYSICAL PARAMETERS
The program stars were taken from the lists of Gray &
Corbally (1998) and Paunzen (2001), with the omission
of apparent spectroscopic binary systems (e.g. HD 38545,
HD 64491, HD 111786, HD 141851 and HD 148638) as well
as of HD 191850 for which no β measurement is available so
no reliable astrophysical parameters could be derived from
the Stromgren photometric system. A further critical as-
sessment of the literature was performed in order to reject
probable non-members and ill-defined objects. In total, 57
well established λ Bootis stars were chosen.
The
data were
photometric
from the
General Catalogue
(GCPD;
http://obswww.unige.ch/gcpd/)
from the
Hipparcos and Tycho database. If available, averaged and
weighted mean values were used.
of Photometric Data
taken
as well
as
The following calibrations for the individual photomet-
ric systems were used to derive the effective temperatures
and surface gravities:
• Johnson UBV: Napiwotzki, Schonberner & Wenske
(1993)
• Stromgren uvbyβ: Moon & Dworetsky (1985) and Napi-
wotzki et al. (1993)
• Geneva 7-colour: Kobi & North (1990) and Kunzli et
al. (1997)
The reddening and absolute magnitudes were estimated by
use of the Stromgren uvbyβ system. The calibrations for the
Johnson UBV and Geneva 7-colour system need an a-priori
knowledge of the reddening which is not easy to estimate.
An independent way to derive the interstellar redden-
ing maps is to use data from open clusters as well as Galac-
tic field stars. Several different models have been published
in the literature (Arenou, Grenon & G´omez 1992, Hakkila
et al. 1997). Chen et al. (1998) compared the results from
Arenou et al. (1992) and those derived from Hipparcos mea-
surements, and found an overestimation in previously pub-
lished results for distances less than 500 pc. They conse-
quently proposed a new model for Galactic latitudes of
±10◦, but otherwise find excellent agreement with the model
by Sandage (1972). We use here the model proposed by Chen
et al. (1998) who corrected previous models by Arenou et
al. (1992) on the basis of the Hipparcos data. The values
from the calibration of the Stromgren uvbyβ and the model
by Chen et al. (1998) are in very good agreement. To min-
imize possible inconsistencies we have averaged the values
from both approaches.
The Hipparcos parallaxes were converted directly into
absolute magnitudes. The latter were averaged (using
weights based on the standard errors) with the abso-
lute magnitudes derived from the photometric calibra-
tions. With the absolute bolometric magnitude of the Sun
(MBol)⊙ = 4.75 mag (Cayrel de Strobel 1996) and the bolo-
metric correction taken from Drilling & Landolt (2000), lu-
minosities (log L∗/L⊙) were calculated (Table 1).
We have also corrected our data for the so-called 'Lutz --
Kelker effect' (Koen 1992), an overestimation of paral-
laxes owing to random errors. Oudmaijer, Groenewegen &
Schrijver (1998) showed that that bias has to be taken into
account if individual absolute magnitudes from Hipparcos
parallaxes are calculated.
The projected rotational velocities were taken from Ue-
sugi & Fukuda (1982), Sturenburg (1993), Abt & Morrell
(1995), Holweger & Rentzsch-Holm (1995), Chernyshova
et al. (1998), Heiter et al. (1998), Paunzen et al. (1999a,b),
Kamp et al. (2001), Solano et al. (2001), Andrievsky et
al. (2002) and Heiter (2002). If possible the individual val-
ues were averaged with weights in accordance with the listed
standard errors.
As the next step, we have used the post-MS evolution-
ary tracks and isochrones from Claret (1995) to estimate the
individual masses and ages for our program stars. The mod-
els were calculated with solar abundances. That is justified
because the abundance pattern found for the λ Bootis stars
must be restricted to the surface only: almost all of them
would lie below the Population II ZAMS which would be ap-
plicable if they were metal-poor throughout. Table 2 lists the
masses together with minimum and maximum ages, which
are not necessarily equally spaced owing to the shape of
the isochrones. Since the lifetime for a star on the MS is
dependent on its mass, we have transformed the ages thus
determined into relative ones (trel) in the following way. For
our sample we find masses (Table 2) from 1.6 to 2.5 M⊙,
which correspond to times on the MS of 2.2 Gyr down to
700 Myr. The relative age is zero for an object which just
arrived at the ZAMS and unity for stars at the TAMS. We
have taken into account the error of the estimated mass as
well as the error box of the calibrated ages.
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
3
Table 1. Photometric data, stellar parameters and calibrated values for the program stars. In parenthesis are the errors in the final
digits of the corresponding quantity.
HD
HR
HIP
V
[mag]
B − V
[mag]
b − y
[mag]
AV
[mag]
v sin i
[kms−1]
Teff
[K]
log g(phot)
[dex]
MV
[mag]
log L∗/L⊙
319
6870
7908
11413
13755
15165
23392
24472
30422
31295
35242
54272
74873
75654
81290
83041
83277
84123
87271
90821
91130
101108
102541
105058
105759
106223
107233
109738
110377
110411
111005
111604
120500
120896
125162
125889
130767
142703
142944
149130
153747
154153
156954
168740
168947
170680
175445
183324
184779
192640
193256
193281
198160
204041
210111
216847
221756
12
541
1525
1570
1777
3481
3517
4124
4824
4828
4875
5351
5930
6338
6871
6944
7400
636
5321
6108
8593
10304
11390
17462
18153
22192
22845
25205
43121
43354
46011
47018
47155
47752
49328
51556
56768
57567
58992
59346
59594
60134
61937
61960
62318
62641
67481
67705
69732
72505
78078
81329
83410
83650
84895
90304
90806
92884
95793
99770
7736
7764C
100286
7764A 100288
7959
102962
105819
8203
109306
8437
113351
116354
8947
5.934
7.494
7.288
5.940
7.844
6.705
8.260
7.092
6.186
4.648
6.348
8.800
5.890
6.384
8.866
8.927
8.304
6.840
7.120
9.470
5.902
8.880
7.939
8.900
6.550
7.431
7.353
8.277
6.228
4.881
7.959
5.886
6.600
8.495
4.186
9.849
6.905
6.120
7.179
8.498
7.420
6.185
7.679
6.138
8.123
5.132
7.792
5.795
8.940
4.934
7.721
6.557
5.663
6.456
6.377
7.060
5.576
0.141
0.246
0.272
0.147
0.318
0.333
0.020
0.304
0.190
0.085
0.122
0.261
0.115
0.242
0.332
0.294
0.311
0.297
0.172
0.105
0.109
0.179
0.230
0.183
0.218
0.288
0.255
0.198
0.195
0.077
0.376
0.160
0.131
0.296
0.084
0.241
0.042
0.240
0.293
0.342
0.140
0.284
0.294
0.201
0.196
0.008
0.110
0.084
0.224
0.154
0.213
0.190
0.189
0.161
0.203
0.242
0.095
0.079
0.164
0.192
0.105
0.181
0.191
0.014
0.214
0.101
0.044
0.068
0.214
0.064
0.161
0.254
0.223
0.226
0.235
0.151
0.068
0.073
0.114
0.163
0.129
0.142
0.228
0.192
0.161
0.120
0.040
0.224
0.112
0.068
0.166
0.051
0.206
0.002
0.182
0.201
0.233
0.098
0.199
0.200
0.136
0.172
0.008
0.055
0.051
0.187
0.099
0.116
0.098
0.108
0.092
0.136
0.155
0.056
0.004
0.000
0.000
0.004
0.000
0.010
0.094
0.003
0.014
0.063
0.042
0.000
0.078
0.012
0.124
0.161
0.131
0.040
0.008
0.013
0.000
0.006
0.097
0.009
0.000
0.015
0.048
0.073
0.000
0.045
0.009
0.000
0.017
0.000
0.039
0.108
0.000
0.021
0.013
0.109
0.128
0.020
0.050
0.035
0.116
0.091
0.108
0.083
0.000
0.016
0.063
0.111
0.022
0.026
0.000
0.000
0.043
60
165
125
90
135
115
90
130
45
55
95
20
150
135
90
140
120
90
95
170
165
180
125
115
100
180
50
145
205
90
80
250
95
200
65
55
105
8020(135)
7330(102)
7145(87)
7925(124)
7080(161)
7010(167)
9805(281)
6945(131)
7865(108)
8920(177)
8250(103)
7010(217)
8700(245)
7350(104)
6895(214)
7120(208)
7000(189)
7025(175)
7515(232)
8190(79)
8135(98)
7810(80)
7665(168)
7740(171)
7485(102)
6855(247)
7265(143)
7610(145)
7720(89)
8930(206)
6860(66)
7760(149)
8220(70)
7260(89)
8720(156)
7275(175)
9195(220)
7265(150)
7000(125)
6945(103)
8205(90)
7055(120)
7130(93)
7630(81)
7555(185)
9840(248)
8520(198)
8950(204)
7210(173)
7940(96)
7740(94)
8035(115)
7870(129)
7980(97)
7550(123)
7355(78)
8510(188)
3.74(8)
3.84(11)
4.10(12)
3.91(21)
3.26(10)
3.23(10)
4.35(9)
3.81(16)
4.00(20)
4.20(1)
3.90(14)
3.83(10)
4.21(11)
3.77(11)
3.82(28)
3.76(20)
3.67(18)
3.73(17)
3.43(10)
3.73(10)
3.78(10)
3.90(18)
4.22(16)
3.77(30)
3.65(10)
3.49(18)
4.03(10)
3.90(13)
3.97(14)
4.14(14)
3.72(10)
3.61(25)
3.86(10)
3.76(10)
4.07(9)
3.88(9)
4.10(8)
3.93(12)
3.19(4)
3.49(5)
3.70(24)
3.56(6)
4.04(13)
3.88(14)
3.67(10)
4.15(6)
3.96(10)
4.13(4)
3.63(21)
3.95(18)
3.69(17)
3.54(4)
3.99(9)
3.97(8)
3.84(15)
3.47(14)
3.90(3)
1.27(19)
2.29(42)
2.60(18)
1.49(10)
0.93(10)
1.12(16)
1.43(30)
2.14(11)
2.35(1)
1.66(22)
1.75(22)
2.33(30)
1.82(1)
1.83(12)
1.85(30)
1.70(30)
1.49(29)
1.58(15)
1.02(8)
0.74(30)
1.36(26)
1.33(30)
2.34(21)
0.86(30)
1.35(21)
1.83(45)
2.64(13)
1.85(30)
1.96(11)
1.90(28)
1.76(53)
0.48(7)
0.85(34)
1.90(30)
1.71(23)
2.32(30)
1.27(1)
2.41(12)
0.80(30)
1.51(30)
1.24(30)
1.86(29)
2.81(33)
1.82(2)
1.28(30)
0.83(23)
1.08(27)
1.64(42)
1.26(30)
1.84(1)
1.08(30)
0.41(30)
1.47(41)
1.75(18)
1.76(15)
0.93(24)
1.16(16)
1.45(8)
1.02(17)
0.90(7)
1.35(4)
1.57(4)
1.50(6)
1.45(12)
1.09(5)
1.01(1)
1.32(9)
1.26(9)
1.01(12)
1.24(1)
1.20(5)
1.20(12)
1.26(12)
1.35(12)
1.31(6)
1.53(3)
1.66(12)
1.42(11)
1.42(12)
1.01(9)
1.60(12)
1.40(8)
1.22(18)
0.88(5)
1.20(12)
1.16(5)
1.22(11)
1.24(21)
1.75(3)
1.62(13)
1.18(12)
1.28(9)
1.01(12)
1.48(1)
0.97(5)
1.62(12)
1.34(12)
1.46(12)
1.19(11)
0.82(13)
1.21(1)
1.43(12)
1.70(9)
1.53(11)
1.32(17)
1.43(12)
1.22(1)
1.51(12)
1.79(12)
1.36(16)
1.25(7)
1.23(6)
1.56(10)
1.50(6)
4
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
Table 2. Calibrated values for the program stars using the models
of Claret (1995); trel is the relative age ranging from zero for
an object just arriving at the ZAMS to unity for a star at the
TAMS; ∆log g = log g(evol) − log g(phot); log t1 and log t2 are the
minimum and maximum ages derived from the error boxes.
HD
M
[M⊙]
∆log g
log t
[dex]
log t1
[dex]
log t2
[dex]
trel
319
6870
7908
11413
13755
15165
23392
24472
30422
31295
35242
54272
74873
75654
81290
83041
83277
84123
87271
90821
91130
101108
102541
105058
105759
106223
107233
109738
110377
110411
111005
111604
120500
120896
125162
125889
130767
142703
142944
149130
153747
154153
156954
168740
168947
170680
175445
183324
184779
192640
193256
193281
198160
204041
210111
216847
221756
2.12(9)
+0.15
1.70(12) +0.22
+0.02
1.61(5)
2.02(4)
+0.03
+0.31
2.21(4)
2.14(6)
+0.38
2.30(11) −0.09
1.74(4)
+0.10
1.76(2)
+0.21
2.08(10) +0.00
1.96(6)
+0.19
1.69(10) +0.16
2.00(3)
+0.00
1.85(5)
+0.15
1.85(11) −0.01
1.90(11) +0.06
1.98(12) +0.05
1.95(5)
+0.03
2.20(3)
+0.28
2.38(16) +0.03
2.10(10) +0.16
2.08(12) −0.03
1.75(6)
−0.06
2.26(11) −0.06
2.05(8)
+0.15
1.85(15) +0.30
1.62(4)
+0.14
1.87(12) +0.09
1.84(4)
+0.08
2.02(10) +0.14
1.88(20) +0.05
2.42(3)
−0.02
2.30(12) −0.06
1.83(11) +0.16
2.04(7)
+0.12
1.70(10) +0.19
+0.02
2.28(4)
1.67(2)
+0.15
2.25(11) +0.31
1.97(12) +0.23
2.15(12) +0.21
1.84(10) +0.30
1.56(8)
+0.14
1.88(2)
+0.10
2.09(12) +0.13
2.50(10) −0.08
2.25(12) −0.03
2.09(17) +0.07
2.08(12) +0.08
1.90(2)
+0.10
2.18(12) +0.09
2.50(12) +0.08
2.02(18) −0.06
1.93(7)
+0.06
1.90(5)
+0.11
2.21(10) +0.17
2.20(8)
+0.06
8.88
9.02
9.02
8.91
9.01
9.00
8.00
9.13
8.69
8.51
8.81
9.12
8.52
9.03
9.10
9.05
9.03
9.04
8.90
8.79
8.86
8.92
8.85
8.85
8.96
9.10
8.93
8.98
8.94
8.00
9.09
8.79
8.81
9.05
8.61
9.03
8.60
9.02
8.99
9.04
8.84
9.08
8.92
8.97
8.94
8.48
8.78
8.50
8.97
8.90
8.89
8.75
8.92
8.90
8.98
8.90
8.78
8.84
8.70
8.88
8.88
8.90
8.93
7.00
9.09
8.52
7.60
8.69
9.00
8.20
9.01
9.03
8.99
8.96
9.01
8.80
8.74
8.83
8.87
8.42
8.79
8.92
9.00
8.60
8.90
8.90
7.00
8.99
8.77
8.75
9.01
8.00
8.99
8.48
8.83
8.90
8.98
8.81
9.03
7.00
8.94
8.88
8.30
8.73
7.00
8.91
8.85
8.83
8.70
8.86
8.82
8.95
8.87
8.73
8.91
9.05
9.11
8.93
9.05
9.10
8.50
9.17
8.80
8.71
8.86
9.20
8.70
9.05
9.17
9.11
9.10
9.10
9.00
8.90
8.89
8.92
8.99
9.00
9.10
9.20
9.06
9.02
8.97
8.66
9.18
8.90
8.90
9.06
8.75
9.10
8.68
9.10
9.06
9.10
8.86
9.13
9.01
8.99
9.01
8.57
8.82
8.73
9.03
8.91
9.00
8.81
8.95
8.92
9.02
9.00
8.82
0.86(5)
0.69(13)
0.70(8)
0.83(3)
1.03(8)
1.01(9)
0.35(23)
0.88(4)
0.54(7)
0.47(23)
0.70(6)
0.83(10)
0.51(13)
0.85(3)
0.92(9)
0.90(8)
0.93(9)
0.93(5)
0.93(9)
0.93(11)
0.83(5)
0.86(6)
0.60(16)
0.94(11)
0.94(10)
0.92(12)
0.61(13)
0.81(7)
0.76(3)
0.33(24)
0.93(14)
0.96(7)
0.90(9)
0.85(6)
0.53(19)
0.77(7)
0.68(7)
0.71(9)
1.05(10)
0.94(8)
0.83(6)
0.89(7)
0.44(29)
0.81(2)
0.91(8)
0.66(10)
0.83(6)
0.45(29)
0.93(8)
0.75(2)
0.92(10)
0.93(7)
0.84(9)
0.76(5)
0.84(4)
0.96(8)
0.80(5)
)
n
u
s
(
L
/
L
g
o
l
2.0
1.9
1.8
1.7
1.6
1.5
1.4
1.3
1.2
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
Bootis
normal stars
l
7.4
7.8
8.4
8.6
8.8
9.0
9.2
4.00 3.98 3.96 3.94 3.92 3.90 3.88 3.86 3.84 3.82 3.80
log Teff
Figure 1. The sample of λ Bootis (filled circles) and normal-type
(open circles) stars within a log L∗/L⊙ versus log Teff diagram.
The isochrones (the different log t values are listed in the legend)
were taken from Claret (1995).
Table 3. Normal-type stars selected as comparison.
HD
HIP
HD
HIP
HD
HIP
2262
3003
5382
9919
11636
13041
16555
17943
19107
39060
40136
45320
49434
50241
50277
50506
56405
59037
70574
2072
2578
4366
7535
8903
9977
12225
13421
14293
27321
28103
30666
32617
32607
33024
31897
35180
36393
41036
71297
79439
85364
87696
88824
96113
98058
98353
101107
102124
105211
111968
116706
118232
122405
135379
135559
145631
159561
41375
45493
48341
49593
50070
54137
55084
55266
56770
57328
59072
62896
65466
66234
68478
74824
74689
79439
86032
160613
170642
175638
181296
186689
187642
192425
195050
196078
201184
205835
205852
205924
207235
207958
210300
210739
211356
220061
86565
90887
92946
95261
97229
97649
99742
100907
101608
104365
106711
106787
106856
107596
108036
109412
109667
109984
115250
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
5
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
-0.05
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.15
(B - V)0
Bootis
l
normal stars
7.0
7.2
7.4
7.6
7.8
8.0
8.2
log age
8.4
8.6
8.8
9.0
9.2
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
0
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
0.6
trel
36
34
32
30
28
26
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
10000
9500
9000
8500
8000
7500
7000
6500
Teff
Figure 2. Histogram of the calibrated ages (upper panel) and
relative ages for both samples (lower panel).
Figure 4. Histogram of (B − V )0 values (upper panel) and the
calibrated effective temperature (lower panel) for the sample of
λ Bootis stars.
log g = +0.10(11)
4.50
4.35
4.20
4.05
3.90
3.75
3.60
3.45
3.30
3.15
)
t
o
h
p
(
g
g
o
l
3.15 3.30 3.45 3.60 3.75 3.90
log g (evol)
4.05 4.20 4.35 4.50
Figure 3. Surface gravities calibrated photometrically and cal-
culated via the mass, luminosity and effective temperature; the
mean difference ∆log g = +0.10(11) is not significant.
3 A TEST SAMPLE OF NORMAL STARS
results
obtained for
comparison with the
For
the
λ Bootis stars we generated a test sample of apparently nor-
mal dwarfs with the same effective temperatures. We limited
the sample to luminosity class V objects for which photo-
metric and Hipparcos measurements are available. Known
spectroscopic binary systems were excluded. Then, only ob-
jects for which the spectral classifications published by Gray
& Garrison (1987; 1989a,b) and Garrison & Gray (1994)
agree within two temperature sub-classes with those by Abt
& Morell (1995) have been considered. The final sample (see
Table 3) has the same number of stars as the λ Bootis list.
Special attention has been paid to the (B − V )0 distribu-
tion of the test sample to ensure that it similar to that
of the λ Bootis objects (Fig. 4, upper panel). Thus, the
test sample represents luminosity class V stars in the so-
lar neighbourhood, covering the same spectral range as the
λ Bootis group.
All basic parameters were derived in exactly the same
way as for the λ Bootis objects. All statistical significance
levels presented in the following sections are based on several
hypothesis tests (e.g. t-test; Rees 1987).
We have not explicitly listed the parameters of this sam-
ple but it is available in electronic form via anonymous ftp
130.79.128.5 or http://cdsweb.u-strasbg.fr/Abstract.html.
D
6
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
4 THE HERTZSPRUNG -- RUSSELL DIAGRAM
BASED ON HIPPARCOS AND
PHOTOMETRIC DATA
Earlier investigations already concluded that the group of
λ Bootis stars comprises the whole area between the ZAMS
and TAMS. Only the interpretation of the evolutionary stage
(PMS or post-MS) varied. In this work we have not inves-
tigated a possible PMS hypothesis as proposed by Paun-
zen (1997). Beside the arguments given in Bohlender et
al. (1999) and Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) we would like
to add a few more points. If we speculate that some of these
stars are in a PMS phase then they would have ages of one
Myr or even younger since they are in the 'right upper cor-
ner' of the Hertzsprung -- Russell diagram (HRD hereafter)
very close to the birth-line according to the models of Palla
& Stahler (1993). So they should be very bright in the IR
region and lie within the boundaries of star-forming regions
or molecular clouds; neither implication has been verified so
far (King 1994).
Figure 1 shows the HRD with the data taken from Ta-
ble 1. The post-MS evolutionary isochrones are from Claret
(1995). It is encouraging to see that no object lies below
the ZAMS; that gives further confidence in the calibrations
used.
To estimate the most probable age distribution of our
program stars, we have used a moving average (Fig. 2). Such
a method takes into account the errors of individual data as
it counts all points (plus and minus the standard deviation)
which lie in a certain bin (Rees 1987). From the histogram
it is clear that the group of λ Bootis stars comprises evo-
lutionary stages of the entire MS with a peak at trel ≈ 0.85
(about 1 Gyr). Taking the few candidates in the Orion OB1
association and NGC 2264, the percentage for very young
objects (log t < 7.0) would be approximately 5% which fits
very well into the overall picture.
Since the distribution of the test sample (Fig. 2) agrees
at a 99.9% significance level, the age distribution of the
λ Bootis objects is not distinct from that of other luminos-
ity class V objects in the same spectral domain within the
solar neighbourhood. That is already a first hint that the
mechanism behind the λ Bootis phenomenon operates only
within very tight constraints, since only 2% of all stars are
objects of the λ Bootis type.
Gray & Corbally (1998, 1999) made an extensive survey
for λ Bootis stars in 24 open clusters and associations and
found not a single candidate. The cluster ages range from 15
to 700 Myr. Therefore, only a few candidates in the Orion
OB1 association and NGC 2264 remain. It seems that the
star-formation process within open clusters does not favour
the manifestation of the λ Bootis phenomenon.
Table 4 lists the 16 stars that we have in common
with the papers of Iliev & Barzova (1995) and Paunzen
(1997). For the calibration of effective temperatures they
both used the method of Moon & Dworetsky (1985) within
the Stromgren uvbyβ photometric system; Iliev & Barzova
(1995) also derived the luminosities with this calibration
whereas Paunzen (1997) took advantage of the Hipparcos
data. For the calibration of mass and age, Iliev & Barzova
(1995) interpolated between the evolutionary tracks given
by Schaller et al. (1992), whereas Paunzen (1997) used the
CESAM models by Morel (1997). As expected, there are
star-to-star variations, but overall the parameters fit well.
The effective temperatures from this work are in very good
agreement with those of both references. The luminosities
and thus the calibrated ages are in better agreement with
those of Iliev & Barzova (1995).
As a further test of the calibrated values, we have cal-
culated the surface gravity via the effective temperature,
mass and luminosity. Figure 3 shows the correlation of
the photometrically calibrated surface gravity log g(phot)
and the calculated one log g(evol). The mean errors for
both parameters are typically ±0.1 dex. Although there is
some indication of a systematic offset, the mean difference
∆log g = log g(evol) − log g(phot) = +0.10(11) is not signifi-
cant. A similar effect was already noticed by Iliev & Barzova
(1995) whereas Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) reported an
inconsistency between the position in the HRD and the log g
values derived from Stromgren uvbyβ photometry using the
calibration of Moon & Dworetsky (1985). We conclude that
the photometric calibrations for the group of λ Bootis stars
are valid, in contradiction to the results of Faraggiana &
Bonifacio (1999).
Before making a detailed statistical analysis, we looked
to see whether our sample exhibits an apparent bias. Fig-
ure 4 shows that the sample includes significantly more
cooler objects (70%) with effective temperatures lower
than 8000 K. However, there is no observational bias from
classification-resolution spectroscopy since the spectroscopic
survey for new members included many more hotter- than
cooler-type objects (Gray & Corbally 1999, Paunzen 2001).
That fact could be interpreted as a manifestation of the
working mechanism itself, or it could be due to the method
used in this very limited spectral range. It is well known that
at cooler temperatures (spectral domain A5 to F2), even a
moderate metal-weakness can be detected at classification
resolution since the overall metallic-line spectrum is much
richer than for an A0-type object. However, we are not able
to decide whether the distribution of the λ Bootis sample is
due to a bias within the observational technique or due to
the phenomenon itself.
Figure 5 shows the averaged effective temperatures,
masses and projected rotational velocities for each age bin.
The mean effective temperature is rather constant up to
trel ≈ 0.5 with values between 8300 K to 8800 K. It then de-
creases linearly almost to 7000 K for the most evolved ob-
jects. The mean masses are constant within the error bars
at about 1.9 M⊙ for trel < 0.75 and then increase to almost
2.2 M⊙. Most interesting is the non-existence of a correla-
tion of the projected rotational velocity with age. The mean
value for the whole range is about 120 km s−1. If we compare
these results with those of our test sample, we find several
differences as well as similarities:
• The trends for the effective temperature and mass are
identical. However, the λ Bootis objects seem to have lower
temperatures as well as masses for trel > 0.8
• The v sin i distributions are
with a slightly higher
(σLB = 19 km s−1 and σNor = 15 km s−1)
scatter
identical within 1σ
the λ Bootis group
for
Overall, there is no obvious distinction between the two sam-
ples.
Gray (1988) reported that several λ Bootis stars exhibit
peculiar hydrogen-line profiles with weak cores and broad
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
7
Table 4. Comparison of the calibrated stellar parameters from this work (columns TW), Iliev & Barzova (1995; columns IL95) and
Paunzen (1997; columns PA97).
HD
319
11413
30422
31295
107233
110411
125162
142703
183324
192640
193256
193281
198160
204041
210111
221756
TW
3.904(7)
3.899(4)
3.896(6)
3.950(9)
3.861(9)
3.951(10)
3.935(5)
3.868(9)
3.950(5)
3.903(2)
3.894(9)
3.907(8)
3.907(13)
3.906(6)
3.888(3)
3.931(9)
log Teff
IL95
±0.02
PA97
±0.02
TW
log L∗ /L⊙
IL95
±0.01
PA97
TW
M
IL95
±0.2
PA97
±0.1
3.92
3.91
3.91
3.96
3.86
3.96
3.95
3.87
3.97
3.91
3.92
3.92
3.90
3.91
3.89
3.96
3.91
3.91
3.90
3.95
3.87
3.94
3.94
3.86
3.96
3.90
3.90
3.91
3.90
3.91
3.88
3.96
1.45(8)
1.35(4)
1.01(1)
1.32(9)
0.88(5)
1.22(11)
1.28(9)
0.97(5)
1.32(17)
1.22(1)
1.51(12)
1.79(12)
1.36(16)
1.25(7)
1.23(6)
1.50(6)
1.53
1.41
1.03
1.40
0.94
1.30
1.38
1.00
1.51
1.23
1.48
1.81
1.24
1.21
1.30
1.67
1.34(5)
1.28(4)
0.96(3)
1.20(3)
0.80(5)
1.09(3)
1.20(1)
0.93(3)
1.20(4)
1.16(2)
1.50(27)
1.96(27)
1.37(7)
1.20(7)
1.16(5)
1.41(4)
2.12(9)
2.02(4)
1.76(2)
2.08(10)
1.62(4)
2.02(10)
2.04(7)
1.67(2)
2.09(17)
1.90(2)
2.18(12)
2.50(12)
2.02(18)
1.93(7)
1.90(5)
2.20(8)
2.2
2.1
1.8
2.2
1.6
2.1
2.1
1.7
2.3
1.9
2.1
2.5
1.9
1.9
2.0
2.4
2.0
1.9
1.8
2.0
1.6
1.9
2.0
1.7
2.1
1.9
2.2
2.5
2.0
1.9
1.8
2.2
TW
8.88
8.91
8.69
8.51
8.93
8.00
8.61
9.02
8.50
8.90
8.89
8.75
8.92
8.90
8.98
8.78
log t
IL95
±0.05
PA97
±0.05
trel
TW
IL95
8.81
8.87
8.58
8.54
9.04
8.30
8.58
9.02
8.52
8.85
8.86
8.72
8.86
8.81
8.94
8.65
8.76
8.82
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.20
8.50
7.00
8.65
8.79
8.84
8.77
8.57
8.84
8.10
0.86(5)
0.83(3)
0.54(7)
0.47(23)
0.61(13)
0.33(24)
0.53(19)
0.71(9)
0.45(29)
0.75(2)
0.92(10)
0.93(7)
0.84(9)
0.76(5)
0.84(4)
0.80(5)
0.77
0.71
0.23
0.38
0.52
0.19
0.40
0.56
0.42
0.54
0.78
0.91
0.58
0.48
0.69
0.68
but often shallow wings. Iliev & Barzova (1993) examined
the peculiar profiles of four objects. They were able to fit
those profiles with two models having different tempera-
tures (hotter for the wings by approximately 400 K) and
concluded that it is a sign of circumstellar material around
the objects. Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) interpret the pe-
culiar profiles as an indication of undetected spectroscopic-
binary systems in which two stars with solar abundances
but different stellar parameters mimic one apparently metal-
weak object. The classification of the hydrogen-line profiles
for 19 stars were taken from Gray & Corbally (1993) and
Paunzen & Gray (1997). For our sample we find only two
objects (HD 30422 and HD 107233) with peculiar profiles
among the younger objects (trel < 0.66) but seven with nor-
mal ones. The picture for the older objects is just the oppo-
site: there are only two objects (HD 90821 and HD 120500)
with normal profiles but nine with peculiar ones.
Several attempts were made to detect signs of circum-
stellar lines in the optical domain (Andrillat, Jaschek &
Jaschek 1995; Hauck, Ballereau & Chauville 1995, 1998; Hol-
weger, Hempel & Kamp 1999). From our list, sixteen objects
were investigated but only three objects have positive detec-
tions: HD 11413, HD 193256 and HD 198160 (Holweger et
al. 1999). These stars are rather evolved (trel = 0.83, 0.92 and
0.84, respectively) but owing to the poor number statistics,
any conclusion about the significance has to be treated with
caution.
9750
9500
9250
9000
8750
8500
8250
8000
7750
7500
7250
7000
2.7
2.6
2.5
2.4
2.3
2.2
2.1
2.0
1.9
1.8
280
260
240
220
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
]
K
[
f
f
e
T
]
)
n
u
s
(
M
[
M
]
1
-
s
m
k
[
i
n
i
s
v
normal stars
l
Bootis
5 THE ABUNDANCE PATTERN OF λ BO OTIS
STARS
Since the first detailed abundance analysis in the late eight-
ies, there has been a question as to whether a unique abun-
dance pattern exists for the λ Bootis group. Most of the
proposed candidates for membership have been found by
classification-resolution spectroscopy (typically 40 A mm−1
to 120 A mm−1). In the classical photographic domain (3800
to 4600 A) spectral lines of Ca, Mg, Fe and Ti are the main
contributors to the overall appearance of the metallic-line
spectrum. Gray (1988) defined the membership of the class
in terms of a weak Ca K and metallic-line spectrum com-
pared to the temperature classification of the hydrogen lines.
Paunzen et al. (1999a) and Kamp et al. (2001) already
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
trel
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
Figure 5. Correlation found for the effective temperature (lower
panel) and mass (middle panel) with the relative age; no corre-
lation is detected with the projected rotational velocity (upper
panel). The λ Bootis (filled circles) and normal-type (open cir-
cles) stars are binned with respect to their relative age.
investigated the behaviour of the lights elements C, N, O
and S for a statistically significant number of members:
• The star-to-star scatter for the abundances of C, N, O
and S is much smaller than that for heavier elements
• The abundances of C, N, O and S are not strictly solar
but range from −0.8 dex to +0.2 dex compared to the Sun
• Fe-peak elements are always more underabundant
8
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
Table 5. Abundances from the literature for our program stars. Different values for a single element were added and a mean was
calculated. All values are given with respect to the Sun as: [X] = log X -- log X⊙. In parentheses are the estimated errors of the means or
the individual error taken from the relevant reference.
HD
C
N
O
Na
Mg
Al
Si
S
Ca
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
−0.10(30) +0.50(30) −0.90(10) −1.10(30)
−0.68(20)
+0.22(10) +1.00(10) −0.73 (5) −0.58(20) −0.45(10)
319 −0.16(15)
−0.20(20)
−0.10(10)
−0.74(30)
−1.18(20)
11413 −0.15(15)
−0.90(30) +0.00(30) −1.00(30)
−0.30(30) +0.00(30) −1.50(30)
15165 +0.00(30)
−0.95(20) −0.16(20) −0.90(20)
31295 −0.17(15) −0.24(15) −0.29(15) −0.52(20) −1.15(20)
74873 +0.60(10)
−1.00(30)
75654 −0.44(10) +0.00(15) +0.14(10)
−0.10(15) −0.84(15)
−0.52(18)
−0.75(20) −0.50(10) −0.58(20)
84123 −0.01(24) +0.00(30) −0.30(20) −0.55(40) −0.76(20)
91130 +0.20(30) +0.30(15) +0.11(30)
−0.63 (6)
−0.45 (7) +0.18(15) −3.00(15)
−0.60(10)
−0.30(20) −0.90(30) −0.50(30)
101108 +0.10(10)
−1.59(10)
−1.40(30) −2.10(30) −1.70(30)
106223 +0.30(10)
−1.40(10)
−0.80(20) −2.20(30)
107233 −0.30(30)
−0.50(10)
−0.84(20)
110411 +0.10(20) +0.30(30)
+0.47(15) −0.98 (5)
111604 −0.25 (5)
120500 +0.20(20) +0.00(15) −0.09(15) +0.32(30) −0.23 (7)
125162 −0.34(20) −0.12(15) −0.22(20) −1.30(15) −2.00(20)
−1.20(20)
142703 −0.28(20) −0.50(15) −0.19(10)
−0.90(10)
168740 −0.42(10)
−0.03(10)
170680 −0.06(10) −0.07(10)
−0.20(20)
183324 +0.11(20) −0.03(30) −0.10(30) +0.10(30) −1.73(20) −1.50(30) −1.10(20) −0.13(15) −1.32(30)
−1.00(30) −0.31(15) −1.35(20)
192640 −0.19(20) −0.22(15) −0.32(30) −1.10(20) −1.62(20)
193256 −0.45(20)
−0.23(10) +0.90(30) −0.15(20)
+0.00(30)
−0.51(30)
+0.14(15) −0.68(20)
193281 −0.49(20) +0.30(15) −0.05(10) +1.00(20) −0.08(10)
198160 −0.18(30)
−0.18(10) +0.30(20) −0.13(10)
−0.67(30)
204041 −0.58(20) −0.05(15) −0.42(20) +0.36(20) −1.04(20) −0.93(20) −0.63(20) +0.07(20) −0.98(20)
210111 −0.23(10)
−0.96(20)
−1.00(20) +0.06(15) −0.49(20)
221756 +0.00(20) +0.20(15) +0.17(20) +1.17(20) −0.70(20)
−0.30(30)
−0.85(30)
−0.95 (5) −0.13(15) −0.30(15)
−1.00(20) −0.45(15) −1.98(15)
−0.53(15) −1.20(10)
−0.60(20)
−0.20(10) +0.60(10) −1.00(12) −0.52(20) −0.65(10)
−0.20(20)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Sc
Ti
Mn
Cr
Fe
Ni
Sr
Y
Ba
319 −1.10(20) −0.75(20)
11413 −1.10(30) −1.40(20)
15165 −1.40(30) −0.50(30)
31295 −0.90(30) −0.96(20)
74873 −0.40(30) −0.90(10)
75654
84123 −0.90(31) −0.86(10) −0.84(20) −0.85(30) −0.72(20) −0.74(30) −0.50(30) −0.55(13) −0.60(20)
91130
−0.35(30)
−0.40(20) −0.64(20)
−1.20(20) −1.43(20)
−1.50(20)
−0.90(30) −1.60(30) −1.00(30) −0.80(30)
−0.75(20) −1.07(20) −0.50(20) −1.51(20)
−0.30(20) −0.70(10) −0.20(30) −0.90(40)
−1.01(29) −1.00(42) −1.10(30) −1.08(14)
−0.48 (3) −1.16 (8)
−0.25(20)
−0.90(20)
−0.64 (8)
−0.45(20)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
−1.30(30) −0.90(30)
−1.10(20)
101108 −0.60(40) −0.20(20) −0.40(20) −0.60(10) −0.70(10) −0.30(10) −0.70(40) +0.00(40) −0.70(30)
106223 −1.10(30) −1.02(10) −1.70(10) −1.34(20) −1.60(10) −0.97(20) −1.70(30) −0.50(30) −1.60(20)
107233 −1.70(30) −1.34(30) −1.30(20) −1.28(30) −1.38(21)
110411 −1.10(30) −0.90(10)
−1.07(20)
−1.07(30) −1.08 (4)
111604
120500
−0.67 (6)
125162 −0.70(20) −2.01(20)
142703 −1.50(30) −1.27(10)
168740 −1.10(30) −0.88(10)
170680
−0.40(10)
183324 −1.46(40) −1.42(20)
−2.00(30)
192640 −1.15(20) −1.33(20) −2.00(20) −1.65(20) −1.63(20) −0.60(20) −1.49(30)
−0.50(30)
193256 −0.90(40) −0.30(30)
−0.10(20)
−0.36(20)
193281
198160
−0.50(20)
−1.30(30)
204041 −1.03(40) −1.21(20)
210111 −1.30(20) −1.05(20)
221756 −0.60(20) −0.50(20)
−1.00(20) −1.98(20) −1.20(20) −2.10(15)
−1.40(10) −1.32(12) −0.90(20) −1.20(30)
−1.10(10) −0.88(10)
−1.00(30)
−0.40(30) −0.50(10)
−1.38(20) −1.50(30)
−1.00(30) −0.90(30)
−0.20(20) −0.93(20)
−0.90(20) −0.78(30)
−0.72(30) −0.87(20) −0.40(20)
−1.18(20) −0.89(20)
−0.50(20) −0.59(30)
−0.67(20)
−1.03(20)
−0.88(50)
−0.54(20)
−0.98(30)
−0.09(20)
−0.20(20)
−0.15(30)
−0.90(20)
−1.50(30)
−0.50(30)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
+0.45(20)
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Heiter (2002) and Heiter et al. (2002) tried to shed more
light on the abundance pattern in the context of the theo-
ries proposed. They used mean values for a sample of 34
stars (not all elements' abundances were determined for all
objects) and concluded:
• The iron-peak elements from Sc to Fe as well as Mg, Si,
Ca, Sr and Ba are underabundant by 1 dex compared to the
Sun
• Al is slightly more depleted whereas Ni, Y and Zr are
slightly less depleted
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
9
Table 6. Kinematic data from the Hipparcos database for the program stars. In parentheses are the errors in the final digits of the
corresponding quantity.
HD
π
[mas]
319
6870
7908
11413
15165
30422
31295
35242
74873
75654
84123
87271
91130
105058
106223
110377
110411
111005
111604
120500
120896
125162
130767
142703
153747
154153
168740
170680
183324
192640
193281
198160
204041
210111
216847
221756
12.45(0.74)
10.30(0.61)
11.41(0.98)
13.37(0.64)
8.51(0.89)
17.40(0.68)
27.04(0.94)
13.32(0.98)
16.38(1.16)
12.82(0.58)
9.09(0.90)
6.80(0.88)
13.33(0.76)
5.32(1.04)
9.10(0.86)
14.60(0.80)
27.10(0.82)
5.75(1.01)
8.43(0.73)
6.97(0.90)
4.87(1.15)
33.58(0.61)
7.82(0.78)
18.89(0.78)
5.32(0.98)
15.16(1.11)
14.03(0.69)
15.30(0.81)
16.95(0.87)
24.37(0.55)
4.58(1.59)
13.67(1.16)
11.46(0.99)
12.70(0.89)
6.76(0.67)
13.97(0.63)
d
[pc]
80(5)
97(6)
88(8)
75(4)
118(12)
57(2)
37(1)
75(6)
61(4)
78(4)
110(11)
147(19)
75(4)
188(37)
110(10)
68(4)
37(1)
174(31)
119(10)
143(19)
205(48)
30(1)
128(13)
53(2)
188(35)
66(5)
71(4)
65(3)
59(3)
41(1)
218(76)
73(6)
87(8)
79(6)
148(15)
72(3)
µα
[mas yr−1]
µδ
[mas yr−1]
+70.01(0.94)
+120.99(0.51)
−5.54(1.04)
−47.97(0.51)
+35.50(1.10)
−4.04(0.48)
−34.71(0.41)
−12.65(0.59)
−37.51(0.50)
−4.30(0.57)
−11.70(0.74)
+18.19(0.60)
+40.08(1.04) −128.37(0.65)
+16.63(0.63)
−30.42(0.99)
−51.06(0.70)
−65.20(1.25)
+41.13(0.49)
−63.91(0.42)
−86.15(0.43)
−20.74(1.11)
+3.33(0.86)
+5.01(0.49)
+6.89(0.42)
+17.10(0.60)
−9.80(0.84)
+0.66(0.81)
+19.29(0.55)
−67.32(1.04)
−106.08(0.78)
+0.71(0.48)
−89.51(0.48)
+82.62(0.80)
−43.12(0.86)
−6.92(0.58)
+21.83(0.56)
−88.59(0.67)
+10.97(0.68)
−26.63(0.70)
−18.65(1.14)
+3.00(0.78)
−187.42(0.52) +159.01(0.43)
−46.63(0.69)
−6.87(0.62)
+71.62(0.83) −305.20(0.67)
+14.08(0.68)
+25.04(0.61)
+0.57(0.59) −101.87(0.49)
−6.98(0.84)
−21.43(0.64)
−33.35(0.43)
−0.51(0.72)
+68.67(0.45)
+69.22(0.46)
−4.32(1.54)
−0.75(1.07)
−49.38(0.92)
+83.04(0.86)
+50.00(1.18)
+13.84(0.77)
+24.90(0.48)
+13.66(0.86)
+12.33(0.40)
+16.85(0.43)
−17.71(0.45)
−45.77(0.42)
+6.55(0.99)
+11.40(0.90)
RV
[km s−1]
−10.7(9.9)
+12.4(3.0)
+13.2(3.0)
+7.2(5.6)
+33.5(2.1)
+16.5(3.5)
+12.9(1.7)
+9.0(3.0)
+23.3(3.0)
+9.4(1.1)
+16.3(3.0)
+0.1(3.0)
−14.5(3.0)
−7.2(3.0)
−15.4(3.7)
+3.0(8.5)
−12.7(11.5)
+0.6(3.0)
−17.1(4.7)
+7.1(3.3)
−24.4(3.0)
−0.3(4.0)
−14.0(3.0)
+15.9(5.4)
−6.3(0.5)
−32.6(3.0)
−21.1(3.0)
−34.6(3.5)
+12.0(3.0)
−18.1(1.1)
+2.0(2.7)
−16.0(3.0)
−15.1(26.7)
−4.4(1.1)
−3.0(1.4)
+13.4(0.5)
U
[km s−1]
V
[km s−1]
−18.1(1.8)
−39.2(2.6)
+9.2(1.0)
+14.3(0.8)
−32.4(1.8)
−12.4(1.8)
−6.0(1.6)
−9.7(2.7)
−23.0(2.4)
−28.0(0.8)
−16.0(2.3)
+0.4(1.5)
+11.6(1.5)
−5.5(1.9)
−32.8(2.9)
−29.0(1.9)
+18.7(1.5)
−27.1(5.3)
−46.7(3.7)
−15.0(2.4)
−25.0(3.7)
−34.6(0.5)
−20.5(2.0)
+23.5(4.8)
−3.2(1.1)
−28.6(2.9)
−36.3(2.6)
−31.8(3.4)
+14.1(2.3)
−22.7(0.4)
+4.2(2.5)
−34.9(2.4)
−25.1(13.3)
−8.5(0.7)
−12.6(1.2)
+7.7(0.5)
−25.5(1.8)
−41.7(2.8)
−11.3(1.1)
+6.5(2.4)
−8.6(1.4)
−6.4(2.1)
−23.9(0.7)
+8.0(1.1)
−22.9(1.4)
−5.3(1.2)
−45.5(4.4)
+3.3(1.5)
+5.6(0.4)
−5.3(1.3)
−7.3(1.9)
−18.7(2.5)
− 1.6(3.1)
−23.6(3.1)
−19.4(2.4)
−6.4(1.9)
−5.5(3.0)
−5.1(1.7)
−24.4(2.1)
+4.0(0.7)
+14.6(1.8)
+17.5(1.0)
−17.5(1.9)
−15.2(0.9)
+0.7(1.9)
−12.4(1.1)
−1.0(1.3)
−8.6(2.3)
−6.7(17.9)
+7.7(0.7)
+5.3(0.7)
+10.9(0.6)
W
[km s−1]
+4.9(9.7)
−0.3(2.3)
−14.5(3.0)
−9.8(5.1)
−20.8(2.1)
−10.2(2.2)
−10.8(0.8)
−8.7(1.2)
−7.9(2.1)
−8.2(0.9)
+8.4(2.3)
+2.5(2.3)
−9.4(2.6)
−8.3(2.8)
−20.9(3.7)
+1.6(8.1)
−16.2(11.0)
−2.6(3.5)
−19.3(4.8)
+13.0(2.9)
−16.7(2.6)
−2.6(3.6)
−0.7(3.0)
−9.2(2.6)
+2.8(1.9)
+3.0(0.5)
−2.8(1.2)
+1.3(0.4)
−5.7(0.5)
−4.2(0.3)
+2.5(2.3)
−9.3(2.5)
−3.4(14.8)
+0.7(0.9)
−6.1(1.5)
−16.7(0.6)
• The mean abundance of Na is solar, but the star-to-star
scatter is about ±1 dex
• The star-to-star scatter is twice as large as for a com-
parable sample of normal stars
Otherwise they find no, or only a poor, correlation of individ-
ual abundances with astrophysical parameters such as the
effective temperature, surface gravity, projected rotational
velocity, age and pulsational period.
We have used the individual abundances published by
Venn & Lambert (1990), Sturenburg (1993), Holweger &
Rentzsch-Holm (1995), Chernyshova et al. (1998), Heiter
et al. (1998), Paunzen et al. (1999a,b), Kamp et al. (2001),
Solano et al. (2001), Heiter (2002) and Andrievsky et
al. (2002) for members of the λ Bootis group. The individ-
ual values were weighted according to the errors listed in
the references. For our further analysis we have used only
objects for which an abundance of carbon or oxygen is avail-
able, since those are key elements for the definition of the
λ Bootis group.
Values for stars of superficially normal type were taken
from Adelman (1991, 1994, 1996), Adelman et al. (1991,
1997), Hill & Landstreet (1993), Hill (1995), Caliskan &
Adelman (1997) and Varenne & Monier (1999).
Let us recall that the membership of an object in the
λ Bootis group is mainly based on spectroscopy at classifi-
cation resolution. The only other approach is the definition
of membership criteria in the UV region (Solano & Paun-
zen 1999). No reference in the literature was found which
describes membership criteria based on detailed abundance
analysis in the optical region. If we compare the status of
other chemically peculiar stars of the upper main sequence
then a similar situation is evident (Wolff 1983; Cowley 1995).
Objects have been classified as being chemically peculiar but
their individual elemental abundances differ widely. No at-
tempt has so far been made to define the membership of
the classical CP stars to a sub-class by detailed abundances
alone (Preston 1974).
The λ Bootis group is unusual in this respect since it
shows strong underabundances, not found for any other
group, of most heavier elements. The only exceptions
are intermediate and true Population II-type objects and
10
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
]
e
F
/
C
[
]
a
C
/
C
[
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
-1.5
-1.0
-0.5
0.5
1.0
1.5
0.0
[Na]
]
a
N
/
C
[
-2.5
-2.0
-1.5
-1.0
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
[Fe]
]
g
M
C
/
[
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-4.0 -3.5 -3.0 -2.5 -2.0 -1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0
[Ca]
-2.5
-2.0
-1.5
-0.5
0.0
0.5
-1.0
[Mg]
Figure 6. Abundance ratios for the λ Bootis stars (filled circles); open circles denote normal-type stars from the literature.
field blue stragglers, post-AGB and F-weak stars (Gray
1988, 1989; Jaschek, Andrillat & Jaschek 1989; Andrievsky,
Chernyshova & Ivashchenko 1995; van Winckel, Waelkens
& Waters 1995). Objects with very low surface gravities
(post-AGB and Population II-type objects) are easily distin-
guished even at classification resolution and will not be con-
sidered in the following discussion. For the other groups the
underabundances of the Fe-peak elements are rather mod-
erate. But, more importantly, the abundances of the light
elements C, N, O and S scale just like those of the heavier el-
ements. We have therefore chosen to use [C/Z] versus [Z] dia-
grams ([O/Z], [N/Z] and [S/Z] behave analogously) in order
to investigate the behaviour of the group of λ Bootis stars.
The field blue stragglers, intermediate Population II and F-
weak types of stars all fall in the area around [C/Z] ≈ 0 in
these diagrams.
Figure 6 shows such diagrams for the elements Fe, Na,
Ca and Mg for the stars on our program as well as for those
of superficially normal types. From this Figure we are able
to conclude:
• All program stars are Population I-type objects with
[C/Fe] ≫ 0
• The λ Bootis stars exhibit iron abundances that are sig-
nificantly lower than those found for the superficially normal
stars
• There is a large overlap for all other heavier elements
Cowley et al. (1982) have proposed that λ Bootis -type and
other weak-line stars may arise from small (≈ 0.3 dex) abun-
dance fluctuations in the interstellar medium. That might
be true for a small fraction of the objects, but underabun-
dances up to a factor of 100 can not be explained without
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
11
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
)
s
i
t
o
o
B
(
]
a
N
[
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
log [Na] (ISM, arbitrary units)
Figure 7. Correlation between the sodium abundances for 13
λ Bootis stars and the values, taken from Welsh et al. (1998), for
the surrounding environment. The latter values are scaled in three
steps (a value of three denotes the highest density).
some other mechanism such as diffusion, accretion or mass-
loss.
A very intriguing fact is that eight program stars ex-
hibit magnesium abundances which range from −0.52 to
−0.13 dex, which seems to contradict the classification based
on moderate-resolution spectroscopy. One of the most im-
portant classification criterion is the moderate to extreme
weakness of the Mg II 4481 A line (Gray 1988). What can ac-
tually cause that discrepancy? Slettebak, Kuzma & Collins
(1980) have shown that the equivalent width of the line
decreases with increasing rotation for models later than
A0. The same fact was also described by Abt & Mor-
rell (1995). A much stronger effect was found for Hγ.
That means that a rapidly rotating star will be classi-
fied much later according to Hγ than on the basis of
Mg II 4481 A. Taking a rapidly rotating A5 type star one
would classify it as hF1mA7 or metal-weak. However, the
three objects with the highest magnesium abundances of
our sample are indeed the fastest rotators: HD 193256
(250 kms−1; −0.15 dex), HD 170680 (205 kms−1; −0.20 dex)
and HD 198160 (200 kms−1; −0.13 dex). But there is no
overall correlation for the whole sample,
fast rota-
tors do also exhibit rather strong underabundances (e.g.
HD 111604) and vice versa. Otherwise the fast rotators are
not outstanding in any respect.
i.e.
One observational fact is the wide range of abundances
(−1.3 to +1.2 dex) for sodium (Table 5 and Fig. 6) first
indicated in the work of Sturenburg (1993). In the recent
literature no explanation of the variability has been given.
Sodium is the only element for which such a behaviour has
been detected so far. Furthermore, predictions for that el-
ement have not been discussed so far within any proposed
theory (Turcotte & Charbonneau 1993). In an effort to shed
some light on the subject, we have investigated whether
a correlation can be found between the individual sodium
abundances and the density of sodium in the surrounding
interstellar medium. Welsh, Crifo & Lallement (1998) pub-
lished the local distribution of interstellar Na I within 250 pc
of the Sun. They used all published absorption densities and
the distances derived from the Hipparcos satellite. The den-
sities were scaled in three steps (a value of three denotes
the highest density) and plotted for different Galactic coor-
dinates and distances from the Sun. We have selected mem-
bers of the λ Bootis group whose sodium abundances are
known and for which nearby data points are available in the
maps of Welsh et al. (1998). We have also checked more
recent references such as Sfeir et al. (1999) and Vergely et
al. (2001) which give essentially the same results. In total,
thirteen objects fulfill the requirements: HD 319, HD 31295,
HD 74873, HD 84123, HD 125162, HD 183324, HD 192640,
HD 193256, HD 193281, HD 198160, HD 204041, HD 210111
and HD 221756.
We have to emphasize that not a single sodium abun-
dance for the line of sight to any λ Bootis star has yet been
measured. Bohlender et al. (1999) reported a few detections
of such features, e.g. for HD 319, HD 192640 and HD 221756,
but they did not derive quantitative densities or abundances.
Figure 7 shows the correlation of the individual sodium
abundances with the absorption densities for the local in-
terstellar medium (ISM hereafter). Since there is a linear
correlation visible it suggests that there is an interaction
(e.g. accretion) between the stars and their environments
at some stage of stellar evolution. The correlation does not
reflect any age dependency, since objects are included with
0.33 < trel < 1.01. This rather small sample is reasonably rep-
resentative of the whole sample of program stars in terms
of its distribution in trel and effective temperature. Unfortu-
nately it is not possible to include any data for superficially
normal objects in Fig. 7 since no sodium abundances for
bright field stars are available. The only data are those pub-
lished by Varenne & Monier (1999; Fig. 6) for members of
the Hyades.
From our current analysis two main questions arise for
the λ Bootis phenomenon: How many mechanisms are in-
volved? What are the observational constraints? It is clear
that there is one mechanism which produces the observed
pattern throughout the whole MS lifetime for stars between
late B and early F types. We are not able to decide if it
is 'internal' or 'external' but we have some hints about it.
It is highly improbable that one mechanism works for early
evolutionary stages and an independent second one at very
late stages producing the same absolute abundance pattern.
That seems to be supported by the non-existence of a cor-
relation between the iron abundance and age (Fig. 8). The
abundance of sodium for the stellar atmosphere is corre-
lated with that of the local ISM. There are two possible
explanations for that: 1) the atmospheric abundance resem-
bles the one from the cloud in which the star was born, or
2) it currently interacts with the local ISM. If we believe in
the first interpretation then all other abundances ought also
l
12
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
]
e
F
[
]
e
F
[
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0
-1.2
-1.4
-1.6
-1.8
-2.0
-2.2
-2.4
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0
-1.2
-1.4
-1.6
-1.8
-2.0
-2.2
-2.4
8.0
8.2
8.4
8.6
log age
8.8
9.0
9.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
0.7
trel
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
e
g
a
t
n
e
c
r
e
P
Bootis
l
normal stars
U
V
W
-60
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
Velocity [kms-1]
Figure 8. No correlation is found between iron abundance and
age.
Figure 9. The histograms of the Galactic space-velocity com-
ponents (U, V and W ) for the λ Bootis and normal-type samples.
The distributions agree at significance levels of 72% (U ), 74% (V )
and 97% (W ).
to resemble those in the local ISM. That seems not to be
the case, since many other 'normal' stars located within the
same ISM clouds show no significant elemental underabun-
dances at all. So we are left with the picture of an interaction
between the star and its environment.
6 THE SPACE MOTIONS OF λ BO OTIS STARS
In order to study the kinematics of nearby stars, one needs to
calculate the Galactic space-velocity components (U , V and
W ), given the star's proper motion, parallax (both listed
in the Hipparcos catalogue) and radial velocity. Here, the
formulae and error propagation are taken from the Hippar-
cos documentation as well as from Johnson & Soderblom
(1987).
It was chosen to calculate heliocentric Galactic veloc-
ity components, which can easily be corrected for the solar
motion. A right-handed coordinate system for U , V and W
was used, so they are positive in the directions of the Galac-
tic centre, Galactic rotation and the North Galactic Pole.
The 'standard solar motion' in this system would be (+10.4,
+14.8, +7.3) taken from Mihalas & Routly (1968).
The authors followed the approach of the Hipparcos
consortium who discussed the calculation, transformation
matrix and error propagation. We would like to give only a
short description of the error estimation. The general equa-
tion for the variance of a function of several variables is used
for this purpose. That formula is true only if the covariances
are zero (the errors are uncorrelated). That assumption is
fulfilled since the two proper-motion components are mea-
sured independently. Furthermore it is assumed that only
the radial velocity, proper motions and parallax contribute
to the error distribution. For nearby stars (about 25 pc) an
error of the proper motions of about ±3 mas yr−1 (most of
the Hipparcos measurements are a factor three better than
that) corresponds to an uncertainty in the transverse mo-
tion of only about 0.5 km s−1; it is clear that the errors of
the radial velocities are much more significant.
The radial velocities for our program stars are listed in
Table 6. The following references were used for that Table:
Wilson (1953), Evans (1967), Batten, Fletcher & MacCarthy
(1989), Barbier-Brossat, Petit & Figon (1994), Duflot et
al. (1995), Hauck et al. (1995, 1998), Fehrenbach et al. (1996,
1997), Nordstrom et al. (1997) and Grenier et al. (1999a,b).
The mean and the error of the mean were calculated with-
out weighting the individual measurements. From Table 6
only three stars (HD 319, HD 110411 and HD 204041) show
evidence for variable radial velocities but no prominent pho-
tometric or spectroscopic variability has been detected so
far. Moreover, Table 6 lists the kinematic data for the pro-
gram λ Bootis stars from the Hipparcos database. The in-
vestigated sample is limited in distance (≈ 220 pc) because
of the lack of Hipparcos data and/or radial velocities for
more distant objects. No star exceeds V = 50 km s−1 and
the sample is very homogeneously distributed. A similar
conclusion is given by G´omez et al. (1998a) for classical CP
The status of Galactic field λ Bootis stars in the post-Hipparcos era
13
stars as well as by G´omez et al. (1998b) for a small sample
of λ Bootis stars.
We have compared the velocities of stars in our
λ Bootis sample with the results of Caloi et al. (1999). They
studied the relationship between the kinematics, age and
heavy-element content for the solar neighbourhood, using
the Hipparcos data. For V < −40 km s−1, U > +60 km s−1
and W > +30 km s−1, the minimum stellar age is about
2 Gyr. Only two of the λ Bootis stars would meet the V
criterion, HD 6870 (V = −41.7(2.8) km s−1) and HD 84123
(V = −45.4(4.4) km s−1), but their U and W velocities (like
those of all other stars in the sample) are well below the
limits given. Overall, the velocities are typical of true Pop-
ulation I objects.
The comparison with the sample of normal stars (Fig. 9)
shows very good agreement between the two distributions.
They agree at significance levels of 72% (U ), 74% (V ) and
97% (W ).
Notice that Faraggiana & Bonifacio (1999) made a simi-
lar analysis for a different sample of candidate λ Bootis stars
(see Section 4 therein). They only investigated the parame-
ter (U 2 + W 2)1/2 which is a measure of the kinematic energy
not associated with Galactic rotation. They come to the con-
clusion that all of their program stars are qualified as disk
members. Since they give no individual values for the space
motions and radial velocities, we are not able to compare
our results with theirs.
7 CONCLUSIONS
We have used all currently available photometric data as
well as Hipparcos data to determine astrophysical parame-
ters such as the effective temperatures, surface gravities and
luminosities. As a next step, masses and ages were calibrated
within appropriate post-MS evolutionary models. Further-
more, Galactic space motions were calculated with the help
of radial velocities from the literature. The comparison with
already published results shows good agreement of the de-
rived parameters. All results were compared with those of
a test sample of normal-type objects in the same spectral
range chosen in order to match the (B − V )0 distribution of
the λ Bootis group. From a comprehensive statistical anal-
ysis we conclude:
• The standard photometric calibrations within the John-
son UBV, Stromgren uvbyβ and Geneva 7-colour systems
are valid for this group of chemically peculiar stars.
• The group of λ Bootis stars consists of true Population I
objects which can be found over the whole area of the MS
with a peak at a rather evolved stage (≈ 1 Gyr). That is in
line with the distribution of the test sample.
• The λ Bootis type group is not significantly distinct
from normal stars except, possibly, by having slightly lower
temperatures and masses for trel > 0.8. The v sin i range is
rather narrow throughout the MS with a mean value of
about 120 kms−1.
• There seems to exist a non-uniform distribution of ef-
fective temperatures for group members with a large pro-
portion of objects (more than 70%) cooler than 8000 K.
• It seems that objects with peculiar hydrogen-line pro-
files are preferentially found among later stages of stellar
evolution.
• No correlation of age with elemental abundance or pro-
jected rotational velocity has been detected.
• A comparison of the stellar Na abundances with
nearby IS sight lines hints at an interaction between the
λ Bootis stars and the ISM.
• There is one single mechanism responsible for the ob-
served phenomenon which produces moderate to strong
underabundances working continuously from very early
(10 Myr) to very late evolutionary stages (2.5 Gyr). It pro-
duces the same absolute abundances throughout the MS life-
time for 2% of all luminosity class V objects with effective
temperatures from 10500 K to 6500 K.
• The current list of stars seem to define a very homo-
geneous group, validating the proposed membership criteria
in the optical and UV region.
These rather strict observational results for a significant
number of λ Bootis stars will need to be taken into account
in future work on theories and models trying to explain
the phenomenon. The constraints presented here will help
considerably to reduce the number of free parameters in
the models and finally to provide a critical test for them.
Acknowledgements. This work was partly supported by
the Fonds zur Forderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung,
project P14984 and it is dedicated to G. Derka who died
during its preparation. Use was made of the SIMBAD database,
operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France and the GCPD database,
operated at the Institute of Astronomy of the University of
Lausanne.
REFERENCES
Abt H.A., Morrell N.I., 1995, ApJS, 99, 135
Adelman S.J., 1991, MNRAS, 252, 116
Adelman S.J., 1994, MNRAS, 271, 355
Adelman S.J., 1996, MNRAS, 280, 130
Adelman S.J., Bolcal C., Hill G., Kocer D., 1991, MNRAS, 252,
329
Adelman S.J., Caliskan H., Kocer D., Bolcal C., 1997, MNRAS,
288, 470
Andrievsky S.M., Chernyshova I.V., Ivashchenko O.V., 1995,
A&A, 297, 356
Andrievsky S.M., Chernyshova I.V., Korotin S.A., et al., 2002,
A&A (in preparation)
Andrillat Y., Jaschek C., Jaschek M., 1995, A&A, 299, 493
Arenou F., Grenon M., G´omez A., 1992, A&A 258, 104
Barbier-Brossat M., Petit M., Figon P., 1994, A&AS, 108, 603
Batten A.H., Fletcher J.M., MacCarthy D.G., 1989, Publ. Do-
minion Astrophys. Obs., 17
Bohlender D.A., Gonzalez J.F., Matthews J.M., 1999, A&A, 350,
553
Caliskan H., Adelman S.J., 1997, MNRAS, 288, 501
Caloi V., Cardini D., D'Antona F., Badiali M., Emanuele A.,
Mazzitelli I., 1999, A&A, 351, 925
Cayrel de Strobel G., 1996, A&AR, 7, 243
Chen B., Vergely J.L., Valette B., Carraro G., 1998, A&A, 336,
137
Chernyshova I.V., Andrievsky S.M., Kovtyukh V.V., Mkrtichian
D.E., 1998, Contributions of the Astronomical Observatory
Skalnat´e Pleso, Vol. 27, No. 3, p. 332
Claret A., 1995, A&AS, 109, 441
Cowley C.R., 1995, PASPC, 81, 467
Cowley C.R., Sears R.L., Aikman G.C.L., Sadakane K., 1982,
ApJ, 254, 191
14
E. Paunzen, I.Kh. Iliev, I. Kamp, I.S. Barzova
Drilling J.S., Landolt A.U., 2000, in A.N. Cox, ed, Allen's Astro-
Paunzen E., Andrievsky S.M., Chernyshova I.V., Klochkova V.G.,
physical Quantities, 4th edition, Springer Verlag, p. 388
Panchuk V.E., Handler G., 1999b, A&A, 351, 981
Duflot M., Fehrenbach Ch., Mannone C., Burnage R., Genty V.,
1995, A&AS, 120, 177
Evans D.S., 1967, Catalogue of stellar radial velocities, IAU
Symp. 30, 5
Faraggiana R., Bonifacio P., 1999, A&A, 349, 521
Faraggiana R., Gerbaldi M., 1998, Contributions of the Astro-
nomical Observatory Skalnat´e Pleso, Vol. 27, No. 3, p. 413
Perryman M.A.C., Høg E., Kovalevsky J., Lindegren L., Turon
C., 1997, The Hipparcos and Tycho Catalogues, ESA SP-1200
Preston G.W., 1974, ARA&A, 12, 257
Rees D.G., 1987, Foundations of Statistics, Chapman & Hall, Lon-
don
Sandage A., 1972, ApJ, 178, 1
Schaller G., Schaerer D., Meynet G., Maeder A., 1992, A&AS,
Fehrenbach Ch., Duflot M., Genty V., Amieux G., 1996, Bull.
96, 269
Inform. CDS 48, 11
Sfeir D.M., Lallement R., Crifo F., Welsh B.Y., 1999, A&A, 346,
Fehrenbach Ch., Duflot M., Mannone C., Burnage R., Genty V.,
785
1997, A&AS, 124, 255
Garrison R.F., Gray R.O., 1994, AJ, 107, 1556
G´omez A.E., Luri X, Grenier S., et al., 1998a, A&A, 336, 953
G´omez A.E., Luri X, Sabas V., et al., 1998b, Contributions of the
Astronomical Observatory Skalnat´e Pleso, Vol. 27, No. 3, p.
171
Gray R.O., 1988, AJ, 95, 220
Gray R.O., 1989, AJ, 98, 1049
Gray R.O., Corbally C.J., 1993, AJ, 106, 632
Gray R.O., Corbally C.J., 1998, AJ, 116, 2530
Gray R.O., Corbally C.J., 1999, AAS, 195, 4702
Gray R.O., Garrison R.F., 1987, ApJS, 65, 581
Gray R.O., Garrison R.F., 1989a, ApJS, 69, 301
Gray R.O., Garrison R.F., 1989b, ApJS, 70, 623
Grenier S., Burnage R., Faraggiana R., et al., 1999a, A&AS, 135,
503
Grenier S., Baylac M.O., Rolland L., et al., 1999b, A&AS, 137,
451
Slettebak A., Kuzma T.J., Collins G.W., 1980, ApJ, 242, 171
Solano E., Paunzen E., 1999, A&A, 348, 825
Solano E., Paunzen E., Pintado O.I., Varela J., 2001, A&A, 374,
957
Sturenburg S., 1993, A&A, 277, 139
Turcotte S., Charbonneau P., 1993, ApJ, 486, 536
Uesugi A., Fukuda I., 1982, Revised Catalogue of Stellar Rota-
tional Velocities, Department of Astronomy, Kyoto Univ., Ky-
oto
van Winckel H., Waelkens C., Waters L.B.F.M., 1995, A&A, 297,
25
Varenne O., Monier R., 1999, A&A, 351, 247
Venn K.A., Lambert D.L., 1990, ApJ, 363, 234
Vergely J.-L., Freire Ferrero R., Siebert A., Valette B., 2001,
A&A, 366, 1016
Welsh B.Y., Crifo F., Lallement R., 1998, A&A, 333, 101
Wilson R.F., 1953, General Catalogue of stellar radial velocity,
Carnegie Inst. of Washington, Publ. 601
Hakkila J., Myers J.M., Stidham B.J., Hartmann D.H., 1997, AJ,
Wolff S.C., 1983, The A-type Stars: Problems and Prospectives,
NASA-SP 463
114, 2043
Hauck B., Ballereau D., Chauville J., 1995, A&AS, 109, 505
Hauck B., Ballereau D., Chauville J., 1998, A&AS, 128, 429
Heiter U., 2000, PASP, 112, 1509
Heiter U., 2002, A&A, 381, 959
Heiter U., Kupka F., Paunzen E., Weiss W.W., Gelbmann M.,
1998, A&A, 335, 1009
Heiter U., Weiss W.W., Paunzen E., 2002, A&A, 381, 971
Hill G.M., 1995, A&A, 294, 536
Hill G.M., Landstreet J.D., 1993, A&A, 276, 142
Holweger H., Rentzsch-Holm I., 1995, A&A, 303, 819
Holweger H., Hempel M., Kamp I., 1999, A&A, 350, 603
Iliev I.K., Barzova I.S., 1993, Ap&SS, 208, 277
Iliev I.K., Barzova I.S., 1995, A&A, 302, 735
Iliev I.K., Paunzen E., Barzova I.S., et al., 2002, A&A, 381, 914
Jaschek M., Andrillat Y., Jaschek C, 1989, A&A, 218, 180
Johnson D.R.H., Soderblom D.R., 1987, AJ, 93, 864
Kamp I., Iliev I.Kh., Paunzen E., et al., 2001, A&A, 375, 899
King J.R., 1994, MNRAS, 269, 209
Kobi D., North P., 1990, A&AS, 85, 999
Koen C., 1992, MNRAS, 256, 65
Kunzli M., North P., Kurucz R.L., Nicolet B., 1997, A&AS, 122,
51
Mihalas D., Routly P.M., 1968, Galactic Astronomy, Freeman &
Co., San Francisco, p. 101
Moon T.T., Dworetsky M.M., 1985, MNRAS, 217, 305
Morel P., 1997, A&AS, 124, 597
Napiwotzki R., Schonberner D., Wenske V., 1993, A&A, 268, 653
Nordstrom B., Stefanik R.P., Latham D.W., Andersen J., 1997,
A&AS, 126, 21
Oudmaijer R.D., Groenewegen M.A.T., Schrijver H., 1998, MN-
RAS, 294, L41
Palla F., Stahler S.W., 1993, ApJ, 418, 414
Paunzen E., 1997, A&A, 326, L29
Paunzen E., 2001, A&A, 373, 633
Paunzen E., Gray R.O., 1997, A&AS, 126, 407
Paunzen E., Kamp I., Iliev I.Kh., et al., 1999a, A&A, 351, 981
|
astro-ph/0608470 | 2 | 0608 | 2007-05-08T18:50:48 | A three stage model for the inner engine of Gamma Ray Burst: Prompt emission and early afterglow | [
"astro-ph"
] | We propose a new model within the ``Quark-nova'' scenario to interpret the recent observations of early afterglows of long Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRB) with the Swift satellite. This is a three-stage model within the context of a core-collapse supernova. Stage 1 is an accreting (proto-) neutron star leading to a possible delay between the core collapse and the GRB. Stage 2 is an accreting quark-star, generating the prompt GRB. Stage 3, which occurs only if the quark-star collapses to form a black-hole, consists of an accreting black-hole. The jet launched in this accretion process interacts with the ejecta from stage 2, and could generate the flaring activity frequently seen in X-ray afterglows. This model may be able to account for both the energies and the timescales of GRBs, in addition to the newly discovered early X-ray afterglow features. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
A three stage model for the inner engine of Gamma Ray Burst:
Prompt emission and early afterglow
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Calgary, 2500 University Drive NW,
Jan Staff and Rachid Ouyed
Calgary, AB T2N 1N4, Canada
and
Manjari Bagchi 1
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhaba Road, Colaba, Mumbai 400005, India
ABSTRACT
We propose a new model within the "Quark-nova" scenario to interpret the
recent observations of early afterglows of long Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRB) with
the Swift satellite. This is a three-stage model within the context of a core-
collapse supernova. Stage 1 is an accreting (proto-) neutron star leading to a
possible delay between the core collapse and the GRB. Stage 2 is an accreting
quark-star, generating the prompt GRB. Stage 3, which occurs only if the quark-
star collapses to form a black-hole, consists of an accreting black-hole. The jet
launched in this accretion process interacts with the ejecta from stage 2, and could
generate the flaring activity frequently seen in X-ray afterglows. This model may
be able to account for both the energies and the timescales of GRBs, in addition
to the newly discovered early X-ray afterglow features.
Subject headings: gamma rays: bursts, stars: evolution, (stars:) supernovae:
general
1.
Introduction
With the launch of the Swift satellite (Gehrels et al. 2004), observations of early X-ray
afterglows from gamma ray bursts (GRBs) have become possible (sometimes as early as 80
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Calgary, Canada AB T2N 1N4
-- 2 --
seconds after the GRB trigger). This led to some surprising observations, most notably, the
existence of one or more (sometimes giant) flares (first discussed by Burrows et al. 2005) in
the early X-ray afterglow (after a few hundred seconds to several thousand seconds) whose
rapid variability has been interpreted as the inner engine being active much longer than the
duration of the GRB itself (see for instance Zhang et al. 2006). Figure 1 shows a canonical
X-ray afterglow light curve. The early X-ray afterglow often has a very steep power-law
decay, lasting up to about a thousand seconds, followed by a flattening of the light curve,
which lasts for 104 − 105 seconds. This is often overlayed with flares and bumps in the
light curve. Thereafter, a "classical" decaying afterglow is seen, as it was known from the
pre-Swift era. It should be noted that not every bursts exhibits all of these features. The
flare(s) and the flattening of the light curve are likely due to extended inner engine activity,
and, this extended inner engine activity is what we focus on in this paper.
The inner engine for the GRB in our model is an accreting quark-star formed shortly
(hours) after the core collapse in a massive star. This process operates in three steps:
i)
the quark nova (Ouyed et al. 2002), where the core is converted to quark matter resulting
in mass ejection, ii) fall back material from the supernova together with some of the matter
ejected during the quark nova can form an accretion disk around the quark-star. Accretion
onto the quark-star launches a jet that will overtake the shell ejected by the quark nova and
is a possible location for the prompt X-ray emission. Internal shocks within the jet produce
the GRB, iii) if enough matter is accreted onto the quark-star, it will collapse and form
a black-hole. Continued accretion onto the black-hole can lead to an ultra-relativistic jet.
Interactions between this jet and the jet from the quark-star create shocks which lead to the
flaring activity frequently seen in X-ray afterglows.
In this paper we assume that the gamma-ray emission is produced by internal shocks.
The afterglow is produced when the merged shell creating the gamma-ray emission interacts
with the external medium in an external shock.
It should be emphasized that quark stars are hypothetical objects, that have not been
observed. They have been discussed theoretically for more than thirty years (see for instance
Itoh 1970). Two requirements are needed for quark stars to form. First the strange quark
matter (SQM) hypothesis must hold true. This hypothesis states that SQM has a lower
energy state than 56F e, thus being the ground state of hadronic matter. Quark stars are
usually thought to form from neutron stars whose central density increases above a critical
density. Only the more massive neutron stars are thought to be able to reach this density
(Staff et al. 2006). Second, the SQM EOS must support a rather massive quark star (the
mass will probably not change much in converting from a neutron star to a quark star).
Optionally, a quark star can form directly in the collapse of the iron core in massive stars,
-- 3 --
in which case the second requirement might be relaxed.
In § 2 we present our model for an inner engine for GRBs in three stages, followed by a
discussion of the energies and timescales of the inner engine in § 3. Then in § 4 we discuss
what happens when the jet from the black-hole and the quark-star interacts followed by a
discussion of the formation of the different features in the X-ray afterglow in § 5. We devote
§ 6 to correlations of features seen in the early afterglow light curve, and then in § 7 we
apply our model to different observed GRBs. Then in § 8 we discuss our model and finally
we summarize our model in § 9.
2. The three stages of activity
In this section, we discuss the three stages in our model for the inner engine for long
GRBs (see Fig. 2). These stages involve a neutron star phase, a quark star phase, and a
black hole phase. The goal is to explain features (e.g. flares and flattening in early X-ray
afterglow) observed in long GRBs as a result of interactions between the neutron star jet,
quark star jet, and the black hole jet. In essence the interaction between these jets is more
generic and could be applicable to other multi-stage models involving other engines.
2.1. Stage 1: Neutron star as the inner engine
The first stage in our model is the formation of a (proto-) neutron star from the collapse
of the core in the supernova. Several suggestions on how to generate GRBs from a newly
formed neutron star exist (e.g. Usov 1992; Kluzniak & Ruderman 1998; Wheeler et al. 2000;
Ruderman et al. 2000; Dai et al. 2006). More elaborate models involve in addition a transi-
tion to a black hole. Here we bring in an intermediate stage where the neutron star collapses
to a quark star (i.e. a quark nova) first. Our model is effectively a two-stage model since we
will be mostly focusing on the interaction between the quark star ejecta and the black hole
ejecta. We note however that the neutron star phase can lead to a short delay between the
collapse of the iron core and the GRB, which in our model occurs during the last two stages
which we describe next.
2.2. Stage 2: Quark star as the inner engine
The neutron star will accrete fall-back material from the exploding star until its den-
sity reaches deconfinement density, whereby the star is converted to a strange quark-star.
-- 4 --
Alternatively, if the density of the compact object left behind in the core collapse is above
deconfinement density, the quark-star can be formed directly in the collapse. The accreting
quark-star will produce the GRB (Ouyed et al. 2005, hereafter ORV), which is discussed
later.
The lifetime of the neutron star will determine whether the GRB and supernova will
be seen as simultaneous (or nearly simultaneous) events, or as temporally separated events.
The timescale for the conversion of the neutron star can vary dramatically, depending on
the accretion rate, the spin-down rate, and how close the state of the neutron star is to a
deconfined state. Observations indicate that the core collapse and the GRB are normally
almost simultaneous events (Della Valle 2006), which means that stage 1 in our model is
usually short or not present at all.
The quark-star will be surrounded by an accretion disk, due to fallback material from
the supernova, as well as quark nova material. As the star accretes matter, it will be heated
up. The decay of Goldstone bosons producing photons is the main cooling mechanism in this
phase (Vogt et al. 2004). For temperatures above about 7.7 MeV these photons can escape
the star, whereas for lower temperature they will be absorbed by the star (see ORV). If the
star heats up above 7.7 MeV, the emitted photons will interact with accreting material and
eject it. This halts accretion until the star has cooled down below 7.7 MeV again. This way,
episodes of accretion and ejection will occur.
The accreting material will follow the star's magnetic field lines towards the magnetic
pole of the star. Hence, most of the ejected material will be ejected from the polar regions,
and it will be collimated by the magnetic field, i.e. it is a jet (ORV). We assume an accretion
m ∼ 10−4M⊙ s−1 onto the quark star (similar to what is expected for neutron stars,
rate of
Fryer et al. 1996). Explaining the physical process that limits the accretion rate is beyond
the scope of this work and is left for future work. If the accretion rate is higher, we suggest
a black hole is formed quickly. This gives us a one stage model, as described in § 8.2.1.
We find that for typical values of the QS magnetic field, B ∼ 1015 G1, the maximum
accretion rate that can be channeled towards the polar cap2 to be m ≈ 10−3M⊙ s−1 (for
higher accretion rates the Alfv´en radius lies inside the star). For B ∼ 1014 G, the accretion
rate must be smaller than m ≈ 10−5M⊙ s−1 for the accretion to be channeled to the polar
1Recent work shows that 1015 G magnetic fields can be obtained during QS formation due to the response
of quarks to the spontaneous magnetization of the gluons (e.g. Iwazaki 2005, and references therein).
2The lack of observational evidence of a precessing jet (Beloborodov et al. 2000) is naturally explained
in our model since the magnetic field immediately after birth will align with the rotational axis of the star
(Ouyed et al. 2006).
-- 5 --
cap by the magnetic field, too low for the more energetic burst but suitable for lower energy
bursts and very long duration bursts.
Most photons will be emitted from the polar regions (where accretion heats up the star),
and they will then interact with some of the accreting material (see Fig 3). The Lorentz
factor of the ejected matter is Γ = ηQSmaccr/mejec, with ηQS ∼ 0.1 (Frank et al. 1992), maccr
and mejec are the accreted and ejected mass respectively (ORV). In order to achieve Lorentz
factors of the order 100, only a small fraction (10−3) of the accreting material can therefore
be ejected. Such a small fraction can be realized since the cooling time (and therefore the
period in which photons are emitted) is of the order microseconds, whereas the heating
(accretion) time is of the order milliseconds (ORV). If we assume a steady accretion, and
that the photons eject an amount of mass mejec ∼ m∆tem for each episode we find:
∆taccr
∆tem
∼
meject
maccr
∼ 10−3,
(1)
∆taccr and ∆tem being the time interval for accretion and ejection during one episode respec-
tively. However, it is likely that only a fraction of this material is ejected, leading to higher
Lorentz factors. This fraction might vary from episode to episode, giving rise to varying
Lorentz factors in the outflow. Internal shocks created by colliding shells in the jet acceler-
ate electrons that emit synchrotron radiation observed as gamma rays, as in Narayan et al.
(1992).
In order to produce merged shells with an internal energy of about 1050 erg (which is
generally required to explain the energies involved in GRBs) and Lorentz factors of more
than a hundred (to overcome the compactness problem; see e.g. Piran 1999), the shells must
be about 10−6M⊙ or 1027 g each. If the Lorentz factors are too large (a few thousands),
internal shocks will occur too late and external shocks occur before the internal shocks can
take place. This sets the upper and lower limits on the Lorentz factors required for GRBs.
For ηQS = 0.1, this means that maccr = 1030 − 1031g ∼ 10−3 − 10−2M⊙. A more likely
scenario is that in each episode less mass is ejected, and several of these ejecta quickly merge
to produce shells with mass ∼ 1027 g relaxing the constraints on maccr to lower values. These
shell mergers will not be observed, as they occur while the jet is still inside the exploding
star. The most efficient conversion of kinetic energy to internal energy is achieved when the
masses of the shells are similar, and the ratio in Lorentz factor of the colliding shells are big,
at least a factor two.
The duration of the accretion process depends on the mass of the disk and the maximum
temperature that the star can be heated to. ORV found that this process can last hundreds
of seconds, and possibly thousands. We will assume that the accretion eventually settles
into a steady state. If this accretion is not high enough to heat the star much above 7.7
-- 6 --
MeV, the ejection will be halted or very limited and the GRB comes to an end. However,
the inner engine is still actively accreting, until the disk has been depleted; this is unless the
star turns into a BH before disk depletion (see next subsection for more discussion).
ORV found that 10% of the rest mass energy of the accretion disk being accreted can be
used to power a jet. A quark-star can probably accrete up to 0.1M⊙ without collapsing to a
black-hole. Hence 0.1M⊙c2 ≈ 2 × 1053 erg is the maximum jet energy powered by accretion
onto a quark-star. We assume a radiative efficiency of 10% in shell collisions during the QS
phase. This means that in our model only about 1% (or about 2 × 1051 erg) of the rest mass
energy of the accretion disk surrounding the quark-star can be released as gamma rays in a
GRB. Using a collimation angle of a few degrees (ORV), this corresponds to Eγ,iso ∼ 1054
erg.
The ejected shells will collide with each other as explained, and be decelerated by the
interstellar medium forming an external shock. Acceleration of electrons in this shock creates
the afterglow (as in the internal -- external shocks model). If the outflow creating the afterglow
is beamed with jet angle θjet, a jet break will be observed as Γ−1 > θjet (Rhoads 1999). This
usually happens after about a day.
2.3. Stage 3: Black-hole as the inner engine
For a given temperature and equation of state (EOS), a mass-radius curve for quark-
stars has a maximum, i.e. there is a maximum mass for quark-stars. As is the case for the
maximum mass of neutron stars, this maximum mass depends on the EOS which is still being
studied. Harko & Cheng (2002) shows that quark stars whose EOS can be approximated by
a linear function of the density has a Chandrasekhar limit based on degenerate quarks. This
point denotes an instability, and so if there is accretion onto a star having this maximum
mass, it collapses into a black hole. We note however, that thermally induced instabilities
can drive the collapse to a BH before reaching the Chandrasekhar limit (for details see
Bagchi et al. 2006).
When the quark-star collapses into a black-hole, the accretion process changes dramat-
ically. The accretion rate is of the order 0.01 to 10 M⊙ s−1 in a hyperaccretion disk around
black holes (Popham et al. 1999), much higher than around quark stars where surface radi-
ation and magnetospheric effects should in principle reduce the accretion rate compared to
the accretion rate onto black holes. An ultrarelativistic jet is launched from the accretion
process onto the black hole as in De Villiers et al. (2005). Interaction between this jet and
the slower parts of the jet from the quark-star can generate flares seen in the early X-ray
-- 7 --
afterglow and when this jet collides with the external shock, late time bumps will be seen.
Internal shocks within the black hole jet itself can also occur, which likely would lead to flares
in either X-ray or gamma-ray wavelengths. Since the duration of this jet is likely short, the
width of these flares would also be short. This may add to the complexity of the observed
light curve.
The duration of the accretion/ejection process depends on the mass of the accretion disk
after the quark-star to black-hole conversion and the accretion rate. The disk is unlikely to
be more than a few solar masses, giving a maximum accretion time of about a hundred
seconds. However as found by De Villiers et al. (2005), accretion onto a black-hole is a much
faster process (about 1M⊙ s−1), which limits the duration of the accretion process to a few
seconds. This we take as a typical timescale for the accretion rate onto black-holes for the
rest of this paper.
3.
Inner engines timescales and energies
We can estimate the ratio between the duration of the inner engine in the black-hole
stage and in the quark-star stage as:
tBH
tQS
=
mdisk,BH
mBH
mdisk,QS
mQS
=(cid:16) mQS
mBH(cid:17)mdisk − mdisk,QS
mdisk,QS
= ζ m(cid:16) mdisk
mdisk,QS
− 1(cid:17)
(2)
where mdisk = mdisk,QS + mdisk,BH and ζ m parameterizes the ratio between the accretion
rate onto a quark-star and a black-hole. As typical values we use the same accretion rate
mQS ≈ 10−4M⊙ s−1 (Fryer et al. 1996, in fact the
onto quark stars as for neutron stars,
accretion rate depends on the maximum temperature the star is heated to as in ORV) and
mBH ≈ 1M⊙ s−1 (De Villiers et al. 2005) giving ζ m ≈ 10−4, and find that the duration of the
BH era is much shorter than the QS era.
The ratio between the energy produced by the inner engine in the two stages can be
found by:
EBH
EQS
=
ηBHmdisk,BH
ηQSmdisk,QS
= ζm
mdisk − mdisk,QS
mdisk,QS
= ζm(cid:16) mdisk
mdisk,QS
For typical values we use ηBH ≈ 10−3 (mejec/macc = 10−5 was found in De Villiers et al.
2005, assuming Γ = 100 this gives ηBH = Γmejec/macc = 10−3), and ηQS = 10−1 (similar to
the efficiency in neutron stars, Frank et al. 1992). This gives ζm = 10−2. Hence, most of the
energy will be output during the QS era, unless almost all of the disk (> 99%) is accreted
during the black-hole era.
− 1(cid:17).
(3)
-- 8 --
We can now combine the two above expressions, to get a simple ratio:
tBH
tQS
=
ζ m
ζm
EBH
EQS
.
(4)
From Eq. 3 we find that if 10% of a disk is accreted onto a quark-star (which then
collapses into a black-hole) and the rest is accreted into the black-hole, the energy output
in a jet from the quark-star is ten times larger than the energy output in a jet from the
black-hole. In this case we see from Eq. 4 that the duration of the accretion process onto the
quark-star is a thousand times longer than the duration of the accretion into the black-hole.
The above discussion is valid for the inner engine. We will now try to relate that to
observations. We assume a direct relation between the energy output from the inner engine
in the black-hole and quark-star phases and the observed energies from the two phases:
EBH,obs ≃ hζsh,BHiEBH
EQS,obs ≃ hζsh,QSiEQS,
(5)
where hζsh,BHi and hζsh,QSi is the energy conversion efficiency in the shocks averaged over the
entire duration of the shock activity (e.g. Kobayashi et al. 1997). For multiple shocks, we
assume this efficiency to be the same for the jet from the black-hole and the quark-star, hence
hζBHi ≃ hζQSi. Using this, we obtain the following ratios between the observed energies and
the accreted masses:
EBH,obs
EQS,obs
≃
EBH
EQS
≃ ζm(cid:16) mdisk
mdisk,QS
− 1(cid:17)
(6)
To a first approximation we can assume that EQS,obs is the observed GRB energy, and EBH,obs
is the observed energy in flares and bumps in the X-ray afterglow.
The observed energies in X-ray flares and bumps compared to the observed energies
released in gamma rays varies a lot in different bursts (from no flares or bumps to flares with
fluence equal to the GRB fluence). If we take
EBH,obs
EQS,obs
≃ 10−2
then, in our model, it would imply that
mdisk,BH ≃ mdisk,QS.
(7)
(8)
In other words, an equal amount of mass is accreted onto the quark-star and the black-hole.
This holds true if we neglect the energy carried by the slow shells from the quark-star, causing
-- 9 --
the flattening of the early X-ray afterglow light curve. This is a reasonable assumption, since
the energy in the flattening is less than in the GRB itself.
As for a direct comparison of the time scale of the inner engine to the observed time
scale, this is not possible since this is rather dictated by the complex interaction between
the black hole ejecta and the quark star ejecta as we show next.
4.
Interaction between black-hole ejecta and quark-star ejecta
Figure 4 illustrates the process of flattening the X-ray light curve and generating X-ray
flares and bumps. If the quark-star emits low-Lorentz factor shells at late stages of shell
emission, the shell from the black-hole can catch up with the last shell and produce an X-ray
flare via internal shocks. This merged shell may be capable of colliding with other slow shells
from the quark-star, whereby more X-ray flares will be seen, an idea bearing resemblance to
what is discussed in Zou et al. (2006). The energy output from the collisions depends on the
difference in Lorentz factor of the colliding shells. This is likely highest in the first collision.
However, the energy also depends on the masses of the colliding shells, so the energy output
is not necessarily highest in the first X-ray flare (see eqs. A3 and A4).
If the mass and Lorentz factor of the merged shell producing the X-ray flare(s) are high
enough, a bump can be seen in the X-ray afterglow light curve as this shell collides with the
external shock from the GRB.
The pulse width of the X-ray flares are generally longer than the width of the flares in
the GRB. There are also indications that later occurring flares are wider than flares occurring
early (Zhang et al. 2006). Qualitatively this can be understood from Eq. A1 in the Appendix.
The width of the burst is proportional to the separation of the colliding shells. The shells
creating the GRB were all produced by the quark-star in a fairly short time, whereas the
black-hole shell was created long thereafter.
Our model seems capable of explaining why later flares have a longer duration. From
Eq. A1 it is seen that the duration (for equal mass shells) depends on the initial distance
between two shells. Since the flares in our model are all due to the jet from the black-hole
colliding with slower parts of the quark-star jet, later flares are created by shells that were
farther away from the black-hole jet initially. This leads to longer duration.
The flattening of the X-ray light curve is due to lower Lorentz-factor shells emitted in
the later stages of the quark-star jet. These shells will catch up with the external shock
from the GRB at later stages, slowly re-energizing the external shock. This is reminiscent
-- 10 --
of the refreshed shocks scenario in Sari & M´esz´aros (2000). Hence the re-energization is
independent of the black-hole. The flare does depend on the black-hole formation, and also
on the fact that the quark-star jet emitted slower shells. A flare does not necessarily lead to
flattening, as only one slow shell from the quark-star is needed to produce a flare, whereas
a more continuous sequence of low-Lorentz factor shells is needed to produce the flattening.
The external shock will be decelerated by the surrounding medium. A low Lorentz factor
shell will catch up with the external shock when this has decelerated to a comparable Lorentz
factor. The range in Lorentz factors of the slow part of the quark-star jet is necessary to
explain a given flattening therefore depends on the deceleration of the external shock, which
is not well known. Following Falcone et al. (2006), a slow shell with Lorentz factor of about
20 will catch up with the external shock after t = 104 seconds, assuming a uniform external
medium with density n = 10 cm−3. A shell with a Lorentz factor Γ ∼ 9 will catch up with
the external shock after t = 105 seconds.
5. Light curve features: timescales and energies
In this section we first summarize the light curve features that our model can produce
(see Fig. 4), and then we discuss the different possible lightcurves (Fig. 5).
Steep decay: The steep decay commonly seen in the early afterglow (t ≈ 102 − 103
seconds) is due to the curvature effect (Kumar & Panaitescu 2000). This is prompt gamma
radiation from parts of the jet directed at an angle relative to the line of sight. Because of
the large Lorentz factors involved, most of the radiation is beamed with a beaming angle
Γ−1. Some of it will be directed to angles outside of Γ−1, but then softened by a Doppler
factor. This is why what is seen as gamma rays along the line of sight is seen as X-rays
at an angle from the line of sight. The steep decay continues until the luminosity from the
external shock is dominant. This effect is dominant only because the central engine does not
produce any visible activity, and the external shock is too weak to be seen.
Flattening: The flattening of the light curve is due to the external shock being re-
energized by low Lorentz factor shells emitted from the quark-star. These shells catch up
with the decellerating external shock. These shells were among the last ejected from the
quark star. It is important to note that there is not a one-to-one ratio for the duration of the
inner engine and the observed radiation in this case. The inner-engine ejection of shells could
last for some hundred seconds, whereas the re-energization can last for 104 − 105 seconds.
Flares: The flares are caused by interaction between a jet launched by a black-hole and
the slower parts of the ejecta from the quark-star. In order for flares to occur, the quark-star
-- 11 --
must have accreted enough matter that it collapses to a black-hole. The shell ejected by the
black hole can be very massive, mBH ∼ 1028 g and have a very large Lorentz factor. The shells
ejected in the quark-star phase are likely less massive, however some of these might merge
into massive ones before the black-hole shell interacts with them. In this case more than 1051
erg can be converted in one flare. The pulse width depends on the initial separation of the
shells and on the width of the rapid shell (Kobayashi et al. 1997). The black hole shell can
be fairly wide initially, and it is not unlikely that it spreads more before it collides with the
quark-star shell. Finally, we mention recent work by (Liang et al. 2006) where a zero time
point (right before the beginning of the flare) was taken as a signature of the reactivation
of the engine. If true, this observation suggests that the engine reactivates more than once
which cannot be reconciled with our model. We will tackle this issue elsewhere.
Bump: The bumps seen at late times (t ∼ 104 − 105 seconds as in GRB 050502B;
Falcone et al. 2006) are the result of the black-hole jet or the merged jet colliding with the
external shock. The black-hole jet may or may not have interacted with shells from the
quark-star to create flares before colliding with the external shock.
If there are no, or only a few, slow shells from the quark-star that the black-hole jet
collides with, the black-hole jet might not be slowed down significantly and it will catch up
with the external shock at an earlier stage. If this happens, a flare with not too steep rise will
result. However, after this flare, there will be no flattening, and no bumps. The black-hole
jet's collision with the external shock marks the end of the inner engine's contribution to the
observed afterglow light curve. Thereafter, a "classical" afterglow decay is the result, with
a possible jet break due to non-isotropic ejecta creating the afterglow.
There is a correlation between the energy emitted in the flares and in the bump (see
§ 6), so that bursts with more significant flares will have less pronounced bumps, and vice
versa. This is assuming that a black-hole was formed and an equal sized disk formed around
the black-hole. A small disk around the black-hole will lead to weak or no flaring and bumps.
In the case when no black-hole formed, no flares and no bump will be seen.
5.1. Generic light curves in our model
Here we discuss the eight different types of light curves that our model can generate
(Fig. 5).
Case 1. This case has all the properties discussed in the previous section i.e. flares,
flattening and a late time bump. The flares are produced when a black-hole jet collides with
slower shells from the quark-star. The flattening is due to slower shells from the quark-star
-- 12 --
re-energizing the external shock, whereas the bump occurs when the black-hole jet collides
with the external shock. This case is also shown in Fig. 4.
Case 2. This case shows a light curve with one or more flares and a flattening of the
X-ray afterglow light curve, but no bump. This will happen if the later stages of the ejection
from the quark-star produces slower shells. These slower shells will re-energize the external
shock, whereby the light curve is flattened. The accretion onto the black-hole launches an
ultrarelativistic shell, and when this interacts with a slower shell from the quark-star, an
X-ray flare is seen. However, the merged shell from the black-hole and the quark-star jet is
not fast enough to catch up with the external shock, so no bump is seen.
Case 3. This case shows flattening and a bump, but no flares. This is because the shell
from the black-hole did not interact with any of the slower shells from the quark-star. This
indicates that the black-hole shell was fairly slow. When the black-hole shell collides with
the external shock, a bump is seen. As before, slower shells in the quark-star jet re-energizes
the external shock, which flattens the light curve.
Case 4. This case has a bump, but no flare and no flattening. This occurs when the
quark-star jet does not produce any late time shells that can flatten the light curve, and the
shell from the black-hole can not interact with any shells to create a flare. A bump is seen
when the shell from the black-hole jet collides with the external shock.
Case 5. This case has a flare and a bump, but no flattening. This is rather similar
to case 4, however the quark-star jet emitted one or a few low Lorentz factor shells that
the black-hole jet interacted with. This happened before the late shells from the quark-star
collided with the external shock, so no flattening was created. GRB 050502B is an example
of a burst in this category.
Case 6. This case shows flattening, but no flare and no bump. This occurs when the
quark-star emits low Lorentz factor shells that can flatten the light curve, but no black-hole
was formed, or the jet from the black hole was to weak too make any observable signatures.
Case 7. This case is similar to case 6, but the quark-star did not emit late time shells,
so no flattening is seen.
Case 8. This case shows flaring, but no flattening and no bump. This occurs when the
quark-star generates some slow shells and a black-hole is formed. The jet from the black-hole
interacts with the slow shells and produces flaring. However, in this process the jet is slowed
down enough that it cannot make any significant impact on the external shock.
Case 1a.
In many observed afterglows the X-ray afterglow decays very steeply just
after the end of the gamma ray emission. We have explained this as being due to the
-- 13 --
curvature effect, that is an off-axis gamma ray emission, that in other directions is seen as
the prompt emission. However, in some bursts this steep decay is not observed.
Instead
the X-ray afterglow declines gradually, with a power law similar to the decline at late times
(t > 105 seconds). We suggest that in this case the external shock sets in earlier. There is
still the possibility of having flares and flattening in the same way as before, when the jet
from the black-hole collides with slower shells from the quark-star or the slower quark-star
shells re-energize the external shock.
6. Light curve features: Correlations
6.1. Anti-correlation between X-ray flares and bumps
We have proposed that the jet launched by the black-hole is responsible for the X-ray
flares and bumps. The flares are produced when the black hole jet collides with slower parts
of the jet from the quark-star. The bumps seen at later times in the X-ray afterglow are due
to the black-hole jet colliding with the external shock.
In Fig. 6 we explore the amount of energy converted and the resulting Lorentz factor of
the merged shell when the black-hole jet with Lorentz factor Γ = 100 and mass m = 3 × 1028
g collides successively with N quark-star shells. We show four different cases, when the
quark-star shells have Lorentz factors Γ = 10, 20, 30, or 40 and mass m = 3 × 1027 g (see
Eqs A3 and A4 in the Appendix). In the first couple of collisions, the difference in Lorentz
factor is fairly large, so a lot of energy is converted. However, after about 15 to 20 collisions,
not much more energy is converted. This is because the Lorentz factors of the colliding
shells are not very different. Several consecutive collisions will lead to several flares. We also
see that if the Lorentz factor of the slow shells are high, the merged shell will get a higher
Lorentz factor but less energy will be converted.
The energy released in the bump depends on the kinetic energy of the black-hole jet
(or the merged jet that produced the flares) when it collides with the external shock. If the
jet is not very energetic, i.e. a lot of energy was lost due to flaring, a weak bump will be
seen. If not much energy was lost due to flaring, because there were no slower shells from
the quark-star, the bump can be more pronounced.
To summarize: Since both the flares and the bump are generated by the black-hole jet, the
maximum energy available to do so is the initial kinetic energy of the jet. If a large fraction
of this energy is used to produce flares, less is available for the bump, and vice versa. This is
in agreement with O'Brien et al. (2006a,b), who find that there is a correlation between the
energy output in flares and in what they call the hump in observed GRB afterglows. The
hump is the flattening starting from about t = 103 seconds and includes possible bumps.
-- 14 --
6.2. Correlation between prompt gamma energy and early X-ray afterglow
energy
The total energy output from the quark-star inner engine is ηQSmdisk,QSc2 ≈ 2 × 1052erg
for mdisk,QS ∼ 0.1M⊙. This energy is shared between the prompt GRB3, the external shock
creating the decaying afterglow, and the re-energization of the external shock creating the
flattening of the early X-ray afterglow light curve. A GRB with low energy in a prompt
gamma-ray phase has more energy available for the early X-ray afterglow. Note however,
that in the early X-ray afterglow more energy can be emitted by the black hole jet interacting
with the quark star ejecta, as explained in the previous section.
7. Case study
In this section we will apply our model to a few observed X-ray afterglows that illustrate
the different properties of our model: flares, flattening and bumps.
7.1. GRB 050219A (case 2)
The observed light curve with the X-ray telescope (XRT) and the Burst Alert telescope
(BAT) do not look like they agree in this burst. This apparent discontinuity was first
reported in Tagliaferri et al. (2005) and may be due to an early X-ray flare (as proposed by
O'Brien et al. 2006a) after about 90 seconds. Since this flare is so early, it may either be
a late internal shock produced purely by the quark-star, or possibly the result of an early
black-hole formation. The early steep decay after this proposed flare is either the end of the
flare or more likely due to the curvature effect (M´esz´aros 2006). At later stages (from about
800 seconds) the light curve flattens and there are some small flares. These are the late and
slow parts of the quark-star jet that re-energize the external shock. If we are right in our
assumption that there is an early flare after about 90 seconds, this would correspond to case
2 in Fig. 5.
3 For a 10% radiative efficiency during shell collisions (as in the internal-external shocks model) in the
quark-star phase this would imply that a maximum of about 2×1051 erg is released as synchrotron radiation.
-- 15 --
7.2. GRB 050502B (case 5)
GRB 050502B shows a very strong X-ray flare, starting after about 350 seconds and
peaking around 700 seconds (Falcone et al. 2006). In addition, there is one (or possibly two)
bumps seen at about 40000 to 50000 seconds after the GRB trigger. The observed fluence
of the flare is comparable or even bigger than the GRB fluence. There are indications of
substructures within the flare itself. The total energy of the flare (or the GRB) is not known.
We find by using Eqs. A3 and A4 that a black-hole jet of mr = 3 × 1028 g, moving with
Lorentz factor of Γr = 200 and colliding with a shell from the quark-star with Lorentz factor
Γs = 10 and mass ms = 5 × 1027 gives an internal energy Eint = 2.4 × 1051 ergs and a Lorentz
factor of the merged shell of Γm = 96. The mass of the slow shell from the quark-star may
seem large, but this can be the result of collisions at earlier times. These collisions may not
have left observable flares if the difference in Lorentz factors in the colliding shells were not
large or these collisions could have been part of the GRB itself. The black-hole must have
ejected a fairly large amount of mass (3 × 1028 g), indicating that the accretion disk must
have been fairly large.
The bump(s) at t > 104 seconds occur when the merged shell that created the flare
catches up with the external shock (as suggested in Falcone et al. 2006). The underlying
decay of the afterglow is due to the external shock. This burst corresponds to case 5 in
Fig. 5.
7.3. GRB 050421 (case 1, 2, 5 or 8)
GRB 050421 shows two flares in the early X-ray afterglow, the first flare peaking after
111 seconds and the second after 154 seconds (Godet et al. 2006). The duration of the
gamma ray emission was about 10 seconds. We remind the reader that these flares are due
to a jet from a black-hole colliding with slower parts of the jet from the quark-star. The
width of the first peak is about 10 seconds. This can be achieved if the quark-star emits a
slow shell about 90 seconds following the first shell (c.f. eq. A1):
δt =
L
ac
=
c∆t
ac
=
20
2
= 10 s
(9)
(∆t being the time interval between the emission of the quark-star shell and the black-hole
shell). Alternatively, if the slower shell is emitted at the end of this burst (after about 10
seconds) but the jet from the black-hole has a significantly higher Lorentz factor, about 10
times higher than the quark-star shell :
δt =
L
ac
=
100c
10c
= 10 s.
(10)
-- 16 --
The second flare is created when the merged shell creating the first flare collides with another
slow shell emitted from the quark-star. The later stages of this afterglow (> 103 seconds) are
not observed. Therefore we cannot say if there is any flattening or bump. This corresponds
to any one of cases 1, 2, 5 or 8 in Fig. 5.
Alternatively, these two flares could both be produced by internal shocks from shells
created in the late stages of the accretion onto the quark star.
7.4. GRB050401 (case 6 without steep decay)
An example of a GRB without the early steep decline is GRB050401 (De Pasquale et al.
2006). The afterglows declines gradually with a decay index α ≈ 0.65 (Panaitescu et al. 2006)
until about 4300 seconds. After this, the decay is steeper with a decay slope α ≈ 1.39. We
ascribe the behavior until about 4300 seconds as flattening due to slower quark star shells
re-energizing the external shock. There is no clear evidence of any flaring in this afterglow,
in which case no black-hole jet interacted with the quark star jet or the external shock. This
corresponds to case 6 without the initial steep decay.
The isotropic equivalent energy of this burst is about Eγ,iso ∼ 3 × 1053 erg. Assuming
a beaming angle of 5◦, this gives a total energy in gamma rays of about 4 × 1050 erg (for a
bipolar jet). Zhang et al. (2006) found that almost five times as much energy was injected
in this burst during the afterglow than during the prompt gamma radiation, meaning about
2 × 1051 ergs was released in the early X-ray afterglow. In our model, this corresponds to
0.1M⊙ disk being accreted onto a quark star with 10% of the accreted energy ejected into a
bipolar jet, and only about 2% of the jet energy goes into radiation. Most of the jet energy
(the remaining 98%) is used to re-energize the external shock.
8. Discussion
8.1. Hypernova-GRB association in our model
The formation of the quark-star through a quark nova (between stage1 and 2) shortly
after the core collapse or directly in the core collapse releases an extra amount of energy that
can re-energize the SN ejecta, reminiscent of a hypernova (Ouyed et al. 2002; Keranen et al.
2005). GRBs seem to be associated with hypernovae (i.e. GRB 030329; Hjorth et al. 2003),
(GRB 980425; Galama et al. 1998), however, the opposite is not always true (i.e. SN 2002ap;
Mazzali et al. 2002, although a lack of GRB observation does not necessarily mean that no
-- 17 --
GRB occurred). In order to get a hypernova, the energy from the conversion to quark matter
is necessary. In our model, the GRB is produced by the jet launched by accretion onto the
quark star. If a black hole is formed directly in the collapse (no quark star stage), there will
be no hypernova. Accretion onto the black-hole can launch a jet, and internal shocks in the
jet can produce a GRB (see § 8.2.1). However, since there is only one stage, there can be no
late activity.
8.2. SN-less GRBs in our model
GRB060614 and GRB060505 were apparent nearby, long duration GRBs that showed
no sign of a supernova, leading to the term SN-less GRBs (Fynbo et al. 2006).
In the
litterature possible explanation for this have been that not enough 56Ni is formed in the
explosion (Tominaga et al. 2007), or that this is a very long and energetic "short" burst
(Zhang et al. 2007). Here we give a possible interpretation of this phenomena within our
model. We suggested above that the energy released by the quark nova (formation of a
quark-star) could potentially lead to a hypernova. However, if the star is too massive to
explode even with the extra energy released from the quark nova it will instead collapse
and no supernova/hypernova will be seen. We assume that a hyperaccretion disk can form
around the quark star while most of the star is trying to explode4, and as before accretion
onto the quark-star powers an ultrarelativistic jet giving rise to a GRB. In this scenario a
black-hole is the most likely final outcome: either the envelope falls back directly onto the
compact core, or it feeds to the accretion disk. In the first case a black hole is formed but
no ultrarelativistic jet is launched from the accretion onto it and hence no flaring or bump
activity is seen in the early X-ray afterglow. In the second case the quark-star collapses to
a black hole when it has accreted enough mass and continued accretion onto the black hole
will launch an ultrarelativistic jet that can give rise to flaring and bump activity seen in the
early X-ray afterglow.
8.2.1. Black-hole formation without a quark-star stage
In the event that a black-hole is formed immediately following the core collapse, a
collapsar scenario can occur if there is sufficient angular momentum present. Simulations
of this scenario by De Villiers et al. (2005) show that an ultrarelativistic jet is launched
4This scenario is initially similar to that leading to a GRB with an associated hypernova, only that in
this case the ejected material does not have enough energy to escape the star.
-- 18 --
that can give rise to internal shocks and a GRB. In addition to the jet, a coronal wind was
launched that could explode the remainder of the star. However, the energy of this wind
was of the order 1048 − 1049 erg, which is not enough to explain a supernova. Hence this
could be another possibility for explaining supernova-less GRBs, as discussed above. The
duration of the accretion process is short (accretion rate of the order 1M⊙ s−1 leading to a
rather short duration GRB).
An alternative occurs when the coronal wind is not strong enough to explode the star.
The star will then collapse, and assuming that it has high angular momentum, it will form
a massive accretion disk around the black-hole. The accretion rate onto the black-hole is
probably of the same order as with a smaller disk, however with much more mass to accrete
this could lead to a somewhat longer duration jet and GRB. This resembles the original
failed supernova discussed by Woosley (1993).
Both cases discussed above lead to a one stage model resulting in the absence of late
time activity. Therefore, there will be no flares or bumps in the afterglow light curve, but
flattening is still possible.
8.3. Collapsar vs. accreting quark-star as inner engine for GRBs
In this section we will briefly discuss the differences and similarities between our model
and the collapsar model (Woosley 1993) for the inner engine for GRBs.
Similarities: Both the collapsar and our model assume the death of a massive, rapidly
rotating star as the triggering mechanism. Both models launch an ultrarelativistic jet, in
which internal shocks accelerate electrons that produce synchrotron radiation. As this jet
is decelerated by the ISM, an external shock forms in which electrons again are accelerated
and emit synchrotron emission that is responsible for the afterglow.
Differences: The collapsar model assumes that the compact core left behind in the
collapse of the core of the progenitor star quickly collapses to a black-hole, whereas in our
model this compact core collapses to a quark star instead. This opens up some interesting
possibilities. The accretion rate into a black-hole and a quark-star are totally different.
Accretion into a black-hole is a very rapid process, with accretion rates of the order of one
solar mass per second. Accretion onto a quark star on the other hand is much slower (about
104 times slower). This can therefore easier explain the long duration (∼ 1000 seconds) seen
in some bursts. A main focus of this paper is the flaring often seen in the X-ray afterglow,
which is indicative of the engine being restarted. With a quark-star the possibility of it
collapsing to a black-hole exists, which explains how the inner engine can be restarted leading
-- 19 --
to the observed features in the early X-ray afterglow.
9. Summary and conclusion
To summarize, the properties of the three stages of the inner engine in our model are:
• The process is initiated by the collapse of the iron core of a massive, rapidly rotating
star.
• The collapsed core will either leave a neutron star or a quark-star behind.
• If a neutron star is left behind, it can collapse to a quark-star at a later stage, creating
a delay between the supernova and the GRB.
• Fallback material from the supernova and the quark nova forms a disk around the
quark-star. Accretion onto the quark-star generates the GRB by powering an ultrarel-
ativistic jet. Internal shocks in this jet create the GRB.
• Accretion continues, but at some point it cannot heat up the star sufficiently. This
halts the emission of shells, ending the GRB.
• When the quark-star has accreted too much material, it collapses into a black-hole.
Further accretion onto the black-hole launches an ultrarelativistic jet.
The emission features in our model can be summarized as follows:
• Early, steep decay in the X-ray afterglow is due to the curvature effect (this is not
specific to our model, but rather a generic feature in many models).
• Flares are created by interaction between the jet from the accretion onto a black-hole
and slower parts from the jet from the quark-star.
• Re-energization of the external shock (seen as flattening of the X-ray afterglow light
curve) is due only to the jet from the quark-star. Slower parts of this jet re-energizes
the external shock.
• When the jet from the black-hole collides with the external shock from the GRB, a
bump is seen in the afterglow light curve.
-- 20 --
In conclusion, we have presented a three stage (effectively two stage) model for the
inner engine for GRBs involving a neutron star phase, followed by a quark star phase then
by a black hole phase. This model seems to account for the observed prompt gamma ray
emission, as well as the features of the early X-ray afterglow and as such warrants further
study.
We would like to thank J. Hjorth, M. Lyutikov M. Cummings, W. Dobler, D. Leahy
and B. Niebergal as well as the anonymous referee for helpful remarks.
A.
Internal-external shocks model
Piran (2005) shows that the pulse width is proportional to the separation between two
shells:
δt ≈ Rs/2aΓ2c = L/ac
equal mass shells,
(A1)
where Rs is the distance at which the collision takes place, a is the ratio between the fast
and slow shells Lorentz factor, Γ the Lorentz factor of the slow shell, L the separation of the
shells and c the speed of light. Assuming that the colliding shells have equal mass, and the
faster has a Lorentz factor two times the slower shell, the separation between the two shells
must be 3 × 1013 cm in order to have a pulse width of 500 seconds. This corresponds to a
thousand seconds separation between the emission of the two shells.
The shells will collide at a distance
Rs ≈ 2Γ2L
(A2)
where Γ refers to the Lorentz factor of the slower shell. For Γ = 20 and a separation of
3 × 1013 cm as before, the collisions occur at Rs = 2 × 1016 cm. If the Lorentz factors are too
big, the external shocks will occur before internal shocks could occur. If the photon energy
is large enough to produce e+e− pairs, the Lorentz factors of the shells have to be above a
hundred to overcome the compactness problem. However, if the shocks creates X-rays, the
photons cannot create e+e− pairs, and there is no lower bound on the Lorentz factor.
The internal energy of the merged shell is given by:
Eint = mrc2(Γr − Γm) + msc2(Γs − Γm),
(A3)
where mr is the mass of the rapid shell, ms of the slow shell, Γr is the Lorentz factor of the
rapid shell, Γs is the Lorentz factor of the slower shell and Γm of the merged shell:
Γm =s mrΓr + msΓs
mr/Γr + ms/Γs
.
(A4)
-- 21 --
A certain fraction of this energy will be emitted as radiation. In order to have an efficient
collision (a collision in which a lot of energy is converted to internal energy), the masses
must be similar, and the Lorentz factor of the fast shell must be at least twice that of the
slower shell. For a mass of the rapid shell of about 3 × 1028 g, which is not unlikely in a
black-hole jet ( M ∼ 10−5Mdisk/s in De Villiers et al. 2005), and a mass of the slow shell of
3 × 1027 g, Lorentz factor of the rapid shell of Γr = 65, and Lorentz factor of the slow shell
of Γs = 20, which gives Γm = 57 and an internal energy of about 1050 erg in a collision.
Alcock, C., Farhi, E., & Olinto, A. 1986, ApJ, 310, 261
REFERENCES
Bagchi, M., Ouyed, R., & Staff, J. E., Ray, S., Dey M., Dey J., 2006, astro-ph/0607509.
Beloborodov, A. M., Stern, B. E., & Svensson, R., 2000, ApJ, 535, 158.
Burrows, D. N., et al., 2005, Science, 309, 1833
Dai, Z. G., Wang, X. Y., Wu, X. F., Zhang, B., 2006, Science, 311, 1127
De Villiers, J. P., Staff, J. E., & Ouyed, R., 2005, astro-ph/0502225.
Della Valle, M. "16th Annual October Astrophysics Conference in Maryland", eds. S. Holt,
N. Gehrels and J. Nousek, AIP Conf. Procs. astro-ph/0604110
De Pasquale, M., et al., 2006, MNRAS, 365, 1031
Falcone, A. D., et al., 2006, ApJ, 641, 1010.
Frank, J., King, R., Raine, & D. J. 1992, Accretion Power in Astrophysics (Cambridge:
Cambridge Univ. Press)
Fryer, Ch. L., Benz, W., Herant, M. 1996, ApJ, 460, 801
Fynbo, J., et al. 2006, Nature, 444, 1047
Galama, T. J., et al. 1998, Nature, 395, 670
Gehrels, N., et al. 2004, ApJ, 611, 1005
Godet, O., et al., 2006, A&A, 452, 819
Harko, T., Cheng, K. S., 2002, A&A, 385, 947
-- 22 --
Hjorth, J. et al., 2003, Nature, 423, 847
Itoh, N, 1970, PThPh, 44, 291
Iwazaki, A. 2005, PhRvD, 72, 114003
Keranen, P., Ouyed, R., & Jaikumar, P., 2005, ApJ, 618, 485
Klu´zniak, W., Ruderman, M., 1998, ApJL, 505, 113
Kobayashi, S., Piran, T., & Sari, R., 1997, ApJ, 490, 92
Kumar, P. & Panaitescu, A. 2000, ApJ, 541,L51
Liang, E. W., et al., 2006, ApJ, 646, 351
Mazzali, P., et al., 2002, ApJ, 572, L61
M´esz´aros, P. , 2006, "16th Annual October Astrophysics Conference in Maryland", eds. S.
Holt, N. Gehrels and J. Nousek, AIP Conf. Procs. astro-ph/0601661
Narayan, R., Paczynski, B., & Piran, T., 1992, ApJ, 392, L83
O'Brien, et al., 2006a, ApJ, 647, 1213
O'Brien, P. T., Willingale, R., Osborne, J. P., & Goad, M. R., 2006b, NJPh, 8, 121.
Ouyed, R., Dey, J., & Dey, M. 2002, A&A, 390, 39
Ouyed, R., Rapp, R., & Vogt, C., 2005, ApJ, 632, 1001 (ORV).
Ouyed, R., Niebergal, B., Dobler, W., & Leahy, D., 2006, ApJ, 653, 558.
Panaitescu, A., M´esz´aros, P., Burrows, D., Nousek, J., Gehrels, N., O'Brien, P., & Willingale,
R. 2006, MNRAS, 369, 2059
Piran, T., 1999, PhR, 314, 575
Piran, T., 2005, Rev. Mod. Phys., 76, 1143.
Popham, R., Woosley, S.E., & Fryer, Ch. 1999, ApJ, 518, 356.
Rhoads, J. E. 1999, ApJ, 525, 737.
Ruderman, M. A., Tao, L., Klu´zniak, W., 2000, ApJ, 542, 243
Sari, R. & M´esz´aros, P. 2000, ApJ, 535, L33.
-- 23 --
Staff, J., Ouyed, R., & Jaikumar, P. 2006, ApJ, 645, L145
Tagliaferri, G. et al., 2005, Nature, 436, 985
Tominaga, N., Maeda, K., Umeda, H., Nomoto, K., Tanaka, M., Iwamoto, N., Suzuki, T. &
Mazzali, P. A., 2007, ApJ, 657, L77.
Usov, V. V. 1992, Nature, 357, 472
Vogt, C., Rapp, R., & Ouyed, R. 2004, Nuc. Phys. A, 735, 543.
Wheeler, J. C., Yi, I., Hoflich, P., Wang, L., 2000, ApJ, 537, 810.
Woosley, S.E. 1993, ApJ, 405, 273.
Zhang, B., Fan, Y.Z., Dyks, J. Kobayashi, S., M´esz´aros, P., Burrows, D.N., Nousek, J.A., &
Gehrels, N. 2006, ApJ, 642, 354.
Zhang, B, Zhang, B. B., Liang, E. W., Gehrels, N., Burrows, D. N. & M´esz´aros, P. 2007,
ApJ, 655, L25.
Zou, Y. C., Dai, Z. G., & Xu, D. 2006, ApJ, 646, 1098.
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 24 --
"Early/New afterglow"
"Late/Classical afterglow"
Steep decay
flare
2
10
− 10
4
s
flattening
e
t
a
r
t
n
u
o
C
bump
jet break
6
10
− 10
5
s
3
10 s
4
10
− 10
5
s
Time
Fig. 1. -- Generic X-ray afterglow (e.g. Zhang et al. 2006). At early times (t < 1000 seconds),
a steep decay is often seen, followed by a flattening starting at t = 103 and lasting for about
104 − 105 seconds. Thereafter a steeper decay, and after about a day or so a new break
is seen. The last break is termed "jet break". On top of this one or more flares are often
observed between t = 102 −104 seconds, and one or more bumps can be seen between t = 104
seconds and t = 105 seconds. NOTE: Not all features are seen in every bursts. Before (the
launch of the) Swift satellite, the part of the figure including the steep decay, the flares and
the flattening was essentially unobserved.
-- 25 --
SN ejecta
External shock
Ultrarelativistic jet
SN ejecta
External shock
Ultrarelativistic jet
SN ejecta
Accretion disk
QN
NS
Accretion disk
BH
QS
Hours to days
2−2000 s
Accretion disk
Black hole
Stage 1
Stage 2
GRB light curve
e
t
a
r
t
n
u
o
C
Stage 3
X−ray afterglow
e
t
a
r
t
n
u
o
C
Time
Time
Fig. 2. -- The three stages in a GRB inner engine. Stage 1: A neutron star is formed in
the core collapse of a massive star. The neutron star can later collapse into a quark-star
due to spin-down or accretion. If this takes a long time, it will cause a delay between the
supernova and the GRB. Stage 2: A quark-star in the CFL phase is formed, either directly
in the supernova, or from the neutron star in Stage 1. Accretion onto this star heats the
star, leading to emission of photons as the main cooling mechanism. If the star is heated
above the plasma frequency of about 7.7 MeV (ORV), the photons can escape the star and
will interact with the accreting matter. The infalling matter is ejected, leading to a halt in
the accretion process. When the star cools down below 7.7 MeV, accretion can be resumed.
This creates episodes of accretion and ejection. Internal shocks created from colliding shells
in the ejected material create the GRB. Stage 3: At later stages in the accretion process the
accretion may not be strong enough to heat the star above 7.7 MeV. This prevents ejection
of material, and hence terminates the GRB. However, the accretion will continue. If the star
accretes too much matter, it will collapse to a black-hole. This dramatically changes the
accretion, and launches an ultrarelativistic jet. This jet will interact with slower parts of the
jet from the quark-star, leading to internal shocks. This creates the flares often seen in the
early X-ray afterglow. When the jet from the black-hole collides with the external shock, a
bump is observed on the light curve.
-- 26 --
Accretion/Heating
Ejection/Cooling
accretion
ω
magnetic
field line
heating
ejected
material
magnetic
field line
photon cooling
QS
~1ms
QS
∼1µ
s
heating
magnetic
field line
accretion
photon cooling
magnetic
field line
ejected
material
Fig. 3. -- Cartoon illustrating the jet launching mechanism in our model. Infalling material
follows magnetic field lines to the polar cap (magnetic pole is at the same location as the
geographic pole in a CFL star, see text), where it heats the star. The timescale for heating
the star is of the order milliseonds. The star then cools by emitting photons on a timescale
of the order of microseconds. These photons interact with the infalling material, ejecting
some of that with large Lorentz factors.
-- 27 --
Fast shell from
BH phase
Slower (late) shells
from QS phase
External shock (ES)
from QS phase
Γ
>Γ
s,BH
s,QS
s,QSΓ >ΓES,QS
ΓES,QS
Re−energization
of QS ext. shock
X−ray flare
Bump (BH jet +QS ES
collision)
x
u
l
f
time
Fig. 4. -- Illustration of the mechanism leading to X-ray flares and flattening of the X-ray
afterglow light curve. In both cases, the quark-star needs to emit low-Lorentz factor shells
in the late stages of shell emission. When these shells collide with the external shock from
the GRB, that shock is re-energized and a flattening of the light curve results. If the quark
star accretes too much mass, it will collapse to a black-hole. The jet emitted in the accretion
process onto the black-hole can be massive and have a high Lorentz factor. When this
outflow collides with a slow shell from the quark-star, an X-ray flare results. If this merged
shell collides with more low-Lorentz factor shells from the quark-star, more flares will result.
A bump can be seen when the black-hole ejecta collide with the external shock.
Case 1
Case 2
-- 28 --
Case 3
Case 4
Case 5
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
time
Case 6
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
time
Case 7
time
Case 8
time
Case 1a
time
x
u
l
f
x
u
l
f
time
time
time
time
Fig. 5. -- The differeant kinds of light curves derived from our model. Case 1 is also illustrated
in Fig. 4. There are flares, flattening and a bump. This occurs when the quark-star jet
produces slow shells that can re-energize the external shock. The black hole jet interacts
with some of these shells and creates flares. When the merged black-hole jet collides with
the external shock, the bump is formed. Case 2: We see one or more flares and a flattening
of the light curve, but no bump. This is because the shell from the black-hole is slowed
down so much by the other shells from the quark-star that it reaches the external shock at
very late times. Case 3: Flattening and a bump, but no flare. The shell from the black-
hole did not collide with any shell and therefore did not create a flare. It creates a bump
when it collides with the external shock. Case 4: No flare, no flattening, but a bump. The
quark-star jet did not contain any late time shells, so there were no flattening and no flare
created. As in Case 3, the black-hole jet creates a bump when it collides with the external
shock. Case 5: Flare and bump, but no flattening. There are only a few late time shells
emitted from the quark-star. The black hole jet collides with these and creates flares. When
this merged shell collides with the external shock a bump is seen. No late time shells can
flatten the light curve. Case 6: No flares, no bump but flattening. The quark-star emits
late time shells that flattens the light curve. No black-hole was formed. Case 7: No flares,
no bump, no flattening. No black-hole was formed, and the quark-star did not emit any late
time shells. Case 8: Flares, but no bump and no flattening. This indicates that a black-hole
which launched an ultrarelativistic jet was formed, but in the process of forming the flares
this jet was slowed down enough so that it cannot energize the external shock to generate a
bump. Case 1a: Same as case 1, but no early steep decay. All cases from 1 to 8 can exist
without the early steep decay as illustrated in case 1a where the decay is absent for case 1.
Note that a possible break in the light curve due to collimation of the outflow producing the
GRB and the afterglow will occur at later times than what is shown in this figure.
2.0⋅1051
2.0⋅1051
2.0⋅1051
2.0⋅1051
1.8⋅1051
1.8⋅1051
1.8⋅1051
1.8⋅1051
1.6⋅1051
1.6⋅1051
1.6⋅1051
1.6⋅1051
1.4⋅1051
1.4⋅1051
1.4⋅1051
1.4⋅1051
1.2⋅1051
1.2⋅1051
1.2⋅1051
1.2⋅1051
t
t
t
t
n
n
n
n
E
E
E
E
i
i
i
i
1.0⋅1051
1.0⋅1051
1.0⋅1051
1.0⋅1051
8.0⋅1050
8.0⋅1050
8.0⋅1050
8.0⋅1050
6.0⋅1050
6.0⋅1050
6.0⋅1050
6.0⋅1050
4.0⋅1050
4.0⋅1050
4.0⋅1050
4.0⋅1050
2.0⋅1050
2.0⋅1050
2.0⋅1050
2.0⋅1050
0.0⋅100
0.0⋅100
0.0⋅100
0.0⋅100
0
0
0
0
100
100
100
100
m
m
m
m
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
80
80
80
80
60
60
60
60
40
40
40
40
20
20
20
20
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-- 29 --
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=10
=10
=10
=10
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=20
=20
=20
=20
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=30
=30
=30
=30
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=40
=40
=40
=40
10
10
10
10
20
20
20
20
30
30
30
30
40
40
40
40
50
50
50
50
60
60
60
60
70
70
70
70
N
N
N
N
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=40
=40
=40
=40
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=30
=30
=30
=30
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=20
=20
=20
=20
Γ
Γ
Γ
Γ
s
s
s
s
=10
=10
=10
=10
10
10
10
10
20
20
20
20
30
30
30
30
40
40
40
40
50
50
50
50
60
60
60
60
70
70
70
70
N
N
N
N
Fig. 6. -- Figure showing the total energy converted to internal energy versus number of
collisions (upper panel) and the Lorentz factor of the merged shell versus number of collisions
(lower panel). In all cases the rapid shell has a Lorentz factor of 100 initially, and all the
slow shells have Lorentz factors of 10, 20, 30 or 40 respectively. The mass of the rapid shell
is 3 × 1028 g, and the mass of the slow shells are 3 × 1027 g. The figures show that after 10
to 20 collisions a plateau is reached and no more energy is converted. The Lorentz factor
reaches a plateau. In this plateau, collisions can still occur, so the merged shell can gain
mass. When the slower shells have higher Lorentz factors, the merged shell ends up with a
higher Lorentz factor after the collisions, and the energy conversion is reduced. This leaves
more energy to be converted when this merged shell collides with the preceding quark-star
external shock.
|
astro-ph/9811445 | 1 | 9811 | 1998-11-27T18:22:38 | Proceedings of the Bonn/Bochum-Graduiertenkolleg Workshop 'The Magellanic Clouds and Other Dwarf Galaxies' | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Workshop 'The Magellanic Clouds and Other Dwarf Galaxies' was held at the Physikzentrum Bad Honnef in January 1998. The proceedings comprise 79 contributions. About 1/3 of the 352 pages contain the following Reviews:
The Violent Interstellar Medium in Dwarf Galaxies: Atomic Gas (Elias Brinks and Fabian Walter),
Hot Gas in the Large Magellanic Cloud (You-Hua Chu),
Astrophysics of Dwarf Galaxies: Structures and Stellar Populations (John S. Gallagher),
Star-forming regions and ionized gas in irregular galaxies (Deidre A. Hunter),
The Law of Star Formation in Disk Galaxies (Joachim Koeppen),
Strange Dark Matters in Nearby Dwarf Galaxies (Mario Mateo),
Holes and Shells in Galaxies: Observations versus Theoretical Concepts (Jan Palous),
Detailed Recent Star Formation Histories of Dwarf Irregular Galaxies and Their Many Uses (Evan D. Skillman et al.), and
Nearby Young Dwarf Galaxies (Trinh X. Thuan and Yuri I. Izotov). See the complete electronic version for further details. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Bonn/Bochum-Graduiertenkolleg Workshop
The Magellanic Clouds and
Other Dwarf Galaxies
Physikzentrum Bad Honnef, Germany
19th – 22nd January 1998
Edited by
Tom Richtler & Jochen M. Braun
Sternwarte der Universitat Bonn, Auf dem Hugel 71,
D–53121 Bonn, Federal Republic of Germany
8
9
9
1
v
o
N
7
2
1
v
5
4
4
1
1
8
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Shaker Verlag
October 1998
Foreword by the Spokesman of the Graduiertenkolleg
It is a great pleasure that the 25th meeting of our Graduate Working Group, which is being
supported now in its 6th year by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, could become a significant
international event. It is also gratifying to see this workshop as a harvest after 5 years of intensive
work. The Graduate Working Group has seen a host of guest scientists who have visited in
the framework of close collaboration, or gave lectures and seminars during the many previous
meetings. This gathering of experts on galaxies, and particularly dwarf galaxies, represents a
small milestone in the recent past of galaxy research at the Universities of Bonn and Bochum.
Until the late 70's, the investigation of dwarf galaxies was restricted to a few small groups.
Although the Magellanic Clouds had been studied extensively due to their proximity, it took
a while until the term dwarf galaxy became fashionable among astrophysicists. There are
several reasons why dwarf galaxy research is one of today's fastest growing branches of modern
astrophysics. First, the Magellanic Clouds have always been appreciated as the ideal astrophysical
laboratory in which one can study all kinds of processes without being hampered by distance
and line-of-sight problems. Second, since it was known early on that dwarf galaxies are so little
evolved, their relevance to cosmology was recognized. Third, by virtue of their low mass, the
evolution of their ISM and stellar populations can be studied in the absence of internal large-scale
triggers like stellar bars or density waves. It is therefore not surprising that the past two decades
have seen a rapidly increasing rate of related research projects and publications, accompanied
by an ever increasing number of conferences dedicated to this subject, one of which is being
reported in these proceedings.
While to the non-expert it might at first glance look as if dwarf galaxy research is a rather
specialized field, a quick look at contemporary reviews on galaxy research demonstrates that
understanding low-mass galaxies is of utter importance to also comprehend what is going on in
more massive and, in particular, more distant ones. A prime example is the understanding of the
faint blue galaxy population at redshift 0.4 to 1.0, which has experienced a further boom with the
scrutiny of distant objects in the Hubble Deep Field. It is obvious that in order to understand
stellar systems at large distances, it is all the more important (also for the cosmologists) to
understand those just outside our door step!
Research on the Magellanic Clouds and other dwarf galaxies had been going on at the
Universities at Bonn and Bochum for some time prior to the Bonn/Bochum Graduate Working
Group. It was therefore quite natural to combine the experience gained in two small research
groups in order to intensify this research, while at the same time establishing an educational
programme in which graduate students could benefit for their own career, and contribute to the
progress in a very proliferous field of research.
We are grateful to the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for financing this Graduate Working
Group, thus rendering possible this intensive educational and research programme in a very
prolific and fascinating field of research. I would like to take this opportunity to thank Christian
Bruns for his invaluable help in organizing this workshop. It has been (and still is) a great
pleasure to work with the students in the Graduate Working Group. It is their enthusiasm
and diligence that, besides my natural endeavour in this field of research, ensures permanent
motivation!
Uli Klein
Bonn, April 1998
Foreword of the Editors
After having completed the present edition of the proceedings of our workshop on "The Magellanic
Clouds and Other Dwarf Galaxies" we wish to express our gratitude to all contributors. The
concept of our "Graduiertenkolleg" is meant to provide an efficient framework for graduate
education and research and to foster not only the relations between students and supervisors
but also between students and distinguished representatives of the community of our field of
research. In this sense the graduate school can be seen as an attempt to realize the old (and
often forgotten) idea of unifying teaching and research at universities. This edition is a handy
manifestation.
We remember quite well that, when we tried to expand our scientific ambitions centered on
the Magellanic Clouds, the extension "... and Other Dwarf Galaxies" sounded meaningless to
many ears. Looking at the entire collection of reviews, talks and posters addressing such a large
variety of astrophysical issues, it now seems to us that no better headline for merging the various
interests within our graduate school could have been found.
We hope that it is of interest for many researchers to have a look at the extensive key word
and object lists (see the apendices "Subject Index" and "List of Objects" on page 337 and 331
respectively) to quickly find specific information among the wealth of topics and objects, which
appear in contributed talks and posters. We also hope that the attractive cover (designed by
Michael Hilker and Sven Kohle) strengthens the wish of a potential reader to know what is in
the book.
We wish to thank the Shaker Verlag, namely Dr. Shaker, for giving us the permission to make
the proceedings available in free electronic form on our webserver (see also the next preface
about "Electronic Publishing") and all the participants (see the "List of Participants" on page
313) for their help in creating a fascinating workshop, for their contributions, and of course for
further supporting the electronic version with updates and new links. We very much appreciate
the contribution by Joachim Koppen, who fell sick shortly before the workshop and could not
participate.
Considering the statistics of incoming contributions (see electronic version, at the URL:
http://www.astro.uni-bonn.de/webgk/ws98/techinf a.html#subm), it is noteworthy that
the first contribution was a review, and so was the last. The distribution of time of the arrival of
the reviews was nearly homogeneous, whereas the one for the talks and especially for the posters
was peaking at our deadline.
Many thanks go to the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft as the funding institution of the
Graduiertenkolleg and also for supporting this workshop.
Tom Richtler & Jochen M. Braun
Bonn, October 1998
Electronic Publishing
In the last few years sciences have improved by new electronic means, not only to create huge
data bases and providing tools for data reduction, but also in electronic publishing (EP) and
information exchange.
One of the most powerful aids apart from E-Mail and FTP (File Transfer Protocol) is the
World Wide Web (WWW or W3), which has developed from the "toy" status to a very fast
publication means, useful for announcing meetings, presenting institutes and working groups,
providing the latest data about equipment, and nowadays also for publishing. Right from the
start WWW was intended as a scientific tool developed at CERN, but soon was adopted by
the whole society, at least in some countries with approriate and cheap telecommunication
infrastructure. Thus in addition to the tools (like browsers) developed by scientists, commerial
products arose and the language of the Web, HyperText Markup Language - HTML, came into
Babylonian trouble. To create future standards and secure the general accessibility, the WWW
Consortium (W3C) formed, which has created the current (but still unsupported) standards
HTML 4.0 and CSS 2.0, and is developing further scientificaly relevant techniques, namely
XML, XSL, and DOM.
To focus on astrophysics, literature search in the good old libraries was supported by electronic
search engines, litearature data bases, and preprint servers, e.g. ADS, CDS, and XXX, and
publishing in printed journals including the well-tried referee process was extended by electronic
versions, in different quality and accessibility. That EP is of enhanced importance today can
be seen e.g. by the controversial panel discussion at the "AG Tagung" in Insbruck 1997 after
the talk "Electronic publishing in its context and in a professional perspective" by Andr´e Heck
(1998, Reviews in Modern Astronomy 11, 337).
Let me stress a few aspects which, from my personal point of view are import in future:
• We need an international referee process decoupled from journals or publishers and revised
international copyright laws doing justice to sciences.
• Scientists have to stay involved in modern techniques, i.e. knowing the basics of TEX, HTML
etc., and every institution needs scientists especially trained in these subjects.
• Continent based mirror servers should be erected providing certified scientific information
easily and freely accessible for the whole international community.
As a small step in this respect we present these proceedings in two different versions. One is
the classical book (constructed with the typesetting system TEX & LATEX), which is published
and distributed by the Shaker Verlag, the second is the electronic version (written in HTML)
on the WWW server of the Astronomical Institutes of the University of Bonn. The latter can
be visited via the following Uniform Resource Locator (URL):
http://www.astro.uni-bonn.de/webgk/ws98/cover.html
and should provide the full information including updates after the day of printing (noted in the
"Erratum", an appendix of the electronic version) and related URLs. As technical modifications
are possible - and even probable, people using the HTML version may also visit the appendix
"Technical Information" (e.g. giving recommended browsers).
I hope that the electronic version will be a fruitful and frequently visited supplement to the
printed version.
Jochen M. Braun
Bonn, October 1998
Table of Contents
Preface
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Foreword by the Spokesman of the Graduiertenkolleg
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Foreword of the Editors
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Electronic Publishing
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Table of Contents
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Review Talks
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Violent Interstellar Medium in Dwarf Galaxies: Atomic Gas
Elias Brinks and Fabian Walter
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Hot Gas in the Large Magellanic Cloud
You-Hua Chu
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Astrophysics of Dwarf Galaxies: Structures and Stellar Populations
John S. Gallagher
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Star-Forming Regions and Ionized Gas in Irregular Galaxies
Deidre A. Hunter
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Law of Star Formation in Disk Galaxies
Joachim Koppen
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Strange Dark Matters in Nearby Dwarf Galaxies
Mario Mateo
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Holes and Shells in Galaxies: Observations versus Theoretical Concepts
Jan Palous
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Detailed Recent Star Formation Histories of Dwarf Irregular Galaxies and
Their Many Uses
Evan D. Skillman, Robbie C. Dohm-Palmer, and Henry A. Kobulnicky
. . . . . . . . . .
Nearby Young Dwarf Galaxies
Trinh X. Thuan and Yuri I. Izotov
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
iii
iii
v
vii
ix
1
1
11
25
37
45
53
67
77
91
Talks
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
107
The Star Formation History of Nearby Dwarf Galaxies: problems, methods and results
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Antonio Aparicio
107
Diffuse Hot Gas in Dwarf Galaxies
Dominik J. Bomans
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
111
The Young Large-Scale Features in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Jochen M. Braun
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
115
A detailed view of the Magellanic Clouds in the FIR
M. Braun, R. Assendorp, Tj.R. Bontekoe, D.J.M. Kester, and G. Richter
. . . . . . . .
121
Bow Shock Induced Star Formation in the LMC: a Large Scale View
Klaas S. de Boer
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
125
6
Preface III
The binary star cluster SL 538/ NGC 2006 (SL 537)
Andrea Dieball and Eva K. Grebel
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
129
Tidal Dwarf Galaxies
P.-A. Duc, U. Fritze-v. Alvensleben, and P. Weilbacher
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133
The ATCA Radio-continuum Investigation of the Magellanic Clouds
Miroslav D. Filipovi´c and Lister Staveley-Smith
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
137
Tidal Dwarf Galaxies: Their Present State and Future Evolution
Uta Fritze - v. Alvensleben and Pierre-Alain Duc
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
141
The star formation history of Leo I
Carme Gallart, Antonio Aparicio, Wendy Freedman, Giampaolo Bertelli,
and Cesare Chiosi
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
147
The Recent Star Formation History of the Large Magellanic Cloud
Eva K. Grebel and Wolfgang Brandner
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
151
Cold dust in NGC 205
Martin Haas
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
155
Is the metallicity and the luminosity related for dwarf irregular galaxies?
A.M. Hidalgo-G´amez and K. Olofsson
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
157
The stellar census of the nearby BCDG VII ZW 403 with HST
Ulrich Hopp, Regina E. Schulte-Ladbeck, and Mary M. Crone
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
161
H i Properties of new nearby Dwarf Galaxies from the Karachentsev Catalog
W.K. Huchtmeier
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
165
An H i Aperture Mosaic Survey of the Large Magellanic Cloud
Sungeun Kim, Lister Staveley-Smith, and Michael A. Dopita
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
169
dSph Satellite Galaxies without Dark Matter: a Study of Parameter Space
Pavel Kroupa
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
173
Starbursts in dwarf galaxies: Blown out or blown away?
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low and Andrea Ferrara
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
177
Recent Star Formation in the Wolf-Rayet BCDG MRK 1094
David I. M´endez, L.M. Cair´os, C. Esteban, and J.M. V´ılchez
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
181
Interpreting the H ii Region Luminosity Function
M.S. Oey and C.J. Clarke
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
185
The first detection of H2 in absorption in the LMC
Philipp Richter, Klaas S. de Boer, Dominik J. Bomans, Andreas Heithausen,
and Jan Koornneef
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
189
Chemodynamical Evolution of Dwarf Galaxies
Andreas Rieschick and Gerhard Hensler
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
193
HST Study of the Stellar Populations around SN 1987A
Martino Romaniello, Nino Panagia, Salvo Scuderi, and the SINS collaboration
. .
197
The Role of Galaxy Interactions in H ii Galaxies
Christopher L. Taylor, Elias Brinks, and Evan D. Skillman
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
201
CO Emission in Low Luminosity Star Forming Galaxies
Christopher L. Taylor, Henry A. Kobulnicky, and Evan D. Skillman
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
205
Table of Contents
7
The Outer Halo of NGC 4449
Christian Theis and Sven Kohle
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
209
WFPC2 Observations of Leo A: A Young Galaxy?
Eline Tolstoy, J.S. Gallagher, A.A. Cole, J.G. Hoessel, A. Saha, R. Dohm-Palmer,
E. Skillman, and M. Mateo
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
213
The recent star formation history in NGC 1569
M. Tosi, M. Clampin, G. De Marchi, L. Greggio, C. Leitherer, and A. Nota
. . . . .
217
The Violent Interstellar Medium of IC 2574
Fabian Walter, Elias Brinks, Neb Duric, Jurgen Kerp, and Uli Klein
. . . . . . . . . . . .
221
Posters
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
225
First results of a CO survey of dwarfs
Marcus Albrecht, Roland Lemke, and Rolf Chini
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
225
Preliminary Results on the Resolved Stellar Population of I Zw 18
A. Aloisi, L. Greggio, M. Tosi, M. Clampin, A. Nota, and M. Sirianni
. . . . . . . . . . .
227
Hot subdwarfs, their kinematics and their galactic distribution
Martin Altmann, Yolanda Aguilar-S´anchez, Klaas S. de Boer,
Michael Geffert, Michael Odenkirchen, and Jacques Colin
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
229
Structure and stellar content of dwarf galaxies: Surface photometry of dwarf
galaxies in the M81 & M101 groups
Torbjørn Bremnes, Bruno Binggeli, and Philippe Prugniel
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
231
H i-Velocity-Bridges in the Magellanic Stream
Christian Bruns, Peter Kalberla, and Ulrich Mebold
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
233
Multiband Analysis of the Brightness Distribution of a Sample of Blue
Compact Dwarf Galaxies
L.M. Cair´os and J.M. V´ılchez
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
235
Recent radio and polarization observations of dwarf irregulars
Krzysztof T. Chyzy, Sven Kohle, Rainer Beck, Uli Klein, and Marek Urbanik
. . .
237
DeNIS Observations on the Magellanic Clouds
Maria Rosa Cioni, Cecile Loup, Harm J. Habing, and Erik R. Deul
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
239
New H i shells in the Milky Way
Sona Ehlerov´a and Jan Palous
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
241
The Formation and Evolution of Rich Star Clusters in the LMC: NGC 1818
Rebecca A.W. Elson, Gerard Gilmore, Sverre Aarseth, Melvyn Davies,
Steinn Sigurdsson, Basilio Santiago, and Jarrod Hurley
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
243
The Local Group at High Redshift
R. Elson, R. Abraham, T. Kodama, B. Poggianti, and M.S. Oey
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
245
Dwarf Galaxies in the Centaurus A Group: Interacting with their Environment?
T. Fritz, U. Mebold, U. Klein, and S. Cot´e
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
247
Observational discovery of the AGB-bump in the color-magnitude diagram
of nearby galaxies
Carme Gallart and Giampaolo Bertelli
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
249
8
Preface III
Be Stars and the IMF of Young Clusters
Eva K. Grebel, Wolfgang Brandner, and Andrea Dieball
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
251
First Results from the Magellanic Cloud Photometric Survey
Eva K. Grebel, Dennis Zaritsky, Jason Harris, and Ian Thompson
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
253
The Center of the Fornax Cluster: Dwarf Galaxies, cD Halo and Globular Clusters
Michael Hilker, Leopoldo Infante, Markus Kissler–Patig, and Tom Richtler
. . . . . .
255
Identification of Be stars in the Magellanic Clouds
Dirk Hoffmann
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
257
Neutral Hydrogen in a sample of selected Blue Compact Dwarf Galaxies
W.K. Huchtmeier, Gopal Krishna, and A. Petrosian
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
259
NIR-Imaging Of Dwarf Galaxies
Marcus Jutte and Rolf Chini
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
261
Comparison of H i and magnetic field structures in our Galaxy
H.-R. Klockner, P.M.W. Kalberla, and U. Klein
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
263
A CO map of NGC 4449
S. Kohle, U. Klein, C. Henkel, and D.A. Hunter
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
265
A Relation between Box/Peanut Bulges and their Satellite Systems
Rainer Lutticke and Ralf-Jurgen Dettmar
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
267
ROSAT observations of the giant H ii complex N 11 in the LMC
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low, Thomas H. Chang, You-Hua Chu, Sean D. Points,
R. Chris Smith, and Bart P. Wakker
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
269
The young population of the Local Group dwarf galaxy Phoenix
D. Mart´ınez-Delgado and A. Aparicio
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
271
The cool atomic gas in the Large Magellanic Cloud
M. Marx-Zimmer, U. Herbstmeier, F. Zimmer, J.M. Dickey, Staveley-Smith,
and U. Mebold
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
273
CO emission toward H i absorption sources in the Large Magellanic Cloud
M. Marx-Zimmer, F. Zimmer, U. Herbstmeier, Y.-N. Chin, J.M. Dickey, and
U. Mebold
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
275
ISO-[C ii]-investigation of cool H i clouds in the Large Magellanic Cloud
M. Marx-Zimmer, U. Herbstmeier, F. Zimmer, J.M. Dickey, and U. Mebold
. . . . .
277
Multi-Color Surface Photometry of Blue Compact Dwarf Galaxies
K.G. Noeske, P. Papaderos, K.J. Fricke, and T.X. Thuan
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
279
The Near-IR Tully-Fisher Relation for Giant and Dwarf Late-type Galaxies
Daniele Pierini and Richard Tuffs
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
281
The Kinematic Structure of the Supergiant Shell LMC 2
Sean D. Points
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
283
Mass Segregation in Young LMC Clusters: NGC 2004 and NGC 2031
T. Richtler, P. Fischer, M. Mateo, C. Pryor, and S. Murray
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
285
A photometric method to study the Wolf-Rayet content of compact H ii regions
in nearby galaxies
P. Royer, J.-M. Vreux, and J. Manfroid
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
287
Table of Contents
9
Does the low-mass galaxy IC 2574 obey MOND?
F.J. S´anchez-Salcedo and A.M. Hidalgo-G´amez
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
289
U BV RI Photometry of Supergiants in Multiple Star Systems and the OB
Association LH 10
Th. Schmidt-Kaler, J. Gochermann, J. Middendorf, and W.F. Wargau
. . . . . . . . . .
291
Red Supergiants as a Tool for the Study of Galaxies
Th. Schmidt-Kaler
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
293
Photoelectric U BV Photometry of Galactic Foreground and LMC Member Stars:
A New Database
Th. Schmidt-Kaler, J. Gochermann, M.O. Oestreicher, H.-G. Grothues,
C. Tappert, A. Zaum, Th. Berghofer, and H.R. Brugger
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
295
Interacting and merging processes between spirals and dwarf galaxies
Uwe Schwarzkopf and Ralf-Jurgen Dettmar
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
297
Holes and Shells in IC 2574
Fabian Walter, Elias Brinks, and Uli Klein
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
299
H i study of the dwarf galaxy DDO 47
Fabian Walter, Elias Brinks, and Uli Klein
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
301
Bubbles around massive stars in LMC H ii regions
Kerstin Weis and Wolfgang J. Duschl
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
303
Spatial distribution of halo high velocity clouds towards the LMC
Bernhard Wierig and Klaas S. de Boer
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
305
Appendices
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
307
Conference Summary
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Photograph of Participants
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
List of Participants
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Final Programme
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Glossary
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Author Index
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
List of Objects
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Subject Index
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Sample Name Label
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Technical Information
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Erratum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
307
311
313
319
323
327
331
337
EV
EV
EV
EV – only part of the electronic version available at the WWW URL:
http://www.astro.uni-bonn.de/webgk/ws98/cover.html
page numbers refer to the printed version published by
Shaker Verlag, Aachen, ISBN 3-8265-4457-9
Conference Summary
Evan D. Skillman
University of Minnesota
This is not formally a conference summary. Foremost, the hosts are thanked
and congratulated. I then share a few impressions and a gedanken experiment is
proposed.
1. Mandatory Laudatory Comments
It has been my great pleasure to be a participant in this workshop. The Bad Honnef conference
center is certainly an exceptional facility which is conducive to interaction. The conference
organizers have done a superb job in arrangements so that we haven't had to worry about
anything (with the possible exception of the participants who still haven't made it back from
Koln yet), and the result has been a wealth of exchange of ideas. I especially appreciated the
poster review sessions, which helped to act as an introduction to the many exciting results
presented as posters.
This meeting represents a solid endorsement of the Graduiertenkolleg (GK), in both its choice
of science themes and its organization. When I was a first year graduate student, Bart Bok visited
the University of Washington, and repeated over and over, "If you want to study star formation,
study the Magellanic Clouds". At the time he was bemoaning the lack of a millimeter observing
facility in the southern hemisphere - something which has been rectified. The expansion of the
theme from the Magellanic Clouds to dwarf galaxies in general has allowed the work at Bonn
and Bochum to reach an even larger audience.
Having attended an earlier meeting of the GK, I should state that my impressions are all
very positive. The benefits of forming a concentration of studies shared between two university
departments are obvious and impressive. The students have access to numerous first class
facilities, faculty, and many other resources. In fact, one can say that the students have enhanced
access to numerous facilities since the resources available through the GK help to make them
more competitive for observing time.
When I attended the GK meeting in the Fall of 1995, I was impressed with the many ideas
for new projects that students were then forming. Many of those projects have been completed
and were presented at this meeting. Good science is being done. The GK experience has become
an excellent platform from which to launch a career in astrophysics.
2. Some Impressions
Some of the most successful conference summaries that I have witnessed were, in fact, not
summaries at all. Thus, I will not attempt to summarize the whole conference, but rather to
present some of my impressions gained during the workshop. Of course, the overall impression
is that by concentrating on the nearest galaxies one can gain insights unafforded in any other
context. Sometimes we may feel that this is lost in the rush to high redshift, but it certainly
is not lost on the participants of this workshop. Again and again we were treated to stunning
views of the Magellanic Clouds in wavelength after wavelength. There is a lot still to be learned
from the Magellanic Clouds and even more to be learned by pushing for comparable studies of
other nearby galaxies.
Conference Summary
11
Simply because of my recent research activities, many of my impressions are grouped under
the category of stellar populations. First among them is that the HST is an instrument ideally
suited for stellar population studies. The leaps forward afforded by the vast improvement over
ground based resolution has revolutionized our view of galaxies.
