Datasets:

kilian-group
/

arxiv-classifier

Dataset card Data Studio Files Files and versions Community

Subset (4)

default · ~99.6k rows (showing the first 120k)

Split (2)

train · ~72.4k rows (showing the first 93.1k)

paper_id stringlengths 9 16	version stringclasses 26 values	yymm stringclasses 311 values	created timestamp[s]	title stringlengths 6 335	secondary_subfield sequencelengths 1 8	abstract stringlengths 25 3.93k	primary_subfield stringclasses 124 values	field stringclasses 20 values	fulltext stringlengths 0 2.84M
astro-ph/9804325	1	9804	1998-04-29T17:45:31	Gravitational Radiation and Rotation of Accreting Neutron Stars	[ "astro-ph", "gr-qc" ]	Recent discoveries by the Rossi X-Ray Timing Explorer indicate that most of the rapidly accreting and weakly magnetic neutron stars in the Galaxy are rotating at spin frequencies greater than 250 Hz. Remarkably, they all rotate in a narrow range of frequencies. I suggest that these stars rotate fast enough so that, on average, the angular momentum added by accretion is lost to gravitational radiation. The strong spin frequency dependence of the angular momentum loss rate from gravitational radiation then provides a natural reason for similar spin frequencies. Provided that the interior temperature has a large scale asymmetry misaligned from the spin axis, then the temperature sensitive electron captures in the deep crust can provide the quadrupole needed to reach this limiting situation at 300 Hz. This quadrupole is only present during accretion and makes it difficult to form radio pulsars spinning more rapidly than 600-800 Hz via rapid accretion. The gravity wave strength is <10^{-26} from most neutron stars and >2 X 10^{-26} for Sco X-1. Prior knowledge of the position, spin frequency and orbital periods will allow for deep searches for these periodic signals with gravitational wave interferometers (LIGO, VIRGO and the dual-recycled GEO 600 detector) and experimenters need to take such sources into account. Sco X-1 will most likely be detected first.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Gravitational Radiation and Rotation of Accreting Neutron Stars Lars Bildsten Department of Physics and Department of Astronomy 366 LeConte Hall, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720 email: [email protected] ABSTRACT Recent discoveries by the Rossi X-Ray Timing Explorer indicate that most of the rapidly accreting ( M ∼> 10−11M⊙ yr−1 ) weakly magnetic (B ≪ 1011 G) neutron stars in the Galaxy are rotating at spin frequencies νs ∼> 250 Hz. Remarkably, they all rotate in a narrow range of frequencies (no more than a factor of two, with many within 20% of 300 Hz). I suggest that these stars rotate fast enough so that, on average, the angular momentum added by accretion is lost to gravitational radiation. The strong νs dependence of the angular momentum loss rate from gravitational radiation then provides a natural reason for similar spin frequencies. Provided that the interior temperature has a large scale asymmetry misaligned from the spin axis, then the temperature sensitive electron captures in the deep crust can provide the quadrupole needed (∼ 10−7M R2 ) to reach this limiting situation at νs ≈ 300 Hz. This quadrupole is only present during accretion and makes it difficult to form radio pulsars with νs > (600 − 800) Hz by accreting M ∼> 10−10M⊙ yr−1 . The gravity wave strength is hc ∼ (0.5 − 1) × 10−26 from many of these at neutron stars and > 2 × 10−26 for Sco X-1. Prior knowledge of the position, spin frequency and orbital periods will allow for deep searches for these periodic signals with gravitational wave interferometers (LIGO, VIRGO and the “dual-recycled” GEO 600 detector) and experimenters need to take such sources into account. Sco X-1 will most likely be detected first. Subject headings: accretion – dense matter – radiation mechanisms: gravitational – stars: neutron – stars: rotation – X-rays: bursts To Appear in The Astrophysical Journal Letters 8 9 9 1 r p A 9 2 1 v 5 2 3 4 0 8 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1. Introduction The launch of the Rossi X-Ray Timing Explorer (RXTE) has allowed for the discovery of fast quasi- periodic variability from many rapidly accreting ( M ∼> 10−11M⊙ yr−1 ) neutron stars. These observations strongly suggest that these neutron stars (NSs) are rapidly rotating, as predicted by those scenarios con- necting the millisecond radio pulsars to this accreting population (see Bhattacharya 1995 for an overview). Strohmayer et al. (1996) were the first to detect nearly coherent νB = 363 Hz oscillations during type I X-ray bursts from the low accretion rate ( M < 10−9M⊙ yr−1 ) NS 4U 1728-34. Pulsations were detected in six of the eight bursts analyzed at that time. In addition, two high frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) were seen in the persistent emission. These changed with accretion rate, but maintained a fixed difference frequency of νd ≈ 363 Hz, identical to the period seen during the bursts. The detection of two drifting QPO’s (in the persistent emission) separated by a fixed frequency identical to that seen in the bursts naturally leads – 2 – to beat frequency models (Strohmayer et al. 1996; Miller, Lamb, & Psaltis 1998). The difference frequency is presumed to be the NS spin frequency, νs , whereas the upper frequency has different origins in different models (see van der Klis 1998 for a summary). In addition, the temporal behavior of the periodic oscillations both during the rise of the bursts (Strohmayer, Zhang, & Swank 1997b) and in the cooling tails (Strohmayer et al. 1997a) are most easily explained in terms of rotation. There are six NSs with measured periodicities during Type I X-ray bursts (see Table 1). Both the difference frequencies (νd ) and the burst frequencies (νB ) are in a narrow range, from 260 to 589 Hz. For two ob jects (KS 1731-260 and 4U 1636-53) the difference frequencies are one-half the burst values. Which value is νs is not resolved. There are also many NSs that accrete at higher rates and are not regular Type I X-ray bursters. Many of these ob jects, notably the “Z” sources, also show drifting QPO’s at fixed separation, again with a similarly narrow frequency range (roughly 250-350 Hz). Beat-Frequency like models are also applied to these observations so as to infer νs . The applicability of such a model is less clear when the difference frequency is not constant (Sco X-1, van der Klis et al. 1997; 4U 1608-52, Mendez et al. 1998). If accreting matter always arrives with the specific angular momentum of a particle orbiting at the NS radius (R = 10R6km), then it only takes ∼ 107 yrs of accretion at M ≈ 10−9M⊙ yr−1 for a M = 1.4M1.4M⊙ NS to reach νs = 50 Hz from an initially low frequency. It is thus remarkable that these NSs are all rotating at nearly the same rate. White and Zhang (1997) argued that this similarity arises because these NSs are magnetic and have reached an equilibrium where the magnetospheric radius equals the co-rotation radius. This requires an intrinsic relation between their magnetic dipoles, µb , and M so that they all reach the same rotational equilibrium (most likely µb ∝ M 1/2 ) and a way of hiding the persistent pulse typically seen from a magnetic accretor. My alternative explanation for these spin similarities is that gravitational wave (GW) emission has started to play an important dnrole. If the NS has a misaligned quadrupole moment, Q, then the strong spin frequency dependence of GW emission defines a critical frequency beyond which accretion can no longer spin-up the star. Such a NS will radiate energy via GW’s at the rate E = 32GQ2ω 6/5c5 , where ω = 2πνs , and lose angular momentum at the rate Ngw = E /ω . Balancing this spin-down torque with the characteristic spin-up torque from time-averaged accretion, Na ≈ M (GM R)1/2 , gives the Q needed so as to make the critical frequency 300 Hz, 10−9 M⊙ yr−1 !1/2 Q ≈ 4.5 × 1037 g cm2 νs (cid:19)5/2 M (cid:18) 300 Hz or < 10−7 of the NS moment of inertia, I ≈ 1045 g cm2 . The similarities in νs may then arise because of the weak dependencies of the critical frequency on Q and M . (1) , What is the source of the misaligned quadrupole? Wagoner (1984) argued that accreting NSs would get hung-up at spin frequencies where the Chandrasekhar-Friedman-Schutz (CFS) instability sets in. However, Lindblom (1995) and Lindblom & Mendell (1995) have shown that the star needs to be very near the breakup frequency (νs ∼> kHz) for such an instability to occur, even for the core temperatures Tc = (1 − 3) × 108 K of rapidly accreting NSs (Ayasli & Joss 1978; Brown & Bildsten 1998). The spin frequencies for these NSs are too slow for such an instability. I present in §2 a new source for lateral density variations in an accreting NS; electron captures (hereafter EC) in the crust. The constant compression of the crust forces nuclei to undergo EC when the electron Fermi energy, EF , is high enough to make a transition. However, the crust is hot enough in a rapidly accreting NSs to make the EC rates temperature sensitive. Hotter regions then capture at lower pressures, so that – 3 – the density jump associated with the EC is at a higher altitude in the hotter parts of the crust. Moderate lateral temperature variations then lead to density variations large enough to generate the required Q. This outcome is independent of the particular source of the temperature variations. One possible cause for a T asymmetry relative to the spin axis is a weak magnetic field. I conclude in §3 by finding the GW signal strength and estimating detection. 2. Electron Captures in the Neutron Star Crust These NSs accrete hydrogen and helium rich material from their companions, and within days of reaching the surface, this matter is burned to heavy elements. The composition of these ashes is still uncertain, but most certainly consists of heavy nuclei, potentially beyond the iron group (Schatz et al. 1997). This material replaces the primordial NS crust and becomes neutron rich by successive EC. Later on, neutron emissions and pycnonuclear reactions occur (Bisnovatyi-Kogan & Chechetkin 1979; Sato 1979; Haensel & Zdunik 1990 (hereafter HZ)). For the M ’s and residual hydrogen abundance (Taam, Woosley, & Lamb 1996) appropriate for these NSs, the temperature of the accumulating matter and deep crust is T8 = T /108 K ≈ (2 − 6) (Brown & Bildsten 1998). I confine my discussion in this Letter to the outer crust (before neutron drip at ρ ≈ (4 − 6) × 1011 g cm−3 , HZ), which is held up by degenerate and relativistic electrons. They exert a pressure p = 1.42 × 1030 erg cm−3 (EF /30MeV)4 from which the mass of the shell above a particular depth is Mcr (EF ) = 4πR2p/g , where g = GM /R2 , or . (2) Mcr (EF ) ≈ 5 × 10−5M⊙ 30 MeV (cid:19)4 R4 M1.4 (cid:18) EF 6 The crust is compressed on a timescale tcomp ≡ p/ mg , where m is the local accretion rate, so that EF rises with time, eventually leading to nuclear EC. Many (Sato 1979; HZ) presumed that the captures were instantaneous once EF > Ed , where Ed is the mass difference between the (A,Z) nucleus and (A,Z-1) nucleus. In reality, the transitions will not occur until the EC lifetime is comparable to tcomp (Blaes et al. 1990). For M ∼ 10−16M⊙ y−1 , Blaes et al. (1990) showed that most captures occur in a thin zone low accretion rates where EF > Ed only slightly. The situation is different for the high M ’s of the bright X-ray sources, as the high crustal temperature leads to most EC occurring out on the thermal tail at a physical location where EF < Ed . I consider a region of the crust consisting of a single nucleus of charge Z e and mass Amp . For many nuclei, the capture to the ground state of the (A,Z-1) nucleus is highly forbidden and proceeds more slowly than tcomp . The element is still abundant when EF reaches a value where a more favorable transition to an excited state of the (A,Z-1) nucleus can occur.1 For this reason, I estimate the EC rates by using f t values in the range of allowed reactions, f t = 104 − 106 s. Since these stars are hot enough for the sub-threshold EC to dominate, the transition occurs when EF,depl = Ed − βkB T , where β ≈ (8 − 12) depends logarithmically on m, T and f t (Bildsten & Cumming 1998). A hotter region undergoes the transition at a higher altitude 1 Since the mass difference of the (A,Z-1) and (A,Z-2) nuclei is smaller than the mass difference of the (A,Z) and (A,Z-1) nuclei, the sequence always consists of two successive captures (HZ). This also blocks the inverse reactions. The larger phase space for the second reaction (as well as the larger number of available excited states with favorable spin-parity) means that the (A,Z-1) nucleus captures electrons more rapidly than the (A,Z) nucleus. Since the first capture is the rate-limiting step, I do not track the intermediate (A,Z-1) nucleus. – 4 – (call sc the distance down to the transition from where EF = 1 MeV, i.e. s increases into the star) compared M = 2 × 10−9 M⊙ y−1 . to a colder region. Figure 1 displays the EC transition layer for a NS accreting at As an example I chose the nucleus 56Ca, which captures at Ed ≈ 23 MeV, where ρ ≈ 2.5 × 1011 g cm−3 . This is the fourth EC transition that HZ found when starting with 56Fe. Since this is a generic process, I show cases for f t = 104 s (dotted) and f t = 106 s (solid) for (from left to right in the upper and lower panels) T8 = 6, 4 and 2. The density jump associated with the ECs is evident and, if discontinuous, would be ∆ρ/ρ = 2/(Z − 2) = 0.11. Fig. 1.— The density, pressure and nuclear abundance in the 56Ca electron capture layer for a R = 10 km, M = 2 × 10−9M⊙ y−1 . These are plotted as a function of increasing depth M = 1.4M⊙ NS accreting at into the star, deeper regions are to the right. For a fixed value of f t, the hotter crusts deplete sooner. The curves are, from left to right, for T8 = 6, 4 and 2. If a transverse temperature gradient is present in the crust, then these ECs generate density asymmetries on the star and a quadrupole with mass ∆M ≈ 4πR2∆ρ∆sc . The mass inferred from the f t = 104 s case for a temperature contrast ∆T8 = 2 (where the difference in physical depth of the EC is ∆sc ≈ 500 cm) is ∆M ≈ 10−7M⊙ , just what is needed for GW’s to be important. More generally, the mass involved is ∆M = Mcr (∆ρ/ρ)(4∆EF,depl /EF ), or since ∆EF,depl ≈ 10kB∆T , 30 MeV (cid:19)3 R4 M1.4 (cid:18) EF 6 for a single EC layer. Since there are a few more electron capture layers underneath this one, there is adequate mass to generate the required Q when ∆T8 ≈ 1. The repercussions of the deeper reactions is still unknown. ∆M ≈ 5.5 × 10−8M⊙∆T8 , (3) The EC’s deposit heat directly into the crust, generating a flux Fdeep = Edeep m, where Edeep ≈ 1017 erg g−1 (HZ). Temporal variations in m lead to local heating at these depths, which takes a few years to equilibrate in the radial direction. The heat transfer is fixed by electron conduction at these depths, – 5 – so that the conductivity is K = π2k2 B T nec2/3EF νe−ph , where νe−ph ≈ 13αkB T /¯h is the electron-phonon scattering frequency (Yakovlev & Urpin 1980). The time it takes heat to cross a scale height, H = p/ρg , is then tth ≈ ρCpH 2/K ∼ yr where Cp ≈ 3kB /Amp is the specific heat at constant pressure. However, lateral thermal asymmetries will persist as long as the heating time, tH ≈ CpT y/Edeep m ∼ 4 × 10−3T8 tcomp , is shorter than the time to transport heat around the star at the same depth. That time M ∼> 3 × 10−11M⊙y−1 (EF /30 MeV)3 (R/10 km)2 , the is tth,R ≈ ρCpR2/K ≈ 6400 y(EF /30 MeV), so for time to transport heat around the crust is longer than the time to locally heat it. All of the ob jects I am discussing are in this regime and so large-scale temperature asymmetries can persist as long as the system is being perturbed in some way. Though the origin of lateral T gradients is still unknown, it is difficult for conduction to wash them out. For example, large-scale m or compositional variations (due to, say, magnetically channeled flow or a “buried field”) will imprint large scale T asymmetries. The pressure as a function of depth in the EC region is shown in the middle panel of Figure 1. Even though the density contrasts are large, the pressure contrasts are not. If one part of the star has a slightly deeper capture zone, at sc,2 = sc,1 + ∆sc , then the pressures at a fixed depth s > sc,1 relate via P1 ≈ P2 (1 + 8∆sc /Z s). The pressure is higher underneath the layer that captured sooner due to the “extra weight” of the dense layer. Since s ∝ EF , the lateral pressure contrast at a fixed depth, ∆P = (P1 − P2 ), is ∆P /P ≈ 80kB∆T /Z EF . These transverse pressure gradients would lead to flow and a cancellation of the quadrupole if the matter was in a liquid state. However, as long as T8 < 10, the matter is solid at these depths and has a finite shear modulus, µ ≈ 10−2p (Strohmayer et al. 1991). The transverse pressure gradients are then balanced by a slight amount of shear stress as the matter underneath the cooler regions laterally shifts a distance ξ . Roughly, ξ is found from the transverse momentum equation ∆P /R ≈ µξ/s2 , or ξ/s ≈ (100s/R)(8∆sc/Z s). This gives ξ/s ≈ 6 × 10−3∆T8 , or a few meters of transverse displacement over the whole surface. For now, I will presume that this configuration will not crack. Relative vertical motion has yet to be investigated and could reduce the estimated Q. 3. Detectability of the Gravitational Waves Most accreting, weakly magnetic neutron stars are spinning at νs ≈ (250 − 500) Hz. I conjecture that this similarity is the result of an equilibrium where the angular momentum accreted is radiated away in gravitational waves. I showed that pre-threshold electron captures will turn any lateral temperature gradients into lateral density gradients. In this case, a small spin-misaligned temperature gradient gives rise to a quadrupole, Q ∼ 10−7M R2 , adequate to explain the similarities at ≈ 300 Hz. These accretion-induced Q’s clearly make it difficult to spin up a neutron star to 1000 Hz by accreting at M ∼> 10−10M⊙ yr−1 . Indeed, M ∼ 10−8M⊙ yr−1 . a NS spinning at 1000 Hz with Q ≈ 10−8M R2 would be difficult to spin-up even at M ’s, reducing Q (see the dependence in equation [3]) The lateral T asymmetries should subside at lower and potentially making it easier to reach higher νs by accreting slowly for a long period of time. There is M sources seem to be rotating the slowest. already some hint of this, as the highest Independent of the cause of the T asymmetry, if gravitational radiation is the explanation of the spin similarities, then the characteristic GW signal strength at Earth (suitably averaged over spin orientations, Brady et al. 1998) is hc = 2.9Gω 2Q/dc4 , where d is the distance to the ob ject (the prefactor is 4 when looking down the spin axis). Presuming the NS luminosity is L ≈ GM M /R then hc is written in terms of – 6 – the observable F = L/4πd2 (Wagoner 1984) 10−8 erg cm−2 s−1 (cid:19)1/2 (cid:18) 300 Hz νs (cid:19)1/2 hc ≈ 4 × 10−27 R3/4 1.4 (cid:18) F 6 M 1/4 which represents a lower limit for hc due to the L to M conversion I chose and since F is never fully measured. The minimum hc ’s for those NSs which have νs inferred from Type I bursts are shown in Table 1. There are many NSs for which only νd has been measured (see van der Klis 1998 for a summary). The average 2-10 keV fluxes from van Paradijs (1995) imply the following GW amplitudes: GX 349+2 (νd = 266 ± 13, hc ≈ 5.4 × 10−27 , Zhang et al. 1998b), 4U 1820-30 (νd = 275 ± 8, hc ≈ 3.7 × 10−27), GX 17+2 (νd = 294 ± 8, hc ≈ 4.7 × 10−27 ), 4U 0614+09 (νd = 327 ± 4, hc ≈ 1.3 × 10−27), GX 5-1 (νd = 327 ± 11, hc ≈ 6.0 × 10−27 ) Cyg X-2 (νd = 343 ± 21, hc ≈ 3.7 × 10−27), and GX 340+0 (νd = 325 ± 10, hc ≈ 3.7 × 10−27 , Jonker et al. 1998). (4) , The highest flux ob ject that shows kHz QPO’s is Sco X-1 with an orbital period of 18.9 hours. It’s difference frequency is not constant however (van der Klis et al. 1997) and so we are still uncertain about the exact spin frequency. If it is rotating at ≈ 250 Hz, then hc ≈ 2.2 × 10−26 at 2νs = 500 Hz. Detection of a weak periodic gravitational wave signal depends on the ability to coherently fold large data sets for a long time, τ , in order to obtain the ∼ (2νs τ )1/2 signal enhancement. The initial LIGO interferometer will have hrms = 10−21 at ν ≈ 500 Hz (Abramovici et al. 1992), requiring integration times ∼ yr. If the orbital parameters, spin frequency and phase were known for Sco X-1, then Brady et al.’s (1998) work implies it would be detected at 99% confidence with the initial LIGO in about one year. However, our lack of detailed prior information on these parameters demands a larger parameter space search. The consequent reduction in the S/N (maybe a factor of ∼ 5) make it more likely that detection will have to wait for the enhanced LIGO (see Thorne 1998 for the sensitivities). The similar spin frequencies of so many ob jects give an advantage to dual-recycling interferometers (such as GEO 600 and TAMA 300). Indeed, the GEO 600 noise strength (from Strain et al. 1998) when tuned to Sco X-1 is competitive with the initial LIGO and VIRGO. Detection of the larger number of NSs2 with h = (0.5 − 1) × 10−26 will have to wait for advanced broad-band interferometers (such as advanced LIGO), further developments in the dual-recycled interferometers, or larger cryogenic detectors. The stability of the GW signal depends on the origin of the mass quadrupole. For the EC origin, I would not expect ma jor differences in Q on timescales shorter than the thermal time (years). Another relevant time is that to replenish the thickness of the EC layer, which is ∼ 100 years at M ∼ 10−9M⊙ yr−1 . However, since M varies, we cannot expect the torques to always be in balance. For example, if M were to drop suddenly, the instantaneous spin-down of the NS due to the equilibrium Q would be ν ≈ 10−13 s−2 (h M i/10−9M⊙ yr−1 ). This would lead to one pulse cycle of drift in a time ≈ (2/ ν )1/2 ≈ 50 days. How does this work affect the accretion spin-up scenario for making millisecond pulsars? The EC Q will decrease once accretion has halted and the temperature equilibrates. In addition, when the crust is cold, it only takes 10−7M⊙ of accretion to wash out the compositional gradients generated during accretion at high rates. There is an important comparison to make in this regard. Namely, as long as Q decays on a timescale, 2The recent RXTE discovery of a persistent 401 Hz accreting pulsar (Wijnands & van der Klis 1998) in the transient binary SAX J1808.4-3658 (in’t Zand et al. 1998) provides hope for GW studies. It was observed in outburst by RXTE (Marshall 1998) and it’s orbit measured by Chakrabarty & Morgan (1998). Enough is known about this weakly magnetic (B < 109 G) accreting pulsar that a coherent data fold can be undertaken. Unfortunately, the time averaged flux (I estimate 2 × 10−10 ergs cm−2 s−1 at most) is low and even if looking right down the spin-axis, h < 7 × 10−28 . It might be that spin-down in quiescence is the best indicator of GW emission from this NS. – 7 – td , much shorter than tspin−up ≡ I ωi/ M (GM R)1/2 ≈ 5 × 107yr then the millisecond pulsar is “born” at roughly the same spin period since νf = νi (1 + 4td /tspin−up)−1/4 . If Q persists at some low level long after accretion has ended, it could still play an important role. Indeed, as many have shown (Thorne 1987, New et al. 1995, Brady et al. 1998) a small Q can go a long way towards explaining the observed spin-down of millisecond pulsars and making them detectable as GW sources. Transverse T gradients may be more prevalent on the B ∼> 1011 G accreting pulsars. However, most of them have νs ≪ Hz so that the Q needed for GW equilibrium is implausibly large, making it unlikely that GW’s play an important role in their spin evolution. However, there is a lack of accreting pulsars with νs > Hz that is usually explained by stating that all pulsars have reached their magnetic equilibrium and that few have B ≪ 1011 G. If we presume a maximum allowed quadrupole Qmax = 10−5M R2 (Thorne 1987), then GW emission could play an important role when νs > 35 Hz( M /10−9 M⊙ yr−1)1/5 , only somewhat alleviating this issue. I thank E. Brown, A. Cumming, E. Flanagan, T. Prince, H. Schatz, G. Ushomirsky and I. Wasserman for helpful discussions and J. Arons, R. Rutledge, and M. van der Klis for comments on the manuscript. P. Brady and K. Thorne clarified issues of GW detection. This research was supported by NASA via grants NAG 5-2819 and NAGW-4517, a Hellman Family Faculty Fund Award (UCB) and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. Abramovici, A. et al. 1992, Science, 256, 325 Ayasli, S., & Joss, P. C. 1982, ApJ, 256, 637 REFERENCES Bhattacharya, D. 1995, in “X-Ray Binaries”, ed. W. H. G. Lewin, J. van Paradijs & E. P. J. van den Heuvel (London: Cambridge), p. 233 Bildsten, L. & Cumming, A. 1998, ApJ, submitted Bisnovatyi-Kogan, G. S. & Chechetkin, V. M. 1979, Sov. Phys. Usp, 22, 89 Blaes, O. et al., 1990, ApJ, 363, 612 Brady, P. R., Creighton, T., Cutler, C., & Schutz, B. F. 1998, Phys. Rev., D57, 1 Brown, E. F. & Bildsten, L. 1998, ApJ, 496, 915 Chakrabarty, D. & Morgan, E. H. 1998, IAU Circ. 6877 Haensel, P. & Zdunik, J. L. 1990, A & A, 227, 431 (HZ) in’t Zand, J. J. M., et al. 1998, A & A, 331, L25 Jonker, P. G. et al., 1998, ApJ, to appear Marshall, F. E. 1998, IAU Circ. 6876 Mendez, M., et al. 1998, ApJ, 494, L65 Miller, M. C., Lamb, F. K. & Psaltis, D. 1998, ApJ, to appear Lindblom, L. 1995, ApJ, 438, 265 Lindblom, L., & Mendell, G. 1995, ApJ, 444, 804 New, K. C. B., Chanmugan, G., Johnson, W. W., & Tohline, J. E. 1995, ApJ, 450, 757 – 8 – Sato, K. 1979, Prog. of Theor. Physics, 62, 957 Schatz, H. et al. 1997, Physics Reports, 294, 167 Smith, D. A., Morgan, E. H. & Bradt, H. 1997, ApJ, 479, L137 Strain, K. A., Campbell, A., Logan, J. E., Robertson N. A. and Rowan, S. 1998 (private communication on GEO 600) Strohmayer, T., Ogata, S., Iyetomi, H., Ichimaru, S., & Van Horn, H. M., 1991, ApJ, 375, 679 Strohmayer, T. E., Zhang, W., Swank, J. H., Smale, A., Titarchuk, L., Day, C. & Lee, U., 1996, ApJ, 469, L9 Strohmayer, T. E., Jahoda, K., Giles, A. B., & Lee, U. 1997a, ApJ, 486, 355 Strohmayer, T. E., Zhang, W. & Swank, J. H. 1997b, ApJ, 487, L77 Strohmayer, T. E., Zhang, W., Swank, J. H., White, N. E. & Lapidus, I. 1998, ApJ, 498, L??? Swank, J. et al. 1997, private communication Taam, R. E., Woosley, S. E., & Lamb, D. Q. 1996, ApJ, 459, 271 Thorne, K. S. 1987, in “Three Hundred Years of Gravitation”, ed. S. W. Hawking & W. Israel (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press), p. 330 Thorne, K. S. 1998, in “Black Holes and Relativistic Stars”, ed. R. M. Wald (Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press), p. 41 van der Klis, M. 1998, in “The Many Faces of Neutron Stars”, ed. A. Alpar, L. Buccheri, and J. van Paradijs (Dordrecht: Kluwer), in press van der Klis, M., Wijnands, R. A. D., Horne, K., Chen, W. 1997, ApJ, 481, L97 van Paradijs, J. 1995, in “X-Ray Binaries”, ed. W. H. G. Lewin, J. van Paradijs & E. P. J. van den Heuvel (London: Cambridge), p. 536 Wagoner, R. V. 1984, ApJ, 278, 345 White, N. & Zhang, W. 1997, ApJ, 490, L87 Wijnands, R. A. D., van der Klis, M., van Paradijs, J., Lewin, W. H. G., Lamb, F. K., Vaughan, B. & Kuulkers, E. 1997, ApJ, 479, L141 Wijnands, R. A. D. & van der Klis, M., 1997, ApJ, 482, L65 Wijnands, R. & van der Klis, M., 1998, IAU Circ. 6876 Yakovlev, D. G. & Urpin, V. A. 1980, Sov. Astron., 24, 303 Zhang, W., et al. 1998a, ApJ, 495, L9 Zhang, W., Strohmayer, T. E. & Swank, J. H. 1998b, ApJ, to appear This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0. – 9 – Table 1: Rapid Periodicities During Type I X-Ray Bursts νd νB Ob ject Name (Hz) (Hz) 330 – 363 363 260 ± 10 524 – 549 581 276 ± 10 – 589 4U 1702-429 4U 1728-34 KS 1731-260 Aql X-1 4U 1636-53 MXB 1743-29 Fluxa 1.0 2.8 0.2-2 hc (10−27 ) 1.2 2.0 2.0 4.4 2.8 Ref.b [1] [2] [3-4] [5] [6-7] [8] a Average 2-10 keV fluxes (in units 10−9 erg cm−2 s−1 ) are from van Paradijs (1995). b REFERENCES: [1] Swank et al. 1997, [2] Strohmayer et al. 1996, [3] Smith et al. 1997, [4] Wijnands & van der Klis 1997, [5] Zhang et al. 1998a, [6] Strohmayer et al. 1998, [7] Wijnands et al. 1997, [8] Strohmayer et al. 1997a
astro-ph/9610149	2	9610	1996-10-21T16:47:00	Is the Universe Homogeneous on Large Scales?	[ "astro-ph" ]	This contribution is the affirmative side of a debate held with Dr. L. Pietronero at Princeton in June, 1996. I present the observational evidence that the fractal behavior which characterizes the small scale galaxy distribution does not continue to arbitarily large scale, but has a well defined cutoff with an outer length scale of order 30h$^{-1}$ Mpc. For example, plots of the IRAS 1.2 Jy survey exhibit a very clear approach to homogeneity on large scale, in complete contradiction to the endless fractal model.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Is the Universe Homogeneous on Large Scales? Marc Davis Depts. of Astronomy and Physics University of California, Berkeley October 8, 2018 1 Two Competing Visions 1.1 Introduction This morning's debate is focused on the question of the large-scale homo- geneity of the Universe. I shall present the affirmative position, that there is overwhelming evidence for large scale homogeneity on scales in excess of approximately 50h−1 Mpc, with a fractal distribution of matter on smaller scales. My worthy opponent, Dr. Luciano Pietronero, will present the counter-argument, that the fractal distribution observed on smaller scales continues to the largest observed scales, and that there is no evidence for homogeneity on any scale. This is an important question, since the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker metric presumes large scale homogeneity and isotropy for the Universe. This is the simplest cosmological model, and it is a fair question to ask the degree to which it is supported by the observational evidence. We know that the galaxy distribution is far from homogeneous on small scales, and large-scale structure in the form of long filaments and chains extends to lengths in excess of 100h−1 Mpc [1]. Redshift surveys often show structures nearly as large as the entire survey size; how confident can we be that homogeneity is a valid concept for the large-scale universe? 1 1.2 The Mean Density of Galaxies The question of large scale homogeneity revolves around the issue of whether the mean density of the Universe, ¯n, is a well defined concept. In the standard cosmological model, ¯n is perfectly well defined, but in the fractal model of the Universe, ¯n has vanishing global value and has relevance only within a given survey volume. In the conventional picture of large scale structure, the rms value of the number density of galaxies as observed at radius r from the vantage point of any randomly chosen galaxy, n(r), is given from the usual definition of the two-point galaxy correlation, ξ(r), by n(r)rms = ¯n (1 + ξ(r)). The measured ξ(r) is well characterized by a power law, ξ(r) ≈ (r/r0)−γ, (r0 ≈ 5h−1 Mpc, γ = 1.8). Alternatively, this can be expressed in terms of the power spectrum of density fluctuations, P (k) ∝ k−1.2, (δM/M)rms ∝ (k3P (k))1/2 = 1 at some well defined scale. In the conventional picture, there exists a distinct transition between "small" and "large" amplitude scales, depending on whether ξ(r) < 1 or ξ(r) > 1. On large scales, where ξ(r) → 0, one has simply n(r) ≡ M(r)/V (r) → constant. On scales where the rms density behaves as a power law, the galaxy distribution has fractal properties, but on larger scales the galaxy distribution approaches uniformity. In contrast, within the fractal model advocated by Pietronero and col- leagues [2] [3] [4], there is no constant term in the rms density, the mass within a radius r scales as M(r) ∝ rD, D = 3 − γ ≈ 1.2 − 1.5, and n(r)rms = M(r)/V (r) ∝ rD−3 → 0 as r → ∞. In order to preserve the cosmological principle that we are not at the center of the Universe or at any point of special symmetry, such an rms density behavior is possible only if the galaxy distribution viewed from a typical observer is extremely anisotropic, with 100% density fluctuations at any distance r from a typical observer. Such a universe does not approach homogeneity on large scales, and large voids, a constant fraction of the survey radius, would be expected within any survey. Because one must always estimate the mean density from within the same volume used to estimate the correlation function, in the fractal picture one expects the correlation length to scale linearly as the survey size r, with r0 ≈ 0.4r. The average density has no meaning in this universe; on a global scale the Universe is empty and its average density approaches zero. There is no transition between linear and nonlinear fluctutions: (δM/M)rms ≈ 1 on all scales because of the trend of mean density with sample volume. Such a model is a radical departure from the standard model of a ho- mogeneous large-scale Universe. Does the observational data support such 2 a conjecture, or can it be decisively ruled out? I shall argue that we have an abundance of observational arguments in support of the standard picture which are incompatible with the fractal model extended to arbitarily large scale. (The theoretical underpinning of such a radical model is another mat- ter altogether.) The question of real interest is to determine the outer scale of the fractal scaling behavior, and I shall argue that there exist firm bounds on this scale. 2 Evidence for Homogeneity (2-d tests) The largest data sets available are two-dimensional in nature, and most of these have been well known for decades. The remarkable isotropy of the CMBR, X-ray counts, radio source counts, and the γ-ray bursts all argue that we are either at the center of the Universe or that on the largest scales the Universe is homogeneous. The arguments given by Weinberg [5] are still valid today. We know the CMBR comes to us from redshifts Z ≫ 1, while the discrete radio sources are distributed to Z > 1, with the X-ray background presumably arising from discrete sources at Z < 3. If the matter distribution is a pure fractal in space, how does it become so smooth in projection on the sky? The proponents of the fractal universe argue that projection of the 3-d fractals is complicated and that all structure can be lost. It is well known that the projection will dilute the information, but it seems evident that not all the information would be lost and that isotropy at the remarkable levels observed, e.g. 1% precision, is not possible unless the outer scale of the fractal structure is considerably smaller than the redshift limit of the databases. Peebles [6] shows that the large-scale isotropy of the X-ray background radiation constrains the fractal dimension D to be 3−D ≤ 0.001 on large scales, which would seem rather definitive. The proponents of the fractal universe have been challenged to produce an example of a fractal that projects to a uniform sky distribution, but to date they have failed to do so. Similarly, the observed counts of galaxies versus flux f , for intermediate magnitudes in the range 14 < m < 18, scales as N(> f ) ∝ f −3/2, just as expected in a homogeneous, Euclidean Universe. For fainter magnitudes, we observe N(> f ) ∝ f −1, which suggests a combination of evolutionary and expansion effects, while the isotropy of the faint number counts is inconsis- tent with fractal behavior. Peebles [6][7] presents considerable detail on the constraints these arguments set on the fractal dimension D. In the fractal 3 model, since M(r) ∝ r3−γ, we expect N(> f ) ∝ f (γ−3)/2 ∝ f −0.6, which is very far from the observations. To fit the faint counts, one must adjust γ, but this is inconsistent with the isotropy of the faint counts and with the fractal dimension found on smaller scales. The angular correlation function w(θ) of the large two-dimensional cat- alogs of galaxies such as the APM catalog [8] obeys the Limber scaling law to a remarkable degree [6]. Again this relationship is fully consistent with homogeneity on large scale. In a fractal universe, the angular correlation length of a galaxy catalog should be a constant, large fraction of the angular extent of the survey, and this scale should be independent of the flux. Again, this is exactly contrary to the observations. The proponents of the fractal model argue that the projection of the three dimensional structure to the observed w(θ) has erased all the information, but years of experience with deconvolution demonstrate that recovery of ξ(r) from w(θ) is reliable and conceptually straightforward. Recent explicit constructions of fractal models [9] demonstrate this point very clearly -- a three dimensional fractal leads to a very anisotropic two-dimensional galaxy distribution. 3 Evidence for Homogeneity (3-d tests) The past decade has witnessed the explosive growth of redshift surveys of galaxies, from which one can estimate three-dimensional statistics directly. To date, these surveys are necessarily much smaller than the very large databases such as the APM catalog, and they correspondingly show more fluctuations from sample to sample. It is important that one beware that many of the early redshift surveys were too small to represent a fair statistical sample of the Universe (as expected in the orthodox school). Furthermore, many of the existing surveys are based on catalogs with irregular edges, and /or with known non-uniformity in their sample selection. These catalogs are usually flux limited, and some of them are far from complete at any flux level! For example, the CfA2 survey is based on Zwicky magnitudes, where systematic errors from one section of the sky to another are suspected, the Perseus-Pisces redshift survey contains a region of substantial extinction from our galaxy, the selection of Abell clusters of galaxies has known selection ef- fects that depend on the zenith angle of the photographic plates from which the clusters are selected. But at least these catalogs are approximately com- plete. Worst of all is to use a database such as LEDA [10] or ZCAT which 4 are repositories of redshifts collected from the literature. There is no way to make a uniform correction for the completeness of these catalogs, since they are constructed in an uncontrolled manner and are most definitely not intended for statistical analysis. The trouble this can lead to is exhibited in a power spectral analysis of the LEDA sample [11]. A comparison of this measure of P (k) with that ob- tained from the complete CfA2 survey is shown in the figures which Professor Pietronero prepared for this debate. The LEDA-derived P (k) is an order of magnitude larger than that derived from CfA2 and does not smoothly ex- trapolate to the Sachs-Wolfe inferred power spectrum on the larger scales measured by COBE (while the CfA2 spectrum can be smoothly connected to the COBE results). Proponents of the fractal picture would cite this in- stability of P (k) as a demonstration of fractal scaling, but I would counter that it is the LEDA database which is a fractal, not the Universe. Redshift catalogs which are appropriate for statistical analysis are those for which the selection is well known and well defined. For the purposes of today's debate, the most suitable redshift catalogs presently available are the survey of a bright subset of the APM galaxies [12], the IRAS catalogs [13], and the recently completed LCRS survey [14]. The notion that the galaxy distribution is a fractal arose from analysis of the two point correlation function ξ(r) in early redshift surveys. Many authors have commented that large coherent structures often appear to be as large as they could be within the sample volume surveyed (e.g. the CfA stickman, [1]). There is widespread agreement that the galaxy distribution approximates a fractal over a considerable range of scales [15]. The early surveys displayed increasing correlation length with increasing sample volume [16], and all surveys continue to show stronger correlation amplitudes for rich clusters, different correlation properties for different types of galaxies [17], and weak evidence for increased correlation strength for more luminous galaxies [18]. In the standard model, these properties are explained by the "bias" of rare events, luminosity bias, and environmental effects. The defense of the standard interpretation of a homogeneous large-scale universe has never been based on examination of the stability of ξ(r) or on examination of redshift survey maps; its defense up until the recent data has rested on the isotropy of the two-dimensional catalogs and on the stability of the mean density as a function of redshift and direction, n(z, ω). Local surveys in opposite hemispheres have very similar n(z) curves, and even in the original CfA1 survey, the mean galaxy density derived in the Northern 5 galactic hemisphere agreed with that in the Southern hemisphere to within a factor of 1.3 [19]. In the fractal interpreatation, this "bias" explanation for the behavior Instead, one argues that n(r) is poorly of ξ(r) is considered a cop-out. defined and the increased ξ(r) for larger volumes is simply the result of a decreasing mean density, as expected in the fractal model. The problems with this explanation are two-fold. In the fractal model the correlation length r0 should increase linearly with sample depth, but even in the shallowest slices of the CfA1 survey r0 increases only as the square-root of the sample depth [16]. Furthermore, it has been clearly demonstrated that different populations of galaxies drawn from the same volume do exhibit differing correlation properties [18], so therefore biasing effects must exist. 4 Recent Results (using 3-d data) 4.1 IRAS redshift surveys Pietronero for years has argued that the most suitable volume for statistical analysis is a sphere, since it most efficiently contains the largest fraction of galaxies within the most compact surface. This ideal has now been closely approximated by the IRAS selected galaxy samples, [13] which cover 88% of the sky to a depth of roughly 180h−1 Mpc, although the diluteness is quite extreme beyond 80 h−1 Mpc. Full sky maps of the observed galaxy distribution of the 1.2 Jy IRAS survey are shown in Figure 1. Each of these plots are independent slices of redshift with nearly constant aspect ratio, such that ∆z/z ≈ 1. In an unbounded fractal universe, the galaxy distribution must be ex- tremely anisotropic if we are not at a special location. The most elementary aspect of a fractal is that it should be approximately scale invariant, which implies that all four of these figures of nearly constant aspect ratio should appear statistically very similar to each other. But the reality is very differ- ent. Within the IRAS survey, or any optical survey, the galaxy distribution in the nearest shell, cz < 1600 km/s, is characterised by 100% fluctuations from one hemisphere to the other. This is the expected behavior of a fractal distribution. But the more distant shells are progressively more and more isotropic. Here is a clear demonstration of the fractal behavior on small scales 6 giving way to homogeneity on large scales, and it is completely contrary to the scale-invariant fractal picture, in which each shell should exhibit similar 100% anisotropies. Plots of n(z) for one hemisphere compared to one another show complete consistency on large scales, indicating that there is no ambiguity in the definition of the mean density. Analysis of ξ(r) for four separate volume limited subsets of the 1.2 Jy IRAS survey yields a correlation length r0 ≈ 4h−1 Mpc that does not change as the volume limiting radius is increased from 60h−1 Mpc up to 120 h−1 Mpc [20]. The disagreement with the fractal predicted amplitude r0 ranges from a factor of 6 to 12. Professor Pietronero, in this conference, stated that he agrees that the IRAS survey does not exhibit fractal behavior, and he ascribes this to the diluteness of the sample. But the problem with the fractal model is that the maps shown in Figure 1 are too smooth; dilute sampling could have increased the fluctuations, but how could it have transformed an anisotropic map into a smooth, isotropic map? The maps show that the outer scale of the fractal structure must be at some radius within the second shell, which is much less anisotropic than the first shell. Thus, the conjecture that the Universe is a fractal to the largest observed scales is false, and the diluteness of the IRAS sample cannot change this conclusion. 4.2 Las Campanas Redshift Survey (LCRS) The LCRS [14] is the first of the next generation of large, deep redshift surveys. It contains over 25,000 galaxies selected in six strips of 80 by 1.5 degrees, to a depth cz ≈ 45, 000 km/s. Three of these strips are nearly adjacent in the North, and three are nearly adjacent in the South. Recently published plots of the LCRS galaxy distribution show an "end of greatness". There are many structures and voids as large as seen in the shal- lower surveys such as CfA2, but there is an absence of larger scale structure. It appears as though the survey has crossed the peak in the power spectrum of fluctuations P (k) . The six slices of the LCRS all seem statistically very similar to each, and the observed distributions of n(z) in the different direc- tions are all the same on large scale, as expected in the standard picture but quite contrary to the idea that the fractal scale extends to the full survey depth. If the fractal did extend to the full LCRS depth, the separate slices should be very different from each other. Thus LCRS, consistent with IRAS, strongly demonstrates the approach to large scale homogeneity. 7 4.3 QSO Absorption Lines The spectra of all quasars at redshifts z > 1.8 contain abundant Ly-α ab- sorption lines due to intervening clouds of neutral hydrogen. In a fractal universe with no outer scale, most of the quasars would have large voids in front of them, and so exhibit no Ly-α absorption clouds. A cursory glance at high quality spectra of QSO's (e.g. as taken by HIRES on Keck [21]) shows that these clouds are ubiquitous, and that the universe is statistically uni- form in all directions probed. The interval probed by the clouds is roughly 1.8 < z < 4, a comoving scale of approximately 0.2c/H0. There are no large holes in the distribution of the Ly-α clouds, and in fact they are so uniformly distributed that it is very difficult to to measure any spatial correlations in the clouds at all [22]. The Ly-α clouds appear to be very nearly uniformly distributed in space, and are the most homogeneous tracers yet discovered. All lines of sight are observed to be statistically equivalent, as expected in a universe homogeneous on large scale. Again, this is completely contrary to the expectations of an unbounded fractal model. It is quite clear that the outer scale of the fractal distribution of matter must be orders of magnitude less than the 600h−1 Mpc probed by the sight line to the distant QSO's. 5 Summary As I have briefly reviewed above, there exist numerous arguments which demonstrate that the outer scale of the fractal distribution is well within the scale of observed volumes. From recent redshift space maps, we detect a characteristic size of voids in the galaxy distribution consistent with a peak in the power spectrum of fluctuations. As emphasized by Kirshner, the new LCRS survey may be seeing the "end of greatness" of large-scale structure. Future surveys such as the AAT redshift survey and the Sloan digital sky survey will lead to much better constraints on the turnover of the large-scale power spectrum and on the amplitude of the large-scale fluctuations. Since I believe that our current surveys are appoaching fair sample volumes, I fully expect the correlation amplitudes of the future, massive surveys to be consistent with current measurements. The measured two-point galaxy correlation function ξ(r) is a power law over three decades of scale and approximates fractal behavior from scales 8 of 0.01h−1 < r < 10h−1 Mpc, but on scales larger than ≈ 20h−1 Mpc, the fractal structure terminates, the rms fluctuation amplitude falls below unity, and the Universe approaches homogeneity, as necessary to make sense of a FRW universe. There clearly exists an outer scale of the fractal behavior, and this outer scale must grow with time (unless Ω0 ≪ 1). The observed galaxy distribution, being a real physical system rather than a mathemati- cal idealization, is a beautiful example of a limited-scale fractal joined onto sensible, dynamically evolving outer boundary conditions. As testimony to our faith in our respective debating positions, Professor Pietronero and I have agreed to wager a case of the best wine from Italy against the best Californian wine on the following proposition: that the correlation length r0 as ultimately measured from optically selected galaxies in the Sloan digital sky survey will be larger (according to LP) or smaller (according to MD) than r0−Cf A2 (LSloan/LCf A2)1/2, where Lsurvey is the radius of the largest inscribed sphere in a given survey. (This splits the harmonic difference of the fractal versus standard prediction.) Neil Turok has agreed to arbitrate this wager. Side bets are welcome. References [1] da Costa, L.N., Geller, M.J., Pellegrini, P.S., Latham, D.W. et al. 1994, ApJ Lett, 424, L1 [2] Coleman, P.H. & Pietronero, L. 1992,, Phys. Rep., 213, 311 [3] Baryshev, Y.U., Sylos-Labini, F., Montouri, M., & Pietronero, L. 1995, 38, 419 [4] Sylos Labini, F., Gabrielli, Montouri, M., & Pietronero, L. 1996, preprint [5] Weinberg, S. "Gravitation and Cosmology" 1972, Wiley & Sons [6] Peebles, P.J.E. 1993, "Principles of Physical Cosmology", Princeton Univ. Press [7] Peebles, P.J.E. 1980, "The Large-Scale Structure of the Universe", Princeton Univ. Press. 9 [8] Maddox,, S.J., Efstathiou, G., Sutherland, W.J., & Loveday, J. 1990, MNRAS 242, 43P [9] Peebles, P.J.E. 1996, unpublished letter [10] Paturel, G. et al. 1995, "Information and On-Line Date in Astronomy", p. 115, Ed. Egret D. & Albrecht M., Kluwer Academic Publications [11] Amendola, L, DiNella, H., Montouri, M., & Sylos-Labini, F. 1996, A&A, in press [12] Loveday, J. 1996, MNRAS, 278, 1025 [13] Fisher, K., Huchra, J., Strauss, M., Davis, M., Yahil, A., & Schlegel, D. 1995, ApJ. Suppl., 100, 69 [14] Shectman, S.A., Landy, S.D., Oemler A., Tucker, D.L., Lin, H., Kirsh- ner, R.P., & Schechter, P.L. 1996, preprint astro-ph/9604167 [15] Borgani, S. 1995, Physics Reports, 251, 1 [16] Davis, M., Meiksin, A., Strauss, M., da Costa, L., & Yahil, A. 1988, Ap.J. Lett., 333, L9 [17] Davis, M., & Geller, M.J. 1976, Ap.J., 208, 13 [18] Park, Vogeley, M., Geller, M.G., & Huchra, J. 1994, Ap.J., 431, 569 [19] Davis, M., & Huchra, J. 1982, Ap.J., 254, 437 [20] Fisher, K., Davis, M., Strauss, M., Yahil, A., & Huchra, J. 1993, MN- RAS, 266, 219 [21] Lu, L., Sargent, W., Womble, D. & Takada-Hidai M. 1996, preprint astro-ph/9606033 [22] Webb, J.K., & Barcons, X. 1991, MNRAS, 250, 270 10 360 360 360 360 180 180 180 180 0 0 0 0 Figure 1: Whole sky projection in galactic coordinates of the IRAS 1.2 Jy redshift survey. The different plots represent the galaxy distribution as di- rectly observed in different windows of observed redshift in the Local Group frame. Note the strong anisotropy in the nearby shell, progressively dimin- ishing in the distant shells. 11
astro-ph/0208563	1	0208	2002-08-30T09:13:11	Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants: concluding remarks	[ "astro-ph" ]	Concluding Remarks of the 270.WE-Heraeus Seminar on Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Proceedings of the 270. WE-Heraeus Seminar on: "Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants" Physikzentrum Bad Honnef, Germany, Jan. 21-25, 2002, eds. W. Becker, H.Lesch & J. Trumper, MPE Report 278, pp. 300- 302 2 0 0 2 g u A 0 3 1 v 3 6 5 8 0 2 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants: concluding remarks F. Pacini1, 2 1 Arcetri Astrophysical Observatory, L.go E. Fermi, 5, I-50125 Firenze,Italy 2 Dept. of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Florence, L.go E. Fermi, 2, I-50125 Firenze, Italy 1. Introduction More than 30 years have elapsed since the discovery of pul- sars (Hewish et al. 1968) and the realization that they are connected with rotating magnetized neutron stars (Gold 1968; Pacini 1967, 1968). It became soon clear that these objects are responsible for the production of the relativis- tic wind observed in some Supernovae remnants such as the Crab Nebula. For many years, the study of pulsars has been car- ried out mostly in the radio band. However, many recent results have come from observations at much higher fre- quencies (optical, X-rays, gamma rays). These observa- tions have been decisive in order to establish a realistic demography and have brought a better understanding of the relationship between neutron stars and SN remnants. The Proceedings of this Conference cover many aspects of this relationship (see also previous Conference Proceed- ings such as Bandiera et al. 1998; Slane and Gaensler, 2002). Because of this reason, my summary will not re- view all the very interesting results which have been pre- sented here and I shall address briefly just a few issues. The choice of these issues is largely personal: other col- leagues may have made a different selection. 2. Demography of Neutron Stars: the role of the magnetic field For a long time it has been believed that only Crab-like remnants (plerions) contain a neutron star and that the typical field strength of neutron stars is 1012 Gauss. The basis of this belief was the lack of pulsars associated with shell-type remnants or other manifestations of a relativis- tic wind. The justification given is that some SN explo- sions may blow apart the entire star. Alternatively, the central object may become a black hole. However, the number of shell remnants greatly exceeds that of pleri- ons: it becomes then difficult to invoke the formation of black holes, an event much more rare than the formation of neutron stars. The suggestion that shell remnants such as Cas A could be associated with neutron stars which have rapidly lost their initial rotational energy because of an ultra- strong magnetic field B ∼ 1014 − 1015 Gauss (Cavaliere & Pacini, 1970) did receive little attention. The observa- tional situation has now changed: a compact thermal X- ray source has been discovered close to the center of Cas A (Tananbaum, 1999) and it could be the predicted ob- ject. Similar sources have been found in association with other remnants and are likely to be neutron stars. We have also heard during this Conference that some shell- type remnants (including Cas A) show evidence for a weak non-thermal X-ray emission superimposed on the thermal one: this may indicate the presence of a residual relativis- tic wind produced in the center. Another important result has been the discovery of neutron stars with ultra-strong magnetic fields, up to 1014 − 1015 G. In this case the total magnetic energy could be larger than the rotational en- ergy ("magnetars"). This possibility had been suggested long time ago (Woltjer, 1968). It should be noticed, how- ever, that the slowing down rate determines the strength of the field at the speed of light cylinder and that the usually quoted surface fields assume a dipolar geometry corresponding to a braking index n = 3. Unfortunately the value of n has been measured only in a few cases and it ranges between 1.4 − 2.8 (Lyne et al., 1996). The present evidence indicates that neutron stars man- ifest themselves in different ways: – Classical radio pulsars (with or without emission at higher frequencies) where the rotation is the energy source. – Compact X-ray sources where the energy is supplied by accretion (products of the evolution in binary sys- tems). – Compact X-ray sources due to the residual thermal emission from a hot surface. – Anomalous X-ray pulsars (AXP) with long periods and ultra strong fields (up to 1015 Gauss). The power emit- ted by AXPs exceeds the energy loss inferred from the slowing down rate. It is possible that AXPs are asso- ciated with magnetized white dwarfs, rotating close to the shortest possible period (5 − 10 s) or, alternatively, they could be neutron stars whose magnetic energy is dissipated by flares. – Soft gamma-ray repeaters. 2 F. Pacini: Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants: concluding remarks In addition it is possible that some of the unidentified gamma ray sources are related to neutron stars. The present picture solves some previous inconsistencies. For instance, the estimate for the rate of core-collapse Super- novae (roughly one every 30-50 years) was about a factor of two larger than the birth-rate of radio pulsars, suggest- ing already that a large fraction of neutron stars does not appear as radio pulsars. The observational evidence supports the notion of a large spread in the magnetic strength of neutron stars and the hypothesis that this spread is an important factor in determining the morphology of Supernova remnants. A very strong field would lead to the release of the bulk of the rotational energy during a short initial period (say, days up to a few years): at later times the remnant would appear as a shell-type. A more moderate field (say 1012 Gauss or so) would entail a long lasting energy loss and produce a plerion. 3. Where are the pulses emitted ? Despite the great wealth of data available, there is no gen- eral consensus about the radiation mechanism for pulsars. The location of the region where the pulses are emitted is also controversial: it could be located close to the stellar surface or, alternatively, in the proximity of the speed of light cylinder. The radio emission is certainly due to a coherent pro- cess because of the very high brightness temperatures (Tb up to and above 1030 K have been observed). A possible model invokes the motion of bunches of charges sliding along the curved field lines with a relativistic Lorentz fac- tor γ such that the critical frequency νc ∼ c ρ γ3 reaches or exceeds the radio band. Typically, this would entail γ > ∼ 102. If we assume Tb ∼ 1030 K and γ ∼ 102 − 103, the ther- modynamical limitation kTb ∼ mc2γF requires a coher- ence factor F (number of electrons in the bunch) of order ∼ 1017. At least one of the sizes of the bunch must be smaller than the emitted wavelength. The radio spectrum is determined by the distribution in size of the bunches and the effect of coherence is gradually lost at very high radio frequencies (Aloisio & Blasi 2002). This may possi- bly explain the up-turn of the spectrum observed in some sources in the millimeter range, as reported here by Sieber. Unfortunately the radio emission does not give suffi- cient information about the parameters of the source since many of them are affected by the degree of coherence. The situation is different if we consider pulsars which emit at higher frequencies (optical and X-ray bands), where the observed brightness is compatible with an incoherent pro- cess. A striking aspect of the optical pulses is the very strong dependency of the power upon the period (they are emit- ted only from a few sources). A possible scenario assumes that the optical radiation is normal synchrotron radiation, emitted from particles which gyrate with a small pitch angle Ψ around the field lines. Such a model, applied to the Crab pulsar, PSR 0531, can explain the observations with parameters compatible with those expected at the speed of light cylinder distance RL = cP 2π : Ψ ∼ 10−2; B⊥ ∼ 104 G; γ ∼ 102 − 103. The model leads to the expectation of a very fast de- crease of the synchrotron intensity with period because of the combination of two factors: a) the reduced particles flux when the period increases; b) the reduced efficiency of synchrotron losses (which scale ∝ B2 ∝ R−6 ∝ P −6) at L the speed of light cylinder (Pacini, 1971; Pacini & Salvati 1983, 1987). The prediction fits the observed secular de- crease of the optical emission from the Crab Nebula and the magnitude of the Vela pulsar. A recent re-examination of all available optical data confirms that this model can account for the luminosity of the known optical pulsars (Shearer and Golden, 2001). If so, the optical radiation supports strongly the notion that the emitting region is located close to the speed of light cylinder. 4. A speculation: can the thermal radiation from young neutron stars quench the relativistic wind? My final remarks concern the possible effect of the ther- mal radiation coming from the neutron star surface upon the acceleration of particles. This problem has been inves- tigated for the near magnetosphere (Supper & Truemper, 2000) and it has been found that the Inverse Compton Scattering (ICS) against the thermal photons is impor- tant only in marginal cases. However, if we assume that the acceleration of the relativistic wind and the radiation of pulses occur close to the speed of light cylinder, the sit- uation becomes different and the ICS can dominate over synchrotron losses for a variety of parameters. The basic reason is that the importance of ICS at the speed of light distance RL scales like the energy density of the thermal photons uγ ∝ R−2 ∝ P −2; on the other hand, L the synchrotron losses are proportional to the magnetic energy density in the same region uB ∝ R−6 L ∝ P −6. Numerically, one finds that ICS losses dominate over synchrotron losses if T6 > 0.4 B1/2 12 Ps where T6 is the temperature in units 106 K; B12 = B Ps is the pulsar period in seconds). 1012G ; The corresponding upper limit for the energy of the electrons, assuming that the acceleration takes place for a length of order of the speed of light distance and that the gains are equal to the losses is given by: Emax ≃ 1.2 × 103T6 −4 Ps GeV. F. Pacini: Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants: concluding remarks 3 Provided that the particles are accelerated and radi- ate in proximity of the speed of light cylinder distance, we conclude that the thermal photons can limit the acceler- ation of particles, especially in the case of young and hot neutron stars. It becomes tempting to speculate that this may postpone the beginning of the pulsar activity until the temperature of the star is sufficiently low. The main manifestation of neutron stars in this phase would be a flux of high energy photons in the gamma-ray band, due to the interaction of the quenched wind with the thermal photons from the stellar surface. This model and its ob- servational consequences are currently under investigation (Amato, Blasi, Pacini, work in progress). References Aloisio, R., & Blasi, P. 2002, Astrop. Phys., Bandiera, R., et al. 1998, Proc. Workshop "The Relationship between Neutron Stars and Supernova Remnants", Mem. Societ Astronomica Italiana, vol. 69, n. 4 Cavaliere, A., & Pacini, F. 1970, ApJ, 159, 170 Gold, T. 1968, Nature, 217, 731 Hewish A., et al. 1968, Nature 217, 709 Lyne, G., et al. 1996, Nature, 381, 497 Pacini, F. 1967, Nature, 216, 567 Pacini, F. 1968, Nature, 219, 145 Pacini, F. 1971, ApJ, 163, L17 Pacini, F., & Salvati, M. 1983, ApJ, 274, 369 Pacini F., & Salvati, M. 1987, ApJ., 321, 447 Shearer, A., and Golden, A. 2001, ApJ, 547, 967 Slane, P. , Gaensler, B. 2002, Proc. Workshop "Neutron Stars in Supernova Remnants"ASP Conference Proceedings (in press) Supper, R., & Trumper, J. 2000, A&A, 357, 301 Tananbaum, B, et al. 1999, IAU Circular 7246 Thompson, C., Duncan, R.C. 1996, ApJ, 473, 322 Woltjer, L. 1968, ApJ, 152, 179
astro-ph/9611048	1	9611	1996-11-06T15:36:04	Disk-Corona Models and X-ray Emission from Seyfert Galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	The current status of understanding of the X-ray emission from Seyfert galaxies involves Comptonization of soft photons by hot subrelativistic electrons. After briefly reviewing the early theoretical basis for the presence of hot optically thin plasma in or around accretion disks and the key observations that led to develop the presently popular model of an accretion disk with a hot corona, we summarize recent progress in accretion models that take into account energy dissipation and/or angular momentum transport in the corona. Finally, adopting the simple scheme of a homogeneous plane parallel corona, we discuss in detail the dependence of the X-ray spectrum on the coronal parameters. Despite the strong coupling between optical depth and temperature which determines a spectral shape insensitive to their precise values, moderate spectral changes are possible. The spectral variability patterns can be used as diagnostics for coronal physics and should allow to determine whether the optical depth of the corona is dominated by e+e- pairs.	astro-ph	astro-ph	DISK-CORONA MODELS AND X-RAY EMISSION FROM SEYFERT GALAXIES Laura Maraschi Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, via Brera 28, 20121 Milano, Italy Francesco Haardt Department of Astronomy & Astrophysics, Institute of Theoretical Physics, Goteborg University & Chalmers University of Technology, 412 96 Goteborg, Sweden Abstract. The current status of understanding of the X-ray emission from Seyfert galaxies involves Comptonization of soft photons by hot sub- relativistic electrons. After briefly reviewing the early theoretical basis for the presence of hot optically thin plasma in or around accretion disks and the key observations that led to develop the presently popular model of an accretion disk with a hot corona, we summarize recent progress in accretion models that take into account energy dissipation and/or an- gular momentum transport in the corona. Finally, adopting the simple scheme of a homogeneous plane parallel corona, we discuss in detail the dependence of the X-ray spectrum on the coronal parameters. Despite the strong coupling between optical depth and temperature which de- termines a spectral shape insensitive to their precise values, moderate spectral changes are possible. The spectral variability patterns can be used as diagnostics for coronal physics and should allow to determine whether the optical depth of the corona is dominated by e+e− pairs. 1. Introduction The main uncertainty in the thory of accretion disks is on the physical processes responsible for energy dissipation and angular momentum transport. Despite important progresses in understanding turbulent and magnetic viscosity it is still impossible to anticipate the precise mechanisms at work in astrophysical plasmas, in particular in accretion disks. The emitted spectra are not too sensi- tive to these mechanisms if the disk is optically thick and the dissipation occurs within the thick layer. However the high energy spectra emitted by black hole binaries and active galactic nuclei indicate conditions far from thermodynamic equilibrium, implying that the above conditions are strongly violated in the inner regions of highly luminous accretion disks around black holes. We review here shortly the evolution of accretion models involving a hot corona as an important site of energy dissipation and the observational grounds for such picture in the case of Seyfert 1 galaxies. We describe the basic features of the radiative coupling and feed back effects of a sandwich configuration that can 1 account for the observed X-ray spectra and present new results on the spectral "dynamics" expected in such models. 2. Early Ideas about X-ray Emission from Accretion Disks The importance of Comptonization for the high energy spectra of luminous ac- cretion disks was recognized since the seminal paper by Shakura and Syunyaev (1973) and it is a pleasure to recall that both authors participated to this confer- ence. However the high temperature and power law spectral shape observed for Cyg X-1 and the instability problems of radiation pressure supported and opti- cally thin disks challenged the selfconsistency of the "standard" model leading Shapiro, Lightman & Eardley (1976) to hypothesize that pressure support could be due to hot ions, weakly coupled to the radiating electrons in a "two tempera- ture" optically thin plasma. Applying the model to Cyg X-1 these authors noted the desirability of having the comptonization parameter y = τ (∆ǫ/ǫ) close to one, without however finding a motivation for such value within the model itself (τ is the optical depth of the corona and (∆ǫ/ǫ) the average energy gain per scattering). The possibility of a hot corona above a relatively cool accretion disk was discussed by Liang and Price (1977) and subsequently Liang (1979) first noted that a sandwich configuration would 1. be "natural" in a magnetoturbulent disk since dissipation of magnetic en- ergy occurs preferentially in a rarefied atmosphere, 2. solve the stability problem (see Ionson & Kuperus 1984 ), 3. imply a feedback between disk and corona that would determine a value of y close to 1. The physics of magnetic dissipation in accretion disks was substantiated and applied to galactic black hole candidates by Galeev, Rosner & Vaiana (1979), while a basic treatment of Comptonization was given by Sunyaev & Titarchuck (1980). The relevance of Comptonization for AGN spectra was first discussed by Katz (1976) and later by Lightman Giacconi and Tananbaum (1978) for the X-ray spectrum of NGC 4151. The latter authors first noted that the inferred parameters for NGC 4151 implied high optical depth for pair production sug- gesting a cut off in the observed spectrum at 500 keV due to this process. Non thermal pair plasmas were studied in depth in the 80's in relation to the X-ray emission of AGN . We will not try to summarize this subject here but refer to Svensson (1994) for a comprehensive review. 3. Key Observations Different "types" of observations were instrumental in leading to the present widely adopted scheme of a cool optically thick disk embedded in a hot corona. New observations in the medium-hard X-ray range with the GINGA satellite, 2 revealed the signature of "cold matter" in the X-ray spectra of Seyfert galax- ies, detecting the Kα emission line of Fe and a broad hump around 10 keV as expected for "reflected" X-rays (Pounds et al. 1990). Systematic comparisons of the UV and X-ray emission in quasars and Seyfert galaxies (Sanders et al. 1989, Walter and Fink 1993) indicated that the power emitted in the latter was at most comparable to but not larger than that emitted in the UV. In order to have similar accretion power, the two emit- ting regions must be at a similar distance from the black hole and a configuration with a hot inner region surrounded by a larger cooler disk is problematic. A possible way out of this difficulty is provided by the new class of advection dominated accretion disk solutions (see the review by Narayan at this meeting) in which the radiative efficiency of the inner disk is reduced. In these solutions however, as in the earlier model by Shapiro Lightman & Eardley the value of the Comptonization parameter is determined "a posteriori". Moreover observations of correlated variability in the UV and X-rays (NGC 4151, Perola et al., 1986, and NGC 5548, Clavel et al., 1992) suggested that a large fraction of the UV emission is due to reprocessing of X-rays, implying that the UV emitting region intercepts a large fraction of the X-rays . The most natural configuration accounting for the above points is that of a two phase or sandwich disk model as described below. An important prediction of this scheme was that a thermal cut-off should be expected above 100 keV in the X-ray spectra of Seyfert nuclei. The OSSE experiment on the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory indeed confirmed this prediction, showing a substan- tial steepening of the spectra in the hard X-ray range (e.g. Maisack et al. 1993, Zdziarski et al. 1995). These results set strong limits to the possible role of non-thermal pair plasmas and provide a measurement of the total luminosity in the comptonized component (due to the "convergence" of the integral flux) which confirms that the luminosity in the UV is comparable or larger than in X-rays. 4. A Homogeneous Two Phase Model for the X-ray Emission Guided by the above theoretical and observational points we analized the ra- diative transfer and coupling in the simple scheme of a sandwich model with a cool optically thick layer embedded in a hot optically thin one. Using a plane parallel limit a thermal balance equation can be written for each of the two "phases" assuming that a fraction f of the gravitational power is dissipated in the hot corona and a fraction 1 − f in the optically thick disk. The coupling between the two "phases" arises from the fact that the Comptonization process in the hot corona gives rise to quasi-isotropic X-ray radiation. Therefore, in the plane parallel limit, only half of it escapes from the source while the other half impinges on the cool disk. The latter is in part (10 -- 20%) reflected, giving rise to the observed spectral hump in the 10 -- 30 keV range; in small part it is reemitted as an Fe fluorescence line, but the largest part (80 -- 90 %) is absorbed, reprocessed and reemitted into black-body photons which contribute to the soft photon input for Comptonization. The two coupled equations determine the value of the Compton amplifica- tion parameter A = 1 + LComp/Lsof t, necessary to close the loop (Haardt & 3 Maraschi 1991, hereinafter HM91). A is determined by the only free parameter f and for small f A ≃ 1 + f , while for f = 1 A ≃ 3. The exact value of A in the limit f = 1 depends on the precise value of the albedo and on the degree of anisotropy of the comptonized radiation and is very important because it fixes the spectral shape of the comptonized X-ray radiation. In the theory of Comp- tonization the spectral index depends on the temperature TC and optical depth of the comptonizing electrons. Therefore fixing A implies a fixed spectral shape and a relation between TC and τ . If the corona is dominated by electron positron pairs its optical depth is determined by the compactness parameter, defined as lc = σT mec2 H/R2L where H is the scale height of the corona, R the radius of the underlying disk and L the total luminosity of the system. The relation between TC and τ imposed by the feed back effect transforms then into a relation between TC and lc, with higher values of the compactness corresponding to lower values of the temperature (HM91). From the approximate estimates in HM91 it was clear that in order to reproduce the average X-ray spectrum of Seyfert galaxies it was necessary to have f ≃ 1, which implied that practically all the energy was dissipated in the corona and the cool disk acted only as a "passive" reprocessor. With this assumption, the model could account for the average value and for the relatively small dispersion of spectral indices of Seyfert I galaxies (Nandra & Pounds 1994), for the reflection hump and for the Fe emission line. It predicted a spectral cut off in the hard X-ray range which was revealed by OSSE (see above). Improved treatment of radiative transfer and detailed spectral calculations (Haardt, 1993; Haardt and Maraschi 1993; Titarchuk 1994) confirmed and re- fined these results. More accurate solutions for the pair corona model are dis- cussed in Poutanen and Svensson (1996) and Stern et al. (1995), not only for a slab but also for cylindrical and hemispherical geometry for the active region. 5. Accretion models of disk+corona systems The success of the two phase model in explaining the X-ray properties of Seyfert galaxies and the realization that most of the accretion power should be released directly in the corona, presumably through magnetic buoyancy and reconnection above the optically thick disk, motivated new investigations of this configuration with different assumptions as to the share of angular momentum tranfer, energy dissipation and accretion rate and with different boundary conditions between disk and corona. Nakamura & Osaki (1993) describe the two phases as two α disks with accretion taking place in the cool disk only. However, as additional constraint the average coronal pressure Pc is taken to be equal to the average disk pressure Pd, clearly an unphysical assumption. A similar approach is adopted by Kusunose & Mineshige (1994) who assume that mass accretion and energy dissipation are shared between disk and corona again with the unphysical condition Pc = Pd. Svensson & Zdziarski (1994) model the cool phase as an α disk except for assuming that a fraction f of the power release associated with the angular momentum transfer takes place above an optical depth τc which is treated as a free parameter due to the poor knowledge of the microphysical processes. 4 They show that in the case of a strong corona (large f ) the unstable radiation dominated region disappears (see also Ionson and Kuperus, 1984 and Chen 1995) coronal pressure and irradiation only affects the surface layers of the cold disk. A more ambitious approach is that of Zycki et al. (1995) and Witt, Czerny and Zycky (1996) who aim at determining the fraction of power dissipated in the corona selfconsistently rather than treating it as a free parameter. They describe the disk and corona as accretion disks with different α parameters, imposing pressure balance at the base of the corona, and allowing the fraction of mass accretion through the disk and corona to be a function of radius. In the first paper they find that coronal solutions are not allowed at high accretion rates due to the impossibility of satisfying the hydrostatic equilibrium equation, while in the second they include vertical supersonic outflow. In the latter case the corona forms only for accretion rates larger than a limiting value and the fraction of energy dissipated in the corona decreases with increasing accretion rate. The interest of this result is clear in view of the possible compar- ison with observational results for black hole binaries in different intensity states or for a comparison of the average properties of Seyfert galaxies and quasars. Although a large uncertainty still exists in the applicability of an α description of viscosity, especially in this complex case, this approach is very promising. 6. The Two -- Phase Model Revisited: A Patchy Corona? The simple two phase model originally proposed has two strong implications. First, the luminosity in the soft blackbody photons emitted by the surface under- lying the comptonizing corona must be equal to the X-ray luminosity (neglecting factors of a few due to the different angular dpendences of the two components). Moreover their intensities must be "perfectly" correlated in time. If we identify the blackbody component with the total UV emission, both these predictions are violated. In fact, as mentioned earlier (see section 3), if the spectral steepening in the hard X-ray range measured by OSSE for a few Seyfert galaxies is a general property, the estimated "bolometric correction" for the X-ray luminosity yields values smaller than the UV luminosity (Walter and Fink 1993). At the same time the correlation between UV and X-ray luminosity is present on timescales of days but may not hold on shorter timescales. Both these difficulties can be solved in a more realistic coronal model, as proposed by Galeev Rosner & Vaiana (1979), where the energy stored in the magnetic field is released in active regions covering only part of the cool disk (Haardt, Maraschi & Ghisellini 1994). The feed back and X-ray spectral prop- erties discussed earlier can be maintained if the power reprocessed under the active regions dominates that which is locally dissipated by other processes. However the disk emission not covered by active regions can leak out freely. The condition that f=1 is therefore not necessary on the large scale. The active regions should produce hot spots on the disk giving rise to a rapidly varying component contributing in part to the UV bump and in part to the so called "soft excess" observed in many Seyferts (e.g. Mushotzky, Done & Pounds, 1993). Also the flat limit may not be valid for each region allowing some more freedom in the expected spectral shapes (see for a review Svensson 1996) 5 Figure 1. The total (direct power law + Comptonized reflection) spectral index in the [2 -- 10] keV range α[2−10] is plotted against the coronal electron temperature kT , for different values of the viewing angle and for different temperatures of the soft blackbody photons. Square symbols refer to a face -- on line of sight, triangles to an incli- nation of 60o. Open symbols, connected with dashed lines, refer to a soft photon temperature kTBB = 100 eV. Closed symbols connecetd with solid lines are for kTBB = 50 eV. The curves show that harder spectra are expected for larger temperatures (lower optical depth) of the comptonizing electrons. The difference between results computed for different inclination angles is larger at higher temperatures (lower optical depths) due to the larger anisotropy of the first scattering. 6 7. Diagnostics of Coronal Models: Broad Band X-ray Variability In view of some existing and many more expected data on the spectral vari- ability of Seyfert galaxies from the soft to the hard X-ray band we explored in some detail the behaviours expected in the model (Haardt Maraschi & Ghisellini 1996). In fact, even adopting a fixed geometry for the active region(s) and de- spite an almost constant Compton parameter imposed by the feed back effect, (LC/LS = 2 for the slab geometry adopted in the following) the spectral shape in the medium X-ray range (characterized by a spectral index α[2−10]) depends somewhat on the parameters of the system (i.e. τ , TC and TBB). Moreover, the optical depth may depend on luminosity as well as the temperature of the soft reprocessed photons. Since TBB, α[2−10] and TC can be simultaneosly observed by broad band satellites like XTE or SAX or by the joint use of different satel- lites, it is interesting to compute the relations between these quantities. The most important results are summarized below. The relation between the spectral index of the total spectrum α[2−10] (in- cluding also Comptonization of the reflected spectrum ) and the temperature of the corona is shown in Figure 1, for different values of TBB and of the incli- nation angle. We recall that the optical depth does not appear explicitly but is related to the temperature by the balance equation for the corona (see also Pietrini and Krolik 1995). Values of TC in the range 30 -- 300 keV, as suggested by observations (Maisak et al. 1993, Johnson et al. 1993, Madejski et al. 1995), correspond to optical depths between 1 and 0.1. The important points to note are the following: 1. Changes in τ and Tc give rise to significant spectral variability despite the fact that the ratio LC/LS is constant in the model. In the slab geometry considered here α[2−10] is found to be in the range [0.4 -- 1.4] for τ varying between 0.1 and 1. 2. Steeper spectra are produced as τ increases approaching unity. Corre- spondingly, an increase of the spectral index is accompanied by a decrease of the coronal temperature, i.e. spectral index and coronal temperature are anticorrelated. The actual values of α and TC in Fig 2 refer to LC/LS ≃ 2, however the anticorrelation between spectral index and the electron tem- perature is a general feature common to models based on Compton cooling with fixed geometry. Note that the dispersion of the α[2−10] vs. kT relation is larger at higher temperature. If the main contribution to τ comes from ordinary electrons, a reliable relation between luminosity and optical depth for the corona cannot be specified a priori. It is conceivable that changes in τ (e.g. fluctuations) occur at constant luminosity. This case is illustrated in Figure 2, where broad band spectra of constant total luminosity and different τ and TC are compared. The spectra pivot around 10-30 keV: in the medium X-ray range higher intensity corresponds to softer spectra. while in the hard X-ray range larger intensity corresponds to harder spectra. In contrast to the above situation, if the optical depth is due to pairs as expected in cases of high compactness, the luminosity (for fixed size) is a pre- dictable and very strong function of τ . This case is illustrated in Figure 3, where 7 Figure 2. Comptonized spectra for constant luminosity and black body temperature (kTBB = 100 eV), computed for different (τ, Θ) equlibrium values [(0.63,011), (0.32,0.21), (0.2,0.3), (0.1,0.5)]. A face -- on line of sight is considered. 8 Spectra for ℓc = 30 (A) and ℓc = 300 (B) are computed Figure 3. assuming a change of luminosity with constant emitting area. Spec- trum "A" has τ = 0.2, Θ = 0.3 and kTBB = 50 eV. Spectrum "B" has τ = 0.32, Θ = 0.21 and kTBB = 89 eV. In both cases a face -- on line of sight is considered. 9 Figure 4. Same as Figure 3, but assuming a constant luminosity and a varying emitting area. As before, spectrum "A" (ℓcv = 30) has τ = 0.2, Θ = 0.3 and kTBB = 50 eV. Spectrum "B" (ellc = 300) has τ = 0.32, Θ = 0.21, but a much larger kTBB = 158 eV. 10 the two spectra refer to a change in luminosity by a factor 10, but have very similar spectral shapes. The higher luminosity spectrum also has a consistently higher TBB. Finally in Figure 4 two spectra due to pair dominated coronae are compared, where the compactness was varied by changing the surface area of the active region at constant luminosity. Here a dramatic change in TBB is apparent with little spectral variations in the medium hard X-ray range. The two spectra also represent an extreme case of a large variation in the soft band without a correspondingly large variation at medium X-ray energies. This demonstrates clearly that the correlation between Lc and Ls does not translate necessarily into a correlation of the observed medium and soft X-ray fluxes. It seems quite premature to derive firm conclusions from the few broad band observations presently available. We note however that some spectral variability episodes observed in NGC 4151 (Perola et al. 1986), NGC 5548 (Done et al. 1995) and Mrk 766 (Leighly et al 1996), resemble more the pivoting behaviour illustrated in Figure 2 rather than those depicted in Figure 3 or 4, suggesting that these sources are not pair dominated. 8. Conclusions Substantial progress in understanding emission processes from the inner regions of accretion disks has been achieved. X-ray observations suggest a two phase model, with hot optically thin gas coupled to a cooler optically thick layer, as may be expected for an accretion disk with large energy dissipation in a hot corona. However, the formation, heating and structure of the corona, its dependence on fundamental parameters like the accretion rate and central black hole mass are still largely unknown. Broad band measurements from the soft to the hard X-ray band, possible with present satellites like ROSAT, ASCA, XTE and SAX offer the exciting per- spective of investigating how the coronal parameters vary in time for the same source or differ statistically in different classes of sources. Important questions such as: is the optical depth dominated by e+e− pairs? are the coronal param- eters related to luminosity? what is the cause of the different X-ray properties of Seyfert galaxies and Quasars? could be answered in the near future. References Chen X., 1995, ApJ, 448, 903 Clavel J., et al., 1992, ApJ, 393, 113 Done C., Pounds K.A., Nandra K., Fabian A.C., 1995, MNRAS, 275, 417 Galeev A.A., Rosner R., Vaiana G.S., 1979, ApJ, 229, 318 Haardt F., 1993, ApJ, 413, 680 Haardt F., Maraschi L., 1991, ApJ, 380, L51 11 Haardt F., Maraschi L., 1993, ApJ, 413, 507 Haardt F., Maraschi L., Ghisellini G., 1994, ApJ, 432, L95 Haardt F., Maraschi L., Ghisellini G., 1996, ApJ, in press Ionson J.A., Kuperus M., 1984 , ApJ, 284, 389 Johnson W.N., et al. 1993, A&AS, 97, 21 Katz J.I., 1976, ApJ, 206, 910 Kusunose M., Mineshige S., 1994, ApJ, 423, 600 Leighly K.M., Mushotzky R.F., Yaqoob T., Kunyeda H., Edelson R., 1996, ApJ, in press Liang E.P.T., 1979, ApJ, 231, L111 Liang E.P.T., Price R.H., 1977, ApJ218, 247 Lightman A.P., Giacconi R., Tananbaum H., 1978, ApJ, 224,375 Madejski G.M., et al., 1995, ApJ, 438, 672 Mushotzky R.F., Done C., Pounds K.A., 1993, ARA&A, 31, 717 Maisack M. et al., 1993, ApJ, 407, L61 Nakamura, Osaki, 1993, PASJ, 45, 775 Nandra K, Pounds K.A., 1994, MNRAS, 268, 405 Perola G.C., et al., 1986, ApJ, 306, 508 Pietrini P., Krolik J.H., 1995, ApJ, 447, 526 Pounds K.A., Nandra K., Stewart G.C., George I.M., Fabian A.C., 1990, Nat, 344, 132 Poutanen J., Svensson R., 1996, ApJ, 470, 249 Sanders D.B., Phinney E.S., Neuegebauer G., Soifer B.T., Matthews K., 1989, ApJ, 247, 29 Shakura N.I., Sunyaev R.A., 1973, A&A, 24, 337 Shapiro S.L., Lightman A.P., Eardley D.M., 1976, apj, 204, 187 Shimura, Mineshige, Takahara, 1995, ApJ439, 74 Stern B.E., Poutanen J., Svensson R., Sikora M., Begelman M.C., 1995, ApJ, 449, L13 Sunyaev R.A., Titarchuk L.G., 1980, A&A, 86, 121 12 Svensson R., 1994, ApJS, 92, 585 Svensson R., 1996, A&A, in press Svensson R., Zdziarski A., 1994, ApJ, 436, 599: Titarchuk L.G., 1994, ApJ, 434, 313 Walter R., Fink H.H., 1993, A&A, 274, 105 Witt H.J., Czerny B., Zycky P.T., 1996, MNRAS, submitted Zdziarski A.A., Johnson W.N., Done C., Smith D., Mc Naron-Brown K., 1995, ApJ, 438, L63 Zycki P.T., Collin -- Souffrin S., Czerny B., 1995, MNRAS, 277, 70 13
astro-ph/0006059	1	0006	2000-06-05T07:02:43	Tunable Imaging Filters in Astronomy	[ "astro-ph" ]	While tunable filters are a recent development in night time astronomy, they have long been used in other physical sciences, e.g. solar physics, remote sensing and underwater communications. With their ability to tune precisely to a given wavelength using a bandpass optimized for the experiment, tunable filters are already producing some of the deepest narrowband images to date of astrophysical sources. Furthermore, some classes of tunable filters can be used in fast telescope beams and therefore allow for narrowband imaging over angular fields of more than a degree over the sky.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Tunable Imaging Filters While tunable filters are a recent development in night time astronomy, they have long been used in other physical sciences, e.g. solar physics, remote sensing and underwater communications. With their ability to tune precisely to a given wave- length using a bandpass optimized for the exper- iment, tunable filters are already producing some of the deepest narrowband images to date of as- trophysical sources. Furthermore, some classes of tunable filters can be used in fast telescope beams and therefore allow for narrowband imaging over angular fields of more than a degree over the sky. The physics of tunable imaging A rich variety of physical phenomena can iso- late a finite spectral band: absorption, scattering, diffraction, evanescence, birefringence, acousto- optics, single layer and multi-layer interference, multi-path interferometry, polarizability, and so on. Most of the available optical filter technolo- gies are listed below: linear / circular variable filter multi-layer dielectric filter Fabry-Perot interferometer Michelson interferometer acousto-optic filter solid etalon filter solid Michelson filter generalized resonant grating filter sub-lambda evanescent grating filter volume phase holographic grating filter Lyot- Ohman filter generalized Lyot filter generalized Solc filter liquid crystal filter There is a bewildering array of future possibili- ties, including tunable crystal lattice structures, and many possible variants on the above technolo- gies. Here, we focus on a few key technologies. The ideal device The ideal filter is an imaging device which can iso- late an arbitrary spectral band δλ at an arbitrary wavelength λ over a broad, continuous spectral range, preferably with a response function which is identical in form at all wavelengths. The tilting interference filter is much the worst form of tunable filter. The spectral range covered is almost negligible, and the filter profile varies with tilt angle. Some devices (e.g. Lyot, linear variable filter) work only at a fixed resolving power but have the ability to tune over a wide spectral window. Better devices allow for a wide selection of resolv- ing powers over a wide range of wavelengths. The different techniques rely ultimately on the interference of beams that traverse differ- ent optical paths to form a signal. The tech- nologies which come closest to the ideal tunable filter are the air-gap Fabry-Perot and Michel- son (Fourier Transform) interferometers. To un- derstand why, we highlight the Taurus Tun- able Filter the first gen- eral purpose device for night-time astronomy (see http://www.aao.gov.au/local/www/jbh/ttf). This is a Fabry-Perot filter where interference is formed between two highly reflective, moving plates. To be a useful filter, not only must the plates move through a large physical range, but they must start at separations of only a few wave- lengths, as we show. (TTF) which was The condition for photons with wavelength λ to pass through the filter is (see Fig. 1) mλ = 2µℓ cos θ from which it follows that dR R = dm m = dℓ ℓ . (1) (2) For an order of interference m, the resolving power is R = mN where N is the instrumental finesse. The finesse is determined by the coating reflectiv- ity and is essentially the number of recombining beams. For the TTF, the plates can be scanned over the range ℓ = 1.5 − 15µm, and the orders of interference span the range m = 4 − 40, such that the available resolving powers are R = 100 − 1000. The sharp core of almost all tunable-filter transmission profiles is not ideal. Even a small amount of flatness at peak transmission can ensure that we avoid narrowly missing most of the spec- tral line signal from a source. In theory, all band- limited functions can be squared off, but in practice this is difficult for all but two devices. Since the Michelson interferometer (filter) obtains its data in the frequency domain, the profile can be partially squared off at the data reduction stage through a suitable choice of convolving function. For the Solc filter, the instrumental profile can be modified through the use of partial polarizers and birefrin- gent retarder elements. Summary of filter technologies Here, we provide a brief outline of some of the key technologies. Monolithic filters Interference filter: The principle relies on a dielec- tric spacer sandwiched between two transmitting layers (single cavity). The substrates are com- monly fused silica in the ultraviolet, glass or quartz in the optical, and water-free silica in the infrared. Between the spacer and the glass, surface coatings are deposited by evaporation which partly trans- mit and reflect an incident ray. Each internally re- flected ray shares a fixed phase relationship to all the other internally reflected rays. For construc- tive interference, for a wavelength λ to be trans- mitted, it must satisfy eqn. 1 where θ = θR is the refracted angle within the optical spacer, and the optical gap is the product of the thickness ℓ and refractive index µ of the spacer. The construction of these filters has undergone a revolution through the use of dielectric, multi-layer thin film coatings, and a proper description is more involved. All such filters can be tuned through a small wavelength interval (δλ/λ = −θ2 R/2µ2), which amounts to no more than 2%λ in practice. Suffice it to say, inter- ference filters make for poor tunable devices. Gap-scanning filters Fabry-Perot filter: The air-gap etalon, or Fabry- Perot filter, was introduced in the previous sec- tion. The etalon comprises two plates of glass kept parallel over a small separation where the inner surfaces are mirrors coated with high reflectivity ℜ. The transmission of the etalon to a monochro- matic source λ is given by the Airy function A = (cid:18)1 + 4ℜ (1 − ℜ)2 sin2(2πµℓ cos θ/λ)(cid:19)−1 (3) where θ is the off-axis angle of the incoming ray and µl is the optical gap. The condition for peaks in transmission is given in eqn. 1. Note that λ can be scanned physically in a given order by chang- ing θ (tilt scanning), µ (pressure scanning), or l (gap scanning). Both tilt and pressure scanning suffer from serious drawbacks which limit their dy- namic range. With the advent of servo-controlled, capacitance micrometry, the performance of gap scanning etalons surpasses other techniques. These employ piezo-electric transducers that undergo di- mensional changes in an applied electric field, or develop an electric field when strained mechani- cally. Queensgate Instruments, Ltd. have shown that it is possible to maintain plate parallelism to an accuracy of λ/200 while continuously scanning over several adjacent orders. Fabry-Perot filters have been made with 15 cm apertures and physical scan ranges up to 3 cm. The etalon is ultimately limited by the finite coat- ing thickness between the mirrors, so it really only achieves the lowest interference orders (m < 5) at infrared wavelengths. Solid etalon filter: These are single cavity Fabry- Perot devices with a transparent piezo-electric spacer, e.g. lithium niobate. The thickness and, to a lesser extent, refractive index can be modified by a voltage applied to both faces. For low volt- age systems, tilt and temperature can be used to fine-tune the bandpass. High quality spacers with thicknesses less than a few hundred microns are difficult to manufacture, so that etalon filters are normally operated at high orders of interference. The largest devices we have seen are 5 cm in clear aperture. In the Fourier Transform or Michelson filter: Michelson filter, the collimated beam is split into two paths at the front surface of the beam-splitter. The separate beams then undergo different path lengths by reflections off separate mirrors before being imaged by the camera lens at the detector. The device shown in Fig. 2 uses only 50% of the available light. As Maillard has demonstrated at the Canada France Hawaii Telescope, it is possible to recover this light but the layout is more involved. The output signal is a function of path differ- ence between the mirrors. At zero path difference (or arm displacement), the waves for all frequen- cies interact coherently. As the movable mirror is scanned, each input wavelength generates a series of transmission maxima. Commercially available devices usually allow the mirror to be scanned con- tinuously at constant speed, or to be stepped at equal increments. At a sufficiently large arm dis- placement, the beams lose their mutual coherence. The filter is scanned from zero path length (x = y = 0) to a maximum path length y = L set by twice the maximum mirror spacing (x = L/2). The superposition of two coherent beams with am- plitude b1 and b2 in complex notation is b1+b2ei2πνy where y is the total path difference and ν is the wavenumber. If the light rays have the same inten- sity, the combined intensity is 4b2 cos2 πνy, where b = b1 = b2. The combined beams generate a series of intensity fringes at the detector. If it was possible to scan over an infinite mirror spac- ing at infinitesimally small spacings of the mirror, the superposition would be represented by an ideal Fourier Transform pair, such that b(y) = Z ∞ B(ν) = Z ∞ −∞ −∞ B(ν)(1 + cos 2πνy) dν (4) b(y)(1 + cos 2πνy) dy (5) where b(y) is the output signal as a function of pathlength y and B(ν) is the spectrum we wish to determine. B(ν) and b(y) are both undefined for ν < 0 and y < 0: we include the negative limits for convenience. Note that (6) 1 2 b(y) − 1 2 −∞ −∞ [b(y) − B(ν) cos 2πνy dν b(0)] cos 2πνy dy(7) b(0) = Z ∞ B(ν) = Z ∞ The quantity b(y) − 1 2 b(0) is usually referred to as the interferogram although this term is sometimes used for b(y). The spectrum B(ν) is normally com- puted using widely available Fast Fourier Trans- form methods. The construction of a Michelson filter is a major optomechanical challenge. The ideal Fourier Transform pair is never realized in practice. However, the Michelson filter probably comes closest to achieving the goal of an ideal tun- able filter. The Michelson does not suffer the coating thickness problems of the Fabry-Perot filter, and therefore reaches the lowest orders even at optical wavelengths. Grating filters Resonant grating filter: These novel filters are inspired by the diffractive colours in many in- sects, and constitute dielectric gratings with three- dimensional, sub-micron microstructure. The ze- roth order reflection exhibits a broad to intermedi- ate bandwidth (R ∼ 20), is highly polarized and maintains useful efficiency over a ±30◦ tilt (or ro- tation) range. Gale (1998) presents one grating de- sign that produces a roughly self-similar bandpass from 450 to 850 nm over this tilt range. Grating fil- ters, and their close relatives, evanescent gratings, show great promise but most have yet to leave the drawing board. However, since much of the re- search is driven by bank note security, we antic- ipate rapid progress. Volume phase holographic gratings − in reflection − can produce a highly efficient grating filter through Bragg diffraction. Acousto-optic filter (AOTF): These are electroni- cally tunable filters that make use of acousto-optic (either collinear, or more usefully, non-collinear) diffraction in an optically anisotropic medium. AOTFs are formed by bonding piezo-electric trans- ducers such as lithium niobate to an anisotropic birefringent medium. The medium has tradition- ally been a crystal, but polymers have been devel- oped recently with variable and controllable bire- fringence. When the transducers are excited to 10- 250 MHz (radio) frequencies, the ultrasonic waves vibrate the crystal lattice to form a moving phase pattern that acts as a diffraction grating. The diffraction angle (and therefore wavelength) can be tuned by changing the radio frequency. These devices are often water cooled to assist the ther- mal dissipation, although this is less important in the UV where AOTFs are particularly useful. The largest devices are 2.5 cm in diameter since it proves to be difficult to maintain a uniform acous- tic standing wave over larger areas. An additional problem is the 15µm structure in the LiNO2 crystal which is not always optimal for good image quality. But the acceptance angle of the AOTF is generally larger than the Fabry-Perot. Birefringent Filters The underlying principle of the birefringent filter is that light originating in a single polarization state can be made to interfere with itself. An optically anisotropic, birefringent medium can be used to produce a relative delay between ordinary and ex- traordinary rays aligned along the fast and slow axes of the crystal. (A birefringent medium has two different refractive indices, depending on the plane of light propagation through the medium.) Title and collaborators have discussed at length the relative merits of different types of birefringent filters. The filters are characterised by a series of perfect polarizers (Lyot filter), partial polarizers, or only an entrance and an exit polarizer (Solc filter). The highly anisotropic off-axis behaviour of uniaxial crystals give birefringent filters a ma- jor advantage. Their solid acceptance angle is one to two orders of magnitude larger than is possi- ble with interference filters although this is partly offset by half the light being lost at the entrance polarizer. Lyot filter: This is conceptually the easiest to un- derstand and forms the basis for many variants. The entrance polarizer is oriented 45◦ to the fast and slow axes so that the linearly polarized, ordi- nary and extraordinary rays have equal intensity. The time delay through a crystal of thickness d of one ray with respect to the other is simply d ∆µ/c where ∆µ is the difference in refractive index be- tween the fast and slow axes. The combined beam emerging from the exit polarizer shows intensity variations described by I 2 cos(2πd ∆µ/λ) where I is the wave amplitude. As originally illustrated by Lyot (see Fig. 3), we can isolate an arbitrar- ily narrow spectral band-pass by placing a number of birefringent crystals in sequence where each ele- ment is half the thickness of the preceding crystal. This also requires the use of a polarizer between each crystal so that the exit polarizer for any ele- ment serves as the entrance polarizer for the next. The resolution of the instrument is dictated by the thickness of the thinnest element. With quarter- wave plates placed between each of the retarder el- ements, λ can be tuned over a wide spectral range by rotating the crystal elements. But to retain the transmissions in phase requires that each crystal element be rotated about the optical axis by half the angle of the preceding thicker crystal. Woodgate (NASA Goddard Space Flight Cen- ter) has made a Lyot filter utilising eight quartz retarders with a 10 cm entrance window. The re- tarders, each of which are sandwiched with half- wave and quarter-wave plates in addition to the polarizers, are rotated independently with stepping motors under computer control. They achieve a bandpass of 0.4−0.8 nm tuneable over half the op- tical wavelength range (350−700 nm). Solc1 filter: These highly non-intuitive filters use only two polarizers and a chain of identical re- tarders with varying position angles (Evans 1958). There are folded (zigzag) and fanned designs with the former having the better performance. Title has made a tunable Solc filter with 7 cm clear aper- ture. It has the extraordinary capability of tuning the spectral profile: an n-element Solc filter can have a profile that is determined by n Fourier coef- ficients. The same can be achieved with polarizing filters by proper choice of crystal lengths. Liquid crystal filter (LCTF): These are rapid switching, electronically tuned devices which em- ploy either ferroelectric or nematic liquid crystals (LC). The more commonly used nematic LCTF (Morris, Hoyt & Treado 1994) comprises a series of liquid crystal elements whose thicknesses are cas- caded in the same way as the Lyot filter. However, the tuning is achieved by electronically rotating the crystal axes of the LC waveplate. When no volt- age is applied, the retardance is at a maximum; at large applied voltages, the retardance reaches a minimum. The retardance can be tuned continu- ously to allow the wavelength to be tuned. Liquid crystal filters are now commercially available from Cambridge Research & Instrumen- tation, Inc. The biggest device we have seen has a clear aperture of 4 cm, requires about 5 V to scan a single order of interference, and appears to have good image quality. The tunable band for a single stage device is about R ∼ 5 but can be tuned over the optical window. The peak transmissions are 30% or less. Differential imaging There are many important reasons for pursuing tunable filter imaging, as demonstrated by the TTF since the mid 1990s at the Anglo-Australian 3.9m and William Herschel 4.2m telescopes. Con- ventional imaging has a major limitation in that images are taken sequentially which is not ideal 1The proper Czech pronunciation is 'Sholtz'. Title A M and Rosenberg W J 1981 Tunable bire- fringent filters Opt. Eng. 20 815 -- 823 Vaughan J M 1989 The Fabry-Perot interferom- eter: history, theory, practice and applications (Bristol: Adam Hilger) Figure captions Fig. 1. (i) Interference filter: the internal struc- ture is not shown. (iii) Wedged Fabry-Perot etalon which avoids the prob- lem of the plates behaving like interference filters. (ii) Fabry-Perot etalon. 2. Fig. (Fourier Transform) interferometer. Schematic of a two-beam Michelson Fig. 3. The transmission profile of a simple Lyot cascade with (top to bottom) 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 stages. The thinnest element has retardance R and the following elements have thicknesses which are multiples of this element. The polaroids P are aligned with each other and oriented at 45◦ to the retarders. at even the best sites. Even small detector, in- strument or atmospheric variations lead to system- atic error between images. A better approach is a multi-band camera so that different bands are ob- served in parallel. However, even this is not ideal in that the optical path is different for each fil- ter. A tunable filter provides a powerful alterna- tive since band switching can be linked to charge shuffling with the CCD. This is a truly differential technique which leads to much smaller systematic errors than is possible with conventional imaging. Wide-field imaging Few telescopes offer more than a wide-field imager at prime focus simply because it is very difficult to exploit the fast beam spectroscopically. Spectral passbands are degraded in converging beams which is unfortunate as the widest fields are achieved at the fastest f/ratios. The wide-field expanded Lyot filter is (almost) the last word in exploiting the widest possible field with a given telescope. Re- markably, beams as fast as f/2 can be compen- sated with crossed birefringent elements, in concert with half-wave plates, such that even a constant sub-Angstrom bandpass is possible over a degree- sized field. This opens up many new astronomi- cal programs, e.g. Lyot filters can be vastly more efficient for redshift-targetted surveys of galaxies (e.g. high redshift clusters) compared with existing multi-aperture spectrographs. To our knowledge, a wide-angle Solc filter using half-wave plates has not been attempted although it is entirely feasible. Bibliography & Further Reading Bell R J 1972 Introductory Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (San Diego: Academic Press) Evans J W 1958 The Solc birefringent filter J. Opt. Soc. Amer. 48 142 Gale M T 1998 In Optical document security, R L van Renesse ed. (Artech House) ch 12 Morris H R, Hoyt C C and Treado P J 1994 Imag- ing spectrometers for fluorescent and Raman mi- croscopy: acousto-optic and liquid crystal tunable filters Applied Spectroscopy 48 857 -- 866 Etalon Wedged Etalon ii) l iii) l Filter l i) R I reflective coatings anti-reflective coatings reflective coatings m m m q q Fixed Mirror Compensating Plate Collimator Lens Reflective Coating Movable Mirror Beam Splitter x = 0 x x = L/2 Camera Lens P:R:P P:R:P:2R:P P:R:P:2R:P:4R:P P:R:P:2R:P:4R:P:8R:P P:R:P:2R:P:4R:P:8R:P:16R:P
astro-ph/0509587	1	0509	2005-09-20T14:25:18	Accelerator Testing of the General Antiparticle Spectrometer, a Novel Approach to Indirect Dark Matter Detection	[ "astro-ph" ]	We report on recent accelerator testing of a prototype general antiparticle spectrometer (GAPS). GAPS is a novel approach for indirect dark matter searches that exploits the antideuterons produced in neutralino-neutralino annihilations. GAPS captures these antideuterons into a target with the subsequent formation of exotic atoms. These exotic atoms decay with the emission of X-rays of precisely defined energy and a correlated pion signature from nuclear annihilation. This signature uniquely characterizes the antideuterons. Preliminary analysis of data from a prototype GAPS in an antiproton beam at the KEK accelerator in Japan has confirmed the multi-X-ray/pion star topology and indicated X-ray yields consistent with prior expectations. Moreover our success in utilizing solid rather than gas targets represents a significant simplification over our original approach and offers potential gains in sensitivity through reduced dead mass in the target area.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Accelerator Testing of the General Antiparticle Spectrometer, a Novel Approach to Indirect Dark Matter Detection C J Haileya, T Aramakia, W W Craigb, L Fabrisb, F Gahbauera,d, J E Koglina, N Maddenb, K Moric, H T Yua, K P Ziockb aColumbia Astrophysics Laboratory, Columbia University, New York, NY bLawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA cCanadian Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, Toronto, Canada dUniversity of Latvia, Riga, Latvia E-mail: [email protected] Abstract: We report on recent accelerator testing of a prototype general antiparticle spectrometer (GAPS). GAPS is a novel approach for indirect dark matter searches that exploits the antideuterons produced in neutralino-neutralino annihilations. GAPS captures these antideuterons into a target with the subsequent formation of exotic atoms. These exotic atoms decay with the emission of X-rays of precisely defined energy and a correlated pion signature from nuclear annihilation. This signature uniquely characterizes the antideuterons. Preliminary analysis of data from a prototype GAPS in an antiproton beam at the KEK accelerator in Japan has confirmed the multi-X-ray/pion star topology and indicated X-ray yields consistent with prior expectations. Moreover our success in utilizing solid rather than gas targets represents a significant simplification over our original approach and offers potential gains in sensitivity through reduced dead mass in the target area. The general antiparticle spectrometer (GAPS) is a novel concept for detection of antimatter. As described below it is particularly well suited for antideuteron searches. Antideuterons provide an indirect signature of neutralino annihilation, as first pointed out by Donato and collaborators [1], and a direct signature of black hole evaporation [2]. The operating principles, designs and sensitivity calculations for potential balloon and satellite-based GAPS experiments have been previously reported in Mori et al. [3], but the GAPS concept has not hitherto been demonstrated in a working prototype. We report here interim progress on analyzing a GAPS prototype exposed to an antiproton beam, as well as various beams representative of cosmic backgrounds, at the KEK accelerator facility in Japan. After a discussion of the use of antimatter in dark matter and primordial black hole searches, we briefly summarize recent theoretical studies of antideuteron searches and their relevance to our ongoing experimental program. We then follow with a description of the GAPS concept, the GAPS prototype experiment and analysis and plans for continued experimental work. We note that our preliminary analysis suggests that the GAPS concept is at least as promising as our previous simulations suggested, and thus recent theoretical analyses based on reference [3] remain unaltered by the current experimental landscape. Page 1 of 18 1. Current Approaches to Dark Matter Detection Many searches are underway to identify the particle nature of cold dark matter (CDM). A strong candidate is the type of weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) that arises in supersymmetric theories (SUSY). The neutralino is the lightest supersymmetric partner (LSP) in many models, so much effort has centered on neutralino searches. Currently, the most intensive experimental activities are associated with underground dark matter searches. These searches attempt to detect neutralinos through their direct recoil interactions with target nuclei [4]. Numerous detection schemes are employed including bolometers and solid or liquid scintillators. A primary challenge is to distinguish the recoil signal of the neutralino from that of neutrons produced in muon collisions and by natural radioactivity. A recent review by Ellis et al. [5] reevaluated direct detection in light of revised estimates of the top quark mass and pion-nucleon sigma term, as well as the WMAP precision determination of the CDM density. His conclusion is that the best current experiment, CDMS II, does not probe any of the parameter space of the constrained minimal supersymmetric model (CMSSM) at the 90% confidence level. Thus third generation experiments are already being actively investigated, which aim to provide the several orders of magnitude improvement in sensitivity necessary to probe deeply into the CMSSM parameter space. An alternate approach is to search for indirect signatures of CDM. The processing of the hadronic and leptonic debris of neutralino-neutralino annihilations leads to the generation of many indirect signatures including antiprotons, gamma-rays, positrons and neutrinos. Several experiments have detected indirect signatures suggested to be of CDM origin. A small enhancement in the cosmic positron spectrum was observed by the HEAT experiment [6,7]. This is most likely due to conventional cosmic-ray processes, but neutralino annihilation has been invoked by Kane et al. [8] and Baltz et al. [9]. Recently the diffuse 511 keV halo observed by INTEGRAL has been interpreted as e+e- annihilation radiation produced in dark matter annihilation by Boehm et al. [10] (In this particular case the origin of the CDM would not be associated with a SUSY model though). Next generation neutrino experiments also show some prospects for detecting neutrinos from neutralino annihilation in the sun [11]. Perhaps the most intensively investigated indirect signature is that of antiprotons. The challenge is to distinguish the primary antiprotons produced by neutralino annihilation from the “background” secondary and tertiary antiprotons. Secondary antiprotons are produced in cosmic-ray (CR) collisions with protons in the interstellar medium (ISM). Tertiary antiprotons are produced in CR collisions with helium and through scattering of antiprotons during transport. The disentangling of the primary signal is best done at low energies, but the similarity in the spectral shape of the three components makes this enormously challenging [12,13]. This is made even more complicated by solar modulation and by intrinsic uncertainties in modeling the secondary and tertiary spectrum with sufficient accuracy. The problem is illustrated in figure 1a, where a recent compilation of data is shown with some theoretical models superimposed [14]. The current data at low energies are consistent with CR models and their uncertainties. Future progress requires much more accurate fits to the data. Lionetto, Morselli and Zdravkovic [15] conclude that currently no single, unified model exists which fits all the CR data on antiprotons, positrons and heavier particles as a function of energy. Use of antiprotons to constrain SUSY models in the future depends totally on the ability to model the non-primary antiprotons with much better accuracy. One then looks for small deviations of the model fits to the “background”, which may be indicative of a primary antiproton signal. This is incredibly challenging. It is often overlooked that theoretical papers on CDM searches with antiprotons assume that the CR background will, at some future time, be modeled with precision well-beyond the current situation, e.g., Profumo and Ullio [16]. Nevertheless, antiprotons can be an important signature of dark matter in some SUSY models, so current experimental efforts to reduce measurement uncertainties through design of more sensitive experiments, as well as theoretical efforts to refine CR models, are necessary. Page 2 of 18 Picozza and Morselli (2002) a) F. Donato, N. Fornengo, P. Salati (1999) b) Primary (SUSY) Solar Maximum Secondary (Spallation) 0.5 1.0 TD [GeV/n] 5 10 10-5 10-7 10-9 1 - ] V e G r s s m 10-11 [ D Φ 10-13 10-15 0.1 Figure 1: a) Antiproton absolute flux plotted versus kinetic energy for experimental data and theoretical predictions (replotted from Picozza and Morselli [14]). b) Solar-modulated antideuteron flux plotted versus kinetic energy per nucleon (replotted from Donato et al. [1]). 2. Antideuterons – A Novel Dark Matter Probe A primary antideuteron signal in the CR presents a potential breakthrough approach for CDM searches, as pointed out by Donato et al. [1]. Secondary antideuterons, like antiprotons, are produced through the CR/ISM interaction p + A → antideuteron + X, where A is the target ISM nucleus (mainly hydrogen and helium). But the kinematic threshold for this reaction is much higher and the steep energy spectrum of CR protons means there are less with sufficient energy to produce secondary antideuterons. Thus, as envisioned by Donato et al., a low energy search for primary antideuterons below ~0.5 GeV/n is essentially free of secondary or tertiary antideuteron contamination. This is illustrated in figure 1b. Unlike primary antiproton searches, which involve fitting for small deviations from the non-primary antiproton spectrum, a low energy antideuteron search is a search – the detection of a single antideuteron can signal CDM. Figure 1b suggests that a low energy primary antideuteron search is most promising since the possibility for confusion with secondary and tertiary antideuteron background is minimized there. Donato et al. pointed out that their results were tentative, since they did not consider in detail the effects of low energy scattering on the transport and spectrum of the secondary antideuterons. Recent papers [12] have more carefully examined the transport of secondary antideuterons at low energy. The preliminary conclusion is that the flux of tertiary (non-annihilating, inelastically scattered) antideuterons at low energies is higher than in figure 1b. However we note here that the elevated tertiary antideuteron flux predictions are not as severe a problem as for the corresponding antiproton searches. For the ultra-long duration balloon experiment we envisage, the primary antideuteron detection limit is >~ 20 times higher than the predicted tertiary antideuteron background. Detection of antideuterons in this case means primary antideuterons. Only on the very largest satellite experiments, where sensitivities and observation times are at their maximum, are primary and non-primary antideuterons likely to be confused. However this happens near the bottom of most SUSY parameter spaces. Even this qualification depends on assumptions about the halo model and clumpiness in the halo distribution, each of which sensitively affects primary antideuteron production. 3. Direct Comparisons of Antideuterons with Other Approaches One of the challenges of evaluating approaches to CDM detection is that experimental sensitivities are directly coupled to model dependencies. So comparisons between various detection schemes are only Page 3 of 18 meaningful when evaluated within the context of specific models. Recently a comprehensive analysis of direct versus indirect detection in minimal supergravity (mSUGRA) was presented by Edsjo, Schelke and Ullio [17]. mSUGRA is the easiest and most popular scheme for implementing SUSY breaking. The unequivocal conclusion of this analysis is that antideuterons and direct detection are the best means to search for the neutralino and constrain the mSUGRA parameter space. In some regions of parameter space the antideuteron is the only viable search approach, and it maintains sensitivity to very high neutralino mass. In other parameter regions antideuterons are competitive with direct detection and with indirect searches using neutrinos produced in neutralino annihilations in the sun. There are more complicated SUSY models which relax one or more of the technical assumptions of the simple mSUGRA models or CMSSM. Recent papers have emphasized the power of antideuterons in these models as well. An example is the recent work of Profumo and Ullio [16] which considered a model with WIMP relic abundance enhancement in three benchmark scenarios. Using published sensitivity curves for a satellite-based GAPS experiment [3] these authors concluded that the neutralino could be detected in all three of their benchmarks (mSUGRA funnel, non-universal gaugino (NUGM) and minimal anomaly-mediated SUSY breaking (AMSB)). Although they did not mention it, even a balloon-based GAPS could detect the neutralino in the first benchmark and depending on the assumed halo CDM distribution, with modest density enhancements in the latter two benchmarks as well. Masiero, Profumo and Ullio [18] has also considered antideuteron constraints on a split-SUSY model. The conclusion is that antideuterons are crucial for neutralino searches in part of this parameter space, antiprotons are best in another part and accelerator-based work will probe none of the parameter space (because of the heaviness of squarks in these models). Within the CMSSM model there is considerable complementarity between underground dark matter searches and antideuteron searches. In fact, even an ultra-long duration balloon GAPS can cover regions of the CMSSM space which are inaccessible to third generation direct detection experiments such as XENON or GENIUS. This has been considered in some detail elsewhere [3]. For most of the SUSY models under current investigation, antideuterons are a powerful and versatile means to hunt for dark matter. In several of the references described above, there are parts of parameter space where antiprotons provide very strong dark matter signatures. However, as noted above, this will require extremely delicate extrication of the signal from the secondary and tertiary antiproton background. At any rate, antiprotons would be detected by a GAPS experiment as a byproduct of an antideuteron search, with sensitivities more than an order of magnitude higher than previously obtained [3]. 4. Antideuterons and Primordial Black Holes There are a variety of potential probes to search for primordial black holes (PBH): gravitational waves, gamma-rays, UHE particles, neutrinos. A recent theoretical analysis by Barrau et al. [2] indicated that antideuterons will ultimately provide the most stringent bounds on PBH density, orders of magnitude better than antiprotons and gamma-rays While antiprotons are emitted by PBH, conventional CR models already give good fits to cosmic antiproton spectra. However, we note that a small excess of low-energy antiprotons in the BESS data has been fit with a PBH model [19]. While not yet competitive with antiprotons, it is notable that the first upper limit on PBH evaporation using antideuterons has recently been presented by the BESS team [20]. Barrau et al. analyzed the ability of both AMS/ISS and a satellite GAPS to constrain PBH density. They parameterized their results in terms of both the poorly constrained diffusive halo size and the coalescence momentum (a parameter relevant to the formation of antideuterons in hadron showers). AMS/ISS would be able to improve on current PBH density limits by ~100 times and GAPS by ~1000 times. The superior GAPS limit results from higher effective grasp (area-solid angle product) and its operation at lower energies where tertiary antideuterons are less of a problem. As we will discuss in a subsequent paper this conclusion is only slightly weakened when the results of [12] on low energy antideuteron transport are taken into account. Page 4 of 18 5. Operating Concept of the General Antiparticle Spectrometer The favorable spectral properties of signal and background in figure 1b come at a price; the flux of primary antideuterons is miniscule. While this flux is clearly model dependent, for experiment search times of months to years the proper order of magnitude of the grasp of an experiment is >~ 1-2 m2-sr. This is to be compared with current premier magnetic spectrometer experiments such as BESS-Polar, AMS/ISS, and PAMELA, which have smaller grasps by approximately a factor of 10 [21]. In addition it is not feasible to scale up the magnetic spectrometers for next generation searches for CDM. For balloon and space-based experiments BESS and AMS likely represent the ultimate performance achievable given the respective mass limits. GAPS was developed as a next generation antimatter detector. In Mori et al. [3] there is a detailed discussion of the atomic physics of GAPS, its design optimization and sensitivity calculations for various experiments. The interested reader is referred to this paper for a more extensive discussion. Below we describe the basic operating principles in just enough detail to elucidate the issues which must be addressed in prototype development. A cartoon of the GAPS concept is shown in figure 2. An antiparticle first passes through a time of flight (TOF) system which measures velocity and hence energy after subsequent particle identification. It is then slowed down by dE/dx losses in a degrader block. The thickness of this block is tuned to select the sensitive energy range of the detector. The antiparticle is stopped in a target, forming an excited, exotic atom with probability of order unity. The exotic atom deexcites through both autoionizing transitions and radiation producing transitions. Through proper selection of target materials and geometry, the absorption of the antiparticle can be tailored to produce three or more well-defined X-rays in the cascade to the ground state. The target is selected such that the X-rays have energies in the 20-200 keV range so that the X-rays can escape with low losses and be efficiently detected in common X-ray detectors. After the emission of the X-rays the antiparticle annihilates in the nucleus producing a shower (star) of pions. The X-ray/pion emission takes place within nanoseconds. The fast timing coincidence between the characteristic decay X-rays of precisely known energy (dependent only on antiparticle mass and charge) and the energy deposition induced by the pion star is an extremely clean antiparticle signature. The GAPS concept is only feasible at extremely low energies (<~ 0.3 GeV/n), where particles can be ranged out with low mass degraders (essential for balloon or satellite missions where low mass is paramount). The advantage of GAPS is that for mass comparable to magnetic spectrometers it can obtain an order of magnitude more grasp. The probability of false particle identification can be reduced to 1 part in 1012 or better. Figure 2: The operating principal of the GAPS detector using antiprotons as an example. Page 5 of 18 6. GAPS Crucial Design Issues In [3] a number of designs were presented for antideuteron experiments. The designs were based on experimental and theoretical results from the literature concerning X-ray deexcitation in exotic atoms. While the results rested on a strong physics foundation, in reality no one has ever developed a detector whose specific purpose was to simultaneously measure the energies of atomic deexcitation X-rays and detect the pion star too. Moreover, while there is a wealth of data on exotic atom X-ray physics, it is often in forms not directly useful for astrophysical instrument design. For instance, X-ray transitions were measured in many gases, but not simultaneously, or they were measured for X-ray transitions whose energies were too low to be of interest in a practical detector. Consequently it was decided to build a prototype whose purpose would be to measure key parameters of interest to an astrophysical instrument designer, not an atomic physicist. To this end we discuss here some of the key design issues that were deemed necessary to address in a prototype experiment at an accelerator. Proper target selection is the key to GAPS design. The number of simultaneously detected X-rays, together with their energies and transition yields, drive the entire design and ultimate sensitivity of the instrument. In particular our original work considered only designs with gas targets. This was because the most detailed measurements of exotic atom processes were in gases. However our prototype work, as described below, has encompassed gas, liquid and solid foil/powder/aerogel targets. The issues in gas targets are simple. The relevant atomic physics is somewhat involved but well- understood both theoretically and experimentally [3]. High pressure (~10-30 atmospheres) is required to achieve adequate antiparticle stopping power, but must be limited in order to avoid Stark mixing which will lower the X-ray transition yields by causing non-radiative transitions. The gases nitrogen, oxygen, neon and argon are all acceptable candidates [3]. These gases are all transparent to their own ladder X-rays at appropriate design pressures. Prior to our first accelerator test (hereafter KEK04) we expanded our list to include organic gases. Higher molecular weight targets translate directly into lower requisite operating pressure. In KEK04 we operated both a nitrogen and an ethyl hexafluoride target (C2F6). Solid targets represent an attractive option for GAPS, since they do not require gas handling systems and the ensuing dead mass. Originally we looked at liquid and solid targets. But despite materials of high X-ray yield, we could not couple out the lowest energy X-rays of interest without large self-absorption. Thus we focused on gas targets. Our interest in solids was rekindled with an investigation of low density carbon aerogel targets, which were employed at KEK04. Following this success we revisited solid targets, reviewing work carried out in the 1970s by Wiegand and Godfrey [22]. Simulations suggested that their foil target geometries, along with “wool” targets, were very attractive, providing substantial increases in X-ray detection efficiency. Thus our KEK05 run (see below) focused on foil and wool targets, as well as organic liquid targets chosen so that the X-ray transitions of interest were high enough energy to avoid self-absorption. The successful demonstration of these non-gaseous targets greatly eases the design challenge of GAPS. In addition to confirming potential target materials, the accelerator experiments had several other goals. One goal was a measurement of the effective X-ray yield. As discussed in [3], a number of processes can interrupt the ladder deexcitation of the exotic atom, leading to missing X-rays. Antiparticle identification is predicated on identification of a specific number of X-rays of known energy. If those X-rays are missing, then an antiparticle will be miscategorized as background. Thus any inefficiency in production of the relevant ladder X-rays is an effective reduction in antiparticle detection efficiency, and thus sensitivity. A key goal of the experiments was also to gather data on event topology for both antiparticles and potential cosmic background. An antiproton event produces three or more X-rays along with a pion star of ~4-5 pions equally divided among charge states. The pion star can provide valuable added information for confirming the presence of an antiparticle. Use Page 6 of 18 of the pion star topology was not considered in our original sensitivity calculations. It is equally important to understand background event topologies when analyzing rare events. Thus we took data with protons, pions and muons in order to understand details of discriminating such particle interactions in the target from antiparticle interactions. We note for thoroughness that the primary source of false antiparticle identifications is not due to particle interactions directly, but rather an accidental coincidence between a particle trigger and X-ray and beta-particles generated from cosmic- ray activation of the X-ray detector [3]. In a subsequent paper we will describe in much more detail how one analyzes real GAPS data, based on the accelerator experiments and simulations. In particular the copious antiproton flux will provide an excellent internal calibration set for verification of antideuteron detection. For thoroughness we mention some key aspects of GAPS which are not addressed in accelerator testing. Antideuterons, like antiprotons, can annihilate as they slow down in matter prior to their capture into an exotic atom. However antideuterons have unique loss modes such as Coulomb annihilation [23] and the Oppenheimer-Phillips process [24]. As noted in Hailey et al. [25] we explicitly account for these loss modes in our sensitivity calculations, along with more common loss modes such as direct disintegration. These losses are not significant, but this is by design; the overall amount of material employed for stopping antideuterons, and thus the energy acceptance, is ultimately restricted by such effects. The lack of a slow antideuteron beam anywhere in the world necessitates the following strategy for GAPS. We verify all the basic atomic physics of GAPS with antiprotons. As described in Mori et al. [3] and references therein, the scaling of the relevant atomic physics to antideuterons is only through the particle mass. The antideuteron pion star differs from the antiproton one only in the number of emitted pions. The losses of antideuterons are handled by explicit calculation, as described above. While the new JAERI facility in Japan may ultimately have a slow antideuteron capability [26], realistically the first antideuterons detected by GAPS are likely to be in space. The presence of nuclear deexcitation gamma-rays is the only difference between antideuterons and antiprotons that cannot be explicitly accounted for by antiproton measurements or modeling. These arise in the daughter nuclei produced in the antiparticle annihilation of the nucleus of the exotic atom, as first noted by Barnes et al. [27]. As we discuss below, these gamma-rays are an unexpected benefit for background rejection. 7. Accelerator Testing of a GAPS Prototype: Experiment Goals A GAPS prototype was tested at the KEK accelerator facility in Tsukuba, Japan. This followed approval at KEK of two separate proposals. One run took place in April 2004, and following an upgrade to the experiment another run took place in May 2005. The following were the goals for prototype testing and all were accomplished or are in process: • detect simultaneous ladder X-rays and pion annihilation stars, • characterize event topologies and compare with simulations, • test an organic gas target of high molecular weight and one “baseline” gas as listed in [3], • test a liquid target; test solid aerogel, powder, foil and wool targets, • evaluate GAPS under exposure to particle background (e.g., protons, pions, muons, electrons etc.). 8. Experimental Setup To create antiprotons, protons must be accelerated to many GeV in energy at particle accelerator facilities. From the interaction of the accelerated protons on a target material, particle-antiparticle pairs are sometimes created including proton-antiproton pairs. These particles are collected and transported to user research areas through secondary beamlines composed of dipole and quadrupole magnets that are used to guide and focus the particles. The secondary beamline delivers the particles in a well-defined beam envelope that can be simulated with a beamline optics program such as TRANSPORT [27]. The size and divergence of the beam in the horizontal and vertical directions as well as the spread in momentum of the particles can be calculated at any point along the beamline. Page 7 of 18 The experiment was performed using the Pi2 secondary beamline of the 8 GeV proton synchrotron at KEK. The beam is steered and focused into the experimental area by means of four quadrupole and three dipole magnets, the first of which defines the momentum. The beam structure is relatively flat with a 4 second spill repetition and a 1.5 second spill length. The characteristics of the Pi2 beamline present unique challenges that drive the design of the experiment. The Pi2 beamline is unseparated such that copious quantities of kaons, pions and electrons are transported to the experimental area along with antiprotons. Pions are the dominant background event type with four orders of magnitude higher rate than the antiprotons. A momentum of 1 GeV/c was chosen to optimize antiproton flux (which increases steeply up to ~2 GeV/c) and losses within a degrader that is required to slow down the beam to appropriate momentum for stopping in GAPS. Most of the antiprotons either undergo direct in-flight annihilation within the degrader (producing electromagnetic showers) or are scattered directly into the GAPS detector such that only a fraction of the original antiprotons are actually stopped in the target (estimated to be only 0.2% of the antiprotons entering the Pi2 experimental area based on TRANSPORT and GEANT4 [28] simulations). In this way, the background to signal in GAPS is >105. This challenging experimental environment is in contrast to a space-based experiment where the antiparticles have much lower energy and require only a thin degrader. Further, the goal of these experiments is not only to identify antiproton events, but also to accurately measure the individual X-ray transition yields. The experimental setup is illustrated in figure 3. The detectors highlighted in green and labeled from above were added for the KEK05 run to provide additional information to more accurately normalize event types and rates. Since all of the particles initially have the same momentum, they can be identified by time of flight (TOF) due to their difference in mass. After entering the Pi2 experimental area, particles are tracked through the P0 and P2 plastic scintillator counters separated by 5.5 m. The timing coincidence of these counters was used as the event trigger for the detector electronics, with the TOF between providing particle identification. The extra beam counter P1 was added for the 2005 measurement to aid in identifying accidental events through TOF consistency. Only timing information was recorded for P0-P2. Figure 3: KEK Experimental Setup. The detectors labeled from above and highlighted in green are new for the 2005 experiment. The P3 and P4 counters provide redundant timing and energy deposit information to tag the antiprotons which have survived passage through the degrader and enter the target. The P5 counter is used to veto antiprotons that did not stop in the target. Both timing and energy information was recorded for the P3-P5 counters. The second half of the degrader was upgraded to an active degrader for the 2005 measurement. In this way, the S1-S4 plastic scintillators interspersed with lead form a shower counter used to confirm the passage of a valid antiproton through its unique dE/dx loss Page 8 of 18 signature. This significantly limits the chance of misidentifying the shower of pions and electrons (in addition to photons and neutrons) produced from direct antiproton annihilation as valid stopped antiproton events. As a further upgrade for the 2005 measurement, six charged particle veto counters (V1-V6) consisting of thin scintillating fiber bundles were added in front of the scintillator crystals to completely surround the target cell. These counters identify beam particles that scatter directly into the crystals. Energy information only was recorded for the S1-S4 shower counters and V1-V6 veto counters. In each case, the intention of the upgrades for the 2005 measurement was to provide a more reliable event tag in order to more accurately extract the X-ray transition yields and characterize background processes. The target has a cylindrical geometry (12 cm diameter, 48 cm length) appropriate to a beamline experiment, as opposed to a flight GAPS which would employ a cubic geometry [3]. The GAPS detector and ancillary electronics are shown in figure 4a and a photograph of the GAPS detector with the gas target installed for the 2004 measurements is shown in figure 4b. Sets of 2x4 NaI crystals (25mm diameter, 5 mm thick) are housed in 16 panels arranged in a hexagonal array. Each of the 128 crystals is coupled to a Hamamatsu RM1924a photomultiplier tube (PMT). The system achieves sufficient energy resolution to resolve the X-ray transitions of interest and 200 ns time resolution for coincidence rejection of background. The level of detector segmentation was chosen to balance cost with the desire to limit the occurrence of multiple X-rays or annihilation products entering the same crystal (<3% for typical GAPS event). The solid angle coverage of the detector (35% for an average event) is limited by the open ended cylindrical geometry required for the beam entrance and exit in addition to the dead space due to NaI crystal packing inefficiencies. A custom 128-channel data acquisition system was constructed to directly handle signals from the NaI detector phototubes. The pulse processing system is built around a gated integrator with a parallel fast channel. A discriminator in the fast channel recognizes an event and initiates the signal processing cycle. The charge from the PMT is integrated and digitized with a low power, 16 bit ADC. The system can be operated either with an external trigger (e.g., based on the TOF trigger in the KEK experiment) or in a self-triggered mode where each channel is read out every time a signal is recognized (e.g., the mode used for energy calibration of the crystals using a radioactive source). The system also digitizes 32 extra ADC channels for the timing and energy deposit of the trigger counters and records 16 logic signals for each event trigger. A fast PCI interface is used to perform high-speed data transfer between the electronics and a personal computer, and the entire system can sustain a rate of over 100 kHz per channel. The total power consumption for the data acquisition system is 150 W. Figure 4: a) Schematic of the GAPS detector. b) Photograph of the GAPS instrument with the gas target. 9. Experimental Conditions Since the rates of antiprotons are low, the beam was set up using protons (105 protons per spill). This is possible because the beamline magnets behave identically with reversed polarity. The focus at the target and the thickness of the lead degrader (~10 cm) were optimized to maximize the number of Page 9 of 18 proton stops in the target (and hence stopped antiprotons as verified by GEANT simulations). The beam focus was optimized by changing an individual magnet setting in small steps over a broad range in values, measuring the proton and beam monitor signals for five seconds and setting the magnet to the value at which the maximum proton signal was obtained. Degrader range curves were performed by incrementally increasing the degrader thickness and recording the event rates in each counter. These experimental range curves were found to be in good agreement with detailed GEANT4 calculations, and the thickness for antiproton operation was set accordingly. Event data from a +1 GeV/c run after the beamline was set up are displayed in figure 5a where the TOF between P0 and P2 is plotted versus the TOF between P0 and P1. Here, the highly relativistic pions, muons and positrons (all with β ≅ 1 and hence referred to as MIP’s – minimum ionizing particles) are clearly distinguished from the protons. There are approximately equal numbers protons and MIP’s in each spill. A similar plot for -1 GeV/c data is plotted in figure 5b. The antiproton rate is approximately 25 per spill (the actual rate varied somewhat over the duration of our measurements due to changes in the overall rate and status of the KEK proton synchrotron). This is to be compared with a rate of ~1.5x105 per spill for negatively charged MIP’s. Since the antiprotons are suppressed by a factor of nearly 104, our event trigger (based on P2-P0 TOF) was prescaled by a factor of 0.015 for the relativistic particles. In this way, all of the antiproton events were recorded to disc in addition to a sample of all other events for use in background studies. In each of these plots, the P2-P0 timing cut (P2-P0 < 2 ns, highlighted by yellow) is the only timing information that was available in the 2004 measurements. A significant amount of accidental background (e.g., one particle triggering the P0 counter and different particle triggering the P2 counter) is rejected with the addition of the P1 counter, which allows for the additional P1-P0 timing cut (P1-P0 < 2 ns, highlighted by pink). 15 15 a) b) 10 5 0 -5 ) 0 P - 1 P ( F O T Prescaled (0.015) P 10 5 0 -5 Accidental _ P π+, µ+ , e+ -10 -15 -10 π-, µ- , e- -10 -15 -10 10 Accidental 0 5 -5 TOF (P2-P0) 5 0 -5 TOF (P2-P0) 10 Figure 5: TOF from P0 to P1 is plotted versus TOF from P0 to P2 for +1 GeV/c particles in a) and -1 GeV/c particles in b). The protons and antiprotons are highlighted by the TOF cuts in a) and b), respectively. The P1 counter allows for the additional horizontal cut (pink) that suppresses accidental background that is present with only the P2-P0 TOF cut (vertical yellow band). Based on the timing information, the energy deposited in the S1-S4 and P3-P5 counters was normalized using the proton range curve data (which provides particles exiting the degrader into these counters with a broad range of momentum, and hence energy deposition). While the energy resolution of is good energy separation between there in not exceptional, the plastic scintillators protons/antiprotons and the other particles, which are all essentially MIP’s. Further, the redundant nature of these counters provides added assurance in making proper event identification. Even without the aid of the P1 and S1-S4 counters in KEK04, good event identification was achieved because the Page 10 of 18 accidental events are all MIP’s with a much smaller energy deposit (~2 MeV for MIP’s instead of ~10 MeV for antiprotons) in P3 and P4 as well as a slight timing difference. The V1-V6 and P5 counters are used to veto antiproton events that exit the target without stopping. Since stopped antiparticles produce exotic atoms with nearly unity probability, the event identification power of our setup provides good normalization of the subsequent X-ray transition yields. The following targets were used during the two runs; C2F6 (gas), N2 (gas), C (aerogel), Al, S, CCl4 (liquid) and CBr4. The sulfur and carbon tetrabromide were powders which were put in three elliptical containers tipped at 45 degrees to the beamline. This is basically the geometry of Wiegand [22]. The aluminum was in the form of “wool” placed in a low density cylinder. The gases were held in a thin- walled (<1mm) carbon-fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) cylinder at a pressure of 10 atmospheres. Ten atmospheres is somewhat below nominal operating pressure for a GAPS experiment [3], but high enough pressure to probe the potential effects of Stark mixing on expected X-ray yield. The CFRP pressure vessel was designed to operate (and successfully tested) at 40 atmospheres, but KEK safety procedures precluded operation at that pressure in these runs. Typical target thicknesses were ~7 g/cm2, chosen to provide good stopping power and X-ray transparency. In this way, antiprotons entering the target with kinetic energy less than 100 MeV would be captured in GAPS. The primary experiments were performed with beam momentum of -1 GeV/c. In addition to antiprotons, data runs were made using a proton beam and negative pion beams with energies between 0.2 and 1.2 GeV since these particles are a background source in space-based experiments. Runs were also made with antiprotons at -1 GeV/c in configurations with GAPS but no degrader and with a degrader but no target in GAPS. This data will allow precise characterization of background event topologies in GAPS for comparison with simulations. Below we present some very preliminary analysis which demonstrates, for the first time, the simultaneous detection of multiple ladder transition X-rays and pion stars, thus verifying the basic GAPS concept. A much fuller analysis will be presented in subsequent papers. However the results of even this preliminary analysis confirm the basic assumption about GAPS performance, which were based on previous sensitivity calculations [3]. Antiprotons were successfully identified in an environment with S/B of ~10-5. The detectors external to GAPS comprised the shower, timing and scintillating fiber veto counters shown in figure 3. These detectors provide a detailed means to identify each particle entering and/or stopping in GAPS with extremely high fidelity. However it is crucial to note that our off-line analysis has enabled us to identify each stopped antiproton directly through its unique X-ray and pion star signature, with no recourse to these external detectors. 10. Experimental Results A variety of solid, liquid and gas targets were used in KEK04 and KEK05, as described above. Since the goal of this paper is simply to present some preliminary data indicating that the basic concept is sound, we restrict our discussion to just a few of these targets. More importantly, the primary goal was to evaluate candidate targets for real space experiments. In that regard high molecular weight organic gases are superior to nitrogen – our original baseline target - because of better stopping power and higher effective X-ray yield. Carbon aerogel is superior to gases (for engineering design reasons), and all the solid and liquid targets of KEK05 are superior to Carbon aerogel (because the 3rd X-ray transition of interest is at higher energy and thus is detected with higher efficiency). So the experimental program has already led to an evolution of the GAPS concept away from gases. During the time in which we ran with an ethyl hexafluoride (C2F6) target, approximately 1500 exotic atoms were formed. A histogram of all X-rays detected in this target is plotted in figure 6a. The X-ray spectrum with the target removed is also plotted (1.5 hours equivalent data scaled to the 31 hours of ethyl hexafluoride data). Based on the ambient X-ray background spectrum and total rate (~10 X-rays/sec/crystal), the total accidental X-rays in the triggered antiproton data is ~100 X-rays. The data set can be corrected for the number of accidentals in each X-ray line of interest. Both GEANT4 and separate Monte-Carlo simulations were used to determine the expected count rate in the X-ray lines. These calculations take into account the triggered antiproton rate on target, the efficiency Page 11 of 18 of detector and electronics and an assumed effective X-ray yield. We expect to see somewhere on the order of 100 X-rays in each exotic transition. This is a preliminary estimate and is comparable to observations. More detailed analysis is ongoing. A comparable calculation to this was performed for each of the targets. The effective X-ray yields, even based on preliminary calculations with a factor of ~2 uncertainty, are consistent with the assumption about X-ray yield in [3]. This is to be expected. While the antiprotonic X-ray yield has only been measured in a limited number of elements (such as nitrogen, the original GAPS baseline), the antiprotonic yields are expected to be comparable to those measured in kaonic exotic atoms, where yields have been measured for all elements and many compounds. We selected targets all known to have kaonic X-ray yields in excess of 30%, some even larger than 50%. Analysis is underway to directly compare the X-ray yield of our targets as a function of Z with Fermi-Teller theory, as has been done extensively for kaonic atoms. 1000 NaI Energy [keV] b) a) Beam Direction 38 π* 86 800 600 400 200 0 0 50 100 150 200 250 NaI Energy Deposit [keV] 300 33 Figure 6: a) Histogram of X-rays for C2F6 target. The X-ray spectrum with the target removed is also plotted. b) GAPS event topology in the C2F6 gas target for a 3 X-ray and a charged pion star tag (π). In addition to these transition X-rays, we expect to see other energy deposits associated with annihilation of the antiproton in the nucleus, as described earlier. Charged and neutral pions are emitted during the annihilation. The charged pions leave an enormous amount of energy as they pass through the NaI crystal (~ 2 MeV) and are recorded as a pion star signal (π). Because the nominal X- ray ladder transitions in ethyl hexafluoride are well-below 100 keV, resolving the X-ray lines in the integrated spectrum is not possible. However on an event by event basis the GAPS event topology provides a clear indication that an antiproton has stopped in the gas. Figure 6b shows an antiproton stop which produces three X-rays at the proper energy along with a charged pion, all in time coincidence. This is a signature of an antiproton annihilation. Here, as in all the events presented below, the experiment trigger as defined in section 9 independently confirms that the event in question really is an antiproton, as the topology indicates. Accurate measurement of X-ray transition energies is important for identifying valid antiproton events. During KEK04 X-ray calibrations with check sources (americium and barium) were run every hour over the entire NaI array. This data was used to correct for temperature drifts (diurnal temperature changes in the experimental hall were as large as 25C). Temperature conditions were more stable in KEK05 requiring less frequent X-ray calibrations. The KEK05 run emphasized solid targets, based on the promising results obtained with Carbon aerogel in KEK04. The most interesting target is carbon tetrabromide (CBr4). Carbon tetrabromide produces up to seven X-ray ladder transitions within the high detection efficiency bandwidth of a thin NaI crystal, many at higher energies. The background rejection power of GAPS goes like (∆E∆τ)n, where ∆E is the energy resolution, ∆τ the system time resolution and n the number of detected X-rays. The minimum required for antideuteron searches is n=3 (c.f., [3], where typically n=3 for gases). Page 12 of 18 Moreover the sensitivity of GAPS is dominated by the lowest energy X-ray, which has the lowest probability of escaping to the target. Thus X-rays of higher energy are most beneficial for GAPS. All the solid and liquid targets investigated can provide three or more X-rays where the lowest X-ray has higher energy than in any of the gases considered in [3] or the targets of KEK04. Figure 7a shows a carbon tetrabromide integrated X-ray spectrum. This spectrum was produced solely using cut criteria intrinsic to GAPS. In this case the cut required more than two ladder X-ray transitions and more than four total energy deposits. The spectrum of figure 7a clearly shows the bromine X-rays (whose capture probability is large compared to the carbon). Again correcting for accidentals, the X-ray ladder transition rates are consistent with high effective X-ray yield – comparable to those in the corresponding kaonic system. More detailed analysis is underway. There are several unidentified lines above ~170 keV in bromine and other solid target spectra. Preliminary analysis suggests these are the nuclear excitation lines associated with the daughter nuclei produced in antiproton annihilation of the nucleus, as first observed by Barnes [29]. We were unaware of the existence of such lines until the KEK experiments, and did not consider their potential salutary impact on the sensitivity and particle identification capability of GAPS in our original analysis. These lines, at well-defined energies, can serve to augment the atomic X-ray ladder transitions. Because these nuclear lines are all at higher energies, they are particularly useful because they easily escape the target. 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 a) 52 31,40 99 71 145 b) NaI Energy [keV] 248 153 Beam Direction Charged Veto [MeV] 74 99 223 50 100 150 200 250 300 X-ray Energy [keV] Time [ns] E [MeV] P1 0.7 P2 0.7 S1 S2 S3 3.1 3.8 5.8 S4 7.6 P3 0.8 5.4 P4 0.3 7.6 Target P5 Figure 7: a) The carbon tetrabromide (CBr4) integrated X-ray spectrum for events with ≥2 ladder X- ray transitions and ≥4 total energy deposits. b) An example of a four ladder X-ray event. Figure 7b shows the signature of a carbon tetrabromide antiproton annihilation. Four ladder X-rays are cleanly identified but there are no associated nuclear annihilation pions. Given that the mean number of pions per annihilation is approximately five, this at first seems striking. However the solid angle coverage of our prototype GAPS is rather modest at ~0.3. In addition any neutral pions will decay immediately to gamma-rays with very small probability of energy deposit in our thin crystals. Thus the existence of such events is expected in the prototype. Figure 7b also shows how we are able to confirm, independently of the GAPS event signature, that the event was induced by an antiproton. The boxes surrounding the segmented crystal display give data on the upstream and downstream diagnostics. In particular, displays P1-P4 for the plastic scintillators indicate the timing deviation at each piece of plastic compared to that expected for an antiproton. In each case the timing deviation is within the timing resolution of the system (~1 ns). The counters S1-S4 show the monotonic increase Page 13 of 18 in deposited energy whose magnitude in each counter is consistent with that expected for slowing down of an antiproton of proper incident momentum. And finally there is no signal in the downstream plastic P5 (indicating a stop in GAPS) and no signal in the scintillating fiber veto inside GAPS which would indicate an antiproton which elastically scattered out of the target cell. Elastically scattered antiprotons can be identified by the signatures they produce on capture and annihilation in the NaI itself. The integrated spectrum for a sulfur target is shown in figure 8a using the same energy cuts as in figure 7a. Figure 8b shows an event where two ladder X-rays are detected along with three annihilation pions. These events are of particular interest to us in our current analysis. The original analysis of Mori et al. [3], while recognizing the existence of the annihilation pions, did not explicitly consider them in calculating the particle identification capability of GAPS. However it is quite clear that when combined with a few ladder X-rays, the pions are an extremely powerful additional means to identify antiparticle stops. In fact the pions, because their stopping power allows them to penetrate several detection cells of the cubic geometry, provide a tremendous opportunity to use GAPS as a tracking/timing chamber to help identify antiparticles. The original GAPS analysis of flight configurations did consider the potential value of higher energy ladder X-rays which Compton scatter in one target cell and then are photoelectrically absorbed in another. But the pions are likely to be an even more powerful tool for enhancing the X-ray signature or making up for the loss of a ladder X-ray. Note that unlike the event of figure 7b, the event in figure 8b has an associated signal in the charged particle veto. The magnitude of the energy deposits is indicative of an annihilation pion transit, not antiproton scatter in the target. a) b) NaI Energy [keV] Charged Veto [MeV] 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 76 139 Page 14 of 18 Beam Direction 147 π* π* 83 π* 1.6 0.3 0.4 0.3 P5 46 30 50 100 150 200 250 300 X-ray Energy [keV] P1 P2 -0.2 -0.1 Time [ns] E [MeV] S1 S2 S3 S4 P3 P4 0.0 -0.2 5.2 5.2 Target 2.9 2.7 3.2 2.5 Figure 8: a) The Sulfur integrated X-ray spectrum for events with ≥2 ladder X-ray transitions and ≥4 total energy deposits. b) An example of a two ladder X-ray event. As a final example of the type of data obtained in the KEK runs, figure 9 shows an event whose topology is consistent with being an antiproton scattered in the GAPS detector. No energy deposit is consistent with a ladder transition, and the topology of a track moving through multiple crystals is present. This indicates a non-annihilating, charged particle. This is confirmed independently by upstream and downstream counters which indicate an antiproton entered GAPS and was scattered into the NaI array (evidently at an oblique angle). All the scattered antiprotons have readily identifiable topologies. 246 π* 1 1 π* P1 0.2 π* Time [ns] E [MeV] NaI Energy [keV] Charged Veto [MeV] 15.3 Beam Direction 187 π* >300 π* 0.3 4.9 P2 0.3 S1 S2 S3 2.8 2.7 4.2 S4 3.6 P3 0.3 5.9 P4 0.0 5.4 Target P5 Figure 9: Antiproton scattered into GAPS detector. Although not presented here, considerable data was also taken with protons, pions and muons to provide basic data to assist in estimating the probability of particle misidentification. For example, we reversed the polarity of the beam magnets and recorded approximately the same number of proton triggers as antiprotons for each target. In the ethyl hexafluoride data set, for instance, the X-ray event rate is significantly less than for antiprotons, and no multiple X-ray events were ever produced, much less a three or four signature event. This is consistent with computer simulations. Much more on this will be reported elsewhere. Another cross-check was to add 2 cm of extra lead to the degrader to stop all of the antiprotons before they enter the target, but not other beam related background. No multiple- signature events were recorded in this data set. These results, while comforting, are not unexpected. Previous modeling [3] suggests that the primary source of particle misidentification in GAPS will be caused by simultaneous energy deposits (X-rays and beta particles) resulting from cosmic-ray activation of the detector and surrounding material (in coincidence with a TOF trigger). Nevertheless it is reassuring that preliminary analysis shows that the particle background is indeed unable to produce a problematic false signature. 11. Experimental Implications and Future Directions for GAPS The most important result of the KEK04 and KEK05 runs was to verify the basic GAPS concept. Simultaneous atomic ladder X-ray transitions and pion stars have been used, for the first time, to specifically identify antiparticles. GAPS provided near unity efficiency in identifying antiproton stops. These results were confirmed with a completely independent array of experiment detectors which identify particles, by type, which stop in GAPS. Two results of great importance to future design work were obtained. Firstly, solid (and liquid) targets have been successfully utilized. This enormously simplifies the design challenges of GAPS. With no need for high pressure gas, as in the original concept, GAPS is easier to operate and it is lighter and more efficient because of the removal of the dead mass of the gas handling system. GAPS efficiency also increases because solid and liquid targets provide more design options. Gas targets must be both transparent to their ladder X-rays and immune to Stark mixing at high gas pressure. These were restrictive conditions given the limited number of gas candidates. Solid and liquid targets permit more choices where there are both more ladder X-rays in the detector bandpass and X-rays of higher mean energy. This translates directly into higher sensitivity, since loss of X-rays and particularly the lowest energy X-ray (the hardest to get out of the target and into the detector) Page 15 of 18 dominates the sensitivity of GAPS. And secondly, the preliminary estimate of effective X-ray yield gives numbers consistent with the >~30% used in the original GAPS sensitivity calculations. Our conclusion from the experiments is that the GAPS concept is sound and that the sensitivity numbers of Mori et al. [3] are basically correct. Thus the theoretical implications of a GAPS experiment, discussed in numerous papers, will not be meaningfully altered when exact effective X-ray yields are produced from our detailed analysis. Two other results are of potential importance, although much more work will be required to understand their implications. Firstly the pion stars provide substantial additional antiparticle identification capability, ignored in the original GAPS work. This added capability is likely to be even more important in a real space experiment, since the cubic array geometries proposed for space-based GAPS are ideally suited to exploiting the track which these pions will produce on escaping the GAPS cell in which they were created. Secondly the nuclear deexcitation lines, correlated with the atomic ladder X-rays, are potentially a source of added confirmation that an antiparticle stop has taken place. The experimental program at KEK in Japan has been sufficiently successful to move on to a flight test of GAPS. Our current plan is to use the KEK GAPS prototype. The prototype cylindrical, single cell, geometry is unlike that proposed for a flight GAPS in [3]. Nevertheless it will be extremely useful for evaluation of in-flight background, since a key GAPS parameter is how effectively it can reject the copious charged particle and cosmic-ray activation background. A successful experiment would be one where all this background is identified and rejected. The plan would be for a 24 hour flight from Lynn Lake, Canada. We note that the electronics used at KEK were flight representative. GAPS could be prepared for such a flight in 3 years or less. Our expectation is that such a test flight would take place in parallel with work to evaluate advanced flight detector and readout concepts. While NaI is a leading candidate for the X-ray detector, there are other promising approaches. CZT was specifically mentioned in our original GAPS work. Another option is CsI(pure), which reduces mass because of its superior stopping power compared to NaI(Tl) and is also cheaper. CsI light output is less than NaI(Tl) but it compensates for this by having better time response. New materials such as LaCl offer improved energy resolution albeit with higher cost. Perhaps the highest leverage for simplifying and improving on GAPS is in the readout for crystal detectors. A crystal bar geometry with miniature PMTs on either end (such as those available in T0-5 cans from Hamamatsu) is a more natural readout geometry than in the GAPS prototype, where the conventional crystal arraying leads to large dead area. Of particular utility to GAPS may be to explore using waveshifting materials to convert NaI(Tl) optical emission to the green region, where avalanche photodiodes or PMTs provide excellent quantum efficiency. This approach, which was used by Ziock and Hailey [30], employs wavelength-shifting fibers abutted to the scintillator bars to detect the bluish scintillation light and downshift it to green for efficient transport in the fiber. The light is detected in a position sensitive PMT, and the pixel of the PMT which is hit gives the “address” of the detector cell. Fiber runs of about a meter are feasible with the light yields expected from ladder X-rays, and this type of system has been demonstrated to work exceptionally well [31]. This approach has a large multiplex advantage though this must be traded against energy resolution. In this scheme virtually all electronics are outside the detector cells, minimizing dead mass. While much work remains to be done, it is realistic to envision flying a GAPS instrument that can detect antideuterons with sufficient sensitivity to probe well into the CMSSM and other SUSY parameter spaces on a timescale of five years or less. The precise timescale will be driven, as always, by funding. Acknowledgements We thank J Collins and the electronics shop staff at LLNL for the development and construction of the GAPS electronics, and T Decker, R Hill and G Tajiri for mechanical engineering support. We would also like to thank J Jou for his assistance during the 2005 KEK beamtime. We gratefully acknowledge Page 16 of 18 the support of M Ieiri and the KEK staff before and during the accelerator experiments. This work was supported in part by a NASA SR&T grant, NAG5-5393. [4] References [1] Donato F, Fornengo N and Salati P, Antideuterons as a signature of supersymmetric dark matter, 2000 Phys. Rev. D. 62 043003 [2] Barrau A et al, Antideuterons as a probe of primordial black holes, 2003 A&A 398, 403 [3] Mori K et al, A novel antimatter detector based on x-ray deexcitation of exotic atoms, 2002 ApJ 566, 604 Jungman G, Kamionkowski M and Griest K, Supersymmetric dark matter, 1996 Phys. Rep. 267 195 [5] Ellis J, Olive K A, Santoso Y and Spanos V, Update on the direct detection of supersymmetric dark matter, 2005 preprint hep-ph/0502001 [6] Barwick S W et al (HEAT collaboration), Measurements of the cosmic-ray positron fraction from 1 to 50 GeV, 1997 Astrophys J 482 L91 [7] Coutu S et al (HEAT collaboration), Positron measurements with the HEAT-pbar instrument, 1997 Proceedings of 27th ICRR astro-ph/9703192 [8] Kane G L, Wang L T and Wang T T, Supersymmetry and the cosmic-ray positron excess, 2002 Phys. Lett. B. 536 263 [hep-ph/0202156] [9] Baltz E A, Edsjo J, Freese K and Gondolo P, Cosmic-ray positron excess and neutralino dark matter, 2002 Phys. Rev. D 65 063511 [astro-ph/0211239] [10] Boehm C, Hooper D, Silk J, and Casse M, MeV dark matter: has it been detected? 2004 Phys. Rev. Lett 101301 [astro-ph/0309686] [11] Halzen F, Lectures on high-energy neutrino astronomy, 2005 astro-ph/0506248 [12] Baret B et al, Atmospheric and galactic production and propagation of light antimatter nuclei, 2003 Proceedings of 28th ICRC astro-ph/0306221; Duperray F et al, Flux of light antimatter nuclei near earth induced by cosmic-rays in the galaxy and in the atmosphere 2005 Phys. Rev. D 083013 [13] Donato F et al, Cosmic-ray antiprotons from relic neutralinos in a diffusion model, 2003 Proceedings of the 28th ICRC astro-ph/0306312 [14] Picozza P and Morselli A, Antimatter research in space, 2003 J. Phys. G. Nuc. Part. Phys. 29 903 [astro-ph/0211286] [15] Lionetto A M, Morselli A and Zdravkovic V, Uncertainties of cosmic-ray spectra and detectability and detection of antiproton mSugra contributions with PAMELA, 2005 preprint astro-ph/0502406 [16] Profumo S and Ullio P, The role of antimatter searches in the hunt for supersymmetric dark matter, 2004 J. Cosmology and Astroparticle Phys. 0407 006 [hep-ph/0406018] [17] Edsjo J, Schelke M and Ullio P, Direct versus indirect detection in mSUGRA with self- consistent halo models, 2004 J. Cosmology and Astroparticle Phys. 09 004 [astro- ph/0405414] [18] Masiero A, Profumo S and Ullio P, Neutralino dark matter detection in split supersymmetry models, 2005 Nucl. Phys. B712 86 [hep-ph/0412058] [19] Yamamoto A et al, BESS and its future prospect for polar long duration flights, 2002 Adv. Space Res. Vol. 30 No. 5 1253 [20] Fuke H et al, Search for cosmic-ray antideuterons, 2005 preprint astro-ph/0504361 [21] Galaktionov Y V, Antimatter in cosmic rays 2002 Rep. Prog. Phys. 65 1243 [stacks.iop.org/RoPP/65/1243] [22] Wiegand C E and Godfrey G L, Measurement of X-rays and gamma-rays from stopped kaons, 1974 Phys. Rev. A 9(6) 2282 [23] Gold R and Wong C, Disintegration of the deuteron in a Coulomb field, 1963 Phys. Rev. 132 6 [24] Oppenheimer J R and Phillips M, Note on the transmutation function for deuterons, 1935 Phys. Page 17 of 18 Rev. 48 500 [25] Hailey C J et al, Development of the gaseous antiparticle spectrometer for space-based antimatter detection, 2004 Nucl. Instr. Meth. B 214 122 [astro-ph/0306589] [26] Iazzi F, An antideuteron beam at JHF, 1999 Nucl. Phys.A 655 1 [27] PSI Graphic Transport Framework by U. Rohrer based on a CERN-SLAC-FERMILAB version by K.L. Brown et al. (http://people.web.psi.ch/rohrer_u/trans.htm). [28] Geant4 Collaboration (S. Agostinelli et al), published in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, NIM A 506 (2003), 250-303 [29] Barnes P D et al, Nuclear gamma-rays associated with stopped kaons, 1972 Phys. Rev. Lett. 29(4) 230 [30] Ziock K P and Hailey C J, Fiber-fed imaging spectrometer, 1989 Proc. SPIE vol. 1159 280 EUV, X-ray and Gamma-ray Instrumentation for Astronomy and Atomic Physics, Siegmund and Hailey eds. [31] Sandler P, Hailey C J, Sprehn G and Ziock K P, GRABIT: a large area, broad bandwidth gamma-ray imaging spectrometer for astrophysics, 1996 IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 43(1) 278 Page 18 of 18
astro-ph/9805170	1	9805	1998-05-13T15:38:06	On the Systematics of Core-Collapse Explosions	[ "astro-ph" ]	Recent observations of supernovae, supernova remnants, and radio pulsars suggest that there are correlations between pulsar kicks and spins, infrared and gamma-ray line profiles, supernova polarizations, and ejecta debris fields. A framework is emerging in which explosion asymmetries play a central role. The new perspective meshes recent multi-dimensional theoretical investigations of the explosion mechanism with trends in $^{56}$Ni yields and explosion kinetic energies. These trends imply that the mass above which black holes form after collapse is $\sim$30 M$_{\odot}$ and that supernova explosion energies may vary by as much as a factor of four. In addition, new neutrino-matter opacity calculations reveal that the inner cores of protoneutron stars are more transparent than hitherto suspected. This may have consequences for the delayed neutrino-driven mechanism of explosion itself.	astro-ph	astro-ph	On the Systematics of Core -- Collapse Explosions A. Burrows1 1 Department of Astronomy, The University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721 Abstract Recent observations of supernovae, supernova remnants, and radio pulsars suggest that there are correlations between pulsar kicks and spins, infrared and gamma-ray line profiles, su- pernova polarizations, and ejecta debris fields. A framework is emerging in which explosion asymmetries play a central role. The new perspective meshes recent multi -- dimensional the- oretical investigations of the explosion mechanism with trends in 56Ni yields and explosion kinetic energies. These trends imply that the mass above which black holes form after col- lapse is ∼30 M⊙ and that supernova explosion energies may vary by as much as a factor In addition, new neutrino -- matter opacity calculations reveal that the inner cores of four. of protoneutron stars are more transparent than hitherto suspected. This may have conse- quences for the delayed neutrino -- driven mechanism of explosion itself. Be that as it may, as the millenium dawns a surprising array of new data and theoretical results are challenging supernova modelers as never before. 1.1 Introduction Summarizing the important issues surrounding supernova theory is a daunting task and fraught with dangers [1, 2], but I will attempt here to highlight some of the recent devel- opments that I find interesting and hope that the reader will be patient with the manifest limitations of this exercise. In the process, some potential systematics will be discussed and new connections between disparate classes of observations will be suggested. It is now not unreasonable to imagine a theory that unifies the spins and velocities of neutron stars, the anisotropies observed in supernova ejecta, and stellar collapse and explosion. These may be connected in a given supernova, with the debris asymmetries correlated with the kick directions and the neutrino and gravitational wave emissions related to both. 1.2 Status of Explosion Modeling All groups that do multi -- D hydrodynamic modeling of supernovae obtain vigorous convection in the semi -- transparent mantle bounded by the stalled shock [3, 4, 5, 7, 6, 8]. There is a consensus that the neutrinos drive the explosion [9] after a delay whose magnitude has yet to be determined, but that may be between 100 and 1000 milliseconds. Whether any convective motion or hydrodynamic instability is central to the explosion mechanism is not clear, with five groups [3, 4, 5, 6, 8] voting yes or maybe and one group [7] voting no. The negative vote is from a group that is taking pains to handle the transport with a minimum of approximations. However, this group opted to do the transport in 1 -- D, save the result, and impose this history on the 2 -- D calculation, without feedback. This prescription is suspect, but so are the prescriptions of all the other groups, which compromised in different ways. Hence, a definitive calculation in either two and three dimensions has not yet been performed. 2 It should be noted that it is not trivial to diagnose the differences between the various calculations of the major groups, nor to reproduce the algorithms they employ. In this regard, one should be cautious of facile comparisons that purport to explain the results of others. For instance, to ascribe the explosions that some groups obtain to the use of the "gray" approximation says next to nothing. There is no one "gray" approximation, though all share the dubious characteristic of not being multi -- energy -- group. There are many implicit spectra and spectral forms that can be assumed, various flux limiters, a variety of source terms, a number of algorithms to merge opaque and transparent regimes, different approximations for the integrals of the Pauli blocking factors, and different cross sections averages, to name only the most obvious. Furthermore, the differences between a multi -- group flux -- limited calculation and a full transport calculation can be larger than the differences between a well -- chosen "non -- gray" calculation and the latter. The range of possible sets of choices under the rubric of "non -- gray" is vast and each set entails painstaking evaluation. Therein lies the major problem: it is harder to assemble a "non -- gray" code that attempts to cover all the limits than to do the problem correctly. It is only in an effort to speed up the calculation that an integral approach is attempted and doing the full problem is always preferable if sufficient computational resources are available. In addition, it is more difficult to have confidence in a patchwork of approximations than to trust a code that incorporates the full equations, though poor angular, energy, and spatial zoning can severely compromise even an otherwise virtuous scheme. 1.3 Many -- Body Correlations To focus exclusively on numerical and transport matters is frequently to lose sight of the important issues. After the ultimate algorithm is implemented, the results will depend on the initial progenitor models and the microphysics, in particular the neutrino cross sections. In this regard, the recent explorations into the effects of many -- body correlations on neutrino -- matter opacities at high densities are germane [10, 11, 12, 13]. Though the final numbers have not yet been derived, indications are that we have been overestimating the neutral -- current and the charged -- current cross sections above 1014 gm cm−3 by factors of from two to ten, depending upon density and the equation of state. The many -- body corrections increase with density, decrease with temperature, and for neutral -- current scattering are roughly indepen- dent of incident neutrino energy. Furthermore, the spectrum of energy transfers in neutrino scattering is considerably broadened by the interactions in the medium. An identifiable com- ponent of this broadening comes from the absorption and emission of quanta of collective modes akin to the Gamow -- Teller and Giant -- Dipole resonances in nuclei (zero-sound; spin sound), with Cerenkov kinematics. This implies that all scattering processes may need to be handled with the full energy redistribution formalism and that ν -- matter scattering at high densities can not be considered elastic. One consequence of this reevaluation is that the late -- time (≥ 500 milliseconds) neutrino luminosities may be as much as 50% larger for more than a second than heretofore estimated. These luminosities reflect more the deep protoneutron star interiors than the early post -- bounce luminosities of the outer mantle and the accretion phase. Since neutrinos drive the explosion, this may have a bearing on the specifics of the mechanism, but it is too soon to tell. 3 1.4 Systematics Unfortunately, theory is not yet adequate to determine the systematics with progenitor mass of the explosion energies, residue masses, 56Ni yields, kicks, or, in fact, almost any parameter of a real supernova explosion. Despite this, there are hints, both observational and theoretical, some of which I would like to touch on here. The gravitational binding energy (B.E.) exterior to a given interior mass is an increasing function of progenitor mass, ranging at 1.5 M⊙ interior mass from about 1050 ergs for a 10 M⊙ progenitor to as much as 3 × 1051 ergs for a 40 M⊙ progenitor [3, 14]. This large range must affect the viability of explosion and its energy. It is not unreasonable to conclude, in a very crude way, that B.E. sets the scale for the supernova explosion energy. When the "available" energy exceeds the "necessary" binding energy, both very poorly defined quantities at this stage, explosion is more "likely." However, how does the supernova, launched in the inner protoneutron star, know what binding energy it will be called upon to overcome when achieving larger radii? Since the post -- bounce, pre-explosion accretion rate ( M ) is a function of the star's inner density profile, as is the inner B.E., and since a large M seems to inhibit explosion, it may be via M that B.E., at least that of the inner star, is sensed. Furthermore, a neutrino -- driven explosion requires a neutrino -- absorbing mass and there is more mass available in the denser core of a more massive progenitor. One might think that binding energy and absorbing mass partially compensate or that a more massive progenitor can just wait longer to explode, until its binding energy problems are buried in the protoneutron star and M has subsided. The net effect in both cases may be similar explosion energies for different progenitors, though the residue mass could be systematically higher for the more massive stars. However, if these effects do not compensate, the fact that binding energy and absorbing mass are increasing functions of progenitor mass hints that the supernova explosion energy may also be an increasing function of mass. Since B.E. varies so much along the progenitor continuum, the range in the explosion energy may not be small. Curiously, the amount of 56Ni produced explosively also depends upon the mass between the residue and the radius at which the shock temperature goes below the explosive Si -- burning temperature, a radius that depends upon explosion energy. Hence, the amount of 56Ni produced may also increase with progenitor mass. Thermonuclear energy only partially compensates for the binding energy to be overcome, the former being about 1050 ergs for every 0.1 M⊙ of 56Ni produced. Not all 56Ni produced need be ejected. Fallback is possible and whether there is significant fallback must depend upon the binding energy profile. Personally, I think that there is not much fallback for the lighter progenitors, perhaps for masses below 15 M⊙, but that there is significant fallback for the heaviest progenitors. The transition between the two classes may be abrupt. I base this surmise on the miniscule binding energies and tenuous envelopes of the lightest massive stars and on the theoretical prejudice that the r -- process, or some fraction of it, originates in the protoneutron winds that follow the explosion for the lightest massive stars [15]. If there were significant fallback, these winds and their products would be smothered. If there is significant fallback, the supernova may be in jeopardy and much of the 56Ni produced will reimplode. There may be a narrow range of progenitor mass over which the supernova is still viable, while fallback is significant and both the mass of 56Ni ejected and the supernova energy are decreasing. Above this mass range, a black hole may form. Hence, both low -- mass and high -- mass supernova progenitors may have low 56Ni yields. Recently, two Type IIp supernovae have been detected, SN1994W [16] and SN1997D [17], which have very low 56Ni yields (≤ 0.0026 M⊙ and ≤ 0.002 M⊙, respectively), long -- duration plateaus, 4 and large inferred ejecta masses (≥ 25M⊙). The estimated explosion energy for SN1997D is a slight 0.4 × 1051 ergs. (SN1987A's explosion energy was 1.5 ± 0.5 × 1051 ergs and its 56Ni yield was 0.07 M⊙.) These two supernovae may reside in the fallback gap and imply that the black hole cut -- off is near 30 M⊙. In sum, supernova 56Ni yields may vary by a factor of ∼100 and may peak at some intermediate progenitor mass, the supernova explosion energy may vary by a factor of ∼ 4 and also may peak at some intermediate progenitor mass, and the black hole hole cut -- off mass may be near 30 M⊙. However, and importantly, whether real theoretical calculations will bear out these hinted -- at systematics is as yet very unclear. 1.5 Young Supernovae and Supernova Remnants There are many observational indications that supernova explosions are indeed aspherical. Fabry -- Perot spectroscopy of the young supernova remnant Cas A, formed around 1680 A.D., reveals that its calcium, sulfur, and oxygen element distributions are clumped and have gross back -- front asymmetries [18]. No simple shells are seen. Many supernova remnants, such as N132D, Cas A, E0102.2-7219, and SN0540-69.3, have systemic velocities relative to the local ISM of up to 900 km s−1 [19]. X -- ray data taken by ROSAT of the Vela remnant reveal bits of shrapnel with bow shocks [20]. The supernova, SN1987A, is a case study in asphericity: 1) its X -- ray, gamma -- ray, and optical fluxes and light curves require that shards of the radioactive isotope 56Ni were flung far from the core in which they were created, 2) the infrared line profiles of its oxygen, iron, cobalt, nickel, and hydrogen are ragged and show a pronounced red -- blue asymmetry, 3) its light is polarized, and 4) recent Hubble Space Telescope pictures of its inner debris reveal large clumps and hint at a preferred direction [21]. Furthermore, radio pictures of the supernova SN1993J, which also has polarized optical spectral features, depict a broken shell. One of the most intriguing recent finds is the supernova SN1997X, which is a so -- called Type Ic explosion. This supernova shows the greatest optical polarization of any to date (Lifan Wang, private communication). Type Ic supernovae are thought to be explosions of the bare carbon/oxygen cores of massive star progenitors stripped of their envelopes. As such, SN1997X's large polarization implies that the inner supernova cores, and, hence, the explosions themselves, are fundamentally asymmetrical. No doubt, instabilities in the outer envelopes of supernova progenitors clump and mix debris clouds and shatter spherical shells. The observation of hydrogen deep in SN1987A's ejecta [22] strongly suggests the work of such mantle instabilities. However, the data collectively, particularly for the heavier elements produced in the inner core, are pointing to asymmetries in the central engine of explosion itself. 1.6 Neutron Star Kicks Strong evidence that neutron stars experience a net kick at birth has been mounting for years. In 1993 [23, 24], it was demonstrated that the pulsars are the fastest population in the galaxy (< v > ∼ 450 km s−1). Such speeds are far larger than can result generically from orbital motion due to birth in a binary (the "so -- called" Blaauw effect). An extra "kick" is required, probably during the supernova explosion itself [25]. In the pulsar binaries, PSR J0045-7319 and PSR 1913+16, the spin axes and the orbital axes are misaligned, suggesting that the ex- plosions that created the pulsars were not spherical [26, 27]. In fact, for the former the orbital motion seems retrograde relative to the spin [28] and the explosion may have kicked the pulsar 5 backwards. In addition, the orbital eccentricities of Be star/pulsar binaries are higher than one would expect from a spherical explosion, also implying an extra kick [29]. Furthermore, low -- mass X -- ray binaries (LMXB) are bound neutron star/low-mass star systems that would have been completely disrupted during the supernova explosion that left the neutron star, had that explosion been spherical [30]. In those few cases, a countervailing kick may have been required to keep the system bound. The kick had to act on a timescale shorter than the orbit period and the explosion orbit crossing time. Otherwise, the process would have been uselessly adiabatic. One is tempted to evoke as further proof the fact that pulsars seen around young (age ≤ 104 years) supernova remnants are on average far from the remnant centers, but here ambiguities in the pulsar ages and distances and legitimate questions concerning the reality of many of the associations make this argument rather less convincing [31, 32]. However, the ROSAT observations of the 3700 year -- old supernova remnant Puppis A show an X -- ray spot that has been interpreted as its neutron star [33]. This object has a large X -- ray to optical flux ratio, but no pulsations are seen. If this interpretation is legitimate, then the inferred neutron star transverse speed is ∼1000 km s−1. Interestingly, the spot is opposite to the position of the fast, oxygen -- rich knots, as one might expect in some models of neutron star recoil during the supernova explosion. Whatever the correct interpretation of the Puppis A data, it is clear that many neutron stars are given a hefty extra kick at birth (though the distribution of these kicks is broad) and that it is reasonable to implicate asymmetries in the supernova explosion itself. 1.7 Theories of Kicks Supernova theorists have determined that protoneutron star/supernova cores are indeed grossly unstable to Rayleigh -- Taylor -- like instabilities [3, 4, 5]. During the post -- bounce delay to explosion that might last 100 to 1000 milliseconds, these cores with 100 -- to 200 -- kilometer radii are strongly convective, boiling and churning at sonic (∼ 3 × 104 km s−1) speeds. Any slight asymmetry in collapse can amplify this jostling and result in vigorous kicks and torques [3, 34, 35] to the residue that can be either systematic or stochastic. Whatever the de- tails, it would seem odd if the nascent neutron star were not left with a net recoil and spin, though whether pulsar speeds as high as 1500 km s−1 (cf. the Guitar Nebula) can be reached through this mechanism is unknown. Furthermore, asymmetries in the matter field may result in asymmetries in the emission of the neutrinos that carry away most of the binding energy of the neutron star. A net angular asymmetry in the neutrino radiation of only 1% would give the residue a recoil of ∼300 km s−1. Not surprisingly, many theorists have focussed on producing such a net asymmetry in the neutrino field, either evoking anisotropic accretion, exotic neutrino flavor physics, or the influence of strong magnetic fields on neutrino cross sections and transport. The latter is particularly interesting, but generally requires magnetic fields of 1014 to 1016 gauss [36], far larger than the canonical pulsar surface field of 1012 gauss. Perhaps, the pre -- explosion convective motions themselves can generate via dynamo action the required fields. Perhaps, these fields are transient and subside to the observed fields after the agitation of the explosive phase. It would be hard to hide large fields of 1015 gauss in the inner core of an old neutron star, while still maintaining standard surface fields of 1012 gauss. In this context, it is interesting to note that surface fields as high as 1015 gauss are very indirectly being inferred for the so -- called soft gamma repeaters [37], but these are a very small fraction of all neutron stars. If such large fields are necessary to impart, via anisotropic neutrino emission, the kicks observed, then the coincidence that Spruit & Phinney [35] note 6 between the fields needed to enforce slow pre -- collapse rotation and those observed in pulsars after flux freezing amplification is of less significance. Whether the kick mechanism is hydrodynamic or due to neutrino momentum, one might expect that the more massive progenitors would give birth to speedier neutron stars. More massive progenitors generally have more massive cores. If the kick mechanism relies on the anisotropic ejection of matter [34], then for a given explosion energy and degree of anisotropy we might expect the core ejecta mass and, hence, the dipole component of the ejecta momen- √2M E"), resulting in a larger kick. The explosion energy itself may tum to be larger ("p ∼ also be larger for the more massive progenitors, enhancing the effect. If the mechanism relies on anisotropic neutrino emission, the residues of more massive progenitors are likely to be more massive and have a greater binding energy (EB ∝ M 2 N S) to radiate. Hence, for a given degree of neutrino anisotropy, the impulse and kick (∝ EB/MN S) would be greater. In either case, despite the primitive nature of our current understanding of kick mechanisms, given the above arguements it is not unreasonable to speculate that the heaviest massive stars might yield the fastest neutron stars. Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge productive conversations with F. Thielemann, K. Nomoto, E. Muller, W. Hillebrandt, R. Hoffman, S. Reddy, M. Prakash, B. Schmidt, R. Kirshner, P. Pinto, and C. Wheeler, as well as support from the NSF under grant No. AST-96-17494. I would also like to acknowledge the facilitating environment of the Santa Barbara Institute for Theoretical Physics, supported by the NSF under grant No. PHY94-07194. References [1] A. Burrows, to be published in the proceedings of the 18'th Texas Symposium on Rela- tivisitc Astrophysics, ed. A. Olinto, J. Frieman, & D. Schramm (World Scientific Press, 1998). [2] A. Burrows, to be published in the proceedings of the 5'th CTIO/ESO/LCO Workshop "SN1987A: Ten Years Later," eds. M.M. Phillips & N.B. Suntzeff, held in La Serena, Chile, February 24 -- 28, 1997. [3] A. Burrows, J. Hayes, & B.A. Fryxell, Astrophys. J. 450 (1995) 830. [4] M. Herant, W. Benz, J. Hix, C. Fryer, & S.A. Colgate, Astrophys. J. 435 (1994) 339. [5] H.-T. Janka & E. Muller, Astron. & Astrophys. 290 (1994) 496. [6] D.S. Miller, J.R. Wilson, & R.W. Mayle, Astrophys. J. 415 (1993) 278. [7] A. Mezzacappa, et al., Astrophys. J. 495 (1998) 911. [8] I. Lichtenstadt, A. Kholkhov, & J.C. Wheeler, Astrophys. J., (1998) submitted. [9] H. Bethe & J.R. Wilson, Bethe, Astrophys. J. 295 (1985) 14. [10] A. Burrows & R. Sawyer, Phys. Rev. C, (1998) in press. [11] A. Burrows & R. Sawyer, Phys. Rev. Letters, (1998) submitted. 7 [12] S. Reddy, M. Prakash, & J.M. Lattimer, Phys. Rev. D, (1998) in press. [13] S. Yamada, (1998) this conference. [14] T.A. Weaver & S.E. Woosley, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 101 (1995) 181. [15] G. Mathews, G. Bazan, & J. Cowan, Astrophys. J. 391 (1992) 719. [16] J. Sollerman, et al., Astrophys. J. 493 (1998) 933. [17] M. Turatto, et al., Astrophys. J. Letters, (1998) submitted. [18] S.S. Lawrence, et al., Astron. J. 109 (1995) 2635. [19] R.P. Kirshner, J.A. Morse, P.F. Winkler, & J.P. Blair, Astrophys. J. 342 (1989) 260. [20] R. Strom, H.M. Johnston, F. Verbunt & B. Aschenbach, Nature 373 (1994) 590. [21] C.S.J. Pun, R.P. Kirshner, P.M. Garnavich, & P.Challis, B.A.A.S. 191 (1998) 9901. [22] D.H. Wooden, et al., Astrophys. J. Suppl. 88 (1993) 477. [23] P.A. Harrison, A.G. Lyne, & B. Anderson, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 261 (1993) 113. [24] A. Lyne & D.R. Lorimer, Nature 369 (1994) 127. [25] C. Fryer, A. Burrows, & W. Benz, Astrophys. J., (1998) in press. [26] I. Wasserman, J. Cordes, & D. Chernoff, (1998) in preparation. [27] V.M. Kaspi, et al., Nature 381 (1996) 584. [28] D. Lai, L. Bildsten, & V.M. Kaspi, Astrophys. J. 452 (1995) 819. [29] E.P.J. van den Heuvel & S. Rappaport, in I.A.U. Colloquium 92, eds. A. Slettebak & T.D. Snow (Cambridge Univ. Press), (1987) pp. 291 -- 308. [30] V. Kalogera, Pub. Astron. Soc. Pac. 109 (1997) 1394. [31] P. Caraveo, Astrophys. J. 415 (1993) L111. [32] D.A. Frail, W.M. Goss, & J.B.Z. Whiteoak, Astrophys. J. 437 (1994) 781. [33] R. Petre, C.M. Becker, & P.F. Winkler, Astrophys. J. 465 (1996) L43. [34] A. Burrows & J. Hayes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76 (1996) 352. [35] H. Spruit & E.S. Phinney, Nature, (1998) in press. [36] D. Lai & Y.-Z. Qian, Astrophys. J., (1998) in press. [37] M. Duncan & C. Thompson, B.A.A.S. 191 (1997) 119.08.
astro-ph/0407591	1	0407	2004-07-28T19:24:07	Discrete Components in the Radial Velocities of ScI Galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	We examine the V_{CMB} velocities and Tully-Fisher distances of 83 ScI galaxies and find that their velocities contain the same discrete velocity components identified previously by Tifft. After removing the discrete velocity components, the scatter remaining on the Hubble plot is in good agreement with the Tully-Fisher distance uncertainties. Although there is, as yet, no physical explanation for these discrete components, the fact that they appear to be identical to those found previously by Tifft suggests that their reality needs to be taken seriously.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Discrete Components in the Radial Velocities of ScI Galaxies M.B. Bell1, S.P. Comeau1 and D.G. Russell2 4 0 0 2 l u J 8 2 1 v 1 9 5 7 0 4 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a ABSTRACT We examine the VCMB velocities and Tully-Fisher distances of 83 ScI galaxies and find that their velocities contain the same discrete velocity components identified previously by Tifft. After removing the discrete velocity components, the scatter remaining on the Hubble plot is in good agreement with the Tully-Fisher distance uncertainties. Although there is, as yet, no physical explanation for these discrete components, the fact that they appear to be identical to those found previously by Tifft suggests that their reality needs to be taken seriously. Subject headings: galaxies: Cosmology: distance scale -- galaxies: Distances and redshifts - galaxies: quasars: general 1. Introduction. Tifft (1976, 1977a,b, 1996, 1997) found fami- lies of discrete velocities in normal galaxies and fitted them to a model in which they were all harmonically related to c the speed of light. In his model the discrete components detected are octave-spaced sub-harmonics of c, and related har- monics, and the redshift is assumed to arise from a time-dependent decay from an origin at the Planck scale. His observed velocity periods can be accu- rately described by the relation P = c2(−9D+T )/9, where D is the number of doublings and T de- fines the different families. There can be many different families but the most common, or ba- sic, of these make up what is referred to by Tifft (1996, 1997) as the T = 0 family of discrete values. These were found in common spiral galaxies. They showed discrete velocity components near 4.5, 9, 18, 36, 72, 145, 290, etc., km s−1 (hereafter Tifft's T=0 period). Although the other period groups were less common, they showed this same octave- related, or doubling nature. We have recently examined the radial veloci- ties and distances of 55 Spiral galaxies and 36 Type Ia Supernovae (SneIa) galaxies with accu- rate distances (Bell & Comeau 2003a). Both 1Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics, National Research Council of Canada, 100 Sussex Drive, Ottawa, ON, Canada K1A 0R6 2Owego Free Academy, Owego, NY 13827, USA groups showed evidence for discrete, intrinsic ve- locity components related to those reported by Tifft. However, the galaxies we studied extended to much larger distances and showed that the en- tire radial velocity was not quantized, as previ- ously thought by Tifft. Instead, the discrete com- ponents were superimposed on top of the Hubble flow. The observed discrete spectral shifts were always positive (redshifts). The origin of these discrete velocities is unknown. When the intrinsic components were removed from the measured ra- dial velocities, a Hubble constant of Ho = 58 km s−1 Mpc−1 was obtained for the local Universe, and the velocity-distance plot contained less scat- ter. This Ho-value is 20% lower than that ob- tained in the Hubble Key Project (Freedman et al. 2001). The difference between these two Hub- ble constants is due to the fact that Freedman et al. (2001) interpreted the scatter on the Hubble plot as random peculiar velocities containing both positive and negative Doppler components. Because what is meant by "peculiar velocity" is of fundamental importance to this analysis we define the following two terms to avoid future con- fusion. The term "peculiar velocities" is used here in the conventional sense to refer to the velocity scatter about the Hubble line and will hereafter be referred to as PVs. Because we assume here that these PVs may contain discrete intrinsic compo- nents that can cause them to fall along lines that run parallel to the Hubble line, our analysis in- 1 volves the determination of the RMS deviation rel- ative to the nearest of these intrinsic lines instead of one Hubble line. We define the scatter about these discrete lines as the "true peculiar velocities" and they are hereafter referred to as TPVs Here we examine the radial velocities of 83 ScI galaxies. We use the same analysis procedure as used previously so the results can be easily com- pared. We first describe the procedure in detail in order to convince the reader that we are really detecting discrete velocity components. 2. The Data B- and I-band Tully-Fisher (TF) distances, and VCMB velocities for the 83 ScI galaxies were ob- tained from Table VI of Russell (2003). The TF distances for these galaxies were calculated utiliz- ing the Type dependent TF relations of Russell (2003), who found that galaxies of morphological types SbcI, Sbc I-II, ScI, ScI-II and Seyferts have systematically underestimated TF distances uti- lizing a standard single TF equation. The 83 ScI galaxies were drawn from the samples of Mathew- son & Ford (1996) and Giovanelli et al. (1997) and are all classified as Sbc or Sc of luminosity class I or I-II in the LEDA database. TF scatter was sig- nificantly reduced with the use of type dependent TF relations for the calibrator samples (Russell 2003) and for cluster samples (Russell 2004). The TF scatter of the calibrators in the B-band was only ±0.09 mag for the ScI group and ±0.16 mag for the Sb/ScIII group when using the type depen- dent TF relations compared with ±0.30 mag with a traditional single calibration (Russell 2003). The scatter quoted here represents the empirical scat- ter of the TF relation relative to calibrator. 3. Analysis From our previous work and Tifft's, we can make the following initial assumptions to limit the number of free parameters. First, The Hubble slope obtained must be Ho = 58 km s−1 Mpc−1. Second, since we are examining spiral galaxies, the discrete components present will be predomi- nantly those predicted by Tifft's most common (T = 0) group, and third, the discrete components will be superimposed on top of the Hubble flow. These assumptions severely restrict what the data must show if our previous results are to be con- 2 firmed. The first of these assumptions is an im- portant one because it allows us to differentiate between real and random features. As in previous analyses (Bell & Comeau 2003a), in a given source sample, VCMB, the radial veloc- ity of each source relative to the cosmic microwave background reference frame, was first plotted vs distance. Fig 1 shows such a plot using peculiar ve- locities (PVs) that were randomly generated. The Hubble slope used in the generation of this sam- ple (Ho = 85) was taken from the actual source distribution and is the slope obtained for the data when the lines in Fig 1 are ignored and a linear relation is fitted to the data points. In this fig- ure the solid lines represent Tifft's relevant T = 0 discrete components superimposed on top of an Ho = 58 Hubble slope. Since the superimposed velocities were randomly generated there should be no evidence in Fig 1 that the source veloci- ties fall along the discrete velocity grid lines, and clearly there is not. As in all previous analyses we then calculated the RMS deviation of the sources from their nearest discrete velocity grid line. We then repeated this calculation for a range of Hub- ble constants. When the velocity distribution does not contain Tifft's discrete components, then, as the Hubble slope is varied, one RMS minimum will be obtained. This minimum will occur for that Hubble slope that positions the densest por- tion of the discrete velocity grid lines on top of the densest portion of the source distribution. The re- sulting RMS deviation plot is shown in Fig 2. As predicted, one RMS minimum is obtained and it occurs near a Hubble slope of Ho = 70. This then, is how the RMS deviation plot is expected to ap- pear when Tifft's discrete velocity components are not present in the radial velocities. We now demonstrate how the RMS deviation plot in Fig 2 will be affected if Tifft's T = 0 dis- crete velocities are present in the source velocities. To do this we generated a second data set con- taining Tifft's T = 0 components superimposed on top of the Hubble slope. The generated veloci- ties contained no distance errors, no true peculiar velocities (TPVs), and were superimposed on top of a Hubble slope of Ho = 50. A slope of 50 was used to show that there is nothing magical about the value 58. Fig 3 shows these velocities plotted versus distance, using the same distance values as in Fig 1. In Fig 3 the velocities are clearly aligned HO= 58 8000 6000 4000 2000 ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V 0 0 20 40 D (Mpc) 60 80 Fig. 1. -- Test set of randomly generated VCMB velocities plotted vs distance. Solid lines represent Tifft's T=0 discrete velocities for Ho = 58. 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 ) 1 - s m k ( S M R 0 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Ho Fig. 2. -- RMS deviation in test VCMB velocities about Tifft's T=0 discrete velocity lines for data in Fig 1 plotted as a function of Ho. Only one minimum is visible in the plot. 3 along Tifft's T = 0 discrete velocity lines for Ho = 50. The RMS deviation of the source veloc- ities from their nearest discrete velocity lines in Fig 3 was then calculated for a range of Hubble slopes as was done in Fig 2. As the Hubble slope is varied, a low RMS value will be obtained as be- fore for that Ho-value that positions the densest portion of the lines near the center of the source velocity distribution. This is again expected to occur near Ho = 70. However, with Tifft's dis- crete components present in the data, a SECOND dip in the RMS deviation plot will occur at the Hubble slope where the source velocities are posi- tioned along the discrete velocity grid lines. The resulting RMS deviation plot is shown in Fig 4, where a second dip is now visible corresponding to a Hubble slope of 50, indicated by the arrow. This SECOND dip in the RMS deviation curve at Ho = 50 in Fig 4 is thus THE DEFINING SIG- NATURE OF DISCRETE VELOCITIES IN THE DATA. The scatter in the source distances about the discrete velocity lines will determine the depth of the second RMS dip. This RMS dip therefore does not have to be deeper than the first dip near Ho = 70 to indicate that discrete velocities are present. For real data, however, it does have to occur at, or very near, Ho = 58, since this is the value found in all previous analyses of real galaxy data. Although it is theoretically possible for an RMS dip to be produced by random fluctuations in the source distances and peculiar velocities, if these fluctuations are truly random, so will be the value of the Hubble constant at which the RMS dip occurs. Also, the amplitude of random dips is ex- pected to decrease, as the number of sources in the sample increases. 4. Tully-Fisher Distance Uncertainties Since, as noted above, the depth of the discrete component signature (i.e. the second RMS dip) is directly proportional to the size of the distance uncertainties, as these increase the second dip will become shallower, until it eventually disappears, as in Fig 2. There are good reasons to suspect that some of the sources will have larger distance errors than others. As long as these sources are present in the sample they are expected to reduce the visibility of the second RMS dip. We therefore first looked at a test sample drawn from the 83 ScI galaxies that we have a good reason to believe will have some of the most accurate distances. By taking the difference between the B- and I-band distances for each source it is found that these differences range from 0 to 57.6 Mpc for the 83 ScI galaxies. Clearly, from this result, some dis- tances have to have large errors. By making the simple assumption that the distances are likely to be more accurate when both B and I-Band dis- tances agree, we obtained a sample that we felt should have accurate distances by choosing the 23 sources with the smallest B-I differences. The mean B-I difference for this sample was 0.8 Mpc. In Fig 5 the VCMB velocities of these 23 sources are plotted vs their B-band distances. Tifft's T = 0 discrete velocity lines are included on the plot. A solid line joins sources assumed to contain the same discrete velocity component. It is apparent from this plot that the sources are aligned along the lines representing the discrete velocity compo- nents for a Hubble slope near 58. If most of the scatter in the plot is then due to the discrete intrin- sic components, the real dispersion (due to TPVs and distance errors) will be given by the scatter about the discrete lines. It must be much smaller and will not be clearly visible until the discrete components are removed (see Fig 7). The mea- surement error for velocity is likely to be less than 35 km s−1 (Jorgensen et al. 1995). In fact, the mean velocity error in Fig 5 is 17.6 km s−1 from the velocity errors listed in the LEDA database for these sources. Although magnitude measure- ment errors are also known, they are expected to bear little resemblance to the true distance errors that are obtained after the various corrections are applied. The RMS deviation plot for the sources in Fig 5 is given by the solid curve in Fig 6 and it also clearly shows the signature of Tifft's discrete veloc- ities by the presence of a second RMS dip near Ho = 58. Also plotted in Fig 6 are two other curves. The dashed curve is the RMS deviation plot ob- tained by replacing the PVs of the 23 sources in Fig 5 with randomly generated ones. The dotted curve is an RMS deviation plot obtained by re- taining the original PVs and generating random distance errors. Both random data sets were gen- erated so that the resulting scatter was similar to that for the real data (assuming one Hubble line with no discrete components). Both plots ob- HO= 50 8000 6000 4000 2000 ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V 0 0 20 40 D (Mpc) 60 80 Fig. 3. -- Test set of VCMB velocities containing only Tifft's T = 0 discrete components, plotted vs distance. Solid lines represent Tifft's T=0 discrete velocities. 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V n i n o i t a v e d S M R i 0 30 40 50 60 70 Ho 90 100 80 Fig. 4. -- RMS deviation in test VCMB velocities about Tifft's T=0 discrete velocity lines for the velocity distribution in Fig 3, plotted versus Ho. Two RMS dips are now visible in the plot, one at Ho = 50 and one near Ho = 70. The arrow indicates the location of the dip produced by the presence of Tifft's discrete velocities. 4 tained using randomly generated data show only one minimum. No second minimum is expected since Tifft's T = 0 components are not present in the randomly generated data. In Fig 7 the discrete components (as defined by the lines in Fig 5) have been removed from the ra- dial velocities leaving only the component VH, due to the Hubble flow, with its uncertainty in distance and any small TPVs remaining. The dashed lines in Fig 7 are assumed to represent the peak-to-peak scatter in the distances, as a function of distance, for the 23 galaxies with smallest B-I differences. The peak-to-peak scatter in Fig 7 corresponds to a 1 σ uncertainty in the distance modulus of ±0.2 mag, if Ho = 58, assuming no TPVs. After con- version to distance, these uncertainties (1 sigma) have been included in Fig 7. This is consistent with the Cepheid calibrators for which the 12 ScI group calibrators had a B-band scatter of ±0.09 mag (1 sigma). The 23 galaxies in Fig 7 represent those galaxies in the sample that are likely to have some of the smallest distance uncertainties. The scatter obtained for the entire sample of 83 galax- ies is expected to be larger. Typical scatter, when type dependence is not accounted for is at least ±0.25 magnitude (Russell 2003). When type de- pendence is taken into account, as here, our value of ±0.2 magnitude is in good agreement with what is expected. These results, after removal of the dis- crete velocity components, indicate that any TPV components present cannot be large. The solid line in Fig 7 represents a linear fit to the data which gave a Hubble constant of Ho = 57 ±2. Previous analyses of galaxies gave values of Ho = 57.9 for SneIa galaxies, 57.5 for Sb galaxies and 60.0 for Sc galaxies (Bell & Comeau 2003a). With equal weighting these results give a mean value of Ho = 58.1±1.2 km s−1 Mpc−1. 5. RMS Deviation Plot for all 83 ScI Galaxies Fig 8 shows the plots obtained for the RMS de- viation in VCMB velocities for all 83 ScI galaxies for both B- and I-band TF distances. There is no evidence in the I-Band curve for a second RMS deviation dip at Ho = 58, and the minimum RMS deviation found is near 580 km s−1. In the B-Band curve there is a clear second dip near Ho = 58, in- dicated by the arrow, and its minimum RMS devi- HO= 57 8000 6000 4000 2000 ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V 0 0 20 40 D (Mpc) 60 80 Fig. 5. -- Plot of VCMB velocities as a function of distance for the 23 ScI galaxies with smallest B-I distance differences from Table VI of Russell (2003). 700 600 500 400 300 200 ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V n i n o i t a v e d S M R i 100 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Ho Fig. 6. -- (solid curve) Plot of the RMS deviation in VCMB about the discrete velocity lines vs Ho for 23 ScI galaxies in Fig 5, showing a second RMS dip at Ho = 58. (dashed curve) Similar plot for sources with randomly generated peculiar veloci- ties. (dotted curve) Similar plot for sources with randomly generated distance errors as described in the text. 5 ation is now close to 420 km s−1. Although this is much higher than the RMS-value of 190 obtained for the 23 sources selected because their B and I- Band distances were similar, this is not surprising since the full sample contains sources with a wide range of inclination angles and rotation velocities. It is well known that distance errors can vary sig- nificantly with inclination (Sakai et al. 2000; Tully & Pierce 2000). 6. Discussion One of the strongest arguments favoring our in- terpretation that the detection of a second dip in the RMS deviation in VCMB as Ho is varied is due to discrete velocities present in the data, is the fact that in the present analysis, as well as in all previous analyses where galaxy TF distances were examined, this second dip has always occurred at the same Hubble slope of Ho = 58. Although the occurrence of RMS dips due to random clumping in the source distribution is possible, there are few arguments that can be made to explain the con- sistent appearance of randomly produced dips at the same Hubble slope. There would appear to be only two reasons why dips would always ap- pear at the same Hubble slope in the real data. One is if the discrete components are real, and the other is if the analysis procedure is somehow affecting the result. The latter case was exam- ined extensively in Test 2 of a previous paper (Bell & Comeau 2003b), where it was clearly demon- strated, by averaging RMS deviation curves for 10 randomly generated samples, that our reduction procedure was not introducing a second RMS dip at a particular Hubble slope. In Test 1 of that pa- per we also demonstrated that the randomly gen- erated samples gave only one RMS dip. We note again that the depth of the second RMS dip, the signature of the presence of discrete components, is unrelated to the overall scatter in the data (i.e. to the size of the PVs generated). It is entirely de- pendent upon how closely aligned the data points are to Tifft's discrete velocity lines (i.e. how small the TPVs and distance errors are). If a second RMS dip appears in the real data it means that the PVs cannot be purely random, but must con- tain discrete components that align the sources along the "discrete velocity" lines. We have fur- ther demonstrated again in Fig 6 of this paper that the second RMS dip is not seen when the dis- 8000 6000 ) 1 - s m k ( H V 4000 2000 0 0 20 40 D (Mpc) 60 80 Fig. 7. -- Plot of the residual velocity VH vs B- band distance after removal of the discrete velocity components in Fig 5. 700 600 500 I-Band B-Band ) 1 - s m k ( B M C V n i n o i t i a v e d S M R 400 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Ho Fig. 8. -- RMS deviation in VCMB about the dis- crete velocity lines for all 83 ScI galaxies when (dotted curve) using I-Band distances and, (solid curve) using B-Band distances. 6 Russell, D.G. 2003, ApSS (submitted), astro- ph/0310284 Russell, D.G. 2004, ApJ, 607, 241 Sakai, S. et al. 2000, ApJ, 529, 698 Tifft, W.G. 1976, ApJ, 206, 38 Tifft, W.G. 1977a, ApJ, 211, 31 Tifft, W.G. 1977b, ApJ, 211, 377 Tifft, W.G. 1996, ApJ, 468, 491 Tifft, W.G. 1997, ApJ, 485, 465 Tully, R.B. & Pierce, M.J. 2000, ApJ, 533, 744 crete components are not present in the data, and it is therefore not produced by the analysis proce- dure. We have also demonstrated in Figs 3 and 4 that the location of the second dip is determined by the data. We conclude that the second RMS dip at Ho = 58 that we have now detected in four completely separate galaxy groups is due to the presence of discrete velocity components in the ra- dial velocities of these galaxies. The fact that the discrete velocities found are identical to those re- ported previously by Tifft strongly reinforces this claim. 7. Conclusions We have examined the velocities and distances of a source sample containing 83 ScI galaxies. We find evidence that the velocity components of Tifft's most common T=0 velocity period are present in the radial velocities of these galaxies. We find for a particular sub-sample of 23 ScI galaxies, chosen because their distances are likely to be accurate, that after the discrete velocities are removed, the distance scatter remaining in the Hubble plot corresponds to a mean magnitude er- ror in their distance modulus of ±0.20 magnitude. This is in good agreement with the value expected when morphological type is taken into considera- tion. We also find, for the 83 sources, that B-band distances are considerably more accurate than I- band. As a result of this we suggest that our tech- nique may be a valuable one to use to study the Tully-Fisher distance errors as a function of galaxy inclination and rotation velocity. We thank Dr. D. McDiarmid for helpful sug- gestions. REFERENCES Bell, M.B. & Comeau, S.P. 2003a, astro- ph/0305112 Bell, M.B. & Comeau, S.P. 2003b, astro- ph/0305060 Freedman et al. 2001, ApJ, 553, 47 Giovanelli R. et al. 1997, AJ 113, 22 Jorgensen, I., Franx, M. and Kjaergaard, P. 1995, MNRAS, 276, 1341 Mathewson, D. & Ford, V. 1996, ApJS, 107, 97 This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2. 7
astro-ph/0412225	1	0412	2004-12-09T19:50:49	Strong latitudinal shear in the shallow convection zone of a rapidly rotating A-star	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have derived the mean broadening profile of the star V102 in the region of the open cluster IC4665 from high resolution spectroscopy. At a projected equatorial rotation velocity of vsini = (105 +- 12)km/s we find strong deviation from classical rotation. We discuss several scenarios, the most plausible being strong differential rotation in latitudinal direction. For this scenario we find a difference in angular velocity of DeltaOmega = 3.6 +- 0.8 rad/d (DeltaOmega/Omega = 0.42 +- 0.09). From the Halpha line we derive a spectral type of A9 and support photometric measurements classifying IC4665 V102 as a non-member of IC4665. At such early spectral type this is the strongest case of differential rotation observed so far. Together with three similar stars, IC4665 V102 seems to form a new class of objects that exhibit extreme latitudinal shear in a very shallow convective envelope.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. Gk024 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) November 2, 2018 4 0 0 2 c e D 9 1 v 5 2 2 2 1 4 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Strong latitudinal shear in the shallow convection zone of a rapidly rotating A-star⋆ A. Reiners1,2, M. Hunsch3, M. Hempel4, and J.H.M.M. Schmitt2 1 Astronomy Department, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720 e-mail: [email protected] 2 Hamburger Sternwarte, Universitat Hamburg, Gojenbergsweg 112, 21029 Hamburg, Germany e-mail: [email protected] 3 Institut fur Theoretische Physik und Astrophysik, Leibnizstrasse 15, 24098 Kiel, Germany e-mail: [email protected] 4 Astrophysikalisches Institut Jena, Schillergasschen 2-3, 07745 Jena, Germany e-mail: [email protected] November 2, 2018 Abstract. We have derived the mean broadening profile of the star V 102 in the region of the open cluster IC 4665 from high resolution spectroscopy. At a projected equatorial rotation velocity of v sin i = (105 ± 12) km s−1 we find strong deviation from classical rotation. We discuss several scenarios, the most plausible being strong differential rotation in latitudinal direction. For this scenario we find a difference in angular velocity of ∆Ω = 3.6 ± 0.8 rad d−1 (∆Ω/Ω = 0.42 ± 0.09). From the Hα line we derive a spectral type of A9 and support photometric measurements classifying IC 4665 V 102 as a non-member of IC 4665. At such early spectral type this is the strongest case of differential rotation observed so far. Together with three similar stars, IC 4665 V 102 seems to form a new class of objects that exhibit extreme latitudinal shear in a very shallow convective envelope. Key words. stars: rotation -- line: profiles -- stars: individual(IC4665 V102/P35) -- clusters:individual(IC4665) 1. Introduction 2. Data The substantial difference between photospheres of solar-type stars and A-type stars is the existence of a convective enve- lope. Late-type stars harbor convective envelopes where tur- bulent motions of photospheric plasma can occur. In convec- tive envelopes, differential rotation can trigger a magnetic dy- namo giving reason for the observed plethora of activity phe- nomena. The onset of convection may be traced by the onset of coronal X-ray emission around spectral type A7 (Schmitt, 1997). Gray & Nagel (1989) searched for the onset of convec- tion analyzing line bisectors of slowly rotating stars. In their targets a bisector reversal was found around spectral type F0. Stronger asymmetries were found in the stars at the hot side of the boundary indicating higher photospheric velocities. While stellar rotation velocities have been measured for al- most a century, differential rotation is more difficult to detect (e.g. Gray, 1977, 1998, and references therein). Measurements of differential rotation have been reported in stars rotating faster than v sin i > 10 km s−1 and covering all spectral types harboring convective envelopes (Reiners & Schmitt, 2003a,b; Reiners & Royer, 2004). ⋆ Based on observations carried out at the European Southern Observatory, Paranal, 71.D-0127(A) Our data of V 102 have been taken on April 18th 2003 with the FLAMES multi-object facility at ESO/VLT. Using the UVES spectrograph at a resolution of 38 000 we gained a signal-to- noise ratio of 150 in a one hour exposure. The spectra were re- duced using the UVES context embedded in the ESO-MIDAS package. The observed spectral range covers the region from 4800 Å to 6800 Å with a gap at 5800 Å. In a second observa- tion during the same night we collected a spectrum with the FLAMES facility using the GIRAFFE spectrograph which cov- ers the Ca H+K resonance lines. A small region of the UVES spectrum is plotted in Fig. 1 (black spectrum). 3. V102 and its membership to IC 4665 IC 4665 is a young (50-70 Myr; Prosser, 1993; Giampapa et al., 1998) open cluster at a distance of roughly 350 pc. The first photometric measurements of V 102 were done by McCarthy & O'Sullivan (1969). Although V 102 fitted onto the main sequence in their color-magnitude diagram, they argued that V 102 is a "less probable" member of IC 4665 due to their proper motion measurements. More than twenty years later, Prosser (1993) carried out a photometric study of IC 4665 and derived more accurate proper motions. From that he derived 2 A. Reiners et al.: Strong latitudinal shear in IC4665 V102 Fig. 1. Data (black) and fit (grey) in a small part of the used wavelength region. In the inset the two broadening functions derived from the spectral regions 4950 Å -- 5550 Å (grey) and 5440 Å -- 5745 Å (black) are shown. Both broadening functions perfectly match one another. an 86% membership probability for V 102. However, he also carried out CCD-photometry and found V 102 not to fit onto the cluster main sequence according to its brightness in V. The results from photometric measurements in V 102 are given in Table 1. The V-magnitudes derived by McCarthy & O'Sullivan (1969) and by Prosser (1993) are significantly different while B-magnitudes are identical and are also reproduced by the value measured by Kislyuk et al. (1999). Since magnitudes in the B-filter are identical in all three references we suspect that one of the magnitudes in V is incorrect, giving rise to the dif- ferent values of B − V. The spectral types according to the B−V measurements are either A9 or F5. In this spectral range the Hα-line is very sen- sitive to temperature and we can deduce the spectral type from our data. The Hα-line of V 102 is plotted in Fig. 2 together with spectra of HD 115 8101 (B − V = 0.27, v sin i = 100 km s−1, light grey) and HD 120 9872 (B−V = 0.44, v sin i = 8.5 km s−1, dark grey) spun up to v sin i ≈ 100 km s−1. From the excellent fit to the Hα-line of HD 115 810, we conclude that the color of V 102 must be similar to HD 115 810. We thus adopt the value of B − V = 0.26 given in Prosser (1993), i.e., from photometry V 102 is likely to be a background star and not a member of IC 4665 (Prosser, 1993). 1 taken with the FOCES spectrograph, DSAZ, Calar Alto 2 taken with the FEROS spectrograph, ESO, La Silla Table 1. Photometric data of IC 4665 V 102. V B 11.65 11.82 12.09 12.081 12.06 B − V 0.44 0.26 V − I B − R designation 0.41 0.69 V 102a P 35b 354 699c 1 Calculated from V and B − V, not given in the catalog a McCarthy & O'Sullivan (1969) b Prosser (1993) c Kislyuk et al. (1999) 4. Broadening Function From our observations we derived the mean line broadening profile following the strategy outlined in Reiners & Schmitt (2002a). Normalization of the spectrum was done by eye, even at rapid rotation the continuum is still visible. Using absorp- tion line wavelengths from the Vienna Atomic Line Database (Kupka et al., 1999) as a reference, we iteratively determine the shape of the broadening function and equivalent widths of all incorporated lines. To check against systematic errors we performed the fit in two overlapping wavelength regions. The wavelength region at 4950 Å -- 5550 Å incorporates 185 lines, the second region at 5440 Å -- 5745 Å 137 lines. A. Reiners et al.: Strong latitudinal shear in IC4665 V102 3 Table 2. Results derived from the broadening function v sin i q2 q1 α = ∆Ω/Ω ∆Ω (105 ± 12) km s−1 1.39 ± 0.01 0.42 ± 0.09 3.6 ± 0.8 rad d−1 5.1. Differentialrotation Convenient quantities characterizing stellar rotational broaden- ing are the first two zeros q1 and q2 of the broadening profile's Fourier transform (cf. Reiners & Schmitt, 2002a). The value of v sin i can be derived from q1. Furthermore, in a rigid rotator, the ratio q2/q1 always is larger than 1.72. For V 102 we derive a ratio q2/q1 = (1.39 ± 0.01) < 1.72. This small ratio is visible in the narrow first side-lobe of the Fourier transform compared to the profile of HD 46 273 in the right panel of Fig. 3. To quantify differential rotation we assume a rotation law parameterized in analogy to the solar case: Ω(l) = ΩEquator(1 − α sin2 l), with l heliographic latitude and ΩEquator angular rotation speed at the equator. Differential rotation can be described by the pa- rameter α, which is the difference of the equatorial and polar rotation velocities relative to the equatorial velocity. (1) As shown in Reiners & Schmitt (2003a), this parameter α can be calculated from the observed ratio q2/q1, specifically q2/q1 ∝ α/ √sin i, with i the inclination angle. For the case of V 102 we derive α = 0.42 ± 0.09, and with a radius of R = 1.5 R⊙ the difference between polar and equatorial angu- lar velocities is ∆ = 3.6 ± 0.8 rad d−1. Such strong a shear in a fast rotator is expected to maintain a strong magnetic dynamo and we would expect significant X- ray flux from V 102. Giampapa et al. (1998) carried out X-ray observations of IC 4665 with no detection of X-ray flux from V 102. However, for a distance of d = 350pc, we estimate ∼ 3.4 1029 erg s−1. This an upper limit of X-ray luminosity LX < is about the typical X-ray luminosity detected in that spectral range (Pallavicini et al., 1981). Since V 102 is likely to be a background object, the X-ray observations do not contradict the picture of a strong magnetic dynamo being driven by rapid differential rotation. 5.2. Alternativescenarios Although we believe that differential rotation is the most prob- able interpretation of the derived broadening profile, other mechanisms can be potential reasons for the deviations from classical rotational broadening as well. We discuss three alter- native scenarios. 5.2.1. Low inclination Very rapidly rotating stars become gravity darkened, i.e., they become cooler at the equator. At (unprojected) rotational ve- locities larger than 150 km s−1, the shape of the broadening profile, and especially the ratio q2/q1, is affected by grav- ity darkening (cf. Reiners, 2003). From the models given in Fig. 2. Hα-line of V 102 (black). Overplotted are spectra of HD 115 810 (B−V = 0.27; light grey) and HD 120 987 (B−V = 0.44 spun up to v sin i ≈ 100 km s−1; dark grey). The spectrum of HD 115 810 resembles the one of V 102 much better than the spectrum of HD 120 987 does. We calculate the variances of the broadening function by taking into account the uncertainties of the two nearest neigh- bors of each pixel. We overplot in Fig. 1 our final fit to the data in grey. The line shapes of all lines are well resembled within data quality. In the inset of Fig. 1 we compare the two broaden- ing functions independently derived from the two overlapping wavelength regions mentioned above. Both broadening func- tions resemble each other indicating indepence on the wave- length region; the broadening function with its errors is plotted in black in the left panel of Fig. 3. Although every pixel was a free parameter during the fit, the broadening profile is symmet- ric within the uncertainties. Quantitative conclusions can be drawn from the Fourier transform of the broadening profile which is shown with its er- rors in the right panel of Fig. 3. In Fig. 3, we also plot the broad- ening profile of HD 46 273, a star of similar spectral type and v sin i (F2V, v sin i = 107 km s−1). This profile was achieved applying the same procedure to data obtained with the FEROS spectrograph at ESO/La Silla (Reiners & Schmitt, 2003b), it has a shape as expected from classical solid body rotation. 5. Interpretation The broadening function of V 102 shows significant differ- ences to classical rotation broadening. Within the error bars a difference is clearly visible between the profiles of V 102 and HD 46 273. At a projected equatorial rotation velocity of v sin i = 105 km s−1, the broadening functions are clearly ro- tation dominated. Since the derived broadening functions are symmetric, it is unlikely that they are dominated by starspots and we argue that the profiles are due to the rotation law of the stellar surface. In the following, we will discuss the amount of differential rotation we derive for V 102 and the consequences for the surface shear. However, we will also discuss several other scenarios that could be reason for such a profile. 4 A. Reiners et al.: Strong latitudinal shear in IC4665 V102 Fig. 3. Broadening functions of IC 4665 V 102 (black) and HD 46 273 (grey) in velocity (left panel) and Fourier space (right panel). The profile of HD 46 273 is resembles classical rotation broadening. Significant differences are visible to the profile of IC 4665 V 102. Note especially the narrowed first sidelobe in the Fourier transform -- a typical signature for differential rotation with the equator rotating faster then the pole. Reiners (2003) we can calculate the equatorial velocity needed for our observed ratio of q2/q1 = 1.39; we get a value of vrot = 800 km s−1, which is far beyond breakup velocity. Thus we can rule out gravity darkening as the main reason for the observed profile. 5.2.2. Bright Polar Spot The surface of V 102 may be covered with spots. If the star were magnetically active, one would expect cool spots cover- ing the star. Cool spots generate characteristic signatures in ab- sorption profiles. Since the derived broadening profile is sym- metric, the surface coverage of spots must also be symmetric to a high degree. One configuration that would satisfy these re- quirements is a polar spot. We examined the influence of spots on the broadening profile (cf. Reiners & Schmitt, 2002b) and found that cool polar spots do change the profile shape and the ratio q2/q1 but in the opposite direction; q2/q1 becomes larger. A profile shape as the one observed could only be due to a hot polar spot. From our models we estimate that a polar cap with a radius larger than 30◦ at a temperature about 1000 K hotter than the rest of the star is needed to produce such a pro- file shape. This could be similar to what is observed in T Tauri stars accreting material at the poles, and one obvious sign of such accretion would be Hα emission. In V 102, no sign of Hα emission can be found (cp. Fig. 2). We emphasize that this may nevertheless be a scenario al- ternative to differential rotation, but we see no physical connec- tion to any phenomenon observed on other stars. 5.2.3. Composite spectrum The derived broadening profile could tentatively also be a com- position of two spectra from rigidly rotating stars. Especially the curvature at around ±70 km s−1 could be interpreted as an indication for that scenario (although it can also be explained by differential rotation). The profile could then be interpreted by a spectrum of the first star rotating at v sin i ≈ 110 km s−1, superimposed by a spectrum of a second object rotating at v sin i ≈ 70 km s−1. Thus both stars would have either sig- nificantly different rotation velocities or were seen under dif- ferent angles of inclination, i.e., a hypothetical double sys- tem could not be corotating. Since we derived identical pro- files from two different wavelength regions covering several hundred Ångstroms, both stars had to be of similar spectral type, otherwise the line profile would change at different wave- lengths. In order to resemble the derived profile, both stars must also contribute approximately the same amount of flux. Given similar spectral types of the components, that implies that both stars are at the same distance and are probably physi- cally bound. The double system would then emit roughly twice the flux a single star would, i.e., the real magnitude of each member would be 0.75 mag higher than the measured ones putting V 102 even further away from the main sequence in the color-magnitude diagram. In this scenario, V 102 would be a physically bound system consisting of two stars of similar spectral type and different ro- tation velocities located far outside the cluster but comoving with the cluster. We would expect such a spectrum to be vari- able. Although we consider this scenario very unlikely, we aim to reobserve the star to check the profile for variability. 6. Conclusions We derived the mean line broadening profile of V 102, a back- ground star of spectral type A9 in the region of the young open cluster IC 4665. From the broadening profile we determined a projected rotation velocity of v sin i = 105 ± 12 km s−1. The broadening profile significantly differs from classical rotation broadening and we discuss several scenarios for such a pro- file. The most plausible scenario is that V 102 does not rotate as a solid body but that its equator rotates at a higher velocity than the pole. For that case we derive a difference in polar and equatorial angular velocities of ∆Ω = 3.6 ± 0.8 rad d−1, or ∆Ω/Ω = 0.42 ± 0.09. This is so far the strongest observed case of differential rotation. The equator of V 102 laps the polar region once every 40 hours, compared to roughly 120 days on the Sun. Three other stars with strong differential rotation of the order of ∆Ω/Ω = 0.3 have been reported in Reiners & Royer (2004), A. Reiners et al.: Strong latitudinal shear in IC4665 V102 5 they have colors of B − V = 0.29 or 0.30. Our result supports evidence for differential rotation being strongest in a class of rapidly rotating objects with very shallow convection zones. Acknowledgements. A.R. has received research funding from the European Commission's Sixth Framework Programme as an Outgoing International Fellow (MOIF-CT-2004-002544). References Cox, A.N., 2000, Allen's astrophysical quantities, 4th ed., AIP Press, Springer, New York, Editedy by Arthur N. Cox Giampapa, M.S., Prosser, C.F. & Fleming, T.A., 1998, ApJ, 501, 624 Gray, D. F., 1977, ApJ, 211, 198 Gray, D. F., & Nagel, T., 1989, ApJ, 341, 421 Gray, D. F., 1998, ASP Conf. Ser. 154, Tenth Cambridge Workshop on Cool Stars, Stellar Systems and the Sun, p. 193 Ivanov, G., Pakuliak, L., & Sergeeva, T., 1999, The FON Astrographic Catalogue, Main Astronomical Observatory of NASU Kislyuk, V., Yatsenko, A., Kupka, F., Piskunov, N.E., Ryabchikova, T.A., Stempels, H.C. & Weiss, W.W., 1999, A&AS, 138, 119 McCarthy, M.F. & O'Sullivan, S.J., Ric. Astron., 7, 483 Pallavicini, R., Golub., L., Rosner, R., Vaiana, G.S., Ayres, T. & Linsky, J.L., 1981, ApJ, 248, 279 Prosser, C.F., 1993, AJ, 105, 1441 Reiners, A., 2003, A&A, 408, 707 Reiners, A. & Schmitt, J.H.M.M., 2003a, A&A, 398, 647 Reiners, A. & Schmitt, J.H.M.M., 2003b, A&A, 412, 813 Reiners, A. & Schmitt, J.H.M.M. 2002a, A&A, 384, 155 Reiners, A. & Schmitt, J.H.M.M. 2002b, A&A, 388, 1120 Reiners, A. & Royer, F., 2004, A&A, 415, 325 Schmitt, J.H.M.M., 1997, A&A, 318, 215