Nowhere is this more true than for the dwarf spheroidal galaxies. In the last decade, our
views of these "simple" systems has changed enormously. The variety of star formation histories
is still begging for a simple explanation. The kinematic studies of literally hundreds of stars
(many now with multiple epochs) in most of the dSphs have continued to bear out Aaronson's
bold claim that these are dark matter dominated systems. As spectra of individual stars provide
detailed abundance analyses, we may still be in for more surprises.
I was very impressed by the degree of sophistication in treatment of color-magnitude-diagrams
(CMDs) and the general agreement between independent groups. For example, the presentations
by Aparicio and Gallart showed how the different features in the CMDs could be used in concert
to place strong constraints on star formation histories reaching back to the earliests epochs.
Tolstoy and Hopp independently studied HST data on VII Zw 403 and (1) came to very similar
conclusions about basic properties and (2) agreed on the features in the CMD which were most
difficult to fit with a range of reasonable models.
There was a great deal of attention paid to the detailed structure in the ISM and its origins.
I will never again confuse the terms "bubbles", "super-bubbles", and "supergiant shells".
In the detailed H i imaging of the Magellanic Clouds, we are confronted with the problem of
how best to deal with the high degree of complexity. Does it make sense to divide everything into
categories of "holes" and "concentrations"? Perhaps it is pertinent to reflect back on the work
that Hodge conducted for many decades, providing H ii region luminosity functions (which also
required making decisions about whether to divide features into components or combine features
into single entities). We have seen that Oey has taken these H ii region luminosity functions and
used them to distinguish between "saturated" and "unsaturated" IMFs. While the analogy is
not sound on a physical basis, I wonder that we may not see a similar understanding of the H i
holes and concentrations in the future.
Concerning ISM structure, it is evident that x-ray observations are rapidly playing an increasing
role in our understanding of the phase structure of the ISM. The x-ray images available today
remind me of the H i images that were available a few decades ago. As the spatial and spectral
resolution and sensitivity increase, important new insights are bound to come from this waveband.
Also, concerning the bubbles, I was disappointed that after presenting a detailed star formation
history of the Sextans A dwarf, no one asked about the connection between the stellar population
and the H i hole. I tried to check on this in preparing for this summary talk, but the limited
field of view of the HST WFPC2 observations didn't allow for a clear answer. Recently, van Dyk
has shown evidence from ground based data for a radial gradient in stellar ages that supports a
wind blown bubble model for the central H i deficit.
Moving to galaxy scales, the numerical calculations presented by Mac Low were very impressive.
There has been endless speculation concerning the effects of star formation on the ISM of dwarf
galaxies, and, in particular, the ability of a galaxy to blow away all of its ISM. These new
calculations appear to present a more realistic impression of what is possible and what is not.
This leads to the connected question of what is the H i that is frequently found in the vicinity
of dwarf galaxies. I refer to this H i which is usually at similar velocity but disconnected from the
normal velocity fields, as "floppy disks". Two alternative origins immediately come to mind. It
could be that this material is tidal debris, left over from an interaction or a merger. Alternatively,
this could be material which is primordial in nature and has not yet been incorporated into
the galaxy. Within the limitations of available observing facilities, it is difficult to design an
observational test which distinguishes these two possibilities. It is, however, a very important
question.
12
E.D. Skillman - Appendix A
Table 1. A Summary of Impressions
1) DH TR DE ES
2) MM P BO BIP
3) ET UH FSP
4) NO AA SA
5) XR HY
6) HST BF SPS
IBVC BSS
7)
8) DS EBKS
9) A H&C LHR
10) NN RFP
11) FD TR PG
Finally, I have to admit that one of the most remarkable things that I heard during the entire
workshop was the story of Hunter's graduate school foreign language exam. To pass the exam,
she was required to translate a scientific article written in German. In fact, she translated the
article into Spanish. I was impressed not only with the demonstration of language skills, but the
display of stubborn independence found in astronomers everywhere.
This presentation of my impressions was accompanied by a visual aid. Uli Klein asked me to
reproduce it in my conference summary, so it appears here as Table 1.
3. A Gedanken Experiment
Finally, knowing that most of the workshop participants would be spending one more night at
Bad Honnef, I proposed an exercise to be carried out after dinner. At the time I called it an
exercise, but since this is Germany, it is probably better referred to as a gedanken experiment.
The conference participants were treated to a trip to Koln, the highlight of which was a tour
of the Dom. The Dom had recently experienced some refurbishing work, as evidenced by the
many ton scaffold that was still hanging in the top of the church.
The following exercise occurred to me. What if that scaffold had fallen and crushed some of
the workshop participants?
For this exercise, I assume the following cosmology: (1) there is a heaven, (2) there is a
single deity, (3) when good people go to heaven the deity answers their questions, and (4) all
astronomers are good. The purpose of the exercise is not to quibble with my assumed cosmology,
but, rather, to imagine the questions of the deceased workshop participants as they enter heaven.
To kick off the proposed exercise, I tackled the question what if all of the invited review
speakers were done in?
I started with Jay Gallagher. (The main reason for this was because I wasn't sure how this
would go over and Jay had already left for Munich.) Jay's talk highlighted the degree of the
interconnections between different studies and how observations of dwarf galaxies had impact
on literally every major question in astronomy today. Actually, I think that Jay's question was
very easy. He would ask "What are the answers to everyone else's questions?"
Mario Mateo's talk emphasized the sophistication of the measurements of the dark matter
associated with dSphs and their complicated star formation histories. I imagine that he would
be able to negotiate a second question and the two together would be "What is dark matter,
really?" and "Concerning dwarf spheroidals, where did the gas go?"
Elias Brinks has always been fascinated with detailed images of the distribution of neutral
hydrogen in galaxies. On one hand, the energetics of the holes can be explained by the presence
of stellar clusters. On the other hand, few of the known holes have identifiable stellar populations
in their interiors. Elias would ask "How are these holes formed?"
Conference Summary
13
Deidre Hunter presented detailed observations of star formation on different scales. In one
case, she pointed to a sequence of two generations of star formation and proposed that a third
might be ready to occur. A theory of star formation should have predictive power, and thus,
Deidre might ask "Is there going to be a third generation of star formation?"
You-Hua Chu presented detailed comparisons of the x-ray distributions and the gas kinematics
in the Magellanic Clouds. She questioned the assumptions of pressure equilibrium. You-Hua
would simply demand a complete picture of the multi-phase ISM in the Large Magellanic Cloud.
Jan Palous showed us, through numerical simulations, how ISM bubbles evolve. The calculations
are simplified by taking advantage of certain symmetries. He would like to know if 2-dimensional
simulations give the correct insight into a three dimensional world.
Trinh Thuan presented observations of SBS 0335 − 052, which he proposes is a young galaxy
which is just forming now. He would like to know if it is possible for galaxies to be forming in
the current epoch.
In summary, I would like to thank the organizers one last time for a truly enjoyable workshop.
I congratulate them on their 25th GK meeting and I look forward to the 50th!
List of Participants
Marcus Albrecht (13)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Alessandra Aloisi (67)
Dipartimento di Astronomia,
Universit´a di Bologna
[email protected]
Martin Altmann (11)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Christian Bruns (50)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Luz Marina Cair´os Barreto (57)
Instituto de Astrof´ısica
de Canarias (IAC)
[email protected]
Rolf Chini (62)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Ralph-P. Andersen (5)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Astronomie
(MPIA), Heidelberg
[email protected]
You-Hua Chu (-)
Astronomy Department,
University of Illinois
[email protected]
Antonio Aparicio (40)
Instituto de Astrof´ısica
de Canarias (IAC)
[email protected]
Dominik J. Bomans (12)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Jochen M. Braun (32)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Michael Braun (63)
ESA-VILSPA Villafranca del Castillo
Satellite Tracking Station
[email protected]
Torbjørn Bremnes (29)
Astronomisches Institut der
Universitat Basel
[email protected]
Elias Brinks (39)
Departamento de Astronomia,
Universidad de Guanajuato
[email protected]
Krzysztof Tadeusz Chy zy (23)
Astronomical Observatory,
Jagiellonian University
[email protected]
Maria Rosa Cioni (20)
Sterrewacht Leiden
[email protected]
Oliver-Mark Cordes (60)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Klaas S. de Boer (43)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Ralf-Jurgen Dettmar (71)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Andrea Dieball (54)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Participants
15
Pierre-Alain Duc (44)
European Southern Observatory
(ESO), Garching
[email protected]
Christian Dusterberg (70)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Harm Jan Habing (48)
Sterrewacht Leiden,
Huygens Laboratorium
[email protected]
Andreas Heithausen
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Sona Ehlerov´a (1)
Astronomical Institute,
Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic
[email protected]
Fabian Heitsch (72)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Rebecca A.W. Elson (38)
Institute of Astronomy,
Cambridge
[email protected]
Ana Maria Hidalgo-G´amez (58)
Astronomiska Observatoriet,
Uppsala
[email protected]
Miroslav D. Filipovi´c (66)
University of Western Sydney Nepean /
MPE, Garching
[email protected]
Michael Hilker (31)
Departamento de Astronom´ıa y Astrof´ısica,
P. Universidad Cat´olica, Santiago, Chile
[email protected]
Thomas Fritz (49)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Uta Fritze - v. Alvensleben (45)
Universitats-Sternwarte
Gottingen
[email protected]
John S. Gallagher (24)
Department of Astronomy,
University of Wisconsin at Madison
[email protected]
Carme Gallart (42)
Carnegie Observatories
[email protected]
Eva K. Grebel (68)
UCO/Lick Observatory,
University of California at Santa Cruz
[email protected]
Martin Haas (4)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Astronomie
(MPIA), Heidelberg
[email protected]
Dirk Hoffmann (15)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Ulrich Hopp (14)
Universitats-Sternwarte
Munchen
[email protected]
Walter Huchtmeier (17)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie
(MPIfR), Bonn
[email protected]
Deidre A. Hunter (46)
Lowell Observatory, Flagstaff
[email protected]
Susanne Huttemeister
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Norbert Junkes (61)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie
(MPIfR), Bonn
[email protected]
16
Appendix C
Marcus Jutte (34)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Sungeun Kim (41)
Mount Stromlo and Siding Spring
Observatories
[email protected]
Uli Klein (36)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Hans-Rainer Klockner
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Joachim Koppen (-)
Equipe 'Evolution Galacticque',
Observatoire de Strasbourg
[email protected]
Sven Kohle (53)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Pavel Kroupa (33)
Institut fur Theoretische Astrophysik
der Universitat Heidelberg
[email protected]
Harald Lesch (19)
Universitats-Sternwarte
Munchen
[email protected]
Rainer Lutticke (51)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Mordecai-Mark Mac Low (3)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Astronomie
(MPIA), Heidelberg
[email protected]
David Mart´ınez-Delgado (55)
Instituto de Astrof´ısica
de Canarias (IAC)
[email protected]
Monika Marx-Zimmer
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Mario L. Mateo (8)
Department of Astronomy,
University of Michigan
[email protected]
Ulrich Mebold
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
David Israel M´endez Alcaraz (56)
Instituto de Astrof´ısica
de Canarias (IAC)
[email protected]
Andrea Moneti (30)
ESA-VILSPA Villafranca del Castillo
Satellite Tracking Station
[email protected]
Kai Noeske (28)
Universitats-Sternwarte
Gottingen
[email protected]
Marion Siang-Li Oey (74)
Institute of Astronomy,
Cambridge
[email protected]
Jan Palous (10)
Astronomical Institute, Academy of
Sciences of the Czech Republic
[email protected]
Nino Panagia (7)
Space Telescope Science Institute
(STScI), Baltimore
[email protected]
Daniele Pierini (18)
Max-Planck-Institut fur Kernphysik,
Heidelberg
[email protected]
Sean Points (52)
Astronomy Department,
University of Illinois
[email protected]
Participants
17
Gotthard Richter
Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam
(AIP)
[email protected]
Philipp Richter
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Tom Richtler (16)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Andreas Rieschick (64)
Institut fur Theoretische Physik und
Astrophysik, Kiel
[email protected]
Martino Romaniello (69)
STScI, Baltimore, USA and
Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa, Italy
[email protected]
Pierre Royer (47)
Institut d'astrophysique de Li`ege
[email protected]
Theodor Schmidt-Kaler
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
Chris Taylor (21)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Christian Theis (65)
Institut fur Theoretische Physik und
Astrophysik, Kiel
[email protected]
Trinh X. Thuan (26)
Department of Astronomy,
University of Virginia
[email protected]
Eline Tolstoy (25)
European Southern Observatory
(ESO), Garching
[email protected]
Monica Tosi (22)
Osservatorio Astronomico
di Bologna
[email protected]
Hugo van Woerden (59)
Kapteyn Institute, Groningen
[email protected]
Fabian Walter (35)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Uwe Schwarzkopf (6)
Astronomisches Institut der
Ruhr-Universitat Bochum
[email protected]
Kerstin Weis (2)
Institut fur Theoretische Astrophysik,
Heidelberg
[email protected]
Wilhelm Seggewiss (73)
Sternwarte der Universitat Bonn /
Observatorium Hoher List
[email protected]
Evan D. Skillman (27)
Astronomy Department,
University of Minnesota
[email protected]
Axel Weiss (37)
Radioastronomisches Institut der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
Bernhard Wierig (9)
Sternwarte der
Universitat Bonn
[email protected]
18
Appendix C
Hans Zinnecker
Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam
(AIP)
[email protected]
The list above shows the names of the participants, the numbers belonging to the photograph on
p. 311 (in brackets, ciphers for invited speakers additionally set in boldface), the names of the institutes
and the E-Mail addresses. The full list of participants including all links is available at the WWW URL:
http://www.astro.uni-bonn.de/ webgk/ws98/part a tbl.html.
|
astro-ph/0212055 | 1 | 0212 | 2002-12-03T04:18:52 | Relativistic Effects on the Appearance of a Clothed Black Hole | [
"astro-ph"
] | For an accretion disk around a black hole, the strong relativistic effects affect every aspect of the radiation from the disk, including its spectrum, light-curve, and image. This work investigates in detail how the images of a thin disk around a black hole will be distorted, and what the observer will see from different viewing angles and in different energy bands. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
RELATIVISTIC EFFECTS ON THE APPEARANCE
OF A CLOTHED BLACK HOLE
Xiaoling Zhang, S.Nan Zhang, Yuxin Feng, Yangsen Yao
Physics Department, University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, AL, USA
National Space Science and Technology Center, Huntsville, AL, USA
[email protected]
Abstract
For an accretion disk around a black hole, the strong relativistic effects
affect every aspect of the radiation from the disk, including its spectrum,
light-curve, and image. This work investigates in detail how the images
will be distorted, and what the observer will see from different viewing
angles and in different energy bands.
Keywords: Relativistic effects, black hole -- image
Introduction
Black holes are believed to be very common in the universe. A black
hole itself, as indicated by its name, is invisible. But the interactions
between a black hole and other objects can generate spectacular phe-
nomena and make the hole "visible".
A "clothed black hole", a black hole with an accretion disk (Luminet,
1978),
is one of the most important laboratories to study relativity.
Strong relativistic modifications on energy spectra, light curves, power
spectra etc., have been observed with the many detectors on the ground
and in space, yet we have never observed any black hole image due to
the limited spatial resolution of currently available instruments. People
have been curious about what a black hole or a clothed black hole would
look like. Luminet (Luminet 1978) studied the Schwarzschild black hole
case and gave a simulated photograph of a spherical black hole with
a thin accretion disk. Fanton et al.(1997) developed a semi-analytical
approach and a code of calculating photon trajectories in Kerr metric,
calculated the redshift maps of both direct and secondary images, and
the temperature map. We used their code in the calculation of the disk
images in this work.
1
2
The observable disk image is actually the flux map. However, the to-
tal flux (in the whole energy range) map might not be a proper object,
because each instrument has its sensitive energy range; it can only de-
tect photons in this range, thus instruments sensitive to different energy
ranges will see different pictures.
In section 1 we demonstrate how the relativistic effects in a Kerr space
will work on various elements of a black hole system. In section 2 we
give the images in different energy ranges, followed by summary and
discussion.
1.
Red-shift maps of disks
Figures 1, 2 and 3 are all redshift maps. Figures 1 shows the redshift
c2 ) and an inner
maps of disks with an outer radius 20R
radius as the last stable orbit. For a small viewing angle, there is only
significant (gravitational) red-shift in the inner region; whereas for large
viewing angles, Doppler shift becomes important, significant blue- and
red-shift can be seen on the whole disk. (It would be clearer in color
figures.) Also, for large viewing angles, far end of the disk bends toward
the observer.
g (R
GM
≡
g
Red-shift map and over-
Figure 1.
all shape of accretion disks around black
holes. g is the ratio between the observed
energy of a photon and the energy in the
rest frame of the disk. Top to bottom:
θ = 5◦, 45◦, 70◦, 85◦, θ is the inclination
angle (the angle between the normal of the
disk and the line of sight). Left to right:
a = 0.01, 0.5, 0.998, where a is the specific
angular momentum of the black hole. The
white zones stand for the regions with zero
red-shift (following Fanton et al.(1997) ).
Left-hand side of the disk is approaching
the observer and blue-shifted.
Figure 2 shows the overall shape of disks due to Doppler and gravita-
tional effects at a large inclination angle (85◦). The inner radius takes
the value of the last stable circular orbit.
In the first row, the white
circles and ellipses show the last stable orbit. The inner contours are
greatly distorted by the focusing effect.
Figure 3 shows the comparison between Shwarzschild black holes and
Kerr black holes, which shows clearly additional distortion due to frame-
dragging effect. Spin results in a smaller last stable orbit, and the inner
contour changes from symmetric for a = 0.01 to asymmetric for a =
Relativistic Effects on the Appearance of a Clothed Black Hole
3
0.998. Therefore in principle, we can tell a rotating black hole from a
non-rotating one from the inner contours of their accrection disks.
Redshift maps for disks
Figure 2.
at inclination angle 85◦ with different
outer radii. Top to bottom: disks with
outer radii 10Rg, 20Rg, 100Rg. Left to
right: a = 0.01, 0.5, 0.998. See text for
details.
Redshift maps for 10 Rg
Figure 3.
disks with different inner radii. Top
inner radii are the radii of the
row:
last stable orbits; Bottom row:
inner
radii are 6 Rg. Left to right: a =
0.01, 0.5, 0.998.
2.
Images of thin accretion disks
With the redshift map, we calculated images of accretion disks around
black holes in several energy ranges. In the calculations, we assume 1)
the disks are standard thin disks (Shakura & Sunyaev, 1973); and 2) lo-
cal radiation results from gravitational potential energy release through
blackbody radiation (Page & Thorne 1974). The inner disk radii are the
respective last stable orbits.
a) a = 0.01
b) a = 0.5
Figure 4. Disk images of 20Rg disks for
different spin of the black holes, viewing
in certain energy ranges.
In all figures,
same energy range in a column, and same
inclination angle in a row. Left to right:
0.01 -- 100, 0.1 -- 1, 1 -- 2, 2 -- 5, 5 -- 10. Top to
bottom: θ = 5◦, 45◦, 70◦, 85◦, 85◦. The
last image row of c) is the same as the
row above it, expect that it is in log scale.
c) also shows the scale bar.
c) a = 0.998
4
In all the images, energy ranges are in the unit of the energy cor-
responding to the maximum temperature in a non-rotating black hole
case. For example, if the maximum temperature in a non-rotating black
hole case is 1 keV, then the above energy ranges are 0.1 to 1 keV, 1
to 2 keV etc.. The maximum temperature in the extremal Kerr black
hole case is about 5 keV. The images show the brightness in gray scale,
with energy flux linearly (if not otherwise specified) mapped to the [0,1]
shown on the scale bar in Figure 4c.
Figure 5. Disk images for 100Rg disks
in the energy range 0.5 -- 2. Top to
θ = 5◦, 45◦, 70◦, 85◦.
bottom:
Left
to right:
a = 0.01, 0.5, 0.998 respec-
tively.
0.5 to 2 keV is the energy
range of NASA's next generation mission
MAXIM (Micro-Arcsecond X-ray Imag-
ing Mission) pathfinder. (The images in
this figure have a lower contrast than the
other images.)
3.
Summary and discussion
We studied the images of standard thin accretion disks around black
holes under the strong relativistic effects. The expected images for sys-
tems with different black hole spin, viewing from different viewing angles
and in different energy bands are given. The spin of the black hole not
only determines how close the disk can extend to the center, but also
causes additional distortion due to the dragging of the frame.
The secondary image are left out because in most cases it will be
blocked by the disk, though it might be important in some cases.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Dr. Fanton for providing us his
code of calculating the redshift map and line profile of a thin disk. This
study is supported in part by NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center and
through NASA's Long Term Space Astrophysics Program.
References
Cadez, A., C. Fanton, and M. Calvani, M. (1998). New Astronomy, 3, (No. 8), 647
Fanton, Claudio, Massimo Calvani, Fernando de Felice, and Andrej Cadez. (1997).
PASJ, 49, 159
Luminet, J.-P.. (1978). A&A, 75, 228
Page, D.N. & K.S. Thorne. 1974. ApJ, 191, 499
Shakura, N. I. & Sunyaev, R. A.. 1973. A&A, 24, 337
This figure "figure1.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure2.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure3.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure4a.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure4b.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure4c-scaleBar.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure4c.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
This figure "figure5.png" is available in "png"(cid:10) format from:
http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/0212055v1
|
astro-ph/9411021 | 1 | 9411 | 1994-11-05T17:23:17 | The EINSTEIN On-Line Service | [
"astro-ph"
] | The Einstein On-Line Service (EOLS) is a simple menu-driven system which provides an intuitive method of querying over one hundred database catalogs. In addition, the EOLS contains over 30 CDROMs of images from the Einstein X-ray Observatory which are available for downloading. The EOLS provides all of our databases to the NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) and our documents which describe each table are written in the ADS format. In conjunction with the IAU working group on Radioastronomical Databases, the EOLS serves as an experimental platform for on-line access to radio source catalogs. The number of entries in these catalogs exceeds half a million. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Proc. Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems { IV, Baltimore, Sept. {,
ASP Conference Series
( )
, eds. H. Payne, D. Shaw, & J. Hayes
The EINSTEIN On-Line Service
D. E. Harris and C. S. Grant
Center for Astrophysics, Garden St., Cambridge, MA
H. Andernach
Observatoire de Lyon, F{ Saint-Genis-Laval Cedex, France
Abstract. The Einstein On-Line Service (EOLS) is a simple menu-
driven system which provides an intuitive method of querying over one
hundred database catalogs.
In addition, the EOLS contains over
CDROMs of images from the Einstein X-ray Observatory which are avail-
able for downloading. The EOLS provides all of our databases to the
NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) and our documents which de-
scribe each table are written in the ADS format. In conjunction with the
IAU working group on Radioastronomical Databases, the EOLS serves as
an experimental platform for on-line access to radio source catalogs. The
number of entries in these catalogs exceeds half a million.
.
INTRODUCTION
In January , SAO established an on-line service to help astronomers prepare
ROSAT proposals by providing access to the preliminary source list from the
\Einstein Observatory Catalog of IPC X-ray Sources". In the intervening years,
we have updated the source list, added to the documentation, included many
more Einstein databases as well as a number of tables from other wavebands,
provided access to images for downloading from all of the Einstein CDROMs, and
installed new software for more sophisticated (cid:12)ltering and retrieval. Although we
have improved the functionality and made signi(cid:12)cant additions to the databases,
we still maintain a simple menu interface accessible from any type of terminal.
An instruction manual does not exist: the on-line help facility provides the
necessary information.
. DATABASE RETRIEVAL OPTIONS
The EOLS provides three options for data retrieval. The DATABASE QUERY
is a menu-driven system which allows users to build their own query and select
which output columns should be retrieved. The QUICK QUERY is a canned
output format which requires only one speci(cid:12)cation of selection criteria, and
returns up to characters per row (preselected by us). The MULTIPLE QUICK
QUERY is a positional search on several tables. We have endeavored to make
the selection process simple and the easiest option is to select one or more a(cid:14)nity
groups. However, the user can specify particular tables from di(cid:11)erent groups by
choosing the \Custom" option or choose to select all tables.
Here are of the rows retrieved from catalogs with a single query:
--------------------------------- eos_source ----------------------------------
SEQ FLDCAT
RA
DEC +/-COR C/S
# # # h m s d ' ''asccts/sec +/- S/N SIZCORRECOID
------------------------------------------------------------------
.+ . e- .e- .
.
Q
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total: rows retrieved.
------------------------------ qso_veron ------------------------------
RA
DEC
radio fdr fdr
name h m s d ' ''
z vmagsource? (cgs) (cgs)
----------------------------------------------------------------
.+ ..
yes. e- . e+
.+ ..
yes. e- . e+
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total: rows retrieved.
----------------------------- rad_cm_bwe ------------------------------
RA
DEC
S(.GHz)ExtensionSpectralSeparation
Name
h m s d ' ''
(mJy)
Flag Index
Flag
------------------------------------------------------------------
+ . +
- .
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total: rows retrieved.
--------------------------------- rad_gb ----------------------------------
RA
RA+/-
DEC
DEC+/-S(.)S +/-EXTWARNCONFFWHMFWHM PA
h m s sec d
' '' arcs (mJy) (mJy)FLGFLAGFLAGMAJ MIN
----------------------------------------------------------------
. .+
. . -
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total: rows retrieved.
---------------------------------- rad_pks ----------------------------------
+/-
fdr fdr fdr
RA
DEC
arcs id mag
z
(Jy)
(Jy)
(Jy) h m s d ' '' alias
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Xs
.
.+ C .
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total: rows retrieved.
. DOWNLOADING X-RAY IMAGES
All of our Einstein CDROMs are permanently available for downloading images.
They may be obtained with ftp or with the VMS \copy" command. As of
June , we have:
The E Catalog of IPC X-ray Sources: FITS smoothed arrays
The Database of HRI X-ray Images: FITS photon arrays
The IPC Slew Survey: Jan
The HRI Images in Event List Format: FITS binary tables
The IPC Images in Event List Format: FITS binary tables
The IPC Unscreened Data Archive: FITS binary tables
. OTHER FEATURES
(cid:15) Low maintenance operation.
(cid:15) The ADS connection { The EOLS provides all of our databases to the
NASA Astrophysics Data System (ADS) and our documents which de-
scribe each table are written in the ADS format.
(cid:15) DOCUMENTATION { Documentation is available for each database table
and provides extensive detail in some areas (e.g. Vol of the IPC catalog),
archival material such as the Einstein Revised User's Manual, and \Help"
(cid:12)les which provide information on system operations.
(cid:15) COMMUNICATION { This section of the EOLS features a bulletin board
(includes ROSAT news) and an email facility for sending yourself docu-
ments and the results of database searches.
(cid:15) TOOLS { Precession of coordinates and column densities of galactic HI
(north of DEC = - degrees) are available.
(cid:15) ACCESS { There are four methods to log onto the EOLS:
. internet { telnet einline.harvard.edu
. decnet { set host
. modem { dial () - or -
. mosaic { http://hea-www.harvard.edu/einline/einline.html
Once successful, the login name is \einline", no password required.
NB: Since UNIX is case sensitive, make sure you use lower case when logging in!
. THE RADIO SOURCE CATALOG INITIATIVE
For many years we have noticed the di(cid:14)culty of (cid:12)nding radio source data in
public archives or on-line databases. In , the IAU Working Group on Ra-
dioastronomical Databases was formed with one of us (H.A.) as the chair. By
now the WG has secured some catalogs of radio sources with altogether
(cid:24) , entries. Although the working group recognized that a long term so-
lution to this problem should be provided by an on-going commitment from
the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO) or the Strasbourg Astro-
nomical Data Center (CDS), the EOLS volunteered to serve as an experimental
platform for access to the catalog collection. This \provisional" solution is now
by far the most complete on-line facility for radio source data, o(cid:11)ering access
to radio catalogs with , searchable entries. Contributions of new data
tables are welcome, but can only be incorporated into the system if authors
provide proper documentation and formatted ASCII tables.
. STATISTICS OF USAGE
The histogram shows the average number of logins per month from outside the
Center for Astrophysics from to mid .
Figure .
Logins per month from outside CfA: {
|
astro-ph/0303280 | 1 | 0303 | 2003-03-13T20:37:45 | A Turbulent Interstellar Medium Origin of the Binary Period Distribution | [
"astro-ph"
] | In this paper, we present a semi-empirical model of isolated binary star formation. This model includes the effects of turbulence in the initial state of the gas, and has binary orbital parameters consistent with observation. Our fundamental assumption is that the angular momenta of binary star systems is directly related to the net angular momentum induced by turbulence in parent molecular cloud cores. The primary results of this model are as follows. (i) A quantitative prediction of the initial width of the binary period distribution ($\sigma_{\log {P}_d} = 1.6 - 2.1$ for a star formation efficiency in the range $\epsilon_* = 0.1 - 0.9$). (ii) A robust, negative anticorrelation of binary period and mass ratio. (iii) A robust, positive correlation of binary period and eccentricity. (iv) A robust prediction that the binary separation of low-mass systems should be more closely separated than those of solar-mass or larger. These predictions are in good agreement with observations of PMS binary systems with periods $P > 10^3$ d, which account for the majority of all binaries.
We conclude with a brief discussion of the implications of our results for observational and theoretical studies of multiple star formation. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A Turbulent Interstellar Medium Origin of the Binary Period
Distribution
Robert T. Fisher
[email protected]
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Mail Code L-023, 7000 East Avenue, Livermore
Ca. 94550
Received
;
accepted
3
0
0
2
r
a
M
3
1
1
v
0
8
2
3
0
3
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
-- 2 --
ABSTRACT
In this paper, we present a semi-empirical model of isolated binary star for-
mation. This model includes the effects of turbulence in the initial state of the
gas, and has binary orbital parameters consistent with observation. Our funda-
mental assumption is that the angular momenta of binary star systems is directly
related to the net angular momentum induced by turbulence in parent molecular
cloud cores. The primary results of this model are as follows. (i) A quantitative
prediction of the initial width of the binary period distribution (σlog Pd = 1.6−2.1
for a star formation efficiency in the range ǫ∗ = 0.1− 0.9). (ii) A robust, negative
anticorrelation of binary period and mass ratio. (iii) A robust, positive correla-
tion of binary period and eccentricity. (iv) A robust prediction that the binary
separation of low-mass systems should be more closely separated than those of
solar-mass or larger. These predictions are in good agreement with observations
of PMS binary systems with periods P > 103 d, which account for the majority
of all binaries.
We conclude with a brief discussion of the implications of our results for
observational and theoretical studies of multiple star formation.
Subject headings: stars: formation, binaries:general, gravitation, hydrodynamics
1.
Introduction
To fully elucidate the mechanisms underlying the origin of binary systems, it is crucial
to compare theory with observations of the field and of nearby star-forming regions.
However, a myriad of complex physical effects have been advanced by theorists to account
for the formation and evolution of binary and multiple star systems, including fragmentation
-- 3 --
(Hoyle 1953; Inutsuka & Miyama 1992), turbulence (Klein, Fisher, & McKee 2001; Bate,
Bonnell, & Bromm 2002), ideal magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) (Galli et al.
2001),
non-ideal MHD, including ambipolar diffusion (Mouschovias 1977; Boss 2000), radiative
transfer (Boss et al.
2000), dust physics (Whitworth, Boffin, & Francis 1998), tidal
torquing (Larson 2002), capture (Clarke & Pringle 1991), competitive accretion (Bonnell,
Bate, Clarke, & Pringle 1997), and accretion disk processes (Laughlin & Bodenheimer
1994). However, to date, no simulation has included all of these varied physical effects, and
few have been run to a substantial evolutionary state. Moreover, as other authors have
pointed out (Larson 2001), once one includes the effect of turbulence, star formation is
inherently a stochastic process, implying that many such simulations need to be performed
before their results can be meaningfully compared to observation.
In this paper, we present a simplified, semi-empirical model of isolated binary star
formation. This model includes the effects of turbulence in the initial state of the gas, and
has binary orbital parameters consistent with observation. Our fundamental assumption
is that the angular momenta of binary star systems is directly related to the net angular
momentum induced by turbulence in parent molecular cloud cores. We do not require that
the binary angular momentum be equal to that of its parent core; indeed, we shall find
that angular momentum loss from the initial core is crucial in determining the median
binary period, as previous authors suggested (Simon 1992; Bodenheimer 1995). While we
do not in this work determine the mechanism underlying the loss of angular momentum,
we find that we can describe a number of observed properties simply by specifying that the
efficiency of transfer of mass and angular momentum from the initial gaseous core to the
final binary are both constant. This model therefore provides an excellent framework with
which to examine the importance of turbulence in the context of isolated star formation,
and to explore the role which the stochastic nature of the initial turbulent state has on the
statistical properties of binary systems. While it is certainly true that a number of other
-- 4 --
physical effects other than turbulence and angular momentum dissipation may play a role
in the star formation process, our model can elucidate their relative importance by serving
as a strawman against which other results can be compared.
The paper begins with an overview of observational evidence (§2), including both
pre-stellar molecular cloud core (§2.1) and binary (§2.2) properties. Next, we describe
our pre-stellar core model in §3. In §4, we present the methodology which connects the
pre-stellar core model with the binary properties. The results of this model are detailed
in §5. We conclude the main body of the paper with a discussion of the implications of
this semi-empirical model for observational and theoretical studies of star formation (§6).
Lastly, appendix A includes an elementary derivation of characteristic binary scales, in
terms of their orbital parameters.
2. Observational Evidence
2.1. Pre-Stellar Core Properties
2.1.1. Density Structure
The observations of Motte & Andr´e (2001) consisted of a complete 1.3 mm survey of
both pre-stellar cores and protostellar envelopes using the IRAM 30m telescope and the
MPIfR bolometer array (MAMBO). Their observations resolved structures from 1,500 AU
to 15,000 AU. Motte & Andr´e (2001) concluded that their observations of pre-stellar core
backgrounds were flatter than predicted by a singular isothermal sphere model (Shu 1977),
but were consistent with Bonnor-Ebert spheres (Bonnor 1957; Ebert 1955).
-- 5 --
2.1.2. Velocity Structure on the Molecular Cloud Core Scale
In 1981, in an extension of an earlier paper (Larson 1979) focusing on the large-scale
structure of the interstellar medium, Larson (1981) published a seminal paper on the
internal velocity dispersion in molecular clouds. Using data already published in the
literature in a wide variety of studies, he accumulated about 50 data points for a number of
different star forming regions, on scales ranging from 10−1 to 102 pc. He established scaling
laws for both the mean density and the total internal velocity dispersion over projected
lengthscales on the sky. Plotting the total internal velocity dispersion (sum of thermal and
non-thermal linewidths) versus the maximum projected linear size of the region, he found
that the internal velocity dispersion obeyed a power law of the form
σ1D(km s−1) = 1.10 L(pc)0.38
(1)
Here we have designated the one-dimensional linewidth dispersion, as inferred from
velocities along the line of sight by σ1D, to properly distinguish it from the fully 3D velocity
dispersion.
Significantly, the power law nature of the turbulent linewidth-size scaling laws supports
the premise, which Larson originally suggested, that over a wide range of scales, the
observed interstellar turbulence is part of a scale-free hierarchy of turbulent eddies. This
scale-free cascade should extend all the way down to about the characteristic scale where
such eddies are damped -- either the minimum Jeans mass in the cloud (Larson 1995) or
the ion-neutral damping length (Myers & Lazarian 1998), depending on whether thermal
or magnetic damping effects dominate, which in turn depends on the relative strength of
the magnetic field and the ionization state of the gas.
Subsequent authors investigated the linewidth-size scaling relationship in more detail
for molecular cloud cores using more precise techniques. In particular, Larson's original
-- 6 --
study contained only 4 cores observed with rather poor angular resolution, and in the
absence of actual data, made blanket assumptions regarding the kinetic temperature of the
gas used in computing the local soundspeed. Leung, Kutner, & Mead (1982) and Myers
(1983) re-investigated Larson's linewidth- size relationship and found the exponent closer to
1/2, rather than 1/3. In the most extensive study of molecular cloud cores to date, Jijina,
Myers, & Adams (1999) studied 264 cores mapped in NH3 in a wide variety of regions
and environmental conditions. They conclude that the linewidth-size relationship for all
cores has an exponent of .63 ± .10, though a slight difference of low statistical significance
existed between subsamples with embedded IRAS sources (exponent .49 ± .12) and without
(exponent .83± .18). Moreover, Jijina, Myers, & Adams (1999) found a significant variation
in the median value of the non-thermal linewidth ∆vN T across regions : from a value of 0.22
km/s in Taurus (thermal linewidth median ∆vT = .44 km/s), to a non-thermal linewidth
∆vN T median value of .86 km/s in Orion A (thermal linewidth median ∆vT = .58 km/s).
Over all regions, cores without IRAS embedded sources or clusters had ∆vN T /∆vT = .65+.35
−.25
(within one quartile of the median). Cores without clusters, but with IRAS embedded
sources had ∆vN T /∆vT = 1.0+.40
−.30. Cores with clusters had higher non-thermal linewidths
still.
We note that the most complete observations to date suggest that even in low-mass
cores, the level of turbulent support is comparable to that of thermal support, although
there are large variations both within and across individual star-forming regions.1 Moreover,
there is little evidence that the non-thermal linewidths diminish during the process of star
formation; if anything, the non-thermal linewidths in cores with IRAS embedded sources
is higher than in their non-IRAS counterparts. However, we note that the non-thermal
1Although these cores are often termed "quiescent", such a designation is somewhat
misleading.
-- 7 --
linewidths measured in cores with embedded objects will in general also include infall
motion towards one or more protostars in a complex flow field. Such infall motions are
extremely difficult, if not impossible, to separate from turbulent motions on the scale of
the core without a full spatial mapping of the velocity field, and so it is remains unclear
(from an observational standpoint) what the timescale for the dissipation of turbulence is,
or indeed, even whether turbulence decays or increases during star formation.
2.2. Binary Star Properties
2.2.1. Binarity Fraction
Prompted by inconsistencies in multiplicity fractions in earlier surveys (Kuiper 1935,
1942; Jaschek & Jaschek 1957; Petrie 1960; Jaschek & G´omez 1970), Abt & Levy (1976)
determined the multiplicity fraction of a sample of 135 bright field stars of types F3-G2,
and found a binarity fraction (the fraction of all primaries having a detectable secondary
companion) of 57%. Later, Duquennoy & Mayor (1991) (DM91 hereafter) using a complete
sample of 164 primary G dwarf stars with types F7-G9, found a remarkably similar binarity
fraction of 58% (although their conclusions regarding the period distribution differed
substantially; see below).
2.2.2. Period Distribution
DM91 demonstrated that the binary periods in a complete sample of field G dwarf stars
fits a broad log-normal distribution remarkably well, with a median period of log ¯Pd = 4.8
and a standard deviation of log σPd = 2.3, where Pd is the period measured in days. DM91's
result is substantially different than the median period log ¯Pd = 3.7 found previously by
Abt & Levy (1976), whose survey was biased by their use of a magnitude-limited sample.
-- 8 --
Similar period distributions were found for field K dwarfs (Mayor, Duquennoy, Halbwachs,
& Mermilliod 1992) and field M dwarfs (Fischer & Marcy 1992), though the K dwarf sample
was found to have a somewhat narrower distribution (log σPd = 1.9).
Mathieu (1994) compiled data of pre-main sequence (PMS) binaries extant at that
time. While the statistics of PMS binaries are not as complete as those in the field, the
compiled PMS binary period distribution appears to fit a log-normal distribution similar to
that of Duquennoy & Mayor (1991). More recently, other observers have begun to produce
tentative evidence in favor of the hypothesis that the period distribution itself varies from
region to region. For instance, in observations of Upper Scorpius A and B, Brandner
& Koehler (1998) argue that the period distribution median varies significantly between
the two regions, with wider binaries being preferred in the low-mass star forming region.
Similarly, Scally, Clarke, & McCaughrean (1999) argue that a deficiency of wide (a > 1000
AU) binaries exists in Orion. However, such studies of individual regions and distribution
tails reduce the counting statistics by necessity (some 20 systems in the case of Brandner
and Koehler's study; some 3 systems in the case of Scally et al's study), and so we must
consider them with some caution.
To date, the period distribution has not been quantitatively explained by theory.
Mouschovias (1977) envisioned dense cores as non-turbulent, highly subcritical, slowly
contracting regions initially endowed with angular velocity induced by galactic shear. In
his picture, magnetic braking becomes inefficient at some critical density at which the core
becomes supercritical, and thereafter the angular momentum of the gas is conserved during
the collapse. He invoked variations in this critical density parameter across all star-forming
regions to explain the broad variation in the binary period distribution. However, it
remains unclear whether this picture is quantitatively consistent with the observed period
distribution.
-- 9 --
More recently, Larson (2002) offered the possibility that tidal interactions among
binaries in a stellar cluster would tend to transfer angular momentum among the
binaries, and thereby broaden the period distribution. However, Kroupa & Burkert
(2001) demonstrated that even under extreme conditions (stellar densities ∼ 106 pc−3),
gravitational encounters were not able to explain the observed breadth of the binary
period distribution. Indeed, even when a very small amount of broadening of the period
distribution was obtained in their densest configurations, disruption dominated over
broadening, so that the binarity fraction dropped from an initial value of unity to ∼ .2
in about 3 · 104 yr, in sharp conflict with observation. Indeed, Kroupa & Burkert (2001)
concluded that the binary period distribution was a remnant of the initial conditions of star
formation, and was not due to subsequent evolution. However, Bate, Bonnell, & Bromm
(2002) found that close systems could form in a gas-rich environment through dynamical
friction. A corollary of Bate's findings is that in a turbulent environment, the angular
momentum dissipation rate should be sensitive to initial conditions -- as had been suggested
earlier by Larson (2001). We will return to this point later (§6).
2.2.3. Eccentricity Distribution
Another important diagnostic of binary stars is the eccentricity distribution. DM91
divided their binary catalog into short (P < 103 d) and long (P > 103 d) samples. They
found that while the short-period binaries had a distribution which peaked at e = .3,
long-period binaries followed a distribution which was roughly linear (f (e) = 2e), up to
eccentricities of about .8, at which point the eccentricity distribution tapers off significantly.
Mathieu (1994) reviewed the data extant at that time for MS and PMS binaries,
and compared plots of the eccentricity e versus period P for each population of binaries
separately. One of his principal findings was that the eccentricities of longer period systems
-- 10 --
(both MS and PMS) were positively correlated with the period of the system, to periods
of at least 103 days. Moreover, the MS eccentricity distribution appears to be roughly
consistent with the PMS eccentricity distribution. This suggests that the eccentricities of
MS binaries are established by age of the PMS stage (about 106 years) or earlier.
2.3. Mass Ratio
An accurate observational determination of the the mass ratio distribution requires a
number of corrections due to observational biases. DM91 found a mass ratio distribution
which was consistent with drawing both individual members of the binary system
independently from the IMF, and could be fitted to a Gaussian. In particular, their mass
ratio distribution exhibited no maximum towards q = 1. However, a later paper (Mazeh,
Goldberg, Duquennoy, & Mayor 1992), pointed out that once additional selection-effect
corrections for spectroscopic binaries with periods less than 3 · 103 d are taken into account,
the resultant period distribution for short period binaries is nearly flat, with a slight rise
towards q = 1.
3.
Initial Molecular Cloud Core Model Formulation
3.1. Overview
Our model for turbulent molecular cloud cores will consist of two essential elements.
The first, the background density model (§3.2) is based upon a Bonnor-Ebert density
profile of isothermal gas, with pressure support enhanced through turbulent pressure. As
we will show, this density profile is consistent both with Larson's mean density relationship
and with resolved observations of molecular cloud cores (§2.1.1). The second element, a
turbulent velocity field (§3.3), is superposed upon this background density. This velocity
-- 11 --
field is consistent with Larson's linewidth-size relation (§2.1.2).
In contrast to our assumptions of isothermal gasdynamics and a turbulent velocity
field, other authors have have assumed that turbulence can effectively be accounted for by
using a logotropic (McLaughlin & Pudritz 1997) or polytropic pressure component (McKee
& Holliman 1999), and derived density profiles for their models under the assumption that
gravity was balanced by the thermal and turbulent pressure of the core. Our approach
differs fundamentally in that it is essentially a non-equilibrium model -- while the kinetic,
thermal, and gravitational energies are in virial balance, our cores are never static. This
difference is absolutely critical in the context of the current work, since we seek to tie the
binary properties to the angular momentum of the turbulent model cores.
3.2. Background Density Model
Since our models include turbulent support, we define an effective soundspeed
ceff, which includes contributions from both thermal and turbulent pressure, added in
quadrature. Because pressure depends on only the 1D rms of the velocity, we include the
one-dimensional turbulent support through the effective soundspeed :
ceff = cisos1 +(cid:18) M√3(cid:19)2
(2)
It is both convenient and physically meaningful to scale the radius r to a dimensionless
unit ξ = r/r0, where r0 proportional to the Jeans length at the central density ρc and to
scale the density itself to a dimensionless unit Θ in terms of the central density :
r0 =
ceff√4πGρc
=
ξ = r/r0,
ceff
p4πGχρedge
(3)
(4)
-- 12 --
and
Θ = ρ/ρc,
(5)
where ρedge is the edge density of the core, and χ = ρc/ρedge is the density contrast between
the center of the core and its edge. Combining the Poisson equation with the momentum
equation, assuming the pressure support is derived from a polytropic equation of state, and
demanding both spherical symmetry and force balance in the radial direction, gives us the
Lane-Emden equation :
1
ξ2
d
dξ (cid:18)ξ2 dΘ
dξ(cid:19) + Θn = 0
(6)
where γ = 1 + 1/n, and γ is the ratio of specific heats. We take the boundary conditions
at ξ = 0 as Θ(ξ = 0) = 1 and Θ′(ξ = 0) = 0, appropriate for centrally condensed initial
conditions. While there is no closed-form solution to (6) for γ = 1, we utilize a simple
analytic approximation originally suggested by Natarajan & Lynden-Bell (1997):
Θ(ξ) =(cid:18) A
C 2 + ξ2 −
B
D2 + ξ2(cid:19)
(7)
where the parameters A, B, C, and D are numerical constants parameterizing the solution.
Natarajan & Lynden-Bell (1997) suggest A = 50, B = 48, C = √10, D = √12. We assume
the density distribution is critically stable, with a contrast χ ≃ 14 (Bonnor 1957; Ebert
1955). The resultant approximation accurately describes the critical Bonnor-Ebert sphere
to within 1% at all spatial points.
In the absence of turbulence, a critically stable core will have the familiar Bonnor-Ebert
mass and radius (Bonnor 1957; Ebert 1955) :
Mth = 1.18
Rth = .485
c3
iso
pG3ρedge
ciso
pGρedge
(8)
(9)
-- 13 --
Where ρedge is the edge density of the core.
Using the effective soundspeed in place of the isothermal soundspeed, we have
expressions for the turbulently-supported Bonnor-Ebert mass and radius:
MBE = 1.18
RBE = .485
c3
eff
pG3ρedge
ceff
pGρedge
(10)
(11)
Larson's mean-density law states that the mean density within a given volume scales
as the inverse size of that region (Larson 1981). Hence the column density through a
given region should remain roughly independent of the size of the region. Applying this
mean-density scaling to our MBE and RBE, we find
MBE
R2
BE ∝ ceffr ρedge
G
= const.
(12)
Hence, because the effective soundspeed ceff must scale with the turbulent linewidth M, we
find that the edge density of the cloud core cannot remain a constant, but must scale as
ρedge =
(13)
ρ0
p1 + (M/3)2
where ρ0 is the central density, or equivalently, the edge density as one approaches M → 0.
In the remainder of the paper, we will set ρ0 = 5 · 10−20 gm cm−3, and ciso = 2 · 104 cm
s−1, which imply RBE = .07 pc and MBE = 2M⊙ for a transonic (M = 1) molecular cloud
core, which is typical for cores in the Taurus region (Jijina, Myers, & Adams 1999). We
note that in a large-scale, isothermal, supersonic molecular cloud, shocks will compress and
rarefy the mean flow of the gas, producing a log-normal distribution in the density field,
where the width of the distribution depends on the Mach number of the region (Padoan &
Nordlund 2002). In the current work, we treat only the median density, and not the tails
-- 14 --
of the density distribution. As a result, the minimum mass binary system treated will be
proportional to the thermal Jeans mass (see §4). This approximation is justified for systems
whose masses are each close to the median stellar mass, but above the substellar limit.
We will extend the semi-empirical method to systems containing at least one substellar
component in a future paper (Fisher 2003).
3.3. Velocity Field Model
As we noted earlier (§2.1.2), Larson's linewidth-size relation, as determined by recent
authors (Jijina, Myers, & Adams 1999) states that the velocity dispersion ∆v along a line
of sight through a region of size R scales roughly as R1/2 on molecular cloud core scales and
above.
We assume that each Fourier mode in the velocity decomposition is uncorrelated.
By the Central Limit Theorem, uncorrelated Fourier modes are equivalent to demanding
that the probability distribution of the amplitude of each mode is drawn from a
Gaussian distribution, and the phase of each mode is drawn from a uniform distribution.
Decomposing an individual mode δk in Fourier space in terms of its amplitude and phase as
δk = rk exp(iφk), the Gaussian probability distribution gk for the amplitude rk and phase
φk can be written as
gk(rk, φk)drkdφk =
2(rkdrk)
σk
2π (cid:19) exp(cid:18)−r2
(cid:18)dφk
k (cid:19)
k
σ2
(14)
The standard deviation σk is referred to as the power spectrum of the perturbation
spectrum. As is conventional, we write P (k) = σk. By examining the successive moments
of a Gaussian distribution, one can show that only the first two moments -- the mean and
standard deviation -- are needed to entirely specify the distribution. Hence, specifying
the mean and standard deviation completely determines the Gaussian spectrum. In the
-- 15 --
following discussion, we assume that the mean of the perturbing field is zero, and that the
perturbing field is homogeneous and isotropic, so that the amplitude of the power spectrum
depends solely on the magnitude of the k−vector.
By Parseval's Theorem, the total power introduced in k-space is identical to the total
power in real space. Hence, the 3D rms velocity ∆v in a 3D spherical volume in real space
extending from Lmin to Lmax in the radial direction can be easily evaluated by integrating
the power spectrum in k-space from kmin = 2π/Lmax to kmax = 2π/Lmin:
(∆v)2 =Z 4π
0
dΩZ kmax
kmin
k2dkP (k)
(15)
Adopting a power-law power spectrum of the form P (k) = Ak−n, then integrating over
angles and wavenumbers, we have
(∆v)2 =
4πA
(3 − n)(cid:0)kmin−n+3 − kmax−n+3(cid:1)
Assuming that most of the power is on large scales (n > 3) and that Lmin ≪ Lmax, the
maximum wavenumber kmax corresponding to the minimum scale in the problem can be
neglected, so we have
(16)
(17)
∆v =(cid:18) 4πA
n − 3(cid:19)1/2
max
(cid:0)2πL(−n+3)/2
(cid:1)
When n = 4, we can recover Larson's Law (∆v ∝ L1/2
perturbation power spectrum provides the basis for our turbulent models. Specifically, we
max). This n = 4 Gaussian velocity
assume all background velocities are zero, and apply three separate turbulent velocity fields
to our model molecular cloud core via
vx(~r) =
vy(~r) =
vz(~r) =
δx(~r)cisoM√3
δy(~r)cisoM√3
δz(~r)cisoM√3
(18)
(19)
(20)
-- 16 --
where δx(~r), δy(~r), and δz(~r) are three realizations of a k−4 Gaussian field, ciso is the
isothermal soundspeed, and M = ∆v/ciso is the 3D rms turbulent Mach number.
While Gaussian perturbation fields and the structures which arise from them have
been a topic of active investigation in the cosmological context for several decades, our use
of them in the context of star formation differs in two critical respects. First, application
of a perturbation to the density field requires that the total power must be small : a
nonlinear perturbation with sufficient total power will drive the density negative in some
regions. By applying perturbations to the velocity field directly, the total power can be
made arbitrarily large without encountering unphysical negative densities. Second, whereas
cosmological density fluctuations typically introduce most power on small scales (the
inflationary Harrison-Zel'dovich spectrum uses n = 1), we introduce most power on large
scales, in accord with observations of star forming regions.
One should appropriately ask how the ratio of rotational to gravitational binding
energy, β, depends on the 3D turbulent Mach number M, while keeping the realization of
the turbulence fixed. Interestingly enough, under the assumption of a critical Bonnor-Ebert
density distribution, for transonic and supersonic cores, a fixed realization yields a β that is
completely independent of the edge-density of the core, and only weakly dependent on the
turbulent Mach number. Specifically,
β ∝(cid:18) J 2
I (cid:19)(cid:18) R
M 2(cid:19)
β ∝(cid:18)M2R
M (cid:19)
β ∝ M2
1 +(cid:16) M√3(cid:17)2
(21)
(22)
(23)
ie, for transonic and supersonic cores with M ≥ 1, β varies by roughly a factor of 3 from
M = 1 to M = ∞. Here I is the moment of inertia of the initial core. This scaling
-- 17 --
explains why turbulent core models naturally produce the same median value of β as is
seen in observation without any fine-tuning of parameters: in critical Bonnor-Ebert spheres
dominated by turbulent pressure support, Mach scaling applies, and as a result the models
are scale-free. Therefore, in the supersonic regime, for a fixed turbulent realization, β
does not depend on any model parameters. This scaling holds approximately even down
to the transonic regime, so that the value of β is primarily determined from the slope
of the turbulent spectrum. The robust agreement between the predicted value of β and
observation gives strong support for our model of the turbulent velocity field.
Similar Gaussian turbulent spectra imposed on the velocity field have been used in
a variety of numerical simulations of turbulence in the interstellar medium. Dubinski,
Narayan, & Phillips (1995) were apparently the first to suggest that Larsonian turbulence
in the interstellar medium could be generated using Gaussian random velocity fields with
index n = 4. A number of authors, beginning with Gammie & Ostriker (1996), studied
the evolution of turbulence in molecular clouds using the same turbulent spectrum --
initially establishing an Alfv´enic spectrum of waves by an initial velocity fluctuation on a
constant density and magnetic field background. Burkert & Bodenheimer (2000) computed
linewidth gradients induced by turbulent eddies on the scale of molecular cloud cores.
Hujeirat, Myers, Camenzind, & Burkert (2000) computed the initial decay of turbulence
and subsequent collapse (followed to an early evolutionary time) of molecular cloud cores
supported by Alfv´enic turbulence. Lastly, Bate, Bonnell, & Bromm (2002) computed the
evolution of a large, highly supersonic (M ∼ 7) turbulent core.
4. Semi-Empirical Model for Binary Formation via Turbulent Fragmention
We may now predict the distribution of binary periods implied by our isolated turbulent
core models. Since our knowledge of the detailed physics of turbulent fragmentation is still
-- 18 --
rudimentary at best, in order to predict binary properties from our initial molecular cloud
core models, we must make several semi-empirical assumptions motivated by observation.
We will assume that the star-formation efficiency ǫ∗ = (M1 + M2)/Mcore is constant.
Further, in direct analogy to the star-formation efficiency, we define the conversion efficiency
of angular momentum of cores to binaries, ǫJ = J/Jcore, and assume it is constant as well.
In addition, we will assume that the individual stellar masses are uncorrelated, so that both
may be randomly drawn from the IMF. Lastly, we will assume that the orbital eccentricities
of all binaries are drawn from a distribution f (e) = 2e.
We recognize that these assumptions may not be rigorously correct; in particular,
based on observations of field stars, there is evidence (Duquennoy & Mayor 1991) that short
(P < 103 d) period binary systems follow a different eccentricity distribution than long
period binaries, and may also have a different mass-ratio distribution (Mazeh, Goldberg,
Duquennoy, & Mayor 1992). However, because such short-period systems will be strongly
affected by disk-star interactions, it is likely that their orbital parameters undergo significant
evolution. Hence it, in the context of obtaining initial binary properties in the current work,
we will explore the consequences of the hypothesis that all binary systems are formed with
uncorrelated masses drawn from the IMF, and obeying a thermal eccentricity distribution.
We proceed as follows.
1) First, we randomly draw two masses M1 and M2 from the IMF. We uniformly draw
ξ over the interval from 0 - 1 twice, and assign masses (scaled to solar) and mass ratio q
according to
m(ξ) = .08 +
γ1ξγ2 + γ3ξγ4
(1 − ξ).58
,
(24)
where γ1 = .19, γ2 = 1.55, γ3 = .050, γ4 = .6 (Kroupa, Gilmore, & Tout 1991). We note
that this IMF introduces a cutoff at .08M⊙, and so does not extend into the substellar
range. We define M1 to be the greater of these two masses; hence q = M2/M1.
-- 19 --
2) Next, using the star formation efficiency factor, set the mass of the initial protostellar
core:
Mcore =
(M1 + M2)
ǫ∗
.
(25)
Since we now know the parent core mass as well as the thermal Bonnor-Ebert mass, we
may also set the 3D turbulent Mach number, using equation (3.2) :
M = 3"(cid:18)Mcore
Mth (cid:19)4/7
− 1#1/2
(26)
In cases where Mcore < Mth, the computed core mass is less than the thermal Bonnor-Ebert
value, implying that the initial core is inconsistent with the selected binary masses and
assumed star formation efficiency. In these instances, we simply reject the model binary
and draw both stars again.
3) We then stochastically generate three perturbation cubes, and perturb the velocity
field of our model core using the known Mach number M, thereby setting the resultant
core angular momentum Jcore as well as the binary system angular momentum J = ǫJ Jcore.
4) Next, we draw the eccentricity of the binary orbit from the thermal distribution
f (e) = 2e. We do this by drawing a number ξ from a uniform distribution ranging from 0
to 1, and setting e = √ξ.
5) Finally, knowing J, e, M and q, we may compute the period P and semi-major axis
a of the binary system, from
and
P =(cid:18) 2π
G2(cid:19)(cid:18) J 3
M 5(cid:19)
1
(1 + q)6
(1 − e2)3/2
q3
a =
1
G(cid:18) J
M 2(cid:19)
1
(1 − e2)
1
M
(1 + q)4
q2
(27)
(28)
(See Appendix A for derivation.)
-- 20 --
These relations are often written down for the special case of an equal-mass, circular
binary (e = 0, and q = 1). Clearly, in that case, the larger the value of J/M, the greater the
amount of angular momentum in the system, and hence, the longer the period. In addition,
the smaller the total mass M of the system, the less the influence of gravity, and hence,
the wider the binary. However, although it is commonly not recognized, for fixed mass and
angular momentum, the eccentricity and the mass ratio can also have a substantial impact
on the orbital properties of binaries. For instance, for a fixed angular momentum, the
larger the eccentricity e of a system, the wider the binary. Similarly, for a fixed mass, the
smaller the mass ratio q, the wider the binary. Although apparently trivial, these scaling
relationships will have an important bearing on the statistical properties of binary star
systems, as we shall soon see.
Our models introduce two free parameters: ǫ∗ and ǫJ , the mass and angular momentum
star formation efficiencies, respectively. The first parameter is relatively well-constrained by
both theory and observation (Matzner & McKee 2000). For a given ǫ∗, the ǫJ parameter
is obtained by requiring that the resultant model binary period distribution median agree
with the observed value. In effect, the imposition of this constraint reduces the parameter
space to one free parameter, which we take to be ǫ∗. We note, from equation (27), that with
the constraint that the model period median must agree with observation, that ǫJ ∝ ǫ5/3
.
∗
The nonlinearity of the dependence of ǫJ on ǫ∗ has a simple interpretation: for low star
formation efficiency, a larger amount of mass must be accreted onto the binary, which
implies a greater angular momentum loss efficiency due to the larger turbulent linewidth on
larger scales.
Note that our model implicitly assumes that the mass of the system M, the mass
ratio q, and the orbital eccentricity e are uncorrelated, whereas the angular momentum
J (and hence the period P ) is explicitly dependent upon M : the higher the mass of
-- 21 --
the binary system, the greater the mass and Mach number M of the initial core. These
assumptions differ from those adopted by Kroupa (1995) in his formulation of the inverse
binary population synthesis problem, where he assumed that P , q, and e were uncorrelated.
In contrast, in our formulation, the period P depends explicitly on q and e through angular
momentum conservation (equation 27), which implies that our model predicts non-trivial
correlations between P and q, and between P and e. We return to these points in later
sections (§5.2 and §5.3), where we detail the nature of these correlations.
5. Results
5.1. Binary Period Distribution
Figure 1 shows the binary period distribution obtained for the star formation efficiency
ǫ∗ = 0.26. The standard deviation of the computed distribution is σPd = 1.7; slightly
narrower than that of the field, though consistent with the PMS distribution. The computed
distribution is in remarkably good agreement with Mathieu's cataloged visual binaries with
periods > 104 d. The computed distribution exhibits a somewhat smaller binarity fraction
at periods shorter than 103 d than either the field or the PMS distribution, although given
the numbers involved, this result is of marginal statistical significance.
There is a small, but systematic increase in the width of the distribution with increasing
star formation efficiency. We interpret this increasing width as a consequence of the decrease
in angular momentum loss efficiency with increasing star formation efficiency. As a result,
higher star formation efficiency models have slightly wider distributions of pre-stellar core
specific angular momenta. The distribution of initial core specific angular angular momenta
for the case of ǫ∗ = 0.26 is shown in figure 2.
-- 22 --
5.2. Eccentricity Versus Period
As we noted in §4, in our semi-empirical model of turbulent star formation, the angular
momentum of the binary system is directly related to the initial angular momentum of
the turbulent core. As a result, the period and eccentricity are no longer uncorrelated
quantities, and the period is explicitly dependent upon the eccentricity; for a fixed angular
momentum and mass, the greater the eccentricity, the longer the period. From observation
(§2.2.3), we know that in binaries wider than the tidal circularization limit (P ∼ 10 d), the
period tends to be correlated with the eccentricity, which is in fact a robust feature of our
model (see equation 27 ).
We plot eccentricity versus the log (base 10) of the period for in figure 5, for the case
of intermediate star-formation efficiency (ǫ∗ = 0.5). For comparison, binaries from the field
(Duquennoy & Mayor 1991), and from PMS regions (Mathieu 1994), are shown in star and
plus symbols, respectively, in the plot on the right. The vertical dashed line indicates the
tidal circularization limit found by Duquennoy & Mayor (1991) at about Pd ∼ 11 d. The
key result here is that the model systems exhibit a positive correlation between eccentricity
and period, which is qualitatively similar to that observed. However, it is certainly true
that our models predict an overabundance of highly eccentric binaries at shorter periods.
It is quite likely that additional angular momentum dissipation mechanisms, including
coupling to circumstellar disks, may help circularize such systems.
5.3. Mass Ratio Versus Period
The semi-empirical model also predicts a correlation between mass ratio and period.
The reason for the correlation is, once again, simply related to conservation of angular
momentum. A system with two unequal masses, and a small mass ratio (q ≪ 1) will have
-- 23 --
a longer period than a similar system with the same total angular momentum and mass,
but with equal masses. The results of 200 model systems for the case of intermediate
star-formation efficiency (ǫ∗ = 0.5) are shown in figure 4.
We emphasize that in order to explain the correlation between mass ratio and
period, the semi-empirical model framework does not require that the masses themselves be
correlated. Instead, the model suggests that it is possible to form two stars independently
within a single turbulent core, with the resultant period anti-correlated with the mass ratio
simply through angular momentum conservation.
5.4. Binary System Mass Versus Semimajor Axis
As we noted previously, observations of low-mass systems have revealed that such
systems do not follow the same statistical trends observed in solar-mass and higher binaries.
Perhaps the most noticeable difference is the trend for low-mass systems to occur in
tighter binaries. In the semi-empirical model, two factors contribute to the explanation
of this effect. First, lower-mass binary systems originate from parent cores of lower mass,
and hence, lower specific angular momentum. Second, drawing stars independently from
the IMF, a low-mass system will naturally tend to have a more equal-mass ratio. Taken
together, the model predicts that low-mass systems should naturally tend to occur in
shorter-period systems, which is in fact what is observed (Mart´ın & Basri 2001).
In figures 6 - 7, we display the results from two model systems of variable star formation
efficiency. The minimum system mass represented for a given star-formation efficiency
ǫ∗ is indicated with a dashed horizontal line; no model systems form below the line. For
comparison, we also plot the largest observable binary separations amax, as determined by
Close, Siegler, Freed, Biller (2003) in their figure 15. They found that the two straight lines
-- 24 --
of constant orbital velocity amax = 23.2(Mtot/.185) AU and amax = 1000(Mtot/.185) AU
(where Mtot is in solar masses) describe the maximal separation upper envelopes relatively
well.
We note that, above the horizontal minimum mass line, our model systems fit the
Close et al. upper envelopes remarkably well; very few systems lie to the right of the
envelopes, quite independent of the star-formation efficiency. In the context of the current
paper, our assumption of a fixed Jeans mass requires that low mass systems must form in
regions of low star-formation efficiency. Hence, it appears that a combination of a variety
of star-formation efficiencies can explain the results of Close et al. More general models
including constant star-formation efficiency and supersonic turbulence on large scales may
also be able to explain the observations; a topic we are investigating further (Fisher 2003).
6. Discussion
One limitation of our current approach is the choice of a fixed central density ρ0. By
specifying ρ0, we have implicitly restricted our attention to systems above a mass ǫ∗Mth.
As we pointed out previously (§3.2), shock compressions in a turbulent molecular cloud
will produce a log-normal distribution of ρ0. We expect that a set of binary systems
formed from cores with varying Mth resulting from to shock compression will in fact have a
slightly broader period distribution than that computed here. Similarly, the IMF adopted
introduces a cutoff at .08M⊙, even though substellar objects are also formed in star-forming
regions. These effects may partially account for the slightly smaller period distribution
standard deviations computed here (σPd ≃ 1.6 − 2.1), in comparison to that found in the
field (σPd ≃ 2.3) (Duquennoy & Mayor 1991).
Detailed theoretical work treating wind-driven outflows (Matzner & McKee 2000)
-- 25 --
predicts that the star-formation efficiency on the molecular cloud scale should lie in the
range 25 - 70%. For star-formation efficiencies in this range, our models predict core
properties consistent with observation. In particular, with our fiducial scaling, the median
Mach number ¯M lies in the range of 1.2 and 0.9 over the range ǫ∗ = 0.1 − 0.9 -- quite close
to the actual median value of .9 observed in Taurus (Jijina, Myers, & Adams 1999). We
note that since both our pre-stellar core and final binary properties are relatively insensitive
to the star-formation efficiency (the median prestellar core Mach number ¯M varies only by
a factor of 2 for star-formation efficiencies over the range ǫ∗ = 0.1 − 0.9) our models do not
provide further constraints on the star-formation efficiency itself.
A key consequence of the semi-empirical model for star formation described here stems
from the fact that many observational properties can be quantitatively described with a
constant angular momentum loss factor. In contrast, several authors have advocated a
"chaotic" description star formation (Larson 2001; Bate, Bonnell, & Bromm 2002), in which
a variety of cluster interactions play a key role in setting the initial properties of binaries.
In this paper, we have explicitly demonstrated that chaotic interactions are not required
to explain many properties of binaries wider than P > 103 d, provided that turbulent
fragmentation can in fact directly produce the mass and eccentricity distributions which we
have assumed. Note that we distinguish the fact that our initial conditions are turbulent,
and therefore inherently stochastic (though deterministic) from the sensitivity upon initial
conditions implied by a chaotic model. We would, however, agree that dynamical friction
is likely to play an important role in the formation of tight binaries, and that subsequent
tidal interactions may also act to broaden the initial period distribution found here.
Another key consequence of our model is the importance which angular momentum loss
from initial molecular cloud cores plays in determining the properties of binaries. Although
this problem has been identified by a number of authors (Simon 1992; Bodenheimer 1995;
-- 26 --
Larson 2002), virtually all simulations of multiple star formation on the molecular cloud
core scale done to date remain purely hydrodynamic, and have neglected the influence of
the magnetic field entirely.2 As a result, the only means of angular momentum transport
treated in most calculations is gravitational torquing. Given the importance of angular
momentum loss in determining binary properties, and the relative effectiveness of magnetic
braking in axisymmetric simulations of single-star formation (Basu & Mouschovias 1994),
caution must be applied in comparing the results of purely hydrodynamic simulations
directly against observation; in all likelihood, the magnetic field plays a critical role in
determining the binary angular momentum.
RTF would like to thank Richard Klein and Christopher McKee for their prescient
suggestion to investigate the physical role of turbulence in multiple star formation as a
thesis topic. Thanks also go to Marc Davis and Matt Craig for the use of their Gaussian
perturbation generation program. This research has made use of NASA's Astrophysics
Data System Bibliographic Service.
A. Characteristic Scales
In this appendix, we derive the characteristic scales of a binary system consisting of
two masses M1 and M2, in terms of its angular momentum J, its mass ratio q = M2/M1,
and its orbital eccentricity e.
From standard two-body classical mechanics in an inverse square law potential
2To the best of our knowledge, the only exceptions are the work of Hujeirat, Myers,
Camenzind, & Burkert (2000) and Boss (2000), although Boss did not include a fully self-
consistent treatment of the MHD equations.
-- 27 --
(Goldstein 1980), we know the angular momentum of a binary system is completely
specified by the semi-major and semi-minor axes of the bound orbit, as well as the reduced
mass of the two-body system µ = M1M2/(M1 + M2), and the inverse square law constant
(A1)
of proportionality k :
J =
b
a1/2pµk,
where µ = M1M2/(M1 + M2) is the reduced mass of the two body system, and k = GM1M2
for the gravitational force. Hence, since b = a√1 − e2, we can determine the final orbital
separation as a function of the eccentricity e, total mass M = M1 + M2, and specific angular
momentum J/M :
J/M = a1/2√1 − e2s G(M1M2)2
(M1 + M2)3
(A2)
Defining the ratio of secondary to primary mass q = M2/M1, for e ≤ 1, the semi-major axis
of a bound orbit is
a =
1
M(cid:19)2
G(cid:18) J
1
1 − e2
1
M
(1 + q)4
q2
(A3)
For a typical molecular cloud core specific angular momentum value of J/M = 3· 1020 cm2/s,
a = 50AU(cid:18)
J/M
3 · 1020 cm2/s(cid:19)2
1
1 − e2 (cid:18)M⊙
M (cid:19) (1 + q)4
q2
(A4)
Then, from Kepler's third law, we can determine the period of the final binary system :
P =
2π
G2
1
(1 − e2)3/2 (cid:18) J
M(cid:19)3 (1 + q)6
q3
1
M 2
P = 300 years
1
(1 − e2)3/2 (cid:18)
J/M
3 · 1020 cm2/s(cid:19)3 (1 + q)6
q3
(A5)
(A6)
M (cid:19)2
(cid:18)M⊙
We anticipate that explicit dependence of P on e in equation (A6) may cause some readers,
who are accustomed to the fact that the Keplerian period depends only on a, and not on e,
some undue consternation. These concerns will be rapidly alleviated when it is recognized
that, for fixed masses and angular momentum, a more eccentric binary system must have
a wider separation (eqn. A4). Our equation (A6) expresses the period in terms of the
-- 28 --
angular momentum J in favor of the semimajor axis a, and hence the origin of the explicit
dependence of P on e.
Lastly, using the classical two-body inverse square law result for the total energy E of
the system
E = −
k
2a
,
one can also determine the final energy E of the binary system :
E =
1
2
G2M 3(e2 − 1)
q3
J (cid:19)2
(1 + q)6 (cid:18) M
(A7)
(A8)
-- 29 --
REFERENCES
Abt, H. A. & Levy, S. G. 1976, ApJS, 30, 273
Basu, S. & Mouschovias, T. C. 1994, ApJ, 432, 720
Bate, M. R., Bonnell, I. A., & Bromm, V. 2002, MNRAS, 332, L65
Bodenheimer, P. 1995, ARA&A, 33, 199
Bonnell, I. A., Bate, M. R., Clarke, C. J., & Pringle, J. E. 1997, MNRAS, 285, 201
Bonnor, W. B. 1957, MNRAS, 117, 104
Boss, A. P., Fisher, R. T., Klein, R. I., & McKee, C. F. 2000, ApJ, 528, 325
Boss, A. P. 2000, ApJ, 545, L61
Brandner, W. & Koehler, R. 1998, ApJ, 499, L79
Burkert, A. & Bodenheimer, P. 2000, ApJ, 543, 822.
Clarke, C. J. & Pringle, J. E. 1991, MNRAS, 249, 584
Close, L. M, Siegler, N., Freed, M., & Biller, B., ApJ, to appear.
Duquennoy, A. & Mayor, M. 1991, A&A, 248, 485
Dubinski, J., Narayan, R., & Phillips, T. G. 1995, ApJ, 448, 226
Ebert, R. 1955, Zeitschrift Astrophysics, 37, 217
Fischer, D. A. & Marcy, G. W. 1992, ApJ, 396, 178
Fisher, R. T. 2003, in preparation.
Galli, D., Shu, F. H., Laughlin, G., & Lizano, S. 2001, ApJ, 551, 367
-- 30 --
Gammie, C. F. & Ostriker , E. C. 1996, ApJ, 466, 814
Ghez, A. M., White, R. J., & Simon, M. 1997, ApJ, 490, 353
Goldstein, H. 1980, Classical Mechanics, Addison-Wesley
Goodman, A. A., Benson, P. J., Fuller, G. A., & Myers, P. C. 1993, ApJ, 406, 528
Hoyle, F. 1953, ApJ, 118, 513
Hujeirat, A., Myers, P., Camenzind, M., & Burkert, A. 2000, New Astronomy, 4, 601
Inutsuka, S. & Miyama, S. M. 1992, ApJ, 388, 392
Jaschek, C. & G´omez, A. E. 1970, PASP, 82, 809
Jaschek, C. & Jaschek, M. 1957, PASP, 69, 546
Jijina, J., Myers, P. C., & Adams, F. C. 1999, ApJS, 125, 161
Klein, R. I., Fisher, R., & McKee, C. F. 2001, IAU Symposium, 200, 361
Kroupa, P. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 1491
Kroupa, P., Gilmore, G., & Tout, C. A. 1991, MNRAS, 251, 293
Kroupa, P. & Burkert, A. 2001, ApJ, 555, 945
Kuiper, G. P. , PASP, 47, 15
Kuiper, G. P. 1942, ApJ, 95, 201
Larson, R. B. 1979, MNRAS, 186, 479
Larson, R. B. 1981, MNRAS, 194, 809
Larson, R. .B. 1995, MNRAS, 272, 213
-- 31 --
Larson, R. B. 2001, IAU Symposium, 200, 93
Larson, R. B. 2002, MNRAS, 332, 155
Laughlin, G. & Bodenheimer, P. 1994, ApJ, 436, 335
Leung, C. M., Kutner, M. L., & Mead, K. N. 1982, ApJ, 262, 583
Looney, L. W., Mundy, L. G., & Welch, W. J. 2000, ApJ, 529, 477
Mart´ın, E. L. & Basri, G. 2001, IAU Symposium, 200, 55
Mathieu, R. D. 1994, ARA&A, 32, 465
Matzner, C. D., & McKee, C.F. 2000, ApJ, 545, 364
Mayor, M., Duquennoy, A., Halbwachs, J.-L., & Mermilliod, J.-C. 1992, ASP Conf. Ser. 32:
IAU Colloq. 135: Complementary Approaches to Double and Multiple Star Research,
73
Mazeh, T., Goldberg, D., Duquennoy, A., & Mayor, M. 1992, ApJ, 401, 265
McKee, C. F. & Holliman, J. H. 1999, ApJ, 522, 313
McLaughlin, D. E. & Pudritz, R. E. 1997, ApJ, 476, 75
Motte, F. & Andr´e, P. 2001, A&A, 365, 440.
Mouschovias, T. C. 1977, ApJ, 211, 147
Myers, P. C. 1983, ApJ, 270, 105
Myers, P. C. & Lazarian, A. 1998, ApJ, 507, L157
Natarajan, P. & Lynden-Bell, D. 1997, MNRAS, 286, 268
-- 32 --
Padoan, P. & Nordlund, A. 2002, ApJ, 576, 870
Petrie, R. M. 1960, AJ, 65, 55
Rodriguez, L. F. et al. 1998, Nature, 395, 355.
Scally, A., Clarke, C., & McCaughrean, M. J. 1999, MNRAS, 306, 253
Shu, F. H. 1977, ApJ, 214, 488
Simon, M. 1992, ASP Conf. Ser. 32: IAU Colloq. 135: Complementary Approaches to
Double and Multiple Star Research, 41
Whitworth, A. P., Boffin, H. M. J., & Francis, N. 1998, MNRAS, 299, 554
This manuscript was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0.
-- 33 --
ǫJ
log ¯Pd
log σPd
ǫ∗
0.1
.002
4.9
0.3
.01
0.5
.04
0.7
.06
0.9
.10
4.9
4.8
4.9
5.0
1.6
1.7
1.8
2.0
2.1
.31
.51
.72
.92
34
30
35
45
ǫ∗Mth/M⊙ ¯a/AU ¯j (cm2 s−1)
.14
30
¯M
1.7
1.2
1.0
.89
.87
1.3 · 1021
7.7 · 1020
4.5 · 1020
3.5 · 1020
3.4 · 1020
Table 1: A table of model parameters, for a variety of star formation efficiencies (ǫ∗ =
0.1 − 0.9) fitted such that the median model period agrees with that of the field. Shown are
the mass and angular momentum star-formation efficiencies ǫ∗ and ǫJ , the median of the log
of the period distribution (in days) log ¯Pd, the standard deviation of the log of the period
distribution (in days) log σPd, the minimum mass binary system (in solar masses) ǫ∗Mth/M⊙,
the median of the semi-major axis (in AU) ¯a, the median prestellar core angular momentum
¯j (in cm2 s−1), and the median prestellar core Mach number ¯M.
-- 34 --
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
log (Pd)
5
6
7
8
9
10
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
log (Pd)
5
6
7
8
9
10
Fig. 1. -- Histogram of log Pd. The left panel shows our numerical results for 200 model
systems for the case of star-formation efficiency ǫ∗ = 0.26. For comparison, the right-hand
panel shows the period distribution inferred from PMS stars (Mathieu 1994) and from field
stars (Duquennoy & Mayor 1991), in solid and dashed lines, respectively.
-- 35 --
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
0
19.5
20
20.5
21
21.5
log (Jcore (cm2 s−1)
22
22.5
23
Fig. 2. -- Histogram of the log of the model initial core specific angular mom entum j = J/M,
measured in cm2 s−1, for 200 binary-producing cores, shown for a low star-formation efficiency
(ǫ∗ = 0.26).
-- 36 --
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
n
o
i
t
c
a
r
F
0
−2
−1
0
1
2
log (a / AU)
3
4
5
6
Fig. 3. -- Histogram of log a(AU). The numerical results for 200 model systems for the cases
of low star formation efficiency (ǫ∗ = 0.26), are shown, with Poisson error bars drawn.
-- 37 --
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
1
M
/
2
0.5
M
=
q
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
log (Pd)
5
6
7
8
9
10
Fig. 4. -- Binary mass ratio versus log Pd. The circles show the results of 200 model systems
for the cases of intermediate star-formation efficiency (ǫ∗ = 0.5).
-- 38 --
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
y
t
i
c
i
r
t
n
e
c
c
E
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
y
t
i
c
i
r
t
n
e
c
c
E
0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
log (Pd)
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
log (Pd)
Fig. 5. -- Eccentricity versus log Pd. The circles show the results of 200 model systems for the
case of intermediate star-formation efficiency (ǫ∗ = 0.5). For comparison, binaries from the
field (Duquennoy & Mayor 1991), and from PMS regions (Mathieu 1994), are shown in star
and plus symbols, respectively, in the plot on the right. The vertical dashed line indicates
the tidal circularization limit found by Duquennoy & Mayor (1991) at about Pd ∼ 11 d.
-- 39 --
101
)
100
n
u
s
M
/
t
o
t
M
(
g
o
l
10−1
100
101
102
103
104
105
log (a / AU)
Fig. 6. -- Log semimajor axis versus log total mass. The circles show the results of model
systems for the very low star-formation effficiency case ǫ∗ = 0.1. The two solid slanted
lines indicate the upper envlopes indicated by Close, Siegler, Freed, Biller (2003) (see text).
The horizontal dashed line is drawn to delineate the minimum mass binary system for this
star-formation efficiency.
-- 40 --
101
)
100
n
u
s
M
/
t
o
t
M
(
g
o
l
10−1
100
101
102
103
104
105
log (a / AU)
Fig. 7. -- Log semimajor axis versus log total mass, as in fig. 6. The circles show the results
of model systems for the intermediate star formation effficiency case ǫ∗ = 0.5.
|
0811.0570 | 1 | 0811 | 2008-11-04T19:02:04 | The Full Spectrum Galactic Terrarium: MHz to TeV Observations of Various Critters | [
"astro-ph"
] | Multi-wavelength studies at radio, infrared, optical, X-ray, and TeV wavelengths have discovered probable counterparts to many Galactic sources of GeV emission detected by EGRET. These include pulsar wind nebulae, high mass X-ray binaries, and mixed morphology supernova remnants. Here we provide an overview of the observational properties of Galactic sources which emit across 19 orders of magnitude in energy. We also present new observations of several sources. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
The Full Spectrum Galactic Terrarium: MHz to TeV
Observations of Various Critters
Mallory S.E. Roberts∗, C. Brogan†, S. Ransom†, M. Lyutikov∗∗, E. de Oña
Wilhelmi‡, A. Djannati-Ataï‡, R. Terrier‡, S.M. Dougherty§, E.D. Grundstrom¶,
J.W.T. Hesselsk, S. Johnston††, M.V. McSwain‡‡, P.S. Ray§§, K.S. Wood§§, G.G.
Pooley¶¶ and A. Weinstein∗∗∗
∗Eureka Scientific, Inc., 2452 Delmer Street, Suite 100, Oakland, CA 94602-3017
†National Radio Astronomy Observatory, 520 Edgemont Road, Charlottesville, VA 22903
∗∗Department of Physics, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
‡Astroparticule et Cosmologie (APC), CNRS, Universite Paris 7 Denis Diderot, 10, Paris, France
§National Research Council of Canada, Herzberg Institute for Astrophysics, Dominion Radio Astrophysical
Observatory, PO Box 248, Penticton, British Columbia V2A 6J9, Canada
¶Physics and Astronomy Department, Vanderbilt University, 6301 Stevenson Center, Nashville, TN 37235
kAstronomical Institute "Anton Pannekoek," University of Amsterdam, 1098 SJ Amsterdam, Netherlands
††Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO, PO Box 76, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia
‡‡Department of Physics, Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA 18015
§§Space Science Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, DC 20375-5352
¶¶Cavendish Laboratory, Cambridge University
∗∗∗Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095
Abstract. Multi-wavelength studies at radio, infrared, optical, X-ray, and TeV wavelengths have discovered probable
counterparts to many Galactic sources of GeV emission detected by EGRET. These include pulsar wind nebulae, high mass
X-ray binaries, and mixed morphology supernova remnants. Here we provide an overview of the observational properties of
Galactic sources which emit across 19 orders of magnitude in energy. We also present new observations of several sources.
Keywords: pulsar, pulsar wind nebula, supernova remnant, EGRET, FERMI, GLAST, gamma-ray, VLA, XMM-Newton, Binary, ATCA,
PSR J2021+3651, HESS, MILAGRO, MGRO J1908+06, RCW 49, LS 5039
PACS: 95.85.Pw, 95.85.Nv, 95.85.Bh, 97.60.Gb, 97.60.Jd, 97.80.Jp, 98.38.Dq, 98.38.Mz
ALL ACROSS THE
YOUNG PULSARS AND PULSAR WIND
ELECTROMAGNETIC SPECTRUM
NEBULAE
For many years, the Crab nebula was the only Galac-
tic source detected across the entire spectrum, from ra-
dio to TeV energies [1]. The EGRET telescope on board
the Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory detected dozens
of Galactic sources at GeV energies [2], most of which
were not firmly identified by the end of the mission.
Since then, multi-wavelength studies of the EGRET er-
ror boxes at radio optical and X-ray wavelengths have
discovered probable counterparts for most of the sources
bright above 1 GeV, most of them the products of su-
pernovae (pulsars, pulsar wind nebulae (PWN), and su-
pernova remnants (SNR), [3]). Furthermore, surveys of
the Galactic plane by HESS, MILAGRO, and VERITAS
(among others) have discovered TeV emitting regions
which can plausibly be associated with many of these
sources. Here we provide an overview of the observa-
tional properties of sources which emit across 19 orders
of magnitude in energy.
Young spin-powered pulsars were the only firmly iden-
tified (through their pulsations) class of Galactic GeV
sources during the EGRET era. Pulsed emission from the
longest radio wavelengths up to a few tens of GeV has
been detected, although in general the g −ray cut-off for
pulsed emission seems to be in the few GeV range [see
4, for a general review of pulsar and pulsar wind nebu-
lae properties]. The winds of young pulsars create nebu-
lae which emit synchrotron radiation from radio through
soft gamma-rays, and through inverse Compton scatter-
ing produce photons with energies up to tens of TeV. The
transition from synchrotron to inverse Compton emission
in PWN seems to be in the ∼ 0.01 − 1 GeV range, al-
though only for the Crab and Vela is the synchrotron cut-
off energy fairly well established. The cut-off energies
of both the pulsed and PWN emission should be greatly
constrained by the Fermi (formerly known as GLAST)
LAT over the coming years.
Inverse Compton (IC) emission is a very efficient
means of producing high-energy photons from an accel-
erated particle with a large fraction of the electron en-
ergy transferred to the seed photon in a single scatter.
The peak of the IC emission is typically 5-10 orders of
magnitude higher in energy than the corresponding syn-
chrotron radiation. It is also not dependent on magnetic
field strength, and so can produce significant amounts of
radiation even in regions with very low magnetic field
strength. The implication of this for emission from PWN
is that the synchrotron lifetimes of the IC emitting elec-
trons can be very long, and it is not necessarily the case
that where the synchrotron emission is bright, the IC
emission is bright. In fact, it is typically the case that
the TeV emission is significantly offset from the current
position of the pulsar. This offset is caused by either the
motion of the pulsar or the interaction of the supernova
remnant reverse shock with the PWN.
The MILAGRO telescope detected two previously un-
known regions of significant emission above 10 TeV [5]:
a complex of sources in the Cygnus region with the
brightest peak known as MGRO J2019+37 and another
extended source called MGRO J1908+06. The nearest
EGRET source to MGRO J2019+37 is GeV J2020+3658
which is associated with the young pulsar and PWN PSR
J2021+3651 [6], which is near the central region of the
Cygnus cross. For this reason, and the fact that the pulsar
was discovered with Arecibo in Puerto Rico, we some-
times refer to it as Cisne (swan in Spanish).
We have performed X-ray observations with XMM-
Newton and 20cm radio observations with the VLA
of the region around PSR J2021+3651. Outside of the
bright inner X-ray nebula there structured hard, faint X-
ray emission extending out ∼ 10 − 15 arcminutes. The
brightest region of this larger X-ray nebula is an exten-
sion to the west of about 8′ in length. The VLA image
shows a radio nebula coincident with this X-ray exten-
sion, with a suggestion of a conical morphology extend-
ing out around 10′, at which point there is a decrease in
surface brightness and a further broadenig of the neb-
ula. The radio nebula extends out at least 20′ to the
west, right to the center of the best fit ellipse to MGRO
J2019+37. This connection, for any reasonable distance
to PSR J2021+3651 (> 6 kpc, see discussion in [6]) re-
sults in a TeV luminosity several times that of the Crab
nebula, making this the most luminous TeV source in the
Galaxy. If we include the EGRET flux, the broad-band
spectral energy distribution of the PWN would appear
to peak in the GeV range. However, much if not most
of the emission seen by EGRET is undoubtably magne-
tospheric pulsed emission, therefore it is likely the syn-
chrotron emitting PWN cuts off in the MeV range. Un-
fortunately, VERITAS has not yet been able to confirm
the TeV source, but should ultimately give a much more
detailed understanding of the TeV emission and its mor-
FIGURE 1. XMM-Newton X-ray image of Cisne, the PWN
around PSR J2021+3651 (for color version, red=0.5-1.5 keV,
green=1.5-2.5, blue=2.5-7.5) with VLA contours
FIGURE 2. VLA 20cm image of Cisne PWN with XMM-
Newton X-ray contours
phological connection to the PWN of PSR J2021+3651.
MGRO J1908+06 is near GeV J1907+0557, for which
a potentially extended X-ray counterpart was discovered
with ASCA [7]. A brief (10 ks) Chandra ACIS obser-
vation showed most of the flux is from a hard (photon
index ∼ 1) moderately absorbed (nH ∼ 2 × 1022cm−2)
point source with no compact nebula and just a faint hint
of the larger nebula seen by ASCA. A moderately deep I
band image with the MDM 2.4m telescope shows no ev-
idence of an optical counterpart. Both HESS and VERI-
TAS (see other contributions, this proceedings) have ver-
ified and resolved the MILAGRO source, with the ASCA
source at the southern edge. AGILE data of the region
verifies the GeV emission is consistent with the position
of GeV J1907+0557 and suggests the third EGRET cata-
log source 3EG J1903+0550 was a composite of the GeV
source and another, unrelated source.
VLA
ASCA
EGRET
MILAGRO
1e-09
1e-10
1e-11
1e-12
1e-13
1e-14
s
/
2
^
m
c
/
g
r
e
)
v
(
F
v
1e-15
1e+08
1e+10
1e+12
1e+14
1e+16
1e+18
1e+20
1e+22
1e+24
1e+26
1e+28
Frequency (Hz)
FIGURE 3. Spectral Energy Distribution of Cisne. Note that
the EGRET flux undoubtably has a significant pulsed compo-
nent.
FIGURE 4. GB6 4850MHz image [8] of MGRO J1908+06
region. The white contour is the HESS source, the black con-
tour is the ASCA 2-10 keV image (nb. that the circle is due
to exposure correction of noise at the edge of the FOV, the
source under discussion lies along the outside edge of the HESS
contour) and the grey contour is the AGILE > 300 MeV image.
Several of the unidentified EGRET sources contain-
ing PWN appear to be variable on timescales of months
according to the Nolan et al. (2003) variability test [9]
with t = Frms/Fmean ∼ 1. This suggests the GeV flux
may be partially due to particle acceleration in the inner
nebula rather than being pulsed emisssion from the mag-
netosphere. Some of these sources (eg. the Rabbit/GeV
J1417-6100 and the Eel/GeV J1825-1310 nebulae, see
[10]) appear to emit TeV emission as well. However,
three potentially variable GeV sources, CTA 1, GeV
J1809-2327 (Taz) and SNR W44, have PWN inside of
mixed-morphoogy SNR [11]. These supernova remnants
have radio shells but are filled with thermal X-rays. Most
SNR of this type also contain young pulsars with pul-
sar wind nebulae. Two mixed-morphology SNR associ-
ated with GeV sources, W28 and IC 443, have had TeV
hotspots reported [12, 13], suggesting the three contain-
ing variable GeV sources are likely to be TeV emitters as
FIGURE 5. Top: ATCA 20cm image of RCW 49. Bottom:
MSX 8.3m
image.
well.
Complicating our understanding of these sources are
their environments. Many are near molecular clouds,
which may both enhance the the production of g −ray
emission by particles accelerated in pulsar winds and
SNR shocks as well as produce g −ray emission on their
own. In addition, there have been a few claims of ex-
tended TeV sources associated with massive stars or col-
liding wind binaries contained within molecular clouds
despite the TeV emission being somewhat offset from
the stellar systems. One should keep in mind that the
bright diffuse radio emission from molecular clouds can
obscure PWN or SNR shells. We have performed ATCA
radio imaging of one such source, the Westerlund 2 com-
plex (also known as RCW 49) near GeV J1025−5809
which is coincident with HESS J1023−575 [14]. While
much of the radio emission can be associated with mid-
infrared emission seen by MSX, there are some arcs in
the ATCA image that do not correlate with infrared struc-
tures. This suggests a non-thermal, i.e. SNR shell, iden-
tification for these arcs.
RADIO-LOUD HIGH MASS X-RAY
BINARIES
There are at least 3 strange radio emitting binary sys-
tems with massive stars in eccentric orbits. PSR 1259-
work was partially supported by SAO Grant No. G07-
8072 and GO6-7136X, NASA Grant No. NNX08AV70G
and NNG06EJ54P. G. McSwain acknowledges institu-
tional support from Lehigh University. M. Roberts would
like to thank the CNRS and the APC for support during
his visit.
REFERENCES
1. T. C. Weekes, et al. ApJ 342, 379 -- 395 (1989).
2. R. C. Lamb, and D. J. Macomb, ApJ 488, 872 -- + (1997).
3. M. S. E. Roberts, "Pulsars Everywhere! A Galactic
EGRET Source Retrospective," in 40 Years of Pulsars:
Millisecond Pulsars, Magnetars and More, edited by
C. Bassa, Z. Wang, A. Cumming, and V. M. Kaspi, 2008,
vol. 983 of American Institute of Physics Conference
Series, pp. 621 -- 623.
4. V. M. Kaspi, M. S. E. Roberts, and A. K. Harding,
Isolated neutron stars, Compact stellar X-ray sources,
2006, pp. 279 -- 339.
5. A. A. Abdo, et al. ApJL 664, L91 -- L94 (2007)
6.
J. W. T. Hessels, M. S. E. Roberts, S. M. Ransom, V. M.
Kaspi, R. W. Romani, C. . Ng, P. C. C. Freire, and B. M.
Gaensler, ApJ 612, 389 -- 397 (2004).
7. M. S. E. Roberts, R. W. Romani, and N. Kawai, ApJS
8.
133, 451 -- 465 (2001)
J. J. Condon, J. J. Broderick, G. A. Seielstad, K. Douglas,
and P. C. Gregory, AJ 107, 1829 -- 1833 (1994).
P. L. Nolan, W. F. Tompkins, I. A. Grenier, and P. F.
Michelson, ApJ 597, 615 -- 627 (2003).
10. M. S. E. Roberts, "What Will Be The Brightest GLAST
Sources in the Galaxy?," in The First GLAST Symposium,
edited by S. Ritz, P. Michelson, and C. A. Meegan, 2007,
vol. 921 of American Institute of Physics Conference
Series, pp. 385 -- 386.
11. Roberts, M. S. E., & Brogan, C. L. 2008, ApJ, 681, 320
12. F. Aharonian, et al. A& A 481, 401 -- 410 (2008).
13. J. Albert, et al. ApJL 664, L87 -- L90 (2007)
14. F. Aharonian, et al. A& A 467, 1075 -- 1080 (2007)
15. S. Johnston, L. Ball, N. Wang, and R. N. Manchester,
MNRAS 358, 1069 -- 1075 (2005)
16. A. Neronov, and M. Chernyakova, AP& SS 309, 253 -- 259
(2007)
17. E. D. Grundstrom, S. M. Caballero-Nieves, D. R. Gies,
W. Huang, M. V. McSwain, S. E. Rafter, R. L. Riddle,
S. J. Williams, and D. W. Wingert, ApJ 656, 437 -- 443
(2007)
18. J. Casares, I. Ribas, J. M. Paredes, J. Martí, and C. Allende
Prieto, MNRAS 360, 1105 -- 1109 (2005)
19. G. Dubus, A& A 456, 801 -- 817 (2006)
63 is a young pulsar in a 3.6 year highly eccentric orbit
around a Be Star. Near periastron, it becomes a moder-
ately bright unpulsed broad-band (radio-TeV) source (al-
though not yet seen in GeV) [15, 16]. LSI+61 303 and
LS 5039 are in much smaller eccentric orbits (26.5 and
3.9 days [17, 18]) which have moderately bright hard X-
ray emission but with luminosities about 2-3 orders of
magnitude smaller than known accreting systems. They
also have moderately bright and variable radio emission
(on the order of 100 mJy) extended on milliarcsecond
scales and are coincident with point sources of TeV emis-
sion [see 19, for an overview]. Their emission appears
modulated at the orbital period at all frequencies. Pulsa-
tions from LS 5039 and LSI+61 303 have not yet been
detected. We are performing deep, high frequency pulse
searches with the GBT. Since both of these sources are
prime targets for the Fermi telescope, we are monitoring
these two sources twice weekly in X-rays with RXTE. In
addition, there are supporting optical and radio monitor-
ing observations planned for LSI+61 303 and LS 5039
lasting through the first year of GLAST.
A CATALOG OF GALACTIC SOURCES
The space here is too limited to discuss all of the mul-
tiwavelength data of the bright Galactic GeV sources
that EGRET detected. An online catalog of multiwave-
length observations of Galactic EGRET sources is
being produced by M.S.E. Roberts, and can be found at:
http://www.physics.mcgill.ca/~pulsar/unidcat.html
This catalog is an expansion of the ASCA Catalog of
Potential Counterparts of GeV source [7] and is a work
in progress.
9.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This research has made use of data obtained from the
High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research
Center (HEASARC), provided by NASA's Goddard
Space Flight Center. The National Radio Astronomy Ob-
servatory Very Large Array is a facility of the National
Science Foundation operated under cooperative agree-
ment by Associated Universities, Inc. This research made
use of data products from the Midcourse Space Experi-
ment, processing of which data was funded by the Ballis-
tic Missile Defense Organization with additional support
from NASA Office of Space Science. The Australia Tele-
scope Compact Array is part of the Australia Telescope
which is funded by the Commonwealth of Australia for
operation as a National Facility managed by CSIRO.
Based on observations obtained with XMM-Newton, an
ESA science mission with instruments and contributions
directly funded by ESA Member States and NASA. This
|
0709.3988 | 2 | 0709 | 2008-04-13T02:43:16 | Do f(R) theories matter? | [
"astro-ph"
] | We consider a modified action functional with a non-minimum coupling between the scalar curvature and the matter Lagrangian, and study its consequences on stellar equilibrium. Particular attention is paid to the validity of the Newtonian regime, and on the boundary and exterior matching conditions, as well as on the redefinition of the metric components. Comparison with solar observables is achieved through numerical analysis, and constraints on the non-minimum coupling are discussed. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Do f (R) theories matter?
O. Bertolami∗ and J. P´aramos†
Instituto Superior T´ecnico, Departamento de F´ısica‡,
Av. Rovisco Pais 1, 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal
(Dated: October 30, 2018)
We consider a modified action functional with a non-minimum coupling between the scalar cur-
vature and the matter Lagrangian, and study its consequences on stellar equilibrium. Particular
attention is paid to the validity of the Newtonian regime, and on the boundary and exterior match-
ing conditions, as well as on the redefinition of the metric components. Comparison with solar
observables is achieved through numerical analysis, and constraints on the non-minimum coupling
are discussed.
PACS numbers: 04.20.Fy, 04.80.Cc, 97.10.Cv
Preprint DF/IST-7.2007
I.
INTRODUCTION
Modern cosmology faces two outstanding challenges,
namely the existence and nature of dark energy and dark
matter. Many theories have been put forward to address
both issues: for dark matter, several candidates are avail-
able, such as weak-interacting particles (WIMPs) aris-
ing from extensions to the Standard Model (e.g. axions,
neutralinos), etc.; for dark energy, "quintessence" mod-
els consider the slow-roll of a scalar field [1, 2], amongst
other candidates; others suggest that the averaging of
inhomogeneities at a cosmological scale may yield an ef-
fective scalar field, thus accounting for the dark energy
component of the Universe [3]. A possible unification of
both "dark" components has also been suggested, resort-
ing to a scalar field model [4] or an exotic equation of
state, as featured by the so-called modified Chaplygin
gas [5].
A different approach assumes that no extra energy
content is needed and that the fundamental laws and
tenets of gravitation may be incomplete, perhaps just a
low-energy approximation; as a consequence, modifica-
tions of the Friedmann equation to include higher order
terms in the energy density ρ (see e.g. [6] and references
therein) have been proposed or, at a more fundamental
level, changes to the action functional. A rather straight
forward approach lies in replacing the linear scalar cur-
vature term in the Einstein-Hilbert action by a function
of the scalar curvature, f (R); alternatively, one could re-
sort to other scalar invariants of the theory [7]. This has
led to some success in replicating the accelerated expan-
sion of the Universe, while comparison with its evolu-
tion throughout the different ages has yielded some con-
straints and exclusions to the form of f (R); perhaps the
most well-known proposal of this type is the Starobin-
sky inflationary model, where a quadratic term in the
curvature is added to the usual linear form (plus cosmo-
‡Also at Instituto de Plasmas e Fusao Nuclear, IST, Lisbon
∗Electronic address: [email protected]
†Electronic address: [email protected]
logical constant), f (R) = R − Λ + αR2 [8]. Solar system
tests could also bring further insight, mostly arising from
the parameterized post-Newtonian (PPN) metric coeffi-
cients derived from this extension of general relativity
(GR). However, some disagreement exists in the commu-
nity, with some arguing that no changes are predicted
at a post-Newtonian level (see e.g.
[9] and references
therein); amongst other considerations, this mostly stems
from an approach based either in the more usual metric
affine connection (that is, where the affine connection is
taken a priori as depending on the metric), or in the
so-called Palatini approach [10] (where both the met-
ric and the affine connection are taken as independent
variables). As an example of a clear phenomenological
consequence of this extension of GR, it has been shown
that f (R) = f0Rn theories yield a gravitational poten-
tial which displays an increasing, repulsive contribution,
added to the Newtonian term [11].
Notwithstanding the significant literature on these
f (R) models, few steps have been taken to address an-
other interesting possibility: not only that the curvature
is non-trivial in the Einstein-Hilbert Lagrangian, but also
that the coupling between matter and geometry is not
minimum; indeed, these are only implicitly related in the
action functional, since one expects that covariantly in-
variant terms in Lm should be constructed by contrac-
tion with the metric (e.g. the kinetic term of a real scalar
field, gµνφ,µφ,ν ). A non-minimum coupling would imply
that geometric quantities (such as the scalar invariants)
would explicitly show in the action; asides from theo-
retical elegance, this could have deep phenomenological
implications:
indeed, in regions where the curvature is
high (which, in GR, are related to regions of high en-
ergy density or pressure), the implications of such the-
ory could deviate considerably from those predicted by
Einstein's theory [12]. Related proposals have been put
forward previously to address the problem of the accel-
erated expansion of the Universe [13] and the existence
of a cosmological constant [14].
In this sense, the immediate question, posed in the ti-
tle of this work, is: what are the implications for the be-
haviour of matter under such conditions? Some work has
been put forward concerning this issue, namely changes
to geodetic behaviour [12], the possibility of modelling
dark matter [15] and the violation of the highly con-
strained equivalence principle [16]. Perhaps the most
important consequence of the mentioned studies is that
energy may no longer be covariantly conserved, that is,
∇µTµν 6= 0, where Tµν is the energy-momentum tensor
of matter; this occurs because, due to the presence of
extra terms in the equations of motion, the Bianchi iden-
tities no longer imply in the covariant conservation of the
energy-momentum tensor.
This work addresses what we believe is the natu-
ral proving ground for a non-minimally coupled gravity
model: regions where the density may be high enough,
to evidence some deviation from GR, although moderate
enough so that effects are still perturbative -- a star. The
results rely upon and expand the methodology followed
by the authors in previous studies [17, 18]. This paper
is divided in the following sections: first, we present the
model upon which the subsequent work is based; then, we
develop the equations of motion, aiming at the modified
Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation, with due
care taken regarding the validity of the Newtonian regime
and resulting modified hydrostatic equilibrium equation;
afterwards, we insert the polytropic equation of state into
the latter, and compute the necessary observables; a nu-
merical session follows, where profiles and bounds are
computed for the relevant quantities; finally, a discussion
of our results is presented.
II. THE MODEL
Following the discussion of the previous section, one
postulates the following action for the theory [12],
S =Z (cid:20) 1
2
f1(R) + [1 + λf2(R)]Lm(cid:21) √−gd4x
(1)
where fi(R) (with i = 1, 2) are arbitrary functions of the
scalar curvature R, Lm is the Lagrangian density of mat-
ter and g is the metric determinant. For convenience, the
contribution of the non-minimum coupling of f2 is gauged
through the coupling constant λ (which has dimensions
[λ] = [f2]−1). The standard Einstein-Hilbert action is
recovered by taking f2 = 0 and f1 = 2κ(R − 2Λ), where
κ = c4/16πG and Λ is the cosmological constant (from
now on, one works in a unit system where c = 1).
Variation with respect to the metric gµν yields the
modified Einstein equations of motion, here arranged as
1
2
f1gµν =
(F1 + 2λF2Lm) Rµν −
( µν − gµν
) (F1 + 2λF2Lm) + [1 + λf2] Tµν ,
µν ≡ ∇µ∇ν for convenience, as well
where one defines
as Fi(R) ≡ f ′(R), and omitted the argument. The mat-
ter energy-momentum tensor is, as usually, defined by
(2)
Tµν = −
2
√−g
δ (√−gLm)
δgµν
.
2
(3)
As stated before, the Bianchi identities, ∇µGµν = 0
imply the non-(covariant) conservation law
∇µTµν =
λF2
1 + λf2
(gµνLm − Tµν )∇µR ,
(4)
and, as expected, in the GR limit λ → 0, one recovers
the conservation law ∇µTµν = 0.
A. Scope of application
(2),
It is our stated purpose to arrive at the modified form
of the TOV equation, the relativistic version of the hy-
drostatic equilibrium condition. From Eq.
it is
clear that a full treatment of the equations of motion
is unattainable unless some specific form for f1(R) and
f2(R) is provided. Furthermore, the presence of both the
pure curvature and non-minimum coupling, respectively,
still constitutes a daunting analytical challenge; hence,
and since one is mainly interested in the relevance of
the effects within a high curvature and pressure medium,
where f2 should overwhelm the modification of the pure
curvature term, f1 − 2κR (neglecting the contribution of
the cosmological constant), it appears sensible to discard
the latter; a treatment of the standard f (R) scenario with
f2 = 0 may be found in Ref. [19].
Mathematically, the chosen approximation reads as
1
2f1 − κR ≪ λf2Lm
F1 − 2κ ≪ 2λF2Lm
,
,
( µν − gµν
) F1 ≪ 2 λ ( µν − gµν
(5)
) (F2Lm)
.
where the second and third inequalities indicate that this
regime stems not just from the comparison between con-
tributions to the action functional, but also those in-
volved in the modified Einstein equations (2); also, notice
that the perturbative condition λf2(R) ≪ 1 has not been
enforced yet. The last inequality is satisfied if the follow-
ing stronger conditions hold,
d(F2Lm)
dr
d2(F2Lm)
λ
dr2
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ
dF1
d2F1
dr (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
≪ 2(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
≪ 2(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
This said, one considers the simplest form f2 = R; this
linear coupling could arise from a first order expansion
of a more general f2(R) function, in the weak field en-
viron of the Sun. Also, one takes Lm = p, a natural
,
(6)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
.
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
choice for the Lagrangian density of an ideal fluid [20] --
characterised by the standard energy-momentum tensor
Tµν = (ρ + p)uµuν − pgµν ,
(7)
where p is the fluid's pressure, ρ its matter-energy density
and u its 4-velocity vector, with uµ = (u0,~0), uµ
µ = 1, so
that u0 = g1/2
Inserting the above expressions for f2
00 .
and Lm, the inequalities (5) become
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
,
f1 ≪ 2 (κ + λp) R
,
F1 ≪ 2 κ + λp
dF1
≪ 2 λp′(r)
,
(8)
(9)
≪ 2λp′′(r)
, (10)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
d2F1
dr2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
where the prime denotes derivation with respect to the
radial coordinate. Clearly, if f1 = 2κR → F1 = 2κ, these
are trivially satisfied. Also, notice that f2 = R implies
that [λ] = [f −1
2 ] = [R]−1 = M −2.
[2]
One must now ascertain the form of f1(R).
In
Ref.
it is shown that acceptable models with
f1a = 2κ(R − αR1−m) (α > 0, [α] = [Rm] = M 2m and
0 < m < 1 or f1b = 2κ(R + αR2 − Λ) (with αΛ ≪ 1 and
[α] = [R−1] = M −2) are cosmologically viable; the latter
may arise from the renomalizability of the theory near
the Planck scale, with α ∼ M −2 and M = 1012 GeV [2].
For the perturbative regime to be valid, one must have,
for the f1 = f1a case
3
1
2
R (gµν + aTµν) =
(13)
(1 + ap) Rµν −
a( µν − gµν
)p +
1
2κ
Tµν ,
where one defines the parameter a ≡ λ/κ = 16πGλ, with
dimension [a] = M −4; accordingly, both ap and aρ are
dimensionless quantities. In the above form, the physi-
cal meaning of the proposed model is more transparent:
aside from a pressure-dependent term on the r.h.s., the
most interesting modification occurs on the l.h.s.; firstly,
the contribution of the Riemann tensor is modified by
a factor 1 + ap; secondly, the scalar curvature is cou-
pled not only to the metric gµν, but also to the energy-
momentum tensor Tµν. One thus gets a clear picture of
the matter-geometry interaction, which occurs via scalar-
tensor combinations.
By taking the trace of the above equation, one obtains
R = − −3aκ p + T
κ [2 + a (T − 2p)]
=
3p − ρ + 3aκ p
κ [2 + a(ρ − 5p)]
,
(14)
having inserted T = T µ
µ = ρ − 3p. Interestingly enough,
in the "strong" a → ∞ regime it yields the asymptotic re-
sult R = 3 p/(ρ−5p): in this regime, a varying, low den-
sity can give origin to extremely high curvatures, while
an almost uniform, even if a high density fluid might yield
a vanishingly small curvature.
(11)
C. Perturbative regime
,
1
λ ≫ ακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
Rmp(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫ (1 − m)mακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫ (1 − m)mακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
,
1
1
dR
R1+mp′
dr(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr(cid:1)2
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
R (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr2 − (1 + m)(cid:0) dR
R1+mp′′(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
d2R
.
Foreseeing a later comparison with solar observables,
which one knows are well predicted by GR, it is now
assumed that the effect of f2 yields only perturbative
corrections: in the approximation λf2 = λR ≪ 1, the
scalar curvature is given by R ≈ (3p − ρ)/κ, resulting in
(λ/κ)(3p − ρ) = a(3p − ρ) ≪ 1; anticipating the New-
tonian approximation p ≪ ρ, this yields aρ ≪ 1 and
ap ≪ 1. Inserting Eq. (14) in the Einstein equation,
one obtains, after some algebraic manipulation,
while, for the f1 = f1b case (which can be derived from
the above inequalities, setting m = −1, α → −α and
ignoring the cosmological constant term),
,
R
dR
p(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫ ακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫ 2ακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
p′′(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
dr2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫ 2ακ(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
1
p′
1
d2R
,
(12)
κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)]Rµν =
(3p − ρ)gµν + 2(1 − ap)Tµν + aκ(4 µν − gµν
(15)
)p ,
keeping only first order terms in a. This shall be the
main tool for the derivation of the TOV equation.
.
III. STELLAR EQUILIBRIUM
B. Equation of motion
A. Static, spherical symmetric scenario
With the above choice for f1 and f2, the equation of
motion becomes
Since one is dealing with an ideal, spherically symmet-
ric system, in which temporal variations are assumed to
occur only at the cosmological scale H −1
0 , and hence neg-
ligible at an astrophysical time scale, one considers the
Birkhoff metric (in its anisotropic form), given by the line
element
ds2 = eν(r)dt2 −(cid:16)eσ(r)dr2 + dΩ2(cid:17) ,
with dΩ = r2(dθ2 + sin2θ dφ2), so that √−g =
r2 sinθ e(ν+σ)/2.
(16)
B. Newtonian limit
4
Before continuing the derivation, it is opportune to ad-
dress the issue of the validity of the Newtonian regime;
clearly, establishing this limit will enable many fruitful
simplifications in the calculations ahead.
In the stan-
dard derivation of the hydrostatic equilibrium equation,
this arises from a set of simplifications imposed on the
relativistic TOV equation; the later reads,
One can resort to the expression of the Riemann tensor
and Eq. (15) to obtain the following intermediary step
(the full algebraic derivation is shown in Appendix A):
p′(r) = −
G
r2
[ρ(r) + p(r)][me(r) + 4πp(r)r3]
1 − 2Gme(r)/r
,
(22)
κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)](cid:20) 1
ap
2
(ρ + 3p) +
1
r2 + e−σ(cid:18) σ′
r −
2 (cid:18)5e−ν
00 + 3e−σ
r2(cid:19)(cid:21) = ρ − (17)
r2 (cid:19) p .
rr + 2 θθ
aκ
One now defines the parameter me, here called the ef-
fective mass, to distinguish it from its identification with
the gravitational mass of the unperturbed GR scenario,
derived from the Schwarzschild metric; it is given by the
usual expression
e−σ = 1 −
2Gme
r
,
which yields
r2 + e−σ(cid:18) σ′
(cid:20) 1
r −
1
r2(cid:19)(cid:21) =
2Gm′
e
r2
,
(18)
(19)
where the prime denotes differentiation with respect to
the radial coordinate. Inserting the above in Eq. (17)
and solving for m′
e, one gets
and the Newtonian approximation is valid if the following
inequalities are satisfied
r ≫ 2Gme(r) , ρ(r) ≫ p(r) , me(r) ≫ 4πp(r)r3 , (23)
yielding the non-relativistic hydrostatic equation of state
p′(r) = −G
ρ(r)me(r)
r2
.
(24)
Since is is assumed that the coupling between mat-
ter and geometry will only produce a perturbative effect,
leading to the redefinition of mass through Eq. (21), it
is clear that no changes occur regarding the validity of
the Newtonian approximation. Hence, foreseeing the ap-
plication of the following results to the Sun, where such
regime is valid, one may simplify the intermediate calcu-
lations and, when convenient, insert the inequalities (23)
in order to simplify a-dependent terms. By the same to-
ken, terms involving the coupling between a-dependent
quantities and any covariant derivatives may be evalu-
ated by taking their Newtonian counterparts,
eν−σ
00p = −
2
rrp = p′′ +
θθp = e−σrp′ ≈ rp′
ν′p′ ≈ 0 ,
σ′p′ ≈ p′′
.
1
2
(25)
,
m′
e = 4πr2ρ
ar2
4G (cid:0)5e−ν
2 − ap(cid:16)1 + 3p
ρ (cid:17)
2 + a(ρ − 3p)
00 + 3e−σ
2 + a(ρ − 3p)
rr + 2
r2
+
(20)
θθ(cid:1) p
.
Notice that this does not imply that one is directly de-
riving the Newtonian hydrostatic equilibrium equation,
since leading order terms will not be approximated.
In the perturbative regime, one may take only first-order
terms in ap and aρ, obtaining
C. Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equation
p2
m′
e ≈ 4πr2ρ(cid:20)1 + a(cid:18)p −
8G (cid:18)5e−ν
00 + 3e−σ
ρ
2 −
rr + 2 θθ
ρ (cid:19)(cid:21) +
r2 (cid:19) p ,
3
2
ar2
using 4Gκ = 1/4π. The above expression clearly shows
the perturbation to the purely gravitational mass, de-
fined by m′
g = 4πr2ρ.
(21)
By following a procedure similar to the one leading
to Eq. (17) (depicted in Appendix A), one obtains the
following equation:
κ [2 + a (ρ − 3p)](cid:20)(cid:18)1 −
2 (cid:18)3e−ν
(p − ρ) +
ap
2
p +
aκ
2Gme
r (cid:19) ν′
r −
00 + 5e−σ
2Gme
r3 (cid:21) = (26)
r2 (cid:19) p .
rr − 2 θθ
Substituting by the expressions for the covariant deriva-
tives, one gets
00p ≈ 0
,
rrp ≈ p′′
,
θθp ≈ rp′
.
(33)
5
(27)
This approximation, together with p ≪ ρ, implies that
rr − 2 θθ
r2 (cid:19) p =
00 + 5e−σ
2Gme
r (cid:19) p′′ +
(cid:18)3e−ν
5(cid:18)1 −
(cid:20)5
1
Gme
Gm′
e
2Gme
r (cid:18)2 +
r (cid:19) 3ν′
2 −
r −(cid:18)1 −
r (cid:19)(cid:21) p′
One now introduces the approximations discussed in the
previous subsection. Also, the approximation m′
e ≈
g = 4πρr2 is taken, since the perturbative corrections
m′
would produce second order terms in a. One obtains,
after a little algebra,
.
2Gme
κ (2 + aρ)(cid:18) ν′
r3 (cid:19) =
r −
2 (cid:20)5p′′ +(cid:18)5
aκ
ρ(cid:17) +
p(cid:16)1 −
a
2
Solving for ν′, one gets
(28)
Gm′
e
r −
3ν′
2 −
2
r(cid:19) p′(cid:21) .
ν′
2
= G
(2 + aρ) me + 4 (2 − aρ) πpr3
r (r − 2Gme)(cid:2)2 + a(cid:0)ρ + 3
4 rp′(cid:1)(cid:3)
4 p′′ +(cid:0)5πGρr − 1
2r(cid:1) p′
2 + a(cid:0)ρ + 3
4 rp′(cid:1)
r − 2Gme
r2
5
a
When a = 0, one recovers the standard expression
+ (29)
with
.
m′
e ≈ 4πr2ρ + ar2(cid:18) 3p′′
8G
+
p′
4Gr − 2πρ2(cid:19) .
(34)
Similarly, one obtains
κ (2 + aρ)
R ≈ −ρ − 3aκ(cid:0)p′′ + 2
r p′(cid:1)
2(cid:20)3(cid:18)p′′ +
ρ
2κ −
−
2
r
a
(35)
≈
p′(cid:19) −
ρ2
2κ(cid:21) .
Although the expression for the scalar curvature R is
somewhat involved, one can approximate its derivative by
the unperturbed value R′ = −ρ′/2κ, losing only terms of
order O(a2); indeed, one could write
R′ = −
λR′ = −
ρ′
2κ
λρ′
2κ
+ aF (ρ, p) →
+ aλF (ρ, p) = −
a
2
(36)
ρ′ + a2 F (ρ, p)
κ
,
F (ρ, p) = −
1
2(cid:20)3(cid:18)p′′ +
2
r
p′(cid:19) −
ρ2
2κ(cid:21)′
.
(37)
To write the modified equation of hydrostatic equilib-
rium, one now resorts to the non-(covariant )conservation
of the energy-momentum tensor, Eq. (4). The expression
for the covariant derivative is purely geometric; in order
to derive an expression for p′, one aims at the ν = r com-
ponent of the above equation; with our choice of f2 = R
and Lm = p, one gets the modified TOV equation
ν′
2
(ρ + p) =
2λ
1 + λR (cid:18)1 −
2Gme
r (cid:19) R′ → (38)
(ρ + p) ≈ p′ −
2λp
1 + λR
R′ ≈ p′ + apρ′
,
p′ +
ν′
2
−
dropping higher order terms and using R′ = −ρ′/2κ.
equations for the problem at hand:
Thus, one finally obtains a set of three differential
(ρ + p) ,
ν′
2
p′ − 2λpR′ = −
e = 4πr2ρ + ar2(cid:18) 3p′′
m′
8G
+
ν′
2
= G
me + 4πpr3
r2 − 2Gmer
+ a(cid:20)(cid:18) 5
p′
4Gr − 2πρ2(cid:19) ,
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:19) r −
8
(39)
(40)
p′
4(cid:21) .(41)
me + 4πpr3
r2 − 2Gmer
Linearizing with respect to a yields
ν′
2
= G
.
(30)
ν′
2
= G
me + 4πpr3
r2 − 2Gmer
+ ah(p, ρ) ,
(31)
where the function h(p, ρ) is defined through
h(p, ρ) =
(32)
,
1
8
8
2
3
8
p′
4
Gρr2 −
Gme
r −
4(cid:19) p′ ≈
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:19) r +(cid:18) 5π
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:19) r −
(cid:18) 5
(cid:18) 5
after considering the inequality r ≫ 2Gme and also
5πGρr2/2 ≪ 1; taking the Sun's maximum, central,
density ρc = 1.622 × 105 kg/m3, and the radius R⊙ =
6.955 × 108 m, one gets 5πGρr2/2c2 = 4.57 × 10−4 ≪ 1.
Before continuing, one can rewrite the expression for
the gravitational mass, obtained before, but imposing the
limit e−σ ≈ e−ν ≈ 1, ν′ ≈ σ′ ≈ 0, which yields
Substituting Eq. (39) into (41), after some algebra one
gets the modified TOV equation,
p′ + G(ρ + p)
=
me + 4πpr3
r2 − 2Gmer
p′
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:21) r −
a(cid:20)(cid:18)(cid:20) 5
8
4(cid:19) ρ + pρ′(cid:21) .
(42)
This yields the non-relativistic hydrostatic equilibrium
equation,
p′ +
Gmeρ
r2 = a(cid:20)(cid:18)(cid:20) 5
8
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:21) r −
p′
4(cid:19) ρ + pρ′(cid:21) .
(43)
D. Polytropic equation of state
Realistic stellar models rely on four differential equa-
tions, together with appropriate definitions [21]; aside
from the mass conservation condition (40) and the hy-
drostatic equilibrium equation (42) or (43), these express
energy conservation and transport, through
and
dL(r)
dr
= 4πr2ǫρ(r)
dT (r)
dr
= −
L(r)
4πr2λc
,
(44)
(45)
respectively. In the above, L(r) is the energy flow across
a sphere of radius r, ǫ is the energy generation rate per
mass unit, and λc is the conductivity coefficient. For
given ǫ and λc, which account for the processes ongoing
inside the star, one is left with five unknowns, m′
e, p, ρ,
T and L; an additional relation is needed, in the form of
a suitable equation of state p = p(ρ).
Many candidate equations of state and solar models are
available, with varying degrees of sofistication, account-
ing for effects such as chemical composition, solar mat-
ter mixing, discontinuities between layers, heat difusion,
etc.; two outstanding examples are the Mihalas-Hummer-
Dappen and OPAL equations of state [22]. However,
solving the above set of differential equations with a re-
alistic equation of state requires heavy-duty numerical
integration with complex code designs, and an analysis
of the perturbations induced by a non-minimum coupling
between matter and curvature is beyond the scope of the
present study.
Instead, one may resort to a very simplistic assump-
tion, the so-called polytropic equation of state. This
is commonly given by p = Kρ(n+1)/n
, where K is the
polytropic constant, ρ0 is the baryonic mass density and
n is the polytropic index [21, 23, 24]. The polytropic
B
6
index n interpolates between the basic thermodynami-
cal processes: n = −1 for isobaric, n = 0 for isomet-
ric, and an infinite polytropic index n for an isothermal
sphere. Adiabatic processes yield n = 1/(γA − 1), with
γA = cp/cV the adiabatic coefficient. Several crude ap-
proximations to relevant astrophysical systems are also
obtained: n = 3/2 may model the degenerate star
cores found in giant (gaseous) planets, white or brown
dwarfs,and red giants; a polytropic index n = 5 yields a
boundless system (that is, with non-vanishing density ev-
erywhere), which was taken by Schuster as the first can-
didate for a stellar system. Finally, a polytropic equation
of state was used by Eddington in his proposal for the
first solar model, with n = 3; naturally, it does not offer
an accurate description of the solar interior, and has been
deprecated by the following advancements.
Nonetheless, the use of a polytropic equation of state
is still of interest, due to its simplicity and ease of ma-
nipulation, which render it a valuable tool in more the-
oretically driven studies, as is the present case (as an
example, the generalized Chaplygin gas is a polytrope
with index n = −1/(1 + α) [18]). Clearly, more realis-
tic assumptions regarding the structure of the Sun would
improve the final results; also, the procedure outlined in
this work could also be applied to more exotic bodies,
either through the use of an adequate polytropic index,
or via a more realistic equation of state, possibly yielding
a more stringent constraint on the coupling parameter λ.
Recall that the effective mass me is defined in terms
of the energy density ρ, which appears in the energy-
momentum tensor;
these two quantities are related
through ρ = ρB + np, yielding the relation
ρ =(cid:16) p
K(cid:17)n/(n+1)
+ np .
(46)
However, since one is interested in probing the Newtonian
regime which occurs in the Sun, the condition p ≪ ρ
holds; therefore, ρ ≃ ρB, and one may take the form
p = Kρ(n+1)/n for the equation of state [25].
In order to transform the modified hydrostatic equilib-
rium Eq. (43) into a differential equation with a single
variable, one first rewrites Eq. (43) as
1
r2 (cid:20) r2
ρ (cid:18)p′ + a(cid:20)(cid:18)(cid:20) 5
= −4πGρ − a(cid:18) 3p′′
8
8
p′′ − 4πGpρ(cid:21) r −
4r − 2πGρ2(cid:19) ,
p′
+
p′
4(cid:19) ρ + pρ′(cid:21)(cid:19)(cid:21)′
(47)
and inserts the polytropic equation of state, p =
Kρ(n+1)/n, written as ρ = ρcθn(ξ) and p = pcθn+1(ξ),
with ξ = r/r0 a dimensionless variable and r2
0 ≡
(n + 1)pc/4πGρ2
c; as stated before, ρc = 1.622 ×
105 kg/m3 is the central density, and pc = 2.48× 1016 P a
is the central pressure. One obtains the perturbed Lane-
Emden equation for the function θ(ξ):
1
ξ2 (cid:20)ξ2θ′(cid:18)1 + Acθn(cid:20)(cid:20) 5
8(cid:18)θ′′ + n
θ′2
θ (cid:19) − Ncθn+1(cid:21) ξ
θ′ +
4(n + 1)(cid:21)(cid:19)(cid:21)′
3n − 1
= −θn(cid:20)1 + Ac(cid:18) 3
8(cid:20)θ′′ + n
θ′2
θ (cid:21) +
θ′
4ξ −
7
θn
2 (cid:19)(cid:21) ,
(48)
where the prime now denotes derivation with respect to
the dimensionless radial coordinate ξ, and one has de-
fined Ac ≡ aρc and Nc ≡ pc/ρc = 1.7 × 10−6, for con-
venience. Obviously, setting Ac = 0 one recovers the
unperturbed Lane-Emden equation [21]
1
ξ2 (cid:0)ξ2θ′(cid:1)′
= −θn .
(49)
One may try to solve Eq.
(48) analytically around
ξ = 0, and compare with the solution of the unperturbed
equation, given (in the vicinity of ξ = 0) by [21]
θ(ξ) ≈ 1 −
1
6
ξ2 +
n
120
ξ4 .
This calculation (outlined in Appendix B) yields
θ(ξ) ≈ 1 − Aξ2 + Bξ4 ,
A =
1
6(cid:18)1 − Ac
13 + 25n
12(n + 1)(cid:19) ,
with
and
B =
n
120(cid:18)1 − Ac
11
60
39 + 59n
n + 1 (cid:19) ,
(50)
(51)
(52)
(53)
neglecting the Nc ≪ 1 term and taking the limit Ac ≪
1. Taking Ac = 0 gives back the unperturbed values
A = 1/6 and B = n/120, as expected.
For n = 0 (a constant density model), one finds
θ(ξ) ≈ 1 −
1
6(cid:18)1 −
11
6
Ac(cid:19) ξ2 .
(54)
For n = 3 (the first proposed model for the Sun), one
obtains
θ(ξ) ≈ 1−
1
6(cid:18)1 −
11
6
Ac(cid:19) ξ2 +
1
40(cid:18)1 −
99
10
Ac(cid:19) ξ4 . (55)
Finally, for n → ∞ (an isothermal sphere), one gets
Ac(cid:19) ξ4 .
Ac(cid:19) ξ2 +
40(cid:18)1 −
6(cid:18)1 −
θ(ξ) ≈ 1 −
1837
180
23
12
1
1
(56)
E. Perturbative solution
Inspection of Eq. (48) shows that it is a third-order
equation, while the unperturbed Lane-Emden equation is
only second-order. Thus, the initial conditions θ(0) = 1
and θ′(0) = 0 alone are not sufficient. Indeed, an extra
condition regarding the initial behaviour of the second
derivative must be provided; this is derived from the se-
ries expansion of θ around ξ = 0 taken before, that is
θ′′(0) = −
1
3(cid:18)1 − Ac
13 + 25n
12(n + 1)(cid:19) .
(57)
In order to numerically solve the perturbed Lane-
(48) (after a long
Emden equation, one rewrites Eq.
derivation) as
θ′′′ = −
24
5
Nc
+
4
5
θn(cid:20) 1
ξ
.
2
8
θn
ξ θ′
5Acξ " θ′′ + 2
θn+1
5(cid:20)4
ξ −
+ 2(2n + 1)Ncθ′(cid:21) − n
+ 1# − n(n − 1)
7n − 1
n + 1
θ (cid:20)3θ′′ +
3n + 2
n + 1
θ′′
ξ
θ′
+
θ′3
θ2
(58)
θ′
ξ2(cid:21) +
8
5
3n + 2
n + 1
θ′
ξ (cid:21)
Clearly, when Ac → 0, the first term blows up unless it is
compensated by the condition θ′′ + 2θ′/ξ = −θn, which
is precisely the unperturbed Lane-Emden equation. By
the same token, the first term expresses the deviation
from the unperturbed case, and should be of order Ac,
therefore cancelling out the divergence.
However, implementing the above third order differ-
ential equation proves too computationally demanding;
thus, one must first approach the perturbed Lane-Emden
equation and, given that one is searching for a perturba-
tion, expand it in terms of θ = θ0(1 + Acδ), where θ0
is the solution to the unperturbed Lane-Emden equation
and δ is the (relative) perturbation, obeying Acδ ≪ 1.
Thus, one may write, for n > 0,
θn = θn
0 (1 + Acδ)n ≈ θn
0 (1 + nAcδ)
.
(59)
If this expansion is introduced in the perturbed Lane-
Emden equation, and considering only terms of order Ac,
one obtains a differential equation for δ, with θ0 as source:
δ′′ + 2(cid:18) θ′
0
θ0
+
1
ξ(cid:19) δ′ + (n − 1)θn−1
0
δ =
5n
2
ξθ2n−2
0
θ′
0 (60)
σ′
−(R⊙) = −2G
8
,
(63)
+(2n + 1)Ncξθ2n−1
0
θ′
0 +
θ2n−1
0
+ 3Ncθ2n
0
9n + 5
4(n + 1)
5n(n − 1)
8
−
ξθn−3
0
θ′3
0 +
n(3n + 7)
4(n + 1)
θn−2
0
θ′2
0 +
θ′
0
1
2
θn−1
0
ξ
.
having eliminated the second derivative of the unper-
turbed solution through Eq. (49). From Eq. (51), one
concludes that this differential equation is supplemented
by the initial conditions δ(0) = 0 and δ′(0) = 0.
Note that δ does not depend on Ac: one must only
find the unique δ (for each Nc and n); one aims at a
simultaneous variation of the model's parameter Ac and
the polytropic index n in the vicinity of the standard
solar value n = 3, enabling the plotting of an exclusion
graph in the (Ac, n) plane. For n = 3, the differential
equation for δ simplifies to
δ′′ + 2(cid:18) θ′
0
θ0
+
1
ξ(cid:19) δ′ + 2θ2
7Ncξθ5
0θ′
0 +
ξθ4
0θ′
0 +
0δ = 3Ncθ6
0 + 2θ5
0 +
(61)
15
2
1
2ξ
θ2
0θ′
0 + 3θ0θ′2
0 −
15
4
ξθ′3
0
.
F. Mass budget and matching conditions
One now computes the deviation between the effective
mass me, defined in Eq. (21), and the gravitational mass,
defined by m′
g = 4πr2ρ; some algebra yields
m′
e − m′
g =
n + 1
G
AcNcξ2θn
0 (cid:20)−
3n
8
θ′2
0
θ0
+
θ′
0
2ξ
+
7
8
θn
(62)
0(cid:21) ,
which is explicitly written in terms of Ac = aρc, the
model's dimensionless parameter, and Nc ≡ pc/ρc, the
ratio that measures the validity of the Newtonian regime.
One has also to eliminate δ′′
0 through Eq. (49); one con-
cludes that not only is the above mass difference small
(due to the perturbative regime, Ac ≪ 1), but that it is
further suppressed by the factor Nc ≪ 1.
Clearly, the model's parameters should be adjusted to
the known observables: the star's radius R⊙ and mass
M . The issue of this identification is rather delicate;
indeed, M should not be identified with the gravitational
mass mg(R⊙), but with the total effective mass me(R⊙).
Asides from the physical interpretation of the full energy
content of the star affecting geodetic motion around it,
one can also resort to the matching conditions of the
inner metric with the outer Schwarzschild metric; indeed,
writing Me ≡ me(R⊙), Mg ≡ mg(R⊙), M ′
e(R⊙)
and M ′
e ≡ m′
g(R⊙), one has
g ≡ m′
Me − M ′
eR⊙
R⊙(R⊙ − 2GMe)
,
GM
R⊙(R⊙ − 2GM )
+
GMe
σ′
+ = −2
ν′
−(R⊙) = 2
R⊙(R⊙ − 2GMe)
4 (cid:18) 5
a
ν′
+ = −σ′
+ = 2
2
GM
p′′(R⊙)R⊙ − p′(R⊙)(cid:19) ,
R⊙(R⊙ − 2GM )
,
where the + and − subscripts indicate inner or outer
boundary condition. If one identifies M = Me, it follows
that M ′
e = 0, which implies
3p′′(R⊙)
2
+
p′(R⊙)
R⊙
= 0 ,
(after resorting to Eq. (21), with ρ(R⊙) = 0), and
5
2
p′′(R⊙)R⊙ − p′(R⊙) = 0 .
Clearly, both conditions hold, since
(64)
(65)
p′(R⊙) ∝ θ′(ξ1)θn(ξ1) = 0 ,
p′′(R⊙) ∝ θ′′(ξ1)θ(ξ1)n + nθ′(ξ1)2θ(ξ1)n−1 = 0 ,
(66)
where ξ1 signals the star's boundary, through θ(ξ1) = 0.
G. A solution for the divergence problem
Given the identification M = Me ≡ me(R⊙), one can
now deduce the perturbation to the central density ρc,
which is a model dependent parameter. However, before
using Eq. (48) to evaluate the perturbation δ and extract
relevant quantities, it should be noticed that, by inspec-
tion, it is clear that δ diverges when θ0 approaches zero.
Hence, one cannot extend the perturbational approach
to the full range of the star, and should instead deal with
the full differential equation for the perturbed θ.
In order to circumvent this issue, recall that there is
a pronounced deviation between the predictions of the
polytropic model and the realistic Standard Solar Model,
for r > Rr = 0.713 R⊙; this reflects the crossing from the
radiative zone, where the n = 3 polytrope is a good ap-
proximation for the Sun, and the convection zone, where
this approach fails. Hence, the irregular behaviour of δ
near ξ1 may be safely disregarded, since the fundamen-
tal equation for θ is not valid there. Instead, one shall
consider only the range 0 ≤ r ≤ Rr or, equivalently,
In doing so, one is of course
0 ≤ ξ ≤ ξr = 0.713 ξ1.
neglecting the contribution of the latter for all relevant
9
quantities: however, although the density and pressure
are still significant at that point, both the polytropic and
the Standard Solar Model show that up to 99.1% of the
Sun's mass is located within the radiative zone.
Also,it can be numerically shown that the boundary
condition θ(ξ) = θ0(ξ)(1 + Acδ(ξ)) = 0 does not shift
significantly from the unperturbed θ0(ξ1) = 0 case, so
that no problem arises from neglecting any changes to
the scale factor r0 (which, recall, relates the dimension-
less coordinate ξ with the physical distance to the center
r). Furthermore, the matching of the inner and outer
derivatives of the metric should not be taken as a real-
istic condition, but merely a consistency check for the
developed model.
H. Model-dependent parameters
FIG. 1: Profiles for the unperturbed solution θ0 (top) and
absolute perturbation ∆ = δθ0 (bottom), for 2.8 ≤ n ≤ 3.2.
One proceeds with the calculation of the total mass of
the Sun or, more accurately, the mass of the radiative
zone: for the unperturbed case, one has (see Appendix
C for the derivation of the following results)
M = −4π
R3
r
ξr
ρc0θ′
0r → ρc0 = −
M
4πθ′
0r
ξr
R3
r
.
(67)
where one defines θ′
0(ξr) and ρc0 is the unperturbed
central density (that is, obtained from M , R and the
numerical results for the unperturbed solution θ0).
0r ≡ θ′
In the perturbed case, one obtains
R3
r
ξr
ρcθ′
M = −4π
"1 −
Ac
r θ′
ξ2
0r Z ξr
0
0r ×
0 (cid:18)nδ +
ξ2θn
(68)
3n
8
θ′2
0
θ0 −
θ′
0
2ξ −
7
8
θn
0(cid:19) dξ# .
Notice that there are two Ac-dependent contributions:
one arising from θ0 and its derivatives, since including
the perturbation δ would only amount to second-order
terms O(A2
c ), and other involving the integral of δ.
Since the total mass M does not change (only its in-
terpretation as a purely gravitational mass or a sum of
gravitational plus "active" components), one gets
1 −
Ac
r θ′
ξ2
ρc0
ρc
=
0r Z ξr
0
(69)
ξ2θn
0 (cid:20)nδ +
3n
8
θ′2
0
θ0 −
θ′
0
2ξ −
7
8
θn
0(cid:21) dξ .
Clearly, taking Ac = 0 yields ρc = ρc0. Also, notice
that ξr is not perturbed: this would reflect a change in ξ1
(since ξr = 0.713 ξ1), which has already been ruled out.
Also, notice that the denominator affecting the integral
is equal to ξ2
0 : thus, one can
0 (ξ2θ′
0 θn
r θ′
0r =R ξr
0)′ = −R ξr
interpret this integral as the volume averaging of the ex-
pression in brackets within the integrand, with the den-
sity as weighting function, that is, θn ∝ ρ.
T n+1, which enables writing
From the polytropic equation of state, one gets ρ ∝
Tc (cid:19)n+1
1 −(cid:18) Tc0
0r Z ξr
Ac
r θ′
ξ2
ξ2θn
0
=
(70)
0 (cid:20)nδ +
3n
8
θ′2
0
θ0 −
θ′
0
2ξ −
7
8
θn
0(cid:21) dξ .
IV. NUMERICAL RESULTS
The above results allow us to construct an exclusion plot
for the central temperature on the (n, Ac) parameter
space, by imposing the constraint 1−Tc/Tc0 ≤ 0.06 (6%),
the uncertainty of the central temperature of the Sun.
Solving numerically the differential equation for δ for a
varying n, and computing all relevant quantities for vary-
ing Ac, and defining the absolute perturbation ∆ ≡ θ0δ,
so that θ = θ0(1 + Acδ) = θ0 + Ac∆, one obtains the
results shown in the Figures 1 to 7.
First, notice that, from Fig. 1, the absolute perturba-
tion ∆ is fairly insensitive to the value of n; clearly, given
that the profile of θ0 for varying n differs more sharply as
ξ → ξr (as seen in Fig. 1), a approximately constant ∆
translates into a relative perturbation δ that also exhibits
this behaviour, as can be seen from Fig. 2. Furthermore,
notice the indication of the divergence of the relative per-
turbation δ in Fig. 2 (which does not depend on n, since
θ0 → 0 and ∆ → const. yields δ → ∞, as previously
discussed); as stated before, this divergence is avoided
by dealing only with the radiative region r ≤ Rr.
Also, as can be seen from Fig. 2, the relative perturba-
tion δ peaks at δmax ≈ 1.1 (for n = 2.9, and a smaller
value of δmax ≈ 0.8 for n = 3); hence, the perturbative
condition Acδ ≪ 1 translates to Ac ≪ 1, leading to the
10
0.2
0
−0.2
−0.4
−0.6
−0.8
−1
δ
n = 2.8
n = 3
n = 3.2
−1.2
0
0.2
0.4
r/R
o
0.6
0.8
FIG. 2: Profile of the relative perturbation δ for 2.8 ≤ n ≤
3.2.
FIG. 5: Relative deviation of the central temperature
Tc/Tc0 − 1 as a function of Ac and n.
1.15
1.1
1.05
1
0.95
M
/
M
g
n = 2.8
n = 3
n = 3.2
3.2
3.1
0
.
0
0
5
0
.
0
0
2
5
n
3
0.0
0
7
5
0
.
0
0
5
0
.
0
0
2
5
2.9
0
.
0
5
2
0
0.0
−
5
2
0
0.0
−
5
0
0.0
−
−0.005
−0.0075
−0.01
−0.0125
0.5
1
0
0
0
0
A
c
0.9
−1
−0.5
0
A
c
0.5
1
1
2
50
.
0
1
5
2.8
−1
0
.
0
0
.
0
.
0
0
1
7
0
0
5
5
−0.5
FIG. 3: Fraction of gravitational to total mass as a function
of Ac, for 2.8 ≤ n ≤ 3.2.
FIG. 6: Contour plot for the relative deviation of the central
temperature Tc/Tc0−1 as a function of Ac and n, with contour
lines of step 0.1%.
1
−
T
/
T
0
c
c
0.02
0.01
0
−0.01
−0.02
−1
n = 2.8
n = 3
n = 3.2
)
g
K
(
M
+
M
a
g
30
x 10
2
1.5
1
−0.5
0
A
c
0.5
1
0.5
0
0
A
= −1
c
A
= 1
c
A
= 0
c
1
2
3
4
5
r/R
o
FIG. 4: Relative deviation of the central temperature
Tc/Tc0 − 1 as a function of Ac, for 2.8 ≤ n ≤ 3.2.
FIG. 7: Mass profiles, for n = 3 and Ac = −1, 0, 1.
chosen (extreme) interval for simulation −1 ≤ Ac ≤ 1.
Hence, according to Figs. 4, 5 and 6, no relative devia-
tion of the central temperature above the experimentally
determined level of 6% is attained. However, the values
found, of the order of 1%, indicate that any future refine-
ment of the experimental error of Tc could yield a direct
bound on the parameter Ac.
The above results show that Ac is presently uncon-
strained by solar observables, aside from the perturbative
condition Ac ≪ 1 → λ ≪ κ/ρc; taking κ = c4/16πG =
2.41 × 1042 kg.m/s2 and ρc = 1.622 × 105 kg/m3, this
yields λ ≪ 1.48× 1037 m4/s2 or, in natural units, λ ≪
4.24 × 1033 eV −2. However, this study assumes that the
effects arising from the non-trivial matter-geometry cou-
pling supersede those from the non-linear curvature term
in the modified Hilbert-Einstein action (1), as expressed
by the inequalities (8), (11) and (12). Having numerically
determined the perturbative solution δ, one can now re-
evaluate these conditions. For this, one first replaces R
by its unperturbed value (with the Newtonian approach
ρ ≫ p), R ≈ −ρ/2κ, since corrections would amount to
second-order terms in λ.
Considering the scaling laws, ρ = ρcθn(ξ) and p =
pcθn+1(ξ), and the inequalities (11) and (12), some al-
gebra (see Appendix D) yields,
for the f1 = f1a ≡
2κ(R − αR1−m) case,
n
2Ncθ
λ ≫ (cid:18) 2κ
λ ≫
ρcθn(cid:19)m+1 α
n + 1(cid:18) 2κ
n + 1(cid:18) 2κ
ρcθn(cid:19)m+1 α(1 − m)m
ρcθn(cid:19)m+1 α(1 − m)m
while, for the f1 = f1b ≡ 2κ(R + αR2) case,
λ ≫
2Ncθ
2Ncθ
n
Cn,m(ξ) ,
λ ≫
λ ≫
λ ≫
α
2Ncθ
n
n + 1
n
n + 1
,
α
Ncθ
α
Ncθ
,
Cn,−1(ξ) ,
(72)
where one defines the quantity
m
3
,
C
1.5
1
0.5
0
−0.5
−1
−1.5
0
11
θ
0
′
θ
0
A
= 1
c
A
= −1
c
0.2
0.4
r/R
o
0.6
0.8
FIG. 8: Profiles of C3,m, for m = −1, 0, 1, superimposed on
profile of θ0 and θ′
0, with n = 3.
Varying m in its domain 0 < m < 1 (for the f1 = f1a
case) and m = −1 (for the f1 = f1b case); its profile
is depicted in Figure 8. One concludes that Cn,m <
∼
1.5, for both the f1 = f1a case (0 < m < 1) as well as
the f1 = f1b case (m = −1). This, together with the
constraint θ(ξ) >
∼ 0.1 (as can be seen from Fig. 1) and
the quantity Nc ≡ pc/(ρcc2) = 1.7 × 10−6 yields, for the
f1 = f1a case,
λ ≫ 6.6 × 106α .
(76)
Using the previously discussed value, α = (1012 GeV )−2
, which arises from the Planck-scale renormalization of
the theory, one gets
λ ≫ 6.6 × 10−36 eV −2 = (3.9 × 108 GeV )−2 .
Also, a recent paper has reported a relation between
the coefficient of the quadratic term in f1 and the PPN
parameter γ [26],
(77)
,
(71)
,
λ ≫ 2.8 × 1043(8.48 × 1036)m(1 − m)mα eV −2(1+m)
while, for the f1 = f1b case,
,
(75)
.
(73)
α =
.
(78)
Cn,m(ξ) ≡(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(1 + nm)θ′2(ξ) − θθ′′(ξ)
nθ′2(ξ) + θθ′′(ξ)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
1
2κs(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
1 − γ
2γ − 1(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
One can plot the function Cn,m(ξ) by evaluating θ by
the unperturbed solution θ0, using Eq. (49) and taking
n ≈ 3. One obtains
Hence, the current experimental constraint γ−1 = (2.1±
2.3) × 10−5 [27] yields
Cn,m(ξ) ≈(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
θ′
0h(1 + 3m)θ′
0 + 2
θ′
0(cid:16)3θ′
0 + 2
ξ θ0i + θ4
0
ξ θ0(cid:17) + θ4
0
.
(74)
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
α ≤ 0.17M −2
P l =(cid:0)3.0 × 1019 GeV(cid:1)−2
where MP l = p¯hc/G = 1.2 × 1019 GeV is the Planck
mass. This yields
,
(79)
(80)
λ ≫ 7.4 × 10−51 eV −2 = (1.2 × 1016 GeV )−2 .
Clearly, the f1 = f1b case does not impose any sig-
nificant bound on λ, with the above value laying many
orders of magnitude below the upper bound,
λ ≪
4.24 × 1033 eV −2, arising from the perturbative treat-
ment.
Notice that the above inequalities (71), (72), (75), (76),
(77) and (80) are not to be considered as restrictions on
the parameters, but as conditions for the validity of the
regime where the effects of the matter-geometry coupling
supersede those of the the non-linear curvature term in
Eq. (1).
V. DISCUSSION
In this work we have examined a model where the usual
Einstein-Hilbert action is modified, not only by allowing
non-linear curvature terms to appear, but by also en-
abling an explicit, non-minimum coupling between the
curvature and the Lagrangian of matter fields. We first
assume that this matter-geometry coupling is linear in
curvature and its effect allows the non-linear curvature
terms to be neglected -- an assertion that is qualified in
the end of the study, for two relevant non-linear f (R)
models.
We then proceed and perform the necessary calcula-
tions to ascertain the effect of the latter in the hydro-
static equilibrium of an n ≈ 3 polytrope such as the Sun.
We assume a perturbative regime to the usual Tolman-
Oppenheimmer-Volkoff equation, and take into consider-
ation the validity of the Newtonian regime in this mod-
ified theory, as well as the redefinition of relevant quan-
tities, which are computed numerically and compared
with Solar observables. This goal is achieved through the
use of the (non-relativistic) polytropic equation of state
p = Kρ(n+1)/n
: as stated before, this is a very simplistic
description of the complex behaviour of solar matter, and
has been superseded by much more elaborate equations
of state; we use it in our study so to better illustrate
the effects of the matter-curvature coupling on an eas-
ily understandable, closed model. However, we should
remark that this restrictive treatment, although advan-
tageous from the theoretical point of view, might conceal
some of the more intricate phenomenology found in stel-
lar systems, which could affect our results. Clearly, a
subsequent study should consider a more realistic solar
model.
B
The results allow us to conclude that no strong con-
straints on the matter-geometry coupling from the com-
parison between the model's predictions and current ex-
perimental sensitivity, aside from the perturbative ap-
proach λf2(R) = λR ≈ (λ/κ)ρc ≪ 1, which yields
λ ≪ 4.24 × 1033 eV −2. However, the numerically ob-
tained results show that a slight increase in accuracy
12
would allow an upper bound to be placed on λ; this close-
ness between the prediction of the perturbative model
and experiment also seems to validate the latter.
APPENDIX A
Given the line element (16), one first writes
g00R00 − grrRrr = e−σ ν′ + σ′
r
.
(A1)
Resorting to Eq. (15), one gets
2κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)](g00R00 − grrRrr) =
2(1 − ap)(g00T00 − grrTrr) + 4aκ(g00
κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)]e−σ ν′ + σ′
=
ρ + p − ap(ρ + p) + 4aκ(e−ν
00 + e−σ
r
00 − grr
(A2)
rr)p →
rr)p ,
since the terms depending on the metric cancel out (that
is, g00g00 − grrgrr = 0).
Next, compute
(A3)
Rθθ
r2 =
2κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)]
gθθ
r2 + 2(1 − ap)
(3p − ρ)
2κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)](cid:20) 1
ρ − 3p + 2(1 − ap)p + aκ(cid:18) 4
κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)](cid:20) 2
ρ − p − 2ap2 + aκ(cid:18) 4
1
Tθθ
r2 +
aκ
r2 (4 θθ − gθθ )p →
r2 + e−σ(cid:18) σ′ − ν′
2r −
θθ + (cid:19) p →
r2(cid:19)(cid:21) =
r2(cid:19)(cid:21) =
−
r2
2
r2 + e−σ(cid:18) σ′ − ν′
θθ + (cid:19) p .
r2
r
Adding Eqs. (A2) to (A3), one obtains Eq. (17)
κ[2 + a(ρ − 3p)](cid:20) 1
−
(ρ + 3p) +
ap
2
r2 + e−σ(cid:18) σ′
r −
2 (cid:18)5e−ν
aκ
(A4)
θθ(cid:19) p ,
2
r2
1
r2(cid:19)(cid:21) = ρ
00 + 3e−σ
rr +
with ≡ e−ν
Eq. (18), one gets Eq. (26)
00 − e−σ
rr − 2 θθ/r2.
By subtracting Eqs. (A2) from (A3), and substituting
κ [2 + a (ρ − 3p)](cid:20)(cid:18)1 −
2 (cid:18)3e−ν
(p − ρ) +
ap
2
aκ
+
2Gm
r (cid:19) ν′
r −
00 + 5e−σ
2Gm
r3 (cid:21) = p (A5)
θθ(cid:19) p .
rr −
2
r2
APPENDIX B
In order to obtain an approximation to the solution of
the Lane-Emden equation (48) in the vicinity of ξ = 0,
one writes θ(ξ) ≈ 1−Aξ2+Bξ4. Inserting this in Eq. (48)
yields, after some algebra and expanding up to fourth
order in ξ,
13
Ac
4(n + 1)
(cid:20)20 +
(cid:20)−1 + Ac
2 + 5A
4
(A [4Nc(n + 1)(2n + 1) + An(13 + 21n)] + 10B(13 + 21n))(cid:21) ξ4 =
(cid:21) ξ2 +(cid:20)An − Ac(cid:18)An(cid:20)1 +
B(cid:19)(cid:21) ξ4 .
A(cid:21) +
11
4
11
2
(B1)
(C4)
Equating second and fourth-order terms, one gets
A ≈
1
6(cid:18)1 − Ac
13 + 25n
12(n + 1)(cid:19) ,
and
B ≈
n
120(cid:18)1 − Ac
11
60
39 + 59n
n + 1 (cid:19) .
APPENDIX C
(B2)
(B3)
In the unperturbed case, the total mass M is purely
gravitational, and hence defined as usual:
r2ρ dr = 4πr3
0ρc0Z ξr
0)′ dξ = −4πr3
0
(ξ2θ′
ξ2θn
0 dξ = (C1)
0ρc0ξ2
r (θ′
0)ξ=ξr =
0
M = 4πZ Rr
0ρc0Z ξr
−4πr3
R3
r
ξr
0r ≡ θ′
−4π
ρc0θ′
0
0r ,
defining θ′
density ρc0, a model dependent parameter, is given by
0(ξr); hence, the (unperturbed) central
0
0
0
G
4π
ρ2
c
m′
n + 1
4πr3
R3
r
ξ3
r
e dr =
r2ρ dr +
ξ2θn dξ +
(cid:18)4πr2
M =Z Rr
4πZ Rr
0ρcZ ξr
ρcZ ξr
pc(cid:19) AcNcr0Z ξr
ρcZ ξr
0ρcAcZ ξr
ρc Z ξr
ρc −ξ2
R3
r
ξ3
r
R3
r
ξ3
r
R3
r
ξ3
r
4πr3
ξ2θn
ξ2θn
r θ′
4π
4π
4π
0
0
0
0
0
R3
r
ξr
−4π
ρcθ′
0r 1 −
ξ2θn
0 Θ dr =
AcNcZ Rr
0
n + 1
G
AcNcr0Z ξr
0
ξ2θn
0 Θ dξ =
ξ2 (θ0(1 + Acδ))n dξ +
ξ2θn
0 Θ dξ ≈
0
0 (1 + nAcδ) dξ +
0 Θ dξ =
0
ξ2θn
0 dξ + AcZ ξr
0r + AcZ ξr
0r Z ξr
Ac
r θ′
ξ2
ξ2θn
0
0
ξ2θn
0 (nδ + Θ) dξ! =
0 (nδ + Θ) dξ! =
0 (nδ + Θ) dξ! .
ξ2θn
ρc0 = −
M
4πθ′
0r
ξr
R3
r
.
(C2)
In the perturbed case, one first uses Eq. (62) to define,
for clarity,
Notice that there are two Ac-dependent contributions:
one arising from θ0 and its derivatives (embodied in Θ),
and other involving the integral of δ.
Θ(ξ) = −
3n
8
θ′2
0
θ0
+
θ′
0
2ξ
+
7
8
θn
0
.
(C3)
APPENDIX D
In the above, θ0 is used instead of θ, since Θ is coupled
to Ac, so that including the perturbation δ would only
amount to second-order terms O(A2
c ). Using the defini-
tions Nc ≡ pc/ρc and r2
0 ≡ (n + 1)pc/4πGρ2
c, one gets
By considering the scaling laws ρ = ρcθn(ξ) and p =
pcθn+1(ξ) and using Eq. (11) one gets, for the f1 = f1a
case,
where the prime denotes denotes differentiation with re-
spect to ξ (the factors r0 arising from changing derivation
with respect to r to derivation with respect to ξ = r/r0
cancel out).
,
(D1)
14
2Ncθn(1+m)+1
α
=
,
n
ρmp
ρ′(r)
λ ≫
2mακ1+m
ρc(cid:19)m+1
=(cid:18) 2κ
λ ≫ 2m(1 − m)mακ1+m(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
ρ1+mp′(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
ρc(cid:19)m+1 α(1 − m)m
n + 1(cid:18) 2κ
2m(1 − m)mακ1+m
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
λ ≫
ρc(cid:19)m+1 α(1 − m)m
2Ncθn(1+m)+1 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
(cid:18) 2κ
2Ncθn(1+m)+1
ρ1+mp′′
ρ′2(r)
ρ′′(r) − (1 + m)
(1 + nm)θ′2(ξ) − θθ′′(ξ)
nθ′2(ξ) + θθ′′(ξ)
ρ
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
=
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
,
while, for the f1 = f1b case, Eq. (12) yields
λ ≫
λ ≫
λ ≫
α
2Ncθ
n
,
α
n + 1
2Ncθ
n
n + 1
α
2Ncθ (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
,
(1 − n)θ′2(ξ) − θθ′′(ξ)
nθ′2(ξ) + θθ′′(ξ)
(D2)
,
(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to thank F. Lobo for fruit-
is sponsored by
ful discussions. The work of J.P.
the FCT under the grant BP D23287/2005. O.B. ac-
knowledges the partial support of the FCT project
P OCI/F IS/56093/2004.
[1] S. Carroll, V. Duvvuri, M. Trodden and M. Turner, Phys.
Rev. D 70, 043528 (2004); S. Capozziello, S. Nojiri, S.D.
Odintsov and A. Troisi, Phys. Lett. B 639, 135 (2006);
S. Nojiri and S.D. Odintsov, Phys. Rev. D 74, 086005
(2006), Int. J. Geom. Meth. Mod. Phys. 4, 115 (2007).
[2] L. Amendola, R. Gannouji, D. Polarski and S. Tsujikawa,
Phys. Rev. D 75, 083504 (2007).
[3] A. Coley, N. Pelavas and R. Zalaletdinov, Phys. Rev.
Lett. 95, 151102 (2005); S. Rasanen, Int. J. Mod. Phys.
D 15. 2141 (2006); T. Buchert, gr-qc/0612166.
[4] O. Bertolami and R. Rosenfeld, hep-ph/0708.1784.
[5] M. Bento, O. Bertolami and A. Sen, Phys. Rev. D 66,
043507 (2002); N. Bilic, G. Tupper and R. Viollier, Phys.
Lett. B 535, 17 (2002); V. Gorini, A. Kamenshchik and
U. Moschella, Phys. Rev. D 67, 063509 (2003).
[6] R. Maartens, Living Rev. Rel. 7, 7 (2004).
[7] S. Capozziello, V. Cardone and A. Troisi, Phys. Rev. D
71, 043503 (2005); G. Allemandi, A. Borowiec and M.
Francaviglia, Phys. Rev. D 70, 103503 (2004).
[8] A. Starobinsky, Phys. Lett. B 91, 99 (1980).
[9] S. Capozziello, A. Stabile and A. Troisi, gr-qc/0708.0723.
[10] T. Sotiriou, Class. Quantum Gravity 23, 5117 (2006); N.
Poplawski, Class. Quantum Gravity 23, 2011 (2006); T.
Sotiriou and S. Liberati, Annals Phys. 322, 935 (2007).
[11] S. Capozziello, V. Cardone, S. Carloni and A. Troisi,
Phys. Lett. A 326, 292 (2004); S. Capozziello, V. Car-
done and A. Troisi, Mon. Not. R. Ast. Soc. 375, 1423
(2007); J. Mbelek, Astron. and Astrophys. 424, 761
(2004).
[14] S. Mukohyama and L. Randall, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92,
211302 (2004); A. Dolgov and M. Kawasaki, astro-
ph/0307442; astro-ph/0310822.
[15] L. Amendola, Phys. Rev. D 62, 043511 (2000); Phys.
Rev. Lett. 86, 196 (2001); L. Amendola and D. Tocchini-
Valentini, Phys. Rev. D 64, 043509 (2001), Phys. Rev.
D 66, 043528 (2002); A Billyard and A. Coley, Phys.
Rev. D 61, 083503 (2000); D. Holden and D. Wands,
Phys. Rev. D 61, 043506 (2000); O. Bertolami and P.
Martins, Phys. Rev. D 61, 064007 (2000); L. Chimento,
A. Jakubi, D. Pavon and W. Zimdahl, Phys. Rev. D 67,
083513 (2003); L. Chimento and D. Pavon, Phys. Rev. D
73, 063511 (2006); C. Boehmer, T. Harko and F. Lobo,
gr-qc/0709.0046.
[16] V. Faraoni, Cosmology in Scalar-Tensor Gravity (Kluwer
Academis Publishers, 2004); O. Bertolami. J. P´aramos
and S. Turyshev, gr-qc/0602016; O. Bertolami, F.
Pedro and M. Le Delliou, astro-ph/0703462; astro-
ph/0705.3118.
[17] O. Bertolami and J. P´aramos, Phys. Rev. D 71, 023521
(2005).
[18] O. Bertolami and J. P´aramos, Phys. Rev. D 72, 123512
(2005).
[19] T. Multamaki and I. Vilja, astro-ph/0612775; K. Kain-
ulainen, J. Piilonen, V. Reijonen and D. Sunhede, Phys.
Rev. D 76, 024020 (2007); A. Bustelo and D. Barraco,
Class. Quantum Gravity 24, 2333 (2007); E. Barausse,
T. Sotiriou and J. Miller, gr-qc/0703132; S. Capozziello,
A. Stabile and A. Troisi, gr-qc/0709.0891.
[12] O. Bertolami, C. Boehmer, T. Harko and F. Lobo, Phys.
[20] B. Schutz, Phys. Rev. D 2, 2762 (1970); J. Brown, Class.
Rev. D 75, 104016 (2007).
Quantum Gravity 10, 1579 (1993).
[13] S. Nojiri and S. Odintsov,Phys. Lett. B 599, 137 (2004);
hep-th/0412030; G. Allemandi, A. Borowiec, M. Francav-
iglia, and S. Odintsov, Phys. Rev. D 72, 063505 (2005).
[21] "The Fundamentals of Stellar Astrophysics", G. Collins
(W.H. Freeman and Co., 1989); J.N. Bahcall, Phys.
Rev. D33 47 (2000); "Textbook of Astronomy and As-
trophysics with Elements of Cosmology", V. Bhatia
(Narosa Publishing House, 2001); "Theoretical Astro-
physics: Stars and Stellar Systems", T. Padmanabhan
(Cambridge University Press, 2001).
[22] J. Bahcall, A. Serenelli and S. Basu, Ap. J. Supp. 165,
400 (2006); R. Trampedach, W. Dappen and V. Baturin,
Ap. J. 646, 560 (2006).
[23] R. Tooper, Ap. J. 140, 434 (1964).
15
[24] N. Stergioulas, Living Rev. Rel., 6 3 (2003).
[25] R. Tooper, Ap. J. 142, 1541 (1965).
[26] S. Capozziello, A. Stabile and A. Troisi, Mod. Phys. Lett.
A 21, 2291 (2006).
[27] B. Bertotti, L. Iess and P. Tortora, Nature 425, 374
(2003).
|
astro-ph/0701255 | 1 | 0701 | 2007-01-09T16:31:45 | Study on polarization of high-energy photons from the Crab pulsar | [
"astro-ph"
] | We investigate polarization of high-energy emissions from the Crab pulsar in the frame work of the outer gap accelerator. The recent version of the outer gap, which extends from inside the null charge surface to the light cylinder, is used for examining the light curve, the spectrum and the polarization characteristics, simultaneously. The polarization position angle curve and the polarization degree are calculated to compare with the Crab optical data. We show that the outer gap model explains the general features of the observed light curve, the spectrum and the polarization by taking into account the emissions from inside of the null charge surface and from tertiary pairs, which were produced by the high-energy photons from the secondary pairs. For the Crab pulsar, the polarization position angle curve indicates that the viewing angle of the observer measured from the rotational axis is greater than 90 degrees. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Proceedings of the 363. WE-Heraeus Seminar on: "Neutron Stars and Pulsars" (Posters and contributed talks)
Physikzentrum Bad Honnef, Germany, May. 14 − 19, 2006, eds. W. Becker, H.H. Huang, MPE Report 291, pp. 120-123
7
0
0
2
n
a
J
9
1
v
5
5
2
1
0
7
0
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
Study on polarization of high-energy photons from the Crab
pulsar
J. Takata1, H.-K. Chang2, and K.S. Cheng3
1 ASIAA/National Tsing Hua University - TIARA, PO Box 23-141, Taipei, Taiwan
2 Department of Physics and Institute of Astronomy, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan
3 Department of Physics, University of Hong Kong, Pokfuam Road, Hong Kong, China
Abstract. We investigate polarization of high-energy
emissions from the Crab pulsar in the frame work of the
outer gap accelerator. The recent version of the outer gap,
which extends from inside the null charge surface to the
light cylinder, is used for examining the light curve, the
spectrum and the polarization characteristics, simultane-
ously. The polarization position angle curve and the polar-
ization degree are calculated to compare with the Crab op-
tical data. We show that the outer gap model explains the
general features of the observed light curve, the spectrum
and the polarization by taking into account the emissions
from inside of the null charge surface and from tertiary
pairs, which were produced by the high-energy photons
from the secondary pairs. For the Crab pulsar, the po-
larization position angle curve indicates that the viewing
angle of the observer measured from the rotational axis is
greater than 90◦.
1. Introduction
Young pulsars such as the Crab pulsar are strong γ-ray
sources. The EGRET instrument revealed that the light
curve with double peaks in a period and the spectrum
extending to above GeV are typical features of the high-
energy emissions from the γ-ray pulsars. Although these
data have constrained proposed models, the origin of the
γ-ray emission is not yet conclusive. On important reason
is that various models have successfully explained the fea-
tures of the observed spectra and/or light curves. For ex-
ample, the polar cap model (Daugherty & Harding 1996),
the caustic model (Dyks et al. 2004) and the outer gap
model (Cheng et al. 2000, hereafter CRZ00), all expect
the main features of the observed light curve. So, we can-
not discriminate the three different models using the light
curve. Furthermore, both polar cap and outer gap models
have explained the observed γ-ray spectrum (Daugherty
& Harding 1996; Romani 1996).
Polarization measurement will play an important role
to discriminate the various models, because it increases
observed parameters, namely, polarization degree (p.d.)
and position angle (p.a.) swing. So far, only the optical
polarization data for the Crab pulsar is available (Kan-
bach et al. 2005) in high energy bands. For the Crab pul-
sar, the spectrum is continuously extending from optical
to γ-ray bands. In addition, their pulse positions are con-
sidered so well that the optical emission mechanism is re-
lated to higher energy emission mechanisms. In the future,
the next generation Compton telescope will probably be
able to measure polarization characteristics in MeV bands.
These data will be useful for discriminating the different
models.
In this paper, we examine the optical polarization char-
acteristics of the Crab pulsar with the light curve and the
spectrum in frame works of the outer gap model. CRZ00
has calculated the synchrotron self-inverse Compton scat-
tering process of the secondary pairs produced outside the
outer gap and has explained the Crab spectrum from X-
ray to γ-ray bands. In CRZ00, however, the outer-wing
and the off-pulse emissions of the Crab pulsars cannot
be reproduced, because the traditional outer gap geom-
etry, which extends from the null charge surface of the
Goldreich-Julian charge density to the light cylinder, is
assumed. Furthermore, the spectrum in the optical band
was not considered. In this paper, on these grounds, we
modify the CRZ00 geometrical model into a more realis-
tic model, following recent 2-D electrodynamical studies
(Takata et al. 2004; Hirotani 2006), and calculate the light
curve, the spectrum and the polarization characteristics of
the Crab pulsar.
2. Calculation method
The outline of the outer gap model for the Crab pul-
sar is as follows. The charge particles are accelerated by
the electric field parallel to the magnetic field lines in so
called gap, where the charge density is different from the
Goldreich-Julina charge density. The high energy particles
accelerated in the gap emit the γ-ray photons (called pri-
mary photons) via the curvature radiation process. For the
Crab pulsar, most of the primary photons escaping from
the outer gap will convert into secondary pairs outside the
gap, where the accelerating electric field vanishes, by col-
liding with synchrotron X-rays emitted by the secondary
J. Takata, H.-K. Chang, & K.S. Cheng: Study on polarization of high-energy photons from the Crab pulsar
121
pairs. The secondary pairs emit optical - MeV photons via
the synchrotron process and photons above MeV with the
inverse Compton process. The high-energy photons emit-
ted by the secondary pairs may convert into tertiary pairs
at higher altitude by colliding with the soft X-rays from
the stellar surface. The tertiary pairs emit the optical-UV
photons via the synchrotron process. This secondary and
tertiary photons appear as the observed radiations from
the Crab pulsar
2.1. Outer gap
We consider the outer gap geometry that is extending from
inside null charge surface to near the light cylinder (Takata
et al 2004; Hirotani 2006). Because the Crab pulsar has a
thin gap, we describe the accelerating electric field (Cheng
et al. 1986) with
E(r) =
ΩB(r)f 2(r)R2
lc
cs(r)
,
(1)
where f (r) is the local gap thickness in units of the light
radius, Rlc = c/Ω, and s(r) is the curvature radius of the
magnetic field line. The typical fractional size of the outer
gap is given by f (Rlc/2) ∼ 5.5B−4/7P 26/21 (∼ 0.04 for
the Crab pulsar) and the local fractional size is estimated
by f (r) ∼ f (Rlc/2)(2r/Rlc)1.5 (Zhang & Cheng 1997).
The electric field described by equation (1) can be
adopted for the acceleration beyond the null charge sur-
face. Inside null charge surface, the electric field rapidly
decreases because of the screening effects of the pairs. To
simulate the accelerating electric field inside null charge
surface, we assume the following field,
E(r) = En
(r/ri)2 − 1
(rn/ri)2 − 1
, ri ≤ r ≤ rn,
(2)
where En is the strength of the electric field at the null
charge surface and rn and ri are the radial distances to
the null charge surface and the inner boundary of the
gap, respectively. The local Lorentz factor of the accel-
erated particles in the outer gap is described by Γe(r) =
[3s2(r)E/2e]1/4 with assuming the force balance between
the acceleration and the curvature radiation back reaction.
We assume that the outer gap extends around the
whole polar cap. In the calculation, we constrain the
boundaries of the axial distance and radial distance for
the emission regions with ρmax = 0.9Rlc and r = Rlc,
respectively.
2.2. Synchrotron radiation from the pairs
We calculate the synchrotron radiation at each radiating
point following CRZ00. The photon spectrum of the syn-
chrotron radiation is (CRZ00)
Fsyn(Eγ, r) =
31/2e3B(r) sin θp(r)
mc2hEγ
× Z (cid:20) dne(r)
dEe (cid:21) F (x)dEedVrad,
(3)
e
is the pitch angle of the particle, F (x) = xR ∞
where x = Eγ/Esyn, Esyn is the typical photon energy, θp
x K5/3(y)dy,
where K5/3 is the modified Bessel function of order 5/3,
dne/dEe ∝ E−2
is the distribution of the pairs and dVrad
is the volume element of the radiation region considered.
The pitch angle of the secondary pairs is estimated
from sin θp(Rlc) ∼ λ/s(Rlc), where λ is the mean free
path of the pair-creation between the primary γ-rays
and the non-thermal X-rays from the secondary pairs.
For the Crab pulsar, the mean free path becomes λ ∼
(nX σγγ)−1 ∼ 107cm, where we used the typical num-
ber density nX ∼ LX(< EX >)/δΩR2
lcc < EX >∼
8 × 1017 cm−3, the luminosity LX ∼ 1035erg/s, the typ-
ical soft-photon energy for the pair-creation, < EX >∼
(2mec2)2/10 GeV ∼ 100 eV, and σγγ ∼ σT /3. There-
fore the pitch angle of the secondary pairs at the light
cylinder is estimated as sin θp ∼ λ/s(Rlc) ∼ 0.06,
and the local pitch angle is calculated from sin θp(r) =
sin θp(Rlc)(r/Rlc)1/2.
Some high-energy photons emitted by the inverse
Compton process of the secondary pairs may convert into
tertiary pairs at higher altitude by colliding with thermal
X-ray photons from the star. In this paper, we assume
that the maximum energy of and the local number den-
sity of the tertiary pairs are smaller than about 10% of
those of the secondary pairs. Because the pitch angle of
the pairs increases with altitude, we use sin θp = 0.1 for
the pitch angle of the tertiary pairs. In fact, the results
are not sensitive to the pitch angle of the tertiary pairs.
2.3. Stokes parameters
For a high Lorentz factor, we can anticipate that the emis-
sion direction of the particles coincides with the direction
of the particle's velocity. In the inertial observer frame,
the particle motion may be described by
n = β0 cos θpb + β0 sin θpb⊥ + βcoeφ,
(4)
where the first term in the right hand side represents the
particle motion along the field line, for which we use the
rotating dipole field, and b is the unit vector of the mag-
netic field line. The second term in equation (4) repre-
sents gyration motion around the magnetic field line and
b⊥ ≡ cos δφk + sin δφk × b is the unit vector perpendicu-
lar to the magnetic field line, where δφ refers the phase of
gyration motion and k = (b ·∇)b/(b·∇)b is the unit vec-
tor of the curvature of the magnetic field lines. The third
term is co-rotation motion with the star, βco = ρΩ/c. The
emission direction of equation (4) is described in terms
122
J. Takata, H.-K. Chang, & K.S. Cheng: Study on polarization of high-energy photons from the Crab pulsar
of the viewing angle measured from the rotational axis,
ξ = cos−1 nz, and the rotation phase, Φ = −Φn − r · n,
where nz is the component of the emission direction par-
allel to the rotational axis, Φn is the azimuthal angle of
the emission direction and r is the emitting location in
units of the light radius.
Because the particles distribute on the gyration phase
δφ, the emitted beam at each point must become cone
like shape with opening angle θp(r). We calculate the ra-
diations from the particles for all of the gyration phase
δφ = 2πi/n (i = 1, · · · , n − 1).
We assume that the radiation at each point linearly
polarizes with degree of Πsyn = (p + 1)/(p + 7/3), where
p is the power law index of the particle distribution, and
circular polarization is zero, that is, V = 0 in terms of
the Stokes parameters. The direction of the electric vec-
tor of the electro-magnetic wave toward the observer is
parallel to the projected direction of the acceleration of
the particle on the sky, that is, Eem ∝ a − (n · a)n
(Blaskiewicz et al. 1991). In the present case, the ac-
celeration with equation (4) is approximately written by
a ∼ β0ωB sin θp(− sin δφk + cos δφk × b).
We define the position angle χi to be angle between
the electric field Eem and the projected rotational axis
on the sky. The Stokes parameters Qi and U i at each ra-
diation is represented by Qi = ΠsynI i cos 2χi and U i =
ΠsynI i sin 2χi. After collecting the photons from the pos-
sible points for each rotation phase Φ and a viewing angle
ξ, the expected p.d. and p.a. are, respectively, obtained
from P (ξ, Φ) = ΠsynpQ2(ξ, Φ) + U 2(ξ, Φ)/I(ξ, Φ) and
χ(ξ, Φ) = 0.5atan [U (ξ, Φ)/Q(ξ, Φ)].
The inclination angle α and the viewing angles ξ mea-
sured from the rotational axis are the model parameters.
The radial distance ri of the inner boundary in equation
(2) is also a model parameter, because the distance ri is
determined by the current through the gap (Takata et al.
2004). Because the last-open line must be modified from
the traditional magnetic surface, which is tangent to the
light cylinder for the vacuum case, by the plasma effects
(Romani 1996), the altitude of the upper surface of the
outer gap, above which the pairs are created and emit the
synchrotron photons, is used as a model parameter using
a fractional polar angle a = θu/θlc, where θu is the po-
lar angle of the footpoints of the magnetic field lines of
the gap upper surface and θlc is the polar angle of the
field lines which are tangent to the light cylinder for the
vacuum case.
3. Results
Figure 1 compares the polarization characteristics at 1 eV
predicted by the traditional (left column) and the present
(right column) outer gap models. The traditional model
considers the emissions from the secondary pairs with the
outer gap starting from the null charge surface of the
Goldreich-Julian charge density, ri = rn. The present
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
-60
-80
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
y
t
i
s
n
e
t
n
I
]
.
g
e
d
[
.
A
P
.
]
%
0
0
1
x
[
.
D
P
.
secondary pairs, ri=rn
secondary+tertiary pairs, ri=0.68rn
1eV
secondary pairs, ri=rn
secondary+tertiary pairs, ri=0.68rn
secondary pairs, ri=rn
secondary+tertiary pairs, ri=0.68rn
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
Φ
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
Φ
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Fig. 1. Polarization characteristics for the traditional
model (left column) and the present model (right column).
The upper, middle and lower panels in each column show,
respectively, the light curve, the position angle and the
polarization degree for α = 40◦ and a = 0.93.
model takes into account the emissions from inside null
charge surface and the tertiary pairs. We assume the outer
gap starts from the radial distance of 68% of the distance
to null charge surface, ri = 0.68rn. The model parameters
are α = 40◦, a = 0.93 and ξ ∼ 101◦, where the viewing
angle is chosen so that the predicted phase separation be-
tween the two peaks is consistent with the observed value
δΦ ∼ 0.4 phase.
From the pulse profiles, we find that the traditional
model can not produce the outer-wing and the off-pulse
emissions. On the other hand, the present model produces
the outer-wing and the off-pulse emissions with the emis-
sions from inside of the null charge surface.
As seen in the polarization characteristics by the tradi-
tional model, we find that the secondary emissions beyond
the null charge surface make the polarization characteris-
tics such that the polarization degree takes a lower value at
the bridge phase and a larger value near the peaks. In the
synchrotron case, the cone like beam is radiated at each
point, and an overlap of the radiations from the different
particles on the gyration phase causes the depolarization.
For the viewing angle ξ ∼ 101◦, the radiations from all
gyration phases contribute to the observed radiation at
the bridge phase, because the line of sight passes through
middle part of the emission regions. In such a case, the
depolarization is strong, and as a result, the emerging ra-
diation from the secondary pairs polarizes with a very low
p.d. (< 10%). Near the peaks, the radiations from the
some range of gyration phases are not observed because
the line of sight passes through the edge of the emission re-
gions at peaks. In such a case, the depolarization is weaker
and the emerging radiation highly polarizes.
In the polarization angle swing in the present model,
the large swings appear at the both peaks, and the differ-
ence of the position angle between the off-pulse and the
bridge phases is about 90 degree. We can see the effects
of the tertiary pairs on the polarization characteristics at
the bridge phase. By comparing the p.d. at the bridge
J. Takata, H.-K. Chang, & K.S. Cheng: Study on polarization of high-energy photons from the Crab pulsar
123
y
]
t
s
t
i
i
n
u
s
.
n
b
r
e
a
[
t
n
x
u
I
l
f
5
4
3
2
1
0
)
o
(
.
A
.
P
]
°
[
ψ
200
150
100
50
50
40
]
)
%
(
%
.
P
D
.
P
[
30
20
10
0
-0.5
total
pulsed
0.0
Φ
0.5
-0.5
0.0
0.5
1.0
Φ
10
]
s
COMPTEL
BeppoSAX PDS
BeppoSAX MECS
BeppoSAX LECS
OSSE
GRIS
2
m
c
/
g
r
e
0
1
-
0
1
[
x
u
F
x
l
2
E
1
0.1
10-6
10-5
10-4
10-3
10-2
Energy [MeV]
10-1
100
101
Fig. 2. Optical polarization for
the Crab pulsar.
Left:Polarization characteristics for the total emissions.
Right:Polarization characteristics of the emissions after
subtraction of the DC level (Kanbach et al. 2005). The
figures was transcribed from Dyks et al. (2004).
Fig. 3. The optical-X ray spectrum for the Crab pulsar.
The calculation is for α = 40◦, a = 0.93, ri = 0.68 and
ξ ∼ 101◦. The X-ray data are taken from Kuiper et al.
(2002) and reference therein, and the optical data from
Sollerman et al. (2000).
phase, we find that tertiary pairs produce the radiations
with ∼ 10% of the p.d. at the bridge phase.
Figure 2 summarizes the Crab optical data. Left col-
umn and the right column show, respectively, the Crab
optical data for the total emissions and for the emissions
after subtraction of the DC level, which has the constant
intensity at the level of 1.24% of the main pulse intensity.
In the total emissions (left column), the impressive polar-
ization feature is that the off-pulse and bridge phases have
the fixed value of the p.a. These polarization features of
the observation are not predicted by the present model.
The present model are more consistent with the Crab op-
tical data after the subtraction of the DC level. Especially,
the model reproduces the most striking feature in the ob-
served p.a. that the large swing at both peaks, and the
observed low p.d. at bridge phase ∼ 10%. Also, the pat-
tern of the p.d. are reproduced by the present model.
Figure 3 compares the model spectrum with the Crab
data in optical-MeV bands. The model parameters are
same with that in the right column in Figure 2. In this
case, we assume that the pairs escape from the light cylin-
der with the Lorentz factor Γ ∼ 20 due to the synchrotron
cooling effect, which makes a spectral break around 10 eV
in Figure 3. The model spectrum also explains the general
features of the data. The outer gap model can explain the
general features of the observed light curve, the spectrum
and the polarization characteristics in optical band for the
Crab pulsar, simultaneously.
It is worth to note that we can distinguish the two
viewing angles mutually symmetric with respect to the
rotational equator using the polarization swing. For such
symmetric viewing angles, the light curves, the spectra
and the p.d. curves are identical. However, the p.a. curves
are mirror symmetry with respect to the rotational equa-
tor because of the difference directions of the projected
magnetic field on the sky. The pattern of the position an-
gle for the viewing angle smaller than 90◦ swings to op-
posite directions from the Crab data at the both peaks.
Therefore, the present model predicts that the viewing
angle larger than 90◦ are preferred for the Crab pulsar.
4. Conclusions
We have considered the light curve, the spectrum and the
polarization characteristics for the Crab pulsar predicted
by the outer gap model which takes into account the emis-
sions from inside the null charge surface and from the ter-
tiary pairs. We have shown that the expected polarization
characteristics are consistent with the Crab optical data
after subtraction of the DC level. The outer gap model
explains the spectrum, light curve and the polarization
characteristics, simultaneously.
Acknowledgements. This work was supported by the Theoret-
ical Institute for Advanced Research in Astrophysics (TIARA)
operated under Academia Sinica and the National Science
Council Excellence Projects program in Taiwan administered
through grant number NSC 94-2112-M-007-002, NSC 94-
2752-M-007-002-PAE and NSC 95-2752-M-007-001-PAE. And
the author, KSC, was supported by a RGC grant number
HKU7015/05P.
References
Blaskiewicz, M. et al. 1991, ApJ, 370, 643
Cheng, K.S., Ho, C. & Ruderman, M. 1986, ApJ, 300, 500
Cheng, K.S., Ruderman, M. & Zhang, L. 2000, ApJ, 537, 964
Daugherty, J.K. & Harding, A.K. 1996, ApJ, 458, 278
Dyks J., Harding A.K. & Rudak B. 2004, ApJ, 606, 1125
Hirotani, K. 2006, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 21, 1319
Kanbach, G. et al. 2005, AIP Conference Proceeding, 801, 306
Kuiper, L., et al. 2001, A&A, 378, 918
Romani R.W. 1996, ApJ, 470, 469
Sollerman, J. et al. 2000, ApJ, 537, 86
Takata, J., Shibata, S. & Hirotani K. 2004, MNRAS, 354, 1120
Takata, J. et al. 2006, MNRAS, 366, 1310
Zhang, L. & Cheng K.S. 1997, ApJ, 487. 370
|
astro-ph/9805144 | 1 | 9805 | 1998-05-12T10:48:02 | Element Ratios and the Formation of the Stellar Halo | [
"astro-ph"
] | It is well-established that the vast majority of metal-poor Galactic halo stars shows evidence for enrichment by solely massive stars. Recent observations have identified more varied behavior in the pattern of elemental abundances measured for metal-rich, [Fe/H]=-1, halo stars, with both high and low values of the ratio of [alpha/Fe]. The low values are most naturally due to the incorporation of iron from Type Ia supernovae. These `low-alpha' halo stars have been interpreted as being accreted from dwarf galaxies. However, these stars are on very high-energy radial orbits, that plunge into the Galactic center, from the outer regions of the stellar halo. We demonstrate here that known dwarf galaxies could not reproduce the observations. Rather, the observations are consistent with fragmentation of a gaseous proto-halo into transient star-forming regions, some of which are sufficiently dense to survive close to the Galactic center, and self-enrich to relatively high metallicities. Those that probe the outer halo sustain star formation long enough to incorporate the ejecta from Type Ia supernovae. The values of the `Type II plateau' in the element ratios for disk stars and for halo stars are equal. This implies that the (massive) stars that enriched the early disk and halo had the same IMF. However, there is a discontinuity in the chemical enrichment history between the halo and disk, as probed by these samples, consistent with previous inferences based on angular momentum considerations. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
ELEMENT RATIOS AND THE FORMATION OF THE STELLAR
HALO
Gerard Gilmore
Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge, UK CB3 0HA
Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218
Rosemary F. G. Wyse
ABSTRACT
It is well-established that the vast majority of metal-poor Galactic halo stars shows
evidence for enrichment by solely massive stars. Recent observations have identified
more varied behavior in the pattern of elemental abundances measured for metal-rich,
[Fe/H]∼ −1 dex, halo stars, with both high and low values of the ratio of [α/Fe]. The
low values are most naturally due to the incorporation of iron from Type Ia supernovae.
These 'low-alpha' halo stars have been interpreted as being accreted from dwarf galax-
ies. However, these stars are on very high-energy radial orbits, that plunge into the
Galactic center, from the outer regions of the stellar halo. We demonstrate here that
known dwarf galaxies could not reproduce the observations, which require the proposed
parent dwarf to have a very high mean density to provide 'low-alpha' stars on orbits
of such low values of periGalactic distance. Rather, the observations are consistent
with fragmentation of a gaseous proto-halo into transient star-forming regions, some
of which are sufficiently dense to survive close to the Galactic center, and self-enrich
to relatively high metallicities. Those that probe the outer halo sustain star formation
long enough to incorporate the ejecta from Type Ia supernovae.
Further, we point out that the values of the 'Type II plateau' in the element ratios
for disk stars and for halo stars are equal. This implies that the (massive) stars that
enriched the early disk and halo had the same IMF. However, the bulk of the halo stars
with [Fe/H]∼ −1 dex that have been observed have significantly lower values of [α/Fe]
than does a typical disk star of that metallicity. Thus there is a discontinuity in the
chemical enrichment history between the halo and disk, as probed by these samples,
consistent with previous inferences based on angular momentum considerations.
Subject headings: Galaxy: halo -- Galaxy: formation -- Galaxy : evolution -- Galaxy
-- abundances
1
1.
Introduction
Elemental abundances contain significantly more
information than just 'metallicity', since differ-
ent elements are synthesised in stars of different
masses, and on different timescales. In particu-
lar, oxygen and the alpha-elements are produced
predominantly by massive stars, ejected into the
interstellar medium by core-collapse, Type II,
supernovae.
Iron has important contributions
by both Type II supernovae and Type Ia su-
pernovae, the latter believed to result from the
explosive nucleosynthesis of degenerate material,
associated with a white dwarf in a binary sys-
tem. The vast majority of local stars belonging
to the Galactic halo population have enhanced
values, compared to that of the Sun, of the ratio
of the abundances of oxygen and of the alpha-
elements to that of iron (e.g. Wheeler, Sneden
& Truran 1989; Nissen et al.
1994; Gratton
et al. 1997a). Further, these halo stars have
very similar values of this 'over-abundance' of
alpha-elements, [α/Fe]halo ∼ +0.3. This 'halo'
value is, within nucleosynthetic yield uncertain-
ties, just that predicted for chemical enrichment
by a mean, IMF-averaged, Type II (core col-
lapse) supernova, assuming a normal (i.e. solar-
neighborhood) massive-star mass function (Wyse
& Gilmore 1992; Nissen et al. 1994).
Thus a typical halo star shows no evidence
for nucleosynthetic products from Type Ia super-
novae. This lack restricts the duration of star for-
mation that created these stars to be shorter than
the time it takes for there to have occurred signif-
icant Type Ia explosions. This timescale is rather
model-dependent.
In the commonly-discussed
double-degenerate models (Iben & Tutukov 1984;
see Iben et al. 1997 for a recent discussion, in-
cluding the expected statistics of close WD bina-
ries) it is plausibly of order 1 Gyr after the forma-
tion of the progenitor stars (e.g. Smecker-Hane &
Wyse 1992; Matteucci & Fran¸cois 1992). A sim-
ilar timescale for significant supernovae follows
from models in which the white dwarf is accret-
2
ing due to Roche-Lobe overflow from a low-mass,
evolved companion (Yungelson & Livio 1998).
This restriction on the duration of star formation
is not necessarily the same as a restriction on the
global age range of the halo, since different re-
gions of the halo could initiate (short-lived) star
formation at different times, resulting in a signif-
icantly larger total age range in the halo (see also
Gilroy et al. 1988 for an analogous argument for
rapid local enrichment, based on the appearance
of s−process elements in metal-poor halo stars).
It is very implausible that the duration of star
formation across the entire halo was as short as
1 Gyr, no matter one's preconceptions of how
the halo formed -- if 'monolithic', this requires
remarkable synchronisation over ∼ 50 kpc, while
if 'chaotic', the regions that formed the halo had
remarkably uniform star formation properties.
Star formation is likely to occur in transient
overdense regions, perhaps of the mass of present-
day Giant Molecular Cloud complexes in the
Galactic disk, even in models that envisage a
well-defined 'monolithic' Galactic potential well
during the formation of the stellar halo (e.g. Fall
& Rees 1985). Was there pre-enrichment of one
region by another? Did some regions self-enrich
sufficiently long to incorporate the products of
Type Ia supernovae? Isochrone-based determi-
nations of the ages of field halo stars are of lim-
ited accuracy, and indeed the only technically-
feasible means of detecting an extended duration
of star formation that may be as short as a Gyr
is to identify halo stars with evidence for pre-
enrichment by Type Ia supernovae. The manifes-
tation of this is lower values of [α/Fe] than can
be understood from Type II supernovae alone.
Given the expectation of some increase in metal-
licity with time as star formation proceeds, the
most natural place to look for such an effect is
among the most chemically-enriched halo stars.
We note that a variation in the massive-star
IMF can also provide for lower values of element
ratios, still with enrichment by only Type II su-
pernovae. However, there is firm observational
evidence for universality of the IMF, surprising
as this may be (see papers in Gilmore & Howell
1998), and indeed any invoked IMF variation to
explain lower values of [α/Fe] would be extremely
ad hoc. Thus we favor interpretations within the
framework of a fixed IMF.
Several recent analyses, most notably that by
Nissen & Schuster (1997), have discovered ex-
actly the element ratio behavior expected for
some enrichment by Type Ia supernovae. The
authors of these analyses have favored, as the ex-
planation for 'low-alpha' halo stars, accretion of
stars from distinct objects such as satellite dwarf
galaxies. Here we argue rather that the observa-
tions are more naturally explained by the varia-
tion in the duration of star formation in regions
of the proto-halo. Fragmentation into cool, dense
self-gravitating regions is fairly generic to models
of the collapse of galaxy-scale perturbations; as-
similation and mixing of these transient regions
is not to be thought of as accretion. Of course,
accretion, in the sense of a distinct other proto-
galaxy merging into our proto-galaxy, remains a
very attractive explanation for the creation of the
thick disk (e.g. Gilmore & Wyse 1985; see Ve-
lazquez & White 1998, for a recent simulation),
some ∼ 12 Gyr ago (e.g. Gilmore, Wyse & Jones
1995).
2. The Observations of Elemental Abun-
dances
Halo stars with low values of the [α/Fe] ele-
ment ratios were identified in a study of metal-
rich halo stars, those with [Fe/H] ∼ −1 dex, by
Nissen & Schuster (1997), and serendipitously
in samples of local, low-metallicity halo stars by
King (1997) and by Carney et al. (1997). Nissen
& Schuster studied approximately equal numbers
of 'disk' and 'halo' dwarfs (16 disk, 13 halo; so
designated based on kinematics) in the metallic-
ity range −1.3 ∼< [Fe/H] ∼< −0.4. Two giant stars
in each of the 'younger' (e.g. Richer et al. 1996)
globular clusters Ruprecht 106 and Pal 12 were
analysed by Brown, Wallerstein & Zucker (1997)
3
and found to have approximately solar values of
alpha-element-to-iron ratios.1
Figure 1 shows the [Mg/Fe] data, as a func-
tion of [Fe/H], for the Nissen & Schuster (1997)
sample of disk and halo stars, plus the anoma-
lous metal-poor halo stars from King (1997) and
Carney et al. (1997); the shaded region indicates
the locus of the majority of metal-poor halo stars
(e.g. Nissen et al. 1994; Gratton et al. 1997a;
note that there are sometimes zero-point offsets
in the value of [Mg/Fe] between different observa-
tional data sets, which can lead to apparent gra-
dients in [α/Fe] plotted against [Fe/H] if all pub-
lished data are naively combined. Each data set
shows similar behavior in their regions of over-
lap in [Fe/H]. Since it is probable that these off-
sets reflect differences in analysis methods rather
than real systematic variations in [α/Fe] as a
function of [Fe/H], we do not consider them fur-
ther here).
As may be seen in the Figure, the major-
ity of the metal-rich halo stars observed shows
significantly lower values of [α/Fe] than the en-
hanced, super-solar values of the alpha-element
ratios derived for the more metal-poor halo stars.
Thus the halo stars with enhanced element ra-
tios are 'anomalous'
in this metallicity range.
This contrasts with the typical (metal-poor) halo
where the stars with low values of [α/Fe] are the
anomalous ones. The halo stars of all metallic-
ity with low values of [α/Fe] share one property
-- they tend to be on orbits with large values of
apoGalactic distances, Rapo ∼> 10 kpc, whereas
the 'normal' halo stars are not to so biased to
the outer halo. This trend suggests a real phys-
ical meaning to the present orbital parameters.
Further, all the halo stars of the Nissen & Schus-
ter (1997) sample are on derived orbits with very
1Note that the relative ages of globular clusters are gener-
ally derived with fixed -- enhanced -- values of the alpha-
element ratios, so this result, if a property of all stars in
the cluster, increases the age assigned to these clusters and
thus reduces the age spread within the system of Galactic
globular clusters.
low periGalactic distances, Rperi ∼< 1 kpc; this
is consistent with the apparent correlation be-
tween Rperi and metallicity established for such
kinematically-selected samples by Ryan & Nor-
ris (1991)2, such that the more metal-rich halo
stars tend to be on orbits of smaller periGalac-
tic distances. Thus all the metal-rich halo stars
observed are on orbits with small values of Rperi,
while of these, the stars with low values of [α/Fe]
are on orbits with large values of Rapo.
Note that it is not the case that all metal-
poor halo stars with large Rapo necessarily have
low values of [α/Fe], although such a trend ex-
ists for the metal-rich stars with low values of
[α/Fe]. As demonstrated in Table 10 of Carney et
al. (1997) there are many metal-poor stars that
have orbits associating them with the outer halo,
but that have normal, enhanced, values of the
alpha-element ratios. The metal-poor halo stars
with low values of [α/Fe] are on retrograde orbits
(King 1997; Carney et al. 1997), but there is no
such signature in the kinematics of the metal-rich
stars with low values of [α/Fe].
3. What Does It All Mean?
We wish to understand why a small fraction of
stars in the stellar halo, biased to metal-rich stars
on high-energy, high-eccentricity orbits, have low
values of [α/Fe].
Consider the pattern of element ratios in self-
enriching systems (of fixed IMF) with given star
formation rates. The solid lines in Figure 1 illus-
trate schematically the trends produced in sim-
2Carney et al. (1996) argue that this correlation arises only
when the azimuthal velocity is used to isolate halo stars
and interpret it as reflecting the existence of a separate
population of very metal-poor 'far' halo stars on retro-
grade orbits. While this is intriguing, the significance of
a distinct population on retrograde orbits is difficult to
establish given that the angular momentum sign of the
orbits of fully 38% of halo stars will be retrograde, given
a mean azimuthal streaming velocity of +30 km/s, and
a V-dispersion of 100 km/s, as found by Ryan & Norris
(1991).
4
ple (homogeneous) models of chemical evolution
with differing star formation rates. The impor-
tant feature is the location of the turndown due
to iron from Type Ia supernovae -- since the short-
est pre-explosion lifetime of Type Ia supernovae
is presumed to be a fixed value, the location of
this turndown occurs at a higher value of [Fe/H]
for a higher star formation rate, reflecting the
more rapid metallicity increase with time (note
that the effect of gas flows on the location of
the turndown from the 'Type II plateau' at early
times/lower metallicities can be incorporated by
a suitably-modified star-formation rate; inflow of
unenriched material will reduce [Fe/H] keeping
[α/Fe] fixed. Outflow driven by Type II super-
novae will behave similarly). Such an effect has
been proposed to explain the element ratios seen
in local disk stars, born at different locations in
the disk (Edvardsson et al. 1993).
Figure 1 shows that the observed differences
in element ratio patterns are inevitable conse-
quences of a variation of the star formation rate.
The amplitude of the invoked variation in star
formation rates is required only to be such as to
allow up to ∼< 1 Gyr longer duration of star for-
mation to produce lower values of [α/Fe]. This
difference in age ranges is undetectable with
current isochrone-based techniques. Note that
there is no requirement from the element ra-
tio data that the progenitor stars of the Type
Ia supernovae be part of the same star form-
ing region as the gas they will eventually enrich.
However, the observed trend for low values of
[α/Fe] to be observed for higher-metallicity halo
stars favors rather self-enrichment scenarios, in
(sub)structure of relatively deep potential wells.
Clearly, the data are consistent with the lower
[α/Fe] stars forming over longer timescales, al-
lowing incorporation of iron from Type Ia super-
novae. But where did these halo stars form? In a
distinct separate galaxy, or essentially where we
observe them now?
3.1. Accretion Models
Nissen & Schuster (1997) considered two pos-
sibilities, either that the outer regions of the stel-
lar halo of the Galaxy had a longer duration of
star formation than did the inner halo, or that
the halo stars with low values of [α/Fe] were ac-
creted from a dwarf galaxy within which star for-
mation is presumed to have been sustained over
a sufficiently long period, longer than in the field
halo. The authors favor the latter explanation.
Indeed, 'distinct accretion events' are the pre-
ferred explanation of all the authors for the data
in Figure 1, and also for the 'anomalous' glob-
ular clusters (it has been suggested that these
two clusters have been captured from the Large
Magellanic Cloud; Lin & Richer 1992).
Motivation for the interpretation in terms of
'accretion' came partially from the prediction of
low values of the alpha-element to iron ratios in
the stars of dwarf galaxies in which there is ex-
tended star formation, perhaps even successive
bursts of star formation, as inferred for many
of the extant satellite galaxies associated with
the Milky Way (Gilmore & Wyse 1991; Una-
vane, Wyse & Gilmore 1996).
It is clear from
observations that only the more massive dwarf
systems can self-enrich to a metallicity of 1/10
the solar value (see, for example the metallicity --
luminosity (mass) relation of Lee et al. 1993).
Of the local dwarf galaxy companions to the
Milky Way, only the Fornax dSph, the Sagittar-
ius dSph and the Magellanic Clouds have a sig-
nificant population of stars as metal-rich as the
observed low-alpha halo stars. However, these
systems also contain stars of a wide range of ages
(e.g. Smecker-Hane 1996), and late accretion of
stars from systems like these satellite galaxies
would produce stars in the halo which are many
Gyr younger than the bulk of the halo, reflecting
the star-formation history of the satellite galaxy
parent. The present sample of 'low-alpha' halo
stars shows no obvious signature of having a rel-
ative youth of this amplitude, which would be
manifest in their colors (e.g. Unavane, Wyse &
5
Fig. 1. -- Iron abundance against element ra-
tio [Mg/Fe] for the halo stars (open circles) and
disk stars (filled circles) from Nissen & Schus-
ter (1997; their Table 4). The disk stars show
a well-defined trend, contrasted with the appar-
ent scatter of the halo stars. The shaded region
marks the locus of normal metal-poor halo stars
in this plane. The star symbol represents the
anomalous metal-poor halo subgiant of Carney
et al. (1997), and the open triangle the anoma-
lous common proper-motion pair of halo dwarfs
from King (1997). The solid lines schematically
illustrate the expected pattern of element ratios
in self-enriching systems of constant IMF, but
varying star formation rates.
Gilmore 1996).
Thus late accretion from systems like the ex-
tant satellite galaxies is not favored. What other
kind of accretion is possible?
Models of the formation of the stellar halo
generically invoke early star formation in tran-
sient ∼ 107 M⊙ local potential wells, perhaps re-
flecting the initial primordial fluctuation power
spectrum, or formed by thermal and/or gravi-
tational instability within a larger system. The
turn-around, collapse and relaxation to dynam-
ical equilibrium of the present-day Galactic po-
tential takes at least a couple of global dynamical
times, or a few Gyr. Thus disruption and as-
similation of transient systems during the relax-
ation of the large-scale Galactic potential should
not be considered as 'accretion', since these sys-
tems never really had a separate identity. Sys-
tems that do retain coherence through this pe-
riod can be said to be 'accreted' if assimilated
subsequently, and it is these we consider next.
Since we are discussing essentially old stars, we
shall focus on the stellar components of this sub-
structure; in any case a satellite galaxy would be
most likely stripped of its gas after a few passages
through the gaseous disk of the Milky Way with
periGalactic distances like those observed for the
halo stars.
'Substructure' orbiting within the (dark halo)
potential of a larger 'parent' galaxy is subject to
tidal forces, and to dynamical friction. The mass
and the (mean) density of the substructure will
to a large extent determine its fate. Dynami-
cal friction will cause the orbit of the substruc-
ture to decay in radius, on a timescale inversely
proportional to the mass of the substructure (for
given orbit and large galaxy); relatively massive
substructure will sink to the center of the larger
galaxy on a few orbital times. Tidal stripping
will cause the substructure to lose material when
its internal gravity is overcome by the gravita-
tional field of the larger galaxy; the simple Jacobi
criterion implies that a system will lose material
unless (or until) its internal density is of order
6
three times the mean density of the larger galaxy
interior to its orbit; simulations have shown that
this simple criterion works remarkably well (e.g.
Johnston, Hernquist & Bolte 1996). Diffuse sub-
structure will lose material while orbiting even
in the far outer regions of the larger galaxy. The
orbits of stars that have been accreted into the
Galaxy by tidal effects on a satellite galaxy are
only slightly different from that of the satellite at
the time the stars were captured; this produces a
kinematic signature of moving groups of stripped
stars, that can persist for many orbital times (cf.
Tremaine 1993; Johnston 1998).
Thus one may consider four broad classes of
dissipationless (stars plus dark matter) substruc-
ture: massive, dense systems will survive fairly
intact while sinking to the center of the larger
galaxy; massive, diffuse systems will be largely
disrupted by tides during their orbital decay; low
mass, dense systems will be largely unaffected,
while low mass, diffuse systems will be disrupted
with no orbital decay.
The stars under consideration here are on
rather eccentric orbits, but with even Rapo much
less than that of typical extant satellite galax-
ies. As discussed by Velazquez & White (1998),
for example,
in their study of the interaction
between satellite galaxies and large disk galax-
ies,
local application of the standard (Chan-
drasekhar) dynamical friction formula provides
reliable results in the case of non-circular orbits.
Thus due to the higher densities in the central
regions of the bigger galaxy, the frictional effects
are higher there. Further, most tidal stripping
occurs at pericenter passage (e.g. Velazquez &
White 1998 and references therein). Thus if the
observed halo stars were removed from a satel-
lite galaxy by tidal stripping, their very low peri-
Galactic distances would require that the satel-
lite galaxy be able to penetrate deep inside the
Milky Way. Their low values of Rapo also would,
in this scenario, require a rather massive satel-
lite, so that dynamical fraction can operate on
less than a Hubble time.
The periGalactic distances provide the more
stringent constraint. As discussed above, the low
[α/Fe] stars are on radial orbits, with periGalac-
tic distances ∼< 5 kpc, and indeed the majority of
the stars having Rperi ∼< 1 kpc. A lower limit to
the mean density of the Milky Way Galaxy inte-
rior to 1 kpc is given by adopting just the mass
of the central bulge, ∼ 1 × 1010M⊙ (e.g. Kent
1992). The predominant stellar populations in
the Galactic bulge and inner disk are probably
at least ∼ 8 Gyr old (Ortolani et al. 1995; Holtz-
man et al. 1993), consistent with theoretical ex-
pectations for the timescale of assembly of the
'core' of the Milky Way in hierarchical-clustering
models (e.g. Lacey & Cole 1993). Thus one may
use inferences from the mass distribution of the
inner Galaxy to constrain the fate of substruc-
ture back to that time.
The mean density interior to the periGalac-
tic approach (∼ 1 kpc) of the 'low-alpha' stars is
then ∼> 2.5 M⊙ pc−3. To be robust against tides,
a satellite galaxy on an orbit with this small a
periGalactic distance would need an mean in-
ternal density of around three times this, or
∼> 7 M⊙ pc−3. This value is significantly larger
(by orders of magnitude) than the typical mean
densities derived for dwarf galaxies, both gas-
poor and gas-rich (e.g. Puche & Carignan 1991;
Ibata et al. 1997). Thus essentially all dwarf
galaxies as we see them now (presumably the
survivors) would be disrupted after only a couple
of such pericenter passages (see Johnston, Hern-
quist & Bolte 1996). Indeed, they would likely
be disrupted significantly earlier in their orbital
decay, when the pericenter distances are of or-
der the present derived apocenter distances of the
anomalous halo stars (e.g. Ibata et al. 1997).
Thus, if the halo stars under discussion repre-
sent stars captured from a satellite galaxy, that
galaxy had to be sufficiently massive to spiral
into the center of the Milky Way in less than a
Hubble time -- this implies a mass perhaps 10%
that of the older stars in the central Milky Way,
or equal to the entire mass of the stellar halo (e.g.
Carney, Latham & Laird 1990). This satellite
had also to be significantly more robust than any
of the extant satellite galaxies (the survivors). If
this satellite contributed to the formation of the
thick disk, it did so without donating any of its
own stars to the disk. Each of these is rather
surprising.
3.2. Halo Star-Formation Regions
The requirements for the progenitor structures
for the metal-rich, 'low-alpha' halo stars may be
summarised as being dense enough to survive to
a periGalactic distance of ∼ 1 kpc, and have a
deep enough local potential well to self-enrich
to −1 dex, while sustaining star formation for
∼ 1 Gyr, being robust not only to internal feed-
back from star formation, but also external ef-
fects. Plausibly the first two of these require-
ments are satisfied by a density criterion for the
substructure, given that the escape energy per
unit mass scales as ρ r2. Sustaining star for-
mation requires gas retention, and the further
requirement that the effects of collisions with
other star-forming clouds, or passages through
the (forming) gas disk of the Galaxy, be min-
imised.
As discussed by many authors (see e.g. Gunn
1980; Jones, Palmer & Wyse 1981) gravitational
instability in the cooling layers behind shocked
gas in the haloes of protogalaxies produces sys-
tems of density ∼> 50M⊙pc−3 and of characteris-
tic (Jeans) mass of a few times 106M⊙. A more
sophisticated analysis by Fall & Rees (1985) in-
cluded thermal instability in the hot, gaseous
halo of a proto-galaxy, like the Milky Way, to
produce cool, dense regions, that are seeds for
gravitational instability. Fall & Rees (1985) ar-
gue that a fairly massive proto-galaxy, with cir-
cular velocity greater than ∼ 150 km/s, is re-
quired for this scenario (essentially to provide
the hot phase of the gaseous halo). In flat Cold-
Dark-Matter dominated cosmologies (e.g. White
& Frenk 1991), dark haloes of this circular ve-
locity have peak abundance at redshifts ∼> 3, or
7
lookback times of ∼> 12 Gyr. Thus this picture
of fragmentation inside dark haloes is reasonable
even in hierarchical clustering scenarios.
The fragments undergo star formation and
are subsequently dispersed, either by the inter-
nal effects of star formation, or the external ef-
fects of cloud-cloud collisions or tidal disrup-
tion by the Galactic potential.
It is plausi-
ble that the fragments probing smaller Galac-
tocentric distance have larger internal densities
(indeed, as predicted by the model of Fall &
Rees 1985) and larger escape velocities, allowing
greater self-enrichment and thus providing a rela-
tion between Rperi and [Fe/H] as observed in the
remnant stars, now the field halo (higher metal-
licity for lower Rperi; Ryan & Norris 1991). The
most dense regions could plausibly form globu-
lar clusters, as suggested by Fall & Rees (1985),
even some of which are subsequently destroyed
(e.g. Gnedin & Ostriker 1997).
The bias to large apoGalactic distances for
the orbits of the 'low-alpha' stars follows natu-
rally from the expected longer survival times of
large, self-enriching clouds in the outer regions
of proto-Galaxy, due to the longer collision times
there, and the larger orbital times. Addition-
ally, a large-scale density gradient could provide
slower local star formation rates in the outer re-
gions, provided the properties of density pertur-
bations correlate with their local background.
Thus fragmentation would appear to provide
the kind of substructure required by the obser-
vations.
4. Disk -- Halo (Dis)connection
A striking aspect of the data in Figure 1 is
that the value of the 'Type II plateau' of element
ratios is the same for the halo stars as for the
disk stars of the same metallicity. Following the
same logic as Wyse & Gilmore (1992), this im-
plies that the IMF of the (massive) stars that
enriched these stars was the same in the early
disk and halo. Inversion of the value of the ele-
ment ratios to determine the actual slope of the
massive star IMF requires adoption of theoreti-
cal supernova yields and is hence uncertain, but
the robust statement that the IMF was invariant
in the enrichment of disk and halo may be made
immediately.
It is also clear from Figure 1 that most of
the metal-rich halo stars do not have element ra-
tios equal to this 'Type II plateau', and that the
typical halo and disk stars of equal metallicity
([Fe/H] ∼ −1 dex) do not have the same values
of the element ratios. There is not the smooth
continuity in chemical enrichment from halo to
disk often derived in models of chemical evolu-
tion. Of course, these halo stars are on orbits
of very different angular momentum than those
of the disk stars, further emphasizing the dis-
tinction between local samples of disk and halo,
and the low likelihood that the halo, as sampled,
pre-enriched the disk (see Wyse & Gilmore 1992;
Gilmore 1995). There is also a spread in [Fe/H]
at fixed values of [Mg/Fe]; as mentioned earlier
in section 3, this may be achieved by different
gas flows/mixing and star formation histories.
The onset of star formation in the local disk,
as measured by the white dwarf luminosity func-
tion, has most recently been estimated to be 10 --
12 Gyr ago (an increase over earlier estimates, in
part due to the inclusion of phase separation and
crystallisation energy in the white dwarf cool-
ing curves; Hernanz et al. 1994; Chabrier 1998).
This older age is in agreement with the ages of
the oldest open clusters (e.g. Phelps 1997) and
the age of the thick disk (e.g. Gilmore, Wyse
& Jones 1995) and in better agreement with
the ages of individual stars from Edvardsson et
al. (1993; see also Ng & Bertelli 1998 for post-
Hipparcos age estimates for stars from this sam-
ple). The recent downward revision in the ages
of the halo globular clusters to ∼ 12 Gyr, based
on Hipparcos calibrations of the luminosities of
field subdwarfs (e.g. Gratton et al. 1997b; Reid
1998), leaves little room for a significant hiatus
between the epoch of halo star formation and the
8
little information about the wings of the metal-
licity distribution of the stellar halo.
The present data for disk and halo stars of
'overlapping' metallicities [Fe/H]∼ −1 dex show
a disk -- halo dichotomy,
in that the elemental
abundances are different for typical disk stars
and for typical halo stars in this metallicity
range, with the halo stars having lower values
of [α/Fe] than the disk stars. This complicates
the requirements for chemical evolution models
for the disk that appeal to gas inflow from the
halo;
indeed if the halo had ejected gas that
pre-enriched the disk, one might have expected
the opposite situation, with the disk stars having
lower values of element ratios than the halo stars.
A simplification of chemical evolution models is
that the elemental abundance data favor a fixed
massive-star IMF for both disk and halo.
We are grateful to NATO Scientific Affairs for
a grant to aid our collaboration. RFGW thanks
all at the Center for Particle Astrophysics (UC
Berkeley) for hospitality during the early stages
of writing of this paper. She acknowledges partial
support from NASA, through ATP grant NAG5-
3928.
onset of star formation in the disk (however, this
calibration depends on many corrections and is
not unique -- see e.g. Pont et al. 1998). It would
follow that disk and halo were independent enti-
ties from the very early stages of Galaxy forma-
tion.
5. Conclusions
The recent observations of halo stars with
elemental abundances reflecting pre-enrichment
from intermediate-mass stars and Type Ia su-
pernovae can be understood in many models of
halo formation. The establishment of trends with
kinematics, suggested at in the present data, will
be important in distinguishing models, as will
be age determinations. The fact that the 'low-
alpha' halo stars tend to be metal-rich favors self-
enrichment scenarios, and the survival of indi-
vidual star-forming complexes for approximately
a Gyr. That the observed low-alpha stars are
on orbits that plunge close to the Galactic cen-
ter also implies that a reasonably robust parent
system is required. We argue for an interpreta-
tion that simply appeals to a small variation in
the duration of star formation within regions of
the stellar halo, rather than 'distinct accretion
events'.
The present data implicates a significant frac-
tion of the metal-rich, outer halo. One may
normalise to the stellar halo as a whole, using
the metallicity distribution for local halo stars
of Carney et al. (1996) in which ∼ 15% of the
stellar halo has [Fe/H]∼> −1 dex, combined with
the halo structural parameters of Unavane, Wyse
& Gilmore (1996) in which ∼ 10% of the halo
is located beyond Z = 5 kpc, to conclude that
at most a few percent (10% times 15%) of the
stellar halo is being discussed. More data -- not
restricted to detailed elemental abundances for
selected halo stars -- will clearly help to substan-
tiate these estimates. For example, the metal-
licity distribution of the halo is derived from lo-
cal, kinematically-selected samples, and the inner
halo is poorly studied. Further, there is currently
9
REFERENCES
Gnedin, O.Y. & Ostriker, J.P. 1997, ApJ, 474,
Brown, J., Wallerstein, G. & Zucker, D. 1997,
AJ, 114, 180
Carney, B., Latham, D. & Laird, J. 1990, AJ, 99,
572.
Carney, B., Wright, E., Sneden, C., Laird, J.,
Aguilar, L. & Latham, D. 1997, AJ, 114, 363
Carney, B., Laird, J., Latham, D. & Aguilar, L.
1996, AJ, 112, 668
Carney, B., Latham, D., Laird, J. & Aguilar, L.
1994, AJ, 107, 2240
Chabrier, G. 1998,
in IAU Symposium 189,
'Fundamental Stellar Properties: The Inter-
action between theory and observation', eds
T.R. Benning, A.J. Booth & J. Davis (Kluwer:
Dordrecht) in press
Edvardsson, B., Andersen, J., Gustafsson, B.,
Lambert, D., Nissen, P. & Tomkin, J. 1993
A&A, 275, 101
Fall, S.M. & Rees, M.J. 1985, ApJ, 298, 18
Gilmore, G. 1995, in IAU Symposium 164, 'Stel-
lar Populations', eds G. Gilmore & P. van der
Kruit (Kluwer, Dordrecht) p99
Gilmore, G. & Wyse, R.F.G. 1985, AJ, 90, 2015
Gilmore, G. & Wyse, R.F.G. 1991, ApJL, 367,
L55
Gilmore, G. & Howell, D. 1998, eds., 'The Stellar
IMF', ASP Conference series 142.
Gilmore, G., Wyse, R.F.G. & Jones, J.B. 1995,
AJ, 109, 1095.
223
Gratton, R., Carretta, E., Clementini, G. & Sne-
den, C. 1997a, in proc. 'Hipparcos Venice 97
Symposium', ESA SP-402.
Gratton, R., Fusi Pecci, F., Carretta, E.,
Clementini, G., Corsi, C & Lattanzi, M.
1997b, ApJ, 491, 749
Gunn, J. 1980,
in 'Globular Clusters', eds
D. Hanes & B. Madore (Cambridge Univer-
sity Press: Cambridge) p301
Hernanz, M., Garcia-Berro, E.,
Isern, J.,
Mochkovitch, R., Segretain, L. & Chabrier, G.
1994, ApJ, 434, 652
Holtzman, J., Light, R.M., Baum, W.A.,
Worthey, G., Faber, S.M., Hunter, D.A.,
O'Neil, E.J., Kreidl, T.J., Groth, E.J. & West-
phal, J.A. 1993, AJ, 106, 1826
Ibata, R., Wyse, R.F.G., Gilmore, G., Irwin, M.
& Suntzeff, N. 1997, AJ, 113, 634.
Iben, I. & Tutukov, A.V. 1984, ApJS, 54, 335
Iben, I., Tutukov, A.V. & Yungelson, L. 1997,
ApJ, 475, 291
Johnston, K., Hernquist, L. & Bolte, M. 1996,
ApJ, 465, 278
Johnston, K. 1998, ApJ, 495, 297
Jones, B.J.T., Palmer, P.L. & Wyse, R.F.G.
1981, MNRAS, 197, 967
Kent, S. 1992, ApJ, 387, 181
King, J. 1997, AJ, 113, 2302
Gilmore, G., Wyse, R.F.G. & Kuijken, K. 1989,
Lacey, C. & Cole, S. 1993, MNRAS, 262, 267
ARAA, 27, 555
Gilroy, K.K., Sneden, C., Pilachowski, C. &
Cowan, J.J. 1988, ApJ, 327, 298.
Lee, M.G., Freedman, W., Mateo, M., Thomp-
son, I., Roth, M. & Ruiz, M.-T., 1993, AJ,
106, 1420
10
Lin, D.N.C. & Richer, H. 1992, ApJL, 358, L57
White, S.D.M. & Frenk, C. 1991, ApJ, 379, 52
Matteucci, F. & Fran¸cois, P. 1992, A&A, 262, L1
Wyse, R.F.G. & Gilmore, G. 1992, AJ, 104, 144
Nissen, P.E. & Schuster, W.J. 1997, A&A, 326,
Yungelson, L. & Livio, M. 1998, ApJ, 497, 168
751
Nissen, P., Gustafsson, B., Edvardsson, B. &
Gilmore, G. 1994, A&A, 285, 440
Ng, Y.K. & Bertelli, G. 1998, A&A, 329, 943
Ortolani, S., Renzini, A., Gilmozzi, R., Marconi,
G., Barbuy, B., Bica, E. & Rich, R.M. 1995,
Nature, 377, 701
Phelps, R. 1997, ApJ, 483, 826
Pont, F., Mayor, M., Turon, C. & vandenBerg,
D.A. 1998, A&A, 329, 87
Puche, D. & Carignan, C. 1991, ApJ, 378, 487
Reid, I.N. 1998, AJ, 115, 204
Richer, H., Harris, W.E., Fahlman, G., Bell, R.,
Bond, H.E., Hesser, J.E., Holland, S., Pryor,
C., Stetson, P., Vandenberg, D.A. & van den
Bergh, S. 1996, ApJ, 463, 602
Ryan, S. & Norris, J. 1991, AJ, 101, 1835
Smecker-Hane, T. A. 1996,
in 'Star Forma-
tion Near and Far' AIP Conf Proc vol 393,
eds. S. Holt & L. G. Mundy (AIP Press: New
York), p571
Smecker-Hane, T. & Wyse, R.F.G. 1992, AJ,
103, 1621
Tremaine, S., 1993, in 'Back to the Galaxy', eds
S. Holt & F. Verter (AIP: New York) p599
Unavane, M., Wyse, R.F.G. & Gilmore, G. 1996,
MNRAS, 278, 727
Velazquez, H. & White, S.D.M. 1998, MNRAS,
in press
Wheeler, J., Sneden, C. & Truran, J. 1989,
ARAA, 27, 279
This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX
macros v4.0.
11
|
astro-ph/0606014 | 1 | 0606 | 2006-06-01T00:01:48 | Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers | [
"astro-ph"
] | Coherent synchrotron emission by particles moving along semi-infinite tracks is discussed, with a specific application to radio emission from air showers induced by high-energy cosmic rays. It is shown that in general, radiation from a particle moving along a semi-infinite orbit consists of usual synchrotron emission and modified impulsive bremsstrahlung. The latter component is due to the instantaneous onset of the curved trajectory of the emitting particle at its creation. Inclusion of the bremsstrahlung leads to broadening of the radiation pattern and a slower decay of the spectrum at the cut-off frequency than the conventional synchrotron emission. Possible implications of these features for air shower radio emission are discussed. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (2006)
Printed 27 October 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers
Qinghuan Luo
School of Physics, The University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
-- Received in original form February, 2006
ABSTRACT
Coherent synchrotron emission by particles moving along semi-infinite tracks is dis-
cussed, with a specific application to radio emission from air showers induced by high-
energy cosmic rays. It is shown that in general, radiation from a particle moving along
a semi-infinite orbit consists of usual synchrotron emission and modified impulsive
bremsstrahlung. The latter component is due to the instantaneous onset of the curved
trajectory of the emitting particle at its creation. Inclusion of the bremsstrahlung
leads to broadening of the radiation pattern and a slower decay of the spectrum at the
cut-off frequency than the conventional synchrotron emission. Possible implications of
these features for air shower radio emission are discussed.
Key words: Plasmas -- radiation mechanisms: nonthermal -- cosmic rays
1
INTRODUCTION
high
energy
growing
attention
recently
is
detection
of
Gorham, et al.
2004; Falcke et al.
(Dagkesamanskii & Zheleznykh
Alvarez-Muniz, V´azquez, & Zas
on
There
cosmic
radio
rays
1989;
Zas, Halzen & Stanev 1992; Hankins, Ekers, & O'Sullivan
2000;
1996;
2004;
Falcke & Gorham
2003;
Falcke, Gorham, & Protheroe
2005).
High energy cosmic rays can initiate an electromagnetic
cascade in a medium where relativistic electrons and
positrons can be produced in a volume with a longitudinal
(along the line of sight) dimension being smaller than the
relevant radio wavelength. So, particles form a coherent
bunch, acting like a single charged particle that emits
a short burst of coherent radio emission. Two radiation
processes have been considered: coherent Cerenkov radi-
ation (Arskar'yan 1962, 1965) and coherent synchrotron
radiation (Falcke & Gorham 2003; Huege & Falcke 2003).
(Coherent radio emission from air showers was first consid-
ered by Kahn & Lerche (1966), also Colgate (1967), but
their theory was not explicitly based on geosynchrotron
emission.) The former requires charge asymmetry, say an
excess of electrons, and a relatively dense medium for
coherent Cerenkov emission to be at radio frequency. For
example, the Moon is a good target for high energy neutri-
nos that can lead to a cascade in the lunar rocks. Excess
electrons can develop leading to coherent Cerenkov emission
at radio frequency with wavelength comparable with or
larger than the longitudinal size of the cascade (Arskar'yan
1962, 1965). For air showers, coherent synchrotron emission
is generally considered more important than Cerenkov
radiation (in the radio band) (Falcke & Gorham 2003;
Gorham, et al. 2004). The shower produces a bunch of
relativistic electrons and positrons emitting coherent syn-
chrotron radiation in geomagnetic fields. Unlike coherent
Cerenkov radiation, coherent synchrotron emission does not
need charge asymmetry (Falcke & Gorham 2003).
(Suprun, Gorham & Rosner
simulation based on the
So far, the relevant spectra of coherent synchrotron
showers were commonly calculated
emission from air
retarded-
using numerical
potential method
2003;
Huege & Falcke 2005a,b). In this method, the radiation
is calculated from the retarded potential (Jackson 1998).
Although coherent synchrotron emission has been consid-
ered analytically (Aloisio & Blasi 2002; Falcke & Gorham
2003; Huege & Falcke 2003), their calculation is based on
the standard synchrotron radiation formula, which does not
include the effect due to the particle's finite track. For air
showers, effective coherent emission occurs in the core of the
shower where most of radiating particles are created. Thus,
it is of interest to consider radiation by a particle moving
along a semi-infinite trajectory. Apart from the usual
synchrotron emission there is emission due to the onset of
the particle's curved trajectory. The latter component is
referred to as the modified impulsive bremsstrahlung (MIB)
as it is due to the combined effect of the usual impulsive
(or prompt) bremsstrahlung due to particle (e±) creation,
which is modeled as an abrupt jump in the particle's
velocity from zero to c, and curvature of the particle's
trajectory. It is worth noting that the finite track effect was
considered for Cerenkov radiation (Tamm 1939) and was
taken into account explicitly in calculation of cosmic-ray
induced showers in a dense medium (Zas, Halzen & Stanev
1992). In the case of Cerenkov radiation, the finite track
leads to a reduction in radiation intensity and modification
2
Luo
of angular distribution of the emission. Since the main
objective of studying radio emission from air showers is
to infer the properties of the cosmic rays that induce
the showers, one needs to determine the radio spectrum
accurately. In this paper, we present a general formalism
for coherent synchrotron radiation from a nonstationary
many-particle system, which takes account of MIB. The
formalism developed here is based on the single particle
treatment (Melrose & McPhedron 1991), in which radia-
tion is due to a current associated with particle's motion
in a medium. Here, the current is regarded as extraneous
as it is different from that due to the plasma response to
waves. The spectrum of radiation from a many-particle
system is derived from the total current that is obtained by
adding all the currents due to individual particles. In the
relativistic limit as in the usual synchrotron radiation, the
spectrum can be expressed in terms of the Airy functions
and as a result, the radiation is highly beamed.
In Sec.2, a general formalism for synchrotron emission
from a many-particle system is derived by including the ef-
fect of MIB due to the effect of a particle's semi-infinite
track. Coherent synchrotron emission is considered in Sec. 3
and the application to air showers is discussed in Sec. 4.
2 ENERGY SPECTRUM
In cosmic ray air showers, electrons and positrons are created
with a relativistic velocity, emitting synchrotron radiation in
the geomagnetic field. Effective coherent emission by these
secondary particles occurs at the core of the shower located
very close to where most particles are produced. Thus, the
finite track effect, in particular the initial position of the par-
ticle's orbit, can be important and needs to be included ex-
plicitly in the calculation of the synchrotron spectral power.
In the following, we start with the single particle formalism.
2.1 Single particle treatment
Consider a charged (q) particle created at t = 0 moving
along a trajectory x(t) with a flight time T . The current
associated with the particle is
j(ω, k) = qZ T
0
dt v(t) exp [i (ωt − k · x(t))] ,
(1)
where v = dx/dt is the particle's velocity. The current (1)
can be regarded as an extraneous current due to a single
particle's motion (as compared to the induced current due
to plasma response). In the usual application to radiation
in astrophysical plasmas, the time integration is taken from
−∞ to ∞ (Melrose 1986). A finite T , particularly the initial
point at t = 0, introduces a boundary (finite track) effect
into (1). The energy spectrum can be found from the ex-
pression (Melrose & McPhedron 1991)
UM (k) =
M · j2,
1
2ε0 e∗
where e∗
M is the complex conjugate of the polarization eM
of the wave emitted in the mode M . The single particle's
spectral power can be derived from PM = UM /T .
(2)
The orbit of a charged particle spiraling in a magnetic
field B oriented along the z-axis can be written as
x(t) = x0c +
v⊥
Ω (cid:20)sin(cid:0)Ωt − ψ0(cid:1)ex + cos(cid:0)Ωt − ψ0(cid:1)ey(cid:21)
(3)
+vkt ez,
where t > 0, x0c is the initial position of the particle's gy-
rocenter, ψ0 is the initial gyrophase, which is defined here
as the the azimuthal angle of the particle's initial velocity
relative to the magnetic field, Ω = ηΩe/γ, q = ηe, η is the
charge sign, γ = 1/(1 − v2/c2)1/2 is the Lorentz factor, and
Ωe = eB/me is the gyrofrequency. The standard method
to calculate the current is to expand the exponential term
in terms of Bessel functions (Melrose & McPhedron 1991).
In the relativistic limit as in the case relevant here, instant
emission can only be seen during a very short time interval
∆t ∼ Rg/cγ3 = β⊥/Ωeγ2, where Rg = v⊥/Ω is the gyrora-
dius. Thus, the orbit can be expanded on tΩe ∼ β⊥/γ2 ≪ 1
and the exponential in (1) can be expressed into the form
ωt − k · x ≈ d + aτ + bτ 3,
where τ = t + t0 with t0 = Ω−1 tan(φ − ψ0) and
a = ω − kkvk
(4)
2 tan(φ − ψ0) sin(φ − ψ0)(cid:21),
b = 1
d = −k · x0c −
−k⊥v⊥(cid:20)cos(φ − ψ0) + 1
6 k⊥v⊥Ω2 cos(φ − ψ0),
Ω(cid:20)ω − kkvk
cos(φ − ψ0)(cid:21) tan(φ − ψ0).
sin2(φ − ψ0)
3 k⊥v⊥
− 2
1
(5)
We assume the observation direction is k = k/k =
(sin θ cos φ, sin θ sin φ, cos θ) and define spherical coordinates
k = er. The projection of the current to the plane perpen-
dicular to k can be written as j⊥ ≡ j − kk · j, which has
the following components:
j⊥θ ≈ eη"v⊥(cid:18)
cos(φ − ψ0)
F
+iΩF ′ sin(φ − ψ0)(cid:19) cos θ − vkF sin θ# eid,
j⊥φ ≈ ieηv⊥ΩF ′ cos(φ − ψ0) eid,
where the relevant integrals are defined as
dτ ei(aτ +bτ 3),
F = Z T +t0
F ′ ≡
∂F
∂a
t0
= iZ T +t0
t0
dτ τ ei(aτ +bτ 3).
(6)
(7)
The relativistic beaming (γ ≫ 1) implies that φ − ψ0 ≪ 1
and α−θ ≪ 1, where α = arctan(v⊥/vk) is the pitch angle.
In these approximations, one has a ≈ ω[1− nβ cos(θ− α)] ≈
(ω/2)[2(1 − n) + γ−2 + (θ − α)2] and b ≈ (nωΩ2/6) cos(φ −
ψ0) sin θ sin α, where the refraction index is assumed to sat-
isfy 1 − n ≪ 1.
Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers
3
2.2 Spectrum
One may write the energy spectrum as the energy radi-
ated per unit frequency per unit solid angle, U (ω, k) =
(ω2/8π3c3)PM UM (k), where UM (k) is given by (2) and
the summation is made over two orthogonal modes. One
finds
U (ω, k) =
≈
ω2
16π3ε0c3(cid:16)j⊥θ2 + j⊥φ2(cid:17)
16π3ε0c(cid:20)(α − θ)2F2 +
e2ω2
Ω2
e
γ2 sin2 α F ′2(cid:21). (8)
The integrals in (7) can be expressed in terms of the Airy
functions provided that the flight time T is much longer
than the duration of the synchrotron pulse (∆t ∼ 1/Ωeγ2).
In this approximation, one may take the limit T + t0 → ∞
and the integrals reduce to the form
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
-0.05
0
2
4
6
8
10
Figure 1. Plots of Gi(ξ) (solid) and Gi′(ξ) (dashed).
F ≈
F ′ ≈
ξ =
π
π
(3b)1/3" Ai(ξ) + iGi(ξ)# − Φ(a, b),
(3b)2/3" Ai′ (ξ) + iGi′(ξ)# −
(3b)1/3 ≈(cid:16) ω
a
∂a
2Ω(cid:17)2/3 2(1 − n) + γ−2 + (θ − α)2
[cos(φ − ψ0) sin θ sin α]1/3 ,
∂Φ(a, b)
(9)
,
(10)
0
0
(12)
dτ ei(aτ +bτ 3),
Φ(a, b) =Z t0
where Gi(ξ) = (1/3)Bi(ξ)−R ξ
[Ai(ξ′)Bi(ξ)− Ai(ξ)Bi(ξ′)]dξ′,
Ai(ξ) and Bi(ξ) are the Airy functions (see Abramowitz &
Stegun 1970). Similar to Ai(ξ) and −Ai′(ξ), both Gi(ξ) and
−Gi′(ξ) are a decaying function for ξ > 0 (as shown in
figure 1). The first terms in both square brackets on the
right-hand sides of (9) and (10) correspond to synchrotron
radiation for a particle moving along a semi-infinite trajec-
tory. The terms Gi and Gi′ describe MIB arising from the
combined effect of the semi-infinite track's initial point and
curvature. One can show that MIB has features of usual im-
pulsive bremsstrahlung (cf. Eq 16), i.e. emission due to an in-
stantaneous change in the velocity from zero to v ∼ c at t =
0 (cf. Eq. 1) (Landau & Lifshitz 1971; Grichine 2003). One
should emphasize here that the impulsive bremsstrahlung
considered here is different from the usual bremsstrahlung
by a charged particle interacting with the Coulomb field of
nuclei in matter. It can be shown that the last terms (Φ
and ∂Φ/∂a) on the right-hand side of both (9) and (10)
can be ignored provided that φ − ψ0γ ≪ π(2Ωeγ2/ω)1/3.
The characteristic frequency can be estimated from a3 ∼ b,
which leads to ω ∼ γ2Ωe.
The spectrum can be written as sum of usual syn-
chrotron emission (Usyn) from a semi-finite track and MIB
emission (Ub) due to the velocity jump at t = 0 and the
trajectory's curvature, that is,
U = Usyn + Ub,
(13)
with
Usyn ≈
e2
16π3ε0c(cid:16) ω
a(cid:17)2"(θ − α)2(cid:16)πξAi(ξ)(cid:17)2
Ub ≈
(11)
e2
(cid:16)πξ2Ai′(ξ)(cid:17)2#,
aγ (cid:19)2
+(cid:18) Ωe sin α
a(cid:17)2"(θ − α)2(cid:16)πξGi(ξ)(cid:17)2
16π3ε0c(cid:16) ω
aγ (cid:19)2
+(cid:18) Ωe sin α
(cid:16)πξ2Gi′(ξ)(cid:17)2#,
(14)
(15)
where we neglect both the term (12) and its derivative.
It is often convenient to separate the radiation into two
components, with one polarized perpendicular to the orbit
plane, corresponding to the first terms in (14) and (15), and
the other polarized in the plane, corresponding to the sec-
ond terms involving derivatives. Specifically, one may write
Usyn = Usyn⊥ + Usynk and Ub = Ub⊥ + Ubk. Notice that
Usyn is smaller by a factor of 4 than that for normal syn-
chrotron emission from a full infinite track (cf. Eq. 17). Tak-
ing the limit Ωe → 0 one can easily verify that Ub reduces to
the familar form for the prompt bremsstrahlung in the case
where a particle's velocity abruptly changes from zero to a
constant velocity (Landau & Lifshitz 1971). In this limit,
the angle α is re-interpreted as an angle that the velocity
makes with respect to the z axis. Since one has ξ → ∞ and
hence πξGi(ξ) → 1 (Abramowitz & Stegun 1970), one finds
Ub(ω, k) ≈
e2
4π3ε0c(cid:20)
θ − α
γ−2 + (θ − α)2(cid:21)2
,
(16)
which is the same as that for the case where a particle in-
staneously acquires a constant velocity (Landau & Lifshitz
1971).
Apart
the usual
from its property of
impulsive
bremsstrahlung, MIB also has a feature of synchrotron ra-
diation (cf. Sec. 2.3), i.e. Ub increases with frequency as a
power-law, similar to the usual synchrotron spectrum at low
frequencies. Such similarity can be understood as due to that
the emitting particle's trajectory is curved, while for the
usual impulsive bresstrahlung the particle's trajectory is a
straight line. Because of this similar feature to synchrotron
radiation MIB is nonzero when one applies it to pair cre-
ation.
4
Luo
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
-10
-5
0
(θ−α)γ
5
10
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
-10
-5
0
(θ−α)γ
5
10
Figure 2. Plot Uk (arbitrary scale) as a function of (θ − α)γ
with φ = ψ0 for a single particle. The dashed line corresponds to
the usual synchrotron emission with Uk = 4Usynk, in the absence
of MIB emission. We assume γ = 80, n = 1, the gyrofrequency
Ωe = 5 × 106 s−1, ω/2π = 100 MHz and the pitch angle α = π/4.
Figure 3. Plot U⊥ (arbitrary scale) as a function of (θ − α)γ
with φ = ψ0. The parameters are as in figure 2. Apart from a
reduction in intensity, the modified synchrotron emission (usual
synchrotron plus MIB) has a much wider profile than the usual
synchrotron emission.
2.3 Usual synchrotron radiation
The conventional synchrotron emission can be reproduced
by adding the other semi-infinite orbit from −∞ to 0 in
(1). Specifically, one first drops the terms Φ in (9) and
∂Φ/∂a in (10), both of which are cancelled out by the
corresponding terms from the negative semi-infinite trajec-
tory, and then replaces F and F ′ in (8) with 2Re(F ) and
2Re(F ′), respectively. Thus, the bremsstrahlung terms can-
cel out. One then reproduces the usual synchrotron for-
mula (Melrose & McPhedron 1991)
1.75
1.5
1.25
1
0.75
0.5
0.25
U (ω, k) = 4Usyn
e2
≈
6π3ε0c(cid:16) ω
×"
(θ − α)2
γ−2 + (θ − α)2 K2
Ω sin α(cid:17)2(cid:20)γ−2 + (θ − α)2(cid:21)2
2/3(ρ)#,
1/3(ρ) + K2
-7.5
-5
-2.5
2.5
5
7.5
0
(θ−α)γ
Figure 4. Angular profile (arbitrary scale) as in figure 2. The
solid and dashed lines correspond respectively to Ubk and Usynk.
(17)
where n = 1 and ρ = (2/3)ξ3/2. We rewrite the Airy func-
tions in terms of the modified Bessel functions and the ap-
proximations θ − α ≪ 1 and φ − ψ0 ≪ 1 are used.
The angular distribution of single particle's spectrum
(13) is shown in figures 2-5. Here, the radiation is separated
into the parallel component, Uk = Usynk + Ubk and perpen-
dicular component, U⊥ = Usyn⊥ + Ub⊥. The inclusion of the
boundary effect leads to an overall reduction in intensity and
a significant broadening of the angular profile. Figures 6 and
7 show a comparison of the two components Ub and Usyn as
a function of frequency. These two components are similar to
each other at low frequencies. However, Ubk has two cutoffs,
with the lower one determined from the zero of Gi′(ξ) (cf.
figure 1). For the perpendicular polarization, Ub⊥ levels out
at high frequencies and behaves much like the usual impul-
sive bremsstrahlung. The energy spectrum for the parallel
polarization is shown in figure 8. The synchrotron emission
drops off exponentially above the critical frequency. Since
Gi(ξ) ∼ 1/ξ and Gi′(ξ) ∼ 1/ξ2, which drop off much slower
than the exponential decay of Ai(ξ) and Ai′(ξ) at a large
ξ, the bremsstrahlung component decays much slower than
the usual synchrotron emission.
1.75
1.5
1.25
1
0.75
0.5
0.25
0
-10
-5
0
(θ−α)γ
5
10
Figure 5. Angular profile (arbitrary scale) as in figure 2. The
solid and dashed lines correspond respectively to Ub⊥ and Usyn⊥.
Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers
5
U2π
b ,
2π
Usyn
-33
10
-34
10
-35
10
U2π
-33
10
-34
10
-35
10
8
10
9
10
ω/2π
(Hz)
10
10
8
10
9
10
10
10
ω/2π (Hz)
Figure 6. Energy spectrum (in J Hz−1 sr−1) as a function of
frequency ω/2π (Hz) for φ = ψ0 for a single particle. The solid
and dashed lines represent 2πUbk and 2πUsynk, respectively. We
assume (θ − α)γ = 0.5, N = 107, γ = 80, n = 1, Ωe = 5 × 106 s−1,
(θ − α)γ = 0.5, and ψ = ψ0. At low frequencies, the spectrum is
very similar to that for the usual synchrotron, i.e. U ∝ ω2/3 for
ω ≪ ωc ∼ Ωeγ2.
Figure 8. Energy spectrum 2πUk = 2π(Ubk + Usynk) (in
J Hz−1 sr−1). The dashed line corresponds to synchrotron emis-
sion 8πUsynk. The parameters are as in figure 6. In comparison
with the normal synchrotron emission (dashed line), due to the
MIB the spectrum (solid line) drops off much slower than the
exponential decay at ω ≫ ωc.
U2π b
2πUsyn
,
-33
10
-34
10
-35
10
8
10
9
10
10
10
ω/2π
(Hz)
Figure 7. Energy spectrum as in figure 6 for the ⊥-polarized
components. Notice that the spectral component 2πUb⊥ (solid
line) tends to level out at high frequencies where the approximate
form (16) applies.
2.4 Many-particle system
The single particle formula can be extended to a many-
particle system by adding all the currents from individ-
ual particles. Let the sth particle be created at time ts. A
nonzero ts adds a phase term ωts to (5). The total current
can be obtained summing up all individual currents given
by (6) with all relevant quantities labelled by s. Then, the
total energy spectrum is derived as
Utot(ω, k) ≈
e2ω2
16π3ε0c
+
Ω2
e
γsγs′
N
Xs,s′=1(cid:20)ηsηs′ (αs − θ)(αs′ − θ)FsF ∗
s′
sin αs sin αs′ F ′
sF ′∗
′ ,
(18)
s′(cid:21) eiϕss
where N is the total number of charged particles. The co-
herence is determined by the phase ϕss′ = ds − ds′ , given
by
ϕss′ ≈ ω(ts − ts′ ) − k · (x0s − x0s′ )
−
+
ω
Ωs
ω
Ωs′
[1 − nβs cos(θ − αs)] (φ − ψ0s)
[1 − nβs′ cos(θ − αs′ )] (φ − ψ0s′ ).
(19)
We use the following expression for the initial position:
x0 = x0c − (v⊥/Ω)(sin ψ0 ex − cos ψ0 ey). The usual sponta-
neous emission corresponds to that the phase is ϕss′ ≫ 1
for s 6= s′ and that only terms of s = s′ contribute to the
total spectrum. Therefore in the case of spontaneous syn-
chrotron radiation, the total spectrum can be written as
Utot = N ¯U , where ¯U is the single particle's spectrum aver-
aged over the particles' momentum distribution. Since the
initial gyrophase does not enter the final form of the energy
spectrum, spontaneous synchrotron radiation is axially sym-
metric with respect to the magnetic field line direction, i.e.
the angular pattern of emission depends only on θ not φ. In
the case of coherent synchrotron emission (cf. Sec. 3), such
symmetry is broken since the maximum coherence depends
explicitly on the initial gyrophases (cf. Eq. 19).
3 COHERENT SYNCHROTRON EMISSION
Coherent emission occurs provided that the majority of
emitting particles satisfy the condition ϕs − ϕs′ ≪ 1. In
general, one can calculate the total spectrum numerically
using (18) for a given distribution of the particle injection
time, position and initial velocity. In some special cases, one
may write down its analytical form. The simplest case is
where all particles have the same initial velocity, which is
considered here.
One may write the total spectrum into the form
6
Luo
(20)
Utot = NhS⊥(ω)U⊥ + Sk(ω)Uki,
where 1 6 Sk,⊥(ω) 6 N is called the coherence factor.
The value Sk,⊥(ω) = N corresponds to completely coherent
emission and Sk,⊥(ω) = 1 to spontaneous emission. When
the number densities of electrons and positrons are equal,
j⊥θ does not contribute to the coherent power as contribu-
tions from electrons and positrons cancel out. This leads to
S⊥ = 1. The total spectrum is
e2
Utot = NhU⊥ + Sk(ω)Uki,
16πε0c sin α(cid:16) 4ω
Uk ≈
×(cid:20)Ai′2(ξ) + Gi′2(ξ)(cid:21),
Ωe sin α(cid:17)2/3
(21)
(22)
where ξ ≈ (ω/2Ω sin α)2/3[γ−2 + (θ − α)2] and n = 1 is
assumed. In contrast to coherent Cerenkov emission, which
requires a charge asymmetry (net charge) (Askar'yan 1962,
1965), coherent synchrotron emission can occur for a neutral
plasma. In the case of charge symmetry, the polarization is
linear, perpendicular to the plane of the magnetic field and
wave vector. The coherence factor is then given by
Sk(ω) =
1
N
N
Xs,s′=1
cos [ω(ts − ts′ ) − k · (x0s − x0s′ )] .
(23)
Eq. (23) is sum of phasors, which can be modeled as (e.g.
Hartemann 2000)
Sk(ω) ≈ 1 − hcos Θi2 + Nhcos Θi2
+2hcos ΘihN (1 − hcos Θi2)i1/2
,
(24)
where N ≫ 1, Θ = ω(ts − n · x0s/c), n = kc/ω, and the
average is made over a distribution P (Θ),
hcos Θi ≡Z 2π
0
dΘ P (Θ) cos Θ.
(25)
For a uniform distribution P (Θ) = 1, corresponding to spon-
taneous emission, one has Sk(ω) = 1, and for P (Θ) = δ(Θ),
one has Sk(ω) = N , corresponding to completely coherent
emission. As an example, we consider the case in which par-
ticles are injected at the same time, say at ts = 0, with
a gaussian profile in the longitudinal (along k) spatial dis-
tribution with a width ∆l. The probability can be written
as
P (Θ) =
1
√π∆Θ
e−(Θ/∆Θ)2
,
(26)
where ∆Θ = ω∆l/c. Then, one finds
hcos Θi =
exp(−∆Θ2/2) = exp[−(ω∆l/c)2/2]. A plot of Sk as a func-
tion of ∆l is shown in figure 9. Similarly, if all particles are
injected at the same location with a gaussian profile with a
width ∆t in time, one has hcos Θi = exp[−(ω∆t)2/2]. This
shows that to attain effective coherence, the spread in time
of particle injection must be ∆t ∼ √2/ω. The spectrum
from a gaussian bunch is calculated using (20) and is shown
in figure 10. The spectrum consists of two regions, separated
by a critical frequency ωcoh ∼ (2 ln N )1/2c/∆l: the coherent
(Sk > 1) emission region ω < ωcoh, where the polarization
is predominantly linear, and spontaneous (Sk = 1) emission
S
7
10
6
10
5
10
4
10
3
10
2
10
10
1
0
2
4
6
8
10
l /λ∆
Figure 9. Coherence factor vs bunch size. The solid and dashed
lines correspond respectively to a gaussian bunch (26) and a
bunch of Γ-form (27) with A = 5. One assumes the total number
of emitting particles N = 107. The bunch size is in units of the
wavelength λ.
region ω > ωcoh, where the polarization is elliptical as both
Uk and U⊥ are present. The calculation of the coherence
factor can easily be extended to other types of distribution.
In particular, the Γ-probability distribution is thought to
be the more relevant for air showers (Agnetta et al. 1997),
which is discussed in detail in Sec. 4.
As the secondary particles from air showers have a dis-
tribution in momentum, one needs to use the full expression
(18) to calculate the spectrum. When the particle's momen-
tum distribution is included, an analytical form for the spec-
trum can be derived only in some special cases. For example,
when the bunch size is smaller than the relevant wavelength,
one may ignore the phase term (19) and expresses the spec-
trum as a integration of the single particle formula over the
particle's distribution. The total intensity is about N 2 times
larger than that by single particle.
4 APPLICATION TO AIR SHOWERS
The formalism developed in the previous sections can
be applied to radio emission from extensive air show-
ers (EAS). Detailed modeling requires numerical model-
ing of EAS, which was already considered by several au-
thors (Suprun, Gorham & Rosner 2003; Huege & Falcke
2005a,b). Here we only discuss qualitatively implications of
the modified synchrotron emission for radio emission from
EAS and further detailed modeling will be considered else-
where. A notable feature of the modified synchrotron emis-
sion is that the corresponding intensity derived from a semi-
inifinite orbit is smaller than the conventional synchrotron
emission by about a factor of 4. In principle, this feature
can be tested against observations provided accurate radio
spectra with well calibrated intensities become available,
for example with the planned Low Frequency Array (LO-
FAR) (Falcke & Gorham 2003). Other features include an
angular broadening of the radiation pattern and a slower de-
cay of the spectrum above the critical frequency (ω ∼ Ωeγ2).
The broadening due to prompt bremstrahlung is more pro-
Coherent synchrotron emission from cosmic ray air showers
7
U2π
tot
-20
10
-22
10
-24
10
-26
10
-28
10
8
10
9
10
ω/2π (Hz)
10
10
Figure 10. Spectrum 2πUtot (in J Hz−1 sr−1) from a gaus-
sian bunch (solid line) with a longitudinal size ∆l = 1 m and
the Γ-pdf bunch (long-dashed line) with A = 3. The short-
dashed line corresponds to the spectrum derived by ignoring
the prompt bremstrahlung. The parameters are as in figure 6.
There is a critical frequency ωcoh that separates the spectrum
into the coherent region ω < ωcoh and spontaneous emission re-
gion ω > ωcoh. For the gaussian bunch, the critical frequency
is ωcoh/2π ∼ (2 ln N )1/2c/2π∆l ∼ 270 MHz and for the Γ-pdf
bunch it is ωcoh/2π ∼ (c/∆l)N 1/(1+A) ≈ 1 GHz.
nounced for the perpendicular polarization than for the par-
allel polarization. Since the perpendicularly polarized com-
ponent depends on the charge excess, such broadening is
important when there is significant charge asymmetry. The
spectral hardening occurs near the synchrotron cut-off fre-
quency, which is much higher than the transition frequency
ωcoh. So, this spectral feature may not be observable for air
showers.
In the following we derive the coherence factor using
the procedure in Sec. 3. As an example, one assumes that
an air shower occurs at a few km height and that all emit-
ting particles are located in the shower maximum. As the
zeroth order approximation, the near field effect can be ig-
nored and the energy spectrum (Eq. 18) derived in Sec. 2 is
applicable. The near field effect may need to be included if
the maximum of an air shower develops very near the ground
level. There are extensive discussions of air showers in the
literature (Gaisser 1990) and in principle, one can obtain a
distribution of particle's injection time (ts), initial momen-
tum (γv0s) and position (x0s). Assuming the primary cos-
mic ray energy to be Ep, the number of secondary electrons
and positrons can be estimated as N ∼ Ep/γmec2 ∼ 107
for Ep ∼ 1015 eV and γ = 80. In the practical situation
these particles are injected over an extended range rather
than at a single fixed height. For EAS, the distribution in ts
for secondary electrons/positrons can be inferred from mea-
surements of arrival times of charged particles (muons plus
electrons/positrons). One should note that these measured
times are not actual arrival times of electrons and positrons
since muons arrive earlier than electrons/positrons. The ar-
rival times can be modeled by a Γ-probability distribution
function (Γ-pdf) (Agnetta et al. 1997; Antoni, et al. 2001).
Thus, the probability can be written as (Huege & Falcke
2003):
P (Θ) =
1
∆ΘΓ(1 + A) (cid:16) Θ
∆Θ(cid:17)A
e−Θ/∆Θ,
(27)
for Θ > 0 and P (Θ) = 0 for Θ 6 0, where Γ(x) is the Gamma
function and the power index A can be estimated from the
distribution of electrons arrival times. The standard devia-
tion is σΓ = (1 + A)1/2∆Θ. From (27), one obtains
hcos Θi =(cid:0)1 + ∆Θ2(cid:1)−(1+A)/2
cos(cid:20)(1 + A) arctan ∆Θ(cid:21), (28)
hΘi = (1 + A)∆Θ.
The corresponding critical frequency is given by ωcoh ∼
(c/∆l)N 1/(1+A). This frequency defines a transition from
coherent to incoherent emission. For ∆l = 1 m, N = 107
and A = 5, one has ωcoh/2π ∼ 1.2 GHz. The coherence fac-
tor can be obtained by substituting (28) for (24). Here we
write down the two limiting cases:
(29)
Sk ≈
N (1 + ∆Θ2)−1−A
× cos2(cid:20)(1 + A) arctan ∆Θ(cid:21), ω < ωcoh,
ω ≫ ωcoh.
1,
(30)
The dashed line in figure 9 shows Sk as a function of
the bunch size ∆l, featuring a higher transition frequency
ωcoh than the gaussian bunch. The low-frequency approx-
imation in (30) corresponds to the nonsquared form given
by Huege & Falcke (2003) except that the cosine factor is
retained here.
The coherent emission can be elliptically polarized if
there is a charge excess as it is the case for air showers.
Assuming the excess number of electrons is Nc, one has
.
(31)
Nc
N
S⊥
Sk ∼
The right-hand side is sensitive to the cut-off energy of the
excess electron energy. For a cut-off near the MeV energy,
the excess of electrons can reach Nc/N ∼ 10 − 15%. (Note
that cascades in a dense medium such as rocks can give rise
to about Nc/N ∼ 20% excess negative charge.) As a result,
the coherent emission can be elliptically polarized with an
ellipticity ∼ (S⊥/Sk)1/2δc = (Nc/N )2δc ∼ 0.3δc, where δc is
the typical ellipticity of single particle's radiation.
5 CONCLUSIONS
Synchrotron emission by a particle moving along a semi-
infinite trajectory is considered. Since effective coherent syn-
chrotron emission by secondary particles in an air shower
occurs in the core of the shower where most emitting parti-
cles are created, the initial point of the particle's trajectory
need be included explicitly. It is shown that radiation from a
particle moving along a semi-infinite track can be separated
into the usual synchrotron emission and the bremsstrahlung-
like emission (MIB). The latter is due to emission as the
result of onset of the particle's curved trajectory. The spec-
tral intensity of the modified synchrotron emission (usual
synchrotron plus MIB) is lower than that for normal syn-
chrotron emission, roughly by a factor of 4. It is interest-
ing to note that such reduction is consistent with the re-
cent result from numerical simulation by Huege & Falcke
Dagkesamanskii, R. D. & Zheleznykh, M., 1989, JETP
Lett. 50, 259.
Falcke, H. et al. 2005, Nature, 435, 313.
Falcke, H. & Gorham, P., Astrop. Phys. 19, 477.
Falcke, H., Gorham, P., & Protheroe, R. J., 2004, New
Astron Rev. 48, 1487.
Gaisser, T. K., 1990, Cosmic Rays and Particle Physics
(Cambridge: University Press).
Gorham, P. W., et al., 2004, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 041101.
Grichine, V. M., 2003, Radiation Phy. & Chem. 67, 93.
Hankins, T., Ekers, R., & O'Sullivan, J. D., 1996, MNRAS,
283, 1027.
Hartemann, F., 2000, Phys. Rev. E61, 972.
Huege, T. & Falcke, H., 2005, Astroparticle Phys. 24, 116.
Huege, T. & Falcke, H., 2005, A&A, 430, 779.
Huege, T. & Falcke, H., 2003, A&A, 412, 19.
Jackson, J. D., 1998, Classical Electrodynamics (New York:
Wiley).
Kahn, F. D. & Lerche, I., 1966, Proc. R. Soc. London,
A289, 206.
Landau, L. D. & Lifshitz, E. M., 1971, The Classical Theory
of Fields (Oxford: Pergamon Press).
Melrose, D. B., 1986, Instabilities in Space and Laboratory
Plasmas, Cambridge University Press.
Melrose, D. B., McPhedron, R. C., 1991, Electromagnetic
processes in dispersive media, Cambridge U. press.
Suprun, D. A., Gorham, P. W., & Rosner, J. L., 2003, As-
troparticle Phys. 20, 157.
Tamm, I. E., 1939, J. Phys. (Moscow) 1, 439.
White, S. M. & Melrose, D. B., 1982, PASA 4, 362.
Zas, E., Halzen, F., & Stanev, T., 1992, Phys. Rev. D45,
362.
8
Luo
(2005b). The radiation pattern has a broader angular dis-
tribution than the usual synchrotron emission. This feature
is especially pronounced for the perpendicularly polarized
component. The spectrum has a much slower decay above
the critical frequency ω ∼ γ2Ωe, while the usual synchrotron
spectrum has an exponential cutoff above the critical fre-
quency. In the application to radio emission from air show-
ers, the reduced intensity can be verified in principle pro-
vided accurate observations of the radio spectrum are avail-
able. Although there exist early observations of air shower
radio emission, there are some uncertainties in determining
the calibration factor (Allan 1971; Atrashkevich et al 1978).
The current LOFAR Prototype Station (LOPES) and the
future LOFAR may provide a better opportunity to test the
predicted spectrum. Since the transition frequency (to spon-
taneous emission) is much lower than the cut-off frequency,
change near the cut-off frequency may not be observable.
The broadening of the radiation pattern occurs mainly for
the perpendicularly polarized component, which may be ob-
servable provided that there is significant charge asymmetry
in the emitting plasma.
A major advantage of the formalism presented here
is that the initial conditions including the time of parti-
cle creation, initial velocity and gyrophase all appear in
the phase (19) and these quantities can be modeled sta-
tistically. Although the single-particle formalism was used
by White & Melrose (1982) to treat coherent gyromagnetic
emission, in their calculation, the finite track effect was not
considered. It is shown here that the distribution of the par-
ticle injection time is important in determining the coher-
ence. The semi-infinite track approximation adopted here is
valid provided that the emitting particles are highly rela-
tivistic with γ ≫ 1. In the relativistic limit, the synchrotron
pulse duration (1/Ωeγ2 ∼ 10−8 s) is much shorter than the
typical flight time T ∼ 10−6 s for a particle's free path 500
m, and therefore the orbit can be approximately regarded as
semi-infinite. If electrons and positrons from an air shower
have an energy cutoff extending to MeV energies with γ ∼ 1,
the synchrotron approximation is no longer valid and one has
cyclotron emission instead. In this case, a finite orbit needs
to be considered. One may extend the calculation in Sec. 3
and 4 to include the particle distribution in momentum and
this requires a numerical approach, which is not considered
here.
REFERENCES
Abramowitz, M., Stegun, I., 1991, Handbook of Mathemat-
ical Functions (New York: Dover Publications).
Agnetta, G. et al. 1997, Astroparticle Phys. 6, 301.
Allan, H. R., 1971, in Progress in Elementary Particles and
Cosmic Ray Physics, Vol. 10, p. 171.
Aloisio, R. & Blasi, P. 2002, Astroparticle Phys. 18, 183.
Alvarez-Muniz, J., V´azquez, R. A., & Zas, E., 2000, Phys.
Rev. D62, 063001.
Antoni, T. et al. 2001, Astroparticle Phys. 14, 245.
Askar'yan, G. A. 1962, Sov. Phys. JETP, 14, 441.
Askar'yan, G. A. 1965, Sov. Phys. JETP, 21, 658.
Atrashkevich, V. B. et al., 1978, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 28,
366.
Colgate, S. A., 1967, J. Geophys. Res. 72, 4869.
|
astro-ph/0110477 | 1 | 0110 | 2001-10-22T08:46:43 | RR Lyrae variables in the dwarf spheroidal galaxy Leo I | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report the discovery of a significant population of RR Lyrae variables in the dwarf spheroidal galaxy Leo I. Based on 40 V and 22 B images of the galaxy taken using the ESO Wide Field Imager we have identified so far 74 candidate RR Lyrae's in two CCD's hosting the main body of the galaxy. Full coverage of the light variations and pulsation periods have been obtained for 54 of them, 47 of which are Bailey {\it ab}-type RR Lyrae's (RRab's) and 7 are {\it c}-type (RRc's). The period distribution of the presently confirmed sample of RRab's peaks at P=0\fd60, with a minimum period of 0\fd54. The pulsational properties indicate for Leo I an intermediate Oosterhoff type, similar to other dwarf galaxies in the Local Group and the LMC. However, the rather long minimum period of the {\it ab}-type variables, and the significant number of RRab's with long period and large amplitude, suggest that the bulk of the old population in Leo I is more like the Oosterhoff type II globular clusters. The most straightforward interpretation is that a range in metallicity is present among the RR Lyrae's of Leo I, with a significant population of very metal-poor stars. Alternatively, these OoII variables could be more evolved. The average apparent magnitude of the RR Lyrae's across the full cycle is $<V(RR)>= 22.60 \pm 0.12$ mag, yielding a distance modulus $(m-M)_{V,0}= 22.04\pm 0.14$ mag for Leo I on the ``long'' distance scale. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 19/02/01
RR LYRAE VARIABLES IN THE DWARF SPHEROIDAL GALAXY LEO I 1
Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, I-35122 Padova, Italy
[email protected]
ENRICO V. HELD
GISELLA CLEMENTINI
Osservatorio Astronomico di Bologna, Via Ranzani 1, I-40127 Bologna, Italy
[email protected]
LUCA RIZZI2
Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, I-35122 Padova, Italy
[email protected]
YAZAN MOMANY
Dipartimento di Astronomia, Università di Padova, Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 2, I-35122 Padova, Italy
[email protected]
IVO SAVIANE
European Southern Observatory, Casilla 19001, Santiago 19, Chile
[email protected]
AND
LUCA DI FABRIZIO
Centro Galileo Galilei & Telescopio Nazionale Galileo, PO Box 565, 38700 S.Cruz de La Palma, Spain
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
We report the discovery of a significant population of RR Lyrae variables in the dwarf spheroidal galaxy Leo I.
Based on 40 V and 22 B images of the galaxy taken using the ESO Wide Field Imager we have identified so far
74 candidate RR Lyrae's in two CCD's hosting the main body of the galaxy. Full coverage of the light variations
and pulsation periods have been obtained for 54 of them, 47 of which are Bailey ab-type RR Lyrae's (RRab's)
and 7 are c-type (RRc's). The period distribution of the presently confirmed sample of RRab's peaks at P=0.d60,
with a minimum period of 0.d54. The pulsational properties indicate for Leo I an intermediate Oosterhoff type,
similar to other dwarf galaxies in the Local Group and the LMC. However, the rather long minimum period
of the ab-type variables, and the significant number of RRab's with long period and large amplitude, suggest
that the bulk of the old population in Leo I
is more like the Oosterhoff type II globular clusters. The most
straightforward interpretation is that a range in metallicity is present among the RR Lyrae's of Leo I, with a
significant population of very metal-poor stars. Alternatively, these OoII variables could be more evolved. The
average apparent magnitude of the RR Lyrae's across the full cycle is hV (RR)i = 22.60 ± 0.12 mag, yielding a
distance modulus (m - M)V,0 = 22.04 ± 0.14 mag for Leo I on the "long" distance scale.
Subject headings: Galaxies: individual (Leo I) -- galaxies: dwarf -- galaxies: stellar content -- Local Group --
stars: horizontal-branch -- stars: variables: other
1. INTRODUCTION
RR Lyrae have long been recognized to be excellent tracers
of old stellar populations, as well as good distance indicators
for Population II systems. RR Lyrae variables and/or extended
horizontal branches (HB's) are now known to exist in all Local
Group dwarf spheroidal (dSph) galaxies, despite the different
and complex star formation histories (Mateo 1998; Da Costa
1998). The Leo I dSph was believed to represent the only ex-
ception to this general trend, with its predominantly "young"
population, and a wealth of intermediate age He-burning stars
giving rise to a conspicuous red clump (Lee et al. 1993; Ca-
puto et al. 1998; Gallart et al. 1999a, 1999b). Recently, color-
magnitude diagrams (CMD's) extended to the outer regions have
revealed a horizontal branch well populated from blue to red
(Held et al. 2000). Given the presence of an extended HB and
the low metallicity of the system ([Fe/H]∼ - 2, Lee et al. 1993)
one would naturally expect to find RR Lyrae variables in Leo I.
Indeed, a few stars near the limit of photographic photometry
were mentioned by Hodge & Wright (1978) as probable RR
Lyrae's caught at maximum light. Unpublished work of Keane
et al. (1993) also reports the presence of these variables.
To confirm these early suggestions, a search for RR Lyrae
and other short period variables in Leo I was undertaken using
the CCD mosaic imager at the 2.2m ESO-MPI telescope. In
this letter we report on the successful detection of a conspicu-
ous number (& 70) of RR Lyrae variables in this galaxy. The
identification of RR Lyrae's in Leo I and the determination of
their average luminosity and pulsational properties provide us
with important tools for studying the metallicity and age of the
oldest stellar population and the early star formation history of
Leo I, by allowing at the same time a new independent mea-
surement of the distance to this galaxy.
1 Based on data collected at E.S.O. La Silla, Chile, Prop. No. 65.N-0530
2 also Dipartimento di Astronomia, Università di Padova
1
2
2. OBSERVATIONS AND REDUCTION
Images of Leo I
(α2000=10 08 27, δ2000=12 18 30) through
the B, V , I filters were obtained on the nights of April 20-25,
2000 with the Wide Field Imager (WFI) at the 2.2 m ESO-MPI
telescope at La Silla, Chile. The WFI camera consists of 8
"ccd 44"-type EEV CCD's with a total field of view 34′ × 33′.
This coverage allowed us to observe the body of the galaxy and
its outer regions in just one pointing. The main body of the
galaxy was centered on the lower four CCD's of the mosaic to
reduce light contamination from Regulus, which is about 20 ar-
cmin south. The full data-set comprises 22 B, 40 V , and 4 I
15-min exposures totaling ∼ 20 hours of observing time spread
over 6 consecutive half nights. Weather conditions were gen-
erally photometric, while the seeing varied considerably during
the observations. Standard stars from Landolt (1992) were ob-
served during all photometric nights of the run in all CCD's.
Basic reduction (flat fielding, registration, co-adding) of the
CCD mosaic data were performed using the IRAF 3 package
MSCRED (Valdes 1998) and the pipeline script package WF-
PRED developed at the Padua Observatory. Reductions were
done, and data calibrated, for the individual CCD's, yielding
calibration uncertainties of 0.03 mag in B and 0.04 mag in V
(night-to-night rms scatter of the zero points). For variable
stars, the calibration were applied only to average magnitudes
and colors given the relatively large color terms of the WFI
camera (about 0.28 and - 0.075 in b and v, respectively). The
ALLFRAME program (Stetson 1994) was used to measure all
images and combine the individual photometric measurements
into a master catalog for each CCD. The combined photometry
reaches V ≃ 25.5 (about 3 mag fainter than the HB) with errors
σV = σB = 0.2 mag (standard error of the mean). The limiting
magnitude for the individual frames varies between V = 23.0
and 24.5 depending on the seeing and photometric conditions.
Measurement errors vary accordingly between σV = 0.12 -- 0.35
at V ∼ 23.5. The measurement errors for stars at the HB level,
estimated from the standard deviations of the measurements for
non-variable stars, are about σV (HB) = 0.13 and σB(HB) = 0.11
on the individual frames.
3. RR LYRAE VARIABLE STARS IN LEO I
The time-series photometric measurements in the CCD cat-
alogs were analyzed to detect variable objects and derive their
light curves. Here we report on the first successful results for
two CCD's (named #6 and #7 in the ESO WFI Manual) com-
prising the body of the galaxy (Leo I was centered on CCD #7).
All results for the remaining CCD's, together with photometric
measurements and light curves, will be presented in a separate
paper (G. Clementini et al. 2001, in preparation). Identifica-
tion of the variables was performed independently on the instru-
mental v and b data sets, running the program VARFIND (devel-
oped by Dr. P. Montegriffo) on the photometric catalogs (see
Clementini et al. 2001 for details). At this stage, the search was
optimized to find candidate variables near the HB. Stars whose
standard deviations of the v and b measurements are larger than
3σ, where σ is the rms of non-variable stars at the HB level,
were flagged as candidate variables. As a result, 96 candidates
were found, some of which are in the innermost area of Leo I.
RR Lyrae's allow us to probe the old population all the way to
the center of the galaxy.
Period search and definition of the light curve of the sus-
pected variables were done using differential photometry in the
instrumental magnitude system, with respect to some carefully
chosen, photometrically stable reference star (in general, red
giants with B - V ≥ 0.6). Period search was performed us-
ing GRATIS (GRaphical Analyzer of TIme Series), a software
developed at the Bologna Observatory (see Clementini et al.
2000, 2001).
FIG. 1. -- Differential v and b light curves of ab- and c-type RR Lyrae's in
Leo I from data in CCD #6 (left panel) and #7 (right panel). Different symbols
are used for data taken in different nights.
Figure 1 presents the first light curves of RR Lyrae stars in
Leo I. We have plotted the differential v and b light variations
for a selection of RR Lyrae stars that sample quite well the typ-
ical periods. Out of 96 candidate variables, the majority were
found to be ab-type RR Lyrae's (63 stars), with a few exam-
ples of c-type RR Lyrae's (11 objects). We also identified one
probable anomalous Cepheid and 6 candidate short period bi-
naries, while the remaining 15 objects could not be classified
unambiguously. Some low amplitude variables, in particular
c-type RR Lyrae's, may actually have escaped detection. A
deeper search is in progress using the Alard's (2000) Optimal
Image Subtraction method (G. Clementini et al. 2001, in prep.).
Periods, amplitudes, and epochs of maximum light were de-
rived for a subset of 54 RR Lyrae's (47 RRab's and 7 RRc's)
with complete light curves, using the GRATIS χ2 Fourier fit-
ting routine (one harmonic was used for the c-type RR Lyrae's
and two to five harmonics for the RRab's). The accuracy of
the derived periods depends on the sampling of the light curves
and is in general of the order 0.001 d. The amplitude uncer-
tainties, estimated from the rms of the fit residuals, are ∼0.10
mag. Intensity-average differential magnitudes were obtained
by integration over the entire pulsation cycle using the best fit-
ting model curves. By adding the instrumental magnitudes of
the reference stars, we obtained the mean b, v magnitudes of
the RR Lyrae's, from which the mean B, V magnitudes were
calculated via the calibration equations.
3 IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories, which are operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under
cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation.
3
FIG. 3. -- Period -- V amplitude relation for the RR Lyrae's in Leo I. Periods
are in days. Filled and open symbols are RRab and RRc variables, respectively.
The regression lines show the AV -
log P relations for the ab-type variables
in the globular clusters M 3 and M 15 (solid lines), M 2 (dotted line), ω Cen
(dashed line), and NGC 6441 (long dashed line). Dots represent the amplitude-
period distribution of RR Lyrae variables in Leo II (Siegel & Majewski 2000).
Figure 3 also shows a comparison with the AV -
logP dis-
tribution of the RR Lyrae variables in the dSph galaxy Leo II
(Siegel & Majewski 2000). The pulsational properties of the
RR Lyrae stars in the two dwarf spheroidals appear quite sim-
ilar. The characteristics of the ab-type RR Lyrae's qualify
Leo I as a system intermediate between the OoI and OoII clus-
ters, similar in this respect to other dwarf galaxies in the Local
Group (Siegel & Majewski 2000; Cseresnjes 2001; and refer-
ences therein) and to the LMC (Bono, Caputo, & Stellingw-
erf 1994). However, both the rather long minimum period of
RRab's and the presence of RRab's with long periods -- large
amplitudes, indicate a larger similarity with the OoII GCs.
The implications of such Oosterhoff intermediate properties
for the old stellar populations in Leo I (and in other dSph's as
well) rests on the usual interpretation of metallicity as the dom-
inant parameter in determining the Oosterhoff dichotomy. In-
deed, OoII clusters are generally very metal-poor while OoI
clusters are of intermediate metallicity (e.g., Smith 1995). If
this interpretation is correct, then the distribution of periods and
amplitudes of Leo I RR Lyrae's implies a metallicity distribu-
tion for the old population extending from values more metal-
poor than [Fe/H]=- 2.15 dex (the metallicity of the OoII cluster
M 15), to as metal-rich as [Fe/H]∼ - 1.6 (the metallicity of the
OoI cluster M 3).
Alternative interpretations may exist, though. There are clus-
ters like M 2, ω Cen, NGC 6441, and NGC 6388 whose po-
sitions in the period-amplitude diagram imply that their RR
Lyrae's are brighter than expected for their metallicity (see Fig-
ure 3). This observational evidence is interpreted as the Oost-
erhoff dichotomy being caused by evolution off the zero-age
horizontal branch (ZAHB), with the OoI variables being on the
ZAHB and the OoII variables being more evolved (Clement &
Shelton 1999, Clement & Rowe 2000, Lee & Carney 1999b).
FIG. 2. -- HR diagram of Leo I from a master ALLFRAME combination of all
data for CCD #6. This CMD is based on the mean calibrated B, V magnitudes
of stars detected in both passbands. The RR Lyrae variables (filled circles) and
a Cepheid (filled square) identified in this chip are plotted according to their
intensity-averaged magnitudes and colors. Lines show the blue and red edges
of the instability strip of the globular cluster M 3, from Corwin & Carney's
(2001) photometry, reddened to the value appropriate for Leo I. The red edge
has been corrected to account for the difference in metallicity with respect to
Leo I (Walker 1998).
The location of the detected variables in the HR diagram of
the outer region of Leo I is shown in Figure 2. The vast majority
of the data points for the RR Lyrae's are found on the HB in cor-
respondence to the instability strip, and their mean magnitude
defines the mean V apparent luminosity of the HB of Leo I.
4. PULSATIONAL PROPERTIES: CLUES TO THE OLD
STELLAR POPULATION IN LEO I
Figure 3 shows the relation between the period and the V
amplitude for the RR Lyrae's in the present sample. Open
symbols represent the c-type pulsators (RRc), filled symbols
are RRab stars. The average period of the Leo I RRab vari-
ables is hPabi=0.d602 (σ=0.d059), and the minimum period is
0.d539. The solid lines in Figure 3 represent the AV -
logP
relations defined by the ab-type variables with clean light
curves in the globular clusters M 3 and M 15 ([Fe/H]=- 1.66
and [Fe/H]=- 2.15, respectively, on the Zinn & West's 1984
scale). These clusters can be considered the prototypes of Oost-
erhoff type I (OoI) and II (OoII) globular clusters (GCs) in the
Milky Way (Sandage, Katem, & Sandage 1981; Sandage 1993).
Also shown are the AV -
logP relations followed by the ab vari-
ables in M2, ω Cen, and NGC 6441 ([Fe/H]=- 1.62, - 1.60, and
- 0.5 dex). The data are from Clement & Shelton (1999) for
M3, Bingham et al. (1984) and Silbermann & Smith (1995)
for M15, Lee & Carney (1999a) for M 2, Clement & Shelton
(1999) for ω Cen, and Pritzl et al. (2000) for NGC 6441.
4
Then, a difference in age would exist between the two Oost-
erhoff groups. Whether this can be a general interpretation of
the Oosterhoff phenomenon or these are just peculiar clusters
is still a matter of debate.
In this regard, it is interesting to
note the presence in Leo I of a variable with very long period
(star 201064 in Figure 3, P = 0.d889). Although its large ampli-
tude may be in doubt since the variable falls near the center of
Leo I where crowding is severe, and is possibly affected from
straylight from Regulus, variables with long periods have been
found in NGC 6441 and NGC 6388 (Pritzl et al. 2000).
A good indication on the mean metallicity of RR Lyrae's
in Leo I can be derived using the relation derived by Sandage
(1993) between the average period of the RRab variables
in the Milky Way GCs and their metallicity,
loghPabi =
- 0.092[Fe/H]- 0.389. By applying this relation to the mean pe-
riod of RRab variables in Leo I, we obtain [Fe/H]hPabi = - 1.82
for the average metallicity of the old population. Previous val-
ues of the metallicity of Leo I are quite uncertain, ranging from
[Fe/H]=- 2 to - 1 (see Lee et al. 1993 and references therein).
A recent comparison of the (V -
I) color of the red giant branch
(RGB) of Leo I with the fiducial sequences of Galactic GCs
yields a mean metallicity [Fe/H]≃ - 1.8 (Y. Momany et al.
2001, in preparation). Since the bulk of the red giant stars in
Leo I have intermediate age (between 2 and 7 Gyr: Caputo et
al. 1998; Gallart et al. 1999b), this value should be corrected
(made more metal-rich) by ∼ 0.2 dex (cf. Held, Saviane, & Mo-
many 1999). The fact that the RR Lyrae's are only slightly more
metal-poor than RGB stars seems to imply that metal enrich-
ment (from the primordial gas composition to [Fe/H]∼ - 1.8)
occurred early in the life of the galaxy, and modest enrichment
took place in between the early burst that gave rise to the oldest
population, and the main star formation episode occurred 4 ± 3
Gyr ago.
5. THE DISTANCE TO LEO I
The mean magnitude of the RR Lyrae's in Leo I provides an
independent method to estimate the distance to this galaxy with
some degree of confidence. The average apparent luminosity of
the RR Lyrae's with full coverage of the B and V light curves is
hV (RR)i = 22.60 ± 0.12 mag (standard deviation of the mean,
48 stars). This dispersion is fully accounted for by the com-
bined effects of photometric errors, metallicity distribution in
the RR Lyrae's sample, and evolution off the ZAHB. Given the
large distance of Leo I, the spread caused by the intrinsic depth
of the galaxy is insignificant.
The absolute magnitude of the RR Lyrae's is MV (RR) ≃
0.50 at [Fe/H]= - 1.5 in the "long" distance scale, consis-
tent with (m - M)RR
0 = 18.53 for the LMC (see Walker 1999,
and references therein), and 0.75 mag in the "short" scale.
To correct
the absolute magnitude of the RR Lyrae's to
the metallicity of the Leo I variables, we adopted the RR
Lyrae luminosity -- metallicity dependence given by the rela-
tion ∆MV (RR)/∆[Fe/H] = 0.2 mag/dex, which is supported
by both the Baade-Wesselink analysis of Fernley et al. (1998)
and recent results on the M 31 globular clusters (Corsi et al.
2000). For the metallicity of Leo I we assumed the value de-
rived in this paper from the mean period of ab-type RR Lyrae's,
[Fe/H]=- 1.82. A reddening E(B - V ) = 0.04 ± 0.02 mag was
adopted following Schlegel, Finkbeiner, & Davis (1998). These
assumptions yield a distance modulus (m- M)RR
0 = 22.04 ± 0.14
mag (d=256 kpc) in the long scale (and 21.79 mag or 228 kpc
in the short scale). The quoted error includes the errors on the
mean RR Lyrae magnitude, the calibration zero point error, and
the adopted reddening uncertainty. This result is in good agree-
ment with our recent distance determination from the RGB tip
method on a different data set (Y. Momany et al. 2001, in
prep.), yielding (m- M)tip
0 = 21.93 ± 0.16. The RGB tip method
is based on the RR Lyrae luminosity-metallicity relation of
Lee, Demarque, & Zinn (1990), yielding MV (RR) = 0.565 at
[Fe/H]= - 1.5. Our new result is intermediate between previous
values in the literature (see Lee et al. 1993).
We thank P. Stetson for providing us his set of photometric
programs, including ALLFRAME. We are grateful to M. Cate-
lan for helpful discussions regarding the nature of the Oost-
erhoff dichotomy, to C. Cacciari for useful comments on the
manuscript, and to an anonymous referee for helpful remarks.
This study was partially supported by the National projects
"Processing of large-format astronomical data" (COFIN-98)
and "Stellar Observables of Cosmological relevance" (COFIN-
00).
REFERENCES
Alard, C. 2000, A&AS, 144, 363
Bertelli, G., Bressan, A., Chiosi, C., Fagotto, F., & Nasi, E. 1994, A&AS, 106,
Bingham, E. A., Cacciari, C., Dickens, R. J., & Fusi Pecci, F. 1984, MNRAS,
Bono, G., Caputo, F., & Stellingwerf, R. F. 1994, ApJ, 423, 294
Caputo, F., Cassisi, S., Castellani, M., Marconi, G., & Santolamazza, P. 1998,
Clement, C. M., & Shelton, I. 1999, ApJL, 515, 85
Clement, C. M., & Rowe, J. 2000, AJ, 120, 2579
Clementini, G. et al. 2000, AJ, 120, 2054
Clementini, G., Gratton, R. G., Bragaglia, A., Carretta, E., Di Fabrizio, L., &
Maio, M. 2001, AJ, submitted (astro-ph/0007471)
Corsi, C. E., Rich, M., Cacciari, C., Federici, L., & Fusi Pecci, F. 2000, in A
Decade of HST Science, ed. M. Livio, STScI Publications, in press
Corwin, T.M., Carney, B.W. 2001, AJ, in press
Cseresnjes P. 2001, A&A, 375, 909
Da Costa, G.S. 1998, In Stellar Astrophysics for the Local Group, ed. A.
Aparicio, A. Herrero, & F. Sanchez (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press),
351
Fernley, J., Carney, B. W., Skillen, I., Cacciari, C., & Janes, K. 1998, MNRAS,
275
209, 765
AJ, 117, 2199
Gallart, C., et al. 1999a, ApJ, 514, 665
Gallart, C., Freedman, W. L., Aparicio, A., Bertelli, G., & Chiosi, C. 1999b,
293, L61
AJ, 118, 2245
Held, E. V., Saviane, I., & Momany, Y. 1999, A&A, 345, 747
Held, E. V., Saviane, I., Momany, Y., & Carraro, G. 2000, ApJL, 530, L85
Hodge, P. W., & Wright, F. W. 1978, AJ, 83, 228
Keane, M., Olszewski, E., Suntzeff, N., & Saha, A. 1993, AAS, 182, #32.03
Landolt, A. U. 1992, AJ, 104, 340
Lee, J.-W., & Carney, B. W. 1999a, AJ, 117, 2868
Lee, J.-W., & Carney, B. W. 1999b, AJ, 118, 1373
Lee, Y. W., Demarque, P., & Zinn, R. 1990, ApJ, 350, 155
Lee, M. G., Freedman, W., Mateo, M., Thompson, I., Roth, M., & Ruiz, M.-T.
1993, AJ, 106, 1420
Mateo, M. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 435
Pritzl, B., Smith, H. A., Catelan, M., & Sweigart, A. 2000, ApJL, 530, 41
Sandage, A. 1993, AJ, 106, 687
Sandage, A., Katem, B., & Sandage, M. 1981, ApJS, 46, 41
Schlegel, D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525
Siegel, M. H., & Majewski, S. R. 2000, AJ, 120, 284
Silbermann, N. A., & Smith, H. A. 1995, AJ, 110, 704
Smith, H. A. 1995, RR Lyrae stars, Cambridge Astrophysics Series,
(Cambridge Univ. Press: Cambridge)
Stetson, P. B. 1994, PASP, 106, 250
Valdes, F. G. 1998, in ASP Conf. Ser. 145: Astronomical Data Analysis
Software and Systems VII, 7, ed. R. Albrecht, R. N. Hook, and H. A.
Bushouse, (ASP, San Francisco), 53
Walker, A.R. 1998, AJ, 116, 220
Walker, A.R. 1999, In Post-Hipparcos Cosmic Candles, ed. A. Heck, & F.
Caputo, (Dordrecht: Kluwer), p. 125
Zinn, R., & West, M. J. 1984, ApJS, 55, 45
5
|
astro-ph/0703757 | 1 | 0703 | 2007-03-29T13:23:00 | Gamma-Rays from Dark Matter Mini-Spikes in M31 | [
"astro-ph"
] | The existence of a population of wandering Intermediate Mass Black Holes (IMBHs) is a generic prediction of scenarios that seek to explain the formation of Supermassive Black Holes in terms of growth from massive seeds. The growth of IMBHs may lead to the formation of DM overdensities called "mini-spikes", recently proposed as ideal targets for indirect DM searches. Current ground-based gamma-ray experiments, however, cannot search for these objects due to their limited field of view, and it might be challenging to discriminate mini-spikes in the Milky Way from the many astrophysical sources that GLAST is expected to observe. We show here that gamma-ray experiments can effectively search for IMBHs in the nearby Andromeda galaxy (also known as M31), where mini-spikes would appear as a distribution of point-sources, isotropically distributed in a \thickapprox 3^{\circ} circle around the galactic center. For a neutralino-like DM candidate with a mass m_{\chi}=150 GeV, up to 20 sources would be detected with GLAST (at 5\sigma, in 2 months). With Air Cherenkov Telescopes such as MAGIC and VERITAS, up to 10 sources might be detected, provided that the mass of neutralino is in the TeV range or above. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Gamma-Rays from Dark Matter Mini-Spikes in M31
Mattia Fornasa1, Marco Taoso1, and Gianfranco Bertone1,2
1 INFN, Sezione di Padova, via Marzolo 8, Padova, 35131, Italy and
2 Institut d Astrophysique de Paris, UMR 7095-CNRS,
Universit´e Pierre et Marie Curie, 98bis boulevard Arago, 75014 Paris, France ∗
The existence of a population of wandering Intermediate Mass Black Holes (IMBHs) is a generic
prediction of scenarios that seek to explain the formation of Supermassive Black Holes in terms of
growth from massive seeds. The growth of IMBHs may lead to the formation of DM overdensities
called "mini-spikes", recently proposed as ideal targets for indirect DM searches. Current ground-
based gamma-ray experiments, however, cannot search for these objects due to their limited field of
view, and it might be challenging to discriminate mini-spikes in the Milky Way from the many as-
trophysical sources that GLAST is expected to observe. We show here that gamma-ray experiments
can effectively search for IMBHs in the nearby Andromeda galaxy (also known as M31), where
mini-spikes would appear as a distribution of point-sources, isotropically distributed in a ≈ 3◦ circle
around the galactic center. For a neutralino-like DM candidate with a mass mχ = 150 GeV, up to
20 sources would be detected with GLAST (at 5σ, in 2 months). With Air Cherenkov Telescopes
such as MAGIC and VERITAS, up to 10 sources might be detected, provided that the mass of
neutralino is in the TeV range or above.
I.
INTRODUCTION
The nature of Dark Matter (DM) is, more than 70
years after its discovery, still an open problem. It is com-
monly assumed that DM is made of Weakly Interact-
ing Massive Particles (WIMPs), arising in theories be-
yond the Standard Model (see Refs. [1, 2] for recent re-
views), the most widely discussed DM candidates being
the supersymmetric neutralino and the lightest Kaluza-
Klein particle (LKP) in theories with Unified Extra-
Dimensions [3, 4, 5]. These particles will be actively
searched for in upcoming high energy physics experi-
ments such as the Large Hadron Collider (LHC, see e.g.
Refs.[5, 6, 7, 8] for recent discussions in the context of DM
searches), while hints on the nature of DM may already
come from direct detection experiments aiming at detect-
ing the nuclear recoils due to DM scattering off nuclei in
large detectors (see e.g. [9] for a recent update on the sta-
tus of direct searches). Alternatively, one could search for
DM indirectly, i.e. through the detection of its annihila-
tion products such as photons, neutrinos, positrons and
antiprotons. The annihilation rate being proportional
to the square of the DM density, ideal targets of indirect
searches include all those regions where the DM density is
strongly enhanced, due to gravitational clustering, as in
the case of the Galactic center [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]
and halo substructures [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25],
or because of energy losses capture in large celestial bod-
ies, as in the case of the Sun and the Earth (see Ref. [2]
and references therein).
Large DM overdensities can also form as a consequence
of astrophysical processes, such as the adiabatic growth
of Supermassive [26, 27, 28] or Intermediate Mass Black
Holes [29, 30]. In fact, DM halos inevitably react to the
growth of black holes, leading, in the case of adiabatic
growth, to the formation of large DM overdensities called
spikes [26]. A DM cusp with a power-law density profile
ρ ∝ r−γ, gets redistributed after the BH growth into a
steeper profile ρsp ∝ r−γsp , with γsp = (9 − 2γ)/(4 − γ),
within the radius of gravitational influence of the Black
Hole (BH) (see below for further details). BHs can thus
be thought as annihilation boosters, because the annihila-
tion rate after their growth is boosted by several orders of
magnitude, making these objects ideal targets for indirect
DM searches. Even in absence of mergers [31], and ignor-
ing a possible off-center formation [32], a spike around the
Supermassive BH at the Galactic center would inevitably
be destroyed by the combined effect of gravitational scat-
tering off the observed stellar cusp at the GC, and DM
annihilations [14]. The very same gravitational processes
can still lead to the formation of moderate enhancements
called crests (Collisionally REgenerated STructures), but
these structures do not lead to significant enhancements
of the annihilation signal
[33]. Mini-spikes around In-
termediate Mass Black Holes (IMBHs) are more promis-
ing targets of indirect detection, since they would not be
affected by these dynamical processes, and they should
appear as bright point-like sources, which could be easily
detected by large field of view gamma-ray experiments as
GLAST [34] and further studied with ground-based Air
Cherenkov telescopes (ACTs) [30] such as CANGAROO
[35], HESS [36], MAGIC [37] and VERITAS [38].
Here, we further explore the mini-spikes scenario, and
focus on the population of IMBHs in the Andromeda
Galaxy (also known as M31), a spiral galaxy very sim-
ilar to the Milky Way (MW), whose center is located
784 kpc away from us. We compute gamma-ray fluxes
from DM annihilations around IMBHs in M31, and show
that the prospects for detection with GLAST are very
promising:
in an optimistic case (a neutralino with a
mass mχ = 150 GeV and annihilation cross section σv =
3 × 10−26 cm3s−1), GLAST may detect up to 20 point-
∗Electronic address: [email protected],[email protected],[email protected]
like sources (at 5σ and with a 2 months exposure), within
3◦ from the center of Andromeda. The proposed observa-
tional strategy appears particularly suited for ACTs like
MAGIC and VERITAS, (M31 is in a region of the sky
not accessible to HESS), since the main difficulty in the
search for Galactic mini-spikes is that they cannot per-
form deep full-sky searches, due to their limited field of
view. In the case of mini-spikes in M31, ACTs can search
for them by scanning a small region of ≈ 3◦ around the
center of M31, and an effective exposure of ≈ 100 hours
in this region would be sufficient to probe the proposed
scenario, at least for DM mass in the TeV range. The
next-generation Cherenkov Telescopes Array (CTA)[39],
is expected to significantly improve the sensitivity, in-
crease the field of view and decrease the energy threshold
with respect to existing ACTs, thus representing an ideal
experiment for the proposed scenario.
The paper is organized as follows: next section (Sec-
tion II) is devoted to describe the formation scenario of
IMBHs. We then (Section III) present the IMBHs cata-
logue and how it is adapted to the Andromeda Galaxy.
We compute the gamma-ray flux emitted by each point-
like spike around an IMBH, considering a particular en-
ergy annihilation spectrum for a DM particle. In section
IV A we estimate the prospects for detection for a generic
ACT. Then in section IV B we turn to GLAST. Finally
our results are discussed in Section V.
II.
INTERMEDIATE MASS BLACK HOLES
A.
IMBHs formation scenario
IMBHs are compact objects with mass larger than ≈
20M⊙, the heaviest remnant of a stellar collapse [40], and
smaller than ≈ 106M⊙, the lower end of the mass range of
SuperMassive Black Holes (SMBH) [41]. The theoretical
and observational motivations for IMBHs were recently
reviewed in Ref. [42]. For instance, Ultra-Luminous X-
ray point sources (ULXs) could be interpreted as accret-
ing IMBHs, since alternative explanations in terms of
AGNs, neutron stars or SMBHs appear to be problem-
atic or even ruled out [42, 43].
From a theoretical point of view, a population of mas-
sive seed black holes could help to explain the origin
of SMBHs.
In fact, observations of quasars at redshift
z ≈ 6 in the Sloan Digital survey [44, 45, 46] suggest
that SMBHs were already in place when the Universe
was only ∼ 1 Gyr old, a circumstance that can be un-
derstood in terms of rapid growth starting from massive
seeds (see e.g. Ref. [47]).
In fact, a generic prediction of scenarios that seek to ex-
plain the properties of the observed SuperMassive Black
Hole population, is that a large number of "wandering"
IMBHs should exist in DM halos [48, 49, 50]. Despite
their theoretical interest,
it is difficult to obtain con-
clusive evidence for the existence of IMBHs. A viable
detection strategy could be the search for gravitational
2
waves produced in the mergers of the IMBH popula-
tion [51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56], with space-based interfer-
ometers such as LISA [57].
In Ref. [30], two scenarios for IMBHs formation have
been considered. The first posits IMBHs as remnants
of the collapse of Population III stars. Zero-metallicity
Population III stars are more massive than more recent
metal-enriched stars and, if heavier than 260M⊙, they
would collapse directly into black holes ([42] and Refs.
therein).
Here, we will focus only on the second scenario, based
on Ref. [49], where IMBHs form at high redshift from
gas collapsing in mini-halos.
If the latter are massive
enough, proto-galactic disks form at the center of each
halo. Gravitational instabilities introduce an effective
viscosity that causes an inward mass and an outward
angular momentum flow. The process goes on till it is
interrupted by feedback from star formation (1-10 Myrs)
that heats the disk. Then the so-formed object undergoes
gravitational collapse into a black hole. A characteristic
mass scale of 107M⊙ is imprinted to the mini-halo by the
requirements that it is heavy enough to form a gravita-
tional unstable disc and that the black hole formation
timescale is shorter than the typical major mergers one.
The resulting black holes have a mass log-normally scat-
tered, with a σ• = 0.9, around the mean value of [49]:
M• = 3.8 × 104M⊙(cid:16) κ
18 (cid:19)3/2(cid:18)
×(cid:18) 1 + z
0.5(cid:17)(cid:18) f
10 Myr(cid:19) ,
0.03(cid:19)3/2(cid:18) Mvir
107M⊙(cid:19) (1)
t
where κ is that fraction of the baryonic mass which
loses its angular moment that remains in the remnant
black hole. f is the fraction of the total baryonic mass
in the halo that has fallen into the disc, Mvir is the
halo virial mass, z is the redshift of formation and t the
timescale for the evolution of the first generation of stars.
In Ref. [30] Bertone et al. have studied the population
of IMBHs in the MW, following the evolution of mini-
halos hosting IMBHs at high redshift (populated with
the prescriptions of Ref. [49]), down to redshift z = 0 (see
Ref. [30] for further details). As a result, they obtained
200 realizations of the IMBHs population in the Galaxy,
that were used to produce 200 mock catalogs of DM mini-
spikes, and to study the prospects for detection of these
objects in the Galaxy. The average number of unmerged
IMBHs was found to be N = 101± 22, and each of these
objects is characterized by its mass, distance from the
center of the galaxy, and surrounding DM distribution.
B. DM distribution around IMBHs
Following earlier work on the dynamics of stars and
DM around compact objects (see Ref. [58] and references
therein), Gondolo and Silk have shown that the adiabatic
growth of a massive black hole in the center of a dark halo
modifies the distribution of the surrounding DM, induc-
ing an enhancement of the density called "spike" [26].
They focused their attention on the SMBH at the center
of our Galaxy, but the same formalism can be applied
also to IMBHs. The initial DM distribution in all mini-
halos can be adequately parametrized with a Navarro,
Frenk and White (NFW) profile [59]:
ρ(r) = ρ0(cid:16) rs
r (cid:17)(cid:18)1 +
r
rs(cid:19)−2
,
(2)
where rs, called the scale radius, sets the radius at which
the profile slope changes. The new profile after the adi-
abatic growth, will be [26]:
gdN
dx
310
210
10
1
-110
-210
3
FPS
Eq.10
BBEG
ρsp(r) = ρ(rsp)(cid:18) r
rsp(cid:19)−7/3
,
(3)
-310
-210
-110
x
1
where ρ is the density function of the initial NFW profile.
rsp gives the upper limit inside which Eq. 3 is considered
valid and is related to the radius of gravitational influ-
ence of the black hole rh: rsp ≈ 0.2rh [60], where rh is
implicitly defined as:
M (r < rh) ≡ Z rh
0
ρ(r)r2dr = 2M•
with M• is the mass of the black hole.
The spike profile diverges at low radii but annihila-
tions set an upper limit to the physical density. Solving
the evolution of the DM particles number density, one
finds that the upper limit depends on the microphysical
properties of the DM particles (mass and annihilation
cross section) and on the evolution timescale of the black
hole. We denote the distance where the density equals
this upper limit rlim, and following Ref. [30] we define a
cut-radius for our density profiles:
rcut = Max[4RSchw, rlim],
(4)
where RSchw = 2.95 km M/M⊙ is the BH Schwarzschild
radius. The density between RSchw and rcut is assumed
to be constant to ρsp(rcut).
Figure 1: Differential photon spectrum per annihilation. Dif-
ferent parametrizations and annihilation channels are shown.
Solid line (FPS) is an analytic fit relative to the b¯b channel, as
obtained in Eq. 7. Dashed line (Eq. 10) is relative to the same
annihilation channel b¯b, but with a different parametrization
of the FFs (see Eqs. 9 and 10). Dotted line (BBEG) is rel-
ative to B 1 annihilations and includes final state radiation
from annihilation to charged leptons [65] (see text for more
details)
between the host halo masses, since the number of un-
merged IMBHs scales linearly with the host halo mass,
and the galactocentric distance by the ratio of virial radii.
We obtain for M31 an average number of IMBHs per re-
alization NM31 = 65.2 ± 14.5. The mass spectrum re-
mains unchanged, with an average mass around 105 M⊙,
while the average distance from the center of the galaxy
is 32.31 kpc. We have verified that our rescaling proce-
dure reproduces in a satisfactory way the properties of
the IMBHs population in Andromeda, by comparing our
results with a limited number of mock catalogs obtained
as an exploratory study in Ref. [30].
III. GAMMA-RAYS FROM IMBHS IN M31
A.
IMBHs in M31
Although similar, the Milky Way and Andromeda do
not have exactly the same properties. The mock catalogs
of IMBHs built for our Galaxy, thus have to be modified
to account for the different average number and different
spatial distribution in the host halo. A comparison be-
tween the properties of Andromeda and of the Galaxy is
shown in Table I.
We start from the mock catalogs obtained in Ref. [30]
and we rescale the total number of objects by the ratio
Distance to the center [kpc]
Virial Radius [kpc]
Virial Mass [M⊙]
rs [kpc]
ρ0 [ M⊙
kpc3 ]
Milky Way Andromeda
8.5
205
784.0
180
1.0 × 1012
6.8 × 1011
21.75
8.18
5.376 × 106 3.780 × 107
Table I: Distance from the Sun (in kpc), virial radius (defined
as the radius within which the density reaches 200 times the
critical density, in kpc), virial mass (in solar masses) and the
two NFW density profile parameters (in kpc and M⊙kpc−3
respectively), both for the MW and the Andromeda Galaxy
[61, 62].
](cid:176) [
[cm
]-1s-2
-12
10
1.5
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
4
300 GeV
500 GeV
1000 GeV
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
-15
-14.5
-14
-13.5
-13
-12.5
-12
-11.5
log
-11
F(
10
)
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
1.5
](cid:176) [
-1.5
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
Figure 2: Left: Map of gamma-rays emission (above 100 GeV, in cm−2s−1) by DM annihilation (mχ = 1 TeV) around IMBHs
in Andromeda, averaged over all realizations. Bins are 0.1◦ wide, to match the angular resolution of ACTs and GLAST.
The circle shows for comparison the M31 scale radius rs. Right: Luminosity function of IMBHs (fluxes are in cm−2s−1), for
mχ = 0.3, 0.5 and 1 TeV. The vertical line shows the contribution of the smooth component of the M31 halo, assuming a NFW
profile and mχ = 1 TeV.
B. Gamma-rays flux from IMBHs in M31
Once the mock catalogs of IMBHs in M31 have been
obtained, it is possible to calculate the gamma-ray flux
from each IMBH in every realization. The calculation
follows Eq. 14 in Ref. [30]:
Φ(E) =
1
d2
σv
2m2
χ
dNγ(E)
= Φ0
rcut
σv
dNγ(E)
ρ2(r)r2dr
dE Z rsp
10−26cm3/s(cid:19)(cid:16) mχ
100 GeV/cm3(cid:19)2
10−3 pc(cid:19)−5/3
dE (cid:18)
780 kpc(cid:19)−2(cid:18)
5 pc(cid:19)14/3(cid:18) rcut
ρ(rsp)
d
,
×(cid:18)
×(cid:18) rsp
(5)
1 TeV(cid:17)−2
where Φ0 = 2.7×10−14 cm−2s−1, d is the IMBH distance
to the observer, σv is the DM annihilation cross section
times relative velocity and mχ is the DM particle mass
(the letter χ, usually adopted for neutralino, is used here
to denote a generic WIMP candidate). rcut and rsp, rep-
resent the inner and outer size of the spike, as discussed
in the previous section.
dNγ(E)/dE is the differential photon yield per annihi-
lation, that can be expressed as:
dNγ(E)
dE
= Xa
Ba dN a
γ (E)
dE
,
(6)
where Ba is the branching ratio BR(χχ → a¯a) and
dN a
γ /dE the secondary photon spectrum relative to the
annihilation channel a¯a. The latter term is thus a purely
Standard Model calculation, while branching ratios have
to be derived in the framework of new theories beyond
the Standard Model, such as SUSY or UED.
We review here different parametrizations of the pho-
ton yield that have been recently proposed in literature.
The first parametrization we focus on, has been obtained
in Ref. [61], and it is relative to annihilations into b¯b. The
authors have parametrized the results obtained with the
event generator PYTHIA [63] as follows
dN b
γ(x)
dx
= xaeb+cx+dx2+ex3
,
(7)
where the parameters depend on the neutralino mass,
and for the specific case mχ = 1 TeV, (a, b, c, d, e) =
(−1.5, 0.37, −16.05, 18.01, −19.50). While for annihila-
tion to τ s
dN τ
γ (x)
dx
= xa(bx + cx2 + dx3)eex,
(8)
=
=
for mχ
(a, b, c, d, e)
and
1 TeV,
(−1.31, 6.94, −4.93, −0.51, −4.53).
Alternatively, one can start from the most recent Frag-
mentations Functions (FFs) (e.g.
[64]), describing the
hadronization of partons into the particles of interest.
The FF of b quarks hadronizing in neutral pions has been
fitted with a simple analytic form that captures in a sat-
isfactory way the behavior of the FF at large x finding
·
j
q
F
the following analytic fit
f (x) =
7.53
x0.87e14.62x .
(9)
Convolving the spectrum pions with their decay spec-
trum into photons one finally obtains the differential pho-
ton yield
dNγ(x)
dx
= Z 1
x
f (x′)
2
x′ dx′.
(10)
We have also considered an example inspired from the-
ories with Unified Extra-Dimensions, where the role of
DM is usually played by the first excitation of the hy-
percharge gauge boson, and referred to as B(1). Since
the B(1) annihilation into fermions does not suffer from
chirality suppression, as in MSSM, we also include the
contribution from annihilation to l¯lγ, as calculated in
Ref. [65], as well as the contribution from τ fragmenta-
tion, and usual from annihilations to b¯b, with the appro-
priate branching ratio. The final state radiation arising
from annihilation to charged leptons has a characteristic,
very hard, spectral shape [65, 66]
dN l
γ(x)
dx
= Xl=e,µ
α
π
x2 − 2x + 2
x
ln(cid:20) m2
B(1)
m2
l
(1 − x)(cid:21) . (11)
The three prescriptions for the annihilation spectrum
are plotted in Fig. 1 (for mχ = 1 TeV). As expected, all
spectra are very similar up to x ≡ E/mχ ∼ 0.1, but the
spectrum relative to B(1) annihilations is harder at large
x, and exhibits a distinctive sharp cut-off at x = 1.
To show the small effect that the adoption of differ-
ent annihilation spectra has on the prospects for indirect
detection, we have calculated the DM annihilation flux
from the smooth component of the M31 halo, assuming
a NFW profile with the parameters described in Tab.
I
above. The results are displayed in Table II, and as one
can see, differences are within a factor of 2. In the re-
main of this paper, we will thus work only with the first
analytic fit, since the uncertainties associated with other
astrophysical and particle physics parameters are signif-
icantly larger.
By calculating the gamma-ray flux in Eq. 5 for IMBHs
in all realizations, we obtain a gamma-ray map, above
Ethr = 100 GeV, from mini-spikes in Andromeda. Each
M31 realization actually produces a different emission
M31 flux [cm−2s−1]
FPS [61]
Eq. 10
BBEG [65]
1.33 × 10−14
9.79 × 10−15
1.60 × 10−14
Table II: Gamma-ray flux over 100 GeV from Andromeda
(in cm−2s−1) for a smooth NFW, and for the different
parametrizations discussed in the text. Differences among
the predicted fluxes are within a factor of 2.
5
signal
Galactic/ExtraGal. back.
Hadronic/Electronic back.
q(<F
) [cm
]-1s-2
-810
-910
-10
10
-11
10
-12
10
-13
10
10
-14
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
](cid:176) [
Figure 3: Gamma-ray flux (in cm−2s−1) from DM annihila-
tion around IMBHs (solid thick line), integrated over a cone of
size θ towards the center of M31, as a function of θ. We show
for comparison the hadronic/electron background, assuming
ǫh = 10−2 (solid thinner line) and the diffuse extragalactic
background (dashed line).
map, so in Fig. 2 we show the average of all 200 maps,
which clearly exhibits, as expected, a strong enhance-
ment of the flux in the innermost regions of the Galaxy.
The pixel size matches the angular resolution of ground-
based telescopes such as VERITAS and MAGIC, and of
GLAST. For the map, a DM particle mass of 1 TeV and
an annihilation cross section σv = 3× 10−26cm3s−1 have
been adopted. Note that this map alone does not provide
any information on the detectability of the fluxes, which
will be discussed in detail in the next 2 sections. Note
also that the actual distribution of IMBHs, will provide
(as we shall see later) a much more 'patchy' emission, far
from the average smooth behaviour shown in Fig. 2.
We also show in the right panel of Fig. 2 the lumi-
nosity function of IMBHs (sum of all realizations), for
different values of the DM particle mass. The distribu-
tion is approximately gaussian, and the average flux of
IMBHs is larger than emission due the smooth compo-
nent. The dependence from the mass results in due to
a balance between the m−9/7
dependence in Eq. 5, and
the mχ dependence of the upper limit in the integral of
the energy spectrum. Having set in the figure an energy
threshold Ethr = 100 GeV, the luminosity flux towards
higher fluxes when the mass increase. We will come back
later to this threshold effect, that leads to higher fluxes
for higher masses when mχ ∼ Ethr despite the explicit
m−9/7
dependence of the annihilation flux. Meanwhile
we note that this effect disappears when mχ ≫ Ethr, as
can be seen from Table III.
χ
χ
q
](cid:176) [
[cm
]-1s-2
10·
-12
](cid:176) [
2
1
0
-1
-2
ACT
-2
-1
0
1
2
2
1
0
-1
-2
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
](cid:176) [
6
[cm
]-1s-2
-910
GLAST
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
-2
-1
0
1
2
0
](cid:176) [
Figure 4: Left (right) panel shows a map of the gamma-ray flux in units of photons cm−2s−1, from DM annihilations around
IMBHs in M31, relative to one random realization of IMBHs in M31. The size of the bins is 0.1◦ and the threshold for the left
(right) panel is 100 GeV (4 GeV) as appropriate for ACTs (GLAST). The circles highlight IMBHs within the reach of current
ACTs for a 5σ detection in 100 hours (within the reach of GLAST for a 5σ detection in 2 months).
IV. PROSPECTS FOR DETECTION
we compare the number of signal photons, to the fluctu-
ations of the background
As we shall see the prospects for detection de-
pend on the expected or measured experimental per-
formances, but also on the atmospheric and astrophys-
ical backgrounds. We perform separate analysis for
Air Cherenkov Telescopes and the upcoming gamma-ray
satellite GLAST.
A. Prospects for ACTs
The calculations in this section are performed for
a generic ACT, but they are particularly relevant for
two specific experiments: MAGIC and VERITAS. As
for HESS, being located in Namibia, it cannot detect
gamma-rays from the direction of Andromeda.
To determine the significance of the signal from an in-
dividual mini-spike, as calculated in the previous section,
Average flux [cm−2s−1]
mχ = 50 GeV
mχ = 150 GeV
mχ = 300 GeV
mχ = 500 GeV
5.26 × 10−11
7.65 × 10−11
6.92 × 10−11
5.81 × 10−11
n =
nγ
√nbk
= √T · ∆Ω R Aef f (E, θ) dΦ
qR Aef f (E, θ) dΦbk
dE dEdθ
dE dEdθ
,
(12)
where T is the exposure time, Aef f the effective area,
∆Ω the solid angle, dΦbk/dE is the total background
differential flux.