astro-ph/9810422	1	9810	1998-10-26T21:46:45	The Earliest Phases of Galaxy Evolution	[ "astro-ph" ]	In this paper we study the very early phases of the evolution of our Galaxy by means of a chemical evolution model which reproduces most of the observational constraints in the solar vicinity and in the disk. We have restricted our analysis to the solar neighborhood and present the predicted abundances of several elements (C, N, O, Mg, Si, S, Ca, Fe) over an extended range of metallicities $[Fe/H] = -4.0$ to $[Fe/H] = 0.0$ compared to previous models. We adopted the most recent yield calculations for massive stars taken from different authors (Woosley & Weaver 1995 and Thielemann et al. 1996) and compared the results with a very large sample of data, one of the largest ever used to this purpose. These data have been analysed with a new and powerful statistical method which allows us to quantify the observational spread in measured elemental abundances and obtain a more meaningful comparison with the predictions from our chemical evolution model. Our analysis shows that the ``plateau'' observed for the [$\alpha$/Fe] ratios at low metallicities ($-3.0< [Fe/H] <-1.0$) is not perfectly constant but it shows a slope, especially for oxygen. This slope is very well reproduced by our model with both sets of yields. This is not surprising since realistic chemical evolution models, taking into account in detail stellar lifetimes, never predicted a completely flat plateau. This is due either to the fact that massive stars of different mass produce a slightly different O/Fe ratio or to the often forgotten fact that supernovae of type Ia, originating from white dwarfs, start appearing already at a galactic age of 30 million years and reach their maximum at 1 Gyr.	astro-ph	astro-ph	The Earliest Phases of Galaxy Evolution Cristina Chiappini Departamento de Astronomia - Observat´orio Nacional (ON/CNPq), Cx. Postal 23002, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil Francesca Matteucci Dipartimento di Astronomia, Universit`a di Trieste, SISSA, Via Beirut 2-4, I-34013 Trieste, Italy Timothy C. Beers Department of Physics and Astronomy Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824 and Ken'ichi Nomoto Department of Astronomy and Research Center for the Early Universe University of Tokyo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113 ABSTRACT In this paper we study the very early phases of the evolution of our Galaxy by means of a chemical evolution model which reproduces most of the observational constraints in the solar vicinity and in the disk. We have restricted our analysis to the solar neighborhood and present the predicted abundances of several elements (C, N, O, Mg, Si, S, Ca, Fe) over an extended range of metallicities [Fe/H] = −4.0 to [Fe/H] = 0.0 compared to previous models. We adopted the most recent yield calculations for massive stars taken from different authors (Woosley & Weaver 1995 and Thielemann et al. 1996) and compared the results with a very large sample of data, one of the largest ever used to this purpose. We have obtained this by selecting the most recent and higher quality abundance data from a number of sources and renormalizing them to the same solar abundances. These data have been analysed with a new and powerful statistical method which allows us to quantify the observational spread in measured elemental abundances and obtain a more meaningful comparison with the predictions from our chemical evolution model. Our analysis shows that the "plateau" observed for the [α/Fe] ratios at low metallicities (−3.0 < [F e/H] < −1.0) is not perfectly constant but it shows a slope, especially for oxygen. This slope is very well reproduced by our model with both sets of yields. This is not surprising since realistic chemical evolution models, taking into account in detail stellar lifetimes, never predicted a completely flat plateau. This is due either to the fact that massive stars -- 2 -- of different mass produce a slightly different O/Fe ratio or to the often forgotten fact that supernovae of type Ia, originating from white dwarfs, start appearing already at a galactic age of 30 million years and reach their maximum at 1 Gyr. For lower metallicities (−4.0 < [F e/H] < −3.0) the two sets of adopted yields differ, especially for iron. In this range the "plateau" is almost constant since at such low metallicities there is almost no contribution from type Ia supernovae. However, there are not enough data in this domain to significantly test this point. Finally, we show the evolution with redshift of the [O/Fe] ratio for different cosmologies and conclude that a sharp rise of this ratio should be observed at high redshift, irrespective of the adopted yields. The same behaviour is expected for the [O/Zn] ratio which should be easier to compare with the abundances observed in high redshift Damped Lyman-α systems, as these elements are likely not to be affected by dust. Future measurements of either [α/Fe] or [α/Zn] ratios in very metal poor stars will be very useful to infer the nature and the age of high-redshift objects. Subject headings: Galaxy: evolution - abundances 1. Introduction The importance of developing an understanding of the earliest phases of galaxy evolution is clear. For example, one might hope to explain details of the heavy element abundance distributions measured in high-redshift galaxies and the metallic systems associated with damped Lyman-alpha systems (e.g., Pettini et al. 1997). Another important reason is that one can compare the abundances of extremely-metal-poor stars with the predictions of chemical evolution models, and thereby impose severe constraints on the theoretical nucleosynthesis calculations in massive stars (M ≥ 10 M⊙). The most massive stars present at the first epoch of star formation were, of course, the first to restore chemically-enriched gas back into the interstellar medium. Because of their long main-sequence lifetimes and lack of deep convection zones, the lower-mass stars (M ≤ 0.8 M⊙) which formed at that same time have preserved the patterns of elemental abundances generated by the initial burst of star formation. Many studies concerning the predicted nucleosynthetic yields of massive stars have appeared in the last few years, all of which attempt to take into account the effect of the initial stellar metallicity on the final yields (Maeder 1992; Woosley & Weaver, hereafter WW95; Langer & Henkel 1996, Thielemann et al. 1996, hereafter TNH96). The most dramatic differences are found between the predicted yields from stars with metallicity Z = 0 and stars with Z 6= 0, as shown by the calculations of WW95. From the standpoint of Galactic chemical evolution such a difference is not so important, because very few stars with truly zero metal content must have ever existed, as only a few supernovae (SN) explosions are required to raise the metallic content of the ISM to a non-zero value within a few million years. For stars with Z > 0, the effects of small differences -- 3 -- in initial stellar metallicity on the predicted final yields of heavy elements appear to be almost negligible. Several studies, such as Arnett (1995), WW95, and TNH96, include approximate treatments of explosive nucleosynthesis on the final predicted yields of chemical elements. The effects of mass loss by stellar winds in very massive stars (M > 30 − 40 M⊙) on the nucleosynthetic yields has been investigated by Maeder (1992), Woosley et al. (1993; 1995), and Langer & Henkel (1996). The net effect of mass loss is to decrease the total yield of metals produced by massive stars because of the helium which is subtracted from further processing. We took into account the presence of mass loss in massive stars by adopting the mass-mass of the He-core relation of Maeder and Meynet (1989). There are, of course, many uncertainties still present in modern nucleosynthesis calculations, as is aptly illustrated by the disparity among various studies concerning the yield of iron (and other iron-peak elements) produced in massive stars. In the WW95 study, for example, the iron yield does not exhibit a monotonic behaviour as a function of the initial stellar mass, as it decreases for masses larger than ≃ 35 M⊙. By contrast, in TNH96 the iron yield is an ever-increasing function of the initial stellar mass, but it is systematically lower than the yields of WW95 for masses smaller than ≃ 30 M⊙. The reason for these differences can be traced to the different physical inputs to the two sets of calculations, namely, the iron and helium core masses, the assumed rate of the 12C(α, γ)16O reaction, differences in the adopted explosion mechanism, etc. (see WW95 for a detailed discussion). Given the "flexibility" of the predicted yields of heavy elements, it is of interest to explore the nature and the magnitude of differences which arise in models of Galactic chemical evolution as a result of the use of the different yields. In this paper, we compare yields from different authors by means of a model of chemical evolution for our Galaxy which reproduces the main observational features (Chiappini et al. 1997), and compare the predictions with one of the largest sample of abundances ever used for this purpose (see also Samland 1998). Particular emphasis is given to the predictions for very-metal-poor stars since they place the strongest constraints on the available yields for massive stars and on the different theories for the progenitors of type Ia SNe. In performing this comparison we use a statistical analysis discussed by Ryan et al. (1996) in order to define the best fit to the data, which always show a considerable spread, and to compare these best fits with the theoretical predictions. The main aim of this paper is to provide the best fits of a large number of elemental ratios as functions of [Fe/H] and compare them with detailed model predictions in order to impose constraints on the nucleosynthesis in massive stars, type Ia SN progenitors, timescale for the formation of the halo and thick disk and finally to predict the behaviour of the relative abundance ratios as functions of redshift in the context of different cosmological models. In fact, abundance ratios can be used either as cosmic clocks or to infer the nature of high -redshift objects. The paper is organized as follows. In §2 we summarize the available observational data from -- 4 -- literature studies of the elemental abundances in metal-poor stars. In §3 we describe the statistical method adopted to describe the best fit to the observed data. A brief description of the chemical evolution model is given in §4. In §5 we discuss a prediction of the [O/Fe] ratio for objects formed at high redshift. In §6 our results are presented and some conclusions drawn. 2. Observational Data Over the past few decades, many studies of very-metal-poor stars have been carried out (e.g., Wallerstein et al. 1963; Spite & Spite 1978; Luck & Bond 1985; Magain 1987; Gilroy et al. 1988; Peterson et al. 1990; Gratton & Sneden 1988,1991; McWilliam et al. 1995; Ryan et al. 1991; 1996). The most recent results, based on stars selected from the HK survey of Beers et al. (1985; 1992), have probed the nature of the relative abundances of elements in large samples of stars at extremely low metallicity. In the McWilliam et al. (1995) study, for instance, the abundances of several heavy elements are derived for 33 extremely-metal-deficient giants, with −4.0 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ −2.0. They found previously unnoticed trends of [Cr/Fe], [Mn/Fe] and [Co/Fe] with [Fe/H]. Both [Cr/Fe] and [Mn/Fe] exhibit a decline of about 0.5 dex with decreasing iron abundance between [Fe/H] = −2.4 and [Fe/H] = −4.0. On the other hand, [Co/Fe] increases by about 0.5 dex over the same range in iron abundance. They confirmed the well known decline in [Al/Fe], [Sr/Fe] and [Ba/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H]. The remarkable fact is that all six of these abundance ratios show a sudden change of slope near [Fe/H] = −2.4. McWilliam et al. concluded that a distinct phase of nucleosynthesis occurred before the Galaxy reached an abundance [Fe/H] ∼ −2.4, their preferred scenario being that of variable stellar yields, either changing with mass, metallicity, or both. Concerning the α-elements, McWilliam et al. found [Mg/Fe], [Si/Fe] and [Ca/Fe] to be overabundant relative to iron ([α/Fe] = +0.44 ± 0.02 dex), confirming the trends found for other halo stars at higher abundances. The element titanium, often considered to be an alpha element, exhibited a smaller overabundance relative to iron, [Ti/Fe]= +0.31 dex. This difference was interpreted as due to a larger contribution to Ti from type Ia SN. However, at very low metallicities [Mg/Fe] appears to decrease whereas [Ti/Mg] and [Ca/Mg] increase by ≃0.2 dex from [Fe/H] = −2.0 to [Fe/H] = −4.0. McWilliam et al. interpreted this as the possible effect of metallicity-dependent yields. Another remarkable result of their study is the large spread (up to 3 dex for a given [Fe/H]) observed in the abundance ratios of some of the heavy elements, especially in [Sr/Fe] and [Ba/Fe], which they interpreted as intrinsic and due to incomplete mixing of the ISM of the early Galaxy. The same conclusion had been already reached by Ryan et al. (1991) and Primas et al. (1994) from the spread they observed in [Sr/Fe] and [Ba/Fe] ratios at very low metallicities. Ryan et al. (1996) obtained abundances for 19 extremely-metal-poor stars (giants and dwarfs). They found that the α elements (Mg, Si, Ca and Ti) have almost uniform overabundances relative to iron down to [Fe/H]≃ −4, which is the current limit of observations. They also observed -- 5 -- a slight increase in the [Mg/Fe] ratio at [Fe/H] < −2.5. These authors found that Ti behaves like the other α-elements and confirmed the underabundance of [Cr/Fe] and [Mn/Fe], and the underabundance of [Co/Fe], in stars with [Fe/H] < −2.5, as reported by McWilliam et al. . These authors concluded that there is a real star-to-star abundance differences at the lowest metallicities, and that this spread exists for both dwarfs and giants, indicating that the observed spread cannot be explained by appealing to mixing processes within the stars themselves. Ryan et al. also discussed a model in which an assumed correlation between SN iron-peak yields and explosive energies is able to explain the existence of well-defined (low scatter) trends among a number of heavy elements (such as Cr, Mn, and Co) down to an abundance [Fe/H] ∼ −2.7, despite the fact that enrichment of the ISM of the proto-halo took place under chaotic and inhomogeneous mixing conditions. The most important recent study on disk stars is that of Edvardsson et al. (1993), who derived abundances of O, Na, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Fe, Ni, Y, Zr, Ba and Nd as well as individual photometric ages for 189 nearby disk population F and G dwarfs. They also estimated, from kinematical data, the orbital parameters of the stars and derived estimates of the Galactocentric distances of the stellar birthplaces. From their high signal-to-noise spectra and a careful treatment of stellar temperatures, Edvardsson et al. obtained iron abundances and abundance ratios relative to iron for most elements with accuracies at a level of 0.05 dex. They found a considerable variation in the metallicity of stars formed at a given time in the disk, implying only a weak correlation between age and metallicity. Their result strongly suggests there is no single age-metallicity relation, but rather several such relations due to different chemical evolution rates in different parts of the Galaxy. Metal-poor ([Fe/H] < −0.4) stars in their sample were shown to be relatively overabundant in the α-elements, confirming all the previous studies, but the most interesting finding is that the [α/Fe] ratios for these metal-poor stars decreases with increasing Galactocentric distance. This implies that star formation started first and proceeded more vigorously in the Galactic center than farther out in the disk, confirming theoretical suggestions about an inside-out formation of the Galaxy (Chiosi & Matteucci, 1980; Matteucci & Fran¸cois 1989, hereafter MF89, Burkert et al. 1992). The scatter found in abundance ratios such as [Si/Fe] is only about 0.05 dex, about 50 times less than the corresponding range in [Fe/H]. In their work they discussed possible explanations for this effect, including orbital diffusion and infall of unenriched material. On the other hand, Fran¸cois & Matteucci (1993) showed that orbital diffusion, coupled with the fact that the Galaxy formed at different rates at different Galactocentric distances, can explain most of the observed spread in [Fe/H] and [α/Fe], and also the fact that the spread in the abundance ratios is smaller than the range in absolute abundances. In this paper we will restrict our attention only to C, N, O, Mg, Si, S, Ca, and Fe as they are the elements for which data of good quality are available and because they allow us to study in particular the [α/Fe] ratios, which are very useful tools to constrain stellar nucleosynthesis, Galactic evolution, and the nature of high-redshift objects. -- 6 -- 2.1. Oxygen The element oxygen deserves a special discussion. The main concern in abundance studies of this element arises due to the paucity of samples of significant size analysed in a homogeneous way. In combined samples, the possible existence of systematic offsets between different sets of data and the discrepancy between O abundances determined using high-excitation permitted and low-excitation forbidden lines (the first usually observed in dwarfs, the latter in giants) limits our ability to interpret observed trends. In an effort to remove the discrepancy between dwarfs and giants, Gratton et al. (1996) reanalyzed the abundances of O and Fe in a large sample of stars in the solar neighbourhood, taking into account recent higher temperature estimates in the analysis of dwarfs, and departures from the LTE assumption when considering the formation of high-excitation permitted OI lines. They found that the [O/Fe] ratio is nearly constant ([O/Fe] ≃ +0.5 dex) among inner-halo and thick-disk stars. Moreover, their data suggest that the [O/Fe] decreases by ≃ 0.2 dex while the [O/H] ratio remains constant during the transition between thick- and thin- disk phases, indicating a sudden decrease in star formation at that epoch. In a recent paper Israelian et al. (1998) performed a detailed abundance analysis of 23 unevolved metal-poor stars and found that the [O/Fe] ratio increases from 0.6 to 1.0 between [Fe/H] -1.5 and -3. In that paper the abundances were determined using the OH bands in the near UV, with high resolution. They also address the long standing controversy, mentioned above, between oxygen abundances from forbidden and permitted lines and show that this can be resolved. As our paper was already submitted these data were not included in the present investigation but their implications are discussed in §3. 2.2. Carbon The results on carbon are still somewhat controversial. Laird (1985) determined carbon abundances in a large sample of halo an disk dwarfs, and found [C/Fe]= −0.22 dex , with an intrinsic scatter of 0.1 dex, over the entire metallicity range considered (−2.5 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ +0.5). However, an analysis of the [C/Fe] ratio as a function of the effective temperature indicated a systematic offset in the derived abundances; a correction of 0.20 dex was applied to all the [C/Fe] determinations, resulting in roughly solar values. Tomkin et al. (1986) examined 32 halo dwarfs with abundances in the range −2.5 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ −0.7 dex and found that [C/Fe] = −0.2 ± 0.15 dex for [Fe/H] > −1.8 dex. Carbon et al. (1987) derived carbon abundances for 83 dwarfs in the metallicity range −2.5 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ −0.6. They found a solar [C/Fe] ratio over most of the metallicity range, with a star-to-star scatter of 0.18 dex. They also noticed a slight increase of [C/Fe] at very low metallicities, but noted that this upturn is sensitive to the assumed O abundance. Wheeler et al. (1989) reanalyzed all three surveys and attempted to place them onto a common effective temperature scale. The overall trend of slightly increasing [C/Fe] ratio at low metallicities did not disappear. -- 7 -- One important recent result which may be of considerable significance to the chemical evolution of the early Galaxy is the fact that the most metal-poor stars exhibit a surprisingly high incidence of carbon enrichment. Roughly 15% of the stars in the sample of Beers et al. (1992) with [Fe/H] < −2.5 have CH (G-band) features which are stronger than normal (see figure 1 of Norris, Ryan, & Beers 1997a). Large [C/Fe] ratios appear to exist among a number of extremely-metal-poor dwarfs and subgiants, as well as giants. Among the carbon-rich stars at extremely low abundance is the r-process enhanced star CS 22892-052, discussed in detail by Sneden et al. (1994, 1996), and Norris et al. (1997a). High-resolution spectroscopic studies of other stars with [Fe/H] < −2.5 and large carbon abundances have been presented by Barbuy et al. (1997), Norris et al. (1997a), Norris et al. (1997b), and Bonifacio et al. (1998). The most extreme cases exhibit [C/Fe] ratios roughly 2 dex above the solar value. The mechanism by which carbon has been produced and/or enhanced in these extreme stars is still unknown. Since it remains possible that all or most of the carbon-enhancement may be due to mixing processes within the stars themselves, or due to the transfer of material from an evolved companion star, we have chosen not to include these stars in the data for our present study. The apparently constant and solar [C/Fe] ratio over the range from [Fe/H] ∼ −2.5 to disk metallicities would seem to indicate that C and Fe, although produced through different nucleosynthesis mechanisms (C being produced through the triple−α process during hydrostatic helium burning in stars of all masses, whereas Fe is synthesized in explosive burning conditions), are originating from similar stellar mass ranges. In other words, the two elements should be mainly produced in the same relative proportions. Anderson & Edvardsson (1994) determined the [C/Fe] ratio in 85 dwarfs in the metallicity range −1.0 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ +0.25 and found that this ratio is slowly decreasing with time and increasing metallicity in the disk. This would indicate a slightly more significant production of carbon from massive stars relative to their iron production. Moreover, Tomkin et al. (1995) determined C abundances in 105 dwarfs in the range −0.8 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ +0.2 and found a moderate enrichment of C in metal-deficient stars, on the order of [C/Fe]= +0.2 ± 0.05 at [Fe/H] = −0.8. Such a behaviour is qualitatively similar to that seen for α-elements and oxygen. The carbon isotope 13C seems to show a predominantly secondary origin, confirmed by the behavior of the 12C/13C ratio in the ISM along the Galactic disk (increasing with decreasing iron abundance -- see Wilson & Matteucci, 1992; Wilson & Rood 1994). 2.3. Nitrogen Nitrogen abundances derived from stellar spectroscopy, especially at low metallicities, are the most uncertain. Laird (1985) determined nitrogen abundances in 116 dwarfs. The survey covered the metallicity range −2.5 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ +0.5, with most of the stars having [Fe/H] > −2.0. He found [N/Fe]= −0.67 ± 0.2 over the entire metallicity range. As discussed by Laird (1985) the reason for this offset is not clear and may be related to a systematic error in the temperature scale. He then applied an offset of +0.65 dex to all the [N/Fe] ratios. -- 8 -- Carbon et al. (1987) derived nitrogen abundances for 83 dwarfs in the range In the present −2.5 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ −0.6, with the majority of stars having [Fe/H] < −1.5. investigation we are adopting the Carbon et al. data for N without any correction for a Teff dependence (see Carbon et al. for a discussion on this correction). From figure 2 it can be seen that when the raw data from Carbon et al. are adopted they are not inconsistent with a secondary N scenario for massive stars although any conclusion about this point still waits for better data. If, as suggested by Carbon et al., their data should be corrected for this temperature dependence, then [N/Fe] turns out to be roughly constant over the entire metallicity range. In that case, as for carbon, this implies that both Fe and N, although they have a different nucleosynthetic origin, are produced in the same proportions in the same stellar mass ranges. However, as stressed by Wheeler et al. (1989) we still are left with considerable uncertainty in the preferred [N/Fe] value even if it is constant with metallicity. The isotope 15N in the ISM has been recently studied by Dahmen et al. (1995), who derived a Galactic gradient of [14N/15N] of 19 ± 8.9 dex kpc−1, and concluded that 15N should be considered a secondary element (normally "secondary" means produced proportionally to the initial stellar metal content, although the same behaviour can be expected if an element is produced without a metallicity dependence but restored on long timescales), and that 14N has a significant primary component. 3. Observed Trends and Scatter We have made an effort to obtain a more quantitative comparison between model predictions and observations of the elemental abundance ratios elements as a function of metallicity. Accordingly, we include in our data set essentially all published observations of the elements under consideration (C, N, O, Mg, Si, S, Ca and Fe), and renormalize all data to a common solar value (the Anders & Grevesse 1989, hereafter AG89, meteoritic values). This is especially important for the adopted solar iron abundance, which has changed (in the literature) by about 0.2 dex in the last 10 years. We recognize, however, that this normalization alone is not enough to obtain an homogeneous sample and that, for instance, we should also correct for the different adopted oscillator strengths (gf). In the case of a differential analysis the correction for the gfs should not be very important whereas for the absolute analysis this correction may not be not negligible. However, this effect is not as important for metal-poor stars as it is for more metal-rich ones (Fran¸cois private communication). As the amount of data for the relative abundances of elements in samples of metal-poor stars increases, it is important to consider improvements in the methodology which we use to describe and analyse the trends which are revealed. Following the approach described by Ryan et al. (1996), we have made use of the summary statistics of Cleveland & Kleiner (1975). After applying corrections to the literature values of abundance ratios (as described above) we obtained a straight average for each elemental ratio. We then obtain three lines which summarize the trend -- 9 -- of the data as a function of [Fe/H]. The three lines are: MM -- the midmean -- an average of all data between the quartiles of the distribution of relative abundances over a given range in [Fe/H]; LSMM -- the lower semi-midmean -- the midmean of all observations below the median; USMM -- the midmean of all observations above the median. If the data are scattered about the midmean according to a normal distribution, the semi-midmeans are estimates of the true quartiles. We have checked this assumption, and it appears to hold, at least globally (over all values of [Fe/H]) for each of the abundance ratios considered herein. In Figures 1 and 2 we show plots of the resulting summary lines, obtained by taking either 10 or 15 data points in the estimation window, depending on the density of data. The final plots represent locally weighted regression (lowess; see Cleveland & Devlin 1988) smooths of the summary lines. Figures 1 and 2 show our plots for O, Mg, Ca, Si, S, C and N respectively. Those elements were chosen not only because they are the most abundant and consequently less uncertain but also because for even-z elements the yields are less dependent on the metallicity (see WW95 and Samland 1997). Samland shows that the stellar models tend to underestimate the yields of odd-z elements, but that there is a good agreement for the even-z ones. The left panels of these figures show the original data sets quoted in Table 1 compared to the models; the right panels show a comparison between the trend lines obtained from the data and the model predictions (see a description of the different models in the next section). At a first glance of figures 1 and 2 one sees that the so-called plateau for the [α/Fe] ratios at low metallicities is not really constant. This is an important fact and it is very likely to be real. In fact, it is not surprising that the plateau is not constant, since theoretical models always predict a slight decrease of [α/Fe] ratios during the halo phase and this is due to the fact that massive stars of different masses produce slightly different O/Fe ratios. In addition, as predicted by the canonical model for SNe Ia (Matteucci and Greggio, 1986) the first SNe appear already after 30 million years although they reach a maximum at around 1 Gyr from the beginning of the evolution. This epoch corresponds to a metallicity of [Fe/H] ∼-1.0 and to the more drastic change of slope in the [α/Fe] ratios. Only simple models where the SN Ia are imposed to appear only after 1 Gyr produce a flat plateau. This large new collection of data is therefore important since it shows clearly this effect. Recently, Israelian et al. (1998) presented new [O/Fe] data, not included in this study, showing that oxygen is overabundant relative to iron, with the [O/Fe] ratio increasing from +0.6 to +1.0 going from [Fe/H]=−1.5 to −3.0. This overabundance is larger than it is shown by the data used in this paper. Moreover they show that the plateau of the [O/Fe] ratio is not constant but it has a slope of −0.31 ± 0.11 in the range −3.0<[Fe/H]< −1.0. It is instructive to consider the spread of the abundance ratios about the underlying trend lines over several intervals of [Fe/H]. To do this, we first obtain the lowess line for each elemental ratio as a function of [Fe/H], then derive the residual in the ordinate of each data point about the trend. In Table 2 we summarize robust estimators of scale for these residuals over the metallicity -- 10 -- intervals: −0.5 > [Fe/H]; −1.5 > [Fe/H] ≤ −0.5; −2.5 < [Fe/H] ≤ −1.5; [Fe/H] ≤ −2.5. The scale estimator we employ, the biweight estimator SBI discussed by Beers et al. (1990), has been shown to have the desirable property that it is not overly influenced by outliers, and approaches the more-commonly-applied standard deviation estimator of scale for samples drawn from a normal parent distribution. For a number of elements we had to combine stars across several abundance intervals due to the paucity of extant data -- entries in the table span the columns over which the abundances have been combined. For each entry in the table we also include an estimate of the 68% (one-sigma) bootstrap confidence interval about the biweight estimate of scale, indicated as IS68, which is useful for assessing the significance of the change in spread from one abundance interval to the next. In the table we also indicate an estimate of the 95% range in the residuals, obtained as R95 = 2 x 1.96 SBI , since 1.96 SBI is the one-sided two-sigma interval of a normal distribution. Figure 3 summarizes the data shown in Table 2. This figure shows that the scatter in the abundance ratios increases with decreasing metal abundance, at least for Ca, Mg, and Si (the alpha elements for which substantial amounts of data are available). For O the scatter is essentially constant over the metallicity range but the statistics are poor, although the sample is a more homogeneous one. In the case of N the data show an increase in the scatter of the [N/Fe] ratio as metallicity decreases. However, as already discussed in §2.3 the data for low metallicities are very uncertain and are probably affected by the [N/Fe] vs Teff correlation found by Carbon et al. (1987). The trend lines in Figure 2 show an obvious decrease in [N/Fe] at low metallicity (when the raw data of Carbon et al. are adopted), but no data presently exist for stars with [Fe/H] ≤ −3.0, so we cannot be certain not only that this trend exists but even if it continues to lower abundances. The scatter in the [C/Fe] ratios also increases as the metallicity decreases. For this element the trend lines in Figure 2 show a small bump around [Fe/H] = −0.5 and a slight increase in the [C/Fe] ratio for metallicities [Fe/H] < −2 (already noted by Carbon et al. 1987). 4. The Chemical Evolution Model The model of chemical evolution we adopt here is that of Chiappini et al. (1997), where a detailed description can be found. We recall the main assumptions of this model: • The Galactic disk is approximated by several independent rings, 2 kpc wide, without exchange of matter between them. Continuous infall of gas ensures the temporal increase of the surface mass density σT ot in each ring. • The instantaneous recycling approximation is relaxed. This is of fundamental importance in treating those isotopes, such as 14N and 56Fe, which are mostly produced by long-lived stars. • The prescription for the star formation rate (SFR) is: T otσk1 g SF R ∝ σk2 (1) -- 11 -- where σT ot is the total surface mass density and σg is the surface gas density and k1 = 1.5 and k2 = 0.5. A threshold in the surface gas density (∼ 7 M⊙pc−2) is also assumed; when the gas density drops below this threshold the star formation stops. The existence of such a threshold has been suggested by star formation studies (Kennicutt 1989). • For the initial mass function (IMF) we adopt the prescriptions from Scalo (1986) as described in Chiappini et al. (1997). • This model assumes that the halo+thick disk and the thin disk are formed during two different infall episodes -- the thin disk does not form out of gas shed from the halo and the thick disk, but simply out of external gas. Such an interpretation is supported by recent dynamical and kinematical studies of stars in the outer Galactic halo by Sommer-Larsen et al. (1997). Under these hypotheses, the infall rate is given by: dGi(r, t) dt = A(r)(Xinf )ie−t/τT σT ot(r, tG) + B(r)(Xinf )ie−(t−tmax)/τD(r) σT ot(r, tG) (2) where τT represents the time scale for the formation of the halo and the thick disk, and τD(r) represents the time scale for disk formation, which is assumed to increase with Galactocentric distance. The best-fit model of Chiappini et al. (1997) suggests that the timescale for the formation of the halo and thick disk is quite short (∼ 0.5 − 1.0 Gyr) whereas the timescale for the formation of the thin disk is quite long (∼ 8.0 Gyr for the solar vicinity). This timescale for the thin disk ensures a very good fit of the new data on the G-dwarf metallicity distribution (Wyse & Gilmore 1995; Rocha-Pinto & Maciel 1996). A(r) and B(r) are derived by the condition of reproducing the present total surface mass density distribution in the solar vicinity. (Xinf )i is the abundance of the element i in the infalling material and TG the age of the Galaxy. The contributions to the chemical enrichment from supernovae of different type (Ia, Ib and II) as well as from stars dying as C-O white dwarfs and contributing processed elements through stellar winds and the planetary nebula phase are taken into account in great detail (see Chiappini et al. 1997). The adopted nucleosynthesis prescriptions are from: (a) Renzini & Voli (1981) for intermediate stellar masses and (b) Thielemann et al. (1993) and Nomoto et al. (1997b) for SNe Ia. For the massive stars we considered two different sets of yields, one from WW95 and the other from TNH96. Figures 4 and 5 show comparisons between both sets of yields for massive stars. In these figures we show also the abundance yields adopted by MF89. WW95 present the yield calculations for stars of up to 40 M⊙, whereas TNH96 obtained the yields for stars of up to 70 M⊙(where the yields for the 18, 40 and 70 M⊙stars are given in Nomoto et al. 1997a and Tsujimoto et al. 1995). Both sets were extrapolated up to Mup = 100 M⊙, though this has little effect on -- 12 -- the results for the chemical evolution of the Galaxy, as the adopted IMF predicts very few stars more massive than 40 M⊙. Matteucci (1996) shows a comparison of yields relative to stars of different metallicities for some of the most important heavy elements. She shows that there are non-negligible differences in the yields from Z = 0 and Z 6= 0 in the WW95 calculations (at least for C, O, Mg, Si and Fe) whereas the yields for different initial metallicities greater than zero are very similar (Z = 0.0001, 0.0002, 0.0020 and 0.0200). As discussed in the introduction, from the point of view of Galactic evolution this difference is not very important since very few stars of zero metallicity must have existed. WW95 present several tables for different metallicities, with the ejected mass as a function of initial stellar mass. We adopt the table which corresponds to the calculation made for Z = Z⊙. The main differences seen in Figure 5, for the elements Si, Ca and S, are due to the adopted yields in MF89 and the present ones. The difference originates in the fact that both the sets of recent yields contain explosive nucleosynthesis calculations. The yields for massive stars adopted by MF89 were from Woosley & Weaver (1986), which did not include the explosion mechanism in their calculations. To overcome this problem MF89 assumed that the fraction of Si-Ca elements which fall back into the collapsing cores of the post-explosion remnants were roughly 40% of what is remaining of the Si-Ca elements after subtracting the iron. As discussed by these authors, this value was uncertain and was chosen to give the best agreement with the observations. The abundances of elements lighter than silicon are almost unmodified by the explosion (see WW95) and the nuclei which are ejected are the same ones present in the pre-supernova star. The yields for S, Si and Ca obtained by TNH96 are systematically larger than those obtained by WW95 for stars more massive than 30 M⊙, whereas they are smaller for masses below this value. The elements Si, S and Ca are products of explosive oxygen burning, and the difference of their yields may stem from (the difference in the explosion energy and/or) the difference in the presupernova density structure of the innermost oxygen layer due to the different treatment of convection. The yields of the most abundant isotopes are not very different. The first example is 16O, which is the most abundant heavy element made in massive stars. Oxygen is produced by helium-burning and neon-burning, and its synthesis is expected to be roughly independent of metallicity. The main source of uncertainty for the 16O and 12C yields is ascribed to the uncertainties in the 12C(α, γ)16O reaction, although the 12C production is also sensitive to details of convection (see WW95 for a discussion). The iron yield from WW95 is higher than the TNH96 value for stars with masses below ≃ 35 M⊙. The iron (and iron-group elements) yield depends strongly on the mass cut that divides the ejecta and the material fallen back onto the neutron star or black hole, thus being sensitive to the explosion mechanism. Hence the predicted yields are uncertain by (at least) a factor of two. In fact, Timmes et al. (1995) suggested that the iron yields from WW95 should be lowered by just this factor. This would lead to an agreement with the TNH96 values for these elements. -- 13 -- For the element Mg we can see a non-negligible difference between both sets of calculations, which would primarily stem from the different treatment of convection (i.e., stability criterion and semi-convective mixing). The WW95 values are much smaller than the TNH96 ones. Chiappini et al. (1997) adopted in their chemical evolution model the WW95 yields, and suggested that it might be appropriate to increase the Mg yields in order to obtain a solar value of Mg in agreement with the observed one. In Figure 6 we present the masses ejected in the form of various elements, weighted by the IMF in the range of massive stars, as a function of the initial mass of the progenitor star for WW95 (upper panel) and TNH96 (lower panel) and calculations, respectively. The new calculations also include the yields for 14N. Figure 7 presents the same plot as Figure 6 for this element (solid line: WW95 and dot-dashed line: TNH96). 14N in massive stars is thought to be mostly secondary although some primary contribution can occur. In Table 3 we show the predicted and observed solar abundances of the elements under consideration adopting each of the two sets of predicted yields (model A with WW95 yields and Model B with the TNH96 yields) and the solar abundance values from Anders and Grevesse (1989). The differences between columns (2) and (3) reflect the differences in the adopted yields for massive stars (in Table 3, the exponents are shown in parentheses). We can see that the difference for 14N in the final abundances is small, even with the very different predictions seen in Figure 7, as this element is mainly produced by stars with progenitors in the intermediate-mass range. The yields adopted for the intermediate-mass range are the same in both models (Renzini & Voli 1981). Note the good agreement for the solar iron abundance when the TNH96 values are adopted. In §6 we discuss the differences in the predicted abundance ratios as a function of metallicity for the two sets of yields considered in this paper. 5. The Abundance Ratio of [O/Fe] at High Redshift In figures 8 and 9 we show the predicted [O/Fe] ratios as functions of redshift for different cosmologies. In particular, a cosmology is identified by the age of the Universe TU , the redshift of the galaxy formation zf , the density parameter Ω0 and the cosmological constant, Λ. Figure 8 shows the predictions of the model which adopts the yields of WW95; Figure 9 shows the predictions using the yields of THN96. A striking characteristic in both figures is the sharp increase of [O/Fe] at very high redshift. The spike in [O/Fe], which is independent of the adopted yields, is the result of the rapid increase of metallicity at the initiation of the star formation process. For instance, for the cosmological model with TU =15 Gyrs, zf =5, Ω0=1 and Λ=0 (solid line in figures 8 and 9), the initial metallicities are [Fe/H] = −5.8 and −5.4 for TNH96 and WW95, respectively. As already mentioned, it is sufficient that some Type II SNe explode to raise the metal content of the interstellar medium from zero to metallicities of the order of [Fe/H] ∼ −5, already in the first 0.5 Gyrs. For the solid line model, in figure 8, we have that [Fe/H] = −5.4 at -- 14 -- a redshift of 3.52. The [O/Fe] plateau extends until a metallicity of about [Fe/H] = −3.0, which corresponds to a redshift value of 3.51 (in other words, a range in metallicity of ∆[Fe/H] = −2.4 corresponds to a change in redshift of ∆z = 0.01). This explains the peaks when plotting the abundance ratios as functions of redshift instead of metallicity. A similar result applies when adopting the TNH96 yields. The same behavior is expected for the [O/Zn] ratio which should be easier to compare with the abundances observed in high redshift DLA systems, as these elements are likely not to be affected by dust, and because the abundance of Zn has been measured for a large number of such systems (Pettini et al. 1997). The element Zn behaves exactly like iron and therefore is very probably formed in the same way, namely mostly during the explosion of a type Ia SN (see Matteucci et al. 1993). This striking feature can be used to identify proto-spiral galaxies similar to our own Galaxy when observing high redshift objects. This is an important point in view of the fact that more and more data are becoming available for damped Lyman-α systems at high redshifts. 6. Results and Conclusions In this paper we computed the chemical evolution of the solar neighbourhood by adopting two different sets of yields for massive stars with the aim of imposing constraints on the early phases of galaxy evolution. To do that we have assembled one of the largest sample of relative abundance ratios observed in a range of metallicity going from [Fe/H]=−4.0 up to solar. We have adopted a detailed method to compare model predictions and observations in a self-consistent way. This method allowed us to quantify the apparent spread in the data, to discover some new trends and to impose constraints on stellar nucleosynthesis. Our main conclusions can be summarized as follows: - From the analysis of the data sample we found that the so-called "plateau" for the [α/Fe] ratio at low metallicities is not perfectly flat but it presents a slight slope, especially for oxygen. This is an important fact that had been not noticed before since the number of data at low metallicities used to compare with chemical evolution models was always small (except in Samland 1997). This slight slope is in very good agreement with our model predictions for both sets of yields in the metallicity range (−3.0< [Fe/H] < −1.0) and it is due partly to the fact that massive stars of different mass produce slightly different O/Fe ratios and partly to the appearence of SNeIa which start occurring already after 30 million years in the adopted model of a white dwarf plus a red giant companion (Matteucci and Greggio 1986). These supernovae reach then a maximum at around 1Gyr which is the time at which the [O/Fe] ratio starts changing more drastically. This corresponds, in our model, to roughly a metallicity of [Fe/H] = −1.0. If we identify this time with the end of the halo phase, although the border line between halo and thick-disk is not so precise, we can infer that 1 Gyr is the average timescale for the formation of the halo. -- 15 -- - By comparing the different sets of yields used in this paper we can not draw very firm conclusions since both of them can reproduce the solar abundances inside a factor of two. However, going more into detail we can say that the model predictions are in agreement with the observed values, except for two elements which are only marginally consistent with observations, namely, Mg when the WW95 yields are adopted, and 12C when the TNH96 yields are adopted. Moreover, the values of Mg and 12C are always underestimated either adopting TNH96 or WW95 yields. For Mg this has been already shown by Chiappini et al. (1997) and Thomas et al. (1997). In the case of 12C the TNH96 yields are systematically lower than the WW95 ones, and this could be the origin of the "valley" seen in figure 2 for [C/Fe] between the metallicities [Fe/H] = −1 and −3. For oxygen both sets of yields are very similar, at least up to 30 M⊙. However, for masses above 30 M⊙ the yields obtained by TNH96 are larger. While the TNH96 yields for iron in massive stars increase almost linearly with mass up to 40 M⊙ being roughly constant after this value, the calculations by WW95 indicate an iron production which is concentrated in the range between 20 and 30 M⊙. The predicted iron solar abundance obtained when adopting the TNH96 yields is closer to the observed value although the difference between the TNH96 and WW95 values are smaller than the uncertainties involved. It can be seen that the O/Fe ratio for very high mass stars varies with the stellar mass much more in WW95 predictions than in the TNH96 ones. This influences the slope of the [O/Fe] plateau at low metallicities and can be used as a constraint to the yields of massive stars. Unfortunately, at such low metallicities ([Fe/H] between −4 and −3) there are still not enough data to be able to choose between the two set of yields. For Si, S, and Ca the WW95 yields are higher than the TNH96 ones up to 35 M⊙. The opposite occurs for masses above 35 M⊙. In this case both models predict [X/Fe] ratios in good agreement with the observational data. This happens because the differences between predicted iron and α-element yields are compensating each others. -The observed increasing scatter in the abundance ratios of many elements with decreasing metallicity could be interpreted as if the interstellar medium was less homogeneous at early times. It seems unlikely that the increasing scatter is due solely to the increased uncertainty in the estimates of elemental abundances in the most metal-poor stars. Although the number of lines suitable for abundance analyses certainly decreases with lower abundances, the continuum against which they are measured also gets cleaner, and uncertainties due to contamination from blends lessens as well. We recall that McWilliam et al. (1995) suggested that the observed spread at very low metallicities could be due to metallicity dependent yields. From the sets of yields analysed here we can exclude this possibility, at least for the α-elements and Fe, since they depend only slightly on the initial stellar metallicity and, again, the global metallicity increases quite fast in the early phases of Galactic evolution as indicated by the absence of zero-metallicity stars in the Galaxy. -Finally, we predicted that in spite of the adopted yields, the [O/Fe] ratio at high redshifts should show a sharp rise and we suggested that the same behaviour is expected for the [O/Zn] -- 16 -- ratio which should be not affected by dust. Future measurements of either [α/Zn] or [α/Fe] ratios in very metal poor stars will be very useful to infer the nature and age of high-redshift objects. CC acknowledges that this work was partially supported by CNPq and FAPESP, Brazil. TCB acknowledges partial support of this work from NSF grant AST 95-29454 to Michigan State University. TCB expresses gratitude to the Instituto Astronomico e Geof´ısico of the University of Sao Paulo (IAG/USP) for hospitality during his visit, when the final version of this paper was completed and acknowledges that this visit was supported by FAPESP and pr´o-reitoria de p´os-gradua¸cao of the University of Sao Paulo, Brazil. KN acknowledges that this research has been supported in part by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (05242102, 06233101) and COE research (07CE2002) of the Japanese Ministry of Education, Science, and Culture. Anders, E., Grevesse, N. 1989, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 53, 197 (AG89) REFERENCES Andersson, H., Edvardsson, B. 1994, A&A 290, 590 Arnett, D. W. 1995, ARA&A 33, 115 (A95) Barbuy, B., Cayrel, R., Spite, M., Beers, T.C., Spite, F., Nordstrom, B., & Nissen, P.E. 1997, A&A 317, L63 Beers, T. C., Flynn, C., Gebhardt, K. 1990, AJ 100, 32 Beers, T. C., Preston, G. W., Shectman, S. A. 1985, AJ 90, 2089 Beers, T. C., Preston, G. W., Shectman, S. A. 1992, AJ 103, 1987 Beers, T. C., Sommer-Larsen, J. 1995, ApJS 96,175 Bonifacio, P., Beers, T.C., Molaro, P., & Vladilo, G. 1998, A&A 332, 672 Burkert, A., Truran, J., Hensler, G. 1992, ApJ 391, 651 Carbon, D. F., Barbuy, B., Kraft, R. P., Friel, E. D. 1987, PASP 99, 335 Chiappini, C., Matteucci, F., Gratton, G. 1997, ApJ 477, 765 Chiosi, C., Matteucci, F. 1980, Mem. Soc. Astron. It. 51, 107 Clegg, R. E. S., Lambert, D. L., Tomkin, J. 1981, ApJ 250, 262 Cleveland, W.S., Devlin, S.J. 1988, J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 83, 596 Cleveland, W.S., Kleiner, B. 1975, Technometrics, 17, 447 -- 17 -- Dahmen, G., Wilson, T. L., Matteucci, F. 1995, A&A 295, 194 Edvardsson, B., Andersen, J., Gustafsson, B., Lambert, D. L., Nissen, P. E., Tomkin, J. 1993, A&A 275, 101 Fran¸cois, P. 1986, A & A 160, 264 Fran¸cois, P. 1987, A & A 176, 294 Fran¸cois, P. 1988, A & A 195, 226 Fran¸cois, P., Matteucci, F. 1993, A&A 280, 136 Gilroy, K. K., Sneden, C. S., Pilachowski, C. A., Cowan, J. J. 1988 , ApJ 327,298 Gratton, R., Carretta, E., Matteucci, F., Sneden, C. 1996, A & A (submitted) Gratton, R., Sneden, C. 1991, A&A 241, 501 Gratton, R., Sneden, C. 1987, A&A 178, 179 Gratton, R., Sneden, C. 1988, A&A 204, 193 Israelian, G., Garc´ıa Lopez, R. J., Rebolo, R. 1998, astro-ph/9806235 Kennicutt, R. C. 1989, ApJ 344, 685 Laird, J. B. 1985, ApJ 289, 556 Langer, N., Henkel, C. 1996, Space Sci. Rev. 74, 343 Luck, R. E., Bond, H. E. 1985, ApJ 292, 559 McWilliam, A., Preston, G. W., Sneden, C., Searle, L. 1995, AJ 109, 2757 Maeder, A. 1992, A&A 264, 105 Magain, P. 1987, A&A 179, 176 Magain, P. 1989, A&A 209, 211 Matteucci, F. 1996, Fund. Cosmic. Phys. 17, 283 Matteucci, F., Fran¸cois, P. 1989, MNRAS 239, 885 (MF89) Molaro, P., Bonifacio, P. 1990, A&A 236, L5 Nissen, P. E., Gustafsson, B., Edvardsson, B., Gilmore, G. 1994, A&A 285, 440 Nomoto, K., Hashimoto, M., Tsujimoto, T., Thielemann, F.-K., Kishimoto, N., Kubo, Y., Nakasato, N. 1997a, Nuclear Physics, A616, 79c. -- 18 -- Nomoto, K., Iwamoto, K., Nakasato, N., T. Thielemann, F.-K., Brachwitz, F., Tsujimoto, T., Kubo, Y., Kishimoto, N. 1997b, Nuclear Physics, A621, 467c. Norris, J.E., Ryan, S.G., Beers, T.C. 1997a, ApJ 488, 350. Norris, J.E., Ryan, S.G., Beers, T.C. 1997b, ApJ (Letters) 489, L169. Peterson, R. C., Kurucz, R. L., Carney, B. W. 1990, ApJ 350, 173 Pettini, M., Smith, L. J., King, D. L., Hunstead, R. W. 1997, ApJ 486, 665 Pilachowski, C. A., Sneden, C., Kraft, R. P. 1996, AJ 111, 1689 Porto de Mello, G. 1996, PhD Thesis, ON-CNPq, Brazil Primas, F., Molaro, P., Castelli, F. 1994, A&A 290, 885 Renzini, A., Voli, M. 1981, A & A 94, 175 Rocha-Pinto, H. J., Maciel, W. J. 1996, MNRAS 279, 447 Ryan, S. G., Norris, J. E., Bessel, M. S. 1991, AJ 102, 303 Ryan, S. G., Norris, J. E., Beers, T.C. 1996, ApJ 471, 254 Samland, M. 1997, Phys. & Astron. (in press) Scalo, J. M. 1986, Fund. Cosmic Phys. 11, 1 Sneden, C., Preston, G.W., McWilliam, A., Searle 1994, ApJ 431, L27 Sneden, C., McWilliam, A., Preston, G.W., Cowan, J.J., Burris, D.L., Armosky, B.J. 1996, ApJ 467, 819 Sommer-Larsen, J., Beers, T. C., Flynn, C., Wilhelm, R., Christensen, P. R. 1997, ApJ 481, 775. Spite, M., Spite, F. 1978, A&A 67, 23 Thielemann, F. K., Nomoto, K., Hashimoto, M. 1996, ApJ 460, 408 (TNH96) Thielemann, F. K., Nomoto, K., Hashimoto, M. 1993, in Origin and Evolution of the Elements, ed. N. Prantzos et al., Cambridge Univ. Press p. 297 Thomas, D., Greggio, L., Bender, R. 1997, MNRAS (in press) Timmes, F. X., Woosley, S. E., Weaver, T.A. 1995, ApJS 98, 617 Tomkin, J., Lambert, D. L., Balachandran, S. 1985, ApJ 290, 289 Tomkin, J., Sneden, C., Lambert, D. L. 1986, ApJ 302, 415 -- 19 -- Tomkin, J., Woolf, V. M., Lambert, D. L. 1995, AJ 109, 2204 Tsujimoto, T., Nomoto, K., Yoshii, Y., Hashimoto, M., Yanagida, S., Thielemann, F.-K. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 945 Wallerstein, G., Greenstein, J. L., Parker, R., Helfer, H. L., Aller, L. H. 1963, ApJ 137, 280 Wheeler, J. C., Sneden, C. Truran, J. W. 1989, ARA&A 27, 279 Wilson, T. L., Matteucci, F. 1992, A&AR 4, 1 Wilson, T. L., Rood, R. T. 1994, ARA&A 32, 1 Woosley, S. E., Weaver, T. A. 1986, in IAU Colloq. 89, Radiation Hydrodynamics in Stars and Compact Objects, ed. D. Mihalas, K.-H.A. Winkler, Berlin, Springer, p. 91 Woosley, S. E., Weaver, T. A. 1995, ApJS 101, 181 (WW95) Woosley, S. E., Langer, N., Weaver, T. 1993, ApJ 411, 823 Woosley, S. E., Langer, N., Weaver, T. 1995, ApJ 448, 315 Wyse, R. F. G., Gilmore, G. 1995, AJ 110, 2771 Zhao, G., Magain, P. 1990, A & A 238, 242 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0. -- 20 -- Table 1: Observational Data Reference Gratton et al. 1996 Pilachowski et al. 1996 Porto de Mello 1996 Ryan et al. 1996 McWilliam et al. 1995 Tomkin et al. 1995 Anderson & Edvardsson 1994 Nissen et al. 1994 Primas et al. 1994 Edvardsson et al. 1993 Gratton & Sneden 1991 Molaro & Bonifacio 1990 Zhao & Magain 1990 Magain 1989 Gratton & Sneden 1988 Carbon et al. 1987 Fran¸cois 1987, 1988 Gratton & Sneden 1987 Fran¸cois 1986 Tomkin et al. 1986 Tomkin et al. 1985 Laird 1985 Clegg et al. 1981 x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x O Mg Ca Si S C N Fe x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x -- 21 -- Table 2: Dispersion Analysis Ratio [F e/H] ≥ −0.5 −1.5 < [F e/H] ≤ −0.5 −2.5 < [F e/H] ≤ −1.5 [F e/H] ≤ −2.5 SBI [C/Fe] 0.16 (N=202) IS68 R95 (0.15-0.17) 0.63 SBI [Ca/Fe] 0.06 (N=202) IS68 R95 (0.06-0.07) 0.24 SBI [Mg/Fe] 0.11 (N=220) IS68 R95 (0.10-0.12) 0.43 SBI [N/Fe] 0.21 (N=67) IS68 R95 SBI [O/Fe] IS68 R95 SBI [S/Fe] IS68 R95 (0.20-.23) 0.82 0.12 (N=74) (0.11-0.13) 0.47 0.17 (N=27) (0.16-0.21) 0.67 0.19 (N=76) (0.17-0.21) 0.75 0.08 (N=72) (0.07-0.08) 0.31 0.11 (N=80) (0.10-0.12) 0.43 0.30 (N=55) (0.27-0.36) 1.18 0.13 (N=45) (0.12-0.14) 0.51 0.21 (N=83) (0.19-0.23) 0.82 0.12 (N=67) (0.11-0.13) 0.47 0.13 (N=70) (0.12-0.14) 0.51 0 .33 (N=23) (0. 28-0.47) 1.29 0.18 (N=46) (0.17-0.21) 0.7 1 0.17 (N=48) (0.16-0.22) 0.6 7 0.2 (0.23- 8 (N=52) 0.34) 1.10 0.1 (0.09-0.15) 1 (N=23) 0.43 0.09 (N=17) (0.08-0.10) 0.35 SBI [Si/Fe] 0.07 (N=221) IS68 R95 (0.06-0.07) 0.27 0.12 (N=77) (0.11-0.13) 0.47 0.15 (N=56) (0.14-0.19) 0.59 0.33 (N=43) (0.31-0.37) 1.29 -- 22 -- Figure Captions Fig. 1 -- Abundance ratios as function of the metallicity for O, Mg, and Ca. The left panels show a comparison between the data (see Table 1) and the models (dashed-line: with WW95 yields; dot-dashed line: with TNH96 yields). The right panels show a comparison between the summary lines (as described in section 3 -- the solid line represents the midmean and the dotted lines represent the lower and upper semi-midmean) and the model predictions. The parameter r represents the number of data points (10 or 15) in the estimation window and s refers to amount of smoothing (the fraction of data included at each location) in the summary lines. Fig. 2 -- The same as Figure 1, for Si, S, C, and N. Fig. 3 -- The biweight estimator of scale, SBI , for the [X/Fe] ratios (X = C, Ca, Mg, N, O, S, and Si) at different [Fe/H] intervals (see Table 2). Fig. 4 -- Ejected masses in the form of 12C, 16O, and 24Mg as function of the initial mass of the progenitor star given by different authors (solid line: WW95, dot-dashed line: TNH96, dotted line: Woosley and Weaver 1986, adopted by MF89). Fig. 5 -- The same as Figure 4, for Si, Fe, Ca, and S. Fig. 6 -- Masses ejected in the form of various elements, weighted by the IMF, for the more massive stars, plotted as functions of the initial mass of the progenitor (upper panel: WW95 yields, lower panel: TNH96 yields). Fig. 7 -- The same as Figure 6, for 14N, based on the WW95 (solid line) and TNH96 (dot-dashed line) yields. Fig. 8 -- [O/Fe] plotted as function of the redshift, for different cosmologies, adopting the WW95 yields (where TU is the age of the Universe, zf initial redshift of galaxies formation, Λ is the cosmological constant). Fig. 9 -- The same as figure 8, but adopting the TNH96 yields. -- 23 -- Table 3: Solar Abundances by Mass Element Model A (WW95) Model B (TNH96) Observations (AG89) 12C 16O 14N M g Si S Ca F e Z 1.78 (−3) 7.15 (−3) 1.38 (−3) 2.48 (−4) 7.04 (−4) 3.07 (−4) 3.95 (−5) 1.37 (−3) 1.41 (−2) 1.31 (−3) 7.74 (−3) 1.38 (−3) 3.27 (−4) 6.06 (−4) 2.33 (−4) 3.44 (−5) 1.24 (−3) 1.39 (−2) 3.03 (−3) 9.59 (−3) 1.11 (−3) 5.15 (−4) 7.11 (−4) 4.18 (−4) 6.20 (−5) 1.27 (−3) 1.7 (−2) -- 24 -- 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 r=10 s=0.5 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 r=15 s=0.3 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 r=15 s=0.3 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 0.9 0.6 0.3 0 -0.3 -4 -3 -2 [Fe/H] -1 0 -4 -3 -1 0 -2 [Fe/H] Fig. 1. -- -- 25 -- 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 r=10 s=0.5 r=10 s=0.5 r=10 s=0.5 r=10 s=0.3 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 0.8 0 -0.8 -4 -3 -2 [Fe/H] -1 0 -4 -3 -1 0 -2 [Fe/H] Fig. 2. -- -- 26 -- Fig. 3. -- 30 20 10 0 20 40 60 80 100 -- 27 -- 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1 0.5 0 Fig. 4. -- 20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 -- 28 -- 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1.5 1 0.5 0 20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 3 2 1 0 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 Fig. 5. -- -- 29 -- Fig. 6. -- -- 30 -- -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 20 40 60 80 100 Fig. 7. -- -- 31 -- Fig. 8. -- -- 32 -- Fig. 9. --
astro-ph/0305231	1	0305	2003-05-13T16:30:29	A universal radio/X-ray correlation in low/hard state black hole binaries	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present a comprehensive study of (quasi-)simultaneous radio:X-ray observations of stellar black hole binaries during the spectrally hard X-ray state, finding evidence for a strong correlation between these two bands over more than three orders of magnitude in X-ray luminosity. The correlation extends from the quiescent regime up to close to the soft state transition, where radio emission starts to decline, sometimes below detectable levels, probably corresponding to the physical disappearance of the jet. The X-ray transient V 404 Cygni is found to display the same functional relationship already reported for GX 339-4 between radio and X-ray flux, namely S_radio \propto S_X (+0.7). In fact the data for all low/hard state black holes is consistent with a universal relation between the radio and X-ray luminosity of the form L_radio \propto L_X (+0.7), implying that - as L_X decreases - the jet becomes more radiatively efficient with respect to the X-rays. Under the hypothesis of common physics driving the disc-jet coupling in different sources, the observed spread to the best-fit relation can be interpreted in terms of a distribution in Doppler factors. Monte Carlo simulations show that, assuming little or no X-ray beaming, the measured scatter in radio power is consistent with Lorentz factors < 2 for the outflows in the low/hard state, significantly less relativistic than the jets associated with X-ray transients. When combined radio and X-ray beaming is considered, the range of possible jet bulk velocities significantly broadens, allowing highly relativistic outflows, but implying therefore severe X-ray selection effects.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000–000 (0000) Printed 20 May 2018 (MN LATEX style file v2.2) A universal radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state black hole binaries E. Gallo1⋆, R. P. Fender1, G. G. Pooley2 1 Astronomical Institute 'Anton Pannekoek' and Center for High Energy Astrophysics, University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, 1098 SJ Amsterdam, The Netherlands. 2 Mullard Radio Astronomy Observatory, Cavendish Laboratory, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HE, UK. 20 May 2018 ABSTRACT Several independent lines of evidence now point to a connection between the physical processes that govern radio (i.e. jet) and X–ray emission from accreting X–ray binaries. We present a comprehensive study of (quasi–)simultaneous radio:X–ray observations of stellar black hole binaries during the spectrally hard X–ray state, finding evidence for a strong correlation between these two bands over more than three orders of mag- nitude in X–ray luminosity. The correlation extends from the quiescent regime up to close to the soft state transition, where radio emission starts to decline, sometimes be- low detectable levels, probably corresponding to the physical disappearance of the jet. The X–ray transient V 404 Cygni is found to display the same functional relationship already reported for GX 339–4 between radio and X–ray flux, namely Sradio ∝ S +0.7 X . In fact the data for all low/hard state black holes is consistent with a universal rela- tion between the radio and X–ray luminosity of the form Lradio ∝ L+0.7 X . Under the hypothesis of common physics driving the disc–jet coupling in different sources, the observed spread to the best–fit relation can be interpreted in terms of a distribution in Doppler factors and hence used to constrain the bulk Lorentz factors of both the radio and X–ray emitting regions. Monte Carlo simulations show that, assuming little or no X–ray beaming, the measured scatter in radio power is consistent with Lorentz factors < ∼ 2 for the outflows in the low/hard state, significantly less relativistic than the jets associated with X–ray transients. When combined radio and X–ray beaming is considered, the range of possible jet bulk velocities significantly broadens, allowing highly relativistic outflows, but implying therefore severe X–ray selection effects. If the radio luminosity scales as the total jet power raised to x > 0.7, then there exists an X–ray luminosity below which most of the accretion power will be channelled into the jet, rather than in the X–rays. For x = 1.4, as in several optically thick jet models, the power output of 'quiescent' black holes may be jet–dominated below LX ≃ 4 × 10−5 LEdd . Key words: Accretion, accretion discs – Binaries: general – ISM: jets and outflows – Radio continuum: stars – X–rays: stars 3 0 0 2 y a M 3 1 1 v 1 3 2 5 0 3 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1 INTRODUCTION There is strong observational evidence for the fact that pow- erful radio–emitting outflows form a key part of the accretion behaviour in some states of X–ray binary systems. Due to its high brightness temperature, 'nonthermal' spectrum and, in some cases, high degree of polarisation, radio emission from black hole binaries is believed to originate in synchrotron ⋆ [email protected] radiation from relativistic electrons ejected by the system with large bulk velocities (Hjellming & Han 1995; Mirabel & Rodr´ıguez 1999; Fender, 2000, 2001a,b,c). Black hole binary systems are traditionally classified by their X–ray features (see Nowak 1995; Poutanen 1998; Done 2001; Merloni 2002 for recent reviews), namely: a) the relative strength of a soft 'black body' component around 1 keV, b) the spectral hardness at higher energies c) X–ray lumi- nosity and d) timing properties. Different radio behaviour is associated with several 'X–ray states', according to the 2 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley following broad scheme. The low/hard state is dominated by a power–law spectrum, with a relatively low luminos- ity and an exponential cut–off above about 100 keV and little or no evidence for a soft, thermal component. It is associated with a steady, self–absorbed outflow that emits synchrotron radiation in the radio (and probably infrared) spectrum. The quiescent/off state, characterised by an ex- tremely low X–ray flux, may simply be interpreted as the hard state 'turned down' to lower accretion rates and radia- tive efficiency. X–ray spectra from high/soft state Black Hole Candidates (BHCs) are instead dominated by thermal radi- ation, while the core radio emission drops below detectable levels, probably corresponding to the physical suppression of the jet. In the very high state both the thermal and the power law components contribute substantially to the spec- tral energy distribution. At a lower luminosity level an in- termediate state is also observed, with properties similar to those of the very high state. For both the very high and the intermediate state the connection with radio behaviour is not yet clearly established. Corbel et al. (2001) show that the radio emission from XTE 1550–564 in the intermediate state was suppressed by a factor > 50 with respect to the hard state, while Homan et al. (2001) claim that intermedi- ate and very high states can actually occur at a wide range of luminosities. Transitions between states are often associated with multi- ple ejections of synchrotron emitting material, possibly with high bulk Lorentz factors (Hjellming & Han 1995; Kuulkers et al. 1999; Fender & Kuulkers 2001). As already mentioned, BHCs in the low/hard state, like Cygnus X–1 and GX 339–4, are characterised by a flat or slightly inverted radio spectrum (α = ∆ log Sν /∆ log ν ≃ 0), interpreted as arising from a collimated, self–absorbed com- pact jet, in analogy to those observed in active galactic nu- clei (Blandford & Konigl 1979). With the direct imaging of a resolved compact radio jet from the core of Cygnus X–1 (Stirling et al. 2001), this association has been confirmed. Radio emission from X–ray binaries, especially the BHCs, is increasingly interpreted as the radiative signature of jet–like outflows. It has been generally accepted that the soft thermal com- ponent of BH spectra originates in an optically thick, ge- ometrically thin accretion disc (Shakura & Sunyaev 1973), whereas the power law component is produced by Comptoni- sation of 'seed' photons in a hot, rarefied 'corona' of (quasi–) thermal electrons (Shapiro, Lightman & Eardley 1976; Sun- yaev & Titarchuk 1980; Haardt & Maraschi 1991; Poutanen & Svensson 1996). Although this picture can successfully reproduce the X–ray behaviour, it can not yet address the clear correlation between radio and X–ray emission estab- lished for the persistent BHCs GX 339–4 and Cygnus X–1 while in the hard state (Hannikainen et al. 1998; Brocksopp et al. 1999; Corbel et al. 2000; Corbel et al. 2003). More- over, some hard state sources, like XTE J1118+480 and GX 339–4, show evidence for a turnover in the infrared–optical band, where the flat–to–inverted radio spectrum seems to connect to an optically thin component extending up to the X–rays (Corbel & Fender 2002; Markoff et al. 2003a,b and references therein), suggesting again that the jet plays a role at higher frequencies. Hence, all the evidence points to the corona in these sys- Figure 1. Radio against X–ray flux density, scaled to a distance of 1 kpc and absorption corrected, for V 404 Cygni and GX 339– 4. Lines denote the fits to the datasets: short and long dashed for GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni respectively. It is found that the data of V 404 Cygni are well fitted by the same functional relationship reported by Corbel et al. (2003) for the BHC GX 339–4, that is Sradio ∝ (SX )0.7. tems being physically related to the presence of a jet: by far the simplest interpretation therefore is that the Comptonis- ing region is just the base of the relativistic outflow (Fender et al. 1999b; Merloni & Fabian 2002; Markoff et al. 2003a). However, joining these two previously independent scenarios is somewhat problematic because they often require differ- ent electron distributions and geometries. Due to the fast timescales in X–ray binary systems, only simultaneous radio and X–ray observations provide the nec- essary tools to probe this conjecture. The following results extend and complete those presented in Gallo, Fender & Pooley (2002). 2 THE SAMPLE Our aim was to compile (quasi–)simultaneous radio and X– ray observations of BHCs during the low/hard state. To this purpose, we have collected all the available (to our knowlege) data from the literature and made use of our own simultaneous observations as well. These were taken with the Ryle telescope at 15 GHz (see Pooley & Fender 1997 for more details) and combined with one–day aver- ages from RXTE ASM (this refers to Cygnus X–1, Cygnus X–3 and GRS 1915+105). Table 1 lists the information for the ten low/hard state BHCs for which we have at our dis- posal (quasi–)simultaneous radio and X–ray coverage (see Section 5, Table 3 for 'non–canonical' hard state sources, such as Cygnus X–3 and GRS 1915+105): distance, mass, orbital inclination, measured hydrogen column densities (see Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 3 Table 1. System parameters for the ten hard state BHCs under consideration. Distance and NH references are given in parentheses next to each value. Inclination and BH mass estimates, unless differently specified, are all taken from Orosz (2002). The last column refers to the literatures' sources from which we have obtained (quasi–) simultaneous radio and X–ray fluxes; no reference appears in case of our own observations (Cygnus X–1). Source Distance(ref) Inclination(12) BH mass(12) Cygnus X–1 V 404 Cygni GRS 1758–258 XTE J1118+480 GRO J0422+32 GX 339–4 1E 1740.7–2942 XTE J1550–564 GS 1354–64 4U 1543–47 (kpc) 2.1 (1) 3.5 (2) 8.5 (3) 1.8 (4) 2.4 (5) 4.0 (6) 8.5 (7) 4.0 (8,9∗) 10.0 (10) 9.0 (11) (degree) (M⊙) 35±5 56±4 ? 81±2 44±2 6.85–13.25 10.06–13.38 ∼8–9 (14) 6.48–7.19 3.66–4.97 15–60 (13) 5.8±0.5 (15) ? 72±5 ? ? 8.36–10.76 ? 20.7±1.5 8.45–10.39 NH (ref) (1021cm−2) 6.2 (16) 5.0 (17) 14.0 (3) 0.1 (18) 2.0 (5) 6.0 (6) 118 (19) 8.5 (20) 32.0 (9) 3.5 (11) Data – 21,22 23 24,25 24 26 27 20,28 29 30 References : 1: Massey et al. 1995; 2: Zycki, Done & Smith 1999; 3: Main et al. 1999; 4: McClintock et al. 2001; 5: Shrader et al. 1997; 6: Zdziarski et al. 1998; 7: Sunyaev et al. 1991; 8: Kong et al. 2002; 9: Tomsick et al. 2001; 10: Kitamoto et al. 1990; 11: Orosz et al. 1998; 12: Orosz 2002; 13: Cowley et al. 2002; 14: Keck et al. 2001; 15: Hynes et al. 2003; 16: Schulz et al. 2002; 17: Wagner et al. 1994; 18: Dubus et al. 2001; 19: Gallo & Fender 2002; 20: Tomsick et al. 2001; 21: Han & Hjellming 1992; 22: Hjellming et al. 2000; 23: Lin et al. 2000; 24: Brocksopp et al. 2003; 25: Markoff, Falkce & Fender 2001; 26: Corbel et al. 2000; 27: Heindl, Prince & Grunsfeld 1994; 28: Corbel et al. 2001; 29: Brocksopp et al. 2001; 30: Brocksopp, private communication. ∗For XTE J1550–564 a distance of 4 kpc is assumed by both Kong et al. (2002) and Tomsick et al. (2001), as average value between 2.5 and 6 kpc, given by S´anchez–Fern´andez et al. (1999) and Sobczak et al. (1999) respectively. Section 2.1) and literature references. Both the X–ray and the radio intensity values come from several different instruments and telescopes. Radio flux den- sities have been measured in different frequency bands, rang- ing from 4.9 up to 15 GHz; nevertheless we generically refer to 'radio flux densities' based on the evidence that, while in the low/hard state, black hole radio spectra are charac- terised by almost flat spectra (α ∼ 0) spectral index (Fender 2001a). X–ray fluxes, taken either from spectral fits or from light curves, have been converted into Crab units in order to be easly compared with radio flux density units (1 Crab ≃ 1060 µJy; energy range 2–11 keV). For this purpose, X–ray fluxes/luminosities in a given range have been first converted into corresponding values between 2–11 keV, and then ex- pressed as flux density. For those sources whose X–ray flux has been derived from count rates, the conversion into Crab has been performed according to the factors provided by Brocksopp, Bandyopadhyay & Fender (2003). 2.1 Absorption corrections Whenever X–ray flux density has been evaluated from count rates or absorbed fluxes, we wanted to compensate for ab- sorption by calculating the ratio between the predicted flux from a hard state BH with a measured NH value, and the predicted flux corresponding to no absorption, as follows. We have first simulated with XSPEC typical spectra of hard state BHCs as observed by Chandra ACIS for ten diffent val- ues of hydrogen column density ranging from zero up to 12.5 ×1022cm−2. A 'typical' spectrally hard BH's spectrum is well fitted by an absorbed power law with photon index 1.5. By keeping fixed the flux corresponding to no absorption, the points turn out to be well fitted by a simple exponential relation, which allows to express the ratio Fabs/Funabs as follows: Fabs,LS Funabs = exph −(NH/1022cm−2) 18.38 i (1) The procedure described has been applied to X–ray fluxes below the transition luminosity between hard and soft state (see Section 3.2). Above that value, the spectrum is not re- produced by a simple power law. In this regime, the X–ray spectrum is usually well fitted by an absorbed power law with photon index Γ ≃ 2.4 plus a disc blackbody compo- nent, with a typical temperature of around 1 keV. Since in this case the 2–11 keV spectrum is almost entirely domi- nated by thermal emission, the previous simulations have been repeated for soft state BHCs by approximating the spectrum with a disc blackbody emission at 1 keV. We have obtained: Fabs,HS Funabs = exph −(NH /1022cm−2) 8.67 i (2) The latter correction has been applied to detections above the hard–to–soft state transition. 3 RADIO VS. X–RAY FLUX DENSITIES 3.1 GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni In Figure 1 we plot radio against X–ray flux densities (mJy vs.Crab), scaled to a distance of 1 kpc and absorption cor- rected, for GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni, the two sources for which we have at our disposal the widest coverage in terms of X–ray luminosity. GX 339–4 was discovered as a radio source by Sood & Campbell–Wilson (1994). When in the low/hard state, it 4 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley , Figure 2. Radio flux density (mJy) is plotted against X–ray flux density (Crab) for a sample of ten hard state BHs (see Table 1), scaled to a distance of 1 kpc and absorption corrected (this means that the axes are proportional to luminosities). On the top horizontal axis we indicate luminosity, in Eddington units for a 10M⊙ BH, corresponding to the underlying X–ray flux density. An evident correlation between these two bands appears and holds over more than three orders of magnitude in luminosity. The dashed line indicates the best–fit to the correlation, that is Sradio = k × (SX ) +0.7, with k = 223 ± 156 (obtained by fixing the slope at +0.7, as found individually for both GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni; see Section 4.1). Errors are given at 3–σ confidence level, and arrows also represent 3–σ upper limits. is characterised by a flat or slightly inverted (α > ∼ 0) ra- dio spectrum (see Corbel et al. 2000) and its synchrotron power has been shown to correlate with soft and hard X– ray fluxes (Hannikainen et al. 1998; Corbel et al. 2000). By means of simultaneous radio:X–ray obsevations of GX 339– 4, Corbel et al. (2003) have recently found extremely inter- esting correlations between these two bands: in particular, S8.6GHz ∝ S +0.71±0.01 (slightly different slopes – within the hard state – have been found depending on the X–ray en- ergy interval). When fitted in mJy vs. Crab (scaled to 1 kpc and absorption corrected), the relation displays the form: Sradio = kGX339−4 × (SX ) +0.71±0.01 3−9keV (3) kGX339−4 = 126 ± 3 The correlation appears to hold over a period of three years – 1997 and between 1999–2000 – during which the source remained almost constantly in a spectral hard state (with a transition to the high/soft state, Belloni et al. 1999, when the radio emission declined below detectable levels). Fig- ure 1 shows radio against X–ray flux densities of GX 339–4 corresponding to simultaneous ATCA/RXTE observations performed between 1997 and 2000 (Corbel et al. 2000, 2003). Note that points above 1 Crab (scaled), which all correspond to RXTE–ASM detections, clearly show a sharp decreas- ing in the radio power (see next Section). The correlation reported by Corbel et al. (2003) actually refers to RXTE– PCA data only; it is worth mentioning that, when ASM detections below 1 Crab (i.e. below the radio quenching) are fitted together with PCA points, the final result is con- sistent, within the errors, with the fit reported by Corbel on PCA data alone (that is, a slope of 0.70±0.06 is obtained in this case). Remarkably, we have found that detections of V 404 Cygni, Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 5 the source for which we have at our disposal the widest radio:X–ray coverage, are well fitted by the same functional relationship – albeit with no apparent cutoff – as GX 339–4 (see Figure 1). V 404 Cygni belongs to the class of X–ray transients, sources undergoing brief episodic outbursts during which their lumi- nosity can increase by a factor ∼ 106 compared to periods of relative quiescence. All V 404 Cygni data – except for the quiescent lowest point – come from simultaneous radio (VLA; Han & Hjellming 1992) and X–ray (Ginga; Kitamoto et al. 1990) observations during the decay following its May 1989 outburst, during which the source, despite very high and apparently saturated luminosity, never entered a spec- tral soft state and always maintained a very hard X–ray spectrum (Zycki, Done & Smith 1999). According to Hjellm- ing et al. (2000), the quiescent state of V 404 Cygni, since it ended the long decay after its 1989 outburst, has been associated with a 0.4 mJy radio source1. Quiescent X–ray flux refers to a 1992 measurement (Wagner et al. 1994 re- port 0.024±0.001 count/sec with ROSAT–PSPC), i.e. well before the onset of significant X–ray variability (see Kong et al. 2002 for details). Denoting Sradio as the radio flux density in mJy and SX as the X–ray flux density in Crab, we have obtained: Sradio = kV 404 × (SX) +0.70±0.20 (4) kV 404 = 301 ± 43 The Spearman's rank correlation coefficient is 0.91; the two sided significance of its deviation from zero equals 4.2 ×10−3. These results indicate that Sradio ∝ (SX )∼0.7 is a funda- mental property of the radio:X–ray coupling in the hard state, rather than a peculiarity of GX 339–4. It is worth stressing that the fitted slopes for V 404 Cygni and GX 339–4 are identical within the errors, with the same nor- malisations within a factor 2.5, while detections from other sources below 1 Crab (scaled), although much narrower lu- minosity ranges, are all consistent with the same placing in the radio:X–ray plane, as discussed in the next Section. 3.2 Broad properties of the correlation In Figure 2 we plot radio flux densities (mJy) against X–ray fluxes (Crab), scaled to a distance of 1 kpc and absorption corrected, for all the ten hard state BHCs listed in Table 1. Note that this scaling and correction means that the axes are proportional to luminosities. Besides GX 339–4, Cygnus X–1 displays a positive Sradio : SX correlation followed by a radio turnover around 3 Crab, whereas three other sources, namely XTE J1118+480, 4U 1543–47 and GS 1354–64, lie very close to the relations in- ferred for GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni. The remaining four systems (GRS 1758–258, GRO J0422+32, 1E 1740.7–2942 1 Starting in early 1999, VLA obervations showed fluctuations ranging from 0.1 to 0.8 mJy on time scales of days; even more extreme radio fluctuations in February 2000 were accompained by strong variability in the X–ray band as well (Hjellming et al. 2000). Figure 3. Top panel: Ryle telescope at 15 GHz and RXTE ASM daily averages for Cygnus X-1 between January 1996 and January 2003. Fluxes have been scaled to a distance of 1 kpc. Bottom panel: open squares for HR (Hardness ratio)1, defined as the ratio between the count rates at 3–5 keV and 1.5–3 keV. Filled circles for HR2, defined as the ratio between 5–12 keV and 3–5 keV. A softening of the X–ray spectrum is shown to correspond to a quenching in the radio emission. and XTE J1550–564) seem instead to have already under- gone the radio quenching. We can assert that these ten BH candidates display very similar behaviour in the Sradio vs. SX plane. There is evi- dence for a positive radio:X–ray correlation over more than three orders of magnitude in terms of Eddington luminosity, as indicated in the top horizontal axis, where we show the L/LEdd ratio corresponding to the underlying X–ray flux (LEdd ≃ 1.3 × 1039 erg/sec for a 10 M⊙BH). As an example, the total luminosity of Cygnus X–1 in the 0.1 to 200 keV band, while the source is in the low/hard state, is ∼ 2% of the Eddington luminosity for a 10 M⊙ BH (di Salvo et al. 2001); that corresponds to mean flux of about 2.5 Crab (scaled to 1 kpc). 3.3 Jet suppression in the soft state As already mentioned, approaching the soft state radio emis- sion from BHCs seems to be quenched below detectable lev- els. Such a behaviour is well recognizable in at least two sources of our sample. As visible in Figure 2, both Cygnus X–1 and GX 339–4 display a clear turnover after which the radio power dramatically declines and reaches undetectable levels within a factor of two in X–ray flux (see also Fender et al. 1999b). In addition, XTE J1550–564, although suffering from poor statistics and large uncertainty in distance esti- mates (2.5–6 kpc), has been detected during the hard state (Corbel et al. 2001; Tomsick et al. 2001) at 'half–quenched' level (about 1 Crab:20 mJy scaled) while the radio emission 6 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley dropped down significantly in the intermediate/very high state (about 6 Crab:<0.15 mJy scaled). The values of the X–ray flux density (scaled) correspond- ing to the turnover in radio flux vary between the sources: GX 339–4, about 1 Crab; Cygnus X–1, about 3 Crab; V 404 Cygni > 1 Crab. This difference could be related to differences between the parameters that govern the pow- ering/quenching mechanism(s) of the radio emitting jet. A discriminant parameter might be the BH mass, which is es- timated to be ∼10 M⊙ in the case of Cygnus X–1 while it has been recently constrained around 6 M⊙ in the case of GX 339–4 (Hynes et al. 2003). If this hypothesis is correct, we would expect not to see jet quenching at X–ray luminosi- ties below the Cygnus X–1 turnover for those systems whose BH mass has been estimated to be bigger than 10 M⊙, as, for instance, the case of V 404 Cygni, which does not ap- pear to be quenched in radio up to about 3 Crab, and is known to possess a 10–14 M⊙BH (Orosz 2002, Hjellming et al. 2000). Despite the poor statistics, this picture seems to bear out the hypothesis that the X–ray luminosity at the ra- dio quenching might positively correlate with the BH mass, being consistent with the jet suppression occurring at a con- stant fraction – a few percent – of the Eddington rate. This is explored further in Gallo, Migliari & Fender (in prepara- tion). In Figure 3 the quenching of the radio power in Cygnus X– 1 (monitored simultaneously in radio and X–ray between January 1996 and January 2003) as a function of the X–ray flux density is shown together with X–ray hardness ratios. The 3–12 keV X–ray spectrum softens until about 5 Crab (scaled), whereas radio quenching begins around 3 Crab (scaled). While it is clear that the quenching occurs some- where near the point of transition from low/hard to softer (intermediate or high/soft) states, pointed observations will be required to see exactly what is happening to the X–ray spectrum at the quenching point. 4 SPREAD TO THE CORRELATION 4.1 Best–fitting So far we have established two main points by looking at the distribution of low/hard state BH binaries in the radio vs. X–ray flux density plane: • Independently of the physical interpretation, Sradio ∝ (SX )+0.7 for GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni from quiescence up to close to the hard–to–soft state transition. All other hard state BHCs lie very close to these correlations, with similar normalisations. • At a luminosity of a few percent of the Eddington rate, close to the hard–to–soft state transition, a sharp turnover is observed in the radio:X–ray relation, that is, the radio flux density drops below detectable levels. Bearing this in mind, our purpose is now trying to find a re- liable expression for a 'best–fit' relationship to all hard state BHs and to estimate the spread relative to such a relation. Assuming 0.7 as a universal slope during the low/hard state, we have determined the normalisation factor by fitting all the data – Cygnus X–1 excluded (see comments at the end of this Section) – up to 1 Crab, below which quenching does not occur for any system. In this way we are able to provide an empirical relationship valid for all the hard state BHs, that we will call 'best–fit' in the following. We have obtained: Sradio = k × (SX )+0.7, k = 223 ± 156 (5) The best–fit and its spread are indicated in Figure 2 in dashed and dot–dashed lines respectively. A scatter of about one order of magnitude in radio power is particularly inter- esting, especially in view of comparing the observed spread to the one we expect based on beaming effects (see next Sec- tion). The choice of excluding the whole dataset of Cygnus X–1 is related to its unusual behaviour in the radio:X–ray flux plane. In fact, a visual inspection of Figure 2 already sug- gested that the points below the radio power quenching be- long to a line with a steeper slope than 0.7. In addition, despite its relatively low inclination to the line of sight (see next Section for clarity), Cygnus X–1 lies on the lower side of the correlation. It is possible that these characteristics can be explained in terms of strong wind absorption. It has been demonstrated that the wind from the donor OB star in Cygnus X–1 partially absorbs the radio emission, up to about 10% (Pooley, Fender & Brocksopp, 1999; Brocksopp, Fender & Pooley, 2002). In addition, since the jet bulk ve- locity during hard state is likely to be relatively low (see Section 4.3), approaching and receding jets contribute a similar amount to the total radio luminosity. However, in Cygnus X–1 only a one–sided jet has been detected (Stirling et al. 2001); this means that, possibly, a significant fraction of the receding jet is lost through wind absorption (however, since the jet structure is about 100 times bigger than the or- bit, it is unlikely that the wind could absorb the entire power of the receding component). Furthermore, because the flat– spectrum radio emission (corresponding to steady jet and generally associated with hard X–ray spectrum) is optically thick, this implies that when the jet power decreases, its size might also decreases linearly with flux. As the jet in Cygnus X–1 becomes smaller, the Sradio:SX relation will be subject to increasingly strong wind absorption, with the net result of steepening the correlation. 4.2 Constraining the Doppler factors What kind of physical information can we deduce from the observed relation? Let us assume a very simple model, in which the same physics and jet/corona coupling hold for all hard state BHs and the observed functional relationship is intrinsic; then, one would predict the following placing in the Sradio vs. SX parameter space: (i) All sources lying on a line with the same slope if nei- ther X–ray or radio emission were significantly beamed (i.e. low Doppler factors). (ii) Different sources lying on lines with the same slope but different normalisations if X–rays were isotropic while radio was beamed, with radio–brighter sources correspond- ing to higher Doppler factors. Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 7 (iii) As point (ii) but with higher Doppler factors sources being brighter in both radio and X–ray if both were beamed. Despite the relatively small sample, we are able to place some constraints on these possibilities. In the first two sce- narios, where X–rays are isotropically emitted while radio power is beamed, we can express the observed radio lu- minosity as the product of the intrinsic (rest–frame) radio power times the effective Doppler factor ∆radio, defined as a function of approaching and receding Doppler factors2. If Sradio,intr = k × (SX )+0.7 for all hard state BHCs, we can write: Sradio,obs = ∆radio × Sradio,intr = ∆radio × N × (SX) +0.7(6) Assuming the same coupling for all sources – that means same normalisation N – the ratio Sradio,1/Sradio,2 between the observed radio powers from source 1 and 2, at a fixed X–ray luminosity, will correspond to the ratio between their relative effective Doppler factors. Returning to the case of V 404 Cygni and GX 339–4, where Sradio,V 404/Sradio,GX339−4 ∼ 2.5, we are drawn to the conclusion that GX 339–4, whose inclination is poorly constrained between 15 < i < 60◦ (Cowley et al. 2002), is likely to be located at a higher inclination than V 404 Cyg, well established to lie at 56 ± 4◦ (Shahbaz et al. 1994). In fact, assuming that ΓGX339−4 ≃ ΓV 404, a ra- tio Sradio,V 404/Sradio,GX339−4 > 1 can be achieved only if iGX339−4 > iV 404. Clearly, the previous arguments are based on the assump- tion that the binary system inclination to the line of sight coincides with the inclination of the jet, while recent find- ings (Maccarone 2002) show that this is not always the case (the misalignment of the disc and the jet has been already observed in Galactic jet sources GRO J1655–40 and SAX J1819–2525). A recent work by Hynes et al. (2003) shows dynamical ev- idence for GX 339–4 being a binary system hosting a BH with mass 5.8 ± 0.5 M⊙. Interestingly, based on the spec- troscopic analysis by Cowley et al. (2002), see their Figure 8, this value is also consistent with a high inclination of the system to the line of sight. 4.2.1 Monte Carlo simulations I: radio beaming In order to link the measured scatter in the radio:X–ray re- lation to the beaming effects, and possibly constraining the Doppler factors, we have performed Monte Carlo simulations according to the following scheme. We have considered the four sources (see Table 2) whose radio:X–ray flux densities have been utilised to obtain the best–fit relationship below 1 Crab; for each of them we have at our disposal a num- ber nj of simultaneous detections, with a total number of points n = Σ4 j=1nj = 23. For each source j, a random incli- nation within the measured range has been generated and associated to an array whose dimension equals the number 2 ∆radio := [(δapp)2 + (δrec)2]/2, where: δrec/app = Γ−1 × (1 ± β cos θ)−1; β = v/c, is the bulk velocity of the radio–emitting material; Γ = (1 − β2)−0.5; θ is the inclination respect to the line of sight. Figure 4. Assuming a simple model in which radio emission is beamed while X–rays are isotropic, equation 6 implies that the spread in radio power to the best fit can be due to the distribution in Doppler factors. The simulated spread in ∆radio (defined as the ratio of standard deviation over the mean value), is plotted for 15 values of the jet bulk velocity between 0 and 0.998c, and compared to the measured scatter in the radio:X–ray correlation. In order to maintain the spread in Doppler factors equal/smaller than observed, the outflow velocity must be smaller than 0.8 times the speed of the light, that is Γradio < 2. Open circles represent Monte Carlo simulation run by allowing the inclination angles to vary within the observed ranges; filled circles are for random inclinations between 0–90◦ . Table 2. Observed sources for which mean Doppler factors have been simulated for 10 different values of the jet bulk velocity; mea- sured range of inclinations and number of simultaneous radio:X– ray detections are listed. Source Inclination Number of (degree) detections (nj) V 404 Cygni XTE J1118+480 4U 1543–47 GX 339–4 56±4a 81±2a 20.7±1.5a 15–60b 7 1∗ 1 14 ∗ This single point corresponds to the average of 33 nearly simultaneous detections over a very narrow interval in X–ray luminosity. References: a: Orosz 2002; b: Cowley et al. 2002. of detections nj , for a total of 23 random inclinations. Then, for 15 different values of the outflow bulk velocity β, the cor- responding Doppler factors ∆β(j) have been calculated by running the simulation 104 times (i.e. for total of 23 × 104 values for each β) . After estimating the mean Doppler factor and its relative standard deviations (σ(∆)) for each value of β, we have compared the simulated spread (defined as the 8 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley ratio σ(∆)/∆mean to the measured spread in normalisation, that is σ(k)/k = 156/223 = 0.70. The result is shown in Figure 4: in order to keep the spread in Doppler factor equal/smaller 3 than observed (actually ≤ 0.77 = 0.70+10%), the bulk velocity of the radio–emitting material must be lower than 0.8c, that is the Lorentz factor must be smaller than 1.7. These remarks are of course valid under the basic assump- tions that no beaming is affecting the X–rays. In addition we are considering a simple model in which both the bulk velocities and opening angles of the jets are constant (only under the latter assumption the probability of observing a source with a given inclination θ is uniformly distributed in cos θ). For comparison, we ran the simulation allowing the incli- nation angles to vary between 0–90◦ (filled circles in Fig- ure 4); this is actually crucial in the light of what has been discussed by Maccarone (2002) about jet–disc misalign- ment in BH binaries, and also takes into account possible model–dependent errors in the estimation of i. The simu- lated spread in Doppler factors starts to significantly deviate from the previous one (calculated allowing the inclination angles for each source to vary within the measured values; open circles in Figure 4) only for very high bulk velocities. As expected, even if inclinations as 0 and 90◦ (i.e. those incli- nations which translate into the highest and lowest possible values of cosine, respectively) are also taken into account, this strongly influences the mean Doppler factor only for really high values of β. 4.2.2 Monte Carlo simulations II: adding beamed X–rays Following a similar approach, it is possible to constrain the Doppler factor due to the combination of beamed radio and X–ray radiation. As before, we assume 0.7 as an intrinsic slope which relates radio and X–ray emission. Supposing that both X–rays and radio are beamed, we will write: Sradio,obs (SX,obs)0.7 ∝ ∆radio (∆X )0.7 (7) Note that the effective Doppler factor for the X–ray radia- tion will be defined as ∆X = [(δrec)2.5 + (δapp)2.5]/2 (assum- ing continuous ejection and photon index 1.5 for low/hard state; see Mirabel & Rodr´ıguez 1994, equations 8, 9). Therefore, Monte Carlo simulations have been run by vary- ing both radio and X–ray bulk velocities with logarithmic steps in Lorentz factors, ΓX and Γradio, between 1 and 30. The mean values of ∆radio/(∆X )0.7 together with their stan- dard deviations and spreads have been calculated for any combination of the two factors. The results are shown in Figure 5. Filled bold circles indicate those combinations of Γradio and ΓX for which the simulated spread with inclinations varying 3 Smaller than measured spread are also 'allowed' on the ground that errors in the distance estimates are likely to influence the observed distribution, causing an additional source of scatter to the relation, which is of course not related to any boosting effect. Figure 5. Same scheme as Figure 4, but assuming a model in which both radio and X–ray beaming are allowed; in this case, Monte Carlo simulations have been performed with logarithmic steps in Lorentz factors (rather than linear in β). The combina- tion of radio plus X–ray beaming has the effect of broadening the range of allowed Γradio with respect to the case of isotropic X– ray emission. In this picture open circles indicate combinations of Γradio and ΓX for which the simulated spread with inclina- tions varying within the measured ranges is smaller than/equal to 0.77. Filled circles, instead, correspond to 'allowed' combina- tions of Γradio and ΓX when the inclination to the line of sight is randomly chosen between 0–90◦ . In this case the range of possible combination is smaller due to the fact that extreme inclinations, such as 0 or 90◦ are also taken into account. between 0–90◦ is smaller than/equal to 0.77. Filled PLUS open circles, instead, correspond to 'allowed' combinations when the inclination to the line of sight varies within the measured ranges. In order to see why the beaming of both wavebands al- lows a wider spread of Γ, consider the effect on the po- sition of a source in the flux–flux diagram: a Doppler– boosted, or deboosted, radio source moves parallel to the Sradio axis, while a source boosted or deboosted in both wavebands moves roughly (not exactly) parallel to the line Sradio = const × SX , and therefore roughly along the di- rection of the observed correlation. Consequently beaming in both wavebands disturbs the correlation less. However, if X–rays were really highly beamed, that would imply strong X–ray selection effects in detecting BH binaries. Clearly, a possible independent estimation of the bulk veloc- ity of the X–ray emitting material (e.g. Beloborodov 1999; Maccarone 2003) would naturally allow a much narrower constraint on the Doppler factor of the radio–emitting ma- terial (see discussion for further details). Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 9 Figure 6. In addition to hard state BHs (open stars) we plot both single simultaneous radio:X–ray fluxes from black hole transients and detections from two canonical soft state plus somewhat 'extreme' sources, close to the Eddington accretion regime. Filled squares correspond to single outbursts from different sources (from Fender & Kuulkers 2001); filled circles are for persistent soft/high state sources LMC X–1 and LMC X–3, upper limits; open polygons refer to GRS 1915+105, while open circles denote Cygnus X–3 points. Based on the 0.7 correlation, and assuming that the radio luminosity scales as the total jet power raised to x = 1.4 (as in the Blandford & Konigl (1979) and MFF models), the radio luminosity is expected to dominate the X–rays below LX ≃ 4 × 10−5LEdd (about 0.005 Crab). Possible detection of the nearby SXT A 0620–00 at the predicted radio level would be capable to probe such a statement at very low X–ray level, requiring a wholly new accretion regime on to stellar BHs. 5 BEYOND THE HARD–TO–SOFT STATE TRANSITION 5.1 Discrete ejections So far, we only have focused on low/hard state BHs, that is, binary systems characterised by a quasi–steady state of stable accretion and whose X–ray spectrum is dominated by a hard power law. In the following we will add to our sample radio and X–ray fluxes from transient BHCs during their episodic outbursts associated with discrete ejection events corresponding to op- tically thin radio emission. All the available data, comprising of soft X–ray and radio peak fluxes with references, have been reported by Fender & Kuulkers (2001). Two points we include in this Section come from systems which have also been shown in Figure 2 while in the hard state, namely V 404 Cygni and GRO J0422+32. Sources under consideration, as well as their fundamental physical parameters, are listed in Table 3. Simultaneous radio:X–ray peak fluxes, scaled to a distance of 1 kpc are plotted in Figure 6 with filled squares. Radio data are based on peak observed flux density at fre- quency of 5 GHz. Where measurements at 5 GHz were not available, a spectral index of α = −0.5 was assumed in order to estimate the 5 GHz flux based on observations performed at different frequencies (see Fender & Kuulkers 2001 for de- 10 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley Table 3. Transient (plus 4 peculiar) sources whose simultane- ous radio:X–ray peak fluxes associated with discrete ejections are plotted in Figure 6 (data from Fender & Kuulkers 2001). Source Distance NH (1022cm−2) 1A 0620–00 GS 2000+25 GS 1124–68 GRO J1655–40 GRS 1716–249 GRS 1739–278 4U 1630–472 XTE J2012+381 XTE J1748–288 XTE J1859+226 XTE J0421+560 GRS 1915+105 Cygnus X–3 LMC X–1 LMC X–3 (kpc) 1 (1) 2 (2) 4.9 (3) 3 (4) 2.4 (5) 8.5 (6) 10 (7) 10 (8) 8 (9) 7.6 (10) 5 (11) 11 (12) 9 (13) 55 (14) 55 (14) 0.2 (a) 0.2 (b) 0.5 (c) 0.7 (d) 0.4 (e) 2.6 (f) 9.4 (g) 1.3 (h) 7.5 (i) 0.3 (l) 0.1 (m) 7.0 (n) 2.7 (o) 0.8 (14) 0.1 (14) References : 1: Shahbaz et al. 1994; 2: Callanan et al. 1996; 3: Shahbaz et al. 1997; 4: Kubota et al. 2001; 5: Della Valle et al. 1994; 6: Mart´ı et al. 1997 ; 7: Parmar et al. 1986; 8: Campana et al. 2002; 9: Kotani et al. 2000; 10: Hynes et al. 2002; 11: Robinson et al. 2002; 12: Fender et al. 1999a; 13: Predehl et al. 2000; 14: Haardt et al. 2001. a: Kong et al. 2002; b: Rutledge et al. 1999; c: Ebisawa et al. 1994; d: Ueda et al. 1998; e: Tanaka 1993 f: Greiner et al. 1996; g: Tomsick & Kaaret 2000; h: Hynes et al. 1999; i: Miller et al. 2001; l: Markwardt et al. 1999; m: Parmar et al. 2000; n: Klein–Wolt et al. 2002; o: Terasawa & Nakamura 1995. tails). Most of the X–ray data are ASM detections, with the only exceptions of GRO J1655–40 and GRO J0422+32, whose outbursts have been detected by either BATSE or GRANAT. For clarity, no error bars are plotted. 5.2 Other BHCs: persistent soft state and 'extreme' sources In between the jet quenching and the discrete ejections from transient sources, there are of course binary systems display- ing a persistent soft spectrum, i.e. whose emission is domi- nated by disc blackbody photons. LMC X–1 and LMC X–3, in the Large Magellanic Clouds, are the only BHCs always observed while the soft state (actually Wilms et al. 2001; Boyd & Smale 2000 and Homan et al. 2000 reported signs that LMC X–3 entered in a hard state). For both these sources, the presence of a black hole is quite well established, with a most likely mass of 9M⊙ and 6M⊙, respectively for LMC X–3 and LMC X–1. By means of radio and X–ray ob- servations performed in 1997, we can place the two sources in the Sradio vs. SX plane, in order to verify the amount of radio power from soft state BHs, which is expected to be well below the hard state correlation. LMC X–3 X–ray flux densities have been derived from Haardt et al. (2001), while LMC X–1 from Gierlinski et al. 2001. Radio upper limits for both sources are taken from Fender, Southwell & Tzioumis (1998). The corresponding values, scaled to a distance of 1 kpc and corrected for absorption according to equation 2, are plotted in Figure 6 with filled circles (at about 150 Crab:<4540 mJy and 45 Crab:<360 mJy, LMC X–1 and LMC X–3 respectively). As expected, both points lie below the hard state relation extended to such high X–ray ener- gies. Although we are only reporting upper limits, we can assert that fluxes from LMC X–1 and LMC X–3 do not dis- agree with our previous finding. For completeness, simultaneous radio:X–ray detections of two extreme sources, namely GRS 1915+105 (open poly- gons) and Cygnus X–3 (open circles), have been included, corresponding to the two big 'clouds' at the top right re- gion of Figure 6. Both systems are traditionally considered 'exotic' due to their timing and spectral behaviours which do not fully resemble any 'standard' picture generally ac- cetpted for BHCs; for instance, both these sources display either optically thin or thick radio spectra. For extensive re- views, see Bonnet–Bidaud & Chardin (1988; Cygnus X–3) and Belloni et al. (2000; GRS 1915+105). Here we note that, despite its unusually high luminosity, detections of GRS 1915+105 in the so called plateau state (Belloni et al. 2000) – which appears to share similar properties with the canonical low/hard state – still seem to belong to the 0.7 correlation extended up to super–Eddington regime. Cygnus X–3 is the strongest observed persistent radio– emitting BH binary and is embedded in a dense stellar wind from the companion Wolf–Rayet star (van Kerkwijk et al. 1992; Fender, Hanson & Pooley 1999), which makes difficult to isolate the compact object high energy spectrum. The high energy emission from the vicinity of the compact object in Cygnus X–3 is likely to be hidden by a dense stellar environment surrounding the source; as a consequence, the intrinsic X–ray luminosity might be higher than inferred, pushing the dataset closer to the 0.7 relation. Moreover, there still remains uncertainty about the nature of the ac- cretor in this system. The neutron star hypothesis can not be ruled out with confidence. It is interesting to note that, while the jets from GRS 1915+105 are at 60–70◦ (Fender et al. 1999a), those of ∼ 14◦, Cygnus X–3 appear to be close to the line of sight ( < Mioduszewski et al. 2001), supporting the previous hypoth- esis, in which higher–than–average normalisation factors would correspond to higher Doppler factors. In addition, the behaviour of Cygnus X–3, with the apparent turnover in the radio power, is very similar to that of Cygnus X–1, except for the flaring behaviour following the jet quenching (note that points corresponding to this flaring show characteristic optically thin radio spectra; on the contrary, pre–flaring de- tections display 'flat' radio spectra, i.e. a different physical origin). 6 PREDICTING RADIO FLUXES AT LOW QUIESCENT LUMINOSITIES As the same correlation appears to be maintained over many years and for different sources (like for instance Cygnus X–1, GX 339–4, V 404 Cyg), we can estimate the level of radio Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 11 Table 4. Five X–ray transients have been monitored in X–rays by different telescopes in different energy ranges (indicated below the table) during quiescence. Here we report the values for the maximum and the minimum luminosity, with relative references and energy ranges. For these values the corresponding predicted radio flux densities have been calculated based upon the radio:X–ray correlation we have found, that is Sradio = [223 × (SX,1kpc/Crab) 0.7]/(D/kpc)2mJy. Source X–ray luminosity Distance Flux density (1032 erg/sec) (kpc) at 1 kpc (10−6Crab) Predicted radio flux density (µJy) 1A 0620–00 GRO J1655–40 XTE J1550–564 GRO J0422+32 GS 2000+25 0.021– 0.042 (a,b) 0.23– 34 (a,c) < 5 5 (d) 0.084 (e) 0.024 (e) 1 3 4 2.4 2 1–5 6–82 < 173 ∼ 2 ∼ 0.5 18–43 6–34 < 32 ∼4 ∼2 References : 1: 0.4–2.4 keV; 2: 0.4–1.4 keV; 3: 0.3–7 keV; 4: 0.5–10 keV; 5: 0.5–7 keV. a: Kong et al. 2002; b: Narayan et al. 1996; c: Asai et al. 1998; d: Tomsick et al. 2001; e: Garcia et al. 2001. emission from a hard state BH by measuring its X–ray flux alone. This is particularly interesting in the case of black hole X–ray transients, whose inferred accretion rate during quiescence may be very small. Kong et al. (2002) present Chandra observations of three BH transients during quiescence for which no simultaneous radio detection is available to date, namely A 0620–00, GRO J1655–40 and XTE J1550–564. In order to check for possi- ble spectral variability, they also report results from previous X–ray observations carried out by different telescopes, such as ROSAT, ASCA and BeppoSAX. According to Tomsick et al. 2001, the lowest luminosity measured for XTE J1550– 564 with Chandra (5 × 1032 erg/sec, for a distance of 4 kpc) should however be considered only as an upper limit on the quiescent luminosity of the system. Chandra detections of other two transient sources, namely GRO J0422+32 and GS 2000+25, are reported by Garcia et al. 2001. In Table 4 we list for each of the five sources the maximum and the mini- mum measured X–ray luminosity in quiescence, the inferred distance and the predicted radio flux density (in µJy) based on our best–fit equation, that is Sradio = 223 × (SX )+0.7. Given a spread of 156 over 223 in the normalisation factor, the predicted values must be considered reliable within one order of magnitude. 6.1 A 0620–00: the ideal candidate The Soft X–ray Transient (SXT) A 0620–00 was discov- ered in outburst in 1975 August (Elvis et al. 1975), while the associated radio source was at a level of 200–300 mJy (Owen et al. 1976) during the onset of the outburst. Six years later the source was detected with the VLA at level of 249±79µJy (Geldzahler 1983); additional VLA observations in 1986 (see McClintock et al. 1995) yielded an upper limit of 140µJy, clearly indicating a decline in radio power (see Figure 6 where A 0620–00 detection/upper limit/predicted radio fluxes are marked with triangles). The 1981 detection might actually be associated to radio lobes resulting from the interaction of a relativistic–decelerating jet with the in- terstellar medium, as observed in the case of XTE J1550–564 about four years after the ejection of plasma from near the BH (Corbel et al. 2002). Due to its relative proximity, A 0620–00 is the most suitable candidate to probe if our empirical radio:X–ray relation does hold down to low quiescent X–ray luminosity (≃ 2 × 1030 erg/sec at 1 kpc, i.e. about 10−8LEdd; Garcia et al. 2001). In other words, if A 0620–00 was detected at the predicted radio level (a few tens of µJy, see Figure 6, bottom left cor- ner), it would confirm that the mechanisms at the origin of radio and X–ray emission are correlated, if not even partly coincident, over more than six orders of magnitude in X–ray luminosity. Moreover, if the radio:X–ray correlation were confirmed at very low X–ray luminosities (below 104 LEdd ) it would strongly constrain the overall theory of accretion in quies- cence. We direct the reader to the discussion for further comments. 7 DISCUSSION The presence of a coupling between radio and X–ray emis- sion in the low/hard state of black hole binaries obviously re- quires a theoretical interpretation that relates somehow the powering/quenching mechanism(s) of the jet to the overall accretion pattern. Zdziarski et al. (2003) ascribe the correla- tion to a correspondence between the level of X–ray emission and the rate of ejection of radio–emitting blobs forming a compact jet. In this picture, there still remains the ques- tion of the condition for jet suppression. Meier (2001) inter- prets the steady–jet/hard–X–ray state association as strong evidence for magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) jet formation, where the most powerful jets are the product of accretion flows characterised by large scale height. The simulations show in fact that the jet is confined by the toroidal compo- nent of the magnetic field lines, coiled due to the disc differ- ential rotation: the bigger the disc scale–height, the stronger the field. The power of the jet naturally decreases (at least 100 times weaker) in the soft/high state, associated with a standard geometrically thin disc (Shakura & Sunyaev 1973). To date, two broad classes of geometries have been pro- posed for explaining X–ray emission from low/hard state BHs. The more classical picture is that of a hot, homo- geneous, optically thin corona of (quasi–)thermal electrons which inverse Compton scatter 'seed' photons coming from the underlying accretion disc (Shapiro, Lightman & Eard- ley 1973 and similar later solutions). The alternative is that of a jet–synchrotron model, in which, under reasonable as- 12 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley sumption on the input power of the jet and the location of the first acceleration zone, optically thin synchtrotron emission can dominate the X–ray spectrum, traditionally thought to be a product of inverse Compton process only (see Markoff, Falcke & Fender 2001 for a detailed description of the model; hereafter MFF). This model however predicts self–synchrotron Compton upscattering in the jet for some scenarios. Remarkably, the MFF model is able to reproduce the observed slope of the radio:X–ray correlation analyti- cally (Markoff et al. 2003a), as a function of the measured X–ray and radio–infrared spectral indices. A revised version of the classical Comptonisation model for the hard state has been proposed by Beloborodov (1999). In this case the hot coronal plasma is powered by magnetic field line reconnections (Galeev, Rosner & Vaiana 1979) and confined within several active flares with mildly relativistic bulk velocities, inferred by the relative weakness of the re- flection component. Due to aberration effects in fact, the amount of X–rays as seen by the reflecting disc turns out to be reduced by a factor consistent with βX ≃ 0.3. Maccarone (2003) draws a similar conclusion on a different ground: he has tabulated all the the available measuremets of X–ray luminosities at the time of the soft–to–hard state transition, for both BHC and neutron star systems. The resultant variance in state transition luminosity is also con- sistent with coming from material with βX ≃ 0.2; therefore ΓX ≃ 1 in both cases. Following the approach of Section 4.2.2, this immediately implies a stringent upper limit on the beaming of radio < emission as well, that is Γradio ∼ 2 (see Figure 5). This is almost certainly significantly less relativistic than the jets produced during transients outbursts of sources such as GRS 1915+105 (Mirabel & Rodr´ıguez 1994; Fender et al. 1999a) and GRO J1655–40 (Hjellming & Rupen 1995; Harmon et al. 1995; see also Fender 2003). Therefore, if mildly relativistic beaming characterises the low/hard state, a mechanism(s) must exist which both switches the jet off – high/soft state – and produces a faster jet – discrete ejections – above ∼ 10−2LEdd , where the hard–to–soft state transition occurs. It is interesting to mention that a few percent of the Ed- dington rate is also close to the regime at which Ghisellini & Celotti (2001) have identified the transition line between FRI and FR II radio–galaxies, the former class being associ- ated with slower kpc–scale jets than the latter (see Begelman 1982; Bicknell 1984; Laing 1993). This leads to a kind of cor- respondence between 'extreme sources' like GRS 1915+105, or Cyg X–3, and FRII, characterised by quite high bulk Lorentz factors, while 'canonical' hard state sources would be associated with FR I, with relatively low outflow bulk velocities. 7.1 Jet–dominated 'quiescence' A main task of the models remains that of reproducing the observational behaviour of accreting stellar BHs at a vari- ety of accretion rates. An interesting prediction of this work concerns the relative power of the jet, with respect to the overall accretion power, at low quiescent luminosities. Figure 7. Broadband spectra of Cygnus X–1, V 404 Cygni and GX 339–4: for low/hard state (LHS) black holes, not only the behaviours in the Sradio/SX plane look very similar, but even the shape of their energy spectrum, from radio wavelengths up to X–rays, suggesting either a common origin or coupling of the basic emission processes. In this regime, the BH spectral energy distribution appears very similar to that of canonical hard state sources (see Fig- ure 7), although the X–ray emission in quiescence is not well reproduced by the standard accretion–corona model, requir- ing a much lower radiative efficiency. Narayan et al. (1996, 1997, 2001) showed that an Advec- tion Dominated Accretion Flow (ADAF), in which the en- ergy released by viscous torques is 'stored' into the flow rather than radiated away, can adequately model the avail- able observations at high energies. However, on the other extreme of the spectrum, in the radio band, the existence of a jet seriously weakens such a solution, requiring a sig- nificantly different physics to model the observed spectrum. Jet–powered radio emission is in fact several orders of mag- nitude brighter than expected extrapolating ADAF spectra down to radio band; moreover, the standard ADAF picture predicts highly–inverted radio spectra, instead of the ob- served flat ones. An alternative scenario for low–luminosity stellar black holes has been proposed by Merloni & Fabian (2002). They show that a coronal–outflow dominated accretion disc, in which the fraction of the accretion power released in the corona increases as the accretion rate decreases, would be an ideal site for jet–launching, both MHD and thermally driven. Based on the radio:X–ray correlation, the ratio between the observed radio and X–ray luminosities scales as: Lradio LX ∝ (LX )−0.3 (8) Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 13 This already implies that, as the X–ray luminosity decreases, the radiative jet power will become more and more impor- tant with respect to the X–rays. Moreover, because of the self–absorption effects, it has been shown that there will be not a linear relationship between the radio luminosity, Lradio, and the total jet power, Ljet, for any optically thick jet model which can explain the flat radio spectrum observed during the hard state. Blandford & Konigl (1979), Falcke & Biermann (1996), and Markoff, Falcke & Fender (2001) ob- tain in fact Lradio ∝ (Ljet)1.4. If so, and in general for any relationship of the form: Lradio ∝ (Ljet)x (9) equation 8 implies the following scaling for the fractional jet power: Ljet LX ∝ (LX )( 0.7 x −1) (10) Hence, for any x > 0.7, there exists an X–ray luminosity below which the jet will be the dominant output channel for the accretion power. If x = 1.4, by re–scaling the numbers to XTE J1118+480 – emitting at ∼ 10−3LEdd, and whose fractional jet power is at > least 20% (Fender et al. 2001) – one obtains that Ljet ∼ LX ∼ 4 × 10−5LEdd (i.e. below 0.005 Crab – scaled – < for LX see Figure 6). Note that observations of GX 339–4 and V 404 Cygni in quiescence already cover this regime, meaning that, if x = 1.4, both these sources actually are in a jet– dominated state. This would be a wholly new accretion regime for X–ray binaries, requiring significant modification of existing (e.g. ADAF) models. In addition it would indicate that the overwhelming majority of 'known' stellar–mass black holes, which are currently in quiescence, are in fact feeding back most of their accretion energy into the interstellar medium in the form of the kinetic energy of the jets and are accret- ing at rather higher levels than derived based only on their X–ray luminosity. If we do establish that accretion is taking place in quies- cence, for instance throught the detection of A 0620–00, and is furthermore channelling most of its power into jet forma- tion, then the arguments for observational evidence for black hole event horizons based upon a comparison of quiescent X–ray luminosities of black hole and neutron star binaries (e.g. Garcia et al. 2001) will need to be re–examined. In fact, assuming that Ljet ∝ (LX )[(0.7/x)] holds for both neu- tron stars and black holes, then the observed difference in 'radio loudness' between black hole and neutron star bina- ries (Fender & Kuulkers 2001) might be enough on its own to explain the discrepancy, and it may be that the event horizon plays no part. This is explored further in Fender, Gallo & Jonker (in preparation). 8 SUMMARY In this paper we provide observational evidence for a broad empirical relation between radio and X–ray emission in Galactic black hole binaries during their spectrally hard state. The main points established throught this work can be summarised as follows: • In low/hard state BHCs the observed radio and X–ray fluxes are correlated over more than three orders of magni- tude in accretion rate, with a spread in radio power of about one order of magnitude. • Even at accretion rates as low as 10−5 Eddington a powerful jet is being formed; no lower limit to the relation has been found. • V 404 Cygni is the second source to display Sradio ∝ (SX) 0.7, from quiescence up close to the hard–to–soft state transition. • Assuming 0.7 as a universal slope for the low/hard state, and under the hypotheses of a) common disc–jet cou- pling and b) isotropic X–ray emission, the measured spread in radio flux can be interpreted in terms of a distribution in Doppler factors. Monte Carlo simulations show that the observed scatter is consistent with relatively low beaming < (Γradio ∼ 2) outflows in the low/hard state, unlike those in transient outbursts. • When the combination of radio and X–ray beaming is taken into account, the range of possible bulk velocities in the jet significantly broadens, allowing the X–ray emitting material to be relativistic for almost any value of Γradio, but implying strong X–ray selection effects. In this case an independent estimation on ΓX is needed to limit Γradio. Un- related works (Beloborodov 1999; Maccarone 2003) impose stringent constraints on the bulk velocity of the X–ray emit- ting material, leading to the conclusion of relatively low ra- dio beaming (Γradio < ∼ 2) in the hard state. • Close to the hard–to–soft state transition the jet switches off, probably in all sources. The X–ray luminosity at which the radio quenching occurs might positively corre- late with the BH mass, being consistent with taking place at a constant fraction of the Eddington rate. It is worth men- tioning that a similar fraction of LEdd has been identified as a dividing line between FR I and FR II radio–galaxies, that is between supermassive BHs producing mildly and highly relativistic jets respectively (Ghisellini & Celotti 2001). • Since the correlation appears to be maintained over many years and for different sources, this leads to the pos- sibility of predicting the level of radio emission from a hard state and/or quiescent BH by measuring its X–ray flux. • If the radio luminosity scales as the total jet power raised to x, with x > 0.7, this implies the existence of an X– ray luminosity below which the most of the accretion power will be channelled into the jet rather than in the X–rays. If x = 1.4 (e.g. Blandford & Konigl 1979, Falcke & Biermann 1996; MFF), then below LX ≃ 4 × 10−5 LEdd the jet is expected to dominate. This work provides evidence for a physical coupling between radio and hard X–ray emitting ouflows from accreting stellar BHs. A key, still unresolved issue concerns the modelling of the transition between X–ray states in a self consistent way, which could possibly account for both the jet suppression, when the disc dominates, and the transition from mildly to highly relativistic jets, as in case of transient outbursts. In- cluding the formation of jets in the overall energetics and dynamics of the accretion process at a variety of X–ray lu- minosities has undoubtedly become of primary importance to address, especially based on mounting evidence for the jet power to be a significant fraction, if not the dominant output channel, of the total accretion power. 14 E. Gallo, R. P. Fender & G. G. Pooley ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors wish to thank Sera Markoff, Stephane Corbel, Peter Jonker and Michiel van der Klis, for many useful sug- gestions and comments on the manuscript. This research has made use of data obtained through the High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Center Online Ser- vice, provided by the NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center. The Ryle telescope is supported by PPARC. REFERENCES Fender R. P., Kuulkers E., 2001, MNRAS 324, 923 Fender R. P., Hanson M. M., Pooley G. G., 1999, MNRAS, 308, 473 Fender R. P., Southwell K., Tzioumis A. K., 1998, MNRAS, 298, 692 Fender R. P., Garrington S. T., McKay D. J., Muxlow T. W. B., Pooley G. G., Spencer R. E., Stirling A. M., Waltman E. B., 1999a, MNRAS, 304, 865 Fender R. P. et al. 1999b, ApJ, 519, L165 Galeev A. A., Rosner R., Vaiana G. S., 1979, ApJ, 229, 318 Gallo E., Fender R. P., 2002, MNRAS, 337, 869 Gallo E., Fender R. P., Pooley G. G., 2002, in Proc. of the Fourth Microquasars Workshop, Eds Ph. Durouchoux, Y. Fuchs, and J. Rodriguez, Center for Space Physics: Kolkata, 201 Asai K., Dotani T., Hoshi R., Tanaka Y., Robinson C. R., Terada Garcia M. R., McClintock J. E., Narayan R., Callanan P., Barret K., 1998, PASJ, 50, 611 D., Murray S. S., 2001, ApJ, 553, L47 Begelman M. C., 1982, Extragalactic Radio Sources, IAU Symp. 97, ed. D. S. Heeschen & C. M. Wade, Kluwer, 223 Belloni T., Klein–Wolt m., M´endez M., van der Klis M., van Geldzahler B. J., 1983, ApJ, 264, L49 Ghisellini G., Celotti A., 2001, A&A, 379, L1 Gierlinski M., Maciolek–Niedzwiecki A., Ebisawa K., 2001, MN- Paradijs J., 2000, A&A, 355, 271 RAS, 325, 1253 Belloni T., M´endez M., van der Klis M., Lewin W. H. G., Dieters S., 1999, ApJ, 519, L159 Beloborodov A. M., 1999, ApJ, 510, 123 Bicknell G. V., 1984, ApJ, 286, 68 Blandford R. D., Konigl A., 1979, ApJ, 232, 34 Bonnet–Bidaud J. M., Chardin G., 1998, Phys. Rep., 170, 326 Boyd P. T., Smale A. P., 2000, IAU Circ., 7424, 3 Brocksopp C., Fender R., Pooley G. G., MNRAS, 2002, 336, 699 Brocksopp C., Bandyopadhyay R. M., Fender R. P., 2003, sub- mitted Greiner J., Dennerl K., Predehl P., 1996, A&A, 314, L21 Haardt F., Maraschi L., 1991, ApJ, 380, L51 Haardt F. et al. , 2001, ApJ, 133, 187 Han X., Hjellming R. M., 1992, ApJ, 400, 304 Hannikainen D. C., Hunstead R. W., Campbell–Wilson D., Sood R. K., 1998, A&A, 337, 460 Harmon B. A., 1995, Nature, 374, 703 Heindl W. A., Prince T. A., Grunsfeld J. M., 1994, ApJ, 430, 829 Hjellming R. M., Rupen M. P., 1995, Nature, 375, 464 Hjellming R. M., Rupen M. P., Mioduszewski A. J., Narayan, R., Brocksopp C., Jonker P. G., Fender R. P., Groot P. J., van der 2000, The Astronomer's Telegram, 54 Klis M., Tingay S. J., 2001, MNRAS, 323, 517 Brocksopp C. et al. 1999, MNRAS, 309, 1063 Callanan P. J., Garcia M. R., Filippenko A. V., McLean I., Teplitz H., 1996, ApJ, 470, L57 Campana S., Stella L., Belloni T., Israel G. L., Santangelo A., Frontera F., Orlandini M., Dal Fiume D., 2002, A&A, 384, 163 Corbel S., Fender R., 2002, ApJ, 573, L35 Corbel S., Nowak M. A., Fender R. P., Tzioumis A. K., Markoff Hjellming R. M., Han X., 1995, Radio properties of X–ray bina- ries, in X–ray binaries, Eds. Lewin W. H. G., van Paradijs J., van den Heuvel E. P. J., Camridge University Press, 308 Homan J., Jonker P. G., van der Klis M., Kuulkers E., 2000, IAU Circ., 7425, 2 Homan J., Wijnands R., van der Klis M., Belloni T., van Paradijs J., Klein–Wolt M., Fender R., Mendez M., 2001, ApJS, 132, 377 Hynes R. I., Steeghs D., Casares J., Charles P. A., O'Brien K., S., 2003, A&A, 400, 1007 2003, ApJ, in press Corbel S., Fender R. P., Tzioumis A. K., Nowak M., McIntyre V., Hynes R. I., Haswell C. A., Chaty S., Shrader C. R., Cui W., Durouchoux P., Sood R., 2000, A&A 359, 251 2002, MNRAS, 331, 169 Corbel S. et al. , 2002, Science, 298, 196 Corbel S. et al. , 2001, ApJ, 554, 43 Cowley A. P., Schmidtke P. C., Hutchings J. B., Crampton D., 2002, ApJ, 123, 1741 Hynes R. I., Roche P., Charles P. A., Coe M. J., 1999, MNRAS, 305, L49 Keck J. W. et al. , 2001, ApJ, 563, 301 Kitamoto S., Tsunemi H., Pedersen H., Ilovaisky S. A., van der Della Valle M., Mirabel I. F., Rodr´ıguez L. F., 1994, A&A, 290, Klis M., 1990, ApJ, 361, 590 803 Klein–Wolt M., Fender, R. P., Pooley G. G., Belloni T., Migliari Di Salvo T., Done C., Zycki P. T., Burderi L., Robba N. R., 2001, S., Morgan E. H., van der Klis M., 2002, MNRAS, 331, 745 ApJ, 547, 1024 Done C., 2001, Adv. Space Res., 28, 255 Dubus G., Kim R. S. J., Menou K., Szkody P., Bowen D. V., 2001, 553, 307 Ebisawa, K. et al. , 1994, PASJ, 46, 375 Elvis M., Page C. G., Pounds K. A., Ricketts M. J., Turner M. J. L., 1975, Nature, 257, 656 Falcke H., Biermann P. L., 1996, A&A, 308, 321 Fender R. P., 2003, MNRAS, in press Fender R. P., 2001a, MNRAS, 322, 31 Fender R. P., 2001b, A&SS, 276, 69 Fender R. P., 2001c, Relativistic flows in Astrophysics, Springer Verlag Lecture Notes in Physics, Eds A.W. Guthmann, M. Georganopoulos, K. Manolakou and A. Marcowith, Lect. Notes Phys. 589, 101 Fender R. P., 2000, in Proc. of the Third Microquasar Workshop, Eds A. J. Castro–Tirado, J. Greiner and J. M. Paredes, A&SS 276, 69 Kong A. K. H., McClintock J. E., Garcia M. R., Murray S. S., Barret D., 2002, ApJ, 570, 277 Kotani T. et al. , 2000, ApJ, 543, L133 Kubota A., Makishima K., Ebisawa K., 2001, ApJ, 560, L147 Kuulkers E., Fender R. P., Spencer R. E., Davis R. J., Morison I., 1999, MNRAS, 306, 919 Laing R. A., 1993, Astrophysical Jets, ed. D. Burgarella, M. Livio & C. O'Dea Cambridge University Press, 95 Lin D. et al. , 2000, ApJ, 532, 548 Maccarone T. J., 2003, MNRAS, submitted Maccarone T. J., 2002, MNRAS, 336, 1371 Main D. S., Smith D. M., Heindl W. A. Swank J., Leventhal M., Mirabel I. F., Rodr´ıguez L. F., 1999, ApJ, 525, 901 Markoff S., Falcke H., Fender R.P., 2001, A&AL, 372, L25 (MFF) Markoff S., Nowak M. A., Corbel S., Fender R., Falcke H., 2003a, A&A, 397, 645 Markoff S., Nowak M., Corbel S., Fender R., Falcke H., 2003b, in Proceedings for 'The Physics of Relativistic Jets in the Radio:X–ray correlation in low/hard state BHCs 15 Chandra and XMM Era', Eds. G. Brunetti, D. E. Harris, R. M. Sambruna & G. Setti Tomsick J., Corbel S., Kaaret P., ApJ, 2001, 563, 229 Ueda Y., Inoue H., Tanaka Y., Ebisawa K., Nagase F., Kotani T., Markwardt C. B., Marshall F. E., Swank J. H., 1999, IAU Circ., Gehrels N., 1998, ApJ, 492, 782; erratum ApJ, 500, 1069 7274, 2 Mart´ı J., Mirabel I.F., Duc P.A., Rodr´ıguez L.F., 1997, A&A, 323, 158 van Kerkwijk M. H. et al. , 1992, Nature, 355, 703 Wagner R. M., Starrfield S. G., Hjellming R. M., Howell S. B., Kreidl T. J., 1994, ApJ 429, L25 Massey P., Johnson K. E., Degioia–Eastwood K., 1995, ApJ, 454, Wilms J., Nowak M. A., Pottschmidt K., Heindl W. A., Dove J. B., Begelman M. C., 2001, MNRAS, 320, 327 Zdziarski A. A., Gilfanov M., Lubinski P., Revnivtsev M., 2003, MNRAS, in press Zdziarski A. A., Poutanen J., Mikolajewska J., Gierlinski M., Ebi- sawa K., Johnson W. N., 1998, MNRAS, 301, 435 Zycki P. T., Done C., Smith D. A., 1999, MNRAS, 305, 231 151 McClintock J. E., Horne K., Remillard R. A., 1995, ApJ, 442, 358 McClintock J. E., et al. , 2001, ApJ, 555, 477 Meier D. L., 2001, ApJ, 548, L9 Merloni A., 2002, in Proc. of the Fourth Microquasars Workshop, Eds Ph. Durouchoux, Y. Fuchs, and J. Rodriguez, Center for Space Physics: Kolkata, 2105. Merloni A., Fabian A. C., 2002, MNRAS, 332, 165 Miller J. M., Fox D. W., Di Matteo T., Wijnands R., Belloni T., Pooley D., Kouveliotou C., Lewin W. H. G., 2001, ApJ, 546, 1055 Mirabel I. F., Rodr´ıguez L. F., Nature, 371, 46 Mirabel I. F., Rodr´ıguez L. F., 1999, ARA&A, 37, 409 Mioduszewski A. J., Rupen M. P., Hjellming R. M., Pooley G. G., Waltman E. B., 2001, ApJ, 553, 766 Narayan R., Barret D., McClintock J. E., 1997, ApJ, 482, 448 Narayan R., Garcia M. R., Mcclintock J. E., 2001, in Proc. of the Ninth Marcel Grossmann Meeting, Eds V. Gurzadyan, R. Jantzen, R. Ruffini, Singapore: World Scientific Narayan R., McClintock J. E., Yi I., 1996, ApJ, 457, 821 Nowak M. A., 1995, PASP, 107, 1207 Orosz, J. A., 2002, in Proc. of the IAU Symp. 212, Eds K. A. van der Hucht, A. Herraro, & C. Esteban, San Francisco: ASP (astro-ph/0209041) Orosz J. A., Jain R. K., Bailyn C. D., McClintock J. E., Remillard R. A., 1998, ApJ, 499, 375 Owen F. N., Balonek T. J., Dickey J., Terzian Y., Gottesman S. T., 1976, ApJ, 203, L15 Parmar A. N., Belloni T., Orlandini M., Dal Fiume D., Orr A., Masetti N., 2000, A&A, 360, L31 Parmar A. N., Stella L., White N. E., 1986, ApJ, 304, 664 Pooley G. G., Fender R., Brocksopp C., 1999, MNRAS, 302, L1 Pooley G. G., Fender R., 1997, MNRAS, 292, 925 Poutanen J., 1998, in Theory of Black Hole Accretion Disks, Cam- ridge University Press, 100 Poutanen J., Svensson R., 1996, ApJ, 470, 249 Predehl P., Burwitz V., Paerels F., Trmper J., 2000, A&A, 357, 25 Robinson E. L., Ivans I. I., Welsh W. F., 2002, ApJ, 565, 1169 Rutledge R. E., Bildsten L., Brown E. F., Pavlov G. G., Zavlin V. E., 1999, ApJ, 514, 945 S´anchez–Fer´andez C. et al. , 1999, A&A, 348, L9 Schulz N. S., Cui W., Canizares C. R., Marshall H. L., Lee J. C., Miller J. M., Lewin W. H. G., 2002, ApJ, 565, 1141 Shahbaz T., Naylor T., Charles P. A., 1997, MNRAS, 285, 607 Shahbaz T., Naylor T., Charles P. A., 1994, MNRAS, 268, 756 Shakura N. I., Sunyaev R. A., 1973, A&A 24, 337 Shapiro S. L., Lightman A. P., Eardley D. M., 1976, ApJ, 204, 187 Shrader C. R., Wagner R. M., Charles P. A., Harlaftis E. T., Naylor T., 1997, ApJ, 487, 858 Sobczak G. J., McClintock J. E., Remillard R. A., Levine A. M., Morgan E. H., Bailyn C. D., Orosz J., 1999, ApJ, 517, L121 Sood R., Campbell–Wilson D., 1994, IAU Circ., 6006, 1 Stirling A. M., Spencer R. E., de la Force C. J., Garrett M. A., Fender R. P., Ogley R. N., 2001, MNRAS, 327, 1273 Sunyaev R. A., Titarchk L. G., 1980, A&A, 86, 121 Sunyaev R. A. et al. , 1991, ApJ, 383, L49 Tanaka Y., 1993, IAU Circ., 5877, 1 Terasawa N., Nakamura H., 1995, A&A, 294, 443 Tomsick J. A., Kaaret P., 2000, ApJ, 537, 448
astro-ph/0603460	2	0603	2006-03-24T13:25:19	Systematic Effects in Measurement of Black Hole Masses by Emission-Line Reverberation of Active Galactic Nuclei: Eddington Ratio and Inclination	[ "astro-ph" ]	We try to identify the sources and systematics of the uncertainty of the masses of the central black holes in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) which have been obtained by reverberation-mapping methods. We characterize the broad H$\beta$ emission-line profiles by the ratio of their full-width at half maximum (FWHM) to their line dispersion, i.e., the second moment of the line profile. We use this parameter to separate the reverberation-mapped AGNs into two populations, the first with narrower H$\beta$ lines with relatively extended wings, and the second with broader lines that are relatively flat-topped. The first population is characterized by higher Eddington ratios than the second. Within each population, we calibrate the black-hole mass scale by comparison of the reverberation-based mass with that predicted by the bulge velocity dispersion. We also use the distribution of ratios of the reverberation-based mass to the velocity-dispersion mass prediction in a comparison with a ``generalized thick disk'' model in order to see if inclination can plausibly account for the observed distribution. We find that the line dispersion is a less biased parameter in general than FWHM for black hole mass estimation, although we show that it is possible to empirically correct for the bias introduced by using FWHM to characterize the emission-line width. We also argue that inclination effects are apparent in a small subset of objects with the narrowest emission lines. Our principal conclusion is that the H$\beta$ profile is sensitive primarily to Eddington ratio, but that inclination effects play a role in some cases. (abridged)	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. Collin July 16, 2018 c(cid:13) ESO 2018 6 0 0 2 r a M 4 2 2 v 0 6 4 3 0 6 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Systematic Effects in Measurement of Black Hole Masses by Emission-Line Reverberation of Active Galactic Nuclei: Eddington Ratio and Inclination Suzy Collin1, Toshihiro Kawaguchi2, Bradley M. Peterson3, and Marianne Vestergaard4 1 LUTH, Observatoire de Paris, Section de Meudon, F-92195 Meudon Cedex, France 2 Optical and Infrared Division, NAOJ, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan 3 Department of Astronomy, The Ohio State University, 140 West 18th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA 4 Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, 933 N. Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA Preprint online version: July 16, 2018 ABSTRACT Context. Scatter around the relationship between central black hole masses in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) obtained by reverberation-mapping methods and host-galaxy bulge velocity dispersion indicates that the masses are uncertain typically by a factor of about three. Aims. In this paper, we try to identify the sources and systematics of this uncertainty. Methods. We characterize the broad Hβ emission-line profiles by the ratio of their full-width at half maximum (FWHM) to their line dispersion, i.e., the second moment of the line profile. We use this parameter to separate the reverberation-mapped AGNs into two populations, the first with narrower Hβ lines that tend to have relatively extended wings, and the second with broader lines that are relatively flat-topped. The first population is characterized by higher Eddington ratios than the second. Within each population, we calibrate the black-hole mass scale by comparison of the reverberation-based mass with that predicted by the bulge velocity dispersion. We also use the distribution of ratios of the reverberation-based mass to the velocity-dispersion mass prediction in a comparison with a "generalized thick disk" model in order to see if inclination can plausibly account for the observed distribution. Results. We find that the line dispersion is a less biased parameter in general than FWHM for black hole mass estimation, although we show that it is possible to empirically correct for the bias introduced by using FWHM to characterize the emission- line width. We also argue that inclination effects are apparent only in some small subset of the reverberation-based mass measurements; it is primarily the objects with the narrowest emission lines that seem to be most strongly affected. Conclusions. Our principal conclusion is that the Hβ profile is sensitive primarily to Eddington ratio, but that inclination effects play a role in some cases. Key words. Quasars: general - black hole - galaxies: active - galaxies: Seyfert 1. Introduction During the last twenty years, reverberation mapping (Blandford & McKee 1982; Peterson 1993) of the broad emission lines in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) has been used to determine the size of the broad-line region (BLR) in these objects. By combining the BLR size with the emission-line Doppler width, it is possible to estimate the mass of the central source, presumed to be a black hole (BH), as MBH = f RBLR∆V 2 G , (1) Send offprint requests to: Suzy Collin ([email protected]) where RBLR is the size of the BLR, ∆V is the emission line width, and f is a scale factor of order unity that depends on the structure, kinematics, and inclination of the BLR. In the cases where multiple emission lines have been ob- served, it is found that the higher-ionization lines tend to have shorter response times, or lags τ , and thus arise in re- gions relatively closer to the central source than the lower- ionization lines. Moreover, the lines with shorter lags tend to be broader than those with longer lags, generally con- sistent with the virial prediction τ = R/c ∝ ∆V −2, pro- viding a strong argument that eq. (1) is valid (Peterson & Wandel 1999, 2000, Onken & Peterson 2002; Kollatschny 2003a). In addition, AGNs show a relationship between BH mass and the host-galaxy bulge velocity dispersion σ∗ 2 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs (Gebhardt et al. 2000b; Ferrarese et al. 2001; Onken et al. 2004; Nelson et al. 2004) that is consistent with this same correlation, the MBH -- σ∗ relationship, that is observed in quiescent galaxies (Ferrarese & Merritt 2000; Gebhardt et al. 2000a; Tremaine et al. 2002). Reverberation mapping has also confirmed the ex- pected relationship between the size of the BLR and the luminosity of the AGN, which takes the form RBLR ∝ Lα, (2) where α ≈ 0.5, but depends somewhat on which luminos- ity measure is being used and possibly also on which emis- sion line is used to determine RBLR (Wandel, Peterson, & Malkan 1999; Kaspi et al. 2000, 2005; Bentz et al. 2006). This radius -- luminosity (R -- L) relationship is im- portant not only because it tells us something about the physics of the emission-line region, but because it also af- fords an almost trivially simple secondary mass indicator, since through eq. (2), measurement of the luminosity pro- vides a surrogate for the otherwise hard-to-measure BLR radius. It thus becomes possible to easily estimate BH masses for large samples of AGNs (Wandel et al. 1999; Vestergaard 2002, 2004; McLure & Jarvis 2002; Kollmeier et al. 2006; Vestergaard & Peterson 2006). Such studies have shown, for example, that the BH masses of high- redshift quasars are very large (Vestergaard 2004; Netzer 2003). At the other extreme, very small BH masses have been inferred for low-luminosity Seyferts (Greene & Ho 2004; Barth et al. 2005). It has also been found that ap- plication of luminosity-scaling relationships indicate that AGNs with small line widths, i.e., narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxies have relatively small BH masses for their luminosity. It appears that the ratio of their bolometric lu- minosity to the Eddington luminosity, which we hereafter refer to as the "Eddington ratio," is high, close in fact to unity. Through accretion-disk modeling, Collin et al. (2002), Kawaguchi (2003) and Collin & Kawaguchi (2004) have shown that NLS1s have accretion rates larger than the Eddington value (although also see Williams, Mathur, & Pogge 2004). These results have important physical and cosmologi- cal consequences (cf. Yu & Tremaine 2003; Kawaguchi et al. 2004b). It is therefore essential to understand the accu- racy of the reverberation measurements (primary mass in- dicators) and their calibration uncertainties as well as the scaling relationships (secondary mass indicators) based on them, especially when these are extrapolated beyond the range over which they were determined, i.e., to much higher and much lower luminosities, to high redshifts, and to high and low Eddington ratios. In principle, this could be achieved through comparison with an independent pri- mary or secondary mass indicator, though at the present time there is no other obvious choice beyond the MBH -- σ∗ relationship. Indeed, the MBH -- σ∗ relationship has been employed in investigations of AGN BH masses in two dis- tinct ways, (a) by using measurements of σ∗ to infer a BH mass to compare with the reverberation-based mass in an attempt to extract information on the inclination of the BLR (Wu & Han 2001; Zhang & Wu 2002), and (b) by normalizing the AGN MBH -- σ∗ relationship to that of quiescent galaxies in order to calibrate the reverberation- based mass scale by determining a statistical average value for the scaling factor hfi (Onken et al. 2004). Of course, it would be even more desirable to use reverberation-mapping techniques to obtain a velocity -- delay map that would reveal the kinematics and structure of the BLR and lead to determination of the central mass. However, various limitations of the reverberation data ob- tained to date have precluded this (Horne et al. 2004), but have nevertheless yielded mean response times for emis- sion lines and have enabled BH mass estimates through eq. (1). This apparent simplication entails a price in the accuracy to which the BH mass can be measured and a number of ambiguities arise. Among the more challenging are: 1. What line-width measure gives the most accurate BH mass? The two commonly used measures are the full width at half maximum (FWHM) and the second mo- ment of the emission-line profile σline, which we refer to as the "line dispersion1." The ratio of these two mea- sures varies widely from one AGN to another and, as discussed below, varies with other AGN spectral prop- erties. Thus, depending on which measure we select, we might be introducing a bias in mass estimate that varies with other AGN parameters. 2. How does one evaluate and interpret the scaling fac- tor f ? It is clear that f should depend strongly on the inclination for a flattened system (e.g., a rotat- ing disk), but it may vary with other AGN properties. Given that we are characterizing the size and velocity dispersion of the BLR by single numbers, we are sub- suming a lot of our ignorance of AGN structure into this single parameter, so interpretation can be difficult and ambiguous. In this contribution, we will examine the systematics of the line-width measures and attempt to identify possi- ble biases associated with the character of the emission- line profiles. We will also, in the spirit of an exercise, assume that the Hβ-emitting component of the BLR is an azimuthally symmetric, relatively flat structure that is dominated by rotational motion (i.e., a Keplerian disk). We will combine this with an isotropic component, a wind perhaps, and investigate the effects of disk inclination on the scaling factor f . Our goal is to attempt to disentangle the different factors which play a role in the determinimg line profile of AGNs, and therefore in the scale factor and in the mass determination. As we noted earlier, we subsume most of our igno- rance about the BLR structure and kinematics into the scale factor f and separate it from the "observable" quan- tity in eq. (1), which we refer to as the "virial product," VP = cτ ∆V 2/G, which has units of mass and differs from 1 The line dispersion for an emission line σline should not be confused with the host galaxy bulge velocity disperion σ∗. Name JD limits ! cent d(! cent) log L Dlog L Mrk 335 Mrk 335 PG0026+129 PG0052+251 F9 Mrk 590 Mrk 590 Mrk 590 Mrk 590 3C120 Akn120 Akn120 Mrk79 Mrk79 Mrk79 Mrk79 PG0804+761 PG0844+349 Mrk110 Mrk110 Mrk110 PG0953+414 NGC3227 NGC3227 NGC3516 NGC3783 NGC4051 NGC4151 PG1211+143 PG1226+023 PG1229+204 NGC4593 PG1307+085 IC4329A Mrk279 PG1411+442 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 NGC5548 PG1426+015 Mrk817 Mrk817 Mrk817 PG1613+658 PG1617+175 PG1700+518 3C390.3 Mrk509 PG2130+099 NGC7469 49156-49338 49889-50118 48545-51084 48461-51084 50473-50665 48090-48323 48848-49048 49183-49338 49958-50122 47837-50388 48148-48344 49980-50175 47838-48044 48193-48393 48905-49135 49996-50220 48319-51085 48319-51085 48953-49149 49751-49874 50010-50262 48319-50997 47894-48049 48623-48776 47894-48047 48607-48833 50183-50263 49305-49404 48319-51000 48361-50997 48319-50997 47894-48049 48319-51042 48643-48832 50095-50289 48319-51038 47509-47809 47861-48179 48225-48534 48623-48898 48954-49255 49309-49636 49679-50008 50044-50373 50434-50729 50775-51085 51142-51456 51517-51791 51878-52174 47212-47360 48334-51042 49000-49212 49404-49528 49752-49924 48397-51073 48362-51085 48378-51084 49718-50012 47653-50374 48382-51084 50237-50295 16.800 12.500 111.00 89.800 17.400 20.700 14.000 29.200 28.800 38.100 47.100 37.100 9.0000 16.100 16.000 5.6000 146.90 3.0000 24.300 20.400 33.300 150.10 8.2000 5.4000 6.7000 10.200 5.8000 3.1000 93.800 306.80 37.800 1.2000 105.60 1.5000 16.700 124.30 19.700 18.600 15.900 11.000 13.000 13.400 21.700 16.400 17.500 26.500 24.800 6.5000 14.300 7.8000 95.000 19.000 15.300 33.600 40.100 71.500 251.80 23.600 79.600 158.10 4.5000 4.5000 6.0500 26.200 24.300 3.7500 3.1000 8.6500 4.9500 3.9000 18.300 10.350 5.1000 8.0500 6.6000 6.1000 3.4000 18.850 11.200 6.9000 8.4000 12.450 22.100 6.7500 11.400 5.3000 2.8000 2.2000 1.3000 33.850 79.700 21.450 7.2500 41.300 2.2500 3.9000 61.350 1.5000 2.2000 2.7000 1.9500 1.5000 4.0500 2.6000 1.1500 1.8000 3.2500 3.1000 4.7000 6.6000 3.3000 33.500 3.8000 3.6000 7.0500 15.100 31.650 42.350 6.4500 5.7500 24.250 0.75000 43.830 43.890 45.020 44.960 44.250 43.870 43.700 43.780 43.900 44.170 44.300 44.170 43.710 43.790 43.730 43.660 44.940 44.350 43.740 43.800 43.620 45.220 42.410 42.360 42.880 43.260 41.930 43.050 44.750 45.960 44.080 43.090 44.880 43.320 43.910 44.630 43.560 43.430 43.540 43.390 43.520 43.550 43.650 43.590 43.470 43.690 43.640 43.410 43.410 43.330 44.720 43.870 43.790 43.790 44.980 44.480 45.630 43.950 44.280 44.460 43.720 0.030 0.020 0.060 0.080 0.050 0.030 0.050 0.030 0.070 0.080 0.020 0.050 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.030 0.080 0.040 0.050 0.060 0.14 0.060 0.070 0.020 0.13 0.040 0.030 0.030 0.070 0.050 0.050 0.14 0.040 0.050 0.040 0.040 0.060 0.060 0.040 0.080 0.040 0.050 0.040 0.070 0.050 0.050 0.070 0.070 0.050 0.050 0.070 0.060 0.040 0.020 0.050 0.080 0.030 0.070 0.080 0.040 0.020 FWHM Mean 1792.1 1678.8 2543.7 5007.9 5998.9 2787.9 3729.3 2743.5 2500.3 2326.8 6041.5 6246.2 5055.6 4759.9 4765.7 4137.3 3052.6 2694.3 1543.2 1658.3 1599.6 3070.9 4445.3 5103.3 5840.1 3769.6 1453.0 6371.2 2012.1 3509.0 3827.8 5661.0 5058.6 5964.0 5354.2 2801.1 4673.9 5417.5 5236.1 5986.1 5930.5 7378.1 6945.6 6623.0 6298.2 6177.4 6247.3 6240.2 6478.1 5556.4 7112.8 4711.3 5236.6 4766.7 9073.8 6641.3 2252.4 12694 3014.9 2852.7 1722.1 DFWHM mean 3.4300 1.8900 56.100 73.180 66.030 28.640 426.22 79.030 42.500 47.970 34.770 77.820 84.540 31.140 71.170 37.460 37.710 58.110 4.6600 2.5500 39.000 27.400 134.30 159.46 1975.5 67.910 3.2900 150.36 36.650 36.270 54.400 139.52 132.66 134.27 32.130 43.100 63.220 107.31 87.360 95.400 41.910 38.710 78.510 92.530 65.410 35.820 56.630 76.540 107.75 230.04 159.80 49.410 66.620 71.790 103.08 190.18 84.980 13.450 2.2700 39.280 29.630 sigma mean 1380.1 1370.9 1738.1 2167.1 2347.4 1941.6 2168.5 1967.4 1879.9 1248.5 1753.3 1862.1 2313.6 2281.2 2311.8 1939.3 1433.6 1505.4 961.54 953.14 986.79 1658.9 1913.8 2473.4 3870.8 1690.7 1500.1 2310.6 1486.9 1777.9 1608.2 2304.8 1963.1 2271.1 1822.9 1773.6 1933.7 2226.9 2205.4 3109.8 2486.3 2877.0 2432.2 2276.4 2178.0 2034.8 2021.2 2010.1 3111.4 1895.9 2905.9 1984.4 2097.6 2195.2 3084.5 2313.3 3160.1 3743.7 1554.5 1485.0 1706.9 Dsigma mean 6.3900 8.3600 99.960 29.710 15.710 26.270 29.660 19.430 19.450 21.290 6.1900 12.830 23.120 25.750 21.260 15.610 18.450 14.450 14.600 9.8900 17.980 31.310 71.100 25.900 28.140 19.210 34.490 11.420 29.580 17.140 24.070 49.750 47.200 57.750 11.160 28.650 5.1400 20.010 15.510 53.300 13.470 17.130 12.600 15.000 11.610 10.970 18.480 29.620 130.71 53.780 79.800 7.5700 12.620 16.040 32.710 68.690 93.140 42.370 6.5100 15.190 19.770 FWHM rms 1629.0 1374.7 1718.5 4165.1 6900.7 1675.2 2565.9 2114.7 1979.3 2204.9 5536.3 5284.5 5086.0 4219.0 5251.3 2786.4 2011.8 2147.9 1494.2 1381.1 1521.4 3001.9 5138.0 3353.3 3092.8 1071.9 4248.5 1316.8 2598.0 3414.5 3769.0 5058.1 6431.4 3385.0 2397.8 4044.1 4664.1 5775.9 5690.7 2542.7 7202.3 6141.9 5706.1 5541.3 4595.6 6376.6 5956.8 6246.8 8047.1 6322.9 3514.7 4952.4 3751.9 7896.6 4717.9 1846.1 9957.7 2714.9 2911.7 2169.2 DFWHM rms 145.34 356.95 495.48 380.51 707.07 587.44 106.36 574.52 385.70 185.34 297.23 202.88 1435.6 261.86 533.46 389.92 845.20 612.03 801.69 528.26 59.290 397.67 786.58 309.66 528.64 112.22 516.11 138.08 298.78 320.37 861.66 524.23 6247.1 348.89 353.13 199.18 324.33 236.78 163.73 605.33 391.89 289.42 356.55 354.03 504.72 146.92 224.12 343.15 1268.2 1295.4 393.07 537.06 994.53 1791.7 990.98 681.87 1045.9 101.30 231.10 459.48 sigma rms 917.22 948.42 1773.5 1782.7 3786.9 789.37 1934.5 1250.7 1201.2 1165.9 1958.9 1884.1 2137.4 1682.5 1853.6 1882.9 1970.9 1447.7 1196.4 1114.7 754.96 1306.1 2017.6 1924.9 1837.2 1753.3 542.61 1913.6 1080.0 1776.8 1385.1 1672.8 1819.9 2476.2 1420.4 1607.0 1687.1 1881.8 2074.9 2263.5 1908.8 2894.8 2247.5 2025.7 1922.9 1731.7 1980.3 1969.1 2172.6 3078.4 3441.7 1392.2 1970.9 1729.3 2547.2 2625.6 1700.2 3105.2 1276.0 1623.5 1456.3 Dsigma rms 52.010 112.69 284.90 86.040 196.73 74.150 52.330 71.770 129.99 50.310 109.01 47.720 375.43 71.610 71.720 245.75 104.80 78.950 140.88 103.47 29.460 143.63 173.70 124.91 115.07 140.80 52.140 41.740 101.81 150.09 110.60 168.54 122.09 225.53 96.280 168.13 55.950 83.280 80.700 87.630 128.84 113.75 133.60 68.390 61.640 75.940 30.230 47.950 89.090 196.95 308.13 78.010 95.520 158.44 341.62 210.91 122.89 81.210 28.070 85.980 207.12 S . C o l l i n , T . K a w a g u c h i , . B M . P e t e r s o n , & M . V e s t e r g a a r d : M a s s e s o f B l a c k H o l e s i n A G N s 3 4 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs the actual BH mass only by the dimensionless factor f . In this contribution, we will not concern ourselves with uncertainties in the virial product, which are generally ∼ 30%. It is the much larger uncertainty in f that will concern us here. In the next section, we study the relationship between FWHM and σline and we show that the ratio of these quan- tities varies strongly among the objects. We try to under- stand the cause and the implications of these variations. By comparing the virial products with the BH masses de- termined through the MBH -- σ∗ relationship, we consider the relationships among the scale factor, the line-width ratio FWHM/σline, and the Eddington ratio. In Section 3, we discuss the influence of the inclination of the BLR on the scale factor. Within the context of our simple two-component model, we will argue that some objects, specifically some of those for which FWHM/σline is small, are likely seen nearly face-on geometry, and consequently their BH masses could be significantly underestimated. In Section 4, we speculate on the physical conditions in the BLR that could explain our results. We conclude with a summary in Section 5. 2. Normalization of Reverberation Masses: The Scale Factor f The fundamental challenge that we need to address is how to obtain from reverberation data masses that are accu- rate and unbiased with respect to the various factors, such as inclination of the BLR, that can affect the value of the virial product. Given our poor understanding of the struc- ture and kinematics of the BLR we do not know a priori what these various factors might be. We do know, how- ever, that the broad Hβ profiles show marked differences among AGNs, and it is certainly true that the mass we adopt for a particular AGN will depend on precisely how we characterize the width of the line. Thus, our approach will be necessarily empirical: we will examine various ways of determining the line-width measure that is used as ∆V in eq. (1) and attempt to identify systematic effects or biases. 2.1. Mean and RMS Spectra In computing reverberation-based masses, it is common practice to take all of the individual spectra that were measured to obtain the continuum and emission-line light curves and construct "mean" and "root-mean-square (rms)" spectra. The advantage of the rms spectrum over the mean spectrum is that it isolates the spectral com- ponents that are actually varying, and automatically re- moves constant or slowly varying components, such as the narrow emission lines that arise on much larger physical scales. The disadvantage of using the rms spectrum is that it is often quite noisy as the amplitude of spectral vari- ability is usually rather low. It is consequently not obvi- ous whether it is better to measure the line width in the mean or the rms spectrum. We will argue here that use of the mean spectrum for line-width measurement gives results consistent with line-width measurements based on rms spectra, provided that one can account for contam- inating features, the narrow-line components being most important in the case of the Balmer lines. This is im- portant because in using single-epoch spectra and scaling relationships to estimate BH masses, the variable part of the emission line cannot be isolated. 2.2. Line-Width Measures: FWHM and σline We first consider the differences between the FWHM and the line dispersion σline. The FWHM is a zeroth-order moment of the profile and the line dispersion is a second- order moment that is relatively more sensitive to the line wings and less sensitive to the line core. It is traditional in AGN studies to use FWHM to characterize line widths. For determination of BH masses, Wandel et al. (1999) and Kaspi et al. (2000) used FWHM, but based on a sugges- tion by Fromerth & Melia (2000), Peterson et al. (2004) investigated use of the line dispersion and found that it can be measured to higher precision (i.e., with the smaller formal uncertainty) than FWHM, especially in noisy spec- tra, and that the virial relationship τ ∝ ∆V −2 is better reproduced with σline than with FWHM. From the point of view of accuracy (i.e., a measurement closest to the true value), however, it is not clear which is the best line-width measure to use in eq. (1), and it is that question we take up here. The relationship between σline and FWHM depends on the line profile: it is well-known, for example, that for a Gaussian profile FWHM/σline = 2(2 ln 2)1/2 = 2.35. For a rectangular function, FWHM/σline = 2√3 = 3.46, and a triangular function has FWHM/σline = √6 = 2.45. Similarly, for an edge-on rotating ring, FWHM/σline = 2√2 = 2.83. At the lower extreme, FWHM/σline → 0 for a Lorentzian profile. Peterson et al. (2004) provide measurements of FWHM and σline from the rms spectra for all the lines for which time-delay measurements are available for virtually all of the reverberation-mapped AGNs (see their Table 6). For the purpose of comparison, we have measured the Hβ line widths in the corresponding mean spectra, using the same algorithms and assumptions of Peterson et al. (2004) and removing the narrow-line components whenever necessary. Also, the Hβ profiles in the mean spectra often have strong contamination in the long-wavelength wing, underneath the [O III] λλ4959, 5007 lines, by Fe II m42 emission. This contamination is much weaker in the rms spectra because Fe II emission seems to be less variable than the Balmer lines (cf. Vestergaard & Peterson 2005). For this reason, the σline measurements we use are based on the short- wavelength side of the line, assuming that line is approxi- mately symmetric. These measurements, plus the Hβ rms spectrum measurements from Peterson et al. (2004), are given in Table 1, and these values will be used throughout the rest of this paper. Columns (1) and (2) identify the S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 5 AGN and time interval (Julian Date − 2400000) during which the data were obtained, respectively. Column (3) gives the cross-correlation function centroid τcent, in days, which is our preferred measure of the emission-line lag. Column (4) gives an estimate of the uncertainty ∆τcent, that is the root mean square of the usually slightly asym- metric upward and downward uncertainties, again in days. Columns (5) give the logarithm of the mean optical lumi- nosity in erg s−1 based on the continuum measurements made during the interval given in column (2), and col- umn (6) gives the rms variability of the luminosity during the same interval. The following columns give the values and uncertainties all in km s−1 in the rest frame of the AGN and corrected for the spectrograph resolution, for FWHM in the mean spectrum (columns 7 and 8), σline in the mean spectrum (columns 9 and 10), FWHM in the rms spectrum (columns 11 and 12), and σline in the rms spec- trum (columns 13 and 14), We note that the optical lumi- nosity has not been corrected for the host-galaxy starlight contribution. Therefore, the luminosity and Eddington ra- tios, especially for the less-luminous objects, are subject to overestimation on account of starlight contamination. Some of the values in this Table will be superceded by work in progress, but since the database is constantly evolving, we have decided to proceed with the present data, as our conclusions are not likely to change drasti- cally by a few more precise measurements. In Fig. 1, we compare measurements of σline for Hβ in the mean and rms spectra (left panel) and FWHM for Hβ in the mean and rms spectra (right panel). Both FWHM and σline measurements in the rms spectra have much larger error bars since the rms spectra tend to be noisy. But we do see that for both line-width measures the widths of the Hβ line in the mean and rms spectra are well correlated, though the lines are typically ∼ 20% broader in the mean spectra. This is a well-documented phenomenon (e.g., Sergeev et al. 1999; Shapovalova et al. 2004). It has been suggested by Shields, Ferland, & Peterson (1995) that the highest velocity gas in the BLR is optically thin, and this could account for the lower level of variability in the line wings. In Fig. 2, we compare the virial product based on σline, equal to cτ σ2 line/G (hereafter VPs), versus the virial product based on FWHM, equal to cτ FWHM2/G (here- after VPf ), for all the datasets in Table 1, except for four data sets for which the lag uncertainty is very large, with ∆τcent > τcent, i.e., PG 0844+349, NGC 3227, NGC 4593 and IC 4329A. While the virial products based on FWHM are well-correlated with those based on σline, there is scat- ter of about a factor of three in each case, reflecting the broad range of values of FWHM/σline in these datasets (cf. Fig. 9 of Peterson et al. 2004). The immediate question now becomes which one of the line-width measures ought to be used to compute the BH mass? To investigate this further, we consid- ered how the line-width ratio FWHM/σline is correlated with other spectral properties. In Fig. 3, we show for Hβ FWHM/σline as a function of the line width σline in both the mean and rms spectra. The results for the mean and the rms spectrum are quite similar. In both cases, the ratio has a large dispersion, but FWHM/σline shows a clear tendency to be smaller than 2.35, the ra- tio for a Gaussian profile, for narrow-line objects, and larger than 2.35 for broad-line objects. Fig. 3 tells us that the broad-line objects have more flat-topped pro- files, while the narrow-line objects have more extended wings, relative to a Gaussian; in other words, this ra- tio correlates with the characteristics of the line profile, which in turn correlate with other spectral properties as is sometimes embodied in "Eigenvector 1" from princi- pal component analysis (e.g., Boroson & Green 1992), as is well known. We can somewhat arbitrarily sepa- rate the AGNs into two "populations" based on line- width ratio, Population 1 with FWHM/σline < 2.35 and Population 2 with FWHM/σline > 2.35. As seen in Fig. 3, is corresponds very roughly to a division around σline = 2000 km s−1, which is approximately FWHM = 4000 km s−1; our demarcation is thus interestingly remi- niscent of the division of AGNs by Sulentic et al. (2000) into a Population A, with FWHM ≤ 4000 km s−1, and a Population B, with FWHM ≥ 4000 km s−1. Sulentic et al. identify Population A, which includes NLS1s, with low BH mass and high accretion-rate sources, and Population B with low accretion-rate radio-loud (or pre-/post-cursors of radio-loud) sources. Apparently the large range of the line- width ratio FWHM/σline is telling us something important about the BLR: the line-of-sight kinematics and/or the BLR structure show a great variety. The inclination can also play an important role, as will be discussed later. 2.3. Effects Other Than Inclination: The Importance of NGC 5548 the best-studied of all The galaxy NGC 5548 is reverberation-mapped AGNs. In Figs. 1 -- 3, NGC 5548 appears multiple times as a result of 14 separate years of intensive optical spectroscopic monitoring first at the Wise Observatory in 1988 (Netzer et al. 1990) then for 13 con- secutive years by the International AGN Watch beginning in late 1989 (Peterson et al. 2002 and references therein). We see that all the quantities in Table 1 vary with time: the FWHM in the mean spectrum and σline in both the mean and the rms spectrum vary by less than a factor of two, but the FWHM in the rms spectrum varies by up to a factor of four. Figure 3 shows that FWHM/σline can also vary by a factor larger than two, and moreover that it can migrate between our two arbitrarily defined pop- ulations, as well as those of Sulentic et al. (2000). This demonstrates clearly that FWHM/σline does not depend solely on either mass or inclination, as these are constant over the timescales involved. An obvious requirement is that the BH mass, or virial product, must be constant for all the individual datasets on NGC 5548. In Fig. 4, we show VPs and VPf , as mea- sured in the mean and rms spectra, as a function of the 6 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs ) c e s / m k ( s m r e n i l ! 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 ) c e s / m k ( s m r M H W F 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 mean (km/sec) ! line 0 0 2000 6000 4000 10000 FWHM mean (km/sec) 8000 12000 14000 Fig. 1. The left panel shows σline in the rms spectrum versus σline in the mean spectrum for Hβ in all 35 datasets in Table 1. The right panel shows the FWHM in the rms spectrum versus the FWHM in the mean spectrum. The open circles mark the different datasets of NGC 5548. The straight line traces the diagonal. ) n u s M ( s m r s P V 109 108 107 106 105 109 108 107 106 ) n u s M ( n a e m s P V 106 107 108 109 rms (Msun) VP f 105 106 107 VP f 108 109 mean (Msun) Fig. 2. Virial product based on σline (VPs), versus the virial product based on the FWHM (VPf ), for all but four of the datasets (identified in the text) in Table 1, based on rms spectra (left panel) and mean spectra (right panel). The straight lines correspond to a Gaussian profile, for which VPs = VPf /5.52. S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 7 e n i l ! / M H W F 3,5 3 2,5 2 1,5 1 0,5 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 (km/s) ! line Fig. 3. The Hβ line-width ratio FWHM/σline versus σline in all the datasets in Table 1. The open and filled circles correspond respectively to values based on mean and rms spectra. The large symbols mark the different datasets for NGC 5548. The horizontal line is the value of the ratio for a Gaussian profile, and the vertical line is an arbitrary division at σline = 2000 km s−1. The horizontal line divides the samples into our Populations 1 (lower) and 2 (upper), and the vertical line approximates the division of Sulentic et al. (2000) into Populations A (left) and B (right). mean luminosity, for 13 NGC 5548 datasets2. In this di- agram, the optical continuum luminosity has been cor- rected for host-galaxy contamination by using the value of the starlight contribution given by Bentz et al. (2006). Despite the large variations in the value of σline as seen in Fig. 1, we see that all the measures of VPs in both the mean and rms spectra are consistent with a constant value, for masses based on either the mean or rms spec- tra. The discrepant point is from Year 12 (2000) of the AGN Watch program (Peterson et al. 2002), which was the most poorly sampled Hβ light curve in the whole series and yielded somewhat ambiguous cross-correlation results (see Fig. 2 of Peterson et al. 2002). 2.4. Comparison with Masses Based on σ∗ Ferrarese & Merritt (2000) and Gebhardt et al. (2000) showed that a tight relationship exists between the BH mass MBH and the velocity dispersion σ∗ of the stars in the bulge of the host galaxy. The galaxies that define the MBH -- σ∗ relationship are nearly all3 quiescent galaxies whose BH masses were measured by stellar or gas kine- matics. It is difficult, but possible, to measure bulge veloc- ity dispersions in at least the lowest-luminosity AGNs. At the present time, velocity dispersion measurements have been published for about 16 AGNs, i.e., almost half of the reverberation-mapped sample. Onken et al. (2004) plot- ted the values of VPs versus σ∗ for these objects and ob- tained a relationship consisent with the quiescent-galaxy MBH -- σ∗ relationship. By making the assumption that the AGN MBH -- σ∗ relationship is identical to that for quies- cent galaxies, they were able to convert the VPs -- σ∗ rela- tionship to a MBH -- σ∗ relationship by determining a sta- tistical value for the scale factor of eq. (1). Onken et al. found hfi = 5.5 ± 1.8. Here we will carry out a similar exercise, but for all four ways of computing the virial product, i.e. VPs and VPf for both the mean and rms spectra. We compute for each AGN in the Onken sample an estimate of the BH mass Mσ∗ in solar masses from the formula of Tremaine et al. (2002), log Mσ∗ = 8.13 + 4.02 log(cid:0)σ∗/200 km s−1(cid:1) . (3) We have excluded two objects with highly uncertain reverberation-based masses, IC 4329A and NGC 4593, leaving a sample of 14 objects and 39 datasets (herafter the "Onken sample"). In Table 2, we give the average scale factors, computed as by Onken et al. (2004). We first note that the scale factor for the entire sample using σline measured the rms spectra yields a value identical to that obtained by Onken et al., f = 5.5. We also note that using σline measured the mean spectra yields f = 3.85, reflecting our earlier observation that on average σline is ∼ 20% broader in the mean spectra than in the rms spectra; the scale factor based on FWHM is only 20% larger for the mean spectra compared to the rms spectra, however, because FWHM is typically only about 10% broader in the mean spectra than in the rms spectra. We see also that VPf /VPs ≈ 4, as expected since hFWHM/σlinei ≈ 2. As noted earlier, there is great range in the values of FWHM/σline and thus the scale factors that we would compute will be strongly dependent on the value of this ratio for the objects in the sample. This leads us to com- pute the scale factors separately, again for all four ways of computing the virial product, for our two populations, Population 1 with FWHM/σline < 2.35 and Population 2 with FWHM/σline > 2.35. These values are also given in Table 2. We have also computed separate scale factors for Population A (FWHM < 4000 km s−1) and Population B (FWHM > 4000 km s−1) of Sulentic et al. (2000). There 2 We have suppressed the point corresponding to the Wise Observatory data from 1988 which is not reliable on account of a variable line-spread function, as noted by Peterson et al. (2004). 3 One Seyfert 2 galaxy, NGC 4258, whose BH mass was measured by megamaser motions (Miyoshi et al. 1995), was included in the sample of galaxies that defined the MBH -- σ∗ relationship. 8 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs ) t c u d o r P l a i r i V ( g o l 8,5 8 7,5 7 based on FWHM Year 12 0,1 NGC 5548 0,2 0,3 (in 10 44 erg/s) L opt 8 7,5 7 6,5 6 ) t c u d o r P l a i r i V ( g o l Year 12 0,1 based on ! line NGC 5548 0,2 0,3 44 erg/s) L (in 10 opt Fig. 4. The virial product based on the FWHM (left panel) and on σline (right panel), versus the optical luminosity of NGC 5548, corrected for the host-galaxy starlight contribution. The open and filled circles correspond respectively to values based on the mean and rms spectra. In the left panel, the point corresponding to the rms spectrum of Year 5 has been suppressed as determination of the FWHM of Hβ is problematic in this case (see Fig. 14 of Peterson et al. 2004). f(! line) df(! line) f(FWHM) df(FWHM) MEAN SPECTRUM total Pop1 Pop2 PopA PopB total Pop1 Pop2 PopA PopB 3.85 4.20 3.48 3.93 3.75 5.49 5.36 5.66 6.23 4.73 1.15 2.09 1.09 1.97 1.13 1.17 1.81 0.69 2.12 0.52 RMS SPECTRUM 1.65 2.71 1.49 3.47 1.11 1.44 2.21 0.92 2.53 0.81 0.50 1.38 0.19 1.47 0.13 0.49 1.22 0.27 1.49 0.19 Table 2. The scale factors with their uncertainties for the Onken sample and for two populations (1) separated at FWHM/σline = 2.35 (Pop1 and Pop2) as explained in the text and (2) separated at FWHM = 4000 km s−1 (PopA and PopB) according to Sulentic et al. (2000). are 9 objects in the Onken sample in Population 1, among which the 6 objects of Population A are all included. The 6 common objects are NGC 4051, NGC 3783, NGC 7469, Mrk 110, Mrk 590, and 3C 120. Population B consists of 8 objects, among which the 5 objects of Population 2 are all included, namely, NGC 4151, NGC 5548, Mrk 817, Akn 120, and 3C 390.3. The results of this exercise are very revealing: there is a clear difference between the scale factors of the different subsets, especially if we compare the objects common to Populations 1 and A with those common to Populations 2 and B. For VPf , Populations 1 and A have scale factors larger by a factor of ∼ 3 than those for Populations 2 and B, both in the mean and rms spectra. This trend does not exist for VPs; in both the mean and rms spectra, the scaling factors computed from VPs are consistent with a constant value. It is clear that the statistics are poor, and that more objects in the sample are urgently needed. Nevertheless some conclusions can already be drawn from these results: 1. Since scale factors based on σline for different pop- ulations are consistent with a single value, contrary to the case for scale factors based on FWHM, VPs is not sensitive to the line profile, the Eddington ra- tios, inclination, or whatever factors distinguish be- tween Populations 1 and 2 or A and B, whereas VPf clearly is affected by these factors. In other words, σline is a less biased measure of the velocity dispersion than is FWHM. 2. Use of FWHM as line-width measure and applying a constant scale factor corresponding to the average for the whole sample will underestimate the masses of Populations 1 and A (including NLS1s) and overesti- S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 9 mate the masses of Populations 2 and B. This could be a contributing factor to why high ratios of bulge-to- BH masses have been found in NLS1s (Wandel 2001; Mathur et al. 2001), since the BH masses are based on FWHM in these works. On the other hand, since it appears that the FWHM is influenced by some still un- defined physical parameters to which σline is not sensi- tive, it could be used as an indicator of whatever these currently unidentified parameters turn out to be. We argue below that one unidentified parameter is BLR inclination, and another is the Eddington ratio. 3. It is possible to correct VPf to obtain an unbiased BH mass. At the present time, the correction is only ap- proximate because the uncertainties on the scale fac- tors are large. According to Table 2, a simple prescrip- tion is to use f = 2.35 for Population 1 and f = 0.85 for Population 2 for the rms spectrum, and f = 1.5 for Population 1 and f = 0.50 for Population 2 for the mean spectrum, so the mass4 is given by MBH = f VPf . But to avoid a discontinuity between these two rather arbitrarily defined populations, we tentatively suggest using for the rms spectrum, as proposed by Onken et al. (2004), and f = 3.85 (i.e. MBH = 3.85VPs) for the mean spectrum. 2.5. Application of the Scale Factors: A Consistency Test In the last section, we provided scaling factors to convert both VPs and VPf into BH masses. We now apply these to the entire sample of 35 objects from Table 1. Figure 5 compares the σline-based masses, computed using f = 5.5 and f = 3.85 for the rms and mean spectra, respectively, with the corrected FWHM-based masses in both the mean and rms spectrum for all the data sets in the sample. In the upper panels, the FWHM-based masses are corrected by using eqs. (4) and (5), while in the lower panels, the corrections are given by eqs. (6) and (7). The two formulations give very similar results, and the scatter is reduced compared to Fig. 2, even when only the FWHM used for the correction. This demonstrates the utility of using eqs. (6) and (7) to adjust FWHM-based mass esti- mates when σline is not known. f = 2.35 (for (FWHM/σline) ≤ 1.4) = 3.85 − 1.07(FWHM/σline) (for 1.4 < (FWHM/σline) < 2.8) = 0.85 (for (FWHM/σline) ≥ 2.8), and for the mean spectrum, f = 1.5 (for (FWHM/σline) ≤ 1.4) = 2.5 − 0.71(FWHM/σline) (for 1.4 < (FWHM/σline) < 2.8) (4) (5) = 0.5 (for (FWHM/σline) ≥ 2.8). It is rarely the case, however, that σline measurements are available, especially in published compilations of line widths. in such cases, we suggest using for the rms spectrum, f = 2.35 (for (FWHM ≤ 2000 km s−1) (6) = 3.1 − 1.5 (FWHM/4000 km s−1) (for 2000 < FWHM < 6000 km s−1) = 0.85 (for FWHM ≥ 6000 km s−1), and for the mean spectrum, f = 1.5 (for (FWHM ≤ 2000 km s−1) = 2 − (FWHM/4000 km s−1) (for 2000 < FWHM < 6000 km s−1) (7) = 0.5 (for FWHM ≥ 6000 km s−1). For σline-based data, for all AGNs we suggest using the value f = 5.5, (i.e., MBH = 5.5VPs) for the rms spectrum, 4 It is perhaps interesting that prior to the actual calibration of the reverberation-based mass scale by Onken et al. (2004), it was common to assume f = 0.75 (Netzer 1990; Wandel et al. 1999; Kaspi et al. 2000) for FWHM-based mass estimates. 2.6. Line Width Measures and the Eddington Ratio The line-width ratio FWHM/σline is of potential impor- tance as it may trace physical parameters in the inner re- gions of AGNs. Since we have already pointed out a quali- tative correlation with Eigenvector 1 properties, which has been argued to measure the Eddington ratio (e.g., Boroson 2002), it is now of interest to look at this more quantita- tively. In Fig. 6, we show the line-width ratio FWHM/σline as measured in the mean spectrum (since it is less noisy than the rms spectrum) as a function of Eddington ratio, which has been computed assuming that the bolometric luminosity is Lbol ≈ 10Lopt (based loosely on Kaspi et al. 2000 and Elvis et al. 1994), and MBH is based on mea- surements of σline in the rms spectrum, which appears to yield the most accurate mass estimate (Peterson et al. 2004). The top panel of Fig. 6 shows a clear anticorre- lation between the line-width ratio FWHM/σline and the Eddington rate, though with considerable scatter. The de- pendency of FWHM/σline on Eddington rate is physically quite plausible as we expect that that the structure and the dynamics of the BLR, which determine the line profile, depend on the accretion rate. We note, however, that the Eddington rates in this figure are somewhat overestimated because the optical luminosities have not been corrected for contamination by host-galaxy starlight. At the present time, it is possible to accurately correct for the host-galaxy contribution to the luminosity for only a subset of these AGNs, those observed by Bentz et al. (2006). In the middle panel of Fig. 6, we show the subset of points from the top panel for which Bentz et al. provide measurements of the starlight contribution. In the bottom panel, we show the points from the middle panel after correction for starlight. The anticorrelation that is clearly seen in the top panel appears to have vanished in the middle and bottom pan- 10 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 1010 109 108 107 ) n u s M ( s m r s M 106 106 107 108 109 1010 M rms (Msun) f 1010 109 108 107 ) n u s M ( s m r s M 1010 109 108 107 ) n u s M ( n a e m s M 106 106 1010 109 108 107 ) n u s M ( n a e m s M 107 108 109 1010 M mean (Msun) f 106 106 107 108 109 1010 106 106 M rms (Msun) f 107 108 109 1010 M mean (Msun) f Fig. 5. Mass estimates based on σline as a line-width measure are plotted versus masses based on FWHM measurements and adjusted according to eqs. (4) and (5) (upper panels) and to eqs. (6) and (7) (lower panels). The data in the left panels are based on line widths in the rms spectrum and those based on the mean spectrum are shown in the right panels. The same four datasets as in Fig. 2 have been suppressed. The straight lines trace the diagonals. els. This is simply because most the high-Eddington rate objects are PG quasars which were not observed by Bentz et al. Given the higher luminosities of these sources, the starlight corrections are likely to be small so the points in the lower right of the top panel will have very nearly the same positions in the bottom panel, thus preserving the anticorrelation. In the lower panel, we highlight by use of larger symbols the multiple independent measurements of NGC 5548. These are dispersed in a direction almost normal to the anticorrelation seen in the top panel, which suggests that much of the scatter in this relationship can be attributed to intrinsic variability. We will discuss this further in a future paper. To summarize this section, we have shown that we can crudely separate AGNs into high Eddington ratio ob- jects whose spectra are characterized by small values of S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 11 FWHM/σline (Population 1) and low Eddington ratio ob- jects, which have large values of FWHM/σline (Population 2). We find that σline is an unbiased estimator of the BH mass, whereas FWHM requires an adjustment for its sen- sitivity to still undefined physical parameters, likely to be the Eddington ratio and/or the source inclination. Finally, we note that FWHM/σline is not correlated with BH mass, or with luminosity. 3. Influence of the BLR Inclination Since we observe only the line-of-sight velocity distribu- tion of the BLR, it is obvious that inclination of the BLR will play a significant role in the value of the scale factor except in the unlikely case of an isotropic velocity field. For instance, Krolik (2001) pointed out that if the BLR is a thin disk, it would lead to an underestimation of the mass by one or two orders of magnitude for objects seen at low inclination To study the influence of the inclination, it is necessary to have an idea of the structure and the dynamics of the BLR. In this section, we show that a few simple but plausible structures can be parameterized in a common fashion and we explore the effects of inclination in this context as an exercise. 3.1. Structure and Dynamics of a Rotationally Dominated BLR It is often noted that the structure and the dynamics of the BLR are not known, despite more than thirty years of in- tense studies. Indeed we only know with certainty, thanks to reverberation studies, that the region emitting the "low- ionization lines" like Hβ is gravitationally bound to the BH (Peterson & Wandel 1999, 2000; Onken & Peterson 2002; Kollatschny 2003a) and more precisely that the bulk radial velocity is small (Clavel 1991). But it remains true that we do not know if the BLR is a spherical structure dominated by turbulent motions, if it includes a wind com- ponent, or if it is a disk dominated by rotational motions, There is actually fairly strong evidence for the latter case in radio-loud AGNs. Based on the ratio of the radio core flux to the extended radio lobe flux, R, which is re- lated to the relativistic amplification of the core source and is large when the object is seen face-on, Wills & Browne (1986) and Jackson & Browne (1991) found a lack of broad lines for face-on objects. Also, Vestergaard, Wilkes, & Barthel (2000) find that the width of the base of the C IV λ1549 emission line is inversely correlated with R, suggesting the existence of a largely radial disk wind. In superluminal objects where the inclination can be derived quite precisely, Rokaki et al. (2003) have shown that the line width is anti-correlated with several beaming indica- tors, and is consistent with a disk structure of the BLR. Finally, double-peaked profiles of the Balmer lines, though observed only in a small fraction of radio AGNs, are an- other suggestion of disk structure (Eracleous & Halpern 1994 and subsequent papers). Such double peaks, more or ) n a e m ( e n i l ! / M H W F ) n a e m ( e n i l ! / M H W F ) n a e m ( e n i l ! / M H W F 3,6 3,2 2,8 2,4 2 1,6 1,2 0,8 3,6 3,2 2,8 2,4 2 1,6 1,2 0,8 3,6 3,2 2,8 2,4 2 1,6 1,2 0,8 starlight not corrected starlight not corrected starlight corrected NGC 4051 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 Eddington ratio (! ) line Fig. 6. The line-width ratio FWHM/σline for Hβ in the mean spectra, versus the Eddington ratio (based on masses from Peterson et al. 2004) for all the datasets for the 35 reverberation-mapped objects in Table 1 (top panel). The middle panel shows the subset of points from the top panel which can be corrected for the host-galaxy starlight contribution to the luminosity using values from Bentz et al. (2006). The bottom panel shows the points from the middle panel after correction for starlight. The larger points in the lower panel represent independent data sets on NGC 5548. Assumptions used in computing the 12 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs less pronounced, are characteristics of our Population 2 AGNs. There is no direct evidence that this picture also ap- plies to radio-quiet objects, but several observations fit this model quite well (e.g., see Smith et al. 2005). There is also indirect evidence which cannot be ignored. A common view of the BLR is that it consists of a large number of clouds with high velocities surrounding a central source of UV -- X-ray radiation that photoionizes the clouds and pro- duces line emission by reprocessing. These clouds should have a large covering factor, since at least 10% of the cen- tral X-UV source, and in some cases a larger fraction, has to be absorbed by the BLR in order to account for the large measured equivalent widths of the broad lines. On the other hand, the column density of the clouds is in- ferred to be high, 1023−24 cm−2. There is actually no ob- servational limit to the real column density of the clouds, as a large fraction can stay neutral and unobservable (for a review, see Collin-Souffrin & Lasota 1988, for example). The lack of Lyman edges in absorption and of damped Lyα lines in AGN spectra is difficult to explain in this context, unless the BLR clouds are not located on the line of sight to the central source. Such a configuration is nat- ural in the framework of unified schemes (Antonnucci & Miller 1985), if the BLR has a disk structure in the same plane as that of the obscuring "torus" and of the inner disk. Since for Seyfert 1 galaxies the central continuum is seen from above at relatively small inclinations to the disk normal, it would not be absorbed by this BLR disk. As explained above, the BLR disk must "see" the cen- tral source, as it must be able to capture a large fraction of its ionizing photons. We can thus immediately elimi- nate the possibility that the BLR disk is a thin, flat struc- ture that is directly illuminated by the central UV -- X-ray source. In this scenario, the central source should have a large scale height above the disk, of the order the radius of the BLR disk itself. But we know from the study of the continuum emission, in particular from the correla- tions between the UV and X-ray flux variability, that the UV -- X-ray source is located much closer to the BH than the BLR, typically at distances of 10 to 102 RG, where RG is the gravitational radius, while the distance of the BLR is of the order of 103 to 104 RG. A possible exception could be the case of low-luminosity AGNs with very broad double-peaked profiles, where it has bee suggested that the inner part of the disk might be an inflated ion-supported torus (cf. §4). Another possibility is that the surface of the BLR disk is illuminated indirectly by the central source, which could occur if its radiation is backscattered by a hot medium (or corona) located above the BLR disk, as proposed by Dumont & Collin-Souffrin (1990). This model faces some difficulties, however, as the hot medium should have a Thomson thickness at least of the order of unity. In this case, the variations of the central source would be smoothed by multiple electron scattering, and the shape of the observed X-ray continuum would be modified by absorption and Compton diffusion (Reynolds & Wilms 2000), two predictions that are contradicted by the ob- servations. However the recent observations of very thick X-ray winds in some NLS1s (Pounds et al. 2003) and the suggestion by Gierlinski & Done (2004) and Chevallier et al. (2005) that the soft X-ray excess is due to the ab- sorption by a very thick warm absorber, could perhaps rehabilitate this idea for high accretion-rate objects. But it cannot be considered as a general solution for the BLR of all AGNs. Thus it is unlikely that the BLR disk is a very thin flat structure entirely dominated by rotation, and other possibilities must be considered5. 3.1.1. The BLR as a Flared Disk The required illumination of the BLR implies that the opening angle of the BLR disk should be large, i.e., Ω/4π ≥ 0.1. In other words, the BLR disk should have an aspect ratio larger than H/R = 0.1 at the location of the line-emitting region, where H is the disk thickness at the radius R. Moreover it should be "flared," i.e., that H increases more rapidly than linearly with increasing R. Such flared disks are predicted in the context of the "standard model" (Shakura & Sunyaev 1973), and were invoked by Dumont & Collin-Souffrin (1990) as being the origin of the low-ionization lines in AGNs. In this case, the BLR disk should be sustained vertically by a pressure which is most probably provided by a turbulent velocity of the order VKepH/R, where VKep is the local Keplerian velocity at the distance R. In this model, the observed value of ∆Vobs is given by ∆Vobs ≈ VKep(cid:2)(H/R)2 + sin2 i(cid:3)1/2 , (8) where i is the inclination of the system to our line of sight. 3.1.2. The BLR as a Warped Disk A configuration which could be invoked for effective il- lumination of the disk by the central source is a warped disk structure. Such a structure is observed in the case of NGC 4258 through the maser spots (Greenhill et al. 1995; Miyoshi et al. 1995). In this object, the rotation law at the distance of the megamaser sources is Keplerian, but the disk is tipped downward by about 10o, which allows more of the disk surface to be directly exposed to the central source. Wijers & Pringle (1999) have suggested that simi- lar warping should arise in AGNs as a response of the disk to the radiation force from the central source, which can cause the disk to tilt out of the orbital plane and to pre- cess. However, NGC 4258 is a low-luminosity AGN, and it is not clear that this would be the case in more luminous objects, which in particular would be more sensitive to the gravitational instability. 5 It is worthwhile recalling that when we speak of a "disk," it does not necessarily mean a continuous medium, but could refer to a clumpy medium made of an ensemble of clouds. S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 13 In this model, the velocity is quasi-Keplerian at any 3.1.4. A Simple Parameterization radius, so ∆Vobs is expressed as (9) ∆Vobs ≈ VKep sin i, but the inclination i varies with the radius, i.e., with the particular line under consideration. Another difference from a flat thin disk is that the line-emitting region ex- tends over a range of radii, therefore over a range of incli- nations. There is thus a lower limit of the inclination, ∆i, while it can be arbitrarily small for a flat disk. 3.1.3. A Two-Component BLR: A Disk and a Wind In recent years, arguments supporting the presence of disk winds have won some popularity on account of the ability of such structures to explain a number of observed phe- nomena such as X-ray and UV absorption, line emission, reverberation results, and some differences among Seyfert galaxies, quasars, broad-line radio galaxies, and the pres- ence or absence of double-peaked emission-line profiles. The importance of outflows that are commonly seen in AGNs as "warm absorbers" in X-rays have been recog- nized through observations made with XMM-Newton and Chandra X-Ray Observatory. It has been suspected for a long time that the BLR has two components, one that is disk-like and other that is some kind of outflow, probably a disk wind, either magnetohydrodynamically or radia- tively driven. The wind scenario also obviates the problem of having to confine the line-emitting clouds. Key papers on the topic of disk winds are by Murray & Chiang (1995, 1998) and by Proga & Kallman (2004). In this model, the broad emission lines are emitted from the base of the disk winds (see also Elvis 2000). A plausible configuration is thus a BLR made of two dynamically distinct components, a disk and a wind. The velocity dispersion could be written as ∆Vobs ≈ (cid:2)α2(cid:0)a2 + sin2 i(cid:1) V 2 Kep + β2V 2 out cos2 i(cid:3)1/2 , (10) where Vout is the outflow velocity, assumed to be normal to the disk, and α and β are the contributions of the thick disk and of the wind, respectively. However, the Vout cos i term in eq. (10) cannot typi- cally dominate the Hβ line, or the Hβ wing would dis- play a strong asymmetry due to absorption on the reced- ing part of the wind located on the far side of the ac- cretion disk relative to the central source as seen by the observer. This is however observed in the most extreme ob- jects of Population A which also show an extended blue wing in the high-ionization line C IV λ1549 (cf. Sulentic et al. 2000), or in NLS1s which also show a blue wing in the [O III] λλ4959, 5007 lines (cf. Zamanov et al. 2002; Aoki, Kawaguchi, & Ohta 2005; Boroson 2003). So, with the exception of these very high Eddington ratio objects (say, with Lbol/LEdd ≥ 0.3), of which we have none in our Population 1 sample, one can neglect the second term in eq. (10). We see that, to a zeroth approximation, in all these cases ∆Vobs can be represented by the expression, ∆Vobs ≈ (cid:0)a2 + sin2 i(cid:1)1/2 VKep, (11) where the parameter a can be identified with H/R or with Vturbulent/VKep, and it can take a null value in the case of a warped disk. If we identify VKep with the virial velocity, the virial product in this parameterization, which we will call the "generalized thick disk," or more simply "thick disk," even though we have seen that it can describe other structures, will be given by VPthick disk = RBLR V 2 Kep G = RBLRV 2 obs G(a2 + sin2 i) . (12) 3.2. Theoretical Considerations The ratio of the virial product in the thick disk model VPthick disk to the virial product in the general case, which we will call the "isotropic case," simply because it does not have cylindrical symmetry, is equal to A = VPthick disk VPisotropic = 1 a2 + sin2 i . (13) The value of the inclination is given as a function of A in Fig. 7. We see that if the thick disk model is correct, the virial product computed in the general case could be strongly underestimated for small inclinations. The gen- eral relation can even lead to an underestimate of the mass by a factor of 100 for a = 0.1. Note that we have neglected any correction due to possible anisotropy of the optical flux (for instance, the flux emerging from the disk can be subject to "limb-darkening" effects), or to any obscura- tion of the BLR. These effects should be small compared to those we are looking for. We can compute how many objects would have a given value of A by assuming that they are distributed at ran- dom for inclinations i ≤ i0. According to the unified scheme (Antonucci & Miller 1985), Seyfert 1 nuclei are not seen edge on, and one can quite reasonably assume i0 ≈ 45◦, though we have checked that our conclusions are not qualitatively changed for i0 = 60◦. The probabil- ity of seeing an object at an inclination angle i per unit angle interval is sin i/(1 − cos i0). The number of objects per unit interval of A is thus 1 (a2 + sin2 i)2 cos i . (14) dN dA = 2(1 − cos i0) 7 shows the Figure expression, i.e., for which VPthick disk/VPisotropic is smaller than a given value. For this fraction of AGNs cumulative the integral of reasonable values, say 0.1 <∼ a <∼ 0.3, VP could underesti- mate the mass by as much as one order of magnitude in a few to several percent of the objects, specifically those 14 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs a=0.3 a=0.1 small inclination: strong underestimation 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 large inclination 40 30 20 10 i n c l i n a t i o n ( i n d e g r e e ) n o i t r o p o r p e v i t l a u m u c 0 1 a=0.3 a=0.1 10 VP(thick-disk)/VP(isotropic) 0 102 Fig. 7. The solid curves show the cumulative fraction (left axis) of AGNs that will have A = VPthick disk/VPisotropic smaller than the value on the bottom axis for two values of the parameter a, assuming that the maximum inclination is 45◦. The dotted lines show the value of A for values of the inclination (right axis) over the range 0◦ ≤ i ≤ 45◦. which are seen at small inclinations. It is thus not implau- sible that a significant fraction of NLS1s, which constitute only ∼ 10% of the local AGN population, are actually seen almost "face-on," and that their Eddington ratio is consequently strongly overestimated. We elaborate on this below. 3.3. Comparison with Observations Some authors (Wu & Han 2001; Zhang & Wu 2002; McLure & Dunlop 2001) assume that the true BH masses in AGNs satisfy the MBH -- σ∗ relationship and that the differences between the masses deduced from the stel- lar velocity dispersion Mσ∗ and the reverberation masses Mrev are due only to inclination effects. They then pro- ceed to deduce the inclinations for individual AGNs, based on the discrepancies between Mrev and Mσ∗. Wu & Han and Zhang & Wu studied the reverberation-mapped ob- jects and assumed that the BLR was a thin disk with no isotropic component of the velocity. McLure & Dunlop studied a sample of 30 quasars where the BH masses were estimated using FWHM and the R -- L relationship of Kaspi et al. (2000) and adopted an ad hoc complex (and rather implausible) disk geometry. We do not think that it is possible to deduce individ- ual inclinations in this way. It would be possible only if there were no intrinsic scatter either in the MBH -- σ∗ rela- tionship or in Mrev; we know from the best-studied AGN, NGC 5548, that VPs and thus Mrev has an intrinsic scat- ter of about a factor of three. Here we take a somewhat different approach with the goal of testing in a statistical fashion whether inclination effects might plausibly account for the distribution of dif- ferences between Mrev and Mσ∗. We compare the observed distribution of Mσ∗/VP with the theoretical distribution VPthick disk/VPisotropic of Fig. 7, since these should be identical to within a scaling constant (that converts VP to Mrev at i = 0◦) if inclination alone is responsible for the discrepancies between Mrev and Mσ∗. In Fig. 8, we show the cumulative distribution of the values Mσ∗/VP for the FWHM-based values of the virial product VPf (left) and the σline-based values VPs (right) for the Onken sample of 14 objects6. The "offset factor" in this and subsequent figures is the number by which the theoretical Mσ∗/VP ratio has been divided to aid in com- parison of the two distributions. It is related to, but is not identical to, the scale factor f if the inclination is the sole cause of the discrepancies between Mrev and Mσ∗, but is otherwise completely arbitrary. Fig. 8 shows that the σline- based values Mσ∗/VPs do not match the theoretical distribution, while on the contrary the FWHM-based val- ues VPf seem to match the theoretical distribution rather well at large values of Mσ∗/VPf for a = 0.1. This suggests that the thick-disk BLR model probably has some merit, particularly in describing the line core (to which FWHM is more sensitive), implying that FWHM has some depen- dence on inclination. However, the poor match of the the- oretical and observed distributions based on σline implies that σline is insensitive to source inclination. We speculate further in §4. We now consider separately Populations 1 and 2. This unfortunately exacerbates the problems associated with small-number statistics, but we find some important dif- ferences between the two populations that we believe are enlightening. Figure 9 shows the cumulative distribution of Mσ∗/VPf for Population 2, although we have actu- ally relaxed our orginal arbitrary criterion FWHM/σline > 2.35 to FWHM/σline > 2 in order to increase the sample size. Figure 9 shows that the cumulative distribution is not well-described by the theoretical curve at large values of Mσ∗/VPf. We conclude that our generalized thick-disk model with i < 45◦ is not a good description for this popu- lation. More specifically, the distribution of Mσ∗/VPf does not appear to be controlled by inclination angle for this population. In contrast, the cumulative distribution of Population 1 shown in Fig. 10 is well-described by the theoreti- cal curve at large values of Mσ∗/VPf for the case a = 0.1. This figure shows clearly that the few AGNs with 6 Note that for the sake of simplicity, we will restrict the discussion only to quantities derived from the mean spectra since these do not differ significantly from those derived from the rms spectra. Also, in the cases of sources for which multiple datasets are available, we use an average value of VP so that each source is counted only once. S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 15 n o i t r o p o r p e v i t a u m u c l 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 a=0.3 a=0.1 offset factor: 5 1 10 Msig* / VP_f(mean) n o i t r o p o r p e v i t a u m u c l 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 1 a=0.3 a=0.1 offset factor: 1 10 102 Msig * / VP_s(mean) Fig. 8. Cumulative fraction of values of Mσ∗/VP for the Onken sample of 14 objects, compared to the theoretical distribution for two thick-disk models, as shown in Fig. 7, for the FWHM-based values Mσ∗/VPf (left) and the σline-based values Mσ∗/VPs (right). The "offset factor" is described in the text. FWHM / ! > 2 line a=0.1 a=0.3 offset factor: 7 n o i t r o p o r p e v i t l a u m u c 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 1 10 Msig* / VP_f(mean) Fig. 9. Cumulative fraction of Mσ∗/VPf for Population 2 objects (expanded to include all objects with FWHM/σline > 2). FWHM/σline < 2 seem to fit the theoretical distribution very well, but the AGNs with 2 < FWHM/σline < 2.35 match the theoretical distribution rather less well. We conclude that among the sample of AGNs with small FWHM/σline ratios, the three objects with the low- est values of Mσ∗/VPf (NGC 4051, Mrk 590 and NGC 7469) are probably actually observed at low inclination. Although the statistics are very poor, we are led to the conclusion that the difference in scale factor f (Table 2) between Population 1/A and Population 2/B is due at least partly to an inclination effect. According to Fig. 7, and taking into account the offset factor, these three ob- jects are probably at inclinations i <∼ 20◦, and their masses Mrev could be underestimated by factors as large as an or- der of magnitude. While some properties of NLS1s can be attributed to either high Eddington ratios or low inclination, a clear consensus based on the preponderance of evidence is that accretion rate is probably the key factor that defines the NLS1 class (see Boller 2000). While we agree that some properties of NLS1s, in particular their rapid and large amplitude X-ray variability, steep X-ray spectra, and the purported larger fraction of bars in their host galax- ies (Crenshaw, Kraemer, & Gabel 2003; Ohta, Aoki, & Kawaguchi, in preparation) can certainly not be explained only by the inclination, we argue that inclination does play an important, although not the dominant, role in defining this class of object. In this context, we point out that Williams, Mathur, & Pogge (2004) show that not all op- tically selected NLS1s seem to be high accretion sources; many have characteristics more typical of broad-line ob- 16 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs n o i t r o p o r p e v i t a u m u c l 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 FWHM / ! < 2 line a=0.1 Mrk 590 NGC 7469 NGC 4051 3C 120 NGC 3516 offset factor: 3 Mrk 110 n o i t r o p o r p e v i t a u m u c l 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 FWHM / ! < 2.35 line a=0.1 Mrk 590 NGC 7469 NGC 4051 3C 120 NGC 3516 offset factor: 4 NGC 3227 Mrk 79 Mrk 110 NGC 3783 1 10 1 10 Msig* / VP_f(mean) Msig* / VP_f(mean) Fig. 10. Cumulative fraction Mσ∗/VPf for Population 1 AGNs in the Onken sample, compared to the predicted distribution for our generalized thick-disk model with a = 0.1. In the left panel, Population 1 is restricted to AGNs with FWHM/σline < 2, while in the right panel, AGNs with 2 < FWHM/σline < 2.35 are also included. jects. These may well be the sources for which inclination is important. 3.4. Inclinations of Individual Objects Unfortunately, there is currently no way to measure the inclination of any AGN BLR to any reasonable accuracy, and there are few observables that are even good indica- tors of inclination. Of the seven Population 2 objects in the Onken sample, estimates are available for only two AGNs, 3C 390.3 and NGC 4151. The former is one of the relatively rare strongly double-peaked emitters; the double peaks are widely regarded as the signature of an inclined disk in Keplerian rotation. Eracleous et al. (1996), based on several indicators, conclude that the inclination of the BLR in this system must be in the range 19 < i < 42◦, and based on the profile fitting alone, Eracleous & Halpern (1994) find that i = 24 − 30◦. At the very least, this rela- tively large inclination is consistent with our finding that 3C 390.3 is not a member of Population 1. On the other hand, it is quite natural to find a relatively large incli- nation for a powerful FRII radio source like 3C 390.3 that does not show superluminal motion. In the case of NGC 4151, the deduced inclination ranges from 12 -- 21◦ (Boksenberg et al. 1995) and 18 -- 23◦ (Winge et al. 1999), to as high as 40◦ (Pedlar et al. 1998) or even 70◦ (Kaiser et al. 2000). There is thus no clear consensus on the incli- nation of this system. There are also few inclination estimates available for the Population 1 objects. The radio source 3C 120 has a superluminal jet, and therefore must be seen fairly close to face-on. Marscher et al. (2002) estimate that the in- clination of this source must be less than 20◦, which is consistent with the fact that it is a Population 1 object and with Fig. 10. In the case of Mrk 110, Kollatschny (2003b) showed that the variable part of the broad lines of this bright NLS1 nucleus are redshifted with respect to the systemic velocity, from which he deduced a "gravita- tional mass" of 1.4 × 108 M⊙, larger than the "isotropic" reverberation mass by almost one order of magnitude, and requiring an inclination angle i ≈ 19◦. The position of Mrk 110 in Fig. 10 indicates a relatively large inclination angle, but we have seen that the objects located in this part of the diagram do not appear to be very sensitive to incli- nation, and are therefore subject to large uncertainties in the determination of the inclination. Popovi´c et al. (2004) attempted to determine inclina- tions for individual objects by detailed fitting of individual line profiles. Unfortunately, their model has more free pa- rameters than observational constraints and these authors are obliged to impose at least one arbitrary constraint, which they choose to be the emissivity as a function of the radius. They generally find quite small inclinations, but with large uncertainties, and inescapable model de- pendence. S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 17 3.5. The Influence of Inclination on the Scale Factor The similarity between the offset factor of 3 found for the Population1/A objects in Fig. 10 and the mass scale fac- tor of 2 to 2.5 of this population (Table 2) could give the impression that the scale factor is determined mainly by inclination, but this is not the case. If indeed the incli- nation effect were the principal factor affecting the scale factor f , then the average ratio would be h VPthick disk VPisotropic i = R A(i) sin i di 1 − cos i0 . Using eq. (13), we obtain VPthick disk VPisotropic i = h (15) (16) 1 2b (1 − cos i0) ×(cid:20)ln(cid:18) b + 1 b + cos i0(cid:19) + ln(cid:18) b − cos i0 b − 1 (cid:19)(cid:21) , where b = (1 + hai2)1/2 and hai is the inclination aver- aged value of a. For hai = 0.1 and i0 = 45◦, we find hVPthick disk/VPisotropici = 7.1 (or 4.8 for a = 0.2). This is larger than the scale factor for Population 1/A, which means that while the inclination does certainly play a role in the determining the scale factor f , it is not the domi- nant source of the differences between Mrev and Mσ∗. 4. Discussion An obvious question to ask is why the FWHM would be more dependent on the inclination than the line disper- sion σline? While a definitive answer is not possible, we speculate that the line wings, to which σline is relatively more sensitive, arise primarily in a more-or-less isotropic component, perhaps in the form of a "disk wind." The line core, to which FWHM is more sensitive, might then arise primarily in a Keplerian disk component, and thus FWHM would be more sensitive to inclination. Such a scenario would also account, at least in part, for the smaller val- ues of FWHM/σline ratios in Population 1 objects, as the presence of stronger winds in Population 1 would naturally correspond to higher Eddington ratios than Population 2. By analogy, we know indeed that hot stars radiating close to their Eddington limit have strong winds, and there seems to be an emerging consensus that this is also the case for quasars accreting at a high Eddington ratio (King & Pounds 2003, Pounds et al. 2003). We can further speculate as to how the BLR can dif- fer between low and high Eddington ratio objects. At large distances from the center, the disk is self-gravitating and gravitationally unstable (see Collin & Hur´e 2001). As a consequence of the gravitational instability, the disk should be broken into clumps. The fate of these clumps, and more generally the state of the disk in this region, the accretion mechanism, and the way angular momentum is removed, are unknown (e.g., Collin & Kawaguchi 2004), but we might speculate that the "disk" would be made of discrete clumps and it seems natural to identify these clumps with the BLR clouds. The heating of the cloud sys- tem would be thus provided by the collisions between the clouds, as suggested also for the molecular torus (Krolik & Begelman 1988). The larger the gravitational instability, the larger the heating rate (cf. Lodato & Rice 2004). It is also probable that a fraction of the clumps constitute the basis of a wind, which would be more efficient when the gravitational instability is strong. Figure 11 displays the ratios RBLR/Rsg versus the Eddington ratio for the reverberation-mapped sample, where Rsg is the radius above which the self-gravity of the disk overcomes the vertical component of the central gravity. Here Rsg has been computed with a 2D simulation using real opacities (Hur´e 1998)7 and assuming a viscosity coefficient α = 0.1. There is a clear correlation between RBLR/Rsg and the Eddington ratio, with the exception of the four outliers labeled in the Figure; three are among the least-luminous AGNs in the sample, so their lumi- nosity could have been overestimated as mentioned in §2, and NGC 7469 is the object suspected to have the largest inclination effect, so its mass could be strongly underesti- mated, and thus its Eddington ratio be also overestimated. The radius at which the disk becomes gravitationnally un- stable is about four times larger than Rsg. Thus, according to Fig. 11, the BLR lies in the gravitationnally unstable re- gion in the objects with L/LEdd >∼ 0.1. On the other hand, objects with low Eddington ratios (L/LEdd <∼ 0.03) have their BLRs in the gravitationnally stable region. We there- fore speculate that the BLR of Population 1/A AGNs, which is gravitationally unstable, is more influenced by the wind than Population 2/B, thus explaining the difference in the line profiles and the difference in the FWHM/σline ratio. Another possible explanation for why the FWHM/σline ratio is larger in Population 2/B objects is that the struc- ture of the inner accretion disk is different in these objects. Population 2/B includes objects like the broad-line radio galaxy 3C 390.3, which have strongly double-peaked line profiles. Chen & Halpern (1989) have suggested that the inner disk is an inflated ion-supported torus which illumi- nates the outer line-emitting part of the extended disk. It is indeed thought that a hot advection dominated accre- tion flow (ADAF, see Narayan & Yi 1994 and subsequent works), or more generally a radiatively inefficient accretion flow (RIAF), is present close to the BH, and that such structures become increasingly prominent with decreas- ing Eddington ratio, If the Eddington ratio is small, we expect that an annular region at relatively small distance from the BH is heated by the X-rays from the geometri- cally thick RIAF, giving rise to very broad two-peaked line profiles. Note however that in this case, the line-emitting region would be a thin disk, which is very sensitive to the inclination, contrary to what we have deduced previously. 7 In the course of these computations, we have confirmed that the analytical formulae for Rsg given by Kawaguchi et al. (2004a) show consistent results (with systematically larger values by a factor of ∼ 1.5). 18 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs not starlight corrected 10 ) D 2 ( g s R / ) R L B R ( 1 NGC7469 NGC4593 IC4329A NGC4051 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 Eddington ratio (! line rms) Fig. 11. The ratio RBLR/Rsg, as described in the text. The four outliers are objects whose luminosity and Eddington ratio are probably overestimated (see the text). If RBLR/Rsg > 4, the BLR is gravitationally unstable. Finally, Murray & Chiang (1997) argue that a vary- ing optical depth in outflowing disk winds can explain the presence of single or double peaked line profiles. In this scenario, a low optical depth would tend to generate double-peaked lines while single-peaked profiles are the result of high optical depths in the wind. instability, Could a combination of these phenomena (gravita- tional inflated inner hot disk, wind) which are all linked with the Eddington ratio, combined with the influence of inclination, explain the variation of the FWHM/σline ratio among the AGN population? Obviously it will be necessary to consider larger samples of objects for which these two parameters are available in order to check these different ideas. 5. Summary In this contribution, we have initiated a study of the re- lationship between AGN BH masses and other physical properties of AGNs that can be discerned from broad emission-line profiles. We have used the ratio of FWHM to the line dispersion σline to characterize the emission- line profiles and have shown that this ratio is anticorre- lated with Eddington ratio and with line widths; broader emission lines tend to have relatively flat-topped profiles, and narrower lines have more extended wings. We sepa- rate AGNs into two populations on the basis of their Hβ profiles, a Population 1 with FWHM/σline < 2.35 and a Population 2 with FWHM/σline > 2.35. Not surprisingly, these two populations overlap strongly with Populations A and B of Sulentic et al. (2000) which are separated by FWHM only. We then make the assumption that AGNs follow the same MBH -- σ∗ relationship as quiescent galaxies and scale the virial product, the observable parameter, to determine the statistical value of the scaling factor hfi of eq. (1) (cf. Onken et al. 2004). We do this for virial products based on both σline and FWHM, as measured in both the mean and rms spectra. We find that, to within the uncertain- ties, the scaling factor is constant for both Populations 1 and 2 for virial products based on using σline as the line- width measure. On the other hand, the scaling factors are significantly different for the two populations if the virial product is based on FWHM. This means that σline is a less biased mass estimator than is FWHM. However, we show that it is possible to remove heuristically the bias in masses based on FWHM and obtain masses estimates consistent with those based on σline. For the 14 objects with measured bulge velocity disper- sions σ∗, we have compared the black hole mass predicted by the MBH -- σ∗ relationship with the mass determined by reverberation mapping. By comparing the distribution of the ratio of these masses with the distribution expected from a generalized thick disk model of the BLR, we find statistical evidence that in some small fraction of cases, the reverberation-based BH masses in Population 1 ob- jects are underestimated on account of inclination effects. We find no evidence for inclination effects in Population 2 objects. We speculate that the difference between the two populations is the relative strength of a disk-wind component, which is stronger in Population 1. Finally, we discuss the possible role of self-gravity as the physical driver controlling the strength of the disk wind. We find a stronger wind is expected for larger Eddington ratios, which is consistent with the smaller FWHM/σline ratios found for Population 1 objects. Acknowledgements. We would like to thank Jean-Marc Hur´e and Didier Pelat for useful discussions. T.K. is grateful for fi- nancial support through a JSPS Postdoctoral Fellowship. This research was supported in part by the US National Science Foundation through grant AST-0205964 (B.M.P.) and AST- 0307384 (M.V.) and by NASA through grant HST-AR-10691 from the Space Telescope Science Institute (M.V. and B.M.P.). References Antonucci, R. R. J. & Miller, J. S. 1985, ApJ, 297, 621 Aoki, K., Kawaguchi, T., & Ohta, K. 2005, ApJ, 618, 601 Barth, A. J., Greene, J. E., & Ho, L. C. 2005, ApJ, 619, L151 Bentz, M.C., Peterson, B.M., Pogge, R.W., Vestergaard, M., & Onken, C.A. 2006, ApJ, in press Blandford, R.D., & McKee, C.F. 1982, ApJ, 255, 419 Boksenberg, A., et al. 1995, ApJ, 440, 151 Boller, T. 2000, New Astronomy Review, 44 Boroson, T. A., & Green, R. F. 1992, ApJS, 80, 109 Boroson, T. A. 2002, ApJ, 565, 78 Boroson, T. A. 2003, ApJ, 585, 647 Chen, K., & Halpern, J. P. 1989, ApJ, 344, 115 S. Collin, T. Kawaguchi, B.M. Peterson, & M. Vestergaard: Masses of Black Holes in AGNs 19 Chevallier, L., Collin, S., Dumont, A.-M., Czerny, B., Mouchet, Nelson, C. H., Green, R. F., Bower, G., Gebhardt, K., & M., Goncalves, A., Goosman, R. 2005 A&A, in press Weistrop, D. 2004, ApJ, 615, 652 Clavel, J. 1991, in Variability of Active Galaxies, ed. W.J. Duschl, S.J. Wagner, & M. Camenzind, (Springer-Verlag: Berlin), p. 31 Collin, S., Boisson, C., Mouchet, M., Dumont, A.-M., Coup´e, S., Porquet, D., & Rokaki, E. 2002, A&A, 388, 771 (C02) Collin, S., & Hur´e, J.-M. 2001, A&A, 372, 50 Collin, S. & Kawaguchi, T. 2004, A&A, 426, 797 Collin-Souffrin, S., & Lasota, J. 1988, PASP, 100, 1041 Crenshaw, D. M., Kraemer, S. B., & Gabel, J. R. 2003, AJ, 126, 1690 Dumont, A. M., & Collin-Souffrin, S. 1990, A&A, 229, 313 Elvis, M., et al. 1994, ApJS, 95, 1 Elvis, M. 2000, ApJ, 545, 63 Eracleous, M., & Halpern, J. P. 1994, ApJS, 90, 1 Eracleous, M., Halpern, J. P., & Livio, M. 1996, ApJ, 459, 89 Ferrarese, L. & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJ, 539, L9 Ferrarese, L., Pogge, R.W., Peterson, B.M., Merritt, D., Wandel, A., & Joseph, C.L. 2001, ApJ, 555, L79 Fromerth, M. J., & Melia, F. 2000, ApJ, 533, 172 Gebhardt, K., et al. 2000, ApJ, 539, L13 Gebhardt, K., et al. 2000b, ApJ, 543, L5 Gierli´nski, M., & Done, C. 2004, MNRAS, 349, L7 Greene, J. E., & Ho, L. C. 2004, ApJ, 610, 722 Greenhill, L. J., Henkel, C., Becker, R., Wilson, T. L., & Netzer, H., 1990, in Active Galactic Nuclei, ed. T. J.-L. Courvoisier & Mayor, M. (Springer Verlag: Berlin), p. 137 Netzer, H. 2003, ApJ, 583, L5 Netzer, H., Maoz, D., Laor, A., Mendelson, H., Brosch, N., Leibowitz, E., Almoznino, E., Beck, S., & Mazeh, T. 1990, ApJ, 353, 108 Onken, C. A., Ferrarese, L., Merritt, D., Peterson, B. M., Pogge, R. W., Vestergaard, M., & Wandel, A. 2004, ApJ, 615, 645 Onken, C. A., & Peterson, B. M. 2002, ApJ, 572, 746 Pedlar, A., Fernandez, B., Hamilton, N. G., Redman, M. P., & Dewdney, P. E. 1998, MNRAS, 300, 1071 Peterson, B.M. 1993, PASP, 105, 247 Peterson, B. M. & Wandel, A. 1999, ApJ, 521, L95 Peterson, B. M. & Wandel, A. 2000, ApJ, 540, L13 Peterson, B. M., et al. 2002, ApJ, 581, 197 Peterson, B. M., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 682 Popovi´c, L. C., Mediavilla, E., Bon, E., & Ili´c, D. 2004, A&A, 423, 909 Pounds, K. A., Reeves, J. N., King, A. R., Page, K. L., O'Brien, P. T., & Turner, M. J. L. 2003, MNRAS, 345, 705 Proga, D., & Kallman, T. R. 2004, ApJ, 616, 688 Reynolds, C. S., & Wilms, J. 2000, ApJ, 533, 821 Rokaki, E., Lawrence, A., Economou, F., & Mastichiadis, A. Wouterloot, J. G. A. 1995, A&A, 304, 21 2003, MNRAS, 340, 1298 Horne, K., Peterson, B.M., Collier, S.J., & Netzer, H. 2004, Sergeev, S. G., Pronik, V. I., Sergeeva, E. A., & Malkov, Yu. PASP, 116, 465 Hur´e, J. 1998, A&A, 337, 625 Jackson, N., & Browne, I. W. A. 1991, MNRAS, 250, 422 Kaiser, M. E., et al. 2000, ApJ, 528, 260 Kaspi, S., Maoz, D., Netzer, H., Peterson, B. M., Vestergaard, M., & Jannuzi, B. T. 2005, ApJ, 629, 61 F. 1999, AJ, 118, 2658 Shakura, N. I., & Sunyaev, R. A. 1973, A&A, 24, 337 Shapovalova, A. I., et al. 2004, A&A, 422, 925 Shields, J. C., Ferland, G. J., & Peterson, B. M. 1995, ApJ, 441, 507 Smith, J.E., Robinson, A., Young, S., Axon, D.J., Corbett, Kaspi, S., Smith, P. S., Netzer, H., Maoz, D., Jannuzi, B. T., E.A., 2005, astro-ph/0502080 & Giveon, U. 2000, ApJ, 533, 631 Sulentic, J. W., Zwitter, T., Marziani, P., & Dultzin-Hacyan, Kawaguchi, T. 2003, ApJ, 593, 69 Kawaguchi, T., Pierens A. & Hur´e J.-M., 2004a, A&A, 415, 47 Kawaguchi, T., Aoki, K., Ohta, K., Collin, S. 2004b, A&A, 420, L23 King, A. R., & Pounds, K. A. 2003, MNRAS, 345, 657 Kollatschny, W. 2003a, A&A, 407, 461 Kollatschny, W. 2003b, A&A, 412, L61 Kollmeier, J.A., Onken, C.A., Kochanek, C.S., Gould, A., Weinberg, D.H., Dietrich, M., Cool, R., Dey, A., Eisenstein, D.J., Jannuzi, B.T., Le Floc'h, E., Stern, D. 2006, submit- ted to ApJ, (astro-ph/0508657) Krolik, J. H. 2001, ApJ, 551, 72 Krolik, J. H., & Begelman, M. C. 1988, ApJ, 329, 702 Lodato, G., & Rice, W. K. M. 2004, MNRAS, 351, 630 Marscher, A. P., Jorstad, S. G., G´omez, J.-L., et al., 2002, Nature, 417, 625 D. 2000, ApJ, 536, L5 Tremaine, S., et al. 2002, ApJ, 574, 740 Vestergaard, M. 2002, ApJ, 571, 733 Vestergaard, M. 2004, ApJ, 601, 676 Vestergaard, M., & Peterson, B.M. 2005, ApJ, 625, 688 Vestergaard, M., & Peterson, B.M. 2006, ApJ, in press Vestergaard, M., Wilkes, B. J., & Barthel, P. D. 2000, ApJ, 538, L103 Wandel, A., Peterson, B. M., & Malkan, M. A. 1999, ApJ, 526, 579 Wandel, A. 2001, ASP Conf. Ser. 224: Probing the Physics of Active Galactic Nuclei, 224, 365 Wijers, R. A. M. J., & Pringle, J. E. 1999, MNRAS, 308, 207 Williams, R.J., Mathur, S., & Pogge, R.W. 2004, ApJ, 610, 737 Wills, B. J., & Browne, I. W. A. 1986, ApJ, 302, 56 Winge, C., Axon, D. J., Macchetto, F. D., et al. 1999, ApJ, Mathur, S., Kuraszkiewicz, J. & Czerny, B., 2001, New Astron., 519, 134 6, 321 McLure, R. J. & Dunlop, J. S. 2001, MNRAS, 327, 199 McLure, R.J., & Jarvis, M.J. MNRAS, 337, 109 Merritt, D., & Ferrarese, L. 2001, ApJ, 547, 140 Miyoshi, M., Moran, J., Herrnstein, J., et al., 1995, Nature, Wu, X. & Han, J. L. 2001, ApJ, 561, L59 Yu, Q., & Tremaine, S. 2002, MNRAS, 335, 965 Zamanov, R., Marziani, P., Sulentic, J. W. et al., 2002, ApJ, 576, L9 Zhang, T.-Z., Wu, X.-B., 2002, Chin. J. Astron. Astrophys. 2, 373, 127 Murray, N., & Chiang, J. 1995, ApJ, 454, L105 Murray, N., & Chiang, J. 1997, ApJ, 474, 91 Murray, N., & Chiang, J. 1998, ApJ, 494, 125 Narayan, R., & Yi, I. 1994, ApJ, 428, L13 487
astro-ph/0012340	1	0012	2000-12-15T02:27:46	New Evidence for the Unified Scheme of BL Lac Objects and Fri Radio Galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	In this paper, we collect radio and X-ray observations for most Fanaroff-Riley I (FRI) radio galaxies in the Zirbel-Baum radio galaxy sample, and investigate the distribution of the radio-to-X-ray effective spectral index, $\alpha_{rx}$, to test the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. It is found that the range of $\alpha_{rx}$ for FRI radio galaxies is almost the same as that for BL Lac objects, that the distribution of $\alpha_{rx}$ probably peaks at the same position as BL Lac objects, and that the distribution of $\alpha_{rx}$ for FRIs is similar to that for BL Lac objects. These suggest that there exist two subclasses of FRI radio galaxies: one is HBL-like, and the other is LBL-like, corresponding to high-energy-peaked (HBL) and low--energy-peaked (LBL) BL Lac objects, respectively. This result is consistent with previous VLA observations, and supports the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Draft version October 27, 2018 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 04/03/99 0 0 0 2 c e D 5 1 1 v 0 4 3 2 1 0 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a NEW EVIDENCE FOR THE UNIFIED SCHEME OF BL LAC OBJECTS AND FRI RADIO GALAXIES J.M. Bai1,2 and Myung Gyoon Lee1 Draft version October 27, 2018 ABSTRACT In this paper, we collect radio and X-ray observations for most Fanaroff-Riley I (FRI) radio galaxies in the Zirbel-Baum radio galaxy sample, and investigate the distribution of the radio-to-X-ray effective spectral index, αrx, to test the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. It is found that the range of αrx for FRI radio galaxies is almost the same as that for BL Lac objects, that the distribution of αrx probably peaks at the same position as BL Lac objects, and that the distribution of αrx for FRIs is similar to that for BL Lac objects. These suggest that there exist two subclasses of FRI radio galaxies: one is HBL-like, and the other is LBL-like, corresponding to high-energy-peaked (HBL) and low -- energy-peaked (LBL) BL Lac objects, respectively. This result is consistent with previous VLA observations, and supports the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. Subject headings: BL Lac objects: general -- galaxies: active -- radiation mechanism: nonthermal -- radio continuum: galaxies -- X-rays: galaxies 1. INTRODUCTION Among active galactic nuclei (AGNs), BL Lac objects are the most extreme class characterized by strong and rapid variability, high polarization, and weak emission lines. These extreme properties are generally interpreted as a consequence of nonthermal emission from a relativistic jet oriented close to the line of sight (Blandford & Konigl 1979). Implicit in this hypothesis is that there exist many objects intrinsically identical to BL Lac objects, with the relativistic jets oriented at large angle to the line of sight (in the plane of the sky or perpendicular to our line of sight). While BL Lac objects are dominated by relativis- tically beamed emission from the jets, these objects are most likely dominated by unbeamed, isotropic emission and appear to be very different. These objects consti- tute the so-called parent population of BL Lac objects, and the unification in this way is usually called the "uni- fied scheme" (Antonucci & Ulvestad 1985). It is generally believed that the parent population of BL Lac objects is Fanaroff-Riley class I (FRI, Fanaroff & Riley 1974) ra- dio galaxies (Browne 1983; Wardle, Moore & Angel 1984). There is growing evidence for bulk relativistic motion in the jets of blazars (BL Lac objects and OVV quasars), and the relativistic beaming model has been widely ac- cepted (Ghisellini et al. 1993). However, almost all ar- guments for beaming can probably be explained in other ways as well (Urry & Padovani 1995). The strongest chal- lenge for this model remains in testing the unified scheme (Urry & Padovani 1990). Numerous studies have found general agreement with the unified scheme of BL Lac ob- jects and FRI radio galaxies, including studies of 1) un- beamed properties of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galax- ies, such as extended radio emission, narrow emission lines, host galaxies and environments, 2) luminosity functions of the parent and beamed populations in different bands, 3) correlation between core-dominance parameter (the ratio between core and extended radio flux) and beamed prop- erties (for a review see Antonucci 1993; Urry & Padovani 1995). Recently, Hubble Space Telescope (HST ) obser- vations of host galaxies of BL Lac objects (Falomo et al. 1997, Urry et al. 1999) and of the optical cores of FRI radio galaxies (Chiaberge et al. 1999, 2000; Capetti & Celotti 1999) also supported this unified scheme. Further- more, superluminal motion confirmed in M87 by HST op- tical observation (Bireta et al. 1999) and in B2 1144+35 by VLBI observation (Giovannini et al. 1999) provided strong evidence to this unified scheme. Early multiwavelength observations showed that emis- sion from BL Lac objects is dominated by synchrotron component with the peak lying in the IR to X-ray energy range. In the 1990's, with the observations by Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory and ground-based Cherenkov telescopes it was found that BL Lac objects emit enormous power in rapidly variable high energy gamma rays (GeV and TeV), indicating a second peak in their overall spec- tral energy distribution (SED; Ulrich, Maraschi and Urry 1997; Fossati et al. 1998). A practical way to parameter- ize the different SEDs is to use the radio-to-X-ray effective spectral index αrx. According to whether αrx is greater than or less than 0.75 (Padovani & Giommi 1995) BL Lac objects are divided into two subclasses, the low-energy- peaked BL Lac objects (LBLs) which have synchrotron peaks in IR/optical and high-energy-peaked BL Lac ob- jects (HBLs) which have synchrotron peaks in UV/soft X-ray. Most radio-selected BL Lac objects (RBLs) are LBLs, while most X-ray-selected BL Lac objects (XBLs) are HBLs. Further studies found that the SED difference between LBL and HBL cannot be explained in terms of different viewing angles alone, suggesting that there must be some intrinsic differences that cause different SEDs be- tween LBL and HBL (Sambruna et al. 1996, 1999; Geor- granopoulos & Marscher et al. 1998; Fossati et al. 1998). If FRI radio galaxies are, as believed today, misaligned 1Astronomy Program, SEES, Seoul National University, Seoul 151-742, Korea; ([email protected]; [email protected]) 2Yunnan Astronomical Observatory, The Chinese Academy of Science, Kunming 650011, China 1 2 BL Lac objects, it is expected that the jet-related nonther- mal emission from FRI radio galaxies also has a double- peak structure in the SED, and that there exist two in- trinsically different subclasses of FRI radio galaxies: one is LBL-like with αrx > 0.75, and the other is HBL-like with αrx < 0.75, corresponding to the parent populations for LBLs and HBLs, respectively. Therefore, the double- peak characteristics of the SED of the jet-related emission and the existence or nonexistence of two subclasses of FRI radio galaxies (or more strictly speaking, the distribution of αrx in FRI radio galaxies) can be used to test the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. There are some difficulties at present to test the uni- fied scheme in terms of the double-peak characteristics of the SED, because the detectors available are not yet sensi- tive enough to detect high-energy emission in most of FRI radio galaxies. In this paper we collect X-ray and radio observations available in the literature for most of FRIs in the Zirbel-Baum sample (Zirbel & Baum 1995), and in- vestigate the distribution of αrx for the sample to test the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. 2. THE SAMPLE Our sample, as listed in Table 1, comprises most of FRI radio galaxies in the sample of radio-loud elliptical galax- ies compiled by Zirbel & Baum (1995). The Zirbel-Baum sample is the largest known sample of radio-loud elliptical galaxies (excluding quasars). The radio luminosity ranges from the "radio-quiet" ellipticals of Phillips et al. (1986) to the more powerful radio galaxies of McCarthy (1988), nicely covering FRIs and FRIIs which are located within the transition region in radio power (Zirbel & Baum 1995). For an FRI radio galaxy, Zirbel & Baum (1995) defined it solely on the basis of radio morphology as a radio galaxy in which the radio emission peaks near the center of the galaxy and the twin jets fade with distance from the center producing the diffuse, plumelike and edge-dimmed radio lobes. Complete samples of FRI radio galaxies, such as 3CR (Laing et al 1983), B2 (Ulrich 1989), Wall-Peacock (Wall & Peacock 1985), and other samples are all included in the Zirbel-Baum sample. It is therefore thought that al- though the Zirbel-Baum FRI sample itself is not complete, it can represent the FRI population (e.g. Kollgaard et al. 1996; Urry & Padovani 1995). Some sources have been reclassified. For example, 3C 28, 3C 293, 3C 305, 3C 310, 3C 346, 3C 433 and NGC 6109 which were identified to be FRIs by Laing et al. (1983) have been reclassified as FRIIs, 3C 40 which was identified to be an FRII by Morganti et al. (1993) has been reclassified as an FRI, and Caganoff's sources (Caganoff 1988) have been all reclassified from the original radio maps (Zirbel & Baum 1995). Although it is true that some of FRII radio galaxies may also be parent population of BL Lac objects which are probably identical to LBLs, we exclude possible FRIIs which have been iden- tified as FRIs initially but have been reclassified as FRIIs later, since our purpose is to investigate whether there ex- ist HBL-like and LBL-like subclasses of FRI radio galaxy. For some sources, X-ray data are not available at present. These sources are therefore excluded from our sample, yet our sample comprises over 70% FRI radio galaxies in the Zirbel-Baum sample. In Table 1, the columns are: (1) IAU name; (2) other name; (3) redshift; (4) flux density of the core at 5GHz in unit of mJy; (5) reference for the radio flux density; (6) flux density of the central unresolved component at 1keV in unit of nJy; (7) reference for X-ray flux; (8) ef- fective spectral indices between 5GHz and 1keV corrected for beaming. For some objects, X-ray flux densities are calculated from broad band flux with the photon index (or spectral index) given in the corresponding reference. Effective spectral index αrx between 5GHz and 1keV is calculated as (Lamer et al. 1994) αrx = log10(S5GHz/S1keV ) 7.68 , and between 5GHz and 2keV as (Perlman et al. 1996) αrx = log10(S5GHz/S2keV ) 7.985 , where S5GHz, S1keV and S2keV are flux densities at 5GHz, 1keV and 2keV in the rest frame of the source, respectively. The flux densities in Table 1 have been all K-corrected be- fore computing αrx. Since the radio cores of FRIs have a flat spectrum, we take αr=0.0 for the K-correction when there is no αr in the literature, and αx=0.8, the typical value for FRI class. The value of αrx in Table 1 has been corrected for beam- ing as well. According to the unified scheme, an FRI radio galaxy with αF rx is viewed at a large angle to the line of sight. When viewed at a small angle, it will appear as a BL Lac object with αB rx. The transformation law for the change of αrx due to relativistic beaming is given by Chiaberge et al. (2000) as αB rx = αF rx + (αr − αx) log10(δB/δF ) 7.68 , where δB and δF are Doppler factors for BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies, respectively. The Doppler factor is defined as δ = [Γ(1 − β cos θ)]−1, where β is the speed of emitting plasma in unit of the speed of light, Γ is Lorentz factor Γ = (1 − β2)−1/2 and θ is the angle to the line of sight. We take typical value for viewing angle and Lorentz factor. The typical viewing angle of FRI radio galaxies is θ = 60◦, and for BL Lac objects, the typical viewing angle is θ = 20◦ (e.g. Padovani 1999). The typical Lorentz fac- tor for relativistic jets is Γ = 5.0 (Padovani 1999; Param et al. 1996; Marscher 1993). 3. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS As mentioned in the Introduction section, a practical way to parameterize the different SEDs is to use the radio- to-X-ray spectral index, αrx, and according to whether αrx is greater than or less than 0.75 (Padovani & Giommi 1995) BL Lac objects are divided into two subclasses, LBL and HBL. Figure 1a displays the distribution of αrx for our sample of 51 FRI radio galaxies. For comparison, Figure 1b illustrates the distribution of αrx for BL Lac objects in the samples of EMSS (the most X-ray-dominated BL Lac objects), ROSAT -Green Bank (RGB, intermediate) and 1Jy (the most radio-dominated BL Lac objects, see the fourth paragraph of this section for detailed properties of BL Lac samples). For RGB objects, αrx is calculated with the data in Laurent-Muehleisen et al. (1999), and for 1Jy and EMSS objects, αrx is taken from Sambruna et al. 3 Table 1 The sample of FRI radio galaxies IAU Name Other Name Redshift (1) (2) 0055−01 0104+32 0123−01 0219+42 0255+05 0300+16 0305+03 0314+41 0316+41 0320−37 0427−53 0430+05 0453−20 0620−52 0625−35 0722+30 0800+24 0915−11 1040+31 1142+19 1144+35 1216+06 1222+13 1228+12 1251−12 1254+27 1256+28 1317+33 1318−43 1322+36 1322−42 1333−33 1346+26 1414+11 1422+26 1511+26 1514+07 1553+24 1610+29 1621+38 1626+39 1648+05 1836+17 1839−48 1855+37 1954−55 2058−28 2152−69 2212+13 2229+39 2335+26 3C29 3C31 3C40 3C66B 3C75 3C76.1 3C78 3C83.1B 3C84 ForA PKS 3C120 B2 PKS OH-342 B2 B2 PKS B2 3C264 B2 3C270 3C272.1 3C274 3C278 B2 B2 B2 NGC5090 B2 CEN A PKS B2 3C296 B2 3C315 3C317 B2 B2 B2 3C338 3C348 3C386 PKS B2 PKS PKS PKS 3C442A 3C449 3C465 (3) 0.0448 0.0167 0.0180 0.0215 0.0232 0.0320 0.0288 0.0255 0.0172 0.0050 0.0380 0.0330 0.0350 0.0510 0.0550 0.0191 0.0433 0.0540 0.0360 0.0208 0.0630 0.0060 0.0031 0.0043 0.0150 0.0246 0.0224 0.0379 0.0110 0.0175 0.0020 0.0130 0.0633 0.0237 0.0370 0.1080 0.0342 0.0426 0.0313 0.0310 0.0298 0.1540 0.0180 0.1120 0.0552 0.0600 0.0380 0.0270 0.0263 0.0171 0.0293 F5GHz (4)(mJy) Ref. (5) F1keV (6)(nJy) Ref. (7) 93.0 140.0 100.0 182.0 39.0 10.0 964.0 40.0 59600.0 26.0 57.0 3458.0 40.0 260.0 600.0 51.0 3.0 217.0 55.0 200.0 250.0 308.0 180.0 4000.0 88.0 2.3 2.0 8.0 580.0 150.0 6984.0 297.0 53.0 77.0 25.0 150.0 391.0 53.6 6.0 50.0 105.0 10.0 14.0 163.0 100.0 50.0 63.0 400.0 2.0 37.0 270.0 1 3 1 5 1 6 1 8 9 1 1 1 1 1 1 10 10 1 10 12 3 1 10 10 1 11 3 11 1 3 1 1 10 10 10 13 1 14 10 10 3 1 15 1 10 1 1 1 10 10 3 11.1 63.7 58.5 141.0 345.1 33.0* 698.6 27.0 1300.0 210.1 116.9 9065.5 48.7 488.5 1327.7 < 20.0 < 3.0 7314.8 16.0 486.0 170.0 147.5 26.0 1080.0 79.3 25.0 < 2.0 7.0 250.5 < 10.0 488.5 179.5 36.0 57.8 4.0 42.0* 5167.4 11.0 12.0 16.0 17.5 790.5 30.0* 229.6 35.0 204.6 116.9 903.2 < 15.0 16.0 65.8 2 4 2 4 2 7 2 4 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 11 11 2 11 4 11 2 4 4 2 11 11 11 2 11 2 2 11 4 11 7 2 11 11 11 4 2 7 2 11 2 2 2 4 4 4 αrx (8) 0.82 0.74 0.73 0.71 0.58 0.61 0.72 0.72 0.92 0.58 0.66 0.65 0.69 0.66 0.65 0.75 0.70 0.50 0.77 0.65 0.72 0.74 0.81 0.78 0.71 0.57 0.70 0.71 0.75 0.85 0.85 0.73 0.72 0.72 0.80 0.74 0.55 0.79 0.66 0.76 0.80 0.45 0.63 0.68 0.76 0.62 0.66 0.65 0.59 0.75 0.78 Note. -- The X-ray flux densities with ∗ are at 2keV. References. -- (1) Morganti et al. 1993; (2) Siebert et al. 1996; (3) Giovannini et 4 (1996). We adopt the data in the RGB sample for overlap- ping sources between the RGB and EMSS or 1Jy sample. Important features are seen in Figure 1a and Table 1: a) The range of αrx of FRI radio galaxies is 0.45 to 0.92, which is almost the same as that of BL Lac objects (0.45 to 1.01, see Figure 1b); b) There is a peak at αrx ≈0.70 and the average of αrx for the whole sample is 0.70. (The average of αrx of BL Lac objects in Fig. 1b is 0.69.); c) 38 out of total 51 FRIs have αrx < 0.75. These suggest that HBL-like FRI radio galaxies are not rare exceptions as in the case for flat spectral radio quasars (FSRQs; Padovani, Giommi, & Fiore 1997), but statistically constitute a sub- class which populates about half of the sample. These results shows that there exist two subclasses of FRI radio galaxies: one is HBL-like and the other is LBL-like. Investigations of multifrequency spectral energy distri- bution from the radio through the X-ray bands for BL Lac objects and FSRQs show that the different SEDs between HBL and LBL cannot be explained in terms of different viewing angles alone (Sambruna et al. 1996; Fossati et al. 1998). There must be some intrinsic differences that cause different SEDs between LBL and HBL. As their par- ent population, FRI radio galaxies should exhibit similar differences, but should not be what was once believed that every FRI could appears as an HBL or an LBL if viewed at different angles to the line of sight. Therefore, the exis- tence of the HBL-like and LBL-like subclasses of FRI radio galaxies supports the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. In fact, as early as in 1992, based on VLA observation for complete samples of LBL and HBL, Kollgaard et al. (1992) and Laurent-Muehleisen et al. (1993) found that only those FRI radio galaxies with intrinsically stronger cores would appear as an LBL if viewed at a small angle to the jet direction, while HBL may be found among the weaker cored FRI radio galaxies. This conflicted with the prevailing point of view at that time that XBLs (mainly HBLs) were intrinsically the same as RBLs (mainly LBLs), but now has actually become another evidence of the uni- fied scheme, and is consistent with our results. In addition, the result of Kollgaard et al. also suggests that care should be taken when using flux-limited complete samples to test the unified scheme, since there may be few HBL-like FRIs in the samples of brighter radio source. In Fig. 1a, there is only one peak at αrx ≈ 0.72 in the distribution of αrx. It had been known for long that the distribution of BL Lac objects is bimodal which peaks at αrx ≈ 0.5 and 0.9 (e.g. Stocke et al. 1985, 1991; Padovani & Giommi 1995, 1996; Sambruna et al. 1996; Fossati et al. 1998). However, a large fraction of newly discovered BL Lac objects have been found to fill in the gap between the two peaks, which are called intermediate BL Lac objects (IBLs, Perlman et al. 1998; Caccianiga et al. 1999; Laurent-Muehleisen 1997; Laurent-Muehleisen et al. 1999). Probably, as Laurent-Muehleisen et al. (1999) pointed out, the bimodal distribution of BL Lac objects found in earlier studies was caused by observational se- lection effects, and the true distribution of X-ray-to-radio flux ratio Sx/Sr (equals the distribution of αrx) is uni- modal (Laurent-Muehleisen et al. 1999). A Kolmogorov- Smirnov test shows that the distributions of αrx for FRI radio galaxies and BL Lac objects in Figs. 1a and 1b are indistinguishable at the level of 90 percent. However, fur- ther quantitative test is necessary in the future, because it seems that none of the flux-limited complete samples of BL Lac objects available at present can represent the whole class of BL Lac objects. Recently, Chiaberge et al. (2000) tested the unification of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies by comparing the core emission of radio galaxies with those of BL Lac objects, taking advantage of the HST optical observation for the core in 3CR FRI radio galaxies. From the com- parison of the optical and radio emission of FRIs and BL Lac objects, they inferred Lorentz factors of Γ ∼ 5, which are typical for a relativistic jet (Padovani 1999; Param et al. 1996; Marscher 1993), supporting the unified scheme. Their study also shows that in the Lo − Lr (optical and radio luminosities of the core) plane, HBL and LBL move on different debeaming trails, and that debeaming trail of LBL crosses the 3CR FRI region (both the simple emission component model and two-velocity jet model). By taking the typical value for the Lorentz factor or assuming a two- velocity structures for the jet, the location of debeamed BL Lac objects in the 1Jy sample in the Lo − Lr plane coincides with that of FRIs in the 3CR sample, indicat- ing that FRIs in the 3CR sample are LBL-like or IBL-like. This is also consistent with our result. It is notable that the percentage of LBL-Like FRIs in our sample is less than 50% after beaming correction. This may indicate that some FRIIs or at least the intermediate sources (FRI/II) should be included in the parent popula- tion of BL Lac objects, which was also suggested by VLA observations (Kollgaard et al. 1992) and optical spectro- scopic observations (Owen et al. 1996). Another possible explanation is that this may be caused by the limited an- gular resolution of X-ray observations. For example, the angular resolution of ROSAT with the HRI is only about 5′′. The X-ray flux of the central unresolved component of an FRI radio galaxy is probably not contributed by the VLA radio core alone. In the near future, Chandra X-ray Observatory (CXO) will observe the central region of FRI radio galaxies with much higher spatial resolution and sensitivity, obtaining a much better and larger X-ray- observed sample to test the unified scheme more reliably. In addition, with the CXO's high sensitive and high spec- tral resolution observation, the existence of HBL-like and LBL-like FRI radio galaxies can be tested directly by com- paring the X-ray spectra. Since the HBL-like FRIs peak the synchrotron emission at UV/X-ray energy range, the X-rays are an extension of synchrotron emission with a steeper spectrum, and the shape of the optical-to-X-ray continuum is convex (αx > αox); while for most LBL- like FRIs, the X-rays are dominated by inverse-Compton emission with a flatter spectrum, and the shape of the optical-to-X-ray continuum is concave (αx < αox). There- fore, HBL-like FRIs can be distinguished from LBL-like FRIs in the optical to soft X-ray energy range. In summary, the range of αrx for FRI radio galaxies is almost the same as that for BL Lac objects, the distribu- tion of αrx probably peaks at the same position as BL Lac objects, and the distribution of αrx for FRIs is similar to that for BL Lac objects. These suggest that there exist two subclasses of FRI radio galaxies: one is HBL-like, and the other is LBL-like, corresponding to HBLs and LBLs, respectively. This result supports the unified scheme of BL Lac objects and FRI radio galaxies. The authors wish to thank the anonymous referee for his/her comments that improved this paper significantly. This work was financially supported by the BK21 Project of the Korean government. 5 REFERENCES Antonucci, R.R.J. 1993, ARA&A, 31, 473 Antonucci, R.R.J. & Ulvestad, J. S. 1985, ApJ, 294, 158 Bireta, J.A., Sparks, W.B., & Macchetto F. 1999, ApJ, 520, 621 Blandford, R. D., & Konigl, A. 1979, ApJ, 232, 34 Browne, I.W.A. 1983, MNRAS, 204, 23P Caccianiga, A., et al. 1999, ApJ, 513, 51 Caganoff, S. 1988, Ph.D. thesis, The Australian National University Canosa, C.M., Worrall, D.M., Hardcastle, M.J., Birkinshaw, M. 1999, MNRAS, 310, 30 Capetti, A. & Celotti, A. 1999, MNRAS, 304, 434 Chiaberge, M., Celotti, A., Capetti, A., & Ghisellini, G. 2000, A&A, 358, 104 Chiaberge, M., Celotti, A., Capetti, A. 1999, A&A, 349, 77 Fabbiano, G., Trinchieri, G., Elvis, M., et al. 1984, ApJ, 277, 115 Falomo, R. et al. 1997, ApJ, 476, 113 Fanaroff, B., & Riley, J.M. 1974, MNRAS, 167, 31P Fanti, C, Fanti, R, De Ruiter H.R., Parma, P. 1987, A&AS, 69, 57 Fossati, G., Maraschi, L., Celotti, A., et al. 1998, MNRAS, 299,433 Gavazzi, G., Perola, g.c., & Jaffe, W. 1981, A&A, 103, 35 Georgranopoulos, M., & Marscher, A.P. 1998, ApJ, 506, 621 Ghisellini, G., Padovani, P., Celotti, A., & Maraschi, L. 1993, ApJ, 407, 65 73 Giovannini, G., et al. 1999, ApJ, 522, 101 Giovannini, G., Feretti, L., Gregorini, L., Parma, P. 1988, A&A, 199, Giovannini, G., Feretti, L., Comoretto, G. 1990, ApJ, 358, 159 Hardcastle, M.J., & Worrall, D.M. 1999, MNRAS, 309, 969 Hogbom, J.A. 1979, A&AS, 36, 173 Kollgaard, R.I., et al. 1996, ApJ, 465, 115 Kollgaard, R.I., Wardle, J.F.C., Roberts, D.H., & Gabuzda, D.C. 1992, AJ, 104, 1687 Laing, R.A., Riley, J.M., & Longair, M.S. 1983, MNRAS, 204, 151 Lamer , G., Brunner, H., & Staubert, R. 1996, A&A, 311, 384 Laurent-Muehleisen, S.A., Kollgaard, R.I., Feigelson, E.D., et al. 1999, ApJ, 525, 127 Laurent-Muehleisen, S.A. 1997, PASP, 109, 341 Laurent-Muehleisen, S.A., Kollgaard, R.I., Moellenbrock, G.A., & Feigelson, E.D. 1993, AJ, 106, 875 Leahy, J.P., Jagers, W.J., & Pooley, G.G. 1986, A&A, 156, 234 Macklin, J.T. 1983, MNRAS, 203, 147 Marscher, A.P. 1993, in Astrophysical Jets, ed. D. Burgarella, M. Livio, & C.P. O'Dea (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 73 McCarthy, P.J. 1988, Ph.D. thesis, University of California at Berkeley Morganti, R., Killeen, N.E.B., Tadhunter, C.N. 1993, MNRAS, 263, 1023 Noordam, J.E., & de Bruyn, A.G. 1982. Nat, 299, 597 O'Dea, C.P., & Owen, F.N. 1985, AJ, 90, 927 Owen, P. N., Ledlow, M.J., & Keel, W.C. 1996, AJ, 111, 53 Padovani, P. 1999, ASP. Conf. Series, 159, 339 Padovani, P. and Giommi, P., & Fiore, F. 1997, MNRAS, 284, 569 Padovani, P. and Giommi, P. 1996, MNRAS, 279, 526 Padovani, P. and Giommi, P. 1995, ApJ, 444, 567 Param, P., de Ruiter, H.R., & Fanti, R. 1996, in IAU Symp. 175, Extragalactic Radio Sources, ed. R. Ekers, C.Fanti, & L.Padrielli (Dordrecht: Reidel), 137 Perlman, E.S., Padovani, P., Giommi, P., et al. 1998, AJ, 115, 1253 Perlman, E.S., et al. 1996, ApJS, 104, 251 Phillips, M.M., et al. 1986, AJ, 91, 1061 Sambruna, R.M., Maraschi, L., & Urry, C.M. 1996, ApJ, 463, 444 Sambruna, R.M., et al. 1999, ApJ, 515, 140 Siebert, J., Brinkmann, W., Morganti, R., et al. 1996, MNRAS, 279, 1331 Stocke, J.T., et al. 1991, ApJS, 76, 813 Stocke, J.T., et al. 1985, ApJ, 298, 619 Strom, R.G., Willis, A.G., Wilson, A.S. 1978, A&A, 68, 367 Ulrich, M.-H., Maraschi, L., & Urry, C.M. 1997, ARA&A, 35, 445 Ulrich, M.-H. 1989, in BL Lac Objects, edited by L. Maraschi, T. Maccacaro and M.-H. Ulrich (Springer, Berlin), 45 Urry, C.M., et al. 1999, ApJ, 512, 88 Urry, C.M., Padovani, P. 1995, PASP, 107, 804 Urry, C.M., Padovani, P. 1990, ApJ, 356, 75 Wardle, J.F.C., Moore, R.L., & Angel, J.R.P. 1984, ApJ, 279, 93 Wall, J.V., Peacock, J.A., 1985, MNRAS, 216, 173 Zirbel, E.L., & Baum, S.A. 1995, ApJ, 448, 548 Fig. 1. -- Distributions of the effective spectral index, α rx. (a): for our sample of FRI radio galaxies, (b): for BL Lac objects in the RGB, 1Jy and EMSS samples.