For Air Cherenkov Telescopes, the main background
is due to hadrons interacting with the atmosphere and
producing electromagnetic showers. Following Ref. [67]
[24], we consider
dΦh
dΩdE
= 1.5 ×(cid:18) E
GeV(cid:19)−2.74
p
cm2s GeV sr
.
(13)
The ratio of the number of hadrons misinterpreted
as gamma-rays, over the total number of cosmic ray
hadrons, ǫh, provides an estimate of the telescope po-
tential to discriminate the gamma-ray signal from the
hadronic background. We adopt a typical value ǫh =
10−2, following Refs. [24] [68]. The electronic contribu-
tion to the background is [24]:
dΦe
dΩdE
= 6.9 × 10−2(cid:18) E
GeV(cid:19)−3.3
e
cm2s GeV sr
(14)
Table III: Average flux from IMBHs in all 200 realizations
(in cm−2s−1), for different values of DM mass, σv = 3 ×
10−26cm3s−1 and Ethr = 4 GeV.
and it is typically subdominant at the energies of interest.
In Figure 3 we compare the DM annihilation signal
with the different sources of background, as a function of
j
q
F
·
j
q
F
7
average realization
ACTs
GLAST
GLAST
ACTs
GLAST
ACTs
10
1
-110
)sN(>5
24
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
cm
1400
[GeV]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
](cid:176)
[
j
Figure 5: Number of detectable mini-spikes in M31 with GLAST (2 months) and ACTs (100 hours) as a function of the DM
particle mass (left) and as a function of the angular distance from the center of M31 (right). In the left panel, error bars denote
the 1 − σ scatter among different realizations. In the right panel, the total number of objects is shown as an empty histogram,
while the vertical lines denote the size of the region that contains 90% of the detectable IMBHs.
the field of view. The minimum flux for a 5σ detection
with an effective area of Aef f = 3×104 m2 [37] and an ex-
posure time of 100 hours, is φmin = 1.6× 10−12cm−2s−1.
To produce this estimate we have considered values of
effective area and angular resolution similar to MAGIC
and the result is consistent with earlier estimates of
the MAGIC sensitivity [2]. An actual estimate of
the instrument performance suggests that the mini-
mum flux can be up to an order of magnitude higher [69].
The fluxes in Fig. 2 are thus found to lie below the min-
imum detectable flux so determined, so one may naıvely
conclude that there is no hope to detect them with this
experimental setting. However, for a more careful assess-
ment of the prospects for detection, we need to estimate
the detectability in each realization and then average over
all the realization, and not viceversa. In fact, as demon-
strated in the left panel of Fig. 4, in each random real-
ization, the emission is much more patchy, with a large
number of high emission peaks, corresponding to indi-
vidual mini-spikes, that can thus be resolved with the
adopted angular resolution. Black circles highlight the
position of objects brighter than the experimental sensi-
tivity (indicated in the color scale by the black line). In
total, for mχ = 1 TeV, the number of detectable IMBHs
is N5σ = 5.2 ± 3.1, where the error is relative to the 1-σ
scatter among different realizations.
We note that current simulations indicate that the
next-generation Cherenkov Telescopes Array (CTA)[39],
may significantly improve the sensitivity, down to φmin ≈
10−13cm−2s−1, thus leading to a substantial improve-
ment in the prospects for detection.
B. Prospects for GLAST
The space satellite GLAST is expected to play a crucial
role in indirect DM searches, thanks both to its ability
to perform observations at energy scales comparable to
the mass of common DM candidates and to its poten-
tial of making deep full-sky maps in gamma-rays, thanks
to its large (∼ 2.4 sr) field of view [34]. Despite the
smaller effective area, it is not affected, being a satellite,
by the atmospheric hadronic and electron background.
Furthermore, its lower energy threshold (30 MeV) allows
to probe lighter DM particles, typically leading to higher
fluxes. The angular resolution of GLAST is ≈ 3◦ in the
energy range 30 MeV-500 MeV, becomes 0.5◦ from 500
MeV to 4 GeV, and reaches 0.15◦ above 4 GeV [34].
As in the case of ACTs, we compare the expected fluxes
with the photon background, which in this case, since
GLAST will perform observations above the atmosphere,
is mainly due to diffuse gamma-ray emission. The galac-
tic and extragalactic background has been measured in
[70, 71] by EGRET in the energy range between 30 MeV
and 10 GeV and we extrapolate it to higher energies by
fitting with a power-law with spectral index of -2.1. The
resulting formula is
dΦextra/gal
dΩdE
= 2.3 × 10−6(cid:18) E
GeV(cid:19)−2.1
γ
cm2s GeV sr
.
(15)
[72, 73, 74, 75],
We note here that a large fraction of the observed
gamma-ray background might be actually due to DM
annihilations
in particular if as-
trophysical processes can boost the annihilation sig-
nal
In this case, the smoking-gun for this
scenario would be the distinctive shape of the angular
power-spectrum of the background, that may allow, al-
ready with GLAST, the discrimination against ordinary
astrophysical sources [78].
[76, 77].
The sensitivity above 30 MeV, i.e. the minimum de-
tectable flux for a 5σ detection with an exposure of 2
months, is found to be φmin = 3.2 × 10−8cm−2s−1. This
value is derived from Eq. 12, adopting values of the en-
ergy dependent effective area provided by [79], and is
consistent with GLAST sensitivity maps obtained in Ref.
[80]. The integral flux above threshold from IMBHs, av-
eraged among realizations and integrated in a 3◦ cone
towards M31, is φ30 = 1.3 × 10−7cm−2s−1.
In the right panel of Fig. 4, we show the results of our
analysis relative to a random realization, and adopting
mχ = 150 GeV, and σv = 3×10−26 cm3 s−1. Mini-spikes
appear as high emission peaks, and can be easily resolved
by selecting photons above 4 GeV, so that the angular
resolution of GLAST approaches 0.1 degrees. Black cir-
cles highlight those objects that produce a flux detectable
at 5σ with GLAST, with a 2 months exposure.
V. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
Although we have performed the analysis of the
prospects for detection with GLAST and ACTs for 2 dif-
ferent benchmark scenarios (essentially high DM particle
mass for ACTs, low mχ for GLAST), the analysis can be
easily extended to any value of the particle physics pa-
rameters of the annihilating DM particle. To explore the
dependence on mχ, we show in the left panel of Fig. 5 the
number of objects that can be detected with the afore-
mentioned experiments, as a function of the DM parti-
cle mass. Near the experiment threshold, fluxes increase
with mass. When mχ ≫ Ethr this threshold effect dis-
appears and one recovers the expected behavior (smaller
fluxes for higher masses).
Similarly, one can plot the number of detectable ob-
jects as a function of the angular distance from the cen-
8
ter of M31, to estimate the region where most mini-spikes
can be found. This is shown in the right panel of Fig. 5
where the total number of objects is also shown for com-
parison. Vertical lines denote the angular size of the re-
gion that contains 90% of the detectable IMBHs for the
various experiments, which has a characteristic size of
θ = 3.3◦.
We stress that while in the case of Galactic IMBHs
the identification of mini-spikes will require a case-by-
case analysis of the spectral properties of unidentified
gamma-ray sources, the detection of a cluster of sources
around the center of Andromeda would per se provide
unmistakable evidence for the proposesd scenario.
In conclusion, we have computed gamma-ray fluxes
from DM annihilations in mini-spikes around IMBHs in
the Andromeda Galaxy. We have studied the prospects
for detection with Air Cherenkov telescopes like MAGIC
and VERITAS and with the GLAST satellite, and found
that a handful of sources might be within the reach of
current ACTs, while the prospects for the planned CTA
are more encouraging. The obvious advantage of the pro-
posed scenario with respect to mini-spikes in the MW, is
that they are not randomly distributed over the sky, but
they are contained, at 90%, within 3 degrees from the
center of Andromeda, and can thus be searched for with
ACTs by performing a deep scan of this small region.
The prospects for GLAST appear more promising,
since an exposure time of 2 months allows the detection
of up to of ≈ 20 mini-spikes, that would be resolved as
a cluster of point-sources with identical spectra, within
a ∼ 3◦ region around the center of Andromeda. Such
a distinctive prediction cannot be mimicked by ordinary
astrophysical sources. As in the case of IMBHs in the
MW, null searches would place very strong constraints
on the proposed scenario in a wide portion of the DM
parameter space.
Acknowledgements
We thank Riccardo Rando, of the GLAST collabora-
tion, as well as Mos`e Mariotti and Michele Doro of the
MAGIC collaboration, for useful information and discus-
sions on experimental strategies and sensitivities. We
also thank Andrew Zentner for earlier collaboration and
for providing the mock catalogs of IMBHs in the MW
and Lidia Pieri for comments. GB is supported by the
Helmholtz Association of National Research Centres.
[1] L. Bergstrom, Rept. Prog. Phys. 63 (2000) 793
[arXiv:hep-ph/0002126].
[2] G. Bertone, D. Hooper and J. Silk, Phys. Rept. 405
(2005) 279 [arXiv:hep-ph/0404175].
[6] http://lhc.web.cern.ch/lhc/.
[7] E. A. Baltz, M. Battaglia, M. E. Peskin and T. Wizanski,
Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006) 103521 [arXiv:hep-ph/0602187].
[8] A. K. Datta, K. Kong and K. T. Matchev, Phys. Rev. D
[3] T. Appelquist, H.-C. Cheng and B. A. Dobrescu, Phys.
72 (2005) 096006 [arXiv:hep-ph/0509246].
Rev. D 64 (2001) 035002 [arXiv:hep-ph/0012100].
[9] C. Munoz,
Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 19 (2004) 3093
[4] G. Servant and T. M. P. Tait, Nucl, Phys. B 650 (2003)
[arXiv:hep-ph/0309346].
391 [arXiv:hep-ph/0206071].
[10] F. Aharonian et al. [H.E.S.S. Collaboration],
[5] H.-C. Cheng, K. T. Matchev and M. Schmaltz, Phys.
Rev. D 66 (2002) 056006 [arXiv:hep-ph/0205314].
Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 (2006) 221102 [Erratum-ibid. 97
(2006) 249901] [arXiv:astro-ph/0610509].
9
[11] G. Zaharijas and D. Hooper, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006)
[46] C. J. Willott, R. J. McLure and M. J. Jarvis, Astrophys.
103501 [arXiv:astro-ph/0603540].
[12] S. Profumo, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005)
103521
[arXiv:astro-ph/0508628].
J. 587 (2003) L15 [arXiv:astro-ph/0303062].
[47] Z. Haiman, and A. Loeb, Astrophys. J. 552 (2001) 459.
[48] R. Islam, J. Taylor and J. Silk, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron.
[13] Y. Mambrini, C. Munoz, E. Nezri and F. Prada, JCAP
Soc. 340 (2003) 6471 [arXiv:astro-ph/0208189].
0601 (2006) 010 [arXiv:hep-ph/0506204].
[14] G. Bertone and D. Merritt, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005)
103502 [arXiv:astro-ph/0501555].
[15] A. Cesarini, F. Fucito, A. Lionetto, A. Morselli
267
and P. Ullio, Astropart. Phys. 21 (2004)
[arXiv:astro-ph/0305075].
[49] S. M. Koushiappas, J. S. Bullock and A. Dekel,
292
Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 354 (2004)
[arXiv:astro-ph/0311487].
[50] M. Volonteri, F. Haardt, and P. Madau, Astrophys. J.
582 (2003) 559 [arXiv:astro-ph/0207276].
[51] K. S. Thorne and V. B. Braginsky, Astrophys. J. Lett.
[16] A. Bouquet, P. Salati and J. Silk, Phys. Rev. D 40 (1989)
204 (1976) L1.
3168.
[17] J. Silk and A. Stebbins, Astrophys. J. 411 (1993) 439.
[18] L. Bergstrom, J. Edsjo and P. Ullio, Phys. Rev. D 58,
083507 (1998) [arXiv:astro-ph/9804050].
[52] ´E ´E Flanagan and S. A. Hughes, Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998)
4566.
[53] ´E ´E Flanagan and S. A. Hughes, Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998)
4535.
[19] C. Calcaneo-Roldan and B. Moore, Phys. Rev. D 62,
[54] R. Islam, J. Taylor and J. Silk, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron.
123005 (2000) [arXiv:astro-ph/0010056].
Soc. 354 (2004) 629 [arXiv:astro-ph/0309559].
[20] R. Aloisio, P. Blasi and A. V. Olinto, Astrophys. J. 601
[55] T. Matsubayashi, H. Shinkai and T. Ebisuzaki, Astro-
(2004) 47 [arXiv:astro-ph/0206036].
[21] S. M. Koushiappas, A. R. Zentner and T. P. Walker,
Phys. Rev. D 69 (2004) 043501 [arXiv:astro-ph/0309464].
[22] J. Diemand, B. Moore and J. Stadel, Nature 433 (2005)
389 [arXiv:astro-ph/0501589].
[56] S. M.
phys. J.614 (2004), 864.
Koushiappas
arXiv:astro-ph/0503511.
and
A.
R.
Zentner,
[57] http://lisa.nasa.gov/.
[58] G. D. Quinlan, L. Hernquist, S. Sigurdsson, Astrophys.
[23] L. Pieri, E. Branchini and S. Hofmann, Phys. Rev. Lett.
J. 440 (1995) 554.
95, 211301 (2005) [arXiv:astro-ph/0505356].
[59] J. F. Navarro, C. S. Frenk, S. D. M. White, Astrophys.
[24] L. Pieri and E. Branchini, Phys. Rev. D 69, 043512
J. 490 (1997) 493.
(2004) [arXiv:astro-ph/0307209].
[25] E. A. Baltz,
J. E. Taylor
and L. L. Wai,
arXiv:astro-ph/0610731.
[26] P. Gondolo, J. Silk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999) 1719
[arXiv:astro-ph/9906391].
[60] D. Merritt, Proceedings of Carnegie Observatories Cen-
tennial Symposium Coevolution of Black Holes and
Galaxies [arXiv:astro-ph/0301257].
[61] N. Fornengo, L. Pieri, S. Scopel, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004)
103529 [arXiv:hep-ph/0407342].
[27] G. Bertone, G. Sigl and J. Silk, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron.
Soc. 337 (2002) 98 [arXiv:astro-ph/0203488].
[28] P. Gondolo, Phys. Lett. B 494,
181
(2000)
[62] J. J. Geehan, M. A. Fardal, A. Babul, P. Guhathakurta,
996
Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 366 (2006)
[arXiv:astro-ph/0501240].
[arXiv:hep-ph/0002226].
[29] H. S. Zhao and J. Silk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 011301 (2005)
[arXiv:astro-ph/0501625].
[30] G. Bertone, A. R. Zentner, J. Silk, Phys. Rev. D 72
(2005) 103517 [arXiv:astro-ph/0509565].
[31] D. Merrit, M. Milosavljevic, L. Verde, R. Jimenez, Phys.
Rev. Lett. 88 (2002) 191301 [arXiv:astro-ph/0201376].
[32] P. Ullio, H. Zhao, M. Kamionkowski, Phys. Rev. D 64
(2001) 043504 [arXiv:astro-ph/0101481].
[63] http://projects.hepforge.org/pythia6/.
D
[64] S.
Kretzer,
054001
www.pv.infn.it/%7Eradici/FFdatabase.
Phys.
[arXiv:hep-ph/0003177]
Rev.
62
(2000)
and
[65] L. Bergstrom, T. Bringmann, M. Eriksson, M.
131301
Gustafsson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005)
[arXiv:astro-ph/0410359].
[66] J. F. Beacom, N. F. Bell and G. Bertone, Phys. Rev.
Lett. 94 (2005) 171301 [arXiv:astro-ph/0409403].
[33] D. Merritt, S. Harfst and G. Bertone, Phys. Rev. D 75
[67] T. Gaisser, M. Honda, P. Lipari and T. Stanev, in Proc.
(2007) 043517 [arXiv:astro-ph/0610425].
[34] http://www-glast.stanford.edu.
[35] http://icrhp9.icrr.u-tokyo.ac.jp/.
[36] http://mpi-hd.mpg.de/hfm/HESS/HESS.html.
[37] http://hegra1.mppmu.mpg.de/MAGICweb/.
[38] http://veritas.sao.arizona.edu/index.html.
[39] http://www.mpi-hd.mpg.de/hfm/CTA/CTA home.html.
[40] C. L. Fryer and V. Kalogera, Astrophyis. J. (2001), 554
[arXiv:astro-ph/9911312].
of the 27th ICRC, (2001).
[68] L. Bergstrom, D. Hooper, Phys. Rev D 73 (2006) 063510
[arXiv:hep-ph/0512317].
[69] http://wwwmagic.mppmu.mpg.de/physics/results/index.html.
[70] A. N. Cillis, R. C. Hartman, Astrophys. J. 621 (2005)
291.
[71] http://heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov/FTP/compton/data/egret/diffuse maps.
[72] L. Bergstrom, J. Edsjo and P. Ullio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87
(2001) 251301 [arXiv:astro-ph/0105048].
[41] L. Ferrarese and H. Ford, Space Science Reviews (2005),
[73] J. E. Taylor and J. Silk, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 339
116.
[42] M. C. Miller, E. J. M. Colbert, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 13
(2004) 1 [arXiv:astro-ph/0308402].
[43] D. A. Swartz, K. K. Ghosh, A. F. Tennant and K.-W.
Wu , arXiv:astro-ph/0405498.
(2003) 505 [arXiv:astro-ph/0207299].
[74] P. Ullio, L. Bergstrom, J. Edsjo and C. Lacey, Phys. Rev.
D 66 (2002) 123502 [arXiv:astro-ph/0207125].
[75] S. Ando, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005)
171303
[arXiv:astro-ph/0503006].
[44] X. Fan et al. [SDSS Collaboration], Astron. J. 122 (2001)
[76] S. Horiuchi and S. Ando, Phys. Rev. D 74, 103504 (2006)
2833 [arXiv:astro-ph/0108063].
[arXiv:astro-ph/0607042].
[45] A. J. Barth, P. Martini, c. H. Nelson and L.C. Ho, As-
[77] E.
J. Ahn,
G. Bertone
and D. Merritt,
trophys. Lett. 594 (2003) L95.
arXiv:astro-ph/0703236.
[80] G. Bertone, T. Bringmann, R. Rando, G. Busetto and
[78] S. Ando, E. Komatsu, T. Narumoto and T. Totani,
A. Morselli, arXiv:astro-ph/0612387.
arXiv:astro-ph/0612467.
[79] http://www-glast.slac.stanford.edu/software/IS/glast lat performance.htm
10
|
astro-ph/0207136 | 2 | 0207 | 2002-12-05T12:56:39 | Statistical characteristics of observed Ly-$\alpha$ forest and the shape of initial power spectrum | [
"astro-ph"
] | Properties of $\sim$ 5000 observed Ly-$\alpha$ absorbers are investigated using the model of formation and evolution of DM structure elements based on the Zel'dovich theory. This model is generally consistent with simulations of absorbers formation, accurately describes the Large Scale Structure observed in the galaxy distribution at small redshifts and emphasizes the generic similarity of the LSS and absorbers.
The simple physical model of absorbers asserts that they are composed of DM and gaseous matter and it allows us to estimate the column density and overdensity of DM and gaseous components and the entropy of the gas trapped within the DM potential wells. The parameters of DM component are found to be consistent with theoretical expectations for the Gaussian initial perturbations with the WDM--like power spectrum. We demonstrate the influence of the main physical factors responsible for the absorbers evolution.
The analysis of redshift distribution of absorbers confirms the self consistence of the assumed physical model and allows to estimate the shape of the initial power spectrum at small scales what in turn restricts the mass of dominant fraction of DM particles to $M_{DM}\approx 0.6 - 2$ keV. Our results verify the redshift variations of intensity of the UV background by about $4 - 6$ times and indicate that, perhaps, the available observations underestimate the intensity of this background. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (0000)
Printed 30 October 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
Statistical characteristics of observed Ly-α forest
and the shape of initial power spectrum
M. Demia´nski1,2, A.G. Doroshkevich3,4 & V.Turchaninov4
1Institute of Theoretical Physics, University of Warsaw, 00-681 Warsaw, Poland
2Department of Astronomy, Williams College, Williamstown, MA 01267, USA
3Theoretical Astrophysics Center, Juliane Maries Vej 30, DK-2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark
4Keldysh Institute of Applied Math Russian Academy of Sciences, 125047 Moscow, Russia
Accepted ..., Received ..., in original form ... .
ABSTRACT
Properties of about 4 500 observed Ly-α absorbers are investigated using the model of
formation and evolution of DM structure elements based on the modified Zel'dovich
theory. This model is generally consistent with simulations of absorbers formation,
describes reasonably well the Large Scale Structure observed in the galaxy distribution
at small redshifts and emphasizes the generic similarity of the LSS and absorbers.
The simple physical model of absorbers asserts that they are composed of DM
and gaseous matter. It allows us to estimate the column density and overdensity of
DM and gaseous components and the entropy of the gas trapped within the DM
potential wells. The parameters of DM component are found to be consistent with
theoretical expectations for the Gaussian initial perturbations with the WDM -- like
power spectrum. The basic physical factors responsible for the absorbers evolution are
discussed.
The analysis of redshift distribution of absorbers confirms the self consistency of
the adopted physical model, Gaussianity of the initial perturbations and allows to
estimate the shape of the initial power spectrum at small scales what in turn restricts
the mass of the dominant fraction of DM particles to MDM ≥ 1.5 − 5 keV. Our results
indicate a possible redshift variations of intensity of the UV background by about a
factor of 2 -- 3 at redshifts z ∼ 2 -- 3.
Key words: cosmology: large-scale structure of the Universe -- quasars: absorption:
general -- surveys.
1
INTRODUCTION
One of the most perspective methods to study the processes
responsible for the formation and evolution of the structure
of the Universe is the analysis of properties of absorbers
observed in spectra of the farthest quasars. The great po-
tential of such investigations was discussed already in Oort
(1981, 1984) just after Sargent et al. (1980) established the
intergalactic nature of the Ly-α forest. The available Keck
and VLT high resolution observations of the forest provide a
reasonable database and allow to apply statistical methods
for such investigations.
The essential progress achieved recently through nu-
merous high resolution simulations of absorbers formation
and evolution confirms that this process is closely connected
with the initial power spectrum of perturbations. These re-
sults allow us to consider the properties of absorbers in
the context of nonlinear theory of gravitational instability
(Zel'dovich 1970; Shandarin & Zel'dovich 1988) and to apply
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
the statistical description of structure formation and evolu-
tion (Demia´nski & Doroshkevich 1999, 2002; hereafter DD99
& DD02) to the Ly-α forest.
This approach is based on the modified Zel'dovich ap-
proximation and describes the formation and evolution of
DM structure elements for the CDM and WDM initial power
spectra without any smoothing or filtering procedures. It
outlines the structure evolution as a random formation and
merging of Zel'dovich pancakes, their transverse expansion
and/or compression and transformation into high density
clouds and filaments. Later on, the hierarchical merging of
pancakes, filaments and clouds forms rich galaxy walls ob-
served at small redshifts. Main stages of this evolution are
driven by the initial power spectrum.
At small redshifts the main results of the statistical ap-
proach are found to be consistent with characteristics of the
observed and simulated Large Scale Structure (Demia´nski et
al. 2000; Doroshkevich, Tucker & Allam 2002). Here we use
2 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
this approach for the analysis and interpretation of the ab-
sorbers observed at large redshifts. We show that the basic
observed characteristics of Ly-α forest are also successfully
described in the framework of this theoretical model.
The application of this approach to Ly-α forest was al-
ready discussed in Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
(2001 a,b, hereafter Paper I & Paper II). Here we improve
this analysis by using a richer and more refined sample of
∼ 4500 observed absorbers and a more refined model of ab-
sorbers. Our approach uses more traditional methods of in-
vestigation of properties of discrete absorbers rather then
associating them with a continuous non-linear line-of-sight
density field (see, e.g., Weinberg et al. 1998; McDonald et al.
2000; Croft et al. 2001; Croft et al. 2002). It allows to reach
more clarity in the description of formation and evolution of
absorbers and to reveal its strong link with the initial power
spectrum. It allows also to separate several subpopulations
of absorbers and to discuss their evolutionary history.
The composition and spatial distribution of observed
absorbers is complicated and at low redshifts a significant
number of stronger Ly-α lines and metal systems is asso-
ciated with galaxies (Bergeron et al. 1992; Lanzetta et al.
1995; Tytler 1995; Le Brune et al. 1996). However as was
recently shown by Penton, Stock and Shull (2002), even at
small redshifts some absorbers are associated with galaxy
filaments while others are found within galaxy voids. These
results suggest that the population of weaker absorbers dom-
inating at higher redshifts can be associated with weaker
structure elements formed by the non luminous baryonic
and DM components in extended low density regions. In
turn, the relatively homogeneous spatial distribution of ab-
sorbers implies a more homogeneous spatial distribution of
both DM and baryonic components as compared with the
observed distribution of the luminous matter.
For the truncated Zel'dovich theory (Coles, Melot &
Shandarin 1993; Bond & Wadsley 1997), some statistical
characteristics of absorbers were already discussed in Gnedin
& Hui (1996); Hui, Gnedin & Zhang (1997); and Hui & Rut-
ledge (1999). In particular, in these papers possible fits for
the number density of absorbers with a threshold hydrogen
column density, NHI , or with a threshold Doppler parame-
ter, b, were proposed. However, because of the complex evo-
lution of absorbers, these functions depend upon both the
initial power spectrum and several random factors discussed
below (Secs. 2.3, 4.3). So, the application and interpretation
of these fits are limited.
Here we use a statistical approach (DD02) based on the
modified Zel'dovich theory which describes both linear and
nonlinear evolution of the DM structure. For the CDM -- like
power spectrum and Gaussian initial perturbations it gives
the expected mean 1D number density and the probabil-
ity distribution function of DM pancakes. Both functions
depend only on the cosmological model and moments of
the initial power spectrum. Comparison of these functions
with absorbers distributions confirms the self consistency of
adopted physical model and Gaussianity of the initial den-
sity perturbations, allows to estimate the spectral moments
and to restrict the mass of dominant DM particles. These re-
sults complement the investigations of the linear power spec-
trum (see, e.g., Croft, Weinberg, Katz & Hernquist 1998;
Gnedin & Hamilton 2002; Zaldarriaga, Scoccimorro & Hui
2002; Croft et al. 2002).
However, this theory does not describe the process of
relaxation of compressed matter, the disruption of structure
elements due to the gravitational instability of DM pan-
cakes and the distribution of neutral hydrogen across DM
pancakes. Now we have only limited information about prop-
erties of the background gas and UV radiation (Scott et al.
2000; Schaye et al. 2000; McDonald & Miralda -- Escude 2001;
McDonald et al. 2000, 2001; Theuns et al. 2002a, b). There-
fore, in this paper some numerical factors remain undeter-
mined. They could be more precisely determined by special
investigations of simulated and observed absorbers.
This analysis should be supplemented by application of
the discussed here approach to simulations which take simul-
taneously into account the impact of many important factors
and provide unified picture of the process of absorbers for-
mation and evolution (see, e.g., Weinberg et al. 1998; Zhang
et al. 1998; Dav´e et al. 1999; Theuns et al. 1999). But so far
such simulations can be performed only in small boxes what
restricts their representativity, introduces artificial cutoffs
in the power spectrum and complicates the quantitative de-
scription of structure evolution (see more detailed discussion
in Hui & Gnedin 1997 and Paper II). The semianalitic mod-
els (see, e.g., Bi & Davidsen 1997; Choudhury, Padmanab-
han & Srianand 2001; Choudhury, Srianand, & Padmanab-
han 2001; Viel et al. 2002) show other perspective approach
to study the structure evolution at high redshifts. Perhaps,
some results obtained below can be also useful for this pur-
pose.
Comparison of results obtained in Paper I and Paper
II and in this paper demonstrates that the quality and rep-
resentativity of the sample of observed absorbers are very
important for the reconstruction of processes of absorbers
formation and evolution. In this paper we use the sample of
∼ 4500 absorbers at 1.7 ≤ z ≤ 4 compiled from 18 high
resolution spectra. However, the redshift distribution of ab-
sorbers is inhomogeneous what increases errors and gener-
ates some uncertainties. In particular, the statistics of ab-
sorbers at z ≥ 3.5 is very poor. Because of the preliminary
character of our investigation we estimate the precision of
only the most important parameters.
Further progress can be achieved with richer samples
covering the range of redshifts at least up to z ∼ 4.5 -- 5.
The observational evidence of the reheating of the Universe
at z ≈ 6 (Djorgovski et al 2001; Fan et al. 2001) makes it
important to perform a complex investigation of the early
period of structure evolution at redshifts z ∼ 4 -- 6.
This paper is organized as follows. The theoretical
model of the structure evolution is discussed in Sec. 2. In Sec.
3 the observational databases used in our analysis are pre-
sented. The results of statistical analysis are given in Secs.
4 -- 6. Discussion and conclusion can be found in Sec. 7 .
2 MODEL OF ABSORBERS FORMATION
AND EVOLUTION
The main observational characteristics of absorption lines
are the redshift, zabs, the column density of neutral hydro-
gen, NHI , and the Doppler parameter, b, while the theo-
retical description of structure formation and evolution is
dealing with the mean linear number density of absorbers,
nabs(z), temperature, overdensity and entropy of DM and
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
gaseous components, and with the ionization degree of hy-
drogen. To connect these theoretical and observed parame-
ters a physical model of absorbers formation and evolution
is required.
Many such models were proposed and discussed during
the last twenty years (see references in Rauch 1998, and in
Paper I and Paper II). However, to describe the properties
of the new wider and refined sample of observed absorbers
it is necessary to develop a more detailed physical model of
absorbers as well. Our model includes some ideas discussed
already in earlier publications.
2.1 Physical model of absorbers.
In this paper we assume that:
(i) The DM distribution forms an interconnected struc-
ture of sheets (Zel'dovich pancakes) and filaments, their
main parameters are approximately described by the
Zel'dovich theory of gravitational instability applied to the
CDM or WDM initial power spectrum (DD99; DD02). The
majority of DM pancakes are partly relaxed, long-lived, and
their properties vary due to the successive merging and ex-
pansion and/or compression in the transverse directions.
(ii) Gas is trapped in the gravitational potential wells
formed by the DM distribution. The gas temperature and
the observed Doppler parameter, b, trace the depth of the
DM potential wells.
(iii) For a given temperature, the gas density within the
wells is determined by the gas entropy created during the
previous evolution. The gas entropy is changing, mainly, due
to shock heating in the course of merging of pancakes, bulk
heating produced by the UV background and local sources
and due to radiative cooling.
(iv) The gas is ionized by the UV background and for the
majority of absorbers ionization equilibrium is assumed.
(v) The observed properties of absorbers are changing be-
cause of merging, transversal compression and/or expansion
and disruption of DM pancakes. The bulk heating and ra-
diative cooling leads to slow drift of the entropy and density
of the trapped gas. Random variations of the intensity and
spectrum of the UV background enhance random scatter of
the observed absorbers properties.
(vi) In this simple model we identify the velocity disper-
sion of DM component compressed within pancakes with
the temperature of hydrogen and the Doppler parameter b
of absorbers. We consider the possible macroscopic motions
within pancakes as subsonic and assume that they cannot
essentially distort the measured Doppler parameter.
As compared with the model discussed in Paper II, here we
take into account more accurately the evolution of pancakes
after their formation.
The formation of DM pancakes as an inevitable first
step of evolution of small perturbations was firmly estab-
lished both by theoretical considerations (Zel'dovich 1970;
Shandarin & Zel'dovich 1989) and numerical simulations
(Shandarin et al. 1995). Both theoretical analysis and simu-
lations show the successive transformation of sheet-like ele-
ments into filamentary-like ones and, at the same time, the
merging of both sheet-like and filamentary elements into
richer walls. Such continuous transformation of structure
goes on all the time. These processes imply the existence
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
3
of a complicated time-dependent internal structure of high
density elements and, in particular, the unavoidable arbi-
trariness in discrimination of such elements into filaments
and sheets.
Our approximate consideration cannot be applied to
objects for which the gravitational potential and the gas
temperature along the line of sight strongly depends on the
matter distribution across this line. In this paper we use the
term 'pancake' to denote structure elements with relatively
small gradient of properties along the line of sight. With
such a criterion, the anisotropic halo of filaments and clouds
can be also considered as 'pancake-like'.
The subpopulation of weaker absorbers also contains
"artificial" caustics (McGill 1990) and absorbers identified
with slowly expanding underdense regions (Bi & Davidsen
1997; Zhang et al. 1998; Dav´e et al. 1999). Such absorbers
produce a short lived noise, which is stronger at higher red-
shifts z ≥ 3. Fortunately, fraction of such absorbers does
not exceed 10 -- 15% of the observed sample and they cannot
significantly distort our final estimates.
In this paper we consider the spatially flat ΛCDM model
of the Universe with the Hubble parameter and mean density
given by:
H 2(z) = H 2
0 Ωm(1 + z)3[1 + ΩΛ/Ωm(1 + z)−3] ,
3H 2
0
8πG
Ωm(1 + z)3, H0 = 100h km/s/Mpc .
hρm(z)i =
Here Ωm = 0.3 & ΩΛ = 0.7 are dimensionless matter density
and the cosmological term, and h = 0.65 is the dimensionless
Hubble constant.
(1)
2.2 Properties of the homogeneously distributed
hydrogen
Properties of the compressed gas can be suitably related
to the parameters of homogeneously distributed gas, which
were discussed in many papers (see, e.g., Ikeuchi & Ostriker
1986; Hui & Gnedin 1997; Scott et al. 2000; McDonald et
al. 2001; Theuns et al. 2002a, b). Thus, the baryonic density
and temperature can be taken as
hnb(z)i = 2.4 · 10−7cm−3(1 + z)3(Ωbh2/0.02) ,
Tbg ≈ 1.6 · 104Kθ2
Here Ωb is the dimensionless mean density of baryons,
Tbg & bbg are the temperature and Doppler parameter of the
gas, θ4
bg(z) ∼ 1 + z describes a slow decrease of temperature
with redshift for low density cosmological models, kB & mH
are the Boltzmann's constant and the mass of the hydrogen
atom.
bbg = r 2kBTbg
mH ≈ 16θbg km/s .
bg(z),
(2)
Under the assumption of ionization equilibrium of the
gas,
αrn2
b ≈ nH Γγ , αr(T ) ≈ 4 · 10−13(cid:18) 104K
T (cid:19)3/4
cm3
s
,
(3)
where αr(T ) is the recombination coefficient (Black, 1981)
and Γγ characterizes the rate of ionization by the UV back-
ground, the fraction of neutral hydrogen is
xbg = nH /nb = hnb(z)i αr(Tbg)Γ−1
γ = x0(1 + z)3,
(4)
4 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
x0 ≈
6.7 · 10−8
Γ12
Ωbh2
0.02 (cid:18) 16km/s
bbg(z) (cid:19)3/2
, Γγ = 10−12s−1Γ12 ,
For the standard power law spectrum of radiation we get
J(ν) = J21 · 10−21(cid:16) νH
ν (cid:17)αγ
Γ12 = 12.6J21(3 + αγ )−1 .
erg s−1cm−2sr−1Hz−1 ,
The gas entropy can be characterized by the function
Fbg =
Tbg
hnbi2/3 =
36keV · cm2
(1 + z)2 (cid:16) 0.02
Ωbh2(cid:17)2/3(cid:18) bbg(z)
16km/s(cid:19)2
2.3 Parameters of absorbers
In this section we introduce the main relations between the-
oretical and observed characteristics of pancakes based on
the physical model discussed in Sec. 2.1. The most impor-
tant characteristics of DM pancakes are presented (without
proofs) as a basis for further analysis. For more details see
DD99 and DD02.
2.3.1 Characteristics of DM component
The fundamental characteristic of DM pancakes is the di-
mensional, µ, or the dimensionless, q, Lagrangian thickness
(the dimensionless DM column density) :
µ ≈ hρm(z)ilvq
(1 + z)
=
3H 2
0
8πG
lvΩm(1 + z)2q ,
(6)
6.6
hΩm
0.65
0.3
Ωm
,
h−1Mpc = 33.8h−1Mpc
lv ≈
where lv is the coherent length of initial velocity field (DD99;
DD02). The Lagrangian thickness of a pancake, lvq, is de-
fined as the unperturbed distance at redshift z = 0 between
DM particles bounding the pancake. The actual thickness of
a pancake is
h
∆r = µρ−1
m = lvq(1 + z)−1δ−1,
δ = ρm/hρm(z)i .
(7)
Here δ is the mean overdensity of a pancake above the back-
ground density.
Comparing the pancake surface density, µ(z), with the
distance between neighboring absorbers,
Dsep =
c∆z
H(z)
= 5.5 · 103 ∆z
(1 + z)3/2r 0.3
Ωm
h−1Mpc ,
(8)
we can also estimate the fraction of matter accumulated by
absorbers as
µ(1 + z)
(1 + z)3/2
hρmiDsep ≈ 6.2 · 10−3q
fabs ≃
The fraction of clustered matter characterized by hfabs(z)i
can be compared with theoretical expectations (see Sec. 4.4).
For Gaussian initial perturbations, the expected prob-
(9)
∆z r 0.13
Ωmh2 .
ability distribution function for the DM column density is
e−ξ erf(√ξ)
2
√π
1
π ≈ 0.82,
√ξ (cid:18) q2
hξ2i ≈
3
4
+
q2 + q2
Nqdq ≈
1
2
hξi ≈
0(cid:19)3/4
dξ,
ξ =
q
8τ 2 , (10)
+
2
π
,
hξ3i ≈
3
16
+
11
2π
,
ΘΦ =
2γ
√π(γ − 1)
Γ(1.5 − 1/γ)
Γ(1 − 1/γ)
=
4
π
.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
(DD02), where the parameter q0 ≪ 1 characterizes the co-
herent length of the initial density field (see Sec. 7.5) and
the dimensionless 'time' τ (z) describes the evolution of per-
turbations in the Zel'dovich theory. For ΛCDM model (1)
and z ≥ 2 we have
τ (z) ≈ τ0(cid:16) 1 + 1.2Ωm
2.2Ωm (cid:17)1/3
1.27τ0
1 + z
1 + z ≈
(11)
1
,
and for the amplitude of perturbations (Doroshkevich,
Tucker & Allam 2002)
.
(5)
τ0 ≈ (0.27 ± 0.04)r Ωmh
0.2
,
ξ ≈ 1.06q(1 + z)2 0.2
Ωmh
.
(12)
Strictly speaking, relations (6) and (10) are valid for
pancakes formed and observed at the same redshift zobs =
zf and after pancake formation the transverse expansion
and compression changes its DM column density. However,
as was shown in DD02, these processes do not change the
statistical characteristics of pancakes observed at redshift
zobs ≤ zf . This means that statistically we can consider each
pancake as created at the observed redshift. More details are
given in DD99 and DD02.
For the DM dominated cosmological model the observed
Doppler parameter is also closely linked with properties of
the DM pancakes. Thus, in Paper II the b -- parameter was
identified with the infall velocity of matter into pancakes:
b ≈ vinf = u0(z)pξ2 + 2ξ ,
u0(z) ≈ 2.3lvH0τ 2√1 + z ≈
310km/s
(1 + z)3/2r 0.13
Ωmh2 .
(13)
This assumption is valid also some time after formation of
the pancake but later on the pancake relaxation, compres-
sion and/or expansion in transverse directions change the
b -- parameter.
As is seen from (13), for hξi independent from redshift
(10), a systematic variation of the mean Doppler parameter
with redshift could be expected. The problem was left open
in Paper II (due to limited observational data set) but now,
with the more representative sample of absorbers, we see
surprisingly weak redshift variations of the mean observed
Doppler parameter (Sec. 4.1). This means that only small
fraction of observed absorbers is 'young' and is described by
(13), whereas 'older' relaxed and gravitationally confined
absorbers dominate this sample. The simple model of re-
laxed absorbers was already considered in Paper II. Here we
substantially improve it.
As is well known, for an equilibrium slab of DM the
depth of potential well is
πGµ2
hρ(z)iδ
Θ2
qΘΦ ,
∆Φ ≈
where random factors ΘΦ & Θq characterizes the nonhomo-
geneity of DM distribution across the slab and the evapora-
tion of matter in the course of its relaxation.
(14)
Analysis of numerical simulations (Demia´nski et al.
2000) indicates that the relaxed distribution of DM com-
ponent can be approximately described by the politropic
equation of state with the power index γ ≈ 2 . In this case,
we can expect that
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
5
where Γ(y) is Euler function. The actual distribution of DM
component across a slab and the value of ΘΦ depend upon
the relaxation process which is essentially accelerated due
to the pancake disruption into the system of high density
clouds and filaments. This means that the factor ΘΦ ran-
domly vary from absorber to absorber.
At each pancake merging ∼ 10 -- 15% of matter is evap-
orated due to the violent relaxation. This means that Θq ∼
1 for absorbers formed from the homogeneously distributed
matter and Θq decreases for rich absorbers formed due to
several successive mergings.
The Doppler parameter is defined by the depth of po-
tential well and for the isentropic gas with pgas ∝ ρ5/3
trapped within the well, we get
gas
upon the spectrum of local UV background and it varies ran-
domly with time and space. The gas temperature varies be-
cause of the pancake expansion and compression and due to
the pancake disruption into a system of high density clouds.
As is seen from (17), these processes change the baryonic
density of pancakes and we can write
δb = κb(z)δ .
(18)
This means that the factor κb is small for absorbers formed
due to adiabatic and weak shock compression because of
the large difference between entropies of the background DM
and the gas, and κb → 1 for richer hot absorbers formed due
to strong shock compression when this difference becomes
small.
qΘΦ = δ0b2
bg
q2
δ
(1 + z) ,
(15)
3
4
5
4
5
Θ2
πGµ2
hρ(z)iδ
b2 ≈
δ0 =
∆Φ ≈
bbg (cid:19)2
10 (cid:18) H0lv
bbg(z) (cid:19)2
Ωmh2(cid:17)(cid:18) 16km/s
Θδ = (cid:16) 0.13
ΩmΘΦΘ2
q ≈ 4 · 103Θδ ,
ΘΦΘ2
q .
Variations of the gas entropy across an absorber increase the
random variations of Θδ and b.
2.3.2 Characteristics of gaseous component
The observed column density of neutral hydrogen can be
written as an integral over a pancake along the line of sight
.
1 + z
0.5
cosθ
NHI = Z dx ρbxH = 2hxHihnb(z)ilvq
Here hxHi is the mean fraction of neutral hydrogen and cosθ
takes into account the random orientation of absorbers and
the line of sight (hcosθi ≈ 0.5). We assume also that both
DM and gaseous components are compressed together and,
so, the column density of baryons and DM component are
proportional to each other.
(16)
However, the overdensity of the baryonic component,
δb = nb/hnbi is not identical to the overdensity of DM com-
ponent, δ, (see, e.g., discussion in Matarrese & Mohayaee
2002). Indeed, the gas temperature and the Doppler param-
eter are mainly determined by the characteristics of DM
component (15) but the gas overdensity is smaller than that
of DM component due to larger entropy of the gas. More-
over, the bulk heating and cooling change the density and
entropy of the gas trapped within the DM potential well.
Under the assumption of ionization equilibrium of the gas
(3) this process is described by the equation
1
nb
dnb
dt
= nbαr(T )[ε(T ) − Tγ /T ],
T = Tbgb2/b2
bg ,
(17)
where the recombination coefficient αr(T ) was given in (4),
Tγ ∼ (5 − 10) · 104K characterizes the energy injected at a
photoionization and
ε(T ) ≈ 2T 1/4
describes the radiative cooling for the bremsstrahlung emis-
sion and recombination of hydrogen and helium (Black
1981).
[1 − 0.3 ln T4 + 0.13T 1/3
T4 = T /104K ,
],
4
4
The energy injected at the photoionization, Tγ , depends
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Under the assumption of ionization equilibrium of the
gas (3) and neglecting a possible contribution of macroscopic
motions to the b-parameter (T ∝ b2), for the fraction of
neutral hydrogen and its column density we get:
hxHi = x0κb(z)δβ−3/2(1 + z)3Θx,
NHI = N0qδβ−3/2(1 + z)5, N0 = 5 · 1012cm−2ΘH ,
bbg(z) (cid:19)3/2
0.02 (cid:19)2(cid:18) 16km/s
cosθ (cid:18) Ωbh2
Ωmh2 hcosθi
κbΘx
Γ12
β = b/bbg ,
ΘH =
(19)
0.13
,
where Γ12, bbg and x0 were defined in (2) and (4) and the
factor Θx describes the nonhomogeneous distribution of ion-
ized hydrogen along the line of sight.
2.3.3 Absorbers characteristics
Eqs. (15) and (19) link the observed and other physical char-
acteristics of absorbers. For the DM column density, q, the
average gas entropy, Σ = ln(Fs), and overdensity, δ, we get:
q3 =
NHI
N0δ0
β7/2
(1 + z)6 ,
δ = δ0
q2
β2 (1 + z) ,
(20)
exp(Σ) = Fs = β2/δ2/3
b = κ−2/3
b
β2/δ2/3 .
Here we use the standard equation of state T /Tbg = β2(z) =
Fs(z)δ2/3(z) .
The precision of these estimates is moderate and the
main uncertainties are generated by the unknown cosθ and
parameters ΘΦ, Θq, Θx, κb and Γγ , which vary -- randomly
and systematically -- from absorber to absorber (estimates of
q and δ are independent from bbg). These variations distort
parameters defined in (20) as follows:
1
Θδ
Θ2
H
Θδ (cid:19)2/9
(cid:18) Θ2
H
,
ΘHΘδ
δ3 ∝
, Fs ∝ κ−2/3
q3 ∝
Independent estimates of these uncertainties can be ob-
tained from the analysis of the redshift distribution of ab-
sorbers (Sec. 6).
(21)
.
b
However, comparing the average DM column density
of pancakes, hqi, with expectations (10) we can restrict the
possible redshift variations of hΘH Θδi and estimate the com-
bined uncertainty introduced by unknown factors. As is seen
from (20),
ξ3 ≈ (1 + z)6 q2 = (cid:16)
NHI
2 · 1016cm−2(cid:17)(cid:18)
b
16km/s(cid:19)7/2
G12 ,
6 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
G12(z) =
Γ12
κbΘxΘΦΘ2
q
cosθ
0.5 (cid:18) Ωmh2
0.13
Ωbh2
0.02 (cid:19)2
.
(22)
larger than the coherent length of initial density field, this
number density can be approximated by the expression
This relation shows that, for statistically homogeneous sam-
ple of absorbers with hξ3i = const., hcosθi = 0.5, we can
estimate the redshift variations of hG12(z)i as follows:
hG12(z)i ∝ (cid:28)
q(cid:29) ∝ hξ3i/hNHI b7/2i .
κbΘxΘΦΘ2
Γ12
Precision of these estimates is limited because of strong ran-
dom scatter of the product NHI b7/2 .
2.3.4 Regular and random variations of absorber
characteristics
The most fundamental characteristic of absorbers is their
DM column density, ξ ≈ q(1 + z)2. It describes the forma-
tion and merging of pancakes, is only weakly sensitive to the
action of random factors and defines the regular variations
of the Doppler parameter, b, overdensity, δ, and entropy, Fs.
These parameters include also a random component which
integrates the evolutionary history of each pancake and the
action of random factors discussed in the previous subsec-
tion. If the structure of a relaxed pancake can be described
by the politropic equation of state with the effective power
index γ then we can discriminate the regular and random
variations of b, δ, & Fs and introduce the reduced character-
istics of relaxed absorbers, υ, ∆ & S:
υ = ln[βξ(1/γ−1)] ,
∆ = ln[(1 + z)3δ/ξ2/γ ] = ln(δ0) − 2υ ,
S = ln[(1 + z)−2Fsξ2(5/3−γ)/γ ] = const. + 10υ/3 .
(23)
These relations indicate that, in fact, our approximate de-
scription use only one random characteristic, namely, υ,
which is expressed through observed parameters as follows:
υ =
7 − γ
6γ
ln β −
γ − 1
3γ
ln(cid:16) NHI
N0δ0(cid:17) .
(24)
As is shown in Secs. 4.5.2, the choice of a suitable value
of γ allows to minimize the correlation between ξ and υ. Of
course, this reduction is approximate and it can be achieved
only statistically for a given sample of absorbers.
2.4 Mean number density of absorbers
Following Paper I we will characterize the 1D mean number
density of absorbers by the dimensionless function
nabs =
c
H0 hli−1 =
H(z)
H0
dN (z)
dz
.
(25)
Here dN (z) is the mean number of absorbers between z and
z + dz, hl(z)i is the mean free path between absorbers at
redshift z and c is the speed of light. When absorbers are
identified with the Zel'dovich pancakes, this 1D mean num-
ber density can be linked with the fundamental character-
istics of the cosmological model and moments of the initial
power spectrum (DD02 & Sec. 7.5).
As was shown in DD02, for Gaussian initial perturba-
tions and for richer DM pancakes with sizes significantly
c
√3(1 + z)2
16πτ (z)√q0
erf(√ξthr)
c
Wp(ξthr)(1 + z)2
,
(26)
H0lv
(cid:21) ,
hq(ξthr)i
π exp(ξthr)[1 − erf2(√ξthr)]
4√πξthrerf(√ξthr) + 2 exp(−ξthr)
nabs ≈
hq(ξthr)i = 4τ 2(cid:20)1 +
Wp(ξthr) ≈ 0.5[1 − erf(pξthr)] ,
where ξthr(z) = qthr/8τ 2(z), qthr(z) is the minimal (thresh-
old) DM column density of pancakes, Wp(ξthr) and hq(ξthr)i
are the fraction of matter and the mean DM column density
for pancakes with q ≥ qthr and the factor (1 + z)2 describes
the cosmological expansion of pancakes population.
The expression (26) contains only one fitting parame-
ter, ξthr, and it describes quite well the evolution of richer
pancakes. However, application of this relation to evolution
of weaker pancakes is problematic as for ξthr ≪ 1 we get
from (26):
nabs ≈ 55(1 + z)4 ,
and this relation does not contain any fitting parameters.
The formation of pancakes with small q is suppressed
due to the small scale cutoff in the initial power spectrum.
For pancakes with small qthr the redshift variations of the
mean number density is described by the expression
H0lv
√ξthr
nabs ≈
(DD02) where again ξthr(z) = qthr(z)/8τ 2 and the value q0
characterizes the coherent length of the initial density field
(see Sec. 7.5).
exp(−ξthr) ,
(27)
Both expressions, (26) and (27), are derived for the
Gaussian initial perturbations. They are valid for DM pan-
cakes formed due to both linear and nonlinear compressions
and allow for merging of pancakes. Moreover, as was shown
in DD02, if the observed redshift is identified with the red-
shift of pancake formation then both relations remain the
same even when the transverse compression and expansion
of pancakes are also taken into account. This means that
they partly account for the pancake disruption as well.
The relation (27) describes also the impact of the
gaseous pressure on the formation of observed absorbers.
In this case, the parameter q0 must be calculated with the
power spectrum corrected for the Jeans damping of small
scale perturbations in the baryonic component (see Sec. 7.5).
2.5 Observational restrictions
The completeness of the observed samples of absorbers is re-
stricted by the condition NHI ≥ Nthr ≈ 1012cm−2 what in
turn distorts the characteristics of observed absorbers and
makes it difficult to compare them with the theoretical ex-
pectations discussed in Secs. 2.3 and 2.4 . This means that
these expectations should be corrected for the impact of the
threshold column density of observed absorbers.
Thus the investigation of spatial distribution of galaxies
in the SDSS EDR (Doroshkevich, Tucker & Allam 2002)
results in estimates of typical parameters of galaxy walls at
small redshifts as
hqi ≈ 0.4,
hδi ≈ 3 .
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
hβi ≈ 20,
(28)
With these data the expected column density of neutral hy-
drogen within the typical wall (16) is
NHI ≈ 0.02N0 ≈ 0.1Nthr ΘH ≤ Nthr .
This means that even so spectacular object as the 'Greet
Wall' does not manifest itself as absorbers. Rare absorbers
with b ≥ 100 km/s, NHI ∼ 1013cm−2 and ξ ∼ 1.5 observed
at z ∼ 1.5 -- 4 can be associated with embryos of wall -- like
elements of the Large Scale Structure of the Universe (see
Sec. 5 for more detailed discussion).
q ≈ hqi ≈ (1 + z)−2,
For absorbers associated with 'young' pancakes the
Doppler parameter is given by (13) and for the richer 'young'
pancakes with the mean DM column density we get
β ≈ 35(1 + z)−3/2 ,
ξ ≈ 1,
δ ≈ 3 Θδ, NHI ≈ 10−2(1 + z)21/4N0Θδ ,
and such pancakes can be seen as absorbers already at red-
shifts z ≥ 1.
have
For more numerous poorer pancakes with q ≤ hqi we
(29)
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
7
Table 1. QSO spectra used
zem zmin
zmax
0000 − 2601
0055 − 2592
0014 + 8133
0956 + 1223
0302 − 0033,2
0636 + 6803
1759 + 7544
1946 + 7665
1347 − 2462
1122 − 4412
2217 − 2822
2233 − 6066
1101 − 2642
0515 − 4412
2126 − 1587
1700 + 6428
1225 + 3179
1331 + 17010
4.11
3.66
3.41
3.30
3.29
3.17
3.05
3.02
2.63
2.42
2.41
2.24
2.15
1.72
3.26
2.72
2.20
2.10
3.4
3.0
2.7
2.6
2.6
2.5
2.4
2.4
2.1
1.9
1.9
1.5
1.6
1.5
2.9
2.1
1.7
1.7
4.1
3.6
3.2
3.1
3.1
3.0
3.0
3.0
2.6
2.4
2.3
2.2
2.1
1.7
3.2
2.7
2.2
2.1
No
of HI lines
431
534
262
256
356
313
307
461
361
353
262
293
277
76
130
85
159
69
(30)
1. Lu et al. (1996), 2. unpublished, courtesy of Dr. Kim 3. Hu
et al., (1995), 4. Djorgovski et al. (2001) 5. Kirkman & Tytler
(1997), 6. Cristiani & D'Odorico (2000), 7. Giallongo et al. (1993),
8. Rodriguez et al. (1995), 9. Khare et al. (1997), 10. Kulkarni et
al. (1996).
can be distorted due to the limited representativity of our
sample and a nonhomogeneous redshift distribution of ob-
served absorbers plotted in Fig. 1 .
However, weak redshift variations of the functions hbi,
hlg(NHI )i & hG12i (Sec. 4.1) show that the influence of varia-
tions of Γ12 on the properties of absorbers is partly compen-
sated by variations of κb, Θx, Θq & ΘΦ introduced in Secs.
2.3.1 & 2.3.2 . As is found in Sec. 4.2, a reasonable descrip-
tion of the mean absorbers characteristics is achieved when
the function hG12i (22) is
hG12i ≈ G0(1 − 0.17z), G0 = 50 .
(32)
Comparison of this function with estimates of Γ12 (Scott
et al. 2000; McDonald & Miralda-Escude 2001) allows to
estimate the unknown factors as
qi ∼ (0.1 − 0.05)(cid:18) Ωmh2
hκbΘxΘΦΘ2
More accurate estimate of these factors can be obtained with
numerical simulations.
0.02 (cid:19)2
0.13
Ωbh2
.
3 THE DATABASE.
The present analysis is based on the 18 spectra listed in
Table 1. The available Ly-α lines were arranged into three
samples. The richest sample, S12
14 , includes 4369 absorbers
with 1015cm−2 ≥ NHI ≥ 1012cm−2 from the first 14 high
resolution spectra. It can be partly incomplete. For compar-
ison, we use the most reliable sample S13
18 which includes
2643 absorbers from all 18 spectra for 1013cm−2 ≤ NHI ≤
1015cm−2 . These lines are more easily identified and they
are not so sensitive to outer random influences. The sample
14 contains 2126 weaker lines with NHI ≤ 1013cm−2 from
W 12
the first 14 QSOs. It is mainly used to characterize possible
δ ≈ 4q(1 + z)2Θδ ,
β ∼ 30√q(1 + z)−1/2,
NHI ≈ 2.5 · 10−2N0q5/4(1 + z)31/4Θδ
≈ (cid:16) q
NthrΘδΘH ,
and such pancakes become visible for z ≥ 1.5 only.
sorbers show that:
0.02(cid:17)5/4(cid:16) 1 + z
2.5 (cid:17)31/4
These rough estimates of expected characteristics of ab-
(i) At redshifts z ≤ 1.5 we can observe mainly old pan-
cakes formed at higher redshifts which kept the measurable
column density of neutral hydrogen up to small redshifts.
(ii) The expected number density of observed absorbers
rapidly increases at redshifts z ∼ 1.5 -- 2 when even rela-
tively poor 'young' pancakes can pass over the observational
threshold and become seen as weak absorbers.
This means that our analysis can be applied to ab-
sorbers observed at z ≥ 1.5 -- 2 when the impact of the
observational threshold becomes moderate.
2.6 Variations of the UV background
Direct estimates of the intensity of UV background through
the proximity effect (Scott et al. 2000) give Γ12 ≈ 2 ± 1 at
z ∼ 2.5 -- 3 while McDonald & Miralda-Escude (2001) got
Γ12 ∼ 0.7 − 0.4 at the same z. Indirect estimates of Γ12
(Songaila 1998) demonstrate a probable sudden drop of the
UV intensity of about 3 times at z ∼ 3. This effect can be
related to the strong ionization of HeII at these redshifts
(Jacobsen et al. 1994; Zeng, Davidsen & Kriss 1998; Theuns
at al. 2002a, b).
As is shown in Sec. 6.2, possible redshift variations of
Γ12 are also seen in the redshift distribution of weaker ab-
sorbers at z ≈ 2.5. These variations can be fitted by the
expression
Γ12 =
a0 + 1
2
h1 +
a0 − 1
a0 + 1
th(cid:16) z − zγ
0.16 (cid:17)i ,
(31)
where a0 ∼ 1.5 -- 3 and zγ ∼ 2.5 -- 3 characterize the am-
plitude and the redshift of these variations. These estimates
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
8 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
Figure 1. Redshift distribution of the fraction of observed ab-
14 (green points) and S13
sorbers for samples W 12
18
(blue points).
14 (red points), S12
variations of the UV background. To decrease the scatter of
absorbers characteristics we exclude from these samples 45
absorbers with b ≥ 90km/s .
As is seen from Fig 1, for all samples the redshift distri-
bution of absorbers is nonhomogeneous and the majority of
absorbers are concentrated at 2 ≤ z ≤ 3 . This means that
some of the discussed absorbers characteristics are derived
mainly from this range of redshifts. Absorbers at z ≥ 3.5
were identified mainly from the spectrum of QSO 0000-260
(Lu et al. 1996) and here the line statistics is insufficient.
4 STATISTICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF
ABSORBERS
Γ12 E = 0.1.
qi = 0.5, ΘH = D κbΘx
In this Section, the functions q, ξ, δ & Fs are found for
the ΛCDM cosmological model (1) with bbg = 16km/s,
Ωbh2 = 0.02 and the function hG12(z)i given by (32) with
G0 = 50, Θδ = hΘΦΘ2
(33)
Some quantitative results of this Section depend on the com-
pleteness and representativity of the samples and the quite
arbitrary choice of Θδ & ΘH (33) through the relations (21).
As was noted above, for each absorber these factors change
in the course of absorbers evolution and, in fact, the ac-
cepted values are averaged over the sample. For the sample
S12
14 , ∼ 10-15% of the weaker absorbers could be related to
the artificial "noise".
For majority of QSO spectra used in our analysis the
scatter of observed NHI is less then 10 per cents, while the
scatter of the measured Doppler parameters, b, can achieve
20 -- 30 per cents. Non the less, dispersions of absorbers char-
acteristics discussed below are defined mainly by their broad
distribution functions and by the completeness of the sam-
ples. Because of this, we discuss in this Section uncertainties
of only the more interesting quantitative characteristics of
absorbers.
Figure 2. Redshift variations of hG12i (top panel), Doppler pa-
rameter, hbi (middle panel) and hlg(NHI )i (bottom panel) for
samples S13
14 (green points). Mean values
(34) and fit (32) are plotted by straight lines.
18 (blue points) and S12
samples S12
prisingly weakly vary with redshift,
14 and S13
18 , the mean values hbi and hlgNHIi sur-
(34)
hbi = (31.7 ± 1.6)km/s,
hlgNHIi = (13.6 ± 0.06),
hbi = (28.6 ± 1.6)km/s,
hlgNHIi = (13.1 ± 0.22),
respectively. At the same time, the mean Doppler parameter
systematically shifts from hbi = (25.6 ± 2.9)km/s for the
sample W 14
12 up to hbi = (38.4 ± 2.7)km/s for 660 absorbers
with NHI ≥ 1014cm−2 what indicates a weak correlation
of observed properties of absorbers. Detailed discussion of
observed characteristics of absorbers can be found in Kim,
Cristiani & D'Odorico (2002), Kim et al. (2002).
The small variations of hbi with the redshift are accom-
panied by similar small variations of dispersion σb ∼ 0.5hbi
which also do not exceed ∼ 8%. This fact indicates that the
broad distribution function of b is weakly dependent upon
the redshift. The same is valid for the depth of potential
wells, h∆Φi (14), and illustrates a correlation between the
DM column density, q, and the overdensity of absorbers, δ
described by (20). The nature of such a weak redshift evolu-
tion of these statistical characteristics of absorbers remains
a mystery.
The function hG12i/G0 is also plotted in Fig. 2 together
with the rough fit (32). Its weak redshift dependence is a
natural consequence of the weak redshift variations of hbi
and hlgNHIi. Its deviations from (32) correlate with the ab-
sorbers distribution plotted in Fig 1 .
4.1 Redshift variations of the mean observed
density, overdensity and entropy of absorbers
4.2 Redshift variations of the mean DM column
characteristics
Redshift variations of two observed characteristics of ab-
sorbers, hbi, and hlgNHIi, are plotted in Fig. 2. For both
Other characteristics of absorbers depend upon the physical
model. For the model discussed in Sec. 2 (Eq. 20) with the
function hG12i (22, 32) the redshift variations of the mean
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
9
6.3 from the analysis of redshift distribution of absorbers.
This disagreement requires more detailed investigation and,
perhaps, redefinition of the factors G0, ΘH and Θδ .
14 can be roughly fitted as follows:
hδi ≈ 4.7ζ −2.5 ,
ζ = (1 + z)/4 .
As is seen from Fig. 3, the redshift variations of func-
tions hδi and hFsi characterizing the overdensity of DM com-
ponent and entropy of gaseous component for both samples
18 and S12
S13
hδi ≈ 7.5ζ −3.1,
hFsi ≈ 1.93ζ 1.6,
These fits emphasize the general tendencies of absorbers evo-
lution. Comparison with the background density (2) and en-
tropy (5) shows that the mean density of absorbers weakly
depends on the redshift and the mean entropy weakly in-
creases with time. These results indicate that our sample is
dominated by long lived relaxed absorbers.
(36)
These estimates may be rescaled according to (21).
4.3 The mean size of absorbers
18 , we have
Our model of absorbers ( see Sec. 2) allows also to estimate
roughly the real size of absorbers along the line of sight,
∆r. Due to the strong correlation between q and δ, this size
should be obtained by averaging ∆r as given by (7). For the
model parameters given in (33) and for both samples, S12
14
and S13
h∆ri ∼ (80 − 100)h−1kpc ,
(37)
and this size increases up to ∼ 150h−1 kpc for weaker ab-
sorbers of the sample W 12
14 . For all samples the PDFs of the
sizes are similar to the Gaussian function with a dispersion
σr ∼ 0.5h∆ri.
sociated with the Doppler parameter, b, as follows:
The mean size of absorbers in the redshift space is as-
h∆rbi = 2hbi/H(z) ≈ 130h−1kpc(cid:16) 4
1 + z(cid:17)3/2r 0.3
Ωm
.
As usual, it is larger than that in the real space (37). This
difference agrees with the domination of relaxed gravitation-
ally bound absorbers in the sample.
The expected mean transverse size of absorbers is com-
parable with their Lagrangian size along the line of sight
and was roughly estimated in DD02 as
0.6lv
lvτ 2
1 + z ≈
(1 + z)3 ≈ 300h−1kpc(cid:16) 4
h∆rti ≈ 5.2
Difference between estimates h∆ri and h∆rti agrees with
expectations of the Zel'dovich theory and indicates that such
absorbers could be unstable with respect to the disruption
into a system of denser less massive clouds with ∆rt ∼ ∆r
(see, e.g., Doroshkevich 1980; Vishniac 1983).
1 + z(cid:17)3
. (38)
4.4 The mean matter fraction accumulated by
absorbers and the mean absorber separation
The mean matter fraction accumulated by absorbers,
hfabs(z)i, and the mean absorber separation, hDsep(z)i, de-
fined by (8 & 9), are plotted in Fig. 4 for the samples W 12
14 ,
14 & S13
S12
18 . The estimates of hfabs(z)i are sensitive to small
measured line separations, ∆z ∼ 10−4, which are unreli-
able. For richer absorbers of the sample S13
18 , the estimates
Figure 3. Functions hξi = (1 + z)2hqi (top panel), hFsi (middle
panel) and the overdensity hδi, (bottom panel) are plotted vs.
redshift, z, for samples S12
18 (blue points).
Fits (35, 36) are plotted by lines.
14 (green points), and S13
DM column density, hξi, the mean entropy and overdensity,
hFsi and hδi, are plotted in Fig. 3.
The mean DM column density of absorbers, hqi & hξi ≈
hqi(1 + z)2, is the most stable parameter. In principle, hξi
does not change due to the formation and merging of ab-
sorbers and due to their transverse compression and/or ex-
pansion (DD02). The differences between the expected and
measured hξi characterize, in fact, the influence of disre-
garded factors, mainly the completeness and representativ-
ity of the samples, the pancake relaxation and the scatter of
the function G12.
As is seen from comparison of Fig. 1 and Fig. 3, for both
14 variations of measured hξ(z)i around
18 and S12
samples S13
the mean values
(35)
For the sample S12
hξi ≈ (0.65 ± 0.09) ,
hξi ≈ (1. ± 0.09),
are roughly correlated with the redshift distribution of ab-
sorbers plotted in Fig. 1 what emphasizes the limited rep-
resentativity of the sample used in the analysis. At small
redshifts, z ≤ 2, the influence of the observational restric-
tions (Sec. 2.5) increase the measured value of hξi.
14 the measured hξ(z)i ≈ 0.65 is close
to the expected value hξ(z)i ≈ 0.82 what verifies the choice
of the amplitude of hG12i in (32). However, the estimates
of hξ(z)i depend also upon the choice of the amplitude of
initial perturbations, τ0 (12), known only with a moderate
precision. For the samples S13
18 , hξ(z)i increases due to the
rejection of weaker absorbers in this sample.
18 , the minimal DM column
density is found to be qmin ∼ 10−2 and it only weakly de-
pends upon the redshift. This result is especially sensitive to
the random noise, it is based on poor statistic and is not re-
liable because our fit of hG12i provides a reasonable descrip-
tion for the sample as a whole only. This value is smaller
than the estimate hqthri ≈ 3 · 10−2 (54) obtained in Sec.
For both samples, S12
14 & S13
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
10 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
with richer samples of observed absorbers and by compari-
son with simulations.
As is well known, at redshifts z ≥ 4 the absorbers be-
gin to overlap and their separation becomes problematic.
Analysis of the evolution of the mean absorbers separa-
tion allows to estimate quantitatively this effect. For this
purpose, we can compare the mean separation of absorbers
at various redshifts, hDsep(z)i, given by (8) with the mean
Doppler parameter which characterizes the observed thick-
ness of absorbers. For samples S12
18 these parameters
are roughly fitted by power laws:
14 and S13
hDsepi ≈ (cid:16) 4
H0hDsepi
1 + z(cid:17)2.7
≈ (cid:16) 6.1
hbi
1 + z(cid:17)2.6
,
respectively.
h−1Mpc, ≈ (cid:16) 5.3
H0hDsepi
hbi
h−1Mpc ,
1 + z(cid:17)2.7
≈ (cid:16) 8
1 + z(cid:17)2.9
,
(39)
Figure 4. Mean fractions of matter accumulated by absorbers,
hfabsi, (top panel) and the mean absorber separations, hDsepi,
(bottom panel), are plotted vs. redshift, z, for samples W 12
14 (red
points), S12
18 (blue points). Fits (39) are
plotted by solid and dashed lines.
14 (green points), and S13
of fabs(z) based on the expression (9) are also unreliable
because they neglect the transverse compression and expan-
sion of matter and formation of high density clouds. So, the
representativity and precision of measured hfabs(z)i are lim-
ited. The estimates of hDsep(z)i are less sensitive to the first
factor but are also influenced by the second one. The ran-
dom scatter of the measured hfabs(z)i and hDsep(z)i could
be caused by the limited representativity of the samples at
small and higher redshifts.
In spite of uncertainties these results are interesting in
some respects. Thus, the regular growth of hfabs(z)i and
decrease of hDsep(z)i with redshifts for the sample S13
18 indi-
cate the progressive disruption of richer absorbers and their
transformation into system of high density clouds. Indeed,
due to small cross -- section of such clouds, they are rarely
cross the line of sight and their formation increases the sep-
aration of richer observed absorber and even can decrease
the measured hfabsi for this sample.
Both the significant fraction of matter seen as numerous
weaker absorbers in the sample W 12
14 and its weak redshift
variation point in favor of the domination of absorbers merg-
ing as compared with the formation of new absorbers from
the background matter. The merging remains unchanged the
hfabs(z)i but progressively increases hDsep(z)i with time.
These variations can be enhanced by the observational re-
strictions, NHI ≥ Nthr, discussed in Sec 2.5 .
For all samples the fraction hfabs(z)i ∼ 0.8 exceeds
the theoretical expectation hfabs(z)i ∼ 0.5 -- 0.6 for z ≃ 3
(DD02 and Sec. 7.6) and is close to the maximal fraction,
fmax ≃ 0.875, which can be compressed in the Zel'dovich'
theory. This disagreement indicates the limited applicability
of the one dimensional expression (9) and the limited preci-
sion of our model of absorbers. These results must be tested
These results verify that at z ≥ 4 absorbers effec-
tively overlap and the system of individual absorbers is
transformed into continuous absorption imitating the Gunn --
Peterson effect.
4.5 Distribution functions of absorber parameters
The observed probability distribution function, PDF, of the
DM column density of absorbers can be compared with the
expected one (10). However, we have no theoretical expres-
sion for the PDFs of the Doppler parameter, overdensity and
entropy of absorbers because the action of random factors
cannot be satisfactory described.
Indeed, the relaxation of DM pancakes depends upon
unknown internal structure of pancakes, the adiabatic com-
pression and/or expansion of an absorber changes its over-
density and temperature. On the other hand, the radiative
cooling and bulk heating lead to the drift of the gas entropy
and overdensity but leaves unchanged the depth of poten-
tial well formed by DM distribution. Merging of pancakes
increases more strongly the depth of potential well and the
gas entropy but the overdensity of the gaseous component
increases only moderately. All the time, the temperature
and overdensity of trapped gas are rearranged in accordance
with the condition of hydrodynamic equilibrium across the
pancake.
Because of this, our discussion of absorbers evolution
has only phenomenological character. The PDF of the DM
column density, Nq, is plotted in Fig. 5 for the sample S12
14
together with the fits (10) and (40). The distribution func-
tions of the reduced Doppler parameter, υ, are plotted in
Fig. 5 for samples S13
14 together with the Gaussian
fits.
18 and S12
4.5.1 Distribution functions of the DM column density
The PDF for the DM column density of pancakes, Nq(q),
plotted in Fig. 5 for samples S12
14 is the most interesting
because it can be compared with the theoretically expected
PDF (10) which, in particular, is sensitive to the coherent
length of initial density field, q0. As is seen from (10), the
PDF Nq(ξ), with ξ ≈ q(1 + z)2, does not depend on the
redshift and, so, the joint PDF can be obtained for absorbers
observed at all redshifts.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
11
Table 2. Parameters of three subpopulations of absorbers for the
sample S12
14
Nabs
hfsi
hlgNHI i
hbi
rbH
full
sh
cl
exp
4369
1940
1664
765
1.00
0.44
0.38
0.18
13.1
13.0
13.5
12.3
29
37
23
18
0.30
0.33
0.67
0.42
γ
1.8
1.8
1.6
3.5
hυi
0.8
1.0
0.6
1.3
fs is the fraction of absorbers in a subpopulation, rbH is the linear
correlation coefficient of b and logNHI .
∆ = ln[(1 + z)3δ ξ−1.1] = ln δ0 − 2υ ,
S = ln[(1 + z)−2Fsξ−0.15] = const. + 3.33 υ .
(41)
These expressions correspond to Eq. (23) with the effec-
tive power index of compressed DM component γ = 1.8.
For the sample S13
18 we have γ = 2.1. Both values are
close to γ = 2 discussed in Sec. 2.3.1 . With such defini-
tion, we get the negligible correlations, ≤ 0.01, between ξ
and other reduced characteristics and a strong correlation
≈ 1 between υ and ∆ & S. The distribution function Nυ
plotted in Fig. 5 is well fitted by the Gauss function with
hυi = 0.81 ± 0.04, συ ≈ 0.11hυi what is consistent with the
assumption of approximate equilibrium of majority of the
observed absorbers.
These results mean that, in fact, the joint action of all
random factors is characterized by the one random func-
tion υ which can be directly expressed through the observed
parameters as follows
υ ≈ 0.48 ln β − 0.15 ln(NHI /N0/δ0),
More detailed analysis requires the discrimination of sub-
populations of absorbers with different evolutionary histo-
ries.
γ = 1.8 .
(42)
4.6 Three subpopulations of absorbers
As a first step of more detailed investigation of absorbers
evolution, we can approximately separate three subpopula-
tions of absorbers with different overdensities and entropies.
Due to continuous distribution of both δ & Fs for the full
samples and because both these values depend upon un-
known random factors (21), the separation is quite arbitrary
and characteristics of subpopulations depend upon the sam-
ple used in the analysis and the parameters (33). Even so,
the redshift variation of mean parameters of subpopulations
allows to trace roughly their evolutionary history and to de-
scribe the main stages of absorbers formation and evolution.
The first subpopulation, let us call it "sh", with δ ≥ 1
and Fs ≥ 1 is formed due to the merging and shock compres-
sion. The second one, called here "cl", includes low entropy
absorbers with δ ≥ 1, Fs ≤ 1 . The third one, called here
"exp", contains peculiar absorbers with δ ≤ 1.
This choice of the threshold parameters allows to sep-
arate absorbers formed and observed at the same redshifts,
zf ≈ zobs. However, due to evolution of the background den-
sity (2) and entropy (5), the functions δ & Fs defined by (20)
are shifted with time even when the overdensity and entropy
of a long lived absorber are not changed. This shift leads to
some artificial intermixture of subpopulations.
For the sample S12
14 the mean parameters of these sub-
Figure 5. Top panel: PDFs of the DM column density, Nq, for
the sample S12
14 . Fits (10) and (40) are plotted by green and blue
lines. Bottom panel: PDF Nυ, for the samples S12
14 (red line) and
S13
18 (green line). Gaussian fit is plotted by blue line.
For ξ ≥ 0.5hξi, the PDF plotted in Fig. 5 is well fitted
by the function (10) for q0 = 0 and hξi = 0.57 what is close
to hξi = 0.65 (35). The deficit of observed absorbers with
ξ ≤ hξi can be related to incompleteness of the observed
sample for small ξ. This result verifies the self consistency
of the physical model used here and the Gaussianity of initial
perturbations.
However, as it is seen from (10), this deficit of weaker
absorbers can be related also to the suppression of the forma-
tion of poorer pancakes caused by the correlations of small
scale initial perturbations and Jeans damping described by
the parameter q0 in (10). Indeed, the observed PDF is well
fitted also by the function
Nq = 0.18
erf(√y)
√y
exp(−y)
(1 + 0.53/y)
,
y = 1.15
,
ξ
hξi
(40)
what is consistent with rough estimate q0 ∼ 0.05. This value
depends on the statistics of absorbers at small ξ ≤ hξi and
can be considered as an upper limit of q0 only.
4.5.2 Distribution functions of the reduced Doppler
parameter
As was noted above, the theoretical description for the PDFs
of the reduced Doppler parameter, overdensity and entropy
of the gas is problematic because they depend upon many
random factors. Therefore, here we will restrict our analysis
to the fits of observed PDFs, Nυ, taking also into account
the correlations of the measured ξ, b, δ & Fs.
To adjust the reduced characteristics of pancakes in-
troduced in Eq. (23), we will minimize the correlation of ξ
with υ, ∆, & S. For the sample S12
14 , the adjusted reduced
characteristics are defined as follows:
γ = 1.8,
υ = ln(βξ−0.44) ,
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
12 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
Figure 6. The mean Doppler parameter, hbi (top panel), the
mean entropy, hFsi (middle panel), and the mean overdensity
hδi (bottom panel), are plotted vs. redshift, z, together with fits
(43, 44, & 45) for the "sh" (red), "cl" (blue) and "exp" (green)
subpopulations of the sample S12
14 .
Figure 7. The DM column density (top panel) and the relative
number fractions of absorbers (bottom panel) for the "sh" (red
lines), "cl" (blue lines) and "exp" (green lines) subpopulations of
the sample S12
14 are plotted vs. redshift, z .
absorbers with
populations are listed in Table 2, where rbH is the linear
correlation coefficient of b and lg NHI . Redshift variations
of hbi, hlgNHIi, hFsi, hδi, hqi, hξi and the relative num-
ber fractions of absorbers in these subpopulations, hfmi, are
plotted in Figs. 6 & 7 and given in (43, 44 & 45).
The subpopulation "sh" is composed of the richest and
hottest absorbers with
(43)
hFsi ≈ 3.0ζ 0.6,
hbi ≈ (37 ± 2.7)km/s ,
hlgNHIi ≈ 13.0 ± 0.4,
hξi ≈ 0.8 ± 0.15,
where ζ = (1 + z)/4. As is seen from Fig. 7, for this sub-
population the decrease of the relative number fraction of
absorbers, hfmi, with z is accompanied by the growth of
the DM column density, hqi. Such variations are typical for
absorbers formed due to pancake merging and strong shock
compression of the matter.
hδi ≈ 3.75/ζ ,
The subpopulation "cl" includes absorbers with
(44)
hδi ≈ 8.7ζ −1.6 .
hFsi ≈ 0.6 ± 0.08,
hbi ≈ (23.1 ± 1.1)km/s ,
hlgNHIi ≈ 13.5 ± 0.37,
hξi ≈ 0.69 ± 0.1,
Such behavior of the mean characteristics indicates that this
subpopulation can be dominated by absorbers formed in low
entropy regions at zf ∼ zobs due to adiabatic and weak shock
compression. Such compression provides higher overdensity
than the strong shock compression and does not change the
entropy of compressed matter. For these absorbers the ra-
diative cooling can also be more important. This subpop-
ulation includes also some fraction of long lived absorbers
formed at zf > zobs due to merging and strong shock com-
pression. This intermixture is caused by redshift variations
of background parameters (2) and (5).
The peculiar subpopulation "exp" accumulates poorer
(45)
hFsi ≈ 2.1ζ 2.5,
hδi ≈ 0.6 ± 0.08 .
hbi ≈ (18 ± 5.4)km/s,
hlgNHIi ≈ 12.3 ± 0.3,
hqi ≈ 1.1 · 10−2,
Such behavior of hqi, hδi &hFsi shows that these absorbers
could be related to the unstable poorer pancakes formed
within low density regions (see, e.g., Zhang et al. 1998).
They are observed mainly at higher redshifts, they expand
together with the background and disappear at low redshifts.
Large values of the factor γ = 3.5 and of the reduced Doppler
parameter hυi = 1.3 (Table 2), verify the peculiar character
of this subpopulation.
Moreover, the analysis performed in Sec. 6.3 indicates
that, for weaker absorbers dominating this subpopulation,
at least the DM column density, hqi, can be underestimated.
This means that other parameters of the subpopulation can
also be estimated unreliably. In particular, if these absorbers
are unstable then the random factors become time depen-
dent and the estimates (45) must be corrected. Fortunately,
the fraction of such absorbers is small and its influence on
other estimates is limited.
In spite of the quite arbitrary separation of subpop-
ulations these results illustrate the action of evolutionary
factors mentioned above. The objective character of the dis-
crimination is seen from the comparison of observed param-
eters, hlgNHIi and hbi, and their linear correlation coeffi-
cient, rbH , listed in Table 2 for the full samples and for the
separated subpopulations.
These results confirm that majority of observed ab-
sorbers represent gravitationally bounded pancakes formed
in the course of adiabatic and shock compression at zf ≥
zobs. They demonstrate similarity of evolutionary history
and generic origin of subpopulations "sh" and "cl". More
detailed statistical investigation of absorbers evolution re-
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
quires finer discrimination of subpopulations and therefore
richer set of observed absorbers is needed.
4.7 Absorbers as a test of background properties
Some absorbers characteristics can be used to estimate the
redshift variations of mean properties of homogeneously dis-
tributed hydrogen (see, e.g., Hui & Gnedin 1997; Schaye et
al. 1999, 2000; McDonald et al. 2001). Thus, weak redshift
variations of hFsi (44) suggest also weak redshift variations
of Tbg (2). However, such estimates are inevitably approx-
imate and their significant scatter is caused by action of
many factors discussed above.
To obtain more stable results Schaye et al. (1999, 2000)
consider a cutoff at small b in the distribution of b(NHI ).
Indeed, relations (20) can be rewritten as follows:
b = bbgκ3/8
b
δ1/8
0 (cid:18) Fs
(1 + z)2(cid:19)9/16
N0 (cid:17)1/4
(cid:16) NHI
.
(46)
Parameters N0, δ0, bbg & κb were defined by (2, 15, & 19). Ev-
idently, for Fs = const. this relation is identical to the equa-
tion of state b2 = const.δ2/3. It demonstrates that, for the
subpopulation of absorbers formed at zf ≈ zobs with the
same Fs, the observed parameters z, b and NHI are strongly
correlated and, for a given NHI , b decreases with Fs. How-
ever, statistics of absorbers near the cutoff is small, the ac-
tion of factors discussed above erodes the cutoff and makes
its interpretation less reliable.
(47)
For absorbers selected from the sample S12
14 in four red-
shift intervals, z ≤ 2 ≤ z ≤ 2.5 ≤ z ≤ 3 ≤ z, the boundary
of the observed distribution b(NHI ) can be roughly fitted by
the relation
b ≈ b0(1 + z)−1(NHI /1012cm−2)γb .
For z ≤ 3 we have γb ∼ 0.25 that coincides with (46) but the
value of b0 ∼ 22 km/s is ∼ 2 times smaller, what is expected
from (46). This means that in the framework of the model
under consideration the cutoff can be naturally related to a
fraction of low entropy absorbers with Fs ∼ 0.3 rather then
with Fs ∼ 1. These absorbers can be formed at zf ∼ zobs
due to the adiabatic compression within low entropy regions
or due to both adiabatic and shock compressions at redshifts
zf ≥ 1.5 zobs. For richer absorbers with lgNHI ≥ 13 the
radiative cooling is also more important. This explanation
is quite consistent with the estimates (44).
At z ≥ 3 we have for the fit parameters γb ∼ 0.15 --
0.17, b0 ∼ 38km/s, what differs from (46). This difference
can be partly related to the poor statistics at higher redshifts
and to admixture of long lived absorbers formed at redshifts
z ≥ 4 when stronger systematic and random variations of
UV background are expected. In particular, at z ∼ 3 HeII
becomes ionized and the spectrum of UV background and
the effective power -- low index of the temperature -- density re-
lation are changed (Songaila 1998; Schaye et al. 2000; The-
uns et al. 2002a, b).
These results demonstrate that, in the framework of
model under consideration, the cutoff in the distribution
of b(NHI ) can be explained but its interpretation is not so
clear. The problem requires further investigation.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
13
5 WALLS AT HIGH REDSHIFTS
Majority of the rare absorbers with higher Doppler param-
eter, b ≥ (80 -- 90)km/s and moderate column density of
neutral hydrogen NHI ≤ 1014.5cm−2, can be identified with
the embryos of richer structure elements which are seen now
as rich walls in the observed galaxy distribution. The num-
ber of such absorbers is small and their statistical char-
acteristics cannot be reliably determined. However, for 45
such absorbers with b ≥ 90km/s selected in 9 spectra at
1.8 ≤ z ≤ 3.8 we have
hlgNHIi ∼ 13.2,
and the mean comoving separation of such absorbers (8) is
hFsi ∼ 10 ,
hξi ∼ 1.45,
hδi ∼ 6,
(48)
(49)
hDsepi ≈ (60 ± 20)p0.3/Ωmh−1Mpc .
Such large separation suggests that these objects will
retain their individuality up to small redshifts and, indeed,
this separation is quite consistent with the mean wall sep-
aration hDwi ≈ (66 ± 13)h−1 Mpc measured for the SDSS
EDR at z = 0 (Doroshkevich, Tucker & Allam 2002). How-
ever, for smaller b, the number of absorbers rapidly increases
and already for 139 absorbers with b ≥ 70km/s in 15 spectra
the mean separation decreases to Dsep ∼ (40 ± 20)h−1Mpc.
These results show that the walls begin to form already
at z ∼ 3 and continue to form up to the present time. At
the same time, the continuous distribution of all parameters
of absorbers shows that at high redshifts the discrimination
of walls and other structure elements is quite arbitrary. The
problem deserves further investigation in a wider range of
redshifts with a more representative sample of absorbers es-
pecially at high redshifts. Perhaps, such walls can be also
observed in the galaxy distribution at high redshifts.
6 REDSHIFT DISTRIBUTION OF
ABSORBERS
In this section we compare the observed redshift distribution
of absorbers with theoretical relations (26, 27) describing the
expected redshift evolution of the 1D number density of DM
pancakes, nabs, due to their formation and merging. As is
seen from these relations, the number density depends upon
the cosmological model, moments of initial power spectrum
and the threshold DM column density, qthr. Therefore, to
compare these expectations with observed absorbers distri-
bution we have to select samples with q ≥ qthr rather than to
use samples with a minimal NHI discussed in Sec. 4. Such
samples can be prepared using estimates of q as given by
(20) in spite of their unreliability for smaller q (see Sec. 4.2,
6.3).
Both relations (26 & 27) are derived for the Gaussian
initial perturbations. They depend on the redshift of ab-
sorbers only and, so, the impact of absorbers velocities and
Doppler parameters on the resulting estimates is minimal.
At z ≤ 4 these factors increase the scatter of measured nabs
but only at z ≥ 4 -- 4.5 they lead to a significant overlapping
of absorbers (Sec. 4.4). The Jeans damping caused by the
temperature of background is well described by (27) through
the parameter q0.
Four samples, namely, Q50
14, with
qthr = 0.05, 0.02, 0.01 & 0.001 were selected from 14 high
14, and Q01
14, Q20
14, Q10
14 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
resolution spectra. These samples contain 1554, 3299, 3998
and 4475 absorbers, respectively. Comparison of qthr used
for the sample preparation with estimates of hqthri obtained
from fits (26, 27) allows to test the self consistency of our
physical model and the choice of parameters (33).
14, Q10
The richest sample Q01
14 includes almost all lines and
probably is incomplete. It can be used for comparison with
results obtained for other samples. The sample Q50
14 contains
richer absorbers and is weakly sensitive to properties of small
scale density field described by the parameter q0 in (27). It
is used to test the expression (26) and to estimate hqthri
for such absorbers. The samples Q20
14 can be used for
independent estimates of both hqthri and q0. Of course, these
estimates are statistical and averaged over the sample.
To test the sample dependence of our results we use the
sample Q10
18 with qthr = 0.01 selected from all 18 spectra. As
compared with the sample Q10
14 it contains ∼10% additional
absorbers with NHI ≥ 1013cm−2. To demonstrate the pos-
sible variations of intensity of UV background we consider
also the sample W 12
14 containing 2126 weaker absorbers with
NHI ≤ 1012cm−2. Here we also use the sample of HST data
(Bahcall et al. 1993, 1996; Jannuzi et al. 1998) which con-
tains 1000 absorbers at z ≤ 1.5 . This sample is probably
incomplete at least at z ≥ 1 .
6.1 Selection of Poissonian subsamples of
absorbers
The first problem is the selection of Poissonian subsamples
of absorbers and estimation of their mean number density at
various redshifts. For this purpose, we use the measured red-
shift separations of neighboring absorbers, ∆z, what partly
attenuates the influence of selection effects inherent in indi-
vidual spectra. Instead of separation we use the dimension-
less comoving distance,
∆l = H0∆z/H(z) ,
and absorbers in the interval z − dz < z < z + dz, taken
from the sample under investigation, are organized into an
'equivalent single field' by arranging the separations ∆l one
after the other along the line of sight. For richer samples,
distribution of absorbers separations obtained in this way is
similar to the Poissonian one and the mean number density,
hni, can be found by comparing the measured PDF with the
differential or cumulative Poissonian PDFs:
dN/dx = exp(−hni x)/hni ,
N = exp(−hni x) .
(50)
(51)
To decrease uncertainties and to estimate the actual
scatter of these fits we rejected all points before the maxima
of differential PDF and only more representative middle part
of PDFs with the fraction of points f ≤ fthr were used.
The threshold fraction, fthr, was varied between fthr = 0.7
and fthr = 0.95. Mean values and dispersions of the set of
measurements with different fthr were taken as the actual
value and scatter of nabs. As a rule, the fit (51) of cumulative
PDFs gives more stable estimates and smaller error bars
than the fit (50) of differential PDFs. Both estimates of nabs
are plotted in Figs. 8 & 9.
Figure 8. Top panel: redshift distribution of absorbers, nabs(z),
found with fits (50) and (51) (red and green points) for the sample
W 12
14 . Fit (27) is plotted by green line. Bottom panel: redshift
variations of nabs/nf it for the same sample. Fit (52) is plotted
by blue line.
6.2 Variations of intensity of the UV background
For the sample W 12
14 the redshift distribution of absorbers
is plotted in Fig. 8 together with the fit (27) which charac-
terizes the expected redshift distribution of absorbers. The
weak absorbers in this sample are especially sensitive to vari-
ations of intensity of the UV background radiation what is
manifested by the strong variations of nabs in comparison
with the smooth fitting curve. This effect can be enhanced
by the incompleteness of the sample and the nonhomogene-
ity of redshift distribution of observed weaker absorbers. At
z ≤ 2 the rapid decrease of nabs is caused by the influence
of the threshold of the observed column density of neutral
hydrogen, NHI ≥ Nthr ≈ 1012cm−2, discussed in Sec. 2.5.
The observed variations of hnabsi are well fitted by the
function
hnabsi/nf it = 1.6 + 0.65 th(cid:16) 2.5 − z
0.16 (cid:17) ,
(52)
also plotted in Fig. 8. Similar variations with smaller ampli-
tude are also seen for absorbers in other samples.
The column density of neutral hydrogen is proportional
to Γ−1
γ and an increase of Γγ shifts weak absorbers below the
observational threshold. This means that the relation (52)
can describe quite well the redshift dependence of variations
of the UV background but their amplitude depends upon the
distribution function of NHI . Direct estimates show that the
variations of the intensity by about 2 -- 3 times described by
(31) are consistent with the observed variation of hnabsi. As
was noted in Sec. 2.6 the influence of these variations on the
mean characteristics of absorbers can be partly compensated
by variations of random factors ΘH & Θδ.
Variations of the UV background at z ∼ 3 were al-
ready detected by different methods (see, e.g., Songaila 1998;
Scott et al. 2000; McDonald & Miralda -- Escude 2001). This
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
15
Here the formal errors of the fits are given.
q0 ≈ (1.1 ± 0.12) × 10−2 .
To test the sample dependence of the results we ana-
lyzed in the same manner the sample S10
18 selected with qthr=
0.01 from all 18 spectra (4404 absorbers). In this case, the
excess of absorbers with NHI ≥ 1013cm−2 and larger separa-
tions decrease the measured nabs and the resulting estimates
are
hqthri ≈ (3.2 ± 0.3) × 10−2,
We see that such perturbations lead to moderate variations
of both hqthri and q0 .
Real precision of both estimates (54) and (55) depends
upon several factors, mostly on the limited representativity
of the sample and precision of estimates τ0 (12). As is seen
from (27), we really evaluate the product qthrτ −2
and q0τ 2
0 ,
and, so, the real precision of both estimates (54) and (55) is
not better than ∼ 20 -- 30% .
As was noted in Sec. 2.4, the redshift distribution of
absorbers with larger qthr is weakly sensitive to small scale
correlations of perturbations and it can be fitted by the ex-
pression (26). Indeed, for samples Q20
14 these dis-
tributions are well fitted by expression (26) with hqthri ≈
0.035 & 0.05, respectively, and the amplitude of the fit is
only ∼ 1.2 -- 1.3 times larger then what is expected in (26).
However, already for the sample Q10
14 the difference between
expected and measured amplitudes of the fit (26) increases
by up to ∼ 1.75 times.
These results show that the actual reliability and pre-
cision of our estimates (55) are limited due to limited repre-
sentativity of the samples and limited precision of estimates
of the amplitude τ0 (12). None the less, they suggest that:
14 and Q50
0
(i) The redshift distribution of absorbers is quite well fit-
ted by relations (26) and (27) derived for the Gaussian initial
perturbations.
(ii) The distribution of weaker absorbers is actually sen-
sitive to the small scale cutoff of power spectrum described
by the parameter q0 ≈ (0.9 ± 0.3) · 10−2 .
(iii) Comparison of estimates (54) with qthr used for the
sample selection indicates that, for weak absorbers with
q ∼ 10−2, the expression (20) with parameters (33) un-
derestimates the DM column density. However, for richer
absorbers the divergence decreases to the quite moderate
value (∼ 10%).
The model as a whole and estimates of q0 can be im-
proved with richer sample of absorbers especially at high
redshifts z ≥ 3.5 where the representativity of our samples
is insufficient. However, as was noted in Songaila (1998) and
Schaye et al. (2000), at z ≥ 3 the random variations of the
UV background and the scatter of hnabsi increase.
7 SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION.
In this paper we continue the analysis initiated in Pa-
per I and Paper II based on the statistical description of
Zel'dovich pancakes (DD99, DD02). This approach allows
to connect the observed characteristics of absorbers with
fundamental properties of the initial perturbations without
any smoothing or filtering procedures, to reveal and to illus-
trate the main tendencies of structure evolution. It demon-
strates also the generic origin of absorbers and the Large
Figure 9. Top panel: redshift distribution of absorbers, nabs(z),
found with fits (50) and (51) (red and green points) for the sample
Q10
14. Fit (27) is plotted by the blue line. Bottom panel: Differences
between measured and fitted absorber distributions.
approach seems to be sufficiently perspective but quantita-
tive results are sample dependent and must be tested with
more representative and homogeneous samples of weak ab-
sorbers.
6.3 Redshift distribution of DM pancakes
14, Q10
14, Q20
14, and Q01
In this Section we consider the redshift distribution of DM
pancakes for the samples Q50
14 prepared
with qthr(z) ≈ const. for parameters (33). For the sample
Q10
14, the function nabs(z) is plotted in Fig. 9 together with
the best fit (27) and the random scatter of observed points
around the fit. At redshifts 1.8 ≤ z ≤ 3.3 where the repre-
sentativity of samples is better the scatter does not exceed
∼ 20% .
mean number density of absorbers
At redshifts z ∼ 1.5 -- 2 the rapid growth of observed
,
(53)
2.7 (cid:17)8
hnabsi ∝ (cid:16) 1 + z
coincides with the expected one (30) and is naturally ex-
plained by the influence of observational threshold NHI ≥
Nthr ≈ 1012cm−2. Such cutoff is not seen for the subpopula-
tion of richer absorbers with NHI ≥ 1014cm−2 what verifies
its connection with the observational threshold. The proba-
ble incompleteness of the sample of weak absorbers at z ≤
1.5 enhances this rapid growth of hnabsi.
The best estimates of the fit parameters (27) for the
samples Q20
14, and Q01
hqthri ≈ (3.3 ± 0.3) · 10−2,
hqthri ≈ (3.1 ± 0.3) · 10−2 ,
and for all three samples
q0 ≈ (0.9 ± 0.1) · 10−2 .
hqthri ≈ (3.1 ± 0.3) · 10−2 ,
14 are, respectively,
14, Q10
(54)
(55)
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
16 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
Scale Structure observed in the spatial galaxy distribution
at small redshifts.
We investigate the new more representative sample of
∼ 4 500 absorbers what allows us to improve the physical
model of absorbers introduced in Paper I and Paper II and
to obtain reasonable description of physical characteristics
of absorbers. The progress achieved demonstrates again the
key role of the representativity of observed samples for the
construction of the physical model of absorbers and reveals
a close connection between conclusions and observational
database.
However, the representativity of this sample is not suf-
ficient for the more detailed study of structure evolution.
Further progress can be achieved with richer sample of ob-
served absorbers.
7.1 Main results
e.g., Songaila 1998; Scott et al. 2000; McDonald & Miralda-
Escude 2001). However, the achieved precision of these esti-
mates is limited. The variations of background temperature
at these redshifts were also detected by Schaye et al. (2000)
and McDonald et al. (2001).
The redshift variations of the mean number density of
weak absorbers discussed in Sec. 6.2 can be naturally related
to such variations caused by the reionization of HeII and pos-
sible variations of activity of quasars and other sources of
UV radiation. They can be enhanced by the incompleteness
and limited representativity of our samples and by the non-
homogeneous redshift distribution of observed absorbers.
However, these variations do not lead to appreciable
variations of the mean absorbers characteristics discussed
in Sec. 4 what indicates the complex character of absorbers
evolution. The problem requires more detailed investigation
using both observations and simulations.
Main results of our analysis can be summarized as follows:
7.3 Properties of absorbers
(i) The approach used in this paper allows to link the ob-
served and other physical characteristics of Ly-α absorbers
such as the overdensity and entropy of the gaseous compo-
nent and the column density of DM component accumulated
by absorbers.
(ii) The basic observed properties of absorbers are quite
successfully described by the statistical model of DM con-
fined structure elements (Zel'dovich pancakes). Comparison
of independent estimates of the DM characteristics of pan-
cakes confirms the self consistency of the physical model for
richer absorbers. However, some characteristics of pancakes
formation and evolution remain uncertain.
(iii) In the framework of this approach, all characteristics
of absorbers can be expressed through two functions, ξ & υ,
describing the systematic and random variations of absorber
properties. They are directly expressed through the observed
parameters, z, NHI & b.
(iv) The main stages of structure evolution are illustrated
by separation of three subpopulations of absorbers with high
and low entropy and low overdensity.
(v) The absorbers with high Doppler parameter, b ≥ 90
km/s, can be naturally identified with the embryos of wall --
like structure elements observed in the spatial distribution
of galaxies at small redshifts.
(vi) The strong suppression of the mean number density
of absorbers at z ≤ 1.8 can be naturally explained by the
influence of the observational threshold NHI ≥ 1012cm−2.
(vii) Redshift distribution of weaker absorbers indicates
the probable systematic redshift variations of the UV back-
ground. They can be caused by the reionization of HeII.
(viii) The PDF of the DM column density and the redshift
distribution of absorbers are consistent with Gaussian initial
perturbations.
(ix) We estimate the spectral moment m0 which in turn
is linked with the cutoff of the power spectrum caused by
the mass of dominant fraction of DM particles and the Jeans
damping.
7.2 Variations of intensity of the UV background
The intensity of the UV background and its variations at
redshifts z ∼ 2 -- 3 were detected by different methods (see,
The physical model of absorbers introduced in Sec.2 links
the measured z, b and lgNHI with other physical charac-
teristics of both gaseous and DM components forming the
observed absorbers. Uncertainties in the available estimates
of the background temperature and UV radiation and un-
known parameters of the model restrict its applications. For-
tunately, actions of these factors partly compensate each
other, what allows us to obtain reasonable statistical de-
scription for majority of absorbers. The self consistency of
this approach is confirmed by two independent estimates
of the column density of DM pancakes. Numerical simula-
tions can clarify action of unknown factors and improve the
model.
Analysis of mean absorbers characteristics performed
in Sec. 4 shows that the sample of observed absorbers is
composed of pancakes with various evolutionary histories.
We discuss five main factors that determine absorbers evo-
lution after formation. They are: the transverse expansion
and compression of pancakes, their merging, the radiative
heating and cooling of compressed gas, and the disruption
of structure elements into a system of high density clouds.
The first two factors change the overdensity of DM and gas
but do not change the gas entropy. Next two factors change
both the gas entropy and overdensity but do not change the
DM characteristics. Using the entropy and overdensity we
can roughly discriminate three subpopulations of absorbers,
illustrate the influence of these factors and correlations be-
tween absorbers characteristics.
Introduction of the reduced Doppler parameter, υ, over-
density, ∆, and entropy, S, allows to discriminate between
the systematic and random variations of absorbers prop-
erties. The former ones are naturally related to the pro-
gressive growth with time of the DM column density of ab-
sorbers, q(z), what can be described theoretically. On the
other hand the action of random factors cannot be sat-
isfactory described by any theoretical model. However, in
the framework of our approach, the reduced parameters are
found to be strongly correlated (41) and, in fact, the joint
action of all random factors is summarized by one random
function, υ, directly expressed through the observed param-
eters (42). These results alleviate the problem of absorbers
description and, perhaps, the modeling of the Ly-α forest
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
based on the simulated DM distribution (Viel et al. 2002).
However, estimates of the matter fraction accumulated by
absorbers (Sec. 4.4) demonstrate that the model needs to be
improved.
Estimates of the size of absorbers (Sec. 4.3) suggest a
possible fast disruption of richer absorbers into a system of
high density clouds, what is the first step of formation of
dwarf galaxies.
7.4 Absorbers as elements of the Large Scale
Structure of the Universe
The close connection of absorbers with the Large Scale
Structure (LSS) of the Universe observed in the spatial
galaxy distribution was demonstrated in numerical simu-
lations and was recently confirmed by direct observations
(Penton, Stocke & Shull 2002). Our results indicate the
generic link of absorbers and DM Zel'dovich pancakes and
demonstrate that the absorbers characteristics are consis-
tent with Gaussian initial perturbations and the Harrison --
Zel'dovich power spectrum. The possible identification of
some absorbers with embryos of walls observed in the galaxy
surveys at small redshifts shows that, perhaps, also a wider
set of richer absorbers could be identified with the LSS ele-
ments at high redshifts.
7.5 Characteristics of the initial power spectrum
The amplitude and the shape of large scale initial power
spectrum are approximately established by investigations of
relic radiation and the structure of the Universe at z ≪ 1
detected in large redshift surveys such as the SDSS (Dodel-
son et al. 2002) and 2dF (Efstathiou et al. 2001). The shape
of small scale initial power spectrum can be tested at high
redshifts where it is not so strongly distorted by nonlinear
evolution (see, e.g., Croft et al. 2002).
Recent discussions on the mass of dominant fraction of
DM component and the shape of small scale initial power
spectrum are focused on the formation of low mass halos
in CDM simulations in comparison with observed low mass
satellites (see, e.g., Colin, Avila-Reese & Valenzuela 2001;
Bode, Ostriker & Turok 2001), and at the simulations of
absorbers formation. Thus, Narayanan et al. (2000) esti-
mate the low limit of this mass as MDM ≥ 0.75 keV, while
Barkana, Haiman & Ostriker (2001) increase this limit up
to MDM ≥ 1 -- 1.25 keV.
Here we can compare these estimates with direct mea-
surements of redshift distribution of absorbers. In fact, our
estimates are related to two spectral moments of the ini-
tial power spectrum, m−2 and m0. The first of them de-
pends mainly upon the large scale power spectrum and was
independently estimated from the measured characteristics
of observed galaxy distribution at small redshifts. Together
with cosmological parameters, Ωm and h, this moment de-
fines the coherent length of initial velocity field, lv, (6),
used in Sec. 2.3 for discussion of properties of DM distri-
bution. The second moment, m0, depends upon the small
scale power spectrum and the shape of transfer function.
This means that the estimates of the mass of DM particles
are model dependent even though our estimates of q0 and
spectral moments are based on the analysis of observations.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
17
Figure 10. Spectral moments, m−2 and m0, and the parame-
ter q0 are plotted vs. MDM for the CDM (red points) and WDM
(blue points) models with the damping factors DW (57) and with
both damping factors, DW & DJ (58) for xJ = (2 & 0.5) · 10−2,
(green points). Black lines show the observational restrictions
(59).
As was shown in DD99 and DD02, for the CDM and
WDM models with the Harrison -- Zel'dovich asymptotic
of power spectrum, p(k) ∝ k, and transfer functions, T (k),
given in Bardeen et al. (1986) the coherent length of ini-
tial density perturbations, lρ, and the parameter q0 can be
written as follows:
q0 = 5
m2
−2
m0
,
m−2 = Z ∞
0
x =
k
k0
,
0.01
lρ = q0lv ≈ 0.34h−1Mpc(cid:16) q0
dx xT 2(x) ≈ 0.023, m0 = Z ∞
k0√m−2
k0 = Ωmh2/Mpc,
lv =
1
0
0.2
Ωmh(cid:17) ,
(56)
dx x3T 2(x) ,
=
6.6
Ωmh2 Mpc ,
where k is the comoving wave number.
For WDM particles the dimensionless damping scale,
Rf , and the damping factor, DW , are
,
Rf = 0.2(cid:18) Ωmh2keV
MDM (cid:19)4/3
DW = exp[−xRf − (xRf )2] ,
(Bardeen et al. 1986). The Jeans wave number, kJ , and the
damping factor, DJ , can be taken as
k−1
J ≈ 0.7bbg(1 + z)H −1(z), DJ ≈ (1 + x2
xJ = k0/kJ ≈ 2 · 10−2r Ωmh2
bbg
0.13 r 4
J x2)−1 ,
16km/s
1 + z
(58)
(57)
,
(see, e.g., Matarrese & Mohayaee 2002).
Variations of the spectral moments and q0 with the
mass of DM particle obtained by integration of the power
spectrum with these damping factors are plotted in Fig.
18 Demia´nski, Doroshkevich & Turchaninov
10 for the CDM and WDM transfer functions and for
xJ = 2 · 10−2 & 0.5 · 10−2. As is seen from this Fig., the
low limit q0 ≥ 0.07√xJ caused by the Jeans damping (58),
restricts the range of masses of DM particles detectable with
this approach to MDM ≤ (3 -- 5)keV.
Our 1σ estimates
q0 ≈ (0.6 − 1.2) · 10−2, m0 ≈ 0.15 − 0.5,
MDM ≈ (1.5 − 5)keV ,
are close to those of Narayanan et al. (2000) and Barkana,
Haiman & Ostriker (2001). They are based on absorbers
with the redshifts z ≤ 3.5 where the scatter of measured
nabs is minimal and, so, they weakly depend upon both the
Doppler parameter and velocities of absorbers which essen-
tially distort nabs at higher redshifts (Sec. 4.4).
(59)
There are plenty of possible candidates for the WDM
particles with the mass ∼ 1 keV. They are, for example, the
sterile neutrinos, majorons and even shadow particles. De-
tailed review of possible candidates can be found in Sommer-
Larsen & Dolgov (2001) and Dolgov (2002). However, our
estimates use the spectral moments and therefore do not
forbid the existence of multicomponent heavy DM particles
with both thermal and non-thermal (Lin et al. 2001) distri-
butions with the same spectral moments m−2 and m0.
7.6 Reheating of the Universe
Recent observations of high redshift quasars with z ≥ 5
(Djorgovski et al. 2001; Becker et al. 2001; Pentericci et al.
2001; Fan et al. 2001) demonstrate clear evidences in fa-
vor of the reionization of the Universe at redshifts z ∼ 6
when the volume averaged fraction of neutral hydrogen
is found to be fH ≥ 10−3 and the photoionization rate
Γγ ∼ (0.2 − 0.8) · 10−13s−1 . These results are consistent
with those expected at the end of the reionization epoch
which probably takes place at z ∼ 6. Extrapolation of the
mean separation of absorbers discussed in Sec. 4.4 is consis-
tent with these conclusions.
These results can be compared with expectations of the
Zel'dovich approximation (DD02) for q0 = 10−2. The poten-
tial of this approach is limited since it cannot describe the
nonlinear stages of structure formation and, so, it cannot
substitute the high resolution numerical simulations. How-
ever, it describes quite well many observed and simulated
statistical characteristics of the structure such as the red-
shift distribution of absorbers and evolution of their DM
column density. This approach does not depend on the box
size, number of points and other limitations of numerical
simulations and it successfully augments them.
This approach allows to estimate the fractions of DM
component accumulated by high density clouds, fcl, fila-
ments, ff , and pancakes, fpan, at different redshifts. These
functions plotted in Fig. 11 for q0 = 10−2 show that at z ∼ 6
only ∼ 3.5% of the matter is condensed within the high den-
sity clouds which can be associated with luminous objects.
This value can increase up to ∼ 5 -- 6% with more correct
description of the clouds collapse. At the same redshifts,
∼ 27% and ∼ 12% of the matter can be already accumulated
by pancakes and filaments, respectively. These expectations
are smaller than estimates of hfabsi obtained in Sec. 4.4 .
The Zel'dovich approximation allows also to estimate
Figure 11. Top panel: expected redshift variations of the DM
fraction accumulated by high density clouds, filaments and pan-
cakes (red, green and blue lines), respectively, at q0 = 10−2. Bot-
tom panel: the expected mass function of the DM clouds at z = 6
and q0 = 10−2.
the mass function of all structure elements (DD02) at dif-
ferent redshifts. For q0 = 10−2 and at z ∼ 6, this function is
plotted in Fig. 11. For these q0 and z, the mean DM mass of
structure elements is expected to be ∼ 1012M⊙ and the main
mass is concentrated within clouds with Mcl ∼ 0.1hMcli. As
is seen from Fig. 11, majority of the clouds have mass be-
tween 10−3hMcli and 10 hMcli. The formation of low mass
clouds with Mcl ≤ 109M⊙ is suppressed due to strong cor-
relation of the initial density and velocity fields at scales
≤ lρ ∼ 0.3h−1 Mpc (56). However, the numerous low mass
satellites of large central galaxies can be formed in the course
of disruption of massive collapsed clouds at the stage of their
compression into thin pancake -- like objects (Doroshkevich
1980; Vishniac 1983). The minimal mass of such satellites
was estimated in Barkana, Haiman & Ostriker (2001).
This means that the investigation of absorbers observed
at high redshifts should be supplemented by the study of
properties of dwarf isolated galaxies and discrimination be-
tween such galaxies and dwarf satellites of more massive
galaxies. It seems to be a perspective way to discriminate
between models with the Jeans damping (58) and the damp-
ing caused by the mass of WDM particles, (57), and, in par-
ticular, between models with one and several types of DM
particles.
Acknowledgments
AGD is grateful to Dr. S. Cristiani and Dr. T.S.Kim for
the permission to use the unpublished observational data.
This paper was supported in part by Denmark's Grund-
forskningsfond through its support for an establishment of
Theoretical Astrophysics Center and by the Polish State
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
Characteristics of Ly-α forest
19
Kim T.S., Cristiani S., & D'Odorico S., 2002, A&A, in press,
astro-ph/0201204
Kim T.S., Carswell R.F., Cristiani S., D'Odorico S. & Gial-
longo E., 2002, MNRAS, in press, astro-ph/0205237
Kirkman D., & Tytler D., 1997, ApJ., 484, 672.
Kulkarni V.P. et al., 1996, MNRAS, 279, 197
Lanzetta K.M., Bowen D.V., Tytler D., & Webb J.K., 1995, ApJ.,
442, 538.
Le Brune V., Bergeron J., & Boisse P., 1996, A&A, 306, 691
Lin W.B., Huang D.H., Zhang X., Brandenberger R., 2001,
Phys.Rev.Lett. 86, 954
Lu L., Sargent W.L.W., Womble D.S., Takada-Hidai M., 1996,
ApJ., 472, 509
Matarrese S. & Mohayaee R., 2002, MNRAS, 329, 37
McDonald P. et al., 2000, ApJ., 543, 1
McDonald P. & Miralda-Escude J., 2001, ApJ., 549, L11
McDonald P. et al., 2001, ApJ., 562, 52
McGill C., 1990, MNRAS, 242, 544
Narayanan V. et al., 2000, ApJ., 543, L103
Oort J.H., 1981, Astr.Astrophys., 94, 359.
Oort J.H., 1984, Astr.Astrophys., 139, 211.
Pentericci L. et al., 2001, astro-ph/0112075
Penton S.V., Stocke J.T., & Shull J.M, 2002, ApJ., 565, 720
Rauch M., 1998, Ann.Rev.Astr.Astrophys., 36, 267
Rodriguez-Pascual P.M., de la Fuente A., 1995, ApJ., 448, 575.
Sargent, W.L.W., Young, P.J., Boksenberg, A. & Tytler, D., 1980,
Ap.J.Suppl, 42, 41
Schaye J., Theuns T., Leonard A. & Efstathiou G., 1999, MN-
RAS, 310, 57
Schaye J.et al., 2000, MNRAS, 318, 817
Scott J., Bechtold J., Dobrzicki A. & Kulkarni V.P., 2000, ApJ-
Supl, 130, 67
Shandarin S., Zel'dovich Ya.B., 1989, Rev.Mod.Phys., 61, 185
Shandarin S. et al., 1995, Phys.Rev.Let., 75, 7
Shectman S.A. et al., 1996, ApJ., 470, 172.
Sommer-Larsen J. & Dolgov A., 2001, ApJ., 551, 608
Songaila A., 1998, AJ., 115, 2184
Stoughton C. et al., 2001, AJ., 123, 485
Theuns T., Leonard A., Schaye J., Efstathiou G., 1999, MNRAS,
303, L58
Theuns T., Schaye J., Zaroubi S., Kim T.-S., Tzanavaris P., &
Carswell R., 2002a, ApJ, 567, L103
Theuns T., Zaroubi S., Kim T.-S., Tzanavaris P., & Carswell R.,
2002b, MNRAS, 332, 367
Tytler D., 1995, in Meylan J., ed., QSO Absorption Lines, p. 289.
Viel M., Matarrese S., Mo J.H., Theuns T., Haehnelt M.G., 2002,
MNRAS, 329, 848
Vishniac E.T., 1983, ApJ., 274, 152
Weinberg D.H., Burles S., Croft R.A.C., et al., 1998, in "Evolution
of Large Scale Structure: From Recombination to Garching",
eds. A.J. Banday, R.K. Sheth, L.N. Da Costa, p. 346
Zaldarriaga M., Scoccimarro R., Hui L., 2001, astro-ph/0111230
Zel'dovich Ya.B., 1970, Astrophysica, 5, 20
Zeng W., Davidsen A.F., & Kriss G.A., 1998, AJ, 115, 391
Zhang Yu., Meiksin A., Anninos P., Norman M.L., 1998, ApJ.,
495, 63
Committee for Scientific Research grant Nr. 2-P03D-014-17.
AGD also wishes to acknowledge support from the Center
of Cosmo-Particle Physics, Moscow. Furthermore, we wish
to thank the anonymous referee for valuable discussion and
many useful comments.
REFERENCES
Bahcall J.N. et al., 1993, ApJS., 87, 1.
Bahcall J.N. et al., 1996, ApJ., 457, 19.
Bardeen J.M., Bond J.R., Kaiser N., Szalay A., 1986, ApJ., 304,
15
Barkana R., Haiman Z., Ostriker J.P., 2001, ApJ., 558, 482
Becker R.H. et al. 2001, AJ, 122, 2850
Bergeron J., Cristiani S., & Shaver P.A., 1992, A&A, 257, 417
Bi H., & Davidsen A.F., 1997, ApJ., 479, 523
Black J.H., 1981, MNRAS, 197, 553
Bode P., Ostriker J.P. & Turok N, 2001, ApJ., 556, 93
Bond R., Wadsley J.W., 1997, in "Structure and Evolution of the
IGM from QSO Absorption Line Systems", Eds. P.Petitjean,
S.Charlot, Editions Frontiers, Paris, p. 143
Choudhury R., Padmanabhan T. & Srianand R., 2001, MNRAS,
322, 561
Choudhury R., Srianand R. & Padmanabhan T., 2001, ApJ, 559,
29
Coles P., Melott A., & Shandarin S., 1993, MNRAS, 289, 37
Colin P., Avila-Reese V., & Valenzuela O., 2001, ApJ., 542, 622
Cristiani S., D'Odorico V., 2000, AJ, 120, 1648
Croft R.A.C., Weinberg D.H., Katz N., & Hernquist L., 1998,
ApJ., 495, 44
Croft R.A.C. et al., 2001, ApJ., 557, 67
Croft R.A.C. et al., 2002, astro-ph/00132324
Dav´e R., Hernquist L., Katz N., Weinberg D.H., 1999, ApJ., 511,
521,
Demia´nski M. & Doroshkevich A., 1999, MNRAS., 306, 779,
(DD99).
Demia´nski M., Doroshkevich A.G., Muller V., & Turchani-
nov V.I., 2000, MNRAS, 318, 665
Demia´nski M., Doroshkevich A.G., & Turchaninov V.I., 2001,
MNRAS, 318, 1177, (Paper I)
Demia´nski M., Doroshkevich A.G., & Turchaninov V.I., 2001,
MNRAS, 318, 1189, (Paper II)
Demia´nski M. & Doroshkevich A., 2002, astro-ph/0206282,
(DD02)
Djorgovski S.G., Castro S., Stern D., Mahabal A.A., 2001, ApJ.,
560, L5
Dodelson S. et al., 2002, ApJ, 572, 140
Dolgov A., 2002, Phys.Rep., in press, hep=ph/0202122
Doroshkevich, A.G., 1980, SvA., 24, 152
Doroshkevich, A.G., Tucker, D.L. & Allam S., 2002, astro-
ph/0206301
Efstathiou G. et al., 2001, astro-ph/0109152
Fan X. et al., 2001, astro-ph/0111184, ApJ., in press
Gnedin N.Y. & Hui L., 1996, ApJ, 472, L73
Gnedin N.Y. & Hamilton A.J.S., 2002, MNRAS, 334, 107
Giallongo E., Cristiani S., Fontana A., & Trevese D., 1993, ApJ.,
416, 137
Hu E.M., Tae-Sun K., Cowie L., & Songaila A., 1995, AJ, 110,
1526
Hui L., Gnedin N.Y., 1997, MNRAS, 292, 27
Hui L., Gnedin N.Y. & Zhang Yu., 1997, ApJ, 486, 599
Hui L., Rutledge R.E., 1999, ApJ, 517, 541
Ikeuchi S., Ostriker J.P, 1986, ApJ., 301, 522.
Jannuzi B.T. et al. ApJS. 1998, 118, 1
Jacobsen P., et al. 1994, Nature, 370, 35
Khare P. et al., Bechtold J., 1997, MNRAS, 285, 167.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
|
0810.4538 | 1 | 0810 | 2008-10-24T20:00:05 | Report of IAU Commission 30 on Radial Velocities (2006-2009) | [
"astro-ph"
] | Brief summaries are given on the following subjects: Radial velocities and exoplanets (Toward Earth-mass planets; Retired A stars and their planets; Current status and prospects); Toward higher radial velocity precision; Radial velocities and asteroseismology; Radial velocities in Galactic and extragalactic clusters; Radial velocities for field giants; Galactic structure -- Large surveys (The Geneva-Copenhagen Survey; Sloan Digital Sky Survey; RAVE); Working groups (WG on radial velocity standards; WG on stellar radial velocity bibliography; WG on the catalogue of orbital elements of spectroscopic binaries [SB9]). | astro-ph | astro-ph | Transactions IAU, Volume XXVIIA
Reports on Astronomy 2006-2009
Karel A. van der Hucht, ed.
c(cid:13) 2009 International Astronomical Union
DOI: 00.0000/X000000000000000X
COMMISSION 30
RADIAL VELOCITIES
PRESIDENT
VICE-PRESIDENT
PAST PRESIDENT
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
VITESSES RADIALES
Stephane Udry
Guillermo Torres
Birgitta Nordstrom
Francis C. Fekel,
Kenneth C. Freeman,
Elena V. Glushkova,
Geoffrey W. Marcy,
Birgitta Nordstrom,
Robert D. Mathieu,
Dimitri Pourbaix,
Catherine Turon,
Tomaz Zwitter
COMMISSION 30 WORKING GROUPS
Div. IX / Commission 30 WG
Div. IX / Commission 30 WG
Div. IX / Commission 30 WG
Radial-Velocity Standard Stars
Stellar Radial Velocity Bibliography
Catalogue of Orbital Elements of
Spectroscopic Binaries
TRIENNIAL REPORT 2006 -- 2009
1. Introduction
This three-year period has seen considerable activity in the Commission, with a wide
range of applications of radial velocities as well as a significant push toward higher
precision. The latter has been driven in large part by the exciting research on extrasolar
planets. This field is now on the verge of detecting Earth-mass bodies around nearby
stars, as demonstrated by recent work summarized below, and radial velocities continue
to play a central role.
This is not to say that classical applications of RVs have lagged behind. On the con-
trary, this triennium has seen the release of several very large data sets of stellar radial
velocities (Galactic and extragalactic) that are sure to have a significant impact on a
number of fields for years to come. The era of mass-producing radial velocities has ar-
rived. Examples include the Geneva-Copenhagen Survey, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey,
and RAVE, and are described below.
Due to circumstances beyond our control, the report of Commission 30 for the previous
(2003 -- 2006) triennium did not appear in the printed version of the Transactions of the
IAU, although it did appear in the electronic version. For progress during the previous
period, the reader is therefore encouraged to consult the latter, which is available from
the Commission web site.
1
8
0
0
2
t
c
O
4
2
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
8
3
5
4
.
0
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
2
DIVISION IX / COMMISSION 30
2. Radial velocities and exoplanets
By G. Torres and J. Johnson
2.1. Toward Earth-mass planets
Detections of Jupiter-mass exoplanets by the radial-velocity method relying on measure-
ments with precisions of a few m s−1 are now quite routine. This technique has provided
by far the majority of the more than 300 planet discoveries to date. The persistence
of astronomers and the increasing precision of their instruments has led to larger and
larger numbers of multi-planet systems being found. One example is the interesting case
of µ Arae (Pepe et al. 2007), with four planets, one of which is as small as 10.5 MEarth.
The host star also presents the signature of p-mode oscillations seen clearly in the radial
velocities. The record-holder for the most planets is the star 55 Cnc, which is orbited
by no less than five planets (Fischer et al. 2008), of which the smallest has a minimum
mass of 10.8 MEarth. Exciting discoveries during this period made possible by the high
precision and stability of the HARPS instrument on the ESO 3.6-m telescope at La Silla
(Chile) include the system Gls 581 (at only 6.3 pc), attended by at least three planets.
In addition to the previously known Neptune-mass body orbiting the star with a period
of 5.3 days, two other low mass planets were found by Udry et al. (2007) with minimum
masses of only 5 MEarth (period 12.9 days) and 7.7 MEarth, the latter being near the outer
edge of the habitable zone of the M3V parent star (period 83.6 days). The three-planet
orbital solution for this case has an rms residual of only 1.2 m s−1. Another system with
three low-mass planets was announced by Mayor et al. (2008) around the nearby (13 pc)
metal-poor K2V star HD 40307. The planets weighed in at 4.2, 6.9, and 9.2 MEarth, and
the three-planet Keplerian orbital fit gave impressive residuals of just 0.85 m s−1. HARPS
has demonstrated that this sort of velocity precision is achievable for "quiet" stars that
present a low level of "jitter" in their radial velocities due to astrophysical phenomena
such as p-mode oscillations, granulation, or chromospheric activity. Indications are that
Neptune-mass or smaller planets are more common around solar-type (F -- K) stars than
previously thought (see, e.g., Mayor & Udry 2008).
2.2. Retired A stars and their planets
Most Doppler searches for planets have concentrated on main sequence stars of spec-
tral types F or later, because the velocity precision for earlier type stars is seriously
compromised by line broadening induced by rapid rotation, as well as the overall fewer
number of spectral lines available. This difficulty in studying higher-mass stars intro-
duces a bias in our understanding of planets, but it can be overcome by looking at such
stars after they have left the main sequence. This is precisely the approach of an on-
going project to investigate the relationship between stellar mass and planet formation
by using the HIRES instrument on the Keck 10-m telescope to search for planets in
a sample of 240 intermediate-mass subgiants (1.3 < M∗/M⊙ < 2.2). Subgiants have
lower surface temperatures and rotational velocities than their main-sequence progen-
itors, making them ideal proxies for A- and F-type stars in Doppler studies. From a
smaller sample of subgiants observed previously by Johnson et al. (2007a) at Lick Ob-
servatory for 4 years with a typical velocity precision of 4 m s−1, a strong correlation was
detected between stellar mass and planet occurrence, with a detection rate of 9% within
2.5 AU among the high-mass sample, compared to 4.5% for Sun-like stars and less than
2% for M dwarfs. A paucity of planets within 1 AU of stars with masses greater than
1.5 M⊙ was found, indicating that stellar mass also plays a key role in planet migration
(Johnson et al. 2007b, Johnson et al. 2008). The goal of the expanded Keck survey (with
RADIAL VELOCITIES
3
an increased velocity precision of about 2 m s−1) is to map out the relationships between
stellar mass and exoplanet properties in greater detail by examining the distribution of
planetary minimum masses, eccentricities, semimajor axes, and the rate of multiplicity
around evolved A stars. If the 9% occurrence rate is confirmed, some 20 -- 30 new planets
should be found in the sample orbiting some of the most massive stars so far examined
by the Doppler technique.
2.3. Current status and prospects
In May of 2008 NASA convened the Exoplanet Forum 2008, a meeting of experts from the
US and other countries in eight different observational techniques related to exoplanet re-
search. The purpose was to discuss paths forward for exploring and characterizing planets
around other stars, and to provide specific suggestions for space missions, technology de-
velopment, and observing programmes that could fulfill the recommendations of a previ-
ously held meeting of the Exoplanet Task Force (http://www.nsf.gov/mps/ast/exoptf.jsp).
The reports resulting from these meetings are intended to provide input for considera-
tion by various advisory committees in the US, and in particular by the Astronomy and
Astrophysics Decadal Survey that is currently underway.
Radial velocities was one of the eight techniques considered by the Exoplanet Forum
2008. The corresponding chapter of the report, available at
http://exep.jpl.nasa.gov/exep exfCommunityReport.cfm ,
summarized the progress in the field over the last few years, which is illustrated by a veloc-
ity precision of 1 m s−1 or slightly better achieved so far, led by the Swiss team using the
HARPS instrument on the ESO 3.6-m telescope, and the California-Carnegie team using
the HIRES instrument on the Keck 10-m telescope. The factors currently limiting the pre-
cision were discussed briefly and have been described in detail by Pepe & Lovis (2007).
They include various sources of astrophysical noise (stellar oscillations, granulation, mag-
netic cycles, collectively known as "stellar jitter"), guiding, the illumination of the spec-
trograph, and the wavelength reference. Good progress has been made in each of these
areas. For example, it appears that jitter can be substantially reduced through longer
exposures or binning, to the level of perhaps 10 cm s−1 or less. A new thorium-argon line
list was developed by Lovis & Pepe (2007) that significantly improves the velocity pre-
cision when using this source as the wavelength reference. Further improvements in the
velocity precision perhaps reaching a few cm s−1 appear possible using a dense spectrum
of lines generated by a femtosecond-pulsed laser ("laser comb"), described in more detail
below. The next few years will tell whether this promise can be realized in practice.
The report of the Exoplanet Forum also described recent progress in techniques to mea-
sure precise velocities in the near infrared (see, e.g., Ramsey et al. 2008), which are now
approaching the 10 m s−1 level in initial tests. Longer wavelengths potentially provide a
significant advantage for the Doppler detection of very small (even Earth-mass) planets,
since these objects produce a larger signal when orbiting less massive stars, which emit
most of their flux in the near infrared.
In addition to velocity precision, the report pointed out what is currently considered
by the community to be the greatest challenge for making progress in the detection of
exoplanets by the Doppler technique: the limited access to telescope time. This has a
direct impact not only on the size of the samples of solar-type stars that can be studied,
but also severely restricts the number of late-type (faint) stars that can be targeted
to search for Earth-mass planets. The need for exposure times longer than dictated
by Poisson statistics to reduce stellar jitter, as mentioned above, is a further strain
4
DIVISION IX / COMMISSION 30
on the limited resources currently available on telescopes equipped with high-precision
spectrographs.
3. Toward higher radial velocity precision
By G. Torres
During this period agreement has been reached for the construction of an improved
copy of the very successful HARPS spectrograph, currently in operation at the ESO
3.6-m telescope at La Silla, for the northern hemisphere (HARPS-NEF). This is a high-
resolution (R ≈ 120,000) fibre-fed optical spectrograph with broad wavelength coverage
(3780 -- 6910 A) designed for high radial velocity precision. HARPS-NEF is a collabora-
tion between the New Earths Facility (NEF) scientists of the Harvard Origins of Life
Initiative and the HARPS team at the Geneva Observatory. It is expected to be the
workhorse for follow-up of transiting planet candidates for NASA's Kepler mission, and
should be operational perhaps in late 2010. HARPS-NEF is a cross-dispersed echelle
spectrograph that will benefit not only from updates and improvements over the original
HARPS instrument, but in addition it will be installed on a larger telescope aperture in
the northern hemisphere (the 4.2-m William Herschel Telescope on La Palma, Canary
Islands). It is designed for ultra-high stability (10 -- 20 cm s−1), and like HARPS it will
be placed in a vacuum chamber with careful temperature control.
One of the key factors that determine the precision of the RVs is the wavelength ref-
erence. Existing technologies in the optical (such as the Th-Ar technique and iodine gas
absorption cell) have already reached sub-m s−1 precision in some cases, but further
improvements are needed if the Doppler method is to reach cm s−1, as is needed to de-
tect terrestrial-mass planets. A new technology that has emerged in the last few years
and that holds great promise for providing a very stable reference is that of laser "fre-
quency combs". As the name suggests, a frequency comb generated from mode-locked
femtosecond-pulsed lasers provides a spectrum of very narrow emission lines with a con-
stant frequency separation given by the pulse repetition frequency, typically 1 GHz for
this application. This frequency can be synchronized with an extremely precise reference
such as an atomic clock. For example, using the generally available Global Position-
ing System (GPS), the frequencies of comb lines have long-term fractional stability and
accuracy of better than 10−12. This is more than enough to measure velocity varia-
tions at a photon-limited precision level of 1 cm s−1 in astronomical objects (see, e.g.,
Murphy et al. 2007). This direct link with GPS as the reference allows the comparison
of measurements not only between different instruments, but potentially also over long
periods of time. To provide lines with separations that are well matched to the resolv-
ing powers of commonly used echelle spectrographs, a recent improvement incorporates
a Fabry-P´erot filtering cavity that increases the comb line spacing to ∼40 GHz over a
range greater than 1000 A (Li et al. 2008). Prototypes using a titanium-doped sapphire
solid-state laser have been built that provide a reference centreed around 8500 A. In
practice, of course, Doppler measurements are also affected by other instrumental prob-
lems, so that the value of this new technology for highly precise RV measurements is still
to be demonstrated. Tests have been initiated during this triennium. Plans call also for
the installation of a laser comb on the HARPS-NEF spectrograph described above. Ap-
plications of this technique are not limited to stars. For example, a direct measurement
of the expansion of the Universe could be made by observing in real time the evolu-
tion of the cosmological redshift of distant objects such as quasars. Such a measurement
RADIAL VELOCITIES
5
would require a precision in determining Doppler drifts of ∼1 cm s−1 per year (see, e.g.,
Steinmetz et al. 2008), which a laser comb can in principle deliver.
4. Radial velocities and asteroseismology
By G. Torres
The significant increase in the precision of velocity measurements over the past few
years, driven by exoplanet searches, has enabled important studies of the internal consti-
tution of stars through the technique of asteroseismology. A number of spectrographs now
reach the precision needed for this type of investigation. During this period Bedding et al. (2006)
observed the metal-poor subgiant star ν Ind with the UCLES instrument on the 3.9-m
Anglo-Australian Telescope, and with the CORALIE spectrograph on the 1.2-m Swiss
telescope at ESO. The precision of those measurements ranged from 5.9 to 9.5 m s−1,
and allowed the authors to place constraints on the stellar parameters confirming that
the star has a low mass and an old age. This was the first application of asteroseis-
mology to a metal-poor star. α Cen A was observed by Bazot et al. (2007) with the
HARPS spectrometer on the ESO 3.6-m telescope, and 34 p modes were identified in the
acoustic oscillation spectrum of the star. Individual observations had errors well under
1 m s−1. A similar study by Mosser et al. (2008a) was conducted on Procyon (α CMi)
using the SOPHIE spectrograph on the 1.9-m telescope at the Haute-Provence Observa-
tory, yielding a precision of about 2 m s−1. The HARPS instrument was used again by
Mosser et al. (2008b) to study the old Galactic disk, low-metallicity star HD 203608. A
total of 15 oscillation modes were identified, and the age of the star was determined to
be 7.25 ± 0.07 Gyr.
5. Radial velocities in Galactic and extragalactic clusters
By E. V. Glushkova, H. Levato, and G. Torres
Searches for spectroscopic binaries in southern open clusters have continued during
this period (e.g., Gonz´alez & Levato 2006). These authors have reported results for the
open cluster Blanco 1. Forty four stars previously mentioned in the literature as cluster
candidates, plus an additional 25 stars in a wider region around the cluster were observed
repeatedly during 5 years. Six new spectroscopic binaries have been detected and their
orbits determined. All of them are single-lined spectroscopic systems with periods ranging
from 1.9 to 1572 days. When considering also all suspected binaries, the spectroscopic
binary frequency in this cluster amounts to 34%. Additional velocities were measured in
this cluster by Mermilliod et al. (2008a), who obtained a rather similar binary frequency.
Results from long term radial velocity studies based on the CORAVEL spectrome-
ters have been presented during this period for the open clusters NGC 6192, 6208, and
6268 (Clari´a et al. 2006), as well as for NGC 2112, 2204, 2243, 2420, 2506, and 2682
(Mermilliod & Mayor 2007). These studies were complemented with photometric obser-
vations in a variety of systems, and included membership determination and binary stud-
ies. A number of new spectroscopic binaries were discovered, and their orbital elements
were determined.
Other individual cluster studies in the Milky Way, which we merely reference here
without giving the details due to space limitations, include: IC 2361 (Platais et al. 2007),
NGC 2489 (Piatti et al. 2007), α Per (Mermilliod et al. 2008b), the five distant open clus-
ters Ru 4, Ru 7, Be 25, Be 73 and Be 75 (Carraro et al. 2007), Tombaugh 2 (Frinchaboy et al. 2008),
6
DIVISION IX / COMMISSION 30
the Orion Nebula cluster (Fur´esz et al. 2008), the most massive Milky way open clus-
ter Westerlund 1 (Mengel & Tacconi-Garman 2008), the Galactic centre star cluster
(Trippe et al. 2008), and the globular clusters M4 (Sommariva et al. 2008) and ω Cen
(Da Costa & Matthew 2008).
This triennium saw the publication of the final results of the 20-year efforts of J.-C.
Mermilliod and colleagues to measure the radial velocities of giant stars in open clusters
for a variety of studies related to their kinematics, membership, and photometric and
spectroscopic properties. A catalogue of spectroscopic orbits for 156 binaries based on
more than 4000 individual velocities was published by Mermilliod et al. (2007), based on
measurements from CORAVEL and the CfA Digital Speedometers. Orbital periods range
from 41 days to more than 40 years, and eccentricities are as high as e = 0.81. Another
133 spectroscopic binaries were discovered but do not have sufficient observations and/or
time coverage to determine orbital elements. This material provides a dramatic increase
in the body of homogeneous orbital data available for red-giant spectroscopic binaries in
open clusters, and should form the basis for a comprehensive discussion of membership,
kinematics, and stellar and tidal evolution in the parent clusters. A companion catalogue
(Mermilliod et al. 2008c) reports mean radial velocities for 1309 red giants in clusters
based on 10,517 individual measurements, and mean radial velocities for 166 open clus-
ters among which 57 are new. This information, combined with recent absolute proper
motions, will permit a number of investigations of the galactic distribution and space
motions of a large sample of open clusters.
Frinchaboy & Majewski (2008) reported on a survey of the chemical and dynamical
properties of the Milky Way disk as traced by open star clusters. They used medium-
resolution spectroscopy (R ≈ 15,000) with the Hydra multi-object spectrographs on the
Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory 4-m and WIYN 3.5-m telescopes to derive mod-
erately high-precision RVs (σ < 3 km s−1) for 3436 stars in the fields of 71 open clusters
within 3 kpc of the Sun. Along with the work described in the preceding paragraph, these
represent the largest samples of clusters assembled thus far having uniformly determined,
high-precision radial velocities.
A good deal of activity focused on kinematic analyses of globular cluster (GC) systems
in other galaxies. Lee et al. (2008a) measured radial velocities for 748 GC candidates in
M31, and Lee et al. (2008b) obtained radial velocities of 111 objects in the field of M60.
Konstantopoulos et al. (2008) obtained new spectroscopic observations of the stellar clus-
ter population of region B in the prototype starburst galaxy M82. Schuberth et al. (2006)
presented the first dynamical study of the GC system of NGC 4636 based on radial ve-
locities for 174 clusters. Bridges et al. (2006) measured radial velocities of 38 GCs in the
Virgo elliptical galaxy M60, and Bridges et al. (2007) obtained new velocities for 62 GCs
in M104.
An interesting problem was discussed by Abt(2008), pointing to a possible bias in the
RVs of many B-type stars. The author looked at 10 open clusters younger than about 30
million years with sufficient numbers of measured radial velocities, many of them being
measured with CORAVEL, and found that in each case, the main-sequence B0 -- B3 stars
have larger velocities than earlier- or later-type stars.
6. Radial velocities for field giants
By G. Torres
A programme to measure precise radial velocities for 179 giant stars has been on-
going at the Lick Observatory, with individual errors of 5 -- 8 m s−1 per measurement
RADIAL VELOCITIES
7
(Hekker et al. 2006). This study presented a list of 34 stable K giants (with RV stan-
dard deviations under 10 m s−1) suitable to serve as reference stars for NASA's Space
Interferometry Mission. A follow-up paper (Hekker et al. 2008) reported that 80% of the
stars monitored show velocity variations at a level greater than 20 m s−1, of which 43
exhibit significant periodicities. One of the goals was to investigate possible mechanisms
that cause these variations. A complex correlation was found between the amplitude of
the changes and the surface gravity of the star, in which part of the variation is periodic
and uncorrelated with log g, and another component is random and does correlate with
surface gravity.
Massarotti et al. (2008) reported radial velocities made with the CfA Digital Speedome-
ters for a sample of 761 giant stars, selected from the Hipparcos Catalogue to lie within
100 pc. Rotational velocities and other spectroscopic parameters were determined as well.
Orbital elements were presented for 35 single-lined spectroscopic binaries and 12 double-
lined binaries. These systems were used to investigate stellar rotation in field giants to
look for evidence of excess rotation that could be attributed to planets that were engulfed
as the parent stars expanded.
7. Galactic structure -- Large surveys
By B. Nordstrom and G. Torres
7.1. The Geneva-Copenhagen Survey
During the previous 3-year period one of the mayor surveys completed and published
is the Geneva-Copenhagen Survey of the Solar Neighbourhood (Nordstrom et al. 2004).
Unfortunately the full description of this project and the important new science results
that came out of it did not make it into the printed version of the Transactions of the
IAU for 2003 -- 2006, so we summarize and update that information here for its significant
impact for the study of Galactic structure. This survey provided accurate, multi-epoch
radial velocities for a magnitude-complete, all-sky sample of 14,000 F and G dwarfs down
to a brightness limit of V = 8.5, and is volume complete to about 40 pc. The catalogue in-
cludes new mean radial velocities for 13,464 stars with typical mean errors of 0.25 km s−1,
based on 63,000 individual observations made mostly with the CORAVEL photoelectric
cross-correlation spectrometers covering both hemispheres. Studies of this rich data set
have found evidence for dynamical substructures that are probably due to dynamical
perturbations induced by spiral arms and perhaps the Galactic bar. These "dynamical
streams" (Famaey et al. 2005) contain stars of different ages and metallicities which do
not seem to have a common origin. These features, which dominate the observed U ,V ,W
diagrams, make the conventional two-Gaussian decomposition of nearby stars into thin
and thick disk members a highly dubious procedure. An analysis by Helmi et al. (2006)
suggests that tidal debris from merged satellite galaxies may be found even in the solar
neighbourhood.
A new release of this large catalogue with updated calibrations as well as new age and
metallicity determinations was published during the present triennium by Holmberg et al. (2007),
and is available from the CDS at
http://cdsweb.u-strasbg.fr/cgi-bin/qcat?J/A+A/475/51 .
A follow-up paper and catalogue are expected to be available shortly, containing new
kinematic data (U V W velocities) resulting from a re-analysis using the revised Hipparcos
parallaxes (van Leeuwen 2007), and online updates.
8
DIVISION IX / COMMISSION 30
7.2. Sloan Digital Sky Survey
This period saw the sixth data release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Adelman-McCarthy et al. 2008),
which now covers an area of 9583 square degrees on the sky. This release includes nearly
1.1 million spectra of galaxies, quasars, and stars with sufficient signal to be usable,
along with redshift determinations, as well as effective temperature, surface gravity, and
metallicity determinations for many stars. The spectra cover the wavelength region 3800 --
9200 A at a resolving power ranging from 1850 to 2200. Velocity precisions range from
about 9 km s−1 for A and F stars to about 5 km s−1 for K stars. The zero point of
the velocities is in the process of being calibrated using spectra from the ELODIE spec-
trograph. These data are a valuable resource for a variety of investigations related to
Galactic structure and the evolution and history of the Milky Way.
7.3. RAVE
The second data release of the Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE) was published dur-
ing this triennium (Zwitter et al. 2008). This is an ambitious spectroscopic survey to
measure radial velocities as well as stellar atmosphere parameters (effective temperature,
metallicity, surface gravity, rotational velocity) of up to one million stars using the 6dF
multi-object spectrograph on the 1.2-m UK Schmidt telescope of the Anglo-Australian
Observatory. The RAVE programme started in 2003, obtaining medium resolution spec-
tra (median R = 7500) in the Ca II triplet region (8410 -- 8795 A) for southern hemisphere
stars drawn from the Tycho-2 and SuperCOSMOS catalogues, in the magnitude range
9 < I < 12. Following the first data release, the current release doubles the sample of
published radial velocities, now reaching 51,829 measurements for 49,327 individual stars
observed between 2003 and 2005. Comparison with external data sets indicates that the
new data collected since April 2004 show a standard deviation of 1.3 km s−1, about twice
as good as for the first data release. For the first time, this data release contains values
of stellar parameters from 22,407 spectra of 21,121 individual stars. The data release
includes proper motions from the STARNET 2.0, Tycho-2, and UCAC2 catalogues, and
photometric measurements from Tycho-2, USNO-B, DENIS, and 2MASS. The data can
be accessed via the RAVE web site at
http://www.rave-survey.org .
Scientific uses of these data include the identification and study of the current structure
of the Galaxy and of remnants of its formation, recent accretion events, as well as the
discovery of individual peculiar objects and spectroscopic binary stars. For example, kine-
matic information derived from the RAVE data set has been used by Smith et al. (2007)
to constrain the Galactic escape velocity at the solar radius to Vesc = 536+58
−44 km s−1
(90% confidence).
8. Working groups
Below are the progress reports of the three active working groups of Commission 30.
Their efforts are focused on providing a service to the astronomical community at large
through the compilation of a variety of information related to radial velocities.
By S. Udry
8.1. WG on radial velocity standard stars
Large radial-velocity surveys are being conducted to search for extrasolar planets
around different types of stars, including A to M dwarfs, and G -- K giants (e.g., Udry & Santos 2007).
RADIAL VELOCITIES
9
Although not aiming at establishing a set of radial-velocity standard stars, the non-
variable stars in these programmes, followed over a long period of time, provide ideal
candidates for our list of standards. They will moreover broaden the domain of stellar
properties covered (brightness and spectral type). At this point, the results of most of
those programmes are still not publicly available and we must still wait a bit in order to
fine-tune and enlarge the list presently available at
http://obswww.unige.ch/∼udry/std/std.html .
In addition to the by-product aspect of planet search programmes, a targeted observa-
tional effort, dedicated to the definition of a large sample of RV standards for GAIA,
is being pursued with several instruments (CORALIE, SOPHIE, etc). It will provide
in a few years a list of several thousand suitable standards spread over the entire sky
(Crifo et al. 2007).
For all of the efforts above, work remains to be done to combine the data from the
different instruments into a common RV system, for example through the observation of
minor planets in the solar system (Zwitter et al. 2007). This has still to be done for most
of the planet search programmes, but is already included in the GAIA effort.
By H. Levato
8.2. WG on stellar radial velocity bibliography
During the 2006 -- 2009 triennium, the WG searched for the papers with measurements
of radial velocities of stars in 33 journals. As of December 2007 113,658 entries have been
catalogued. We expect to finish 2008 with more than 150,000. It is worth mentioning that
at the end of 1996 there were 23,358 entries recorded, so that in 10 years the number
of entries in the catalogue has expanded by a factor of five. During the triennium we
have improved the search engine to search by different parameters. In the main body
of the catalogue we have included information about the technical characteristics of the
instrumentation used for radial velocity measurements, and comments about the nature
of the objects. The catalogue can be accessed at
http://www.casleo.gov.ar/catalogue/catalogue.html .
8.3. WG on the catalogue of orbital elements of spectroscopic binaries (SB9)
By D. Pourbaix
In Manchester, a WG was set up to work on the implementation of the 9th catalogue of
orbits of spectroscopic binaries (SB9), superseding the 8th release of Batten et al. (1989)
(SB8). SB9 exists in electronic format only. The web site
http://sb9.astro.ulb.ac.be
was officially released during the summer of 2001. This site is directly accessible from the
Commission 26 web site, from BDB (in Besan¸con), and from the CDS, among others.
Since the last report, substantial progress has been accomplished, in particular in the
way complex systems can be uploaded together with their radial velocities. That is the
case, for instance, for triple stars with the light time effect accounted for and systems
with a pulsating primary.
At the time of this writing SB9 contains 2802 systems (SB8 had 1469) and 3340 orbits
10
DIVISION IX / COMMISSION 30
(1469 in SB8). A total of 563 papers were added since August 2000, although most of
them come from outside the WG. Many papers with orbits still await uploading into the
catalogue. According to ADS, the release paper (Pourbaix et al. 2004) has been cited a
total of 58 times since 2005. This is twice as many as the old Batten et al. catalogue over
the same period.
Even though this work has been very well received by the community and a number
of tools have been designed and implemented to make the job of entering new orbits
easier (input file checker, plot generator, etc.), the WG still suffers from a serious lack
of manpower. Few colleagues outside the WG spontaneously send their orbits (but they
are usually pleased to send their data when we ask for them). Any help (from authors,
journal editors, and others) is therefore very welcome. Uploading an orbit into SB9 also
involves checking for typos. In this way we have found several mistakes in published
solutions, which we have corrected. Sending orbits to SB9 prior to publication (e.g., at
the proof stage) would therefore be a way to prevent some mistakes from making it into
the literature.
Guillermo Torres
Vice-President of the Commission
References
Abt, H. 2008, PASP, 120, 715
Adelman-McCarthy, J. K., Agueros, M. A., Allam, S. S. et al. 2008, ApJS, 175, 297
Batten, A. H., Fletcher, J. M., & MacCarthy, D. G. 1989, Eighth catalogue of the orbital elements
of spectroscopic binary systems, Publ. Dom. Astr. Obs., 17, 1
Bazot, M., Bouchy, F., Kjeldsen, J., Charpinet, S., Laymand, M., & Vauclair, S. 2007, A&A,
470, 295
Bedding, T. R., Butler, R. P., Carrier, F. et al. 2006, ApJ, 647, 558
Bridges, T., Gebhardt, K., Sharples, R. et al. 2006, MNRAS, 373, 157
Bridges, T., Rhode, K. L., Zepf, S. E., & Freeman, K. C. 2007, ApJ, 658, 980
Carraro, G., Geisler, D., Villanova, S. et al. 2007, A&A, 476, 217
Claria, J. J., Mermilliod, J.-C., Piatti, A. E., & Parisi, M. C. 2006, A&A, 453, 91
Crifo, F., Jasniewica, G., Soubiran, C. et al. 2007, in Towards a new set of radial velocity
standards for GAIA, eds. J. Bouvier, A. Chalabaev, & C. Charbonnel, Proceedings of the
Annual meeting of the French Society of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Grenoble (France),
p. 459
Da Costa, G. S., & Matthew, C. G. 2008, AJ, 136, 506
Famaey, B., Jorissen, A., Luri, X. et al. 2005, A&A, 430, 165
Fischer, D. A., Marcy, G. W., Butler, R. P. et al. 2008, ApJ, 675, 790
Frinchaboy, P. M., Marino, A. F., & Villanova, S. et al. 2008, MNRAS (in press), arXiv:0809.2559
Frinchaboy, P. M., & Majewski, S. R. 2008, AJ, 136, 118
Fur´esz, G., Hartmann, L. W., Megeath, S. T. et al. 2008, ApJ, 676, 1109
Gonz´alez, J. F., & Levato, H. 2006, RMxAA, 26, 171
Hekker, S., Reffert, S., Quirrenbach, A., Mitchell, D. S., Fischer, D. A., Marcy, G. W., & Butler,
R. P. 2006, A&A, 454, 943
Hekker, S., Snellen, I. A. G., Aerts, C., Quirrenbach, A., Reffert, S., & Mitchell, D. S. 2008,
A&A, 480, 215
Helmi, A., Navarro, J. F., Nordstrom, B. et al. 2006, MNRAS 365, 1309
Holmberg, J., Nordstrom, B., & Andersen, J. 2007, A&A, 475, 519
Johnson, J. A. et al. 2007a, ApJ, 670, 833
Johnson, J. A., Marcy, G. W., Fischer, D. A. et al. 2008, ApJ, 675, 784
Johnson, J. A., Butler, R. P., Marcy, G. W., Fischer, D. A., Vogt, S. S., Wright, J. T., & Peek,
K. M. G. 2007b, ApJ, 665, 785
RADIAL VELOCITIES
11
Karchenko, N. V., Scholz, R.-D., Piskunov, A. E. et al. 2007, AN, 328, 889
Konstantopoulos, I. S., Bastian, N., Smith, L. J. et al. 2008, ApJ, 674, 846
Lee, M. G., Hwang, Ho S., Kim, S. Ch. et al. 2008a. ApJ, 674, 886
Lee, M. G., Hwang, Ho S., Park, H. S. et al. 2008b, ApJ, 674, 857
Li, Ch.-H., Benedick, A. J., Fendel, P. et al. 2008, Nature, 452, 610
Lovis, C., & Pepe, F. 2007, A&A, 468, 1115
Massarotti, A., Latham, D. W., Stefanik, R. P., & Fogel, J. 2008, AJ, 135, 209
Mayor, M., & Udry, S. 2008, Phys. Scr., 130 (in press)
Mayor, M., Udry, S., Lovis, C. et al. 2008, A&A (in press), arXiv:0806.4587
Mengel, S., & Tacconi-Garman, L. E. 2008, in Young massive star clusters - Initial conditions
and environments, Granada, Spain (in press), arXiv:0803.4471
Mermilliod, J.-C., Platais, I., James, D. J., Grenon, M., & Cargile, P. A. 2008a, A&A, 485, 95
Mermilliod, J.-C., & Mayor, M. 2007, A&A, 470, 919
Mermilliod, J.-C., Andersen, J., Latham, D. W., & Mayor, M. 2007, A&A, 473, 829
Mermilliod, J.-C., Queloz, D., & Mayor, M. 2008b, A&A, 488, 409
Mermilliod, J.-C., Mayor, M., & Udry, S. 2008c, A&A, 485, 303
Mosser, B., Bouchy, F., Marti´c, M. et al. 2008a, A&A, 478, 197
Mosser, B., Deheuvels, S., Michel, E. et al. 2008b, A&A, 488, 635
Murphy, M. T., Udem, Th., Holzwarth, R. et al. 2007, MNRAS, 380, 839
Nordstrom, B., Mayor, M., Andersen, J. et al. 2004, A&A, 418, 989
Pepe, F., Correia, A. C. M., Mayor, M. et al. 2007, A&A, 462, 769
Pepe, F. A., & Lovis, C. 2007, in Physics of Planetary Systems, Nobel Symposium 135, in press
Piatti, A., Clari´a, J. J., Mermilliod, J.-C., Parisi, M. C., & Ahumada, A. V. 2007, MNRAS, 377,
1737
Platais, I., Melo, C., Mermilliod, J.-C. et al. 2007, A&A, 461, 509
Pourbaix, D., Tokovinin, A. A., Batten, A. H. et al. 2004, A&A, 424, 727
Ramsey, L. W., Barnes, J., Redman, S. L., Jones, H. R. A., Wolszczan, A., Bongiorno, S., Engel,
L., & Jenkins, J. 2008, PASP, 120, 887
Schuberth, Y., Richtler, T., Dirsch, B. et al. 2006, A&A, 459, 391
Smith, M. C., Ruchti, G. R., Helmi, A. et al. 2007, MNRAS, 379, 755
Sommariva, V., Piotto, G., Rejkuba, M. et al. 2008, A&A (in press), arXiv:0810.1897
Steinmetz, T., Wilken, T., Araujo-Hauck, C. et al. 2008, Science, 321, 1335
Trippe, S., Gillessen, S., Gerhard, O. E. et al. 2008, A&A (in press), arXiv:0810.1040
Udry, S., & Santos, N. C. 2007, ARA&A, 45, 397
Udry, S., Bonfils, X., Delfosse, X. et al. 2007, A&A, 469, L43
van Leeuwen, F. 2007, A&A, 474, 653
Zwitter, T., Mignard, F., & Crifo, F. 2007, A&A, 462, 795
Zwitter, T., Siebert, A., Munari, U. et al. 2008, AJ, 136, 421
|
astro-ph/9701141 | 1 | 9701 | 1997-01-20T17:19:19 | The ages and distances of globular clusters with the luminosity function method: the case of M5 and M55 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present new age and distance determinations for the Galactic Globular Clusters M55 and M5, using the luminosity function method (Jimenez & Padoan 1996, Padoan & Jimenez 1997). We find an age of $11.8 \pm 1.5$ Gyr for M55 and $11.1 \pm 0.7$ Gyr for M5. This confirms previous results (Jimenez et al. 1996, Sandquist et al. 1996) and allows to conclude that the oldest stars in the Universe are not older than 14 Gyr. We also find $m-M=14.13 \pm 0.11$ for M55, and $m-M=14.49 \pm 0.06$ for M5. These values agree with the ones obtained using the tip of the red giant branch (Jimenez et al. 1996) and the sub-dwarf fitting method (Sandquist et al. 1996). | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (0000)
Printed 14 August 2018
(MN LATEX style file v1.4)
The ages and distances of globular clusters with the
luminosity function method: the case of M5 and M55.