astro-ph/0012153	2	0012	2001-07-30T23:01:28	Position-Space Description of the Cosmic Microwave Background and Its Temperature Correlation Function	[ "astro-ph" ]	We suggest that the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature correlation function C(theta) as a function of angle provides a direct connection between experimental data and the fundamental cosmological quantities. The evolution of inhomogeneities in the prerecombination universe is studied using their Green's functions in position space. We find that a primordial adiabatic point perturbation propagates as a sharp-edged spherical acoustic wave. Density singularities at its wavefronts create a feature in the CMB correlation function distinguished by a dip at theta ~ 1.2 deg. Characteristics of the feature are sensitive to the values of cosmological parameters, in particular to the total and the baryon densities.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Position-Space Description of the Cosmic Microwave Background and Its Temperature Correlation Function Sergei Bashinsky1 and Edmund Bertschinger2 1Center for Theoretical Physics, 2Center for Space Research, and 1,2Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139 We suggest that the cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature correlation function C(θ) as a function of angle provides a direct connection between experimental data and the fundamental cos- mological quantities. The evolution of inhomogeneities in the prerecombination universe is studied using their Green's functions in position space. We find that a primordial adiabatic point pertur- bation propagates as a sharp-edged spherical acoustic wave. Density singularities at its wavefronts create a feature in the CMB correlation function distinguished by a dip at θ ≈ 1.2◦. Characteristics of the feature are sensitive to the values of cosmological parameters, in particular to the total and the baryon densities. The cosmic microwave background (CMB) radiation provides the best probe today of the early universe and a number of fundamental astrophysical constants [1 -- 7]. Dynamical evolution of primordial perturbations mani- fests itself in the form of "acoustic peaks" in the CMB temperature angular power spectrum Cl. After over a decade of studies, the physical content of the peaks has become qualitatively understood [8 -- 11]. Neverthe- less, one has to rely on standard numerical codes [12,13] to establish a quantitative connection between the CMB anisotropy pattern and cosmological parameters. This connection is particularly important now that high- precision CMB measurements have become reality. In this letter we show that previously unnoticed interesting phenomena are unraveled by considering the radiation-matter dynamics in position rather than Fourier space. Traditional CMB anisotropy analy- ses begin with the Fourier expansion of spatial inho- mogeneities and studying time evolution of individual Fourier modes [16 -- 18]. The position space approach, while offering a formally equivalent description, differs in its physical interpretation, associated calculational meth- ods, and its implications for data analysis. As we show here, a new side of CMB physics is revealed in position space. One goal of our work is a deeper physical un- derstanding of both the CMB power spectrum Cl and the angular correlation function C(θ). We demonstrate that acoustic evolution of perturbations before recombi- nation, as viewed in position space, produces sharp fea- tures in C(θ). These signatures not only provide a simple interpretation of the acoustic peaks, but they may also enable fast and accurate extraction of cosmological pa- rameters directly from C(θ). As a simplified model for the essential physical pro- cesses, we consider the evolution of potential and den- sity perturbations in gravitationally interacting photon- baryon and cold dark matter fluids. We use the con- formal Newtonian gauge [18,19] to describe gravity and assume adiabatic (isentropic) primordial fluctuations as preferred by the present data [14,15] and the simplest in- 1 flationary models. The photons are assumed to be tightly coupled to electrons and baryons by Thomson scatter- ing until recombination at redshift zrec ∼ 1100. Neu- trinos are treated like photons. The disregard of neu- trino free-streaming and photon diffusion introduces a 10%−20% error [20,21] for CMB temperature anisotropy. This model is helpful for developing understanding. Our numerical results for the correlation function and the an- gular spectrum are obtained a full calculation with CMB- FAST [12] including all relevant effects. Long before recombination during the radiation era, the growing mode of gravitational potential pertur- bation is described in Fourier space by φ(k, τ ) = 3(cid:2)sin(q)/q3 − cos(q)/q2(cid:3) φ0(k), q ≡ kcsτ , where τ is con- formal time, k is the wave vector corresponding to a comoving coordinate r, and cs = 1/√3 is the speed of sound in the radiation era [16]. A delta function primor- dial perturbation φ(r, τ → 0) = δ(3)(r) is represented in k-space by constant initial amplitude φ0(k) = 1. Fourier transforming the resulting φ(k, τ ) we obtain the three- dimensional Green's function for the gravitational poten- tial in the radiation dominated epoch, φ(3)(r, τ ) = 3 4π (csτ )−3 θ(csτ − r) , (1) where θ(x) ≡ {1, x > 0; 0 otherwise}. Eq. (1) illus- trates the essential property of the position-space Green's functions -- the perturbation is localized within the acous- tic sphere, with a sharp edge at the sound horizon r = S(τ ) ≡ R τ 0 cs(τ ′) dτ ′. When cold dark matter (CDM) and baryons are taken into account, we split the total gravitational potential φ = φr + φc into a part connected to the photon-baryon plasma, φr, and a part due to the CDM, φc . The sources of the potentials φr and φc are given respectively by the radiation-baryon and CDM energy densities relative to the net zero-momentum hypersurfaces, the analogues of Bardeen's [16] gauge-invariant density variable ǫm. The potentials φr and φc unambiguously determine the val- ues of all the density and velocity perturbations in our model [22]. Their evolution is described by a pair of cou- pled equations, (2) φr +Pi=r,c(Ari φi + Briφi) = c2 φc +Pi=r,c(Aci φi + Bciφi) = 0 s ∇2φr , where Aij and Bij are simple rational functions of τ [22]. The first of eqs. (2) shows that a primordial isentropic perturbation at a point propagates as a spherical acous- tic wave in the photon-baryon plasma with the sound speed c2 s = dpγ/d(ργ + ρb) = (1/3)/[1 + (3ρb)/(4ργ)], where ργ and ρb are the photon and baryon mean energy densities. As the sound wave passes by, its gravitational effect perturbs the CDM causing it to evolve as described by the second of eqs. (2). Since perturbations propagate differently in the radiation and the CDM components, inhomogeneities do not remain isentropic for τ > 0 . We integrate eqs. (2) numerically along their char- acteristics starting from the radiation-era solution (1) at τinit ≃ 10−4τrec, and increasing the space-time grid spacing with time in proportion to the acoustic horizon size S(τ ). It is convenient to solve eqs. (2) in only one spatial dimension with the initial condi- tions φ(1)(x) → δ(x) and vanishing entropy pertur- The resulting one-dimensional, bation as τ → 0. or plane-parallel, Green's function for the total poten- tial, φ(1)(x, τ ), is related to the conventional transfer function φ(k, τ ) as φ(k, τ ) = R φ(1)(x, τ ) e−ikxdx. The potential Green's function in three dimensions equals φ(3)(r, τ ) = −(2πr)−1∂φ(1)(r, τ )/∂r. A superscript "(1)" will be used for any quantity (e.g. density perturbation or temperature anisotropy) obtained from the isentropic initial condition φ(x, τ → 0) = δ(x), and such quanti- ties will similarly be referred to as "Green's functions." The Fourier transform of any Green's function gives the corresponding k-space transfer function. Fig. 1 shows the result for an effective temperature Green's function ∆(1) eff (x) describing the combined intrin- sic and gravitational redshift contributions to CMB tem- perature anisotropy. Within our tight coupling assump- tion, it contains delta function singularities at the wave fronts given by (3/4) [1 + (3ρb)/(4ργ)]−1/4 δ (x − S), where S(τ ) ≡ R τ 0 cs(τ ′)dτ ′. The contribution of the delta function to R ∆(1) eff (x, τrec) dx exceeds the absolute value of the contribution from the regular part by ∼ 40%, showing that the singularities play a major role in CMB anisotropy. The massive baryons coupled to the radiation fluid re- duce the sound speed that decreases the acoustic horizon at recombination. They also drag radiation out of the x = 0 region in Fig. 1 being repelled by a kink in CDM potential φ(1) at x = 0. This effect causes the prominent "gully" in the middle of the transfer function in Fig. 1. The peculiar features of the position space transfer functions are manifested in the angular correlation func- tion c ) 1 ( φ + γ ) 1 ( δ 4 2 1 0 Ω b= 0.03 h−2 Ω b= 0 / 1 = −1 f f e ) 1 ( ∆ −2 − cτ rec − 0.5 cτ rec 0 x 0.5 cτ rec cτ rec FIG. 1. The position space transfer function for the in- trinsic ( 1 4 δγ ) plus gravitational redshift contributions to the CMB temperature anisotropy ∆T /T at recombination, for Ωm = 0.35, ΩΛ = 0.65, and h = 0.65. The vertical spikes rep- resent the wave-front delta function singularities described in the text. Baryon drag effects are evident from comparing the solid and dashed lines. C(θ) ≡ h∆T (n1)∆T (n2)i = Xl (2l + 1) 4π ClPl(cos θ) , (3) where ∆T (ni) is the temperature anisotropy in the di- rection ni, and θ is the angle between n1 and n2 . The connection between C(θ) and the Green's functions may be illustrated in the large angle limit when ∆T (ni)/T ≈ ∆eff (ni, τrec) ≡ 1 4 δγ + φ, δγ ≡ δργ/ργ, for θ exceed- ing a few degrees. Writing each ∆T (ni) as the con- volution of the Green's function in Fig. 1 with a pri- mordial potential field φ0, assuming that recombination occurs instantaneously, and averaging over the primor- dial fluctuations with power spectrum hφ0(k1)φ0(k2)i ∝ δ(3)(k1 + k2)kns−4, we get C(θ) ∝ Z dx1 ∆(1) eff (x1)Z dx2 ∆(1) eff (x2) K(x1 + x2, θ) , (4) where K is an analytically known function of x1 + x2, angle θ, the comoving distance to CMB photosphere R, and the spectral index ns [22]. The exact formula for C(θ) applicable to subdegree scales should also include Doppler and integrated Sachs-Wolfe effects and integra- tion along the line of sight [12]. Eq. (4) neglects these contributions but is sufficient to give a good qualitative description of the effects considered below. From eq. (4), the delta function singularities pro- duce a singular C(θ) behavior in the vicinity of θs ≡ 2 arcsin(S/R), where S ≡ S(τrec) ≃ 140 Mpc is the acoustic horizon size at recombination. For a flat uni- verse and the scale-invariant power spectrum ns = 1, C(θ)−C(θs) ∼ −∆s ln∆s, ∆s ≡ sin(θ/2)−S/R. When the two observed points come into acoustic contact at the critical angle θs, dC(θs)/dθ = +∞ in the instantaneous recombination approximation. At this angular separa- tion, a spherical sound wave emitted at τ = 0 from the point halfway between the observed points on the pho- 2 2 K 9 − 0 1 , ) θ ( C bh2= 0.03 ΛCDM , Ω same, dip cut out 1/4 δγ + φ , inst. rec. ΛCDM , Ω bh2= 0.02 Ω m= Ω = 0.35 8 6 4 2 0.4 0.8 1.2 θ, degrees 1.6 2 FIG. 2. Angular CMB temperature correlation function. The parameters of the ΛCDM model are Ωm = 0.35, ΩΛ = 0.65, h = 0.65, ns = 1. For this set of parameters and the displayed Ωbh2 values, θs ≃ 1.17◦ and 1.22◦. The thin solid curve is calculated using eq. (4). All the other plots are obtained in full CMBFAST calculation, except for the dotted line that artificially cuts the dip for its Fourier analy- sis in Fig. 4. The whole feature in C(θ) is shifted to smaller angles in the open model (dash-dotted line). Baryon density variation modifies the slope for θ < θs/2 (dashed vs. solid line). tosphere has, by recombination, just reached the two ob- served points separated by a distance 2S. the Paradoxically, initial acoustic contact anti- correlates the temperature fluctuations causing a dip in the correlation function just below θs . As evident from Fig. 2 , the dip is also present in the full result obtained from a CMBFAST calculation (wide solid line) although smoothed by the Silk damping [23] and the finite thick- ness of the recombination photosphere. An anomaly in the correlation function at this angular separation was pointed out earlier in [24] and [25]. At even smaller an- gles the correlation function rises steeply. The dip occurs when the comoving separation of the observed points on the photosphere is about 2S ≃ 280 Mpc, providing a "standard ruler" in the early universe. The comoving dis- tance to the photosphere R and thus the observed angle θs are determined by the rate of the subsequent Hubble expansion and by the cosmic curvature, which both de- pend on the total density parameter Ω. The dash-dotted line in Fig. 2 demonstrates the shift in the visible location of the dip for an open model. What is the physical origin of the dip in the correla- tion function at the acoustic contact? According to our earlier discussion, ∆(3) eff /∂r, which contains the derivative of a delta function. When con- volved with the primordial potential field φ0, δ′(r − S) relates ∆T (r) to the gradient of φ0(r). The vectorial na- eff (r) = −(2πr)−1∂∆(1) 3 ture of ∇φ0 results in contributions of opposite signs to the temperature of two points located at distance S in opposite directions. For θ < A larger primordial power spectrum ns leads to a greater magnitude of all small-scale features in the cor- relation function. In the instantaneous recombination approximation, C(θ) − C(θs) varies as ∆s/(1 − ns) for ns < 1 and ∆s/∆sns−1 for ns > 1. Thus, the dip at θ = θs is enhanced for ns > 1 and suppressed for ns < 1. ∼ θs/2 the correlation function slope becomes sensitive to the baryon density Ωb. This can be seen from comparing the dashed and the solid lines in Fig. 2. At such a small angular separation, the Doppler and ISW ef- fects provide significant contribution to the temperature correlation. Nevertheless, the Ωb dependence is largely determined by the same intrinsic plus gravitational red- shift contributions shown in Fig. 1. It is the interference of the baryon induced "gully" in the middle of one of the transfer functions in eq. (4) and the delta function con- tributions of the other that causes the steeper C(θ) rise at θ < ∼ θs/2. The effect is almost linearly proportional to Ωbh2 and may be useful for measuring the baryon density value using CMB data. The finite extent of the position-space Green's func- tions results in oscillations in their Fourier transforms, the k-space transfer functions. These oscillations appear as the famous acoustic peaks in the CMB angular spec- trum Cl . The characteristic period of the oscillations is ∆l = πR/S ≃ 300 for Ωm = 0.35, ΩΛ = 0.65, and h = 0.65. The wavefront and x = 0 Green's function singularities in Fig. 1 do not map directly to a particular distinct feature in Cl spectrum because they are com- pletely delocalized by Fourier transformation. An interesting connection between features in C(θ) and the acoustic peaks in Cl is established by artificially cut- ting out the dip in C(θ) and replacing it by a smooth interpolation with no local minimum as shown by the dotted line in Fig. 2. Fig. 3. shows that this operation 8 6 4 bh2= 0.03 ΛCDM , Ω same, dip cut out ΛCDM , Ω bh2= 0.02 2 K 9 − 0 1 , π 2 / l 2 C ) 1 + l ( l 0 0 500 1000 l 1500 2000 FIG. 3. Angular power spectra for the ΛCDM models of Fig. 2. The dotted line gives Cl corresponding to the correla- tion function of the first model with the dip cut out. [1] L. Knox and L. Page, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 1366 (2000). [2] A. H. Jaffe et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3475 (2001). [3] M. Tegmark and M. Zaldarriaga, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2240 (2000); M. Tegmark, M. Zaldarriaga, and A. J. Hamilton, Phys. Rev. D 63, 043007 (2001). [4] W. Hu et al., Astrophys. J. 549, 669 (2001). [5] S. Dodelson and L. Knox, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 3523 (2000). [6] N. Bahcall et al., Science 284, 1481 (1999). [7] J. R. Bond, G. Efstathiou, and M. Tegmark, MNRAS 291, L33 (1997). [8] W. Hu, N. Sugiyama, and J. Silk, Nature 386, 37 (1997). [9] W. Hu and M. White, Astrophys. J. 471, 30 (1996). [10] W. Hu and N. Sugiyama, Astrophys. J. 444, 489 (1995). [11] M. White, D. Scott, and J. Silk, Ann. Rev. Astron. As- trophys. 32, 319 (1994). [12] U. Seljak and M. Zaldarriaga, Astrophys. J. 469, 437 (1996). [13] A. Lewis, A. Challinor, and A. Lasenby, Astrophys. J. 538, 473 (2000). [14] P. de Bernardis et al., Nature (London) 404, 955 (2000). [15] S. Hanany et al., Astrophys. J Letters, 545, 5 (2000). [16] J. M. Bardeen, Phys. Rev. D22, 1882 (1980). [17] H. Kodama and M. Sasaki, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 78, 1 (1984), Int. J. Mod. Phys. A2, 491 (1987). [18] V. F. Mukhanov, H. A. Feldman, and R. H. Branden- berger, Phys. Rept. 215, 203 (1992). [19] C. Ma and E. Bertschinger, Astrophys. J. 455, 7 (1995). [20] U. Seljak, Astrophys. J. Lett. 435, L87 (1994). [21] W. Hu et al., Phys. Rev. D52, 5498 (1995). [22] S. Bashinsky and E. Bertschinger (to be published). [23] J. Silk, Astrophys. J. 151, 459 (1968). [24] A. A. Starobinskii, Sov. Astron. Lett. 14 3, 166 (1988). [25] H. E. Jorgensen et al., Astron. Astrophys. 294, 639 (1995). [26] I. Szapudi et al., Astrophys. J. 548, L115 (2001). [27] U. Seljak and E. Bertschinger, Astrophys. J. Lett. 417, L9 (1993). eliminates all the acoustic peaks besides the first one. The first peak is closely connected with the sharp rise in C(θ) at θ < θs. Increasing the baryon density we increase the magnitude of the slope of C(θ). The magni- tude of the first peak grows accordingly (dashed vs. solid lines in Fig. 3) leading to the known [10] reduction in the ratio of second to first acoustic peaks. In conclusion, the Green's function method provides a promising alternative to the conventional Fourier analysis of perturbations in the early universe. It offers new ana- lytical methods and intuition for the familiar phenomena such as the acoustic oscillations and the dependence of peak ratios on Ωbh2. It also reveals new features that are localized and easily noticeable in position space but which were stretched over a multitude of wavenumbers in the Fourier domain. In particular, the singularities of the Green's functions lead to potentially measurable features in the CMB angular correlation function. Transfer functions are computed faster in position space than in Fourier space because the integration effort is concentrated within compact regions of space interior to the acoustic horizon. Computation of ∆(1) eff (x, τrec) in Fig. 1 takes less than one second for 0.01% numerical ac- curacy on a PC. We are working to extend the method to integration of the Boltzmann equation for free-streaming neutrinos and for photons after recombination. Experimental data are collected in position space. As we have attempted to demonstrate, position space is also more appropriate for describing the acoustic dynamics of CMB radiation. It may thus seem natural to remain in position space when comparing observational results with theoretical predictions. The utility of the correla- tion function C(θ) for data analysis has been recently considered by Szapudi et al. [26]. Data analysis using the correlation function is complicated by the covariance of observational estimates of C(θ) [27]. Such correlations are eliminated for estimates of Cl made with uniformly- sampled all-sky maps. Nonetheless, the correlation func- tion may still be a valuable experimental tool because it concentrates much of the cosmologically essential in- formation into localized features. This may enable data processing efforts, and observing strategy, to be focused on the most relevant angular features. We thank J. Bond, K. Burgess, D. Pogosyan, and A. Shirokov for helpful discussion and gratefully acknowl- edge the hospitality of CITA where part of this work was performed. We thank an anonymous referee for the sug- gestion to consider ns variation. Support was provided by NSF grant AST-9803137 and by the U. S. Depart- ment of Energy under cooperative research agreement DF-FC02-94ER40818. 4
astro-ph/0408235	1	0408	2004-08-12T17:12:50	Disruption time scales of star clusters in different galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	The observed average lifetime of the population of star clusters in the Solar Neighbourhood, the Small Magellanic Cloud and in selected regions of M51 and M33 is compared with simple theoretical predictions and with the results of N-body simulations. The empirically derived lifetimes (or disruption times) of star clusters depend on their initial mass as t_dis ~ Mcl^0.60 in all four galaxies. N-body simulations have shown that the predicted disruption time of clusters in a tidal field scales as t_dis^pred ~ t_rh^0.75 t_cr^0.25, where t_rh is the initial half-mass relaxation time and t_cr is the crossing time for a cluster in equilibrium. We show that this can be approximated accurately by t_dis^pred ~ M_cl^0.62 for clusters in the mass range of about 10^3 to 10^6 M_sun, in excellent agreement with the observations. Observations of clusters in different extragalactic environments show that t_dis also depends on the ambient density in the galaxies where the clusters reside. Linear analysis predicts that the disruption time will depend on the ambient density of the cluster environment as t_dis ~ rho_amb^-0.5. This relation is consistent with N-body simulations.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. 1476 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) July 26, 2018 Disruption time scales of star clusters in different galaxies Henny J.G.L.M. Lamers1 , 2, Mark Gieles1 and Simon F. Portegies Zwart3 , 4 1 Astronomical Institute, Utrecht University, Princetonplein 5, NL-3584CC Utrecht, the Netherlands [email protected], [email protected] 2 SRON Laboratory for Space Research, Sorbonnelaan 2, NL-3584CC, Utrecht, the Netherlands 3 Astronomical Institute, University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, NL-1098SJ, Amsterdam, the Netherlands [email protected] 4 Informatics Institute, University of Amsterdam, Kruislaan 403, NL-1098SJ, Amsterdam, the Netherlands Received date ; accepted date pred ∝ t0.75 rh t0.25 cr cl emp ∝ Mcl pred ∝ M 0.62 Abstract. The observed average lifetime of the population of star clusters in the Solar Neighbourhood, the Small Magellanic Cloud and in selected regions of M51 and M33 is compared with simple theoretical predictions and with the results of N -body simulations. The empirically derived lifetimes (or disruption times) of star clusters 0.60 in all four galaxies. N -body simulations have shown that the depend on their initial mass as tdis predicted disruption time of clusters in a tidal field scales as tdis , where trh is the initial half-mass relaxation time and tcr is the crossing time for a cluster in equilibrium. We show that this can be approximated for clusters in the mass range of about 103 to 106 M⊙, in excellent agreement with accurately by tdis the observations. Observations of clusters in different extragalactic environments show that tdis also depends on the ambient density in the galaxies where the clusters reside. Linear analysis predicts that the disruption time will depend on the ambient density of the cluster environment as tdis ∝ ρ−1/2 amb . This relation is consistent with N -body simulations. The empirically derived disruption times of clusters in the Solar Neighbourhood, in the SMC and in M33 agree with these predictions. The best fitting expression for the disruption time is tdis = Cenv(Mcl/104M⊙)0.62(ρamb/M⊙pc−3)−0.5 where Mcl is the initial mass of the cluster and Cenv ≃ 300 − 800 Myr. The disruption times of star clusters in M51 within 1 - 5 kpc from the nucleus, is shorter than predicted by about an order of magnitude. This discrepancy might be due to the strong tidal field variations in M51, caused by the strong density contrast between the spiral arms and interarm regions, or to the disruptive forces from giant molecular clouds. Key words. Galaxy: open clusters -- Galaxy: solar neighborhood -- Galaxies: individual: M33 -- Galaxies: individual: M51 -- Galaxies: individual: SMC -- Galaxies: star clusters -- 1. Introduction The age distribution of star clusters in the disk of the Milky Way, can only be explained if galactic clusters dis- rupt on a time scale on the order of a few times 108 years (Oort 1957; Wielen 1971, 1988). Clusters in the LMC and SMC survive longer than those in the solar neighborhood (e.g. Elson & Fall 1985,1988; Hodge 1987). The disruption time of clusters is expected to depend on both the internal cluster conditions, such as the initial mass, density and velocity dispersion and the stellar initial mass function (IMF), and on the external conditions, such as the orbit in the galaxy and tidal heating by encoun- ters with for example giant molecular clouds. Recently, Boutloukos & Lamers (2003, hereafter called BL03) have derived an empirical expression for the disruption time of clusters as a function of their initial mass in selected Send offprint requests to: H. J. G. L. M. Lamers regions in four galaxies. They found large differences in the disruption times between these regions. This allows a crucial test of the theoretical disruption times of clusters predicted with N -body simulations. The purpose of this paper is three-fold: (a) to explain the empirical dependence of the cluster dis- ruption times on cluster mass; (b) to explain the strong dependence, found by BL03 of the disruption time on the conditions in the host galaxies; (c) to confront the predicted disruption theory with the empirically derived disruption relations. In Sect. 2 we describe the predicted dependence of the disruption times of star clusters on their initial mass and on their environment. In Sect. 3 we review the method used for the determination of the disruption times based on a statistical analysis of large cluster samples and the re- sulting expressions for the disruption times in four galax- ies. In Sect. 4 we discuss the observed dependence of the 2 H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies disruption times on the environment of the clusters in their host galaxies and we compare it with the predictions. We discuss the peculiar case of the clusters in M51. The con- clusions are in Sect 5. 2. The predicted dependence of the disruption time on cluster parameters and environment The evolution of an isolated star cluster is characterized by three distinct phases: (1) infant mortality (the dissolution of unbound clusters) within about 10 Myr (Bastian et al. 2004; Whitmore 2004), (2) stellar evolution dominates the cluster mass loss in the first ∼ 108 years (see Takahashi & Portegies Zwart 2000) followed by (3) a relaxation domi- nated phase in which the cluster mass loss is driven by its internal dynamical evolution and the external influence of the tidal field of the host galaxy. If the cluster survives the first two phases, its lifetime will be dominated by the third phase as it generally lasts much longer, until complete dis- solution. During this episode mass loss is about constant with time and appears to depend weakly on the density profile of the cluster (Spitzer 1987; Portegies Zwart et al. 2001b, but see Portegies Zwart et al. 1998, for some com- plications near the end of the lifetime of the star cluster). During the third phase there are two important effects which drive the cluster dissolution. These are internal two- body relaxation and the interaction between the cluster and the tidal field of the host Galaxy. Internal two-body relaxation drives the cluster evapo- ration on a very long time scale of many initial half-mass relaxation times (Baumgardt et al. 2002). The half-mass relaxation time scale can be written as (Spitzer 1958): trh = 0.138 N 1/2r3/2 hm hmi1/2G1/2 ln Λ ∝ 3 N ln Λ (cid:18) rhm GMcl(cid:19)1/2 (1) where N is the initial number of stars in the clusters, hmi = Mcl/N is the mean mass of the stars and rhm is the half-mass radius. The Coulomb logarithm Λ is ap- proximately proportional to N (see Gierz & Heggie 1996; Spinnato et al. 2003). The mass loss rate for clusters in a tidal field is much higher and the lifetime shorter than for clusters in isola- tion. Baumgardt (2001) found that for clusters in a tidal field the disruption time depends not only on the relax- ation time but also on the crossing time tcr because, due to their circulation within the cluster, stars with sufficient energy still need a considerable time to reach the outskirts of the cluster from where they can escape. He showed that the disruption time can be approximated as Baumgardt (2001) showed on theoretical arguments that x is expected to be about 3/4. A more accurate esti- mate of the value of 0 < x < 1 can be found empirically from N -body simulations (see below). Combining Eqs. 1, 2 and 3 an expression for the disruption time can be derived of the form tdis = C(cid:20) N ln (γN )(cid:21)x(cid:20) rhm GMcl(cid:21)1/2 3 (4) where we replaced Λ with γN , with 0.01 < γ < 0.4. Baumgardt & Makino (2003, hereafter BM03) have performed an extensive set of simulations of clusters in the Galactic halo tidal field and fitted the results to find the constant C and the value of x in the approximation of Eq. 4. They used a logarithmic potential of the form φ(RG) = V 2 G ln(RG), where RG is the distance to the galactic center and VG is the circular velocity. Their clus- ters started with a tidal radius equal to the tidal radius of the external field, rt = (cid:18) GMcl 2V 2 G (cid:19)1/3 R2/3 G (5) If we assume the tidal radius scales linearly with the half- mass radius, which holds for clusters with the same density profile, Eq. 5 can be combined with Eq. 4, which yields tdis Myr = β(cid:20) N ln (γN )(cid:21)x RG kpc (cid:18) VG 220 km s−1(cid:19)−1 (6) where β is a constant whose value can be found empiri- cally. BM03 fitted this relation to the results of their simu- lations of clusters at different distances from the Galactic center. For clusters that initially followed a King (1966) profile with central concentration W0 = 5.0 they found β = 1.91 and x = 0.75. For clusters with W0 = 7.0 they found β = 1.03 and x = 0.82. For γ a value of 0.02 was adopted. We found that the factor β{N/ ln(0.02N )}x in Eq. 6 for both combinations of β and x can be approxi- mated by a power law 1.95N 0.62 with high accuracy. This is illustrated in Fig. 1. The density of the clusters depends on the ambient density which depends on the adopted potential field. The ambient density, for the potential field adopted in the study by BM03 can be found by applying Poisson's law which gives ρamb = 1 4πG (cid:18) VG RG(cid:19)2 (7) tdis ≃ tx rh t1−x cr where the crossing time for a cluster in equilibrium is tcr ∝ r3/2 hm /pGMcl. and so tcr ∝ trh ln Λ/N . (2) (3) Combining this with Eq. 6, and assuming an initial mean stellar mass of hmi = 0.54M⊙, as done by BM03 based on the stellar IMF of Kroupa (2001), we can write the disruption time as a function of cluster mass and local ambient density: tdis ≃ 810 (cid:18) Mcl 104 M⊙(cid:19)0.62 ρ−1/2 amb Myr (8) H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies 3 equals the Jacobi radius of the star cluster in the tidal field of the Galaxy (see e.g. Binney & Tremaine 1994). This predicts that the constant in Eq. (8) is about 330 Myr. This is 0.4 times as small as the value derived from the models by BM03 . The line passes through the data of the individual models of Portegies Zwart et al. (1998, 2002). The simulations by Portegies Zwart et al. (1998, 2002) result in shorter disruption times than the simulations by BM03, by about a factor of 2.5. This difference can be ex- plained by variations in the initial conditions and between the two codes. The initial mass function used in Portegies Zwart et al. (2002) is taken from Scalo (1986) and has a mean stellar mass of hmi ≃ 0.7M⊙. BM03 adopted the initial mass function of Kroupa (2001), which has a mean stellar mass of 0.54 M⊙. Portegies Zwart et al. (1998) and BM03 use King (1966) models for the initial density dis- tribution, whereas Portegies Zwart et al (2002) adopt self consistent Heggie & Ramamani (1995) models. But also the stellar evolution in the calculations are slightly dif- ferent: the stellar evolution in BM03 is based on Pols et al. (1998) whereas the calculations of Portegies Zwart et al. use the stellar evolution predicted by Eggleton et al. (1989). Moreover, the end of the cluster lifetime is defined differently in the various calculations: BM03 and Portegies Zwart et al. (2002) uses the time when 5 percent of the initial mass remains, whereas Portegies Zwart et al. (1998) use the time when 10 percent of the initial mass remains. The most important difference, however, is in the treat- ments of the tidal field and the way stars escape from the cluster. Portegies Zwart et al. (1998) did not include a full tidal potential, but a simple cut-off radius. This easily leads to a shorter disruption time for the cluster. BM03 and Portegies Zwart et al (2002), on the other hand adopt a self-consistent tidal field up to the quadrupole moment.2 A few notes about these estimate: (a) The constant of expression (8) was derived for clusters moving in circular orbits in the Galactic potential field. Clusters in elliptical or inclined orbits will experience disk or bulge shocking that reduces their lifetime (Spitzer 1987, Zhang & Fall 1999; BM03). However the propor- tionality with mass and density remains the same. (b) Encounters with giant molecular clouds (GMCs) or spiral density waves are not included in these calculations. In situations where these effects are likely to occur, e.g. for clusters in orbits in a galactic plane, the constant will be smaller than estimated above. Based on these considerations we can expect the fol- lowing expression for the disruption times of star clusters 2 In an extensive collaborative experiment Heggie et al. (1998) perform a detailed comparison between the N-body codes used by Portegies Zwart and Baumgardt (and others). The difference in cluster lifetime is between 20 and 40%. (see http://www.maths.ed.ac.uk/∼douglas/experiment.html) Fig. 1. The function β{N/ ln(0.02N )}x of equation 6 for the two combinations of β and x for clusters with W0 = 5 (solid line) and 7 (dashed) from BM03 and the power law approximation 1.95 N 0.617 (dots). with Mcl in units of M⊙ and ρamb in M⊙pc−3. The con- stant indicates the time when 95 per cent of the initial cluster mass is lost. If the initial mean stellar mass is 0.70 M⊙, predicted by the stellar IMF from Scalo (1986), the constant decreases from 810 to 690. (For clusters in el- liptical orbits with ellipticity ǫ moving within a logarith- mic potential field the disruption time is shorter by factor 1 − ǫ, if ρamb is the density at the apogalactic radius.) The positive exponent 0.62 indicates that the disruption time increases with mass, as expected. The results of N -body simulations and their predicted dependence on the ambient density are plotted in Fig. 2. These are based on N -body simulations of clusters of 104 M⊙ from different authors. These simulations are from Portegies Zwart et al. (1998; 2002), and BM03 . All simula- tions were performed with NBODY4 (Aarseth 1999; BM03) and the Starlab (Portegies Zwart et al. 2001a)1 software environment with both codes running on the GRAPE fam- ily of special purpose computers (Makino 2003). The mod- els by Portegies Zwart et al. (2002) were calculated for star clusters near the Galactic center, i.e. they are representa- tive for a high density ambient medium. The dashed line shown in this figure represents the mean relation derived by BM03 and described by Eq. (8). This line passes through the data of their individual mod- els. The full line is the mean relation predicted by Portegies Zwart et al. (2001b). It is derived from the argument that the lifetime of a cluster will depend on the two-body re- laxation time near the tidal radius as tdis ≃ 0.3trt. The tidal radius can be obtained from Eq. 5, but the required average cluster density ρcl is not readily available from the observations. Since the cluster is in equilibrium with its en- vironment one can estimate ρcl/ρamb ≃ 3 for a standard Roche-solution by assuming that the clusters follow a King (1966) model and that the tidal radius of the King model 1 see also http://www.manybody.org 4 H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies initial stellar IMF. Then, the values of γ and t4 can be derived from the mass and age histograms of cluster sam- ples with a well determined brightness limit. Boutloukos & Lamers (BL03) have applied this method for an empirical determination of γ and t4 in specific regions of M51, M33, (observed with HST − W F P C2) and in the SMC and the solar neighbourhood. The method has been improved by Lamers (2004) and by Gieles et al. (2004c), who showed that the distribution of the observed clusters in a mass versus-age-diagram provides a more powerful method for deriving t4 and γ than the mass and age histograms sep- arately. The results are given in Table 1. Column 2 gives the range of galactocentric distances of the cluster sample. Columns 3, 4 and 5 give the number of clusters and their age and mass range. Columns 6 and 7 give the resulting values of the disruption time t4 and γ. Column 8 gives the ambient density of the host galaxy at the location of the cluster samples used for the determination of the disruption time (see Sect. 4). In the determination of γ we adopted a cluster IMF with α = 2.0 (Zhang & Fall 1999, Bik et al. 2002, de Grijs et al. 2003). The values of t4 and γ of the SMC is from BL03. The values for M51 have been redetermined by Gieles et al. (2004c) on the basis of the extended cluster sample of Bastian et al. (2004) and the improved method mentioned above. The values for M33 have been redeter- mined by Lamers et al. (2004b), on the basis of the ex- tended cluster sample by Chandar et al. (2001, 2002). The new value of t4 for this galaxy is considerably higher than originally derived by BL03, due to the largely improved cluster sample and a redetermination of the cluster ages. The values for the Solar neighbourhood have been rede- termined by Lamers et al. (2004b), based on the clusters sample by Loktin et al. (1994). Notice that the values of γ of the four galaxies are the same, within the uncertainty, but the values of t4 differ strongly. The mean value of the empirically determined value of γ and its uncertainty is hγempi = 0.60 ± 0.02. (11) where 0.02 is the uncertainty in the mean value, which is much smaller than the uncertainty in the individual mea- surements. This exponent agrees very well with γpred = 0.62 predicted by BM03, Eq. 8, on the basis of their nu- merical simulations. The agreement between the observed and the predicted value of γ was first pointed out by Gieles et al. (2004d), but based on slightly different theoretical arguments. Fig. 2. The predicted dependence of the disruption time, t4, of clusters of initial mass of 104 M⊙ on the mean am- bient density, ρamb. The symbols refer to N -body simula- tions; filled squares are from Portegies Zwart et al. (1998, from left to right models IR16, IC16 and FH16), filled tri- angles are calculations for star clusters near the Galactic center from Portegies Zwart et al (2002, from left to right models R150W4, R90W4 and R34W4). The open circles represent models from BM03 (from left to right models V, I, II and IV with 16384 stars). The dashed line is the relation predicted by BM03, Eq. 8, and the full line is the relation predicted by Portegies Zwart et al. due to tidal interactions in different extragalactic environ- ments tdis = Cenv (cid:18) Mcl 104 M⊙(cid:19)0.62 (cid:18) ρamb M⊙ pc−3(cid:19)−1/2 (9) where Cenv ≃ 300 − 800 Myr. If encounters with giant molecular clouds or disk shocking (for clusters in orbits tilted with respect to the galactic plane) becomes impor- tant, the disruption times might be shorter than given by Eq. (9). 3. The empirically determined disruption times The disruption times of systems of star clusters in dif- ferent extragalactic environments have been determined statistically by BL03 from samples of star clusters in four galaxies. We will summarize their method and results. Suppose that the disruption times of clusters in some region of a galaxy can be written as tdis = t4 × (Mcl/104)γ (10) 4. The dependence of the disruption time on the where Mcl is the initial cluster mass (in M⊙) and t4 is the disruption time (in yrs) of a cluster with an initial mass of Mcl = 104 M⊙. Assume also that the cluster forma- tion rate is constant over the period of time for which t4 and γ are determined, and that all clusters had the same conditions in the host galaxy Table 1 shows that the constant t4, which is the disruption time of a clusters of Mcl = 104M⊙, differs greatly between the regions in the galaxies that were studied. This indi- cates that the disruption time depends strongly on the H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies 5 Table 1. The parameters of the disruption time: tdis = t4 × (Mcl/104)γ Galaxy rGal kpc Nr clusters Age range Mass range log (yrs) log M⊙ log t4 log (yrs)a γ log ρamb M⊙ pc−3 Remark M51 M33 Galaxy (d ≤ 1kpc) SMC 1.0 - 5.0 0.8 - 5.0 7.5 - 9.5 0 - 4 1152 147 184 314 6.3 -- 9.0 6.5 -- 10.0 7.2 -- 9.5 7.6 -- 10.0 2.6 -- 5.6 3.6 -- 5.6 -- -- 7.85 ± 0.22 (7.6) 8.80 ± 0.20 (8.1) 8.75 ± 0.20 (9.0) 9.90 ± 0.20 (9.9) Mean 0.57 ± 0.10 −0.70 ± 0.30 0.60 ± 0.15 −0.66 ± 0.30 0.60 ± 0.12 −1.00 ± 0.04 0.61 ± 0.08 −2.10 ± 0.30 0.60 ± 0.02 2 3 1,4 1 5 (a) The value in parenthesis is the original value from BL03 (1) t4 and γ from age distribution only (2) Improved determination of t4 and γ by Gieles et al. (2004c), based on new cluster sample of Bastian et al. (2004) (3) Improved determination of t4 and γ by Lamers et al. (2004b) based on extended cluster samples by Chandar et al.(2001, 2002) (4) Improved determination by Lamers et al. (2004a) based on cluster sample of Loktin et al. (1994) (5) The quoted error is the uncertainty in the mean value local conditions in the host galaxy. In Sect. (2) we have shown that t4 is expected to scale with the inverse square- root of the mean density in the host galaxy, if evolutionary mass loss, relaxation driven evaporation and tidal strip- ping are the dominant mass loss mechanism for clusters. In this section we compare this predicted dependence with the empirically derived values of the disruption time t4. 4.1. The ambient density in the host galaxies We estimate the ambient density ρamb at the galacto- centric distances of the observed environments for which BL03, Gieles et al. (2004c) and Lamers et al. (2004b) de- termined the value of t4. M51: The clusters are at galactocentric distances of 1 to 5 kpc. The column density of M51 decreases exponentially as σ = 540 exp(−r/4.65) M⊙ pc−2, with r in kpc (Salo & Laurakainen 2000). The total disk mass within a ring of 1 to 5 kpc is 2.0 × 1010 M⊙ and the mean surface density in that annulus is 2.6 × 102 M⊙ pc−2. Van der Kruit (2002) has shown that spiral galaxies have a vertical scale-height of 1/7 times the radial scale-length. This implies a value of hz = 0.66 kpc and a mean mid-plane density between 1 and 5 kpc of 0.20 M⊙ pc−3. The structural parameters of M51 derived by Athanassoula et al. (1987) result in a very similar estimate of the mid-plane density. M33: The sample of clusters is located at galactocentric dis- tances between 1 and 5 kpc. More than 90 percent of the clusters are between 1 and 4 kpc. The column density of M33 decreases exponentially as σ = 525 exp(−r/1.45) M⊙ pc−2, with r in kpc (Athanassoula et al. 1987). The total disk mass within a ring of 1 to 4 kpc is 4.2 × 109 M⊙ and the mean surface density is 90 M⊙ pc−2. Adopting an effective thickness of the disk of 1/7 of the radial scale- length, i.e. 0.21 kpc, we find a mean mid-plane density of 0.22 M⊙ pc−3. Solar Neighborhood: The mean gas and stellar density in the solar neighbor- hood, derived from Hipparcos data is 0.10 ± 0.01 M⊙ pc−3 (Holmberg & Flynn 2000). SMC: The sample of clusters is distributed throughout the SMC. With a total mass of about 2×109 M⊙ (Mathewson & Ford 1984) and a radius of the central core of 4 kpc (Caldwell & Laney 1991) we find a mean density of 8 × 10−3 M⊙ pc−3. The ambient densities are listed in Table 1, where we have adopted an uncertainty of a factor 2 in the densities, except for the solar neighbourhood. The relation between t4 and the ambient densities is shown in Figure 3. The figure shows a clear trend of decreasing disruption time with increasing ambient density. 4.2. Comparison between observed and predicted disruption time scales We compare the observed values of t4 for the different galaxies with the predictions based on N -body simula- tions, discussed in Sect.2. These simulations were done for clusters in Galactic environments. However, by using the expected scaling laws (Sect. 2), we can apply the re- sults of these simulations to the conditions in the galaxies where the cluster disruption times were measured. In Fig. 4 we compare the observed relation between t4 and ρamb with the predicted mean relations derived from N -body simulations of clusters of 104 M⊙ from Portegies Zwart (1998, 2002) and BM03, shown in Fig. 2. The empirically derived values of t4 roughly follow the relations predicted by the N -body simulations within the uncertainty of the data, except for the clusters in M51, whose disruption time is almost an order of magnitude shorter than expected. There are several possible explanations for the short cluster lifetimes in M51, some of which originate from variations in the birth conditions of the clusters or from 6 H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies controversial, but is suggested in young star clusters like MGG-11 (McCrady et al. 2003) and MGG-F, both in M82 (Smith and Gallagher 2001) and in several of the young star clusters in the Antennae galaxies (Mengel et al. 2002). Since M51 experienced a recent star formation event, about 60 Myr ago (Bastian et al. 2004), possibly part of the discrepancy can be explained by variations in the IMF. (This starburst event was taken into account in the deter- mination of the disruption time for M51 by Gieles et al. 2004b). Young star formation environments also tend to have higher metalicity, which drives stronger winds and therefore more stellar mass loss. Another possible expla- nation for the short disruption time of clusters in M51 is related to the strength of the tidal field variations. M51 has the highest density contrast between the arm and in- terarm regions of any spiral galaxy (Rix & Rieke 1993), so the tidal field variations experienced by star clusters will be higher than normal, which might explain the short disruption time of the star clusters in M51. This last effect is studied by Gieles et al. (2004a). 5. Conclusions We analyzed the disruption time of star clusters in the Solar Neighbourhood, the SMC and in selected regions of M33 and M51. We find the following result. (a) Within each region, there is a clear relation between the empirically derived cluster disruption time and the cluster mass of the type tdis ∝ M γ. The mean empirical value of γemp = 0.60 ± 0.02 agrees very well with the pre- dicted value of γpred = 0.62, derived from direct N -body simulations of galactic star clusters. (b) Comparing the disruption times in different galaxies, we find that the disruption time depends on the ambient density in the environment where the clusters reside. N - body simulations of clusters at different galactocentric dis- tances predict that the disruption time decreases with the −0.5. The empirical values ambient density as tdis ∝ ρamb of three galaxies, SMC, M33 and the Solar neighbourhood agree roughly with this prediction. However, the disrup- tion time of star clusters in the inner 4 kpc of M51 is shorter than predicted by about an order of magnitude. The difference is most likely due to large tidal field varia- tions, due to the high density contrast in the spiral arms and interarm regions of M51, or due the starburst trig- gered by the last encounter with its companion NGC 5195. The disruption time of star clusters of initial mass Mcl in circular orbits in an environment with a mean ambient density ρamb is given by Eq. (9). The disruption time may be shorter in starburst regions. Acknowledgements. We thank Nate Bastian for discussions and comments on the manuscript, Albert Bosma and Piet van der Kruit for advice on the densities of spiral galaxies and Holger Baumgardt for providing the results of his numerical simulations. We are grateful to the referee, Douglas Heggie, for constructive suggestions that improved the paper. This work was supported by a grant from the Netherlands Research School for Astronomy (NOVA) to HJGLML and by a grant Fig. 3. The relation between the measured values of the disruption time t4 of clusters with an initial mass of 104 M⊙ and the mean ambient density ρamb in M⊙ pc−3, of the galaxies at the galactocentric distances where the studied clusters were located. Fig. 4. Comparison between the observed (large dots) and predicted (lines) disruption time t4 of clusters with an ini- tial mass of 104 M⊙ as a function of the mean density ρamb in M⊙ pc−3 of the host galaxy. The solid curve present the predictions by Portegies Zwart et al. (1998, 2002) and the dashed line by BM03 . star formation histories of the host galaxy. For example, the constant used in Eq. (9) depends via hmi, quite sen- sitively on the adopted initial mass function. If we adopt a Salpeter (1955) initial mass function with a lower mass limit of 1 M⊙, instead of 0.1 M⊙, the mean stellar mass increases by about an order of magnitude. Such dramatic change to the initial mass function results via Eqs. (4) in a reduction of the cluster lifetime by about a factor 3. Such a lower mass cut-off for the initial mass function is H.J.G.L.M. Lamers et al.: Disruption of star clusters in different galaxies 7 McCrady, N., Gilbert, A.M., & Graham, J.R. 2003, ApJ, 596, 240 Mengel, S., Lehnert, M.D., Thatte, N., & Genzel, R. 2002, A&A, 383, 137 Oort, J.H. 1957, in Stellar populations, (Rome: Pontifical Academy of Science) discussion in Session on star clusters Pols, O.R., Schroder, K.P., Hurley, J.R., Tout, C.A., & Eggleton, P.P. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 525 Portegies Zwart, S.F., Hut, P., & Makino, J. 1998, A&A, 337, 363 Portegies Zwart, S.F., McMillan, S.L.W., Hut, P., & Makino, J. 2001a, MNRAS, 321, 199 Portegies Zwart, S.F., Makino, J., McMillan, S.L.W, & Hut, P. 2001b, ApJ, 546, L101 Portegies Zwart, S.F., Makino, J., McMillan, S.L.W, & Hut, P. 2002, ApJ, 565, 265 Rix, H., & Rieke, M.J. 1993, ApJ, 418, 123 Salpeter, E.E. 1955, ApJ, 121, 161 Salo, H., & Laurikainen, E. 2000, MNRAS, 319, 377 Scalo, J.M. 1986, Fund. of Cosm. Phys., 11, 1 Smith, L.J., & Gallagher, J.S. 2001, MNRAS, 326, 1027 Spinnato, P.F., Fellhauer, M., & Portegies Zwart, S.F. 2003, MNRAS, 344, 22 Spitzer, L.Jr 1958, ApJ, 127, 544 Spitzer, L.Jr 1987, in Dynamical evolution of globular clusters, (Princeton: Princeton University Press), p.191 Takahashi, K., & Portegies Zwart, S.F. 2000, ApJ, 535, 759 van der Kruit, P.C. 2002, in The dynamics, structure & history of galaxies, ed. G.S. Da Costa & H. Jerjen, ASP Conf. Proc., 273, p.7 Whitmore, B. 2004, in The formation and evolution of massive young star clusters, ed. H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, A. Nota, & L.J. Smith, ASP Conf. Ser., 322, 419 Wielen, R. 1971, A&A, 13, 309 Wielen, R. 1988, The Harow Shapley Symposium on Globular Cluster Systems in Galaxies, ed. J. Grindlay & A.G.D. Philip, (Dordrecht:Reidel) 393 Zhang, Q., & Fall, S.M. 1999, ApJ, 527, L81 from the Royal Netherlands Academy of Sciences (KNAW) to SPZ. References Aarseth, S.J. 1999, PASP, 111, 1333 Athanassoula, E., Bosma, A., & Papaioannou, S. 1987, A&A, 179, 23 Bastian, N., Gieles, M., Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., de Grijs, R., & Scheepmaker, R. 2004, A&A, (in press) Baumgardt, H. 2001, MNRAS, 325, 1323 Baumgardt, H., & Makino, J. 2003, MNRAS, 340, 227 (BM03) Baumgardt, H., Hut, P., & Heggie, D.C. 2002, MNRAS, 336, 1069 Bik, A., Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., Bastian, N., Panagia, N., & Romaniello, M. 2002, A&A, 397, 473 Binney, J., & Tremaine, S. 1994, Galactic Dynamics, (Princeton: Princeton University Press) Boutloukos, S.G., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2003, MNRAS, 338, 717 (BL03) Chandar, R., Bianchi, L., & Ford, H.C. 2001, A&A, 366, 498 Chandar, R., Bianchi, L., Ford, H.C. & Sarajedini, A. 2002, ApJ, 564, 712 Caldwell, J.A.R., & Laney, C.D. 1991, in The Magellanic Clouds, ed. R. Haynes & D. Milne, (Dordrecht: Kluwer), 249 de Grijs, R., Anders, P., Bastian, N., Lynds, R., Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., & O'Neil, E.J. 2003, MNRAS, 343, 1285 Eggleton, P.P., Fitchet, M., & Tout, C.A. 1989, ApJ, 347, 998 Elson, R.A.W., & Fall, S.M. 1985, ApJ, 299, 211 Elson, R.A.W., & Fall, S.M. 1988, AJ, 96, 1383 Gieles, M., Athanassoula, E., & Portegies Zwart, S.F. 2004a, (in preparation) Gieles, M., Bastian, N., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2004b, in The formation and evolution of massive young star clusters, ed. H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, A. Nota, & L.J. Smith, ASP Conf. Ser., 322, 479 Gieles, M., Bastian, N., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2004c, (in preparation) Gieles, M., Baumgardt, H., Bastian, N., & Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2004d, in The formation and evolution of massive young star clusters, ed. H.J.G.L.M. Lamers, A. Nota, & L.J. Smith, ASP Conf. Ser., 322, 481 Giersz, M., & Heggie, D.C. 1996, MNRAS, 279, 1037 Heggie, D.C., & Ramamani, N. 1995, MNRAS, 272, 317 Heggie, D.C., Giersz, M., Spurzem, R., & Takahashi, K., 1998, Highlights in Astronomy, 11, 591 Hodge, P. 1987, PASP, 99, 742 Holmberg, J., & Flynn, C. 2000, MNRAS, 313, 209 King, I.R., 1966, AJ, 71, 64 Kroupa, P. 2001, MNRAS, 322, 231 Lamers, H.J.G.L.M. 2004, (in preparation) Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., Bastian, N., Gieles, M., & Baumgardt, H., 2004a, A&A (submitted) Lamers, H.J.G.L.M., Gieles, M., Seth, A. 2004b (in prepara- tion) Loktin, A.V., Matkin, N.V., & Gerasimenko, T.P. 1994, Astron. Astrophys. Trans., 4, 153 Makino, J. 2003, PASJ, 55, 1163 Mathewson, D.S., & Ford, V.L. 1984, in Structure and Evolution of the Magellanic Clouds, ed. S. van den Bergh & K.S. de Boer, (Dordrecht: Reidel) p. 125
astro-ph/9605118	1	9605	1996-05-20T13:19:10	The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies - constraints on starburst models	[ "astro-ph" ]	This paper presents an analysis of the correlation between the far-infrared (FIR) and the radio emission of starburst galaxies. Data for interacting galaxies, many of which are undergoing a starburst, and for normal galaxies have been analysed and compared in order to test for any influence of the star-formation activity on the ratio between the FIR and the radio emission at 2.4 GHz, $\q24$. No statistically significant indication for such an influence has been found: There is neither a significant difference between $\q24$ of the two samples nor a dependence of this ratio on the starburst strength. This observational fact is unexpected because of the different physical conditions and the short time-scale of the star-formation activity in a starburst. In order to interprete the observations the FIR and the radio emission during a starburst have been modeled. The following conclusions could be drawn from the observed constancy of $\q24$: A strong and fast ($\approx 10^7$ yr) increase of the magnetic field at the beginning of the starburst is required in order to maintain a constant $\q24$. Otherwise the strong Inverse Compton losses that are due to the intense radiation field in a starburst would lower the synchrotron emission drastically resulting in a value of $\q24$ significantly higher than the observed one. Furthermore, the time-scale of the variation of the star-formation rate has to be longer than some $10^7$ yr. For lower values the different time-scales of the FIR and the radio emission produce large fluctuations of $\q24$.	astro-ph	astro-ph	A&A manuscript no. (will be inserted by hand later) ⋆ Your thesaurus codes are: 03(11.13.2; 11.19.3; 13.09.1; 13.18.1) ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 8.10.2019 The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu Max-Planck-Institut fur Kernphysik, Postfach 10 35 80, D-69029 Heidelberg, Germany 6 9 9 1 y a M 0 2 1 v 8 1 1 5 0 6 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Received 30 January 1996/ Accepted 22 April 1996 Abstract. This paper presents an analysis of the correla- tion between the far-infrared (FIR) and the radio emission of starburst galaxies. Data for interacting galaxies, many of which are undergoing a starburst, and for normal galax- ies have been analysed and compared in order to test for any influence of the star-formation activity on the ratio be- tween the FIR and the radio emission at 2.4 GHz, q2.4GHz. No statistically significant indication for such an influence has been found: There is neither a significant difference between q2.4GHz of the two samples nor a dependence of this ratio on the starburst strength. This observational fact is unexpected because of the different physical condi- tions and the short time-scale of the star-formation activ- ity in a starburst. In order to interprete the observations the FIR and the radio emission during a starburst have been modeled. The following conclusions could be drawn from the observed constancy of q2.4GHz: A strong and fast (≈ 107 yr) increase of the magnetic field at the beginning of the starburst is required in order to maintain a constant q2.4GHz. Otherwise the strong Inverse Compton losses that are due to the intense radiation field in a starburst would lower the synchrotron emission drastically resulting in a value of q2.4GHz significantly higher than the observed one. Furthermore, the time-scale of the variation of the star- formation rate has to be longer than some 107 yr. For lower values the different time-scales of the FIR and the radio emission produce large fluctuations of q2.4GHz. Key words: Galaxies: starburst -- galaxies: magnetic fields -- infrared: galaxies -- radio continuum: galaxies 1. Introduction Starburst galaxies are found to follow the tight correla- tion between the far-infrared (FIR) and the radio emis- sion (Wunderlich et al. 1987; van den Driel et al. 1991; ⋆ Present address: Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, Largo E. Fermi 5, I-50125 Florence, Italy Send offprint requests to: H.J. Volk Franceschini et al. 1988a; Condon et al. 1991). Here, the correlation is even more unexpected than in normal galax- ies (see Lisenfeld et al. 1995 for a discussion of normal galaxies) because of the following reasons. In starburst galaxies the different time-scales involved in the produc- tion of the radio and the FIR emissions become impor- tant: Whereas the FIR emission and the thermal radio emission are instantaneously related to the stellar radia- tion, the synchrotron emission shows a time delay because it takes some 106 yr until the first supernovae (SNe) oc- cur, and some 107 yr till the maximum of SN activity is reached. These time-scales are comparable to the duration of starbursts of about 107 − 108 yr (Rieke et al. 1980; van den Broek et al. 1991; Bernlohr 1993) and should there- fore result in a time delay between the maximum emis- sion of the FIR and the radio emission. Furthermore, dur- ing a starburst the intensity of the radiation field changes with time in a significant way. Little is known about vari- ations of the magnetic field energy density. The ratio of these two parameters that determine the major radiative losses of the cosmic ray (CR) electrons (inverse Compton and synchrotron losses) is crucial for the total synchrotron emission of a galaxy. The aim of this paper is to understand why, in spite of the above considerations, the FIR/radio ratio is observed to be very constant in starburst galaxies, and, more im- portantly, to use this observational fact to find constraints for starburst models. The paper consists of two parts: In the first part (Sects. 2 and 3), we present data for two large samples of galaxies, a starburst sample and a con- trol sample, in order to investigate whether the FIR/radio ratio shows any dependence on the star-formation activ- ity. In the second part (Sects. 4-6) we present a model for the FIR and the radio emission in a starburst in order to interprete the observational results. Section 7 summarizes our conclusions. 2 U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models 2. The sample Both the sample of starburst galaxies and the control sam- ple are selected from the list of UGC galaxies which are surveyed with the Arecibo 300m telescope at 2.4 GHz (Dressel & Condon 1978) and were covered by IRAS in FIR . These galaxies form a complete sample (down to mB = 14.5) of a local galaxy population, which have been studied by Franceschini et al. (1988a,b) for the radio and FIR luminosity functions. It has been well established that non-Seyfert Markar- ian galaxies (Huchra 1977; Balzano 1983; Xu & De Zotti 1989; Mazzarella et al. 1991) and interacting galaxies (Lar- son & Tinsley 1978; Kennicutt et al. 1987; Telesco et al. 1988; Xu & Sulentic 1991) have on average significantly higher current star-formation rates than standard galax- ies like the Milky Way. Therefore we select these galaxies for our starburst galaxy sample. It includes those galaxies classified in the UGC catalog (Nilson 1973) as peculiars, double, trible, or multiple systems, and galaxies identi- fied by Markarian and collaborators as having ultraviolet excesses (see Mazzarella & Balzano 1986 for a review). Galaxies with active galactic nuclei (e.g. Seyfert galax- ies) are not considered. The region of low galactic latitude (b < 30◦) is avoided in order to minimize the influence of Galactic extinction. Virgo galaxies listed in the VCC cata- log (Binggeli et al. 1985) are excluded, because in clusters galaxies may have additional radio emission mechanisms other than the star-formation alone (Gavazzi et al. 1991; Volk & Xu 1994). There are 133 objects in the starburst galaxy sample. The control sample includes spiral galaxies which are at high Galactic latitude (b > 40◦), and from the mor- phological types Sa through Sd in the UGC catalog. The sample excludes Virgo cluster, Markarian, as well as Seyfert galaxies. Galaxies catagorized simply as 'S' are not included, because the probability that they are misclassi- fied early types is relatively high. There are 397 spirals in the control sample. For the majority of objects in both samples, fluxes at 60µm and 100µm are taken from the Second Version IRAS Point Source Catalog. The exceptions are those extended (size > 5′) and faint (f60µm < 0.6 Jy) sources listed in the catalog of IRAS Faint Source Survey (FSS) fluxes of CfA galaxies (Thuan & Sauvage, 1992), for which the data are taken from Thuan & Sauvage (1992). For 133 objects in the starburst sample, 113 are detected at both 60µm and 100µm, corresponding to a detection rate of 85%. For the control sample, 329 are detected out of 397 objects, i.e. a detection rate of 83%. The integrated flux in the wavelength range 42.5 -- 122.5 µm, SF IR , or its upper limit, is calculated from the IRAS fluxes (limits) accord- ing to Helou et al. (1988). Radio fluxes at 2.4 GHz are taken from the Arecibo survey data (Dressel & Condon 1978). Fourty-six objects in the starburst sample and 92 in the control sample are detected in radio, correspond- ing to detection rates of 35% and 23%, respectively. For an overwhelming majority of sources in our samples, the total "face-on" blue magnitude B0 T, corrected for Galactic extinction, inclination effect and for redshift, can be found in the Third Reference Catalog (RC3) (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991). For a few exceptionals whose B0 T are not avail- able, the blue magnitude is simply taken from the pho- tographic magnitude given in UGC and corrected for the Galactic extinction calculated using the formula given in RC3. Taking H0 = 75kms−1Mpc−1, the distances are cal- culated from the recession velocities after correcting for the Virgocentric flow (Aaronson et al. 1982). 3. Statistical results Fig. 1a. The FIR and the radio luminostities for the starburst sample. Upper limits are indicated by arrows. In the statistical analysis carried out in this section, we use the so called 'survival technique' (Schmitt 1985; Feigelson & Nelson 1985) to exploit the information car- ried by the upper limits. We plot in Figs. 1a and 1b the logarithms of the ra- dio intensities versus the logarithms of the FIR luminosi- ties for the starburst sample and for the control sample, respectively. The crosses are detected data, and the ar- rows denote the upper limits. Both samples show tight correlations between the FIR and the radio luminosities: the linear correlation coefficients are 0.90 and 0.88 for the starburst sample and the control sample, respectively. The slope of the log-log plot of the starburst sample is very close to unity: 0.98±0.01. On the other hand, the radio intensities increase slightly faster than the FIR luminosi- ties for the normal spiral galaxies in the control sample: U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models 3 Fig. 1b. The FIR and the radio luminostities for the control sample. Upper limits are indicated by arrows. Fig. 2. The logarithmic ratio of the FIR -- to -- radio luminostity, q2.4GHz, and the indicator of the starburst strength, SB, defined in Eq. 2, for the starburst sample the slope is equal to 1.09±0.01 in Fig. 1b. In both plots, no galaxy is detected to seriously violate the correlation. Similar to the q parameter defined by Helou et al. (1985), we introduce a parameter q2.4GHz: q2.4GHz = log[(SFIR/3.75 1012)/Sν(2.4GHz)] (1) For the starburst sample, the mean of the q2.4GHz is 2.40± 0.03, while for the control sample it is 2.52±0.02. The sta- tistical dispersion of the logarithm of the FIR/radio ratio, calculated using the survival technique, is σ = 0.22 for the starburst sample, and σ = 0.21 for the control sam- ple. Therefore, although the q2.4GHz value of the starburst sample is slightly lower than the control sample, the dif- ference is within the dispersion. An important question in this study is: does the FIR/radio ratio depend on the starburst strength? In prin- ciple, the starburst strength can be defined either via the FIR -- to -- blue luminosity ratio or via the radio -- to -- blue luminosity ratio. Both reflect, approximately, the ratio between the star-formation rates averaged over the last ∼ 108 yr, s8, and the last ∼ 3 × 109 yr, s9, respectively (Xu et al. 1994). However, there is a trivial dependence (positive) of the FIR -- to -- radio ratio on the FIR -- to -- blue ratio, because the FIR luminosity is involved in both ra- tios. Similarly, a trivial dependence (negative) exists be- tween the FIR -- to -- radio ratio and the radio -- to -- blue ratio. In order to minimize this artificial effect, we introduce a starburst strength indicator SB invoking both ratios: SB =0.5 × [(cid:18)log(cid:18) LFIR LB (cid:19) − hlog(cid:18) LFIR LB (cid:19) − hlog(cid:18) P2.4GHz LB (cid:19)i(cid:19) + LB (cid:19)i(cid:19)] (cid:18)log(cid:18) P2.4GHz (2) Fig. 3. q2.4GHz and the logarithm of the FIR colour, log f60µm/f100µm, for the starburst sample where hlog(cid:16) LFIR LB (cid:17)i = −0.47 ± 0.02 and hlog(cid:16) P2.4GHz LB (cid:17)i = −15.70 ± 0.05 are the means of the logarithms of the FIR -- to -- blue and of the radio -- to -- blue luminosity ratios of the control sample. A mean SB of 0.46±0.05 is found for the starburst sample, indicating that on average the s8 -- to -- s9 ratio is a factor of 2.9±0.4 higher than that of the nor- mal spirals in the control sample, consistent with previous studies (Kennicutt et al. 1987; Xu & Sulentic 1991). 4 U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models Fig. 2 shows q2.4GHz vs SB for 113 objects in the star- burst sample. The other twenty sources undetected either in the FIR or in the radio are dropped because no con- straint can be imposed on their q2.4GHz values. No corre- lation is found in this diagram. The two galaxies with the highest SB values show very normal q2.4GHz. The varia- tion of the FIR -- to -- blue and the radio -- to -- blue ratios, so the SB, may be due to the variation of the extinction, in addition to the depence on the starburst strength. In or- der to verify the results obtained in Fig. 2, we plot in Fig. 3 the dependence of q2.4GHz on another -- extinction-free -- starburst indicator, namely the log f60µm/f100µm, for the same galaxies as in Fig. 2. As pointed out by Xu & De Zotti (1989) and by Bothun et al. (1989), log f60µm/f100µm is tightly associated to the high mass star-formation rate of galaxies, and the galaxies with the strongest starbursts usually show the highest log f60µm/f100µm values. Again, we do not detect any dependence of q2.4GHz on this star- burst indicator. Therefore, we conclude that the strength of the starburst does not introduce any siginificant influ- ence on the FIR -- to -- radio ratio. 4. The starburst model 4.1. Star formation during a starburst In the model we describe the starburst galaxy as the sum of two components: a starburst population with a star for- mation rate (SFR) ΨSB(t) changing on short time-scales and a background population whose SFR Ψbg is constant in time. The total SFR is the sum of both components, Ψ(t) = ΨSB(t)+Ψbg. The SFR of the starburst population is parametrized in the following way: ΨSB(t) = (cid:26) Ψ0 expt/τgrow Ψ0 exp−t/τSB for t < 0 for t ≥ 0 (3) where τgrow and τSB are the time-scales of the increase and the decrease of the SFR. The ratio between the maxi- mum SFR of the starburst population and the background population a = Ψ0/Ψbg is a measure of the starburst strength. An upper limit for a can be estimated from the total amount of molecular gas available. The SFR of the background population can be estimated by assuming that the total amount of gas present is used up in about 1010 yr. Then we can estimate an upper limit of a by: a = Ψ0/Ψbg ≤ 1010 · x τSB (4) where x is the fraction of molecular gas available for the starburst. In a nuclear starburst, about 20 − 30% of the total amount of gas is in the nucleus and therefore avail- able for the starburst (Bernlohr 1992). The efficiency of the conversion of gas to stars can reach in starburst galax- ies 50% (e.g. Rieke et al. 1980). With these numbers we derive x = 0.1 − 0.15. Thus, e.g., for τSB = 107 yr, an upper limit for a is about 100. The Initial Mass Function (IMF), Φ(m), which deter- mines the mass distribution of the stars produced, is de- scribed by a power-law Φ(m)dm = m−γdm (5) with an upper mass limit mu = 100 M⊙ and a lower mass limit ml = 1 M⊙ (stars less massive than that are neither of importance for the FIR nor the radio emission). We adopt γ = 2.7, in agreement with Scalo (1986) and the more recent results of Basu and Rana (1992). In addition, we considered the effect of changes in the slope of the IMF and ml. 4.2. FIR emission The FIR luminosity is calculated as LFIR(t) = Z mu ml dmΦ(m)L(m)P (m)ζ(m)Z t t−τ (m) dtΨ(t)(6) where τ (m) is the stellar main-sequenze life-time, L(m) the stellar luminosity (taken from Cox et al. 1988 and Cox et al. 1986), P (m) the fraction of light absorbed by the dust and ζ(m) the fraction of the absorbed light that is reemitted in the IRAS 40 -- 120 µm band. Here, we parametrize the last two parameters in the same way as explained in detail in Lisenfeld et al. (1995): For mas- sive, ionizing stars (m > 20 M⊙) we assume P (m) = 0.6, ζ(m) = 0.5. The radiation transfer of the non-ionizing emission of the intermediate massive stars (5 M⊙ < m < 20 M⊙) and the old stars (1 M⊙ < m < 5 M⊙) is ap- proximated by an infinite parallel-slab geometry in which dust is homogenously mixed with the stars. We assume AV = 1.5 for the starburst population (Bernlohr 1993) and AV = 0.2 for the background population (Lisenfeld et al. 1995; Xu & Buat 1995). We make the further sim- plification that the radiation of the intermediate massive stars is absorbed according to the dust opacity in the UV (2000 A) and the radiation of the old stars according to the dust opacity in the blue (4400 A). Finally we split the FIR luminosity into the emission coming from H ii regions, LHII FIR, and the diffuse emission Ldiff FIR, by assuming that stars more massive than 20 M⊙ are responsible for the dust heating in H ii regions, and less massive stars for the diffuse dust heating. 4.3. Radio emission The radio emission consists of thermal bremsstrahlung and of synchrotron emission. The thermal radio emission is proportional to the total number of Lyman continuum photons NLyc emitted by the stars: Ptherm(ν) = 1.08·10−33(cid:18) NLyc phot s−1(cid:19)(cid:18) ν GHz(cid:19)−0,1 [W/Hz](7) U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models 5 The value of SB depends very sensitively on the extinc- tion. The extinction in the starburst region is most likely higher than for the background population. We assumed AV = 1.5, which is the typical internal extinction of the H ii regions in nearby galaxies (Kennicutt 1983), and at the same time consistent with the average AV found for the Markarian galaxies by Xu & De Zotti (1989). In reality it seems plausible that some galaxies have an even higher extinction, explaining the large range in SB found for the starburst sample. The extinction mainly has an influence on SB, through LB, and hardly on the FIR emission (see Fig. 9) because even for the value of AV assumed for the background population (AV = 0.2) the galaxies are optically thick for the nonionizing UV light which is the main heating source for the dust (Xu 1990). 5. Variation of q2.4GHz during a starburst In order to show the general features of the temporal evolution of q2.4GHz during a starburst, we display in Fig. 4 the variation of q2.4GHz during a starburst with a timescale τSB = 107 yr and τgrow = 0 for different star- burst strengths, and in the Figs. 5 and 6 separately the temporal evolution of the FIR and the radio emission. (e.g. Condon 1992) where we have assumed that the frac- tion of Lyman continuum photons directly absorbed by the dust is f = 0.2 and the electron temperature in the H ii region Te = 7000 K. The total number of Lyman con- tinuum photons is calculated as: NLyc = Z mu ml dmφ(m)nlyc(m)Z t t−τ (m) dtΨ(t) (8) where nLyc(m) is the production rate of Lyman continuum photons of a star of mass m, taken from Gusten & Mezger (1983). In order to calculate the synchrotron emission in a starburst a time-dependent equation has to be solved. The details are described in the Appendix. Here we will only outline the most important features. Several pro- cesses are taken into account: We assume that the CR electrons are accelerated in shocks of SN remnants. Then they propagate into the galactic disk and halo losing their energy radiatively through inverse Compton and syn- chrotron losses. Since the radiation field in a starburst is very strong, the inverse Compton losses of the electrons are very high. This has the effect of shortening their radia- tive life-time, τloss, and therefore of decreasing the tempo- ral shift between the FIR and the synchrotron radiation. (In a radiation field which is, for example, a factor of 10 higher than in the Galaxy, i.e. about 10 eV cm−3, the life-time is τloss ≈ 106 yr.) On the other hand, a high radiation field lowers the synchrotron emission itself, be- cause the number density of electrons at a given energy is lowered (see Appendix). Therefore, during a starburst -- if the magnetic field stays constant -- the synchrotron emission is a sensitve function of the radiation field and therefore of the starburst strength. In particular it is very low during the phase of most active star-formation. 4.4. Starburst strength parameter SB In order to compare our model with the data displayed in Fig. 3, we compute in the model the starburst pa- rameter SB. The blue luminosity is obtained by assum- ing that the stellar emission is a blackbody spectrum. We obtain for the background, steady state population of the galaxy within our model: hlog(cid:16) LFIR hlog(cid:16) P2.4GHz LB (cid:17)i = −0.34 and LB (cid:17)i = −15.48. The model predictions are in rather good agreement with the mean values of the control sample. The small difference between model and data of hlog(cid:16) LFIR LB (cid:17)i, might be due to a slight overestimate of the average galactic extinction or due to the crude model as- sumptions (e.g. blackbody emission of stars). In the model P2.4GHz for the background population is calculated from the model result for LFIR and the mean value of q2.4GHz of the control sample. Therefore the model prediction for hlog(cid:16) P2.4GHz LB (cid:17)i is simply a combination of hlog(cid:16) LFIR LB (cid:17)i (model), and q2.4GHz (control sample). Fig. 4. The ratio between the FIR and the radio emission at 2.4 GHz, q2.4GHz(t), is shown as a function of time for τSB = 107 yr, τgrow = 0, B =const, a = Ψ0/Ψbg = 100 (full line), a = 50 (dashed line), and a = 25 (dotted line). The dash-dotted line shows q2.4GHz for a steady state galaxy. The temporal variation of q2.4GHz can be split into 3 phases: In the early phase (phase I; here: until ≈ 50 Myr) q2.4GHz(t) is higher than the steady state value at this fre- quency. In this phase the emissions from H ii regions dom- inate the total FIR and radio emission (see Figs. 5 and 6). 6 U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models Fig. 5. For a starburst with a = 100 and otherwise the same parameters as in Fig. 4 the FIR emission (full line) is shown as a function of time. The FIR emission from H ii regions (dashed line) and the FIR emission from diffuse dust (dotted line) are shown separately. The dash-dotted line describes the FIR emis- sion from the background galaxy. Fig. 6. For a = 100 and otherwise the same parameters as in Fig. 4 the radio emission during the starburst is shown (full line), devided into thermal bremsstrahlung (dashed line) and synchrotron emission (dotted line). The dash-dotted line de- scribes the radio emission from the background galaxy. With respect to the FIR emission, this is due to the high relative abundance of massive stars. For the synchrotron emission other reasons are more important: First of all, it takes serveral 106 yr until the first SN explosions oc- cur. More important, however, is the fact that during the first serveral 107 yr the synchrotron emission is strongly suppressed (see Fig. 6) due to the strong inverse Comp- ton losses caused by a high radiation field. It is worth to note that only because of the presence of the thermal ra- dio emission and because the two ratios (log(LHII FIR/Ptherm) and log(Ldiff FIR/Psyn) are relatively similiar no major differ- ence of q2.4GHz with respect to a steady state galaxy occurs in this phase. In the next phase (phase II; here: between about 50 − 100 Myr), q2.4GHz can be even lower than in a steady state. This is due to the time delay between the SN explosions and the FIR emission: it leads to a maximum of the radio emission at a time when the FIR emission is already in its declining phase. In the last phase (phase III; here: after about 100 Myr) the opposite temporal effect occurs: The synchrotron ra- diation has already decreased to the steady state value -- or even below because the inverse Compton losses are still higher than before the starburst -- but the FIR emission is still high due to dust heating by low-mass (m = 1 − 3 M⊙) stars. Therefore during this phase q2.4GHz is higher than the steady state value and depends sensitively on a = Ψ0/Ψbg. In this phase the galaxy is already completely in the post-starburst phase. Fig. 7. The model result for the same parameters as in Fig. 4 (with a = 100) are compared to the data. The full line shows the model results for SB and q2.4GHz for the time interval be- tween t = 0 and t = 109 yr with the arrow indicating the direction of increasing time. The deviations of q2.4GHz from the steady state value in the various phases are therefore either due to the different time-scales of the FIR and the radio emission or due to the high inverse Compton losses experienced by the electrons. U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models 7 In Fig. 7 the model results are compared to the data. It can be seen that in phase I the model predictions for q2.4GHz lie substantially above the data. In the following we will try to find parameters that reduce the temporal variation of q2.4GHz to a minimum and fit the data. 6. Constraints on starburst parameters by comparison with the observations 6.1. Young starburst (phase I): Fast increase of the magnetic field? The main reason for the high model value of q2.4GHz dur- ing the early phase is a lack of synchrotron radiation due to high inverse Compton losses. The radio emission during the first ∼ 2 × 107 yr is therefore -- if the magnetic field remains constant -- practically completely thermal (Fig. 6). This has not been observed, however: Van den Driel et al. (1991) determined the thermal radio fraction of a sam- ple of starburst galaxies and derived only 40% at 5 GHz (corresponding to about 30% at 2.4 GHz). A possibly very high thermal fraction should furthermore be noticeable in a flat radio spectrum (Prad(ν) ∝ ν−0.1) which has not been observed either. The suppression of the synchrotron emission will be substantially diminished if the magnetic field increases rapidly, already in phase I. The behaviour of the mag- netic field in a starburst has not been well studied yet, but it seems plausible that the field increases. Ko & Parker (1989) proposed a model in which the increase of inter- stellar turbulence due to a high SFR activates a turbulent galactic dynamo. An alternative process to increase the magnetic field in a starburst could be the compression by SN shocks of the ionized gas in which the field is frozen. A third field enhancement process could be the systematic dynamo effect due to a commencing galactic wind as we may be observing in M 82 or even at the centre of our Galaxy. In each of the three scenarios the increase of the mag- netic field is ultimately caused by the star formation. Af- ter the end of the starburst, the magnetic field enhance- ment stops and the field dissipates slowly. Therefore we will tentatively parametrize the temporal variation of the magnetic field as: Fig. 8. q2.4GHz is shown for τSB = τgrow = 107 yr, a = 100 (dashed line), τSB = τgrow = 3 × 107 yr, a = 50 (full line) (both with ml = 1 M⊙) and for τSB = τgrow = 3 × 107 yr, a = 50, ml = 3 M⊙(dotted line). An increase of the magnetic field according to Eq. (9) has been taken into account in all three cases. B(t)2(cid:26) ∝ LFIR(t) = constant otherwise if ∂LFIR ∂t > 0 (9) In Figs. 8 and 9 the results are shown. It can be seen that the magnetic field increase lowers substantially the value of q2.4GHz in phase I and allows to fit the data. We would like to stress that the results presented do not crucially depend on the exact parametrization of the magnetic field increase during phase I. The important point is a fast increase of the magnetic field. The time- scale of this increase has to be rather short (≈ 107) be- cause a large magnetic field strength is required already Fig. 9. In the same way as in Fig. 7 the model results and the data are compared. The parameters for the model are: τgrow = τSB = 3 × 107 yr, a = 50, ml = 1 M⊙, AV = 1.5 (full line). In the dashed line the result for AV = 5 is shown in order to illustrate the influence of the extinction on the parameter SB. in an early stage of the starburst. The time-scale for the dynamo activity has been estimated to be between 108 8 U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models (Ko & Parker 1989) and > 109 yr (Field 1993). Therefore a dynamo may be a too slow process for a starburst. How- ever the alternative processes, such as outward "combing" of the field by a mass outflow or of field compression by SN shocks, would occur on the time-scale of stellar wind bubble evolution and SN activity. At least the wind ac- tivity is directly coupled to the FIR enhancement with delays of the order of a million years only. An example for this might be the nearby starburst galaxy M 82. It lies on the FIR/radio correlation (e.g. Wunderlich et al. 1987). Bernlohr (1992) estimated that the starburst in M 82 has been active for 1 − 5 × 107 yr, i.e. M 82 is in our phase I. The fast galactic outflow from the starburst nucleus and the corresponding convective electron transport is consis- tent with the observed synchrotron emission and the SN rate (Volk et al. 1989). Parker (1992) has argued that galactic dynamos can be driven by the pressure of cosmic rays and the sub- sequent reconnection of azimuthal field lines to produce poloidal fields. This process is competitive to our assumed extension of magnetic field lines to "infinity" by a wind. The point here is that also the above version of a galac- tic dynamo can more or less adiabatically follow the time variations in the production of cosmic rays, presumably in SNRs, as our data indeed suggest. 6.2. Evolved starburst (phase II): Time-scale If the time-scale of the variation of the star formation rate is very short, i.e. roughly shorter than the time-scale for SN-explosions (∼ 107 yr, i.e. the life-time of SN progen- itors), the maximum of the attendant synchrotron emis- sion occurs at a time when the FIR emission, which has about the same time-scale as the starburst, has already decreased significantly. This results in a very low model value of q2.4GHz (less than 3 σ below the steady state value). Therefore, in order to fit the data satisfactorily during this phase, τgrow + τSB has to be at least compara- ble to the SN time-scale, i.e. about 107 yr. Such time-scales are short enough to allow for repetitive bursts of star for- mation on time-scales of 108 yr as discussed by Krugel & Tutukow (1993). Our model results provided good fits to the data for time-scales longer than about 3 × 107 yr. These numbers are in agreement with other authors who found starburst time-scales between 2 × 107 and some 108 yr (Rieke et al. 1980; van den Broek et al. 1991; Bernlohr 1993). We furthermore inferred a minimum time-scale for >∼ 3 × 107 yr. This slow the increase of the SFR of τgrow increase was necessary in order to provide a large enough magnetic field strength and SN rate in the early starburst phase. 6.3. Post-starburst (phase III): A higher low-mass cut-off of the IMF? We also tested the effect of changes in the IMF, both of the slope k and the low-mass cut-off ml. These two pa- rameters are suggested by many authors to be different in a starburst in the sense that the star formation is likely to be biased towards massive stars (e.g. Rieke et al. 1980; Rieke et al. 1993; Bernlohr 1992; Wright et al. 1988). For our model, the most noticeable influence of the IMF oc- curs in the post-starburst phase (III). When the canonical IMF (Eq. (5)) is assumed for the starburst, the enhance- ment in the FIR emission lasts significantly longer than the radio emission because of the dust-heating due to the A stars (∼ 2 M⊙) produced in the burst. This is shown by a relatively high model value of q2.4GHz in this phase (Figs. 4 and 8). A better agreement with the data can be obtained if a higher low-mass cut-off, i.e. ml ∼ 3 M⊙ (see Fig. 8), is adopted. A flatter slope will have a similar ef- fect. Hence, our result seems also in favour of a top-heavy IMF for starbursts. 7. Summary and Conclusions We have analysed and compared the FIR and radio data of a sample of interacting/Markarian galaxies (starburst sample) and a sample of normal galaxies (control sam- ple) in order to test for the influence of the star formation activity on the FIR-to-radio ratio. A model for the FIR and the radio emission in a starburst was used to inter- prete the observational results and to derive constraints on starburst parameters. The following main conclusions could be drawn: -- The mean FIR-to-radio ratio, q2.4GHz, showed no sig- nificant difference between the starburst sample and the control sample and is independent of the starburst strength. -- The magnetic field is required to increase strongly on short time-scales (≈ 107 yrs) in order to maintain a sufficiently constant q2.4GHz in the first ≈ 2 × 107 yr of a starburst. Otherwise the inverse Compton losses during this phase would lead to a very low synchrotron emission, resulting in a value of q2.4GHz significantly higher than the observed one. -- The time-scale of the variation of the star-formation rate has to be longer than some 107 yr. Otherwise the different time-scales of the FIR and the radio emission produce large fluctuations in q2.4GHz. -- Our results favour a top-heavy IMF for starbursts (i.e. either a higher lower mass cut-off of ml ∼ 3 M⊙ or a flatter slope of the IMF) because this reduces the con- tribution of A stars to the dust heating, thus short- ens the time-scale of the FIR emission and therefore improves the agreement with the data for the post- starburst (phase III). U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models 9 Acknowledgements. We would like to thank M. Ko for helpful discussions. UL gratefully acknowledges the re- ceipt of a stipend of the Max-Planck-Gesellschaft and of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG). HJV and CX acknowledge that part of their work in this paper has been done in the framework of the Sonderforschungsbere- ich 328 (Entwicklung von Galaxien) of the DFG. In order to calculate f (E, t) from Eq. (A2), one has to know νSN(t) and b(t), the latter being proportional to Urad(t) + UB(t). The supernova rate νSN(t) is calcu- lated directly from the SFR given in Eqs. (3) and (5). The temporal evolution of the energy density of the radiation field, Urad(t), is proportional to the bolometric luminosity Lbol(t) of the galaxy if the volume emitting the radition does not change significantly during the starburst: Appendix : Synchrotron emission during a star- burst Urad(t) = Lbol(t) · U bg rad Lbg bol (A4) We take the radiation energy density of the steady state galaxy before the starburst U bg rad = 1eV/cm3, according to the value in our Galaxy. Lbg bol, its bolometric luminosity, is derived from the model, assuming a constant SFR. The temporal evolution of the magnetic field is parametrized according to Eq. (9). The energy density of the magnetic field in a steady state is taken as the Galactic value: U bg B = 1eV/cm3 which corresponds to a magnetic field of Bbg = 6.3µG. Knowing the electron particle density f (E, t), we can calculate the synchrotron radiation by: Psyn(ν, t)dν = f (E(ν), t) dE dν dν (A5) dE dt (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)syn with (dE/dt)syn as the energy loss by synchrotron radia- tion and dE/dν given through: ν = (cid:18) E mc2(cid:19)2 νG(B) 0.45 (A6) Assuming that the time-scale of the radiative energy losses is much shorter than the time-scale of diffusion, which is certainly a valid assumption for a starburst where the inverse Compton losses of the electrons are very large, we can neglect diffusion and describe the temporal evolution of the electron particle density f (t, E) by the following equation: ∂ ∂t mc2(cid:19)−x ∂f (t, E) qSNνSN(t)+ = (cid:18) E ∂E(cid:26)b(t) E2 f (t, E)(cid:27)(A1) where (E/mc2)−xqSNνSN(t) is the source spectrum of the relativistic electrons with νSN(t) as the supernova rate and qSN as the number of relativistic electrons produced per supernova and per energy interval. The power law index of the source spectrum is taken as x = 2.2 (Volk et al. 1988). The energy losses b(t) ∝ c1(Urad(t) + UB(t)) describe the inverse Compton and synchrotron losses which are propor- tional to the energy density of the radiation field Urad and the energy density of the magnetic field UB, respectively. The solution of Eq. (A1) for the starburst population is given by: mc2(cid:19)−x · qSN fSB(E, t) = (cid:18) E Z t max(tstart,t−τloss(E,t)) dt′ νSB SN(t′)(cid:18)1 − EZ t t′ b(t′′)dt′′(cid:19)x−2 . Here, τloss(E, t) is the time-scale of the radiation losses of the electrons during the starburst which is defined by the relation: (Longair 1994) with νG being the gyrofrequency. This cor- responds to the simplification that an electron of energy E emits the whole synchrotron radiation at the maximum frequency of the synchrotron spectrum. (A2) In order to find the absolute normalization of the syn- chrotron radiation we scale the synchrotron radiation such that the FIR/radio ratio q2.4GHz for the background popu- lation is equal to the observed average value of the control sample. EZ t t−τloss(E,t) b(t′)dt′ = 1. (A3) References The boundary condition is that at the beginning of the starburst, at t = tstart (which we approximate here as tstart = −4×τgrow), the electron density fSB(E, tstart) = 0. For the background population a similiar solution is de- rived. The solution for the electron density can be un- derstood in the following way: SNe taking place between t− τloss(E, t) and t contribute to f (E, t). The contribution of SNe at a time t′ gets a weight corresponding to the radi- ation losses that are relevant between t′ and t. The higher the radiation losses, the lower is the number density of electrons in a particular energy range. Aaronson M., Huchra J., Mould J., Schechter P., Tully R.B., 1982, ApJ 258, 64 Balzano V.A., 1983, ApJ 268, 602 Basu S., Rana R.C., 1992, ApJ 393, 373 Bernlohr K., 1992, A&A 263, 54 Bernlohr K., 1993, A&A 268, 25 Binggeli, B. Sandage A., Tammann G. A., 1985, AJ 90, 1681 Bothun G.D., Lonsdale C.J., Rice, W., 1989, ApJ 341, 129 Condon J.J., 1992, A&AR 30, 575 Condon J.J., Huang Z.P. Yin Q.F. 1991, ApJ 378, 65 10 U. Lisenfeld@, H.J. Volk, C. Xu: The FIR/radio correlation in starburst galaxies -- constraints on starburst models Cox M.J., Eales S.A.E., Alexander P., Fitt A.J., 1988, Wunderlich E., Klein U., Wielebinski R., 1987, A&AS 69, MNRAS 237, 381 487 Xu, C., 1990, ApJ 365, L47 Xu C., Buat V., 1995, A&A 293, L65 Xu C., De Zotti G. 1989, A&A 225, 12 Xu C., Sulentic J.W. 1991, ApJ 374, 407 Xu C., Lisenfeld U., Volk H.J., Wunderlich E., 1994, A&A 282, 19 Cox P., Krugel E., Mezger P.G., 1986, A&A 155, 155 de Vaucouleurs G., de Vaucouleurs A., Corwin H. et al., 1991, Third Reference Catalog of Galaxies. New York, Springer-Verlag (RC3) Dressel L.L., Condon J.J. 1978, ApJS 36, 53 Feigelson E.D., Nelson P.I. 1985, ApJ 293, 192 Field G., 1993, in: J. Franco, F. Ferrini, G. Tenorio-Tagle (eds.), Star Formation, Galaxies and the Interstellar Medium. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Franceschini A., Danese L., De Zotti G., Toffolatti L., 1988a, MNRAS 233,157 Franceschini A., Danese L., De Zotti G., Xu C., 1988b, MNRAS 233,157 Gavazzi G., Boselli A., Kennicutt R., 1991, AJ 101, 1207 Gusten R., Mezger P.G., 1983, Vistas in Astronomy 26, 159 Helou G., Soifer B.T., Rowan-Robinson M., 1985, ApJ 298, L7 Helou G. Khan I.R., Malek L., Boehmer L., 1988, ApJS 68, 151 Huchra J.P., 1977, ApJ 217, 928 Kennicutt R.C., 1983, ApJ 272, 54 Kennicutt R., Keel W., van der Hulst J., Hummel E., Roettiger K., 1987, AJ 93, 1011 Ko C.M., Parker E.N., 1989, ApJ 341, 828 Krugel E., Tutukov A.V., 1993, A&A 275, 416 Larson R.B., Tinsley B.M., 1978, ApJ 219, 46 Lisenfeld U., Volk H.J., Xu C., 1996, A&A 306, 677 Longair M.S., 1994, High Energy Astrophysics. Vol 2., Cambridge University Press Mazzarella J.M., Balzano V.A., 1986, ApJS 62, 751 Mazzarella J.M., Bothen G.D., Borrosen T.D., 1991, AJ 101, 2034 Nilson P., 1973, Uppsala General Catalogue of Galaxies. Uppsala Astronomical Observatory, Uppsala (UGC) Parker E.N., 1992, ApJ 401, 137 Rieke G.H., Lebofsky M.J., Thompson R.I., Low F.J., Tokunaga T., 1980, ApJ 238, 24 Rieke G.H., Loken K., Rieke M.J., Tamblyn P., 1993, ApJ 412, 99 Scalo J.M., 1986, Fundam. of Cosmic Research, 11 Schmitt J.H.M.M., 1985, ApJ 293, 178 Telesco C., Wolstencroft R., Done C., 1988, ApJ 329, 174 Thuan T.X., Sauvage M., 1992, A&AS 92, 749 van den Broek A.C., de Jong T., Brink K. 1991 A&A 246, 313 van den Driel W., van den Broek A.C., de Jong T., 1991 A&AS 90, 55 Volk H.J., Xu C. 1994, Infrared Phys. Technol. 35, 527 Volk H.J., Zank L.A., Zank G.P, 1988, A&A 198, 274 Volk H.J., Klein U., Wielebinski R., 1989, A&A 213, L12 Wright G.S., Joseph R.D., Robertson N.A., James P.A., Meikle W.P.S., 1988, MNRAS 233,1
0705.3800	1	0705	2007-05-25T15:51:56	Spitzer/IRS Imaging and Spectroscopy of the luminous infrared galaxy NGC 6052 (Mrk 297)	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present photometric and spectroscopic data of the interacting starburst galaxy NGC 6052 obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope. The mid-infrared (MIR) spectra of the three brightest spatially resolved regions in the galaxy are remarkably similar and are consistent with dust emission from young nearly coeval stellar populations. Analysis of the brightest infrared region of the system, which contributes ~18.5 % of the total 16\micron flux, indicates that unlike similar off-nuclear infrared-bright regions found in Arp 299 or NGC 4038/9, its MIR spectrum is inconsistent with an enshrouded hot dust (T > 300K) component. Instead, the three brightest MIR regions all display dust continua of temperatures less than ~ 200K. These low dust temperatures indicate the dust is likely in the form of a patchy screen of relatively cold material situated along the line of sight. We also find that emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and the forbidden atomic lines is very similar for each region. We conclude that the ionization regions are self-similar and come from young (about 6 Myr) stellar populations. A fourth region, for which we have no MIR spectra, exhibits MIR emission similar to tidal tail features in other interacting galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Spitzer/IRS Imaging and Spectroscopy of the luminous infrared galaxy NGC 6052 (Mrk 297) D. G. Whelan1, D. Devost1, V. Charmandaris2,3, J.A. Marshall1, J. R. Houck1 [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] ABSTRACT We present photometric and spectroscopic data of the interacting starburst galaxy NGC 6052 obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope. The mid-infrared (MIR) spectra of the three brightest spatially resolved regions in the galaxy are remarkably similar and are consistent with dust emission from young nearly co- eval stellar populations. Analysis of the brightest infrared region of the system, which contributes ∼18.5% of the total 16µm flux, indicates that unlike simi- lar off-nuclear infrared-bright regions found in Arp 299 or NGC 4038/9, its MIR spectrum is inconsistent with an enshrouded hot dust (T>300K) component. In- stead, the three brightest MIR regions all display dust continua of temperatures less than ∼ 200K. These low dust temperatures indicate the dust is likely in the form of a patchy screen of relatively cold material situated along the line of sight. We also find that emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and the forbidden atomic lines is very similar for each region. We conclude that the ionization regions are self-similar and come from young (. 6 Myr) stellar populations. A fourth region, for which we have no MIR spectra, exhibits MIR emission similar to tidal tail features in other interacting galaxies. Subject headings: dust, extinction -- infrared: galaxies -- galaxies: ual(NGC6052) -- galaxies: starburst -- galaxies: tion individ- interactions -- stars: forma- 1Center for Radiophysics and Space Research, Cornell University, 219 Space Sciences Building, Ithaca, NY 14853-6801, USA 2University of Crete, Department of Physics, P.O. Box 2208 GR-71003, Heraklion, Greece 3IESL, Foundation for Research and Technology-Hellas, GR-71110, Heraklion, Greece, and Chercheur Associ´e, Observatoire de Paris, F-75014, Paris, France -- 2 -- 1. Introduction NGC 6052 (also known as Mrk 297, Arp 209, VV 86) is an interacting system located at a distance of 70.4 Mpc and having an LIR = 1 × 1011 L⊙ (Sanders et al. 2003), which puts it into the class of luminous infrared galaxies (LIRGs). The peculiar morphology of the system has made it the subject of several multi-wavelength observations (e.g. Weedman 1972; Taniguchi et al. 1991). There is a general consensus that NGC 6052 is a merger of two galaxies (Burenkov 1988; Alloin & Duflot 1979; Taniguchi et al. 1991), although the exact morphological type of the galaxies involved is still unclear. H-α imaging revealed a number of star formation regions throughout the system (Cair´os et al. 2001). Hecquet et al. (1987) identified the locations of forty-three different optical knots in NGC 6052, distributed along the central bar-like structure of the galaxy and on the spiral-arm/tidal feature which extends along the north-south direction. An extensive study of the infrared properties of the system was performed with the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) involving both MIR imaging with ISOCAM and spec- troscopy with PHOT-S and LWS (Metcalfe et al. 2005). Seven MIR knots were visible in the 14.3µm images of the system. The most luminous of these sources, identified as "region- 1" by Metcalfe et al. (2005), is approximately 8′′ to the north of the main bulge of the galaxy. This source contributes ∼22% of the 15µm flux of NGC 6052, yet the ISO data indicated that it was faint optically. This suggested that it may be a more extreme example of the infrared-bright, optically-obscured "overlap region" region found between the two galactic nuclei of the Antennae galaxies (Vigroux et al. 1996). The MIR luminosity of the NGC 6052 source is a factor of ∼14 higher than that of the Antennae source. An alternative possibility is that the source is an obscured active galactic nucleus, like IC 694 (Gallais et al. 2004). This hypothesis was tested by Metcalfe et al. (2005) using infrared diagnostics, who con- cluded that an AGN in the NGC 6052 source would be deeply embedded and needed to be confirmed with hard X-ray observations. In this paper, we present photometry and spectroscopy of the three brightest MIR regions in NGC 6052 and photometry of a fourth region, using the Infrared Spectrograph1 (IRS) on board the Spitzer Space Telescope. We present the observations and data reduction in §2, the analysis in §3, and discuss the implications of our observations in §4. 1The IRS was a collaborative venture between Cornell University and Ball Aerospace Corporation funded by NASA through the Jet Propulsion Laboratory and the Ames Research Center. -- 3 -- 2. Observations and Data Reduction NGC 6052 was observed in mapping mode with the Spitzer/IRS (Werner et al. 2004; Houck et al. 2004) in both the short-low (SL, 5.2-14.5µm) and long-low (LL, 14.0-38.0µm) modules. The SL data were obtained on 15 July 2004 and the LL data on 4 March and 17 July 2004, resulting in a map of the central area of the system over the whole 5.3 -- 37µm range. The total exposure time per IRS slit was 44 sec for SL, and 20 sec for LL. Target acquisition was performed using the IRS blue (16 µm) peak-up camera.2 As a result of the IRS peak-up procedure, a 16µm image with a total exposure time of 201 sec centered on the brightest position of our target was obtained. The field of view of the image is 60′′×72′′ and its scale is 1.8′′ pixel−1. All the observations were processed by the Spitzer Science Center pipeline version 13.2. The stability of Spitzer's pointing enables the registration of the image on a world coordinate system (WCS) grid with an accuracy which is better than the pixel size of the peak-up array. The 16µm contours along with 2MASS contours are overlaid on the HST image in Figure 1. Two different spectral extractions were performed. First, an integrated spectrum of NGC 6052 was extracted using the Spectral Modeling, Analysis, and Reduction Tool (SMART Ver. 5.5.1 Higdon et al. 2004) for all the SL and LL pointings of the spectral map. The 2D images were coadded together and a standard full slit extraction was performed on each coadded low resolution aperture. The resulting spectrum is shown in Figure 3. Second, we extracted individual sources (labeled A, B, and C in Figure 1) in the SL module. Sources A and C were located within the same slit, requiring the development of custom software to perform a Gaussian model fit to the spatial profile of multiple sources within a slit. Each source in the slit was traced using information about the location of each wavelength element on the array (Whelan et al. 2005). We estimate the cross-contamination between sources A and C to be . 5%. The full-width at half-maximum of each curve fit was assumed to be the same as that of a stellar point-source, and therefore was allowed to vary with wavelength. Source B was extracted in a likewise fashion, for one source within a slit. The spectral map does not cover source D. We flux calibrated the data using observations of α Lac that were extracted in exactly the same manner as the object spectra. The extracted spectrum from the star was used in conjunction with a template to produce a Relative Spectral Response Function (RSRF) (Cohen et al. 2003). The RSRF was applied to each extracted spectrum of NGC 6052. The spectra of sources A, B and C are shown in Figure 4. We estimate our spectrophotometry 2For details on the IRS peak-up, see chapter 7 of Spitzer Observing Manual at http://ssc.spitzer.caltech.edu/documents/som/ -- 4 -- to be better than 10%. The flux from the various polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) features was cal- culated using the fitted Drude profiles from the spectral decompositions described in §3.4. The [Ne ii]12.81µm line flux was also measured using this fitting method since it is blended with the 12.7µm PAH feature in the SL module. All other atomic lines have a well defined continuum, so we calculated their total fluxes by simply summing the pixel values following a local continuum subtraction. Our PAH feature and line measurements are presented in Table 2. Near-IR J, H, and K aperture photometry was performed on the 2MASS images (Skrutskie et al. 2006) at the positions of sources A, B, C, and D. These measurements are included with the spectra in Figure 4, as they are important to the spectral decompositions (discussed in §3.4). To compare the overall optical morphology of the system to the thermal dust emission we use a V-band (F555W) Hubble Space Telescope (HST) image of the galaxy from the HST archive (Figure 1). We also use archival broadband MIR images of NGC 6052 obtained with the Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) instrument on Spitzer (Fazio et al. 2004). The images were obtained on March 27, 2005 with the 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 µm broadband filters and they were processed with the Spitzer Science Center pipeline version 14.0. The FWHM of the point spread function of the images varies between 1′′.6 and 2′′.0 for the different filters. The images have a pixel size of 1.2′′ ×1.2′′ and a field of view 5.2′ × 5.2′ The total integration time per filter was 150s. 3. Analysis 3.1. Global Morphology The distribution of dust and star emission from NGC 6052 is displayed in Figure 1, where we overlay contours of the 16 µm Blue Peak-Up (BPU) and 2MASS K-band images onto the optical HST image. The regions marked A, B, C, and D align with optically visible HII regions, but none are associated with the two brightest optical regions, which are labeled by Alloin & Duflot (1979) as the compact regions of the merged galaxies forming NGC 6052. See Table 1 for a comparison of our source identification to the MIR regions from Metcalfe et al. (2005) and the B-R color knots from Hecquet et al. (1987). Source alignment was based on the reconstructed pointing of Spitzer and the astrometry of the 2MASS image. With the better registration of Spitzer and 2MASS, we find that -- 5 -- source A is shifted 4′′ north relative to the optical, compared to the ISO data presented in Metcalfe et al. (2005), and is not as optically-obscured as was previously thought based on ISOCAM data. The pointing accuracy of Spitzer is a factor of two smaller than the 1.8′′ pixel size of the 16µm image. We confirmed our astrometry using 2MASS J, IRAC 3.6, 4.5, 5.8 and 8.0 µm, and IRS 16.0 µm images, as shown in the Figure 2 mosaic. This mosaic best illustrates the centroid shifts of the sources. The location of the near-IR bulge of the galaxy is indicated by a white cross and we observe an obvious shift in the emission as wavelebgth changes from predominantly main sequence star light in the 2MASS image, to PAH and hot dust in the IRAC bands, to just dust at 16.0 µm. It is clear that the concentration of warm dust and PAH emission as traced by the IRAC 5.8 and 8µm bands lies to the north and east of the NIR bulge, in regions A, B and C, and more faintly along the eastern tidal arm, where source D lies. At 16µm, where more embedded star forming regions may be probed, the spatial resolution is lower, but most of the emission originates from regions A and B. The total MIR flux of the galaxy at 16µm is measured as 260 mJy ± ∼ 12% (see Table 1 for a complete list of flux densities). Metcalfe et al. (2005) found a 15 µm flux density of 289 mJy ± ∼ 15%. This flux density, as well as our 16µm image, globally match the MIR morphology presented by Metcalfe et al. (2005) using ISOCAM. Metcalfe et al. (2005) showed that region A in NGC 6052 contributes 22% of the total emission at 15 µm. In contrast, see Table 1, we find that region A contributes only 18.5% of the total emission at 16 µm. This difference in flux density between the ISOCAM measure- ments and the Spitzer IRS BPU measurements is equal to 18.5 mJy. A similar difference of 67 mJy between the ISOCAM 7.7 µm and the IRAC 8 µm fluxes, where the ISOCAM measurement is again higher than what we measure, is also noted. The reason for these differences is unclear. All of our flux measurements appear to be systematically lower than those given by Metcalfe et al. (2005). 3.2. Radio Continuum Emission Since radio emission is also an extinction-free tracer of star forming regions, we use the high resolution radio continuum map of Yin (1994) to compare the radio morphology of the galaxy to our 16µm image. The radio map gives evidence for a bright radio supernova located at the position of knot 14 in Hecquet et al. (1987) (Lonsdale et al. 1992; Sage et al. 1993; Yin 1994). Knot 14, which is unresolved in the MIR, does not coincide with either regions A or C (see Figure 1), but it does fall within the SL slit. As a result it is possible that some of the emission from the source surrounding the radio supernova may contribute to the extracted IRS spectra of sources A and C. Yin (1994) notes that the flux from Hecquet's -- 6 -- knot 14 is either from SN 1982aa (five years after the explosion) or from an HII region. As is discussed by Metcalfe et al. (2005) the most likely type for SN 1982aa is Ib/c. The HST image of Figure 1 indicates that the position attributed to knot 14 of Hecquet et al. (1987) is a diffuse HII region. However, the supernova presumed to be associated with knot 14 is not visible in recent optical and near-IR images and the spectra of regions A and C do not greatly differ in spectral continuum slope or feature strength from that of region B (see §3.3 below). In other words, we see no MIR features associated with the supernova, and its HII region is unresolved. There is a region to the northeast of SN 1982aa in Yin's radio continuum map which is associated with our region A. There is also diffuse radio emission associated with regions B and C. Region D is not resolved in the radio continuum map. 3.3. Spitzer Mid-IR Spectroscopy Our spectrum, displayed in Figure 3, is in overall agreement with the 6 -- 11µm spectrum obtained by ISO/PHOT-S in Metcalfe et al. (2005). Our spectrum displays strong emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) at 6.2, 7.7, 8.6, 11.25 12.7 and 17.1 µm. Several fine structure lines, including [Ne ii], [Ar iii], [S iv], and [Ne iii], are also clearly visible in the spectrum, as well as the molecular hydrogen lines: S(3)λ9.66µm; and S(2)λ12.27µm. The ratio [Ne iii]/[Ne ii]=0.84 ±0.16 while the [S iv]/[S iii]=0.52 ±0.18. This is similar to typical values ( ∼1 and ∼0.5 respectively) found in other starburst galaxies (Brandl et al. 2006) and lower than those seen in Blue Compact Dwarf galaxies (Wu et al. 2006). In addition, the narrow width of the IRS SL slits (3.6′′) enable us to obtain 5.3 -- 15µm spectra for the three brightest MIR regions in the galaxy. Extending the spectrum of those regions to longer wavelengths was not possible since the individual regions are unresolved within the 9.7′′ width of the IRS 15 -- 37µm LL slit. Inspection of our IRS spectra, displayed in Figure 4, reveals that the MIR spectra for all three regions are surprisingly similar. For instance, even though region A is brighter than regions B or C at 16 µm, lending to a marginally steeper MIR slope, the PAH spectrum shows few noticeable differences. Of special note is the shallow 9.6µm silicate absorption feature. We will elaborate on a possible physical explanation of these features in §4. Table 2 lists the integrated line fluxes and major PAH features for the whole system, as well as in the individual regions A, B, and C. -- 7 -- 3.4. Spectral Decomposition In order to characterize the properties of the emitting and obscuring dust (including dust temperatures, optical depths, and PAH feature strengths), we decompose the infrared spectral energy distribution of each spectrum into emission from: (1) multiple dust com- ponents at different characteristic temperatures; (2) stellar photospheres; (3) PAHs; and (4) atomic and molecular lines. The contribution from each dust component is calculated using a realistic dust model consisting of a distribution of thermally emitting carbonaceous and silicate grains. The model accounts for stochastic emission from PAHs by fitting ob- servationally derived PAH templates to the spectra. Details of the method are described in Marshall et al. (2007) (and see Armus et al. (2006, 2007) for additional applications). For the integrated spectrum of the galaxy we find that three dust components fit the data well, at temperatures of 25, 57, and 203 ±5 K. The τ (9.7) for the global spectrum was found to be 0.9 ± 0.5, where the uncertainty is due to statistics, as well as the dependence on model choice for the PAH template and dust geometry. This number is far more than the optical depth computed by Takagi et al. (2003) of τ V = 0.9 which corresponds to τ (9.7) ∼0.1 using a standard extinction curve. Takagi et al. (2003) derive their τ V from the modeled mass fraction of hydrogen and the mass fraction of stars. In contrast, our optical depth estimate is derived from the MIR spectrum. The integrated PAH luminosity of the system is ∼6.5% ± 0.5% of the total LIR, nearly 50% higher than the value found for the prototypical starburst galaxy NGC 7714 (Brandl et al. 2004; Marshall et al. 2007). The sum of the 6.2µm PAH feature strengths from regions A, B, and C is ∼19% of the total 6.2µm PAH feature strength from the inte- grated spectrum. In comparison, the 14µm flux from regions A, B, and C totals to ∼40% of the 14µm flux from the integrated spectrum. The PAH emission in the galaxy is therefore dominated by the diffuse regions, not associated with the brightest MIR sources. Regions A, B, and C have derived warm dust temperatures of 187 K (source A); 179 K (source B); and 201 K (source C), with statistical uncertainties from the fits of a few K. The lack of higher spatial resolution photometry beyond 15µm for this system clearly limits our ability to trace the behavior of colder dust components for individual regions. The optical depths at 9.7µm of the warm dust components are 0.76, 0.58, and 0.75 ± 0.2 for regions A, B, and C, respectively. In addition, optical depths from the interstellar radiation field (ISRF, Mezger et al. (1982)) are 0.31, 0.47, and 0.24 ± 0.2 for sources A, B, and C, respectively. Generally speaking, each region has a similar optical depth at 9.7 µm, ∼0.6-0.8, and the ISRF optical depth is about uniform for each region, ∼0.3-0.4. To confirm our estimates for source extinction and age based on MIR data, an inde- -- 8 -- pendent assessment using broadband photometry from Hecquet et al. (1987) and a stan- dard extinction curve (Mathis 1990) was established. Using the B-R colors published by Hecquet et al. (1987) and the ages derived in our Starburst models (see §3.5) we derived E(B-R) for regions A, B, and C, and compared these values to the standard extinction curve. The τ (9.7) values for our three sources are 0.27, 0.17, and 0.16, respectively. These values are a factor of two or three less than those derived from the MIR spectra. The MIR probes more deeply into dust-enshrouded regions than optical light, which tends to be dom- inated by emission from less-obscured stars. Thus MIR indicators of extinction tend to give higher values than optical. 3.5. Starburst Modeling The atomic lines present in the single source spectra (Figure 4) enable us to investigate the nature of the sources powering the MIR in NGC 6052. [Ar iii], [Ne ii], and [S iv] lines are detected in all three regions. By applying the measurements of these atomic lines to young stellar population models, we have estimated relative ages for the young stellar populations of sources A and C, and have established an upper limit for source B. We used Starburst99 (Leitherer et al. 1999) to model the radiation from the underlying stellar population, and MAPPINGS III (Dopita et al. 2000; Kewley et al. 2001) to estimate the flux from the photoionized regions. The stellar population models were used as input to the photoionization code. The age of the stellar population was allowed to vary and the models were run for several metallicities between Z⊙/20 and 2Z⊙. The reason we varied the metallicity was also motivated by the fact that there is a scatter in the published values of the metallicity of Mrk 297. Shi et al. (2005) estimates [O/H] to be 8.34. Assuming solar abundance of 8.83 (Grevesse et al. 1998), this scales to ∼ 0.25Z⊙. Likewise, Calzetti et al. (1994) and James et al. (2002) found [O/H] =8.61 and 8.65 respectively (Z ≃ 0.5Z⊙). Our best fit models are for solar metallicity. The IMF is fixed at the standard Salpeter values of α = 2.35, Mdown = 1.0 M⊙ and Mup = 100 M⊙, and the star formation mode was instantaneous. As such, the variation of the ionization parameter is only linked to the variation in age and metallicity of the stellar population. We find that the young stellar populations in source A is ∼3 Myr ± 0.5 Myr, while for source C it is ∼5.5 ± 0.5 Myr. For source B though we can only place an upper limit of . 5 Myr due to the fact that the models were degenerate for region B's atomic line ratios, which are consistent with ages of both ∼1.5 and ∼4 Myr. -- 9 -- 4. Discussion As mentioned in the previous section and presented in Figure 4, there is a strong sim- ilarity in all three MIR-bright region spectra in NGC 6052. Starburst models have shown regions A, B, and C are nearly coeval, which suggests that some mechanism induced star for- mation across the galaxy simultaneously. This mechanism is most probably the collision of two galaxies as discussed in Taniguchi et al. (1991), though why the burst of star formation should come 150 Myr after the two galaxies' closest approach is unclear. The shallow 9.6µm silicate absorption feature observed in all of our spectra (indicative of low optical depths), in conjunction with the morphological properties discussed in §3.1 lead us to believe NGC 6052 has a nonuniform obscuring dust screen associated with it. The shallow 9.6µm feature implies that the dominant sources of MIR emission are not embedded dusty star forming regions but rather exposed in a manner where we can readily sample the MIR contribution from the photodissociation regions. An embedded geometry would be proposed if the silicate feature were much deeper, as is seen in ULIRGs (Armus et al. 2007), where hot dust temperatures suggest that the dust is very close to the hot, young stars heating it. This is clearly not the case in NGC 6052. Dust temperatures in NGC 6052 of around 200 K (as opposed to the ∼700 K found in by Armus et al. (2007) or even the > 300 K dust temperatures implied in the overlap region of the Antennae described by Mirabel et al. (1998)) mean the dust is relatively far away from the heating source, likely in the form of a dust screen in front of the exciting sources. A non-embedded geometry would also explain why the continuum is not as steep as other embedded systems. However, we believe this screen to be nonuniform because the system is still in an early stage of interaction and has not reached the merger phase. There are no apparent symmetries visible in the MIR morphology of the system; the coincidence of concentrated MIR flux with a select few HII regions appears arbitrary. That NGC 6052 is enshrouded nonuniformly by dust is in general agreement with other published indications of nonuniformity. Rothberg et al. (2004) found "large residuals" in their K-band model-subtracted image of the galaxy and concluded that NGC 6052 has a "thin diffuse patchy structure". The predicted morphology of the system based on dynamical modeling of the stellar component by Taniguchi et al. (1991) demonstrated that when they can reproduce the overall morphology of the system (see their Figures 2 and 4), one of the tidal tails extends to the north of the central bulge of the galaxy, across the location of regions A and C, while the other tidal tail extends eastward, across region B and including region D. Based on this scenario it is thus conceivable that clumpy gas and dust associated with these tails are associated with the four distinct regions we see in the infrared. In §3.1 we noted that region A, which emits most at 16 µm, contributes 18.5 % of the -- 10 -- total flux. This fact begs comparison to the fluxes of the obscured regions of the Antennae galaxies and IC 694, since both of these systems have off-nuclear sources which contribute largely to the MIR emission. The hidden source in the Antennae galaxy contributes 15 % of the total luminosity between 12.5µm and 18µm (Mirabel et al. 1998), and IC 694 con- tributes ∼ 26 % of the total flux between 12µmand 18µm. However, neither of the hidden sources present such spectral similarities with other regions of their host galaxy as region A does to the other regions of NGC 6052 (cf. the spectra presented in Vigroux et al. (1996); Mirabel et al. (1998); Gallais et al. (2004)). Also, we now know that all of the MIR-bright regions in NGC 6052 are optically visible (see Table 1). For this reason, and because there is currently no evidence which allows region A to be considered an AGN (as is the case with the obscured source in IC 694), a comparison between NGC 6052 and these two objects yields very little information about the physical properties of the MIR-bright regions. Because all of the MIR bright regions in NGC 6052 lie within the dust trail or in one of the two tidal tails, we compare NGC 6052 to other galaxies with bright sources existing in the tidal tails. One obvious comparison can be drawn with the MIR-bright region in NGC 2207 / IC 2163. This region (called "feature i") contributes 12% of the total 24µmflux, and also dominates the H-α and radio continuum emission (Elmegreen et al. 2006). The implication of this finding is that "feature i" is a compact region of star formation. Our region A also exhibits bright MIR flux and corresponding radio emission (see §3.2 and Yin (1994)). Tidal tail-induced star formation is also present in the Arp 82 system, where the brightest off-nuclear clump contributes ∼ 7% of the total 24 µm flux (Hancock et al. 2007). Region D likewise contributes ∼ 5% of the total 16 µm flux. We can also calculate the MIR luminosities of the regions in NGC 6052 and compare them with studies which include other interacting galaxy samples (i.e. Smith et al. 2007). For regions A, B and C we find that the 3.6µm luminosities, which we treat as a proxy of the stellar mass content, are 1.34, 1.38 and 1.77×1042 ergs s−1 respectively. The 8.0µm luminosities, which probe the emission from PAH molecules and thus are tracers of the star formation activity, are 7.46, 7.13 and 8.30×1042 ergs s−1 for the same three regions. These values are very similar to values found in the spiral galaxy and the tidal feature samples of Smith et al. (2007) (see their Figs. 12 and 13) if one takes into account that there is an RMS of ∼0.5 in dex in the values of the Smith et al. sample. When we examine region D in the tidal tail of NGC6052 we find that its 3.6 and 8.0µm luminosities are 7.05×1041 ergs s−1 and 2.50×1042 ergs s−1 respectively. These luminosities are slightly higher than the mean value of the tidal features in the Smith et al. sample. However, NGC 6052 is also nearly 3 times more distant than the furthest source in the Smith et al. survey, so in our photometry for all four regions of our galaxy we may be including other parts of the galaxy which would have likely been excluded by Smith et al. (2007). This inherent error is likely -- 11 -- biasing our luminosity measurements towards measurements made of entire galaxies, and away from small-scale tidal features. 5. Conclusions We have presented photometric and spectroscopic results of the NGC 6052 system. The main conclusions of our analysis are as follow: (1) The brighteset MIR region, labeled A, contributes ∼ 18.5% of the total 16µm flux, and resembles the brightest 24 µm source from NGC 2207 / IC 2163 photometrically, but is dissimilar spectroscopically from the hidden sources in the Antennae galaxies and Arp 299; (2) the spectra of regions A, B, and C are all surprisingly similar, and are consistent with dust emission from nearly coeval young stellar populations; (3) the geometry of this system includes a patchy dust screen of colder material in front of the young stellar clusters, and these clusters are not deeply embedded in dusty material; and (4) region D has MIR properties which are typical of those found in tidal tails. This work is based [in part] on observations made with the Spitzer Space Telescope, which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under NASA contract 1407. Support for this work was provided by NASA through Contract Number 1257184 issued by JPL/Caltech. D.G. Whelan would like to thank an anonymous referee whose comments greatly im- proved this paper, and H. Spoon for stimulating conversations. We would also like to thank C. Markwardt for distributing the MPFIT package (http://cow.physics.wisc.edu/craigm/idl/mpfittut.html). Some of the data presented in this paper were obtained from the Multimission Archive at the Space Telescope Science Institute (MAST). STScI is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555. Support for MAST for non-HST data is provided by the NASA Office of Space Science via grant NAG5-7584 and by other grants and contracts. This research has made use of the NASA/ IPAC Infrared Science Archive, which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. Facilities: Spitzer (IRS) -- 12 -- REFERENCES Alloin, D., & Duflot, R. 1979, A&A, 78, L5. Appleton, P.N., et al. 2006, ApJ, 639, L51. Armus, L., et al. 2006, ApJ, 640, 204. Armus, L., et al. 2007, ApJ, 656, 148. Bevington, P. R., & Robinson, D. K. Data Reduction and Error Analysis for the Physical Sciences. Boston, McGraw Hill, 2003. Brandl, B., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 188. Brandl, B., et al. 2006, ApJ, 653, 1129. Burenkov, A.N. 1988, Astrofizika 28, 47. Cair´os, L.M., Caon, N. V´ılchez, J. M., P´erez, J. N. G., & Munoz-Tun´on, C. 2001, ApJS, 136, 393. Calzetti, D., Kinney, A.L., & Storchi-Bergmann, T. 1994, ApJ, 429, 582. Charmandaris, V., Stacey, G. J., & Gull, G. 2002, ApJ, 571, 282. Cohen, M., Megeath, S.T., & Stauffer, J. 2003, AJ, 125, 2645. Dopita, M. A., Kewley, L. J., Heisler, C. A., & Sutherland, R. S. 2000, ApJ, 542, 224. Dunne, L., Eales, S., Edmunds, M., Ivison, R., Alexander, P., & Clements, D. L. 2000, MNRAS, 315, 115. Elmegreen, D. M., Elmegreen, B. G., Kaufman, M., Sheth, K., Struck, C., Thomasson, M, & Brinks, E. 2006, ApJ, 642, 158. Fazio et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 10. Gallais, P., Charmandaris, V., Le Floc'h, E., Mirabel, I. F., Sauvage, M., Vigroux, L., & Laurent, O. 2004, A&A, 414, 845. Grevesse, N., & Sauval, A. J. 1998, SSR, 85, 161. Haas, M., Klaas, U., Coulson, I., Thommes, E., & Xu, C. 2000, A&A, 356, L83. -- 13 -- Hancock, M., Smith, B. J., Struck, C., Giroux, M. L., Appleton, P. N., Charmandaris, V., & Reach, W. T. 2007, AJ, 133, 676. Hecquet, J., Coupinot, G., & Maucherat, A.J. 1987, A&A, 183, 13. Heeschen, D., Heidmann, J, & Yin, Q.F. 1983, ApJ, 267, L73. Higdon, S. J. U., et al. 2004, PASP, 116, 975. Houck, J. R., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 18. James, A., Dunne, L., Eales, S., & Edmunds, M. G. 2002, MNRAS, 335, 753. Kewley, L. J., Dopita, M. A., Sutherland, R. S., Heisler, C. A., & Trevena, J. 2001, ApJ, 556, 121. Laurent, O., Mirabel, I. F., Charmandaris, V., Gallais, P., Madden, S. C., Sauvage, M., Vigroux, L., & Cesarsky, C. 2000, A&A, 359, 887. Leitherer, C., et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 3. Lonsdale, C. J., Lonsdale, C. J., & Smith, H. E. 1992, ApJ, 391, 629. Marshall, J.A., et al. 2007, ApJ, submitted. Mathis, J.S. 1990, ARA&A, 28, 37. Metcalfe, L., et al. 2005, A&A, 444, 777. Mezger, P. G., Mathis, J. S., Panagia, N. 1982, A&A, 105, 372. Mirabel, I.F., et al. 1998, A&A, 333, L1. Peeters, E., Spoon, H.W.W., & Tielens, A.G.G. 2004, ApJ, 613, 986. Rothberg, B., & Joseph, R.D. 2004, AJ, 128, 2098. Sage, L. J., Loose, H. -H., & Salzer, J. J. A&A, 273, 6. Sanders, D. B., Mazzarella, J. M., Kim, D.-C., Surace, J. A., & Soifer, B. T. 2003, AJ, 126, 1607. Shi, F., Kong, X., Li, C., & Cheng, F. Z. A&A, 437, 849. Skrutskie, M. F., et al. 2006, AJ, 131, 1163. -- 14 -- Smith, B. J., Struck, C., Hancock, M., Appleton, P. N., Charmandaris, V., & Reach, W. T. 2007, AJ, 133, 791. Sofue, Y., Taniguchi, Y., Handa, T., Wakamatsu, K., Nakai, N., Fujisawa, K., & Yasuda, N. 1990, PASJ, 42, L45. Spinoglio, L., Malkan, M. A., Rush, B., Carrasco, L., & Recillas-Cruz, E. 1995, ApJ, 453, 616. Takagi, T., Arimoto, N., & Hanami, H. 2003, MNRAS, 340, 813. Taniguchi, Y. & Tamura, S. 1987, A&A, 181, 265. Taniguchi, Y. & Noguchi, M. 1991, AJ, 101, 1601. Vigroux, L., et al. 1996, A&A, 315, L93. Weedman, D. W. 1972, ApJ, 171, 5. Werner, M. W., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 1. Whelan, D.G., Devost, D., Charmandaris, V., & Houck, J.R. 2005, in proceedings of "The Spitzer Science Center 2005 Conference: Infrared Diagnostics of Galaxy Evolution." Wu, Y., Charmandaris, V., Hao, L., Brandl, B. R., Bernard-Salas, J., Spoon, H. W. W., & Houck, J. R. 2006, ApJ, 639, 157. Xu, C., Sulentic, J. W., & Tuffs, R. 1999, ApJ, 512, 178. Yin, Q. F. 1994, ApJ, 420, 152. This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2. -- 15 -- Table 1. Source Identificationa Labels Fluxes in mJy Spitzer Metcalfeb Hecquetc J band H band K band 3.6µm 4.5µm 5.8µm 8.0µm 16.0µm A B C D all 1 2 4 7 7,8 22,23 15 41 −− −− 0.96 1.89 1.26 1.21 43.65d 1.16 2.42 1.43 1.36 56.23d 1.05 2.11 1.34 1.26 38.90d 2.68 2.76 3.53 1.41 22.3 2.46 2.21 2.42 1.04 16.4 10.6 9.73 11.5 3.68 63.2 33.1 31.6 36.8 11.1 179 48.0 36.1 30.1 11.9 260 aErrors in flux densities are measured to be about 12 % systematically. bTaken from Metcalfe et al. (2005) Figure 1, sources 1, 2, 4, amd 7 refer to the MIR regions they labeled from the ISOCAM 14.3 µm image cTaken from Hecquet et al. (1987) Figure 2b, a B-R color image of NGC 6052 dGlobal flux density values for the J, H, and K bands are taken from Spinoglio et al. (1995) -- 16 -- Table 2. Mid-IR Emission Features of NGC 6052 Feature Region A Region B Region C Total Flux ×10−20 W cm−2 4.32 ±0.04 15.8 ±0.2 2.93 ±0.5 3.72 ±0.8 2.75 ±0.4 3.41 ±0.03 4.92 ±0.04 65.6±0.8 PAH 6.2µm 1.85 ±0.03 198 ±6 15.0 ±0.7 PAH 7.7µm 2.96 ±0.6 3.45 ±0.06 30.1±0.7 PAH 8.6 µm 4.4 ±0.1 3.4 ±0.1 38.9±0.9 PAH 11.3µm PAH 12.7µm 2.56 ±0.4 2.36 ±0.08 15.0±0.5 [ArIII]λ8.99µm 0.139 ±0.002 0.196±0.001 0.071±0.002 5.7±0.3 0.41 ±0.04 0.20 ±0.02 2.3±0.5 [SIV]λ10.51µm 0.43 ±0.02 [SIII]λ19.01µm 4.4±0.5 0.95 ±0.11 0.74 ±0.11 6.3±0.6 [NeII]λ12.81µm 0.65 ±0.11 [NeIII]λ15.80µm 5.3±0.5 H2S(3)λ9.7µm 0.0792±0.007 0.171±0.01 0.17 ±0.02 8.9±0.7 H2S(2)λ12.3µm 0.10 ±0.01 0.16 ±0.01 0.101±0.01 6.5±0.3 − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − − -- 17 -- A SN1982aa C D 12.0 13.5 16:05:13.0 12.5 Right Ascension (J2000) Right Ascention (J2000) ) 0 0 0 2 ) 0 J 0 ( 0 2 n J o ( i n t o a i t n a i n l i c l c e e D D 50.0 45.0 20:32:40.0 35.0 30.0 25.0 20.0 B 10 arcsec 3.4 kpc 14.0 Fig. 1. -- The HST optical (F 555W) image of the galaxy, over-plotted with 2MASS K-band image (white) and Spitzer/IRS 16µm image (black). The three regions from which IRS spectra were extracted are labeled A, B, and C. Source D is also labeled. Note that region A emits most at 16 µm. The position of SN 1982aa (see §3.2) is marked by a square. -- 18 -- + + J−band IRAC 3.6 IRAC 4.5 + + IRAC 5.8 IRAC 8.0 IRS 16.0 + + Fig. 2. -- A snapshot composite of the near-IR 2MASS J-band image of NGC 6052, along with the 3.5, 4.0, 5.8, and 8.0µm IRAC images as well as the IRS 16µm peak-up image. Each snapshot is centered at RA(J2000)=16:05:12.89, Dec(J2000)=+20:32:32.5, which coincides with the location of the near-IR bulge of the galaxy as indicated by the J-band image. -- 19 -- [SIII] [SIV] 12.7PAH/[NeII] 17.1PAH NGC6052 Total Cold Tepid Warm PAHs ISRF 7.7PAH 6.2PAH H2S(3) [NeIII] 8.6PAH 11.3PAH 6 6 7 7 8 8 9 9 10 10 15 15 rest [µm] λ 20 20 25 25 30 30 35 35 1.0 1.0 0.1 0.1 ] y J [ ν f 101 101 NGC6052 Total Cold Tepid Warm ISRF 100 100 10−1 10−1 ] y J [ ν f 10−2 10−2 1 1 10 10 λ rest [µm] 100 100 1000 1000 Fig. 3. -- Top: The integrated Spitzer/IRS spectrum of NGC 6052, with all strong MIR spectral features marked. Bottom: The 1 µm to 100 µm SED of the system. The far-IR pho- tometric points for the systems were obtained from Metcalfe et al. (2005) and Dunne et al. (2000) (filled symbols were used in the spectral decomposition while open symbols were not), and the near-IR photometric points are from Spinoglio et al. (1995). The warm dust, PAH, and interstellar radiation field (ISRF) components of the model fits are also indicated. -- 20 -- NGC6052−A Total Warm PAHs ISRF 2 2 4 4 6 6 8 8 λ rest [µm] 10 10 12 12 14 14 NGC6052−B Total Warm PAHs ISRF 2 2 4 4 6 6 8 8 λ rest [µm] 10 10 12 12 14 14 NGC6052−C Total Warm PAHs ISRF 10−2 10−2 ] y J [ ν f 10−3 10−3 10−2 10−2 ] y J [ ν f 10−3 10−3 10−2 10−2 ] y J [ ν f 10−3 10−3 2 2 4 4 6 6 8 8 λ rest [µm] 10 10 12 12 14 14 Fig. 4. -- The ∼5 -- 15µm IRS SL spectrum of sources A, B, and C. The filled circles indicate the J,H, and K 2MASS points for each region. The warm dust, PAH, and interstellar radiation field (ISRF) components of the model fits are also indicated.
astro-ph/9910045	1	9910	1999-10-04T08:47:53	Meteor Streams of Comet Encke. Taurid Meteor Complex	[ "astro-ph" ]	Application of the theoretical results of the author are presented for the case of meteor streams of comet Encke. Theoretical determination of meteor orbit for comet Encke, as a parent body, is presented. Four significant theoretical meteor streams, corresponding to Tauds N, Tauds S, $\beta$ Tauds and $\xi$ Perds are found. The meteor stream membership criterion is applied to the photographic orbits of The IAU Meteor Data Center in Lund: Taurid meteor stream is found for several possible areas in phase-space of orbital elements.	astro-ph	astro-ph	A&A manuscript no. (will be inserted by hand later) Your thesaurus codes are: 07 (07.09.1; 07.13.1; 07.13.2 ) ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 16.4.2015 9 9 9 1 t c O 4 1 v 5 4 0 0 1 9 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Meteor Streams of Comet Encke. Taurid Meteor Complex. Jozef Klacka Institute of Astronomy, Faculty for Mathematics and Physics, Comenius University, Mlynsk´a dolina, 842 15 Bratislava, Slovak Republic Abstract. Application of the theoretical results of the author are presented for the case of meteor streams of comet Encke. Theoretical determination of meteor orbit for comet Encke, as a parent body, is presented. Four significant theoretical meteor streams, corresponding to Tauds N, Tauds S, β Tauds and ξ Perds are found. The meteor stream membership criterion is applied to the photographic orbits of The IAU Meteor Data Center in Lund: Taurid meteor stream is found for several possible areas in phase-space of orbital elements. Key words: interplanetary medium - meteoroids – meteor streams 1. Introduction Application of the meteor stream membership criterion and the method of prediction of theoretical radiants, suggested in Klacka (1995a: Meteor stream membership criteria - paper I) and Klacka (1995b: Meteor streams and parent bodies – paper II), is presented for the case of meteor streams connected with the comet Encke. Gravitational forces acting on meteoroids of the comet Encke yield that semimajor axis a (energy E, E = 1/a – the sign is not important, now), z−component of the angular momentum ( Lz ≡ Hz = pa(1 − e2) cos i ) and the angle π (π = ω + Ω) show small dispersions during evolution for several 10,000 years. This suggest that these quantities should be used in determining the meteor stream membership and in prediction 2 of theoretical radiants. e – eccentricity was taken as the fourth important quantity for determination of meteor stream. The reason for this choice is that distributions in E, Lz, π and e may be approximated with normal distribution. The data for the photographic meteor orbits of The IAU Meteor Data Center in Lund were used. 2. Theoretical prediction of radiants Let us consider that comet Encke is the only parent body for a meteor stream. We use the result of section 6 of paper I in the form of "Energy −Hz − π method" (see section 5.1 in paper II) for the purpose of finding of meteor stream(s). The local minima yield four theoretical radiants, summarized in Table 1; the theoretical radiants should correspond to β Tauds, Tauds S, Tauds N and ξ Perds. Table 1. Theoretical radiants for comet Encke as a parent body. Energy-Hz-π method. q[AU ] e i[◦] ω[◦] Ω[◦] α[◦] δ[◦] λ⊙[◦] 0.326 0.853 0.324 0.854 0.321 0.855 0.321 0.855 6.6 4.8 0 0 242 118 298 62 278 42 222 98 84 54 52 85 18 16 19 24 98 222 222 98 △H2 0.009 0.011 0.014 0.015 3. Photographic data and membership to meteor stream Section 5 of paper I is used in determining the membership to meteor stream. The data for the photographic meteor orbits of The IAU Meteor Data Center in Lund were used. We have found that orbital elements E, Lz, π and e may be approximated with normal distribution. Thus, the density function in Eq. (8) of paper I is taken in the form of four- dimensional normal density function. The area Ω in Eq. (8) of paper I may be chosen in an infinity ways – we take, in this paper, only some of special cases summarized by the form Dp ≡ 4 Xi=1 (cid:18)Qi − QiM ri σi (cid:19)p ≤ Dp c , (1) where Q1 = E, Q2 = e, Q3 = Hz, Q4 = π, and, the value Dc corresponds to the case when multidimensional normal distribution yields that meteors with D > Dc are members of a group, for given ri (i = 1 to 4) and p, only with probability less than 5 % (QiM corresponds to the mean value of the quantity Qi). We consider the following 3 cases, as examples: 1. p = 2, r1 = r2 = r3 = r4 = 1. 2. p = 1, r1 = r2 = r3 = 1, r4 → ∞, 3. p = 2, r1 = r2 = r3 = 1, r4 → ∞, (We must stress that Eq. (1) is principally different from Eq. (1) in Klacka (1992) – the case 1 corresponds, roughly, to Eq. (1) in Klacka (1992); however, even in the case that area Ω is of the type of a quadratic form, it may be even of indefinite type.) 3.1. Description of the procedure and basic results As we have already mentioned, the data for the photographic meteor orbits of The IAU Meteor Data Center in Lund were used. The requirement 0.15 AU ≤ q ≤ 0.5 AU and 0.4 ≤ e ≤ 0.999 and i ≤ 20◦ yields 418 objects of the total set. The set of 418 meteors was used in finding the required meteor stream. The case 1, already defined, was ellaborated in the following way. At first, 418/36 = 11.6 objects per 10◦. The interval of π, in which number of objects per 10◦ is greater than 11.6, corresponds to π ∈ (110◦, 190◦) ≡ I (no object exists for π ∈ (105◦, 110◦)). The distribution for π ∈ I may be approximated by normal. Thus, initial set of 418 objects reduced to 213 objects with π ∈ I. Four-dimensional normal distribution was used (quantities Q1 = E, Q2 = e, Q3 = Hz, Q4 = π). Since only several objects had 8.5◦ < i < 20◦ (no object existed for i ∈ ( 8.5◦, 9.5◦)), we reduced the initial set of 213 objects into a set with i < 8.5◦ – the final starting set contained 191 objects. Four- dimensional normal distribution was applied to the set of 191 objects (quantities Q1 = E, Q2 = e, Q3 = Hz, Q4 = π). The final result is characterized by 4-dimensional normal distribution with mean values Q1M , Q2M , Q3M , Q4M and covariant matrix of the vector (Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4) with components σij (i, j = 1 to 4) – see Table 2. We have obtained 130 objects for the case 1 (probability 95 % – Dc = 3.31). (Quantities σi, i = 1 to 4, used in Eq. (1) are given by the relations σi = √σii, i = 1 to 4.) In the cases 2 and 3, already defined, the three-dimensional normal distribution was used (quantities Q1 = E, Q2 = e, Q3 = Hz). In both cases the statistics yielded that the obtained distributions in π corresponded to normal for π ∈ (110◦, 190◦) ≡ I, the number of objects with π ∈ I ′ was smaller than the number of objects with π ∈ I. As for the distribution in inclinations, the same holded as in the case 1. Thus, the final starting set of the data contained 191 objects. Three-dimensional normal distributions were applied to the set of 191 objects (quantities Q1 = E, Q2 = e, Q3 = Hz). The final results are characterized by 3-dimensional normal distributions with mean values Q1M , Q2M , Q3M 4 Table 2. Mean values and components of covariant matrix for the case 1. (Probability 95 % – Dc = 3.31). Q1M Q2M Q3M Q4M 0.4701585 0.8334692 0.8028469 154.4876923 σ11 σ12 σ13 σ14 0.0036200 -0.0006914 -0.0015446 -0.4048438 σ21 σ22 σ23 σ24 -0.0006914 0.0007624 -0.0010880 -0.0410647 σ31 σ32 σ33 σ34 -0.0015446 -0.0010880 0.0037522 0.4382409 σ41 σ42 σ43 σ44 -0.4048438 -0.0410647 0.4382409 278.4472892 and covariant matrix of the vector (Q1, Q2, Q3) with components σij (i, j = 1 to 3) – see Table 3 for the case 2 and Table 4 for the case 3. We have obtained 130 objects for the case 2 (probability 95 % – Dc = 4.69) and 131 objects for the case 3 (probability 95 % – Dc = 3.02). (Quantities σi, i = 1 to 3, used in Eq. (1) are given by the relations σi = √σii, i = 1 to 3.) Table 3. Mean values and components of covariant matrix for the case 2. (Probability 95 % – Dc = 4.69). Q1M Q2M Q3M 0.4672623 0.8323077 0.8076754 σ11 σ12 σ13 0.0034363 -0.0006934 -0.0014475 σ21 σ22 σ23 -0.0006934 0.0007924 -0.0011204 σ31 σ32 σ33 -0.0014475 -0.0011204 0.0037191 5 Table 4. Mean values and components of covariant matrix for the case 3. (Probability 95 % – Dc = 3.02). Q1M Q2M Q3M 0.4676122 0.8334656 0.8049176 σ11 σ12 σ13 0.0035460 -0.0006960 -0.0015081 σ21 σ22 σ23 -0.0006960 0.0007820 -0.0011135 σ31 σ32 σ33 -0.0015081 -0.0011135 0.0037759 3.2. Comparison of the results Table 5 presents objects classified as members of all three meteor streams – each object belongs to the stream in the cases 1, 2 and 3, simultaneously (127 objects). Table 6 yields those objects which are members only in one or two streams; the term "yes" denotes that an object is member of a given stream, the term "no" denotes that an object is not member of a given stream. While in the cases 1 and 2 the number of objects belonging only to one of the streams to the number of objects belonging to the both streams is 3/127 ≈ 2.4%, all three cases yield similar ratio 7/127 ≈ 5.5%. It is evident that this number may even increase when other areas Ω are used. All three cases yield λ⊙ ∈ (165◦, 265◦). Distribution in λ⊙ is not approximable by normal distribution. The relation between quantities of different distributions in a form of linear regression is not wise. This holds, as a special case, between an orbital element and λ⊙ – even in a small interval ∆λ⊙ (as for larger interval, the procedure may even not be used due to the fact that periodicity is not secured). Evident approximate relation exists between π and λ⊙ due to the well-known relation among π − Ω − λ⊙; however, we again emphasize that density functions for π and λ⊙ are different. However, in order to be able to compare our Taurid stream with that obtained in the past, we present the following linear regressions: q[AU ] = (0.096 ± 0.018) − (0.791 ± 0.811)10−4λ⊙[◦] , π[◦] = (−12.065 ± 4.710) + (0.7563 ± 0.0213)λ⊙[◦] , (2) 6 Table 5. Objects belonging to all three meteor streams (all three cases). 2192 2198 2209 2254 2256 2259 2264 2372 2381 2391 2418 2452 2457 2461 2480 2485 2506 2516 2526 2528 2532 2552 2556 2565 2576 2580 2586 2604 2611 2629 2637 2668 2680 2681 2684 2702 2713 2720 2722 2724 2726 2733 2739 2747 2748 2752 2755 2761 2763 2764 2768 2769 2777 2787 2793 2794 2796 2801 2805 2807 2812 2814 2815 2816 2818 2820 2821 2822 2823 2826 2834 2840 2842 2844 2846 2847 2849 2850 2852 2854 2857 2858 2864 2866 2869 2874 2875 2877 2878 2886 2890 2891 2892 2899 2900 2903 2906 2907 2910 2911 2923 2935 2979 2980 2994 3000 3001 3012 3029 3036 3041 3043 3050 3063 3066 3069 3082 3084 3093 3112 3116 3125 3134 3136 3178 3189 3264 Table 6. Objects of meteor streams maximally in two of the three cases. object case 1 case 2 case 3 no no yes yes no no yes yes yes yes yes no no no 2248 2298 2371 2523 2547 2599 2727 no yes no no yes yes no for the case 1, q[AU ] = (0.094 ± 0.018) − (0.671 ± 0.816)10−4λ⊙[◦] , π[◦] = (−18.410 ± 5.246) + (0.7826 ± 0.0237)λ⊙[◦] , for the case 2, and, q[AU ] = (0.087 ± 0.017) − (0.363 ± 0.791)10−4λ⊙[◦] , π[◦] = (−16.756 ± 4.887) + (0.7759 ± 0.0221)λ⊙[◦] , (3) (4) 7 for the case 3. Comparison of Eqs. (2) – (4) with the results of Porubcan and Stohl (1987 – Table 1) shows that our Taurid meteor complex is different from that obtained on the basis of D-criterion of Southworth and Hawkins (1963). We must stress again that criterion suggested in paper I (in section 5), and applied in this paper, is of purely mathematical character, based on mathematical statistics. Our criterion is not of physical character, as was interpreted in Neslusan (1996). 4. Conclusion We have applied methods developed in papers I and II to meteor streams of comet Encke. We have found, in a simple physical way, theoretical radiants which should correspond to comet Encke as a parent body. The coincidence with the reality is not very bad. Taurid meteor complex, based on the data of photographic orbits, was found for various areas in phase space. Comparison of the results based on statistical method of multidimensional density function is not consistent with that obtained on the basis of Southworth and Hawkins D-criterion. The difference will even increase with the increasing number of photographic meteors. We can conclude that our definition of the Taurid meteor complex corresponds to the multidimensional normal distribution in phase space of orbital elements. As an example, we have used three different areas Ω. Physical problem is to make a decision which kind of area Ω is the most reasonable. Acknowledgements. Special thanks to the firm "Pr´ıstrojov´a technika, spol. s r. o.". This work was partially supported by Grants VEGA No. 1/4304/97 and 1/4303/97. References Klacka J., 1992, Acta Astron. et Geophys. Univ. Comenianae XV-XVI, 5 Neslusan, L., 1996, Meteor Reports 17, 11 Porubcan, V., Stohl, J., 1987, Symposium on the Diversity and Similarity of Comets, Brussels, Belgium, ESPA SP-278 Southworth, R. B., Hawkins, G. S., 1963, Smithson. Contrib. Astrophys. 7, 261 This article was processed by the author using Springer-Verlag LaTEX A&A style file 1990.
astro-ph/0610068	1	0610	2006-10-03T12:22:39	Empirical strong-line oxygen abundance calibrations from galaxies with electron temperature measurements	[ "astro-ph" ]	We determine the gas-phase oxygen abundance for a sample of 695 galaxies and H II regions with reliable detections of [O III]4363, using the temperature-sensitive Te method. Our aims are to estimate the validity of empirical methods such as R23, R23-P, log([N II]/Halpha) (N2), log[([O III]/Hbeta)/([N II]/Halpha)] (O3N2), and log([S II]/Halpha) (S2), and especially to re-derive (or add) the calibrations of R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices for oxygen abundances on the basis of this large sample of galaxies with Te-based abundances. We select 531 star-forming galaxies from the SDSS-DR4, and 164 galaxies and H II regions from literature for such study. Their (O/H) abundances obtained from Te are within 7.1<12+log(O/H)<8.5 mostly. For roughly half of the SDSS samples, the Bayesian abundances obtained by the MPA/JHU group are overestimated by ~0.34 dex compared with the Te-based (O/H) measurements, possibly due to the treatment of nitrogen enrichment in the models they used. R23 and R23-P methods systematically overestimate the O/H abundance by a factor of ~0.20 dex and ~0.06 dex, respectively. The N2 index, rather than the O3N2 index, provides relatively consistent O/H abundances with the Te-method, but with some scatter. The relations of N2, O3N2, S2 with log(O/H) are consistent with the photoionization model calculations of Kewley & Doptita (2002), but R23 does not match well. Then we derive analytical calibrations for O/H from R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices on the basis of this large sample of galaxies, especially including the excitation parameter P as an additional parameter in the N2 calibration. These can be used as calibration references in the future studies about metallicities of galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies. N2=log([N ]6583/Hα), O3N2=log(([O ]5007/Hβ)/([N ]6583/Hα)), S2=log([S ]6717,6731/Hα), P=[O ]/([O ]+[O ]). (O/H)Bay=12+(O/H)Bayesian obtained by the MPA/JHU group. 1 (1) Num 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID 266- 51630- 407 270- 51909- 617 276- 51909- 490 277- 51908- 451 282- 51658- 543 283- 51959- 572 285- 51930- 154 289- 51990- 369 292- 51609- 372 296- 51984- 416 297- 51959- 442 299- 51671- 311 304- 51957- 12 304- 51957- 568 308- 51662- 412 309- 51994- 489 310- 51990- 136 311- 51665- 8 313- 51673- 638 337- 51997- 593 339- 51692- 437 344- 51693- 321 348- 51671- 297 348- 51671- 331 350- 51691- 500 351- 51780- 212 351- 51780- 600 353- 51703- 479 358- 51818- 403 363- 51989- 532 364- 52000- 66 364- 52000- 384 374- 51791- 612 375- 52140- 118 375- 52140- 348 380- 51792- 253 384- 51821- 281 386- 51788- 573 388- 51793- 239 388- 51793- 457 394- 51913- 402 398- 51789- 223 406- 51869- 484 408- 51821- 472 409- 51871- 50 414- 51901- 546 415- 51810- 285 419- 51879- 364 420- 51871- 156 420- 51871- 474 423- 51821- 402 (3) IAU designations J094333.91+010659.4 J101430.99+004754.9 J105342.55+000945.0 J110116.39+004814.4 J113703.79+002817.4 J114649.34+005345.9 J120047.07-003611.8 J122419.73+010559.6 J124715.31+003806.7 J131937.25+005043.8 J132654.62+011346.5 J133649.51-001158.9 J142214.30-003919.8 J142200.19+010213.2 J144458.53+004618.8 J145533.67+003657.2 J150356.83-004200.3 J151320.62-002551.9 J152830.72+001740.2 J125526.06-021333.9 J130324.17-021046.9 J155957.38+004741.2 J163012.60-005408.6 J163107.20+005324.7 J171212.07+650248.4 J170201.44+604746.3 J170922.63+614851.1 J170517.74+593546.6 J173021.82+571531.6 J153258.27+004100.2 J163006.89-001810.8 J162150.66+003509.2 J221823.86+003918.3 J222510.13-001152.8 J221823.86+003918.3 J225906.70-005810.2 J232936.56-011057.0 J235347.69+005402.1 J000703.98-003447.6 J000657.02+005125.9 J005105.28+004600.1 J011633.94-002043.0 J022407.68+003226.1 J023900.79+001836.0 J024939.72-011151.3 J032750.16+010135.0 J033031.22-005846.5 J004236.94+160202.7 J005425.68+144852.2 J005300.53+150129.6 J011354.58+153947.8 (4) t3 (104K) 1.080 ± 0.062 1.198 ± 0.037 1.203 ± 0.073 1.450 ± 0.029 1.199 ± 0.025 1.608 ± 0.035 1.056 ± 0.067 1.245 ± 0.033 1.235 ± 0.048 1.005 ± 0.028 1.175 ± 0.028 0.977 ± 0.040 1.411 ± 0.044 0.994 ± 0.056 0.972 ± 0.048 1.126 ± 0.053 1.059 ± 0.045 1.119 ± 0.064 1.185 ± 0.039 1.560 ± 0.029 0.982 ± 0.053 1.305 ± 0.058 1.157 ± 0.045 1.175 ± 0.055 1.137 ± 0.065 1.003 ± 0.040 1.046 ± 0.066 1.127 ± 0.063 1.074 ± 0.061 1.036 ± 0.065 1.106 ± 0.063 1.337 ± 0.079 1.097 ± 0.074 1.413 ± 0.020 1.150 ± 0.063 0.972 ± 0.058 1.184 ± 0.025 1.194 ± 0.088 1.246 ± 0.033 1.221 ± 0.029 0.982 ± 0.049 1.144 ± 0.076 1.141 ± 0.072 1.265 ± 0.037 1.309 ± 0.033 1.057 ± 0.048 1.178 ± 0.034 1.103 ± 0.042 1.156 ± 0.035 1.200 ± 0.060 1.265 ± 0.036 (5) 12+(O/H)Te 8.197 ± 0.050 8.141 ± 0.031 8.142 ± 0.051 7.982 ± 0.025 8.210 ± 0.022 7.884 ± 0.030 8.311 ± 0.061 8.075 ± 0.027 8.099 ± 0.032 8.417 ± 0.032 8.178 ± 0.026 8.381 ± 0.045 7.971 ± 0.028 8.400 ± 0.057 8.432 ± 0.054 8.232 ± 0.039 8.308 ± 0.043 8.130 ± 0.054 8.150 ± 0.032 7.831 ± 0.026 8.372 ± 0.056 8.077 ± 0.041 8.169 ± 0.034 8.159 ± 0.042 8.072 ± 0.049 8.316 ± 0.038 8.251 ± 0.058 8.152 ± 0.047 8.297 ± 0.055 8.346 ± 0.062 8.255 ± 0.053 8.018 ± 0.041 8.260 ± 0.065 7.972 ± 0.020 8.213 ± 0.051 8.459 ± 0.065 8.192 ± 0.024 8.179 ± 0.067 8.128 ± 0.027 8.173 ± 0.025 8.426 ± 0.051 8.187 ± 0.063 8.194 ± 0.053 8.140 ± 0.033 8.042 ± 0.028 8.296 ± 0.038 8.199 ± 0.031 8.265 ± 0.040 8.206 ± 0.029 8.136 ± 0.042 8.075 ± 0.027 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.659 8.427 8.179 8.090 8.206 7.990 8.234 7.993 8.087 8.469 8.348 8.615 8.076 8.448 8.706 8.577 8.358 8.842 8.454 7.854 8.493 8.739 8.474 8.084 8.819 8.616 8.622 8.589 8.568 8.694 8.483 8.334 8.315 7.984 8.343 8.619 8.217 8.217 8.163 8.492 8.177 8.115 8.104 8.376 8.013 8.472 8.127 8.814 8.160 8.138 8.131 (7) N2 -0.911 ± 0.005 -1.331 ± 0.010 -1.250 ± 0.014 -1.605 ± 0.026 -1.413 ± 0.014 -2.019 ± 0.041 -1.247 ± 0.010 -1.615 ± 0.014 -1.362 ± 0.011 -1.352 ± 0.008 -1.434 ± 0.013 -1.222 ± 0.008 -1.580 ± 0.026 -1.225 ± 0.008 -1.009 ± 0.008 -1.006 ± 0.006 -1.300 ± 0.010 -0.871 ± 0.007 -1.385 ± 0.013 -2.040 ± 0.048 -1.141 ± 0.007 -1.375 ± 0.022 -1.149 ± 0.010 -1.357 ± 0.010 -0.786 ± 0.004 -0.963 ± 0.005 -1.029 ± 0.008 -1.036 ± 0.006 -1.181 ± 0.010 -0.837 ± 0.006 -1.162 ± 0.009 -1.048 ± 0.007 -1.214 ± 0.013 -1.763 ± 0.012 -1.213 ± 0.012 -1.131 ± 0.007 -1.384 ± 0.008 -1.379 ± 0.033 -1.468 ± 0.015 -1.345 ± 0.009 -1.297 ± 0.008 -1.281 ± 0.015 -1.309 ± 0.010 -1.509 ± 0.028 -1.652 ± 0.015 -1.104 ± 0.006 -1.481 ± 0.013 -1.091 ± 0.010 -1.406 ± 0.009 -1.282 ± 0.012 -1.426 ± 0.011 (8) S2 -0.683 ± 0.005 -0.954 ± 0.011 -0.746 ± 0.009 -1.346 ± 0.029 -0.918 ± 0.008 -1.392 ± 0.022 -0.769 ± 0.009 -1.019 ± 0.009 -0.774 ± 0.007 -0.966 ± 0.007 -1.041 ± 0.013 -0.911 ± 0.007 -1.126 ± 0.014 -0.812 ± 0.011 -0.887 ± 0.011 -0.727 ± 0.007 -0.866 ± 0.008 -0.918 ± 0.012 -0.906 ± 0.009 -1.497 ± 0.018 -0.741 ± 0.006 -1.115 ± 0.029 -0.776 ± 0.016 -0.813 ± 0.008 -0.773 ± 0.006 -0.739 ± 0.005 -0.705 ± 0.009 -0.669 ± 0.005 -0.848 ± 0.011 -0.729 ± 0.007 -0.789 ± 0.007 -0.576 ± 0.006 -0.780 ± 0.010 -1.250 ± 0.008 -0.787 ± 0.009 -0.931 ± 0.008 -0.931 ± 0.007 -0.866 ± 0.023 -0.970 ± 0.011 -0.989 ± 0.009 -0.814 ± 0.005 -0.750 ± 0.010 -0.699 ± 0.006 -1.145 ± 0.027 -1.060 ± 0.010 -0.689 ± 0.004 -0.972 ± 0.008 -1.054 ± 0.030 -0.929 ± 0.007 -0.748 ± 0.008 -0.955 ± 0.009 (9) O3N2 1.436 ± 0.003 2.128 ± 0.008 1.941 ± 0.012 2.581 ± 0.024 2.303 ± 0.012 3.018 ± 0.033 1.947 ± 0.008 2.419 ± 0.012 2.077 ± 0.009 2.184 ± 0.005 2.278 ± 0.011 1.945 ± 0.005 2.426 ± 0.024 1.938 ± 0.006 1.796 ± 0.007 1.678 ± 0.004 2.053 ± 0.008 1.517 ± 0.005 2.172 ± 0.010 2.958 ± 0.044 1.814 ± 0.005 2.265 ± 0.020 1.856 ± 0.008 2.084 ± 0.009 1.320 ± 0.002 1.579 ± 0.003 1.612 ± 0.006 1.618 ± 0.005 1.942 ± 0.008 1.558 ± 0.003 1.898 ± 0.007 1.647 ± 0.005 1.965 ± 0.011 2.680 ± 0.010 1.969 ± 0.009 1.911 ± 0.005 2.249 ± 0.006 2.182 ± 0.031 2.313 ± 0.013 2.215 ± 0.006 2.034 ± 0.007 2.002 ± 0.013 1.956 ± 0.008 2.455 ± 0.026 2.519 ± 0.013 1.742 ± 0.004 2.343 ± 0.010 1.926 ± 0.008 2.190 ± 0.007 1.957 ± 0.009 2.214 ± 0.008 (10) P 0.552 0.776 0.639 0.924 0.811 0.937 0.656 0.809 0.679 0.774 0.822 0.731 0.804 0.667 0.758 0.617 0.720 0.711 0.770 0.942 0.670 0.854 0.685 0.698 0.625 0.636 0.607 0.600 0.721 0.673 0.687 0.537 0.714 0.896 0.700 0.716 0.821 0.742 0.792 0.799 0.684 0.699 0.609 0.891 0.857 0.601 0.815 0.807 0.737 0.633 0.761 6 0 0 2 t c O 3 1 v 8 6 0 0 1 6 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 2 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 424- 51893- 368 430- 51877- 97 431- 51877- 191 436- 51883- 391 442- 51882- 223 443- 51873- 542 446- 51899- 86 446- 51899- 283 446- 51899- 352 446- 51899- 541 447- 51877- 172 452- 51911- 387 452- 51911- 487 454- 51908- 111 455- 51909- 369 456- 51910- 195 458- 51929- 42 458- 51929- 185 459- 51924- 253 460- 51924- 128 460- 51924- 592 463- 51908- 299 467- 51901- 628 468- 51912- 250 469- 51913- 110 472- 51955- 546 474- 52000- 610 483- 51924- 495 483- 51924- 594 489- 51930- 434 490- 51929- 363 490- 51929- 396 493- 51957- 144 493- 51957- 219 502- 51957- 7 505- 52317- 228 507- 52353- 87 507- 52353- 347 509- 52374- 268 509- 52374- 592 512- 51992- 524 513- 51989- 521 515- 52051- 378 516- 52017- 403 519- 52283- 507 519- 52283- 615 524- 52027- 16 524- 52027- 260 525- 52295- 626 527- 52342- 247 530- 52026- 525 535- 51999- 52 539- 52017- 356 J012223.90+152031.9 J015453.90+130721.7 J073256.71+370449.8 J075446.42+451502.7 J082001.71+505039.1 J083108.23+493159.1 J084526.52+531916.2 J083516.99+533211.0 J083313.18+542222.8 J084703.00+545039.4 J084852.46+514532.7 J092635.26+582047.4 J093248.77+582530.7 J022907.37-085726.2 J023426.93-072807.6 J024453.66-082137.8 J030539.70-083905.4 J030321.41-075923.2 J031023.95-083432.8 J032101.01-080150.1 J032613.63-063512.4 J034543.94-065446.0 J085201.82+010459.5 J085207.68-001117.8 J090106.55+005418.0 J091652.23+003114.1 J092918.38+002813.0 J090047.45+574255.0 J090139.89+575945.9 J103007.42+654756.0 J105506.12+670918.3 J105032.50+661654.1 J121333.58+665053.8 J120821.93+661905.8 J101430.99+004754.9 J103412.22+014248.9 J105331.42+011740.5 J104642.48+022930.1 J110719.03+015909.6 J111224.38+022734.5 J112938.16+031503.9 J113655.80+033333.4 J115117.02+032656.0 J120055.63+032403.9 J122416.44+030036.0 J122948.09+030658.6 J130831.56+012208.0 J130148.03+013718.4 J131710.87+025620.0 J132654.62+011346.9 J135155.89+032524.2 J143210.15+012551.9 J145814.74+020652.2 (4) t3 (104K) 1.146 ± 0.036 1.173 ± 0.083 0.966 ± 0.039 0.975 ± 0.045 1.099 ± 0.046 1.145 ± 0.039 1.011 ± 0.050 0.979 ± 0.050 1.062 ± 0.054 1.114 ± 0.051 1.058 ± 0.065 1.251 ± 0.060 1.018 ± 0.039 1.051 ± 0.035 1.187 ± 0.077 1.236 ± 0.032 1.261 ± 0.075 1.480 ± 0.024 1.016 ± 0.039 1.020 ± 0.047 1.110 ± 0.023 1.126 ± 0.064 1.226 ± 0.035 1.034 ± 0.049 1.192 ± 0.024 1.017 ± 0.042 1.298 ± 0.023 1.037 ± 0.039 1.087 ± 0.040 1.171 ± 0.079 1.188 ± 0.040 1.211 ± 0.038 1.280 ± 0.066 1.217 ± 0.054 1.185 ± 0.024 1.501 ± 0.043 1.231 ± 0.038 1.126 ± 0.060 1.226 ± 0.057 1.517 ± 0.117 1.010 ± 0.060 1.073 ± 0.062 1.134 ± 0.052 1.535 ± 0.029 1.059 ± 0.063 1.203 ± 0.043 1.133 ± 0.036 1.074 ± 0.033 1.146 ± 0.029 1.255 ± 0.023 1.052 ± 0.036 1.086 ± 0.038 1.111 ± 0.050 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.226 ± 0.034 8.190 ± 0.065 8.372 ± 0.042 8.348 ± 0.048 8.265 ± 0.039 8.177 ± 0.032 8.658 ± 0.063 8.409 ± 0.051 8.305 ± 0.053 8.231 ± 0.042 8.328 ± 0.062 8.123 ± 0.048 8.324 ± 0.039 8.318 ± 0.034 8.163 ± 0.056 8.101 ± 0.023 8.142 ± 0.057 7.898 ± 0.021 8.377 ± 0.042 8.333 ± 0.049 8.269 ± 0.023 8.215 ± 0.052 8.104 ± 0.025 8.344 ± 0.046 8.183 ± 0.022 8.344 ± 0.043 8.071 ± 0.022 8.322 ± 0.041 8.271 ± 0.036 8.164 ± 0.060 8.150 ± 0.028 8.152 ± 0.030 8.064 ± 0.042 8.138 ± 0.041 8.142 ± 0.021 7.858 ± 0.026 8.130 ± 0.029 8.212 ± 0.047 8.199 ± 0.051 7.903 ± 0.054 8.359 ± 0.057 8.257 ± 0.053 8.237 ± 0.042 7.841 ± 0.022 8.286 ± 0.058 8.112 ± 0.033 8.228 ± 0.032 8.319 ± 0.033 8.218 ± 0.027 8.108 ± 0.020 8.264 ± 0.038 8.243 ± 0.037 8.240 ± 0.041 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.812 8.165 8.697 8.615 8.499 8.028 8.196 8.491 8.403 8.086 8.112 8.049 8.500 8.186 8.149 8.046 8.207 7.898 8.480 8.429 8.754 8.362 8.081 8.571 8.307 8.153 8.041 8.724 8.124 8.103 8.094 8.100 8.129 8.097 8.481 7.977 8.112 8.472 8.144 8.408 8.497 8.462 8.304 7.909 8.228 8.048 8.495 8.256 8.273 8.210 8.834 8.823 8.239 (7) N2 -1.038 ± 0.007 -1.256 ± 0.021 -0.981 ± 0.005 -1.022 ± 0.008 -1.206 ± 0.011 -1.407 ± 0.012 -1.290 ± 0.008 -1.202 ± 0.007 -1.320 ± 0.013 -1.404 ± 0.023 -1.452 ± 0.017 -1.750 ± 0.065 -1.194 ± 0.007 -1.328 ± 0.011 -1.315 ± 0.016 -1.493 ± 0.010 -1.420 ± 0.028 -1.586 ± 0.016 -1.334 ± 0.010 -1.263 ± 0.008 -1.101 ± 0.007 -1.176 ± 0.009 -1.387 ± 0.012 -1.212 ± 0.016 -1.443 ± 0.010 -1.342 ± 0.009 -1.625 ± 0.011 -1.059 ± 0.006 -1.311 ± 0.009 -1.305 ± 0.015 -1.338 ± 0.008 -1.524 ± 0.014 -1.326 ± 0.013 -1.439 ± 0.015 -1.323 ± 0.007 -1.757 ± 0.023 -1.496 ± 0.014 -1.147 ± 0.008 -1.742 ± 0.043 -1.049 ± 0.014 -1.104 ± 0.008 -1.145 ± 0.010 -1.236 ± 0.012 -1.806 ± 0.019 -1.238 ± 0.011 -1.359 ± 0.012 -1.304 ± 0.008 -1.412 ± 0.010 -1.421 ± 0.023 -1.415 ± 0.010 -1.036 ± 0.007 -1.167 ± 0.008 -1.241 ± 0.008 (8) S 2 -1.008 ± 0.012 -0.711 ± 0.010 -0.851 ± 0.007 -0.776 ± 0.010 -0.818 ± 0.009 -0.896 ± 0.008 -0.819 ± 0.007 -0.796 ± 0.006 -0.907 ± 0.011 -0.780 ± 0.008 -0.826 ± 0.009 -1.119 ± 0.037 -0.796 ± 0.006 -0.894 ± 0.011 -0.745 ± 0.010 -0.926 ± 0.008 -0.930 ± 0.018 -1.414 ± 0.030 -0.958 ± 0.007 -0.843 ± 0.007 -0.937 ± 0.009 -0.730 ± 0.008 -0.858 ± 0.008 -0.846 ± 0.012 -1.011 ± 0.008 -0.882 ± 0.007 -1.161 ± 0.009 -0.910 ± 0.009 -0.788 ± 0.008 -0.725 ± 0.010 -0.818 ± 0.006 -0.945 ± 0.010 -0.797 ± 0.009 -0.825 ± 0.009 -0.939 ± 0.007 -1.104 ± 0.012 -0.942 ± 0.009 -0.752 ± 0.009 -1.286 ± 0.040 -0.636 ± 0.013 -0.713 ± 0.006 -0.739 ± 0.010 -0.835 ± 0.010 -1.257 ± 0.016 -0.773 ± 0.012 -0.804 ± 0.009 -0.928 ± 0.008 -0.949 ± 0.009 -0.992 ± 0.010 -0.999 ± 0.011 -0.992 ± 0.015 -1.051 ± 0.013 -0.773 ± 0.007 (9) O3N2 1.897 ± 0.005 1.971 ± 0.016 1.640 ± 0.003 1.677 ± 0.006 1.941 ± 0.010 2.147 ± 0.010 2.010 ± 0.006 1.881 ± 0.005 2.106 ± 0.011 2.123 ± 0.021 2.212 ± 0.014 2.651 ± 0.063 1.883 ± 0.005 2.104 ± 0.010 2.015 ± 0.014 2.260 ± 0.008 2.312 ± 0.026 2.482 ± 0.014 2.137 ± 0.008 1.985 ± 0.006 1.939 ± 0.005 1.853 ± 0.007 2.136 ± 0.009 1.941 ± 0.014 2.306 ± 0.008 2.087 ± 0.007 2.532 ± 0.009 1.826 ± 0.004 2.047 ± 0.006 2.005 ± 0.012 2.053 ± 0.006 2.353 ± 0.012 2.022 ± 0.009 2.222 ± 0.013 2.112 ± 0.005 2.577 ± 0.021 2.305 ± 0.012 1.804 ± 0.006 2.724 ± 0.041 1.737 ± 0.010 1.730 ± 0.005 1.797 ± 0.008 1.992 ± 0.010 2.691 ± 0.017 1.923 ± 0.009 2.103 ± 0.009 2.103 ± 0.006 2.239 ± 0.008 2.258 ± 0.020 2.273 ± 0.008 1.787 ± 0.005 1.939 ± 0.006 1.950 ± 0.007 (10) P 0.822 0.649 0.684 0.695 0.689 0.732 0.393 0.642 0.760 0.684 0.703 0.870 0.687 0.747 0.647 0.740 0.816 0.902 0.767 0.714 0.798 0.641 0.725 0.688 0.818 0.733 0.885 0.757 0.698 0.665 0.678 0.786 0.645 0.738 0.784 0.826 0.764 0.618 0.909 0.595 0.585 0.638 0.696 0.906 0.665 0.739 0.761 0.774 0.804 0.823 0.785 0.785 0.666 Table 1. The properties of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) 3 (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 544- 52201- 67 544- 52201- 610 548- 51986- 324 548- 51986- 347 549- 51981- 90 550- 51959- 485 553- 51999- 134 555- 52266- 517 557- 52253- 590 560- 52296- 204 564- 52224- 363 566- 52238- 497 568- 52254- 244 569- 52264- 609 570- 52266- 61 582- 52045- 445 587- 52026- 155 587- 52026- 495 588- 52045- 483 589- 52055- 483 590- 52057- 200 594- 52045- 493 597- 52059- 460 597- 52059- 586 602- 52072- 19 605- 52353- 616 606- 52365- 604 608- 52081- 255 609- 52339- 441 613- 52345- 342 615- 52347- 606 616- 52374- 349 620- 52375- 428 620- 52375- 506 621- 52055- 618 623- 52051- 396 625- 52145- 72 627- 52144- 253 627- 52144- 295 627- 52144- 446 628- 52083- 555 629- 52051- 497 631- 52079- 307 633- 52079- 336 636- 52176- 439 637- 52174- 399 639- 52146- 143 648- 52559- 288 649- 52201- 637 651- 52141- 304 656- 52148- 140 658- 52146- 17 659- 52199- 307 J080139.46+382305.2 J080406.22+393656.8 J081829.71+453309.3 J082059.30+461823.4 J083350.23+454933.6 J083914.95+481518.3 J091052.58+522756.5 J093126.23+551221.6 J095513.13+573203.1 J103103.99+585602.0 J084216.95+033806.7 J090531.08+033530.4 J092251.26+025607.4 J093815.91+043408.4 J094646.66+033812.8 J140725.32+052837.9 J144610.32+033921.6 J144441.37+040941.7 J145424.60+035925.0 J150339.41+035051.7 J151045.41+033038.5 J154654.55+030902.1 J113303.79+651341.1 J114047.42+644710.3 J131426.57+633311.5 J141145.34+623911.1 J142619.15+622750.0 J144329.11+585543.6 J144845.84+634620.2 J150728.68+595913.2 J153737.27+584740.5 J153534.13+545534.3 J155829.49+520650.7 J160041.62+514443.0 J161156.30+532630.1 J161031.34+522305.9 J163106.19+484527.0 J163240.72+463338.1 J163055.78+461805.7 J163445.34+465903.1 J164235.52+422349.5 J164359.16+443632.7 J164645.10+413208.8 J165711.23+401915.6 J205430.86-061739.8 J210114.40-055510.2 J211902.28-074226.6 J234148.29-105619.6 J235604.68-085423.4 J000430.34-101129.7 J004645.72-105410.4 J010513.49-103740.8 J010409.91-095346.6 (4) t3 (104K) 1.086 ± 0.036 1.067 ± 0.068 1.339 ± 0.098 1.027 ± 0.043 0.947 ± 0.049 1.188 ± 0.081 1.040 ± 0.043 1.121 ± 0.030 1.169 ± 0.074 1.075 ± 0.066 1.094 ± 0.044 1.484 ± 0.018 1.078 ± 0.049 1.106 ± 0.037 1.145 ± 0.061 1.234 ± 0.028 1.105 ± 0.039 1.679 ± 0.022 1.183 ± 0.051 1.159 ± 0.078 1.094 ± 0.057 1.154 ± 0.025 1.363 ± 0.053 1.102 ± 0.032 1.057 ± 0.052 1.106 ± 0.052 1.048 ± 0.039 1.195 ± 0.084 1.062 ± 0.054 1.138 ± 0.034 1.253 ± 0.053 1.102 ± 0.037 1.032 ± 0.061 1.230 ± 0.060 1.064 ± 0.047 1.405 ± 0.057 1.812 ± 0.177 0.986 ± 0.054 1.052 ± 0.050 1.010 ± 0.040 1.105 ± 0.031 0.957 ± 0.045 1.242 ± 0.091 1.080 ± 0.064 1.217 ± 0.089 1.056 ± 0.029 1.276 ± 0.047 1.049 ± 0.048 1.121 ± 0.044 1.489 ± 0.055 1.128 ± 0.072 1.187 ± 0.041 1.205 ± 0.074 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.258 ± 0.036 8.209 ± 0.062 8.011 ± 0.054 8.314 ± 0.043 8.453 ± 0.056 8.130 ± 0.058 8.335 ± 0.039 8.244 ± 0.025 8.152 ± 0.056 8.199 ± 0.054 8.298 ± 0.043 7.871 ± 0.018 8.277 ± 0.041 8.245 ± 0.035 8.220 ± 0.053 8.103 ± 0.025 8.228 ± 0.030 7.841 ± 0.021 8.177 ± 0.036 8.138 ± 0.062 8.272 ± 0.049 8.209 ± 0.022 8.012 ± 0.035 8.274 ± 0.029 8.302 ± 0.048 8.269 ± 0.048 8.328 ± 0.039 8.116 ± 0.064 8.323 ± 0.053 8.164 ± 0.028 8.124 ± 0.041 8.269 ± 0.032 8.285 ± 0.057 8.132 ± 0.047 8.305 ± 0.041 7.905 ± 0.037 7.664 ± 0.058 8.365 ± 0.056 8.329 ± 0.050 8.372 ± 0.043 8.232 ± 0.026 8.473 ± 0.051 8.064 ± 0.066 8.273 ± 0.061 8.116 ± 0.062 8.360 ± 0.029 8.048 ± 0.033 8.279 ± 0.045 8.233 ± 0.040 7.865 ± 0.033 8.283 ± 0.063 8.202 ± 0.035 8.129 ± 0.055 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.414 8.624 8.163 8.052 8.591 8.248 8.282 8.547 8.603 8.699 8.272 7.914 8.575 8.713 8.557 8.032 8.573 7.930 8.573 8.574 8.213 8.554 8.193 8.313 8.595 8.508 8.559 8.043 8.203 8.759 8.542 8.613 8.621 8.118 8.144 7.929 8.148 8.681 8.566 8.534 8.589 8.481 8.023 8.291 8.300 8.401 8.032 8.163 8.120 7.933 8.290 8.136 8.060 (7) N2 -1.353 ± 0.010 -0.983 ± 0.011 -1.227 ± 0.012 -1.310 ± 0.008 -1.137 ± 0.012 -1.175 ± 0.011 -1.234 ± 0.007 -1.270 ± 0.008 -1.148 ± 0.011 -0.847 ± 0.006 -1.315 ± 0.046 -1.758 ± 0.012 -1.078 ± 0.007 -1.243 ± 0.009 -1.196 ± 0.011 -1.533 ± 0.012 -1.099 ± 0.006 -2.036 ± 0.029 -1.069 ± 0.009 -1.051 ± 0.010 -1.231 ± 0.010 -1.327 ± 0.009 -1.420 ± 0.032 -1.345 ± 0.008 -1.142 ± 0.007 -1.258 ± 0.016 -1.329 ± 0.010 -1.375 ± 0.014 -1.346 ± 0.012 -1.039 ± 0.006 -1.147 ± 0.046 -1.132 ± 0.007 -1.031 ± 0.007 -1.319 ± 0.017 -1.275 ± 0.010 -1.628 ± 0.025 -1.216 ± 0.017 -0.977 ± 0.006 -1.184 ± 0.010 -1.212 ± 0.011 -1.164 ± 0.006 -1.260 ± 0.008 -1.430 ± 0.019 -1.249 ± 0.011 -1.142 ± 0.012 -1.333 ± 0.011 -1.447 ± 0.011 -1.223 ± 0.008 -1.427 ± 0.016 -1.594 ± 0.034 -1.346 ± 0.015 -1.529 ± 0.014 -1.486 ± 0.019 (8) S2 -0.947 ± 0.008 -0.770 ± 0.010 -0.676 ± 0.008 -0.810 ± 0.006 -0.832 ± 0.009 -0.712 ± 0.008 -0.777 ± 0.005 -0.892 ± 0.007 -0.798 ± 0.012 -0.727 ± 0.008 -1.000 ± 0.018 -1.207 ± 0.008 -0.747 ± 0.006 -0.981 ± 0.008 -0.928 ± 0.015 -1.059 ± 0.013 -0.741 ± 0.007 -1.621 ± 0.025 -0.803 ± 0.010 -0.764 ± 0.009 -0.748 ± 0.007 -0.971 ± 0.007 -1.098 ± 0.041 -0.920 ± 0.007 -0.833 ± 0.007 -0.921 ± 0.029 -0.972 ± 0.008 -0.816 ± 0.010 -0.874 ± 0.019 -0.909 ± 0.008 -1.027 ± 0.023 -0.891 ± 0.011 -0.778 ± 0.008 -0.742 ± 0.009 -0.745 ± 0.007 -1.058 ± 0.016 -0.632 ± 0.012 -0.823 ± 0.009 -0.895 ± 0.014 -0.853 ± 0.009 -0.857 ± 0.007 -0.872 ± 0.007 -0.826 ± 0.013 -0.829 ± 0.009 -0.706 ± 0.008 -0.905 ± 0.008 -0.907 ± 0.010 -0.754 ± 0.006 -0.933 ± 0.014 -1.322 ± 0.047 -0.886 ± 0.011 -0.978 ± 0.009 -0.830 ± 0.011 (9) O3N2 2.141 ± 0.008 1.610 ± 0.009 1.855 ± 0.010 2.026 ± 0.006 1.855 ± 0.011 1.801 ± 0.008 1.915 ± 0.004 2.045 ± 0.006 1.842 ± 0.009 1.381 ± 0.004 2.178 ± 0.044 2.632 ± 0.009 1.765 ± 0.005 2.054 ± 0.007 2.016 ± 0.008 2.373 ± 0.010 1.773 ± 0.004 3.052 ± 0.027 1.799 ± 0.007 1.728 ± 0.007 1.925 ± 0.006 2.150 ± 0.007 2.292 ± 0.030 2.133 ± 0.006 1.854 ± 0.005 2.081 ± 0.014 2.128 ± 0.008 2.079 ± 0.011 2.145 ± 0.010 1.773 ± 0.004 2.023 ± 0.045 1.906 ± 0.005 1.659 ± 0.005 2.075 ± 0.008 1.970 ± 0.008 2.426 ± 0.023 1.810 ± 0.013 1.665 ± 0.005 1.976 ± 0.009 1.980 ± 0.009 1.893 ± 0.004 2.002 ± 0.006 2.154 ± 0.016 2.032 ± 0.009 1.831 ± 0.010 2.165 ± 0.010 2.210 ± 0.009 1.905 ± 0.006 2.227 ± 0.014 2.434 ± 0.033 2.196 ± 0.012 2.377 ± 0.012 2.218 ± 0.017 (10) P 0.781 0.673 0.572 0.715 0.697 0.598 0.628 0.731 0.683 0.565 0.819 0.898 0.648 0.798 0.779 0.834 0.648 0.961 0.671 0.682 0.635 0.788 0.842 0.735 0.681 0.786 0.771 0.695 0.752 0.753 0.833 0.727 0.637 0.696 0.642 0.833 0.550 0.697 0.753 0.741 0.707 0.678 0.725 0.765 0.650 0.759 0.753 0.681 0.778 0.856 0.765 0.780 0.701 4 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 659- 52199- 435 660- 52177- 414 660- 52177- 450 663- 52145- 406 664- 52174- 112 664- 52174- 447 666- 52149- 532 668- 52162- 89 716- 52203- 368 726- 52226- 532 730- 52466- 376 735- 52519- 461 740- 52263- 267 753- 52233- 593 755- 52235- 300 756- 52577- 37 761- 52266- 443 761- 52266- 454 762- 52232- 217 762- 52232- 575 767- 52252- 463 768- 52281- 193 769- 52282- 100 769- 52282- 575 771- 52370- 490 772- 52375- 270 773- 52376- 143 775- 52295- 291 779- 52342- 355 782- 52320- 22 784- 52327- 179 792- 52353- 110 794- 52376- 460 817- 52381- 424 828- 52317- 319 834- 52316- 157 836- 52376- 378 838- 52378- 595 841- 52375- 333 845- 52381- 1 846- 52407- 267 847- 52426- 522 848- 52669- 528 853- 52374- 577 857- 52314- 386 859- 52317- 70 864- 52320- 379 870- 52325- 321 879- 52365- 14 881- 52368- 567 884- 52374- 404 886- 52381- 129 886- 52381- 605 J010643.32-092223.1 J011616.82-085021.4 J011729.09-084403.8 J013844.90-083540.5 J014721.67-091646.2 J014713.82-080702.6 J020356.90-080758.4 J022037.66-092907.4 J215637.75-070007.9 J231322.68-084503.9 J212442.05+114751.0 J220802.88+131334.6 J224422.71+131608.7 J002652.08+152737.8 J073928.39+314502.1 J075507.92+340827.6 J082542.86+422758.6 J082614.16+422833.6 J083343.87+431951.6 J083803.72+445900.2 J092429.86+514301.2 J093733.77+523924.8 J095131.78+525936.2 J095408.42+544606.9 J101242.98+613302.8 J102132.50+614404.5 J104500.96+621527.3 J111439.19+605418.3 J120725.66+623458.0 J130445.62+622420.8 J132002.90+614627.4 J150127.22+553126.3 J152045.65+533807.0 J163210.01+412055.6 J083145.67+384756.7 J093855.90+471228.8 J112145.51+055756.5 J114359.54+052154.7 J115641.37+054315.6 J123523.86+034536.0 J123538.74+041245.0 J124954.84+060610.4 J125657.58+055616.4 J133810.13+053504.5 J074034.66+244136.6 J080000.70+274641.8 J083833.53+374216.5 J092600.41+442736.0 J113247.69+510215.3 J115240.85+533228.3 J122611.16+532602.0 J125427.22+510436.1 J125931.51+531554.0 (4) t3 (104K) 1.117 ± 0.059 1.263 ± 0.041 1.045 ± 0.038 1.233 ± 0.046 1.139 ± 0.042 1.251 ± 0.063 1.027 ± 0.048 1.220 ± 0.028 1.198 ± 0.082 1.080 ± 0.068 1.014 ± 0.037 1.192 ± 0.041 1.021 ± 0.063 1.273 ± 0.066 1.086 ± 0.039 1.146 ± 0.035 1.342 ± 0.025 1.123 ± 0.074 1.002 ± 0.058 1.205 ± 0.050 1.208 ± 0.048 1.114 ± 0.068 1.268 ± 0.021 1.069 ± 0.040 1.123 ± 0.030 1.277 ± 0.067 1.269 ± 0.083 1.163 ± 0.039 0.993 ± 0.043 0.961 ± 0.042 1.247 ± 0.088 1.113 ± 0.072 1.070 ± 0.054 1.105 ± 0.043 1.107 ± 0.067 1.100 ± 0.053 1.066 ± 0.039 1.459 ± 0.033 1.082 ± 0.067 1.099 ± 0.049 1.113 ± 0.041 1.105 ± 0.035 0.949 ± 0.055 1.000 ± 0.055 1.096 ± 0.038 1.117 ± 0.031 1.137 ± 0.064 1.268 ± 0.029 1.260 ± 0.046 0.997 ± 0.049 1.497 ± 0.027 1.197 ± 0.083 1.044 ± 0.049 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.255 ± 0.054 8.060 ± 0.029 8.305 ± 0.036 8.118 ± 0.033 8.218 ± 0.036 8.056 ± 0.043 8.307 ± 0.043 8.140 ± 0.023 8.110 ± 0.058 8.274 ± 0.056 8.324 ± 0.036 8.127 ± 0.033 8.338 ± 0.062 8.048 ± 0.049 8.264 ± 0.037 8.185 ± 0.030 8.032 ± 0.018 8.241 ± 0.057 8.363 ± 0.056 8.099 ± 0.036 8.117 ± 0.032 8.237 ± 0.054 8.087 ± 0.021 8.318 ± 0.037 8.248 ± 0.028 8.086 ± 0.045 8.058 ± 0.048 8.199 ± 0.030 8.310 ± 0.043 8.382 ± 0.045 8.109 ± 0.059 8.255 ± 0.059 8.326 ± 0.054 8.226 ± 0.036 8.257 ± 0.059 8.259 ± 0.047 8.300 ± 0.042 7.881 ± 0.024 8.251 ± 0.059 8.255 ± 0.044 8.260 ± 0.034 8.230 ± 0.029 8.368 ± 0.059 8.332 ± 0.054 8.277 ± 0.035 8.269 ± 0.030 8.239 ± 0.059 8.094 ± 0.023 8.087 ± 0.034 8.303 ± 0.051 7.853 ± 0.022 8.153 ± 0.061 8.305 ± 0.046 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.159 8.070 8.567 8.114 8.123 8.038 8.594 8.407 8.352 8.484 8.610 8.485 8.544 8.722 8.063 8.729 8.117 8.431 8.157 8.598 8.124 8.290 8.027 8.366 8.105 8.303 8.594 8.311 8.709 8.695 8.196 8.160 8.421 8.487 8.188 8.096 8.537 8.717 8.567 8.159 8.420 8.338 8.678 8.672 8.366 8.189 8.416 8.459 8.724 8.603 7.937 8.184 8.601 (7) N2 -1.369 ± 0.016 -1.386 ± 0.011 -1.139 ± 0.008 -1.404 ± 0.013 -1.391 ± 0.016 -1.388 ± 0.014 -1.091 ± 0.007 -1.144 ± 0.006 -1.138 ± 0.009 -1.081 ± 0.008 -1.007 ± 0.005 -1.295 ± 0.009 -1.150 ± 0.010 -1.249 ± 0.031 -1.367 ± 0.009 -1.012 ± 0.006 -1.506 ± 0.011 -1.097 ± 0.009 -1.207 ± 0.008 -1.186 ± 0.011 -1.284 ± 0.009 -1.197 ± 0.009 -1.599 ± 0.009 -1.247 ± 0.034 -1.453 ± 0.009 -1.263 ± 0.014 -0.691 ± 0.005 -1.284 ± 0.009 -0.970 ± 0.006 -0.936 ± 0.005 -1.247 ± 0.015 -1.284 ± 0.012 -1.246 ± 0.019 -1.164 ± 0.009 -1.310 ± 0.014 -1.384 ± 0.011 -1.298 ± 0.010 -1.457 ± 0.014 -1.120 ± 0.009 -1.332 ± 0.011 -1.246 ± 0.007 -1.233 ± 0.007 -0.972 ± 0.006 -1.030 ± 0.006 -1.312 ± 0.029 -1.408 ± 0.009 -1.415 ± 0.034 -1.409 ± 0.011 -1.305 ± 0.016 -0.986 ± 0.006 -1.858 ± 0.019 -1.267 ± 0.013 -1.092 ± 0.008 (8) S2 -0.871 ± 0.012 -0.900 ± 0.008 -0.824 ± 0.009 -0.860 ± 0.009 -0.841 ± 0.013 -0.797 ± 0.009 -0.759 ± 0.007 -0.985 ± 0.007 -0.710 ± 0.008 -0.686 ± 0.007 -0.816 ± 0.005 -0.908 ± 0.008 -0.776 ± 0.007 -1.026 ± 0.027 -0.810 ± 0.006 -0.876 ± 0.009 -0.945 ± 0.012 -0.694 ± 0.007 -0.705 ± 0.007 -0.821 ± 0.010 -0.740 ± 0.006 -0.743 ± 0.007 -1.103 ± 0.006 -0.874 ± 0.009 -0.914 ± 0.007 -0.872 ± 0.012 -0.477 ± 0.006 -0.850 ± 0.007 -0.830 ± 0.006 -0.813 ± 0.005 -0.769 ± 0.011 -0.741 ± 0.009 -0.887 ± 0.015 -0.771 ± 0.009 -0.846 ± 0.013 -0.810 ± 0.008 -0.934 ± 0.011 -1.172 ± 0.013 -0.755 ± 0.008 -0.828 ± 0.018 -0.826 ± 0.006 -0.799 ± 0.006 -0.790 ± 0.007 -0.819 ± 0.006 -0.944 ± 0.012 -0.939 ± 0.007 -1.141 ± 0.039 -1.020 ± 0.011 -1.047 ± 0.010 -0.737 ± 0.006 -1.138 ± 0.009 -0.779 ± 0.010 -0.815 ± 0.008 (9) O3N2 2.171 ± 0.012 2.154 ± 0.009 1.855 ± 0.005 2.184 ± 0.011 2.177 ± 0.014 2.079 ± 0.011 1.748 ± 0.006 1.973 ± 0.005 1.732 ± 0.007 1.706 ± 0.006 1.687 ± 0.003 2.064 ± 0.007 1.846 ± 0.008 2.081 ± 0.028 2.130 ± 0.007 1.778 ± 0.005 2.339 ± 0.009 1.725 ± 0.007 1.852 ± 0.006 1.876 ± 0.009 1.960 ± 0.007 1.851 ± 0.007 2.468 ± 0.007 2.023 ± 0.032 2.257 ± 0.007 2.031 ± 0.011 1.218 ± 0.003 2.034 ± 0.007 1.579 ± 0.003 1.580 ± 0.003 1.937 ± 0.012 1.952 ± 0.009 2.072 ± 0.015 1.856 ± 0.006 2.074 ± 0.011 2.121 ± 0.009 2.129 ± 0.008 2.288 ± 0.011 1.793 ± 0.007 2.094 ± 0.008 1.997 ± 0.005 1.932 ± 0.005 1.542 ± 0.003 1.640 ± 0.004 2.117 ± 0.027 2.245 ± 0.006 2.306 ± 0.032 2.257 ± 0.009 2.116 ± 0.014 1.627 ± 0.004 2.696 ± 0.015 1.982 ± 0.010 1.787 ± 0.006 (10) P 0.755 0.756 0.697 0.738 0.750 0.682 0.653 0.793 0.574 0.576 0.682 0.768 0.673 0.845 0.743 0.758 0.788 0.560 0.614 0.689 0.644 0.603 0.849 0.719 0.757 0.709 0.491 0.693 0.652 0.663 0.624 0.601 0.770 0.672 0.718 0.695 0.821 0.854 0.655 0.732 0.691 0.676 0.611 0.616 0.763 0.781 0.862 0.813 0.785 0.692 0.861 0.661 0.678 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) 5 (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 890- 52583- 49 890- 52583- 65 893- 52589- 76 893- 52589- 177 896- 52592- 125 901- 52641- 536 902- 52409- 135 903- 52400- 600 904- 52381- 501 908- 52373- 27 909- 52379- 616 915- 52443- 598 926- 52413- 279 927- 52577- 514 934- 52672- 483 936- 52705- 477 937- 52707- 275 940- 52670- 594 945- 52652- 423 949- 52427- 359 952- 52409- 264 952- 52409- 439 952- 52409- 447 955- 52409- 383 956- 52401- 20 956- 52401- 347 957- 52398- 210 957- 52398- 530 959- 52411- 137 963- 52643- 165 964- 52646- 570 969- 52442- 354 971- 52644- 599 972- 52435- 370 978- 52441- 408 979- 52427- 83 984- 52442- 263 987- 52523- 394 987- 52523- 440 988- 52520- 456 992- 52644- 19 997- 52734- 474 999- 52636- 150 1001- 52670- 385 1001- 52670- 611 1002- 52646- 525 1005- 52703- 268 1007- 52706- 225 1008- 52707- 430 1013- 52707- 229 1014- 52707- 393 1020- 52721- 287 1021- 52460- 446 J075308.57+304512.6 J075454.69+312821.0 J082010.56+374354.4 J081755.35+372959.6 J084419.08+414310.2 J093816.85+504200.0 J094903.36+500126.0 J100751.67+525624.0 J102024.05+540043.9 J111558.18+554806.4 J112313.30+570327.7 J140539.17-015334.4 J153804.80-014940.8 J074553.04+231017.0 J084725.06+355451.4 J085949.13+380632.0 J090741.52+385202.2 J094330.67+422142.8 J095859.35+552415.8 J104337.66+580820.7 J112509.46+584700.9 J112555.10+593319.0 J113116.49+601229.5 J121142.86+603626.6 J124340.29+590311.1 J122630.60+595712.6 J125328.61+584021.7 J125856.26+604730.8 J132455.03+574510.7 J105315.89+471517.2 J110918.05+494753.8 J115630.62+500822.2 J123153.64+500056.5 J165844.50+351923.1 J171400.93+313023.4 J172006.75+255827.4 J205510.41-001903.0 J211958.32+005233.6 J212043.97+010006.8 J212829.71+003021.9 J093625.35+050332.0 J101637.77+065214.5 J103404.17+061210.4 J104727.84+072238.2 J105445.74+073731.8 J105854.79+080043.9 J094422.13+480130.3 J100912.50+500604.6 J101855.46+515527.8 J111824.48+540115.9 J112544.09+550532.2 J122842.45+535723.0 J204018.05+010324.4 (4) t3 (104K) 1.039 ± 0.044 1.057 ± 0.063 1.366 ± 0.081 1.137 ± 0.066 1.063 ± 0.039 1.253 ± 0.038 1.091 ± 0.037 1.216 ± 0.050 1.078 ± 0.044 1.175 ± 0.037 1.362 ± 0.027 1.160 ± 0.068 1.072 ± 0.063 1.080 ± 0.048 1.069 ± 0.025 1.260 ± 0.032 1.107 ± 0.066 1.013 ± 0.058 1.161 ± 0.040 1.235 ± 0.040 1.004 ± 0.046 1.235 ± 0.025 1.105 ± 0.058 1.166 ± 0.054 1.071 ± 0.070 1.126 ± 0.063 1.114 ± 0.027 1.074 ± 0.045 1.163 ± 0.028 1.289 ± 0.057 1.109 ± 0.030 1.156 ± 0.036 1.105 ± 0.057 1.108 ± 0.035 1.053 ± 0.043 1.110 ± 0.066 1.063 ± 0.065 1.145 ± 0.039 1.025 ± 0.058 1.100 ± 0.067 1.362 ± 0.036 1.184 ± 0.079 1.156 ± 0.036 0.983 ± 0.055 1.127 ± 0.058 0.917 ± 0.051 1.446 ± 0.045 1.339 ± 0.108 1.267 ± 0.033 1.188 ± 0.086 1.039 ± 0.066 1.183 ± 0.052 1.075 ± 0.064 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.356 ± 0.045 8.332 ± 0.063 8.022 ± 0.046 8.170 ± 0.048 8.256 ± 0.035 8.101 ± 0.027 8.256 ± 0.034 8.105 ± 0.034 8.272 ± 0.045 8.166 ± 0.028 7.966 ± 0.021 8.192 ± 0.054 8.320 ± 0.060 8.248 ± 0.041 8.326 ± 0.025 8.113 ± 0.027 8.212 ± 0.055 8.367 ± 0.059 8.184 ± 0.033 8.322 ± 0.076 8.360 ± 0.046 8.157 ± 0.016 8.224 ± 0.053 8.204 ± 0.045 8.309 ± 0.063 8.235 ± 0.057 8.272 ± 0.027 8.289 ± 0.044 8.219 ± 0.028 8.083 ± 0.034 8.249 ± 0.025 8.147 ± 0.029 8.192 ± 0.048 8.251 ± 0.030 8.309 ± 0.039 8.223 ± 0.054 8.235 ± 0.053 8.235 ± 0.037 8.335 ± 0.055 8.229 ± 0.053 8.015 ± 0.028 8.140 ± 0.060 8.185 ± 0.030 8.342 ± 0.060 8.230 ± 0.047 8.503 ± 0.064 7.958 ± 0.033 7.910 ± 0.063 8.097 ± 0.024 8.226 ± 0.071 8.275 ± 0.062 8.166 ± 0.047 8.253 ± 0.058 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.227 8.336 8.171 8.501 8.714 8.260 8.608 8.076 8.162 8.334 8.004 8.146 8.352 8.681 8.570 8.118 8.610 8.429 8.214 8.049 8.612 8.197 8.103 8.235 8.258 8.144 8.306 8.297 8.760 8.472 8.453 8.764 8.673 8.329 8.621 8.219 8.740 8.138 8.513 8.274 8.118 8.078 8.587 8.847 8.479 8.578 8.055 8.660 8.153 8.166 8.688 8.131 8.536 (7) N2 -1.299 ± 0.010 -1.352 ± 0.016 -1.315 ± 0.016 -1.073 ± 0.007 -0.925 ± 0.005 -1.341 ± 0.015 -1.058 ± 0.006 -1.396 ± 0.017 -1.374 ± 0.011 -1.237 ± 0.007 -1.747 ± 0.022 -1.312 ± 0.011 -1.294 ± 0.008 -0.981 ± 0.007 -1.248 ± 0.008 -1.512 ± 0.014 -1.141 ± 0.009 -1.116 ± 0.009 -1.266 ± 0.010 -1.497 ± 0.013 -1.153 ± 0.007 -1.347 ± 0.009 -1.343 ± 0.013 -1.295 ± 0.013 -1.234 ± 0.015 -1.429 ± 0.024 -1.375 ± 0.009 -1.319 ± 0.012 -1.281 ± 0.009 -1.127 ± 0.009 -1.169 ± 0.007 -1.040 ± 0.007 -1.000 ± 0.007 -1.248 ± 0.008 -1.032 ± 0.007 -1.214 ± 0.014 -0.812 ± 0.005 -1.449 ± 0.012 -1.064 ± 0.007 -1.139 ± 0.009 -1.516 ± 0.013 -1.375 ± 0.017 -1.217 ± 0.008 -0.909 ± 0.007 -1.173 ± 0.037 -1.198 ± 0.008 -1.813 ± 0.027 -0.946 ± 0.009 -1.418 ± 0.011 -1.562 ± 0.027 -0.990 ± 0.007 -1.455 ± 0.014 -1.156 ± 0.009 (8) S2 -0.839 ± 0.009 -0.943 ± 0.011 -0.764 ± 0.010 -0.676 ± 0.006 -0.832 ± 0.007 -0.903 ± 0.013 -0.844 ± 0.008 -0.802 ± 0.008 -0.907 ± 0.009 -0.800 ± 0.006 -1.072 ± 0.010 -0.818 ± 0.008 -0.860 ± 0.007 -0.838 ± 0.011 -0.923 ± 0.008 -0.988 ± 0.010 -0.797 ± 0.009 -0.730 ± 0.008 -0.808 ± 0.007 -0.996 ± 0.010 -0.839 ± 0.006 -0.817 ± 0.006 -0.871 ± 0.011 -0.823 ± 0.012 -0.759 ± 0.009 -0.930 ± 0.013 -0.930 ± 0.007 -0.889 ± 0.009 -1.056 ± 0.010 -0.748 ± 0.008 -0.780 ± 0.006 -0.950 ± 0.013 -0.824 ± 0.010 -0.822 ± 0.007 -0.841 ± 0.013 -0.760 ± 0.010 -0.709 ± 0.006 -0.947 ± 0.009 -0.722 ± 0.006 -0.664 ± 0.007 -1.050 ± 0.014 -0.793 ± 0.011 -0.911 ± 0.007 -0.919 ± 0.016 -0.836 ± 0.014 -0.851 ± 0.008 -1.169 ± 0.016 -0.746 ± 0.010 -0.932 ± 0.012 -1.002 ± 0.019 -0.815 ± 0.008 -0.965 ± 0.011 -0.782 ± 0.007 (9) O3N2 2.093 ± 0.008 2.178 ± 0.014 2.055 ± 0.014 1.626 ± 0.004 1.614 ± 0.003 2.124 ± 0.012 1.816 ± 0.004 2.070 ± 0.014 2.162 ± 0.008 1.946 ± 0.004 2.562 ± 0.020 2.058 ± 0.007 2.074 ± 0.006 1.669 ± 0.006 2.071 ± 0.006 2.384 ± 0.012 1.809 ± 0.006 1.836 ± 0.007 2.046 ± 0.008 2.291 ± 0.011 1.842 ± 0.004 2.133 ± 0.007 2.098 ± 0.011 2.121 ± 0.011 1.950 ± 0.013 2.240 ± 0.022 2.211 ± 0.006 2.105 ± 0.009 2.152 ± 0.007 1.815 ± 0.006 1.890 ± 0.005 1.772 ± 0.005 1.664 ± 0.004 2.011 ± 0.006 1.746 ± 0.006 1.903 ± 0.012 1.354 ± 0.004 2.303 ± 0.010 1.722 ± 0.002 1.753 ± 0.006 2.396 ± 0.011 2.069 ± 0.014 1.991 ± 0.006 1.587 ± 0.005 1.897 ± 0.035 1.931 ± 0.006 2.721 ± 0.023 1.532 ± 0.006 2.232 ± 0.009 2.439 ± 0.024 1.631 ± 0.005 2.308 ± 0.012 1.871 ± 0.007 (10) P 0.742 0.783 0.657 0.541 0.696 0.736 0.743 0.648 0.780 0.667 0.823 0.699 0.716 0.681 0.771 0.830 0.659 0.680 0.752 0.523 0.667 0.695 0.753 0.779 0.652 0.778 0.785 0.759 0.824 0.608 0.674 0.748 0.680 0.724 0.681 0.664 0.558 0.806 0.624 0.588 0.844 0.668 0.754 0.717 0.677 0.711 0.866 0.636 0.765 0.785 0.656 0.842 0.714 6 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315 316 1024- 52826- 106 1026- 52558- 122 1026- 52558- 596 1028- 52562- 373 1028- 52562- 388 1028- 52562- 422 1028- 52562- 592 1028- 52884- 386 1028- 52884- 562 1030- 52914- 77 1030- 52914- 107 1032- 53175- 635 1033- 52822- 458 1034- 52525- 551 1034- 52813- 521 1035- 52816- 574 1040- 52722- 21 1040- 52722- 358 1042- 52725- 399 1043- 52465- 78 1052- 52466- 115 1054- 52516- 499 1060- 52636- 21 1060- 52636- 328 1063- 52591- 389 1064- 52577- 509 1067- 52616- 112 1069- 52590- 399 1073- 52649- 409 1073- 52649- 419 1074- 52937- 186 1074- 52937- 573 1081- 52531- 17 1083- 52520- 354 1084- 52591- 99 1093- 52591- 261 1094- 52524- 543 1095- 52521- 381 1095- 52521- 619 1096- 52974- 102 1096- 52974- 630 1101- 52621- 576 1104- 52912- 439 1104- 52912- 511 1116- 52932- 12 1116- 52932- 89 1156- 52641- 378 1156- 52641- 423 1158- 52668- 370 1160- 52674- 534 1163- 52669- 284 1168- 52731- 639 1170- 52756- 485 J210134.44-002846.9 J211451.48-011046.2 J211829.85+003059.4 J212705.80+005827.1 J212702.90+002701.8 J212829.71+003021.9 J213338.95+002605.2 J212705.80+005827.1 J213338.95+002605.2 J214642.29+000009.0 J214459.59-001140.2 J220412.46+002201.5 J220707.90+004658.8 J221549.25+010938.8 J221549.25+010938.8 J222358.95+005007.8 J132150.45+534127.9 J130728.44+542652.4 J133446.30+534927.4 J135624.07+523851.0 J153808.50+431421.1 J155411.09+400602.8 J075638.45+291819.8 J075230.29+301607.6 J033128.49+003737.5 J032713.08+003112.3 J030502.28-000453.7 J024359.02+003322.6 J021306.62+005612.4 J021332.93+010825.8 J020551.72-003229.0 J020817.62+004358.4 J011640.25-004712.8 J005410.34+003812.4 J005132.11-004608.0 J233817.90-001157.4 J233549.15+001314.8 J232122.52+003455.2 J232757.74+005819.2 J231845.21-002610.3 J232122.52+003455.2 J224041.33+005703.6 J221243.06+000648.6 J221523.06+000246.6 J205034.66-004619.9 J204827.46-005958.5 J033128.49+003737.5 J033047.69+002920.4 J135013.80+585313.5 J141652.46+571215.8 J144328.47+533919.0 J155548.46+465715.8 J160821.94+432738.5 (4) t3 (104K) 1.401 ± 0.099 1.142 ± 0.062 1.262 ± 0.041 1.362 ± 0.041 1.011 ± 0.056 1.004 ± 0.061 1.334 ± 0.038 1.291 ± 0.040 1.328 ± 0.032 1.076 ± 0.047 1.003 ± 0.050 1.328 ± 0.058 1.306 ± 0.097 1.197 ± 0.053 1.091 ± 0.047 1.217 ± 0.037 1.221 ± 0.061 1.123 ± 0.061 1.172 ± 0.052 1.203 ± 0.077 1.164 ± 0.078 1.098 ± 0.067 1.342 ± 0.090 1.247 ± 0.046 1.599 ± 0.082 1.184 ± 0.062 1.169 ± 0.059 1.304 ± 0.036 1.427 ± 0.018 1.419 ± 0.042 1.021 ± 0.057 1.145 ± 0.045 1.257 ± 0.075 1.259 ± 0.078 1.343 ± 0.097 1.212 ± 0.071 1.426 ± 0.069 1.217 ± 0.071 1.279 ± 0.096 1.124 ± 0.057 1.173 ± 0.061 1.257 ± 0.073 1.141 ± 0.061 1.304 ± 0.019 1.486 ± 0.095 1.615 ± 0.060 1.392 ± 0.065 1.166 ± 0.048 1.175 ± 0.085 1.103 ± 0.057 1.221 ± 0.031 1.243 ± 0.078 1.041 ± 0.064 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 7.982 ± 0.056 8.210 ± 0.051 8.102 ± 0.029 8.011 ± 0.027 8.357 ± 0.059 8.351 ± 0.058 8.024 ± 0.025 8.071 ± 0.028 8.029 ± 0.022 8.498 ± 0.057 8.355 ± 0.051 8.045 ± 0.045 8.035 ± 0.064 8.141 ± 0.040 8.273 ± 0.041 8.170 ± 0.032 8.127 ± 0.047 8.204 ± 0.045 8.162 ± 0.046 8.095 ± 0.058 8.174 ± 0.057 8.207 ± 0.061 7.944 ± 0.048 8.076 ± 0.035 7.789 ± 0.039 8.171 ± 0.050 8.161 ± 0.051 8.075 ± 0.028 7.972 ± 0.021 7.973 ± 0.030 8.292 ± 0.054 8.214 ± 0.040 8.141 ± 0.050 8.120 ± 0.059 7.957 ± 0.062 8.175 ± 0.054 7.887 ± 0.043 8.154 ± 0.057 8.067 ± 0.067 8.224 ± 0.046 8.204 ± 0.052 8.145 ± 0.052 8.221 ± 0.053 8.093 ± 0.020 7.867 ± 0.045 7.723 ± 0.030 7.919 ± 0.037 8.187 ± 0.038 8.113 ± 0.064 8.223 ± 0.048 8.121 ± 0.024 8.080 ± 0.055 8.309 ± 0.063 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.150 8.109 8.395 8.079 8.464 8.187 8.074 8.125 8.084 8.227 8.441 8.058 8.102 8.110 8.095 8.301 8.083 8.166 8.768 8.613 8.530 8.058 8.690 8.037 8.086 8.212 8.041 8.108 8.654 8.045 8.602 8.182 8.264 8.143 7.923 8.268 7.882 8.122 8.075 8.147 8.103 8.334 8.505 8.711 8.000 7.896 7.991 8.176 8.217 8.157 8.577 8.135 8.579 (7) N2 -1.370 ± 0.027 -1.378 ± 0.018 -1.320 ± 0.017 -1.647 ± 0.023 -1.256 ± 0.012 -1.139 ± 0.008 -1.610 ± 0.018 -1.552 ± 0.020 -1.597 ± 0.015 -1.420 ± 0.010 -1.242 ± 0.009 -1.512 ± 0.019 -1.473 ± 0.031 -1.341 ± 0.014 -1.372 ± 0.011 -1.310 ± 0.046 -1.545 ± 0.016 -1.172 ± 0.007 -1.319 ± 0.017 -1.191 ± 0.013 -1.067 ± 0.009 -1.299 ± 0.012 -0.834 ± 0.007 -1.556 ± 0.031 -1.439 ± 0.025 -1.320 ± 0.016 -1.478 ± 0.016 -1.606 ± 0.020 -1.555 ± 0.007 -1.699 ± 0.023 -1.022 ± 0.006 -1.440 ± 0.014 -1.355 ± 0.018 -1.546 ± 0.036 -2.024 ± 0.070 -1.338 ± 0.013 -1.746 ± 0.061 -1.558 ± 0.029 -1.596 ± 0.034 -1.297 ± 0.009 -1.626 ± 0.024 -1.400 ± 0.027 -1.278 ± 0.035 -1.350 ± 0.007 -1.528 ± 0.032 -1.828 ± 0.028 -1.506 ± 0.019 -1.360 ± 0.012 -1.160 ± 0.011 -1.212 ± 0.012 -1.259 ± 0.008 -1.238 ± 0.013 -1.157 ± 0.009 (8) S2 -0.824 ± 0.024 -0.823 ± 0.009 -0.904 ± 0.013 -0.993 ± 0.011 -0.872 ± 0.009 -0.645 ± 0.006 -0.961 ± 0.009 -0.951 ± 0.010 -0.962 ± 0.008 -0.957 ± 0.009 -0.829 ± 0.006 -0.862 ± 0.011 -0.865 ± 0.015 -0.818 ± 0.008 -0.816 ± 0.006 -1.008 ± 0.012 -0.908 ± 0.011 -0.702 ± 0.006 -1.098 ± 0.030 -0.880 ± 0.014 -0.684 ± 0.007 -0.769 ± 0.009 -0.731 ± 0.014 -0.943 ± 0.013 -0.809 ± 0.013 -0.859 ± 0.011 -0.935 ± 0.011 -1.053 ± 0.012 -1.259 ± 0.007 -1.047 ± 0.013 -0.700 ± 0.006 -0.995 ± 0.011 -0.874 ± 0.014 -1.109 ± 0.026 -1.082 ± 0.019 -0.889 ± 0.009 -1.284 ± 0.054 -0.988 ± 0.018 -0.940 ± 0.017 -0.784 ± 0.012 -1.005 ± 0.013 -0.986 ± 0.021 -0.965 ± 0.024 -1.162 ± 0.010 -0.902 ± 0.021 -1.089 ± 0.013 -0.891 ± 0.011 -0.880 ± 0.009 -0.716 ± 0.010 -0.719 ± 0.011 -0.925 ± 0.007 -0.697 ± 0.009 -0.815 ± 0.011 (9) O3N2 2.159 ± 0.025 2.133 ± 0.016 2.136 ± 0.015 2.475 ± 0.021 2.002 ± 0.010 1.757 ± 0.006 2.409 ± 0.015 2.368 ± 0.018 2.409 ± 0.012 2.248 ± 0.008 1.946 ± 0.007 2.356 ± 0.012 2.269 ± 0.029 2.092 ± 0.012 2.123 ± 0.009 2.202 ± 0.044 2.335 ± 0.014 1.702 ± 0.001 2.146 ± 0.015 1.896 ± 0.011 1.708 ± 0.006 2.001 ± 0.009 1.386 ± 0.005 2.341 ± 0.028 2.172 ± 0.019 2.124 ± 0.014 2.268 ± 0.013 2.483 ± 0.018 2.501 ± 0.005 2.602 ± 0.020 1.627 ± 0.004 2.252 ± 0.012 2.140 ± 0.016 2.443 ± 0.033 2.792 ± 0.068 2.154 ± 0.010 2.558 ± 0.059 2.408 ± 0.025 2.394 ± 0.031 2.035 ± 0.007 2.483 ± 0.021 2.265 ± 0.025 2.102 ± 0.033 2.280 ± 0.005 2.213 ± 0.029 2.574 ± 0.026 2.220 ± 0.017 2.125 ± 0.010 1.774 ± 0.008 1.902 ± 0.010 2.049 ± 0.006 1.913 ± 0.010 1.882 ± 0.007 (10) P 0.726 0.714 0.771 0.781 0.728 0.593 0.758 0.772 0.776 0.562 0.693 0.795 0.773 0.722 0.706 0.840 0.755 0.501 0.827 0.712 0.595 0.718 0.557 0.778 0.715 0.766 0.783 0.830 0.921 0.868 0.620 0.777 0.696 0.858 0.794 0.739 0.853 0.803 0.770 0.707 0.811 0.785 0.806 0.877 0.671 0.801 0.720 0.724 0.619 0.675 0.764 0.644 0.714 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) 7 (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 1176- 52791- 591 1177- 52824- 556 1177- 52824- 616 1184- 52641- 581 1192- 52649- 173 1195- 52724- 60 1199- 52703- 600 1203- 52669- 570 1205- 52670- 307 1207- 52672- 506 1212- 52703- 388 1212- 52703- 584 1213- 52972- 88 1213- 52972- 500 1214- 52731- 339 1215- 52725- 273 1215- 52725- 629 1217- 52672- 271 1223- 52781- 287 1224- 52765- 566 1233- 52734- 335 1237- 52762- 42 1240- 52734- 340 1268- 52933- 318 1269- 52937- 177 1274- 52995- 258 1279- 52736- 147 1283- 52762- 315 1286- 52725- 150 1286- 52725- 579 1301- 52976- 356 1303- 53050- 66 1304- 52993- 245 1306- 52996- 292 1310- 53033- 508 1316- 52790- 581 1324- 53088- 524 1325- 52762- 519 1326- 52764- 377 1331- 52766- 258 1331- 52766- 554 1332- 52781- 27 1332- 52781- 602 1333- 52782- 172 1335- 52824- 291 1338- 52765- 329 1345- 52814- 364 1349- 52797- 175 1349- 52797- 429 1355- 52823- 98 1356- 53033- 248 1357- 53034- 245 1357- 53034- 540 J165712.75+321141.2 J214350.86-072003.8 J214338.30-065034.8 J082057.60+034503.6 J090356.79+045613.5 J092540.94+063116.6 J090610.83+395335.1 J074915.48+225342.3 J075838.40+252558.4 J082527.65+295739.2 J090403.60+363914.0 J091208.95+362226.4 J091724.07+362618.9 J091640.05+373159.5 J092126.45+384619.2 J093538.86+383754.4 J094314.40+403842.7 J095538.93+414320.6 J112437.80+083112.7 J114025.94+104653.7 J123444.26+104308.7 J101629.88+073404.8 J103509.33+094516.9 J083038.23+285852.6 J084219.08+300703.7 J092125.53+345858.4 J125153.04+493216.7 J132751.58+480805.2 J141020.62+460501.6 J141121.91+472849.4 J090934.68+085837.5 J093623.28+090001.0 J093317.21+085425.9 J094756.86+091132.2 J113734.87+572406.1 J123801.22+580114.5 J140721.21+553807.8 J141431.20+543056.1 J142344.91+535924.7 J152115.67+465840.8 J152841.69+475445.7 J154120.02+453619.0 J153821.29+465103.6 J154544.52+441551.8 J155944.57+403325.2 J162350.72+371003.7 J134251.19+441343.3 J143248.38+395917.8 J143036.00+402413.6 J153536.14+332843.3 J100052.15+383056.8 J101207.44+393132.1 J101541.16+412050.2 (4) t3 (104K) 1.208 ± 0.031 1.388 ± 0.044 1.155 ± 0.061 1.049 ± 0.064 1.238 ± 0.041 1.198 ± 0.040 1.170 ± 0.050 0.983 ± 0.054 1.018 ± 0.055 1.001 ± 0.048 1.137 ± 0.036 1.281 ± 0.029 0.974 ± 0.050 1.277 ± 0.039 0.996 ± 0.047 1.187 ± 0.024 1.078 ± 0.062 1.040 ± 0.065 1.237 ± 0.069 1.191 ± 0.074 1.219 ± 0.033 1.173 ± 0.035 1.070 ± 0.039 1.089 ± 0.044 1.046 ± 0.039 1.134 ± 0.060 1.158 ± 0.056 1.080 ± 0.048 1.210 ± 0.045 1.124 ± 0.052 1.041 ± 0.054 1.166 ± 0.056 1.153 ± 0.074 1.403 ± 0.032 1.107 ± 0.047 1.367 ± 0.024 1.001 ± 0.057 1.260 ± 0.059 1.308 ± 0.067 1.290 ± 0.090 1.247 ± 0.032 1.016 ± 0.051 1.492 ± 0.137 1.281 ± 0.048 1.195 ± 0.053 1.106 ± 0.036 1.068 ± 0.065 1.224 ± 0.021 1.193 ± 0.065 0.984 ± 0.052 1.016 ± 0.051 1.080 ± 0.071 1.037 ± 0.042 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.094 ± 0.025 7.950 ± 0.028 8.179 ± 0.048 8.296 ± 0.058 8.086 ± 0.031 8.163 ± 0.031 8.171 ± 0.035 8.417 ± 0.056 8.265 ± 0.052 8.368 ± 0.046 8.238 ± 0.030 8.061 ± 0.022 8.397 ± 0.053 8.105 ± 0.028 8.344 ± 0.050 8.205 ± 0.025 8.282 ± 0.051 8.328 ± 0.064 8.074 ± 0.047 8.167 ± 0.056 8.158 ± 0.026 8.211 ± 0.029 8.263 ± 0.039 8.226 ± 0.041 8.280 ± 0.038 8.212 ± 0.048 8.193 ± 0.048 8.250 ± 0.045 8.133 ± 0.032 8.232 ± 0.042 8.272 ± 0.043 8.201 ± 0.049 8.153 ± 0.052 7.930 ± 0.023 8.252 ± 0.040 8.057 ± 0.022 8.387 ± 0.058 8.091 ± 0.043 8.029 ± 0.045 7.948 ± 0.054 8.075 ± 0.028 8.345 ± 0.053 7.870 ± 0.066 8.075 ± 0.033 8.167 ± 0.045 8.290 ± 0.034 8.268 ± 0.064 8.148 ± 0.019 8.186 ± 0.051 8.441 ± 0.059 8.347 ± 0.052 8.286 ± 0.062 8.357 ± 0.044 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.097 8.551 8.221 8.584 8.411 8.112 8.278 8.539 8.797 8.346 8.124 8.641 8.552 8.136 8.653 8.786 8.581 8.111 8.573 8.290 8.119 8.722 8.596 8.884 8.623 8.417 8.128 8.572 8.507 8.331 8.671 8.701 8.607 7.987 8.132 8.367 8.590 8.256 8.092 8.696 8.362 8.846 8.242 8.107 8.310 8.509 8.171 8.434 8.187 8.531 8.573 8.489 8.585 (7) N2 -1.344 ± 0.008 -1.299 ± 0.013 -1.215 ± 0.009 -1.091 ± 0.007 -1.310 ± 0.022 -1.419 ± 0.011 -1.151 ± 0.009 -1.163 ± 0.008 -0.938 ± 0.006 -1.129 ± 0.007 -1.411 ± 0.011 -1.230 ± 0.009 -1.152 ± 0.008 -1.464 ± 0.015 -1.050 ± 0.007 -1.440 ± 0.011 -1.035 ± 0.008 -1.341 ± 0.013 -1.098 ± 0.009 -1.252 ± 0.014 -1.494 ± 0.011 -1.088 ± 0.008 -1.207 ± 0.009 -0.890 ± 0.006 -1.113 ± 0.006 -1.161 ± 0.010 -1.377 ± 0.012 -1.122 ± 0.009 -1.091 ± 0.008 -1.190 ± 0.010 -0.888 ± 0.004 -1.211 ± 0.015 -0.909 ± 0.007 -1.735 ± 0.018 -1.319 ± 0.013 -1.575 ± 0.012 -1.141 ± 0.009 -1.406 ± 0.027 -1.416 ± 0.019 -0.903 ± 0.010 -1.445 ± 0.012 -0.956 ± 0.009 -1.197 ± 0.019 -1.462 ± 0.014 -1.369 ± 0.021 -1.329 ± 0.010 -1.335 ± 0.014 -1.393 ± 0.009 -1.396 ± 0.018 -1.209 ± 0.008 -0.988 ± 0.007 -1.085 ± 0.035 -1.209 ± 0.009 (8) S2 -0.894 ± 0.007 -0.957 ± 0.011 -0.755 ± 0.009 -0.735 ± 0.006 -0.948 ± 0.011 -0.862 ± 0.008 -0.679 ± 0.006 -0.777 ± 0.007 -0.873 ± 0.007 -0.679 ± 0.006 -0.854 ± 0.008 -0.993 ± 0.011 -0.773 ± 0.007 -0.903 ± 0.010 -0.879 ± 0.008 -1.131 ± 0.013 -0.682 ± 0.007 -0.830 ± 0.009 -0.739 ± 0.007 -0.804 ± 0.013 -0.905 ± 0.007 -0.922 ± 0.012 -0.914 ± 0.009 -0.953 ± 0.009 -0.877 ± 0.008 -0.737 ± 0.011 -0.871 ± 0.009 -0.829 ± 0.008 -0.740 ± 0.007 -0.741 ± 0.008 -0.681 ± 0.005 -0.979 ± 0.017 -0.665 ± 0.006 -1.087 ± 0.010 -0.787 ± 0.008 -1.146 ± 0.014 -0.817 ± 0.016 -1.020 ± 0.026 -0.835 ± 0.012 -0.727 ± 0.011 -1.063 ± 0.011 -0.915 ± 0.011 -0.734 ± 0.018 -0.901 ± 0.010 -0.995 ± 0.020 -0.965 ± 0.011 -0.882 ± 0.011 -0.993 ± 0.008 -0.907 ± 0.013 -0.850 ± 0.008 -0.783 ± 0.009 -0.767 ± 0.010 -0.960 ± 0.009 (9) O3N2 2.085 ± 0.006 2.097 ± 0.011 1.912 ± 0.005 1.740 ± 0.005 2.093 ± 0.019 2.204 ± 0.008 1.805 ± 0.006 1.850 ± 0.005 1.526 ± 0.004 1.761 ± 0.005 2.178 ± 0.008 2.033 ± 0.007 1.824 ± 0.005 2.289 ± 0.013 1.753 ± 0.005 2.345 ± 0.009 1.657 ± 0.005 2.083 ± 0.010 1.773 ± 0.006 2.012 ± 0.011 2.296 ± 0.007 1.920 ± 0.007 1.962 ± 0.006 1.624 ± 0.004 1.816 ± 0.004 1.870 ± 0.008 2.148 ± 0.007 1.850 ± 0.006 1.816 ± 0.006 1.905 ± 0.007 1.416 ± 0.003 2.066 ± 0.013 1.484 ± 0.004 2.549 ± 0.015 2.065 ± 0.010 2.530 ± 0.009 1.861 ± 0.007 2.234 ± 0.025 2.192 ± 0.016 1.447 ± 0.008 2.262 ± 0.009 1.713 ± 0.007 1.867 ± 0.016 2.239 ± 0.011 2.221 ± 0.019 2.152 ± 0.008 2.100 ± 0.011 2.245 ± 0.007 2.206 ± 0.015 1.978 ± 0.004 1.699 ± 0.005 1.820 ± 0.034 2.015 ± 0.006 (10) P 0.751 0.793 0.665 0.624 0.775 0.734 0.608 0.635 0.640 0.597 0.702 0.781 0.653 0.758 0.721 0.859 0.569 0.709 0.661 0.708 0.736 0.774 0.761 0.755 0.711 0.669 0.733 0.724 0.681 0.666 0.535 0.822 0.561 0.826 0.704 0.885 0.683 0.799 0.755 0.598 0.822 0.756 0.633 0.727 0.820 0.756 0.770 0.807 0.743 0.700 0.690 0.692 0.760 8 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 1357- 53034- 579 1363- 53053- 411 1363- 53053- 599 1365- 53062- 381 1368- 53084- 334 1372- 53062- 517 1382- 53115- 231 1388- 53119- 39 1391- 52817- 231 1394- 53108- 259 1395- 52825- 242 1398- 53146- 573 1399- 53172- 204 1401- 53144- 397 1405- 52826- 395 1409- 52824- 461 1418- 53142- 442 1425- 52913- 518 1428- 52998- 568 1430- 53002- 389 1442- 53050- 396 1445- 53062- 429 1454- 53090- 204 1455- 53089- 287 1457- 53116- 381 1462- 53112- 184 1464- 53091- 232 1464- 53091- 442 1466- 53083- 92 1467- 53115- 32 1467- 53115- 579 1474- 52933- 51 1476- 52964- 530 1487- 52964- 510 1491- 52996- 350 1492- 52932- 10 1495- 52944- 627 1522- 52932- 40 1562- 53052- 557 1570- 53149- 146 1571- 53174- 155 1580- 53145- 418 1580- 53145- 419 1584- 52943- 372 1584- 52943- 486 1590- 52974- 628 1595- 52999- 532 1597- 52999- 50 1597- 52999- 168 1597- 52999- 251 1597- 52999- 358 1601- 53115- 168 1601- 53115- 526 1607- 53083- 205 J101803.24+410621.2 J110251.98+433827.2 J110744.09+443825.8 J111727.26+450043.2 J114424.02+443630.2 J123915.79+444800.7 J143532.88+364630.7 J153656.45+312248.0 J155338.85+280257.8 J141240.42+424213.3 J142405.74+421646.2 J150321.55+401652.6 J151242.96+372535.0 J152821.98+362409.3 J160135.95+311353.7 J163305.62+260026.6 J160055.10+344551.8 J170450.35+204718.9 J102847.64+394941.5 J102909.31+394426.1 J112546.80+470000.3 J114138.04+423437.2 J123506.50+413736.4 J123803.77+461820.1 J125251.63+480508.1 J132032.04+405901.6 J133037.68+401953.0 J133346.30+415213.0 J135403.26+442616.4 J141022.27+441455.6 J141007.10+450817.5 J220200.67-011208.6 J221549.25+010938.8 J234249.56+002440.3 J000938.35+002535.7 J002425.03-010359.0 J004829.64+003710.5 J212657.96-003227.9 J025754.79+002726.6 J164202.38+210345.7 J163527.94+222518.8 J154613.87+330423.1 J154659.02+325632.2 J080824.94+230840.9 J080911.47+224758.9 J090405.90+313045.0 J095115.96+364031.0 J101828.39+095412.2 J101546.87+101234.5 J101139.17+101042.2 J100950.23+110439.3 J104829.23+111520.1 J104819.42+123745.8 J113530.91+111717.8 (4) t3 (104K) 1.407 ± 0.036 1.135 ± 0.045 1.074 ± 0.058 1.349 ± 0.031 1.102 ± 0.055 0.964 ± 0.045 1.295 ± 0.087 1.088 ± 0.052 1.074 ± 0.068 1.210 ± 0.090 1.353 ± 0.018 1.494 ± 0.138 1.067 ± 0.068 1.069 ± 0.042 1.021 ± 0.061 1.920 ± 0.219 1.155 ± 0.055 1.052 ± 0.053 0.923 ± 0.047 0.955 ± 0.046 0.865 ± 0.044 1.299 ± 0.060 0.975 ± 0.058 1.243 ± 0.026 1.059 ± 0.068 1.020 ± 0.064 1.016 ± 0.041 1.138 ± 0.064 1.065 ± 0.063 1.079 ± 0.066 1.057 ± 0.047 1.302 ± 0.060 1.077 ± 0.052 1.309 ± 0.049 1.546 ± 0.147 1.498 ± 0.046 1.369 ± 0.049 1.713 ± 0.152 1.250 ± 0.043 1.067 ± 0.045 0.959 ± 0.053 1.087 ± 0.048 1.277 ± 0.034 0.981 ± 0.048 1.113 ± 0.069 1.332 ± 0.082 1.041 ± 0.061 1.021 ± 0.063 1.131 ± 0.076 1.059 ± 0.053 1.024 ± 0.042 1.224 ± 0.027 1.324 ± 0.103 1.104 ± 0.040 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 7.979 ± 0.026 8.206 ± 0.036 8.286 ± 0.053 8.072 ± 0.029 8.198 ± 0.046 8.368 ± 0.049 8.010 ± 0.053 8.260 ± 0.045 8.222 ± 0.054 8.156 ± 0.062 8.059 ± 0.019 7.863 ± 0.069 8.321 ± 0.068 8.323 ± 0.043 8.335 ± 0.063 7.595 ± 0.068 8.138 ± 0.042 8.359 ± 0.053 8.515 ± 0.055 8.401 ± 0.052 8.557 ± 0.059 8.024 ± 0.039 8.358 ± 0.062 8.153 ± 0.022 8.340 ± 0.064 8.326 ± 0.063 8.356 ± 0.042 8.226 ± 0.050 8.296 ± 0.057 8.244 ± 0.059 8.274 ± 0.038 8.041 ± 0.043 8.264 ± 0.049 8.011 ± 0.034 7.801 ± 0.070 7.895 ± 0.032 7.983 ± 0.031 7.744 ± 0.062 8.179 ± 0.036 8.219 ± 0.039 8.413 ± 0.060 8.241 ± 0.044 8.110 ± 0.030 8.413 ± 0.048 8.238 ± 0.050 7.921 ± 0.047 8.267 ± 0.053 8.270 ± 0.060 8.230 ± 0.064 8.325 ± 0.051 8.301 ± 0.042 8.161 ± 0.024 7.944 ± 0.059 8.245 ± 0.036 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.649 8.077 8.423 8.182 8.505 8.622 8.243 8.589 8.780 8.146 8.786 8.134 8.550 8.543 8.585 8.046 8.615 8.500 8.623 8.602 8.688 8.065 8.735 8.662 8.225 8.708 8.156 8.460 8.588 8.296 8.597 8.056 8.091 8.025 8.093 7.998 8.082 8.124 8.116 8.816 8.557 8.592 8.137 8.780 8.575 8.613 8.623 8.663 8.189 8.120 8.598 8.161 8.627 8.112 (7) N2 -1.440 ± 0.023 -1.390 ± 0.012 -1.221 ± 0.010 -1.518 ± 0.024 -1.167 ± 0.010 -0.969 ± 0.006 -1.183 ± 0.015 -1.110 ± 0.007 -0.708 ± 0.005 -1.290 ± 0.013 -1.330 ± 0.009 -1.280 ± 0.021 -1.248 ± 0.018 -1.290 ± 0.011 -1.135 ± 0.010 -1.539 ± 0.045 -1.051 ± 0.008 -1.247 ± 0.011 -1.071 ± 0.007 -1.108 ± 0.007 -0.963 ± 0.005 -1.365 ± 0.015 -0.902 ± 0.007 -1.262 ± 0.008 -1.307 ± 0.016 -1.041 ± 0.008 -1.304 ± 0.008 -1.131 ± 0.011 -1.090 ± 0.008 -1.183 ± 0.009 -0.975 ± 0.006 -1.621 ± 0.029 -1.347 ± 0.013 -1.519 ± 0.032 -1.416 ± 0.044 -1.808 ± 0.028 -1.514 ± 0.019 -1.562 ± 0.049 -1.581 ± 0.023 -0.801 ± 0.005 -1.200 ± 0.007 -1.090 ± 0.008 -1.543 ± 0.030 -0.846 ± 0.006 -0.973 ± 0.007 -1.022 ± 0.008 -0.914 ± 0.006 -0.994 ± 0.006 -1.304 ± 0.020 -1.366 ± 0.013 -1.153 ± 0.007 -1.421 ± 0.010 -1.048 ± 0.015 -1.327 ± 0.011 (8) S2 -1.186 ± 0.032 -0.817 ± 0.008 -0.805 ± 0.009 -1.322 ± 0.030 -0.773 ± 0.007 -0.776 ± 0.006 -0.755 ± 0.010 -0.829 ± 0.007 -0.696 ± 0.006 -0.695 ± 0.010 -1.180 ± 0.012 -0.731 ± 0.017 -0.956 ± 0.017 -0.968 ± 0.010 -0.842 ± 0.010 -0.805 ± 0.021 -0.794 ± 0.008 -0.886 ± 0.010 -0.759 ± 0.006 -0.815 ± 0.007 -0.846 ± 0.006 -0.837 ± 0.011 -0.800 ± 0.009 -0.979 ± 0.008 -0.825 ± 0.010 -0.897 ± 0.009 -0.821 ± 0.008 -0.727 ± 0.008 -0.797 ± 0.008 -0.752 ± 0.008 -0.674 ± 0.006 -0.955 ± 0.016 -0.803 ± 0.009 -0.939 ± 0.011 -0.835 ± 0.020 -1.180 ± 0.016 -0.892 ± 0.009 -0.902 ± 0.031 -1.066 ± 0.017 -0.798 ± 0.005 -0.821 ± 0.007 -0.841 ± 0.008 -1.196 ± 0.016 -0.826 ± 0.007 -0.635 ± 0.010 -0.725 ± 0.009 -0.676 ± 0.006 -0.768 ± 0.006 -0.806 ± 0.012 -0.811 ± 0.009 -0.830 ± 0.007 -0.909 ± 0.012 -0.717 ± 0.017 -0.819 ± 0.008 (9) O3N2 2.340 ± 0.021 2.117 ± 0.009 1.948 ± 0.006 2.497 ± 0.022 1.827 ± 0.007 1.607 ± 0.004 1.825 ± 0.013 1.811 ± 0.004 1.241 ± 0.003 1.978 ± 0.011 2.276 ± 0.007 1.948 ± 0.017 2.070 ± 0.015 2.126 ± 0.008 1.861 ± 0.007 2.183 ± 0.041 1.712 ± 0.006 2.056 ± 0.009 1.695 ± 0.004 1.780 ± 0.005 1.627 ± 0.003 2.093 ± 0.013 1.556 ± 0.005 2.135 ± 0.005 2.063 ± 0.013 1.717 ± 0.006 2.037 ± 0.006 1.828 ± 0.008 1.780 ± 0.005 1.851 ± 0.007 1.563 ± 0.003 2.436 ± 0.027 2.098 ± 0.011 2.300 ± 0.030 2.156 ± 0.041 2.705 ± 0.025 2.276 ± 0.014 2.359 ± 0.047 2.528 ± 0.021 1.420 ± 0.002 1.893 ± 0.005 1.814 ± 0.005 2.463 ± 0.028 1.542 ± 0.004 1.555 ± 0.005 1.614 ± 0.005 1.469 ± 0.004 1.588 ± 0.004 2.062 ± 0.017 2.123 ± 0.010 1.851 ± 0.005 2.295 ± 0.008 1.623 ± 0.012 2.077 ± 0.009 (10) P 0.872 0.696 0.688 0.919 0.673 0.666 0.629 0.666 0.547 0.613 0.889 0.636 0.776 0.791 0.715 0.617 0.672 0.738 0.558 0.684 0.665 0.709 0.679 0.800 0.680 0.671 0.706 0.633 0.645 0.660 0.570 0.795 0.742 0.783 0.755 0.884 0.724 0.760 0.855 0.654 0.690 0.718 0.879 0.654 0.527 0.635 0.561 0.636 0.711 0.703 0.717 0.815 0.598 0.721 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) 9 (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 1609- 53142- 238 1615- 53166- 206 1616- 53169- 205 1620- 53137- 470 1623- 53089- 493 1632- 52996- 135 1644- 53144- 564 1648- 53171- 21 1650- 53174- 305 1682- 53173- 3 1689- 53177- 521 1697- 53142- 48 1702- 53144- 62 1704- 53178- 345 1704- 53178- 478 1734- 53034- 490 1744- 53055- 450 1745- 53061- 463 1747- 53075- 182 1758- 53084- 338 1821- 53167- 496 282- 51630- 546 296- 51665- 411 297- 51663- 446 301- 51641- 525 304- 51609- 583 309- 51666- 282 348- 51696- 339 351- 51695- 217 394- 51812- 480 394- 51876- 472 406- 51817- 490 406- 51900- 204 406- 51900- 488 414- 51869- 459 414- 51869- 524 415- 51879- 284 419- 51812- 362 419- 51868- 362 425- 51884- 635 437- 51876- 460 483- 51942- 474 483- 51942- 586 594- 52027- 516 616- 52442- 336 662- 52178- 466 673- 52162- 73 675- 52590- 39 676- 52178- 192 677- 52606- 374 677- 52606- 533 678- 52884- 446 681- 52199- 201 681- 52199- 595 J114837.49+121407.8 J122900.39+112302.0 J123534.25+111926.0 J114228.75+075709.3 J120344.83+072903.8 J034254.29-005520.2 J142805.52+362710.4 J150950.07+314639.7 J151634.77+300653.6 J160810.37+352809.1 J171108.98+234547.1 J131644.79+105733.1 J135832.26+104718.9 J140158.15+134830.2 J140555.23+140528.3 J073149.49+404513.3 J100307.77+130326.2 J101157.09+130822.2 J102744.14+130934.2 J082520.11+082723.0 J154453.28+062452.9 J113703.79+002817.4 J131937.25+005043.8 J132654.62+011346.5 J140018.94+010453.7 J142200.19+010213.2 J145146.99-005643.8 J163107.20+005324.7 J170201.44+604746.3 J005147.30+000939.9 J005147.30+000939.9 J022407.68+003226.1 J022312.62-004539.9 J022407.68+003226.1 J032724.17+004804.3 J032750.16+010135.0 J033031.22-005846.5 J004236.94+160202.7 J004236.94+160202.7 J013700.31+144157.1 J080147.11+435302.0 J090047.45+574255.0 J090139.89+575945.9 J154654.55+030902.1 J153534.13+545534.3 J013258.54-085337.6 J223126.30-000456.2 J225059.28+000032.7 J225059.28+000032.7 J225833.74+005630.4 J230210.00+004939.0 J230703.74+011311.2 J232936.56-011057.0 J233435.40+002714.4 (4) t3 (104K) 1.170 ± 0.045 1.105 ± 0.069 1.151 ± 0.039 0.991 ± 0.059 1.234 ± 0.089 1.124 ± 0.045 1.418 ± 0.022 1.238 ± 0.076 0.988 ± 0.044 1.800 ± 0.039 1.279 ± 0.049 1.123 ± 0.033 1.202 ± 0.025 1.177 ± 0.069 1.185 ± 0.077 1.224 ± 0.031 1.015 ± 0.061 1.437 ± 0.018 1.043 ± 0.054 1.122 ± 0.042 1.314 ± 0.089 1.156 ± 0.034 1.062 ± 0.037 1.209 ± 0.028 1.232 ± 0.025 1.011 ± 0.053 1.162 ± 0.026 1.168 ± 0.061 1.034 ± 0.041 1.566 ± 0.023 1.548 ± 0.018 1.085 ± 0.070 1.432 ± 0.125 1.183 ± 0.068 1.026 ± 0.051 1.040 ± 0.061 1.139 ± 0.039 1.059 ± 0.064 1.004 ± 0.059 1.028 ± 0.063 1.094 ± 0.034 0.985 ± 0.048 1.114 ± 0.045 1.109 ± 0.034 1.083 ± 0.054 1.003 ± 0.041 1.038 ± 0.065 1.763 ± 0.049 1.628 ± 0.033 1.247 ± 0.095 1.731 ± 0.029 1.002 ± 0.049 1.202 ± 0.027 1.315 ± 0.102 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.142 ± 0.036 8.247 ± 0.061 8.247 ± 0.034 8.403 ± 0.062 8.071 ± 0.062 8.229 ± 0.039 7.941 ± 0.017 8.084 ± 0.057 8.387 ± 0.047 7.745 ± 0.031 8.075 ± 0.034 8.259 ± 0.033 8.222 ± 0.026 8.163 ± 0.049 8.149 ± 0.055 8.145 ± 0.028 8.339 ± 0.058 8.000 ± 0.019 8.307 ± 0.053 8.265 ± 0.040 7.985 ± 0.056 8.248 ± 0.031 8.346 ± 0.038 8.135 ± 0.025 8.124 ± 0.021 8.359 ± 0.052 8.188 ± 0.023 8.177 ± 0.047 8.293 ± 0.035 7.782 ± 0.018 7.797 ± 0.017 8.263 ± 0.059 7.906 ± 0.063 8.158 ± 0.048 8.310 ± 0.047 8.343 ± 0.054 8.250 ± 0.037 8.319 ± 0.063 8.393 ± 0.066 8.301 ± 0.063 8.271 ± 0.031 8.409 ± 0.053 8.235 ± 0.037 8.286 ± 0.032 8.314 ± 0.047 8.381 ± 0.042 8.328 ± 0.062 7.697 ± 0.032 7.758 ± 0.023 8.088 ± 0.070 7.655 ± 0.022 8.334 ± 0.047 8.176 ± 0.025 8.038 ± 0.061 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.041 8.536 8.118 8.498 8.099 8.190 8.065 8.042 8.498 7.879 8.094 8.188 8.794 8.277 8.159 8.106 8.614 8.361 8.589 8.379 8.034 8.186 8.485 8.103 8.536 8.553 8.067 8.088 8.624 7.866 7.864 8.125 8.499 8.130 8.661 8.445 8.132 8.821 8.826 8.052 8.584 8.767 8.127 8.532 8.568 8.349 8.575 7.909 7.855 8.319 7.835 8.819 8.225 8.189 (7) N2 -1.360 ± 0.010 -1.148 ± 0.011 -1.410 ± 0.014 -1.232 ± 0.012 -1.268 ± 0.015 -1.341 ± 0.022 -1.502 ± 0.009 -1.439 ± 0.018 -1.098 ± 0.007 -2.528 ± 0.054 -1.515 ± 0.017 -1.425 ± 0.018 -1.466 ± 0.011 -1.180 ± 0.010 -1.248 ± 0.014 -1.549 ± 0.012 -0.991 ± 0.007 -1.644 ± 0.013 -1.039 ± 0.007 -1.423 ± 0.014 -1.337 ± 0.017 -1.443 ± 0.018 -1.364 ± 0.012 -1.445 ± 0.012 -1.303 ± 0.008 -1.189 ± 0.008 -1.545 ± 0.013 -1.384 ± 0.011 -0.961 ± 0.005 -1.880 ± 0.024 -1.873 ± 0.018 -1.272 ± 0.011 -1.015 ± 0.013 -1.281 ± 0.011 -1.086 ± 0.007 -1.131 ± 0.008 -1.518 ± 0.016 -1.105 ± 0.012 -1.063 ± 0.011 -1.295 ± 0.009 -1.236 ± 0.008 -1.053 ± 0.006 -1.317 ± 0.008 -1.302 ± 0.012 -1.125 ± 0.009 -1.147 ± 0.007 -1.100 ± 0.008 -1.639 ± 0.014 -1.687 ± 0.013 -1.290 ± 0.023 -2.212 ± 0.030 -0.833 ± 0.005 -1.394 ± 0.010 -1.269 ± 0.039 (8) S2 -0.861 ± 0.008 -0.789 ± 0.010 -0.875 ± 0.009 -0.844 ± 0.015 -0.694 ± 0.011 -0.910 ± 0.011 -1.029 ± 0.008 -0.868 ± 0.013 -0.832 ± 0.006 -1.833 ± 0.032 -0.897 ± 0.010 -0.959 ± 0.009 -1.199 ± 0.011 -0.716 ± 0.010 -0.741 ± 0.010 -1.013 ± 0.008 -0.742 ± 0.007 -1.349 ± 0.013 -0.817 ± 0.008 -1.016 ± 0.016 -0.770 ± 0.013 -0.916 ± 0.010 -0.995 ± 0.010 -0.977 ± 0.012 -0.955 ± 0.008 -0.800 ± 0.011 -0.976 ± 0.008 -0.828 ± 0.008 -0.747 ± 0.005 -1.260 ± 0.010 -1.289 ± 0.009 -0.708 ± 0.007 -0.630 ± 0.012 -0.709 ± 0.008 -0.841 ± 0.009 -0.720 ± 0.007 -0.991 ± 0.009 -1.050 ± 0.028 -1.107 ± 0.040 -0.779 ± 0.006 -0.912 ± 0.009 -0.934 ± 0.009 -0.813 ± 0.007 -0.968 ± 0.011 -0.832 ± 0.019 -0.700 ± 0.007 -0.776 ± 0.007 -1.445 ± 0.034 -1.398 ± 0.023 -0.912 ± 0.023 -1.456 ± 0.015 -0.819 ± 0.006 -0.937 ± 0.007 -0.700 ± 0.014 (9) O3N2 2.096 ± 0.008 1.879 ± 0.008 2.237 ± 0.011 1.974 ± 0.009 1.918 ± 0.012 2.132 ± 0.021 2.333 ± 0.006 2.191 ± 0.015 1.812 ± 0.004 3.529 ± 0.047 2.312 ± 0.015 2.275 ± 0.016 2.414 ± 0.008 1.841 ± 0.007 1.922 ± 0.012 2.409 ± 0.009 1.630 ± 0.004 2.622 ± 0.011 1.772 ± 0.005 2.287 ± 0.011 2.016 ± 0.015 2.333 ± 0.016 2.199 ± 0.008 2.286 ± 0.011 2.135 ± 0.006 1.893 ± 0.006 2.346 ± 0.011 2.116 ± 0.009 1.568 ± 0.003 2.709 ± 0.022 2.718 ± 0.016 1.919 ± 0.008 1.597 ± 0.010 1.920 ± 0.008 1.751 ± 0.005 1.788 ± 0.006 2.382 ± 0.014 1.931 ± 0.010 1.894 ± 0.010 2.001 ± 0.007 2.017 ± 0.006 1.830 ± 0.004 2.048 ± 0.006 2.149 ± 0.010 1.913 ± 0.007 1.844 ± 0.002 1.797 ± 0.005 2.543 ± 0.007 2.559 ± 0.011 2.093 ± 0.020 3.039 ± 0.027 1.467 ± 0.003 2.255 ± 0.008 1.927 ± 0.035 (10) P 0.738 0.693 0.745 0.706 0.638 0.762 0.816 0.739 0.694 0.980 0.756 0.805 0.867 0.613 0.634 0.820 0.618 0.918 0.720 0.818 0.681 0.822 0.770 0.828 0.799 0.677 0.773 0.692 0.602 0.880 0.898 0.607 0.550 0.588 0.667 0.593 0.807 0.800 0.809 0.719 0.746 0.754 0.697 0.788 0.726 0.656 0.657 0.934 0.916 0.788 0.910 0.645 0.813 0.597 10 Table 1. The characteristic parameters of the SDSS galaxies (Continued) (1) Num (2) Plate-MJD-FiberID (3) IAU designations 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 682- 52525- 63 682- 52525- 172 683- 52524- 279 684- 52523- 494 684- 52523- 560 685- 52203- 296 686- 52519- 2 686- 52519- 185 686- 52519- 406 686- 52519- 476 691- 52199- 252 691- 52199- 307 691- 52199- 573 691- 52199- 636 692- 52201- 394 693- 52254- 403 693- 52254- 454 693- 52254- 463 693- 52254- 480 694- 52209- 73 694- 52209- 231 695- 52202- 261 698- 52203- 250 699- 52202- 337 701- 52179- 117 702- 52178- 335 703- 52209- 215 704- 52205- 42 704- 52205- 494 707- 52177- 11 707- 52177- 369 707- 52177- 525 708- 52175- 147 708- 52175- 155 708- 52175- 172 708- 52175- 299 708- 52175- 579 710- 52203- 611 712- 52179- 108 712- 52199- 115 713- 52178- 213 713- 52178- 496 714- 52201- 91 802- 52289- 423 804- 52286- 85 805- 52586- 144 805- 52586- 482 805- 52586- 550 805- 52586- 605 806- 52592- 587 811- 52669- 415 960- 52466- 61 972- 52428- 368 978- 52431- 415 J234209.77-002451.1 J233751.94-001000.4 J234209.77-002451.1 J235242.19+002345.9 J235519.63+000051.8 J235519.63+000051.8 J001042.84-010200.9 J000703.98-003447.6 J000657.02+005125.9 J000635.54+002333.3 J004406.79-010838.4 J004020.02+000008.6 J004859.14+005553.0 J005147.30+000939.9 J005147.30+000939.9 J010101.27+011040.0 J010112.24+005449.3 J010000.24+001727.2 J005959.88+000014.0 J011210.87-000330.9 J010628.39-002000.9 J011210.87-000330.9 J013525.58-011348.3 J014246.61+010450.5 J020223.52-002728.0 J020411.35+004304.8 J021514.66-005254.4 J022635.74-011021.3 J022322.78+002336.9 J024939.72-011151.3 J024355.18+011148.8 J024702.71+011529.5 J025540.01-002240.0 J025436.22+000339.9 J025324.24-000716.6 J025020.86-005828.9 J025536.26+005609.6 J031314.21+004726.5 J032708.26-002551.9 J032708.26-002551.9 J033211.81-004416.0 J033319.20+001731.2 J034254.29-005520.2 J030135.57+011420.0 J031918.24-005859.1 J032708.26-002551.9 J032713.08+003112.3 J032750.16+010135.0 J033128.46+003737.2 J033653.64+005657.4 J030903.89+003846.6 J134225.32+582432.7 J165844.50+351923.1 J171400.93+313023.4 (4) t3 (104K) 1.282 ± 0.065 1.809 ± 0.033 1.140 ± 0.062 1.180 ± 0.081 1.183 ± 0.046 0.993 ± 0.057 1.244 ± 0.085 1.258 ± 0.032 1.195 ± 0.027 1.317 ± 0.087 1.280 ± 0.039 1.060 ± 0.056 1.420 ± 0.063 1.506 ± 0.025 1.617 ± 0.027 1.144 ± 0.066 1.178 ± 0.075 1.152 ± 0.043 1.483 ± 0.092 1.203 ± 0.059 1.368 ± 0.048 1.200 ± 0.057 1.092 ± 0.051 1.368 ± 0.052 1.519 ± 0.038 1.173 ± 0.050 1.091 ± 0.065 1.173 ± 0.068 1.310 ± 0.036 1.326 ± 0.039 1.093 ± 0.070 1.285 ± 0.022 1.187 ± 0.081 1.443 ± 0.040 1.276 ± 0.063 1.338 ± 0.087 1.235 ± 0.071 1.506 ± 0.126 1.212 ± 0.071 1.209 ± 0.057 1.785 ± 0.195 1.248 ± 0.036 1.046 ± 0.060 1.340 ± 0.037 1.093 ± 0.067 1.243 ± 0.038 1.108 ± 0.041 1.006 ± 0.045 1.289 ± 0.087 1.285 ± 0.077 1.512 ± 0.049 1.158 ± 0.034 1.125 ± 0.036 1.024 ± 0.048 (5) 12+log(O/H)Te 8.103 ± 0.047 7.738 ± 0.020 8.251 ± 0.056 8.146 ± 0.068 8.187 ± 0.038 8.387 ± 0.066 8.161 ± 0.066 8.117 ± 0.026 8.177 ± 0.025 8.037 ± 0.057 8.110 ± 0.029 8.221 ± 0.053 7.928 ± 0.035 7.833 ± 0.020 7.768 ± 0.020 8.225 ± 0.059 8.173 ± 0.058 8.259 ± 0.042 7.857 ± 0.046 8.154 ± 0.042 8.036 ± 0.031 8.168 ± 0.043 8.262 ± 0.047 7.963 ± 0.032 7.820 ± 0.026 8.171 ± 0.044 8.298 ± 0.060 8.186 ± 0.053 8.037 ± 0.026 8.035 ± 0.031 8.287 ± 0.066 8.099 ± 0.021 8.189 ± 0.061 7.890 ± 0.024 8.100 ± 0.044 7.962 ± 0.048 8.069 ± 0.047 7.903 ± 0.059 8.212 ± 0.055 8.205 ± 0.046 7.588 ± 0.064 8.136 ± 0.028 8.332 ± 0.060 8.059 ± 0.034 8.298 ± 0.062 8.174 ± 0.030 8.249 ± 0.037 8.355 ± 0.041 8.036 ± 0.058 8.055 ± 0.047 7.932 ± 0.034 8.194 ± 0.032 8.216 ± 0.031 8.335 ± 0.046 (6) (O/H)Bay 8.122 8.048 8.139 8.037 8.145 8.087 8.469 8.191 8.530 8.097 8.147 8.763 8.039 7.881 7.888 8.225 8.094 8.466 8.041 8.112 8.144 8.139 8.552 8.119 7.887 8.429 8.160 8.114 8.047 8.048 8.562 8.650 8.163 7.983 8.211 8.493 8.106 8.163 8.186 8.235 8.686 8.403 8.169 7.907 8.186 8.147 8.201 8.471 8.056 8.100 8.071 8.486 8.317 8.608 (7) N2 -1.593 ± 0.027 -1.804 ± 0.017 -1.575 ± 0.028 -1.512 ± 0.032 -1.424 ± 0.015 -1.433 ± 0.019 -1.416 ± 0.028 -1.427 ± 0.013 -1.336 ± 0.008 -1.537 ± 0.027 -1.485 ± 0.016 -0.942 ± 0.007 -1.541 ± 0.029 -1.858 ± 0.021 -1.836 ± 0.024 -1.327 ± 0.053 -1.460 ± 0.020 -1.480 ± 0.020 -1.403 ± 0.020 -1.391 ± 0.014 -1.643 ± 0.035 -1.391 ± 0.018 -1.209 ± 0.029 -1.353 ± 0.014 -1.812 ± 0.025 -1.372 ± 0.021 -1.408 ± 0.018 -1.392 ± 0.016 -1.525 ± 0.016 -1.626 ± 0.014 -1.226 ± 0.016 -1.430 ± 0.010 -1.434 ± 0.035 -1.691 ± 0.016 -1.424 ± 0.033 -1.052 ± 0.009 -1.249 ± 0.010 -1.270 ± 0.063 -1.421 ± 0.020 -1.392 ± 0.018 -0.844 ± 0.008 -1.264 ± 0.026 -1.378 ± 0.031 -1.884 ± 0.054 -1.446 ± 0.020 -1.364 ± 0.013 -1.314 ± 0.012 -1.106 ± 0.006 -1.473 ± 0.020 -1.456 ± 0.022 -1.844 ± 0.037 -1.393 ± 0.010 -1.215 ± 0.008 -1.035 ± 0.008 (8) S2 -0.997 ± 0.035 -1.331 ± 0.012 -0.998 ± 0.043 -0.976 ± 0.019 -0.945 ± 0.011 -0.943 ± 0.012 -1.090 ± 0.024 -0.961 ± 0.010 -0.979 ± 0.008 -0.881 ± 0.014 -1.012 ± 0.011 -0.816 ± 0.015 -0.913 ± 0.015 -1.256 ± 0.011 -1.276 ± 0.012 -0.929 ± 0.016 -0.822 ± 0.016 -1.150 ± 0.027 -0.797 ± 0.015 -0.837 ± 0.011 -1.057 ± 0.020 -0.841 ± 0.014 -0.893 ± 0.013 -0.847 ± 0.012 -1.133 ± 0.015 -0.954 ± 0.014 -0.885 ± 0.015 -0.801 ± 0.012 -0.938 ± 0.009 -1.087 ± 0.010 -0.984 ± 0.022 -1.132 ± 0.011 -0.871 ± 0.017 -1.059 ± 0.009 -0.901 ± 0.013 -0.664 ± 0.009 -0.729 ± 0.008 -0.751 ± 0.022 -0.878 ± 0.052 -0.833 ± 0.051 -0.645 ± 0.011 -0.942 ± 0.011 -0.903 ± 0.014 -1.481 ± 0.031 -0.969 ± 0.012 -0.839 ± 0.049 -0.856 ± 0.007 -0.695 ± 0.005 -0.832 ± 0.011 -0.823 ± 0.018 -1.267 ± 0.022 -0.999 ± 0.011 -0.792 ± 0.007 -0.842 ± 0.014 (9) O3N2 2.448 ± 0.025 2.748 ± 0.014 2.443 ± 0.025 2.315 ± 0.029 2.226 ± 0.013 2.236 ± 0.017 2.339 ± 0.026 2.272 ± 0.011 2.181 ± 0.005 2.341 ± 0.024 2.353 ± 0.014 1.629 ± 0.006 2.312 ± 0.026 2.695 ± 0.019 2.683 ± 0.022 2.171 ± 0.050 2.206 ± 0.017 2.410 ± 0.017 2.108 ± 0.017 2.161 ± 0.012 2.531 ± 0.034 2.164 ± 0.016 1.982 ± 0.027 2.117 ± 0.011 2.638 ± 0.022 2.194 ± 0.018 2.227 ± 0.016 2.163 ± 0.014 2.351 ± 0.014 2.492 ± 0.012 2.059 ± 0.013 2.337 ± 0.008 2.216 ± 0.034 2.483 ± 0.015 2.245 ± 0.031 1.658 ± 0.007 1.924 ± 0.008 1.962 ± 0.059 2.292 ± 0.017 2.267 ± 0.016 1.275 ± 0.004 2.118 ± 0.024 2.179 ± 0.030 2.857 ± 0.051 2.276 ± 0.018 2.257 ± 0.011 2.115 ± 0.010 1.747 ± 0.004 2.181 ± 0.016 2.151 ± 0.019 2.801 ± 0.034 2.232 ± 0.008 1.957 ± 0.006 1.749 ± 0.006 (10) P 0.790 0.899 0.814 0.806 0.747 0.800 0.855 0.791 0.797 0.768 0.803 0.750 0.753 0.878 0.876 0.807 0.701 0.867 0.698 0.720 0.821 0.709 0.751 0.757 0.870 0.804 0.762 0.722 0.804 0.842 0.791 0.863 0.713 0.805 0.763 0.599 0.671 0.621 0.762 0.779 0.480 0.790 0.770 0.940 0.773 0.797 0.776 0.614 0.682 0.649 0.903 0.823 0.715 0.696 Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. Yin2006AA July 12, 2018 c(cid:13) ESO 2018 Empirical strong-line oxygen abundance calibrations from galaxies with electron temperature measurements S. Y. Yin1,3, Y. C. Liang1,2, F. Hammer2, J. Brinchmann4, B. Zhang1,3, L. C. Deng1, and H. Flores2 1National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 20A Datun Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100012, China 2GEPI, Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, 92195 Meudon, France 3Department of Physicals,Hebei Normal University,Shijiazhuang 050016, China 4 CAUP, Rua das Estrelas S/N, 4150-752 Porto, Portugal Received; accepted ABSTRACT Context. Aims. We determine the gas-phase oxygen abundance for a sample of 695 galaxies and H  regions with reliable detections of [O ]4363, using the temperature-sensitive (Te) method, which is the most reliable and direct way of measuring metallicity. Our aims are to estimate the validity of empirical methods such as R23, R23 − P, log([N ]/Hα) (N2), log[([O ]/Hβ)/([N ]/Hα)] (O3N2), and log([S ]/Hα) (S2), and re-derive (or add) the calibrations of R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices for oxygen abundances on the basis of this large sample of galaxies with Te-based abundances. Methods. We select 531 star-forming galaxies from the Fourth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey database (SDSS-DR4) with strong emission lines, including [O ]4363 detected at a signal-to-noise larger than 5σ, as well as 164 galaxies and H  regions from literature with Te measurements. O/H abundances have been derived from a two-zone model for the temperature structure, assuming a relationship between high ionization and low ionization species. Results. We compare our (O/H)Te measurements of the SDSS sample with the abundances obtained by the MPA/JHU group using multiple strong emission lines and Bayesian techniques (Tremonti et al. 2004). For roughly half of the sample the Bayesian abundances are overestimated ∼0.34 dex, possibly due to the treatment of nitrogen enrichment in the models they used. R23 and R23 − P methods systematically overestimate the O/H abundance by a factor of ∼0.20 dex and ∼0.06 dex, respectively. The N2 index, rather than the O3N2 index, provides more consistent O/H abundances with the Te-method, but with some scatter. The relations of N2, O3N2, S2 with log(O/H) are consistent with the photoionization model calculations of Kewley & Doptita (2002), but R23 does not match well. We derive analytical calibrations for O/H from R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices on the basis of this large sample, as well including the excitation parameter P as an additional parameter in the N2 calibration. These empirical calibrations are free from the systematic problems inherent in abundance calibrations based on photoionizatoin models. Conclusions. We conclude that, the N2, O3N2 and S2 indices are useful indicators to calibrate metallicities of galaxies with 12 + log(O/H) < 8.5, and the R23 index works well for the metal-poor galaxies with 12+log(O/H)<7.9. For the intermediate metallicity range (7.9 < 12 + log(O/H) < 8.4), the R23 and R23 − P methods are unreliable to characterize the O/H abundances. Key words. galaxies: abundances - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: ISM - galaxies: spiral - galaxies: starburst - galaxies: stellar content 6 0 0 2 t c O 3 1 v 8 6 0 0 1 6 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1. Introduction The chemical properties of stars and gas within a galaxy pro- vides both a fossil record of its star formation history and in- formation on its present evolutionary status. It is therefore de- sirable to extract as much, and as accurate, information as pos- sible from observations of galaxies. In particular it is important that different methods for extracting information provides this without systematic offsets, or at the very least that these sys- tematic offsets are well understood. Accurate abundance mea- surements for the ionized gas in galaxies require the determina- tion of the electron temperature (Te) in this gas which is usu- ally obtained from the ratio of auroral to nebular line intensi- ties, such as [O ]λλ4959, 5007/[O ]λ4363. This is generally known as the "direct Te-method" because the electron temper- ature is directly inferred from observed line ratios. It is well known that this procedure is difficult to carry out for metal-rich galaxies since, as the metallicity increases, the electron tem- Send offprint requests to: S. Y. Yin: [email protected], Y. C. Liang: [email protected] perature decreases (as the cooling is via metal lines) and the auroral lines eventually become too faint to measure. Instead, the most common method used for estimating oxygen abun- dance of metal-rich galaxies (12+log(O/H)≥8.5) uses the R23 (=([O ]λ3727+[O ]λλ4959,5007)/Hβ) parameter, which is the ratio of the flux in the strong optical oxygen lines to that of Hβ (Pagel et al. 1979; Tremonti et al. 2004 and the references therein). The R23 indicator can also be used for metal-poor galax- ies (12+log(O/H)<8.5) (Skillman et al. 1989; Kobulnicky et al. 1999; McGaugh 1991; Pilyugin 2000; Edmunds & Pagel 1984). Several researchers have however found that R23-derived abundances are inconsistent with the Te-derived ones, showing a systematic offset. For example, Kennicutt et al. (2003) found that R23 will overestimate the actual log(O/H) abundance by a factor of 0.2-0.5 dex using a sample of 20 H  regions in M101 with high-S/N spectra. Some other researches found the simi- lar results, for example, Bresolin et al. (2004, 2005), Garnett et al. (2004a,b), Pilyugin (2006), Shi et al. (2005, 2006). A much larger dataset can help to understand better this effect and ex- tending it to galaxies will also be of considerable interest. 2 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations To estimate abundances of galaxies, when Te and R23 cannot be used, some other metallicity-sensitive "strong- line" ratios are very useful, for example, [N ]λ6583/Hα, [O ]λ5007/[N ]λ6583, [N ]λ6583/[O ]λ3727, [N ]λ6583/[S ]λλ6717,6731, [S ]λλ6717,6731/Hα, and [O ]λλ4959,5007/Hβ (Liang et al. 2006; Nagao et al. 2006; P´erez-Montero & D´iaz 2005; Pettini & Pagel 2004, hereafter PP04; Denicol´o et al. 2002, hereafter D02; Kewley & Dopita 2002, hereafter KD02). Even when R23 is available, some of these line-ratios are useful to overcome the well-known problem that the R23 vs. 12 + logO/H relation is double-valued and further information is required to break this degeneracy. Alternative methods for breaking the degeneracy when a well established luminosity-metallicity relation exists, or when the likelihood of each branch can be calculated, which has been discussed by Lamareille et al. (2006). Strong-line abundance indicators are typically calibrated in one of two ways: (1) using the samples of galaxies with direct (Te-based) abundances (e.g. PP04; Pagel et al. 1979 etc.); (2) using photoionization models (e.g. McGaugh 1991; Tremonti et al. 2004 etc.). Since the Te-method is generally thought to be the most accurate method for metallicity estimation, we will take oxygen abundances derived using this method as our base- line. We select a large sample of 531 galaxies from the SDSS- DR4 with their [O ]λ4363 emission line detected at a S/N ratio greater than 5σ, and 164 associated galaxies and H  regions from literature. We compare their Te-based O/H abundances with the Bayesian estimates provided by the MPA/JHU group (shown as log(O/H)Bay), which were obtained by fitting multi- emission lines using the photoionization models of Charlot et al. (2006), and with those derived from some strong-line ra- tios given in previous studies, including R23, P, N2 and O3N2 methods etc. (Kobulnicky et al. 1999; Pilyugin 2001; PP04). We also compare the observational results with the photoionization model results of KD02 for the relations of O/H vs. R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices. Specially, we study the abundance calibrations of strong-line ratios on the basis of their Te-based metallicities. When we com- pare the observational relations of O/H vs. strong-line ratios with the photoionization model results of KD02, we find that only the N2, O3N2, S2 indices are useful to estimate abundances for galaxies with low metallicity, 12+log(O/H)Te<8.5, while other line ratios, such as [N ]/[O ], [N ]/[S ] are [O ]/Hβ are not good indicators for this metallicity range due to their insensi- tivity to metallicities there, except in the extremely metal-poor environments (e.g. 12+log(O/H)<7.5 or 7.0) (Stasi´nska 2002; KD02). R23 is a useful indicator of metallicity for the low metal- licity region with 12+log(O/H)<7.9. Thus, we will only calibrate the relationships of the R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices to O/H abundances from the observational data in this study. Moreover, for the N2 index, we follow Pilyugin (2000;2001a,b) to add the excitation parameter P (=[O ]/([O ]+[O ])) to separate the sample galaxies into three sub-samples in the calibrations. These calibrations can be the extension of the metal-rich region studied by Liang et al. (2006) to the low metallicity region. This paper is organized as follows. The sample selection cri- teria are described in Sect. 2. The determinations of the oxy- gen abundances from Te are presented in Sect. 3. In Sect. 4, we present the comparisons between the (O/H)Te and the (O/H)Bay, as well as those abundances derived from other strong-line rela- tions. Sect. 5 shows the comparison of the observational data with the photoionization models of KD02. In Sect.6, we re- derive analytical calibrations between O/H and R23, N2, O3N2, S2 indices, as well the two-parameter calibrations for the N2 index with P-parameter included. The conclusions are given in Sect. 7. 2. Observational data 2.1. TheSDSS-DR4data The SDSS-DR4 (Adelman-McCarthy et al 2006) provides spec- tra in the wavelength range ∼ 3800 -- 9200Å for > 500,000 galaxies over 4783 square degrees1. The MPA-JHU collabora- tion has in addition made measurements of emission-line fluxes and some derived physical parameters for a sample of 520,082 unique galaxies at the MPA SDSS website2. Therefore, we will call the working sample selected in this study as the "MPA/JHU sample" hereafter. We select the "star-forming galaxies" with metallicity measurements, which have been identified follow- ing the selection criteria of the traditional line diagnostic dia- gram [N ]/Hα vs. [O ]/Hβ (Baldwin et al. 1981; Veilleux & Osterbrock 1987; Kewley et al. 2001; Kauffmann et al. 2003). The fluxes of emission-lines have been measured from the stellar-feature subtracted spectra with the spectral population synthesis code of Bruzual & Charlot (2003) (Brinchmann et al. 2004; Tremonti et al. 2004). We select the galaxies with redshifts 0.03< z <0.25 to ensure to cover from [O ] to Hα and [S ] emission lines. Tremonti et al. (2004) also discussed the weak effect of aperture on estimated metallicities of the sample galaxies with 0.03 < z < 0.25 and this was further discussed by Kewley et al. (2005), but for the present study the aperture effects are unimportant. In this study, we use the Te-method to derive O/H abun- dances of the sample galaxies (see Sect. 3 for details), there- fore, we select the samples with [O ]λ4363 emission-line de- tected at a S/N ratio greater than 5σ. To be consistent with Liang et al. (2006) and Tremonti et al. (2004), we also consider the objects having been measured fluxes of [O ]λλ3726,3729, [O ]λ5007, Hβ, Hα, [N ]λ6583, [S ]λλ6717, 6731 emission lines, and the S/N ratio of Hβ, Hα, [N ], [S ] are larger than 5σ. The final sample consists of 531 galaxies. These have fluxes in [O ]λ4363 greater than 5.3×10−17 ergs s−1 cm−2, with a mean value of 21.27 ×10−17 ergs s−1 cm−2. The fluxes of the emission lines are corrected for dust extinction, which are estimated using the Balmer line ratio Hα/Hβ: assuming case B recombination, with a density of 100 cm−3 and a temperature of 104 K, and the intrinsic ratio of Hα/Hβ is 2.86 (Osterbrock 1989), with the relation of ( IHα )obs= IHβ ( IHα0 )intr10−c( f (Hα)− f (Hβ)). Using the average interstellar extinc- IHβ0 tion law given by Osterbrock(1989), we have f (Hα)- f (Hβ) = -0.37. For the 56 data points with c < 0, we assume they have c = 0 since their intrinsic Hα/Hβ may be lower than 2.86 if their electron temperature is high (Osterbrock 1989, p.80). Nearly all previous empirical oxygen abundance calibrations have been derived from individual H  regions since it is much easier to detect [O ]4363 that way. In contrast the SDSS data samples the inner few kpc of most galaxies. One question is whether the global spectrum from a mixture of different H  re- gions will yield meaningful average abundances of the galaxies or not. Kobulnicky et al. (1999), Moustakas & Kennicutt (2006) and Pilyugin et al. (2004) concluded that the spatially unresolved emission-line spectra can reliably indicate the chemical proper- ties of distant star-forming galaxies. However, as Kobulnicky et 1 http://www.sdss.org/dr4/ 2 http://www.mpa-garching.mpg.de/SDSS/ Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 3 3. Abundance determination from Te A two-zone model for the temperature structure within the H  region was adopted. In this model, Te([O ]) is taken to rep- resent the temperature for high-ionization species such as O++, while Te([O ]) is used for low-ionization species such as O+. The general method is firstly to derive t3 (=10−4Te([O ])) from the emission-line ratio of [O ]4959,5007/[O ]4363, and then to estimate t2 (=10−4Te([O ])) from an analytical relation be- tween t2 and t3 inferred from photoionization calculations. Izotov et al. (2005) have recently published a set of equations for the determination of the oxygen abundances in H  regions for a five-level atom. They used the atomic data from the refer- ences listed in Stasi´nska (2005). According to those authors, the electron temperature t3 (in units of 104 K), and the ionic abun- dances O++/H+ and O+/H+ are estimated as follows: Fig. 1. Comparison between the Te-based oxygen abundances (this work) and those from literature. CT = (8.44 − 1.09t3 + 0.5t2 3 − 0.08t3 3) 1 + 0.0004x3 1 + 0.044x3 , t3 = 1.432 log((λ4959 + λ5007)/λ4363) − logCT , where (1) (2) al. (1999) mentioned, the standard nebular chemical abundance measurement methods may be subject to small systematic errors when the observed volume includes a mixture of gas with diverse temperatures, ionization parameters, and metallicities. For the low-mass, metal-poor galaxies, as those we are studying in this work, standard chemical analyses using global spectra will over- estimate the electron temperatures Te due to the non-uniform Te and large variations in the ionization parameter since the global spectra are biased to the objects with stronger emission lines. As a result, the oxygen abundances derived from Te will be un- derestimated, i.e. about <0.1 dex in log(O/H) (for more massive metal-rich galaxies like local spiral galaxies, it is about ±0.2 dex discrepancy). However, since this bias is small, and not well con- strained for our dataset, we do not attempt to correct for it. 2.2. Themetal-poorgalaxiesfromliterature In addition to the MPA/JHU samples, we also collect 164 low-metallicity samples including some blue compact galax- ies (BCDs) and H  regions from literature, which are taken from Izotov et al. (1994, 1996, 1997a, 1997b, 1998a, 1998b, 1999a, 2001a, 2001b, 2004a, 2004b), van Zee (2000), Kniazev et al. (2000), Vilchez et al. (2003), Guseva et al. (2003a,b,c), Melbourne et al. (2004), and Lee et al. (2004). There are 110 H  regions and 54 galaxies in this sample. We re-estimate their O/H abundances by using the electronic temperatures method given in Sect. 3. Their metallicities are 7.1<12+log(O/H)<8.4, more metal-poor than the SDSS galax- ies generally. To check if there is systematic difference between our esti- mates and the values given in the previous studies, we compare their Te-based oxygen abundances obtained by us with those Te- based given in the original reference in Fig. 1, which shows that they are very consistent, and the very slight difference may come from different atomic data. with x3 = 10−4net−1/2 And 3 , and ne is the electron density in cm−3. 12 + log(O++/H+) = log(I[OIII]λ4959+λ5007/IHβ) + 6.200 + 1.251 t3 − 0.55logt3 − 0.014t3, (3) 12 + log(O+/H+) = log(I[OIII]λ3726+λ3729/IHβ) + 5.961 + 1.676 t2 − 0.40logt2 − 0.034t2 + log(1 + 1.35x2), (4) The total oxygen abundances are then derived from the fol- , and ne is the electron density in cm−3. with x2 = 10−4net−1/2 2 lowing equation: O H = O+ H+ + O++ H+ . (5) The electron temperature t2 (in units of 104 K) of the low- ionization zone is usually determined from t3 following an equa- tion derived by fitting H  region models. Several versions of this relation of t2 vs. t3 have been proposed. We use the one of Garnett (1992), which has been widely used: t2 = 0.7t3 + 0.3. (6) The electron densities in the ionized gas of the galaxies are calculated from the line ratios [S ]λ6717/[S ]λ6731 by us- ing the five-level statistical equilibrium model in the task -  contained in the / package (de Robertis, Dufour & Hunt 1987; Shaw & Dufour 1995), which uses the latest atomic data. A reasonable upper limit of the ratios is 1.431 (Osterbrock 1989). However, we find that 118 out of the 531 SDSS galax- ies have [S ] line ratios larger than 1.431. For 71 of the 118 galaxies the difference between the measured ratio and 1.431 was less than the error in the line ratio. So it is very possible that most of the high [S ]λ6717/[S ]λ6731 ratios come from errors. Therefore, we adopt 1.431 for these galaxies. Indeed, this approximation would not affect much the ionic abundances. The reasons are: the term containing x3 is never important and can 4 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations be omitted in calculating CT since ne is always smaller than 103 cm−3; and x2 is also insignificant since it is generally less than 0.1 with ne < 103 cm−3. Oxygen abundances of all the 695 samples (531 from SDSS- DR4 and 164 from literature) are estimated using the relations outlined above. The whole sample show a metallicity range of 7.1 < 12 + log(O/H)Te < 8.5 mostly. Most of the SDSS-DR4 galaxies lie in the more metal-rich region, i.e., 7.6 < 12 + log(O/H)Te < 8.5, and only 63 of them have lower metallicities than 12 + log(O/H)Te = 8.0. Most of the samples from literature have lower metallicities, i.e., 12 + log(O/H) < 8.0. The typical uncertainty of the estimates is about 0.044 dex in 12+log(O/H), and about 500 K in Te([O ]). All the data for the SDSS galaxies are given in Table 1. with a rms of 0.176 dex. The log(N/O) abundance ratios are ob- tained from the electron temperature in the [N ] emission re- gion (is equal to the t2 given in Sect. 3) and the flux ratio of [N ]λλ6548,6584 to [O ]λ3727 following the method given in Thurston et al. (1996). This means that the overestimates of CL01 models for the O/H abundances may be related to the onset of secondary N enrichment. There is a considerable spread in the onset of N enrichment and therefore in this transition region the assumption of the CL01 models of a single N enrichment trend is too simplistic. The simple way to avoid this problem might be to exclude [N ] from their fitting procedure. In this transi- tion region the relations between the log(N/O) and the log(O/H) of galaxies are not monotonic, not as the almost constant trend in the low-metallicity region or the increasing trend in the high- metallicity region (see fig.8 of Liang et al. 2006). 4. Comparisons between the Te and strong-line oxygen abundances 4.2. R23 method 4.1. ComparisonwiththeBayesianmetallicitiesobtainedby theMPA/JHUgroup It will be very interesting to compare the Te-based O/H abun- dances with the Bayesian oxygen abundances provided by the MPA/JHU group for the sample galaxies. The MPA/JHU group used photoionization model (Charlot et al. 2006) to fit simulta- neously most prominent emission lines. Based on the Bayesian technique, they calculated the likelihood distribution of the metallicity of each galaxy in the sample by comparing with a large library of models (∼2×105) corresponding to different assumptions about the effective gas parameters, and then they adopted the median of the distribution as the best estimate of the galaxy metallicity (Tremonti et al. 2004; Brinchmann et al. 2004). Very surprisingly, Fig. 2a shows that, for almost half of the sample galaxies (∼227), their metallicities are overestimated by a factor of about 0.34 dex on average by using the model of Charlot et al. (2006). There is no obviously monotonic trend be- tween the increasing discrepancy and the weakening [O ]4363 line or the decreasing [O ]4363/Hβ ratio. What is the reason for such obvious difference? Indeed, Charlot's model was based on Charlot & Longhetti (2001, CL01 hereafter), which is a model for computing con- sistently the line emission and continuum from galaxies based on a combination of recent population synthesis and photoion- ization codes of CLOUDY. What they did is to use a sample of 92 local galaxies as the observed constraints to determine the best model parameters, including metallicity Z etc. In their cal- ibrations, they used the emission-line luminosities of Hα, Hβ, [O ]λ3727, [O ]λ5007, [N ]λ6583 and [S ]λλ6717,6731 emission lines. The main difference from this method and the other strong line methods discussed below is that all the emis- sion lines are used simultaneously so that any clear change in the abundance ratio X/O for any element X from that used in the CL01 models has the potential of causing offsets. In partic- ular, the clear offset between (O/H)Bay and (O/H)Te is possibly related to how secondary nitrogen enrichment is treated in the CL01 models. Fig. 2b shows that the "offset" between log(O/H)Bay and log(O/H)Te (the former minus the latter) strongly correlates with the log(N/O) abundance ratio, which can be shown as a linear least squares fit: offset = 1.589 × log(N/O) + 2.352, (7) Pagel et al.(1979) first proposed the empirical abundance indi- cator R23 for metal-rich galaxies. Skillman et al. (1989) further suggested that this indicator also can be used for metal-poor galaxies. The relationship between O/H and R23 has been ex- tensively discussed in literature (see Tremonti et al. (2004) and references therein). Different calibrations will result in slightly different oxygen abundances even for the same branch (see fig. 3 of Tremonti et al. 2004 for comparison). A few calibrations have attempted to improve the calibration by introducing an empiri- cal estimator of the ionization parameter as a second parameter (e.g. McGaugh 1991; Charlot & Longhetti 2001; KD02 etc.). At present, one of the popular formulas is the calibration given by Kobulnicky et al.(1999), which includes two analytical formu- las, for the metal-rich and metal-poor branches respectively, and is derived from the photoionization model of McGaugh (1991). As we mentioned in the introduction, R23 may overesti- mate the actual O/H abundances by a factor of ∼0.2-0.5 dex (Kennicutt et al. 2003 etc.). On the basis of this large sample of 695 galaxies, here we compare their oxygen abundances de- rived from R23 and Te methods. Figs. 3a,3b show this compari- son, where we use the calibration formula of Kobulnicky et al. (1999) to derive the 12+log(O/H)R23 for the sample galaxies. In Fig. 3a, for the galaxies with 12+log(O/H)Te<7.95, we use their calibration formula for metal-poor galaxies; and for the galax- ies with 12+log(O/H)Te≥8.2, we use their formulas for metal- rich branch. These two metallicity limits are defined following the R23 − P method in Sect. 4.3 and some other related stud- ies (Pilyugin 2000, 2001a,b; Shi et al. 2006). Fig. 3a shows that R23 method will overestimate the O/H abundances by a factor of ∼0.20 dex, which is analogous to what was found by Kennicutt et al. (2003) and Shi et al. (2005, 2006). Detailed discussions about this discrepancy can be found in Kennicutt et al. (2003). For the sample galaxies with 8.0<12+log(O/H)Te<8.2, which are in the turn-over region, the calibration of Kobulnicky et al. (1999) of metal-poor branch gives (O/H)R23 in good agreement with (O/H)Te. These galaxies are omitted when we discuss the dis- crepancy between the Te- and R23-based metallicities, which is acceptable. Fig. 3a does not show any obvious offset between the H  regions and galaxies. P´erez-Montero & D´iaz (2005) showed that the giant extragalactic H  regions (GEHRs) have more dis- persion than the H  galaxies and H  regions in the Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds (their figs.1,3,7) since the GEHRs may have different ionizaiton parameters and stellar effective temper- atures. Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 5 4.3. The R23 − P method Pilyugin (2000, 2001a,b) suggested the P method to esti- mate oxygen abundances of galaxies, in which the oxygen abundance can be derived from two parameters, R23 and P (=[O ]/([O ]+[O ])). Therefore, we call this method as the "R23 − P method". They derived the O/H= f (R23, P) formulas from a sample of metal-poor H  regions with 7.1<12+log(O/H)Te<7.95 and a sample of moderately metal- rich H  regions with 8.2<12+log(O/H)Te<8.7. The best fitting relation for metal-poor objects was given as Eq.(4) in Pilyugin (2000), and that for moderately metal-rich objects was given as Eq.(8) in Pilyugin (2001a). Fig. 3c shows that there is slight difference of ∼0.06 dex be- tween the (O/H)Te and the (O/H)R23−P abundances for the sam- ples. Indeed, the good agreement is not surprising since Pilyugin (2000, 2001a,b) derived the R23 − P method formulas by using a subset of the sample we use here (Izotov et al. 1994, 1997a and Izotov & Thuan 1998b,1999b). The minor offset is likely caused by two reasons: (1) our sample is much larger than that used by Pilyugin which allows us to determine the relations with higher precision; (2) the different Te-formulas and/or atomic data used in calculations. Moreover, for the low excitation samples in low- metallicity branch with P <0.75, the R23 − P method may over- predict their oxygen abundances by a factor ∼0.1 dex, which is consistent with the 0.1-0.2 dex overestimates found by van Zee & Haynes (2006) for the low excitation H  regions in dwarf irregular galaxies. Pilyugin & Thuran (2005) have renewed the R23 − P calibra- tions by including several improvements, such as enlarging the sample by 1 order of magnitude etc. We have used the new cal- ibrations to re-calculate the (O/H)R23−P abundances for our sam- ple galaxies, and found the overestimate factor by the R23 − P method decreases to be ∼0.025 dex. Because there is no observational samples with 7.95< 12+log(O/H)< 8.2 in Pilyugin's calibration for R23 − P method, the R23 − P method cannot provide information for the galax- ies within this oxygen abundance range. To understand more about this, we calculate oxygen abundances for galaxies with 12+log(O/H)Te=7.9 -- 8.4 using the two formulas for the metal- rich and metal-poor branches. The results are indicated as the points between the two vertical dashed lines in Fig. 3d. Similarly to what we saw for R23 the two branch calibrations give quite different metallicities with a difference of up to ∼0.4 dex. Thus one must be very careful when applying the R23 − P method to samples of galaxies with metallicities in the turn-over region. 4.4. N2method The [N ]/Hα emission-line ratio can also be used to esti- mate metallicities of galaxies. Nitrogen is mainly synthesized in intermediate- and low-mass stars. The [N ]/Hα ratio will therefore become stronger with on-going star formation and evo- lution of galaxies, until very high metallicities are reached, i.e. 12+log(O/H)>9.0, where [N ] starts to become weaker due to the very low electron temperature caused from strong cooling by metal ions. It is worth pointing out that this ratio gives an indirect measurement of the oxygen abundance however, since oxygen lines are not used in the method. Following the earlier work by Storchi-Bergmann, Calzetti & Kinney(1994) and Raimann et al.(2000), D02 and PP04 suggested calibration relations for O/H vs. N2 index from 236 and 137 galaxies respectively. D02 combined a sample of 128 metal-rich galaxies and 108 metal-poor galaxies with Fig. 2. (a) Comparison between the electron temperature-based oxygen abundances and those Bayesian estimates obtained by the MPA/JHU group. The solid line is the equal-value line, and the long-dashed line represents a +0.34 dex discrepancy from the equal-value line to show the overestimates of the oxygen abun- dances by using the model of Charlot et al. (2006) for almost half of the sample galaxies. (b) The offset between the log(O/H)Bay and the log(O/H)Te as a function of the log(N/O) abundance ra- tios for the MPA/JHU sample galaxies. The solid line is the lin- ear least squares fit for the relations, given as Eq. (7). To illustrate clearly the uncertainties due to the double- valuedness of the R23-O/H relation, we used both of the cali- bration formulas for metal-poor and metal-rich branches to cal- culate the 12+log(O/H)R23 abundances for the galaxies having 7.9<12+log(O/H)Te<8.4. Fig. 3b gives the results as the points between the two vertical dashed lines, which shows that these two different formulas will result in quite different metallici- ties, and the discrepancy may be up to ∼ 0.4 dex. Therefore, one should be very careful when using R23-method to derive the metallicities of the galaxies having metallicities in the turn-over region. 6 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations [O ]4363 detected to derive their calibration. The way they estimated the metallicities of their galaxy sample was to use the Te-method for the metal-poor galaxies and the R23 or S 23 (=log(([S ]6717,6731+[S ]9096,9531))/Hβ) method for the metal-rich ones. PP04 extracted the metal-poor objects from the work of D02 and updated the abundances for some of them with recent measurements by Kennicutt et al. (2003) for H  regions in M101 and by Skillman et al. (2003) for dwarf irregular galax- ies in the Sculptor Group. To be consistent with the Te-method, here we use the calibration formula given by PP04 to derive the metallicities 12+log(O/H)N2 for our 695 sample galaxies. Fig. 3e gives the comparison between the 12+log(O/H)Te and 12+log(O/H)N2, which shows that the two estimates are consis- tent but with some scatter. The scatter may mostly come from the different ionization parameters of the galaxies, and the different samples (see Sect.6.5). One of the advantages of using the N2 index for estimat- ing metallicity is that the N2 indicator can break the degen- eracy when the R23-(O/H) and (R23, P) -(O/H) relations are double-valued. Also, the N2 index is not affected by dust ex- tinction since Hα and [N ] are so closely spaced in wavelength. Furthermore near infrared spectrographs can measure these two lines for galaxies out to high redshifts, where equivalently to early epochs in the evolution of galaxies (see more discussion in Liang et al. 2006). 4.5. O3N2method O3N2 = log{([O ]λ5007/Hβ)/([N ]λ6583/Hα)} is another in- dicator for metallicities of galaxies. It was introduced by Alloin et al.(1979) and further studied by PP04. PP04 presented one such calibration by doing linear least squares fit for a sample of 65 (from the 137) galaxies with −1 < O3N2 < 1.9, and pro- vided a calibration formula. This calibration does not work for the cases of O3N2 > 1.9 since the data points are so scattered there in their study. Fig. 3f shows the comparison between the 12+log(O/H)Te and the oxygen abundances derived from O3N2 method using the calibration of PP04 for our 695 sample galax- ies. But we extrapolate to use the PP04's calibration to the galax- ies with O3N2>1.9. It is clear that this calibration will overestimate the O/H abundances by a big factor, up to 1.0 dex, for the metal-poor galaxies with O3N2 > 1.9 (about 12+log(O/H)<8.0). The scatter of the data with −1 <O3N2 < 1.9 are also large, which may be due to the different ionization parameters of the galaxies. Fig. 3. Comparison between the Te-based abundances with those derived from other strong-line calibrations: (a,b). R23 method; (c,d). R23 − P method; (e). N2 method; (f). O3N2 method (see text). The small blue points represent the SDSS sample, and the larger magenta points (open circles) represent the sample com- piled from literature. The solid lines are the equal-value lines, and the long-dashed lines in (a) and (c) are the linear least- squares fits to the data points, which show a discrepancy of ∼0.20 dex and ∼0.06 dex from the equal-value lines, respec- tively. The two pairs of vertical dashed lines in (b) and (d) show the range of 7.9<12+log(O/H)Te<8.4 for the samples whose metallicities are estimated from strong-line ratios by using two calibrations for metal-rich and metal-poor branches. 5. Comparisons with photoionization models KD02 has calculated the metallicity calibrations for strong- line ratios on the basis of photoionization models. They used a combination of stellar population synthesis and photoioniza- tion models to develop a set of ionization parameters and abun- dance diagnostics based on emission-line ratios from strong op- tical lines, with seven ionization parameters q = 5 × 106, 1 × 107, 2 × 107, 4 × 107, 8 × 107, 1.5 × 108, and 3 × 108 cm s−1. The ionization parameter q is defined on the inner boundary of the nebula, and can be physically interpreted as the maximum velocity of an ionization front that can be driven by the local ra- diation field. It will be interesting to compare the observational samples with these model results. Fig. 4 shows the comparisons for the relations of 12+log(O/H) versus R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices. These relations are for the Te-based oxygen abundances of the metal-poor galaxies. Liang et al. (2006) has shown such relations for the metal-rich SDSS galaxies based on R23 abun- dances, and derived the corresponding calibrations (see the thick solid lines in Figs. 4b,c). Fig. 4a shows that the significant discrepancy in the theoret- ically expected R23 sequence with respect to the observed trend beginning from 12 + log(O/H)Te = 8.0 to lower metallicities. Nagao et al. (2006) also pointed out this. The observed relation of R23 - log(O/H) of the data points does not show much scat- ter in contrast to the models of the lower-branch of metallicity, which may mean the weak independence of R23 on ionization pa- rameters there. Especially, the distribution of observational data is nearly vertical in oxygen abundance range of 7.9 ∼ 8.5. The physical reason for the insensitivity of R23 to metallicity in this metallicity region is that the [O ]/Hβ ratio (also [O ]/Hβ) is independent of Te, hence of metallicity there (Stasinska 2002). It proves again that the oxygen abundance cannot be accurately measured by using R23 in the metallicity turnover region, but Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 7 R23 indicator works well for the metal-poor galaxies with 12 + log(O/H)<7.9. Fig. 4b shows the comparison between 12+log(O/H) and N2 index. It shows that the observational data follow the gen- eral trend of the model results well, namely, the N2 indices of galaxies increase following the increasing metallicities, up to 12+log(O/H)=9.0 (by models and Liang et al. 2006). The obser- vational data show some scatter, which may be due to their dif- ferent ionization parameters. We also plot a thick solid line (the short one) in Fig. 4b to show the calibration relation derived by Liang et al. (2006) with the metal-rich SDSS galaxies (8.5<12 + log(O/H)<9.3). If we derive a calibration from the Te-based oxy- gen abundances of the metal-poor galaxies, and extrapolate it to the metal-rich region, it will result in relatively lower O/H abun- dance than directly using the calibration from metal-rich galax- ies. Perhaps one reason for this discrepancy is from the different methods to determine metallicities of the metal-poor and metal- rich galaxies, i.e. the Te-method versus the R23-method or pho- toionization models. However, Stasi´nska (2005) pointed out that, at high metallicity, the derived O/H values from Te for model H  regions deviate strongly from the true ones, i.e., important devi- ations appear around 12 + log(O/H)=8.6, and may become huge as the metallicity increases (see their fig.1a). Fig. 4c shows the comparison between 12+log(O/H) and the O3N2 index. The general trend of the observations and that of the models are similar, and show increasing O/H abun- dance with decreasing O3N2 index. However, the large scat- ter of the data points in this plot may be due to the strong effect of ionization parameter, and such effect is stronger in the low-metallicity region (12+log(O/H)<8.5) than in the high- metallicity region (12+log(O/H)>8.5). Moreover, O3N2 is much less dependent on metallicity in the low-metallicity region than in the high-metallicity region, in particular, it is almost inde- pendent of metallicity for the sample galaxies with metallicities of 12+log(O/H)=7.1-7.7. This is possibly the main reason that PP04 had to limit their calibration to O3N2<1.9. We also present the calibration for metal-rich SDSS galaxies obtained by Liang et al. (2006) in Fig. 4c, which is given as the thick solid line (the short one) in the 8.5<12+log(O/H)<9.3 region. Both the cali- brations for the metal-rich and metal-poor sample galaxies are consistent with the general trend of the model predictions, but the calibration for metal-poor galaxies corresponds to relatively higher ionization parameter than the metal-rich galaxies. Fig. 4d shows the comparison between 12+log(O/H) and the S2 index. Both the observations and models clearly show an increasing S2 with increasing O/H. This increasing trend will extend up to 12+log(O/H)∼8.9-9.0. S2 is affected more by the ionization parameters than the N2 index is. The large scatter of this relation may be caused by the different ionization pa- rameters. Most of the SDSS galaxies cluster around −1.0 < S 2 < −0.5. Liang et al. (2006) did not derive a metallicity cali- bration for S2 for the metal-rich galaxies since the data points show obvious turnover and double-valued distribution around 12+log(O/H)∼8.9-9.0. In summary, Figs. 4a-d show that R23 is not a good metallic- ity indicator for the galaxies with 7.9<12+log(O/H)< 8.5 due to its independence on metallicity there, and is a good indi- cator for lower metallicity region with 12+log(O/H)< 7.9; N2 is a useful indicator for estimating metallicities of galaxies be- cause it is strongly monotonicly correlated with metallicity (up to about 12+log(O/H)∼9.0); although O3N2 and S2 can be used to estimate metallicities of galaxies, they are more sensitive to ionization parameters than N2 is, and O3N2 is less dependent on metallicity than the other two. In addition, when we have Fig. 4. Comparison between the observational data and the pho- toionization models of KD02. The symbols are the same as in Fig. 3. The seven lines represent the model results from KD02 with seven photoionization parameters from q = 5 × 106 cm s−1 to q = 3 × 108 cm s−1, which increase orderly from the red dotted line to the black solid line. The solid thick line (in red) in Fig.(a) is the calibration derived by Tremonti et al. (2004) for the metal- rich galaxies, and those in Fig.(b) and Fig.(c) are the calibrations derived by Liang et al. (2006) for the metal-rich SDSS galaxies. the indicator of O3N2 and/or S2, normally we also have N2. Furthermore, if we can find a way to take into account the ion- ization parameters of the sample galaxies in the calibrations, it will provide more reliable metallicities (see Sects. 6.5,6.6). 6. Deriving oxygen abundance calibrations We have obtained the Te-based O/H abundances for the 695 sample galaxies and H  region. They have metallicities of 7.1 <12+log(O/H)Te < 8.5 mostly. Then we use their (O/H)Te and line ratios to re-derive the oxygen abundance calibrations for the strong-line ratios N2, O3N2 indices, and add a S2 in- dex. We also derive the calibration for R23 for the 12+log(O/H)Te < 7.9 region. Moreover, we try to add an excitation parameter P (=[O ]/([O ]+[O ])) in the calibrations to separate the sam- ple galaxies to be three sub-samples, which improves the N2 calibration, but does not improve well the O3N2 and S2 calibra- tions. 6.1. The R23 index The R23 index is useful for calibrating metallicities of low metal- licity galaxies with 12+log(O/H)<7.9 due to its obvious correla- tion with log(O/H) and weak dependence on ionization parame- ters there. Fig. 5a shows this correlation. The linear least-squares fit for all the 120 data points with 12+log(O/H)<7.9 is: 12 + log(O/H) = 6.486 + 1.401 × log(R23), (8) the data to the fit with R23=([O ]λ3727+ [O ]λλ4959,5007)/Hβ. The rms of is about 0.103 dex. The appropri- ate range of this calibration is about 0.4<log(R23)<1.0 and 7.0<12+log(O/H)<7.9. The calibrations of Kobulnicky et 8 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations al.(1999) are also presented in the figure for comparison as the dashed lines for the cases of y (=log([O ]/[O ])) equal to 0, 1, 1.5. It shows that the y=1.0 and 1.5 can explain these observa- tional data generally. 6.2. TheN2index Since the data points show a relatively tight linear relation- ship between N2 and 12+log(O/H), we obtain a linear least- squares fit for this relation. We use the mean-value points in 11 bins of metallicities to avoid too much weights on the high metallicity range where most of the data are distributed. The bin width is ∆[log(O/H)] = 0.1 for the galaxies in the range of 7.4 <12+log(O/H) < 8.5, and ∆[log(O/H)] = 0.3 for the range of 7.1 < 12 + log(O/H)Te < 7.4 because of the small number of sources in this range. These bin widths are the same as for the O3N2 and S2 indices discussed in the consequent two sub- sections. The objects with higher uncertainty than 0.06 dex on log(O/H) and log([N ]/Hα) have been excluded in calculating the mean values and calibrating, which leaves 584 data points. 19 galaxies from literature cannot be included in deriving calibra- tions since they do not have [N ] emission-line measurements. The derived analytical relation of a linear least squares fit is: 12 + log(O/H) = 9.263 + 0.836 × N2, (9) with N2=log([N ]λ6583/Hα), shown as the solid line in Fig. 5b. The rms of the data to the fit is 0.159 dex. The two dashed lines show a spread of 2σ. This calibration is valid in the range of −2.5 < N2 < −0.5. The calibrations of D02 (12 + log (O/H) = 9.12 + 0.73 × N2, the dotted line) and PP04 (12 + log (O/H) = 8.90 + 0.57 × N2, the long-dashed line) are also plotted for comparison. It shows that D02's calibration is similar to ours, but the one of PP04 shows a slightly lower slope and the difference is more obvious for the low metal- licity region with 12+log(O/H)<8.0. The reason may be that PP04's sample does not extend to much lower metallicity with 12+log(O/H)<7.7, and most of their samples have metallicities of 7.7<12+log(O/H)<8.5, while the fit for their these samples results in a bit lower slope than for ours (see fig.1 of D02 and fig.1 of PP04). 6.3. TheO3N2index Fig. 5c shows our sample galaxies for their (O/H)Te abundances versus O3N2 indices. Although they are quite scattered, there still exists an obvious trend, i.e., O/H increases following the decreasing O3N2 index. We try to derive a calibration of O3N2 index for O/H abundances from these sample galaxies. The ob- jects with an higher uncertainty than 0.06 dex on log(O/H) and O3N2 are excluded, which leaves 585 data points. 19 objects from literature without their [N ] emission-line measurements are excluded. The mean-value points within 11 bins are obtained for the left sample galaxies. The bin widths are the same as for the N2 calibration (Sect. 6.2). A two-order polynomial fit is ob- tained by fitting the mean-value points: 12 + log(O/H) = 8.203 + 0.630 × O3N2 − 0.327 × O3N22, (10) with O3N2 = log[([O ]λ5007/Hβ)/([N ]λ6583/Hα)], shown as the solid line in Fig. 5c. The rms of the data to the fit is 0.199 dex. This fit is valid for 1.4<O3N2<3. The two dashed lines show 2σ discrepancy. The calibration of PP04 (12 + log(O/H) = 8.73 − 0.32 × O3N2) has been plotted as the long-dashed line, which is only valid for 1<O3N2<1.9. The calibration of PP04 shows a shallower slope than ours, which comes from their much smaller sample (65 objects) and the much narrower O3N2 range. 6.4. TheS2index S2 = log([S ]λλ6717,6731/Hα) is also a metallicity-sensitive indicator. Although it is less useful than N2 for metallicity cali- bration due to the stronger dependence on ionization parameter, it is still interesting to derive a calibration from S2 since it is dependent on metallicity monotonicly in the studied metallicity range. This relation has the advantage of not being strongly de- pendent on reddening corrections. Although the sample data is much scatter, a linear relation exists obviously between O/H and S2. We calculated the mean values of S2 and O/H abundances for the sample galaxies in 11 bins, the bin widths are the same as we used for the N2 and O3N2 calibrations. Again, the ob- jects with an higher uncertainty than 0.06 dex on log(O/H) and log([S ]/Hα) are excluded in the calculations, which leaves 607 data points. A least-squares linear fit to the mean-valued points yields the relation: 12 + log(O/H) = 9.128 + 1.051 × S 2, (11) with S2 = log([S ]λλ6717,6731/Hα), which is shown by the solid line in Fig. 5d. The rms of the data to the fit is about 0.176 dex. The two dashed lines show the discrepancy of 2σ. 6.5. AddthePparameter The calibration of O/H vs. N2 is dependent on ionization pa- rameter (Fig. 4b), as well the O3N2 and S2 indices (Figs. 4c,d). Therefore, to get more reliable O/H abundances, an excitation parameter could be included in the calibrations which correlates strongly with ionization parameter and the hardness of the ion- izing radiation field. We use the P parameter given by Pilyugin (2000, 2001a,b), where P was defined as [O ]/([O ]+[O ]), which is similar to [O ]/[O ], the excitation parameter used by Kobulnicky et al. (1999) in calibrations. We should notice that P needs to be computed from the dereddened emission lines. In Fig. 6a, we plot the (log(O/H)Te - log(O/H)N2) vs. P re- lations for the sample galaxies, which shows that these galaxies can roughly be separated to be three subsamples with P <0.65 (143 data points), 0.65< P<0.80 (292 data points) and P > 0.80 (149 data points). We derive the N2 calibrations for these three subsamples individually. The analytical calibrations of linear least-squares fits for the three subsamples with different P pa- rameters are: 12 + log(O/H) = 9.514 + 0.916 × N2, = 9.457 + 0.976 × N2, = 9.332 + 0.998 × N2, (P > 0.80), (0.65 < P < 0.80), (P < 0.65), (12) which are given as the solid, long-dashed and dashed lines in Fig. 6b, respectively. The rms of the data to each fit are 0.150, 0.140, 0.189 dex, respectively. The dotted lines are the photoion- ization model results of KD02. It shows that the three different P values just correspond to the cases of KD02 of q = 4 × 107, 1 × 107(as well 2 × 107) and 5 × 106 cm s−1, respectively. We have also tried to add P as an additional parameter for the O3N2 and S2 indices. The sample galaxies are separated into three sub-samples with P<0.60, 0.60<P<0.85 and P>0.85 to derive calibrations for these two indices. The basic results fol- low the photoionization models of KD02 consistently. However, Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 9 1 Fig. 5. R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices for oxygen abundance calibrations from the sample galaxies: (a). the R23 index; (b). the N2 index; (c). the O3N2 index; (d). the S2 index. The small filled points represent the SDSS galaxies and the open squares refer to the samples from literature. The points with uncertainties larger than 0.06 dex in all these line ratios and log(O/H) abundances have been excluded. The solid line in Fig.(a) refers the linear least-squares fit for all the 120 data points in the figure. The three dashed lines refer the calibrations given by Kobulnicky et al. (1999) for the three different cases of y (=log([O ]/[O ])). In Fig.(b), the long-dashed and dotted lines refer to the calibrations of PP04 and D02, respectively. In Fig.(c), the long-dashed line refers to the calibration of PP04. In Figs.(b-d), the 11 large filled circles represent the mean values in each bin of oxygen abundances (see text), and the solid lines are the least-squares fits for these mean-value points. The two dashed lines show the 2σ discrepancy from the fits in all the four panels. we find adding a P parameter does not improve the fits much. Therefore, we won't present the two-parameter calibrations for the O3N2 and S2 indices as figures here. We should notice that using P with [N ]/Hα means that we need observations covering a much wider wavelength range, which might not be practical at high z. It is not necessary to add the P parameter to the R23 cal- ibration since the observational data in the R23 vs. O/H relation does not show obvious dependence on ionization parameter in contrast to the lower-branch models (Fig. 4a). 6.6. Theaccuraciesofthederivedcalibrations the N2 calibration. Among these, the rms of the O3N2 and S2 calibrations are large, about 0.191 and 0.171 dex respectively (Fig. 7c,d). The calibration of (N2,P) case (Fig. 7b) shows the lowest rms, which is about 0.158, a bit lower than the rms in Fig. 7a and Fig. 3e for the N2 calibration (0.162 and 0.160 dex respectively). Some of the remaining scatter in log(O/H)N2,P may come from the different star forming history and evolutionary status of the sample galaxies. Fig. 8 shows a clear correlation between the log(O/H)N2,P - log(O/H)Te and the log(N/O) abundance ra- tios of the sample galaxies, which can be given as a linear least squares fit: We have presented the least-squares fits for the relations of 12 + log(O/H)Te and N2, O3N2 and S 2 indices with and without considering the P excitation parameter. To show the accuracies of these calibrations, we plot in Figs. 7a-d the comparisons be- tween log(O/H)Te and those from line indices. Figs. 7a,c,d show the comparisons with the calibrated abundances from N2, O3N2, S2 indices following Eqs. (9-11), which have been given as the solid lines in Figs. 5b-d, respectively. Fig. 7b show the cali- brated abundances from the N2 index but adding the P param- eter following Eq. (12). Adding the P parameter has improved log(O/H)N2,P − log(O/H)Te = 0.902 × log(N/O) + 1.240, (13) with a rms of 0.104 dex. The corrected calibration of (N2,P) by considering this correlation will provide much accurate oxygen abundance, and the rms of the data to the equal-value lines in Fig. 7a and Fig. 7b will decrease to be 0.115 dex, which is much less than the previous ones (0.162 and 0.158 dex, respectively). This correlation can be used to correct the derived oxygen abun- dances from strong-line ratio when it is necessary. Nevertheless, to apply the N/O correction to 12+log(O/H) abundances, we 10 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 1 Fig. 7. Comparisons between the Te-based O/H abundances with those derived from strong-line ratios, including N2 (without and with P), O3N2 and S2 indices: (a). for the N2 index (without P, Eq.(9), Fig. 5b); (b). for the N2 index (with P, Eq.(12), Fig. 6); (c). for the O3N2 index (Eq.(10), Fig. 5c); (d). for the S2 index (Eq.(11), Fig. 5d). The rms values of the data to the equal-value lines in each plot are 0.162, 0.158, 0.191 and 0.171 dex, respec- tively, they will increase to be 0.173, 0.167, 0.215 and 0.203 dex if the data points with uncertainties larger than 0.06 dex in line indices and log(O/H) are included. The symbols in Figs.(a,c,d) are the same as in Fig. 4, and the symbols in Fig.(b) are the same as in Fig. 6b. Fig. 6. (a). The relation between log(O/H)Te-log(O/H)N2 vs. P for the sample galaxies, which shows that they can be roughly divided into three subsamples with different P parameters: P > 0.80, 0.65 < P < 0.80 and P < 0.65. The symbols are the same as in Fig. 4. (b). The calibration of N2 index together with the P parameter. The blue open squares represent the samples with P > 0.80, the red points represent those with 0.65 < P < 0.80, and the green triangles represent those with P < 0.65. The solid, long-dashed and short-dashed lines refer to the linear least-squares fits for each of the three subsamples, respectively (Eq. (12)). The five dotted lines are the model results of KD02, from the right to the left ones, the ionization parameter q in- creases from the 5×106 to the 1×107, 2×107, 4×107 and 8×107 cm s−1 grids. need to measure [O ], [O ] and Hβ in addition to [N ] and Hα, thus it will not always be practical. We should notice that both the x and y axis of Fig. 8 de- pends on nitrogen abundance, which means that the observed correlation could be spurious if the errors in log(N) are large. However, the errors of the log(N/O) abundances of the sample galaxies are quite small. It is about 0.011 dex on average for the MPA/JHU sample galaxies, which is expected since we only se- lect the objects with higher signal-to-noise ratio, i.e. larger than 5σ, on the flux measurements of [N ] (see Sect.2.1). For other samples from literature, the errors of their log(N/O) values are about 0.021 dex on average. Therefore, this correlation is ro- bustly measured, and could be used to correct 12+log(O/H)N2,P measurements if desired. More importantly, the strong trend in Fig. 8 highlights the sensitivity of the N2 calibration to a galaxy's past history of star formation, since it determines the present-day N/O ratio. Fig. 8. Correlation between the difference of log(O/H)N2,P and log(O/H)Te and the log(N/O) abundance ratios of the sample galaxies. The symbols are the same as in Figs. 6b,7b. The solid line is the linear least squares fit for the relations with a rms of 0.104 dex. 7. Conclusions We compiled a large sample of 695 low-metallicity galaxies and H  regions with [O ]4363 detected, which consists of 531 galaxies from the SDSS-DR4 and 164 galaxies and H  regions from literature. We determined their electron temperatures, elec- tron densities, and then the Te-based oxygen abundances. The derived oxygen abundances of them are 7.1<12+log(O/H)<8.5. The comparison between the Te-based oxygen abundances and the Bayesian metallicities obtained by the MPA/JHU group Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations 11 show that, for about half of the MPA/JHU sample galaxies in this study, their O/H abundances were overestimated by a fac- tor of 0.34 dex on average by using the photoionization models (Charlot et al. 2006; Tremonti et al. 2004; Brinchmann et al. 2004). This is possibly related to how secondary nitrogen en- richment is treated in the models they used. The Te-derived oxygen abundances of these sample galaxies were compared with those derived from other strong-line ratios, such as R23, R23 − P, N2 and O3N2 indicators. The results show that R23 and R23−P methods will generally overestimate the oxy- gen abundances of the sample galaxies by a factor of ∼0.20 dex and ∼0.06 dex, respectively. This 0.06 dex discrepancy is quite small, and will decrease to be 0.025 dex when the improved R23 − P calibrations given by Pilyugin & Thuan (2005) are used. The abundance calibration of N2 index, rather than O3N2 index, from PP04 can result in consistent O/H abundances with (O/H)Te but with a scatter of about 0.16 dex. From this large sample of 695 star-forming galaxies and H  regions, we re-derive abundance calibrations for R23, N2, O3N2 and S2 indices on the basis of their oxygen abundances derived from Te. The N2, O3N2 and S2 indices monotonicly change fol- lowing the increasing O/H abundances from 12+log(O/H)=7.1 to 8.5, which are consistent with the photoionization model re- sults of KD02. R23 is a good metallicity indicator for the metal- poor galaxies with 12+log(O/H)<7.9. Nevertheless, R23 does not follow the KD02 models well. The scatter of the observational data may come from the differences in the ionizing radiation field. We add an excita- tion parameter P to separate the sample galaxies to be three sub-samples, and then re-derive the N2 calibrations with three different P cases (<0.65, 0.65-0.80, > 0.80), which improves the calibration, confirmed by the decreasing rms of the data to the equal-value line, which decreases from 0.162 in Fig. 7a to 0.158 in Fig. 7b. But adding the P parameter in the O3N2 and S2 indices does not improve the calibrations. However, some of the remaining scatter in the (N2,P) calibration may come from the different star forming history and evolutionary status of the galaxies, which can be confirmed by the correlation between the log(O/H)N2,P - log(O/H)Te and log(N/O) of them (Fig. 8 and Eq. 13). In the future studies about calibrating oxygen abundances of galaxies, when their Te values are not available, we can use the R23, N2, O3N2 or S2 indices, together with the P parameter sometimes (if the wavelength coverage is wide enough), to cal- ibrate their oxygen abundances. R23 shows obvious correlation with oxygen abundances for the low-metallicity galaxies with 12+log(O/H)<7.9. Comparing with O3N2 and S2, N2 is less affected by ionization parameter and more obviously correlate with O/H abundances. Also it can be detected by the near in- frared instruments for the intermediate- and high-z star-forming galaxies. The N2 index has helped to provide important infor- mation on the metallicities of galaxies at high-z, for example, Shapley et al. (2004) for a sample of 7 star-forming galaxies at 2.1<z<2.5, Shapley et al. (2005) for a sample of 12 star-forming galaxies at z ∼1.0-1.5, and Erb et al. (2006) from the six compos- ited spectra of 87 rest-frame UV-selected star-forming galaxies at z>2 etc. However, considering the dependence of N2 (as well the (N2,P)) calibration on log(N/O) shown as Fig. 8, we should keep in mind that the resulted log(O/H) abundances from N2 may involve the specific history of N-enrichment in the galax- ies. We may worry a bit about comparing the low and high-z observations using [N ] for this reason. Given the good consistency of our N2 and S2 abun- dance calibrations with the models of KD02 at low metallic- ity (see Fig. 4b,d), it may be appropriate to linearly extrapo- late our calibrations up to the high metallicity region, up to 12+log(O/H)∼9.0 and 8.8 respectively. However, this extrapo- lation on N2 will result in lower log(O/H) abundance than the one directly derived from the calibration of the metal-rich SDSS galaxies obtained by Liang et al. (2006), which may be due to the discrepancy between the Te- and the R23-based metallicities. However, the Te-based O3N2 calibration cannot be directly ex- trapolated to the metal-rich region since the slopes of the cor- relation relations between log(O/H) vs. O3N2 are not the same in the high-metallicity branch as in the low-metallicity branch (Fig. 4c). R23 parameter cannot provide reliable oxygen abun- dances for the galaxies in the metallicity turn-over region with 7.9<12+log(O/H)<8.5. Acknowledgments We thank the referee for many valuable and wise suggestions and comments, which help us in improving well this work. We thank Stephane Charlot for the interesting discussions about their mod- els to estimate the oxygen abundances of the SDSS galaxies. S.Y.Y. and Y.C.L. thank Jing Wang and Caina Hao for the in- teresting discussions about the SDSS database. S.Y.Y thanks Yongheng Zhao and the LAMOST group kindly provide their of- fice for staying. This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) Foundation under No.10403006. References Adelman-McCarthy, J. K. et al., 2006, ApJS, 162, 3!8 Alloin, D., Collin-Souffrin, S., Joly M., Vigroux, L., 1979, A&A, 78, 200 Baldwin, J., Phillips, M.M., Terlevich, R.J., 1981, PASP, 93, 5 Bresolin, F., Garnett, D.R., & Kennicutt, R. C. Jr., 2004, ApJ, 615, 228 Bresolin, F., Schaerer, D. et al. 2005, A&A, 441, 981 Brinchmann, J., Charlot, S., White, S.D.M., Tremonti, C., Kauffmann, G., Heckman, T. & Brinkmann, J., 2004, MNRAS, 351, 1151 Bruzual, A.G., Charlot, S., 2003, MNRAS, 344, 1000 Calzetti, D., Kinney, A.L., Storchi-Bergmann, T., 1994, ApJ, 429, 582 Charlot, S. & Longhetti, M., 2001, MNRAS, 323, 887 (CL01) de Robertis, M.M., Dufour, R. J., Hunt, R.W., 1987, JRASC, 81, 195 Denicol´o, G., Terlevich, R., Terlevich, E., 2002, MNRAS, 330, 69 (D02) D´iaz, A.I., P´erez-Montero, E., V´ilchez, J.M., Pagel, B.E., Edmunds, M.G., 1991, MNRAS, 253, 245 Erb, D. K., Shapley, A. E., Pettini, M. et al. 2006, ApJ, 644, 813 Garnett, D.R., 1992, AJ, 103, 1330 Garnett, D.R., Edmunds, M.G., Henry, R.B.C., Pagel, B.E.J., Skillman, E.D., 2004a, ApJ, 128, 2722 Garnett, D.R., Kennicutt, R.C. Jr., Bresolin, F., 2004b, ApJ, 607, L21 Guseva, N.G., Papaderos, P., Izotov, Y.I., et al. 2003a, A&A, 407, 75 Guseva, N.G., Papaderos, P., Izotov, Y.I., et al. 2003b, A&A, 407, 91 Guseva, N.G., Papaderos, P., Izotov, Y.I., et al. 2003c, A&A, 407, 105 Izotov, Y.I., Andrew, B.D., et al. 1996, ApJ, 458, 524 Izotov, Y.I., Chaffee, F.H., Foltz, R.F., Green, R.F., Guseva, N.G., Thuan, T.X., 1999a, ApJ, 527, 757 Izotov, Y.I., Chaffee, F.H., Green, R.B., 2001a, ApJ, 562, 727 Izotov, Y.I., Chaffee, F.H., Schaerer, D., 2001b, A&A, 378, L45 Izotov, Y.I., Lipovetsky, V.A., et al. 1997b, ApJ, 476, 698 Izotov, Y.I., Papaderos, P., Guseva, N.G., Fricke, K.J., Thuan, T.X., 2004b, A&A, 421, 539 Izotov, Y.I., Stasinska, G., Meynet, G., Guseva, N.G., Thuan, T.X., 2005, A&A, 448, 955 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., 1998a, ApJ, 497, 227 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., 1998b, ApJ, 500, 188 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., 1999b, ApJ, 511, 639 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., 2004a, ApJ, 602, 200 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., Lipovetsky, V.A., 1994, ApJ, 435, 647 Izotov, Y.I., Thuan, T.X., Lipovetsky, V.A., 1997a, ApJS, 108, 1 Kauffmann, G., Heckman, T.M., Tremonti, C.A., et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, 1055 Kennicutt, R.C.Jr., 1992, ApJ, 388, 310 Kennicutt, R.C.Jr., Bresolin, F., Garnett, D.R., 2003, ApJ, 591, 801 Kewley, L.J., & Dopita, M.A., 2002, ApJS, 142, 35 (KD02) 12 Yin et al.: Oxygen abundance calibrations Kewley, L.J., Dopita M., Sutherland R., Heisler C., Trevena J., 2001, ApJ, 556, 121 Kewley, L.J., Jansen, R.A., Geller, M.J., 2005, PASP, 117, 227 Kinney, A.L., Bohlin, R.C., Calzetti, D., Panagia, N., Wyse, R.F.G., 1993, ApJS, 86, 5 Kniazev, A.Y., Pustilnik, S.A., Masegosa, J., et al. 2000, A&A, 357, 101 Kobulnicky, H.A., Kennicutt, R.C.Jr., & Pizagno, J.L., 1999, ApJ, 514, 544 (K99) Lamareille, F., Contini, T., Brinchmann, J., Le Borgne, J.-F., Charlot, S., & Richard, J. 2006, A&A, 448, 907 Lee, J.C., Salzer, J.J., & Melbourne, J., 2004, ApJ, 616, 752 Liang, Y.C., Yin, S.Y., Hammer, F. et al. 2006, ApJ (in press), astro-ph/0607074 McGaugh, S. S. 1991, ApJ, 380, 140 Melbourne, J., Phillips, A., Salzer, J.J., Gronwall, C., Sarajedini, V.l., 2004, AJ, 127, 686 Moustakas, J. & Kennicutt, R.C.Jr. 2006, ApJ, astro-ph/0511731, Nagao, T., Maiolino, R., Marconi, A., 2006, A&A, (in press), astro-ph/0603580 Osterbrock, D.E., 1989, Astrophysics of Gaseous Nebulae and Active Galactic Nuclei. Mill Valley, California: University Science Books Pagel, B.E.J., Edmunds, M.G., Blackwell, D.E., et al. 1979, MNRAS, 189, 95 Pettini, M., & Pagel, B.E.J., 2004, MNRAS, 348, L59 (PP04) P´erez-Montero, E., D´iaz, A.I., 2005, MNRAS, 361, 1063 Pilyugin, L.S., 2000, A&A, 362, 325 Pilyugin, L.S., 2001a, A&A, 369, 594 Pilyugin, L.S., 2001b, A&A, 373, 56 Pilyugin, L. S., Contini, T., V´ılchez, J. M., 2004, A&A, 423, 427 Pilyugin, L. S. Thuan, T. X., 2005, ApJ, 631, 231 Pilyugin, L. S. Thuan, T. X., V´ılchez, J. M., 2006, MNRAS, 367, 1139 Raimann, D., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Bica, E., et al. 2000, MNRAS, 316, 559 Shapley, A. E., Coil, A. L., Ma, C. P., Bundy, K., 2005, ApJ, 635, 1006 Shapley, A. E., Erb, D. K., Pettini, M. et al. 2004, ApJ, 612, 108 Shaw, R.A., & Dufour, R.J., 1995, PASP, 107, 896 Shi, F., Kong, X., Li, C., Cheng, F.Z., 2005, A&A, 437, 849 Shi, F., Kong, X., Cheng, F.Z., 2006, A&A, 453, 487 Skillman, E.D., Cote, S., Miller, B. W., 2003, AJ, 125, 610 Skillman, E.D., Kennicutt, R.C.Jr., Hodge, P.W., 1989, ApJ, 347, 875 Stasi´nska, G. 2002, lecturestobepublishedintheproceedingsoftheXIIICanary IslandsWinterSchoolofAstrophysics, astro-ph/0207500 Stasi´nska, G., & Leitherer C., 1996, ApJS, 107, 661 Stasi´nska, G. 2005, A&A, 434, 507 Storchi-Bergmann, T., Calzetti, D., Kinney, A.L., 1994, ApJ, 429, 572 Thurston, T. R., Edmunds, M. G., Henry, R. B. C. 1996, MNRAS, 283, 990 Tremonti, C.A., Heckman, T.M., Kauffmann, G., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 898 van Zee, L., 2000, ApJ, 543,L31 van Zee, L. & Haynes, M. P. 2006, ApJ, 636, 214 Veilleux, S., Osterbrock, D., 1987, ApJS, 63, 295 V´ilchez, J.M., & Iglesias-P´aramo, J., 2003, ApJS, 145, 225
astro-ph/9604145	1	9604	1996-04-24T21:14:46	Properties of Simulated Compact Groups of Galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	We analyze compact groups of galaxies appearing in a galaxy formation simulation dominated by cold dark matter (omega_0=1, omega_{baryon}=0.1). The simulation uses an N-body code to model the behavior of the non-baryonic matter and smoothed particle hydrodynamics to model the baryons. One run includes gas dynamics alone, and the other incorporates star formation as well. Groups identified as physically compact at z=0 form originally along filaments and become compact in the final ~20% of the simulation; they contain x-ray--luminous diffuse gas well before becoming compact. The component masses, baryon fractions, and gas-to-galaxy mass fractions of the simulated groups are roughly similar somewhat more gas-rich and have x-ray temperatures a factor of 3 lower than those seen in HCGs. These discrepancies may be alleviated by adding the effects of energy input into the diffuse group gas by star formation and supernovae.	astro-ph	astro-ph	To appear in The Astronomical Journal, August 1996 Properties of Simulated Compact Groups of Galaxies Department of Astronomy, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1090; Rachel A. Pildis1 [email protected] August E. Evrard Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1120; [email protected] and Joel N. Bregman Department of Astronomy, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1090; [email protected] ABSTRACT We analyze compact groups of galaxies appearing in a galaxy formation simulation dominated by cold dark matter (Ω0=1, Ωbaryon=0.1). The simulation uses an N-body code to model the behavior of the non-baryonic matter and smoothed particle hydrodynamics to model the baryons. One run includes gas dynamics alone, and the other incorporates star formation as well. Groups identified as physically compact at z=0 form originally along filaments and become compact in the final ∼20% of the simulation; they contain x-ray -- luminous diffuse gas well before becoming compact. The component masses, baryon fractions, and gas-to-galaxy mass fractions of the simulated groups are roughly similar to those of Hickson compact groups (HCGs), although they tend to be somewhat more gas-rich and have x-ray temperatures a factor of 3 lower than those seen in HCGs. These discrepancies may be alleviated by adding the effects of energy input into the diffuse group gas by star formation and supernovae. 1current address: Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden St., MS 83, Cambridge MA 02138 -- 2 -- 1. Introduction Most galaxies are neither completely isolated nor in rich clusters, but instead are found in galaxy groups that contain only a handful of members. Although galaxy groups are very common, they have not been extensively studied due to the difficulty of determining whether a galaxy density enhancement on the plane of the sky is a true group or simply a superposition of field galaxies. Thus, many investigations of groups have focused on "compact groups of galaxies", particularly those catalogued by Hickson (1982). Hickson compact groups (HCGs) were selected to have high average surface brightness and to be relatively isolated, conditions that increase the probability that the groups are physically compact. Subsequent redshift measurements showed that 92 of the original 100 HCGs contain at least three galaxies with concordant redshifts, strengthening this argument (Hickson et al. 1992). HCGs have been observed throughout the electromagnetic spectrum for signs of galaxy-galaxy interaction and other indications of physical compactness (see Pildis, Bregman, & Evrard 1995, hereafter Paper I, for an overview). The results have been contradictory at best: strong hints of interaction (e.g., HI deficits in HCG spiral galaxies, a probable diffuse x-ray -- emitting intragroup medium in a subset of groups) coexist with the lack of other interaction signs (e.g., no obviously merged HCG remnants, few to no HCG ellipticals with signs of recent mergers). Furthermore, the analysis of the x-ray observations of these groups is complicated by systematic differences between the reduction procedures of different groups. Depending on the choice of background level and plasma metallicity, as well as other free parameters, the same data can be interpreted to give gas and total masses that differ by up to an order of magnitude (e.g., Paper I, Saracco & Ciliegi 1995, Mulchaey et al. 1996). While preceding papers in this series (Paper I and Pildis, Bregman, & Schombert 1995, hereafter Paper II) and other recent work have shown that some order can be found in this confusion -- for example, that elliptical-rich HCGs tend to have intragroup media while spiral-rich groups don't, and that HCG ellipticals are not as quiescent as they appear at first glance -- in no sense is there a coherent picture of what Hickson compact groups are and how they evolve. Observations alone can shed only a limited amount of light on the puzzle of Hickson compact groups. While optical and x-ray data can give information about the matter that radiates in those wavebands as well as some indirect indication about quantities such as the total gravitating mass, they cannot provide direct and unambiguous information about invisible baryonic components such as hot gas whose emission is absorbed by Galactic neutral hydrogen or diffuse cold gas, much less non-baryonic matter. Furthermore, while optical signs of interaction in HCGs -- such as shells around galaxies and diffuse light in the -- 3 -- group potential -- imply certain limits on the interaction history of a group, they do not provide many details about that history. Simulations of galaxy formation and structure evolution can help answer some of these questions. For example, recent simulations by Hernquist, Katz, & Weinberg (1995) have found that galaxies form in filaments, and thus many compact-appearing groups may be filaments of galaxies seen end on. In such cases, even though the galaxies have projected separations of tens of kiloparsecs, they are physically separated by 2 -- 10 Mpc along the filament. While Hernquist et al. did not propose any immediate tests to determine how many Hickson groups are probable projections (redshift-independent distance indicators would test their hypothesis, but such indicators are not sufficiently accurate to use for this purpose), their study illustrates how simulations can explain earlier, seemingly contradictory observations and can help guide future observations in order to test a theory. One suggestion as to how to discriminate between projected groups and physically compact ones has been made by Ostriker, Lubin, & Hernquist (1995). They claim that their Q parameter should be a constant for all physically compact groupings, from compact groups up to rich clusters (Q = LX a3 the bolometric x-ray luminosity, Lg the galaxy luminosity in the blue, and f (T ) gives the temperature dependence for the x-ray luminosity of a thermal plasma). Using cluster data and the results that were given in Paper I, they conclude that HCGs are either elongated along the line of sight to the extent that they cannot be considered true groups or extremely gas-poor relative to rich clusters. g f (T )−1, where ap is the projected radius, LX pL−2 In order to interpret the observational results from Paper I and Paper II, we analyze some "Hickson-like" groups found in a simulation of galaxy formation in a universe dominated by cold dark (non-baryonic) matter. Such an analysis improves our qualitative understanding of group formation and provides some level of quantitative detail on basic quantities related to their evolution and present structure. Properties such as a group's baryon fraction, gas-to-stellar mass ratio, and temperature of its x-ray -- luminous gas can be compared to observed quantities in HCGs. In addition, the simulations provide the dynamical histories of the groups. If the simulated groups have roughly the same properties as do the HCGs in our sample, then examining the time evolution of the simulated groups will provide insight into how compact groups form and evolve. 2. Simulation Description -- 4 -- 2.1. Galaxy Formation Simulation We model the formation of structure in a flat (Ω = 1) universe that is 10% baryons and 90% cold dark matter by mass. We assume a (current) Hubble constant of H0=50 km s−1 Mpc−1, zero cosmological constant, and a biased normalization of the power spectrum σ8=0.59, where σ8 is the rms level of fluctuations in spheres of radius 8h−1 Mpc. The volume simulated is a periodic cube, with sides of comoving length 16 Mpc. Although this model does not fit all observations of large-scale structure, it fares best on the scales of galaxies and small groups. The most serious concern is the low global baryon fraction of 10% which may be inconsistent with the high baryon fraction observed in x-ray clusters (White et al. 1993). The method used to create the simulation is described in Evrard, Summers, & Davis (1994 -- hereafter ESD). Our simulation differs from ESD in two important respects: (i) the initial conditions were not constrained to produce a cluster of galaxies and (ii) the simulation was evolved to z=0 instead of z=1. Other methods and assumptions are identical to ESD. The dark matter dynamics are simulated using the N-body code of Efstathiou & Eastwood (1981), while the baryons are modeled using smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH), with thermal pressure, shock heating, and radiative cooling taken into account and primordial elemental abundances assumed. Each mass component is resolved by 643 particles. A minimum temperature of 104 K is imposed for the baryons. The simulation is evolved from z = 31 to z = 0 in 2000 equal time steps of 6.5 × 106 years. Due to data storage capacity limitations, we are examining the output from only every fortieth time step, leading to a time resolution of 2.6 × 108 years for this study. The baryon particles each have a mass of 1.08 × 108 M⊙, while the dark matter particles are nine times more massive. The simulation was run twice with the same initial conditions. The first run (designated "GO" for "gas only") had no star formation; all the baryon particles behaved as a gas. Galaxies, or more precisely, "galaxy-like objects," are defined here as in ESD: cool (T ∼ 104 K) clumps of baryons with mean densities greater than 106 times the current background density of the universe (n > 0.5 cm−3). The second run (designated "SF" for "star formation") included star formation by flagging baryonic particles above a particle density n∗ = 0.1 cm−3 and below a temperature T∗ = 2 × 104 K as star-forming. These particles were turned into collisionless "stars" in 1 -- 20 time steps (6.5 -- 130 × 106 years) after they were flagged as star-forming, with the length of the delay being determined by a random number generator. The results are not particularly sensitive to the choice of the threshold parameters, as long as one is targeting the highly dissipated baryonic component. -- 5 -- Neither of the runs includes metal enrichment or energy feedback into the intragroup medium by star formation and supernovae. These important effects will be added in future simulations. Each of the above simulations was run on an HP 735 workstation and required roughly one month of CPU time to execute. 2.2. Group Selection and Description It would be difficult to find compact groups in this simulation using criteria similar to the ones employed by Hickson (1982), since this simulation is of a volume of 4 × 103 Mpc3 and the observed space density of HCGs is 4 × 10−5 h3 Mpc−3 (Mendes de Oliveira & Hickson 1991). This implies that one would have to run 50 simulations or have 50 distinct viewing angles for projected groups (since h = 0.5 here) to create even one HCG. Thus, the groups we have chosen should be considered to be simply illustrative of how some types of compact-appearing groups evolve in a CDM universe, rather than a definitive study of all possible HCG-like objects. The similarities we have found between these groups and actual HCGs, however, make a strong case for the relevance of our choices. Initially, three probable compact groups were chosen from the z=0 GO data set as similar to Hickson compact groups in appearance. Group members were first found using a friends-of-friends algorithm with a linking parameter equal to 0.15 times the mean interparticle separation. The center of the group was defined to be the position of the most bound dark matter particle, and all particles within a sphere of overdensity 100 were designated as part of the group. The evolution of those particles was then traced back to the initial redshift. Further examination showed that the smallest of the three groups was too poor to be classified as a Hickson-type compact group, and thus our final sample is comprised of two groups. We will use the nomenclature from the GO simulation as a whole and call them g2 (the larger group) and g4. These groups were recovered (with slightly different masses and locations) in the SF run, so a comparison can be made between the evolution and properties of groups with and without star formation. Using a three-dimensional visualization program (the Application Visualization System) to examine the evolution of these groups, we find that both g2 and g4 formed in the same type of environment (see Fig. 1 -- 2). As in the Hernquist et al. (1995) simulation, we find that most of the "galaxy-like objects" in each group are found initially in a single filament. As time passes, however, these objects are seen to stream towards a T-intersection with another, poorer filament (where the larger filament is the crossbar of the T -- this is best seen in the xy projection of Fig. 1 and the zx projection of Fig. 2). At the junction of the two filaments, a physically compact group forms in the last 2 -- 3 Gyr of the simulation. -- 6 -- Fig. 1. -- The distribution of different mass components in group g2 as a function of lookback time and viewing angle in the simulation with star formation. The three columns show the position of particles at lookback times of 6.5, 3.1 and 0 Gyr (left to right) projected onto the yz, zx, and xy planes (top to bottom), where the first coordinate listed is always plotted along the horizontal axis. The large tickmarks are at 1 Mpc intervals. The sharp edge seen in some of the particle distributions is due to the definition of a group as a sphere at z = 0. (a) Dark matter. (d) Galaxy-like objects in the "gas only" simulation. Note the lack of mergers relative to (c). (b) ROSAT -detectable gas (T > 106 K). (c) Galaxy-like objects. -- 7 -- Fig. 1b. -- -- 8 -- Fig. 1c. -- -- 9 -- Fig. 1d. -- -- 10 -- Fig. 2a. -- The distribution of different mass components in group g4 as a function of lookback time and viewing angle in the simulation with star formation. See the caption to Fig. 1. (a) Dark matter. (b) ROSAT -detectable gas (T > 106 K). (c) Galaxy-like objects. (d) Galaxy-like objects in the "gas only" simulation. Note the lack of mergers relative to (c). -- 11 -- Fig. 2b. -- -- 12 -- Fig. 2c. -- -- 13 -- Fig. 2d. -- -- 14 -- From Figs. 1c and 2c, it appears that "galaxy" mergers occur more readily in the simulation with star formation than without (compare to Figs. 1d and 2d). However, Fig. 3, which gives a magnified view of the group centers, shows that several distinct galaxies lurk under the tidal debris. Comparable numbers of distinct galaxy-like objects are found in the GO and SF runs. In the latter, the collisionless nature of the "stellar particles" leaves them susceptible to being stripped by gravitational tides. This effect is enhanced by the limited spatial resolution of the simulation; real galaxies are more compact and would suffer less tidal mass loss than the simulated galaxies in the SF run. The merger history of the dark matter groups in the SF run as a function of lookback time is shown in Fig. 4. As is seen in Fig. 1, group g2 consists of two large subgroups of equal mass that only begin merging in the final Gyr of the simulation. Group g4 has a significant merger at a lookback time of roughly 5 Gyr, involving three sub-groups differing in mass by less than a factor of 2. A smaller merger of a satellite only 10% of the group mass occurs 2.5 Gyr from the present. Most of the mass in galaxies is formed in small halos which collapse within the first 2 Gyr of the simulation (at redshifts z ∼ 2 -- 3). In these compact groups and in smaller subgroupings that form along the filaments, mergers of galaxy-like objects in the GO run occur roughly every 109 years, similar to the timescales seen in other simulations of physically compact groups (Mamon 1987, Barnes 1989, Bode et al. 1993). In each group, a few galaxy-like objects continue streaming in along the two filaments to their intersection after a compact group is formed. If left alone for several billion years, the galaxies in each physically compact group would spiral into the center of the common group potential and merge to a single, final remnant. Group g4 is much closer to this stage than is g2; indeed, the two subgroups of g2 are classified as separate Hickson-like groups for several Gyr before their merger at the end of the simulation. Hickson-like groups identified at z=0.2 (lookback time of 3.2 Gyr) or z=0.5 (lookback time of 6.1 Gyr) are either the progenitors of g4 and g2 or merge into the poor cluster that also forms in the simulation -- no isolated merger remnants of halo mass ∼1013 M⊙ are found. The fact that we find no clear "fossil" group remnants may be due to our small simulated volume rather than the inherent rarity of such objects. Larger simulations will test this. 3. Quantitative Analysis and Comparison to Observations -- 15 -- Fig. 3a. -- A close-up view of the galaxy-like objects in the simulation with star formation (left) and the "gas-only" simulation (right) at a lookback time of 0 Gyr. The projections and tickmarks follow the same convention as in Fig. 1 -- 2. (a) Group g2. (b) Group g4. -- 16 -- Fig. 3b. -- -- 17 -- Fig. 4. -- Merger histories for groups g2 (top) and g4 (bottom) in the simulation with star formation. A group-finding algorithm is run every twentieth timestep to identify subgroups with masses over 3 × 1010 M⊙ at least half of whose mass ends up in the final group at z=0. Group g2 is comprised of two separate Hickson-like groups until the final Gyr of the simulation, while g4 has a significant merger at a lookback time of ∼5 Gyr. -- 18 -- 3.1. Mass Fractions Since the number of particles in each of the groups is fixed as the simulation is evolved, the total mass and the baryon fraction does not change in time. Table 1 lists the total mass and baryon fraction for each group in both runs, as well as the hot gas (T > 106 K) and galaxy masses and their ratio at z=0. Also given is the "observed" baryon fraction where, as in x-ray -- observed HCGs, the only baryons counted are those in galaxies and hot gas. Table 2 lists the same quantities at a radius of 0.2 Mpc, the typical extent of ROSAT PSPC detections of x-ray emission in HCGs. For comparison, Table 3 lists the similar mass components measured for HCGs in Paper I. While the total mass increases by factors of 2 -- 4 as one goes from a radius of 0.2 Mpc to the outermost radius of the groups (typically 0.8 -- 1.0 Mpc at an overdensity of 100), the baryon fraction changes very little, declining by under 30% for all groups. The gas-to-galaxy mass ratio, however, roughly doubles at the larger radius in the GO simulation and triples in the SF run. Such changes are expected both theoretically and observationally. Due to dissipation, galaxies cluster more strongly than does the dark matter. Conversely, the hot gas is less bound than either galaxies or dark matter due to mergers, which also explains why the baryon fractions of the groups as a whole are less than the baryon fraction of the simulation (10%). Mergers transfer energy from the dark matter to the gas, resulting in a flatter radial distribution for the gas than the dark matter (Pearce et al. 1994). X-ray observations of groups and clusters support this hypothesis, finding that galaxies are the most centrally concentrated mass component and hot gas the least concentrated, with dark matter having an intermediate distribution (David et al. 1995). At a radius of 0.2 Mpc, the simulated groups have smaller total and galaxy masses than those measured for the HCGs listed in Table 3, but roughly comparable gas masses. The simulated groups also have slightly lower baryon fractions and greater gas-to-galaxy mass ratios than HCGs measured at the same radius. As one moves to larger radii in the simulated groups, the masses move closer to the observed values, but the mass ratios (gas-to-galaxy and baryon fraction) depart more and more from what is seen in HCGs. We have divided the non-stellar baryons into four classes: cold and dense (i.e., galaxies or galaxy-like objects), cold and diffuse, hot and detectable by ROSAT , and hot and not detectable by ROSAT . Table 4 lists the characteristics of each. Both density and temperature are critical in determining whether a particular set of baryons could be detected by the type of x-ray and optical observations described in Papers I and II. Matter must be both cold and dense to form a galaxy, and a diffuse intragroup medium needs to be sufficiently hot to emit detectable x-rays. -- 19 -- Table 1. Total component masses for simulated groups Group Mtotal/M⊙ Mgas/M⊙ Mgal/M⊙ Mgas/Mgal fb,obs a fb,tot a g2-GO 1.89 × 1013 g4-GO 6.25 × 1012 4.06 × 1011 1.38 × 1011 1.05 × 1012 4.25 × 1011 g2-SF g4-SF 2.11 × 1013 6.42 × 1012 1.02 × 1012 1.73 × 1011 8.50 × 1011 3.26 × 1011 38.7% 32.6% 119% 52.9% 7.7% 7.9% 9.0% 9.4% 8.9% 9.2% 7.9% 9.1% aThe "observed" baryon fraction counts only galaxy-like objects and hot gas as baryons and the "total" baryon fraction counts all baryons. Table 2. Component masses for simulated groups at r=0.2 Mpc Group Mtotal/M⊙ Mgas/M⊙ Mgal/M⊙ Mgas/Mgal fb,obs a fb,tot a g2-GO 5.51 × 1012 g4-GO 3.09 × 1012 7.97 × 1010 5.66 × 1010 3.67 × 1011 3.64 × 1011 g2-SF g4-SF 5.35 × 1012 2.97 × 1012 1.17 × 1011 4.70 × 1010 3.74 × 1011 2.63 × 1011 21.7% 15.5% 31.2% 17.8% 8.1% 8.2% 13.7% 13.8% 9.2% 9.4% 10.5% 10.9% aThe "observed" baryon fraction counts only galaxy-like objects and hot gas as baryons and the "total" baryon fraction counts all baryons. -- 20 -- Table 3. Component masses for HCGs Group Mgrav/M⊙ Mgas/M⊙ Mgal/M⊙ Mgas/Mgal fbaryon HCG 12 HCG 62 HCG 68 HCG 97 1.4 × 1013 2.9 × 1013 8.7 × 1012 1.4 × 1013 2.2 × 1011 8.1 × 1011 4.0 × 1010 1.5 × 1011 1.9 × 1012 7.3 × 1011 1.6 × 1012 1.5 × 1012 12% 110% 2.5% 10% 15% 5.3% 19% 12% Note. -- Adapted from Paper I: Mgrav is the total gravitating mass of a group as determined from X-ray observations and Mgal is the mass in stars as determined from the optical magnitude of a group. Table 4. Non-stellar baryon classification Type Temperature (K) Density (cm−3) cold, dense cold, diffuse hot, non-ROSAT hot, ROSAT < 105 < 105 105 ≥ T ≥ 106 > 106 > 10−2 ≤ 10−2 all n all n -- 21 -- The evolution of the mass in each of these four components is similar in both groups and both runs (Fig. 5). The initial dominance of the cold, diffuse component is quickly surpassed by that of the cold, dense galaxy-like objects (which are mainly composed of stars in the SF run). The amount of ROSAT -detectable gas grows steadily through time, while the amount of hot but non-ROSAT -detectable gas rises to a maximum at a lookback time of 6 -- 8 Gyr, then decreases to a level comparable to that in cold, diffuse gas. The exception to this is group g4 in the SF run, which has a moderate jump in ROSAT -luminous gas at a lookback time of roughly 4 Gyr and a similar drop in the amount of gas not detectable by ROSAT . These changes are due to the major merger event in g4 which begins at a lookback time of 5 Gyr (see Fig. 4). Except in g4-SF, all but ∼5% of the baryons are either in galaxies or hot (ROSAT - detectable) gas by z = 0, with gas-to-galaxies ratios of 39% (g2) and 33% (g4) for the GO run, and 119% (g2) and 53% (g4) for the SF run. These are smaller ratios than those seen in rich groups and clusters (200 -- 600% [Arnaud et al. 1992, David et al. 1990]) or in the ESD simulation of a medium-sized cluster of galaxies (∼200%), but are larger than the values for HCGs listed in Table 3. Examining the simulated groups at radii comparable to those of the observed groups reduces but does not eliminate this discrepancy (see Table 2). Since the observed values from x-ray observations depend strongly on the assumed values for the metallicity of the intragroup medium and x-ray background level (Paper I, Mulchaey et al. 1996) and since the gas-to-galaxy mass ratios in simulations are likely to be altered by the addition of supernova-powered energy feedback, this discrepancy is less important than the confirmation that small groups of galaxies continue the trend of decreasing gas fraction with decreasing mass scale that is seen both theoretically and observationally in clusters of galaxies. The SF groups have noticibly more mass in hot gas and less in galaxy-like objects than do the GO groups (see also Tables 1 and 2). This difference arises from the lower ambient densities, and therefore longer cooling times, for gas attempting to cool and accrete onto galaxies in the SF run. It must be remembered that supernova feedback from star-forming galaxies, an effect not included in these runs, may significantly affect the dynamics of the hot gas component (White 1991, Metzler & Evrard 1996). 3.2. X-Ray Properties Since x-ray measurements of HCGs provide a great deal of information about their physical reality and component masses, a good test of these simulated groups is to explore the properties of the baryons that would emit radiation detectable by the ROSAT PSPC. -- 22 -- Fig. 5. -- Mass fractions for the baryons in g2 (top) and g4 (bottom) as a function of lookback time for both simulations. The dotted lines are the cold, diffuse component; the solid lines are the cold, dense component; the dashed lines are the ROSAT -detectable hot gas; and the dash-dot lines are the non-ROSAT -detectable hot gas. In the star formation simulation, the upper solid line is stars plus cold, dense gas, and the lower solid line is stars alone. -- 23 -- Figure 6 shows contour plots of the predicted x-ray flux from the simulated groups in the SF run in a style similar to observational x-ray contour plots. The groups are placed at an assumed redshift z = 0.015, typical of nearby HCGs. Plotted on top of the contours are the positions of the stellar or dark matter particles in the group. The emission from both groups is elongated, similar to that seen in the HCGs described in Paper I (e.g., HCG 12 and 97). The position angle changes from the center, where it is close to that of the galaxy-like objects, to the outer regions, where it follows the dark matter potential. The difference in orientation is an indication of recent dynamical evolution. The x-ray contours do not extend as far out as ones in actual HCGs -- the lowest contour displayed is at a level equivalent to 1% of the assumed background of 3 × 10−4 PSPC counts s−1 arcmin−2, while the lowest contours shown in Paper I are at ∼10% of the background level. To some degree, this may reflect the lack of metal enrichment in the simulation. Figure 7 shows the time evolution of the mass in ROSAT -detectable gas in the groups, as well as two different measures of the temperature of that gas. The gas temperature measured by an x-ray telescope is the "emission-weighted temperature," where the weighting factor is the volume emission measure (VEM): n2dV, integrated over the gas, where n is the particle density in the hot gas and dV is a volume element. The mass-weighted temperature cannot be determined in actual groups, but it is a more accurate measure of the average temperature of the hot gas. As is seen in Fig. 5, Fig. 7 shows that the two groups exhibit similar behavior of their mass in x-ray gas: an initial quick rise lasting ∼2 Gyr, followed by a slow but steady rise until the present, with the SF run producing more hot gas than the GO run. In both runs, group g2 has hot gas 2 Gyr before g4 does and has a greater final gas mass, which is not surprising since g2 is a more massive group. The two measures of the temperature appear to follow each other closely and to have similar histories in both groups; however, the emission-weighted temperature tends to be somewhat higher than the mass-weighted temperature, and also exhibits larger fluctuations. The run with star formation has gas temperatures that are systematically lower than the GO run, as well as smaller fluctuations. These differences are produced by the exchange of momentum and energy between the hot and cold phases of the gas in the GO run, an effect which does not exist in the SF run due to the dramatically reduced cold, dense gas fraction. Overall, the groups in both simulations show relatively steady temperatures from the initial appearance of the hot gas until lookback times of 2 -- 4 Gyr, where a sharp rise of ∼50% is seen, more clearly in the mass-weighted temperature than in the observable emission-weighted temperature. This rise is correlated with the formation of a physically compact group. Group g2-SF is the exception, with a constant to slowly increasing -- 24 -- Fig. 6. -- X-ray contours and star positions (left) or dark matter positions (right) for g2 (top) and g4 (bottom) for a lookback time of 0 Gyr. The axes are marked in arcminutes, assuming a redshift for both groups of z=0.015 (1′= 0.026 Mpc). The contours are logarithmic at intervals of 100.25 and the heavy contour is at 10% of the typical background level detected by the ROSAT PSPC. The large subgroup in g2 is not within the boundaries of the upper two plots. -- 25 -- Fig. 7. -- Mass and two measures of the temperature of the ROSAT -detectable hot baryons in in g2 (top) and g4 (bottom) as a function of lookback time in both simulations. The dotted lines represent the log of the mass in ROSAT -detectable hot gas (right axes); the solid lines are the emission-weighted temperature of that gas; and the dashed lines are the mass-weighted temperature of the gas. -- 26 -- temperature through the last 10 Gyr in lookback time. This lack of a sharp increase in temperature is due to the merger of the two subgroups being delayed slightly in the SF run relative to the GO run. It is likely that such a sharp increase would have been seen if the SF simulation had continued beyond z = 0. A decline in temperature is seen in g4 at small lookback times, which may be due to the cooling of gas heated by the merger that occurs at ∼5 Gyr. The one exception to the overall similarities between the two temperature measures is the behavior of the emission-weighted temperature in g2-GO at lookback times of 5 -- 8 Gyr. This temperature measure follows the rise of the mass-weighted temperature, but with a displacement: it is 1.5 to 2 times higher than the mass-weighted temperature. This implies that the density of some of the hot gas in g2 is unusually high at lookback times of 5 -- 8 Gyr, probably due to the large amount of merging seen in g2 during that epoch. The emission-weighted temperature in g2-SF is also systematically higher than the mass-weighted temperature for most of the simulation, but by a smaller degree since most of the dense gas is turned into stars. The emission-weighted temperature of the hot gas in these simulated groups is a factor of 2 to 5 lower than the 0.7 -- 1.2 keV temperatures observed for the intragroup medium (IGM) in HCGs (Paper I). The main reason for this difference is likely to be the lack of feedback from the "galaxy-like objects" in the simulation. Star formation in galaxies -- specifically, the resulting supernova blasts -- leads to the expulsion of some of a galaxy's interstellar medium into the surrounding group. This gas, which is both hot and enriched with metals from the supernovae (and earlier star formation activity), will heat the IGM and increase its metallicity. A measure of the importance of star formation and supernovae to the state of the IGM can be found by examining the value of β in spatial models of x-ray emission in HCGs, where the surface brightness is described by a hydrostatic-isothermal model of the form S(r) = S0 1 +(cid:18) r rcore(cid:19)2!−3β+0.5 where rcore and β are the fitted parameters (Cavaliere & Fusco-Femiano 1976). Nominally, β is the ratio of the "galaxy temperature" (i.e., a temperature derived from the velocity dispersion of the group) to the gas temperature, and the observed values of β for HCGs are 0.3 -- 0.6 (Paper I). These values of β imply that the measured gas temperatures in HCGs are 1.5 -- 3 times higher than one would expect without some sort of feedback, consonant with the temperature discrepancy between the simulated groups and actual compact groups. This conclusion assumes an isothermal intragroup medium, but observations show that HCGs do not have large temperature gradients (Paper I). In the simulated groups, the values of β obtained from the density profiles of the hot gas are 0.8 -- 1.0 for the GO run -- 27 -- and 0.5 -- 0.7 for the SF run. Thus, adding star formation does bring the spatial distribution of the hot gas closer to that seen in HCGs, but additional physics (such as feedback) is probably needed to correctly simulate the temperature of the intragroup medium. The volume emission measure is not only the weighting factor for the measured temperature of a hot plasma, but it is an observable quantity as well, since it is the normalization factor for a thermal x-ray spectrum (when divided by 4πD2, where D is the distance to the object being observed). In a beta model, the VEM is used to determine the central electron density n0, which is directly proportional to the total mass in x-ray gas. The VEMs for the Hickson groups analyzed in Paper I are listed in Table 5, along with the range in VEM for g2 and g4 in both runs for the final 0.5 Gyr in lookback time. For the simulated groups, the VEM is calculated at a density contrast of ∼2000, roughly that at which the HCGs were observed. The group g4-SF has a disproportionately large range due to a small merger event near the end of the simulation (see Fig. 4). In general, the VEMs of the simulated groups are comparable to those of the HCGs. The SF run produced significantly lower VEMs than did the GO run due to the transfer of dense gas into stellar particles. Even with this systematic difference, the range of observed VEMs in HCGs is so large that one cannot determine whether the addition of star formation helps to better simulate actual groups. Also, since the volume emission measure is quite sensitive to high density hot gas, the assumption of primordial metallicity in the simulations may lead to an overestimate of the amount of such gas in HCGs. Line radiation from ionized C and Fe cools high-density hot gas very efficiently, so even a small increase in the metallicity of the intragroup medium would greatly reduce its VEM. As was stated in the Introduction, Ostriker et al. (1995 -- hereafter OLH) suggest that the Q parameter is a constant for physically compact galaxy groupings, and thus the low Table 5. VEM for observed and simulated groups Group log (VEM/1065 cm−3) Group log (VEM/1065 cm−3) HCG 12 HCG 62 HCG 68 HCG 97 −0.24 +0.54 −1.03 +0.08 g2-GO g4-GO g2-SF g4-SF +0.61 ± 0.08 +0.08 ± 0.10 −0.20 ± 0.08 −0.48 ± 0.46 -- 28 -- values they calculate for HCGs (two to four orders of magnitude below the cluster values of Q) imply that these groups are not physically compact, unless groups are gas-poor relative to clusters. If a group is elongated (i.e., has a large axial ratio), then the assumption of spherical symmetry used in the standard calculation of the gas mass will lead to an underestimate of the true gas mass of the group. The Q parameter is an effective way of determining whether such an underestimate is occurring. However, as OLH point out, Q depends not only on a group's axial ratio, but also on the square of the fraction of mass in hot gas. As was shown in David et al. (1995), Paper I, and Mulchaey et al. (1996), the fraction of the total gravitating mass in a system that is in hot gas increases by at least an order of magnitude as one moves from early-type galaxies to rich clusters, with HCGs being closest to early-type galaxies. This effect is partially due to the x-ray emission being detected at greater radii (smaller density contrasts) in clusters than in poorer systems, and partially to a real deficit of gas in groups as compared to clusters, possibly a result of more efficient galaxy formation. Our simulations show that groups are poorer in gas than are clusters, even when the groups are gravitationally bound and physically compact. A decrease of an order of magnitude in the hot gas mass fraction thus leads to a hundred-fold decrease in Q (the difference between clusters and elliptical-rich HCGs) without requiring that the groups be less physically compact. Dell'Antonio, Geller, & Fabricant (1995) have also discussed this particular difficulty with applying Q to groups and poor clusters. 4. Concluding Discussion The fundamental result of this study is that compact-appearing groups in a simulation of a cold-dark-matter -- dominated universe are similar in many ways to actual compact groups. The simulated groups that we analyzed have lower gas-to-galaxy mass ratios than do simulated clusters, and their total and component masses are fairly similar to those measured for HCGs. In addition, the x-ray properties of the simulated groups are in many cases similar to those of x-ray -- bright HCGs, even when the simulated groups are not physically compact. An important difference between these groups and HCGs is that the simulated groups are chosen by examining the dark matter distribution at a modest density contrast, then examining the galaxies within them. Much larger simulations will be required before realistic selection (including isolation criteria) from "optical" catalogues will be available. While the gross similarities between the simulated groups and the x-ray -- luminous HCGs discussed in Paper I are striking, there are also some important differences. While this simulation does produce gas-to-galaxy mass ratios nearly an order of magnitude smaller -- 29 -- than those of clusters (both simulated and actual), the ratios are not as low as some observed in HCGs. Also, the emission-weighted temperatures for the hot baryons in the simulation are a factor of 2 -- 5 less than the 0.9 keV temperatures measured in Hickson groups. Both these discrepancies may be due to the lack of galactic winds and metallicity enhancement in the simulation, as well as systematic effects that arise in x-ray data reduction such as the choice of gas metallicity and background level (Paper I, Mulchaey et al. 1996). While incorporating star formation into the simulation did make some observable properties of the simulated groups (such as the spatial structure of the x-ray -- luminous gas) more similar to those of HCGs, it increased the differences in other areas (e.g., the temperature of the intragroup medium). However, in most respects, HCGs fall somewhere in between the extremes of the GO and SF runs. The addition of the effects of of energy feedback into the intragroup medium is likely to reduce the remaining discrepancies considerably. If g2 and g4 can be considered typical x-ray -- bright compact groups, then perhaps the best description of how compact groups evolve is a combination of the bound group simulations of Barnes (1989) and the filamentary "false groups" of Hernquist et al. (1995). Until the final 2 Gyr of the simulation (when the groups become physically compact), the galaxy-like objects in each group are found mainly along a single filament. For a viewing angle down that filament, the "galaxies" would appear to be close together and to have concordant redshifts due to their infall to the intersection with a poorer filament, but actually be physically far apart along the filament. At a lookback time of roughly 2 Gyr, the galaxies become physically close, and the group becomes truly compact and somewhat richer as additional galaxies infall from the poorer filament. At this point, the evolution should proceed as in the simulations of Barnes (1989) and others (e.g., Governato et al. 1991, Bode et al. 1993). Our results provide no clear method to discriminate between projected and physical groups. The x-ray temperatures of the groups rise to a constant value very early in their evolution, due to shock heating of gas as it falls into galactic potential wells and filaments (Katz et al. 1992). The behavior of the various baryonic mass components does not appear to be affected by the formation of a physically compact group, either. The rise in the x-ray temperature in the final few Gyr of the simulation is the principal indication of the formation of a physically compact group, but this simulation finds gas temperatures considerably lower than those of HCGs (likely due to the absence of heating from galactic winds), making it difficult to determine what magnitude of a temperature increase should be searched for. As discussed above, the Q parameter of OLH is not appropriate for gas-poor objects such as compact groups. While it may be difficult to determine whether an individual group is physically -- 30 -- compact, this simulation indicates that, on the whole, many HCGs are likely to be true groups rather than simply projections. Although the groups in this simulation spend more time as filaments than as physically compact groups, filaments would be identified as groups only from a small percentage of viewing angles (<20%). Since the groups are compact for over 30% of their (x-ray -- luminous) lifetimes, a significant proportion of x-ray -- bright HCGs are probably physically compact groups. A good criterion for distinguishing true groups from projected ones might be found from a greater ensemble of simulated groups. Not only would trends seen with the groups analyzed here become more clear, but examining the evolution of more groups chosen at z > 0 would illustrate the probable future state of HCGs. Perhaps the final merger products would have some distinctive property that would permit a search for such objects. The addition of supernova-driven galactic winds to the simulations would bring them closer to reflecting reality, and perhaps provide some indication of how one can distinguish projected groups from bound ones. Such simulations would also predict the metallicity of the hot gas in compact groups, a measurement of which will be able to be made with the next generation of x-ray telescopes. -- 31 -- REFERENCES Arnaud, M., Rothenflug, R., Boulade, O. Vigroux, L., & Vangioni-Flam, E. 1992, A&A, 254, 49 Barnes, J. E. 1989, Nature, 338, 123 Bode, P. W., Cohn, H. N., & Lugger, P. M. 1993, ApJ, 416, 17 Cavaliere, A. & Fusco-Femiano, R. 1976, A&A, 49, 137 David, L. P., Arnaud, K. A., Forman, W., & Jones, C. 1990, ApJ, 356, 32 David, L. P., Jones, C., & Forman, W. 1995, ApJ, 445, 578 Dell'Antonio, I.P., Geller, M.J., & Fabricant, D.G. 1995, AJ, 110, 502 Efstathiou, G. & Eastwood, J. W. 1981, MNRAS, 194, 503 Evrard, A. E., Summers, F. J., & Davis, M. 1994, ApJ, 422, 11 (ESD) Governato, F., Bhatia, R., & Chincarini, G. 1991, ApJ, 371, L15 Hernquist, L., Katz, N., & Weinberg, D. H. 1995, ApJ, 442, 57 Hickson, P. 1982, ApJ, 255, 382 Hickson, P., Mendes de Oliveira, C., Huchra, J. P., & Palumbo, G. G. C. 1992, ApJ, 399, 353 Katz, N. S., Hernquist, L., & Weinberg, D. H. 1992, ApJ, 399, L109 Mamon, G. A. 1987, ApJ, 321, 622 Mendes de Oliveira, C. & Hickson, P. 1991, ApJ, 380, 30 Metzler, C. A. & Evrard, A. E. 1996, in preparation Mulchaey, J.S., Davis, D.S., Mushotzky, R.F., & Burstein, D. 1996, ApJ, 456, 80 Ostriker, J. P., Lubin, L. M., & Hernquist, L. 1995, ApJ, 444, L61 (OLH) Pearce, F. R., Thomas, P. A., & Couchman, H. M. P. 1994, MNRAS, 268, 953 Pildis, R. A., Bregman, J. N., & Evrard, A. E. 1995, ApJ, 443, 514 (Paper I) Pildis, R. A., Bregman, J. N., & Schombert, J. M. 1995, AJ, 110, 1498 (Paper II) -- 32 -- Saracco, P. & Ciliegi, P. 1995, A&A, 301, 348 White, R. E. 1991, ApJ, 367, 69 White, S. D. M., Navarro, J. F., Evrard, A. E., & Frenk, C. S. 1993, Nature, 366, 429 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0.