Raul Jimenez,1 and Paolo Padoan2
1Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9-3HJ, UK
2Theoretical Astrophysics Center, Juliane Maries Vej 30, DK-2100 Copenhagen 0, Denmark
14 August 2018
ABSTRACT
We present new age and distance determinations for the Galactic Globular
Clusters M55 and M5, using the luminosity function method (Jimenez &
Padoan 1996, Padoan & Jimenez 1997).
We find an age of 11.8 ± 1.5 Gyr for M55 and 11.1 ± 0.7 Gyr for M5.
This confirms previous results (Jimenez et al. 1996, Sandquist et al. 1996)
and allows to conclude that the oldest stars in the Universe are not
older than 14 Gyr.
We also find m− M = 14.13± 0.11 for M55, and m− M = 14.49± 0.06 for
M5. These values agree with the ones obtained using the tip of the red giant
branch (Jimenez et al. 1996) and the sub-dwarf fitting method (Sandquist et
al. 1996).
Key words: globular clusters: general -- globular clusters: individual (M5,
M55)
1
INTRODUCTION
An accurate determination of the ages and distances of Globular Clusters (GCs) is an im-
portant constraint for the age of the Universe, and for the theory of galaxy formation. In
particular it is important to compute very accurate relative ages to understand if there is a
spread in ages among the Galactic GCs or not.
The use of the stellar luminosity function (LF) to compute ages of GCs was first proposed
by Paczynski (1984). Later on, Jimenez & Padoan (1996) and Padoan & Jimenez (1996)
developed a method to determine the age and the distance of a GC simultaneously, using
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS
2
R. Jimenez & P. Padoan
the LF. The method is described in detail in Padoan & Jimenez (1996), where it is concluded,
on the basis of artificial data, that an uncertainty of about 0.6 Gyr in the age and 0.06 mag
in the distance modulus can be achieved, if the number of stars, in 1 mag-wide luminosity
bins, is known with an uncertainty of 3%.
In this paper we use recent observations of the Galactic Globular Clusters M5 (Sandquist
et al. 1996) and M55 (Desidera & Ortolani, private communication) to apply the LF method
and compute accurate ages and distance module. These two clusters are very adequate since
M55 is a metal-poor one and M5 has intermediate metallicity, so we can investigate the
spread in ages (if any) in the formation of the GC system.
In this letter we apply for the first time the LF method to real data and we show that
the method is much more superior to traditional methods (isochrone fitting to the main
sequence turn off point, ∆V method, or any other methods that involve the fitting of the
main sequence turn off). The method is superior because it allows to determine the age and
the distance simultaneously and independently and because the errors in computing the age
and distance are straightforward to calculate. Furthermore, it gives age determinations with
sufficient accuracy to make cosmological predictions. This first application of our LF method
to real data shows that our previous theoretical predictions were correct.
2 THE DATA
In order to apply our LF method it is necessary to obtain the complete LF of the glob-
ular cluster from almost the tip of the red giant branch (RGB), down to the upper main
sequence. The number of observed stars should be very large, in order to keep statistical
errors sufficiently low. Recently, two LFs that fulfill these requirements have been obtained
by Sandquist et al. (1996) for M5, and by Desidera & Ortolani (private communication) for
M55.
M5 is a massive globular cluster, with an average metallicity of [F e/H] = −1.17 ± 0.01,
according to Sneden et al. (1992), and [F e/H] = −1.4, according to Zinn & West (1984).
Since it is a high altitude cluster (b = 46.8o), it is not seriously affected by contamination
and interstellar reddening. For the metallicity of this cluster we used [F e/H] = −1.3, and
adopt Y = 0.24. The completeness of the LF is discussed in detail in Sandquist et al. (1996).
M55 is among the poor-metal clusters. The main advantage of M55 is that it is not
very concentrated and therefore it is possible to resolve its core into stars. Again due to its
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
The ages and distances of globular clusters with the luminosity function method: the case of M5 and M55.
3
high galactic latitude (b = −23o), interstellar reddening and contamination are negligible.
We adopt a metallicity of [F e/H] = −1.9 (Briley et al. 1993) and Y = 0.24. The LF
was provided to us by Desidera & Ortolani (private communication.), who have performed
extensive tests with artificial stars, in order to compute the completeness of the sample.
In this letter we use the data in the filter band V for M55 and in I for M5. This allows
us to illustrate the robustness of the method in two very different bands. The other colours
were used in both cases to remove the horizontal and asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars.
In the case of the horizontal branch it is quite easy to distinguish them from the RGB. Even
if this is not the case for the AGB stars, the number of stars used in the LF method is
so large in that bin that a small mistake in distinguishing RGB and AGB stars does not
contribute significantly to the errors in the final age and distance determination.
In producing LFs to study both GCs we have used [α/F e] = 0.4 and compute this effect
in our solar-scaled tracks using the approach by Chieffi, Straniero & Salaris (1991). This
value of alpha enhancement is well justified by spectroscopic observations of giants in GCs
(Minniti et al 1996), and this enhancement is valid for a metallicity range ([F e/H] = −1.5
to −2.0).
3 THE LUMINOSITY FUNCTION METHOD
To determine the age and the distance of a GC, two independent constraints are needed
from the LF, that is to say the number of stars in two different bins. One more bin is needed
for the normalization, and a fourth bin is useful to estimate the completeness of the data,
but it is not used in this work, since the completeness was previously estimated performing
experiments with artificial stars (nevertheless, we have checked that the fourth bin gives the
same completeness estimation as the artificial star tests).
We use a bin positioned at the RGB to normalize the LF, and two bins around the
sub-giant region to constrain age and distance modulus. As discussed in Padoan & Jimenez
(1996), the precise position of the two bins at the sub-giant region is extremely important.
In fact, our LF method is based on the careful optimization of those two bins.
The result of the optimization process is a contour plot of the quantity R(t, m − M), on
the plane (t, m − M), where:
R2(t, m − M) = [n2,th(t) − n2,obs(t, m − M)]2
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
4
R. Jimenez & P. Padoan
+[n3,th(t) − n3,obs(t, m − M)]2
(1)
where t is the age, m− M the distance modulus, ni,obs the normalized ratio Ni,obs/N1,obs,
Ni,obs the number of stars in the ith observational bin and ni,th the corresponding theoretical
ratio. The values of ni,th are only functions of the age of the GC, since the shape of the
theoretical LF depends only on the age (for a given chemical composition), while the values
of ni,obs are also functions of the distance modulus, because the observational LF depends
on the distance modulus, if the bins are defined in absolute magnitudes.
If the set of bins is not optimal, the contour plot of R shows only open lines, which
define a relation between age and distance modulus. Once the set of bins is optimized, the
contour plot shows also closed lines, that define both the age and the distance modulus of
the GC at the same time. If the lines start to become closed only for R ≤ 0.1, the degeneracy
age-distance modulus is broken only if stellar counts are available with uncertainty smaller
than 10%. This is the reason why the method requires LF with a large number of stars and
excellent photometry.
The optimization process, applied to M55 and M5 gave the following set of bins:
MV,optimal,M 55 = (tGyr − 9.0) × 0.05
+[4.01, 3.01, 2.01, 0.01]mag
MI,optimal,M 5 = (tGyr − 8.0) × 0.05
+[2.87, 2.07, 1.27, −3.13]mag
The optimal bins shift by 0.05 mag/Gyr, as determined in our previous work (Padoan
& Jimenez 1996). This is an essential point in the attempt to obtain the contour plot of R.
Note that for M5 we could use two bins narrower than 1.0 mag, in order to improve the
sensitivity of the method, thanks to the very large number of stars in the bins and to the
good quality of the photometry.
Our results for M55 is shown in Fig. 1, and for M5 in Fig. 2. In both cases, closed contour
lines are obtained for R ≤ 0.1, and the uncertainty in age and m− M, obtained at any given
level of R, is comparable for the two clusters, and similar to what we previously predicted
with artificial LFs (Padoan & Jimenez, 1996)
Given the photometric uncertainty and the statistical uncertainty in the stellar counts
(1/√N, where N is the number of stars), we estimate a global uncertainty of 6% for the
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
The ages and distances of globular clusters with the luminosity function method: the case of M5 and M55.
5
M5
M55
age
m-M 14.49 ± 0.06
11.1 ± 0.7
11.8 ± 1.5
14.13 ± 0.11
Table 1. The table gives the values for the age and distance modulus for M5 and M55. These values have been determined
simultaneously using the luminosity function method described in the text.
case of M55, and of 4% for the case of M5. Entering Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 with R = 0.06 and
R = 0.04 respectively, one gets the results listed in Table 1.
4 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
The results listed in Table 1 show that the age and the distance modulus of M55 are in
good agreement with previous determinations by Mandushev et al. (1996) and Alcaino et
al. (1992).
In the case of M5 the results agree with Sanquist et al. conclusions. They estimate in
fact an age of 13.5 ± 1 Gyr, for [F e/H] = −1.17, and they state that the age would be 11.5
Gyr, for [F e/H] = −1.4. We use [F e/H] = −1.3, and get an age of 11.1 ± 0.7 Gyr. They
also estimate m − M = 14.50 ± 0.07 mag for [F e/H] = −1.17, and m − M = 14.41 ± 0.07
mag, for [F e/H] = −1.4, using the sub-dwarf fitting of the main sequence. We get m− M =
14.49 ± 0.06 mag, for [F e/H] = −1.3. Note that in Padoan & Jimenez (1996) we estimated
a variation of 0.02 mag in m − M, for a shift of 0.1 in metallicity; so we would predict
m − M = 14.47 ± 0.06 mag, for [F e/H] = −1.4.
The distance modulus measured with the LF method is therefore in excellent agreement
with the distance modulus determined with the sub-dwarf fitting. The uncertainty of our
estimates is very small (±0.06 mag), and no assumption on the age is required.
The LF method is superior to the main sequence turn-off (MSTO) method (Chaboyer,
Demarque & Sarajedini 1996), to determine the absolute age of globular clusters, because
it is not affected by the three largest sources of theoretical uncertainty affecting the MSTO
method, that is to say the determination of the value of the mixing length parameter,
the morphology of the MSTO and the color-Teff calibration (see Jimenez et al. 1996 for
a detailed discussion of the main uncertainties in the MSTO method). Furthermore, the
MSTO method needs to know the distance in order to determine the age, and it is unable
to break this degeneracy.
The absolute ages, determined in this work for M55 and M5, seem to indicate that the
oldest GCs are not older than 14 Gyr.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
6
R. Jimenez & P. Padoan
Figure 1. The figure shows the contour plots of R(t, m − M ) (see text) in determining simultaneously the distance modulus
and age of M55. Notice that the contours closed around a central value, showing that the method works quite well in breaking
the age-distance degeneracy.
The LF method is a very powerful tool to investigate relative ages, since most uncertain-
ties of stellar evolution theories are in that case avoided. From the comparison of the ages
of M5 and M55 we can conclude that the age of the two GCs is not significantly different.
We conclude by remarking that most methods to determine age and distance module of
GCs share two common problems: some degree of dependence of age on distance modulus (or
vice-versa), and a somewhat fuzzy procedure to estimate the uncertainty of the final result.
Our LF method, instead, gives constraints for both age and distance modulus independently,
and estimates both most probable values and uncertainties in a straightforward way.
On the basis of the present work, we think that very high quality data for GCs, together
with the LF method, may shed new light on the problems of the age of the oldest stars in
the Universe and the formation of the Galaxy.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are grateful to S. Desidera % S. Ortolani for providing us with unpublished data of M55.
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
The ages and distances of globular clusters with the luminosity function method: the case of M5 and M55.
7
Figure 2. The same as before but for M5. The estimated uncertainty of 4% is marked with dashed lines.
REFERENCES
Alcaino, G., Liller, W., Alvarado, F., Wenderoth, E., 1992, AJ, 104, 190
Briley, M.M., Smith, G.H., Hesser, J.E., Bell, R.A., 1993, ApJ, 306,142
Chaboyer, B., Demarque, P., & Sarajedini, A. 1996, ApJ, 459, 558
Chieffi, A., Straniero, O., Salaris, M., 1991, in ASP Conf. Ser. 13, The Formation and Evolution of Star Clusters, ed. K. Janes
(San Francisco: ASP), 219
Jimenez, R., Thejll, P., Jørgensen, U.G., MacDonald, J., Pagel, B., 1996, MNRAS, 282, 926
Jimenez, R., Padoan, P., 1996, ApJ, 463, L17
Mandushev, G.I., Fahlman, G.G., Richer, H.B., Thompson, I.B., 1996, AJ, 112, 1536
Minniti, D., Petterson, R.C., Geisler, D., Claria, J.J., 1996, ApJ, 470, 953
Paczynski, B., 1984, ApJ, 284, 670
Padoan, P. & Jimenez, R. 1997, ApJ, 475, 580
Sandquist, E.L., Bolte, M., Stetson, P.B., Hesser, J.E., 1996, ApJ, 470, 910
Sneden, C., Kraft, R.P., Prosser, C.F., Langer, G.E., 1992, AJ, 104, 2121
Zinn, R. & West, M. J. 1984, ApJS, 55, 45
c(cid:13) 0000 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
|
astro-ph/9408068 | 1 | 9408 | 1994-08-18T21:08:01 | The Damping and Excitation of Galactic Warps by Dynamical Friction | [
"astro-ph"
] | We investigate the dynamical interaction of galactic warps with the surrounding dark matter halo, using analytic perturbation theory. A precessing warp induces a density wake in the collisionless dark matter, which acts back on the original warp, transferring energy and angular momentum between the warp and halo (dynamical friction). In most cases dynamical friction damps the warp, but in unusual circumstances (such as a halo that rotates in the same direction as the precession of the warp, or a warp in the equatorial plane of an axisymmetric prolate halo) friction can excite a warp. The damping/excitation time is usually short compared to the Hubble time for realistic systems. Thus most warps cannot be primordial; they must be maintained by some ongoing excitation mechanism. | astro-ph | astro-ph | The Damping and Excitation of Galactic Warps by
Dynamical Friction
Robert W. Nelson and Scott Tremaine
Canadian Institute for Theoretical Astrophysics
ABSTRACT
We investigate the dynamical interaction of galactic warps with the surrounding
dark matter halo, using analytic perturbation theory. A precessing warp induces
a density wake in the collisionless dark matter, which acts back on the original
warp, transferring energy and angular momentum between the warp and halo
(dynamical friction). In most cases dynamical friction damps the warp, but in unusual
circumstances (such as a halo that rotates in the same direction as the precession of
the warp, or a warp in the equatorial plane of an axisymmetric prolate halo) friction
can excite a warp. The damping/excitation time is usually short compared to the
Hubble time for realistic systems. Thus most warps cannot be primordial; they must
be maintained by some ongoing excitation mechanism.
1 Introduction
The origin and maintenance of the `integral sign' warps commonly seen in the outer parts of disk
galaxies is a longstanding puzzle in galactic dynamics (for a recent review see Binney 1992). Many
if not most disk galaxieseven isolated onesappear to be warped, which implies that warps are
either long-lived or repeatedly excited (Sanchez-Saavedra et al. 1990, Bosma 1991). Following an
initial suggestion by Lynden-Bell (1965), Hunter & Toomre (1969; hereafter HT) explored the
possibility that warps are discrete modes of oscillation of a thin, self-gravitating disk. They found,
however, that isolated disks with realistic density pro les actually support a continuum of bending
modes; consequently, any packet of bending waves should disperse. Dekel & Shlosman (1983)
and Toomre (1983) suggested a solution to this problem, which was analyzed in detail by Sparke
& Casertano (1988; hereafter SC): realistic disks can support discrete bending modes if they
are embedded in the static potential of a
attened dark matter halothese modes are distorted
versions of the neutral tilt mode of an isolated disk. Thus the gravitational in
uence of galaxy
halos may play an important role in the maintenance of galactic warps; conversely, by studying the
dynamics of warps in galaxies we may learn about the shape and dynamics of the unseen halos.
Unfortunately, galaxy halos are not simply static potentials: the collisionless halo material
whatever its naturemust respond to the gravitational eld of an embedded disk. A warped,
precessing disk induces a density wake in the dark matter halo and the gravitational eld from the
wake will then act back on the disk; in this manner energy and angular momentum are transferred
{ 2 {
between disk and halo in a manner analogous to the Landau damping of waves in a collisionless
plasma or dynamical friction on a point mass travelling through a stellar system. In general,
then, any bending mode of a galaxy disk is not precisely neutral; the question is whether the
dynamical coupling between the halo and the disk is strong enough to dampor excite, as we
shall seebending modes of a galaxy on timescales less than the age of the galaxy itself
.
1
This issue was rst investigated by Bertin & Mark (1980), who approximated the warp as
a tightly-wound (WKB) bending wave, embedded in an in nite, homogeneous, and isotropic
`halo' having a Maxwell-Boltzmann velocity distribution. Their analysis predicted that the
amplitude of the bending wave would grow inside the corotation radiusand on a short timescale.
Unfortunately, this interesting conclusion is suspect, because Bertin and Mark neglected the
unperturbed halo's contribution to the vertical restoring force (see Section 3.1).
In this paper we examine the role of a responsive halo in damping or exciting bending
disturbances in galactic disks. We extend Bertin and Mark's seminal analysis to include warps and
halos with more realistic shapes, as well as halos with anisotropic velocity distribution and net
rotation. In particular, if the orbits of halo particleswe shall refer to these as `stars' although
their nature is unknownare quasiperiodic, energy and angular momentum exchange between disk
and halo occurs via stars whose orbits are nearly resonant with the frequency of the time-varying
disk potential (Tremaine & Weinberg 1984). In this situation, the direction of energy and angular
momentum
ow can be from disk to halo or vice versa, so that dynamical friction with the halo
may either damp or excite warps, depending on the details of the halo structure.
Our analysis of this phenomenon is more elaborate than any in the literature so far, but still
has a number of limitations. We do not consider the self-gravity of the halo response. We calculate
the unperturbed orbits of stars in the disk plus halo system by assuming that the potential is
spherical, and assume that the halo is axisymmetric for the purpose of computing the precession
rate and energy of the bending disturbance; whereas cosmological N-body simulations of the
collapse of protogalactic density peaks typically result in triaxial halos. We use linear perturbation
theory, whose validity is suspect since warps often have substantial amplitudes.
Despite these shortcomings, we believe that the principal results of our analysis are robust.
In particular, we nd that dynamical friction from the halo can either damp or excite bending
disturbances in a disk, although damping is the most common outcome for plausible disk/halo
con gurations. The characteristic growth or decay time is generally less than a Hubble time,
implying that dynamical friction plays a ma jor role in determining the present properties of galaxy
warps.
In Section 2 we review the dynamics of bending disturbances in a thin disk embedded in
a static halo potential. In Section 3 we relax this assumption and consider the coupling of the
1
`One key question about this kind of proposal is how long the central disk can thereafter remain tilted despite
dynamical friction against the doubtless
abby halo' (Toomre 1983).
{ 3 {
bending perturbation to the dynamics of the halo stars. In particular, we give general formulae
for the damping/excitation rate of bending disturbances from dynamical friction with the halo. In
Section 4 we present numerical calculations of damping/excitation times for reasonably realistic
halo and disk potentials and warp shapes. Finally, in Section 5 we discuss the implications of our
results.
2 Warp Dynamics
We review the behavior of linear bending waves of a zero-thickness, axisymmetric, self-gravitating
disk embedded in a static halo potential, delaying until Section 3 consideration of the coupling of
bending waves to a responsive halo. Many, but not all, of the results we describe are presented in
HT, Sparke (1984), and SC.
2.1 The equation of motion
We work in cylindrical coordinates (R; ; z ) and take the unperturbed disk to lie in the z = 0
plane, so that position in the disk is described by the vector R (R; ). We consider a razor-thin
axisymmetric disk of surface density (R), rotating at angular speed
(R) > 0. The equation of
motion in the inertial frame for small vertical displacements, Z (R; ; t), is (HT)
2
2
D
Z
@
@
+
Z = F
+ F
+ F
;
(1)
h
sg
ext
2
Dt
@ t
@
where the three terms on the right side are the vertical components of the force per unit mass
arising from the gravitational eld of the static halo (F
) and the disk (F
), and from any other
h
sg
sources (F
). We assume that the halo is axisymmetric and that its density is smooth near the
ext
disk, so that the halo potential can be expanded in a Taylor series
U
(R; z ) = U
(R; 0) +
(R)z
; where
(R) =
(R; z = 0)
(2)
h
h
2
h
h
2
@ z
1
2
2
2
2
@
U
h
is the square of the frequency of small vertical oscillations in the eld of the halo. Thus
F
(R; t) =
(R)Z (R; t):
(3)
h
h
2
It is sometimes useful to decompose the radial force
R into its contributions from the halo
2
and the disk,
2
2
2
(R) =
(R) +
(R);
(4)
h
d
where
2
2
h
1
@U
G
d
dR
(R
)
Z
0
0
(R) =
(R; z = 0);
(R) =
:
(5)
h
d
0
R
@R
R
dR
jR R
j
{ 4 {
The vertical restoring force from a slightly distorted disk is given by HT,
Z
0
0
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
F
(R; t) = G
dR
(R
)
:
(6)
sg
jR R
j
0
3
We may write the disturbance Z as a superposition of eigenfunctions of the form
Z (R; t) = Re
h(R)e
;
(7)
n
o
i(m !t)
where we assume m 0 without loss of generality. If ! is real and m 6= 0, the pattern speed
!=m is the angular speed of the rotating frame in which the disturbance is stationary.
p
When external forces are absent (F
= 0), the dynamical equation (1) for a single
ext
eigenfunction reduces to
n
o
Z
1
[! m
(R)]
(R)
h(R) = G
dR
R
(R
)[h(R)H (R; R
) h(R
)I
(R; R
)]
(8)
h
m
2
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
where
2
Z
Z
2
2
0
0
d
d cos m
H (R; R
) =
;
I
(R; R
) =
; (9)
2
0
0
3=2
2
0
0
3=2
2
2
m
0
0
(R
+ R
2RR
cos )
(R
+ R
2RR
cos )
these are Laplace coecients and can be evaluated in terms of elliptic integrals.
The component of the torque on the disk parallel to the z = 0 plane may be written
=
e
+
e
, where
x
x
y
y
Z
+ i
=
dR(R)[F
(y ix) z (F
iF
)];
(10)
x
y
z
y
x
here F = (F
; F
; F
) is the force per unit mass on the disk at R, composed of a radial component
x
y
z
2
2
R and a vertical component
Z + F
. Thus
sg
h
Z
+ i
= i
dR(R)Re
[(
)Z (R; t) + F
]:
(11)
x
y
sg
h
i
2
2
Since the torque from the disk on itself must be zero we have (Kuijken 1991)
Z
i
2
0 =
dR(R)Re
[
Z (R; t) + F
];
(12)
d
sg
(a result which can also be derived by manipulating eqs. 5 and 6) and
+ i
= i
dR(R)Re
(
)Z (R; t):
(13)
x
y
h
h
Z
i
2
2
2
0
The functions H and I
diverge as R
! R but the integral in equation (8) is nevertheless well-de ned.
m
{ 5 {
These equations degenerate to 0 = 0 when m 6= 1 but when m = 1 we may use equations (1) and
(7) to reduce equation (12) to the form
Z
1
0
2
2
2
2
dRR
(R)[
2
+ (
)]h(R) = 0:
(14)
p
h
h
p
This constraint provides a quadratic equation for the pattern speed
in terms of the eigenfunction
p
h(R); its unique feature is that the self-gravity of the disk does not have to be evaluated explicitly.
In general, one of the roots of equation (14) is spurious and we shall assume that the correct root
is the one with the smallest absolute value. The motivation for this choice is that we focus on the
distorted tilt mode, which has a small pattern speed.
Numerical solutions of the eigenvalue equation (8) for various disk and halo density pro les
are given by HT, Sparke (1984) and SC. The following special cases o er useful insight:
1. In the absence of disk self-gravity, equation (8) reduces to
! = m
(R)
(R);
(15)
h
as does (14) when m = 1. In general, the combination of terms on the right side will
depend on radius, so the eigenfunctions are singular (van Kampen modes), and any spatially
extended initial disturbance will damp by phase mixing.
2. If the halo is spherical, the disk is neutrally stable to tilting. To see this from equation (8)
we use equations (5) and (9) to write
Z
1
G
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
(R) =
dR
R
(R
)[RH (R; R
) R
I
(R; R
)];
(16)
d
1
R
0
it follows that when m = 1 and the halo is spherical (
=
) a solution of (8) is ! = 0,
h
h
h(R) / R (the `tilt mode').
3. For a nearly spherical halo, the tilt mode is distorted and acquires a small but non-zero
pattern speed.
In equation (14) we may therefore drop the term proportional to
;
p
2
moreover, in a rst approximation we can replace the eigenfunction h(R) by the tilt mode
h(R) / R. Thus we obtain (SC)
R
1
2
2
3
(
)(R)R
dR
0
h
h
R
'
;
(17)
p
1
3
2
(R)(R)R
dR
0
note that the angular frequency in the denominator includes the contribution from both
disk and halo, while the frequencies in the numerator represent only the halo contribution.
Equation (17) simply says that the precession rate of the warped disk is the torque from the
halo divided by the o -axis angular momentum (Kuijken 1991); we shall refer to it as the
Sparke-Casertano formula for the pattern speed.
{ 6 {
The distorted tilt mode is closely related to the Laplace invariable plane
: each annulus of
3
the disk is in the Laplace plane determined by the halo and the other annuli. Thus we shall refer
to this mode as the `Laplace mode' (SC use the term `modi ed tilt mode').
2.2 Energy and angular momentum
To determine the energy E
associated with a bending disturbance Z (R; t), we assume that the
w
disturbance has been generated by an external potential U
(r; t), where r = (R; ; z ) = (R; z ). If
ext
the disk has density (r; t) and velocity v(r; t) then the rate at which the external potential does
work on the disk is
Z
Z
dE
w
dt
=
drv F
=
drv rU
:
(18)
ext
ext
We may write v = (0;
R; DZ=Dt); the radial and azimuthal velocities have been set to their
unperturbed values since we are working to rst order in the small quantity Z (R; t) and to this
order the horizontal and vertical motions are decoupled. Thus
dE
w
Z
=
dr [
U
+ (Z;
+
Z;
)U
] ;
ext;
t
ext;z
dt
Z
=
dr [
U
Z;
U
+
Z;
U
] ;
(19)
;
ext
t
ext;z
;z
ext
where the second line follows from integration by parts. The density of our razor-thin disks may
be written (r; t) = (R) [z Z (R; t)]. Thus
=
(z Z )Z;
=
Z;
:
(20)
;
;z
0
Substituting this result in equation (19) we nd that the rst and third terms cancel, so that
Z
Z
=
drZ;
U
=
dRF
Z;
(21)
t
ext;z
ext
t
dE
w
dt
where as usual F
is the z -component of the external force (note that the expression is not
R
ext
dRF
(DZ=Dt), as one might expect from considering only vertical motions).
ext
We may eliminate the external force F
from equation (21) using equations (1), (3) and (6).
ext
Then using integration by parts with respect to , we can convert the right side of equation (21)
3
Consider a
attened planet that is accompanied by a massive satellite on an inclined orbit. A test particle
orbiting the planet in the Laplace plane will remain in that plane (except for short-period oscillations) despite the
perturbations from the planet's equatorial bulge and the massive satellite. The normal to the Laplace plane lies in the
plane determined by the spin and orbital angular momentum vectors of the planet and satellite, while the orientation
of the plane is xed so that the angular momentum vectors of the planet, satellite and test particle all precess at the
same rate.
{ 7 {
into the total time derivative of a quantity which must equal the energy E
to within a constant.
w
Setting this constant to zero when Z = 0, we obtain
Z
Z
G
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
2
1
2
2
2
2
2
0
0
E
=
dR(R)[Z;
+
Z
Z;
] +
dRdR
(R)(R
)
:
(22)
w
2
t
h
4
jR R
j
0
3
In the absence of an external force, the energy (22) is conserved
.
4
Note that the energy of a disturbance is not guaranteed to be positive, since the rst
integrand can be negative. HT examined the sign of the energy for azimuthal wavenumbers m = 0
(axisymmetric) and m = 1 (tilt or warp). When m = 0 Z;
= 0 so equation (22) implies that the
energy is positive (or zero, in the trivial case
= 0, Z =constant, corresponding to the translation
h
of an isolated disk). Since unstable modes must have zero energy, all m = 0 modes are stable.
In the case m = 1 it is useful to decompose the angular speed into contributions from the disk
and halo (eqs. 4, 5). HT then show that
Z
Z
G
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
2
1
2
2
0
0
dR(R)
(R)Z;
+
dRdR
(R)(R
)
2
Z
G
d
0
3
4
jR R
j
=
dRdR
d (R)(R
)[RZ (R
; ; t) R
Z (R; ; t)]
I
(R; R
);
(24)
1
0
0
0
0
2
0
4
where I
is de ned in equation (9). Thus the energy of an m = 1 disturbance may be written
m
Z
Z
G
E
=
dR(R)[Z;
+(
)Z
]+
dRdR
d (R)(R
)[RZ (R
; ; t) R
Z (R; ; t)]
I
(R; R
):
1
2
2
2
2
0
0
0
0
2
0
w
2
t
h
h
4
1
(25)
If there is no halo (
=
= 0) the energy is positive or zero; zero energy corresponds to the
h
h
disturbance Z = AR cos(
) where A and
are constants (physically, an isolated disk is
0
0
neutrally stable to a uniform tilt). Since unstable modes must have zero energy, all m = 1 modes
of an isolated disk are stable, a conclusion due to HT.
When the disk is embedded in a halo, m = 1 disturbances can have positive or negative
energy. We shall call an axisymmetric halo `vertically sti ' if
>
at all radii (which is
h
h
generally the case if the disk lies in the equatorial plane of an oblate mass distribution), and
`vertically soft' if
<
(which occurs for prolate distributions). Equation (25) shows that the
h
h
total energy of an m = 1 disturbance is positiveso that m = 1 modes are stablewhenever the
halo is vertically sti .
4
This result for the energy is perhaps somewhat unexpected: in the absence of self-gravity, the most natural way
to derive an energy is to treat the disk particles as independent vertical harmonic oscillators. This procedure yields
Z
Z
0
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
E
=
dR(R)[(DZ=Dt)
+
Z
] =
dR(R)(Z;
+
Z
+
Z;
+2
Z;
Z;
);
(23)
w
h
t
h
t
2
2
which is not the same as the rst term of (22). Both E
and E
are conserved if F
= F
= 0, but equation (22)
w
sg
ext
w
0
is the only energy-like quantity conserved when self-gravity is present (except in the special case of uniform rotation,
which is described at the end of this section).
{ 8 {
The expression for the energy (22) can be rewritten in a simpler form. We operate on equation
R
(1) with
dR(R); setting F
= 0 we obtain
ext
Z
dR(R)(ZZ;
+2
ZZ;
+
ZZ;
+
Z
)
tt
t
h
2
2
2
Z
Z (R; t)[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
= G
dRdR
(R)(R
)
0
0
jR R
j
0
3
Z
0
2
G
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
0
=
dRdR
(R)(R
)
;
(26)
2
jR R
j
0
3
where the last expression is obtained from the second by interchanging primed and unprimed
variables and averaging with the original expression. Using this result to eliminate the last term
from equation (22) we nd
Z
1
2
2
2
2
E
=
dR(R)[Z;
ZZ;
2
ZZ;
Z;
ZZ;
]:
(27)
w
tt
t
2
t
The terms proportional to
cancel upon integrating by parts with respect to . Thus
2
Z
1
2
E
=
dR(R)[Z;
ZZ;
2
ZZ;
]:
(28)
w
tt
t
2
t
For a disturbance of the form (7) with m 6= 0 and real frequency ! = m
, we have
p
Z
2
2
E
= m
dRR(R)jh(R)j
(
):
(29)
w
p
p
Thus disturbances with zero pattern speed have zero energy; if the pattern speed is negative
(retrograde precession) the energy is always positive; if the pattern speed is small and positive the
energy is negative.
We can also work out the z -component of angular momentum associated with a disturbance
excited by an external potential:
Z
dJ
w
dt
=
drU
ext;
Z
=
dr;
U
ext
Z
=
dr;
Z;
U
z
ext
Z
=
drU
Z;
;
(30)
ext;z
where the third line follows from equation (20). We eliminate U
= F
using equations (1)
ext;z
ext
and (3) and derive an expression for the angular momentum by a similar procedure to the one
used to derive equation (22). In this derivation we use the results
Z;
Z;
= (Z;
Z;
);
(Z;
);
(31)
tt
t
t
2
t
1
2
{ 9 {
and
Z
Z
0
0
Z;
(Z Z
)
0
dR(R)Z;
F
= G
dRdR
(R)(R
)
sg
jR R
j
0
3
Z
0
2
G
[(Z Z
)
];
0
0
=
dRdR
(R)(R
)
2
jR R
j
0
3
Z
G
@
0
0
0
2
0
3
=
dRdR
(R)(R
)(Z Z
)
jR R
j
;
(32)
2
@
which is zero, because the integrand to the left of @ =@ is symmetric under interchange of primed
and unprimed variables, while @ jR R
j
=@ is antisymmetric.
0
3
In this way we nd
Z
J
=
dR(R)(Z;
Z;
+
Z;
):
(33)
w
t
2
Thus, in the absence of external forces, there are two independent conserved quantities that
are quadratic in the disturbance strength. These quantities correspond to the energy E
and
w
z -component of angular momentum J
. For a disturbance of the form (7) with real frequency
! = m
, we have
p
w
Z
J
= m
dRR(R)jh(R)j
(
):
(34)
w
p
2
2
Comparison of equation (34) with equation (29) shows that
E
=
J
:
(35)
w
p
w
We close this section by considering the special case of disks with constant angular speed,
(R) =
=const. Combining equations (22) and (33) we obtain the conserved quantity
0
Z
Z
G
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
0
2
1
2
2
2
0
0
E
J
=
dR(R)[(Z;
+
Z;
)
+
Z
] +
dRdR
(R)(R
)
:
w
0
w
t
0
2
h
4
jR R
j
0
3
(36)
Since this quantity is non-negative, all bending disturbances in a uniformly rotating disk are
stable.
2.3 The WKB approximation
The equation of motion (1) for bending waves can be solved analytically in the WKB or
short-wavelength limit. This solution o ers useful insights, even though the WKB approximation
is poor for the bending waves actually seen in galaxies.
In the WKB limit the radial wavelength is much shorter than any relevant radial scale
length, i.e.,
R;
;
(37)
dR
1
d ln (R)
but long compared to the wave amplitude,
{ 10 {
jZ j:
(38)
We write the vertical disturbance as
Z (R; t) = Re
A(R; t)e
e
;
(39)
R
R
i
K (R)dR
i(m !t)
where K (R) = 2=(R) is the local wavenumber and A(R; t) is a slowly varying amplitude.
The vertical gravitational force from the disturbed disk (eq. 6) can be evaluated using local
Cartesian coordinates, R
= R + xe
+ ye
, where at R the x axis points radially outward and
x
y
0
the y axis points azimuthally. Because the radial wavelength is short, we neglect the radial
variation in the surface density (R
) and the azimuthal variation in Z , and write
0
0
i(K x !t)
i!t
Z (R
; t) = Re[A
e
];
Z (R; t) = Re[A
e
];
(40)
0
0
where
R
R
i
K (R)dR
im (R)
A
A(R; t)e
e
:
(41)
0
Then equation (6) yields
F
(R; t) = G(R) Re
A
e
dx dy
sg
0
2
2
3=2
(x
+ y
)
Z
i!t
[1 exp(iK x)]
= 4G(R)jK jZ (R; t)
du
0
0
(1 + v
)
2
3=2
2
u
Z
Z
1
1
dv
(1 cos u)
= 2G(R)jK jZ (R; t):
(42)
The WKB dispersion relation follows from the dynamical equation (1),
D(! ; K ) [! m
(R)]
2G(R)jK j
(R) = 0:
(43)
h
2
2
At the corotation radius, the angular speed of the disk equals the pattern speed,
(R) =
= !=m.
p
At the vertical resonance radii K (R) = 0, that is, ! = m
(R)
(R) (cf. eq. 15). Because
2
2
2
h
the dispersion relation can only be satis ed when m
(
)
, there is a forbidden region
p
h
between the two vertical resonance radii and including corotation, in which WKB bending waves
cannot propagate.
The radial group velocity for WKB bending waves is (Toomre 1969, Whitham 1974)
@ !
G(R) sgn(K )
c
=
=
:
(44)
g
@K
m[
(R)
]
p
Thus the direction of propagation depends on whether the waves are leading (K < 0) or trailing
(K > 0), and on whether they are inside corotation (
>
, assuming that the angular speed
p
decreases outward) or outside.
{ 11 {
The equation of motion for vertical disturbances (1) can be derived from a Lagrangian. The
dynamics in the WKB limit are therefore described by an averaged Lagrangian that is obtained
by averaging over the short-wavelength oscillations (Whitham 1974),
L(! ; K; A) =
RjAj
D(! ; K );
(45)
2
1
2
where jAj is the wave amplitude and D(! ; K ) is the dispersion relation (43). The energy density
of the wave per unit radius is
@L
2
2
(R) = !
= m
R(R)
(
)jAj
:
(46)
p
p
@ !
The energy density is positive if the pattern speed is prograde (
> 0) and outside corotation
p
(
<
), or if the pattern speed is retrograde. The total energy of the disturbance is
p
Z
E
=
(R)dR;
(47)
w
which is the same as the energy derived in the previous section (eq. 29)in this case it happens
that the WKB approximation is exact.
The density of z angular momentum per unit radius is (Bertin & Mark 1980)
which is exactly consistent with equation (34).
j (R) = m
=
;
(48)
@L
(R)
@ !
p
3 Dynamical Friction Between a Warped Disk and a Spherical Halo
So far we have treated the halo potential as a static background eld, which in
uences the
disk only through its contribution to the vertical and radial restoring force. In fact, the halo
is composed of stars whose orbits respond to the time-varying gravitational eld of the warped
disk. The gravitational attraction between the coherent response of the halo and the warped
disk transfers energy and angular momentum between the two components, thereby dampingor
possibly excitingthe warp (dynamical friction).
To describe this response, we write the halo potential as U
(r) = U
(r) + U
(r; t), where the
h
h
h
0
1
two terms denote the static, unperturbed halo potential and the potential arising from its response
to the warp. The corresponding densities are
(r) and
(r; t). For consistency with Section
h
h
0
1
2.2, we de ne the energy of the bending disturbance in the disk, E
, to include the kinetic and
w
self-gravitational energies of the disk material plus its potential energy in the static eld U
, but
h
0
not its potential energy in the response eld U
; the forces arising from the latter eld are treated
h
1
as an external force F
= rU
. Thus
ext
h
1
{ 12 {
dE
w
dt
Z
Z
=
dr
v
F
=
drr (
v
)U
d
d
ext
d
d
1
Z
Z
@
d
@
d
1
0
h
1
h
=
dr
U
= G
drdr
h
0
@ t
@ t
jr r
j
Z
Z
@U
@U
1
1
d
w
=
dr
=
dr
:
(49)
h
h
@ t
@ t
where we have integrated by parts and used the continuity equation for the disk mass; the subscript
`d' denotes disk, and in the last line we have replaced the disk potential U
by the warp potential
d
U
since the potential of the unwarped disk is stationary. To rst order in the perturbation
w
strength we may write
= r (
r), where r(r; t) is the Lagrangian displacement of the
h
h
1
0
halo stars caused by the perturbation. The last line of equation (49) may now be written
Z
dE
@U
w
w
0
=
dr
r r
:
(50)
dt
@ t
h
There are two equivalent ways to determine the dynamical friction exerted by the halo on
the disk: (i) calculate the density and potential perturbation induced in the halo by the disk and
then integrate the resulting gravitational force from the halo over the disk mass distributionthis
is analogous to the standard discussion of Landau damping in a collisionless plasma (cf. Ichimaru
1973) and corresponds to the rst line in equation (49); (ii) calculate the rate of change of energy
of each halo star due to the warp, and integrate these energy changes over the halo (which
corresponds to eq. 50). We use the second approach in this paper.
Our calculations are based on the action-angle formalism developed in papers by Lynden-Bell
& Kalna js (1972), Tremaine & Weinberg (1984), and Weinberg (1986), which may be consulted
for details. Our analysis employs three (not very good) approximations: (i) the warp is small, so
that we can use perturbation theory in which the small parameter is the amplitude of the warp;
in this approximation both r and @U
=@ t are proportional to the warp amplitude so dE
=dt
d
w
is second-order in the amplitude (this is the same order as the energy of the warp computed in
Section 2.2; thus the damping rate
E
=E
is independent of amplitude); (ii) the unperturbed
w
w
_
potential (halo plus
at disk) is spherical; this is certainly incorrectand moreover inconsistent,
since we assume that the halo is axisymmetric but non-spherical when estimating the pattern
speed and energy of bending modesbut orbits in spherical potentials are easier to analyze than
orbits in
attened potentials and the dynamical friction force should not depend strongly on
the shape of the halo orbits; (iii) we neglect the self-gravity of the halo response; again, this is
certainly incorrect but unlikely to cause more than a factor of two or so error in the results.
In the unperturbed state (no warp) the motion of the halo stars is described by an autonomous
Hamiltonian H
. The phase-space coordinates of a star are speci ed using the action-angle
0
variables of this Hamiltonian (I; w); in these coordinates H
= H
(I) so that Hamilton's equations
0
0
become
_
@H
@H
0
0
I =
= 0;
w =
_
(I);
(51)
@w
@ I
{ 13 {
with solutions
I(t) I
= constant
w(t) w
(t) =
(I
)t + constant:
(52)
0
0
0
The density of halo stars in phase space is described by a distribution function (hereafter df) F
and Jeans' theorem implies that F = F (I).
When a warp is present the Hamiltonian becomes
Hamilton's equations become
H = H
+ U
:
(53)
0
w
_
@U
@U
w
w
I =
;
w =
(I) +
_
:
(54)
@w
@ I
The perturbing potential can be expanded in an action-angle Fourier series (cf. Appendix A),
8
9
<
=
1
1
X
X
i(lw !
t)
l
U
(I; w; t) = Re
(I)e
:
(55)
w
l
l
l
1
2
3
:
;
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
The rst-order corrections to the orbit (52) caused by the perturbation are
@
@
I =
;
w =
(56)
@w
@ I
where
8
9
Z
t
<
i(lw !
t)
=
1
1
X
X
e
l
=
U
dt = Re
;
(57)
w
l
l
l
1
2
3
1
i(l
!
)
l
:
;
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
and these quantities are evaluated along the unperturbed orbit (I
; w
). We have assumed that
0
0
!
has a small positive imaginary part, , as if the potential were turned on slowly in the distant
l
past.
The integrand of equation (50) may be written
@U
@
U
@
U
w
w
w
2
2
r r
=
(I
; w
; t)I +
(I
; w
; t)w:
(58)
0
0
0
0
@ t
@ I@ t
@w@ t
We evaluate this expression using equations (55){(57). Since the df depends only on the actions
we can average the result over the unperturbed angles w
. As described in Tremaine & Weinberg
0
(1984), the terms in this expression involve combinations of periodic exponentials, most of which
vanish upon averaging over initial phases
. Combining the surviving terms we nd
5
1
1
X
X
2t
@U
@
2(!
l
)e
w
2
l
(
)
r r
=
l
j
(I)j
;
(59)
@ t
@ I
2(jl
!
j
+
)
w
l
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
l
2
2
5
Or are oscillatory in time, in the case l
= 0.
3
{ 14 {
where !
is now taken to be real as the contribution from the small imaginary part is written
l
out explicitly. We now use the identity
lim
= (x):
(60)
!0
x
+
+
2
2
Integrating over the df of halo stars nally gives the rate of change of the disk energy
(cf. eq. 50),
6
Z
Z
_
E
=
dIdwF (I)r r
= (2 )
dIF (I)
r r
d
@U
w
3
@U
w
@ t
@ t
w
1
1
Z
X
X
4
2
@ F (I)
= 4
dI(l
)l
j
(I)j
(l
!
)
@ I
l
l
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
1
1
Z
X
X
4
2
4
dS l(l
)F (I)j
(I)j
(l
!
);
(61)
l
l
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
where dS is the area element on the boundary of action space and we have set t = 0. For
most dfs the last (surface) term vanishes, as the following argument shows: Let dS be an
area element on the boundary of action space. The
ux of stars through this element with
angles in the interval dw is dwdS
IF (I); using equations (54) and (55) this
ux equals
_
P
dwdS lF (I)Refi
(I) exp[i(l w !
t)]g. The terms in this sum are linearly independent
l
l
l
functions of w. Since stars cannot leave action space, each term in the sum must be zero. Thus
dS lF (I)
(I) must vanish, which implies that the surface term in (61) must vanish. (This
l
argument can fail if the df diverges on the boundary of action space.) If the surface term vanishes,
equation (61) simpli es to
_
4
2
@ F (I)
1
1
Z
X
X
E
= 4
dI(l
)l
j
(I)j
(l
!
):
(62)
d
l
l
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
@ I
Only resonant orbits with l
(I) = !
contribute to the energy transfer; a particular resonant
l
triplet l = (l
; l
; l
) contributes to a net damping or growth of the perturbation depending on the
1
2
3
components of
(I) and the gradient of F (I) along the resonant triplet.
Finally, we note that the formalism we have developed is related to Goodman's (1988) stability
criterion for galaxies, which is based on the sign of a quadratic functional of a trial perturbation.
Consider a trial perturbation U
with time dependence e
with real (not e
as we have
w
t
im
t+t
p
assumed so far). Then Goodman shows that a sucient criterion for instability is
Z
0
2
G
[Z (R; t) Z (R
; t)]
_
0
0
E
>
dRdR
(R)(R
)
;
(63)
w
2
jR R
j
0
3
6
Our result is consistent with equation (65) of Tremaine & Weinberg (1984), who assume l
6= 0 and a single pattern
3
_
speed, so that !
= l
and the torque is related to the rate of energy change by
E =
(Jacobi's integral).
3
p
p
z
l
We have assumed that the evolution of the warp is suciently rapid that we are in the `fast' limit of Tremaine and
Weinberg, that is, that the damping rate is large compared to the perturbation strength; this assumption is always
justi ed if the warp amplitude is suciently small, because the damping time is independent of amplitude.
{ 15 {
where
E
is de ned by equation (49) and evaluated using equation (59)compare Goodman's
w
_
equation (24).
3.1 Halos with isotropic distribution functions
An important special case is an unperturbed halo df that depends on energy alone,
F = F (E ) = F [H
(I)]. Then equations (51) and (62) imply
0
_
4
2
2
dF
1
1
Z
X
X
E
= 4
dI(l
)
j
(I)j
(l
!
):
(64)
d
l
l
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
dE
In most model galaxies with F = F (E ) the halo df is a decreasing function of energy, dF =dE < 0;
following Goodman (1988), we call these `iddf halos' (for `isotropic, decreasing distribution
function'). In iddf halos, equation (64) implies that
E
< 0. In other words, in iddf halos, a
d
_
warped disk always loses energy to the halo. Thus disk disturbances with positive energy damp,
while disturbances with negative energy grow.
Equation (22) shows that bending disturbances with a single azimuthal wavenumber m 0
have positive energy if
(R) > m
(R) at all radii. Thus in iddf halos, dynamical friction damps
h
all bending disturbances so long as
(R) > m
(R) at all R:
(65)
h
For m = 1 disturbances, equation (25) implies that the damping criterion (65) can be replaced by
the stronger damping criterion
(R) >
(R) at all R;
(66)
h
h
which is the condition that the halo is vertically sti . In other words, in vertical ly sti iddf halos,
al l m = 1 bending disturbances damp.
Bertin & Mark (1980) examined the evolution of short-wavelength bending waves of a
thin disk embedded in a halo. The halo was assumed to have an isotropic Maxwellian velocity
distribution, and the disk dynamics were analyzed in the WKB approximation. They concluded
that dynamical friction from the halo would excite all bending waves propagating inside the
corotation radius. Toomre (1983) has pointed out that the validity of this conclusion is suspect,
because Bertin and Mark ignored the halo's contribution to the vertical frequency, e ectively
setting
= 0 and thereby ensuring that the halo was vertically soft. The more general approach
h
developed in this paper allows a rapid derivation of the correct answer: if, like Bertin and Mark,
we assume an iddf halo, then bending waves are excited by dynamical friction from the halo if
and only if they have negative energy. From equation (46) the energy density of a WKB bending
wave is negative if and only if
0 <
<
(R);
(67)
p
i.e. for prograde waves inside corotation.
{ 16 {
Equation (67) is the condition for excitation of WKB bending waves for any iddf halo. The
WKB dispersion relation (43) for m = 1 waves implies that j
j
, so a necessary condition
p
h
7
for excitation is
<
, which is consistent with the damping criterion (65)
. These results imply
h
that the excitation of WKB bending waves by the halo is considerably more dicult than Bertin
& Mark (1980) assumed.
We shall not pursue the analysis of WKB bending waves further, since the WKB approximation
is invalid for most observed galactic warps. Instead we shall focus on numerical evaluation of
damping and excitation rates for more realistic warps.
3.2 A model for the halo
In this section we describe the analytic model for the halo df that we shall use in our numerical
estimates of damping rates.
In a universe dominated by collisionless dark matter, galaxy halos form by the gravitational
collapse of random peaks in the cosmological density eld (cf. Warren et al. 1992 and references
therein). Both analytic arguments and numerical simulations show that halos have power-law
density pro les that are roughly consistent with the pro les / r
implied by observations
2
of
at rotation curves of spiral galaxies. The simulated halos tend to be triaxial with minor to
ma jor axis ratios c=a 0:5, although the uncertain e ects of dissipation are likely to reduce the
triaxiality (Katz & Gunn 1991; Dubinski 1994). The velocity ellipsoid in the halo is radially
elongated: the ratio of the mean-square radial velocity to the mean-square tangential velocity is
given by 2hv
i=hv
i ' 1:4 (Dubinski 1992), whereas an isotropic dispersion tensor would have the
r
t
2
2
value unity. Tidal torquing from neighboring structures gives the halo a net angular momentum;
Dubinski nds that the ratio of the maximum rotation velocity to the central line-of-sight velocity
dispersion is roughly correlated with the dimensionless spin parameter, v
=
4, where
max
c
= J jE j
G
M
has a median value of about 0:05 (White 1984; Barnes & Efstathiou 1987;
1=2
1
5=2
Zurek et al. 1988).
To simplify our calculations we ignore the intrinsic triaxiality of the halo and the contribution
of the disk to the total potential: thus we assume a halo df, halo orbits, and a rotation curve
for the disk that are consistent with a spherical potential provided entirely by the halo. This
approximation is not strictly consistent, since we assume that the halo is axisymmetric but
non-spherical when estimating the pattern speed of bending modes or calculating the mode energy
7
In the WKB approximation the damping criteria (65) and (66) are generally the same when m = 1, because
there is no distinction between
and
. The reason is that the dispersion relation (43) can usually be satis ed
h
in the WKB limit (jK Rj 1) only if the surface density is small, so the disk's contribution to the total rotation
speed
is negligible.
{ 17 {
(see eq. 75 at the end of this subsection). The bias caused by the spherical approximation should
lead us to underestimate the damping and excitation rates in the likely case that the halo is
attened towards the disk plane, since the halo density will be higher and the velocity of the halo
stars will be lower than we have assumed.
Our model for the halo df: (i) assumes that the halo potential generates a
at rotation curve
with circular speed v
,
c
2
r
which implies a halo density
U
(r) = v
ln
;
(68)
h
c
r
s
2
2
r
U (r)
v
c
(r) =
=
(69)
4G
4Gr
2
(r
is a ducial radius, which eventually scales out of the problem); (ii) allows for a range of
s
velocity ansiotropy, expressed by the ratio 2hv
i=hv
i; (iii) allows a non-zero mean rotation speed
r
t
2
2
hv
i, which is taken to be independent of radius.
The df that we use is
F (E ; J; J
) = F
J
e
(1 + J
=J );
(70)
z
0
z
2(
1)
E =
2
where E is the energy, J is the angular momentum, and J
is the component of angular momentum
z
normal to the unperturbed disk. The parameter controls the halo rotation, while
controls the
velocity anisotropy; we must have j j 1 so that the df is non-negative, and
> 0 so that the
spatial density is nite
. In order that this df generates the density (69) we must have
8
2
+1=2
2
c
v
1
=
;
F
=
;
(71)
2
4
r
Gv
s
c
J
(
)
s
0
5=2
2
2(
1)
where J
= r
v
. In the special case = 0,
= 1, the df and potential reduce to those of the
s
s
c
singular isothermal sphere (the normalization is the same as Weinberg 1986, eq. 24). In turn, F is
a special case of the larger classes of scale-free dfs discussed by Gerhard (1991) and Evans (1994).
The mean-square velocities in the radial and tangential directions are
2
2
2
2
hv
i =
;
hv
i = 2
;
(72)
r
t
so the ratio of the principal axes of the velocity ellipsoid is given by
2
2hv
i
1
r
2
=
;
(73)
hv
i
t
8
Galaxies with predominantly radial orbits are likely to be unstable; in fact Palmer & Papaloizou (1987) have
shown that all galaxies with distribution functions that are unbounded as J ! 0 are unstable. However their proof
assumes that the resonant combination of frequencies
2
/ J as J ! 0; while this is generally true for galaxies
1
2
with a
at central core, in the singular isothermal sphere
2
/ 1=j ln J j as J ! 0, and the Palmer-Papaloizou
1
2
proof does not apply. In any case, it is not crucial for our purposes to work with stable halo models, because the
self-gravity of the halo responsewhich is central to the instabilityis neglected in our calculations of dynamical
friction.
{ 18 {
a halo with nearly radial orbits corresponds to
! 0 while one with nearly circular orbits has
! 1. The mean rotation speed is
hv
i
(
+
)
1
v
c
=
sin :
(74)
2
1=2
2
(
)
The cosmological simulations described above suggest that typical parameter values are
' 0:7
(from the velocity anisotropy) and ' 0:4 (we have identi ed v
with hv
i( =
) and 3
max
2
c
1
2
with hv
i + hv
i).
r
t
2
2
Finally, when estimating the pattern speed or energy of a bending mode, we generalize the
expression for the halo potential (68) to an axisymmetric halo:
1
2
2
2
2
U
(R; z ) =
v
ln
R
+ z
=q
;
(75)
h
2
c
where q
is the axial ratio of the equipotential surfaces and
1 q
is their ellipticity (
> 0
for oblate halos and < 0 for prolate halos). In this case the vertical and azimuthal frequencies in
the eld of the halo are (eqs. 2 and 5)
v
c
v
c
=
;
=
:
(76)
h
h
q
R
R
3.3 A model for the warp
To calculate the damping rate in a realistic warped galaxy we need to know the shape of the warp
h(R) (eq. 7) and its associated gravitational potential U
(r). Rather than solving equation (8) to
w
obtain an exact eigenfunction, we have chosen a simple analytic parametrization of the warp. We
assume that the surface density of the disk is exponential,
(R) =
e
;
(77)
0
R=R
d
so that the total disk mass M
= 2
R
. We set the parameter
d
0
d
2
GM
d
2
R
v
d
c
= 1:6;
(78)
in all of our simulations, which is roughly correct for our Galaxy. We write h(R) = R
f (R=R
)
d
d
where R
is the scale length of the disk. If the mode has real eigenfrequency then we can assume
d
that h(R) is real (by the anti-spiral theorem of Lynden-Bell & Ostriker 1967); in this case the line
of nodes is radial, which is approximately consistent with observations.
Our parametrization has the form
f (x) = C x
e
;
(79)
n
x
where C is an arbitrary normalization (recall that the damping rate is independent of the
amplitude). This parametrization permits us to model two distinct types of warps. (i) For n = 1
{ 19 {
the inner part of the disk is tilted relative to the halo (as in the Laplace mode) and the outer disk
is
at; in this case equation (79) gives a warp whose curvature in its outer parts is more gradual
than observed warps (see Figure 1a), but this is not a ma jor defect since most of the interaction
with the halo comes from the tilted inner disk, which is not curved either in our model or in real
galaxies. (ii) For n 1 the inner disk is
at and the outer disk is tilted. In this case the shape of
the warp can be made to closely resemble observed warps (except that at very large radii the disk
becomes
at againits maximum height is at x
= n=but if x
1 the surface density in
max
max
the region where the disk becomes
at again will be negligible).
An advantage of the functional form (79) is that the spherical harmonic expansion of the warp
potential U
(r)Y
(; ) can be evaluated in terms of incomplete gamma functions (see Appendix
ln
ln
B).
Fig. 1a. The solid line shows the shape of a typical warp used in our estimates of the warp
damping/excitation rate, derived from eq. (79) with C = 1, n = 1, = 0:2. The dotted and
dashed lines indicate the rst two non-zero components, U
(r); U
(r), of the spherical harmonic
21
41
expansion of the potential of the warped disk with m = 1; the scale for the potentials is shown on
the right hand axis in units of GM
=R
.
d
d
{ 20 {
Fig. 1b. The pattern speed in units of v
=R
(the angular speed of the disk at one scale length),
c
d
as a function of the ellipticity of the halo potential. The pattern speed is computed using the warp
shape in Figure 1a and eq. (14)the solution of the quadratic equation with the smaller value of
j
j is shown. The dotted line corresponds to the Sparke-Casertano formula (eq. 17).
p
Fig. 1c. Energy of the warp shown in (a) as a function of the ellipticity of the halo potential,
computed from eqs. (29), (77) and (78).
{ 21 {
Figure 1a shows an example of a warp shape parametrized by equation (79) with n = 1 and
= 0:2, along with the radial potential functions associated with the rst two nonvanishing m = 1
spherical harmonics, U
(r), U
(r). Figure 1b shows the pattern speed for this warp, calculated
21
41
using equation (14), as a function of the halo ellipticity
(eq. 75). The dotted line shows the
Sparke-Casertano formula for the pattern speed (eq. 17), which is a good approximation to the
more accurate formula. Figure 1c shows the energy of the warp (eq. 29) with C = 1. The gure
illustrates that warps embedded in vertically sti halos (
> 0) generally precess in a retrograde
direction (
< 0) and have positive energy, while warps embedded in vertically soft halos (
< 0)
p
precess in a prograde direction (
> 0) and have negative energy.
p
4 Calculation of Damping and Excitation Rates
We now calculate the rate of change of the warp energy, and the resulting damping or growth rate
caused by dynamical friction from the halo. Weinberg (1986) has described similar calculations,
based on a formula analogous to (62), for the rate of decay of a satellite on a circular orbit in a
spherical potential. Thus we have simply summarized the principal formulae in Appendix A and
refer the reader to Weinberg (1986) for details.
The formula (62) for the rate of change of the warp energy is combined with equation (29) for
the energy to obtain the characteristic evolution rate
1
dE
w
=
;
(80)
E
dt
w
> 0 implies excitation and < 0 implies damping. In our model the evolution rate is a
function of the velocity anisotropy of the halo (parametrized by
), the rotation of the halo
(parametrized by ), the warp pattern speed (written in dimensionless form as
R
=v
), and the
p
d
c
shape of the bending disturbance; it is proportional to the mass of the disk but independent of
the amplitude of the disturbance (for small perturbations) since both the energy and the rate of
energy change scale with the square of the amplitude.
We evaluate the action-angle transform of the perturbing potential using equations (A1){(A3)
and (A23), along with equations (79) and (B9){(B10) for the warp shape and potential. We
treat the integrals in equations (A10), (A11) and (A23) as the solutions to a coupled set of
ordinary di erential equations, which we integrate using an adaptive Runge-Kutta routine. We
use Romberg integration to evaluate the integral in equation (A26), summing over the possible
resonant triplets in the integrand itself, rather than evaluating an integral for each term separately.
Since the number of resonant triplets grows / l
, we must cut o the summation at a relatively
3
small maximum harmonic l
. Experiments on a few points show that
E (l
) =
E + C l
, with
max
max
max
_
_
' 1. In practice we evaluated
E (l
) at l
= 2; 4, and 6, tting these values to a quadratic
max
max
_
1
in l
, and extrapolate to l
! 1. We believe that the damping/excitation rates we have
max
max
obtained are accurate to within 3%.
{ 22 {
We have veri ed our results in the epicycle limit (1 1) where the functional form for the
potential transforms becomes analytic, and also compared our formulas with similar transforms
calculated by Weinberg (1985).
Fig. 2. The damping rate =
E
=E
as a function of the ellipticity of the halo potential. The
w
w
_
warp shape is shown in Figure 1a. The halo df is described by eq. (70) with
= 1 (isotropic velocity
distribution). Warps with > 0 grow, while those with < 0 damp. Damping or excitation occurs
within a Hubble time if j j > 0:0015 (assuming R
=v
= 1:5 10
y). The small errorbar centered
d
c
7
at
= 0 corresponds to the range of damping rates where damping or excitation does not occur
within a Hubble time. The dotted, solid, and dashed lines correspond respectively to halos with
rotation parameters = 1; 0; 1 described in the text; these values span the range of possible
rotation rates.
Figure 2 shows the dimensionless damping/excitation rate R
=v
as a function of the
d
c
halo ellipticity
. The warp has the shape shown in Figure 1a and is embedded in a halo
with an isotropic velocity distribution, 2hv
i=hv
i = 1. For parameters corresponding to those
r
t
2
2
of our Galaxy, R
=v
= 1:5 10
y, the damping/excitation time is less than 10
y when
d
c
7
10
j jR
=v
> 0:0015.
d
c
{ 23 {
We plot results for three values of which span the range of possible rotation rates consistent
with our model (eq. 74). First consider the non-rotating halo ( = 0) with isotropic velocity
distribution (an iddf halo in the notation of Section 3.1). As shown in that section, a warp
always loses energy to an iddf halo. Thus warps with positive energy damp. However, if the
halo is vertically soft (
< 0, which obtains if the disk lies in the equatorial plane of a prolate
halo potential), the energy of the warp is negative (Figure 1c). Thus, a warp embedded in a
non-rotating, vertically soft iddf halo can grow in amplitude, while one embedded in a vertically
sti halo must damp.
Halo rotation tends to increase the rate of change of warp energy
E
if the halo rotates in
w
_
the same sense as the pattern speed, and decreases
E
if the halo rotates in the opposite sense.
w
_
Thus, adding rotation tends to increase (or decrease) the warp amplitude if the sign of
=E
p
w
is positive (negative). If the pattern speed is small, E
=
is always negative (eq. 29); thus halo
w
p
rotation contributes to warp growth only if the halo rotates in the opposite sense to the disk.
Fig. 3. Same as Figure 2, but with for a halo with predominantly radial orbits, 2hv
i=hv
i = 1:5.
r
t
2
2
Note that the vertical range of the graph is a factor of ten larger than Figure 2.
Figure 3 shows the damping/excitation rates for warps embedded in halos with predominantly
{ 24 {
radial orbits, 2hv
i=hv
i = 1:5. The damping rate is much larger than in the isotropic case; in fact
2
2
r
t
>
so large (j j
j
j) that our treatment of the warp as a slowly evolving normal mode is suspect.
p
Fig. 4. Same as Figure 2, but with for a halo with predominantly circular orbits, 2hv
i=hv
i = 0:5.
r
t
2
2
Note that the vertical range is only half as large as Figure 2.
Figure 4 shows the damping/excitation rates for warps embedded in halos with predominantly
circular orbits, 2hv
i=hv
i = 0:5. In this case energy
ows from the halo to the warp, a consequence
r
t
2
2
of the strong anisotropy in the phase space distribution function. Thus positive energy warps
(
> 0) grow, while negative energy warps damp.
Figure 5 shows the dimensionless damping rate as a function of the halo velocity anisotropy,
for a warped disk with a retrograde pattern speed, R
=v
= 0:5; this pattern speed corresponds
d
p
c
to a halo whose equipotentials have ellipticity
= 0:5 (Figure 1b). For halos with predominantly
circular orbits the warp is excited, while in halos dominated by radial orbits it is damped. An
interesting feature is that the damping rate diverges as hv
i=hv
i ! 2, corresponding to
!
.
r
t
2
2
2
1
We show in Appendi<x C that the apparent divergence is an artifact of the perturbation theory
that we have used: according to equation (61) the rate of energy loss
E
arising from the response
w
_
of the halo to a perturbation potential is O(
), but in fact the response is O(
) where
2
p
{ 25 {
Fig. 5. The damping rate as a function of the velocity anisotropy of the halo. The halo
equipotentials are oblate,
= 0:5. The dotted, solid, and dashed lines correspond to halos with
dimensionless rotation = 1:0; 0:0; 1:0. Halos with predominantly circular orbits excite the warp,
while halos with predominantly radial orbits damp the warp.
{ 26 {
p = min(2; 2
+ 1); thus for
<
the energy loss rate is of lower order than O(
). Our analysis
1
2
2
1
is not powerful enough to determine the damping rate for halos with
<
; nevertheless it is clear
2
that the damping is very strong when the orbits of the halo stars are predominantly radial.
We have also examined the damping of disks that are only warped relative to the halo in their
outer parts (eq. 79 with n = 5, = 1). Although the damping/excitation times are substantially
longer, signi cant damping still generally occurs in less than a Hubble time.
5 Discussion and Conclusions
The most striking feature shown by Figures 2{4 is the rapid evolution of the warps from dynamical
friction. All of the models we examined had damping/excitation times less than a Hubble time
when the halo ellipticity was larger than 0.2, and in general the damping/excitation times were
much shorter than a Hubble time. For example, in a non-rotating halo with a plausible value of
the velocity anisotropy, 2hv
i=hv
i = 1:5 (recall from Section 3.2 that cosmological simulations
r
t
2
2
yield a typical value of 1.4 for this parameter), the damping time
= 10
y even when the
1
8
ellipticity of the halo potential is as small as
= 0:2.
Thus our numerical results show that dynamical friction between a warped galaxy disk and
its surrounding dark matter halo usually leads to signi cant evolution of the warp over a Hubble
time. The rate of evolution depends strongly on the velocity anisotropy and net rotation of the
halo stars and the ellipticity of the halo potential.
Dynamical friction can either damp or excite a warp: warps can have either positive or
negative energy, and friction can either add energy to or remove energy from the warp. If the disk
lies in the equatorial plane of an axisymmetric halo, then the energy of an m = 1 warp is generally
positive if the halo is oblate or vertically sti , and negative if the halo is prolate or vertically soft.
A non-rotating iddf halo always removes energy from the warp. Halos with predominantly radial
orbits remove energy more rapidly than halos with an isotropic velocity distribution, while in the
unlikely case that the halo orbits are predominantly circular, dynamical friction can add energy to
the warp. The e ect of halo rotation is to add energy to the warp if the mean rotation rate is in
the same direction as the precession of the warp, and to remove energy otherwise.
Our assumption that the halo is axisymmetric is a ma jor oversimpli cation, since cosmological
simulations of galaxy formation typically produce halos that have highly triaxial shapes. The
formation of gaseous disks in triaxial potentials has been investigated by analytic arguments
and numerical simulations (Steiman-Cameron & Durisen 1984, Habe & Ikeuchi 1985, Pearce &
Thomas 1991, Thomas et al. 1994). Disks can form in the principal plane normal to the ma jor
or the minor axis (orbits in the principal plane normal to the intermediate axis are unstable).
As a rst approximation, we may treat the halo as vertically sti if the disk is normal to the
minor axis and vertically soft if the disk is normal to the ma jor axis. The principal plane in
which accreted gas will settle depends on its initial angular momentum; simple analytic arguments
{ 27 {
based on perturbation theory imply that the probability that gas with randomly directed angular
momentum will settle into the principal plane normal to the ma jor axis is 2I
= , where
crit
2
2
2
b
a
sin
I
=
:
(81)
crit
2
2
c
a
Taking typical halo axis ratios of c=a = 0:45, b=a = 0:7 (Dubinski & Carlberg 1991, Warren et
al. 1992), we nd that the probability that disks lie in the principal plane normal to the ma jor
axis is roughly 0.3; this is an upper limit since in practice the angular momentum vector of the
infalling gas is strongly correlated with that of the halo material (e.g. Katz & Gunn 1991) For
the minority of galaxies in which the disk forms in the principal plane normal to the halo ma jor
axis, our results show that the disk is likely to be strongly unstable to warping; the outcome of
this instability is presumably the settling of the disk into the principal plane normal to the minor
9
axis
. It is possible that some warped galaxies are a manifestation of this instability.
Rotating halos can also excite warps. Warps in vertically sti halos generally have retrograde
pattern speeds (eq. 17) and positive energy, so that excitation requires that the halo and the
disk rotate in opposite directions; as we have mentioned, cosmological simulations show that the
angular momentum vectors of halos and their embedded disks are generally similar (although polar
rings [Casertano et al. 1991] and counter-rotating disks [Rubin et al. 1992] o er counter-examples).
Warps can also be excited if the halo orbits are predominantly circular, but simulations of galaxy
formation suggest that halo orbits are radial rather than circular. Thus excitation by either of
these mechanisms is unlikely to be the ma jor cause of warps either.
A general diculty with explaining warps by excitation from dynamical friction is that the
excitation timescales are short compared to a Hubble time, and there is no obvious nonlinear
process to limit the amplitude of the warps at their observed values.
In the ma jority of galaxies, for which dynamical friction damps rather than excites warps,
the damping time is short compared to the Hubble time. In the plausible case that halos have
predominantly radial orbits, the damping time is often shorter than even the precession time
2=j
j (Figure 2).
p
These results bring into sharp focus the problem of exciting warps. Ostriker & Binney
(1989) have argued that normal galaxy formation processes will not excite the Laplace mode; our
calculations show that even if the mode were excited during galaxy formation, it would by now
have been damped away. Thus we require an excitation mechanism that operates throughout the
life of the galaxy.
One plausible mechanism is twisting of the halo by cosmic infall (Ostriker & Binney
1989). Both analytic arguments and N-body simulations show that the direction of the angular
momentum vector of a haloand hence the orientation of its principal planesis reoriented by
9
A corollary is that massive polar rings should be unstable.
{ 28 {
infalling material with each doubling of the halo age (see Binney 1992 for a review). This steadily
changing orientation is communicated to the inner halo and disk by gravitational torques; the
warp arises because it is necessary to transport o -axis angular momentum between the inner and
outer disk. In this model the warp amplitude is determined by the present rate of twisting rather
than the past history of excitation and damping.
Our results can be applied to warps with other azimuthal wavenumbers; although we have
done no calculations we can make some comments. Sparke (1994) has argued that axisymmetric
(m = 0) `bowl-shaped' modes may be present in spiral galaxies and polar rings. The analysis of
Section 2.2 shows that all m = 0 warps have positive energy; hence they will be damped in an
iddf halo. Symmetry arguments show that halo rotation will not tend to excite axisymmetric
modes either. We expect the damping from dynamical friction to be rapid, since the frequency of
the m = 0 mode is usually much larger than the pattern speed of the Lagrange mode. Thus it
is unlikely that m = 0 modes are excited by dynamical friction; and if they are excited by other
mechanisms, they will be rapidly damped. For higher azimuthal wavenumbers, m 2, there is a
continuum of bending modes in realistic disks, so such modes will disperse even without damping
from the halo.
We close this section with a summary of the approximations we have made:
1. We have used linear perturbation theory (in the warp amplitude), which is inadequate:
observed warps may have amplitudes
10
, which represents only the di erence in
>
inclination between the inner disk and the outer edge. In perturbation theory the tilted
disk tends to align with the equatorial plane of the halo; in reality a tilted disk with mass
comparable to the inner halo has much more angular momentum than the halo, so that the
inner halo tends to align with the disk rather than the disk with the halo (then over a longer
timescale the outer halo continues to exert signi cant frictional force and eventually brings
all three components to a common alignment).
2. In calculating the orbits of halo stars, we have assumed that the unperturbed potential of
the halo plus disk is spherical, whereas in fact the halo potential is probably triaxial and
the disk provides an additional
attened component. With a more realistic potential the
friction would probably be increased, since the halo would generally be
attened towards
the disk plane so its interaction with the warp would be stronger. An inconsistency in our
calculations is that we assume the halo is axisymmetric but non-spherical when computing
the warp energy and pattern speed.
3. We have approximated the halo potential as that of a singular isothermal sphere. This
approximation leads us to underestimate the damping/excitation for warps with small
pattern speeds, since the absence of a core implies that fewer halo stars are close to the
(l
; l
) = (1; 2) resonance that dominates the friction at small pattern speeds.
1
2
4. We have neglected the self-gravity of the halo response in order to simplify the friction
{ 29 {
calculations. Including the self-gravity of the halo response should generally increase the
dynamical friction (for satellites, the inclusion of the response self-gravity decreases the
friction [Hernquist & Weinberg 1989], but this re
ects mainly the diculty of treating the
motion of the center of mass consistently without self-gravity), and therefore strengthen our
conclusion that the damping times are short.
5. We have treated the disk as razor-thin, with no internal structure. The dispersion relation
for bending or corrugation waves in stellar systems with slab geometry (uniform in x and
y , self-gravitating, and symmetric about the z = 0 plane) has been investigated by Araki
(1985), Weinberg (1991), and Toomre (1966, 1994). The bending wave is damped by
near-resonant stars; if the horizontal variation of the bending wave is / exp[i(k x ! t)],
the resonant stars are those with k v = n (E
) + ! , where n is an integer and (E
) is the
z
z
vertical oscillation frequency as a function of vertical energy (this approximation neglects
the curvature of the epicyclic orbits in a real galaxy disk, but this should not invalidate
our analysis since the epicycle frequency is small compared to ). If the typical horizontal
velocity dispersion is , the criterion for signi cant dampingplenty of resonant starsis
k= (0) > 1 + j! j= (0). The term j! j= (0) is usually negligible for Laplace modes, which
have small pattern speeds. Taking = 2=k = 10 kpc, = 40km s
, (0) = 3 10
s
1
15
1
(corresponding to a local density of 0:15M
pc
), we nd k= (0) = 0:3; which is probably
3
too small for signi cant damping in a typical warp.
Many of the concerns raised by these assumptions can be addressed by N-body simulations,
which complement the analytic approach described here. Dubinski & Kuijken (1994) have recently
examined the evolution of tilted disks (both rigid and N-body) embedded in N-body halos. They
nd that the disk rapidly aligns with the inner halo, and the damping times that they observe are
even shorter than the ones we calculate (probably because the disk contains most of the angular
momentum, so that the halo aligns with the disk rather than vice versa). Our results suggest
other worthwhile N-body experiments. It would be interesting to con rm whether warps can be
excited in rotating or vertically soft halos, to test our prediction that the damping is strongest in
halos with predominantly radial orbits, and to investigate the fate of massive polar rings.
Our conclusions are summarized brie
y in the abstract.
We acknowledge helpful discussions with James Binney, Omer Blaes, Ray Carlberg, John
Dubinski, Peter Goldreich, Linda Sparke, and Alar Toomre. This research was supported by
NSERC.
A The Dimensionless Energy Loss Rate
We wish to evaluate the rate of energy transfer to the disk given by equation (62).
{ 30 {
An orbit in a spherical potential can be described by the canonical actions
(I
; I
; I
) = (I
; J; J
), and their conjugate angles (w
; w
; w
); I
is the radial action, and
1
2
3
r
z
1
2
3
r
J and J
are the magnitude of the total angular momentum and its component along e
which
z
z
we take to be normal to the unperturbed disk. The conjugate angles vary from 0 to 2 , with
frequencies given by Hamilton's equations (51).
Following Tremaine & Weinberg (1984) and Weinberg (1986), we expand the perturbing
potential from the warped disk in both spherical harmonics and an action-angle Fourier series (cf.
eq. 55)
,
10
U
(r; t) =
U
(r)Y
(; 0)e
w
ln
ln
in(
t)
p
1
l
X
X
l=1
n= l
8
9
<
=
1
1
X
X
= Re
(I)e
(A1)
i(lw !
t)
l
:
;
l
l
l
1
2
3
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
3
1
2
where l
= jnj, !
= l
, U
= ( 1)
U
, and the radial functions U
are derived in Appendix
3
3
p
l; n
ln
l
ln
n
B. The amplitudes in the two lines of equation (A1) are related by
1
X
2
l
1
(I
; I
; I
) =
V
( )W
(I
; I
);
(A2)
l
l
l
1
2
3
ll
l
1
2
1
2
3
2
3
ll
l
2
3
l=1
1 +
l
0
3
where
V
( ) = r
( )Y
(
; 0)i
;
(A3)
ll
l
2
3
l
l
2
3
ll
2
2
l
1
l
l
3
2
l
1
Z
1
W
(I
; I
) =
dw
cos[l
w
l
( w
)]U
(r);
(A4)
ll
l
2
3
1
2
1
1
1
2
2
ll
3
0
here is the angle in the orbital plane measured from the ascending node, and explicit formulae
for the angles w
and w
are given in Tremaine & Weinberg (1984) and below (eqs. A10 and A11).
1
2
Here cos = J
=J is the cosine of the orbital inclination, and r
( ) are rotation matrices which
z
l
l
2
3
l
satisfy the orthogonality condition (cf. Gottfried 1979, section 34.5)
Z
l
l
0
2
d sin r
( )r
( ) =
mn
mn
0
:
ll
(A5)
0
2l + 1
It can be shown that
=
.
l
l
For the logarithmic potential given in equation (68) it is convenient to de ne a dimensionless
radius and angular momentum (Weinberg 1986)
r
2
J
E =v
c
~r =
e
;
=
;
(A6)
r
s
J
(E )
c
10
i!t
in
t
p
When n = 0 the time-dependence must be written as e
rather than e
. For simplicity, we shall not
explicitly include this special case in our formulae.
{ 31 {
where J
(E ) = J
e
is the maximum angular momentum possible for a given energy (a
c
s
2
(E =v
1=2)
c
circular orbit) and J
= r
v
. In these variables the orbital frequencies can be written in the form
s
s
c
(E ; J ) e
();
(A7)
i
i
E =v
2
c
where the new frequencies are given by
= (v
=r
)
,
e
i
c
s
i
I
1
1
d~r
e
() =
1
;
(A8)
2
( 2 ln ~r
=e~r
)
2
2
1=2
I
e
()
1
d~r
e
() =
2
;
(A9)
1=2
2
2
2
1=2
2e
~r
( 2 ln ~r
=e~r
)
and
= 0. The integrations are taken over a complete orbit with turning points determined by
3
the roots of the denominators.
11
The angles are de ned as a function of the dimensionless radius by
Z
~r
d~r
w
(~r) =
()
;
(A10)
e
1
1
~r
p
( 2 ln ~r
=e~r
)
2
2
1=2
()
d~r
2
Z
~r
w
=
w
:
(A11)
2
1
()
1
e
~r
( 2 ln ~r
=e~r
)
~r
p
1=2
2
2
2
1=2
We divide the directional derivative of the df in equation (70) into two parts, even and odd
in cos ,
@ F
@ F
@ F
@ F
l
= l
+ l
+ l
= F
(E ; J ) + F
(E ; J ) cos ;
(A12)
2
3
1
2
@ I
@E
@ J
@ J
J;J
z
E ;J
E ;J
z
z
where
F
(E ; J ) = F
J
e
+
[2(
1)l
+ l
]
;
(A13)
1
0
2
3
2
J
2(
1)
E =
2
l
1
and
F
(E ; J ) = F
J
e
l
:
(A14)
2
0
2
J
2
2(
1)
E =
2
(2
3)
l
Here we have used
= @E =@ I. Using dI
dI
= J dJ d(cos ), the integral over in equation (62)
2
3
due to the rst term, F
(E ; J ), is proportional to
1
Z
0
d sin j
(I)j
=
jY
(
; 0)j
jW
(I
; I
)j
;
(A15)
l
2
ll
2
2
ll
l
2
3
1
2
2
1
2
l
1
2
(2l + 1)(1 +
)
l
0
3
l=1
1
X
8
11
1=2
Weinberg sometimes uses dimensionless units r
= = 1; in these units v
= 2
.
s
c
{ 32 {
which follows from equations (A2) and (A5). The integral arising from the second term,
F
(E ; J ) cos , is proportional to
2
Z
0
d sin cos j
(I)j
=
W
(I
; I
)W
(I
; I
)Y
(
; 0)Y
(
; 0)
l
2
ll
l
2
3
1
2
1
2
ll
0
l
l
l
2
3
2
2
0
l
l
2
2
2
l
1
l
1
1
1
4
1
X
(1 +
)
l
0
3
0
l;l
=1
Z
l
l
0
d sin cos r
( )r
( ):
(A16)
l
l
l
l
2
3
2
3
0
0
The last integral vanishes unless l = l
1 (cf. Gottfried 1979); we show in Appendix B that the
potential contains only terms odd in l + l
so this integral will vanish. Consequently, using (A15)
3
in (62) we nd
X
X
1
4
32
!
Z
_
l
1
2
l
1
2
E
=
jY
(
; 0)j
dI
J dJ jW
j
F
(E ; J ) (l
!
):
(A17)
w
2
ll
2
2
1
1
l
ll
l
2
3
l
l=1
(2l + 1)(1 +
)
l
0
3
The resonance constraint can be written as a delta function in energy,
[E E
()]
v
l
l
c
2
(l
!
) =
=
[E E
()]
(A18)
l
l
j@ l
=@Ej
j!
j
!
l
l
where
2
l ()
E
() = v
ln
(A19)
l
c
!
l
is the resonant energy associated with a particular and is the unit step function. We replace
dI
by dE =
(E ; J ); then using equations (71), (A6), (A7) and (A13) we nd
1
1
J dJ F
(E ; J )
2F
J
1
0
s
2
2(
1)
(E ; J )
v
e
()
e
1
1
c
2
=
f ()d
(A20)
where
f () =
l
() e
[(
1)l
+
l
]:
(A21)
e
2
3
2
1=2
1
and we have replaced the frequencies
by their dimensionless counterparts
. After integration
e
i
i
over energy, the integral in equation (A17) becomes
Z
l
1
2
!
dI
J dJ jW
j
F
(E ; J ) (l
!
) =
l
l
1
1
ll
l
2
3
2
2
2
2(
1)
1
Z
2F
J
G
M
l
e
0
s
d
f
l
1
2
sgn(!
)
d
f ()j
W
()j
;
(A22)
2
e
R
d
l
ll
l
2
3
0
1
e
()
e
!
l
where the dimensionless transform is (cf. eq. A4)
f
l
1
e
Z
~r
a
1
dw
1
~rl
e
e
W
(;
!
) =
d~r
cos[l
w
l
( w
)]
U
;
(A23)
ll
l
2
3
l
1
1
2
2
ll
3
d
r
e
~r
p
e
!
l
e
!
= R
!
=v
, and U
(r) = (GM
=R
)
U
(r=R
).
l
l
3
3
d
c
ll
d
d
ll
d
e
{ 33 {
Finally, inserting this result in equation (A17) and using equation (71) we obtain the form we
use for numerical computations,
2
GM
v
d
c
_
_
e
E
=
E (
;
; );
(A24)
w
p
R
2
d
where
and
_
e
1
2
l
_
1
e
E (
;
; ) =
jY
(
; 0)j
E
(
;
; );
(A25)
p
ll
2
2
ll
l
2
3
p
1
1
1
X
X
X
4
l
=0
l
;l
= 1
l=1
3
1
2
(2l + 1)
l
1
_
e
p
f
e
l
1
2
sgn(
)
4
l
e
E
(
;
; ) =
d
f ()j
W
(; l
)j
:
(A26)
ll
l
2
3
2
ll
l
2
3
p
3
p
(1 +
)
e
(
)
e
()
l
0
3
0
1
e
l
3
p
e
1
1=2
+1=2
2(
1)
Z
!
When
= 1 and = 0, the df is that of a singular isothermal sphere. In this case, we recover
the result of Weinberg (1986; eq. 40), after correcting two minor typographical errors (the factor
2l + 2 in Weinberg's paper should be 2l + 1; and the sum over l
should run from 0 to l, not l to
3
l) and converting from torque to energy loss.
Note the symmetry
which implies that
l
1
_
e
l
1
_
e
E
(
;
; ) =
E
(
;
; );
(A27)
ll
l
l; l
;l
2
3
2
3
p
p
_
e
_
e
E (
;
; ) =
E (
;
; ):
(A28)
p
p
Thus if the halo is non-rotating ( = 0) and l
6= 0,
E
is independent of the sign of the pattern
3
w
_
speed as one would expect from symmetry.
The term in equation (A21) proportional to the halo spin contributes energy to the bending
wave if the pattern speed is in the same direction as the halo rotation, and removes energy if the
pattern speed and halo rotation are opposite.
B Gravitational Potential of a Disk Bending Mode
The potential of a thin, warped disk of surface density (R) is
Z
0
(R
)
0
U
(r; t) = G
dR
(B1)
d
jr r
(R
; t)j
0
0
where r
= R
+ Z (R
; t)e
. Subtracting o the potential of the unperturbed (
at) disk, and
z
0
0
0
expanding to rst order in the small displacement Z , we obtain the potential due to the warp
Z
0
0
0
@
1
U
(r; t) = G
dR
(R
)Z (R
; t)
:
(B2)
w
0
0
@ z
jr r
j
0
z
=0
In spherical coordinates
{ 34 {
1
4
r
X
l
<
0
0
=
Y
(; )Y
(
;
);
(B3)
0
l+1
ln
ln
jr r
j
2l + 1
ln
r
>
so that
@
1
X
l
4
r
1
@ Y
0
<
in
ln
1
=
Y
(; )
(
; 0)e
:
(B4)
ln
0
0
l+1
0
2
@ z
jr r
j
0
2l + 1
R
@ cos
z
=0
ln
r
>
The values of the spherical harmonics are
@ Y
2l + 1
(l n)!
(l + n)!!
ln
1
(l+n 1)=2
(
; 0) = ( 1)
n + l
odd
(B5)
@ cos
4
(l + n)!
(l n 1)!!
2
1=2
s
where the double factorial terms are
(2n 1)!! =
;
(2n)!! = 2
n!:
(B6)
(2n)!
n
n
2
n!
Terms with l + n even vanish.
We now substitute equation (7) for Z (R; t). Then we may write
U (r; t) =
U
(r)Y
(; 0)e
;
(B7)
ln
ln
X
i(n !
t)
n
l;n
where
2
l
1
Z
4
G
@ Y
r
lm
1
0
0
<
0
0
U
(r) =
(
; 0)
dR
(R
)
[h(R
)
+ h
(R
)
];
(B8)
ln
mn
m; n
2l + 1
@ cos
0
r
>
2
l+1
and !
= ! , !
= !
.
m
m
In this paper we mostly consider disturbances with m = 1. Since n = m and n + l must be
odd, only terms with even l will be non-zero. We assume that the disk surface density and warp
shape are given by equations (77) and (79). Then equation (B8) can be evaluated as
GM
2
@ Y
d
Z
1
l
x
l1
1
<
x
U
(r) =
(
; 0)
dxf (x)
e
(B9)
l1
2
l+1
R
2l + 1
@ cos
d
0
x
>
where
Z
1
l
l+1
x
R
(n + l + 1; (1 + )r=R
)
<
x
d
d
dxf (x)
e
= C
0
x
>
l+1
n+l+1
r
(1 + )
l
r
(n l; (1 + )r=R
)
d
+
:
(B10)
R
(1 + )
d
n l
In this equation the gamma functions are de ned by
Z
Z
z
1
p 1
x
p 1
x
(p; z ) =
x
e
dx;
(p; z ) =
x
e
dx;
(B11)
0
z
{ 35 {
note that
If p is a positive integer then
(p; z ) + (p; z ) = (p) = (p 1)!
(B12)
(p; z ) = (p 1)!e
:
(B13)
p 1
X
k
z
z
For negative integers, n 0,
k!
k=0
1
where E
(z ) is an exponential integral.
n
( n; z ) =
E
(z );
(B14)
n+1
n
z
C The Contribution of Near-Radial Orbits to Dynamical Friction
In this Appendix we elucidate the reason for the apparent divergence in the damping/excitation
rate in halos with predominantly radial orbits.
Suppose that a torque (t) is exerted on the star in a nearly radial orbit. The resulting
change in the angular momentum vector may be written
where =
(t)dt. The change in J = jJj is then
R
J = ;
(C1)
J
(J )
2
3
"
#
2
2
J =
+
+ O(
):
(C2)
J
2J
2J
3
As J ! 0, in general approaches a xed, non-zero value. Thus as J ! 0
J ! cos +
;
(C3)
2
2
2
sin
2J
3
where is the angle between and J (plus terms that are O(
), which we neglect). The O()
term can be dropped, since it averages to zero in a spherically symmetric distribution of stars, and
in any case does not diverge as J ! 0. In a spherical distribution, the average of sin
is
, so
2
2
1
the average change is hJ i =
=J . The corresponding energy change is
4
1
2
2
@H
0
hE i =
hJ i =
hJ i;
(C4)
@ J
2
which also diverges as J
, since
is generally constant and non-zero as J ! 0.
2
1
The number of stars in a small interval of energy and angular momentum is
dN = 16
F (E ; J )dE J dJ=
. Now assume that the df has the form (70), that is
1
3
F (E ; J ) = J
g (E ). Since
is constant as J ! 0, the total energy change of the
1
2(
1)
{ 36 {
stars of a given energy on near-radial orbits is proportional to
J
hJ idJ =
J
dJ ,
4
R
R
2
1
2
2
2
2
1
which diverges if
.
2
1
Thus we have explained the apparent divergence in dynamical friction for dfs with
.
2
1
Our arguments also show that the divergence is an artifact of the expansion procedure: the exact
change in angular momentum is
J
= (J
+ 2J +
)
J;
(C5)
exact
2
2
2
1=2
and the total energy or angular momentum change from near-radial orbits (J < J
, say) is
max
proportional to
Z
J
max
2
1
J
hJ
idJ:
(C6)
exact
1
2
0
When
>
this integral is O(
) (after averaging over orientations assuming hcos i = 0); this
2
is the usual case in which the frictional energy or angular momentum change is second-order in
the perturbation strength . When
<
the integral is O(
); thus the frictional force is of a
1
2
+1
lower order in the perturbation strength than
, but is not divergent.
2
2
REFERENCES
Araki, S. 1985, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, MIT
Barnes, J., & Efstathiou, G. 1987, ApJ 319, 575
Bertin, G., & Mark, J. W.-K. 1980, A&A 88, 289
Binney, J. 1992, ARA&A 30, 51
Bosma, A. 1991, in Casertano et al. (1991), 181
Casertano, S., Sackett, P. D., & Briggs, F. H., eds. 1991, Warped Disks and Inclined Rings around
Galaxies, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Dekel, A., & Shlosman, I. 1983, in Internal Kinematics and Dynamics of Galaxies, IAU Symposium
100, ed. E. Athanassoula (Dordrecht: Reidel), 187
Dubinski, J. 1992, ApJ 401, 441
Dubinski, J. 1994, preprint
Dubinski, J., & Carlberg, R. G. 1991, ApJ 378, 496
Dubinski, J., and Kuijken, K. 1994, preprint
Evans, N. W. 1994, MNRAS 267, 333
{ 37 {
Gerhard, O. E. 1991, MNRAS 250, 812
Goodman, J. 1988, ApJ 329, 612
Gottfried, K. 1979, Quantum Mechanics, London: W.A. Benjamin, Inc.
Habe, A., & Ikeuchi, S. 1985, ApJ 289, 540
Hernquist, L., & Weinberg, M. D. 1989, MNRAS 238, 407
Hunter, C., & Toomre, A. 1969, ApJ 155, 747 (HT)
Ichimaru, S. 1973, Basic Principles of Plasma Physics, Reading: W.A. Benjamin, Inc.
Katz, N., & Gunn, J. E. 1991, ApJ 377, 365
Kuijken, K. 1991, ApJ 376, 467
Lynden-Bell, D. 1965, MNRAS 129, 299
Lynden-Bell, D., & Kalna js, A. J. 1972, MNRAS 157, 1
Lynden-Bell, D., & Ostriker, J. P. 1967, MNRAS 136, 293
Ostriker, E. C., & Binney, J. J. 1989, MNRAS 237, 785
Palmer, P. L., & Papaloizou, J. 1987, MNRAS 224, 1043
Pearce, F. R., & Thomas, P. A. 1991, MNRAS 248, 699
Rubin, V. C., Graham, J. A., & Kenney, J.D.P. 1992, ApJ 394, L9
Sanchez-Saavedra, M. L., Battaner, E., & Florido, E. 1990, MNRAS 246, 458
Sparke, L. S. 1984, ApJ 280, 117
Sparke, L. S. 1994, preprint
Sparke, L. S., & Casertano, S. 1988, MNRAS 234, 873 (SC)
Steiman-Cameron, T. Y., & Durisen, R. H. 1984, ApJ 276, 101
Thomas, P. A., Vine, S., & Pearce, F. R. 1991, MNRAS 268, 253
Toomre, A. 1966, Notes on the 1966 Summer Study Program in Geophysical Fluid Dynamics,
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, 111
Toomre, A. 1969, ApJ 158, 899
Toomre, A. 1983, in Internal Kinematics and Dynamics of Galaxies, IAU Symposium 100, ed. E.
Athanassoula (Dordrecht: Reidel), 177
{ 38 {
Toomre, A. 1994, private communication
Tremaine, S., & Weinberg, M. D. 1984, MNRAS 209, 729
Warren, M. S., Quinn, P. J., Salmon, J. K., & Zurek, W. H. 1992, ApJ 399, 405
Weinberg, M. D. 1985, MNRAS 213, 451
Weinberg, M. D. 1986, ApJ 300, 93
Weinberg, M. D. 1991, ApJ 373, 391
White, S.D.M. 1984, ApJ 286, 38
Whitham, G. B. 1974, Linear and Nonlinear Waves (New York: Wiley)
Zurek, W. H., Quinn, P. J., & Salmon, J. K. 1988, ApJ 330, 519
This preprint was prepared with the AAS L
T
X macros v3.0.
A
E
{ 39 {
Authors' Addresses
Robert W. Nelson and Scott Tremaine
CITA, University of Toronto
60 St. George Street
Toronto, ON, M5S 1A7
CANADA
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
|
0812.1756 | 2 | 0812 | 2009-05-21T09:22:33 | Analysis of non-Gaussian CMB maps based on the N-pdf. Application to WMAP data | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present a new method based on the N-point probability distribution (pdf) to study non-Gaussianity in cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps. Likelihood and Bayesian estimation are applied to a local non-linear perturbed model up to third order, characterized by a linear term which is described by a Gaussian N-pdf, and a second and third order terms which are proportional to the square and the cube of the linear one. We also explore a set of model selection techniques (the Akaike and the Bayesian Information Criteria, the minimum description length, the Bayesian Evidence and the Generalized Likelihood Ratio Test) and their application to decide whether a given data set is better described by the proposed local non-Gaussian model, rather than by the standard Gaussian temperature distribution. As an application, we consider the analysis of the WMAP 5-year data at a resolution of around 2 degrees. At this angular scale (the Sachs-Wolfe regime), the non-Gaussian description proposed in this work defaults (under certain conditions) to an approximative local form of the weak non-linear coupling inflationary model (e.g. Komatsu & Spergel 2001) previously addressed in the literature. For this particular case, we obtain an estimation for the non-linear coupling parameter of -94 < F_nl < 154 at 95% CL. Equally, model selection criteria also indicate that the Gaussian hypothesis is favored against the particular local non-Gaussian model proposed in this work. This result is in agreement with previous findings obtained for equivalent non-Gaussian models and with different non-Gaussian estimators. However, our estimator based on the N-pdf is more efficient than previous estimators and, therefore, provides tighter constraints on the coupling parameter at degree angular resolution. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 13 (1998)
Printed 25 October 2018
(MN LATEX style file v2.2)
Analysis of non-Gaussian CMB maps based on the N-pdf.
Application to WMAP data
P. Vielva1, J. L. Sanz1,2
1Instituto de F´ısica de Cantabria (CSIC - Univ. de Cantabria), Avda. Los Castros s/n, 39005 - Santander, Spain
2CNR Istituto de Scienza e Tecnologie dell'Informazione, 56124, Pisa, Italy
E-mails : [email protected], [email protected]
Accepted ???. Received ???; in original form 25 October 2018
ABSTRACT
We present a new method based on the N-point probability distribution (pdf) to
study non-Gaussianity in cosmic microwave background (CMB) maps. Likelihood and
Bayesian estimation are applied to a local non-linear perturbed model up to third
order, characterized by a linear term which is described by a Gaussian N-pdf, and
a second and third order terms which are proportional to the square and the cube
of the linear one. We also explore a set of model selection techniques (the Akaike
and the Bayesian Information Criteria, the minimum description length, the Bayesian
Evidence and the Generalized Likelihood Ratio Test) and their application to decide
whether a given data set is better described by the proposed local non-Gaussian model,
rather than by the standard Gaussian temperature distribution. As an application, we
consider the analysis of the WMAP 5-year data at a resolution of ≈ 2◦. At this angular
scale (the Sachs-Wolfe regime), the non-Gaussian description proposed in this work
defaults (under certain conditions) to an approximative local form of the weak non-
linear coupling inflationary model (e.g. Komatsu et al. 2001) previously addressed in
the literature. For this particular case, we obtain an estimation for the non-linear
coupling parameter of −94 < fNL < 154 at 95% CL. Equally, model selection criteria
also indicate that the Gaussian hypothesis is favored against the particular local non-
Gaussian model proposed in this work. This result is in agreement with previous
findings obtained for equivalent non-Gaussian models and with different non-Gaussian
estimators. However, our estimator based on the N-pdf is more efficient than previous
estimators and, therefore, provides tighter constraints on the coupling parameter at
degree angular resolution.
Key words: cosmology: observations -- cosmology: cosmic microwave background --
methods: data analysis -- methods: statistical
9
0
0
2
y
a
M
1
2
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
2
v
6
5
7
1
.
2
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
1
INTRODUCTION
The Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) fluctuations, a
relic radiation originated around 400,000 years after the Big-
Bang, is one of the most outstanding sources for understand-
ing the evolution and energy/matter content of the Uni-
verse. The large amount of high quality data provided by
recent CMB experiments and other complementary astro-
nomical observations, have provided with a consistent pic-
ture for a flat Universe filled with cold dark matter (CDM)
and dark energy in the form of a cosmological constant
(Λ), plus the standard baryonic and electromagnetic com-
ponents: the concordance model (e.g. Komatsu et al. 2008).
However, beyond the strength of the CMB measurements
to put constraints on the cosmological parameters, like the
ones already provided by the NASA Wilkinson Microwave
Anisotropy Probe (WMAP, Hinshaw et al. 2008) and the
ones expected from the incoming ESA Planck satellite, the
CMB is a unique tool to probe fundamental principles and
assumptions of the so-called standard model. In particular,
the application of sophisticated statistical analysis to CMB
data might help us to understand whether the temperature
fluctuations of the primordial radiation are compatible with
the fundamental isotropic and Gaussian predictions from the
inflationary phase. The basic inflationary scenario relates
the CMB fluctuations, as well as the large-scale structure
of the Universe, to the Gaussian quantum energy density
perturbations present during the early Universe (see for in-
stance Liddle & Lyth 2000). The present homogeneity and
isotropy of the Universe is compatible with an inflation-
ary era in the early universe and this idea is the only way,
2
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
nowadays, to explain efficiently current observations rang-
ing from galaxies to the CMB. In particular, this fundamen-
tal hypothesis predicts that the CMB fluctuations follow an
isotropic and Gaussian random. In fact, the estimation of the
cosmological parameters defining the concordance model is
done by assuming these statistical properties.
The quality of current CMB data (in particular the
ones provided by the WMAP satellite) has allowed for a
systematic probe of the statistical properties of the relic
radiation. Indeed, the interest of the scientific community
in this field has experimented a significant growth, since
the analysis of the WMAP data has reported several hints
for departure from isotropy and Gaussianity of the CMB
temperature distribution. Some of these works are the
following. Park (2004) detected a Gaussianity deviation
with a genus-based statistic; Vielva et al. (2004) found a
significant non-Gaussian signature on the 1-year WMAP
data on the kurtosis of the Spherical Mexican Hat (SMHW)
wavelet coefficients at scales of around 10 degrees, pointing
out a very large cold spot (CS) on the southern hemisphere
as a possible source for this non-Gaussianity. A posterior
analysis (Cruz et al. 2005) confirmed the anomalous nature
of the CS by performing an area-based statistical analysis of
the wavelet coefficients. This detection, as well as new ones,
were confirmed by analyzing WMAP with various wavelet
bases and several statistical estimators (Mukherjee & Wang
2004; Cay´on et al. 2005; McEwen et al. 2005; Cruz et al.
2006; Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez et al. 2006; Cruz et al. 2007a;
McEwen et al. 2006; Pietrobon et al. 2008; Wiaux et al.
2008). Isotropy deviations were also reported in different
manners: an anomalous alignment of the low multipoles of
the CMB (Copi et al. 2004; de Oliveira-Costa et al. 2004;
Katz & Weeks 2004; Schwarz et al. 2004; Bielewicz et al.
2005; Land & Magueijo
2006;
Freeman et al. 2006; Land & Magueijo 2007); north-south
asymmetries of
(Eriksen et al.
2004a,b; Hansen et al. 2004a,b; Donoghue & Donoghue
2005; Eriksen et al.
2005a;
Bernui et al. 2006, 2007; Eriksen et al. 2007; Rath et al.
2007; Gordon 2007);
an anomalous variance value
(Monteser´ın et al. 2008); unexpected correlation among
the CMB phases (Chiang et al. 2003; Coles et al. 2004;
Chiang & Naselsky 2006); unbalanced distribution of the
temperature extrema (Tojeiro et al. 2006); and anoma-
lous alignment of CMB structures (Wiaux et al. 2006;
Vielva et al. 2006, 2007).
the CMB fluctuations
2005b; Abramo et al.
2005;
Land & Magueijo
All the previous analyses can be considered as blind
approaches, since null tests were performed to probe the
CMB compatibility with the isotropic and Gaussian hy-
potheses. Complementary to these works, the reader can
also find in the literature several studies where targeted
departures from Gaussianity are explored, based on non-
standard physical models. In particular, several analy-
ses have studied the WMAP data compatibility with
anisotropic universes: the Bianchi VIIh model (Jaffe et al.
2006a,b,c; Bridges et al. 2007a, 2008). Recently,
some
works have proposed non-rotational invariant models like
Bohmer & Mota (2008) and Ackerman et al. (2007) (ex-
prored by Groeneboom & Eriksen 2008,
in the context
of WMAP data). Although these non-rotational invariant
models are promising and provide us with anisotropic tem-
plates that could help to fix some anomalies in WMAP
data, more work is still needed to connect these anisotropic
patterns of the CMB fluctuations to a satisfactory physi-
cal model describing the evolution of the anisotropic field
(Himmetoglu et al. 2008a,b).
In addition to the previous analyses, several works have
studied different hypotheses to explore the anomalous na-
ture of the CS; for instance Cruz et al. (2008) explored the
CS compatibility with different non-standard models, point-
ing out that an explanation in terms of a cosmic texture
(as proposed by Cruz et al. 2007b) is much more favored
than other alternatives already discussed in the literature,
like a very large void in the large scale structure of the
Universe or contamination,
in the form of the Sunyaev-
Zeldovich emission, due to a large and nearby galaxy clus-
ter. However, the study of non-standard inflationary mod-
els is the problem that has attracted a larger attention.
For instance, and for the WMAP case, the non-linear cou-
pling parameter fNL that describes the non-linear evolution
of the inflationary potential (see e.g. Bartolo et al. 2004,
and references therein) has been constrained by several
groups: using the angular bispectrum (Komatsu et al. 2003;
Creminelli et al. 2006; Spergel et al. 2007; Komatsu et al.
2008); applying the Minkowski functionals (Komatsu et al.
2003; Spergel et al. 2007; Gott et al. 2007; Hikage et al.
2008; Komatsu et al. 2008); and using different statistics
based on wavelets (Mukherjee & Wang 2004; Cabella et al.
2005; Curto et al. 2008). Besides a claim for fNL > 0 with
a probability greater than 95% (Yadav & Wandelt 2008),
there is a general consensus on the WMAP compatibility
with the predictions made by the standard inflationary sce-
nario at least at 95% confidence level. The current best limits
(Curto et al. 2008) are: −8 < fNL < 111 at 95% CL.
The present paper is related to non-blind or targeted
probes for Gaussianity deviations, and, more specifically, it
addresses two common topics arose in these kind of studies:
the definition of an optimal estimator for the non-standard
model (and, therefore, the optimal estimation of the param-
eters that define such a model) and the complementary is-
sue of model selection. The former aspect is, usually, quite
complex, since, for many physical models and realistic obser-
vational limitations (e.g. incomplete sky coverage) there is
not a trivial solution and, therefore, non-optimal estimators
are usually proposed (which are posteriorly characterized by
simulations). The latter issue on model selection is equally
complex, since, generally, relies on heuristic principles. Some
authors adopt a fully Bayesian view, whereas others adopt
asymptotic measurements for the distance between two hy-
pothesis, and others prefer to rely on the information that
can be obtained from the likelihood itself. In this work we
propose to study a non-Gaussian model for the CMB that
is a local non-linear expansion of the temperature fluctua-
tions. For this model -- that, at large scales, is considered
by some authors as an approximation to the non-linear cou-
pling parameter fNL -- we are able to build the exact like-
lihood on pixel space. To work in pixel space allows one to
include easily non-ideal observational conditions, like incom-
plete sky coverage and anisotropic noise. We show how, from
this likelihood, it is straightforward to obtain an analytical
expression for the optimal estimator for the non-Gaussian
term. In addition, we also explore different model selection
criteria, like the Akaike information criterion (Akaike 1973),
the Bayesian information criterion (Schwarz 1978), the min-
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
3
imum description length (Rissanen 2001), the Bayesian evi-
dence, and the generalized likelihood ratio test.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we de-
scribe the physical model based on the local expansion of
the CMB fluctuations and derive the full posterior proba-
bility. In Section 3 we address the issue of the parameter
estimation (3.1) and model selection (3.2). The methodol-
ogy is explored on WMAP-like simulations in Section 4 and
it is applied to WMAP 5-year data in Section 5. Finally,
conclusions are given in Section 6.
model. Indeed, the reason to select the specific model given
by equation 1 is twofold. One the one hand, it is an useful
parametrization for describing a small departure from Gaus-
sianity, that allows us to present a new methodology. On the
other hand, it is a model previously addressed by other au-
thors (using other estimators), and, therefore, it is easier to
make a straightforward comparison among the results.
For simplicity,
let us transform the Gaussian part
(∆T i)G into a zero mean and unity variance random vari-
able φi, hence, equation 1 can be rewritten as:
2 THE NON-GAUSSIAN MODEL
where:
xi = φi + ǫ`φ2
i − 1´ + αǫ2φ3
i ,
Current observations indicate that CMB temperature fluc-
tuations can be well described by random Gaussian fluctu-
ations, as predicted by the standard inflationary scenario.
However, as it was discussed in the Introduction, these ob-
servations still allow for a small departure from the Gaussian
distribution, which could reflect the role played by physical
processes described by non-standard models for the struc-
ture formation.
In this paper, we will
focus on a parametric non-
Gaussian model, that accounts for a small and local (i.e.
point-to-point) perturbation of the CMB temperature fluc-
tuations, around its intrinsic Gaussian distribution:
G −(∆T i)2
G¸ + b (∆T i)3
∆T i = (∆T i)G + a(∆T i)2
G . (1)
(∆T i)G (the linear term) is the Gaussian part, whose N-
point probability density function (N-pdf) can be easily de-
scribed in terms of the standard inflationary model. The
second and third terms on the right-hand side are the
quadratic and cubic perturbation terms, respectively. Their
corresponding contribution to the observed CMB fluctua-
tions (∆T i) is governed by the a and b parameters. Subindex
i refers to the direction corresponding to a certain pixeliza-
tion on the sphere, and the operator h·i averages over all
the pixels defining the sky coverage. Notice that the previ-
ous expression does not include instrumental noise. We have
adopted this simplification, since we aim to focus the work
on large-scale CMB data sets (> 1◦), where (as it is the
case for WMAP), the contribution from noise is typically
negligible.
Let us point out that the particular situation for
b ≡ 0 defaults into a well known case that has been al-
ready addressed in the literature (e.g. Komatsu et al. 2001;
Cay´on et al. 2003; Curto et al. 2007). It describes a local
approximation to the weak non-linear coupling inflation-
ary model (e..g Komatsu et al. 2001; Liguori et al. 2003) at
scales larger than the horizon scale at the recombination
time (i.e. above the degree scale). In this context, the a fac-
tor is usally related to the non-linear coupling parameter
fNL by:
a ≡
3fNL
T0
,
(2)
where T0 = 2, 725 mK is the CMB temperature, and we
follow the sign convention in Liddle & Lyth (2000) for the
relation between the temperature fluctuations and the gravi-
tational potential at the Sachs-Wolfe regime. Let us remark
that, of course, this model do not pretend to incorporate
all the gravitational (like lensing) and non-gravitational ef-
fects, due to the evolution of the initial quadratic potential
1
σ
(∆T )G ,
ǫ ≡ aσ, α ≡
bσ2
ǫ2 ,
(3)
(4)
1
σ
x ≡
∆T , φ ≡
and σ2 ≡(∆T i)2
G¸ is the rms of the CMB fluctuations. Let
us remark that, since the proposed non-Gaussian model is
a perturbation of the standard Gaussian one, the non-linear
parameters have to satisfy:
ǫ ≪ 1,
α . 1.
(5)
It is straightforward to show that the normalized Gaussian
field φ satisfies:
hφii = hφ3
ii = 0,
hφ2
ii = 1,
hφiφji = ξij ,
(6)
where ξij represents the normalized correlation between pix-
els i and j. The N-pdf of the φ = {φ1, φ2, ..., φN} random
field (where N refers to the number of pixels on the sphere
that are observed) is given by a multivariate Gaussian:
p(φ) =
1
(2π)N/2(det ξ)1/2 e− 1
2
φξ−1φ t
,
(7)
where ξ denotes the correlation matrix and operator ·t de-
notes standard matrix/vector transpose.
Our goal is to compute the N-pdf associated to the non-
Gaussian x = {x1, x2, ..., xN} field, as a function of the non-
linear coupling parameters based on the full N-pdf for the
underlaying Gaussian signal φ. Hence, let us make first the
inversion of equation 3 to find the expression of φi as a
function of xi:
i − 1) + ǫ2[(2 − α)x3
φi = xi − ǫ(x2
Obviously, since previous equation is a local transfor-
mation, the Jacobian matrix is diagonal and, therefore, the
Jacobian (Z) is given by:
i − 2xi] + O(3).
(8)
Z = det» ∂φi
∂xj -- =Yi „ ∂φi
∂xi« .
(9)
It is more convenient to work with the log-Jacobian (log Z),
which, taking into account equation 8 and expanding the log
function up to second order, is given by:
log Z = Xi
= −2ǫXi
log„ ∂φi
∂xi«
xi + ǫ2"−2N + (4 − 3α)Xi
(10)
x2
i# + 0(3).
Now, taking into account equation 3 and recalling that φ is
a Gaussian field, it is straightforward to prove that the data
4
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
x satisfy: Pi xi = 0 and 1
the log-Jacobian is given by:
N Pi x2
i = 1 + O(2). Therefore,
log Z = N ǫ2 (2 − 3α) + O(3),
(11)
Finally, it is easy to calculate p(xǫ), the N-point pdf of x
given the ǫ parameter:
p(xǫ) = p(φ = φ(x))Z = p(x0)el(xǫ)
(12)
where the probability p(x0) is given by:
(2π)N/2(det (ξ))1/2 e− 1
p(x0) =
1
2
xξ−1x t
,
(13)
i.e., it is the N-point Gaussian pdf (i.e. p(x0) ≡ p(φ ≡ x)),
and the log-likelihood l(xǫ) reads as:
l(xǫ) = log Z −
1
2 φξ−1φt − xξ−1xt .
It is easy to show that l(xǫ) is given by:
l(xǫ) ≡ N [ǫR − ǫ2Q + O(3)],
where the functions R and Q are given by:
and
,
R =
1
N
xξ−1x2 − It
Q = −2 + J + αS,
non-Gaussian model in equation 1 can be seen as an ap-
proximation at large scales) is really negligible or not with
respect to the quadratic contribution. For the former sce-
nario (negligibility of the cubic term), the particular value
of α becomes an irrelevant issue since, naturally, one will
have that S ≪ −2 + J (of course, α should always satisfy
the condition given in equation 5). However, for the latter
case different results could be obtained, depending on the
specific value for α. In the following, we will discuss pa-
rameter estimation and model selection assuming α ≡ 0 in
equation 17. However, we will explore (analyzing WMAP
data and simulations) whether the condition S ≪ −2 + J is
naturally satisfied or not.
3 STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
In this Section we aim to address two aspects very much
linked one to the other: the estimation of the parameter
defining the local non-Gaussian model (ǫ, Section 3.1) and
the computation of some heuristic rules to decide whether a
given data set is better described by the local non-Gaussian
model rather than by the standard Gaussian one (Sec-
tion 3.2).
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
being I the unity vector of dimension N and
3.1 Parameter estimation
J =
and
+
1
N 2xξ−1x`x2 − I´t
N Iξ−1It −
S =
3
1
2 x2 − I ξ−1x2 − Itff
xξ−1x3tff .
1
3
(18)
(19)
Let us remark that R and Q could be seen as a kind of
generalized third-order and fourth-order moments, respec-
tively (or, equivalently, in terms of the spherical harmonic
coefficients, to the bispectrum and the trispectrum). As an
example, for the particular case of uncorrelated data (i.e.,
ξ ≡ δ), it is straightforward to show that R = k3 and
N Pi xn
Q = −5/2 + (3α − 2)k2 + (5/2 − α)k4, with kn = 1
i .
The N-pdf p(xǫ) given by equation 12 contains all the
required information, on the one hand, to estimate the non-
linear coupling parameter ǫ and, on the other hand, to per-
form a model selection (Gaussian vs. non-Gaussian). These
two aspects will be studied in next Section.
Notice that the parameter α (or, equivalently, b) can-
not be estimated in this framework: it just appears as an
arbitrary constant in the definition of Q (equation 17): it
just controls the relevance of S in Q. If one were inter-
ested in obtaining a posterior probability of the data x
given both non-linear parameters (ǫ and α), then it would
be necessary to expand the local non-Gaussian model be-
yond 0(3). However, we would always find an expression in
which the non-linear parameter controlling the highest order
in the expansion, acts as an arbitrary constant. For that rea-
son, we keep terms up to 0(3). There is a discussion within
the field (e.g., Okamoto & Hu 2002; Kogo & Komatsu 2006;
Babich 2005; Creminelli et al. 2007) about to what extend
the cubic term in the description of the weak non-linear
coupling inflationary model (for which, we recall, the local
The description of the full N-pdf for the non-Gaussian model
proposed in Section 2 allows one to obtain an optimal esti-
mation of the non-linear coupling parameter ǫ.
Let us recall that an optimal estimation of the ǫ pa-
rameter is possible, since it would be derived from the full
pdf for the non-Gaussian model, p(xǫ). In other words, we
could obtain an unbiased and minimum variance estimator.
This is possible, precisely, for the specific selection of the
local non-Gaussian model in equation 3: for other physical
non-Gaussian models it is not always trivial to obtain a full
description of the posterior probability of the data given the
parameters (at least, under realistic observational conditions
like incomplete sky coverage) and shortcuts have to be taken
by defining pseudo-optimal estimators that are, afterwards,
validated with simulations.
3.1.1 Parameter estimation from the log-likelihood
We shall define the optimal estimator for the non-linear pa-
rameter as the value, ǫ, that maximizes the probability of x
given ǫ. From equation 12, it is obvious that maximizing this
probability is equivalent to maximize l(xǫ) in equation 15.
By derivation one obtains:
ǫ =
R
2Q
.
(20)
We can also estimate the error associated to ǫ from the
Fisher matrix Fǫ ≡ − d2l
dǫ2 = 2N Q:
σǫ = F −1/2
ǫ
= (2N Q)−1/2.
(21)
Notice that the error on the estimation of the parameter ǫ
is constant, up to the order considered in equation 3.
3.1.2 Bayesian parameter estimation
Within the Bayesian framework we can include any a priori
information that we might have in relation to the ǫ parame-
ter. In particular, following Bayes' theorem, the probability
of ǫ given the data x read as:
p(ǫx) ∝ p(xǫ)p(ǫ),
(22)
where p(ǫ) is the prior probability function for the parame-
ter ǫ. Of course, for the case of the local non-Gaussian model
proposed in this work, there is not a clear physical motiva-
tion to choose a particular prior.
Let us however explore, as an exercise, two simple sce-
narios, which could be useful for more general purposes. We
consider first a uniform prior given by:
1
ǫM−ǫm
0
if ǫ ∈ [ǫm, ǫM]
otherwise
,
(23)
p(ǫ)8<
:
where, obviously, the range allowed to ǫ is such that ǫ ≪ 1
for any ǫ ∈ [ǫm, ǫM]. For this particular case, it is trivial to
show that the Bayesian estimation for the non-linear cou-
pling parameter (¯ǫ) is equivalent to the one obtained via the
maximum-likelihood estimation (i.e, ¯ǫ ≡ ǫ) if ǫ ∈ [ǫm, ǫM].
The second case we want to address corresponds to a
Gaussian prior p(ǫ), described by a most probable value ǫ∗
and a dispersion σ∗:
p(ǫ) =
(ǫ−ǫ∗ )2
2σ∗ 2
.
−
e
1
√2πσ∗
(24)
By deriving the posterior probability, it is trivial to obtain
the Bayesian estimation for the non-linear coupling param-
eter (¯ǫ):
¯ǫ =
N σ∗
2N σ∗
2R + ǫ∗
2Q + 1
.
(25)
For the particular case of σ∗ → 0, i.e. a very strong prior
for ǫ, peaked around ǫ∗, one trivially obtain ¯ǫ ≡ ǫ∗, that
is, the prior dominates Bayesian estimation, leading to a
most probable value for ǫ equal to the maximum value for
the prior. Also trivially one finds that, for a non-informative
scenario (i.e., σ∗ → ∞), ¯ǫ ≡ ǫ = R/2Q.
3.2 Model selection
In this subsection we aim to calculate under which condi-
tions (according to different model selection criteria) a given
observation x is better described by a local non-Gaussian
model as the one described by equation 3 with ǫ > 0
(hereinafter H1) rather than by a Gaussian random field
described just in term of the N-point correlation function ξ
(hereinafter H0).
Some of
the model
selection approaches
inves-
tigated in this paper have been previously applied
to different astronomical/cosmological problems For in-
stance,
(Szydlowski & Godlowski 2006; Szydlowski et al
2006; Borowiec et al. 2006) applied the Akaike and the
Bayesian information criteria (AIC and BIC, recpectively)
to study whether astronomical data sets favored simplest
models for the accelerating universe against more complex
ones. This issue was also addressed by Davis et al. (2007) by
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
5
analyzing the ESSENCE supernova survey data, and appliy-
ing Bayesian evidence (BE) in addition to the AIC and the
BIC approaches, to study. These three model selection crite-
ria (AIC, BIC and BE) were also applied to study the impact
of non-standard physical models on the Friedmann equa-
tions (Szydlowski et al. 2008). Liddle (2004) used the AIC
and the BIC techniques to study, on the one hand, whether
WMAP 1-year data preferred a spatially flat cosmology ver-
sus a closed one, and, on the other hand the significance
of the running spectral index detected on this WMAP data
release. In a posterior work (Liddle 2007), BE was added to
the AIC and the BIC approaches to study the suitability of
different cosmological models to the WMAP 3-year data.
Bayesian evidence (BE) is, probably, the model selec-
tion criterion that has attracted a greater interest from
cosmologists during the past years. In addition to the
works mentioned above (where it was compared with
other model selection criteria),
it has been also applied
to several problems where competing cosmological mod-
els were explored. Some of these applications are the fol-
lowing: Mukherjee et al. (2006) followed a BE approach
to study cosmological models with different matter power
spectra and dark energy evolution models; Liddle et al.
(2006)
studied different dark energy evolving scenar-
ios; Bridges et al. (2006, 2007b) performed a model selec-
tion on the matter power spectrum from the BE analy-
sis of the WMAP; Bridges et al. (2007a, 2008) followed a
similar approach for analyzing the WMAP compatibility
with anisotropic Bianchi VIIh models; Cruz et al. (2007b,
2008) used it to decide whether the WMAP cold spot
was compatible or not with predictions from non-standard
models like the cosmological defects; Mukherjee & Liddle
(2008) studied the Planck ability to discriminate between
several re-ionization models; the BE criterion was also
applied (Carvalho et al. 2008; Feroz et al. 2008b) to the
problem of compact source detection on microwave data;
and more recently, Feroz et al. (2008a) investigated differ-
ent properties of the constrained minimal supersymmetric
model (mSUGRA), using WMAP data.
3.2.1 The Akaike information criterion (AIC)
The Akaike information criterion (AIC, Akaike 1973) pro-
vides with a selection index to decide among competing hy-
pothesis, being the model associated to the lowest index the
most favored one. The Akaike index corresponding to a given
model or hypotheses Hi defined by p parameters and with
a maximum value for the log-likelihood of l is given by:
AIC(Hi) = 2"p − l" .
(26)
From equation 15, one can find that AIC(H1) =
2"1 − N R2
4Q", whereas, trivially, AIC(H0) = 0. Therefore,
according to the AIC, the decision rule reads as:
H0
H1
AIC :8><
>:
if R2
Q 6 4
N
if R2
Q > 4
N
(27)
where ν is an arbitrary value indicating the strength in
choosing H1 instead of H0. Therefore, according to the
GLRT, the decision rule reads as:
H0
H1
if R2
Q 6 4
N ν
(33)
if R2
Q > 4
N ν
GLRT :8><
>:
(28)
Notice that the case ν ≡ 1 provides the same decision rule
as the AIC (equation 27), and that ν ≡ ln√N corresponds
to the BIC case (equation 29).
6
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
3.2.2 Bayesian information criterium (BIC)
This asymptotic bayesian criterion introduced by Schwarz
(1978) is prior independent. It is based on the BIC function,
that provides a measurement of the goodness-of-fit of the
model to the data, taking into account the number of pa-
rameters defining the model as well as the amount of data
(N ):
BIC(Hi) ="−2l + p ln N" ,
where p is the number of parameters defining the data and l
is the maximum value for the log-likelihood. As for AIC, BIC
provides a ranging index for competing hypothesis, where
the one with the lower BIC value is the most favored one.
From equation 15, one can find that (for our specific prob-
2Q + ln (N ) and BIC(H0) = 0. There-
lem) BIC(H1) = −N R2
fore, according to the BIC, the decision rule reads as:
H0
H1
BIC :8><
>:
if R2
Q 6 2
N ln N
(29)
if R2
Q > 2
N ln N
3.2.3 Minimum description length (MDL)
MDL (e.g. Rissanen 2001) is an inference approach mostly
developed during the 80s and 90s, based on the key idea
that the more regular a given data set is, the higher is the
compression degree to which we can code the data, and,
therefore, the more we can learn on the properties of the
data. Among many statistical applications, MDL is used to
select between competing models describing the data, select-
ing the one allowing for a higher compression degree (which
can be seen as an alternative formulation of the Occam's
Razor).
For our particular case described by equation 3, the
MDL measurement of compression is given by:
MDL(ǫ) = −l +
1
2
ln„ N
2π« + lnZǫ∈Ω
dǫ[det Fǫ]1/2,
(30)
where Fǫ
is the Fisher matrix of ǫ. Therefore, taking
into account equations 12 and 15, one can easily compute
MDL(H1) and MDL(H0) providing a decision rule that
reads as:
MDL :
,
(31)
H0
H1
8>>>><
>>>>:
if R2
Q 6 4
if R2
Q > 4
N ln„N Ωq Q
π«
N ln„N Ωq Q
π«
where Ω is the interval where ǫ is defined.
3.2.5 Bayesian evidence (BE)
BE is defined as the average likelihood of the model Hi in
the prior p(ǫ):
EHi (x) =Z dǫ p(ǫ, Hi)p(xǫ, Hi),
(34)
where p(xǫ, Hi) is given by equation 12. Model selection in
terms of the BE grounds on the Bayes' factor, B10:
B10(x) =
EH1 (x)
EH0 (x)
.
(35)
BE framework provides a rule to quantify how strong the
decision is. In the literature it is commonly accepted the Jef-
freys' scale (Jeffreys 1961), that provides a recipe in terms of
the logarithmic Bayes' factor. Roughly speaking, it is com-
monly said that the evidence for H1 against H0 is not sig-
nificant if 0 6 ln B10(x) < 1, mild if 1 6 ln B10(x) 6 3 and
strong if ln B10(x) > 3.
As it was already discussed, the alternative hypothesis
H1 representing the local non-Gaussian model (equation 3)
does not offer any physical motivation for a particular prior.
Even thus, we study here the two particular cases already
mentioned in subsection 3.1.2: the Gaussian (equation 24)
and the uniform (equation 23) priors.
For the former, it is straightforward to prove that:
B10 =
σǫ
ǫ + σ2
∗
pσ2
whereas for the latter, one can obtain:
ǫ2
2σ2
∗
∗
+
−
e
ǫ +ǫσ2
(ǫ∗ σ2
ǫ (σ2
σ2
2σ2
∗)2
ǫ +σ2
∗
∗) ,
(36)
B10 =r π
2
σǫ
ǫM − ǫm
ǫ2
2σ2
e
ǫ »erf„ ǫM − ǫ
√2σǫ « + erf„ ǫ − ǫm√2σǫ « -- ,
(37)
where ǫ is the maximum-likelihood estimation for the non-
linear parameter ǫ (equation 20) and σǫ is the error on this
estimation (equation 21). Finally, notice that for the par-
ticular cases of σ∗ ≫ σǫ or ǫM − ǫm ≫ σǫ in equations 36
and 37, respectively (i.e., a broad prior), one obtains:
3.2.4 Generalized likelihood ratio test (GLRT)
Generalized likelihood ratio test (GLRT) is one of the most
common approaches in model selection and its particular
application to solve astronomical/cosmological problems has
been very extensive.
The criterion established by the GLRT to accept the al-
ternative hypothesis H1 against H0 is given by p(xǫ, H1) >
eνp(x0, H0) or, equivalently by:
l ≡ l(ǫ) = N
R2
4Q
> ν,
(32)
B10 ≃
ǫ2
2σ2
ǫ ,
e
σǫ
γ
(38)
where γ = σ∗
(ǫM − ǫm) /√2π (for the uniform prior).
(for
the Gaussian prior) or γ =
4 APPLICATION TO WMAP SIMULATIONS
In this Section we aim to explore the performance of
the parameter estimators and the model selection crite-
ria described in the previous Section. We apply them to
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
7
computed this large number of simulations to assure an ac-
curate description of the CMB Gaussian temperature fluc-
tuations. Additional 1,000 simulations were also generated
to carry out a statistical analysis on the performance of the
different parameters estimators and model selection criteria.
Each of these 1,000 (∆T )G simulations are transformed
into x (following equations 1 and 4) to study the response
of the statistical tools as a function of the non-linear ǫ pa-
rameter defining the local non-Gaussian model proposed in
equation 3.
4.1 Parameter estimation
Let us first consider the estimation made via maximum-
likelihood estimation (Subsection 3.1.1). As it was men-
tioned above, we have generated 1,000 non-Gaussian
WMAP-like observations according to equation 3 for a range
of values of ǫ, in particular, we have considered ǫ ∈ [0, 0.035],
or equivalently, in terms of the most common coupling fNL
parameter (equation 2), we explore fNL ∈ [0, 500]. We only
explore positive values of the non-linear parameter, since the
response of the proposed methodology does not depend on
the sign of ǫ.
In figure 2 we present the ǫ distributions obtained from
the analysis of local non-Gaussian simulations. From left to
right and from top to bottom, the panels show the cases:
ǫ = 0, 0.001, 0.002, 0.003, 0.004, 0.005, 0.010, 0.015, 0.020,
0.025, 0.030 and 0.035. Notice that, as expected, the pa-
rameter estimation is unbiased for reasonable values of the ǫ
parameter: all the distributions are peaked around the value
of ǫ used to generate the simulations. Only for ǫ > 0.025 (or,
equivalently, fNL ' 350) a bias starts to appear. This effect
comes from the fact that these values of ǫ are not small
enough to assure a local non-Gaussian model as the one de-
scribed by equation 3, i.e., a non-Gaussian model that is a
local perturbation of the underlaying CMB Gaussian signal.
Also as expected (see equation 21), the width of these dis-
tributions does not depend on the particular value of ǫ, if,
once more, ǫ is small enough to assure a proper expansion for
the local non-Gaussian model. In this regime, we obtain, on
average, σǫ ≈ 0.004, or, equivalently, σ fNL ≈ 60. Again, for
ǫ > 0.025 the width of the distributions starts to be slightly
smaller, indicating an inadequate value of the non-linear pa-
rameter. These two effects (bias of the maximum-likelihood
parameter estimation and dependence on the error on the
parameter estimation) provide a natural range (at least for
a pixel resolution of ≈ 2◦) where the non-linear parameter
is allowed to take values: ǫ ∈ [−0.025, 0.025].
This allowed range for ǫ can be seen as a natural prior
p (ǫ), that could be used for performing a parameter estima-
tion within a Bayesian framework. Obviously (as discussed
in Subsection 3.1.2), the Bayesian estimation made with this
uniform prior produces the same estimations for ǫ already
reported from the maximum-likelihood.
Finally, we have also investigated whether the value of
S in equation 17 is negligible as compared to −2 + J, which,
as discussed in Section 2, would lead to a situation where the
choice of a particular value for the non-linear parameter α
becomes an irrelevant problem. We found that, actually, this
is not the case: on average, S/(−2 + J) ≈ 0.7. This implies
that, first, different values of α could provide different re-
sults, not only to the ones presented in this work, but also for
Figure 1. Mask at NSIDE=32 HEALPix resolution used in this
work. It corresponds to the WMAP KQ75 mask, although the
point source masking has not been considered, since the point
like-emission due to extragalactic sources is negligible at the con-
sidered resolution. At this pixel resolution, the mask keeps around
69% of the sky.
CMB simulations of the WMAP 5-year data at NSIDE=32
HEALPix (G´orski et al. 2005) resolution (≈ 2◦).
The procedure to generate a CMB Gaussian simulation
-- (∆T )G in equation 1 -- is as follows. First, using the Cℓ
obtained with the cosmological parameters provided by the
best-fit to WMAP data alone (Table 6 in Hinshaw et al.
2008), we simulate WMAP observations (taking into ac-
count the corresponding beam window functions) for the
Q1, Q2, V1, V2, W1, W2, W3, W4 difference assemblies
at NSIDE=512 HEALPix resolution. We obtain a single co-
added CMB map through a noise-weighted linear combi-
nation of the eight maps (from Q1 to W4). Weights are
proportional to the inverse mean noise variance. They are
independent on the position (i.e., they are uniform across
the sky for a given difference assembly) and they are nor-
malized to unity. Notice that we do not add a random noise
realization to each map, since we have checked that noise
plays a negligible role at the angular resolution in which we
are interested in (≈ 2◦). However, we perform the linear
combination of the difference assembly maps following the
procedure described above, since it will be the same pro-
cess that we will follow with the WMAP data.1 Afterwards,
the co-added map at NSIDE=512 is degraded down to the
final resolution of NSIDE=32. Finally, a mask representing
a sky coverage like the one allowed by the WMAP KQ75
mask (Gold et al. 2008) is adopted. At NSIDE=32 the mask
keeps around 69% of the sky (notice that we do not consider
the masking due to point sources, since at this resolution
the contribution from individual extragalactic point sources
is negligible, see figure 1). Let us remark that observational
constraints like incomplete sky coverage can be easily taken
into account by the local non-Gaussian model proposed in
this work, since it is naturally defined in pixel space.
We have used 500,000 simulations of (∆T )G, generated
as described above, to estimate the correlation matrix ξ ac-
counting for the Gaussian CMB cross-correlations. We have
1 Co-added WMAP 5-year data is made in this way to produce
a final map with a noise level smaller than, for instance, the one
that could be achieved just by averaging the 8 difference assembly
maps, assuring better a negligible noise contribution to the final
map at resolution of ≈ 2◦.
8
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.003
f
NL
= 44
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
∈ = 0.001
f
NL
= 15
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.004
f
NL
= 58
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.030
= 436
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
∈ = 0.002
f
NL
= 29
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
∈ = 0.035
= 509
f
NL
−0.02
0
0.02
0.04
ǫ
Figure 2. Distributions for the maximum-likelihood estimations of the non-linear parameter ǫ obtained by analyzing 1,000 simulations,
according to the local non-Gaussian model given in equation 3. Several values of ǫ, or, equivalently of the coupling fNL parameters (both
numbers are written in each panel) are explored. Vertical dashed lines indicate the value of the ǫ used to generate each set of local
non-Gaussian simulations.
other works in the literature (where, we recall, it is assumed
α ≡ 0). In particular, it is trivial to show that, values of
α . 0.15 would affect the determination of the coupling pa-
rameter ǫ in ≈ 10%. Second, as it has been discussed by some
authors (Okamoto & Hu 2002; Kogo & Komatsu 2006), it
would indicate that, for the weak non-linear coupling infla-
tionary model, the role played by cubic terms could be non
negligible as compared to quadratic contributions, since, to
some extent, they will contribute to the full trispectrum (as
one can notice from equation 17, where α governs the role
played by S). This results could be important when describ-
ing more complete non-local non-Guassian model, since it
would indicate the need of including physical effects up to
third order.
4.2 Model selection
We discuss which is the performance of the different model
selection criteria presented in Subsection 3.2. For the par-
ticular case of BE, we assume the natural prior p (ǫ) found
in the previous Subsection: ǫ ∈ [−0.025, 0.025]. As for the
case of the parameter estimation previously discussed, we
have considered a set of local non-Gaussian models given by
different values of the non-linear parameter.
We present the results, graphically, in figure 3. This
plot consist in 6 rows and 5 columns. Each row corresponds
to the results obtained for a given value of the ǫ parameter
(namely, from top to bottom: ǫ = 0, 0.005, 0.010, 0.015, 0.020
and 0.025). Each column refers to a model selection crite-
rion (from left ro right: AIC, BIC, MDL, BE and GLRT).
For the first column (i.e., the AIC case) we plot the dis-
tributions (obtained after analysing 1,000 simulations) of a
statistical variable defined as: WAIC ≡ R2/Q − 4/N , no-
tice (from equation 27) that a positve value of WAIC implies
to accept H1 against H0. The second column accounts for
the distributions of the variable WBIC ≡ R2/Q − 2 ln N/N ,
which (from equation 29) also satisfies to be positive when
favoring H1. Equivalently, third column shows the distribu-
tions of WMDL ≡ R2/Q − 4/N ln N ΩpQ/π, that according
to equation 31 is also positive when H1 is more likely than
H0. Fourth column provides ln B10, obtained from equa-
tion 37. Finally, in the fifth column we present the distri-
butions obtained for ν = `R2/N´ / (4/N ) which, according
to the GLRT decision rule (equation 33) provides a mea-
surement of the strength in accepting H1 against H0.
In addition to the distributions, we also plot, as an in-
dication, a vertical line in each panel. For WAIC, WBIC and
WMDL, this vertical line separate the region where H0 is fa-
vored (left side) from the one where H1 is more likely (right
side). The percentage of the 1,000 simulations that fall on
the H1 region is also reported at each panel. The vertical
line for the WBE statistic represents the limit for which the
logarithmic Bayes' factor (ln B10) is greater than 1, which,
in terms of the Jeffreys' rule, indicates that H1 is, at least,
mildly favored against H0. We also provide the percentage
of the simulations satisfying this condition. Finally, the ver-
tical line for the WGLRT statistic indicates the value of ν
for which 95% of the 1,000 simulations favor H1 instead of
H0. This value of ν is also written in the panels. Notice
that, among the asymptotic model selection criteria (AIC,
BIC and MDL), AIC offers a less restrictive criterion than
BIC, whereas BIC behaves similarly with respect to MDL,
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
9
The figure also shows that BE provides a more conservative
criterion than the asymptotic methods.
5 APPLICATION TO WMAP 5-YEAR DATA
We have applied the statistical approaches described in Sec-
tion 3 to WMAP 5-year data. In particular, we have ana-
lyzed a co-added CMB map generated from the global noise-
weighted linear combination of the reduced foreground maps
for the Q1, Q2, V1, V2, W1, W2, W3 and W4 difference as-
semblies (see Gold et al. 2008, for details). Weights are nor-
malized to unity and, for each map, they are proportional to
the inverse average noise variance across the sky. This op-
eration is made at NSIDE=512 HEALPix resolution, being
degraded afterwards down to NSIDE=32.
Hence, we are in the same conditions as for the analysis
on simulations described in the previous Section and, there-
fore, the CMB cross-correlation in WMAP data is given by
the ξ correlation matrix already defined in Section 4. The es-
timated full N-pdf of the WMAP 5-year data given the non-
linear parameter ǫ is showed in figure 4 (indeed, it is given in
terms of the most common fNL parameter for allowing a bet-
ter comparison with previous works). Maximum-likelihood
estimation (equation 20) provides fNL = 30 with an error for
the parameter (equation 21) of σfNL
= 62 (compatible with
the values obtained from simulations). Hence our WMAP
5-year data analysis reports: fNL = 30 ± 124 at 95% CL
(or, equivalently, ǫ = 0.019 ± 0.078 at 95%). This result
is compatible with similar works in the literature reporting
WMAP compatibility with Gaussian hypothesis. However,
let us remark that this estimation is more efficient than pre-
vious ones at similar angular resolution, since it provides
a smaller error bar. For instance, Curto et al. (2007) per-
formed a Gaussianity test on the WMAP data, at the same
HEALPix resolution, although in a smaller region of the
sky (16% instead of the 69% considered in this work). Their
fNL estimator was based on the three Minkowski functionals,
providing an error bar of ≈ 200. The expected σfNL
provided
by our maximum-likelihood estimator for a similar observed
region would be σfNL ≈ 124, i.e., ≈ 40% smaller than the
one obtained by the Minkowski functionals. This result was
expected since, as it was already discussed, the maximum-
likelihood estimation of the non-linear parameter is optimal,
given the local non-Gaussian model in equation 1.
As it has been mentioned above, this result shows
WMAP data compatibility with the Gaussian hypothesis,
since fNL ≡ 0 can not be rejected at any significant confi-
dence level. Of course, same conclusions are obtained from
the model selection criteria described in Subsection 3.2. Nei-
ther AIC, BIC, MDL nor BE criteria select H1 against H0,
whereas GLRT would favor H1 under the very weak condi-
tion for ν in equation 33 of ν ≈ 0.1 (which implies a likeli-
hood ratio of ≈ 1.1)
Finally, let us remark that, as it also happened for the
simulations analyzed in Section 4, the contribution of the S
term to the value of Q (see equation 17) is not negligible,
in particular, S/(−2 + J) = 0.74. This indicates that, as it
was already mentioned, the cubic term in the model given
by equation 3 is not naturally negligible as compared to
the quadratic term and, therefore, α should be chosen small
enough (like the case α ≡ 0 considered in this work).
10
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
#(>0) = 17.0%
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
−0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
W
AIC
2
2.5
3
3.5
x 10−3
#(>0) = 43.6%
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
0
1
2
W
AIC
3
4
x 10−3
#(>0) = 85.4%
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
#(>0) = 0.4%
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
−2.5
−2
−1.5
−1
−0.5
W
BIC
0
0.5
1
1.5
x 10−3
#(>0) = 4.4%
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
−2
−1
0
W
BIC
1
2
3
x 10−3
#(>0) = 31.8%
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
2
0
2
4
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
W
BIC
4
6
W
AIC
8
x 10−3
#(>0) = 99.1%
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
6
x 10−3
10
x 10−3
#(>0) = 77.8%
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
4
6
8
W
BIC
#(>0) = 98.0%
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
6
8
10
0
−2
0
2
W
AIC
x 10−3
#(>0) = 99.9%
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
5
10
W
AIC
15
x 10−3
0
−2
0
2
4
6
W
BIC
8
10
12
14
x 10−3
#(>0) = 100.0%
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
10
15
W
AIC
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
20
x 10−3
0
5
0
5
#(>0) = 99.9%
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
10
15
W
BIC
x 10−3
500
400
300
200
100
0
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
150
100
50
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
#(>0) = 0.1%
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
−3.5
−3
−2.5
−2
−1
−0.5
0
−1.5
W
MDL
0.5
x 10−3
#(>0) = 0.9%
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
−3
−2
−1
W
MDL
0
1
2
x 10−3
#(>0) = 16.0%
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
−3
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
4
5
W
MDL
x 10−3
#(>0) = 59.3%
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
−2
0
4
6
2
W
MDL
8
x 10−3
#(>0) = 93.5%
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
−2
0
2
4
0
5
6
8
10
12
W
MDL
x 10−3
#(>0) = 99.7%
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
10
15
W
MDL
x 10−3
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
150
100
50
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
#(>1) = 0.0%
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
−20
−15
−5
0
−10
ln(B
)
10
#(>1) = 0.0%
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
−20
−15
−5
0
−10
ln(B
)
10
#(>1) = 0.0%
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
−20
−15
−5
0
−10
ln(B
)
10
#(>1) = 1.1%
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
−20
−15
−20
−15
−10
−10
ln(B
−5
)
10
−5
ln(B
0
)
10
0
5
#(>1) = 16.0%
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
5
10
15
#(>1) = 60.1%
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
−15
−10
−5
0
10
15
20
25
5
ln(B
)
10
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
ν(>95%) = 0.001
∈ = 0.000
f
NL
= 0
0
2
4
ν
6
8
ν(>95%) = 0.006
∈ = 0.005
f
NL
= 73
0
2
4
ν
6
8
10
ν(>95%) = 0.372
∈ = 0.010
= 146
f
NL
0
5
10
ν
15
ν(>95%) = 2.263
∈ = 0.015
= 218
f
NL
0
5
10
ν
15
20
25
ν(>95%) = 5.754
∈ = 0.020
= 291
f
NL
0
5
10
15
ν
20
25
30
35
ν(>95%) = 10.737
∈ = 0.025
= 364
f
NL
0
10
20
ν
30
40
Figure 3. From left ro right, columns show the distribution for several statistics referred to different model selection criteria: AIC, BIC,
MDL, BE and GLRT. From top to bottom, results for local non-Gaussian models for different non-linear parameters are give: ǫ = 0,
0.005, 0.010, 0.015, 0.020 and 0.025. Panels in columns 1, 2, 3 and 4 present a vertical line, separating the region where H0 and H1 are
preferred (to the left and to the right of the vertical line, respectively). The vertical line on the last column represents the value for the
ν parameter for which 95% of the non-Gaussian simulations are more likely described by H1 rather than H0.
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
11
x 10−3
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
)
L
N
f
x
(
p
0
−400
−200
200
400
0
f
NL
Figure 4. This curve represent the probability given in equa-
tion 12, i.e. the full pdf of the WMAP 5-year data x given the
non-linear parameter ǫ (or, equivalently, fNL). Vertical dotted line
marks the maximum-likelihood estimation fNL = 30.
6 CONCLUSIONS
We have presented a parametric non-Gaussian model for the
CMB temperature fluctuations. The non-Gaussian model
is a local perturbation (up to third order) of the stan-
dard CMB Gaussian field which recovers (for the case of
b ≡ 0 in equation 1) an approximative form of the weak
non-linear coupling inflationary model (e.g. Komatsu et al.
2001; Liguori et al. 2003) at scales larger than the horizon
scale at the recombination time (i.e. above the degree scale).
For this model, we are able to build the posterior prob-
ability of the data given the non-linear parameter ǫ (see
equation 3), from which, in principle, an optimal estimator
(i.e., unbiased and with minimum variance) can be derived.
Analytical expressions for the maximum-likelihood estima-
tion of the non-linear parameter (ǫ) and its associated error
(σǫ) are derived. In addition, we also discuss an alterna-
tive Bayesian estimation (in terms of the posterior prob-
ability of the non-linear parameter), for the hypothetical
case in which we might have some prior information for ǫ.
As an example, two cases are addressed: a non-informative
(i.e, uniform) and a Gaussian priors. We also investigate
an issue very much linked to the parameter estimation: the
model selection. Indeed, we discuss several well known tech-
niques to perform hypotheses test, like the Akaike infor-
mation criterion (AIC, Akaike 1973), the Bayesian informa-
tion criterion (BIC, Schwarz 1978), the minimum description
length (MDL, Rissanen 2001), the generalized likelihood ra-
tio test (GLRT) and the Bayesian evidence (BE). We derive
analytical expressions, for the particular local non-Gaussian
model proposed in this work, for all these model selection
techniques.
The performance of both, parameter estimators and
model selection criteria, are investigated by analyzing non-
Gaussian simulations, as they could be observed by WMAP.
We check that the maximum-likelihood estimation provides
an unbiased and efficient estimation of the non-linear pa-
rameter defining the deviations from Gaussianity. We find
that, for the HEALPix resolution considered in this work
(NSIDE=32), results are consistent up to a value of ǫ =
0.025, which approximately corresponds (at the Sachs-Wolfe
regime) to a value of the the non-linear coupling parameter
fNL ≈ 350. This parameter is the one commonly used to
described the weak non-linear coupling inflationary model
(e..g Komatsu et al. 2001). We also find that, among the
model selection criteria, AIC is the asymptotic method that
provides the less restrictive decision rule, whereas, on the
other hand, MDL is the most strict one. We also find that
BE, for a uniform prior given by ǫ ∈ [−0.025, 0.025], is even
more restrictive than MDL.
The proposed methodology is applied to WMAP 5-year
data. We obtain a value for the non-linear coupling parame-
ter of fNL = 30±124 at 95% CL. This result provides a more
efficient estimation than previous works in the literature, at
the same angular scales. For instance, comparing with the
work by Curto et al. (2007) using Minkowski functionals, we
can infer that the maximum-likelihood error bar is ≈ 40%
smaller than the one obtained with those geometrical esti-
mators. Application of model selection criteria to WMAP
data confirms that standard hypothesis of Gaussianity is fa-
vored against the alternative hypothesis of non-Gaussianity,
for the specific local model proposed in this work, and for
the adopted resolution of ≈ 2◦.
Finally, we would like to comment that, currently, we
are extending the technique based on the N-pdf presented
in this work, to deal with a more realistic non-local non-
Gaussian model, where higher resolution CMB data are con-
sidered, including as well the effect of anisotropic noise.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors thank Andr´es Curto, R. Bel´en Barreiro and
Enrique Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez for useful comments and dis-
cussion. We acknowledge partial financial support from
the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovaci´on project
AYA2007-68058-C03-02. PV also acknowledges financial
support from the Ram´on y Cajal programme. PV thanks to
the CNR Istituto de Scienza e Tecnologie dell'Informazione
(ISTI, Pisa) for their warm hospitality during his research
stays in March and June 2008. JLS acknowledge partial
financial support by the Spanish MEC and thanks the
CNR ISTI in Pisa for their hospitality during his sabbati-
cal leave. The authors acknowledge the computer resources,
technical expertise and assistance provided by the Span-
ish Supercomputing Network (RES) node at Universidad de
Cantabria. We acknowledge the use of Legacy Archive for
Microwave Background Data Analysis (LAMBDA). Support
for it is provided by the NASA Office of Space Science. The
HEALPix package was used throughout the data analysis
G´orski et al. (2005).
12
P. Vielva and J. L. Sanz
REFERENCES
Abramo L.R., Bernui A., Ferreira I.S., Villela T., Wuensche
C.A., 2006, Phys. Rev. D, 74, 063506
Ackerman L., Carroll S.M., Wise M.B. 2007, Phys. Rev. D,
75, 083502
Akaike H., 1973, Proceed. of the 2nd International Sympo-
sium on Information Theory (eds. Pertov B.N. & Czaki
F), Akad. Kiado, Budapest, 267
Babich D., 2005, Phys. Rev. D., 72, 043003
Bartolo N., Komatsu E., Matarrese S., Riotto A., 2004,
Phys. Rep., 402, 103
Bernui A., Villela T., Wuensche C.A., Leonardi R., Ferreira
I., 2006, A&A, 454, 409
Bernui A., Mota B., Rebou¸cas M.J., Tavakol R., 2007,
A&A, 464, 479
Bielewicz P., Eriksen H.K., Banday A.J., G´orski K.M., Lilje
P.B., 2005, ApJ, 635, 750
Bohmer C.G., Mota D.F., 2008, Phys. Lett. B, 663, 168
Borowiec A., Godlowski W., Szydlowski M., 2006, Phys.
Rev. D, 74, 043502
Bridges M., Lasenby A.N., Hobson M.P., 2006, MNRAS,
369, 1123
Bridges M., McEwen J.D., Lasenby A.N., Hobson M.P.,
2007a, MNRAS, 377, 1473
Bridges M., Lasenby A.N., Hobson M.P., 2007b, MNRAS,
381, 68
Bridges M., McEwen J.D., Cruz M., Lasenby A.N., Hob-
son M.P., Vielva P., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., 2008, MNRAS,
390, 1372
Cabella P., Liguori M., Hansen F.K., Marinucci D., Matar-
rese S., Moscardini L., Vittorio N., 2005, MNRAS, 358,
684
Carvalho P., Rocha G., Hobson M.P., 2008, MNRAS, sub-
mited (preprint arXiv0802.3916)
Cay´on L., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Argueso F., Banday A.J.,
G´orski K.M., 2003, MNRAS, 339, 1189
Cay´on L., Jin J., Treaster A., 2005, MNRAS, 362, 826
Chiang L.-Y., Naselsky P.D., Verkhodanov O. V., 2003,
ApJ, 590, 65
Chiang L.-Y., Naselsky P. D., 2006, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D,
15, 1283
Barreiro R.B., Santos D., D´esert F.-X., Tristram M., 2007,
A&A, 474, 23
Curto A., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Mukherjee P., Barreiro
R.B., Hansen F.K., Liguori M., Matarrese S., 2008, MN-
RAS, in press
Davis T.M. et al., 2007, ApJ, 666, 716
de Oliveira-Costa A., Tegmark M., Zaldarriaga M., Hamil-
ton A., 2004, Phys. Rev. D, 69, 063516
Donoghue E.P., Donoghue J.F., 2005, Phys. Rev. D, 71,
043002
Eriksen H.K., Hansen F.K., Banday A.J., G´orski K.M.,
Lilje P.B., 2004a, ApJ, 605, 14
Eriksen H.K., Novikov D.I., Lilje P.B., Banday A.J., G´orski
K.M., 2004b, ApJ, 612, 64
Eriksen H.K., Banday A.J., G´orski K.M., Lilje P.B., 2005,
ApJ, 622, 58
Eriksen H.K., Banday A.J., G´orski K.M., Hansen F.K.,
Lilje P.B., 2007, ApJ, 660, L81
Feroz F., Allanach B.C., Hobson M., Abdus Salam S.S.,
Trotta R., Weber A.M., 2008a, Journ. of High Energy
Phys., 10, 64
Feroz F., Hobson M.P., Zwart J.T.L., Sounders R.D.E.,
Grainge K.J.B., 2008b, MNRAS, submited (preprint
arXiv0811.1199)
Freeman P.E., Genovese C.R., Miller C.J., Nichol R.C.,
Wasserman L., 2006, ApJ, 638, 1
Gordon C., 2007, ApJ, 656, 636
Gold B., 2008, ApJS, in press
G´orski K.M., Hivon E., Banday A.J., Wandelt B.D.,
Hansen F.K., Reinecke M., Bartelmann M., 2005, ApJ,
622, 759
Gott J.R., Colley W.N., Park C.-G., Park C., Mugnolo C.,
2007, MNRAS, 377, 1668
Groeneboom N.E., Eriksen H.K., 2008, ApJ, in press
Hansen F.K., Cabella P., Marinucci D., Vittorio N., 2004a,
ApJ, 607, L67
Hansen F.K., Banday A. J., G´orski K.M., 2004b, MNRAS,
354, 641 0, 063004
Hikage C., Matsubara T., Coles P., Liguori M., Hansen F.