0810.1141	1	0810	2008-10-07T09:36:20	Multiwavelength spectral and high time resolution observations of SWIFT J1753.5-0127: new activity?	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have conducted an extensive observational campaign of SWIFT J1753.5-0127 during June 2007 after its bright outburst episode in 2005. We have performed multi-band optical photometry, optical spectroscopy, X-ray spectroscopy and timing and ULTRACAM optical photometry simultaneously in three bands. Both the optical spectrum and the X-ray spectrum, along with enhanced brightness in broad-band photometry point to recent increased activity. We analyze the different spectral regions, finding a smooth optical continuum with a remarkable lack of lines and a very blue component modulated with a period of 3.2hr and a hard power-law X-ray spectrum. Both the X-ray and optical power spectra are flat at low frequencies up to the 0.1 Hz (10 s) range, then decreasing roughly as a power law consistent with flickering. Furthermore, the optical data show quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) near 0.08 Hz (13 s). Together with a dynamical and auto-correlation analysis of the light curves we attempt to construct a complete physical picture of this intriguing system.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 20 (2008) Printed 11 June 2018 (MN LATEX style file v2.2) Multiwavelength spectral and high time resolution observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127: new activity? M. Durant1⋆, P. Gandhi2, T. Shahbaz1, H. H. Peralta1 and V. S. Dhillon3 1 Instituto de Astrof´ısica de Canarias, La Laguna, E38205 Tenerife, Spain 2 RIKEN Institute of Physical and Chemical Research, 2-1 Hirosawa, Wakoshi, Saitama, Japan 3 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield S3 7RH, UK ABSTRACT We have conducted an extensive observational campaign of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 dur- ing June 2007 after its bright outburst episode in 2005. We have performed multi-band optical photometry, optical spectroscopy, X-ray spectroscopy and timing and ULTRA- CAM optical photometry simultaneously in three bands. Both the optical spectrum and the X-ray spectrum, along with enhanced brightness in broad-band photometry point to recent increased activity. We analyze the different spectral regions, finding a smooth optical continuum with a remarkable lack of lines and a very blue component modulated with a period of 3.2 hr and a hard power-law X-ray spectrum. Both the X- ray and optical power spectra are flat at low frequencies up to the 0.1 Hz (10 s) range, then decreasing roughly as a power law consistent with flickering. Furthermore, the optical data show quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) near 0.08 Hz (13 s). Together with a dynamical and auto-correlation analysis of the light curves we attempt to construct a complete physical picture of this intriguing system. Key words: X-rays: binaries, binaries: individual (SWIFT J1753.5-0127), timing analysis. 1 INTRODUCTION Soft X-ray Transients (SXRTs) are a subset of the low mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) which are thought to con- tain a black hole primary, and undergo periodic brightening episodes lasting a few months, with recurrence times of a few years (Tanaka & Shibazaki, 1996). The outburst episodes typically coincide with spectral and timing changes, for ex- ample the X-ray high/soft state (thermal emission when ac- cretion is high) and the X-ray low/hard state (coronal/jet or optically thin disc emission when accretion is low; review in Remillard & McClintock, 2006). Such changes are attributed to varying contributions from the various emission mecha- nisms e.g., dense disc, jet, low density zone (e.g., van der Klis, 2006). It turns out, however, that such a classification may be simplistic, as some systems have been seen to go into outbursts without changing their X-ray state. It is a chal- lenge to understand, in these cases, what indeed is changing (e.g., Meyer-Hofmeister, 2004). Two main models exist as possible explanations for the low/hard state in accreting binaries. The first and oldest is the Advection-Dominated Accretion Flow (ADAF, e.g., Cz- erny et al. 2000) model, in which the accretion disc is trun- cated at a large inner radius, and the relatively inefficient ⋆ E-mail: [email protected] ADAF channels matter to the compact object and to any jets; this region is low-density and responsible for the high- energy emission. In a typical outburst cycle, the accretion disc gains enough mass to overwhelm the ADAF, and fast accretion progresses until the disc is depleted, whereupon the ADAF reforms from small radii to large. The contender model, the Accretion Disc Corona (ADC; e.g., Malzac, 2007) is not dissimilar in its effects, but the mechanism is subtly different. A hot corona of energetic particles may form above and below an accretion disc, and most of the accretion power is carried by strong magnetic fields. When the fields in the corona are strong, the emission from the corona is strong, and a higher proportion of in-falling material is channelled into the jets. When the mass-flow rate increases beyond a critical level, however, enough soft X-ray photons are emit- tied by the disc to efficiently cool the corona, causing it to condense onto the disc, halting the chanelling of energy and particles away from the core region, which then dom- inates the emitted spectrum with thermal radiation from small radii. Note that this model was developed initially fpr sources where the central accretion disc is obscured by the outer torus of material, making the ADC relatively more important. In general, it may be assumed that both processes, with their different physical mechanisms, occur in systems either simultaneously or episodically. The most obvious difference 2 Durant et al. between the two is that for the ADC, the accretion disc extends down to very small radii, to the last stable orbit in the case of a black-hole system. The transitions between accretion modes and feedback in the systems is very poorly understood, however. It seems not to be purely a function of accretion rate, and there certainly appears to be hysteresis in all the transient systems, as typically depicted by their path through the X-ray hardness-luminosity diagram (Homan & Belloni, 2005). One object which has received a lot of attention in re- cent times, being an out-lier in the SXRT population, is XTE J1118+480 (Chaty et al. 2003). This system was thor- oughly observed through outburst to quiescence in X-rays, UV, optical and radio (Hynes at al. 2003), and showed inter- esting breaks and possible QPOs in its periodograms (Shah- baz et al. 2005). Being high above the Galactic plane, it has been suggested that XTE J1118+480 belongs to a new population of black hole binaries, with the question of how they can appear in the halo still open (McClintock et al. 2001). XTE J1118+480 is one of the few systems which does not follow the typical path for an SXRT through X-ray hardness/luminosity space: it stayed in the low/hard state throughout. It is also the only system for which a high signal- to.noise optical/X-ray cross-correlation has been calculated, which showed an unexpected "precursor" anti-correlation with optical leading X-rays (and a stronger positive resonse; Kanbach et al. 2001). The SXRT SWIFT J1753.5−0127 is an X-ray transient system which has been of great interest recently following its outburst episode and detailed observations with the SWIFT satellite. First discovered by the SWIFT/BAT (Burst Alert Telescope; Palmer et al., 2005) in 2005, pointed γ-ray, X-ray, UV, optical and radio observations all detected a new bright source at this location (Morris et al., 2005; Still et al., 2005; Halpern et al., 2005; Fender et al., 2005). Swift/XRT (X-ray Telescope; Burrows et al. 2005), and RXTE (Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer; Jahoda et al. 1996) observations detected the existence of a strong 0.6 Hz quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO; Morgan et al. 2005; Ramadevi & Seetha, 2005), per- sistent for some time after the outburst episode. This QPO has so far only been seen in X-ray observations. Zhang et al. (2007) presented the evolution of the QPO frequency with time after the outburst, and its relationship to X-ray hard- ness. With a high Galactic latitude, comparisons with XTE J1118+480 promise to be very interesting. Summarizing the above works very briefly, after a fast initial rise in X-ray flux, the source returned to its previous level, almost undetectable by the RXTE All-sky Monitor, in a few months (rise time of 4.5 days, decay of an exponential time-scale initially ∼32 d, later ∼100 d, peak flux ∼0.2 crab in the RXTE/PCA or SWIFT/XRT band). Throughout, it remained hard in X- and γ-rays (a rising spectrum in νfν out to ∼200 keV), suggesting a hot Comptonizing corona (ADC). The optical counterpart also faded, but the fade slowed, and it remains relatively bright and blue. Hα and He lines were originally observed, double-peaked, but dis- appeared after the initial outburst (Torres, 2005). The ac- cretion disc inclination is thus non-negligible, but neither is it extreme (> 80◦), since eclipses are never observed. The Hα line was not particularly strong (equivalent width ∼ 3 A) but very broad (FWHM∼2000 km s−1). From the NaI doublet and UV observations, the extinction equiva- lent to NH ∼ 2 × 1021 cm−2 and a distance of ∼ 6 kpc have been estimated. The radio spectrum was variable and con- sistent with a flat power law (fν ∼ ν 0) which lies underneath the optical points, if extrapolated (Fender et al. 2005). This suggests that, initially at least, the optical emission did not appear like a typical synchrotron spectrum. Cadolle Bel et al. (2007; CB07 from hereon) performed follow-up simultaneous multi-wavelength observations. They identify SWIFT J1753.5−0127 as a likely Black-Hole Can- didate, which stayed in a low/hard state throughout its outburst and gradual fade. They also detected a QPO in their X-ray data, but weaker, and at the somewhat lower frequency of 0.24 Hz. Such a reduction in the frequency is consistent with what would be expected for the inner ra- dius of an accretion disc, which expands during the decay- ing lifetime of the outburst in the ADAF model. The INTE- GRAL count-rate during their observation was constant at 43 cts s−1 (∼ 205 mCrab between 20 -- 320 keV), with a hard- ness ratio HR = f20−40 keV/f40−80 keV ∼ 0.75. They also found a flat radio spectrum with fluxes of the order 0.65 mJy. Miller et al. (2006a) observed SWIFT J1753.5−0127 some months after the outburst episode above with XMM- Newton and RXTE, when the source was assumed to have reached quiescence. Their spectral modelling indicated a prominent accretion disc was required by the X-ray spec- trum with high significance. This disc is cool (kT = 0.2 keV), and extends to very small radii near the last inner stable or- bit. This model would pose problems for models of low-level accretion involving an ADAF region near the central source, and complicate jet-formation scenarios. An ADAF model is commonly invoked to explain the existence of a jet in the low/hard state and its absence in the high/soft state, in systems where both states have been observed (e.g., Fender, 2006). We have conducted a comprehensive observational cam- paign of SWIFT J1753.5−0127, including optical photomety in different filters on five successive nights, with ∼ 1 min time resolution, contemporary X-ray observations, optical spectroscopy and high time-resolution optical observations with ULTRACAM. Here we present the results of this cam- paign, particularly timing analyses of the data-sets and com- parisons between them. In the companion paper, Durant et al. (2008) analyze the cross-correlation of the X-ray and optical light curves from the simultaneous high-speed ob- servations, finding suprisingly that the optical precedes the X-rays with a broad anticorrelation peak, followed by a weak positive response for the optical lagging the X-rays. The only contemporaneous radio observation of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 we are aware of were taken by Soleri et al. (2008), who did not detect the source with the Westerbrook Synthesis Radio Telescope in July 2007, establishing a 3σ limiting flux of 1.1 mJy at 5 GHz and 8 Ghz. Zurita et al. (2008) also observed this system in the optical band, but over a much longer time base-line (several months) and they discuss the long-term optical brightness trend and newly dis- covered ∼ 3.2 hr superhump/orbital period. In the following section we describe the various observa- tions and processing. In Section 3, we give the results of this, and further analysis comparing the different data, including timing and spectral analyses. In Section 4, we discuss the re- sults and attempt to draw physical conclusions from them. SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 3 2 OBSERVATIONS Table 1 lists all the observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 that are analyzed here. Of the observations listed there, only the WHT/ISIS spectrum was not obtained during the same week of 2007 (it is from one year earlier), whereas the radio limits of Soleri et al. (2008) were approximately contempo- rary with our observations. Further to our own observations below, we retrieved the Rossi All Sky Monitor (AMS; Levine et al., 1996) daily average count rates for SWIFT J1753.5−0127, as well as regular monitoring observations by the gamma-ray satellite INTEGRAL's wide-field lower energy-band imaging instru- ment ISGRI (Integral Soft Gamma-ray Instrument; Lebrun et al. 2003). These are shown in Figure 1. The ASM ob- serves the whole sky, and INTEGRAL surveys the Galactic Centre regularly, and all interesting bright objects are auto- matically measured. These data are publicly available (the reduction is not described here, see the references above). 2.1 X-ray SWIFT J1753.5−0127 was observed for 53.6 min each on 11 Jun 2007 and 13 Jun 2007 with the Rossi X-ray Tim- ing Explorer (RXTE). RXTE comprises three instruments: the Proportional Counting Array (PCA; Jahoda et al. 1996) for soft-band pointed observations with large effective area, the High-Energy X-ray Timing Experiment (HEXTE; Roth- schild et al. 1998) for energies up to 200 keV and the All-Sky Monitor (ASM, see above), with a very large effective field of view. None are imaging instruments, but provide high temporal resolution. For the first observation, only two of the PCA units were functional, and in the second observa- tion, three. We use only the PCA light curves in our timing analysis, since the count rates are so much higher than the high-energy HEXTE count rates. The latter we only use in the spectral fitting. Events were processed through the standard pipeline for both the PCA and HEXTE data-sets. Standard Good Time Intervals were applied and we selected all events flagged as good for further analysis. We generated light curves by bin- ning the events on a regular grid; uncertainties on each sam- ple are dominated by photon counting noise. When a fluxed spectrum is generated from the data, using the instrument response functions, the HEXTE and PCA parts of the spectrum do not appear to meet: there seems to be a 15% discrepancy, which corresponds to the effect of dead time. We corrected for this and performed our spectral analysis on these data. 2.2 Optical Photometry We observed SWIFT J1753.5−0127 with the 2.2 m Nordic Optical Telescope (NOT; 2007 Jun 16, 17) and the 1.5 m Mercator (2007 Jun 18, 19, 20) telescopes at Roque de los Muchachos Observatory, La Palma, Spain. In each case, we performed CCD-based imaging with exposure times of 60 s. With the NOT we acquired images in the U and B filters, and with the Mercator in the BV R filters. Standards were imaged with the NOT in the U and B filters, and the Mer- cator photometry was calibrated via images of both the sci- ence field and standards fields with the IAC80 telescope at the Teide Observatory, Tenerife. The weather was generally good, especially for the NOT run, with some variability and thin cloud during the Mercator run. Images were in every case first bias-subtracted, then flat-fielded using drift images of the twilight sky. Note that the NOT/Alfosc images were affected by unrepeatable elec- tronic pick-up, and that the photometry was therefore some- what degraded. Photometry was measured in small aper- tures relative to a bright local reference in the field. For this, we used the ULTRACAM pipeline, as below with the ULTRACAM data. The local reference was in each case calibrated relative to the Landolt standard list (Landolt, 1992), correcting for a colour term for each filter set. Hav- ing other stars in the field of similar brightness to SWIFT J1753.5−0127 enabled us to check that the analysis pro- cess was not introducing any systematic signal into the light curves. The uncertainty on each measurement is estimated from the photon statistics of the counts within an aperture and the sky background. Our measurements are source pho- ton noise dominated. 2.3 Optical Spectroscopy We obtained spectra across the optical range with the In- termediate dispersion Spectrograph and Imaging System (ISIS1) on the 4.2 m William Herschel Telescope (WHT) at the Observatorio Roque de los Muchachos, La Palma, Spain. ISIS features twin spectrographs optimized for the red and blue end of the optical, which can be used simul- taneously with the use of a dichroic in the main beam. We obtained 1.72 A/pixel mean dispersion in the blue arm, and 1.65 A/pixel in the red, with a mean resolution ∼ 3 A throughout, under good conditions. The two spectra were wavelength calibrated and extracted using standard iraf tools, and co-added into master spectra. In order not to lose any resolution when co-adding, each spectrum was first re- sampled to 0.5 A. To flux and produce the final spectrum, we observed a spectral standard at a similar airmass, and for both the ob- ject and the standard spectrum, summed together the red and blue parts into a single master spectrum (sampled at 0.5 A). Since the dicroic provides a sharp but finite cut-off, calculating the response function for any one arm in the cut- off region is hard, but yet there are enough photons in total at any given wavelength to find the overall sensitivity. The final response curve we used to flux the data was a heavily smoothed version of the ratio of the tabulated flux to the measured counts for the standard. These observations were done one year after the outburst of SWIFT J1753.5−0127, during the faintest part of the ASM light curve since detec- tion (Figure 1). We also obtained a spectrum of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 during our June observing campaign with the Focal Reducer and low dispersion Spectrograph (FORS2, Appenzeller et al. 1998) on the 8.2 m Unit Telescope 1 (Antu) of the VLT, Cerro Paranal, Chile. This observation was simultaneous with one RXTE and one ULTRACAM observation. The 1 http://www.ing.iac.es/Astronomy/observing/manuals/ html manuals/wht instr/isis hyper/isis hyper.html 4 Durant et al. spectral scale was 3.17 A/pixel, and resolution ∼ 7 A. Condi- tions were mediocre, with variable cloud cover, transparency and seeing. Since the whole spectral range is obtained in a single go, the problems associated with matching two spec- tra (above) were not encountered here, and the extraction was straight-forward. 2.4 ULTRACAM In addition, SWIFT J1753.5−0127 was also observed with ULTRACAM, mounted on the VLT/3 (Melipal) telescope on the nights of 2007 Jun 12 and 17, for 1.3 hr and 0.5 hr respectively. ULTRACAM is an instrument employing dichroic beam splitters, frame-transfer CCDs and a GPS- based timing system in order to be able to make simultane- ous multi-wavelength optical light curves at very high time resolution, up to 500 Hz (Dhillon et al. 2007). We used two small windows on each CCD (one for the source of interest, one for a local standard), with exposure times of 140 ms for the 12th and 39 ms for the 17th (and duty cycles of 142 ms and 41 ms respectively). The reason for the difference in ex- posure times was thin cloud on the first of the two nights, giving similar signal-to-noise per image. The object was visible in every frame in the r′ and g′ bands, but not in the u′ band. For the latter, therefore, the source could only be detected by co-adding many images, resulting in reduced temporal resolution but better signal- to-noise. On the first night, with the poor conditions, the effect was particularly strong, and we do not attempt to analyze these data. On the 17th, however, it was possible to get reasonable measurements from averages of every 50 images. Thus it was not possible to search for high-frequency variability in these data, but timescales >4 s were accessible. Fluxes were extracted by aperture photometry with a variable aperture size scaled to the FWHM of the refer- ence star on each image. This enables some optimization for signal-to-noise under variable conditions. The optimal extraction method (Naylor, 1992) did not yield appreciably different results, since that method is more applicable to the faint, background-dominated regime. The night of the 2007 June 12 was badly affected by transparency variations. In addition, the comparison star chosen was of similar brightness to our source in r′ and sig- nificantly redder, introducing additional uncertainty in r′ and even more in g′. This is evidenced by the difference in the r′-band and g′-band light curves. Only for the 17th can we give reliable average magnitudes, based on the calibrated zero-points of the instrument. These are on the SDSS pho- tometric system (systematic uncertainties here are ±0.03 -- 0.05 mag, increasing to the blue). By the transformations given in Jester et al. (2005), the SDSS average magnitudes correspond to V=16.62(5), B=16.92(7), consistent with the slow photometry above. The slow photometry has a better absolute calibration. 3 ANALYSIS AND RESULTS 3.1 Long-term trend Figure 1 shows the long-term luminosity trend of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 as seen in the X-ray and gamma-ray bands. It appears that, after the initial outburst and fade, the source has been steadily increasing in flux to a peak at the time of our observation, of the order of the flux in the tail of the initial outburst. Note that on the left-hand extreme of Figure 1, one can see the zero level for the default extraction for this source. The ASM count rate at the time of the June 2007 observations is clearly higher than this, near 2 cts s−1. This corresponds to a flux of order F ∼ 1×10−9 erg s−1cm−2 in the 1 -- 10 keV range (estimated using WebPIMMS). Note further, that the INTEGRAL rate ratios in the observa- tions available were similar in each epoch, and the light curve follows that of the ASM, indicating that the high- energy portion of the emission changed little in spectral slope/hardness. Unfortunately, observations closer in time to our campaign are not yet publicly available. In the optical, as detailed in Zurita et al. (2008), the counterpart also settled to a steady optical magnitude, which has periodic and aperiodic variability superposed. 3.2 Orbital Modulation The light curves from our photometric observations with the NOT and Mercator telescopes are shown in Figure 2. In each night and each band (U BV R), the ∼ 3.2 hr modulation reported in the R band by Zurita et al. (2008) is clearly apparent, confirming their result. We are unable, however, to aproach the accuracy of their period determina- tion from our four nights' data. Furthermore, simultaneous light curves in each filter show remarkably similar shapes. (Note that the observations here were not strictly simul- taneous: they were made through each filter in turn) This variabilty has a shape typical of superhump modulations (the conclusion reached by Zurita et al), but we cannot ex- clude eclipsing (of the disc) or emission from the irradiated side of the donor star from these data alone. Clearly, the colours vary very little through the modulation period. The overall brightness does vary during each night and from one night to the next. Table 2 lists the mean magnitudes and colours from each of the five nights. The variability within each night is smooth and at the ∼ 10% level. Interestingly, our average magnitudes do not match those of Zurita et al (2008), which were determined on 2007 June 7, not far in time from our own observations. We find that the object is typically brighter by ∼ 0.1 mag in each of the bands BV R in our data. 3.2.1 Pulsed Fraction The light curves presented also give information about the amount of flux involved in the 3.2 hr modulation. This can be measured directly from the graphs from the peak-to- peak amplitude. In Figure 3 we plot both the total flux (as an average across the observations) and modulated flux in the optical region. Here the uncertainties in the pulsed flux come from the scatter in points on the light curves rather than variability between nights - a caveat for comparing the points. Although there is night-to-night variability, it is clear that the pulsed flux increases with energy, whereas the total flux is flat or turns over. It appears that the pulsing com- ponent is hotter than the DC component (or fast-varying component); specifically, a linear function fitted to the log- log points in Figure 3 yields slopes of -0.1(2) and 0.7(2) for SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 5 Figure 1. (upper) RXTE/ASM long-term light curve SWIFT J1753.5−0127. The vertical dotted lines show the times of the observations by CB07, Miller et al. (2006) and our RXTE pointed observations in this work, from left to right. (lower) INTEGRAL monitoring average count-rates on the same time-scale. Open circles are counts in the 22 -- 40 keV range, crosses in the 40 -- 80 keV range (left scale), and triangles with errors are average count ratios (22 -- 40/40 -- 80, right scale). 6 Durant et al. Table 1. Observation log of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 [h!] Date (UT) Type Instrument Filter(s) Duration (min) 2006-06-17 2007-06-11 2007-06-13 2007-06-13 2007-06-13 2007-06-16 2007-06-17 2007-06-17 2007-06-18 2007-06-19 2007-06-20 Spectrum X-ray WHT/ISIS red, blue RXTE Photometry ULTRACAM u′g′r′ RXTE X-ray Spectrum VLT1/FORS2 NOT/Alfosc NOT/Alfosc ULTRACAM Photometry Photometry Photometry Photometry Mercator/Merope Photometry Mercator/Merope Photometry Mercator/Merope U B U u′g′r′ BV BV R BV R 160 54 78 54 3 434 420 30 411 290 432 Table 2. Slow photometry of SWIFT J1753.5−0127. Date (start) < U > < B > < V > < R > 2007-06-16 2007-06-17 2007-06-18 2007-06-19 2007-06-20 16.43(15) 16.51(19) 17.05(9) 16.89(15) 16.89(12) 16.94(13) 16.49(14) 16.49(10) 16.55(11) 16.29(8) 16.34(11) All magnitudes are in the Johnson-Cousins system. Numbers in parentheses indicate the spread in values. the total and modulated components respectively. We can speculate that modulated emission would dominate in the near-UV. Note that these points have not been de-reddened in order not to add additional uncertainty to the plot. De- reddening the pulsed flux points by AV ∼ 1 would yield a spectrum which is roughly consistent with a Wien slope. The dependence of the pulsed fraction on wavelength rules out that this component originates from X-ray reprocessing. 3.3 Spectrum 3.3.1 X-ray The spectrum was extracted from the valid photon events, and the nominal background subtracted. We fit the re- sulting spectrum (using Xspec) in the range 2 -- 50 keV (in- cluding both PCA and HEXTE observations) to an ab- sorbed power law, and find a statistically satisfactory fit with Γ = 1.548 ± 0.005 (Nγ ∝ E−Γ) and normalization A = 0.1057 ± 0.0011 ph keV−1cm−2s−1 -- see Figure 4. A thermal disc component at low energies and a Gaussian fea- ture at an energy E ∼ 6.2 keV are consistent with the data and modestly improve the χ2 statistic of the fit, each with a significance of ∼ 2σ, after taking into account the un- certainty on the column density for the former. The broad line might be consistent with a Fe Kα line with a rest-frame energy of E ≈ 6.4 keV. Specifically, using the hydrogen column found by CB07, we fitted the X-ray spectrum with a model consisting of a power-law continuum as above, summed with a disc ther- mal model (diskbb in Xspec) and Gaussian emission feature. The best-fit parameters we find are as follows: disc tempera- ture kT = 0.19 ± 0.03 keV, normalization2 N = 4.8(6) × 104, emission peak energy E = 6.15 ± 0.17 keV, normalization A = 2.63 ± 1.3 × 10−4 ph cm−2s−1. The plotted points and fitting included only photon-counting uncertainties and as- sume that the pipeline deals correctly with the calibration. It should be noted, that the RXTE/PCA calibration for the low energies of these putative detections is somewhat uncer- tain, and further complicated by non-negligible background contamination, which increases rapidly to lower energies (Ja- hoda et al. 2006). The fit values and implied significance of the components should therefore be read cautiously, partic- ularly for the thermal component. We did, however, include the most recent calibrations available, which fixed previously unknown problems with the background estimation, such as correctly recording the time since last passage through the South-Atlantic Anomaly 3. We regard the detection of a disc component and of a broad emission feature as suggestive, however the line would fit with a gravitationally red-shifted, velocity-broadened Iron K line, as has been seen for some other black hole ac- creting systems (Miller, 2007). For the neutral Iron K line at ≈ 6.4 keV, the gravitational red-shift would correspond to 3.6 Schwarzschild radii. Ramadevi & Seetha (2007) had found strong evidence for a very soft thermal component in the X-ray spectrum of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 during the brighter emission near the (D/10 kpc)i2 2 defined in Xspec as h (Rin/km) inner radius, from Kubota et al. (1998) 3 see pca/doc/bkg/bkg-2007-saa/ http://www.universe.nasa.gov/xrays/programs/rxte/ where Rin is an effective SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 7 NOT Mercator Figure 2. Optical light curves of SWIFT J1753.5−0127. The upper panels are from the NOT, the lower from the Mercator telescope. The five panels are subsequent nights 16 -- 20 Jun 2007 (left to right, top to bottom). Vertical lines are estimates of the statistical error on each point (but horizontal bars purely mark the point centre). outburst of 2005. The temperature of this component was kT ≈ 0.4 keV, whereas Miller et al. (2006a) report a much cooler thermal component of 0.2 keV at a later time, further after the outburst. The latter was based on XMM-Newton EPIC and grating spectra, which are much more sensitive at low energies than RXTE. Our marginal detection of a ther- mal component is consistent with the later temperature. A comparison of preferred fit parameters by different authors (at different times since the outburst) are shown in Table 3. Note that Ramadevi & Seetha (2007) reported finding 8 Durant et al. Figure 3. Spectral energy distribution of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 in the optical region. The upper points are the mean observed flux in the broad-band filters, with uncertainties derived from the scatter between nights. The lower points are the pulsed flux in the 3.2 hr periodicity, with uncertainties from the error on measuring the pulsed fraction. The points are as measured, uncorrected for reddening. an absorption edge at E ∼ 7 keV. In their analysis, this improved the quality of the fit from χ2 ≈ 5 to 1.3. This may explain the departure from a power law in our spec- trum. The shape around this energy does not look like an absorption edge feature, however. red flux in the The total spectrum is 1.6±0.1×10−9 erg s−1cm−2 in the 2 -- 20 keV range. This is fainter than the flux reported by CB07, which was measured in the tail of the initial outburst, and brighter than the flux reported by Miller et al. (2006), who performed their observations some months after the outburst (the times of the various follow-up observations are indicated in Figure 1, and the fluxes measured match the ASM curve well). 3.3.2 Optical The signal-to-noise ratio throughout the WHT spec- trum (Figure 5) is significantly better than for the later VLT/FORS2 spectrum, the latter of which was taken in the same epoch as the rest of the observations. Some of the fea- tures are apparent in both spectra, however, and the equiva- lent widths for the most significant features is given in Table 4. Uncertainties are derived by measuring the standard de- viation of the flux in the continuum at either side of the line in question. The continuum is assumed to be a straight line, and determined from the data at either side of each spec- tral line. Assuming that the continuum is a straight line and that the standard deviation is a measure of the uncertainty on each point is clearly not the case for such a undulating spectrum (in fact, it is an over-estimate). Additional sys- tematic uncertainty due to this is not included in the errors presented in Table 4. The broad-band photometry measurements in Table 2 are equivalent to average fluxes in their respective band- passes (e.g., the zero points of Bessel, 1995). These fluxes appear to be some 20% above the continuum level of our spectroscopy. Note, however, that the flux scale shown in Figure 5 is affected by slit losses and poor transparency during the observations. This accounts for the apparent dis- crepancy between the typical flux shown here and the broad- band magnitudes in Table 2, which are more reliable. The photometry values show beyond doubt that the spectrum shown has the correct shape (i.e., it is not affected by broad- band mis-calibration of the continuum) and has reddened signifiacntly since the optical spectrum of CB07. The Na-I interstellar absorption appears to be some- what higher than previously measured by CB07. Since this measurement is based on relative fluxes (across the lines, compared to the continuum on either side), and the intru- ment response functions do not change significantly across the width of a narrow line in the centre of the sensativ- ity range, the statistical uncertainties given should be a fair measure of the accuracy of the EW measurements, affected only by the underlying spectrum and not by the instru- ment calibration, resolution etc. Here we refer only to the WHT/ISIS equivalent width, which should be more reliable. This implies a higher reddening to the object and therefore correspondingly higher distance; see below. Since the in- terstellar extinction should not have changed, we infer that the extinction internal to the binary varies. The difference in the equivalent width between the WHT and VLT spectra is ∆EW = 0.4 ± 0.2 We can use the depths of the interstellar lines to es- timate the total extincting column to the source. Following SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 9 Table 3. Summary of X-ray spectral fits and QPO detections by different authors. Parameter Ramadevi & Seetha Miller et al. Cadolle-Bel et al. This work Satellite Tobs 4 Γ kTBB (keV) 3 (km) RBB kTseed τ 4 χ2 NH (cm−2) fQP O (Hz) δfQP O (Hz) %RMS red (2006)2 XMM March 2006 1.66±0.01 0.21±0.02 2 -- 6 0.17±0.1 1.03±0.01 1.15 2.3 ± 0.1 × 1021 (2007)1 RXTE July-November 2005 1.76 ± 0.014 0.38 ± 0.07 100 1.3 2.3 × 1021 0.891±0.008 ∼0.2 ∼23 (2007) RXTE August 2005 0.54±0.06 1.06±0.02 1.17 2 × 1021 0.241±0.006 0.03+0.02 −0.01 5.4±1.8 RXTE July 2007 1.548±0.005 0.19±0.03 170 1.01 2.3 ± 0.2 × 1021 See §3.4.1 Note that each fit is for a different combination of instrument, spectral range and fitted model, and that the hydrogen column is not necessarily variable in the fit. χ2 values are for the best fit in each case. 1: Parameters at the start of the outburst. 2: The power law plus black-body model, and the Comptomized model parameters both given. 4: Comptomized models, seed photon energy and corona optical depth. 3: At 8 kpc. Figure 4. X-ray spectrum of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 from RXTE for the two observations and two instruments: PCA (left) HEXTE (right). The solid line is the best-fit model in Table 3. the calculation in CB07, NH = 0.25×5.8×1021 ×EWNa I = 2.45 ×1021 cm−2. The uncertainty on this from the measure- ment of the equivalent width alone is 0.13 × 1021 cm−2, but one must keep in mind the uncertainty in determining the continuum and of the conversion factors. We estimate that our column density is accurate to 10%. From this we can in principle estimate distance to SWIFT J1753.5−0127 by comparison with field stars of known distance and extinction or H-II clouds. Zurita et al's (2008) distance puts SWIFT J1753.5−0127 well above the Galactic plane, in the halo (z > 1 kpc). Unfortunately, at such a distance there are few field stars, HII regions or other 10 Durant et al. fiducial distance indicators to compare with. The bulk of the stars along the line of sight are foreground Galactic Plane stars, so it is not possible to find the main sequence or red clump at large distance in this direction. The hydrogen col- umn we estimate from absorption lines above, larger than CB07's, is consistent with the total Galactic extinction (Still et al. 2006), so the distance d ∼7 kpc estimated by Zurita et al. from the lower column, is consistent with our analysis. Note that there is no clear way to determine how much of the extinction is internal to the binary system. Hopefully, in a future quiescent state we would be able to determine the donor type spectroscopically, and thus find the distance and extinction independently. Beyond this, all features remain surprisingly weak, with a notable lack of absorption, similar to the results of CB07, who see only a faint hint of H and He absorption. Early in the outburst, there had been significant Hα and He emission, initially double-peaked (Torres et al. 2005), but there is very little evidence of this in our data. For a line of similar width to the interstellar ones seen, we place a 99% upper limit on the equivalent width of EW < 0.28A, whereas Torres et al. found EW (Hα) ∼ 3A (no uncertainty given, except S/N∼30). Finally, the spectrum still appears blue (as seen also from the multi-colour photometry, Section 3.2), but less so than at the peak of the outburst. The shape of the continuum in the VLT/FORS2 spec- trum is qualitatively more similar to the early spectrum in CB07 than to our intermediate spectrum from WHT/ISIS. The blue part of the continuum appears to have recov- ered somewhat, although the red has stayed rather similar throughout. We note that, although much closer to a power- law shape, the undulations or deviation froma straight line by ∼ 5%, apparent in the FORS spectrum are real and not an artefact of the flux calibration (the calibration function was calculated for each wavelength bin and smoothed, rather than attempting to fit with a polynomial or other analytic function, which can easily introduce such undulations). To check the evolution of the continuum shape, we per- formed further optical spectroscopy with the ALFOSC in- trument of the 2.5 m Nordic Optical Telescope (NOT), La Palma, in April 2008. The NOT/ALFOSC spectrum, taken almost a year after our main observation campaign, is also shown in Figure 5. Intriguingly, absorption lines are even less obvious in this spectrum than before, and we do not list them; even the strongest Na-D line seems to have de- creased in strength. Using different telescopes, instruments and resolutions, it is hard to say whether these changes are real. If so, they hint at a fair amount of extincting material within the system, the amount of which evolves with time. The undulations in the continuum (i.e., departure from a power law) are still clearly present, however. Slight undulations or humps are apparent in each of the spectra to a greater or lesser degree. These are on the scale of a few percent in flux and of order ∼500A broad in Figure 5, compared to a power law (straight line in these plots); such features have now appeared in each of the four optical spectra since SWIFT J1753.5−0127's discovery. We must note that H and He emission lines were seen in the initial phases of SWIFT J1753.5−0127's outburst (Torres, 2005), so there is no lack of hydrogen or helium in the system. The existance of broad humps throughout the optical spectral range is suggestive of cyclotron emission, but of- Table 4. Optical spectral lines in SWIFT J1753.5−0127. All equivalent widths are in absorption. DIL stands for diffuse in- terstellar line (of unknown, PAH or metallic origin). Limits are at 95% significance. Element λ (A) Equivalent Width (A) WHT/ISIS VLT/FORS2 Ca Ca DIL DIL DIL DIL Na Ca DIL 3934 3969 4430 4885 5780 5797 5892 6283 6614 0.38±0.02 0.43±0.02 0.66±0.03 1.00±0.06 1.09±0.05 0.222±0.007 1.69±0.09 0.77±0.05 1.20±0.11 ¡0.3 ¡0.3 0.86±0.10 1.15±0.11 ¡0.6 ¡0.5 2.1±0.2 0.91±0.05 ¡0.5 fers little clear evidence; in theory they could be extremely broadened lines or combinations of lines. The lack of sharp lines argues strongly that the optical emission is not thermal emission from a dense disc over-layed by less dense material, as this would result in absorption and/or emission lines, de- pending on the dominant temperature. A pure black-body or multi-colour dics would have smooth power laws either side of a single peak. Likewise, synchrotron may well exist in the spectrum, but is generally thought to have a Fν ∝ ν 0 flat spectrum. Charateristic strong cyclotrons humps are not seen, but this is not a similar situation to the more obvious cyclotron emission in the case of Schwope et al. (2003): that is for a polar system, where the emission region has a well- defined magnetic field strength. In our case there could be combined emission from various active patches with various field strengths throughout the disc, not necessarily resulting in a series of clear, well-defined humps. Thus although there is no clear evidence for cyclotron emission, the spectra do not look like what might be ex- pected from other typical emission mechanisms, so cyclotron may be a successful description. 3.3.3 SED In Figure 6 we show the spectral energy distribution of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 in our observations, compared to the comprehensive multi-wavelength campaign of CB07 over a year earlier. We have included limits in the radio from So- leri et al (2008, taken two weeks after our observations), and de-reddened the optical with AV = 1.05, the value used by CB07 (so that the comparison is fair). We find the overall luminosity has dropped by a factor ∼3, but that the X-ray spectrum has qualitatively the same shape as before (a hard power law). The optical is different: there appears to be a smooth break around the blue such that the V-band flux is significantly fainter, but R and I are consistent, and the slope is redder. One thing is clear: the X-rays and optical require separate emission components, and if the radio is at similar levels to before or lower by a similar factor as the X-rays, then it too requires a separate emission component: synchrotron emission from a jet can- not be dominant in the optical region, if it has a typical flat Fν spectrum. Intriguingly, the black body component sug- gested in the X-ray spectrum (and not present in CB07) may SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 11 Figure 5. WHT/ISIS (upper),( VLT/FORS2 (middle) and NOT/ALFOSC (lower) optical spectra of SWIFT J1753.5−0127. A list of the equivalent widths of features in these spectra is given in Table 4. The sharpest lines are marked, and atmospheric telluric absorption bands, which have been removed, are marked with "T". connect the softest X-rays with the optical. This is merely speculation, however, as the optical spectrum itself does not appear black-body-like. Any radio emission, if synchrotron in origin (such as the flat Fν spectrum in CB07) would be too weak to account for any significant fraction of the optical emission. Synchrotron does not, however, have to be flat: emission from a single optically-thick clump rises as ν 3. Such a spectrum has not, to our knowledge, been seen thus far, although de-convolving the various mechanism possible in the optical is tricky. 3.4 Timing We produced light-curves for the X-ray observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127. We used only PCA rates, since the HEXTE is far less sensitive. Note that there were three Pro- portional Countrer Units (PCUs) active in the second obser- vation and only two in the first. Neither observation shows any general or long time-scale trend in flux. We also produced optical light curves, for further analy- sis. For the optical light curve on the 17th, the more stable of the two nights, rapid variability is seen, on the order ∼ 20 s, of a similar magnitude to the 3.2 hr modulation above. The typical uncertainty on each measurement is 0.03 mag in the r′ band, and 0.05 mag in the g′ and 0.08 mag in the u′ band throughout the observation window. 3.4.1 Power Density Spectra A comparatively high fraction of flux is involved in short- term (T < 1 min) variability in both X-ray and optical -- >10%, similar or larger than the orbital-like modulation above. Figures 7 to 10 show the power spectra for all the light curves. Note that, for the optical, the Lomb-Scargle method is required, because the sampling is not strictly reg- ular, and some points have null values. A Fourier analysis of these data do give indistinguishable results, if one assumes regular sampling. White noise can be calculated by assum- ing a standard deviation equal to the Poisson noise (p(N )) on each sample, or obtained by fitting a function to the power spectra which includes a constant term. Fitting the 12 Durant et al. Figure 6. Spectral energy distribution of SWIFT J1753.5−0127 around the time of our observations (July 2007) from the radio to gamma rays. The radio points are upper limits. The grey points are those of Cadolle-Bel at al. (2007; reproduced by kind permission) the black points are from our observations, black triangles are 3σ upper limits from Soleri et al (2008). We have only included X-ray points with good signal-to-noise, and de-reddened the optical by AV = 1.05 for a fair comparison with Cadolle-Bel et al.'s points. Table 5. Power spectrum best-fit parameters. The power law (PL) exponent refers only to the high-frequency (>0.1 Hz) part of the power spectra, whereas the rest of the parameters are for double zero-centred Lorentzians (see text). Parameter RXTE/PCA ULTRACAM 2007 June 11 2007 June 13 2007 June 13 r′ g′ PL exponent 1.20 1.18 0.95 0.90 Width 1 (Hz) %RMS Width 2 (Hz) %RMS QPO? (Hz) %RMS χ2/dof 0.102(9) 12.0(7) 1.7(2) 9.3(8) . . . <3 0.095(8) 13.1(7) 1.5(2) 9.1(7) . . . <3 145/123 116/123 0.040(4) 9.70(8) 0.9(2) 6.15(15) 0.033(3) 37.7(3) 1.5(2) 32.2(5) 0.0789(15) 0.0791(16) 4.4(10) 136/85 11(2) 101/85 2007 June 18 r′ 0.92 0.049(6) 4.00(5) 1.3(2) 2.55(5) 0.079(2) 1.5(6) 92/95 g′ 0.89 u′ 1 1.7 0.051(5) 15.8(2) 1.3(3) 10.7(3) 0.087(9) 4.8(3) . . . . . . 0.074(12) 0.08(3) 7(2) 94/95 <10 55/42 Numbers in perentheses are 1-sigma uncertainties in the last digit, 95% confidence for limits. 1 Due to the smaller number of points available, the fitting function only included one Lorentzian. power spectra and calculating from the known count rates give very similar values for the white noise. Qualitatively, one can see a number of features common to the power spectra: a power law-like decay at high frequen- cies and a break around 0.07 Hz becoming flat in the 0.01 Hz range. Some possible QPOs can be seen at around 0.08 Hz in the optical power spectra but not in the X-ray ones, but with significance only at the 2 -- 5σ level. The optical power spectra are all similar to one-another in this respect also. groups of 50 images, and analyzing these. The temporal reso- lution was thus degraded (to about 2 s), with still significant scatter in the measurements. This accounts for the different appearence of the u′ band power spectrum in Figure 10 (the u′-band power spectrum is the one with the least points). Many of the same features can be seen in the power spec- trum: red noise power law, break, excess in the 0.01 -- 0.1 Hz region and a flat power spectrum at low frequencies. Even a QPO is possibly seen, but not statistically significant. For the u′ band, we obtained a light curve by co-adding By visual inspection, we find that the power spectrum SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 13 Figure 7. Power spectra of the RXTE/PCA observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127, 2007 June 11 (top) and 13 (bottom). The power spectra have been rebinned and the best fit over plotted (solid line) and its components (dotted lines, see Table 5). continua are each well-fitted by zero-centred Lorentzian functions (as used by CB07, for example). We have, there- fore, fitted each power spectrum accordingly, and the result of these fits are shown in Table 5. Also shown are what one would find assuming a power-law noise function for the high- frequency (>0.1 Hz) part of each power spectrum. These numbers are consistent with flickering (superposition of dis- creet, stochastic flares of various heights and durations), for which one expects a power-law exponent of 1 (Bruch, 1992). The flattening of the power spectrum towards lower fequen- cies does not imply that this considerable power cannot be produced by micro-flares, but implies that the micro-flares cannot have arbritarily long durations. Uttley & McHardy (2001) give arguments against a Lorentzian and/or power-law power spectrum necessarily being produced by flickering; specifically, if the average flux and variance of sections of the light-curve are linearly cor- related, without the line passing through the origin. This is indeed to case here, and implies that although flickers can occur on a wide range of time-scales as measured by the power spectra, there is likely an extra component of constant or very small RMS, perhaps the process which feeds the larger amplitude variability (e.g., Merloni & Fabian, 2001). Although the power spectra all look rather similar, the numbers presented in Table 5 are not. If the ideas of Uttley & McHardy are correct, then there seems to be a variable competition between the variable component and the low RMS/constant component which depents both on time and spectral range. For the simultanous r' and g' numbers, the variability is consistently higher for the shorter wavelength, yet we see generally more variability in the optical than in the X-rays (where, as already stated, we do not find signifi- 14 Durant et al. Figure 8. Power spectra of the ULTRACAM observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127from 2007 August 13, r' (top) and g' (bottom), displayed as in Figure 7 cant QPOs). Any micro-flares must thus be rather blue, but damped in their effect on the X-ray emission. 3.4.2 Auto-correlation functions Figure 11 shows the auto-correlation functions for the fast timing observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127. This is a mea- sure of how well each light curve is correlated with itself as a function of time difference, and therefore of the timescales dominant in the variability. In this sense, it complements the power spectrum, viewing the time-series from the point of view of individual events rather than coherent periodic signals. All the curves are well approximated by Lorentzian functions. The X-ray autocorrelation functions are very nar- row (FWHM∼ 2 s), implying that the variability seen at longer time-scales in the power spectra above are not very coherent. The wings of the auto-correlation do, however, seem to extend to large values, with continued structure. Note that the apparent flat tops of the auto-correlations is due to excising the zero-lag value, which is contaminated by white noise. After this, the functions have simply been normalized to 1. The optical auto-correlations in Figure 11 are all gen- erally broader than their X-ray counterparts (FWHM∼4 s). One would normally expect this from a consideration of the energy scales: higher-energy emission is produced in an op- tically thin medium, and can escape easily. The u′ curve is consistent with the others from the night of the 17th, given its lower sampling rate. The optical auto-correlation functions also show some structure at larger lags, which we haven't shown as it would make the central peaks hard to see. SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 15 Figure 9. Power spectra of the ULTRACAM observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127from 2007 August 18, r' (top) and g' (bottom), displayed as in Figure 7 In Durant et al. (2008) we present the cross-correlation functions between various energy bands of the RXTE/PCU and the ULTRACAM observations. We find that there is a strong anti-correlation with the optical arriving earlier than the X-rays on timescales of 1 -- 10 s, followed by a much weaker positive response after δt = 0, for the softest X-ray energies. This is a similar result to the "precursor" signal in the cross-correlation function derived for XTE J1118+480 by Kanbach et al (2001). For medium energies, the correla- tion function is similar but narrower, and we find no correla- tion for high X-ray energies (where noise dominates). Please refer to this paper for further details. 3.4.3 Dynamic analysis We produced dynamic power spectra (based on successive small sections of each light curve) from our rapid timing observations. At first glance, the dynamic power spectra show the same information as the average power spectra above: power concentrated in the 0.01 -- 0.1 Hz range, with no abrupt changes thoughout the observation windows. The two sets of optical dynamis power spectra taken simultanously look identical. For the X-ray, the fluctuation with time is totally consistent with noise. For the optical, however, there is a hint of structure, but again nothing that can be significantly distiguished from noise. 16 Durant et al. Figure 10. Power spectrum of the ULTRACAM observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127from 2007 August 18, u', displayed as in Figure 7 with one fitted Lorentzian. Figure 11. Auto-correlation functions for the different light curves. The top panel shows the two RXTE observations, the bottom panel the optical for the two nights, with the 2007 June 13 data shifted vertically by +1. Each function is normalized to 1 at the peak, and the central point at δt = 0 has been omitted, as it is strongly affected by white noise. The u′ curve represents a light curve of much lower time-resolution (by a factor of 50), and its apparently enhanced width is a result of this. SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 17 4 DISCUSSION A summary of our results:- SWIFT J1753.5−0127 has not returned to a quiescent state, either in X-rays (ASM data), gamma-rays (INTEGRAL data) or optical; rather, it seems to have re-brightened somewhat, compared to one year be- fore our observations. We do not know the current state of radio emission, only the upper limits of Soleri et al. (2008). The optical light curves show superhump-like mod- ulations with a period of 3.2 hr, increasingly significant to- wards the blue, but not detected in X-rays. The X-ray spec- trum is well-described by a single power law of spectral in- dex α = 1.54 from 2 -- 60 keV, with hints of a possible soft disc component and an emission line near 6 keV. The opti- cal spectrum shows no sharp features beyond interstellar ones, only small deviations from a power law. The SED shows a need for separate components for each wave-band, in particular, that the optical cannot be a continuation of a flat synchrotron-dominated spectrum. In contrast to pre- vious observations, we find no significant QPOs in power spectra of the X-ray light curves, but we do find ∼0.08 Hz QPOs in the optical; aside from these, all power spectra are well-described by two zero-centred Lorentzian functions, with widths ∼0.05 Hz and ∼1.5 Hz. Autocorrelation func- tions show a narrower peak (∼2 s) for the X-ray emission than the optical (∼ 3 -- 4 s), which are consistent with one- another for all the u′g′r′ bands. The cross-correlation func- tions (Durant et al. 2008) show the optical leading by 1 -- 10 s and strongly anti-correlated with the X-rays, for the lower energies of the RXTE range. Dynamic power spectra show features which may be short-lived QPOs in the 0.02-0.1 Hz region, more poorly defined in the X-rays than in the optical. From the work of CB07 and Zurita et al. (2008), we suspect that the system contains a stellar-mass black hole and M2V-type companion (which has an undetectable con- tribution to the current total optical luminosity of the bi- nary), and is located at a distance of several kpc, signifi- cantly above the Galactic Plane (in the halo, since its height of order > 1 kpc is much larger than the disc scale height). Our measurement of interstellar absorption, particularly of Na, strongly supports a large distance but also suggests an unknown amount of absorbtion internal to the system. 4.1 Evolution The optical evolution of this source since its 2005 outburst and discovery is more completely analyzed in Zurita et al. (2008). It is clear that the compact object in the sys- tem, probably a black hole, is continuing to accrete mate- rial, which is powering the observed luminosity. The sys- tem was not observed to leave its low/hard state, indicating that some low density/high energy region continued to exist throughout the outburst phase and afterwards. The X-ray spectrum has changed very little, except for the bolometric luminosity. There is apparent evolution in the overall shape of the optical spectrum between CB07, WHT/ISIS and VLT/FORS2 representing two years of the system's life since outburst. This is also seen in the broad-band photometry values in Table 2 compared to CB07 - these are a more ac- curate measure of the change of spectral slope. The wiggles in the WHT/ISIS spectrum are not present either earlier (CB07) or later (out VLT/FORS and NOT/ALFOSC) spec- tra. The smooth continuum and the lack of lines in main- tained throughout, although hydrogen (Hα) emission was seen immediately after the outburst (Torres et al, 2005). The red part of the spectrum changes very little, and in- deed the R-band magnitude has remained remarkably con- stant (see Zurita et al. 2008). The blue part of the spectrum has changed, however: the large peak at ∼4000A dip at ∼4500A and second peak at ∼5000A seen in CB07 were not evident in 2006, but had recovered to some extent by 2007. It would appear that the process which had caused the en- hanced emission during the outburst flare is continuing at a lower level, and that this had maintained the optical emis- sion through the two-year period. Ongoing activity is also suggested by the ASM and INTEGRAL light curves. In terms of timing, the gross power spectrum has re- mained qualitatively similar: flat at low frequencies and flick- ering at high frequencies. A QPO was, however, initially de- tected at 0.6 Hz by Morgan et al. (2005) and later at 0.4 Hz by Ramadevi & Seetha (2005); an evolution that was tracked in many RXTE observations by Zhang et al. (2007); in this work we see such a QPO, relatively weak, but only in the optical data and not in the X-rays, and at a much lower frequency. The slowing of characteristic QPO frequencies and time-scales has been seen for other transient systems (Mc- Clintock & Remillard, 2006; Shahbaz et al. 2005, 2003), and is commonly taken to indicate an expanding inner radius of the accretion disc, inside of which a low density ADAF region forms. The linking of such a QPO frequency with Keplarian periods may be misleading, however: it is not ob- vious how a rotation rate translates into luminosity varia- tions, and why there would exist preferred orbits within the disc. If for this system a disc existed at small radii well af- ter the outburst (as suggested by Miller et al. 2006a), then the frequency characterised by the QPOs seen cannot have a Keplerian interpretation. More simple origins for variability might be disc-corona- jet interaction, turbulence timescales or magnetic field pro- duction/migration timescales; these might depend on factors such as accretion rate, magnetic/particle energy balance, jet efficiency, disc density profile etc. Why these in turn should evolve raises further questions; recurrent outburst- ing episodes suggested hysteresis in X-ray transients (e.g., Malzac, 2007), but the maintenance of a low/hard state in this case would imply only a small change in the mass flow rate. The re-brightening of the source since 2006, and its as- sociated bluer optical colours point to somewhat increasing mass flow from 2006 to 2007. 4.2 Emission mechanisms The X-ray spectrum is typical of Comptonized emission from a population of energetic particles. This in turn requires a source of lower energy photons to scatter (possibly seen at the lowest edge of our X-ray spectrum, and claimed by Miller at al. 2006, and Ramadevi & Seetha, 2007) and a replen- ishable energy reservoir in the particles. At the same time, we suggested the possibility of a contribution of cyclotron emission in the optical, requiring significant energy content in the magnetic field. Note that Beloborodov (1999) showed 18 Durant et al. that emission from magnetically driven clouds moving away from the disc would not produce significant re-processing in cooler material, if the bulk motion was mildly relativistic. We cannot exclude either a static optically thick syclotron emitting region nor multiple blackbodies where particular temperatures are favoured. From the cross-correlation, we can discount simple reprocessing being an important factor in the optical emission. The case is further complicated by the superhump con- tribution. This accounts for about 10% of the variation in the optical region, but increasing towards the UV. If it is indeed due to a superhump process (i.e., either tidal res- onance between the disc and orbital periods, or changing area of the disc; Haswell et al. 2001), then the emission is thermal and very hot with a black-body-like peak blueward of B. We do not see any lines from this emission, but we do not have good spectral sensitivity shortward of 400 nm. The 2006 WHT spectrum showed less of a blue component. This could also be the reason that no QPO was seen in the u′-band power spectrum - thermal emission may already be dominating at these energies. Finally there is the case of jet emission. Malzac et al. (2007) presented a model for how jet and disc emission could be coupled in a black hole system such as this. Jet radio emission was certainly seen earlier, closer to the onset of the outburst (CB07; Fender et al. 2005), and Soleri et al's limits are not stringent enough to exclude even a stronger jet than before. Jet/synchrotron emission cannot, however, be significant in the optical. 4.3 Dynamic behaviour In Durant et al. (2008) we suggest that the cross-correlation function implies that the optically emitting region was driv- ing rather than responding to the higher-energy emission. Here we add to this that the optical auto-correlation func- tions are broader than the X-rays, so it would appear that a relatively slowly building process in the optical leads to a faster and anti-correlated X-ray response. Furthermore, the power spectra show that this process occurs as a distribution of small flares (flickering), with a break at a characteristic time-scale corresponding to a period of ∼ 20 s. Although Malzac et al. (2007) produced a model con- sidering the dynamic interaction of a jet and accretion disc, in an effort to explain the optical/X-ray cross-correlation function for XTE J1118+480, they explicitly consider only optical emission dominated by synchrotron emission, with some additional X-ray re-processing by dense disc material. In our case, the optical is not a simple continuation of a synchrotron spectrum int he radio (which extrapolates to below the optical emission); nevertheless, the idea of a mag- netic energy reservoir may still be valid, as it can produce the types of dynamic behaviour and feedback observed here. We would be interested to see if their model has a parameter space to match the details given here. 4.4 Comparisons It is interesting to note, that SWIFT J1753.5−0127 is the highest Galactic latitude SXRT after XTE J1118+480. The latter object shows some of the same characteristics, which set it apart from the bulk of the SXRT population: short- period superhump/orbital modulation of 4.1 hr, a persis- tent low/hard state, similar power spectra and unusually bright optical emission (Hynes et al., 2003; Shahbaz et al. 2005). The X-ray/optical cross-correlation function for XTE J1118+480 was the first to unambiguously show an optical- leading anti-correlation component ("precognition peak", in some sources), although a positive, standard, optical lag sig- nal was dominant (Kanbach et al. 2001). Unlike SWIFT J1753.5−0127, XTE J1118+480 did set- tle into quiescence. In this state XTE J1118+480 also showed a power spectrum which could be described as a power law with break or power law plus QPO. One inter- pretation of this is to connect this characteristic frequency with the inner edge of the accretion disc: asthe disc-ADAF interface increases in radius, the system decreased in lumi- nosity (Shahbaz et al., 2005). Can the changes of state really be explained by variable accretion rate alone? A leading anticorrelation was seen once for GX 339−4 in the past (Motch et al. 1983). Since this initial and un- confirmed measurement, based on a very short observation window, GX 339−4 has changed markedly. In particular, Gandhi et al. (2008) find the cross-correlation is very differ- ent and weak, in a fainter state, although optical and X-ray spectral characteristics have not changed much. Assuming that the threshold for an X-ray binary to leave the Low-Hard State (where the X-ray spectrum is pre- dominantly a power law, rather than thermal) is 1 percent of the Eddington luminosity (McClintock & Remillard, 2006), we can place a limit on the black hole mass in this system, under several assumptions. If the bolometric luminosity can be scaled from CB07 to the peak observed luminosity at the time of outburst, i.e., if the spectrum remained the same throughout the process, then for a distance d kpc we can place the limit 1% × LEdd < 6 × 1037(cid:18) d M < 6.4M⊙(cid:18) d 6 kpc(cid:19)2 6 kpc(cid:19)2 × 3.5 erg cm−2s−1 Zurita et al. (2008) suggest that a stellar-mass black hole (M ∼ 3M⊙) and M-type star adequately fit the orbital period and quiescent (i.e., pre-outburst) luminosity of the system. Only by obtaining a radial-velocity curve and rota- tional velocity of the donor star, combined with ellipsoidal light curves can the black hole mass be concretely estab- lished. 5 CONCLUSIONS We have conducted optical and X-ray simultaneous spec- tral and timing observations of SWIFT J1753.5−0127, while the X-ray binary was still in an active state following its 2005 outburst. We find a superhump-like blue modulation and remarkably featureless emission in the optical, and hard power-law spectrum in the X-ray, with possible thermal and iron K-line contributions. The power spectra are similar in X-rays and optical, flat below 0.05 Hz and decreasing at higher frequencies, except that the optical power spectra show ∼0.08 Hz QPOs. Dynamic power spectra show these SWIFT J1753.5−0127: multiwavelength observations and reactivation 19 QPOs to be discreet signals wandering in frequency and per- sistent on timescales of ∼10 min. These, together with the respective auto- and cross-correlation functions and possi- ble cyclotron emission, suggest that magnetic processes tie together the disc and high-energy emission. Similar features have been seen for two other interesting SXRTs, XTE J1118+480 and GX 339−4. One suggested reason for the difference of these sources to normal SXRTs is that the accretion disc extends right in to the inner-most stable orbit. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS MD and TS are funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science under the grant AYA 2004 02646 and AYA 2007 66887. PG is a Fellow of the Japan Society for the Promotion of Sci- ence (JSPS). Based on observations carried out in ESO pro- grammes 079.D-0535, and 279.D-5021, and during RXTE Cycle 12. ULTRACAM was designed and built with fund- ing from PPARC (now STFC), and used as a visiting instru- ment at ESO Paranal, and RXTE is operated by NASA. We are grateful for rapid service observations by NOT. Partially funded by the Spanish MEC under the Consolider-Ingenio 2010 Program grant CSD2006-00070: "First Science with the GTC" (http://www.iac.es/consolider-ingenio-gtc/). Thanks to Cadolle-Bel et al. and Paolo Soleri for use of their data in our SED plots. REFERENCES Beloborodov, A., 1999, ApJ, 510, L123 Bessell, M., 1995, IAU Symposium, 167, 175 Bradt, H., Rothschild, R., Swank, J., 1993, A&AS, 97, 355 Bruch, A., 1992, A&A, 266, 237 Burrows, D. N., Hill, J. E., Nousek, J. A., Kennea, J. A., Wells, A., Osborne, J. P., Abbey, A. F., Beardmore, A., Mukerjee, K., Short, A. D. T., Chincarini, G., Cam- pana, S., Citterio, O., Moretti, A., Pagani, C., Tagliaferri, G., Giommi, P., Capalbi, M., Tamburelli, F., Angelini, L., Cusumano, G., Brauninger, H. W., Burkert, W., Hartner, G. D., 2005, SSRv, 120, 165 Cadolle Bel, M., Rib´o, M., Rodriguez, J., Chaty, S., Corbel, S., Goldwurm, A., Frontera, F., Farinelli, R., D'Avanzo, P., Tarana, A., Ubertini, P., Laurent, P., Goldoni, P., Mirabel, I., 2007, ApJ, 659, 549 Chaty, S., Haswell, C., Malzac, J., Hynes, R., Shrader, C., Cui, W., 2003, MNRAS, 346, 689 Czerny, B., R´oz a´ska, A., Janiuk, A., Z ycki, P., 2000, NewAR, 44, 439 Dhillon, V., Marsh, T., Stevenson, M, Atkinson, D., Kerry, P., et al. 2007, MNRAS, 378, 825 Durant, M., Gandhi, P., Shahbaz, T., Fabian, A., Miller, J., Dhillon, V., Marsh, T., 2008, ApJL submitted Fabian, A., Guilbert, P., Motch, C., Ricketts, M., Ilovaisky, S., Chevalier, C., A&A, 111, L9 Fender, R., Garrington, S., Muxlow, T., 2005, ATel, 558 Fender, R. & Belloni, T., 2004, ARA&A, 42, 317 Gandhi et al., 2008 in preparation Halpern, J., 2005, ATel, 549 Haswell, C., King, A., Murray, J., Charles, P., 2001, MN- RAS, 321, 475 Homan, J., Belloni, T., 2005, Ap&SS, 300, 107 Hynes, R., Haswell, C., Cui, W., Shrader, C., O'Brien, K., Chaty, S., Skillman, D., Patterson, J., Horne, K., 2003, MNRAS, 345, 292 Hynes, R., 2005, ASPC, 330, 237 Hynes, R., 2006, AIPC, 840, 88 Jahoda, K., Swank, J. H., Giles, A. B., Stark, M. J., Strohmayer, T., Zhang, W., Morgan, E. H., 1996, SPIE, 2808, 59 Jahoda, K., Markwardt, C., Radeva, Y., Rots, A., Stark, M., Swank, J., Strohmayer, T., Zhang, W., 2006, ApJS, 163, 401 Kanbach, G., Straubmeier, C., Spruit, H., Belloni, T., 2001, Nature, 414, 180 Lebrun, F., Leray, J. P., Lavocat, P., Cr´etolle, J., Arqu´es, M., Blondel, C., Bonnin, C., Bou´ere, A., Cara, C., Chaleil, T., Daly, F., Desages, F., Dzitko, H., Horeau, B., Lau- rent, P., Limousin, O., Mathy, F., Mauguen, V., Meignier, F., Molini´e, F., Poindron, E., Rouger, M., Sauvageon, A., Tourrette, T., 2003, A&A, 411, L141 Levine, A., Bradt, H., Cui, W., Jernigan, J.., Morgan, E., Remillard, R., Shirey, R., Smith, D., 1996, ApJ, 469, L33 Liu, B., Taam, R., Meyer-Hofmeister, E., Meyer, F., 2007, ApJ, 671, 695 Malzac, J., Merloni, A., Fabian, A., 2004, MNRAS, 351, 253 Malzac, J., 2007, MmSAI, 78, 382 McClintock, J. E., Garcia, M. R., Caldwell, N., Falco, E. E., Garnavich, P. M., Zhao, P., 2001, ApJ, 551, L147 McClintock, J., Remillard, R., 2006, Chapter 4 of "Com- pact Stellar X-ray Sources", eds. W. Lewin and M. van der Klis, CUP Merloni, A. & Fabian, A., 2001, MNRAS, 328, 958 Meyer-Hofmeister, E., 2004, A&A, 423, 321 Miller, J., Homan, J, Miniutti, G., 2006, ApJ, 652, L113 Miller, J., 2007, ARA&A, 45, 441 Morgan, E., Swank, J., Markwardt, C., Gehrels, N., 2005, ATel, 550 Morris, D., Burrows, D., Racusin, J., Roming, P., Chester, M., Verghetta, R., Markwardt, C., Barthelmy, S., 2005, ATel, 552 Motch, C., Ricketts, M., Page, C., Ilovaisky, S., Chevalier, C., 1983, A&A, 119, 171 Palmer, D., Barthelmey, S., Cummings, J., Gehrels, N., Krimm, H., Markwardt, C., Sakamoto, T., Tueller, J., 2005, ATel, 546 Ramadevi, M., Seetha, S., 2007, MNRAS, 378, 182 Remillard, R. A., McClintock, J. E., 2008, ARA&A, 44, 49 Rothschild, R. E., Blanco, P. R., Gruber, D. E., Heindl, W. A., MacDonald, D. R., Marsden, D. C., Pelling, M. R., Wayne, L. R., Hink, P. L., 1998, ApJ, 496, 538 Schwope, A., Thomas, H-C., Mantel, K-H., Haefner, R., Staude, A., 2003, A&A, 402, 201 Shahbaz, T., Dhillon, V. S., Marsh, T. R., Casares, J., Zu- rita, C., Charles, P. A., Haswell, C. A., Hynes, R. I., 2005, MNRAS, 362, 975 Shahbaz, T., Dhillon, V. S., Marsh, T. R., Zurita, C., Haswell, C. A., Charles, P. A., Hynes, R. I., Casares, J., 2003, MNRAS, 346, 1116 Soleri, P., Altamirano, D., Fender, R., Casella, P., Tudose, 20 Durant et al. V., Maitra, D., Mijnands, R., Belloni, T., Miller-Jones, J., Klein-Wolt, M., van der Klis, M., 2008 Stil, J., Taylor, A., Dickey, J., Kavars, D., Martin, P., Roth- well, T., Boothroyd, A., Lockman, F., & McClure-Griffiths, N., 2006, AJ, 132, 1158 Still, M., Roming, P., Brocksopp, C., Markwardt, C., 2005, ATel, 553 Tanaka, Y., & Shibazaki, N., 1996, ARA&A, 34, 607 Torres, M., Steeghs, D., Garcia, M., McClintock, J., Miller, J., Jonker, P., Callanan, P., Zhao, P., Huchra, J., U, Vivian, Hutcheson, C., 2005, ATel, 551 Uttley, P. & McHardy, I., 2001, MNRAS, 312, 880 Uzdensky, D., Goodman, J., 2007, MmSAI, 78, 403 van der Klis, M., in Compact Stellar X-ray Sources. (eds Lewin W. H. G., van der Klis M.), Cambridge Univ. Press, p. 39 Zhang, G.-B., Qu, J.-L., Zhang, S., Zhang, C.-M., Zhang, F., Chen, W., Song, L.-M., Yang, S.-P., 2007, ApJ, 659, 1511 Zurita, C., Durant, M., Torres, M., Shahbaz, T., Casares, J., 2008, ApJ, accepted This paper has been typeset from a TEX/ LATEX file prepared by the author.
astro-ph/0502517	3	0502	2005-09-16T14:53:13	The baryonic mass function of galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	In the Big Bang about 5% of the mass that was created was in the form of normal baryonic matter (neutrons and protons). Of this about 10% ended up in galaxies in the form of stars or of gas (that can be in molecules, can be atomic, or can be ionised). In this work, we measure the baryonic mass function of galaxies, which describes how the baryonic mass is distributed {\it within} galaxies of different types (e.g. spiral or elliptical) and of different sizes. This can provide useful constraints on our current cosmology, convolved with our understanding of how galaxies form. This work relies on various large astronomical surveys, for example the optical Sloan Digital Sky Survey (to observe stars) and the HIPASS radio survey (to observe atomic gas). We then perform an integral over our mass function to determine the cosmological density in baryons in galaxies: $\Omega_{\rm b, gal} = 0.0035$. Most of these baryons are in stars: $\Omega_{*} = 0.0028$. Only about 20% are in gas. The error on the quantities, as determined from the range obtained between different methods, is $\sim 10$%; systematic errors may be much larger. Most ($\sim 90$%) of the baryons in the Universe are not in galaxies. They probably exist in a warm/hot intergalactic medium. Searching for direct observational evidence and deeper theoretical understanding for this will form one of the major challenges for astronomy in the next decade.	astro-ph	astro-ph	The baryonic mass function of galaxies 1Institute of Astronomy, Cambridge University, Madingley Road, By J. I. Read 1† & Neil Trentham 1 Cambridge, CB3 OHA, England In the Big Bang about 5% of the mass that was created was in the form of normal baryonic matter (neutrons and protons). Of this about 10% ended up in galaxies in the form of stars or of gas (that can be in molecules, can be atomic, or can be ionised). In this work, we measure the baryonic mass function of galaxies, which describes how the baryonic mass is distributed within galaxies of different types (e.g. spiral or elliptical) and of different sizes. This can provide useful constraints on our current cosmology, convolved with our understanding of how galaxies form. This work relies on various large astronomical surveys, for example the optical Sloan Digital Sky Survey (to observe stars) and the HIPASS radio survey (to observe atomic gas). We then perform an integral over our mass function to determine the cosmological density in baryons in galaxies: Ωb,gal = 0.0035. Most of these baryons are in stars: Ω∗ = 0.0028. Only about 20% are in gas. The error on the quantities, as determined from the range obtained between different methods, is ∼ 10%; systematic errors may be much larger. Most (∼ 90%) of the baryons in the Universe are not in galaxies. They prob- ably exist in a warm/hot intergalactic medium. Searching for direct observational evidence and deeper theoretical understanding for this will form one of the major challenges for astronomy in the next decade. Keywords: mass function, stellar, HI, gas, baryonic 1. Introduction The hot Big Bang theory is the current paradigm for the formation and evolution of the Universe. Parts of the theory that describe the Universe in the first small fraction of a second, like superstring theory, cannot rigorously be tested by experiment and so are not well-constrained at present. But the parts that describe the subsequent evolution of the Universe have been very successful. Examples of the successes are the predictions of the cosmic microwave background (CMB), the abundances of light elements and the expansion of the Universe (Peacock 1999). One feature of the model is the partitioning of mass-energy into entities that obey different equations of state. In Table 1, we list current estimates for the den- sities of these forms of mass-energy (Fukugita & Peebles 2004, Allen et al. 2004). These numbers come from matching the theory to observations of the CMB (e.g. Spergel et al. 2003), the distance-redshift relation obtained from Type Ia super- nova (e.g. Riess et al. 2004), and observations of rich galaxy clusters a different † Email: [email protected] Article submitted to Royal Society TEX Paper 2 Read & Trentham Table 1. Composition of the Universe Total density Dark energy density Ω = 1 ΩΛ = 0.73 Matter density Dark matter density ΩM = 0.27 Ωdm = 0.22 Baryonic density Ωb = 0.05 redshifts (Allen et al. 2004). The two main components are a dark energy com- ponent with density ΩΛ, which could be a cosmological constant†, and a matter component with density ΩM . The matter density can further be divided into a dark-matter component and a baryonic component. Inferences about the density of the baryonic component come from observations of the CMB angular power spec- trum (Spergel et al. 2003) and the abundances of light elements D, 3He, 4He and 7Li (Coc et al. 2004) when compared with big bang nucleosynthesis theory (BBN). The existence of the dark matter component is strengthened by independent evidence from the dynamics and clustering of galaxies and clusters of galaxies (e.g. de Blok et al. 2001, Kleyna et al. 2001 and Borriello & Salucci 2001); and from gravitational lensing measurements (Mellier 1999 and Sand et al. 2004). The baryonic component is the subject of the present paper. Understanding the present distribution of material in the Universe is a formidable challenge. With the advent of fast computers and efficient algorithms for calculating the force between many particles, we can now make solid predictions for the current distribution of dark matter (Bertschinger 1988). However, understanding the distri- bution of stars and gas is more difficult. This involves a detailed understanding of the physics underlying galaxy formation: gas hydrodynamics, star formation, and feedback from exploding stars and forming black holes. Despite these difficulties, much progress has been made and simulations are now on the verge of being able to make predictions about where and in what form we should expect to find baryons† in the universe today (see e.g. Mayer 2004 and Springel et al. 2005). The new hy- drodynamic simulations of galaxy formation (e.g. Dav´e et al. 2001 and Nagamine et al. 2005) include an intergalactic medium, which makes it straightforward to include these effects. Technological advances in observational astronomy have also been rapid, mainly as regards our ability to compile and process large datasets. The results from many surveys have recently been published. These include optical redshift surveys, like the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS; Abazajian et al. 2004) and the 2DF Galaxy Redshift Survey (Colless et al. 2001), near-infrared photometric surveys like 2MASS (Gao et al. 2004), and HI atomic gas surveys like HIPASS (Koribalski et al. 2004). The time, therefore, is ripe to use the survey results in conjunction with each other to calculate precisely the distribution of baryons in the Universe. This will † The energy density of a given component, Ωi = ρi/ρc, is defined as the ratio of its density to the critical density which would make the universe spatially flat: ρc = 3H 2 0 /8πG, where G is the gravitational constant and H0 is the Hubble constant at the present epoch, which we assume to be H0 = 70 km s−1Mpc−1. The astronomical unit of a parsec (pc) is 3.09 ×1016 m. † Baryons are any hadron which comprises three quarks; typically this refers to protons and neutrons. Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 3 then provide a valuable resource against which cosmological simulations which in- clude the complex physics of star formation and galaxy formation may be tested. It also presents a vital census of that part of the universe which we can see. While models which invoke dark matter or dark energy may come and go, the light we observe from galaxies and the distribution of the baryons within these systems remains a firm result. A first attempt at such a calculation was made by Salucci & Persic (1999) for disc galaxies while Bell et al. (2003) recently presented the baryonic mass function of all galaxies, calculated using a combination of 2MASS and SDSS data. Other authors have computed the stellar mass function of galaxies (Cole et al. 2001 and Panter et al. 2004) or the gas mass function (Keres et al. 2003, Koribalski et al. 2004, Springob 2004). In this paper we present the baryonic mass function for nearby galaxies sep- arated by Hubble Type†. We convert the the field galaxy luminosity function of Trentham et al. (2005) (which depends on SDSS measurements at the bright end) to a mass function using dynamical mass estimates where possible (e.g. Kronawit- ter et al. 2000) and stellar population synthesis models otherwise (e.g. Bruzual & Charlot 2003). We use data from the HIPASS survey (Koribalski et al. 2004) to de- termine the HI (atomic hydrogen) gas masses of galaxies and data from the FCRAO Extragalactic CO survey of Young et al. (1995) to determine the H2 (molecular hy- drogen) gas masses of galaxies of a given luminosity and Hubble Type. We further use recent X-ray surveys of disc and elliptical galaxies to constrain the contribu- tion of ionised hydrogen (Mathews & Brighenti 2003) and use microlensing data to constrain the contribution of stellar remnants (Alcock et al. 2000, Derue et al. 2001 and Afonso et al. 2003). Combining all these measurements gives the baryonic mass function. This paper is organised as follows. In section 2 we present the luminosity function of field galaxies separated by Hubble Type. In section 3 we describe our method for calculating mass-to-light ratios of stellar populations in different galaxies and compute the stellar mass function of galaxies. In section 4 we compute the gas mass function for field galaxies. In section 5 we present the full baryonic mass function of galaxies and compare this with results from the literature. We then discuss baryonic mass components which have been left out of the analysis: halo stars, stellar remnants, and hot ionised gas and dust. In section 6 we integrate the baryonic mass function to obtain the relative contribution of each baryonic mass component to Ωb,gal and compare our results to values of Ωb derived from the CMB and light element abundances. Finally, in section 7 we present our conclusions. † The Hubble 'tuning fork' galaxy classification scheme separates galaxies by morphology into 'early types' (elliptical and lenticular - E, S0) and 'late types' (spirals - Sa, Sb, Sc, Sd, Sm - and irregulars - Irr). Dwarf galaxies are denoted dE (dwarf elliptical) or dIrr (dwarf irregular). In this paper we group the dIrr and Irr galaxies together. Note that while such classifications are historical, these galaxies are genuinely distinct in their chemical and dynamical properties. E, dE and S0 galaxies are largely supported by random stellar motions and are of typically higher metallicity, while Sa/b/c/d, Irr and dIrr are largely rotationally supported and of lower metallicity. The dynamical differences, plus the differences in chemistry make determinations of the stellar and gas mass-to-light ratios for these systems necessarily different. Thus splitting the galaxy populations into different types in this way is useful for a study such as this one. Article submitted to Royal Society 4 Read & Trentham 2. The luminosity function of field galaxies The luminosity function φ(MR), is defined such that φ(MR) dMR dV is the number of galaxies in the absolute R-band magnitude range [MR, MR + dMR]‡ within co-moving volume element dV. The field galaxy luminosity function is plotted by Hubble Type in Figure 1. As in Trentham et al. (2005), the bright end of the luminosity function was computed using data from the SDSS galaxy survey, while the faint end was taken from observations of nearby galaxy groups (e.g. Trentham & Tully 2002). We show parameter values on the plot for a Schechter function fit to the luminosity function¶. While the error bars are small enough that the Schechter function does not provide a good formal fit, it is a simple analytic form which captures the main features of the mass and luminosity functions which are presented in this paper. The Hubble Type is a subjective assessment that depends on many parame- ters that can be measured for nearby bright galaxies. It cannot be determined for the faint galaxies in SDSS images, so we cannot determine type-specific luminos- ity functions from SDSS data alone. Broadband colours are often regarded as a straightforward way to distinguish between different kinds of galaxies. These are available for the SDSS sample, but this is a poor discriminant since different Hubble Types can have very similar colours (Fukugita et al. 1995), particularly different kinds of spiral galaxies. Another discriminant is the light concentration parameter, but this alone cannot be used to distinguish different types of late-type galaxies: concentration parameters do not depend on scale length if the profiles are exponen- tial. Hα emission-line strength is yet another discriminant, but there is considerable scatter in the Hα equivalent width of galaxies of a single Hubble type (Kennicutt & Kent 1983). We therefore use the following procedure: brightward of MR = −17.5, concentra- tion parameters, K-corrected† broadband colours, and Hα equivalent widths were used in conjunction with each other to classify the SDSS galaxies as early-type, ‡ The absolute magnitude is a logarithmic measure of the luminosity in the R-band. Histori- cally, the luminosity of galaxies is presented as MX = −2.5 log10RX LλTX (λ) dλ+constant where X denotes some filter (e.g. R-band), TX (λ) is the transmission function of that filter, and Lλ is the spectral energy distribution of the galaxy. The nomenclature for filters is complicated because many groups define their own system. Often these labels overlap so that the 'r-band' has several different definitions in the literature. For a full review see Fukugita et al. (1995). In this paper we will refer only to the Cousins R-band (5804-7372 A) and the Johnson B-band (3944-4952 A) (Fukugita et al. 1995). In the days of photographic astronomy, the names were often taken from the types of plates supplied by photographic companies. For example, the J in the well-known bJ filter comes from the particular type of photographic emulsion obtained from Kodak. We even learnt one story where the notation had to be changed when the photographic company changed the plate name because the yak whose stomach lining they used to manufacture the glue used in the emulsion became endangered! function luminosity in mass Schechter ¶ The given (M ) (L) by: or is φ(M ) = φ∗ exp(cid:16)− M M∗(cid:17)(cid:16) M 0.92φ∗ (cid:16)10[−0.4(MR −MR∗ )](cid:17)α+1 KX (z) = 2.5 log10 (cid:20)(1 + z) R ∞ 0 Lλ(λ′)TX (λ′)dλ′ 0 Lλ( λ′ R ∞ . units In magnitude M∗(cid:17)α × exp(cid:16)−10[−0.4(MR−MR∗ )](cid:17) (Schechter 1976). 1+z )TX (λ′)dλ′(cid:21) . It corrects for two effects: (i) the redshifted φ(MR) gives: this = † The K-correction for filter X for a galaxy at redshift z is defined by the following equation: spectrum is stretched through the bandwidth of the filter, and (ii) the rest-frame galaxy light that we see through the filter comes from a bluer part of the spectral energy distribution because of the redshift (Frei & Gunn 1994). Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 5 !"#$%& '(#)& Figure 1. The field galaxy luminosity function split by Hubble Type. The top left plot is for Elliptical and S0 galaxies, the top right is for spirals (Sa-Sd), the bottom left is for the dwarf galaxies (irregular and elliptical) and the bottom right is the combined luminosity function. In each plot a spline-fit to the luminosity function is shown to guide the eye and these spline fits are also overlaid on the combined luminosity function in the bottom right plot. Galaxies which are very luminous in the R-band lie to left of these plots, while those which are very faint lie to the right. Overlaid on the bottom right panel are parameters for a Schechter fit to the total luminosity function. intermediate-type, or late-type using local galaxies as templates. Luminosity func- tions were computed for each. The early-type luminosity function was then further split into an elliptical luminosity function and an S0 luminosity function in such a way that the relative numbers of these kinds of galaxies corresponded to that in each magnitude range in the Nearby Galaxies Catalogue (Tully 1988), which lists a sample of luminous galaxies within 40 Mpc. The intermediate luminosity function was split into a Sa luminosity function and a Sb luminosity function similarly. The late-type luminosity function was split into a Sc, a Sd, and an irregular luminosity function. Brightward of MR = −17.5, dwarf elliptical galaxies do not seem to ex- Article submitted to Royal Society 6 Read & Trentham Figure 2. The field galaxy stellar mass function split by galaxy Hubble type. The data points are for all galaxies, while the lines show spine fits by Hubble Type. The lines have the same meaning as in Figure 1. Bright (massive galaxies) lie to the right of this plot, while faint galaxies lie to the left. Overlaid are parameters for a Schechter fit to the total mass function. ist outside rich clusters (see e.g. Binggeli et al. 1988). Faintward of MR = −17.5, the luminosity function was split according to the relative numbers of the different kinds of galaxies in the groups surveyed by Trentham & Tully (2002) and the Local Group. This method of computing the luminosity function is motivated by our need to obtain stellar mass-to-light ratios and gas masses or galaxies of particular magni- tudes and types. It forces the SDSS galaxy sample to have properties similar to the local galaxy sample, but it generates a luminosity function that is less sus- ceptible to cosmic variance problems than a luminosity function derived from the local galaxy sample alone. Our method is subject to systematic problems if the two galaxy samples are very different. Other authors have used concentration parame- ters (see e.g. Kauffmann et al. 2003) or star formation histories derived from the SDSS spectra (Panter et al. 2004) to determine the mass-to-light ratios. Comparing our results to other values in the literature will be an important test of our method (see sections 3, 4 and 5). Our derived luminosity function agrees very well, both by Hubble type and inte- grated, with one obtained using only local galaxies (Binggeli et al. 1988). However, the agreement with a recent luminosity function obtained from the SDSS alone by Blanton et al. (2004) is not so good at the faint end (see dotted black line, Figure Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 7 µB 1 0.64 0.33 -- 0.40 0.16 -- 0.25 0.06 -- 0.09 E S0+S0/a Sa+Sab Sb+Sbc Sc+Scd Sd+Sdm+Sm Irr+dIrr dE ∼0 ∼0 - M/LB mHI/LB mH2 /mHI 6.8 -- 7.5 4.8 -- 5.4 3.1 -- 3.6 2.1 -- 2.6 1.6 -- 2.1 1.6 -- 2.1 0.9 -- 1.2 1.7 -- 4.9 ∼ 0.01 0.11 -- 0.33 0.078 -- 0.32 0.24 -- 0.46 0.46 -- 0.65 0.62 -- 0.70 0.55 -- 0.99 ∼0 ∼1 1.3 -- 6.7 1.5 -- 5.8 2.0 -- 4.2 1.1 -- 1.8 0.70 -- 1.3 0.30 -- 0.58 - Table 2. Galaxy properties as a function of Hubble Type. 1). Their faint end slope, corrected for incompleteness, is significantly steeper than ours (they find α ∼ −1.5; we find α ∼ −1.3). The difference could be caused by cosmic variance effects: our particular patch of the universe may be under-dense. In addition, Schechter fits to the bright end of the luminosity function (where the Poisson errors are small) tend to over-predict the number of faint galaxies. Finally, notice that there is a dip in the luminosity function at MR ∼ −17. A similar dip in the luminosity function was recently found by Flint et al. (2003) suggesting that it might not simply be the result of incompleteness or poor overlap in the surveys used (see also Trentham et al. (2005) for further discussion of this feature). 3. The stellar mass function of field galaxies In order to convert the luminosity function to a mass function, we require the mass- to-light ratio of the stellar populations. This will in general be a function of galaxy type, age, metallicity and even luminosity. We determine the mean mass-to-light ratio of ellipticals and assume that this may also be applied to the bulge component of S0 and spiral galaxies. We then determine the mean mass-to-light ratio of discs, irregular galaxies and dwarf elliptical galaxies. These mean mass-to-light ratios are then combined using bulge-to-disc ratios, µB, using the measurements of Kent (1985). The results are presented, along with the gas properties of galaxies that we derive in the next section, in Table 1. In fact, we could do better than just taking a mean value for each of the Hubble types; in future work we will use a distribution of mass-to-light ratios as a function of luminosity for each Hubble type. This is beyond the scope of this present work. (a) A note on random v.s. systematic errors Stellar masses depend on both the galaxy luminosity function and the mass-to-light ratios of the stellar populations in the different kinds of galaxies. The errors in the former are random and are determined by counting statistics. The errors in the latter are systematic and come from our lack of knowledge about input parameters like metallicity and stellar IMF in the stellar population models used to calculate the mass-to-light ratios. We can get around this problem to some extent by comparing Article submitted to Royal Society 8 Read & Trentham these mass-to-light ratios with those derived from dynamical measurements; we may then quote a range of mass-to-light ratios determined from these two methods. In this paper we take this pragmatic approach. However, the reader should be aware that dynamical measurements have their own systematic uncertainties and so it is not clear that we can really quantify all of our systematics in this way. As a conservative estimate, we suggest that the total systematic error may be as large as ∼ 50% (compared with our quoted errors of ∼ 10%). In future, we may hope to better quantify these systematics through spectroscopy of individual stars, deep photometry and improved modelling. (b) Ellipticals and bulges Two methods were employed here. The first uses stellar population synthesis models to convert an age, metallicity and colour into a B-band mass-to-light ratio M/LB. We use the models of Bruzual & Charlot (2003) with an initial stellar mass function (IMF), η(M )†, taken from Kroupa (2001): η(m) =   25 η(1) m−0.3 2 η(1) m−1.3 η(1) m−2.3 : 0.01 ≤ m < 0.08 : 0.08 ≤ m < 0.5 : 0.5 ≤ m < 100 (3.1) where m is in units of solar masses M⊙. The results are very sensitive to the IMF, since arbitrarily many low-mass stars can be included with no change to the measured colour, metallicity or age of a galaxy. This IMF has been empirically determined from deep observations of local field stars and of young star clusters. It is denoted the 'universal IMF' since it appears to be the same across the enormous range of scale, environment and epoch in which it has been determined (Kroupa 2001). This IMF is also attractive in that it is the end result of star formation that exhibits a Salpeter IMF whilst in progress (Kroupa & Weidner 2003). Using the stellar population models of Bruzual & Charlot (2003), adopting the IMF above, and assuming a mean age and metallicity for ellipticals of tE ≃ 12 ± 2 Gyr and Z = 2 Z⊙‡ respectively, we obtain M/LB = 9.81 − 11.05¶. Note that fitting a power law to the stellar population models of Bruzual & Charlot (2003) gives M/LB ∼ 6.7(Z/Z⊙)0.58. Thus the results are sensitive both to the choice of IMF, and to the choice of mean metallicity for the ellipticals. We may also obtain the mass-to-light ratio of ellipticals from dynamics. While there is significant evidence for dark matter in ellipticals, interior to the majority of the stellar light the dark matter component is small (van der Marel 1991 and Kronawitter et al. 2000) so the stellar velocities (as measured from their relative Doppler shifts) may be used to calculate the total gravity produced by masses of the stars. † The stellar IMF is defined such that η(M ) is the number of stars in the interval M to M +dM . M⊙ = 1.989 × 1030 kg is the mass of the sun. ‡ The metallicity, Z, is the ratio of the total mass in heavy elements, Mh, to the total baryonic mass (Binney & Merrifield 1998). ¶ This is in units of M⊙L−1 ⊙,B - solar masses per B-band solar luminosity, which we use through- out this paper. Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 9 A recent study of 21 elliptical galaxies by Kronawitter et al. 2000 gives M/LB = 6.78 − 7.54 which is a factor ∼ 0.7 of the stellar population value. This is surprising since the presence of dark matter should tend to make the stellar populations value smaller than the dynamical estimate rather than the other way round. We favour the dynamical estimate because modelling stellar populations is extremely difficult and errors of the order 2 are not uncommon (Charlot et al. 1996). Perhaps more importantly, the 'universal' IMF of Kroupa (2001) has not been explicitly verified for elliptical galaxies and so may not be the correct one to use (Jorgensen 1997). Chabrier (2003) suggest an IMF which gives a much better agreement between stel- lar population models and dynamical masses for elliptical galaxies, however similar agreement may be obtained by using the Kroupa (2001) IMF and assuming a mean metallicity for ellipticals of solar, rather than twice solar. The double degeneracy of metallicity and IMF for the ellipticals leads us to favour the dynamical value for the mass to light ratio. This has its own systematic limitations: the internal velocity dispersions of ellipticals are unknown since only the line of sight velocities may be measured; and the presence of dark matter may complicate things at large radii. Future dynamical mass measurements, improved stellar population modelling, deep photometry of nearby galaxies and good spectra of individual stars will all help to pin down these systematic uncertainties in the future. (c) The mass-to-light ratio of discs Following Fukugita et al. (1998) we compile a mean mass-to-light ratio for discs from three independent methods. The first is from measurements of the column density of stars in the solar neighbourhood, Σ∗ = 27 − 40M⊙pc−2 (Gould et al. 1996 and Kuijken & Gilmore 1989). Combining this with the local luminosity surface density, ΣLB ≃ 18M⊙pc−2 (Bahcall & Soneira 1980) gives M/LB = 1.5 − 2.2. The second method uses the stellar population synthesis models of Tinsley (1981) and Portinari et al. (2004). These are on a firmer footing than for the elliptical galaxies since the IMF has been explicitly measured for spiral galaxies (Kroupa 2001). These give M/LB = 1.1 − 1.9 using the IMF given in equation 3.1. The third method uses a dynamical mass estimate for the stars (Salucci & Persic 1999). This gives M/LB = 1.11. The mean of all of these values gives M/LB = 1.24 − 1.7. We adopt this value here. This value was then corrected for internal extinction in the galaxies, using the corrections of (Tully & Fouque 1985) and a field sample inclination distribution equivalent to that seen in the Ursa Major Cluster (Tully et al. 1996). A similar value for M/LB was recently obtained dynamically from a compilation of spiral galaxies by McGaugh (2004). This further strengthens our confidence in this value. (d ) The mass-to-light ratio of dwarfs and irregulars The mass-to-light ratios for the irregulars (and dwarf irregulars) may be adapted from the above value for discs corrected for their younger age and consequent bluer colour (Fukugita et al. 1998): M/LB = 0.9 − 1.24. Recent observations of the Ursa Minor Local Group dwarf elliptical (dE)† galaxy † Ursa Minor or UMi is usually labelled as a dwarf spheroidal galaxy (dSph) which is an alternate name for a dwarf elliptical galaxy. Article submitted to Royal Society 10 Read & Trentham Figure 3. The field galaxy HI (left) and H2 (right) gas mass functions split by galaxy Hubble Type. The data points are for all galaxies, while the lines show spine fits by Hubble type. The lines are as in Figure 1. Overlaid are parameters for a Schechter fit to the total mass function. by Wyse et al. (2002) suggest that dE stellar populations are very similar to the Milky Way globular clusters. As such, we use the dynamical mass-to-light ratio of Galactic globular clusters (Pryor & Meylan 1993) for dE galaxies: M/LB = 1.7−4.9. We find excellent agreement between our derived stellar mass function and that of Panter et al. (2004) (see the black dotted line in Figure 2). They also use the SDSS data, but derived stellar masses from star formation histories constrained by the spectra of the galaxies. This gives some weight to the validity of our method of classifying galaxies by Hubble type and then determining masses. Our data gives Ω∗ = 0.0028 ± 0.0003, whereas Panter et al. find Ω∗ = 0.0034 ± 0.0001. 4. The gas mass function of field galaxies The gas mass function of local galaxies is presented in Figure 3. (a) Atomic hydrogen (HI) A large sample of HI (atomic) gas measurements of nearby galaxies was compiled recently as part of the Australian HIPASS survey, using the Parkes radio telescope. Measurements of the 1000 brightest galaxies in this sample were recently published (Koribalski et al. 2004). In order to measure the total amount of gas in galaxies in the Universe, we need to determine how much gas the galaxies contain per unit optical luminosity. We can then get the gas mass function from the luminosity function. We computed the atomic gas mass per unit luminosity for each Hubble Type as follows. We compiled a sample of galaxies with velocities between 2000 and 3000 km/s that were observed at optical wavelengths and also in HI in the HIPASS survey. For each Hubble Type, we used this sample to determine the ratio between the atomic gas mass and the Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 11 optical luminosity. These numbers are given in Table 2. The wide ranges reflect the conservative error estimates that we are forced to use because of the intrinsic scatter in the ratio for galaxies of a given Hubble Type and because the errors are systematic (see also section 3a). The HI mass function that we derived is very similar to the one derived by HIPASS (Zwaan et al. 2003) at the high-mass end, but falls significantly below theirs at the low-mass end. This difference can be attributed to the difference in sample selection and scaling -- the HIPASS sample is selected by HI mass but ours is selected and scaled by optical luminosity. They therefore include many systems that we do not, as well as including gas in the outer parts of galaxies which is not included in our analysis -- a galaxy that we think has mass M of atomic gas may really have 2M , so our points should be shifted towards the right if we wish to include all the atomic gas in the Universe. Both of these effects could be more important at low masses -- the highest mass HI galaxies will invariably be in optical surveys, and all scaling relations were derived using the properties of these galaxies.. This difference also accounts in our different values of ΩHI: HIPASS finds ΩHI = (4.1 ± 0.6) × 10−4, whereas we get ΩHI = (2.9 ± 0.6) × 10−4. (b) Molecular hydrogen (H2) Similarly, we determine the relationship between galaxy Hubble Type and molecular gas mass using the data of Young et al. (1995). The results are also presented in Table 2. This survey measures CO line luminosities, which are converted to gas masses using the empirical formula of Young & Scoville (1991): MH2 = 12000 SCOD2M⊙, where SCO is the CO flux in Jy km/s and D is the distance to the galaxy in Mpc. We find a very similar molecular gas mass function to that of Keres et al. (2003), who presented this function for a far-infrared (FIR)-selected sample, also derived from the Young et al. (1995) sample. This is consistent with the idea that most of the currently observed molecular gas in the Universe is in normal galaxies, which are the same objects as the FIR sources. 5. The baryonic mass function of field galaxies The baryonic mass function is presented in Figure 4. This is the sum of the functions in the three previous Figures, where the masses in the gas functions are multiplied by 1.33 to take into account the presence of helium. The error bars are small enough that Schechter or any other analytical fits to the data are formally poor. However, we show our best fit values on the plot. In Table 3, we present the total mass density of the Universe in baryons within galaxies, in different forms. Typical errors are 10% (but see section 3a). For the stellar masses the uncertainty mainly comes from our lack of knowledge of the mass-to-light ratios. For the gas components the error primarily comes from the uncertainty in the scaling of optical luminosity to gas mass for galaxies of a given Hubble Type. About 8% of the baryons in galaxies are in atomic gas and about 7% are in molecular gas. In the Milky Way about 8% of the baryons are in atomic gas and a further 2% are in molecular gas. Article submitted to Royal Society 12 Read & Trentham A comparison with the CDM mass function is also shown in Figure 4. The nor- malisation for the baryonic component in galaxies is very much lower, reflecting the fact that galaxy masses are dominated by dark matter, not baryons. Additionally, the baryonic mass function has a very different shape from the dark mass function. This suggests that the collapse of baryons into galaxies and the ability of the galax- ies to retain the gas once star formation has begun is very much a scale-dependent process. At the very low mass end, where galaxies are heavily dark-matter domi- nated, the baryonic mass function is still very much shallower than the CDM mass function -- this is the classical missing satellites problem (Moore et al. 1999). At the high mass end it is also deficient. This could be caused by feedback from centrally active black holes within galaxies (Silk & Rees 1998). Finally, notice that there is a slight bump in the baryonic mass function at ∼ 109M⊙. This corresponds to a similar dip in the stellar mass function (see Figure 2) and a dip in the luminosity function at MR ∼ −17 (see Figure 1 and section 2). The dip is much less significant in the baryonic mass function than in the stellar mass function and the luminosity function. It is possible in all cases that this dip is a statistical artifact: its significance is not high. However it is interesting that it occurs at the transition point in galaxy type from ellipticals and spirals to dwarfs. The fact that it is less pronounced in the full baryonic mass function than in the stellar mass function may then simply highlight the fact that the gas mass fraction in dwarf irregulars is much larger than in ellipticals and spirals. There are a number of baryonic mass components which we have not included in the above analysis because they comprise only a tiny fraction of the total mass in baryons within galaxies. Field halo stars: In the Milky Way and M31 there is a faint spheroidal stellar population of stars which lie neither in the disc nor bulge components of the galaxy (Gilmore et al. 1989). While the total mass of this component is quite uncertain and estimates range from ∼ 108 (Binney & Merrifield 1998) to ∼ 109 M⊙ (Freeman & Bland-Hawthorn 2002), this is still only ∼ 0.1 − 1% of the total baryonic mass and, therefore, a negligible Galactic mass component. Because of the low surface density of these halo stars, they are difficult to resolve in galaxies much further away than M31. Perhaps other galaxies have a much more significant stellar halo and we are missing an important baryonic mass component. This is probably not the case, however, because stars from these halos would generate a high extragalac- tic background light in galaxy clusters, which is not observed (Zibetti et al. 2005)†. MACHOs and stellar remnants: Limits can be placed on massive compact halo objects (MACHOs) of any form, which may or may not be made of baryonic matter, from microlensing experiments (e.g. Alcock et al. 2000). Current data (Afonso et al. 2003) suggests that the contribution of MACHOs to the total baryonic mass of the Galaxy may be small, and we neglect this contribution here. A more stringent † In fact an argument of this sort requires some care. Zibetti et al. (2005) find that ∼ 30% of the stars in clusters can be attributed to background light of some sort. However, ∼ 20% of this is associated with the large central cluster galaxy. It is likely that these these stars are tidal debris left over from infalling galaxies; they would have formed within discs or bulges, rather than stellar halos. We take what we feel is a conservative upper bound from these cluster measurements of 10% for the contribution from stars which formed within stellar halos. Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 13 Figure 4. The field galaxy baryonic mass function. The data points are for all galaxies, while the lines show spine fits by Hubble Type. The lines are as in Figure 2. The CDM mass spectrum from the numerical simulations of Weller et al. (2004) is also shown. Overlaid are parameters for a Schechter fit to the total mass function. Ωb 0.00064 E 0.00073 S0 0.00036 Sa+Sab 0.00056 Sb+Sbc Sc+Scd 0.00072 Sd+Sdm+Sm 0.00037 0.00013 Irr+dIrr dE 0.00002 0.0035 total Ω∗ ΩHI 0.00064 ∼ 0 0.00068 0.00032 0.00040 0.00047 0.00021 0.00007 0.00002 ∼ 0 0.0028 0.00003 0.00001 0.00004 0.00010 0.00007 0.00003 0.00029 ΩH2 ∼ 0 0.00001 0.00002 0.00008 0.00008 0.00005 0.00001 ∼ 0 0.00026 Table 3. The baryonic mass density of galaxies. Typical errors are ∼ 10%. A discussion of the larger systematic errors is given in section 3a. constraint can be placed on the total mass in MACHOs that are the endpoints of stellar evolution (neutron stars and black holes) due to the lack of large amounts of heavy elements in the Universe (e.g. Freese et al. 2001). Fukugita & Peebles (2004) estimated the cosmological density in the remnants to be Ωremnants ∼ 0.00001, which is far less than the sums in Table 3, and we ignore this contribution here. Article submitted to Royal Society 14 Read & Trentham Hot gas: There are two main hot ionised gas components in galaxies: a component associated with HII regions, which is heated by ionising radiation from O and B stars, and an extended component which is associated with the dark matter halo. The mass of the component associated with HII regions is negligible (∼ a tenth of the molecular gas mass) for both early and late type galaxies (e.g. O'Sullivan et al. 2001, Mathews & Brighenti 2003 and Goudfrooij 1999). The extended com- ponent is what we refer to later as the warm/hot intergalactic medium or WHIM. Some of this gas is likely bound to galaxies; much of it presumably also resides in the intergalactic medium. This component, which we do not count as part of galac- tic baryonic matter, is probably the dominant form of baryons in the Universe. Dust: In the Milky Way, a dust-to-gas ratio by mass is about 1/200 (Gilmore et al. 1989). There does not seem to be any evidence for this ratio being different in the majority of external normal galaxies (see e.g. the review by Young and Scoville 1991), and we neglect the contribution of dust to the baryonic mass density of the Universe. 6. The contribution to Ωb The value that we get of Ωb,gal ∼ 0.0035 in galaxies is only about one-tenth of the value of the baryonic density of the universe Ωb ∼ 0.05 derived from measurements of light element abundances (Coc et al. 2004) and from the shape of the angular power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background (Spergel et al. 2003). This opens up the important question: if they are not in galaxies, where do 90% of the baryons in the Universe reside? Hydrodynamic simulations (Cen & Ostriker 1991) suggest that most of these baryons are in a warm/hot intergalactic medium (WHIM), that is highly ionised. This medium is very difficult to detect, but there might be indirect evidence for its existence, from observations of OVII X-ray absorption along the lines of sight to high redshift quasars (e.g. Fang et al. 2003). Directly detecting the WHIM and will be a major area of observational study over the next few years. The main conclusions from this work are as follows: 7. Conclusions 1. The baryonic density of the universe that resides in galaxies is Ωb,gal = 0.0035 ± 0.0003. This is far less than the value of Ωb = 0.05 inferred from the CMB or from BBN. Most of the baryons in the Universe do not reside in galaxies and probably reside in the warm/hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). Direct detection of the WHIM will form one of the major challenges for astronomy in the next decade. 2. Most of the baryons in galaxies are in stars, not gas, and about one-half of these stars are in early-type galaxies. We derive the value of Ω∗ = 0.0028 ± 0.0003, assuming stellar mass-to-light ratios derived from population synthesis models, a Kroupa IMF in discs and irregular galaxies and stellar mass-to-light ratios derived from dynamical measurements in bulges and elliptical galaxies. Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 15 3. About 15 -- 20% of the baryons in galaxies are in gas. Of this, about one half is in molecular gas. 4. About 30% of the atomic gas seen by HIPASS is not present in our atomic gas mass function. We attribute this to gas in galaxies that are missing in the sample that we used to define a scaling between optical luminosities and gas masses. The main uncertainties in this work arise from the systematic errors in determina- tions of the stellar and gas mass-to-light ratios. The errors we quote throughout this paper are small, since they derive from the range in mass-to-light ratios deter- mined from different methods. Such errors do not take account of systematic errors within each mass determination which are much harder to quantify and may be as large as 50%. Spectroscopy, deep photometry and improved modelling will all help to pin down and reduce such systematics in the future. An accurate baryonic mass function is already beginning to form one of the observational pillars of modern cosmology. 8. Acknowledgements We would like to thank the three anonymous referees, Stacy McGaugh and Gilles Chabrier for their useful comments. REFERENCES Abazajian et al. 2004, AJ, 128, 502 Afonso et al. 2003, A&A, 404, 145 Alcock et al. 2000, ApJ, 541, 734 Allen et al. 2004, MNRAS, 353, 457 Bahcall J. N., Soneira R. M., 1980, ApJS, 44, 73 Bell E. F., McIntosh D. H., Katz N., Weinberg M. D., 2003, ApJ, 585, L117 Bertschinger E., 1998, ARA&A, 36, 599 Binggeli B., Sandage A., Tammann G. A., 1988, ARA&A, 26, 509 Binney J., Merrifield M., 1998, Galactic astronomy. Princeton University Press. Blanton M. R., et al., 2004 Borriello A., Salucci P., 2001, MNRAS, 323, 285 Bruzual G., Charlot S., 2003, MNRAS, 344, 1000 Cen R., Ostriker J. P., 1999, ApJ, 514, 1 Chabrier G., 2003, PASP, 115, 763 Charlot S., Worthey G., Bressan A., 1996, ApJ, 457, 625 Coc et al. 2004, ApJ, 600, 544 Cole et al. 2001, MNRAS, 326, 255 Article submitted to Royal Society 16 Read & Trentham Colless et al. 2001, MNRAS, 328, 1039 Dav´e R., Cen R., Ostriker J. P., Bryan G. L., Hernquist L., Katz N., Weinberg D. H., Norman M. L., O'Shea B., 2001, ApJ, 552, 473 de Blok W. J. G., McGaugh S. S., Bosma A., Rubin V. C., 2001, ApJ, 552, L23 Derue et al. 2001, A&A, 373, 126 Fang T., Sembach K. R., Canizares C. R., 2003, ApJ, 586, L49 Flint K., Bolte M., Mendes de Oliveira C., 2003, Ap&SS, 285, 191 Freeman K., Bland-Hawthorn J., 2002, ARA&A, 40, 487 Freese K., Fields B. D., Graff D. S., 2001, in Identification of Dark Matter . p. 213 Frei Z., Gunn J. E., 1994, AJ, 108, 1476 Fukugita M., Hogan C. J., Peebles P. J. E., 1998, ApJ, 503, 518 Fukugita M., Peebles P. J. E., 2004, ApJ, 616, 643 Fukugita M., Shimasaku K., Ichikawa T., 1995, PASP, 107, 945 Gao J., Chen L., Wang J., Hou J., Zhao J., 2004, Progress in Astronomy, 22, 275 Gilmore G., Wyse R. F. G., Kuijken K., 1989, ARA&A, 27, 555 Goudfrooij P., 1999, in Ast. Soc. of the Pacific Conf. Series . p. 55 Gould A., Bahcall J. N., Flynn C., 1996, ApJ, 465, 759 Jorgensen I., 1997, MNRAS, 288, 161 Kauffmann et al. 2003, MNRAS, 341, 33 Kennicutt R. C., Kent S. M., 1983, AJ, 88, 1094 Kent S. M., 1985, ApJS, 59, 115 Keres D., Yun M. S., Young J. S., 2003, ApJ, 582, 659 Kleyna J. T., Wilkinson M. I., Evans N. W., Gilmore G., 2001, ApJ, 563, L115 Koribalski et al. 2004, AJ, 128, 16 Kronawitter A., Saglia R. P., Gerhard O., Bender R., 2000, A&AS, 144, 53 Kroupa P., 2001, MNRAS, 322, 231 Kroupa P., Weidner C., 2003, ApJ, 598, 1076 Kuijken K., Gilmore G., 1989, MNRAS, 239, 605 Mathews W. G., Brighenti F., 2003, ARA&A, 41, 191 Mayer L., 2004, in Proc. of Baryons in Dark Matter Halos. . p. 37 McGaugh S. S., 2004, ApJ, 609, 652 Mellier Y., 1999, ARA&A, 37, 127 Moore B., Ghigna S., Governato F., Lake G., Quinn T., Stadel J., Tozzi P., 1999, ApJ, 524, L19 Article submitted to Royal Society The baryonic mass function of galaxies 17 Nagamine K., Cen R., Hernquist L., Ostriker J. P., Springel V., 2005, ApJ, 618, 23 O'Sullivan E., Forbes D. A., Ponman T. J., 2001, MNRAS, 328, 461 Panter B., Heavens A. F., Jimenez R., 2004, MNRAS, 355, 764 Peacock J. A., 1999, Cosmological physics. Cosmological physics. Publisher: Cam- bridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1999. ISBN: 0521422701 Portinari L., Sommer-Larsen J., Tantalo R., 2004, MNRAS, 347, 691 Pryor C., Meylan G., 1993, in Ast. Soc. of the Pacific Conf. Series . p. 357 Riess et al. 2004, ApJ, 607, 665 Salucci P., Persic M., 1999, MNRAS, 309, 923 Sand D. J., Treu T., Smith G. P., Ellis R. S., 2004, ApJ, 604, 88 Schechter P., 1976, ApJ, 203, 297 Silk J., Rees M. J., 1998, A&A, 331, L1 Spergel et al. 2003, ApJS, 148, 175 Springel V., White S. D. M., Jenkins A., Frenk C. S., Yoshida N., Gao L., Navarro J., Thacker R., Croton D., Helly J., Peacock J. A., Cole S., Thomas P., Couchman H., Evrard A., Colberg J., Pearce F., 2005, Nature, 435, 629 Springob C. M., 2004, American Astronomical Society Meeting Abstracts, 205, Tinsley B. M., 1981, ApJ, 250, 758 Trentham N., Sampson L., Banerji M., 2005, MNRAS, pp 52 -- + Trentham N., Tully R. B., 2002, MNRAS, 335, 712 Tully R. B., 1988, Nearby galaxies catalog. Cambridge University Press Tully R. B., Fouque P., 1985, ApJS, 58, 67 Tully et al. 1996, AJ, 112, 2471 van der Marel R. P., 1991, MNRAS, 253, 710 Weller J., Ostriker J. P., Bode P., 2004 Wyse et al. 2002, New Astronomy, 7, 395 Young J. S., Scoville N. Z., 1991, ARA&A, 29, 581 Young et al. 1995, ApJS, 98, 219 Zibetti S., White S. D. M., Schneider D. P., Brinkmann J., 2005 Article submitted to Royal Society
astro-ph/0408259	1	0408	2004-08-13T17:46:55	A Statistical Investigation of HI in the Magellanic Bridge	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present results from two statistical analyses applied to an neutral hydrogen (HI) dataset of the nearby tidal bridge in the Magellanic System. Primarily, analyses of the Spatial Power Spectrum suggest that the Magellanic Bridge, historically considered to be a single contiguous feature, may in fact be a projection of two kinematically and morphologically distinct structures. The southern and more obviously turbulent parts appear to show structure organized similarly to the adjacent Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), while the northern regions are shown to be relatively deficient in large scale power. The extent of modification to the spatial power index by the velocity fluctuations is also highly variant across these parts of the Bridge. We find again that the northern part appears distinct from the southern part and from the SMC, in that the power spectrum is significantly more affected by slower velocity perturbations. We also probe the rate of spectral variation of the HI by measuring the Spectral Correlation Function over selected regions. The results from this analysis highlight a tendency for the HI spectra within the bright parts of the Bridge to have a more persistent correlation in the E-W direction than in the N-S direction. These results are considered to be quantitative evidence for the tidal processes which are thought to have been active throughout the evolution of the Magellanic Bridge	astro-ph	astro-ph	Draft version June 28, 2018 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 4/12/04 A STATISTICAL INVESTIGATION OF Hi IN THE MAGELLANIC BRIDGE Arecibo Observatory, HC3 Box 53995, Arecibo, Puerto Rico 00612 E. Muller Radio Astronomy Lab, UC Berkeley, 601 Campbell Hall, Berkeley, CA 94720 S. Stanimirovi´c, E. Rosolowsky and L. Staveley-Smith Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO, PO Box 76, Epping, N.S.W. 1710, Australia (Received 2004 May 27) Draft version June 28, 2018 ABSTRACT We present results from two statistical analyses applied to an neutral hydrogen (HI) dataset of the nearby tidal bridge in the Magellanic System. Primarily, analyses of the Spatial Power Spectrum suggest that the Magellanic Bridge, historically considered to be a single contiguous feature, may in fact be a projection of two kinematically and morphologically distinct structures. The southern and more obviously turbulent parts appear to show structure organized similarly to the adjacent Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), while the northern regions are shown to be relatively deficient in large scale power. The extent of modification to the spatial power index by the velocity fluctuations is also highly variant across these parts of the Bridge. We find again that the northern part appears distinct from the southern part and from the SMC, in that the power spectrum is significantly more affected by slower velocity perturbations. We also probe the rate of spectral variation of the Hi by measuring the Spectral Correlation Function over selected regions. The results from this analysis highlight a tendency for the Hi spectra within the bright parts of the Bridge to have a more persistent correlation in the E-W direction than in the N-S direction. These results are considered to be quantitative evidence for the tidal processes which are thought to have been active throughout the evolution of the Magellanic Bridge. Subject headings: ISM: structure -- galaxies: interactions -- Magellanic Clouds -- ISM: atoms 1. INTRODUCTION The Magellanic Bridge (MB) is an elongated, pre- dominantly neutral hydrogen (Hi) structure, located be- tween and joining the Large and Small Magellanic Clouds (Kerr, Hindman, & Robinson, 1954). Numerical simula- tions (Ruzicka, 2003; Gardiner, Sawa, & Fujimoto, 1994; Gardiner & Noguchi, 1996) and the relative geometrical arrangement of the components of the Magellanic Sys- tem (e.g. Mathewson, Schwarz & Murray, 1977) indi- cate that the MB was formed directly from the Magel- lanic Clouds, following a particularly close mutual pass ∼200 Myr ago. Recent high resolution observations have shown that the Hi in the MB has a complex and chaotic filamentary structure (Muller et al. 2003). Apparently coherent Hi features are identifiable across the entire range of observed angular scales, from ∼98′′ up to ∼7◦, although the filamentary component is clearly unevenly distributed throughout the entire MB region. Statistical techniques are a useful means to compare populations of similar objects in different systems, under- stand and model general properties and behaviors, and expose and isolate any hidden underlying trends within a dataset. In particular, statistical analyses provide some of the most useful descriptions of turbulent flows. The results of statistical analyses of emission-line data sets can be directly compared with theoretical predictions to determine the properties of the turbulence under that Electronic address: [email protected] theoretical framework. While there are many statistical techniques that have been used to analyze different data sets, this paper focuses on two complimentary methods: the Spatial Power Spectrum (SPS) and the Spectral Cor- relation Function (Rosolowsky et al, 1999). The SPS and the SCF were chosen because they high- light the importance of structure across a wide range of spatial scales. The organisation of spatial scales has a direct influence on the efficiency of energy transport throughout the interstellar medium (ISM) of the subject system and also vice versa: the transport of energy is an important operator on the arrangement and distribution of spatial scales. The relationship between the observed SPS and the characteristics of the underlying turbulent flows has been the work of several theoretical studies (Lazarian & Pogosyan 2000; Goldman 2000; Miville-Deschenes et al. 2003). In contrast with the SPS which measures structure of data sets on a more global scale, the SCF measures local variations as a function of spatial scale. No studies have yet made a direct and dedicated com- parison of the outcomes and predictions of the SPS and the SCF. Measurements of the SCF on the Hi of the LMC (Padoan et al. 2001) were shown to be in rough, though not particularly good agreement with earlier studies us- ing the SPS (Elmegreen et al. 2001) and a more detailed discussion of the predictions of the SCF in the context of the turbulent and small-scale structure of the LMC Hi were not entered into. 2 Muller et al. To date, studies of the SPS have been made of Hi in the SMC and the LMC (Stanimirovic et al. 1999a; Stan- imirovic & Lazarian 2001; Elmegreen et al. 2001). SCF studies have been made only of the LMC (Padoan et al. 2001). These results have highlighted the existence of important active processes and structure trends within these systems and have been used as a quantifier for the organisation of structure within these systems indepen- dently. The MB forms a physical link between the SMC and the LMC, and represents a feature which has evolved purely in response to tidal forces. The MB is therefore an ideal system to test and compare the response of the SCF to a) a system which has developed in response to large-scale forces and b) in the context of the host sys- tems, i.e. the SMC and LMC. Such an analysis may characterize the turbulence in tidal features in general and in addition, a comparison of the SPS results derived for different components in the Magellanic System can provide insights into different evolutionary paths for or- ganization of Hi structures in an galactic versus an in- tergalactic medium. The structure of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we review the SPS and SCF. In Section 3 we summarize the observations of the subject Hi MB dataset. Sections 4 and 5 detail the methodology and results of the calculation of the Hi SPS and SCF on the MB Hi dataset. Sections 6 presents the discussion and interpretation of our results. Finally, we summarize our results in Section 7. 2. STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES 2.1. The Spatial Power Spectrum The SPS has traditionally been applied to obtain a useful insight into hydrodynamics, MHD theory and tur- bulent motions (e.g. Lazarian & Pogosyan 2000). For example, a shallow SPS results from a system which is dominated by small-scale structure, while a steep SPS results from a system which is dominated by large-scale fluctuations. The SPS has been commonly applied on large datasets in an attempt to parameterise the struc- ture hierarchy of the Hi in these systems. (Crovisier & Dickey 1983; Green 1993; Stanimirovi´c et al. 1999a; Sta- nimirovi´c & Lazarian 2001; Elmegreen, Kim, & Staveley- Smith 2001; Dickey et al. 2001). The SPS is derived from the Fourier transform power spectrum of an observed 2-d image, denoted P (k), where k is the spatial frequency. Different types of observations commonly show that the SPS of intensity fluctuations can be characterized by a power-law, or the sum of two power laws: P (k) ∝ kγ or P (k) ∝ C1kγ1 + C2kγ2. The composite power law is observed when the dynam- ics of a system are shaped by a process (or processes) which generate excess power over a specific range of scales. For example, supernovae are capable of inject- ing power across scales of tens of parsecs. The constants C1 and C2 are dependent on the relative importance of the two terms (see also Elmegreen & Scalo, 2004; Scalo & Elmegreen, 2004, for a detailed review of turbulent processes). In the case of a Kolmogorov-type of turbulent fluid (isotropic and incompressible turbulence, characterized by energy injection on large scales with a dissipationless cascade of energy over intermediate scales and dissipa- tion of energy only on smallest scales) the SPS of both 3-d density and velocity fluctuations is a power law with a slope equal to −11/3. However, a spectral index of γ ∼ −3.7 does not nec- essarily imply Kolmogorov-like turbulence. Recent work using simulated datasets have shown that other turbu- lent regimes are capable of producing spectral indices which are approximately equal to this value. For ex- ample, Miville-Deschenes, Levrier & Falgarone (2003) have developed synthetic fractal Brownian motion (fBm) datasets which can yield spatial spectral indices of −3.7. Furthermore, synthetic datasets containing randomly distributed, supernovae-driven expanding shells also ap- pear to produce a Kolmogorov spectrum (Hodge & Desh- pande, in preparation). Both of these studies are in need of further clarification however, specifically in that the fBm set does not represent coherent turbulent structures (i.e. it is constructed from Brownian noise), and that the Hodge & Deshpande analysis involves unphysical forma- tion processes (i.e. they do not solve the hydrodynamic equations in the development of the set). To distinguish and disentangle the nature and extent of velocity fluc- tuations from static hierarchical density structure, tech- niques which measure the velocity statistics of the set must be used. An important advantage the SPS has over other sta- tistical techniques is in relating statistics of the observed intensity fluctuations with the statistics of the underly- ing 3-d density and velocity fields. A recent development in SPS studies involves the averaging of data across a number of observed velocity channels. By integrating a spectral-line data cube over varying ranges of velocity, Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) showed that it is possible to disentangle the influences of density and velocity fluc- tuations in the turbulent flow, i.e. the power-law index is a function of both the velocity, and the velocity width of the observations: γ = γ(v, ∆v). When an image is generated from a small range in velocities (small ∆v), a significant fraction of the observed structure results from the velocities of the turbulent flow moving emis- sion into different velocity channels. Since an SPS is usually inferred to characterize the density fluctuations in a turbulent flow, the velocity fluctuations would cor- rupt the results. However, when integrated over a large velocity range (large ∆v), most of the velocity fluctu- ations average out, leaving only static density fluctua- tions. By measuring the power law spectrum over a range of widths in the velocity window, Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) showed that it was possible to separate the power- law spectrum of the density fluctuations from those of the velocity fluctuations. In their Velocity Channel Analy- sis (VCA), they refer to the regime where the velocity thickness of the integrated slice averages out the velocity fluctuations as the "thick slice regime" and the opposite regime where the velocity fluctuations are important as the "thin slice regime". 2.2. The Spectral Correlation Function As the SPS is derived from the Fourier transform of the data set, information from the entire image contributes to the power spectrum. However, this global approach compromises the usefulness of the SPS in isolating local features in the data. By contrast, the SCF does not transform the data and operates on entire spectra in a data cube instead of en- tire images. The SCF parameterizes the 'similarity', S0, between two spectra as a function of their spatial sep- aration, ∆r and often shows a power-law relationship S0 ∝ ∆rα over a range of separations (e.g. Padoan, Rosolowsky & Goodman, 2001). The SCF is normalized so that a perfect match between two spectra will yield a value of S0 = 1, and a value of zero is obtained for no similarity, or for an anti-correlation. Since this technique does not use a Fourier transform it does not require the data to be edge tapered and thereby reduces problems arising from the finite sampling and the associated edge effects. Therefore, the minimum size of the region that may be sampled with this technique is much smaller than that available to the power spectrum analysis. However, the SCF is sensitive to the noise in the data cube and its application is limited to high signal-to-noise data. The early forms of the SCF technique were used to de- rive an estimate of spectral similarity over a lag range which was defined by the velocity dispersion of the spec- tra of interest. It was therefore limited to data cubes that were described by a simple, single velocity compo- nent. Later modifications to the SCF made by Padoan, Rosolowsky & Goodman (2001) included a parameter which weights the function by the ratio of the RMS of the signal and noise. These modifications improved the ability of the algorithm to handle noise and expanded its application to more complex and multi-component spectra and across any range of spatial lags (Padoan, Rosolowsky & Goodman 2001). An interesting applica- tion of the SCF was shown in the study by Padoan et al. (2001) where a break in the power-law behavior of the SCF was interpreted as a signature of the LMC's disk thickness. As the SCF is a rather recent development, the re- lationship between the SCF results and the proper- ties of the observed turbulence are not understood as completely as for the SPS. We have attempted here a more dedicated study and comparison of the the SCF in the context of predictions from the relatively well- parameterized SPS. 3. THE MB Hi DATASET We use the high-resolution Hi observations of Muller et al. (2003) for the present statistical investigation of the Hi distribution in the MB. These observations encom- pass a ∼ 7◦ × 7◦ region, centered on RA = 2h08m40s, Dec. = −73◦27′59′′ (J2000), and covering the heliocen- tric velocity range 100 -- 350 km s−1. The data were col- lected with both the Australia Telescope Compact Ar- ray (ATCA) and the Parkes Telescope1. The observing parameters, data reduction and data combination pro- cedures are described in Muller et al. (2003). The fi- nal Hi data cube has 1-σ brightness temperature sensi- tivity of ∼0.9 K (corresponding to a column density of ∼1.62×1018 cm−2), a velocity resolution of ∼1.6 km s−1, and an angular resolution of 98′′. These observations are sensitive to all spatial scales from about 29 pc (corre- sponding to angular scale of ∼98′′) to 7.3 kpc (corre- 1 The Australia Telescope Compact Array and Parkes telescopes are part of the Australia Telescope which is funded by the Com- monwealth of Australia for operation as a National Facility man- aged by CSIRO. 3 sponding to angular scale of ∼7◦), assuming a distance of 60 kpc to the MB. An important note in the context of this work, is that the ATCA interferometer, being com- posed of discrete elements is not capable of uniformly sampling the entire UV plane. The missing data is ex- trapolated during the deconvolution and inversion pro- cess which also homogonises the sensitivities somewhat (refer to Muller et al. 2003 and also Stanimirovi´c, 1999 for explicit information on the data deconvolution and inversion process). Fig. 1 shows an RA-Dec. peak intensity image of the Hi spectral line data cube used in this study. The diverse range of morphologies in the Hi of the MB is striking in this image: some regions are bright and filamentary, particularly in the southern parts, while others are more tenuous and smooth. Fig. 2 shows a peak pixel image of the same dataset viewed in the Dec.-Velocity projec- tion. The distribution of Hi in this figure appears well- organised into at least two components. Notably, these two components appear to be distinct also in declina- tion. The velocity separation of these components is ∼ 40 km s−1. The rapid spatial and velocity variability of the Hi in the MB shown in Figs. 1 & 2, indicates a turbulent and highly inhomogeneous morphology over the entire range of observed spatial and velocity scales. Consequently, we have applied a separate SPS analysis on four subregions within the data set, as shown in Fig. 1 with the overlaid grid. Each region spans ∼ 2.2×2.2 kpc (256×256 pixels). We will refer to these regions as (clockwise starting from the bottom left on Fig. 1): the South East (SE), the North East (NE), the North West (NW) and the South West (SW). The SW region is dominated by bright, filamentary features across its entire extent. The Hi in the SE region is similarly filamentary, although the spatial coverage of the brightest feature is less complete. The NE region defines an area of less diverse structure where the Hi ap- pears relatively tenuous and smooth. The NW region appears to be dominated by part of a large loop-like fea- ture. Fig. 2 shows that the northern two sub-regions (NE and NW) encompass Hi which occurs at lower Heliocen- tric velocities. The SPS analyses was applied on each region separately. Due to the unpredictable response of the SCF to noisy data, we have restricted the SCF analysis to a the bright- est region of the Magellanic Bridge, shown in Fig. 3. Much of this area has a spectral quality of Q > 6 (see Eq. 2 in Section 5.1) . Restricting the tested data to those with a quality of this level limits the effects of noise on the SCF to < 20%. In contrast, the northern regions of the data set is more dominated by noise, having areas where Q < 6. Although binning can increase the spec- tral quality, the degree of averaging necessary to effect a substantial increase in Q ultimately obscures the velocity structure, thereby compromising the utility of the SCF. The 10×3 grid overlaid on Fig. 3 shows the eight areas over which the SCF was averaged (see §5. Each small square defines a 500 ×500 pc area (63 × 63 pixels). As the telescope beam subtends approximately three image pixels, a new data cube was generated that sampled ev- ery third pixel in the x and y directions to ensure that the SCF samples independent spectra. 4 Muller et al. Fig. 1. -- Peak intensity map of the entire MB Hi dataset. The overlaid square indicates the four 256 × 256 pixel (∼2.2×2.2 kpc) subsections over which the power spectrum analysis is calculated. 4. THE SPATIAL POWER SPECTRUM ANALYSES 4.1. Derivation of the SPS The two-dimensional SPS used here is derived fol- lowing methodologies used in previous studies (Cro- visier & Dickey 1983; Green 1993; Stanimirovi´c et al. 1999a; Stanimirovi´c & Lazarian 2001; Elmegreen, Kim, & Staveley-Smith 2001; Dickey et al. 2001). We start with two-dimensional images of the Hi intensity distribu- tion. These images are tapered with a Gaussian function to suppress the sin(k)/k ringing that appears from the sharp edges of the original image under the Fourier trans- form. The power (square of the modulus of the Fourier transform) is then measured as a function of wave num- ber (or spatial scale). The power is then azimuthally averaged in rings of logarithmically increasing intervals of wave numbers. The interferometric (ATCA) part of this dataset has negligible non-circularity of the u − v sampling function (see also Muller et al. 2003, Fig. 1) and no compensa- tion was made for any ellipticity of the u − v sampling function. The median Hi column density for the final Hi data cube is quite low (∼4×1020 cm−2), so any correc- tions for self-absorption are unnecessary (see discussion by Minter 2002). We emphasise that this dataset is a combination of observations obtained with the Parkes single-dish tele- scope and with the ATCA interferometer. Therefore, a complete range of spatial frequencies was sampled from zero spacing, up to ∼ 600λ, corresponding to a minimum spatial scale of ∼ 100 pc (note that this is the contigu- ously sampled range of spatial frequencies; although spa- tial frequencies up to ∼ 1600λ have been sampled, these are not part of a complete contiguous spatial frequency distribution). A sample SPS from the MB dataset, typical for velocity channels with significant Hi emission, is shown in Fig. 4. Data points calculated from a continuous range of spatial frequencies < 600λ were used for fitting and are denoted by squares. The error bars in the figure correspond to 1- σ statistical uncertainties, which were taken into account during the fitting procedure. 5 Velocity Offset Fig. 2. -- Integrated intensity map of the Declination-Velocity projection of the combined ATCA-Parkes data cube. The northern part of the Hi in the Bridge is clearly offset to higher velocities with respect to the southern part by ∼40-50 km s−1. We see a clear bimodal distribution of Hi in the more southern part in this figure. This apparent two-fold structure originates in the body of the SMC and extends approximately 4 kpc towards the LMC (Muller et al. 2003). It has clearly been significant in the evolution of the Bridge and is the subject of a future work. The grey scale is a linear transfer function as shown in the wedge and units are K.arcsec . As this map is integrated along the x image axis, the labeled Declination axis is correct only for RA=2h08m8s. 2,2 3,2 4,2 5,2 6,2 7,2 8,2 9,2 Fig. 3. -- Peak pixel map of a subregion of the MB Hi dataset. The overlaid grid shows the eight regions for which the S(∆r) maps are calculated. Each square labeled with a grid reference forms the centre of a larger square region over which the SCF is calculated. The surrounding regions constitute the buffer. This entire area approximately corresponds to regions SE and SW of Fig. 1 At spatial frequencies > ∼700λ the effect of the ATCA beam becomes prominent, as shown with a dashed line in Fig. 4. The SPS derived from an emission-free velocity channel is shown in the same figure with crosses. We see that the contribution of power to the SPS from the noise component of the Hi dataset is negligible at low spatial frequencies (by a factor of 105/106.5 ≈0.03 at ≈700λ) and is important only at the largest spatial frequencies (> 700λ). As these frequencies are usually compromised by the ATCA beam, they are already excluded from the fit. Although some efforts have been made to compen- sate for the effects of noise and beam shape in power spectra (Green 1993), we have minimized these effects by restricting the spatial frequency range to < 700λ from the fit. 4.2. The SPS as a function of velocity Fig. 5 shows a typical SPS for all four sub-regions, derived from single velocity channels with significant Hi emission. A single power-law function, P (k) ∝ kγ, can be fitted to the SPS for most of the spatial frequency range. Similarly featureless SPS were found for the SMC (e.g. Stanimirovi´c et al. 1999a,b) and for the Galaxy (Green 1993; Dickey et al. 2001). The variation of the power-law slope with heliocentric velocity γ(v, ∆v = 1.6 km s−1) for each of the four re- gions defined in Fig. 1 is shown in Fig. 6. The left axis corresponds to the power-law index γ(v), while the right 6 Muller et al. Fig. 4. -- Sample SPS from the South East sub-region (dotted line), at velocity ∼169 km s−1 (heliocentric). The spectrum is typical for channels which contain bright Hi. The fitted line shown (solid line) is an error-weighted fit, derived using the points marked with squares. Importantly, we see that the power spectra of the Bridge are able to be well fitted with a single component power-law. Also shown on this plot is the power spectrum for a spectral channel containing only noise (crosses) and for the 98′′ beam (dashed line). The error bars mark one standard deviation, those showing a downward pointing arrow indicate a large lower error limit. axis shows the mean integrated Hi brightness tempera- ture for a given velocity channel. The power-law index generally varies significantly with velocity, even over the velocity channels with the bright- est Hi emission. The nature of this variation is different in the different quadrants. This large variation in γ(v) contrasts to that which was found for the Hi in the rel- atively homogeneous SMC: Stanimirovi´c et al. (1999a) measured no dramatic or large changes in the power-law index across the entire (∼200 km s−1) velocity range. This has important ramifications in the next part of the SPS analysis, where the fundamental assumption is that the structure of the set under study is largely homoge- neous throughout the velocity range of the data. To some extent, the plots of Fig. 6 suggest a relation- ship between the mean brightness temperature and the index of the power-law, in that a hight mean TB is as- sociated with a steeper power spectrum. This is can be seen for velocity channels where the mean TB <2K or so. This effect is primarily a manifestation of the increasing relative importance of the noise component: for channels where TB is low, the spectrum becomes 'whiter' (i.e. the spectrum flattens). In the case of the SW region, the variation of TB is very large and we see that the variations of TB are not reflected by similar variations of γ, which appears to have a limiting slope of approximately −3. This is close to that expected from a Kolmogorov flow. 4.3. The SPS as a function of velocity slice thickness We now investigate the extent to which velocity fluc- tuations affect the apparent SPS of the Hi intensity dis- tribution by applying the VCA technique (Lazarian & Pogosyan 2000) to Hi data cube subsets averaged over a range of velocity intervals, which is just the measure- ment of γ(∆v). As the VCA technique assumes that the morphology of the original dataset is quite homogeneous over the velocity range of interest, we will apply the VCA analysis only over selected contiguous velocity windows for which the SPS index is approximately constant to fa- cilitate comparison with theoretical models. In doing so, we avoid mixing kinematically different regions. Unfor- tunately, choosing velocity windows limits the available velocity thickness range considerably. Velocity windows used for this analysis are shown as shaded bands in Fig. 6. We selected regions with roughly constant γ(v, ∆v = 1.6 km s−1) and mean Hi brightness temperature (& 4 K) as a sample of relatively homoge- neous regions. There is no usefully large velocity range over which the power-law index is particularly constant in the NW region, so we do not attempt to measure γ(∆v) in this subregion. Quantitatively, the ranges selected for each region follow: North West: None North East: 196 -- 230 km s−1 South West: 143 -- 203 km s−1 7 Fig. 5. -- Sample SPS from each of the four regions (marked in upper left) shown in Fig. 1. These spectra are typically well fitted by a single component power-law. Error bars indicate one standard deviation and those showing downward pointing arrows indicate a large lower error limit. South East: 156 -- 194 km s−1 The variation of the SPS power-law index as a function of velocity slice thickness for the three regions is shown in Fig. 7. Generally, γ(∆v) becomes steeper with increas- ing velocity thickness for all three regions. This trend agrees with predictions by Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) and suggests that both density and velocity fluctuations contribute to the measured Hi intensity fluctuations for thin slices. The selected range of velocity channels for the SE region is narrower than that of the SW region; however over the common range, γ(∆v) is very similar. This suggests that turbulence has comparable character- istics in the two southern regions although, the power-law index derived for the NE region appears very different. Over the whole range of ∆v the slope for the NE region is significantly shallower than the slope of the southern regions. It is interesting to note that for all three regions γ(∆v) starts to converge a constant value around ∆v ∼ 10 km s−1. Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) predicted that the presence of gas at different temperatures will show a characteristic 'turn-over' in γ(∆v). This slight 'turn- over' of γ, seen in Fig. 6, around ∆v ∼ 10 km s−1could be an indication of a significant contribution from warm gas with temperature < 103 K. In contrast, we do not see a similar converging trend for small values of ∆v end of this plot. Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) suggests that typically for cold Hi ∆v ∼ 2.6km s−1 would be enough to approach the asymp- totic value for 'thin' slices (our thinest channel is 1.65 km s−1 wide). Together with the observed turn-over at ∆v ∼ 10, the lack of convergence for small ∆v sug- gests that Hi in the MB is primarily in the warm neutral phase. However, absorption observations of a number of continuum sources throughout the MB made by Kob- ulnicky & Dickey (1999), have revealed the presence of cold (< 20K) clouds. This cold phase is probably only a small fraction of the MB ISM and as such, the mech- anisms responsible for preserving the cold component in equilibrium with the warmer ambient ISM remain to be explained. 4.4. Spatial power as a function of azimuthal angle By examining the power as a function of azimuthal angle, we can probe for any structure anisotropy of the MB Hi dataset. Any such anisotropies will manifest in the Fourier plane as significant structure as a function of phase, with excess power aligned aproximately in the direction perpendicular to that of the structure bias in the un-transformed image. Such azimuthal anisotropy could result from directionally-specific peturbations, for example, the effects of a magnetic field (Esquivel et al. 2003), which may act to organise the ISM by shaping the ionised or dusty component. Fig. 8 shows the mean power as a function of azimuthal angle across spatial scales 100-600λ of the Fourier trans- form for the Hi integrated intensity distribution of each of the four subregions. We find no evidence for any az- imuthal anisotropy in the Fourier plane, despite the fil- 8 Muller et al. Fig. 6. -- Variation of the index γ (P(k)∝kγ ) as a function of velocity for all four regions (marked in upper left) is plotted here as the solid line with error bars (left axis). The total integrated Hi brightness is over plotted as the dotted line (right axis). The shaded regions are those over which the power index is relatively constant and are the subjects for the study of the variation of spatial power-law index with integrated velocity thickness in Section 4.3. The velocity intervals shown here are those for which γ< ∼0 i.e. those channels which are not dominated by noise. The horizontal dot-dashed line marks the RMS TB for each subregion, as measured in line-free parts of the cube. amentary and apparently east-west orientation appear- ance of the Hi distribution in the southern regions shown in Fig. 1. It is likely that the dynamic range of any structure in the Hi images is insufficient to manifest as features in the Fourier transform: for such a feature to be distinct it is necessary to have a power at least 2 -- 3 orders of magnitude larger than the surrounding structure. This is equivalent to an integrated temperature difference of 10-30 K.km s−1. The apparent East-West structure of Fig. 1 shows an integrated brightness range significantly smaller than this, typically only ∼2 -- 5K.km s−1 less than the ambient and less structured Hi. In addition, these structures are not particularly well defined, which will dilute the overall effect. 5. THE SPECTRAL CORRELATION FUNCTION ANALYSES The motivation for the use of the SCF here is intended as a benchmark, by which we can compare the outcomes of the SCF and the SPS on the same dataset, and to test the response of the SCF on a purely tidally-generated system and in comparision to previous SCF studies of the LMC (Padoan et al, 2001). in the following way (see also Rosolowsky et al. 1999; Padoan, Rosolowsky, & Goodman, 2001): S0,N (r) (cid:19) S0(r, ∆r) =(cid:18) S0(r, ∆r) with the numerator being defined by: (1) S0(r, ∆r) =(cid:18)1 −s Pv[T (r, v) − T (r + ∆r, v)]2 Pv T (r, v)2 +Pv T (r + ∆r, v)2(cid:19) The noise term in the denominator is defined for the subject spectrum, T (r, v), by: S0,N (r) = 1 − 1 Q(r) where Q(r) is the spectrum 'quality' and is given by: Q(r) = T 2(r, v) (2) 1 RsXv and R is the RMS in signal free parts of the cube. We aim to generate maps of the spatial variation of S0(r,∆r), for a number of regions in the Hi MB dataset. The algorithm used is outlined below: 5.1. Derivation of the SCF The algorithm used here to calculate the SCF is that employed by Padoan et al. (2001) for the study of the Hi intensity distribution in the LMC. The SCF is defined 1. Dataset Selection. A square region of a side with N pixels is defined within the data cube. The SCF is calculated iteratively using every spectrum in this region in turn as the subject spectrum. 9 Fig. 7. -- Modification to the SPS index as a result of successively thicker velocity averaging for three of the four subregions shown in Fig. 1. The SPS index of the North East region is quite distinct from the two southern regions and changes more rapidly at narrower velocity intervals than does the southern regions. 2. Calculate S0(r, ∆r) map. A new larger region of an area of (2N − 1)2 is defined with the subject spectrum at the centre. The S0(r,∆r) for each spectrum in this region is calculated relative to the centre subject pixel. This process forms a two di- mensional map, where the value at each point is proportional to the similarity of the spectrum to that of the centre spectrum. The value for the cen- tre pixel in this SCF map is unity and all other pixel values are ≤1. This map is stored for subse- quent averaging. 3. Iteration and averaging. Step 2 from above is re- peated for each pixel in the initial N × N region of interest. Ultimately, a total of N 2 maps are ob- tained, each having an area of (2N − 1)2. The final result is determined by finding the mean for all of the calculated SCF maps: S(∆r)= (cid:10)S0(r,∆r)(cid:11)r This approach requires a 'buffer' of spectra, at least N pixels wide around the region of interest. Without this buffer, there is not a uniform sampling population for each pixel of the SCF map and edge effects become important. The numbering in Fig. 3 shows the grid ref- erence of the centre square region defining the subject spectra (step 1 above). S0(r,∆r) is calculated for all spectra within each box relative to all spectra within 20 pixels (step 2 above) and then averaged over all 212 pix- els in that map (step 3). Overall, we obtain 8 different maps of S0(∆r) from this dataset. 5.2. Results of the SCF analyses The results for the SCF analysis are shown Fig. 9. The left-hand panels show the eight SCF maps, correspond- ing to each of the labeled regions in Fig. 3. Note that the maps contain significant structure, so that simply calculating S0 as a function of ∆r = px2 + y2 (i.e. the azimuthally-averaged approach taken by Padoan et al. 2001) does not characterise the S0(∆r) appropri- ately. As such, the right-hand panels of Fig. 9 show the behaviour of S0(∆r) along the major and minor axes of the elliptical contours. The map is clearly anisotropic and indicates some structure bias present in the organ- isation of the gas in the MB. In particular, the major axes of the ellipses appear to be generally aligned with direction of filamentary structure in the MB. In order to interpret the SCF maps, we have fitted an elliptical power-law function to the distribution. We modeled the typical S0 surface using a function with pa- rameters ci: f (x, y) = c0(x2 + y2)β/2, where (3) β = c1 cos2 (φ − c3) + c2 sin2 (φ − c3) , c1 ≥ c2, and φ = arctan(y/x) This function characterises the S0 surface with two sep- arate power-laws falling off in orthogonal directions from ∆r = 0 with indices c1 (major axis) and c2 (minor axis) respectively. The angle c3 represents the orientation of these axes with respect to the coordinate axes. The data S0(x, y) are weighted inversely proportional to their dis- 10 Muller et al. Fig. 8. -- The variation of power in the Fourier transform of an integrated intensity map for each of the four regions is plotted here as diamonds. The log of Power is shown as a function of azimuthal angle. The dotted circle shows the mean power for this baseline interval. Error bars of one standard deviation show that there is no convincing consistent deviation from the dotted circle, and no indication of coherent structure in the Fourier transformed data for any of the four regions. tance from S0(0, 0). The singularity at f (0, 0) for nega- tive values of c1 and c2 is ignored. We fit the function f to S0 for every position that is completely sampled. Padoan, Goodman, & Juvela (2003) point out a rela- tionship between the power-law scaling of S0(∆r) and the line width of the spectra considered. We find no such correlation present in the MB Hi data, however, the 13CO molecular cloud data used by Padoan, Goodman, & Ju- vela (2003) are systems with well defined size -- line width relationships and where such line profiles can typically be described with only a single component. In contrast, the Hi data used here are complex, and show multiple velocity components for any line-of-sight (e.g. McGee & Newton, 1986; Muller et al. 2003) There is evidence for a correlation between the power- law index of the SCF and the integrated intensity. This is most notable when step 3 of the SCF processing is omit- ted and the major and minor axes are derived by fitting without averaging. Fig. 10 shows this correlation with respect to the major axis index, c1, for all points outside the 21 pixel buffer at the edge of the map. The correla- tion is not outstanding, but appears to obey a power-law such that c1 ∝ (R TAdv)0.5±0.1. Padoan, Rosolowsky, & Goodman (2001) note that higher density gas appears to be traced by a steeper power-law slope. However, this effect may be due to different spatial distributions for different molecular tracers. 6. DISCUSSION OF STATISTICAL RESULTS 6.1. Spatial Power Spectrum We find that the SPS of the Hi intensity distribution in the MB can be well described by a single power-law func- tion over a wide range of spatial scales (29 pc to at least 2 kpc). As in the case of the SMC (Stanimirovi´c et. al, 11 Fig. 9. -- Results of SCF analysis on the Hi in the MB for grids (2,2) -- (5,2) (left panel; see Fig. 3) and for grids (6,2) -- (9,2) (right panel). The left part of each panel shows the map of S0(∆r) according to the SCF algorithm in the text. The right part of each panel shows radial plots of S0(∆r). The two cuts indicated in the left panel (solid and dashed line) appear in the right panel for the major (black) and minor (gray) axes of the elliptical S0 map respectively. We see that without exception, the ellipses are aligned with the major axis (i.e. the more slowly changing axis) approximately East-West. Each panel is annotated to indicate the corresponding Hi subset defined on Fig. 3. 1999a,b), no significant changes to the power-law shape of the SPS were found when varying heliocentric velocity or the thickness of velocity channels, though the power- law index varies significantly. This indicates that the MB is likely to have a large line-of-sight depth. In con- trast, the SPS derived from the Hi intensity distribution in the LMC showed a break at the spatial scale equiv- alent to ∼100 pc (Elmegreen, Kim & Staveley-Smith, 2001) which was interpreted as evidence for the finite thickness of the LMC disk. However, the SMC and the MB have large-scale morphologies which are distinctly different from the LMC, namely that they are not ap- proximately face-on systems and have a substantial line- of-sight depth. There is a clear variation of γ(∆v) over the range of velocity widths considered, and the NE section of the analysis has qualitatively different variation than the SW and SE sections. Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000) relate the measured variations of γ(∆v) to physical properties of the turbulence, a particular strength of SPS analysis. In particular, γ(∆v) can be related to the indices of the three-dimensional power spectra of the density and ve- locity fluctuations. If the density fluctuation power spec- trum is a power law with index of n and the velocity fluctuation power spectrum has an index of µ the rela- tionships between γ, n and µ are given in Table 1 for n > −3 (Shallow 3-D density) and n < −3 (Steep 3-D density). Following the description of Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000): if we assume that the smallest ∆v traces 'thin' velocity slices and that the largest ∆v corresponds to 'thick' velocity slices, we can estimate the factor by which the velocity fluctuations modify the SPS density spec- trum. The derived values for the slopes of the density and velocity spectra are listed in Table 2. These values are given as upper and lower limits since asymptotic so- lutions were not fully met, especially at the lower ∆v end. Similarly, if we assume that the thickest velocity slices used in the study of Section 4.3 are probing the pure density-dominated regime of Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000), then the 3-D density index for the SW region has a lower limit of n ≈ −3.4, indicating that this region is in the velocity-dominated regime. Using the SPS index for the thinnest velocity slice of this region leads to a lower limit estimate of the velocity fluctuations µ ≈ −4 (Table 2). Similarly for the NE region, the SPS index for thickest velocity slice has a lower limit of n ≈ −2.9, 12 Muller et al. Fig. 10. -- Correlation between integrated intensity and the major axis power-law index c1 for the SCF. The correlation includes only those pixels sufficiently far from the edge of the map to avoid edge effects. The solid line plots the best fitting correlation c1 ∝ (R TAdv)0.5±0.1 . γ Shallow 3-D density Steep 3-D density Thin slice (∆v small) Thick slice (∆v large) Very Thick Slice (∆v very large) n − µ/2 − 3/2 n n −9/2 − µ/2 −3/2 + µ/2 n The value of the observed power-law index γ for different values of ∆v in different turbulent regimes. n is the static spatial power law index of the turbulence which is modified by velocity fluctuations with a slope of µ (Lazarian & Pogosyan, 2000). TABLE 1 indicating that this region is in the density-dominated regime and that velocity fluctuations are small in this region. The derived 3-D velocity index has an upper limit of µ ∼ −4.5 and is extremely steep, indicating an overwhelming deficiency of high-velocity fluctuations. The steepening of the SPS slope with increasing in- tegrated velocity thickness, as predicted by Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000), was also measured from Hi in the SMC (Stanimirovi´c & Lazarian 2001) and for a test region in the Galaxy (Dickey et al. 2001). Table 2 shows that the slopes for the southern two regions in the MB are gen- erally similar to those derived for the SMC which has a n = −3.3 and µ = −3.4 (Stanimirovic & Lazarian 2001). Both the SMC and the MB appear to have power-law indices that are more shallow that what is predicted for a Kolmogorov turbulent spectrum. For the case of Hi in the Galaxy a shift of the SPS slope from about −3 to −4 after velocity integration was noticed by Dickey et al. (2001). Other studies of the LMC (Elmegreen, Kim & Staveley-Smith 2001) and the Magellanic Stream (Stanimirovi´c et al. 2002) also show apparent steepening of the power spectra with increasing integrated velocity thickness. A different interpretation of the power-law SPS in the case of the SMC was provided by Goldman (2000) whereby a featureless SPS was interpreted as a signature of turbulence being driven on spatial scales larger than the size of the SMC. This turbulence was induced by lo- cal instabilities due to tidal interactions in the Magellanic System. This approach also defines the relationship be- tween the 2-d intensity and 3-d density statistics, where the Power-law index of intensity fluctuations, γ, is re- lated to the power-law index of density fluctuations, n, by γ = n+ 1. In the MB case studied here, this approach will result in n ∼ −4 for the Southern two regions, and n ∼ −3.2 for the North-East region. The second important result from these studies of the MB, is that the slopes of the SPS derived for the northern and southern regions appear to be strikingly different: the northern part shows a distinctly shallower (although still monotonic) power spectrum, indicating a relative lack of large-scale power (or equivalently, an excess of small scale power). Furthermore, these results could be interpreted as evidence for a warm (∼103 K) component. This is slightly perplexing, given the results of absorption detections which indicate the presence for a very cool 13 γ T hin γ T hick (= n) µ 3-D Velocity (upper limit) (lower limit) (upper limit) 3-D Density South East −3.05±0.06 South West −2.94±0.04 North East −2.24±0.03 −3.4±0.2 −3.4±0.2 −2.9±0.2 −3.6±0.3 −3.9±0.2 −4.5±0.4 SPS indices for thickest and thinnest velocity slices for the three sampled regions in the MB (SE, SW and NE regions of Fig. 1). The degree by which two-dimensional velocity fluctuations affect the SPS index are shown, along with the estimated 3-D velocity index (see Lazarian & Pogosyan, 2000 and Table 1). TABLE 2 (∼20 K) component. Muller et al. (2003) have observed that at least two distinctly different Hi velocity components exist through- out the MB, being centered on about 150 and 190 km s−1 (see also Fig. 2). Furthermore, the two components are distinct in declination: the higher velocity component is predominantly at northerly declinations and is sampled by the NE and NW regions, while the lower velocity com- ponent is sampled by the SE and SW regions. Numerical simulations (Gardiner, Sawa & Noguchi, 1994) suggest that the two velocity components could be associated with arms extending from the SMC. In this model, the more distant arm is projected as a higher ve- locity and slightly northern feature, while the nearer arm correlates with lower velocity component. The nearer arm is clearly contiguous with the SMC and LMC may be more properly regarded as 'The Magellanic Bridge'. The distances to these two arms have been predicted by Gardiner, Sawa & Noguchi (1994) to be centered at 50 and 70 kpc, with an expected line-of-sight depth for both entities of ∼5 -- 10 kpc. We propose that as an explanation for the differences in the behavior of the power indices of the northern and southern regions in Figs. 6 & 7, these regions encompass two separate and distinct arms of the SMC. We view the arms projected approximately on top of one another, whereas these features are not well spa- tially connected at all. 6.2. Spectral Correlation Function Like the SPS, the SCF shows a logarithmic dependence of scale which can be parameterised with a single compo- nent. We do not expect the slopes of the SCF and SPS to be consistent, since the SPS probes structure in excess of the mean, large scale power (i.e. that represented by the zero lag), whereas the SCF algorithm, as used here and by Padoan et al. (2000), does not factor for a mean brightness level which will otherwise tend to flatten the SCF slope. Interestingly, the SCF slopes derived here for the MB dataset are largely consistent with those de- rived from the Hi in the LMC (S0(∆r) ∼ −0.15 - −0.4; Padoan et al, 2001). The lack of radial symmetry in the maps of S0(∆r) is itself an interesting result. It appears then that the SCF is more successful in detecting structure trends over a smaller dynamic range than the approach using the Fourier transform and the SPS in Section 4. The obvious structure in the approximate East-West direction (i.e. the line joining the SMC and LMC) indi- cates a more persistent similarity of spectra along that direction. What we see here is that the rate of change of the entire spectra (rather than a single velocity channel, or integrated brightness) across the entire sampled ve- locity range is more gradual in the East-West direction than in the North-South direction. We interpret the East-West S0(∆r) structure as a re- sult of the tidal stretching imposed by the LMC-SMC in- teraction, although in this case the morphology of the Hi is already visually suggestive of this process. We should also bear in mind that the brightest parts of the dataset can dominate the SCF results, biasing steeper power-law indices and the overall structure of the SCF maps. A floating temperature scaling factor in the SCF algorithm would probably go some way to removing this bias. We note that there is no evidence for a break in the Bridge SCF power law, as was found for the LMC at ∼100 pc, although these two objects are widely sepa- rated in space and there is no outstanding reason that they should share a common morphology at that scale. However, since a typical width of the structures in the filaments is ∼ 100 pc in the plane of the sky, and we do not see a departure from a power law on this scale, this may be another indication of significant line-of-sight depth in the Bridge. We see in Fig. 9 that there may be some evidence for a consistent break in the power-law for both the major and the minor axes, at ∼300 -- 500 pc. However, this departure occurs at scales which are comparable to the maximum size of the tested areas (i.e. ∼500 pc). The degree to which the boundary and size of the sample affects the SCF has not been well studied, and it is probable that the departure is influenced by the edge of the sample region. As such, any interpretation for the reasons of the observed departure at this scales should be made with caution. It is not appropriate to simply expand the spatial size of the sampled areas since this would sample data which is excessively dominated by noise and the SCF algorithm will be affected unpre- dictably. In this study, we did not attempt to study the be- haviour of the SCF in a similar way to that used by the velocity-component analysis (VCA), namely, measuring the modification to the SCF as a function of varying ve- locity integrated width. As the SCF operates in the im- age domain, we expect that by averaging across the ve- locity fluctuating component the SCF will flatten some- what, and that there will be some correlation of the SCF slope with velocity integrated width. However, to con- duct this test appropriately, a study with a well charac- terized dataset should be used, rather than the complex 14 Muller et al. Hi profiles of Magellanic Bridge dataset. 7. SUMMARY We have attempted two statistical analyses of the fila- mentary Hi in the Magellanic Bridge. Together with the fact that there also appears to be an identifiable disconti- nuity in the velocity distribution of the Hi in the MB, the most significant result from the calculation of the spatial power spectrum (SPS) here has provided support for a scenario suggested by numerical simulations, where the southern and northern parts of the Bridge represent the projection of two distinct arms of gas emanating from the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). These findings suggest that we now need to re-assess the current interpretation of the Bridge as a single filamentary feature. Similarly to the SMC, the power spectra throughout the MB are well described as a power law with a sin- gle power component. In particular, the southern region which contains brighter and more turbulent Hi, have 3- d density and velocity indices similar to that which was found for the SMC. The more tenuous and higher veloc- ity (i.e. northern) parts show a significantly shallower SPS, with the 3-d density slope of −2.9. This is indica- tive of relatively quiescent gas. The 3-d velocity index (−4.5) of this region is significantly steeper that for the case of a Kolmogorov turbulent flow. We find that the a velocity component analysis (VCA) of the Hi in the MB behaves, on the whole, according to predictions by Lazarian & Pogosyan (2000), where mod- ifications to the power spectra by velocity fluctuations can be removed by integrating over a velocity window. This has again highlighted the dissimilarities between the northern and southern parts of the MB. The contribu- tions by velocity fluctuations to the southern part of the MB are again similar to those in the SMC, whereas the SPS from the northern part of the MB shows evidence for a very steep three-dimensional velocity index and a lack of rapid velocity fluctuations. A study of the azimuthal isotropy of the Fourier trans- form of the Hi dataset does not show any such East-West structure which is apparent in the Hi peak and integrated intensity maps. It is likely that the dynamic range of the Fourier transformed dataset is insufficient to distinguish any such structure tends from the ambient Hi. Con- versely, the spectral correlation function (SCF), due to the nature of the algorithm, is much more successful in indicating more subtle, local trends in structure. The analysis using the SCF has shown more quantita- tively the effects of tidal stretching on this dataset. It confirms that the observed Hi spectra in this region vary more slowly along the approximate direction of the tidal stretching. Although limitations of the application of the SCF has confined the region sampled to the bright- est parts of the MB, the SCF shows enormous potential as a tool for more easily parameterising suspect tidal features, insofar as the direction and extent of the tidal perturbation. Although the behavior of the SCF cannot be directly related to the physical properties of the underlying tur- bulence, the SCF provides some provocative results. We see that, like for the SPS, the SCF shows a power-law dependence with indices compatible with previous stud- ies of the LMC Hi datset. However, the results from the SCF analysis also hint at a characteristic scale length, which is not observed in the SPS of the same region and are not at scales consistent with the studies of the LMC. It is important to bear in mind that the departure ob- served here is at the limits of the sampled scale range and any interpretation should be made carefully. How- ever, we can conclude that the SCF and the SPS do not appear to measure structure variations in the same way. Specifically, the SCF appears to be much more sensitive to low-power and small scale variations in structure. It will be necessary to explicitly test and compare behav- iors of the SCF and SPS to different turbulence types before the full application of the SCF can be recognized. 8. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The Authors would like to thank Alex Lazarian for his time in reading the draft and providing helpful sug- gestions for improvement. The Arecibo Observatory is part of the National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center, which is operated by Cornell University under a cooper- ative agreement with the National Science Foundation. SS acknowledges support by NSF grants AST-0097417 and AST 9981308. REFERENCES Crovisier, J., Dickey, J. M. 1983, A&A, 122, 282 Dickey, J. M., McClure-Griffiths, N. M., Stanimirovi´c, S., Gaensler, Miville-Deschenes, M.-A., Levrier, F., & Falgarone, E. 2003, ApJ, 593, 831 B. M., & Green, A. J. 2001, ApJ, 561, 264 Muller, E., Staveley-Smith, L., Zealey, W., & Stanimirovi´c, S. 2003, Elmegreen, B. G., Kim, S., & Staveley-Smith, L. 2001, ApJ, 548, MNRAS, 339, 105 749 Elmegreen, B. G.,Scalo, J.,2004 astro-ph/0404451 Esquivel, A., Lazarian, A., Pogosyan, D., & Cho, J. 2003, MNRAS, 342, 325 Gardiner, L. T. & Noguchi, M. 1996, MNRAS, 278, 191 Gardiner, L. T., Sawa, T., Fujimoto, M. 1994, MNRAS, 266,567 Green, D. A. 1993, MNRAS, 262, 327 Goldman, I. 2000, ApJ, 541, 701 Kerr, F. J., Hindman, J. F., Robinson, B. J. 1954, Aust. Jp. 7, 297 Kobulnicky, H. A., Dickey, J. M., 1999, AJ, 117, 908 Lazarian, A. & Esquivel, A. 2003, ApJ, 592, L37 Lazarian, A. & Pogosyan, D. 2000, ApJ, 537, 720 Mathewson, D. S., Schwarz, M. P., & Murray, J. D. 1977, ApJ, 217, L5 Padoan, P., Goodman, A. A., & Juvela, M. 2003, ApJ, 588, 881 Padoan, P., Kim, S., Goodman, A., & Staveley-Smith, L. 2001, ApJ, 555, L33 Padoan, P., Rosolowsky, E. W., & Goodman, A. A. 2001, ApJ, 547, 862 Rosolowsky, E. W., Goodman, A. A., Wilner, D. J., & Williams, J. P. 1999, ApJ, 524, 887 Ruzicka, A., 2003, A&SS, 484, 519 Scalo, J., Elmegreen, B. G., 2004 astro-ph/0404452 Stanimirovi´c, S., Dickey, J. M., Krco, M., & Brooks, A. M. 2002, ApJ, 576, 773 Stanimirovi´c, S. & Lazarian, A. 2001, ApJ, 551, L53 Stanimirovic, S., Staveley-Smith, L., Dickey, J. M., Sault, R. J., & Snowden, S. L. 1999a, MNRAS, 302, 417 McGee, R. X., Newton, L. M., 1986, PASAu, 6,471 Minter, A. 2002, ASP Conf. Ser. 276: Seeing Through the Dust: The Detection of HI and the Exploration of the ISM in Galaxies, 221 Stanimirovic, S., Staveley-Smith, L., Sault, R. J., Dickey, J. M., & Snowden, S. L. 1999a, IAU Symp. 190: New Views of the Magellanic Clouds, 190, 103 Stanimirovi´c, S., Weisberg, J., Dickey, J. M., de la Fuente, A., Devine, K., Hedden, A., & Anderson, S. B. 2003, ApJ, 592, 953 Stanimirovi´c, S, PHDT, University of Western Sydney, 1999 Stavely-Smith, L., Kim, S., Putman, M., & Stanimirovi´c, S. 1998, Reviews of Modern Astronomy, 11, 117 15
astro-ph/0604381	1	0604	2006-04-18T15:14:23	Quiet Sun magnetic fields from simultaneous inversions of visible and infrared spectropolarimetric observations	[ "astro-ph" ]	We study the quiet Sun magnetic fields using spectropolarimetric observations of the infrared and visible Fe I lines at 6301.5, 6302.5, 15648 and 15653 A. Magnetic field strengths and filling factors are inferred by the simultaneous fit of the observed Stokes profiles under the MISMA hypothesis. The observations cover an intra-network region at the solar disk center. We analyze 2280 Stokes profiles whose polarization signals are above noise in the two spectral ranges, which correspond to 40% of the field of view. Most of these profiles can be reproduced only with a model atmosphere including 3 magnetic components with very different field strengths, which indicates the co-existence of kG and sub-kG fields in our 1.5" resolution elements. We measure an unsigned magnetic flux density of 9.6 G considering the full field of view. Half of the pixels present magnetic fields with mixed polarities in the resolution element. The fraction of mixed polarities increases as the polarization weakens. We compute the probability density function of finding each magnetic field strength. It has a significant contribution of kG field strengths, which concentrates most of the observed magnetic flux and energy. This kG contribution has a preferred magnetic polarity, while the polarity of the weak fields is balanced.	astro-ph	astro-ph	DRAFT VERSION MAY 13, 2018 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 6/22/04 QUIET SUN MAGNETIC FIELDS FROM SIMULTANEOUS INVERSIONS OF VISIBLE AND INFRARED SPECTROPOLARIMETRIC OBSERVATIONS I. DOMÍNGUEZ CERDEÑA Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Spain J. SÁNCHEZ ALMEIDA Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Spain AND F. KNEER Institut für Astrophysik, Friedrich-Hund-Platz 1, D-37077 Göttingen, Germany (Dated: ) Draft version May 13, 2018 ABSTRACT We study the quiet Sun magnetic fields using spectropolarimetric observations of the infrared and visible Fe I lines at 6301.5, 6302.5, 15648 and 15653 Å. Magnetic field strengths and filling factors are inferred by the simultaneous fit of the observed Stokes profiles under the MISMA hypothesis. The observations cover an intra-network region at the solar disk center. We analyze 2280 Stokes profiles whose polarization signals are above noise in the two spectral ranges, which correspond to 40% of the field of view. Most of these profiles can be reproduced only with a model atmosphere including 3 magnetic components with very different field strengths, which indicates the co-existence of kG and sub-kG fields in our 1.′′5 resolution elements. We measure an unsigned magnetic flux density of 9.6 G considering the full field of view. Half of the pixels present magnetic fields with mixed polarities in the resolution element. The fraction of mixed polarities increases as the polarization weakens. We compute the probability density function of finding each magnetic field strength. It has a significant contribution of kG field strengths, which concentrates most of the observed magnetic flux and energy. This kG contribution has a preferred magnetic polarity, while the polarity of the weak fields is balanced. Subject headings: Sun: magnetic fields -- Sun: photosphere 1. INTRODUCTION The quiet Sun can be defined as that part of the Sun far from magnetic activity. If we exclude plages and network, the remaining quiet area covers 90% of the surface of the Sun, and remains almost unchanged during the solar cycle (e.g., Harvey-Angle 1993). Few decades ago, this internetwork (IN) was thought to be almost devoid of magnetic fields and consequently, its relevance for the solar magnetism was not obvious (Livingston & Harvey 1975; Smithson 1975). How- ever, with the present instrumentation, when the spatial reso- lution is around 1′′, the quiet Sun turns out to be full of mag- netic fields (Grossmann-Doerth et al. 1996; Lin & Rimmele 1999; Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000), with an unsigned flux density measured with techniques based on the Zeeman effect of the order of 10 G (e.g., Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000; Lites 2002). The analysis of observations with a spatial resolution twice better yields an unsigned flux twice larger (Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003a)1. There are reasons to believe that these resolutions are not enough to completely resolve the magnetic structures (see Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003b, and references therein). Recent measurements based on the Hanle effect find an unsigned flux of, at least, 60 G (Trujillo Bueno et al. 2004; Bommier et al. 2005), which is much higher than the magnetic flux observed with Zeeman techniques. Considering the fraction of solar surface corre- Electronic address: [email protected] Electronic address: [email protected] Electronic address: [email protected] 1 However, see Lites & Socas-Navarro (2004). sponding to the quiet Sun, the flux measured in the IN is com- parable to (or larger than) that coming from all active regions even in the maximum of activity. Thus, the quiet Sun may play a significant role in the physical processes governing the solar global magnetism (e.g., Unno 1959; Stenflo 1982; Sánchez Almeida 2003a; Schrijver & Title 2003). The topology and the scale of variation of the quiet Sun magnetic fields are not yet clear. There is evidence for the existence of mixed polarities, at least when the spatial resolu- tion is 1′′ (Sánchez Almeida et al. 1996; Sigwarth et al. 1999; Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000; Lites 2002; Khomenko et al. 2003). The small-scale magnetic structures in the quiet Sun seem to be smaller than 50 -- 100 km (see Khomenko et al. 2003; Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003b). This size assumes one single structure in the resolution element, however, it is to be expected that the dynamical influence of the gran- ulation on the magnetic fields produces a distribution of many smaller structures. This fragmentation shows up in MHD simulations of turbulent dynamos (Cattaneo 1999; Emonet & Cattaneo 2001), and 3D magneto-convection (e.g., Stein & Nordlund 2002; Vögler 2003; Vögler et al. 2005). Recently, Cameron & Galloway (2005) studied various mech- anisms proposed to produce intense magnetic concentrations and limited the radii of the magnetic flux tubes to less than 10 km, which is approximately the magnetic diffusion length scale (Schüssler 1986). This scenario was already proposed by Sánchez Almeida et al. (1996) with an atmosphere formed by optically thin magnetic structures with diverse proper- ties (see also Sánchez Almeida 1998). Such a scheme is called MISMA (Micro-Structured Magnetized Atmosphere). 2 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer An inversion procedure based on it has been able to fit the whole variety of asymmetric Stokes profiles2 produced by the quiet Sun magnetic fields (Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000; Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida 2002). 1999; Sigwarth et al. Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida Observational studies based on infrared (IR) spectral lines find magnetic field strengths in the range below 1 kG (sub-kG; Lin & Rimmele 1999; Khomenko et al. 2003), while works using lines in the visible spectral (Grossmann-Doerth et al. range tend to find kG fields Sánchez Almeida & Lites 1996; 2000; 2002; Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003a,b; Lites & Socas-Navarro 2004). Kilogauss fields are also inferred from the presence of a considerable number of G-band bright points in the quiet Sun (Sánchez Almeida et al. 2004; de Wijn et al. 2005). Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) put forward a solution for this apparent contradiction: the co-existence in the resolution element of a distribution of field strengths going from zero to kG. They show how to reproduce the observed bias with the vertical gradient of the field strength induced by the hydrostatic equilibrium in the atmosphere. Another possi- bility with the same consequences is a horizontal gradient (Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida 2003). The presence of a range of field strengths from sub-kG to kG fields bias the measurements based on IR Stokes profiles to sub-kG fields. Such a particular behavior is due to the high sensitivity of the IR lines to magnetic fields. The Fe I λ15648 Å (used by Lin & Rimmele 1999; Khomenko et al. 2003) is magnetically saturated3 at 400 G while the visible pair Fe I λ6301.5 Å, Fe I λ6302.5 Å (e.g., used by Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000; Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003a) saturates at 1.5 kG. The IR polarization signals coming from the strongest fields are spread in a wide range of wavelengths and they produce little signal. On the contrary, weak fields saturate the IR line and a significant Stokes V signal is built up in a narrow wavelength range. Weak field and strong field components appear in the same wavelengths in the visible lines so that their relative contribution is proportional to their magnetic flux. The weak field component can dominate over the strong component in the IR Stokes V profiles, while the strong fields dominate over the weak ones in the visible profiles. Thus, an incomplete analysis of the IR profiles leads to weak fields, whereas the same analysis of the visible lines shows strong fields. In order to test this conjecture, Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a) presented simultaneous spectropolarimetric observations in the visible and IR ranges. An independent Milne-Eddington inversion of the visible and IR lines suggests the co-existence of sub-kG and kG fields. However, a more sophisticated and simultaneous inversion is desirable to provide further support to the conjecture of Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) and Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2003). This paper presents such simultaneous inversions under the MISMA approximation of the visible and the infrared Stokes profiles used in Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a). As we dis- cuss above, it seems to be appropriate for reproducing the 2 We use the standard Stokes parameters to define the polarization state: I for the intensity, Q and U for the two orthonormal states of lineal polariza- tion and V for the circular polarization. The Stokes profiles of a spectral line give the variation with wavelength of these four parameters. If the spectral line is formed in a homogeneous atmosphere, the Stokes profiles are expected to be symmetric or antisymmetric (e.g., Landi Degl'Innocenti 1992). 3 The Stokes V signals no longer have a linear relationship with the mag- netic field strength. The level of polarization stays constant while the splitting of the Stokes V lobes grows in proportion to the field strength. ATOMIC PARAMETERS OF THE LINES UNDER STUDY. TABLE 1 Wavelength [Å] χ [eV]a Ag f b Transitionc 6301.499d 6302.492d 15648.515e 15652.874e 3.65 3.69 5.426 6.246 9.766·10- 6 2.630·10- 6 8.035·10- 6 3.443·10- 5 5P2 5P1 7D1 7D5 5D2 5D0 7D1 7D4 gL 1.67 2.5 3 1.53 from Moore et al. (1966) and Kurucz aExcitation potential (1994). bAbundance of Fe times statistical weight of the lower level times oscillator strength from Gurtovenko & Kostik (1981, visible lines) and from Borrero et al. (2003, IR lines). cSpectral terms from Nave et al. (1994). dWavelengths from Higgs (1962). eWavelengths from Nave et al. (1994). complex Stokes profiles produced by the quiet Sun. Section 2 summarizes the observations and the data reduction. Some properties of interest of the magnetograms obtained in the two spectral ranges are shown in § 3. The strategies for the data analysis and the inversion are explained in § 4. We present the results in § 5 whose consistency is analyzed in § 6. A final § 7 discusses the main conclusions. 2. OBSERVATIONS AND DATA REDUCTION We re-analyze the spectra used by Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a) whose properties are only sketched in the original reference. For the sake of comprehensiveness, the data and reduction are detailed here. The part of the reduction in which we bring the visible and IR spectra to equal spatial resolution is new. We use two telescopes for the simultaneous visible and IR observation4. The observation was performed at the Span- ish Observatorio del Teide (Tenerife, Spain). The IR spec- tra were gathered with the Tenerife Infrared Polarimeter (TIP, Collados 1999; Martínez Pillet et al. 1999) operated at the German Vacuum Tower Telescope (VTT). Spectrograms of the full Stokes vector (I,Q,U,V ) were obtained in the IR iron lines Fe I λ15648 Å (Landé factor gL=3) and Fe I λ15652 Å (gL=1.53). The visible observations were carried out with the French-Italian telescope THEMIS (Téléscope Heliographique pour l'Étude du Magnétisme et des Instabilités Solaires) using the spectropolarimetric mode MTR (Mein & Rayrole 1985; Rayrole & Mein 1993). The lines analyzed are the pair Fe I λ6301.5 Å (gL=1.66) and Fe I λ6302.5 Å (gL=2.5). The atomic parameters of the four spectral lines are listed in Ta- ble 1. In order to obtain spectra in a two-dimensional field of view (FOV), the solar surface was scanned from East to West with a step size of 0.′′5. The slit width was set to 0.′′5 in both telescopes and the scan consisted in 60 positions. To improve the signal to noise ratio, the integration time was set to 30 s per position. This work analyzes data obtained on August 10 2002 in a quiet Sun region close to disk center (µ = 0.94). We choose a region without magnetic activity as judged with the help of Ca II K and Hα slit-jaw images from video cameras at the VTT. A video link between both telescopes providing the slit- jaw images from VTT at THEMIS was helpful to point both 4 Nowadays, the observation is possible using a single telescope with TIP+POLIS (VTT, Tenerife, see Khomenko et al. 2005) and with SPINOR (DST, Sacramento Peak Observatory, see Socas-Navarro et al. 2005). Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 3 FIG. 1. -- Intensity images in the continuum of the IR lines before (left) and after (middle) smearing, and continuum image of the visible lines (right). The rectangles point out structures that can be easily identified in both the IR and the visible images. Axes are in arcsec from the lower left corner. telescopes to the same target. Since the absolute pointing of the telescopes was not accurate enough, and the slit-jaw im- ages of the granulation did not allow us to recognize the re- gion pointed by the two telescopes, we used another differen- tial method for accurate pointing. First, both telescopes were pointed to a characteristic small structure which could eas- ily be identified, e.g., a small pore. The pointing of the VTT was moved to a quiet Sun region, and then THEMIS pointing was displaced by the same distance. As we explain below, the scans provided by the VTT and THEMIS are post-processed for fine-tuning co-alignment. This final step removes residual pointing errors plus some additional effects (e.g., differential refraction between the visible and the IR). The scan under study here has an offset between telescopes of only 1′′ (see below). Since we scanned with a step size of 0.′′5 and with an exposure time of 30 s per step, the time lag between IR and visible data of the same point corresponds to only 1 minute. The data reduction of the two data sets was carried out in a similar way. A flat-field correction was applied to the spec- tra. In order to get the Stokes parameters, we demodulate the measurements with the calibration matrix, and finally we cor- rect for seeing-induced crosstalk by combining the two beams of each polarimeter. The crosstalk produced by instrumental polarization (IP) of the telescopes themselves was considered too. Since THEMIS is free of IP, the visible data do not need correction. Due to the configuration of mirrors in the VTT, the IR data are affected by an important crosstalk between the different Stokes parameters. It was calibrated with a model Mueller matrix set using a linear polarizer mounted at the en- trance window of the telescope (see Collados 2003). Since the purpose of this work is the simultaneous inver- sion of visible and IR lines, one needs a consistent scale of wavelengths in both spectral ranges. We carried out an abso- lute wavelength calibration so that the lines are unshifted in this scale when the solar plasma is at rest. The central wave- length of Fe I λ6301.5 Å and Fe I λ6302.5 Å was considered to be the zero-crossing of the Stokes V profiles correspond- ing to the signals in the network points of our FOV. Such a reference gives an accuracy of 200 m s- 1 (Solanki 1986). Solanki & Stenflo (1986) find that the zero-crossing wave- CONVECTIVE BLUE SHIFT OF THE SPECTRAL TABLE 2 LINES. line vCB a [m s- 1] vCB b [m s- 1] Fe I λ6301.5 Å Fe I λ6302.5 Å Fe I λ15648 Å Fe I λ15652 Å +50 -80 -370 -430 -100 -150 -400 -400 aFrom synthesis in numerical simulations by (Asplund et al. 2000). bFrom two-component iron Borrero et al. 2003). inversion of many 2002; (Borrero & Bellot Rubio lines length depends on the spectral resolution. Using their sim- ulations, we check that our resolution of 21.9 mÅ per pixel does not threaten the absolute accuracy given above. The strongest polarization signals were chosen to trace the net- work (V > 0.02 Ic with Ic the intensity of the continuum near the lines). Weaker signals tend to be red-shifted. Since this method has not been tested for the IR lines, their absolute wavelengths need another way of calibration. We computed the mean line profile from the data and then corrected for the expected convective blue-shift. We average the Stokes I pro- file over the FOV. The minima of the lines were fitted with fourth order polynomials whose minima were taken as the central wavelengths of the spectral lines. These wavelengths corrected for the convective blue-shifts provide the reference for an atmosphere at rest. Table 2 presents the convective blue-shift for Fe I λ15648 Å and Fe I λ15652 Å obtained from a two-component inversion of many line profiles in the quiet Sun (Borrero et al. 2003) and from line synthesis from numer- ical simulations of granulation (Asplund et al. 2000, private communication). We cannot asses the accuracy of our abso- lute wavelength calibration based on them, however, the fact that the two numerical simulations provide the same convec- tive blue-shift suggests the consistency of the approach. 4 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer FIG. 2. -- Magnetograms from Fe I λ15648 Å (left) and Fe I λ6302.5 Å (right). White and black distinguish the two polarities. Both magnetograms are scaled to flux densities Beff < 20 G. The distance between small tickmarks is 1′′. One of the most important steps in the data reduction is the spatial co-alignment of the visible and IR scans. The aim of this process is to ensure that the scans are not only taken from the same region on the Sun but also that each individual pixel of the visible and IR scans come from the same point of the IN region. The correct alignment must be guaranteed for a mean- ingful analysis of the data, i.e., for the simultaneous interpre- tation of both data sets. In order to align the scans we displace and re-scale them allowing for five degrees of freedom. First, we correct for differences in the spatial scales along the X and Y directions. We define X as the direction of scanning and Y as the direction along the slit. The step width of the scans was slightly different in both telescopes (less than 1%), and the spatial scales along the slit were computed from the focal length of the telescopes. Their (relative) agreement with re- spect to each other were checked using reference images of a sunspot. Then, we found the shift in the X and Y directions by cross-correlation of the visible and IR continuum images. It corresponds to the offset of 1′′ mentioned above. Finally both slits were not exactly oriented with the same angle with respect to the Sun. There was a small rotation of 1◦ which we also determine by cross-correlation. Once the correspon- dence between the visible and IR spatial coordinates was set, we interpolate the visible spectra to obtain the spectra at the positions of the pixels in the IR scan. It is important to have the same spatial resolution in both data sets. However, the angular resolution of the observa- tions at the VTT was better than at THEMIS due to the use of a correlation tracker (Ballesteros et al. 1996). To solve this problem, the IR data were degraded to the resolution of the visible data by convolution with a Gaussian. The contrast of the IR continuum image depends on the angular resolu- tion. We set the width of the Gaussian, and so the angular resolution of the IR map, by comparison with the synthetic images from numerical simulations of magneto-convection (Vögler 2003; Vögler et al. 2005). Specifically, we tune the IR contrast so that the ratio between the visible and the IR contrasts agrees with the ratio obtained from numerical simu- lations (0.48). Such theoretical ratio was found to be almost independent of the angular resolution and in excellent agree- ment with the value measured by Khomenko et al. (2005) us- ing a single telescope to obtain simultaneous visible and IR data. The central panel in Figure 1 shows the continuum im- age in the IR after smearing. The contrast of the IR image is 0.9%. The right panel of Figure 1 contains the continuum in- tensity image of the visible data (contrast 1.9%). The squares point out regions easy to identify in both images showing the goodness of the alignment. After all data reduction, including smearing of the IR data and Fourier filtering of the visible data, the level of noise in polarization for Stokes V is (2-3)×10- 4Ic for the IR data and 5×10- 4Ic for the visible data. A more detailed description of the telescopes and the data reduc- tion can be found in Domínguez Cerdeña (2004). De- scriptions of the instruments can be found in Collados (1999) and Schlichenmaier & Collados (2002) for TIP, and in López Ariste et al. (2000) and Bommier & Rayrole (2002) for THEMIS. 3. MAGNETOGRAMS Figure 2 shows the magnetograms calculated from the Stokes V profiles of Fe I λ6302.5 Å and Fe I λ15648 Å. The longitudinal magnetic flux density or Beff was computed with the magnetograph equation under the weak field approx- imation using the same method as Domínguez Cerdeña et al. (2003a). The magnetograms thus obtained are equivalent to the routine magnetograms (e.g., that obtained with the MDI Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 5 instrument on board of SOHO5), if we exclude the velocity fields. Figure 2 displays both magnetograms with the same scale of magnetic flux densities. At first sight, both images are similar with the exception that the signals found in visible are larger than the signals found in IR. Indeed, this is the first important difference. Since only the IN fields are of interest here, the network region pointed by a circle in the lower left part of our FOV was discarded from the analysis by rejecting pixels with flux densities larger than 20 G in the visible and 10 G in the IR. The noise levels turned out to be 2 G in the visible and 1 G in the IR. The method to estimate the noise is detailed in Domínguez Cerdeña et al. (2003b). The unsigned flux density obtained from pixels in the FOV with flux density below the upper limit and above noise was, Beff =(cid:26) 3.0 G, for Fe I λ6302.5 Å, 1.5 G, for Fe I λ15648 Å. (1) In both cases the pixels with signals cover 45% of the total FOV (the rest of the pixels were set to zero in the calculation of Beff). Under the same conditions of noise and spatial res- olution, the measurements in the visible detect more flux than in the IR. This suggests that visible and IR lines trace different magnetic structures. The difference of flux is conspicuous, and one may be tempted to ascribe it to the approximations used for Beff. However, more elaborated techniques show the same behavior (ME inversions in Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003a; Domínguez Cerdeña 2004, and §5). Some magnetic flux concentrations are very similar in both magnetograms (squares in the upper part of Figure 2) but some others differ (see the other two squares). There are structures having one polarity in the IR magnetogram and the opposite in the visible one. This effect is evident even in the network area with large polarization signals (see the circle in Fig. 2). Such a result can be considered as an additional evi- dence of the different sensitivity to magnetic fields of the vis- ible and the IR lines. The magnetic fields in the visible magnetogram (Fig. 2 right) exhibit a preferred polarity while the IR magnetogram (Fig. 2 left) looks well balanced. The signed flux was mea- sured to be, Beff =(cid:26) - 2.0 G, for Fe I λ6302.5 Å, - 0.1 G, for Fe I λ15648 Å. to similar flux is (2) This imbalanced that mea- sured in other visible observations (e.g., Lites 2002; Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003b). Yet, Khomenko et al. (2003) found almost no signed flux using the same IR lines (they observed 0.2 G). results indicate visible these that All lines may conjectured Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2003). different magnetic Sánchez Almeida & Lites trace by and structures, IR as (2000); 4. DATA ANALYSIS In order to infer the magnetic field strengths from the ob- servations, we carried out an inversion of the Stokes pro- files under the MISMA hypothesis. MIcro-Structured Mag- netized Atmospheres (MISMAs) were introduced for the first time by Sánchez Almeida et al. (1996), with the objec- tive of reproducing the asymmetric Stokes profiles observed in most solar structures. Unresolved optically thin micro- structures naturally render asymmetric Stokes profiles. The 5 See http://sohowww.nascom.nasa.gov/. MISMA scenario turns out to be an appropriate scheme of analysis since the observed quiet Sun Stokes profiles are very asymmetric, and it has been shown to work with the asymmetries of Fe I λ6301.5 Å and Fe I λ6302.5 Å (Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000). In this section we give a description of the procedure followed to invert the data. 4.1. PCA classification We only analyze those Stokes V profiles clearly above noise. A threshold of three times the noise level was cho- sen in order to separate clear polarization signals from noisy profiles. Pixels with profiles whose peak polarization is above the threshold in both the IR and the visible data cover 40% of the FOV. This data set includes some 2280 pixels. Following Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000, § 3.2) the Stokes V profiles in the selected data set were classified us- ing a principal component analysis algorithm (PCA). The aim is twofold. On the one hand, it reduces the number of rep- resentative profiles and, on the other hand, it provides low noise profiles to perform inversions used as initialization for the inversion of individual Stokes profiles. The classification is carried out simultaneously for the visible and the IR Stokes V profiles. The profiles of the four lines were scaled to the blue lobe of the Fe I λ6302.5 Å Stokes V profile. The PCA method gives 38 classes. All profiles with large polarization signals were included in one single class to avoid contami- nating the other classes with network profiles. The Stokes V threshold was chosen to be 1%Ic in the visible, and this special class includes all profiles from the network patch in the bottom left of our map (see Fig. 2). The large number of classes compared with those obtained for visible lines by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000, 10 classes) or for IR lines by Khomenko et al. (2003, 8 classes) is due to the combi- nation of the different asymmetries found in the Stokes V profiles of the two pairs of lines. Note that, in general, the classes found in this work do not correspond to those obtained by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) and by Khomenko et al. (2003). We represent each class with the average of all profiles corresponding to the class. The individual profiles are not scaled to carry out the average. We only multiply them by the sign of the blue lobe of Fe I λ6302.5 Å. Some of these classes are shown in Figures 3 and 4 (the dots). There is a clear improvement in the signal to noise ratio (S/N, de- fined as the maximum of the unsigned Stokes V profile di- vided by the noise) from the individual profiles to those rep- resenting the class. The individual profiles have a typical S/N between 3 and 10, whereas the two first classes have a S/N of 100. The IR profiles from classes 0 and 4 have tails ex- tending far out from their extremes, as those predicted by Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2003). These tails come from the contribution of kG field strengths. Such profiles are similar to class 0 in Khomenko et al. (2003, Fig. 1). The first 6 classes include 42% of the total number of profiles. One conspicuous fact is that some classes (e.g., classes 11 and 20) show one polarity in the visible and the opposite in the IR. Such a result was expected from the magnetograms in Fig- ure 2. Approximately 20% of the profiles show the effect (see also Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003a). The MISMA inversion by Sánchez Almeida (1997). We will follow a strategy similar described 4.2. MISMA inversion is code 6 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer FIG. 3. -- Some representative classes of observed Stokes V profiles showing the large variety of asymmetries produced by the quiet Sun magnetic fields. The circles represent the observed profiles and the solid lines the fits with MISMA model atmospheres. The header on top of each row displays the class number, the percentage of profiles belonging to the class, and the magnetic field of the three MISMA components at the base of the photosphere, sorted in order of decreasing mass. The polarity of the magnetic fields is indicated by plus and minus signs. to Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000). Here we summarize the main characteristics of the underlying model atmospheres: 1. There are four different components, one non-magnetic and three magnetic. the inversion of visible lines performed by Sánchez Almeida & Lites As (2000) require two magnetic components. Note that §4.2) discuss, Sánchez Almeida et al. (1996, is impossible to reproduce even the mildest observed asymmetries with only one component. Here we need one additional component to characterize the weak magnetic field strength revealed by the IR lines (Lin & Rimmele 1999; Khomenko et al. 2003; it Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 7 FIG. 4. -- Same as Figure 3 for 6 additional classes. Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003a). The components are embedded in a background producing unpolarized stray light. 2. The magnetic fields are vertical, along the line of sight. Since the observed Stokes Q and U signals are rarely above the noise level, it is reasonable to assume the inclination of the magnetic field to be 0◦ or 180◦. The inversions were performed only for Stokes I and Stokes V . This approach allows us to compute longitudinal magnetic fields, however, the observations are compatible with inclined fields producing a linear polarization hidden by noise (see Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000, § 4.7). The implica- tions of this assumption are discussed in § 6.2. 8 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer FIG. 5. -- Example of a fit of the Stokes I profiles of the four lines. The circles represent the observed profiles, and the solid lines are the fits. Note the two strong telluric blends in the red wings of Fe I λ6302.5 Å and Fe I λ15648 Å. 5. Motions are only allowed along magnetic field lines. The temperatures are retrieved at four fixed heights in the atmosphere. The parameters characterizing each compo- nent are set at the bottom of the model atmosphere. They are the magnetic field strength, the occupation fraction, the bulk velocity, and the broadening parameter. The stratifi- cation of these parameters is obtained under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium and horizontal pressure balance. Three parameters account for the stray light, and another one parametrizes both the solar macroturbulence and the instru- mental broadening due to limited spectral resolution. De- spite the fact that the spectral resolution in the visible and the IR differ by 30 %, one can use a single macroturbulence for the two wavelength domains because the macroturbulence inferred from the inversions is completely dominated by true solar motions rather than instrumental smearing. The to- tal number of free parameters amounts to 25. They are used to fit some 400 observables (each wavelength position of the Stokes I and V profiles of the four lines). An example of the fit to the intensity profiles is shown in Figure 5. The observed profiles (circles) exhibit line blends. These are a telluric line close to the red wing of Fe I λ6302.5 Å, a solar Fe I line at 15647.3 Å, and an uniden- tified possibly telluric line in the red wing of Fe I λ15648 Å. To avoid the contamination by these blends, the Stokes I pro- files at the wavelengths of the blends are excluded from the fit. There are also two OH bands of solar origin close to Fe I λ15652 Å, however, these bands are only visible in cool solar regions such as sunspots. The intensity profiles in Fig- ure 5 are those from class 0. All models have three magnetic components. In order to distinguish between them, we denote them as first, second and third components. The first component is that carrying the largest mass, as was defined by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000), and it is followed by the second and the third. If the three components would have the same magnetic field strength, the first would be the one producing the largest po- larization signal. FIG. 6. -- MISMA model from the inversion of class 0. The six pan- els show the variation with height of different physical parameters of inter- est. From left to right and top to bottom: the continuum optical depth at 5000 Å, the temperature, the magnetic field strength, the occupation frac- tion, the density, and the velocity along the field lines. The parameters are displayed for the four components except the optical depth: the solid line corresponds to the non-magnetic component, and the dotted, the dashed, and the dot-dashed lines to the three magnetic components. Note that the spec- tral lines are formed between 100 km and 300 km, so that the properties of the atmosphere outside this range are not constrained by the observations and therefore are not reliable. 3. The temperature of the components is forced to be the same. Since the magnetic structures are optically thin the radiative exchange between components is very ef- ficient, washing out temperature differences in seconds. 4. The four components are in lateral pressure balance. Figure 6 displays the model MISMA of class 0 (see the Stokes V in Fig. 3). The different physical parameters of the non-magnetic, the first, the second, and the third mag- netic components are plotted with solid, dotted, dashed and dot-dashed lines, respectively. The first magnetic component presents a weak magnetic field strength (∼100 G at the base of the photosphere), while the other two have strong field strengths (larger than 1 kG). The density of the first mag- netic component is the same as for the non-magnetic com- Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 9 ponent (Fig. 6 bottom-left panel) whereas the other two com- ponents have much lower density. The reduction is forced by the coupling between field strength and density produced by the lateral pressure equilibrium. The higher the magnetic field the lower the gas pressure and, for the same temperature, the lower the density. 5. RESULTS Figures 3 and 4 show the fits produced by the MISMA in- version of 12 representative classes. All kinds of observed profiles are properly reproduced with three magnetic compo- nents per resolution element. From now on, all results correspond to a single height in the atmosphere. We select the base of the quiet Sun photo- sphere, defined as the height where the total pressure equals to 1.3 × 105 dyn cm- 2. Invoking lateral pressure balance among the individual model MISMAs, this definition sets a single geometrical height for all the inversions, and it corresponds to the height where the continuum optical depth is one in the 1D quiet Sun model atmospheres (e.g., Maltby et al. 1986). The study is focused on two particularly important physical parameters, namely, the magnetic field strength and the oc- cupation fraction. The latter corresponds to a volume filling factor. The magnetic field strength inferred from the MISMA in- version of each class is also given in Figures 3 and 4. The magnetic field of the components are denoted as B1, B2 and B3, in order of decreasing mass. Very often the inversions require one component with a sub-kG field strength and two with strong kG fields. Such a behavior is typical of the most abundant classes (e.g., classes 0, 1, 4). The Fe I λ15648 Å Stokes V profiles of these classes are similar to that expected from the synthesis by Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2003). The lobes of the profiles have a splitting equivalent to that produced by a weak field, however, they exhibit extended wings characteristic of strong fields. Some other classes have all components with fields in the range clearly below 1 kG (e.g., classes 5, 19, 20). In this case, there are no extended wings in the profiles of Fe I λ15648 Å. Finally, note the pres- ence of very asymmetric profiles. The IR profiles tend to have a higher degree of asymmetry. Some 28% of the analyzed pixels present IR profiles with three lobes (e.g., class 5). We found a fraction similar to that observed by Khomenko et al. (2003, 30%). There is also a small fraction of very asymmet- ric IR profiles with four lobes (3%, classes 14 and 30), while there are only a few visible profiles with three lobes (3%, e.g., class 30). The model atmospheres obtained from the classes were used to initialize the inversion of the individual Stokes V pro- files belonging to the class. From this moment on we refer only to results obtained from the inversion of the 2280 indi- vidual profiles. 5.1. Magnetic field strength and magnetic flux The histograms of the distribution of magnetic field strength obtained from the inversion of the individual profiles are displayed in Figure 7. They show the percentage of pix- els within bins of 50 G for the different components. The solid, the dashed, and the dotted lines distinguish the first, the second, and the third magnetic components, respec- tively. The results from the network patch were omitted (see § 3). The first component tends to have much weaker fields than the other two and it has a shape similar to the distribution obtained by Khomenko et al. (2003) using only FIG. 7. -- Histograms of the magnetic field strength at the base of the pho- tosphere, determined from inversion of the individual Stokes I and V profiles. The first, the second and the third components are plotted with solid, dotted and dashed lines, respectively. IR lines. The mean field obtained for this component is 290 G. The second and the third components show the same behavior as the histograms obtained with visible lines by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000). They have mean fields of 970 and 1100 G respectively. Despite the similarity between the magnetic field strengths of the second and the third com- ponents, they are well separated by the inversion code. There are large differences of Doppler shift between them; 85 % of the models are separated by more than 500 m s- 1 at the base of the photosphere, and this difference increases substantially in the heights of formation of the spectral lines. (See also § 6.3.) The top panels of Figure 8 show the maps of field strength for the three magnetic components. The magnetic field of the first, the second and the third components are displayed from left to right. The network point (bottom left) is almost the only feature with strong kG fields in the first component. Most of the pixels show at least one component with strong fields. More specifically, 92% of the analyzed pixels possess at least one field larger than 500 G while the fraction with field strengths above 1 kG is 74%. The map with the filling factor of the magnetic fields (the sum of occupation fractions of the three components) is dis- played in the bottom left panel of Figure 8. It goes from 10% in network points to 0.5%, and the mean value is approxi- mately 4%. If we consider the whole FOV (all values in the pixels not analyzed are set to zero), and we exclude the net- work profiles, the measured magnetic fields fill only 1.5% of the IN region. The bottom right panel of Figure 8 gives the map of the total magnetic flux density computed as the product of the occupation fraction times the magnetic field strength. Note that the flux density is given in G (or Mx cm- 2), thus it can be directly compared with other measurements with differ- ent pixel size or FOV. Most parts of the analyzed surface present a flux density larger than 25 G (sum of the three com- ponents). Considering the whole map, we measure a total flux density of 9.6 G which is similar to the value obtained by Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2002) or Lites (2002) with better spatial resolution. 10 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer FIG. 8. -- The three upper panels (a,b,c) show maps of the magnetic field strength at the base of the photosphere of the first, the second and the third components, respectively. The bottom left panel (d) gives the occupation fraction (filling factor) of the three components all together in a logarithmic scale. The total unsigned magnetic flux is shown in the bottom right panel (e). It is saturated at 30 G. Black regions correspond to pixels with polarization signals too low to be inverted. The separation between minor tickmarks is one arcsec. Figure 9 shows the variation of the magnetic field strength of all components with the magnetic flux density. The shaded area represents the standard deviation above and below the mean value. A difference between the two standard devia- tions reveals the asymmetry between the distribution of field strength above and below the mean value. There is a strong tendency for the field strengths to weaken when the magnetic flux decreases. Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) obtained a less pronounced dependence, but their lowest detectable flux density was 10 G while in this work it decreases down to 1 G. 5.2. Mixed polarities 50% of the analyzed pixels can be fitted only with mixed polarities in the model MISMA. Since we fit 40% of the total pixels, this fraction corresponds to 20% of the FOV. This large amount of pixels includes all profiles with three or four lobes in the IR and/or visible (30%), and also those profiles with a clear polarity in the visible Stokes profiles and the opposite in the IR profiles (20%). We find that the fields of those pixels are weaker than the rest. Figure 10 shows the histograms of the field strength as in Figure 7 but only for models including mixed polarities. All components show fields weaker than in Figure 7. From the first, the second and the third magnetic FIG. 9. -- Mean magnetic field strength of all components as a function of the magnetic flux density. The shaded area gives the standard deviation above and below the mean value. Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 11 FIG. 10. -- Same as Figure 7 but only for those pixels with mixed polarities in the resolution element. FIG. 11. -- Percentage of pixels with mixed polarities versus the Stokes V signal of Fe I λ6302.5 Å. components we retrieve a mean field of 250, 700 and 880 G, respectively. Figure 11 gives the percentage of mixed polarities as a func- tion of the Stokes V signal of Fe I λ6302.5 Å. The weaker the polarization signal the larger the fraction of mixed polarities. This behavior was already noted by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) and Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2002) but they obtained a maximum fraction of 25%. The fraction in Figure 11 flattens to 65% for Stokes V lower than 0.002. 5.3. Distribution of field strengths We compute the probability density function (PDF) of the magnetic field strength from the magnetic field and occupa- tion fractions procured by the MISMA inversions of the in- dividual profiles. The PDF gives the probability of finding a specific magnetic field strength in the observed IN region. The range of magnetic fields from 0 to 2000 G was divided into bins of 50 G. Each individual intrinsic field B is assigned to one bin. The probability to find the magnetic field of a FIG. 12. -- Probability density function of the magnetic field strength at the base of the photosphere as inferred from Zeeman signals. single bin is the sum of the occupation fractions of all pixels with B belonging to this bin. We normalize the PDF so that its integral provides the filling factor of magnetic structures in the IN region assuming that the pixels without signals have no magnetic field strength. The PDF of the magnetic field strength condenses informa- tion on the quiet Sun magnetism that can be used for compar- isons with other observations and numerical simulations. The first moment hBi is connected with the magnetic flux density and the second moment provides the magnetic energy density hB2i/8π: 0 hBi =Z ∞ hB2i =Z ∞ 0 B PDF(B) dB, B2 PDF(B) dB. (3) (4) Figure 12 shows the PDF of our IN region. Once again, we have avoided those pixels belonging to the small network patch in the FOV. The shape of the PDF is to be expected from the histogram of Figure 7. Most of the filling factor is con- centrated in the weak fields, while most of the magnetic flux comes from the strong fields. Table 3 summarizes the prop- erties of the PDF. It shows the filling factor, the flux density, the fraction of flux, and the fraction of energy in four differ- ent ranges of magnetic field strengths, i.e., the full range, the weak fields (B < 500 G), the strong fields (B > 500 G), and the kG fields (B > 1000 G). Three quarters of the total observed flux and 90% of the magnetic energy is in the kG fields, de- spite they represent only 30% of the total filling factor. There is an accumulation of field strength between 1600 and 1800 G. It may be due to the combined effect of a mag- netic intensification mechanism plus the existence of an upper limit that the magnetic field strength cannot exceed. This limit of 1800 G corresponds to a magnetic pressure equal to the gas pressure of the non-magnetic plasma at the base of the photo- 12 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer FILLING FACTOR, MAGNETIC FLUX DENSITY AND MAGNETIC ENERGY DENSITY OF THE PDF TABLE 3 IN FIGURE 12. Range filling factor flux density total B<500 G B>500 G B>1000 G [%] 1.50 0.87 0.63 0.42 [G] 9.6 1.2 8.4 7.0 energy density [erg cm- 3] 500 10 490 450 fraction of flux fraction of energy [%] 100 10 90 75 [%] 100 2 98 90 sphere. The magnetic intensification mechanism would try to pile up magnetic fields right before the upper limit. 5.4. Signed flux When we average over the FOV, the signed magnetic flux does not cancel completely. The flux density, taking into account the direction of the magnetic field, turns out to be - 3.5 G. This net flux was expected from the results in § 3 (equation [2]). Lites (2002) already observed the presence of an imbalanced flux in almost all the observation he studied. He measured an imbalance (defined as the signed flux divided by the unsigned flux) between - 0.20 and +0.48, and found a direct correlation between the imbalance of the IN fields and the imbalance of the network fields around them. Our im- balance is - 0.36 and our network region is negative almost everywhere. Figure 13 shows the PDF of the signed magnetic field strength, i.e., the magnetic field strength times the sign of the vertical component of the magnetic field. There is a large contribution of strong fields in the negative flux part of the PDF, while the positive part has a continuous fall off from weak to strong fields. The weak fields are well balanced while the strong fields have a preference toward negative polarity, i.e., the same polarity as the network patch. For fields weaker than 500 G the imbalance is only - 0.09, and for field strengths FIG. 13. -- PDF of the magnetic field strength times the sign of the polarity of the flux. The vertical dotted line points out B = 0 G. stronger than 1 kG the imbalance is - 0.5. Socas-Navarro et al. (2004) already observed the preference of the strong fields to- wards one polarity, and Figure 13 shows a clear observational evidence of such an effect. 6. CRITICAL ASSESSMENT OF SOME ASSUMPTIONS AND RESULTS Some of the properties of the observational material used in the work, and the assumptions of the inversion, are not ideal but dictated by feasibility. In order to strengthen the validity of the results, we devote this section to analyze the assump- tions and results that may be more critical. 6.1. Time lag between IR and visible data sets Our visible and IR spectra average the IN properties in spa- tial scales of 1.′′5 arcsec and temporal scales of 30 sec (§ 2). The time lag between visible and IR spectra would be of con- cern only if this spatio-temporal average changes significantly during 1 min. Fortunately, large changes of the average prop- erties are not expected for a number of reasons. First, the in- tegration time of the individual measurements smears out the short time-scale variations of the IN fields, and only variations in the range between 30 sec and 1 min are of concern. Sec- ond, low spatial resolution observations of IN magnetic fields show how many structures remain stable for tens of minutes, and longer (e.g., Zhang et al. 1998; Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003b). Obviously, our time lag does not represent a prob- lem for these structures. In view of the results coming from high resolution observations and numerical simulations of magneto-convection, this time stability cannot not be inter- preted as the stability of individual magnetic structures but the stability of the average properties. For example, a strong granular downdraft lives longer than the granules and, dur- ing its lifetime, it continuously advects magnetized plasma towards a specific point of the solar surface (Rast 2003). Ob- served with low resolution, one would detect a magnetic patch that remains in place for a long period of time, despite the fact that it is formed by many small-scale short-lived mag- netic structures that are continuously advected and engulfed by the downdraft. Finally, for the average magnetic properties to present significant variations during the time lag, the typi- cal velocities of the magnetized plasma would have to be un- physically high. Consider the horizontal velocities required to sweep out during the time lag all magnetic elements existing in a resolution element. In this case the magnetic structures in the same resolution element of the visible and IR maps will be completely different, questioning any interpretation based on their simultaneity. The required velocities would have to be of the order of the speed needed to cross a resolution element during the time lag, i.e., 18 km s- 1. Such speed is too high to be common. It is supersonic, and much larger than the ob- served vertical velocities. Obviously, the lack of simultaneity Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 13 becomes more problematic as the spatio-temporal resolution of the observation improves. From our point of view, the spatial and temporal integration of the measurements represents a problem more serious than the time lag and the small spatial resolution differences that may remain between the IR and the visible data sets,. The polarization detected in each resolution element results from adding up contributions from many magnetic structures hav- ing very different properties. Our inversions provide only a crude representation of what may be happening in the real Sun. This problem, however, is not specific of our work but affects all previous observational works on the IN magnetic fields. In the case of the MISMA inversions the problem is ameliorated because a sketchy model MISMA actually repre- sents many different underlying atmospheres, including very complex ones. All those atmospheres having the same aver- age properties produce the same spectrum, and these average properties are the ones that the inversions retrieve (see the dis- cussion in Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000, § 5). 6.2. The inclination of the magnetic fields The inversions were carried out under the assumption of longitudinal magnetic fields, which minimizes the number of free parameters and simplifies the inversions. This assump- tion, however, biases the inferred PDF(B). Fortunately, the importance of the bias can be estimated and it turns out to be small. If a magnetic field has an inclination γ with respect to our vertical line-of-sight, the Stokes V spectrum remains approximately as in the case of vertical field but scaled with the factor cos γ. This is a general property of the radiative transfer equation, and is not restricted to weak fields on plane- parallel atmospheres (see Sánchez Almeida & Trujillo Bueno 1999, § 3.1). Consequently, if an observed Stokes V profile is reproduced with the wrong inclination, all the parameters of the inversion would remain the same except for the occupa- tion fraction α(B). The occupation fraction provides a global scaling factor for the Stokes V profiles, and so it absorbs the full bias. Our PDF(B) is biased because it is based on occu- pation fractions underestimated by a factor cos γ(B), PDF(B) = N- 1 n(B) Xi=1 cos γi(B)αi(B), (5) with the subscript i denoting one of the n(B) pixels with a field strength B, and the symbol N standing for a normalization constant. Obviously, PDF(B) sets a lower limit to the true PDF∗(B), PDF∗(B) = N- 1 n(B) Xi=1 αi(B) ≥ PDF(B), (6) since cos γi(B) ≤ 1. On the other hand, it is possible to set an upper limit by estimating the maximum inclina- tion allowed by the noise in Stokes Q and U. Following, Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000, § 4.7), we synthesize the lin- ear polarization produced by our model atmospheres when the magnetic field of the three components is inclined. For each model MISMA we determine the largest inclination γu pro- ducing undetectable linear polarization, i.e., below the obser- vational noise. If we use this inclination to correct the occupa- tion fractions, one can define a new PDFu(B) which represents an upper limit to the true PDF ∗(B), PDFu(B) = N- 1 n(B) Xi=1 cos γi(B) cos γui(B) αi(B) ≥ PDF∗(B), (7) the inequality follows where that cos γi/cos γui ≥ 1 for all i. We find that the unsigned flux corresponding to PDFu(B) is only 25% larger than the flux of PDF(B), indicating that the assumption of vertical fields have a very limited effect on the PDF estimated in the paper. from the fact 6.3. Need for three magnetic components Due to the similarity between the magnetic field strengths of the second and the third magnetic components, one may wonder whether they are really needed to reproduce the line shapes. Moreover, if they are not needed, the exis- tence of mixed polarities may be an artifact since the sig- nals of the two components cancel our producing no ob- servable residual. As we stress in § 4.2, the three compo- nents are needed. Here we elaborate on the reasons. Re- producing the Stokes V asymmetries of the visible lines re- quires two magnetic components, even for the mildest asym- metries characteristic of the network. One single magnetic component produces Stokes V area and the peak asymme- tries of the same magnitude, in contradiction with the observa- tions (Sánchez Almeida et al. 1996, p. 545). Somehow unex- pectedly, Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) find that these two components are enough to explain not only the mildest asym- metries, but the whole range of observations including ex- treme profiles with an even number of lobes. These two com- ponents have similar kG magnetic field strengths, but very different velocities (Sánchez Almeida & Lites 2000, Figs. 12 and 14). The large difference of velocities is demanded by the observed Stokes V asymmetries, and it is the reason why the inversion code is able to separate them. Here we analyze pro- files similar to those reproduced by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) and, consequently, a minimum of two magnetic com- ponents is needed. In addition, we also want to reproduce the IR lines which, according to the literature, indicate the existence of weak fields in the quiet Sun. A third weak mag- netic field component was needed too. This argument does not imply that all the observed profiles necessarily require three components. It implies that the typical cases need three components (regular Fe I λ6301.5 Å and Fe I λ6302.5 Å, with Fe I λ15648 Å and Fe I λ15652 Å showing weak fields). It also implies that that typical Stokes V profiles have enough information to constrain the three components. Finally, it im- plies that if a single MISMA scenario is going to be used to reproduce all the asymmetries, it must contain three compo- nents. 6.4. The inferred magnetic field strengths One of the main conclusions of this work is the co-existence of kG and sub-kG fields in resolution elements of 1.′′5 as inferred from the simultaneous inversion of IR and visible Stokes profiles. The use of visible lines to measure kG magnetic field strength has been criticized. The analysis of extremely noisy Stokes V profiles of Fe I λ6301.5 Å and Fe I λ6302.5 Å may induce a bias towards kG (see Bellot Rubio & Collados 2003), and the Stokes V profiles from the visible lines are the major tracers of the kG magnetic fields in our inversion. However, the kG that we infer are not produced by such a bias for a number of reasons. The classes have much less noise than the individual profiles, and yet the inversion yields as much kG of the individual profiles. The classes that yield at least one kG magnetic component represent 75% of the total pixels. They include the two main classes with a S/N 14 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer der the assumption of Micro-Structured Magnetized Atmo- sphere (MISMA). We generate model MISMAs able to re- produce all kinds of asymmetries presented in the observed Stokes V profiles, even when there are clear differences in the asymmetries of the visible and the IR Stokes profiles. The model atmospheres have three magnetic components. The simultaneous inversion of the visible and IR pairs re- veals the co-existence of kG and sub-kG fields in the low photosphere. We have observed this combination of weak and strong fields in 74% of the pixels under study, which means 30% of the pixels of the FOV (see § 5.1). This was already observed by Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a) from the separate inversion of the IR and visible lines, however, this work presents the first evidence of the co-existence of kG and sub-kG fields from a simultaneous inversion of lines in the two spectral ranges. From the three magnetic compo- nents, the one having most of the mass includes most of the weak fields. The two other components tend to show strong kG fields. The preference of the first component to have the weakest fields is due to the coupling between field strength and plasma density. The weaker the field the larger the density so that the component of weakest field tends to have the largest mass. The histogram of field strengths of these minor components (Fig. 7) looks similar to that ob- tained by Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000), while the first component has a distribution similar to that obtained with the analysis of IR lines by Khomenko et al. (2003). This sup- ports the hypothesis of Sánchez Almeida & Lites (2000) and Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida (2002, 2003): the study of the quiet Sun magnetism with only visible lines or only IR lines biases the resulting field strengths; the IN fields must be studied combining Stokes profiles from both spectral ranges. The inferred magnetic fields occupy 1.5 % of the total FOV. Other observations with better spatial resolution (1′′; Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida 2002; Khomenko et al. 2003) yield a total filling factor of 1 %. We obtain a larger value thanks to the combined use of the information from vis- ible and IR lines, while all previous works used lines from a single spectral range. The filling factor inferred for the same observations used in this paper by Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a) was only 0.85%. The difference is due to the dif- ferent model atmospheres used to reproduce the observa- tions. While here we use a realistic multicomponent model, Sánchez Almeida et al. (2003a) carried out Milne-Eddington inversions with a single magnetic component. Thus, the filling factors in pixels with mixed polarities (see § 5.2) are underes- timated. We have measured an average flux density over the FOV of 9.6 G (those pixels without polarization signals contribute to this average with zero field strength; § 5.1). This flux is sim- ilar to that obtained by analysis of visible lines with 1′′ spa- tial resolution (see Socas-Navarro & Sánchez Almeida 2002; Lites 2002) while it is two times larger than the magnetic flux derived from IR lines (Khomenko et al. 2003). Albeit our ob- servations have lower resolution (1.′′5), the use of visible and IR lines reveals more magnetic structures than the use of lines from a single spectral range. The flux density is also larger than the magnetic flux obtained in § 3 using the magneto- graph equation applied to a single line. A combination of factors explain such bias. First, we obtained magnetic field strengths larger than the saturation limit of the lines, thus the circular polarization signals are no longer proportional to the magnetic flux and equation (1) is a lower limit of the real flux. Second, the presence of mixed polarities (see § 5.2) produces FIG. 14. -- PDF of the magnetic field strength computed from the inversion of the IR profiles alone. The solid line is the PDF inferred from the inversion under the MISMA hypothesis, and the dashed line the PDF from the Milne- Eddington inversion. larger than 100. Another 10 classes have S/N larger than 30, which ensures inversions without the bias pointed out by Bellot Rubio & Collados (2003). Another way to test the consistency of our results is to in- vert only the IR lines to see whether it is possible to infer kG fields in the quiet Sun without visible lines. This inver- sion was performed in the same way as in § 4.2 but only for Fe I λ15648 Å and Fe I λ15652 Å with MISMA mod- els including only 2 magnetic components (see more details in Domínguez Cerdeña 2004). The result of such analysis was a major magnetic component similar to the first component in Figure 7 and a second with weak and strong fields. A field stronger than 1 kG was found in 50% of the inverted pix- els (those with the strongest IR signals). The strong fields were retrieved from the extended wing of the Stokes V pro- files. Figure 14 gives the PDF obtained from these inversions. The strong field contribution is not as large as in Figure 12, but it still carries most of the magnetic energy and flux. The presence of fewer strong fields as compared to the full inver- sions including visible lines is due to the incompleteness of the information given by the IR lines, since most of the con- tributions from strong fields remains hidden by noise. The signed flux has a behavior similar to that of the full inversion described in § 5.4. It is more important for the fields stronger than 1 kG while the weak fields are balanced. Figure 14 also shows the PDF obtained from the Milne-Eddington inversion of the IR lines (the dashed line; see Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003a). This inversion was performed with a single magnetic component and shows only the weak field component. 7. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS A new observational technique was used to study the quiet Sun magnetism. Simultaneous visible (Fe I λ6301.5 Å and Fe I λ6302.5 Å) and infrared (Fe I λ15648 Å and Fe I λ15652 Å) polarimetric observations were analyzed un- Quiet Sun Magnetic Fields 15 cancellation of polarization signals and the magnetic flux is underestimated. Third, the lines weaken in strong magnetic concentrations, leading to a well known diminishing of polar- ization signals (e.g., Harvey & Livingston 1969). Finally, the visible and IR signals often trace different concentrations co- existing in the resolution element. Then, combined inversions allow us to detect more flux than the inversion of one of the spectral ranges. The inversion indicates the presence of mixed polarities in at least 20% of the FOV (§ 5.2). This is the largest fraction of mixed polarities obtained from direct measurements. The fraction of pixels with mixed magnetic polarities grows as the polarization signals weaken (Fig. 11). More than half of the profiles with Stokes V signal lower than 0.2% of the contin- uum intensity have mixed polarities. We have estimated the probability of finding a given mag- netic field strength in the quiet Sun, i.e., the probability den- sity function of the magnetic field strength (PDF; § 5.3). It is largest for the weakest fields, however, an extended kG tail goes up to a limit around 1800 G. Despite the fact that the kG fields have only 30% of the total filling factor, they carry 75% of the total flux and 90% of the total magnetic energy. There is a clear imbalance of the magnetic flux towards one polarity. We measure a signed flux density of - 3.5 G which is mostly due to the strong kG fields (§ 5.4). The signed PDF (Fig. 13) shows how the weak fields are well bal- anced whereas the strong fields have a clear preference for the negative polarity. This imbalanced flux has the same sign as the surrounding network, as it was already observed by Lites (2002). This imbalance is qualitatively similar to those im- posed in some MHD simulations of granular convection (see Vögler 2003; Vögler & Schüssler 2003). These simulations have an initial unipolar field. The convection reprocesses this field to yield a continuous PDF with a clear imbalance in the strongest fields. The MISMA inversion of the IR profiles alone also gives rise to a PDF with extended kG tail (§ 6.4). Such tail does not appear in Milne-Eddington inversions of the same profiles, which tend to select the component of weakest field in the resolution element. The magnetic fields studied in this paper fill only 1.5% of the total FOV. The unsigned flux density that we mea- sure is only a lower limit of the real flux. Larger fluxes are obtained in observations with better spatial resolu- tion (Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2003a,b; Sánchez Almeida 2003b) and, furthermore, measurements based on the Hanle effect are compatible with a flux density of 60 G or more (Sánchez Almeida et al. 2003b; Trujillo Bueno et al. 2004; Bommier et al. 2005). A large fraction of the magnetic structures remains undetected in Zeeman based observations. Based on our biased observations, we have produced a PDF with the distribution of magnetic field strengths. Obviously, this is not the real solar PDF. A natural step forward would be working out an unbiased PDF with the help of different mea- surements based on the Zeeman effect, the Hanle effect, and also MHD simulations. This work of synthesis is carried out in a separate paper (Domínguez Cerdeña et al. 2006). De- spite these and other efforts, we are still far from having a complete picture of the quiet Sun magnetism. There is a re- duced number of observations and each one is gathered with different instruments under different conditions. Thus, we need a survey of polarimetric data across many IN regions of the Sun, if we want to study the quiet Sun with a systematic and global point of view. Such data would allow us to start ex- ploring the connection of the IN with active regions, the chro- mosphere and corona and, eventually, to follow the evolution of the IN with the solar cycle. Observations with better spa- tial and temporal resolution are mandatory. They are coming up thanks to the advent of new generation ground based and space-borne solar telescope (Keil & Avakyan 2003). These improvements, together with the development of more realis- tic numerical simulations, guarantee a rapid evolution of the field. Thanks are due to the support astronomers and operators of THEMIS and VTT for help during the observation. The VTT is operated by the Kiepenheuer-Institut für Sonnenphysik, Freiburg, and the French-Italian telescope THEMIS is oper- ated by CNRS-CNR, both at the Spanish Observatorio del Teide of the Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias. The work has been partly funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology, project AYA2004-05792 and by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through grant 418 SPA-112/14/01. REFERENCES Asplund, M., Nordlund, Å., Trampedach, R., Allende Prieto, C., & Stein, R. F. 2000, A&A, 359 Ballesteros, E., Collados, M., Bonet, J. A., Lorenzo, F., Viera, T., Reyes, M., & Rodriguez Hidalgo, I. 1996, A&AS, 115, 353 Bellot Rubio, L. R., & Collados, M. 2003, A&A, 406, 357 Bommier, V., Derouich, M., Landi Degl'Innocenti, E., Molodij, G., & Sahal- Bréchot, S. 2005, A&A, 432, 295 Bommier, V., & Rayrole, J. 2002, A&A, 381, 227 Borrero, J. M., & Bellot Rubio, L. R. 2002, A&A, 385, 1056 Borrero, J. M., Bellot Rubio, L. R., Barklem, P. S., & del Toro Iniesta, J. C. 2003, A&A, 404, 749 Cameron, R., & Galloway, D. 2005, MNRAS, 358, 1025 Cattaneo, F. 1999, ApJ, 515, L39 Collados, M. 1999, in ASP Conf. Ser. 184: Third Advances in Solar Physics Euroconference: Magnetic Fields and Oscillations, 3 -- 22 Collados, M. 2003, Proc. SPIE, 4843, 55 de Wijn, A. G., Rutten, R. J., Haverkamp, E. M. W. P., & Sütterlin, P. 2005, A&A, 441, 1183 Domínguez Cerdeña, I. 2004, PhD thesis, Göttingen University, Göttingen Domínguez Cerdeña, I., Kneer, F., & Sánchez Almeida, J. 2003a, ApJ, 582, Domínguez Cerdeña, I., Sánchez Almeida, J., & Kneer, F. 2003b, A&A, 407, L55 741 -- . 2006, ApJ, 636, 496 Emonet, T., & Cattaneo, F. 2001, ApJ, 560, L197 Grossmann-Doerth, U., Keller, C. U., & Schüssler, M. 1996, A&A, 315, 610 Gurtovenko, E. A., & Kostik, R. I. 1981, A&AS, 46, 239 Harvey, J., & Livingston, W. 1969, Sol. Phys., 10, 283 Harvey-Angle, K. L. 1993, PhD thesis, Utrecht University, Utrecht Higgs, L. A. 1962, MNRAS, 124, 51 Keil, S. L., & Avakyan, S. 2003, Innovative Telescopes and Instrumentation for Solar Astrophysics (Proceedings of the SPIE, Volume 4853) Khomenko, E. V., Collados, M., Solanki, S. K., Lagg, A., & Trujillo-Bueno, J. 2003, A&A, 408, 1115 Khomenko, E. V., Martínez González, M. J., Collados, M., Solanki, S. K., Ruiz Cobo, B., & Beck, C. 2005, A&A, 436, L27 Kurucz, R. 1994, Atomic Data for Fe and Ni. Kurucz CD-ROM No. 22. Cambridge, Mass.: Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, 1994., 22 Landi Degl'Innocenti, E. 1992, in Solar Observations: Techniques and Interpretation, ed. F. Sánchez, M. Collados, & M. Vázquez (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 71 Lin, H., & Rimmele, T. 1999, ApJ, 514, 448 Lites, B. W. 2002, ApJ, 573, 431 Lites, B. W., & Socas-Navarro, H. 2004, ApJ, 613, 600 Livingston, W. C., & Harvey, J. W. 1975, BAAS, 7, 346 López Ariste, A., Rayrole, J., & Semel, M. 2000, A&AS, 142, 137 16 Domínguez Cerdeña, Sánchez Almeida & Kneer Maltby, P., Avrett, E. H., Carlsson, M., Kjeldseth-Moe, O., Kurucz, R. L., & Loeser, R. 1986, ApJ, 306, 284 Martínez Pillet, V., Collados, M., Sánchez Almeida, J., González, V., Cruz- Lopez, A., Manescau, A., Joven, E., Paez, E., Diaz, J. J., Feeney, O., Sánchez, V., Scharmer, G., & Soltau, D. 1999, in ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 183, High Angular Resolution Solar Physics: Theory, Observations, and Techniques, ed. T. Rimmele, K. S. Balasubramaniam, & R. Radick (San Francisco: ASP), 264 Mein, P., & Rayrole, J. 1985, Vistas in Astronomy, 28, 567 Moore, C. E., Minnaert, M. G. J., & Houtgast, J. 1966, The Solar Spectrum from 2935 Å to 8770 Å , NBS Mono. 61 (Washington: NBS) Nave, G., Johansson, S., Learner, R. C. M., Thorne, A. P., & Brault, J. W. 1994, ApJS, 94, 221 Rast, M. P. 2003, ApJ, 597, 1200 Rayrole, J., & Mein, P. 1993, in ASP Conf. Ser. 46: IAU Colloq. 141: The Magnetic and Velocity Fields of Solar Active Regions, 170 Sánchez Almeida, J. 1997, ApJ, 491, 993 Sánchez Almeida, J. 1998, in ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 155, Three-Dimensional Structure of Solar Active Regions, ed. C. E. Alissandrakis & B. Schmieder (San Francisco: ASP), 54 Sánchez Almeida, J. 2003a, in AIP Conf. Proc., Vol. 679, Solar Wind 10, ed. M. Velli, R. Bruno, & F. Malara (New York: AIP), 293 -- . 2003b, A&A, 411, 615 Sánchez Almeida, J., Domínguez Cerdeña, I., & Kneer, F. 2003a, ApJ, 597, L177 Sánchez Almeida, J., Emonet, T., & Cattaneo, F. 2003b, ApJ, 585, 536 Sánchez Almeida, J., Landi Degl'Innocenti, E., Martínez Pillet, V., & Lites, B. W. 1996, ApJ, 466, 537 Sánchez Almeida, J., & Lites, B. W. 2000, ApJ, 532, 1215 Sánchez Almeida, J., Márquez, I., Bonet, J. A., Domínguez Cerdeña, I., & Muller, R. 2004, ApJ, 609, L91 Sánchez Almeida, J., & Trujillo Bueno, J. 1999, ApJ, 526, 1013 Schlichenmaier, R., & Collados, M. 2002, A&A, 381, 668 Schrijver, C. J., & Title, A. M. 2003, ApJ, 597, L165 Schüssler, M. 1986, in Small Scale Magnetic Flux Concentrations in the Solar Photosphere, ed. W. Deinzer, M. Knölker, & H. H. Voigt (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht), 103 Sigwarth, M., Balasubramaniam, K. S., Knölker, M., & Schmidt, W. 1999, A&A, 349, 941 Smithson, R. C. 1975, BAAS, 7, 346 Socas-Navarro, H., Elmore, D., Pietarila, A., Darnell, A., Lites, B. W., & Tomczyk, S. 2005, Sol. Phys., in press, astro-ph/0508685 Socas-Navarro, H., Martínez Pillet, V., & Lites, B. W. 2004, ApJ, 611, 1139 Socas-Navarro, H., & Sánchez Almeida, J. 2002, ApJ, 565, 1323 -- . 2003, ApJ, 593, 581 Solanki, S. K. 1986, A&A, 168, 311 Solanki, S. K., & Stenflo, J. O. 1986, A&A, 170, 120 Stein, R. F., & Nordlund, Å. 2002, in IAU Colloquium 188, ed. H. Sawaya- Lacoste, ESA SP-505 (Noordwijk: ESA Publications Division), 83 Stenflo, J. O. 1982, Sol. Phys., 80, 209 Trujillo Bueno, J., Shchukina, N. G., & Asensio Ramos, A. 2004, Nature, 430, 326 Unno, W. 1959, ApJ, 129, 375 Vögler, A. 2003, PhD thesis, Göttingen University, Göttingen Vögler, A., & Schüssler, M. 2003, Astron. Nachr., 324, 399 Vögler, A., Shelyag, S., Schüssler, M., Cattaneo, F., Emonet, T., & Linde, T. Zhang, J., Lin, G., Wang, J., Wang, H., & Zirin, H. 1998, Sol. Phys., 178, 2005, A&A, 429, 335 245
astro-ph/0106238	1	0106	2001-06-13T13:54:28	Observation of solar flares through the ART-P telescope side shield	[ "astro-ph" ]	Some preliminary results of observations of six solar flares though the ART-P telescop side shield in 1990-1992 are presented.	astro-ph	astro-ph	TITLE ASP Conference Series, Vol. VOLUME, PUBLICATION YEAR EDITORS Observation of solar flares through the ART-P telescope side shield Lutovinov A., Pavlinsky, M., Grebenev S. Space Research Institute, Profsoyuznaya 84/32, 117810 Moscow, Russia Abstract. Some preliminary results of observations of six solar flares though the ART-P telescop side shield in 1990-1992 are presented. 1. Introduction The X-ray imaging telescope ART-P was one of the two main instruments on board the Granat Observatory, which was launched in 1989. The telescope consists of four coaxial, completely independent modules; each module includes a coded mask, a collimator and a position-sensitive detector (energy band is ∼3-100 keV) with a geometric area of 625 cm2. The detector equipped with the vessel, window, the analog and digital electronics units. The vessel is made of 4 mm thickness of the titan, which covers a 1.5 mm of the tin as a shield. The collimator has a dual role, it acts as a support structure for the thin window against the internal pressure of the detector and it limits the field of view. The collimator cell geometry is chosen to be square with 6×6 mm. The material of the collimator is a copper with thickness of 200 µm. 2. Observations The analysis of the archive data obtained with ART-P in 1990-1992 has shown that more than 100 X-ray bursts and flares were detected during this period (Grebenev et al., 2001). Most of them were identified as type I X-ray bursts from low-mass X-ray binaries, but also we found six unusual events. Comparison of them with the PHEBUS/GRANAT instrument data, obtained in the 80- 600 keV energy band (Terekhov et al., 1996), has allowed us to conclude that the telescope ART-P detected solar flares passed through its side shield. Time profiles of several of them were practically the same in a wide energy range (3- 600 keV), whereas profiles of other flares in high and low energy bands differed considerably (Fig.1). The solar flares observed by PHEBUS instrument and ART-P telescope on May 24, 1990 was of our special interest. This event is associated with a limb flare (N33 W78), where GeV protons were observed in interplanetary space and the largest increase due to solar neutrons was recorded at ground levels. The spectrum obtained with ART-P during this flare is shown in Fig.2 (left panel). As is obvious from the figure that the powerful emission feature near 9 keV is present in the flare spectrum. This feature was interpreted as the K-fluorescence line produced by the copper. Such point of view is supported by the right panel 1 2 Lutovinov, Pavlinsky, Grebenev Time, s Time, s Figure 1. ART-P and PHEBUS data for different types of flares. Energy dependence of the flares profiles as derived from of Fig.2, in which the counts distribution along one of the detector axis are shown. The 6mm-collimator structure is obvious from this figure. The detailed analysis of other solar flares detected by the ART-P telescope and the evaluating of possibility to detect solar flares or powerful gamma-ray bursts during the INTEGRAL and SRG missions now in progress. Figure 2. Spectrum of the solar flare observed on May 24, 1990. Solid line is represent the best-fit approximation by Gaussian with a centroid energy E ≃ 112 cnl, what corresponds to ∼ 8.7 keV (left panel). Counts distribution along the Sun oriented detector axis (right panel). References Grebenev, S., Lutovinov, A., Pavlinsky, M. et al. 2001, Astron. Lett., 27, in press. Terekhov, O., Kuzmin, A., Sunyaev, R. et al. 1996, Astron. Lett., 22, 362.
0810.4717	1	0810	2008-10-26T20:58:16	Powering the Jets in NGC1052	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have studied the inner regions of the LINER galaxy NGC1052 since the mid 1990s at high resolution with 15 GHz very-long-baseline interferometry observations. A compact, two-sided jet structure is revealed, with multiple sub-parsec scale features moving outward from the central region with typical speeds of 0.26 c. Complementary to this, since early 2005 we are performing a multi-mission campaign of observations of this source, including X-ray spectroscopy, X-ray, and radio flux density monitoring, and VLBA observations at 22 GHz and 43 GHz. X-ray variability is present at time scales of weeks, comparable with the structural changes observed by VLBI. Here we present first results of the high-resolution imaging observations and discuss these findings in the context of the multi-band campaign.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Powering the jets in NGC 1052 Eduardo Ros1 and Matthias Kadler2,3,4,5 1 Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hugel 69, 53121 Bonn, Germany 2 Dr. Remeis-Sternwarte Bamberg, Friedrich-Alexander-Universitat Erlangen, Sternwartstrasse 7, D-96049 Bamberg, Germany 3 CRESST/NASA Goddard Flight Space Center, 662 Greenbelt, MD 20771, USA 4 Universities Space Research Association, 10211 Wincopin Circle, Suite 500 Columbia, MD 20144, USA 5 Erlangen Centre for Astroparticle Physics, Erwin-Rommel-Str. 1, D-91058 Erlangen, Germany E-mail: [email protected], [email protected] Abstract. We have studied the inner regions of the LINER galaxy NGC 1052 since the mid 1990s at high resolution with 15 GHz very-long-baseline interferometry observations. A compact, two-sided jet structure is revealed, with multiple sub-parsec scale features moving outward from the central region with typical speeds of 0.26 c. Complementary to this, since early 2005 we are performing a multi-mission campaign of observations of this source, including X-ray spectroscopy, X-ray, and radio flux density monitoring, and VLBA observations at 22 GHz and 43 GHz. X-ray variability is present at time scales of weeks, comparable with the structural changes observed by VLBI. Here we present first results of the high-resolution imaging observations and discuss these findings in the context of the multi-band campaign. resolution observations 1. High-resolution and the AGN engines The highest in astronomy are possible via very-long-baseline interferometry (VLBI), which can be conducted routinely up to frequencies of 86 GHz, yielding sharp images of the brightest objects in the Universe resolved up to some tens of microarcseconds (µas; see, e.g., the latest pioneering results by Doeleman et al 2008 at even higher frequencies). Typical resolutions are of the order of 0.5 -- 3 mas at the frequencies where atmospheric and ionospheric effects do not severely affect the performance of the observations. High resolution observations of active galactic nuclei (AGN) provide access to the regions close to the central engine, believed to be a super-massive black hole (e.g., Zensus 1995). Those are complemented by single-dish flux density monitoring to follow the changes in the innermost part also from the spectra, which reveal variations of the optically-thin (synchrotron) and optically thick regions (closer to the self-absorbed jet base). Additionally, radio spectra turnover frequency imaging yields information on the jet physics, particle density, composition, etc. (e.g., Lobanov 1998). Polarisation observations at the higher frequencies can also reveal the direction and nature of the magnetic fields in the inner jet. Following the standard model (e.g., Marscher 2006) the emission of a radio loud AGN at different radio wavelengths originates at different distances from the base of the jet. At higher frequencies, the bulk emission comes from closer to the central engine, since the synchrotron- self-absorption of the inner part of the jet is reduced at shorter wavelengths. Assuming a central black hole surrounded by an accretion disk, and perpendicularly to this, a jet with superluminal plasma accelerated, the radio emission is produced by synchrotron at a region where no self- absorption is present. High-resolution radio observations are complemented by other regions of the spectra. AGN broadband spectra show absorption, reflection and emission lines as well as a power-law continuum radiation which can be studied by analyzing the spectral energy distribution. Their spectra show radio variability. In the X-rays, the observations of the iron Kα line at 6.4 keV (the most prominent fluorescent line) probes the AGN circumnuclear environment, from its variability and profile. The combination of radio and X-ray has been successful, i.e., in the case of 3C 120 (Marscher et al 2002), where X-ray flux density "dips" precede VLBI jet ejections. The time delays are of the order of weeks to months caused by the offset of the core from the central engine and by the core shift between the observation frequency and the self-absorption turnover frequency. These "dips" can be put in the context of the discoveries in X-ray binaries (see Fender & Belloni 2004). 2. NGC 1052: the bridge between Type 1 and Type 2 sources Flux-density selected samples of radio-loud AGN are usually dominated by Type 1 sources, with a one-sided jet morphology in high resolution radio images and the counter-jet usually not seen due to Doppler relativistic boosting (see e.g., Ros, these proceedings). Type 1 sources have an accretion disk which is seen face-on, and no absorption is seen in the soft region of the X-ray spectrum. Type 2 sources have an edge-on accretion disk, detected by strong absorption in the soft X-rays (Fabian et al 2000), and free-free absorption is observed at the multi-wavelength radio structure imaging close to the central engine. NGC 1052 (B0238−084, J0241−0815), classified as low-ionization nuclear emission-line region object (LINER), is a key source between both types, since it is radio loud, oriented in the plane of the sky, and emits in X-rays. Due to its closeness (with a redshift of z=0.0049 (Knapp et al 1978), NGC 1052, despite of its relatively low radio luminosity, is still very bright in radio wavelengths and can be detected at all observing VLBI bands in jet and counter-jet (see, e.g., Lee et al 2008 for 86 GHz for the highest available VLBI frequency results published, with just one bright component). At arcsecond scales (Kadler et al 2004a; Cooper et al 2008) it presents an east-west faint emission (of 30′′ in extension) with a dominating core, which is also seen on mas-scales with a double-sided radio with a position angle of ∼65◦. The jet axis is considered to be nearly parallel to the plane of the sky, with values between a lower limit of 57◦ and 72◦ (Vermeulen et al 2003; Kadler et al 2004b). Sawada-Satoh et al (2008) determine values around 76◦ -- 80◦. High opacities are measured toward the innermost component of the western jet (Kadler et al 2004b; Kameno et al 2001; Vermeulen et al 2003), and also at the inner edge of the eastern jet at centimetre wavelengths (Kadler et al 2004b; Sawada-Satoh et al 2008). Millimetre observations can see through this screen and reveal some structure at the innermost region. Emission from H2O spots has been detected both at jet and counter-jet (Sawada-Satoh et al 2008 and references therein), redshifted by 50 -- 350 km s−1 with respect to the systemic velocity of the galaxy. This water emission is interpreted to be located at the region where opacity dominates due to the thermal plasma in the obscuring torus via free-free absorption. X-ray spectra further support the presence of a dense gas torus (Guainazzi & Antonelli 1999; Weaver et al 1999; Kadler et al 2004a) toward the nuclear X-ray source. We started in 2005 a multi-mission campaign to track the ejection of new features at the base of the jet and counter-jets and compare with brightness monitoring and spectral studies in X-rays and radio, with the goal of establishing a relationship between changes in the high energy and the jet production in AGN. First results of the campaign were presented in Kadler et al (2006) and Ros et al (2007). 1995.57 2007.60 Figure 1. VLBA images of NGC 1052. The images shown are spaced by their relative time intervals. The contours are logarithmic with steps of factor 2. The alignment is relative to the emission gap. At the left panel we show images from the 2 cm Survey/MOJAVE programme, registered over a decade. At the right panel we show preliminary images from our monitoring programme at high frequencies, during three years since early 2005. The images have been convolved with common restoring beams, being 1.0 × 0.5 mas in P.A. for the λ2 cm images. The beam for the shorter wavelengths are shown as grey ellipses next to the wavelength label. The lowest contours are set accordingly to the noise level individually for each epoch, with values of some mJy beam−1. 2.1. Observations λ2 cm VLBA observations NGC 1052 has been observed with the VLBA by the 2.1.1. 2 cm Survey/MOJAVE programme since 1995, with typical resolutions of 1×0.5 mas in P.A. 0◦. The images resulting from these measurements are shown in the left panel of Fig. 1. To reproduced the structural variations in the jets of NGC 1052, we modelled the observed radio visibilities with Gaussian circular functions. We cross-identified the modelled features from epoch to epoch by criteria of continuity in the positions and flux densities. A complex data base of functions results, with over 30 components along the more than 10 years of observations. In Fig. 2 we show the proper motions of these model-fitted features (the observations and results are part of the complete kinematic analysis of the MOJAVE/2 cm Survey program (M L Lister et al, in preparation; Ros, these proceedings). The reference origin to align the images has been chosen as the middle point between the two innermost components, although we note that the opacity effects can shift this position. This sets the question of the ejection epoch for the emerging components, since we can extrapolate the linear fit to be zero, but this can be considered as a lower limit. Notice that when computing kinematic epoch ejections for one-sided radio sources, the origin values are usually extrapolated to the core position (τ ∼ 1 surface). We show the speeds and maximum flux densities for selected components in Table 1. A more detailed analysis on the ejection, possible acceleration of components, non-linear motions, etc., is going to be presented in M Kadler et al (in preparation) and elsewhere. Table 1. Kinematic results for selected components of the twin jet in NGC 1052 No of Epochs [µas yr−1] µ [yr] βapp epoch 25 26 14 12 10 11 14 23 20 447 ± 174 595 ± 26 824 ± 27 1038 ± 34 889 ± 27 0.15 ± 0.06 0.196 ± 0.009 0.272 ± 0.009 0.34 ± 0.01 0.294 ± 0.09 536 ± 46 813 ± 53 757 ± 36 763 ± 30 0.18 ± 0.02 0.27 ± 0.02 0.25 ± 0.01 0.25 ± 0.01 1971 ± 13 1987.4 ± 0.7 1999.1 ± 0.1 2002.8 ± 0.1 2003.2 ± 0.1 2003.3 ± 0.3 1999.6 ± 0.2 1994.1 ± 0.1 1982.8 ± 0.8 ID E01 E03 E11 E17 E18 W11 W06 W03 W01 2.1.2. λλ1.3 cm and 0.7 cm VLBA Observations We have been monitoring the structure of NGC 1052 at 22 GHz and 43 GHz using the VLBA every six weeks (with some larger gaps in the time sampling due to scheduling reasons) since early 2005. The observations at these frequencies have different dynamic ranges and beams due to the different constraints during the observing epochs (e.g., weather constraints or failure of one or two stations of the VLBA). We present contour plots of the preliminary images convolved with a common beam in the right panel of Fig. 1. A detailed model fitting of the observed features is in progress, as well as the astrometric registration of the images, since they were observed in phase-referencing mode, including scans on the calibrator J0243−0550. The imaging results show the free-free absorption screen to be still present at 22 GHz and getting transparent at 43 GHz. New components can be traced when being ejected from the Figure 2. Model fitting results to the parsec-scale twin-jet radio structure of NGC 1052 at 15 GHz. The relative distances to the central region are shown as a function of time for the jet (top) and the counter-jet (bottom). The solid lines are linear regression fits to the data points, and their slopes give the reported proper motions. The typical speeds observed are of ≈0.26 c both in jet and counter-jet. Table 1 shows the speed values for selected components. innermost part of the jet. The light curves of the single-dish telescope measurements show a decay from 2005 to early 2008, with some hints of a rising flux density for the latest months (H Aller and M Aller, private communication). 3. Results Our long-term 15 GHz results confirm the morphology and kinematics reported in Vermeulen et al (2003), with prominent jet and counter-jet features moving downstream with mildly relativistic speeds of ≈0.25 c. The source has experienced a decrease in flux density at all frequencies since 2005. This is caused by the fading out of the features travelling outward the jet, which is not compensated by new, strong components at the base of the jet. There are some hints that this situation is beginning to change from the early 2008 observations. The results of the multi-band campaign, including RXTE light curves and spectra, XMM- Newton, Suzaku, and Chandra observations, will be published elsewhere. Our imaging campaign at the highest frequencies is planned to last at least until early 2009. The MOJAVE program will be also continued beyond that and at least until 2010, providing observations of NGC 1052 at 15 GHz every several months. Acknowledgments The VLBA is operated by the National Radio Astronomy Observatory, which is a facility of the USA National Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement with Associated Universities, Inc. References Cooper N J, Lister M L and Kochanczyk M D 2008 ApJS 171 376 -- 388 Doeleman S D et al 2008 Nature 455 78 -- 80 Fabian A C, Iwasawa K, Reynolds C S and Young A 2000 PASP 112 1145 -- 1161 Fender R and Belloni T 2004 ARA&A 42 317 Guainazzi M A and Antonelli L A 1999 MNRAS 304 L15 -- L19 Kadler M, Kerp J, Ros E, Falcke H, Pogge R W and Zensus J A 2004a A&A 420 467 -- Kadler M, Ros E, Lobanov A P, Falcke H and Zensus J A 2004b A&A 426 481 -- 493 Kadler M et al 2006 Challenges of Relativistic Jets http://www.oa.uj.edu.pl/2006jets/posters/Kadler/Kadler.pdf Kameno S, Sawada-Satoh S, Inoue M, Shen Z Q and Wajima K PASJ 53 169 -- 178 Lee S S, Lobanov A P, Krichbaum T P, Witzel A, Zensus J A, Bremer M, Greve A and Grewing M 2008 AJ 136 159 -- 180 Lobanov A P A&A 330 79 -- 89 Marscher A P, Jorstad S G, G´omez J L, Aller M F, Terastranta H, Lister M L and Stirling A M 2002 Nature 417 625 -- Marscher A P 2006 Relativistic Jets ed P A Hughes and J N Bregman, (New York: American Institute of Physics) pp 1 -- 22 Ros E, Kadler M, Kaufmann S, Kovalev Y Y, Tueller J and Weaver K A 2007 Highlights of Spanish Astrophysics IV ed F Figueras et al (Dordrecht: Springer) p 165 Sawada-Satoh S, Kameno S, Nakamura K, Namikawa D, Shibata K M and Inoue M 2008 ApJ 680 191 -- 199 Vermeulen R C, Ros E, Kellermann K I, Cohen M H, Zensus J A and van Langevelde H J 2003 A&A 401 113-127 Weaver K A, Wilson A S, Henkel C and Braatz J A 1999 ApJ 520 130 -- Zensus J A 1995 AR&A 35 607
astro-ph/0503551	1	0503	2005-03-24T18:10:54	Prospects for Detection of Catastrophic Collisions in Debris Disks	[ "astro-ph" ]	We investigate the prospects for detecting dust from two body collisions during the late stages of planet formation at 1-150 AU. We develop an analytic model to describe the formation of a dusty cloud of debris and use numerical coagulation and n-body calculations to predict observable signals from these events. In a minimum mass solar nebula, collisions of 100-1000 km objects at distances of 3-5 AU or less from the parent star are observable at mid-infrared wavelengths as bright clumps or rings of dust. At 24 microns, the clumps are roughly 0.1-1 mag brighter than emission from dust in the background debris disk. In edge-on systems, dusty clumps produce eclipses with depths of 1.0 mag or less that last for roughly 100 orbital periods. Large-scale surveys for transits from exosolar planets, such as Kepler, can plausibly detect these eclipses and provide important constraints on the terrestrial environment for ages of less than or roughly 100-300 Myr.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Prospects for Detection of Catastrophic Collisions in Debris Disks Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA; Scott J. Kenyon e-mail: [email protected] and Benjamin C. Bromley Department of Physics, University of Utah, 201 JFB, Salt Lake City, UT 84112, USA; e-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT We investigate the prospects for detecting dust from two body collisions dur- ing the late stages of planet formation at 1 -- 150 AU. We develop an analytic model to describe the formation of a dusty cloud of debris and use numerical coagulation and n-body calculations to predict observable signals from these events. In a minimum mass solar nebula, collisions of 100 -- 1000 km objects at distances of 3 -- 5 AU or less from the parent star are observable at mid-infrared wavelengths as bright clumps or rings of dust. At 24 µm, the clumps are ∼ 0.1 -- 1 mag brighter than emission from dust in the background debris disk. In edge-on systems, dusty clumps produce eclipses with depths of . 1.0 mag that last for ∼ 100 orbital periods. Large-scale surveys for transits from exosolar planets, such as Kepler, can plausibly detect these eclipses and provide important constraints on the terrestrial environment for ages of . 100 -- 300 Myr. Subject headings: planetary systems -- solar system: formation -- stars: formation -- circumstellar matter 1. INTRODUCTION Throughout history, collisions have shaped the Earth. Repeated mergers of 10 km and larger objects produced the proto-Earth in 10 -- 30 Myr (Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Ag- nor, Canup, & Levison 1999; Chambers 2001; Yin et al. 2002). A few Myr later, a giant collision with a Mars-sized planet removed the first terrestrial atmosphere and led to the -- 2 -- formation of the Moon (Hartmann & Davis 1975; Cameron & Ward 1976; Benz, Slat- tery, & Cameron 1986; Canup 2004a,b). During the Late Heavy Bombardment ∼ 4 Gyr ago, a sustained period of large collisions shaped the surfaces of all terrestrial objects (e.g., Tera, Papanastassiou, & Wasserburg 1974; Hartmann 1980; Neukum 1983; Ryder 2002; Koeberl 2003). Giant collisions also produced structure in the Zodiacal dust band and perhaps mass extinctions on the Earth (e.g. Alvarez et al. 1980; Nesvorn´y et al. 2002b). Understanding the formation and early evolution of our solar system requires unraveling this collisional history from current images, orbits, and samples of asteroids, meteorites, planets, and satellites. Although these data yield a remarkably detailed picture of the formation of the solar system, the record is incomplete, particularly at the earliest epochs (e.g., Swindle 1993; Melosh, Vickery, & Tonks 1993; Wadhwa & Russell 2000). Some of the early collisional history is also erased by subsequent events, including volcanic activity and collisions (e.g., Wilhelms 1987; Strom, Schaber, & Dawsow 1994). The ambiguity of the early record leads to uncertainties in our understanding of the formation of chondrites (e.g., Itoh & Yurimoto 2003; Wood 2004; Connolly 2005), the origin of the Late Heavy Bombardment (e.g. Cohen, Swindle, & Kring 2000; Levison et al. 2001; Koeberl 2003), and other aspects of the early history of the solar system. Observations of debris disks surrounding other stars provide another way to study col- lisions during the evolution of a solar system. At least 40% of all A-type stars and 10% of all solar-type stars have far-infrared excesses from circumstellar dust (e.g., Backman & Paresce 1993). Debris disks with masses of ∼ 0.01 M⊕ in small, 1 -- 100 µm grains explain the scattered-light images and the spectral energy distributions of the best-studied systems (e.g., Backman & Paresce 1993; Artymowicz 1997; Greaves 2005, and references therein). However, collisions and radiation forces remove small grains on timescales, . 1 Myr, much shorter than the 10 Myr to 1 Gyr age of the parent star (Aumann et al. 1984; Backman & Paresce 1993; Zuckerman 2001; Th´ebault, Augereau, & Beust 2003). If the mass in 1 -- 10 km bodies is ∼ 10 -- 100 M⊕, debris produced from high velocity collisions among these larger bodies can replenish the small grain population for 100 Myr or longer (Habing et al. 2001; Kenyon & Bromley 2002; Dominik & Decin 2003). Detailed numerical calculations suggest that the formation of debris disks coincides with the growth of 1000 km or larger planets throughout the disk on similar 10 -- 100 Myr timescales (e.g. Kenyon & Bromley 2004a,b). Thus, debris disks also provide a signpost for the formation of solar systems. Recent theoretical work helps to link our understanding of the collisions in debris disks with the collisions that shaped our solar system. For debris disks around A-type stars, Dominik & Decin (2003) and Kenyon & Bromley (2002, 2004b) showed that the ratio of the disk luminosity Ld to the stellar luminosity L⋆ should follow a simple power-law relation, -- 3 -- Ld/L⋆ ≈ L0/(1 + t/t0), where L0 ∼ 10−3 to 10−2 and t0 ∼ 100 -- 300 Myr. Observations of infrared excesses in nearby stars follow a similar relation (e.g. Kalas 1998; Rieke et al. 2005; Greaves et al. 2005). These results suggest an exponential decline in the collision rate, similar perhaps to the monotonic decline in the background accretion rate following the formation of the Moon1 (e.g., Ryder 2002; Koeberl 2003). Among others, Wyatt & Dent (2002) noted that large collisions are frequent enough to produce dusty clumps in debris disks, with long-term structure similar to the local Zodiac (Nesvorn´y et al. 2002b). In the terrestrial zone, Kenyon & Bromley (2004a) demonstrated that collisions between 50 -- 100 km and larger objects can raise the debris disk luminosity above the simple power- law relation, suggesting that moderate and giant impacts are observable for short periods of time (see also Stern 1994; Grogan et al. 2001; Nesvorn´y et al. 2002a; Zhang & Sigurdsson 2003). Here, we continue to develop the idea that giant collisions produce observable structures in debris disks. We derive an analytic model to identify collisions that produce observable clumps of dust and we use numerical calculations to explore the conditions where large collisions are visible. In a minimum mass solar nebula, collisions of 100 -- 1000 km objects at distances of 3 -- 5 AU or less from the parent star are observable as bright clumps or rings of dust. In disks observed close to edge-on, the optical depth is often large enough to produce eclipses of the parent star. These eclipses last for several days and recur over 10 -- 100 orbital periods. We use detailed N-body simulations to illustrate the evolution of these eclipses and to make estimates for the frequency of these events. Current and planned surveys for planetary transits can detect these eclipses and test our predictions. We develop the analytic model in §2, describe numerical simulations of an ensemble of colliding planetesimals in §3, and derive the time evolution of single catastrophic collisions in §4. We conclude with a brief discussion and summary in §5. 1We distinguish a general monotonic decline in the impact rate 4 -- 4.5 Gyr ago from the Late Heavy Bombardment, an apparent spike in the impact rate ∼ 600 Myr after the formation of the Earth and the Moon (see, for example, Hartmann 1975, 1980; Ryder 1988; Hartmann et al. 2000; Ryder 2002; Koeberl 2003, and references therein). -- 4 -- 2. ANALYTIC MODEL 2.1. Derivation We begin with an analytic model for the formation of a clump of dusty debris from two colliding planetesimals. Each planetesimal has mass density ρ. The larger planetesimal is the 'target' and has mass mt, radius rt, and orbital eccentricity et and inclination it. The smaller 'projectile' has mass mp, radius rp, eccentricity ep, and inclination ip. The planetesimals lie in a disk with surface density Σ(a), where a is the distance from a star with mass M⋆ and luminosity L⋆. We assume that the collision produces a spherical cloud of debris with radius rc and mass md. The debris consists of particles with sizes ranging from 1 µm to 1 m or larger. We follow previous investigators and derive the debris mass from the ratio of the impact energy QI to the disruption energy Qd, md = 0.5(mp + mt)(cid:18)QI Qd(cid:19)βe , (1) where βe is a constant of order unity (see Davis et al. 1985; Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Kenyon & Luu 1998; Benz & Asphaug 1999, and references therein). If V is the relative velocity of the two planetesimals and Ve is the escape velocity of a single body with mass, m = mp + mt, the center-of-mass collision energy is (Wetherill & Stewart 1993) QI = mpmtV 2 I 4m2 , (2) where the impact velocity V 2 mass of two colliding planetesimals is I = V 2 + V 2 e . The energy needed to remove half of the combined Qd = Qb(cid:16) r 1 cm(cid:17)βb + ρQg(cid:16) r 1 cm(cid:17)βg , (3) where Qbrβb is the bulk (tensile) component of the binding energy and ρQgrβg is the gravity component of the binding energy (see, for example, Davis et al. 1985; Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Holsapple 1994; Benz & Asphaug 1999; Housen & Holsapple 1999). To derive the amount of stellar radiation intercepted by the debris cloud, we define the radial optical depth through the cloud as τ ≈ 3R n(r)r2dr r2 c , (4) where n(r) is the number of particles with radius r within the debris cloud. The radiation c /4a2. As orbital shear broadens the debris intercepted by the debris is roughly Ld/L⋆ ≈ τ r2 -- 5 -- cloud into a ring, τ drops but Ld/L⋆ remains roughly constant. If n(r) = n0r−α and md = (4πρ/3)R n(r)r3dr, Ld/L⋆ is a function of a, md, and α and does not depend on the initial radius of the debris cloud rc. The collision rate places strict limits on α. For the late stages of planet formation, the timescale for a collision between an object and smaller bodies in the disk is (Lissauer 1987; Wetherill & Stewart 1993) tc P , (5) ≈ ρr πnΣ where P is the orbital period. If we integrate the expressions for τ and md over r, adopt ρ = 1 -- 3 g cm−3, and set the surface density of small particles in the background debris disk to Σ = Σba−3/2 with Σb ≈ 0.1 g cm−2 at 1 AU, we can rearrange equation (5) as tc P ∼ 10−25 r3(cid:18)1 AU a (cid:19)1/2(cid:18) L⋆ Ld(cid:19) . (6) In each orbit, particles with tc/P < 0.1 have many collisions with material in the background debris disk. Because the background has a wide range of sizes, r ∼ 1 -- 10 µm to r ∼ 1 km, objects in the debris cloud rapidly reach an equilibrium size distribution with α ≈ 3.5 (Dohnanyi 1969; Durda & Dermott 2002; Williams & Wetherill 1994). For an observable debris cloud with Ld/L⋆ & 10−5, particles with r . 10 -- 20 km reach this limit at a = 1 AU. Although larger particles may have a steeper size distribution (Campo Bagatin & Petit 2001; Michel et al 2001, 2002), these contribute little to the optical depth. Thus, we assume α ≈ 3.5 for all particles in the debris. With α known, the optical depth and luminosity are where hri is a typical radius of a particle, and τ ≈ md πρhrir2 c , Ld L⋆ ≈ md 4πρhria2 . (7) (8) The reprocessed luminosity is independent of the geometry of the debris cloud and depends only on the location of the collision and the mass distribution of the particles in the debris. For Ld/L0 & 10−5, this expression constrains the total debris mass: md & 1021(cid:18) hri 1 mm(cid:19)(cid:16) a 1 AU(cid:17)2 g. (9) Thus, an observable debris cloud requires the complete disruption of (i) two 100 km objects at 1 AU, (ii) two 300 km objects at 10 AU, or (iii) two 1000 km objects at 100 AU. From -- 6 -- equation (5) these debris clouds form every ∼ 102 yr at ∼ 1 AU and every ∼ 1 − 3 × 106 yr at 30 AU. The timescale for orbital shear to broaden the debris cloud into a ring and mix with the background disk is tm ≈ (a/rc)P . After the collision, the debris has a velocity dispersion2 Vd/VK ∼ 10−3 (e.g. Michel et al 2001, 2002), which implies an approximate size rc/a ≈ Vd/VK ∼ 10−3. Gravity sets a lower limit to the extent of the debris cloud. Debris cannot remain bound to the largest objects beyond the mutual Hill radius, RH/a = (2mp/3M⋆)1/3 ∼ 1 − 4 × 10−4 for 100 -- 300 km projectiles. The disk scale height, H ≈ 0.01-0.1a provides a rough upper limit to the width of the debris cloud. These estimates suggest that the cloud remains distinct for at least 102 orbital periods. Our approach ignores the increase in thermal energy during a collision. From detailed numerical calculations (e.g., Canup 2004b), large impacts produce considerable increases in the temperature of the colliding bodies. The results suggest that the temperature of two large bodies rises to ∼ 5000 K to 10,000 K during the impact (see also Stern 1994). At these temperatures, the timescale to radiate the impact energy is short, ∼ days, compared to the lifetime of the debris cloud, ∼ years. If the increase in thermal energy is large compared to the impact energy, our analysis overestimates the amount of debris and therefore yields upper limits to the debris cloud luminosity. 2.2. Application To apply the analytic model to debris disks, we use parameters appropriate for the late stages of planet formation. We adopt a minimum mass solar nebula model for the surface density, Σ = Σ0(a/a0)−3/2, where a0 = 1 AU and Σ0 = 15 g cm−2 (Weidenschilling 1977; Hayashi 1981). For this section, we ignore the change in surface density at the 'snow line,' where the surface density increases due to ice condensation. This approximation decreases our collision rates by a factor of two, but has no impact on the luminosity or optical depth of a debris cloud. 2The range in the velocity dispersion is a factor of ∼ 2 -- 3. After the collision, dynamical interactions with other objects and radiative processes such as the Yarkovsky effect can modify the velocity dispersion (e.g., Michel et al 2002, 2004). -- 7 -- The size distribution of projectiles and targets is (Kenyon & Bromley 2004c) n(r) =   nSr−αS r ≤ r1 nI r1 ≤ r < r0 (10) nLr−αL r ≥ r0 Numerical simulations of planet formation suggest r0 ≈ 1 -- 100 km, with αL ≈ 4 for large objects and αS ≈ 3.5 for small objects (e.g. Stern & Colwell 1997; Kenyon & Bromley 2004a). We use r0 ≈ 10-100 km and r1 ≈ 0.1-1 km (Kenyon & Bromley 2004c). For the orbital parameters, we use M⋆ = 3 M⊙, e = 0.2, and i/e = 0.5. We assume standard values for the bulk parameters of large objects. In our model, rocky objects have ρ = 3.0 g cm−3, Qb = 6 × 107 erg g−1, αb = −0.37, Qg = 0.4 erg cm−3, and αg = 1.36; icy objects have ρ = 1.5 cm−3, Qb = 103 erg g−1, αb = 0.0, Qg = 1.4 erg cm−3, and αg = 1.25. For this paper, we ignore a weak relation between the disruption energy and the impact velocity (Housen & Holsapple 1990, 1999; Benz & Asphaug 1999). To explore the sensitivity of our results to the bulk properties, we consider two alter- natives. For rocky objects, our simple approximation to the empirical Qd derived from the size distribution of asteroids in the solar system (Durda, Greenberg, & Jedicke 1998) is Qb = 5 × 104 erg g−1, αb = 0.0, Qg = 1.7 × 10−8 erg cm−3, and αg = 2.4. As an approximation for icy rubble piles, we also consider Qb = 1 erg g−1, αb = 0.0, Qg = 10−3 erg cm−3, and αg = 1.25 (e.g., Leinhardt & Richardson 2000, 2002). To calculate the properties of debris clouds, we use the orbital parameters and bulk properties to derive md from equations (1) -- (3). For n(r) = n0r−α and α = 3.5, n0 = 3md/(4πρR r3−αdr). With rc/a . 10−2, equation (4) yields a lower limit for the optical c /4a2. Although τ depends on rc, the depth. The cloud luminosity is then Ld/L⋆ ≈ τ r2 luminosity is independent of cloud geometry. Clouds viewed in the orbital plane of the disk can eclipse the central star. The visual extinction through the cloud is AV = 1.086τ . The maximum eclipse depth is ∆m ≈ AV (cid:16) rc a(cid:17)2(cid:18) a R⋆(cid:19)2 , (11) where R⋆ is the radius of the central star. At 1 AU, a debris cloud with rc/a ≈ 10−2 in orbit around a 1 -- 3 M⊙ star produces eclipses with ∆m ≈ 0.1-1.0 AV . Figure 1 shows derived luminosities for debris clouds at 1 AU (rocky objects, solid lines), 10 AU (rocky objects, dot-dashed lines), and 100 AU (icy objects, dashed lines). -- 8 -- Larger projectiles produce more luminous debris clouds. In some cases, the largest projec- tiles completely shatter the target, leading to a saturation in debris production. Complete disruption leads to a maximum in the relative luminosity for a given target, illustrated by the plateaus in the Figure. This maximum luminosity is roughly Ld,max L⋆ ≈   3 × 10−2 4 × 10−5(cid:0) a 10 AU(cid:1)−3.5 a . 1.6 AU a & 1.6 AU (12) The luminosity of a debris cloud is sensitive to the distance from the parent star. Our results suggest a roughly 7 order of magnitude decline in Ld/L⋆ from 1 AU to 100 AU. This large change is a result of the changing angular scale and amount of debris with semimajor axis. For a cloud of fixed mass, the angular size of an opaque cloud as viewed from the central star varies as a−2. For a fixed eccentricity, the impact kinetic energy scales as a−1; thus, the debris mass produced from a collision of two bodies varies as a−1. Because collisions at larger stellar distance produce less debris, the mass of the largest remnant increases roughly with a. Taken together, these simple scaling laws suggest Ld/L⋆ ∝ a−4. Complete disruption becomes more important close to the central star, reducing the scaling to Ld/L⋆ ∝ a−3.5 The luminosity of the debris is also sensitive to the bulk properties of the colliding bodies (Figure 2). For collisions between the largest objects at 1 -- 10 AU, the Qd relation derived from asteroids in our solar system yields a factor of ten smaller luminosity as the 'standard' relation for basalts from Benz & Asphaug (1999). The debris luminosity from smaller collisions is unchanged from the standard relation. For the Durda, Greenberg, & Jedicke (1998) Qd relation, small changes, ± 0.1, in βg yield factor of 3 variations in the debris luminosity. At 100 AU, the Qd relation for rubble piles results in much more luminous debris clouds for collisions between 100 -- 1000 km objects. However, the luminosity is still small, Ld/L⋆ . 10−6, compared to typical luminosities, ∼ 10−5 to 10−3, of known debris disks. Close to the central star, debris clouds can produce modest eclipses (Figure 3). At 1 AU, collisions between 300 km and larger objects have AV ∼ 0.01 -- 0.1 mag. Although smaller collisions produce observable debris clouds in scattered or thermal emission, they produce tiny eclipses with ∆m . 10−3 mag. Beyond ∼ 3 AU, eclipses from all debris clouds are unobservable with current techniques. Our estimates of the collision times indicate that individual collisions between large objects are observable (see also Stern 1994; Grogan et al. 2001; Zhang & Sigurdsson 2003). At 1 AU, the collision rates range from 1 -- 10 Myr−1 for collisions between two 1000 km objects -- 9 -- to 10−2 yr−1 for 100 km + 100 km collisions. Smaller collisions occur more frequently but do not produce significant eclipses or debris luminosity. At 10 -- 100 AU, observable collisions between 300 km and larger objects occur every 10 Myr to 1 Gyr. Because the debris cloud merges with the disk on 104 to 105 yr timescales, the chances of observing these debris clouds are small. 2.3. Uncertainties The main uncertainties in our estimates are collision physics and the behavior of the debris cloud following the collision (e.g., Durda et al. 2004). Because collisions between small objects are frequent, the size distribution of small bodies probably is a small uncertainty. For optically thin clouds, the cloud geometry sets the optical depth of the cloud but not the luminosity. For rocky objects, the collision parameters have been well-studied with numerical sim- ulations (e.g., Benz & Asphaug 1999; Michel et al 2001; Canup 2004a) and observations of the debris of large collisions among asteroids (e.g., Durda, Greenberg, & Jedicke 1998). The two approaches yield similar optical depths and cloud luminosities for r . 100 km, but differ by a factor of ∼ 10 for objects with r ∼ 1000 km. Because the number of large asteroids with r & 500 km is small, the uncertainty in the observational estimates are large (Durda, Greenberg, & Jedicke 1998). Observations of sufficient numbers of collisions in debris disks may reduce the uncertainty (see below). For icy objects, the uncertainties in the bulk properties are much larger. Numerical simulations yield Qb ∼ 106 erg g−1 for crystalline ice or snow (Benz & Asphaug 1999); simulations of rubble piles suggest Qb . 10 erg g−1 (Leinhardt & Richardson 2002). The rubble pile results agree with analyses of simulations of the break up of comets, such as Shoemaker-Levy 9 (e.g., Asphaug & Benz 1996) and C/2000 C6 (Uzzo et al. 2001). The apparent break in the size distribution of Kuiper belt objects in the outer solar system (Bernstein et al. 2004) also favors Qb . 103 erg g−1 (Pan & Sari 2005; Kenyon & Bromley 2004c). The size distribution of Kuiper belt objects also favors a small exponent for the gravity component of the disruption energy, βg . 1.2 -- 1.3 instead of the βg ≈ 2 expected from simple theory (Kenyon & Bromley 2004c). However, current observations cannot distinguish be- tween the two relations used in Figures 1 -- 3. Improved constraints from the size distribution of Kuiper belt objects may yield tests of these relations (Bernstein et al. 2004). The evolution of the debris cloud following the collision is an important uncertainty in -- 10 -- our estimates. For a cloud with a radial extent rc, the number of secondary collisions with material in the background debris disk ranges from less than one per orbit for the largest remnant of the collision to a hundred or more collisions per orbit for debris particles with radii of 1 km or smaller. Because the debris cloud expands azimuthally at a rate roughly comparable to the collision rate, the optical depth through the cloud probably cannot increase with time. However, the mass and luminosity may increase. Depending on the surface density in the disk, we estimate that secondary collisions can increase the luminosity of the debris cloud by a factor of 2 -- 10. This uncertainty has little impact on our main results. If the debris cloud luminosity is a factor of 10 larger than our analytic estimates, individual collisions between objects with radii of 100 km or smaller are not detectable at 1 AU. At 10 -- 100 AU, individual collisions between objects with radii of 1000 km and smaller remain invisible. 3. Coagulation Calculations 3.1. Methods To explore the visibility of individual collisions in more detail, we consider numerical calculations of the evolution of particle disks around 1 -- 3 M⊙ stars. Our calculations for the terrestrial zone around solar-type stars show that individual collisions between 100 km and larger objects are visible as short-lived increases in the disk luminosity (Kenyon & Bromley 2004b, see also Grogan et al. 2001). Beyond 30 AU, individual collisions are not visible as discrete events in our calculations (Kenyon & Bromley 2004a). Here, we consider a broader suite of calculations designed to test the visibility of individual collisions at 1 -- 100 AU. To evolve a particle disk in time, we follow the Safronov (1969) statistical approach to calculate the collisional evolution of an ensemble of planetesimals in orbit around a star of mass M⋆ and luminosity L⋆ (Kenyon & Bromley 2004c, and references therein). The model grid contains N concentric annuli with widths δai centered at heliocentric distances ai. Calculations begin with a differential mass distribution n(mik) of bodies with orbital eccentricity eik(t) and inclination iik(t). To evolve the mass and velocity distributions in time, we solve the coagulation and Fokker-Planck equations for bodies undergoing inelastic collisions, drag forces, and long- range gravitational interactions (Kenyon & Bromley 2002). We adopt collision rates from kinetic theory -- the particle-in-a-box method -- and use an energy-scaling algorithm to assign collision outcomes (Kenyon & Bromley 2004c). We derive changes in orbital parameters from gas drag, dynamical friction, and viscous stirring (Adachi et al. 1976; Ohtsuki, Stewart, -- 11 -- & Ida 2002). Dynamical friction transfers kinetic energy from large bodies to small bodies and drives a system to energy equipartition. Viscous stirring transfers angular momentum between bodies and increases the velocities of all planetesimals. To compute dust masses and luminosities, we use the dust production rates and particle scale heights derived from the coagulation code as input to a dust evolution code (Kenyon & Bromley 2004a). This calculation includes collisions between dust grains and Poynting- Robertson drag. We use a simple radiative transfer method to derive the optical depth through the disk; dust luminosities follow from the scale height derived from the coagulation code. Our numerical calculations begin with 1 -- 1000 m planetesimals in 32 -- 64 concentric annuli with initial surface density Σ = Σ0 (a/1 AU)−3/2 (see, for example, Kenyon & Luu 1999; Kenyon & Bromley 2004a,b). Table 1 lists ain and aout, the inner and outer radii of the computational grid, ρ, the mass density of a planetesimal, Σ0, and tg, the timescale for exponential gas removal (Kenyon & Luu 1999). We divide the initial continuous mass distribution of planetesimals into a differential mass distribution with discrete mass batches. The spacing between successive mass batches is δ = mi+1/mi. We add mass batches as planetesimals grow in mass. Each planetesimal batch begins in a nearly circular orbit with eccentricity e0 and inclination i0 = e0/2. For these calculations, δ = 1.4 -- 2 and e0 = 10−5 -- 10−4. In the next two sections, we consider the evolution of icy and rocky planetesimals in orbit around solar-type and A-type stars. Because our calculations do not include gas accretion, we avoid the region of the gas giant planets and restrict our attention to the terrestrial zone and the region of the Kuiper belt around solar-type stars. For A-type stars, we consider two representative regions at 3 -- 20 AU and at 30 -- 150 AU. Although gas giants may form around A-type stars, our calculations provide reasonable estimates for the formation of the rocky or icy cores of gas giants. As a planetary core accretes gas from the disk, it will continue to stir up the leftover planetesimals and remove the debris more rapidly than estimated in our calculations. Thus our estimates for the lifetimes and dust luminosity of debris disks are probably reasonable upper limits for these systems. 3.2. Solar-type stars: results at 0.4 -- 2 AU and 30 -- 150 AU At 1 AU, the growth of planetesimals into planets follows a standard pattern (Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Weidenschilling et al. 1997). All bodies begin with small orbital eccentric- ities. Gas drag maintains small e for the smallest bodies; dynamical friction maintains small -- 12 -- e for the largest bodies. Thus, collisions produce larger bodies instead of smaller fragments. After ∼ 104 yr, 1000 km and larger bodies form and stir up the orbits of planetesimals with radii of 0.1 -- 10 km. Collisions between the leftover planetesimals then produce smaller fragments. The largest bodies sweep up some of the fragments, but most of the fragments collide with other fragments to produce still smaller fragments. Because the largest bodies are nearly immune to fragmentation, this collisional cascade concentrates most of the initial mass in the largest and the smallest bodies. During the earliest stages of our calculations, the collisional cascade produces an ob- servable amount of dust (Figure 4). After ∼ 103 yr, the dust produces an order of magnitude more radiation at mid-infrared (mid-IR) wavelengths than the central solar-type star. Con- tinued dust production maintains a roughly constant mid-IR excess for ∼ 106 yr. Because the large bodies are slowly depleted, the dust production rate then slows and the mid-IR excess declines. In these calculations, the mid-IR excess becomes comparable to the stellar radiation after ∼ a few × 107 yr. In addition to the slow evolution of the 'background' mid-IR excess, individual collisions produce large spikes in the dust luminosity (Figure 4). During the early stages of the evolution, collisions between large objects tend to produce even larger objects and are also too frequent for any single, disruptive collision to modify the mid-IR excess significantly. As the average dust production rate declines, individual collisions between large objects are less frequent but produce more dust. Thus, after ∼ 106 yr, spikes from large collisions dominate the evolution of the mid-IR luminosity. To learn more about the nature of these spikes, we consider the dust production rate as a function of time (Figure 5). At this point in the evolution (∼ 5 × 106 yr), numerous collisions between small objects set the background dust production rate. Because we use a random number generator to assign collision outcomes (Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Kenyon & Luu 1998), an occasional lack of collisions leads to a smaller than average dust production rate. In addition, occasional collisions between larger objects produce distinct spikes in the dust production rate. The frequency distribution of the spikes in the dust production rate tracks the size distribution of large bodies; small spikes are much more frequent than large spikes. The smaller spikes, where the dust production rate is a few times the background rate, produce little change in the mid-IR excess. Larger spikes -- produced by collisions between 100 km or larger objects -- yield fluctuations in the mid-IR excess ranging from a few percent to more than 100%. The largest fluctuations in Figure 5 produce the largest spikes in the evolution of the mid-IR excess shown in Figure 4. At 30 AU, the evolution follows a different path. Because the orbital periods are longer and the surface density smaller, planets take much longer to form at 30 AU than at 1 AU. -- 13 -- Large bodies begin to form at ∼ 10 Myr and soon contain a few percent of the initial mass. These objects stir up leftover planetesimals along their orbits and begin the collisional cascade. In these models, large bodies grow more slowly, and the leftovers are more easily shattered. Collisions then efficiently convert most of the initial mass into smaller objects which are removed by radiation pressure and Poynting-Robertson drag. Thus, the final ensemble of large bodies contains less than 5%, and sometimes less than 1%, of the initial mass in solid objects. The evolution of the IR excess is also different at 30 AU than at 1 AU (Figure 6). Because the dust is farther away from the central star, the dust is cooler, ∼ 30 -- 40 K instead of ∼ 300 -- 400 K. At the start of our calculations, this dust produces a significant IR excess, which slowly declines as small bodies merge into larger bodies. Once the collisional cascade begins at ∼ 10 Myr, the far-IR excess rises significantly. At shorter wavelengths, the dust produces a small excess. As in calculations at 1 AU, the cascade maintains a roughly constant excess until planet formation reaches the outer edge of the disk at 100 -- 150 AU. Poynting- Robertson drag and radiation pressure then remove small grains faster than collisions can replenish them. The IR excess then rapidly declines. However, individual collisions never contribute a significant amount to the IR excess. In our calculations, the evolution of the IR excess is smooth, with 1% -- 2% fluctuations about the general trend. In our calculations at 30 AU, there are several reasons for the lack of significant spikes in the IR excess. Because the collisional cascade is efficient at removing 1 -- 10 km bodies from the evolution, few of these objects grow into 100 km and larger objects. Collisions between individual objects also do not produce an observable amount of dust (Figs. 1 -- 2). To test the relative importance of these processes, we calculated several models with more robust planetesimals, where the collisional cascade leaves more material in larger bodies. These calculations suggest that individual collisions never produce observable amounts of dust. Our suite of calculations confirms the basic conclusions of our analytic model. At 30 AU, binary collisions never produce an observable IR excess. Although the dust in our calculations produces a large far-IR excess, the evolution of the excess is very smooth. At 1 AU, occasional collisions between large objects produce observable changes in the mid-IR excess. Small, few percent, changes in the mid-IR excess should recur on timescales of tens to hundreds of years. Large changes are much less frequent and recur on thousand year or longer timescales. -- 14 -- 3.3. A-type stars: results at 3 -- 20 AU and 30 -- 150 AU Calculations for planet formation around A-type stars follow the same pattern as for solar-type stars. During the early stages, runaway growth leads to the formation of proto- planets with radii of 1000 km and larger. At 3 AU, it takes about 105 yr for 1000 -- 2000 km objects to form. Due to the large gradient in surface density, the growth of large bodies slowly propagates to larger distances (Lissauer 1987). The timescale for the formation of 1000 km objects is ∼ 106 yr at 9 AU and ∼ 107 yr at 18 -- 20 AU. Once large planets form, their gravity stirs up the leftover planetesimals along their orbits. Collisions then produce fragments instead of mergers, and the collisional cascade In simulations at 3 -- 20 AU, the dust luminosity starts to rise at ∼ 104 yr and begins. peaks at ∼ 106 yr (Figure 7). As planet formation moves from ∼ 10 AU to ∼ 20 AU, the dust produced in the collisional cascade has smaller optical depth and subtends a smaller solid angle as seen from the central star. Thus, the dust luminosity declines. Once planet formation reaches the outer edge of the 20 AU disk, Poynting-Robertson drag removes dust more rapidly than collisions can replenish it. The dust luminosity then declines more rapidly and falls to very small levels in ∼ 109 yr. In calculations at 30 -- 150 AU (Kenyon & Bromley 2004a), planet formation leads to dust production on much longer timescales. In these models, large planets begin to form at the inner edge of the disk at 10 -- 20 Myr. After 1 Gyr, planet formation reaches the outer edge of the disk. Throughout this period, the collisional cascade maintains a large reservoir of small dust grains, which produce a measurable dust luminosity (Figure 7). From 10 Myr to 1 Gyr, the dust luminosity smoothly declines from LD/L0 ∼ 10−3 to LD/L0 ∼ 10−4. After 1 Gyr, Poynting-Robertson drag rapidly removes dust and the dust luminosity declines more rapidly. Figure 8 shows the evolution of the 25 µm excess for a planetesimal disk around an A-type star with mass M⋆ = 3 M⊙, luminosity L⋆ = 50 L⊙, and temperature T⋆ = 9500 K. In both cases, the excess first declines with time as small bodies merge into larger and larger bodies. Once the collisional cascade begins, the 24 µm excess rises. Small fluctuations from individual collisions mark the rise of the excess at 3 AU. At 30 AU, the rise is smooth. At the peak of both calculations, small fluctuations in the excess are apparent. At 3 AU, individual collisions produce the small fluctuations. At 30 AU, the occasional merger of large objects produces more stirring and a temporary increase in the dust production rate. These results also confirm the basic predictions of the analytic collision model. In planetesimal disks surrounding A-type stars, binary collisions at 3 -- 5 AU produce modest, ∼ 10%, fluctuations in the mid-IR excess. Farther out in the disk, binary collisions do not -- 15 -- produce enough dust to change the amount of mid-IR excess. However, mergers of larger objects can produce modest fluctuations in the mid-IR excess by increasing the local stirring rate, which leads to more dust and a larger mid-IR excess. 4. N-BODY CALCULATIONS When binary collisions occur, our model predicts two observable changes in the lumi- nosity. After a collision produces a debris cloud, we expect a rapid rise in infrared brightness. As orbital shear spreads the debris cloud into a ring, secondary collisions with material in the rest of the disk remove smaller particles. The mid-infrared flux then declines. In our picture, this decline occurs on the timescale for the cloud to spread into a ring, ∼ 102 orbital periods. For edge-on systems, we expect the debris cloud to eclipse the central star. The predicted eclipse depth ranges from ∼ 0.5 mag for large collisions to less than 0.01 mag for smaller collisions. As the debris cloud spreads into a ring, the eclipses should last longer and become shallower. This behavior distinguishes a debris cloud from the transit of an exosolar planet, where the eclipse depth and duration are constant (see, for example, Alonso et al. 2004, and references therein). To illustrate the appearance of eclipses from a debris cloud, we use N-body simulations to follow the evolution of debris following a major two body collision. For these examples, we consider collisions between equal mass bodies with radius 300 km and 1000 km. To begin the evolution, we place 10,000 "dust" particles in a small volume of radius rc/a = 10−3 around a guiding center on a circular orbit around a star of mass M⋆ = 1 M⊙. We give each dust particle a relative velocity V /VK ∼ 10−3. In one configuration, the positions and velocities have Gaussian random distributions (generating a "random blob"). In another configuration, the particle density declines as r−2 out to radius rc, with velocities proportional to the distance from the guiding center (yielding a homologous "explosion"). These two configurations represent two reasonable choices for the initial velocity distribution (e.g., Michel et al 2001). Each N-body particle represents a population of dust with mass distributed according to equation (10), with α = 3.5. The minimum size of the dust particles is 1 µm. We set the maximum size in one of two ways. In the first case, we assume that all of the mass in the collision goes into "dust particles" with a single-index power law size distribution and a single large remnant containing 10% -- 15% of the mass. In the second model we suppose that 20% of the mass ends up in a single large object, with the remaining 80% in dust -- 16 -- with a maximum radius of 10 km. Although these choices do not exhaust the possible mass configurations following a completely disruptive collision, they provide a good illustration of the range of eclipse depths and evolution with time. To derive the properties of the eclipses, we calculate the position of the particles on Keplerian orbits evaluated with an 8th-order ODE solver. We divide the surface of a star with radius 1 R⊙ into O(100) elements and project the particle positions onto the stellar disk. For each path from the observer through the particles to the stellar disk, we compute i(t) = e−τ (t)Ii, where the unobscured the optical depth τ (t) and the emergent intensity I ′ intensity from the star is I0 = P Ii. This procedure assumes that the mass distribution for all particles is identical. We then derive a light curve from -2.5 log (P I ′ Figure 9 illustrates light curves for the collision of two 1000 km objects. The lower (upper) panel shows results for a random blob (explosion) when a large remnant contains 20% of the initial mass. In both simulations, the eclipse depth is ∼ 0.5 -- 0.7 mag ∼ 6 months after the collision. Each eclipse lasts ∼ 5 -- 10 days, ∼ 2% to 4% of the orbital period. After 10 -- 20 orbits, the eclipses are ∼ 10% of their original depth and last ∼ 10 times longer than eclipses immediately after the collision. After ∼ 100 orbits, dust from both the blob and the explosion lies in a roughly uniform ring around the star. Although tiny eclipses remain visible, most of the dust produces a uniform extinction of ∼ 2% to 3% of the stellar flux. i(t))/I0. In these simulations, dust from the random blob expands more rapidly and merges into the background debris disk faster than dust from the explosion. This behavior is a feature of the initial conditions. In the homologous explosion, the dust particles are less concentrated to the center, which produces shallower eclipses relative to the random blob. However, particles close to the center of the explosion expand more slowly than those in the blob. Thus, these particles remain closer to the point of the collision and continue to produce narrow, shallow eclipses when most of the rest of the blob has expanded into a ring. Figure 10 repeats Figure 9 for the collision of two 300 km bodies. Because these collisions produce less dust, the eclipses have roughly the same duration but are shallower. As for the collision of 1000 km bodies, the eclipses slowly fade away and last a longer and longer fraction of the orbital period. After 30 -- 100 orbits, orbital shear transforms the debris cloud into a ring, which obscures ∼ 1% to 2% of the stellar surface. Figure 11 compares results for configurations where we place all of the debris in "dust" particles with radii of 10 km or smaller. The lower (upper) panel shows light curves for the collision of two 1000 km (300 km) bodies. Compared to configurations where 20% of the initial mass in contained in a single large object (Figures 9 -- 10), the optical depth in the debris cloud is larger and eclipses are much deeper. The timescale for the cloud to expand -- 17 -- into a ring is identical to the timescale derived for the other cases. Thus, the magnitude of the eclipses declines over 30 -- 100 orbital periods. These calculations illustrate the simplest evolution of a debris cloud formed in a large binary collision. Calculations with more complex initial configurations produce a remarkable variety of eclipse light curves. Shepherd moons or planets can confine the debris cloud and thus can slow the decline of the eclipse depth with time. Planets in orbits inclined to the orbital plane of the debris cloud lead to a precessing cloud or ring with very different eclipse morphology. Winn et al. (2004) and Chiang & Murray-Clay (2004) show how the eclipse morphology changes when an opaque cloud or ring orbits an eccentric binary star and apply their results to the young variable star KH 15D (Hamilton et al. 2001). We derive similar results when a debris cloud spreads into a ring. Because the range of possible geometries is large, the discovery of additional eclipsing systems with rings or blobs of dust will guide future numerical calculations. 5. DISCUSSION AND SUMMARY During the late stages of planet formation, binary collisions between leftover, large planetesimals in orbit around solar-type stars are potentially observable. At 1 AU, these collisions produce large spikes, ∼ 1 mag or less, in the mid-infrared luminosity (Figure 4). In systems viewed edge-on, the debris cloud eclipses the parent star (Figures 9 -- 11). Maximum eclipse depths range from ∼ 0.5 mag for collisions between 1000 km objects to ∼ 0.01 mag or less for collisions between 100 -- 300 km objects. Typical eclipses last 5 -- 10 days. As the debris cloud expands into a ring, the eclipses fade and grow longer. The lifetime of the debris cloud as a distinct entity is ∼ 102 orbital periods. At large distances from the parent star, & 3 AU, binary collisions are more difficult to detect. Because collisions are less frequent and produce less dust, they are harder to detect against the emission from the background debris disk. Our results indicate that the maximum luminosity from individual collisions declines as a−3.5 (equation 12). Wyatt & Dent (2002) derive similar conclusions from different approaches. To estimate the likelihood of detecting binary collisions, we consider Kepler3, a satel- lite designed to detect the transits of exosolar planets across their parent star. During a 4 yr mission, the Kepler team plans to acquire very high precision photometry for 105 stars. Roughly 0.5% of these stars have favorable orbital inclinations to detect transits from terres- 3http://www.kepler.arc.nasa.gov -- 18 -- trial planets. For the planned observing frequency of once every few hours and an expected precision of 0.01% or better, the expected detection rate is ∼ 50 -- 100 terrestrial planets per 105 stars. To modify this estimate for the detection of debris clouds, we use the results from our coagulation and n-body calculations. Because the scale height of the debris disk is larger than the radius of a terrestrial planet, ∼ 2% to 3% of potential solar systems have orientations that produce eclipses. If the lifetime of the collision phase is a few hundred Myr, ∼ 10% of Kepler targets are young enough to observe collisions. Thus, eclipses from debris clouds are possible in ∼ a few hundred stars of the Kepler sample. To estimate the probability of detecting binary collisions in these stars, we adopt the collision rates from the coagulation calculations and the lifetimes derived from the n-body results. For the anticipated precision of Kepler, binary collisions between 100 km objects yield a detectable eclipse. With a collision rate of 10−2 yr−1 for these objects, the probability of a collision during the Kepler lifetime is roughly 100%. In a 4 yr mission, the eclipse depth can change by a factor of two or more. The duration of each eclipse lengthens to maintain a roughly constant total optical depth, integrated over the complete eclipse. The prospect for observing collisions between the largest objects is poorer but still significant. The rate for collisions between two 1000 km objects is . 10−5 yr−1. This rate yields a ∼ 1% probability for detecting one large collision during the Kepler mission. However, with a typical lifetime of 30 -- 100 yr, the probability of observing eclipses after a large collision is ∼ 10 times larger than observing a collision during the mission. Thus, it is possible that Kepler will detect eclipses from the aftermath of one large collision between two 1000 km objects. These eclipses should lengthen and decrease in depth throughout the 4 yr Kepler mission. 2003; Pont et al. Ground-based surveys could also detect collisions in the terrestrial zone. The OGLE and TRES projects have identified several transiting exosolar planets (Alonso et al. 2004; 2004). The PASS project envisions a complete survey Konacki et al. of planetary transits for all stars with V ∼ 5.5 -- 10.5 (Deeg et al. 2004). As part of a much deeper all-sky survey, Pan-STARRS4 might also detect eclipses from debris clouds. To detect the unique signal from a large two body collision, these projects need to distinguish real events with diminishing depth and lengthening duration from spurious signals and from repetitive eclipses with constant depth and duration. Successful detections of the dust produced in large two body collisions can teach us about 4http://pan-starrs.ifa.hawaii.edu/public/index.html -- 19 -- terrestrial planet formation. Characterizing the frequency of events associated with stars of different ages and spectral types yields estimates for the space density of large bodies as a function of stellar mass and age. Simultaneous optical, infrared, and submm observations provide measures of the dust albedo and size distribution. Coupled with direct detection of exosolar terrestrial planets, measurements of the properties of the terrestrial environment allow a better understanding of the formation of the Earth-Moon system and, ultimately, the formation of the current environment on the Earth and other terrestrial planets. We acknowledge a generous allotment, ∼ 1000 cpu days, of computer time on the Silicon Graphics Origin-2000 'Alhena' at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory through funding from the NASA Offices of Mission to Planet Earth, Aeronautics, and Space Science. T. Currie, M. Geller, J. Winn, and an anonymous referee provided helpful comments on the manuscript. The NASA Astrophysics Theory Program supported part of this project through grant NAG5- 13278. REFERENCES Adachi, I., Hayashi, C., & Nakazawa, K. 1976, Progress of Theoretical Physics 56, 1756 Agnor, C. B., Canup, R. M., & Levison, H. F. 1999, Icarus, 142, 219 Alonso, R., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, L153 Alvarez, L. W., Alvarez, W., Asaro, F., & Michel, H. V. 1980, Science, 208, 1095 Artymowicz, P. 1997, ARE&PS, 25, 175 Asphaug, E., & Benz, W. 1996, Icarus, 121, 225 Aumann, H. H., Beichman, C. A., Gillett, F. C., de Jong, T., Houck, J. R., Low, F. J., Neugebauer, G., Walker, R. G., & Wesselius, P. R. 1984, ApJ, 278, L23 Backman, D. E., & Paresce, F. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III, eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 1253 Bernstein, G. M., Trilling, D. E., Allen, R. L., Brown, M. E., Holman, M., & Malhotra, R. 2004, AJ, 128, 1364 Benz, W., & Asphaug, E. 1999, Icarus, 142, 5 -- 20 -- Benz, W., Slattery, W. L., & Cameron, A. G. W. 1986, Icarus, 66, 515 Cameron, A. G. W., & Ward, W. R. 1976, Abstracts of the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference, vol 7, p. 120 Campo Bagatin, A., & Petit, J.-M. 2001, Icarus, 149, 210 Canup, R. 2004a, Icarus, 168, 433 Canup, R. 2004b, ARA&A, 42, 441 Chambers, J. E. 2001, Icarus, 152, 205 Chiang, E. I., & Murray-Clay, R. A. 2004, ApJ, 607, 913 Cohen, B. A., Swindle, T. D., & Kring, D. A. 2000, Science, 290, 1754 Connolly, Jr., H. C. 2005, Science, 307, 75 Davis, D. R., Chapman, C. R., Weidenschilling, S. J., & Greenberg, R. 1985, Icarus, 62, 30 Deeg, H. J., Alonso, R., Belmonte, J. A., Alsubai, K., Horne, K., Doyle, L. 2004, PASP, 116, 985 Dohnanyi, J. W. 1969, J. Geophys. Res., 74, 2531 Dominik, C., & Decin, G. 2003, ApJ, 598, 626 Durda, D. D., & Dermott, S. F. 2002, Icarus, 130, 140 Durda, D. D., Greenberg, R., Jedicke, R. 1998, Icarus, 135, 431 Durda, D. D., Bottke, W. F., Enke, B. L., Merline, W. J., Asphaug, E., Richardson, D. C., & Leinhardt, Z. M. 2004, Icarus, 170, 242 Grogan, K., Dermott, S. F., & Durda, D. D. 2001, Icarus, 152, 251 Greaves, J. S. 2005, Sci., 307, 68 Greaves, J. S., Holland, W. S., Wyatt, M. C., Dent, W. R. F., Robson, E. I., Coulson, I. M., Jenness, T., Moriarty-Schieven, G. H., Davis, G. R., Butner, H. M., Gear, W. K., Dominik, C., & Walker, H. J. 2005, ApJ, 619, L187 Habing, H. J., et al. 2001, A&A, 365, 545 Hamilton, C. M., Herbst, W., Shih, C., & Ferro, A. 2001, ApJ, 554, L201 -- 21 -- Hartmann, W. K. 1975, Icarus, 24, 181 Hartmann, W. K. 1980, In Conference on the Lunar Highlands Crust, edited by J. Papike & R. Merrill, Pergamon, New York, p. 155 Hartmann, W. K., & Davis, D. R. 1975, Icarus, 24, 504 Hartmann, W. K., Ryder, G., Dones, L., & Grinspoon, D. H. 2000, In Origin of the Earth and Moon, edited by R. Canup & K. Righter, UofA Press, Tucson, p. 493 Hayashi, C. 1981, Prog Theor Phys Suppl, 70, 35 Holsapple, K. A. 1994, Planet. Space Sci., 42, 1067 Housen, K., & Holsapple, K. 1990, Icarus, 84, 226 Housen, K., & Holsapple, K. 1999, Icarus, 142, 21 Itoh, S., & Yurimoto, H. 2003, Nature, 423, 7281 Kalas, P. 1998, Earth, Moon, & Planets, 81, 27 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2002, AJ, 123, 1757 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004a, AJ, 127, 513 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004b, ApJ, 602, L133 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004c, AJ, 128, 1916 Kenyon, S. J., & Luu, J. X. 1998, AJ, 115, 2136 Kenyon, S. J., & Luu, J. X. 1999, AJ, 118, 1101 Koeberl, C. 2003, EM&P, 92, 79 Konacki, M., Torres, G., Sasselov, D. D., Pietrzyski, G., Udalski, A., Jha, S., Ruiz, M. T.; Gieren, W., Minniti, D. 2003, ApJ, 609, L37 Leinhardt, Z. M., & Richardson, D. C. 2000, Icarus, 146, 133 Leinhardt, Z. M., & Richardson, D. C. 2002, Icarus, 159, 306 Levison, H. F., Dones, L. Chapman, C. R., Stern, S. A., Duncan, M. J., & Zahnle, K. 2001, Icarus, 151, 286 -- 22 -- Lissauer, J. J. 1987, Icarus, 69, 249 Melosh, H. J., Vockery, A. M., & Tonks, W. B. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III, eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 1339 Michel, P., Benz, W., & Richardson, D. C. 2004, P&SS, 52, 1109 Michel, P., Benz, W., Tanga, P., & Richardson, D. C. 2001, Science, 294, 1696 Michel, P., Tanga, P., Benz, W., & Richardson, D. C. 2002, Icarus, 160, 10 Nesvorn´y, D., Bottke, W. F., Dones, L., & Levison, H. F. 2002a, Nature, 417, 720 Nesvorn´y, D., Morbidelli, A., Vokrouhlick´y, D., Bottke, W. F., & Broz, M. 2002b, Icarus, 157, 155 Neukum, G. 1983, Meteoritenbombardement und Datierung Planetarer Oberflaechen Ohtsuki, K., Stewart, G. R., & Ida, S. 2002, Icarus, 155, 436 Pan, M., & Sari, R. 2005, Icarus, 173, 342 Pont, F., Bouchy, F., Queloz, D., Santos, N. C., Melo, C., Mayor, M., & Udry, S. 2004, A&A, 426, L15 Rieke, G. H., Su, K. Y. L., Stansberry, J. A., Trilling, D., Bryden, G., Muzerolle, J., White, B., Gorlova, N., Young, E. T., Beichman, C. A., Stapelfeldt, K. R., & hines, D. C. 2005, ApJ, 620, 1010 Ryder, G. 1988, in it Workshop on Moon and Transition: Apollo 14, KREEP, and Evolved Lunar Rocks, p. 71 Ryder, G. 2002, J. Geophys. Res., 107, E4, 6-1 Safronov, V. S. 1969, Evolution of the Protoplanetary Cloud and Formation of the Earth and Planets, Nauka, Moscow [Translation 1972, NASA TT F-677] Stern, S. A. 1994, AJ, 108, 2312 Stern, S. A., & Colwell, J. E. 1997, AJ, 114, 841 Strom, R. G., Schaber, G. G., & Dawsow, D. D. 1994, JGR, 99, 10899 Swindle, T. D. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III, eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 867 -- 23 -- Tera, F., Papanastassiou, D. A., & Wasserburg, G. J. 1974, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett., 22, 1 Th´ebault, P., Augereau, J. C., & Beust, H. 2003, A&A, 408, 775 Uzzo, M., Raymond, J. C., Biesecker, D., Marsden, B., Wood, C., Ko, Y.-K., & Wu, R. 2001, ApJ, 558, 403 Wadhwa, M., & Russell, S. S. 2000, in Protostars abd Planets IV, eds. V. Mannings, A. P. Boss, & S. S. Russell, Tucson, Univ. of Arizona, p. 995 Weidenschilling, S. J. 1977, Astrophys Sp Sci, 51, 153 Weidenschilling, S. J., Spaute, D., Davis, D. R., Marzari, F., & Ohtsuki, K. 1997, Icarus, 128, 429 Wetherill, G. W., & Stewart, G. R. 1993, Icarus, 106, 190 USGS Prof. Pap, 1348, 1987 Williams, D. R., & Wetherill, G. W. 1994, Icarus, 107, 117 Winn, J. N., Holman, M. J., Johnson, J. A.; Stanek, K. Z., & Garnavich, Peter M. 2004, ApJ, 603, L45 Wood, J. A. Geochimica & Cosmochimica Acta, 68, 4007 Wyatt, M. C., & Dent, W. R. F. 2002, MNRAS, 334, 589 Yin, Q., Jacobsen, S. B., Yamashita, K., Blichert-Toft, J., T´elouk, P.; Albar`ede, F. 2002, Nature, 418, 949 Zhang, B., & Sigurdsson, S. 2003, ApJ, 596, L95 Zuckerman, B. 2001, ARA&A, 39, 549 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2. e = 0.2 -- 24 -- 6.0 5.5 8.0 7.5 7.0 6.5 1 AU 10 AU 100 AU 8 4 5 7 log Projectile Radius (cm) 6 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 -16 -18 -20 i y t i s o n m u L e v l i t a e R g o l Fig. 1. -- Luminosity of debris clouds as a function of projectile radius at 1 AU (solid curves), 10 AU (dot-dashed curves), and 100 AU (dashed curves). The log of the target radius (in cm) is listed to the right of each solid curve. The target radii for the other curves follow the same pattern. The curves assume bulk properties of (a) basalts from Benz & Asphaug (1999) at 1 -- 10 AU, and (b) modified ices from Benz & Asphaug (1999) as listed in the main text. At 1 AU, collisions between 100 km and larger objects produce observable debris clouds. At 3 AU and beyond, individual debris clouds are not visible. -- 25 -- 8.0 7.5 7.0 6.5 e = 0.2 6.0 5.5 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12 i y t i s o n m u L e v l i t a e R g o l -14 -16 -18 4 5 7 log Projectile Radius (cm) 6 1 AU 100 AU 8 Fig. 2. -- As in Figure 1 for objects with (a) bulk properties for asteroids from Durda, Green- berg, & Jedicke (1998, solid curves), and (b) bulk properties of rubble piles from Leinhardt & Richardson (2002, dashed curves). -- 26 -- 7.5 8.0 7.0 e = 0.2 5.5 6.5 6.0 h t p e D l a c i t p O g o l 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -10 -12 -14 1 AU 10 AU 100 AU 8 4 5 7 log Projectile Radius (cm) 6 Fig. 3. -- Optical depths for the models in Figure 1. -- 27 -- 1.5 0 , 4 2 F / 4 2 F g o l 1.0 0.5 0.0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 log Time (yr) Fig. 4. -- Evolution of the 24 µm excess as a function of time for planetesimal disks at 1.0 AU. The radial extent of the disk is 0.68 -- 1.32 AU (0.4 -- 2.0 AU) for the dashed (solid) curve. In both cases, formation of lunar mass objects leads to the production of copious amounts of dust and a significant excess of radiation at 24 µm (F24/F24,0 > 1). As objects grow into Mars-sized or larger planets, less frequent collisions produce smaller amounts of dust. Individual large collisions are then responsible for large increases in the dust excess. -- 28 -- 22 ) 1 - r y g ( e t a r n o i t c u d o r P t s u D g o l 21 20 19 18 0 500 1000 1500 Time (yr) Fig. 5. -- Variation of the dust production rate with time for the 0.4 -- 2 AU calculation in Figure 4 at 5 ×106 yr. Numerous collisions between 1 m to 1 km objects produce the roughly constant dust production rate of ∼ 5 × 1018 g yr−1. Binary collisions produce occasional spikes in the dust production rate. -- 29 -- 450 µm 60 µm 3 2 / 0 F D F g o l 1 0 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (yr) Fig. 6. -- Evolution of the IR excess at 60 µm and at 450 µm for a planetesimal disk at 30 -- 80 AU around a solar-type star. -- 30 -- -2 -3 -4 -5 -6 3-20 AU 30-150 AU 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr) / 0 L D L g o l Fig. 7. -- Evolution of the dust luminosity for models at 3 -- 20 AU and at 30 -- 150 AU. The central A-type star has M⋆ = 3M⊙, L⋆ = 50L⊙, and T⋆ = 9500 K. Binary collisions produce the small variations in dust luminosity at the peak luminosity of each model. During the decline, individual collisions are not visible as distinct luminosity spikes. -- 31 -- 0 , 4 2 F / 4 2 F g o l 1.5 1.0 0.5 3-20 AU 30-150 AU 0.0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr) Fig. 8. -- As in Figure 7 for the 24 µm excess. -- 32 -- 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 ) s e d u t i n g a m ( s s e n t h g i r b e v l i t a e R Explosion Random Blob 0.5 yr 1.5 4.0 10 25 0.5 yr 1.5 2.5 5.0 25 -15 -10 -5 0 Time (days) 5 10 15 Fig. 9. -- Variation in brightness of a solar-type star eclipsed by a debris cloud formed from the collision of two 1000 km objects at 1 AU. In these calculations, a large remnant contains ∼ 15% of the initial mass; the remaining mass is in smaller objects with a power-law size distribution (q = 3.5). The legend in each panel indicates the time after the collision for each curve. Orbital shear and internal expansion of the cloud produce the gradual evolution in eclipse depth and duration. -- 33 -- 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 ) s e d u t i n g a m ( s s e n t h g i r b e v l i t a e R Explosion Random Blob 0.5 yr 1.5 3.0 8.0 25 0.5 yr 1.5 2.5 5.0 25 -15 -10 -5 0 Time (days) 5 10 15 Fig. 10. -- As in Figure 9 for the collision of two 300 km objects. -- 34 -- 0.0 0.1 300 km objects 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 1000 km objects ) s e d u t i n g a m ( s s e n t h g i r b e v l i t a e R 0.5 yr 1.0 2.0 5.0 25 0.5 yr 2.0 3.5 5.0 25 -15 -10 -5 0 Time (days) 5 10 15 Fig. 11. -- As in Figures 9 -- 10 for collisions where 20% of the mass is in a single large remnant and 80% of the mass is in objects with radii of 10 km or smaller. -- 35 -- Table 1. Model Parameters Parameter Symbol G Star Models A Star Models Stellar mass (M⊙) Stellar luminosity (L⊙) Inner radius (AU) Outer radius (AU) Particle mass density (g cm−3) Surface density at 1 AU (g cm−2) Gas removal timescale (yr) M⋆ L⋆ ain aout ρ Σ0 tg A 1 1 0.4 2.0 3.0 B 1 1 30 150 1.5 7.5 -- 30 106 -- 107 15 -- 60 107 A B 3 75 3 20 3.0 5 -- 50 106 -- 107 3 75 30 150 1.5 5 -- 50 107
astro-ph/0409532	1	0409	2004-09-22T09:20:45	The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have observed 44 planetary nebulae (PNe) in the direction of the Galactic bulge, and merged our data with published ones. We have distinguished, in the merged sample of 164 PNe, those PNe most likely to prtain physically to the Galactic bulge and those most likely to belong to the Galactic disk. We have determined the chemical composition of all the 164 objects in a coherent way. We looked for stellar emission features and discovered 14 new [WR] stars and 15 new weak emission line central stars. The analyzed data led us to the following conclusions: (1) The spectral type distribution of [WR] stars is very different in the bulge and in the disk of the Galaxy. However, the observed distributions are strongly dependent on selection effects. (2) The proportion of [WR] PNe is significantly larger in the bulge than in the disk. (3) The oxygen abundances in [WR] stars do no appear to be significantly affected by nucleosynthesis and mixing in the progenitors. (4) The O/H gradient of the Galactic disk PNe population flattens in the most internal parts of the Galaxy. (5) The median oxygen abundance in the bulge PN population is larger by 0.2 dex than in the disk population seen in the direction of the bulge. (6) Bulge PNe with smaller O/H tend to have smaller radial velocities. (7) The oxygen abundance distribution of bulge PNe is similar in shape to that of the metallicity distribution of bulge giants, but significantly narrower. (8) The location of SB 32 (PN G 349.7-09.1) in the (V_lsr, l_II) diagram and its low oxygen abundance argues that it probably belongs to the halo population.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. 0064 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) October 17, 2018 The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge ⋆ Chemical abundances and Wolf-Rayet central stars G´orny, S. K.1, Stasi´nska, G.2, Escudero, A. V.3, and Costa, R. D. D.3 1 Copernicus Astronomical center, Rabia´nska 8, 87-100 Toru´n, Poland e-mail: [email protected] 2 LUTH, Observatoire de Meudon, 5 Place Jules Janssen, F-92195 Meudon Cedex, France e-mail: [email protected] 3 Departamento de Astronomia, Instituto de Astronomia, Geof´ısica e Ciencias Atmosf´ericas da USP, Rua do Matao 1226, 05508-090, Sao Paulo, Brazil Received ???; accepted ??? Abstract. We have observed 44 planetary nebulae (PNe) in the direction of the Galactic bulge, and merged our data with published ones. We have distinguished, in the merged sample of 164 PNe, those PNe most likely to prtain physically to the Galactic bulge and those most likely to belong to the Galactic disk. We have determined the chemical composition of all the 164 objects in a coherent way. We looked for stellar emission features and discovered 14 new [WR] stars and 15 new weak emission line central stars. The analyzed data led us to the following conclusions: (1) The spectral type distribution of [WR] stars is very different in the bulge and in the disk of the Galaxy. However, the observed distributions are strongly dependent on selection effects. (2) The proportion of [WR] PNe is significantly larger in the bulge than in the disk. (3) The oxygen abundances in [WR] stars do no appear to be significantly affected by nucleosynthesis and mixing in the progenitors. (4) The O/H gradient of the Galactic disk PNe population flattens in the most internal parts of the Galaxy. (5) The median oxygen abundance in the bulge PN population is larger by 0.2 dex than in the disk population seen in the direction of the bulge. (6) Bulge PNe with smaller O/H tend to have smaller radial velocities. (7) The oxygen abundance distribution of bulge PNe is similar in shape to that of the metallicity distribution of bulge giants, but significantly narrower. (8) The location of SB 32 (PN G 349.7-09.1) in the (Vlsr, lII) diagram and its low oxygen abundance argues that it probably belongs to the halo population. Key words. stars: Wolf-Rayet -- ISM: planetary nebulae: general -- Galaxy: bulge -- Galaxy: abundances 4 0 0 2 p e S 2 2 1 v 2 3 5 9 0 4 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1. Introduction Planetary nebulae (PNe) are indicators of the chemical com- position of the interstellar matter out of which the progenitors stars were born (mainly through the abundances of elements such as O, Ne, S). They are also indicators of the nucleosynthe- sis and mixing processes occurring in their central stars (mostly through the abundances of He, C, N). Among planetary nebulae, those with central stars of Wolf- Rayet type have received considerable attention recently (e.g. Tylenda et al. 1993, G´orny & Stasi´nska 1995, Pena et al. 2001, Blocker et al. 2001, De Marco 2003, Acker & Neiner 2003). Planetary nebulae with Wolf-Rayet central stars ([WR] PNe) are believed to represent around 6-10% of the total popula- Send offprint requests to: S. K. G´orny ⋆ Based on observations made at the South African Astronomical Observatory tion of planetary nebulae (G´orny & Stasi´nska 1995, Tylenda 1996). Until recently, their mechanism of production was not well understood: how to obtain a PN nucleus whose atmo- sphere is almost completely devoid of hydrogen and essen- tially composed of helium and carbon? The late-helium flash scenario of Iben et al. (1983) could possibly account for only a minority of [WR] PNe, primarily those with an old nebular envelope surrounding a star of late [WC] type. Acker et al. (1996) and G´orny & Tylenda (2000) have shown that the major- ity of [WR] PNe seem to draw an evolutionary sequence from late-type to early-type [WC] types. Recently, Herwig (2001) and Blocker et al. (2001) showed that overshoot applied to models of stars in the AGB phase was able to produce abun- dances similar to those observed in [WR] stars, and that a fi- nal thermal pulse occurring on the AGB was able to produce [WR] PNe with young kinematic ages. However, De Marco & Soker (2002) make the point that the double dust chemistry in 2 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge [WR] PNe revealed by ISO spectra requires a different expla- nation and propose a scenario where a low-mass star or planet spirals into the AGB star, enhancing the mass-loss rate and in- troducing extra mixing. It is not clear yet whether [WR] PNe are produced only by a certain subclass of intermediate mass stars. Neither the mor- phology, nor the chemical composition, nor the Galactic distri- bution or kinematics of [WR] PNe seem to differ statistically from those of non-[WR] PNe (G´orny & Stasi´nska 1995, G´orny 2001). However, this statement needs to be reexamined using a better defined control sample of non-[WR] PNe. A coherent analysis of a large sample of planetary nebu- lae in the direction of Galactic bulge offers the possibility of a more detailed comparison. One of the advantages of plane- tary nebulae in the direction of the galactic bulge is that their distances are known (to within about 10% at least for the ma- jority of them). However, the population of planetary nebulae in the Galactic bulge is probably not the same as that of the Galactic disk, since the stellar population in the bulge is 10 Gyr old (Zoccali et al. 2003), while in the disk the stellar ages span the entire range from 10 Gyr to virtually zero (Chiappini et al. 2001). Therefore, it is also interesting to investigate whether the global properties of [WR] PNe in the Galactic bulge are different from those of disk [WR] PNe. In this respect, it is re- markable that in the Magellanic Clouds, the spectral types of [WR] PNe central stars lie between [WC4] and [WC8] (Pena et al. 1997) (except the nucleus of N66, which until recently was the only known [WN] type star until another case was found in our Galaxy by Parker & Morgan 2003) while the [WR] PNe known in the Galaxy are either of very late ([WC8] - [WC11]) or very early ([WC2] - [WC4]) types (G´orny 2001, Acker & Neiner 2003), clearly avoiding the middle types for some un- known reason. This suggests that the WR phenomenon is de- pendent on the charateristics of the stellar population giving rise to the observed PNe. For the Galactic bulge, it has also been proposed that [WR] stars are mostly of intermediate spec- tral types (G´orny 2001), although Acker & Neiner (2003) do not confirm such a view. However all these inferences are based on small samples. In this paper, we first enlarge the sample of [WR] PNe to- wards the Galactic bulge, by presenting a new set of obser- vations. We combine our observations with those of previous data sets which also allow us to detect the possible presence of stellar emission lines and to determine which of these PNe harbour a [WR] type central star (or weak emission line star (WELS) possibly related to [WR] stars, see e.g. Tylenda et al. 1993, Pena et al. 2001). The samples are described in Sect. 2, and rearranged into one sample of PNe pertaining physically to the Galactic bulge and another sample of PNe seen in the direction of the Galactic bulge but pertaining to the Galactic disk. In Sect. 3, we determine the chemical composition of all the PNe in the combined sample and discuss the accuracy of the derived abundances. In Sect. 4, we show the results of our search of [WR] stars and WELS in the entire sample. We de- fine the spectral types of the newly discovered [WR] stars, and comment on the statistics of the [WC] types as well as on the physical location of the [WR] PNe, including a discussion of the observational selection effects. In Sect. 5, we comment on the chemical composition of the PNe, by comparing several subsamples. Our main conclusions are summarized in Sect. 6. 2. Observational data 2.1. Newobservationsandreductionprocedure The main aim of our observations was to detect new Wolf- Rayet central stars in the direction of the Galactic center (i.e. within, say, 20 degrees from the Galactic center in Galactic lon- gitude and 15 degrees in Galactic latitude). The selection of PNe for observations was based on two criteria. First, we have dismissed all PNe for which there already existed spectral in- formation on the central star, i.e. the spectral type was known or the stellar continuum had been observed but no emission lines were seen (Tylenda et al. 1993, Tylenda et al. 1991). Next, we selected objects with IRAS mid-infrared colours similar to the colours of known [WR] PNe (see G´orny et al. 2001). Therefore, obviously, this sample cannot be used to estimate the propor- tion of [WR] PNe among PNe in the Galactic bulge. For com- parison purposes and to assess the quality of our spectra we also observed a few objects already known to have emission line central stars. The spectra of the 44 objects of our observational sample were obtained in July 2000 with the 1.9-meter telescope at the South African Astronomical Observatory. The spectral cover- age was 3500-7000Å with an average resolution of 1000. A slit width of 1.8 arcsec was selected, resulting in some loss of stel- lar light due to seeing conditions but allowing to avoid blend- ing of important nebular lines. The typical integration time was 60 minutes (30 minutes if the central star was a known [WR] or WELS) with additional short time exposure to secure un- saturated spectra of the strongest nebular lines. The log of the observations is presented in Table 11. Two spectroscopic stan- dard stars, Feige 110 and CD -32 9927, were also observed each night. A CuAr lamp exposure was taken before or after each PN spectrum for wavelength calibration purposes. The reduction of the spectra was done with standard pro- cedures of the MIDAS2 (99NOV) longslit spectra package. These included bias subtraction, flat-field correction, atmo- spheric extinction correction, wavelength and flux calibra- tion and extraction of the 1-dimensional spectra. The line fluxes were derived with the REWIA package (J. Borkowski; http://www.ncac.torun.pl/∼jubork) adopting Gaussian profiles and performing multi-Gaussian fits in case of blended lines. 2.2. AmergedsampleofPNeinthedirectionofthe Galacticbulge Published spectroscopic data on planetary nebulae towards the Galactic bulge are numerous (see Stasi´nska et al. 1998 for a compilation until 1997). However, the only data that allow us to check for the presence of emission lines in the central stars are those of Cuisinier et al. (2000) (30 objects), Escudero & Costa 1 Table 1 is available in electronic form only. 2 MIDAS is developed and maintained by the European Southern Observatory. G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 3 Fig. 1. Distribution in various diagrams of the PNe from our merged sample. Top left: bII vs. lII; top right: Vlsr, the radial velocities corrected for solar motion vs. lII; bottom left: total nebular flux in Hβ corrected for reddening vs. lII; bottom right: angular diameters as a function of lII. The number on the top right of each panel gives the total number of objects represented in the plot. Objects pertaining to different samples are marked by different symbols: G: circles, C: squares, B: triangles, K: plus signs, E: diamonds. (See Sect. 2.2 for detailed definitions.) Symbols for [WR] PNe are thicker than for the rest of PNe. (2001) (45 objects) and Escudero et al. (2004) (57 objects). We thus merged these three samples with the one described in Sect. 2.1, obtaining a total of 164 objects composing what we will refer to as the merged sample. In the case of duplicate spectra, we kept for further analysis the ones described in Sect. 2.1. Fig. 1 shows the distribution in various diagrams of the PNe from our merged sample. Each of the set of observations is marked by a different symbol: circles are for subset G (the set of observations described in Sect. 2.1), squares are for subset C (the sample of Cuisinier et al. 2000), triangles are for subset B (the objects from the list of Beaulieu et al. 1999 observed by Escudero & Costa 2001), plus signs for subset K (the ob- jects from the list of Kohoutek 1994 observed by Escudero & Costa 2001) and diamonds for subset E (the objects observed by Escudero et al. 2004). [WR] PNe are marked by thicker symbols. The top left panel shows the Galactic latitude and longitude, bII and lII. The top right panel shows Vlsr, the ra- dial velocities corrected for solar motion as a function of lII (the radial velocities have been taken from Durand et al. 1998 and have been corrected from solar motion using the formulae given in Beaulieu et al. 2000). The bottom left panel shows the total extinction corrected nebular flux in Hβ 3 as a function of lII. The bottom right panel shows the angular diameters as a 3 The Hβ fluxes for most of objects come from Acker et al. (1992) and have been corrected for interstellar extinction as determined from the ratio of the radio to Hβ fluxes if good quality radio flux measure- ments are available (references as in Stasi´nska et al. 1992). Otherwise the extinction has been derived from the Hβ/Hα ratio using values from Tylenda et al. (1994). For objects from the list of Beaulieu et al. (1999) we have calculated the Hβ fluxes from Hα fluxes given in this paper using the Hβ/Hα ratios from our spectra to calculate the extinction. 4 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge function of lII. A clear segregation of the various subsamples is seen. This is due to the various selection criteria used to define each sample. The sample of Cuisinier et al. (2000) is part of the list of PNe from Stasi´nska & Tylenda (1994) that lie within 10 degrees of the Galactic center, have radio fluxes and diam- eters measured with the VLA, with angular diameters smaller than 15 arcsec and radio fluxes at 6 cm between 10 and 100 mJy. The PNe from samples G and B extend over larger zones in lII and bII. But, while the objects from sample G are rather luminous, the objects from sample B are newly discovered PNe that are rather faint and have larger angular diameters. The ob- jects from sample E are found in a more extended zone than the objects from sample C and are of intermediate luminosity. Since these different observational sets obey to different selec- tion criteria, none of them can be considered to represent the population of the Galactic bulge and it is no surprise that each one may have different mean properties (as already noted by Escudero & Costa 2001). By merging these data sets, we are getting a more complete view of the PN populations in the di- rection of the Galactic bulge, although, unfortunately, none of the samples we consider is complete in any sense. We can divide our merged sample of PNe into two distinct populations. The first one, hereafter referred to as b, is com- posed of objects lying within 10 degrees of the Galactic cen- ter, having angular diameters smaller than 20 arcsec and radio fluxes at 6 cm smaller than 100 mJy. About 95% of these ob- jects are likely physically related to the Galactic bulge as shown by Stasi´nska et al. (1991). The second subsample, hereafter re- ferred to as d, contains the remaining objects and most of them should be related to the Galactic disk population. Note that this distinction between "bulge" and "disk" populations does not use the radial velocities of the nebu- lae. However, as already noted by Zijlstra et al. (1997), PNe thought to be physically related to the Galactic bulge exhibit a large range of radial velocities, between -250 km s−1 and +250 km s−1. The distinction in kinematic properties between our subsamples b and d of PNe in the direction of the Galactic bulge is clearly seen by comparing Figs. 12 and 13 (to be fully described later), which repeat the (Vlsr, lII) diagram for samples b and d respectively. Objects from sample d that are found at a Galactic longitude close to zero have a radial velocity close to zero, compatible with rotation in circular orbit in the Galactic disk. 3. Analysis of nebular emission lines The chemical composition of the newly observed planetary nebulae was derived as described below. We also rederived the abundances of the PNe with published line intensities using the same methods in order to obtain a reasonably homogeneous set of abundances. 3.1. Reddeningcorrection The measured line intensities of the newly observed sample have first been corrected for interstellar extinction using the ex- tinction law of Seaton (1979) and forcing the observed Hα/Hβ ratio to the theoretical recombination value. However, with Fig. 2. The electron temperature derived from [O ] λ4363/5007 versus the electron temperature derived from [N ] λ5755/6584. such a procedure, the reddening-corrected Hδ/Hβ and Hγ/Hβ ratios were often significantly different than theoretically ex- pected. We attribute this to the E-W orientation of the slit and to the fact that the spectra were taken at different airmasses (reaching values of 2) which resulted in substantial loss of reg- istered light at short wavelengths. It is important, for abun- dance determinations, to use intensities of [O ] λ4363 and [O ] λ3727 as reliable as possible. Therefore we have used the Hδ/Hβ and Hγ/Hβ ratios and have calculated the values of the additional correction that would bring them to the teo- retical recombination values. This correction was then linearly propagated to the observed fluxes at all wavelengths shorter of 4681Å(Hβ). The resulting line fluxes are presented in Table 24 on the scale of Hβ=100. We also give line identification and laboratory wavelengths. The same additional correction procedure has been applied to the objects from Escudero & Costa (2001) and Escudero et al. (2004) samples that originally also revealed some devi- ations from the theoretical Balmer decrement as discussed in Escudero et al. (2004). 3.2. Nebularabundancedeterminations The abundances were derived with the classical empirical method. The electron densities were obtained from the [S ] λ6731/6717 ratio, the electron temperatures from the [O ] λ4363/5007 and [N ] λ5755/6584 ratios. The ionic abun- dances and elemental abundances were then derived using the code ABELION as in Pena et al. (2001). The only difference is that here we used the collision strengths of Keenan et al. (1996) for [S ] lines. Those objects for which the electron tempera- ture could be determined neither from [O ] λ4363/5007 nor 4 Table 2 is available in electronic form only. G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 5 data. The second and third row give the upper and lower limit respectively of these parameters as derived taking into account the observational error bars. Errors in the derived abundances result not only from ob- servational errors (including the dereddening procedures), but also from uncertainties in the atomic data and the adequacy of the abundance derivation scheme. Comparing abundances de- rived by different authors for the same objects gives an idea of the uncertainty including all the sources of errors. This is shown in Fig. 3, where we plot the values of log N/O versus log O/H +12 for all the objects in common among several of the subsamples we considered. Values pertaining to the same object are linked by thin lines. The symbols are the same as in Fig. 1. From this figure, we conclude that global uncertainties in abundance ratios are typically of 0.2 -- 0.3 dex for O/H but can be much larger in some cases for N/O. Apart from differ- ent determinations of the temperatures, the main source of un- certainty in the oxygen abundance is the estimation of O+/H+, especially in low excitation objects. The [O ] λ3727 line is severely affected by reddening, while the [O ] λ7320,7330 line is intrinsically much weaker, more dependent on temperature and strongly affected by possible recombination. Both lines are sensitive to density, but in different ways. The N/O ratio is less affected by errors in the electron temperature than the O/H ra- tio. On the other hand, its derived value strongly depends on the value adopted for the O+ abundance. Quite often, a differ- ence in N/O between the determination by two authors traces back to a different estimate of the electron density, which has important consequences for very dense nebulae. For helium, the expected errors in the abundances are much smaller, except in the case of PNe of very low excitation, where no correction can be made for the presence of neutral helium. However, even for high excitation nebulae, the errors are rela- tively large compared to expected object-to-object variations. The lowest oxygen abundances found in our merged sam- ple are as low as log O/H +12 = 7.1 -- 7.2. One may suspect that such low values are not real but result simply from an overestimated electron temperature (which, in general, is the main source of uncertainty in the oxygen abundance deriva- tion). In Fig. 4, we plot the value of the electron temperature Te, as derived from [O ] λ4363/5007, as a function of the computed value of log O/H + 12, together with the observa- tional error bar on Te and the error bars on log O/H resulting only from Te. This figure shows that indeed, some of the lowest derived abundances are affected by large error bars, implying that the true abundances might be significantly higher than de- rived. However, there are four objects, for which log O/H + 12 is definitely smaller than 7.6. We are, of course, aware of the fact that recombination lines in planetary nebulae lead to larger values of the elemental abundances, sometimes by factors up to 10 (see e.g. Liu 2002 for a review). Here we adopt the view, as in all statistical studies on abundances so far, that the abun- dances derived from the forbidden lines are representative of the chemical composition in the bulk of the nebula. Fig. 3. The values of log N/O versus log O/H +12 for all the ob- jects in common in the various data sets composing or merged sample. Symbols corresponding to the same object are linked by thin lines. The meaning of the symbols is the same as in Fig. 1. from [N ] λ5755/6584 were discarded from abundance deter- minations. This concerns only 5 objects among 164 (4 in sam- ple b, one in sample d). The temperature derived from [N ] was used for ions of low ionisation potential, that from [O ] λ4363/5007 for ions of high ionization potential. In general, the temperatures from [O ] λ4363/5007 and [N ] λ5755/6584 are similar, but often not identical within their error bars as shown in Fig. 2. If the temperature from [N ] was very uncer- tain, we rather used the temperature from [O ] λ4363/5007 for all the ions. We have adopted for the abundance of O+ the mean of the abundances derived from the [O ] λ3727 and the [O ] λ7320,7330 line, when available. A discussion of the comparison between both abundances can be found in Escudero et al. (2004). Table 3 5 lists the resulting plasma diagnostics and abundances for all the objects of the merged sample. Column (1) gives the PNG number; Column (2) gives the usual name of the PN; Column (3) indicates the obser- vational subsample (G, C, B, K or E). Column (4) indicates whether the object belongs to sample "b" as defined in Sect. 2.2. Column (6) gives the electron density deduced from [S ] λ6731/6717, columns (7) and (8) give the electron temperature deduced from [N ] λ5755/6584 and [O ] λ4363/5007 respec- tively. Columns (9) gives the He/H ratio, column (10), (11), (12), (13) give the N/H, O/H, Ne/H, S/H ratios, respectively, in units of 10−6. Columns (14),(15),(16),(17), (18) give He+/H+, He++/H+, O+/H+ as derived from the 3727 line, O+/H+ as de- rived from the 7325 line, O++/H+. Column (19) gives the loga- rithmic extinction at Hβ derived from the spectra. In this table, there are three rows for each object, and a fourth row used to separate the objects. The first row gives the values of param- eters computed from the nominal values of the observational 5 Table 3 is available in electronic form only. 6 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge ria, we find 5 new [WR] PNe in the sample of Cuisinier et al. (2000). In total, including the [WR] and WELS already known, we find 18 [WR] and 24 WELS among 164 objects consid- ered. The rate of occurence of [WR] PNe in the direction of the bulge is thus somewhat higher than that found by Tylenda et al. (1993) by examining 350 PNe spectra in the whole Galaxy. The ratio of WELS is much higher. This is likely due to two reasons. First, the spectra we examined are of substantially better qual- ity than those examined by Tylenda et al. (1993), which came from a snapshot spectroscopic survey of the Galaxy. Second, our own observations were conducted on a sample specially designed to favor new discoveries of [WR] PNe, as explained in Sect. 2.1. In the following of this paper, we will concentrate on [WR] PNe and their comparison with remaining PNe. Table 4 presents all the PNe in the direction of the Galactic bulge whose nuclei were found to present emission lines. The [WR] stars and WELS discovered by us constitute "group 1". The [WR] stars and WELS that were already known to exist in the samples we analyzed constitute "group 2". There are also 15 [WR] PNe and 11 WELS reported in the literature to exist in the direction of the Galactic bulge but that do not belong to our "merged" sample6. They are also listed in Table 4 for com- pleteness, under "group 3". For each of these groups, column (1) gives the PN G number; column (2) gives the usual name of the PN; column (3) indicates the observational subset (using the same convention as in column (3) of Table 3); column (4) indicates whether the object belongs to sample b as defined in Sect. 2.2; column (5) gives the FWHM of the C  λ5805 or C  λ5695 line; column (6) gives the category of the star: W for [WR], w for WELS. For convenience, the same indications (i.e. W or w), are reported also in column (5) of Table 3. Fig. 5 presents the spectra of all the objects we identifed as [WR] PNe in samples G, B, K and E. 4.2. [WR]PNespectralclassification The classification criteria we used followed the classical scheme (van der Hucht et al. 1981, M´endez & Niemela 1982, Hu & Bibo 1990) which is based solely on relative intensities of selected lines: C  λ 5805, C  λ5695, C  λ5663, O  λ5670, O  λ5290 and O  λ5595. In addition, the presence of O  λ3822 and C  λ7235 was also checked. The O  λ3822 line is expected to be several times brighter than the basic C  λ5805 line in early [WC] spectral types, therefore even if sub- ject to large extinction it may be more easily detectable than the C  λ5805 line. On the other hand C  λ7235 is expected to be the brightest line in the late [WC] types (Acker & Neiner 6 Recently, 2 additional [WR] PNe were discovered in the direc- tion of the Galactic bulge (Parker & Morgan 2003) during a follow-up spectroscopic survey of 1000 new PNe candidates proposed from vi- sual scans of AAO/UKST narrow-band Hα survey of the Milky Way (Parker et al. 1999, Parker et al. 2003). However, among 700 objects observed to date, only 7 new [WR] PNe were found (Parker & Morgan 2003). This very low detection rate possibly involves important selec- tion effects and these new objects have to be considered separately in future works. Fig. 4. The value of the electron temperature Te as derived from [O ] λ4363/5007 as a function of the computed value of log O/H + 12. The observational error bar on Te and the error bar on log O/H resulting from the error in Te is shown (unless the error in log Te is smaller than 0.1 and the error in log O/H smaller than 0.2, in which case the symbol is marked with a black heavy line). Arrows indicate that only an upper limit on Te or a lower limit on O/H ca be obtained. The shape of the symbols has the same meaning as in Fig. 1. 4. [WR] PNe 4.1. Searchfornew[WR]PNe We first searched our new spectra for the presence of emis- sion line central stars. The distinction between [WR] stars and WELS is made as in Tylenda et al. (1993) on the basis of the strength and width of the C  λ5805 doublet. This doublet is often seen as two separate components in WELS and is much weaker and narrower than in [WR]-type stars. It is the only stellar emission line seen in the spectra of WELS, among the lines used to classify [WR] stars. Note that the difference be- tween [WR] stars and WELS is not always easy to make and one may suspect that better quality spectra could perhaps reveal additional spectral features especially for cooler stars. We found 4 new [WR] stars and 8 new WELS in sample G, in addition to the 3 [WR] stars and 8 WELS already known to exist in this sample. We also examined the spectra of Escudero & Costa (2001) and Escudero et al. (2004). In the Escudero & Costa2001) sub- sample we found 2 [WR] stars and 3 WELS among 45 PNe. In the Escudero et al. (2004) sample we found 3 new [WR] stars and 4 new WELS in addition to the 1 known [WR] and 1 known WELS. The observations by Cuisinier et al. (2000) are published only as a list of emission lines, among which lines of C  λ5695 and C  λ5805 appear. These lines are in fact of stellar origin and we attribute them to [WR] stars. With these crite- G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 7 Table 4. [WR] and WELS planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge. PN G 1 name 2 sample Bulge FWHM W/w 3 4 5 b b b b b b b b b group 1: [WR] PNe discovered in this work K 5- 1 000.4+04.4 H 2-11 000.7+04.7 Bl 3-13 000.9-02.0 H 1-47 001.2-03.0 M 1-37 002.6-03.4 K 5- 3 1 002.6+05.5 003.6+03.1 M 2-14 005.9-02.6 006.5-03.1 008.3-01.1 008.1-04.7 008.3-07.3 009.6+14.8 009.8-04.6 009.6-10.6 013.7-10.6 014.4-06.1 343.9-05.8 347.4+05.8 350.1-03.9 351.5-06.5 MaC 1-10 H 1-61 M 1-40 M 2-39 NGC 6644 NGC 6309 H 1-67 M 3-33 Y-C 2-32 SB 19 SB 30 H 1- 2 H 1-26 SB 34 E G2 E C C K G G G G E G G E E E B B G G B b SB 35 351.7-06.6 352.1+05.1 M 2- 8 Th 3-13 356.1+02.7 M 1-27 356.5-02.3 H 1-39 356.5-03.9 357.1-04.7 H 1-43 359.8+05.6 M 2-12 359.3-01.8 M 3-44 M 3-17 359.3-03.1 B G2 G C C E E G C b b b b b b b b 16.0 18.0 7.8+7.4 28.2 21.8 37.4 12.6+11.2 instr+instr 19.4 6.0+6.8 8.7+7.3 30.3 7.6+7.8 7.3+6.7 15.3 9.2 instr+instr 34.8 31.6 instr+instr 31.8 21.5: instr 3 instr 3 instr 3 6 w w w W W W w W w w w w w W w w w w w W W w W w W W W W W W type 7 wels wels wels [WC11]? [WC11]? [WC4] wels [WC8] wels wels wels wels wels [WC2-3] wels wels wels wels wels [WC4-5] [WC2] wels [WC2-3] wels [WC11]? [WC11]? [WC11] [WC11] [WC11] [WC11]? wels wels wels wels [WC10] [WC4] wels [WC4] wels [WC4] wels wels [WC6] [WC5] wels [WC5-6] [WC4-6] [WC4] [WC5-6] [WC10] wels wels wels [WC2-3] [WC4] wels wels [WC11] wels [WC3-4] spectra details or reference Acker&Neiner (2003) 8 9 CIII present, CIV absent CIII present, CIV absent CIV strong, OV>OVI, OVI 3822 present CIV ≈ CIII (? - very late) (? - very late) ([WO3]) ([WC7-8]) CIV present, OVI5290 ?, OVI3822 strong ([WO2]?) CIV>>CIII, OV>OVI & OV>CIII CIV present, OVI 3822 very strong, OVI 5290 ?, OVII 5670 ? ([WO4]) ([WO2]) OVI5290 present, OVI3822 present ([WO3]) CIII present, CIV absent CIII present, CIV absent CIII present, CIV absent, CII ? CIII present, CIV absent, CII present CIII present, CIV absent, CII ? CIII present, CIV absent 10* 10* 1 10* 6,8,10* 1,3,10* 9 1,10* 9 8,10 9 9 2,10* 10* 9 7 7 10* 7 6,5,10 9 9 9 10* 2 9 9 1,4,8,10 9 1,10* (? - very late) (? - very late) (? - very late) (? - very late) (? - very late) (? - very late) [WC5-6] [WC4] [WC4] [WC9]pec [WO3] [WO4]pec [WO3] [WC5-6] [WC4] [WC4]? [WO4]pec [WC10] [WO2] [WC4] [WC11] [WO3] W [WC5-6]? w w w W [WC4-5]? wels wels wels 28.0 b b b b b b b instr+instr instr+instr group 2: known [WR] PNe belonging to our "merged sample" 000.4-01.9 M 2-20 002.6+08.1 H 1-11 004.2-04.3 H 1-60 006.4+02.0 M 1-31 M 2-31 006.0-03.6 M 2-34 007.8-03.7 007.0-06.8 VY 2- 1 351.1+04.8 M 1-19 355.2-02.5 H 1-29 Cn 2-1 356.2-04.4 356.7-04.8 H 1-41 357.1+03.6 M 3- 7 359.9-04.5 M 2-27 no emission w w instr+instr w w E E G G G G G G G G G G G 25.3 41.8 16.2 22.5 b b b b b no emission W w instr+instr w W [WC4-5]? [WC] wels wels 17.7 34.3 b b b b b b group 3: known [WR] PNe not belonging to our "merged sample" SwSt 1 001.5-06.7 NGC 6369 002.4+05.8 M 2-33 002.0-06.2 Cn 1-5 002.2-09.4 IC 4776 002.0-13.4 Hb 4 003.1+02.9 Hb 7 003.9-14.9 004.6+06.0 H 1-24 004.9+04.9 M 1-25 006.8+04.1 M 3-15 H 1-65 007.8-04.4 NGC 6629 4 009.4-05.0 NGC 6578 4 010.8-01.8 011.9+04.2 M 1-32 011.7-00.6 012.2+04.9 012.5-09.8 014.3-05.5 016.4-01.9 017.9-04.8 019.7-04.5 019.4-05.3 341.8+05.4 352.9+11.4 355.9-04.2 358.3-21.6 NGC 6567 4 PM 1-188 M 1-62 V-V 3-6 M 1-46 M 3-30 M 1-60 M 1-61 NGC 6153 K 2-16 M 1-30 IC 1297 W W w W w W w w W W w W W W W W w w w W W w w W w W b notes: 1) K 5-3 = IRAS17276-2342 in Acker et al. (1996); 2) spectra of Escudero & Costa (2001) (sample E) were used to measure stellar emissions; 3) FWHM of C  λ5695; 4) objects classified as WELS in Pena et al. (2001) references: 1) Tylenda et al. (1993); 2) Acker et al. (1996); 3) Koesterke & Hamann (1997); 4) Leuenhagen et al. (1996); 5) Leuenhagen & Hamann (1998); 6) reclassified using data of Crowther et al. (1998); 7) Pena et al. (2001); 8) reclassified using data of de Ara´ujo et al. (2002); 9) Acker & Neiner (2003); 10*) reclassified using data of Acker & Neiner (2003); 8 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 2003) and replaces the hardly detectable C  λ5663 line origi- nally proposed by Hu & Bibo (1990). Recently two refined classifications schemes have been proposed for Wolf-Rayet central stars of planetary nebulae based on quantitative criteria (Crowther et al. 1998, Acker & Neiner 2003). The first one imposes identical criteria of clas- sification for massive population I WC stars and central stars of planetary nebulae but requires good quality spectra in or- der to derive reliable equivalent width measurements of stellar emission lines, especially if the nebular continuum is domi- nating. The second one is, in principle, better adapted to the CSPN specificity. Unfortunately, the primary criteria are not clearly defined. In addition, the ranges in line ratios defining the classes show strong discontinuities. Finally, the classifica- tion of early-types is not independent of the chemical compo- sition. For all these reasons we decided to continue to use in this work the classical criteria. These criteria are more suited to the quality of our observations and can be directly compared to most of previous classification works. The results of our spectral classification of [WR] stars are presented in columns (7) and (8) of Table 4. Column (7) gives the [WR] type. Column (8) describes the details of our spectra indicating this type or gives the references of the papers were the classification was published. For reference purposes, col- umn (9) gives the spectral class assigned by Acker & Neiner (2003) to the [WR] PNe known at that time. We have tried to use the classification scheme of Acker & Neiner (2003) also to our newly discovered [WR] PNe. The results are given in the same column in parenthesis. As can be seen from Table 4, a large proportion of the [WR] stars we discovered can be best described as late [WC11] type using the long-used, classical classification scheme adopted here. Their spectra look as expected for a very late WC type at a large distance. They are characterized by the presence of the narrow (FWHM < 5 Å) C  λ5695 line and the absence of the C  λ5805 line. Therefore they fulfil one of the criteria to classify them as [WC11] (Hu & Bibo 1990). For some ob- jects, especially the ones belonging to sample C, a classically definied [WC10] type cannot be excluded, since better spectra might reveal the presence of weak C  lines. Interestingly, the C  λ7235 line was definitely seen in only one of the spectra we examined, while it was proposed that the [WC11] type should be dominated by both C  and C  lines (Hu & Bibo 1990). Again, this might be because the C  lines are too weak to be detected in our spectra therefore we regard this classification criteria as less important and imprecise. Note that even the new classification schemes would re- quire some clarification as far as the [WC11] class is con- cerned. In both papers (Crowther et al. 1998 and Acker & Neiner 2003), only one object, K 2-16, is classified as [WC11]. The defining criteria of the [WC11] class are obtained by ex- trapolation of the properties from adjacent classes and it is therefore not certain what intensity of C  lines should be ex- pected. It must also be mentioned that K 2-16 has a rather un- usual spectrum showing C  λ5805 and O  λ5595 in absorp- tion and surprisingly also some photospheric lines not expected to be present in [WR] stars (Crowther et al. 1998, de Ara´ujo et al. 2002). It was proposed by Pena et al. (2001) that this ob- Fig. 5. Spectra of the newly discovered [WR] PN G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 9 ject may have undergone a late helium-shell flash, so that it did not follow the common evolutionary path in which the [WR] phenomenon appears just after the AGB phase (see G´orny & Tylenda 2000). This is supported by the distinct properties ob- served for K 2-16 in the infrared domain (G´orny et al. 2001, Szczerba et al. 2001, Szczerba et al. 2003). 4.3. Statisticsof[WR]types Having determined which of the [WR] PNe are most likely physically linked to the bulge (see Sect. 2.2), we can compare the distributions of [WC] types in the bulge and in the disk. Figure 6 shows the histograms of [WC] types for [WR] PNe pertaining to the bulge (top) and for [WR] PNe pertaining to the disk population (bottom). If we consider only objects from our "merged sample" (described in Sect. 2.2.) it is remarquable that all the three [WR] PNe in sample "d" are of type earlier than [WC6] while there are only 5 such objects among 14 in sample "b". Since the statistics for our sample "d" are extremely low, we consider in the Fig. 6 all the known [WR] PNe by merg- ing the ones from Table 4 with those collected in the littera- ture by G´orny & Tylenda (2000). The top histogram concerns [WR] PNe of the Galactic bulge population, the bottom one shows all the known [WR] PNe pertaining to the entire Galactic disk. The litterature data add to our "merged sample" only 3 [WR] PNe in the bulge, but increases the disk sample from 3 to 46 (as most of the known [WR] PNe lie outside the direction of the galactic bulge). The difference between the bulge and disk histograms is highly significant. First, we find a much larger proportion of [WR] stars later than [WC10] in the entire bulge sample (47%) than in the disk sample (17%). Second, the [WR] PNe in the direction of the Galactic bulge are underrepresented in spectral types [WC2] and [WC3] with respect to Galactic disk [WR] PNe. We have found only one such case (M 2-8) (i.e. 6%) in the Galactic bulge while there are 26% of objects in the disk sample. Note, finally, that the proportion of intermediate classes ([WC5] to [WC6]) is significantly larger in the bulge sample (22%) than in the disk sample (11%). We thus confirm the claims by G´orny (2001) which were based on the analysis of much smaller samples. It has been suggested (e.g. G´orny & Tylenda 2000, Pena et al. 2001) that the [WC] sequence is an evolutionary sequence, with most of the late-type [WC] being surrounded by high den- sity PNe and most of the early-type [WC] being surrounded by low density PNe. In Fig. 7, we show the nebular density de- duced from [S ] λ6731/6717 as a function of the [WC] type for all the newly discovered [WR] PNe. The same trend is found as previously, well in line with the hypothesis that most [WR] PNe draw their evolution directly from the AGB. Fig. 6. The histograms of [WC] types for [WR] PNe in the Galactic bulge as defined in Sect. 2.2 (top) and in the Galactic disk (bottom) for all known [WR] PNe in the Galaxy including our newly discovered sources. The total number of objects used to construct each histogram is given in the upper right corner. The empty parts of the bars correspond to [WC 2-3], [WC 3-4] [WC 4-5], [WC 4-6] and [WC 5-6] types, distributed over two neighbouring bins. Fig. 7. The nebular density deduced from [S ] λ6731/6717 as a function of the [WC] type for all the newly discovered [WR] PNe. Objects pertaining to different samples are marked with the same symbols as in Fig. 1. 4.4. Selectioneffects It may be surprising that most of the [WR] PNe we discovered are of late types, since one would expect the earliest [WC] types to be more easily detectable than the latest types, because the stellar features are both wider and stronger. However, before interpreting our findings in terms of stellar evolution or stellar masses, one should examine the selection effects more closely. First of all, in the bulge, where the conditions of detection of PNe are difficult due to high extinction and crowding, there is a discrimination against detection of PNe with very hot cen- 10 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge Fig. 8. The histogram of Zanstra He  temperature for the PNe catalogued in Acker et al. (1992) that pertain to the Galactic bulge (upper panel) and for the remaining PNe (lower panel). The number of objects used to construct the plot is given in the top right of each panel. The dashed bars stand for objects in common with our G, C or E samples and their number is given in parenthesis. tral stars, because such nebulae are less luminous and more dif- fuse. This probably explains, at least in part, why the proportion of PNe with high effective temperatures is higher in the disk than in the bulge, as seen in Fig. 8 which compares the observed distribution of of He  Zanstra temperatures, TZan(He ), in the bulge (upper panel) and in the disk (lower panel). To construct this figure, we have used the criteria described in Sect. 2.2 to divide the Strasbourg-ESO catalogue of Galactic PNe (Acker et al. 1992) into one subsample of 263 objects that most likely be- long to the bulge, and one subsample of 878 objects which, for their vast majority, belong to the disk. We computed TZan(He ) for all the PNe with central stars hot enough to ionise He+ and for which the necessary data could be found in Acker et al. (1992) and Tylenda et al. (1994), obtaining values of He  Zanstra temperatures for 90 PNe in the bulge and 386 in the disk. The error bar on TZan(He ) is typically of 0.05 in the log. The dashed bars in Fig. 8 stand for the objects present in our G, C or E subsamples. We see that, in the bulge, the number of PNe with sufficiently hot central stars (log TZan(He ) >4.9) is very small, making the discovery of an early type [WC] star very unlikely. It is also interesting to note that the proportion of objects in the range 4.7>log TZan(He )>4.85 (corresponding to the temperatures of intermediate [WC] types) is in fact simi- lar in both groups of PNe: 21% (55/263) for the Galactic bulge objects and 18% (154/878) for the remaining PNe. Next, one must consider the condition of detection of the stellar emission lines. PNe in the bulge have small angular dimensions, so that a large fraction of their total nebular flux is recorded in their Fig. 9. The ratio LV /L(Hβ) as a function of the star effective temperature, T ∗, for a series of simple models of expanding planetary nebulae around central stars of different masses (see text). Symbols are placed every 500 yr. Circles: M⋆=0.58 M⊙; squares: M⋆ =0.60 M⊙; triangles: M⋆ =0.62 M⊙. Fig. 10. The ratio LV /S (Hβ) as a function of T ∗. Same models and same presenation as in Fig. 9. spectra. Therefore the detection of [WR] PNe is possible only for objects in which the luminosity of the star in the V band (LV) is sufficiently large with respect to the total nebular contin- uum emission (which is proportional to the luminosity in Hβ). For illustrative purposes, we show in Fig. 9 the ratio LV /L(Hβ) as a function of the star effective temperature, T ∗, for a series of simple models of expanding planetary nebulae around central stars of different masses (the central stars evolve according to an interpolation of Blocker 1995 evolutionary tracks, the neb- ulae are homogeneous with a total mass of 0.3 M⊙, and the ex- pansion velocity of the outer rim is taken to be 20 km s−1). This corresponds to the extreme case where the entire nebula is cov- G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 11 ered by the region of the slit where the spectrum is extracted). This figure shows that the most favourable cases for detection of [WR] features in nebulae of small angular dimentions are those corresponding to the lowest stellar temperatures, i.e. to the latest spectral types, despite the fact that stellar emission lines are stronger in early-types. On the contrary, many of the PNe known in the Galactic disk are relatively close-by, and have large angular dimensions, so only a small fraction of the nebular emission is recorded in the spectrograph slit. Then, a [WR] star will be preferentially detected in PNe with large LV /S (Hβ) (where S (Hβ) is the neb- ular surface brightness in Hβ). Fig. 10 shows this ratio as a function of T ∗ for the same models as Fig. 9. We see that, the conditions of detectability of [WR] features are more compli- cated. In the early phases of evolution, the LV /S (Hβ) ratio is large, but this regime does not last long. At intermediate val- ues of T ∗, the conditions of detectability of stellar features are less favourable. Finally, at high values of T ∗, the LV /S (Hβ) ra- tio increases due to the expansion of the nebula, and the star becomes easier to observe, especially if the object is close-by. Note that, especially for close-by nebulae with high tem- perature central stars, stellar features are much easier to detect for low than for high central star masses. The distribution of [WR] stars among spectral classes is thus highly dependent on the selection effects just described. In addition, one must recall that the quality of the spectra used for the discovery and classification of [WR] PNe is very heterogeneous. For example, the quality of our new observa- tions presented in Sect. 2.1, specially aimed at discovering new [WR] PNe is much higher than that of the survey on which was based the seminal paper by Tylenda et al. (1993). All this badly hampers any attempt to use [WR] types statistics to study the populations of the central stars and their evolution. 4.5. Do[WR]PNeoccurmorefrequentlyinthe Galacticbulgethaninthedisk? We now compare the global characteristics of the [WR] PNe in our "merged sample" with those of the remaining PNe in this sample. Fig. 1 shows that the [WR] PNe are more concentrated than the non [WR] PNe in the (lII, bII) diagram and have also larger Hβ fluxes. It is interesting that the [WR] PNe that lie close to the center of the Galaxy are of late [WC11] type. Among the objects whose spectra we examined, there are 15 [WR] PNe among a total of 94 objects in the b subsample and 3 [WR] PNe among a total of 52 objects in the d subsam- ple. Thus [WR] PNe appear preferentially in the bulge popu- lation than in the disk population, at least in the direction of the Galactic bulge. Does this mean that the real proportion of [WR] PNe is larger in the former than in the latter? Since all the spectra from our "merged sample" have been obtained in the same conditions and have been examined in a similar way for the possible presence of [WR] stars, the only effect to con- sider is whether it is easier to recognize a [WR] star in bulge or in disk PNe. A priori, it is easier to recognize a [WR] in a nebula of large angular dimensions and relatively close-by. Therefore, we conclude that the true proportion of [WR] PNe Fig. 11. The histogram of the oxygen abundances we derived for the objects of our merged sample that pertain to the bulge subsample b (top panel) and for the objects that pertain to the disk subsample d (bottom panel) as defined in Sect. 2.2. is significantly larger in the bulge than in the disk. Keeping in mind the considerations in Sect. 4.4, this could indicate that, in the direction of the Galactic bulge, the central star masses are likely smaller, on average, in the bulge than in the disk. 5. Abundances 5.1. Oxygenabundances:bulgeversusdisk Cuisinier et al. (2000) compared the oxygen abundances of bulge and disk PNe (their Fig. 5) by considering their own sam- ple for the bulge (which indeed strictly obeys our criteria for sample b) with data taken from Maciel & Koppen (1994) for the Galactic disk. They found that the oxygen abundances in bulge PNe are comparable to those in disk PNe, with a slightly higher proportion of high abundances in the bulge. However, the distributions of the oxygen abundances in PNe in the en- tire Galactic disk shows important gradients (Maciel & Koppen 1994, Maciel & Quireza 1999) so that such a comparison is of limited utility. With our merged data set, we can do somewhat better, because our sample d contains only objects in the direc- tion of the Galactic bulge, and is likely dominated by objects located between the Sun and the Galactic center, with a larger proportion of objects at small galactocentric distances. In Fig. 11, we show the histograms of the oxygen abun- dances for our sample b and d. One can see that the distribution is significantly narrower and more skewed to high O/H values in sample b. Non parametric statistical tests confirm this im- pression. The median value, and the 25 and 75 percentiles are 8.45 (8.21, 8.68) for sample b while they are 8.32 (7.93, 8.59) for sample d. The above considerations concern the nominal abundances derived from the observed line intensities. Errors 12 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge SB32 Fig. 12. The (Vlsr, lII) diagram for samples b only. The radius of the circle is proportional to O/H. in abundance derivations were discussed in Sect. 3.2. They are not expected to change our conclusions, except perhaps as re- gards the PNe which were found to have very low abundances. However, of the 5 PNe with a nominal value of log O/H +12 smaller than 7.5 in the entire sample, 2 have abundance with better than 0.2 dex accuracy as seen in Fig. 4, and for the three remaining ones, two pertain to sample b and one in sample d. In addition, we should consider that, within our entire sample of observations, there are 4 objects in sample b and 1 in sample d for which the abundances could not be derived because the electron temperature is unknown. The relative proportion of b and d objects among these 4 objects, compared to a total of 105 objects in sample b and 54 objects in sample d implies that our conclusions are not likely to be affected by errors in the abun- dances. Clearly, better data on a larger sample would be needed to confirm this. From the compilation of Maciel & Quireza (1999), which concerns PNe at Galactocentric distances between 3 and 14 kpc, the oxygen abundance steadily increases inwards, reaching log O/H +12 of about 8.7 at the Galactocentric dis- tance of the Sun and about 9 at 3 kpc, with a dispersion of about ± .2 dex. Comparing these values with the histogram shown in Fig. 11 for our d sample (lower panel), we conclude that O/H levels off and probably even decreases in the most internal parts of the Galactic disk. This is well in line with the findings of Smartt et al. (2001) based on abundance determination of four B-type stars. As concerns the bulge, the oxygen abundance distribution we find has roughly the same shape as that found by Zoccali et al. (2003) for the metallicity distribution of bulge giants (with a sharp cut-off at the high abundance end and a long tail towards low abundances), but it is narrower by roughly 0.3 dex. It is remarkable also that the median oxygen abundance in sample b is larger by about 0.2 dex than that of our sample d. We also examined whether oxygen abundances show any trend with some other properties. The most interesting results Fig. 13. The (Vlsr, lII) diagram for samples d only. The radius of the circle is proportional to O/H. The object SB 32 (PN G 349.7-09.1), which possibly belongs to the halo (see Sect. 5.1) has been labelled. are seen in Figs. 12 and 13, where we show again the (Vlsr, lII) diagram for samples b and d separately, this time representing the nebulae by circles whose surface is proportional to O/H. Fig. 13 displays one important feature. While most of the ob- jects are roughly consistent with rotation of the Galactic disk, one object is clearly an outlier. This is SB 32 (PN G 349.7- 09.1), which has log O/H + 12 = 7.77 (+0.47, -0.24). Both its position in the (Vlsr, lII) diagram and its low oxygen abundance indicate that this PN likely belongs to the Galactic halo and not to the disk. In Fig. 12, which concerns sample b, we may note that the PNe with smaller oxygen abundances tend to have smaller ra- dial velocities. 5.2. Oxygenabundances:[WR]PNeversusotherPNe inthebulge abundances of [WR] PNe comparing the When and non[WR] PNe, G´orny & Stasi´nska (1995) refrained from comparing oxygen abundances, which are strongly affected by the location of the PN in the Galaxy. With our present work, we are in a much more favourable situation. We have a sample of PNe in the bulge out of which was drawn a sample of [WR] PNe. Fig. 14 shows in the top panel the histogram of the oxygen abundances for the [WR] PNe in our sample b while in the bottom panel the same is shown for the remaining PNe in this sample. Although the sample of [WR] PNe is small (15 objects), the distributions are remarkably similar and undistinguishable by non parametric statistical tests. We thus conclude that the oxygen abundances in [WR] stars are not significantly affected by nucleosynthesis and mixing in the progenitors. This implies that [WR] PNe, similarly to ordi- nary PNe, can be used to determine the oxygen abundance of the media out of which the progenitors were born. G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 13 Fig. 16. The histogram of N/O ratios derived for the [WR] PNe of our merged sample that pertain to the bulge subsample b as defined in Sect. 2.2. Fig. 16 shows the histogram of N/O in the [WR] PNe of sample b. Although also in this case the number of objects is small (15), again we can conclude that the distribution is indis- tinguishable, statistically, from the previous ones. We thus conclude that, although N is known to be produced and dredged-up by the PNe progenitors, and that the nitrogen enrichment is expected to by a function of the progenitor's mass and of the mass loss rate (Marigo 2001), a statistical study such as the one we present is not able to give any real clue. 7. Conclusions We have conducted a statistical analysis of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge, with the double aim of a better understanding of the global properties of PNe with Wolf- Rayet type central stars, and of a more refined characterization of the different populations of PNe that are seen in this direc- tion. We have performed new observations of 44 PNe in the di- rection of the Galactic bulge, and merged them with data from previous studies suitable for our purposes, constituting a sam- ple of 164 PNe. We have distinguished, in this merged sample, the PNe most probably pertaining physically to the Galactic bulge, and the PNe most likely belonging to the Galactic disk. We have determined the chemical composition of all the 164 objects in a coherent way and discussed the uncertainties in the derived abundances. We have looked for stellar emission features in all the 164 objects. This search resulted in the discovery of 14 new [WR] stars and 15 new weak emission line central stars, significantly enlarging the number of emission line stars known in the direc- tion of the Galactic bulge. We have also performed a spectral classification of all the new [WR] stars. Our findings were then discussed with the aim of getting some clues on [WR]PN production and evolution, on the var- ious populations of planetary nebulae seen in the direction of the Galactic disk, and on the distribution of oxygen abundance in the Galaxy as measured by planetary nebulae. Particular at- tention was paid to take into account selection effects. Our main results are the following: Fig. 14. The histogram of the oxygen abundances we derived for the [WR] PNe of our merged sample (top panel) and for the non-[WR] PNe (bottom panel) that pertain to the bulge subsam- ple b as defined in Sect. 2.2. Fig. 15. The histogram of the N/O ratios we derived for the PNe of our merged sample that pertain to the bulge subsample b (top panel) and for the PNe that pertain to the disk subsample d (bottom panel) as defined in Sect. 2.2. 6. N/O ratios Fig. 15 show the histograms of the N/O ratios in samples b (top panel) and d (bottom panel) respectively. The distributions are seen to be similar and they are undistinguishable by non parametric statistical tests. 14 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge We confirm that the spectral type distribution of [WR] stars is very different in the bulge and in the disk of the Galaxy. However, we show that the selection effects, being not the same between bulge and disk PNe, can explain, at least in part, this observed difference in spectral type distribution. We show that the proportion of [WR] PNe with respect to the remaining PNe is significantly larger in the bulge than in the disk. We show that this is likely an indirect indication that the central star masses are, on average, smaller in the bulge than in the disk. There is no difference, in the Galactic bulge, between the oxygen abundances in [WR] PNe and in the remaining PNe. This implies that the oxygen abundances in [WR] stars are not significantly affected by nucleosynthesis and mixing in the pro- genitors. This is the first time that such an inference can be made, since this is the first time that a significant sample of [WR] PNe and non-[WR] PNe belonging exactly to the same Galactic population is available. The O/H gradient of the PNe population in the Galactic disk flattens in the most internal parts of the Galaxy and possibly changes sign, in line with results from abundance determina- tions in B-type stars (Smartt et al. 2001). The median oxygen abundance in the bulge is larger by 0.2 dex than that PNe seen in the direction of the bulge but per- taining to the disk. The oxygen abundance distribution for the bulge PNe has a shape similar to that found by Zoccali et al. (2003) for the metallicity distribution of bulge giants (with a sharp cut-off at high abundance and a long tail at low abundance), but it is nar- rower by about 0.3 dex. The bulge PNe with smaller oxygen abundances tend to have smaller radial velocities. Among the PNe seen in the direction of the bulge and per- taining to our merged sample, SB 32 (PN G 349.7-09.1) has a location in the (Vlsr, lII) diagram and a low oxygen abundance, indicating that it probably belongs to the Galactic halo popula- tion. Finally, the distributions of N/O are the same in the disk PNe seen in the direction of the bulge and in PNe pertaining physically to the bulge. They are also the same in [WR] PNe and non[WR] PNe pertaining to the bulge. Some of these findings are in line with what was known before. Others are rather unexpected. Taken together, and com- bined with data from other sources, they should provide inter- esting constraints on the stellar populations in the inner parts of the Galaxy, on the Galaxy chemical evolution and on the causes of the [WR] phenomenon. Acknowledgements. S.K.G. acknowledges the "Jumelage Astronomie France-Pologne" as well as the Polish grant KBN 2.PO3D.017.25 for financial support. G.S. acknowledges the "Jumelage Astronomie France-Pologne" and the "PICs Franco-Bresilien" for financial sup- port. A.V.E. acknowledges FAPESP for his graduate fellowship. References Acker, A., Neiner, C. 2003, A&A, 403, 659 Acker A., Ochsenbein F., Stenholm B., et al. 1992, Strasbourg-ESO Catalogue of Galactic Planetary Nebulae. ESO publication Acker, A., G´orny, S.K., Cuisinier, F. 1996, A&A, 305, 944 Beaulieu, S.F., Dopita, M.A., Freeman K.C. 1999, ApJ 515, 610 Beaulieu S.F., Freeman K.C., Kalnajs A.J., et al. 2000, AJ 120, 855 Blocker, T. 1995, A&A, 299, 755 Blocker, T. 2001, Ap&SS, 275, 1 Blocker, T., Osterbart, R., Weigelt, G., et al. 2001, in "Post-AGB ob- jects as a phase of stellar evolution", eds. R. Szczerba & S. K. G´orny, Astrophysics & Space Science Library (Kluwer), p. 241 Chiappini, C, Matteucci, F., Romano, D. 2001, ApJ, 554, 1044 Crowther P.A., De Marco O., Barlow M.J. 1998, MNRAS 296, 367 Cuisinier, F., Maciel, W.J., Koppen, J., et al. 2000, A&A 353, 543 de Ara´ujo, F.X., Marcolino W.L.F., Pereira, C.B., Cuisinier F. 2002, AJ 124, 464 De Marco, O. 2003, in Proc. IAU 209 "Planetary Nebulae: their Evolution and Role in the Universe", eds. Kwok S., Dopita M. & Sutherland R., ASP/IAU Publications, p.215 De Marco, O., Soker, N. 2002, PASP, 114, 602 Durand, S., Acker, A., Zijlstra, A. 1998, A&AS 132, 13 Escudero, A.V., Costa, R.D.D. 2001, A&A, 380, 300 Escudero, A. V., Costa, R. D. D., Maciel, W. J. 2004, A&A, 414, 211 G´orny, S.K. 2001, in "Low mass Wolf-Rayet Stars: origin and evo- lution", eds. Waters, E., Zijlstra, A. & Blocker T., Ap&SS, 275, 67 G´orny, S.K., Stasi´nska, G. 1995, A&A, 284, 949 G´orny, S.K., Tylenda, R. 2000, A&A, 362, 1008 G´orny, S.K., Stasi´nska, G., Szczerba, R., Tylenda, R. 2001, A&A, 377, 1007 Herwig, F. 2001, Ap&SS, 275, 15 Hu, J.Y., Bibo, E.A. 1990, A&A, 234, 435 Iben I., Kaler J.B., Truran J.W., Renzini A. 1983, ApJ, 264, 605 Keenan, F.P., Aller, L.H., Bell, K.L., et al. 1996, MNRAS 281, 1073 IAU Symp. 180 Koesterke L., Hamann W.-R. 1997, "Planetary Nebulae", eds. Habing H.J. & Lamers H.J.G.L.M., Kluwer, p.114 in Proc. Kohoutek, L. 1994, Ast. Nach. 315, 235 Leuenhagen U., Hamann W.-R. 1998, A&A, 330, 265 Leuenhagen U., Hamann W.-R., Jeffery C.S. 1996, A&A, 312, 167 Liu, X.-W. 2002, Rev. Mex. A&A (Serie de Conferencias) 12, 70 Maciel, W., Koppen, J. 1994, A&A, 282, 436 Maciel, W., Quireza, C. 1999, 1&A, 345, 629 Marigo, P. 2001, A&A 370, 194 M´endez, R.H., Niemela, V.S. 1982, in IAU Symp. 99 "Wolf-Rayet Stars", eds. de Loore & Willis, p. 457 Parker, Q.A., Morgan D.H., 2003, MNRAS 341, 961 Parker Q.A., Phillipps S., Morgan D.H. 1999, in "New Perspectives on the Interstellar Medium", Taylor, Landecker & Joncas (eds.), ASP Conf. Ser. Vol. 168, p. 126 Parker, Q.A., Hartley, M., Russeil, D., et al. 2003, in IAU Symp. 209 "Planetary Nebulae: their Evolution and Role in the Universe", eds. Kwok S., Dopita M. & Sutherland R., ASP/IAU Publications, p. 25 Pena, M., Hamann, W.-R., Koesterke, L., et al. 1997, ApJ 491, 233 Pena, M., Stasi´nska, G., Medina, S. 2001, A&A 367, 983 Seaton, M.J. 1979, MNRAS 187, 73 Smartt, S. J., Venn, K. A., Dufton, P. L., et al. 2001, A&A, 367, 86 Stasi´nska, G., Tylenda, R. 1994, A&A, 289, 225 Stasi´nska, G., Tylenda, R., Acker, A., Stenholm, B. 1991, A&A, 247, 173 Stasi´nska,,G. Tylenda, R., Acker, A., Stenholm, B. 1992, A&A, 266, 486 Stasi´nska, G., Richer, M. G., McCall, M. L. 1998, A&A, 336, 667 Szczerba, R., G´orny, S.K., Stasi´nska G., et al. 2001, in "Low mass Wolf-Rayet Stars: origin and evolution", eds. Waters, E., Zijlstra, A. & Blocker T., Ap&SS 275, 113 G´orny, S. K. et al.: The populations of planetary nebulae in the direction of the Galactic bulge 15 Szczerba, R., Volk, K., G´orny, S.K. 2003, in IAU Symp. 209 "Planetary Nebulae: their Evolution and Role in the Universe", eds. Kwok S., Dopita M. & Sutherland R., ASP/IAU Publications, p. 301 Tylenda, R. 1996, in "Hydrogen-Deficient Stars", Jeffery C.S., Heber U. (eds.), ASP Conference Series, p.101 Tylenda, R., Acker, A., Stenholm, B., et al. 1991, A&AS, 89, 77 Tylenda, R., Acker, A., Stenholm, B. 1993, A&AS, 102, 595 Tylenda, R., Stasi´nska, G., Acker, A., Stenholm, B. 1994, A&AS, 106, 559 van der Hucht, K.A., Conti, P.S., Lundstrom, I., Stenholm, B. 1981, Space Sci. Rev. 28, 227 Zijlstra, A. A., Acker, A., Walsh, J.R. 1997, A&AS, 125, 289 Zoccali, M.; Renzini, A.; Ortolani, S., et al. 2003, A&A, 399, 931
astro-ph/0310552	3	0310	2004-04-12T12:36:03	Cosmological principle and honeycombs	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present the possibility that the gravitational growth of primordial density fluctuations leads to what can be considered a week version of the cosmological principle. The large scale mass distribution associated with this principle must have the geometrical structures known as a regular honeycombs. We give the most important parameters that characterize the honeycombs associated with the closed, open, and flat FLRW models. These parameters can be used to determine by means of observations which is the appropriate honeycomb. For each of these honeycombs, and for a nearly flat universe, we have calculated the probability that a randomly placed observer could detect the honeycomb as a function of the density parameters.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Cosmological Principle and Honeycombs C. Criado ∗ Departamento de Fisica Aplicada I, Universidad de Malaga, 29071 Malaga, Spain (c [email protected]) N. Alamo † Departamento de Algebra, Geometria y Topologia, Universidad de Malaga, 29071 Malaga, Spain ([email protected]) Abstract We present the possibility that the gravitational growth of primordial density fluctuations leads to what can be considered a week version of the cosmological principle. The large scale mass distribution associated with this principle must have the geometrical structures known as a regular honeycombs. We give the most important parameters that characterize the honeycombs associated with the closed, open, and flat Friedmann- Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker models. These parameters can be used to determine by means of observations which is the appropriate honeycomb. For each of these honeycombs, and for a nearly flat universe, we have calculated the probability that a randomly placed observer could detect the honeycomb as a function of the density parameters Ω0 and ΩΛ0. PACS: 98.65.Dx, 98.80.-k, 04.20.-q. Keywords: cosmological principle, honeycombs, large-scale structure of universe. 1 Introduction In recent works (see Refs. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]), it has been speculated that the cos- mological large scale matter distribution may form repetitive structures analo- gous to the crystalline ones formed with polyhedra. The geometrical structures of largest symmetry into which a homogeneous space can be decomposed are known as regular honeycombs. A regular honeycomb is a decomposition of the ∗Partially supported by the Spanish Research Grant FQM-192 †Partially supported by the Spanish Research Grant BFM2001-1825 1 space into congruent regular polyhedra (see [6, 7]). In Sect. 2 we give a new version of the cosmological principle that we call the weak cosmological princi- ple. This version is the most natural way to extend the cosmological principle to a universe with inhomogeneities. The geometrical structures that fit it are precisely the regular honeycombs. Because closed, open, and flat Friedmann- Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models correspond to the three possible homogeneous spaces: elliptic, hyperbolic, and Euclidean respectively, we have given the distances, angles and others characteristic parameters for the regular honeycombs of these spaces (Sects. 3 and 4). The calculation of the distances and angles appears in the appendix. Observe that among these three spaces only the Euclidean one does not have a proper scale. The other two have a charac- teristic scale, namely, the curvature radius (see [8]). Thus, in these spaces there are no homothetic polyhedra and the honeycombs are rigid in the sense that the size of the basic cell cannot be arbitrary as is the case for the Euclidean honey- combs. In particular, in these spaces there cannot be fractal structures because fractals do not have any characteristic scale. In Sect. 5 we present a possible interpretation of this geometric scenario in terms of the cosmological dynamic, by interpreting the spherical and hyperbolic honeycombs as the pattern of large scale mass distribution. Such crystalline structures would be the result of the evolution of a homogeneous one. If the basic cell of the honeycomb lies in the interior of the particle horizon then the appropriate honeycomb could be deter- mined by observations, providing a check on the parameters values that we have calculate in sections 3 and 4. In section 6 we have detailed some observational prospect for detection of the honeycomb structure. The case in which the size of the basic cell is much smaller than the particle horizon is commented in sub- section 6.1. In subsection 6.2 we have studied the case that the particle horizon is of the order of the basic cell's size, and we have calculated, for each regular honeycomb, the probability that a randomly placed observer could detect the honeycomb as a function of the density parameters Ω0 and ΩΛ0. 2 A weak version of the cosmological principle The assumption of large-scale homogeneity together with that of large-scale isotropy, is called the cosmological principle (CP) (see, for example, [11]). This principle applies for continuous mass distribution. For the discrete case, the symmetry of the regular honeycombs is the most natural definition of discrete homogeneity and isotropy. A regular (or homogeneous) honeycomb is a decom- position of the space into congruent regular polyhedra, which are called the cells of the honeycomb. Any motion that takes a cell into another, takes the whole honeycomb into itself, i.e., belongs to the group of symmetries of the honeycomb. The homogeneity corresponds to the decomposition of the space into regular polyhedra (see [7]), and the isotropy corresponds to the symmetry of regular polyhedra. When all the matter is distributed homogeneously at the vertices of a honeycomb, we say that it obeys the discrete cosmological principle (DCP). We can consider another version of the CP, in which the matter is dis- 2 Table 1: Three-dimensional spherical honeycombs. Name 5 − cell 8 − cell 16 − cell 24 − cell 120 − cell 600 − cell Schlafli N0 symbol {3, 3, 3} {4, 3, 3} {3, 3, 4} {3, 4, 3} {5, 3, 3} {3, 3, 5} 5 16 8 24 600 120 N1 N2 N3 Basic cell 10 32 24 96 1200 720 10 24 32 96 720 1200 5 8 16 24 120 600 tetrahedron cube tetrahedron octahedron dodecahedron tetrahedron tributed in a continuous way, in the pattern of a honeycomb, with a hierarchical distribution of matter densities, increasing though the sequence: interior, faces, edges, and vertices of the basic cells. In general, if a distribution of matter has the symmetry of a honeycomb, we say that it obeys the weak cosmological prin- ciple (WCP). It includes the CP when the matter is distributed homogeneously and isotropically in the basic cell, and also includes the considered above DCP as a limit case. Another weak version of the cosmological principle has been considered in [9, 10]. In that version the universe is locally homogeneous and isotropic but not necessarily globally homogeneous and isotropic. In a space of dimension 3 with constant curvature, the honeycombs are classified by means of three integer numbers {p, q, r} called the Schlafli sym- bols, which completely characterize the honeycomb (see [7]). Specifically, {p, q} characterizes the polyhedron which is the basic cell of the honeycomb, p is the number of vertices (or edges) of each regular polygon that constitute the faces of a cell, q is the number of faces (or edges) having a common vertex in each cell, and r is the number of cells having a common edge. Therefore the dihedral angle of each cell, α, equals 2π/r. Note that because the dihedral angle must be a divisor of 2π not all the regular polyhedra can be the cells of a regular honeycomb. It is easy to see that the number of vertices, V, edges, E, and faces, F, in a polyhedron with Schlafli symbols {p, q} can be given in terms of p, q by V = 2 2 − 1 1 − q( 1 p ) , E = qV 2 , and F = qV p . (1) 3 Honeycombs in the closed FLRW models In this case the space-like sections of the universe are three dimensional spheres, S3. Honeycombs in S3 are in one-to-one correspondence with regular polyhedra in R4. The correspondence can be described as follows. The convex hull of a set M is the minimal convex set containing this set; it is the intersection of all convex sets containing M . Then the convex hull in R4 of the set of vertices of a honeycomb in S3 is a regular polyhedron inscribed in S3, and conversely if P is a regular polyhedron inscribed in S3, then the central projection of its faces 3 Table 2: Characteristic parameters associated with the three-dimensional spher- ical honeycombs (R(t) = 1). rc Vol dE dF ri 1.8235 1.0472 1.5708 1.0472 0.2709 0.6283 1.3181 1.0472 1.0472 0.7854 0.3881 0.3881 1.1503 0.9553 0.7854 0.6155 0.3648 0.2318 0.9117 0.7854 0.5236 0.5236 0.3141 0.1354 1.1503 0.7854 0.9553 0.6155 0.2318 0.3649 3.9478 2.4674 1.2337 0.8224 0.1644 0.0329 0.2533 0.8105 0.4023 1.2158 30.3964 6.0793 d ρ Name 5 − cell 8 − cell 16 − cell 24 − cell 120 − cell 600 − cell onto S3 forms a honeycomb in S3. From the six regular polyhedra of R4 (see [6, 7]) we get the following six regular honeycombs in S3: of 8 spherical cubes. of 8 spherical tetrahedra. of 24 spherical octahedra. 5-cell of S3, which is composed of 5 spherical tetrahedra. The regular simplex of R4 with Schlafli symbols {3, 3, 3} gives the honeycomb The regular cube of R4 ({4, 3, 3}) gives the 8-cell of S3, which is composed The regular cocube of R4 ({3, 3, 4}) gives the 16-cell of S3, which is composed The regular 24-hedron ({3, 4, 3}) gives the 24-cell of S3, which is composed The 120-cell honeycomb ({5, 3, 3}) is composed of 120 spherical dodecahedra. Finally the 600-cell honeycomb ({3, 3, 5}) is composed of 600 spherical tetra- Reversing the order of the Schlafli symbols yields the so called dual honey- combs. The vertices of the honeycomb P ∗, dual to the honeycomb P, should be taken as the centres of the cells of P. The symmetry groups of P and P ∗ coincide. The honeycombs 8-cell and 16-cell are dual to one another, and the same holds for the 120-cell and 600-cell. For symmetric Schlafli symbols, dual honeycombs are congruent. This is the case of the 5-cell and the 24-cell. In our interpretation of the honeycombs as the patterns of the large scale matter distribution, if the higher density is at the vertices of a honeycomb then the lower density is at the vertices of the corresponding dual honeycomb. hedra. Table 1 gives the following characteristics of these honeycombs: the Schlafli symbols {p, q, r}; the number of vertices, N0, edges, N1, faces, N2, and poly- hedra, N3. Note that N0 − N1 + N2 − N3 is the Euler characteristic of S3, so it is zero. In Table 2 we also give the distance between adjacent vertices (or edge-length), d; the distance from the centre C of a cell to a vertex V (or circum-radius), rc; to an edge E, dE; to a face F (or in-radius), ri; and the distance from the centre of a face to a vertex of that face, dF . The calculation of these parameters is shown in the appendix. The distances in the R-W spherical space for any cosmic time t are the above multiplied by the expansion function of the universe, R(t). To obtain the corresponding recessional velocities we have to multiply the above distances by the Hubble parameter, H(t). 4 Table 3: Other characteristic parameters associated with the three-dimensional spherical honeycombs. Name Dihedral 5 − cell 8 − cell 16 − cell 24 − cell 120 − cell 600 − cell angle 120o 120o 90o 120o 120o 72o Interior CV EV angle 109.47o 109.47o 90o 70.53o 109.47o 63.43o 4 4 8 6 4 20 4 4 6 8 4 12 We can also obtain the volume of a cell, Vol, as the quotient of the volume of S3, 2π2R(t)3, and the number N3 of cells of the honeycomb. The density of vertices ρ is the quotient of N0 and the volume of S3. In Table 2 we list the values of the volume Vol and ρ for the six honeycombs considered. Other interesting parameters of the honeycombs are: the number of edges that share a vertex, EV , which is given by EV = 2N1/N0 and the number, CV , of cells that share a vertex, which is given by CV = rEV /q. This number corresponds also to the number of vertices of basic cell of the dual honeycomb, and thus is given by CV = 1/(1 − q( 1 r )). In table 3 we list the values of these parameters, as well as the dihedral angle, and the interior angle φ of the polygons constituting the faces of each cell. 2 − 1 4 Honeycombs in the open and flat FLRW mod- els The space-like sections of the universe, in the open FLRW model, are 3-dimensional spaces of constant negative curvature, and these spaces are isomorphic to H 3, the hyperbolic space (or Lobachevskij space) of dimension 3. If we restrict ourselves to honeycombs with bounded cells it follows that there are only four regular honeycombs in H 3 [7]( see the appendix). Their Schlafli symbols and dihedral and interior angles are listed in table 4. We have also calculated the characteristic distances and angles of the basic cell of these honeycombs, as well as the volume of the basic cell, the number, EV , of edges that share a vertex, the number, CV , of cells that share a vertex, the volume of the basic cell, Vol, and the density, ρ. Table 4 and 5 give the values of all these parameters. Note that the honeycombs d90 and c72 are dual to one another, and that d120 and d72 are self-dual. The flat universe corresponds to the Euclidean tridimensional space. The regular polyhedra of this space are the five platonic polyhedra. Among these polyhedra only the cube has the dihedral angle divisor of 2π. Thus the only possible regular honeycomb is formed by cubes. Its Schlafli symbols are {4, 3, 4}, the dihedral and the interior angles are both of 90o, CV = 8, and EV = 6. But 5 Table 4: Characteristic parameters associated with the three-dimensional bounded honeycombs of the open R-W space Name i120 d90 c72 d72 Schlafli symbol {3, 5, 3} {5, 3, 4} {4, 3, 5} {5, 3, 5} Basic cell icosahedron dodecahedron cube dodecahedron Dihedral angle 120o 90o 72o 72o Interior CV EV angle 41.81o 90o 63.43o 63.43o 12 8 20 20 20 6 12 12 Table 5: Other characteristic parameters associated with the three-dimensional bounded honeycombs of the open R-W space (R(t) = 1). Name i120 d90 c72 d72 d 1.7366 1.0613 1.6169 1.9927 rc 1.3826 1.2265 1.2265 1.9028 dE 0.9726 1.0613 0.8425 1.4391 ri 0.8683 0.8085 0.5306 0.9964 dF 0.9727 0.8425 1.0613 1.4321 Vol 4.6860 4.3062 1.7225 11.1991 ρ 0.2134 0.5806 0.2322 0.0893 because in a flat space there are not a proper length, the basic cube can be of any size and there is no characteristic distance. We can also consider whether there are honeycombs structures for models of the universe with local constant curvature but with topology different to the usual one. Models of universes of this type have been considered; see [12, 13, 20]. See also [14] for a recent result that constrain the possible topology of these spaces. Special attention has been paid to the locally flat and the locally hyperbolic ones. The reason is that one can then have universes that are compact and flat, and universes that are compact and have negative constant curvature respectively. One which is very popular is known as the Seifert- Weber dodecahedral space (see [8, 21]). This space is obtained from the above d72 hyperbolic honeycomb. To construct this space we have to glue together the opposite faces of the basic dodecahedron using a clockwise twist of 3/10 of a revolution. Another example, this one with positive constant curvature, is the Poincar´e dodecahedral space. This space is associated with the 120-cell spherical honeycomb. To obtain it, opposite faces of the basic honeycomb are glued together using this time a twist of 1/10 of a revolution. For the flat space, identification of the opposite faces of a cube gives the 3-torus, which is a compact flat model of the universe. Only this last space, among all spaces with non trivial topology, admits a regular honeycomb structure. This is because for constant non zero curvature there are not two basic polyhedra whose distances between vertices, are such that one is a divisor of the other. Comment. The relation of the above regular honeycombs and the multiply connected spherical orientable spaces (see [15, 16, 17]) is as follows: to obtain a spherical orientable 3-manifold by identifying the faces of a platonic polyhedron Σ, the polyhedron must obey two conditions (see [18]): (1) the dihedral angle 6 must be a submultiple of 2π, say 2π/r, and (2) the number of edges of Σ must be divisible by r. By definition, the basic polyhedron cell of any honeycomb obeys (1), but there are two spherical honeycomb, the 16-cell and the 600-cell, that do not satisfy (2). With the remaining four spherical honeycombs we can associate globally homogeneous spherical 3-manifolds. These manifolds are single action spherical manifolds. The single action spherical manifolds are those for which the members of a subgroup R of S3 act as pure right-handed Clifford translations (see [19]). With the honeycomb 5-cell, whose basic cell is a tetrahedron, we can associate the lens space L(5, 1), which is the single action manifold associate to the cyclic group Z5. With the honeycomb 8-cell, whose basic cell is a cube, we can associate the Montesinos's quaternionic space, which is a prism manifold associate to the binary dihedral group D∗ 2. With the honeycomb 24-cell, whose basic cell is an octahedron, we can associate the Montesinos's octahedral space, which is the single action manifold associate to the binary tetrahedral group T ∗. Finally, with the honeycomb 120-cell, whose basic cell is a dodecahedron, we can associate the above-mentioned Poincar´e dodecahedral space, which is the single action manifold associate to the binary icosahedral group I ∗. These associations provide a way to show that S3 is a covering space of the above manifolds. Among the four hyperbolic honeycombs only the i120 and the d72 obey the above condition (2). By identification of opposites faces of the basic icosahedron cell of i120 we get a hyperbolic compact manifold, the 3-torus T 3. The basic dodecahedron cell of the honeycomb d72, gives rise by identification of opposites faces, to the above-mentioned Seifert-Weber dodecahedral space. Finally, [18] gives other possible manifolds associated with these honeycombs. 5 Interpretation in terms of standard FLRW cos- mology Analysis of the power spectrum of density perturbations and the correlation function have shown that galaxies appear to be gathered into immense sheets and filaments surrounding very large voids (see Refs. [1, 2, 3]). The most sym- metric distribution of matter, after the homogeneous and isotropic one, are those associated with the honeycomb structures. These structures give the most natural generalization of the cosmological principle (CP). We have named this generalization weak cosmological principle (WCP). Then we propose that the large scale structure of the universe could have the structure of a honeycomb. We have seen that there are eleven suitable honeycombs, six corresponding to a closed universe, four to an open one, and one to a flat one. We have calculated the different parameters that characterize these honeycombs. The model that we propose is very speculative, but we think that it could be useful in looking for new ways to interpret the inhomogeneities that has been discovered on large cosmological scales. To make this scenario feasible we have to assume that, initially, there was a homogeneous and isotropic distribution of 7 dark matter or of some other non observable kind of matter. We accept also that inhomogeneities with higher energy density than the mean, formed during the cosmic evolution, are distributed in the most homogeneous and isotropic manner possible, which we assume to have the honeycomb structure. From this, we can speculate with the fact that the visible matter is concentrated in these inhomogeneities of higher density, with a hierarchical distribution of densities, increasing through the sequence: interior, faces, edges, and vertices of the basic cells. The above symmetric distribution may be considered as the limit attractor of the less symmetrical present distribution consisting of a huge net of filaments made up of clusters of galaxies. This net would evolve seeking the stability associated with the symmetry of any of the above-described honeycombs. At the present time we could be just in the phase transition that goes from a more or less homogeneous distribution to a crystalline one. We do not know what the precise dynamic governing the above process might be. Presumably, it would be a very complex one, with the extragalactic magnetic field as a principal actor. It is possible that the seeds of these structures were generated in the first moments after the big bang, perhaps before the inflation due to the strong magnetic fields generated by the turbulence of the charged plasma (see [5, 22, 23, 24]). If this were the case, there would be a suppression of cosmological density fluctuations on scales beyond the size of the basic cell, similar to what happens in small universes models (see [25, 19]). Then the honeycomb models could also explain the existence of a cut-off in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) angular power spectrum on large angular scales (see [26]). 6 Observational prospect 6.1 The case in which the size of the basic cell of the honeycomb is much smaller than the particle horizon If the size of the basic cell of the honeycomb is much smaller than the particle horizon we could verify the correctness of the above model. A possible way would be to study the distribution of high redshifts, z, in any direction. They should exhibit peaks with periodic separations in log(1 + z). The period should depend on the periodic structure of the honeycomb and, therefore, on the observational direction. Sufficient observations of this kind would enable the determination of the appropriate honeycomb. Regularities of this type has been reported by Broadhurst et al (see Refs. [3]). They found that in regions of small area around the northern and southern galactic polar caps, the high and low density alternate with a rather constant step of 128h−1M pc. In other directions the regularity is much less pronounced. Another possible observational parameter could be the number of filaments that converge on a supercluster. The open space honeycombs only admit 6, 12, or 20 filaments; the possibilities for the closed space are 4, 6, 8 and 12; the flat one only admit 6 filaments (see tables 3 and 4). 8 Once we know the honeycomb we can use its characteristic distances to determine the present curvature of the universe R0. The value of R0 may then be used to sharpen the value of the density parameter, Ωtot, (it can be calculated from Ωtot = 1− kc2/(R0H0)2, k = 1,−1 for the closed and open case respectively), as well as other cosmological parameters. We can look also for observable effects of these structures on the gravitational waves, analogous to the x-rays diffraction on crystals. Another possible obser- vational fact is the lens effect of these periodic structures on electromagnetic waves. 6.2 The case where the particle horizon is of the order of the basic cell's size If the particle horizon is of the order of the basic cell's size, we may observe only a part of that basic cell, but the data ratio between the characteristic distances of the cell as well as the values of EV and CV can be enough to determinate which is the appropriate honeycomb. To this end, it would be important that we can observe at least one vertex of the honeycomb, because in that case we can observe EV , CV , and the dihedral and interior angles, and if these values are the given in the above tables then we will have evidence that we are in a honeycomb. Also these values will be enough to determinate the appropriate honeycomb in all the cases except for the pair of spherical honeycombs the 5 − cell and 8 − cell, and the hyperbolic c72 and d72, for which the values of these four parameters coincide. To discriminate between these cases, we must use the observable distances to the vertex, edges, and faces to reconstruct the basic cell. Now we will calculate for each of the honeycombs, the probability that a randomly placed observer can detect a vertex of the honeycomb. This probability, pr, will depend on the considered horizon radius rh. In the following we assume that the universe can be described by the R- W metric, and that the matter is made up from dust of density ρm and a cosmological constant Λ. The Friedmann equation is then given by: H 2 = 8πGρm 3 kc2 R2 + Λ 3 , − (2) Moreover, we have that ρm = (R/R0)3ρm0, and the red-shift z, is given by where H = R/R is the Hubble parameter, G is the Newton's constant, and k = 1, 0,−1 for an open, flat, and closed universe respectively. z = R0/R − 1, where the subscript 0 denote evaluation at the present time. The RW metric gives dr = (1/R)cdt for the photon equation. Integrating this equation, and taking into account the above relations, we can find (see [27]) that the comoving distance r(z), run over by a photon as function of the red-shift z, is given by: r(z) = p1 − ΩtotZ z 0 (ΩΛ0 + (1 − Ωtot)(x + 1)2 + Ω0(x + 1)3)−1/2dx, (3) 9 1 pr 0 0 1.08 0.5 0.5 W0 W0 Wtot 0.3 0.3 1 Figure 1: Probability, pr, that a randomly located observer can detect the spherical honeycomb 16 − cell, for 0.3 < Ω0 < 0.5, 1 < Ωtot < 1.08 and z = ∞. where Ω0, ΩΛ0, and Ωtot are the density parameters given by Ω0 = 8πGρm0 , ΩΛ0 = Λc2 3H 2 , and Ωtot = Ω0 + ΩΛ0. The above distance, r(z), is given in units of the curvature radius R0. The horizon radius, rh, corresponds to z = ∞; the last scattering surface radius, rLSS, associated with the cosmic microwave back- ground (CMB), corresponds to z ≈ 1100; and for the quasars and the clusters of galaxies, we could take red-shift cut-offs of z ≈ 6 and z ≈ 1 respectively. The probability pr associated with any of these radius r(z), is given by the fraction of the basic cell volume in which the distance to a vertex is smaller than r(z), that is : 3H0 2 pr = Vr V , (4) where Vr is the volume of the region of the basic cell such that the distances from its points to a vertex are less than r(z), and V is the volume of the basic cell of the honeycomb. If 2r(z) < edge-length d, the spheres with centres at the vertices and radius r(z) do not intersect, and Vr is given by: If r(z) > rc then Vr = V , and pr = 1. Vr = V Vs(r(z)) CV , (5) ) is the where Vs(r(z)) is the volume of the sphere of radius r(z), CV = ) is the number of vertices of number of cells around a vertex, and V = a cell. The volume of a sphere of radius r in S3 and in Π3 is given respectively by: 2 1−q( 1 − − p 1 r 2 1−q( 1 2 1 2 Vs(r) = π(2r − sin 2r), Vs(r) = π(2r − sinh 2r), (6) 10 Table 6: Probability that a randomly located observer detect a given hon- eycomb, for red-shift z = 1, 6, 1100,∞. For the honeycombs of the closed universe we have taken (Ω0, Ωtot) = (0.3, 1.03), and for the open universe (Ω0, Ωtot) = (0.3, 0.95). Honeycomb r(z)(0.3, 1.03) 5 − cell 8 − cell 16 − cell 24 − cell 120 − cell 600 − cell r(z)(0.3, 0.95) i120 d90 c72 d72 z = 1 0.135 0.003 0.008 0.004 0.012 0.311 0.062 0.170 0.004 0.012 0.005 0.002 z = 6 0.337 0.040 0.127 0.064 0.191 - 0.913 0.423 0.070 0.191 0.076 0.029 z = 1100 0.558 0.173 0.546 0.277 0.809 1 1 0.706 0.347 0.740 0.374 0.145 z = ∞ 0.576 0.190 0.590 0.304 0.860 1 1 0.729 0.386 0.779 0.420 0.161 where we have taken the curvature radius R = 1. If d/2 < r(z) < distance from the centre of a face to a vertex of that face dF , there are no common points to more than two spheres. The volume of the region of the intersection of two spheres is the double of the volume of the spherical cup, Vc corresponding to the height r(z) − d/2, multiplied by the number of edges of a cell, E, and divided by the number of cells with a common edge, r. Thus we have: Vr = V CV Vs(r) − E r 2Vc(r − d/2) (7) segment of height d/2, Vseg(d/2). But Vseg(h) = R h The volume Vc(r − d/2) equals Vs(r)/2 minus the volume of the spherical 0 A(y)dx, where A(y) is the area of the circle of radius y. Taking into account that for the spherical and hyperbolic cases we have respectively: A(y) = π sin2 y, cos r = cos y cos x, and A(y) = π sinh2 y, cosh r = cosh y cosh x, we obtain, for the spherical and hyperbolic segment volume respectively, Vseg(h) = (h − cos2 r tan h), Vseg(h) = (h − cosh2 r tanh h). (8) With the above expressions we can calculate the probability pr in all the cases except when dF < r(z) < rc. In this case we can approximate the value of pr by interpolation. Using equation 3 we can express pr as a function of the density parameters Ω0, and Ωtot. As an example, we have shown in Fig. 1 the probability for a randomly located observer of detecting the spherical honeycomb 16 − cell, for 0.3 < Ω0 < 0.5, 1 < Ωtot < 1.08 and z = ∞. Note that if Ωtot → 0, then r(z) → 0, and the probability pr also goes to 0. 11 1.2 a 1.15 5 - c Wtot 1.1 1.05 16 - c 24 - c 8 - c Wtot 600 - c 120 - c 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 b d90 c72 i120 1 0.2 0.25 0.3 W0 0.35 0.4 0.2 0.25 d72 0.3 W0 0.35 0.4 Figure 2: Region of the (Ω0, Ωtot) plane where rLSS is greater than the circum- radius, rc, that is, the region on which the probability of detecting the honey- comb is 1. Fig. 2(a) shows these regions for the spherical honeycombs. The points in which rLSS < rc correspond to the region above the marked line (rLSS = rc). In the same way Fig. 2(b) gives these regions for the hyperbolic honeycombs. In this case the points with rLSS < rc are in the regions below the marked lines. Table 6 gives the probability of detecting any of the regular honeycombs considered above for z = 1, 6, 1100,∞. For the honeycombs of the closed universe we have taken (Ω0, Ωtot) = (0.3, 1.03), and for the open universe (Ω0, Ωtot) = (0.3, 0.95). These values of the density parameters are in the range, 0.9 < Ωtot < 1.1, of the nearly flat universes that have been given by recent observations [28]. The value omitted in the table corresponds to a value of r(z) such that dF < r(z) < rc, and, as it have been pointed out previously, it can not be calculated with the above procedure. Notice that in the closed universe the higher probabilities correspond to the 120− cell and 600− cell honeycombs, and to d90 in the open case. We have also calculated for each regular honeycomb the region of the (Ω0, Ωtot) plane, where rLSS is greater than the circum-radius, rc, that is, the region on which the probability of detecting the honeycomb is 1. Fig. 2(a) shows these regions for the spherical honeycombs, and Fig. 2(b) gives these regions for the hyperbolic honeycombs. Observe that the honeycombs that are easier to detect in a nearly flat universe are the spherical 120 − cell and 600 − cell. 12 7 Summary In this article, we have considered the possibility that the gravitational growth of primordial density fluctuations leads to what can be considered a week version of the cosmological principle, for which the large scale matter distribution has the pattern of a regular honeycomb. In a recently published paper (see [29]) we had studied the honeycombs in the space of relativistic velocities and in the Milne cosmological model. In both cases the honeycombs were the hyperbolic ones. In that paper we advanced some of the ideas of this one. There are 6 regular honeycombs associated with the closed FLRW universe, and 4 with bounded cells, to the open case. We have calculated the most important parameters characterizing these honeycombs. We have also given some observational prospect for detecting the honeycomb. Moreover, we have calculated, for each honeycomb, and for a nearly flat universe, the probability that a randomly placed observer could detect the honeycomb as a function of the density parameters Ω0 and ΩΛ0. 8 Appendix In this appendix we will calculate the characteristic distances and angles of the regular honeycombs considered in this paper. To calculate these distances as functions of the Schlafli symbols {p, q, r} of the honeycomb we proceed as follows. First, we decompose each polyhedron into F identical pyramids with the apex in the centre of the polyhedron. Each of these pyramids is then decomposed into 2p double-rectangular tetrahedra by dropping perpendicular lines from the apex onto the faces and onto the lines bounding the faces. The vertices of this tetrahedron are: the centre of the cell, P3, the centre of a face, P2, the centre of an edge, P1, and a vertex of the cell, P0 (see Fig. 3). We recall that a tetrahedron P0P1P2P3 is said to be double-rectangular if its edge P3P2 is orthogonal to the face P0P1P2 and its edge P1P0 is orthogonal to the face P1P2P3. Thus, three out of the six dihedral angles are right angles. Thus, the double-rectangular tetrahedron is determined by its dihedral angles α, β, and γ corresponding to the edges, a = P3P2, b = P3P0, and c = P1P0 respectively. Then using spherical trigonometry we have (see [7]) tan a tan α = tan b tan( π 2 − β) = tan c tan γ = √∆ cos α cos γ , (9) where ∆ = sin2 α sin2 γ − cos2 β. By definition of p, q, and r it follows that α = π/p, β = π/q, and γ = π/r. Therefore, by substituting these values in Eq. (9) we obtain a, b, and c. The above defined characteristic distances of a honeycomb are then given by: d = 2c, rc = b, dE = arg sin(sin a/sin γ), ri = a, and dE = arg sin(sin c/sin α) (see Table 2). Moreover, we can get the interior angle φ of the polygons constituting the faces of each cell by solving the hyperbolic triangle P0P1P2. In fact, we have 13 P3 Α P2 Β P0 Γ P1 Figure 3: One of the 2pF identical double-rectangular tetrahedra which any regular polyhedron is decomposed into. sin φ 2 = cos α/cos c. In this way we have obtained the values of φ in Table 3. The space-like sections of the universe, in the open FLRW model, are 3- dimensional spaces of constant negative curvature, and these spaces are iso- morphic to H 3. We have followed Vinberg and Shvartsman [7] classification of hyperbolic honeycombs, which does not include as honeycombs those with cells inscribed in horospheres instead of finite spheres. As in the spherical case, for a honeycomb with Schlafli symbols {p, q, r} the dihedral angle of each cell, α, equals 2π/r, but in the hyperbolic case α has the restriction αmin ≤ α < αEuc, where αmin is the minimal possible dihedral angle in such a regular polyhedron in the hyperbolic space, and αEuc is the dihedral angle of the corresponding polyhedron in the Euclidean space. From this fact and if we restrict ourselves to honeycombs with bounded cells it follows that there are only four regular honeycombs in H 3 [7]. Their Schlafli symbols, dihedral, and interior angles are listed in Table 4. In our paper [29], we calculated the characteristic distances and angles of the basic cell of these honeycombs, as well as the volume of the basic cell, the number, EV , of edges that share a vertex, the number, CV , of cells that share a vertex, the volume of the basic cell, Vol, and the density, ρ. Tables 4 and 5 give the values of all these parameters. References [1] J. Einasto, M. Einasto, S. Gottlober, V. Muller, V. Saar, A.A. Starobinsky, E. Tago, D. Tucker, H. Andernach, & P. Frisch, Nature 385, 139-141 (1997). [2] J. Einasto, M. Einasto, P. Frisch, S. Gottlober, V. Muller, V. Saar, A.A. Starobinsky, E. Tago, D. Tucker, & H. Andernach, "The Supercluster-void network II. An oscillating cluster correlation function," Mon. Not. R. Astr. Soc. 269, 801-812 (1997). [3] T.J. Broadhurst, R.S. Ellis, D.C. Koo, & A.S. Szalay, "Large-scale distri- bution of galaxies at the galactic poles," Nature 343, 726-728 (1990). 14 [4] R. Kirsner, "The Universe as a lattice," Nature 385, 112-113 (1997). [5] E. Battaner, E. Florido, & J.M. Garcia-Ruiz, "Magnetic fields and large scale structure in a hot universe III. The polyhedric network," A&A 327, 8-10 (1997). [6] H.S.M. Coxeter, Regular Polytopes, (Dover, New York, 1973). [7] E.B. Vinberg & O.V. Shvartsman, Discrete Groups of Motions of Spaces of Constant Curvature, in Geometry II (ed. E.B. Vinberg), Encyclopaedia Math. Sci., Vol. 29 (Springer-Verlag, New York, 1993), pp. 139 - 248. [8] W. P. Thurston, Three-dimensional Geometry and Topology, Vol. 1 (Princeton University Press, New Jersey, 1997). [9] K. T. Inoue, & N. Sugiyama,"How large is our universe?," Phys. Rev. D67, 043003 (2003). [10] B. F. Roukema,"How to avoid the ambiguity in applying the Corpernicam principle for cosmic topology: take the observational approach," Advances in Space Research 31, 2, 449-457 (2003). [11] W. Rindler, Essential Relativity, 2nd ed. (Springer-Verlag, New York, 1986). [12] N.J.Cornish, D.N. Spergel and G.D. Starkman, "Circles in the sky:Finding topology with the microwave background radiation," Class.Quant.Grav. 15, 2657-2670 (1998). [13] J.R. Weeks, "Reconstructing the global topology of the universe from the cosmic microwave background," Class. Quant. Grav. 15, 2599-2604 (1998). [14] N.J.Cornish, D.N. Spergel, G.D. Starkman and E. Komatsu, "Constraining the Topology of the Universe," [arXiv:astr-ph/0310233], (2003). [15] M. Lachize-Rey and J-P Luminet, "Cosmic Topology," Phys. Rep. 254, 135-214 (1995). [16] K. T. Inoue, "Exploring Topology of the Universe in the Cosmic Microwave Background," PhD thesis [arXiv:astr-ph/0103158], (2001). [17] J. Levin, "Topology and the Cosmic Microwave Background," Phys. Rep. 365, 251-333 (2002). [18] B. Everitt, "3-manifolds from Platonic solids," Topology Appl. 138,1-3, 253-267 (2004). [19] R. Lehoucq, J. R. Weeks, J. P. Uzan, J.P. Gausmann, & J. P. Luminet, "Eigenmodes of 3-dimensional spherical spaces and their application to cosmology," Class. Quant. Grav. 19, 4683-4708 (2002). 15 [20] N. J. Cornish and J.R. Weeks, "Measuring the Shape of the Universe," Notice of the AMS 45, 11, 1463-1470 (1998). [21] W. P. Thurston and J.R. Weeks, Scientific American, July 1984, 108-120 (1984). [22] E. Battaner, E. Florido, & J. Jimenez-Vicente, "Magnetic fields and large scale structure in a hot universe I. General Equations," A&A 326, 13-22 (1997). [23] E. Florido & E. Battaner, "Magnetic fields and large scale structure in a hot universe II. Magnetic flux tubes and filamentary structure," A&A 327, 1-7 (1997). [24] E. Battaner, E. Florido, "Magnetic fields and large scale structure in a hot universe IV. The egg-carton Universe," A&A 338, 383-385 (1998). [25] J. P. Luminet, J. R. Weeks, A. Riazuelo, R. Lehoucq, & J. P. Uzan, Nature, 425, 593-595 (2003). [26] C. N. Bennett et al, "First year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe(WMAP) observations: Preliminary maps and basics results," As- trophys. J. Suppl. 148, 1-27 (2003). [27] J. A. Peacock, Cosmological Physics (Cambridge University Press, Cam- bridge, 1999), pp. 76. [28] J. L. Sievers et al, "Cosmological parameters from Cosmic Background Imager Observations and Comparations with BOOMERANG, DASI, and MAXIMA3," [arXiv:astr-ph/0205387]. [29] C. Criado, N. Alamo, "Relativistic Kinematic Honeycombs," Found. Phys. Lett. 15, 4, 345-358 (2002). 16
astro-ph/9612161	1	9612	1996-12-17T11:27:34	Global regularities in integrated galaxy spectra	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have investigated some statistical properties of integrated spectra of galaxies from Kennicutt (1992a) spectrophotometric atlas. The input for the analysis are galaxy spectra sampled in 1300 bins between 3750 \AA~ and 6500 \AA. We make use of Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to analyse the 1300-dimensional space spanned by the spectra. Their projection onto the plane defined by the first two principal components, the principal plane, shows that normal galaxies are in a quasi-linear sequence that we call spectral sequence. We show that the spectral sequence is closely related to the Hubble morphological sequence. These results are robust in the sense that the reality of the spectral sequence does not depend on data normalization. The existence of this sequence suggests that a single parameter may describe the spectrum of normal galaxies. We have investigated this hypothesis with Bruzual & Charlot (1995) models of spectral evolution. We show that, for single age models (15 Gyr), the spectral sequence can be parametrized by the characteristic star formation time-scales of the different morphological types. By examining the projection of evolutionary tracks of normal galaxies onto the principal plane, we verify that the spectral sequence is also an evolutive sequence, with galaxy spectra evolving from later to earlier spectral types. Considering the close correspondence between the spectral and morphological sequences, this lead us to speculate that galaxies may evolve morphologically along the Hubble sequence, from Sm/Im to E.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- ?? (2018) Global regularities in integrated galaxy spectra Laerte Sodr´e Jr.1⋆ & H´ector Cuevas1† 1Departamento de Astronomia, Instituto Astronomico e Geof´ısico da USP, Av. Miguel Stefano 4200, 04301-904 Sao Paulo, Brazil 6 September 2018 ABSTRACT We have investigated some statistical properties of integrated spectra of galaxies from Kennicutt (1992a) spectrophotometric atlas. The input for the analysis are galaxy spec- tra sampled in 1300 bins between 3750 A and 6500 A. We make use of Principal Com- ponent Analysis (PCA) to analyse the 1300-dimensional space spanned by the spectra. Their projection onto the plane defined by the first two principal components, the principal plane, shows that normal galaxies are in a quasi-linear sequence that we call spectral sequence. We show that the spectral sequence is closely related to the Hubble morphological sequence. These results are robust in the sense that the reality of the spectral sequence does not depend on data normalization. The existence of this se- quence suggests that a single parameter may describe the spectrum of normal galaxies. We have investigated this hypothesis with Bruzual & Charlot (1995) models of spectral evolution. We show that, for single age models (15 Gyr), the spectral sequence can be parametrized by the characteristic star formation time-scales of the different morpho- logical types. By examining the projection of evolutionary tracks of normal galaxies onto the principal plane, we verify that the spectral sequence is also an evolutive se- quence, with galaxy spectra evolving from later to earlier spectral types. Considering the close correspondence between the spectral and morphological sequences, this lead us to speculate that galaxies may evolve morphologically along the Hubble sequence, from Sm/Im to E. Key words: galaxies: general - classification - evolution - methods: statistical 1 INTRODUCTION Normal galaxies tend to present great morphological reg- ularities, which allow us to classify them along the Hub- ble sequence (Hubble 1926, Sandage 1961). The integrated spectra of nearby galaxies also show remarkable regulari- ties. Their general properties have been recently discussed by Kennicutt (1992a,b), who has shown that normal galaxies have spectra that progress smoothly with the morphological type. Since the integrated spectrum of a galaxy represents a weighted mean in luminosity of the stellar populations that make it up, these results indicate that galaxies of same morphological type tend to have similar stellar populations, what provides the basis for a spectral classification of galax- ies (Humason 1936, Morgan & Mayall 1957). We present here a study of Kennicutt's (1992a) spec- trophotometric atlas, looking for global regularities in the ⋆ e-mail: [email protected] † e-mail: [email protected] integrated spectra of galaxies. This is done with a standard statistical technique, Principal Component Analysis (PCA). PCA has previously been applied to the analysis and objec- tive classification of spectra. Francis et al. (1992) have car- ried out a study of a large sample of QSO spectra, developing a quantitative classification scheme based on the first three principal components. Sodr´e & Cuevas (1994) have analysed a set of 24 normal galaxies from Kennicutt's atlas, conclud- ing that most of the variance present in their integrated op- tical spectra is due to their morphological differences. They have shown that these spectra may be parametrized by the morphological type, what allows a quantitative galaxy clas- sification based on integrated spectra. Connolly et al. (1995) have studied the continuum spectra of the central regions of ten galaxies, covering a wavelength range from 1200A to 1µm, also finding that ordinary galaxy spectra can be de- scribed by a one-parameter family. Folkes, Lahav & Maddox (1996) have used a combination of PCA and artificial neu- ral networks for automated classification of galaxies from low signal-to-noise spectra. 2 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas Here we describe each spectrum by a point in a high- dimensional space where each dimension is the flux at each wavelength. We then apply PCA to obtain a suitable pro- jection of the spectra onto a plane. This is done by iden- tifying the orthogonal combinations of the variables with maximum variance, the 'principal components'. Such a pro- jection provides a synthetic view of the data space, allowing to investigate correlations between the spectra. The plan of this paper is as follows. In section 2 we describe our input data, taken from Kennicutt's atlas, and a data subset containing only normal galaxies. Some aspects of principal component analysis that are useful for the study presented here are reviewed in section 3. In this section we also discuss data normalization and scaling, since it is well known that it affects the output of PCA. The results of the application of PCA to all galaxies, as well as to the subset of normal galaxies, are presented in section 4 and discussed in section 5. Finally, section 6 summarises our conclusions. 2 THE DATA The 55 integrated spectra investigated here are from Kenni- cutt's (1992a) spectrophotometric atlas of galaxies. Most of the observations cover the wavelength range between 3650 A and 7100 A, with 5 - 8 A resolution. To avoid incomplete- ness in the spectral coverage, we analyse here the rest-frame wavelength interval 3750 - 6500 A. This spectral range was then uniformly re-sampled with 1300 bins, in order to ap- proximately preserve the original bin width. The spectra in the atlas are normalized to unity at 5500 A, implying that we are not taking into account any dependence with galaxy luminosity. We discuss below other normalizations and their effect on the results. We have analysed two sets of data, one containing all galaxies (AGS), and a subset of AGS with normal galaxies only (N GS). The sample of normal galaxies con- tains 23 objects and covers the Hubble sequence from E to Im, avoiding objects with any evidence of pecu- liarity (e.g. AGNs, starbursts, mergers). The galaxies in this set are: NGC3379 (E0), NGC4472 (E1/S0), NGC4648 (E3), NGC4889 (E4), NGC3245 (S0), NGC3941 (SB0/a), NGC4262 (SB0), NGC5866 (S0), NGC1357 (Sa), NGC2775 (Sa), NGC3368 (Sab), NGC3623 (Sa), NGC1832 (SBb), NGC3147 (Sb), NGC3627 (Sb), NGC4775 (Sc), NGC5248 (Sbc), NGC6217 (SBbc), NGC2903 (Sc), NGC4631 (Sc), NGC6181 (Sc), NGC6643 (Sc), and NGC4449 (Sm/Im). Al- though small, the N GS allows us to explore the connection between normal galaxy spectra and morphology. 3 PRINCIPAL COMPONENT ANALYSIS 3.1 General Principles Suppose we have a sample of N integrated spectra of galax- ies, all covering the same rest-frame wavelength range. Each spectrum is described by a M -dimensional vector X contain- ing the galaxy flux at M uniformly sampled wavelengths. Let S be the M -dimensional space spanned by the 'spectral' vec- tors X. An integrated spectrum, then, is a point in S-space, and the spectra in the sample form a cloud of points in S. If the spectral vectors of normal galaxies are indeed correlated with their morphology, one would expect that these points would be arranged more or less along a line, mimicking the Hubble morphological sequence. It is impossible, of course, to visualize how the data is distributed in high-dimensional spaces, like the 1300-dimensional spectral space discussed in next section. An alternative is to employ some technique for dimension reduction by projecting the data in, say, two dimensions. Here we analyse the data with a standard technique, Principal Component Analysis (PCA). It is also known as Hotelling transform, or discrete Karhunen-Lo`eve transform, but we call it PCA because this designation is more often used in Astronomy (e.g. Murtagh & Heck 1987 and refer- ences therein). PCA is an orthogonal transformation that allows build- ing more compact linear combinations of the data that are optimal with respect to the mean square error crite- rion. A detailed description of PCA can be found in several books on statistics or pattern recognition (e.g. Kendall 1975, Fukunaga 1990), as well as in the astronomical literature (e.g. Brosche 1973, Whitney 1983, Efstathiou & Fall 1984, Lahav et al. 1996). Here we restrict ourselves to a short out- line of the procedure, emphasizing only the aspects that are relevant for our analysis. Consider a set of N objects (galaxies) each with M fea- tures (flux at M given wavelengths). Let xij be the spectrum of the i-th object, i.e., it is the flux (or a scaled version of it, see below) at the j−th wavelength. It is often more useful to do the analysis with a pre-processed version of the data. For example, it is convenient to subtract the sample mean from each spectrum. This is equivalent to put the origin of the coordinate system at the barycentre of the data in the spec- tral space S. It may be interesting, additionally, to re-scale each variable to unit variance. The first case is analogous to PCA of the covariance matrix, while the second is the same as PCA of the correlation matrix. Let us then assume that the spectral vectors X have zero mean. The covariance matrix of the data in this case is Cjk = 1 N − 1 N X i=1 xijxik (1) Now, let us consider a new vector, Y, which is a transformed version of X, given by Y = AX (2) where A is a M × M matrix whose rows are the eigenvectors of the covariance matrix C. This transform has several interesting properties. The covariance matrix of Y is diagonal, with elements equal to the eigenvalues λk of A. This means that the transformed vector components yk are uncorrelated. Additionally, each eigenvalue λk is equal to the variance of the k-th element of Y. Since A is a real and symmetric matrix, its inverse is equal to the transpose, A−1 = A′. Then, it follows that X can be reconstructed from Y by using the relation X = A′ KY (4) correlation X = A′Y (3) Suppose, however, that instead of using all the M compo- nents of Y, we form a new matrix, AK, from the K eigen- vectors corresponding to the K largest eigenvalues. The Y vectors will then be K-dimensional and the reconstruction will no longer be exact. Let represent the approximation of X obtained with the trans- formation matrix AK. It can be shown that the mean square error between X and X is given by E = M X j=1 λj − K X j=1 λj = M X λj j=K+1 (5) This equation indicates that the reconstruction is exact if K = M . Also, for a given K, the error is minimized by se- lecting the eigenvectors associated with the K largest eigen- values. Thus, the PCA transform is optimal in the mean square error sense. Note that, contrarily to most implementations of PCA, here we do not re-normalize each transformed component by its corresponding λ1/2 k , since this gives unit variance along the new axis, changing the metric of the transformed space. The PCA transform has an important difference when compared to other orthogonal transforms: the basis vectors in ordinary orthogonal transforms (e.g. Fourier) are fixed, while in PCA they are the eigenvectors of the covariance matrix and, hence, they are data dependent. The main body of this paper contains the analysis and discussion of the projected distribution of the spectra onto the plane (y1, y2) defined by the two first components of Y. We call it the principal plane. The first principal component is taken to be along the direction in the M -dimensional spec- tral space with the maximum variance. The second principal component is constrained to lie in the subspace perpendic- ular to the first and, within that subspace, it is also taken along the direction with the maximum variance. Then, the principal plane is the plane that contains the maximum vari- ance in the spectral space. In this sense it is the most infor- mative plane contained in the data space. 3.2 Data Scaling It is well known that the set of orthonormal coordinates re- sulting from an application of PCA is affected by the scaling of the data, and then the projection of the spectra onto the plane defined by the first two components is different for distinct data normalizations. The problem, here, is that the scaling may affect differently lines and continuum. Consider, first, the normalization of the spectra. Re- sults are different if the spectra are set to unit at 5500A, f5500 = 1, as they appear in Kennicutt's atlas, or if they are normalized to have the same mean flux within the wave- length range of interest, like in the analysis of Francis et al. (1992). Connolly et al. (1995) normalize each spectrum to unit norm, Pλ f 2 λ = 1, and notice that the results are similar to the latter case above. The coefficients of the ex- pansion, in this case, are direction cosines (e.g. Whitmore Regularities in Galaxy Spectra 3 Table 1. Percentage of the variance explained by the first two principal components method sample cumulative variance (%) covariance N GS AGS N GS AGS 94.6 93.1 86.5 85.0 1984), and the spectra are distributed now onto the surface of a hypersphere of unit radius in the spectral space. Here we consider only the normalization of the spectra to the same mean flux, Pλ fλ = 1. We have repeated the analysis with the other normalizations, verifying that they do not affect our main results. As discussed in the previous section, the data is usu- ally pre-processed before the analysis. Flux values at each wavelength can be scaled to zero mean (which we call co- variance method) or to zero mean and unity variance (cor- relation method). The variance in the lines and continuum are equal in this last case. In order to control the effects due to scaling, we have applied both methods to the analysis of our data sets. It is worth pointing out, as we shall see, that our results are also invariant to the different data scal- ing, because the linear nature of the transform considered here preserves correlations between variables, independent of scaling (e.g. Francis et al. 1992). 4 RESULTS We have applied PCA to a sample containing the spectra of all galaxies in Kennicutt's atlas (set AGS), as well as to a subsample comprising only normal galaxies (set N GS). The data was scaled before the analysis according to one of the procedures discussed above. We consider first the compression achieved by the two transformed components (y1, y2). The results are summa- rized in Table 1, which gives the cumulative fraction of the variance explained by these components for the two data sets, and for different scalings. We notice that there are not significant differences between the two sets. With the covari- ance method, ∼ 93 - 95% of the total variance is described by the two first terms of the expansion. For the analysis with the correlation matrix, the cumulative variance is lower, but at least ∼ 85% of the data variance is contained in two com- ponents now. 4.1 Analysis of the normal galaxies set (N GS) Figure 1 shows the projection of the spectra of the N GS onto their principal plane. The most remarkable aspect in this figure is that the projected spectra of almost all galaxies are arranged along a quasi-linear sequence which we shall call spectral sequence. There are some outliers of the sequence for the covariance method (figure 1a), corresponding mainly 4 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas Figure 2. The first principal component, y1, versus T -types for the N GS and the covariance method. to late-type galaxies. For instance, the point with largest value of y1 in figure 1 corresponds to the Sm/Im galaxy NGC4449. This is due, at least partially, to the 'nebular' nature of the spectrum of this galaxy (see section 4.3). Note that the Magellanic irregulars in the atlas are completely dominated by young stars and HII regions, and their spectra may not be representative of this class (Kennicutt 1992a). The sequence width is relatively larger for the correlation method (figure 1b), but even in this case it is clearly defined (the ratio between the standard deviations of y1 and y2 is (λ1/λ2)1/2 ≃ 3.7). Most of the variance in the N GS seems to be due to the morphological mix of the sample. We also show in fig- ure 1 the projection of the mean spectra of 4 morphological groups (E, S0, Sa-Sbc, Sc-Im) onto the principal plane as crosses. Clearly, these groups are disposed along the spec- tral sequence keeping a ranking analogous to the Hubble se- quence. It can be verified, however, that there is significant overlap of spectra of galaxies that are in distinct morpholog- ical groups. Indeed, an inspection of the spectra shows that there is a large scatter of spectral properties within each morphological group, and it is not difficult to find a bona fide galaxy of a given morphological type with a spectrum typical of galaxies of another type. Note that part of this discrepancy should be attributed also to the fuzzy nature of the morphological classification, as discussed by Naim et al. (1995) and Lahav et al. (1995), who found a dispersion of Figure 1. Projection of the spectra of the N GS onto the princi- pal plane: (a) covariance method; (b) correlation method. Differ- ent symbols correspond to different morphological types: E (open circles), S0 (filled circles), Sa-Sbc (open triangles), Sc-Im (filled triangles). Also shown in the figure are the projections of the mean spectra of these 4 morphological groups (crosses): E, S0, Sa-Sbc and Sc-Im (from left to right). 1.8 T -units in the classification of a set of 830 APM galaxies by 6 experts. In figure 2 we plot the first principal component y1 versus the Hubble type, measured in the T -type system of RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991), for the covariance method (results are similar for the correlation method). This plot presents a clear (non-linear) correlation between y1 and T - type. In fact, Spearman's rank-order correlation coefficient between T -types and y1 is high, 0.93 and 0.90 for the covari- ance and correlation methods, respectively, confirming that the correlation between these two quantities is significant. The same analysis done with the second principal compo- nent fails to show any significant correlation between T and y2. We conclude, then, that the spectral sequence correlates strongly with the Hubble morphological sequence. This result is relevant for galaxy classification since it allows to ascribe a type to a normal galaxy from its spectrum alone (e.g. by its value of y1 or by its position along the spectral sequence). Another point of interest contained in figure 2 is that the spectral variation, as measured by y1, is slow from E to Sab, increasing quickly for later types. This result also is independent of the data scaling, and reveals that the spec- tral distance between E (T =-5) and Sab (T =2) galaxies is smaller than between Sb (T =3) and Sc (T =5). Kennicutt (1992a) arrived at the same conclusion, arguing that un- less one were able to measure the blue continuum colours or [OII]λ3727 emission line to high accuracy, it would be dif- ficult to distinguish the spectrum of a Sa-Sb from an E-S0 galaxy. Figure 2 also shows that the variance of y1 increases with T , indicating that late-type galaxies present a richer spectral variety than early-types, at least for the sample studied here. 4.2 Analysis of all galaxies (AGS) Figure 3 shows the projection of the AGS spectra onto their principal plane for the covariance method. This set includes normal galaxies, AGN, starburst, and interacting or merging galaxies. Most of the variance, now, is due to two galaxies only: Mk59 and Mk71. They are Sm galaxies with spectra dominated by HII-region emission, and here too the nebu- lar nature of their spectra as well as the faintness of their continuum seems to be the cause of their position in the fig- ure. The point to be stressed, however, is that the normal galaxies are again disposed along a sequence. This is best seen in figure 3b, where we have zoomed out part of figure 3a. The projections resulting from the correlation method are shown in figure 4, and are qualitatively similar to those displayed in figure 3. The spectral sequence is clearly vis- ible, what confirms that it is an intrinsic property of the integrated spectra of normal galaxies. How are galaxies other than the normal ones distributed in the (y1, y2) plane? The answer now depends on the scaling and, for most types of peculiar galaxies, their location with respect to the normal galaxies varies from plot to plot in fig- ures 3 and 4. An important exception are the starburst nu- clei NGC3471, NGC5996 and NGC7714, which consistently fall over the Sc-Im region of the spectral sequence. Regularities in Galaxy Spectra 5 Figure 3. Projection of the spectra of AGS onto the principal plane for the covariance method. The projected spectra of normal galaxies are represented here as filled hexagons, while those of peculiar galaxies are shown as open circles. The mean spectra are represented by crosses (see caption of figure 1). Figure 3b is similar to 3a, but zoomed out to enhance the spectral sequence. 6 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas Figure 4. Same as figure 3a, but for the correlation method. 4.3 The nature of the principal components PCA is a linear transform and then each principal compo- nent is a linear combination of the flux at all wavelengths. We plot in figure 5 the weights associated with each wave- length for the two first principal components for galaxies in the N GS. This figure is useful because it provides an insight on what determines y1 and y2 for each type of data scaling. Results for the AGS are similar. Figure 5a shows the weights corresponding to y1 for the covariance method. They are the components of the first eigenvector of the covariance matrix. The overall weight dis- tribution is regular, being positive in the blue and decreas- ing to negative values for longer wavelengths. Blue galaxies, then, tend to have larger values of y1 than the red ones. But large weights are associated with wavelengths of emission lines, mainly [OIII]λλ4959,5007 and Hβ. This might lead one to suppose that y1 is actually measuring the strength of these lines. To clarify this point, we repeated the anal- ysis excluding small regions around the Balmer lines and the [OIII] nebular lines. The projection of the galaxies onto their principal plane looks like that shown in figure 1b, with the two previous late-type outliers of figure 1a now disposed along the sequence. Note that most galaxies in the N GS present negligible or small emission at the wavelengths of the [OIII] lines and Hβ, and then the information carried by these wavelengths is proportional to the continuum flux at ∼ 5000A. Galaxies with strong nebular spectrum will have larger values of y1 because they tend to be bluer than the others and, mainly, because of the large and positive contribution of their line flux. We conclude that the infor- mation associated with the spectral sequence comes essen- tially from the continuum, with a significant contribution of emission lines, when present. This is confirmed by figure 5b, where it is shown the weights corresponding to y2. These weights are almost zero, except at the wavelengths close to the emission lines, where they present an oscillation. These oscillations act like a line detector as it computes a linear combination of differences between the flux at the line and the nearby continuum (adjacent continuum - line, actually): y2 is near zero for spectra without emission lines, and neg- ative for those where the lines are prominent. This explains the position of the outliers in figure 1a. The covariance method preserves the differences be- tween the continuum and the lines and then our result re- veals that a large fraction of the variance of the sample is coming from wavelengths associated with Hβ and the [OIII] nebular lines. In the correlation method, lines and contin- uum are put to the same variance, and the resulting weights are quite different, as shown in figures 5c and 5d. The contin- uum now provides a contribution to y1 more significant than the emission lines. The distribution of the weights shows that y1 is measuring the flux difference between the blue and red parts of a spectrum, with a non negligible contri- bution of some lines. The weights associated with y2 in the correlation method are shown in figure 5d. Their behaviour is quite different from that shown in figure 5b for the covari- ance method. Now y2 is essentially probing the wavelength interval between 4300A and 5200A. Then, to first order, y1 is measuring a colour and y2 the relative flux at ∼4750A. The discussion in this section reveals that the detailed interpretation of the principal components are quite depen- dent of the data set. At the same time, it indicates that is the continuum that gives the major contribution to the first component, but nebular emission may also be important. 4.4 Effect of the errors The overall accuracy of the spectrophotometry of the galax- ies in the atlas is ∼5-10%. To investigate the effect of these errors we have adopted the following procedure. For two normal galaxies, NGC3379 (E0) and NGC4631 (Sc), we pro- duced 100 simulated spectra by adding Gaussian noise with standard deviation equal to 0.1 times the flux at each wave- length to the two observed spectra. For each data set and type of scaling, the simulated spectra were pre-processed and projected onto the principal plane. We have verified that the errors have more effect on the late-type galaxy spectrum than on the elliptical spectrum, due to the emission lines Regularities in Galaxy Spectra 7 Figure 5. Weights (components of eigenvectors) associated to the principal components y1 and y2 for the N GS: (a) y1, covariance method; (b) y2, covariance method; (c) y1, correlation method; (d) y2, correlation method. present in the spectrum of the former object. Their effect on the results presented here are, however, negligible. plane in figure 3 maximizes the variance of the AGS. The same is true for figures 1b and 4 for the correlation method. 5 DISCUSSION 5.1 The spectral sequence The results of the previous section allow us to conclude that the spectral sequence is real in the sense that the spectra of normal galaxies form a sequence in the spectral space. This result is robust because, as we have seen, it is independent of data normalization and scaling. Note that figures 1a and 3 represent projections of the same data space (for the co- variance method) onto different planes: while in figure 1a the plane maximizes the variance of the N GS, the principal It is well known that several parameters related to spectra, like colours or spectral indices, correlate well with the Hubble sequence (e.g. Roberts & Haynes 1994). We had already noticed (Sodr´e & Cuevas 1994) that in a data space defined by spectral parameters, like the amplitude of the 4000A break and the strength of the G band or the Mg2 index, the morphological types are distributed along a one-dimensional sequence. Our results here indicate that these empirical correlations are due to the global regulari- ties present in galaxy spectra, illustrated here by the spec- tral sequence. It provides quantitative support for a one- dimensional description of the general properties of normal galaxies, like the Hubble morphological sequence. It also in- dicates that there is not a dividing line in spectral properties 8 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas between elliptical and spiral galaxies, and that lenticulars have spectra intermediate between those two morphological groups (c.f. figures 2-4). The existence of the spectral sequence and its relation with the morphological sequence has been recognized by Connolly et al. (1995). They applied a procedure similar to ours to a sample of 10 composite spectra of the cen- tral regions of normal and starburst galaxies, each covering a wavelength range of 1200A to 1µm. Interestingly, they found that their 10 spectra were disposed along a spectral sequence, in disagreement with our results, where the spec- tral sequence is defined only by the normal galaxies. This is due to two effects. First, they have removed the strongest nebular emission lines from the starburst spectra, decreas- ing the variance associated with the lines (c.f. section 4.3). Second, a visual examination of their spectra indicates that most of the variance, now, is coming from the UV contin- uum (λ <∼ 3000A), a region not included in our analysis. This discussion confirms how dependent of the input data the results of PCA are! Another point that is worth men- tioning is that Connolly et al. (1995) found a curved spectral sequence, while in our study it is more or less linear. This is a consequence of their normalization by the scalar product, that projects the spectra onto the surface of a hypersphere in the spectral space. Taken together, these results increase the robustness of the spectral sequence of normal galaxies, as it appears in all these analysis of galaxy spectra, irrespective of the wave- length interval, spectral resolution, or the detailed form of the input. Consequently, we expect that a study of a sample that includes, say, Hα, will lead to the same general conclu- sions although the projection of the galaxies onto the new principal plane probably will be different. The principal plane is convenient for classification of normal galaxies, because we can ascribe an objective spec- tral type to a normal galaxy from its position along the sequence. The spectra of peculiar galaxies, however, occupy positions in the principal plane that depend whether one uses the covariance or the correlation method, since the rel- ative role of continuum and lines is different for each of the two scaling methods. Hence, the principal plane is not ade- quate for classification of non-normal galaxies, i.e., one needs more than just two dimensions to describe the general man- ifold of integrated spectra of galaxies. An obvious advantage of spectral classification over morphological classification is that the former is more ad- equate to a quantitative approach than the latter. For in- stance, Folkes, Lahav & Maddox (1996) developed a method for galaxy classification from low signal-to-noise spectra typ- ical of reshift surveys. They have simulated spectra of nor- mal galaxies with the parameters of the 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey. Using a combination of PCA and artificial neural networks, they show that it is necessary typically 8 princi- pal components to describe normal noisy spectra and be able to classify them. Their results indicate that ∼ 95% of the spectra are correctly classified in 5 morphological groups at bJ = 19.7, the limiting magnitude of the survey. Since they also used Kennicutt's data, their PCA results are very simi- lar to ours, even noting that their sample of normal galaxies contains 3 galaxies more than ours. 5.2 Model spectra The principal plane provides us with a useful tool to analyse spectra. We illustrate this point with the following exercise. The very existence of the spectral sequence, and its cor- relation with the Hubble sequence, indicates that one sin- gle parameter may be responsible for the integrated spec- tra of normal galaxies- and of the morphological sequence. For instance, Gallagher, Hunter & Tutukov (1984), Sandage (1986) and Ferrini & Galli (1988), suggest that several prop- erties of the Hubble sequence can be explained by variations in the star formation rate of galaxies. We have investigated this hypothesis with Bruzual & Charlot (1995, hereafter B&C) revised models of spectral evolution of galaxies (see also Bruzual & Charlot 1993). We have only considered models with a single parameter, the characteristic star formation time-scale of a galaxy, τ , where the SFR decreases with time as exp(−t/τ ). We assume a Salpeter IMF, with lower and upper mass limits equal to 0.1 and 125 M⊙, respectively, and neglect gas recycling. Each model results in a spectrum sampled at 238 channels within the wavelength range of interest here. For consistency, we have computed the principal components of our two data sets using the same 238 channels of the theoretical spectra, instead of our 1300 previous wavelengths. The cumulative variance explained by the principal plane is not too affected by this reduction of spectral resolution. For the AGS, it is now 93.7% and 86.0% for the covariance and correlation methods, respectively. Let us first consider single age models (15 Gyr). In fig- ure 6 we show, for several values of τ , the projection of the model spectra onto the principal plane defined by the galaxies in each of our two data sets. The model spectra overlap the spectral sequence for the two methods, although they tend to fall below the mean types for the correlation method. For each data set and normalization, the spectrum corresponding to a single instantaneous burst (τ = 0, i.e., B&C model bc95-ssp-sp-1) falls just at the left extreme of the sequence. On the opposite extreme, the spectrum of a composite stellar population with constant star formation rate (τ = ∞, i.e., model bc95-cons-sp-1), a simple model for irregular galaxies, is near the mean locus of Sc galaxies in the principal plane. Other values of τ are distributed along the sequence, between these two extremes. Figure 6 indi- cates that the parameter τ provides a good parametrization of the spectral sequence, from elliptical to irregular galaxies (although this seems not to be quite true for the correlation method applied to the N GS, even in this case the results are satisfactory if one takes into account the simplicity of the models considered here). This result is in agreement with the conclusions of Kennicutt, Tamblyn & Congdon (1994), who have shown that the photometric properties of spiral galaxies along the Hubble sequence are predominantly due to changes in the star formation histories of disks, and only secondarily to changes in the bulge-to-disk ratio, which also varies systematically along the morphological sequence. Regularities in Galaxy Spectra 9 Figure 6. Projection of B&C model spectra for several values of the mean star formation time scale τ and age equal to 15 Gyr onto the principal plane: (a) N GS, covariance method; (b) N GS, correlation method; (c) AGS, covariance method; (d) AGS, correlation method. Model spectra are represented by open squares. They correspond, from left to right, to τ =0, 3, 5, 7, 10, 15 and ∞ Gyr (see text for details). Other symbols have the same meaning as in figure 3. In figures 6c and 6d, only the part of the principal plane occupied by the spectral sequence is shown. 10 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas We plot in figure 7 evolutive tracks for the τ = 0 and τ = ∞ models, with galaxy ages running from 0 to 20 Gyr. The evolutive track of an instantaneous burst, for the co- variance method, overlaps the spectral sequence, that is, its spectrum evolves from late to early-types along the se- quence. The same is partially true for the constant star for- mation rate model, but in this case the oldest spectrum falls near the centroid of normal Sc galaxies. Hence, in the princi- pal plane obtained with the covariance method, the spectral sequence not only characterizes the locus of normal galax- ies but is almost coincident with their evolutionary tracks. Figure 7 also shows that, for the correlation method, these tracks present more structure, but the same evolutive trend holds. It is worth pointing out that these tracks correspond to very simple models, and 'cosmic variance', e.g. differences in the epoch of galaxy formation, IMF, SFR, metallicity, dust content, etc., may well lead to models able to cover all the spectral sequence. Note that these tracks do not ex- plain why some galaxies are out of the spectral sequence. Although most of them probably have a more complex star formation history than the simple exponential decreasing star formation rate considered here, the main reason is that B&C spectra do not include nebular emission produced by HII regions, and hence they are not adequate to describe galaxies with spectra dominated by ongoing star formation, like Mk59 or Mk71. 5.3 On the nature of the Hubble sequence Our results lead us to conclude that the spectral sequence is also an evolutive sequence, with galaxy spectra evolv- ing from Magellanic irregulars to that of ellipticals. Con- sequently, we expect that the fraction of galaxies with late- type spectra should increase with redshift. It is well known that the fraction of blue objects increases with the red- shift, as evidenced originally by the Butcher-Oemler (1978) effect in clusters (see Rakos & Schombert 1995 for a re- cent study) or by the dramatic excess (with respect to no- evolution models) in galaxy counts in faint blue magnitudes (see Ellis 1990 for a review). Additionally, recent observa- tions with the HST have been able to show that these galax- ies are mainly late-type spirals and irregulars (Glazebrook et al. 1995; Driver, Windhorst & Griffiths 1995). We have seen that there is a close correspondence be- tween the spectral and morphological sequences today, and that the spectral sequence is also an evolutive sequence. If we do not live in a special epoch in the history of the Uni- verse, we may suppose that the spectral and morphological sequences have been always related. Then the Hubble se- quence itself would be an evolutionary sequence, with galax- ies evolving from Im to E! This is a speculation, of course, since our results refer to spectra and not to morphologies, and then the appearance of an E galaxy with age of 1 Gyr may be quite different of what is today an ∼Sc galaxy. But is worth noting that some recent works present evidence that the morphology of a normal galaxy may evolve from late to early types. For instance, Pfenniger, Combes & Martinet (1994) and Pfenniger, Martinet & Combes (1996) argue that this evolution may be driven by internal and external fac- tors due to the likely coupling between dynamics and star formation. The key point is that dynamical process that ac- tuate during a galaxy life- like formation and destruction of bars, mergers, close encounters, gas compression and/or stripping, etc.- tend to favour an increase of the spheroidal component at the expense of the disk, leading to a univo- cal sense of morphological evolution, from Sm to Sa. This sense of evolution also explains the morphological content of galaxy clusters, where most of galaxies are E or S0. The simplest explanation assumes that there is an infalling pop- ulation of late-type galaxies (Sodr´e et al. 1989, Kauffmann 1995) that are transformed in E and S0 (as well as in dwarf ellipticals) in the hostile environment of the clusters. Moore et al. (1996) have recently proposed that frequent encoun- ters at high speed among the galaxies in clusters ("galaxy harassment") may be the driver of morphological transfor- mations in these environments. This process may explain the Butcher-Oemler effect and the form of the blue objects observed in high-redshift clusters by the HST. Hierarchi- cal models also indicate that galaxy morphology may well change as consequence of mergers and interactions (Baugh, Cole & Frenk 1996), although these models do not have yet enough resolution to address the question of evolution within spiral types. This scenario also suggests that the first galax- ies should look more like faint gas rich irregular objects- in agreement with the inhomogeneous galaxy formation models of Baron & White (1987)- than the presumed bright precur- sors of today's elliptical galaxies and bulges of spirals in the scenario devised by Eggen, Lynden-Bell & Sandage (1962). Note that our results are consistent with this 'nurture' scenario, but they do not exclude by any means the 'nature' framework, where the morphology of a galaxy is already im- printed in the initial conditions at the moment of birth, with the galaxy spectrum evolving passively with time, without any significant morphological evolution. We hope that HST observations may be able to constrain the amount of mor- phological evolution of high redshift galaxies and help solv- ing the long standing problem of the origin of the Hubble sequence. 6 CONCLUSIONS We have applied PCA to the study of integrated spectra of galaxies. We have found useful to analyse the projected dis- tribution of galaxy spectra onto the principal plane, defined as the plane in the data space that contains most of the data variance. We have shown that normal galaxies delineate a spectral sequence, which is related to the Hubble morpholog- ical sequence, i.e., the spectrum of normal galaxies changes smoothly from E to S0 to Sa, up to Sc and Im, without a gap between ellipticals and spirals. The spectral sequence in the principal plane is somewhat analogous to the main sequence in the HR diagram. The existence of the spectral sequence is independent of the data scaling and provides quantitative support for the Hubble morphological sequence. The fact that normal galaxies form a one-dimensional spectral sequence may indicate that a single parameter con- trols their integrated spectra (and the Hubble sequence). With Bruzual & Charlot models we have shown that the Regularities in Galaxy Spectra 11 Figure 7. Projection of B&C evolutive tracks for τ = 0 (continuous line) and τ = ∞ (dotted line) onto the principal plane: (a) N GS, covariance method; (b) N GS, correlation method; (c) AGS, covariance method; (d) AGS, correlation method. Symbols have the same meaning as in figure 3. The age (in Gyr) is indicated next to the tracks. Note that the track for τ = 0 completely overlaps the track for τ = ∞ in the covariance method (7a and 7c). 12 L. Sodr´e Jr. & H. Cuevas characteristic star formation time scale of galaxies provides a good parametrization of the spectral sequence. Additionally, the evolutionary tracks of normal galaxies, when projected onto the principal plane defined by the spectra of presently normal galaxies, overlap completely (for E galaxies) or par- tially (for late-type galaxies) the spectral sequence. This means that galaxy spectra evolve along the sequence, at least for the simple evolutionary models discussed here. Taking into account the close correspondence between the spectral and morphological sequences, our results are consistent with the hypothesis that galaxies may also evolve morphologically along the Hubble sequence, from Sm/Im to E. It is worth noting that PCA is dependent of the data set, since the analysis is done over the covariance or correlation matrix of the data. As we have shown, however, our main results are robust in the sense that they are, in a large extent, independent of data scaling or spectral resolution. It will be interesting to repeat this analysis when richer samples, including high redshift galaxies, become publically available. Glazebrook K., Ellis R.S., Santiago B., Griffiths R.E., 1995, MNRAS, 275, L19 Hubble E., 1936, The Realm of Nebulae. Yale Univ. Press, New Haven Humason M.L., 1936, ApJ, 83, 18 Kauffmann G., 1995, MNRAS 274, 153 Kendall M., 1975, Multivariate Analysis. Griffin, London Kennicutt R.C., 1992a, ApJS, 79, 255 Kennicutt R.C., 1992b, ApJ, 388, 310 Kennicutt R.C., Tamblyn P., Congdon C.W., 1994, ApJ, 435, 22 Lahav O., Naim A., Buta R.J., Corwin H.G., de Vaucouleurs G., Dressler A., Huchra J.P., van den Bergh S., Raychaudhury S., Sodr´e L., Storrie-Lombardi M.C., 1995, Science, 267, 859 Lahav O., Naim A., Sodr´e L., Storrie-Lombardi M.C., 1996, MNRAS, submitted Moore B., Katz N., Lake G., Dressler A., Oemler A., 1996, Nature, 379, 613 Morgan W.W., Mayall N.U., 1957, PASP, 69, 291 Murtagh F., Heck A., 1987, Multivariate Data Analysis. D. Reidel, Dordrecht Naim A., Lahav O., Sodr´e L., Storrie-Lombardi M.C., 1995, MNRAS, 275, 567 Pfenniger D., Combes F., Martinet L., 1994, A&A, 285, 79 Pfenniger D., Martinet L., Combes F., 1996, preprint, ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS astro-ph/9602139 Rakos K.D., Schombert J.M., 1995, ApJ, 439, 47 Roberts M.S., Haynes M.P., 1994, ARA&A 32,115 Sandage A., 1961, The Hubble Atlas of Galaxies. Carnegie Institute of Washington, Washington, DC Sandage A., 1986, A&A, 161, 89 Sodr´e L., Capelato H.V., Steiner J.E., Mazure A., 1989, AJ 97, 1279 Sodr´e L., Cuevas H., 1994, Vistas in Astron., 38, 287 Whitmore B.C., 1984, ApJ, 278, 61 Whitney C.A., 1983, A&AS, 51, 443 We are pleased to thank G. Bruzual and S. Charlot for mak- ing their galaxy isochrone synthesis spectral evolution li- brary (GISSEL95) available to us, Ofer Lahav and Avi Naim for many discussions on PCA, and an anonymous referee for comments that allowed us to improve the paper. We also thank Eduardo Telles and Claudia Mendes de Oliveira for their help on the revision of this paper. The Kennicutt atlas was obtained from the Astronomical Data Center (ADC). This work benefited from the financial support provided by the Brazilian agencies FAPESP, CNPq, and CAPES. REFERENCES Baron E., White S.D.M., 1987, ApJ, 322, 585 Baugh C.M., Cole S., Frenk C.S., 1996, MNRAS, submitted Brosche P., 1973, A&A, 23, 259 Bruzual G., Charlot S., 1993, ApJ, 405, 538 Bruzual G., Charlot S., 1995, Galaxy Isochrone Synthesis Spectral Evolution Library (GISSEL95) Butcher H., Oemler A., 1978, ApJ, 219, 18 Connolly A.J., Szalay A.S., Bershady M.A., Kinney A.L., Calzetti D., 1995, AJ, 110, 1071 de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs A., Corwin Jr. H.G., Buta R., Paturel G., Fouqu´e P., 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies. Springer-Verlag, New York Driver S.P., Windhorst R.A., & Griffths R.E., 1995, ApJ, 453, 48 Efstathiou G., Fall S.M., 1984, MNRAS, 206, 453 Eggen O., Lynden-Bell D., Sandage A., 1962, ApJ, 136, 748 Ellis R.S., 1990, in Kron R.G., ed, Evolution of the Universe of Galaxies, A.S.P. Conference Series, Vol. 10, p248 Ferrini F., Galli D., 1988, A&A, 195, 27 Folkes S.R., Lahav O., Maddox S.J., 1996, MNRAS, submitted Francis P., Hewett P.C., Foltz C.B., Chafee F.H., 1992, ApJ, 398, 480 Fukunaga K., 1990, Statistical Pattern Recognition. Academic Press, New York Gallagher J., Hunter D., Tutukov A., 1984, ApJ, 284, 544
0811.3441	3	0811	2009-06-29T20:43:11	Helioseismic data inclusion in solar dynamo models	[ "astro-ph" ]	An essential ingredient in kinematic dynamo models is the velocity field within the solar convection zone. In particular, the differential rotation is now well constrained by helioseismic observations. Helioseismology also gives us information about the depth-dependence of the meridional circulation in the near-surface layers. The typical velocity inputs used in solar dynamo models, however, continue to be an analytic fit to the observed differential rotation and a theoretically constructed meridional flow profile that matches only the peak flow speed at the surface. Here we take the first steps towards realistic helioseismic data assimilation, by presenting methodologies for constructing differential rotation and meridional circulation profiles that more closely conform to the observational constraints currently available. We also present simulations driven by the assimilated rotation and four plausible profiles for the internal meridional circulation -- all of which match the helioseismically inferred near-surface depth-dependence, but whose magnitudes are made to vary. We discuss how the results compare with those that are driven by purely analytic fits. Our results indicate that the latitudinal shear of the rotation in the bulk of the solar convection zone plays a more important role, than either the tachocline or surface radial shear, in the induction of toroidal field. We also find that it is the speed of the equatorward counter-flow in the meridional flow at the base of the convection zone, and not how far into the radiative interior it penetrates, that primarily determines the dynamo cycle period. Given that improved helioseismic constraints are expected to be available in the future, our analysis lays the basis for assimilating these data within dynamo models.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Helioseismic data inclusion in solar dynamo models Andr´es Munoz-Jaramillo Department of Physics, Montana State University, Bozeman, MT 59717, USA [email protected] and Dibyendu Nandy Indian Institute for Science Education and Research-Kolkata, WB 741252, India [email protected] and Petrus C. H. Martens Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA [email protected] ABSTRACT An essential ingredient in kinematic dynamo models of the solar cycle is the internal velocity field within the simulation domain -- the solar convection zone. In the last decade or so, the field of helioseismology has revolutionized our understanding of this velocity field. In particular, the internal differential rotation of the Sun is now fairly well constrained by helioseismic observations almost throughout the solar convection zone. Helioseismology also gives us some information about the depth-dependence of the meridional circulation in the near-surface layers of the Sun. The typical velocity inputs used in solar dynamo models, however, continue to be an analytic fit to the ob- served differential rotation profile and a theoretically constructed meridional circulation profile that is made to match the flow speed only at the solar surface. Here we take the first steps towards the use of more accurate velocity fields in solar dynamo models by presenting methodologies for constructing differential rotation and meridional circula- tion profiles that more closely conform to the best observational constraints currently available. We also present kinematic dynamo simulations driven by direct helioseismic measurements for the rotation and four plausible profiles for the internal meridional circulation -- all of which are made to match the helioseismically inferred near-surface depth-dependence, but whose magnitudes are made to vary. We discuss how the results from these dynamo simulations compare with those that are driven by purely analytic -- 2 -- fits to the velocity field. Our results and analysis indicate that the latitudinal shear in the rotation in the bulk of the solar convection zone plays a more important role, than either the tachocline or surface radial shear, in the induction of the toroidal field. We also find that it is the speed of the equatorward counterflow in the meridional circula- tion right at the base of the solar convection zone, and not how far into the radiative interior it penetrates, that primarily determines the dynamo cycle period. Improved helioseismic constraints are expected to be available from future space missions such as the Solar Dynamics Observatory and through analysis of more long-term continuous data sets from ground-based instruments such as the Global Oscillation Network Group. Our analysis lays the basis for the assimilation of these helioseismic data within dynamo models to make future solar cycle simulations more realistic. Subject headings: Sun: magnetic fields, Sun: interior, Sun: rotation, Sun: helioseismol- ogy, Sun: activity 1. Introduction The dynamic nature of solar activity can often be traced back to the presence and evolution of magnetic fields in the Sun. The more intense magnetic fields on the order of 1000 Gauss (G) are observed to be concentrated within regions known as sunspots, which often appear in pairs of opposite magnetic polarities (Hale 1908). Sunspots have been observed regularly now for about four centuries starting with the telescopic observations of Galileo Galilei in the early 1600s. These observations point out that the number of sunspots on the solar surface varies in a cyclic fashion with an average periodicity of 11 years (Schwabe 1844), although there are variations both in the amplitude and period of this cycle. At the beginning of a cycle sunspots appear at about mid- latitudes in both hemispheres (with opposite polarity orientation across the hemispheres) and then progressively appear at lower and lower latitudes as the cycle progresses (Carrington 1858) until no sunspots are seen (i.e., solar minimum). In the next cycle, the same pattern repeats, but the new cycle spots have their bipolar magnetic orientation reversed relative to the previous cycle (in both hemispheres). So considering sign as well as amplitude, the solar cycle has a period of 22 years. There is a weaker, more diffuse component of the magnetic field outside of sunspots which is seen to have a somewhat different evolution. This field -- whose radial component has been observable at the solar surface since the advent of the magnetograph -- was believed to be on the order of 10 Gauss. It is found that this field is concentrated in unipolar patches, which originate at sunspot latitudes at the time of sunspot maxima, and then moves poleward with the progress of the sunspot cycle (Babcock 1959; Bumba and Howard 1965; Howard and LaBonte 1981). The sign of this radial field of any given cycle is opposite to the old cycle polar field, which it cancels and reverses upon reaching the poles. The amplitude of this radial field achieves a maximum (at the poles) at the time of sunspot minimum (i.e. with a 90◦ phase difference relative to the -- 3 -- sunspots). However, the periodicity of the cycle of this field matches the sunspot cycle period, underscoring that they are related. Recent observations by Hinode indicate that this radial field gets concentrated within unipolar flux tubes with field strength on the order of 103 Gauss (Tsuneta et al. 2008). Explanations of this observations of the solar magnetic cycle rely on the field of magneto- hydrodynamic dynamo theory, which seeks to address the generation and evolution of magnetic fields as a complex non-linear process involving interactions between the magnetic field and plasma flows within the solar interior. In particular, it is now believed that the solar cycle involves the generation and recycling (feeding on the energy available in plasma motions) of two components of the magnetic field -- the toroidal component and the poloidal component. In an axisymmetric spherical coordinate system, the magnetic and velocity fields can be expressed as B = Bφeφ + ∇ × (Aeφ) v = r sin(θ)Ωeφ + vp (1) (2) where the first term on the right hand side (R.H.S.) of Equations 1 and 2 is the toroidal component (in the case of the velocity field this corresponds to the differential rotation) and the second term is the poloidal component of the field (in the case of the velocity field this corresponds to the meridional circulation). The toroidal component of the magnetic field is thought to be produced by stretching of an initially poloidal field by the differential rotation of the Sun (the dynamo Ω-effect); subsequently, strong toroidal flux loops rise up due to magnetic buoyancy emerging through the solar surface as sunspots (Parker 1955a). To complete the dynamo cycle, the poloidal field (whose radial component is manifested as the observed vertical field on the solar surface) has to be regenerated from this toroidal field in a process that is traditionally called the dynamo α-effect. The first explanation of this α-effect was due to Parker (1955b) who suggested that helical turbulent convection in the solar convection zone (SCZ) would twist rising toroidal flux tubes into the poloidal plane, recreating the poloidal component of the magnetic field. Much has changed since this pioneering description of the first solar dynamo model by Parker, although the basic notion of the recycling of the toroidal and poloidal components remain the same. First of all, simulations of the buoyant rise of toroidal flux tubes point out that to match the observed properties of sunspots at the solar surface, the strength of these flux tubes at the base of the SCZ has to be much more than the equipartition field strength of 104 G (D'Silva & Choudhuri 1993; Fan, Fisher & DeLuca 1993). The classical dynamo α-effect due to helical turbulence is expected to be quenched for super-equipartition field strengths and therefore other physical processes have to be invoked as a regeneration mechanism for the poloidal field. One of the alternatives is an idea originally due to Babcock (1961) and Leighton (1969). The Babcock and Leighton (hereby BL) model proposes that the decay and dispersal of tilted bipolar sunspot pairs at the near-surface layers, mediated by diffusion, differential rotation, and meridional circulation, can regenerate the poloidal field. This mechanism is actually observed and is simulated as a surface flux transport process that can reproduce the solar polar field reversals (Wang, Nash & Sheeley 1989). -- 4 -- Therefore a synthesis of Parker's original description along with the BL mechanism for poloidal field generation is now widely accepted as a leading contender for explaining the solar dynamo mechanism (Choudhuri, Schussler & Dikpati 1995; Durney 1997; Dikpati & Charbonneau 1999; Nandy & Choudhuri 2001; Nandy 2003), although there are other alternative suggestions as well. A description of all of those is beyond the scope of this paper and interested readers are referred to the review by Charbonneau (2005). Second, helioseismology has now mapped the solar internal rotation profile (Schou et al. 1998; Charbonneau et al. 1999), which is observed to be vary mainly in the latitudinal direction in the main body of the SCZ. Helioseismology has also discovered the tachocline -- a region of strong radial and latitudinal shear beneath the base of the SCZ which is expected to play an important role in the generation and storage of strong toroidal flux tubes. Third, more is now known about the meridional circulation, which is observed to be polewards at the surface (Hathaway 1996). To conserve mass, this circulation should turn equatorwards in the solar interior. This circulation is deemed to be important for the dynamics of the solar cycle (see Hathaway et al. 2003 and the review by Nandy 2004) but the profile of this in the solar interior remains poorly constrained. Nandy and Choudhuri (2002) proposed a deep equatorward counterflow in the circulation (penetrating into the radiative interior beneath the SCZ) to better reproduce in dynamo simulations the latitudinal distribution of sunspots (because equatorward advective transport and storage of the deep seated toroidal field is more efficient at these depths where turbulence is greatly reduced). However, Gilman and Miesch (2004), based on a laminar analysis, argued that the penetration of the circulation would be limited to a shallow Ekman layer close to the base of SCZ. A recent and more detailed analysis of the problem by Garaud and Brummell (2008) suggests that the circulation can in fact penetrate deeper down into the radiative interior. At this point there is no consensus on the profile and nature of the meridional circulation in the solar interior. Helioseismic data does provide some information about the depth-dependence of this circulation at near-surface layers (Braun & Fan 1998, Giles 2000, Chou & Ladenkov 2005 , Gonz´alez-Hern´andez et al. 2006), which, in conjunction with reasonable theoretical arguments, can be used to construct some plausible interior profiles of this flow. Numerous kinematic dynamo models have been constructed in recent years (see Charbonneau 2005 for a review) incorporating these large scale flows (differential rotation and meridional cir- culation) as drivers of the magnetic evolution. More recently such dynamo models (based on the BL idea of poloidal field generation) have also been utilized to make predictions for the upcoming cycle (Dikpati, de Toma & Gilman 2006; Choudhuri, Chatterjee & Jiang 2007). At present, all these kinematic dynamo models incorporate the information on large-scale flows as analytic fits to the differential rotation profile and a theoretically constructed meridional circulation profile that is subject to mass conservation but matches the flow speed only at the solar surface (i.e., without incorporating the depth-dependent information that is available). However, these large-scale flows are crucial to the generation and transport of magnetic fields; the differential rotation is the primary source of the toroidal field that creates solar active regions, and the meridional flow is thought to -- 5 -- play a crucial role in coupling the two source regions for the poloidal and toroidal field through advective flux transport. Given this, it is obvious that the next step in constructing more sophis- ticated dynamo models of the solar cycle is to move towards a more rigorous use of helioseismic data to constrain these models in a way such that they conform more closely to the best available observational constraints; that is the goal of this study. In Section 2, we describe the basic features of the kinematic dynamo model based on the BL idea that we use for our study; in this model, we use fairly standard parametrization (commonly used in the community) of various processes such as the diffusivity, dynamo α-effect and magnetic buoyancy. In Sections 3.1 and 3.2 we present the methodologies for using the helioseismically observed solar differential rotation and constraining the meridional circulation profiles within this dynamo model and describe how they improve upon the commonly used analytic profiles. In Section 4 we present results from dynamo simulations using these improved helioseismic constraints and conclude in Section 5 with a summary of our main results and their contextual relevance. We substitute Equations 1 and 2 into the magnetic induction equation 2. Our Model and add the phenomenological BL poloidal field source α to obtain the axisymmetric dynamo equations: (cid:20) ∂B ∂t + s + ∂A ∂t (cid:18) B 1 s (cid:19)(cid:21) vp · ∇ s A + α(r, θ)F (Bav)Bav, B + s ([∇ × (Aeφ)] · ∇Ω) ∂B ∂t = ∇ × (v × B − η∇ × B) (cid:19) (cid:19) 1 s2 (cid:18) (cid:18) ∇2 − ∇2 − ∂(sB) 1 s2 ∂η ∂r , 1 s ∂r [vp · ∇(sA)] = η + (∇ · vp)B = η + (3) (4) (5) where s = r sin(θ). The terms on the LHS of both equations with the poloidal velocity (vp) correspond to the advection and deformation of the magnetic field by the meridional flow. The first term on the RHS of both equations corresponds to the diffusion of the magnetic field. The second term on the RHS of both equations is the source of that type of magnetic field (BL mechanism for A and rotational shear for B). Finally, the third term on the RHS of Equation 5 corresponds to the advection of toroidal field due to a turbulent diffusivity gradient. As mentioned before, the generation of poloidal field near the surface due to the decay of active regions is modeled through the inclusion of a source term, which acts as a source for the vector potential A. It is localized both in radius and latitude matching observations of active region emergence patterns and depends on the average toroidal field at the bottom of the convection -- 6 -- zone (Dikpati & Charbonneau 1999). The radial and latitudinal dependence of the source is the following: α(r, θ) = α0 16 cos(θ) 1 + erf (cid:18) ∗ (cid:18) (cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:18) (cid:18) θ − (90o − β) (cid:18) r − ral (cid:19)(cid:19)(cid:18) γ dal (cid:19)(cid:19) (cid:18) θ − (90o + β) (cid:19)(cid:19) (cid:18) r − rah γ 1 − erf 1 − erf dah 1 + erf (6) where α0 sets the strength of the source term and we set it to the value in which our system starts having oscillating solutions. The parameters β = 40o and γ = 10o characterize the latitudes in which sunspots appear. On the other hand, ral = 0.94R(cid:12), dal = 0.04R(cid:12), rah = R(cid:12) and dah = 0.01R(cid:12) characterize the radial extent of the region in which the poloidal field is deposited (see Figure 1-a and b). Besides radial and latitudinal dependence, we also introduce lower and upper operating thresholds on the poloidal source that is dependent on toroidal field amplitude -- which is a more realistic representation of the physics involving magnetic buoyancy (as argued in Nandy & Choudhuri 2001; Nandy 2002; see also Charbonneau, St-Jean & Zacharias 2005). The presence of a lower threshold is in response to the fact that the plasma density inside weak flux tubes is not low enough (compared to the density of the surrounding plasma) to make them unstable to buoyancy (Caligari, Moreno-Insertis & Schussler 1995) and those that manage to rise have very long rising times (Fan, Fisher and De Luca 1993). On the other hand, if flux tubes are too strong they are not tilted enough when they reach the surface to contribute to poloidal field generation (D'Silva and Choudhuri 1993; Fan, Fisher and Deluca 1993). The dependence of the poloidal source on magnetic field is F (Bav) = Kae 1 + (Bav/Bh)2 1 1 + (Bav/Bl)2 , (7) (cid:18) 1 − (cid:19) (cid:18) where Kae = 1/ max(F (Bav)) is a normalization constant and Bh = 1.5 × 105G and Bl = 4 × 104G are the operating thresholds (see Figure 1-c). Another ingredient of this model is a radially dependent magnetic diffusivity; in this work we use a double-step profile (see Figure 2) given by η(r) = ηbcd + ηcz − ηbcd 2 1 + erf + ηsg − ηcz − ηbcd 2 1 + erf (cid:18) (cid:19)(cid:19) (cid:18) r − rcz dcz (cid:19)(cid:19) (cid:18) r − rsg dsg , (8) where ηbcd = 108cm2/s corresponds to the diffusivity at the bottom of the computational domain,ηcz = 1011cm2/s corresponds to the diffusivity in the convection zone, ηsg = 1013cm2/s corresponds to the supergranular diffusivity and rcz = 0.73R(cid:12), dcz = 0.03R(cid:12), rsg = 0.95R(cid:12) and dsg = 0.05R(cid:12) characterize the transitions from one value of diffusivity to the other. Although it is common these days to use these sort of profile, a point we note in passing is that the exact depth dependence of turbulent diffusivity within the SCZ is poorly, if at all, constrained. Besides the value of the supergranular diffusivity ηsg, which can be estimated by observations (Hathaway & Choudhary 2008), the others parameters are not necessarily well constrained. -- 7 -- Once all ingredients are defined(see Section 3 for the flow field), we solve the dynamo equations using a recently developed and novel numerical technique called exponential propagation (see Ap- pendix). Our computational domain is defined in a 250× 250 grid comprising only one hemisphere. Since we run our simulations only in one hemisphere our latitudinal boundary conditions at the equator (θ = π/2) are ∂A/∂θ = 0 and B = 0. Furthermore, since the equations we are solving are axisymmetric, both the potential vector and the toroidal field need to be zero (A = 0 and B = 0) at the pole (θ = 0), to avoid singularities in spherical coordinates. For the lower boundary condition (r = 0.55R(cid:12)), we assume a perfectly conducting core, such that both the poloidal field and the toroidal field vanish there (i.e., A, B = 0 at the lower boundary). For the upper boundary condition we assume that the magnetic field has only a radial component (B = 0 and ∂(rA)/∂r = 0); this con- dition has been found necessary for stress balance between subsurface and coronal magnetic fields (for more details refer to van Ballegooijen and Mackay 2007). As initial conditions we set A = 0 throughput our computational domain and B ∝ sin(2θ) ∗ sin(π ∗ ((r − 0.55R(cid:12))/(R(cid:12) − 0.55R(cid:12)))). After a few cycles, all transients related to the initial conditions typically disappear and the dynamo settles into regular oscillatory solutions whose properties are determined by the parameters in the dynamo equations. 3. Constraining the Flow Fields The last two ingredients of the dynamo model are the velocity fields (differential rotation and meridional circulation), which are the focus of this work. The differential rotation is probably the best constrained of all dynamo ingredients but the actual helioseismology data has never before been used directly in dynamo model, only an analytical fit to it. We discuss below how the actual rotation data can be used directly within dynamo models through the use of a weighting function to filter out the observational data in the region where it cannot be trusted. On the other hand, the meridional circulation is one of the most loosely constrained ingredients of the dynamo. Traditionally only the peak surface flow speed is used to constrain the analytical functions that are used to parameterize it, in conjunction with mass conservation. In this work we take advantage of the properties of such functions and make a fit to the helioseismic data on the meridional flow that constrains the location and extent of the polar downflow and equatorial upflow, as well as the radial dependence of the meridional flow near the surface -- thereby taking steps towards better constrained flow profiles. 3.1. Differential Rotation As opposed to meridional circulation, there are helioseismic measurements of the differential rotation for most of the convective envelope which can be used directly in our simulations. Here we use data from the Global Oscillation Network Group (GONG) (courtesy Dr. Rachel Howe) obtained using the RLS inversion mapped onto a 51 × 51 grid (see Figure 3-a). However, these -- 8 -- observations cannot be trusted fully in the region within 0.3R(cid:12) of the rotation axis (specifically at high latitudes), because the inversion kernels have very little amplitude there. Below we outline a method to deal with this suspect data by creating a composite rotation profile that replaces these data at high latitudes with plausible synthetic data, that smoothly matches to the observations in the region of trust. 3.1.1. Adaptation of the Data to the Model In the first step we use a splines interpolation in order to map the data to the resolution of our simulation (a grid of 250 × 250 see Figure 3-a). The next step is to make a composite with the data and the analytical form of Charbonneau et al. (1999; see Figure 3-b). The analytical form is defined as: (cid:104) (cid:16) (cid:16) r−rtc (cid:17)(cid:17) wtc (cid:105) (Ωe − Ωc + (Ωp − Ωe)ΩS(θ)) ΩA(r, θ) = 2π Ωc + 1 2 1 − erf (9) ΩS(θ) = a cos2(θ) + (1 − a) cos4(θ), where Ωc = 432 nHz is the rotation frequency of the core, Ωe = 470 nHz is the rotation frequency of the equator, Ωp = 330 nHz is the rotation frequency of the pole, a = 0.483 is the strength of the cos2(θ) with respect to the cos4(θ) term, rtc = 0.716 the location of the tachocline and wtc = 0.03. We use the parameters defining the tachocline's location and thickness as reported by Charbonneau et al. (1999) for a latitude of 60o. This is because they match the data better at high latitudes (which is the place where the data merges with the analytical profile) than those reported for the equator. This composite replaces the suspect data at high latitudes within 0.3R(cid:12) of the rotation axis with that of the analytic profile. However, it is important to note that at low latitudes, within the convection zone, the actual helioseismic data is utilized. In order to make the composite we create a weighting function m(r, θ) with values between 0 and 1 for each grid-point defining how much information will come from the RLS data and how much from the analytical form (see Figure 3-d). We define the weighting function in the following way: (cid:18) (cid:18) r2 cos(2θ) − r2 m (cid:19)(cid:19) d2 m m(r, θ) = 1 − 1 2 1 + erf , (10) where rm = 0.5R(cid:12) is a parameter that controls the center of the transition and dm = 0.6R(cid:12) controls the thickness. The resultant differential rotation profile, which can be seen in Figure 3-c, is then calculated using the following expression: Ω(r, θ) = m(r, θ)ΩRLS(r, θ) + [1 − m(r, θ)]ΩA(r, θ) (11) -- 9 -- 3.1.2. Differences Between the Analytical Profile and the Composite Data It is instructive to compare the analytical and composite profiles with the actual helioseis- mology data. In Figure 4-a we present the residual error of subtracting the analytical profile of Charbonneau et al. (1999), with rtc = 0.7 and wtc = 0.025, from the RLS data. In Figure 4-b we present the residual error of subtracting our composite from the RLS data. As is expected, there is no difference between the composite and raw data at low latitude, but the residual increases as we approach the rotation axis -- where the RLS data cannot be trusted. For the analytical profile, the residuals errors are more significant, even at low latitudes. This demonstrates the ability of our methodology to usefully integrate the helioseismic data for differential rotation. 3.2. Meridional Circulation The meridional flow profile remains rather poorly constrained in the solar interior even though the available helioseismic data can be used to constrain the analytic flow profiles that are in use currently. Here we present ways to betters constrain this profile with helioseismic data. In order to do that, we use data from GONG (Courtesy Dr. Irene Gonz´alez-Hern´andez) obtained using the ring-diagrams technique. This data, which we can see in Figure 6-a, corresponds to a time average of the meridional flow between 2001 and 2006; and it comprises 19 values of r from R(cid:12) down to a depth of 0.97R(cid:12), and 15 different latitudes between −52.5o and 52.5o. It is important to note that our work relies heavily in the assumption that the meridional flow is adequately described by a stream function with separable variables. This is consistent with the assumption present implicitly in all work on axisymmetric solar dynamo models up to this date. Below we use this property of our stream function, along with weighted latitudinal and radial averages of the data, to completely constrain its latitudinal dependence, as well as the topmost ten percent of its radial dependence. As this data currently does not constrain the depth of penetration of the flow in the deep solar interior, we explore two different plausible penetration depths of the circulation. For reasons described later, we choose to perform simulations with two different peak meridional flow speeds, therefore exploring four plausible meridional flow profiles altogether. 3.2.1. Constraining the Latitudinal Dependence of the Meridional Flow Meridional circulation has been typically implemented in these type of dynamo models by using a stream function in combination with mass conservation, i.e.: −→v p (r, θ) = 1 ρ(r) (cid:126)∇ × (Ψ(r, θ)(cid:98)eφ) . (12) The two stream functions that are commonly used were proposed by van Ballegooijen and Choud- huri (1988) and by Dikpati and Choudhuri (1995). They have in common the separability of variables and thus can be written in the following way: -- 10 -- Ψ(r, θ) = v0F (r)G(θ), where v0 is a constant which controls the amplitude of the meridional flow. Using such a stream function the components of the meridional flow become: vr(r, θ) = v0 F (r) rρ(r) 1 sin(θ) ∂ ∂θ (sin(θ)G(θ)) , vθ(r, θ) = −v0 1 rρ(r) ∂ ∂r (rF (r))G(θ), (13) (14) (15) which can themselves be separated into the multiplication of exclusively radially and latitudinally dependent functions. This property allows us to constrain the entire latitudinal dependence of this family of functions by using the available helioseismology data for vθ at the surface. This can be done because the latitudinal dependence of vθ is exactly the same as that of the stream function and only the amplitude of this functional form changes with depth, see for example Figure 5 for the latitudinal velocity at different depths used by van Ballegooijen and Choudhuri (1988). In this work we assume a latitudinal dependence like the one they used, i.e., G(θ) = sin(q+1)(θ) cos(θ). (16) In order to estimate the parameter q we first take a density weighted average of the helioseismic data using the values for solar density from the Solar Model S (Christensen-Dalsgaard et al. 1996), such that ¯vθ(θj) = . (17) (cid:80) (cid:80) i vθ(ri, θj)ρ(ri) i ρ(ri) In Figure 6-b we plot the meridional flow at different depths weighted by density, which we add for each latitude in order to find the average. We then use this average to make a least squares fit to the analytical expression (eq 16), which we can see in Figure 6-c. We find that a value of q = 1 fits the data best. This therefore constrains the latitudinal (θ) dependence of the flow profile. 3.2.2. Constraining the Radial Dependence of the Meridional Flow As opposed to the latitudinal dependence, the radial dependence of the meridional flow is less constrained since there is no data below 0.97R(cid:12). However, at least some of the parameters can be constrained: We start with the solar density, for which we perform a least squares fit to the Solar Model S using the following expression: (cid:18) R(cid:12) (cid:19)m ρ(r) ∼ r − γ (18) we find that values of γ = 0.9665 and m = 1.911 fit the model best (see Figure 7-c). In the second step we constrain the radial dependence of the stream function. We begin with -- 11 -- (cid:18) (cid:19)a the function F (r) = 1 r (r − Rp)(r − R(cid:12)) sin π r − Rp R1 − Rp , (19) where R(cid:12) corresponds to the solar radius, Rp to the maximum penetration depth of the meridional flow and a and R1 control the location in radius of the poleward peak and the value of the meridional flow at the surface. In order to constrain them we use the helioseismic data again, but this time we use the radial dependence (see Figure 7-a). We first remove the latitudinal dependence, which we do by dividing the data of each latitude by G(θ) using the value of q = 1 found in the previous section. In Figure 7-b we plot the flow data after removing the latitudinal dependence, note that there is no longer any sign difference between the two hemispheres. The next step is to generate the latitudinal average which we can see as black dots in Figure 7-c. It is evident from looking at the radial dependence of the meridional flow that the velocity increases with depth for most latitudes, and that the point of maximum velocity is not within the depth up to which the data extends. Since the exact radial dependence of the data is too complex for our functional form to grasp, the features we concentrate on reproducing are the presence of a maximum inside the convection zone, as well as the amplitude of the flow at the near surface-layers. The logic here is to use the fewest possible parameters and a simple, physically transparent profile that does a reasonable job of matching the data. In view of the lack of better constraints, we assume here that the peak of the return flow is at 0.97R(cid:12) (which is the depth at which the current helioseismic data has it's peak). Following the procedures and steps above we construct profiles to fit the depth-dependence pointed out in the available helioseismic data; however, this does not constrain how far the merid- ional flow can penetrate and therefore we try two different penetration depths, one shallow 0.71R(cid:12) (i.e., barely beneath the base of the SCZ) and one deep Rp = 0.64R(cid:12) (into the radiative interior) -- both of which match the latitudinal and radial constraints as deduced from the near-surface helio- seismic data. Note that observed light element abundance ratios limit the depth of penetration of the circulation to about Rp = 0.62R(cid:12) (Charbonneau 2007). Now we know that the meridional flow speed is highly variable, with fluctuations that can be quite significant and the measured flow speed can change depending on the phase of the solar cycle (Hathaway 1996; Gizon & Rempel 2008). The magnetic fields are also expected to feed back on the flow (Rempel 2006). Taken together these considerations point out that the effective meridional flow speed to be used in dynamo simulations could be less than that implied from the Gonz´alez-Hern´andez et al. data, a possibility that is borne out by the work of Braun & Fan (1998) and Gizon & Rempel (2008), who find much lower peak flow speeds in the range 12 -- 15 m/s. Keeping this in mind, we use the same latitudinal and radial constraint as deduced earlier, but consider in our simulations two additional profiles with peak flow speeds of 12 m/s with deep and shallow penetrations. Therefore, in total we explore four plausible meridional flow profiles in our dynamo simulations (see Figure 7-c and Table 1 for an overview), the results of which are presented in the next section. -- 12 -- vo 12 m/s 22 m/s 12 m/s 22 m/s Set 1 Set 2 Set 3 Set 4 Rp a R1 0.64R(cid:12) 1.795 1.027R(cid:12) 0.71R(cid:12) 2.03 1.03R(cid:12) Table 1: Sets of parameters characterizing the different meridional flow profiles used in our dynamo simulations. vo corresponds to the meridional flow peak speed, Rp the maximum penetration of the flow, and a and R1 are parameters that control the location of the poleward flow as well as the surface speed. 4. Dynamo Simulation: Results and Discussions 4.1. Analytic vs. Helioseismic Composite Differential Rotation We first compare dynamo solutions found using the helioseismology composite of the differential rotation (Section 3.1.1) and the analytical profile of Charbonneau et al. (1999). In doing so, we perform simulations with a model as described in Section 2 (see also numerical methods in the Appendix) and generate field evolution maps for the toroidal and poloidal fields. From the simulated butterfly diagrams for the evolution of the toroidal field at the base of the SCZ and the surface-radial field evolution (Figure 8), we find that large-scale features of the simulated solar cycle are generally similar across the two different rotation profiles (even with different meridional flow penetration depths and speeds), specially for the shallowest penetration (sets 3 and 4 with Rp = 0.71R(cid:12)). In order to understand this similarity, it is useful to look at Figures 10 and 11 corresponding to simulations using the composite differential rotation, and the meridional flow sets 1 (Rp = 0.64R(cid:12), vo = 12m/s) and 4 (Rp = 0.71R(cid:12), vo = 22m/s). The first two columns, from left to right of both figures show the evolution of the shear sources (Br · ∇rΩ) and (Bθ · ∇θΩ) -- which contribute to toroidal field generation by stretching of the poloidal field. It is evident that the location and strength of these sources is different -- the radial shear source is mainly present near the surface whereas the latitudinal shear is spread throughout the convection zone. It can also be seen that the radial shear source is roughly five times stronger than the latitudinal. However, if attention is paid to the evolution of the toroidal field (third column from the right in both figures), it is clear that this radial shear term has no significant impact on the structure and magnitude of the toroidal field (a similar result was found by Dikpati et al. 2002). The reason is that the upper boundary condition (B = 0 at r = R(cid:12)), in combination with the high turbulent diffusivity (and thus short diffusive time scale) there, imposes itself very quickly on the toroidal field generated by the radial shear -- washing it out. This greatly reduces the relative role of the surface shear as a source of toroidal magnetic field, effectively making the surface dynamics very similar across simulations using the analytical rotation profile (without any surface shear) or the composite helioseismic profile. -- 13 -- Once the surface layers are ruled out as important sources of toroidal field generation we are faced with the fact that the strongest source of toroidal field is the latitudinal shear inside the convection zone (and not the tachocline radial shear), as is evident in Figures 10 and 11. This goes against the commonly held perception that the tachocline is where most of the toroidal field is produced. However, the importance of the latitudinal shear term in the SCZ is clearly demonstrated here where we have plotted the shear source terms, which is not normally done by dynamo modelers. The establishment of the SCZ as an importance source region of toroidal field is of relevance when regarding the similarity of the solutions obtained using the composite data and the analytical profile. This is because the region where the shear of the analytical profile and the helioseismic composite data differ most (both for radial and latitudinal shear) is in the tachocline. This is evident in Figure 9 where we plot the residual of subtracting the radial and latitudinal shear of the analytical profile from the shear of the composite data. The similarity between solutions is specially important for shallow meridional flow profiles with low penetration -- which does not transport any poloidal field into the deeper tachocline, thereby further diminishing the role of the tachocline shear. 4.2. Shallow versus Deep Penetration of the Meridional Flow In the second part of our work we compare dynamo solutions obtained for each of the four different meridional flow profiles with two different penetration depth and with two different peak flow speeds. First, from Figure 8 it is evident that the shape of the solutions changes with varying penetration depth; this is caused by the increasing role of the tachocline shear in generation and storage of the toroidal field as the penetration depth of the meridional flow increases. This is apparent when one compares Figure 10 (deep penetration) to Figure 11 (shallow penetration). If we look at the inductive shear sources it is evident that for the shallowest penetration no field is being generated inside the tachocline. In the poloidal field plots (right column) we see that no poloidal field is advected into the tachocline region for the shallowest penetration, but some is advected for the deepest. Second we compare the periods of our solutions in Table 2: We find that most solutions have a sunspot cycle (i.e., half-dynamo cycle) period that is comparable to that of the Sun, with the exception of the fast flow with deep penetration and the slow flow with shallow penetration, which have respectively a comparatively smaller and larger period. As the meridional flow is buried deeper, one expects the length of the advective circuit to increase, thereby resulting in larger dynamo periods. However, it is evident that as we increase the penetration, the period decreases -- even if the length of the flow loop that supposedly transports magnetic flux increases; this is counterintuitive but has a simple explanation. Our simulations and exhaustive analysis points out that it is not how deep the flow penetrates that governs the cycle period, but it is the magnitude of the meridional counterflow right at the base of the SCZ (Rp = 0.713R(cid:12)) that is most relevant. This is because most of the poloidal field creation at near-surface layers is coupled to buoyant eruptions -- 14 -- of toroidal field from this layer of equatorward migrating toroidal field belt at the base of the SCZ (see third columns in Figures 10 and 11) and it is the flow speed at this region that governs the dynamo period. In Figure 7 it is clear that the speed of the counterflow in this convection zone -- radiative interior interface increases as the flow becomes more penetrating (a consequence of the constraints set by mass conservation and the fits to the near-surface helioseismic data), thereby reducing the dynamo period. Overall, an evaluation of the butterfly diagram (Figure 8), points out that the toroidal field belt extends to lower latitudes (where sunspots are observed) for deeper penetrating meridional flow, although there is a polar branch as well. For the shallow flow, we find that the toroidal field belt is concentrated around mid-latitudes with almost symmetrical polar and equatorial branches -- a signature of the convection zone latitudinal shear producing most of the toroidal field (as in the interface dynamo models, see, e.g., Parker 1993 and Charbonneau & MacGregor 1997). Rp 0.64R(cid:12) 0.71R(cid:12) vo 12 m/s 22 m/s 12 m/s 22 m/s Set 1 Set 2 Set 3 Set 4 τ - HS data (yrs) τ - Analytical (yrs) 9.67 5.63 14.67 11.85 10.00 5.67 14.02 12.85 Table 2: Simulated sunspot cycle period for the different sets of meridional flow parameters. Rp corresponds to the maximum penetration depth of the meridional flow, vo to the peak speed in the poleward flow and τ is the period of the solutions in units of years. For the rest of the parameters in each set please refer to Table 1 4.3. Dependence of the solutions on changes in the turbulent diffusivity profile Although a detailed exploration of the turbulent diffusivity parameter space is outside the scope of this work, we study two special cases in which we vary a single parameter while leaving the rest fixed. For the first case we lower the diffusivity in the convection zone, ηcz, from 1011cm2/s to 1010cm2/s. As can be seen in Figure 12, this introduces two important changes in the dynamo solutions: The first one is an overall increase in magnetic field magnitude due to the reduction in diffusive decay while keeping the strength of the field sources constant. The second is a drastic increase in the dynamo period (which can be seen tabulated in Table 3) for the solutions that use a meridional flow with a penetration of Rp = 0.71R(cid:12). The reason behind such a change resides in the nature of the transport processes at the bottom of the convection zone, which are a combination of both advection and diffusion. In the case of flow profiles with deep penetration the velocity at the bottom is high enough for downward advection to transport flux into the tachocline. On the other hand, in the case of low penetration, the last bit of downward transport into the tachocline is done -- 15 -- by diffusive transport and thus dominated by diffusive timescales. Because of this, by decreasing turbulent diffusivity by an order of magnitude, we drastically increase the period of the solutions. Rp 0.64R(cid:12) 0.71R(cid:12) vo 12 m/s 22 m/s 12 m/s 22 m/s Set 1 Set 2 Set 3 Set 4 τ - HS data (yrs) τ - Analytical (yrs) 12.46 6.47 87.78 70.48 12.86 6.55 90.92 74.41 Table 3: Simulated sunspot cycle period for the different sets of meridional flow parameters when using a low diffusivity in the convection zone (ηcz = 1010cm2/s). Rp corresponds to the maximum penetration depth of the meridional flow, vo to the peak speed in the poleward flow and τ is the period of the solutions in units of years. In the second parameter space experiment, we lower the super-granular diffusivity ηsg from 1013cm2/s to 1011cm2/s. This was done to study the impact of the surface radial shear under low diffusivity conditions. However, as can be seen in Figure 13, there is very little difference between the two solutions. This means that even after reducing the super-granular diffusivity by two orders of magnitude, the radial shear has very little impact on the solutions and the upper boundary conditions still play an important role in limiting the relative contribution from the near-surface shear layer. 5. Conclusions In summary, we have presented here methods which can be used to better integrate helioseismic data into kinematic dynamo models. In particular, we have demonstrated that using a composite between helioseismic data and an analytical profile for the differential rotation, we can directly use the helioseismic rotation data in the region of trust and substitute the suspect data by smoothly matching it to the analytical profile where the data is noisy. This paves the way for including the helioseismically inferred rotation profile directly in dynamo simulations. We have also shown how mathematical properties of the commonly used analytic stream functions describing the meridional flow can be fit to the available near-surface helioseismic data to entirely constrain the latitudinal dependence of the meridional flow, as well as weakly constrain the radial (depth) dependence. In our simulations, comparing the helioseismic data for the differential rotation with the an- alytical profile of Charbonneau et al. (1999), with four plausible meridional flow profiles, we find that there is little difference between the solutions using the helioseismic composite and the ana- lytical differential rotation profile -- specially for shallow penetrations of the meridional flow and even at reduced super-granular diffusivity. This is because the impact of the surface radial shear, which is present in the helioseismic composite but not the analytic profile, is greatly reduced by the proximity of the upper boundary conditions. Also, for the shallow circulation, the toroidal field -- 16 -- generation occurs in a region located above the tachocline with mainly latitudinal shear, where the difference between the composite data and the analytical profile is not significant. The main result from this comparative analysis is that the latitudinal shear in the rotation is the most dominant source of toroidal field generation in these type of models that are characterized by high diffusivity at near surface layers, but lower diffusivity within the bulk of the SCZ -- specially near the base where most of the toroidal field is being created. Since this latitudinal shear exists throughout the convection zone, an interesting question is whether toroidal fields can be stored there long enough to be amplified to high values by the shear in the rotation, without being removed by magnetic buoyancy. If this were to be the case, i.e., the latitudinal shear is indeed confirmed to be the dominant source of toroidal field induction, we anticipate then that downward flux pumping (Tobias et al. 2001; see also Guerrero & de Gouveia Dal Pino 2008) -- which tends to act against buoyant removal of flux, may have an important role to play in this context. This could also call into question the widely held view that the solar tachocline is where most of the toroidal field is created and stored (see Brandenburg 2005 for arguments favoring a more distributed dynamo action throughout the SCZ). Our attempts to integrate helioseismic meridional flow data into dynamo models and related simulations have uncovered points that are both encouraging and discouraging. On the discouraging side, we find that the currently available observational data are inade- quate to constrain the nature and exact profile of the deep meridional flow, especially the return flow. Neither do the simulation results and their comparison with observed features of the solar cycle clearly support or rule out any possibility. A recent analysis on light-element depletion due to transport by meridional circulation indicates that solar light-element abundance observations restrict the penetration to 0.62R(cid:12) (Charbonneau 2007); however this analysis does not necessarily suggest that the flow does penetrate that deep. Also vexing is the fact that different inversions, involving different helioseismic techniques such as ring-diagram or time-distance analysis recovers different profiles and widely varying peak meridional flow speeds (Giles et al. 1997; Braun & Fan 1998; Gonz´alez-Hern´andez et al. 2006; Gizon & Rempel 2008). In our analysis, we chose to use the Gonz´alez-Hern´andez et al. data because at present, this provides the (relatively) deepest full inversion of the flow within the SCZ. Chou and Ladenkov (2005) reported time-distance diagrams reaching a depth of 0.79R(cid:12) but have not yet reported a full inversion that could be used on our simulations. We point out that there is an important consequence of the presence of the flow speed maximum inside the convection zone -- which is related to mass conservation: If the maximum poleward flow speed is found to be deeper inside the convection zone this would result in a stronger mass flux poleward, which needs to be balanced by a deeper counterflow subject to mass conservation; the density of the plasma increases rapidly as one goes deeper; e.g., the density at 0.97R(cid:12) is ten thousand times larger than at the surface. Although that is not achieved currently, our extensive efforts to fit the data point out that stronger constraints on the return flow may be achieved even -- 17 -- with data that does not necessarily go down to where this return flow is located, a fact that may be usefully utilized when better depth-dependent helioseismic data on meridional circulation becomes available. Although the depth of penetration of the circulation is an important constraint on the flow itself, our results indicate that the period of of the dynamo cycle does not in fact depend on this depth. Rather, our simulations point out that the period of the dynamo cycle is more sensitive to changes on the speed of the counterflow than changes anywhere else in the transport circuit, as this is where the dynamo loop originates. An accurate determination of the average meridional flow speed over this loop closing at the SCZ base is very important in the context of the field transport timescales. As shown by the analysis of Yeates, Nandy & Mackay (2008), the relative timescales of circulation and turbulent diffusion determines whether the dynamo operates in the advection or diffusion dominated regime -- two regimes which have profoundly different flux transport dynamics and cycle memory (the latter may lead to predictability of future cycle amplitudes). Getting a firm handle on the average meridional flow speed is therefore very important and that is not currently achieved from the diverging helioseismic inversion results on the meridional flow. This suggests that a concerted effort using different helioseismic techniques on data for the meridional flow over at least a complete solar cycle (over the same period of time) may be neces- sary to generate a more coherent picture of the observational constraint on this flow profile. It's important to note that even though we used time averaged data, nothing prevents one from using the same methods to assimilate time dependent helioseismic data at different phases of the solar circle, allowing us to study the impact of time varying velocity flows on solar cycle properties and their predictability. On the encouraging side, our dynamo simulations show that it is relatively straightforward to use the available helioseismic data on the differential rotation (on which there is more consensus and agreement across various groups) within dynamo models. Also encouraging is the fact that the type of solar dynamo model presented here is able to handle the real helioseismic differential rotation profile and generate solar-like solutions. Moreover, as evident from our simulations, this dynamo model also generates plausible solar-like solutions over a wide range of meridional flow profiles, both deep and shallow, and with fast and slow peak flow speeds. This certainly bodes well for assimilating helioseismic data to construct better constrained solar dynamo models -- building upon the techniques outlined here. 6. Acknowledgements We are grateful to Irene Gonz´alez-Hern´andez and Rachel Howe at the National Solar Ob- servatory for providing us with helioseismic data and useful counsel regarding it's use. We also thank Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard of the Danish AsteroSeismology Center for data and discus- sions related to the solar Model S. Finally, we want to thank Paul Charbonneau and an anonymous -- 18 -- referee for useful comments and recommendations. The simulations presented here were performed at the computing facilities of the Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics and this research was funded by NASA Living With a Star Grant NNX08AW53G to the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory. A. Numerical methods In order to use exponential propagation, we transform our system of Partial Differential Equa- tions(PDEs) in to a system of coupled Ordinary Differential Equations(ODEs) by discretizing the spatial operators using the following finite difference operators: ∂x + χ(x)(cid:1), where v is the velocity, we use a third order upwind scheme: For advective terms(cid:0) ∂A ∂t = −v ∂A (cid:40) v 6(cid:52)x(−2Ai−1 − 3Ai + 6Ai+1 − Ai+2) (cid:16) ∂A 6(cid:52)x(2Ai+1 + 3Ai − 6Ai−1 + Ai−2) ∂A ∂x (cid:17) = v v For diffusive terms ∂t = η ∂2A ∂x2 + χ(x) order space centered scheme: if v < 0 if v ≥ 0 + O((cid:52)x3) (A1) , where η is the diffusion coefficient, we use a second ∂2A ∂x2 = η For other first derivative terms(cid:0) ∂A η ((cid:52)x)2 (Ai−1 − 2Ai + Ai+1) + O((cid:52)x2) ∂t = ∂B ∂x + χ(x)(cid:1) we use a second order space centered scheme: (A2) ∂B ∂x = 1 2(cid:52)x (Ai−1 − Ai+1) + O((cid:52)x2) (A3) Here, χ(x) corresponds to all the additional terms a PDE might have on the righthand side besides the term under discussion and Ai = A(x0 + i(cid:52)x), i = 1, 2, ..., Nx is our variable evaluated in a uniform grid of Nx elements separated by a distance (cid:52)x. -- 19 -- A.1. Exponential Propagation After discretization and inclusion of the boundary conditions we are left with an initial value problem of ordinary differential equations: ∂U(t) (A4) (A5) where U is the solution vector in RN . Provided that the Jacobian ∂F (U(t)) exists and is continuous in the interval [t0, t0 + ∆t], we can linearize F (U(t0 + ∆t)) around the initial state to obtain ∂t U(t0) = U0 = F (U(t)) ∂U(t) ∂t = F (U0) + ∂F (U0)(U(t0 + ∆t) − U0) + R(U(t0 + ∆t)) (A6) where R(U(t0 +∆t) are the residual high order terms. The solution to this equation can be written as U(t0 + ∆t) = U0 + eA∆t − I + O(∆t2) (A7) A where A = ∂F (U0). Neglecting higher order terms leaves us with a scheme that is second order accurate in time and is an exact solution of the linear case. However there is a way of increasing the time accuracy of this method by following a generalization of Runge-Kutta methods for non-linear time-advancement operators proposed by Rosenbrock (1963). The combination of exponential propagation with Runge-Kutta methods was first proposed by Hochbruck and Lubich (1997) and then generalized by Hochbruck, Lubich and Selhofer (1998). In this work we use a fourth order algorithm which goes to the following intermediary steps to advance the solution vector between timesteps (Un) → Un+1)): (cid:19) (cid:18)1 2 k1 = Φ ∆tA F (Un) k2 = Φ (∆tA) F (Un) 3 8 w3 = (k1 + k2) u3 = Un + ∆tw3 d3 = F (u3) − F (Un) − ∆tAw3 (cid:19) k3 = Φ (cid:19) (cid:18) (cid:18)1 ∆tA d3 2 Un+1 = Un + ∆t k2 + 16 27 k3 A = F (Un) , Φ (∆tA) = eA∆t − I A -- 20 -- A.2. Krylov Approximation to the Exponential Operator Without any further approximation, this method is very expensive computationally due to the need of continuously evaluating the matrix exponential. However, it is possible to make a good approximation by projecting the operator into a finite dimensional Krylov subspace SKr = span{U0, AU0, A2U0, ..., Am−1U0}. (A8) In order to do this we first compute an orthonormal basis for this subspace using the Arnoldi algorithm (Arnoldi 1951): 1. v1 = U0/U02 2. For j = 1, ..., m do j(cid:88) i=0 i ∗ Avj • for i = 1, ..., i compute hi,j = vT • calculate w = Avj − • evaluate h(j + 1, j) = w2 • if hj+1,j < stop, else compute the next basis vector vj+1 = w/hj+1,j hi,jvi where is the parameter that sets the error tolerance in this approximation. Once we have finished computing the algorithm, we have the relationship AVm ≈ VmH, (A9) i ∗ Avj. The validity of where Vm = [v1, ..., vm] and H is a matrix whose elements are hi,j = vT this approximation depends on the dimension of the Krylov subspace but numerical experiments have found that 15-30 Krylov vectors are usually enough (see Hochbruck and Lubich 1997; Tokman 2001). Since {v1, ..., vm} is an orthonormal basis of the Krylov subspace SKr then V T m VM is a m×m m is a projector from RN onto SKr. Using this projector we can find an identity matrix and VmV T approximation to any matrix vector multiplication by projecting them onto the Krylov subspace by calculating Ab ≈ VmV T m b. After using Equation A9 this becomes m AVmV T Ab ≈ VmHV T m b. (A10) In fact we can approximate the action of any operator Φ(A), that can be expanded on a Taylor series, on the vector U0 using the Krylov subspace projection: Φ(A)U0 ≈ VmΦ(H)V T m U0 = U02VmΦ(H)e1 (A11) where e1 = [1 0 ... 0] and we used v1 = U0/U02 and V T m v1 = e1. As we can see in Equation A11, the use of the Krylov approximation effectively reduces the size of the matrix operator; this makes the use of the exponential operator relatively inexpensive computationally. -- 21 -- These two algorithms, in combination with a robust error control and an adaptative time-step mechanism strategy, form the core of the SD-Exp4 integrator (for more details see Hochbruck and Lubich 1997; Hochbruck, Lubich and Selhofer 1998 and Tokman 2001). In order to verify the performance standards of the SD-Exp4 code we ran case C' of the dynamo benchmark by Jouve et al. (2008). This case is similar in nature to the simulations done in this work with the following differences: • The meridional flow profile has different radial and latitudinal dependence. • The poloidal source term has no quenching term and a different radial and latitudinal depen- dence. • The turbulent diffusivity profile consists of only one step and reaches a peak value of 1011 cm2/s. • The analytic differential rotation has no cos4(θ) dependence and uses a thinner tachocline. s = αcrit In order to compare the performance of the different codes in the benchmark study, two 0 R(cid:12)/ηcz which quantifies the minimum strength of the source- quantities are used: Ccrit relative-to-dissipation that yields stable oscillations and ω = 2πR2(cid:12)/(T ηcz) which quantifies the frequency of the magnetic cycle relative to the diffusion timescale. The dependence of this quantities is then plotted versus resolution for all the different codes (see Figure 11 of Jouve et al. 2008). In order to compare our code, we perform simulations with the same parameters and model ingredients as in case C' of Jouve et al. (2008) and plot this two quantities versus resolution. We also plot the location of the mean found by the other codes and a shaded area encompassing one standard deviation around the mean. As can be seen in Figure 14, we find lower values of Ccrit than the values obtained in Jouve et al. 2008 (1.86 as opposed to an average 2.46) for oscillatory solutions; this may be due to a lower amount of numerical diffusion in our code. Moreover, we find values of ω in very good agreement with those found in Jouve et al. 2008 (540 as opposed to an average of 538.2). We also find that for our code this quantities are less sensitive to resolution when compared to other codes used in the benchmark. This is likely due to the fact that we try to avoid numerical differentiation whenever we can do it analytically. s As a final remark, Table 4 of Jouve et al. 2008 specifies the different time steps that are used by the different codes, which range from values of 10−8 to 10−5 code time units. Thanks to the use of Krylov approximations we are able to use time steps as large as 10−2 in code time units while solving Case C'. However, this does not translate to a performance improvement of several orders of magnitude (due to the added computations in the Krylov approximation). In order to quantify the relative performance improvement, we also made comparisons with the Surya code, which has been studied extensively in different contexts (e.g. Nandy & Choudhuri 2002, Chatterjee, Nandy & Choudhuri 2004, Choudhuri, Chatterjee & Jiang 2007), and is made available to the public on request. In comparison to the Surya code, we find that the SD-Exp4 code achieves a performance -- 22 -- improvement that reduces runtime from a half to a tenth of the total runtime depending on the particularities of the simulation. REFERENCES Arnoldi, W. E. 1951, Quart. Appl. Math., 9, 17 Babcock, H. D. 1959, Astrophys. J., 130, 364 Babcock, H. W. 1961, Astrophys. J., 133, 572 Brandenburg, A. 2005, ApJ, 625, 539 Braun, D. C. & Fan, Y. 1998, Astrophys. J., Lett., 508, L105 Bumba, V. & Howard, R. 1965, Astrophys. J., 141, 1502 Caligari, P., Moreno-Insertis, F., & Schussler, M. 1995, Astrophys. J., 441, 886 Carrington, R. C. 1858, MNRAS, 19, 1 Charbonneau, P. 2005, Living Reviews in Solar Physics, 2, 2 -- . 2007, Advances in Space Research, 39, 1661 Charbonneau, P. and Christensen-Dalsgaard, J. and Henning, R. and Larsen, R. M. and Schou, J. and Thompson, M. J. and Tomczyk, S. 1999, Astrophys. J., 527, 445 Charbonneau, P., St-Jean, C. and Zacharias, P. 2005, Astrophys. J., 619, 613 Charbonneau, P. and MacGregor, K. B. 1997, Astrophys. J., 486, 502 Charbonneau, P., St-Jean, C. and Zacharias, P. 2005, Astrophys. J., 619, 613 Chatterjee, P. and Nandy, D. and Choudhuri, A. R. 2004, Astron. Astrophys., 427, 1019 Chou, D.-Y. & Ladenkov, O. 2005, Astrophys. J., 630, 1206 Choudhuri, A. R., Schussler, M. and Dikpati, M. 1995, Astron. Astrophys., 303, L29 Choudhuri, A. R., Chatterjee, P., & Jiang, J. 2007, Physical Review Letters, 98, 131103 Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Dappen, W., Ajukov, S. V., Anderson, E. R., Antia, H. M., Basu, S., Baturin, V. A., Berthomieu, G., Chaboyer, B., Chitre, S. M., Cox, A. N., Demarque, P., Donatowicz, J., Dziembowski, W. A., Gabriel, M., Gough, D. O., Guenther, D. B., Guzik, J. A., Harvey, J. W., Hill, F., Houdek, G., Iglesias, C. A., Kosovichev, A. G., Leibacher, J. W., Morel, P., Proffitt, C. R., Provost, J., Reiter, J., Rhodes, Jr., E. J., Rogers, F. J., Roxburgh, I. W., Thompson, M. J., & Ulrich, R. K. 1996, Science, 272, 1286 -- 23 -- Dikpati, M. & Charbonneau, P. 1999, Astrophys. J., 518, 508 Dikpati, M. & Choudhuri, A. R. 1995, Solar Physics, 161, 9 Dikpati, M., Corbard, T., Thompson, M. J., & Gilman, P. A. 2002, Astrophys. J., Lett., 575, L41 Dikpati, M., de Toma, G., & Gilman, P. A. 2006, Geophys. Res. Lett., 33, 5102 D'Silva, S. & Choudhuri, A. R. 1993, Astron. Astrophys., 272, 621 Durney, B. R. 1993, Astrophys. J., 486, 1065 Fan, Y., Fisher, G. H., & Deluca, E. E. 1993, Astrophys. J., 405, 390 Garaud, P. & Brummell, N. H. 2008, Astrophys. J., 674, 498 Giles, P. M. 2000, PhD thesis, AA(STANFORD UNIVERSITY) Giles, P. M., Duvall, Jr., T. L., Scherrer, P. H., & Bogart, R. S. 1997, Nature, 390, 52 Gilman, P. A. & Miesch, M. S. 2004, Astrophys. J., 611, 568 Gizon, L. & Rempel, M. 2008, Sol. Phys., 251, 241 Gonz´alez Hern´andez, I., Komm, R., Hill, F., Howe, R., Corbard, T., & Haber, D. A. 2006, Astro- phys. J., 638, 576 Guerrero, G. & de Gouveia Dal Pino, E. M. 2008, A&A, 485, 267 Hale, G. E. 1908, Astrophys. J., 28, 315 Hathaway, D. H. 1996, Astrophys. J., 460, 1027 Hathaway, D. H. and Nandy, D. and Wilson, R. M. and Reichmann, E. J. 2003, Astrophys. J., 589, 665 Hathaway, D. H. & Choudhary, D. P. 2008, Sol. Phys., 250, 269 Hochbruck, M. & Lubich, C. 1997, SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, 34, 1911 Hochbruck, M., Lubich, C., & Selhofer, H. 1998, SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, 19, 1552 Howard, R. & Labonte, B. J. 1981, Sol. Phys., 74, 131 Jouve, L., Brun, A. S., Arlt, R., Brandenburg, A., Dikpati, M., Bonanno, A., Kapyla, P. J., Moss, D., Rempel, M., Gilman, P., Korpi, M. J., Kosovichev, A. G. 2008, Astron. Astrophys., 483, 949 Leighton, R. B. 1969, Astrophys. J., 156, 1 -- 24 -- Nandy, D. 2002, Astrophys. Space. Sci., 282, 209 -- . 2003, in ESA Special Publication, Vol. 517, GONG+ 2002. Local and Global Helioseismology: the Present and Future, ed. H. Sawaya-Lacoste, 123 -- 128 -- . 2004, in ESA Special Publication, Vol. 559, GONG 2004. Helio- and Asteroseismology: Towards a Golden Future, ed. D. Danesy, 241 Nandy, D. & Choudhuri, A. R. 2001, Astrophys. J., 551, 576 -- . 2002, Science, 296, 1671 Parker, E. N. 1955a, Astrophys. J., 122, 293 -- . 1955b, Astrophys. J., 121, 491 -- . 1993, Astrophys. J., 408, 707 Rempel, M. 2006, Astrophys. J., 647, 662 Rosenbrock, H. 1963, Comput. J., 5, 329 Schou, J., Antia, H. M., Basu, S., Bogart, R. S., Bush, R. I., Chitre, S. M., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., di Mauro, M. P., Dziembowski, W. A., Eff-Darwich, A., Gough, D. O., Haber, D. A., Hoeksema, J. T., Howe, R., Korzennik, S. G., Kosovichev, A. G., Larsen, R. M., Pijpers, F. P., Scherrer, P. H., Sekii, T., Tarbell, T. D., Title, A. M., Thompson, M. J., & Toomre, J. 1998, Astrophys. J., 505, 390 Schwabe, M. 1844, Astronomische Nachrichten, 21, 233 Tobias, S. M., Brummell, N. H., Clune, T. L. & Toomre, J. 2001, Astrophys. J., 549, 1183 Tokman, M. 2001, PhD thesis, California Institute of Technology Tsuneta, S. and Ichimoto, K. and Katsukawa, Y. and Lites, B. W. and Matsuzaki, K. and Nagata, S. and Orozco Su´arez, D. and Shimizu, T. and Shimojo, M. and Shine, R. A. and Suematsu, Y. and Suzuki, T. K. and Tarbell, T. D. and Title, A. M. 2008, Astrophys. J., 688, 1374 van Ballegooijen, A. A. & Choudhuri, A. R. 1988, Astrophys. J., 333, 965 van Ballegooijen, A. A. & Mackay, D. H. 2007, Astrophys. J., 659, 1713 Wang, Y.-M., Nash, A. G., & Sheeley, Jr., N. R. 1989, Astrophys. J., 347, 529 Yeates, A. R., Nandy, D. & Mackay, D. H. 2008, Astrophys. J., 673, 544 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2. -- 25 -- (a) (b) Fig. 1. -- Latitudinal(a) and radial(b) dependence of the poloidal source as quantified by the dynamo α-term. (c) Magnetic quenching of the poloidal source term. (c) Fig. 2. -- Radial dependence of the turbulent magnetic diffusivity. 02040608000.20.40.60.81α(0.96∗Rs,θ)(normalized)Latitude (o)Poloidal Source at r = 0.96Rs02040608000.20.40.60.81α(0.96∗Rs,θ)(normalized)Latitude (o)Poloidal Source at r = 0.96Rs0.60.70.80.9100.20.40.60.81α(r,π/2)(normalized)r/RsPoloidalSourceatθ=π/4−10−5051000.20.40.60.81F(B) (normalized)Toroidal Field (105 Gauss)Quenching Function of the Poloidal Source0.60.70.80.911081091010101110121013η(cm2/s)r/RsMagnetic Diffusivity Profile0.60.70.80.911081091010101110121013η(cm2/s)r/RsMagnetic Diffusivity Profile -- 26 -- (a) (c) (b) (d) Fig. 3. -- (a) Spline interpolation of the RLS inversion. (b) Analytical profile of Charbonneau et al. (1999). (c) Differential rotation composite used in our simulations. (d) weighting function used to create a composite between the RLS inversion and the analytical profile of Charbonneau et al. 1999. For all figures the red denotes the highest and blue the lowest value and the units are nHz with the exception of the weighting function. Splines Interpolation of RLS Inversionr/Rsr/Rs 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.81(nHz)340360380400420440460Analytical Profiler/Rsr/Rs 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.81(nHz)340360380400420440460Differential Rotation Compositer/Rsr/Rs 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.81(nHz)340360380400420440460r/Rsr/RsComposite Mask 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.810.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.9 -- 27 -- (a) (b) Fig. 4. -- (a) Residual of subtracting the composite used in this work to the RLS inversion. (b) Residual of subtracting the analytical profile commonly used by the community to the RLS in- version. Red color corresponds to the hightest value and blue to the lowest. Graphs in units of nHz Fig. 5. -- Latitudinal velocity as a function of θ used by van Ballegooijen and Choudhuri 1988 for different depths. Notice that the curves differ from each other only on their amplitude. Data Minus Compositer/Rsr/Rs 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.81(nHz)−40−30−20−10010203040Data Minus Analytical Profiler/Rsr/Rs 00.20.40.60.8100.20.40.60.81(nHz)−40−30−20−10010203040−50050−20−15−10−505101520Latitudinal velocity at different depthsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o) 1Rs0.9Rs0.8Rs0.75Rs -- 28 -- (a) (b) (c) Fig. 6. -- (a) Measured meridional flow as a function of latitude at different depths (Courtesy Dr. Irene Gonz´alez-Hern´andez), each combination of colors and markers corresponds to a different depth ranging from 0.97R(cid:12) to R(cid:12). (b) Meridional flow after being weighted using solar density. If we sum all data points at each latitude we obtain the average velocity. (c) Normalized average velocity and analytical fit. −50050−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−6−4−20246Density Weighted Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−6−4−20246Density Weighted Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−6−4−20246Density Weighted Meridional Flow Speed at Different DephtsVθ(m/s)Latitude(o)−50050−1−0.500.51Theta dependent part of the stream functionNormalized data and FitLatitude (o)−50050−1−0.500.51Theta dependent part of the stream functionNormalized data and FitLatitude (o) DataFit−50050−1−0.500.51Theta dependent part of the stream functionNormalized data and FitLatitude (o) DataFit -- 29 -- (a) (b) [h] (c) Fig. 7. -- (a) Measured meridional flow as a function of radius at different latitudes (Courtesy Dr. Irene Gonz´alez-Hern´andez), each combination of colors and markers corresponds to a different latitude varying from −52.5 to 52.5. (b) Meridional flow after removing the latitudinal dependence, i. e. vθ/G(θ). The horizontal line with zero latitudinal velocity corresponds to the Equator. (c) Radial dependence of the latitudinally averaged meridional flow for our helioseismic data is depicted as large black dots. Other curves correspond to the radial dependence of the meridional flow profiles used in our simulations and solar density: Set 1 (black dotted) Rp = 0.64R(cid:12), vo = 12m/s; Set 2 (magenta solid) Rp = 0.64R(cid:12), vo = 22m/s; Set 3 (green dash-dot) Rp = 0.71R(cid:12), vo = 12m/s and Set 4 (blue dashed line) Rp = 0.71R(cid:12), vo = 22m/s. The solar density taken from the solar Model S (Christensen-Dalsgaard et al. 1996) is depicted as a solid red line. The left-vertical axis is in units of velocity and the right-vertical is in units of density. 0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed for Different LatitudesVθ(m/s)r/Rs0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed for Different LatitudesVθ(m/s)r/Rs0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed for Different LatitudesVθ(m/s)r/Rs0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−30−20−100102030Meridional Flow Speed for Different LatitudesVθ(m/s)r/Rs0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−20020406080100120Vth/G(th) for Different LatitudesVθ/G(θ)(m/s)r/Rs0.970.9750.980.9850.990.9951−20020406080100120Vth/G(th) for Different LatitudesVθ/G(θ)(m/s)r/Rs0.60.650.70.750.80.850.90.951−23−16−9−25Vθ(m/s)r/RsRadial dependence of Vth at 35o and Solar Density DataSet 1Set 2Set 3Set 400.090.180.260.35ρ(g/cm3) Density -- 30 -- Rp = 0.64R(cid:12) vo = 12m/s Rp = 0.64R(cid:12) vo = 22m/s Rp = 0.71R(cid:12) vo = 12m/s Composite DR Rp = 0.71R(cid:12) vo = 22m/s Analytical DR Fig. 8. -- Butterfly diagram of the toroidal field at the bottom of the convection zone (color) with radial field at the surface (contours) superimposed on it. Each row corresponds to one of the different meridional circulation sets. The left column corresponds to runs using the helioseismic composite and the right one to runs using the analytical profile. -- 31 -- [h] (a) (b) Fig. 9. -- (a) Residual after subtracting the radial shear of the analytical profile commonly used by the community from the radial shear of our composite data. (b) Residual of subtracting the latitudinal shear of the analytical profile commonly used by the community from the latitudinal shear of our composite data. -- 32 -- (Br · ∇rΩ) (Bθ · ∇θΩ) Toroidal Field Poloidal Field Fig. 10. -- Snapshots of the shear source terms and the magnetic field over half a dynamo cycle (a sunspot cycle). Each row is advanced by an eight of the dynamo cycle (a quarter of the sunspot cycle) i.e., from top to bottom t = 0, τ /8, τ /4 and 3τ /8. The solution corresponds to the composite differential rotation and meridional flow Set 1 (deepest penetration with a peak flow of 12 m/s) -- 33 -- (Br · ∇rΩ) (Bθ · ∇θΩ) Toroidal Field Poloidal Field Fig. 11. -- Snapshots of the shear source terms and the magnetic field over half a dynamo cycle (a sunspot cycle). Each row is advanced by an eight of the dynamo cycle (a quarter of the sunspot cycle) i.e., from top to bottom t = 0, τ /8, τ /4 and 3τ /8. The solution corresponds to the composite differential rotation and meridional flow Set 4 (shallowest penetration with a peak flow of 22 m/s) -- 34 -- Rp = 0.64R(cid:12) vo = 12m/s Rp = 0.64R(cid:12) vo = 22m/s Rp = 0.71R(cid:12) vo = 12m/s Composite DR Rp = 0.71R(cid:12) vo = 22m/s Analytical DR Fig. 12. -- Butterfly diagram of the torodial field at the bottom of the convection zone (Color) with radial field at the surface (Contours) superimposed on it when using a low diffusivity in the convection zone (ηcz = 1010cm2/s). Each row corresponds to one of the different meridional circulation sets. The left column corresponds to runs using the helioseismology composite and the right one to runs using the analytical profile. -- 35 -- Analitical DR Composite DR Toroidal Field Poloidal Field Toroidal Field Poloidal Field Fig. 13. -- Snapshots of the magnetic field over half a dynamo cycle (a sunspot cycle) when using a low super-granular diffusivity (ηcz = 1011cm2/s). Each row is advanced by an eight of the dynamo cycle (a quarter of the sunspot cycle) i.e., from top to bottom t = 0, τ /8, τ /4 and 3τ /8. The solutions correspond to the meridional flow Set 2 (deepest penetration with a peak flow of 12 m/s) and analytic differential rotation (left) and composite data (right) -- 36 -- Fig. 14. -- Simulation results (dots) of running case C' of the dynamo benchmark by Jouve et al. (2008). The top figure shows how the minimum value of Cα = α0R(cid:12)/ηcz for which the dynamo has stable oscillations depends on resolution. The bottom figure shows how ω = 2πR2(cid:12)/(T ηcz) depends on resolution. In order to make the plot comparable to the benchmark, we include the mean value found by the different codes and a shaded area corresponding to one standard deviation around this mean. This run was made using the same meridional flow and poloidal source profiles as in the benchmark study (for details see Jouve et al. 2008).