K., Matarrese S., 2008, MNRAS, 389, 1439
Himmetoglu B., Contaldi C.R., Peloso M., 2008a, (preprint
arXiv0809.2779)
Coles P., Dineen P., Earl J., Wright D., 2004, MNRAS, 350,
Himmetoglu B., Contaldi C.R., Peloso M., 2008a, (preprint
989
Copi C.J., Huterer D., Starkman G.D., 2004, Phys. Rev.
D, 70, 043515
Creminelli P., Nicolis A., Senatore L., Tegmark M., Zaldar-
riaga M., 2006, Journal of Cosmology and Astro-Particle
Physics, 5, 4
Creminelli P., Senatore L., Zaldarriaga M., 2007, Journal
of Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics, 3, 19
Cruz M., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vielva P., Cay´on L., 2005,
MNRAS, 356, 29
Cruz M., Tucci M., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vielva P., 2006,
MNRAS, 369, 57
Cruz M., Cay´on L., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vielva P., Jin
J., 2007a, ApJ, 655, 11
Cruz M., Turok N., Vielva P., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Hob-
son M.P., 2007b, Science, 318, 1612
Cruz M., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vielva P. Diego J.M., Hob-
son M.P., Turok N., 2008, MNRAS, 390, 913
Curto A., Aumont J., Mac´ıas-P´erez, Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E.,
arXiv0812.1231)
Hinshaw G. et al., 2008, ApJS, in press
Jaffe T.R., Banday A.J., Eriksen H.K., G´orski K.M.,
Hansen F.K., 2006a, ApJ, 629, L1
Jaffe T.R., Hervik S., Banday A.J., G´orski K.M., 2006b,
ApJ, 644, 701
Jaffe T.R., Banday A.J., Eriksen H.K., G´orski K.M.,
Hansen F.K., 2006c, preprint (arXiv:astro-ph/0606046v1)
Jeffreys H., 1961, Theory of Probability (3rd edition) Ox-
ford university Press
Katz G., Weeks J., 2004, Phys. Rev. D, 70, 063527
Kogo N., Komatsu E., 2006, Phys. Rev. D., 73, 083007
Komatsu E., Spergel D.N., 2001, Phys. Rev. D, 63, 063002
Komatsu E., et al., 2003, ApJS, 148, 119
Komatsu E., et al., 2008, ApJS, in press
Land K., Magueijo J., 2005a, MNRAS, 357, 994
Land K., Magueijo J., 2005b, Phys. Rev. Lett., 95, 071301
Land K., Magueijo J., 2007, MNRAS, 378, 153
Liguori M., Matarrese S., Moscardini L., 2003, ApJ, 597,
Analysis of NG CMB maps based on the N-pdf
13
57
Liddle A., Lyth D. H., 2000, Cosmological inflation and
large-scale structure, Cambridge University Press
Liddle A., 2004, MNRAS, 351, 49
Liddle A., 2007, MNRAS, 377, 74
Liddle A., Mukherjee P., Parkinson D., Wang Y., 2006,
Phys. Rev. D, 74, 123506
Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Cruz M., Cay´on L., Vielva P., 2006,
New Astron. Rev., 50, 875
McEwen J.D., Hobson M.P., Lasenby A.N., Mortlock D.J.,
2005, MNRAS, 259, 1583
McEwen J.D., Hobson M.P., Lasenby A.N., Mortlock D.J.,
2006, MNRAS, 371, 50
Monteser´ın C., Barreiro R.B., Vielva P., Mart´ınez-
Gonz´alez, Hobson, M.P., Lasenby A.N., 2008, MNRAS,
387, 209
Mukherjee P., Wang Y., 2004, ApJ, 613, 51
Mukherjee P., Parkinson D., Liddle A., 2006, ApJL, 638,
51
Mukherjee P., Liddle A., 2008, MNRAS, 389, 231
Okamoto T., Hu W., 2002, Phys. Rev. D., 66, 063008
Park C.-G., 2004, MNRAS, 349, 313
Pietrobon D., Amblard A., Balbi A., Cabella P., Cooray
A., Mirinucci D., 2008, Phys. Rev. D, 10, 3504
Rath C., Schuecker P., Banday A.J., 2007, MNRAS, 380,
466
Reissanen J., 2001, IEEE Transactions on Information The-
ory, 47, 5
Schwarz G., 1978, Ann. Stat., 6, 461
Schwarz D.J., Starkman G.D., Huterer D., Copi C.J., 2004,
Phys. Rev. Lett., 93, 221301
Spergel D.N. et al., 2007, ApJS, 170, 377
Szydlowski M., Godlowski W., 2006, Phys. Lett. B, 633,
427
Szydlowski M., Kurek A., Krawiec A., 2006, Phys. Lett. B,
642, 171
Szydlowski M., Godlowski W., Stachowiak T., 2008, Phys.
Rev. D, 77, 043530
Tojeiro R., Castro P.G., Heavens A.F., Gupta S., 2006,
MNRAS, 365, 265
Vielva P., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Barreiro R.B., Sanz J.L.,
Cay´on L., 2004, ApJ, 609, 22
Vielva P., Wiaux Y., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vandergheynst
P., 2006, New Astron. Rev., 50, 880
Vielva P., Wiaux Y., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vandergheynst
P., 2007, MNRAS, 381, 932
Wiaux Y., Vielva P., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez E., Vandergheynst
P., 2006, Phys. Rev. Lett., 96, 151303
Wiaux Y., Vielva P., Barreiro R.B., Mart´ınez-Gonz´alez,
Vandergheynst P., 2008, MNRAS, 385, 939
Yadav A.P.S., Wandelt B.D., 2008, Phys. Rev. Lett., 100,
181301
|
astro-ph/9806346 | 1 | 9806 | 1998-06-25T20:32:38 | Mass Transfer and Accretion in the Eccentric Neutron-Star Binary Circinus X-1 | [
"astro-ph"
] | I have carried out a project to study the eccentric neutron-star binary Circinus X-1 through an extensive series of observational studies with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite and through theoretical computer models I developed to explore mass transfer and evolution in an eccentric binary. I modeled the evolution of the energy spectrum during intensity dips with a variably absorbed bright component plus a fainter unabsorbed component. I show that variability not attributable to absorption dips is related to the spectral/intensity states of the ``Z source'' class of low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs), namely motion along (or shifts of) the horizontal, normal, and flaring branches of the ``Z'' track in color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams. I found rapid X-ray variability properties associated with each spectral/intensity state: On the horizontal branch, quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in the X-ray intensity shift in frequency from 1.3 to 35 Hz. On the normal branch, a different QPO occurs at about 4 Hz. On the flaring branch only strong aperiodic variability occurs. I also modeled the evolution of the energy spectra associated with each of these branches. To study mass transfer in an eccentric binary, I developed computer codes for transfer via Roche-lobe overflow and from a stellar wind. I derive theoretical mass accretion profiles and compare them to the observed profile of the X-ray intensity. In order to explore the possible evolutionary history of Circinus X-1, I developed a binary-evolution computer code for a neutron-star and low-mass companion in an eccentric orbit. I use this code in a population-synthesis study to show that the number of systems in the Galaxy expected to resemble Cir X-1 is of order unity, consistent with its unique status as an LMXB with high eccentricity. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Mass Transfer and Accretion in the Eccentric Neutron-Star
Binary Circinus X-1
by
Robert E. Shirey
Submitted to the Department of Physics
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
at the
MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
September 1998
c(cid:13) Robert E. Shirey, MCMXCVIII. All rights reserved.
The author hereby grants to MIT permission to reproduce and distribute publicly
paper and electronic copies of this thesis document in whole or in part, and to grant
others the right to do so.
Author . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Department of Physics
June 19, 1998
Certified by . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Hale V. D. Bradt
Professor of Physics
Thesis Supervisor
Accepted by . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Thomas J. Greytak
Associate Department Head for Education
Mass Transfer and Accretion in the Eccentric Neutron-Star Binary
Circinus X-1
by
Robert E. Shirey
Submitted to the Department of Physics
on June 19, 1998, in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
Abstract
I have carried out a project to study the eccentric neutron-star binary Circinus X-1 through an
extensive series of observational studies with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite and through
theoretical computer models I developed to explore mass transfer and evolution in an eccentric
binary. We also organized two multi-frequency campaigns to study correlated variability in different
frequency bands.
The X-ray observations showed that the intensity of Cir X-1 currently maintains a bright baseline
level, with strong flares occurring after phase zero of each 16.55-day cycle of the source. This behavior
is thought to be due to enhanced mass transfer occurring near periastron of a highly eccentric binary
orbit. Dips below the baseline intensity level also occur near phase zero.
I modeled the evolution of the energy spectrum during dips with a variably absorbed bright com-
ponent plus a fainter unabsorbed component. I show that variability not attributable to absorption
dips is related to the spectral/intensity states of the "Z source" class of low-mass X-ray binaries
(LMXBs), namely motion along (or shifts of) the horizontal, normal, and flaring branches of the
"Z" track in color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams.
I found rapid X-ray variability properties associated with each spectral/intensity state: On the
horizontal branch, quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in the X-ray intensity shift in frequency from
1.3 to 35 Hz. On the normal branch, a different QPO occurs at about 4 Hz. On the flaring branch
only strong aperiodic variability occurs. I modeled the evolution of the energy spectra associated
with each of these branches.
To study mass transfer in an eccentric binary, I developed computer codes for transfer via Roche-
lobe overflow and from a stellar wind. I derive theoretical mass accretion profiles and compare them
to the observed profile of the X-ray intensity.
In order to explore the possible evolutionary history of Circinus X-1, I developed a binary-
evolution computer code for a neutron-star and low-mass companion in an eccentric orbit. I use this
code in a population-synthesis study to show that the number of systems in the Galaxy expected
to resemble Cir X-1 is of order unity, consistent with its unique status as an LMXB with high
eccentricity.
Thesis Supervisor: Hale V. D. Bradt
Title: Professor of Physics
Acknowledgments
First, I would like to thank Prof. Hale Bradt for giving me the opportunity to work with him and
participate in the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer project. He has demonstrated how to think like
a scientist and produce clear scientific writings. He has always supported me and encouraged my
efforts.
I also want to thank Prof. Saul Rappaport for helping with the several theoretical modeling
projects in my thesis. Although I was initially reluctant to delve into theoretical calculations, I
eventually found that they were not to be feared and could be quite interesting.
Ed Morgan got me started on Circinus X-1 several years ago by suggesting I work on a proposal
to observe Cir X-1 with RXTE once it launched. I also learned many analysis techniques from Ed.
Al Levine has provided much-appreciated scientific guidance, especially in writing papers. His
participation has certainly improved the quality of my work.
In fact, all the members of the RXTE team at M.I.T. have contributed to my education and to
this project. Ron Remillard, Wei Cui, and Deepto Chakrabarty have all given helpful advice and
shared experiences with analyzing and interpreting RXTE data.
The people I've interacted with most at M.I.T. are the other graduate students, and my office
mates in particular. Don Smith came to M.I.T. at the same time I did, so we've shared all the
ups and downs of the experience. He, Linqing Wen, and Mike Muno have all been great to work
with and to discuss ideas with around the office. Our former office mates Charlie Collins and Chris
Becker provided a wealth of knowledge and experience about M.I.T., Boston, and astrophysics. In
particular my binary evolution code was based on one Chris developed as part of his thesis.
I would like to thank all the members of our multi-frequency campaigns for all their efforts to
coordinate observations and willingness to share data: George Nicolson, Ian Glass, Allyn Tennant,
Rob Fender, Kinwah Wu, and Helen Johnston.
My parents have supported my interest in astronomy from the beginning. They gave me a 6-inch
diameter telescope for Christmas when I was in elementary school (and then let me sell it several
years later when an Atari system seemed more important).
Finally, I want to thank my wife, Anne, for supporting me in so many ways throughout the
whole process. When we were married, exactly five years ago, I'm sure she didn't know what she
was getting into. She has made many sacrifices to help make this happen. Now five years and two
children (Ben and Alex) later, we've finally reached this milestone. I thank her for her patience,
support, and love. This thesis is for Anne.
Robert Shirey
Cambridge, MA
June 19, 1998
Contents
1 Introduction
1.1 X-ray Astronomy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.2 X-ray Binaries
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.2.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.2.2 HMXBs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.2.3 LMXBs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3 Circinus X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.1
Intensity Cycle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.2 X-ray Bursts
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.3 Rapid X-ray Variability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.4 Distance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.5 Young Runaway Binary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.6
Infrared and Optical Counterpart . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.3.7 Radio Ephemeris . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.4 Objectives and Overview of this Project . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 The Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer
2.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.2 Proportional Counter Array . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.3 High-Energy X-ray Timing Experiment
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.4 All-Sky Monitor
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.5 Experiment Data System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3 Overview of RXTE Observations
3.1 ASM Observations of Circinus X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.1.1 General Features of the ASM Light Curves
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.1.2 Cycling Hardness Ratios . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.1.3
16.55-day Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5
23
23
23
23
24
25
28
28
28
29
29
29
30
31
31
33
33
33
35
36
37
39
39
39
41
41
6
CONTENTS
3.1.4 Folded Cycle Profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2 PCA Observations of Circinus X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2 Observation Summaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.1
Study A: 1996 March 5–21 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.2
Study B: 1996 April 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.3
Study C: 1996 May 7–14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.4
Study D: 1996 Sept. 20 – Oct. 8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.5
Study E: 1997 Feb. 18 – Mar. 4
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.6
Study F: 1997 May 16 – May 21 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.7
Study G: 1997 June 4–22 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.2.2.8
Study H: 1997 Sept. 18 – Oct. 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4 X-ray Timing and Spectral Evolution vs. Orbital Phase
4.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.2 Observations and Results
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4.3 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5 QPOs Associated with Spectral Branches
5.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.2 Observations
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.3 Analysis and Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.3.1 Color-color and Hardness-intensity Diagrams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.3.2 Power Density Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.3.3 Temporal Behavior versus Position on Spectral Branches . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.1 Horizontal Branch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.2 Normal Branch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.3 Flaring Branch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.4.4 Relation to Other Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6 Correlated Timing and Spectral Behavior
6.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.2
1997 June PCA Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
41
44
44
46
46
48
49
49
50
50
50
50
53
53
54
59
61
61
62
64
64
67
73
73
73
75
76
76
79
81
81
82
CONTENTS
6.3 Complete Spectral Track . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.4 Evolution of the Power Density Spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.5 Evolution of the Energy Spectrum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.6 Selection of Spectral Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
6.7 Fits to Spectra from 20 HID Regions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
82
89
91
93
96
6.8 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101
7 Absorption Dips
103
7.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103
7.2 Dips in RXTE Light Curves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103
7.3 Evolution of Hardness Ratios During Dips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104
7.4 Evolution of Energy Spectra During Dips
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109
7.4.1
Spectral Model
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109
7.4.2
Spectral Fitting Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112
7.4.3 Energy Spectra Inside and Outside Dips . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113
7.4.4
Iron Emission Line . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117
7.4.5
Spectral Evolution During Dip Transitions
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118
7.5 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122
8 Multi-frequency Observations
125
8.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125
8.2 May 1996 Campaign . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125
8.2.1 Radio (HartRAO)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
8.2.2
Infrared Photometry (SAAO) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128
8.2.3 Correlated Multi-frequency Variability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128
8.3 June 1997 Campaign . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128
8.3.1 Radio (HartRAO)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130
8.3.2
IR Photometry (SAAO) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130
8.3.3
IR Spectroscopy (ANU) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132
8.3.4 Optical Spectroscopy (AAT)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132
8.3.5 Comparison of the AAT Optical Spectrum to HST Results
. . . . . . . . . . 132
8.4 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135
9 Mass Transfer in an Eccentric Binary
137
9.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137
8
CONTENTS
9.2 Mass Transfer via Roche-Lobe Overflow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137
9.2.1 Equipotential Surfaces in an Eccentric Binary Orbit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138
9.2.2 Keplerian Orbits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138
9.2.3 Trajectory of a Particle in the Binary Potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139
9.2.4 Final Outcome of Particle Trajectories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139
9.2.5 Comparison to the X-ray Intensity Profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 142
9.3 Mass Transfer via a Stellar Wind . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 142
9.3.1 Bondi-Hoyle Accretion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145
9.3.2 Wind Accretion Profile in an Eccentric Binary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146
9.3.3 Comparison to the X-ray Intensity Profile . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147
10 Eccentric Binary Evolution
149
10.1 Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149
10.2 Binary Evolution Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149
10.2.1 Evolution of Binary Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149
10.2.2 Evolution of the Donor Star Radius
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151
10.2.2.1 Nuclear Evolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151
10.2.2.2 Thermal Readjustment Toward Equilibrium . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152
10.2.2.3 Adiabatic Response to Mass Loss
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152
10.2.3 Evolution of Orbital Parameters
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 152
10.2.3.1 Tidal Evolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153
10.2.3.2 Effect of Mass Transfer on the Orbit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154
10.2.3.3 Magnetic Braking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155
10.2.3.4 Gravitational Radiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155
10.2.4 Stable Mass Transfer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156
10.3 Binary Evolution Code . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158
10.3.1 Code Algorithm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158
10.3.2 Results
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159
10.4 Monte-Carlo Population Synthesis
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163
10.4.1 Systems Resembling Cir X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163
10.4.2 Predicted System Parameters for Cir X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165
10.5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170
11 Conclusions
171
CONTENTS
A Fourier Timing Techniques
9
175
A.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175
A.2 Power Density Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176
A.2.1 Leahy Normalization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176
A.2.2 Estimate of the Poisson Noise Level
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176
A.2.3 Fractional RMS Variability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177
A.2.4 Estimates of Power Variance
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 177
A.2.5 Data Gaps
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178
A.2.6 Variable Number of Detectors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 178
A.3 Complex Cross Spectra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180
A.3.1 Time Lags . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180
A.3.2 Coherence Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180
B Standard PCA Light Curves
183
10
CONTENTS
List of Figures
1-1 X-ray color-color diagrams and power density spectra typical of Z sources and atoll
sources. The soft color is approximately I [3–5 keV] / I [1–3 keV] and the hard color
I [6.5–18 keV] / I [5–6.5 keV]. Power spectra are shown for the horizontal, normal, and
flaring branches (HB/NB/FB) of Z sources, and the island state, lower banana, and
upper banana (IS/LB/UB) of atoll sources. (Figure from van der Klis 1995 [78].)
.
27
2-1 Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer spacecraft. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
34
3-1 ASM light curve (1.5–12 keV; 90-s exposures) covering 1996 January – 1998 May.
Phase zero is indicated by vertical dotted lines. Bars along the top axis mark the
times of PCA observations (labeled A–H; see section 3.2).
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
40
3-2 Light curve and two hardness ratios for the first ten full 16.55-day cycles of Cir X-1
observed with the ASM. Each light-curve point is the average count rate (I [1.5–
12 keV]) from a single 90-s ASM exposure. The hardness ratios were obtained from
1-day averages of the 90-s intensities and are defined as HR1=I [3–5 keV] / I [1.5–
3 keV] and HR2=I [5–12 keV] / I [3–5 keV]. The vertical dotted lines indicate phase
zero.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
42
3-3 Folded light curve of Cir X-1 from the three ASM energy bands. The data are repeated
in order to show two complete cycles. Each point is from a 90-s exposure, with a
typical error bar of 1–2 c/s. The folded data spans the entire time period covered by
Figure 3-1.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43
11
12
LIST OF FIGURES
3-4 Left: Folded Cir X-1 light curve from the full ASM energy band (1.5–12 keV) and
two hardness ratios. Right: Folded light curves from the three ASM energy bands.
The data are binned into 100 phase bins per cycle, averaged in each phase bin, and
duplicated to show two complete cycles. Error bars on the light curves indicate the
standard deviation of the mean value derived for each phase bin, and these error
estimates were propagated when computing the hardness ratios. The folded data
spans the entire time period covered by Figure 3-1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
45
3-5 Light curves for each 16.55-d cycle of Cir X-1 observed with the PCA. For each cycle,
the phase-zero date and letter of the study (see Table 3.1) are listed. The intensity is
for the full PCA energy range, and a conversion factor of 1 Crab ≈ 2600 counts s−1
PCU−1 has been used. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3-6 PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the
hard band to that in the soft band, for the observation on 1996 April 7 (study B),
spanning 15 ks. The lowest intensity in both bands during dips is well above the
background level (∼30 c/s and ∼45 c/s for 2–7.4 keV and 7.4–28 keV respectively,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
not subtracted).
47
48
3-7 PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the
hard band to that in the soft band, for the observations on 1996 September 24 –
October 8 (study D). Due to some observations with a PCU not operating, all points
in this plot were derived from PCUs 0, 1, & 2 and adjusted by 5/3 for comparison
with other figures in this section. Phase zeros occurred at days 346.782 and 363.328.
49
3-8 PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins; 13 kilocounts/s=1.0 Crab for the
combined 2-33 keV band), and the ratio of intensity in the hard band to that in the
soft band, for the observation on 1997 September 20 (part of study H), spanning
7000 s.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
51
4-1 PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the
hard band to that in the soft band, for observations 1–11 of 1996 March. Phase
zero corresponds to day 148.227. The intensity is well above the background level
in both bands (∼25 c/s and ∼40 c/s for 2–6.3 keV and 6.3–24 keV respectively, not
subtracted) even during the dips. Observation 12 is omitted since it was carried out
with only three PCUs and a different gain setting.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
55
LIST OF FIGURES
4-2 Sample PCA light curves (2–60 keV) comparing 2000-s segments showing (a) strong
variability and dips near phase zero (phase 0.98; Obs. 1), (b) a brighter portion of the
bright flaring state three days later (phase 0.15; Obs. 2), and (c) a typical observation
away from phase zero (phase 0.50; Obs. 6). Background (∼100 c/s) is not subtracted
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
and no deadtime corrections have been made.
13
56
4-3 Power density spectra from seven RXTE orbits away from phase zero, offset downward
at decade intervals. (The ordinate scale applies to the top curve.) The curves are
ordered by the frequency of the 1.3–12 Hz QPO peak and are labeled with orbital
phase.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
4-4 Flat-top power level (a) and QPO frequency (b) as a function of orbital phase over a
single orbital cycle. (c) Frequency of the narrow low-frequency QPO and the broad
high-frequency QPO vs. the flat-top power level. (d) Cut-off frequency of the flat-
topped power vs. flat-top power level.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
59
5-1 RXTE ASM light curves (1.5–12 keV) for three 16.55 d cycles of Cir X-1 showing
different flaring profiles. Each intensity point corresponds to a 90-s exposure by one of
the three ASM cameras, and the hardness ratio (HR), defined as the ratio of counting
rates for 5–12 keV to 3–5 keV, is shown in one-day averages. The 3–5 keV to 1.5–3 keV
hardness ratio exhibits very similar behavior and is not shown here. The intensities
are for Cir X-1 after background and other sources in the field of view have been
subtracted. The Crab nebula yields ∼75 c/s. Vertical dashed lines indicate phase
zero based on the radio ephemeris of Stewart et al. 1991. Day zero corresponds to
(a) 1997 April 23.87 (b) 1996 August 2.14 and (c) 1997 February 16.69. For cycle
(c), the intensity ranges (I [2.0–18 keV]) seen in the eight RXTE PCA observations
(I–VIII in time order) are also shown.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
63
5-2 PCA light curves (2–18 keV, 5 PCUs) and hardness ratios (HR = I [6.3–13 keV] /
I [2.0–6.3 keV]) in 16 s time bins for the eight observations made during 1997 Febru-
ary 18 – March 4. A count rate of 13 kcts/s ≈ 1.0 Crab. The data gaps in Obs. VI were
longer than as shown here; the second segment of the observation has been shifted
left by 4000 s and the third segment by 5000 s. These data were used to construct
the hardness-intensity diagram in Figure 5-3. The association with specific regions of
that diagram is indicated below each light curve.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
65
14
LIST OF FIGURES
5-3 Color-color diagram (a) and hardness-intensity diagram (b) for all eight observations
(I–VIII). In the CD, soft color is defined as I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV] and hard
color as I [13–18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV]. In the HID, the intensity, I [2.0–18 keV], is
from all five PCUs and the hardness ratio is a "broad" color: I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–
6.3 keV]. Each point corresponds to 16 s of data. Background has been subtracted,
but it does not affect the intensity or soft color and only slightly affects the hard color.
The three insets in the CD separate overlapping points from observations I–V. The
HID track for each observation has been divided into three regions (1–3) for timing
analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
66
5-4 Averaged and rebinned power density spectra (2–32 keV) for each of the three HID
regions for each observation. Poisson noise has been subtracted from each PDS (see
text). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
67
5-5 Averaged and rebinned power density spectra for HID region VIII-3 in three energy
bands. A harmonic peak of the 7.6 Hz QPO is clearly visible in the high-energy
channel (c). The broad high-frequency peak, most clear in (b), occurs near ∼100 Hz
in this observation. The low-frequency noise cuts off less sharply as energy increases.
69
5-6 Centroid frequency of the QPOs versus intensity (I [2.0–18 keV]). A filled circle rep-
resents the narrow QPO and a filled square represents the broad ∼4 Hz QPO (all
points below 5 Hz are the broad QPO). Unfilled circles and squares indicate the
approximate frequency of a knee or very weak peak that may be associated with the
narrow and broad QPO respectively. Error bars on frequency measurements (filled
points only) represent 90% confidence intervals for a single parameter (∆χ2=2.7). In
many cases, the error bar for the QPO frequency is smaller than the plot symbol. . .
71
5-7 Rms amplitude of QPOs versus photon energy. Panel (a) shows the rms for the narrow
QPO at 7.2 Hz (solid dot) and (b) for an example of the broad 4 Hz QPO (solid box).
In panel (c), unfilled circles and boxes indicate the rms amplitude of a component
forming a knee or very weak peak that may be associated with the narrow and broad
QPOs respectively. The broad QPO points have been offset slightly to the right in
energy for clarity. Errors on QPO amplitudes represent 90% confidence intervals. . .
72
5-8 Hardness-intensity diagram showing QPO properties for the regions from Figure 5-3b.
The frequency of the 6.8 to 32 Hz QPO is labeled (in Hz) beside each region where it
is present. Parenthesized frequencies indicate that this component was unpeaked, i.e.,
a knee. Letters indicate the strength of the broad 4 Hz QPO: S-strong, M-medium,
and W-weak or unpeaked.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
74
LIST OF FIGURES
15
5-9 Broad-color and hard-color CDs and HIDs for observations V and VI. In all four
diagrams, Obs. V is in the lower left and Obs. VI in the upper right. The CD and
HID tracks for Obs. V both turn upward at the left end in the broad-color diagrams
(a,b) but turn downward in the hard-color diagrams (c,d). In the HIDs, presence of
the 32 Hz HBO, 4 Hz NBO, and VLFN is indicated along the branches. An apparent
shift of the normal branch between observations V and VI is labeled in (b). The
intensity, I [2.0–18 keV], is from all five PCUs. The soft color is defined as I [4.8–
6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV], the broad color as I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV], and
the hard color as I [13–18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV]. Each point corresponds to 16 s of
background-subtracted data.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
77
6-1 Light curves in four energy bands and two hardness ratios for PCA observations of
Cir X-1 from 1997 June 10–20, covering a 10-day period around phase zero (φ = 0).
The intensities at the beginning of these observations (day 610) are typical "quiescent"
levels. Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1,
and 2. Ratios of the intensities in the four bands produce soft (I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–
4.8 keV]) and hard (I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV]) hardness ratios. Segments labeled
A, B, C & D were used for spectral studies.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
83
6-2 Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams from PCA observations during 1997 June
10–21 (the entire period covered by Figure 6-1). Each point represents 16 s of
background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
84
6-3 Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams from time segments "C" (left panels)
and "D" (right panels) of Figure 6-1 (1997 June 13.625–14.125 and 1997 June 17.075–
17.600 respectively). Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted data from
PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
85
6-4 Hardness-intensity diagram from time segment C (1997 June 13.625–14.125; day
12.625–13.125). The HID track has been divided into 20 regions from which power
density spectra and energy spectra were constructed.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
87
6-5 Top: light curves in 3 energy channels and bottom: total 2–18 keV light curve, broad
color, and HID regions for time segment C (1997 June 13.625-14.125; see Figure 6-1).
Based on HID region numbers, the predominant spectral branch is identified for each
portion of the data. Absorption dips (omitted from HID regions) are clearly identified
by decreased intensity coupled with upward broad-color spikes.
. . . . . . . . . . . .
88
16
LIST OF FIGURES
6-6 Averaged and rebinned power density spectra (2–32 keV) for each of the 20 regions
along the HID track in Figure 6-4. The estimated Poisson noise level has been sub-
tracted from each PDS.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
90
6-7 Cir X-1 energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) for several regions on each segment
of the HID track in Figure 6-4. The region numbers within the figures are ordered
vertically to match the relative intensities at the low and/or high-energy ends of the
spectra.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92
6-8 Spectrum A and model (histogram) consisting of a disk blackbody and blackbody
(see Table 6.1). The residuals show a peak at 6–7 keV that may be due to an iron
emission line.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
95
6-9 Fitted energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) and model components (disk black-
body and blackbody) for HID regions 1, 7, and 11 of Figure 6-4. The disk blackbody
dominates at low energy and the blackbody dominates at high energy. Fit parameters
are listed in Table 6.2.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
98
6-10 Fitted energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) and model components (disk black-
body and blackbody) for HID regions 13, 15, and 20 of Figure 6-4. The blackbody
only contributes to the high-energy end of the spectrum in region 13, and has faded
away entirely in regions 15 and 20. Fit parameters are listed in Table 6.2.
. . . . .
99
6-11 Spectra from HID regions 17 and 20 (crosses) and fitted models (histograms) consist-
ing of a disk blackbody and blackbody. The ratio of residuals to error bars shows a
narrow edge or line-like feature above 10 keV.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100
7-1 Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios for PCA observations
of Cir X-1 from 1996 September 20–22, covering a two-day period around phase zero
(φ = 0). Three dips have been identified for further study. Each point represents
16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2. Ratios of the intensities
produce soft (I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV]) and hard (I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV])
hardness ratios. The intensity levels of the segment at day ∼347.2 (after Dip 1) are
close to the level in each band during the quiescent phases of the orbit.
. . . . . . . 105
7-2 Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 1. Time zero corresponds to day 347.041 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness
ratio points are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from two 96-
s time segments (A and B), indicated by dotted vertical lines, and four 16-s segments
(a–d) indicated by diamonds.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
LIST OF FIGURES
17
7-3 Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 2. Time zero corresponds to day 347.254 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness
ratio points are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from two
304-s time segments (A and B), indicated by dotted vertical lines, and four 16-s
segments (a–d), indicated by diamonds.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107
7-4 Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 3. Time zero corresponds to day 347.325 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness
ratio points are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from six
16-s time segments (a–f), indicated by diamonds.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108
7-5 Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams for the last 1716 s of data in Figure 7-4,
during which the intensity gradually transitioned from the non-dip baseline to the
bottom of a dip. Intensity is I [2.0–18 keV], and the hardness ratios are defined as soft
color: I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV], hard color: I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV], and
broad color: I [6.3–18 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]. Each point represents 16 s of background-
subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110
7-6 Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams for the first three segments in Figure 7-1
(day 346.31–346.52), during which Cir X-1 was in an extended low/dip state. Intensity
is I [2.0–18 keV], and the hardness ratios are defined as soft color: I [4.8–6.3 keV] /
I [2.0–4.8 keV], hard color: I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV], and broad color: I [6.3–
18 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]. Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted data
from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111
7-7 Top: Spectral fits for 96-s segments prior to Dip 1 (spectrum A) and during Dip 1
(spectrum B). Bottom: same spectra and model (see text), but with a Gaussian
emission-line component included to fit the peaked residuals near 6.5 keV. The data
shown are from PCU 0 only. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114
7-8 Top: Spectral fits for 304-s segments prior to Dip 2 (spectrum A) and during Dip 2
(spectrum B). Bottom: same spectra and model (see text), but with a Gaussian
emission-line component included to fit the peaked residuals near 6.5 keV. The data
shown are from PCU 0 only. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115
7-9 Spectral fits for four 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 1. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the four jointly-fit curves.
The data shown are from PCU 0 only.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119
18
LIST OF FIGURES
7-10 Spectral fits for four 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 2. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the four jointly-fit curves.
The data shown are from PCU 0 only.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120
7-11 Spectral fits for six 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 3. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the six jointly-fit curves. The
data shown are from PCU 0 only. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121
8-1 X-ray, IR, and radio light curves of Cir X-1 from 1996 May 7–17. Phase zero is
indicated by the vertical dotted line at day 214.413 (1997 May 11.413). PCA intensity
is from the 2–32 keV band (16-s bins) and ASM intensity is from 2–12 keV (90-s
exposures). Errors on the PCA data are negligible. Typical error bars are shown for
the ASM, IR, and radio data: errors on the ASM data are typically 2–5 c/s, on the IR
data are typically about 0.03 magnitudes (worse on days 214 & 215), and on the radio
data are about 30 mJy. The average quiescent level of 29 mJy has been subtracted
from the radio data. (Data provided by I. Glass (IR), G. Nicolson (radio), and the
RXTE /ASM team.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126
8-2 X-ray and IR light curves of Cir X-1 from day 212.93–213.19. X-ray intensity is from
the 2–32 keV PCA band (16-s bins). A typical IR error bar of +/−0.03 magnitudes
is shown. (IR data courtesy of I. Glass.)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129
8-3 X-ray (PCA and ASM) and radio (5.0 GHz) light curves of Cir X-1 from 1997 May 7 –
August 25. Phase zero is indicated by the vertical dotted lines. PCA intensity is from
the 2–32 keV band (16-s bins) and ASM intensity is from 2–12 keV (90-s exposures).
Errors on the PCA data are negligible and errors on the ASM data are typically 2–
5 c/s. For each 16.55-d cycle, the average radio flux for the phase interval 0.3 to 0.9
of that cycle was subtracted from the data; the bias removed was typically 50–60 mJy
and a typical error bar is shown. (The radio data was provided by G. Nicolson, and
ASM data by the RXTE /ASM team. The PCA data are from studies F and G; see
Table 3.1.)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131
8-4 Infrared spectrum of Cir X-1 from ANU on 1997 June 20 (about phase 0.5), showing
He I (2.06 µm) and H Brackett γ (2.165 µm) emission lines. This spectrum was
compiled from the sum of 16 120-s exposures. (Figure courtesy of H. Johnston.)
. . 133
8-5 Optical spectrum of Cir X-1 from AAT on 1997 June 4 (about phase 0.5), showing a
prominent Hα emission line, as well as weaker He I(6678 A) and He I(7065 A) lines.
(Figure courtesy of H. Johnston.)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134
LIST OF FIGURES
19
9-1 Panels (a) and (c): stop time of particles in a system with e=0.5 (and P=16.55 d)
versus time of release from donor (1 M⊙), with the final outcome (recapture or entry
into disk) indicated. Panels (b) and (d): normalized rate of particles entering the
accretion disk versus their arrival time relative to periastron. The top panels, (a) and
(b), are for an initial radial velocity from the surface of 30 km/s, and the bottom
panels, (c) and (d), are for 60 km/s. In (a) and (c), the solid diagonal line has a slope
of unity and indicates zero elapsed time between release and the final outcome; the
horizontal dashed line indicates a final outcome occurring at periastron.
. . . . . . . 141
9-2 Panels (a) and (c): stop time of particles in a system with e=0.8 (and P=16.55 d)
versus time of release from donor (1 M⊙), with the final outcome (recapture or entry
into disk) indicated. Panels (b) and (d): normalized rate of particles entering the
accretion disk versus their arrival time relative to periastron. The top panels, (a) and
(b), are for an initial radial velocity from the surface of 50 km/s, and the bottom
panels, (c) and (d), are for 100 km/s. In (a) and (c), the solid diagonal line has a
slope of unity and indicates zero elapsed time between release and the final outcome;
the horizontal dashed line indicates a final outcome occurring at periastron.
. . . . 143
9-3 Trajectory of a particle moving in an eccentric binary system (Mdon=1 M⊙, e=0.5),
where the particle starts with an initial radial velocity of 60 km/s off the surface of
the donor at a time t0 relative to periastron. The plot is in a non-rotating frame with
the CM at the origin (+). The location of the particle, donor star, and neutron star at
t0 are indicated by the diamond, asterisk, and solid dot respectively. The subsequent
motion of the particle until enters the accretion disk or is recaptured is shown as a
solid curve, and the motion of the donor and neutron star in their orbits during that
time is indicated by a dashed or dotted ellipse segment respectively.
. . . . . . . . . 144
9-4 Wind accretion rate versus orbital phase for three eccentricities and wind speeds for
a 5 M⊙ donor. Each curve is normalized by its peak value; the actual wind capture
fraction (relative to the mass-loss rate of the donor) decreases significantly with higher
velocity.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148
10-1 Results of a binary evolution calculation for a system started with the donor star just
filling its critical potential lobe, with initial values: Mdon = 2 M⊙, a = 9.34 R⊙, and
e = 0.6. The donor remains in contact with its critical potential lobe throughout the
evolution; thus, the curve for Rlobe coincides with the curve for Rdon. A solid dot on
some of the curves marks the time corresponding to an orbital period of 16.55 days.
161
20
LIST OF FIGURES
10-2 Results of binary evolution calculation for a system started with the donor underfilling
its critical potential lobe, with initial values: Mdon = 1 M⊙, a = 27 R⊙, and e = 0.9.
162
10-3 Eccentricity and mass transfer rate versus time for binaries with initial values Mdon =
2 R⊙, e = 0.9, and semimajor axes (a) between 37 and 128 R⊙.
. . . . . . . . . . . 164
10-4 Histograms of number of binaries versus initial Mdon and e which eventually reach
P = 16.55 d and 1×10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 1×10−7 M⊙/yr. The y-axis normalization
is arbitrary.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166
10-5 Histograms of the number of binaries versus various system parameters at the time
when systems resemble Cir X-1, i.e., P = 16.55 d and 1×10−9 M⊙/yr < M <
1×10−7 M⊙/yr. The y-axis normalization is arbitrary.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 167
10-6 Optical and infrared absolute magnitudes (V,R,I,J,K) of the donor star in systems
that resemble Cir X-1, i.e., those from Figure 10-5. The y-axis normalization of the
histograms is arbitrary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 169
List of Tables
2.1 Approximate energy ranges for eight PCA bands (A–H) defined in terms of absolute
(0–255) and Standard2 (0–128) channels. Gain epoch 1 includes all observations
before before 1996 March 21, epoch 2 1996 March 21 – April 15, and epoch 3 after
1996 April 15. Energy values shown are derived from the full PCA with all detectors
and layers added.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
37
3.1 PCA observations of Cir X-1 (1996–1997). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
46
4.1 March 1996 PCA observations of Cir X-1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
54
5.1 PCA observations of Cir X-1 during 1997 February 18 – March 4. . . . . . . . . . . .
62
6.1 Fit parameters for spectra A & B for four models.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
94
6.2 Fit parameters for HID regions 1–20 using a model consisting of a disk blackbody and
a blackbody. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
97
7.1 Top group: joint fit parameters of the bright and faint components of spectra from
outside (A) and inside (B) dips 1 and 2. Middle group: the same, but with an added
Gaussian line. Third group: joint fit parameters for the four to six 16-s spectra for
dips 1, 2, and 3. The absorption parameters (N (1)
H ) for the bright component are given
in Tables 7.2 (A–B) & 7.4 (a-f) and the iron line parameters are given in Table 7.3.
116
7.2 Effective hydrogen column density of the bright component outside (A) and inside
(B) Dips 1 and 2 (from fits with and without a ∼6.5 keV Gaussian emission line).
. 116
7.3 Gaussian emission-line parameters for the joint fits of spectra outside and inside dips
(A–B) and during entry into a dip (a–d, a–f). In each case, the same Gaussian line
parameters were used for each spectrum in a joint fit.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118
21
22
LIST OF TABLES
7.4 Effective hydrogen column density responsible for the variable absorption in the bright
component, due to photo-electric absorption and Thompson scattering, during 16-s
spectra from Dips 1, 2, and 3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122
8.1 Multi-frequency Observations of Cir X-1 from 1996 May. Dates in parentheses were
cancelled due to poor weather conditions.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127
8.2 Multi-frequency Observations of Cir X-1 from 1997 June. Dates in parentheses were
cancelled due to poor weather conditions.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 130
8.3
Infrared JHKL photometry measurements from 1997 June 14 & 15. Errors are
+/− 0.03, except on the L magnitude the error is +/− 0.05.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . 132
Chapter 1
Introduction
1.1 X-ray Astronomy
X-rays are strongly absorbed by the Earth's atmosphere, making ground-based observations of
astronomical X-ray sources impossible. Thus, X-ray astronomy did not begin until rockets and
high-altitude balloons became available to carry instruments above a significant fraction of the at-
mosphere. The first celestial X-ray source (other than the Sun), Scorpius X-1, was discovered in
1962 using a rocket-borne detector [22]. Additional X-ray sources were first detected by balloon and
rocket experiments during the 1960's.
Many more sources were discovered with the launch of the first astronomical X-ray satellite,
Uhuru, in 1970. This was followed by a series of satellites in the 1970's, including Vela 5, Copernicus,
Ariel V, SAS-3, OSO-7, OSO-8, COS-B, HEAO-1, Einstein, and Hakucho. In the 1980's Tenma,
EXOSAT , Ginga , and Mir-Kvant were launched. Missions in the 1990's include Granat, ROSAT
and ASCA , and most recently, RXTE and BeppoSAX. In the next few years, several major X-ray
spectroscopy and imaging missions will be launched, including AXAF, XMM, and Spectrum-X-
Gamma.
1.2 X-ray Binaries
1.2.1 Overview
Most of the bright celestial X-ray sources are thought to consist of a neutron star or black hole
accreting matter from a binary companion star (see the book X-ray Binaries [43] for a thorough
review of the subject). The gravitational potential energy released when matter falls onto these
23
24
CHAPTER 1.
INTRODUCTION
highly compact objects produces high-luminosity radiation (of order 1037–1038 erg/s) from a small
area (∼10 km radius), resulting in an effective temperature of 106–107 K, i.e., primarily X-ray
wavelengths (λ ∼0.1–100 A, E ∼0.1–100 keV).
The binary orbital period can be well established through Doppler studies of X-ray pulsars (see
section 1.2.2 below). The period is sometimes detected through modulation of the intensity in X-ray,
optical, or other frequency bands. X-ray binaries have periods as short as minutes to as long as
months. When the radial component of the orbital velocity of the companion is also measured,
from Doppler-shifted lines in the optical spectrum, a lower limit to the mass of the compact object
(the mass function) can be derived. A more exact estimate requires knowledge of the mass of the
companion (e.g. measured from Doppler shifts of pulsed X-ray emission) and the inclination angle
of the orbit relative to the line of sight. Even a lower limit can be very informative, since degeneracy
pressure in a neutron star is not expected to be able to support more than about 3 times the mass
of the sun (M⊙). Systems with a mass function in excess of 3 M⊙ are considered strong candidate
black-holes.
X-ray binaries are generally classified into two groups, based on the spectral type (observed or
inferred) of the companion star. High mass X-ray binaries (HMXBs) have O or B-star companions
with masses from several to about 40 M⊙, while low mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) have companions
later than type A (or even a white dwarf), with masses usually about 1 M⊙ or less. The two classes
are believed to be produced via different evolutionary pathways.
1.2.2 HMXBs
In HMXBs, the OB star can have a substantial radiative-driven stellar wind, which removes 10−10–
10−6 M⊙/yr (1 M⊙/yr = 6.30×1025 gm/s) with a terminal velocity up to 2000 km/s. The orbit
of the neutron star or black hole can bring it close enough to the OB star so that it can capture
a significant fraction of the material in the wind and thus power the X-ray source. Because the
compact object is immersed in the wind material, photo-electric absorption often attenuates the
X-ray intensity. In some HMXBs, Roche-lobe overflow also contributes to (or dominates) the total
mass transfer (see section 1.2.3 on LMXBs). Since OB stars are quite bright in optical/UV light,
the optical counterparts of HMXBs are often easily identified.
The spindown rate of radio (rotation-powered) pulsars indicates a high surface magnetic field of
(B >
∼1012 G). Many HMXBs are X-ray pulsars and are also thought to contain a neutron star with
a high magnetic field. Such objects channel accreting material along the magnetic field lines to the
magnetic poles. If the spin and magnetic axes are misaligned, the X-ray beam will rotate (like a
lighthouse beam). If the beam crosses our line of sight, the system will be observed as an accretion-
1.2. X-RAY BINARIES
25
powered X-ray pulsar (in contrast to rotation-powered radio pulsars). The accreted matter produces
a torque that can slow or increase the spin rate (and pulse frequency) of the compact object. In
many systems an accreting white dwarf can be rule out because the rate of change of the pulse
period is too high for an object with a relatively high moment of inertia (compared to a much
smaller neutron star) such as a white dwarf [31]. Pulsations are also assumed to require a surface,
allowing black holes to be ruled out in systems that pulse. Thus, X-ray pulsars are well established
as highly-magnetized accreting neutron stars.
1.2.3 LMXBs
When the companion star in an X-ray binary lacks a significant stellar wind, as is the case for
most LMXBs and some HMXBs, mass transfer generally occurs though overflow of the critical
equipotential surface (Roche lobe) of the star. Matter transferred in this manner is driven through
the inner Lagrange point between the stars and has a high specific angular momentum. The material
forms an accretion disk around the compact object and loses angular momentum though viscosity
until falling onto the surface (or being expelled). X-ray heating of the disk and companion dominates
the optical light from the donor star, often making it difficult to determine the spectral type of the
companion.
Some LMXBs exhibit flares known as type I X-ray bursts. These bursts typically have rise times
from less than a second to ∼10 s and slower decay times, in the range of ∼10 s to minutes. Spectral
evolution during bursts suggests a sharp rise in temperature at the onset of a burst and gradual
cooling during the decay. This behavior is consistent with thermonuclear ignition of accreted matter
that has accumulated on the surface of a neutron star. Because a black hole has no surface, type I
X-ray bursts provide strong evidence that a system contains a neutron star.
Most persistently bright LMXBs are believed to contain low magnetic field neutron stars (B <
∼
109 G) since they generally show X-ray bursts and do not show pulsations (a higher magnetic
field would funnel matter along the field lines onto the poles, where the material would be burned
continuously rather than in bursts, and might produce pulsations due to the non-uniform emission
from the surface [30].)
Neutron-star LMXBs can be classified as either "Z" or "atoll" sources. These categories are
based on the correlated X-ray timing and spectral properties of these sources [27, 78] (see Fig-
ure 1-1). The fast timing properties (on time scales of seconds or less) of LMXBs and black-hole
candidates are typically studied by computing Fourier power density spectra (PDSs), which often
show several broad-band noise components and sometimes peaks due to quasi-periodic intensity
oscillations (QPOs). The spectral properties can be examined by forming ratios of count rates in
26
CHAPTER 1.
INTRODUCTION
different energy bands (X-ray hardness ratios or "colors").
The six LMXBs known as Z sources are: Sco X-1, GX 349+2, GX 17+2, Cyg X-2, GX 5-1,
and GX 340+0. These sources typically trace a "Z" pattern in color-color and hardness-intensity
diagrams (CDs/HIDs), where X-ray "color" or "hardness" refers to the ratio of intensity in one
energy band to that in a lower-energy band, while atoll sources trace a single arc (see Figure 1-1).
Z sources show two types of quasi-periodic oscillations: along the top "horizontal branch" (HB)
of the Z pattern are 13–60 Hz horizontal-branch oscillations (HBOs) which increase in frequency
moving to the right on the diagram, and on the diagonal "normal branch" (NB) are ∼6 Hz normal-
branch oscillations (NBOs). In some Z sources, the normal-branch oscillations are observed to evolve
into 6–20 Hz QPOs (FBOs) on the lower "flaring branch" (FB). The broad-band noise components
of atoll sources also show correlations with position in the spectral diagrams.
The most widely held model for these two classes of LMXBs proposes two physical differences
between them: Z sources have stronger magnetic fields (1–5×109 G) and higher mass accretion
MEdd ∼ 3×10−8 M⊙/yr, or luminosity LEdd ∼ 1.8×1038 erg/s)
rates (near the Eddington limit of
∼108 G and luminosities between 10−3 LEdd and a few
10−1 LEdd) [77]. The suggestion that Z sources have stronger magnetic fields than atoll sources was
than atoll sources (with magnetic fields <
based largely on the existence of QPOs in Z sources and their general absence in atoll sources. In
the magnetospheric beat-frequency model for Z-source horizontal-branch oscillations, the QPOs are
the result of clumps of matter at the inner edge of the accretion disk (at the magnetospheric radius)
which fall in along magnetic field lines to the surface with a frequency that is the difference between
the Keplerian frequency at the magnetospheric radius and the neutron-star spin frequency [1, 37].
In this picture, the absence of such QPOs in atoll sources suggests lower fields so that the disk might
extend almost to the neutron star surface. Near-Eddington accretion rates in Z sources are thought
to be responsible for the QPOs on the normal and flaring branches, where a radial accretion inflow
occurs with oscillations in the optical depth [20].
Recently kilohertz QPOs (∼300–1200 Hz) have been discovered in a number of Z and atoll sources
with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE ). These QPOs possess many interesting properties
(see van der Klis [79] for a recent review). They often appear in pairs that shift together in fre-
quency. In some sources, nearly coherent oscillations have been observed during type I bursts at a
frequency equal to or double the separation between peaks in kHz QPO pairs. This suggests that
a beat-frequency mechanism is responsible, e.g., if the higher-frequency QPO peak is related to the
Keplerian frequency at the inner edge of the accretion disk and the oscillations during bursts reflect
the spin frequency (or twice the spin frequency) of the neutron star, then the lower frequency QPO
would occur at the beat-frequency between the former two frequencies. One such beat-frequency is
1.2. X-RAY BINARIES
27
Figure 1-1: X-ray color-color diagrams and power density spectra typical of Z sources and atoll
sources. The soft color is approximately I [3–5 keV] / I [1–3 keV] and the hard color I [6.5–18 keV] /
I [5–6.5 keV]. Power spectra are shown for the horizontal, normal, and flaring branches (HB/NB/FB)
of Z sources, and the island state, lower banana, and upper banana (IS/LB/UB) of atoll sources.
(Figure from van der Klis 1995 [78].)
28
CHAPTER 1.
INTRODUCTION
the magnetospheric beat-frequency model, previously applied to Z-source horizontal branch oscil-
lations (see above). This model cannot be correct for both types of QPOs since sometimes HBOs
and kHz QPOs are observed simultaneously; other beat-frequency models propose a different radius
associated with the kHz QPOs, e.g., the sonic-point model [48]. Important constraints on neutron
star masses, radii, and equations of state can be derived from these oscillations, since they may
reflect neutron-star spin frequencies and frequencies of orbits very close to the neutron-star surface.
The recent discovery of coherent 2.49-ms pulsations in RXTE observations of the source SAX
J1808.4-3658 demonstrates the existence of millisecond X-ray pulsars [85, 13]. Millisecond X-ray
pulsars are widely held to be the progenitors of millisecond radio pulsars. Angular momentum
transfered to the neutron star by accreting matter is thought to be the mechanism that has spun-up
millisecond radio pulsars, and such sources are expected to appear as X-ray pulsars during the mass
accretion phase.
1.3 Circinus X-1
1.3.1
Intensity Cycle
The X-ray binary Circinus X-1 is unique in its complex temporal and spectral variability. A 16.55 day
cycle of flaring is observed in the X-ray [32] as well as optical [50], IR [23], and radio bands [83].
The high degree of stability of the period of this cycle is evidence that it is the orbital period.
The periodic behavior is believed to be the result of a highly eccentric binary orbit, in which mass
transfer occurs only near periastron, leading to intermittent obscuration and flaring near phase zero
[52, 54, 12].
The X-ray profile and average intensity of the 16.55 day cycle has varied considerably over time
scales of years. The phase zero behavior has been described as a high-to-low transition, a low-to-
high transition, or complex dips and flares (see e.g., [16, 68, 54, 62]). This has lead some authors to
suggest that disk precession or apsidal motion with a time scale of several years plays an important
role in the observed profile [52, 54].
1.3.2 X-ray Bursts
Eight X-ray bursts detected during an EXOSAT observation of Cir X-1 somewhat resembled type I
bursts, but had profiles which left their identification inconclusive [71]. Three additional X-ray bursts
seen during a later EXOSAT observation provided more convincing evidence for type-I behavior,
and thus demonstrated that Cir X-1 is a neutron star with a weak magnetic field [72]. This in turn
1.3. CIRCINUS X-1
29
suggests that Cir X-1 is an LMXB. Further type I bursts have not been observed from Cir X-1 since
the EXOSAT discovery, possibly because the source intensity has been higher during subsequent
observations. (At higher accretion rates, the material is expected to burn continuously on the surface
rather than accumulate, as is necessary for type I bursts [30].)
1.3.3 Rapid X-ray Variability
The rapid X-ray variability of Cir X-1 at times resembles that of both "atoll" and "Z" low-mass
X-ray binaries (LMXBs) as well as black-hole candidates [54]. Quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs)
were reported at 1.4 Hz, 5–20 Hz, and 100–200 Hz in EXOSAT observations of Cir X-1 in a bright
state [69, 70], but other observations at lower intensity showed no such QPOs [54]. Based on these
data, it has been suggested that Cir X-1 is an atoll source that can uniquely reach the Eddington
accretion rate and exhibit normal/flaring branch QPOs at 5–20 Hz [54, 77]. Similar QPOs were
observed in Ginga observations of Cir X-1 [45]. A significant portion of this current project is
devoted to studying the rapid X-ray variability of Cir X-1. The current results demonstrate behavior
associated with all three branches of Z-sources (horizontal, normal, and flaring), including horizontal
and normal branch QPOs. No evidence for atoll-source behavior is found in the current observations;
this might be related to the currently bright state of the source.
1.3.4 Distance
Neutral hydrogen clouds orbiting in the Galaxy produce 21-cm absorption features in the radio
spectrum of sources observed through such clouds. The absorption lines are Doppler shifted by an
amount equal to the radial velocity of clouds in their orbits around the Galaxy. The maximum
velocity observed in these features indicates the radius of the Galactic orbit tangential to the line of
sight, thus putting a lower limit on the distance to the absorbed source. HI absorption features in
the spectrum of Cir X-1 extend to as much as −90 km/s, which puts a lower limit on the distance of
Cir X-1 at about 80% of the distance from the Sun to the center of the Galaxy (∼8–10 kpc, where
1 kpc≡3.086×1021 cm), or 6.4–8 kpc [25, 24].
1.3.5 Young Runaway Binary
Radio images show that Cir X-1 is embedded in a synchrotron nebula which trails back toward the
nearby (∼ 1/2 ◦, or 70 pc at 8 kpc) supernova remnant (SNR) G 321.9-0.3. Inside the nebula, there
is a compact source at the position of Cir X-1, located at (J2000) RA 15 h 20 m 40.99 s, Dec. -57◦
09′ 59.91′′. Jet-like radio structures emanate outward from the compact source for about 30 arcsec
30
CHAPTER 1.
INTRODUCTION
before curving back several arcmin toward the SNR. This suggests that the system is a runaway from
the explosion that created the neutron star ∼30,000-100,000 years ago [67]. The velocity required
for Cir X-1 to travel ∼70 pc in this time is 700–2200 km/s. Although this velocity is quite high
for a binary system, it is not unprecedented. Furthermore, there is spectral evidence that may
also support a high velocity for the system; this is discussed in Chapter 8 in conjunction with our
multi-frequency observations, as are the prospects for a measurement of the angular velocity (proper
motion) of Cir X-1.
The possibility of a young age makes the object highly interesting from the standpoint of binary-
system evolution. For example, mass transfer in a long-period LMXB (P >
∼days) is usually initiated
when the donor star evolves to become a Roche-lobe filling giant star.
If the primary star has
only recently collapsed into a neutron star, this scenario implies that the secondary (probably less
massive) star would be close behind in its evolution; this may be an unlikely scenario. Based
on binary evolution calculations (Chapter 10), I show in this thesis that the system need not be
unusually young to have a high eccentricity and substantial accretion rate, and in fact would probably
have to be much older than the supernova remnant if the donor star has low mass.
1.3.6
Infrared and Optical Counterpart
An optical counterpart of Cir X-1 was resolved from a group of three stars using images and pho-
tometry in the V[0.55µm], R[0.70µm], and I[0.90µm] optical bands and J[1.25 µm], H[1.65 µm],
and K[2.2 µm] infrared bands. This counterpart is highly reddened and shows variability with the
16.55-d period [50].
Each cycle shows an infrared flare beginning shortly after phase zero. IR magnitudes at peak can
reach K=7.2, H=8.5, and J=9.7, while the non-flaring component has magnitudes K∼11.5, H∼12.1,
J∼13.3 [23, 24]. The magnitude of the non-flaring component in optical bands is I∼18.4, R∼19.6,
and V∼21.5 [50].
The non-flaring V−K color is ∼10 mag which would suggest a late type (low-mass) companion.
However, the optical spectrum shows no atmospheric features that would identify the spectral type
of the companion star, suggesting that disk emission dominates over the light of the companion [17].
An early type (high-mass) star would have to be reddened by AV ∼ 11 mag. Based on the minimum
X-ray absorption column observed (NH ∼ 1022), the interstellar extinction can be estimated to be
AV ∼ 4 mag, favoring a low-mass star. However, other methods result in AV ∼ 5 − 11 mag, so that
an O or B-type dwarf or giant (but not supergiant) cannot be ruled out [24]. Past X-ray behavior
has suggested that Cir X-1 is a low mass X-ray binary, and the results in this thesis strengthen this
X-ray evidence by demonstrating Z-source behavior (Chapters 5 and 6).
1.4. OBJECTIVES AND OVERVIEW OF THIS PROJECT
31
1.3.7 Radio Ephemeris
Based on the onset times of radio flares (defined to be phase zero) observed at Hartebeeshoek Radio
Astronomical Observatory (HartRAO) between 1978 and 1988, G. Nicolson calculated the following
ephemeris equation, reported by Stewart et al. [68]:
JD0 = 2443076.87 + (16.5768 − 0.0000353N )N.
(1.1)
Although radio flares have been too weak during the past decade to determine an updated radio
ephemeris, equation 1.1 has proven to be be an excellent predictor of the current X-ray behavior
(see Chapter 3). It should be noted, however, that phase zero no longer necessarily corresponds to
the onset of radio flares. Furthermore, if the cycle is indeed orbital, the exact time of periastron
relative to phase zero is not known. In this thesis, all references to the phase of Cir X-1 cycles are
based on equation 1.1, unless otherwise noted.
The quadratic term in equation 1.1 implies that the period is currently decreasing by about two
minutes per year ( P =4.26×10−6=134 s/yr). This would imply a characteristic time scale (P/2 P )
of only ∼5000 y for the period to change by an amount equal to the current period, assuming the
period changed at a constant rate. If the period truly is changing at such a rapid rate, it would
further support the notion that Cir X-1 is very young. However, the radio and X-ray data are not
yet able to confirm that a quadratic term is required. The change of period in equation 1.1 amounts
to a shift of phase zero of about 25 minutes per year or about 4 hours over a decade.
For convenience, the zero point of equation 1.1 can be shifted by 423 cycles to 1995 De-
cember 31.04, immediately after the December 30 launch of RXTE , by making the substitution
N ′ = N − 423:
JD0 = 2450082.54 + (16.54694 − 0.0000353N ′)N ′.
(1.2)
Thus, the current period will be quoted as 16.55 d throughout this thesis.
1.4 Objectives and Overview of this Project
The M.I.T. Center for Space Research was heavily involved in the pre-launch planning and instru-
mentation for the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer satellite (RXTE ), and continues to participate in the
operations and scientific endeavors of that observatory now that it is in orbit. The capabilities and
scientific instruments of RXTE are described in Chapter 2. Briefly, the main strengths of RXTE
are: excellent time resolution, large collecting area, broad spectral coverage, flexible scheduling,
and ability to monitor the X-ray sky to track the intensity of known sources and detect transient
32
phenomena.
CHAPTER 1.
INTRODUCTION
A main objective of this project was to apply the unique capabilities of RXTE toward some
of the outstanding problems of Circinus X-1 and to relate the results to X-ray binaries in general.
Since the overall intensity of Cir X-1 is known to evolve over a period of years, we first sought to
establish the current state of the source and to study the nature of its cycle profile. Chapter 3 gives
a summary of the long-term behavior of Cir X-1 observed with RXTE as well as an overview of
specific studies we carried out through observations of specific cycles.
A major outstanding issue for Cir X-1 is its unique status among LMXBs as a possible high- M
atoll source that can at times show some types of Z-source behavior. Thus, several studies were
carried out to explore the characteristics of the rapid variability in Cir X-1, as well as how those
timing properties relate to other properties such as orbital phase (Chapter 4) or spectral/intensity
state (Chapters 5 and 6). Chapters 5 and 6 also demonstrate how the energy spectrum evolves
during various stages of the flaring state.
The variability of Cir X-1 has been described as both flares and dips. Dips are important to
understand for several reasons: (1) they might be caused by some part of the mass transfer process,
(2) they help probe the local environment of the system, and (3) they can be confused with other
variability if not properly identified. Detailed spectral analysis of dips in the intensity of Cir X-1 is
presented in Chapter 7.
Since the periodic flaring activity is also observed at other wavelengths, we organized two multi-
frequency campaigns to study correlated variability. These observations are presented in Chapter 8.
An additional objective of this project was to explore how the eccentric orbit of Cir X-1 affects
mass transfer and the evolution of the system. In Chapter 9, I show the results of simple computer
simulations of mass transfer due to a stellar wind or Roche-lobe overflow, for systems with an
eccentric orbit. An eccentric binary evolution code was also developed (Chapter 10) to explore
possible evolutionary paths for systems similar to Cir X-1.
The conclusions based on these studies are discussed in Chapter 11, as are several promising
future studies of Cir X-1.
Chapter 2
The Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer
2.1 Overview
The Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE , see Figure 2-1) is a NASA orbiting astrophysical observa-
tory designed to provide temporal and spectral information about celestial X-ray sources [10]. The
satellite was launched on a Delta II rocket on 1995 December 30. Its primary targets are compact
objects in our galaxy, such as white dwarfs, neutron stars, and stellar-mass black holes, as well as
active galactic nuclei, which may contain super-massive black holes. The strengths of RXTE are
its high time resolution, large collecting area, broad spectral coverage, and ability to detect and
respond quickly to transient phenomena. These capabilities are achieved through three instruments:
the Proportional Counter Array (PCA), the High-Energy X-ray Timing Experiment (HEXTE), and
the All-Sky Monitor (ASM). In addition, a specialized on-board computer, the Experiment Data
System (EDS), serves to pre-analyze and compress data from the ASM and PCA to maximize use
of telemetry. Each instrument is briefly described below. For more details see The RXTE Technical
Appendix [61].
2.2 Proportional Counter Array
The PCA (built by the Goddard Space Flight Center of NASA) consists of five Proportional Counter
Units (PCUs) with a total open area of ∼6250 cm2. This large collecting area allows photons to be
detected at a rate high enough to study variability as short as milliseconds. The detector electronics
record the arrival time of each photon to an accuracy of 1 µs, and the EDS is also capable of
processing data with 1 µs resolution (see section 2.5). The PCUs are sensitive to X-ray photons
33
34
CHAPTER 2. THE ROSSI X-RAY TIMING EXPLORER
Figure 2-1: Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer spacecraft.
2.3. HIGH-ENERGY X-RAY TIMING EXPERIMENT
35
with energies between 2 keV and 90 keV, and can detect sources down to a flux level of a few mCrab,
where 1.0 Crab ≈ 1060 µJy at 5.2 keV. The intrinsic energy resolution (∆E/E, FWHM) of the PCA
is about 18% at 6 keV and 10% at 20 keV. The PCUs have no imaging capability, but collimators
restrict the field of view to ∼ 1◦. Since the number of bright X-ray sources in the sky numbers less
than 100, the 1◦ field of view is small enough to exclude other bright sources in all but the most
crowded fields (i.e., towards the Galactic center).
Each PCU detector consists of a chamber of xenon gas (and a small quantity of methane) with
three layers of high-voltage anode wires. The anodes closest to the detector walls, and a fourth layer
on the bottom form an anti-coincidence detector used to reject events due to particles which enter
through the walls of the detector. X-ray photons enter through the front window of the chamber and
eject a photo-electron from an atom in the gas. The electron is accelerated toward an anode wire,
creating ion pairs along its path. The multiplied electron signal is read out by the anode electronics.
A propane chamber between the main chamber and the detector window is only sensitive to low-
energy photons (<
∼3 keV). Anode wires in the propane layer are also used in the anti-coincidence
logic to screen out electron-induced events. All data from the PCA is sent to the EDS for processing
before being telemetered to the ground (see section 2.5).
The capabilities of the PCA are particularly well-suited for studies of the rapid variability in X-
ray binaries, and we have made use of these capabilities in our study of Cir X-1. Data can be obtained
at high time resolution (fractions of a millisecond) simultaneously in multiple energy bands to study
the variability components (such as the quasi-periodic oscillations) and their energy-dependence
(Chapters 4, 5, and 6). All PCA data are also telemetered as 16-s spectra with 129 channels,
allowing more detailed spectral studies to be made on time scales shorter than or comparable to
most changes in the state of the source (Chapters 6 and 7).
2.3 High-Energy X-ray Timing Experiment
The HEXTE detectors (built by the University of California, San Diego) are sensitive to X-ray
photons in the 20–200 keV band, extending the full capability of RXTE to cover two orders of
magnitude in photon energy (2–200 keV). They are co-aligned with the PCA detectors and are also
collimated to produce a ∼ 1◦ field-of-view. The HEXTE consists of two independent clusters of
four NaI(Tl)/CsI(Na) phoswich scintillation detectors. Photons entering such a detector undergo
multiple interactions in the NaI scintillation crystal, and the resulting signal is transferred through
the CsI crystal to a photo-multiplier tube. The CsI crystal also serves to reject photons that only
partially deposit their energy and events that are induced by particles. The two detector clusters are
36
CHAPTER 2. THE ROSSI X-RAY TIMING EXPLORER
alternately rocked on and off-source to provide continued background monitoring. Each phoswich
detector has a net collecting area of 200 cm2 and an energy resolution of about 13% at 60 keV.
HEXTE data is obtained in parallel with all PCA observations. For Cir X-1, the HEXTE count
rates are relatively low since the X-ray spectrum of Cir X-1 is soft, resulting far more counts in
the PCA than HEXTE. Furthermore, the analysis of HEXTE data is complicated by the rocking
detectors and complex calibration issues. Thus, the data we obtained for Cir X-1 from HEXTE is
not incorporated into this thesis.
2.4 All-Sky Monitor
The ASM (built by the Center for Space Research at M.I.T.) consists of three scanning shadow
cameras (SSCs) which regularly monitor all bright (>
∼10 mCrab) celestial X-ray sources (about 10
times per day), providing long-term light curves of their intensity in three energy bands between
2 keV and 12 keV [42]. Each SSC contains a position-sensitive proportional counter mounted below
a wide-field collimator (∼ 6◦× ∼ 90◦ FWHM). The PSPCs each contain eight carbon-coated quartz
fibers which are used as anode wires in a chamber filled with Xe and CO2. The anode electronics
read out signals from both ends of each anode and can determine the position along the wire by
comparing the relative strength of the signals due to the resistance of the anodes. A mask covering
the outer window of the collimator is coded with rectangular slit openings which cast X-ray shadows
on the detector and allow positions to be determined (typical error boxes of 3′ × 12′). The three
cameras are mounted on a tripod at one end of the satellite (see Figure 2-1) and are rotated together,
stopping for 90-s dwells every 6◦. A sensitivity of about 30 mCrab (3σ) is achieved for each such
90-s exposure. The fields-of-view of two of the cameras point in the same direction perpendicular
to the rotation axis and cross at a ∼ 24◦ angle (resulting in positional error boxes that cross and
can be used for further refinement of positions). The third camera points along the rotation axis.
Several of the anodes lost functionality shortly after launch, but this has not significantly affected
the overall performance.
For Cir X-1 the ASM has proved invaluable in understanding the general spectral and intensity
profile of the 16.55-d cycle. The ASM also plays an important role by placing other observations
(e.g., our PCA observations) in context with the rest of the cycle and by aiding plans for future
observations. With continued successful performance, the detailed long-term light curve will allow
us to track how the source behavior evolves between its various states (see section 1.3). So far, the
ASM light curve of Cir X-1 has shown the source to maintain the same high baseline intensity level
for the entire duration of the RXTE mission (see Chapter 3), with no evidence for evolution on a
2.5. EXPERIMENT DATA SYSTEM
37
Channel
Energy (keV)
Abs
0–9
10–13
14–17
18–23
24–35
36–49
50–87
88–249
Std2
0–5
6–9
10–13
14–19
20–31
32–45
46–66
67–127
Epoch 1
0–2.6
2.6–3.6
3.6–4.7
4.7–6.3
6.3–9.5
9.5–13.2
13.2–24
24–71
Epoch 2
0–3.0
3.0–4.2
4.2–5.5
5.5–7.4
7.4–11.1
11.1–15.6
15.6–28
28–84
Epoch 3
0–3.5
3.5–5.0
5.0–6.5
6.5–8.7
8.7–13.1
13.1–18.3
18.3–33
33–99
Band
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
Table 2.1: Approximate energy ranges for eight PCA bands (A–H) defined in terms of absolute
(0–255) and Standard2 (0–128) channels. Gain epoch 1 includes all observations before before 1996
March 21, epoch 2 1996 March 21 – April 15, and epoch 3 after 1996 April 15. Energy values shown
are derived from the full PCA with all detectors and layers added.
few-year time scale as has been suggested based on previous observations (see section 1.3).
2.5 Experiment Data System
The EDS (also built by the CSR at M.I.T.) is a computer containing eight microprocessor Event
Analyzers (EAs), of which six are dedicated to handling PCA data while the other two are dedicated
to the ASM. For each 90-s dwell, one of the ASM EAs produces position histograms of the X-ray
shadow patterns on each wire of each detector in the three energy channels mentioned above. The
second ASM EA produces time-series histograms of "good" and background count rates, as well
as pulse height histograms useful in monitoring the gain of the detectors based on an on-board
calibration source.
Two of the PCA EAs process data using standard modes: one that provides count rates for
each layer of the five PCU detectors and other rates every 1/8 s (Standard1) and another which
provides 129-channel spectra every 16 s (Standard2). The other four PCA EAs can be set to process
data in parallel using a wide variety of modes in order to fit desired information into the telemetry
constraints. Most data modes fall into two categories: event modes which send down the time
and energy of every event and binned modes which send down the number of photons detected in
selectable energy and time bins. Many data modes process data from within standard sub-bands of
the entire PCA energy range. These sub-bands are defined in terms of the 256 "absolute" channels
of the PCA. Table 2.1 shows the channel and energy ranges for eight standard bands. The gain
of the PCA detectors was changed twice early in the mission, resulting in a different channel-to-
energy relationship for each of three epochs. Although the relationship is not strictly linear, a single
38
CHAPTER 2. THE ROSSI X-RAY TIMING EXPLORER
channel-to-energy conversion factor is a good approximation for each epoch: through 1996 March 21,
0.27 keV/chan; 1996 March 21 – 1996 April 15, 0.32 keV/chan; after 1996 April 15, 0.38 keV/chan.
All light curves, hardness ratios, and Fourier power spectra in this thesis have been binned into one
or several of these standard bands.
The four PCA Event Analyzers not devoted to standard modes are typically configured, through
modes selected by the observer based on science goals, to provide optimal time resolution and energy
resolution within the available telemetry. For Cir X-1, we generally chose two or three "single-bit"
modes (single-channel binned modes) which covered absolute channels 0–35 of Table 2.1 (up to
13 keV in epoch 3) using various combinations of energy bands A–E. These configurations provided
a time resolution of 61 µs or 122 µs. Due to lower count rates in the higher channels, the energy
and time of every photon with energy above channel 35 (bands F–H in Table 2.1) could be recorded
with an event mode having 32 or 64 channels covering absolute energy channels 36–249 and time
resolution of 16 µs or 64 µs. Sometimes a binned mode was used to provide 32 low-energy channels
at 0.5 s resolution to allow the possibility of creating spectra on time scales shorter than the 16 s
provided by the Standard2 mode. Thus, all Cir X-1 data were obtained with high time resolution in
multiple energy bands for rapid variability studies (Chapters 4, 5, and 6) and good energy resolution
every 16-s or less for spectral studies (Chapters 6 and 7).
Chapter 3
Overview of RXTE Observations
3.1 ASM Observations of Circinus X-1
3.1.1 General Features of the ASM Light Curves
The RXTE All-Sky Monitor (see section 2.4) has provided 90-s intensity measurements of most
bright X-ray sources in three energy channels (1.5–3 keV, 3–5 keV, and 5-12 keV) about 12 times
daily since early 1996 [42]. The intensity for each source in the ASM field of view, and the diffuse
X-ray background, is obtained from fits to the ASM mask patterns of each 90-s exposure. Thus
background has, in effect, been subtracted from the source light curves.
The ASM light curve of Cir X-1 for the entire RXTE mission to date (through 1998 May) is
shown in Figure 3-1. (A gap of ∼40 days occurred early in the mission due to instrumental problems,
and a gap of 2–3 weeks has occurred annually, near days 420 and 780, due to sun-angle constraints.)
These observations show Cir X-1 in a sustained bright state with a baseline intensity level very
similar to that of the Crab nebula (1.0 Crab ≈ 75 ASM counts/s; 1060 µJy at 5.2 keV). Each cycle
shows strong flaring wherein the intensity increases by a factor of three or more. Phase zero of each
cycle (based on equation 1.1) is indicated in Figure 3-1. The consistent alignment of brief dips with
phase zero and subsequent flaring shortly after phase zero demonstrate that the decade-old radio
ephemeris is very successful in predicting the current X-ray behavior.
The flaring state typically begins during the day following phase zero, reaching as high as 3.7 Crab
(corresponding to a luminosity at 8 kpc that is several times the Eddington limit) and typically
lasting 2–5 days. The profile of the flaring state is actually quite variable, sometimes showing a
secondary flare or an extended main flare lasting most of the cycle (see Chapter 5).
Many cycles observed with the ASM show brief dips below the 1 Crab level, usually immediately
39
40
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
Figure 3-1: ASM light curve (1.5–12 keV; 90-s exposures) covering 1996 January – 1998 May. Phase
zero is indicated by vertical dotted lines. Bars along the top axis mark the times of PCA observations
(labeled A–H; see section 3.2).
3.1. ASM OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
41
before or shortly after phase zero, but occasionally occurring later in the cycle as well. Previous
satellites have also observed intensity dips from Cir X-1 near phase zero. For example, Brandt
et al. [12] recently presented evidence for strong absorption during a phase-zero intensity transition
in ASCA observations of Cir X-1. More extensive RXTE PCA observations of dips will be discussed
in Chapter 7.
3.1.2 Cycling Hardness Ratios
The light curve and hardness ratios of counts in adjacent energy channels for the first ten 16.55-d cy-
cles of Cir X-1 observed with the ASM are shown in Figure 3-2. These data show significant spectral
evolution during the non-flare phases. The hardness ratios were found to generally increase (harden)
from about phase 0.2 until phase 0.6-0.85. Beyond this point the hardness ratios usually flatten,
decrease, or dip and rise again before phase zero. Near phase zero, the ratios vary dramatically (not
apparent in the one-day averages shown) but generally become quite low during the flaring phases
(0 <
∼φ<
∼ 0.2). The hardening in the two colors (0.2 <
∼φ<
∼ 0.7) is usually due to both an increase in
the 5–12 keV count rate and a decrease in the 1.5-3 keV count rate.
3.1.3
16.55-day Period
The onset of flaring relative to phase zero can vary by of order one day. Over the ∼50 cycles observed
by the ASM, this allows the period to be determined to within about 1/50 d = 0.02 d. Since this
uncertainty is similar to the change in period of 0.03 d over 20 yr implied by equation 1.1, it is not yet
possible with the ASM to confirm or reject a period change of that magnitude. However, to obtain
the best-fitting period I used a 64-times oversampled Fourier power density spectrum from the ASM
data in Figure 3-1 (and fitting the peak corresponding to the ∼16.55-d period with a Gaussian).
This method gave a best-fitting constant period of 16.555 d. Within the 0.02 d uncertainty, this
is consistent with equation 1.1, with or without the quadratic term. The possibility of using the
phase-zero dips as "markers" for the period is explored in the next section (using the average folded
light curve). Hopefully the ASM will continue to operate for several more years, potentially allowing
the period to be determined with the accuracy necessary to test the constancy of the period.
3.1.4 Folded Cycle Profile
ASM light curves of Cir X-1 folded at the 16.55-d period (using equation 1.1; Figure 3-3) show the
rapid rise and more gradual decline of the profile. The scatter of points during the "flaring" state
demonstrates the high degree of variability at those phases. The 5–12 keV band exhibits flaring
42
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
Figure 3-2: Light curve and two hardness ratios for the first ten full 16.55-day cycles of Cir X-
1 observed with the ASM. Each light-curve point is the average count rate (I [1.5–12 keV]) from
a single 90-s ASM exposure. The hardness ratios were obtained from 1-day averages of the 90-s
intensities and are defined as HR1=I [3–5 keV] / I [1.5–3 keV] and HR2=I [5–12 keV] / I [3–5 keV].
The vertical dotted lines indicate phase zero.
3.1. ASM OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
43
Figure 3-3: Folded light curve of Cir X-1 from the three ASM energy bands. The data are repeated
in order to show two complete cycles. Each point is from a 90-s exposure, with a typical error bar
of 1–2 c/s. The folded data spans the entire time period covered by Figure 3-1.
44
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
above a baseline that dips below the quiescent level. This is related to the spectral softening seen
during flaring in Figure 3-2. Although dips typically occur anywhere between phases −0.03 and
+0.10, they occur most consistently in a narrow range immediately before phase zero. There is a
clear absence of points at the baseline level in the narrow phase range 0.985–0.989; however, the
total number of points in a phase range of that width is typically only about 30, so sparse coverage
may play a role in the width of this gap.
The data shown in Figure 3-3 for the three ASM bands were also binned into 100 phase bins
and averaged within each bin. These average folded profiles, as well as those for the the total ASM
energy band and the two hardness ratios, are shown in Figure 3-4. The average profile has a very
narrow dip at phase −0.012 (±0.004), followed by a sharp rise over the first 1.5 d of the cycle and a
much more gradual decline. The hardness ratios are anti-correlated with the total intensity. Similar
intensity and hardness profiles were seen in folded Ginga ASM data from 1987 [75]. The folded
profile from the highest energy ASM band (5–12 keV) does not exhibit the large increase in flux
characteristic of the other two bands and shows only increased variability during the flaring state,
due to the scatter of points above and below the baseline (see Figure 3-3).
We attempted to use the narrow dip at phase −0.012 in the average folded curves to constrain
the best period. Constant periods of 16.535–16.555 d all showed similar dips, and the dips were
deepest (and most similar to Figure 3-4) using a period of 16.540–16.545. Although the range of
periods showing the narrow dip is lower than the earlier radio periods by about 0.02–0.04 d, we have
no a priori knowledge of what shape (if any) this feature should have, and thus must use caution
when interpreting periods determined by maximizing its depth (or other property).
3.2 PCA Observations of Circinus X-1
3.2.1 Overview
We have proposed and carried out an extensive observation campaign for Cir X-1 with the RXTE
PCA, collecting over 800 kiloseconds of data, as shown in Table 3.1. The project consisted of eight
separate "studies" which used a variety of strategies for different 16.55-d cycles: We sampled several
cycles with brief observations (typically about 6000 s), distributed at different phases, to study
how the detailed timing and spectral characteristics evolve with orbital phase and relate to the
spectral evolution indicated by the cycling hardness ratios of the ASM (see above). High-efficiency
observations (i.e., ∼60% coverage) during two long time segments (2 and 7 days) including phase-zero
were used to study the highly complex dipping and flaring behavior associated with that portion
of the cycle.
In order to study correlated behavior at different wavelengths, we coordinated two
3.2. PCA OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
45
Figure 3-4: Left: Folded Cir X-1 light curve from the full ASM energy band (1.5–12 keV) and two
hardness ratios. Right: Folded light curves from the three ASM energy bands. The data are binned
into 100 phase bins per cycle, averaged in each phase bin, and duplicated to show two complete
cycles. Error bars on the light curves indicate the standard deviation of the mean value derived
for each phase bin, and these error estimates were propagated when computing the hardness ratios.
The folded data spans the entire time period covered by Figure 3-1.
46
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
Study Dates
A
B
C
1996 Mar. 5 - 21
1996 Apr. 7
1996 May 7 - 14
Observing
Time
76 ksec
10 ksec
54 ksec
D
E
F
G
1996 Sept. 20 - Oct. 8
190 ksec
1997 Feb. 18 - Mar 4
1997 May 16 - 21
1997 June 4 - 22
48 ksec
13 ksec
396 ksec
H
1997 Sept. 18 - Oct. 4
50 ksec
837 ksec
Description
12 observations over one 16.6-d cycle
1 observation during phase-zero dips
7 observations between phase 0.78-0.16,
coord. with HartRAO (radio) & SAAO (IR)
60% coverage for 2 days (phase 0.97-0.09),
13 observations over remainder of 16.6-d cycle
8 samples over one 16.6-d cycle
13 1-ksec observations, twice daily
56% coverage for 7 days (phase 0.93-0.33),
sampling observations before and after;
portions coordinated with AAT (optical),
ANU (IR), HartRAO (radio), & SAAO (IR)
8 samples over one 16.6-d cycle
Table 3.1: PCA observations of Cir X-1 (1996–1997).
multi-frequency campaigns to provide optical, infrared, and radio observations simultaneous with
our X-ray coverage. The light curves, from the full PCA energy range, for each of the studies are
shown in Figure 3-5 as a function of phase for comparison between cycles. Standard 20-kilosecond
light curves of all these observations are collected in Appendix B. The time of each PCA observation
is also indicated on the 2.3-year ASM light curve in Figure 3-1.
3.2.2 Observation Summaries
The intensity and activity level of Cir X-1 had been observed to change over a period of years (see
section 1.3). We thus did not know what to expect from Cir X-1 once RXTE launched. By the end
of 1996 February, it was already clear from the very early ASM data that Cir X-1 was currently
bright and active. Thus, we requested that our proposed PCA/HEXTE observations of Cir X-1 be
activated, and began observations in early 1996 March. The eight studies (A–H) of our project are
described briefly here.
3.2.2.1 Study A: 1996 March 5–21
The first study consisted of twelve observations, each ∼6000 s in duration. They were separated
by ∼2-day intervals to sample one complete 16-d cycle (see Figure 3-5A). The first observation of
study A occurred during the half day before phase zero and showed significant dipping behavior.
The second observation occurred shortly after phase zero, and the source was very bright (up to
3.2. PCA OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
47
Figure 3-5: Light curves for each 16.55-d cycle of Cir X-1 observed with the PCA. For each cycle,
the phase-zero date and letter of the study (see Table 3.1) are listed. The intensity is for the full
PCA energy range, and a conversion factor of 1 Crab ≈ 2600 counts s−1 PCU−1 has been used.
48
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
Figure 3-6: PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the hard
band to that in the soft band, for the observation on 1996 April 7 (study B), spanning 15 ks. The
lowest intensity in both bands during dips is well above the background level (∼30 c/s and ∼45 c/s
for 2–7.4 keV and 7.4–28 keV respectively, not subtracted).
∼2.6 Crab) and highly variable. Nine observations carried out between phases 0.2 and 0.8 showed
a quite steady flux, and a final observation shortly before the next phase zero showed increased
activity again. These data are presented in Chapter 4, with a focus on the evolution of the timing
and spectral properties during the non-flaring phases.
3.2.2.2 Study B: 1996 April 7
This study consisted of a single 10-ks observation carried out on 1996 April 7, approximately one full
cycle after the end of the initial monitoring campaign (see Figure 3-6). This observation also showed
significant dipping below the ∼1.0 Crab baseline (∼13 kilocounts/s) during the half day before phase
zero. The dips are chaotic and accompanied by dramatic spectral evolution (as indicated by the
hardness ratio). Similar dipping behavior from study D (see below) was studied in detail and is
presented in Chapter 7. This observation occurred during PCA gain epoch 2 (which defines the
channel-to-energy conversion factor, see Table 2.1). All following observations of Cir X-1 occurred
during gain epoch 3.
3.2. PCA OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
49
Figure 3-7: PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the hard
band to that in the soft band, for the observations on 1996 September 24 – October 8 (study D).
Due to some observations with a PCU not operating, all points in this plot were derived from PCUs
0, 1, & 2 and adjusted by 5/3 for comparison with other figures in this section. Phase zeros occurred
at days 346.782 and 363.328.
3.2.2.3 Study C: 1996 May 7–14
In 1996 May, the first of two multi-frequency campaigns was carried out, with coordinated infrared,
radio, and RXTE observations. These observations spanned several days on either side of phase
zero, and showed an increase in intensity in all three frequency regimes during the day following
phase zero. These multi-frequency observations are discussed in more detail in Chapter 8.
3.2.2.4 Study D: 1996 Sept. 20 – Oct. 8
In 1996 September, a high efficiency observation was carried out, providing 60% coverage of the
48-hour period beginning 0.5 days before phase zero. These data showed extensive dipping both
before and after phase zero and are the focus of Chapter 7, in which the spectral evolution of dips
is studied in detail. Following this extensive phase zero observation, 13 sampling observations were
made over the remainder of the 16.55-d cycle. These are shown in Figure 3-7 and demonstrate a
gradual hardening of the spectrum with orbital phase, as well as more dramatic spectral evolution
during dips in the last observation.
50
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
3.2.2.5 Study E: 1997 Feb. 18 – Mar. 4
Eight 6-kilosecond observations were carried out during 1997 February 18 – March 4, sampling a
complete cycle at approximately 2-day intervals (see Figure 3-5E). The intensity of this cycle declined
from its peak value gradually over ∼10 days. These observations are used in Chapter 5 to study the
evolution of timing properties as a function of intensity and spectral state.
3.2.2.6 Study F: 1997 May 16 – May 21
In 1997 May, a series of short (1 ks) public observations of Cir X-1 were carried out between
phases 0.35 and 0.7 (the data were originally part of another observer's program, but were made
publicly available due to a scheduling conflict). Although these data were not part of our proposed
observations, they fit well with our other sampling studies and were thus incorporated into the
project. The intensity level during each observation was relatively steady, but the average level
varied between 1.0 and 1.6 Crab.
3.2.2.7 Study G: 1997 June 4–22
Our most extensive set of observations were carried out during 1997 June. These included a 7-
day period of 56% coverage that included dips before phase zero and most of a very active flaring
state. This excellent coverage allowed us to observe continuous transitions between the various
spectral/intensity states we found in the earlier 1997 February–March data. These results are
presented in Chapter 6.
Some of our June PCA observations were coordinated with with radio, optical, and infrared
observations made by collaborators in South Africa and Australia. The results from this second
multi-frequency campaign are presented in Chapter 8 along with the previous campaign (study C).
3.2.2.8 Study H: 1997 Sept. 18 – Oct. 4
A final set of eight 6-kilosecond observations were carried out during 1997 September–October to
again sample a complete 16-d cycle. These observations all showed the intensity to be near the
1.0 Crab baseline, except for the sample at phase 0.06, where the intensity reached 2.5 Crab. The
soft and hard light curves and hardness ratio for the flaring observation are shown in Figure 3-8.
There is strong variability on time scales of hundreds of seconds during the climb to 2.5 Crab. The
hardness ratio is generally anti-correlated with intensity during the first segment and then correlated
with intensity during the remainder of the observation. This bi-modal behavior can be understood as
relating to different branches in a hardness-intensity diagram. Both types of behavior are associated
3.2. PCA OBSERVATIONS OF CIRCINUS X-1
51
Figure 3-8: PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins; 13 kilocounts/s=1.0 Crab for the
combined 2-33 keV band), and the ratio of intensity in the hard band to that in the soft band, for
the observation on 1997 September 20 (part of study H), spanning 7000 s.
with the spectral/intensity states that are discussed in Chapters 5 and 6 in the context of studies E
and G.
52
CHAPTER 3. OVERVIEW OF RXTE OBSERVATIONS
Chapter 4
X-ray Timing and Spectral
Evolution vs. Orbital Phase
This chapter has been published (in a slightly modified form) in the September 20, 1996 issue of
The Astrophysical Journal (Vol. 469) [62].
4.1 Overview
We have carried out a study of Cir X-1 (study A, see Figure 3-5) through detailed sampling over a
single 16.55-d intensity cycle with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE ) Proportional Counter
Array (PCA). We report here the current state of the source and focus primarily upon the evolution
of the emission characteristics away from the flaring activity, i.e., at phases 0.2 <
∼φ<
∼ 0.9 (based on the
1991 radio ephemeris of Stewart et al. [68]). Heretofore, these phases have not been systematically
sampled with an instrument of large aperture. In the eccentric binary scenario, the source would be
relatively remote from the secondary during these phases.
During the non-flaring phases, Cir X-1 remained unusually bright (∼1.0 Crab) and relatively
steady. The Fourier power density spectrum of the source was observed to vary with strong correla-
tions among low-frequency flat-topped power (<
∼ 1–10 Hz), a QPO peak centered at 1.3–12 Hz, and a
broad QPO peak centered at ∼20 Hz up to ∼100 Hz. As orbital phase increased within the cycle, the
rms amplitude of the flat-topped power generally (but not monotonically) decreased, while the QPO
features generally evolved toward higher frequency. The PCA spectrum was observed to generally
harden during the non-flaring phases, consistent with results from the RXTE All-Sky Monitor (see
section 3.1).
53
54
CHAPTER 4. X-RAY TIMING AND SPECTRAL EVOLUTION VS. ORBITAL PHASE
Julian Date Orbital
Obs.1 −2450000.52 Phase3
0.98
0.15
0.28
0.39
0.46
0.50
147.9
150.7
152.8
154.6
155.8
156.6
1
2
3
4
5
6
Julian Date Orbital
Phase
0.61
0.63
0.69
0.75
0.78
0.94
Obs. −2450000.5
7
8
9
10
11
12
158.3
158.7
159.7
160.7
161.1
163.8
Table 4.1: March 1996 PCA observations of Cir X-1
4.2 Observations and Results
In 1996 March, Cir X-1 was sampled with the PCA (effective area ∼7000 cm2, see section 2.2) twelve
times during one 16.55-day orbital period. The observation times and orbital phases are summarized
in Table 4.1. The low and high-energy light curves for observations 1–11 are shown in Figure 4-1,
along with the hardness ratio derived from those intensities. Observation 12 used a different PCA
gain setting (gain epoch 2, see Table 2.1 on page 37) and only 3 PCUs, so it is not included in
Figure 4-1. The hardness ratio generally increases during the non-flaring phases as phase increases
up to ∼0.7, beyond which the ratios are more steady. This confirms the evolution observed in the
ASM data (see section 3.1).
Three detailed sample light-curve segments are shown in Figure 4-2. In the full PCA energy band
(2–60 keV), Cir X-1 was found to be extremely active, remaining bright (>
∼ 1.0 Crab) throughout the
16.55-d cycle (1 Crab ≈ 13,000 c/s). In the vicinity of phase zero (Obs. 1, 2, & 12), dramatic flares
and dips occurred (Figure 4-2a,b). In Obs. 2 (phase 0.15), the count rate climbed to more than
2.5 Crab (Figure 4-2b). Away from phase zero (0.2 <
∼φ<
∼ 0.8; Obs. 3–11), the count rate remained
fairly steady (within 15%) at about 1.0 Crab. Figure 2c shows a sample light curve for phase 0.5,
which is typical of these observations. The source is relatively steady but exhibits flickering greatly
in excess of Poisson statistics.
Power density spectra (PDS) were produced from PCA data covering 2–8.6 keV in 61-µs time
bins. For each 96-min RXTE orbit, a continuous observation of 1 to 4 ks was divided into 64-s
segments, and the PDS was calculated for each segment. All PDS from the segments of a single
continuous observation were averaged together, weighted by the total counts. The resulting average
1Each observation lasted 1–5 hr and produced 1.4–10 ks of data. Dates and phases listed are the centroids of the
observations.
2JD-2450000.5=147 corresponds to 1996 March 5.
3Orbital phase based on the radio ephemeris of Stewart et al. 1991 [68]. Due to faint radio flares in recent years,
this ephemeris is still currently in use as the best available (G. Nicolson 1996, private communication).
4.2. OBSERVATIONS AND RESULTS
55
Figure 4-1: PCA light curves in two energy bands (16-s bins), and the ratio of intensity in the
hard band to that in the soft band, for observations 1–11 of 1996 March. Phase zero corresponds to
day 148.227. The intensity is well above the background level in both bands (∼25 c/s and ∼40 c/s
for 2–6.3 keV and 6.3–24 keV respectively, not subtracted) even during the dips. Observation 12 is
omitted since it was carried out with only three PCUs and a different gain setting.
56
CHAPTER 4. X-RAY TIMING AND SPECTRAL EVOLUTION VS. ORBITAL PHASE
Figure 4-2: Sample PCA light curves (2–60 keV) comparing 2000-s segments showing (a) strong
variability and dips near phase zero (phase 0.98; Obs. 1), (b) a brighter portion of the bright flaring
state three days later (phase 0.15; Obs. 2), and (c) a typical observation away from phase zero
(phase 0.50; Obs. 6). Background (∼100 c/s) is not subtracted and no deadtime corrections have
been made.
4.2. OBSERVATIONS AND RESULTS
57
power spectrum from each RXTE orbit was then logarithmically rebinned, with dead-time-corrected
Poisson noise subtracted [88] and normalized to give the fractional rms amplitude squared per Hz
(after Belloni & Hasinger [5]).
The PDS from seven orbits are shown in Figure 4-3, offset downward by one-decade intervals.
These samples show significant low-frequency flat-topped power which cuts off above 1-10 Hz and also
a QPO peak which sits on the high-frequency edge of the flat-topped power at 1.3–12 Hz (compared
to 1.4 Hz and 5-17 Hz QPO reported near phase zero by [69, 70]. The PDS in Figure 4-3 are
ordered by the frequency of the QPO peak. All the PDS during the non-flaring phases exhibit these
features. The flat-topped power level systematically decreases as the cutoff and QPO frequencies
increase (note that each flat-top level is more than one decade below the previous level in Figure 4-3).
Above the cut-off frequencies, the curves all track together with roughly the same power. A few
PDS not illustrated here have a steep low-frequency component below 0.1-0.4 Hz.
A broad high-frequency QPO is also apparent in Figure 4-3 centered at ∼20 Hz to ∼100 Hz or
more. For observations in which the 1.3–12 Hz QPO frequency is below ∼8 Hz, the high-frequency
broad peak is always clearly present; otherwise, it is sometimes marginally detectable above 100 Hz.
Note that this high-frequency QPO peak moves to higher frequencies with the low-frequency QPO
peak.
All the PDS in the non-flaring phases were analyzed to further study these trends. The flat-
topped component was fit with a zero-centered Lorentzian profile, the two peaked features were also
each fit with a Lorentzian, and the high-frequency tail was fit with a power law. Although the results
of the fits indicate that this model is crude (via large values of the associated chi-squared statistic),
the fits were adequate to determine approximate centroid frequencies and power levels. Errors (rms)
for QPO centroid frequencies were estimated from 90% confidence intervals of the fits or 20% of the
FWHM of the peak, whichever was greater. Errors for the flat-top power level were estimated to be
∼5%. As the orbital phase increased, the power level of the flat-topped noise generally decreased
(Figure 4-4a) while the narrow QPO frequency increased (Figure 4-4b), in accord with the trends
noted above. The trends are not monotonic though; a large excursion occurs at φ = 0.4 in both
curves. Remarkably, the correlation between these two quantities (flat-topped level and narrow QPO
frequency) in Figure 4-4c is very strong (and negative). Moreover, the frequency of the 20–100 Hz
peak scales as ∼13 times the frequency of the 1.3–12 Hz peak (Figure 4-4c) with a weak tendency
for the frequency ratio to decrease (from ∼16 to ∼11) with increasing frequency. The frequency
difference between the two peaks changes by more than a factor of four over this range, from less
than 20 Hz to more than 80 Hz. The cutoff frequency of the flat-topped component (as measured
by the width of the best fitting zero-centered Lorentzian) also moved to higher frequency with the
58
CHAPTER 4. X-RAY TIMING AND SPECTRAL EVOLUTION VS. ORBITAL PHASE
Figure 4-3: Power density spectra from seven RXTE orbits away from phase zero, offset downward
at decade intervals. (The ordinate scale applies to the top curve.) The curves are ordered by the
frequency of the 1.3–12 Hz QPO peak and are labeled with orbital phase.
4.3. DISCUSSION
59
Figure 4-4: Flat-top power level (a) and QPO frequency (b) as a function of orbital phase over a
single orbital cycle. (c) Frequency of the narrow low-frequency QPO and the broad high-frequency
QPO vs. the flat-top power level. (d) Cut-off frequency of the flat-topped power vs. flat-top power
level.
narrow QPO peak (Figure 4-4d). These two frequencies agree within 20% for all observations.
4.3 Discussion
The 1.4 and 5-17 Hz QPO reported by Tennant et al. [69, 70] were found during observations near
phase zero. It was suggested that the QPO were bimodal, with the 1.4 Hz QPO independent of
luminosity and the 5–17 Hz component correlated with the estimated 2–10 keV unabsorbed energy
flux [69, 70]. Our observations show a gradual evolution of the QPO from 1.3 to 12 Hz over the
non-flaring phases. Some of the phase zero EXOSAT observations which exhibited 5–17 Hz QPO
60
CHAPTER 4. X-RAY TIMING AND SPECTRAL EVOLUTION VS. ORBITAL PHASE
also had a QPO peak at 100–200 Hz [69]. This low/high frequency QPO pair is likely to be the
evolving QPO pair we have observed, but extended to higher frequencies.
The correlation between the flat-topped power level and the cut-off frequency (Figure 4-4d) is
similar to the effect observed by Belloni and Hasinger [6] in the the black hole candidate Cyg X-1
and also observed in the neutron star 4U 1608-522 [87] by Yoshida et al. In fact, several properties
of 4U 1608-522 show correlations similar to those we have observed in Cir X-1. In two of the three
observations of 4U 1608-522 by Yoshida et al. [87], QPO were seen (at 0.4 and 2.0 Hz respectively)
just above the knee in the power spectrum, and a broader peaked noise feature was observed at
higher frequencies of 1.0 and 5.1 Hz respectively [87]. We note that the ratio of the two peaks is
the same in both observations, just as the two peaks in our Cir X-1 observations move to higher
frequency with a nearly constant frequency ratio (although the ratio is different for the two sources).
In both sources, the spectrum generally (but not always) hardens as these these features move out
to higher frequencies and the flat-topped power level decreases.
The RXTE observations of Cir X-1 have (1) confirmed a general hardening of the spectrum
during the non-flaring phases 0.2–0.7, (2) demonstrated a trend (with moderate scatter) for the
power density features to shift to higher frequency and the amplitude of the low-frequency power to
decrease with increasing orbital phase during the non-flaring phases, and (3) demonstrated extremely
tight correlations among the QPO features and the flat-topped power. In the eccentric-orbit model,
these characteristics may reflect the evolving state of the accretion disk while it is being depleted
with little or no replenishment. For example, the leveling of the hardness ratios after phase 0.6-0.8
may reflect a time constant (of order 10 days) of the disk structure.
Chapter 5
QPOs Associated with Spectral
Branches
This chapter is scheduled to be published (in a slightly modified form) in the October 10, 1998 issue
of The Astrophysical Journal (Vol. 506) [63].
5.1 Overview
We present Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE ) All-Sky Monitor observations of the X-ray binary
Circinus X-1 which illustrate the variety of intensity profiles associated with the 16.55 d flaring cycle
of the source. We also present eight observations of Cir X-1 made with the RXTE Proportional
Counter Array over the course of a cycle wherein the average intensity of the flaring state decreased
gradually over ∼12 days (study E, see Figure 3-5). This unusually slow transition allows us to
demonstrate how the time-variability properties of the source are related to its intensity and its
spectral properties (In Chapter 4, we characterized only the quiescent phases of a typical cycle).
Fourier power density spectra for these observations show a narrow quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO)
peak which shifts in frequency between 6.8 Hz and 32 Hz, as well as a broad QPO peak that
remains roughly stationary at ∼4 Hz. We identify these as Z-source horizontal and normal branch
oscillations (HBOs/NBOs) respectively. Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams (CDs/HIDs)
show curvilinear tracks for each of the observations. The properties of the QPOs and very low
frequency noise allow us to identify segments of these tracks with Z-source horizontal, normal, and
flaring branches which shift location in the CDs and HIDs over the course of the 16.55 d cycle.
These results contradict a previous prediction, based on the hypothesis that Cir X-1 is a high- M
61
62
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
Obs.
Julian Date1 Phase Mean Intensity
I
II
III
IV
V
VI
VII
VIII
2450497.90
2450499.98
2450501.69
2450503.66
2450505.80
2450507.31
2450509.35
2450511.62
0.10
0.23
0.33
0.45
0.58
0.67
0.79
0.93
(Crab)2
2.3
1.8
1.6
1.5
1.2
1.3
1.1
1.0
Table 5.1: PCA observations of Cir X-1 during 1997 February 18 – March 4.
atoll source, that HBOs should never occur in this source [54, 77].
5.2 Observations
The RXTE ASM has provided 2–12 keV light curves of Cir X-1 since 1996 February (see Figure 3-1).
Throughout the ASM observations, the baseline intensity of Cir X-1 has remained near 1.0 Crab.
However, the profile of each 16.55-d flaring cycle can vary considerably. The variety of intensity
profiles is illustrated in Figure 5-1, which shows ASM light curves and hardness ratios for three
individual cycles. In many cycles, after 3–5 days in the flaring state, the intensity is quite steady
for the remainder of the cycle (e.g., Figure 5-1a). In addition to the main flaring episode, some
cycles show a mid-phase flare (not always at the same phase) to as high as 2 Crab (Figure 5-1b).
Occasionally, the flaring state begins after phase zero and continues for most of the cycle with
a gradually decreasing intensity (Figure 5-1c). Despite the variety of intensity profiles, all cycles
observed with the ASM show the general pattern of spectral hardening mentioned in section 2.4.
During the half day before phase zero, and continuing intermittently for up to two days, brief dips
occur in many cycles (perhaps in all cycles, since the ASM coverage is incomplete). These dips are
seen as isolated low points in the ASM light curves of Figure 5-1.
Eight PCA observations (∼6 ksec each) were carried out at roughly two-day intervals (Table 5.1)
during 1997 February 18 – March 4 to sample the 16.55 day cycle shown in Figure 5-1c. The very
gradual decline of the flaring-state intensity in this cycle serendipitously provided an opportunity
to study intensity-related source properties. All five proportional counter units (PCUs) of the
PCA operated normally during each observation, except during the first few minutes of the first
1Midpoint of 2–3 hr observation (∼6 ksec of data per observation).
21.0 Crab ≈ 13,000 counts/s (2–32 keV, all 5 PCUs)
5.2. OBSERVATIONS
63
Figure 5-1: RXTE ASM light curves (1.5–12 keV) for three 16.55 d cycles of Cir X-1 showing
different flaring profiles. Each intensity point corresponds to a 90-s exposure by one of the three
ASM cameras, and the hardness ratio (HR), defined as the ratio of counting rates for 5–12 keV to
3–5 keV, is shown in one-day averages. The 3–5 keV to 1.5–3 keV hardness ratio exhibits very similar
behavior and is not shown here. The intensities are for Cir X-1 after background and other sources
in the field of view have been subtracted. The Crab nebula yields ∼75 c/s. Vertical dashed lines
indicate phase zero based on the radio ephemeris of Stewart et al. 1991. Day zero corresponds to
(a) 1997 April 23.87 (b) 1996 August 2.14 and (c) 1997 February 16.69. For cycle (c), the intensity
ranges (I [2.0–18 keV]) seen in the eight RXTE PCA observations (I–VIII in time order) are also
shown.
64
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
observation when only three PCUs were on. All intensities for that period have been adjusted by
a factor of 5/3, but these data are not used in color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams due to
gain differences between detectors.
Figure 5-2 shows the light curves and hardness ratios (with 16 s time resolution) for each of
the PCA observations (I–VIII in time order), made as the intensity declined from 2.5 Crab to
1.0 Crab. On time-scales of hundreds of seconds, the observations made at high intensities show
strong variability, while observations at 1.0 Crab (∼13 kilocounts/s) show quite steady count rates.
As expected from the ASM hardness ratios, the PCA hardness ratio gradually increases from a low
value during the early observations when the source was in the flaring state to a factor four higher as
it reached the quiescent level. The relationship between intensity and spectral changes is discussed
in detail below.
5.3 Analysis and Results
5.3.1 Color-color and Hardness-intensity Diagrams
For the eight PCA observations of 1997 February–March, 16 s intensity and hardness-ratio measure-
ments were used to construct color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams (CDs/HIDs, Figure 5-3).
The hardness ratios were defined as the ratio of count rates in selected energy bands: a soft color
(I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV]) and hard color (I [13–18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV]) for the CD, and a
broad color (I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]) for the HID. The evolution from flaring to quiescent
state produced a large range of colors and intensities over the entire cycle. In contrast, each individ-
ual observation yielded a localized cluster or track within the CDs and HIDs. The spectral branches
for each of the observations are easier to distinguish in the HID than the CD. The long tracks in
the HID associated with observations I–V show the color changes associated with the large intensity
variations during the flaring phases. The intensity variations are smaller for observations VI–VIII,
but significant color changes do occur during these observations as well.
The choice of energy bands used in constructing these diagrams can affect the appearance of
spectral tracks. For observations showing a single branch, only the length and slope of the branch
is affected. Observations V and VI each show two branches. The orientation of these branches is
discussed in more detail below.
The tracks in the CD and HID are reminiscent of the correlated spectral/intensity behavior of
Z and atoll class LMXBs (see Figure 1-1), which also show correlations of temporal properties with
position along tracks or branches in CDs and HIDs [27]. Thus, we have investigated how the temporal
properties of Cir X-1 are related to position in the CD or HID. For this purpose, we divided the
5.3. ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
65
Figure 5-2: PCA light curves (2–18 keV, 5 PCUs) and hardness ratios (HR = I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–
6.3 keV]) in 16 s time bins for the eight observations made during 1997 February 18 – March 4. A
count rate of 13 kcts/s ≈ 1.0 Crab. The data gaps in Obs. VI were longer than as shown here; the
second segment of the observation has been shifted left by 4000 s and the third segment by 5000 s.
These data were used to construct the hardness-intensity diagram in Figure 5-3. The association
with specific regions of that diagram is indicated below each light curve.
66
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
Figure 5-3: Color-color diagram (a) and hardness-intensity diagram (b) for all eight observations
(I–VIII). In the CD, soft color is defined as I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV] and hard color as I [13–
18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV]. In the HID, the intensity, I [2.0–18 keV], is from all five PCUs and the
hardness ratio is a "broad" color: I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]. Each point corresponds to 16 s
of data. Background has been subtracted, but it does not affect the intensity or soft color and
only slightly affects the hard color. The three insets in the CD separate overlapping points from
observations I–V. The HID track for each observation has been divided into three regions (1–3) for
timing analysis.
5.3. ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
67
Figure 5-4: Averaged and rebinned power density spectra (2–32 keV) for each of the three HID
regions for each observation. Poisson noise has been subtracted from each PDS (see text).
HID track for each of the eight observations into three regions (Figure 5-3b). The choice of numbers
for each region was motivated in part by the timing results discussed below, but the numbers serve
mainly as reference labels rather than as meaningful quantities (such as Z "rank number").
5.3.2 Power Density Spectra
Fourier power density spectra (PDSs) were computed using 16 s segments with 244 µs (2−12 s)
time bins. This was done for both the full 2–32 keV energy range and for four energy channels:
2.0–4.8 keV, 4.8–13 keV, 13–18 keV, and 18–32 keV. The Leahy-normalized power spectra [40] were
converted to the fractional rms normalization by dividing by the background-subtracted count rate in
the selected band. The expected Poisson level, i.e. the level of white noise due to counting statistics,
was estimated taking into account the effects of deadtime [51, 88, 89] and subtracted from each
PDS; this method tends to slightly underestimate the actual Poisson level. For each of the 24 HID
68
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
regions defined in Figure 5-3, an average PDS was calculated from the power spectra corresponding
to points in that region. The PDSs were then logarithmically rebinned.
The average PDS (2–32 keV) for each HID region is shown in Figure 5-4. During the extended
active state (observations I-VI), a broad peak is often observed near 4 Hz; this feature is prominent
in PDSs from observations III–VI, weak in observation II, and indistinguishable from a flat-topped
component in observation I (see below). A strong narrow QPO feature is seen at frequencies from
6.8 to 13 Hz in observations VII and VIII. In some cases, especially at higher photon energy (see
Figure 5-5), a harmonic peak is observed at twice the frequency of this QPO. A weak narrow QPO
feature is present at frequencies above 20 Hz in regions II-1 and VI-1. A sharp "knee" is present
at similar frequencies in regions II-2, II-3, III-1, IV-1, VI-2, VI-3, and possibly I-1. Broad high-
frequency noise is sometimes seen, e.g. at ∼100 Hz in observation VIII (Figure 5-5b). There is an
underlying red continuum spectrum of noise in all of the regions of the HID, but the shape and low
frequency slope of the continuum vary over a wide range.
The narrow QPO peaks and the low frequency noise in the PDSs from the "quiescent" 1 Crab
observations (VII and VIII) resemble previously observed PDSs (Chapter 4, [62, 54, 69]). Those
PDSs also contained narrow QPO features, with centroid frequencies in the range 1.3–20 Hz, and
similarly shaped low-frequency noise (e.g. see Figure 4-3). The broad high-frequency component
that we detect in the present observations is similar to the 20–100 Hz QPO seen in earlier PCA
observations (Chapter 4, [62]) and to the 100–200 Hz QPO observed with EXOSAT [69].
The weak narrow QPO feature above 20–30 Hz in regions II-1 and VI-1 occurs near the knee
of the low-frequency noise component. This similarity to the LFN and prominent QPO at lower
frequency in observations VII and VIII suggests these higher frequency oscillations are produced by
the same physical process as the lower frequency QPOs. In observations II and VI, this QPO feature
is visible in region 1 as a small peak that fades in region 2 and becomes only a "knee" in region 3
(see Figure 5-4). Thus we assume that this knee is related to the QPO. Similar knees are present
in regions III-1, IV-1, and possibly I-1. We include a narrow QPO component in fits of PDSs which
show a knee above 20 Hz, but identify these cases as "unpeaked" in the discussion below.
Likewise, although no peak appears in the PDSs from observation I, a broad noise component
has roughly constant power below about 4 Hz and drops off above that frequency, forming a "knee"
which might indicate the presence of the 4 Hz QPO component. The PDS for region I-1 somewhat
resembles those of regions III-1 and IV-1, in that all show a break in the power spectrum near 4 Hz
and a second knee or change in slope near 30 Hz. We include a broad QPO component in fits of the
PDSs for observation I, but we identify these cases as "unpeaked".
The PDSs were fit with models comprising both broad-band and QPO components: a power-law
5.3. ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
69
Figure 5-5: Averaged and rebinned power density spectra for HID region VIII-3 in three energy
bands. A harmonic peak of the 7.6 Hz QPO is clearly visible in the high-energy channel (c). The
broad high-frequency peak, most clear in (b), occurs near ∼100 Hz in this observation. The low-
frequency noise cuts off less sharply as energy increases.
70
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
for the very low frequency noise (VLFN), an exponentially cut-off power-law for the broad low-
frequency noise, a Lorentzian for the broad QPO near 4 Hz, Lorentzians for the narrow QPO and
its first harmonic, a broad Lorentzian for the high-frequency peak, and a second power-law to fit the
residual Poisson noise at high frequency. The model for each PDS consisted of two to five of these
components, depending on which components were necessary for an acceptable fit. The frequency
of the harmonic (when present) of the narrow QPO was fixed at twice the fundamental frequency.
For the fits of the PDSs from the four narrower energy channels, the QPO centroid frequencies were
fixed at the values determined from the 2–32 keV PDSs. There were generally not enough counts to
obtain useful PDS fits for the 18–32 keV channel. For use in performing the fits, we estimated the
variance of each power in each binned and averaged PDS by calculating the sample variance of the
powers in the individual PDSs that were averaged to obtain each point, and dividing the result by
the number of the powers used in computing the sample variance.
The centroids of the narrow variable-frequency QPO and the ∼4 Hz QPO were measured accu-
rately whenever a clear peak was visible. However, in cases where these components are weak or
unpeaked, the centroids were less well-constrained. The centroid of the broad high-frequency peak
and the cut-off frequency of the LFN were often poorly constrained.
Figure 5-6 shows the frequency of the broad and narrow QPOs versus intensity (2–18 keV). The
frequency of the narrow peak is generally correlated with intensity, starting at 6.8 Hz at 1 Crab and
reaching 32 Hz at 1.3 Crab. At higher intensity, this QPO is sometimes present above 20 Hz and
is often unpeaked (i.e., a knee). In observations III–VI, the broad QPO is clearly present at 3.3 to
4.3 Hz. This QPO component was included in the fits of the PDSs from observations I and II, and
the resulting frequencies (2.1–4.5 Hz) are shown as unfilled squares (indicating a weak peak or a
knee) above 20 kcts/s in Figure 5-6.
The ratio of the width of the narrow QPO peak to its centroid frequency (∆ν/ν) is about 0.15
when at 6.8 to 13 Hz. At higher frequency this QPO becomes broader, with ∆ν/ν ∼ 0.4. When the
broad QPO near 4 Hz is strong, we find that ∆ν/ν ∼ 1, and when it is weak ∆ν/ν ∼ 2 to 3.
Figure 5-7 illustrates the dependence of the rms amplitude of the QPOs upon photon energy.
Typical values for the rms amplitude of the 6.8–13.1 Hz QPO at 2–4.8 keV, 4.8–13 keV, and 13–
18 keV are 4%, 5%, and 8% respectively (Figure 5-7a), indicating a weak trend of increasing rms
amplitude at higher photon energy. The amplitude of the broad QPO increases significantly at
higher photon energy. For clearly peaked 4 Hz QPOs, the rms amplitude is typically about 3%,
8%, and 18% in these three energy bands (Figure 5-7b). The rms values vary considerably when
these components are weak or unpeaked but their amplitudes still generally increase with energy
(Figure 5-7c).
5.3. ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
71
Figure 5-6:
Centroid frequency of the QPOs versus intensity (I [2.0–18 keV]). A filled circle
represents the narrow QPO and a filled square represents the broad ∼4 Hz QPO (all points below
5 Hz are the broad QPO). Unfilled circles and squares indicate the approximate frequency of a
knee or very weak peak that may be associated with the narrow and broad QPO respectively. Error
bars on frequency measurements (filled points only) represent 90% confidence intervals for a single
parameter (∆χ2=2.7). In many cases, the error bar for the QPO frequency is smaller than the plot
symbol.
72
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
Figure 5-7: Rms amplitude of QPOs versus photon energy. Panel (a) shows the rms for the narrow
QPO at 7.2 Hz (solid dot) and (b) for an example of the broad 4 Hz QPO (solid box). In panel (c),
unfilled circles and boxes indicate the rms amplitude of a component forming a knee or very weak
peak that may be associated with the narrow and broad QPOs respectively. The broad QPO points
have been offset slightly to the right in energy for clarity. Errors on QPO amplitudes represent 90%
confidence intervals.
5.4. DISCUSSION
73
5.3.3 Temporal Behavior versus Position on Spectral Branches
The outlines of the HID regions of Figure 5-3b are reproduced in Figure 5-8 with labels summarizing
the observed QPO properties. As the hardness ratio decreases and the intensity increases along the
HID tracks for observations VIII, VII, and VI, the frequency of the narrow QPO feature increases
from 6.8 Hz to 32 Hz. The feature is rather weak and knee-like in observation VI, but it appears to
have a width consistent with the width of the prominent QPO peak in observations VII and VIII.
A similar weak and somewhat knee-like feature is also present in observation II, where it increases
in frequency from 22 Hz to 30 Hz as the intensity increases. The PDSs from observations I, III, and
IV all show a knee above 30 Hz at the high-intensity, hard end of their HID tracks; these knees may
be related to the narrow QPO features seen in the other observations.
The broad 4 Hz QPO is not present in the "quiescent" observations (VII and VIII). This QPO
is strongest in portions of the intermediate-intensity observations (III–VI) and is weakly present in
the soft, high-intensity observations (II and possibly I).
Very low frequency noise dominates the power spectrum of regions V-3 and III-3. Both of these
regions appear to begin upturned branches at the low-intensity, soft end of branches showing the
more pronounced 4 Hz QPOs.
5.4 Discussion
The combined temporal and spectral-branch properties of the observations presented here suggest
Z-like behavior. We identify the 6.8–32 Hz QPOs as horizontal-branch oscillations (HBOs), the
4 Hz QPO as normal-branch oscillations (NBOs), and the strong VLFN as flaring-branch behavior
(see discussion below). These identifications of characteristic time-variability patterns then help to
identify the tracks in the HID as horizontal, normal, and flaring branches (HB/NB/FB), where each
6 ks observation of Cir X-1 appears to have captured a snapshot of portions of one or two of the
branches. The spectral branches appear to shift around as the flaring gradually subsides, rather than
forming a stable Z pattern. It is likely that the shapes of the spectral branches become distorted
somewhat during these large shifts. We now describe the inferred properties of each of the spectral
branches in more detail.
5.4.1 Horizontal Branch
HID regions VIII, VII, and VI-1 show a narrow QPO peak or knee at 6.8–7.6 Hz, 11.3–13.1 Hz, and
32 Hz respectively. This frequency range overlaps the 13–60 Hz range of typical horizontal branch
QPOs [78]. The associated low-frequency noise and harmonic peak are also typical of horizontal
74
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
Figure 5-8: Hardness-intensity diagram showing QPO properties for the regions from Figure 5-3b.
The frequency of the 6.8 to 32 Hz QPO is labeled (in Hz) beside each region where it is present.
Parenthesized frequencies indicate that this component was unpeaked, i.e., a knee. Letters indicate
the strength of the broad 4 Hz QPO: S-strong, M-medium, and W-weak or unpeaked.
5.4. DISCUSSION
75
branch power spectra. The broad high frequency peak in Cir X-1 may be related to the high
frequency noise component often observed on the horizontal branch.
The HID track for observation VI shows the narrow QPO at 32 Hz on a roughly horizontal
segment (region VI-1) and a knee at 37 Hz on the right end of this segment (region VI-2). The apex
of region VI-2 brings a transition to the 4 Hz QPO, which is dominant on the downward branch of
this track (region VI-3). This is very similar to the HB/NB transition in Z sources.
When Cir X-1 is in "quiescence" in observations VII and VIII, the "horizontal branch" turns
upward and becomes vertical in the HID. For comparison, RXTE PCA observations of Cir X-1 from
1996 March 10–19 which show a narrow QPO peak at 1.3–12 Hz [62] (Chapter 4) are almost entirely
confined to the 12.3–14.7 kcts/s (2–21 keV) intensity range. The HID tracks for those observations
lie along a nearly vertical line, and probably represent sections of the "horizontal" branch.
Observation II may also be on part of the HB, since a weak narrow QPO appears to evolve into
a knee and increase in frequency from 22 to 30 Hz as the intensity increases. However, the broad
QPO is also weakly visible in PDSs for this observation. The fact that observations II, VI, VII, and
VIII all show little variation of the hard color used in Figure 5-3a suggests that observation II may
be associated with the other HB observations.
5.4.2 Normal Branch
The 4 Hz QPO is observed when the source intensity rises above the "quiescent" 1-Crab level
(∼13 kcts/s). It is roughly stationary in frequency (3.3–4.3 Hz when clearly peaked) and broader
than the HBO. The feature is easily seen in observations III–VI; at these times the location in the
HID moves along diagonal tracks. The ∼4 Hz frequency and motion along diagonal tracks in the
HID is consistent with the 4–7 Hz NBOs observed at nearly constant frequency on the NB of typical
Z sources [27]. We therefore identify the broad 4 Hz QPO as a normal branch oscillation, and the
diagonal tracks for observations III–VI as shifted normal branches.
The broad QPO component may be also present in the highest intensity observations, as a weak
feature in observation II and in the form of a break near the 4 Hz QPO frequency in observation I.
We also note that at the top of the normal branch (regions I-1, III-1, IV-1, VI-2) a knee above 30 Hz
is present in addition to the NBO component.
A similar broad 4 Hz QPO is present in observations from 1996 March 5–6 (Obs. 1 in Table 4.1)
made immediately before phase zero of the cycle showing the 1.3–12 Hz narrow QPO.
76
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
5.4.3 Flaring Branch
Beyond the left apex of the normal branch a short upturned branch is observed in HID region V-3
and possibly III-3. The PDS for these regions are dominated by very low frequency noise, which is
typical for flaring branches, and no QPO peaks are obviously apparent. We note that in the well-
established Z sources neither NBOs nor HBOs are present on the flaring branch, except for Sco X-1
and GX 17+2, in which the NBO evolves into a 6–20 Hz QPO (see [78] and references therein).
The left end of the spectral track for observation V bends upward in the HID shown in Figure 5-
3b, but bends downward in the CD in Figure 5-3a. This behavior is demonstrated more clearly
in Figure 5-9, which shows CDs and HIDs for observations V and VI. When a broad color (I [6.3–
13 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]) is used as the ordinate of the diagrams (Figure 5-9a,b), the track for
observation V turns upward on the left end. When a harder color (I [13–18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV])
is used as the ordinate (Figure 5-9c,d), this branch turns downward. The CD and particularly the
HID version based on the harder color show the most clear similarity to canonical Z diagrams, with
the temporal behavior of observations V and VI being generally consistent with horizontal, normal,
and flaring branches. The broad-color HID (Figure 5-9b) shows evidence for a shift of the normal
branch that does not show up in the other three diagrams of that figure.
5.4.4 Relation to Other Sources
Our observations reveal spectral branches which shift in the CD and HID as Cir X-1 evolves from a
soft, high-intensity state to a hard, lower-intensity state. The ASM light curves and hardness ratios
(Figure 5-1) show that this evolution occurs periodically with the 16.55 day cycle, thus suggesting
that the CD/HID shifts may also be periodic. Shifts of the "Z" pattern in CDs and HIDs have
been observed in the so-called Cyg-like Z sources: Cyg X-2 [35]), GX 5-1 [34], and GX 340+0 [33].
However, the shifts do not occur periodically in those sources, nor do they have the magnitude of
the shifts observed in Cir X-1.
The flaring branch of Cir X-1 turns upward when a soft or broad color is used on the vertical
axis. When a harder color is used, this branch turns downward but then bends to the left. In the
Cyg-like Z sources, the flaring branch sometimes turns upward or starts toward higher intensity and
then loops back to lower intensity [35, 34, 33, 55]). In some cases, these sources are observed to
"dip" while on the flaring branch [34, 55, 84]), with tracks which turn down and then to the left,
similar to that of Cir X-1 in Figure 5-9c.
The left end of the horizontal branch in Cir X-1 turns upward and becomes vertical at low
intensity (Figure 5-8). On this section of the branch, HBO frequencies are low: 6.8–13 Hz in
5.4. DISCUSSION
77
Figure 5-9: Broad-color and hard-color CDs and HIDs for observations V and VI. In all four
diagrams, Obs. V is in the lower left and Obs. VI in the upper right. The CD and HID tracks for
Obs. V both turn upward at the left end in the broad-color diagrams (a,b) but turn downward in
the hard-color diagrams (c,d). In the HIDs, presence of the 32 Hz HBO, 4 Hz NBO, and VLFN is
indicated along the branches. An apparent shift of the normal branch between observations V and
VI is labeled in (b). The intensity, I [2.0–18 keV], is from all five PCUs. The soft color is defined as
I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV], the broad color as I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV], and the hard color
as I [13–18 keV] / I [8.5–13 keV]. Each point corresponds to 16 s of background-subtracted data.
78
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
observations VII and VIII and 1.3–12 Hz in the earlier 1996 March observations. A similar effect
was reported in GX 5-1 [44, 34], in which the HB turns upward at the low-intensity end while
HBOs are observed at relatively low frequency (13–17 Hz). Lewin et al. [44] suggested that other Z
sources might show such an upward turn of the HB if their intensities and QPO frequencies became
sufficiently low. Recent RXTE observations of Cyg X-2 [65] show a long vertical extension of the
horizontal branch in an HID.
The 5–20 Hz narrow QPO was detected with EXOSAT at an intensity similar to the quiescent
level observed by RXTE . We note that absorption dips are responsible for much of the structure
seen in the CD shown for that observation; however, the HIDs show that the narrow QPO occurred
on an upturned left end of a horizontally oriented track as in our data (see Figures 2–4, 8, & 10 in
[54]). At higher intensity during the same observation, the narrow QPO was not present, and we
note that some of the high-intensity PDSs show hints of a broad peak near 4 Hz. We thus conclude
that the behavior observed by EXOSAT during that observation is related to the Z-like behavior
we observe with RXTE .
Most of the other EXOSAT observations took place when Cir X-1 was significantly lower in
intensity than the "quiescent" level of the current observations. The CDs and HIDs for these
EXOSAT observations did not show tracks which could clearly be identified as Z or atoll. Their
power spectra were generally dominated by VLFN, typical of atoll sources in the banana state,
and sometimes also showed a broad red noise component resembling atoll high-frequency noise [54].
However, these power-spectral shapes are not unique to atoll sources: power spectra for black hole
candidates in the high state are dominated by VLFN, as are those of the current observations on
the low-intensity end of the normal branch and on the flaring branch (i.e., regions III-3 and V-3).
Cir X-1 was expected to never show HBOs since atoll-like behavior was taken as evidence that
the magnetic field is not strong enough to allow the magnetospheric beat frequency mechanism
(MBFM) to operate [77, 54]. (However, it is also possible that the HBOs are not produced by the
MBFM.) The results presented here demonstrate both HBOs and NBOs in Cir X-1 and show no
evidence for atoll behavior. Since the atoll-like behavior observed with EXOSAT occurred at lower
intensity than in the present observations, it is possible that they do represent a different state of
the source. If Cir X-1 actually can show atoll behavior as well as the Z-like behavior shown here,
then we would have new clues to the differences between the two types of sources. Such observations
would challenge the hypothesis that differences in both M and magnetic field distinguish these two
classes.
5.5. SUMMARY
5.5 Summary
79
Our results from an analysis of RXTE observations of Cir X-1 reveal behavior similar to that of Z
sources, and, in particular, allow us to identify temporal and spectral signatures of the horizontal,
normal, and flaring branches. The spectral variability of Cir X-1 is seen to correspond to tracks in
a HID which are similar in direction to the typical direction in the HID of Z sources in general, but
the locations of the tracks corresponding to each branch move from observation to observation in a
systematic manner.
To be specific, in the current observations of Cir X-1 the horizontal branch is characterized by
the presence of relatively narrow 6.8–32 Hz QPO features in the PDS. The track in the HID of the
horizontal branch is horizontal at the high intensity end and becomes vertical at the low intensity end,
where the source is "quiescent", i.e., has an intensity near 1 Crab and is characterized by a relatively
low degree of variability on time scales longer than 1 s. The normal branch is characterized by broad
4 Hz QPOs, and by motion in the HID which generally falls along tracks which run diagonally from
hard high-intensity locations to soft low-intensity locations. There are also time intervals when the
PDS is dominated by very low frequency noise. We identify these intervals as excursions onto the
flaring branch.
The large amplitude intensity variations associated with the active/flaring state of Cir X-1 can
be divided into three categories: (1) motion across the horizontal portion of the horizontal branch
and along the normal and flaring branches, (2) shifts of the spectral branches, and (3) absorption
dips. While our RXTE observations have allowed us to recognize and distinguish these different
types of variability, there is still much to be understood about the physical mechanisms responsible.
80
CHAPTER 5. QPOS ASSOCIATED WITH SPECTRAL BRANCHES
Chapter 6
Correlated Timing and Spectral
Behavior
6.1 Overview
The eight observations presented in Chapter 5 (study E) were characterized by well-separated spec-
tral tracks in color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams. Based on timing characteristics, the spec-
tral branches were identified with Z-source horizontal, normal, and flaring branches (HB/NB/FB).
However, due to the short duration of the observations and the large shifts of the tracks between
them, the complete spectral-branch pattern for could only be inferred from fragmented pieces.
Those results indicated that the transition between the quiescent and flaring states of Cir X-1 is
at least partially related to motion around the "Z" track. In 1997 June, we carried out an extensive
RXTE campaign to study in detail the transition to active state, including 7 days of 56% coverage
beginning before the phase zero dips (study G, see Figure 3-5). The excellent coverage provided by
those observations allowed us to find portions of the transition which clearly demonstrate the full
spectral track of Cir X-1. The evolution of the timing characteristics and energy spectrum were
studied as a function of position along the track. We found a continuous evolution of the power
density spectrum between the different states defined by the spectral branches. We also found that
each branch of the spectral track is associated with a specific type of evolution of the energy spectrum
(e.g., pivoting about 7 keV in one case and increasing at low energy while remaining constant at
high energy in another case). We explored various physical models for the energy spectrum and
parameterized the evolution of the spectrum in terms of a two-component model consisting of a
multi-temperature "disk blackbody" and a higher-temperature isothermal blackbody.
81
82
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
6.2
1997 June PCA Observations
The PCA light curves and hardness ratios for the 1997 June observations are shown in Figure 6-1.
These data show only moderate variability before phase zero until entering a phase of significant
dipping during the half day before phase zero. The hardness ratios show that significant spectral
evolution (both hardening and softening) occurs during these dips. Similar dip behavior from another
set of PCA observations was studied in detail and is presented in Chapter 7.
By phase zero (day 611.5), the main dipping episode ends, and the climb to the flaring state
begins. While the intensity increases by more than a factor of three in the lowest energy band
(2–4.8 keV), the intensity between 6.3 keV and 13 keV does not climb at all, and above 13 keV
the intensity actually decreases by a factor of about 10 over the first 1.5 days following phase zero.
This anti-correlation of the low and high-energy intensity during the transition results in decreased
hardness ratios after phase zero, as is observed by the ASM (section 2.4). After a relatively smooth
transition toward high total intensity during the first day following phase zero, the intensity becomes
highly variable (i.e., the "active" or "flaring" state) for the remainder of the observations (about a
week).
6.3 Complete Spectral Track
The color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams (CDs/HIDs) for all data in Figure 6-1 are shown in
Figure 6-2. These data cover a significant portion (10 d) of an entire 16.55 d cycle. The dips seen
in Figure 6-1 appear as prominent light tracks with two sharp bends in the CD (initially toward the
right of the main arc-shaped locus) and one sharp bend in the HID (I < 2.3 kilocounts/s/PCU).
I show in Chapter 7 that tracks with these shapes are indicative of highly variable absorption of
a bright spectral component and only moderate, fixed absorption of a fainter component. Having
identified absorption dip signatures, I will now focus on non-dip spectral behavior (presumably more
directly related to the X-ray source) for the remainder of this chapter.
Most of the data fall along a single arc-shaped locus in the CD and a more complicated curved
structure in the HID. This behavior is quite similar to that shown for the eight brief sampling
observations from 1997 February–March presented in Chapter 5 (see the CD and HID in Figure 5-
3). However, the high-efficiency coverage of the current observations has filled in many of the gaps
that occurred between the tracks of the earlier observations.
In order to examine the detailed structure with the overall locus of CD/HID points, the data
were divided into shorter time segments (of order hours) and plotted separately in CDs and HIDs.
In general, each segment produced a fragmented track or tracks, similar to the 1997 February–March
6.3. COMPLETE SPECTRAL TRACK
83
Figure 6-1: Light curves in four energy bands and two hardness ratios for PCA observations of
Cir X-1 from 1997 June 10–20, covering a 10-day period around phase zero (φ = 0). The intensities
at the beginning of these observations (day 610) are typical "quiescent" levels. Each point represents
16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2. Ratios of the intensities in the four bands
produce soft (I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV]) and hard (I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV]) hardness
ratios. Segments labeled A, B, C & D were used for spectral studies.
84
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-2: Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams from PCA observations during 1997 June
10–21 (the entire period covered by Figure 6-1). Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted
data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
6.3. COMPLETE SPECTRAL TRACK
85
Figure 6-3: Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams from time segments "C" (left panels) and
"D" (right panels) of Figure 6-1 (1997 June 13.625–14.125 and 1997 June 17.075–17.600 respectively).
Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
86
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
observations. In Figure 6-3, the CDs and HIDs are shown for two time segments (labeled "C" and
"D" in Figure 6-1), during which the source traced out a significant portion of several connected
branches. These time segments were each about 12 hours in duration and separated by several days.
Tracks of other time segments generally each resembled some portion of the entire pattern shown in
Figure 6-3, but often with a shifted position in the diagrams.
The location of the tracks for segments C and D in the HID for the total 10 d observation set is
such that the "hole" produced by the looped branches is visible between 3 and 4 kilocounts/s/PCU
in Figure 6-2. The data from the segment C included some absorption dips, resulting in tracks
moving off the right side of the CD and the left side of the HID (and far beyond the limits of the
plot in both cases). The HID patterns are consistent with the shape of the full "Z" track as inferred
by the fragmented tracks in Chapter 5. For segment C, there is a large upturned left extension of
the horizontal branch, the horizontal portion of the HB, the diagonal normal branch, and a flaring
branch that turns above rather than below the NB. Similar tracks are also present in the HID for
segment D, except there is only a small hint an upward turn at the left end of the HB. The plots for
the two segments have the same limits and show a significant shift of the HB and upper NB between
the two time segments. The HID for segment D is remarkably similar to that derived from RXTE
PCA observations of the Z source Cyg X-2 [65]. The Cyg X-2 HID shows a very prominent vertical
extension of the HB.
The branches in Figure 6-3 are less well separated in the color-color diagrams, as noted in Chap-
ter 5. However, the flaring branch clearly turns above the normal branch in the current diagrams,
and the upturned left extension of HID horizontal branch of segment C appears to also have an in-
creased slope in the CD. The upturned flaring branch is very similar to the flaring branch observed
in the color-color diagram for the Z source GX 349+2 in recent RXTE PCA observations [90].
Twenty regions along the HID track of time segment C, shown in the lower left panel of Figure 6-
3, were selected for further timing and spectral analysis. These regions are shown in Figure 6-4 and
labeled with increasing numbers from the left HB, through the NB, to the FB. We will refer to this
label as the "rank number" after similar work done by other authors on the standard Z sources;
however, the numbers at the various apexes have no special significance. It should also be noted
that region 6 does not fit in with the monotonic increase of rank number around the spectral track,
and may be an indication of a shifted horizontal portion of the HB.
The light curves, hardness ratio, and HID regions versus time for the data in Figure 6-4 (time
segment C) are shown in Figure 6-5. During this half-day segment, the source generally moves
toward higher rank number around the spectral track as the observation progresses. Thus, the data
have been divided into four sub-segments which predominantly correspond to each portion of the
6.3. COMPLETE SPECTRAL TRACK
87
Figure 6-4: Hardness-intensity diagram from time segment C (1997 June 13.625–14.125; day 12.625–
13.125). The HID track has been divided into 20 regions from which power density spectra and energy
spectra were constructed.
88
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-5: Top: light curves in 3 energy channels and bottom: total 2–18 keV light curve, broad
color, and HID regions for time segment C (1997 June 13.625-14.125; see Figure 6-1). Based on
HID region numbers, the predominant spectral branch is identified for each portion of the data.
Absorption dips (omitted from HID regions) are clearly identified by decreased intensity coupled
with upward broad-color spikes.
6.4. EVOLUTION OF THE POWER DENSITY SPECTRUM
89
HID track: the horizontal and vertical portions of the HB, the NB, and the FB. Brief absorption
dips occur in all but the flaring branch during this particular data set; these are easily identified by
sharp intensity dips coupled with a spiked increase in broad color.
The different branches are characterized by the following characteristics, excluding the behavior
associated with the dips: The upturned left portion of the HB evolves relatively smoothly, with a
slight increase in 2–6.3 keV intensity and a decrease of almost a factor of two in the 13–18 keV
band. The horizontal portion of the HB shows a substantial increase in soft intensity and on average
shows relatively steady hard intensity. The normal branch shows increased variability; it is bright
in the soft bands but shows a decrease in the hard band. The NB/FB transition occurs at lower
intensity in all bands compared to most of the NB. The flaring branch itself is then produced by
high-variability "mini-flares" or bursts above the NB/FB apex level.
Although the HID regions were defined in Figure 6-4 such that obvious absorption tracks were
avoided, one brief dip, on day 612.98, occurred from region 12 on the normal branch and placed a
few points artificially across regions 9, 7, and 5. These points are easily identified in Figure 6-5 and
are thus not included in subsequent timing and spectral analysis.
Likewise, the highest mini-flares on the flaring branch actually extend beyond region 20 and cross
regions 8 and 9. In fact a few such points can even be seen above region 10 in Figure 6-4. The FB
points that fell into HB regions can also be clearly identified as points with rank numbers of 8 or 9
in the FB portion of Figure 6-5. These are not included in subsequent timing and spectral analysis.
6.4 Evolution of the Power Density Spectrum
Fourier power density spectra (PDSs) were computed for each 16 s of time segment C (1997 June
13.625–14.125). Each transform used 216 244-µs (2−12 s) time bins and covered the full 2–32 keV
energy range. The expected Poisson level, i.e. the level of white noise due to counting statistics,
was estimated taking into account the effects of deadtime [51, 88, 89] and subtracted from each
PDS; this method tends to slightly underestimate the actual Poisson level. For each of the 20 HID
regions defined in Figure 6-4, an average PDS was calculated from the power spectra corresponding
to points in that region. The PDSs were then logarithmically rebinned and are shown in Figure 6-6.
The general features of the power spectra are similar to those observed in previous PCA obser-
vations (see Figures 4-3 and 5-4), although here a continuous evolution is observed between each
timing state in a single observation. The narrow QPO is observed to evolve from 12–25 Hz moving
down the upturned left extension of the HB (regions 1–5 and 7; region 6 may be a shifted version
of 8). Across the horizontal portion of the HB (8–11), the narrow QPO remains close to 30 Hz and
90
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-6: Averaged and rebinned power density spectra (2–32 keV) for each of the 20 regions
along the HID track in Figure 6-4. The estimated Poisson noise level has been subtracted from each
PDS.
6.5. EVOLUTION OF THE ENERGY SPECTRUM
91
fades into a knee, while the broad QPO gradually rises up near 4 Hz. The broad QPO is present all
along the normal branch (regions 8–16) but is most prominently peaked in the middle of the branch.
On the flaring branch (regions 18–20), no QPOs are present and the power spectrum shows only
strong very low frequency noise.
6.5 Evolution of the Energy Spectrum
The Standard2 data mode of the PCA produces 129-channel energy spectra every 16 s. A parallel
background file was constructed using the "pcabackest" program provided with the FTOOLS analy-
sis package (version 4.0) and three background model files provided by the PCA instrument team at
NASA/GSFC (pca bkgd q6 e03v01.mdl, pca bkgd xray e03v02.mdl, pca bkgd activ e03v03.mdl).
Average energy spectra (and background spectra) were constructed for each of the 20 HID regions,
separately for each of the five PCUs. A 1% systematic error estimate was added to each channel of
the spectra to account for calibration uncertainties.
Representative energy spectra for each segment of the HID track are shown in Figure 6-7. They
demonstrate how the spectrum evolves along each branch. One spectrum in each panel is included
in the next (since it is derived from the intersection of branches), allowing the comparison to be
boot-strapped around the entire HID track. The region numbers in the figures are ordered vertically
to aid the comparison.
The spectrum is hardest in region 1, at the top of the vertical extension of the horizontal branch.
Motion down the branch (softening, regions 1–7) is due to pivoting of the spectrum about ∼7 keV,
i.e., increasing intensity below ∼7 keV and decreasing intensity above that energy. Motion to the
right across the horizontal portion of the HB (regions 8–11) is due to continued increasing low-energy
intensity, but with a nearly constant spectrum above 12 keV. The numerator of the hardness ratio
(I [6.3–13 keV] / I [2–6.3 keV]) does not extend very far into this band of nearly constant flux and
furthermore is dominated by photons with energies at the low end of the 6.3–13 keV band where the
intensity increases by a factor more similar to that of the denominator. So, although the 2.5–25 keV
spectrum softens significantly (e.g., comparing the intensity at 5 keV to 18 keV), the hardness ratio
in Figure 6-7 decreases only slightly from region 7 to region 11.
While moving down the normal branch (regions 11–17), the spectrum decreases across the entire
2.5–25 keV band, but most strongly at high energy (thus further softening). Towards the bottom
of the NB, the spectrum begins to show an abrupt steepening in slope above 10 keV. Motion up
the FB (regions 18–20) is produced by increasing intensity above ∼4 keV and a relatively constant
spectrum below that energy (thus hardening). The change in slope above 10 keV evolves into a
92
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-7: Cir X-1 energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) for several regions on each segment of
the HID track in Figure 6-4. The region numbers within the figures are ordered vertically to match
the relative intensities at the low and/or high-energy ends of the spectra.
6.6. SELECTION OF SPECTRAL MODELS
93
much more prominent step feature, with structure more complicated than merely a change in slope
(see below).
6.6 Selection of Spectral Models
In order to explore possible models for use in fitting the spectra from the HID regions, two high-
quality spectra were constructed from long steady segments (17–19 ks) at the beginning of the 1997
June observations (time segments A and B in Figure 6-1, from days 609.93–610.16 and 610.66–610.90
respectively). Based on timing properties measured throughout these data sets, time segment A falls
on the vertical portion of the HB (strong narrow QPO at 8.4–11.5 Hz) and time segment B falls near
the HB/NB apex (weak narrow QPO above 30 Hz and/or the broad 4 Hz QPO). Variability in both
of these segments was limited to less than 10% in all energy bands between 2.5–18 keV. We thus
constructed a single (averaged) spectrum for each segment, and we will refer to them as spectrum A
and spectrum B. Errors in these spectra are dominated by the 1% systematics at all energies up to
∼20 keV.
Based on a study of the PCA response matrices using Crab nebula data, R. Remillard has
recommended limiting fits to 2.5–25 keV and using only PCUs 0, 1, and 4 (pvt. comm., currently
available at http://lheawww.gsfc.nasa.gov/users/keith/ronr.txt). Spectra from each of these
detectors are fit separately. Fit parameters reported are the average values for PCUs 0, 1, and when
possible 4 (see below), and errors are conservatively estimated from the entire range allowed by 90%
confidence intervals from each of the detectors. PCU 4 consistently gives lower normalizations for
fitted spectral components, so normalizations and flux values from that detector are not included
when computing the average values and their errors. Furthermore, spectrum B was not constructed
for PCU 4 since that detector was turned off during part of time segment B.
Several single-component models were fit to spectra A and B (all models included an additional
component for interstellar absorption). Blackbody and power-law models fit very poorly in both
cases, as did a multi-temperature "disk blackbody" spectrum (summed emission from various radii
of an accretion disk [49, 46]; model "diskbb" in XSPEC), with reduced χ2 (χ2
r) values of 22–545.
A thermal bremsstrahlung model (emission due to acceleration of electrons by protons or ions in
an optically thin plasma cloud) provided a better fit to spectrum B (χ2
r = 4.0), but fit spectrum A
poorly (χ2
r = 34). A relatively good fit was achieved for both spectra with a modified bremsstrahlung
model (see Table 6.1), which includes the self-Comptonization of bremsstrahlung photons to higher
energy due to interactions with electrons in an optically thick plasma cloud [38] (model "compLS"
in XSPEC).
94
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
NH /1022 1
(cm−2)
2.80+0.22
−0.23
3.94+0.18
−0.21
Model Components2
Self-Comptonized Bremsstrahlung
T
(keV)
2.78+0.04
−0.05
2.89+0.12
−0.11
Optical
depth
11.05+0.47
−0.36
7.20+0.71
−0.69
Cutoff Power Law 5
norm
4.54+0.24
−0.23
9.67+0.37
−0.43
Blackbody 6
Photon
index
0.27+0.94
−0.27
1.95+0.74
−0.86
−0.65+0.72
−0.30
−0.34+0.46
−0.60
Ecut
(keV)
1.73+0.58
−0.24
1.67+0.31
−0.27
Blackbody 6
T
(keV)
R
(km)
1.16+0.02
−0.02
1.12+0.01
−0.02
Disk Blackbody 7
24.13+0.38
−0.37
30.46+0.92
−0.40
Tin
(keV)
1.81+0.08
−0.06
1.54+0.04
−0.04
Rin cos1/2 θ
(km)
9.39+0.64
−0.64
15.63+0.93
−0.84
0.00+0.02
−0.00
0.01+0.21
−0.01
1.44+0.26
−0.27
2.49+0.23
−0.23
T
norm
(keV)
R
(km)
2.24+1.53
−0.47
5.97+2.70
−2.29
2.44+0.10
−0.05
2.29+0.09
−0.07
Blackbody 6
4.40+0.34
−0.87
4.61+0.67
−0.73
T
(keV)
R
(km)
2.33+0.02
−0.03
2.20+0.03
−0.03
Blackbody 6
5.38+0.16
−0.15
5.59+0.27
−0.25
T
(keV)
2.47+0.04
−0.04
2.28+0.05
−0.05
R
(km)
4.10+0.25
−0.25
4.66+0.37
−0.37
Flux/10−8 3
erg cm−2 s−1
4
χ2
r
2.73+0.02
−0.02
3.04+0.02
−0.02
1.16–1.55
1.51–2.02
2.73+0.02
−0.02
3.04+0.02
−0.02
0.79–1.04
0.79–1.35
2.72+0.02
−0.02
3.04+0.02
−0.02
2.51–2.82
1.42–1.78
2.73+0.02
−0.02
3.04+0.02
−0.02
0.79–1.06
0.75–1.31
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
Table 6.1: Fit parameters for spectra A & B for four models.
A number of two-component models were also fit to these two spectra. A model using a disk
blackbody and power law did not fit well (χ2
r=3–5), mainly because the spectrum does not flatten to
a single slope at high energy. A hard (high-temperature, >
∼2 keV) blackbody is often used to fit the
spectra of LMXBs thought to contain a neutron star, where emission near the surface might produce
a high-temperature blackbody with small effective area. A power law with high-energy exponential
cutoff plus a hard blackbody fit well (see Table 6.1) but parameters for the cutoff power law were
poorly constrained since the cutoff energy (Ecut ≈ 1.7 keV ) was below the PCA bandpass.
Two blackbodies (∼1.1 keV and ∼2.2 keV) fit moderately well (see Table 6.1), but required neg-
ligible interstellar absorption. The low absorption is inconsistent with previous measurements from
ASCA and ROSAT (both sensitive below 2 keV where the absorption is most easily constrained)
which estimated the interstellar column density to be NH =(1.8–2.4)×1022 cm−2 [12, 56].
1Absorption column density (Hydrogen atoms per cm2).
2 Errors quoted are 90% confidence limits for a single parameter (∆χ2 = 2.7).
3Total 2.5–25 keV flux.
4 Reduced χ2 = χ2/dof , where dof = degrees of freedom = the number of spectral bins (52–54/spectrum) minus
the number of fit parameters (4–6).
5High-energy exponential cut-off.
6Blackbody radius assumes a distance of 8 kpc.
7 For the disk blackbody, the inner radius of the accretion disk (times cos1/2 θ, where θ is the disk inclination angle
and θ = 0 is parallel to the line of sight) is given for a distance of 8 kpc.
6.6. SELECTION OF SPECTRAL MODELS
95
Figure 6-8: Spectrum A and model (histogram) consisting of a disk blackbody and blackbody (see
Table 6.1). The residuals show a peak at 6–7 keV that may be due to an iron emission line.
A soft disk blackbody, with temperatures at the inner edge of the disk of 1.5–1.8 keV, plus the
hard blackbody fit both spectra quite well (see Table 6.1). This gave absorption column densities
roughly consistent with the ASCA and ROSAT values. Other two-component models could also
produce similar fits to those describe above. Thus, the spectrum cannot be uniquely deconvolved
into separate components. However, for purposes of fitting the HID regions, the model composed of
a disk blackbody and blackbody was used. This model is physically motivated (a component from
an accretion disk and a harder component from near the surface of a neutron star) and provides
good fits with interstellar column densities roughly consistent with previously measured values.
The spectral fit for spectrum A for a disk blackbody plus blackbody is shown in Figure 6-8.
This plot illustrates the good fit of the model over the entire 2.5–25 keV band. Peaked residuals at
6–7 keV suggest the presence of an emission line, probably iron Kα. Very similar residuals appear in
most of the fits discussed above for both spectra A and B. Addition of a Gaussian line to the models
does in fact improve the fits in almost all cases; however, the best-fitting line often has an extremely
96
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
large Gaussian width (σ > 1 keV). The energy resolution of the PCA is about 1 keV FWHM at
6 keV; thus it is difficult to place reliable constraints on the parameters (such as centroid and width)
of a narrow component such as an emission line. We have not included an emission line in the fits
reported in Table 6.1. The presence of an emission line near 6.4 keV is discussed in more detail in
Chapter 7 in conjunction with spectra of absorption dips, which show the line more prominently.
6.7 Fits to Spectra from 20 HID Regions
A disk blackbody plus blackbody was fit to the spectra from each of the 20 HID regions. The resulting
fit parameters are listed in Table 6.2, and several representative fits are shown in Figures 6-9 and 6-
10. We estimated the distance to Cir X-1 to be 8 kpc (see section 1.3) in converting blackbody and
disk blackbody normalizations to radii.
The spectra along the horizontal branch (regions 1–11) were all fit relatively well, with residuals
similar to those for spectra A and B above, suggesting a possible emission line from iron. These
spectra all show column densities of 1.8–2.3×1022 cm−2, consistent with the ASCA and ROSAT
values discussed above. The temperatures of both components (∼1.3 keV for the inner disk and
∼2.0 keV for the hard blackbody) are quite stable on the HB, with only slight evidence for cooling
down the vertical portion of the branch (i.e., higher temperatures in regions 1–4). The pivoting
spectrum on the vertical portion of the HB may be related to these temperature changes. The inner
radius of the disk blackbody component (times a factor of order unity involving the inclination angle
of the disk) increases from 19 to 33 km, while the radius of hard blackbody remains between 3 and
4 km. Thus, it is mainly changes in the (soft) disk blackbody radius that produce the HB track.
These size scales are consistent with the hypothesis that these components arise from emission close
to a neutron star, which has a radius of order 10 km. From region 1 to 11, the total 2.5–25 keV
flux increases monotonically (with the exception of region 6) from 2.89–4.35×10−8 erg cm−2 s−1
(corresponding to 1.2–1.8 times the Eddington luminosity limit for a 1.4 M⊙ neutron star at 8 kpc).