astro-ph/9904008	1	9904	1999-04-01T09:02:29	Differences in the fractions of Be stars in galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	The number ratios Be/(B+Be) of Be to B-type stars in young, well studied clusters of the Galaxy, the LMC and SMC are examined. In order to disentangle age and metallicity effects we choose clusters in the same age interval and for which reliable photometric and spectroscopic data are available. Number counts are made for various magnitude intervals, and the results are found to be stable with respect to this choice. In the magnitude interval Mv = -5 to -1.4 (i.e. O9 to B3) we obtained a ratio Be/(B+Be) = 0.11, 0.19, 0.23, 0.39 for 21 clusters located in the interior of the Galaxy, the exterior of the Galaxy, the LMC and the SMC, respectively. Various hypotheses for these differences are examined. An interesting possibility is that the average rotation is faster at low metallicities as a result of star formation processes. The much higher relative N-enrichment found by Venn et al. (1998) in A-type supergiants of the SMC, compared to galactic supergiants, also strongly supports the presence of more rotational mixing at low metallicities. We discuss whether high rotational mixing may be the source of primary nitrogen in the early chemical evolution of galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	A&A manuscript no. (will be inserted by hand later) Your thesaurus codes are: emission line, Be: 08.05.2; evolution: 08.05.3; rotation: 08.18.1 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS 5.10.2018 Differences in the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. Andr´e Maeder1, Eva K. Grebel2,3,⋆, and Jean -- Claude Mermilliod4 1 Observatoire de Gen`eve, CH-1290 Sauverny, Switzerland, e -- mail: [email protected] 2 UCO/Lick Observatory, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA 3 University of Washington, Department of Astronomy, Box 351580, Seattle, WA 98195, USA 4 Institut d'Astronomie, UniL, CH -- 1290 Chavannes -- des -- Bois, Switzerland Received date; accepted date Abstract. The number ratios Be/(B + Be) of Be to B -- type stars in young, well studied clusters of the Galaxy, the LMC and SMC are examined. In order to disentangle age and metallicity effects we choose clusters in the same age interval and for which reliable photometric and spec- troscopic data are available. Number counts are made for various magnitude intervals, and the results are found to be stable with respect to this choice. In the magnitude interval MV = −5 to -1.4 (i.e. O9 to B3) we obtained a ratio Be/(B + Be) = 0.11, 0.19, 0.23, 0.39 for 21 clusters located in the interior of the Galaxy, the exterior of the Galaxy, the LMC and the SMC, respectively. Various hypotheses for these differences are examined. An interesting possibility is that the average rotation is faster at low metallicities as a result of star formation processes. The much higher relative N -- enrichment found by Venn et al. (1998) in A -- type supergiants of the SMC, compared to galactic supergiants, also strongly supports the presence of more rotational mixing at low metallicities. We discuss whether high rotational mixing may be the source of primary nitrogen in the early chemical evolution of galaxies. 9 9 9 1 r p A 1 1 v 8 0 0 4 0 9 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1. Introduction About 50% of the B stars in the SMC cluster NGC 330 were found to be Be stars by Feast (1972). This high frac- tion, compared to 10 to 20% in the Milky Way, was con- firmed by subsequent studies done by Grebel (1992, 1996), Mazzali et al. (1996), and Keller et al. (1999). A pro- nounced difference between the Be star content in the Magellanic Cloud clusters and in the Milky Way was also found by Grebel et al. (1994). The Be phenomenon is closely related to fast rotation. Suggestions were made in the past that Be stars occur ⋆ Hubble Fellow near the end of the main sequence (MS) phase; however, extended studies in clusters have shown the occurrence of Be stars from the zero -- age sequence to the end of the MS (Mermilliod 1982). Mermilliod has also found that the fraction of Be stars with respect to normal B stars is low in very young clusters, that it reaches a maximum for clusters with turnoff in the range of O9 to B3 and that it declines after that. Evidences for an age effect are also well shown by Fig. 5 from Grebel (1997). Be stars are generally slightly shifted to the red of the MS band (Grebel et al. 1996; cf. also Fig. 1 below). This effect is consistent with the effect of rotational reddening found by Maeder and Peytremann (1970) and also with the effect of a circumstellar envelope, which contributes to a reddening as well as to the formation of the emission lines (Gehrz et al. 1994, Cot´e & Waters 1987). A phys- ical model of the radiation-driven wind in rotating stars has been proposed by Bjorkman and Cassinelli (1993). This model, the so-called wind compressed disk (WCD) model, predicts that the isotropic wind particles travel along trajectories that go through the equatorial plane, where shocks occur. The gas is thus confined there and forms a dense equatorial disk. Owocki et al. (1998) have shown that gravity darkening, as predicted by the von Zeipel theorem, leads to a very different wind morphology, where the disk is more difficult to form. The application of the radiative wind theory to rotating stars leads to an ex- pression (cf. Maeder 1999a) for the mass loss rates M (ϑ) as a function of the colatitude ϑ, this expression shows that there are two main effects influencing the anisotropic mass loss: a) the "geff" -- effect, i.e. the higher gravity and Teff at the pole of a rotating star (due to von Zeipel's theorem) enhances the polar mass loss; b) the "opacity -- effect", i.e. the higher opacity, and the higher force multipliers, due to the lower temperature at the equator favour an equatorial ejection and the formation of a ring. The B[e] stars show both polar and equatorial ejections (Zickgraf 1998). The equatorial ejection is strongly favoured by the so -- called bi -- stability effect (Lamers 1997), i.e. a jump of the opac- 2 A. Maeder et al.: Differences of the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. ity near 20'000◦K, i.e. close to spectral type B2 where a maximum of the fraction of Be stars is observed. Models of rotating stars, including hydrostatic distor- sion, shear mixing, meridional circulation, enhanced mass loss rates, loss of angular momentum etc. have been con- structed recently (Meynet 1999; Maeder 1999b). These models show the high influence of rotation on massive star evolution. The main reason is that shear mixing, which is the most efficient mixing process, is favoured by a high thermal diffusivity as observed in massive stars (Maeder 1997); also, other effects such as meridional circulation (Maeder & Zahn 1998) and anisotropic mass loss are quite significant in massive stars. In view of the large conse- quences of rotation, it is particularly useful to examine whether the Be fraction is systematically higher in clus- ters of lower metallicities, a possibility also suspected by Grebel et al. (1992, 1997) and Mazzali et al. (1996). Sec- tion 2 establishes the number data of Be stars in an ensem- ble of clusters of the Galaxy, LMC and SMC. The relation of the results with metallicity is examined in Section 3, together with abundance indications related to rotation. Section 4 gives the conclusions. 2. Number counts of Be stars in clusters 2.1. Cluster data Since the fraction of Be stars is rapidly changing with cluster ages (Mermilliod 1982), we must carefully sepa- rate ages and metallicity effects. We select clusters in the age range of log age = 7.00 to 7.40 which have their turnoff around the maximum of the Be star distribution. The com- parison of clusters of various ages in different galaxies may lead to confusion between age and metallicity effects. For the Milky Way the clusters were selected from the cluster data base WEBDA (Mermilliod 1999). This data base contains homogeneous photometric data with con- sistent estimates of reddening, distance moduli and ages. WEBDA also provides indications on known binaries, stel- lar peculiarities and Be star identifications based on stan- dard spectroscopic criteria. The data base includes the recent survey of stars with Hα emission by Kohoutek and Wehmeyer(1997). Some 11 well studied clusters of the Galaxy are in the age interval considered (Table 1). On the basis of their galactocentric distances, the clusters are separated in two groups: one outside and one inside the solar location. For the LMC the photometric data, the age determina- tions and the identifications of Be stars come from Grebel (1997), Dieball and Grebel (1998), Keller et al. (1999), and Grebel and Chu (in preparation). A distance modulus of 18.50 is taken in agreement with current determinations (cf. Cole 1998). Nine LMC clusters (listed in Table 1) are in the considered age interval. For the SMC the typical cluster NGC 330 is analysed with the data from Grebel et al. (1996). Unfortunately there is no other cluster with re- Fig. 1. Example of colour -- magnitude diagram used for the number counts of Be and B stars in the case of NGC 884 from the WEBDA data base (Mermilliod 1999). The limits of the various magnitude intervals are shown: MV = -4, -2; MV = -5, -2; MV = -5, -1.4. Be stars are represented by black dots. The isochrone corresponding to log age = 7.1 is represented by a continuous line, and the top of the binary sequence upwards shifted by 0.75 mag. is shown by a broken line. liable Be star identification in or even near the considered age range. The cluster NGC 346 of the SMC, which con- tains a few Be stars, is much too young and has a turnoff far out of the age range where the maximum of Be stars occurs. Kudritzki et al. (1989) give an age of 2.6 ·106 yr for NGC 346, which is consistent with the presence of stars up to about 100 M⊙ (Massey et al. 1989). This is in agree- ment with other authors (Cassatella et al. 1996; Haser et al. 1998) who notice the presence of O3 stars in NGC 346. 2.2. Number counts of Be stars in luminosity intervals We choose to proceed to number counts in given intervals of magnitude MV rather than in given ranges of spectral type and Teff since spectral types are not available for all clusters. Also, we noticed that high rotation strongly mod- ifies the average Teff and very little the average stellar lu- minosities (Maeder and Peytremann 1970). Furthermore, massive stars of the same mass, but different metallicites, have rather large differences in Teff , while this is not the case for the luminosities (Schaller et al. 1992). In order to test the independence of the results with respect to the chosen MV range we have done number counts in three intervals of MV centered on the domain O9 to B3, i.e. MV = -4, -2; MV = -5, -2; MV = -5, -1.4 (the limit MV = A. Maeder et al.: Differences of the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. 3 Table 1. Cluster data Cluster SMC NGC 330 LMC Hodge 301 KMHK 1019 NGC 1818 A NGC 1818 B NGC 1948 NGC 2004 NGC 2006 NGC 2100 SL 538 TOTAL Galaxy ext. NGC 457 NGC 581 NGC 663 NGC 869 NGC 884 NGC 957 NGC 2439 NGC 7160 TOTAL Galaxy int. NGC 3293 NGC 3766 NGC 4755 TOTAL MV = -5, -1.4 MV = -5, -2 MV = -4, -2 log(age) DM B+Be Be B+Be Be B+Be Be Ref. 7.30 18.90 128 50 89 7.30 7.20 7.40 7.40 7.40: 7.40 7.30 7.40: 7.20 7.30 7.20 7.20 7.10 7.10 7.15 7.30 7.20 7.20 7.40 7.20 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 18.50 Rgc(kpc) 9.92 9.54 9.61 9.60 9.91 9.41 10.45 8.22 7.70 7.44 7.07 44 11 94 7 101 130: 35 67 46 535 28 8 35 42 28 15 31 3 190 37 42 47 126 10 2 34 3 11 25 10 19 11 125 4 1 12 3 6 4 5 1 36 1 10 3 14 25 1 58 4 71 96: 21 49 29 354 17 5 23 33 24 13 21 2 138 32 25 27 84 39 9 1 22 2 9 21 5 16 9 94 4 0 12 3 6 4 5 1 35 1 8 3 12 81 25 -- 51 4 64 82: 21 43 28 318 13 4 21 28 18 12 21 2 119 25 24 23 72 37 9 -- 19 2 9 17 5 15 9 85 1 0 10 2 3 3 5 1 25 1 8 3 12 Grebel et al. 1996 Grebel & Chu in prep Dieball & Grebel 1998 Grebel 1997 Grebel 1997 Keller et al. 1999 Grebel 1998 Dieball & Grebel 1998 Keller et al. 1999 Dieball & Grebel 1998 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 Mermilliod 1999 -1.4 corresponds to the spectral type B3 according to the calibration of Zorec and Briot (1991) for main sequence B -- type stars). Fig. 1 shows an example of the HR dia- gram used for the number counts in the case of NGC 884 (χ Persei cluster) with the various magnitude intervals considered. Table 1 shows the number counts for the 19 clusters in the four different locations considered. The 2nd column gives the log of the age, the 3rd column gives the distance moduli in the SMC and LMC, the galactocentric distance for galactic clusters is given in the 3rd column as well; the following columns give the numbers of B plus Be stars, and those of Be stars only in the indicated magnitude intervals. The reference for the data is in the last column. The average number ratios Be/(B + Be) stars in the four zones and for the different magnitude intervals considered are given in Table 2. We clearly notice a systematic trend for smaller Be/(B + Be) number ratios in the sequence of the four groups considered from SMC to LMC to the galactic exterior and interior. The total difference in the Be/(B + Be) ratios amounts to a factor of about three, which is important and also systematic in relation with the metallicities as discussed below. 2.3. Possible relations with Z We examine the possible relation between the fraction of Be stars and the local metallicity Z in the regions where these stars were formed. Let us notice that the suggestion to determine whether the frequency of Be stars is somehow related to the metal abundance was also made by Grebel et al. (1992) and Mazzali et al. (1996). We use the recent data on the metallicity Z for the var- ious zones. For the solar metallicity we take a value of Z⊙ = 0.018, which is consistent with recent solar models and heliosismological data (Brun et al. 1998). For the chemical gradient in the Galaxy the current values range between ∆[O/H]/kpc = −0.07 (cf. Shaver et al. 1983; Gummers- bach et al. 1998) and -0.05 (cf. Vilchez and Esteban 1996). The group of clusters towards the anticenter has an aver- 4 A. Maeder et al.: Differences of the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. Table 2. Number ratios of Be to B+Be stars in the Magellanic Clouds and Milky Way. MV 128 535 190 126 Be B+Be -5, -1.4 -5, -2 -4, -2 .39 .23 .19 .11 .44 .27 .25 .14 .46 .27 .21 .17 SMC LMC Galaxy ext. Galaxy int. age galactocentric distance Rgc of about 1.5 kpc larger than that of the Sun (taken to be Rgc = 8 kpc), while this average difference is 0.6 kpc for the group of clus- ters towards the galactic interior. Thus we consider that the average local metallicities for the exterior and inte- rior groups are respectively Z = 0.014 and Z = 0.020 for a galactic gradient of -0.07. For a gradient of -0.05 the Z- values would be 0.015 and 0.019 respectively, i.e. not very different from the latter values. For the young population in the LMC the range of esti- mated metallicities is rather large. For example, Olszewski et al. (1991) give [Fe/H] values in the range -0.3 to - 0.42, which corresponds to Z = 0.010 to 0.008. Jasniewicz and Th´evenin (1994) find values from [Fe/H] = -0.4 for NGC 1818 to -0.55 for NGC 2004, which correspond to respec- tively Z = 0.008 and 0.006. Bica et al. (1998) obtained val- ues Z = 0.004 to 0.005. Luck et al. (1998) find a mean [Fe/H] = −0.34 ± 0.15 for LMC field Cepheids. In this context, an average value of 0.007 seems appropriate. For the SMC field Reiterman et al. (1990), Spite et al. (1991), Grebel and Richtler (1992) give values corresponding to Z = 0.001 to 0.003. For NGC 330, Hilker et al. (1995) give a value Z = 0.002, and the results of Hill (1997) correspond to 0.003 to 0.004 and those of Oliva et al. (1998) to 0.001. Luck et al. (1998) find a value corresponding to Z=0.004. Gonzalez and Wallerstein (1999 1999) find Z = 0.002. In this context an average value Z = 0.002 for the SMC is appropriate. Fig. 2 shows the relation between the fraction Be/(B+ Be) and the local average metallicity. The trend is quite clear for the various magnitude intervals considered. For the sample of the 4 locations there seems to be a clear increase of the fraction of the relative number of Be stars with the local average initial metallicity. 3. Interpretation of the results There are various possibilities to interpret the above re- sults. 1. Statistical effects related to the intermittence of the Be phenomenon. Fig. 2. Relation between the number ratio Be/(B+Be) and the local metallicity for the 4 groups of clusters considered in Table 2. To test the validity of the results, the number counts were made in different magnitude intervals, the dots refer to counts made in the magnitude interval MV = -5, -1.4, the crosses to the interval -5, -2 and the triangles to the interval -4, -2. 2. The visibility of the Be phenomenon is enhanced at low metallicities. 3. Shell ejection is favoured at low metallicities. 4. Differences in the distribution of the rotational ve- locities. The first possibility is very unlikely. In the Milky Way Be stars have generally been observed over a longer period than in the LMC or SMC. Therefore, the intermittent Be star have a higher chance to be detected in the Milky Way. Consequently, the correction of this possible effect would increase the trend observed in Fig. 2 rather than reduce it. Indeed, in the SMC cluster NGC 330 the Be phenomenon has been found to be intermittent in a num- ber of stars re-observed over the period of several years (Grebel 1995, Keller et al. 1999). The second hypothesis also seems difficult to sustain, because at higher metallic- ities the ejected shell and circumstellar material would be more opaque and contain more dust, thus their visibility through emission lines as well as by their infrared contin- uum would be enhanced. Thus, the correction of such an effect (if feasible) would increase the observed trend. The same kind of remark holds for the third hypothe- sis. Models of rotating stars with mass loss (Maeder 1999a) show two effects: a) polar ejection is favoured in rotating stars by the higher Teff at the pole; b) equatorial ejection of a shell is favoured by larger opacities. Thus, at lower A. Maeder et al.: Differences of the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. 5 Z, it is not expected that shell ejection is favoured in the equatorial regions of a rotating star, because the opacities are lower. The possible effect of metallicity on the termi- nal velocities, which may follow from the wind-compressed disk model (Bjorkman and Cassinelli 1993; Grebel 1997), is found to be negligible (Maeder 1999a). Thus we are left with the possibility that the higher fraction of Be stars at lower Z is the signature of more fast rotators at lower Z. Obviously, direct measurements in nearby galaxies are very needed and envisaged in order to confirm or reject this suggestion. For NGC 330 mea- surements of projected rotational velocities (v sin i) by Mazzali et al. (1996) and Keller and Bessell (1998) show values of up to 400 km s−1. Furthermore, a recent study of nitrogen abundances done by Venn (1995) offers a strong support to the possibility of faster rotation in NGC 330 of the SMC. Indeed, several authors have found that B -- and A -- type supergiants in the Galaxy, LMC and SMC show nitro- gen enhancements not predicted by standard evolutionary models (cf. Lennon et al. 1996; Fitzpatrick and Bohan- nan 1993; Venn 1995, 1998). The current interpretation of these surface enhancements requires some additional mixing processes, possibly rotational mixing (cf. Langer 1998; Meynet 1998; Maeder and Zahn 1998). New rotat- ing models show consistently some N -- enrichments already present for medium rotation from the end of the MS on- wards (Meynet 1998). A remarkable point is that part of the N -- enhancement observable in B -- and A -- type super- giants could be of primary origin, due to the fact that some new 12C resulting from the 3α burning is rotation- ally diffused into the H -- burning shell, where the CNO cycle converts this "new 12C" into 14N, which is thus of primary origin. Another interesting fact recently found by Venn (1998) is that the degree of N enhancement for A supergiants is much higher in the SMC than in the Milky Way. For galac- tic supergiants the typical enhancement of [N/H] is about a factor of 2, while in the SMC it reaches a factor of 10 -- 20 with respect to the standard local average [N/H] in the SMC. As a matter of fact, converting the 12C entirely into 14N by the end of the CN cycle (which is dominant) would lead to an increase of [N/H] by a factor of 4 -- 5, but not as high as 20. Thus the high [N/H] enhancement observed for SMC supergiants might be a sign of primary nitrogen. We do not know, the only way to clarify is to measure the sum of CNO elements and check whether it is the same or not in supergiants as in MS stars. Anyhow, whether this is primary or secondary nitrogen, the point for now is that this higher [N/H] is the signature of much more mix- ing in the SMC than in the Galaxy, a fact which is quite consistent with the above suggestion of faster rotation for massive stars in the SMC. The possibility of faster rota- tion in the SMC has also been mentioned by Venn (1998) and the results presently available on the Be star fractions as a function of Z clearly support this view. 4. Conclusions The main result is that the relative fraction of Be stars with respect to all B stars in the spectral interval O9 to B3 is increasing for lower metallicities Z. This fact together with the much larger N-excesses observed in A-type super- giants of the SMC than in galactic supergiants strongly supports the suggestion that there are more fast rotators among massive stars at lower Z. Of course, direct observa- tions of large numbers of v sini in LMC and SMC clusters are very much needed in order to further substantiate the above results. We may wonder about the origin of the possible higher rotation velocities at low metallicities. This origin is likely related to some metallicity effects in the process of star formation. There are many possibilities, for example we may notice that a lower Z implies less dust and ions in star forming regions. The coupling of the magnetic field to the matter is then weaker, the ambipolar diffusion of the magnetic field should proceed faster, thus leading to less angular momentum losses by the central contracting body. Another possibility is that during pre-main sequence evolution, the weaker opacities at lower Z are leading to an earlier disappearance of the external convective zones and thus to less magnetic coupling between the forming star and its surroundings. Also the importance and the survival lifetime of the accretion disk may increase with metallic- ity, thus favouring the dissipation of angular momentum at higher Z. Of course, numerical models are needed to examine these various tentative suggestions. Looking ahead we may also mention that the conse- quence of faster rotation at lower Z may be considerable, with large differences in evolutionary tracks, lifetimes and nucleosynthesis. In particular we know that current mod- els are unable to account for the occurrence of the large quantity of red supergiants in the SMC for which more mixing would be needed (cf. Langer and Maeder 1998). In the context of nucleosynthesis the possible formation of primary nitrogen at low Z is interesting in relation with the suggestion that primary nitrogen is needed in the early chemical evolution of galaxies (cf. Matteucci and Fran¸cois 1986; Pagel 1998). Appropriate stellar models would bring new insight into the interpretation of star populations in low Z galaxies, like blue compact galaxies or galaxies at cosmological distances like in the Hubble Deep Field. Acknowledgements. We thank Dr. Kohoutek for having pro- vided a printed and an e-version of his catalogue to one of us (J.-C. M.). EKG gratefully acknowledges support by NASA through grant HF-01108.01-98A from the Space Telescope Sci- ence Institute, which is operated by the Association of Univer- sities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS5-26555. AM expresses his thanks to Dr. Hans Zinnecker for nice discussions on the possible origin of faster rotation at lower metallicities. 6 A. Maeder et al.: Differences of the fractions of Be stars in galaxies. References Bica E., Geisler D., Dottori H., Claria J.J., Piatti A.E., Santos J., 1998, AJ 116, 723 Bjorkman J.E., Cassinelli J.P., 1993, ApJ 409, 429 Brun A.S., Turck-Chieze S., Morel P., 1998, ApJ 506, 913 Cassatella A., Barbero J., Brocato E., Castellani V., Geyer E.H., 1996, A&A 306, 125 Cole A.A., 1998, ApJ 500, L137 Cot´e, J., Waters, L.B.F.M. 1987, A&A 176, 93 Dieball A., Grebel E.K., 1998, A&A 339, 773 Feast M.W., 1972, MNRAS 159, 113 Fitzpatrick E.L., Bohannan B., 1993, ApJ 404, 734 Gehrz R.D., Hackwell, J.A., Jones, T.W., 1974, ApJ 191, 675 Gonzalez G., Wallerstein G., 1999, AJ, in press. Grebel E.K., 1995, PhD Thesis, Bonn University Grebel E.K., 1997, A&A 317, 448 Grebel E.K., Richter T., 1992, A&A 253, 359 Grebel E.K., Richtler T., de Boer K.S., 1992, A&A 254, L5 Grebel E.K., Roberts W.J., Will J.M., de Boer K.S., 1994, Space Sci. Rev. 66, 65 Grebel E.K., Roberts W.J., Brandner W., 1996, A&A 311, 470 Gummersbach C.A., Kaufer A., Schaefer D.R., Szeifert T., Wolf B., 1998, A&A 338, 881 Haser S.M., Pauldrach A.W.A., Lennon D.J., Kudritzki R.P., Lennon M., Puls J., Voels S.A., 1998, A&A 330, 285 Hilker M., Richtler T., Gieren W., 1995, A&A 294, 468 Hill V., 1997, A&A 324, 435 Jasniewicz G., Th´evenin F., 1994, A&A 282, 717 Keller S.C., Bessell M.S., 1998, A&A 340, 397 Keller S.C., Wood P.R., Bessell M.S., 1999, A&AS 134, 489 Kohoutek L., Wehmeyer R., 1997, Abhandlungen Hamburg Sternwarte, vol. 11. Kudritzki R.P., Cabanne M.L., Husfeld D., Niemela V.S., Groth H.G., Puls J., Herrero A., 1989, A&A 226, 235 Langer N., 1998, In Wolf B., Stahl O. (eds.) IAU Coll. 169 Variable and non -- spherical stellar winds. in press Langer N., Maeder A., 1995, A&A 295, 685 Lamers H., 1997, ASP Conf. Ser. 120, 76 Lennon D.J., Dufton P.L., Mazzali P.A., Pasian F., Marconi G., 1996, A&A 314, 234 Luck R.E., Moffett T.J., Barnes T.G., Gieren W.P., 1998, AJ 115, 605 Maeder A., 1997, A&A 321, 134 Maeder A., 1999a,A&A, in press Maeder A., 1999, In van der Hucht K.A. et al. (eds.) Wolf -- Rayet Phenomena in Massive Stars and Starburst Galaxies. IAU Symp. 193, in press Maeder A., Peytremann E., 1970, A&A 7, 120 Maeder A., Zahn J.-P., 1998, A&A 334, 1000 Massey P., Parker J.W., Garmany C.D., 1989, AJ 98, 1305 Matteucci F., 1986, MNRAS 221, 911 Mazzali P.A., Lennon D.J., Pasian F., Marconi G., Baade D., Castellani V., 1996, A&A 316, 173 Mermilliod J.C., 1982, A&A 109, 48 Mermilliod J.C., 1999, In R. Rebolo, M.R. Zapaterio (eds.) Very low -- mass Stars and Brown dwarfs in Stellar Clusters and Associations. Cambridge Univ. Press Meynet G., 1998, In: Wolf B., Stahl O. (eds.), in IAU Coll. 169, Variable and non spherical Stellar Winds. in press Meynet A., 1999, In: von der Hucht K. et al. (eds.) Wolf -- Rayet Phenomena in Massive Stars and Starburst Galaxies. IAU Symp. 193, in press Oliva E., Origlia L., 1998, A&A 332, 460 Olszewski E.W., Schommer R.A., Suntzeff N.B., Harris H.C., 1991, AJ 101, 515 Owocki, S.P., Gayley, K. G., Cranmer, S.R., 1998, ASP Conf. Ser. 131, 237 Pagel B., 1998, Chemical Evolution of Galaxies, Cambridge Univ. Press Reiterman A., Stahl O., Wolf B., Baschek B., 1990, A&A 234, 109 Schaller G., Schaerer D., Meynet G., Maeder A., 1992, A&AS 96, 269 Shaver P.A., McGee R.X., Newton L.M., Danks A.C., Pottasch S.R. 1983, MNRAS 204, 53 Spite F., Spite M., Richtler T., 1991, A&A 252, 689 Venn K.A., 1995, ApJ 449, 839 Venn K.A., McCarthy J.K., Lennon D.J., Kudritzki R.P., 1998, PASP Conf. Ser. 131, 177 Vilchez J.M., Esteban C., 1996, MNRAS 280, 720 Zickgraf F.J., 1998, In: Wolf B., Stahl O. (eds), in IAU Coll. 169, Variable and non spherical Stellar Winds. in press Zorec J., Briot D., 1991, A&A 245, 150 This article was processed by the author using Springer-Verlag LATEX A&A style file L-AA version 3.
astro-ph/0702230	1	0702	2007-02-08T14:53:52	A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present the results of an optical multi-band survey for low-mass Pre-Main Sequence (PMS) stars and young Brown Dwarfs (BDs) in the Chamaeleon II (Cha II) dark cloud. This survey constitutes the complementary optical data to the c2d Spitzer Legacy survey in Cha II. Using the Wide-Field Imager (WFI) at the ESO 2.2m telescope, we surveyed a sky area of about 1.75 square degrees in Cha II. The region was observed in the Rc, Ic and z broad-bands, in H-alpha and in two medium-band filters centered at 856 and 914 nm. We select PMS star and young BD candidates using colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) and theoretical isochrones reproduced ad-hoc for the WFI at the ESO2.2m telescope system. The selection criteria are also reinforced by using the previously known PMS stars in Cha II to define the PMS locus on the CMDs and by investigating the infrared (IR) colours of the candidates. By exploiting the WFI intermediate-band photometry we also estimate the effective temperature and the level of H-alpha emission of the candidates. Our survey, which is one of the largest and deepest optical surveys conducted so far in Cha II, recovered the majority of the PMS stars and 10 member candidates of the cloud from previous IR surveys. In addition, the survey revealed 10 new potential members. From our photometric characterisation, we estimate that some 50% of the 20 candidates will result in true Cha II members. Based on our temperature estimates, we conclude that several of these objects are expected to be sub-stellar and give a first estimate of the fraction of sub-stellar objects.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. lspezziChaIIWFIsurveyastroph September 8, 2017 c(cid:13) ESO 2017 A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud⋆ L. Spezzi1, J.M. Alcal´a2, A. Frasca1, E. Covino2, and D. Gandolfi3 1 INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania, via S. Sofia, 78, 95123 Catania, Italy 2 INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, Salita Moiariello, 16, 80131 Napoli, Italy 3 Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Universit`a di Catania, via S. Sofia 78, 95123 Catania, Italy Received ; accepted ABSTRACT Aims.We present the results of an optical multi-band survey for low-mass Pre-Main Sequence (PMS) stars and young Brown Dwarfs (BDs) in the Chamaeleon II (Cha II) dark cloud. This survey constitutes the complementary optical data to the c2d Spitzer Legacy survey in Cha II. Methods. Using the Wide-Field Imager (WFI) at the ESO 2.2 m telescope, we surveyed a sky area of about 1.75 square degrees in Cha II. The region was observed in the Rc, Ic and z broad-bands, in Hα and in two medium-band filters centered at 856 and 914 nm. We select PMS star and young BD candidates using colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) and theoretical isochrones reproduced ad-hoc for the WFI at the ESO2.2m telescope system. The selection criteria are also reinforced by using the previously known PMS stars in Cha II to define the PMS locus on the CMDs and by investigating the infrared (IR) colours of the candidates. By exploiting the WFI intermediate-band photometry we also estimate the effective temperature and the level of Hα emission of the candidates. Results. Our survey, which is one of the largest and deepest optical surveys conducted so far in Cha II, recovered the majority of the PMS stars and 10 member candidates of the cloud from previous IR surveys. In addition, the survey revealed 10 new potential members. From our photometric characterisation, we estimate that some 50% of the 20 candidates will result in true Cha II members. Based on our temperature estimates, we conclude that several of these objects are expected to be sub-stellar and give a first estimate of the fraction of sub-stellar objects. Key words. stars:low-mass, brown dwarfs – stars: formation – stars: pre-main sequence – ISM: clouds – ISM: individual objects: Chamaeleon II 1. Introduction Recent investigations in star-forming regions (SFRs) have pointed out that the fraction of young Brown Dwarfs (BDs) rel- ative to low-mass and more massive Pre-Main Sequence (PMS) stars may vary significantly among different SFRs (Kroupa 2002). In particular, the fraction is different in T and in OB as- sociations (Briceno et al. 2002; Hillenbrand & Carpenter 2000; Luhman et al. 2000; Muench et al. 2003; Preibisch et al. 2003). Different environments may give rise to different initial condi- tions for star and planet formation and, hence, to differences in the observed spectrum of masses (Kroupa 2001, 2002). This may have strong consequences on the Initial Mass Function (IMF), in particular in the sub-stellar domain. It has also been proposed that BDs may form as members of small groups of objects, that may be ejected by dynamical interactions be- fore they can grow to stellar masses (Reipurth & Clarck 2001); hence, many low-mass and sub-stellar objects might have es- Send [email protected] offprint requests to: L. Spezzi, e-mail: ⋆ Based on observations carried out at the European Southern Observatory, La Silla, Chile under proposals numbers 67.C-0225 and 68.C-0311. caped detection in surveys that concentrate sharply in the cores of SFRs. Thus, one possible reason for the differences in the fraction of young sub-stellar objects in T and OB associations can in principle be ascribed to the photometric and spatial in- completeness of the imaging surveys. Spatially complete deep imaging surveys are thus crucial in order to single out low-mass star and BD candidates to be investigated by follow-up spec- troscopy. Only then, problems like mass segregation in SFRs and the low-mass end of the IMF can be addressed. In this paper, optical wide-field imaging observations in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud (hereafter Cha II), complemented with JHK photometry from 2MASS (Cutri et al. 2003), are used to search for low-mass PMS stars and young BDs. Our survey covers almost 2 square degrees in the Cha II cloud. age young Because of its proximity to the Sun (d≈178 pc, Whittet et al. 1997), (0.1-10 Myr, Hughes & Hartigan 1992) and relatively high galactic lat- itude (b≈−15 deg, Schwartz 1991), which decreases the effects of contamination by background stars, the Cha II dark cloud is particularly well-suited for studies of low-mass PMS stars and young BDs. It is indeed characterised by the presence of objects with Hα emission (Hartigan 1993; Hughes & Hartigan 2 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 1992), as well as of embedded Class-I and Class-II IR sources (Larson et al. 1998; Prusti et al. 1992; Whittet et al. 1991) and X-rays sources (Alcal´a et al. 2000). Investigations in the near-IR by the DENIS sur- vey revealed several candidate young BDs in Cha II (Vuong et al. 2001); however, a spectroscopic follow-up by Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana (2004), though reveal- ing the least massive classical T Tauri star in the cloud, failed in confirming the young BD candidates. Persi et al. (2003) per- formed ISOCAM observations and IR spectroscopy of several objects in the core of Cha II and found a number of sources with IR excess. Their most promising candidate, ISO-CHA II 13, was confirmed recently as the first BD in the region known to be surrounded by a disk (Alcal´a et al. 2006). An optical wide- field imaging survey by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005) proposed two young BD candidates. However, that survey covered only about 10% of the cloud area. The Cha II cloud has also been included in the Spitzer Legacy survey "From Molecular Cores to Planet Forming Disks" or c2d (Evans et al. 2003) as a test case of a cloud with moderate star formation activity. Results of the c2d survey in Cha II have been published recently by Young et al. (2005), Allers et al. (2006) and Porras et al. (2006) . The data presented in this paper constitute the optical ancillary data for the c2d survey in Cha II. As such, they are part of a multi-wavelength study of the Cha II cloud which will be presented in a forth- coming paper (Alcal´a et al., in preparation). The outline of the paper is as follows. In Sec. 2 the observa- tions, data reduction and calibration procedures are described. In Sec. 3 we present specific tools for the analysis of the pho- tometric data. Sec. 4 describes the criteria for the selection of PMS star and BD candidates in Cha II, using the tools devel- oped in Sec. 3. The results of the survey and, in particular, the fraction of sub-stellar objects estimated in Cha II are dis- cussed in Sec. 5. Our conclusions are presented in Sec. 6 and, finally, a few notes on some individual objects are presented in Appendix C. 2. Observations and data reduction 2.1. Observations The observations were carried out in two observing runs (27- 30 April 2001 and 20-23 March 2002) using the Wide Field Imaging (WFI) mosaic camera attached to the ESO 2.2m tele- scope at La Silla (Chile). The mosaic consists of eight 2k×4k CCDs forming a 8k×8k array with a pixel scale of 0.238′′/pix; hence, a single WFI pointing covers a sky area of about 30′×30′. The Cha II dark cloud has an extention of about 2 square degrees (Hughes & Hartigan 1992). Thus, seven adja- cent WFI pointings allowed us to cover about 70% of the cloud area. The distribution on the sky of the WFI pointings is shown in Fig. 1. The overlap of about 2′ between adjacent pointings allowed us to check the consistency in the photometry as well as in the astrometry. The observations were performed in the RC, IC and z broad-bands, in two Hα filters, narrow (Hα7, λc=658 nm and FWHM=7.4 nm) and wide (Hα12, λc=665 nm and Table 1. Journal of the observations. The R.A. (in hh:mm:ss) and Dec. (in dd:mm:ss) of each pointing are indicated between parenthesis. Total exposure time (Texp), seeing and air mass (X) values correspond to the final staked images (see Sec. 2.2). Field (RA,DEC) Date (d/m/y) Filter Texp (min) Seeing (") X ChaII 1† (13:06:18,-76:44:21) ChaII 2 (12:57:31,-76:44:20) ChaII 3 (13:08:13,-77:14:27) ChaII 4 (12:59:03,-77:13:58) ChaII 5 (12:49:53,-77:13:59) ChaII 6 (13:10:07,-77:45:08) ChaII 7 (13:00:28,-77:44:39) 22/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 21/03/02 21/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 23/03/02 29/04/01 29/04/01 29/04/01 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 23/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 24/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 23/03/02 30/04/01 30/04/01 30/04/01 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 23/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 22/03/02 21/03/02 21/03/02 23/03/02 23/03/02 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856/14 914/27 2×5 2×5 2×5 5×4 3×5 2×5 2×5 2×5 5×5 3×5 4×5 5×5 10×5 10×5 10×5 5×5 3×5 4×5 5×5 2×5 2×5 2×5 5×5 3×4 4×5 5×5 2×5 2×5 2×5 5×5 3×5 4×5 5×5 10×6 10×6 10×6 5×5 3×5 4×5 5×5 2×4 2×5 2×5 5×5 3×5 4×5 5×5 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.0 1.0 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 2.7 2.7 2.7 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 1.4 1.4 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.48 1.48 1.49 1.54 1.51 1.55 1.53 1.51 1.53 1.56 1.50 1.48 1.84 1.69 1.60 1.64 1.59 1.51 1.53 1.49 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.51 1.57 1.54 1.60 1.62 1.66 1.75 1.66 1.49 1.50 1.67 1.57 1.52 1.61 1.66 1.67 1.74 1.78 1.74 1.69 1.52 1.51 1.58 1.62 † Not observed in the 856-nm and 914-nm bands. FWHM=12.1 nm), and in two intermediate-band filters cen- tered at 865 and 914 nm. In order to cover the gaps between the WFI CCDs and to correct for moving objects and cosmic ray hits, for every pointing a sequence of typically five ditherings was performed in each filter. The journal of the observations is presented in Tab. 1. L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 3 Fig. 1. IRAS 100µm dust emission map of the Cha II dark cloud. The contours, from 10 to 40 MJy × sr−1 in steps of 2.5 MJy × sr−1 are also drawn (white lines). The big polygons define the area covered by the seven ESO2.2m+WFI pointings. The confirmed members of the cloud and the candidates selected in previous surveys are represented with open circles and squares respectively; the black dots mark the objects recovered by our selection criteria (see Sec. 4). Some 13 previously known PMS stars appear saturated in at least one of the bands of our survey and this is why they appear as open circles only. However, when using photometry from the literature, these objects are also recovered from our selection criteria (see Sec. 4). 2.2. Pre-reductionandAstrometry The pre-reduction of the raw images, passing through bias subtraction, flat-fielding and correction for fringing, was per- formed on a nightly basis, using the mscred package un- der IRAF1, following the guidelines described in Alcal´a et al. (2002). The resulting pre-reduced images are uniform to about 1 IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatories (NOAO). 1%. In order to correct for large-scale illumination variations a super-flat was used. The astrometric calibration and relative flux scaling be- tween ditherings were done using the ASTROMETRIX tool2. ASTROMETRIX performs a global astrometric solution which takes into account overlapping sources falling on adjacent CCDs in different ditherings. For each pointing, the astrometric solution was first computed for the R-band dithering-set using 2 Available at: http://www.na.astro.it/∼radovich. 4 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud the USNO-A2.0 catalogue (Monet et al. 1998) as a reference. A catalogue of sources was then extracted from the re-sampled R-band image and used as reference catalogue for all the other bands. Within the global astrometry process, the astrometric solution was constrained for each CCD by both the positions from the R-band catalogue and those from overlapping sources in all the other CCDs. The co-addition of the different dithered images for a given filter and pointing was performed using the SWARP tool3. The resulting 8k×8k stacked images were nor- malised by the exposure time. The absolute astrometric preci- sion of our images is about 0.35 arcsec, corresponding to the RMS accuracy of the USNO-A2.0 catalogue, while the inter- nal RMS, computed from overlapping sources in different ex- posures, is within 0.05 arcsec, indicating the good performance of ASTROMETRIX. 2.3. Thephotometriccalibration In order to transform the R and I instrumental magnitudes to the standard Cousins system, the Landolt standard fields SA 98, SA 101 and SA 107 (Landolt 1992) were observed nightly. The standard RC and IC magnitudes were determined using the transformation equations: RC = r0 + cR · (r0 − i0) + ZPR IC = i0 + cI · (r0 − i0) + ZPI (1) (2) where r0 and i0 are the instrumental magnitudes corrected for atmospheric extinction and cR and ZPR and cI and ZPI the colour terms and zero points for the R and I bands respectively. The standard magnitudes from Stetson (2000) were used in or- der to determine the zero points and colour terms. The intermediate-band instrumental photometry was trans- formed to the standard AB photometric system following the prescriptions by Jacoby et al. (1987) and Alcal´a et al. (2002) by using the equation: mAB(λ) = m0(λ) + ZPλ (3) where m0 is the instrumental magnitude in a given intermediate-band filter corrected for atmospheric extinction and ZPλ the zero point derived by using the spectrophotometric standard stars Hiltner 600, LTT 4364 and Eg 274 (Hamuy et al. 1992), observed by us in the same run. The resulting magni- tudes in the intermediate band filters are in the AB system. The nightly calibration coefficients are reported in Tab. 2. 2.3.1. The z-band photometric calibration The calibration of the z magnitudes required more effort as there are no data for standard stars available in the literature. Since we aimed at determining the colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) of the sources in Cha II (Sec. 4) and their spectral en- ergy distributions (SEDs, Sec. 5), we needed both to tie the z magnitudes with some "reference" photometric system and to 3 Available at: http://terapix.iap.fr/cplt/oldSite/soft/swarp. Table 2. Photometric calibration coefficients (atmospheric ex- tinction coefficient, K, zero point, ZP, and colour terms, c) for the WFI filters used in this work. Filter Date K† ZP c R " " " I " " " z " " " 04/27/2001 04/28/2001 04/29/2001 03/21/2002 04/27/2001 04/28/2001 04/29/2001 03/21/2002 04/27/2001 04/28/2001 04/29/2001 03/21/2002 03/20/2002 Hα7 03/20/2002 Hα12 856nm 03/22/2002 914nm 03/22/2002 0.096 0.096 0.096 0.096 0.082 0.082 0.082 0.082 0.080 0.080 0.080 0.080 0.096 0.096 0.080 0.080 24.418±0.004 24.388±0.001 24.445±0.004 24.397±0.003 23.413±0.012 23.399±0.001 23.431±0.001 23.335±0.001 21.546±0.804 21.246±0.303 21.248±0.353 21.460±0.014 21.249±0.095 21.733±0.133 20.894±0.089 21.018±0.082 -0.038±0.010 -0.056±0.008 -0.023±0.003 -0.030±0.003 0.222±0.002 0.216±0.003 0.221±0.007 0.222±0.002 0.336±0.311 0.230±0.143 0.214±0.140 0.373±0.001 / / / / † The mean atmospheric extinction coefficients for La Silla have been adopted. determine the flux at Earth of a star with magnitude z = 0. To this aim, we observed the same Landolt standard fields in the z filter. In the Landolt SA 98 field we selected the A0-type star SA 98 653, whose visual magnitude and colours are reported in Tab. 3. This star is very well characterised and its absolute spectrophotometry is well determined (Guti`errez Moreno et al. 1988). For this A0-type star we can assume (IC − z) = 0, thus defining the "standard" z-magnitude system as that for which the colour (IC − z) is zero for A0 type stars. The zero point of this calibration is then determined as follows: Z p = z − z0 = IC − z0 (4) where IC = 9.522 is the standard magnitude of SA 98 653 in the Cousins system and z0 its z-band instrumental magni- tude corrected for atmospheric extinction. We then applied this zero point correction to the z0 instrumental magnitude of all the stars in the Landolt fields. In this way we obtained a catalogue of Landolt stars with z magnitudes and (I − z) colours in our internal WFI-Cousins system. We then used this catalogue to find the least squares solution to the equation: z = z0 + cz · (i0 − z0) + ZPz (5) where z0 and i0 are the standard stars instrumental magni- tudes corrected for atmospheric extinction and ZPz and cz the z calibration coefficients for the newly defined WFI-Cousins photometric system. The nightly mean values obtained for ZPz and cz are reported in Tab. 2. Since the absolute spectrophotometry of SA 98 653 is avail- able from Guti`errez Moreno et al. (1988), we can use this star L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 5 Table 3. Standard photometry of SA 98 653 (R.A. = 06:52:05, Dec. = −00:18:18) from Stetson (2000). V (B − V) (U − B) (V − RC) (R − I)C 9.539 −0.004 −0.097 0.007 0.008 to obtain the absolute flux calibration in the z filter, i.e. to ob- tain the flux at Earth of a star with z=0. Following the procedure outlined in Appendix A we derive: F(z = 0) = (8.4 ± 0.1) · 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1 Å−1 = (2608 ± 31) Jy This value can be used to derive the flux in the z-band of the sources in our catalogue using their corresponding z-band magnitudes. 2.4. Thecatalogueextraction 2.4.1. PSF fitting procedure PSF fitting photometry has been performed by using the IRAF/daophot package (Stetson 1987). Since we are interested in the faintest stellar objects, the threshold level was defined in order to select all the sources having a signal-to-noise ratio (σ) greater than 3. This choice may lead to the extraction of many spurious detections, however daophot allows us to dis- criminate between stars, extended sources (galaxies), saturated objects and other spurious detections. The PSF fitting proce- dure was re-iterated twice for each Cha II field; given the mod- erate crowding of these fields, this choice allowed us to detect the faintest neighbours to bright stars while keeping the number of spurious detections relatively small. The typical residual of the PSF fitting is less than 2% of the peak brightness. A single catalogue comprising all the stellar sources detected in all the available photometric bands was finally produced. In Fig. 2 the internal photometric errors of all the detected point-like sources are plotted against the magnitude for all the available filters; the relative exponential fits are over-plotted. Tab. 4 summarises the number of point-like sources detected in the surveyed area in each filter and the limiting magnitudes achieved at the 10σ, 5σ and 3σ levels, respectively. 2.4.2. Completeness The completeness of our catalogues was estimated in the stan- dard way by inserting artificial stars into the images and recov- ering them using the same extraction parameters as for the real objects; the fraction of the recovered artificial objects provides a measure of the completeness. We used the IRAF/addstar package to perform the exercise. We inserted 3000 artificial sources; this number should not alter significantly the crowding statistics in the images. The profile for the artificial sources was Fig. 2. Photometric errors versus magnitudes and relative expo- nential fits for all the point-like sources detected in Cha II and for all the available filters. The "double sequence", clearly vis- ible in R and Hα12 bands, is due to different seeing conditions in the individual exposures. generated by using the same PSF model used for the source ex- traction; the position of the artificial objects are randomly dis- tributed over the entire area of the mosaic and their magnitudes range uniformly between the detection and the saturation lim- its in each band. As an example we show the results for the ChaII 2 field (see Tab. 1). Fig. 3 shows the fraction of recov- ered artificial objects as a function of magnitude for each filter. The corresponding magnitude limits at 95% completeness level (C=95%) are reported in Tab. 4. 3. Tools for candidates selection Our primary criterion for the selection of low-mass PMS star and BD candidates from the extracted catalogue was based on the comparison of the object location in CMDs with theoretical isochrones. In addition, our WFI data in the 865-nm and 914- 6 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud Fig. 3. Completeness plots for extraction of artificial stars from the ChaII 2 mosaic (see Tab. 1) for all the photometric bands used in this work (see text). Table 4. Number of stellar sources (N∗) detected in each filter and relative limiting magnitudes at the 10σ, 5σ and 3σ level. The last column report the magnitude limit at 95% complete- ness level. Filter N∗ Mag 10σ Mag 5σ Mag 3σ Mag (C=95%) Rc/162 Ic/Iwp z+/61 Hα/7 Hα/12 856-nm 914-nm 141400 141000 79000 72500 84200 76700 80400 21.8 21.0 18.7 17.5 17.8 18.6 18.9 22.6 21.7 19.6 19.8 19.9 19.4 19.5 23.2 22.3 20.2 20.4 20.8 20.0 20.1 21.3 21.0 18.8 18.0 18.4 18.0 18.0 nm intermediate-bands allowed us to obtain a first estimate on the effective temperature of the candidates, whereas the mea- surements in Hα provided us with a diagnostics for possible Hα emission. Our selection method exploits the tools which are now described. 3.1. TheoreticalIsochrones Theoretical isochrones for low-mass stars and BDs down to 0.001 M⊙ are provided by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) in the Cousins photometric system (Bessel 1990). Since the WFI filters transmission curves are somewhat different from the original Cousins ones, in par- ticular for the I-band, it is crucial to transform the colours and magnitudes into the appropriate photometric system. We thus transformed the isochrones by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) into the WFI-Cousins system as de- scribed in Appendix B. In this way, we can use the isochrones to define the PMS locus in the CMDs (e.g. Fig. 9) in a photo- metrically consistent way. In Fig. 4 the theoretical RC vs. (R-I)C colour-magnitude di- agram is shown. The 95% completeness limit was determined from the values reported in Tab. 4. For AV =0 we are com- plete down to 0.02 M⊙ at the 95% level for objects younger Fig. 4. Theoretical RC vs. (R-I)C diagram. The isochrones (con- tinuous curves) and PMS tracks (dashed curves), shifted to the distance modulus of Cha II (6.25 mag, Whittet et al. (1997)) are in the WFI-Cousins photometric system. The dashed straight line represents the 95% completeness limit. The AV=2 mag reddening vector is shown. than 10 Myr. For an average extinction AV ≈2 mag for Cha II (Cambr´esy 1999) a 95% completeness limit corresponds to 0.03 M⊙. 3.2. The(m856 − m914)indexvs.temperaturerelation Late-type dwarfs are characterised by strong molecular absorp- tion bands essentially due to metallic oxides (TiO and VO). The ESO-WFI medium-band filter centered at 856 nm covers important TiO absorption features that deepen with decreasing temperature, while the medium-band filter centered at 914 nm lies in a wavelength range which is relatively featureless in late- type objects (see Fig. B.1 lower panel in Appendix B). Thus, the (m856 − m914) colour index is sensitive to the effective tem- perature for very cool objects (2000 K.Teff .3800 K), where TiO dominates the opacity (Allard 1990; Burrows & Liebert 1993; O'Neal et al. 1998). In the absence of interstellar extinc- tion, this index can provide a first reliable guess of the temper- ature of the cool candidates. Using the filter transmission curves for the correspond- ing intermediate-band filters and the synthetic low-resolution StarDusty spectra for low-mass stars and BDs by Allard et al. (2000) we derived the relationship between the (m856 − m914) index and the effective temperature, applying the methods de- scribed in Appendix B. The synthetic (m856 − m914) index, de- rived by integrating the StarDusty spectra under the filter trans- missions and CCD quantum efficiency curves, is in the instru- mental WFI system. As such, it was transformed into the stan- dard AB photometric system by applying the zero points de- rived from the spectrophotometric standard stars Hiltner 600, LTT 4364 and Eg 274, observed with WFI in the 856-nm and 914-nm bands (see Sec. 2.3). From the standard fluxes (Hamuy et al. 1992) integrated under the WFI passbands like- L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 7 Fig. 5. (m856 − m914) index versus effective temperature rela- tion derived from the corresponding WFI intermediate-band filters and the synthetic low-resolution StarDusty spectra for low-mass stars and BDs by Allard et al. (2000). The two solid curves show the relation for log g=5.0 (lower boundary) and log g=3.5 (upper boundary); the dashed curve represents the Teff-colour relation for log g=4.0. The straight line is the em- pirical relationship derived by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2004). wise the StarDusty spectra, we found an average zero-point correction for the (m856 − m914) colour of −0.13 mag, which allowed us to obtain the calibrated synthetic (m856 − m914) in- dex as: (m856 − m914)synt calib = (m856 − m914)synt instr − 0.13 (6) In Fig. 5 we show the resulting (m856 − m914) index ver- sus temperature relation. This relation depends on the stellar gravity, as indicated by the shaded area in Fig. 5, which en- compasses all the calibrations for models in the range 3.5≤ log g ≤5. We also derived this relationship using other stellar atmosphere models (e.g. NextGen, COND, etc.); the StarDusty models were chosen because they better match the empirical relationship between the (m856 − m914) index and the effec- tive temperature by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2004) (straight line in Fig. 5). Furthermore, Allard et al. (2001) found that silicate dust grains can form abundantly in the outer atmospheric layers of the latest M dwarfs and BDs. In the case of high interstellar extinction (AV &4 mag), the temperature derived from this relation may be underestimated because the (m856 − m914) index becomes larger than in the ab- sence of extinction. Thus, without any reliable evaluation of AV, we can use these temperature estimates only for candidate selection purposes (see Sec. 4). 3.3. Hα EquivalentWidthcalibration The WFI Hα7 filter covers the Hα line, while the Hα12 filter lies in a wavelength range which is affected by neither the Hα wings nor strong photospheric lines (see Fig. B.1 mid panel in Appendix B). The (Ha12 − Ha7) index is thus sensitive to the intensity of the Hα line. We used the StarDusty spectra by Allard et al. (2000) to define a calibration relation between this Fig. 6. Calibration relation between the (Hα12 − Hα7) index and the Hα equivalent width derived from the corresponding WFI intermediate-band filters and the synthetic low-resolution StarDusty spectra for low-mass stars and BDs by Allard et al. (2000). index and the Hα equivalent width (EWHα). In order to sim- ulate stellar spectra with different values of EWHα, we added to the synthetic spectra a Gaussian emission profile centered at Hα (656.2 nm) and having a FWHM of 3 Å. The latter value was fixed by considering the Hα line profiles of a sample of 75 PMS stars presented by Fern`andez et al. (1995); we found that the typical FWHM of the Hα emission lines of these objects is around 3 Å, though it can be higher for classical T Tauri stars (5-6 Å). However, from tests made by using profiles with dif- ferent FWHM, we have verified that the FWHM value has no significant effect on the (Hα12 − Hα7) vs. EWHα calibration. By applying the method described in Appendix B and correcting the synthetic (Hα12 − Hα7) colour by the mean (Hα12 − Hα7) colour of the spectrophotometric standard stars used to transform the intermediate-band photometry into the AB system (see Sec. 2.3), we obtained the calibration relation (Hα12 − Hα7) vs. EWHα displayed in Fig. 6. This relation does not depend on the FWHM of the Gaussian emission core but is strongly dependent on the effective temperature for objects cooler than about 4500 K. As expected from the contribution of the Hα absorption wings (see Fig. B.1, mid panel), for a fixed EWHα the (Hα12 − Hα7) index is higher for cooler objects; be- tween 3000 and 2000 K this trend is inverted because the Hα12 filter covers strong molecular absoption bands that heavily af- fect the continuum of very cool stars. The relationship between the Hα index and EWHα derived above was checked by using unpublished WFI Hα photome- try and spectroscopy of already confirmed PMS stars in the L1616 cometary cloud obtained with [email protected] (Alcal´a et al. 2004) and FORS@VLT (Alcal´a et al., in prepa- ration). The spectra of the PMS stars in L1616 were integrated under the transmission curves of the WFI Hα filters to derive their "synthetic" (Hα12 − Hα7) index. Such index was then transformed into the AB system by using the mean Hα colour 8 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud than 0.1, corresponding to EWHα ≈ 10 Å for an object with Teff ≈ 4000 K. The Hα index versus EWHα relation was also checked using data from the literature for the Cha II PMS stars. In Fig. 8 the Hα equivalent width derived from spectro- scopic data (Hughes & Hartigan 1992), EWHα (spec), is com- pared with the one derived from the Hα photometric index, EWHα (phot). In order to estimate the latter, the effective tem- peratures reported by Hughes & Hartigan (1992) were used, while for the PMS star C 41 the temperature reported by Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana (2004) was used. From Fig. 8, the EWHα values derived from the Hα photometric index are in good agreement with those derived from spectroscopic data. The computed RMS suggests that the relationship shown in Fig. 6 can be used to estimate the EWHα from the WFI Hα photometry for objects with EWHα & 10 Å and EWHα & 30 Å, at the 1σ and 3σ levels respectively, provided we have an esti- mate of the stellar temperature. 4. Selection of the candidates For the selection of low-mass PMS star and young BD can- didates we exploited both the optical data from our survey and the JHK photometry available from the 2MASS catalogue (Cutri et al. 2003), using the tools described in the previous sections. A matching radius of 0.5′′was used to merge the WFI and the 2MASS catalogues; this value was set by taking into account the astrometric accuracy of both catalogues. Low-mass PMS star and BD candidates in SFRs can be identified in optical CMDs. In such diagrams the colour in- creases rapidly for late spectral types and hence, the contam- ination from foreground stars is expected to decrease. A first sample of candidates was then selected based on the IC vs. (IC − z) and IC vs. (R − I)C CMDs. All the point- like sources detected in Cha II above the 3σ level were placed in these CMDs (Fig. 9) and their position was compared with the theoretical isochrones. The isochrones transformed into the WFI-Cousins system, as described in Sec. 3.1, were scaled to the Cha II distance of 178 pc (Whittet et al. 1997) in both CMDs. We then selected all the objects falling above the 10 Myr isochrone in both CMDs (Fig. 9). This criterion takes into account the age spread of the previously known PMS stars in Cha II (0.1-10 Myr, Hughes & Hartigan 1992) and the PMS locus that they define on the CMDs, as well as the uncertainties in interstellar extinction. In this way we selected 114 objects of which 17 were previously known Cha II members. However, the 97 new candidates from the selection above may still be contaminated by background giants and highly- reddened objects. We therefore investigated the properties of the selected sample in the JHK bands using their 2MASS magnitudes. It has been found by different authors that the intrinsic (J − H) and (H − K) colours of young late-M ob- jects are dwarf-like with, in some cases, an (H − K) excess, mainly arising from a circumstellar disk or an in-falling en- velope (Lee et al. 2005; Luhman & Rieke 1999; Meyer et al. 1997). Furthermore, Meyer et al. (1997) found that classical T Tauri stars, with prominent IR excesses due to circumstel- lar accretion disks, exhibit a narrow range of colours in the Fig. 7. (Hα12 − Hα7) observed colours for PMS stars in L1616 as a function of the synthetic (Hα12 − Hα7) colours (see text). The continuous line represents the best fit of the data; the dashed line has offset a=0 and slope b=1. Fig. 8. Comparison between the Hα equivalent width esti- mated in this work from the (Hα12 − Hα7) photometric in- dex and that measured by Hughes & Hartigan (1992) and Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana (2004) for confirmed PMS stars in Cha II (open circles). The smaller black dots mark the objects recovered by our selection criteria (see Sec. 4). index of the corresponding spectrophotometric standard stars observed in the L1616 run. The WFI Hα photometry of these PMS stars was then used to compare the observed (Hα12 −Hα7) index with the one derived from the spectra. Fig. 7 shows the results. The best fitting line (continuous line in Fig. 7) has a slope close to 1 and an offset close to zero; this implies that no significant correction must be applied to the (Hα12 − Hα7) vs. EWHα relation deduced from the synthetic spectra. Based on the errors of the observed (Hα12 − Hα7) index we conclude that bona-fide emission line objects will have an Hα index greater L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 9 Fig. 10. (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagram for the sources detected in Cha II (small gray dots). The solid curve shows the relation between these indexes for main sequence stars (lower branch) and giants (upper branch). The dashed line indicates the clas- sical T Tauri stars locus by Meyer et al. (1997). The continu- ous line is dividing line between giants and dwarfs. The shaded area indicates the locus presumably uncontaminated by giants. The previously known PMS stars and candidates are indicated with open circles and squares respectively. The big black dots represent the objects selected in this work. The AV=2 mag red- dening vector is shown. The two PMS stars which fall outside the selection area are the heavily veiled star Sz 47 (below the shaded area) and the binary Sz 60E (above the shaded area). 84 objects, which still include the 17 previously known mem- bers. The sub-sample passing the secondary selection may still contain foreground and highly-reddened background objects. We thus performed a third-level selection as follows. We as- sumed that the objects passing the primary and secondary selections above are all at the distance of Cha II and esti- mated their temperature and luminosity as described in Sec. 5. Although these are first guesses of the actual stellar temper- atures and luminosities, these values already provide good estimates for candidate selection purposes. We then con- structed the HR diagram of our candidates sample and se- lected all the objects falling between the birth-line and the 20 Myr isochrone, using the models by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000). Although the age distribution of the confirmed members of Cha II ranges between 0.1 and 10 Myr (Hughes & Hartigan 1992), the more relaxed criterion of a 20 Myr cut-off for the candidates with a high membership prob- ability was set by taking into account the uncertainties on the distance to the Cha II cloud (∆d=18 pc, Whittet et al. 1997) and the interstellar extinction. The evolutionary tracks of low-mass PMS stars run almost parallel to the luminosity axis of the H-R diagram. Thus, though mass estimates are not greatly affected by interstellar extinction, the age dispersion may be consider- ably increased if the adopted extinction for each candidate is Fig. 9. IC vs. (IC − z) and IC vs. (R − I)C diagrams for the point-like objects in our survey (small gray dots). The lines represent the theoretical isochrones derived as explained in Sec. 3.1, shifted to the distance modulus of Cha II (6.25 mag, Whittet et al. (1997)). The continuous line in each diagram rep- resents the saturation limit. The big black dots represent the 37 sources selected from our criteria, while the open circles and squares represent the known PMS stars and candidates se- lected from previous surveys respectively. The magnitudes re- ported by Hughes & Hartigan (1992) were used to plot the ob- jects above and/or close to our saturation limits in any of the three broad-bands. Note that basically all the known PMS stars and candidates are recovered in our selection. The AV=2 mag reddening vector is shown in both diagrams. (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagram (dashed line in Fig. 10). By using the (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagram we then performed a secondary selection on the sample coming from the optical CMDs, fol- lowing similar criteria as in Lee et al. (2005). The sub-sample of all the objects falling below the dividing line between giants and dwarfs (c.f. Fig. 10) should be less contaminated by back- ground giant stars. In this way we end up with a sub-sample of 10 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud not well determined. The mean uncertainty on our visual ex- tinction determinations is ∼1.5 mag (see Sec. 5.3.1); this would correspond to a luminosity uncertainty of ∼16% and, hence, and age uncertainty of ∼2 Myr for an object with mass ∼0.5M⊙ and age 2-3 Myr, i.e. the typical values in Cha II (Alcal´a et al., in preparation). Thus, the criterion of the 20 Myr isochrone ensures that the selected objects are, to a first approximation, consistent with Cha II membership. The theoretical isochrones depend on the physics involved in the models. As such they may be rather uncertain, in partic- ular in the very low-mass domain. We have thus tested the reli- ability of our selection criteria using as test-bench the publicly available samples of confirmed PMS stars and BDs in Taurus and IC348 reported by Briceno et al. (2002) and Luhman et al. (2003), respectively. As can be seen in Fig. 14 (available only in electronic form), the selection criteria recover the vast majority of the previously known PMS stars and BDs in these regions, providing a good check that they work well on selecting these type of objects. 5. Results of the survey The already confirmed Cha II population members consist of some 36 objects, comprised of 33 PMS stars (Alcal´a et al. 2000; Hughes & Hartigan 1992; Young et al. 2005), one BD (Alcal´a et al. 2006), and two planetary-mass objects (Allers et al. 2006; Jayawardhana & Ivanov 2006). The screening of our data lead, on the other hand, to the selection of 37 interesting objects. Of these, 17 were already known (16 PMS stars plus the BD) and 10 are candidates with high probability of membership based on their selection in pre- vious surveys (Allers et al. 2006; Persi et al. 2003; Vuong et al. 2001; Young et al. 2005). The remaining 10 selected objects are completely new candidates. The other 13 previously known PMS stars are saturated and/or close to the saturation limit in at least one of our broad-band RIz images and hence, we could not apply our selection criteria. However, using their magnitudes and colours from the literature (Alcal´a et al. 1995; Hughes & Hartigan 1992), these objects would fall within our selection; this means that, adding these to the 17 previously known non-saturated objects, our criteria recover 30 of the 36 previously known Cha II members. fail: the heavily (Hughes & Hartigan 1992) criteria 47 There are a few exceptions in which the above veiled T Tauri selection and C 41 stars Sz (Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana 2004), which ex- hibit strong UV excess that affects their colours, and the Class-I source IRAS 12500-7658 (Young et al. 2005), which is a deeply embedded object. These three sources are sub- luminous in both CMDs. In addition, the other Class-I source, ISO-CHA II 28, is not detected in any of our images. Although this type of objects would escape our selection, they are expected to be rare in Cha II (Young et al. (2005); Alcal´a et al., in preparation). The two planetary-mass candidates reported by Allers et al. (2006) also escaped selection because they were barely detected only in our I-band images. The Herbig-Haro object HH 54 (Giannini et al. 2006) and the Class-0 source BHR 86 (Garay et al. 2002) are also associated with Cha II. HH 54 was detected only in our R-band and Hα images, while BHR 86 was not detected in any of the optical bands. These objects will be discussed in detail in a forthcoming paper (Alcal´a et al., in preparation). In conclusion, our selection criteria recover the majority (about 80%) of the confirmed and candidate members of Cha II reported in previous surveys. For the sake of clarity, in all the diagrams we use dots to represent the 37 objects selected with our criteria, open circles to represent the already confirmed members and open squares to represent the 10 candidates se- lected in previous surveys. The 10 new candidates appear sim- ply as dots in all the diagrams. In Tab. 7 we report all the objects with at least one photo- metric measurement in the optical bands4. The table contains the confirmed members of Cha II, the candidates selected by previous surveys and the new candidates selected in this work, as well as other sources identified as possible candidates in previous studies, but which were rejected by our selection criteria. The latter sample includes objects like the candidates reported by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005)5 and some of the sources identified by Persi et al. (2003). Comments on some individual objects are given in Appendix C. In the following we concentrate on the sample of 20 candi- dates, namely the 10 candidates selected from previous sur- veys, but also recovered from our selection criteria, and the 10 new candidates; they are reported in Tab. 6 and their spatial distribution is shown in Fig. 1. The 10 previously known can- didates we recovered in our selection have also been proposed as young members of Cha II by recent studies (Allers et al. 2006; Vuong et al. 2001; Young et al. 2005); this supports their membership to the cloud and, at the same time, the reliabil- ity of our selection method. Moreover, several of them pos- sess Hα emission (see Sec. 5.2). We remark that these are the candidates with the highest membership likelihood but we do not exclude that a few true Cha II members could have escaped some of our selection criteria. In particular, if they are heavily veiled, deeply embedded or components of unre- solved binaries. If all the 20 candidates will be confirmed by spectroscopy, the population of Cha II will increase to some 56 members. Two of the 10 new candidates in our sample (WFI J12585611-7630105 and WFI J13005531-7708295) have been spectroscopically confirmed to be PMS stars (Alcal´a et al., in preparation). 5.1. Possiblecontaminants One possible source of contamination of our candidates is rep- resented by field dwarfs. In order to estimate the number of possible foreground dwarfs in the field of ChaII we followed the prescriptions by Burgasser et al. (2004). We used the low- mass luminosity function simulations from Burgasser (2004) and the absolute magnitudes for late M and L field dwarfs from 4 Table 7 is published only in electronic form. 5 The BD candidates selected by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005) do not comply with our selection criteria, probably because the colour effects on the isochrones due the WFI filters was not taken into account. L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 11 Dahn et al. (2002). Assuming a limiting magnitude of I=20, i.e. the I magnitude of our faintest candidates, and a mass function dN/dM ∝ Mα with 0.5< α <1.5, we expect 8-10 foreground dwarfs with 2000<Teff <3000 K in the ∼2 square degrees area observed in Cha II. Therefore, up to about 50% of the candi- dates might be foreground dwarfs unrelated to the SFR. Another possible source of contamination is represented by faint galaxies which may have colours similar to those of PMS objects, in particular of BD candidates. From the K-band galaxy number counts toward the celestial south pole, the ex- pected number of background galaxies with K .13 mag, i.e. the K magnitude of our faintest candidates, in a ∼2 square de- grees area is ∼20 (Minezaki & Kobayashi 1998). For this es- timate only diffuse interstellar extinction, which is negligible (∼0.02 mag) at the K-band (Jones et al. 1981), is considered. In Cha II, the extinction may be as high as AV ≈6-8 mag, i.e. AK ≈1 mag. Thus, in order to contaminate our sample, the background galaxies should have K . 12 mag; the predicted galaxy number count at this magnitude is less than 2 in the sur- veyed area. In addition, our PSF extraction methods remove the extended objects quite efficiently; thus, the only contami- nants may be eventually the point-like extra-galactic objects, mainly QSO's. According to Prescott et al. (2006) only a hand- ful of QSO's are expected to be present in 2 square degrees for magnitudes brighter than R =20 mag. The number increases for fainter magnitudes, but the vast majority of our candidates are brighter. Thus, we do not expect that extra-galactic objects represent a major problem of contamination. Fig. 11. RC magnitudes versus (Hα12 − Hα7) colours for the point-like objects in Cha II (small gray dots). The previously known PMS stars and candidates are indicated by open circles and squares respectively, whereas the sources selected in this work are represented with big black dots. The AV=2 mag red- dening vector is shown. tected on our Hα images. The Hα information drawn from our data for the selected candidates is reported in Tab. 6. 5.2. Hα emissionofthecandidates 5.3. Towardsthefractionofsub-stellarobjectsinChaII The calibration relation between the (Hα12 − Hα7) index and the EWHα (see Sec. 3.3) allows us to investigate a possible Hα emission of the candidates. Based on this calibration, a thresh- old of (Hα12 − Hα7)=0.1 mag would translate into an equiv- alenth width EWHα ≈ 10 Å at the 1σ level of detection (c.f. Sec. 3.3). Most of the previously known PMS stars and candi- dates have an Hα index larger than this value (c.f. Fig. 11). 40% of the 20 candidates show Hα emission at the 1σ level, but only 2 of the 20 show it at the 3σ level. Considering that the Hα line can be strongly variable in young objects, we cannot use the index as a major diagnostic for the selection of the candidates, but only as a consistency check on their possible PMS nature. However, the 1σ level detections are yet consistent with recent spectroscopic evidence of Hα emission (Alcal´a et al., in prepa- ration). Moreover, the EWHα range covered by our candidates (10-35 Å) is in line with that found by White & Basri (2003) for the slowly rotating, non-accreting stars and BDs in Taurus- Auriga. For the remaining candidates the (Hα12 − Hα7) index does not indicate clear evidence for Hα emission. For three objects (WFI J12533662-7706393, WFI J12583675-7704065, and WFI J13005297-7709478) the level of Hα emission could not be estimated because they are not detected in our Hα im- ages (the magnitude limit is ∼20.5 mag at the 3σ level). These very faint candidates are indeed of relevant importance be- cause their optical colours resemble those of ISO-CHA II-13 (Alcal´a et al. 2006). Note that also ISO-Cha II-13 was not de- An interesting and important quantity in this investigation is the number of sub-stellar objects relative to the PMS stars in Cha II. In order to determine this quantity, we must sin- gle out the sub-stellar objects. According to Chabrier et al. (2000), the sub-stellar limit for 3-4 Myr objects, the approx- imate age of Cha II (Alcal´a et al. 2000; Cieza et al. 2005; Hughes & Hartigan 1992), falls at a temperature of about 2900 K. Using the tools described in Sec. 3 and exploiting the potential of our photometric data, we attempted a first estimate of the temperature of the candidate members of Cha II and hence, a guess on the fraction of sub-stellar candidates rela- tive to the PMS stars. We derived first the dereddened SEDs of the candidates and then provided a first estimate of their tem- perature. 5.3.1. Dereddened SEDs The SEDs were derived by merging the RIz WFI-Cousins photometry with the 2MASS JHK magnitudes. The standard fluxes at each of the optical and near-IR pass-bands have been derived from the observed magnitudes using the expression Fλ = F0 is the observed mag- nitude corrected for interstellar reddening and F0 λ is the Earth flux of an A0-type star of magnitude V = 0 (Tab. 5). In order to derive the visual extinction, AV, a SED minimization procedure was used as follows. We assume that the observed magnitude at , where magcorr λ · 10−0.4·magcorr λ λ 12 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud Fig. 12. Spectral energy distributions of the 10 new candidates selected in this work. Dereddened optical data are represented with filled circles; the IR data are from 2MASS (filled squares), IRAC@Spitzer and MIPS@Spitzer (filled triangles and upside down triangles respectively). The open circles represent the observed fluxes. The best fitting StarDusty spectra by Allard et al. (2000) with the same temperature as the objects are over-plotted (see Sec. 5.3.2). WFI J12585611-7630105, WFI J13014752- 7631023 and WFI J13031616-7629381 fall outside the areas mapped with MIPS and IRAC; although WFI J13071960-7655476 and WFI J13005297-7709478 fall in the area surveyed with MIPS, they were not detected. L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 13 Table 5. Absolute flux calibration constants and effective wavelengths for the optical and near-IR pass-bands. Filter F0 λ (erg · s−1 · cm−2 · Å−1) RC IC z J H K 2.25 ·10−9 1.19 ·10−9 8.40 ·10−10 3.13 ·10−10 1.13 ·10−10 4.28 ·10−11 λeff (µm) 0.64 0.79 0.96 1.25 1.62 2.20 Ref. Cousins (1976) Cousins (1976) This work Cutri et al. (2003) Cutri et al. (2003) Cutri et al. (2003) each wavelength (mλ tion: obs) can be derived by the following equa- mλ obs − mλ re f = AV · dAλ dAV + S (7) and mλ obs − mλ re f is a distance-scaled reference magnitude at a given where mλ wavelength (λ) and temperature (Teff). In Eq. 7 AV is the visual extinction, Aλ the wavelength-dependent extinction and S a scaling factor depending only on the stellar radius. Using a grid of reference magnitudes and temperatures, we perform a linear fit to the previous expression were dAλ re f are the dAV independent and dependent variables, respectively, and AV and S the two free parameters of the fit. The dAλ term was derived dAV using the extinction law by Cardelli et al. (1989), assuming the standard value RV =3.1. The grid of reference SEDs was con- structed by combining the tabulations of colours as function of spectral types by Kenyon & Hartmann (1995), Luhman et al. (2003) and Ducati et al. (2001). The AV value of the reference SED minimizing the χ2 of the fit corresponds to the best ap- proximation of the actual visual extinction. As a check, we have compared the results from our fitting procedure with the extinc- tion derived from the spectral types and the observed colours of previously known PMS stars in Cha II. The RMS difference in AV is less than 1.5 mag, with only one object having a residual of about 4 mag. In Fig. 12 the SEDs of the 10 new candidates selected in this work are shown. For six of these, we found a match in the c2d Spitzer catalogues and their IRAC and/or MIPS fluxes are also included. As appears from their SEDs, no significant IR excess is detected in these six objects. If they will be spectro- scopically confirmed as Cha II members, they will most likely correspond to weak-line T Tauri stars (WTTS) or to BDs with thin disks. For the four remaining objects lacking Spitzer data we cannot assess the presence of strong IR excess. However, for three of the latter we estimate an Hα equivalenth width greater than about 20Å. It is interesting to note that the number of WTTS relative to CTTS in Cha II is very small. Even assuming that all the candidates in our sample (see Tab. 6) would result in WTTS, which is not likely because several of them show evidence for strong Hα emission, the CTTS would outnumber the WTTS by a factor ∼2. This would be in contrast with what it is found the confirmed T Tauri stars in Cha II Fig. 13. Upper panel: comparison between the effective tem- perature resulting from the SED fitting procedure described in Sec. 5.3.2 and that derived from the spectral classi- fication for re- ported by Hughes & Hartigan (1992) and, for C 41, by Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana (2004) (open circles). The black dots mark the objects recovered by our selection criteria. The point at Tspec ≈2900 K represents ISO-CHA II 13 as reported by Alcal´a et al. (2006). Lower Panel: comparison between the effective temperature resulting from the SED fit- ting procedure described in Sec. 5.3.2 and that derived from the Teff vs. (m856 − m914) calibration. The open circles and squares represent previously known PMS stars and candidates respec- tively. The black dots mark the objects recovered by our selec- tion criteria in other clouds, like Cha I and Taurus, where WTTS dominate the PMS population (Feigelson & Montmerle 1999). Our se- lection based on the (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagram, picks up objects later than about K5. This might lead to the conclusion that some earlier type WTTS could have escaped our selec- tion. However, such objects would have been detected in the previous ROSAT X-ray surveys by Alcal´a et al. (1995, 2000). Only two WTTS in the cloud, namely RXJ1301.0-7654a and RXJ1303.1-7706 were discovered in such surveys. Thus, the low fraction of WTTS in Cha II seems to be real. More details on this will be discussed in a future c2d paper (Alcal´a et al., in preparation), with a more complete set of SEDs for the Cha II members. 5.3.2. Temperature The temperature of the candidates was estimated using the Teff vs. (m856 − m914) calibration relation reported in Sec. 3.2. This calibration is valid for cool objects with temperature in the range 2000–3800 K, corresponding to a dereddened (m856 − m914) index in the range 1.16–0.16 mag. Thus, we ap- 14 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud plied the calibration to objects with dereddened index (m856 − m914)>0.16 mag. The AV values determined as explained in Section 5.3.1 and the extinction law by Cardelli et al. (1989) were used to deredden the (m856 − m914) index. For objects with (m856 − m914)<0.16 mag, i.e. hotter than about 3800 K, a temperature estimate was done by fitting a grid of refer- ence SEDs to the dereddened SEDs. The grid of reference SEDs was constructed by combining the tabulations of colours as a function of spectral type by Kenyon & Hartmann (1995), Luhman et al. (2003) and Ducati et al. (2001); the best approx- imation to the dereddened SED was then obtained by χ2- minimization of the flux differences between the dereddened SED and the reference SED. The minimization procedure was applied to the short-wavelength portion (λ ≤ λJ) of the SED, which is less affected by an eventual IR excess (Fig. 12). The method results to be accurate within 250 K relative to the spectroscopic temperature estimates for most of the pre- viously known PMS stars. This is shown in the upper panel of Fig. 13, where the residuals between the temperature derived from the dereddened SED fitting, Tfit, and that obtained from spectroscopy by Hughes & Hartigan (1992), Tspec, are shown. For ISO-CHA II 13 we adopt the temperature value determined spectroscopically by Alcal´a et al. (2006). For the cool candidates, we also performed a consistency check between the temperature derived from SED fitting and that coming from the Teff vs. (m856 − m914) calibration. We find that the two methods yield consistent results within ∼200 K, as can be seen from the lower panel of Fig. 13. We can then use the Teff vs. (m856 − m914) calibration confidently for those objects with dereddened (m856 − m914)>0.16 mag. The resulting temperature for each of the candidates is re- ported in Tab. 6. Using these estimates, we attempted to deter- mine their radius and luminosity as follows: 1. First the reference SED of the same effective temperature as the object was selected and scaled to the Cha II distance (d= 178 pc, Whittet et al. 1997): F ′ d !2 re f = Fre f · R⋆ (8) where R⋆ is the stellar radius; since R⋆ is an unknown quantity, we let it vary between 0.1, i.e. the value expected for a BD at the Deuterium burning limit (Baraffe et al. 2003), and 10 R⊙; for the objects whose effective temper- ature could not be estimated from the (m856 − m914) index, both Teff and R⋆ were set as free parameters in the assump- tion that the short-wavelength side of the dereddened SED (λ ≤ λJ) is mainly influenced by Teff; 2. the best estimate of R⋆ was then obtained by minimiz- ing the flux differences between the observed dereddened SED and the reference one. The minimization procedure was performed, as above, to the short-wavelength portion (λ ≤ λJ) of the SED; 3. Finally, we calculated the bolometric luminosities by ap- plying bolometric corrections to both the dereddened I- band and J-band data. Bolometric corrections were taken from Kenyon & Hartmann (1995) for objects earlier than M6 (i.e. Teff &3000 K), while for cooler objects we followed the prescriptions by Luhman (1999) and com- bined the compilations of bolometric corrections as a func- tion of temperature by Bessel (1991), Monet et al. (1992), Tinney et al. (1993) and Leggett et al. (1996). Having an estimate of the temperature and luminosity of the candidates, we determined their masses and ages by comparison with the set of evolutionary tracks by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) on the HR diagram. 5.4. Thefractionofsub-stellarobjects Previous investigations (Alcal´a et al. 2000; Hughes & Hartigan 1992) showed some evidences that the mass spectrum in Cha II might be biased towards very-low mass objects. It is thus inter- esting to investigate what our data suggest on this matter. Assuming that all the 20 candidates are true cloud mem- bers, we end up with 6 candidates with Teff ≤2900 K, i.e. below the substellar limit for 5 Myr old objects. The remain- ing 14 objects result to be PMS star candidates (see Tab. 6). Taking into account the BD ISO-CHA II 13 and the 33 con- firmed PMS stars, the resulting fraction of sub-stellar ob- jects (0.02M⊙ < M < 0.08M⊙) relative to the PMS stars N(0.02−0.08) N(0.08−10) , in Cha II (0.08M⊙ < M < 10M⊙), Rss = would be ∼15% (19% if we consider the two planetary-mass objects reported by Jayawardhana & Ivanov 2006). This last value would imply a peculiar mass-spectrum for the popula- tion of Cha II relative to other T associations (where Rss=12- 14%, Briceno et al. 2002; L´opez Mart´ı et al. 2004), in partic- ular in the sub-stellar domain. If we assume that only the candidates having Hα emission are true cloud members, the Rss value would drop to ∼10% (15% if we consider the two planetary-mass objects reported by Jayawardhana & Ivanov 2006), i.e. more similar to that measured in other T asso- ciations and lower than that measured in OB associations (∼26%, Barrado y Navascu`es et al. 2001; Boulanger et al. 1998; Briceno et al. 2002; Hillenbrand & Carpenter 2000; Muench et al. 2002). If Rss in Cha II is similar as in other T associations, we expect that at least 50% of the candidates re- ported in Tab. 6 will be genuine Cha II members. Assuming that the 7 IRAS sources with Hα emission dis- cussed in Appendix C are PMS stars, the fraction of substellar objects would drop to about 8% or 13% depending on whether the two planetary-mass objects are counted among the sub- stellar ones. By comparing the position of the candidates in the HR di- agram with the Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) evolutionary tracks, their age distribution would peak between 2 and 3 Myr, if they were genuine Cha II members. This would be fairly consistent with the average age of 3.6 Myr determined by Cieza et al. (2005) for a sample of T Tauri stars in Cha II. Taking into account the candidates, the mean mass in Cha II would be ∼0.5M⊙, i.e. slightly lower than the mean mass of the confirmed members alone (0.6 M⊙) and comparable to the mean mass for the Cha I population (∼0.45 M⊙ 6). 6 Luminosity and temperature determinations are reported by Luhman (2004) for 144 members of Cha I. We derived masses and L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 15 Table 6. The 20 candidates selected in this work. The visual extinction (AV) and temperature (Teff) of the candidates were estimated as explained in Sec. 5.3.1 and Sec. 5.3.2, respectively. Wherever possible, the extinction and temperature values were compared with other estimates from literature. Designation EWHα (Å) AV (mag) Teff (K) Alit V (mag) Tlit eff (K) Ref. Classification in this work WFI J12533662-7706393 C 17 C 33 IRAS 12535-7623 WFI J12583675-7704065 WFI J12585611-7630105 ISO-CHA II 29 WFI J12591881-7704419 WFI J12592348-7726589 WFI J13005297-7709478 WFI J13005531-7708295 IRAS F12571-7657 WFI J13014752-7631023 C 50 C 51 WFI J13031615-7629381 C 62 WFI J13071960-7655476 C 66 2MASS13125238-7739182 Not Det. No Em. No Em. No Em. Not Det. 30 No Em. No Em. No Em. Not Det. No Em. No Em. No Em. 20 20 15 35 25 25 10 5.58 5.95 4.48 3.38 3.84 1.91 5.94 4.98 3.33 5.50 4.13 3.95 0.88 3.46 1.16 0.61 3.53 0.50 3.87 1.36 †3000±250 ⋆3600±200 †3700±250 ⋆3900±200 †2400±200 †2900±200 ⋆3900±200 ⋆3800±200 †3700±250 †2500±200 ⋆3800±200 ⋆⋆>3000 †2800±200 †3000±200 †3300±250 †2900±200 †3000±200 ⋆3000±200 †2900±200 †3400±250 5.1 2.4 5 11.5 8,13 2.0 2.3 b b a b b,c b b 4.1,4 3140 b,c 3.7,0 2793 b,c d PMS star cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. BD cand. BD cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. BD cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. BD cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. BD cand. PMS star cand. PMS star cand. BD cand. PMS star cand. Notes to column 4: † Temperature derived from the dereddened (m856 − m914) colour index (Sec. 3.2). ⋆ Temperature derived from the SED fitting method described in Sec. 5.3.2. ⋆⋆ See Appendix C. References: a) Larson et al. (1998); b) Vuong et al. (2001); c) Allers et al. (2006); d) Young et al. (2005). 6. Conclusions The optical survey presented here is one of the deepest and more extensive conducted so far in Cha II and constitutes the optical ancillary data for the c2d Spitzer Legacy survey in this cloud. The photometric selection based on our optical imaging data, combined with data in the near-IR from the 2MASS, al- lowed us to recover basically all the previously known mem- bers of the cloud, including 10 candidates from previous IR surveys, with a high membership probability. Furthermore, we provided 10 new likely member candidates that were not de- tected by previous surveys, thereby increasing the total number of candidates to 20. Should all these objects be spectroscopi- cally confirmed as PMS stars and young BDs, the population of Cha II will increase to 56 members. Up to 50% of the sam- ple may be contaminated by field dwarfs. According to our characterisation criteria of the candidates, we estimate that at least some 50% of them will result in true Cha II members and, based on our temperature estimates, several of these objects are expected to be sub-stellar. Under these assumptions, we con- clude that the fraction of substellar objects relative to the PMS stars in Cha II is on the order of ∼19%, i.e. larger than that reported for other T associations like Taurus. In the most con- servative hypothesis in which only the candidates showing Hα emission would result in true member of the cloud, this frac- tion would drop to ∼15%, i.e. comparable with that measured in other T associations. From the completeness of our survey, both in space and flux, we conclude that the optical population of Cha II mem- bers discovered so far is nearly complete. We do not expect to find many more PMS stars based on optical observations. More clues to these issues will be addressed in a forthcoming paper by combining the optical data presented here with those from the MIPS@Spitzer and IRAC@Spitzer observations in Cha II (Alcal´a et al., in preparation). ages for these objects using the evolutionary tracks by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) in a homogeneous way. Acknowledgements. This work was partially financed by the Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica (INAF) and the Italian Ministero 16 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud dell'Istruzione, Universit´a e Ricerca (MIUR). We thank the anony- mous referee for his/her constructive comments and suggestions. We also thank M. Radovich for many explanations on the use of ASTROMETRIX. We thank N. Evans, PI of the c2d Spitzer Legacy Program, and L. Cieza for many useful comments and suggestions on an earlier version of the paper. We also thank F. Com´eron and E. Marilli for discussions. L. Spezzi acknowledges financial sup- port from COFIN-MIUR-2004 (The X-Shooter spectrograph for the VLT) and PRIN-INAF-2005 (Stellar clusters: a benchmark for star formation and stellar evolution) and a grant by the Europen Southern Observatory (ESO) for a two-months stay at Garching. Support for this work, part of the Spitzer Legacy Science Program, was provided by NASA through contract 1224608 issued by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under NASA contract 1407. We also thank the Lorentz Center in Leiden for hosting sev- eral meetings that contributed to this paper. This research made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS (Strasbourg, France) and the data products from the Two-Micron All-Sky Survey, which is a joint project of the University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center at California Institute of Technology, funded by NASA and the National Science Foundation. References Cardelli J.A., Clayton G.C. & Mathis J.S. 1989, ApJ 345, 245 Chabrier G., Baraffe I., Allard F. & Hauschildt P. 2000, ApJ 542, 464 Chen H., Myers P.C., Ladd E.F. & Wood D.O.S. 1995, ApJ 445, 377 Chen H., Grenfell T.G., Myers P.C. & Hughes J.D. 1997, ApJ 478, 295 Chen B.C., M´endez, Ren´e A., Tsay W.S. & Lu P.K. 2001, ApJ 121, 309 Cieza, L. A., Kessler-Silacci, J. E., Jaffe, D.T., et al. 2005, ApJ, 635, 422 Cousins A.W.J. 1976, Mem. R. Astr. Soc. 81, 25 Covino E., Alcal´a J. M., Allain S. et al. 1997, A&A 328, 187 Cutri R.M., Skrutskie M.F., Van Dyk S. et al. 2003, Explanatory Supplement to the 2MASS All Sky Data Release Dahn C.C., Harris H.C., Vrba F.J. et al. 2002, AJ 124, 1170 D'Antona F. & Mazzitelli I. 1997, Mem. S.A.It. 68, 807 Ducati J.R., Bevilacqua C.M., Rembold S.B. & Ribeiro D. 2001, ApJ 558, 309 Dullemond C.P., Dominik C. & Natta A. 2001, ApJ 560, 957 Evans N.J. II, Allen L.E., Blake G.A. et al. 2003, PASP 115, 965 Feigelson E.D., Casanova S., Montmerle T. & Guibert J. 1993, Alcal´a J.M., Krautter J., Schmitt J. et al. 1995, A&A Supp. Ser. ApJ 416, 623 114, 109 Alcal´a J.M., Covino E., Sterzik M.F. et al. 2000, A&A 355, 629 Alcal´a J.M., Radovich M., Silvotti R. et al. 2002, proceedings Feigelson E.D. & Montmerle T. 1999, Ann. Rev. A&A 37, 363 Fern`andez M., Ortiz E., Eiroa C. & Miranda L.F. 1995, A&A Supp. Ser. 114, 439 of the SPIE 4836, 406 Garay G., Mardones D., Rodr`ıguez L.F. et al. 2002, ApJ 567, Alcal´a J.M., Wachter S., Covino E. et al. 2004, A&A 416, 677 Alcal´a J.M., Spezzi, L., Frasca, A., Covino, E., Porras, A., Mer´ın, B., Persi, P. 2006, A&A, 453, 1 Allard F. 1990, PhD Thesis, Ruprecht Karls Univ. Heidelberg Allard F., Hauschildt P.H. & Schwenke D. 2000, ApJ 540, 1005 Allard F., Hauschildt P.H., Alexander D.R. et al. 2001, ApJ 556, 357 980 Giannini T., Mccoey C., Nisini B. et al. 2006, A&A, in press Graham J.A. & Hartigan P. 1988, ApJ 95, 1197 Gray D.F. 1992, The observations and analysis of stellar pho- tospheres, Cambridge Univ. Press Guti`errez Moreno A., Moreno H., Cortes G. & Wenderoth E. 1988, PASP 100, 973 Allers K.N., Kessler-Silacci J.E., Cieza L.A. & Jaffe D.T. 2006, Hamuy M., Walker A.R., Suntzeff N.B. et al. 1992, PASP 104, ApJ 644, 364 533 Baraffe I., Chabrier G., Allard F. & Hauschildt P.H. 1998, A&A 337, 403 Baraffe I., Chabrier G., Allard F. & Hauschildt P.H. 2002, A&A Hartigan P. 1993 ApJ 105, 1511 Hauschildt P.H., Allard F. & Baron E. 1999, ApJ 512, 377 Henning T., Pfau W., Zinnecker H. & Prusti T. 1993, A&A 276, 382, 563 129 Baraffe I., Chabrier G., Barman T.S. et al. 2003, A&A 402, 701 Barrado Y Navascu`es D., Stauffer J.R., Briceno C. et al. 2001, ApJS 134, 103 Barrado Y Navascu`es D. & Jayawardhana R. 2004, ApJ 615, 840 Bessel M.S., PASP 102, 1181 Bessell M.S. 1991, AJ 101, 662 Bohlin R.C. & Gilliland R.L 2004, ApJ 128, 3053 Boulanger F., Bronfman L., Dame T.M. & Thaddeus P. 1998, A&A 332, 273 Briceno, Luhman K.L., Hartmann L. et al. 2002, ApJ 580, 317 Burgasser A.J. 2004,ApJ Supp. Ser. 155, 207 Burgasser A.J., Kirkpatrick J.D., McGovern M.R. et al. 2004, Hillenbrand L.A. & Carpenter J. 2000, ApJ 540, 236 Hughes J.H. & Hartigan P. 1992, ApJ 104, 680 Jacoby G.H., Africano J.L. & Quigley R.J. 1987, PASP 99, 672 Jayawardhana R. & Ivanov V.D. 2006, in press Jones T., Ashley M., Hyland A. & Ruelas-Mayoroga A. 1981, MNRAS 197, 413 Kenyon S.J. & Hartmann L. 1995, ApJ Supp. Ser. 101, 117 Kenyon S.J. & Hartmann L. 1995, ApJ Supp. Ser. 101, 117 Kroupa P. 2001, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 322, 231 Kroupa P. 2002, Science 295, 82 Kurucz R.L. 1979, ApJ Suppl. Ser. 40, 191 Landolt A.U. 1992, ApJ, 104, 340 Larson K.A., Whittet D.C.B., Prusti T. & Chiar J.E. 1998, A&A ApJ 604, 827 337, 465 Burrows A. & Liebert J. 1993, Rev. of Modern Physics Vol. 65, No. 2, p. 301 Cambr´esy L. 1999, A&A 345, 965 Lee H.T., Chen W.P., Zhi W.Z. & Jing Y.H. 2005, ApJ 624, 808 Leggett S.K., Allard F.,Berriman G. et al. 1996, ApJ Supp. Ser. 104, 117 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 17 L´opez Mart´ı B., Eisloffel J., Scholz A. & Mundt R. 2004, A&A 416, 555 L´opez Mart´ı B., Eisloffel J. & Mundt R. 2005, A&A 444, 175 Luhman K.L. & Rieke G.H. 1999, ApJ 525, 440 Luhman K.L. 1999, ApJ 525, 466 Luhman K.L., Rieke G.H., Young E.T. et al. 2000, ApJ 540, 1016 Luhman K.L., Stauffer J.R., Muench A.A. et al. 2003, ApJ 593,1093 Luhman K.L. 2004, ApJ 602, 816 Luhman K.L., D'Alessio P., Calvet N. et al. 2005, ApJ, 620, 51 Meyer M.R., Calvet N. & Hillenbrand L.A. 1997, ApJ 114, 288 Minezaki T. & Kobayashi Y. 1998, ApJ 494, 111 Monet D.G., Dahn C.C., Vrba F.J. et al. 1992, AJ 103, 638 Monet D., Bird A., Canzian B. et al. 1998, The USNO-A2.0 catalogue, U.S. Naval Observatory Muench A.A., Lada E.A., Lada C.J. & Alves J. 2002, ApJ 573, 366 Muench A.A., Lada E.A., Lada C.J. et al. 2003, ApJ 125, 2029 O'Neal D., Neff J.E. & Saar S.H. 1998, ApJ 507, 919 Palla F. & Stahler S.W. 1999, ApJ 525, 772 Persi P., Marenzi A. R., G´omez M. & Olofsson G. 2003, A&A 399, 995 Porras A., Jorgensen, J.K, Allen, L. et al., 2006 submitted Preibisch T., Stanke T. & Zinnecker H. 2003, A&A 409, 147 Preibisch T., McCaughrean M.J., Grosso N. et al. 2005, ApJ Supp. Ser. 160, 582 Prescott, M.K.M., Impey, C.D., Cool, R.J., Scoville, N. 2006, ApJ 644, 100 Prusti T., Whittet D.C.B., Assendorp R. & Wesselius P.R. 1992, A&A 260, 151 Reipurth B. & Clarck C. 2001, ApJ 122, 432 Schwartz R.D. 1977, ApJS 35,161 Schwartz R.D. 1991, ESO rep. No. 11, p. 93 Stetson P.B. 1987, PASP 99, 191 Stetson P.B. 2000, PASP 112, 925 Tinney C.G., Mould J.R. & Reid I.N. 1993, AJ 105, 1045 Vuong M.H., Cambr´esy L. & Epchtein N. 2001, A&A 379, 208 White R.J.& Basri G. 2003, ApJ 582, 1109 Whittet D.C.B., Laureijs R.J., Zhang C.Y. 1991, A&A 251, 524 Whittet D.C.B., Prusti T., Franco G.A.P. et al. 1997, A&A 327, 1194 Young K.E., Harvey P.M., Brooke T.Y. et al. 2005, ApJ 628, 283 Zerbi F.M., Pallavicini R., Conconi P. et al. 2006, Mem. S.A.It. Suppl., Vol. 9, 419 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud, Online Material p 1 Online Material Table 7. Optical photometry of objects in the Cha II dark cloud. The positions for most objects are from the R-band images. For saturated objects in the R-band the positions are from the Hα12 images; the coordinates of Sz 62, not observed in Hα, are from the z-band image. Magnitudes marked with an asterisk are taken from the the literature (see the relative references) and correspond to objects saturated in our images. Symbols and labels are as explained in the footnote. Comments about some of these objects are given in Appendix C. Designation IRAS 12416-7703 IRAS 12448-7650 IRAS F12488-7658 IRAS 12496-7650 WFI J12533662-7706393 C 17 IRAS 12500-7658 ChaII 304 ChaII 305 C 33 2MASS12560549-7654106 Sz 46NW Sz 46N Sz 46S Sz 47 IRAS 12533-7632 IRAS 12535-7623 ISO-CHA II 13 WFI J12583675-7704065 WFI J12585611-7630105 C 41 ISO-CHA II 29 WFI J12591881-7704419 WFI J12592348-7726589 IRAS 12556-7731 WFI J13005297-7709478 Sz 48NE Sz 49 Sz 48SW Sz 50 WFI J13005531-7708295 RXJ1301.0-7654a IRAS F12571-7657 ISO-CHA II 73 WFI J13014752-7631023 Sz 51 CM Cha C 50 IRAS 12589-7646 RXJ1303.1-7706 C 51 ChaII 376 WFI J13031615-7629381 ISO-CHA II 98a ISO-CHA II 98b ISO-CHA II 110 RAJ2000 (hh:mm:ss) 12:45:06.43 12:48:25.70 12:52:30.49 12:53:17.17 12:53:36.62 12:53:38.84 12:53:42.79 12:55:16.00 12:55:16.48 12:55:25.72 12:56:05.43 12:56:32.85 12:56:33.59 12:56:33.64 12:56:58.63 12:57:00.49 12:57:11.64 12:58:06.67 12:58:36.75 12:58:56.11 12:59:09.86 12:59:10.19 12:59:18.81 12:59:23.48 12:59:26.50 13:00:52.97 13:00:53.15 13:00:53.26 13:00:53.56 13:00:55.28 13:00:55.31 13:00:56.22 13:00:59.21 13:01:46.03 13:01:47.52 13:01:58.94 13:02:13.49 13:02:22.82 13:02:47.73 13:03:04.46 13:03:09.04 13:03:12.45 13:03:16.15 13:03:25.85 13:03:26.10 13:04:18.96 DECJ2000 (dd:mm:ss) −77:20:13.52 −77:06:36.72 −77:15:12.92 −77:07:10.63 −77:06:39.31 −77:15:53.21 −77:15:11.59 −76:46:21.83 −76:46:20.89 −77:00:46.62 −76:54:10.69 −76:45:44.78 −76:45:45.18 −76:45:49.54 −76:47:06.72 −76:48:35.10 −76:40:11.14 −77:09:09.22 −77:04:06.53 −76:30:10.48 −76:51:03.49 −77:12:13.72 −77:04:41.92 −77:26:58.96 −77:47:08.70 −77:09:47.77 −77:09:09.18 −76:54:14.98 −77:09:08.28 −77:10:22.01 −77:08:29.54 −76:54:01.76 −77:14:02.80 −77:16:02.89 −76:31:02.32 −77:51:21.74 −76:37:57.68 −77:34:49.51 −77:02:46.32 −77:07:02.75 −77:55:59.52 −76:50:50.82 −76:29:38.15 −77:01:48.36 −77:01:48.40 −76:53:59.96 Rc S S 14.84±0.01 16.43±0.01 22.22±0.14 17.08±0.01 21.54±0.08 21.85±0.09 21.82±0.09 16.86±0.01 15.95±0.01 18.45±0.01 14.61±0.01 16.81±0.01 13.86±0.01∗ 21.19±0.12 13.61±0.01 22.51±0.27 22.45±0.25 16.39±0.01 18.51±0.01 16.19±0.02 15.69±0.01 14.41±0.01 S 22.63±0.30 16.08±0.01 14.86±0.01 16.26±0.01 14.42±0.01 14.93±0.01 11.59±0.01∗ 18.62±0.01 16.31±0.02 16.83±0.05 13.47±0.02∗ 12.93±0.01 17.78±0.01 S 12.27±0.01∗ 16.88±0.01 16.31±0.01 16.42±0.01 17.09±0.02 17.09±0.02 14.52±0.01 Ic S S 12.21±0.02∗ 13.92±0.01 19.35±0.04 15.09±0.01 19.40±0.01 19.28±0.02 19.30±0.01 15.16±0.01 14.54±0.01 17.69±0.17 13.16±0.01 16.05±0.02 13.38±0.01∗ 19.76±0.01 12.13±0.01 19.38±0.01 19.32±0.01 14.38±0.01 17.03±0.01 14.23±0.01 14.09±0.01 12.99±0.01 S 19.64±0.07 14.32±0.04 13.53±0.03 14.50±0.02 12.50±0.01∗ 13.29±0.01 10.54±0.01∗ 16.16±0.01 15.12±0.01 15.23±0.01 12.38±0.01∗ 11.84±0.01 15.49±0.02 S 11.17±0.01∗ 14.47±0.01 15.45±0.01 14.41±0.03 16.42±0.04 16.37±0.01 14.03±0.01 z S S S 12.82±0.02 18.00±0.04 14.23±0.01 18.44±0.06 18.27±0.05 18.29±0.05 14.66±0.01 14.04±0.02 17.56±0.04 12.68±0.01 15.93±0.02 13.45±0.01 ND 11.53±0.02 17.89±0.04 17.85±0.04 13.54±0.02 16.45±0.02 13.36±0.01 13.34±0.01 12.39±0.01 S 18.25±0.05 13.55±0.01 13.01±0.01 13.72±0.01 11.96±0.02 12.64±0.01 10.17±0.01 15.00±0.01 14.68±0.01 14.65±0.06 11.80±0.02 11.18±0.01 14.53±0.01 S 10.80±0.01 13.46±0.02 15.35±0.05 13.68±0.03 16.24±0.03 16.18±0.02 14.03±0.01 Hα7 Hα12 m856 m914 Main Ref. Note 11.86±0.09 13.15±0.09 15.48±0.10 16.12±0.10 ND 12.10±0.13 13.55±0.13 15.60±0.13 16.84±0.14 ND 17.67±0.10 20.81±0.38 17.36±0.13 21.24±0.46 ND ND 17.15±0.22 16.17±0.10 18.72±0.13 14.80±0.10 17.07±0.10 13.68±0.10 ND 13.69±0.10 ND ND 16.08±0.09 18.06±0.10 16.41±0.19 15.86±0.10 14.78±0.12 12.34±0.09 ND 16.11±0.09 13.90±0.09 16.13±0.09 14.34±0.10 15.26±0.14 11.63±0.09 19.26±0.14 16.71±0.22 16.84±0.20 12.46±0.09 12.15±0.10 17.78±0.10 12.72±0.09 12.34±0.09 16.82±0.10 16.40±0.10 16.30±0.10 17.53±0.10 17.47±0.10 14.59±0.09 ND ND 16.93±0.13 16.15±0.13 18.70±0.14 15.07±0.13 17.03±0.13 14.07±0.13 20.90±0.38 13.73±0.13 ND ND 16.60±0.13 18.88±0.14 16.32±0.13 15.88±0.17 14.62±0.12 12.66±0.13 ND 16.24±0.13 14.93±0.13 16.57±0.13 14.74±0.13 15.24±0.13 11.71±0.14 19.23±0.16 16.55±0.13 17.05±0.21 13.37±0.13 12.57±0.13 18.19±0.20 12.92±0.13 12.08±0.13 17.16±0.13 16.42±0.13 16.67±0.15 17.27±0.11 17.24±0.11 14.58±0.13 S S 12.27±0.09 13.52±0.10 19.26±0.20 15.10±0.09 19.43±0.23 19.26±0.17 19.20±0.17 15.22±0.09 14.58±0.09 17.96±0.10 13.24±0.09 16.32±0.09 13.72±0.09 19.92±0.33 12.22±0.09 19.44±0.19 19.51±0.20 14.34±0.09 17.31±0.09 14.37±0.09 14.19±0.09 13.13±0.09 S 19.85±0.25 14.44±0.09 13.62±0.09 14.51±0.09 12.79±0.09 13.39±0.09 10.61±0.09 16.48±0.23 15.38±0.09 15.77±0.17 12.55±0.09 11.55±0.09 15.48±0.09 S S S S 13.41±0.08 18.58±0.12 14.79±0.08 19.06±0.15 18.65±0.11 18.68±0.12 14.79±0.08 14.42±0.08 18.07±0.09 13.08±0.08 16.38±0.08 13.86±0.08 19.83±0.29 12.03±0.08 18.33±0.11 18.27±0.10 13.81±0.08 17.07±0.08 13.91±0.08 13.86±0.09 12.75±0.08 S 18.66±0.12 14.02±0.08 13.35±0.08 14.19±0.08 12.43±0.08 13.15±0.09 10.66±0.09 15.79±0.14 15.13±0.08 15.18±0.12 12.29±0.08 11.62±0.08 14.93±0.08 S 11.29±0.09 14.39±0.09 11.16±0.08 14.03±0.10 NO NO NO NO 16.83±0.09 17.68±0.43 17.17±0.24 16.99±0.22 NO NO i i f,i a m f i j j f i a a a a e e,i g,k m m f,h g,i m m i m a a a a m d e,g g m a b f,g i c f j m g g g • • • ⋆ U NEW U D D • U ⋆ ✪ • ✤ • ✤ • U • D • ✤ ⋆ ✤ • ✤ ⋆ ✰ D U D U U • • U ⋆ U NEW U NEW U ⋆ ✰ • U NEW NEW U U • NEW U ⋆ ✤ ⋆ ✰ ⋆ ✤ ⋆ U NEW U ⋆U • U • D NEW U ⋆ ⋆ U • U • ⋆ U • U • D NEW U • ✤ • ✤ • D D D Table 7. Continued. Designation Hn 22 Hn 23 Sz 52 Hn 24 Hn 25 Sz 53 Sz 54 Sz 55 Sz 56 Sz 57 Sz 58 Sz 59 C 62 WFI J13071960-7655476 Sz 60W Sz 60E Hn 26 Sz 61 C 66 IRAS F13052-7653NW IRAS F13052-7653S IRAS F13052-7653N Sz 62 Sz 63 2MASS13102531-7729082 2MASS13110329-7653330 2MASS13125238-7739182 Sz 64 R.A.J2000 (hh:mm:ss) 13:04:22.78 13:04:24.06 13:04:24.84 13:04:55.74 13:05:08.51 13:05:12.66 13:05:20.80 13:06:30.49 13:06:38.70 13:06:56.56 13:06:57.35 13:07:09.23 13:07:18.04 13:07:19.60 13:07:22.30 13:07:23.33 13:07:48.50 13:08:06.33 13:08:27.19 13:09:09.81 13:09:10.67 13:09:10.98 13:09:50.44 13:10:04.12 13:10:25.26 13:11:03.27 13:12:52.37 13:14:03.83 Dec.J2000 (dd:mm:ss) −76:50:05.86 −76:50:01.39 −77:52:30.11 −77:39:49.21 −77:33:42.66 −77:30:52.56 −77:39:01.48 −77:34:00.12 −77:30:35.39 −77:23:09.46 −77:23:41.46 −77:30:30.24 −77:40:53.00 −76:55:47.64 −77:37:22.62 −77:37:23.20 −77:41:21.73 −77:55:05.05 −77:43:23.41 −77:09:43.52 −77:09:46.84 −77:09:44.14 −77:57:23.94 −77:10:44.62 −77:29:08.70 −76:53:32.89 −77:39:18.58 −77:53:07.48 Rc Ic z Hα7 Hα12 13.51±0.01∗ 12.23±0.01∗ 16.89±0.01 13.30±0.06∗ 16.11±0.01 15.58±0.02 11.58±0.02∗ 16.37±0.01 15.41±0.01∗ 15.97±0.01 14.63±0.01 13.42±0.02∗ 18.60±0.01 18.33±0.01 14.88±0.02∗ 15.32±0.02∗ 16.07±0.01 13.69±0.02∗ 18.91±0.01 15.37±0.01 13.49±0.01 13.47±0.01 14.03±0.02∗ 14.66±0.01 16.49±0.01 14.50±0.01 15.36±0.01 15.82±0.01 12.68±0.01∗ 11.33±0.08∗ 14.94±0.01 11.95±0.02∗ 14.17±0.02 13.86±0.02 10.61±0.06∗ 14.70±0.06 13.47±0.02∗ 13.65±0.01 13.16±0.01 12.08±0.01∗ 16.10±0.01 16.49±0.02 13.45±0.02∗ 13.60±0.01∗ 14.31±0.01 12.38±0.01∗ 16.51±0.01 14.04±0.02 12.57±0.01 12.42±0.02 12.56±0.02∗ 13.21±0.01 15.36±0.05 13.85±0.00 13.62±0.02 14.01±0.01 12.17±0.02 S 14.12±0.01 11.50±0.02 13.36±0.01 13.15±0.01 10.47±0.43 14.06±0.47 12.71±0.44 12.59±0.41 12.53±0.43 11.51±0.43 15.00±0.44 15.77±0.02 13.02±0.46 12.94±0.46 13.54±0.46 11.48±0.42 15.44±0.44 13.52±0.44 12.38±0.47 12.07±0.45 11.66±0.43 12.66±0.44 14.95±0.48 13.68±0.01 12.97±0.47 13.16±0.45 13.23±0.09 12.11±0.09 17.00±0.10 13.49±0.09 16.45±0.12 15.58±0.09 11.28±0.10 15.65±0.09 15.41±0.09 15.71±0.09 14.44±0.09 12.96±0.10 18.42±0.11 18.12±0.10 14.60±0.09 15.01±0.09 15.89±0.11 12.69±0.09 19.24±0.14 15.59±0.09 13.09±0.09 13.51±0.09 NO 14.40±0.09 16.49±0.10 14.62±0.09 15.57±0.09 15.25±0.09 13.85±0.13 12.34±0.13 17.35±0.13 13.43±0.14 16.61±0.13 15.90±0.18 11.57±0.13 16.96±0.13 15.75±0.13 16.23±0.13 14.58±0.13 13.39±0.13 18.97±0.17 18.57±0.14 15.01±0.13 15.69±0.13 16.25±0.13 13.47±0.13 19.72±0.22 16.11±0.13 13.04±0.13 13.74±0.13 NO 15.09±0.13 16.49±0.13 14.57±0.13 15.78±0.13 16.29±0.13 m856 NO NO 14.84±0.09 12.19±0.09 14.40±0.09 15.16±0.12 10.80±0.09 14.61±0.09 13.67±0.09 13.74±0.09 12.98±0.09 12.57±0.09 16.23±0.09 NO 13.42±0.09 13.98±0.09 14.41±0.09 12.27±0.09 16.76±0.09 14.02±0.09 12.69±0.09 12.54±0.09 NO m914 NO NO 14.43±0.08 12.01±0.08 14.01±0.09 14.47±0.08 11.05±0.15 14.53±0.08 13.15±0.08 13.07±0.08 12.78±0.08 12.50±0.08 15.60±0.08 NO 13.23±0.07 13.61±0.08 14.13±0.08 12.14±0.08 16.03±0.08 13.84±0.08 12.77±0.08 12.47±0.08 NO 13.25±0.09 15.54±0.09 13.03±0.08 15.43±0.08 NO NO 13.83±0.09 14.40±0.09 13.51±0.08 13.65±0.08 Main Ref. Note b b a b b a a a a a a a f,l m a a b a f,l e e e a a i i i a ⋆ ✤ ⋆ ✤ ⋆ U U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U ⋆ U • U NEW U U ⋆ ✤ ⋆ ✤ ⋆ U ⋆ U • U • ✤ • ✤ • ✤ ⋆ U ⋆ U • D • D • U ⋆ U Main references: a) Hughes & Hartigan (1992); b) Hartigan (1993); c) Alcal´a et al. (1995); d) Covino et al. (1997); e)Alcal´a et al. (2000); f) Vuong et al. (2001); g) Persi et al. (2003); h) Barrado y Navascu`es & Jayawardhana (2004); i) Young et al. (2005); j) L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005); k) Alcal´a et al. (2006); l) Allers et al. (2006); m) This work. Notes: – ⋆ = Confirmed member – • = Previously known candidate – U= Object recovered by our selection criteria NEW = Member candidate firstly identified in this work – U – D= Object rejected on the basis of our selection criteria – ✰ = Veiled object – ✪ = Embedded object – ✤ = Component of a visual binary or multiple system – S = Saturated object – ND = Object not detected – NO = Object not observed 4 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud Fig. 14. IC vs. (R − I)C and (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagrams for the PMS populations in Taurus and IC348. The isochrones, shifted by the corresponding distance modulus, are as in Fig. 9. The selection limits in the (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagrams are as in Fig. 10. L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 5 Appendix A: Flux at z = 0 In order to derive the flux at zero magnitude in the z band we used the following procedure: 1. The spectrophotometry of SA 98 653 is available from Guti`errez Moreno et al. (1988) in the form of monochro- matic instrumental magnitudes, covering a wavelength range from 3200 to 8000 Å, in steps of 40 Å for λ ≤ 5400 Å and 80 Å for λ > 5400Å. Since the z band is cen- tered at 9648 Å (FWHM=616 Å), we need the spectropho- tometry in a wider wavelength range. We have thus ex- trapolated the SED of SA 98 653, up to 16000 Å, by us- ing the Kurucz grid of stellar atmosphere models (Kurucz 1979) in the following way. We first dereddened the SED of SA 98 653 using the canonical absorption-to-reddening ratio RV=3.2, as suggested by Chen et al. (2001) for the SA 98 field. Assuming that SA 98 653 is a main sequence star, as indicated by its spectrophotometry and broad-band photometric indexes, we derived its distance by comparing its observed V magnitude with the expected absolute visual magnitude (MV = 0.7, Gray 1992) for an A0-type main se- quence star. Assuming an error of two spectral sub-classes on SA 98 653 spectral type, we constrained its distance be- tween 300 and 450 pc, i.e. 0.30 mag< AV <0.45 mag. Note that the extinction of the nearby star SA 98-667 (spectral type B9V) is AV=0.33 calculated from its Hipparcos par- allax (Chen et al. 2001), which is consistent with the range of values allowed for SA 98 653. The interstellar extinc- tion coefficients at each wavelength were derived by using the extinction curve by Cardelli et al. (1989). We then per- formed a two-parameters least-square fit to the observed spectrophotometry of SA 98 653 by taking as free parame- ters the extinction (in the range 0.30 mag< AV <0.45 mag in steps of 0.01 mag) and the effective temperature of the model spectrum. Both the Kurucz models and the dered- dened SED of SA 98 653 were normalised to the flux at 5556 Å. A minimum χ2 for a model with Teff = 11000 K, log g=4 and AV=0.33 was derived (Fig. A.1). We then used this synthetic spectrum reddened with AV=0.33 to extrapo- late the spectrophotometry of SA 98 653 in the near-IR. 2. The absolute Earth flux at 5556 Å of a star with magnitude V ∗ calibrated with Vega, the primary photometric standard, is given by (Gray 1992): log(F ∗ 5556) = −0.400 · V ∗ − 8.451 (A.1) in units of erg · cm−2 · s−1 · Å−1. When this expression is used for stars whose effective tem- perature is different from Vega (Teff = 9790 K), as in the case of SA 98 653, a small systematic error is introduced because the effective wavelength of the V band is 5480 Å, i.e. 76 Å shorter than the reference wavelength (5556 Å). An adequate correction for this is given by the following colour term (Gray 1992): log F ∗ F ∗ 5556 5480! = −0.006 + 0.018 · (B − V)∗ (A.2) Fig. A.1. Observed (dots) and dereddened (open triangles) spectral energy distribution of SA 98 653 normalised to the flux at 5556 Å. The best fitting model by Kurucz (1979) is over- plotted (continuous line). Considering the dereddened visual magnitude of SA 98 653 and its intrinsic (B − V), and applying Eq. A.2 and Eq. A.1 respectively, we obtain: Vcorr S A 98 653 = 9.24 and log[F5556 S A 98 653] = −12.1465 We now can calculate the flux of SA 98 653 at any wave- length with respect to the flux at 5556 Å as: F synt S A 98 653(λ) = F5556 S A 98 653 · 10−0.4·magsynt S A 98 653(λ) (A.3) where magsynt S A 98 653 is the synthetic magnitude of SA 98 653 at each wavelength normalised to the magnitude at 5556 Å, determined in the previous step. 3. We finally determined the synthetic flux of SA 98 653 in the z band by integrating its synthetic spectrum F synt S A 98 653(λ) in the z filter transmission curve Tλ, i.e. the product of the de- tector quantum efficiency and the filter transmission curve: Fz S A 98 653 = 1 Az ·Z λ2 λ1 F synt S A 98 653(λ) · Tλ · dλ (A.4) where: We obtained: Az = Z λ2 λ1 Tλ · dλ (A.5) S A 98 653 = 1.62 · 10−13 Fz erg · cm−2 · s−1 · Å−1 Fz S A 98 653 is the flux in the z filter of an A0 type star with visual magnitude V = 9.539 and z = IC = 9.522. What we need, in order to obtain an absolute flux calibration for the 6 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud z band, is the flux of an A0-type star with V = 0 and z = 0 (Fz A0V). Since SA 98 653 is an A0-type star and we have defined its intrinsic colour as (IC − z) = 0, we have: Thus, we derive Fz zS A 98 653 A0V as: def = IS A 98 653 = 9.522 (A.6) Fz A0V = Fz S A 98 653 · 10(0.4·zS A 98 653) (A.7) By considering the uncertainties on magnitude and inter- stellar extinction measurements, we obtained: A0V = (8.4 ± 0.1) · 10−10 erg cm−2s−1Å−1 Fz = (2608 ± 31) Jy A slightly smaller absolute flux calibration constant for the WFI z band has been estimated by F. Com´eron (private com- munication) using the absolute flux calibration of Vega ob- tained by Bohlin & Gilliland (2004) with the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS). Using these data we derive a value of 7.2 · 10−10 erg · cm−2 · s−1 · Å−1. However, for the sake of homogeneity, we prefer to use the value we derive above. Appendix B: Isochrones In order to transform the colours and magnitudes of the isochrones reported by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) into the WFI-Cousins system we determined first the WFI synthetic magnitudes, m∆λ: m∆λ = −2.5 · log10( f∆λ) + C∆λ (B.1) where C∆λ is the absolute calibration constant of the pho- tometric system, tied to the Earth flux of an A0-type star with magnitude V = 0 (see Tab. 5), and f∆λ is the observed flux. In order to compute the expected flux of a PMS star or a young BD in the pass-band ∆λ of a given filter we proceeded as follows. We first determined the transmission curve, Tλ, i.e. the product of the detector quantum efficiency and the given filter transmission curve7. We then computed: f∆λ = 1 A∆λ ·Z λ2 λ1 Fλ · Tλ · dλ (B.2) where A∆λ = Z λ2 λ1 Tλ · dλ (B.3) and Fλ is the absolute flux of a given PMS star or BD. For this purpose we used the synthetic low-resolution spectra for low-mass stars by Hauschildt et al. (1999) calculated with their NextGen model-atmosphere code. For simulating very cool ob- jects (i.e. Teff <3000 K) we used the StarDusty and BD-Dusty atmosphere models by Allard et al. (2000), which include dust opacity. 7 Available at: http://www.ls.eso.org/lasilla/sciops/2p2/E2p2M/WFI/ filters. Fig. B.1. The R, I, z (upper panel), Hα7, Hα12 (central panel), 856 and 914 nm (lower panel) WFI+ESO2.2m transmis- sion bands. Examples of two normalised NextGen spectra (Hauschildt et al. 1999) with Teff =2500 K and Teff =6000 K are over-plotted. Fig. B.2. The Cousins colours as a function of the WFI in- strumental colours for the standard stars in the Landolt's field SA 98. The continuous lines display the best fit of the data while the dashed lines have slope equal to 1 (i.e. no correction). L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 7 As an example of our procedure we show in Fig. B.1 (upper panel) two model spectra and the R, I and z WFI+ESO2.2m transmission curves over-plotted. However, the flux f∆λ that we obtained in this way is the one at the surface of the star. The observed flux at any distance (d) is given by: d !2 f∆λ(d) = f∆λ · R⋆ (B.4) where R⋆ is the object radius. The values for R⋆ can be computed from theoretical PMS evolutionary tracks, which in our case are those by Baraffe et al. (1998) for low-mass stars and those by Chabrier et al. (2000) for sub-stellar objects (i.e. M. 0.1M⊙). Finally, setting d=10 pc and using Eq. B.1, one can derive the absolute magnitudes for a given Teff, age and R⋆ and hence, determine the isochrones in the CMDs. Note that, consistently with the RIz photometric calibra- tion of the sources in Cha II, the absolute calibration constants used in Eq. B.1 are those of the WFI-Cousins photometric sys- tem (see Tab. 5). However, a non-negligible difference between the I-WFI and the I-Cousins pass-bands arises from the fact that the red cut-off of the I-WFI filter is defined by the CCD response and it is centered at a redder wavelength (0.85µm) with respect to the standard Cousins I filter (0.79µm). In or- der to take into account this difference in the determination of the theoretical isochrones, we have exploited the relations be- tween the WFI-Cousins (R − I)C and (IC − z) standard colours and the WFI instrumental colours for the standard stars in the Landolt's fields. By a least-square linear fitting (Fig. B.2), we derive the coefficients which allow us to correct the colours of the computed isochrones: (R − I)synt = 0.75 · (R − I)instr (I − z)synt = 1.10 · (I − z)instr (B.5) (B.6) In this way we were able to report in the WFI-Cousins photometric system the isochrones originally calculated by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) in the Cousins system of Bessel (Bessel 1990). This allows us to use the isochrones in a photometrically homogeneous way. In Fig. B.3 the 1, 5 and 10 Myr isochrones by Chabrier et al. (2000) are compared with those derived by us in the WFI- Cousins photometric system. Note the large difference, in par- ticular for the coolest objects, i.e. (R − I)C >1.7, where the use of the isochrones in the Bessel-Cousins system would have produced many spurious member candidates. In order to check our procedure, we used the standard filters of Bessel (1990) and we were successful in reproducing the isochrones presented by Chabrier et al. (2000) (see the smaller panel in Fig. B.3). Appendix C: Comments on individual objects IRAS 12416-7703, IRAS 12448-7650, IRAS F12488- 7658,IRAS12556-7731,IRAS12589-7646 These objects were selected as member candidates of Cha II by Young et al. (2005) on the basis of MIPS@Spitzer observa- Fig. B.3. Theoretical isochrones by Baraffe et al. (1998) and Chabrier et al. (2000) for the Cousins photometric system of Bessel (continuous line) and for the WFI-Cousins system (dashed lines, this work). In the smaller panel the 5 Myr isochrone by Chabrier et al. (2000) (continuous line) is com- pared with that reproduced by our algorithm when using the same Bessel filters (dashed line). tions. IRAS F12488-7658/C 13 was also previously proposed as a young object by (Vuong et al. 2001). We cannot conclude whether our selection criteria are satisfied for these objects be- cause they are saturated in at least one of the three broad-bands RIz. However, their (Hα12 − Hα7) indices suggest Hα emission (see Tab. 7) at ∼2σ level and their location on the (J − H) vs. (H − K) diagram is consistent with the PMS stars locus (see Sec. 4 and Fig. 10). ChaII304,ChaII305,ChaII376 the (2005) detected only Hα emitter by ChaII 376 was L´opez Mart´ı et al. in their WFI pointing. They also proposed that their candidates ChaII 304 and ChaII 305 are two low-mass BDs or planetary-mass objects close to the Deuterium burning limit. These two objects, however, do not satisfy our selection criteria. The early classification of these objects as possible Cha II members by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005), though based on WFI images taken with the same set of filters as in our survey, is probably not accurate because the isochrones in the Cousins system of Bessel (Chabrier et al. 2000) used for the selection are inadequate for the WFI- Cousins photometric system (see Appendix B). From their dereddened (m856 − m914) colour index we estimate an effec- tive temperature of 2800 K and 3000 K for ChaII 304 and ChaII 305, respectively. Assuming these temperature values, we find that the location of the two objects on the HR diagram would be inconsistent with membership to Cha II. We found that the optical colours of ChaII 376 are inconsistent with membership, as also asserted by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005), and we do not detect any significant Hα emission for this object. Moreover, its R-band magnitude (16.31 mag) is remarkably 8 L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud brighter than the one reported by L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005) (18.38 mag). Since the magnitude of this object in the other bands are in fair agreement with ours, we think that the R-band magnitude reported in L´opez Mart´ı et al. (2005) may be incorrect. This may explain why ChaII 376 was selected as their only Hα emitter. of a PMS star with strong IR excess (see also Young et al. 2005). Previous authors (Allers et al. 2006; Vuong et al. 2001) report an extinction value significantly higher than what we de- termine from the Cambr´esy (1999) extinction map. Given the strong IR excess, our procedure for the temperature estimate provides unreliable results. Therefore, it may be a deeply em- bedded source or a highly reddened PMS star. Sz46 This is one of the 19 PMS stars originally identified by Schwartz (1977) in Cha II. Subsequent photometric observa- tions by Hughes & Hartigan (1992) showed that the object is a visual triple system. The Hα emission star originally discov- ered by Schwartz (1977), Sz 46N, has two companions, namely Sz 46NW and Sz 46S; both are bluer than Sz 46N and are prob- ably unrelated to it (Hughes & Hartigan 1992). Based on our analysis, both Sz 46NW and Sz 46S have optical colours in- consistent with membership to the Cha II cloud, their tempera- ture is well above 4000 K according to their (m856 −m914) index and the (Hα12 − Hα7) colour suggests no Hα emission. Thus, Sz 46NW and Sz 46S are most probably not PMS stars and hence, not physically associated with Sz 46N. IRAS12533-7632,IRASF13052-7653 These objects were detected as ROSAT X-rays sources (Alcal´a et al. 2000) and proposed as possible members of Cha II by different authors (Larson et al. 1998; Prusti et al. 1992; Young et al. 2005). IRAS 12533-7632 appears on our images as a point-like object associated with a nebulosity, consistently with what re- ported in Prusti et al. (1992). However, it was not detected in our z and Hα images; its RI magnitudes and 2MASS near-IR colours are inconsistent with those expected for a PMS star. In Young et al. (2005) IRAS F13052-7653 is reported as CHIIXR 60 which is a non-existent identifier. This must be a typo because IRAS F13052-7653 is identified with the ROSAT source CHIIXR 37 (Alcal´a et al. 2000). The opti- cal counterpart of IRAS F13052-7653 appears as a visual triple system (Larson et al. 1998) whose components are des- ignated as IRAS F13052-7653N, IRAS F13052-7653NW and IRAS F13052-7653S in Tab. 7. None of the three compo- nents was recovered by our selection criteria, most likely be- cause their colours, both in optical and and near-IR, may be contaminated. However, two of them, namely IRAS F13052- 7653N and IRAS F13052-7653NW, fall just below the 10 Myr isochrone and their (Hα12 − Hα7) indices suggest Hα emission above 3σ level (see Tab. 7); moreover, their near- IR colours are also consistent with those expected for PMS stars. IRAS F13052-7653S is not detected in 2MASS; its opti- cal colours are inconsistent with membership to Cha II and its Hα colour does not indicate significant emission. IRASF12571-7657 This object was detected in X-rays with ROSAT (Alcal´a et al. 2000). Its optical and near IR colours are consistent with those C62,C66 These sources have been firstly detected by DENIS and proposed as young stellar object candidates of Cha II by Vuong et al. (2001) based on their IR colours and, more re- cently, by Young et al. (2005) and Allers et al. (2006) on the basis of IRAC@Spitzer and MIPS@Spitzer observations re- spectively. From the effective temperature and AV estimates provided in Tab. 6, and calculating their luminosities as ex- plained in Sec. 5, we estimate a mass of 0.08 and 0.06 M⊙ for C 62 and C 66, respectively. The age we derive for both objects using the Baraffe et al. (1998) tracks is around 2 Myr. These estimates of mass and age are fairly consistent with those derived by Allers et al. (2006). From their Hα index we also notice strong line emission (∼3σ level) in both objects (see Tab. 6). ISO-CHAII29 This source has been detected in the near and mid-IR by Persi et al. (2003), but it was first revealed as an X-ray emit- ting source, CHIIXR3, by Alcal´a et al. (2000). The association of this object with IRAS 12551-7657 is still unclear. Based on these evidences and the effective temperature estimated by us (Tab. 6), ISO-CHA II 29 is proposed to be a PMS star in Cha II with a mass of about 1 M⊙. ISO-CHAII73,ISO-CHAII98,ISO-CHAII110 None of these sources, originally identified by Persi et al. (2003), were selected with MIPS@Spitzer by Young et al. (2005). These sources do not satisfy our criteria and their (Hα12 − Hα7) index suggests no emission in Hα. In our optical images ISO-CHA II 98 appears as a visual binary, but the colours and magnitudes of its components are inconsistent with our selection criteria. We stress that ISO- CHA II 98 has been wrongly identified in SIMBAD with the ROSAT X-ray source CHIIXR 24 by Alcal´a et al. (2000). The optical spectrum of CHIIXR 24 shows the Li I 6708Å absorp- tion line, but the Hα line is well in absorption (Alcal´a et al. 2000). Being classified as a G7-type star, CHIIXR 24 is most likely a field object unrelated to Cha II. 2MASS13102531-7729085, 2MASS13110329- 7653330,2MASS13125238-7739182 These sources are reported in the list of candidates by Young et al. (2005). While 2MASS 13102531-7729085 and 2MASS 13110329-7653330 are rejected by our selection crite- L. Spezzi et al.: A WFI survey in the Chamaeleon II dark cloud 9 ria, 2MASS 13125238-7739182 is selected as a PMS star can- didate. The former two sources have Hα indices indicating no Hα emission, while the Hα index of the latter suggests Hα in emission at 1σ level. Thus, it is likely that 2MASS 13102531- 7729085 and 2MASS 13110329-7653330 are field stars unre- lated to Cha II.
astro-ph/0001291	1	0001	2000-01-17T13:00:52	CADIS deep star counts: Galactic structure and the stellar luminosity function	[ "astro-ph" ]	In this paper we present the first results of deep star counts carried out within the Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey, CADIS (Meisenheimer 1998). Although CADIS was designed as an extragalactic survey, it also attempts to identify the stars in the fields in order to avoid confusion with quasars and compact galaxies. We have identified a sample of about 300 faint stars 15.5< R < 23), which are well suited to study the structure of the Galaxy. The stars lie in two fields, hereafter 16h and 9h field, respectively. The stars have been separated from galaxies by a classification scheme based on photometric spectra and morphological criteria. Distances were derived by photometric parallaxes. We are able to find stars up to distances of approximately 25 kpc above the Galactic plane. The vertical density distribution of the stars shows the contribution of the thin disk, the stellar halo and the ``thick disk'' of the Galaxy. We give quantitative descriptions of the components in terms of exponential disks and a de Vaucouleurs spheroid. For the disk stars we derive the luminosity function. It is equal within the errors to the local luminosity function and continues to rise out to at least M_V = 13. Implications for the mass function are briefly discussed.	astro-ph	astro-ph	A&A manuscript no. (will be inserted by hand later) Your thesaurus codes are: 04(10.19.3; 08.12.3) ASTRONOMY ASTROPHYSICS AND CADIS deep star counts: Galactic structure and the stellar luminosity function S. Phleps1, K. Meisenheimer1, B. Fuchs2, and C.Wolf1 1 Max-Planck-Institut fur Astronomie, Konigstuhl 17, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany 2 Astronomisches Rechen-Institut, Monchhofstr. 12-14, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany Received 2. 6. 1999 / Accepted 3. 12. 1999 Abstract. In this paper we present the first results of deep star counts carried out within the Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey, CADIS (Meisenheimer et al. 1998). Although CADIS was de- signed as an extragalactic survey, it also attempts to identify the stars in the fields in order to avoid confusion with quasars and compact galaxies. We have identified a sample of about 300 faint stars (15.5 <∼ R <∼ 23), which are well suited to study the structure of the Galaxy. The stars lie in two fields with central coordi- nates α2000 = 16h24m32.s3, δ2000 = 55◦44′32′′ (Galactic coordinates: l = 85◦, b = 45◦) and α2000 = 9h13m47.s5, δ2000 = 46◦14′20′′ (l = 175◦, b = 45◦) (hereafter 16h and 9h field, respectively. The stars have been separated from galaxies by a classification scheme based on photometric spectra and morphological criteria. Distances were derived by photometric parallaxes. We are able to find stars up to distances of ≈ 25 kpc above the Galactic plane. The vertical density distribution of the stars shows the contribution of the thin disk, the stellar halo and the "thick disk" of the Galaxy. We give quantitative de- scriptions of the components in terms of exponential disks and a de Vaucouleurs spheroid. For the disk stars we derive the lu- minosity function. It is equal within the errors to the local lu- minosity function and continues to rise out to at least MV = 13. Implications for the mass function are briefly discussed. Key words: Galaxy: structure -- stars: luminosity function, mass function 1. Introduction The stellar structure of the Galaxy has been studied by many groups using a variety of methods, such as metallicity-age determinations or studies of the kinematics of nearby halo and disk stars (for a review see Norris 1998). Other discussions can be found in Fuchs & Jahreiss (1998), or Fuhrmann (1998). The method predominantly used to study Galactic strucure is the method of starcounts. This provides a measurement of the density distribution of the stellar component of the Galaxy (Gilmore & Reid 1983; Reid et al. 1996; Reid et al. 1997; Send offprint requests to: S.Phleps ([email protected]) Gould et al. 1998). In the so called standard model (Bahcall & Soneira 1980) the vertical structure of the disk follows an exponential law (ρ ∼ e−z/hz ) with scaleheight hz. As Gilmore & Reid (1983) showed, the data can be fitted much better by a superposition of two exponentials. Whether or not this deviation from the single exponential is due to a distinct population of stars is not clear, although this is suggested by the different kinematics and lower metallicities (Freeman 1992). We will call the deviation "thick disk", regardless of its unknown physical origin. Although the existence of the "thick disk" component seems well established now (Norris 1998), the proper values for the scaleheights and lengths are not exactly determined yet, since in most studies the distance of observable stars has been limited to a few kpc above the Galactic plane. Another topic of debate has been whether the stellar luminosity function (hereafter SLF) of main sequence stars in the disk declines beyond MV = 12mag. Most photometric studies find a down-turn of the slope of the SLF at MV = 12mag (Stobie et al. 1989; Kroupa 1995; Gould et al. 1998), whereas local observations of stars in the solar neighbourhood indicate a flat continuation to fainter magnitudes (Wielen et al. 1983; Jahreiss & Wielen 1997a). Therefore, it is worthwhile to derive the SLF from the CADIS starcounts. the Calar Alto Deep The paper is structured as follows: Imaging Survey is outlined in Sect. 2. Sect. 3 describes the preparation of the stellar data, Sect. 4 deals with the density distribution of the stars, Sect. 5 with the SLF and its implica- tions for the mass function. Sect. 6 gives a brief summary and an outlook on future prospects. 2. The Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey The Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey combines an emission line survey carried out with an imaging Fabry-Perot interfer- ometer with a deep multicolour survey using three broad-band optical to NIR filters and up to eighteen medium-band filters when fully completed. The combination of different observing strategies facilitates not only the detection of emission line objects but also to derive photometric spectra of all objects 2 S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts Table 1. Exposure times for the three broadband filters used for the analysis of the stellar component in in the two CADIS fields. Numbers shown in italics indicate, that the exposures were actually obtained at the 3.5 m telescope and scaled to the 2.2 m telescope. Filter texp,16h texp,9h BC RC I815 6200 5300 30700 10000 2800 1750 in the fields without performing time consuming slit spec- troscopy. Details of the survey and its calibration will be given in Meisenheimer et al. (in preparation). All observations were performed on Calar Alto, Spain, in the optical wavelength region with the focal reducers CAFOS (Calar Alto Faint Object Spectrograph) at the 2.2 m telescope and MOSCA (Multi Object Spectrograph for Calar Alto) at the 3.5 m telescope, and with the Omega Prime camera for the NIR observations. As a byproduct of the survey we obtain a lot of multi-color data about faint stars in the Galaxy. Although for the ob- ject classification (see below) exposures in two broadband filters and seven medium-band filters (in the case of the 9 h field eight medium-band filters) are used, the present analysis of the stellar component of CADIS is based only on exposures in three filters, RC (central wavelength/width λc/∆λ = 649 nm/170 nm), BC (λc = 461 nm/100 nm) and I815 (λc = 815 nm/32 nm). Exposure times converted to the 2.2 m telescope are given in Table 1. The nine CADIS fields measure ≈ 1/30 ⊓⊔◦ each and are located at high Galactic latitude to avoid dust absorption and reddening. In all fields the total flux on the IRAS 100 µm maps is less than 2 MJy/sr which corresponds to EB−V < 0.07, so we do not have to apply any color corrections. A second selection criterium for the fields was that there should be no star brighter than ≈ 16mag in the CADIS R band. In fact the brightest star in the two fields under consideration has an R magnitude of 15.42mag. 2.1. Object detection and classification Objects are identified on each of the deep images (super- position of 5 to 15 individual exposures) using the Source Extractor software SExtractor (Bertin & Arnouts 1996), and the resulting lists merged into a master catalogue. Photometry is done using the program Evaluate, which has been developed by Meisenheimer & Roser (1986). Variations in seeing in between individual exposures are taken into account, in order to get accurate colors. For photometric calibration we use a system of "tertiary" standard stars in the CADIS fields, which are calibrated with secondary standard stars (Oke 1990; Walsh 1995) in photometric nights. From the locus of the stars in the 8-dimensional color space we conclude that the relative calibration between each pair of wavebands is better than 3 % for all objects with R = 22. Since one of the major goals of the survey is the classification of every object found in all CADIS fields (≈ 80 000 to 100 000 in total), a classification scheme was developed which is based on template spectral energy distributions (see Wolf 1998). The observed colors of every object are compared with a color library of known objects, whose colors are obtained from synthetic photometry performed on our CADIS filterset. The input library for stellar spectra was the Gunn & Stryker (1983) catalogue. For each object the probability to belong to a certain object class (stars -- quasars -- galaxies) is computed. Objects classified as stars have stellar colors with a likelihood of more than 75%, and images the profile of which does not deviate significantely from that of well defined stars. Details about the performance and reliability of the classifica- tion are given in Wolf et al. 1999, and Wolf (in preparation). With the current filter set and exposure times the classification is reliable down to a limit of R ≃ 23mag. This was checked by spectroscopic follow-up observations of 245 arbitrarily chosen objects (55 stars, 153 galaxies and 20 quasars) with R < 23mag. One galaxy has been classified as a star by it's colors, two quasars as galaxies and two galaxies as quasars. The star counts are not significantly affected by the misclas- sifications down to R = 23mag. Thus we restrict our present analysis to stars with R ≤ 23mag. 3. Preparation of the stellar data 3.1. Photometric parallaxes To derive distances of the stars from the distance modulus mR − MR, it is essential to know the absolute magnitudes of the stars, MR. In principle absolute magnitudes of main sequence stars can be obtained from a color-magnitude diagramm. This main se- quence approximation is valid for all stars in our sample since we can be sure that it is free from contamination of any non- main sequence stars, as the faint magnitude intervall we ob- serve (16 ≤ R ≤ 23) does not allow the detection of a giant star. We took a mean MVJ versus (B − V )J relation from Lang (1992). A complication arises, because there is no V filter included in our filter set. Thus we have to convert MV and (B − V )J into our filter system, in order to derive the absolute magnitudes from mean main sequence fit in MR versus (b− r), where the CADIS color is defined by: F γ R F γ B . k is the flux outside the atmosphere in units of Photons (b − r) = 2.5 log Here F γ m−2 s−1 nm−1 in the CADIS filter k. In order to convert (b − r) into the Johnson (B − V )J we per- formed synthetic photometry on the Gunn-Stryker stars (Wolf, priv. comm.). (1) S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts 3 b − r can be calibrated to the Johnson-Cousins system (the CADIS RC is very close to the Cousins R) by using Vega as a zero point: (B − R)C = (b − r) + 2.5 log = (b − r) + 0.725 . F γ F γ Vega(λ = 440nm) Vega(λ = 648nm) (2) The absolute magnitude MRC is then given by (3) MRC = MVJ − (VJ − RC ) , with (VJ − RC ) = (BC − RC ) − (B − V )J , where we assume BJ = BC (see Huang et al., in preparation). With the above conversions, the main sequence (MR vs (b−r)) can be approximated by a fourth order polynomial in the range −1 ≤ (b − r) ≤ 1.8: MR = c0 + c1 (b − r) + c2 (b − r)2 (4) + c3 (b − r)3 + c4 (b − r)4, the parameters of which are: sequence relation, but shifted towards fainter magnitudes by MR = 0.75mag (see Fig. 1). This value is the mean devia- tion from the mean main sequence defined by the CNS 4 stars (Jahreiss & Wielen 1997b) of a subsample of 10 halo stars, for which absolute R magnitudes were available (Jahreiss, priv. com.).1 The spread in a two color diagram (b − r) versus (r − i) (that is the CADIS color between RC and I815 analog to Eq. (1)) becomes significant at (b − r) ≈ 1.0, see Fig. 2. The maxi- mal photometric error for the very faint stars is 0.15mag. Here metallicity effects will distort the relation between the mea- sured (b − r) colors and the spectral type (temperature) and thus lead to wrong absolute magnitudes, so we have to correct for metallicity in order to avoid errors in the photometric par- allaxes. The RC filter is strongly affected by metallicity effects like c0 = 4.01236 c1 = 4.12575 c3 = 0.762053 c4 = 0.341384 , c2 = −1.89076 as shown in Fig. 1. One further complication arises due to the fact that the mean Fig. 2. The b − r colors are projected along the "isophotes" onto the mean main sequence track (solid line). For some of the very red stars (b− r > 1.8), which are subject to the largest corrections, photometric errors are plotted. Fig. 1. The mean main sequence from Lang (1992), converted to CADIS color b − r and RC magnitude; the solid line is the fourth order polynomial (Eq. (4)). For the blue (b − r < 0.7) metal-poor stars the mean main sequence is shifted towards fainter magnitudes. main sequence relation is valid strictly only for stars with so- lar metallicities, whereas our sample may contain stars spread over a wide range of different metalicities. For the blue stars (b − r < 0.7), which are almost all halo stars (see Fig. 4), and therefore supposed to be metal-poor, we use the same main absorption bands of TiO2 and VO molecules in the stars' atmo- sphere, whereas the BC and the medium-band filter I815 (the wavelength of which was chosen in order to avoid absorption bands in cool stars) are not. So in a first approximation we can assume the "isophotes" of varying metallicity in a (b − r) ver- sus (r − i) two color diagram to be straight lines with a slope of −1, along of which we project the measured colors with (b − r) ≥ 1.0 onto the mean main sequence track which in the interval 1.0 ≤ (b − r) ≤ 1.8 is defined by (r − i) = 0.39 (b − r)4 corr − 0.36 (b − r)3 corr + 0.09 (b − r) + 0.06 . (5) This projection implies that stars with (b − r)corr >∼ 1.8 cannot exist in Fig. 3, which shows the spatial distribution of metal- 1 Note that this artificial separation may well lead to wrong absolute magnitudes for individual stars (e.g. a disk star with r < 1 kpc but b − r < 0.7), but should be correct on average. 4 S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts Fig. 3. Spatial distribution of metallicity corrected (b − r)corr. The solid line represents the distance dependent upper color limit at R = 23mag, the dotted line is the lower limit due to the selection criterium of the fields (no star brighter than R ≈ 15.5). Since the metal-poor halo stars are intrinsically fainter, the color limits are shifted accordingly. The horizontal line denotes the cut between halo and disk stars, the dashed -- dotted line indicates the cutoff at (b − r)corr = 1.8 due to the metallicity correction. The different symbols refer to the different fields: squares -- 16h field, triangles -- 9h field. licity corrected (b − r)corr colors (the limit is indicated by the dashed -- dotted line). Both the upper and lower magnitude lim- its lead to selection effects which have to be taken into account. As one can see in Fig. 3 there is an bimodality of the observed color distribution. The accumulation of red stars in the upper left consists mainly of disk stars, and is separated by a void from the blue stars, which predominantly belong to the halo. Thus a crude disk-halo separation can be drawn by a color cut -- we take stars with (b − r)corr < 0.7 to be halo, stars with (b − r)corr > 0.7 to be disk stars. In the following we will make use of this color cut to derive the distribution of the disk stars separately. In a second step, the distribution as a whole will be analysed. In Fig. 3 the cut is denoted by a dotted hori- zontal line. In the two fields we have analysed so far we find 95 halo and 178 disk stars, that is a factor of two more disk stars than pre- dicted by the standard model (Bahcall & Soneira 1980). This surplus of disk stars was already noted by Reid & Majewski (1993). Fig. 4 shows the distribution of the (b − r)corr in the two fields under consideration. 4. Density distribution of the stars 4.1. Completeness correction As expected, the detection limit of absolute magnitudes (col- ors) is distance dependent (see Fig. 3). Fig. 4. Distribution of (b− r)corr in the two fields, this bimodal distribution can be used to separate halo and disk stars by a color cut. We use the two-dimensional distribution of stars in the (b − r)corr vs log r diagram (Fig. 3) to correct for this incomplete- ness in the following way: First, we divide the distance in log- arithmic bins of 0.2 as indicated in Fig. 3 and count the stars up to the the upper color limit (b − r)lim (this is the distance dependent color (luminosity) limit, up to which stars can be de- S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts 5 The stars in our normalization sample are selected from the CNS4 by their absolute visual magnitudes, according to the distribution of absolute magnitudes of the CADIS disk stars (6.5 ≤ Mv ≤ 14.5). Fig. 5 shows the resulting density distribution of the disk stars in the two CADIS fields. The solid line represents a fit with a superposition of two exponentials, the dotted line is the fit for the thin disk component (the first seven data points). Obviously a single exponential is not a good description. It was suggested to fit the thin disk with a secans hyperbolicus -- the exponential is unphysical in that sense, that it is not con- tinuously differentiable at z = 0. A squared secans hyperboli- cus (which represents a self-gravitating isothermal disk) can be proved not to fit the data very well -- indicating that the stellar disk is in no way isothermal (the velocity dispersion depends on the spectral type). The fits for the three functions under consideration: ρexp(z) = n1 exp(−z/h1) + n2 exp(−z/h2) ρsech(z) = n3sech(−z/z0) + n4 exp(−z/h3) ρsech2 (z) = n5sech2(−z/ z0) + n6 exp(−z/h4) . are shown in Fig. 6, the corresponding parameters are given in Table 2. As the secans hyperbolicus is a sum of two exponentials (9) (10) (11) (7) sech(z/z0) = 2 exp(z/z0) + exp(−z/z0) , (12) z0 is not really a scaleheight, but has to be compared to h1 by multiplying it with arcsech 1 1 = z0 · 1.65745 (cf. Tab. 2). The errors of the scaleheights and corresponding parameters e ≈ 1.65745: h′ Table 2. Fit parameter for the three fit functions (8) Parameter 16h field 5.06·107 4.14 ·106 9h field 5.84 ·107 6.23 ·105 (280 ± 14)pc (1267 ± 74)pc (267 ± 9)pc (1296 ± 116)pc 4.54 ·107 9.86 ·106 (172 ± 12)pc (286 ± 20)pc (1478 ± 30)pc 4.62 ·107 2.78 ·106 5.19 ·107 1.02 ·106 (216 ± 8)pc (358 ± 13)pc (1132 ± 84)pc 5.4 ·107 1.37 ·106 (352 ± 26)pc (1158 ± 112)pc (360 ± 13)pc (1047 ± 71)pc n1 n2 h1 h2 n3 n4 z0 h′ 1 h3 n5 n6 z0 h4 tected. The metal-poor halo stars are intrinsically fainter (see paragraph 3)), thus the limits are shifted accordingly). The nearest bins (−0.8 ≤ log r ≤ −0.2) are assumed to be complete. For the incomplete bins we multiply iteratively with a factor given by the ratio of complete to incomplete number counts in the previous bin, where the limit for the uncorrected counts is defined by the bin currently under examination (j): N corr j = Nj j−1 (1 + Yi=1 ′′ N i N ′ i ) , (6) ′ is the number of where Nj is the number of stars in bin j, N stars in the previous bin (j − 1), up to the limit given by the bin ′′ is the number of stars from that limit up to the limit j, and N given by bin j − 1, see also appendix. With the poissonian errors σN = √N , σN ′ = √N ′, and σN ′′ = √N ′′ the error of the corrected number counts be- comes: σ2 N corr j = σ2 Nj j−1 + · j−1 Xi=1 Ym=1 m6=j i !2 + N i σ2 N ′′ ′′ N i N ′ j−1 Yi=1 1 +  i(cid:19)2 (cid:18) 1 i ! 1 + ′′ N i N ′ N ′ ′′ i N ′ i !2 σ2 N ′ i  For a detailed deduction see appendix. The completeness correction is done for each field separately. With the corrected number counts the density in the logarith- mic spaced volume bins (Vj = 1 j )) can than be calculated according to j+1 − r3 3 ω(r3 ρj = N corr j Vj = c · Nj Vj , For every logarithmic distance bin we use the mean height z above the Galactic plane < zj >= sin b· < r >, where < log r >= log rj + (log rj+1 − log ri)/2 = log ri + 0.1 ⇒< r >= 1.259ri. 4.2. Vertical density distribution We first study the density distribution of the disk stars by tak- ing only stars in the corresponding color interval into account. Although the color-cut at (b−r)corr = 0.7 is a rather crude sep- aration between disk and halo, we gain a clearer insight into the disk distribution since the contamination by halo stars is sup- pressed considerably. As the nearest stars in our fields have still distances of about 200 pc the normalization at z = 0 has to be established by other means: We take stars from the CNS4 (Jahreiss & Wielen 1997b), which are located in a sphere with radius 20 pc around the sun. z0 and z0 are estimated by changing their values until χ2 increases by 1. We find that at z = 0 the contribution of the thick disk component to the entire disk is 2 ± 4%. Our values for the scaleheights lie within the range given by different authors in the literature. The proposed values for the exponential scaleheights of the thin disk range between 200 6 S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts Fig. 6. A secans hyperbolicus (dotted line) or a squared secans hyperbolicus (dashed line) can be shown to fit the thin disk equally well like an exponential (solid line). The normalisation is given by data from the CNS4. call 1986): ρH (z, b, l) = ρ0 exp(cid:20)−10.093(cid:16) R R⊙(cid:17)1/4 R⊙(cid:17)7/8 (cid:16) R + 10.093(cid:21) exp(cid:20)−10.093(cid:16) R r⊙(cid:17)1/4 R⊙(cid:17)6/8 (cid:16) R · 1.25 · h1 − 0.08669/(R/R⊙)1/4i , R ≥ 0.03R⊙ + 10.093(cid:21) , R < 0.03R⊙ (13) ⊙ + z2 + z2 z tan2 b − 2R⊙ where R = (R2 tan b cos l)1/2, b and l are Galactic latidude and longitude, the distance of the sun from the Galactic center R⊙ = 8 kpc, R = (x2 + z2)1/2, ⊙ + d2 cos2 b − 2R⊙d cos b cos l)1/2, z = d sin b. The x = (R2 dot-dashed is the sum of both halo and disk distribution func- tion. The density of halo stars extrapolated to z = 0 is compared with the data from the CNS4 with an estimated error of ≈ 10%. The stars are discriminated against disk stars by their metallic- ities and kinematics (Fuchs & Jahreiss 1998). They are further selected according to the color cut of the CADIS halo stars ((b − r ≤ 0.7). Fig. 8 shows the distribution of all stars in the range z = 0 to z = 10 kpc, the fit for a single exponential disk, the deVau- couleurs law, the sum of both, and the sum of the thin plus thick disk fit and the deVaucouleurs law. It is obvious that between ≈ 1.5 kpc to 5.0 kpc the thick disk provides the predominant contribution to the overall distribution. Thus, the sum of thin disk and deVaucouleurs halo does not fit the distribution. If we assume the sun to be 8 kpc away from the Galactic cen- ter and the normalisation ρ0 to be fixed by the data from the CNS4, all parameters are completely determined. As can be Fig. 5. Vertical density distribution of the disk stars (b − r > 0.7) in the two fields, the normalisation (star) is given by data from the CNS4. The distribution shows clearly the contribu- tion of the thick disk component -- the solid line is a fit with a superposition of two exponentials, the dotted line is the single exponential fit for the thin disk component only. pc (Kent et al. 1991 ) and 325 pc (Bahcall & Soneira 1980). The parameters z0 and h4 we found in the 16 h field are equal within the errors to the values found by Gould et al (1997). 4.3. Density distribution in the halo Fig. 7 shows the density distribution of all stars in the two CADIS fields. The dotted line is the secans hyperbolicus + ex- ponential fit for the thin and thick disk components, the dashed line is a deVaucouleurs law. Although the space density corre- sponding to the r1/4 law in projection has no simple analytic form (Young 1976) it is possible to form expansions about the origin and the point at infinity. The latter expansion is valid for a large range of distances. An analytic approximation is (Bah- S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts 7 Fig. 8. Distribution of all stars in the range 0 ≤< z ≤ 10 kpc, the fit for a single exponential disk (dotted line) the deVau- couleurs law (short-dashed), the sum of both (dot-dashed), and the sum of the thin plus thick disk fit and the deVaucouleurs law (long-dashed). Fig. 9. An inverse power law (broken line) can also be fitted to the data - in comparison with the a de Vaucouleurs law (solid line), shown here for the CADIS 9h field. 5. The stellar luminosity function The knowledge of the distribution function enables us to calcu- late the SLF for the thin disk stars. We selected the stars with distances less than 1.5 kpc. Beyond this point the contribution by thick disk and halo stars becomes dominant. Although CADIS does not include a filter which is close to the Johnson-V, we calculate absolute visual magnitudes from the R magnitudes to make comparison with literature eas- ier. In the relevant magnitude intervall (5 ≤ MV ≤ 14, i.e −1 < (b − r) < 1.8) there holds a linear relation (see Sect. 3.1): MVJ = 1.058 · MRC . (15) Fig. 7. Density distribution perpendicular to the Galactic Plane, stars are data taken from the CNS4; the dotted line is the secans hyperbolicus plus exponential fit for the disk, the dashed line is a deVaucouleurs law and the dot-dashed the sum of both. seen in Fig. 7, the corresponding plots fit the distribution of the halo stars up to a distance of about 22 kpc above the Galactic plane. The de Vaucouleurs law is an empirical description of the density distributions of stars in ellipticals, bulges of spirals and galactic halos (de Vaucouleurs & Pence 1978) but it is equally justified to fit other distribution functions to the data: a smoothed power law fits the halo stars equally well (Fuchs & Jahreiss 1998; Gould et al. 1998), see e.g. Fig. 9. When apply- ing the power-law fit, we add a further free parameter which describes the flattening of the halo: ρH (z, b, l) = c + r2 r2 ⊙ + z2 z tan b cos l + z2 (c/a)2!α/2 , (14) ρ⊙ r2 c + r2 tan2b − 2r⊙ ⊙ with an arbitrarily chosen core radius of rc = 1 kpc. We find an axial ratio c/a of (0.63 ± 0.07), with an exponent α = (2.99 ± 0.13). 8 S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts We calculate an effective volume for every luminosity bin by integrating the distribution function along the line of sight, r, where the integration limits are given by the minimum between 1.5 kpc and the distance modulus derived for upper and lower limiting apparent magnitude: al. 1998). At this faint end both incompleteness and uncertainties of the exact location of the main sequence may introduce systematic errors which are hard to quantify. V eff max = ω Rmax ZRmin ν(r, b) r2 dr , (16) where Rmin = 100.2(16mag−MR)−2.0 , Rmax = min(1.5 kpc, 100.2(23mag−MR)−2.0) . The distribution function ν(r, b) = exp(−r sin b/h1) is normalised to unity at z = 0. The weighted mean of the SLFs of the two CADIS fields is shown in Fig. 10, in comparison with the SLF of the stars in- side a distance of 20 pc (Jahreiss & Wielen 1997a), which is based on HIPPARCOS parallaxes. As can be seen from Fig. (17) Fig. 10. The mean SLF of the two CADIS fields (solid line) and the local SLF (Jahreiss & Wielen 1997a). 10, the CADIS SLF is equal within the errors to the local SLF. Since the errors are dominated by Poissonian statistics, the er- ror bars are small at the faint end, and larger at the bright end, complementary to the local SLF. Thus the weighted mean of CADIS and local SLF which com- bines the large number of bright stars in the local sample with our superior sampling of faint stars (shown in Fig. 11) can be regarded as the most accurate determination of the SLF. The combined CADIS/local SLF keeps rising with constant slope to its limit at MV = 13. This is in pronounced contrast to previous determinations of the SLF based on faint star counts (Stobie et al. 1989; Kroupa 1995). The discrepancy is demonstrated in Fig. 11 where we compare the combined SLF with the most recent photometric SLF based on HST observations (Gould et Fig. 11. The weighted mean of CADIS and local SLF in com- parison with a photometric SLF which is based on HST obser- vations (Gould et al. 1998). 5.1. Implications for the mass function The stellar mass function (SMF) can in principle be inferred from the SLF by converting the MV magnitudes of the disk stars (r ≤ 1.5 kpc) into masses; this requires a mass-luminosity relation, for which we adopted the analytical fit taken from Henry et al. (1993, 1999). Their relation is valid for stellar masses from 0.08 M/M⊙ to 2.0 M/M⊙. If we count the stars in equally spaced mass intervals of 0.1 and divide the number counts in the jth interval by the maximum effective volume (see Eq. (16)), calculated for the corresponding luminosity, the SMF can be represented by a power law: . M⊙(cid:21)a Ψ(M/M⊙) ∝(cid:20) M From the data of the disk stars in the two CADIS fields we 0.42 for [0.2 < M/M⊙ < 1.1]. Its slope derived a = −1.28±0.68 is equal (within the errors) to the value proposed by Henry et al. (1993) (a = −1). (18) 6. Summary and future prospects Although the Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey is designed as an extragalactic survey, we obtain a substantial set of multicolor-data about faint stars in the Galaxy. With the cur- rent filter set and exposure times the classification is reliable down to MR = 23. S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts 9 As soon as better template spectra of stars with sub-solar metal- licities become available, the currently rough correction for metallicity effect can be replaced by a more accurate metal- licity dependent main sequence. With this much more accurate determination of photometric distances and an at least 4-fold increased statistics it should be possible to adress the following issues concerning the density and luminosity function of the stars in the Galaxy: -- the scalelength hr of the density distribution of stars in the disk. This can be done if one takes the longitude dependent radial decrease of the density into account, e.g. the scale- height measured in the CADIS 16h field (l ≈ 90◦) should be only very slightly affected by the radial density gradient, whereas the 9h field is suffering from a maximal radial de- crease in density, so one measures an effective scaleheight heff. Likely the star counts in the 18 h and 23 h field (at Galactic coordinates b = 30◦, l = 95◦, and b = −43◦, l = 90◦, respectively, are only very slightly affected by the radial density gradient, so it should be possible to measure the "true" scaleheights h1 and h2 for thin and thick disk component with high precision. From this, the counts in the 9h field and the 10 h field (b = 53◦, l = 150◦), we will deduce the scalelength ri = [1/heff − 1/h]−1. inverse power law with higher precision. -- the axial ratio of a flattened halo and the exponent of the -- a bulge -- halo separation. By analysing the star counts in all eight fields it will be possible to separate the contribution of the bulge from the halo distribution. -- the slope of the SLF with higher precision. From the entire data set with limiting magnitude R ≥ 23.5 we will be able to deduce the SLF down to MV ≥ 14 with good statistics and thus decide whether the features like the Wielen dip (Wielen et al. 1983) at MV ≈ 7 and the apparent rise of the SLF beyond MV = 12 are real. Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank H.Jahreiss who identified the subset of stars from the Forth Catalogue of Nearby Stars (CNS4) and thus provided the local normalisation for the disk compo- nent. We are greatly indebted to the anonymous referee who pointed out several points which had not received sufficient attention in the origi- nal manuscript. This led to a substantial improvement of the paper. We also thank the Calar Alto staff for their help and support during many observing runs at the observatory. From the ≈ 300 stars we identified in two CADIS fields cover- ◦, we deduced the density distribution ing a total area of 1/15 of the stars up to a distance of about 20 kpc above the Galac- tic plane. The density distribution shows unambiguously the contribution of a thick disk component of the Galaxy with a scaleheight of ≈ 1.3 kpc. There has been discussion whether this "thick disk" is intro- duced artificially by the assumption that all stars are on the main sequence (Bahcall & Soneira 1984). Our present sample of very faint field stars does rule out this ambiguity: if there were any giant stars included in our data, they would have dis- tances of about 250 kpc, thus their contribution to our sample can be neglected. The density distribution in the halo, which essentially is cor- roborated by comparing the local density of CNS4 stars with the density between 5.5 kpc and 15 kpc above the Galactic plane from CADIS, is perfectly fit by a de Vaucouleurs' law. Based on our present, limited data set of 72 stars beyond z=5.5 kpc, it is equally well justified to fit an inverse power law with exponent α = 2.99 ± 0.07 to the data, with the axial ratio of the halo as an additional free parameter. The best fit value for the axial ratio is (c/a = 0.63 ± 0.07). Based on this knowledge of the density distribution, we deter- mined the stellar luminosity function (SLF) for the disk stars. To this end, we confine our sample to stars with distances less than 1.5 kpc, for at this point the contribution of the thick disk and the halo population becomes predominant. Our result is within the errors indistinguishable from the local SLF (Jahreiss & Wielen 1997a). Thus we conclude that the weighted aver- age between the local SLF (containing predominantly stars at bright magnitudes (MV < 10)) and the CADIS SLF (with su- perior statistics at the faint end (MV > 10)) can be regarded as the best estimate of the SLF of the disk stars. The SLF con- tinues to rise at least up to MV = 13, in contrast to most other photometric SLFs, which show a down-turn at MV = 12. We regard this as a hint that incompleteness corrections and the closely connected issue of the "true" sampling volume of these faint star counts might need some critical revision. The stellar mass function (SMF) of the disk stars was derived by converting the visual magnitudes into masses (Henry et al. 1993; Henry et al. 1999). For a power-law SMF Ψ ∝ (M/M⊙)a we find a slope a = −1.28±0.68 0.42. This is (within the errors) consistent with the slope proposed by Henry et al. (1993) (a = −1). The main purpose of the present paper was to explore to what extent the faint star counts in CADIS can be used for deter- mining the stellar density distribution and the stellar luminos- ity function of the disk. However, one should keep in mind that our present analysis is based only on about a quarter of of the entire Calar Alto Deep Imaging Survey data. In the entire sam- ◦each, we expect ple which will contain eight fields of 1/30 to identify a total of >∼ 1200 stars with R ≤ 23, of which 800 are supposed to be disk stars and 400 to be halo stars. In addition with the complete multicolor data of the survey it should be possible to push the limit for a reliable star classifi- cation to R = 23.5 or beyond. 10 S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts Appendix A: Completeness correction Since the first distance bin is assumed to be complete, we can iteratively correct the number counts in the next bins. ′ is the number of stars in Nj is the number of stars in bin j, N the previous bin (j − 1), up to the limit given by the bin j, and ′′ is the number of stars from that limit up to the limit given N by bin j − 1, as indicated in Fig. A.1. ′′ is done to avoid correlated errors. The division into N The first bin (j = 1) is assumed to be complete (N1). The ′ and N 1(cid:19)2 + (cid:18) N2 N ′ σ2 N ′′′′ 1 and for the third bin + N2N ′′ 1 N ′′2 1 !2 σ2 N ′ 1 , σ2 N corr 3 = σ2 ′′ N 1 N ′ 2!2 + N3 1 + 3 1 + 3 1 + ′′ N 2 N ′ 2!2 1 + 1! 2(cid:19)2 (cid:18) 1 2! 1(cid:19)2 (cid:18) 1 N ′ N ′ ′′ N 1 N ′ ′′ N 2 N ′ + N 2 + N 2 ′′ 2 N ′ + N + N ′′ 1 N ′ 2!2 1!2 σN ′′ 2 σN ′′ 1 σ2 N ′′ σ2 N ′′ 2   1   Thus the error of the completeness corrected counts in the jth bin is i !2 + N i ′′ i N ′ i !2 j−1 ′′ N i N ′ Yi=1 1 +  i(cid:19)2 (cid:18) 1 i ! . 1 + ′′ N i N ′ σ2 N ′′ N ′ σ2 N ′ i  (A.2) σ2 N corr j = σ2 Nj j−1 j−1 Xi=1 Ym=1 m6=j + · ′′ N 1 N ′ 1! , (A.1) r r o c ) r - b ( N''1 N' 1 2N'' N'2 3N'' N'3 Fig. A.1. Schematic sketch of Fig. 3. log r corrected number N corr 2 in the second bin is then N corr 2 = N2 ·(cid:18) N1 N ′ 1(cid:19) = N2 N ′ ′′ 1 1 + N N ′ 1 ! = N2 1 + and for the third bin N corr 3 ′ N ′ N ′ 2 N ′ = N3(cid:18) N corr = N3 N = N3 1 + 2 (cid:19) = N3(cid:18) N1 1 ! N 1! 1 + 1 + N N ′ ′′ N 1 N ′ 1(cid:19)(cid:18) N2 2(cid:19) 2 ! 2! . 2 + N N ′ ′′ N 2 N ′ ′′ 1 ′′ 2 ′ Thus this can generally be written as N corr j = Nj j−1 Yi=1 1 + ′′ N i N ′ i ! The errors of the number counts Nj, N ′ j−1 and N ′′ j−1 are in- dependent of each other and thus Poissonian: σNj = pNj, j−1. Following Gaussian er- σN ′ ror propagation the error for the corrected number of stars in the second bin is = qN ′′ = qN ′ j−1, σN ′′ j−1 j−1 σ2 N corr 2 = σ2 N2 + N ′′ 1 N ′ 1!2 σ2 N2 References Wolf, C., 1998, Ph.D. thesis, Ruprecht-Karls-Universitat Hei- S. Phleps et al.: CADIS deep star counts 11 delberg Wolf, C., Meisenheimer, K., Roser, H.-J., et al., 1999, A&A 343, 399 Young P.A., 1976, AJ 81, 807 Bahcall, J. N., 1986, ARA&A, 24, 577 Bahcall J. N., Soneira R. M., 1980, ApJS 44, 73 Bahcall J. N., Soneira R. M., 1984, ApJS 55, 67 Bertin E., Arnouts S., 1996, A&AS 117, 393 de Vaucouleurs G., Pence W. D., 1978, AJ 83, 1163 Freeman K.C., 1992, in The Stellar Populations of Galaxies, Barbuy B., Renzini A. (eds.), Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, IAU Symp.149, 65 Fuchs B., Jahreiss H., 1998, A&A 329, 81 Fuhrmann K., 1998, A&A 338, 161 Gilmore G., Reid N., 1983, MNRAS 202, 1025 Gould A., Bahcall J. N., Flynn C., 1997, ApJ 482, 913 Gould A., Flynn C., Bahcall J. N., 1998, ApJ 503, 798 Gunn J. E., Stryker L. L., 1983, ApJS 52, 121 Henry T. J., McCarthy D. W. Jr., 1993, AJ 106, 773 Henry T. J., Franz O. G., Wasserman L. H. et al., 1999, ApJ 512, 864 Jahreiss H., Wielen R., 1997a, in HIPPARCOS '97. Presen- tation of the HIPPARCOS and TYCHO catalogues and first astrophysical results of the Hipparcos space astrome- try mission., Battrick B., Perryman, M.A.C., Bernacca P.L., (eds.), ESA SP-402, Noordwyk p. 675 Jahreiss H., Wielen R., 1997b, in HIPPARCOS '97. Presen- tation of the HIPPARCOS and TYCHO catalogues and first astrophysical results of the Hipparcos space astrome- try mission., Battrick B., Perryman, M.A.C., Bernacca P.L., (eds.) , ESA SP-402, Noordwyk , p. 587 Kent, S. M., Dame, T. M., Fazio, G., 1991, ApJ, 378, 131 Kroupa P., 1995, ApJ 453, 350 Lang K.R., 1992, Astrophysical Data I, Planets and Stars, Berlin, Springer-Verlag Meisenheimer K., Roser H.-J., 1986, in The Optimization of the Use of CCD Detectors in Astronomy, Baluteau J.-P., D'Odorico S., (eds.), (ESO-OHP:Garching bei Munchen), p.227 Meisenheimer K., Beckwith S., Fockenbrock R., et al., 1998, in The Young Universe: Galaxy Formation and Evolution at Intermediate and high Redshift, D'Odorico, S., Fontana, A., Giallongo E., (eds.), ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 146, p. 134 Norris, J.E., 1998 in Galaxy Evolution: Connecting the Dis- tant Universe with the local Fossil Record, Spite M. (eds.), Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, in press Oke, J. B., 1990, AJ, 99, 1621 Reid I.N., Majewski S.R., 1993 ApJ 409, 635 Reid I.N., Yan L., Majewski S., et al., 1996, AJ 112, 1472 Reid I.N., Gizis J.E., Cohen J.G., et al., 1997 PASP 109, 559 Stobie R. S., Peacock J. A., Ishida K., 1989, MNRAS 276, 709 Walsh, J. 1995, Optical and uv spectrophotometric standard stars. http://www.eso.org/observing/standards/spectra. Wielen, R., Jahreiss, H., Kruger, R., 1983, in The Nearby Stars and the Stellar Luminosity Function, Davis Philip A.G., Upgren (eds.), Davis Press, Schenectady, N.Y., IAUC 76, p.163
astro-ph/0509484	3	0509	2005-11-06T09:39:25	Neutron Star Kicks in Isolated and Binary Pulsars: Observational Constraints and Implications for Kick Mechanisms	[ "astro-ph" ]	We study observational constraints on neutron star (NS) kicks for isolated pulsars and for neutron stars in binary systems. We are particularly interested in the evidence of kick-spin alignment/misalignment and its dependence on the neutron star initial spin period. For several young pulsars, X-ray observations of compact nebulae showed that pulsar proper motion is aligned with the spin direction as defined by the symmetry axis of the nebula. We also critically examine the measurements of the proper motion and the projected spin axis from a large sample of pulsars with well-calibrated polarization data. We find that among the two dozen pulsars for which reliable measurements are available, there is a significant correlation between the spin axis and the proper motion. For various NS binaries, including double NS systems, binaries with massive main-sequence star companion and binaries with massive white-dwarf companion, we obtain constraints on the kick magnitudes and directions from the observed orbital characteristics of the system. We find that the kick velocity is misaligned with the the NS spin axis in a number of systems, and the NS spin period (when available) in these systems is generally longer than several hundreds milliseconds. These constraints, together with spin-kick alignment observed in many isolated pulsars, suggest that the kick timescale is hundreds of milliseconds to 1 s, so that spin-kick alignment or misalignment can be obtained depending on the initial spin period of the NS. We discuss the implication of our result for various NS kick mechanisms.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Neutron Star Kicks in Isolated and Binary Pulsars: Observational Constraints and Implications for Kick Mechanisms 5 0 0 2 v o N 6 3 v 4 8 4 9 0 5 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Chen Wang1, Dong Lai2,1, J. L. Han1 ABSTRACT We study observational constraints on neutron star (NS) kicks for isolated pulsars and for neutron stars in binary systems. We are particularly interested in the evidence of kick-spin alignment/misalignment and its dependence on the neutron star initial spin period. For several young pulsars, X-ray observations of compact nebulae showed that pulsar proper motion is aligned with the spin direction as defined by the symmetry axis of the nebula. We also critically examine the measurements of the proper motion and the projected spin axis from a large sample of pulsars with well-calibrated polarization data. We find that among the two dozen pulsars for which reliable measurements are available, there is a significant correlation between the spin axis and the proper motion. For various NS binaries, including double NS systems, binaries with massive main-sequence star companion and binaries with massive white-dwarf companion, we obtain constraints on the kick magnitudes and directions from the observed orbital characteristics of the system. We find that the kick velocity is misaligned with the the NS spin axis in a number of systems, and the NS spin period (when available) in these systems is generally longer than several hundreds milliseconds. These constraints, together with spin-kick alignment observed in many isolated pulsars, suggest that the kick timescale is hundreds of milliseconds to 1 s, so that spin-kick alignment or misalignment can be obtained depending on the initial spin period of the NS. We discuss the implication of our result for various NS kick mechanisms. Subject headings: stars: kinematics -- pulsars: general -- stars: neutron -- stars: rotation -- binaries: close 1National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Jia 20 Datun Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing, 100012, China; [email protected], [email protected] 2Department of Astronomy, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853; [email protected] -- 2 -- 1. Introduction It has long been recognized that neutron stars (NSs) may have received large kick velocities at birth. First, the measured NS velocities, several hundreds km s−1, are much larger than their progenitors' velocities (e.g., Lorimer et al. 1997; Hansen & Phinney 1997; Arzoumanian et al 2002; Chatterjee et al. 2005; Hobbs et al. 2005; see §2 below). Second, while large space velocities can in principle be accounted for by binary break-up (see Iben & Tutukov 1996), many observed characteristics of NS binaries can be explained only if there is a finite kick at NS birth (e.g., Dewey & Cordes 1987; Yamaoka et al. 1993; Kaspi et al. 1996; Fryer & Kalogera 1997; Fryer et al. 1998; Wex et al. 1999; Stairs et al. 2003; Dewi & van den Heuvel 2004; Willem et al. 2004; Thorsett et al. 2005; see §3). In addition, direct observations of many nearby supernovae (e.g., Wang 2004; Leonard & Filippenko 2004) and supernova remnants (e.g. Hwang et al. 2004) show that supernova explosions are not spherically symmetric, consistent with the existence of NS kicks. While the evidence for NS kicks is unequivocal, the physical origin remains unclear. The proposed mechanisms include hydrodynamical instabilities in the collapsed supernova core, asymmetric neutrino emission induced by super strong magnetic fields and post-natal electromagnetic boost (see Lai 2004; Janka et al. 2004 and references therein; see §4). One of the reasons that it has been difficult to spin down the kick mechanisms is the lack of correlation between NS velocity and the other properties of NSs. The situation has changed with the recent X-ray observations of the compact X-ray nebulae of several young pulsars, which indicate an approximate alignment between the pulsar proper motion and its spin axis (see Lai et al. 2001; Romani & Ng 2003). For a number of NS binary systems, possible spin- kick relationship can be probed from the observed binary property (e.g. geodetic precession; It is therefore useful to see whether a consistent picture about NS kicks can be see §3). obtained from the two sets of observational constraints. In this paper we seek empirical constraints on the kick mechanism. We are particularly interested in the possible alignment/misalignment between the kick and the angular momen- tum of the NS, and how such alignment/misalignment depends on the NS initial spin period. In §2, we summarize and update relevant observational data on isolated pulsars. In addition to several young pulsars for which the spin axis can be measured from the pulsar wind neb- ula, one can also constrain the spin axis from well-calibrated polarization data. We critically assess the information from such polarization study and demonstrate a correlation between spin axis and proper motion for these pulsars (see Fig. 1). In §3 we discuss constraints on NS kicks in various types of NS binaries. In addition to several well-studied NS/NS binaries, we also consider other types of binaries, such as pulsar/main-sequence and pulsar/white-dwarf binaries. We show that in general, the kick direction is misaligned with the NS spin axis. -- 3 -- We discuss the implications of our findings in §4. 2. Kicks in Isolated Pulsars By now a number of statistic studies on pulsar velocity have been carried out (e.g., Lyne and Lorimer 1994; Lorimer et al. 1997; Hansen & Phinney 1997; Cordes & Chernoff 1998; Arzoumanian et al 2002; Hobbs et al. 2005). These studies give a mean birth velocity 100− 500 km s−1, with possibly a significant population having V & 1000 km s−1. Arzoumanian et al. (2002) favor a bimodal pulsar velocity distribution, with peaks around 100 km s−1 and 500 km s−1. An analysis of the velocities of 14 pulsars with parallax by Chatterjee et al. (2005) yields a similar result (with σv ≃ 100 km s−1 and 300 km s−1). Another recent study of 73 young pulsars by Hobbs et al. (2005) gives a mean 3D pulsar velocity of 400 km s−1, consistent with a single Gaussian distribution. Despite some early claims, there is currently no statistically significant correlation be- tween the pulsar velocity and the period or the dipole magnetic field strength (as inferred P ) (e.g., Lorimer et al. 1995). This lack of correlation is not surprising given the from P, large systematic error in the analysis. From a physics point of view, it is also not surprising: (1) The observed spin period for young pulsars is 10 ms or longer, much too slow compared to the breakup rotation rate of a NS (period 1 ms or less); such a slow rotation would not play any dynamically important role in the supernova explosion. (2) The currently ob- served dipole field of pulsars is 1012−14 G, much weaker than the 1015−16 G fields required for magnetic field to affect the explosion dynamics or neutrino emission in proto-NSs (see §4). The lack of correlation between the velocity and the other property of pulsars has been one of the reasons that theoretical models of kicks are not well constrained. However, recent X-ray observation of compact nebulae around several young pulsars has provided evidence for spin-kick alignment; these are summarized in §2.1. Another way of constraining the pulsar spin axis is through radio polarization profile (§2.2). 2.1. Spin-Kick Correlation from Study of Pulsar Wind Nebulae Recent Chandra observations of the pulsar wind nebulae (PWN) have provided evidence for spin-kick alignment for several pulsars (e.g., Pavlov et al. 2000; Helfand et al. 2001; Lai et al. 2001; Ng & Romani 2004; Romani 2004; see Table 1). In particular, the X-ray nebulae of the Crab and Vela pulsars have a two-sided asymmetric jet at a position angle coinciding with the position angle of the pulsar's proper motion (Pavlov et al. 2000; Helfand et al. 2001). -- 4 -- The symmetric morphology of the nebula with respect to the jet direction strongly suggests that the jet is along the pulsar's spin axis. Analysis of the polarization angle of Vela's radio emission corroborates this interpretation (Lai et al. 2001; Radhakrishnan & Deshpande 2001). Ng & Romani (2004) performed a systematic image analysis of pulsar wind tori to determine the pulsar spin axis, and found that several other cases for spin-kick alignment. In Table 1 we list all the pulsars with the projected rotation axis position angle Ψrot as determined from PWN symmetry axis, the proper motion position angle ΨPM, and their difference ∆ΨΩ·v . In addition, we list the polarization angle Ψpol where available (see §2.2) and its difference from the proper motion position angle ∆Ψpol·v . For each pulsar, we obtain the initial spin period Pi using the standard equation Pinit = P0(cid:18)1 − n − 1 2 τ τc(cid:19)1/(n−1) , (1) where P0 is the observed period, τc is the characteristic age, n is the breaking index, and τ is the true age of the system. We summarize the key results in the following (see Table 1). Table 1: Spin and proper motion directions for young pulsars with the spin axis determined from PWN PSR B0531+21 J0538+2817 B0833-45 B1706-44 B1951+32 J1124-5916 Ψrot deg ΨPM deg ∆ΨΩ·v deg Ψpol deg 124.0 ± 0.1 155 ± 8 130.6 ± 0.1 163.6 ± 0.7 85 ± 5 292 ± 10 328 ± 4 301 ± 2 160 ± 10 252 ± 7 −60±10 35±10 72±10 12 ± 10 7 ± 9 8.6 ± 4 3.6 ± 11 13 ± 9 22 ± 7 ∆Ψpol·v deg 8±20 86±12 88±20 τ kyr 0.95 30±4 ... 8.9 64±18 2.5 τc kyr 1.24 618 11.4 17 107 2.9 P0 ms 33.1 143.2 89.3 102.5 39.5 135.3 Pinit ms 19 139.7±0.5 .70 76±4 27±6 65±20 PSR B0531+21 (Crab pulsar). The breaking index of the Crab pulsar has been measured to be 2.51±0.01 between glitches (Lyne et al. 1993). Eq. (1) thus gives Pinit = 19 ms. Caraveo & Mignani (1999) report a HST-derived proper motion for the Crab pulsar, (µα, µδ)=(−17±3, 7±3) mas yr−1, or µ=18±3 mas yr−1 (implying projected space velocity v⊥ = 140 km s−1) with a position angle ΨPM = 292◦±10◦. Ng & Romani (2004) fitted the two Crab tori of the PWN found in the CXO images, and gave the spin direction, Ψ = 124.0◦ ± 0.1◦ and ∆ΨΩ·v = 12◦ ± 10◦. PSR J0538+2817. This 143 ms pulsar (Lewandowshi et al. 2004) is associated with the supernova remnant S147. From the measured proper motion (67+48 −22 mas yr−1) and the separation of the pulsar from SNR center (2.2×106 mas), Kramer et al. (2003) deduce the true -- 5 -- age of the pulsar and the remnant, τ = 30± 4 kyr, which is a factor of 20 times less than the pulsar's characteristic age, τc = 618 kyr. This implies an initial spin period of Pinit = 139 ms. The PWN morphology indicates the spin axis at a position angle of Ψrot = 155◦ ± 8◦ (Ng & Romani, 2004), which differs from the proper motion axis (328◦ ± 4◦) by less than one σ (Romani & Ng 2003). PSR B0833-45. The Vela pulsar has P0 = 89.3 ms and τc = 11.4 kyr, and is associated with the large Vela supernova remnant. The real age of the pulsar is not known precisely. Using τ /τc & 0.5, and n & 1.5, we obtain an upper limit of the initial period, Pinit < 70 ms. The Vela pulsar CXO ACIS images have a typical double tori structure, from which Ng & Romani (2004) deduce the polar axis direction of Ψrot = 130.6◦ ± 0.1◦. Dodson et al. (2003) have measured the proper motion and parallax (µα cos δ = −49.68 ± 0.06 mas yr−1, µδ = 29.9 ± 0.1 mas yr−1 and a distance of 287+19 −17 pc), which give transverse space velocity VT = 61 ± 2 km s−1, and ΨPM = 301◦ ± 2◦. This vector lies 8.◦6 ± 4o from the fitted torus axis. PSR B1706-44. This P0 = 102.5 ms pulsar has a spindown age of 17.4 kyr (Wang et al. 2000). It is supposed on the outer edge of a shell-type supernova remnant G343.1-2.3, implying a likely association and the pulsar proper motion direction ΨPM = 160◦ ± 10◦ (e.g. McAdam et al. 1993; Dodson & Golap 2002; Bock & Gvaramadze 2002). A best fit of a thermal spectrum to the X-ray emission from the SNR gives a distance of 3.1 kpc, and an age of 8.9 kyr (Dodson & Golap 2002). From eq. (1) we find Pinit=78 ms for n = 1.5 and Pinit=72 ms for n = 3. Romani et al. (2005) fit the tori of PWN and obtain the polar axis direction Ψrot = 163.6◦ ± 0.7◦, and ∆ΨΩ·v = 15◦ ± 11◦. PSR B1951+32. This rapidly spinning (P0 = 39.5 ms) radio, X-ray, and γ-ray pulsar is located on the edge of the unusual SNR CTB80 (Kulkarni et al. 1988; Hobbs et al. 2004). The four epochs between 1989 and 2000 show a clear motion for the pulsar of 25±4 mas yr−1 at a position angle 252◦ ± 7◦, corresponding to a transverse velocity 240 ± 40 km s−1 for a distance to the source of 2 kpc (Migliazzo et al. 2002). The offset between the pulsar and the center of its associated supernova remnant implies an age for the pulsar 64±18 kyr, somewhat less than its characteristic age of 107 kyr, from which they give Pinit = 27 ± 6 ms (for n=1.5 -- 3.0). From the pulsar's polar jets, Ng & Romani (2004) measure the spin axis at ≈ 265◦ ± 5◦, which is 13◦ (∼ 1.4σ) away from the proper-motion axis. Finally, Romani (2004) mentioned another pulsar, PSR J1124-5916, where the misalign- ment angle may be measurable. This pulsar has a period of 135 ms and a characteristic age of 2900 yr (Camilo et al. 2002), and is associated with the Oxygen-rich composite supernova remnant G292.0+1.8 (Hughes et al. 2001; Gaensler & Wallace 2003). The precise age of SNR G292.0+1.8 is unknown; for estimate we use τ = 2500 yr (e. g., Gonzales & Safi-Harb -- 6 -- 2003). Eq. (1) then gives Pinit = 65 ± 20 ms. Romani (2004) measured the elongation of the central PWN and compared this with the direction to the explosion center, and obtained the misaligned angle of ∆ΨΩ·v ≈ 22◦ ± 7◦. We note that for three of the pulsars discussed above (see Table 1), the spin axis can be measured from the intrinsic polarization profile (see §2.2). This gives a consistent spin- velocity angle as the measurement from PWN, after one takes into account of the possible orthogonal mode emission from pulsars. 2.2. Spin-Kick Correlation from Polarization Study The polarization angle of linearly polarized emission from pulsars is related to the dipole magnetic field geometry of the emission region of a NS. At the pulse center, the line of sight and the spin axis are in the same plane as the curved magnetic field line. This provides another constraint of the projected spin axis on the plane of the sky. Note that radio emission from pulsars could have linear polarization parallel or orthogonal to magnetic field. If spin-kick aligns well, the difference between intrinsic polarization angle (IPA) and proper motion could be either 0◦ (for normal mode emission) or 90◦ (for orthogonal mode emission). Previous investigations of spin-velocity correlation based on polarization data have given inconsistent results. Tademaru (1977) found some evidence for alignment from the polar- ization angle and proper motion data of 10 pulsars. Morris et al. (1979) measured IPA at the pulse center of 40 pulsars, and claimed that the polarization direction is either parallel or perpendicular to the proper motion vector. Anderson & Lyne (1983) did not find any relation between proper motion directions and pulsar spin axis for 26 pulsars. Deshpande et al. (1999) checked a sample of 29 pulsars for which they estimated IPA and proper motions, and did not find any significant matching between IPA and proper motion. With the new measurements of proper motions of 233 pulsars (Hobbs et al. 2005), it is useful to re-examine the spin-velocity correlation from polarization data available. To this end, we select normal pulsars (with characteristic age less than a few ×107 yr) for which the uncertainty of position angle of the proper motion is less than 15 degree (see ATNF pulsar catalog, Manchester et al. 2005; Hobbs et al. 2005). We then search the literature for obser- vations of their polarization properties and rotation measures. Note that many polarization profiles were not well-calibrated in the polarization angle, and some observations have seri- ous (10% or more) instrumental effect. In our analysis, we use high frequency (&1.4 GHz) data; low frequency polarization observations are excluded because of the large-uncertainties of measured polarization angle from even a small uncertainty of Faraday rotations. The po- -- 7 -- larization profiles we use are mostly from Parkes observations (Qiao et al. 1995; Manchester 1971; Manchester et al. 1980; Wu, et al. 1993; van Ommen et al. 1997; Han et al. 2005, in preparation), for which we know that their polarization angles were well calibrated. We take the polarization angle at the maximum sweeping rate or about the pulse center, and calculate IPA with the observation frequency and the pulsar rotation measures. We discard the pulsars when the errors of the calculated IPA are greater than 20 degree. Finally, we obtain the difference between the direction of proper motion and IPA, and remove any object with uncertainty of the difference greater than 25 degree. After above procedures, 24 pulsars are left (see Table 2). In Table 2, the second and third columns give directions of proper motion on the sky plane, ΨPM, and IPA, Ψpol. The fourth columns gives the difference angle ΨPM − Ψpol . The fifth and sixth columns give current period P0 and characteristic age τc. Figure 1 shows the number distribution of the angular difference ΨPM−Ψpol . A signif- icant peak appears near 90◦, and another peak near 0◦ is also visible. Since the polarization direction is either parallel or perpendicular to the spin axis, the data therefore indicate a sig- nificant correlation between the spin and velocity. Given the result of PWN studies (§2.1), the most likely cause for the two peaks is that spin and kick are aligned in many cases, and different pulsars prefer to emit in one of the two orthogonal modes. Obviously, in this interpretation, intrinsic polarization emission favors perpendicular-mode emission for most pulsars. We note that for older pulsars in the sample, the proper motion may not directly reflect the initial kick direction because of the pulsar motion in the Galactic potential (e.g., Sun & Han 2004). Indeed, three of five old pulsars in Table 2 with τc & 10 Myr (although the real age τ may be less than τc) show appreciable misalignment, possibly because their proper motion directions have been modified by the Galactic potential. While our paper was in the final phase of preparation, we became aware of the work by Johnston et al. (2005b) which showed a similar spin-velocity correlation as discussed above. 3. Kicks in Binary Neutron Stars We now study the constraint on NS kicks (both magnitude and direction) from bi- nary pulsar systems, including NS/NS binaries, NS/Main-Sequence Star (MS) binaries, NS/Massive white dwarf (MWD) binaries and high-mass X-ray binaries (HMXBs). A num- ber of previous studies have focused on individual systems, particularly NS/NS binaries (e.g., Wex et al. 2000; Willems et al. 2004; Thorsett et al. 2005 and references therein) and -- 8 -- Table 2: Spin and proper motion directions for 24 pulsars with the spin axis determined from polarization profiles PSR ΨPM deg Ψpol deg ΨPM − Ψpol deg P0 ms τc yr References 173.4 ± 3.0 B0149-16 B0531+21† 292.0 ± 10.0 294.2 ± 2.6 B0628-28 B0736-40 312.9 ± 6.8 277.9 ± 4.4 B0740-28 169.2 ± 11.9 B0818-13 145.9 ± 1.9 B0823+26 B0833-45 301.0 ± 2.0 187.3 ± 7.0 B0835-41 12.0 ± 0.1 B0919+06 B0950+08† 355.9 ± 0.2 348.6 ± 0.1 B1133+16 295.0 ± 0.1 B1237+25 3.2 ± 10.4 B1325-43 B1426-66 235.9 ± 8.1 216.9 ± 2.8 B1449-64 252.7 ± 0.6 B1451-68 B1508+55 225.7 ± 1.1 268.1 ± 6.5 B1600-49 353.0 ± 3.2 B1642-03 B1706-44 160.0 ± 10.0 202.8 ± 0.7 B1857-26 65.2 ± 0.2 B1929+10 B2045-16 92.4 ± 2.6 91.5 ± 9.0 120.0 ± 10.0 31.4 ± 3.8 161.6 ± 5.3 100.8 ± 3.8 51.6 ± 4.6 72.5 ± 5.2 35.0 ± 10.0 97.3 ± 4.3 137.2 ± 16.4 82.2 ± 3.8 94.7 ± 4.0 138.1 ± 4.4 66.9 ± 11.4 51.6 ± 5.9 131.3 ± 5.9 146.9 ± 3.6 28.5 ± 6.3 153.9 ± 17.7 74.7 ± 6.7 72.0 ± 10.0 161.6 ± 3.8 51.4 ± 16.2 178.5 ± 3.8 81.9 ± 12.0 8.0 ± 20.0 82.8 ± 6.4 28.7 ± 12.1 2.9 ± 8.2 62.4 ± 16.5 73.4 ± 7.1 86.0 ± 12.0 90.0 ± 11.3 54.8 ± 16.5 86.3 ± 4.0 73.9 ± 4.1 23.1 ± 4.5 63.7 ± 21.8 4.3 ± 14.0 85.6 ± 8.7 74.2 ± 4.2 17.2 ± 7.4 65.8 ± 24.2 81.7 ± 9.9 88.0 ± 20.0 41.2 ± 4.5 13.8 ± 16.4 86.1 ± 6.4 832.7 33.1 1244.4 374.9 166.8 1238.1 530.7 89.3 751.6 430.6 253.1 1187.9 1382.4 532.7 785.4 179.5 263.4 739.7 327.4 387.7 102.5 612.2 226.5 1961.6 1.02e+07 1.24e+03 2.77e+06 3.68e+06 1.57e+05 9.32e+06 4.92e+06 1.13e+04 3.36e+06 4.97e+05 1.75e+07 5.04e+06 2.28e+07 2.80e+06 4.49e+06 1.04e+06 4.25e+07 2.34e+06 5.09e+06 3.45e+06 1.75e+04 4.74e+07 3.10e+06 2.84e+06 1, 2 3 3, 2 4, 3, 2 4, 2 1, 2 5 3 4, 2 2 4, 2 4, 2 5 6 4, 2 4, 2 4, 2 5 6 2 3 3, 2, 4 5 4, 2 †Cases where the Ψpol have an ambiguity due to orthogonal flips. Note. -- REFERENCES: (1) Qiao et al. (1995); (2) van Ommmen et al. (1997); (3) Han et al. (2005); (4) Manchester et al. (1980); (5) Manchester (1971); (6) Wu et al. (1993). -- 9 -- Fig. 1. -- The number distribution of the angular difference between the proper motion and intrinsic polarization direction for 24 pulsars. Each pulsar is represented by a symbol specified by the characteristic age of the pulsar. -- 10 -- HMXBs (e.g. Pfahl et al. 2002). Here we consider all systems where such kick constraints are possible. 3.1. Method and Assumptions The basic procedure for obtaining the constraint is as follows: In the pre-supernova (SN) binary system, we have two stars with mass 1 mAi and mBi in a circular orbit (eccentricity ei = 0) with semi-major axis ai. Star B is a helium star ready to explode, and its mass mBi = mHe is constrained within the range 2.1 -- 8.0 M⊙ (the lower limit corresponds to the lowest mass for which a He star is expected to form a NS instead of a white dwarf, while the upper limit corresponds to the highest mass for which a He star is expected to form a NS rather than a black hole; see, e.g., Fig.1 in Belczynski et al. 2002, and Table 16.4 in Tauris & van den Heuvel 2004). Star A is either a NS, a massive MS or a massive WD. In the first case, dynamical stability in the mass transfer from the He star to its NS companion requires mBi/mAi . 3.5 (see Ivanova et al. 2003). As B explodes in a SN (the explosion can be considered instantaneous compared to the orbital period), it leaves behind a NS with mass mB < mBi, and because of the asymmetry in the explosion or in the neutrino emission, the NS (in its rest frame) receives a kick velocity Vk. The angle between Vk and the pre-SN angular momentum Li is γ. To a good approximation, star A is assumed to be unaffected by the explosion of B (see below), i.e., its mass mA = mAi after the SN, its post-SN velocity equals the pre-SN velocity. Because of the mass loss and kick in the explosion, the post-SN orbit (with semi-major axis af) will in general be eccentric (ef 6= 0), and the orbital angular momentum Lf will be misaligned relative to Li by an angle θ. Using angular momentum conservation and energy conservation, we find V 2 k = GMf af cos2 γ = (cid:2)2ξ − 1 + ξη−1 − 2(1 − e2 f ) sin2 θ ξ2(1 − e2 f )1/2ξ3/2η−1/2 cos θ(cid:3) , 2ξ − 1 + ξη−1 − 2(1 − e2 f )1/2ξ3/2η−1/2 cos θ , (2) (3) where Mf = mA + mB, Mi = mA + mBi, η = Mf /Mi (with η < 1), and ξ = af/ai, which satisfies (1 + ef)−1 < ξ < (1 − ef)−1. The assumptions leading to eqs. (2)-(3) are fairly standard, and similar equations have been used in numerous previous studies (e.g., Hills 1983). To obtain useful constraint on the kick-spin correlation, we need to make further assumptions about the rotations of the two stars: 1The subscript "i" specifies parameters before SN, "f" after SN, and "0" currently observed parameters. -- 11 -- Assumption (1): In the pre-SN binary, the assumption of circular orbit made above is justified from the strong tidal interaction and/or mass transfer, which also guarantee that spin angular momentum vectors of the two stars are aligned with the orbital angular momentum vector (i.e., SAi k SBi k Li). As an example, consider the progenitor system of a NS/NS binary: The NS spin SAi is expected to be aligned with Li because of the mass accretion which spins up the NS. Since the He star is fully convective, the tidal effect on the He star can be estimated using the standard tidal friction theory. Following Zahn (1989; eq. [21]), the tidal circularization time is given by 1 tcirc = 21 λcirc tf ai (cid:19)8 q(1 + q)(cid:18)RHe , (4) where q = mA/mHe is the mass radio, tf = (mHeR2 He/LHe)1/3 is the convective friction time (mHe, LHe are the radius and convective luminosity of the He star), and λcirc is a dimensionless average of the turbulent viscosity weighted by the square of the tidal shear. In the prescription of Zahn (1989), λcirc can be approximated by λcirc ≃ 0.019α4/3(1 + η2/320)−1/2, where α (≃ 2) is the mixing length parameter and η = 2tf/Porb measures the timescale mismatch. For the He star parameters, we use the result of Dewi et al. (2002, 2003), who studied the late stage evolution of different types of He-star/NS binaries: (i) Case BA (mass transfer during He core burning) with mHe = 1.5 − 2.9 M⊙: the remnants are heavy, degenerate CO white dwarfs (WDs). (ii) Case BB (mass transfer during He shell burning): mHe = 1.5 − 2.1 M⊙ produces CO or ONe WDs, mHe = 2.4 − 2.5 M⊙ produces ONe WDs and more massive He stars produce NSs. (iii) Case BC (the He star fills its Roche lobe during carbon core burning or beyond) with mHe = 2.8 − 6.4 M⊙ producing NSs. Table 3 lists some typical values of mHe, RHe, LHe and Porb for He-star/NS binaries considered by Dewi et al. (2002, 2003), together with the tidal friction time and circularization time as calculated from eq. (4). We see that the tidal circularization time is about one hundred years, and the corresponding synchronization/alignment timescale for the spin of the He star is even shorter [by a factor ∼ (RHe/ai)2]. These timescales are much less than the typical time of mass transfer from the He star prior to its supernova explosion. Thus, the assumption SAi k SBi k Li is very reasonable2. We note that the synchronized He star has a large specific angular momentum compared to a maximal-rotating NS. So the He-star core has to shed 2Our analyses here are based on the model of Dewi et al. (2002, 2003), which posits that the He star fills its Roche lobe at certain stage of its evolution. Such Roche-lobe-filling configuration is most likely required for many systems considered here (e.g., PSR J0737-3039 and PSR B1534+12). We note that population studies of binary compact object formation (e.g., Portegies Zwart & Verbunt 1996; Belczynski, Kalogera & Bulik 2002) indicate that a small fraction of progenitors might not be circularized before the explosion. -- 12 -- significant angular momentum before it can collapse to a NS. Such angular momentum loss (most likely mediated by magnetic stress; see Heger et al. 2004) does not change the spin orientation of the He core. We shall make similar reasonable assumption (that the pre-SN binaries are circular) about MS/He-star binaries (the progenitor systems of MS/NS binaries) and WD/He-star binaries (the progenitor systems of MWD/NS binaries). Table 3: Tidal circularization timescale of different types of He-star/NS binaries Case MHe RHe Log(LHe/L⊙) Porb days 0.08 0.5 1.0 10 0.6 M⊙ R⊙ 0.5 2.8 1.8 2.8 2.8 2.8 12 2.8 3.6 2 BB BB BB BC BC tf yr 0.01 0.03 0.04 0.10 0.02 tcirc yr 170 100 120 330 140 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 5 Assumption (2): In deriving eqs. (2) and (3), we have assumed that the SN of star B (He star) does not affect the mass and motion of star A. As discussed below, in several systems, the post-explosion spin orientation of star A, SAf , can be constrained observationally, and we will assume that the spin direction of star A is unchanged during the explosion, i.e. SAf k SAi. To justify these assumptions, consider the explosion of the He star in a MS/He-star binary (the progenitor of a MS/NS system)3 and we can estimate the ejecta mass and momentum captured by the MS star. Assuming that the explosion of the He star is only mildly aspherical (indeed, only small asymmetry is enough to generate large kick to the NS), the ejecta mass captured by the MS star is mcap ∼ πR2 MS 4πa2 i mej (5) where RMS is the radius of the MS star, ai the binary separation before explosion, and mej is the total mass ejected by the He star. As an estimate, we use the parameters for the PSR J0045-7319/MS system (see §3.3 below): From the observed semi-major axis a0 and eccentricity e0 of the current PSR/MS binary, we find ai > af (1 − ef) ≃ a0(1 − e0) ≃ 4RMS. Thus at most 1/64 of the ejecta mass is captured by the MS star, or mcap . 0.03M⊙ for mej = 3The effect of ejecta capture by the NS in a NS/He-star binary is obviously much smaller. -- 13 -- mHe − mNS ∼ 2M⊙. For a typical mass ejection velocity Vej ∼ 104 km s−1, the MS star will receive an impact velocity ∆V less than 30 km s−1. In general, requiring ∆V = mcapVej/mMS to be less than pre-explosion orbital velocity of the MS star, (Gmtot/ai)1/2mHe/mtot (where mtot = mMS + mHe), leads to the condition ai & 2RMS. Thus the momentum impact on the MS star due to the ejecta is negligible in most cases. We note that even in extreme cases, when ai/RMS =a few, the momentum impact is along the pre-SN orbital plane. This impact, by itself, does not change the orientation of the orbital plane. From the above considerations, we conclude that the assumption SAi k SBi k Li k SAf is most likely valid. Thus the angle θ between Li and Lf is equal to the angle between Lf and SAf , which can be constrained observationally (see below). What about spin orientation SBf of the newly formed NS (star B)? Obviously, if the angular momentum of the NS originates entirely from its progenitor, then SBf k SBi. But it is possible that even with zero "primordial" rotation, finite NS rotation can be produced by off-centered kicks (Spruit & Phinney 1998; see also Burrows et al. 1995, who reported a proto-NS rotation period of order 1 s generated by stochastic torques in their 2D supernova simulations). Such SN-generated spin will necessarily make SBf misalign with SBi. Thus in general, the angle γ in eq. (3) refers to the angle between the kick Vk imparted on star B and its primordial spin SBi, not necessarily the angle between VK and SBf (see §4). Finally, the post-SN binary may continue to evolve, so the currently observed orbital elements a0, e0 may not be the same as af, ef . Depending on the type of systems, the evolution may be driven by gravitational radiation or tidal effect. 3.2. NS/NS Binaries Currently there are 8 observed NS/NS binary systems observed in our Galaxy (7 are listed in Stairs 2004, plus PSR J1756-2251 reported by Faulkner et al. 2005)4 They consist of a recycled millisecond pulsar (A) and a second-born NS (B) which, in most cases, is not visible as a radio pulsar (with the exception of the double pulsar system, PSR J0737-3039). Following the birth of the second-born NS (B) in a SN, the NS/NS binary evolution is 4Our Table 4 does not include the new system PSR J1906+0746 (Porb = 3.98 h, e = 0.0853, Mtot = 2.6 M⊙) recently discovered by Arecibo (Lorimer et al. 2005). With the reasonable assumptions that mAi = 2.1 − 8.0 M⊙, mA = mB = 1.3 M⊙ and θ = 0◦ − 180◦, we can give the kick velocity Vk = 50 − 1590 km s−1 and the misalignment between kick and pre-spin axis γ = 24◦ − 156◦. -- 14 -- governed by gravitational radiation reaction, with (Peters 1964) 1 a 1 e da dt de dt = − = − 64G3 5c5 304G3 15c5 mAmBMf a4(1 − e2)7/2 (cid:18)1 + a4(1 − e2)5/2 (cid:18)1 + mAmBMf 37 96 e4(cid:19) , e2 + 73 24 121 304 e2(cid:19) . (6) (7) The time lapse T since the SN to the present is unknown. In our calculations below we adopt the characteristic age of the pulsar, τc = P/(2 P ), as a conservative upper limit to T , although the actual value of T may be a lot smaller (see below for specific cases). From the measured a0 and e0, we can integrate eqs. (6)-(7) backward in time to obtain af and ef. We also note that the angle between SA and Lf is unchanged during the evolution and is given by θ. We now consider individual NS/NS binary systems (see Table 4). The kicks in PSR J0737-3039, PSR B1534+12, PSR B1913+16 have been studied in detail by Willems et al. (2004) (see also Dewi & van den Heuvel 2004; Piran & Shaviv 2004) and PSR B1534+12 by Thorsett et al. (2005). Our constraints on the kick are based on the observed orbital elements and spin parameters of the systems. For several of the systems, additional constraint can be obtained from the proper motion and location of the binary in the Galaxy. We summarize our key findings below (see Table 4). PSR J0737-3039. This double-pulsar system contains 22.7 ms pulsar (Pulsar A) and a 2.77 s pulsar (Pulsar B), with the current orbital period Porb=0.1 d and eccentricity e0=0.0878 (Lyne et al. 2004). For the He progenitor mass of pulsar B, we consider both the range mBi = 2.1 − 4.7M⊙ (for stable mass transfer) as well as the range mBi = 2.3 − 3.3M⊙ as suggested by Dewi & van den Heuvel (2004). The spindown time of pulsar A is 210 Myr and pulsar B 50 Myr; we use the latter as the approximate upper limit for the time lapse since the SN, thus we consider ef=0.0878 -- 0.103 and af=2.94 -- 3.28 ls. The angle θ has not be measured directly. Theoretical modeling of the eclipse lightcurve (Lyutikov & Thompson 2005) suggests that pulsar-B's spin axis SBf is inclined from the orbital angular momentum vector by 60◦ (or 120◦); if SBf k SBi (see §3.1), then this angle is equal to θ. Our constraints on VK and γ for different cases are given in Table 4. For the same input parameters (θ = 0◦− 180◦, mBi = 2.1− 4.7M⊙), our result is consistent with that of Willems et al. (2004) (see their Table 2). With the more constrained parameters, we obtain stronger for θ = 60◦, the kick direction is γ = 36◦ -- 47◦ or 133◦ -- 144◦ with constraints on the kick: velocity Vk = 610− 760 km s−1; for θ = 120◦, even larger kicks (Vk = 1040− 1300 km s−1) are required5. 5Such large kick velocities are likely inconsistent with the small measured proper motion of the system -- 15 -- Table 4: Constraints on kicks in double NS binaries PSR J0737-3039 mB mA mBi M⊙ M⊙ M⊙ 1.25 1.25 1.25 2.1 -- 4.7 2.3 -- 3.3 2.3 -- 3.3 1.34 1.34 1.34 ef af ls 0.088 -- 0.103 0.088 -- 0.103 0.088 -- 0.103 2.94 -- 3.28 2.94 -- 3.28 2.94 -- 3.28 θ deg 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 γ deg 24 -- 156 28 -- 152 60 36 -- 47 or 133 -- 144 J1518+4904 1.05 1.31 1.56 1.31 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.249 0.249 56.68 56.68 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 19 -- 161 12 -- 168 Vk km s−1 60 -- 1610 80 -- 1490 610 -- 760 11 -- 500 4 -- 500 B1534+12 1.35 1.35 1.33 1.33 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.274 -- 0.282 0.274 -- 0.282 7.63 -- 7.82 7.63 -- 7.82 21 -- 29 151 -- 159 10 -- 74 or 106 -- 170 75 -- 83 or 97 -- 105 160 -- 480 660 -- 1360 J1756-2251 1.20 1.37 2.1 -- 8.0 0.181 -- 0.197 6.27 -- 6.65 0 -- 180 20 -- 160 31 -- 1390 J1811-1736 1.11 1.37 1.62 1.37 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.828 0.828 96.58 96.58 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 J1829+2456 1.36 1.25 1.14 1.25 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.139 -- 0.149 0.139 -- 0.149 14.78 -- 15.47 14.78 -- 15.47 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 20 -- 160 22 -- 158 0 -- 873 0 -- 867 19 -- 867 25 -- 870 B1913+16 1.39 1.39 1.44 1.44 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.617 -- 0.657 0.617 -- 0.657 6.51 -- 7.44 6.51 -- 7.44 12 -- 24 156 -- 168 0 -- 84 or 96 -- 180 77 -- 87 or 93 -- 103 180 -- 660 530 -- 2170 B2127+11C 1.36 1.35 2.1 -- 8.0 0.681 -- 0.725 6.57 -- 7.81 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 0 -- 2370 -- 16 -- Additional constraint from the observed proper motion and galactic location of the system tends to rule out the high values of kick velocity (see Piran & Shaviv 2004; Willems et al. 2004), but does not change the fact that a misaligned kick (γ 6= 0) is required to explain the observed orbital property of the system. PSR J1518+4904 contains a 40.9 ms pulsar with Porb = 8.634 d and e0 = 0.249 (Nice, Sayer & Taylor 1996; Hobbs et al. 2004). Thorsett & Chakrabarty (1999) gave the total mass Mf = mA + mB = 2.62(7)M⊙, and mA = 1.56+0.13 −0.11. The spindown age of this pulsar is 16 Gyr, According to eqs. (6)-(7), we find that the eccentricity and semi-major axis have changed very little, af ≃ a0, ef ≃ e0. The spin-orbit inclination angle θ for Pulsar A is currently unknown (although it will likely be constrained by measuring geodetic precession in the next few years), so we consider the full range θ = 0 − 180◦. For MBi = 1.05M⊙, the kick direction is constrained to 19◦ − 161◦ and the kick velocity could be as small as 10 km s−1. For more typical masses, MA = 1.32 M⊙, MB = 1.30 M⊙, the kick constraints are similar. −0.44, mB = 1.05+0.45 PSR B1534+12 contains a 37.9 ms pulsar with Porb = 0.42 d and e0 = 0.274. Mea- surement of geodetic precession of the pulsar constrains the spin-orbit inclination angle θ = 25◦ ± 4◦ or θ = 155◦ ± 4◦ (Stairs et al. 2004; Thorsett et al. 2005). The spindown time is 250 Myr, and according to eqs. (6)-(7), we obtain the range ef =0.274 -- 0.282, af=7.63 -- 7.82 ls. For θ = 25◦ ± 4◦, our result (Vk ≃ 160 − 480 km s−1) is consistent with Thorsett et al. (2005), who used additional constraint from proper motion (µα = 1.34(1) mas yr−1, µδ = −25.05(2) mas yr−1; with the distance of 0.68 kpc, this corresponds to transverse ve- locity of VT = 107.04 km s−1; Konacji et al. 2003) to obtain Vk = 230 ± 60 km/s. The θ = 155◦ ± 4◦ solution leads to much greater values of Vk and might be inconsistent with the observed proper motion. In all cases, aligned kicks (γ = 0) are ruled out. PSR J1756-2251 contains 28.5 ms pulsar with Porb = 0.32 d and e0 = 0.181 (Faulkner et al. 2005). The total system mass mA + mB = 2.574 M⊙ from measurement of relativistic periastron advance, and the companion mass is constrained to mB < 1.25 M⊙. We adopt mB = 1.2M⊙ and mA = 1.37M⊙, θ = 0◦ -- 180◦. The spin down age is 443 Myr. The kick direction is constrained in 20◦ − 160◦, which means that aligned kicks are ruled out. PSR J1811-1736 contains a 104.2ms pulsar with Porb = 18.8 d and e0 = 0.828 (see Stairs 2004). The mass ranges are mA = 1.62+0.22 −0.15. The spindown age is about 900 Myr. For θ=0◦ -- 180◦, the kick is not well constrained. Aligned kicks are allowed −0.55, mB = 1.11+0.53 (VT < 30 km/s; see Kramer et al. 2005; Coles et al. 2005) unless the system has significant line-of-sight velocity. One may thus rule out the Lyutikov-Thompson solution (θ = 60◦ or 120◦), or, more likely, if the the Lyutikov-Thompson solution is correct, one may conclude that SBf is not parallel to SBi. -- 17 -- for relatively low mBi. PSR J1829+2456 contains a 41 ms pulsar (τc = 12.4 Gyr) with Porb = 1.18 d and e0 = 0.139 (Champion et al. 2004; Champion et al. 2005). The masses are mA = 1.14+0.28 −0.48 and mB = 1.36+0.50 −0.17. The kicks are constrained with γ = 20◦−160◦ and Vk = 20−880 km s−1, which means spin-kick misaligned. For mA = mB = 1.25 M⊙, the constraints are similar. PSR B1913+16 (Hulse-Taylor binary) contains a 59 ms pulsar with Porb = 0.323 d and e0 = 0.617. Measurement of geodetic precession of the pulsar constrains the spin-orbit inclination angle θ = 18◦±6◦ or θ = 162◦±6◦ (Wex et al. 2000; Weisberg & Taylor 2003). The spindown time of the pulsar is 109 Myr, so we adopt T < 109Myr, giving ef = 0.617− 0.657, af = 6.51 − 7.44 ls. For the pre-SN mass of the He star in the range of 2.1 -- 8.0M⊙, we get a similar result compared to Willems et al. (2004) (see their Table 2): if θ = 18◦ ± 6◦, γ=0◦ -- 84◦ or 96◦ -- 180◦, Vk ≃ 180− 660 km s−1; if θ = 162◦ ± 6◦, γ=77◦ -- 87◦ or 93◦ -- 103◦, Vk ≃ 530 − 2170 km s−1. The transverse velocity VT = 88 km s−1 (µα = −2.56(6) mas yr−1, µδ = 0.49(7) mas yr−1, see Weisberg & Taylor 2003; and distance 7.13 kpc, see Taylor & Cordes 1993) suggests that the θ = 18◦ ± 6◦ solution may be more reasonable. PSR B2127+11C contains 30.53 ms-pulsar with Porb = 0.335 d, e0 = 0.681 and char- acteristic age 97.2 Myr (Deich & Kulkarni 1996). According to eqs. (6)-(7), we find ef = 0.681 − 0.725, af = 6.57 − 7.81 ls. The kicks are not well constrained, and aligned kicks are allowed by the data. Note that this system lies in the globular cluster M15, and it may have formed by many-body interactions in the cluster core. Our general conclusion from NS/NS binaries is that modest kicks which are misaligned with the pre-SN orbital angular momentum are required to produce the spin-orbit charac- teristics of these systems (see also van den Heuvel 2004). 3.3. Pulsar/MS Binaries There are three published pulsar/MS binary systems (see Table 5) 6 Such systems evolve from He-star/MS binaries (which in turn evolves from MS/MS binaries) when the He star explodes in a SN to form a NS. After the explosion, the pulsar/MS binary may further evolve under tidal interaction if the orbit is sufficiently compact. The evidence for such tidal evolution is most clear in the PSR J0045-7319 system. 6We do not include the system PSR J1638-4715, a 0.764 s pulsar with a Be star companion, with Porb ≃ 1800 d and e0 = 0.808 (A. Lyne 2005, private communication). -- 18 -- Table 5: Constraints on kicks in pulsar/MS binaries PSR J0045-7319 1.58 J0045-7319 1.58 J0045-7319 1.58 mA mB M⊙ M⊙ 8.8 8.8 11 mAi M⊙ ef af ls θ deg γ deg 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.808 0.950 0.808 293.96 128.79 293.96 115 -- 160 115 -- 160 115 -- 160 53 -- 85 or 95 -- 127 52 -- 87 or 93 -- 128 53 -- 85 or 95 -- 127 Vk km s−1 119 -- 740 52 -- 750 130 -- 800 B1259-63 B1259-63 1.35 1.35 10 10 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.870 0.870 531.51 531.51 0 -- 180 10 -- 40 0 -- 180 0 -- 86 or 94 -- 180 13 -- 330 22 -- 110 J1740-3052 1.35 J1740-3052 1.35 12 -- 20 12 -- 20 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.579 0.579 873.26 873.26 30 -- 75 105 -- 150 0 -- 64 or 116 -- 180 48 -- 80 or 100 -- 132 37 -- 240 89 -- 370 PSR J0045-7319 contains a 0.926 s pulsar (with characteristic age 3 Myr) in an orbit with a B star companion (mass= 10 ± 1 M⊙) with Porb = 51 d and e0=0.808 (Kaspi et al. 1996). Timing observation revealed the effects of classical spin-orbit coupling due to the rapid rotation of the B star, including periastron advance and precession of the orbital plane (Kaspi et al. 1996; see also Lai et al. 1995; Wex 1998). This constrains the angle between L and SB (spin axis of the B star) to be θ = 20◦ -- 65◦ or θ = 115◦ -- 160◦. Timing data also revealed rapid orbital decay, Porb/ Porb = −0.5 Myr, which can be naturally explained by dynamical tidal interaction between the pulsar and the B star near periastron, provided that the B star rotation axis is (approximately) opposite to L (Lai 1996; Kumar & Quataert 1997). We therefore choose the θ = 115◦ -- 160◦ solution. Lai (1997) showed that during the dynamical tidal evolution, a(1 − e) is approximately constant. Since tidal interaction tends to align SB and L and the current system has a highly misaligned geometry, the binary should not have evolved very long. We therefore consider the range ef = 0.808 − 0.95 (most likely ef is rather close to e0). We find that with different values of ef, the implied Vk and γ change only slightly: Vk ≃ 50 − 750 km s−1, and γ ≃ 52◦ − 87◦ or 93◦ − 128◦, which implies spin-kick misalignment. Another important point for this system is that the initial spin of the pulsar can be constrained. A generic theory of dynamical-tide induced orbital decay combined with the currently measured orbital decay rate, yield an upper limit, 1.4 Myr, to the age of the system since the SN (Lai 1996). Since the characteristic age of the pulsar is 3 Myr, we find that the initial spin period of the pulsar is close to the current value, Pinit & 0.5 s. -- 19 -- PSR B1259-63 contains a 47.8 ms pulsar and a Be star companion (mass mB ≃ 10 M⊙), with Porb = 1236.7 d and e0=0.870 (see Wex et al. 1998; Wang, Johnston & Manchester 2004). Because of the large orbital period and the short characteristic age (0.33 Myr), tidal interaction is probably unimportant, i.e., the evolution of the system since the SN is neg- ligible. We therefore adopt ef ≃ e0 and af ≃ a0. (With different ef, the constraint on the kick is similar.) Although spin-orbital coupling effects are likely important in this system, no self-consistent timing solution has been obtained so far (see Wang et al. 2004; Johnston et al. 2005a) and hence θ has not been measured. For θ = 0◦ -- 180◦, the kick velocity is constrained to 10 -- 340 km s−1, and the kick direction is unconstrained. In particular, for θ = 23◦ − 42◦, aligned kicks (γ = 0) are allowed (see Fig. 1). Melatos et al. (1995) modeled the variation of the dispersion measure and rotation measure near periastron produced by the circumstellar disk of the Be star and suggested that the disk is tilted with respect to the orbital plane by 10◦ − 40◦. For θ in this range, aligned kicks are also allowed. PSR J1740-3052 contains a 0.57 s pulsar (with characteristic age 0.35 Myr) and an early Be star companion (mass> 11 M⊙), with Porb = 231 d and e0=0.579 (Stairs et al. 2001). The large orbital period and small characteristic age imply that tidal evolution has not changed the binary parameters, thus we use ef ≃ e0. The spin-orbital inclination angle θ lies in the range 30◦ -- 75◦ (or 105◦ -- 150◦) (see Stairs et al. 2003). We find that aligned kicks (γ = 0) are allowed for this system for θ = 30◦ − 75◦, but not allowed for θ = 105◦ − 150◦. 3.4. Young pulsars with massive white dwarf companions Such systems are thought to evolve from binaries in which both stars are initially less massive than the critical mass required to produce a NS (Tauris & Sennels 2000; Stairs 2004). The initially more massive star transfers mass to its companion before becoming a WD. If sufficient matter can be accreted by the initially low mass star, it will exceed the critical mass and produce a NS. Should the system remain bound, an eccentric binary with a young NS and a MWD companion will be produced. Two such systems are known (see Table 6). PSR J1141-6545 contains a WD (mass=0.986 M⊙) and a young pulsar (P0=0.4 s, mass=1.30 M⊙), with current orbital period Porb=0.198 d and e0=0.172 (see Bailes et al.2003). Measurement of geodetic precession constrains the spin-orbit inclination angle to θ = 15◦ − 30◦ (or 150◦ -- 165◦) (see Hotan et al. 2005). From the pulsar's spindown age (1.46 Myr), we find that the orbit has evolved very little, thus ef ≃ e0 = 0.172 and af ≃ a0 = 4.38 ls. For all reasonable mass of the NS progenitor, aligned kicks are ruled out (see Table 6). -- 20 -- Fig. 2. -- The allowed kick angle γ (shaded region) as a function of spin-orbit misalignment angle θ in the PSR B1259-63 system. Table 6: Constraints on kicks in binary pulsars with massive WD companion PSR mBi mB mA M⊙ M⊙ M⊙ ef af ls J1141-6545 1.30 1.30 0.99 0.99 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0.172 0.172 4.38 4.38 θ deg 15 -- 30 150 -- 165 γ deg 21 -- 78 or 102 -- 159 76 -- 85 or 95 -- 104 Vk km s−1 160 -- 620 890 -- 1610 B2303+46 1.34 1.30 2.1 -- 8.0 0.658 72.16 0 -- 180 0 -- 180 0 -- 690 -- 21 -- PSR B2303+46 contains a white dwarf (mass=1.3 M⊙) and a young pulsar (P0=1.1 s, mass=1.34 M⊙), with current orbital period Porb=12.34 d and e0=0.658 (see Thorsett et al. 1993; van Kerkwijk & Kulkarni 1999). The spin-orbital inclination angle θ has not been measured. From the characteristic age of the pulsar (30 Myr), we find that the orbit has evolved very little after the NS's birth. The kick direction for this system is not constrained. 3.5. High-Mass X-Ray Binaries A HMXB consists of a NS, which often appears as an X-ray pulsar, and a massive stellar companion (e.g. a Be star). Of the ∼ 130 known HMXBs, about 20 have well-constrained orbital elements, mostly determined from the timing of the X-ray pulsars. Table 7: Constraints on kicks in some Be X-ray binary systems PSR 4U0115+63 Porb days 24.32 24.32 ef 0.340 0.340 mA mB M⊙ M⊙ 1.33 8.00 20.00 1.33 mAi M⊙ 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 Vk km s−1 0 -- 470 3 -- 660 V0332+53 34.25 34.25 0.310 0.310 1.33 1.33 8.00 20.00 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0 -- 410 0 -- 580 2S1417-624 42.12 42.12 0.446 0.446 1.33 1.33 8.00 20.00 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0 -- 440 15 -- 620 EXO2030+375 46.01 46.01 0.370 0.370 1.33 1.33 8.00 20.00 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0 -- 360 5 -- 510 A0535+26 110.3 110.3 0.470 0.470 1.33 1.33 8.00 20.00 2.1 -- 8.0 2.1 -- 8.0 0 -- 320 13 -- 460 There are three classes of HMXBs, distinguished by their orbital parameters (the first two classes are apparent in Table 3 of Bildsten et al. 1997): (1) Systems with Porb . 10 days and e . 0.1: The low orbit period and low eccentricity indicate that tidal circularization has played a significant role. So one cannot obtain constraint on NS kicks from the observed orbital parameters. (2) Be X-ray binaries with moderately wide orbits and high eccentricities (Porb ∼ 20 − 100 days, e ∼ 0.3 − 0.5). The high eccentricities indicates these systems have -- 22 -- received large kicks, with a mean speed of ∼ 300 km s−1 (Table 7; see Pfahl et al. 2002). (3) Possibly another class of Be X-ray binaries has recently been identified by Pfahl et al. (2002) (see their Table 1). These systems are distinguished from the well-known Be X-ray binaries by their wide orbits (all have Porb > 30 days) and fairly low eccentricities (e . 0.2). The NSs born in these systems apparently have received only a small kick, . 50 km s−1. Pfahl et al. (2002) and van den Heuvel (2004) discussed possible origin for the bimodal kicks in the two classes of Be X-ray binaries. The eccentric Be X-ray binaries have similar orbital parameters as the pulsar/MS bi- naries discussed in §3.3. In Table 7 we list 5 Be X-ray binaries which belong to the second class discussed in the prevous paragraph. With the reasonable assumptions that the mass of the companion main-sequence star mB = 8 − 20 M⊙, the mass of the NS progenitor mAi = 2.1 − 8.0 M⊙ and the NS mass mA = 1.33 M⊙, the allowed range of kick velocities is given in Table 7. Since the angle θ is unknown, we find the kick directional angle γ is unconstrained for these systems, i.e. γ = 0◦ − 180◦ (see Table 7), similar to the PSR B1259- 63 case (cf. Table 5). The magnitude of the kick velocity ranges from 0 to several hundred km s−1. 4. Discussion 4.1. Tentative Inference from Observational data Our analysis of the velocity-spin correlation for isolated pulsars (§2) shows that kick is aligned with spin axis for many (but most likely not all) pulsars (see Table 1-2 and Fig. 1). Of particular interest is the fact that for pulsars with estimated initial spin periods (when such estimate can be made) less than ∼ 200 ms, the kick is apparently aligned with the spin axis to within the error of measurements (typically ±10◦; see Table 1). If we exclude PSR J0538+281 (for which Pinit ∼ 140 ms), the initial spin periods of these pulsars are all less than ∼ 70 ms. Of course, we should add the usual caveat that a pulsar might have experienced a phase of rapid spindown before electromagnetic braking begins, so that the actual spin period of the proto-NS may be shorter than the estimated Pinit. On the other hand, our analysis of SN kicks in NS binaries based on the observed spin- orbital property of various NS binaries (§3) shows that in a number of systems, the kick must not be aligned with the spin axis of the NS progenitor. How can we reconcile this conclusion with the apparent spin-kick alignment for many isolated pulsars? One possibility is that although the kick Vk is misaligned with the spin axis (denoted by SBi in §3) of the He star, it may still be aligned with the spin axis of the NS, since the NS -- 23 -- may get most of its angular momentum from off-centered kicks rather than from its He star progenitor (Spruit & Phinney 1998; see also Burrows et al. 1995). However, in the absence of any "primordial" angular momentum from the progenitor, a kick (of any duration) displaced by a distance s from the center, produces a spin of ≃ 12 (Vk/300 km s−1)(s/10 km) Hz, with the spin axis necessarily perpendicular to the velocity direction. If the kick is the result of many thrusts on the proto-NS (Spruit & Phinney 1998), the relative direction of the net kick and spin depends on how the orientation of each thrust is correlated with each other. Spin- kick alignment is possible in some circumstances, but is by no means a generic prediction of the "multiple thrusts" scenario. If the kick direction is not aligned with the He star spin (as we show for many NS binaries in §3), it will not be aligned with the NS spin in general, regardless of the origin of the NS spin. An important clue comes from the PSR 0045-7319/B-star system: The kick imparted to the pulsar at its birth is misaligned with its spin axis, and the initial spin period has been constrained to be Pinit > 0.5 s (see §3.3). Also, for PSR 0737-3039 (with pulsar B spin period P0 = 2.77 s) and many other NS/NS binaries, as well as for the PSR J1141- 6545/MWD system (with P0 = 0.39 s), the kick is misaligned with the spin axis. In addition, for the PSR J1740-3053/MS (with P0 = 0.57 s) system, the kick and spin may be misaligned. Combining these kick constraints obtained from NS binaries with the information we have about kicks in isolated pulsars, we are led to the following tentative suggestion: When the NS initial spin period is less than a few ×100 ms, the kick will be aligned the the spin axis; otherwise, the kick will in general not be aligned with the spin axis, except by chance. This suggestion, by no means definitive, is consistent with all the observational data on NS kicks in isolated pulsars and in NS binaries which have have analyzed/summarized in §2 and §3. We now discuss the implications of this suggestion for NS kick mechanisms. 4.2. Implications for kick mechanisms Many mechanisms for NS kicks have been suggested or studied. They generally fall into the following categories (e.g., Lai 2004; Janka et al. 2004). (i) Hydrodynamically driven kicks in which the SN explosion is asymmetric (with the explosion stronger in one direction than the other directions), and the NS receives a kick according to momentum conservation. Large-scale convections in the neutrino-heated mantle behind the stalled shock (at ∼ 100 km) may naturally lead to such asymmetric explosion, particularly when the delay between core bounce and shock revival is sufficiently long to -- 24 -- allow for small-scale convective eddies to merge into bigger ones (Scheck et al. 2004; see also Thompson 2000; Blondin & Mezzacappa 2005; Foglizzo et al. 2005). Pre-SN asymmetric perturbations due to convective O-Si burning (Bazan & Arnett 1998), amplified during core collapse (Lai & Goldreich 2000), may also play a role (Burrows & Hayes 1996; Goldreich et al. 1996; Fryer 2004). The kick timescale ranges from 10's ms to 100's ms. Obviously, detailed calculations of this class of mechanisms are still uncertain -- such a calculation/simulation is an integral part of the general problem of SN explosion mechanism. (ii) Magnetic-Neutrino Driven kicks rely on asymmetric neutrino emission induced by strong magnetic fields. This could arise because the strong magnetic field modifies the neu- trino opacities either through standard weak-interaction physics (e.g. Dorofeev et al. 1985; Lai & Qian 1998; Arras & Lai 1999a,b; Duan & Qian 2005) or through nonstandard physics (e.g., Fuller et al. 2003; Lambiase 2005). It could also arise from the dynamical effect of the magnetic field on the proto-NS (e.g., the B field can affect the neutrino-driven convec- tion/instabilities, and thus creating dark or hot neutrino spots; Duncan & Thompson 1992; Socrates et al. 2004). All these effects are important only when the magnetic field of the proto-NS is stronger than 1015 G. The kick timescales are of order the neutrino diffusion time, a few seconds. (iii) Electromagnetically driven kicks involve radiation from off-centered rotating dipole, which, for appropriate dipole orientation/displacement, imparts a gradual acceleration to the pulsar along its spin axis (Harrison & Tademaru 1975; Lai et al. 2001). This effect is important only if the NS initial period is . 2 ms. The kick time is of order the initial spin-down time (≃ 107 s for B = 1013 G and Pinit = 14 ms). (iv) Other mechanisms are possible if the collapsing iron core has large angular momen- tum. For example, the combination of rapid rotation and magnetic field may lead to bipolar jets from the SN, and a slight asymmetry between the two jets will lead to a large kick (e.g. Khokhlov et al. 1999; Akiyama et al. 2003). Another mechanism could be that, if a rapidly rotating core fragments into a double proto-NS binary (current numerical simulation indicates this is unlikely; see Fryer & Warren 2003), the explosion of the lighter proto-NS (after mass transfer) could give the remaining NS a kick (Colpi & Wasserman 2002; see also Davis et al. 2002). It is of interest to use observations to constrain or rule out some of these mechanisms. Since the initial spin period of radio pulsars is ≫ 1 ms, (iii) and (iv) appear unlikely in general. The observed dipole magnetic field of most radio pulsars lies in the range 1012 − 1013 G, but it is not clear whether most proto-NSs can have (even transient) magnetic fields stronger than 1014 G. So we cannot easily rule out (ii). Regarding spin-kick alignment/misalignment, the crucial point is the ratio between the initial spin period Pinit and kick timescale τkick. In hydrodynamically driven kicks (i) and magnetic-neutrino driven kicks (ii), the primary thrust to the NS does not depend on the NS spin axis. But the net kick will be affected by rotational averaging if Pinit is much less than τkick. Let V0 be the kick velocity that the NS attains in the case of zero rotation, and θk be the angle between the primary asymmetry and the rotation axis. The expected components of kick along the rotation axis and perpendicular to it are (for τkick ≫ Pinit) -- 25 -- √2 P 2π τkick Vkickk = V0 cos θk, Vkick⊥ ∼ V0 sin θk. (8) Thus the angle γ between the kick vector Vkick and the spin axis is given by tan γ ∼ 0.2(Pinit/τkick) tan θk. Typically, the spin-kick alignment will be achieved when τkick ≫ Pinit. The observed spin-kick alignment for Pinit . 100's ms discussed in §4.1 therefore suggests that τkick lies between hundreds of ms to 1 s. Such kick timescale is consistent with magnetic- neutrino driven mechanisms or hydrodynamical mechanisms with long-delayed SN explo- sions. Obviously, this conclusion is far from definitive. For example, since the primary thrust may be applied at a distance larger than the NS radius, a somewhat more stringent con- dition on Pinit is required to produce spin-kick alignment (see Lai et al. 2001). In another word, the inequality Pinit ≪ τkick is a necessary (but not sufficient) condition for spin-kick alignment. Also, an initial spin period of order 100's ms could be generated by the SN kick itself (see above). We have argued (see §4.1) that a kick-induced spin without "primordial" angular momentum (i.e. from the progenitor) would not in general give rise to spin-velocity alignment. The situation may be different with even a modest primordial spin. We plan to study these issues in the future. This work is supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (10328305, 1025313 and 10473015). DL has also been supported in part by NSF grant AST 0307252 and NASA grant NAG 5-12034. DL thanks IAS (Princeton), CITA (Toronto), Tsinghua University (Beijing) and particularly NAOC (Beijing) for hospitality during the course of the work. Anderson, B. & Lyne, A. G. 1983, Nature, 303, 597 REFERENCES Akiyama, S., Wheeler, J. C., Meier, D. L., & Lichtenstadt, I. 2003, ApJ, 584, 954 -- 26 -- Arras, P. & Lai, D. 1999a, PhRvD, 60, 3001A Arras, P. & Lai, D. 1999b, ApJ, 519, 745 Arzoumanian, Z., Chernoff, D. F., & Cordes, J. M. 2002, ApJ, 568, 289 Bailes, M., Ord, S. M., Knight, H. S., & Hotan, A. W. 2003, ApJ, 595, 49 Bazan, G. & Arnett, D. 1998, ApJ, 496, 316 Belczynski, K., Kalogera, V., & Bulik, T. 2002, ApJ, 572, 407 Bildsten, L., Chakrabarty, D., & Chiu, J. et al. 1997, ApJS, 113, 367 Blondin, J. M. & Mezzacappa, A. 2005, astro-ph/0507181 Bock, D. C.-J. & Gvaramadze, V. V. 2002, A&A, 394, 533 Burrows, A. & Hayes, J. 1996, Phys. Rev. Lett., 76, 352 Burrows, A., Hayes, J.,& Fryxell, B. A. 1995, ApJ, 450, 830 Camilo, F., Manchester, R. N., & Gaensler, B. M. et al. 2002, ApJ, 567, 71 Caraveo, P. A. & Mignani, R. P. 1999, A&A, 344, 367 Champion, D. J. et al. 2004, MNRAS, 350, 61 Champion, D. J. et al. 2005, astro-ph/0508320 Chatterjee, S., Vlemmings, W. H. T., Cordes, J. M., & Chernoff, D. F. 2005, ApJ, submitted Coles, W. A., McLaughlin, M. A., Rickett, B. J., Lyne, A. G., & Bhat, N. D. R. 2005, ApJ, 623, 392 Colpi, M. & Wasserman, I. 2002, ApJ, 581, 1271 Cordes, J. M. & Chernoff, D. E. 1998, ApJ, 505, 315 Davies, M. B., King, A., Rosswog, S., & Wynn, G. 2002, ApJ, 579, 63 Deich, W. T. S & Kulkarni, S. R. 1996, in Compact Stars in Binaries, ed. J. van Paradijs et al., 279 Deshpande, A. A., Ramachandran, R., & Radhakrishnan, V. 1999, A&A, 351, 195 Dewey, R. J. & Cordes, J. M. 1987, ApJ, 321, 780 -- 27 -- Dewi, J. D. M., Podsiadlowski, Ph., & Pols, O. R. 2005, astro-ph/0507628 Dewi, J. D. M. & Pols, O. R. 2003, MNRAS, 344, 629 Dewi, J. D. M., et al. 2002, MNRAS, 331, 1027 Dewi, J. D. M. & van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 2004, MNRAS, 349, 169 Dodson, R. & Golap, K. 2002, MNRAS, 334, 1 Dodson, R. G., Legge, D., Reynolds, J. E., & McCulloch, P. M. 2003, ApJ, 596, 1137 Dorofeev, O. F., Rodionov, V. N., & Ternov, I. M. 1985, SvAL, 11, 123 Duan, H. Y. & Qian, Y. Z. 2005, astro-ph/0506033 Duncan, R. C. & Thompson, C. 1992, ApJ, 392, 9 Faulkner, A. J., Kramer, M. , & Lyne, A. G. et al. 2005, ApJ, 618, 119 Foglizzo, T., Scheck, L., & Janka, H. -Th. 2005, astro-ph/0507636 Fryer, Chris L. 2004, ApJ, 601, 175 Fryer, C., Burrows, A., & Benz, W. 1998, ApJ, 496, 333 Fryer, C. L. & Kalogera, V. 1997, ApJ, 489, 244 Fryer, C. L. & Warren, M. S. 2004, ApJ, 601, 391 Fryer, C. L., Warren, M. S., Holz, D. E., Hughes, S. A., & Dupuis, R. 2003, SPIE, 4856, 123 Fuller, G. M., Kusenko, A., Mocioiu, I., & Pascoli, S. 2003, PhRvD, 68, 3002 Gaensler, B. M. & Wallace, B. J. 2003, ApJ, 594, 326 Goldreich, P., Lai, D., & Sahrling, M. 1996, in "Unsolved Problems in Astrophysics", eds. J.N. Bahcall and J.P. Ostriker (Princeton Univ. Press) Gonzalez, M. & Safi-Harb, S. 2003, ApJ, 583, 91 Han, J. L. et al. 2005, in preparation. Hansen, B. M. S. & Phinney, E. S. 1997, MNRAS, 291, 569 Harrison, E. R. & Tademaru, E. 1975, ApJ, 201, 447 -- 28 -- Heger, A., Woosley, S. E., Langer, N., & Spruit, H. C. 2004, in Stellar Rotation, Proceedings of IAU Symposium No. 215, eds. A. Maeder & P. Eenens, 591 Helfand, D. J., Gotthelf, E. V., & Halpern, J. P. 2001, ApJ, 556, 380 Hills, J. G. 1983, ApJ, 267, 322 Hobbs, G., Lorimer, D. R., Lyne, A. G., & Kramer, M. 2005, MNRAS, 475 Hobbs, G., Lyne, A. G., & Kramer, M. 2004, MNRAS, 353, 1311 Hotan, A. W., Bailes, M., & Ord, S. M., 2005, ApJ, 624, 906 Hughes, J. P., Slane, P. O., & Burrows, D. N. 2001, ApJ, 559, 153 Hwang, U., Laming, J. M., & Badenes, C. 2004, ApJ, 615, 117 Iben, I. Jr. & Tutukov, A. V. 1996, ApJ, 456, 738 Ivanova, N., Belczynski, K., Kalogera, V., Rasio, F. A., & Taam, R. E. 2003, ApJ, 592, 475I Janka, H.-T., Scheck, L., & Kifonidis, K. et al. 2004, astro-ph/0408439 Johnston, S., Ball, L., Wang, N., & Manchester, R. N. 2005a, MNRAS, 358, 1069J Johnston, S. et al. 2005b, MNRAS, submitted Kaspi, V. M., Bailes, M., & Manchester, R. N. 1996, Nature, 381, 584 Khokhlov, A. M., et al. 1999, ApJ, 524, 107 Konacki, M., Wolszczan, A., & Stairs, I. H. 2003, ApJ, 589, 495 Kramer, M., Lyne, A. G., & Loehmer, O., et al. 2003, ApJ, 593, 31 Kramer, M., Lorimer, D. R., & Lyne, A. G., et al. 2005, astro-ph/0503386 Kulkarni, S. R., Clifton, T. C., & Backer, D. C. 1988, Nature, 331, 50 Kumar, P. & Quataert, E. J. 1997, ApJ, 479, 51 Lai, D. 1996, ApJ, 466, 35 Lai, D. 1997, ApJ, 490, 847 Lai, D. 2004, in Cosmic Explosions in 3D: Asymmetries in Supernovae and Gamma-ray Bursts. eds. P. Hoflich et al. (Cambridge Univ. Press), p.276 (astro-ph/0312542) -- 29 -- Lai, D., Bildsten, L., & Victoria M. 1995, ApJ, 452, 819 Lai, D., Chernoff, D. F., & Cordes, J. M. 2001, ApJ, 549, 1111 Lai, D. & Goldreich, P. 2000, ApJ, 535, 402L Lai, D. & Qian, Y. Z. 1998, ApJ, 505, 844 Lambiase, G. 2005, MNRAS, 362, 867 Leonard, D. C. & Filippenko, A. V. 2004, astro-ph/0409518 Lewandowski, W. et al. 2004, ApJ, 600, 905L Lorimer, D. R., Bailes, M., & Harrison, P. A. 1997, MNRAS, 289, 592 Lorimer, D. R., Lyne, A. G., & Anderson, B. 1995, MNRAS, 275, 16 Lorimer, D. R. et al. 2005, submitted to ApJ. Lyne, A. G., Burgay, M., & Kramer, M. 2004, Science, 303, 1153 Lyne, A. G. & Lorimer, D. R. 1994, Nature, 369, 127 Lyne, A. G., Pritchard, R. S., & Smith, F. G. 1993, MNRAS, 265, 1003 Lyutikov, M. & Thompson, C. 2005, astro-ph/0502333 Manchester, R. N. 1971, ApJS, 23, 283 Manchester, R. N., Hamilton, P. A., & McCulloch, P. M. 1980, MNRAS, 192, 153 Manchester, R. N., Hobbs, G. B., Teoh, A., & Hobbs, M. 2005, AJ, 129, 1993M McAdam, W. B., Osborne, J. L., & Parkinson, M. L. 1993, Nature, 361, 516 Melatos, A., Johnston, S., & Melrose, D. B. 1995, MNRAS, 275, 381 Migliazzo, J. M., Gaensler, B. M., & Backer, D. C. 2002, ApJ, 567, 141 Morris, D., et al. 1979, A&A, 73, 46 Ng, C.-Y. & Romani, R. W. 2004, ApJ, 601, 479 Nice, D. J., Sayer, R. W., & Taylor, J. H. 1996, ApJ, 466, 87 Pavlov, G. G., Sanwal, D., & Garmire, G. P. 2000, A&AS, 196, 3704 -- 30 -- Peters, P. C. 1964, Phys. Rev., 136, 1224 Pfahl, E., Rappaport, S., Podsiadlowski, P., & Spruit H. 2002, ApJ, 574, 364 Piran, Tsvi & Shaviv, Nir J. 2004, astro-ph/0409651 Portegies Zwart, S. F. & Verbunt, F. 1996, a, 309, 179P Qiao, G., Manchester, R. N., Lyne, A. G., & Gould, D. M. 1995, MNRAS, 274, 572bv Radhakrishnan, V. & Deshpande, A. A. 2001, A&A, 379, 551 Romani, R. W. 2004, astro-ph/0404100 Romani, R. W. & Ng, C.-Y. 2003, ApJ, 585, 41 Romani, R. W., Ng, C. -Y., Dodson, R., & Brisken, W. 2005, astro-ph/0506089 Scheck, L., Plewa, T., Janka, H.-Th., Kifonidis, K., & Mller, E. 2004, PhRvL, 92, 1103S Socrates, A., Blaes, O., Hungerford, A., & Fryer, C. L. 2004, astro-ph/0412144 Spruit, H. C. & Phinney, E. S. 1998, Nature, 393, 139 Stairs, I. H. 2004, Science, 304, 547 Stairs, I. H., Manchester, R. N., & Lyne, A. G. et al. 2001, MNRAS, 325, 979 Stairs, I. H., Manchester, R. N., & Lyne, A. G. et al. 2003, in Radio Pulsars, ASP Conf. Proceedings, ed. M. Bailes, D. J. Nice, & S. E. Thorsett, 302 Stairs, I. H., Thorsett, S. E., & Arzoumanian, Z. 2004, PhRvL, 93, 1101 Sun, X. H. & Han, J. L. 2004, MNRAS, 350, 232 Tademaru, E. 1977, ApJ, 214, 885 Tauris, T. M. & Sennels, T. 2000, A&A, 335, 236 Tauris, T. M. & van den Heuvel, E.P.J. 2004, in "Compact Stellar X-Ray Sources", eds. W.H.G. Lewin and M. van der Klis (Cambridge University Press) Taylor, J. H. & Cordes, J. M. 1993, ApJ, 411, 674 Thompson, C. 2000, ApJ, 534, 915 Thorsett, S. E., Arzoumanian, Z., McKinnon, M. M., & Taylor, J. H. 1993, ApJ, 405, 29 -- 31 -- Thorsett, S. E., Dewey, R. J., & Stairs, I. H. 2005, ApJ, 619, 1036 van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 2004, in Proc. of 5th Integral Science Workshop (astro-ph/0407451) van Kerkwijk, M. H. & Kulkarni, S. R. 1999, ApJ, 516, 25 van Ommen, T. D., et al. 1997, MNRAS, 287, 307V Wang, N., Johnston, S., & Manchester, R.N. 2004, MNRAS, 351, 599 Weisberg, J. M. & Taylor, J. H. 2003, ASPC, 302, 93 Wex, N. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 67 Wex, N., Johnston, S., & Manchester, R. N. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 997 Wex, N., Kalogera, V., & Kramer, M. 2000, ApJ, 528, 401 Wex, N. & Kopeikin, S. M. 1999, ApJ, 514, 388 Willems, B., Kalogera, V., & Henninger, M. 2004, ApJ, 616, 414 Wu, Xinji, Manchester, R. N., Lyne, A. G., Qiao, G. 1993, MNRAS, 261, 630W Yamaoka, H., Shigeyama, T., & Nomoto, K. 1993, A&A, 267, 433 Zahn, J.-P. 1989, A&A, 220, 112 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
astro-ph/0210516	1	0210	2002-10-23T15:29:09	Rotational mixing in low-mass stars : I Effect of the mu-gradients in main sequence and subgiant Pop I stars	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present a first set of results concerning stellar evolution of rotating low-mass stars. Our models include fully consistent transport of angular momentum and chemicals due to the combined action of rotation induced mixing (according to Maeder & Zahn 1998) and element segregation. The analysis of the effects of local variations of molecular weight due to the meridional circulation on the transport of angular momentum and chemicals are under the scope of this study. We apply this mechanism to low mass main sequence and subgiant stars of population I. We show that the so-called $\mu$-currents are of major importance in setting the shape of the rotation profile, specially near the core. Furthermore, as shown by Talon & Charbonnel (1998) and Charbonnel & Talon (1999) using models without $\mu$-currents, we confirm that rotation-induced mixing in stars braked via magnetic torquing can explain the blue side of the Li dip, as well as the low Li abundances observed in subgiants even when $\mu$-currents are taken into account. We emphasize that $\mu$ variations are not to be neglected when treating rotation-induced mixing, and that they could be of great importance for latter evolutionary stages.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. PTCF2002 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) September 24, 2013 2 0 0 2 t c O 3 2 1 v 6 1 5 0 1 2 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Rotational mixing in low-mass stars : I Effect of the µ-gradients in main sequence and subgiant Pop I stars Ana Palacios1 , Suzanne Talon2 , Corinne Charbonnel1 and Manuel Forestini3 1 Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Toulouse, CNRS UMR5572, OMP, 14, Av. E.Belin, 31400 Toulouse, France 2 D´epartement de Physique, Universit´e de Montr´eal, Montr´eal PQ H3C 3J7, Canada; CERCA, 5160 Boul. D´ecarie, Montr´eal PQ H3X 2H9, Canada 3 Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de l’Obs. de Grenoble, 414, rue de la Piscine, 38041 Grenoble Cedex 9, France the date of receipt and acceptance should be inserted later Abstract. We present a first set of results concerning stellar evolution of rotating low-mass stars. Our models include fully consistent transport of angular momentum and chemicals due to the combined action of rotation induced mixing (according to Maeder & Zahn 1998) and element segregation. The analysis of the effects of local variations of molecular weight due to the meridional circulation on the transport of angular momentum and chemicals are under the scope of this study. We apply this mechanism to low mass main sequence and subgiant stars of population I. We show that the so-called µ-currents are of ma jor importance in setting the shape of the rotation profile, specially near the core. Furthermore, as shown by Talon & Charbonnel (1998) and Charbonnel & Talon (1999) using models without µ-currents, we confirm that rotation-induced mixing in stars braked via magnetic torquing can explain the blue side of the Li dip, as well as the low Li abundances observed in subgiants even when µ-currents are taken into account. We emphasize that µ variations are not to be neglected when treating rotation-induced mixing, and that they could be of great importance for latter evolutionary stages. Key words. Stars: interiors, rotation, abundances - Hydrodynamics- Turbulence 1. Introduction Whereas standard stellar evolution models (allowing solely for mixing in convective regions) represent a good tool for a zeroth order description of stellar observations, they cannot account for series of abundance patterns observed in various locations of the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram. While some abundance anomalies are best explained in terms of surface features (as is the case of Am stars for example; see Turcotte et al. 2000), others probably involve deep mixing (as the He overabundances in O stars; see Maeder & Meynet 2000 for details). Rotation induced mixing, in the form of meridional circulation, baroclinic and shear instabilities, in conjunction with microscopic diffusion has been extensively used in order to reduce the discrepancies between standard models and observations, and has proved to be quite promising. However, following rotation induced mixing in stellar evolution codes is challenging and, up to now, many of the theoretical results from numerical computations have assumed some hypothesis that could be too restrictive. Send offprint requests to : Ana Palacios ; [email protected] mip.fr Here, we wish to further examine the role of horizontal chemical inhomogeneities in the evolution of meridional circulation. As first pointed out by Mestel (1953), meridional circu- lation is generated by a departure from spherical symme- try, and settles to restore it, but in turn generates itself a new dissymmetry: the meridian currents transport mate- rial with different mean molecular weights from one place to another of the radiative zone, so that a non-spherical µ-distribution is set up which retroacts on the circulation, diminishing its magnitude. In this early description, as- suming that the radiative zone does not suffer any local turbulent mixing and that the star remains in solid body rotation, this retroaction was actually shown to inhibit to- tally the circulation in chemically inhomogeneous regions. Kippenhahn (1974) pointed out the importance of tak- ing into account the changes in molecular weight, partic- ularly because a strong ∇µ may represent a barrier that hinders mixing. In the models he proposes to explain the Am phenomenon, Vauclair (1977) emphasizes also the im- portant role of the µ-barrier and underlines the fact that it can considerably delay mixing below the convective en- velope of slow rotators. This point, and more precisely the 2 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars retroaction effect of the µ-currents on meridional circula- tion still in the case of Am stars, was rediscussed further by Moss (1979). This idea of the chocking of meridional circulation by mean molecular gradients was pushed further by Zahn (1992). In the formalism he develops the vertical velocity of meridional circulation, U , can be written as the sum of two ma jor terms, one describing the effects of rotation in a homogeneous star, and the other accounting for the effects of chemical inhomogeneities on the circulation (see § 2). In this description, he emphasizes the fact that, due to the strong vertical stratification in stars, horizontal motions are much favoured compared to vertical ones and that strongly anisotropic turbulence is likely to set in (such a description is also used by Tassoul & Tassoul 1982). The effect of that turbulence is to mix chemicals horizontally, thus slowly destroying the horizontal inhomogeneities that give rise to µ-currents. Vauclair (1999) uses simplified expressions for rota- tional mixing and couples them to microscopic diffusion in order to examine their combined effect in slowly solid- body rotating stars. After the build-up of the horizontal µ gradients that block the Ω-currents as in Mestel’s descrip- tion, she describes a self-regulated process which could freeze both meridional circulation and gravitational set- tling. In the present paper, we present complete treatment of rotation induced mixing, including meridional circula- tion, turbulence by shear instabilities and microscopic dif- fusion. We will describe the effects of such a combination of processes on the transport of both angular momentum and chemical species in main sequence and subgiant Pop I stars. Concerning the later point, we refer to the papers of Talon & Charbonnel (1998) and Charbonnel & Talon (1999) (hereafter TC98 and CT99 respectively) who in- vestigated these kind of processes under the scope of the so-called lithium dip problem, but did not include the ef- fects of the variations of the mean molecular weight on the mixing. We will only consider stars that, according to obser- vations in open clusters, lie on the hot side of the lithium dip. Indeed, as pointed out by TC98, other transport pro- cesses for momentum are known to act in lower mass stars. In particular, the rotation induced mixing we implemented here fails to reproduce the solar rotation profile as inferred from helioseismology (Matias & Zahn, 1997), a conclu- sion also reached using other versions of detailed rotation induced mixing (Chaboyer, Demarque, & Pinsonneault, 1995). TC98 suggested that the additional mechanism re- sponsible for momentum transport in the Sun could well explain the rise of Li abundances on the red side of the Li dip, and it is the point of view we adopt here by restricting our study to the blue side. We intend to apply our description of rotational in- duced mixing to abundance anomalies in evolved stars (red giants) in a forthcoming study and will therefore set here the theoretical stage that we will use in this and in papers to come. In § 2, we give a detailed description of the physics at work, recalling the basis of the theory pre- sented in Zahn (1992) and Maeder & Zahn (1998). We will then (§ 3) describe the numerical method as well as the in- puts used in the models presented. In § 4 we compare the models including mixing to standard evolutionary tracks, and analyze in more details the effects of the µ-currents on the transport in § 5. We will finally compare our results to observations of main sequence and subgiant stars in § 6, before giving a summary and conclusions in § 7. 2. Rotation induced mixing Meridional circulation takes place in the radiative inte- riors of rotating stars where it is generated by the ther- mal imbalance induced by the departure from spherical symmetry (Eddington 1925, Vogt 1926). Once established, this large scale circulation generates in turn advection of momentum and thus favours the development of strong horizontal diffusion through shear instability, which is the main source of turbulence1 (Zahn 1992, Talon & Zahn 1997, Maeder & Zahn 1998). On the other hand, verti- cal turbulence is partly inhibited due to the high level of stratification in this direction. Under these conditions of strong anisotropic turbu- lence, one can use the hypothesis of the so-called “shellular rotation” (Zahn 1992). In this configuration Ω ≃ Ω(P ) for differential rotation is weak on isobars. All quantities de- pend solely on pressure and can be split into a mean value and its latitudinal perturbation f (P, θ) = f (P ) + f (P )P2 (cos θ) (1) where P2 (cos θ) is the Legendre polynomial of order two. The combined effects of meridional circulation and hori- zontal turbulence lead to the vertical transport of chemical species and angular momentum. The transport of angular momentum obeys an advection-diffusion equation treated in Lagrangian coor- dinates, namely d (cid:0)r2Ω(cid:1)dt ∂ r (cid:19) , ∂ r (cid:18)r4 ρνv ∂Ω ∂ r being the radius, ρ the density and νv the vertical com- ponent of the turbulent viscosity. The vertical component of the meridional velocity is given by (ρr4ΩU r) + 1 5r2 ∂ ∂ r 1 r2 ρ = (2) × U (r) = P Cp ρT g [∇ad − ∇ + ϕ/δ∇µ ] (cid:20) L ∂ t (cid:21) (3) ∂Θ M where L is the luminosity, M the mass, P the pressure, Cp the specific heat at constant pressure, T the temper- ature, ∇ad , ∇ and ∇µ the adiabatic, radiative and mean molecular weight gradients respectively (Maeder & Zahn (EΩ + Eµ ) + CpT δ 1 Baroclinic instabilities might set in as well, but we adopt the view that they will be less efficient than the shear. This point is discussed by Zahn (1992) and Talon & Zahn (1997). Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 3 1998). g is the modulus of the effective gravity, defined by the hydrostatic equilibrium equation g = ∇Φ + 1 2 Ω2∇s2 . (4) ϕ = −ξµ/ξρ and δ = ξT /ξρ , where ξµ , ξρ and ξT are the coefficients in the general expression of the equation of state (6) δ (cid:19) Θ(cid:21) 1 We have considered non-stationarity, foreseeing papers to come where the mixing processes described here will be further investigated inside RGB stars. The effects of non-stationarity on the circulation, which need to be in- cluded as soon as nuclear burning takes place in shells, appear through the terms ∂Θ/∂ t and εgrav (Maeder & Zahn 1998). As shown by Chaboyer & Zahn (1992), the vertical transport of chemicals through the combined action of vertical advection and strong horizontal diffusion can be described as a pure diffusive process. Indeed, splitting the concentration ci of the ith element according to Eq. (1), the advective transport in the rigorous evolution equation for the mean concentration ∂ r (cid:21) ∂ r (cid:20)r2 ρDv ∂ ci ∂ can be replaced by a diffusive term, with an effective dif- fusion coefficient given by ∂ r2ρ h ciU i ∂ r ∂ ci ∂ t 1 r2 1 r2 (9) + = Deff = rU (r)2 30Dh . (10) ρ + dci dt The vertical transport of chemicals then obeys a diffu- sion equation which, in addition to this macroscopic trans- port, also accounts for (vertical) turbulent transport, mi- croscopic diffusion (see § 3) and nuclear reactions: ∂ 1 ∂ r (cid:2)r2 ρUdiff ci (cid:3) = ci + r2 ∂ r (cid:21) . ∂ r (cid:20)r2 ρ (Deff + Dv ) ∂ ci ∂ Microscopic diffusion appears through the velocity term (∝ Udiff ), and ci represents the variations of chemical com- position due to nuclear reactions. Dv is the vertical tur- bulent diffusion coefficient, taken equal to the turbulent viscosity (Zahn 1992). The total diffusion coefficient Dtot for chemicals can be written as the sum of three coeffi- cients: 1 r2 (11) Dtot = Dmic + Deff + Dv . (12) Λ is tightly related to the horizontal inhomogeneities of chemicals, and obeys a similar law as the concentration of the chemicals under the assumption of shellular rotation, + U (13) = − ∂Λ ∂ t ∂ ln µ ∂ r 6 r2 DhΛ (see Chaboyer & Zahn 1992 and Maeder & Zahn 1998 for details). Even though this equation admits a stationary solution for t ≫ r2 /6Dh , we will follow its time evolu- tion since it allows for greater stability in the numerical algorithms. Because of the low viscosity in stellar interiors, verti- cal shear due to differential rotation eventually becomes turbulent, and we will assume that this instability domi- nates, noting that baroclinic instabilities may also grow. However, development of the shear instability is possible only under certain conditions which are fulfilled when the + − − + − (5) d ln ρ d ln µ. d ln T + d ln P = ∂ ln ρ (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)T ,µ ∂ ln P {z } ξρ ∂ ln µ (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)T ,ρ ∂ ln T (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)ρ,µ ∂ ln P ∂ ln P {z {z } } ξµ ξT EΩ and Eµ depend respectively on the rotation profile and on the mean molecular weight as EΩ = 2 "1 − # g (ε + εgrav ) Ω2 − 2πGρ g εm δ (cid:19) − χT (cid:18) Θ dr (cid:20)HT ρ (cid:26) r dr (cid:18) Θ δ (cid:19) + (cid:18)1 − ρm d d − 3 r (cid:18)1 + K (cid:19) (cid:18) Θ δ (cid:19) + Θ(cid:27) 2 Dh 2HT 3 δ (cid:19) + (fε εT − χT ) (cid:18) Θ dr (cid:18) Θ δ (cid:19) (cid:20)HT (ε + εgrav ) d − εm + (cid:18)2 − fε − δ (cid:19) Θ(cid:21) 1 and dr (cid:20)HT ρ (cid:26) r d ρm 3 Λ(cid:17)(cid:27) r (cid:16) ϕ 2HT δ (cid:20)HT (ε + εgrav ) εm (χT + 1)Λi , where HT is the temperature scale height, K the thermal diffusivity and fε ≡ ε/(ε + εgrav ), with ε and εgrav being respectively the mean nuclear and gravitational energy. χµ and εµ are logarithmic derivatives of the radiative conductivity χ and the total energy ε with respect to µ, while derivatives with respect to T are noted as χT and εT . Λ(cid:17) + fε (εT + Λ(cid:17) − (χµ + dr (cid:16) ϕ d δ dr (cid:16) ϕ d δ )Λ(cid:21) εµ ) − χµ Eµ = χT + ϕ δ ϕ δ ϕ δ ϕ δ (7) εm (r) ≡ L(r)/M (r) and ρm is the mean density inside the considered level surface. Dh is the horizontal diffusion coefficient (see Eq. 18). Θ and Λ are the relative variations over an isobar of density and mean molecular weight respectively, with Θ = ρ ρ = r2 3g dΩ2 dr and Λ = µ µ . (8) 4 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars flow satisfies to both the Reynolds and the Richardson instability criteria. The Richardson criterion compares the stabilizing ef- fect of the entropy gradient to the amount of energy that can be extracted from differential rotation. The instability condition is in general written as . 1 4 (14) Ri = ≤ Ricrit N 2 (du/dz )2 ≤ Ricrit ≃ This criterion is extremely severe and is seldom satisfied in stellar interiors. However, as first pointed out by Townsend (1958), thermal diffusivity can decrease the stabilizing effect of entropy stratification. Maeder (1995) used this character- istic to show that in actual conditions, there will always exist a small enough length scale that will make the fluid unstable. The modified Richardson criterion becomes Ri = (cid:16) Γ Γ+1 (cid:17) N 2 T + N 2 µ (du/dz )2 where Γ = vℓ/6K , v is the turbulent velocity, ℓ the tur- bulent length scale, K is the thermal diffusivity, N 2 T is the thermal part of the Brunt-Vaisala frequency and N 2 µ is related to mean molecular weight gradients. Γ can be viewed as a turbulent Peclet number, the turbulent vis- cosity νv = vℓ replacing the normal microscopic viscosity. The turbulent viscosity is then obtained by setting the equality in Eq. (15). Further discussion on these topics may be found in Canuto (1998), who suggests that, in such a context, the critical Richardson number might ac- tually be closer to unity. In order for the instability to grow, the associated tur- bulent viscosity must also be larger than the microscopic viscosity ν , as expressed by the Reynolds criterion (15) νv ≤ νRec (16) where Rec is the critical Reynolds number (≃ 10). The estimation of the appropriate formulation for the Richardson criterion is critical to give a good estimation of the turbulent viscosity, and in turn of the turbulent diffusion coefficient. Meynet & Maeder (2000) present a critical review of the different expressions proposed so far concerning this coefficient. In the present work, we shall take the expression derived by Talon & Zahn (1997) for the vertical component of the turbulent viscosity , 8 5 (17) Dv = νv = Ricrit(rdΩ/dr)2 N 2 T /(K + Dh ) + N 2 µ /Dh which adds to Maeder’s prescription by also taking into account the weakening effect of the strong horizontal dif- fusion on the entropy stratification associated with the (vertical) µ gradients. The factor 8 5 includes, in addition to a geometrical factor, the coefficient 2 5 found by Maeder (1995) when deriving the criterion for shear instabilities assuming spherical geometry for the turbulent eddies. Dh is the horizontal diffusion coefficient and is such as Dh ≫ Dv , thus leading to strong anisotropic turbulence, − 1 2 Dh = d ln ρr2U d ln r which is one of the basic hypothesis of the derivation pre- sented. This coefficient appears directly in Eq. (13) de- scribing the evolution of the variations of Λ, as well as in the vertical and effective diffusivity coefficients. Its evalu- ation is the weakest point of the theory first developed by Zahn (1992). In the present paper, we use an expression linking this coefficient to the advection of angular momen- tum d ln r (cid:21) . Ch (cid:20) 1 d ln r2Ω rU 3 Ch is a free parameter of order unity (see Zahn 1992) which describes the weakening effect of horizontal turbu- lence on the vertical transport of chemicals. It appears through Dh in both effective (Deff ) and turbulent (Dv ) diffusion coefficients as can be seen from Eq. (10) and −1 , the net effect of vary- (17). As Deff ∝ Ch and Dv ∝ Ch ing this parameter on the global diffusion coefficient Dtot might not be very important. On the other hand, the magnitude of turbulent dif- fusion Dv depends on Ricrit (see Eq. 17). Changing the Richardson criterion as previously suggested, by using a larger critical number Ricrit , will result in an enhancement of Dv and in turn of the global diffusion coefficient. (18) 3. Numerical simulations : inputs We present and discuss models computed with the Grenoble stellar evolution code, STAREVOL. We included the transport of angular momentum and chemical species due to the combined action of meridional circulation, tur- bulence and microscopic diffusion (in the case of chemi- cals), following the formalism of Maeder & Zahn (1998) as described in the previous section. 3.1. Numerical treatment of the transport of angular momentum The 4th order differential equation for the transport of an- gular momentum (Eq. 2) is split into four 1st order equa- tions. The system is complemented by Eq. (13) in order to follow the feedback of variations of the mean molecular weight on transport. We use the Newton-Raphson method according to Henyey (1964) to solve for angular momentum trans- port within the evolutionary code. The first boundary conditions impose momentum conservation at convective boundaries r4 ρ dr# = − ∂ t "Ω Z R ∂ rt r4 ρ dr(cid:21) = ∂ t (cid:20)Ω Z rb 1 ∂ r4 ρΩU 5 0 We complement them by requiring the absence of differ- ential rotation at convective boundaries r4 ρΩU + FΩ for r = rb . for r = rt 1 5 ∂Ω ∂ r = 0 for r = rt , rb Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 5 (19) We also impose Λ = 0 there, a natural consequence of the fact that convective regions are assumed to be chemically homogeneous. rt and rb correspond to the top (surface) and bottom (center) of the radiative zone respectively. FΩ represents the torque applied at the surface of the star. Note that momentum conservation is equivalent to U = 0 when there is no convective core. In the models presented here, we considered a classical perfect gas so that δ = ϕ = 1 in Eqs. (3), (5) and (7). We also used Ch = 1 and Ric = 0.25, thus not allowing these two parameters to vary. The transport of chemicals according to Eq. (11) is treated via a finite element method. Boundary conditions impose conservation of the integrated mass of each ele- ment and can be written as follows ∂ t "ci Z R r2 ρ dr# = −r2 ρ (Udiff ci ) − r2 ρ (Dv + Deff ) ∂ ci ∂ ∂ r rt − M ci for r = rt ∂ t (cid:20)ci Z rb r2 ρ dr(cid:21) = r2 ρ (Udiff ci ) + r2 ρ (Dv + Deff ) ∂ ci ∂ ∂ r 0 for r = rb , where M is the mass loss rate. induced mixing is We emphasize that rotational treated in a self-consistent way and that coupling to the evolutionary code ensures feedback of transport mecha- nisms on structure at all evolutionary phases. 3.2. Structure equations One of the basic effects of rotation on internal structure is to break the spherical symmetry of the star. Rigorously, corrections due to this departure from spherical symmetry should thus be applied when writing the internal struc- ture equations. Meynet & Maeder (1997) developed a for- malism suitable in the “shellular rotation” context. They showed that rotation has little influence on the hydrostatic structure of massive stars, while the effects at the stellar surface (in particular on the effective temperature) may be important. In the HR diagram, these effects may be of the same order of magnitude as those due to mixing. In the present work, we made the assumption of negligi- ble departures from spherical symmetry, and we did not include these corrections (i.e., stellar structure equations are solved in a standard way). The effects on surface pa- rameters such as L and Teff discussed here are thus only due to rotation-induced mixing. 3.3. Evolution of the rotational surface velocity As already mentioned, we only consider stars hotter than 6500 K on the ZAMS, associated to the hot side of the lithium dip in open clusters. We refer to the work of Gaig´e (1993) on the Hyades F-stars to choose the initial velocity of our models and further determine the braking to be ap- plied according to the temperature. For further discussion dJ dt = (Ω ≤ Ωsat ) (Ω > Ωsat ). on rotation in F-stars, the reader is referred to TC98 and CT99 where these aspects are more extensively discussed. In the present paper, stars have an initial velocity of 110 km.s−1 and are assumed to undergo magnetic brak- ing while arriving on main sequence (see Tab. 2) as sug- gested by the early work of Schatzman (1962). This brak- ing was proved to be more efficient for thicker convective envelopes, that is to say for lower masses at given metallic- ity, a trend which is confirmed by the observations. Their rotational velocity is further reduced to only a few km.s−1 when they are on the subgiant branch due to the star’s ex- pansion. The braking law adopted follows the description of Kawaler (1988)  R⊙ (cid:19)1/2 (cid:18) M M⊙ (cid:19)−1/2 −K Ω3 (cid:18) R  R⊙ (cid:19)1/2 (cid:18) M M⊙ (cid:19)−1/2 sat (cid:18) R −K Ω Ω2 This formulation corresponds to a field geometry interme- diate between a dipolar and a radial field (Kawaler 1988). Neglecting the evolution of stellar structure and assum- ing solid body rotation, this leads to a Skumanich law in t−1/2 for the surface velocity. It is widely used in the lit- erature (Chaboyer et al. 1995, Krishnamurti et al. 1997, Bouvier et al. 1997, Sills & Pinsonneault 2000). The pa- rameter Ωsat expresses the fact that magnetic field gener- ation saturates at some critical value, as shown by various diagnostics of magnetic activity (see Saar 1996 and refer- ences therein). This saturation is actually required in or- der to retain a sufficient amount of fast rotators in young clusters, as originally suggested by Stauffer & Hartmann (1987). The constant K is related to the magnitude of the magnetic field strength. In particular, in the mass range we are studying here, the convection zone shrinks signif- icantly from the 1.35M⊙ to the 1.8M⊙ model, and this parameter, which is normally calibrated on the Sun and taken to be a constant in all stars (see Bouvier et al. 1997) could very well vary here. In studies of stars less massive than ∼ 1.2M⊙ , there is a suggestion that Ωsat varies with mass, and a scaling in τ −1 conv is invoked (Barnes & Sofia 1996, Krishnamurti et al. 1997, Bouvier et al. 1997, Sills & Pinsonneault 2000). This is required to explain the fact that K stars rotate more rapidly than G stars in the Hyades. However, any diagnosis depends on the actual model for momentum dis- tribution in the stellar interior. For the masses under the scope of this study, braking remains much smaller than it is for lower mass stars, as reflected by the fact that at the age of the Hyades, even the less massive model is still rotating at 30 km.s−1 . Table 1 presents the rotational characteristics of our models, as well as the global convective time-scale as de- fined by Kim & Demarque (1996) τconv = Z R rt dr/vconv . (20) 6 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars Table 1. Rotational parameters of the models M (M⊙ ) 1.35 KΩ2 sat 2.3 × 1043 τconv days 6.0 1.4 4.4 × 1042 4.0 1.5 5.1 × 1041 3.4 1.8 7.1 × 1040 0.44 Teff (K ) 6620 6630 6625 6770 6760 6745 7080 7045 6990 8280 8020 7625 v (km.s−1 ) 70.3 43.6 30.6 97.5 66.2 46.3 100 83.0 76.0 110 94.4 84.1 Age α Per Pleiades Hyades α Per Pleiades Hyades α Per Pleiades Hyades α Per Pleiades Hyades The scaling of K Ω2 sat is clearly not inversely proportional to τconv . Furthermore, braking for stars more massive than ∼ 1.35M⊙ is less efficient than it is in lower mass stars, while their convective time-scales are lower. We are thus lead to believe it is a mass range for which the value of K itself varies, in agreement with our knowledge that it is also a transition region for stellar activity. Let us note that all our calculations were performed in the saturated regime, and that our stars follow the evo- lution of the mean velocity for the 3 considered clusters (α Per, Pleiades, Hyades). It is thus not possible to disen- tangle the effect of a variation of Ωsat and a variation of K . 3.4. Treatment of the microscopic diffusion We included microscopic diffusion in the form of gravita- tional settling as well as that related to thermal gradients, using the formulation of Paquette et al. (1986). Atomic diffusion for trace elements Li, Be, B must be addressed with care in the limited range of effective temperature on the left side of the Li dip. Indeed, Richer & Michaud (1993) showed that, for main sequence stars with an ef- fective temperature in the range ∼ 6900 − 7100 K, radia- tive forces on Li and Be could lead to increased surface abundances, at least if large scale mixing is not efficient enough to counter balance them. The recent discovery of a slowly rotating Li rich dwarf (Deliyannis et al. 2002) is nicely explained in this framework. This had lead TC98 and CT99 to remove microscopic diffusion on those ele- ments, in the corresponding temperature range. Here, we adopt a different view point. We compute a first series of models including microscopic diffusion (but not radiative forces) on all light elements. Then, for stars in the range of effective temperature between ∼ 6900 − 7100 K, we also compute models without microscopic diffusion on Li, Be and B. The differences between these two series of models give an indication of the amount of microscopic diffusion that remains in our rotating models. As we shall show, this amount is minute. One must keep in mind though that the real effect of microscopic diffusion in these stars will be to slightly enhance Li and Be abundances rather than diminish them. Let us note that radiative forces have a magnitude which is similar to that of settling (see Richer et al. 2000 Figs. 5 & 6). Thus, if mixing is efficient enough to (almost) in- hibit settling, it will also inhibit levitation by radiation. For main sequence stars with Teff > 7100 K, radiative forces do not play a ma jor role compared to atomic diffu- sion, which is thus the only process (apart from rotation- induced mixing) which is applied. 3.5. Input physics A rather detailed description of our stellar evolution code can be found in Siess et al. (1997) (see also Siess et al. (2000) for more recent aspects). As far as main sequence and subgiant models are concerned, let us briefly sum- marize here the relevant physics. Our equation of state has been developed from the Pols et al. (1995) formal- ism. Thermodynamical features of each plasma compo- nent (ions, electrons and photons, as well as H− and H2 ) are obtained by minimizing the Helmholtz free energy that includes separately non-ideal effects (Coulomb shielding and pressure ionisation). In input, instead of the usual pressure or density variable, it uses a new independent variable that describes the electron degeneracy. This al- lows in turn to treat analytically the ionisation process and provides very smooth profiles of thermodynamical quanti- ties. It is particularly well suited to treat partially ionised and partially degenerated regions, pressure ionisation and Coulomb interactions in a stellar evolution code. More de- tails about this equation of state are given in Siess et al. (2000). Radiative opacities are interpolated from Alexander & Fergusson (1994) at temperatures below 8000 K, and from Iglesias & Rogers (1996) at higher temperatures. Atmospheres are integrated in the gray, plan-parallel and Eddington approximations. Our nuclear reaction network allows to follow the abundance evolution of 53 species (from 1H to 37Cl) through 180 reactions. All nuclear re- action rates have been updated with the NACRE com- pilation (Angulo et al., 1999). The value of αp = l/Hp , the ratio of the mixing length to the pressure scale height, is taken equal to 1.75. No overshooting is considered for convection. 4. Global characteristics of the models We present evolutionary results for five different masses (1.35, 1.4, 1.5, 1.8 and 2.2 M⊙ ) at Z = 0.02. Models include complete treatment of angular momentum and chemicals transport, taking into account the effects of changes of µ (Eµ 6= 0) and applying microscopic diffusion to all ele- ments. These models sample the effective temperature domain covered by the observations of main-sequence stars on the hot side of the lithium dip in young open clusters Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 7 Table 2. Characteristics of the stellar models and rotation velocities. Models computed with Z = 0.02. The turn-off (TO) is defined as the point for which the central hydrogen mass fraction is lower than 10−9 . M (M⊙ ) 1.35 1.4 1.5 1.8 2.2 vinit (km.s−1 ) 110 0 110 0 110 0 110 0 110 0 vHyades (km.s−1 ) 30 0 51 0 80 0 82 0 77 0 Teff ,TO (K) 6113 6328 6218 6451 6382 6585 7001 7255 8034 8228 LTO (L⊙ ) 5.92 5.68 6.92 6.42 8.80 8.38 17.81 17.17 39.41 39 tTO (Gyrs) 4.140 3.418 3.555 2.885 2.967 2.404 1.470 1.317 0.788 0.746 with nearly solar metallicity such as the Hyades, Coma Berenices and Praesepe. They also span the mass range of Pop I subgiants to which our results will be compared in a further section (§ 6). In Fig. 1, we plot the evolutionary tracks of our ro- tating models in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram (solid lines), comparing them to their standard analogs (dashed lines). Table 2 presents some characteristics of the computed models with and without rotation. All models were com- puted with the same set of parameters for rotation induced mixing (Ch = 1 and Ricrit = 0.25), but with different ro- tational histories (see § 3.2). One can see clearly how mixing affects main-sequence evolution. In rotating models, the turn-off is moved to- wards cooler temperatures while the luminosity is slightly enhanced. Due to surface effects, still cooler effective tem- peratures (by up to ∼ 100 K in the fastest stars considered here) would be obtained if the effects of rotation on struc- ture equations were taken into account (Per´ez Hern´andez et al. 1999). Let us note that the actual value depends on the inclinaison angle of the star. Our models are computed without convective core overshooting. We checked however that for the 1.8M⊙ model, the effect of mixing on main sequence lifetime and on the turnoff in the HRD is equivalent to an overshoot- ing distance for convection of about 0.1HP (where HP is the pressure scale height at the edge of the classical core). This value is smaller than the one (0.2) typically used to fit the observed color-magnitude diagrams of young and in- termediate age galactic open clusters (Meynet et al. 1993, Lebreton 2000 and references therein) . Whether the ro- tating models would fit the cluster isochrones remains to be checked. This requires a more extended grid of masses and is out of the scope of the present paper. On the subgiant branch, stars evolve at higher lumi- nosities. This is due to the effect of microscopic diffusion during the main sequence phase. Indeed, even if it is partly balanced by the action of large scale mixing, microscopic Fig. 1. HR diagrams for the five masses considered in this paper. Dashed lines are for standard models and solid lines are for models with the “complete mixing” and Ch = 1. Masses are as indicated on the plot. Z = 0.02 for all models presented. diffusion leads to the build up of a negative helium gradi- ent at the base of the convective envelope. When the first dredge-up begins, the envelope encounters regions with a lower opacity (due to enhancement of helium) leading to enhanced luminosities compared to standard models. When reaching the RGB, differences in effective tempera- ture and luminosity between standard and rotating models become marginal: both tracks are almost identical in the HR diagram (see Fig. 1). Models with rotational mixing behave as if their metal- licity was lower than in the standard cases. This trend was already emphasized by CT99. On the other hand, the lifetimes of rotating models are enhanced with respect to those of standard models. In fact, due to the positive slope of the hydrogen profile, mixing slightly feeds the core with fresh hydrogen fuel. The exhaustion of hydrogen in the central region is delayed and the time spent on main sequence increases. In the mass range we are studying here, the less mas- sive the star, the more turn-off ages differ between rotat- ing and non-rotating models2 . This trend with mass has to be related to braking, which is more important for lower mass stars as imposed by both theory and observations. Stronger mixing corresponds to a more efficient extraction of angular momentum at the surface, thus leading to en- hanced meridional circulation and mixing. There should 2 The time spent on the main sequence is increased by more than 20% in the lower mass stars, and by ≈ 10% in the higher mass models. 8 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars thus be a correlation between mixing and braking, as we will show from the comparison of our models with obser- vations (see § 6). 5. Effects of ∇µ and µ-currents To discuss the effects of chemical composition variations on transport, we will focus on the 1.5 M⊙ model. We present a comparative study of the results obtained with and without µ-currents (Eµ = 0 or Eµ 6= 0. In both cases all parameters are kept identical in order to make the com- parison clearer. Furthermore, we applied a torque so that surface velocity at the age of the Hyades (≃ 700 Myrs) is the same whether Eµ is zero or not. 5.1. Meridional circulation velocity U (r) Figure 2 presents profiles of U , Ω and the diffusion coef- ficient Dtot at different times on the main sequence, in- dicated in terms of central hydrogen mass fraction Xc . We superimpose the profiles obtained for Eµ = 0 (dashed lines) and Eµ 6= 0 (solid lines). When neglecting µ-currents (Eµ = 0), the meridional velocity is negative in the entire mixing zone. There is only one meridian loop that brings matter upwards at the equa- tor and down in polar regions. This leads to the extraction of angular momentum in the radiative zone, a consequence of braking. The amplitude of meridional velocity decreases as the star evolves and braking slows down. When Eµ is not zero, some changes appear. There are now two loops of circulation. In the outer parts of the radiative zone, the negative loop keeps on transporting material from the equator up along the pole, in response to the extraction of angular momentum. In the interior however, circulation is positive, revealing an inward trans- port of angular momentum. Equations (3), (5) and (7) already suggest a strong interaction between Ω- and µ- currents. Apart from the first term in Eq. (3), which in- cludes Eddington-Sweet and Gratton- Opik terms, EΩ and Eµ are almost mirrored. At the beginning of the evolu- tion, EΩ > Eµ , for µ-currents have not settled yet. As the star evolves and µ-gradients built-up, µ-currents may grow. Eµ and EΩ eventually become of the same order of magnitude, and U disminishes. Contrary to what was expected by Mestel (1953) the circulation is not frozen. Indeed, the two terms Eµ and EΩ , while being of the same order, never compensate each other as can be seen in Fig. 3, where U becomes very small, but never disappears completely. Indeed, due to the strength of the horizontal diffusion, the circulation must remain to continuously refresh the horizontal µ fluc- tuation. However, the difference between both contribu- tions EΩ and Eµ decreases significantly as the star evolves. Meridional circulation velocity is thus quite slow near the end of the main sequence, but transport of chemicals still occurs, as can be seen from the diffusion coefficient in Fig. 2. 5.2. Rotation profile Ω The inner transport of angular momentum also affects the rotation profiles (Fig. 2 middle panels): when including µ- currents, differential rotation grows larger. In particular, the core gains momentum and gets accelerated as evolu- tion proceeds instead of keeping a nearly constant rotation rate. This can be of crucial importance when further fol- lowing the evolution of the star on the red giant branch. This behaviour may be interpreted as follows: the rate of differential rotation and the relative variations of mean molecular weight are related to each other via the equa- tion of state (Eq. 5). Observations and theory show us that the circulation in main sequence stars on the hot side of the Li dip must act to extract angular momentum. In this configuration, the term EΩ creates an anti-clockwise cir- culation transporting matter from the pole down to the equator. Eµ , on the otherside, opposing EΩ (see Eq. 3), generates a clockwise circulation. The net effect is a re- duction of angular momentum transfer to the surface and an enhancement of differential rotation. In Fig. 4 we present profiles of Θ and Λ at given evo- lutionary points. The bold line represents the Θ profile in the absence of µ-currents. The difference between both is striking. It shows, as was already pointed out by Talon et al. (1997) in their study of a 9 M⊙ star, that the descrip- tion of the rotation profile and of the circulation is not anymore a matter of Θ (or Ω) alone, but of Θ − Λ. Indeed, Θ is then conditioned by Λ due again to their mirrored evolution (Eqs. 5 and 7). The large central differential rotation is a key ingredi- ent in core evolution. Indeed, µ-gradients in that region inhibit the development of a large turbulent diffusivity (see Eq. 13). However, the large shear resulting from the mirror evolution of Θ and Λ significantly increases local core mixing3 . Let us mention the work of Th´eado & Vauclair (2001), who performed calculations including the effects of µ- currents according to Vauclair (1999) in order to re- produce the low dispersion found in the “Spite lithium plateau”. Assuming slow, constant, solid body rotation (a few km.s−1 in typical halo dwarfs), and that the transport of chemicals is progressively blocked when Eµ = EΩ (a sit- uation they call creeping paralysis), they achieve a disper- sion of 0.1 dex in the lithium plateau, in agreement with observations. We point out the fact that their scenario implies solid body rotation and thus prevents the rotation profile to react to horizontal molecular weight gradients as is the case in our description. Solid body rotation would be enforced in the presence of a small magnetic field or by gravity waves (Talon & Charbonnel, in preparation), 3 As explained in Talon et al. 1997, in a non-evolving model, Eq. (2) has a stationnary solution in which advection of mo- mentum by the circulation is compensated by turbulent trans- port. There is thus a Θ equilibrium profile. When adding µ- currents, about the same equilibrium exists for Θ − Λ. This leads to Θ following the behavior of Λ, resulting in large dif- ferential rotation in the core. Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 9 Fig. 2. Profiles of the vertical component of the meridional velocity Ur (left panels), angular velocity Ω (middle panels) and diffusion coefficients (right panels) inside a 1.5 M⊙ , Z = 0.02 star. Solid lines are for the model with Eµ 6= 0 and dashed lines for the model with Eµ = 0. Central hydrogen content is as indicated. In the left panels, bold parts in the solid lines indicate positive values of Ur . which might be the case in halo stars as well as in the stars lying on the cool side of the Li dip. However, as dis- cussed by TC98, such an additional process of extraction of angular momentum is not expected to be efficient in the more massive stars lying on the left side of the Li dip which are under the scope of this study. 5.3. Diffusion coefficients The examination of the total diffusion coefficients (from Fig. 2), reveals that, except towards the centre, they ap- pear to be very much the same, whether Eµ is zero or not. The transport of chemicals, contrary to that of angu- lar momentum, will thus not be significantly affected dur- ing main sequence evolution (see next section). However, while the total coefficients are of similar amplitude, they are not the result of the same combination of effects. Fig. 5 presents various diffusion coefficients in both cases for a central hydrogen content Xc = 0.2. We can firstly empha- size the fact that the shellular rotation is actually realistic, for Dh ≫ Deff and Dv . Secondly, when Eµ 6= 0, the tur- bulent diffusion coefficient Dv is larger than the effective coefficient Deff almost everywhere in the radiative zone. This is a consequence of the enhancement of the differen- tial rotation rate in this case, which favours the growth of turbulence4 . Due to the strong anisotropy of turbulent motions, the buoyancy restoring forces in the vertical di- rection are slightly reduced because of the horizontal diffu- sion, and vertical turbulent mixing is allowed. The profile of the effective diffusion coefficient is influenced by U (r) (Eq. 10), so that it reflects the loops of the circulation in the presence of µ-currents, each “drop” corresponding to an inversion of the direction of the flow. When neglecting variations of µ, turbulence can only marginally develop in a small portion of the radiative zone and the vertical diffusion coefficient Dv is reduced to molecular viscosity which is always smaller than Deff . 4 This appears clearly when turning to Eq. (17), through ∝ (dΩ/dr)2 . which Dv 10 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars Fig. 3. Vertical component of the meridional circulation velocity, U as a function of the reduced radius at the same epochs inside the same star. (left panel), where we see Deff dropping down below 101 just above the core. Dv also decreases in the same re- gion, where contrary to the rest of the radiative zone, it is dominated by the molecular viscosity rather than by the turbulent viscosity (there is no turbulence). Figure 6 presents a comparison between the evolution of the lithium surface abundance in the 1.5M⊙ rotating star when considering or not the effects of µ-currents. Both tracks are similar, but the depletion of lithium during the main sequence is larger in case of Eµ = 0. The surface abundance of lithium differs by more than 0.3 dex at 700 Myrs, which is more than the observational errorbar com- monly assumed. Accounting for µ variations reduces the effect of mixing when al l others assumptions remain the same. We have seen that µ-currents rule the evolution of the rotation profile. They lead to an enhancement of the degree of differential rotation, which in turn allows for the horizontal turbulence to develop more easily. This hori- zontal turbulence hinders the transport towards the ver- tical direction. This effect shows up through the surface abundance of lithium, that is less depleted when Eµ 6= 0. Nevertheless, this abundance feature can not be advocated as an observational clue to the action of the µ-currents. Indeed, braking plays a ma jor role in determining the am- plitude of mixing (and thus the amplitude of lithium de- pletion), and thus may rub off the effects of the variations of µ. The surface velocity reached for Teff ≃ 4900 K is of Fig. 4. Profiles of Θ and Λ inside the 1.5 M⊙ star for three different values of the central hydrogen content. Solid lines are for Θ, dashed ones for Λ. Thin lines stand for models where “complete mixing” (Eµ 6= 0) is applied while the bold line gives the profile of Θ when Eµ = 0. In the central part, we may notice that the total dif- fusion coefficient is lowered by one order of magnitude in the presence of µ-currents. As pointed out before, µ- gradients in that region inhibit the development of an ef- ficient turbulent diffusivity. This appears clearly in Fig. 5 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 11 Fig. 5. Profiles of the different components of the diffusion coefficient and of the thermal diffusivity as a function of the reduced radius when Eµ 6= 0 (left) and Eµ = 0 (right). The models correspond to the 1.5M⊙ star with Xc = 0.2. Fig. 6. Evolution of the surface abundance of lithium with temperature in the 1.5 M⊙ star for the two different ap- proaches of mixing as mentioned on the plot and in the text. a few km.s−1 in both cases, velocity for the model with Eµ = 0 being slightly larger (9 km.s−1 versus 6.5 km.s−1 when Eµ 6= 0), because of the different braking constant used in this case in order to achieve the same surface ve- locity at 700 Myrs as in absence of µ-currents. Both veloc- ities reached at the end of the computation are consistent with observations (Gaig´e 1993). As a result, accounting for the effects of µ-currents under the assumptions de- scribed in § 3 does not make any significant change in the outcoming surface abundances compared to the case without variations of µ. The observed abundances used as constraints do not allow to distinguish between these two cases. However we pointed out differences in the final rota- tion profiles, which might change significantly rotational transport during later evolutionary phases. 6. Comparison with observations We now compare the predictions of our rotating-models with the observations of Li, Be and CNO on the hot side of the so-called Li dip at the age of the Hyades, and of Li in subgiants of solar metallicity. 6.1. Li, Be and CNO on the hot side of the Li dip in the open clusters The drop-off in the Li content of main-sequence F stars in a narrow range of effective temperature centred around 6700 K, or “Li dip” (Wallerstein et al. 1965, Boesgaard & Tripicco 1986, Balachandran 1995), is the most striking signature of transport processes that occur inside these stars. We refer to TC98 and CT99 for a detailed discus- sion of the different processes which have been proposed to account for this feature. These papers show how rotation induced mixing shapes in a very natural way the hot side of the Li dip. As already mentioned, we did not consider the effects of the µ gradients in these previous papers. However, as discussed in § 4.2.3, the total diffusion coeffi- cients, and thus the resulting transport of chemicals, is not significantly affected by these terms during main sequence. As a consequence, the comparison of the predictions of Li and Be surface abundances with observations on the hot side of the Li dip remains highly satisfactory, as can be seen in Figs. 7 and 8. In CT99, microscopic diffusion on LiBeB had been turned off (while it was applied to all other chemicals) for stars with Teff higher than 6900 K, because of the competi- tion between radiative acceleration and gravity (Richer & Michaud 1993, Richer et al. 2000, see discussion § 3.4). In Figs. 7 and 8, we present the results of computations with and without gravitational settling of LiBeB at the effective temperature where radiative forces can over-compensate gravitation. As can be seen, for the rotationnal velocities considered here, the differences are minute. In addition, the effect on stellar structure itself is null, since LiBeB are trace elements. Observations of C, N and O are precious clues on trans- port mechanisms inside main-sequence F-type stars, and on the competition between atomic diffusion and macro- scopic processes. Indeed, in the case of pure atomic diffu- sion, these elements are expected to be underabundant in the Li dip, as shown in Fig. 9. On the other hand, in our 12 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars Fig. 7. Comparison of the models (hexagons and open bold star) with observations in the Hyades (crosses), in Praesepe (squares) and in Coma Berenices (circles and triangles). Downward triangles are for upper limits. Observations are from Burkhart & Coupry (1998,2000) and Boesgaard (1987). The corresponding masses of the models are as indicated on the figure. All models presented have Z = 0.02 and an initial velocity of 110 km.s−1 ; the reader is referred to Tab. 2 for details on braking. For the 1.5 M⊙ model, open bold star is obtained when not in- cluding microscopic diffusion on LiBeB while for hexagons microscopic diffusion was included also for these light el- ements (see text for further details). models rotation induced mixing strongly inhibits the set- tling effects. As a result, the surface abundances of CNO do not vary in the Teff range considered. This is in per- fect agreement with observations in the Hyades (Varenne & Monier 1998, Takeda 1998; see also Boesgaard 1989, Friel & Boesgaard 1990, Garcia Lopez et al. 1993), as can be seen in Fig. 9. Let us stress that in the temperature domain of A-type stars, most of the observations report abundances for chemically peculiar ob jects, namely Am stars, that are slow rotators in which the action of gravi- tational settling is important on CNO elements. These pe- culiar patterns might be achieved by considering the com- bined effects of large scale circulation, turbulence, gravita- tional settling and radiative forces (the effects of the latter not being included in our evolutionary code) in models with a slow initial rotation. Such computations are not presented here for this is out of the scope of the present study to focus on such a particular phenomenon. Fig. 8. Beryllium abundance as a function of effective temperature in the Hyades (Boesgaard & King 2002). The pentagon, hexagon and triangle are the values obtained for the 1.35 M⊙ , 1.4 M⊙ and 1.5 M⊙ models respectively. The empty triangle is a 1.5 M⊙ model where microscopic dif- fusion is not applied to LiBeB. Refer to Tab. 1 for further details on braking. 6.2. Li in subgiants Early observations by Alschuler (1975) of a few field stars crossing for the first time the Hertzsprung gap indicated that lithium depletion starts earlier than predicted by standard dilution for stars more massive than 2 M⊙ . Later on, significant lithium depletion was observed in a non negligible number of slightly evolved field stars (Brown et al. 1989, Balachandran 1990). do Nascimento et al. (2000) studied the behaviour of lithium in a sample of field sub- giants observed by L`ebre et al. (1999) for which Hipparcos data allowed the precise determination of both evolution- ary status and mass. They confirmed that stars originating from the hot side of the dip present a large range of lithium abundances which can not be explained by standard dilu- tion alone and which reflect different degrees of depletion of this element while on the main sequence, even if its sig- nature does not appear at the stellar surface at the age of the Hyades (see Vauclair 1991, Charbonnel & Vauclair 1992). In this cluster, dilution is not sufficient to explain lithium values in evolved stars (which have masses of the order of 2.2 M⊙ ), while main sequence stars present galac- tic abundance (Boesgaard et al. 1977, Duncan et al. 1998). This has been observed also in open clusters with turnoff masses higher than ∼ 1.6 M⊙ (Gilroy 1989, Pasquini et al. 2001). In Fig. 10 we compare our predictions for the surface Li abundance of various models with the observations in Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 13 Fig. 9. Abundances of carbon, nitrogen and oxygen vs ef- fective temperature in the Hyades, presented as asterisks and open stars for A and Am stars respectively (the lat- ter ones are not meant to be reproduced here; see text for details). Observations of C and O are from Varenne & Monier (1998). Observations of N are from Takeda et al. (1998), crosses are derived from the 8629 A line and stars are from 8683 A line. Abundances are given rela- tive to solar values from Grevesse & Noels (1993). The typical errorbar for observational values is given for each panel. Models with complete mixing, a turbulence param- eter Ch = 1 and braking as reported in Tab. 2 are repre- sented by the filled points with hexagon, pentagon, square and triangle standing for 1.8, 1.5, 1.4 and 1.35 M⊙ respec- tively, with Z⋆ = 0.02. Lines are from calculations includ- ing gravitational settling and radiative forces by Turcotte et al. (1998) (see Varenne & Monier 1999 for further de- tails). both field and open cluster evolved stars. First note that in classical models without rotation the variation in surface Li abundance is very similar for stars of different masses because it is only due to the first dredge-up dilution. More importantly, classical Li depletion starts at a too low Teff (around ∼ 5850 K) and leads to final Li abundances too high when compared to observational data. On the other hand, and even if no important lithium depletion is ex- pected at the surface of the main sequence stars on the hot side of the dip at the age of the Hyades, more lithium de- struction occurs inside rotating models compared to clas- sical ones. Indeed, due to the enlargement of the Li free radiative regions, important surface Li depletion occurs at much higher Teff than in classical models. Also, total Li depletion after dredge-up is more important in rotating models than in models without transport processes. The predicted evolution of the surface lithium abundance in Fig. 10. Lithium abundance versus effective temperature in open clusters (open symbols) and field (filled symbols) subgiants compared with our rotating models. Triangles indicate upper limits. Observations are from L`ebre et al.(1999) (field), Wallerstein et al. (1994) (field), Pasquini et al. (2001) (NGC 3680), Gilroy (1989) (open clus- ters) and Burkhart & Coupry (1989,2000) (Hyades among other open clusters). Dot-dashed lines represent results for standard models of 1.35M⊙, 1.4M⊙ , 1.5M⊙ , 1.8M⊙ and 2.2M⊙ . They all coalesce in a single line, standard dilution starting around 5750 K. Other lines are for models with rotation induced mixing and magnetic braking. Solid line, dotted line, long dashed line, dashed line and dot-dashed line are for 1.5M⊙ , 1.4M⊙ , 1.8M⊙ , 1.35M⊙ , 2.2M⊙ respec- tively. Refer to Tab. 1 for details concerning rotational velocities. our rotating models explains the behaviour and the disper- sion in field and open cluster evolved stars more massive than ∼ 1.4 M⊙ . 7. Conclusions To study the evolution of low mass rotating stars and the effects of rotation induced mixing on surface abundance patterns, we have presented here a first series of results concerning main sequence and subgiant Pop I stars lo- cated on the hot side of the lithium dip. We performed calculations including the treatment of transport of an- gular momentum and chemical species due to meridional circulation, shear turbulence and gravitational settling ac- cording to Maeder & Zahn (1998) formalism. In particu- lar, we take into account horizontal variations of mean molecular weight, and their action on the transport itself. These terms prove to be very important in defining the shape of the internal rotation profile. Indeed the horizon- 14 Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars tal variations of µ and the derivative of Ω, namely, Λ and Θ respectively, have a mirrored behaviour, Θ following Λ when it is not null. As soon as the circulation is settled, the µ-currents grow larger and induce a stronger differential rotation. On the other hand, the effects of these terms on the surface abundances of light elements appear not to be con- straining compared with braking for instance. The ma jor change introduced in the transport of chemicals when tak- ing µ-currents into account concerns the dominant con- tributor to the diffusion coefficient. In an “homogeneous” star (where there are no horizontal variations of µ), the effective diffusion coefficient Deff is the ma jor contribu- tor, while in the inhomogeneous case, turbulent diffusion coefficient dominates the transport of chemicals. Finally, contrary to what has been suggested in previ- ous work concerning rotation induced mixing in solid body rotating low mass stars (typically halo main sequence stars with M⋆ < 0.9M⊙), when considering extraction of angu- lar momentum through magnetic braking, the situation of “creeping paralysis” of the circulation is not reached in the models presented here. It shall actually never be the case as long as differential rotation is allowed to exist for the mirrored terms never compensate each other. The point to be emphasized is the fact that these vari- ations of mean molecular weight are not to be neglected when considering rotating ob jects. They modify the action of mixing and can be of ma jor importance after main se- quence evolution, for they constrain the internal rotation profile. Acknow ledgements. We are grateful to the referee Pr. Andr´e Maeder and Pr. Sylvie Vauclair for their usefull comments, that helped to improve this paper. We wish to thank the french “Programme National de Physique Stellaire” for financial sup- port. S.T. was supported by NSERC of Canada and by the Canada Research Chair in Stellar Astrophysics awarded to G. Fontaine. A.P. would like to thank the Centre Informatique National de l’Enseignement Sup´erieur where calculations were performed. References Alexander D.R., Ferguson J.W., 1994, ApJ 437, 879 Alschuler D.R., 1975, ApJ 195, 649 Angulo C., Arnould M., Rayet M., Descouvemont P., Baye D., Leclercq-Willain C., Coc A., Barhoumi S., Aguer P., Rolfs C., Kunz R., Hammer J.W., Mayer A., Paradellis T., Kossionides S., Chronidou C., Spyrou K., degl’Innocenti S., Fiorentini G., Ricci B., Zavatarelli S., Providencia C., Wolters H., Soares J., Grama C., Rahighi J., Shotter A., Lamehi Rachti M., Nuclear Physics A 656, 3 Balachandran S., 1990, ApJ 354, 310 Balachandran S., 1995, ApJ 446, 203 Barnes S., Sofia S., 1996, ApJ 462, 746 Boesgaard A.M., Heacox W.D., Conti P.S., 1977, ApJ 214, 124 Boesgaard A.M.,Tripicco M.J., 1986, ApJ 303, 724 Boesgaard A.M., 1989, ApJ 336, 798 Boesgaard A.M., King J.R., 2002, ApJ 565, 587 Bouvier J., Forestini M., Allain S., 1997, A&A 326, 1023 Brown J.A., Sneden C., Lambert D.A., Dutchover E., 1989, ApJS 71, 293 Burkhart C., Coupry M.F., 1989, A&A 220, 197 Burkhart C., Coupry M.F., 2000, A&A 354, 216 Canuto V. M., 1998, ApJL 505, 47 Chaboyer B., Demarque P., Guenther D.B., Pinsonneault M.H., 1995, ApJ 446, 435 Chaboyer B., Zahn J.P., 1992, A&A 253, 173 Charbonnel C., Vauclair S., 1992, A&A 265, 55 Charbonnel C., Talon S., 1999, A&A 351, 635 do Nascimento J.D., Charbonnel C., L`ebre A., de Laverny P., de Medeiros J.R., 2000, A&A 357, 931 Duncan D.K., Peterson R.C., Thorburn J.A., Pinsonneault M.H., 1998, ApJ 499, 871 Eddington A.S., 1925, The Observatory 48, 73 Friel E.D., Boesgaard A.M., 1990, ApJ 351, 480 Gaig´e Y., 1993, A&A 269, 267 Garc´ıa Lopez R.J., Rebolo R., Herrero A., Beckman J.E., 1993, ApJ 412, 173 Gilroy K.K., 1989, ApJ 347, 835 Grevesse N., Noels A., 1993, Physica Scripta T 47, 133 Iglesias C.A., Rogers F.J., ApJ 464, 943 Kawaler S.D., 1988, ApJ 333, 236 Kim Y.C., Demarque P., 1996, ApJ 457, 340 Kippenhahn R., 1974, IAU Symp. 66: Late Stages of Stellar Evolution, 20 Krishnamurthi A., Pinsonneault M.H., Barnes S., Sofia S., 1997, ApJ 480, 303 L`ebre A., de Laverny P., de Medeiros J. R., Charbonnel C., da Silva L., 1999, A&A 345, 936 Lebreton Y., 2000, ARAA 38, 35 Maeder A., Zahn J.P., 1998, A&A 334, 1000 Matias J., Zahn J.P., 1997, Sounding solar and stellar interi- ors, IAU Symposium 181, Nice, Eds. J. Provost and F.X. Schmider Mestel L., 1953, MNRAS 113, 716 Meynet G., Mermilliod J.-C., Maeder A., 1993, A&A Suppl. Series 98, 477 Meynet G., Maeder A., 2000, A&A 361, 101 Moss D., 1979, A&A 78, 119 Palacios A., Charbonnel C., Forestini M., Talon S., 2002, A&A, in preparation Paquette C., Pelletier C., Fontaine G., Michaud G., 1986, ApJS 61, 177 Pasquini L., Randich S., Pallavicini R., 2001, A&A 374, 1017 Per´ez Hern´andez F., Claret A., Hern´andez M.M., Michel E., 1999, A&A 346, 586 Pols O.R., Tout C.A., Eggleton P.P., Han Z., 1995, MNRAS 274, 964 Richer J., Michaud G., 1993, ApJ 416, 312 Richer J., Michaud G., Turcotte S., 2000, ApJ 529, 338 Saar S.H., 1996, in “Stellar surface structure: proceedings of the 176th Symposium of the International Astronomical Union”, Eds. K.G. Strassmeier and J.L. Linsky Schatzman E., 1962, Ann. d’Ap. 25, 18 Sills A., Pinsonneault M., 2000, ApJ 540, 489 Siess L., Forestini M., Bertout C., 1997, A&A 326, 1001 Siess L., Dufour E., Forestini M., 2000, A&A 358, 593 Stauffer J.R., Hartmann L.W., 1987, ApJ 318, 337 Takeda Y., Kawanomoto S., Takada-Hidai M., Sadakane K., 1998, PASJ, 50, 509 Talon S., Charbonnel C., 1998, A&A 335, 959 Talon S., Charbonnel C., 2003, A&A, in preparation Palacios et al.: Rotational mixing in Pop I low-mass stars 15 Talon S., Zahn J.P., 1997, A&A 317, 749 Talon S., Zahn J.P., Maeder A., Meynet G., 1997, A&A 322, 209 Tassoul J.L, Tassoul M., 1982, ApJS 49, 317 Th´eado S., Vauclair S., 2001, A&A 375, 70 Townsend A.A., 1958, J. Fuid. Mech. 4, 361 Turcotte S., Richer J., Michaud G., Christensen-Dalsgaard J., 2000, A&A 360, 603 Varenne O., Monier R., 1999, A&A 351, 247 Vauclair S., in IAU Symp. 145, Evolution of stars: the photo- spheric abundance connection, Michaud G. an Tutukov A. eds, 327 Vauclair S., 1999, A&A 351, 973 Vauclair G., 1979, A&A 55, 147 Vogt H., 1926, Astron. Nachrichten 227, 325 Wallerstein G., Herbig G.H., Conti P.S., 1965, ApJ 141, 610 Wallerstein G.,Bohm-Vitense E., Vanture A.D., Gonzalez G., 1994, AJ 107, 221 Zahn J.P., 1992, A&A 265, 115 Zahn J.P., Talon S., Matias J., 1997, A&A 322, 320
astro-ph/0602347	2	0602	2006-02-16T10:54:36	The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present a comprehensive theoretical study, within a fully realistic semi-analytical framework, of the photometric properties of early-type progenitors in the redshift range 0<z<1, as a function of the luminosity and local environment of the early-type remnant at present-day. We find that, averaging across all environments at z~1, less than 50 percent of the stellar mass which ends up in early-types today is actually in early-type progenitors at this redshift. The corresponding value is ~65 percent in clusters due to faster morphological transformations in the such dense environments. We develop probabilistic prescriptions which provide a means of including spiral (i.e. non early-type) progenitors at intermediate and high redshifts, based on their luminosity and optical (BVK) colours. For example, at intermediate redshifts (z~0.5), large (M_B<-21.5), red (B-V>0.7) spirals have ~75-95 percent chance of being a progenitor, while the corresponding probability for large blue spirals (M_B<-21.5, B-V<0.7) is ~50-75 percent. Finally, we explore the correspondence between the true progenitor set of present-day early-types and the commonly used `red-sequence', defined as the set of galaxies within the part of the colour-magnitude space which is dominated by early-type objects. While large members (M_V<-22) of the `red sequence' trace the progenitor set accurately in terms of numbers and mass, the relationship breaks down severely at fainter luminosities (M_V>-21). Hence the red sequence is generally not a good proxy for the progenitor set of early-type galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- ?? (2003) Printed 24 October 2018 (MN LATEX style file v2.2) The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies S. Kaviraj1⋆, J. E. G. Devriendt2, I. Ferreras3, S. K. Yi4 and J. Silk1 1Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, UK 2Observatoire Astronomique de Lyon, 9 Avenue Charles Andr´e, 69561 Saint-Genis Laval cedex, France 3Physics Department, King's College London, Strand, London, WC2R 2LS 4Center for Space Astrophysics, Yonsei University, 134 Shinchon, Seoul 120-749, Korea 11 January 2006 ABSTRACT We present a comprehensive theoretical study, within a fully realistic semi-analytical framework, of the photometric properties of early-type progenitors in the redshift range 0 < z < 1, as a function of the luminosity and local environment of the early-type remnant at present-day. We find that while larger early-types are generally assembled later, their luminosity-weighted stellar ages are typically older. In dense environments, ∼ 70 percent of early-type systems are in place by z = 1 and evolve without major interactions thereafter, while in the field the corresponding value is ∼ 30 percent. Av- eraging across all environments at z ∼ 1, less than 50 percent of the stellar mass which ends up in early-types today is actually in early-type progenitors at this redshift. The corresponding value is ∼ 65 percent in clusters due to faster morphological transfor- mations in the such dense environments. We also develop probabilistic prescriptions which provide a means of including spiral (i.e. non early-type) progenitors at interme- diate and high redshifts, based on their luminosity and optical (BV K) colours. For example, at intermediate redshifts (z ∼ 0.5), large (MB < −21.5), red (B − V > 0.7) spirals have ∼ 75 − 95 percent chance of being a progenitor, while the corresponding probability for large blue spirals (MB < −21.5, B − V < 0.7) is ∼ 50 − 75 percent. Finally, we explore the correspondence between the true progenitor set of present- day early-types and the commonly used 'red-sequence', defined as the set of galaxies within the part of the colour-magnitude space which is dominated by early-type ob- jects. While large members (MV < −22) of the 'red sequence' trace the progenitor set accurately in terms of numbers and mass, the relationship breaks down severely at fainter luminosities (MV > −21). Hence the red sequence is generally not a good proxy for the progenitor set of early-type galaxies. Key words: galaxies: elliptical and lenticular, cD -- galaxies: evolution -- galaxies: formation -- galaxies: fundamental parameters 1 INTRODUCTION As 'end points' of galaxy merger sequences, early-type galax- ies carry important signatures of mass assembly and star formation in the Universe. Deducing their star formation histories (SFHs) therefore contains the key to understand- ing not only the evolution of these galaxies but characteris- tics of galaxy formation as a whole. Our view of early-type galaxy formation has developed over the years, away from the classical version of 'monolithic collapse' and towards the hierarchical assembly of these objects through mergers and accretion of fragments over a Hubble time, as advocated by the currently popular LCDM paradigm of galaxy formation. Traditionally, the evolution in the properties of early- ⋆ E-mail: [email protected] type galaxies, for example their optical colours, has been traced by studying early-type populations at progessively higher redshift. However, a fundamental feature of early- type formation in the standard model is that stellar mass that eventually ends up in present-day early-type galaxies is not entirely contained in early-type systems at high redshift. Looking only at early-type systems at high redshift intro- duces a progenitor bias, which becomes increasingly more se- vere at higher redshift, as the fraction of early-type progeni- tors becomes progressively smaller (van Dokkum and Franx 2001, 1996). In the current era of large scale (optical) surveys e.g. SDSS, COMBO-17, GALEX, MUSYC, GEMS, unprece- dented amounts of data spanning a large range in redshift and environment is becoming available, allowing us to study statistically significant numbers of galaxies at various stages 2 S. Kaviraj et al. of evolution. A quantitative assessment of progenitor bias is therefore needed to gauge the role of non-early-type progen- itors, especially for studies which centre on high redshift. A central theme of this work is to quantify progen- itor bias. This phenomenon has already been studied by van Dokkum and Franx (2001). However, their study em- ployed phenomenological SFHs, with the simple assumption that morphological transformations occur ∼ 1.5 Gyrs af- ter the cessation of star formation in a particular galaxy. Our study extends the results of van Dokkum and Franx (2001) by using a fully realistic semi-analytical framework, in which mass assembly and morphological transformation can be followed more accurately in the context of the cur- rently popular ΛCDM paradigm. We study the evolution of the progenitor set (galaxies that are progenitors of present- day early-types) with redshift, as a function of the luminos- ity and environment of the early-type remnant which is left at present-day. We pay particular attention to spiral progen- itors in the model, since these are routinely excluded from studies of early-type galaxies at high redshift by virtue of their morphology, even though they form an important part of the progenitor set. By comparing the properties (optical colours and luminosities) of spiral progenitors to the gen- eral spiral population, we provide a means of correcting for progenitor bias by including specific parts of the spiral popu- lation at high redshift into the study of early-type evolution. The plan of this paper is as follows. In Section 2, we quantify the morphology of the progenitor set and map the general properties of elliptical, S0 and spiral progenitors as a function of redshift. In Section 3 we focus exclusively on spiral progenitors and compare their photometric proper- ties to the general spiral population. In Section 4 we trace the contribution of galaxies in dense regions (groups and clusters) at high redshift to cluster early-types at present- day. In Section 5 we explore the correspondence between the true progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies and the 'red-sequence', defined as the set of galaxies within the part of the colour-magnitude space dominated by early- type objects, which is commonly used as a proxy for the progenitor set (e.g. Bell and GEMS collaboration 2004). Note that throughout this study we provide rest-frame magnitudes for all model galaxies. Unless otherwise noted, the filters used are in the standard Johnson system. 2 DISSECTING THE PROGENITOR SET: MORPHOLOGIES OF PROGENITORS Early-type galaxies have an assortment of SFHs. Crucial to this study is the dynamical age of an early-type galaxy, which we define as the epoch at which its last merger took place. This last merger creates the early-type remnant and imparts its final early-type morphology. As our subsequent analysis of progenitor bias involves morphologies and envi- ronments of model galaxies, a brief explanation of the defi- nition of these quantities is necessary. Galaxy morphology in the model is determined by the ratio of the B-band luminosities of the disc and bulge components which correlates well with Hubble type (Simien and de Vaucouleurs 1986). A morphology index is defined as I = exp(cid:18) −LB LD (cid:19) (1) such that a pure disc has I = 1 and a pure bulge has I = 0. Following Baugh et al. (1996), ellipticals have I < 0.219, S0s have 0.219 < I < 0.507 and spirals have I > 0.507. This simple prescription is clearly incapable of capturing the complex spectrum of real galaxy morpholo- gies. Therefore, in what follows, 'spirals' refer to all systems which do not have a dominant spheroidal (bulge) compo- nent. Observationally, this includes not only systems with distinctive spiral morphologies, but also peculiar or irregu- lar systems. Galaxy environments in the model are driven by the mass of the dark matter (DM) halo in which they are em- bedded. At z = 0, DM halo masses greater than ∼ 1014M⊙ correspond to 'cluster' environments, while halo masses be- tween ∼ 1013M⊙ and ∼ 1014M⊙ correspond to 'groups'. All other halo masses correspond to the 'field'. At higher red- shifts these definitions do not strictly hold since the DM halo population is evolving - for example, the largest haloes at z = 1 are likely to be roughly half their size at present day (e.g van den Bosch 2002). We take this mass accretion history into account when specifying the environments of galaxies at high redshift. The mass accretion history is taken from van den Bosch (2002, see their Figure 5). Figure 1 (top panel) indicates the last merger redshifts of the sample of early-types in the model split by environ- ment of the remnant at z = 0. The bottom panel in Figure 1 shows histograms of the last merger redshifts shown in the top panel, again split by environment. The inset shows the fraction of mergers at a given redshift. In Figure 2 we plot the average last merger ages as a function of the luminos- ity and environment of the early-type remnant at z = 0. As expected, we find that, in all environments, larger early- types are assembled later (although their stars are generally older (Kaviraj et al. 2005)). Cluster galaxies (at least those brighter than L∗) have significantly larger dynamical ages - morphological transformations in clusters proceed more quickly than in all other environments. This point is more clearly made in Figure 3, where we plot the cumulative frac- tion of early-type galaxies which have already has their last merger. These galaxies have therefore achieved their final 'early-type' morphology and are evolving 'monolithically'. We find that, on average, without reference to environment, only 35 percent of early-type galaxies are in place by z = 1 (black line) - the rest are still 'in pieces'. In terms of morpho- logical transformations cluster environments are special, in that early-type morphologies are attained significantly faster in clusters (red curve), with almost 70 percent of early-type galaxies having undergone their last merger by z = 1. Before the last merger occurs, the morphology of the progenitors is not necessarily early-type. Figure 4 shows the morphologies of progenitors in binary mergers as a function of redshift. Non-binary mergers do happen but are rare, and only take place at redshifts greater than z ∼ 1. In the local Universe, mergers between early-type progenitors make up less than 20 percent of the merger activity. All other merg- ers contain at least one spiral progenitor. Mergers involving solely spiral progenitors increasingly dominate at higher red- shift and dominate the merger activity beyond z = 1. Having provided a picture of the merger activity within The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 3 Figure 3. Cumulative fraction of early-type galaxies which have has their last merger as a function of redshift. Figure 1. TOP: Last merger redshifts of the sample of early- types in the model split by environment of the remnant at z = 0. BOTTOM: Histograms of last merger redshifts shown in the top panel, split by environment. The inset shows the fraction of mergers at a given redshift. Figure 2. Last merger ages as a function of average luminosity and environment of the early-type remnant at z = 0. Figure 4. Morphologies of progenitors in binary mergers as a function of redshift. Non-binary mergers do happen but are rare, and only take place at redshifts greater than z ∼ 1.5. Mergers at intermediate and high redshift are dominated by pairs of progen- itors which contain at least one spiral progenitor. the progenitor set, it is instructive to look at the fraction of the progenitor set which is made up of a certain mor- phological type as a function of redshift. Figures 5 and 6 shows the number and mass fractions contained in progen- itors of different morphological types in the redshift range 0 < z < 3, split by environment and luminosity of the early- type remnant at z = 0 respectively. We find that, averaging across all environments, at z ∼ 1, less than 50 percent of the stellar mass which ends up in early-types today is actually in early-type progenitors at this redshift. Faster morpholog- ical transformation in cluster environments means that this value is ∼ 65 percent in clusters at z ∼ 1. As a result, look- ing only at early-type galaxies at z ∼ 1 does not take into account almost half the stellar mass in the progenitor set. In other words, the mass in the progenitor set doubles be- tween z = 1 and z = 0. A similar result was found by Bell at al. (2004), although they used the optical 'red sequence' 4 S. Kaviraj et al. Figure 5. Number (top) and mass (bottom) fractions contained in progenitors of different morphological types in the redshift range 0 < z < 3, split by environment of the early-type rem- nant. Figure 6. Number (top) and mass (bottom) fractions contained in progenitors of different morphological types in the redshift range 0 < z < 3, split by luminosity of the early-type remnant. in their study, which does not completely correspond to the progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies (see section 5 below). The bias does not arise simply because some progenitor mass is not taken into account, but because the age profile of the mass in progenitors of different morphological types tends to vary. We illustrate this point in Figure 7. The top panel shows the average N U V -weighted ages of progenitors of different morphological types. The N U V weighting, gen- erated using the GALEX (Martin el al. 2005) N U V filter, is heavily dominated by stars formed within the last 0.5 to 1 Gyr of look-back time. At all redshifts, early-type progeni- tors have higher N U V -weighted ages, because the mass frac- tion contributed by recent star formation (RSF) i.e. within the last 1 Gyr is smaller than for spiral progenitors. The dif- ferences between elliptical and spiral progenitors are most pronounced at low redshift. The bottom panel shows the fraction of the RSF across the progenitor that is contained in each morphological type. This plot obviously has to be interpreted in conjunction with the mass fractions hosted by each morphological type as a function of redshift. For example, at z ∼ 0.1, although spiral progenitors host ∼ 40 percent of the total RSF in the progenitor set, they only con- stitute ∼ 30 percent of the mass in the progenitor set (see bottom panel of Figure 5. Early-type progenitors (elliptical and S0 taken together) contribute ∼ 60 percent of the RSF - but they also constitute ∼ 70 percent of the total mass in the progenitor set. Therefore at z ∼ 0.1 spiral progenitors host 1.5 times the amount of RSF per unit mass than their early-type counterparts. At higher redshift the balance of RSF contained in each morphological type moves towards spiral progenitors, partly because they are more spirals in the Universe than early-types. Figure 7 illustrates that an increasingly larger fraction of RSF in the progenitor set is contained in late-type systems at increasing redshift. In the context of colour-magnitude re- lations (CMRs), which are often used to age-date early-type populations at all redshifts, the exclusion of spiral progeni- tors at high redshift biases the CMR towards redder colours and does not give a proper indication of the age of the stel- lar mass that eventually constitutes present-day early-type galaxies. 3 THE SPIRAL PROGENITORS One of the aims of this study is to provide a means of in- cluding spiral populations observed at high redshift which might be early-type progenitors, and thus correct, at least partially, for progenitor bias. We therefore focus on spiral progenitors predicted by the model and compare their pho- tometric properties to the general spiral population. Providing reasonably accurate prescriptions for finding The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 5 Figure 7. TOP: Average N U V -weighted ages of progenitors of different morphological types. The N U V weighting is heavily dominated by stars formed in these progenitors within the last 0.5 to 1 Gyr of look-back time. Note that the N U V weighting was generated using the GALEX (Martin el al. 2005) N U V filter. BOTTOM: The fraction of recently formed stars (age < 1 Gyrs old) across the progenitor set which is contained in progenitors of each morphological type. progenitors (of any morphology) based on predicted pho- tometry is clearly reliant on the predictions being reasonably representative of the observed data. The correspondence be- tween predictions from GALICS and observed optical pho- tometry (mainly at low redshift) is shown in Hatton et al. (2003, Section 8). The predictions from GALICS produces good agreement to the galaxy luminosity functions observed by the 2dF survey in the B and K bands (Cross et al. 2001). The (B − V ) colours of spiral galaxies closely follow the observed data of Buta et al. (1994), both in terms of aver- age values and scatter. The version of the model used in this study is the same as that used in Kaviraj et al. (2005), who calibrated GALICS to accurately reproduce the opti- cal colours of elliptical galaxies in dense environments from z = 0 to z ∼ 1.23. Since our study hinges on photomet- ric predictions at high redshift, we compare, as a further check, in Figure 8, the (B − V ) colours of the spiral pop- ulation in GALICS to recent photometry from COMBO-17 survey (Wolf et al. 2004) in the redshift range 0 < z < 1. The COMBO-17 sample used is restricted to galaxies which correspond to the GALICS completeness limits in the B and V bands of -18.9 and -19.7 mag respectively. We find that predicted spiral colours in GALICS cor- Figure 8. Comparison between the colours of COMBO-17 galax- ies and the predicted spiral population in GALICS. The COMBO- 17 sample is restricted to galaxies which correspond to the GAL- ICS completeness limits in the B and V bands of -18.9 and -19.7 mags respectively. respond well to the range of observed (B − V ) colours in the COMBO-17 survey in the redshift range 0 < z < 0.8. Comparison to higher redshifts is not possible because the accuracy of the observed V magnitudes cannot be guaran- teed beyond z ∼ 0.7 (Wolf et al. 2004). However, these com- parisons give us some confidence that the colour parameter space spanned by the predicted spiral population in GALICS is consistent with observations for a wide range of redshifts. 3.1 The luminosity function of spiral progenitors We begin by studying the luminosity function (LF) of spiral progenitors. We are interested in studying how the lumi- nosities of spiral progenitors compare to the general spiral population and what fraction of spirals, at a given lumi- nosity, are early-type progenitors. In Figure 9 we show the evolution of the B-band LF of spiral progenitors - we also show the spiral progenitors separated by the environment of their present-day early-type remnant. The left hand col- umn illustrates the evolution of the spiral LFs - the yellow curve denotes the LF of the general spiral population and the black curve the LF of all spiral progenitors. The LFs of spiral progenitors whose early-type remnants are, at z = 0, in clusters, groups and the field, are shown in red, green and blue respectively. Figures 10 and 11 show the corresponding 6 S. Kaviraj et al. Figure 9. The B-band luminosity function of spiral progenitors. plots for the predicted V -band and K-band photometry re- spectively. 3.2 The colour magnitude space of spiral progenitors It is apparent that there is a greater preponderance of progenitors among larger spirals at all redshifts. For exam- ple, at low redshifts (z < 0.l), 20 to 40 percent of spirals with M (B) < −20.5 are early-type progenitors. At inter- mediate redshifts (0.3 < z < 0.52), these values rise to 30 and 60 percent respectively. At high redshift (z ∼ 1) spirals with M (B) < −21.5 have more than a 60 percent proba- bility of being an early-type progenitor, while spirals with −20 < M (B) < −21.5 have between a 30 and 40 percent chance of being early-type progenitors. The falling progen- itor fractions towards lower redshift are partly due to the changing morphological mix of the Universe. While investigating the LFs of spiral progenitors is useful in indicating the probability that a spiral of a given luminos- ity has of being a progenitor, it is also desirable to explore the colour-magnitude (CM) space of the spiral population, so that we can separate progenitor spirals better from the general population at a given luminosity. In Figure 12 we compare the (B − V ) colours of the general spiral population to the (B − V ) colours of spiral progenitors. The left-hand column shows the spiral (B − V ) CMR from z = 0 to z = 1. Black dots represent the spi- ral galaxies and red dots represent spiral progenitors. In the right hand column we show the fraction of spiral progeni- tors across the (B − V ) CMR. The fractions are indicated The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 7 Figure 10. Same as Figure 10 but for the V -band. using the colour coding shown in the legend. Warmer colours indicate a higher progenitor fraction (red implies a progen- itor fraction of 1, black represents a progenitor fraction of 0 and parts of the CM space without any galaxies are not colour-coded). At local redshifts (z ∼ 0.03), spirals brighter than M (B) ∼ −21 have ∼ 30 percent chance of being an early- type progenitor, irrespective of their (B − V ) colour. At z ∼ 0.1, spirals with −21.5 < M (B) < −20.5 have ∼ 30 per- cent chance of being a progenitor. For larger spirals, those with red (B − V ) colours, i.e. (B − V ) > 0.8, have ∼ 60 per- cent chance of being a progenitor, while the corresponding probability for bluer spirals is 30 to 50 percent. At intermediate redshift (z ∼ 0.5), red spirals, with −21.5 < M (B) < −20.5 and (B − V ) > 0.6, have ∼ 30 percent probability of being an early-type progenitor, while blue spirals in the same luminosity range have a low pro- genitor probability. For larger spirals at these redshifts, the probabilities are appreciably higher - red spirals with (B − V ) > 0.7 have between a 75 and 95 percent chance of being progenitors, while 50 to 75 percent of blue spirals in this luminosity range are progenitors. The situation at high redshift z ∼ 1 is similar to that at intermediate redshift. For completess we also show, in Figure 13, the corresponding plot for the (V − K) colours for the spiral population - the trends are similar to those we have just described in (B −V ). 8 S. Kaviraj et al. Figure 11. Same as Figure 11 but for the K-band. 4 PROGENITOR EVOLUTION IN CLUSTERS Before the advent of large scale surveys, dense regions of the Universe were often targetted for early-type galaxy studies, both at low and high redshift (e.g. Bower et al. 1992; Stanford et al. 1998; van Dokkum et al. 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001; Blakeslee et al. 2003). While studies of dense re- gions are attractive for a variety of reasons (e.g. Ellis 2002; van Dokkum 2004), a key benefit is observational (statisti- cal) convenience - clusters provide access to large homoge- neous samples of luminous objects at all redshifts. It has been usual to 'connect' results from cluster studies over large redshift ranges to determine (at least qualitatively) the chronology of galaxy evolution. In this section we investigate progenitors of present-day cluster early-types, which are themselves in dense regions at z > 0. The motivation for this investigation is two fold. Firstly (and most importantly), it provides a comparison to the vast literature of 'cluster' early-type studies. Secondly, this version of the GALICS model has been accurately cal- ibrated to match the optical CMRs of early-types in dense regions from low to high redshift (Kaviraj et al. 2005), which implies that the colours of early-type progenitors are also reasonably well constrained. In short, the GALICS model reproduces the optical colours of cluster early-types at z = 0 and the colours of all progenitors (regardless of morphology) in dense regions at high redshift. Hence, our analysis of the evolution of the complete progenitor set (i.e. not just spirals as was studied in the previous section), restricted to dense regions, is likely to be robust. The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 9 Figure 12. (B − V ) colours of the general population compared to the (B − V ) colours of those spirals which are progenitors of present-day early-type galaxies. Black dots represent spiral galaxies and red dots represent spiral progenitors. The left-hand column shows the spiral (B − V ) CMR from z = 0 to z = 1. In the right hand column we show the fraction of spirals in parts of the (B − V ) CMR space which are progenitors of early-type galaxies. The fractions are indicated using the colour coding shown in the legend. Warmer colours indicate a higher progenitor fraction (red implies a progenitor fraction of 1, black represents a progenitor fraction of 0 and parts of the CM space without any galaxies are not colour-coded). It is important here to clarify the definitions of 'den- sity' that we use to define both 'clusters' at present-day, and 'dense' regions at high redshift. As mentioned before, model 'density' is assumed to be a direct function of the mass of the DM halo in which galaxies are embedded. At z = 0, a DM halo mass of 1014M⊙ represents the lower limit for a cluster-hosting halo. Observational studies of dense re- gions at high redshift are likely to contain an assortment of cluster-type haloes of varying occupancies. Furthermore, DM haloes themselves are evolving - on average, the largest haloes at z = 1 are likely to be roughly half their size at present day (e.g van den Bosch 2002). To take these two points into account, we use a variable lower mass limit for 'cluster-hosting' haloes at z > 0. At a given redshift this lower limit is calculated from the average mass accretion history (van den Bosch 2002, see their Figure5) applied to a 1014M⊙ halo. Figure 14 shows the (B − V ) CMR in clusters in the redshift range 0 < z < 1. Large diamonds indicate progen- itor galaxies - black indicates ellipticals, green corresponds 10 S. Kaviraj et al. Figure 13. (V − K) colours of the general population compared to the (V − K) colours of those spirals which are progenitors of present-day early-type galaxies. Black dots represent spiral galaxies and red dots represent spiral progenitors. The left-hand column shows the spiral (V − K) CMR from z = 0 to z = 1. In the right hand column we show the fraction of spirals in parts of the (V − K) CMR space which are progenitors of early-type galaxies. The fractions are indicated using the colour coding shown in the legend. Warmer colours indicate a higher progenitor fraction (red implies a progenitor fraction of 1, black represents a progenitor fraction of 0 and parts of the CM space without any galaxies are not colour-coded). to S0s and blue indicates spiral galaxies. Small dots indicate galaxies which do not contribute to the mass in present-day cluster early-types. All early-type galaxies in dense regions are, not unexpectedly, progenitors of cluster early-types at present day. The top panel in Figure 15 shows the fraction of spiral galaxies in dense regions at high redshift (split by lu- minosity) which are progenitors of early-types at z = 0. The bottom panel shows the offset in (B − V ), with respect to el- liptical progenitors, of the S0 and spiral progenitor galaxies. The offsets are shown split by luminosity. We find that at high redshift (z ∼ 1) up to 40 percent of large spirals (−23 < M (V ) < −21) are progenitors, whereas only ∼10 percent of small spirals (M (V ) > −21) are mem- bers of the progenitor set. Large spirals are four times more likely to be progenitors than small spirals, regardless of red- shift, in the redshift range 0 < z < 1. Elliptical galaxies form the reddest locus in (B − V ). S0 galaxies show an av- erage offset of -0.04 compared to the elliptical population, regardless of luminosity. Large spiral progenitors show an average (B − V ) offset of -0.05 compared to the elliptical The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 11 Figure 14. The (B − V ) CMR in clusters in the redshift range 0 < z < 1. Large diamonds indicate the progenitors of present- day cluster early-type galaxies. Small dots indicate galaxies which do not contribute to the mass in present-day cluster early-types. Note that all elliptical and S0 galaxies in dense regions are, not unexpectedly, progenitors of present-day cluster early-types. population at high redshift, mainly because the scatter in the elliptical colours also tends to be large at high redshift. At low redshift the offset is more pronounced - large spiral progenitors are upto 0.1 mags bluer in (B − V ) than the elliptical population. 5 THE 'RED SEQUENCE' AS A PROXY FOR THE PROGENITOR SET Early-type galaxies in clusters tend to preferentially popu- late the reddest parts of the CM space. In this section we investigate whether the sample of galaxies (without refer- ence to morphology), within the 'red sequence' defined by the early-type population, can be used as a proxy for the progenitor set. We define the red sequence as the galaxy population which occupies the part of the CM space 'domi- nated' by early-type galaxies. In Figures 16 and 17 the CM space dominated by early-type galaxies is shown in grey - this region is determined by a progressive one-sigma fit to the colours of the early-type population. It therefore con- tains, on average, 68 percent of the early-type population within it. Large diamonds indicate galaxies which are part of the progenitor set. Galaxies which are not part of the Figure 15. TOP PANEL: The fraction of spiral galaxies in dense regions at high redshift (split by luminosity) which are progenitors of cluster early-types at z = 0. BOTTOM PANEL: The offset in the (B − V ), with respect to elliptical progenitors, of S0 and spiral progenitors in clusters. The offsets are shown split by luminosity. progenitor set are shown using small crosses. Galaxies in the red sequence are circled. It is apparent that the red se- quence misses blue progenitor galaxies, both early-type and late-type. Figure 16 shows the evolution of the 'red sequence' from low to intermediate redshift and Figure 17 the evolu- tion from intermediate to high redshift. In Figure 18 we compare galaxies in the actual progen- itor set to those in the red sequence. The top panel shows the number ratio between the progenitor set population and the red sequence population, split by redshift and luminos- ity, while the bottom panel shows the mass ratio between the progenitor set population and the red sequence popu- lation split by redshift and luminosity. It is apparent that large galaxies (−23 < M (V ) < −21) in the red sequence trace the progenitor set well in terms of number and mass but that the relationship breaks down as we go towards the lower end of the luminosity function (M (V ) > −21). The number and mass fractions remain stable, as a function of the luminosity slices shown in Figure 18, within the redshift range explored in this study (0 < z < 1). Luminosity evolution studies which use the red sequence as a proxy for the early-type population (e.g. Bell et al. 2004) can therefore achieve accurate results only for the upper end of the luminosity function. However, the red sequence should not be used as a proxy for the progenitor set further down 12 S. Kaviraj et al. Figure 16. The composition of the 'red sequence', defined as the galaxy population which occupies the part of the CM space dominated by early-type galaxies (shown in grey), compared with the progenitor set in cluster populations. The diamonds indicate galaxies which are part of the progenitor set. Galaxies which are not part of the progenitor set are shown using small crosses. Galaxies in the red sequence are circled. The 'red sequence' misses blue galaxies, both early-type and late-type. This plot shows the evolution of the 'red sequence' from low to intermediate redshift. Figure 17. The composition of the 'red sequence', defined as the galaxy population which occupies the part of the CM space dominated by early-type galaxies (shown in grey), compared with the progenitor set in cluster populations. The diamonds indicate galaxies which are part of the progenitor set. Galaxies which are not part of the progenitor set are shown using small crosses. Galaxies in the red sequence are circled. The 'red sequence' misses blue galaxies, both early-type and late-type. This plot shows the evolution of the 'red sequence' from intermediate to high redshift. the luminosity function, since a larger fraction of the (spi- ral) red sequence does not contribute to the progenitor set. In addition, the red sequence, almost by definition, misses contributions due to early-types which lie blueward of it. This is increasingly true at higher redshift - hence conclu- sions based on the colours of the red sequence should not generally be applied to early-type evolution. 6 CONCLUSIONS We have comprehensively explored the extent of progenitor bias as a function of the luminosity and environment of the early-type remnant at z = 0. Our study, using the GALICS semi-analytical model, is the first of its kind which uses a fully realistic semi-analytical framework, in which mass as- sembly and morphological transformation can be followed accurately in the context of the currently popular hierarchi- cal merger paradigm. Against the backdrop of the impend- ing or recent release of data from large-scale surveys at high redshift, the results of this study are timely, providing a pic- ture of the mass assembly in present-day early-types and gauging the extent by which progenitor bias may affect the conclusions from 'early-type only' studies at high redshift. The main conclusions from our study can be sum- marised as follows: • Larger early-types in all environments are assembled later than their less massive counterparts. However, their stellar populations are generally older (Kaviraj et al. 2005). • On average, without reference to environment, only 35 percent of early-type galaxies are in place by z = 1. Mor- phological transformations ar significantly faster in cluster environments (where the vast majority of early-type studies have been based before the advent of large-scale surveys). In clusters almost 70 percent of early-types are in place by z = 1. In other words, the probability of a 'major merger', which creates an early-type remnant is low after z = 1 in cluster type environments. • Averaging across all environments, at z ∼ 1, less than 50 percent of the stellar mass which ends up in early-types today is actually in early-type progenitors at this redshift. This value is around 65 percent in clusters owing to faster The progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies 13 20 to 40 percent of spirals with M (B) < −20.5 are early- type progenitors. At intermediate redshifts 0.3 < z < 0.5, these values rise to 30 and 60 percent respectively. At high redshift (z ∼ 1) spirals with M (B) < −21.5 have more than a 60 percent probability of being an early-type progenitor while spirals with −20 < M (B) < −21.5 have between a 30 and 40 percent chance of being early-type progenitors. The falling progenitor fractions towards lower redshift are partly due to the changing morphological mix of the Universe. • The colour-magnitude space of the spiral population provides a better route to identifying spiral progenitors us- ing both the luminosity and the optical colour. At z ∼ 0.1, spirals with −21.5 < M (B) < −20.5 have ∼ 30 percent chance of being a progenitor. For larger spirals, those with red (B − V ) colours, i.e. (B − V ) > 0.8, have ∼ 60 per- cent chance of being a progenitor, while the corresponding probability for bluer spirals is 30 to 50 percent. At intermediate redshift (z ∼ 0.5), red spirals, with −21.5 < M (B) < −20.5 and (B − V ) > 0.6, have ∼ 30 percent probability of being an early-type progenitor, while blue spirals in the same luminosity range have a low pro- genitor probability. For larger spirals at these redshifts, the probabilities are appreciably higher - red spirals with (B − V ) > 0.7 have between a 75 and 95 percent chance of being progenitors, while 50 to 75 percent of blue spirals in this luminosity range are progenitors. The situation at high redshift z ∼ 1 is similar to that at intermediate redshift. The trends in the (V − K) colour are similar to those in (B − V ). • Finally we have explored the correspondence between the progenitor set and the 'red sequence', defined as the part of the CM parameter space which is dominated by early-type galaxies. We find that galaxies, both late and early-type, that fall in this parameter space do not necessarily trace the progenitor set well. Large galaxies (−23 < M (V ) < −21) in the red sequence correspond to the progenitor set reason- ably well in terms of number and mass but the relationship breaks down as we go towards the lower end of the lumi- nosity function (M (V ) > −21). Hence, luminosity evolution studies which use the red sequence as a proxy for the early- type population, therefore achieve accurate results only for the upper end of the luminosity function. In addition, the red sequence, almost by definition, misses contributions due to early-types which lie blueward of it - hence conclusions based on the colours of the red sequence should not gen- erally be applied to early-type evolution, especially at high redshift. REFERENCES Baugh, C. M., S. Cole, and C. S. Frenk (1996). MN- RAS 283, 1361 -- 1378. Bell, E. F. and GEMS collaboration (2004). ApJ 608, 752 -- 767. Blakeslee, J. P., M. Franx, M. Postman, P. Rosati, B. P. Holden, G. D. Illingworth, H. C. Ford, N. J. G. Cross, C. Gronwall, N. Ben´ıtez, R. J. Bouwens, T. J. Broadhurst, M. Clampin, R. Demarco, D. A. Golimowski, G. F. Hartig, L. Infante, A. R. Martel, G. K. Miley, F. Menanteau, G. R. Meurer, M. Sirianni, and R. L. White (2003). ApJ 596, L143 -- L146. Figure 18. Comparison between galaxies in the actual progenitor set to those in the red sequence. TOP: Number ratio between the progenitor set population and the red sequence population split by redshift and luminosity. BOTTOM: Mass ratio between the progenitor set population and the red sequence population split by redshift and luminosity. It is apparent that large galaxies in the red sequence trace the progenitor set well in terms of number and mass but that the relationship breaks down rather rapidly as we go towards the lower end of the luminosity function. morphological transformation in this environment. In other words, looking only at early-type progenitors does not take into account almost half the mass in the progenitor set - the progenitor set doubles in mass in the redshift range 0 < z < 1. • Progenitor bias does not arise simply because (late- type) progenitor mass is missed, but also because the age profile of mass in progenitors of different morphological types tend to vary. Spiral progenitors are typically 'bluer' because they host more recently formed stars than early- type progenitors. Hence, age-dating the progenitor set using an 'early-type only' CMR after excluding the spiral progen- itors biases the CMR towards redder colours and overesti- mates the average of the population. • One of the principal aims of this study is to provide a means of including spiral progenitors which might be early- type progenitors, and thus correct, at least partially, for pro- genitor bias. We have therefore focussed on spiral progeni- tors in the model and compared their properties, in detail, to the general spiral population. • There is a greater preponderance of progenitors among larger spirals at all redshifts. At low redshifts (z < 0.1), 14 S. Kaviraj et al. Bower, R. G., J. R. Lucey, and R. Ellis (1992). MN- RAS 254, 589. Buta, R., S. Mitra, G. de Vaucouleurs, and H. G. Corwin (1994). AJ 107, 118 -- 134. Cross, N., S. P. Driver, W. Couch, C. M. Baugh, J. Bland- Hawthorn, T. Bridges, R. Cannon, S. Cole, M. Colless, C. Collins, G. Dalton, K. Deeley, R. De Propris, G. Efs- tathiou, R. S. Ellis, C. S. Frenk, K. Glazebrook, C. Jack- son, O. Lahav, I. Lewis, S. Lumsden, S. Maddox, D. Madg- wick, S. Moody, P. Norberg, J. A. Peacock, B. A. Peter- son, I. Price, M. Seaborne, W. Sutherland, H. Tadros, and K. Taylor (2001). MNRAS 324, 825 -- 841. Ellis, R. S. (2002). In ASP Conf. Ser. 268: Tracing Cosmic Evolution with Galaxy Clusters, pp. 311 -- +. Hatton, S., J. E. G. Devriendt, S. Ninin, F. R. Bouchet, B. Guiderdoni, and D. Vibert (2003). MNRAS 343, 75 -- 106. Kaviraj, S., J. E. G. Devriendt, I. Ferreras, and S. K. Yi (2005). MNRAS 360, 60 -- 68. Martin, D. C. and GALEX Team (2005). ApJ 619, L1 -- L6. Simien, F. and G. de Vaucouleurs (1986). ApJ 302, 564 -- 578. Stanford, S. A., P. R. Eisenhardt, and M. Dickinson (1998). ApJ 492, 461 -- +. van den Bosch, F. C. (2002). MNRAS 331, 98 -- 110. van Dokkum, P. (2004). In Wide-Field Imaging From Space. van Dokkum, P. G. and M. Franx (1996). MNRAS 281, 985 -- 1000. van Dokkum, P. G. and M. Franx (2001). ApJ 553, 90 -- 102. van Dokkum, P. G., M. Franx, D. Fabricant, G. D. Illing- worth, and D. D. Kelson (2000). ApJ 541, 95 -- 111. van Dokkum, P. G., M. Franx, D. Fabricant, D. D. Kelson, and G. D. Illingworth (1999). ApJ 520, L95 -- L98. van Dokkum, P. G., M. Franx, D. D. Kelson, and G. D. Illingworth (1998). ApJ 504, L17+. van Dokkum, P. G., S. A. Stanford, B. P. Holden, P. R. Eisenhardt, M. Dickinson, and R. Elston (2001). ApJ 552, L101 -- L104. Wolf, C., K. Meisenheimer, M. Kleinheinrich, A. Borch, S. Dye, M. Gray, L. Wisotzki, E. F. Bell, H.-W. Rix, A. Cimatti, G. Hasinger, and G. Szokoly (2004). A&A 421, 913 -- 936.
astro-ph/0201172	1	0201	2002-01-11T11:31:22	Selection of high-z supernovae candidates	[ "astro-ph" ]	Deep, ground based, optical wide-field supernova searches are capable of detecting a large number of supernovae over a broad redshift range up to z~1.5. While it is practically unfeasible to obtain spectroscopic redshifts of all the supernova candidates right after the discovery, we show that the magnitudes and colors of the host galaxies, as well as the supernovae, can be used to select high-z supernova candidates, for subsequent spectroscopic and photometric follow-up. Using Monte-Carlo simulations we construct criteria for selecting galaxies in well-defined redshift bands. For example, with a selection criteria using B-R and R-I colors we are able to pick out potential host galaxies for which z>0.85 with 80% confidence level and with a selection efficiency of 64-86%. The method was successfully tested using real observations from the HDF. Similarly, we show that that the magnitude and colors of the supernova discovery data can be used to constrain the redshift. With a set of cuts based on V-R and R-I in a search to m_I~25, supernovae at z~1 can be selected in a redshift interval sigma_z <0.15.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Selection of high-z supernovae candidates Tomas Dahl´en Stockholm Observatory, SCFAB, SE-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden [email protected] and Ariel Goobar Physics Department, Stockholm University, SCFAB, SE-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden [email protected] ABSTRACT Deep, ground based, optical wide-field supernova searches are capable of de- tecting a large number of supernovae over a broad redshift range up to z ∼ 1.5. While it is practically unfeasible to obtain spectroscopic redshifts of all the su- pernova candidates right after the discovery, we show that the magnitudes and colors of the host galaxies, as well as the supernovae, can be used to select high-z supernova candidates, for subsequent spectroscopic and photometric follow-up. Using Monte-Carlo simulations we construct criteria for selecting galaxies in well-defined redshift bands. For example, with a selection criteria using B − R and R−I colors we are able to pick out potential host galaxies for which z ≥ 0.85 with 80% confidence level and with a selection efficiency of 64 -- 86%. The method was successfully tested using real observations from the HDF. Similarly, we show that that the magnitude and colors of the supernova dis- covery data can be used to constrain the redshift. With a set of cuts based on V − R and R − I in a search to mI ∼ 25, supernovae at z ∼ 1 can be selected in a redshift interval σz ≤ 0.15. Subject headings: Cosmology: observations -- supernovae: general 1. Introduction High-z Type Ia supernovae (hereafter SNe) have been shown to be very accurate tools for studying cosmological parameters (Perlmutter et al. 1999; Riess et al. 1998). As the -- 2 -- sensitivity of the magnitude-redshift relation increases with the size of the redshift range probed, searches for SNe at redshifts z >∼ 1 become crucial to refine our understanding of cosmology (Goobar & Perlmutter 1995; Goliath et al. 2001). One of the difficulties in searches dedicated to high-z SNe is to select candidates for subsequent follow-up. An I-band SN search down to mI ∼ 25 generates candidates in a broad redshift range: 0.1 < z <∼ 1.5. On a 1 square degree detection image, separated by three weeks from a reference image, there will be about a dozen Type Ia SNe on the rising part of the light curve. Additional information is required to make the follow-up of z > 0.85 SNe efficient. This is particularly important as the follow-up of candidates with space instruments, such as HST, needs to be decided upon very soon after discovery, leaving limited time for prior spectroscopic screening. In this paper we discuss how broad-band photometry of the host galaxy, as well as the SN can be used in order to select targets with σz ∼ 0.15 with high efficiency. We focus on the optical bands, producing mainly SNe up to z ∼ 1.5. In Section 2 we discuss the SN rates that are used in our simulations. In Section 3 we study the use of host galaxy magnitudes and colors to estimate the redshift of a SN candidate, followed by a discussion in Section 4 on how deep a survey must be in order to obtain the required galaxy colors. In section 5 we discuss the use of SN magnitude and color for redshift estimation. Finally, a summary and conclusions are given in Section 6. In this paper we assume a flat cosmology with ΩM = 0.3 and ΩΛ = 0.7, and a Hubble constant H0 = 65 km s−1 Mpc−1 Magnitudes are given in the standard Vega based system. 2. SN rates Models of high-z SN rates predict an increase out to z ∼ 1.5 (Madau, Della Valle & Panagia 1998; Dahl´en & Fransson 1999). This increase reflects the observed increase in the star formation in galaxies out to these redshifts. (e.g. Madau, Pozzetti & Dickinson 1998). At higher redshifts the evolution of the star formation rate, and therefore SN rate, is more uncertain. This is mainly due to the uncertainty in the amount of dust extinction affecting observations of high-z galaxies. A direct relation between star formation rate and SN rate is, however, only valid for core collapse SN (Types II, Ib/c), where the SN progenitor is a short lived star. For Type Ia SNe there is an unknown time delay between the formation of the SN progenitor star and the explosion of the SN. In the models cited above, a parameter τ is introduced to represent this time delay. Considered values of τ lie in the range 0.3-3 -- 3 -- Gyr. Calculating the absolute numbers for the SN rates involves a number parameters, such as the distribution of SN types, peak luminosities, light curves, IMF, cosmology, and most important, assumptions about dust extinction. Estimated rates could therefore have an uncertainty of about a factor 2-3. Using simulations described in Dahl´en & Fransson (1999), we estimate that a detection image, taken three weeks after a reference image, should result in ∼ 20 − 45 SNe per sq. deg. Here we have used a limiting magnitude mI = 25, and a detection criteria where the SNe on the second image are > 0.5 mag brighter than on the reference image. Approximately half of the SNe are Type Ia that are still brightening. In this paper we are not directly affected by the absolute value of the SN rate at different z, since the aim here is to estimate the redshift for SN candidates already detected. However, in our simulations we estimate the redshift distribution of the observable SNe, therefore, the relative evolution of the SN rate with z must be considered. In our models we use both a constant and an evolving Type Ia SN rate, where the latter is taken from the theoretical models in Dahl´en & Fransson (1999). Figure 1 shows the differential observable Type Ia SN rate vs redshift (arbitrary units) for models with constant SN rate (solid line) and evolving rates with τ = 1.0 Gyr (dashed line) and τ = 3.0 Gyr (dotted line). The distribution was generated with a Monte-Carlo (MC) simulation of 105 SNe (for each model) up to a redshift z = 2. The integrated rate is normalized to unity for all three cases. Note that the shape of the distribution is given by two effects when going from intrinsic rates, to rates in the observer's frame: the volume effect makes the number of high-z SNe increase to z ∼ 1.8, and the cosmological time dilation makes the rates fall as (1 + z)−1. 3. Selection by host galaxy colors Using the magnitude and colors of the host galaxy to select SN candidates has the advantage that a catalog listing probable high-z galaxies can be constructed in advance. When a SN is detected, it possible to immediately determine if it is a high-z candidate. Also, the host galaxy redshift gives an estimate of the absolute magnitude of the SNe, which can set constraints regarding SN type, since Type Ia's have brighter peak luminosities than other SN types, except for a small fraction of extremely luminous core collapse SNe. This is important since an increasing fraction of the SNe will be Type Ib/c or II as one reaches for fainter magnitude limits. -- 4 -- Using host galaxy magnitudes requires deep images of the survey field from which colors can be obtained. The limiting magnitude of this field should typically be >∼ 1 mag deeper than the limiting magnitude of the SN search images in order to reach equivalent depth for the extended galaxies and the point source SNe. A natural way of obtaining a deep background field is to add the images from the subsequent search epochs. When calculating the galaxy properties we are here primarily interested in the host galaxies of Type Ia SNe. Therefore, we include all types of galaxies, even though only Type Ia's have been found to occur in ellipticals (e.g. Wang, Hoflich & Wheeler 1997). The accuracy of redshift determination by using host galaxy magnitude and colors depend on the limiting magnitude, the accuracy in the photometry and the choice of filters, and is a trade off between the required precision in redshift and the amount of observing time available. 3.1. One filter Using the host galaxy magnitude in the band where the SN search is conducted can be used to calculate a rough probability of the SN being at high z. To quantify this we estimate the redshift distribution of galaxies as a function of the observed I-band magnitude. We simulate the field by distributing galaxies over a redshift range 0 < z < 2, with absolute magnitudes according to a field luminosity function (LF). We choose a LF described by two Schechter functions (Schechter 1976), one for early type galaxies with M ∗ B = −20.2 and α = −0.8, and one for late type galaxies with M ∗ B = −20.6 and α = −1.25. These values are consistent with results from Metcalfe et al. (1991). Note, however, that the uncertainties B, are fairly large, and it is not clear if early-types or late- in these parameters, especially M ∗ types have the brightest M ∗ B (e.g. Metcalfe et al. 1991; Lilly et al. 1995; He et al. 2001). It is also expected that the LF evolve with redshift (Lilly et al. 1995). At first we do not include a luminosity evolution, but take this into account further down. The two Schechter functions are normalized so that the fraction of early-type galaxies is 15%. The late-type galaxies are further divided so that 35% of the total number of galaxies are spirals and 50% Irregulars. This is approximately the same fractions as for galaxies in the HDF to z ∼ 1 (Fern´andes-Soto, Lanzetta & Yahil 1999). Observed magnitudes are calculated by adding the distance modulus and type dependent K-corrections to the rest frame magnitudes. K-corrections are calculated from the E, Sbc, Scd and Im galaxy templates in Coleman, Wu & Weedman (1980). We also include a Sa template from Kinney et al. (1996). In the left panel of Figure 2 we plot the resulting redshift -- 5 -- distribution for three magnitude bins, mI = 20 -- 21 (dotted line), mI = 22 -- 23 (dashed line) and mI = 24 -- 25 (solid line). The mean redshifts in these bins are ¯z = 0.38, 0.59 and 0.75, respectively. The percentages of galaxies with redshift z > 0.85 are 0.6, 18 and 39%, respectively. Without any additional information these results indicate that a host galaxy should have mI > 24, in order to have a reasonably high probability of being at high redshift. Note that the peak in each distribution in Figure 2 is normalized to unity. Next we take into account that SNe should be more frequent in galaxies with high intrin- sic luminosity. We do this by weighting each galaxy with its rest-frame B-band luminosity. For Type Ia's, with the unknown time delay between star formation and SN explosion, the relation between galaxy luminosity and SN rate is probably more complex than a pure pro- portionality. However observations show that Type Ia SN rates, as well as Type II rates, are close to proportional to the B-band luminosity (Cappellaro et al. 1993). Therefore, in order to compensate for galaxy luminosities, we use the assumption that Type Ia rates are proportional to B-band luminosities. In the left panel of Figure 3 we show the resulting probability distribution for host galaxy absolute magnitudes. The solid line shows the total distribution, while the dashed and dotted lines show the distribution divided into early-type and late-type galaxies, respectively. The most probable host galaxy magnitudes lies in a range of ∆M ± ∼ 1.5 mag from M ∗ B. Note also that the shape of the LF creates a sharp cut-off at bright magnitudes. This can be used in a first rejection of host galaxies based on their apparent magnitudes. For example, a galaxy with apparent magnitude mI ∼ 20 would have to have MB <∼ − 22.5, in order to be at z >∼ 0.8, which according to the plot is unlikely. A strongly evolving LF could, however, move this cut-off to brighter magnitudes. In the right panel of Figure 3 we plot MB as a function of redshift for a galaxy with observed magnitude mI = 20, for five different galaxy types. The choice of magnitude, mI = 20, is here arbitrary, the plot can be scaled to any apparent I-band magnitude. Using the probability function for host galaxy magnitudes, we plot the redshift distribu- tion of SN host galaxies in the middle panel of Figure 2, using the same magnitude intervals as above. The distributions are here shifted towards higher redshift compared to the left panel. This is natural since intrinsically bright galaxies can be detected to higher redshifts. We must also consider that SNe are not likely to be detected at z >∼ 1.4 in optical searches to mI ∼ 25 (shown in a later section). Therefore, we may safely neglect host galaxies at these redshifts. To compensate for this we introduce a linear cut-off between z = 1.3 and z = 1.4, as illustrated this by the dash-dotted line in Figure 2. The mean redshifts in the three magnitude intervals, mI = 20 -- 21, 22 -- 23 and 24 -- 25, are ¯z = 0.54, 0.87 and 1.06, respectively. The percentages of probable host galaxies with z > 0.85 are 3, 54 and 82% -- 6 -- for the three magnitude bins, indicating that mI ∼ 22 should be sufficiently deep for a relatively high probability of a host galaxy being at high z. So far we have used a non evolving LF, which here is equivalent to assuming a constant SN rate with redshift. Next we take the increase in galaxy luminosity at high-z into account by using an evolving Type Ia SN rate (τ = 1 Gyr model from Dahl´en & Fransson (1999)). The resulting host galaxy distribution is shown in the right panel of Figure 2. There is here a small shift towards higher redshifts compared to the case with constant SN rate. The mean redshifts in the three magnitude intervals are now ¯z = 0.64, 0.96 and 1.12. The fractions of host galaxies with z > 0.85 in the three bins are 9, 70 and 90%, respectively. In Figure 4 we plot the probability that a host galaxy has a redshift z > 0.75 (dotted line), z > 0.85 (solid line) and z > 0.95 (dashed line), as a function of apparent I-band magnitude. The host galaxies are here weighted with their intrinsic luminosities as above. We have used a constant SN rate in the left panel, and an evolving rate in the right panel. In the following discussion of host galaxy colors it is important to take into account these results regarding the apparent magnitudes when estimating the redshift of SN host galaxies. 3.2. Two filters With two filters we can use the color information of the host galaxy together with the In addition to the I-band, we here apparent magnitude to better constrain the redshift. assume that B or V -band magnitudes are available. Figure 5 shows B − I and V − I colors as a function of redshift for the five different galaxy types. The figure clearly illustrates the strong evolution of the galaxy color with redshift. The main reason for the reddening with z is the cosmological shift of the 4000A break out of the B- and V -bands at increasing redshift. At z ∼ 1 the 4000 A break moves into the I-band, and the curves flatten. The stronger break in early-type galaxies leads to a more pronounced color evolution in E and Sa galaxies. A problem when using a single color is the large spread between different galaxy types. Morphological information on the host galaxy makes the selection efficiency better, even though one should remember that there is no one-to-one correspondence between the morphological type and the spectroscopical type giving the colors (e.g., Dressler et al. 1999; Poggianti et al. 1999). Also, the presence of internal redding can affect the colors of a specified morphological type. Therefore, one should be careful when using a single color to estimate redshift. Note also that the evolution is generally stronger in B − I. However, this also leads to a -- 7 -- rapid fainting of the galaxies in B, and long exposure times are needed in order to measure the colors. 3.3. Three filters When the galaxy spectrum is cosmologically redshifted the colors change, as described in the previous section. This effect can be quantified by the evolution of observed colors in a color-color diagram. The left panel of Figure 6 shows the position of galaxies (E, Sa, Sbc, Scd and Im) in a two-dimensional color-color diagram of B − R vs. R − I, while the right panel shows the same for V − R vs. R − I. The 'x's define the z = 0 position for each galaxy type. The contours show the color-color evolution up to z = 1.2, marked by an 'o', where steps in z of 0.2 are shown by a '' mark. Note that marks defining the same redshifts approximately fall on straight "iso-redshift" contours going from the bottom left to the top right part of the figures. Including a larger sample of templates with intermediate types results in color-color curves with redshift marks approximately falling on these contours. Including internal redding in the templates also shifts the curves along the "iso-redshift" contours. E.g., assuming E(B − V ) = 0.3 in an Scd galaxy makes the colors become almost identical to an Sbc galaxy. Internal redding is therefore not a severe problem when estimating redshifts using color-color selection. As can be seen in the plot, the bottom right part defines a region with z >∼ 0.85. Note also that using B instead of V results in a more distinct evolution (note different scales on the y-axis). As already mentioned, however, the trade-off with the B-band is that significantly more observing time is required. We discuss this in Section 4. One should notice that there are many factors involved when using color-color selection, i.e filter choices, magnitude limits, accuracy in magnitudes, the galaxy types of interest and their absolute magnitudes. To quantify how three filter color-color selection can be used in order to select high-z candidates we use MC simulations. In the example we choose to select host galaxies with z ≥ 0.85. For this redshift limit, R and I filters should be used, since here the 4000 A break has just left the R-band and is moving into the I-band. In the simulations, both the B- and V -bands are used as the third filter. The U-band has not been considered due to the long exposure times that would be needed in that case. -- 8 -- 3.3.1. Color -- color selection with BRI and V RI A total of ∼ 250000 galaxies were generated and distributed from early-type ellipticals to irregulars, with a distribution according to the LF described in Section 3.1, and in a redshift range 0 < z < 1.4. Observed magnitudes are calculated by adding distance modulus and type dependent K-corrections. To each magnitude (i.e B, V , R and I) of each galaxy, a random error is generated as to mimic the real uncertainties in photometry. We use a normal distribution with a sigma value varying from 0.06 mag at bright magnitudes, mI < 20, to 0.1 mag at our limit mI = 25. Besides the variation in colors due to spectral type and internal redding, there is also a possibility of an intrinsic variation in the colors within a specified spectral type. To account for this we add an extra dispersion of 0.1 mag to each color. This is consistent with the difference in colors between the template sets of Coleman, Wu & Weedman (1980) and Kinney et al. (1996), when comparing elliptical and Sbc galaxies individually. We distribute galaxies out to the cut-off at z ∼ 1.4, described in Section 3.1. We consider two models with different SN rates. The first model has a constant SN rate, equivalent with a non-evolving LF. In the second model we weight each galaxy with the SN rate taken from the evolving model with τ = 1. Figure 7 shows a representative fraction of the generated galaxies in a color-color dia- grams in the case of a non-evolving LF. The circles represent galaxies with redshift z > 0.85, crosses show the galaxies with z < 0.85. Three lines are also shown in the figure as exam- ples of selection criteria. On the right side of these lines the probability that a host galaxy has z > 0.85 is 0.7, 0.8 and 0.9 for the left, middle and right lines, respectively. In the following we call these probability criteria p(0.7), p(0.8) and p(0.9). As expected, these criteria are almost parallel to the "iso-redshift" contours for z ∼ 0.85. Therefore, using a larger set of templates, or including internal redding do not affect the results since this mainly moves the galaxy colors along these contours. The difference in selection efficiency between using B and V can be quantified by cal- culating the fraction of the simulated galaxies with known redshift z > 0.85, that are actually picked out by the selection criteria. With BRI selection, (40,64,86)% of the galax- ies that have z > 0.85 are picked out when using (p(0.9), p(0.8), p(0.7)). With V RI selection, the numbers are (31,47,73)%. For the model with evolving SN rate, there are relatively more SNe at high z, therefore the selection efficiency is higher in this model. We find that (51,86,99)% of the galaxies that have z > 0.85 are picked out when we construct selection criteria (p(0.9), p(0.8), p(0.7)) in BRI. With V RI, the percentages are (43,80,98)%. Similar selection criteria can easily be produced for other choices of redshift, filters, photometric errors and limiting magnitudes. Note that it is important that the selection criteria are calculated for a limiting magnitude matching that of the real observations. For -- 9 -- example, if the limiting magnitude is mI = 22, instead of mI = 25 as used here, then the lines representing the 0.9 probability criterion in the plot, will no longer be valid. Instead, these lines would represent a ∼ 0.6 -- 0.7 probability. Note also that the apparent magnitudes for the individual galaxies are not explicitly used in the color-color selections (except that they must be brighter than the limiting I magnitude). Therefore, one should take the results regarding the absolute magnitudes of the host galaxy into account, e.g. the results described by Figure 3. 3.3.2. Checking the simulation against HDF To test the color-color selection against real observations we calculate selection criteria for the HDF-N using MC simulations as above, using a constant SN rate. We use the f450w, f606w and f814w filters, corresponding to B, V and I. In Figure 8 we plot selection criteria analogue to Figure 7, i.e to the right of the three lines the probabilities are 0.7, 0.8 and 0.9, that a host galaxy has z > 0.85, going from left to right lines. In the figure we have also plotted galaxies in the HDF with spectroscopic redshift 0.0 < z < 1.4 and mI < 25. Photometry and redshifts for these galaxies are taken from the catalog published by Fern´andes-Soto et al. (1999). Galaxies with spectroscopic redshift z > 0.85 are marked by circles, while lower redshift galaxies are marked by crosses. In total there are 79 galaxies to the limiting magnitude, of which 22 are at z > 0.85. The figure shows that the high-z and low-z galaxies occupy different regions in the color-color plot. To the right of the p(0.7) line, 65% of the real galaxies have z > 0.85. For the p(0.8) and p(0.9) lines, 80 and 100% of the galaxies have z > 0.85. Of the total number of galaxies with z > 0.85, 100% lie to the right of p(0.7), while 91 and 36% lies to the right of p(0.8) and p(0.9), respectively. 3.4. Four or more filters With a set of four or more filters available, it is possible to set both lower and upper limits on the redshifts of individual galaxies, using photometric redshift techniques (as compared to the three filters case where we estimate the probability that a galaxy has a redshift above, or below, some chosen limit). The photometric redshift technique has developed much during the last years, and has now been used in a variety of applications. There are basically two different approaches to the technique. In the empirical fitting method (e.g. Connolly et al. 1995; Connolly et al. 1997; Wang, Bahcall & Turner 1998; Brunner, Connolly & Szalay 1999) a training set of galaxies with known redshifts are used to derive a polynomial giving the -- 10 -- redshift as a function of colors and magnitudes. In the template fitting technique (Puschell, Owen & Laing 1982; Gwyn 1995; Mobasher et al. 1996; Sawicki, Lin & Yee 1997; Fern´andes- Soto et al. 1999; Bolzonella, Miralles & Pell´o 2000; Fontana et al. 2000) a chi-square fit is made between observed colors and as set of galaxy templates redshifted over a range of redshift. The accuracy of the method to z <∼ 1.3 can reach σz ∼ 0.05(1 + z) (Cohen et al. 2000), depending on the number of filters and photometric errors. With this accuracy, high-z host galaxies can readily be found. The trade-off with the method is, of course, the large amount of observing time required to map a large sky coverage inat least four bands. A public available code, hyperz, for calculating photometric redshifts using the template fitting method is published by Bolzonella et al. (2000). 4. Galaxy magnitudes In this analysis we have used a limiting magnitude mI = 25. Two questions should be addressed here. Is this deep enough to reach host galaxies at redshifts of interest, and what limiting magnitudes are required in the other filters in order to get the desired colors? In Table 1 we give the rest frame B magnitudes as a function of redshift for different galaxy types, assuming an observed magnitude mI = 25. Comparing these results with Figure 3 shows that most host galaxies at z <∼ 1 should be reached, since we here reach an absolute magnitude MB >∼ − 19. To quantify this further we also list the fraction of SN host galaxies that can be detected at different redshifts, assuming three different limiting magnitudes, mI = 24, mI = 25 and mI = 26. Next we investigate the limiting magnitudes that must be reached in different filters to get the colors of galaxies of different types, and at different redshifts. In Table 2 we list the apparent magnitudes in B, V and R for a galaxies with an observed magnitude mI = 25. We list the magnitudes for E, Sbc and Im galaxies. Sa and Scd galaxies have magnitudes approximately in between these. Note that Table 2 does not imply that galaxies get brighter at higher redshift. If we consider two elliptical galaxies at, i.e., z = 0.8 and z = 1.4, that have the same apparent magnitude in the I-band, then the galaxy at z = 1.4 will be 0.8 mag brighter in B, than the galaxy at z = 0.8. This is a consequence of the turn-over at z >∼ 0.8 in the B − I color vs. redshift diagram (Figure 5). Finally we estimate the limiting magnitudes in B, V and R that are required in order to detect 70, 80, 90 and 95% of the host galaxies with mI ≤ 25, in these three filters, at different redshifts. Results are listed in Table 3. Again, in some bands there is an apparent -- 11 -- trend of brighter limiting magnitudes at higher z, which is explained by the use of a constant limit on the I-band. One must here take into account that a decreasing fraction of the total number of host galaxies are detected to this limit in I, as shown in the "f (mI = 25)" column of Table 1. It is also important to remember that the fractions given in Table 1, and the magnitudes given in Table 3, are calculated for SN host galaxies, i.e. where we have weighted each galaxy with its intrinsic luminosity. The fractions and magnitudes are therefore not valid for a pure galaxy search. As an example, Table 3 shows that in order to get colors of 90 percent of the objects at z ∼ 1, detected in a survey with limiting magnitude mI = 25, it is necessary to reach mB ∼ 28.1, mV ∼ 26.8 and mR ∼ 25.6. This information should be complemented with the results in Table 1, which shows that ∼ 82% of the total number of host galaxies at z ∼ 1 should be brighter than the limiting magnitude mI = 25. The typical telescope time needed to reach mI = 25 with an 8m class telescope is ∼ 0.3h (1.1h) for a S/N = 5 (10). The total time required to get three color information in V RI is ∼ 1.5h (6h), assuming depths mV ∼ 27, mR ∼ 26 and mI ∼ 25. Adding the B-band requires an additional 2.2h (8.9h) of observing time, i.e. more than the other three band together. Numbers are taken from the Subaru telescope's Suprime-Cam1. 5. Using SN magnitude and color to estimate redshift Similar to using host galaxy magnitudes and colors, it is possible to use these quantities of the SNe themselves to estimate the redshift and SN type. For example, Riess et al. (2001) concluded that the most distant known supernova, SN1997ff, was a Type Ia supernova at a redshift z = 1.7 ± 0.1, based on the SN photometry. From the host galaxy, Riess et al derived a consistent photometric redshift, z = 1.65 ± 0.15. One difficulty is the temporal evolution of the SN light: one does not know at which phase in the lightcurve the SN was discovered. In this section we use the Monte-Carlo simulation package SNOC (Goobar et al. 2001) to compute the SN discovery and selec- tion probabilities using the photometric and spectroscopic templates of "normal" Type Ia SNe described in Nugent et al. (2001). A potential selection bias due to color-brightness correlations could be a source of concern but is not considered in this work. The simulated redshift distribution of the discovered Type Ia SNe in an I-band search is 1Exposure Time Calculator at http://www.subaru.naoj.org/ -- 12 -- shown in the upper panel of Figure 9. To produce a conservative estimate of the number of SNe with redshift z > 1, we have assumed that the SN rate per comoving volume is constant up to z ∼ 1.5. In the simulations, SNe are selected when the subtraction of SN photometry three weeks apart exceeds the threshold brightness in I-band, e.g. mI < 252. The absolute peak magnitude of the Type Ia SNe is assumed to be MB = −19.33, with an intrinsic spread of ∆M rest B = 0.40 mag. This large spread gives a conservative representation of the distribution of brightness for Ia supernovae prior to any lightcurve shape corrections. The intrinsic brightness spread at discovery is further enlarged by the wide range of possible supernova lightcurve phases. For simplicity, we have assumed that all the SNe have the same lightcurve shape, i.e. constant "stretch" (or ∆m15). As discussed earlier, Type Ia SNe are found in a very broad redshift range if the selection of candidates is set by a threshold on the SN I-band magnitude alone. One way to narrow down the distribution is to impose a lower cut-off on the candidate's brightness. However, this may not be sufficiently efficient as shown in the bottom panel of Figure 9, where we plot the redshift distribution of SN in two magnitude intervals, 23 < mI < 24 and 24 < mI < 25. Long tails towards the lower redshifts makes this approach not optimal. In addition, this sort of criteria is likely to introduce a selection bias which could severely worsen the precision of cosmological parameters to be estimated from the data set and the measurements of the SN rates. Next, we investigate the brightness and colors of Type Ia SN vs redshift. Figure 10 shows the optical color and magnitude evolution at the date of maximum for the redshifted rest-frame B-band light of a "normal" Type Ia SN. We use SNOC to study the magnitudes and colors of the SNe at the discovery epoch assuming a three weeks gap between reference and discovery images. Figure 11 shows the average magnitude and its standard deviation in BV RI and the B − V , V − R and R − I color at the discovery epoch. Note that the intrinsic spread in the SN peak magnitude, as well as the measurement errors, are small compared to the magnitude range that emerges from all the possible reference and discovery epochs for the SNe. 2The selection criteria is thus not identical to the one described in section 2 -- 13 -- 5.1. Two and three band selection Next we show examples of possible selection criteria using two and three filters. Figure 12 shows the selected range of redshifts demanding R − I > 0.8 (dashed line) and in addition demanding V − I > 1.5 (dotted line). The solid line shows the total distribution of Type Ia SNe with mI ≤ 25. We assume an uncertainty in the color from both intrinsic color dispersion and measurement Gaussian error of σM = 0.1 magnitudes. In the bottom panel we fit a Gaussian probability density function to the redshift distribution of SNe after imposing both criteria. This fit shows that it is possible to select candidates around z ∼ 1 with an accuracy σz ≈ 0.12, if three bands are used. The V RI selection rejects about 73 % of the detected SNe, but it is 82 (99)% efficient in keeping candidates with z ≥ 0.9 (z ≥ 1.0). Out of the selected sample, less than 6 (27) % are below z = 0.9 (z = 1.0). If the selection is done based solely on R − I, 41 % of the detected SNe are kept and the width of redshift distribution is σz ≈ 0.15. The selection efficiency becomes nearly 100 % for z ≥ 0.9. The fraction of selected SNe below z = 0.9 (z = 1.0) is then 21 (49) %. Thus, the V-band information does help in rejecting the lower redshift SNe tail while introducing a moderate decrease in overall efficiency. Given the faintness of z > 1 SNe in V -band, V >∼ 27 mag, a simple R − I selection might be adequate in a realistic scenario. Finally, we address the issue of non-Ia contamination. Figure 13a shows the simulated redshift distribution of discovered Type Ia (solid line) and core collapse (dashed line) SNe for a three week image separation search with limiting magnitude mI < 25. The non-Ia SNe were simulated in the same way as Type Ia SNe. All SN types were assumed to have constant rate per comoving volume in the considered redshift range. The adopted relative intrinsic rate was NI a/Ncore = 1/2.6 for z < 1.6. Within the non-Ia class, the various SN-types (Ib/c,IIL,IIn,IIP,87a-like) were given absolute peak magnitudes, dispersions and relative fractions according to Table 1 in Dahl´en & Fransson (1999). For dust extinction by the SN host galaxy we assume a face on value AB0 = 0.32. Inclination effects are taken into account by adding an extinction ABi = 0.32[(cosi)−1 − 1], where a random inclination, i, is assigned to each object. The type of search we simulated produces a non-Ia candidate for every 2 Type Ia supernovae found3. Figures 13b and 13c show how the adopted color selections, V − R > 1.5 and R − I > 0.8 (and mI < 25) discriminate against the non-Ia supernovae, leaving a negligible contamination rate, even when a 0.3 magnitude uncertainty in color from either 3This number is rather sensitive to the limiting magnitude adopted. For example, for a limiting magnitude mI < 23 one expects only 1 non-Ia for every 5 Ia's assuming constant rate per comoving volume for all SN types -- 14 -- measurement or intrinsic dispersion is added (dashed curves). 6. Summary and conclusions We have shown that deep wide-field SN searches will detect a number of SNe over a broad redshift range. E.g., an optical search to mI ∼ 25 will find Type Ia SNe to z ∼ 1.5. In this paper we discuss the use of magnitudes and colors of the SNe, as well as the host galaxies, in order for a prompt selection of high-z SN candidates, for subsequent spectroscopic follow- up. We first discuss the use of additional photometric information on the host galaxies. The advantage of using the host galaxies for redshift estimates is that a catalog of high-z candidate galaxies can be constructed in advance, enabling a direct selection once a SN is discovered. Using the available magnitude information in the search filter gives a first indication of the probability that a SN is at high z. Adding broad-band filters increases the probability for a correct selection. Due to the cosmological shift of galaxy spectra, galaxies appear redder when they are at higher redshift (in optical to z ∼ 1). Using the color from two filters, together with the magnitude information, one can therefore set additional constraints on the redshift of the galaxy. Note, however, that different galaxy types have different colors, as well as evolution in color, which makes a single color difficult to use. The selection efficiency increases if the galaxy type is known, however, one must remember that there is no one-to-one relation between morphological type and colors. If observations of the host galaxies are available in three filters, then it is possible to derive selection criteria from the position of the galaxy in a color-color diagram. As an example, we show how such criteria can be constructed to select host galaxies with z > 0.85. Using B, R and I photometry, we construct a selection criteria so that the probability is 80% that a galaxy has z > 0.85, and where ∼ 64 − 86 % of the total number of host galaxies above this redshift are actually selected. By changing the selection criteria it is possible to increase the probability that the host galaxy is at high-z, this will, however, lead to a decrease of the fraction of the total number of high-z host galaxies that are selected. With four or more available filters it is possible to estimate photometric redshift of the host galaxies. This results in an estimate of the redshift for each galaxy separately, as compared to the three filter case, where we instead calculate the probability that a host galaxy has a redshift above, or below, some chosen limit. We also discuss the necessary depth of a search in order to detect host galaxies at z ∼ 1, and the depths required in other filters in order to calculate colors. From the results listed in -- 15 -- Table 1 & 3, we see that with a limiting magnitude mI = 25, about 80% the host galaxies at z ∼ 1.0 can be detected, while at z ∼ 1.3 the fraction is ∼ 60%. The required depths in the other optical filters to detect 90% of the galaxies with mI = 25 are mB ∼ 28.1, mV ∼ 26.8 and mR ∼ 25.6. In a similar way, we show that colors of the Type Ia SNe can also be used to constrain the redshift. A selection criteria based on (V )RI magnitudes in a SN search with limiting magnitude mI ∼ 25, leads to a possible narrowing of the redshift range of the candidates to σz ≤ 0.15 at z ∼ 1. Here 30-40% of the total number of SNe are selected, of which 75-90% have z > 0.9. Multiband photometry of SNe is also very useful to distinguish between SNe of different types. Selections based on the host galaxy magnitude and colors are preferable as they are less likely to introduce selection biases. Also, obtaining colors of the SNe requires deep multi- band observations of each candidate taken within a relatively short time interval, making this technique less feasible. More observational data is needed in order to understand and quantify the possible color-brightness correlation of high-z SNe and the resulting selection bias. Finally, the accuracy of the redshift determination, both form the galaxy and SN pho- tometric information, depends on several parameters: depths, number of available filters, accuracy in photometry etc, and is a trade-off between required accuracy and the amount of observing time available. We wish to thank the anonymous referee for valuable comments and suggestions. We also thank Peter Nugent for providing us with spectral templates of Type Ia SNe. We are grateful to Saul Perlmutter and Goran Ostlin for useful discussions. The work by TD is supported by the Swedish Research Council and the Swedish Board for Space Sciences. AG is a Royal Swedish Academy Research Fellow supported by a grant from the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation. REFERENCES Bolzonella M., Miralles J. -- M., & Pell´o R. 2000, A&A, 363, 476 Brunner R.J., Connolly A.J., & Szalay A.S. 1999, ApJ, 516, 563 Cappellaro E., et al. 1993, A&A, 268, 472 -- 16 -- Cohen, J. G., et al. 2000, ApJ, 538, 29 Coleman G.D., Wu C.-C., & Weedman D.W. 1980, ApJS, 43, 393 Connolly A.J., Csabai I., Szalay A.S., Koo D.C., Kron R.G., & Munn J.A. 1995, AJ, 110, 2655 Connolly A.J., Szalay A.S., Dickinson M., SubbaRao M.U., & Brunner R.J. 1997, ApJ, 486, 11 Dahl´en T., & Fransson C. 1999, A&A, 350, 349 Dressler A., Smail I., Poggianti B.M., Butcher H., Couch W.J., Ellis R.S., Oemler A. 1999, ApJS, 122, 51 Fern´andes-Soto A., Lanzetta K.M., & Yahil A. 1999, AJ, 513, 34 Fontana A., et al. 2000, AJ, 120, 2206 Goliath M., Amanullah R., Astier P., Goobar A., & Pain R. 2001, A&A, 380, 6 Goobar A., & Perlmutter S. 1995, ApJ, 450, 14 Goobar A., et al., 2001, in preparation Gwyn S. 1995, MS Thesis, University of Victoria He P., Zou Z.-L., & Zhang Y.-Z. 2001, preprint, astro-ph/0101095 Kinney A.L., Calzetti D., Bohlin R.C., McQuade K., Storchi -- Bergmann T., & Schmitt H.R. 1996, ApJ, 467, 38 Lilly S.J., Tresse L., Hammer F., Crampton D., & Le F`evre O. 1995, ApJ, 455, 108 Madau P., Della Valle M., & Panagia N. 1998, MNRAS, 297, L17 Madau P., Pozzetti L., & Dickinson M. 1998, ApJ, 498, 106 Metcalfe N., Shanks T., Fong R., & Jones L.R. 1991, MNRAS, 249, 498 Mobasher B., Rowan -- Robinson M., Georgakakis A., & Eaton N. 1996, MNRAS, 282, L7 Nugent P., et al. 2001, submitted to PASP Perlmutter S., et al. 1999, ApJ, 517, 565 -- 17 -- Poggianti B.M., Smail I., Dressler A., Couch W.J., Berger A.J., Butcher H., Ellis R.S., Oemler A. 1999, ApJ, 518, 576 Puschell J.J., Owen F.N., & Laing R.A. 1982, ApJ, 275, 57 Riess A.G., et al. 1998, AJ, 116, 1009 Riess A.G., et al. 2001, ApJ, 560, 49 Sawicki M.J., Lin H., & Yee H.K.C. 1997, AJ, 113, 1 Schechter P. 1976, ApJ, 203, 297 Wang L., Hoflich P., & Wheeler J.C. 1997, ApJ, 483, L29 Wang Y., Bahcall N., & Turner E.L. 1998, AJ, 116, 2081 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.0. -- 18 -- Fig. 1. -- Differential observable Type Ia SN rate as a function of redshift for three models (arbitrary units), were the integrated rate up to z = 2 has been normalized to 1 using 105 MC simulated SNe. The solid line assumes a constant SN rate per comoving volume. The dashed line shows the observable rate for τ = 1 Gyr, the dotted line τ = 3 Gyr. Note that apart from the volume effect, the observable rate falls as (1 + z)−1 due to the cosmological time dilation. -- 19 -- Fig. 2. -- The left panel shows the redshift distribution of field galaxies in three different magnitude intervals, 20 < mI < 21 (dotted line), 22 < mI < 23 (dashed line) and 24 < mI < 25 (solid line). The middle panel shows the redshift distribution of SN host galaxies. We have here weighted each galaxy with its intrinsic B-band luminosity in order to take into account that bright galaxies have higher probability of hosting a SNe. The right panel shows the distribution of SN host galaxies where we assume an evolving SN rate with redshift. The dash-dotted line represents a high-z cut-off at z ∼ 1.4, since in a mI <∼ 25 search, SNe are too faint to be detected at higher redshifts. Therefore, there should be no host galaxies beyond this cut-off. The peak in each distribution is normalized to unity. -- 20 -- Fig. 3. -- The left panel shows the probability distribution of SN host galaxy absolute magnitudes in the B-band. The solid line shows the average probability for all galaxy types, while the dashed and dotted lines show the probability for early-types and late-types separately. The distributions are derived by weighting the B-band luminosity function with the intrinsic luminosity at each magnitude. Peaks are normalized to unity. The right panel shows MB as a function of redshift for a galaxy with observed apparent magnitude mI = 20, for five different galaxy types. -- 21 -- Fig. 4. -- The probability that a SN host galaxy has z > 0.75 (dotted line), z > 0.85 (solid line) and z > 0.95 (dashed line) as a function of observed I magnitude. The left panel shows the case for a constant SN rate, while the right panel shows the case for a SN rate that evolves with redshift. -- 22 -- Fig. 5. -- B − I and V − I color as a function of redshift for five different types of galaxies. -- 23 -- Fig. 6. -- Left panel: the evolution of the V − R vs R − I color-color diagram with redshift for five different galaxy types. Right panel: the same for B − R vs R − I. High-z galaxies occupy the bottom right part of the plot. -- 24 -- Fig. 7. -- Left panel: Color-color selection criteria in B − R vs R − I. Crosses represent galaxies with z < 0.85, and circles galaxies with z > 0.85. On the right side of the lines the probability that a host galaxy has z > 0.85 is 0.7, 0.8 and 0.9 for the left, middle and right line, respectively. Right panel: the same for V − R vs. R − I. -- 25 -- Fig. 8. -- Color-color selection criteria for the HDF calculated from MC simulations. To the right of the three lines the probabilities are 0.7, 0.8 and 0.9 that a galaxy has z > 0.85, going from left to right. Galaxies in the HDF with spectroscopic redshift 0.85 < z < 1.4 are marked by circles, while galaxies with z < 0.85 are marked by crosses. Spectroscopic and photometric data for the HDF are taken from Fern´andes-Soto et al. (1999). -- 26 -- Fig. 9. -- The redshift distribution of discovered Type Ia SNe (in arbitrary units), assuming a constant SN rate per comoving volume. A discovery requires that the subtracted SN photometry between the detection and reference images exceeds the threshold brightness in the I-band. On the left hand side, the redshift distributions are calculated for limiting I-band magnitudes, mI = 23 (dotted), 24 (dashed) and 25 (solid), using the SNOC Monte- Carlo package (Goobar et al. 2001). The bottom panel shows also the redshift distribution that arises with magnitude bounds on both sides: 23 < I < 24 (dotted) and 24 < I < 25 (dashed). -- 27 -- Fig. 10. -- Color and magnitude vs redshift at light curve maximum for "normal" Type Ia SNe. -- 28 -- Fig. 11. -- Left: Average BV RI magnitudes (top to bottom) vs redshift at the discovery epoch. Right: average color vs redshift at discovery epoch for SN magnitudes mI < 25. -- 29 -- Fig. 12. -- Top panel: selected redshift range with cut on R − I > 0.8 (dashed), and a combined criteria R − I > 0.8 and V − R > 1.5 (dotted). Bottom panel: Gaussian fit to the z-distribution imposing both selection criteria. The mean redshift of the selected SNe is ¯z ∼ 1.1, with a deviation σz ∼ 0.13 for an assumed color uncertainty (intrinsic + measure ment error of 0.2 magnitudes. -- 30 -- Fig. 13. -- (a) The redshift distribution of observable Type Ia SNe (solid line) is compared to the non-Ia contamination (dashed line) for a SN search with limiting magnitude mI < 25 (units are arbitrary). (b) The V-R color at the discovery epoch for the selected non-Ia SNe. The dashed curves includes a 0.3 magnitude uncertainty from either measurement error or intrinsic dispersion. The dotted line shows the adopted color selection V − R > 1.5. (c) R-I at the discovery epoch for the non-Ia simulated SNe. The dotted line shows the selection criteria R − I > 0.8 -- 31 -- Table 1: Rest frame B magnitudes as a function of redshift for five different galaxy types, assuming an observed magnitude mI = 25. The three rightmost columns list the fraction of the SN host galaxies that can be detected at the different redshifts for three limiting magnitudes, mI = 24, mI = 25 and mI = 26. z 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 E -17.5 -18.1 -18.8 -19.3 -19.8 -20.1 -20.5 Sa -17.5 -18.0 -18.6 -19.2 -19.7 -20.1 -20.4 Sbc -17.5 -17.9 -18.4 -18.8 -19.3 -19.7 -20.1 Scd -17.5 -17.9 -18.3 -18.7 -19.1 -19.5 -19.8 Im f (mI = 24) -17.5 -17.8 -18.1 -18.5 -18.9 -19.2 -19.4 0.80 0.73 0.63 0.51 0.40 0.30 0.22 f (mI = 25) f (mI = 26) 0.91 0.87 0.82 0.75 0.67 0.58 0.50 0.96 0.94 0.92 0.88 0.84 0.79 0.74 -- 32 -- Table 2: Apparent magnitudes in different filters for galaxies at different redshifts, when the observed magnitude is mI = 25. Elliptical Sbc galaxy Irr galaxy z mB mV mR mB mV mR mB mV mR 25.8 0.8 25.8 0.9 1.0 25.8 25.7 1.1 25.6 1.2 1.3 25.5 25.4 1.4 26.3 26.2 26.2 26.0 25.9 25.8 25.7 27.1 27.1 27.1 26.9 26.8 26.6 26.5 26.6 26.5 26.4 26.3 26.1 26.0 26.0 26.2 26.3 26.3 26.3 26.2 26.1 26.0 29.9 29.8 29.6 29.4 29.2 29.2 29.1 27.7 27.8 27.9 28.1 28.2 28.4 28.3 26.6 26.5 26.4 26.4 26.5 26.8 26.9 27.9 27.8 27.7 27.5 27.3 27.2 27.0 -- 33 -- -- 34 -- Table 3: Limiting magnitudes in B, V and R that are required in order to detect 70, 80, 90 and 95% of the galaxies with mI <∼ 25. f70 f80 f90 f95 z mB mV mR mB mV mR mB mV mR mB mV mR 25.6 0.8 25.8 0.9 1.0 25.9 26.0 1.1 26.1 1.2 1.3 26.3 26.6 1.4 26.7 27.0 27.2 27.3 27.2 27.0 26.7 25.2 25.5 25.6 25.7 25.8 26.0 26.2 28.1 28.5 28.6 28.7 28.7 28.8 28.7 26.4 26.8 27.1 27.4 27.7 27.9 27.9 27.5 27.9 28.1 28.2 28.2 28.2 28.1 26.1 26.3 26.4 26.3 26.2 26.0 25.9 25.0 25.4 25.7 25.8 25.8 25.7 25.6 24.3 24.6 24.9 25.1 25.2 25.3 25.3 25.5 25.8 26.1 26.3 26.4 26.3 26.1 24.7 25.0 25.2 25.4 25.5 25.6 25.5 26.0 26.3 26.6 27.0 27.2 27.4 27.3