Moving down the normal branch, the quality of the fits decrease, as indicated by the increasing
χ2 values in Table 6.2. The absorption column density gradually decreases by a factor of two, but
may be related to the decreasing fit quality. The inner radius and temperature of the disk blackbody
change only slightly on the normal branch. In contrast, the hard blackbody begins to fade on the
upper portion of the normal branch (regions 12–14), as indicated by a decreasing radius for the
emission area. In fact, by the middle of the normal branch, the hard blackbody has faded entirely
and fits have lower χ2 values without it. Thus, the hard blackbody is omitted from the fits for
regions 15–20. The 2.5–6 keV residuals continue to appear similar to those on the HB, but the
6.7. FITS TO SPECTRA FROM 20 HID REGIONS
97
HID 1 NH /1022 2
region
(cm−2)
1.83+0.28
−0.32
1.97+0.30
−0.28
2.04+0.27
−0.35
2.18+0.37
−0.32
2.29+0.33
−0.27
2.35+0.30
−0.24
2.31+0.24
−0.25
2.27+0.29
−0.25
2.18+0.21
−0.24
2.01+0.23
−0.24
1.98+0.19
−0.22
1.78+0.22
−0.26
1.63+0.21
−0.25
1.53+0.18
−0.17
1.48+0.15
−0.16
1.43+0.19
−0.17
0.94+0.17
−0.15
0.56+0.16
−0.18
0.64+0.17
−0.16
0.81+0.15
−0.19
T
(keV)
2.16+0.09
−0.07
2.15+0.09
−0.10
2.08+0.09
−0.08
2.07+0.18
−0.17
2.02+0.11
−0.14
2.02+0.11
−0.13
2.03+0.09
−0.11
2.01+0.12
−0.14
2.01+0.14
−0.14
2.01+0.12
−0.11
1.93+0.08
−0.08
1.94+0.17
−0.12
2.12+0.22
−0.19
2.34+0.53
−0.40
Tin
(keV)
1.45+0.05
−0.05
1.41+0.04
−0.05
1.38+0.04
−0.04
1.36+0.05
−0.06
1.31+0.03
−0.05
1.34+0.03
−0.04
1.30+0.02
−0.03
1.29+0.02
−0.03
1.30+0.03
−0.03
1.31+0.02
−0.03
1.30+0.02
−0.02
1.29+0.02
−0.02
1.28+0.02
−0.02
1.26+0.01
−0.02
1.22+0.00
−0.00
1.19+0.00
−0.00
1.20+0.00
−0.00
1.26+0.01
−0.01
1.29+0.01
−0.01
1.33+0.01
−0.01
Rin cos1/2 θ 3
(km)
19.29+1.31
−1.22
20.87+1.46
−1.29
22.24+1.30
−1.16
23.46+2.27
−1.85
27.22+1.97
−1.74
26.21+1.33
−1.19
28.67+1.20
−1.05
30.06+1.70
−1.48
30.68+1.15
−1.07
31.35+1.31
−1.10
32.90+1.24
−1.17
33.41+1.51
−1.34
34.02+1.09
−0.92
33.94+1.28
−1.06
35.30+0.51
−0.49
35.88+0.50
−0.48
32.69+0.23
−0.53
28.22+0.49
−0.48
27.02+0.35
−0.36
26.25+0.38
−0.37
R 4
(km)
Flux/10−8 5
erg cm−2 s−1
3.65+0.50
−0.52
3.71+0.68
−0.64
4.00+0.56
−0.52
3.89+1.27
−1.18
3.78+0.97
−0.94
3.31+0.58
−0.53
3.30+0.65
−0.57
3.34+0.91
−0.83
3.36+0.85
−0.69
3.02+0.86
−0.67
3.52+0.67
−0.54
3.09+0.82
−0.72
1.51+0.70
−0.47
0.84+0.77
−0.46
2.89+0.03
−0.02
2.99+0.02
−0.02
2.96+0.02
−0.02
3.02+0.03
−0.02
3.21+0.02
−0.02
3.37+0.02
−0.02
3.27+0.02
−0.02
3.46+0.03
−0.02
3.75+0.02
−0.02
4.15+0.02
−0.03
4.39+0.03
−0.03
4.35+0.03
−0.03
4.21+0.03
−0.03
3.98+0.03
−0.03
3.68+0.02
−0.02
3.32+0.02
−0.02
3.00+0.02
−0.01
2.94+0.02
−0.02
3.08+0.02
−0.02
3.24+0.02
−0.02
6
χ2
r
1.41–2.14
1.40–1.70
1.32–1.81
2.21–3.47
2.51–3.24
1.41–1.55
2.22–2.76
2.41–2.70
2.29–2.44
1.82–2.56
2.55–3.05
2.87–3.06
3.74–4.66
4.19–5.11
5.15–6.34
5.91–7.52
5.87–7.16
9.59–11.39
9.36–10.45
14.67–17.01
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Table 6.2: Fit parameters for HID regions 1–20 using a model consisting of a disk blackbody and a
blackbody.
peaked ∼6.5 keV residual on the left HB becomes broader and more complicated for higher rank
numbers.
On the flaring branch (regions 18–20), the fit quality decreases further, accompanied by very low
values for the absorption column density. A significant contribution to the high χ2 values on the
flaring branch is due to the feature above 10 keV that was mentioned above in section 6.5. This
feature actually begins to develop on the lower NB, as early as region 14 and is illustrated by two
spectra shown Figure 6-11. The residuals shown for each bin have been divided by the size of the
error bar for that bin. The feature resembles a narrow line or absorption edge but its location above
10 keV rules out even hydrogen-like iron as a possible source.
A number of other spectral models were fit to the HID-region spectra, and all failed to satis-
1 Errors quoted are 90% confidence limits for a single parameter (∆χ2 = 2.7).
2Absorption column density (Hydrogen atoms per cm2).
3 Inner radius of the accretion disk (times cos1/2 θ, where θ is the disk inclination angle and θ = 0 is parallel to
the line of sight) assuming a distance of 8 kpc.
4Blackbody radius assuming a distance of 8 kpc.
5Total 2.5–25 keV flux.
6 Reduced χ2 = χ2/dof , where dof = degrees of freedom = the number of spectral bins (52–54/spectrum) minus
the number of fit parameters (4–6).
98
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-9: Fitted energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) and model components (disk blackbody
and blackbody) for HID regions 1, 7, and 11 of Figure 6-4. The disk blackbody dominates at low
energy and the blackbody dominates at high energy. Fit parameters are listed in Table 6.2.
6.7. FITS TO SPECTRA FROM 20 HID REGIONS
99
Figure 6-10: Fitted energy spectra (2.5–25 keV; PCU 0 only) and model components (disk black-
body and blackbody) for HID regions 13, 15, and 20 of Figure 6-4. The blackbody only contributes
to the high-energy end of the spectrum in region 13, and has faded away entirely in regions 15 and
20. Fit parameters are listed in Table 6.2.
100
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Figure 6-11: Spectra from HID regions 17 and 20 (crosses) and fitted models (histograms) consisting
of a disk blackbody and blackbody. The ratio of residuals to error bars shows a narrow edge or line-
like feature above 10 keV.
6.8. SUMMARY
101
factorally fit the lower portion of the track (rank number 14 and greater). In addition no single
or double-component model was found that could reproduce the unusual feature above 10 keV. For
example, a broken power law (model with two different slopes above and below a cutoff energy) fails
to account for the more step-like nature of the feature.
6.8 Summary
Although color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams for Cir X-1 are complicated by absorption
dips and shifting spectral tracks, the source clearly traces out a complete Z-source track during
short time segments (hours). Power spectra taken from regions of the HID track show continuous
evolution from the narrow QPO (increasing in frequency from 12–30 Hz) on the horizontal branch,
to the broad 4 Hz QPO on the normal branch, to only very low frequency noise on the flaring branch.
Flaring-branch light curves show high levels of variability due to "mini-flares".
The energy spectrum on the horizontal branch is fit well with a two-component model consisting
of a soft disk blackbody and a harder blackbody (presumably from closer to the surface). In this
model, motion along the HB is mainly associated with an increasing inner radius of the disk (in-
creasing disk blackbody normalization). This would imply that, as the luminosity increases across
the HB, the inner edge of the disk is pushed further away from the surface. It is not clear how this is
related to the increasing QPO frequency, which would typically be expected to require a decreasing
radius if the QPOs were related to Keplerian motion at the inner edge of the disk. Energy spectra
on the normal branch indicate that the hard blackbody fades away, leaving only the disk blackbody.
On the lower NB, a feature in the spectrum develops above 10 keV. This feature becomes more
prominent on the flaring branch. Although, there is still much to be understood about the physical
mechanisms responsible for the spectral and timing evolution of Cir X-1 around the HID diagram,
these results have demonstrated the specific timing and spectral properties associated with each
branch.
102
CHAPTER 6. CORRELATED TIMING AND SPECTRAL BEHAVIOR
Chapter 7
Absorption Dips
7.1 Overview
RXTE All-Sky Monitor light curves of Cir X-1 show that dips occur near phase zero of the 16.55-
day cycle of the source (Chapter 3). RXTE Proportional Counter Array observations carried out
between 1996 September 20–22 provided 60% observing efficiency for 48 hours around phase zero
(study D, see Figure 3-5). These observations showed significant dipping activity during much of
those two days. We have studied the dramatic spectral evolution associated with the dips, and show
that the spectrum throughout the dips is well-fit by variable and at times heavy absorption of a
bright component, plus a faint component that is only weakly absorbed. We also show that an iron
emission line near 6.5 keV present during dips maintains a constant absolute flux level outside the
dips as well, indicating that the line is associated with the faint component. We suggest that these
results are consistent with a model in which the bright component is reprocessed by a scattering
medium, only slightly modifying the spectral shape, but adding an iron line due to fluorescence.
These results are also generally consistent with a spectral study based on ASCA observations of a
low-to-high transition in Cir X-1 [12], where the spectrum was fit with a partial-covering model.
7.2 Dips in RXTE Light Curves
Light curves from the ASM and PCA show that the intensity of Cir X-1 drops below the 1 Crab
baseline near phase zero of most (possibly all) cycles. These low-intensity episodes, which we refer
to as "dips", are brief compared to the 16.55-d cycle, lasting as short as seconds (e.g., Figure 6-5)
and as long as half a day (e.g., Figure 7-1). They often show abrupt transitions (rise or fall times
103
104
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
much smaller than the total duration), and are characterized by specific spectral evolution which
we describe in detail below. During the strongest dips observed in PCA observations, the intensity
dropped to levels more than a factor of 10 below the baseline level (2–90 keV). Dips in the ASM
light curves (2–12 keV) reached similar levels (i.e., as low as ∼80 mCrab).
The dips most often occurred during the half day before and after phase zero, but also sometimes
continued through day 1.5 in ASM data and day 2.5 in PCA data. On a couple of occasions, dips
also occurred at later phases in the ASM light curve, e.g., near day 4 of the cycle. Dips occurred in
all six cycles of Cir X-1 for which we obtained PCA observations during the half day before phase
zero (see Figure 3-5). All-Sky Monitor light curves of Cir X-1 show intensity points below the 1 Crab
baseline in about half of the cycles observed (see section 2.4). Because ASM coverage is incomplete
(about ten to twelve 90-s exposures per day), it is possible that dips might actually occur in all
cycles.
The PCA observations (study D) made during 1996 September 20–22 (Figure 7-1) covered a
48-hour period around phase zero (with ∼60% observing efficiency) and showed significant dipping
for about half of the observed time. These observations provided the opportunity to study dipping
behavior in detail, and are thus the focus of this chapter. Dips in other cycles have also been
examined and show similar behavior to that presented below.
The observations shown in Figure 7-1 began about a half day before phase zero. The intensity of
Cir X-1 was very low (an extended dip) during the first half day of the observations, and then returned
to the much higher "quiescent" level shortly after phase zero. During the half day immediately
following phase zero, the intensity underwent shorter intermittent dips. The strongest dips all
reached similar minimum levels of about 200–350 counts/s/PCU (2–18 keV) after background (∼10
c/s/PCU) was subtracted. A second episode of significant extended dipping occurred from about
0.5 to 0.9 days after phase zero, followed by flaring-state activity for the remaining half day of the
observation. The flaring state is characterized by (1) a gradual increase of the average intensity
in the low-energy PCA bands (which then dominate the total PCA count rate) accompanied by a
significant drop in the high-energy bands and (2) individual flares on shorter timescales (less than
a few hours) which show increased intensity in all PCA energy bands. The spectral and timing
evolution during the flaring state of Cir X-1 was discussed in Chapters 5 and 6.
7.3 Evolution of Hardness Ratios During Dips
Three dips in Figure 7-1 have been identified for further study (Dips 1–3). A 4000-s segment of
Figure 7-1 is shown for each of these dips in Figures 7-2, 7-3, and 7-4. The light curves in multiple
7.3. EVOLUTION OF HARDNESS RATIOS DURING DIPS
105
Figure 7-1: Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios for PCA observations of
Cir X-1 from 1996 September 20–22, covering a two-day period around phase zero (φ = 0). Three
dips have been identified for further study. Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted
data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2. Ratios of the intensities produce soft (I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV])
and hard (I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV]) hardness ratios. The intensity levels of the segment at
day ∼347.2 (after Dip 1) are close to the level in each band during the quiescent phases of the orbit.
106
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Figure 7-2: Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 1. Time zero corresponds to day 347.041 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness ratio points
are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from two 96-s time segments (A and
B), indicated by dotted vertical lines, and four 16-s segments (a–d) indicated by diamonds.
7.3. EVOLUTION OF HARDNESS RATIOS DURING DIPS
107
Figure 7-3: Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 2. Time zero corresponds to day 347.254 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness ratio points
are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from two 304-s time segments (A and
B), indicated by dotted vertical lines, and four 16-s segments (a–d), indicated by diamonds.
108
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Figure 7-4: Light curves in four energy channels and two hardness ratios spanning 4000 s including
Dip 3. Time zero corresponds to day 347.325 in Figure 7-1. The intensity and hardness ratio points
are the same as in Figure 7-1. Energy spectra were extracted from six 16-s time segments (a–f),
indicated by diamonds.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
109
PCA energy channels show that the transitions into and out of dips occur more rapidly at low energy
that in higher energy bands (best demonstrated by the gradual ingress of Dip 3 in Figure 7-4), thus
hardness ratios initially increase (harden) as the denominator falls more quickly than the numerator.
Low energy count rates are also the first to reach a fixed bottom level. This causes hardness ratios
to decrease (soften) since the denominator approaches a constant while the numerator continues to
decrease.
The intensity and hardness ratios from Dip 3 (the last 1716 s of data in Figure 7-4) have been
used to produce color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams (CDs/HIDs), shown in Figure 7-5. The
spectral evolution during the dip produces tracks with dramatic bends in both the CD and the
HID. A similar CD and HID has also been produced for the first three segments of Figure 7-1 (day
346.31–346.52), during which the intensity was mostly in an extended low/dip state (Figure 7-6).
In the HIDs of Figures 7-5 and 7-6, dips produce motion to the left (toward lower intensity)
and initially upward (harder), but turn downward (softer) when the count rate in the denominator
reaches its bottom level. In the CDs (most prominently in Figure 7-6), since two hardness ratios are
employed (hard and soft color), motion is initially to the right and upward (harder in both colors
but mostly in the lower channels). When the lowest channel reaches the bottom level, the track
turns to the left but continues upward. When intermediate channels stop decreasing and only the
highest channels still drop, the track finally turns downward. The intensity of the second lowest
energy band rapidly drops by a factor of two (at time 3500 s in Figure 7-4) just before settling to
its lowest level; this resulted in a gap in the the middle CD branch in Figure 7-5.
Evolution of the position in CDs and HIDs apart from dips is interpreted in Chapters 5 and 6
as motion around a "Z" track as well as shifts of the entire "Z" pattern. The exact position of a
dip track in the diagrams depends on its starting point, i.e., the baseline intensity and spectrum.
Although starting from different positions, all dips we have observed in RXTE light curves of Cir X-1
produce the same general shape in CDs and HIDs (but not always complete tracks if dips are weak).
7.4 Evolution of Energy Spectra During Dips
7.4.1 Spectral Model
Cold (neutral) matter most effectively absorbs photons at lower energies, so obscuration by cold
matter produces dips that are more gradual at high energy than at low energy, as we observe in
Cir X-1. However the fact that strong dips in Cir X-1 appear to "bottom-out" well above background
suggests the presence of a faint component unaffected by the dips. Thus, in modeling spectra of dips
in Cir X-1, at least two components are necessary: (1) a bright component modified by variable and
110
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Figure 7-5: Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams for the last 1716 s of data in Figure 7-4,
during which the intensity gradually transitioned from the non-dip baseline to the bottom of a dip.
Intensity is I [2.0–18 keV], and the hardness ratios are defined as soft color: I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–
4.8 keV], hard color: I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV], and broad color: I [6.3–18 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV].
Each point represents 16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
111
Figure 7-6: Color-color and hardness-intensity diagrams for the first three segments in Figure 7-1
(day 346.31–346.52), during which Cir X-1 was in an extended low/dip state. Intensity is I [2.0–
18 keV], and the hardness ratios are defined as soft color: I [4.8–6.3 keV] / I [2.0–4.8 keV], hard
color: I [13–18 keV] / I [6.3–13 keV], and broad color: I [6.3–18 keV] / I [2.0–6.3 keV]. Each point
represents 16 s of background-subtracted data from PCUs 0, 1, and 2.
112
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
at times very heavy absorption and (2) a faint component seen through a constant and relatively
low column density. For simplicity, we assume that the spectral shape of the two components are
similar, as might be the case if the faint component is due to scattering (e.g., by a corona, stellar
wind, etc.) of the main bright component back into the line of sight from other initial emission
directions. (Although the terms "direct" and "scattered" components would be more physical, we
will continue to use the terms "bright" and "faint" since they do not tie the discussion to a particular
assumed model.)
From a study of the energy spectrum during non-dip observations (Chapter 6), we found that
the 2.5–25 keV spectrum of Cir X-1 was generally fit well with a model consisting of a multi-
temperature "disk blackbody" plus a hard blackbody. Thus, we adopt this model for the bright
component during dips and constrain the faint component to use the same model parameters, but
with the flux multiplied by a constant factor f which is less than unity.
The absorption column density for the faint component is assumed to remain constant throughout
a dip, but the column density for the bright component is allowed to vary to produce the dips.
The light curves during strong dips show a significant reduction in intensity even at high energy
(13–18 keV), indicating very high column densities (NH > 1024 cm−2). Photo-electric absorption
is the dominant process responsible for dips at low energy, but the photo-electric cross-section
decreases with energy. Thus, above about 10 keV, Thomson scattering (with an approximately
energy-independent cross section) becomes important. Both photo-electric and Thomson cross-
sections are included in the absorption calculation for the bright component. The complete model
used can then be expressed as:
F =hexp(−σphNH
(1)) exp(−σT hNH
(1)) + exp(−σphNH
(2))fi M,
(7.1)
where F is the observed flux, σph and σT h are the photo-electric and Thomson cross-sections,
(2) are the effective hydrogen column densities of the bright and faint components
(1) and NH
NH
respectively, f is the ratio of the flux of the faint component to that of bright component, and M is
the disk blackbody plus blackbody model.
7.4.2 Spectral Fitting Strategy
Because dip spectra are composed of multiple components (variably absorbed and faint manifes-
tations of the disk blackbody and blackbody) we make use of joint fits of spectra from inside and
outside dips to simultaneously constrain the parameters of the various components. The combined
χ2 value obtained when the model is fit to multiple spectra is minimized by varying the model pa-
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
113
rameters, but allowing only the absorption column density of the bright component to vary between
spectra. Since the disk blackbody and blackbody parameters typically evolve on timescales of hours
(see Chapter 6), it is important to compare spectra during a dip to spectra immediately outside the
dip.
In order to perform joint spectral fits, we extracted PCA energy spectra from time segments
before and during the three dips shown in Figures 7-2, 7-3, and 7-4. The same procedure for
constructing and fitting PCA spectra presented in sections 6.5 and 6.6 is used here as well (comparing
results from PCUs 0, 1, and 4).
7.4.3 Energy Spectra Inside and Outside Dips
We compiled spectra from a 96-s time segments immediately prior to Dip 1 and from another 96-s
segment during the lowest portion of Dip 1 (segments labeled "A" and "B" in Figure 7-2). Likewise,
we selected a 304-s segment from before Dip 2, and other segment of the same duration from the
lowest portion of that dip (segments "A" and "B" in Figure 7-3). These spectra are shown in Figures
7-7 and 7-8 (top panels), along with fitted curves using the model described above (equation 7.1).
The best-fitting parameters for the bright and faint component of each fit are listed in the first two
(2)) of the faint component is given in the table. The
(1)) of the bright component differs for spectra A and B of each fit and is thus
lines of Table 7.1. The column density (NH
column density (NH
given separately in Table 7.2.
The disk blackbody and blackbody parameters for both dips are similar to those obtained for
non-dip spectra in Chapter 6 (temperatures of 1.5 keV and 2.2 keV respectively). The flux of the
faint component is 10–11% that of the bright component (f ). The column density of the faint
component is very low, and consistent with zero. This low value is inconsistent with estimates of the
interstellar column density measured with ASCA and ROSAT (NH =1.8–2.4×1022 cm−2) [12, 56].
This may indicate that the spectral shape of the faint component is not exactly the same as that
of the bright component.
If scattering is responsible for the faint component, then this process
might distort the spectrum slightly toward lower energy, thereby giving the appearance of reduced
interstellar absorption. The use of different spectral models for the bright and faint components
becomes unproductive due to the large number of parameters involved, so we allow the column
density of the faint component to account for small difference in spectral shape.
114
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Figure 7-7: Top: Spectral fits for 96-s segments prior to Dip 1 (spectrum A) and during Dip 1 (spec-
trum B). Bottom: same spectra and model (see text), but with a Gaussian emission-line component
included to fit the peaked residuals near 6.5 keV. The data shown are from PCU 0 only.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
115
Figure 7-8: Top: Spectral fits for 304-s segments prior to Dip 2 (spectrum A) and during Dip 2
(spectrum B). Bottom: same spectra and model (see text), but with a Gaussian emission-line com-
ponent included to fit the peaked residuals near 6.5 keV. The data shown are from PCU 0 only.
116
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Disk Blackbody 3
Tin
Rin cos1/2 θ
Blackbody 4
R
T
Faint Component
Joint
fit1
1A–B
2A–B
1A–B
2A–B
1a–d
2a–d
3a–f
Iron
Line 2
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
(keV)
1.51+0.10
−0.17
1.51+0.04
−0.06
1.23+0.22
−0.15
1.35+0.06
−0.05
1.18+0.19
−0.16
1.26+0.14
−0.14
1.07+0.08
−0.09
(km)
(keV)
(km)
16.94+3.96
−2.20
17.54+1.25
−0.87
25.32+8.56
−7.03
22.45+1.83
−1.69
27.04+9.39
−6.33
25.12+7.66
−5.20
42.66+8.34
−6.60
2.20+0.62
−0.42
2.32+0.16
−0.15
1.79+0.33
−0.16
2.10+0.12
−0.09
1.72+0.22
−0.12
2.08+0.25
−0.15
1.74+0.09
−0.09
3.77+3.33
−2.55
3.47+0.86
−0.76
7.87+3.34
−4.14
5.23+0.92
−0.93
8.22+2.69
−3.03
5.46+1.08
−1.08
9.23+1.41
−1.32
f 5
0.107+0.005
−0.006
0.103+0.003
−0.003
0.096+0.007
−0.006
0.092+0.002
−0.002
0.103+0.009
−0.011
0.117+0.013
−0.014
0.054+0.005
−0.005
N (2)
H /1022 6
(cm−2)
0.00+0.07
−0.00
0.03+0.28
−0.03
0.00+0.10
−0.00
0.00+0.10
−0.00
0.00+0.44
−0.00
0.15+0.70
−0.15
0.00+0.14
−0.00
7
χ2
r
3.89–4.07
7.58–7.84
1.44–1.62
1.87–2.15
0.99–1.20
0.80–1.12
1.27–1.34
joint fit parameters of the bright and faint components of spectra from
Table 7.1: Top group:
outside (A) and inside (B) dips 1 and 2. Middle group: the same, but with an added Gaussian line.
Third group: joint fit parameters for the four to six 16-s spectra for dips 1, 2, and 3. The absorption
parameters (N (1)
H ) for the bright component are given in Tables 7.2 (A–B) & 7.4 (a-f) and the iron
line parameters are given in Table 7.3.
Spectrum
N (1)
H /1022
(cm−2)
Spectrum
N (1)
H /1022
(cm−2)
No Gaussian
1A
1B
1A
1B
2.83+0.57
−0.43
176+12
−13
2A
2B
With Gaussian
2A
2B
3.81+0.71
−0.81
184+15
−14
3.50+0.29
−0.34
306+21
−19
4.30+0.26
−0.26
283+16
−14
Table 7.2: Effective hydrogen column density of the bright component outside (A) and inside (B)
Dips 1 and 2 (from fits with and without a ∼6.5 keV Gaussian emission line).
1 In joint fits (using the model given in equation 7.1), only the column density (N (1)
H ) of the bright component
is allowed to vary between spectra (see Tables 7.2 and 7.4). Errors quoted are 90% confidence limits for a single
parameter (∆χ2 = 2.7).
2 A Gaussian emission line (∼6.5 keV) was included in the final five fits (see Table 7.3).
3 For the disk blackbody, the inner radius of the accretion disk (times cos1/2 θ, where θ is the disk inclination angle
and θ = 0 is parallel to the line of sight) is given for a distance of 8 kpc.
4The blackbody radius is given assuming a distance of 8 kpc.
5 The bright and faint components are assumed to have the same disk blackbody and blackbody parameters, but
the faint component is scaled down by a factor f .
6 Absorption column density on the faint component (Hydrogen atoms per cm2).
7 Reduced χ2 = χ2/dof , where dof = degrees of freedom = the number of spectral bins (∼54/spectrum) minus
the number of fit parameters.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
117
The column density of the bright component outside dips (spectra 1A and 2A; see Table 7.2)
is about 3×1022 cm−2, just slightly above the interstellar value. The column density during the
low segments of dips (spectra 1B and 2B) is extremely high: 184×1022 cm−2 for spectrum 1B
and 283×1022 cm−2 for spectrum 2B. This high column density value is required to produce the
observed reduction in flux at 20 keV and is sufficient to render the absorbed component totally
negligible at lower energies. Thus, the flux in spectra 1B and 2B below 5 keV is due entirely to the
faint component.
7.4.4
Iron Emission Line
The fits for both dips show similar residuals for the spectra from outside and inside the dip (Figures 7-
7 and 7-8). These residuals are also similar to those obtained in fits of spectra from the horizontal
branch or upper normal branch in the study in Chapter 6. In particular, the fits of these spectra
all show peaked residuals near 6.5 keV. In the two spectra from the bottom of dips (spectra 1B
and 2B), the feature is prominently visible as a "bump" in the spectra themselves (see Figures 7-7
and 7-8). The parameters of this feature are best constrained when only the faint component is
present. The line component is probably from iron Kα emission, which occurs at 6.4 keV for neutral
iron and higher energy for ionized iron. The fact that these residuals in the dip spectra are very
similar in absolute flux level to the residuals immediately outside the dips strongly suggests that
the line feature is associated with the faint component. For example, iron fluorescence might occur
during the scattering process.
Based on the similar peaked residuals inside and outside the dips, a Gaussian emission line
component was added near 6.5 keV (see the bottom panels of Figures 7-7 and 7-8). The addition
of the line does reduce the peaked residuals near 6.5 keV, but does not improve the residuals (of
similar strength but indicating data below the model) between 4–5 keV. The results of the joint fits,
now including the Gaussian line, are listed in the second group in Tables 7.1 and 7.2, showing that
the other model parameters are generally consistent with the previous fits within the 90% confidence
limits. Table 7.1 also shows that a significant improvement in the reduced χ2 value was achieved in
both cases. We will continue to include a Gaussian line in all subsequent fits.
The parameters for the Gaussian line are shown in Table 7.3. Although the best-fitting centroid
energy of the line is close to 6.6 keV, the Gaussian width is large (probably due to the relatively
coarse energy resolution of the PCA: ∼1 keV FWHM at 6 keV), so that we cannot confirm whether
the line is from neutral or partially ionized iron or whether it is actually composed of multiple
unresolved narrow lines.
118
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
E
(keV)
Joint
Fit
1A–B 6.59+0.12
−0.13
2A–B 6.58+0.06
−0.07
6.59+0.16
1a–d
−0.15
6.45+0.16
2a–d
−0.20
6.46+0.23
3a–f
−0.27
σ
normalization
(keV)
(photons cm−2 s−1)
0.18+0.28
−0.18
0.29+0.10
−0.13
0.13+0.29
−0.13
0.47+0.29
−0.32
0.39+0.32
−0.39
0.018+0.007
−0.004
0.016+0.002
−0.002
0.015+0.002
−0.002
0.025+0.012
−0.008
0.012+0.004
−0.003
Table 7.3: Gaussian emission-line parameters for the joint fits of spectra outside and inside dips
(A–B) and during entry into a dip (a–d, a–f). In each case, the same Gaussian line parameters were
used for each spectrum in a joint fit.
7.4.5 Spectral Evolution During Dip Transitions
Through its large collecting area, the PCA provides good-quality spectra of bright sources such as
Cir X-1 every 16 s. This enables us to study the detailed evolution of the spectrum during the
transitions between the high and low states outside and inside dips. We selected four to six 16-s
segments from the ingress of Dips 1, 2 and 3 (indicated as diamonds on Figures 7-2, 7-3, and 7-4).
The 16-s spectra from each of these dips are shown in Figures 7-9, 7-10, and 7-11, along with the
model curves from joint fits of the 4–6 spectra of each dip.
As expected from the light curves of the dips (Figures 7-2, 7-3, and 7-4), the intensity in each
case initially decreases at low energy, but then reaches a fixed level while the intensity at higher
energy continues to decrease. Intermediate spectra in each figure show a "step" near 7.1 keV, which
cannot be accounted for solely by the emission line, but is naturally fit by the iron K absorption
edge of the absorption component and indicates a column density of NH > few×1023. As discussed
above, the intensity at the bottom of the dip is significantly reduced (relative to outside the dip)
even at 20 keV due to Thomson scattering,
The fit parameters for the bright and faint components in each joint fit of the 16-s spectra (1a–d,
2a–d, and 3a–f) are shown in Table 7.1. The flux in the faint component relative to the bright
component ranges from 5% and 12% in these fits, and the column density for the faint component
is again consistent with zero. The Gaussian line parameters for these fits are listed in Table 7.3,
and indicate a line centered at 6.4–6.6 keV. The best-fitting normalization (absolute flux) of the line
differs by a factor of two among the three dips but is consistent with no change within the errors.
For each set of spectra, the variable absorption column density of the bright component is shown in
Table 7.4. In each case the column density increases from a relatively low value (NH = 4–9×1022)
at the start of a dip to very high values (NH > 1024) at the lowest part of the dips.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
119
Figure 7-9:
Spectral fits for four 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 1. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the four jointly-fit curves. The data shown
are from PCU 0 only.
120
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Figure 7-10:
Spectral fits for four 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 2. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the four jointly-fit curves. The data shown
are from PCU 0 only.
7.4. EVOLUTION OF ENERGY SPECTRA DURING DIPS
121
Figure 7-11:
Spectral fits for six 16-s segments (a–d) during the decline into Dip 3. Only the
column density of the bright component varies between the six jointly-fit curves. The data shown
are from PCU 0 only.
122
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Spectrum
1a
1b
1c
1d
N (1)
H /1022
(cm−2)
4.16+1.10
−0.75
25.8+1.6
−1.3
43.6+1.7
−2.1
129+8
−8
Spectrum
2a
2b
2c
2d
N (1)
H /1022
(cm−2)
8.84+1.37
−1.09
25.8+1.4
−1.5
64.0+2.4
−2.5
242+83
−52
Spectrum
3a
3b
3c
3d
3e
3f
N (1)
H /1022
(cm−2)
8.31+1.09
−0.96
15.7+1.0
−1.1
33.2+1.4
−1.5
66.7+1.6
−1.5
127+8
−7
> 2×104
Table 7.4: Effective hydrogen column density responsible for the variable absorption in the bright
component, due to photo-electric absorption and Thompson scattering, during 16-s spectra from
Dips 1, 2, and 3.
These fits show that the model developed above, where only the absorption column density on
the bright component varies between all spectra of a given dip, is quite successful in reproducing
the evolution of the spectrum throughout the dips.
7.5 Discussion
The spectral evolution during dips in Cir X-1 produces curved tracks in CDs and HIDs. By identi-
fying these tracks we can exclude absorption dip behavior from analysis intended to study Z-source
spectral tracks, as we have done in Chapter 6.
Similar absorption-dip behavior was recently observed in RXTE observations of the black-hole
candidates GRO J1655-40 and 4U 1630-47 [36, 74]. Dips in these sources show evidence for a faint
unabsorbed component and produced curved tracks in CDs and HIDs similar to those we observe
in Cir X-1.
Spectral analysis from an ASCA observation of Cir X-1 during an intensity transition also showed
evidence for an unabsorbed component [12]. A partial-covering model was used to fit the energy
spectrum (with two blackbodies), but it was noted that the model could be interpreted as a direct
component plus a scattered component. The ASCA spectra also showed an iron K edge due to
absorption with column densities near 1024 cm−2. Thus our results are generally consistent with
the ASCA results, but we are able to demonstrate how the continuum spectrum evolves throughout
dips.
An iron line at 6.4 keV was seen in the low-state ASCA spectrum, but no line was detected at
a similar flux level in the high-state spectrum [12]. Our analysis shows that an iron emission line
appears to be associated with the faint component, and is present outside dips at the same flux level.
7.5. DISCUSSION
123
Since scattering by an extended cloud of material is probably responsible for the faint component,
it is likely that the iron Kα emission is also produced as a result of the scattering process.
The fact that absorption dips in Cir X-1 mainly occur within a day of phase zero and are then
followed by significant flaring, suggests that the dips are associated with the mass transfer process.
Thus, absorption might be due to the mass transfer stream itself or due to a bulge on the disk
produced by the addition of matter. The intermittent nature of the PCA light curves near phase
zero (Figure 7-1) indicate that we are observing the fine structure (temporal or geometrical) of the
obscuring material.
124
CHAPTER 7. ABSORPTION DIPS
Chapter 8
Multi-frequency Observations
8.1 Overview
The 16.55-d X-ray period of Cir X-1 is also seen in the radio, infrared, and optical bands (see
Chapter 1). We organized two multi-frequency campaigns, in 1996 May and 1997 June, to study
correlated variability in different frequency bands. Such observations have the potential to constrain
emission mechanisms and provide information about the mass accretion rate. For example, in
Z source LMXBs the optical flux is believed to result from higher energy photons being reprocessed
in the accretion disk. Thus optical intensity is taken as a measure of mass accretion rate, and
has been used to argue that mass accretion rate increases along Z source spectral tracks from the
horizontal branch, down the normal branch, and onto the flaring branch [28, 2].
8.2 May 1996 Campaign
The first campaign (see Table 8.1) occurred during 1996 May 7–14, covering a week including phase
zero on May 11.413 UT (JD 2450214.913). Radio observations were made from South Africa with
the 28-m dish at Hartebeeshoek Radio Astronomical Observatory (HartRAO) by George Nicolson.
Infrared observations were made with the 1.9-m telescope at the South African Astronomical Obser-
vatory (SAAO) by Ian Glass. In addition to the ongoing All-Sky Monitor observations, seven RXTE
PCA (and HEXTE) observations were made with a combined exposure time of 54 kiloseconds.
125
126
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
Figure 8-1: X-ray, IR, and radio light curves of Cir X-1 from 1996 May 7–17. Phase zero is indicated
by the vertical dotted line at day 214.413 (1997 May 11.413). PCA intensity is from the 2–32 keV
band (16-s bins) and ASM intensity is from 2–12 keV (90-s exposures). Errors on the PCA data are
negligible. Typical error bars are shown for the ASM, IR, and radio data: errors on the ASM data
are typically 2–5 c/s, on the IR data are typically about 0.03 magnitudes (worse on days 214 & 215),
and on the radio data are about 30 mJy. The average quiescent level of 29 mJy has been subtracted
from the radio data. (Data provided by I. Glass (IR), G. Nicolson (radio), and the RXTE /ASM
team.)
8.2. MAY 1996 CAMPAIGN
127
Frequency
Band
Radio
IR
X-ray
X-ray
Observatory
Type of
Observation
HartRAO
8.5 GHz (3 samples/d)
SAAO (1.9 m)
RXTE
RXTE
8.5 GHz & 5.0 GHz
K-band photometry
ASM
PCA
Dates
ongoing
May 10–15
May (7),8–12,(13)
ongoing
May 7–14
Table 8.1: Multi-frequency Observations of Cir X-1 from 1996 May. Dates in parentheses were
cancelled due to poor weather conditions.
8.2.1 Radio (HartRAO)
Radio intensity measurements of Cir X-1 at 8.5 GHz (3.5 cm) are routinely carried out as often as sev-
eral times daily at HartRAO. In recent years the periodic flares have been weak, i.e. no flares above
100 mJy, compared to 200 mJy – 2 Jy between 1976–1986 (1 Jansky = 1 Jy = 10−26 W m−2 Hz−1).
In fact, radio flares since 1986 have not been strong enough to update the radio ephemeris.
In conjunction with our multi-frequency campaign, HartRAO observations were made 12–20
times per day at both 8.5 GHz and 5.0 GHz from 1996 May 10–15 and 5–7 times per day at 8.5 GHz
for several days prior to and after that period. Each measurement takes about 8 minutes. The
observations are made as drift scans, i.e., the telescope is stationary during a scan, which begins
pointing ahead of the source. Because Cir X-1 lies in the Galactic plane, there is strong confusion
from other sources such as H II regions and the supernova remnant with which Cir X-1 is associated.
A quiescent average scan is subtracted from the data and then fit the telescope beam pattern at the
position of Cir X-1. This method gives a residual flux relative to the quiescent background rather
than the absolute flux, but is sufficient to monitor the flaring behavior.
The 8.5 GHz data from JD-2450000.5 = 210–219 are shown in Figure 8-1. The error on a
typical point is about 30 mJy (1 σ). The average flux from observations between phase 0.2 to 1.0
is 29 mJy, and has been subtracted from the data. There is no evidence for variability during that
phase interval. Between days 215.5–218.0 (phase ∼0.05–0.2) the flux is higher. After subtracting
the 29 mJy quiescent level from the data, then 66% of the data points lie between 2–5 sigma above
the noise of 19 mJy. This is consistent with weak flaring observed in other cycles from earlier in
1996, but flaring may be occurring earlier in the cycle than the corresponding period in 1995, when
the flaring was between phases 0.2–0.3.
128
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
8.2.2
Infrared Photometry (SAAO)
The infrared observations at SAAO provided K band (2.2 µm) photometry measurements 4–32 times
per night for five nights from 1996 May 8–12 (see Figure 8-1). An aperture of 9 arcsec diameter
was used. The K magnitude was 11.2 on May 8–9 (day 211–212) and gradually brightened by
about 1 magnitude during May 10–12 (day 213–215) to 10.15 (K = 0 mag corresponds to a flux
density of 6.3 × 10−23 W m−2 Hz−1, and other magnitudes are related to flux through m2 − m1 =
−2.5 log[F2/F1]). The quiescent and flaring magnitudes are similar to those obtained by Glass
during 1980–1993, but are somewhat lower than the high values (K=9.5 to 7.7) observed in the
late 1970's [24]. Observing conditions during the first two and last nights were good and the errors
are 0.03 mag or better. The data suggest a possible precursor event during day 214; however the
observing conditions were not as good during the third and fourth nights. When the conditions were
bad, Cir X-1 was measured relative to star J from the image in Whelan et al. [83], which was used
as a standard taken to be K=9.82.
8.2.3 Correlated Multi-frequency Variability
The X-ray and radio light curves in Figure 8-1 reach a peak value during the second day after phase
zero, while the IR reaches a peak value only 0.5 d after phase zero. The PCA and IR data both
show evidence for increasing variability before phase zero. Furthermore, both show a gradual rise
in intensity during the period from day 213.0 to 213.15, shown in more detail in Figure 8-2. Fourier
power spectra from each of the five PCA segments in Figure 8-2 show a narrow quasi-periodic
oscillation peak at 26.0 Hz, 24.2 Hz, 25.4 Hz, 31.54 Hz, and 37.61 Hz (in time order of the five
segments). This timing behavior indicates that increasing X-ray intensity corresponds to motion to
the right or down the horizontal branch in a hardness-intensity diagram (see Chapters 5 & 6 and
[63]). Thus, this segment shows IR flux increasing from the horizontal branch toward the normal
branch, similar to the optical trend in Z sources [28, 2].
8.3 June 1997 Campaign
The second campaign (see Table 8.2) occurred during 1997 June 4–22, covering a half cycle before
and after phase zero on June 12.506 UT (JD 2450612.006). Radio observations were made from South
Africa at Hartebeeshoek Radio Astronomical Observatory (HartRAO) by George Nicolson. Infrared
photometry measurements were made with the 1.9-m telescope at the South African Astronomical
Observatory (SAAO) by Ian Glass.
IR spectroscopy at the the ANU 2.3 m telescope in Siding
Springs, Australia and optical spectroscopy at the Anglo-Australian Telescope (AAT, 3.9 m) were
8.3. JUNE 1997 CAMPAIGN
129
Figure 8-2: X-ray and IR light curves of Cir X-1 from day 212.93–213.19. X-ray intensity is from
the 2–32 keV PCA band (16-s bins). A typical IR error bar of +/−0.03 magnitudes is shown. (IR
data courtesy of I. Glass.)
130
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
Frequency
Band
Radio
IR
Optical
X-ray
Observatory
Type of
Observation
HartRAO
8.5 GHz & 5.0 GHz
SAAO (1.9 m) K-band photometry
ANU (2.3 m) K-band spectroscopy
AAT (3.9 m)
spectroscopy
RXTE
ASM
Dates
ongoing
June (10–14),15–16
June (12),20
June 4,(12)
ongoing
PCA (samples)
June 4,6,8,18,19,20
PCA (∼continuous)
June 11–17
Table 8.2: Multi-frequency Observations of Cir X-1 from 1997 June. Dates in parentheses were
cancelled due to poor weather conditions.
carried out by Rob Fender, Kinwah Wu, and Helen Johnston. In addition to the ongoing All-Sky
Monitor observations, extensive RXTE PCA (and HEXTE) observations were made, with 56%
coverage over 7 days around phase zero, and shorter observations before and after that week. The
X-ray observations for this campaign are discussed in Chapter 6.
8.3.1 Radio (HartRAO)
In conjunction with our multi-frequency campaign, coverage during the ongoing radio (8.5 GHz and
5.0 GHz) monitoring at HartRAO was increased. The 5.0 GHz radio data for 1997 May – August
are shown in Figure 8-3, along with the ASM light curve and the PCA data from the 1997 June
observations (study G) and the brief observations from 1997 May (study F). As in the previous
year, the radio intensity was faint with only minimal variability (a constant DC bias level has again
been subtracted). However, in at least two cycles (starting at days 611 and 661), including the cycle
that was the main focus of this multi-frequency campaign, there does appear to be weak evidence
for flaring at about the same time as the X-ray flaring observed with the PCA and ASM.
8.3.2
IR Photometry (SAAO)
Infrared photometry observations (see section 8.2.2) were scheduled at SAAO for seven nights, from
1997 June 10–16 (JD-2450000.5 = 609–615). Due to poor weather conditions, only limited data were
obtained, shown in Table 8.3. On June 14, the JHK magnitudes are similar to typical peak values
observed since 1980. On June 15, the K magnitude is about 0.5 mag lower, but still well above the
typical quiescent value of K≈11.5.
8.3. JUNE 1997 CAMPAIGN
131
Figure 8-3: X-ray (PCA and ASM) and radio (5.0 GHz) light curves of Cir X-1 from 1997 May 7 –
August 25. Phase zero is indicated by the vertical dotted lines. PCA intensity is from the 2–32 keV
band (16-s bins) and ASM intensity is from 2–12 keV (90-s exposures). Errors on the PCA data
are negligible and errors on the ASM data are typically 2–5 c/s. For each 16.55-d cycle, the average
radio flux for the phase interval 0.3 to 0.9 of that cycle was subtracted from the data; the bias
removed was typically 50–60 mJy and a typical error bar is shown. (The radio data was provided
by G. Nicolson, and ASM data by the RXTE /ASM team. The PCA data are from studies F and
G; see Table 3.1.)
132
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
J
H
11.97
10.68
JD
2450614.35
.42
.48
2450615.41
L
8.98
K
9.88
9.88
9.85
10.34
Table 8.3: Infrared JHKL photometry measurements from 1997 June 14 & 15. Errors are +/− 0.03,
except on the L magnitude the error is +/− 0.05.
8.3.3
IR Spectroscopy (ANU)
Infrared K-band spectroscopy was carried out at the ANU 2.3 m telescope at Siding Spring, Australia.
Two nights were scheduled, near phase 0.0 on June 12 and near phase 0.5 on June 20. Observations
on the first night were cancelled due to bad weather, but conditions were more favorable on June 20
and good quality K-band spectra of Cir X-1 were obtained (see Figure 8-4). The spectrum shows H
Brackett γ and HeI emission lines. Both lines are red-shifted by about +430 km/s, and there is a
hint of asymmetry on the blue (shorter wavelength) wing.
8.3.4 Optical Spectroscopy (AAT)
Optical spectroscopy at the Hα region (6100–7200 A) was carried out with the AAT 3.9 m telescope.
Observations were scheduled on two nights, near phase 0.5 on June 4 and near phase 0.0 on June 12.
Like the ANU observations on June 12, the AAT observations on that night were cancelled due to bad
weather. The observations on June 4 were successful, and six good-quality spectra were obtained.
The average spectrum, normalized by the continuum, is shown in Figure 8-5. This spectrum shows
a prominent Hα emission line, as well as weaker He I(6678 A) and He I(7065 A) lines. The Hα
line is asymmetric, as suggested by previous observations [17, 47, 53, 83], and can be fit well by
two Gaussians lines: a broad component blue-shifted from the rest wavelength by -300 km/s and
a narrow component red-shifted from the rest wavelength by +375 km/s. The two narrow He I
lines are red-shifted by an amount similar to the narrow Hα line, and thus all three show a similar
red-shift to the lines in the IR spectrum in section 8.3.3. All three narrow lines have widths of about
9.5 A, or ∼400 km/s, while the width of the broad Hα component is 46 A, or 2100 km/s.
8.3.5 Comparison of the AAT Optical Spectrum to HST Results
The optical spectrum obtained with AAT during our 1997 June campaign is comparable to the
spectrum of Cir X-1 obtained with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Faint Object Spectrograph
(FOS) in 1995 June by Mignani, Caraveo, & Bignami [47]. The HST spectrum also showed an
8.3. JUNE 1997 CAMPAIGN
133
Figure 8-4:
Infrared spectrum of Cir X-1 from ANU on 1997 June 20 (about phase 0.5), showing
He I (2.06 µm) and H Brackett γ (2.165 µm) emission lines. This spectrum was compiled from the
sum of 16 120-s exposures. (Figure courtesy of H. Johnston.)
134
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
Figure 8-5: Optical spectrum of Cir X-1 from AAT on 1997 June 4 (about phase 0.5), showing a
prominent Hα emission line, as well as weaker He I(6678 A) and He I(7065 A) lines. (Figure courtesy
of H. Johnston.)
8.4. CONCLUSIONS
135
asymmetric Hα emission line, and was likewise fit by a broad and a narrow Gaussian line. The
broad line is centered on the Hα rest wavelength and has a width of 11.4 A. The narrow component
is red-shifted by 380 km/s and has a width of 3.32 A. Based on the HST results, the authors
suggested that the broad line originates in the accretion disk, with temperatures of order ∼20000 K
responsible for its large width. They further suggest that the narrow line arises from a "hot spot"
where the accretion stream from the companion impacts the disk. Thus the narrow line, observed
at phase zero with HST, was expected to be observed at varying blue/red-shifts at other orbital
phases.
The interpretation suggested for the HST spectrum is not compatible with the additional results
obtained with AAT, which show the narrow line at almost the same wavelength as HST, but at
phase 0.5. Furthermore, it is the broad component which has shifted, from the rest wavelength to
−300 km/s blue-shifted. Clearly, further observations at various orbital phases are needed. If the
narrow Hα component, and the other optical and IR lines, prove to be fixed at about +400 km/s,
then that velocity might reflect the radial velocity of the system, providing further support for the
hypothesis that Cir X-1 is a high-velocity runaway from SNR 321.9-0.3. Measuring the velocity of
the shifting broad component might help map the binary orbit, about which very little is securely
known.
8.4 Conclusions
The X-ray light curves of Cir X-1 show significant variability on all time scales down to seconds (and
even shorter time scales including the QPOs). Unfortunately, most observations at other wavelengths
typically provide measurements on timescales of hours, allowing only coarse correlations to be stud-
ied. Yet even those measurement can be quite valuable. For instance, our multi-frequency campaign
from 1996 has shown that according to the ephemeris equation currently in use (equation 1.1), the
X-ray, IR, and radio bands all show enhanced emission within a day of phase zero (all peaking after
phase zero). The 1997 radio data also show weak evidence for flares after phase zero, coincident
with those in the X-ray band. The correlated increase in IR and X-ray intensity over several hours
shown in Figure 8-2 demonstrates the need for observations with improved time-resolution.
Clearly a return of the radio intensity to its previous bright levels would be very useful in
improving the orbital ephemeris equation (i.e., testing the change in period implied by the current
quadratic term.) Bright radio flares would also be able to be studied in much greater detail than the
current marginal detections, allowing short-term correlation with other wavelengths to be explored.
Delays of specific events between wavebands would provide information on how photons are being
136
CHAPTER 8. MULTI-FREQUENCY OBSERVATIONS
reprocessed from one band into another. We continue to maintain a Target of Opportunity proposal
with RXTE to provide X-ray coverage, should bright radio flares return.
As mentioned above, one promising follow-up project to these campaigns is to study the shifting
optical/IR emission lines. If such work can provide information about the binary orbit (through
Doppler mapping), then the X-ray data can be re-examined with more consideration of the geometry
of the system. This work may begin as early as this summer.
A promising radio-interferometry imaging project is the attempt to detect proper motion of
Cir X-1 away from the nearby supernova remnant (SNR), as is expected in the runaway binary
scenario (see Chapter 1). Based on the 700–2000 km/s velocity implied by its distance from the
SNR, and assuming a distance of 8 kpc, suggests that proper motion might be of order 1′′ in 20 yr [67],
which could be detected in only a few years of precise measurements. Confirmation of association
with the SNR, and thus of a young age, would be highly significant to our understanding of the
evolution of the system. Preliminary work has recently been started on this project (by R. Fender
et al.), with Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) images taken to establish the location
of an appropriate point source to use as a reference for proper motion measurements. Such radio
imaging may also provide further information on the jet-like structures seen inside the synchrotron
nebula surrounding Cir X-1.
Chapter 9
Mass Transfer in an Eccentric
Binary
9.1 Overview
Mass transfer in X-ray binaries generally occurs through Roche-lobe overflow or via a stellar wind.
Significant stellar winds only occur in high-mass donor (O or B) stars. Although the X-ray properties
of Cir X-1 most resemble those of a low-mass X-ray binary, the true nature of the donor star and the
mechanism for mass transfer remain uncertain (see section 1.3.6). Furthermore, the high eccentricity
inferred from the 16.55-d intensity cycle of Cir X-1 will have a significant effect on how mass transfer
occurs. In this chapter, I explore the effect of eccentricity on mass transfer through both Roche-lobe
overflow and a stellar wind.
9.2 Mass Transfer via Roche-Lobe Overflow
Mass transfer in most low-mass X-ray binaries is believed to occur through Roche-lobe overflow,
wherein one star fills its critical equipotential surface and matter from the stellar surface streams
through the inner Lagrange (L1) point (a saddle point in the net gravitational and centrifugal
potential between the stars) toward the other star. As matter flows in, the Coriolis force causes it to
orbit the compact object, forming an accretion disk wherein matter loses angular momentum through
viscosity and spirals inward. In an eccentric orbit, the situation is much more complicated, with
such mass transfer limited to the time near periastron passages. To help understand the behavior
of mass transfer in an eccentric binary, I developed a computer code to follow the trajectory of a
137
138
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
test particle started from the surface of a donor star and moving in an eccentric binary system. The
particle was followed until it reaches the neutron-star accretion disk, returns to the donor, or leaves
the system.
9.2.1 Equipotential Surfaces in an Eccentric Binary Orbit
The standard Roche-lobe framework describes the potential of a binary pair of stars in circular orbit,
co-rotating at the orbital frequency. In an eccentric orbit, not only does the separation between
the stars vary, but so does the instantaneous angular frequency of the orbit, making co-rotation
impossible. A generalized Roche potential for centrally condensed stars in an eccentric binary orbit
has been derived by Avni [3]. A Cartesian coordinate system was used, with the origin at the center
of mass of star 1, of mass M1, which rotates with an angular velocity (~ωrot) along the Z axis. The
reference frame rotates about the center of mass of star 1 such that star 2 (of mass M2), always lies
on the +X axis. The potential at a point (X,Y ) is:
ψ = −
GM1
d1 −
GM2
d2
+
GM2
D2 X −
1
2
ω2
rot(X 2 + Y 2)
(9.1)
where d1 and d2 are the distances from (X,Y ) to the center of mass of each star and D is the
instantaneous separation of the stars. To determine the location of the instantaneous inner Lagrange
point, this potential is maximized along the line connecting the centers of the two stars. Although
this potential is derived for the frame rotating with the orbit (and thus with an angular frequency
continuously changing to match the instantaneous Keplerian frequency) the location of the L1 point
is specified by a distance from the center of mass of star 1 along the line between the stars, and is
thus well-defined in an inertial frame. Likewise, the quantities in equation 9.1 necessary to calculate
the location of the L1 point are distances and masses, which can be measured in inertial space, and
the angular rotation frequency of star 1, which is also measured in the inertial frame. Thus, this
equation can be used to locate the instantaneous L1 point in an inertial frame, which will prove
convenient in the calculation below.
9.2.2 Keplerian Orbits
Keplerian orbits can be parameterized by a quantity know as the eccentric anomaly, u, which evolves
in time according to Kepler's equation:
2πt
P
= u − e sin u,
(9.2)
9.2. MASS TRANSFER VIA ROCHE-LOBE OVERFLOW
139
where t is the time elapsed since periastron, P is the orbital period, and e is the eccentricity. The
left-hand side of equation 9.2 is also know as the mean anomaly. The separation vector of the two
stars is then given by:
x(u) = a(cos u − e)
y(u) = a√1 − e2 sin u,
(9.3)
where a is the semimajor axis of the orbit (half of the maximum separation distance of the stars),
and periastron lies along the +x axis. For each time step, equation 9.2 is solved for u via Newton's
method, and the positions of the two stars are calculated from equations 9.3. The velocities of the
stars can be calculated by substituting du/dt, from the time derivative of equation 9.2, and u into
the time derivatives of equations 9.3.
9.2.3 Trajectory of a Particle in the Binary Potential
The trajectory of a particle of negligible mass m moving in the potential of a binary system can be
calculated by integrating the instantaneous velocity and acceleration of the particle in the inertial
(non-rotating) frame of reference as the stars move in their orbits. The instantaneous velocity (~vm)
and acceleration are given by:
d~rm
dt
= ~vm,
and
d~vm
dt
=
~Fm
m
= −
GM1m (~rm − ~r1)
~rm − ~r13
−
GM2m (~rm − ~r2)
~rm − ~r23
,
(9.4)
(9.5)
where the subscripts 1, 2, and m refer to the two stars and the particle respectively, ~Fm is the
gravitational force on the particle, M is the mass of a star, and ~r is a position vector. The x and
y components of equations 9.4 and 9.5 are integrated by a Runge-Kutta algorithm [57] to obtain
the trajectory of the particle. The initial coordinate of the particle is taken to be a point on the
surface of the donor (whose radius is defined to be the size of its critical lobe at periastron and held
constant around the orbit) on the line between the centers of the two stars. The initial velocity of
the particle is the vector sum of the instantaneous orbital velocity of the donor, the velocity of a
particle on the surface due to rotation of the donor, and possibly an additional radial velocity away
from the surface (see below).
9.2.4 Final Outcome of Particle Trajectories
The possible final outcomes of the particle trajectory are as follows:
1. It is assumed that the accretion disk almost fills the instantaneous critical lobe of the neutron
140
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
star at periastron (i.e., 80% of the distance between the neutron star and the L1 point at
periastron), and that the disk maintains that size at all other orbital phases. The particle is
assumed to have entered the disk if it passes closer than this distance from the neutron star
at any point in the orbit.
2. The donor is likewise assumed to fill its critical lobe at periastron and maintain that radius
throughout the orbit. The particle is considered to be recaptured if it re-enters that radius
relative to the donor at any point in the orbit.
3. The particle is assumed to be ejected from the binary (or at least no longer a likely contributor
to mass transfer) if its distance from the CM exceeds twice the semimajor axis of the orbit.
4. After two full binary orbits, if none of the above three cases have occurred, the outcome is
undetermined.
In all cases, the orbital period was taken to be that of Cir X-1, 16.55 days, and the mass of the
neutron star was taken to be 1.4 M⊙. For simplicity, the donor star is assumed to rotate uniformly
at the average Keplerian frequency (ωrot = 2π/16.55 days). Also, a donor mass of 1 M⊙ has been
adopted for the discussion below, where results are shown for two eccentricities: 0.5 and 0.8. Such
values might be close to actual values for Cir X-1, but are mainly chosen for illustrative purposes.
Figure 9-1 shows the final outcome of particles which were released from the surface of the
donor at different orbital phases (evenly spaced in time) of a system with e = 0.5. The top panels
(Figures 9-1a, b) are for an initial radial velocity off the surface of 30 km/s, or about 15% of the
escape velocity from the star (if it were isolated). In Figure 9-1a, one can see the arrival time as a
function of start time, where the different symbols indicate where the particle entered the accretion
disk and where it was recaptured by the donor. Only particles that begin transfer during the interval
−0.9 to +0.3 days relative to periastron eventually enter the disk, and most of the particles arrive
at the disk (Figure 9-1b) closely spaced in time near day 0.3 or shortly after. Figures 9-1c and 9-
1d show that similar behavior occurs for particles with a larger radial velocity from the surface of
60 km/s (∼30% of the escape velocity from the donor). The larger initial velocity allows particles to
reach the disk over a somewhat longer portion of the orbit, and also results in most of the particles
reaching the disk before periastron.
The fact that mass transfer is most effective for particles released before periastron is related
to the relative velocity of the stars in their eccentric orbit. Particles released as the stars approach
periastron naturally move toward the neutron star, and are more likely to be captured by the disk.
Particles released after periastron have to try to "catch up" to a receding neutron star, and after a
certain point will simply be recaptured by the donor. The asymmetric profile of particles entering
9.2. MASS TRANSFER VIA ROCHE-LOBE OVERFLOW
141
Figure 9-1: Panels (a) and (c): stop time of particles in a system with e=0.5 (and P=16.55 d)
versus time of release from donor (1 M⊙), with the final outcome (recapture or entry into disk)
indicated. Panels (b) and (d): normalized rate of particles entering the accretion disk versus their
arrival time relative to periastron. The top panels, (a) and (b), are for an initial radial velocity from
the surface of 30 km/s, and the bottom panels, (c) and (d), are for 60 km/s. In (a) and (c), the
solid diagonal line has a slope of unity and indicates zero elapsed time between release and the final
outcome; the horizontal dashed line indicates a final outcome occurring at periastron.
142
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
the disk is also related to the relative motion of the stars. Particles released shortly before periastron
are carried along the orbit of the donor and their arrival times are thus focussed near the time of
periastron.
Figures 9-2a and 9-2b show the outcome of a similar transfer scenario as Figure 9-1, but with a
larger eccentricity (e = 0.8) and with each particle receiving an initial release velocity of 50 km/s
radially away from the surface of the donor (again about 15% of the escape velocity). The higher
eccentricity confines mass transfer to a narrower range of orbital phase, mainly a release within
0.15 d prior to periastron passage.
Figures 9-2c and 9-2d also show the outcome of transfer in a system with e = 0.8, but with a
larger radial velocity of 100 km/s (∼30% of the escape velocity from the donor). In this case the
accretion rate shows two sharp peaks after periastron passage, separated by only 0.25 d (Figure 9-2d).
The combined high orbital velocity approaching periastron in the eccentric orbit and the high initial
velocity from the surface cause some particles to initially "overshoot" the neutron star, eventually to
be captured in the disk, but only after a delay that concentrates the arrival time of many particles
near day 0.4
Eight illustrative trajectories for some of the test particles shown in Figure 9-1c (e = 0.5), released
at various orbital phases with vradial = 60 km/s, are shown in Figure 9-3. These plots show how
the motion of the two stars in their eccentric orbits can produce a wide variety of trajectories for a
particle transferred from the surface of the donor.
9.2.5 Comparison to the X-ray Intensity Profile
The sharp rise time of the number of particles entering the accretion disk in Figures 9-1 and 9-2
resembles the sharp rise in X-ray intensity from Cir X-1 after phase zero (not necessarily periastron)
in the ASM light curve (see Chapter 3). These peaks are quite narrow (generally only a fraction of
a day) compared to the ∼3-5 days typically observed in the X-ray light curve. However, the actual
intensity profile depends on additional factors, such as the duration of time that matter spends in
the disk before falling onto the neutron star. These results serve primarily as an example of what
can be done once more is known about the parameters of the Cir X-1 system, such as the actual
eccentricity and the mass and stellar type of the donor.
9.3 Mass Transfer via a Stellar Wind
When the donor star in an X-ray binary does not fill its Roche lobe, a stellar wind or other outflow
must be responsible for mass transfer. This is the case in some high-mass X-ray binaries, where
9.3. MASS TRANSFER VIA A STELLAR WIND
143
Figure 9-2: Panels (a) and (c): stop time of particles in a system with e=0.8 (and P=16.55 d)
versus time of release from donor (1 M⊙), with the final outcome (recapture or entry into disk)
indicated. Panels (b) and (d): normalized rate of particles entering the accretion disk versus their
arrival time relative to periastron. The top panels, (a) and (b), are for an initial radial velocity from
the surface of 50 km/s, and the bottom panels, (c) and (d), are for 100 km/s. In (a) and (c), the
solid diagonal line has a slope of unity and indicates zero elapsed time between release and the final
outcome; the horizontal dashed line indicates a final outcome occurring at periastron.
144
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
Figure 9-3: Trajectory of a particle moving in an eccentric binary system (Mdon=1 M⊙, e=0.5),
where the particle starts with an initial radial velocity of 60 km/s off the surface of the donor at
a time t0 relative to periastron. The plot is in a non-rotating frame with the CM at the origin
(+). The location of the particle, donor star, and neutron star at t0 are indicated by the diamond,
asterisk, and solid dot respectively. The subsequent motion of the particle until enters the accretion
disk or is recaptured is shown as a solid curve, and the motion of the donor and neutron star in
their orbits during that time is indicated by a dashed or dotted ellipse segment respectively.
9.3. MASS TRANSFER VIA A STELLAR WIND
145
the donor star experiences significant mass loss via a wind from the surface. Since a high-mass
companion for Cir X-1 cannot yet be ruled out, I also studied wind transfer in an eccentric binary.
I developed a computer code to study the mass transfer rate as a function of orbital phase. The
resulting theoretical mass accretion profiles can be compared with the observed X-ray intensity
profiles, which at least in some circumstances may be a measure of the accretion rate.
9.3.1 Bondi-Hoyle Accretion
Material in the stellar wind passing within a critical radius of the neutron star is sufficiently deflected
by the gravitational field of the neutron star to eventually be captured and accrete onto the surface
(first presented by Bondi & Hoyle in 1944 [9]). Since the wind material flows around both sides of
the neutron star (in the orbital plane; the problem is actually three-dimensional) the net angular
momentum of the captured matter is small and accretion occurs without forming an accretion
disk. The critical radius, i.e., the maximum accretion radius (racc), is the radius inside which the
gravitational potential energy due to the neutron star exceeds the kinetic energy of the particles in
the wind due to the relative velocity of the wind and neutron star (~vrel = ~vwind − ~vorb) and the
thermal particle motion (related to the sound speed vs):
GMnsm
racc ≃
1
2
mv2
rel +
1
2
mv2
s ,
(9.6)
where Mns is the mass of the neutron star and m is the mass of a wind particle (mainly protons).
Solving equation 9.6 for the critical accretion radius gives
The mass accretion rate is then
racc ≃
2GMns
v2
rel + v2
s
.
Macc = ρ(r)vrelπr2
acc,
(9.7)
(9.8)
where ρ(r) is the density of the wind at a distance r from the center of the donor star, i.e., the
separation between the stars. Conservation of mass provides an expression that relates the mass
loss rate of the donor due to wind ( Mw), vwind, and ρ(r):
Mw = ρ(r)vwind4πr2.
(9.9)
146
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
Combining equations 9.7, 9.8, and 9.9 gives the fraction of the wind captured by the neutron star:
Macc
Mw
=
G2M 2
ns
r2
vrel
vwind
1
(v2
rel + v2
s )2 .
(9.10)
9.3.2 Wind Accretion Profile in an Eccentric Binary
For a given set of binary parameters (masses, orbital period, and eccentricity), the positions and
velocities of the two stars around their orbits can be calculated according to the expressions given
in section 9.2.2. The mass of the neutron star is taken to be 1.4 M⊙ and a period of 16.55 days is
used.
High-mass stars such as OB supergiants typically have high wind speeds of 1000-2000 km/s. A
wind speed of 1000 km/s is used in the case discussed below. The relative velocity between the wind
and the neutron star is calculated from the wind speed and the relative orbital velocity of the stars.
For a wind temperature T , the sound speed is given by vs =pγkT /m, where k is Boltzmann's
constant and γ = 5/3 for a monatomic gas. A typical wind temperature of 10000 K thus corresponds
to a sound speed of about 12 km/s. This is much less than the wind speeds in this calculation. So,
the wind temperature does not contribute significantly to the final results, but a value of 10000 K
has been adopted for concreteness.
In this calculation, wind propagation delays are ignored, i.e. the wind velocity vector is calculated
using the current position and velocity of the donor star. This simplification is valid when the wind
speed is significantly larger than the orbital velocity of the donor. In the limit of very high wind
speed, vrel ≈ vw ≫ vs, and so equation 9.10 reduces to
G2M 2
ns
(9.11)
Macc
Mw
=
1
v4
w
.
r2
Thus, for a given wind speed, it is primarily the distance between the stars that determines the
fraction of the wind captured. However, equation 9.10 is still used in the code, since the orbital
motion of the neutron star will produce an asymmetry of the profile relative to phase zero.
In an eccentric orbit the separation between the stars changes with orbital phase (θ) according
to
r(θ) = a
1 − e2
1 + e cos θ
=(cid:18) P
2π(cid:19)2/3
G1/3(Mns + Mdon)1/3
1 − e2
1 + e cos θ
,
(9.12)
where the Kepler's third law was used in the second equality. Thus for a fixed orbital period and
high wind speed, the wind capture fraction is weakly dependent on the mass of the donor star,
strongly dependent on eccentricity, and varies with orbital phase as (1 + e cos θ)2. Thus, only the
normalization, and not the shape, of the wind accretion profiles change significantly with different
9.3. MASS TRANSFER VIA A STELLAR WIND
147
donor masses or (high) wind speeds.
The profile of mass accretion rate versus orbital phase for a 5 M⊙ donor is shown in Figure 9-4 for
three values of eccentricity (0.2, 0.5, 0.8) and three wind speeds (500, 1000, 2000 km/s). As expected,
a low eccentricity produces a broad profile, while a high eccentricity shows a much narrower peak.
The peak value occurs slightly after phase zero due to the relative velocity of the wind and neutron
star near periastron, and this shift is largest when the wind speed is slowest.
9.3.3 Comparison to the X-ray Intensity Profile
The X-ray light curve of Cir X-1 as observed by the ASM (see Chapter 3) shows that flaring is usually
limited to a quarter to a third of each 16.55-d cycle, suggesting at least a moderate eccentricity. The
flaring is complex and varies significantly from cycle to cycle. In contrast to the wind profiles in
Figure 9-4, many X-ray cycles show an asymmetric profile, with the intensity declining more slowly
than the rise. Some cycles even show a secondary peak well separated from the first. Such behavior
cannot be accommodated in the simple wind model presented here. Moreover, the X-ray light curves
show a substantial baseline intensity level that does not occur in simulations with a large eccentricity.
148
CHAPTER 9. MASS TRANSFER IN AN ECCENTRIC BINARY
Figure 9-4: Wind accretion rate versus orbital phase for three eccentricities and wind speeds for a
5 M⊙ donor. Each curve is normalized by its peak value; the actual wind capture fraction (relative
to the mass-loss rate of the donor) decreases significantly with higher velocity.
Chapter 10
Eccentric Binary Evolution
10.1 Overview
In order to explore the possible evolutionary history of Circinus X-1, I have developed a binary
evolution code to model the evolution of a neutron-star and low-mass companion (M < 3 M⊙) in an
eccentric orbit. Although a high-mass companion cannot be ruled out based on the observed optical
and infrared magnitudes (see section 1.3.6), the X-ray behavior is most consistent with a low-mass
X-ray binary, and thus I only consider systems with a low-mass companion in this model. This
code was originally developed by C. M. Becker to model accreting white dwarfs in circular binary
orbits [4]. In order to keep the model simple, yet include eccentricity, I assumed that mass transfer
(via Roche-lobe overflow) occurs only at periastron and that the transfer is conservative (no mass
lost from the system). I have also added the effects of tidal dissipation on the orbit and allow a
system to evolve even when not transferring mass. I then used this code as the basis for a Monte
Carlo population synthesis study of low-mass X-ray binaries that might resemble Cir X-1. I show
that the number of systems in the Galaxy with parameters similar to those of Cir X-1 should be
of order unity, consistent with the unique status of the source as an eccentric LMXB with a high
accretion rate.
10.2 Binary Evolution Theory
10.2.1 Evolution of Binary Parameters
The Keplerian elements of the binary system can be specified by the mass of the neutron star (Mns),
the mass of the donor star (Mdon), the orbital angular momentum (Jorb), and the eccentricity (e).
149
150
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
The orbital period (Porb), angular frequency (Ωorb), and semimajor axis (a) are related to these four
quantities by straightforward application of Kepler's third law
2π (cid:19)2
(cid:18) Porb
= Ω−2
orb =
a3
GMT
and the expression for the orbital angular momentum
Jorb = G1/2MnsMdonM −1/2
T
a1/2(1 − e2)1/2,
where MT = Mns + Mdon.
(10.1)
(10.2)
Mass transfer will occur when the donor star fills its critical potential lobe. For simplicity, I
assume that the mass transfer is conservative, i.e., all matter lost by the donor is accreted by the
neutron star: δMns = −δMdon and δMT = 0. Furthermore, since the critical potential lobe will
be smallest at periastron, it is assumed that mass transfer occurs only at periastron. This is likely
to be a good approximation for large eccentricities but clearly cannot hold true in the limit of zero
eccentricity. For the purpose of studying systems that resemble Cir X-1, systems with very low or
zero eccentricity (i.e., e<
∼0.01) are not of interest.
Because mass transfer depends on the size of the donor relative to its critical potential lobe, it
is necessary to follow the evolution of the donor star radius. There are several means by which the
donor radius may change, each of which will be discussed in more detail below. At this point I will
only mention what those mechanisms are: (1) The radius of the donor changes over time due to the
nuclear evolution of its core. (2) The star responds adiabatically to the removal of mass. (3) The
radius, if not at equilibrium, adjusts toward the equilibrium radius on a thermal time scale. The
net effect of these contributions on radius evolution can be expressed as:
δRdon
Rdon
=(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)nuc
+(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)th
+(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)ad
.
(10.3)
Orbital angular momentum is lost through tidal dissipation, magnetic braking, and gravitational
radiation.
δJ
J
=(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)tid
+(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)mb
+(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)gr
.
(10.4)
Likewise, these mechanisms produce a change in eccentricity. Unlike angular momentum (which is
assumed to be conserved during mass transfer), the eccentricity changes due to mass transfer. Thus,
10.2. BINARY EVOLUTION THEORY
the total change in eccentricity is given by:
δe
e
=(cid:18) δe
e (cid:19) m
+(cid:18) δe
e (cid:19)tid
+(cid:18) δe
e (cid:19)mb
+(cid:18) δe
e (cid:19)gr
.
151
(10.5)
I will discuss each of these mechanisms in detail below. The final two terms in equation 10.5 are
expected to occur on much longer time scales than the first two terms and are thus ignored.
10.2.2 Evolution of the Donor Star Radius
10.2.2.1 Nuclear Evolution
The equilibrium radius of a star depends on its total mass, as well as the mass of its core produced
by nuclear evolution. An expression for this radius is given by Rappaport et al. [60]:
Req
R⊙ ≃ 0.85(cid:18)Mdon
M⊙ (cid:19)0.85
+
4950M 4.5
(1 + 4M 4
c )
c
,
(10.6)
where Mc is the mass of the core expressed in solar units.
As the core mass grows through nuclear evolution, the radius of the donor will also increase.
Taking the derivative of equation 10.6 and dividing by the donor radius gives the fractional change
in the radius due to nuclear evolution:
Rdon (cid:19)nuc
(cid:18) δRdon
=
δReq
Rdon
=
Req − 0.85(Mdon/M⊙)0.85
Rdon
(cid:20)4.5 −
16M 4
c
(1 + 4M 4
c )(cid:21) δMc
Mc
(10.7)
The nuclear evolution of the core is straightforward to compute since in a red giant the luminosity
is generated from nuclear burning in a thin shell surrounding a helium core. The change in core
mass is determined by the rate at which hydrogen is burned in a shell around the helium core.
In the low-mass giants being considered here, hydrogen is fused into helium via the proton-proton
chain, which converts 0.7% of the hydrogen mass into energy. Thus, the core gains mass at a rate
proportional to the luminosity of the donor (Ldon). Becker gives an expression for this rate [4]:
Mc = 1.47×10−11fc(cid:18) Ldon
L⊙ (cid:19)(cid:18) X
0.7(cid:19)−1
M⊙ yr−1.
(10.8)
where X is the hydrogen abundance (mass fraction), taken to be ∼0.75 and fc is an ad hoc constant
multiplicative factor of 2 to make this simple evolutionary model more consistent with the results
of more sophisticated codes.
An approximate analytic formula for the luminosity of a star on the red giant branch is given by
152
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
the following expression, adapted from the result of Eggleton [19]:
Ldon
M⊙ (cid:19)4
L⊙ ≃ 2(cid:18) Mdon
+
2×105(Mc/M⊙)6
1 + 2.5(Mc/M⊙)4 + 3(Mc/M⊙)5 .
(10.9)
10.2.2.2 Thermal Readjustment Toward Equilibrium
If the radius of the donor star differs from its thermal equilibrium radius, it will adjust toward the
equilibrium radius on a thermal timescale. For example, if the critical potential lobe of the star
restricts its radius to be smaller than it would be if it were in thermal equilibrium, the star will
expand on a thermal time scale, driving mass transfer. The following relation is used to describe
the readjustment of the stellar radius of the donor on a thermal (Kelvin-Helmholtz) timescale:
(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)th ≃
Req − Rdon
RdonτKH
δt ,
(10.10)
where
τKH ≃
3GM 2
7RL ≃ 1.5×107(cid:18) Mdon
M⊙ (cid:19)2(cid:18) Rdon
R⊙ (cid:19)−1(cid:18) Ldon
L⊙ (cid:19)−1
yrs.
(10.11)
10.2.2.3 Adiabatic Response to Mass Loss
A star will respond adiabatically to mass loss. Rappaport, Joss, and Webbink [59] relate the resulting
change of the radius to the change in mass through a factor ξad:
Rdon (cid:19)ad
(cid:18) δRdon
= ξad
δMdon
Mdon
.
(10.12)
Di Stefano et al. [15] performed detailed evolution studies with a Henyey-type code including mass
loss. They found that for stars with a low core mass (Mcor < 0.2M⊙), the radius shrinks when mass
is removed, but for higher core mass, the mass loss causes the star to expand (resulting in unstable
transfer). They parameterized their results for ξad with respect to core mass:
ξad = ξad"1 −(cid:18) Mc
Mc(cid:19)2# ,
(10.13)
where ξad = 4.0 and Mc = 0.2 M⊙.
10.2.3 Evolution of Orbital Parameters
10.2. BINARY EVOLUTION THEORY
153
10.2.3.1 Tidal Evolution
In a binary system, tidal friction will dissipate energy while conserving the total angular momentum.
In particular, in a system where one star is compact (e.g. a neutron star), the sum of the total orbital
energy plus the rotational energy of the "donor" star (actually not necessarily donating matter in
this discussion) will decrease while angular momentum is exchanged between the orbit and the
rotation of the star. In the weak friction model, it is assumed that the star is tidally deformed into
the equipotential surface it would have formed a constant time τ ago in the absence of the tidal
friction, i.e., a tidal bulge that is offset from the line between the centers of the stars. The rate of
change of the orbital and rotational parameters due to this tidal dissipation is given by Hut [29]
(using variables as defined above):
da
dt
= −6
GMdonkτ
R3
don
de
dt
= −27
GMdonkτ
R3
don
1 + q
a (cid:19)8
q2 (cid:18) Rdon
a (cid:19)8
q2 (cid:18) Rdon
1 + q
a
(1 − e2)15/2 (cid:20)f1(e2) − (1 − e2)3/2f2(e2)
(1 − e2)13/2 (cid:20)f3(e2) −
(1 − e2)3/2f4(e2)
11
8
Ωrot
Ωorb(cid:21) ,
Ωorb(cid:21) ,
Ωrot
e
(10.14)
(10.15)
and
dΩrot
dt
= 3
where
GMdonkτ
1
R3
don
q2r2
a (cid:19)6
g (cid:18) Rdon
Ωorb
(1 − e2)15/2 (cid:20)f2(e2) − (1 − e2)3/2f5(e2)
Ωrot
Ωorb(cid:21) ,
(10.16)
64 e8
16 e6 + 25
8 e4 + 185
2 e2 + 255
f1(e2) = 1 + 31
f2(e2) = 1 + 15
8 e4 + 15
2 e2 + 45
16 e6
4 e2 + 15
8 e4 + 5
f3(e2) = 1 + 15
64 e6
2 e2 + 1
f4(e2) = 1 + 3
8 e4
f5(e2) = 1 + 3e2 + 3
8 e4.
Also, q = Mdon/Mns is the mass ratio and Ωrot and Ωorb are the rotational and mean orbital angular
velocities. The dimensionless radius of gyration, rg, is related to the moment of inertia of the donor
star by I = r2
gMdonR2
donor. A typical value for the radius of gyration is r2
don, and the apsidal motion constant k is also related to the structure of the
g = 0.1 for the low-mass relatively unevolved
stars considered here.
For stars with an outer convective zone (i.e. low-mass stars with M <
∼ 1–2 M⊙), Lecar gives an
approximate expression for the product of the apsidal motion constant and the tidal time lag [41]:
kτ ≈ 25
ηλvconv(km/s)
g/g⊙
s,
(10.17)
154
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
where g = GM/R2 is the gravitational acceleration. The convective velocity, vconv, is typically
∼1 km/s for a wide range of convective stars. Furthermore, η and λ are the fractional mass and
fractional depth respectively of the outer convection zone of the donor star. Lecar gives a table of
these two quantities for main-sequence stars with effective temperatures of in the range of T =5200–
7200 K [41]. To facilitate interpolation and extrapolation of values for ηλ, an analytic function was
fit to the table entries, resulting in the following relation:
log10(ηλ) =
10.66 − 2.7907 × 10−6 T 2 + 7.5778 × 10−10 T 3 − 5.899 × 10−14 T 4 T ≥ 5000K
T < 5000K.
−1.25375
(10.18)
For stars with effective temperatures below 5000 K, the tidal circularization time scale is very
short and systems containing such stars will circularize before other mechanisms affect the orbital
evolution. In contrast, for stars with effective temperatures above 7200 K, the time scale is very
long and tidal dissipation will not play a significant role in the evolution of the orbital parameters.
10.2.3.2 Effect of Mass Transfer on the Orbit
The effect of mass transfer in a circular orbit is relatively simple to calculate: if angular momentum
is conserved, then the change in the semimajor axis of the orbit depends uniquely on the change
in the masses of the stars. Mass transfer onto a star less massive than the donor star will decrease
their separation, and transfer onto a more massive star will increase the orbital separation. In an
eccentric orbit, the angular momentum depends on both the eccentricity as well as the semimajor
axis, and thus conservation of angular momentum is insufficient to determine how both orbital
parameters change. So, Eggleton has derived a prescription for the effect of mass transfer on the
orbital eccentricity [19]. Mass transfer that occurs at orbital angle θ (position angle of one star
relative to the other, where θ = 0 corresponds to periastron) results in a change in eccentricity given
by:
δe = −2 (1 − q)(cos e + e)
δMdon
Mdon
.
(10.19)
When mass is transferred at a constant rate around the entire orbit, the average change in eccentricity
is zero, since over a complete orbit hcos θi = −e. In the other extreme, when mass transfer occurs
only at periastron (as in a highly eccentric orbit),
δe = −2 (1 − q)(1 + e)
δMdon
Mdon
.
(10.20)
Since δMdon < 0 during mass transfer and q = Mdon/Mns, equation 10.20 shows that mass
10.2. BINARY EVOLUTION THEORY
155
transfer will decrease the eccentricity when Mdon > Mns and will increase the eccentricity when the
mass ratio is reversed.
10.2.3.3 Magnetic Braking
This section on magnetic braking is reproduced from Becker [4].
Most stars have some magnetic field, and the interaction of the field lines with the ejected matter
increases the effective "lever arm" and, therefore, the amount of specific angular momentum carried
away by the stellar wind. Thus a small amount of mass loss can, in principle, extract a significant
amount of angular momentum from the rotation of the star. If tidal interactions between the donor
and companion keep the donor star co-rotating with the orbit, then magnetic braking can result in
angular momentum losses from the orbit.
Skumanich [64] and Smith [66] independently determined a rotation rate/age relation for isolated
stars, mostly with masses about 1 M⊙, in clusters of various ages. From this relation an empirical
magnetic braking torque was inferred. Verbunt & Zwaan [82] applied this to binary systems as a
way to drive angular momentum loss. I use a slightly modified version of this braking law as given
by Rappaport et al. [58]:
J (cid:19)mb
(cid:18) δJ
= −1.73×10−27fmb" R4
⊙(Rdon/R⊙)γM 1/3
T
G2/3MwdP 10/3
# δt ,
(10.21)
where γ is the parameterized magnetic braking index (typically γ = 4), fmb is a multiplicative
constant of order unity, and "cgs units" are used. In the process of applying magnetic braking to
binaries, a number of liberties were taken in applying the results of Skumanich and Smith. The use
of the magnetic braking law in binaries extends to shorter periods and different masses for stars
than in the original data. The parameter γ is used in place of any real knowledge of how the braking
depends on stellar radius since most of the stars used to develop the original relation were G stars
with more or less the same radius.
10.2.3.4 Gravitational Radiation
This section on gravitational radiation is reproduced from Becker [4].
Gravitational radiation arises from a mass distribution with a time varying quadrupole moment,
such as a pair of stars orbiting each other. For such a simple geometry (a circular orbit), the rate of
angular momentum loss is given by the Einstein quadrupole radiation formula:
J (cid:19)gr
(cid:18) δJ
32
5
(4π2)4/3 G5/3
c5
= −
MwdMdon
M 1/3
T P 8/3
δt ,
(10.22)
156
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
where P is the orbital period [39]. For the systems we will consider, with periods typically larger
than 10 hours, gravitational radiation alone drives mass transfer too slowly to have any significant
effect.
10.2.4 Stable Mass Transfer
Mass transfer can act as a sort of regulator, preventing the donor radius from exceeding the critical
potential lobe radius (stable transfer). If mass transfer is unable to prevent the donor from over-
filling the critical potential lobe, transfer will be unstable. If mass transfer (or another mechanism)
eventually results in the donor underfilling its critical potential lobe, mass transfer will stop. Thus,
during stable mass transfer the donor radius can continuously adjust so that it always equals the
Roche lobe radius. Based on the assumption of stable transfer, I will now derive the expression that
governs the rate of mass transfer.
For the case of circular orbits, the Roche-lobe radius is related to the semimajor axis of the orbit
through a function f (q) of the mass ratio q = Mdon/Mns:
An analytic approximation of this function has been derived by P. Eggleton [18]:
RL = f (q) · a.
f (q) =
0.49q2/3
0.6q2/3 + ln(1 + q1/3)
.
(10.23)
(10.24)
For non-zero eccentricity, a plausible approximation to the effective critical potential lobe size is
obtained by replacing the semimajor axis in equation 10.23 with the instantaneous separation d.
A more precise measure for size of the critical potential lobe can be obtained by calculating the
location of points on the critical surface of an effective potential that accounts for the eccentricity
of the orbit, e.g., as given by Avni [3] (see section 9.2.1). However, for simplicity and speed in the
evolution code, I will use equation 10.23 with the instantaneous separation.
In a Keplerian orbit, the separation as a function of angle (θ) from periastron is given by
d =
a (1 − e2)
1 + e cos θ
.
(10.25)
Thus at periastron, d = a (1− e). As described above, mass transfer via Roche-lobe overflow requires
that the radius of the donor star equal the radius of the critical potential lobe at periastron radius:
Rdon ≡ RL = f (q) · a · (1 − e).
(10.26)
10.2. BINARY EVOLUTION THEORY
157
Taking the logarithmic derivative of equation 10.26 shows how changes in these parameters are
coupled:
δRdon
Rdon
= (1 + q)
d ln f
d ln q
δMdon
Mdon
+
δa
a −
δe
1 − e
.
(10.27)
The logarithmic derivative of f (q) is calculated from equation 10.24 to be:
d ln f
d ln q
=
2
3
1+q1/3
0.6q2/3 + ln(1 + q1/3)
ln(1 + q1/3) − 0.5 q1/3
.
(10.28)
Since I have chosen to work with orbital angular momentum rather than the semimajor axis, the
logarithmic derivative of the orbital angular momentum (equation 10.2) is needed:
δJ
J
=
δMns
Mns
+
δMdon
Mdon −
1
2
δMT
MT
+
1
2
δa
a −
e δe
1 − e2 .
(10.29)
The masses in this relation can be re-expressed in terms of only the donor mass and the mass ratio:
δJ
J
= (1 − q)
δMdon
Mdon
+
1
2
δa
a −
e δe
1 − e2 .
(10.30)
Combining equations 10.27 and 10.30 to eliminate the semimajor axis gives:
δJ
J
=(cid:20)1 − q −
1 + q
2
d ln f
d ln q(cid:21) δMdon
Mdon
+
1
2
δRdon
Rdon
+
1
2
e
(1 + e)
δe
e
.
(10.31)
Using equations 10.3, 10.4, and 10.5 to explicitly include each source of evolution into 10.31:
2(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)mb
+ 2(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)gr
+ 2(cid:18) δJ
2(cid:20)1 − q −
J (cid:19)tid −
1 + q
2
e
(1 + e)(cid:18) δe
d ln q(cid:21) δMdon
e (cid:19)tid −(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)th
Rdon (cid:19)nuc −(cid:18) δRdon
e (cid:19) m
(1 + e)(cid:18) δe
Rdon (cid:19)ad
+(cid:18) δRdon
Mdon
d ln f
+
e
=
, (10.32)
where all the explicitly time-dependent terms have been moved to the left hand side, and terms
directly proportional to mass loss appear on the right hand side.
Now using equations 10.12 and 10.19 to replace the last two terms in equation 10.32 with their
dependencies on mass transfer, we find
2(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)mb
+ 2(cid:18) δJ
J (cid:19)gr
e
J (cid:19)tid −
(1 + e)(cid:18) δe
+ 2(cid:18) δJ
(cid:20) ξad + 2(1 − q) − 2hcos θi + e
1 + e
e (cid:19)tid −(cid:18) δRdon
Rdon (cid:19)nuc −(cid:18) δRdon
=
Rdon (cid:19)th
d ln q(cid:21) δMdon
Mdon
d ln f
(1 − q) − (1 + q)
. (10.33)
The time-dependent left-hand side of this equation, referred to as the "numerator", governs the
158
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
time scale for mass transfer. The right-hand side depends on the mass transferred, rather than time.
The term in square brackets on the right-hand side (the "denominator"), determines if mass transfer
is stable. As mentioned in section 10.2.3.2, mass transfer limited to periastron results in hcos θi = 1,
so that the second and third terms in the denominator cancel. For transfer around the entire orbit,
when hcos θi = −e, the third term of the denominator vanishes.
All of the terms in the numerator are time dependent and can be calculated from the expressions
given in the discussion above. The expressions given for gravitational radiation and magnetic braking
are strictly correct only for circular orbits. However, these mechanisms of angular momentum loss
are small in a system with a relatively long orbital period such as Cir X-1 (days), and thus the
circular-orbit approximation is sufficient to estimate the magnitude of these quantities.
10.3 Binary Evolution Code
10.3.1 Code Algorithm
The parameters that need to be specified at the start of the evolution are the inital donor mass
and the eccentricity and semimajor axis of the orbit. The initial core mass can be varied, but was
generally taken to be zero and evolved as part of the code. The initial neutron star mass was taken
to be 1.4 M⊙ in all cases. The initial spin of the donor was assumed to be slow relative to the
orbital frequency (Ωrot/Ωorb = 1×10−3 for concreteness) and allowed to spin-up via tidal effects.
The donor star was assumed to start in equilibrium (Rdon = Req). It generally underfilled its initial
periastron critical potential lobe, but in some cases just filled the critical lobe. Mass transfer started
immediately in the latter case.
A minimum of 10 time steps are used per decade of time. Smaller time steps are chosen as
necessary so that no parameter changes by more than 0.25% during each step, and 107 yr is the
largest time step allowed. For each time step:
1. The new core mass is determined from the simplified stellar evolution code.
2. The equilibrium radius of the donor is determined from its total and core mass.
3. The change in donor radius due to nuclear evolution, thermal adjustment, and adiabatic re-
sponse to mass loss is calculated.
4. The effects of tidal dissipation, magnetic braking, and gravitational radiation on the orbit are
calculated.
10.3. BINARY EVOLUTION CODE
159
5. If the donor star fills its critical potential lobe, determine the amount of mass transfer necessary
to keep the donor radius no larger than the radius of critical potential lobe (calculate numerator
and denominator from equation 10.33).
6. Update all the system parameters based on the above changes.
The evolution is stopped if any of the following conditions occur:
1. The donor star is stripped (Mdon − Mcor < 0.05 M⊙).
2. The mass of the donor star drops below 0.1 M⊙.
3. The denominator of equation 10.33 is negative (mass transfer is unstable).
4. The binary circularizes (e < 0.01), and thus is no longer a candidate to produce a system that
resembles Cir X-1.
5. The binary comes close to being unbound. When a becomes extremely large and e approaches
unity, the system has become nearly unbound or has unphysical parameters. Thus I stop the
code when e > 0.99 and refer to such systems as being "unbound".
6. More than 10 billion years have elapsed (longer than the age of most stars in the Galaxy).
10.3.2 Results
As mentioned in section 10.2.3.2, mass transfer tends to decrease the eccentricity while the donor
star is more massive than the neutron star. In some cases, this can lead to circularization of the
orbit. However, in many cases mass transfer eventually inverts the mass ratio (or Mdon < Mns to
begin with) so that the eccentricity and the semimajor axis are increased during continued mass
transfer, often nearly unbinding the system. Systems that start with the donor star in contact with
its critical potential lobe transfer mass at a high rate and usually unbind (see equation 10.20) in
∼108 years.
Figure 10-1 shows the binary evolution calculation results for a 2 M⊙ donor that starts with
donor star in contact with its critical potential lobe. In this situation, the thermal expansion of
the donor towards the equilibrium radius dominates over other mechanisms, as is evident from the
panel in Figure 10-1 showing the various time scales (τth ≡ Rdon/( Rdon)th, τnuc ≡ Rdon/( Rdon)nuc,
τcirc ≡ 1/ etid, and τKH is given by equation 10.11). (The thermal expansion time scale is related to
the Kelvin-Helmholtz time scale, but is longer by a factor shown in equation 10.10.)
Mass transfer initially decreases the eccentricity and semimajor axis (such that periastron sepa-
ration remains unchanged since transfer occurs only at periastron). After 1.2×108 yr, 0.3 M⊙ has
160
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
been transferred, making the neutron star more massive than the donor. Continued mass transfer
then gradually increases the eccentricity and semimajor axis (again such that periastron distance,
a(1−e), remains approximately constant) until the system is nearly unbound (after about 3×108 yr).
This system maintains a moderately high mass transfer rate during most of its entire lifetime,
and its period increases to the level of Cir X-1 (16.55 d) and beyond (the time corresponding to a
16.55-d period is indicated with a dot on several of the curves in Figure 10-1). Thus this system
might go through a phase that resembles Cir X-1. At the point where the period is near 16 days,
its eccentricity is quite high, about 0.9, and the mass transfer rate is 3.5×109 M⊙/yr.
The results of a calculation starting with a 1 M⊙ donor initially underfilling its critical potential
lobe are shown in Figure 10-2. This system evolves uneventfully for over a billion years before the
nuclear evolution of the core eventually brings the donor into contact with its critical potential lobe.
(The time scales for magnetic braking and tides to affect the orbit are much longer than the nuclear
time scale for most of the system's lifetime.) Once in contact, the donor begins mass transfer and
continues for about 1.3×108 yr until the system is nearly unbound. This system would also go
through a phase of moderate mass transfer (∼10−9 M⊙/yr) and high eccentricity with a period near
16 days.
The results for mass transfer depend strongly on the size of the critical potential lobe, and thus
depend on the separation of the stars at periastron (a(1− e)). Here I illustrate this effect by holding
e constant and varying a. Figure 10-3 shows the evolution of eccentricity and mass transfer rate for
four systems which differ only in their initial semimajor axes (initially, Mdon = 2 M⊙ and e = 0.9).
For the system with the smallest orbit (a = 37 R⊙), the donor star initially just fills its critical
potential lobe, similar to the system in Figure 10-1, and thus transfers mass continuously until it
unbinds after about 1.8×108 yr.
The second system in Figure 10-3 (a = 40 R⊙) initially underfills its critical potential lobe,
similar to that in Figure 10-2. Nuclear evolution eventually brings the donor into contact, at which
point mass transfer begins. Unlike the system in Figure 10-2, the donor in this binary is initially
more massive than the neutron star, so the eccentricity dips before ultimately increasing towards
unity.
Skipping the third binary for the moment, the final system in Figure 10-3 has a large semimajor
axis (a = 128 R⊙) and the donor is far from filling its critical potential lobe. The radius of the donor
increases due to nuclear evolution of the core, resulting in a cooler effective temperature. The tidal
time scale strongly depends on the temperature through the convection-shell parameters η and λ
(see section 10.2.3.1). Thus, the tidal time scale drops rather sharply after ∼2×108 yrs, resulting in
rapid circularization of the orbit. The donor star never fills its critical potential lobe; thus, no mass
10.3. BINARY EVOLUTION CODE
161
Figure 10-1: Results of a binary evolution calculation for a system started with the donor star
just filling its critical potential lobe, with initial values: Mdon = 2 M⊙, a = 9.34 R⊙, and e = 0.6.
The donor remains in contact with its critical potential lobe throughout the evolution; thus, the
curve for Rlobe coincides with the curve for Rdon. A solid dot on some of the curves marks the time
corresponding to an orbital period of 16.55 days.
162
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
Figure 10-2: Results of binary evolution calculation for a system started with the donor underfilling
its critical potential lobe, with initial values: Mdon = 1 M⊙, a = 27 R⊙, and e = 0.9.
10.4. MONTE-CARLO POPULATION SYNTHESIS
163
transfer occurs.
The third binary in Figure 10-3 (a = 81 R⊙) is intermediate between the second and fourth.
It initially underfills its critical potential lobe, but comes into contact though nuclear evolution.
The eccentricity initially dips and then rises, as in the second system. However, the mass transfer
eventually results in reduced tidal time scale (shorter than in the fourth system). Tidal effects
then rapidly reduce the eccentricity and the orbit circularizes, as in the fourth system. Tidal
circularization also approximately doubles the periastron separation, pulling the donor out of contact
with its critical potential lobe and turning off mass transfer about 4×106 yrs after it began.
10.4 Monte-Carlo Population Synthesis
10.4.1 Systems Resembling Cir X-1
The results of individual binary evolution calculations show that systems resembling Cir X-1 can be
produced. However, an entire population of LMXBs must be studied in in order to determine the
likelihood of actually observing such a system.
Terman, Taam, & Savage [73] have conducted a population synthesis study of LMXBs, following
an initial distribution of zero-age binaries (with the more massive star > 8 M⊙) from the main
sequence, through a common-envelope phase, to just after the subsequent supernova explosion of the
more evolved star. Systems that remain bound after the supernova explosion and do not immediately
merge produce a population of low-mass main sequence stars (<
∼3 M⊙) with a neutron-star companion
(pre-LMXBs) that are expected to eventually transfer mass through evolution of the orbit and/or
the companion star.
Using the binary evolution code described in the previous section, I have conducted a Monte-
Carlo simulation of the evolution of pre-LMXBs throughout their entire lifetime as potential eccentric
LMXBs. The initial population was drawn from the pre-LMXB population derived by Terman,
Taam, & Savage [73], which yielded a relatively uniform distribution of systems in a specific range
of e and log a. Thus, I chose the eccentricity from a linear distribution in the range e = 0.01 to
0.99, and the semimajor axis from a logarithmic distribution in the range a = 1.25 R⊙ to 400 R⊙.
Combinations outside the pre-LMXB distribution of Terman, Taam, & Savage were discarded. The
initial neutron-star mass was fixed to be 1.4M⊙ in all cases. Donor star masses were randomly
chosen in the range Mdon = 0.8 to 3M⊙, and all donors were assumed to initially have zero core
mass. Donor masses that corresponded to an equilibrium radius larger than the periastron critical
potential lobe size were discarded as being systems that merge immediately or otherwise fail to
contribute to the LMXB population
164
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
Figure 10-3: Eccentricity and mass transfer rate versus time for binaries with initial values Mdon =
2 R⊙, e = 0.9, and semimajor axes (a) between 37 and 128 R⊙.
10.4. MONTE-CARLO POPULATION SYNTHESIS
165
For this study, 105 systems were evolved as described in the previous section. The following
criteria were established to classify a system as one that resembled Cir X-1: an orbital period within
∼20% of 16.55 days (13 d < P < 20 d), a high mass transfer rate (10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 10−7 M⊙/yr),
and at least a moderate eccentricity (e > 0.1).
Cir X-1 is 6–10 kpc away, yet still quite bright in X-rays, so any similar such system should
also be visible from almost anywhere in the Galaxy. Since there is only one system detected with
parameters meeting the above criteria, there is probably only about one such system in the Galaxy
at this time.
Of the 105 systems, 42% were discarded immediately due to the donor being too large for the
orbit. Of the remaining systems, (pre-LMXBs) 15% resembled Cir X-1 at some point in their lifetime.
On average, each of the pre-LMXBs eventually resembled Cir X-1 for 4.0×105 yrs. Terman, Taam,
& Savage [73] predict a pre-LMXB birth rate of ∼3×10−6–10−5 yr−1 in the Galaxy. Multiplying the
predicted birth rate by the average lifetime in a state resembling Cir X-1 results in an expectation
of 1–4 systems similar to Cir X-1 in the Galaxy at any given time. Thus, the fact that Cir X-1 exists
but is unique is consistent with binary evolution calculations.
10.4.2 Predicted System Parameters for Cir X-1
In addition to determining the lifetime of systems that resemble Cir X-1, the Monte Carlo simulation
was also used to study the distribution of system parameters corresponding to 16.55 day orbital
periods and 10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 10−7 M⊙/yr.
Histograms of the number of binaries versus the initial donor mass and eccentricity for binaries
that eventually reach P = 16.55 d and 10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 10−7 M⊙/yr are shown in Figure 10-
4. The initial donor mass distribution shows that most progenitors of systems resembling Cir X-1
have donor stars more massive than the neutron star. As I will show below, these systems come into
contact and transfer mass due to the nuclear evolution of the donor. There is also smaller population
of low-mass systems (the peak below 1 M⊙) which evolve into contact through angular momentum
losses (tides and magnetic braking). The initial eccentricity distribution includes all values above
e = 0.33 and is skewed toward higher eccentricity, peaking near e = 0.9.
Figure 10-5 shows histograms of the number of systems versus various system parameters for
binaries at the time they reach a state resembling Cir X-1: P = 16.55 d and 10−9 M⊙/yr < M <
10−7 M⊙/yr. The donor mass distribution peaks at about 1.25 M⊙ and is almost entirely confined
to Mdon < 1.5 M⊙. This is a reflection of the fact that most systems that reach 16.55 d periods
during mass transfer are in the stage of increasing orbital period, which can occur only after the
donor has become less massive than the neutron star. The core mass distribution shows that most
166
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
Figure 10-4: Histograms of number of binaries versus initial Mdon and e which eventually reach
P = 16.55 d and 1×10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 1×10−7 M⊙/yr. The y-axis normalization is arbitrary.
10.4. MONTE-CARLO POPULATION SYNTHESIS
167
Figure 10-5: Histograms of the number of binaries versus various system parameters at the time
when systems resemble Cir X-1, i.e., P = 16.55 d and 1×10−9 M⊙/yr < M < 1×10−7 M⊙/yr. The
y-axis normalization is arbitrary.
168
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
systems have developed a moderate core of 0.10–0.16 M⊙, indicating that nuclear evolution is driving
transfer in most of the systems. A small fraction of donor stars with a low core mass correspond to
the lower-mass systems which evolve mainly through angular momentum losses.
The eccentricity distribution is constrained to high values, showing a peak between e = 0.83 −
−0.93. A tail extending above e = 0.93 corresponds to the angular-momentum driven systems. The
fact that no systems with low eccentricity have a 16.55-day orbit during mass transfer is due to the
large periastron separation for a system with a ≈ 30–40 R⊙ (as required for two stars with nearly
equal masses, ∼ 1 M⊙, and P = 16.55 d) and small eccentricity. For such systems, the critical lobe
exceeds the donor size and no mass transfer will occur.
The luminosity of the donor star in most systems is less than about 13 L⊙, as expected for a
low-mass star that is not highly evolved. The optical and infrared magnitudes of the donor are
discussed below.
The mass transfer rate is roughly uniform between 10−8–10−7 M⊙/yr (3×10−8 M⊙/yr is approx-
imately the Eddington limit for a 1.4 M⊙ neutron star) and falls off gradually below 10−8 M⊙/yr.
There is also a narrow peak in the distribution at about 3×10−9 M⊙/yr, corresponding to the
angular-momentum driven systems.
The ages of systems when reaching a stage that resembles Cir X-1 are typically 4×107 to 1×109.
Systems older than about 1×109 are mainly the angular-momentum driven systems. All of the
systems are significantly older than the young age (∼30000–100000 yr) that would be implied for
Cir X-1 if it were associated with the nearby supernova remnant. Thus this model implies that
association with the supernova remnant is inconsistent with the assumption that Cir X-1 has a
low-mass companion.
The optical and infrared absolute magnitudes (V, R, I, J, & K) of the donor star the systems
that resemble Cir X-1 are shown in Figure 10-6. Most donors have a V magnitude of 2–4. Assuming
a distance of 8 kpc for Cir X-1 (see section 1.3.4), the distance modulus is -14.5 magnitudes. Using
this and a visual extinction of AV ∼ 4 (see section 1.3.6), the mean absolute visual magnitude of
V ∼ 3 in Figure 10-6 corresponds to a apparent magnitude of mV ∼ 21.5, which is very similar to
the non-flaring component of the observed visual magnitude [50]. A higher visual extinction would
further increase the apparent visual magnitude, making the donor star fainter than the observed
magnitude and requiring a contribution from the accretion disk.
The K-band absolute magnitude in Figure 10-6 is ∼1–3 for most donors. Applying the same
distance modulus correction as above (and ignoring the much smaller extinction in at this longer
wavelength), gives an estimated apparent K magnitude of about 16.5, which is more than 4 mag-
nitudes fainter than the observed non-flaring value [24]. Thus, the K-band flux of a low-mass
10.4. MONTE-CARLO POPULATION SYNTHESIS
169
Figure 10-6: Optical and infrared absolute magnitudes (V,R,I,J,K) of the donor star in systems
that resemble Cir X-1, i.e., those from Figure 10-5. The y-axis normalization of the histograms is
arbitrary.
170
CHAPTER 10. ECCENTRIC BINARY EVOLUTION
companion is much too faint to account for the observed flux, implying a significant contribution
from the accretion disk (X-ray heating of the companion would be a variable contribution due to
the different viewing angles around the orbit). Thus, the optical and infrared magnitudes of donor
stars in the modeled systems are not inconsistent with (brighter than) the observed fluxes.
10.5 Conclusions
The eccentric binary evolution code developed for this chapter has shown that a system such as
Cir X-1 can be naturally produced with a low-mass companion. A population synthesis study based
on this code has shown that the number of systems expected to resemble Cir X-1 is consistent with
its unique status in the Galaxy. These results also strongly favor a high eccentricity and donor less
massive than the neutron star as current system parameters. Currently the orbital period is the only
well-established orbital parameter of the system, making detailed comparison of the evolution results
to actual values difficult. For example, in most cases, systems reached 16.55-d periods during mass
transfer while unbinding (P increasing). However, if the current ephemeris equation (equation 1.1) is
to be taken literally, the period may be decreasing rapidly. If such a change becomes well established,
then this would be a significant constraint on models for the system. Furthermore, if Cir X-1 truly is
a young LMXB (105 yr) associated with a nearby supernova remnant (see Chapter 1), then it must
have evolved through a different scenario (i.e., Mdon > 3 M⊙) than the LMXB model developed
here, which generally requires ages of at least 4×107 yr.
This evolution code (or a slightly modified version that allows circular orbits) can also be applied
to other systems and can be used as the basis for a population synthesis study of LMXB properties
in general. Some of this spin-off work is already in progress.
Chapter 11
Conclusions
The All-Sky Monitor light curve of Cir X-1 has shown consistent flaring above a steady, bright
baseline, as well as significant variety among intensity profiles of each cycle.
I have developed
computer codes to calculate theoretical accretion-rate profiles for an eccentric binary in which mass
transfer occurs via Roche-lobe overflow or via a stellar wind. These profiles generally show much
less structure than the X-ray intensity profile. The theoretical profiles show that mass transfer is
strongly peaked near periastron (in the case of a stellar wind and moderate eccentricity) or entirely
confined to phases near periastron (for Roche-lobe overflow). The fact that the intensity of Cir X-1
maintains a high baseline level at all orbital phases might be related to the gradual emptying of the
accretion disk (not included in the models). More difficult to understand is the strong mid-phase
flares that sometimes occur in the X-ray light curve, when the neutron star and donor star are
believed to be relatively far apart (near apastron).
I developed a binary evolution code for an eccentric low-mass X-ray binary. About 15% of systems
drawn from a post-supernova population of pre-LMXBs [73] were found to possess parameters that
might be similar to those of Cir X-1 during some stage of their evolution. On average, each LMXB
system resembled Cir X-1 for 4×105 yrs. This result implies that the number of systems in the
Galaxy that should currently resemble Cir X-1 should be of order a unity, consistent with its unique
status as an eccentric LMXB with a high accretion rate.
Our multi-frequency campaigns showed that the current X-ray, radio, and infrared flaring all
occur within a day of each other, shortly after phase zero. Unfortunately recent radio flares have
been very weak, allowing only marginal detection of the flares. Clearly, a return of bright radio
flares would be a welcomed opportunity to study correlated behavior in more detail. Infrared pho-
tometry on timescale shorter that hours might also prove useful in future campaigns. Optical and
171
172
CHAPTER 11. CONCLUSIONS
IR spectroscopy carried out during our second multi-frequency campaign showed evidence for emis-
sion lines with high-velocity Doppler shifts (∼300–400 km/s). Compared with similar measurements
made with the Hubble Space Telescope [47], these observations strongly suggest the need for a spec-
troscopy study around an entire 16.55-d cycle in order to search for evidence of the binary orbit.
Another promising future project is the attempt to detect the angular velocity (proper motion) of
the system away from the supernova remnant with which it might be associated [67], thus establish-
ing that the system is young. This project will require precise radio astrometry using VLBI (very
long baseline interferometry). Preliminary work for the proper motion study was recently carried
out at ATCA by R. Fender.
In this project I have used extensive RXTE observations of Circinus X-1 to characterize much
of the complex behavior exhibited by the source. Based on several timing and spectral studies, I
classify the variability we have observed from Cir X-1 into three categories: (1) absorption dips, (2)
motion along a Z-source hardness-intensity track, and (3) shifts of the Z-source hardness-intensity
track. I will now summarize the main characteristics associated with each type of variability.
Absorption dips generally occur within the 0.5 d before to 1.5 d after phase zero and last sec-
onds to hours in duration. During dips, the intensity drops below the baseline intensity level while
hardness ratios initially increase, but then return to a low value during strong dips. A faint com-
ponent (∼10% of the total flux) remains unaffected by the heavy absorption, and is probably due
to scattering by material distributed over a larger region than the X-ray source itself. This con-
clusion is similar to that presented by Brandt et al. [12] based on ASCA observations of a single
low-to-high transition. Here I have shown that multiple dips occur near phase zero in a complex and
cycle-dependent manner, as might be expected for obscuration due to inhomogeneities in the mass
transfer stream or intermittent "bumps" on the outer edge of the accretion disk. I have shown that
the evolution of the energy spectrum throughout transitions into dips is consistent with a variably
absorbed bright component and faint unobscured component, and that an iron emission line present
both inside and outside dips appears to be associated with the faint (scattered) component. I have
also identified the curved tracks that absorption dips produce in color-color and hardness intensity
diagrams. The tracks are similar to those due to dips in the black-hole candidates GRO J1655-40
and 4U 1630-47 [36, 74]. Having recognized spectral tracks due to absorption, I was able to focus
other studies on other behavior that may be more intrinsic to the source.
I have identified much of the current behavior of Cir X-1 as that of a Z-source low-mass X-ray bi-
nary. Hardness-intensity diagrams show that the track for Cir X-1 (e.g., Figure 6-4) differs somewhat
from the canonical "Z" track (see Figure 1-1), but the timing characteristics on the branches strongly
support the Z-source interpretation. In hardness-intensity diagrams, the "horizontal branch" (HB)
173
in Cir X-1 becomes almost vertical on the left end. Power density spectra of Cir X-1 from times cor-
responding to the vertical portion of the HB show horizontal-branch QPOs that evolve in frequency
between 1.3 Hz and 30 Hz (increasing in frequency moving down the branch). On the horizontal
portion of the HB, this QPO occurs at ∼30–35 Hz and fades in strength, becoming only a "knee" in
the power spectrum. A broad peak begins to arise near 4 Hz in power spectra from the horizontal
portion of the HB. This peak becomes a prominent normal-branch QPO on the NB, and remains
centered near 4 Hz. The flaring branch for Cir X-1 generally turns above rather than below the
normal branch (although it's orientation depends on the energy bands used in the hardness ratio).
No QPOs are present in power spectra from the flaring branch.
The energy spectrum on the horizontal branch of Cir X-1 is fit well with a two-component model
consisting of a soft disk blackbody and a higher-temperature blackbody (presumably from closer
to the surface). In this model, motion along the HB is mainly associated with an increasing inner
radius of the disk, implying that as the luminosity increases across the HB, the inner edge of the
disk moves further away from the surface (contrary to expectations that the higher luminosity, and
thus probably higher mass accretion rate, should result in a decrease in the radius of the inner edge
of the disk). Energy spectra on the normal branch indicate that the hard blackbody fades away,
leaving only the disk blackbody. On the lower NB, a feature in the spectrum develops above 10 keV.
This feature becomes more prominent on the flaring branch.
When the intensity of Cir X-1 is at the "quiescent" (1.0 Crab) level, it is generally on the vertical
portion of the HB. Much of the "flaring" activity above the "quiescent" level corresponds to motion
across the HB. From the HB/NB apex, the intensity can decrease either down the normal branch
(with hardness correlated with intensity) or back across the HB. The lower end of the normal branch
is often at a similar intensity level to that of the vertical HB; however, from the low-intensity end of
the normal branch, small bursts or "mini-flares" occur, resulting in motion up the flaring branch and
producing very low frequency noise (VLFN) in the power spectrum. Bildsten [7, 8] has proposed
that VLFN in low mass X-ray binaries is produced by small patches on the neutron-star surface
burning intermittently due to slow non-convective combustion, rather than the rapid ignition of the
entire surface which occurs in type I bursts. The "flares" or "bursts" seen on the flaring branch in
Z sources, and Cir X-1 in particular, may be part of a continuous range from weak VLFN bursts,
to small flares, to type I bursts.
I have shown that some of the variability in Cir X-1 is due to shifts of the "Z" track in hardness-
intensity diagrams. These shifts are at least in part related to the cycling hardness ratios we observe
with the All-Sky Monitor, i.e., gradual hardening of the spectrum during much of the 16.55-d cycle
and more rapid hardening of the spectrum at the onset of the flaring state. There is a tendency for
174
CHAPTER 11. CONCLUSIONS
horizontal-branch behavior to occur at the low-intensity, hard portion of the cycle, and normal or
flaring-branch behavior to occur during high-intensity, soft portions of the cycle. Thus, evolution of
the timing properties versus orbital phase is related to both the shifting Z-track and motion around
the Z track. Clearly this can produce behavior more complicated than we observed in our first set
of observations, presented in Chapter 4.
Although there is still much to be understood about the physical mechanisms responsible for
the correlated spectral and timing behavior in Cir X-1, this project has demonstrated that these
unanswered questions for Cir X-1 are related to similar issues in an entire class of systems (Z sources).
In fact, some of the unique features of the behavior of Cir X-1 may prove useful in future studies of
the Z and atoll classes of low-mass X-ray binaries.
If the baseline intensity level of Cir X-1 decreases from its current bright level, it will provide
an opportunity to test the hypothesis that Cir X-1 shows atoll-source behavior at lower mass-
accretion rates. Establishing the existence of a source showing the behavior of both classes under
different conditions would be helpful in determining the physical distinctions between the classes
(e.g., different magnetic fields would be ruled out).
Aspects of the behavior of Cir X-1 that differ from that of typical Z sources may also provide
important constraints on models for Z-source behavior. For example, models of horizontal-branch
oscillations (typically observed at 13–60 Hz) will have to address what physical property (e.g., mass,
spin, or magnetic field of the compact object) of Cir X-1 results in significantly lower-frequency
HBOs (1.3–35 Hz). Also, the large shifts of the Z-track in hardness-intensity diagrams for Cir X-1,
and the fact that such shifts are associated with the 16.55-d orbital cycle of Cir X-1, are not explained
by the hypothesis that mass accretion rate increases along the Z track. Kuulkers et al. [33, 35, 34]
have suggested that secular shifts in several Z sources are due to inclination effects. However, the
shifts in those sources were not observed to occur periodically as in Cir X-1, nor were the shifts as
large (see section 5.4.4). Another possibility is, if accretion occurs both through a disk and through
a spherical inflow (or other means), then the accretion rate of each component may be responsible
for one aspect of the observed behavior.
In the past, the unique status of Cir X-1 among X-ray binaries has often resulted in its being
relegated to the discussion of "other sources". The results presented here show that Cir X-1 has
much in common with other low-mass X-ray binaries and that its unusual features may provide the
opportunity to study a system with somewhat atypical physical parameters.
Appendix A
Fourier Timing Techniques
A.1
Introduction
Temporal analysis in X-ray astronomy is generally accomplished through examination of the Fourier
power density spectrum (PDS) and complex cross spectrum. The following is a brief review of some
of the standard techniques that are directly applicable to RXTE data (see van der Klis [76], e.g.,
for a more complete discussion of standard techniques). In addition, specific formulae are derived
to show how the analysis software handles such complications as data gaps and variable number of
detectors.
The analysis software we developed at M.I.T. operates on time series data stored in "DS (DataS-
tream)" format, which dynamically changes storage format to reduce file sizes, and allows data to
be piped between programs to chain together several tasks. These features result in smaller files
and faster processing than the standard FTOOLS package provided by NASA. Useful information
can be stored as keywords in header blocks of DS files. Since the timing programs in particular
rely heavily on using keyword parameters, keyword names will be referenced in the throughout this
appendix, which is intended to provide documentation to our software.
175
176
APPENDIX A. FOURIER TIMING TECHNIQUES
A.2 Power Density Spectra
A.2.1 Leahy Normalization
The discrete Fourier transform of a time series of N bins (keyword NUMPOINT) containing counts
xk (k = 0, .., N − 1) is
aj =
N −1
Xk=0
xke2πijk/N ,
j = −N/2, ..., N/2 − 1.
(A.1)
Frequency bin j corresponds to a frequency of ν = j/T = j/N tb, where T is the total duration of the
time series and tb is the duration of a single time bin. The normalization used by Leahy et al. [40]
defines the power in frequency bin j to be
Pj =
2
Nphaj2,
j = 0, ..., N/2
(A.2)
where Nph is the total number of photons in the transform. In this normalization, the distribution
of powers for Poisson counting noise has a mean value of 2 and obeys the χ2 distribution with 2
degrees of freedom. This has the advantage of straightforward estimation of the significance of high
points in the PDS.
A.2.2 Estimate of the Poisson Noise Level
Real time series data always contains counting noise (x = xsource + xnoise). This adds power
P = Psource + Pnoise.
In the absence of detector effects, Poisson counting noise produces a constant power equal to 2
in the Leahy normalization. However, detector dead-time effects result in a Poisson-level that varies
with Fourier frequency. Zhang et al. [88, 89] (see also [51]) have calculated this effect to be
< Pnoise(ν) >= 2[1 − 2r0τd(1 −
τd
2tb
)] − 2
N − 1
N
r0τd(
τd
tb
) cos(2πtbν) + 2rvler0τ 2
vle[
sin(πτvleν)
πτvleν
)]2,
(A.3)
where r0 is the count rate per PCU detector, τd is the dead time per event (10 µs for the PCA), tb
is the time bin size, and N is the number of time bins in the transformed segment. The last term
accounts for dead time due to very large events (VLEs), occurring at a rate rvle per PCU with a
dead-time window (τvle) of 55 µs or 155 µs for each VLE [89].
A.2. POWER DENSITY SPECTRA
177
A.2.3 Fractional RMS Variability
Dividing a Leahy-normalized PDS by the mean count rate from the source results in a normalization
giving the square of the fractional root-mean-squared variability per Hz. In this normalization, the
square root of the integrated power under a PDS feature (such as a QPO peak) gives the fractional
rms variability of the intensity due to that feature.
The average total count rate per second (keyword RATE) is
R =
1
tbPN
k=1 xk
N
=
¯x
tb
.
However, to obtain the mean rate of the source R
′
, the background b must be subtracted:
′
R
=
1
tbPN
k=1(xk − bk)
N
=
1
tb
(¯x − ¯b) = R − B,
(A.4)
(A.5)
where B is the average background rate per second (keyword BKGD). Generally, the average back-
ground rate is estimated from slew data or other means modeled with software provided with the
FTOOLS package.
A.2.4 Estimates of Power Variance
The variance of powers in the Leahy normalization is 4 (so σ = 2 = µ). The variance of the mean
power from M consecutive frequency bins or from W PDSs is:
σµ =
2
√M W
.
(A.6)
However, intrinsic noise from the source often causes the actual variance of the averaged powers to
exceed the theoretical variance. Thus, a useful error estimate is derived from the sample variance
resulting from averaging M W powers Pi, i = 1, .., M W (dropping the frequency index for clarity):
s2 =
1
M W − 1
MW
Xi=1
(P 2
i − < P >2)
The sample variance of the mean power is
s2
µ =
s2
M W
=
1
M W (M W − 1)
MW
Xi=1
(P 2
i − < P >2)
(A.7)
(A.8)
178
APPENDIX A. FOURIER TIMING TECHNIQUES
A.2.5 Data Gaps
Ideally, each PDS should be derived from a continuous time series with no gaps. However, gaps are
common in real data, making it necessary to work with partially filled (but not sparse) time series'.
The simplest way to handle data gaps is to fill the empty bins with the mean number of counts per
bin. (In practice the mean is subtracted from the data to suppress the DC term in the PDS, so
unoccupied bins are filled with zeros.) To compensate for an incomplete time series, averages should
be weighted by the fraction exposure f , the fraction of occupied bins in the time series (keyword
FILL). I.e., in averaging M frequency bins from each of W power spectra, each with fractional
exposure fw,
Likewise, the sample variance is
< P >= PM
m=1PW
m=1PW
PM
w=1 fwPmw
w=1 fw
s2 =
which can be re-expressed as
1
w=1 fw − 1
PM
m=1PW
M
W
Xm=1
(P 2
mw− < P >2)
Xw=1
(A.9)
(A.10)
(A.11)
(A.12)
s2 = PM
m=1PW
PM
m=1PW
w=1 fw
w=1 fw − 1
(< P 2 > − < P >2)
. Finally, the sample variance of the mean power is
where < P 2 >= PM
m=1PW
m=1PW
PM
w=1
fw P 2
mw
fw
w=1
s2
µ =
s2
w=1 fw
PM
m=1PW
=
< P 2 > − < P >2
PM
m=1PW
w=1 fw − 1
Both < P > and < P 2 > are saved in the PDS files and used in error estimates (COL keywords
with PDS and PDS2 labels).
A.2.6 Variable Number of Detectors
For instrument safety, one or more of the five proportional counter units (PCUs) of the PCA may
be shut off during an observation. Transforms are not performed for time segments which include a
discontinuous detector turn-on/turn-off. However, separate PDSs with different numbers of PCUs
turned on, ¯pw (keyword NUMPCU), can still be averaged if care is taken to handle the various
parameters properly. When averaging W PDSs the combined average of the number of PCUs on,
¯pw (keyword NUMPCU), is weighted by the total number of occupied bins nw = WwNwfw (from
A.2. POWER DENSITY SPECTRA
keywords NUMFFT × NUMPOINT × FILL):
179
(A.13)
= PW
w=1 nw ¯pw
ntot
w=1 nw ¯pw
w=1 nw
¯p = PW
PW
where ntot is the total number of occupied bins. Alternately, the PCU average can be expressed as
p=1 npp/ntot, where np is the number of bins with p PCUs on.
¯p =P5
For the rms normalization, the relevant rates are those actually observed, regardless of the number
of detectors involved. Thus, the combined average rate and background rate from W PDSs, each
with average rate ¯xw and background rate ¯bw, are simply weighted by the number of occupied bins:
¯x = PW
w=1 nw ¯xw
ntot
,
¯b = PW
w=1 nw¯bw
ntot
.
(A.14)
Deadtime effects in each PCU are independent of the other PCUs, so the average rate per PCU
r0 used in the Poisson-level estimate (equation A.3) should be weighted by the number of PCUs on:
r0 =
p=1 npp ¯xp
p
p=1 npp
1
tbP5
P5
=
1
tbP5
p=1 np ¯xp
ntot ¯p
(A.15)
where ¯xp is the average number of counts in all time bins having p PCUs on. The numerator of the
last term above is simply the total number of counts, which is equal to ntot ¯x. Thus, the average
rate per PCU reduces to
r0 =
1
tb
¯x
¯p
=
R
¯p
.
(A.16)
The Poisson-level estimate also requires the average product per PCU of the VLE rate and the good
count rate. For a constant number of PCUs p:
< rvler0 >p=
1
t2
k=1 p vk
p
k=1 p
b Pntot
Pntot
xk
p
=
1
t2
b Pntot
k=1 vkxk
ntotp2
,
(A.17)
where vk is the VLE rate per bin. The average over different numbers of PCUs must be based on
the number of occupied bins for each p:
< rvler0 >= P5
p=1 npp
P5
p=1 npp < rvler0 >p
p=1 npp < rvler0 >p
.
(A.18)
= P5
ntot ¯p
(The keyword VLEP saves this VLE product as ¯p2 < rvler0 > to be consistent with the RATE and
BKGD keywords, which are not per PCU.)
180
APPENDIX A. FOURIER TIMING TECHNIQUES
A.3 Complex Cross Spectra
The Fourier transforms of a time series in two energy channels can be used to produce a complex
cross spectrum in addition to the two power density spectra. Using the same notation as for the
PDS (see above), the cross spectrum derived from two Fourier transforms aj and bj is defined as
Cj = aj
∗bj,
j = 0, ..., N/2.
(A.19)
A.3.1 Time Lags
The argument of the complex-valued cross spectrum is the phase delay (in radians) between intensity
fluctuations in the two channels (once again dropping the frequency subscript):
δφ = arctan(cid:18) Im(C)
Re(C)(cid:19) = arctan(cid:18) Re(a)Im(b) − Im(a)Re(b)
Re(a)Re(b) + Im(a)Im(b)(cid:19) .
(A.20)
This is easily converted to a time delay via δt = δφ/2πν. A positive value of δt indicates that
intensity fluctuations in the second channel lag those in the first.
A.3.2 Coherence Function
The magnitude of the cross spectrum can be used to derive the coherence function between two
channels. The coherence function is a measure of the degree of linear correlation between the two
time series at each Fourier frequency [81]. For noiseless signals, the coherence function is defined as
γ2 =
< a∗b > 2
< a∗a >< b∗b >
, = < C > 2
< P1 >< P2 >
(A.21)
where P1 and P2 are the power spectra derived from a and b respectively and the angle brackets
denote an average over m independent measurements (ideally m → ∞).
For signals with Poison counting noise, the quantities used in equation A.21 should be for the
source only, thus
γ2 = < (a − anoise)∗(b − bnoise) > 2
< P1 − P1,noise >< P2 − P2,noise >
γ2 = < a∗b > − < a∗bnoise > − < anoise
∗b > + < anoise
< P1 − P1,noise >< P2 − P2,noise >
∗bnoise > 2
(A.22)
(A.23)
γ2 = < C > − < a∗bnoise > − < anoise
∗b > + < Cnoise > 2
< P1 − P1,noise >< P2 − P2,noise >
.
(A.24)
According to Vaughan and Nowak [81], in the Gaussian limit the numerator in equation A.24
A.3. COMPLEX CROSS SPECTRA
can be expressed as
< Csource > 2 = < C > 2− < n2 >,
181
(A.25)
where n2 ≡ (P1,sourceP2,noise + P1,noiseP2,source + P1,noiseP2,noise)/m. Thus, the intrinsic source
coherence function can be expressed in terms of the observed powers and cross spectra and the
estimated Poisson noise powers:
γ2 = < C > 2 − (P1,sourceP2,noise + P1,noiseP2,source + P1,noiseP2,noise)/m
< P1 − P1,noise >< P2 − P2,noise >
.
(A.26)
182
APPENDIX A. FOURIER TIMING TECHNIQUES
Appendix B
Standard PCA Light Curves
This appendix contains standard 20-kilosecond light curves of all our 1996–1997 PCA observations
of Cir X-1. By displaying all data with a uniform scale, the wide range of variability and intensity
levels is apparent.
Each 20-ks panel is labelled along the right side with the letter of the study with which it was
associated (A–H, see Table 3.1) and several time labels referring to time zero of that panel: the
truncated Julian date (JD-2450000.5), the calendar date (YR-MO-DAY), the mission elapsed time
(MET = seconds since 1994 Jan. 1.0), and the orbital phase (see equation 1.1).
The counting rates are derived from 16 s time bins over the full PCA energy band and are the
average rates from PCUs 0, 1, and 2, which were operating during all observations (PCUs 3 and
4 were often switched off). A counting rate of 2.6 kcts/s corresponds to an intensity of ∼1.0 Crab
(1060 µJy at 5.2 keV). Background is not subtracted but is negligible. The data have not been
corrected for detector deadtime; such corrections would increase the baseline 1 Crab level by about
5% and the peak 2.7 Crab level by about 13%.
183
184
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
185
186
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
187
188
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
189
190
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
191
192
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
193
194
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
195
196
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
197
198
APPENDIX B. STANDARD PCA LIGHT CURVES
Bibliography
[1] M. Ali Alpar and Jacob Shaham. Is GX 5-1 a millisecond pulsar? Nature, 316:239–241, 1985.
[2] T. Augusteijn et al. Coordinated X-ray and optical observations of Scorpius X-1. The Astro-
physical Journal, 265:177–182, 1992.
[3] Yoram Avni. The eclipse duration of the X-ray pulsar 3U 0900-40. The Astrophysical Journal,
209:574–577, 1976.
[4] Christopher M. Becker. Studies of Supersoft X-ray Sources in the ROSAT Database of Pointed
Observations. PhD thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1997.
[5] T. Belloni and G. Hasinger. An atlas of aperiodic variability in HMXB. Astronomy and
Astrophysics, 230:103–119, 1990.
[6] T. Belloni and G. Hasinger. Variability in the noise properties of Cygnus X-1. Astronomy and
Astrophysics, 227:L33–L36, 1990.
[7] Lars Bildsten. Rings of fire: Nuclear burning as the origin of sub-Hertz noise and weak X-ray
bursts in accreting neutron stars. The Astrophysical Journal, 418:L21–L24, 1993.
[8] Lars Bildsten. Propagation of nuclear burning fronts on accreting neutron stars: X-ray bursts
and sub-Hertz noise. The Astrophysical Journal, 438:852–875, 1995.
[9] H. Bondi and F. Hoyle. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 104:273, 1944.
[10] H. V. Bradt, R. E. Rothschild, and J. H. Swank. X-ray Timing Explorer mission. Astronomy
and Astrophysics Supplement Series, 97:355–360, 1993.
[11] Hale Bradt, Robert Shirey, and Alan Levine. Observations of Circinus X-1 with RXTE. In
L. Scarsi, H. Bradt, P. Giommi, and F. Fiore, editors, Nuclear Physics B Proceedings Supple-
ments, The Active X-ray Sky: Results from Beppo-SAX and Rossi-XTE. Elsevier Science B. V.,
1998.
199
200
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[12] W. N. Brandt, A. Fabian, T. Dotani, F. Nagase, H. Inoue, and T. Kotani. ASCA observations
of the iron K complex of Circinus X-1 near zero phase: spectral evidence for partial covering.
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 283:1071–1082, 1996.
[13] Deepto Chakrabarty and Edward H. Morgan. The 2 hour orbit of the bursting millisecond
X-ray pulsar SAX J1808-3658. Submitted to Nature, 1998.
[14] L. Chiapetti and S. J. Bell Burnell. X-ray observations of Circinus X-1 in its low state. Monthly
Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 200:1025–1031, 1982.
[15] R. Di Stefano, L. A. Nelson, W. Lee, T. Wood, and S. Rappaport. Luminous supersoft X-ray
sources as type Ia progenitors.
In R. Canal and P. Lapuente-Ruiz, editors, Thermonuclear
Supernovae, page 147, 1996.
[16] Richard G. Dower, Hale V. Bradt, and Edward H. Morgan. Circinus X-1: X-ray observations
with SAS 3. The Astrophysical Journal, 261:228–250, 1982.
[17] A. R. Duncan, R. T. Stewart, and R. F. Haynes. Hα position determination of the binary
Circinus X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 265:157–160, 1993.
[18] P. Eggleton. Approximations to the radii of Roche lobes. The Astrophysical Journal, 268:368–
369, 1983.
[19] P. P. Eggleton. Evolutionary Processes in Binary and Multiple Stars. Cambridge Press, Cam-
bridge, 1997.
[20] B. Fortner, F. K. Lamb, and G. S. Miller. Origin of 'normal-branch' quasiperiodic oscillations
in low-mass X-ray binary systems. Nature, 342:775–777, 1989.
[21] J. Garc´ia-S´anchez and J. M. Paredes. Particle injection in the Circinus X-1 radio outbursts.
Astronomy and Astrophysics, 323:867–880, 1997.
[22] R. Giaconni. Scorpius x-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 9:L439, 1962.
[23] I. S. Glass. Variations of Circinus X-1 in the infrared. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical
Society, 183:335–340, 1978.
[24] I. S. Glass. Long-term infrared behavior of Cir X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical
Society, 268:742–748, 1994.
[25] W. M. Goss and U. Mebold. The distance of Cir X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical
Society, 181:255–258, 1977.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
201
[26] Amos Harpaz, Saul Rappaport, and Noam Soker. The rings around the Egg Nebula. The
Astrophysical Journal, 487:809–817, 1997.
[27] G. Hasinger and M. van der Klis. Two patterns of correlated X-ray timing and spectral be-
haviour in low-mass X-ray binaries. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 225:79–96, 1989.
[28] G. Hasinger, M. van der Klis, K. Ebisawa, T. Dotani, and K. Mitsuda. Multifrequency observa-
tions of Cygnus X-2: X-ray observations with Ginga. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 235:131–146,
1990.
[29] P. Hut. Tidal evolution in close binary systems. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 99:126–140, 1981.
[30] P. C. Joss. Helium-burning flashes on an accreting neutron star - A model for X-ray burst
sources. The Astrophysical Journal, 225:L123–L127, 1978.
[31] Paul C. Joss and Saul A. Rappaport. Neutron stars in interacting binary systems. Annual
Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics, 22:537–592, 1984.
[32] L. J. Kaluzienski, S. S. Holt, E. A. Boldt, and P. J. Serlemitsos. Evidence for a 16.6 day period
from Circinus X-1. The Astrophysical Journal, 208:L71–L75, 1976.
[33] E. Kuulkers and M. van der Klis. GX 340+0 with EXOSAT: Its correlated X-ray spectral and
timing behavior. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 314:567–575, 1996.
[34] E. Kuulkers, M. van der Klis, T. Oosterbroek, K. Asai, T. Dotani, J. van Paradijs, and W. G. H.
Lewin. Spectral and correlated timing behavior of GX 5-1. Astronomy and Astrophysics,
289:795–821, 1994.
[35] E. Kuulkers, M. van der Klis, and B. A. Vaughan. Secular variations in the Z source Cygnus
X-2. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 311:197–210, 1996.
[36] E. Kuulkers, R. Wijnands, T. Belloni, Mario Mendez, M. van der Klis, and J. van Paradijs.
Absorption dips in the light curves of GRO J1655-40 and 4U 1630-47 during ourburst. The
Astrophysical Journal, 494:753–758, 1998.
[37] F. K. Lamb, N. Shibazaki, M. A. Alpar, and J. Shaham. Quasi-periodic oscillations in the
bright galactic-bulge X-ray sources. Nature, 317:681–687, 1985.
[38] P. Lamb and P. W. Sanford. Compton scattering effects observed in Sco X-1 and similar sources.
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 188:555–563, 1979.
[39] L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz. The Classical Theory of Fields. Pergamon, Oxford, 1962.
202
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[40] D. A. Leahy, W. Darbro, R. F. Elsner, M. C. Weisskopf, P. G. Sutherland, S. Kahn, and
J. E. Grindlay. On searches for pulsed emission with application to four globular cluster X-ray
sources: NGC 1851, 6441, 6624, and 6712. The Astrophysical Journal, 266:160–170, 1983.
[41] Myron Lecar, J. Craig Wheeler, and Christopher F. McKee. Tidal circularization of the binary
X-ray sources Hercules X-1 and Centaurus X-1. The Astrophysical Journal, 205:556–562, 1976.
[42] Alan M. Levine, Hale Bradt, Wei Cui, J. G. Jernigan, Edward H. Morgan, Ronald Remillard,
Robert E. Shirey, and Donald A. Smith. First results from the All-Sky Monitor on the Rossi
X-ray Timing Explorer. The Astrophysical Journal, 469:L33–L36, 1996.
[43] W. G. H. Lewin, J. van Paradijs, and E. P. J. van den Heuvel, editors. X-ray Binaries. Num-
ber 26 in Cambridge Astrophysics Series. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1995.
[44] Walter H. G. Lewin, Lori M. Lubin, Jianmin Tan, Michiel van der Klis, Jan van Paradijs, Wim
Penninx, Tadayasu Dotani, and Kazuhisa Mitsuda. Quasi-periodic oscillations in the Z source
GX 5-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 256:545–570, 1992.
[45] Yukihiro Makino. Circinus X-1 Observed with Ginga. PhD thesis, Osaka University, Japan,
1993.
[46] K. Makishima, Y. Maejima, K. Mitsuda, H. V. Bradt, R. A. Remillard, I. R. Tuohy, and
R. Hoshi. Simultaneous X-ray and optical observations of GX 339-4 in an X-ray high state.
The Astrophysical Journal, 308:635–643, 1986.
[47] R. Mignani, P. A. Caravoe, and G. F. Bignami. Assymmetric Hα disk emission dominates the
HST/FOS spectrum of Circinus X-1. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 323:797–800, 1997.
[48] M. Coleman Miller, Frederik K. Lamb, and Dimitrios Psaltis. Sonic-point model of kilohertz
quasi-periodic brightness oscillations in low-mass X-ray binaries. The Astrophysical Journal,
1998. in press.
[49] K. Mitsuda et al. Energy spectra of low-mass binary X-ray sources observed from Temna.
Publications of the Astronomical Society of Japan, 36:741–759, 1984.
[50] A. Moneti. Optical and infrared observations of Circinus X-1. Astronomy and Astrophysics,
260:L7–L10, 1992.
[51] E. H. Morgan, R. A. Remillard, and J. Greiner. RXTE observations of QPOs in the black hole
candidate GRS 1915+105. The Astrophysical Journal, 482:993–1010, 1997.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
203
[52] P. Murdin, D. L. Jauncey, R. F. Haynes, I. Lerche, G. D. Nicolson, S. S. Holt, and L. J.
Kluzienski. Binary model of Circinus X-1. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 87:292–298, 1980.
[53] G. D. Nicolson, M. W. Feast, and I. S. Glass. Recent changes in the optical, infrared and radio
emission from Circinus X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 191:293–299,
1980.
[54] T. Oosterbroek, M. van der Klis, E. Kuulkers, J. van Paradijs, and W. G. H. Lewin. Circinus X-
1 revisited: Fast-timing properties in relation to spectral state. Astronomy and Astrophysics,
297:141–158, 1995.
[55] W. Penninx, W. G. H. Lewin, J. Tan, K. Mitsuda, M. van der Klis, and J. van Paradijs. Quasi-
periodic oscillations in the Z source GX 340+0. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical
Society, 249:113–121, 1991.
[56] P. Predehl and J. H. M. M. Schmitt. X-raying the interstellar medium: ROSAT observations
of dust scattering halos. Astronomy and Astrophysics, 293:889–905, 1995.
[57] William H. Press, Brian P. Flannery, Saul A. Teukolsky, and William T. Vetterling. Numerical
Recipies in C. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1988.
[58] S. Rappaport, P. C. Joss, and F. Verbunt. A new technique for calculations of binary stellar
evolution, with application to magnetic braking. The Astrophysical Journal, 275:713–731, 1983.
[59] S. Rappaport, P. C. Joss, and R. F. Webbink. The evolution of highly compact binary stellar
systems. The Astrophysical Journal, 254:616–640, 1982.
[60] S. Rappaport, Ph. Podsiadlowski, P. C. Joss, R. Di Stefano, and Z. Han. The relation between
white dwarf mass and orbital period in wide binary radio pulsars. Monthly Notices of the Royal
Astronomical Society, 273:731–741, 1995.
[61] Eric M. Schlegel (editor). The RXTE Technical Appendix. NASA / Goddard Space Flight
Center, Greenbelt, MD, 1995. Currently available via the world wide web or anonymous ftp at
ftp://legacy.gsfc.nasa.gov/xte/nra/appendix f/.
[62] Robert E. Shirey, Hale V. Bradt, Alan M. Levine, and Edward H. Morgan. X-ray timing and
spectral evolution of Circinus X-1 versus orbital phase with the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer.
The Astrophysical Journal, 469:L21–L24, 1996.
204
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[63] Robert E. Shirey, Hale V. Bradt, Alan M. Levine, and Edward H. Morgan. Quasi-periodic
oscillations associated with spectral branches in RXTE observations of Circinus X-1. The
Astrophysical Journal, 506, 1998.
[64] A. Skumanich. The Astrophysical Journal, 171:565, 1972.
[65] Alan P. Smale. A type i burst with radius expansion observed from Cygnus X-2 with the Rossi
X-ray Timing Explorer. The Astrophysical Journal, 498:L141–L145, 1998.
[66] M. A. Smith. Rotational studies of lower main-sequence stars. Publications of the Astronomical
Society of the Pacific, 91:737–745, 1979.
[67] R. T. Stewart, J. L.. Caswell, R. F. Haynes, and G. J. Nelson. Circinus X-1: A runaway binary
with curved radio jets. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 261:593–598, 1993.
[68] R. T. Stewart, G. J. Nelson, W. Penninx, S. Kitamoto, S. Miyamoto, and G. D. Nicolson. Long-
term infrared behavior of Circinus X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society,
253:212–216, 1991.
[69] A. F. Tennant. High-frequency oscillations from Cir X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astro-
nomical Society, 226:971–978, 1987.
[70] A. F. Tennant. Observations of 1.4-Hz quasi-periodic oscillations in Cir X-1. Monthly Notices
of the Royal Astronomical Society, 230:403–414, 1988.
[71] A. F. Tennant, A. C. Fabian, and R. A. Shafer. The discovery of X-ray bursts from Cir X-1.
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 219:871–881, 1986.
[72] A. F. Tennant, A. C. Fabian, and R. A. Shafer. Observations of type I X-ray bursts from
Cir X-1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 221:27P–31P, 1986.
[73] James L. Terman, Ronald E. Taam, and Craig O. Savage. A population synthesis study of low-
mass X-ray binary systems. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 281:552–564,
1996.
[74] J. A. Tomsick, I. Lapshov, and P. Kaaret. An X-ray dip in the X-ray transient 4U 1630-47.
The Astrophysical Journal, 494:747–752, 1998.
[75] Hiroshi Tsunemi, Shunji Kitamoto, Makoto Manabe, Shigengori Miyamoto, and Koujun Ya-
mashita. All Sky Monitor on board the Ginga satellite and its performance. Publications of the
Astronomical Society of Japan, 41:391–403, 1989.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
205
[76] M. van der Klis. Fourier techniques in X-ray timing.
In H. Ogelman and E. P. J. van den
Heuvel, editors, Timing Neutron Stars, pages 27–69. Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1989.
[77] M. van der Klis. Similarities in neutron star and black hole accretion. The Astrophysical Journal
Supplement Series, 92:511–519, 1994.
[78] M. van der Klis. Rapid aperiodic variability in X-ray binaries.
In W. G. H. Lewin, J. van
Paradijs, and E. P. J. van den Heuvel, editors, X-ray Binaries, pages 252–307. Cambridge
University Press, 1995.
[79] M. van der Klis. Kilohertz quasiperiodic oscillations in low-mass X-ray binaries. In R. Buccheri
and J. van Paradijs, editors, The Many Faces of Neutron Stars, page (in press). Dordrecht:
Kluwer, 1998.
[80] B. A. Vaughan et al. Searches for millisecond pulsations in low-mass X-ray binaries II. The
Astrophysical Journal, 435:362–371, 1994.
[81] Brian A. Vaughan and Michael A. Nowak. X-ray variability coherence: How to compute it,
what it means, and how it constrains models of GX 339-4 and Cygnus X-1. The Astrophysical
Journal, 474:L43–L46, 1997.
[82] F. Verbunt and C. Zwaan. Magnetic braking in low-mass X-ray binaries. Astronomy and
Astrophysics, 100:L7–L9, 1981.
[83] J. A. J. Whelan et al. The optical and radio counterpart of Circinus X-1 (3U 1516-56). Monthly
Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 181:259–271, 1977.
[84] Rudy Wijnands and Michiel van der Klis. KiloHertz quasi-periodic oscillations in the Z sources
GX 340+0, Cygnus X-2, GX 17+2, GX 5-1, and Scorpius X-1. In S. S. Holt and T. Kallman,
editors, Proceedings of the 8th Annual Astrophysics Conference in Maryland, 1997.
[85] Rudy Wijnands and Michiel van der Klis. Discovery of the first accretion-powered millisecond
X-ray pulsar. Submitted to Nature, 1998.
[86] K. S. Wood et al. Searches for millisecond pulsations in low-mass X-ray binaries. The Astro-
physical Journal, 379:295–309, 1991.
[87] K. Yoshida, K. Mitsuda, K. Ebisawa, Y. Ueda, R. Fujimoto, and T. Yaqoob. Low state prop-
erties of the low-mass X-ray binary X1608-522 observed with Ginga. Publications of the Astro-
nomical Society of Japan, 45:605–616, 1993.
206
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[88] W. Zhang, K. Jahoda, J. H. Swank, E. H. Morgan, and A. B. Giles. Dead-time modifications
to fast Fourier transform power spectra. The Astrophysical Journal, 449:930–935, 1995.
[89] W. Zhang, E. H. Morgan, K. Jahoda, J. H. Swank, T. E. Strohmayer, G. Jernigan, and R. I.
Klein. Quasi-periodic X-ray brightness oscillations of GRO J1744-28. The Astrophysical Journal,
469:L29–L32, 1996.
[90] W. Zhang, T. E. Strohmayer, and J. H. Swank. Discovery of two simultaneous kilohertz quasi-
periodic oscillations in the persistent flux of GX 349+2. The Astrophysical Journal, 500:L167–
L169, 1998.
|
astro-ph/0703610 | 2 | 0703 | 2007-03-26T11:01:26 | Color Intensity Projections: A simple way to display changes in astronomical images | [
"astro-ph"
] | To detect changes in repeated astronomical images of the same field of view (FOV), a common practice is to stroboscopically switch between the images. Using this method, objects that are changing in location or intensity between images are easier to see because they are constantly changing. A novel display method, called arrival time color intensity projections (CIPs), is presented that combines any number of grayscale images into a single color image on a pixel by pixel basis. Any values that are unchanged over the grayscale images look the same in the color image. However, pixels that change over the grayscale image have a color saturation that increases with the amount of change and a hue that corresponds to the timing of the changes. Thus objects moving in the grayscale images change from red to green to blue as they move across the color image. Consequently, moving objects are easier to detect and assess on the color image than on the grayscale images. A sequence of images of a comet plunging into the sun taken by the SOHO satellite (NASA/ESA) and Hubble Space Telescope images of a trans-Neptunian object (TNO) are used to demonstrate the method. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Page 1 of 9
Color Intensity Projections
A simple way to display changes in astronomical images
Keith S Cover1, Frank J. Lagerwaard1, Suresh Senan1
VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam1
Corresponding author:
Keith S Cover, PhD
VU University Medical Center
Post Box 7057
1007 MB Amsterdam
The Netherlands
Email: [email protected]
Accepted for publication by
Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
Abstract
To detect changes in repeated astronomical images of the same field of view (FOV), a
common practice is to stroboscopically switch between the images. Using this method,
objects that are changing in location or intensity between images are easier to see because
they are constantly changing. A novel display method, called arrival time color intensity
projections (CIPs), is presented that combines any number of grayscale images into a
single color image on a pixel by pixel basis. Any values that are unchanged over the
grayscale images look the same in the color image. However, pixels that change over the
grayscale image have a color saturation that increases with the amount of change and a
hue that corresponds to the timing of the changes. Thus objects moving in the grayscale
images change from red to green to blue as they move across the color image.
Consequently, moving objects are easier to detect and assess on the color image than on
the grayscale images. A sequence of images of a comet plunging into the sun taken by the
SOHO satellite (NASA/ESA) and Hubble Space Telescope images of a transNeptunian
object (TNO) are used to demonstrate the method.
Subject headings: methods: data analysis, techniques: image processing, comets: general
Page 2 of 9
1 INTRODUCTION
Detection of changes in a sequence of images of the same region of the sky is widely
used in astronomy to detect comets, asteroids, supernova, variable stars and other objects.
While there are several fully automated methods to detect these changes (Jewitt et al.
1998, Gladman 1998, Allen et al. 2001, Petit et al 2004), in many cases visual inspection
for these changes is still used both for detection and for reviewing the results of changes
detected automatically.
A commonly used method of visual inspection is to stroboscopically switch between
images. Alternately, if the comparison of only 2 or 3 images is required, the images are
sometimes displayed in the red, green and blue image planes (Buie et al. 2003). In the
resulting color image, constant objects appear grayscale while changing objects appear in
color. Buie et al. report the detection of changes by visual inspection to be much faster
for the three color method than the stroboscopic method. They also report the three color
method also allows the detection of some objects that have gone undetected by fully
automated methods. However, a major limitation of the three color method is that it is
limited to only 3 images because there are only 3 primary colors. Also, a major limitation
of any method that depends on visual inspection is that it requires human intervention
with all it complications including human error.
The method of color intensity projections (CIPs) was originally developed by the authors
for applications in medical imaging but it was apparent from the start that the method
may find useful applications in other fields including astronomy. The first publication of
CIPs demonstrated its use in presenting the motion of lung tumors and normal organs
during respiration (Cover et al. 2006). In the first version of CIPs, called percentage time
CIPs, the hue of the color is used to encode the percentage of time there is tissue in a
pixel. The second publication used the arrival time version of CIPs to visualize the flow
of blood into and out of the brain using an Xray contrast agent (Cover et al. 2007). The
arrival time version of CIPs is calculated by adding a preprocessing step to the
percentage time method. All the details of the arrival time CIPs method are described in
the references but are also included in this paper for convenience.
While the primary mission of the SOHO satellite is to constantly monitor the sun, it has a
long history of observing comets both grazing the sun and plunging into it (Sekanina
2002; Biesecker 2002). In particular, the LASCO C3 coronagraph of SOHO (Morrill et
al. 2006) has observed many of these comets. With its field of view extending from 3.8
Page 3 of 9
to 30 solar radii and images acquired dozens of times a day, the C3 coronagraph provides
ideal data for applying CIPs.
The detection of transNeptunian objects (TNO) rely on the changes from one
astronomical image to the next. Hubble Space Telescope (HST) (NASA/ESA) images of
the binary TNO 1998 WW31 are also used to demonstrated the CIPs display method
(Veillet et al. 2002)
2 METHOD
A total of 18 grayscale images of a comet plunging into the sun that were acquired by the
SOHO LASCO C3 coronagraph during November 2nd and 3rd, 2006 are used to
demonstrate the arrival time CIPs display technique. The images were cropped to 1014
by 690 pixels for processing and display purposes. In addition, six grayscale images of
the binary TNO 1998 WW31 acquired by the Hubble Space Telescope between July
2001 and February 2002 where also used for demonstration. The HST images were
cropped to 50 by 50 pixels for processing.
Grayscale images are characterized by a single value per pixel. While they are often
displayed in grayscale they can also be presented in false color. Color images are defined
by 3 values per pixel. The values may correspond to the intensity of the red, green and
blue components or some other numerical representation of color.
The first step in calculating an arrival time CIP image is to calculate a new image
sequence from the original time ordered sequence. The new sequence, which will be
referred to as the cumulative maximum intensity projection (cumulative MaxIP), is
simple to calculate. The first image of the cumulative MaxIP sequence is set equal to the
first image of the original image sequence. The second image of the cumulative MaxIP
sequence is set equal to the pixel by pixel maximum of the first two images of the
original image sequence. The third image of the cumulative MaxIP sequence is set equal
to the pixel by pixel maximum of the first three images of the original image sequence.
Following the same pattern, all the images of the cumulative MaxIP sequence can be
calculated.
The arrival time CIPs is then calculated by applying the percentage time CIPs method to
the cumulative MaxIP sequence. The first step is to scale the pixel values of the
cumulative MaxIP sequence to values between 0 and 1. This new image sequence, the
Page 4 of 9
normalized cumulative MaxIP sequence, is calculated by dividing each pixel in each
cumulative MaxIP image by the maximum value of all pixels in all images. The second
step is to calculate, on a pixelbypixel basis, the maximum, mean and minimum of the
normalized cumulative MaxIP sequence. The maximum (PMAX), mean (PMEAN) and
minimum images (PMIN) are then combined, on a pixel by pixel basis, using the following
equations to get the hue, saturation and brightness (HSB) of the composite color image:
Brightness = PMAX
Saturation = (PMAXPMIN)/PMAX
Hue = 2/3*(PMEANPMIN)/(PMAXPMIN)
(1)
The HSB for each pixel is then converted to the standard red, green and blue (RGB)
presentation of color, using standard subroutines (Arnold et al. 2005). The hue is
multiplied by 2/3 so there is a clear difference between the hue corresponding to the
earliest and latest arrival times.
Calculating a CIP for the 18 SOHO images with 1014 by 690 pixels took less than a
second to calculate on an AMD Duron running at 1GHz. If additional processing speed is
needed for a very large data set, the algorithm can be easily parallelized because each
pixel is calculated independently.
3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The upper 4 panels of Fig. 1 (ad) show 4 of 18 images of a comet plunging into the sun
taken by the C3 coronagraph. Structures common to all the images are 1) the occulting
disk in the center of each image that blocks out the sun and 2) jets of gas emerging
radially out from the sun in several directions.
The comet is clearly visible on panels (b) and (c) to the lower right of the sun.
Extrapolating the motion of the comet makes the comet easier to find on panels (a) and
(d). Closer examination of the images also shows the apparent motion of the stars from
the left to the right on the images. The apparent motion of the stars is actually due to the
motion of the SOHO satellite, along with the earth, in orbit around the sun.
As CIPs images present pixels that are unchanged in all the grayscale images as a shade
of gray in the color image, it is easy to pick out in the CIP image, panel (e), the structures
that are unchanged over the grayscale images. These are the occulting disk and the jets of
gas.
Page 5 of 9
The moving objects in the CIP image, such as stars, planets and the comet, change from
red to green to blue as they move across the FOV, as indicated by the color scale in the
upper left corner of the CIP. Careful examination of the CIP will show the very first
occurrence of an object is actually a shade of gray. This is another characteristic of
arrival time CIPs.
The comet plunging into the sun can be clearly seen to the lower left of the sun in the CIP
image. The uneven spacing between the various hues of the comet are due to the uneven
timing of the C3 images. The movement of the background stars from the left to the right
of the CIP standout because their tracks are all the same length.
Two planets can also be seen in the CIPs image. An object brighter than most of the stars
and with a track less than half the length of the stars can be seen to the right of the sun. It
is the planet Mars. The very bright object just to the upper left of the sun is also a planet.
The planet, which is Venus, can be easily seen to be moving in the opposite direction to
the stars.
Some objects only appear in a single hue, such as the yellow object near the base of the
rod supporting the occulting disk. The single hue indicates a one time event that only
appears on a single image, and the hue itself is indicative for the timing of this one time
event. Artifacts such as cosmic rays can be discerned by this characteristic.
Through the example of SOHO images of a comet plunging into the sun, CIPs has been
demonstrated as a simple and fast method for the detection of changes in astronomical
images. While CIPs has been demonstrated for medical imaging and astronomical
applications, there are likely a wide range of other applications where it may be applied.
The relative motion of the binary TNO in Fig. 2 is clearly shown by the CIP. One of the
binary objects appears stationary as the grayscale images were shifted to align it on all 6
grayscale images. The orbit and direction of motion of the second object relative to the
first is clearly apparent from the CIP. As the grayscale images were not evenly spaced in
time, the hue gives the order rather than the precise timing of the object in the grayscale
images.
One of the strengths of CIPs is that many different types of information can be encoded
in the hue. As mentioned in the Methods section, the hue can be used to represent the
Page 6 of 9
percentage time an object spends at a particular location rather than the time it arrives at
the location. Another possible modification is to make the first occurrence of an object
have a red hue rather than the grayscale of arrival time CIPs. This can be accomplished
by modifying the percentage time CIPs so that the hue is determined by the time of the
peak signal in each pixel.
Another variation of CIPs that may be useful in the detection and visualization of
variable stars is introducing artificial motion to the images. This can be accomplished by
shifting each grayscale image by a pixel or two relative to the previous image before
calculating the CIPs. Thus, fixed stars will appear to move in a manner similar to SOHO
images as shown in Fig. 1. The artificial motion will make the variation of the intensity of
a star over time more apparent. If a star field is crowded, circular or spiral patterns of
artificial motion might be worth considering to reduce overlaps.
Whichever version of CIPs are being considered for an application, it would be best to
apply the various versions of CIPs to a variety of data sets to find which variation
performs the best for each application.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was funded by the VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam. The VU
University Medical Center is pursuing a patent on color intensity projections on behalf of
the authors.
REFERENCES
Allen R.L., Bernstein G.M. & Malhotra R.. 2001, ApJ 549, L241.
Arnold K., Gosling J. & Holmes D. 2005, Java Programming Language, The 4th Edition.
Prentice Hall PTR.
Biesecker D. A., Lamy P., St. Cyr O. C., Liebaria A. & Howard R. A. 2002, ICARUS,
157, 323.
Page 7 of 9
Buie M.W., Millis R.L., Wasserman L.H., Elliot J.L., Kern S.D., Clancy K.B., Chiang
E.I., Jordan A.B., Meech K.J., Wagner R.M. & Trilling D.E. 2003, Earth, Moon and
Planets, 92, 113.
Cover K. S., Lagerwaard F. J. & Senan S. 2006, Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys., 64,
954.
Cover K. S., Lagerwaard F. J., van den Berg R., Buis D. R. & Slotman B. J. 2007,
Neurosurgery, 60, 511.
Gladman B., Kavelaars J.J., Nicholson P.D., Loredo T.J. & Burns J.A. 1998, AJ, 116,
2042
Jewitt D., Luu J. & Trujillo C. 1998. AJ, 115, 2125.
Morrill J.S., Korendyke C.M., Brueckner G.E., Giovane F., Howard R.A., Koomen M.,
Moses D., Plunkett S.P., Vourlidas A., Esfandiari E., Rich N., Wang D., Thernisien A.F.,
Lamy P., Llebaria A., Biesecker D., Michels D., Gong Q. & Andrews M. 2006, Solar
Physics, 233, 331.
Petit J.M., Holman M., Scholl H., Kavelaars J. & Gladman B. 2004, MNRAS, 347, 471.
Sekanina Z. 2002, ApJ, 566, 577.
Veillet C, Parker JW, Griffin I, Marsden B, Doressoundiram A, Buie M, Tholen DJ,
Connelley M, Holman MJ. 2002, Nature 416, 711.
Page 8 of 9
Figure 1. Images from the SOHO LASCO C3 coronagraph showing a comet plunging
into the sun. Panels (a) (d) show the standard presentation for 4 of the 18 grayscale
images acquired. Panel (e) shows the arrival time CIP of the 18 component images. The
color bar in the upper right corner of the CIP gives the timing of the different hues.
Page 9 of 9
Figure 2. Images of binary TNO 1998 WW31 taken by the HST presented as a CIP. The
images have been aligned so the brightest object (a) appears stationary. The second object
was imaged in July (b), August (c), September (d) and December (e) of 2001 and again in
January (f) and February (g) of 2002 to delineate its orbit.
|
0802.1769 | 1 | 0802 | 2008-02-13T07:05:57 | Transient horizontal magnetic fields in solar plage regions | [
"astro-ph"
] | We report the discovery of isolated, small-scale emerging magnetic fields in a plage region with the Solar Optical Telescope aboard Hinode. Spectro-polarimetric observations were carried out with a cadence of 34 seconds for the plage region located near disc center. The vector magnetic fields are inferred by Milne-Eddington inversion. The observations reveal widespread occurrence of transient, spatially isolated horizontal magnetic fields. The lateral extent of the horizontal magnetic fields is comparable to the size of photospheric granules. These horizontal magnetic fields seem to be tossed about by upflows and downflows of the granular convection. We also report an event that appears to be driven by the magnetic buoyancy instability. We refer to buoyancy-driven emergence as type1 and convection-driven emergence as type2. Although both events have magnetic field strengths of about 600 G, the filling factor of type1 is a factor of two larger than that of type2. Our finding suggests that the granular convection in the plage regions is characterized by a high rate of occurrence of granular-sized transient horizontal fields. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. 9022
October 25, 2018
c(cid:13) ESO 2018
Letter to the Editor
Transient horizontal magnetic fields in solar plage regions
R. Ishikawa1,2, S. Tsuneta2, K. Ichimoto2, H. Isobe3, Y. Katsukawa2, B. W. Lites4, S. Nagata5, T. Shimizu6,
R. A. Shine7, Y. Suematsu2, T. D. Tarbell7, and A. M. Title7
1 Department of Astronomy, University of Tokyo, Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-0033, Japan
2 National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan
3 Department of Earth and Planetary Science, University of Tokyo, Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, 113-0033, Japan
4 High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research, P.O. Box 3000, Boulder CO 80307-3000, USA
5 Kwasan and Hida Observatories, Kyoto University, Yamashina, Kyoto, 607-8471, Japan
6 ISAS/JAXA, Sagamihara, Kanagawa, 229-8510, Japan
7 Lockheed Martin Solar and Astrophysics Laboratory, B/252, 3251 Hanover St., Palo Alto, CA 94304, USA
Received/Accepted
ABSTRACT
Aims. We report the discovery of isolated, small-scale emerging magnetic fields in a plage region with the Solar Optical
Telescope aboard Hinode.
Methods. Spectro-polarimetric observations were carried out with a cadence of 34 seconds for the plage region located
near disc center. The vector magnetic fields are inferred by Milne-Eddington inversion.
Results. The observations reveal widespread occurrence of transient, spatially isolated horizontal magnetic fields. The
lateral extent of the horizontal magnetic fields is comparable to the size of photospheric granules. These horizontal
magnetic fields seem to be tossed about by upflows and downflows of the granular convection. We also report an event
that appears to be driven by the magnetic buoyancy instability. We refer to buoyancy-driven emergence as type1 and
convection-driven emergence as type2. Although both events have magnetic field strengths of about 600 G, the filling
factor of type1 is a factor of two larger than that of type2.
Conclusions. Our finding suggests that the granular convection in the plage regions is characterized by a high rate of
occurrence of granular-sized transient horizontal fields.
Key words. Sun: faculae, plages, Sun: granulation, Sun: magnetic fields, Sun: photosphere
1. Introduction
Sunspots and active regions are believed to form from mag-
netic flux globally emerging from the solar interior into the
solar atmosphere. The emergence of magnetic flux is due
to the buoyancy of large-scale, coherent toroidal flux tubes
in the convection zone (Parker 1955). Emerging horizon-
tal fields become more or less vertical to the photosphere,
and the vertical fields provide natural connectivity with ob-
served X-ray loops in the corona. This established paradigm
is widely supported by observations and theory, but a con-
cern has been raised on theoretical grounds that flux rising
buoyantly through the convection zone will fail to maintain
a coherent magnetic structure, and therefore fail to emerge
(Magara 2001; Moreno-Insertis et al. 1995). Here we report
on observations at granular scales of widespread emergence
of isolated magnetic fields that may be related to the con-
cern.
Our observations were made with the Solar Optical
Telescope (SOT, Tsuneta et al. 2007) aboard Hinode
(Kosugi et al. 2007). This
telescope performs high-
resolution (∼0.′′3) polarimetric observations with a very sta-
ble point spread function. Its Spectro-Polarimeter (SP) ob-
tains the complete polarization state (Stokes I, Q, U , and
V ) of the absorption profiles of the Zeeman-sensitive pho-
tospheric lines FeI 630.15 nm and FeI 630.25 nm. We ob-
served a plage region located near the center of the solar
disk. A narrow area of 2.′′5 (8 slit positions, East-West) ×
164′′(North-South) was rapidly scanned with a coarse pixel
size of 0.′′32 by the SP, resulting in the moderate spatial res-
olution of ∼0.′′6, and very high time cadence of 34 seconds
over 40 minutes.
2. Ubiquitous transient fields in a plage region
We obtain the continuum intensity, Ic, linear polarization,
LP = R pQ2 + U 2dλ/ R Icdλ, and circular polarization,
CP = R V dλ/ R Icdλ. The integration for LP is performed
between -21.6 pm and +21.6 pm from the average center
of the Stokes I profiles (FeI 630.25 nm) for pixels without
magnetic signals, and the integration for CP is between
+4.32 pm and +21.6 pm from the center of each Stokes I
profile. In the weak field limit, LP is proportional to squares
of the transverse field strength, and CP to the line-of-sight
field strength.
We discovered the frequent appearance and disappear-
ance of nearly horizontal magnetic structures in the plage
region: we find 52 occurrences of transient horizontal mag-
netic fields in this short time series. These events appear to
be randomly located spatially and temporally in the 2.′′5 ×
164′′region observed for a duration of 40 min. These events
are not associated with existing long-lived magnetic fields,
and appear in a region of insignificant vertical fields. An
2
R. Ishikawa et al.: Transient horizontal magnetic fields in solar plage regions
Fig. 1. The plage region located near disk center (72′′W, 76′′S) was observed from 16:00 to 16:40 UT on February 10,
2007. The Stokes profiles at two slit positions with integration time of 1.6 s each and scan step of 0.′′16 each are summed,
and 2 pixels along the slit with a pixel size of 0.′′16 are also summed to obtain polarization accuracy better than 0.1%:
The images consist of 8 slit positions (0.′′32 width) with a total scan time of 34 s. The pixel size along the slit is 0.′′32.
The evolution of physical quantities for the plage region are shown: (a) CP (vertical magnetic field), (b) LP (horizontal
magnetic field), (c) Ic. The region where LP is larger than 0.3% is enclosed by red lines. The emergence of the horizontal
magnetic flux starts at ∆t = 0 s. Solar north is up and east to the left in all images of this report.
episode of such transient horizontal magnetic fields is shown
in Figure 1. The maximum size of the transient horizontal
magnetic field is ∼1.′′4 ×1′′, and its duration is about 6 min.
A remarkable feature is that the horizontal magnetic struc-
ture first appears inside the granule, subsequently moves to
the inter-granular lane, and finally disappears in the inter-
granular lane. The horizontal magnetic structure continues
to be smaller than or at most as large as the size of the gran-
ule where it appears. Horizontal magnetic fields with nega-
tive vertical magnetic fields at one end appear at ∆t=34 s
(black patch in Fig.1), where there are no pre-existing ver-
tical magnetic fields@at ∆t=0 s. Vertical magnetic fields
with positive polarity start to be seen clearly at the op-
posite end at ∆t=102 s. After ∆t=238 s, it is difficult to
identify the bipolar configuration around the shrinking hor-
izontal magnetic fields due to the weak vertical magnetic
signals.
The transient horizontal fields discovered in the plage
regions have lifetimes ranging from a minute to about ten
minutes, comparable to the lifetime of granules. Among 52
events, 43 horizontal magnetic structures appear inside the
granules, and four appear in inter-granular lanes with the
remaining five events ambiguous in position. Since 52 events
are detected in the 2.′′5 × 164′′observing area during the 40
minutes, a new horizontal field appears every 46 seconds in
the same observing region. The turnover time of the gran-
ules is approximately 1000 sec with a velocity of 2 km s−1
and with a depth comparable to the horizontal scale. There
are approximately 182 granules in the observing area, as-
suming that the size of the granules is 1.′′5 × 1.′′5. 84% of
these granules are not associated with stable strong ver-
tical magnetic fields, and we use this smaller sample for
estimating the frequency of events. Were every granule to
have one embedded horizontal magnetic field structure, the
horizontal field would have appeared at the surface every
6.6 seconds (∼1000 seconds/152 granules) in the observ-
ing area. This shows that more than approximately 10% of
the granules have embedded horizontal fields, suggesting a
relatively common occurrence of horizontal magnetic fields
underneath the plage region.
We examined the Stokes profiles along the strong hor-
izontal magnetic structure at ∆t=136 s (Figure 2). The
Stokes Q and U profiles representing the horizontal mag-
netic fields are blue-shifted by 0-1 km s−1 with respect to
the line center of each Stokes I profiles. The strong hori-
zontal magnetic field rises along with the upward convective
motion of the granule in the early phase of the event; these
magnetic fields would be subject to the convective flows.
The polarity of the very weak vertical field component de-
tected by the Stokes V profile reverses along the horizontal
magnetic structure, indicating either convex- or concave-
upward magnetic fields, depending on the resolution of the
180-degree ambiguity in the direction of the horizontal field.
Because we follow the emergence of this event from its in-
ception, the only logical configuration is convex-upward;
i.e., an emerging omega-shaped loop. This scenario is con-
sistent with the higher upward flow near the center of the
granular cell.
The transient horizontal fields reported here differ from
the typical emerging flux driven by the Parker instabil-
ity (Parker 1955; Shibata et al. 1989; Strous et al. 1996;
Lites et al. 1998; Kubo et al. 2003, and references therein).
This difference can be seen in an observation made with
SOT which we describe next.
3. Comparison with buoyancy-driven emerging flux
We also present an example of an emerging flux event
in a remnant active region located around the disk cen-
ter. The properties of the event are considerably different
from the previous example. We find only one such event
in the observing area of 3.′′8 × 82′′ during 50 minutes' ob-
servation. The episode starts with the appearance of hori-
zontal magnetic fields, that appear to cause a considerable
R. Ishikawa et al.: Transient horizontal magnetic fields in solar plage regions
3
deformation of the surrounding granules (Figure 3). The
maximum size of the horizontal structure is ∼1.′′6 along
its major axis. At ∆t=-128 s, prior to the emergence of
magnetic flux, the granules become elongated with their
alignment parallel to the orientation of the emerging fields.
At ∆t=0 s, strong horizontal magnetic field structure ap-
pears in the region between the elongated granules and
existing vertical fields, and vertical magnetic components
are detected at both ends of the horizontal magnetic struc-
ture. Note that we employ unsigned circular polarization,
nCP = R V dλ/ R Icdλ, instead of CP because highly de-
formed Stokes V profiles, some of which have three lobes,
are seen in the region. The integration is carried out with
the same wavelength range as LP . The horizontal flux
emerges with separating vertical components at both ends.
At ∆t=128 s, the horizontal magnetic structure becomes
longer and stronger, and the vertical magnetic fields also
strengthen. The bright point appears where the vertical
field is strong. In the next frame (∆t= 256 s), the horizontal
magnetic structure disappears (most likely rising above the
line formation height), and we are left with vertical bipolar
components. The series of observations indicate that the
emerging magnetic field structure is stiff against the gran-
ular motion since it affects the surrounding granules even
before its emergence into the photosphere.
The Stokes profiles along the horizontal magnetic struc-
ture at ∆t=128 s are shown in Figure 4. The Stokes Q
and U profiles show that the direction of the magnetic vec-
tor is roughly parallel to the major axis of the flux tube.
The Stokes U profiles representing the horizontal magnetic
structure are blue-shifted by 1-2 km s−1 at the top of the
loop with respect to the line center of the Stokes I profiles,
while the Stokes V profile is strongly red-shifted at one end
of the horizontal magnetic structure with a velocity up to
5 km s−1, which is below but close to the local sound speed
(6-7 km s−1). The strong downward flow may be related
to the convective collapse (Bellot Rubio et al. 2001). The
expansion velocity is estimated to be about 2 km s−1 from
the change of the length of the horizontal magnetic struc-
ture. This velocity is comparable to the upward velocity
at the top of the loop. The high-velocity downflows at one
end of the flux tube continuing over 4 minutes show that
plasma descends in the flux tube in association with the ris-
ing flux tube. At the other footpoint, a few km s−1 upflow
is detected mainly at ∆t=128 s. This may be a reverse flow
due to the local enhancement of gas pressure triggered by a
downflow near the footpoint. Another possibility is siphon
flow driven by the pressure gradient of the two foot points
(Cargill & Priest 1980). Note that even with the upflow at
one end of the footpoints, the higher downflow dominates,
and reduces the net mass in the flux tube. The magnetic
buoyancy will be sustained as a result. This property is
closer to that of emerging flux by the Parker instability
than the previous one.
Given the significant difference in the two episodes pre-
sented here, we hereafter call this episode type1, and the
previous episode type2. We do not find any events of type1
in the data set where we find many type2 events. The oc-
currence rate of type1 is much lower than that of type2. The
three components of the magnetic field are estimated by a
Milne-Eddington inversion for the Stokes spectra shown in
the Figures 2 and 4. (The black lines indicate the observed
Stokes spectra, while the red lines the fitted spectra.) The
average horizontal magnetic field strengths are 560 Gauss
(type1) and 580 Gauss (type2). The field lines are roughly
aligned along the major axis of the strong horizontal mag-
netic field region. For type2, we have chosen the event hav-
ing the strongest LP , so that we were able to perform a
reliable Stokes inversion. Other type2 events generally have
smaller LP .
A remarkable difference between the types 1 and 2 is in
the average filling factors, which are 0.44 and 0.17, respec-
tively. The filling factor is an areal fraction of the magnetic
atmosphere within a resolution element. We estimate the
maximum diameter of the flux tube under the assumption
of a single horizontal flux tube partially occupying a pixel.
The width is equal to the size of the telescope's point spread
function (0.′′32) multiplied by the filling factor. The size of
the type1 horizontal flux tube thus derived is less than ∼100
km, while that for the type2 is less than ∼40 km. They are
much smaller than the scale height of the line forming layer,
indicating that actual diameter of the flux tube is not as
small as this. Nevertheless, it is true that the type2 tube is
much thinner than the type1 tube.
4. Discussion
The occurrence of isolated small-scale, transient horizon-
tal magnetic fields in the quiet Sun was discovered us-
ing spectro-polarimetric data from the Advanced Stokes
Polarimeter at a spatial resolution of 1′′(Lites et al. 1996).
These horizontal fields are interpreted to be convection-
driven or buoyancy-driven emerging bipolar fields. Very re-
cently, the high time variability and ubiquity of horizontal
fields in the quiet Sun were clearly shown in data from
the SOLIS and GONG instruments (Harvey et al. 2007).
Subsequently, Hinode data has permitted us to directly see
the ubiquitous presence of horizontal magnetic fields in the
quiet Sun at unprecedented small scales (Lites et al. 2008;
Centeno et al. 2007; Orozco Su´arez et al. 2007). It is as yet
unclear if the granular-size emergence phenomenon in the
plage region reported herein pertains to flux elements hav-
ing a stronger degree of polarization than much of that
reported for the quiet Sun. It is important to understand
whether the plage and quiet Sun horizontal fields have a
similar origin.
e
1
The equi-partition field strength Be is the field strength
B 2
where magnetic energy is equal to kinetic energy:
8π =
2 ρυ2. The typical equipartition field strength Be is about
400 Gauss for granules with a velocity of υ = 2×105 cm s−1,
and the density ρ is 3×10−7 g cm−2 at the solar surface. The
magnetic field strengths of both type1 and type2 are appar-
ently stronger than the equi-partition field. The magnetic
field strength of type1 higher than the equi-partition field
strength is consistent with the observed robustness against
granular motion (Cheung et al. 2007). The type1 event is
interpreted as essentially the instability-driven emergence
of flux tubes. As strong a field for type2 cannot be readily
explained. It appears that the horizontal flux tubes of the
type 2 event are carried by the upflow of convection to the
photosphere, and then the horizontal flow of the convection
transports them to the inter-granular lane. The type2 event
is apparently subject to granular motion.
The buoyant force is proportional to (ρe − ρi)πga2,
where ρe and ρi are the plasma density inside and out-
side the horizontal flux tubes, and a the radius of the flux
tube. The drag force is given by 0.5Cdρeu2a, where Cd is an
4
R. Ishikawa et al.: Transient horizontal magnetic fields in solar plage regions
Fig. 2. The frame at ∆t = 136 sec in Fig.1 is enlarged on
the left. Stokes profiles (I, Q, U , and V ) along the major
axis (blue line) are shown to the right with black lines. The
fitted profiles are shown with red lines. The profiles marked
by A and B correspond to the NE and SW ends of the
horizontal field structure, respectively. The vertical line in
the Stokes profiles shows the average center of the Stokes I
absorption profiles (FeI 630.25 nm) without magnetic fields,
and provides a fiducial for the zero point in velocity. The
tick mark indicates 2.16 pm.
aerodynamic coefficient of order unity, and u the turbulent
velocity. The magnetic tension force is πa2B 2/4πL, where
L is the curvature radius of horizontal fields. We substitute
a granular size of 103 km for L to obtain the upper limit of
magnetic tension. The three forces become comparable for
a of 50 km and B of 600 G. The type2 tube diameter of 40
km means that the effect of buoyancy is relatively smaller
than the drag force. This implies that a thinner flux tube
is more strongly influenced by turbulent motion.
Convective collapse (Parker 1978) would not work due
to its horizontal nature throughout the evolution for the
type 2 event. Indeed, Abbett (2007) shows that a convective
surface dynamo can generate horizontally directed mag-
netic structures. The transient horizontal fields revealed
by Hinode in our study suggest the possibility of such a
local dynamo process (Cattaneo 1999; Vogler & Schussler
2007). An alternative physical picture is presented by the
extended fields caused by an exploding magnetic structure
(Moreno-Insertis et al. 1995) and/or by horizontal mag-
netic fields that failed to emerge (Magara 2001).
Acknowledgements. The authors thank B. C. Low for his valuable
comments and encouragement. Hinode is a Japanese mission devel-
oped and launched by ISAS/JAXA, with NAOJ as a domestic part-
ner and NASA and STFC (UK) as international partners. It is oper-
ated by these agencies in co-operation with ESA and NSC (Norway).
The National Center for Atmospheric Research is sponsored by the
National Science Foundation.
References
Abbett, W. P. 2007, ApJ, 665, 1469
Bellot Rubio, L. R., Rodr´ıguez Hidalgo, I., Collados, M., Khomenko,
E., & Ruiz Cobo, B. 2001, ApJ, 560, 1010
Cargill, P. J. & Priest, E. R. 1980, Sol. Phys., 65, 251
Cattaneo, F. 1999, ApJ, 515, L39
Centeno, R., Socas-Navarro, H., Lites, B., et al. 2007, ApJ, 666, L137
Cheung, M. C. M., Schussler, M., & Moreno-Insertis, F. 2007, A&A,
467, 703
Fig. 3. NOAA AR 0931 located not far from disk center
(289′′E, 83′′S) was observed from 17:35 to 18:25 UT on
December 28, 2006. The images consist of 24 consecutive
slit positions (0.′′16 width) with a total scan time of 128
s. The pixel size along the slit is 0.′′16. (a) nCP (vertical
magnetic field), (b) LP (horizontal magnetic field), (c) Ic.
The region where LP is larger than 0.5% is enclosed by red
lines.
Fig. 4. The frame at ∆t = 128 sec in Fig.3 enlarged on the
left. The caption is the same as Fig.2.
Harvey, J. W., Branston, D., Henney, C. J., & Keller, C. U. 2007,
ApJ, 659, L177
Kosugi, T., Matsuzaki, K., Sakao, T., et al. 2007, Sol. Phys., 243, 3
Kubo, M., Shimizu, T., & Lites, B. W. 2003, ApJ, 595, 465
Lites, B. W., Kubo, M., Socas-Navarro, H., et al. 2008, ApJ, 672, 1237
Lites, B. W., Leka, K. D., Skumanich, A., Martinez Pillet, V., &
Shimizu, T. 1996, ApJ, 460, 1019
Lites, B. W., Skumanich, A., & Martinez Pillet, V. 1998, A&A, 333,
1053
Magara, T. 2001, ApJ, 549, 608
Moreno-Insertis, F., Caligari, P., & Schuessler, M. 1995, ApJ, 452, 894
Orozco Su´arez, D., Bellot Rubio, L. R., del Toro Iniesta, J. C., et al.
2007, ApJ, 670, L61
Parker, E. N. 1955, ApJ, 121, 491
Parker, E. N. 1978, ApJ, 221, 368
Shibata, K., Tajima, T., Steinolfson, R. S., & Matsumoto, R. 1989,
ApJ, 345, 584
Strous, L. H., Scharmer, G., Tarbell, T. D., Title, A. M., & Zwaan,
C. 1996, A&A, 306, 947
Tsuneta, S., Suematsu, Y., Ichimoto, K., et al. 2007, Sol. Phys., sub-
mitted
Vogler, A. & Schussler, M. 2007, A&A, 465, L43
|
astro-ph/0609800 | 1 | 0609 | 2006-09-28T22:09:54 | The Formaldehyde Masers in Sgr B2: Very Long Baseline Array and Very Large Array Observations | [
"astro-ph"
] | Observations of two of the formaldehyde (H2CO) masers (A and D) in Sgr B2 using the VLBA+Y27 (resolution ~0.01") and the VLA (resolution ~9") are presented. The VLBA observations show compact sources (<10 milliarcseconds, <80 AU) with brightness temperatures >10^8 K. The maser sources are partially resolved in the VLBA observations. The flux densities in the VLBA observations are about 1/2 those of the VLA; and, the linewidths are about 2/3 of the VLA values. The applicability of a core-halo model for the emission distribution is demonstrated. Comparison with earlier H2CO absorption observations and with ammonia (NH3) observations suggests that H2CO masers form in shocked gas. Comparison of the integrated flux densities in current VLA observations with those in previous observations indicates that (1) most of the masers have varied in the past 20 years, and (2) intensity variations are typically less than a factor of two compared to the 20-year mean. No significant linear or circular polarization is detected with either instrument. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
The Formaldehyde Masers in Sgr B2: Very Long Baseline Array
23 Sept 2006 version
and Very Large Array Observations
Ian M. Hoffman
St. Paul's School, 325 Pleasant Street, Concord, NH 03301
[email protected]
W. M. Goss
National Radio Astronomy Observatory, Socorro, NM 87801
and
Patrick Palmer
Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, 5640 S. Ellis Ave.,
Chicago, IL 60637
ABSTRACT
Observations of two of the formaldehyde (H2CO) masers (A and D) in Sgr B2
using the VLBA+Y27 (resolution ≈ 0.′′01) and the VLA (resolution ≈ 9′′) are
presented. The VLBA observations show compact sources (. 10 milliarcseconds,
. 80 AU) with brightness temperatures > 108 K. The maser sources are partially
resolved in the VLBA observations. The flux densities in the VLBA observations
are about 1/2 those of the VLA; and, the linewidths are about 2/3 of the VLA
values. The applicability of a core-halo model for the emission distribution is
demonstrated. Comparison with earlier H2CO absorption observations and with
ammonia (NH3) observations suggests that H2CO masers form in shocked gas.
Comparison of the integrated flux densities in current VLA observations with
those in previous observations indicates that (1) most of the masers have varied
in the past 20 years, and (2) intensity variations are typically less than a factor of
two compared to the 20-year mean. No significant linear or circular polarization
is detected with either instrument.
Subject headings: ISM: individual(Sgr B2) -- ISM: molecules -- masers -- radio
lines: ISM
-- 2 --
1.
Introduction
The nature of Galactic formaldehyde (H2CO) masers is a growing mystery. While
hundreds of Galactic OH, H2O, and CH3OH masers are known, only five Galactic star-
forming regions have associated H2CO maser emission. To date, this emission is seen only in
the 110 → 111 transition at 6 cm wavelength. Shortly after the discovery of the first H2CO
maser in NGC 7538 (Downes & Wilson 1974; Forster et al. 1980), a radiative pumping model
was proposed (Boland and de Jong 1981). The H2CO masers discovered subsequently did not
meet the conditions required for this mechanism (Gardner et al. 1986; Mehringer, Goss, &
Palmer 1994, hereafter MGP94; Hoffman et al. 2003; hereafter H03). Thus, twenty-five years
after the discovery of the first H2CO maser, these sources remain rare and the excitation
mechanism remains unknown.
Sgr B2, the northernmost component of the extended Sgr B radio source, is located
within a few hundred pc of the Galactic center (Reid et al. 1988). (The distance to the
Galactic center is assumed to be 8.5 kpc in this paper.) Sgr B2 is comprised of three main
star-forming complexes designated north (N), middle or main (M), and south (S), and many
smaller Hii regions. The H2CO masers occur throughout Sgr B2, shown in Figure 1. The
heating mechanisms and complex chemistry of the region are subjects of ongoing study (e.g.,
Gaume & Claussen 1990; Goicoechea et al. 2004).
Sgr B2 contains nine individual H2CO maser regions, several of which have multiple
velocity components. All of the masers are unresolved at 1′′ angular resolution, except for
maser C which MGP94 suggest consists of several masers blended within the beam. These
regions are near Hii regions distributed over the ∼3.6 arcmin2 complex (MGP94). Whiteoak
and Gardner (1983) and MGP94 designated the maser regions with letters (Fig. 1). The
H2CO masers are observed over the velocity range +40 km s−1. vLSR . +80 km s−1, while
other species, such as H2O masers, are observed over a larger range −30 km s−1. vLSR .
+120 km s−1 (Kobayashi et al. 1989; McGrath, De Pree, and Goss 2004). Of the nine maser
regions observed in Sgr B2 by MGP94, the G maser was shown to be time variable, at least
quadrupling in intensity over 10 yr. (Similarly, H03 found one NGC 7538 feature to triple
in intensity over ≈ 10 yr.) As initially noted by Whiteoak and Gardner (1983), all of the
Sgr B2 H2CO masers lie close to OH, H2O, CH3OH, and NH3 masers. For most of the masers
in MGP94, the separation to an OH maser was less than 0.05 pc.
Recent successes in search techniques for new masers (Araya et al. 2004, 2005, 2006a) and
in high-resolution observational techniques (H03) promise to provide empirical constraints for
the development of a realistic model for the Galactic H2CO maser emission. The necessary
steps in compiling an empirical picture of the H2CO emission in Sgr B2 are (1) detailed
imaging of the masers in order to quantify the intrinsic properties of the emission (e.g.,
-- 3 --
brightness temperature), (2) assessment of intensity variability in the masers, and (3) precise
astrometry for elucidating spatial relationships between the H2CO masers and more common
masers (OH, H2O, CH3OH). In this paper, we present new observations of the H2CO masers
in Sgr B2 using the the Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) and Very Large Array (VLA) of
the NRAO1.
2. Observations and Results
2.1. VLBA+Y27
We observed the A and D H2CO masers in Sgr B2 using the ten antennas of the VLBA
and the 27 antennas of the VLA as an 11-station VLBI array. Parameters of the observations
are summarized in Table 1. The total observing time was approximately 8.0 hours alternating
between the A and D pointing positions which are separated by approximately 1′. At each
pointing position there is a useful correlated field of view of approximately 1′′ (e.g., Bridle
& Schwab 1999). To observe each of the nine H2CO masers in Sgr B2 optimally would have
required observations at nine pointing centers. Because of signal-to-noise considerations, we
observed only the two masers measured to be most intense by MGP94. The baseline lengths
of the VLBA+Y27 array range from 52 km to 8611 km; the array is not sensitive to angular
scales larger than 0.′′25. The antennas have right- (R) and left- (L) circularly polarized feeds
from which RR, LL, RL, & LR cross-correlations were formed. The visibilities were integrated
for 8.4 s. The amplitude scale is set using online system temperature monitoring and a priori
antenna gain measurements. The station delays were determined from observations of J1733-
130.
The maser observations were phase referenced to J1745-283 (called W56 in Bower et al.
2001). Because the properties of this source limit our observations, we discuss it in some
detail. The absolute position uncertainty of this source is 12 milliarcseconds (hereafter: mas)
(Reid et al. 1999). Bower et al. find that J1745-283 is probably the core of an extragalactic jet
source and that its apparent size at 5 GHz (30 mas) is determined by scatter-broadening. We
also observed J1745-283 on 22 November 2002 using only the ten VLBA stations (a snapshot
observation with a bandwidth of 4 MHz in both polarizations). The 2002 observation yields
a deconvolved angular size of 21 × 18 mas and an integrated flux density of 28 mJy; the
2003 observation yields a size of 28 × 16 mas and a flux density of 31 mJy. (The flux density
1The VLA and VLBA are components of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO), a facility
of the National Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc.
-- 4 --
determined by Y27 [the VLA alone] during the 2003 observations was 161 mJy.) Bower et
al. report an angular size 42 × 25 mas and peak intensity 89 mJy beam−1 from VLBA+Y1
observations. Therefore, the flux density must have decreased significantly between 1999 and
2002. Such variability would not be unusual for an inverted spectrum source like J1745-283
(e.g., Urry & Padovani 1995).
Our imaging of J1745-283 with the VLBA makes use of only the inner-most stations
(VLA, Pie Town, Los Alamos, Fort Davis, Kitt Peak, and Owens Valley) because the source
is resolved on longer baselines. Some additional resolution for the maser observations was
gained by self-calibration; but, because only the shorter baselines in the VLBA data were
absolutely calibrated in phase, the position registration accuracy of the resulting VLBA
images is approximately 15 mas. In summary, we could not make use of the full potential
resolution of the VLBA when using this phase referencing calibrator, and no other suitable
nearby source is known.
We detected masers toward the A and D regions. The F maser is also within the
correlated field of view near the A maser, but was not detected with the current sensitivity.
The image and spectrum of the A maser from the VLBI data is shown in Figure 2. Because
the radio continuum of Sgr B2 is fully resolved by the VLBA, no continuum subtraction was
necessary. The positions, center velocities (vLSR), linewidths (∆vFWHM), peak flux densities
(S0), and deconvolved major and minor axes and position angles are summarized in Table 2.
In parentheses following each entry are the 1-σ errors.
The deconvolved sizes of the VLBI images of the A and D masers are ≈ 10 mas. At
the distance of Sgr B2, this size corresponds to a linear diameter of approximately 80 AU,
comparable to the sizes (30 to 130 AU) observed for the H2CO masers in NGC 7538 and
G29.96-0.02 using the VLBA (H03). The brightness temperatures of the Sgr B2 A and D
masers in the current VLBI data are 5.9 × 108 K and 1.2 × 108 K, respectively, similar to the
107−8 K observed for other H2CO masers (H03). No significant linear or circular polarization
is detected in either maser (≤ 20% for the strongest maser [A]).2
2All data reduction and analysis was performed with the the The Groningen Image Processing System
(GIPSY) software package (http://www.ast ro.rug.nl/∼gipsy/) and the Astronomical Image Processing
System (AIPS) software package (http://www.nrao.edu/aips/).
-- 5 --
2.2. VLA
Because of the known variability of H2CO masers (Forster et al. 1985; H03), the Sgr B2
masers were observed in 2005 with the VLA in order to access any possible time-variability.
Parameters of the observations are summarized in Table 1. The array configuration available
was DnC for an observation period of approximately 7 hours. Two pairs of RR and LL bands
were recorded centered at the expected velocities of the A and the D masers.
Of the nine maser regions described by MGP94, eight of the sources were detected. Six
velocity components in the regions observed by MGP94 lie outside the velocity range of the
current observations. No new H2CO maser regions were discovered.
The 2005 data have inferior angular resolution (10′′ versus 1′′) but improved spectral
resolution (0.19 km s−1 versus 1.5 km s−1) compared with the 1993 VLA observations of
MGP94. Comparison of the current data to the MGP94 data is uncertain due to (1) the
severe blending of the strong H2CO absorption with the nearby masers and (2) the insufficient
velocity resolution of the MGP94 data, which did not spectrally resolve the lines. Variability
of the flux density of the masers is apparent and is discussed in §3.2. The 2005 results are
summarized in Table 3 and a spectrum from these data (region E) is shown in Figure 3. The
C maser region is not discussed in this paper due to confusion of the maser spectra with
nearby absorption and continuum emission. With the current 10′′ angular resolution of the
VLA data, as with the 1′′ resolution of MGP94, none of the masers are spatially resolved.
In §3.2, we also compare the current data with the 1983 VLA observations of Gardner et
al. (1986). The velocity resolution of the 1983 data is 0.76 km s−1 and the angular resolution
is 1.′′25. Although we resolve many of the maser line profiles in velocity for the first time
with the 2005 VLA data, most of the linewidths presented in Table 3 agree with the values
measured by Gardner et al. (1986).
No circular polarization is detected in any of the H2CO masers. This corresponds to a
3-σ upper limit of approximately 4% circular polarization for the strongest maser (A).
3. Discussion
3.1. Angular Scatter Broadening
Images of radio sources are angularly broadened by scattering by the ionized component
of the interstellar medium. In the direction of the Galactic center, this problem becomes
severe (e.g., Lazio & Cordes 1998). As discussed in §2.1, J1745-283, is an extragalactic
-- 6 --
point-like source whose image is broadened to ∼30 mas at 6 cm wavelength by scattering
(Bower et al. 2001). In this section we discuss the extent to which this scattering medium
affects the current VLBI observations of the H2CO masers in Sgr B2.
The observed size for J1745-283, 28 × 16 mas, is larger than the observed deconvolved
size for the A maser, 13 × 5 mas. This result may be expected even if both sources are
intrinsically point-like because the proximity of the maser to the scattering medium results
in reduced angular broadening (e.g., Rickett 1990). Nevertheless, as discussed below, we
expect significant angular broadening in the images of the masers. Therefore, the deconvolved
angular sizes in Table 2 are upper limits to the intrinsic sizes and the brightness temperatures
are lower limits.
Gwinn et al. (1988) quantified the scattered sizes of H2O and OH masers in Sgr B2,
finding a λ2.2 dependence for the broadening. From their determinations of minimum angular
sizes of 0.3 mas for 1.35-cm H2O masers and 100 mas for 18-cm OH masers, we expect a min-
imum apparent size of approximately 9 mas for the 6.2-cm H2CO masers. The deconvolved
angular sizes of the masers in Table 2 are in agreement with this expectation.
3.2. Variability of the H2CO masers in Sgr B2
In comparing the current VLA observations with earlier VLA data, both the differing
angular resolution and spectral resolution must be considered. As discussed in §2.2, both the
differences in array configuration and in correlator setup were significant. To compensate
for the difference in velocity resolution, in Table 4 we tabulate the velocity-integrated flux
density for observations made in 1983 (Gardner et al. 1986), 1993 (MGP94), and 2003 and
2005 (this paper). However, it is impossible to compensate for emission outside of the velocity
range covered in the current observations and for the confusion of features caused by the
lower angular resolution. (The notes in the final column of Table 3 summarize limitations of
the current data from these causes.) The error values in Table 4 are dominated by systematic
uncertainties rather than by thermal noise in most cases.
We find that the A maser has approximately doubled in velocity-integrated flux density
since 1993, while B, G, and H increased between 1983 and 1993, and subsequently decreased.
The velocity-integrated flux densities from regions D, E, F, and I have not changed signifi-
cantly since 1993.
-- 7 --
3.3. Core/Halo Morphology
For the A and D H2CO masers in Sgr B2, a comparison of the current VLBA+Y27 data
with past and current VLA data shows two major differences: (1) only a fraction of the flux
density seen with the VLA is observed in the VLBI data (∼70% for the A maser; ∼40% for
the D maser); and (2) the velocity widths in the VLBI data are more narrow than in the
VLA data (∼80% for the A maser; ∼50% for the D maser). In this section we discuss a
schematic model for the structure of the emission which addresses both the observed angular
distribution and velocity widths.
The flux density detected by the VLA but resolved by VLBI baselines must lie at
angular scales between ≈ 100 mas (the resolution of the shortest VLBA+Y27 interferometer
spacings) and ≈ 500 mas (the masers are unresolved in the MGP94 observations with 1′′
resolution), while the flux density observed with the VLBI is emitted by a source ∼10 mas.
These limits suggest a core-halo source morphology. A similar morphology was proposed
by H03 for the H2CO masers in NGC 7538 and G29.96-0.02. A model consisting of two coin-
cident circular Gaussian components with different angular sizes can reproduce the observed
results. For the A maser, the flux density observed with the VLA is about 2000 mJy. To
determine the decrease in flux density with increasing projected baseline length, we use the
highest signal-to-noise baselines only: those between Y27 and other antennas. The average
flux densities observed on baselines with Y27 are: 1400 mJy at 0.71 Mλ (to Pie Town, av-
erage projected spacing ∼44 km)3; 1300 mJy at 3 Mλ; and 1200 mJy at 5 Mλ. These data
are fit by a two component Gaussian model with a 600 mJy in a 300 mas halo and 1400 mJy
in a 10 mas core. The brightness temperature of the halo is TB ≈ 4 × 105 K; for the 10 mas
core component, TB ≈ 8 × 108 K (Table 2, Fig. 2). A more precise model is justified only
after higher signal to noise measurements.
It is reasonable to assume that the background radiation is relatively uniform on 300 mas
angular scales because the continuum emission is well resolved on the VLBA baselines.
Therefore, the difference in brightness temperatures between the core and halo components
may be attributed to differences in maser gain. We estimate that the halo has a gain
of approximately 10 (in the exponential amplification regime) and the core has a gain of
approximately 2000 (in the saturated regime). Because the observed angular sizes are upper
limits for the intrinsic sizes, the derived brightness temperatures are lower limits for the
intrinsic brightness temperatures; therefore, the actual gains may exceed the above values.
The gain of the maser medium is dependent upon four factors: the pathlength, the density
3Mλ denotes million wavelengths
-- 8 --
of H2CO, the level inversion, and the velocity coherence (see §4.2 of H03). Therefore, one or
more of these factors must be significantly different between the core and halo components.
We suggest that the narrower line widths arising from the core component indicate that the
velocity coherence is enhanced in the core region compared to the halo, yielding a higher
gain. Similar arguments may be applied to the D maser, but the resulting ranges of size and
TB are not well constrained because of the higher noise level on the VLA-Pie Town baseline.
Additional maser species in other star-forming regions -- excited OH (Palmer, Goss,
& Devine 2003), OH in supernova remnants (Hoffman et al. 2005), as well as other H2CO
masers (H03) -- exhibit a similar narrowing of line widths between VLA and VLBA angular
scales.
3.4. Associations with Other Molecular Lines
H2CO absorption toward Sgr B2 has been studied extensively with 10′′ × 20′′ resolution
both by Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1990) and Mehringer et al. (1995). Mart´ın-Pintado et al.
(1990) noted that the absorption is dominated by three velocity components (vLSR= 55, 64,
and 80 km s−1), each with τ > 1. Linewidths of these absorption features ranged from 9 --
26 km s−1, i.e. much greater than that of the maser features (< 1 km s−1; see Table 3).
Mehringer et al. (1995) provide optical depth profiles toward selected positions. All but
maser E lies within 30′′ of one of these positions displayed.
(Maser E lies at a position
with no radio continuum.) It is striking that the maser velocities, except for maser I (which
is more than a beamwidth away from the position of a displayed profile), do not occur in
velocity ranges with large H2CO optical depths. Masers A and F occur in a velocity range
with τ =1, but this velocity range is a rather sharp minimum in the optical depth profile at
this position. Therefore, we conclude that the gas containing the H2CO masers is distinct
from the bulk of the H2CO containing gas observed in absorption.
Insight into why the maser containing gas may be distinct is provided by (3,3) and
(4,4) NH3 observations made with the VLA by Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1999). With their 3′′
resolution, 80-90% of the NH3 emission is resolved out, and only small angular scale features
remain. Among these features are a number of rings and arcs, most naturally interpreted as
complete or partial shells with linear sizes ∼2 pc. The shells are hot (Tk ∼ 50 -- 70 K), and
the H2 densities derived for them are typically a factor of 10 greater than those derived from
the H2CO absorption studies of Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1990). H2CO masers C, D, E, G, and
H fall within the field imaged by Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1999). As these authors note, all of
the H2CO masers occur at positions on hot NH3 shells. The higher temperature (Tk > 100
K) region of apparent interaction between shells A and B contains the closely spaced D, G,
-- 9 --
and H masers. Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1999) propose that the pumping mechanism for the
H2CO masers as well as that for the NH3 and class II CH3OH masers must depend on the
physical conditions in the hot shells.
In the search for additional constraints on the H2CO emission environment, we examine
the possible association of H2CO masers with other molecular emission for which physical
conditions are better understood. In Table 5 we present a summary of possible associations
with H2O masers observed by McGrath, Goss, and De Pree (2004), CH3OH masers observed
by Houghton and Whiteoak (1995), and OH masers observed by Argon, Reid, and Menten
(2000). The excitation conditions for the different species are mutually exclusive, but if the
masers exist in a shocked region as proposed by Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1999) for Sgr B2 (and
for NGC 7538 by H03), a rapid change in densities, temperatures, and velocity fields over a
small linear distance is to be expected. Of the NH3 masers in Sgr B2 with interferometically
determined positions, only masers M1 and M6 lie similarly near an H2CO maser (E), and
both differ in velocity by >10 km s−1 from the H2CO maser. The existence of H2O and
CH3OH masers near the H2CO F maser is significant because previously the F maser had
no known maser or continuum associations (MGP94).
The H2CO maser in NGC 7538 (H03) and many of those reported in Section 3.2 varied
in intensity with timescales from years to decades. H03 noted a common variability of some
of the H2CO and H2O masers in NGC 7538. This was further confirmed by long-term
observations by Lekht et al. (2003, 2004b). Similarly in Sgr B2, the long-term monitoring of
the H2O masers presented by Lekht et al. (2004a, 2004c) may indicate common variability
of H2O masers with the H2CO A maser. However, variablity of an H2CO maser in IRAS
18566+0408 was recently seen to occur on much more rapid timescale (Araya et al. 2006b).
4. Conclusions
We present VLBA+Y27 images of the Sgr B2 A and D H2CO masers. The measured
sizes (. 80 AU) and brightness temperatures (> 108 K) are comparable to those found in
other VLBI studies of H2CO masers. However, about half of the flux density from these
regions is resolved out with the VLBA data. A comparison between VLA and VLBA obser-
vations shows that the missing flux density exhibits a broader linewidth than the emission
from the compact VLBI source. We demonstrate quantitatively the applicability of a core-
halo model for these masers.
We also present new VLA observations of the H2CO masers in Sgr B2 with improved
velocity resolution. We have detected variability in several of the masers.
-- 10 --
H2O and CH3OH masers discovered near the H2CO masers may indicate associations
among the species, suggestive of a related origin. The association of H2CO masers in Sgr B2
with hot NH3 shells proposed by Mart´ın-Pintado et al. (1999), together with the arguments
for shock excitation of the maser region in NGC 7538 in H03, provide an encouraging stepping
stone toward a solution of the problem of the excitation of these poorly understood masers.
We are indebted to an anonymous referee for a very careful reading of this paper and
for directing our attention to two very important references.
Facilities: VLA (), VLBA ().
REFERENCES
Araya, E., Hofner, P., Linz, H., Sewilo, M., Watson, C., Churchwell, E., Olmi, L., & Kurtz,
S. 2004, ApJS, 154, 579
Araya, E., Hofner, P., Kurtz, S., Linz, H., Olmi, L., Sewilo, M., Watson, C., Churchwell, E.
2005, ApJ, 618, 339
Araya, E., Hofner, P., Goss, W. M., Kurtz, S., Linz, H., & Olmi, L. 2006a, ApJ, 643, L33
Araya, E., Hofner, P., Sewilo, M., Linz, H., Kurtz, S., Olmi, L., Watson, C., & Churchwell,
E. 2006b, ApJ (in press)
Argon, A. L., Reid, M. J., & Menten, K. M. 2000, ApJS, 129, 159
Boland, W. & de Jong, T. 1981, A&A, 98, 149
Bower, G. C., Backer, D. C., Sramek, R. A. 2001, ApJ, 558, 127
Bridle, A. H. & Schwab, F. R. 1999, in Synthesis Imaging in Radio Astronomy II. Edited by
G. B. Taylor, C. L. Carilli, and R. A. Perley. ASP Conference Series, 180, 371
Downes, D. & Wilson, T. L. 1974, ApJ, 191, L77
Forster, J. R., Goss, W. M., Wilson, T. L., Downes, D., & Dickel, H. R. 1980, A&A, 84, L1
Forster, J. R., Goss, W. M., Gardner, F. F., & Stewart, R. T. 1985, MNRAS, 216, 35P
Gardner, F. F., Whiteoak, J. B., Forster, J. R., & Pankonin, V., 1986, MNRAS, 218, 385
Gaume, R. A. & Claussen, M. J. 1990, ApJ, 351, 538
-- 11 --
Goicoechea, J. R., Rodr´ıguez-Fern´andez, N. J., Cernicharo, J. 2004, ApJ, 600, 214
Gwinn, C. R., Moran, J. M., Reid, M. J., Schneps, M. H. 1988, ApJ, 330, 817
Hoffman, I. M., Goss, W. M., Palmer, P., & Richards, A. M. S. 2003, ApJ, 598, 1061 (H03)
Hoffman, I. M., Goss, W. M., Brogan, C. L., Claussen, M. J. 2005, ApJ, 620, 257
Houghton, S. & Whiteoak, J. B. 1995, MNRAS, 273, 1033
Kobayashi, H., Ishiguro, M., Chikada, Y., Ukita, N., Morita, K.-I., Okumura, S. K., Kasuga,
T., & Kawabe, R. 1989, PASJ, 41, 141
Lazio, T. J. W. & Cordes, J. M. 1998, ApJ, 505, 715
Lekht, E. E., Munitsyn, V. A., & Tolmachev, A. M. 2003, Astronomy Reports, 47, 838
Lekht, E. E., Ram´ırez, O., Tolmachev, A. M., & Berulis, I. I. 2004, Astronomy Reports, 48,
171
Lekht, E. E., Munitsyn, V. A., & Tolmachev, A. M. 2004, Astronomy Reports, 48, 200
Lekht, E. E., Ram´ırez, O., & Tolmachev, A. M. 2004, Astronomy Reports, 48, 965
Mart´ın-Pintado, J., de Vicente, P., Wilson, T. L., & Johnston, K. J. 1990, A&A, 236, 193
Mart´ın-Pintado, J., Gaume, R. A., Rodr´ıguez-Fern´andez, N., de Vicente, P., & Wilson, T.
L. 1999, ApJ, 519, 667
McGrath, E. J., Goss, W. M., & De Pree, C. G. 2004, ApJS, 155, 577
Mehringer, D. M., Goss, W. M., & Palmer, P. 1994, ApJ, 434, 237 (MGP94)
Mehringer, D. M., Palmer, P., & Goss, W. M. 1995, ApJS, 97, 497
Palmer, P., Goss, W. M., & Devine, K. E. 2003, ApJ, 599, 324
Reid, M. J., Schnepps, M. H., Moran, J. M., Gwinn, C. R., Genzel, R., Downes, D., &
Ronnang, B. 1988, ApJ, 330, 809
Reid, M. J., Readhead, A. C. S., Vermeulen, R. C., & Treuhaft, R. N. 1999, ApJ, 524, 816
Rickett, B. J. 1990, ARA&A, 28, 561
Urry, C. M., Padovani, P. 1995, PASP, 107, 803
-- 12 --
Whiteoak, J. B. & Gardner, F. F. 1983, MNRAS, 205, 27P
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
-- 13 --
Table 1. Observational Parameters
Instrument
VLBA+Y27
VLA
Observing date(s)
Position (J2000.0)
Synthesized beam
Flux density calibrator
Phase calibrator
Bandpass calibrator
Rest frequency
Number channels
Channel spacing
Velocity Resolutiona
Center velocity
Total velocity range
Typical noise per channel
aafter Hanning smoothing
2003 May 17 & 22
2005 October 11, 13, & 14
17 47 20.0463, -28 23 46.587
17 47 19.8562, -28 22 12.900
(A) 20 × 15 mas, P.A.= 1◦
(D) 35 × 21 mas, P.A.= 1◦
17 47 19.96, -28 22 59.8
10.′′7 × 9.′′0, P.A.= 88◦
--
J1745-283
J1733-130
3C286
J1751-253
J1733-130
4829.6569 MHz
4829.6590 MHz
128
1.953 kHz
0.24 km s−1
63
3.052 kHz
0.19 km s−1
50.6 km s−1 & 75.6 km s−1
51.4 km s−1 & 74.6 km s−1
±7.5 km s−1
35 mJy beam−1
±5.5 km s−1
5 mJy beam−1
Table 2. VLBA+Y27 H2CO Results from 2003 May
Source
α (J2000)
δ (J2000)
vLSR
(km s−1)
∆vFWHM
(km s−1)
S0
θb
(mJy beam−1) mas mas
θa
P.A.
deg
A
D
17 47 19.856(1) −28 22 12.99(2)
23 46.59(2)
20.047(2)
75.33(1)
50.07(2)
0.59(2)
0.36(5)
645(15)
160(20)
13(3)
10(4)
5(2)
8(4)
110(20)
5(40)
--
1
4
--
-- 15 --
Table 3. VLA H2CO Results from 2005 October
Source
α (J2000)
δ (J2000)
vLSR
A
B
D
E
F
G
H
I
17 47 19.94 −28 22 13.0
22 40.6
23 47.2
20.04
20.01
18.64
24 24.5
19.61
19.57
20.43
22 13.5
23 49.9
23 46.7
24.72
21 43.0
(km s−1)
75.31(7)
51.0(2)
50.1(1)
53.9(1)
49.1(1)
51.5(1)
76.3(2)
48.7(3)
70.6(3)
73.1(1)
74.6(1)
70.9(1)
∆vFWHM
(km s−1)
S0
Notes
(mJy beam−1)
0.71(2)
0.4(2)
0.75(5)
0.88(9)
0.94(4)
0.60(6)
0.3(1)
0.8(2)
0.3(2)
0.9(5)
0.8(3)
0.92(6)
1900
80
510
320
230
120
40
120
50
50
70
60
U
U
F
F
U
U
U
U
U,N
Note. --
F -- full velocity range of features observed earlier not covered
N -- possible new velocity feature
U -- position, velocity, and/or intensity uncertain due to blending (see §2.2)
-- 16 --
Table 4.
Integrated Flux Density Comparisons 1983 -- 2005
Source
Integrated Flux Density (mJy km s−1)
2005c
1983a
(VLA)
(VLA)
2003c
(VLBA)
1993b
(VLA)
A
B
D
E
F
G
H
I
720±15
80±15
700±25
230±80
< 60
< 30
140±60
< 60
850±15
150±10
1400±30
350±20
70±15
320±15
350±15
100±15
640±50
1900±400
--
55±20d
--
--
--
--
--
20±10
1200±300
330±30
40+40
−20
75+50
−25
35±20
75±20
afrom Whiteoak and Gardner 1983
bfrom MGP94
cthis paper
dIncludes only one of the velocity components de-
tected in the VLA observations
-- 17 --
Table 5. Nearby Masers
Source
H2O
A
F
H
CH3OH
B
D
E
F
I
OHd
A
B
C
D
H
Displacement from H2CO Maser
∆θa
(′′)
∆vLSR
(km s−1)
∆ℓb
(AU)
0.6
0.1
0.2
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.8
0.5
4.5
0.5
0.6
0.6
0.15
0.05
0.06
0.18
0.07
0.10
0.21
0.24
5000
850
1700
5500
5500
6000
7400
4200
38000
4200
5000
5000
130
40
50
150
60
850
180
200
0.1
18.8
9.9
6.6
11.9
c
c
c
c
c
2.5
1.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.9
1.1
0.1
2.0
aangular separation
bprojected linear separation
cnumerous velocity components
dZeeman shifting makes velocity comparison
uncertain
References. -- McGrath, Goss, & De Pree
(2004); Houghton & Whiteoak (1995); Argon,
Reid, & Menten (2000)
-- 18 --
50
100
150
(N)
F
A
B
C
(M)
H
D
(S)
G
E
18
16
22
20
RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000)
)
0
0
0
2
J
(
I
I
N
O
T
A
N
L
C
E
D
I
-28 22 00
30
23 00
30
24 00
30
17 47 26
24
Fig. 1. -- Image of the continuum radiation at 4.8 GHz from the Sgr B2 region from the
1993 VLA-BnA observations (MGP94). The contours are -6, 6, 24, 64, 128, 256, and 384
times the image RMS noise level of 0.4 mJy beam−1 and the greyscale at the top is in units
mJy beam−1. The beam is 1.′′12 × 0.′′88 at a position angle of 52◦. The image has not been
corrected for attenuation by the primary beam of the VLA antennas (FWHM approximately
10′). The labelled crosses indicate the locations of the H2CO maser regions (after MGP94)
and the italicized letters in parentheses denote the common designations of the major star-
forming complexes. Masers A and D were detected using the VLBA+Y27.
-- 19 --
200
300
400
500
600
-28 22 12.84
12.86
12.88
12.90
12.92
12.94
12.96
12.98
13.00
13.02
13.04
)
0
0
0
2
J
(
I
N
O
T
A
N
L
C
E
D
I
17 47 19.868 19.866 19.864 19.862 19.860 19.858 19.856 19.854 19.852
RIGHT ASCENSION (J2000)
Fig. 2. -- VLBA+Y27 image of the H2CO A maser at vLSR = 75.4 km s−1. The contour
levels are −4, 4, 8, 12 and 16 times the image RMS noise level of 40 mJy beam−1 (no negative
contours appear). The beam (lower left corner) is 26 × 9 mas at a position angle of 4◦. The
greyscale at the top is in units of mJy beam−1. (inset) Spectrum at the A maser image
peak. The observed properties are summarized in Table 2. The brightness temperature of
the emission is 5.9 × 108 K.
-- 20 --
Fig. 3. -- VLA spectrum of the E maser from the 2005 observations. The beam is 10.′′7 × 9.′′0
at position angle 88◦ and the velocity resolution is 0.19 km s−1.
|
astro-ph/9706176 | 1 | 9706 | 1997-06-17T18:38:52 | Supersonic motions in dark clouds are not Alfven waves | [
"astro-ph"
] | Supersonic random motions are observed in dark clouds and are traditionally interpreted as Alfv\'{e}n waves, but the possibility that these motions are super-Alfvenic has not been ruled out. In this work we report the results of numerical experiments in two opposite regimes: beta ~1 and beta << 1, where beta is the ratio of gas pressure and magnetic pressure: beta=P_g/P_m. Our results, combined with observational tests, show that the model with beta ~ 1 is consistent with the observed properties of molecular clouds, while the model with beta << 1 has several properties that are in conflict with the observations. We also find that both the density and the magnetic field in molecular clouds may be very intermittent. The statistical distributions of magnetic field and gas density are related by a power law, with an index that decreases with time. Magnetically dominated cores form early in the evolution, while later on the intermittency in the density field wins out. | astro-ph | astro-ph |
Supersonic motions in dark clouds are not Alfv´en waves
Theoretical Astrophysics Center, Juliane Maries Vej 30, DK-2100 Copenhagen, Denmark
Paolo Padoan
Astronomical Observatory and Theoretical Astrophysics Center, Juliane Maries Vej 30, DK-2100
Ake Nordlund
Copenhagen, Denmark
ABSTRACT
Supersonic random motions are observed in dark clouds and are traditionally interpreted as
Alfv´en waves, but the possibility that these motions are super-Alfv´enic has not been ruled out.
In this work we report the results of numerical experiments in two opposite regimes; β ≈ 1
and β ≪ 1, where β is the ratio of gas pressure and magnetic pressure: β = Pg/Pm.
Our results, combined with observational tests, show that the model with β ≈ 1 is consistent
with the observed properties of molecular clouds, while the model with β ≪ 1 has several
properties that are in conflict with the observations.
We also find that both the density and the magnetic field in molecular clouds may be very
intermittent. The statistical distributions of magnetic field and gas density are related by a
power law, with an index that decreases with time. Magnetically dominated cores form early in
the evolution, while later on the intermittency in the density field wins out.
Subject headings:
turbulence - ISM: kinematics and dynamics- magnetic field
1.
Introduction
The observation of supersonic motions in molecular clouds (eg Zuckerman & Palmer 1974) raised the
question of how these motions could be supported (Norman & Silk 1980; Fleck 1981; Scalo & Pumphrey
1982). Supersonic motions are expected to quickly dissipate their energy in highly radiative shocks, because
of the very short cooling time of molecular gas or metal rich atomic gas (Mestel & Spitzer 1956; Spitzer
1968; Goldreich & Kwan 1974).
Strictly related was the issue of the support of molecular clouds (MCs) against gravitational collapse,
since it was soon realized that the observed motions could not be understood as a gravitational collapse
(Zuckerman & Evans 1974; Morris et al. 1974), although MCs contain many Jeans' masses.
Theoreticians therefore formulated the hypothesis that MCs were primarily magnetically supported
(Mestel 1965, Strittmatter 1966; Parker 1973; Mouschovias 1976a,b; McKee & Zweibel 1995) and interpreted
the observed motions as long-wavelength hydro-magnetic waves (Arons & Max 1975; Zweibel & Josafatsson
1983; Elmegreen 1985, Falgarone & Puget 1986). It was also shown that the properties of the observed
'turbulence' (Larson 1981; Leung, Kutner & Mead 1982; Myers 1983; Quiroga 1983; Sanders, Scoville
& Solomon 1985; Goldsmith & Arquilla 1985; Dame et al. 1986; Falgarone & P´erault 1987) could be
understood if the motions were sub-Alfv´enic (Myers & Goodman 1988; Mouschovias & Psaltis 1995, Xie
1996).
-- 2 --
Nevertheless, recent attempts to detect the Zeeman effect, in lines of molecules such as OH and CN,
that probe regions of dense gas (Crutcher et al. 1993; Crutcher et al. 1996), resulted in a number of
non-detections of the effect, and therefore in rather stringent upper limits for the magnetic field strength,
despite the fact that regions expected to favor detections were targeted. It is therefore possible, that the
field strength in dense molecular gas is weaker than assumed in theoretical studies.
In the present work, we describe the dynamics of MCs, with the numerical solution of the equations of
3-D compressible magneto-hydrodynamics (MHD), in a regime of highly supersonic random motions. We
avoid any sort of idealization of the physical system, apart from describing it as a fluid, and simply rely
on the physical assumption (supported by the observations) that the motions in MCs are random. The
main limitation of our numerical models, compared with MCs, is the absence of gravity. We have excluded
gravity on purpose (our code is capable of handling self-gravity), because one of the aim of our work is to
show that (magneto-)hydrodynamic processes alone are able to explain most of the observed properties of
MCs, without the need of gravity. Although gravity is certainly responsible for the fragmentation into stars
of high density regions, supersonic random motions shape the structure of molecular clouds with a minor
contribution from gravity (Padoan 1995; Padoan, Jones & Nordlund 1997a; Padoan, Nordlund & Jones
1997b), apart from the possibility that gravity is the energy source of the motions on the large scale. The
importance of supersonic motions in fragmenting the gas is certainly apparent on very small scales, where
young and probably transient clumps are not originated by gravitational instability (Falgarone, Puget &
P´erault 1992; Langer et al. 1995).
Previous numerical studies have shown that compressible turbulence can qualitatively explain several
observational properties of MCs, even if the effect of gravity and magnetic fields are not included. The first
two-dimensional (2-D) simulations of turbulence, with rms Mach number larger than one, were performed
by Passot & Pouquet (1987). These were the first simulations where shocks are shown to develop inside
a turbulent flow. The importance of shock formation inside mildly supersonic flows was later confirmed
in 3-D simulations by Lee, Lele & Moin (1991). It was immediately recognized that shocks might have
been responsible for the fragmentation of the density field inside MCs, and especially for the origin of their
filamentary structure (Passot, Pouquet & Woodward 1988). Kimura & Tosa (1993) simulated the passage of
a strong shock through a turbulent molecular cloud, and found that this process can generate dense clumps,
with a power law mass spectrum. V´azquez-Semadeni (1994) made use of 2-D numerical simulations to show
that supersonic turbulence generates a very intermittent density field, reminiscent of the clumpy nature
of MCs. The density field was also found to be self-similar, which could be the reason for the hierarchical
structure of MCs (Scalo 1985, Houlahan & Scalo 1992). Falgarone et al. (1994), analyzing the numerical
simulation by Porter, Pouquet & Woodward (1994), argued that the properties of the profiles of molecular
emission spectra from MCs can be interpreted as arising from turbulent motions.
Other numerical works included gravity in the turbulent flows, yet without describing the magnetic
field. Turbulence was shown to be able to prevent gravitational collapse (cf Chandrasekhar 1958; Arny
1971; Bonazzola et al. 1987, 1992) in the 2-D numerical simulations by L´eorat, Passot & Pouquet (1990).
V´azquez-Semadeni, Passot & Pouquet (1995) modeled the galactic disc, on the scale of 1 Kpc, as a
turbulent self-gravitating flow. They simulate a 2-D turbulent flow that is forced by the energy released
by star formation (expansions of HII regions), and found that the main mechanism of cloud formation is
the turbulent ram pressure, rather than gravity. They were not able to form self gravitating clouds, due to
limitations in the thermal modeling, and the consequent low density contrast.
A 3-D description of a magnetized self-gravitating cloud was given by Carlberg & Pudritz (1990),
and was used to simulate molecular emission spectra by Stenholm & Pudritz (1993). Carlberg & Pudritz
-- 3 --
found that the magnetic field and hydro-magnetic waves can support the cloud against gravity. The
clouds contract, because of ambipolar diffusion, on a timescale of approximately four free-fall times. These
simulations do not solve the MHD equations, but instead make use of a 'sticky particles' code. Energy is
injected in the form of a spectrum of Alfv´en waves, and the outcome of the computation is dependent on
the spectral index, that is a free parameter. This way of forcing the particles is rather unphysical, because
an arbitrary spectrum of Alfv´en waves is imposed, instead of being obtained as a result of the simulated
magneto-hydrodynamics. Passot, V´azquez-Semadeni & Pouquet (1995) introduced the magnetic field in
their previous 2-D model for the galactic disc (V´azquez-Semadeni, Passot & Pouquet 1995), and obtained a
flow with rough equipartition of kinetic and magnetic energy, probably in rough equipartition also with the
mean thermal energy. The same simulation, and others with larger density contrast and resolution, have
been studied by V´azquez-Semadeni, Ballesteros-Paredes & Rodr´iguez (1997), who were able to reproduce
the observed relation between line-width and size (Larson 1981). Gammie and Ostriker (1996) solved the
MHD equations in a slab geometry, including self-gravity. By forcing the flow with a nonlinear spectrum of
MHD waves, they were able to prevent the gravitational collapse of their 1-D cloud model.
Apart from the intentional exclusion of gravity, we have improved significantly on all previous
calculations of turbulent flows. First of all we have solved the MHD equations in three-dimensions, while all
previous solutions are in two or one dimensions. In MHD the dimensionality of the flow has a fundamental
importance, because it determines the topological freedom of the magnetic field. Another improvement of
our work is the high rms Mach number of the flows (∼ 5), while previous models are only mildly supersonic
(Mach number ∼ 1). While previous models of magnetized clouds focused on the role of the magnetic field
as opposed to gravity, and therefore have assumed a magnetic pressure much larger than the gas pressure,
the main purpose of the present work is to show that MCs are well described as flows with much lower
magnetic pressure than previously assumed, and probably in rough equipartition with the gas pressure.
We report on the results of two numerical models. In model A, β ≈ 1, in model B, β ≪ 1, where β is
the ratio of gas pressure and magnetic pressure: β = Pg/Pm. The observations of magnetic field strengths
are in agreement with a scenario where the mean magnetic pressure, hB2ai, is dynamically low (model
A). Magneto-hydrodynamic (MHD) flows develop a very intermittent spatial distribution of the magnetic
energy, and therefore, when the field is detected at a favorable position, its strength is far stronger than the
mean field strength. Dense cores with sub-Alfv´enic velocity dispersion can still be generated, in agreement
with the observations.
2. The experiments
The study of the dynamics of MCs belongs to the field of random MHD flows, in a highly supersonic
regime. The Reynolds number and the magnetic Reynolds number in MC flows are very large. Their
random nature is therefore a basic feature of the dynamics of these flows, and requires an appropriate
description.
For this reason, a realistic description of the dynamics of molecular clouds had to be based on the
numerical solution of the compressible MHD equations in three dimensions, in a random and highly
supersonic regime. We did it with relatively high resolution (1283), with a code designed for turbulence
and MHD turbulence experiments (Nordlund, Galsgaard & Stein 1994; Stein, Galsgaard & Nordlund 1994;
Galsgaard & Nordlund 1996; Nordlund, Stein & Galsgaard 1996; Nordlund & Galsgaard 1997), specifically
adapted to be able to deal with very strong shocks and very large density contrasts.
-- 4 --
One of our purposes with these particular experiments is to explicitly address the classical arguments
about dissipation time scales for super- and sub-Alfv´enic motions, and we therefore perform the experiments
in the spirit of "freely decaying turbulence"; studying the decay of an initial, solenoidal velocity field,
without applying any external forcing. We include external forcing in other experiments that we have made
(e.g., Padoan et al. 1997a, 1997b).
Although we have already developed a version of the code with the inclusion of the gravitational force,
all the experiments were run without gravity, for the following reasons:
• We are mainly interested in studying the magneto-hydrodynamics, rather than the gravitational
instability.
• The observed motions have velocities comparable with the virial velocity, or larger, on a range of
scales, and the clouds are not free-falling.
• If the results of our experiments are discussed only up to a time shorter than or comparable to the
dynamical (or free-fall) time, all our conclusions remain basically unchanged. This time is about a few
million years on a scale of 10 pc, and clouds are not supposed to live much longer than that, before
star formation takes place and becomes energetically important.
We solve the compressible MHD equations:
2.1. The equations
∂ ln ρ
∂t
+ v · ∇ ln ρ = −∇ · v,
∂v
∂t
+ v · ∇v = −
1
ρ
∇P +
1
ρ
j × B + f ,
∂e
∂t
+ v · ∇e = −
P
ρ
∇ · v + QJoule + Qviscous + Qradiative,
∂B
∂t
= ∇ × v × B,
j = ∇ × B,
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
plus numerical diffusion terms, and with periodic boundary conditions. v is the velocity, B the magnetic
field, f an external force (= 0 in these particular experiments), and p = ρT is the pressure at T ≈ const.
Conditions in the cold molecular clouds that we are modeling are such that an isothermal approximation
is adequate; the radiative heat exchange is so efficient that the temperature remains low in most places.
Even if the temperature momentarily increases in shocks, the subsequent cooling is rapid, and the result is
shock structures that are qualitatively and quantitatively similar to isothermal shocks.
-- 5 --
We have thus used isothermal conditions in most of our runs and have verified that this is appropriate,
by rerunning segments of some experiments using the full energy equation. No significant change of
the statistics was found and, since using the full energy equation increases the cost of the experiments
considerably (the strong cooling required to maintain a low temperature forces a much smaller time step),
we performed most of the experiments at constant temperature.
The absence of an explicit resistivity η in the induction equation corresponds to an assumption of flux
freezing on well resolved scales. The code uses shock and current sheet capturing techniques to ensure
that magnetic and viscous dissipation at the smallest resolved scales provide the necessary dissipation
paths for magnetic and kinetic energy. As shown by Galsgaard & Nordlund (1976, 1977), dissipation of
magnetic energy in highly turbulent MHD plasmas occurs at a rate that is independent of the details of
the small scale dissipation. In ordinary hydrodynamic turbulence the corresponding property is one of the
cornerstones of Kolmogorov (1941) scaling.
We have not included ambipolar diffusion in the present experiments, because it occurs on a time-scale
significantly longer than the dynamical time, as recently shown by Myers & Khersonsky (1995) and is thus
expected to be of secondary importance. However, our code has the ability to handle ambipolar diffusion,
and we plan to study its effects in a subsequent paper.
2.2. The code
The code solves the compressible MHD equations on a 3D staggered mesh, with volume centered
mass density and thermal energy, face centered velocity and magnetic field components, and edge centered
electric currents and electric fields (Nordlund, Stein & Galsgaard 1996).
The original code works with "per-unit-volume" variables; mass density, momenta, and thermal energy
per unit volume. In the super-sonic regime relevant in the present application, we found it advantageous to
P
rewrite the code in terms of "per-unit-mass" variables; lnρ, u, and E = 3
ρ . With these variables, the time
evolution of all variables is governed by equations of the type
2
Df
Dt
=
∂f
∂t
+ v · f = ...;
(6)
i.e., equations that specify the time rate of change following the motion. These are better conditioned
than the divergence type equations that result from using per-unit-volume variables (the large -- order
M 2 -- density variation in isothermal shocks cause the per-unit-volume fluxes to vary over several orders of
magnitude).
We use spatial derivatives accurate to 6th order, interpolation accurate to 5th order, and Hyman's 3rd
order time stepping method (Hyman 1979).
In order to minimize the viscous and resistive influence on well resolved scales, we use monotonic
3rd order hyper-diffusive fluxes instead of normal diffusive fluxes, and in order to capture hydrodynamic
and magneto-hydrodynamic shocks we add diffusivities proportional to the negative part of the velocity
divergence, and resistivity proportional to the negative part of the cross-field (two-dimensional) velocity
divergence. Further details of the numerical methods are given by Nordlund, Galsgaard & Stein (1996) and
Nordlund & Galsgaard (1997).
-- 6 --
2.3. Weak and strong magnetic field
For the purpose of this work we have run two experiments: one with βi = 4 (model A), and the other
with βi = 0.04 (model B), where βi = (Pg/Pm)i is the initial ratio of gas and magnetic pressure.
In both experiments the initial density is uniform, and the initial velocity is random. We generate
the velocity field in Fourier space, and we give power, with a normal distribution, only to the Fourier
components in the shell of wave-numbers 1 < k < 2. We perform a Helmholtz decomposition, and use
only the solenoidal component of the initial velocity. The initial magnetic field is uniform, and is oriented
parallel to the z axis: B = B0z.
In experiment B, the initial velocity field is perpendicular to the magnetic field (zero z component), in
order to excite the Alfv´en waves, while in experiment A the initial velocity field has equal amplitude in all
three components. Both experiments are decaying flows, because no external forcing is applied.
We define the Alfv´enic Mach number, MA, as the ratio of the flow rms velocity and the Alfv´en velocity.
In model A, MA ≈ 10, and in model B, MA ≈ 1, initially. Under isothermal conditions, in our units, the
ordinary Mach number M = MA/β1/2, so the ordinary Mach number is initially M ≈ 5 in both cases.
Fig. 1 shows the time evolution of the rms Mach number and rms density in the two experiments. In
both cases, the rms density grows to the value σn ≈ 0.5M, where M is the rms Mach number of the flow,
in about one dynamical time, defined as the ratio of half the linear size of the box over the initial rms
velocity, tdyn = 0.5Lbox/σv,0.
The initial Mach number in experiment B is a bit smaller than in experiment A, because the amplitude
of the initial z component of the velocity field is zero. Nevertheless, energy is immediately transferred to
the z component of the velocity, and the rms z component is subsequently about half the value of the other
two components.
Fig. 2 illustrates the time evolution of the kinetic and magnetic energies, expressed in units of the
mean thermal energy. The time evolution of the magnetic energy is totally different in the two experiments.
In model B the field lines are only weakly perturbed by the flow, and exchange their energy with the flow
periodically (oscillations in magnetic and kinetic energy, Em and Ek); in model A, instead, the magnetic
field is almost passively advected, and its intensity and direction are strongly influenced by compressions
and stretching of field lines. Em grows until it is in approximate equipartition with the thermal energy of
the gas, but remains well below equipartition with the kinetic energy.
In this section we compare our numerical results with observed properties of molecular clouds.
3. Observational tests
3.1. Dissipation of supersonic motions
The time evolution of the kinetic energy is plotted in Fig. 2. After two dynamical times, t = 2.0tdyn,
the flow in experiment A still contains about 30% of its initial kinetic energy or, in other words, the rms
velocity is still about 55% of its initial value. In experiment B, the mean kinetic energy of the oscillations
after two dynamical times is about 40% of its initial value, i.e. the rms velocity is about 63% of the initial
-- 7 --
value.
Thus, contrary to the beliefs that partly motivated developing the Alfv´en wave model of MC turbulence,
the dissipation in model A is not particularly rapid in absolute terms, and the dissipation in model B is
not particularly small. Thus, the advantage of the Alfv´en wave model, as far as the energy dissipation
time-scale is concerned, is little: tdiss,B = 1.3tdiss,A. Although this was already appreciated in Zweibel &
Josafatsson (1983) and Elmegreen (1985), it should be noticed that here we do not include the dissipation
mechanism of ion-neutral friction. Alfv´en waves dissipate mainly because they transfer their energy to
motions along the magnetic field, that are eventually dissipated in shocks. This was found also by Gammie
and Ostriker (1996). It is clear therefore that, from the point of view of the dissipation mechanism, model
B is not significantly superior to model A.
The dissipation of the supersonic motions is not a problem for any of the models, however, because:
• If motions are present there must be a source for their energy; such a source may be active for more
than one dynamical time.
• After one dynamical time 50% of the initial energy in model A is still in the flow. At the scale of 10
pc the dynamical time is about 3 × 106 years: clouds do not need to exist much longer than that
before star formation significantly affects their energetics (Blitz & Shu 1980).
3.2. Magnetic energy probability distribution
We illustrate the probability distribution of the magnetic energy in units of the mean thermal pressure:
1/β = B2/ < Pgi. We recall that initially β is uniform in both models, and its value is βi = 4 in model A,
and βi = 0.04 in model B.
The distribution of the magnetic energy is shown in Fig. 3. Model A develops a very intermittent
distribution, with an exponential tail.
Taking into account the relation between field strength and density (see next section), one finds that
approximately 0.5% of the total mass of the system contains a field 10 times stronger than the mean value.
For example, in a cloud of 104M⊙, one can find a couple of clumps of about 30M⊙ each, with a field
strength B = 40µG, while the mean field of the cloud is only B = 4µG.
Model B is much less intermittent than model A.
3.3. The relation B-n
In regions of maser emission, at densities of about n = 107cm−3, a field strength of the order of
B = 103 − 104µG is observed, while in regions of molecular emission, with approximately n = 102 − 103cm−3,
the field is found to be of the order of B = 10µG (eg Myers & Goodman 1988).
A relation of the type B ∝ n0.3−0.6 may be deduced from the observations (eg Troland, Crutcher &
Kaz`es 1986; Heiles 1987; Dudorov 1991), but it is quite uncertain, especially in the light of the above
discussion about the intermittency of the distribution of the magnetic energy.
The fact remains, however, that observationally the field strength certainly grows with the gas density,
-- 8 --
and this is found over a range of 6 orders of magnitudes in density, and 3 orders of magnitude in field
strength.
Fig. 4 shows the relation B − n in models A and B. The dispersion in the relation B − n is shown in
the form of 1 − σ 'error' bars in the plot of Fig. 4. In model A the slope of the relation decreases with
time. We find B ∝ n0.8 at t = 0.2tdyn, B ∝ n0.7 at t = 1.0tdyn, B ∝ n0.5 at t = 2.0tdyn, and B ∝ n0.3 at
t = 3.0tdyn. We interpret this time evolution of the relation B − n in the next section.
In model B there is no significant correlation between B and n. The lack of correlation between B and
n was to be expected: most of the density enhancement occurs by convergent flows along the field lines, in
the z direction, and these motions do not affect the magnetic field. A nice illustration of this is provided
by the snapshots in Fig. 5 (lower row), where the density field is stratified in planes that are predominantly
perpendicular to the z direction (vertical direction in the images). The densest regions develop at nodes in
the large-scale waves, as found by Carlberg & Pudritz (1990).
One could possibly argue that the lack of correlation of B and n is consistent with the majority of
observations, because no field is detected, and hence nothing can be said about the correlation. However, as
further discussed in Section 4 below, the upper limits of the non-detections speak against this interpretation.
Also, the cases where a field is detected would then have to be explained with ad hoc arguments, rather
than as a natural part of a statistical distribution.
An interesting consequence of the model A results is that the observed relation could in principle be
used to set an independent estimate of the age of molecular clouds: the comparison between model A
and the observations would indicate that molecular clouds, on the average, have survived, since they were
almost uniform in density and field distribution, for 2 or 3 dynamical times, that is about 107 years, on a
scale of 20 pc. This estimate has little to do with the estimate of the time-scale for massive stars to destroy
the parent molecular cloud (Blitz & Shu 1980), since that calculation has nothing to say about the lifetime
of the cloud after it cooled from diffuse warm gas.
To conclude, note that Fig. 4 illustrates that, even if in model A the mean magnetic field is such that
the hβi ≈ 0.7, in regions only 10 times denser than the mean, the field can be as intense as in model B.
3.4. Cloud and flow topology
An understanding of the spatial structure of the density field in dark clouds is very important for a
correct interpretation of observational data, and for the formulation of a number of physical models.
The snapshots in Fig. 5 give an idea of the dimensionality of the structures in the density field. It
is apparent that experiment B (lower row of panels) develops a stratified density field, with sheet-like
structures, the sheets being approximately perpendicular to the magnetic field (the z direction corresponds
to the vertical direction in the figures). This is consistent with the fact that only the motions in the z
direction can compress the gas to very high density.
The topology of the density field in experiment A (upper row of panels in Fig. 5) has a clear evolution
in time. In the very beginning, until t ≈ 0.4tdyn, the density grows predominantly in sheets. These are the
fronts of blobs of coherent motion, advancing at supersonic velocity. Later, these fronts start to intersect
each other, and the density increases especially in filaments (at the intersections of fronts). The evolution
continues with the intersection of filaments into knots, at t ≈ 1.5tdyn. The fully developed topology, at
-- 9 --
t = 2.0tdyn, is characterized by both filaments and knots (cores).
The evolution of the magnitudes of the mass density and the magnetic field may be discussed with
reference to Lagrangian version of the continuity equation,
and the scalar induction equation
D ln ρ
Dt
= −∇ · v,
D ln B
Dt
= −∇⊥ · v,
(7)
(8)
where ∇⊥· stands for the divergence perpendicular to the magnetic field, following both the motion and the
change of orientation of the field lines.
Although −∇ · v vanishes for the solenoidal initial condition, the supersonic motions rapidly lead to the
formation of shock fronts, where the local value of −∇ · v is large and positive because of the discontinuity
in the velocity perpendicular to the shock.
The initially homogeneous magnetic field is carried along by the perpendicular components of the
velocity field, and is hence also collected into sheets, except at those rare locations where the initial field
happens to be strictly parallel to the velocity field. This explains why sheets initially form in both mass
density and magnetic flux density, and why the B − n relation initially has an exponent close to unity.
Note that the usual argument for a slope of 2/3, that applies to isotropic and non-shocking compressible
motion does not apply here, because of the development of discontinuities. In term of Eqs. 7 and 8, the 2/3
follows if −∇⊥ · v typically picks up two of the three directional contributions to −∇ · v. However, at a
shock, the divergence is dominated by the derivative in one particular direction; the one perpendicular to
the shock front. The magnetic field that is swept into the discontinuity quickly becomes almost parallel to
the shock front, because the component in the plane of the shock grows exponentially with time. Thus, as
long as the topology is dominated by sheets, the mass density and the magnetic flux grow more or less in
unison in the sheets, corresponding to an exponent in the B − n relation close to unity.
In the subsequent evolution, there are effects that tend to reduce the exponent in the B − n relation.
First, the non-linear evolution of the initially solenoidal velocity field also leads to the development of
regions of space with a positive divergence, in which both the mass density and the magnetic flux density
decline. In these regions, there is no particular dominance of the cross-field divergence, and thus the
three-dimensional divergence picks up un additional contribution relative to the two-dimensional divergence,
consistent with the classical 2/3 argument outlined above.
In experiment B the motions are mainly Alfv´en waves, and therefore the velocity is predominantly
perpendicular to the direction of the magnetic field. This is illustrated in Fig. 6, where we have plotted the
histogram of cos(α), where α is the angle between v and B. Note that, even though motions across the
field lines are the most common ones, it is the less frequent motions along the field lines that dominate the
dissipation, as mentioned in connection with the discussion of Fig. 5 above. The motions across field lines
are subject to magnetic restoring forces, and do not lead to density enhancements. It is the motions along
the field lines that lead to the sheet like density enhancements visible in Fig. 5.
In experiment A, the magnetic field is advected by the flow, and the stretching of field lines instead
produces some alignment between v and B, already before one dynamical time has passed, as illustrated in
Fig. 6.
Alignment between B and v may be caused by two, complementary effects: 1) Dynamical alignment
-- 10 --
is expected when the magnetic energy approaches and exceeds the kinetic energy; the Lorentz force then
forces the flow to be predominantly along the magnetic field lines. 2) Kinematic alignment occurs when a
spatially non-uniform velocity field causes stretching of magnetic field lines, and hence a correlation of B
and v. Pure shear, for example, tends to align an embedded magnetic field with the direction of the flow.
Motions that are aligned with the magnetic field affect the mass density without affecting the magnetic
flux density. In particular, the non-linear concentration into first sheets and then filaments due to the
interaction of shock fronts continues into the formation of knots in the density field, by the convergence of
matter flowing along filaments. There is no corresponding process available to a divergence free vector field
such as the magnetic field; once the field has concentrated into filaments, it cannot concentrate further; the
magnetic field in a filament is insensitive to flow along the filament.
In the same way that converging flows along the magnetic field may lead to extreme concentrations of
mass, those regions where the flow is diverging along magnetic field lines may lead to extreme rarefactions
of mass, without affecting the magnetic flux density. In B − n scatter plots, this corresponds to the
development of more extreme excursions of the mass, relative to those of the magnetic flux density, and
hence a flattening of the B − n relation with time.
In model A, dynamical alignment is at most significant in the few cores that develop a strong
(sub-Alfv´enic) magnetic field in the early evolution of the experiment. In scatter plots of B against n
most contributions come from regions where dynamical alignment is unimportant. We thus conclude that
the evolution of the B − n relation in model A, towards a smaller exponent with time, is caused by the
kinematic alignment of B and v.
3.5. Stellar extinction
Padoan, Jones, & Nordlund (1997) have shown that near-infrared stellar extinction determinations
can be used to infer the 3-D probability distribution of the gas density in dark clouds. They have shown
that there is qualitative and quantitative agreement between the inferred 3-D density distribution in dark
clouds, and the one produced by their experiment of random supersonic flows.
The method is based on the plot of the dispersion of the extinction measurements in cells, versus the
mean extinction in the same cells (Lada et al. 1994). In Padoan, Jones & Nordlund (1997), the theoretical
plots are produced by generating random density fields of given statistics and power spectra. Here we show
one example of the same plot, but produced directly from the density field of experiments A and B. The
plot is shown in Fig. 7, that can be compared directly with the plots shown in Padoan, Jones, & Nordlund.
The plot of model A looks like the observational one. It has a smaller slope because the rms Mach number
in Experiment A is smaller than in the observed cloud.
The plot for Experiment B seems instead to differ from the observational one. The absence of locations
with very low extinction in model B is due to the fact that the density field in experiment B is mainly
organized in sheets, perpendicular to the magnetic field direction.
-- 11 --
4. Discussion
It is difficult to get an objective view on the magnetic field strength in dark clouds from the literature.
The reasons are the following:
• Negative results from observational programs, in which detections have been reported, often remain
unpublished.
• The positions searched for Zeeman splitting never represent a statistically meaningful sample.
Favorable regions are always selected, because the observations are very time consuming.
• The total number of regions in dark clouds, for which OH Zeeman observations are published, is still
small.
The best study of OH Zeeman splitting in dark clouds we are aware of is by Crutcher et al. (1993).
They selected 4 cores in the Taurus dark cloud complex, 2 in the Libra complex, 2 in ρ Oph, 1 in the Orion
molecular ridge, 1 position in L889, and the core of B1 (Barnard 1), in the Perseus region. The only certain
detection is in the cloud B1. For the other regions, the weighted average value of the field is +2.7 ± 1.5µG in
Taurus, −2.1 ± 2.8µG in Libra, +6.8 ± 2.5µG in ρOph, −0.6 ± 2.1µG in L889, and −4.7 ± 3.5µG in L1647.
Two well known regions of very intense magnetic field are Orion A and Orion B. OH Zeeman splitting
in Orion A revealed a magnetic field strength of B = −125µG (Troland, Crutcher, & Kaz`es 1986), and
B = +38µG toward Orion B (Crutcher, & Kaz`es 1983).
Crutcher et al. (1996) have reported the first attempt to measure CN Zeeman splitting. They observed
towards the cores OMC-N4 and S106-CN. They did not detect the magnetic field, and their upper limits
are several times smaller than the value expected if the observed motions were sub-Alfv´enic.
An average field of +9µG was found in Cas A by Heiles and Stevens (1986).
The OH Zeeman splitting should probe regions with n = 103 − 104 cm−3, while the CN Zeeman
splitting, should probe regions of n ≈ 106 cm−3.
Note that all works are biased toward regions of strong field, because only regions considered to be
favorable for magnetic field detections are selected for Zeeman splitting observations. Despite that, in many
cases the field is not detected, and upper limits are quite stringent.
In our model A we find that, if the mean field strength is hB2i1/2 = 5µG, and the mean density
hni = 103cm−3, at the time t = 2.0tdyn, then 20% of the total mass is in dense clumps, with density ten
times larger than the mean, n ≈ 104cm−3, and field strength five times, or more, larger than the mean,
B ≥ 25µG. Therefore, even if field strengths of about 30µG are detected sometimes in dense cores, the
Ai1/2 ≈ CS.
mean Alfv´en velocity in the molecular cloud may be just comparable to the sound speed, hv2
On the basis of the observational results by Crutcher et al. (1993, 1996), it may be concluded that
model A is in consistent with the observational estimates of magnetic field strength in dark clouds. The
particular values of the magnetic field used in the comparison here should not be taken too literally; the
small scale field strengths could be larger than estimated by the Zeeman effect if the magnetic field is
tangled.
It is difficult to envisage how the measurements could be consistent with model B, however, since
the magnetic field in a sub-Alfv´enic model by definition has an energy that exceeds the kinetic energy.
-- 12 --
As demonstrated by Galsgaard & Nordlund (1996), a magnetically dominated plasma is able to quickly
dissipate structural complexity, independent of the value of the resistivity. Thus, a sub-Alfv´enic field
could not remain strongly tangled, and hence could not avoid detection. Using the same argument, we
expect those cores where a strong (sub-Alfv´enic) field has indeed been observed to have a relatively simple
magnetic field structure.
Model A can be used for the description of a typical molecular cloud with linear size of about 5 pc and
hni = 500 cm−3. At the time t = 1.0tdyn, the relation B − n is then:
B = 5µG(
n
500cm−3 )0.7
(9)
Since the exponent is > 0.5, most of the dense cores are found to have magnetic pressure larger than
thermal pressure, at early times. This is illustrated in Fig. 8, where we have plotted the Alfv´en velocity
versus the gas density, after one dynamical time, for experiments A and B. In model A, one can see that,
on average, regions with density larger than the mean are characterized by an Alfv´en velocity larger than
the sound velocity, and therefore by a magnetic pressure larger than the thermal pressure.
The lowering of the exponent in the B − n power law with time means that later on, the dominance
of the magnetic field in these cores tends to be reduced. Although the flow is random and approximately
isotropic, the kinematic alignment of B with v makes dense cores accrete mass along B at an increased rate.
Therefore, the accretion of mass around dense cores, embedded in a random flow with β ≈ 1, is such that,
while magnetic pressure becomes dominant over thermal pressure during the initial phase of fragmentation,
later on magnetic pressure decreases to the level of thermal pressure, even in the absence of gravity, and on
a timescale that is competitive with ambipolar diffusion. This mechanism could be relevant for the process
of star formation.
The main point we want to clarify in this paper is that the fact of finding some cloud cores, with
sub-Alfv´enic velocity dispersions and with magnetic pressure larger than thermal pressure, does not
necessarily mean that the dynamics of molecular clouds is dominated by MHD waves; those cores may be
formed, in a few million years, in a supersonic and super-Alfv´enic flow, only marginally affected by the
magnetic field (model A). The dynamics becomes strongly affected by the magnetic field only in some very
dense regions, on small scales, and at early times.
We stress that a key theoretical ingredient to the interpretation of OH Zeeman splitting data is the
B − n relation. The fact that the exponent of the relation is > 0.5 for more than two dynamical times is
the reason why sub-Alfv´enic cores can be found in the experiment.
In this work we have shown that:
5. Conclusions
• Supersonic motions in model A are relatively long-lived, with decay times comparable to the estimated
life-time of molecular clouds. Even in the absence of an energy source, supersonic and super-Alfv´enic
motions can persist as such, on a scale of 20 pc, for about 107 years.
• Supersonic sub-Alfv´enic motions (model B) dissipate their energy almost as fast as super-Alfv´enic
motions. The original motivation for the MHD wave model is therefore absent.
-- 13 --
• Random supersonic motions produce a very intermittent probability distribution of the magnetic
energy, with an exponential tail. Since the distribution is so intermittent, one could easily detect a
field strength that is several times in excess of the mean strength.
• Dense cores, with magnetic pressure larger than thermal pressure, and velocity dispersions smaller
than vA, are found as the result of the evolution of supersonic and super-Alfv´enic flows (model A).
• A power law statistical B − n relation is generated by supersonic motions, in model A, but not by
MHD waves, in model B. The exponent of the relation is > 0.5 for about two dynamical times, which
allows for the existence of cores with vA > CS.
• The exponent in the B − n relation decreases with time, because magnetic field lines are stretched and
partially aligned with the flow. The statistical importance of the magnetic pressure in dense cores is
thus expected to decrease with time, even in the absence of gravity and ambipolar diffusion.
• The topology of the density field generated by model A is mainly filamentary and clumpy. This is
reminiscent of the morphology of molecular clouds. On the other hand, the density field produced by
MHD waves in model B is mainly structured in sheets, perpendicular to the magnetic field.
• The statistical properties of the density field generated by random supersonic motions (as in model
A) are in agreement with the statistical properties of the gas density in dark clouds, as inferred from
stellar extinction determinations. Model B does not give such a good agreement.
The comparison between model A and model B shows that model A (super-Alfv´enic motions) provides
a nice understanding of the dynamics and structure of molecular clouds. Moreover, it is consistent with the
OH Zeeman detections.
We conclude that the supersonic motions observed in dark clouds, on a scale of a few parsecs to several
parsecs, can be understood, without any major problem, as super-Alfv´enic motions, although sub-Alfv´enic
dense cores certainly exist.
We thank Prof. L. Mestel and Prof. E. Zweibel for their comments on the manuscript. This work has
been supported by the Danish National Research Foundation through its establishment of the Theoretical
Astrophysics Center. Computing resources were provided by the Danish National Science Research Council,
and by the French 'Centre National de Calcul Parall`ele en Science de la Terre'.
REFERENCES
Arny, T. 1971, ApJ, 169, 289
Arons, J. & Max, C. E. 1975, ApJ, 196, L77
Blitz, L. & Shu, F. H. 1980, ApJ, 238, 148
Bonazzola, S., Falgarone, E., Heyvaerts, J., Perault, M. & Puget, J. L. 1987, A&A, 172, 293
Bonazzola, S., Perault, M., Puget, J. L., Heyvaerts, J., Falgarone, E. & Panis, J. F. 1992, J. Fluid Mech.,
245, 1
-- 14 --
Carlberg, R. G. & Pudritz, R. E. 1990, MNRAS, 247, 353
Chandrasekhar, S. 1958, Proc. Roy. Soc., 246, 301
Crutcher, R. M. & Kaz`es, I. 1983, A&A, 125, L23
Crutcher, R. M., Troland, T. H., Goodman, A. A., Heiles, C., Kaz`es, I. & Myers, P. C. 1993, ApJ, 407, 175
Crutcher, R. M., Troland, T. H., Lazareff, B. & Kaz`es, I. 1996, ApJ, 456, 217
Dame, T. M., Elmegreen, B. G., Cohen, R. S., Thaddeus, P. 1986, ApJ, 305, 892
Dudorov, A. E. 1991, Sov. A., 35(4), 342
Elmegreen, B. G. 1985, ApJ, 299, 196
Falgarone, E. & Puget, J. L. 1986, A&A, 162, 235
Falgarone, E., P´erault, M. 1987, in Physical Processes in Interstellar Clouds, ed. G. Morfil, M. Scholer
(Dordrecht: Reidel), 59
Falgarone, E., Puget, J., -L. & P´erault, M. 1992, A&A, 257, 715
Falgarone, E., Lis, D. C., Phillips, T. G., Pouquet, A., Porter, D. H. & Woodward, P. R. 1994, ApJ, 436,
728
Fleck, R. C. Jr 1981, ApJ, 246, L151
Galsgaard, K. & Nordlund, A. 1996, J. of Geophys. Res., 101(A6),13445
Galsgaard, K. & Nordlund, A. 1997, J. of Geophys. Res., 102, 231
Gammie, C. F. & Ostriker, E. C. 1996, ApJ, 466, 814
Goldreich, P. & Kwan, J. 1974, ApJ, 189, 441
Goldsmith, P. F. & Arquilla, R. 1985, in Protostars and Planets II, University of Arizona Press, p. 137
Heiles, C., Stevens, M. 1986, ApJ, 301, 331
Heiles, C. 1987, D. J. Hollenbach & H. A. Thronson (eds.), Interstellar Processes, Reidel, p. 171
Houlahan, P. & Scalo, J. 1992, ApJ, 393, 172
Hyman, J. M. 1979, R. Vichnevetsky & R. S. Stepleman (eds.), in Adv. in Comp. Meth. for PDE's, p. 313
Kimura, T. & Tosa, M. 1993, ApJ, 406, 512
Kolmogorov, A. N. 1941, Dokl. Akad. Nauk. SSSR, 30, 301 -- 305.
Lada, C. J., Lada, E. A., Clemens, D. P., & Bally, J. 1994, ApJ, 429, 694
Langer, W. D., Velusamy, T., Kuiper, T. B. H., Levin, S., Olsen, E., Migenes, V. 1995, ApJ, 453, 293
Larson, R. B. 1981, MNRAS, 194, 809
Lee, S., Lele, S. K., Moin, P. 1991, Phys. Fluids A 3, 657
-- 15 --
L´eorat, J., Passot, T., Pouquet, A. 1990, MNRAS, 243, 293
Leung, C. M., Kutner, M. L., Mead, K. N. 1982, ApJ, 262, 583
McKee, C. F. & Zweibel E. G. 1995, ApJ, 440, 686
Mestel, L. & Spitzer, L. 1956, MNRAS, 116, 503
Mestel, L. 1965, Q. Jl. R.A.S., 6, 161, 265
Morris, M., Zuckerman, B., Turner, B. E. & Palmer, P. 1974, ApJ, 192, L23 ıı
Mouschovias, T. Ch. 1976a, ApJ, 206, 753
Mouschovias, T. Ch. 1976b, ApJ, 207, 141
Mouschovias, T. Ch. & Psaltis, D. 1995, ApJ, 444, L105
Myers, P. C. 1983, ApJ, 270, 105
Myers, P. C. & Goodman, A. A. 1988, ApJ, 326, L27
Myers, P. C. & Khersonsky, V. H. 1995, ApJ, 442, 186
Nordlund, A, Galsgaard, K. & Stein, R. F. 1994, in R, J, Rutten, C J. Schrijver (eds.), Solar Surface
Magnetic Fields, Vol. 433, NATO ASI Series
Nordlund, A, Stein, R. F. & Galsgaard, K. 1996, in J. Wazniewski (ed.), Proceedings from the PARA95
workshop, Vol 1041 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, p. 450
Nordlund, A& Galsgaard, K. 1997, Journal of Computational Physics, (in preparation)
Norman, C., Silk, J. 1980, ApJ, 238, 158
Padoan, P. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 377
Padoan, P., Jones, B. J. T. & Nordlund, A. 1997, ApJ, 474, 730
Padoan, P., Nordlund, A. & Jones, B. J. T. 1997, MNRAS, in press
Parker, D. A. 1973, MNRAS, 163, 41
Parker, E. N. 1994, Spontaneous Current Sheets in Magnetic Fields, Oxford University Press
Passot, T., Pouquet, A. 1987, J. Fluid Mech., 181, 441
Passot, T., Pouquet, A., Woodward, P. 1988, A&A, 197, 228
Passot, T., V´azquez-Semadeni, E. & Pouquet A. 1995, ApJ, 455, 536
Porter, D. H., Pouquet, A. & Woodward, P.R. 1994, Phys. Fluids, 6, 2133
Quiroga, R. J. 1983, Ap. Sp. Sci., 93, 37
Sanders, D. B., Scoville, N. Z., Solomon, P. M. 1985, ApJ, 289, 372
Scalo, J. M., Pumphrey, W. A. 1982, ApJ, 258, L29
-- 16 --
Scalo, J. M. 1985, in Protostars and Planets II, ed. D. C. Black and M. S. Mathews (Tucson: University of
Arizona Press), 349
Spitzer, L. 1968, in Nebulae and Interstellar Matter, Stars and Stellar Systems, ed. B. Middlehurst, L. H.
Aller, 7, 1, Univ. Chicago Press
Stein, R. F., Galsgaard, K. & Nordlund, A. 1994, in J. D. B. et al (ed.), Proc. of the Cornelius Lanczos
International Centenary Conference, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics, Philadelphia,
p. 440
Stenholm, L. G. & Pudritz, R. E. 1993, ApJ, 416, 218
Strittmatter, P. A. 1966, MNRAS, 132, 359
Troland, T. H., Crutcher, R. M. & Kaz`es, I. 1986, ApJ, 304, L57
V´azquez-Semadeni, E. 1994, ApJ, 423, 681
V´azquez-Semadeni, E., Ballesteros-Paredes, J. & Rodr´iguez, L. F. 1997, ApJ, 474, 292
V´azquez-Semadeni, E., Passot, T. & Pouquet, A. 1995, ApJ, 441, 702
Velusamy, T., Kuiper, T. B. H., Langer, W. D., in preparation
Zuckerman, B. & Evans, N. J. 1974, ApJ, 192, L152
Zuckerman, B. & Palmer, P. 1974, ARA&A, 12, 279
Zweibel, E. G. & Josafatsson, K. 1983, ApJ, 270, 511
Xie, T. 1997, ApJ, 475, L139
This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
-- 17 --
Fig. 1. -- Time evolution of rms Mach number and rms number density.
-- 18 --
Fig. 2. -- Time evolution of kinetic and magnetic energies, in units of the mean thermal energy.
-- 19 --
Fig. 3. -- Distribution of magnetic energy in units of the mean gas pressure, after one dynamical time. The
dotted vertical line marks the initial mean value of the magnetic energy, and the dashed line the mean value
after one dynamical time.
-- 20 --
Fig. 4. -- The relation B − n, after one dynamical time. The magnetic field is expressed in the numerical
units, that is as an Alfv´en velocity (defined with the mean gas density), in units of the sound speed. The
1 − σ 'error' bars show the dispersion of values of B around the mean for each bin. The size of the bins is
chosen in order to have the same number of measurements inside each bin.
-- 21 --
Fig. 5. -- 3-D representation of the time evolution of the density field. Time evolves from left to right. The
upper row of panels show model A, while the lower row shows model B.
-- 22 --
Fig. 6. -- Histograms of the cosine of the angle between v and B.
alignement, while in experiment B the two fields are mainly perpendicular to each other.
In experiment A there is a partial
-- 23 --
Fig. 7. -- Relation between the dispersion of the extinction and the mean extinction, on a regular grid
superposed of the projection of the density field. The value of the extinction are measured at random
positions, simulating the random position of a star behind the cloud.
-- 24 --
Fig. 8. -- The Alfv´en velocity, in units of the sound velocity, versus the gas density. The dashed line is the
B − n relation, that is to say the Alfv´en velocity defined with the mean density, instead of with the local
density. In Experiment A, the magnetic pressure is on average larger than the gas pressure, in regions with
gas density larger than the mean.
|
0810.1519 | 1 | 0810 | 2008-10-08T20:00:25 | Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1 | [
"astro-ph"
] | We present highlights from a series of four simultaneous Suzaku/RXTE observations of the black hole candidate Cyg X-1. We briefly summarize several key results from our decade long RXTE monitoring campaign. We then comment on challenges of analyzing the Suzaku data, i.e., improving the aspect correction beyond that of the existing tools, and quantitatively assessing pileup. All of our Suzaku observations (one, by design) occurred at or very near orbital phase 0 (superior conjunction), and hence show evolution in color-color diagrams due to X-ray absorption by material from the wind of the secondary. We present simple partial absorption models for this evolution. We then compare the Suzaku and RXTE data, and explicitly divide the Fe line region into narrow and broad components. Both are required for the Suzaku data, and are seen to be consistent with the RXTE data. These Suzaku observations occurred near historically hard, low flux states. We present fits of the broad band spectra with a simple phenomenological broken powerlaw model, as well as a more physically motivated Comptonization model. Whereas the former class of models described nearly all of the RXTE campaign better than any physical model, here the latter model is slightly more successful. The Comptonization model, however, exhibits little evidence for a soft disk component, which formally corresponds to a small, inner disk radius. Whether this is physical, due to unmodeled absorption, or is a calibration issue, remains an open question. | astro-ph | astro-ph | Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak∗†
MIT Kavli Institute, Cambridge, USA
E-mail: [email protected]
We present highlights from a series of four simultaneous Suzaku/Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer
(RXTE) observations of the black hole candidate Cyg X-1. We first briefly summarize several
key results from our decade long RXTE monitoring campaign (which to date contains over 250
observations). We then comment on challenges of analyzing the Suzaku data, i.e., improving the
aspect correction beyond that of the existing tools, and quantitatively assessing pileup. All of our
Suzaku observations (one, by design) occurred at or very near orbital phase 0 (superior conjunc-
tion), and hence show evolution in color-color diagrams due to X-ray absorption by material from
the wind of the secondary. We present simple partial absorption models for this evolution. We
then compare the Suzaku and RXTE data, and explicitly divide the Fe line region into narrow
and broad components. Both are required for the Suzaku data, and are seen to be consistent with
the RXTE data. These Suzaku observations occurred near historically hard, low flux states. We
present fits of the broad band spectra with a simple phenomenological broken powerlaw model, as
well as a more physically motivated Comptonization model. Whereas the former class of models
described nearly all of the RXTE campaign better than any physical model, here the latter model
is slightly more successful. The Comptonization model, however, exhibits little evidence for a
soft disk component, which formally corresponds to a small, inner disk radius. Whether this is
physical, due to unmodeled absorption, or is a calibration issue, remains an open question.
8
0
0
2
t
c
O
8
]
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
[
1
v
9
1
5
1
.
0
1
8
0
:
v
i
X
r
a
VII Microquasar Workshop: Microquasars and Beyond
September 1 - 5, 2008
Foca, Izmir, Turkey
∗Speaker.
†With the assistance of Paolo Coppi (Yale), John E. Davis (MIT Kavli Institute), Manfred Hanke (Universität
Erlangen-Nuremberg), Sera Markoff (University of Amsterdam), Katja Pottschmidt (CRESST/GSFC/UMBC), Sarah
Trowbridge (MIT Kavli Institute), and Jörn Wilms (Universität Erlangen-Nuremberg). Anything coherent and truthful
herein is largely thanks to them, while any incoherent ramblings are wholly my own. This work was supported in part
by NASA Grants SV3-73016 and NNX08AE23G.
c(cid:13) Copyright owned by the author(s) under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Licence.
http://pos.sissa.it/
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
1. Summary of RXTE Campaign
Cyg X-1 is one of the best studied of the galactic black hole candidates (BHC). It has been a
persistent X-ray source, exhibiting, very broadly, spectrally hard to somewhat softer X-ray states.
(Whereas the hard X-ray tail softens, it never completely vanishes for Cyg X-1.) In Cyg X-1 these
spectral states occur over a factor of only a few in X-ray flux. A summary of the system properties
can be found in [13], while a summary of the broad band spectral behavior can be found in [22],
and references therein. Whereas Cyg X-1 exhibits an interesting variety of variability behavior (see
[15, 16, 1, 7, 20], etc.) and radio behavior (see [5, 6, 14, 22], etc.) correlated with the X-ray spectra
and flux, here we concentrate on the X-ray spectral properties.
In Fig. 1, we present some of the spectral highlights from our RXTE monitoring campaign
([22]). First, we see that the broad band spectra are extremely well-described by a very sim-
ple model: an absorbed, exponentially cutoff broken powerlaw, with a broad gaussian line. The
spectral break always occurs near 10 keV, with the degree of the break increasing for softer (typi-
cally brighter) spectra. More physically motivated Comptonization models ([9, 22]) and X-ray jet
models ([11]) fit the data nearly as well. The former fit the soft X-ray power law with a combi-
nation of disk photons and Comptonization, and the (exponentially cutoff) hard X-ray powerlaw
with Comptonization and reflection. The jet models also utilize these same physical components,
but also allow for jet synchrotron radiation (usually in the soft X-ray), and jet synchrotron self-
Compton (usually in the hard X-ray). For neither the Comptonization nor jet models is there a
single continuum component underlying the Fe Ka
line region.
Prior studies have ascribed the G 1 -- G 2 correlation predominantly to a hardness-reflection anti-
correlation ([23, 9]). Although this effect is seen somewhat by our campaign ([22], Fig. 1), it is
greatly reduced from prior claims (e.g., [9]). A major difference between these studies is that we
have allowed the fitted seed photon temperature to be a free parameter, whereas other studies have
not (i.e., [9]). Fig. 1 shows that to some extent, a hardness-disk flux anti-correlation subsumes a
substantial fraction of any hardness-reflection anti-correlation. The ability of Suzaku to measure
the soft X-ray spectral regime is therefore seen to be crucial in further constraining such models.
For all of our RXTE spectral fits, whether broken power law, Comptonization, or jet, a broad
gaussian is found near the expected position of the 6.4 keV, Fe Ka
line. However, the width of this
line, and its correlations with spectral hardness, do depend upon the exact fitted model. (Broken
power laws tend to produce the narrowest lines; different Comptonization models, e.g., comptt
vs. eqpair yield differing line widths [22].) Furthermore, RXTE lacks the spectral resolution to
decompose the residuals in the line region into broad and narrow components. Suzaku, on the other
hand, does have sufficient resolution to decompose the line into components, and again is seen to
be crucial for further constraining spectral models.
2. Attitude Correction and Pileup Estimation for the Suzaku Observations
Before we can describe and fit the Suzaku spectra, we must first make sure that we have
minimized instrumental effects. Most important among these is the reduction of photon pileup,
i.e., when more than one photon lands in the same or adjacent pixels in one CCD readout frame
(see [4] for a technical description). These "piled" events are either lost (due to exceeding the
2
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
b
1.2
1.0
0.8
2
−
1
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
1.5
1037
]
1
−
s
g
r
e
[
k
s
i
d
L
2.0
2.5
1
3.0
3.5
Fdisk
(lh/ls)−0.19
2p
/
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
2
4
lh/ls
6
0
2
4
lh/ls
6
8
Figure 1: A brief summary of results from our monitoring campaign of Cyg X-1 ([22]). The upper left
shows unfolded RXTE-PCA/HEXTE spectra (see also [14]), fit with a simple absorbed, exponentially cutoff
broken powerlaw plus broad gaussian line. (This spectrum is among the softest seen in the campaign.) The
amplitude of the powerlaw break is correlated with the soft powerlaw slope (softer corresponds to a greater
break), as shown in the upper right. Solid points are the Cyg X-1 hard state (as defined by [18]), and hollow
points are the Cyg X-1 soft state. The lower left shows results from fitting the eqpair Comptonization
model of [3], which parameterizes spectral hardness with a ratio of coronal compactness to seed photon
compactness (≡ ℓh/ℓs). Here the break between the soft and hard X-ray powerlaws are a combination of
anti-correlations between the spectral hardness and reflection fraction (left) and amplitude of any additional,
soft X-ray disk component (right).
3
G
G
G
(cid:181)
W
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
Figure 2: Left: An example of Suzaku attitude correction. The left half of the image shows a Suzaku PSF
for Cyg X-1 using the standard attitude correction. The right half of the image shows the improvement with
aeattcorr.sl. Right: Improving the attitude correction allows for a better estimate of pileup in the
image. Here we show an image where discrete colors correspond to the minimum level of pileup in that
region. The outer white circle is the extraction region, while the inner white circle is the excluded region
(with pileup fractions as high as 30%). The average effective residual pileup level is less than 4%.
event energy threshold, or migrating to bad "event grades"), or are read as a higher energy photon,
therefore distorting the spectrum. (This distortion can be especially problematic at high energies,
as the intrinsic photon count rate spectra tend to be (cid:181) E −1.7.) In order to assess the degree of
pileup, we must first have the most accurate measure of the X-ray image. This in turn requires
an accurate spacecraft attitude. For Suzaku, the latter is affected by "thermal wobbling" of the
spacecraft, induced during day/night passages during the spacecraft orbit ([19]).
Whereas a statistical correction has been developed to correct the spacecraft attitude ([19]), for
bright sources (e.g., many AGN, and our Cyg X-1 data), the correction can be improved further by
measuring the mean position of the point spread function (PSF) on short time scales, then refining
the empirical correction of the spacecraft attitude. Such an algorithm, aeattcor.sl, has been
developed by John Davis, and as shown in Fig. 2 it further improves the Cyg X-1 image.
With this improved image, one can then calculate the mean counts per 3 × 3 pixel region per
CCD readout frame, and thereby arrive at a quantitative assessment of the fractional pileup level
in a given image. We have developed a tool (pileup_estimate.sl) to automate this process.
It further allows one to create a region filter that excludes the central piled regions, and returns an
estimate of the average pileup fraction in the remainder of the image.
These tools have been made available publicly1. For each of our observations we exclude
approximately 1/3 of the total counts from the center of the (attitude corrected) image. We estimate
that any residual pileup fractions are <∼ 4%.
1http://space.mit.edu/CXC/software/suzaku/
4
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
5
.
2
2
2
5
.
1
1.5
2
3
2.5
1
Figure 3: As discussed by [22], RXTE observations of Cyg X-1 are well-fit by an exponentially cutoff,
broken powerlaw. The low energy power law (G 1) is strongly correlated with the high energy powerlaw
(G 2). The triangles correspond to the Cyg X-1 hard state, while the circles correspond to the Cyg X-1 soft
state. The filled diamonds correspond to the RXTE observations simultaneous with our Suzaku observations.
(Note that points are shown for eight individual color-color regions from the four separate observations.)
3. The Suzaku Observations
Over the course of a year and a half, we have obtained four simultaneous Suzaku/RXTE ob-
servations. (The most recent observation in April 2008 was also performed simultaneously with
Chandra, XMM-Newton, INTEGRAL, and Swift.) In Fig. 3 we show the location in the G 1 -- G 2
diagram of broken powerlaw fits to the simultaneous RXTE data. We immediately see that these
spectra were among the spectrally hardest observations of the past decade.
Note that Fig. 3 shows eight, rather than just four points, as we have subdivided each observa-
tion by its location on a color-color diagram defined by the Suzaku bandpasses (see Fig. 4). All of
our observations show evolution towards the lower left corner of these diagrams, with three of the
four observations rounding the corner and evolving to the right along the bottom of the diagram.
These three observations (with durations of 0.2 in phase) overlapped with orbital phase 0 (i.e.,
superior conjunction; the April 2008 observation was specifically scheduled for that phase). The
fourth observation covered orbital phase 0.2 -- 0.3. Thus all observations were subject to a series of
dipping events due to absorption by the stellar wind of the secondary (see [2]).
We can model the color-color diagrams by fitting a spectrum to the locus of points in the
upper right hand of the plot, and then multiplying this spectrum by a range of additional column
densities (above and beyond the Galactic column). This yields the downward/leftward evolution on
the diagram. In order to obtain the evolution to the right along the bottom of the diagram, we need
to presume a partial covering fraction of 80% (i.e., 20% uncovered) for at least the soft X-rays. Our
best fit to the diagram, however, is for the middle X-rays to be 100% covered. The uncovered soft
X-rays, rather than being wholly local to the source, is likely dominated by the dust scattering halo
5
G
G
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
5
1
.
1
5
0
.
)
V
e
k
9
−
3
(
/
)
V
e
k
3
−
5
.
1
(
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
(0.5−1.5 keV)/(1.5−3 keV)
Figure 4: Color-color diagram for a Suzaku Cyg X-1 observation. The evolution to the lower left corner
of the diagram is consistent with increased absorption, while the rightward extending tail indicates partial
absorption. The lines show partial covering models where only the absorption is changed. From left to
right, respectively, they represent: all channels having the same 82% covering fraction, the two high energy
channels having the same (100%) covering fraction (the soft channel is 82% covered), and the highest energy
channel being completely uncovered (the soft channel is 81% covered, the middle channel is 100% covered).
Three of our Cyg X-1 observations occurred near orbital phase 0, and show similar color-color diagrams.
(see [17]), a substantial fraction of which is contained within the 2 arcminute Suzaku PSF. We note
that Chandra observations of such dipping are more consistent with a 95% covering fraction (see
[8], and the contribution by M. Hanke in this volume).
We have divided each observation into as many as three pieces - the locus of points in the
upper right, the downward slope to the left, and the evolution to the right along the bottom of the
diagram. These time intervals were defined by the Suzaku observations, and then RXTE spectra
were extracted from the intersections with those time intervals. Throughout the rest of this work,
we only consider spectra from the locus of points in the upper right.
4. The Fe Ka Line Region
We next turn to the line region of the data. RXTE data have suggested a broad Fe line ([22]),
but questions have remained as to contributions from narrow components, especially given the very
modest resolution of RXTE2. First, we wish to address the consistency between the two detectors.
We do this by fitting a simple phenomenological model (e.g., a powerlaw) simultaneously to the
3.5 -- 4.5 keV and 7.5 -- 8.5 keV data, and then noticing the ratio residuals in the full 3 -- 9 keV range.
This procedure does not necessarily produce an accurate profile for any broad line in the 4 -- 8 keV
region (it produces perhaps the "most optimistic" estimate of such a line), but it can show the
consistency of the Suzaku and RXTE residuals. We show such ratio residuals in Fig. 5.
2Chandra resolves the narrow components of the line (see [12]). For Chandra, however, the broad components are
difficult to assess with great accuracy (see [8], and the contribution by M. Hanke in this volume).
6
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
5
1
.
1
1
1
.
5
0
.
1
o
i
t
a
R
1
5
9
.
0
4
6
8
Energy (keV)
Figure 5: Fit residuals for RXTE (filled diamonds) and Suzaku (histogram), designed to emphasize features
in the Fe Ka
region. A simple power law spectrum was fit to the 3.5 -- 4.5 and 7.5 -- 8.5 keV spectra, and then
the full 3.5 -- 9 keV spectra were noticed without refitting the model. The Suzaku data have been binned to
half width half maximum (HWHM) of the spectral resolution.
There is indeed very good agreement between the Suzaku and RXTE residuals, and both show
broad deviations from a simple continuum, consistent with a relativistically broadened line. (We
have not, however, included all the potential continuum complexity discussed above, i.e., disk,
Comptonization, synchrotron, synchrotron self-Compton, and reflection). The Suzaku data also
strongly suggest narrow components. A narrow emission feature is seen at 6.4 keV, and a possible
absorption feature is seen at 6.7 keV. Based upon prior Chandra observations at orbital phase 0
([8]), both features are expected. The emission and absorption features have comparable equivalent
widths (absolute value ≈ 10 -- 30 eV), and hence do not form the main contribution to the broad
residuals seen in the RXTE data (equivalent width ≈ 100-150 eV, if fitting just a single component).
We see that at least three components are required to fit the broad line region residual in the
RXTE data. In Fig. 6 we present such continuum plus multi-component line fits. Specifically, we
include a relativistic diskline model, a narrow gaussian emission line, and a narrow gaussian
absorption line. We show fits with and without an additional smeared edge. Both sets of fits
require a broadened line component, with an inner radius ranging from 10 GM/c2 to 60 GM/c2.
The equivalent width of the broad line component is in the 40 -- 130 eV range (and is 10% -- 30%
lower if including a smeared edge). It is interesting to note that the peak in the blue wing of the line
is obscured by the absorption line at 6.7 keV. We have found, however, that it is difficult to fit the
width and location of the RXTE residuals without such a blue peak in the broad line component.
5. Broad Band Fits
We now turn to the broad band spectra by considering models fit to the 0.7 -- 9 keV XIS data3,
the 3 -- 22 keV RXTE-PCA data, and the 18 -- 200 keV RXTE-HEXTE data. As for our RXTE cam-
3For plotting purposes, all XIS spectra are summed, however, we fit each XIS data set individually. The HXD-PIN
7
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
V
V
V
V
e
e
e
e
k
k
k
k
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
s
s
s
s
2
2
2
2
−
−
−
−
m
m
m
m
c
c
c
c
s
s
s
s
n
n
n
n
o
o
o
o
t
t
t
t
o
o
o
o
h
h
h
h
P
P
P
P
2
2
2
2
V
V
V
V
e
e
e
e
k
k
k
k
o
o
i
i
t
t
a
a
R
R
5
5
5
5
.
.
.
.
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
5
5
5
5
.
.
.
.
2
2
2
2
5
5
0
0
.
.
1
1
1
1
5
5
9
9
.
.
0
0
4
4
6
6
8
8
Energy (keV)
Energy (keV)
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
V
V
V
V
e
e
e
e
k
k
k
k
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
s
s
s
s
2
2
2
2
−
−
−
−
m
m
m
m
c
c
c
c
s
s
s
s
n
n
n
n
o
o
o
o
t
t
t
t
o
o
o
o
h
h
h
h
P
P
P
P
2
2
2
2
V
V
V
V
e
e
e
e
k
k
k
k
o
o
i
i
t
t
a
a
R
R
5
5
5
5
.
.
.
.
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
5
5
5
5
.
.
.
.
2
2
2
2
5
5
0
0
.
.
1
1
1
1
5
5
9
9
.
.
0
0
4
4
6
6
8
8
Energy (keV)
Energy (keV)
Figure 6: A simultaneous fit to the RXTE/Suzaku data in the 3.5 -- 9 keV range, consisting of an absorbed
disk plus powerlaw, a relativistically broadened and a narrow Fe Ka
line, and a 6.7 keV absorption line (left),
plus an additional smeared edge (right). (Each model component is shown individually.) Such complexity
is required for the Suzaku data, and is seen to give very good consistency with the RXTE data. Note that the
data here are unfolded without reference to any model and only rely on the detector responses.
paign, we first consider simple phenomenological fits consisting of an absorbed, exponentially cut-
off broken powerlaw. Instead of adding a single broad gaussian, we also include a narrow gaussian.
Additionally, we include a soft disk component. An example fit is shown in Fig 7.
Although this fit is relatively successful, several points are worth noting. For this, and all of
our fits, there are sharp, ≈ 5% residuals in the 0.7 -- 1.2 keV region, i.e., near absorption edge fea-
tures. We fit absorption with tbnew, a modification of the model of [21], which includes detailed
structure at these edges. Altering absorption abundances, however, did not remove these residuals.
We are unsure currently whether these residuals are instrumental (e.g., contaminant unmodeled in
the Suzaku spectral response) or physical features (e.g., unmodeled line absorption or emission).
The additional disk component is both of high temperature and low amplitude. Formally, low am-
plitude corresponds to a small inner disk radius4 Given the high fitted disk temperature, here the
disk amplitude implies an inner disk radius of only ≈ 0.1GM/c2. A different (more heavily piled
up, even with removal of data from the center of the image) Suzaku observation of Cyg X-1 re-
cently has been described with a more complex Comptonization model consisting of different low
and high energy Comptonized components ([10]). Perhaps the low normalization/high temperature
disk component is indicating the need for continuum models with such added complexity.
In Fig. 7 we also show the same spectra fit with the eqpair Comptonization model, allowing
for reflection, an unComptonized disk component tied to the temperature of the seed photons, and
a second disk component with temperature left free (here, ≈ 100 eV). Overall, this fit is somewhat
data are in good agreement with the 20 -- 70 keV RXTE-HEXTE data, and do not alter the fits. Consideration of the
HXD-GSO background is a complex issue, and we defer discussion of these data to a forthcoming work.
4Discussions of the inner disk radius not receding as a BHC enters the low/hard state often have shown ratio
residuals of the model -- excluding the disk component -- in order to illustrate their points. It is the relative weakness of
this ratio, however, that formally indicates a small inner disk radius, i.e., a non-recessed disk.
8
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
8
8
8
8
8
−
−
−
−
−
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
9
9
9
9
9
−
−
−
−
−
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
−
s
s
s
s
s
2
2
2
2
2
−
−
−
−
−
m
m
m
m
m
c
c
c
c
c
s
s
s
s
s
g
g
g
g
g
r
r
r
r
r
e
e
e
e
e
(
(
(
(
(
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
5
0
.
1
1
o
i
t
a
R
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
−
−
−
−
−
−
−
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
−
−
−
−
−
−
−
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
−
−
−
−
−
−
−
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
−
−
−
−
−
−
−
m
m
m
m
m
m
m
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
s
s
s
s
s
s
s
g
g
g
g
g
g
g
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
e
e
e
e
e
e
e
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
Fn
5
0
.
1
1
o
i
t
a
R
1
10
100
1
10
100
Energy (keV)
Energy (keV)
Figure 7: Broad-band Cyg X-1 spectra that have been unfolded solely using the detector response matrices
(i.e., without regard to the fit model). The Suzaku data from all available XIS have been summed and binned
to HWHM of the detector, and we show the simultaneous RXTE-PCA and RXTE-HEXTE data. (Model data
have been "unfolded" identically to the source data.) Left: absorbed, exponentially cutoff broken powerlaw,
plus additional disk, and broad and narrow line components. All (absorbed) model components are also
shown individually, and we also show the broken powerlaw with and without the hardening above 10 keV.
Right: The eqpair Comptonization model fits, including additional unComptonized disk components (one
tied to the seed photon temperature, and one free), broad and narrow lines, and reflection. We also show the
additional (absorbed) disk and line components individually, the (absorbed) seed photon spectrum (highest
amplitude thermal bump in the figure), and the Compton spectrum without reflection.
better than the broken powerlaw model. However, as for the broken powerlaw fit, any soft excess
(here dominated by the seed photons for Comptonization) is both of high temperature, and low
amplitude. (To date, for these historically hard "low state" observations, we have been unable to
find a satisfactory fit with low seed photon temperatures.) Note also that the fitted reflection fraction
is ≈ 0.3, i.e., counter to any expectations from a hardness-reflection fraction anti-correlation. We
have simultaneous Chandra-HETG and XMM-RGS data for one of our observations, thus, we are
exploring whether the inclusion of narrow absorption and emission components (e.g., from a highly
ionized wind) can fundamentally alter the broad-band properties suggested by the above models.
References
[1] M. Axelsson, L. Borgonovo, and S. Larsson, Evolution of the 0.01-25 Hz power spectral components
in Cygnus X-1, A&A 438, 999 -- 1012 (2005).
[2] M. Bałuci´nska-Church, M. J. Church, P. A. Charles, F. Nagase, J. LaSala, and R. Barnard, The
distribution of X-ray dips with orbital phase in Cygnus X-1, MNRAS 311, 861 -- 868 (2000).
[3] Paolo Coppi, PASP Conference Series, 161, 375, 1999.
[4] John E. Davis, Event pileup in charge coupled devices, ApJ 562, 575 -- 582 (2001).
[5] E. Gallo, R. P. Fender, and G. G. Pooley, A universal radio-X-ray correlation in low/hard state black
hole binaries, MNRAS 344, 60 -- 72 (2003).
9
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
Suzaku Observations of Cyg X-1
Michael Nowak
[6] T. Gleissner, J. Wilms, G. G. Pooley, M. A. Nowak, K. Pottschmidt, S. Markoff, S. Heinz,
M. Klein-Wolt, R. P. Fender, and R. Staubert, Long term variability of Cyg X-1. III. radio-X-ray
correlations, A&A 425, 1061 -- 1068 (2004).
[7] T. Gleissner, J. Wilms, K. Pottschmidt, P. Uttley, M. A. Nowak, and R. Staubert, Long term
variability of Cyg X-1. II. the rms-flux relation, A&A 414, 1091 -- 1104 (2004).
[8] M. Hanke, J. Wilms, M. A. Nowak, K. Pottschmidt, N. S. Schulz, and J. C. Lee, Chandra X-ray
spectroscopy of the focused wind in the Cygnus X-1 system I. the non-dip spectrum in the low/hard
state, ApJ (2008), in press.
[9] A. Ibragimov, J. Poutanen, M. Gilfanov, A. A. Zdziarski, and C. R. Shrader, Broad-band spectra of
Cygnus X-1 and correlations between spectral characteristics, MNRAS 362, 1435 -- 1450 (2005).
[10] K. Makishima, H. Takahashi, S. Yamada, C. Done, A. Kubota, T. Dotani, K. Ebisawa, T. Itoh,
S. Kitamoto, H. Negoro, Y. Ueda, and K. Yamaoka, Suzaku results on Cygnus X-1 in the low/hard
state, PASJ 60, 585 -- (2008).
[11] S. Markoff, M. Nowak, and J. Wilms, Going with the flow: Can the base of jets subsume the role of
compact accretion disk coronae?, ApJ 635, 1203 -- 1216 (2005).
[12] J. M. Miller, A. C. Fabian, R. Wijnands, R. A. Remillard, P. Wojdowski, N. S. Schulz, T. Di Matteo,
H. L. Marshall, C. R. Canizares, D. Pooley, and W. H. G. Lewin, Resolving the composite Fe Ka
Emission line in the galactic black hole Cygnus X-1 with Chandra, ApJ 578, 348 -- 356 (2002).
[13] Michael A. Nowak, Brian A. Vaughan, Jörn Wilms, James Dove, and Mitchell C. Begelman, RXTE
observations of Cygnus X -- 1: II. Timing analysis, ApJ 510, 874 -- 891 (1999).
[14] Michael A. Nowak, Jörn Wilms, Sebastian Heinz, Guy Pooley, Katja Pottschmidt, and Stephane
Corbel, Is the 'IR coincidence' just that?, ApJ 626, 1006 -- 1014 (2005).
[15] K. Pottschmidt, J. Wilms, M. A. Nowak, W. A. Heindl, D. M. Smith, and R. Staubert, Temporal
evolution of X-ray lags in Cygnus X-1, A&A 357, L17 -- L20 (2000).
[16] K. Pottschmidt, J. Wilms, M. A. Nowak, G. G. Pooley, T. Gleissner, W. A. Heindl, D. M. Smith,
R. Remillard, and R. Staubert, Long term variability of Cyg X-1 (1998 to 2001) I. systematic
spectral-temporal correlations in the hard state, A&A 407, 1039 -- 1058 (2003).
[17] P. Predehl and J. H. M. M. Schmitt, X-raying the interstellar medium: ROSAT observations of dust
scattering halos, A&A 293, 889 -- 905 (1995).
[18] R. A. Remillard and J. E. McClintock, X-ray properties of black-hole binaries, Annual Review of
Astronomy and Astrophysics 44, 49 -- 92 (2006).
[19] Y. Uchiyama, Y. Maeda, M. Ebara, R. Fujimoto, Y. Ishisaki, M. Ishida, R. Iizuka, M. Ushio, H. Inoue,
S. Okada, H. Mori, and M. Ozaki, Restoring the Suzaku source position accuracy and point-spread
function, PASJ 60, 35 -- 42 (2008).
[20] P. Uttley, I. M. McHardy, and S. Vaughan, Non-linear X-ray variability in X-ray binaries and active
galaxies, MNRAS 359, 345 -- 362 (2005).
[21] J. Wilms, A. Allen, and R. McCray, On the absorption of X-rays in the interstellar medium, ApJ 542,
914 -- 924 (2000).
[22] Jörn Wilms, Michael Nowak, Katja Pottschmidt, Guy G. Pooley, and Sonia Fritz, Long term
variability of Cygnus X-1. IV. Spectral evolution 1999-2004, A&A 447, 245 -- 261 (2006).
[23] Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Piotr Lubi´nski, and David A. Smith, Correlation between Compton reflection
and X-ray slope in Seyferts and X-ray binaries, MNRAS 303, L11 -- L15 (1999).
10
|
astro-ph/9810347 | 1 | 9810 | 1998-10-21T19:01:34 | The ROSAT Deep Survey IV. A distant lensing cluster of galaxies with a bright arc | [
"astro-ph"
] | An unusual double-lobed extended X-ray source (RX J105343+5735) is detected in the ROSAT ultra-deep HRI image of the Lockman Hole. The angular size of the source is 1.7 X 0.7 arcmin^2 and its X-ray flux is 2 X 10^-14 erg cm^-2 s^-1. R-band imaging from the Keck telescope revealed a marginal excess of galaxies brighter than R=24.5, but Keck LRIS spectroscopy of 24 objects around the X-ray centroid did not yield a significant number of concordant redshifts. The brightest galaxy close to the centre of the eastern emission peak appears to be a gravitationally lensed arc at z=2.570, suggesting that the X-ray object is associated with the lens, most likely a cluster of galaxies. Based on a comparison of lensing surface mass density, X-ray luminosity, morphology and galaxy magnitudes with clusters of known distance, we argue that RX J105343+5735 is a cluster at a redshift around 1. Future X-ray, ground-based optical/NIR and high resolution HST observations of the system will be able to clarify the nature of the object. | astro-ph | astro-ph | A&A manuscript no.
(will be inserted by hand later)
Your thesaurus codes are:
06 (11.09.3; 12.04.1; 12.07.1; 13.25.2)
ASTRONOMY
AND
ASTROPHYSICS
30.1.2018
8
9
9
1
t
c
O
1
2
1
v
7
4
3
0
1
8
9
/
h
p
-
o
r
t
s
a
:
v
i
X
r
a
The ROSAT Deep Survey
IV. A distant lensing cluster of galaxies with a bright arc
G. Hasinger1, R. Giacconi2, J.E. Gunn3, I. Lehmann1, M. Schmidt4, D.P. Schneider5, J. Trumper6, J.
Wambsganss1, D. Woods1, and G. Zamorani7
1 Astrophysikalisches Institut Potsdam, An der Sternwarte 16, D-14482 Potsdam
2 European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 2, 85740 Garching bei Munchen, Germany
3 Princeton University Observatory, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
4 California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
5 Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA
6 Max -- Planck -- Institut fur extraterrestrische Physik, Giessenbachstr. 1, 85740 Garching bei Munchen, Germany
7 Osservatorio Astronomico, via Zamboni 33, I-40126 Bologna, Italy
Received 15 September 1998; accepted 21 October 1998
Abstract. An unusual double-lobed extended X-ray
source (RX J105343+5735) is detected in the ROSAT
ultra-deep HRI image of the Lockman Hole. The angular
size of the source is 1.7 × 0.7 arcmin2 and its X-ray flux is
2 × 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1. R-band imaging from the Keck
telescope revealed a marginal excess of galaxies brighter
than R=24.5, but Keck LRIS spectroscopy of 24 objects
around the X-ray centroid did not yield a significant num-
ber of concordant redshifts. The brightest galaxy close to
the centre of the eastern emission peak appears to be a
gravitationally lensed arc at z=2.570, suggesting that the
X-ray object is associated with the lens, most likely a clus-
ter of galaxies. Based on a comparison of lensing surface
mass density, X-ray luminosity, morphology and galaxy
magnitudes with clusters of known distance, we argue that
RX J105343+5735 is a cluster at a redshift around 1. Fu-
ture X-ray, ground-based optical/NIR and high resolution
HST observations of the system will be able to clarify the
nature of the object.
Key words: Galaxies: intergalactic medium; Cosmology:
dark matter, gravitational lensing; X-rays: galaxies
1. Introduction
and the evolution of structures in the universe. Surveys at
the faintest X-ray fluxes (e.g. Hasinger et al. 1998, here-
after paper I) predominantly find active galactic nuclei
(Schmidt et al. 1998, hereafter paper II) often in conjunc-
tion with starburst regions, which might also be responsi-
ble for the absorption observed in the sources of the X-ray
background (Fabian et al. 1998).
Clusters of galaxies are the second most abundant class
of objects in deep X-ray surveys. They are the largest
bound structures in the universe, composed of dark matter
condensations, hot X-ray emitting gas and galaxies. X-ray
radiation is an efficient means to select clusters of galaxies,
because the X-ray flux is proportional to the square of
the electron density. The highest observed redshifts of X-
ray selected clusters to date are ∼0.8-0.9 (Henry et al.,
1997; Rosati et al., 1998) and extended X-ray emission
of clusters selected by other techniques has been reported
out to z=1.27 (Stanford et al., 1997; Hattori et al., 1997).
In this letter we report on the discovery of a faint
double-lobed X-ray source, RX J105343+5735, detected
in the ROSAT ultra-deep HRI image of the Lockman
Hole (paper I). In section 2 and 3 we present the X-ray
and optical observations, and in section 4 we discuss the
properties of the object in the context of what we know
about other galaxy clusters. We use a Hubble constant
H0 = 50 km s−1 Mpc−1 and a deceleration parameter
q0 = 0.5 throughout this paper.
X-ray surveys efficiently select cosmic X-ray sources at dis-
tances ranging from our immediate neighbourhood to the
edge of the observable universe. By studying their proper-
ties as a function of redshift we can probe the formation
Send offprint requests to: G. Hasinger
2. X-ray observations
The ROSAT Deep Survey (RDS) project is described in
paper I. The RDS consists of a series of deep pointings
of 207 ksec with the ROSAT PSPC and 1.31 Msec with
2
Bright arc cluster
Table 1. X-ray sources detected near RX J105343+5735
RA (2000)
Source
10h53m43.4s
A+B
10h53m46.6s
A
10h53m40.1s
B
10h53m29.5s
C
10h53m48.2s
D
a 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1
DEC (2000)
57d35m21s
57d35m17s
57d35m25s
57d35m38s
57d33m55s
Fluxa
2
Type
cluster
0.18
0.17
group
QSO
the ROSAT HRI in the direction of the "Lockman Hole",
a line of sight with exceptionally low HI column density.
A catalogue of 50 X-ray sources with fluxes brighter than
0.55 × 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1 has been published in paper
I; the spectroscopic optical identifications are presented
in paper II. The ultra-deep HRI pointing covers a solid
angle of 0.126 deg2 inside the RDS.
In the north-east quadrant of the HRI image (see paper
I) is RX J105343+5735, a clearly extended X-ray source
with a double-lobed structure. In Fig.1 we show X-ray
contours of this source and its surroundings, superposed
on an optical image. The extension of the source is about
1.7 and 0.6 arcmin in the E-W and N-S direction, respec-
tively. We denote the Eastern lobe (A) and the Western
lobe (B); both components are significantly extended. Two
more X-ray sources are detected at a significance of ∼ 4σ:
a possible group of galaxies at z=0.7 (C) and a QSO at
z=2.572 (D). Details for the detected X-ray sources are
given in Table 1. None of them appears in the previously
published source list, because either their off-axis angle is
too large (A, B) or their X-ray flux too low (C, D) for the
selection criteria applied in paper I.
The extended source is detected in the PSPC point-
ing at an off-axis angle of ∼ 19 arcmin and therefore is
not well resolved. With about 590 net photons detected
in the PSPC a coarse spectrum could be obtained. We
fixed the NH value to 1020 cm−2, consistent with the in-
dependent determination of NH from a fit to the summed
spectrum of all resolved sources in the Lockman Hole
(Hasinger et al. 1993). Using a Raymond-Smith model
with solar abundances (Z=1) we obtain acceptable fits
(see χ2 in Table 3) to the data assuming various redshifts
for the source. The results are not significantly different
for Z=0.3. The flux observed in the 0.5-2.0 keV band is
∼ 2 × 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1 for all these fits. The derived
temperatures range between 1.8 and 3.5 keV, the lumi-
nosities (0.5-2 keV) between 1043 and 2.4 × 1044 erg s−1
for redshifts between 0.3 and 1.2 (see Table 3).
3. Optical observations
An R-band image of the field of RX J105343+5735 was
obtained on 1996 April 13 with the Low Resolution
Imaging Spectrometer (LRIS; Oke et al. 1995) on the
Keck I telescope. The exposure time was 300s and the
seeing (FWHM) was 0.75". The image scale on the back-
9
4
.
3
1
0
1
-
.
6
1
1
8
7
5
-
Fig. 1. X-ray contours of a region about 3.6 × 3.6 arcmin2
in the ROSAT HRI ultra-deep pointing of the Lockman Hole,
superposed on a Keck R-band exposure. Numbers indicate the
objects for which we have obtained spectra. The insert in the
upper right is a 20 × 20 arcsec2 zoom of the image close to the
centre of lobe A. An arc-like feature (#2) is visible here.
Fig. 2. Keck LRIS spectrum of the arc (#2 in Fig.1). The
wavelengths of prominent UV metal absorption lines, red-
shifted to z=2.570 are indicated. "S" denotes the position of
a strong sky line. The spectrum is typical for a high redshift
starforming galaxy.
illuminated 2048 × 2048 Tektronix CCD is 0.215" pixel−1.
The CCD image was de-biased and flatfielded in the stan-
dard fashion using IRAF routines. A flatfield was gener-
ated by performing a median of 8 different R images, all of
which lacked bright stars and were taken over the course
of the night. We were able to flatten the resultant images
to better than ∼ 1%. Detection and photometric analysis
of the galaxies and stars present in the program field was
done using the SExtractor package (Bertin and Arnouts
1996). The faintest detections (3σ) have R ≈ 25.5.
Bright arc cluster
3
Fig. 1 shows a section of the LRIS image underlying
the HRI X-ray contours of the field. Close to the centroid
of lobe A is an arc-like feature (#2). It has a length of ∼ 7"
along the major axis and is not resolved along the minor
axis. The arc has an integrated magnitude of R=21.4, a
maximum surface brightness of µR = 22.9 mag arcsec−2
and some asymmetry along the major axis. There is diffuse
emission around it with a surface brightness of µR ≈ 25.5
mag arcsec−2 as well as some faint galaxies.
Spectra of 24 objects in this field were acquired with
a multislit mask using LRIS on Keck II on 1998 March
19. The conditions were photometric, the seeing was ∼ 1"
and the exposure time 3600s. The slits were all 1.4" wide
and some of them tilted to maximize the number of galax-
ies observed. The 300 line/mm grating produced spectra
in the range 3800 to 8200 A with a resolution of ∼ 15A.
Spectra were processed using standard MIDAS procedures
for bias subtraction, flat-field correction, optimal extrac-
tion and wavelength calibration. Relative flux correction
and atmospheric absorption correction was done using the
spectrophotometric standard BD +26 2606.
Table 2 gives details about the observed galaxies using
the numbering scheme given in Fig. 1 (#19-24 are outside
the area covered by Fig. 1): coordinates, R magnitudes,
redshifts and absolute R magnitudes calculated using K-
corrections for the LRIS R-filter computed assuming the
spectral energy distribution for a giant elliptical galaxy
for objects with z < 1 and an assumed K-correction of
0 for the two high-redshift objects (#1 and #2). Apart
from four concordant redshifts around 0.7 (#13,16,17,18),
three of which are coincident with a discrete X-ray source
(C in Fig. 1), possibly a group of galaxies, three galaxies
at z=0.308 (#7,11,19), scattered throughout the image,
and two galaxies at z=0.782 (#5,8), there is no obvious
clustering of redshifts in this sample.
The spectrum of the brightest object (#2) close to
the centroid of lobe A is displayed in Fig. 2. It shows
prominent absorption features of Lyα and low-ionization
metal lines typical of the rest-frame UV emission of star-
burst galaxies which are characteristic of a young stel-
lar population. The spectrum is very similar to those of
the UV-dropout galaxies detected by Steidel et al. (1996),
which gives us confidence in the redshift determination at
z = 2.570 ± 0.002. Its absolute magnitude (MR = −25.1)
indicates significant magnification and its spectrum, ap-
parent magnitude (R=21.4) and redshift (z=2.570) are
all very similar to the gravitationally lensed galaxy at
R=21.2, z=2.515 in the cluster A2218 (Ebbels et al, 1996),
supporting the gravitational arc interpretation. Interest-
ingly, the QSO (C) at z=2.572 ± 0.002 is at a projected
distance of only 0.6 Mpc from the arc galaxy.
4. Discussion
The morphology, observed flux and lensing action of RX
J105343+5735 strongly suggests that the X-ray source is
# ∆R.A. ∆Dec.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
32
31
31
29
12
9
1
-9
-15
-24
-28
-45
-59
-76
-91
-108
-115
-119
-128
-138
-165
-167
-173
-278
-91
-11
1
-11
-6
-4
10
20
21
30
30
43
52
35
7
13
14
17
109
126
136
92
19
44
R
22.6
21.4
22.1
22.9
22.9
23.1
19.1
22.2
22.7
22.4
22.6
21.5
22.6
21.5
22.3
22.1
21.2
22.3
20.1
22.0
20.1
20.8
21.6
19.3
z
2.567
2.570
0.736
0.782
0.543:
0.308
0.782
0.581
0.097
0.308
0.045
0.697
0.602:
0.521
0.695
0.700
0.695
0.308
0.383
0.039:
0.595
0.815:
0.352
MR
-23.9
-25.1
-23.4
-22.8
-20.8
-22.8
-23.5
-21.6
-16.6
-19.2
-15.7
-22.6
-22.9
-21.5
-23.1
-24.0
-22.9
-21.8
-20.6
-16.8
-23.6
-24.3
-23.0
Table 2. Parameters of galaxies with spectroscopy. #: number
of object as indicated in Fig. 1; ∆R.A., ∆Dec.: distance ["]
relative to the cluster centroid centroid at R.A. 10h53m43.4s,
Dec. 57d35m21s (Epoch 2000); R: approximate R magnitude;
z: redshift; MR: absolute R magnitude.
Table 3. Cluster parameters for assumed redshifts
red
Redshift
kT
χ2
LX
ML
RcD
0.3
0.7
1.2
1.8 ± 0.5
2.6 ± 1.1
3.5 ± 1.1
keV
0.49
0.09
0.11
18.8
0.81
0.66
0.22
22.2
0.89
2.40
0.40
24.9
1044 erg/s
1014 M⊙
mag
associated with a moderately luminous, distant cluster of
galaxies. To quantify a possible excess of the projected
density of galaxies compared to the field objects, we use
the estimator discussed by Lidman and Peterson (1996,
eqn. 1) which gives a value for the cluster contrast, σcl.
Using the X-ray centroid as assumed cluster centre, we
find a slight excess (σcl > 2.0) of galaxies with R=23.5-
24.5 for a 2' diameter aperture. The group observed at
z=0.7 (galaxies #16, 17 and 18) shows a significant excess
(σcl ≈ 3) of brighter galaxies (R < 23.5). No obvious
enhancement of galaxies is observed near the QSO (#1).
Since the redshift of the lens is unknown, we have pro-
duced a series of simple models for various values of the
lens redshift (see Table 3). For all considered redshifts the
object fits onto the empirical luminosity-temperature re-
lation for clusters of galaxies (see e.g. Ebeling et al., 1996).
4
Bright arc cluster
We estimate that the lensed arc has a radius of curvature
ΘE ≈ 7.5 ± 2". We can estimate the lensing mass inside
this radius by assuming the arc radius corresponds to the
Einstein ring radius for a mass ML. Assuming different
redshifts we obtain the lensing masses in Table 3. Note
that this mass corresponds to the core mass of one lobe
only. In Table 3 we also give an estimate of the expected R
magnitude for the brightest cluster galaxy RcD, assuming
MR = −23 based on the compilation of Hoessel & Schnei-
der (1985). We now discuss what would be the properties
of the extended X-ray object for various assumed redshifts:
z ≈ 0.3: Three galaxies (#7,11,19) at this redshift are
found, including the 19th magnitude galaxy (#7) close
to the symmetry axis. If the X-rays originate at this red-
shift, the X-ray luminosity would correspond to a group
of galaxies. The observed double structure could be sim-
ilar to some nearby groups, which can have complicated
morphologies (Mulchaey et al. 1996). In this case, object
#7 could be the brightest galaxy of the group, but no
other galaxy of similar magnitude is seen around it. The
detection of an arc is an argument against a group in-
terpretation. The lensing surface mass density would be
a factor of ∼ 10 higher than that typically estimated for
groups (Mulchaey et al., 1996).
z ≈ 0.7: Four galaxies (#13,16,17,18) are detected at
this redshift, but three of them are associated with source
C, a very faint discrete X-ray source, possibly a group
of galaxies (LX = 5 × 1042 erg/s). The X-ray luminos-
ity would be consistent with a moderately rich cluster
of galaxies. The elongated morphology is similar to other
high-redshift clusters (Henry et al., 1997) and there is an
interesting linear arrangement between A, B and C, which
could indicate that all three mass condensations are in the
same filamentary structure at z=0.7. But in this case A+B
would have a factor of 10 higher X-ray luminosity than C,
while C has clearly visible cluster galaxies in the right
absolute magnitude range which are not seen in A+B.
Therefore A+B would have to be a "dark" cluster with-
out bright galaxies (Tucker et al., 1995). While this is an
interesting possibility, we regard it as unlikely.
z > 0.7: In this case all the measured properties are
consistent with a normal, moderately rich cluster at very
high redshift. The object would be similar to the lensing
cluster 2016+112 at z=1 (Schneider et al. 1986; Hattori
et al. 1997). In this scenario the brightest cluster galax-
ies might just be visible in our R-band exposure (see Ta-
ble 3) and we would not have a chance of detecting any
cluster member within our spectroscopic limit of R ≈ 23.
The lensing surface mass density falls among those for
other clusters of galaxies. In this case the object would be
one of the highest redshift clusters with X-ray emission.
Assuming no evolution for the Rosati et al. (1998) clus-
ter luminosity function, we would expect 0.15 clusters in
the redshift range z=1-1.5 in our survey volume. We re-
gard this as the most likely possibility which can be easily
tested with future observations. Upcoming deep surveys
with AXAF and XMM should have no problem detecting
and studying a number of similar objects at high redshift.
In conclusion, RX J105343+5735 is an intriguing ob-
ject at any of the redshifts we can plausibly assign to the
lens and well worth follow-up studies (e.g. NIR imaging,
high-resolution imaging with HST, X-ray spectroscopy).
In particular, it is the first detection of a gravitational arc
which is optically brighter than any of the components of
the lens. The detection of a QSO at the same redshift as
the arc indicates that an enhanced density of background
galaxies in this direction might have increased the likeli-
hood to observe a lensed object.
Acknowledgements. We thank an anonymous referee for help-
ful comments. The ROSAT project is supported by the
Bundesministerium fur Bildung, Forschung und Wissenschaft
(BMBF), by the National Aeronautics and Space Administra-
tion (NASA), and the Science and Engineering Research Coun-
cil (SERC). The W. M. Keck Observatory is operated as a sci-
entific partnership between the California Institute of Technol-
ogy, the University of California, and the National Aeronautics
and Space Administration. It was made possible by the gen-
erous financial support of the W. M. Keck Foundation. This
work was supported by DLR grant 50 OR 9403 5 (G.H., I.L.),
National Science Foundation grant AST-95-09919 (D.P.S.) and
ASI grant ARS-96-70 (G.Z.).
References
Bertin E. & Arnouts S. 1996, A&AS 117, 393
Ebbels T.M.D., Le Bourgne J.-F., Pello R., et al. 1996, MNRAS
281, L75
Ebeling H., Voges W., Bohringer H., et al. 1996, MNRAS 281,
799
Fabian A.C., Barcons X., Almaini O. & Iwasawa K. 1998, MN-
RAS 297, L11
Hattori M., Ikebe Y., Asaoka I., et al. 1997, Nat 388, 146
Hasinger G., Burg R., Giacconi R., et al. 1993, A&A 275, 1
Hasinger G., Burg R., Giacconi R., et al. 1998, A&A 329, 482
(paper I)
Henry J.P., Gioia I.M., Mullios C.R., et al. 1997, AJ 114, 1293
Hoessel J.G. & Schneider D.P. 1985, AJ 90, 1648
Lidman C.E. & Peterson B.A. 1996, AJ 112, 2454
Mulchaey J.S., Davis D.S., Mushotzky R.F., Burstein D. 1996,
ApJ 456, 80
Oke J.B., Cohen J.G., Carr M., et al. 1995, PASP 107, 375
Rosati P., Della Ceca R., Norman C. & Giacconi R. 1998, ApJ
492, L21
Schneider D.P., Gunn J.E., Turner E.L., et al. 1986, AJ 91,
991
Schmidt M., Hasinger G., Gunn, J., et al. 1998, A&A, 329, 495
(paper II)
Stanford S.A., Elston R., Eisenhardt P.R. et al. 1997, AJ 114,
2232
Steidel C.C., Giavalisco M., Pettini M., Dickinson M. & Adel-
berger K. 1996, ApJ 462, L17
Tucker W.H., Tananbaum H. & Remillard R.A. 1995, ApJ 444,
532
This article was processed by the author using Springer-Verlag
LaTEX A&A style file L-AA version 3.
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.