0805.0977	1	0805	2008-05-07T13:02:19	The CoRoT Evolution and Seismic Tools Activity: Goals and Tasks	[ "astro-ph" ]	The forthcoming data expected from space missions such as CoRoT require the capacity of the available tools to provide accurate models whose numerical precision is well above the expected observational errors. In order to secure that these tools meet the specifications, a team has been established to test and, when necessary, to improve the codes available in the community. The CoRoT evolution and seismic tool activity (ESTA) has been set up with this mission. Several groups have been involved. The present paper describes the motivation and the organisation of this activity, providing the context and the basis for the presentation of the results that have been achieved so far. This is not a finished task as future even better data will continue to demand more precise and complete tools for asteroseismology.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astrophysics and Space Science (CoRoT/ESTA Volume) manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Y. Lebreton · M. J. P. F. G. Monteiro · J. Montalb´an · A. Moya · A. Baglin · J. Christensen-Dalsgaard · M.-J. Goupil · E. Michel · J. Provost · I.W. Roxburgh · R. Scuflaire and the ESTA Team The CoRoT Evolution and Seismic Tools Activity Goals and Tasks Received: date / Accepted: date Abstract The forthcoming data expected from space mis- sions such as CoRoT require the capacity of the available tools to provide accurate models whose numerical precision is well above the expected observational errors. In order to secure that these tools meet the specifications, a team has been established to test and, when necessary, to improve the codes available in the community. The CoRoT evolution and seismic tool activity (ESTA) has been set up with this mis- sion. Several groups have been involved. The present paper describes the motivation and the organisation of this activity, providing the context and the basis for the presentation of the results that have been achieved so far. This is not a finished task as future even better data will continue to demand more precise and complete tools for asteroseismology. Keywords stars: interiors · stars: evolution · stars: oscillations · methods: numerical PACS 97.10.Cv · 97.10.Sj · 95.75.Pq Y. Lebreton Observatoire de Paris, GEPI, CNRS UMR 8111, 5 Place Janssen, 92195 Meudon, France E-mail: [email protected] M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro Centro de Astrof´ısica da Universidade do Porto and Departamento de Matem´atica Aplicada da Faculdade de Ciencias, Universidade do Porto, Portugal J. Montalb´an · R. Scuflaire Institut d'Astrophysique et Geophysique, Universit´e de Li`ege, Li`ege, Belgium A. Moya Instituto de Astrof´ısica de Andaluc´ıa- CSIC, Granada, Spain A. Baglin · M.-J. Goupil · E. Michel · I.W. Roxburgh Observatoire de Paris, LESIA, France J. Christensen-Dalsgaard Institut for Fysik og Astronomi, Aarhus Universitet, Aarhus, Denmark J. Provost Cassiop´ee, URA CNRS 1362, Observatoire de la Cote d'Azur, Nice, France I.W. Roxburgh Queen Mary University of London, England 1 Introduction The CoRoT satellite was launched into space on December 27, 2006. This experiment will provide us with stellar oscil- lation data (frequencies, amplitudes, line widths) for stars of various masses and chemical compositions -- mainly main sequence solar type stars, d Scuti stars and b Cephei stars -- with an expected accuracy on the frequencies of a few 10−7 Hz (Baglin et al., 2002; Michel et al., 2006). Such an accuracy is needed to determine some of the key features of the stellar interiors such as the ex- tent of the convective core of intermediate mass stars (Roxburgh and Vorontsov, 1999; Mazumdar et al., 2006; Cunha and Metcalfe, 2007) or the position of the external convection zone (Audard and Provost, 1994; Monteiro, Christensen-Dalsgaard and Thompson, 2000; Ballot, Turck-Chi`eze, and Garc´ıa, 2004; Verner, Chaplin and Elsworth, 2006) and the envelope helium abundance in low mass so- lar type stars (Monteiro and Thompson, 1998; Basu et al., 2004; Verner, Chaplin and Elsworth, 2006). High-quality seismic data also make possible inverse analyses to in- fer the stellar density (Gough and Kosovichev, 1993) and rotation profiles from separated multiplets (Goupil et al., 1996). More generally, it is expected that CoRoT will pro- vide constraints on those aspects of the physics of stel- lar interiors which are still poorly understood, in par- ticular on convection (Samadi et al., 2005) and on trans- port mechanisms at work in the radiative zones such as microscopic diffusion and rotationally induced transport (Goupil et al., 2004; Th´eado et al., 2005). As a result stel- lar models will be improved by seismological inferences, and if they are combined with high-quality observational data of the global stellar parameters (luminosity, effec- tive temperature, radius, abundances), it will allow to im- prove the determination of those stellar parameters not di- rectly accessible through observation like ages and masses of single stars with valuable returns on the understand- ing of galactic structure and evolution (Lebreton, 2005; Monteiro, Christensen-Dalsgaard and Thompson, 2002). However, studies in helioseismology have taught us that in order to probe fine details of the solar internal struc- 2 Y. Lebreton et al. ture, we need both the constraints of high-quality seis- mic data and extremely accurate numerical solar models (Reiter, Walsh and Weiss, 1995; Gough et al., 1996; Monteiro, Christensen-Dalsgaard and Thompson, 2002). Therefore, to be able to draw valuable information from the future CoRoT data, we have to ensure that we will be able to interpret them with models having reached the optimal level of accuracy. In the 1990's the GONG solar model comparison project has been one of the first attempts to compare thoroughly so- lar structure models calculated with stellar evolution codes differing both in the numerical procedures and input physics. Extensive comparisons were made which allowed to better understand differences between models and to correct or im- prove the codes under comparison (Christensen-Dalsgaard, 1988; Gabriel, 1991; Turck-Chi`eze et al., 1998). In the same spirit, within the CoRoT Seismology Working Group, the ESTA group has been set up (see Sect. 3), with the aim to extensively test, compare and optimise the numerical tools used to calculate stellar models and their oscillation frequencies. The goals of the ESTA group have been (i) to be able to produce theoretical seismic predictions by means of different numerical codes and to understand the possible differences between them and (ii) to bring stellar models at the level of accuracy required to interpret the future CoRoT seismic data. In this introductory paper, we outline the tools and spec- ifications of the comparisons that will be presented in detail in the different papers in this volume. Sect. 2 provides a brief overview of the characteristics of the CoRoT seismology tar- gets to be modeled. Sect. 3 presents the ESTA group (par- ticipants, tools, past meetings and publications) and briefly introduces the numerical tools (stellar evolution codes and seismic codes) used in the successive steps of the compar- ison work. In Sect. 4, we present the three ESTA tasks we have focused on. In Sect. 5 we give the specifications of the tasks concerning the input physics and parameters of the stellar models. Finally in Sect. 6 we present reference grids of stellar models and associated oscillation frequencies cal- culated by ESTA participants in parallel to the main ESTA work. These grids have been used all along the preparation of the CoRoT mission and have been made available on the ESTA web site. 2 The observational seismic program of CoRoT The CoRoT mission has been designed and built to satisfy the scientific specifications as expressed in the document COR- SP-0-ETAN-83-PROJ, written in 2001. At that time more recent developments of the seismology theory as well as dis- coveries of pulsations were evidently not taken into account. More precisely CoRoT has been required to reach: • a photometric noise of 0.6 ppm in five days in the 0.1 to 10 mHz frequency domain, • a duty cycle of 90%, • a percentage of polluted frequencies less than 5% of the Fig. 1 H -- R diagram of the targets of the 5 first long runs of the CoRoT mission, as planned presently. Long Runs are numbered as LRx0Y where x is a or c depending on whether it is a direct run in the center or anticenter direction and Y is the order ot the run in the given direction. Standard evolutionary tracks, labelled with their mass (in solar units) and corresponding to solar metallicity, no overshooting, are also shown (see Lebreton and Michel, 2008a). The major goals of the seismology programme were then to detect solar type oscillations in a few bright objects, cov- ering the H -- R diagram and to see whether classical pulsators (d Scuti and b Cephei stars in particular) near the main se- quence had also lower amplitude modes. With these goals in mind the seismology program has been defined with two components: ⋆ the central program having at least 5 sessions of 150 days (see Fig. 1), ⋆ the exploratory program with a few short sessions of 20 days, to complement the H -- R diagram coverage. The instrument has two different fields: • the seismology field in which 10 bright stars are ob- served at the same time (5.5<mV <9.5) with a sampling of 32 seconds, • the exoplanet field which observes 12 000 stars at the same time (11<mV <16) with a sampling of 512 seconds and in a few cases 32 seconds. In this field the required photometric accuracy is 7×10−4 in 1 hour for a 15.5 magnitude star. After one year of operations the mission fulfils all its frequency interval. specifications. Goals and Tasks of ESTA-CoRoT 3 ESTA organisation and tools The Evolution and Seismic Tools Activity (ESTA) has been set up in 2002, following the ESA announcement of opportu- nity for participation in the CoRoT mission. The actual work has started in 2004 at the kick-off meeting that took place during the CoRoT Week 7 in Granada (December 2004). Following this several other meetings and workshops (7 so far) have been organised as the activities progressed. A web- site has been created to coordinate the activities, allowing for an efficient exchange of data and documentation as well as to share the results of the tasks that have been organised around the key objectives of ESTA. This site is available at the following url: http : //www.astro.up.pt/corot/ ESTA has been open to participation of the whole com- munity and in particular the involvement of groups with evo- lution codes or seismic codes has been actively pursued. Up to now there are over 40 team members involved in one or several of the tasks corresponding to more than 16 in- stitutes/groups spread over 9 countries. It includes the par- ticipation of 10 evolution codes and 9 oscillation codes in the tasks and comparisons that have been developed over the last three years. As part of the effort several results have been published (as papers or proceedings of the workshops) or made available through the web-page. 3.1 Stellar internal structure and evolution codes Ten stellar evolution codes have participated in ESTA at dif- ferent levels. The list is given below. Each of them is pre- sented in detail in a specific paper in this volume. 3 • GARSTEC -- The Garching Stellar Evolution Code is a German stellar evolution code that has participated in ESTA TASKS 1 and 3. It is presented by Weiss and Schlattl (2008). • GENEC -- The Geneva Stellar Evolution Code is a Swiss stellar evolution code that has participated in ESTA TASK 1. It is presented by Eggenberger et al. (2008). • STAROX -- This is an English stellar evolution code that has participated in ESTA TASK 1. It is presented by Roxburgh (2008b). • TGEC -- The Toulouse-Geneva Evolution Code is a French stellar evolution code that has participated in ESTA TASKS 1 and 3. It is presented by Hui-Bon-Hoa (2008). • YREC -- The Yale Rotating Stellar Evolution Code is a US stellar evolution code. Up to now it has participated only marginally in ESTA activities. It is presented by Demarque et al. (2008). 3.2 Stellar oscillation codes Nine stellar oscillation codes have been used for the compar- isons of ESTA TASK 2. The list is given below. Each of them is presented in details in a specific paper in this volume. • ADIPLS -- The Aarhus Adiabatic Pulsation Package2 contains the ADIPLS stellar oscillation code itself but also many programs to manipulate the stellar model files and the output of the pulsation program (cf. Sect. 5). It is presented by Christensen-Dalsgaard (2008a). • FILOU -- This stellar oscillations code developed at Paris- Meudon Observatory is presented by Suarez and Goupil (2008). • GRACO -- The Granada Oscillation Code is presented by • ASTEC -- The Aarhus Stellar Evolution Code is a Danish stellar evolution code that has been involved in all the ESTA TASKS. It is presented by Christensen-Dalsgaard (2008b). • ATON -- This is an Italian stellar evolution code. Up to now it has participated only marginally in ESTA activi- ties. It is presented by Ventura et al. (2008). • CESAM -- The Code d' ´Evolution Stellaire Adaptatif et Modulaire is a French stellar evolution code. This public code1 has been involved in all the ESTA TASKS as well as in the reference grids calculation. It is presented by Morel and Lebreton (2008). • CL ´ES -- The Code Li´egeois d' ´Evolution Stellaire is a Bel- gian stellar evolution code that has been involved in all the ESTA TASKS as well as in the reference grids calcu- lation. It is presented by Scuflaire et al. (2008b). • FRANEC -- The Frascati Raphson Newton Evolutionary Code is an Italian stellar evolution code that has par- ticipated in ESTA TASKS 1 and 3. It is presented by Degl'Innocenti (2008). Moya and Garrido (2008). Scuflaire et al. (2008a). • LOSC -- The Li`ege Oscillations Code is presented by • NOSC -- The Nice Oscillations Code is presented by Provost (2008). • OSCROX -- This English stellar oscillations code is pre- sented by Roxburgh (2008a). • POSC -- The Porto Oscillations Code is presented by Monteiro (2008). • PULSE -- This Canadian stellar oscillations code is pre- sented by Brassard and Charpinet (2008). • LNAWENR -- This Romanian code for Linear Non- Adiabatic NonRadial Waves is presented by Suran (2008). 4 Presentation of the TASKs To perform the comparison of the participating numerical codes, the ESTA group has focused on specific TASKS. The 1 available at http://www.obs-nice.fr/cesam 2 available at http://astro.phys.au.dk/∼jcd/adipack.n 4 Y. Lebreton et al. first task, TASK 1, has consisted in comparing stellar mod- els and evolution sequences produced by eight stellar in- ternal structure and evolution codes. For that purpose we have fixed some standard input physics and initial param- eters for the stellar models to be calculated and we have defined several specific study cases corresponding to stars covering the range of masses, evolution stages and chemi- cal compositions expected for the bulk of CoRoT target stars. The second task, TASK 2, has consisted in testing, compar- ing and optimising the seismic codes by means of the com- parison of the frequencies produced by nine different oscil- lation codes, again for specific stellar cases. Finally, the third task, TASK 3, still in progress, is similar to TASK 1 but for stellar models including microscopic diffusion of chemical elements. 4.1 TASK 1: basic stellar models TASK 1 has been defined with the aim of comparing the properties of stellar models and evolutionary sequences cov- ering a rather large range of stellar parameters (initial mass, initial chemical composition and evolution stage) corre- sponding to the bulk of the CoRoT targets. Seven study cases have been considered, the specifica- tions of which are given in Table 1. The cases are defined as follows. Seven evolutionary sequences have been cal- culated for different values of the stellar mass and initial chemical composition (X,Y, Z where X, Y and Z are re- spectively the initial hydrogen, helium and metallicity in mass fraction). The masses are in the range 0.9−5.0M⊙. For the initial chemical composition, several pairs (Y, Z) have been considered by combining two different val- ues of Z (0.01 and 0.02) and two values of Y (0.26 and 0.28). The corresponding values of (Z/X) are in the range 0.014−0.029. We have adopted the so-called GN93 solar mixture (see Grevesse and Noels, 1993) which has (Z/X)⊙ = 0.0245. We have therefore metallicities such that [Fe/H] ∈ [−0.25, +0.17] dex (with the standard definition [Fe/H] = log (Z/X) − log (Z/X)⊙). Table 1 Target models for TASK 1 (see Fig. 2). We have considered 7 cases corresponding to different initial masses, chemical compositions and evolutionary stages. One evolutionary sequence (denoted by "Ov" in the 5th column has been calculated with core overshooting -- see text). Case M/M⊙ 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 0.9 1.2 1.2 2.0 2.0 3.0 5.0 Y0 0.28 0.28 0.26 0.28 0.26 0.28 0.28 Z0 Specification Xc=0.35 Xc=0.69 0.02 0.02 0.01 MHe 0.02 0.02 0.01 0.02 c =0.10 M⊙ Tc=1.9×107 K Xc=0.01,Ov Xc=0.69 Xc=0.35 Type MS ZAMS SGB PMS TAMS ZAMS MS Fig. 2 H -- R diagram showing the targets for TASK 1 (see Table 1). Red lines correspond to the PMS, black lines to the MS and blue lines to the post-main sequence SGB evolution. The targets are ordered in mass and age along the diagram, from Case 1.1 (bottom-right) up to Case 1.7 (top-left) On each evolutionary sequence, an evolutionary stage has been selected, either on the pre-main sequence (PMS), main sequence (MS) or subgiant branch (SGB). On the PMS we have specified the value of the central temperature of the model (Tc = 1.9 ×107 K). On the MS, we have fixed the value of the central hydrogen content: Xc = 0.69 for the model close to the zero age main sequence (ZAMS), Xc = 0.35 for the model in the middle of the MS and Xc = 0.01 for the model close to the terminal age main sequence (TAMS). On the SGB, a model can be chosen by specifying the value of the mass MHe of the central region of the star where c the hydrogen abundance is such that X ≤ 0.01. We chose MHe c = 0.10 M⊙. Figure 2 displays the location in the H -- R diagram of the targets for TASK 1 together with their parent evolutionary track. All models calculated for TASK 1 are based on rather simple input physics, currently implemented in stellar evo- lution codes and one model has been calculated with over- shooting (see Sect. 5 below). The first results of TASK 1 have been presented by Monteiro et al. (2006). Detailed results are presented in this volume (?Lebreton et al., 2008b; Montalb´an et al., 2008b; Marconi et al., 2008). Goals and Tasks of ESTA-CoRoT 4.2 TASK 2: oscillation frequencies Under TASK 2 we have aimed at evaluating the precision and uncertainties affecting the determination of oscillation frequencies. In particular we have studied the numerical pre- cision of the frequencies using different meshes and with a wide range of options to solve the equations for linear adi- abatic (radial and non-radial) oscillations. In particular two steps have been considered in this TASK: Step 1 -- comparison of the frequencies from different codes for the same stellar model; Step 2 -- comparison of the frequencies from the same seismic code for different stellar models of the same stel- lar case. In this exercise stellar models at the middle of the main se- quence, produced by ASTEC and CESAM, have been used with a mass of 1.5 M⊙. The models have been provided with different number of mesh points. Preliminary results of this task were reported by Moya (2007) while the final results of Step 1 are discussed in this volume by Moya et al. (2008). Step 2 remains to be done. 4.3 TASK 3: stellar models including microscopic diffusion The goals of TASK 3 are to test, compare and optimise stellar evolution codes which include microscopic diffusion of chemical elements. At this stage we only consider dif- fusion resulting from pressure, temperature and concentra- tion gradients (see Thoul and Montalb´an, 2007) while we do not take into account diffusion due to the radiative forces, nor the extra-mixing of chemical elements due to differen- tial rotation or internal gravity waves (see Alecian, 2007; Mathis et al., 2007; Zahn, 2007). The other physical as- sumptions proposed as the reference for the comparisons are the same as used for TASK 1 and no overshooting (see Sect. 5). Three study cases have been considered for the mod- els to be compared. Each case corresponds to a given value of the stellar mass (see Table 2). We chose rather low val- ues of the masses (i.e. M < 1.4 M⊙) in order to keep in a mass range where radiative accelerations can be omitted. Furthermore, this avoids the problems occurring at higher masses where the use of microscopic diffusion alone pro- duces a very substantial depletion of helium and heavy ele- ments at the surface (and a concomitant increase of the hy- drogen content) and in turn requires to invoke other mixing processes to control the gravitational settling (see, for in- stance Turcotte et al., 1998). For the three cases we have adopted a chemical compo- sition close to the solar one (Z/X = 0.0243). For each case, models at different evolutionary stages have been consid- ered. We focused on three particular evolution stages: mid- dle of the MS, TAMS and SGB (respectively stage A, B and C). Figure 3 displays the location in the H -- R diagram of the targets for TASK 3 together with their parent evolutionary track. 5 Table 2 Target models for TASK 3. Left: Three cases with corre- sponding masses and initial chemical composition. Right: Three evolu- tionary stages examined for each case. Stages A and B are respectively in the middle and end of the MS stage. Stage C is on the SGB. Case M/M⊙ 3.1 3.2 3.3 1.0 1.2 1.3 Y0 0.27 0.27 0.27 Z0 0.017 0.017 0.017 Stage A B C Xc 0.35 0.01 0.00 MHe c - - 0.05 M⋆ Fig. 3 H -- R diagram showing the targets for TASK 3 (see Table 2). Evolutionary tracks correspond to Case 3.1 (bottom-right), Case 3.2 (middle) and Case 3.3 (top-left). On each track filled circles indicate the stages A, B, C. Preliminary results of TASK 3 have been presented by Lebreton et al. (2007); Montalb´an, Th´eado and Lebreton (2007); Christensen-Dalsgaard (2008c). Advanced compar- isons are presented in this volume (Lebreton et al., 2008b). 5 Specifications for the TASKS In order to reduce the sources of discrepancies in the com- parison due to sources not relevant in this context it has been necessary to specify the initial parameters and the physics to be used in the models. Special care has also been given to the exchange of data in order to facilitate the exchange of models and evolutionary tracks and their use in detailed comparisons. Here we briefly describe the common specifications used for all TASKS. Further details can be found in the documen- tation available at the ESTA web-site3. 3 at http://www.astro.up.pt/corot/compmod/task1 6 5.1 Initial parameters A list of reference values of some astronomical and physi- cal constants have been specified to safeguard consistency in the comparison of the output from different codes. We have also fixed the mixture of heavy elements to be used in the calculations. a) Physical constants: We have specified the values of the physical constants necessary for the calculation of a stel- lar model according to Cohen and Taylor (1987) and Lide (1994) (see Table 3). Furthermore a reference set of values is provided for the mass of neutron and atomic mass of the elements from 1H to 17O. b) Astronomical constants: We have chosen the values to consider for the global parameters of the present Sun. We have adopted R⊙ = 6.9599 × 1010 cm, for the solar radius (Allen, 1973), L⊙ = 3.846 × 1033 erg s−1, for the solar luminosity (Willson et al., 1986) and M⊙ = 1.98919 × 1033 g, for the solar mass. Here M⊙ is obtained from (GM⊙) = 1.32712438 × 1026 cm−3s−2 (Lide, 1994) and G = 6.6716823 × 10−8cm−3g−1s−2. The value R⊙ refers to the radius of the model layer where T = Teff = 5777.54 K. c) Initial abundances of the elements and heavy elements mixture: All models are calculated with the classical GN93 solar mixture of heavy elements (Grevesse and Noels, 1993). As shown in Tables 1 and 2 the mass fractions of hydrogen (X), helium (Y ) and heavy elements (Z) are specified for each model. 5.2 Input physics In order to be able to make basic comparisons between the codes, we chose some reference input physics that have the advantage to be currently implemented in stellar evolution codes. a) Equation of State: We chose to use the OPAL equation of state (EOS) in its 2001 version (Rogers and Nayfonov, 2002) available at the OPAL Web site4. It consists in a series of tables and in an associated interpolation pack- age. The tables provide a set of thermodynamic quanti- ties, i.e. pressure, internal energy, entropy, specific heat Cv, c r = (d lnP/d lnr )T , c T = (d lnP/d ln T )r and the adiabatic indices G 1, G 2/(G 2−1) and (G 3−1), at given val- ues of the temperature, density, X and Z. However, there 4 http://www-phys.llnl.gov/Research/OPAL Y. Lebreton et al. are differences in the handling of the tables by the differ- ent codes. Some use the interpolation package provided by the OPAL group, others have developed their own interpolation package. In addition, it has been pointed out by Boothroyd and Sackmann (2003) that there are some inconsistencies in the OPAL tables with the re- sult that the tabulated values of the adiabatic indexes G 1, G 2/(G 2−1) and (G 3−1) may differ by several per cent from the values that can be recalculated from the tabu- lated values of P, Cv, c r and c T by means of thermody- namic relations. Furthermore, in the course of the com- parisons undertaken by the ESTA group it has been shown by one of us (I.W. Roxburgh) that the tabulated values of the specific heat Cv in OPAL tables are incorrect, and also acknowledged by the OPAL team that this param- eter should better be obtained from the other quantities provided by OPAL. For these reasons, some codes only draw P, c r , c T and G 1 from the OPAL EOS tables and apply thermodynamic relations to derive the other ther- modynamic quantities. b) Opacities: We chose to use the 1995 OPAL opacity ta- bles (Iglesias and Rogers, 1996) complemented at low temperatures by the Alexander and Ferguson (1994) ta- bles, and not to include the conductive opacity. However slightly different OPAL tables are actually used by the different codes. Pre-calculated OPAL tables have been made available by the OPAL group either prior to pub- lication or later on the OPAL Web site. They have been obtained for a "reduced" GN93 solar mixture, i.e. while the GN93 mixture is given for 23 elements, the OPAL opacity calculation only considers 19 elements but adds the abundances of "lacking" elements to the abundances of nearby elements (having close atomic number). Also, on the OPAL Web site there is the option to calculate tables on-line for any desired 19 elements-mixture and to pass or not a smoothing filter to reduce the random numerical errors that affect the OPAL opacity computa- tion. Different groups used either one of these possibili- ties. Moreover, some codes use the interpolation routines provided by the OPAL group, others designed their own routines. c) Nuclear reaction rates: No specifications have been given for the choice of the nuclear network. The basic pp chain and CNO cycle reaction networks up to the 17O (p,a )14N reaction have generally been used. Some models have been calculated with the option/assumption that either one or all the light elements (3He, 7Li, 7Be, 2H) are at equilibrium while other models have followed them explicitly. We chose to compute the nuclear re- action rates from the analytical formulae provided by the NACRE compilation (Angulo et al., 1999). Different prescriptions have been used for the screening. Most of- ten, weak screening has been assumed under the Salpeter (1954) formulation. In that case the screening factor is written f = exp Az1z2rrx T 3! , Goals and Tasks of ESTA-CoRoT 7 Table 3 Some of the physical constants necessary for the calculation of a stellar model. The units are cgs, except where otherwise noted. Boltzmann's constant Atomic mass unit Perfect gas constant Electron mass Electron charge Planck's constant Speed of light Radiation density constant Stefan-Boltzmann constant Electron -- Volt Atomic weight of hydrogen Atomic weight of helium Ionisation potential for H 1st ionisation potential for He 2nd ionisation potential for He k = 1.380658 × 10−16 mu = 1.6605402 × 10−24 R = 8.3145111 × 107 me = 9.1093897 × 10−28 e = 1.602177333 × 10−19 C h = 6.6260755 × 10−27 c = 2.99792458 × 1010 a = 7.5659122 × 10−15 s = 5.67051 × 10−5 1.60217733 × 10−11 1 eV = AH = 1.00782500 AHe = 4.00260330 c H = 13.595 eV c He = 24.580 eV c He+ = 54.403 eV where z1 and z2 are the charges of the interacting nuclei. Some codes have used the expression (4-221) of Clayton (1968) giving A = 1.88 × 108 and x = (cid:229) i zi(1+zi)xi where xi is the abundance per mole of element i. Finally, in the nuclear reaction network the initial abundance of each chemical species is split between its isotopes ac- cording to the isotopic ratio of nuclides for which values have been given (see the ESTA Web site5). ad−(cid:209) ad and (cid:209) rad<0) where (cid:209) d) Convection and overshooting: We chose to use the clas- sical mixing length treatment of Bohm-Vitense (1958) under the formulation of Henyey, Vardya, and Bodenheimer (1965) taking into account the optical thickness of the convective bubble. The value of the mixing length pa- rameter has been chosen to be a MLT = 1.6. The onset of convection is determined according to the Schwarzschild criterion ((cid:209) rad are respec- tively the adiabatic and radiative temperature gradient. In models with overshooting, the convective core is ex- tended on a distance lov = a ov × min(Hp, Rcc) where Hp is the pressure scale height and Rcc the radius of the con- vective core. We have chosen the value of the overshoot- ing parameter to be a ov = 0.15. The core is mixed in the region corresponding to the convective and overshooting region. In the overshooting region the temperature gra- dient is taken to be equal to the adiabatic gradient. Note that some codes have provided models including over- shooting but following different parametrizations (e.g. STAROX takes the temperature gradient to be equal to the radiative gradient in the overshooting region while FRANEC uses a formulation of overshooting depending on the mass). 5 at http://www.astro.up.pt/corot/compmod/task1 e) Atmosphere: Eddington's grey T (t ) law has been pre- scribed for the atmosphere calculation: T = Teff(cid:20) 3 4(cid:18)t + 2 3(cid:19)(cid:21) 1 4 , where t is the optical depth. The radius of the star is taken to be the bolometric radius, i.e. the radius at the level where the local temperature equals the effective temperature (t = 2/3 for the Eddington's law). Codes manage differently the integration of the hydrostatic equation in the atmosphere from a specified upper value of the optical depth t to the connexion with the envelope. f) Microscopic diffusion: We only considered the diffu- sion of helium and heavy elements due to pressure, temperature and concentration gradients and we ne- glected radiative accelerations that are not yet fully in- cluded and tested in the participating codes. We did not impose the formalism to be used. As reviewed by Thoul and Montalb´an (2007), two approaches to ob- tain the diffusion equation from the Boltzmann equa- tion for binary or multiple gas mixtures can be fol- lowed: one is based on the Chapman-Enskog the- ory (Chapman and Cowling, 1970, hereafter CC70) and the other on the resolution of the Burgers equations (Burgers, 1969, hereafter B69). In both methods, ap- proximations have to be made to derive the various co- efficients entering the diffusion equations, in particu- lar the diffusion velocities which are written as a func- tion of the collision integrals. In the stellar evolution codes which have participated in TASK 3, different treat- ments of the diffusion processes have been adopted. The TGEC code follows the CC70 approach. The other codes follow the B69 approach but differently: (i) the ASTEC and FRANEC codes use the simplified formalism of Michaud and Proffitt (1993, hereafter MP93), (ii) the 8 Y. Lebreton et al. CL ´ES and GARSTEC codes compute the diffusion coef- ficients by solving Burgers' equations according to the formalism of Thoul, Bahcall and Loeb (1994) and (iii) CESAM provides two options to compute diffusion veloc- ities, one based on the MP69 approximation, the other on Burger's formalism, with collision integrals derived from Paquette et al. (1986). Furthermore, the number of chemical elements considered in the diffusion process differs in the different codes and some codes consider that all the elements are completely ionised while others calculate the ionisation explicitly. 5.3 Output format Each code had previously designed its own output format. But to facilitate the comparisons we have adapted some of the output in order to include all information required for detailed code-to-code comparisons of models. In most ex- ercises we have adopted the file format prescribed by the GONG solar model team which is described in the documen- tation files in the ADIPLS package and on the ESTA Web site6. This permits a rather easy treatment of the models which can be read, plotted and compared by means of the programme tools available in the ADIPLS package. In addition, a tool MODCONV and associated documentation have been made available on the ESTA Web-site by M. Monteiro to allow the direct conversion between the different formats available. In all cases ESTA participants have been asked to pro- vide ASCII files ready for comparisons which contain, for the TASK case considered, the global properties of the model (name, mass, age, initial composition, luminosity, photo- spheric radius, etc.) as well as a wide range of model vari- ables at each mesh point (distance r to the centre, mass in- side the sphere of radius r, pressure, density, temperature, chemical composition, opacity and several other physical parameters including quantities of interest for the compu- tation of adiabatic oscillations like the Brunt-Vaisala fre- quency). Modelers have also provided ASCII files giving the vari- ation with time of some global or internal properties of their evolution sequences (luminosity, effective temperature, ra- dius, central hydrogen content, surface helium and heavy- element abundances, radius and mass of the convective core and depth and mass of the convection envelope, etc). 5.4 Oscillations Stellar oscillations modelers involved in TASK 2 were asked to provide adiabatic frequencies in the range [20, 2500] m Hz and with spherical degrees ℓ=0,1,2 and 3. To obtain the so- lution of the equations, the modelers were asked to adopt the following specifications: a) Mesh: Use the mesh provided by the equilibrium model (no re-meshing). b) Outer mechanical boundary condition: Set the La- grangian perturbation to the pressure to zero (d P = 0). c) Physical constants: Use the same as in TASK 1 and 3. d) Equations: Use linear adiabatic equations. However, different methods and assumptions are made to write and to solve numerically the differential equations in the participating oscillation codes. In particular: a) Set of eigenfunctions: Either the Lagrangian or the Eu- lerian perturbation to the pressure (d P or P′) have been used which affects the form of the equations. b) Order of the integration scheme: Either a second-order or a fourth-order scheme has been used. c) Richardson extrapolation: Some codes using a second- order scheme have the possibility to use Richardson extrapolation (Shibahashi and Osaki, 1981) to decrease the truncation error. The combination of a 2nd order scheme with Richardson extrapolation leads to errors which scale as N −4, where N is the number of mesh points (e.g. Christensen-Dalsgaard and Mullan, 1994). d) Integration variable: Either the radius r or the ratio r/P have been used as integration variables. e) Physical constants: Some codes use a value of the grav- itational constant G slightly different than the one spec- ified in the other TASKS. As pointed out by Moya et al. (2008), using different values of G in the stellar struc- ture equations and in the oscillation equations gives rise to inconsistencies. The consequences of these choices are discussed in de- tails in Moya et al. (2008). 6 Reference grids In parallel to the three TASKS, grids of models have been especially calculated with the CESAM and CL ´ES codes for masses in the range 0.8−10 M⊙ and chemical compositions [Fe/H]=0.0 and −0.10. These reference grids have been used to locate CoRoT potential targets in the H -- R diagram in the process of target selection (see Figure 1) and to study some d Scuti candidates for CoRoT (Poretti et al., 2005). In addition, associated oscillation frequencies have been calcu- lated for selected models in the grid either with the ADIPLS, POSC or LOSC codes. This material is described in this volume by Montalb´an et al. (2008a); Lebreton and Michel (2008a); Marques, Monteiro, and Fernandes (2008). In addition, a database of models of b Cephei stars and their oscillation frequencies called BetaDat has been de- signed in the context of ESTA (Thoul, 2008), although the models do not use exactly the same input physics and con- stants. It is accessible through a Web interface7. 6 at http://www.astro.up.pt/corot/ntools/ 7 http://astrotheor3.astro.ulg.ac.be/ Goals and Tasks of ESTA-CoRoT 7 Conclusion In this paper we briefly presented the different activities un- dertaken by the evolution and seismic tools activity (ESTA, see Monteiro et al., 2006) organised under the responsibil- ities of the Seismology Working Group (see Michel et al., 2006) of the CoRoT mission. A description of the ESTA team and TASKS aimed at improving stellar evolution codes and oscillation codes is presented. This provides the context and the reference for the more detailed works published in this volume with the descriptions of the codes and the results of the comparisons. The seismic study of the Sun (helioseismology) had al- ready pushed the need to calculate solar models to a new level of accuracy due to the necessity to calculate theoretical oscillation frequencies that could match the observed solar values. As we now approach the same level of precision for other stars in asteroseismology the codes used to model the evolution of stars of different masses have now to reach the same high precision for stellar regimes very different from the Sun. As the physics dominating different regimes in the H -- R diagram are different a strong effort towards this is re- quired. In the work developed by ESTA we are pursuing that goal. The results of this exercise so far have shown that we are able to meet the present requirements. But more work is planned to address some pending aspects of the physics that must be included in the models with sufficient precision to be able to reproduce the observed seismic behaviour. This is an open project as the arrival of data from CoRoT and other future projects will required our tools to improve further the precision of the models in order to test the highly accurate data made available for asteroseismology. Acknowledgements This work is being supported in part by the Eu- ropean Helio- and Asteroseismology Network (HELAS), a major in- ternational collaboration funded by the European Commission's Sixth Framework Programme. MJPFGM is supported in part by FCT and FEDER (POCI2010) through projects POCI/CTE-AST/57610/2004 and POCI/V.5/B0094/2005. A.M. acknowledge financial support of the Spanish PNE under Project number ESP 2004-03855-C03-C01. J.M. has received a financial support from the Federal Science Policy Office (BELSPO) in the frame of the ESA/Prodex program, contract C90199 -- CoRoT -- Preparation to exploitation. 9 Angulo, C., Arnould, M., Rayet, M., et al.: A compilation of charged-particle induced thermonuclear reaction rates. Nuclear Physics A 656, 3 (1999) Audard, N., Provost, J.: Seismological properties of intermediate-mass stars. A&A 282, 73 (1994) Bohm-Vitense, E.: Uber die Wasserstoffkonvektionszone in Sternen verschiedener Effektivtemperaturen und Leuchtkrafte. Mit 5 Textabbildungen. Zeitschrift Astro- physics 46, 108 (1958) Baglin, A., Auvergne, M., Barge, P., et al.: COROT: aster- oseismology and planet finding. In: Stellar Structure and Habitable Planet Finding, ESA SP-485, 17 (2002) Ballot, J., Turck-Chi`eze, S., Garc´ıa, R.A.: Seismic extrac- tion of the convective extent in solar-like stars. The obser- vational point of view. A&A 423, 1051 (2004) Basu, S., Mazumdar, A., Antia, H.M., Demarque, P.: Aster- oseismic determination of helium abundance in stellar en- velopes. MNRAS 350, 277 (2004) Boothroyd, A.I., Sackmann, I.J.: Our Sun. IV. The Standard Model and Helioseismology: Consequences of Uncertain- ties in Input Physics and in Observed Solar Parameters. ApJ 583, 1004 (2003) Brassard, P., Charpinet, S.: PULSE: A finite element code for solving adiabatic nonradial pulsation equations. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Burgers, J.M.: Flow Equations for Composite Gases, New York Academic Press (1969) Chapman, S., Cowling, T.G.: The mathematical theory of non-uniform gases: an account of the kinetic theory of vis- cosity, thermal conduction and diffusion in gases. Cam- bridge University Press, 3rd ed. (1970) Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.: Computational procedures for the GONG solar model comparison project, Aarhus Univer- sity (1988) Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Mullan, D.J.: Accurate Frequen- cies of Polytropic Models. MNRAS 270, 921 (1994) Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.: ADIPLS - the Aarhus adiabatic oscillation package. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008a) Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.: ASTEC - the Aarhus STellar Evolution Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008b) Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.: Comparisons for ESTA-TASK3: ASTEC, CESAM and CL ´ES. In: Stellar Evolution and Seismic Tools for Asteroseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publication Series, Vol 26, 167 (2008c) Clayton, D.D.: Principles of stellar evolution and nucleosyn- References Alecian, G.: Atomic diffusion and radiative accelerations in stars. In: Stellar Evolution and Seismic Tools for Aster- oseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publication Series, Vol 26, 37 (2007) Alexander, D.R., Ferguson, J.W.: Low-temperature Rosse- land opacities. ApJ 437, 879 (1994). Allen, C.W.: Astrophysical Quantities. University of Lon- don, Athlone Press, 3rd ed. (1973) thesis. New York McGraw-Hill (1968) Cohen, E.R., Taylor, B.N.: The 1986 adjustment of the fun- damental physical constants. Reviews of Modern Physics 59, 1121 (1987) Cunha, M.S., Metcalfe, T.S.: ApJ 666, 413 (2007) Degl'Innocenti, S., Prada Moroni, P.G., Marconi, M., Ruoppo, A.: The FRANEC stellar evolutionary code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Demarque, P., Guenther, D.B., Li, L.H., Mazumdar, A., Straka, C.W.: YREC: The Yale Rotating Stellar Evolution Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) 10 Y. Lebreton et al. Eggenberger, P., Meynet, G., Maeder, A., et al.: The Geneva Stellar Evolution Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Gabriel, M.: Accuracy Tests for the Computation of So- lar Models. Challenges to Theories of the Structure of Moderate-Mass Stars, LNP Vol. 388, 51 (1991) Gough, D.O., Kosovichev, A.G.: The Influence of Low- Degree P-Mode Frequencies on the Determination of the Structure of the Solar Interior. MNRAS 264, 522 (1993) Gough, D.O., Kosovichev, A.G., Toomre, J., et al.: The Seis- mic Structure of the Sun. Science 272, 1296 (1996) Goupil, M.J., Dziembowski, W.A., Goode, P.R., Michel, E.: Can we measure the rotation rate inside stars ? A&A 3020085, 487 (1996) Goupil, M.J., Samadi, R., Lochard, J., Dziembowski, W.A., Pamyatnykh, A.: Inferring information about rotation from stellar oscillations. In: Stellar Structure and Habit- able Planet Finding, Favata, F., Aigrain, S., Wilson, A. (Eds): ESA SP-538, 133 (2004) Grevesse, N., Noels, A.: Cosmic abundances of the Ele- ments. In: Origin and Evolution of the Elements (1993) Henyey, L., Vardya, M.S., Bodenheimer, P.: Studies in Stel- lar Evolution. III. The Calculation of Model Envelopes. ApJ 142, 841 (1965) Hui-Bon-Hoa, A.: The Toulouse-Geneva Evolution Code (TGEC). Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Iglesias, C.A., Rogers, F.J.: Updated Opal Opacities. ApJ 464, 943 (1996) the Gaia Mission. Lebreton, Y.: Stellar Interiors and Atmospheres in the Framework of In: The Three- Dimensional Universe with Gaia, Turon, C., O'Flaherty, K.S., Perryman, M.A.C. (Eds). ESA SP-576, 493 (2005) Lebreton, Y., Michel, E.: Reference grids of stellar models and oscillation frequencies. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008a) Lebreton, Y., Montalb´an, J., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Rox- burgh, I., Weiss, A.: CoRoT/ESTA -- TASK 1 and TASK 3 comparison of the internal structure and seismic proper- ties of representative stellar models. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008b) Lebreton, Y., Montalb´an, J., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., et al.: Microscopic diffusion in stellar evolution codes: first comparisons results of ESTA TASK 3. In: Stellar Evolu- tion and Seismic Tools for Asteroseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publica- tion Series, Vol 26, 155 (2007) Lide, D.R.: CRC Handbook of chemistry and physics. A ready-reference book of chemical and physical data. Boca Raton CRC Press, 75th ed. (1994) Marconi, M., Degl'Innocenti, S., Prada Moroni P.G., Ruoppo A.: FRANEC versus CESAM predictions for se- lected CoRoT ESTA Task 1 models. Ap&SS -- this vol- ume (2008) Marques, J.P. Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G., Fernandes, J.: A CE- SAM+POSC grid of stellar models from the birh-line to the sub-giant branch. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Mathis, S., Eggenberger, P., Decressin, T., et al.: Advances in secular magnetohydrodynamics of stellar interiors ded- icated to asteroseismic spatial missions. In: Stellar Evolu- tion and Seismic Tools for Asteroseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publica- tion Series, Vol 26, 65 (2007) Mazumdar, A., Basu, S., Collier, B.L., Demarque, P.: Aster- oseismic diagnostics of stellar convective cores. MNRAS 372, 949 (2006). Michaud, G., Proffitt, C.R.: Particle transport processes. In: Weiss, W.W., Baglin, A. (eds.) IAU Colloq. 137: Inside the Stars. Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, vol. 40, pp. 246 -- 259. (January 1993) Michel, E., Baglin, A., Auvergne, M., et al.: The Seismol- ogy programme of CoRoT. In: The CoRoT Mission, M. Fridlund, A. Baglin, J. Lochard, L. Conroy, (Eds): ESA SP-1306, 39 (2006) Montalb´an, J., Lebreton, Y., Miglio A., Scuflaire R., Morel P., Noels, A.: Thorough analysis of input physics in CESAM and CL ´ES. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008b) Montalb´an, J., Miglio A., Noels A., Scuflaire R.: Grids of stellar models and frequencies with CLES + LOSC. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008a) Montalb´an, J., Th´eado, S., Lebreton, Y.: Comparisons for ESTA-TASK 3: CLES and CESAM. In: Stellar Evolu- tion and Seismic Tools for Asteroseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publica- tion Series, Vol 26, 167 (2007) Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G., Thompson, M.J.: On the seismic sig- nature of the HeII ionization zone in stellar envelopes. In: New Eyes to See Inside the Sun and Stars. IAU Symposia 185, 317 (1998) Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Thomp- son, M.J.: Seismic study of stellar convective regions: the base of the convective envelope in low-mass stars. MN- RAS 316, 165 (2000) Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Thomp- son, M.J.: Asteroseismic inference for solar-type stars. In: Stellar Structure and Habitable Planet Finding, Battrick, B., Favata, F., Roxburgh, I.W., Galadi, D. (eds.): ESA SP- 485, 291 (2002) Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G., Lebreton, Y., Montalb´an, J., et al.: Re- port on the CoRoT Evolution and Seismic Tools Activ- ity. In: The CoRoT Mission, M. Fridlund, A. Baglin, J. Lochard & L. Conroy (Eds): ESA SP-1306, 363 (2006) Monteiro, M.J.P.F.G.: POSC -- The Porto Oscillations Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Morel, P., Lebreton, Y.: CESAM: Code d'Evolution Stellaire Adaptatif et Modulaire. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Moya, A.: Current Status of ESTA-Task 2. In: Stellar Evolu- tion and Seismic Tools for Asteroseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publica- tion Series, Vol 26, 187 (2007) Moya, A., Garrido R.: Granada oscillation Code (GraCo). Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Moya, A., Christensen-Dalsgaard, J., Charpinet, S., et al.: Inter-comparison of the g-, f- and p-modes calculated us- ing different oscillation codes for a given stellar model. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Goals and Tasks of ESTA-CoRoT 11 Paquette, C., Pelletier, C., Fontaine, G., Michaud, G.: Diffu- sion coefficients for stellar plasmas. ApJS 61, 177 (1986). Poretti, E., Alonso, R., Amado, P.J., et al.: Preparing the COROT Space Mission: New Variable Stars in the Galac- tic Anticenter Direction. AJ 129, 2461 (2005) Provost, J.: NOSC: Nice Oscillations Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Reiter, J., Walsh, L., Weiss, A.: Solar models: a comparative study of two stellar evolution codes. MNRAS 274, 899 (1995) Rogers, F.J., Nayfonov, A.: Updated and Expanded OPAL Equation-of-State Tables: Implications for Helioseismol- ogy. ApJ 576, 1064 (2002) Roxburgh, I.W., Vorontsov, S.V.: Asteroseismological Con- straints on Stellar Convective Cores. In: Stellar Structure: Theory and Test of Connective Energy Transport, ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 173, 257 (1999) Roxburgh, I.W.: The OSCROX stellar oscillation code. 539 (1998) Ventura, P., D'Antona, F., Mazzitell, I., The ATON 3.1 stel- lar evolutionary code: a version for asteroseismology. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Verner, G.A., Chaplin, W.J., Elsworth, Y.: The Detectability of Signatures of Rapid Variation in Low-Degree Stellar p-Mode Oscillation Frequencies. ApJ 638, 440 (2006) Weiss, A., Schlattl, H.: GARSTEC: the Garching Stellar Evolution Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Willson, R.C., Hudson, H.S., Frohlich, C., Brusa, R.W.: Long-term downward trend in total solar irradiance. Sci- ence 234, 1114 (1986) Zahn, J.-P.: Modeling stellar interiors with rotational mix- ing. Stellar Evolution and Seismic Tools for Asteroseis- mology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Mon- teiro, EAS Publication Series, Vol 26, 49 (2007) Ap&SS -- this volume (2008a) Roxburgh, I.W.: The STAROX stellar evolution code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008b) Salpeter, E.E.: Electron Screening and Thermonuclear Re- actions. Australian Journal of Physics 7, 373 (1954) Samadi, R., Goupil, M.J., Alecian, E., et al.: Excitation of Solar-like Oscillations: From PMS to MS Stellar Models. JApA 26, 171 (2005) Scuflaire, R., Montalb´an, J., Th´eado, S., et al.: The Li`ege Oscillations Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008a) Scuflaire, R., Th´eado, S., Montalb´an, J., et al.: CL ´ES, Code Li´egeois d'Evolution Stellaire. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008b) Shibahashi, H., Osaki, Y.: Theoretical Eigenfrequencies of Solar Oscillations of Low Harmonic Degree L in 5- MINUTE Range. PASJ 33, 713 (1981) Suarez, J.C., Goupil, M.J.: FILOU Oscillation Code. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Suran, M.: LNAWENR - Linear Nonadiabatic Nonradial Waves. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Th´eado, S., Vauclair, S., Castro, M., Charpinet, S., Dolez, N.: Asteroseismic tests of element diffusion in so- lar type stars. A&A 437, 553 (2005) Thoul, A.A., Bahcall, J.N., Loeb, A.: Element diffusion in the solar interior. ApJ 421, 828 (1994) Thoul, A.A., Montalb´an, J.: Microscopic diffusion in stellar plasmas. In: Stellar Evolution and Seismic Tools for Aster- oseismology, (Eds) C.W. Straka, Y. Lebreton, M.J.P.F.G. Monteiro, EAS Publication Series, Vol 26, 25 (2007) Thoul, A.: betaDat - a Database for b Cepheis. Ap&SS -- this volume (2008) Turck-Chi`eze, S., Basu, S., Berthomieu, G., et al.: Sensitiv- ity of the Sound Speed to the Physical Processes Included in the Standard Solar Model. In: Structure and Dynamics of the Interior of the Sun and Sun-like Stars, Korzennik, S. (Ed.): ESA SP-418, 555 (1998) Turcotte, S., Richer, J., Michaud, G., Iglesias, C.A., Rogers, F.J.: Consistent Solar Evolution Model Including Diffusion and Radiative Acceleration Effects. ApJ 504,
0811.0153	2	0811	2008-11-05T14:35:08	Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation	[ "astro-ph" ]	Bars in spiral galaxies can weaken through gas inflow towards the center, and angular momentum transfer. Several bar episodes can follow one another in the life of the galaxy, if sufficient gas is accreted from the intergalactic medium to revive young disks. Pattern speeds of the successive bars are different, due to mass concentration, or increased velocity dispersion of the remaining stellar component. In the same time, the spiral galaxy evolves in morphological type. Numerical simulations are presented, trying to correlate type and bar pattern speeds.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mem. S.A.It. Vol. 75, 282 c(cid:13) SAIt 2008 Memorie della ae eed ev i ad ba efai F. Combes Observatoire de Paris, LERMA -- 61 Av. de l'Observatoire, F-75014 Paris, France e-mail: [email protected] Abstract. Bars in spiral galaxies can weaken through gas inflow towards the center, and angular momentum transfer. Several bar episodes can follow one another in the life of the galaxy, if sufficient gas is accreted from the intergalactic medium to revive young disks. Pattern speeds of the successive bars are different, due to mass concentration, or increased velocity dispersion of the remaining stellar component. In the same time, the spiral galaxy evolves in morphological type. Numerical simulations are presented, trying to correlate type and bar pattern speeds. Key words. Galaxies: dynamics -- Galaxies: structure -- Galaxies: star formation -- Galaxy: interstellar matter -- Galaxies: evolution 1. Evolution through gas accretion In the hierarchical scenario, most of the mass of galaxies is assembled through mergers of sub-units. Although this mechanism works pretty well for early-type galaxies and ellipti- cals, the interaction between galaxies is quite destructive for disks. To account for the high prevalence of thin disks in today observations, another scenario has to be invoked in parallel, namely external gas accretion from filaments. This diffuse, progressive and smooth mass ac- cretion is much less destructive, and help to replenish galaxy disks in gas available to new star formation. Gas accretion can reform cool and thin disks, which are then unstable to new spiral and bar patterns, in addition to star formation (Bournaud & Combes 2002). The relative role of gas accretion and mergers has recently been estimated in numerical simulaitons (Dekel et al 2008). The detailed analysis of a cosmo- Send offprint requests to: F. Combes logical simulation with gas and star formation shows that most of the starbursts are due to smooth flows, which exceed the merger source by about a factor 10. Inflow rates are sufficient to assemble galaxy masses (10-100 M⊙/yr). These considerable gas flows should have large consequences on the dynamics of galaxy disks. In particular, they should accelerate the succession of patterns in the disk. The role of gas on bars has been investigated for a long time now (e.g. Friedli & Benz 1993). In these early simulations, there was no dark matter component. The non-axisymmetric patterns produced gravity torques and the ex- change of angular momentum between gas and stars and from inner to outer parts. The ex- pulsion of the angular momentum in the outer parts, allows the gas to flow towards the cen- ter. This was accompanied by the destruction of the bar and formation of a triaxial bulge. 8 0 0 2 v o N 5 ] h p - o r t s a [ 2 v 3 5 1 0 . 1 1 8 0 : v i X r a Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation 283 Fig. 1. Comparison between gSb galaxy models, without gas accretion (top) and with accretion (bottom). The gSb model is the maximum disk model, the gas accretion rate is 5 M⊙/yr, and the snapshot corresponds to T=8 Gyr. Note that a bar is maintained only in the case of gas accretion. 2. Bar formation and destruction The mechanism invoked to account for the ob- served destruction of bars due to the gas in- flow, was the implied central mass concentra- tions (CMC). When a massive CMC is added like a black hole in the center of a purely stellar disk, the effect is indeed to weaken and destroy bars (Norman, Sellwood & Hasan 1996). This is attributed to the chaos induced by the super- position of CMC and bar on the stellar orbits, as checked by the computation of surface of sections. 2.1. Bardestructionbygas The effect of the gas inflow is not only to pro- duce a central mass concentration. In fact, the gas is driven in by the bar torques, but recipro- cally, the gas exerts the opposite torque on the stars. The angular momentum lost by the gas is taken up by the bar wave. Since the latter is a pattern with negative angular momentum (in- side its corotation), this exchange of momen- tum weakens and destroys the bar. Simulations show that the gas infall of 1-2% of disk mass is enough to transform a bar in a lens (Friedli 1994, Berentzen et al 1998, Bournaud et al 2005). 2.2. Reformationofbars If it is the gas inflow itself that destroys the bar, the advantage over the CMC mechanism is that it does not prevent a new bar to form. As soon as some new gas is accreted to replenish the disk, and makes it unstable again to bar for- mation, there could be a succession of patterns crossing the disk (see e.g. Figure 1). It works like a self-regulated cycle: the first step being the formation of a bar in a cold un- stable disk, then the bar produces gas inflow, 284 Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation Fig. 2. Evolution of bar strength, measured as the ratio Q2 of the maximal m = 2 tangential force to the radial force, measured at a radius of 3.3kpc. The black curve corresponds to the purely stellar run, the red curve, to the spiral galaxy with initial gas, subject to star formation, but not replenished. These two curves are respectively the top and the bottom curves. The other curves corresponds to the models with gas accretion, 5 M⊙/yr for the green one, and 5 M⊙/yr for the blue one. The galaxy model is an early-type gSa. Note that the presence of gas triggers bar instability earlier than in the purely stellar run. which weakens or destroys the bar. External gas accretion closes the loop. The gas enters the disk by intermittence: first it is confined outside OLR until the bar weakens, then it can replenish the disk, to make it unstable again to bar formation. This is the mechanism when the dark mat- ter component may be ignored, in the inner parts of giant galaxies. When a massive dark matter is taken into account in simulations, the angular momentum exchange is preferentially done with the DM particles, due to dynami- cal friction. Because of its low mass, the gas plays then a minor role in the AM transfer, at least when the fraction of gas is lower than 8% (Berentzen et al 2007). However in DM-dominated simulations, the bar is still weakened or destroyed more quickly in the presence of gas. This is inter- preted in terms of the destruction by the gas of vertical resonances, and with the help of the CMC. To destroy the bar, the gas fraction must be higher in the presence of a massive halo. The role of gas is complex since simu- lations reveal that it prevents peanut forma- tion. The presence of gas implies more chaos in the orbits, which stop the effect of verti- cal resonance. However, the vertical peanut in- stability is a factor of bar weakening, in pure stellar disk. Since the bar is weakened more quickly in the presence of gas, the bar weak- ening mechanism must be different from the vertical buckling. 3. New simulations of bar reformation To further investigate the relative role of gas and dark matter in the angular momentum transfer, and in the bar successive formation, weakening and re-formation, we have car- Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation 285 Table 1. Summary of the different models simulated (bulge, disk, halo and gas components are respectively described) Model Mb 1010 M⊙ rb kpc Md 1010 M⊙ rd kpc Mh 1010 M⊙ rh kpc Mgas 1010 M⊙ rgas kpc gSa gSb-st gSb-dmx gSb-nfw gSd-st gSd-dmx gSd-nfw 4.6 1.1 2.2 1.1 0. 0. 0. 2. 1. 1. 1. -- -- -- 6.9 4.6 9.2 4.6 5.7 11.4 5.7 4. 5. 5. 5. 6. 6. 6. 11.5 17.2 11.4 17.2 17.2 11.4 17.2 10. 12. 12. 12. 15. 15. 15. 1.3 0.9 0.9 0.9 1.7 1.7 1.7 5. 6. 6. 6. 7. 7. 7. ried out a series of simulations, with differ- ent galaxy models, described in Table 1. Three Hubble types are considered, Sa, Sbc and Sd, and since they are giant spiral galaxies, they are noted gSa, gSb and gSd. ations of the gas component, the number of gas particules is kept constant, but the individual particle mass is variable. The same is assumed for the "star" particles, which can be newly born, or lose mass. 3.1. Prescriptionofthesimulations The simulations are fully self-consistent, with live dark haloes. They are using a 3D Particle- Mesh code, based on FFT, with a useful grid of 1283 (the algorithm of James (1977) to supress the Fourier images is used). The gas is repre- sented by sticky particles, and a total of 240 000 particles is used. Similar simulations with TREE-SPH have also been run (e.g. Di Matteo et al 2007). The star formation is assumed to follow a Schmidt law, with exponent n=1.4, and a den- sity threshold. It is calibrated for a gas con- sumption time-scale of 5 Gyr. We do not as- sume instantaneous recycling, but take into account a continuous mass loss, across Gyrs (Jungwiert et al 2001). The mass loss by stars is distributed through gas on neighbouring par- ticles, with a velocity dispersion, to schematize the feedback energy. When external gas accretion is considered, the gas is deposited at the inner border of the disk, over 4kpc. At this radius, the gas is as- sumed to have already settled in the plane, with circular velocity. To cope with large mass vari- The mass and characteristic radii of all components in the seven initial conditions, are displayed in Table 1. The standard model has a disk dominated by dark matter, but with a core. An NFW model, with a cusp and a cen- tral concentration of c=8 has been run, then a maximum disk model (dmx) with equal mass in baryons and DM within the optical disk. For each galaxy model, we have 4 runs: a control simulation with pure stellar disks, without gas, then a run with gas and star formation, and two other runs with gas accretion, either 5 M⊙/yr, or 10 M⊙/yr. The rotation curves are fitted to the ob- served typical curves for these Hubble types. For these giant spiral galaxies, the total mass inside 35kpc is 2.4 1011 M⊙, with 75% n DM and 25% baryons, for the standard model (and equality between baryons and DM for the dmx model). In the gas accretion runs, the final mass is 17% or 35% higher after 9 Gyr. Due to the varying bulge-to-disk mass ratio over the se- quence, the precession rate Ω − κ/2 sweeps a large range, so that the expected pattern speed of the bar patterns are expected to vary corre- spondingly. 286 Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation Fig. 3. Evolution of bar strength, as in Figure 2 (black is the purely stellar run, red, with gas but no accretion, green with 5 M⊙/yr accretion, and red 10 M⊙/yr), for the 3 potential models of the gSb galaxy: standard, maximum disk, and cuspy NFW dark matter halo. The bar strength and pattern speed are computed from Fourier analysis of the poten- tial, as in Combes & Sanders (1981): Q2 = Fθ(m = 2)/Fr We take the maximum over the azimuth of Q2, estimated at a radius of R=3.3kpc. Fig. 4. Same as in Figure 3, but for the gSd models. 3.2. Angularmomentum(AM)transfer When the galaxy disk is dominated by the mass of the dark matter halo, the main angu- lar momentum transfer is from baryons to the dark matter (Athanassoula 2002, 2003). In that sense, the DM halo can favor (instead of pre- vent) bar formation. With light dark matter haloes, the bar is formed or weakened while AM is exchanged between the inner disk and the outer disk or gas. The exact processus depends on the amount of dark matter inside the visible disk. In addition, the pattern speed of the bar de- creases due to dynamical friction against the Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation 287 no accretion 5 Mo/yr Fig. 6. Power spectrum displaying the pattern speed of the m = 2 Fourier component, over the whole simulation of the gSd model, version NFW potential, without accretion (top), and with accretion by 5 M⊙/yr (bottom). Without gas accretion, the bar is distroyed rapiddly, and has no time to slow down, due to dynamical friction. The signature shows a single pattern speed. For the case with gas accretion, a new bar is formed, with a smaller pattern speed, and several values can be read. Note that the bar is more extended, when slower. ble accretion rate (10M⊙/yr), although the ef- fect remains small. This might be due to the great stability inferred by the massive bulge. The same features occur also in the case of the gSb model (Figure 3), but now the gas accretion succeeds to reform a new bar, at the same level as the control run, with purely stel- lar disk. The case of the gSd model is more com- plex (Figure 4). The instability of the disk is large, and dynamical feedback effects, due to gravitational heating, can produce unexpected Fig. 5. Star formation rate versus time (bot- tom), average plane thickness (top left), and vertical velocity dispersion (top right), for the gSd standard model. The dash lines correspond to the stellar component, and the full lines to the gas. dark matter particles (Debattista & Sellwood 2000). We observed the same phenomenon with our standard models, in the case of pure stellar disks. In the gSa model for instance, the pattern speed Ωb begins at 50 km/s/kpc, and the bar slows down until around 10 km/s/kpc in the pure stellar run. With initial gas, and no accre- tion, the bar is quickly weakened, and there is then three times less angular momentum trans- fer: Ωb decreases less, from 50 to 25 km/s/kpc, in 9 Gyr. 3.3. Comparisonofbarstrengths Figure 2 compares the bar strength of several runs, in the case of the gSa galaxy model. When the disk is purely stellar, the bar is long lived (black curve), although it is suddenly weakened when the peanut resonance thick- ens the disk vertically. When the gas is in- cluded (and for this early-tupe galaxy, it is 5% of the toal mass), then the bar is destroyed (red curve). Note that with gas, the bar instabil- ity occurs earlier than in the pure stellar case, since the disk is then cooler, and thus more un- stable. With gas accretion (5M⊙/yr), the bar re- mains at a higher level, even more with a dou- 288 Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation no accretion 5 Mo/yr Fig. 7. Power spectrum displaying the pattern speed of the m = 2 Fourier component, over the whole simulation of the gSb model, version NFW potential, without accretion (top), and with accretion by 5 M⊙/yr (bottom). Note how thick is the spectrum, accumulating several bar patterns with slower and slower speeds. With gas accretion, a new bar is formed, more ex- tended, with a smaller pattern speed. behaviour. The dark matter halo stabilises the standard gSd model; the thin disk, in absence of bulge, is vertically unstable, and buckles even before forming a bar, which delays by 4 Gyr the bar formation. In presence of gas, the bar forms in less than 1 Gyr however. Secondary bar episodes are observed. Figure 5 shows how gas accretion can maintain the star formation rate at a nearly con- stant value, while it is exponentially decreas- ing without external gas accretion. The star for- mation and corresponding feedback is heating progressively the stellar disk (visible both in vertical height of the disk and vertical velocity dispersion). The peanut formation heats also the stars, while the gas can cool down, and re- trieve an approximately constant z-dispersion. 4. Pattern speeds The normal bar evolution is often accompanied by a decrease of the pattern speed, and this phenomenon occurs even without dark matter halo and dynamical friction. This phenomenon was observed in models without DM halo, or with rigid haloes (Friedli & Benz 1993). Stellar orbits are more and more elongated during bar growth, and their precession rate decreases (e.g. Combes et al 1990). This AM exchange with the outer disk is also accompanied by chaotic escape. More unstable stellar disks end up with a weaker bar. Fugure 6 shows the power spectrum of the NFW-potential gSd model. The power spec- trum is defined by the Fourier transform over time of the bar strength, at each radius: Power(ω, r) = Z Q2(t, r)exp(iωt)dt In the case of no gas accretion, the bar is quikcly destroyed, and the spectrum is clear and thin: only one bar at 28 km/s/kpc is seen. With gas accretion, a second bar is formed, but with lower pattern speed, 18 km/s/kpc, and two features are seen in the power-spectrum. In the case of a bar only weakened, but not destroyed, and slowed down by dynamical friction, a thick spectrum is observed, as a tracer of the contin- uously decreasing pattern speed (cf Figure 7). It is important to note that bars always end up near their corotation. When the bar is slowed down, its length increases correspond- ingly. Figure 6 shows clearly how the slower bar is more extended in radius. It will then be quite difficult observationnally to retrieve the history of the bar pattern speed evolution. As a consequence of AM transfers, mass is redistributed in the disk, and the surface density reveals breaks in the radial profiles. Surface density breaks have been interpreted as the formation of successive bars by Debattista et al (2006). These could be a stellar proces- sus (Pfenniger & Friedli 1991), or a gas pro- cess, with star formation threshold (Roskar et al 2008). Combes: Pattern speed evolution and bar reformation 289 Debattista V.P., Mayer, L., Carollo, C. M. et al.: 2006, ApJ 645, 209 Dekel, A., Birnboim, Y., Engel, G. et al. 2008, sub, astro-ph/0808.0553 Di Matteo P., Combes F., Melchior A-L., Semelin B.: 2007: A&A 468, 61 Friedli, D., Benz W.: 1993, A&A 268, 65 Friedli, D., 1994, in Mass-Transfer Induced Activity in Galaxies, Ed I. Shlosman, Cambridge University Press, p.268 James, R.A. 1977: J. Comput. Phys. 25, 71 Jungwiert B., Combes F., Palous J.: 2001, A&A 376, 85 Norman C., Sellwood J.A., Hasan H.: 1996 ApJ 462, 114 Pfenniger, D., Friedli, D.: 1991, A&A, 252, 75 Roskar R., Debattista V.P., Stinson G.S. et al: 2008, ApJ 675, L65 5. Conclusions Gas plays a fundamental role in spiral galax- ies. Even when representing only 5-7% of the total mass inside 35kpc, the presence of gas weakens or destroys the bar. It can weaken the peanut, changes the bar pattern speed. To account for the bar frequency observed today, it is essential to take into account gas accretion: it provides bar reformation, through disk replenishment. The amount of gas accre- tion required, is justified and confirmed by cos- mological simulations. It is possible that mass assembly could be attributed to smooth accretion more than merg- ers: this will solve the problem of the high fre- quency of bars observed today, and also the ex- istence of thin stellar disks, that mergers would over-heat. Finally, pattern speeds have a tendency to decrease, first due to the elongation of or- bits, and the heating of the disk, then bars are slowed down by dynamical friction against the dark halo. When bars are reformed, they occur with a lower pattern speed. This may constrain the amount of dark matter present within the optical disk. Acknowledgements. I am grateful to E. Corsini and V. Debattista to invite me at such an exciting and friendly conference. References I., Shlosman, Athanassoula, E.: 2002, ApJ 569, L83 Athanassoula, E.: 2003, MNRAS 341, 1179 Berentzen I., Heller, C. H., Shlosman, I., Fricke, K. J.: 1998, MNRAS 300, 49 Berentzen I., Martinez- Valpuesta, I., Heller, C.: 2007, ApJ 666, 189 Bournaud F., Combes F.: 2002, A&A 392, 83 Bournaud F., Combes F., Semelin B.: 2005, MNRAS 364, L18 Combes F., Sanders R.H.: 1981, A&A 96, 164 Combes F., Debbasch F., Friedli D., Pfenniger D.: 1990, A&A 233, 82 Debattista V.P., Sellwood J.: 2000, ApJ 543, 704
astro-ph/0412360	1	0412	2004-12-15T08:58:56	The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high-z optically-obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001: a classic radio quiet QSO	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present a 30 ks XMM-Newton observation of the z = 2.35 Type II radio quiet quasar RX J1343.4+0001. These data provide the first good quality X-ray spectrum for this object. We measured a continuum slope Gamma = 1.85+/-0.10 with only an upper limit on the column density of the absorbing material of Nh(z) <~ 10^22 cm^-2 as well as an Fe Kalpha emission line at the 3 sigma confidence level. We do not find therefore a highly absorbed object nor a truly flat spectrum as suggested on the basis of previous less sensitive ROSAT and ASCA measurements. The Nh(z) upper limit is fully consistent with the optical extinction 3 <A_V <10 inferred from IR observations. The Fe Kalpha line is consistent with fluorescence from neutral iron and, noteworthy, is one of the most distant observed so far. The X-ray spectral properties of RX J1343.4+0001 agree well with the steep continuum slope (Gamma ~ 1.9) being independent of increasing redshift and luminosity as inferred by X-ray studies of large samples of RQ QSOs.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. aa1804 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) December 13, 2018 The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high-z optically-obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001: a classic radio quiet QSO⋆ E. Piconcelli1, M. Guainazzi1, M. Cappi2, E. Jimenez -- Bailon1, N. Schartel1 1 XMM-Newton Science Operations Centre (ESAC), Apartado 50727, E -- 28080 Madrid, Spain 2 IASF/CNR, via Piero Gobetti 101, I -- 40129 Bologna, Italy H < Abstract. We present a 30 ks XMM -- Newton observation of the z = 2.35 Type II radio quiet quasar RX J1343.4+0001. These data provide the first good quality X -- ray spectrum for this object. We measured a continuum slope Γ = 1.85±0.10 with only an upper limit on the column density of the absorbing material of Nz ∼ 1022 cm−2 as well as an Fe Kα emission line at the 3σ confidence level. We do not find therefore a highly absorbed object nor a truly flat spectrum as suggested on the basis of previous less sensitive ROSAT and ASCA measurements. The Nz H upper limit is fully consistent with the optical extinction 3< AV <10 inferred from IR observations. The Fe Kα line is consistent with fluorescence from neutral iron and, noteworthy, is one of the most distant observed so far. The X -- ray spectral properties of RX J1343.4+0001 agree well with the steep continuum slope (Γ ≈ 1.9) being independent of increasing redshift and luminosity as inferred by X -- ray studies of large samples of RQ QSOs. Key words. Galaxies: individual: RX J1343.4+0001 -- Galaxies: active -- Quasar: general -- X-ray: galaxies 1. Introduction In the framework of unified models, the differences be- tween Type I and Type II Seyferts are explained by the existence of an obscuring screen (the so-called "torus"), which prevents us from observing the inner regions around the black hole (i.e. the accretion disk and the broad line region), if our line of sight intersects it (Antonucci 1993). This picture (which is thought to hold also for QSOs) implies that Type I and II AGNs are essentially the same objects viewed at different inclination angles. Nonetheless, the existence of high -- luminosity analogues of Seyfert IIs (i.e. with only narrow emission lines in their optical spec- tra) has been hotly debated during the last decade, and only with the advent of new generation X-ray telescopes XMM -- Newton and Chandra has a handful of these objects been unambiguously detected in the optical follow -- up of deep X -- ray surveys (e.g. Norman et al. 2002; Padovani et al. 2004; Fabian et al. 2003 for a review). Most of the studies carried out so far on the X-ray spectral properties of QSOs concern optically-selected (i.e. not obscured) samples at z < ∼ 1 (see e.g. Zamorani et al. 1981; Williams et al. 1992; Fiore et al. 1998). At higher redshifts (i.e. z ≫ 1) the situation is more uncertain be- Send offprint requests to: [email protected] ⋆ Based on observations with XMM-Newton, an ESA Science Mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by ESA Member states and the USA (NASA) cause of the limited number of sources accounted for so far. Moreover, since at a given optical luminosity "radio quiet" (RQ) QSOs are ∼ 3 times less X-ray luminous than "radio loud" (RL) QSOs, most of the spectroscopically analyzed QSOs at higher redshifts were RL. So the average spec- tral properties observed for RL QSOs at low z (hΓiRL ∼ 1.6 and intrinsic NH exceeding the Galactic value) were confirmed to persist up to z ∼ 3-4 by ASCA and ROSAT observations (Cappi et al. 1997; Reeves & Turner 2000, hereafter RT00). On the contrary, spectral properties of high-z RQ QSOs were poorly constrained before the launch of XMM -- Newton and Chandra. Early ASCA results (Vignali et al. 1999), which suggested a flattening of the average slope with increasing redshifts, have been recently revised after the results of individual spectral analysis of QSOs at z ∼ 2 detected in a shallow XMM -- Newton survey (Piconcelli et al. 2003, hereafter P03) and stacked-spectra analysis of very high-z (i.e. z ≈ 5 -- 6) objects (Vignali et al. 2003). These findings indicate that no change in the X -- ray continuum slope with redshift occurs. Such a trend is also confirmed by recent optical surveys (Fan et al. 2004) which find no significant evolution in the average emission line and continuum properties of z ∼ 6 QSOs compared to those of lower redshift samples of QSOs. It is worth stressing that these results are based on samples of broad line QSOs. The X-ray spectral properties 2 E. Piconcelli et al.: The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high -- z optically -- obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001 of type II QSOs, however, remain almost unexplored ow- ing to their very faint X-ray fluxes. Furthermore the exis- tence of such a large population of high-luminosity (LX > 1044 erg cm−2 s−1) obscured objects is also required in all the synthesis models of the cosmic X-ray background in order to reproduce the source counts in the 2 -- 10 keV band (Gilli et al. 2001). In this paper we report on the XMM -- Newton observa- tion of RX J1343.4+0001 (z = 2.35; Almaini et al. 1995, hereafter A95). Its relative brightness (F0.5−10 ≈ 2 × 10−13 erg cm−2 s−1) makes RX J1343.4+0001 an excel- lent candidate to get better insight in the X -- ray spectral properties of high-z RQ QSOs. 2. RX J1343.4+0001 RX J1343.4+0001 was discovered during the optical follow-up of a deep ROSAT survey and classified as a Type II QSO because of its high luminosity (LX ∼ 2 × 1045 erg s−1) and the lack of any broad lines (i.e. with v > 900 km/s) in its optical spectrum (A95). The ROSAT 0.1-2 keV low-statistics spectrum was fitted by A95 with an unabsorbed power law model with Γ ∼ 1.5. Georgantopoulos et al. (1999, hereafter G99) presented the results of near-IR and ASCA observations of this QSO. They detected a broad Hα emission line redshifted at 2.2 µm: therefore this object is not a pure QSO 2, but, more properly, a "Type 1.9" QSO, i.e. a luminous analogue of a Seyfert 1.9 galaxy, considering the source -- frame opti- cal spectra. The ASCA spectrum is hard and either a flat (Γ ∼ 1.3) or a steeper (Γ ∼ 1.9) absorbed (NH ∼ 1023 cm−2) power-law model yielded acceptable fits. The limited photon statistics prevented a firm conclusion on the spectral shape of this source. Similar conclusions were reached by G99 who also added ROSAT data in their anal- ysis. RX J1343.4+0001 was also included in the ASCA QSOs survey presented by RT00. These authors reported the detection (at 90% confidence level) of a Fe Kα line at 6.4 keV with a rest -- frame equivalent width EW = 432+435 eV. −358 3. XMM -- Newton observation and data reduction RX J1343.4+0001 was observed by XMM -- Newton (Jansen et al. 2001 and references therein) on January 29, 2004 for 35.4 ks. The EPIC PN (Turner et al. 2001) and MOS (Struder et al. 2001) observations were carried out in the full frame mode using the Thin filter. XMM -- Newton data were processed with SAS v6.0. We used the EPCHAIN and EMCHAIN tasks for processing the raw PN and MOS data files, respectively, in order to gener- ate the relative linearized event files. X -- ray events cor- responding to patterns 0 -- 12(0 -- 4) for the MOS(PN) cam- eras were selected. We employed the most updated calibra- tion files at the time the reduction was performed (June 2004). Flickering and bad pixels were removed. The event lists were furthermore filtered to ignore periods of high background flaring according to the method presented in Piconcelli et al. (2004a) based on the cumulative dis- tribution function of background lightcurve count-rates. After this data cleaning, we obtained as net exposure time 24.9, 27.8, 32.4 ks for PN, MOS1 andMOS2, respec- tively. Given the current calibration uncertainties, we dis- carded PN(MOS) events below 0.3(0.6) keV and above 12(10) keV. EPIC spectra were binned to a minimum of 20 counts/bin to facilitate the use of the χ2 minimization technique in the spectral fitting. All fits were performed using the XSPEC package (v11.3). PN and MOS data were then fitted simultaneously. The quoted errors in the model parameters correspond to a 90% confidence level for one interesting parameter (∆χ2 = 2.71; Avni 1976). All lumi- nosities are calculated assuming a ΛCDM cosmology with (ΩM,ΩΛ) = (0.3,0.7) and a Hubble constant of 70 km s−1 Mpc−1 (Bennett et al. 2003). 4. The X -- ray spectrum We initially fitted the EPIC spectrum with a power law model modified by Galactic absorption (NGal H =2.6 × 1020 cm−2; A95). This fit (PL hereafter) turned out a photon index Γ = 1.82+0.10 −0.09 with an associated χ2(ν) =41(47). In order to test the presence of heavy intrinsic obscu- ration in RX J1343.4+0001 as claimed by previous X -- ray studies, we added an additional absorption compo- nent due to neutral gas to the PL model. No intrinsic absorption was significantly detected and the upper limit on the column density in the QSO rest -- frame (z = 2.35) H< 5 × 1021 cm−2. In Fig. 1 the two -- dimensional was Nz contour plot in the parameter space Nz H -- Γ is shown. Our EPIC data place tighter than ever limits on the slope of the primary continuum as well as on the amount of the absorption in RX J1343.4+0001. Note that assuming the RT00 best fit model (i.e. Γ = 1.9±0.4 and Nz −4.1 × 1022 cm−2) yields χ2 ν ≈ 4.2. We also tested the possibil- ity that the obscuration occurs in an 'warm' (i.e. ionized) material. Even if the X -- ray opacity of such a gas is lower than neutral, a warm absorber with internal dust could, however, significantly obscure the optical/UV band (as suggested in Komossa & Fink (1997) for the Seyfert 1.8 NGC3786). This fit, performed using the ABSORI model in XSPEC, yielded no statistical improvement with respect to the model with cold absorption. The resulting column density of the warm gas was NH < 1 × 1022 cm−2, while its ionization parameter remained unconstrained with a best-fit value ξ ∼0 erg cm−2 s−1. H 4.8+6.5 Visual inspection of the data -- to -- model ratio residuals (see Fig. 2) suggests the presence of an emission feature at ∼ 2 keV (i.e. ∼ 6.4 keV in the QSO rest -- frame). This spectral feature was already marginally detected by ASCA (RT00) and it is associated to fluorescence emission from the K -- shell of iron. Thus we introduced a narrow Gaussian line in the fitting model to account for it. The fit gave a rest -- frame energy of the line at E = 6.42+0.08 −290 eV in the QSO -- frame) with a statistical improvement significant at 98.5% confidence level. The centroid of the line corresponds to −0.21 keV (EW = 460+330 E. Piconcelli et al.: The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high -- z optically -- obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001 3 Fig. 1. Confidence contour plot showing the QSO photon index (Γ) against the intrinsic rest -- frame column density (Nz H). The contours are at 68%, 90% and 99% confidence levels, respectively, for two interesting parameters. The column density of the Galactic foreground absorption is NGal H = 2.6 × 1020 cm−2. Fig. 2. A close -- up of the ratios of the PN spectral data to a simple power law model. The plot shows the excess at ∼ 1.9 keV corresponding to ∼ 6.4 keV in the QSO rest -- frame. low ionization states, i.e. Fe I -- XVIII (Makishima 1986). The resulting slope of the underlying continuum was Γ = 1.85±0.10. Furthermore we checked (and ruled out) the possibility that background subtraction affects the detection and/or the strength of this line by a visual inspection of the source and background superposed spectra. We also fitted the line leaving the σKα parameter free to vary, which yielded a value of σKα ∼ 0 (with an upper limit of σKα < 1.3 keV) and no statistical improvement in the goodness of fit. The velocity width of the line is not well constrained because of the limited number of photons collected from this faint QSO. Further investigations on the possible "broadness" of this line require better data quality. We measured a 2 -- 10 (0.5 -- 2) keV observed flux of 6.5±0.1(4.0±0.2) × 10−14 erg cm−2 s−1, which cor- responds to a luminosity of ∼ 2.2 (1.1) × 1045 erg s−1 once corrected for Galactic absorption. During this XMM -- Newton observation the 0.5 -- 10 keV flux of RX J1343.4+0001 was therefore a factor of 40% lower than measured by ASCA on 1996. Assuming that the black hole produces X -- rays with an efficiency of 0.01 × EPIC PN of Fig. 3. RX J1343.4+0001 when the best fit model (i.e. power law + Gaussian line) is applied. The lower panel shows the deviations of the observed data from the model. and MOS spectra LEdd (Norman et al. 2002) we can estimate a MBH ≈ 3 × 109 M⊙ which lies in the typical range inferred for high -- z QSOs (Dietrich & Hamann 2004). 5. Discussion 5.1. X -- ray continuum and absorption < The EPIC observation presented here provides the first good -- quality X -- ray spectrum of this "Type 1.9 QSO" as it allows us to strongly constrain both the slope of the primary continuum and the column density of the ∼ 1022 absorbing material, Γ = 1.85±0.10 and Nz H cm−2, respectively. Thanks to the unprecedented large collecting area of XMM -- Newton, it is therefore possible to rule out both hypotheses about the X -- ray nature of RX J1343.4+0001 suggested on the basis of low -- sensitivity ROSAT and ASCA measurements, i.e. a truly flat or a highly obscured spectrum (e.g. Sect. 2). Note that Georgantopoulos et al. (2004) derived similar values for these spectral parameters (i.e Γ = 1.77 ± 0.36 and Nz H < 6 × 1022 cm−2) from an off-axis shallow EPIC exposure of RX J1343.4+0001. We also performed a hardness ratio (HR) analysis of a 10 ks Chandra observation of this QSO. The HR for this source is slightly lower than the corresponding one calculated using Γ = 1.9 and Nz H = 1022 cm−2. This finding implies that a column density value larger than 1022 cm−2 is also ruled out on the basis of these Chandra data, taken when the source was at a similar flux level as the present EPIC observation. Previous ASCA claims (G99; RT00) for a large amount of Nz H (∼ 1023 cm−2) appear to be due to the limited sensitivity and the narrower energy range affecting these measurements. We rule out a possible contamination due to another source present in the ASCA errorbox: no addi- tional X -- ray source lies within the 1 arcmin box centered on the QSO. Some recent works based on XMM -- Newton observa- tions (Ferrero & Brinkmann 2003; Grupe et al. 2004) also do not confirm earlier ASCA results about the presence of a strong absorption toward high -- z QSOs. Nevertheless, 4 E. Piconcelli et al.: The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high -- z optically -- obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001 even though affected by large errors, the results found by A95 (i.e. a 95% upper limit of Γ <1.98 and a value of H < 1022 cm−2) for the ROSAT spectrum are consis- Nz tent with ours. Furthermore, the value obtained for the photon index is similar to the canonical one measured for RQ QSOs at 0.01 < ∼ 2 (e.g. RT00). This result is in agreement with the observational evidence that the mean X -- ray spectral shape of QSOs does not show any variation over z (P03; Vignali et al. 2003). ∼ z < < ∼ Nz H < The upper limit on the column density (Nz H ∼ 1022 cm−2) is fully consistent with the optical extinction. On the basis of the results from an IR observation (i.e. B − K = 5.4 and presence(absence) of the broad Hα(Hβ) line), G99 concluded that this QSO is obscured by a moder- ate amount of dust, with a lower limit of the photoelec- tric extinction of AV >3 (excluding, however, a reddening much higher than this value i.e. AV < 10 as suggested by Georgantopolous et al. 2003). Such a limit on the redden- ing to the BLR implies a range for the column density of 5 ∼ 2 × 1022 cm−2 according to the formula × 1021 < NH/AV = 1.79 × 1021 cm−2 mag−1 (Predehl & Schmitt 1995). On the one hand, this suggests that X -- ray and op- tical/UV obscuration likely occur in the same matter (e.g. the putative torus invoked in the AGN Unified models); on the other hand, it rules out the hypothesis of a gas-to- dust ratio along the line of sight several times larger than that of the Milky Way (G99). RX J1343.4+0001 therefore poses a notable exception among intermediate type 1.8- 1.9 AGNs which usually have a low AV /NH as pointed out by Maiolino et al. (2001) and Granato et al. (1997). Such a possibility has also been proposed to explain the existence of X-ray absorbed broad line QSOs (Akyiama et al. 2000). However, recent XMM -- Newton results (P03; Akylas et al. 2004) do not yield a large population of these objects and, moreover, there is growing evidence that obscuration in broad line QSOs is basically due to ionized (instead of "cold") material (Porquet et al. 2004; Piconcelli et al. 2004b; Schartel et al. 2004). Alternatively, the change in the spectral properties be- tween the ASCA and the XMM -- Newton observation could be explained in terms of a temporal variation of the col- umn density in the absorbing material as seen in some local AGNs (e.g. Akylas et al. 2002; Risaliti et al. 2002; Lamer et al. 2003). This spectral behaviour suggests the presence of clouds with different NH drifting across our line of sight responsible of the observed NH variations. 5.2. Fe Kα emission line ∼ 100 eV at L2−10≈1045 erg s−1 with that reported in RT00. It appears, therefore, that the strength of the iron line did not change between the two observations. This indicates that the Fe emitting material traces the variability of the nuclear flux and that the flu- orescence originates near the nucleus. Given the temporal difference between the two observations we infer an upper limit of < 2.45 pc on the distance nucleus/Fe emitter. The value of the EW is unusually large if compared with the results of Page et al. (2004) who reported a decrement of the mean EW with increasing L2−10. In particular they predict an hEWi < i.e. the luminosity measured for RX J1343.4+0001. The en- ergy of the line indicates that it emerges from cold matter, therefore an origin in the X -- ray/optical absorbing mate- rial appears likely. However, the best-fit value of the EW is too large to be accounted by the amount of the absorp- tion (few × 1021 cm−2) estimated for RX J1343.4+0001. A plausible explanation for such an EW value could be a combination of different processes such as fluorescence in transmission along the obscuring material plus reflection off the inner walls of the optically thick torus and/or the accretion disk into our line of sight. The detection of a con- tinuum Compton-reflection component in the EPIC spec- trum is very marginal and we could only obtain an upper limit of R(=Ω/2π) <2 for the covering factor of the ma- terial irradiated by the X-ray source, which is still con- sistent with observed Fe Kα line EW. Since the latter is consistent at 2σ with a value (EW ∼ 700 eV) typically observed in Compton -- thick AGNs (Levenson et al. 2002; Guainazzi et al. 2004) we also calculated the ratio T = F2−10/FOI I I , which is an indicator of the "thickness" of the absorbing matter (Bassani et al. 1999) using the IR data in G99. The resulting value of T ≫ 1 rules out this hypothesis that the observed X -- ray continuum is entirely due to reflection scattering. In conclusion, the X -- ray spectral properties of RX J1343.4+0001 obtained by this XMM -- Newton ob- servation agree well with the predictions of the AGN Unified Models concerning absorption. They also follow the trend of X -- ray spectral slopes being constant with redshift or luminosity, as recently inferred for large sam- ples of RQ QSOs (e.g. P03; Vignali et al. 2003; Piconcelli et al. 2004b). Acknowledgements. We thank the anonymous referee for her/his interesting suggestions. We gratefully acknowledge Marcus Kirsch and Pedro Rodriguez-Pascual for helpful com- ments. We would like to thank the staff of the XMM -- Newton Science Operations Center for their support. The Fe Kα emission line detected at ∼ 3σ in RX J1343.4+0001 is the most distant in a unlensed QSO observed so far (Chartas et al. 2004). Even more interest- ing is the fact that it has been observed in a Type II QSO, an elusive class of objects whose X -- ray spectral properties are not well known. Bearing in mind the large errors affect- ing both the measurements, the value of EW = 460+330 −290 eV obtained by the XMM -- Newton observation agrees well References Akylas, A., Geogakakis, A., & Georgantopolous, I., 2004, MNRAS, in press Akiyama, M., Ohta, K., & Yamada, T., et al., 2000, ApJ, 532, 700 Almaini, O., Boyle, B. J., Griffiths, R. E., et al., 1995, MNRAS, 277, L31 (A95) Antonucci, R., 1993, ARA&A, 31, 473 E. Piconcelli et al.: The XMM-Newton spectrum of the high -- z optically -- obscured QSO RX J1343.4+0001 5 Bassani, L., Dadina, M., Maiolino, R., et al., 1999, ApJS, 121, Zamorani, G., Henry, J.P., Maccacaro, T., et al., 1981, ApJ, 473 245, 357 Bennett, C. L., Halpern, M., Hinshaw, G., et al., 2003, ApJS, 148, 1 Cappi, M., Matsuoka, M., Comastri, A., et al., 1997, ApJ, 478, 492 Chartas, G., Eracleous, M., Agol, E., & Gallagher, S. C., 2004, ApJ, 606, 78 Dietrich, M., & Hamann, F., 2004, ApJ, 611, Fabian, A. C., 2003, Proc. of "Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies," ed. L.C. Ho (Cambridge Univ. Press) Fan, X., Hennawi, J. F., Richards, G. T., et al., 2004, ApJ, in press(astro-ph/0405138) Ferrero, E., & Brinkmann, W., 2003, A&A, 402, 465 Fiore, F., Elvis, M., Giommi, P., & Padovani, P., 1998, ApJ, 429, 79 Georgantopoulos, I., Almaini, O., Shanks, T., et al. 1999, MNRAS, 305, 125 (G99) Georgantopoulos, I., Georgakakis, A., Stewart, G. C., et al., 2003, MNRAS, 342, 321 Georgantopoulos, I., Georgakakis, A., Akylas, A., et al., 2004, MNRAS, 352, 91 Gilli, R., Salvati, M., & Hasinger, G., 2001, A&A 366, 407 Granato, L., Danese, L., & Franceschini, A., 1997, ApJ, 486, 147 Grupe, D., Mathur, S., Wilkes, B., & Elvis, M., 2004, ApJ, 127, 1 Guainazzi, M., Fabian, A. C., Iwasawa, K., Matt, G., & Fiore, F., 2004, MNRAS, (astro-ph/0409689) Jansen, F., Lumb, D., Altieri, B., et al., 2001, A&A, 365, L1 Komossa, S., & Fink, H., 1997, A&A, 327, 555 Lamer, G., Uttley, P., & McHardy, I. M., 2003, MNRAS 342, L41 Levenson, N. A., Krolik, J. H., Zycki, P. T., et al., 2002, ApJ 573, 81 Makishima, K., 1986, Lecture Notes in Physics, 266, 246 Norman, C., Hasinger, G., Giacconi R., et al., 2002, ApJ, 571, 218 Padovani, P., Allen, M. G., Rosati, P., & Walton, A., 2004, A&A, in press (astro-ph/0406056) Page, K. L., O'Brien, P. T., Reeves, J. N., & Turner, M. J., 2004, MNRAS, 347, 316 Piconcelli, E., Cappi, M., Bassani, L., Di Cocco, G., Dadina, M., 2003, A&A, 412, 689 (P03) Piconcelli, E., Jimenez-Bailon, E., Guainazzi, M., et al., 2004a, MNRAS, 351, 161 Piconcelli, E., Jimenez-Bailon, E., Guainazzi, M., et al., 2004b, A&A in press, (astro -- ph/0411051) Predehl, P., & Schmitt, J. H. M. M., 1995, A&A 293, 889 Porquet, D., Reeves, J.N., O'Brien, P., & Brinkmann, W., 2004, A&A, 422, 85 Reeves, J. N., Turner, M. J. L., 2000, MNRAS, 316, 234 (RT00) Schartel, N., Rodriguez-Pascual, P. M., Santos-Lleo, M., et al., 2004, A&A, in press Struder, L., Briel, U., Dennerl, K., et al., 2001, A&A 365, L18 Turner, M. J. L., Abbey, A., Arnaud, M., et al., 2001, A&A, 365, L27 Vignali, C., Comastri, A., Cappi, M., et al., 1999, ApJ, 516, 582 Vignali, C., Brandt, W. N., Schneider, D. P., et al., 2003, AJ, 125, 2876 Williams, O.R., Turner, M. J. L., Stewart, G. C., et al., 1992, ApJ, 389, 157
0804.2634	2	0804	2008-09-24T21:33:24	Fine tuning and the ratio of tensor to scalar density fluctuations from cosmological inflation	[ "astro-ph", "gr-qc", "hep-ph" ]	The form of the inflationary potential is severely restricted if one requires that it be natural in the technical sense, i.e. terms of unrelated origin are not required to be correlated. We determine the constraints on observables that are implied in such natural inflationary models, in particular on $r$, the ratio of tensor to scalar perturbations. We find that the naturalness constraint does not require $r$ to be lare enough to be detectable by the forthcoming searches for B-mode polarisation in CMB maps. We show also that the value of $r$ is a sensitive discriminator between inflationary models.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Fine tuning and the ratio of tensor to scalar density fluctuations from cosmological inflation OUTP-08-05P Shaun Hotchkiss, Gabriel Germ´an,∗ Graham G Ross† and Subir Sarkar Rudolf Peierls Centre for Theoretical Physics, University of Oxford, 1 Keble Road, Oxford, OX1 3NP, UK Abstract The form of the inflationary potential is severely restricted if one requires that it be natural in the technical sense, i.e. terms of unrelated origin are not required to be correlated. We determine the constraints on observables that are implied in such natural inflationary models, in particular on r, the ratio of tensor to scalar perturbations. We find that the naturalness constraint does not require r to be lare enough to be detectable by the forthcoming searches for B-mode polarisation in CMB maps. We show also that the value of r is a sensitive discriminator between inflationary models. The nature of the density perturbations originating in the early universe has been of great interest both observationally and theoretically. The hypothesis that they were generated during an early period of inflationary expansion has been shown to be consistent with all present observations. The most discussed mechanism for inflation is the 'slow roll' of a weakly coupled 'inflaton' field down its potential -- the near-constant vacuum energy of the system during the slow-roll evolution drives a period of exponentially fast expansion and the density perturbations have their origin as quantum fluctuations in the inflaton energy density. In such models the detailed structure of the density perturbations which give rise to the large scale structure of the universe observed today depends on the nature of the inflationary potential in the field region where they were generated. Boyle, Steinhardt and Turok [1] have argued that "naturalness" imposes such strong restrictions on the inflationary potential that one may derive interesting constraints on observables today. They concluded that in theories which are "natural" according to their criterion, the spectral index of the scalar density perturbations is bounded as ns < 0.98, and that the ratio of tensor-to-scalar perturbations satisfies r > 0.01 provided ns > 0.95, in accord with then current measurements [2]. Such a lower limit on the amplitude of gravitational waves is of enormous interest as there is then a realistic possibility of detecting them as 'B-mode' polarisation in CMB sky maps (see e.g. [3]) and thus verifying a key prediction of inflation. Of course these conclusions are crucially dependent on the definition of naturalness. In this paper we re-examine this important issue and argue that the criterion proposed by Boyle et al does not capture the essential aspects of a physically natural theory. We propose an alternative criterion that correctly reflects the constraints coming from underlying symmetries of the theory and we use this to determine a new bound on r that turns out to quite opposite to the previously inferred one. We emphasise that our result, although superficially similar to the 'Lyth bound' [4], follows in fact from different considerations and in particular makes no reference to how long inflation lasts. ∗On sabbatical leave from Instituto de Ciencias F´ısicas, Universidad Nacional Aut´onoma de M´exico †Corresponding author: [email protected] 1 Inflation predicts a near scale-invariant spectrum for the scalar and tensor fluctuations, the former being in reasonable agreement with current observations. Here we explore the predictions for natural models involving a single inflaton at the time the density perturbations are produced. Models with two or more scalar fields affecting the density perturbations require some measure of fine tuning to relate their contribution to the energy density, whereas the single field models avoid this unnatural aspect. In order to characterize the inflationary possibilities in a model independent way it is convenient to expand the inflationary potential about the value of the field φH just at the start of the observable inflation era, ∼ 60 e-folds before the end of inflation when the scalar density perturbation on the scale of our present Hubble radius 1 was generated, and expand in the field φ∗ ≡ φ− φH [5]. Since the potential must be very flat to drive inflation, φ∗ will necessarily be small while the observable density perturbations are produced, so the Taylor expansion of the potential will be dominated by low powers of φ∗: V (φ∗) = V (0) + V ′(0)φ∗ + 1 2 V ′′(0)φ∗2 + . . . (1) The first term V (0) provides the near-constant vacuum energy driving inflation while the φ∗- dependent terms are ultimately responsible for ending inflation, driving φ∗ large until higher- order terms violate the slow-roll conditions. These terms also determine the nature of the density perturbations produced, in particular the departure from a scale-invariant spectrum. The observable features of the primordial density fluctuations can readily be expressed in terms of the coefficients of the Taylor series [5]. It is customary to use these coefficients first to define the slow-roll parameters ǫ and η [6] which must be small during inflation: M 2 V (0) (cid:19)2 2 (cid:18) V ′(0) ǫ ≡ ≪ 1, η ≡ M 2(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) V ′′(0) V (0) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) ≪ 1, (2) where M is the reduced Planck scale, M = 2.44 × 1018 GeV. In terms of these the spectral index is given by (3) ns = 1 + 2η − 6ǫ, the tensor-to-scalar ratio is r = 16ǫ, and the density perturbation at wave number k is Finally the 'running' of the spectral index is given by δ2 H(k) = 1 150π2 V (0) ǫM 4 . where nr ≡ dns d ln k = 16ǫη − 24ǫ2 − 2ξ, ξ ≡ M 4 V ′V ′′′ V 2 . (4) (5) (6) (7) At this stage we have four observables, ns, nr, δH and r and four unknown parameters V (0), V ′(0), V ′′(0) and V ′′′(0) which, for an arbitrary inflation potential, are independent. However for natural potentials these parameters are related, leading to corresponding relations between the observables. Observational confirmation of such relations would provide evidence for the underlying potential, hence crucial clues to the physics behind inflation. 1 Numerically this is H −1 0 ≃ 3000h−1 Mpc, where h ≡ H0/100 km s−1 Mpc−1 ∼ 0.7 is the Hubble parameter. The density perturbation is measured down to ∼ 1 Mpc, a spatial range corresponding to ∼ 8 e-folds of inflation. 2 As discussed above we are considering the class of natural models in which a single inflaton field dominates when the density perturbations relevant to the large-scale structure of the universe today are being produced.2 In classifying "natural" inflation, Boyle et al imposed a set of five conditions [1]: 1. The energy density (scalar) perturbations generated by inflation must have amplitude ∼ 10−5 on the scales that left the horizon ≈ 60 e-folds before the end of inflation; 2. The universe undergoes at least N > 60 e-folds of inflation; 3. After inflation, the field must evolve smoothly to an analytic minimum with V = 0; 4. If the minimum is metastable, then it must be long-lived and V must be bounded from below; 5. Inflation must halt and the universe must reheat without spoiling its large-scale homogeneity and isotropy. They proposed that the level of fine-tuning for potentials satisfying the above conditions should be measured by the integers Zǫ,η that measure the number of zeros that ǫ and η and their derivatives undergo within the last 60 e-folds of inflation [1]. Here we argue that such a measure does not capture the essential character of physical naturalness. At a purely calculational level this is illustrated by the fact that it is necessary to impose an (arbitrary) cut-off on the number of derivatives included in the criterion.3 This is necessary because ǫ and η are defined in terms of the ratio of first or second order derivatives of the potential to the potential itself, so all higher order derivatives must be considered separately when counting the total number of zeros. The difficulty follows from the observation that, as far as naturalness is concerned, it is the inflaton potential that is the primary object, being restricted by the underlying symmetries of the (effective) field theory describing the inflaton dynamics. As stressed by 't Hooft [7], a natural theory is one in which all terms in the Lagrangian allowed by the underlying symmetries of the theory are present, with no relations assumed between terms unrelated by the symmetries. It is important however to note that such natural potentials do not preclude significant contri- butions from unrelated terms. Indeed such contributions are inevitable if, for example, the inflation field is moving from small to large field values. For small field values the lowest allowed power in the inflaton field is likely to be the most important, but at larger field values higher powers will ultimately dominate. For this reason the last four conditions have a different character to the first in that they involve the end of inflation when naturalness does not require that a single term in the inflation potential should dominate. For example in inflationary models with the inflaton rolling from small to large field values, the higher powers can cause the potential to evolve smoothly to an analytic minimum with V = 0 or govern the properties of an unstable minimum. Similarly it may be these higher powers that cause inflation to halt and the universe to reheat without affecting the predictions for the observable density perturbation. Given the freedom there is in choosing these higher powers (non-renormalisable terms in the effective field theory description), it is always possible to find a model in which the end of inflation is satisfactory without violating the natural- ness constraints [5]. On the other hand the range of φ∗ relevant during the production of density perturbations is quite small (corresponding to only 8 of the ∼ 60 e-folds of inflation) and so it is reasonable to suppose that unrelated terms do not simultaneously contribute significantly to the generation of the observed density perturbation. Although we have made this argument in the context of 'new inflation' models where the inflaton field evolves from low to high values, similar 2This does not exclude 'hybrid inflation' models in which additional fields play a role at the end of inflation. 3Boyle et al imposed the cut-off at 15 derivatives (L. Boyle, private communication). 3 considerations apply to the other natural models. For the case where the underlying symmetry is a Goldstone symmetry it is still possible to change the end of inflation in a natural way through the effect of a second 'hybrid' field. Given these considerations we do not need to impose the last four conditions when determining the phenomenological implications of natural inflationary models. However we will comment on how these conditions can indeed be satisfied for the various classes of inflation potential. Our definition of naturalness is the standard one in particle physics [7], viz. pertaining to a potential whose form is guaranteed by a symmetry. This should apply at the time the observable density perturbations are being produced. What form can such natural potentials take? The relevant symmetries that have been identified capable of restricting the scalar inflaton potential are relatively limited. The most direct are Abelian or non-Abelian symmetries, either global or gauge, and continuous or discrete. For a single field inflation model these will either limit the powers of the inflaton field that may appear in the potential or, if the inflaton is a pseudo-Goldstone mode, require a specific form for the potential. Less direct constraints occur in supersymmetric theories where the scalar inflaton field is related to a fermionic partner. In this case chiral symmetries of the associated fermion partner and R-symmetries may further restrict the form of the potential.4 As observed earlier [8], such symmetries are very promising for eliminating the fine-tuning problem in inflationary potentials because they can forbid the large quadratic terms in the inflaton field that, even if absent at tree level, arise in radiative order in non-supersymmetric theories (unless protected by a Goldstone symmetry). We turn now to a discussion of the observable implications of the natural inflation models. In this we find it useful to classify the models into two classes, namely those involving small, sub- Planckian field values only and those that require large, super-Planckian, field values. Here we use the reduced Planck scale, M , to define the sub- and super- regimes as this is the scale that orders typical higher order terms in supergravity. In the small-field models we allow for the possibility of higher order terms which can dominate as the vacuum expectation value of the inflaton field becomes large. In the large field models it is necessary to forbid such higher order terms since they would otherwise dominate the potential and there should be an underlying symmetry to enable this to be done. 1 Small field models These potentials are of the 'new inflation' form V (φ) = ∆4(cid:20)1 − λ(cid:18) φ Λ(cid:19)p(cid:21) , (8) with a single power of the inflaton field, φ, responsible for the variation of the potential, plus a constant term driving inflation. Such a form does not require fine-tuning as the two terms need not be related and the dominance of a given single power can be guaranteed by a symmetry [8]. Since the slow-roll parameters get no contribution from the constant term their main contribution will necessarily come from the leading term involving the inflaton field and the naturalness condition is trivially satisfied because this is dominated by a single power of φ. From Eq.(5) it is clear that δH is the only observable that depends on ∆, so one can fit its observed value but cannot predict 4In supersymmetric theories it is the superpotential that is constrained by the underlying symmetries. The resulting scalar potential has natural relations between different powers of the inflaton field. 4 it without a theory for ∆. The slow-roll parameters are given by , λ2p2 Λ (cid:19)2 η = −λp(p − 1)(cid:18) φH Λ (cid:19)p−2(cid:18) M Λ (cid:19)2p−2(cid:18) M Λ (cid:19)2 Λ (cid:19)2p−4(cid:18) M ξ = λ2p2(p − 1)(p − 2)(cid:18) φH 2 (cid:18) φH = η2 ǫ = , 1 M (cid:19)2 2(p − 1)2 (cid:18)φH Λ (cid:19)4 = η2 (p − 2) (p − 1) (9) (10) (11) . Turning to the other observables let us consider first the cases p ≥ 2. Note that the naturalness arguments apply only if φ/Λ < 1 and hence η > ǫ. In this case ns is effectively determined by η alone, so the measurement of ns does not impose a lower bound on ǫ. Thus the expectation is that r will naturally be small for this class of models [8]. To quantify this we note that η ≃ (1 − ns)/2 hence r = 16ǫ = η2 . (12) 8 M (cid:19)2 (p − 1)2 (cid:18) φH This implies that any value 0.9 . ns . 1 can be obtained. Imposing the bound ns > 0.95 following Boyle et al [1]5 then requires r < 0.005. We emphasise that this makes no explicit reference to the excursion of the field during inflation, as in the 'Lyth bound' [4]. Note that the precise value for r depends here on the value of φH which, as discussed earlier, is determined by the higher order terms that may be present in the potential. Specific examples have been constructed [5] showing that r can be much lower than the bound given above, even as small as 10−16. These results are inconsistent with the lower bound quoted by Boyle et al [1] and reflect our different physical interpretation of naturalness. Finally the prediction for nr is (p − 2) (p − 1) nr ≃ −2ξ ≃ −0.001 (13) . The case p = 1 is special since now η and ξ both vanish giving r = 8(1 − ns)/3 < 0.13 and nr = −2(1 − ns)2/3 ≃ 10−3. This is the only case of a sub-Planckian model yielding a large tensor amplitude and it has been argued [10] that this case cannot be realised in a complete model due to the requirement that the universe should undergo at least ∼ 50 e-folds of inflation. The problem is that for this case ǫ = (1 − ns)/6 is large, limiting the number of e-foldings, which is given by N = 1 M Z φe φH 1 √2ǫ dφ, (14) where φe is the field value at the end of inflation. For sub-Planckian models φe ≤ M , hence N < 1/√2ǫ = p3/(1 − ns). For the case ns = 0.95, which gives the large r value, we have only N < 8 e-folds. In this case the effect of higher order terms near the Planck scale does not help as the linear term already contributes too much to the slope of the potential and thus limits the number of e-folds of inflation. The only way out of this is that there should be a subsequent inflationary era which generates ∼ 40− 50 additional e-folds of inflation after the φ field has settled into its minimum. At first sight this looks like an unnatural requirement. However we have shown elsewhere [11] that in supergravity models it is natural to expect some ∼ 3 ln(M/Λ) e-folds of 'multiple inflation' due to intermediate scale symmetry breaking along 'flat directions', where Λ4 is the magnitude of the potential driving this subsequent period of inflation. Taking Λ ∼ 1011 GeV (typical of the supersymmetry breaking scale in supergravity models) one generates ∼ 50 e-folds of inflation. Although this two-stage inflationary model appears complicated, it is still natural in the sense discussed above and should not be ignored as a possibility. 5This is slightly more restrictive than the recent WMAP 5-year result: ns = 0.963+0.014 −0.015 [9]. 5 2 Large field models 2.1 Chaotic inflation The simplest potential involves a single power of the inflaton V (φ) = λ φp Λp−4 , (15) where we have allowed for the possibility that the scale, Λ, relevant for higher dimensional terms in the effective potential need not be the Planck scale but can correspond to the mass of some heavy states that have been integrated out in forming the effective potential. Expanding around φ = φH yields , p2 ǫ = 2 (cid:18) M φH(cid:19)2 η = p(p − 1)(cid:18) M ξ = p2(p − 1)(p − 2)(cid:18) M φH(cid:19)2 , φH(cid:19)4 (16) (17) (18) . The slow-roll conditions, ǫ,η ≪ 1, requires M/φH ≪ 1 which means that inflation occurs for φ above the Planck scale -- usually called 'chaotic inflation' [12].6 In this case, in order to explain why ever higher order terms φm, m → ∞, do not dominate, it is necessary to have a symmetry which forbids such terms. One such (Goldstone) symmetry has been invoked in a supergravity context [14], although it is not known if this can arise in realistic models. Another recent proposal for a large field potential exploits monodromy in a D-brane setup but contains no Standard Model sector which would give rise to large corrections to the slow-roll parameters [15]. Thus whether such models can actually be realised remains an open question. What are the observable implications of this potential? As before, δH is the only observable that depends on λ so one can fit its observed value but lacking a theory for λ this is not a prediction. The other 3 observables are determined in terms of the parameter x = M/φH and the power p. ns = 1 − x2p(p + 2), r = 8p2x2, nr = −2x4p2(p + 2). (19) (20) (21) From this one sees that the ratio of tensor to scalar fluctuations and the running of the spectral index are tightly constrained by the measurement of ns r = 8p (p + 2) 2 (1 − ns), (1 − ns)2. nr = − (p + 2) (22) (23) Note that these results are independent of φH and so, as anticipated above, do not depend on exactly when inflation ends. For the quartic potential p = 4, r = 0.27 and nr ≃ −8 × 10−4. The maximum value of r is 8(1 − ns) ≃ 0.4 with nr = 0. 6In fact "chaotic" actually refers to the initial conditions for inflation and 'chaotic inflation' can also be realised in a small-field model [13]. 6 2.2 Natural inflation Another class of non-fine-tuned models is based on an approximate Goldstone symmetry [16], often called 'natural inflation' (although it should now be clear that this is not the only natural possibility). In this case the potential is not a simple polynomial but has the form V (φ) = ∆4(cid:18)1 + cos φ f(cid:19) . The slow-roll parameters are: ǫ = 1 2 (cid:18) M f (cid:19)2 η = −(cid:18) M f (cid:19)2 ξ = −(cid:18) M f (cid:19)4 f (cid:17)2 (cid:16)sin φH f (cid:17)2 , (cid:16)1 + cos φH cos φH f f (cid:17) (cid:16)1 + cos φH f (cid:17)2 (cid:16)sin φH f (cid:17)2 . (cid:16)1 + cos φH , (24) (25) (26) (27) For these to be small we require f > M . Unlike the previous case the predictions now depend sensitively on φH and hence on the related value of the field at the end of inflation. If the end of inflation is determined, as has usually been assumed, by the steepening of the above potential then φH has a value such that ǫ and η are comparable. In this case ǫ can be close to its slow-roll limit, particularly interesting for tensor fluctuations which can now be large. Imposing the bound ns > 0.95 [9] implies 0.02 < r < 0.2 [17], the range corresponding to the variation of φH with f for allowed values of f . As with the other models, the running is small, nr ∼ O(10−3). However it may be more natural for inflation to end much earlier due to a second (hybrid) field. Then φH is reduced so that sin(φH/f ) can be small, hence η ≫ ǫ. In this case r will be (arbitrarily) small, being proportional to ǫ, The running is also very small, nr ≃ 12ǫη. 3 Conclusions We have discussed natural possibilities for the inflationary potential. From this it is clear that the gravitational wave signal need not be large enough to be observable as argued by Boyle et al [1]. The models considered fall broadly into two classes. The first has ǫ comparable in magnitude to η hence r can saturate the upper bound of 0.4 implied by the slow-roll constraint. A characteristic of these models however is that inflation occurs only at field values higher than the Planck scale and it is not clear if this can be naturally realised. An interesting exception is the 'new inflation' model with a leading linear term in the inflaton field which however requires a subsequent period of inflation to create our present Hubble volume. The second class of models has η larger than ǫ. These are indeed natural but there is no lower bound to r and the upper bound is (unobservably) small. A characteristic of most such models is that inflation occurs at low field values, much below the Planck scale. Examples of this are provided by 'new inflation' where r is bounded from above by 0.005 and is usually much below this bound. A large-feld exception to this is a modified form of 'natural inflation' where a hybrid field ends inflation early. To summarise, in models that are not fine-tuned, the amplitude of density perturbations and the spectral index are not predicted, being determined by free parameters of the model. However 7 the tensor-to-scalar ratio, r, and the running, nr, are determined in terms of the spectral index. The ratio r provides a sensitive discriminator of the natural models but there is no requirement that it be greater than 0.01 even if the spectral index is bounded from below ns > 0.95.7 All the natural models have the running small, nr ∼ (1− ns)2, so observation of a much larger value would indicate a departure from naturalness, perhaps because more than one inflaton field is active at the time density perturbations are generated. This in turn would suggest there should be a departure from a near-Gaussian distribution of the perturbations. 4 Acknowledgements G.G. acknowledges support from DGAPA, UNAM and the hospitality of the Rudolf Peierls Cen- tre, Oxford. S.S. acknowledges a STFC Senior Fellowship (PP/C506205/1) and the EU network 'UniverseNet' (MRTN-CT-2006-035863). We thank Latham Boyle for helpful correspondance. References [1] L. A. Boyle, P. J. Steinhardt and N. Turok, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006) 111301. [2] D. N. Spergel et al. [WMAP Collaboration], Astrophys. J. Suppl. 148 (2003) 175. [3] G. Efstathiou, arXiv:0712.1513 [astro-ph]. [4] D. H. Lyth, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997) 1861 [5] G. German, G. G. Ross and S. Sarkar, Nucl. Phys. B 608 (2001) 423. [6] A. R. Liddle and D. H. Lyth, Cambridge, UK: Univ. Pr. (2000) 400 p [7] G. 't Hooft, NATO Adv. Study Inst. Ser. B Phys. 59 (1980) 135. [8] G. G. Ross and S. Sarkar, Nucl. Phys. B 461 (1996) 597. [9] G. Hinshaw et al., arXiv:0803.0732 [astro-ph]. [10] L. Alabidi and D. H. Lyth, JCAP 0605 (2006) 016. [11] J. A. Adams, G. G. Ross and S. Sarkar, Nucl. Phys. B 503 (1997) 405. [12] A. D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B 129 (1983) 177. [13] A. D. Linde, Phys. Lett. B 132 (1983) 317. [14] M. Kawasaki, M. Yamaguchi and T. Yanagida, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 (2000) 3572. [15] E. Silverstein and A. Westphal, arXiv:0803.3085 [hep-th] [16] K. Freese, J. A. Frieman and A. V. Olinto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 65 (1990) 3233. [17] K. Freese, W. H. Kinney and C. Savage, arXiv:0802.0227 [hep-ph]. [18] W. H. Kinney, E. W. Kolb, A. Melchiorri and A. Riotto, Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006) 023502. 7 This conclusion is in agreement with another analysis of specific models [18]. 8
astro-ph/0703322	1	0703	2007-03-13T16:42:15	Discovery of a new M32-like "Compact Elliptical" galaxy in the halo of the Abell 496 cD galaxy	[ "astro-ph" ]	Aims: ``Compact ellipticals'' are so rare that a search for M32 analogs is needed to ensure the very existence of this class. Methods: We report here the discovery of A496cE, a M32 twin in the cluster Abell 496, located in the halo of the central cD. Results: Based on CFHT and HST imaging we show that the light profile of A496cE requires a two component fit: a Sersic bulge and an exponential disc. The spectrum of A496cE obtained with the ESO-VLT FLAMES/Giraffe spectrograph can be fit by a stellar synthesis spectrum dominated by old stars, with high values of [Mg/Fe] and velocity dispersion. Conclusions: The capture of A496cE by the cD galaxy and tidal stripping of most of its disc are briefly discussed.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. 7291lett December 14, 2013 c(cid:13) ESO 2013 Letter to the Editor Discovery of a new M32-like “Compact Elliptical ” galaxy in t he halo of the Abell 496 cD galaxy ⋆ I. Chilingarian1,2 , V. Cayatte3 , L. Chemin4 , F. Durret5,1 , T. F. Lagan ´a 6 , C. Adami7 , and E. Slezak8 1 Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, LERMA, UMR 8112, 61 Av. de l’Observatoire, Paris, 75014, France 2 Sternberg Astronomical Institute, Moscow State University, 13 Universitetski prospect, 119992, Moscow, Russia 3 Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, LUTH, UMR 8102, 5 pl. Jules Janssen, Meudon, 92195, France 4 Observatoire de Paris-Meudon, GEPI, UMR 8111, 5 pl. Jules Janssen, Meudon, 92195, France 5 Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris, CNRS, UMR 7095, Universit ´e Pierre et Marie Curie, 98bis Bd Arago, 75014 Paris, Fran ce 6 Instituto de Astronomia, Geof´ısica e C. Atmosf. /USP, R. do Mat ao 1226, 05508-090 S ao Paulo /SP, Brazil 7 Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Marseille, UMR 6110, Traverse du Siphon, 13012 Marseille, France 8 Observatoire de la C ote d’Azur, Laboratoire Cassiop ´ee, U MR 6202, BP 4229, 06304 Nice Cedex 4, France Received March 01, 2007; accepted March 13, 2007; in original form February 13, 2007 ABSTRACT Aims. “Compact ellipticals” are so rare that a search for M32 analo gs is needed to ensure the very existence of this class. Methods. We report here the discovery of A496cE, a M32 twin in the cluster Abell 496, located in the halo of the central cD. Results. Based on CFHT and HST imaging we show that the light profile of A 496cE requires a two component fit: a S ´ersic bulge and an exponential disc. The spectrum of A496cE obtained with the ESO-VLT FLAMES/Giraffe spectrograph can be fit by a stellar synthesis spectrum dominated by old stars, with high values of [Mg/Fe] and velocity dispersion. Conclusions. The capture of A496cE by the cD galaxy and tidal stripping of most of its disc are briefly discussed. Key words. evolution of galaxies – kinematics – stellar populations – d warf galaxies 1. Introduction Compact elliptical galaxies are known to be high surface bright- ness low-luminosity objects like the prototype of this class, M 32, satellite of the Andromeda galaxy. Compared to dwarf ellipticals of same absolute magnitude, the effective surface brightness of M 32 is about 100 times higher and its effective radius is 10 times smaller (Graham 2002). Presently, only fiv e objects belonging to the class of “compact elliptical” gala xies (cE) are known; the four other objects are NGC 4486B (in the vicinity of M 87, the Virgo cluster cD), NGC 5846A (a close satellite of the giant elliptical galaxy NGC 5846), and two ob- jects in the Abell 1689 cluster (Mieske et al. 2005). These ex- tremely rare galaxies are thought to be generated by tidal strip- ping of more massive galaxies (Nieto & Prugniel 1987, Bekki et al. 2001, Choi et al. 2002), but how such a high stellar surface density can be put in the central part of the galaxy is not entirely clear. The structural parameters of M 32 derived by Graham (2002) from the light pro file include a bulge and a low surface brightness disc, indicating that the precursor could be an early type disc galaxy. The evolution in the past of the prototypical cE is however still a matter of debate (see Mieske et al. 2005) and several observational projects aimed at searching for cE galaxies Igor e-mail: Chilingarian to: Send offprint requests [email protected] ⋆ Based on observations obtained at the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (program 03BF12) which is operated by the National Research Council of Canada, the Institut des Sciences de l’Univers of the Centre National de la Recherche Scienti fique and the Univ ersity of Hawaii. Also based on ESO VLT data (program 074.A-0533), and on HST archive data (proposals 5121 and 8683). Fig. 1. HST WFPC2 image of the central region of Abell 496 ( filter F702W). The objects discussed in this Letter are labeled. were conducted until now with no success (Drinkwater & Gregg 1998, Ziegler & Bender 1998). In this Letter we report the discovery of the sixth “com- pact elliptical” galaxy in the cluster Abell 496. We present results based on the analysis of high-resolution spectroscopic data (R=7000 in the 5000 –5800 Å range) obtained with FLAMES/Giraffe (multi-object “MEDUSA” mode) at ESO VLT UT2 in the fall of 2004, combined with a photometric study based on HST WFPC2 direct images in three filters: F555W, F702W, and F814W available through the HST archive. The dis- 2 Chilingarian et al.: cE in the Abell 496 cluster covery has been made from deep ground-based u* g’ r’ i’ imag- ing conducted at CFHT with Megacam in the fall of 2003 and dedicated to obtain morphological and structural properties of dwarf early type galaxies in Abell 496. Detailed informations on spectroscopic and photometric observations as well as data re- duction will be provided in a forthcoming paper discussing the whole sample of galaxies. For the Abell 496 cluster we adopt the distance modulus 35.70 and spatial scale 0.627 kpc arcsec−1 , assuming H0 = 73 km s−1 , ΩM = 0.27, and ΩΛ = 0.73. All the photometric measurements discussed in this Letter are corrected for Galactic absorption according to Schlegel et al. (1998), and redshift ef- fect (K -correction) assuming an early-type galaxy spectrum. A cosmological surface brightness dimming correction has been applied with the cluster velocity, corrected for infall of the Local Group towards Virgo taken equal to 9707 km s−1 . 2. Properties of the newly discovered object The galaxy is listed in HyperLeda1 as PGC 3084811 (Paturel et al. 2003). However, this name cannot be resolved by other pub- lic astronomical databases (NED, SIMBAD), therefore we adopt the IAU recommended name, ACO496J043337.35-131520.2 and will refer to it hereafter as “A496cE ”. A496cE is located 22 arcsec (14 kpc in projected distance) from the cluster centre; it appears in projection on the outer parts of the central cD galaxy (see Fig. 1). The background (i.e. the cD halo) has been subtracted from the HST images using a multiscale wavelet analysis and reconstruction technique de- scribed e.g. by Adami et al. 2005. The cD halo surface brightness at the region where A496cE resides is about 24 mag arcsec−2 in the B band and has a significant gradient, therefore correct background estimation is crucial for the surface photometry of A496cE. Elliptical isophotes with free central position, elliptic- ity and position angle have been fitted to the images of A496cE using the IRAF ELLIPSE task. On the r’ image, the position an- gle changes notably and the ellipticity rises from about 0.05 to 0.1 between 1.8 and 2.6 arcsec. We have combined the HST light pro files for the inner part of the galaxy (rad iu s <3.5 arcsec) with the deeper r’ band CFHT photometry for the outer parts (rad iu s >3.5 arcsec), where the seeing (FWHM=0.8 arcsec) does not play an important role. The empirical normalization factor for the r’ pro file has been de rived from the best match of the two pro files between 2 and 4 arcsec. We have fit the 1-dimensional surface brightness pro file us- ing both a S ´ersic and a S ´ersic + exponential disc model (see Graham 2002 and Graham & Guzm ´an 2003) with a free constant background level within 10 arcsec from the galaxy centre. As in the case of M 32 (Graham 2002), a single-component S ´ersic pro file does not fit accurately the light pro file and an exponen tial disc is needed. Fig. 2 and Table 1 present the surface brightness pro file of A496cE and the best- fitting results of the photomet ric decomposition of the pro file. An unsharp masking technique with elliptical blurring (Lisker et al. 2006), shown to be very sensitive to the presence of possible embedded structures, reveals no structures either on HST or on CFHT images. We have built F555W-F702W and F555W-F814W colour maps using the Voronoi adaptive binning technique (Cappellari & Copin 2003) to achieve minimal signal-to-noise ratios of 20 per bin in the F814W image and 40 in F702W. No colour gra- dient is detected. However, this should not be considered as a 1 http://leda.univ-lyon1.fr/ Fig. 2. Best fitting two-component S ´ersic +disc pro file overplot- ted on the composite light pro file (F555 and r’). Bulge and dis c components are shown as dash-dotted blue and dashed green lines respectively. Table 1. Global parameters (luminosity, radial velocity, cen- tral velocity dispersion) and best- fitting parameters for t he one- component (S ´ersic) or two-component model (S ´ersic +disc) of the light pro files of A496cE, A496g1, and A496g2 in B band. Data for M 32 are taken from van der Marel et al. (1998), Graham (2002), and for NGC 4486B from Ferrarese et al. (2006) and HyperLeda. MB,tot v km/s σ0 km/s MB,b Re,b kpc µ0,b nb µe < µ >e MB,d Re,d kpc µ0,d A496cE -16.79 9747±1 104±2 -16.60 0.24 17.37 1.29 19.82 18.00 -14.80 0.92 22.55 A496g1 -17.32 10286±3 145±3 -17.32 0.66 18.70 1.35 21.30 20.44 n/a n/a n/a A496g2 -17.91 9948±1 79±1 -17.91 0.96 17.79 1.94 21.65 20.63 n/a n/a n/a M 32 -15.85 -197±15 76±10 -15.34 0.10 16.31 1.5 19.23 18.34 -14.78 0.84 22.28 N4486B -16.63 1557±35 170±4 -16.63 0.18 14.00 2.73 19.58 18.39 n/a n/a n/a certain evidence for the uniform distribution of stellar popula- tion parameters with radius. For instance, for M 32 the effects of age and metallicity gradients on the V − I colour exactly com- pensate each other, resulting in a flat colour pro file (Rose et al. 2005). We have analysed the spectrum of A496cE using the novel stellar population fitting technique described in det ail in Chilingarian (2006) and Chilingarian et al. (2007). By fitti ng the spectrum with high-resolution models of simple stellar pop- ulations (SSP) computed with PEGASE.HR (Le Borgne et al. 2004), we are able to extract simultaneously stellar kinematics: v, σ, and stellar population parameters such as SSP-equivalent age and metallicity. Although some template mismatch is seen due to the supersolar [α/F e] in A496cE, the quality of the fit is rather good (χ2 /DOF = 1.6). We have obtained the α/Fe abundance ratio of the stellar pop- ulation by measuring the following absorption line-strength in- dices (Worthey et al. 1994): Mgb, Fe5270 , and Fe5335 using the α-enhanced models by Thomas et al. (2003). The kinematical parameters are given in Table 1 and those of the stellar pop- ulations in Table 2. A496cE has a rather high velocity disper- sion for its luminosity. It resides above the sequence of ellip- Chilingarian et al.: cE in the Abell 496 cluster 3 Table 2. Stellar population parameters of A496cE, A496g1, and A496g2 compared to M 32 and NGC 4486B (S ´anchez-Bl ´azquez et al. 2006). Comma-separated values for M 32 correspond to the parameters at the core and at one effective radius as given by Rose et al. (2005). A496cE A496g1 A496g2 M 32 N4486B t, Gyr 16.4±1.9 15.3±2.8 13.1±2.0 4.0, 7.0 9.5 Z , dex -0.04±0.02 -0.19±0.03 -0.43±0.03 0.00, -0.25 0.4 [Mg/Fe] 0.19±0.07 0.43±0.09 0.28±0.08 -0.25, -0.08 0.3 Fig. 3. Faber–Jackson relation for ellipticals and bulges of disc galaxies. Giant and intermediate-luminosity ellipticals are in blue, bulges of disc galaxies in red, dwarf ellipticals and lenticu- lars in black. The upper end of the arrow representing M 32 cor- responds to the HST STIS measurements (Joseph et al. 2001), and the filled circle represents the value obtained from earl ier HST FOS data (van der Marel et al. 1998), which was in agree- ment with more recent ground-based observations. tical galaxies on the Faber-Jackson (1976) relation, shown in Fig. 3, presenting a compilation of data for dwarf (Geha et al. 2003; van Zee et al. 2004; De Rijcke et al. 2005), intermedi- ate luminosity, and giant elliptial galaxies and bulges of bright lenticulars (Bender et al. 1992). Due to the aperture size of the FLAMES/Giraffe fibre our velocity dispersion for A496cE nearly corresponds to the effective velocity dispersion and the central value is probably significantly higher. The propert ies of A496cE, such as metallicity and Mg/Fe ratio are similar to those of bulges of moderate-luminosity lenticulars and spirals. The age and metallicity of A496cE correspond to a stellar mass-to-light ratio (M/L)∗,B = 19 ± 2 (M/L)⊙ (value for the PEGASE.HR SSP computed with Salpeter IMF). Thus, the derived stellar mass of A496cE is (1.7 ± 0.4) · 1010 M⊙ . 3. Discussion 3.1. Comparisonwith otherE, dE,and cE galaxies The very small effective radius, about 250 pc, high mean sur- face brightness, µBe = 19.60 mag arcsec−2 , and dwarf luminos- ity (MB = −16.96 mag) put the bulge of A496cE on the con- tinuation of the sequence of giant ellipticals and bulges in the Kormendy (Kormendy 1977) and MB − µeff diagrams toward small effective radii and fainter luminosities. Fig. 4 presents the updated versions of Figs. 9a,g from Graham & Guzm ´an (2003): absolute B magnitude and effective radius Re versus mean B sur- Fig. 4. Structural properties of elliptical galaxies and bulges. Giant and intermediate-luminosity ellipticals, power-law and core galaxies are shown in blue, bulges of disc galaxies in red, dwarf ellipticals and lenticulars in black. We keep the original morphological classification (E / dE) for the data points com- ing from the Virgo Cluster ACS Survey, Caon et al. (1993), and D’Onofrio et al. (1994), therefore they appear both in blue and black. face brightness within effective radius < µ >e . The plot contains only data for elliptical galaxies and bulges of lenticulars/spirals (where bulge/disc decomposition has been made in the origi- nal sources), all integrated measurements for S galaxies have been excluded. Data in computer-readable format for dE and E galaxies from Binggeli & Jerjen (1998), Caon et al. (1993), D’Onofrio et al. (1994), Faber et al. (1997), Graham & Guzm ´a n (2003), Stiavelli et al. (2001) and homogenization algorithms for these datasets have been kindly provided by A. Graham. We also included: photometric parameters of E and dE/dS0 galax- ies from the Virgo Cluster ACS Survey (Ferrarese et al. 2006), photometric data on giant, intermediate elliptical galaxies and bulges of spirals and lenticulars from Bender et al. (1992), pho- tometric parameters of the S ´ersic component of M 32 (Graham 2002), and data for 430 elliptical galaxies from the HyperLeda database, with radial velocities below 10000 km s−1 and brighter than MB = −18.0 mag. All the measurements are corrected for Galactic absorption, cosmological dimming, K-correction, and converted into B band according to Fukugita et al. (1995) as- suming an elliptical galaxy SED. Re flecting structural properties of elliptical galaxies, g iants and dwarfs reside in different regions of these diagrams. The se- quence formed by giant elliptical galaxies and bulges of spirals is clearly extended towards smaller effective radii / higher surface brightnesses by M 32 and NGC 4486B. A496cE resides very close to NGC 4486B in both plots. Thus, we can conclude that the structural properties of the A496cE bulge resemble those of elliptical galaxies and bulges of spirals and lenticulars. However 4 Chilingarian et al.: cE in the Abell 496 cluster the bulges of M 32 and A496cE lie in a region where no other object is found, indicating that they differ from normal bulges. We have chosen S0 galaxies from the sample of Sil’chenko (2006), with velocity dispersion and stellar population param- eters coinciding with the values for A496cE: NGC 3098 (σ = 105 km s−1 , [Fe/H] = −0.2, t = 10 Gyr), and NGC 4379 (σ = 108 km s−1 , [Fe/H] = 0.0, t = 15 Gyr). Their B luminosi- ties (MB = −18.9, −18.6, HyperLeda) are about two magnitudes higher than that of A496cE. Assuming a bulge-to-disc ratio of 1:1 by mass for early-type galaxies, this implies that if the pro- genitor of A496cE was an intermediate-luminosity disc galaxy, with its disc completely stripped by harassment, it must have lost at least 2/3 of its bulge mass. We now compare the properties of A496cE with two galaxies of our spectroscopic sample in the WFPC2 field: ACO496J043338.22-131500.7 and ACO496J043332.07- 131518.1 (PGC 93410), hereafter A496g1 and A496g2 respectively. The light pro file of A496g1 is well fitted with a single S ´ersic component law. We can also fit the A496g2 pro file with a single component model, though a faint disc in t he external part may also be present, as discussed in a forthcoming paper. For both objects the effective radii are several times larger than for A496cE, while the luminosities do not differ strongly. The metallicity and velocity dispersion of A496g2 are not higher than expected for an object of such a luminosity, but the [Mg/Fe] ratio is very high, indicating a very short star formation period (see e.g. Matteucci, 1994). Gas might have been expelled by ram pressure, efficient in the central parts of rich clusters (see e.g. Abadi et al. 1999), so star formation was abruptly terminated. For A496g1 the overall metallicity is ∼0.2 dex higher than expected for its luminosity, but the [Mg/Fe] ratio and velocity dispersion are exceptionally high (see Fig. 3), so this galaxy is closer to an intermediate-luminosity elliptical or S0 galaxy with MB ≈ −19 mag. The old ages of the stellar populations of A496cE, A496g1, and A496g2 prove that none of these objects merged with galaxies having young stellar populations or star- formation during the last 10 Gyr, an indirect evidence for their habitation in the centre of Abell 496 since that epoch. 3.2. Possible origin ofA496cE The presence of an outer exponential disc in A496cE argues that this galaxy should not be considered as purely elliptical. Lisker et al. (2007) have proposed that only nucleated dwarf ellipticals follow the classical spheroid picture and a large number of dEs in Virgo could be shaped like thick discs and formed from mass loss from bigger infalling galaxies. However A496cE did not fol- low the same evolutionary path as the three peculiar subclasses of dwarfs described by Lisker et al., since its properties provide decisive evidence that this object is quite unique. Block et al. (2006) have simulated a head-on collision of Andromeda with a low mass companion, now observed as M 32. Their numerical simulations show that a fraction of M 32 gets stripped on a timescale of a few 107 years. Under certain cir- cumstances if the disc galaxy is stripped starting from its outer parts, the overall potential becomes shallower and the bulge may shrink, leading to a smaller object. A496cE is observed very close to the cluster centre. If it has a short-period orbit partially immersed in the cD halo, consecutive passages should lead to a relatively fast and efficient stripping. The old stellar population of A496cE indicates that the main part of the disc was stripped long ago. But how could such an object survive for about 10 Gyr very close to the cD galaxy without being accreted by it? The two aspects that rule the processes of galaxy mergers are: (1) dynamical friction, decreasing the orbit size and causing an accreting object to pass closer and closer to the centre of the cluster; and (2) tidal forces, which can totally disrupt an object if it passes sufficiently close to the cD galaxy. The bulge of A496cE is very compact and dense, thus it must be rather resistant to tidal disruption. Its exponential pro- file shows no evidence for truncation beyond the tidal radius of A496cE rtid ∼ 2 kpc. We assume a pericentral distance d p = 14 kpc, i.e. that A496cE is passing near its pericentre now with an orbital plane orthogonal to the line of sight. This is possibly the case, because the radial velocity of A496cE differs from that of the cD by only 100 km s−1 . Assuming a mass of ∼ 1013 M⊙ for the cD, the pericentral velocity is v ≈ 2000 km s−1 . The dy- M2 ρ namical friction is ∼ . Given that A496cE is 4-6 times more v2 massive (assuming the same dark matter fraction) than M 32 (≈ 3.0 · 109M⊙ ), the orbital velocity 10 times higher, and halo densities are comparable, the dynamical friction force is 3 –4 times less efficient for A496cE than for M 32. Therefore, there is a good chance for A496cE to survive for billions of years in the central region of the cluster. Its progenitor must have lost a large fraction of its mass during the first passage in order to decre ase significantly the dynamical friction e ffects. The high metallic- ity and supersolar [Mg/Fe] ratio are additional arguments for its massive progenitor origin. Acknowledgements. Special thanks to Alister Graham and Franc¸ oise Combes for fruitful discussions and to the anonymous referee for his/her fast and care- ful report and useful suggestions. This Letter was inspired by the panel discus- sion ”What is the relationship between compact ellipticals (such as M32) and more massive ellipticals ” at IAU Symposium 241. We thank the CFHT team for service observing and the Terapix team for reducing our Megacam data. This paper has made use of the HST archive and of the NED and HyperLeda data bases. IC acknowledges support provided by the “HORIZON ” pr oject, INTAS YS Fellowship (04-83-3618) and bilateral Russian-Flemmish grant RFBR-05- 02-19805-MF a. References Abadi M., Moore B., Bower R.G. 1999, MNRAS 308, 947 Adami C., Slezak E., Durret F. et al. 2005, A&A 429, 39 Bekki K., Couch W., Drinkwater M., Gregg M. 2001, ApJ, 557, L39 Bender R., Burstein D., Faber S. M. 1992, ApJ 399, 462 Binggeli B. & Jerjen H. 1998, A&A, 333, 17 Block D. L., Bournaud F., Combes F. et al. 2006, Nature 443, 832 Caon N., Capaccioli M., D’Onofrio M. 1993, MNRAS, 265, 1013 Cappellari M.& Copin Y. 2003, MNRAS, 342, 345 Chilingarian I. 2006, PhD Thesis, astro-ph/0611893 Chilingarian I., Prugniel P., Sil’chenko O., Afanasiev V. 2007, MNRAS in press, astro-ph/0701842 Choi P., Guhathakurta P., Johnston K. 2002, AJ, 124, 310 De Rijcke S., Michielsen D., Dejonghe H., Zeilinger W. W., Hau G. K. T. 2005, A&A, 438, 491 D’Onofrio M., Capaccioli M., Caon N. 1994, MNRAS 271, 523 Drinkwater M. J. & Gregg M. D. 1998, MNRAS, 296, L15 Faber S. M., Jackson R. E. 1976, ApJ, 204, 668 Faber S. M., Tremaine S., Ajhar E.A. et al. 1997, AJ 114, 1771 Ferrarese L., C ot ´e P., Jord ´an A. et al. 2006, ApJS 164, 334 Fukugita M., Shimasaku K., Ichikawa T. 1995, PASP 107, 945 Geha M., Guhathakurta P., van der Marel R. P., 2003, AJ, 126, 1794 Graham A. 2002, ApJ 568, L13 Graham A. & Guzm ´an R. 2003, AJ 125, 2936 Joseph C. L., Merritt D., Olling R. et al. 2001, ApJ, 550, 668 Kormendy J. 1977, ApJ 218, 333 Le Borgne D., Rocca-Volmerange B., Prugniel P. et al. 2004, A&A 425, 881 Lisker T., Grebel E.K., Binggeli B. 2006, AJ 132, 497 Lisker T., Grebel E.K., Binggeli B., Glatt K. 2007, astro-ph/0701429 Matteucci F., 1994, A&A, 288, 57 Mieske S., Infante L., Hilker M. et al. 2005, A&A 430, L25 Chilingarian et al.: cE in the Abell 496 cluster 5 Nieto J.-L. & Prugniel P. 1987, A&A 186, 30 Paturel G., Petit C., Prugniel P. et al. 2003, A&A 412, 45 Rose J.A., Arimoto N., Caldwell N. et al. 2005, AJ 129, 712 S ´anchez-Bl ´azquez P., Gorgas J., Cardiel N., Gonz ´alez J. 2006, A&A 457, 809 Schlegel D.J., Finkbeiner D.P., Davis M. 1998, ApJ 500, 525 Sil’chenko O. K. 2006, ApJ 641, 229 Stiavelli M. Miller B.W., Ferguson H.C. et al. 2001, AJ 121, 1385 Thomas D., Maraston C., Bender R. 2003, MNRAS 339, 897 van der Marel R.P., Cretton N., de Zeeuw P.T., Rix H.-W. 1998, ApJ, 493, 613 van Zee L., Skillman E., Haynes M. 2004, AJ, 128, 121 Worthey G., Faber S. M., Gonz ´alez J.J., Burstein D. 1994, Ap JS 94, 687 Ziegler B. L. & Bender R. 1998, A&A 330, 819
astro-ph/0308155	1	0308	2003-08-09T09:13:04	Constrained Simulations of the Magnetic Field in the Local Supercluster and the Propagation of UHECR	[ "astro-ph" ]	Magnetic fields (MF) in the Local Supercluster (LSC) of galaxies may have profound consequences for the propagation of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECR). Faraday rotations measurements provide some informations about MF in compact clusters. However, very few is known about less dense regions and about the global structure of MF in the LSC. In order to get a better knowledge of these fields we are performing constrained magnetohydrodynamical simulations of the LSC magnetic field. We will present the results of our simulation and discuss their implications for the angular distribution of expected UHECR deflections.	astro-ph	astro-ph	The 28th International Cosmic Ray Conference 1 Constrained Simulations of the Magnetic Field in the Local Supercluster and the Propagation of UHECR Klaus Dolag1, Dario Grasso2, Volker Springel3 and Igor Tkachev4 (1) Dipartimento di Astronomia, Universit`a di Padova, Padua, Italy (2) Scuola Normale Superiore, Pisa - Italy (3) Max-Planck-Institut fur Astrophysik, Garching, Germany (4) CERN - Theory Division, Geneve, Switzerland Abstract Magnetic fields (MF) in the Local Supercluster (LSC) of galaxies may have profound consequences for the propagation of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECR). Faraday rotations measurements provide some informations about MF in compact clusters. However, very few is known about less dense regions and about the global structure of MF in the LSC. In order to get a better knowledge of these fields we are performing constrained magnetohydrodynamical simulations of the LSC magnetic field. We will present the results of our simulation and discuss their implications for the angular distribution of expected UHECR deflections. 1. Introduction Several arguments suggest that Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECR) are extragalactic in origin (see e.g.[1]). Propagation of electrically charged CR primaries is affected by intergalactic MF. Resulting picture crucially depends on magnetic field mean intensity and power spectrum. MF have been observed in several clusters of galaxies [7]. An indisputable evidence of these fields is provided by diffuse cluster-wide synchrotron emission from several clusters compatible with a field strength larger than 0.1 µG. In addition, indirect observational evidence of the magnetization of the Inter Cluster Medium (ICM) comes from Faraday Rotation Measurements (RM) of the polarized radio sources located within or behind the clusters. Analyzing these observations several authors (see e.g. [3]) found that the ICM in clusters are permeated with a high filling factor by magnetic fields at a level of 1 −10 µG with a correlation length of 10÷100 kpc extending up to 1 Mpc from the cluster center. Beyond this distance the IGM density becomes too low to allow an observable Faraday rotation since the effect is proportional to the free electron density. In this case only upper bounds are available which are B < 10−9 ÷ 10−8 G in unclustered regions and a significantly weaker upper limit B < ∼ 10−6 in the sheets or the filaments of galaxy clusters [2]. What is most pp. 1 -- 4 c(cid:13)2003 by Universal Academy Press, Inc. 2 crucial for UHECR reaching the Earth is the MF in the Local Supercluster (LSC) since it comprise most of the GZK volume. The MF structure of the LSC is very poorly known. RM allowed to determine its intensity only in some overdense regions like the Virgo cluster where it was found to be about 10−6 G. A method to determine the power spectrum of IGMF from a systematic analysis of RM of a large number of distance sources may allow a better knowledge of the LSCMF in a not too distant future [5]. Meanwhile, however, the only way to improve our understanding of UHECR observational data is to estimate the LSCMF large scale structure by numerical simulations. 2. MHD simulations in clusters Magneto Hydrodynamical (MHD) simulations of MF evolution in galaxy clusters have been already performed by one of us (KD) and collaborators [4]. This kind of codes combines the merely gravitational interaction of a dominant dark-matter (DM) component with the hydrodynamics of a magnetized gas to simulate the formation of magnetized galaxy clusters. Initial conditions are spec- ified at redshift zin ∼ 20 by a random choice of density perturbations compatible with standard ΛCDM cosmology and an initial seed field to be tuned to repro- duce RM of clusters at redshift close to zero. The MF is amplified by adiabatic compression during cluster collapse and, more efficiently, by the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability where merger events give rise to strong shear flows. It was found that the simulation reproduce quite well the general features of the observed RM with an initial field strength of ∼ 5×10−9 G. In the outer regions of the clusters, the av- erage field strength follows the gas density profile quite well though with a steeper slope compared to estimates based on flux conservation and adiabatic compres- sion (B ∝ ρ2/3 gas ), showing that shear flow have to play an important role there. As a consequence the required initial intensity of the MF is smaller than expectation based on a mere adiabatic amplification. The MHD simulations are designed to study individual clusters within a cosmological environment, and therefore can not describe voids or filaments. Nevertheless an order of magnitude estimate can be obtained on the basis of the following simple argument. In the voids, as well as in low density regions around the LG, we do expect the adiabatic compression to give a rather good description of the MF evolution. Using flux conservation, which implies B(z = 0) = B(zin)(1+zin)−2, we see that a field strength of 5×10−9 G at zin = 20, as required for the MHD simulations to reproduce RM of clusters, corresponds to the present time intensity of B(z = 0) ∼ 10−11 G in the unclus- terized IGM. The rms deflection angle of a particle of charge Ze traveling over the distance d through an irregular MF with a coherence length lc ≪ d and local intensity B is given by the expression θ(E, d) ≃ 1o Z 1020 eV E ! d 10 Mpc!1/2 lc 1 Mpc!1/2 3 (1) (cid:18) B 10−9 G(cid:19) . It is clear that a MF with strength ∼ 10−11 G have a negligible influence on UHECR propagation. Therefore we expect significant deflections only when UHECR trajectory crosses cluster or a strongly magnetized filament. In that case deflection of few degrees can be produced (see Fig.1). A different situation was examined recently by Sigl at al. [9]. The authors of [9] performed an Eulerian hydro+N-body simulation of the entire LSC and added to it a MF which follows passively the gas. Such simulation, however, is not a constrained simulation (see below) which implies that it is not suited to reproduce the real spatial distri- bution of matter and of magnetic fields. In [9] the authors chosen the observer position to lie in a region with a rather strong magnetization B ∼ 0.1µG. This was required in order to reproduce the observed isotropy in the arrival directions of UHECR under the hypothesis that the source distribution trace that of the matter in the LSC. Such an hypothesis, however, has not been proved so far and other reasonable possibilities have been discussed in the literature. In our opin- ion the assumption of a widely extended MF with intensity around 10−7 G in the surrounding of the LG is unrealistic. Indeed the LG lie in a quite peripherical region of the LSC and it is neither within a rich cluster nor within a strongly radio emitting region. So far these are the only extended systems where observational evidence of MF with strength comparable or larger than 0.1 µG have been found. 3. Constrained simulation in the LSC Realistic maps of expected UHECR deflections by EGMF as a function of distance to plasuable sources are highly desirable. Ideally, such maps should reflect obsreved distribution of galaxies and clusters and therefore different kind of simulations is needed. A promising approach is that of constrained simulations, i.e. simulations with initial conditions constrained to reproduce the observed large-scale structures in the nearby universe. Simulations of this kind have been already performed for the collisionless DM and the gaseous components of the LSC (see e.g.[6,8]) which succeed to recover the main observed structures starting from initial conditions at high redshift compatible with standard cosmology. We are now working to produce a fully MHD constrained simulation of the LSC. Our code incorporates the MSPH technique [4], which was developed to follow MF evolution in simulated galaxy clusters, into a constrained N-body simulation of the DM and the gas in the LSC. Hopefully, at the end we will have simulated 3D maps resembling real local structure of MF fields. Once we will be in possession of such maps we will trace UHECR trajectories through the magnetic web. We will not limit ourselves by UHECRs sources located inside the LSC. Deflection angle vs direction on the sky 4 n o i t a n i l c e D 80 60 40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 -80 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Right Ascension Fig. 1. Deflection angle as a function of the direction. 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 In particular, we are interested to find out if and when correlations of charged UHECR with BL Lacs, found in Ref. [10], are compartible with expected EGMF structure. In other words, one of our main goals is to produce maps of expected UHECR deflections for a wide range of source distances. We will present detailed results of our simulation in the course of ICRC2003. We provide here a sample of our simulation. Fig. 1 represents a map of deflections of protons with energy E = 4 × 1019 eV derived from a Virgo like cluster, seen from 5 Mpc. The MF intensity at the cluster center corresponds to ∼ 1 µG which is representative of a clusterized region. Rays have been propagated about 10-15 Mpc in each direction. Deflections larger than 5 degrees are cut at this value to increase dynamical range of the plot for small deflections. Bibliography 1. Berezinsky V., Gazizov A. Z. and Grigorieva S. I., arXiv:astro-ph/0210095 2. Blasi P., S. Burles S. and A. V. Olinto A.V. 1999, Astrophys. J. 514, L79 3. Clarke T.E., Kronberg P.P. and Boehringer H. 2001, Astrop. J. 547, L111 4. Dolag K., Bartelmann M. and Lesch H., 2002, A&A 387, 383 5. Kolatt T., 1998, Astrophys. J. 495, 564 6. Kravtsov A.V., Klypin A.A. and Hoffman Y., 2002, Astrop.J., 571, 563 7. Kronberg P.P., 1994, Rep. Prog. Phys. 57, 325 8. Mathis H. et al., 2002, MNRAS, 333, 739 9. Sigl G., Miniati F. and Ensslin T., arXiv:astro-ph/0302388 10. Tinyakov P.G. and Tkachev I.I. 2002, Astropart. Phys. 18, 165
astro-ph/0105459	2	0105	2001-08-28T16:20:09	Relativistic fine structure and resonance effects in electron-ion recombination and excitation of (e + C IV)	[ "astro-ph", "physics.atom-ph" ]	Relativistic close coupling calculations are reported for unified electronic recombination of (e + C IV) including non-resonant and resonant recombination processes, radiative and dielectronic recombination (RR and DR). Detailed comparison of the theoretical unified results with two recent experiments on ion storage rings (Mannervik etal. [1] and Schippers etal. [2]) shows very good agreement in the entire measured energy region 2s -- 2p with 2pnl resonances. The results benchmark theory and experiments to uncertainties of ~15%, and show that the resonant and the background cross sections are not an incoherent sum of separate RR and DR contributions. The limiting values of the DR cross sections, as n ---> infinity, are shown to correspond to those due to electron impact excitation (EIE) at the 2Po_(1/2,3/2) fine structure thresholds, delineated for the first time. The near-threshold 2s 2S_(1/2) - 2p 2Po_(1/2,3/2) EIE cross sections are also compared with recent experimental measurements. The demonstrated threshold fine structure and resonance effects should be of general importance in excitation and recombination of positive ions.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Relativistic fine structure and resonance effects in electron-ion recombination and excitation of (e + C IV) Anil K. Pradhan, Guo Xin Chen, Sultana N. Nahar Department of Astronomy, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210 Applied Physics Division, Los Alamos national Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87544 (October 24, 2018) Hong Lin Zhang Relativistic close coupling calculations are reported for unified electronic recombination of (e + C IV) including non-resonant and resonant recombination processes, radiative and dielec- tronic recombination (RR and DR). Detailed comparison of the theoretical unified results with two recent experiments on ion storage rings (Mannervik et al. [1] and Schippers et al. [2]) shows very good agreement in the entire measured energy region 2s -- 2p with 2pnℓ resonances. The results benchmark theory and experiments to uncertainties of ∼15%, and show that the resonant and the background cross sections are not an incoherent sum of separate RR and DR contributions. The limiting values of the DR cross sections, as n → ∞, are shown to correspond to those due to electron impact excitation (EIE) at the 2P o 1/2,3/2 fine structure thresholds, delineated for the first time. The near-threshold 2s2S1/2 − 2p2P o 1/2,3/2 EIE cross sections are also compared with recent experimental measurements. The demonstrated threshold fine structure and resonance effects should be of general importance in excitation and recombination of positive ions. PACS number(s): 34.80.Kw, 32.80.Dz, 32.80.Fb Although (e + ion) recombination has long been studied experimentally and theoretically, there appears to be con- siderable uncertainty over comparisons between measurements and theory, even for expectedly simple atomic systems such as C IV [1,2]. A comparison of the experimental (e + C IV) DR rates with theoretical data shows disagreement up to orders of magnitude [2]. However, as demonstrated by Mannervik et al. [1], using the ion storage ring CRYRING in Stockholm, there are complicated physical effects such as near-threshold fine structure resonances with unexpect- edly large autoionization widths. Theoretically therefore, it is essential to account for both the relativistic and the complex electron correlation and resonance effects accurately. While experiments measure the combined cross section for (e + ion) recombination, via the resonances and the background (since there is no natural separation between the two), they are still considered individually as dielectronic and radiative recombination (DR and RR) respectively. Apparently there are difficulties in measuring the non-resonant background at very low energies, possibly owing to external field effects [2]. But practical applications generally require (e + ion) rate coefficients, which in turn require cross sections for both RR and DR at all relevant energies. To that end a theoretical method has been developed for an ab initio unified treatment of both processes, based on the close coupling (CC) approximation and its relativistic extension, the Breit-Pauli R-matrix (BPRM) method (e.g. [3 -- 8]). The BPRM (e + ion) recombination cross sections for several ions have been compared with experiments, with excellent agreement in all cases [9]. It is therefore of interest to apply the BPRM method to elucidate the physical effects and issues related to (e + C IV) recombination, in direct comparison with experimental data [1,2]. Dielectronic recombination (DR) is also naturally linked to electron impact excitation (EIE). At the Rydberg series limit, as n −→ ∞ (where the RR background is negligible), the photon flux in DR should in principle equal the electron scattering flux at threshold (E = 0), in accordance with Unitarity [10,6]. Threshold fine structure would however give rise to related structure in the DR and EIE cross sections. In this Letter we present theoretical calculations based on the relativistic CC method to demonstrate that: (i) the theoretical results for (e + ion) recombination agree with both ion storage ring measurements [1,2] to within experimental uncertainties, including near-threshold resonance strengths and non-resonant background, and (ii) fine structure resonance series and threshold effects in DR below the EIE threshold, that should be of general importance but have not heretofore been studied. The coupled-channel wavefunction expansion for an (e + C IV) may be expressed as Ψ(E; e + C IV ) = X i χi(C IV )θi(e) + X j cjΦj(C III), (0.1) where the Ψ denote both the bound (E < 0) and the continuum (E > 0) states of C III, expanded in terms of the core ion eigenfunctions χi(C IV); the Φj are correlation functions. The CC approximation, using the efficient R-matrix method and its relativistic Breit-Pauli extension [12,13], enables a solution for the total Ψ, with a suitable expansion over the χi. The extention of the BPRM formulation to unified electronic recombination [6 -- 8] entails the 1 following. Resonant and non-resonant electronic recombination takes place into an infinite number of bound levels of the (e + ion) system. These are divided into two groups: (A) the low-n (n ≤ no ≈ 10) levels, considered via detailed CC calculations for photorecombination, with highly resolved delineation of autoionizing resonances, and (B) the high-n (no ≤ n ≤ ∞) recombining levels via DR, neglecting the background. In previous works (e.g. [6]) it has been shown that the energy region corresponding to (B), below thresholds for DR, the non-resonant contribution is negligible. The DR cross sections converge on to the electron impact excitation cross section at threshold (n→ ∞, as required by unitarity, i.e. conservation of photon and electron fluxes. This theoretical limit is an important check on the calculations, and may also be used to show precisely the behavior of the resonances in DR fine structure cross sections as they approach and cross the fine structure thresholds towards the EIE cross section, as shown in this work. The BPRM calculations for (e + C IV) recombination involve photorecombination into 212 low-n levels of C III, up to ν ≤ 10.0 (ν is the effective quantum number), and all SLJ symmetries with J = 0 -- 10 (112 even parity levels and 110 odd parity levels). In the high-n energy region, 10 < ν ≤ ∞, the background (RR-type) contribution to (e + ion) recombination is negligible. We calculate DR cross sections σDR due to the resonance series 2P o 3/2nℓ approaching the two fine structure thresholds 2P o 1/2,3/2, and in between. Both the detailed σDR and the resonance averaged < σDR > [10,6] are computed. Finally, the EIE cross sections σEIE are computed at the 2P o 1/2,3/2 thresh- olds and above. Details of the calculations will be presented elsewhere, together with rate coefficients for practical applications. 1/2nℓ,2 P o Fig. 1(a) shows the detailed unified (e + C IV) recombination cross section σRC in the 1s22s(2S1/2) − −1s22p(2P o 1/2,3/2) region. In order to compare with experiment, we compute the rate coefficient v · σRC , and convolve with a gaussian of ∆E(FWHM) that corresponds to the experimental resolution in the heavy-ion storage ring TSR [2]. Fig. 1(b) shows the convolved theoretical results compared with the experimental results in 1(c) (Fig. 3 in [2]). The experimental results in 1(c) (black dots) are reported in the region 2 -- 8.5 eV, as shown, and compared with theoretical DR results (solid line) in [2] (multiplied by a factor of 0.8 and shifted by 0.06 eV). The present unified σRC in 1(a) show considerably more detail than the experimental results, but the convolved results agree remarkably well with the individual n-complexes of resonances. We also incorporate an approximate field ionization cut-off in < v · σRC >, experimentally estimated at nF = 19, with the results shown as the dashed line in 1(b), compared to the dashed line in 1(c) (the dot-dashed line in 1(c) represents a model calculation of detection probabilities for high Rydberg states [2]). A more accurate ionization cut-off may be possible by considering overlapping (n,J) manifolds of detailed σRC as in Fig. 1(a). At the series limit in Fig. 1(b) our results up to n = ∞ also agree very well with the experimental results augmented as described in [2] (shaded portion). Although the qualitative and quantitative agreement in Fig. 1 appears to be excellent, the present unified results also include the background contribution, which was measured but subtracted from the reported experimental results. A very precise quantitative comparison can however be done for the resonance strength of the 2p4ℓ complex measured by both the CRYRING [1] and the TSR [2] experiments. Fig. 2(a) shows the present detailed unified σRC for the 2p4ℓ complex, with the individual resonances identified. As in Fig.1, the convolved < v · σRC > is shown in Fig. 2(b), and compared with (i) the CRYRING data (open circles), (ii) TSR data (dark circles), and (iii) calculated rate by Mannervik et al. [1] (shaded area) that is up to 50% higher than the experimental values. We particularly note that our background rate αRC = 0.2 ×10−10 cm3s−1 (dark circle) in Fig. 2(b), at E = 0.1 eV, agrees precisely with the measured background value reported in [2] at the same energy. Schippers et al. [2] quote the measured 2p4ℓ resonance strengths of 1.9 ×10−11 eVcm3s−1 and 2.5 ×10−11 eVcm3s−1 from the CRYRING and the TSR data respectively, a difference of about 30%. Our theoretical value is 2.16 ×10−11 eVcm3s−1, obtained by direct integration over the resonances in Fig. 2(b), and subtracting a constant background of 0.2 ×10−10 cm3s−1 in the energy region covered by the resonances. Thus our theoretical value agrees better with each experiment, to ∼15%, than the two experimental values do with each other, differing by 30% (although each experiment has a reported uncertainty of 15%). The present unified results confirm the experimentally measured background around E ≈ 0.1 eV, as reported in Fig. 7 of [2], and in present Fig. 2(b). Whereas the experimental data are uncertain at very low energies, E < 0.1 eV, due to 'excess recombination' possibly due to external fields, the background may not be so affected at higher energies E > 0.1 eV. We suggest that, except at energies close to the RR peak E ≈ 0, the experiments accurately measure the total (e + ion) recombination cross sections that can, therefore, be directly compared with the unified theoretical calculations. Schipper et al. [2] do not however report total (e + ion) recombination cross section since they eliminate the measured background. Instead, they use near-hydrogenic approximations to estimate the RR-contribution [14] to derive total recombination rates, which agree with the earlier LS coupling rates of Nahar and Pradhan [15], to within experimental uncertainties at all temperatures except at low-T < 5000K (the discrepancy is due to the omission of K-shell excitation correlation functions Φj (Eq. 1) that leads to some bound levels of C III appearing as resonances just at threshold). However, as seen from Figs. 1 and 2 the (e + C IV) recombination cross sections may not be considered as an incoherent sum of RR and DR. The unified calculations on the other hand incorporate the background and resonant 2 recombination in an ab initio manner, taking account of quantum mechanical interference between the RR and DR processes. We shall compare these approximations in detail with the present more accurate BPRM photoionization calculations in the low-energy region in a subsequent paper on recombination rates for (e + C IV) . 1/2 level, but still with the detailed resonance structures due to the higher series 2P o Next, we consider the threshold behavior of (e + C IV) DR and EIE. In Fig. 3 we delineate the fine structure σDR 1/2,3/2 thresholds. Fig. 3(a) shows the detailed resonances in 1/2nℓ below 3/2nℓ (solid line). The σDR 3/2nℓ series. The 1/2nℓ resonance series, 3/2nℓ contribution still low in spite of the fact that n ≈ 96. The large drop in the DR cross section is 1/2nℓ channel opens up at the lower fine structure 3/2nℓ) contribution builds up to the second in the energy region spanned by the fine structure 2P o the vicinity of the two series limits. Fig. 3(b) shows the σDR averaged over the lower resonance series 2P o the 2P o averaged over both series is shown as the dashed line. Above the 2P o sharp drop in the total σDR at the 2P o and with the 2P o due to enhanced autoionization into the excited level, when the 2P o threshold 2P o peak at 2P o 3/2. 1/2 while the radiative decay remains constant. The σDR(2P o 1/2 threshold reflects the termination of DR due to the 2P o 1/2, σDR is averaged over the 2P o In Fig. 3(b) it is shown that the resonance averaged limn→∞ < σDR(2P o 1/2), but the detailed σDR has resonances due to the higher series (2P o 3/2nℓ) lying at and near threshold. The resonance averaged σDR at the next DR peak, limn→∞ < σDR(2P o 3/2). Interestingly, the fine structure in the theoretical σDR in Fig. 3(a,b) appears to be discernible as a small dip in experimental data in Fig. 2(c) just below 8 eV. Although the 2P o 1/2,3/2 separation is only 0.013 eV, it may be possible to detect these fine structure threshold effects in future experiments with increased resolution. 3/2nℓ) > = 441.81 Mb (dark circle at 2P o 1/2nℓ) > = 242.57 Mb (dark circle at 2P o At the 2P o 1/2,3/2 thresholds the sum of the averaged fine structure < σDR > = σEIE = 684.38 Mb. Fig. 3(c) compares the near-threshold EIE cross sections with the absolute measurements from two recent experiments, (Greenwood et al. [16] and Janzen et al. [17]), convolved over their respective beam widths of 0.175 eV [16] and 2.3 eV [17]. Our results are in good agreement with both sets (and also with another recent experiment by Bannister et al. [18,16]). Although the present results are the first CC calculations with relativistic fine structure for C IV , their sum is in good agreement with previous LS coupling CC calculations of σEIE [19,20,17]. In this Letter we demonstrate several new aspects of (e + ion) recombination and excitation calculations and experiments: (i) the hitherto most detailed unified relativistic CC calculations agree with two sets of experimental data, such as to constrain both theoretical and experimental uncertainties to ∼15%, (ii) except close to the RR peak at E ≈ 0, the experiments perhaps need not eliminate the background entirely and may report the combined (RR + DR) rate in future, (iii) the finely delineated DR resonances could possibly be used to study field-ionization effects from the n, J-dependent partial DR cross sections, and (iv) the fine structure threshold effects in (e + C IV) should manifest themselves more strongly in heavier and complex ions, in both DR and EIE. This work was partially supported by the National Science Foundation and the NASA Astrophysical Theory Pro- gram. The computational work was carried out at the Ohio Supercomputer Center. [1] S. Mannervik, D.R. DeWitt, L. Engstrom, J. Lidberg, R. Schuch and W. Zhong, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 313 (1998). [2] S. Schippers, A. Muller, G. Gwinner, J. Linkemann, A. Saghiri and A. Wolf, Astrophys. J. 555, 1027 (2001); the subtracted background was re-added to the DR contribution to obtain the total recombination rate coefficient. [3] S.N. Nahar and A.K. Pradhan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1488 (1992). [4] H.L. Zhang and A.K. Pradhan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 195 (1997). [5] A.K. Pradhan and H.L. Zhang J. Phys. B 30, L571 (1997). [6] H.L. Zhang, S.N. Nahar, and A.K. Pradhan, J. Phys. B 32, 1459 (1999). [7] S.N. Nahar, A.K. Pradhan, and H.L. Zhang, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 131, 375 (2000). [8] S.N. Nahar, A.K. Pradhan, and H.L. Zhang, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 133, 255 (2001). [9] These include (e + ion) recombination to: C IV, C V, O VII [6], Ar XIV [4], Fe XXIV [5], and Fe XVII [11] [10] R.H. Bell and M.J. Seaton, J. Phys. B 18, 1589 (1985). [11] A.K. Pradhan, S.N. Nahar, and H.L. Zhang, Astrophys. J. (Lett.) 549, L265 (2001). [12] D.G. Hummer, K.A. Berrington, W. Eissner, A.K. Pradhan, H.E. Saraph and J.A. Tully, Astron. Astrophys. 279, 298 (1993). [13] K.A. Berrington, W. Eissner, and P. H. Norrington, Comput. Phys. Commun. 92, 290 (1995). 3 [14] Schippers et al. use RR recombination rates from Pequignot et al. (D. Pequignot, P. Petitjean, & C. Boisson, Astron. Astrophys. bf 251, 680 1991), that are derived from photoionization cross sections by N. Sakhibulin and A. Willis (Astron. Astrophys. Suppl. 31, 11 (1978)) calculated using the quantum defect method, which are nearly hydrogenic and differ from the CC calculations [15]. [15] S.N. Nahar and A.K. Pradhan, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 111, 339 (1997). [16] J.B. Greenwood, S.J. Smith, and A. Chutjian, Phys. Rev. A 59, 1348 (1999). [17] P.H.Janzen, L.D. Gardner, D.B. Reisenfield, D.W. Savin, and J.L. Kohl, Phys. Rev. A 59, 4821 (1999). [18] M.E. Bannister, R.-S.Chung, N. Djuric, B. Wallbank, O. Woiteke, S. Zhou, G.H. Dunn, and A.C.H. Smith, Phys. Rev. A 57, 278 (1998). [19] V.M. Burke, J. Phys. B 25, 4917 (1992). [20] D.C. Griffin, N.R. Badnell and M.S. Pindzola, J. Phys. B 33, 1013 (2000). 4 FIG. 1. (a) Unified (e + C IV) recombination cross section σRC with detailed resonance structures; (b) theoretical rate coefficient (v ·σRC ) convolved over a gaussian with experimental FWHM [2]; (c) the experimentally measured rate coefficient [2]. The unified σRC in (a),(b) incorporate the background cross section eliminated from the experimental data in (c). The dashed and dot-dashed lines represent approximate field ionization cut-offs (see text). 5 FIG. 2. (a) The 2p4ℓ resonance complex: detailed unified σRC ; (b) convolved rate coefficient (v ·σRC ); (c) experimentally measured values from CRYRING [1] (open circles), TSR [2] (dark circles), and theoretical calculations from [1] (shaded region). The filled circle in (b) at E = 0.1 eV represents the experimentally measured background values (Fig. 7 in [2]. 6 ) b M ( R D σ 10000 1000 100 10 1 600 (a) Detailed σ DR (2Po 1/2,3/2nl) 2Po 1/2 <σ DR(2Po 1/2nl)> (b) Averaged <σ DR(2Po 1/2,3/2nl)> σ 400 ) b M + DR(2Po 3/2nl) ( R D σ ) 2 m c 6 1 − 0 1 ( E E I σ 2Po 1/2 7.995 <σ DR(2Po 3/2nl)> 8 8.005 Photoelectron Energy (eV) (c) Convolved σ EIE(2s−2p) 200 0 10 8 6 4 2 0 2Po 3/2 2Po 3/2 8.01 6 8 10 12 Impact Electron Energy (eV) FIG. 3. σDR and σEIE of C IV : (a) detailed σDR with 2P o 3/2nℓ resonances (solid line), average over the 2P o 1/2nℓ and detailed 2P o 3/2nℓ (dashed line); the dark circles are the peak averaged σDR ; (c) σEIE convolved over experimental data with FWHM = 0.175 eV from [16] (filled squares), and with FWHM = 2.3 eV from [17] (open circles). 1/2,3/2nℓ resonances; (b) σDR averaged over 2P o 7
astro-ph/0108214	1	0108	2001-08-13T14:58:31	Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present a systematic search for parallax microlensing events among a total of 512 microlensing candidates in the OGLE II database for the 1997-1999 seasons. We fit each microlensing candidate with both the standard microlensing model and also a parallax model that accounts for the Earth's motion around the Sun. We then search for the parallax signature by comparing the chi^2 of the standard and parallax models. For the events which show a significant improvement, we further use the `duration' of the event and the signal-to-noise ratio as criteria to separate true parallax events from other noisy microlensing events. We have discovered one convincing new candidate, sc33_4505, and seven other marginal cases. The convincing candidate (sc33_4505) is caused by a slow-moving, and likely low-mass, object, similar to other known parallax events. We found that irregular sampling and gaps between observing seasons hamper the recovery of parallax events. We have also searched for long-duration events that do not show parallax signatures. The lack of parallax effects in a microlensing event puts a lower-limit on the Einstein radius projected onto the observer plane, which in turn imposes a lower limit on the lens mass divided by the relative lens-source parallax. Most of the constraints are however quite weak.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 000 -- 000 (2001) Printed 1 November 2018 (MN LATEX style file v1.4) Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge Martin C. Smith1, Shude Mao1, P. Wo´zniak2,3 ⋆ † 1Univ. of Manchester, Jodrell Bank Observatory, Macclesfield, Cheshire SK11 9DL, UK 2Princeton University Observatory, Princeton, NJ 08544-1001, USA 3Los Alamos National Laboratory, MS D436, Los Alamos, NM 87545, USA Accepted ........ Received .......; in original form ...... ABSTRACT We present a systematic search for parallax microlensing events among a total of 512 microlensing candidates in the OGLE II database for the 1997-1999 seasons. We fit each microlensing candidate with both the standard microlensing model and also a parallax model that accounts for the Earth's motion around the Sun. We then search 2 of the standard and parallax models. for the parallax signature by comparing the χ For the events which show a significant improvement, we further use the 'duration' of the event and the signal-to-noise ratio as criteria to separate true parallax events from other noisy microlensing events. We have discovered one convincing new candidate, sc33 4505, and seven other marginal cases. The convincing candidate (sc33 4505) is caused by a slow-moving, and likely low-mass, object, similar to other known parallax events. We found that irregular sampling and gaps between observing seasons hamper the recovery of parallax events. We have also searched for long-duration events that do not show parallax signatures. The lack of parallax effects in a microlensing event puts a lower-limit on the Einstein radius projected onto the observer plane, which in turn imposes a lower limit on the lens mass divided by the relative lens-source parallax. Most of the constraints are however quite weak. Key words: gravitational microlensing - galactic center 1 INTRODUCTION Gravitational microlensing was originally proposed as a method of detecting compact dark matter objects in the Galactic halo (Paczy´nski 1986). However, it also turned out to be an extremely useful method to study Galactic structure, mass functions of stars and potentially extra- solar planetary systems (for a review, see Paczy´nski 1996). Most microlensing events are well described by the standard light curve (e.g. Paczy´nski 1986). Unfortunately, from these light curves, one can only derive a single physical constraint, namely the Einstein radius crossing time, which involves the lens mass, various distance measures and relative velocity (see §3). This degeneracy means that the lens properties cannot be uniquely inferred, thus making the interpretation of the microlensing results ambiguous; this ambiguity is par- ticularly serious for the interpretation of microlensing events ⋆ e-mail: (msmith, smao)@jb.man.ac.uk, [email protected] † Based on observations obtained with the 1.3 m Warsaw Tele- scope at the Las Campanas Observatory of the Carnegie Institu- tion of Washington. c(cid:13) 2001 RAS toward the Large Magellanic Clouds (e.g. Sahu 1994; Zhao & Evans 2000; Alcock et al. 2000b, and references therein). Fortunately, some microlensing events are exotic, in that they deviate from the standard shape appropriate for a point source lensed by a single star (e.g. Paczy´nski 1986). The deviations include binary microlensing events (e.g., Mao & Paczy´nski 1991; Udalski et al. 2000; Alcock et al. 2000a), the finite source size events (Gould 1994; Nemiroff & Wick- ramasinghe 1994; Witt & Mao 1994) and parallax microlens- ing events. The importance of these non-standard events is that they allow one to derive extra constraints on the lens parameters. Parallax signatures in microlensing events arise when the event lasts long enough that the Earth's mo- tion can no longer be approximated as rectilinear during the event (Gould 1992; see also Refsdal 1966). Unlike the light curves for the standard events which are symmetric, these parallax events exhibit asymmetries in their light curves due to this motion of the Earth around the Sun. These events allow one to derive the physical dimension of the Einstein radius projected onto the observer plane (i.e., the solar sys- tem). The first parallax microlensing event was reported by the MACHO collaboration toward the Galactic bulge 2 Smith, Mao & Wo´zniak (Alcock et al. 1995), and the second case (toward Carina) was discovered by the OGLE collaboration and reported in Mao (1999). Additional parallax microlensing candidates have been presented in a conference abstract (Bennett et al. 1997). A spectacular microlensing event that exhibits par- allax signatures over a span of two years was reported by Soszy´nski et al. (2001). The MOA collaboration also dis- covered a parallax microlensing event toward the Galactic bulge (Bond et al. 2001). However, despite the importance of parallax events, there have been no reported systematic searches in the existing databases. This paper is an attempt to remedy this situation. We search for parallax signatures among 512 microlensing candidates discovered by Wo´zniak et al. (2001) using the difference image analysis. The outline of the paper is as follows. In §2 we briefly describe the mi- crolensing database, in §3 we describe our fitting and search procedures, and in §4 we describe our candidate parallax events, including both convincing and marginal cases. We also search the long-duration events that show no obvious parallax signatures and study their constraints on the lens parameters. Finally, in §5 we discuss the implications of our results and highlight observational issues in identifying par- allax events. 2 DATABASE OF MICROLENSING EVENTS All observations presented in this paper were carried out during the second phase of the OGLE experiment with the 1.3 m Warsaw telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory, Chile. The observatory is operated by the Carnegie Insti- tution of Washington. The telescope was equipped with the "first generation" camera with a SITe 3 2048×2048 pixel CCD detector working in the drift-scan mode. The pixel size was 24µm, giving the scale of 0.417′′pixel−1. Ob- servations of the Galactic bulge fields were performed in the "medium" speed reading mode with the gain 7.1 e− ADU−1 and readout noise about 6.3 e−. Details of the in- strumentation setup can be found in Udalski, Kubiak & Szyma´nski (1997). The majority of the OGLE-II frames were taken in the I-band, roughly 200-300 frames per field during observing seasons 1997 -- 1999. A typical observing season for the Galactic bulge lasts between mid February to the end of October, which unfortunately produces gaps of more than a quarter of a year in length (for more de- tails, see Section 5). Udalski et al. (2000) gives full de- tails of the standard OGLE observing techniques, and the DoPhot photometry is available from the OGLE web site at http://www.astrouw.edu.pl/ ogle/ogle2/ews/ews.html. Wo´zniak et al. (2001) presented a sample of microlens- ing events from difference image analysis of the three year OGLE-II bulge data. His difference image analysis pipeline is designed and tuned for the OGLE bulge data (Wo´zniak 2000), and is based on the algorithm from Alard & Lup- ton (1998) and Alard (2000). The difference image anal- ysis pipeline returned a catalog of over 200,000 candidate variable objects, for which only very modest assumptions have been made about the variability type. This sample was further searched for objects which somewhere in the light curve showed no significant variations in a window contain- ing about half of all photometric points, but had one or two brightening episodes (to allow for binaries, which often have two peaks). Wo´zniak et al. (2001) describes the details of the selection process. Briefly, a brightening episode is de- fined as 3 or 4 consecutive points deviating respectively by 4 or 3 σ upwards with respect to the baseline flux (deter- mined from the quiet period). At this point there are no assumptions made about the shape of the light curve near the event. In all, 4424 light curves passed the above criteria. Further cuts requiring the light curves to be satisfactorily fit by the standard microlensing model would strongly discrim- inate against the non-standard ones such as parallax events (see Section 1). To avoid this problem, the most efficient way to recover as many of these events as possible, including the interesting non-standard ones, is still a visual search. 512 events were found in the course of visual inspection of all 4424 light curves in the weakly filtered sample, the largest set of microlensing light curves published so far. Allowing for slightly larger number of searched fields, this is roughly a factor of 2 more than discovered by the standard photo- metric pipeline from essentially the same data (Udalski et al. 2000). In contrast to the standard pipeline, the error distri- bution from the difference image analysis follows a Gaussian distribution and the photometric error is reduced by a fac- tor of 2 -- 3. These two properties further increase the chance of seeing departures from the standard microlensing model. The error bars were re-calibrated so as to enforce the χ2 per degree of freedom to be unity for the best-fitting model (see §4). 3 SELECTION PROCEDURE We first fit each microlensing candidate with the standard single microlens model which is sufficient to describe most events. In this model, the (point) source, the lens and the observer are all assumed to move with constant spatial ve- locities. The standard light curve, A(t) is given by (e.g. Paczy´nski 1986): A(t) = u2 + 2 u√u2 + 4 , u(t) ≡ pu2 0 + τ (t)2, (1) where u0 is the impact parameter (in units of the Einstein radius) and t − t0 tE τ (t) = tE = (2) , rE v , with t0 being the time of the closest approach (maximum magnification), rE the Einstein radius projected onto the observer plane, v the lens transverse velocity relative to the observer-source line of sight, also projected onto the observer plane, and tE the Einstein radius crossing time ‡. The Ein- stein radius projected onto the observer plane is given by rE = r 4GM Dsx c2(1 − x) , (3) where M is the lens mass, Ds the distance to the source and x = Dl/Ds is the ratio of the distance to the lens and the distance to the source. Eqs. (1-3) shows the well-known lens ‡ In this paper, we differentiate tE from the duration of a mi- crolensing event, which is defined at the end of this section. c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge 3 degeneracy, i.e., from a measured tE, one can not infer v, M and x uniquely even if the source distance is known. The flux difference obtained from difference image anal- ysis can be written as (4) f (t) = fL [A(t) − 1] + ∆f, where fL is the baseline flux of the lensed star, and ∆f is the difference between the total baseline flux [i.e. the flux of the unlensed source and the blended star(s), if present] and the flux of the reference image. Note that in general ∆f does not have to be zero (or even positive). Therefore, to fit the I-band data with the standard model, we need five parameters, namely, fL, ∆f , u0, t0, and tE. Best-fitting parameters (and their errors) are found by minimizing the usual χ2 using the MINUIT program in the CERN library§. We then proceeded to fit these light curves with a model which accounts for the parallax effect. To do this we need to describe the lens trajectory in the ecliptic plane. This requires two further parameters, namely the projected Ein- stein radius onto the observer plane, rE, and an angle ψ in the ecliptic plane, which is defined as the angle between the heliocentric ecliptic x-axis and the normal to the tra- jectory (This geometry is illustrated in Fig. 5 of Soszy´nski et al. 2001). Once these two parameters are specified, the resulting lens trajectory in the ecliptic plane completely de- termines the separation between the lens and the observer (i.e., the quantity which is analogous to the standard model's u0 parameter from eq. 1). This allows the light curve to be calculated; the complete prescription is given in Soszy´nski et al. (2001), to which we refer the reader for further technical details (see also Alcock et al. 1995; Dominik 1998). For the parameters fL, ∆f , u0, t0, and tE, we take the fit parameters from the standard fit as the initial guesses, while rE and ψ are arbitrarily chosen (see below for more details). The best- fitting model is again found by minimizing the χ2. While the standard fit to an observed microlensing light curve is almost always unique, this is not necessarily the case for the paral- lax events. To avoid missing the best-fitting parallax fit in the multi-dimensional parameter space, we ran the parallax fitting program with 24 combinations of rE and ψ as initial guesses; the model with the lowest χ2 is selected as the best parallax fit. We then compared the χ2 values for the standard and parallax fits to determine which events were better described by the parallax model. Since the parallax fit utilized two additional parameters, we had to establish whether a given improvement in χ2 was simply due to the increase in the number of free parameters, or whether this improvement was actually due to a deficiency in the standard model. This was done by performing the standard F-test for the significance of parameters (e.g. Lupton 1993) on each event. Briefly, we first calculate the variable S/χ2 S and χ2 P − 1(cid:3) × (N − 7)/2, l = (cid:2)χ2 P are the χ2 for the best standard and par- where χ2 allax fits, respectively, N − 7 is the number of degrees of freedom for the parallax fit, and the factor of 2 is the differ- ence in the degrees of freedom between the parallax fit and (5) § http://wwwinfo.cern.ch/asd/cernlib/ c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 the standard fit. The variable l follows an F2,n−7 distribu- tion. The statistical significance can then be evaluated using a one-sided test, i.e., the upper-tail of the F2,n−7 distribu- tion. A large value of l, i.e., a small one-sided probability, pF ≡ F (> l), means that there is a significant improvement using the parallax model and vice versa. We selected events with probability less than pF < 0.001 as potential parallax candidates. In total, 109 microlensing candidates passed this selection criterion. We visually examined many of these can- didates, and found that the database was still contaminated by events with low signal-to-noise ratios. We needed to nar- row down the parallax candidates further and to do this we employed two additional criteria: the event 'duration' and the peak signal-to-noise ratio. The duration constraint is imposed because the paral- lax effect should, in general, be more prominent for events that have long duration, since the Earth is able to move a substantial distance around the Sun during these events. However, the Einstein radius crossing time, tE, can some- times be misleading. For example, bright events with large peak fluxes and small photometric error bars exhibit notice- able magnification for a period longer than ∼ 2tE because the microlensing variability can still be detected even out- side the Einstein ring. To avoid this problem we classified the duration of an event as being the length of time which the flux of the standard fit was 3σ above its baseline value. This corresponds to the length of time which we can practicably utilize in our analysis of the lensed part of the light curve. For every event we recorded the duration along with the previously mentioned probability, and events with duration greater than 100 days were considered as potential parallax affected candidates. In total, 18 microlensing events passed this additional test. However, more than two thirds of these events still turn out to have noisy data and are unsuitable for detecting par- allax signatures. A typical example of this is given in Fig. 1(a), which clearly illustrates the fact that more accurate data are needed in order to observe the often slight devia- tions between the standard and parallax fits. Another com- mon problem which occurs with the noisy events is shown in Fig. 1(b). In this case, the parallax fit substantially improves the χ2 because the parallax fit has multiple peaks that better reproduce the fluctuations in the data. However, one notices that the secondary peak falls in a gap between two observing seasons. Many other parallax fits for the noisy events show similar multiple-peak structures. While such multi-peak par- allax events have been predicted (Gould et al. 1994), the large error bars make the identification un-convincing. This is further supported by their often unusual parameter val- ues; for example, the majority of these events have values of rE which are significantly different from the value of a few AU which is expected for a typical microlensing event. It is therefore clear that the identification of parallax signatures requires accurate data in order to observe the slight devi- ations and so the light curves for these noisy events were of little use and we do not regard them as parallax events. To eliminate these events from our selection procedure we needed to quantify how noisy the data were for an event. This was done by analysing the signal-to-noise ratio. To as- sess this signal-to-noise ratio, we use a quantity, (S/N)peak, defined as the difference between the peak flux and the base- line flux divided by the average error estimated using the 4 Smith, Mao & Wo´zniak data points outside the 'duration' of the light curve. We find empirically that (S/N)peak > 30 provides an excellent separator. This criterion, while satisfactory, is somewhat ar- bitrary; we return to this issue briefly in the discussion. As well as identifying events which displayed paral- lax signatures, we also wished to find events which unex- pectedly exhibited no deviations from the standard light curve. Of particular interest are events which have unusu- ally large time-scales but no signs of asymmetry, since they provide lower-limits on rE (see §4.3). To isolate these we used the event duration which was mentioned earlier. We also used two further criteria: firstly, a measure of the im- provement in χ2 between the standard and the parallax fits (i.e. a high value of pF , which corresponds to no signifi- cant improvement in χ2) and secondly, the signal-to-noise ratio, (S/N)peak. Events which had duration > 100 days, (S/N)peak > 30, and probability pF > 0.05 were considered as long-duration events that showed no parallax signatures. 4 RESULTS Out of the 512 events, there were 8 events where the incor- poration of the parallax effect substantially improved the goodness of the fit (see above) and passed our test of event duration and the peak signal-to-noise ratio. These events are given in Table 1. One light curve was found to show clear signs of parallax affected behaviour, in addition to a num- ber of others which could be classified as marginal cases. In the following, we shall first discuss these parallax can- didates and in §4.3 we discuss the physical limits that one can derive from the long-duration events that exhibited no parallax signatures. For all the microlensing events presented here, we re- normalize the χ2 per degree of freedom to be unity for the best-fitting model by multiplying the quoted observational errors by a constant factor (usually between 0.8 to 1.3). This is necessary because we found that the quoted error bars in observations are often too large. The events in §4.1 and §4.2 were re-normalized using the best-fitting parallax model, while the events in §4.3 were re-normalized using the best-fitting standard model (which has essentially the same χ2 as the best-fitting parallax model). This re-normalization affects primarily the quoted error bars in the model param- eters. It also weakly affects the selection procedure through both the peak flux ratio, (S/N)peak, and duration, although this perturbation is only very slight since l in eq. (5) remains unchanged. 4.1 Parallax microlensing candidate From the catalogue of 512 microlensing events, the most convincing parallax event we found was sc33 4505, which is shown in Fig. 2. Despite the lack of data for two impor- tant regions (namely t ≡ JD − 2450000 < 550 days and 760 < t < 870 days), the systematic deviations from the standard curve can clearly be seen. During the upward slope of the light curve the standard fit undoubtedly has a gradi- ent which is too shallow and yet for the downward slope this fit's gradient is clearly too steep. This prominent asymmetry provides strong evidence that the light curve may be exhibit- ing parallax behaviour and this is further supported when the parallax model is used to fit the data. This model pro- vides a much more accurate fit, with the χ2 being drastically reduced from 398.972 (or χ2 = 2.23 per degree of freedom) to 177 (χ2 = 1 per degree of freedom). When observing re- sumed after t = 870 days it can be seen that the parallax model fitted this region more accurately, even though the lensing event was very nearly over and the magnification was only a fraction of the peak value. The best fit parameters from both the standard and parallax fit are given in Table 2. In particular, for the best- fitting parallax model, we find that tE = 194 ± 30 days, rE = 6.37 ± 0.53 AU. An expression for the lens mass as a function of the relative lens-source distance can be shown to be (see Soszy´nski et al. 2001), (6) c2 r2 E M = 1 4G (cid:16) 1 Ds(cid:17) = 0.0123M⊙(cid:16) rE Dl − is the relative lens-source parallax in milli- where πrel arcseconds. For this event, the parallax parameters give a projected velocity of AU(cid:17)2(cid:16) πrel 0.1mas(cid:17) , πrel ≡ AU Dl − AU Ds ,(7) v = rE tE = 57+16 −12 km s−1. (8) The lens mass depends on the relative lens-source parallax (eq. 7). If the source is about 7 kpc away, and the lens lies in the disk half-way between the observer and the source (x = 1/2), then πrel ≈ 0.143 mas, which gives a lens mass of about 0.71M⊙; as a comparison, for a bulge self-lensing event with Ds ≈ 8 kpc and Dl ≈ 6 kpc, then πrel ≈ 0.042 mas, which would give a lens mass of about 0.21M⊙. How- ever, this latter scenario is less likely since the projected velocity of the lens is relatively low. It appears that similar to the previous parallax microlensing events, this event is caused by a slow-moving and likely low-mass lens. 4.2 Marginal parallax microlensing candidates Apart from the above convincing candidate, sc33 4505, a number of events were found which showed indications of parallax signatures. However, the case for classifying these events as having parallax affected light curves is not wholly convincing, mainly due to the insufficiency of the data. Figs. 3-9 show these 'marginal' microlensing events that we have found, and Table 3 presents the best fit parameters for both the standard and parallax models. The problem of insufficient sampling is clear from sev- eral marginal cases. For example, for the sc41 3299 event (Fig. 8), there are very few points in the rising branch of the light curve. As a result, although the parallax fit seems to provide a somewhat better fit in the region be- tween t = 880 − 900 days, it is not clear whether this is a genuine parallax event or just due to the large errors in the data. The situation is similar for events sc20 5748 (Fig. 4), sc27 3078 (Fig. 6), and sc43 836 (Fig. 9). For the event sc6 2563 (Fig. 3), the standard fit consistently over-predicts the fluxes between t = 1040 to 1140 days, and the parallax model provides a much better fit for these parts. Unfortu- nately, there was no data for the time period (t ∼ 1180 days) when the standard model and the parallax model are pre- dicted to show substantial deviations. The fact that we can c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge 5 pick out marginal cases like sc41 3299 implies that our se- lection method is sensitive, and it is unlikely that we could have missed many true candidate parallax events. The situations for the events sc20 5875 (Fig. 5) and sc35 2526 (Fig. 7) are slightly different. For the sc35 2526 event, the light curve is highly asymmetric, and the stan- dard model is clearly a bad fit. The parallax model, on the other hand, provides a much better fit; the improvement in χ2 is from 361.5 to 170. However, the fit is not perfect, par- ticularly at the peak and for the few data points between 700 < t < 750 days. For this reason, we still cautiously re- gard this event as a "marginal" parallax candidate event. The situation for sc20 5875 is similar, but less dramatic. It is possible that these two events are produced by binaries, where the asymmetry is provided, e.g., by the shear per- turbation by the secondary on the primary lens (e.g. Mao & Di Stefano 1995). Notice that, for the event sc35 2526, the tE parameter is unusually long (see Table 3); however, this is just an artifact due to the well-known degeneracy between the impact parameter, u0, and tE for microlensing light curves in blended light curves (Wo´zniak & Paczy´nski 1997), where only the combination of u0tE can be inferred in some cases. 4.3 Long microlensing events that show no parallax signatures Of almost equal interest to parallax events are the events which have large time-scales and yet exhibit no signs of par- allax induced asymmetry. A total of 20 events were identi- fied using the selection criteria which were given in §3, i.e. events which had duration > 100 days, (S/N)peak > 30, and probability pF > 0.05. The parallax signatures become more pronounced for small values of rE because the Earth's mo- tion around the Sun then becomes a larger fraction of the Einstein radius, and hence presents a larger perturbation to the light curve. The lack of parallax signatures therefore provides a lower-limit on rE. For each such event, we fix rE in a range of values while letting all the other six parameters vary and find the minimum χ2 value for each fixed rE. The 2σ confidence constraint on rE is then given by the rE value corresponding to the point at which its χ2 becomes larger than the best fit χ2 by 4.00 (e.g. Lupton 1993). From eq. (7), one sees that this lower limit on rE can then be translated into a lower limit on M/πrel. The events which produced the 4 largest constraints are given in Table 4, and their light curves are shown in Fig. 10. In all cases, the lower limits on the mass are rather weak, the best case being for event sc26 2218, where the lower limit reaches about 0.2M⊙ for πrel = 0.1 mas. These weak constraints are similar to those found by the EROS col- laboration for the microlensing event EROS2-GSA1 (Derue et al. 1999), from which they obtained values of rE ≥ 1.33 AU and M >∼ 10−3M⊙. 5 SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION We have conducted an extensive search for parallax events in the microlensing database of 512 microlensing events ob- tained by the difference image analysis of the OGLE II data. Our selection procedure involves a direct comparison of the c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 standard microlensing model and the parallax model, aug- mented by the requirements of long duration and high peak signal-to-noise ratio. While empirically we found these cri- teria to be very effective, there is no guarantee that these selection procedures are optimal. This issue is best explored using the recovery of artificial parallax events in Monte Carlo simulations (see below). Using our selection criteria, we found one convincing new parallax microlensing event, sc33 4505. A number of other more marginal cases were also recovered. However, while these marginal events are better fitted by a model incorporating the parallax effect, their parallax nature can- not be established beyond any doubt due to the poor sam- pling in the light curve. This may be particularly severe for the events which last for about one year, due to the gap of approximately three months between observing seasons. In such cases either the rising or the declining branch of the light curve will typically be missing, and so the paral- lax induced asymmetry is particularly difficult to identify. We have also found some very long events that showed no parallax signatures, and these events provide a lower-limit on the Einstein radius projected onto the observer plane. Consequently, a lower-limit on the lens mass M/πrel can be derived (cf. eq. 7). However, in most cases, the lower limits on M/πrel are rather weak. The convincing parallax event (sc33 4505) is similar to all of the other 4 known parallax events (see introduction) in that it is caused by a slow-moving lens and, quite likely, a low mass lens. The low projected velocity favors the inter- pretation that this microlensing geometry is a disk source lensed by a disk lens. For such events, the observer, the lens and the source rotate about the Galactic center with roughly the same velocity, and the relative motion is only due to the small, ∼ 10 km s−1, random velocities (see, e.g. Derue et al. 1999). On the other hand, the chance for a bulge source (with its much larger random velocity, ∼ 100 km s−1) to have such a low projected velocity relative to the lens (whether in the disk or bulge) is small. So it appears that all known par- allax events are caused by disk-disk lensing. If this is true, then the radial velocities of the lensed sources are expected to be small. It will therefore be very interesting to check this by obtaining the radial velocities of the parallax events spec- troscopically. Since their projected transverse velocities are known, one obtains a more complete kinematic picture of these unusual microlensing events that can be used to probe the dynamical model of the Milky Way. As a by product, one also obtains the metallicity and age of these stars. While the number of convincing parallax events toward the Galactic bulge seems to be very low (1 out of 512), the number of marginal cases makes the true fraction somewhat uncertain. A related question is whether existing microlens- ing catalogs are biased against parallax events. This is an important issue because parallax events preferentially have long durations, which may be detectable only when one has monitored the stars for many years. In fact, after the com- pletion of this work, eight additional events were recovered by cross identification of the 214 microlensing candidates from the standard OGLE database with the difference im- age analysis variability database of Wo´zniak (2000). Some of these were missed in the first search because they have such long durations that they have not yet reached a constant baseline. We plan to analyze these additional unique events 6 Smith, Mao & Wo´zniak for parallax signatures. On the theoretical side, Buchalter & Kamionkowski (1997) have estimated the expected fraction of parallax events which would be identified, using a regu- lar sampling of every few minutes to ∼ 1 day. Our search strongly suggests that the irregular sampling and gaps be- tween different observing seasons hamper the recovery of parallax events. We plan to perform a simulation with real- istic sampling and photometric errors similar to those found in observations. A comparison between the observed and predicted rates may enable us to provide constraints on the lens and source kinematics. Such simulations will also be helpful for devising the optimal search strategy for selecting parallax events from the experiments. The results of these Monte Carlo simulations will be reported in a future publi- cation. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We acknowledge Bohdan Paczy´nski for discussions and com- ments on the manuscript. We also thank Ian Browne for crit- ical remarks that improved the paper. MCS acknowledges receipt of a PPARC grant. PW was supported by the NSF grant AST-9820314 to Bohdan Paczynski and by the Labo- ratory Directed Research & Development funds (X1EM and XARF programs at LANL). REFERENCES Alard C., Lupton R. H., 1998, ApJ, 503, 325 Alard C., 2000, A&A Suppl., 144, 363 Alcock C. et al., 1995, ApJ, 454, L125 Alcock C. et al., 2000a, ApJ, 541, 270 Alcock C. et al., 2000b, ApJ, 542, 281 Bennett D. P. et al., 1997, BAAS, 191, 8303 Bond I. A. et al. (the MOA collaboration) 2001, preprint (astro- ph/0102181) Buchalter A., Kamionkowski M., 1997, ApJ, 482, 782 Derue F. et al., 1999, A&A, 351, 87 Dominik M., 1998, A&A, 329, 361 Gould A., 1992, ApJ, 392, 442 Gould A., 1994, ApJ, 421, L71 Gould A., Miralda-Escude J., Bahcall J.N., 1994, ApJ, 423, L105 Lupton R. H., 1993, Statistics in theory and practice (Princeton: Princeton University Press) Mao S., Paczynski B., 1991, ApJ, 374, L37. Mao S., Di Stefano R., 1995, ApJ, 440, 22 Mao S., 1999, A&A, 350, L19 Nemiroff R.J., Wickramasinghe W.A.D.T., 1994, ApJ, 424, L21 Paczy´nski B., 1986, ApJ, 304, 1 Paczy´nski B., 1996, ARAA, 34, 419 Refsdal S., 1966, MNRAS, 134, 315 Sahu K. C., 1994, Nature, 370, 275 Soszy´nski I. et al., 2001, ApJ, 552, 731 Udalski A., Kubiak M., Szyma´nski M., 1997, Acta Astron., 47, 319 Udalski A., Zebru´n K., Szyma´nski M., Kubiak M., Pietrzy´nski G., Soszy´nski I., Wo´zniak P., 2000, Acta Astron., 50, 1 Witt H.J., Mao S., 1994, ApJ, 430, 505 Wo´zniak P., Paczy´nski B., 1997, ApJ, 487, 55 Wo´zniak P., 2000, Acta Astron., 50, 421 Wo´zniak P. et al., 2001, Acta Astron., submitted (astro- ph/0106474) Zhao H.S., Evans W.N., 2000, ApJ, 545, L35 c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge 7 Figure 1. Two events which highlight the problems associated with noisy data. The solid and dotted lines represent the stan- dard fit and the parallax fit, respectively. (a) The event sc39 5310, which illustrates how slight deviations between the two fits can easily be hidden by noisy data. The error bars have been omitted for clarity, but a typical error bar is shown in the top left hand corner. (b) The event sc30 3395, which demonstrates how a mi- crolensing light-curve can be seemingly-erroneously fitted with a parallax model exhibiting many peaks. This leads to a significant improvement in χ2. Such multi-peak parallax models often occur in events with noisy data, which may signal additional variability other than microlensing. Figure 2. Difference flux (f (t), as defined in eq. 4) as a func- tion of time for the best candidate parallax microlensing event, sc33 4505. The solid line shows the best standard fit while the dotted line shows the best fit that accounts for the parallax ef- fect. The insets show the light curves for the 'non-lensed' seasons. Figure 3. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc6 2563. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 8 Smith, Mao & Wo´zniak Figure 4. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc20 5748. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. Figure 6. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc27 3078. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. Figure 5. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc20 5875. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. This event is not perfectly fit by the parallax model. This event may, instead, be caused by a (weak) binary lens (see also Fig. 7). Figure 7. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc35 2526. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. This event is not perfectly fit by the parallax model. This event may, instead, be caused by a (weak) binary lens (see also Fig. 5). c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 Parallax Microlensing Events in the OGLE II Database Toward the Galactic Bulge 9 Figure 8. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc41 3299. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. Figure 10. The 4 long-duration lensing events which produced the most stringent lower-limits on the lens mass M/πrel (see eq. 7 and Table 4). For these events, the incorporation of parallax effects produces virtually no improvement in the χ2. The dotted line shows the theoretical baseline flux and the horizontal axis covers a length of time corresponding to the event duration, as specified in §3. Figure 9. The marginal candidate parallax microlensing event, sc43 836. The notations are the same as in Fig. 2. c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000 10 Smith, Mao & Wo´zniak Table 1. The 8 events which were systematically selected as po- tential parallax affected light-curves, and their subsequent classi- fication. The probability pF and (S/N)peak are defined in §3. The convincing candidate (sc33 4505) and other marginal candidates are shown in Figs. 2-9. Event RA DEC Duration (day) tE (day) pF (S/N)peak Classification sc6 2563 sc20 5748 sc20 5875 sc27 3078 sc33 4505 sc35 2526 sc41 3299 sc43 836 18:08:02.64 17:59:39.05 17:59:08.99 17:48:15.92 18:05:46.71 18:04:22.42 17:52:19.08 17:34:52.64 -31:49:05.2 -28:27:16.6 -28:24:54.7 -34:50:09.0 -28:25:32.1 -27:57:52.2 -32:48:20.8 -27:23:14.4 245 150 146 162 663 162 119 207 66.6 ± 1.3 78.2 ± 2.5 27.22 ± 0.21 124 ± 10 194 ± 30 6600 ± 180 98 ± 18 45.1 ± 1.6 1.22 × 10−8 2.58 × 10−5 0.00 2.04 × 10−7 5.78 × 10−32 1.44 × 10−28 1.28 × 10−5 4.31 × 10−5 228.39 38.99 119.04 142.82 78.79 47.02 35.17 31.70 marginal marginal marginal/binary? marginal convincing marginal/binary? marginal marginal Table 2. The best standard model (first row) and the best par- allax model (second row) for the convincing candidate sc33 4505. Model t0 tE (day) u0 fL ∆f S P 647.22 ± 0.36 654.4 ± 4.1 166 ± 11 194 ± 30 −0.412 ± 0.036 −0.207 ± 0.065 730 ± 91 440 ± 150 −172.2 ± 1.8 −174.3 ± 2.1 ψ -- rE (AU) -- 3.136 ± 0.011 6.37 ± 0.53 χ2 399.0 177 Table 3. The best standard model (indicated by 'S') and the best parallax model (indicated by 'P') for marginal parallax can- didates. The error bars have been rescaled so as to enforce the χ2 per degree of freedom to be unity for the best-fitting parallax model. Event t0 sc6 2563,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc20 5748,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc20 5875,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc27 3078,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc35 2526,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc41 3299,S -- -- -- -- ,P sc43 836,S -- -- -- -- ,P 1251.971 ± 0.068 1263.85 ± 0.62 1277.03 ± 0.22 1315.12 ± 0.96 948.74 ± 0.10 933.88 ± 0.28 1243.481 ± 0.077 1238.75 ± 0.34 696.33 ± 0.20 695.46 ± 0.23 927.65 ± 0.29 913.1 ± 7.7 1054.69 ± 0.41 1040.0 ± 1.6 tE (day) 89.2 ± 2.8 66.6 ± 1.3 357 ± 120 78.2 ± 2.5 31.3 ± 1.7 27.22 ± 0.21 312 ± 77 124 ± 10 0.0758 ± 0.0032 0.0272 ± 0.0085 −0.0148 ± 0.0056 −0.325 ± 0.041 0.461 ± 0.042 2.073 ± 0.011 0.0070 ± 0.0018 −0.6266 ± 0.0068 53000 ± 11000 0.000107 ± 0.000021 6600 ± 180 63.2 ± 8.3 98 ± 18 71.5 ± 7.2 45.1 ± 1.6 0.01512 ± 0.00018 0.186 ± 0.034 0.19 ± 0.16 0.437 ± 0.067 −0.104 ± 0.035 u0 fL ∆f 135.9 ± 5.7 192.8 ± 5.5 4.1 ± 1.5 16.67 ± 0.79 1950 ± 250 320 ± 25 4.8 ± 1.2 18.2 ± 1.3 0.0291 ± 0.0057 0.0920 ± 0.0066 40.8 ± 8.5 26.2 ± 6.8 126 ± 28 176 ± 13 −49.43 ± 0.52 −48.84 ± 0.49 −26.24 ± 0.67 −25.50 ± 0.41 −181.9 ± 1.7 −182.0 ± 1.6 −12.08 ± 0.52 −11.60 ± 0.36 −7.39 ± 0.59 −4.65 ± 0.57 −4.63 ± 0.40 −4.87 ± 0.47 −17.91 ± 0.41 −17.38 ± 0.37 Table 4. The 4 non-lensed events which produced the best 2σ confidence lower limit on the projected Einstein radius in the observer plane (rE) and on M/πrel (cf. eq. 7). The 'duration' of the event is defined in §3, and the probability pF is defined below eq. (5). The relative lens-source parallax πrel is in units of milli-arcseconds; for microlensing events toward the Galactic bulge, πrel ∼ 0.1 mas. Event RA DEC Duration (day) tE (day) pF rE (AU) M/πrel (M⊙ ) sc22 1992 sc26 2218 sc34 3906 sc45 810 17:56:35.30 17:47:23.29 17:58:37.11 18:03:30.06 -30:56:33.4 -34:59:52.4 -29:06:29.9 -30:09:55.6 151 195 331 115 45.5 ± 3.7 45.10 ± 0.59 58.7 ± 6.2 98 ± 54 0.132 0.104 0.204 0.151 0.94 3.74 1.44 1.73 0.11 1.71 0.25 0.37 ψ -- rE (AU) -- 0.262 ± 0.012 4.27 ± 0.16 -- -- 1.234 ± 0.057 2.43 ± 0.11 -- -- 0.235 ± 0.011 0.3515 ± 0.0021 -- -- 2.971 ± 0.026 1.68 ± 0.019 -- -- 2.9967 ± 0.0087 63.02 ± 0.73 -- -- 6.222 ± 0.096 2.33 ± 0.68 -- -- 3.1744 ± 0.0054 1.511 ± 0.091 χ2 253.7 214 243.2 221 666.7 189 245.2 212 361.5 170 197.1 173 262.0 241 c(cid:13) 2001 RAS, MNRAS 000, 000 -- 000
astro-ph/9907359	1	9907	1999-07-26T17:33:40	Supernovae Rates: A Cosmic History	[ "astro-ph" ]	We discuss the cosmic history of supernovae on the basis of various assumptions and recent data on the star formation history. We show that supernova rates as a function of redshift can be used to place significant constraints on progenitor models, on the star formation history, and on the importance of dust obscuration. We demonstrate that it is unlikely that the current observational indications for the existence of a cosmological constant are merely an artifact of the dominance of different progenitor classes at different redshift intervals.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Supernovae Rates: A Cosmic History Lev R. Yungelson1 and Mario Livio Space Telescope Science Institute 3700 San Martin Drive Baltimore, MD 21218 Received ; accepted 9 9 9 1 l u J 6 2 1 v 9 5 3 7 0 9 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1Permanent address: Institute of Astronomy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 48 Pyatnitskaya Street, 10917 Moscow, Russia. -- 2 -- ABSTRACT We discuss the cosmic history of supernovae on the basis of various assumptions and recent data on the star formation history. We show that supernova rates as a function of redshift can be used to place significant constraints on progenitor models, on the star formation history, and on the importance of dust obscuration. We demonstrate that it is unlikely that the current observational indications for the existence of a cosmological constant are merely an artifact of the dominance of different progenitor classes at different redshift intervals. Subject headings: binaries: close -- stars: formation -- supernovae: general -- cosmology: observations -- 3 -- 1. Introduction The interest in the cosmic history of supernovae stems from several sources. First, core-collapse supernovae (types II and Ib/c) directly follow the star formation history and some of them may be related to gamma-ray bursts. Secondly, Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are being used as the primary standard candle sources for the determination of the cosmological parameters Ω and Λ (e.g. Perlmutter et al. 1999; Riess et al. 1998). Thirdly, a comparison of SNe Ia rates (for the different models of their progenitors) with observations may shed light on both the star formation history and on the nature of the progenitors (e.g. Yungelson & Livio 1998; Madau 1998a). Finally, the counts of distant SNe could be used to constrain cosmological parameters (e.g. Ruiz-Lapuente & Canal 1998). As a consequence of the above, studies of cosmological SNe are among the primary targets for the Next Generation Space Telescope (NGST), which presumably will be able to detect, with proper filters, virtually all the SNe up to a redshift z ∼ 8 (see e.g. http://ngst.gsfc.nasa.gov/Images/sn.GIF). In the present study we combine data on the precursors of SNe Ia in our Galaxy with data on the cosmic star formation rate in an attempt to analyse the frequency of events as a function of redshift. In view of the uncertainties that still exist concerning the cosmic star formation history, we use two types of inputs to characterize the star formation rate (SFR). In the first, we use profiles inferred from deep observations (e.g. Madau, Panagia & Della Valle 1998). In the second, we use a step-wise SFR which includes a burst of star formation and a subsequent stage of a lower SFR. In the latter case the star formation history is parameterized by the duration of the star burst phase and by the fraction of the total mass of the stellar population that is formed in the burst. The different scenarios for SNe Ia are briefly discussed in §2. The basic assumptions -- 4 -- and model computations are presented in §3 and §4, and a discussion and conclusions follow. 2. The Progenitors of SNe Ia The observed SNe Ia do represent somewhat of a mixture of events, with a majority of "normal" ones and a small minority of "peculiar" ones (see e.g. Branch 1998, and references therein). A more moderate diversity is present even among the "normals." There exist certain relations between the absolute magnitudes and light curve decline rates and the morphological types of the host galaxies (e.g. Branch, Romanishin, & Baron 1996; Hamuy et al. 1996). This may suggest a possible diversity among the progenitors of SNe Ia (see e.g. review by Livio 1999). On the theoretical side, SNe Ia are very probably thermonuclear disruptions of accreting white dwarfs. Two classes of explosive events are generally considered in the literature. The first involves central ignition of carbon when the accreting white dwarf reaches the Chandrasekhar mass MCh ≈ 1.4 M⊙. In the second, the ignition of the accreted helium layer on top of the white dwarf induces a compression of the core which leads to the ignition of carbon at sub-Chandrasekhar masses (these are known as edge-lit detonations or ELDs). Parameterized models for the events in the former class are able to reproduce most of the typical features of SNe Ia, while ELD models encounter a few serious problems when confronted with observations (see e.g. Hoflich & Khokhlov 1996; Nugent et al. 1997; Branch 1998; Livio 1999 for a discussion and references). On the other hand, binary evolution theory clearly predicts situations in which helium may accumulate on top of white dwarfs (see e.g. Branch et al. 1995; Yungelson & Tutukov 1997). It is presently not entirely clear whether ELDS indeed do not occur in nature, or whether they are responsible for a subset of the events (e.g. the subluminous ones). However, both the existing diversity in the -- 5 -- observed properties of SNe Ia and the uncertainties still involved in theoretical models, suggest that it is worthwhile to explore all the possible options. The occurence rate of SNe Ia inferred for our Galaxy is ∼ 10−3 yr−1 (Cappellaro et al. 1997). There are three evolutionary channels in which according to population synthesis calculations the realization frequency of potentially explosive configurations in the disk of the Milky Way is at least at the level of 10−4 yr−1. These are: A. Mergers of double degenerates resulting in the formation of a M >∼ MCh object and central C ignition. The channel involves the accretion of carbon-oxygen. B. Accretion of helium from a nondegenerate helium-rich companion at a rate of M ∼ 10−8 M⊙ yr−1, resulting in the accumulation of a He layer of ∼ (0.10 − 0.15) M⊙ and an ELD. C. Accretion of hydrogen from a (semidetached ) main-sequence or evolved companion. The burning of H may result either in the accumulation of MCh and central C ignition or in the accumulation of a critical layer of He for an ELD. The positive aspects and draw-backs of these channels were discussed in detail elsewhere and also by other authors (e.g. Tutukov, Iben, & Yungelson 1992; Branch et al. 1995; Iben 1997; Ruiz-Lapuente et al. 1997; Yungelson & Livio 1998; Hachisu, Kato & Nomoto 1999; Livio 1999). Here we present for "pedagogical" purposes a simplified flow-chart which illustrates some of the evolutionary scenarios which may result in SNe Ia (Fig. 1). Other channels may definitely contribute to the total SNe Ia rate but they are either less productive or they involve large uncertainties (see also §5). In a typical scenario, one starts with a main-sequence binary in which the mass of the primary component is in the range ∼ (4 − 10) M⊙. The initial system has to be wide enough to allow the primary to become an Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB) star with a -- 6 -- degenerate CO core. After the AGB star overfills its Roche lobe a common envelope forms. If the components do not merge inside the common envelope, the core of the former primary becomes a CO white dwarf. The subsequent evolution depends on the separation of the components and on the mass of the secondary. If the latter is higher than ∼ 4 M⊙ and the secondary fills its Roche lobe in the AGB stage, then following a second common envelope phase, a pair of CO white dwarfs forms. The two white dwarfs may merge due to systemic angular momentum losses via gravitational wave radiation. As a result, a Chandrasekhar mass may be accumulated, leading potentially to a SN Ia (scenario A). If the mass of the secondary is above ∼ 2.5 M⊙ and it fills its Roche lobe before core He ignition it becomes a compact He star. If inside the common envelope the components get sufficiently close, the He star may fill its Roche lobe in the core He burning stage and transfer matter at a rate of ∼ 10−8 M⊙ yr−1. The accumulation of He on top of the white dwarf may result in an ELD (scenario B). Finally, if the mass of the companion to the white dwarf is below ∼ (2 − 3) M⊙, the companion may fill its Roche lobe on the main-sequence or in the subgiant phase. Such a star could stably transfer matter at a rate which allows for the accumulation of MCh, or of a critical-mass He layer (scenario C). Below we refer to all the potentially explosive situations listed above as "SNe Ia," in spite of the fact that it is not entirely clear whether most of these configurations actually result in a SN (see e.g. Livio 1999). We should note that while the above quoted masses are only approximate, the uncertainties are not such that they can change the expected rates significantly. A special remark has to be made concerning the exclusion of symbiotic stars. Yungelson et al. (1995) have shown that the accumulation of MCh in these systems occurs at a low rate: ∼ 10−5 yr−1 (see however discussion in §5). The accumulation of 0.15 M⊙ of He via -- 7 -- H burning occurs at a rate of ∼ 10−4 yr−1, but the accretion rate is typically high, and hence, one would normally not expect an ELD to ensue. Rather, weak helium flashes may occur. A cautionary note has also to be made concerning ELDs which under certain sets of parameters have an occurence rate of ∼ 10−3 yr−1 in semidetached systems (scenario C, Yungelson & Livio 1998). We assumed that ELDs occur even if the accretion rate of hydrogen was initially high but then dropped to below 3 × 10−8 M⊙ yr−1. By this, we neglected the possible influence of hydrogen flashes on the helium layer. The response of the helium layer and the underlying white dwarf to the varying accretion rate (from several times 10−7 M⊙ yr−1 to 3 × 10−8 M⊙ yr−1) was never treated in detail to the best of our knowledge. One may expect a competition between cooling (due to the expansion of the hydrogen layer) and the inward heat propagation (due to nuclear burning). Cassisi, Iben, & Tornamb`e (1998) for example, claim that heating by hydrogen flashes keeps the temperature of the He layer high and may even prevent the explosive ignition of He. Rather, they conclude, quiescent burning may be expected (for accretion rates 10−8 -- 10−6 M⊙ yr−1) during which the white dwarf expands to giant dimensions and its envelope may be removed by interaction with the companion. If an explosion nevertheless happens, it may produce a powerful nova-type event (a "super nova"). As a result of all of these uncertainties (and others) the issue of ELDs via a channel of hydrogen accretion is not definitively settled (see Livio 1999). One of the cornerstones of channel C is the assumption of negligible mass loss in the form of a wind during helium flashes (e.g. Kato, Saio, & Hachisu 1989), which allows for the accumulation of MCh despite the flashes. The expansion of the helium layers found by Cassisi et al. and the accompanying mass loss may (in some cases at least) prevent the accumulation of MCh. Thus, the realization frequency of both scenarios for SNe Ia (explosion at MCh or at -- 8 -- a sub MCh mass) via channel C is a matter of considerable uncertainty. Nevertheless, we include channel C in our consideration (although see discussion in §5). The basic difference between the possible progenitor scenarios of SNe Ia is in the "evolutionary clock" -- the time interval between the formation of the binary system and the SN explosion. Figure 2 shows the dependence of the supernova rate on time after an instantaneous star formation burst, for the four mechanisms listed above, as computed in the present study. The curves shown were computed for a common envelope efficiency parameter αce = 1; the dependence on this parameter within reasonable limits on αce between 0.5 and 2 is not too strong. For semidetached systems, we considered the case of mass exchange stabilized by the presence of a thick stellar wind (Hachisu, Kato, & Nomoto 1996, henceforth, HKN) as modified by Yungelson and Livio (1998). Further suggested modifications to the standard evolution will be discussed in §5. The differences in the timespan between the formation of a binary and the SN Ia event, and in the rate of decay of the SNe rates in the different channels, manifests itself in the redshift dependence of the SNe Ia rates. Our calculations are based on the assumption that the IMF, and the mechanisms of SNe Ia are the same throughout the Hubble time. This assumption may not be valid, for example because of metallicity effects. Stars with lower Z develop larger helium and carbon-oxygen cores for the same main-sequence mass (e.g. Umeda et al. 1998), and hence, form more massive white dwarfs. At the same time, the upper mass limit of stars which form CO white dwarfs decreases towards a lower metallicity. However, assuming a power-law IMF both of these effects result in an increased number of potential pre-SNe Ia white dwarfs. On the other hand, a low metallicity can inhibit strong optically thick stellar winds which are essential for the HKN model of SNe Ia (Kobayashi et al. 1998). Assuming for the moment that several channels may contribute (see however Livio 1999), the net -- 9 -- effect may be an enhanced rate of SNe Ia from the channels of double-degenerates and ELDs from systems with nondegenerate He donors, and a reduction in the rate from the channel of hydrogen-donor systems. 3. SNe and the Star Formation rate 3.1. Supernovae Rates The rest-frame frequency of SNe of a certain type at any time t, n(t), may be derived by convolving the star formation rate Ψ(τ ) with the function f (t) giving the rate of SNe after an instantaneous burst of star formation: Two approaches for the evaluation of f (t) are encountered in the literature. The n(t) = Z t 0 f (t − τ )Ψ(τ )dτ. (1) first is not to consider any specific mechanisms of SNe (which are still a matter of some debate), but rather to parameterize f by the fraction of exploding stars in the binary star population (the "explosion efficiency") and the delay between formation and explosion, or the "evolutionary clock" (e.g. Madau et al. 1998; Dahl´en & Fransson 1998; Sadat et al. 1998). For core-collapse supernovae (SN II and SN Ib/c) it is natural to assume that the shape of f follows the SFR and the delay between the formation of the star and the SN event is negligible, since the lifetime of stars more massive than 10 M⊙ is <∼ 20Myr. For SNe Ia Madau et al. considered a parameterized f (t) with timescales of 0.3, 1, and 3 Gyr between the formation of the WD and the explosion. These authors reproduce the ratio of SNII/SNIa ≈ 3.5 in the local Universe, if the explosion efficiency is 5% to 10%. A similar parameterization was adopted by Dahl´en & Fransson (1998), who estimated the number of core-collapses and type Ia SNe which may be detected by NGST in different -- 10 -- filters for different limiting stellar magnitudes. Sadat et al. (1998) considered a power-law f ∝ t−s, and explored a range of s from 1.4 to 1.8. Another parameter of Sadat et al. is the rise time of the SNe Ia rate from 0 to a maximum which was fixed at 0.75 Gyr. The ranges of s and rise times were derived from models of the chemical evolution of Fe in elliptical galaxies and in clusters of galaxies. Concerning the explosion efficiency, Sadat et al. actually do not exploit this parameter since they additionally normalize their rates, in order to reproduce the local rate of SNe Ia by the adopted SFR. A different approach to the determination of f relies on population synthesis calculations. Using this method, Jørgensen et al. (1997) derived the rates of core-collapse supernovae (SNe II and SNI b), mergers of binary WDs with a total mass exceeding MCh, and collapses of Chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs in semidetached systems (in the standard model, without the thick wind of HKN). Ruiz-Lapuente & Canal (1998; see also Ruiz-Lapuente, Canal, & Burkert 1995; Canal, Ruiz-Lapuente, & Burkert 1996) considered as SNe Ia progenitors merging double degenerates and cataclysmic binaries. For the latter channel, n(t) was estimated in two cases. First, the "standard" case which allows only thermally stable mass exchange for Mdonor/Maccretor < ∼ 0.78. Second, the case of the "wind" solution of HKN, which allows for mass exchange at rates of up to ∼ 10−4 M⊙ yr−1, for systems with q <∼ 1.15. Ruiz-Lapuente & Canal find a distinct difference between the behavior of the predicted SN Ia rates vs. limiting red stellar magnitude for different families of progenitors. Namely, the dN/dmR − mR relation for descendants of cataclysmic variables is much steeper than that for merging double degenerates. However, the computations of Dahl´en & Fransson (1998) do not show any significant difference in the behavior of the SNe Ia counts for different delays in the -- 11 -- 0.3 -- 3 Gyr range (the main difference between double degenerates and cataclysmic variable like systems is in the delay time). 3.2. The star formation rate The star formation rate which is used as an ingredient in calculations of the evolution of the cosmic SNe rate is usually derived from studies which model the observed evolution of the galaxy luminosity density with cosmic time. For example, Madau, Pozetti, & Dickinson (1998) and Madau, Della Valle, & Panagia (1998, hereafter MDVP98) have shown that the observational data can be fitted if one assumes, as an ingredient of the model, a time-dependent star formation rate. However, there exist uncertainties in this model, due to the uncertain amount of dust extinction at early epochs. For example, MDVP98 have shown that the same observational data may be fitted if one assumes a constant EB−V = 0.1 or a z-dependent dust extinction which rises rapidly with redshift, EB−V = 0.011(1 + z)2.2. The latter authors provide convenient fitting formulae for the star formation rates for these two cases. Model 1 ("little dust extinction") has Ψ(t) = 0.049t5 9e−t9/0.64 + 0.2(1 − e−t9/0.64) M⊙ yr−1 Mpc−3 , (2) where t9 is the time in Gyr, t9 = 13(1 + z)−3/2. Model 2 ("z-dependent dust opacity") has Ψ(t) = 0.336e−t9/1.6 + 0.0074(1 − e−t9/0.64) + 0.0197t5 9e−t9/0.64M⊙ yr−1 Mpc−3 . (3) Note that eqs. (2) and (3) give slightly different current SFR and the integrated values are also different by about 10%. Both SFR models predict a similar, rather steep rise, by a factor ∼ 10, at z <∼ 1.5. The difference between the two rates is in the behavior at z >∼ 1.5. -- 12 -- While in the "little dust extinction" case the rate drops almost linearly by a factor of about 10 to z⋆ = 5, in the "z-dependent dust opacity" case it continuously grows to z⋆, by a factor of ∼ 2.5. Formally, the star formation process switches on discontinuously at z⋆. We should note that Model 2 may be a more realistic representation of the global star formation history, since there is growing evidence of a significant effect of dust absorption at high z (e.g. Pettini et al. 1998; Calzetti & Heckman 1998; Huges et al. 1998; Steidel et al. 1998; Blain et al. 1998). Also, selection effects due to the low surface brightness of galaxies (e.g. Ferguson 1998) or the shift of typical spectral features to the red (e.g. Hu, Cowie, & McMahon 1998) may result in an underestimate of the SFR at high redshifts. Equation (2) gives a star formation history which is consistent with expectations from hierarchical clustering cosmologies, while Eq. (3) gives the model prediction for SFR typical for a monolitic collapse scenario (e.g. Madau 1998b). Ruiz-Lapuente & Canal (1998) used in their computations the star formation rate given by Madau (1997), without corrections for dust extinction. The effect of extinction was considered by Dahl´en & Fransson (1998) and by Sadat et al. (1998). In the latter case, the SFR at z >∼ 1 was taken to be several times higher than in the "low-dust" case. Jørgensen et al. (1997) considered two modes of star formation: a "burst" lasting for 500 Myr, and a continuous SFR for a Hubble time, and computed models for a range of relative contributions of both star formation modes. 4. Model computations 4.1. Models using "observed" star formation rates The population synthesis code used for the computations of the SNe rates was previously applied by the authors to a number of problems related to the population -- 13 -- of galactic binary stars and, in particular, to SNe. Within the range of observational uncertainties, the code reproduces correctly the rates of SNe inferred for our galaxy (Tutukov, Yungelson, & Iben 1992; Yungelson & Livio 1998 and references therein). Throughout this paper we assume a cosmology with Ω0 = 1, H0 = 50 km s−1Mpc−1. These values of the cosmological parameters are assumed only for convenience. Our qualitative results and conclusions do not depend on this choice. Star formation is assumed to start at z⋆ = 5. The Hubble time in this model was taken to be 13 Gyr. For the different SNe Ia scenarios listed in §2 and for different star formation histories, we first calculated the rest-frame rates of events n0. We then computed differential functions for the number of events observed at redshift z and cumulative functions n(< z). We use eq. [3.3.25] from Zel'dovich & Novikov (1983) for the number of events observed from a layer between redshifts z and z + dz in an expanding, curved Universe, taking into account time dilation: dn dz = n0 4πc3 H 3 0 1 1 + z ξz(z, Ω0)z2dz . Where, for the particular case of Ω0 = 1 ξz(z, 1) = 4[(1 + z)1/2 − 1]2 z2(1 + z)5/2 . Notice, that ∂ξz ∂z < 0. Time t is related to z as t = 2H −1 0 3(1 + z)3/2 . (4) (5) (6) We operate with the number of events per yr instead of expressing the SNe rates in the more conventional Supernovae Units (SNU), since both the computation of blue luminosities and their observational determination involve additional parameters (expressing the rates in SNU may result in loss of information on both the SNe rates and on the SFR). -- 14 -- Our simulations give the rates of SNe as a function of z. Clearly, the number of observable events depends on other factors such as the limiting stellar magnitude of the sample, etc. Nevertheless, our results provide the basis for theoretical expectations, which need subsequently to be convolved with observational selection effects. In principle, NGST observations can approach the theoretical limits. Figure 3 compares the values of dn/dz for the different channels of SNe and the different assumptions about the SFR given by eqs. (2) and (3). Figure 4 shows the behavior with redshift of the cumulative numbers of SNe. The behavior of dn/dz can be understood as follows. In Model 1 (low dust) as one progresses from z = 0 to z⋆, the SFR reaches a maximum at z ≈ 1.5. The maxima of the rest-frame SNe rates happen at a slightly lower z in order of decreasing delay times: ELDs in systems with subgiant companions, MCh accumulations in the latter, mergers of double degenerates, ELDs in systems with nondegenerate He donors, core-collapse SNe (Fig. 2). The behavior of the dn/dz counts depends also on the geometrical z-dependent factors given by eqs. (4) and (5). In particular, the derivative of the product z2ξz changes sign from positive to negative at z ≈ 0.96. This factor shifts the maximum in the counts to a lower z. The steep rise of dn/dz at low z is entirely due to the expanding horizon. Similarly, in Model 2 (z-dependent dust opacity), the behavior of dn/dz at low z is dominated by the expansion of the comoving volume and the rates suggested by the two models are almost indistinguishable. However, already at z ∼ 0.5, the increase in the rates in Model 2 becomes somewhat less steep, reflecting the more moderate growth of the SFR. The rate of core-collapse SNe starts to decrease at z ≈ 1.2 despite the continuous growth of the SFR. This is a consequence of the negative ∂ξz ∂z . The rates of SNe Ia start to decline at a higher z, as a consequence of the longer delay times. The difference in the time delays between SNe II and the different hypothetical SNe Ia manifests itself in an increase in the SN Ia/SN II ratio at low z and its subsequent decline (Fig. 7). This feature was already -- 15 -- noticed by Yungelson & Livio (1998) for SNe Ia from double degenerates, but in the present study we find that (i) this effect is less pronounced due to the different approximation to the SFR and (ii) the redshift of the maximum of the ratio is different for different SNe Ia scenarios. The difference in the rate of decline of dn/dz at z >∼ 1 is clearly distinct in Models 1 and 2 and may provide important information about the star formation behavior. The most pronounced feature of dn/dz for both types of dust models is the disappearance of SNe Ia at z ≈ 3 for the channels of progenitors with relatively long delays. Thus, in principle, a determination of SNe Ia rates at z > ∼ 3 with NGST can unambiguously distinguish between different progenitor models. Long delay times are typical for both modes (Chandrasekhar or sub-Chandrasekhar explosions) of SNe Ia resulting from systems with subgiant donors. The relative role of different channels for SNe Ia changes with z. In both models 1 and 2 (for the dust) mergers of double degenerates dominate over ELDs in systems with He nondegenerate donors up to z <∼ 0.4. In Model 1, ELDs in systems with subgiants dominate over He-ELD at z <∼ 0.8 and over DD-Ch at z <∼ 1.3. In Model 2 these limits are at about z ∼ 1 and z ∼ 2.2. If it were the case that all three channels really contribute to SNe Ia but have somewhat different characteristics, one would expect to find variations in the statistical properties of SNe Ia with redshift. We will return to this point in the discussion. As expected, the cumulative numbers of SNe grow faster in the "low dust" case than in the model with dust. Only the cumulative counts of SNe II and SNe Ia from the DD-Ch and He-ELD channels grow continuously to high redshifts, while those for SNe involving subgiants saturate at z ∼ 3. To summarize this section: observations of SNe beyond z ≈ 1 can provide valuable -- 16 -- information on the star formation rate (see also §5). The counts of SNe Ia at z >∼ 3 will indicate the timescale of the delay between births of binaries and SN events and will then provide information on the nature of the progenitors. 4.2. Parameterized star formation rates The main uncertainty in the global SFR is due to the effects of dust obscuration in star-forming galaxies (see e.g. Calzetti & Heckman 1998; Pettini et al. 1998; for a discussion of the fraction of light absorbed by dust). Therefore, it is worthwhile to investigate the cosmic history of SNe for several parameterized SFR. We consider four parameterized modes of galactic star formation (intended to bracket and cover a range of possibilities): Model 3 -- constant star formation rate from z⋆ = 5 to z = 0; Model 4 -- a star formation burst which begins at z⋆ and has a constant SFR for 1 Gyr; Model 5 -- a star formation burst which begins at z⋆ and has a constant SFR for 4 Gyr; Model 6 -- an initial star formation burst which lasts for 4 Gyr with a constant SFR and converts 50% of the total mass into stars, followed by another stage of a lower constant SFR which produces the remaining 50% of the stars ("step-wise SFR"). For all the cases we normalize the SFR in such a way that the total amount of matter converted into stars is equal to the integral over time of Eq. (2). The overall normalization is of no real significance however, since we are interested in the qualitative behavior of SNe counts. The computations provide us with information on the behavior of SNe rates with redshift, for different star formation histories. The results provide insights into the -- 17 -- understanding the SNe histories in galaxies of different morphological types, which show a wide variety of star formation patterns both along the Hubble sequence and within particular classes (e.g. Sandage 1986; Hodge 1989; Kennicutt, Tamblyn, & Congdon 1994; Kennicutt 1998). Even among the Local Group dwarf galaxies one encounters very different star formation histories, including early bursts, almost constant SFR, and step-wise ones (e.g. Mateo 1998). Figures 5 and 6 present the number counts of SNe Ia per unit ∆z and the cumulative rates of events n(< z) for the above models. The results can be summarized as follows. 1. Models 3 and 4, with initial starbursts of different durations ∆τ , clearly predict an abrupt decline in the SNe II rate when moving from z⋆ to lower redshifts, reflecting the cessation of star formation. The redshift of this sharp decline in the rate indicates (for given cosmological parameters) the value of ∆τ . It also depends of course on z⋆. The behavior of SNe Ia from ELDs in systems with He donors (He-ELD) and Chandrasekhar mass SNe in systems with subgiant donors (SG-CH) shows a similar decline, but shifted to a lower z and less abrupt. For stellar populations with strong initial star formation bursts this means that, if He-ELD and SG-Ch SNe Ia were the only mechanisms for SNe Ia, then as one advances to higher redshifts, first the rate of SNe Ia and then the rate of SNe II would rapidly rise. In the case of SG-Ch SNe Ia the rate would rapidly decline at z ∼ 3.3. Such a behavior of the rates of SNe Ia in E-S0 galaxies would provide evidence supporting the SG-Ch mechanism for SNe Ia. 2. Strong initial peaks in the SFR followed by a variation of the SFR on a short timescale manifest themselves in changes in d2n/dz2 for SNe Ia. These changes are delayed (to lower redshifts) compared to the decrease in the SNe II rates. -- 18 -- 3. SNe Ia from the mergers of double degenerates (DD-Ch) are the only types of events which may show up close to z⋆ and which continue to z = 0 irrespective of the star formation mode. 4. Although SNe Ia from ELDs in subgiant systems (SG-ELD) start to explode only at z ≈ 3, in the constant SFR and step-wise SFR models, at z <∼ 2 the distribution of their number counts vs. z becomes very similar to the one from double degenerates (DD-Ch) both in morphology and in amplitude. These SNe, however, follow the variations in the SFR slightly slower. These two types of SNe Ia are the only events which may be present at low z even if the star formation process ceased long ago (see however §5). 5. SNe Ia from collapses of Chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs in subgiant systems (SG-Ch) may be observed only if the star formation still continues or ceased less than ≃ 2 Gyr ago (see however §5). The same is true for SNe from ELDs in systems with nondegenerate donors (He-ELD). A fast decline of the SNe Ia rate shortly after (at lower z) the decline of the SNe II rate would indicate that either He-ELD or SG-Ch occur. 6. In the case of a SFR which was almost constant during the past several Gyr there is no decline in the SNe Ia/SNe II ratio between z = 0 and 1. 7. The difference between the behavior of dn/dz for a constant-rate and for step-wise SFR models is not significant. This means that only a very significant increase in the SFR towards high z (like in Model 2) may be reflected in the behavior of the differential SNe counts. On the other hand, a rapid decline in the SFR beyond a certain redshift (like in Model 2) can be detected easily. 8. The counts of dn/dz in the redshift range z < ∼ 0.2 -- 0.4 can hardly provide any information about the SFR since they are dominated by the increase of the comoving -- 19 -- volume. 5. Discussion and Conclusions Since observations of SNe Ia are now being used as one of the main methods for the determination of cosmological parameters, the importance of identifying the progenitors of SNe Ia cannot be overemphasized. We have shown that different progenitor models result in different SNe Ia rates (or different ratios of frequencies of SNe Ia to those resulting from massive stars) as a function of redshift. One key difference, for example, is in the fact that in all the models that involve relatively long delays between the formation of the system and the SN event (e.g. models with subgiant donors), the ratio R(SNe Ia)/R(SNe II, Ia, Ic) decreases essentially to zero at z > ∼ 3 (Fig. 7). Thus, future observations with NGST will in principle be able to determine the viability of such progenitor models on the basis of the frequencies of SNe Ia at high redshifts. Probably the most important question that needs to be answered is the following: assuming that two (or more) different classes of progenitors may produce SNe Ia, is it possible that the rate of SNe Ia is entirely dominated by one class at low redshifts (z < 0.5) and by another at higher redshifts (0.5 < ∼ z < ∼ 1.2)? Clearly, if this were the case, then the suggestion of a cosmological constant would have to be re-examined (SNe Ia at the higher z only need to be systematically dimmer by ∼ 0.25 mag to mimic the existence of a cosmological constant). An examination of the qualitative behavior of the rates in Fig. 7 reveals that in principle, the rate at low redshifts could be dominated by ELDs, while the rate at higher redshifts by coalescing double-degenerates. However, if ELDs produce SNe Ia at all, these are probably of the underluminous variety (like SN 1991bg; e.g. Nugent et al. 1997; Livio 1999; Ruiz-Lapuente et al. 1997). Therefore, a division of this type would produce exactly the opposite effect to the one required to explain away the need for -- 20 -- a cosmological constant (the high redshift ones would be brighter). A second possibility is that the rate of SNe Ia resulting from the accumulation of MCh in systems with giant or subgiant components (SG-Ch) has been underestimated. This is in fact a very likely possibility. A number of potential ways have been suggested to increase the frequency of SNe Ia of this class (e.g. Hachisu, Kato & Nomoto 1999). These ways include: (i) mass stripping from the (sub-)giant companion by the strong wind from the white dwarf (this has the effect of increasing the range of mass ratios which result in stable mass transfer). (ii) An efficient angular momentum removal by the stellar wind in wide systems (where the wind velocity and orbital velocity are comparable; this increases the range of binary separations with result in interaction). While large uncertainties plague both of these suggestions (see Livio 1999 for a discussion), it is definitely possible that some physical processes which have not yet been properly included in the population synthesis calculations, will result in a significant increase in the rates from the channel with giant or subgiant companions. This means that in principle, the curve describing the SG-Ch channel (subgiant donor) in Fig. 7 (with the z-dependent dust opacity), may have to be shifted upwards (essentially parallel to itself, because of the involved delays). The curve could be shifted just enough for double-degenerates to dominate at redshifts z <∼ 0.5, while SG-Ch dominate at z >∼ 0.5. The question is now, could such a dominance shift be responsible for the apparent need for a cosmological constant? The answer is that this is definitely possible in principle. In particular, it has recently been suggested that the fiducial risetime of nearby SNe Ia is ∼ 2.5 days longer than that of high-redshift SNe Ia (Riess et al. 1999a,b). It is far from clear though, whether such a change in the risetime (if real) could be attributed to different progenitor classes or to other evolutionary effects. One possibility could be that because SNe Ia resulting from double-degenerates (if they indeed occur; Livio 1999) may have different surface compositions from those resulting from subgiant donors, this could affect the risetime. We would like to note, however, that we find the possibility of one -- 21 -- progenitor class dominating at low redshifts and another at high redshifts rather unlikely (see also Livio 1999). The reason is very simple. As Fig. 7 shows, even if the SG curve were to be shifted upwards, the result would be that the local (low z) sample would have to contain a significant fraction of the SNe resulting from the SG channel. Therefore, unless SNe Ia from the SG channel conspire to look identical to those from double-degenerates at low z, but different at high z, this would result in a much less homogeneous local sample than the observed one (which has 80 -- 90% of all SNe Ia being nearly identical "branch normals"; e.g. Branch 1998 and references therein). Consequently, it appears that the observational indication of the existence of a cosmological constant cannot be the result of us being "fooled" by different progenitor classes (this does not exclude the possibility of other evolutionary effects). Finally, our models indicate that a careful determination of the rates of SNe Ia as a function of redshift can place significant constraints on the cosmic star formation history, and on the significance of dust obscuration. This work was supported by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research grant No. 96- 02-16351. LRY acknowledges the hospitality of the Space Telescope Science Institute. ML acknowledges support from NASA Grant NAG5-6857. We acknowledge helpful discussions with N. Chugaj, M. Sazhin, and A. Tutukov, and useful comments by D. Branch. -- 22 -- REFERENCES Blain, A. W., Smail, I., Ivison, R. J., & Kneib, J.-P. 1998, astro-ph/9806062 Branch, D. 1998, ARAA, 36, 17 Branch, D., Livio, M., Yungelson, L., Boffi, F., & Baron, E. 1995, PASP, 107, 717 Branch, D., Romanishin, W., & Baron, E. 1996, ApJ., 465, 73 Calzetti, D. & Heckman, T. M. 1998, astro-ph/9806083 Canal, R., Ruiz-Lapuente, P., & Burkert, A. 1996, ApJ, 456, L101 Cappellaro, E., Turatto, M., Tsvetkov, D. Yu., Bartunov, O. S., Pollas, C., Evans, R., & Hamuy, M. 1997, A&A, 322, 431 Cassisi, S., Iben, I., & Tornamb`e, A. 1998, ApJ, 496, 376 Dahl´en, T. & Fransson, C. 1998, astro-ph/9809379 Ferguson, H. C. 1998, astro-ph/9801058 Hachisu, I., Kato, M., & Nomoto, K. 1996, ApJ, 470 , L97 (HKN96) Hachisu, I., Kato, M., & Nomoto, K. 1999, ApJ, in press Hamuy, M. et al. 1996, AJ, 112, 2398 Hodge, P. W., 1989, ARAA, 27, 139 Hoflich, P. & Khokhlov, A. 1996, ApJ, 457, 500 Hu, E. M., Cowie, L. L., & McMahon, R. G. 1998, ApJ, 502, L99 Hughes, D. H. et al. 1998, Nat, 394, 241 Iben, I., Jr. 1997, in Thermonuclear Supernovae, ed. P. Ruiz-Lapuente, R. Canal, & J. Isern, (Dordrecht: Kluwer), p. 111 -- 23 -- Jørgensen, H. E., Lipunov, V. M., Panchenko, I. E., Postnov, K. A., & Prokhorov, M. E. 1997, ApJ, 486, 110 Kennicutt, R. C. 1998, ARAA, 36, 189 Kennicutt, R. C., Tamblyn, P., & Congdon, C. W. 1994, ApJ, 435, 22 Kato, M., Saio, H., & Hachisu, I. 1989, ApJ, 340, 509 King, A. R. & van Teeseling, A., 1998, A&A in press Kobayashi, C., Tsujimoto, T., Nomoto, K., Hachisu, I., & Kato, M. 1998, astro-ph/9806335 Livio, M. 1999, in Supernovae Type Ia: Theory and Cosmology, eds. J. C. Niemeyer & J. W. Truran (Cambridge: CUP), in press Madau, P. 1997, in The Hubble Deep Field, eds. M. Livio, S. M. Fall, P. Madau, (Cambridge: CUP), p. 200 Madau, P. 1998a, in The Next Generation Space Telescope: Science Drivers and Technological Challenges, 34th Liege Astrophysics Colloquium, in press Madau, P. 1998b, astro-ph/9801005 Madau, P., Della Valle, M., & Panagia, N. 1998, M.N.R.A.S., 297, L17 (MDVP98) Mateo, M. 1998, ARAA, 36, 435 Nugent, P., Baron, E., Branch, D., Fisher, A., & Hanschildt, P. H. 1997, ApJ, 485, 812 Perlmutter, S. et al. 1999, ApJ, in press, astro-ph/9812133 Pettini, M., Kellogg, M., Steidel, C. C. et al. 1998, astro-ph/9806219 Riess, A. G. et al. 1998, AJ, 116, 1009 Riess, A. G., Filippenko, A. V., Li, W., Treffers, R. R., Schmidt, B. P., Qiu, Y., Hu, J., Armstrong, M., Faranda, C., & Thouvenot, E. 1999a, astro-ph/9907037 Riess, A. G., Filippenko, A. V., Li, W., & Schmidt, B. 1999b, astro-ph/9907038 -- 24 -- Ruiz-Lapuente, P. & Canal, R. 1998, ApJ, 497, L57 Ruiz-Lapuente, P., Burkert, A., & Canal, R. 1995, ApJ, 447, L69 Ruiz-Lapuente, P., Canal, R., & Burkert, A. 1997, in Thermonuclear Supernovae, ed. P. Ruiz-Lapuente, R. Canal, & J. Isern, (Dordrecht: Kluwer), p. 205 Sadat, R., Blanchard, A., Guiderdoni, B., Silk, J. 1998, A&A, 331, L69 Sandage, A. 1986, A&A, 161, 89 Steidel, C. C., Adelberger, K. L., Giavalisco, M., Dickinson, M., & Pettini, M. 1998, astro-ph/9811399 Stockman, P. & Mather, J. 1997, AAS, 191 Tutukov, A., Yungelson, L., & Iben, I. Jr. 1992, ApJ, 386, 197 Umeda, H., Nomoto, K., Yamaoka, H., Wanajo, S. 1998, astro-ph/9806336 Yungelson, L. & Tutukov, A. 1997, in Advances in Stellar Evolution, ed. R. T. Rood & A. Renzini (Cambridge: CUP), p. 237 Yungelson, L. & Livio, M. 1998, ApJ, 497, 168 Yungelson, L., Livio, M., Tutukov, A., & Kenyon, S. J. 1995, ApJ, 447, 656 Zel'dovich, Ya. B. & Novikov, I. D. 1983, The Structure and Evolution of the Universe, (Chicago: U. Chicago Press) This manuscript was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0. -- 25 -- Fig. 1. -- Evolutionary scenarios for the most "productive" potential progenitors of SNe Ia. Ch -- accumulation of a Chandrasekhar mass by a white dwarf and central carbon ignition. ELD -- accumulation of 0.15 M⊙ of He on top of a subChandrasekhar mass white dwarf. See text for details. Fig. 2. -- The rates of potentially explosive events after an instantaneous star formation burst. The rates are normalized to a formation of 4.7 M⊙ of stars per yr. He-ELD -- edge-lit detonations in systems with nondegenerate He donors; DD-Ch mergers of double degenerates with a total mass above MCh; SG-ELD -- edge-lit detonations in systems with subgiant donors; SG-Ch -- accumulations of MCh in systems with subgiant donors. Fig. 3. -- Number counts of SNe per unit ∆z vs. redshift for different channels of explosive events in Models 1 ("low dust") and 2 ("z-dependent dust opacity"). Notations as in Fig. 2. Fig. 4. -- Cumulative counts of SNe below a given redshift z for different channels of explosive events in Models 1 and 2. Notations as in Fig. 2. Fig. 5. -- Number counts of SNe per unit ∆z vs. redshift for different channels of explosive events and different parameterized star formation histories (Models 3 to 6). Notations as in Fig. 2. Fig. 6. -- Cumulative counts of SNe below a given redshift z for different channels of explosve events in Models 3 to 6. Notations as in Fig. 2. Fig. 7. -- The ratios of the rates of different possible SNe channels to core-collapse SNe, for different assumptions on the dust and the SFR (see text). Notations as in Fig. 2. This figure "f1.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f2.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f3a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f3b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f4a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f4b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f5a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f5b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f5c.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f5d.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f6a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f6b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f6c.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f6d.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f7a.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f7b.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f7c.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1 This figure "f7d.gif" is available in "gif"(cid:10) format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/astro-ph/9907359v1
astro-ph/0607567	1	0607	2006-07-25T18:50:40	An empirical temperature calibration for the Delta a photometric system. II. The A-type and mid F-type star	[ "astro-ph" ]	With the Delta a photometric system, it is possible to study very distant galactic and even extragalactic clusters with a high level of accuracy. This can be done with a classical color-magnitude diagram and appropriate isochrones. The new calibration presented in this paper is a powerful extension. For open clusters, the reddening is straightforward for an estimation via Isochrone fitting and is needed in order to calculate the reddening-free, temperature sensitive, index (g1-y)0. As a last step, the calibration can be applied to individual stars. Because no a-priori reddening-free photometric parameters are available for the investigated spectral range, we have applied the dereddening calibrations of the Stromgren uvbybeta system and compared them with extinction models for the Milky Way. As expected from the sample of bright stars, the extinction is negligible for almost all objects. As a next step, already established calibrations within the Stromgren uvbybeta, Geneva 7-color, and Johnson UBV systems were applied to a sample of 282 normal stars to derive a polynomial fit of the third degree for the averaged effective temperatures to the individual (g1-y)0 values with a mean of the error for the whole sample of Delta T(eff) is 134K, which is lower than the value in Paper I for hotter stars. No statistically significant effect of the rotational velocity on the precision of the calibration was found.	astro-ph	astro-ph	For open clusters, the reddening is straightforward for an estimation via Isochrone fitting and is needed in order to calculate the reddening-free, temperature sensitive, in- dex (g1 −y)0. As a last step, the calibration can be applied to individual stars. Because no a-priori reddening-free photometric parameters are available for the investigated spectral range, we have applied the dereddening calibra- tions of the Stromgren uvbyβ system and compared them with extinction models for the Milky Way. As expected from the sample of bright stars, the extinction is negligible for almost all objects. As a next step, already established calibrations within the Stromgren uvbyβ, Geneva 7-color, and Johnson U BV systems were applied to a sample of 282 normal stars to derive a polynomial fit of the third degree for the averaged effective temperatures to the indi- vidual (g1 − y)0 values. We derived an empirical tempera- ture calibration for the ∆a photometric system for A-type to mid F-type with a mean of the error for the whole sam- ple of ∆Tef f is 134 K, which is lower than the value in Paper I for hotter stars. No statistically significant effect of the rotational velocity on the precision of the calibration was found. We have derived a new intrinsically consistent, empirical, effective temperature calibration for a spectral range from early B-type to mid F-type, luminosity class V to III stars within the photometric ∆a system. The statis- tical mean error over the complete spectral range of about 140 to 240 K will allow to individual objects of far distant galactic be studied as well as extragalactic clusters with high accuracy. Key words. Stars: early-type -- techniques: photometric 6 0 0 2 l u J 5 2 1 v 7 6 5 7 0 6 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. ms4889rev3 (DOI: will be inserted by hand later) October 10, 2018 An empirical temperature calibration for the ∆a photometric system. II. The A-type and mid F-type stars E. Paunzen, A. Schnell, H.M. Maitzen Institut fur Astronomie der Universitat Wien, Turkenschanzstr. 17, A-1180 Wien, Austria Received 23 January 2006 / Accepted 22 June 2006 Abstract. With the ∆a photometric system, it is possible to study very distant galactic and even extragalactic clusters with a high level of accuracy. This can be done with a classical color-magnitude diagram and appropriate isochrones. The new calibration presented in this paper is a powerful extension. 1. Introduction We present the continuation of our efforts to derive an empirical temperature calibration for the photometric ∆a system (characteristics described in Paunzen et al. 2005b). In the first paper (Paunzen et al. 2005d, Paper I), the re- sults for the B-type stars and the applied methods were published. In total, 225 stars were used to derive effec- tive temperatures within the Stromgren uvbyβ, Geneva 7- color, and Johnson U BV systems based on (u −b), X, and (B −V )0, respectively. The final calibration for (g1 −y)0 in the ∆a photometric system is valid for effective tempera- tures between 33000 and 10000 K and yields a statistical mean error of 238 K for the whole spectral range. In this paper we investigate the A-type to mid F-type objects that exhibit an increase line blanketing and lu- minosity effects without the availability of any a-priori reddening-free parameter. Only Stromgren β does, in gen- eral, not depend on the extinction. However, it is sensitive not only to the effective temperature alone but also to the luminosity (Gerbaldi et al. 1999). Based on the methods used in Paper I, the following parameters were used for our purpose: (b − y)0, (B2 − V 1)0, and (B − V )0. The scatter of the derived effective temperatures for spectral types between A0 and A3 is not larger than that for later type stars because our sample of bright galactic-field stars is almost free of reddening. Applying the same selection criteria as in Paper I yields 282 luminosity class V to III A-type to mid F- type stars. The derived mean errors for the effective tem- perature calibrations within all photometric systems are smaller than those from Paper I. With the established intrinsically consistent, empiri- cal, effective temperature calibrations for B-type to mid F-type stars, it is now possible to study individual ob- jects in very distant galactic open clusters (Paunzen et al. Correspondence to: [email protected] 2005c) and extragalactic systems (Paunzen et al. 2005a) for which, in general, no photometric data are available within a standard system. 2. Sample of program stars The selection criteria for the A-type to mid F-type ob- jects are exactly the same as in Paper I and will not be repeated here. The Johnson, Geneva and Stromgren colors are excerpted from the General Catalogue of Photometric Data (GCPD, http://obswww.unige.ch/gcpd/gcpd.html, Mermilliod et al. 1997). The ∆a photometry is from the paper by Vogt et al. (1998). The final list (Table 1) includes 282 objects and is only available in electronic form at the CDS or upon request from the first author. This table includes the identification of objects, the complete Stromgren uvbyβ, (g1 − y)0, (B − V )0, and (B2−V 1)0 values, V magnitudes, E(b−y) values, effective temperature with the corresponding errors, v sin i values, and spectral types, respectively. The distribution of Johnson V and (B − V )0 for our sample is shown in Fig. 1. The estimation of the reddening is explained in more detail in Sect. 3. The distribution of V is comparable to the one published in Paper I, peaking at V = 6.25, mag, whereas the one for (B − V )0 exhibits two maxima at spectral types of about A0 (+0.0 mag) and F0 (+0.3 mag, see also Table 2). However, there is a statistically significant number of objects in the complete investigated spectral range. 3. Estimation of the reddening Our sample comprises stars later than a spectral type of A0. A typical A0 main sequence object has a mean abso- lute magnitude of about +0 mag. A visual magnitude of 7 mag (Fig. 1) then corresponds to a distance of 250 pc, E. Paunzen, A. Schnell, H.M. Maitzen: An empirical temperature calibration for ∆a: A and F-type stars 3 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 (B - V)0 0.3 0.4 50 40 30 20 10 0 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 s r a t s f o r e b m u N s r a t s f o r e b m u N 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 V Fig. 1. The distribution of Johnson (B − V )0 (upper panel) and V (lower panel) for our sample of 282 main sequence A to mid F-type objects. The distribution of (B − V )0 shows two maxima at spectral types of about A0 and F0. for which the reddening can be almost neglected in all directions (Neckel et al. 1980). The calibrations following photometric in the Stromgren uvbyβ system were used to estimate the reddening according to the valid spectral range that is estimated by the standard relations of the different indices: -- A0 − A3: Crawford (1978) and Hilditch et al. (1983) -- A3 − F0: Crawford (1979) and Domingo & Figueras (1999) -- later than F0: Crawford (1973) and Schuster & Nissen (1989) The calibrations are not very reliable for stars with spec- tral types between A0 and A3 (Gerbaldi et al. 1999), mainly because for these stars, the reddening-free parame- ter β is no longer a temperature indicator alone but is also sensitive to the luminosity, therefore the standard relation of (b − y)0 versus m0 as listed by Hilditch et al. (1983) and their method of calibration were used. Only some objects that fall outside the given relation were dereddened using the calibration by Crawford (1978). Furthermore, we used the interstellar extinction model by Chen et al. (1998) to derive the reddening for all pro- gram stars as described in Paper I. The values from the calibration of the Stromgren uvbyβ and the model by Chen et al. (1998) very closely agree. As expected, all objects have a calibrated total absorption AV of less than 0.35 mag with 233 (82% of the complete sample) stars even lower than 0.05 mag. Taking the following relations into account: AV = 3.1E(B − V ) = 4.3E(b − y) = 4.95E(B2 − V 1) = 7.95E(g1 − y), (1) the effect of the reddening on the calibration for our sam- ple can be neglected and does not introduce a significant error source. 4. The calibration of the effective temperature As in Paper I, the first step was to derive the effective temperature for each individual star within the Geneva, Stromgren, and Johnson photometric systems. For this purpose we used the reddening relations as listed in Eq. 1 to calculate the unreddened indices that are necessary to make the proper calibration as listed. Geneva system: the calibration by Kunzli et al (1997) is the most recent for the investigated spectral range. For intermediate stars hotter than 8500 K, they use the pa- rameters pT and pG, which are linear combinations of the seven Geneva colors. Those two indices can be dereddened with the following relations: pT0 = pT − E(B2 − V 1) and pG0 = pG − 1.1E(B2−V 1). For cooler objects, the grids of m2 and d versus (B2 − V 1)0 serve as a calibration tablet. The definition of these indices are listed in Golay (1994). Stromgren system: Napiwotzki et al. (1993) investigated several calibrations based on a0 and r∗ for hotter, as well as β, and c0 for cooler objects yielding a rather unsatisfac- tory result. Finally, they established a Tef f versus (b − y)0 relation (Eq. 10 therein), which was applied to our sam- ple. Johnson system: we used the semi-empirical Tef f versus (B − V )0 relation as listed in Gray (1992; Eq. 15.14). It is based on synthetic colors from theoretical stellar atmo- spheres that are normalized to observations of spectro- scopic binary systems, as well as bright stars. It is given as log Tef f = + 3.988 − 0.881(B − V )0 + 2.142(B − V )2 0 − 3.614(B − V )3 − 1.4727(B − V )5 0 + 3.2637(B − V )4 0 0 + 0.2600(B − V )6 0 (2) and is valid for all A-type to mid F-type, luminosity class III to V objects. It superseded the relation listed in Code et al. (1976). The individual effective temperature values for the three photometric systems were first tested for their in- trinsic consistency and then averaged. The final values, together with the standard deviations of the means, are listed in the Table 1 which is electronically-available. No 4 E. Paunzen, A. Schnell, H.M. Maitzen: An empirical temperature calibration for ∆a: A and F-type stars 11000 10000 9000 8000 7000 f f e T 6000 -0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 -0.18 -0.12 -0.06 0.00 0.06 0.12 0.18 0.24 (b - y)0 (B2 - V1)0 f f e T 11000 10000 9000 8000 7000 6000 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 -0.03 0.00 0.03 0.06 0.09 0.12 0.15 0.18 (B - V)0 (g1 - y)0 Fig. 2. Mean relation between the effective temperature and (b − y)0, (B2 − V 1)0, (B − V )0, as well as (g1 − y)0 for A-type to mid F-type, luminosity class V to III objects. statistical significant outliers in any photometric system were detected. 5. The result for the ∆a photometric system The relation between the mean effective temperature and the different temperature sensitive indices for the four in- vestigated photometric systems is shown in Fig. 2. The er- rors are constant over the complete spectral range. There is a larger scatter only for the Geneva (B2 − V 1)0 index at effective temperatures hotter than 9000 K. We checked this region with the grids of pT0 and pG0 originally used. It is exactly where both indices become zero for the Main Sequence and small shifts result in larger uncertainties. It therefore seems to be an intrinsic numerical problem of the grids themselves; however the overall statistical error of (B2 − V 1)0 is satisfying. The final calibrations param- eterized as third-degree polynomials are: log Tef f = +3.9793(4) − 1.34(2) · (b − y)0 + +4.90(15) · (b − y)2 0 − 8.06(38) · (b − y)3 0 (3) = +3.8853(4) − 0.459(5) · (B2 − V 1)0 + +1.02(2) · (B2 − V 1)2 0 − −2.36(16) · (B2 − V 1)3 0 = +3.9825(4) − 0.670(10) · (B − V )0 + (4) +1.05(7) · (B − V )2 0 − 0.98(12) · (B − V )3 0 (5) = +3.9817(8) − 1.79(5) · (g1 − y)0 + +8.14(77) · (g1 − y)2 0 − 19(3) · (g1 − y)3 0 (6) with the mean of the errors for the whole sample of ∆Tef f [(b − y)0, (B2 − V 1)0, (B − V )0, (g1 − y)0] = [66,100,71,134 K]. These are statistical errors for the com- plete sample. The errors for individual stars are, of course, larger than that. Note that the error for the Johnson (B − V )0 calibration is surprisingly small. It shows the overall robustness of broad-band indices against metallic- ity and luminosity effects, which makes them superior for statistical analysis of larger samples over a wide spectral range. However, it has to be emphasized that it is a-priori not possible to apply dereddening methods in the Johnson U BV system for stars cooler than B9 (Johnson 1958). The statistical error for (g1 − y)0, 134 K is significantly smaller than the one for the hotter stars (238 K). But one has to keep in mind that the absolute errors are over the complete spectral range from early B-type to F-type con- stant, but only the relative one, as listed, is decreasing. Table 2 lists the mean relations between the effective temperature and (B − V )0, (b − y)0, (B2 − V 1)0, as well as (g1 − y)0, depending on spectral types (taken from Paunzen et al. 2005b). Only standard spectral types of the Yerkes system (Keenan 1985) are given. The (B − V )0 and (g1 − y)0 values for A0 are, within the error limits, identical to those derived in Paper I (Table 1), which guar- antees an intrinsic consistent calibration from B0 to F5 for the ∆a photometric system. As in Paper I, we checked the effect of high v sin i ob- jects on the derived calibrations in the same manner. This might be an issue for early A-type objects only because the rotational velocities decrease significantly for cooler objects (Fekel et al. 2004). Again, no statistical significant effect of the rotational velocity, which can be distinguished from other error sources, was found on the precision of the calibration. The detailed calibration procedure for determining the effective temperature within the ∆a photometric system is given in Paper I. We only give a short overview of the main method here. After the estimation of the reddening E(g1 − y), the dereddened standard (g1 − y)0 has to be calculated and the calibration for the appropriate spectral region applied. As a final check, a comparison with the values for other photometric systems, if available, should be performed. 6. Conclusion In the second and last parts of this series, we established an empirically effective temperature calibration for the ∆a photometric system for main sequence (luminosity class V to III) A-type to mid F-type star. Applying the same methods as in Paper I, the calibrations in the Stromgren uvbyβ, Geneva 7-color, and Johnson U BV photometric systems based on (b − y)0, (B2 − V 1)0, and (B − V )0, re- spectively are used to derive effective temperature for 282 normal type objects. The final calibrations are expressed third-degree polynomials. As expected from the brightness and thus the distance from the Sun (< 250 pc) for our sample, the reddening can E. Paunzen, A. Schnell, H.M. Maitzen: An empirical temperature calibration for ∆a: A and F-type stars 5 Johnson, H. L. 1958, Lowell Obs. Bull., No. 4, 37 Keenan, P.C. 1985, in Calibration of fundamental stellar quan- tities, Dordrecht, D. Reidel Publishing Co., p. 121 Kunzli, M., North, P., Kurucz, R. L., Nicolet, B. 1997, A&AS, 122, 51 Mermilliod, J.-C., Mermilliod, M., & Hauck, B. 1997, A&AS, 124, 349 Napiwotzki, R., Schonberner, D., & Wenske, V. 1993, A&A, 268, 653 Neckel, Th., Klare, G., & Sarcander, M. 1980, A&AS, 42, 251 Paunzen, E., Pintado, O. I., Maitzen, H. M., Claret, A., 2005a, MNRAS, 362, 1025 Paunzen, E., Stutz, Ch., & Maitzen, H. M. 2005b, A&A, 441, 631 Paunzen, E., Netopil, M., Iliev, I. Kh., Maitzen, H. M., Claret, A., Pintado, O. I. 2005c, A&A, 443, 157 Paunzen, E., Schnell, A., & Maitzen, H. M. 2005d, A&A, 444, 941 (Paper I) Schuster, W. J., & Nissen, P. E. 1989, A&A, 221, 65 Vogt, N., Kerschbaum, F., Maitzen, H. M., Fa´undez-Abans, M. 1998, A&AS, 130, 455 Table 2. Mean relation between the effective temperature and (B−V )0, (b−y)0, (B2−V 1)0, as well as (g1−y)0 for A- type to mid F-type, luminosity class V to III objects. Only spectral types according to the Yerkes system (Keenan 1985) are listed. Spec. A0 A2 A3 A5 A7 F0 F2 F3 F5 Tef f 10000 8750 8300 7900 7500 7050 6750 6650 6450 (B − V )0 −0.025 +0.067 +0.112 +0.161 +0.221 +0.304 +0.368 +0.390 +0.433 (b − y)0 −0.015 +0.031 +0.055 +0.082 +0.120 +0.185 +0.238 +0.254 +0.284 (B2 − V 1)0 −0.160 −0.093 −0.060 −0.024 +0.022 +0.087 +0.141 +0.159 +0.196 (g1 − y)0 −0.010 +0.025 +0.042 +0.062 +0.087 +0.125 +0.155 +0.165 +0.184 almost be neglected for most of the objects. This is im- portant because no reddening-free photometric parameter is a-priori available for the whole investigated spectral do- main. The established standard system guarantees a direct link to the calibration for B-type stars published in Paper I. It is therefore possible to calibrate effective tempera- tures via (g1 − y)0 in a consistent way for spectral types from B0 to F5 for luminosity classes V to III with a con- stant absolute error of a few percent. This will allow us to independently investigate individ- ual stars of distant galactic, as well as extragalactic open clusters within the ∆a photometric system, to a high level of accuracy. Acknowledgements. This research was performed within the projects P17580 and P17920 of the Austrian Fonds zur Forderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung (FwF). Use was made of the SIMBAD database, operated at the CDS, Strasbourg, France, and of the NASA's Astrophysics Data System. We would like thank the referee for her/his important comments pointing at serious problems in the first version. References Chen, B., Vergely, J. L., Valette, B., Carraro, G. 1998, A&A, 336, 137 Code, A. D., Bless, R. C., Davis, J., Brown, R. H. 1976, ApJ, 203, 417 Crawford, D. L. 1975, AJ, 80, 955 Crawford, D. L. 1978, AJ, 83, 48 Crawford, D. L. 1979, AJ, 84, 1858 Domingo, A., & Figueras, F. 1999, A&A, 343, 446 Fekel, F. C., Warner, P. B., & Kaye, A. B. 2004, in Stellar Rotation, ed. A. Maeder, & Ph. Eenens, San Francisco, ASP Conf. Series, 215, 53 Gerbaldi, M., Faraggiana, R., Burnage, R., Delmas, F., G´omez, A. E., Grenier, S. 1999, A&AS, 137, 273 Golay, M. 1994, in The MK process at 50 years. A powerful tool for astrophysical insight, ed. Ch. Corbally, R. O. Gray, & R. F. Garrison, San Francisco, ASP Conf. Series, 60, 164 Gray, D. F. 1992, The Observation and Analysis of Stellar Photospheres, Cambridge University Press Hilditch, R. W., Hill, G., & Barnes, J. V., 1983, MNRAS, 204, 241
astro-ph/0204489	1	0204	2002-04-29T13:53:08	Is the EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203 the radio galaxy NGC 6251?	[ "astro-ph" ]	We discuss the nature of the unidentified EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203. In an effort to identify the gamma-ray source, we have examined X-ray images of the field from ROSAT PSPC, ROSAT HRI, and ASCA GIS. Of the several faint X-ray point sources in the error circle of 3EG J1621+8203, most are stars or faint radio sources, unlikely to be counterparts to the EGRET source. The most notable object in the gamma-ray error box is the bright FR I radio galaxy NGC 6251. If 3EG J1621+8203 corresponds to NGC 6251, then it would be the second radio galaxy to be detected in high energy gamma rays, after Cen A, which provided the first clear evidence of the detection above 100 MeV of an AGN with a large-inclination jet. If the detection of more radio galaxies by EGRET has been limited by its threshold sensitivity, there exists the exciting possibility that new high energy gamma-ray instruments, with much higher sensitivity, will detect a larger number of radio galaxies in the future.	astro-ph	astro-ph	ACCEPTED FOR PUBLICATION IN The Astrophysical Journal, August 2002 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 14/09/00 IS THE EGRET SOURCE 3EG J1621+8203 THE RADIO GALAXY NGC 6251? R. MUKHERJEE Dept. of Physics & Astronomy, Barnard College, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027 J. HALPERN, N. MIRABAL & E. V. GOTTHELF Dept. of Physics & Astronomy, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027 Accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal, August 2002 ABSTRACT We discuss the nature of the unidentified EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203. In an effort to identify the gamma- ray source, we have examined X-ray images of the field from ROSAT PSPC, ROSAT HRI, and ASCA GIS. Of the several faint X-ray point sources in the error circle of 3EG J1621+8203, most are stars or faint radio sources, unlikely to be counterparts to the EGRET source. The most notable object in the gamma-ray error box is the bright FR I radio galaxy NGC 6251. If 3EG J1621+8203 corresponds to NGC 6251, then it would be the second radio galaxy to be detected in high energy gamma rays, after Cen A, which provided the first clear evidence of the detection above 100 MeV of an AGN with a large-inclination jet. If the detection of more radio galaxies by EGRET has been limited by its threshold sensitivity, there exists the exciting possibility that new high energy gamma-ray instruments, with much higher sensitivity, will detect a larger number of radio galaxies in the future. Subject headings: gamma rays: observations -- X-rays: observations -- gamma-rays: individual (3EG J1621+8203) -- radio galaxy: individual (NGC 6251) 1. INTRODUCTION 2. THE GAMMA RAY OBSERVATIONS Surveys of the gamma-ray sky by the Energetic Gamma Ray Experiment Telescope (EGRET) on the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory (CGRO) in the 30 MeV to 10 GeV energy range have revealed 271 point sources of gamma rays (Hartman et al. 1999). Of these the largest group of identified sources are the active galaxies of the blazar class. Blazars are sources with high gamma-ray luminosity, which are characterized by flat ra- dio spectra, rapid temporal variability at most frequencies, and a high degree of optical polarization. Besides the blazars, only two other extragalactic sources have been detected by EGRET, namely the radio galaxy Cen A, and the normal galaxy LMC. Most of the 65% other sources remain unidentified due to lack of convincing counterparts at other wavelengths. EGRET sources have large error contours, typically ∼ 0.5◦ - 1◦, which makes identifications on the basis of position alone challenging. The principle method of identification of the EGRET sources relies on finding positional coincidences with flat-spectrum radio quasars (e.g. Thompson et al. 1995) or is based on the statistical evidence that blazars are the domi- nant population (e.g. Mattox et al. 1997; Mattox, Hartman & Reimer 2001), relying in part on the sources' 5 GHz flux den- sity. Often additional information from observations at other wavebands are used to aid in the identification of the EGRET sources. Progress has been made with recent studies in the X- ray band carried out for several EGRET fields (e.g. Roberts et al. 2001), and used to suggest counterparts for a few unidenti- fied EGRET sources, such as 3EG J2227+6122 (Halpern et al. 2001a), 3EG J1835+5918 (Mirabal et al. 2000; 2001; Reimer et al. 2001), and 3EG J2016+2657 (Mukherjee et al. 2000; Halpern et al. 2001b). In this article we present gamma-ray and X-ray observa- tions of one unidentified EGRET source, 3EG J1621+8203. In particular, we examine the evidence in order to see if 3EG J1621+8203 could be a second radio galaxy to be detected in high energy gamma-rays by EGRET. 3EG J1621+8203 is a high latitude source located at l=115.53, b=31.77, with a 95% confidence error radius of 0◦.85 (Hartman et al. 1999). Recently, Mattox, Hartman, & Reimer (2001) have generated elliptical fits to the 95% confidence con- tours for the Third EGRET Catalog (3EG) sources. This analy- sis yields an error ellipse with semi-major and semi-minor axes of 0◦.97 and 0◦.74, respectively. Figure 1 shows the EGRET source position superimposed on the ROSAT X-ray image that is described in §3. 3EG J1621+8203 is not very bright in high energy gamma rays, and individual viewing periods yielded near-threshold de- tections by EGRET. In the cumulative exposure from multiple EGRET viewings, 3EG J1621+8203 was clearly detected and the measured flux above 100 MeV was 1.1 × 10- 7 photon cm- 2 s- 1 (Hartman et al. 1999). The background-subtracted γ-ray spectrum of 3EG J1621+8203 was determined by dividing the EGRET energy band of 30 MeV -- 10 GeV into 6 bins and estimating the number of source photons in each interval, following the EGRET spectral analysis technique of Nolan et al. (1993). The data were fitted to a simple power law model of the form F(E) = k(E/E0)- α photon cm- 2 s- 1 MeV,- 1 where F(E) is the flux measured at an energy E. The photon spectral index α and the coefficient k are the free parameters of the fit. The energy normalization factor E0 is chosen so that the statistical errors in the power-law index and the overall normalization are uncorre- lated. The fit to the gamma-ray spectrum of 3EG 1621+6203 yielded a photon spectral index of 2.27±0.53 and is shown in Figure 2. The majority of the high energy photons for this source are in the 100-500 MeV band. 3. THE X-RAY OBSERVATIONS Archival X-ray imaging observations were available for the field of the EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203. ROSAT (Roent- gen Satellite) observations with the Position Sensitive Propor- tional Counter (PSPC) in the range 0.2 -- 2.0 keV covered most 1 2 of the error contour of 3EG J1621+8203. Additional partial coverage was also available from the ROSAT High Resolution Imager (HRI) and the ASCA (Advanced Satellite for Cosmol- ogy and Astrophysics) Gas Imaging Spectrometer (GIS). His- torically, these fields have been studied in X-rays because they contained the radio-loud active galaxy NGC 6251 (e.g. Sam- bruna, Eracleous, & Mushotzky 1999; Turner et al. 1997; Mack, Kerp & Klein 1997; Birkinshaw & Worrall 1993), and the gamma-ray burst GRB 970815, which generated target-of- opportunity observations (Murakami et al. 1997). FIG. 1. -- ROSAT PSPC soft X-ray image of 3EG J1621+8203, exposure- corrected and smoothed with a 3 × 3 top hat kernel. The scaling has been adjusted to highlight the faint emission. The circle corresponds to the ∼ 95 % confidence contours from the 3EG catalog (Hartman et al. 1999). The dashed ellipse is the 95% error contour derived from elliptical fits to the 3EG data (Mattox, Hartman, & Reimer 2001). The numbers and letters correspond to sources described in §3 and Tables 1 and 2. We have created ROSAT PSPC image of the field of 3EG J1621+8203 by co-adding exposure corrected sky maps of 14.7 ks of data taken during 1991 March 12-15, as shown in Fig. 1. The ROSAT HRI and ASCA GIS images of the partial field of 3EG J1621+8203 are shown in Fig. 3. The figures also show the EGRET positions for the source, both as derived from the 3EG catalog, as well as that from the elliptical fits to the EGRET data. In the archival ROSAT and ASCA data overlapping the EGRET 95% error circle ellipse of 3EG J1621+8203 we find several faint X-ray point sources. In addition, we have also searched the ROSAT All Sky Survey (RASS) catalog for sources in the field of 3EG J1621+8203, particularly in the re- gions not covered by the pointed ROSAT PSPC and HRI data. The source positions are marked in figures 1 and 3, and listed in Table 1. Count rates for the ASCAand ROSATsources were obtained following the method described in Gotthelf & Kaspi (1998). Photons were extracted using a 2′ radius aperture and the background contribution was estimated using a large annu- lus away from the source. FIG. 2. -- Photon spectrum of 3EG J1621+8203 in the the 30 MeV to 10 GeV energy range with superimposed fit to a simple power-law model. The ROSAT sources are listed in Table 1 along with their background subtracted count rates, detection significances, and hardness ratios. Sources with count rates below 2.4 × 10- 3 cts/s are not listed in the table. The faintest source in Table 1 is a detection at the 3.0σ level, with a background subtracted count rate of 0.0020 ±0.0006 cts/s in a 2.0′ diameter circular aperture. For this analysis we report all sources down to the 3σ detection level. The sources listed reached a minimum detectable intrin- sic flux of 1.3 × 10- 14 erg cm- 2 s- 1 in the 0.1 -- 2.4 keV band, assuming a power-law photon spectral index of 2.0, and no ab- sorption (estimated NH is ∼ 5 × 1020 cm,- 2 is expected to have a small effect). We have searched for optical and radio counterparts to the ROSAT and ASCA point sources shown in figures 1 and 3. Most of the X-ray point sources have possible optical coun- terparts, as listed in Table 1, and some are coincident with faint radio sources. Individual sources denoted by their source num- bers in Table 1 are described in the following section. 4. NOTES ON INDIVIDUAL SOURCES 1. NGC6251: This is the bright FR I radio galaxy (Bicknell 1994; Urry & Padovani 1995) at a redshift of 0.0234 (implied distance 91 Mpc for H0 = 75 km s- 1 Mpc- 1). NGC 6251 is the parent galaxy of an exceptional radio jet from pc to Mpc scale which makes an angle of ∼ 45◦ to our line of sight (Sudou & Taniguchi 2000). High dynamic range observations of NGC 6251 with the VLBI show the presence of a bright core, and an asymmetric jet, that implies relativistic beaming in this source (Jones et al. 1986). The VLBI observations are described fur- ther in §6. NGC 6251 has been studied in X-rays in the past. A detailed investigation of the ROSATPSPC data was carried out X-RAY SOURCES IN THE FIELDS OF 3EG J1621+8203 TABLE 1 3 Optical/Radio Position 16 32 32.0 +82 32 16 16 41 08.6 +82 33 09 ∆d 1" 17" #a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14b 15b 16b 17 RA Dec cts/s HRc 16 32 32.5 16 41 05.1 82 32 15 82 32 54 16 24 30.0 16 24 12.7 16 22 32.6 16 25 13.2 16 25 27.3 16 46 04.1 16 39 00.9 16 25 29.6 16 44 12.6 16 41 18.9 16 42 58.1 16 03 24.5 16 06 52.0 16 13 17.3 16 37 20.6 82 19 00 82 32 48 82 37 06 82 36 13 82 34 49 82 02 34 82 35 47 82 14 39 82 30 07 82 07 56 82 01 02 81 42 19 81 30 28 81 23 33 82 07 36 0.102 0.053 0.006 0.005 0.008 0.004 0.002 0.503 0.004 0.005 0.009 0.014 0.016 0.016 0.003 0.010 ... 0.92 0.99 0.45 0.92 0.66 0.83 0.91 0.24 0.57 0.74 0.33 0.03 0.13 ... ... ... ... Suggestede Identification NGC 6251, Radio Galaxy 2E 1646.6+8238, Galaxy Cluster, z = 0.26 USNO, R = 17.4, B = 16.9 USNO, R = 18.4, B = 19.4 R = 20.0, B = 20.2 USNO, R = 15.0, B = 16.2 USNO, R = 18.9, B = 19.1 NVSS, 46.2 mJy at 1.4 GHz HD 153751 (RS CVn type) USNO, R = 14.5, B = 15.6 10" 13" 3.6" 8" 8" 8" 25" 3" 16" WN B1630.5+8221, 52 mJy at 0.325 GHz USNO, R = 18.3, B = 18.0 USNO, R = 13.1, B = 14.4 ... BD+82 477, B = 10.05, G0 V > 24.3, GRB 970815 USNO, R = 13.6, B = 14.3 Seyfert 1, z = 0.0402 16 24 26.2 +82 18 53 16 24 06.0 +82 32 49 16 22 34.0 +82 37 04 16 25 13.4 +82 36 21 16 25 28.2 +82 34 57 16 25 27.7 +82 34 57 16 45 58.2 +82 02 14 16 39 01.9 +82 35 49 16 25 31.4 +82 14 55 16 44 07.8 +82 30 06 16 41 11.8 +82 07 53 ... 16 03 26.5 +81 42 21 .... 16 13 20.6 +81 23 33 16 37 27.3 +82 07 07.5 10" 15" ... 4" ... 8" ... (a) Identifying number in ROSAT PSPC image, Fig. 1. (b) ROSAT HRI source, indicated in Fig. 3. (c) Hardness ratio; HR = (B - A)/(B + A), where A is the count rate in the energy range 0.1-0.4 keV, and B is the count rate in the 0.5-2.0 keV band (Voges, et al. 1999). (d) Positional offset from the optical/radio position. (e) Most of the USNO objects are only suggested IDs, based on positional coincidence and/or color. by Birkinshaw & Worrall (1993), who found the X-ray emis- sion to be consistent with a point source at the position of the nucleus. Some extended X-ray emission surrounding the nu- cleus of NGC 6251 was noted, and a flat-spectrum power-law component (photon spectral index Γ ∼ 1) plus emission of a thermal plasma (kT ∼ 0.5 keV) was found to fit the ROSAT data best. The X-ray jet was studied in some detail by Mack, Kerp & Klein (1997) who found that the X-ray emission in the jet is mostly due to bremsstahlung and line emission of hot, thin plasma, rather than synchrotron or inverse Compton scat- tering. The ASCAdata for NGC 6251 were analyzed by Turner et al. (1997) and Sambruna, Eracleous, & Mushotzky (1999). The ASCA spectrum was best modelled with a hard power law Γ = 1.83+0.21 - 0.18 plus a thermal plasma component kT = 1.04+0.21 - 0.18 keV that is harder than observed in the ROSATdata (Sambruna, Eracleous, & Mushotzky 1999). 2. RXJ1641.2+8233: A galaxy cluster, at a redshift of 0.26, corresponding to the Einstein Imaging Proportional Counter (IPC) source 2E 1646.6+8238. This is an extended X-ray source with 90 galaxies within 3′ of the X-ray centroid, and all within 3 magnitudes of the three brightest galaxies (Tucker, Tananbaum & Remillard 1995). Another X-ray point source, 2RXP J164016.6+823203 is located close to the galaxy cluster. It is not clear if this is a separate source or part of the cluster. 7. This is a possible QSO, based on its blue color and asso- ciation with a weak radio source. 8. HD153751: Also known as SAO 2770, this is the bright- est X-ray source in the ROSAT image of 3EG J1621+8203. It is a variable star of the RS CVn type (Eker 1992). It has a B magnitude of 5.098 and a V magnitude of 4.22. Its spectral type is G5III. 10. WNB1630.5+8221: A weak radio source with a flux density of about 58 mJy at 0.925 GHz. 14. BD+82477: Present only in a ROSATHRI image of the region, it is also known as SAO 2659, and is a star of B and V magnitudes of 10.05 and 9.44, respectively, and spectral type G0 (Perryman et al. 1997). 17. 1AXG J163720+8207: Using the MDM 2.4m tele- scope we have spectroscopically identified this source with a reddened Seyfert 1 galaxy at z=0.0402. The coordinates of this galaxy are (J2000) 16 37 27.3, +82 07 07.5. (It should not be confused with its physical companion, the galaxy IRAS F16419+8213, which lies 1′.3 away and has the same redshift, but only H II region emission lines.) This X-ray source is there- fore unlikely to be the EGRET source. Source 5 was imaged on the MDM 1.3 m, and an object with R = 20.0 and B = 20.2 was found in the field. Such color is typical of a QSO. The field of source 15 was empty in the op- tical down to the DSS limit. We have observed this field at the MDM, and there is no optical counterpart to a V magni- tude limit of 24.3. Source 15 is the possible afterglow of GRB 970815 (Smith et al. 1999; Murakami et al. 1997). The ASCA and ROSAT fields were observed as a result of the target of opportunity generated by the gamma-ray burst. Source 15 is a weak X-ray source seen both in the ASCA and ROSAT im- ages, and is slightly outside the error box of the GRB event, as reported by the RXTE/ASM (Smith et al. 1997). ASCA ob- served the source three days after the GRB event, and the flux of source 15 remained stable at ∼ 3 × 10- 13 erg cm- 2 s- 1 dur- ing the observations. The association of source 15 with GRB 970815 remains uncertain. 4 TABLE 2 ROSATALL SKY SURVEY SOURCES IN THE FIELD OF 3EG J1621+8203a Numberb Source Name a b c d e f g h i 1RXS J163525.2+825330 1RXS J161242.6+821525 1RXS J160752.0+821316 1RXS J160452.7+820748 1RXS J162554.6+815602 1RXS J160733.9+812118 1RXS J163027.4+813206 1RXS J163220.1+813201 1RXS J163121.3+812641 Cts/s 0.010 0.009 0.016 0.022 0.012 0.014 0.025 0.015 0.022 Optical Position 16 35 14.66 +82 53 31.7 16 12 46.30 +82 15 44.2 16 07 56.62 +82 13 03.2 16 04 56.66 +82 07 47.1 16 25 58.97 +81 55 56.7 ... 16 30 24.12 +81 32 09.6 16 32 23.19 +81 31 45.2 16 31 21.99 +81 26 43.7 ∆c Magnituded 20" 21" 16" 8" 11" ... 8" 17" 3" R = 17.4, B = 18.2 R = 18.7, B = 19.7 R = 12.7, B = 13.1 R = 15.7, B = 17.4 R = 19.0, B = 18.8 ... R = 14.6, B = 16.3 R = 12.4, B = 13.5 R = 17.6, B = 19.0 (a) ROSAT all sky survey sources not seen in the pointed PSPC and HRI images. (b) Identifying number in the ROSAT images (Fig. 1 & Fig. 3). (c) Positional offset from the optical position. (d) Most of the USNO stars are only suggested IDs, based on the fact that they are the nearest. The remaining numbered sources, except for 13, have posi- tional correspondences with objects in the USNO star catalog. Their R and B magnitudes are included in Table 1. ROSAT All SkySurveySources(RASS): In addition to the point sources in Table 1, Figs. 1 and 3 also show the locations of faint sources from the RASS catalog (Voges et al. 2000) not detected in the pointed PSPC and HRI data. The RASS field covers the entire EGRET error circle, even the areas not cov- ered or detected by the pointed PSPC and HRI data sets. The RASS sources are marked with crosses and listed in Table 2. Except for the source marked "f" all the sources in Table 2 are positionally coincident with objects from the USNO catalog. Source "g" was determined to be a dMe star from spectroscopic observation on the MDM 2.4m. 5. THE RADIO OBSERVATIONS We have searched the NRAO/VLA Sky Survey (NVSS) cat- alog (Condon et al. 1998) for possible 1.4 GHz radio counter- parts to the X-ray point sources. There were 111 radio sources in the field of 3EG J1621+8203 of which only 10 had integrated radio fluxes > 100 mJy. These are shown in Fig. 4 and listed in Table 3. Of these, B1 is NGC 6251 and B2 · · · B5 probably cor- respond to emission from the jet of NGC 6251. No significant X-ray emission is seen at the positions of the other sources and the NASA Extragalactic Database (NED) reveals that these are steep spectrum radio sources. Mack, Kerp & Klein note another X-ray/radio coincidence east of source 7 at RA: 16 26 24.8 and Dec: 82 35 07. This source is 8C 1631+826, and has an X-ray flux density of (9.8 ± 2.9) × 10- 3 µJy. It should be noted that that the most effective way to look for radio candidates for gamma-ray sources is to start not with the NVSS, but with a high-frequency radio catalog that is most likely to isolate the flat-spectrum, blazar candidates. The best such catalog in the northern hemisphere is the Becker, White, & Edwards (1991) 4.85 GHz survey. However, it covers only declinations between 0◦ and +75,◦ which excludes this field. 6. DISCUSSION Our analysis of the archival X-ray data of the field containing 3EG J1621+8203 reveals that the region contains several bright stars, weak radio sources, a radio galaxy, and a galaxy clus- ter. We note that unlike the majority of the identified EGRET sources, 3EG J1621+8203 lacks a radio-loud, spectrally flat, FIG. 3. -- (Top) ROSAT HRI image and (Bottom) ASCA image in the field of 3EG J1621+8203. The circles corresponds to the ∼ 95 % confidence con- tours from the 3EG catalog (Hartman et al. 1999). The dashed ellipses are the 95% error contours derived from elliptical fits to the 3EG data (Mattox, Hart- man & Reimer 2001). The numbers and letters correspond to sources described in §3 and Tables 1 and 2. TABLE 3 5 BRIGHT (> 100 MJY) NVSS SOURCES IN THE FIELD OF 3EG J1621+8203 Number Flux (mJy) Name RA Dec B1 B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7 B8 B9 B10 16 32 26.14 16 31 47.88 16 30 51.13 16 29 25.21 16 27 42.31 16 28 9.52 16 26 43.74 16 24 11.83 16 21 24.93 16 07 29.40 +82 32 20.3 +82 32 54.7 +82 33 45.6 +82 35 34.1 +82 42 26.1 +81 50 21.3 +81 58 50.8 +82 09 14.1 +81 35 34.1 +82 01 34.5 802 144 875 131 114 137 172 334 100 314 NGC 6251 NGC 6251 jet " " " 8C 1632+819 8C 1631+820 8C 1628+822 WN B1621.7+8142 8C 1612+821 blazar-like source catalogued within its error circle that could be its potential counterpart. No radio counterpart search was carried out by Mattox, Hartman and Reimer (2001) for this source, as it is in a region of sky not covered by the 5 GHz Green Bank survey. Of the notable X-ray sources in Table 1 the brightest is the RS CVn star, source # 8. X-ray emission from such stars is believed to arise from coronal loop structures (Ros- ner et al. 1978), or perhaps as a result of interaction between the mass transfer stream and the mass gaining star in a binary system (Welty & Ramsey 1995). RS CVn stars are not known to be gamma-ray emitters, and thus we reject source # 8 as a counterpart to the EGRET source. Similarly, none of the other stars listed in Table 1 is likely to correspond to the gamma-ray source. FIG. 4. -- Contour map of NVSS sources in the field of the EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203 superimposed on the ROSAT PSPC image (grey scale). The source positions are listed in Table 3. Source B9, which is within the EGRET error contour but outside the X-ray image, is not shown. X-ray sources 7 and 10 are coincident with weak radio sources listed in Table 1. The two sources of interest in Table 1, however, are the galaxy cluster 2E 1646.6+8238 and the radio galaxy NGC 6251. The question of whether gamma-ray emission above 100 MeV is possible from X-ray clusters is not yet resolved. It has been suggested that some of the unidentified EGRET sources at high latitudes could be gamma-ray clusters, perhaps a new population of gamma-ray emitting sources (Totani & Ki- tayama 2000). Gamma-ray emission in clusters is presumably due to the inverse Compton scattering of the cosmic microwave background photons off high energy electrons accelerated in the shock waves produced during cluster formation. However, Totani & Kitayama (2000) note that there is no statistically significant association of clusters from either the Abell cata- log (Abell, Corwin & Olowin 1989) or the catalog of ROSAT Brightest Cluster Sample (Ebeling et al. 1998) with the error circles of the unidentified EGRET sources at high latitudes. In fact, the X-ray surface brightness and surface number density of galaxies in gamma-ray clusters are expected to be lower by a factor of about 200 and 30, respectively, than those of or- dinary clusters (Totani & Kitayama 2000), and the likelihood of finding gamma-ray clusters in past X-ray and optical sur- veys is small. Brighter, closer sources of this class have not been previously detected by EGRET. In this case it is unlikely that the gamma-ray emission in 3EG J1621+8203 is due to the galaxy cluster 2E 1646.6+8238, despite the positional coinci- dence. Perhaps deeper searches with more sensitive X-ray and gamma-ray instruments (e.g. GLAST) will resolve this issue conclusively in the future. Based on the present X-ray data, NGC 6251 appears to be the most likely candidate identification for the EGRET source 3EG J1621+8203. In that case, NGC 6251 would be the second radio galaxy to be detected by EGRET. In the 3EG catalog, Cen A (NGC 5128) is the only candidate detection of a radio galaxy at energies above 100 MeV (Sreekumar et al. 1999). Its derived gamma-ray luminosity is weaker by a factor of 10- 5 compared to the typical EGRET blazar. All other active galaxies iden- tified with EGRET sources are blazars, which are believed to have nearly aligned jets along our line-of-sight. Cen A has a jet that is offset by an angle of about 70◦ (Bailey et al. 1986; Fujisawa et al. 2000). Cen A happens to be the brightest and nearest radio galaxy (z = 0.0018, ∼ 3.5 Mpc). It has a double- lobed radio morphology, as evidenced from radio studies and shows the presence of a one-sided X-ray jet, collimated in the direction of the giant radio lobes. Cen A has a relatively weak radio luminosity ∼ 1040 ergs s- 1, and is classified as a FR I ra- dio galaxy. In the past Cen A was believed to be a misaligned blazar (Bailey et al. 1986). 6 High dynamic range VLBI and VLA maps are available for NGC 6251 at 6, 13, and 18 cm, showing a bright core, a jet/counterjet brightness ratio of ∼ 80 to 1 (Jones et al. 1986). The fact that the source has a nuclear structure and a large scale radio morphology, implies relativistic beaming. Blazars de- tected by EGRET are compact radio sources, with radio spec- tral indices ≥ - 0.5. The kpc-scale jet of NGC 6251 has a slightly smaller spectral index (-0.64) (Saunders et al. 1981), but it could account for relativistic electrons and inverse Comp- ton emission in this source (Jones, et al. 1986). Figure 5 shows the spectral energy distribution of NGC 6251 assuming that it is the counterpart to 3EG J1621+8203. The radio through optical data for the plot are from Ho (1999) and the references therein. The ROSAT data is from Worrall & Birkinshaw (1994) who find that 90% of the total PSPC flux comes from an unresolved component of diameter ≤ 4′′. The ASCA data is from Sambruna, Eracleous & Mushotzky (1999) and agrees with the continuum model of Turner et al. (1997) who analyzed the data previously. We have also in- cluded VLBI and VLA data at 2.22, 6, and 18 cm (Jones et al. 1986). Similar to Cen A, the high energy gamma-ray emission from 3EG J1621+8203 represents a lower luminosity (3 × 1043 ergs/s) than that of other EGRET blazars (typically 1045 to 1048 ergs/s). Sreekumar et al. (1999) note that Cen A has a gamma-ray photon spectral index of 2.40 ± 0.28, which is steeper than the average power-law spectrum from gamma- ray blazars (2.15 ± 0.04), and the spectrum of the extragalactic gamma-ray background (2.10 ± 0.03). The gamma-ray spectral index of 3EG J1621+8203 has a larger error (2.27±0.53), but it may be worth noting that it too is probably steeper than the av- erage blazar spectrum. Unlike Cen A, however, NGC 6251 has not been detected by either COMPTEL or OSSE. There is no upper limit for this source in the first COMPTEL source catalog (Schönfelder et al. 2000). ) 1 - s 2 - m c g r e ( f g o L 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 10-13 10-14 10-15 ASCA ROSAT 1010 1015 Log Frequency n (Hz) 1020 1025 FIG. 5. -- Broad-band spectral energy distribution plot of NGC 6251, as- suming that it is the counterpart to 3EG 1621+8203. The radio through optical data are obtained from a compilation by Ho (1999). The sensitivity of EGRET to off-axis emission from AGN, whose jets are pointed away from our line-of-sight, needs to be addressed. The total amount of scattered energy, F1, as a func- tion of viewing angle for an active galaxy may be estimated us- ing the relation (see Dermer, Schlickeiser, Mastichiadis 1992; Weferling & Schlickeiser 1999), F1(s, µ∗ s ) = D3+s(1 - µ∗ s )(s+1)/2 (1) where the gamma-ray flux seen by the observer is due to the scattered inverse Compton emission of ambient low energy photons by highly relativistic particles in the jet. In this case, the particles are assumed to be electrons and positrons, dis- tributed in energy as a power-law with a spectral index of s. s is the cosine of the angle between the jet axis and the di- µ∗ rection to the observer, and D is the Doppler factor of the blob, s )- 1, where βc is the bulk velocity of defined as D = Γ the plasma. - 1(1 - βµ∗ Figure 6 shows the decrease in scattered energy for off-axis emission, using the above relation, for different viewing an- gles, corresponding to two typical values of Lorentz factors (Γ) seen in blazars. The figure shows that a decrease in observer angle from 70◦ (e.g. Cen A) to 45◦ (e.g. NGC 6251) corre- sponds to an increase in the scattered energy by about a factor of 10, all other things assumed equal. Cen A (z = 0.0018) is the only source to be detected by EGRET with a large incli- nation angle, presumably due to its proximity to Earth. NGC 6251 (z = 0.0234) is much further away, but it is possible that the source is still detectable by EGRET due to its smaller jet angle. G = 5 G = 10 FIG. 6. -- Decrease in the observed emission from a blazar as a function of jet orientation with respect to the observer (Weferling & Schlickeiser 1999; Sreekumar 1999). The threshold sensitivity of EGRET (> 100 MeV) for a single 2-week observation was ∼ 3 × 10- 7 photons cm- 2 s- 1 (Thompson et al. 1993). Due to the intrinsically low luminos- ity of radio galaxies and the limitations of EGRET's sensitivity, it is not surprising that many radio galaxies have not been de- tected as gamma-ray sources above 100 MeV thus far. It is very likely that more distant radio-loud AGN with intermedi- ate inclination angles will be detected in the future with higher sensitivity gamma-ray instruments. FR I galaxies have been hypothesized to be the likely parent populations of BL Lac ob- jects, which are believed to be beamed FR I galaxies (Padovani & Urry 1990; Ghisellini et al. 1993). Since the number density of radio-loud FR I sources is nearly 1000 times larger than FS- RQs and BL Lac objects, the possibility that such sources could form a new source class for future instruments like VERITAS (e.g. Weekes et al. 2000) or GLAST (e.g. Gehrels & Michelson 1999) is an exciting one. NGC 6251=3EG J1621+8203 and Cen A=3EG J1324-4314 could be examples of such sources. In fact, there exists the likelihood that such "misaligned blazars" could contribute to the extragalactic gamma-ray background around 1 n n MeV (Stienle et al. 1998; Sreekumar et al. 1999; Watanabe & Hartmann 2001). Gamma-ray sources not resolved by present- day detectors must contribute to the extragalactic gamma-ray background detected by EGRET in the 30 MeV to 100 GeV range. The contribution of misaligned blazars to the gamma- ray background has been calculated by Weferling & Schlick- eiser (1999) where the authors modeled the EGRET-detected extragalactic gamma-ray background. The misaligned blazars clearly outnumber the aligned ones, but direct observation of these sources may only be possible in the future with more sen- sitive gamma-ray instruments. This research has made use of data obtained from HEASARC at Goddard Space Flight Center and the SIMBAD astronomical database. R.M. acknowledges support from NSF grant PHY-9983836. E.V.G. is supported by NASA LTSA grants NAG 5-22250. References Abell, G. O., Corwin, H. G., Olowin, R. P. 1989, ApJS, 70, 1. Bailey, J., Sparks, W. B., Hough, J. H., Axon, D. J. 1986, Na- ture, 322, 150. Becker, R. H., White, R. L., Edwards, A. L. 1991, ApJS, 75, 1. Bicknell, G. V. 1994, ApJ, 422, 542. Birkinshaw, M., & Worrall, D. M. 1993, ApJ, 412, 568. Condon, J. J., Cotton, W. D., Greisen, E. W., Yin, Q. F., Perley, R. A., Taylor, G. B., Broderick, J. J. 1998, AJ, 115, 1693. Dermer, C. D., Schlickeiser, R., Mastichiadis, A. 1992, A&A, 256, L27. Ebeling, H., Edge, A. C., Bohringer, H., Allen, S. W., Craw- ford, C. S., Fabian, A. C., Voges, W., Huchra, J. P. 1998, MN- RAS, 301, 881. Eker, Z 1992, ApJS, 79, 481. Fujisawa, K., Inoue, M., Kobayashi, H., Murata, Y., Wajima, K., et al. 2000, PASJ, 52, 1021. Gehrels, N., & Michelson, P. 1999, Astropart. Phys., 11, 277. Ghisellini, G., Padovani, P., Celotti, A., Maraschi, L. 1993, ApJ, 407, 65. Gotthelf, E. V., Ueda, Y., Fujimoto, R., Kii, T., Yamaoka, K. 2000, ApJ, 543, 417. Gotthelf, E. V., & Kaspi, V. M. 1998, ApJ, 497, L29. Halpern, J. P., Camilo, F., Gotthelf, E. V., Helfand, D. J., Kramer, M., Lyne, A. G., Leighly, K. M., Eracleous, M. 2001a, ApJ, 552, L125. Halpern, J. P., Eracleous, M., Mukherjee, R., Gotthelf, E. V. 2001b, ApJ, 551, 1016. Hartman, R. C., Bertsch, D. L., Bloom, S. D., Chen, A. W., Deines-Jones, P., Esposito, J. A., Fichtel, C. E., Friedlander, D. P., et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 79. Ho, L. 1999, ApJ, 516, 672. Jones, D. L., Unwin, S. C., Readhead, A. C. S., Sargent, W. L. W., Seielstad, G. A., et al. 1986, ApJ, 305, 684. Mattox, J. R., Schachter, J., Molnar, L., Hartman, R. C., Patnaik 1997, ApJ, 481, 95. Mattox, J. R., Hartman, R. C., & Reimer, O. 2001, ApJS, 135, 155. Mack, K. -H., Kerp, J., & Klein, U. 1997, A&A, 324, 870. Mirabal, N., & Halpern, J. P. 2001, ApJ, 547, 137L. Mirabal, N., Halpern, J. P., Eracleous, M., Becker, R. H. 2000, 541, 180. Mukherjee, R., Gotthelf, E. V., Halpern, J., Tavani, M. 2000, ApJ, 542, 740. Murakami, T., Ueda, Y., Yoshida, A., Kawai, N., Marshall, F. 7 E., et al. 1997, IAU Circular, 6732, 1. Nolan, P. L., Arzoumanian, Z., Bertsch, D. L., Chiang, J., Fich- tel, C. E., Fierro, J. M., Hartman, R. C., Hunter, S. D., et al. 1993, ApJ, 409, 697. Padovani, P., & Urry, C. M. 1990, ApJ, 356, 75. Perryman, M. A. C., Lindegren, L., Kovalevsky, J., Hoeg, E., Bastian, U., Bernacca, P. L., Crézé, M., Donati, F., et al. 1997, A&A, 323L, 49. Reimer, O., Brazier, K. T. S., Carramiñana, A., Kanbach, G., Nolan, P. L., Thompson, D. J. 2001, MNRAS, 324, 772. Roberts M. S. E., Romani, R. W., Kawai, N. 2001, ApJS, 133, 451. Rosner, R., Tucker, W. H., Vaiana, G. S. 1978, ApJ, 220, 643. Sambruna, R. M., Eracleous, M., & Mushotzky, R. F. 1999, ApJ, 526, 60. Saunders, R., Baldwin, J. E., Pooley, G. G., Warner, P. J. 1981, MNRAS, 197, 287. Schönfelder, V., Bennett, K., Blom, J. J., Bloemen, H., Collmar, W., Connors, A., Diehl, R., Hermsen, W., et al. 2000, A&AS, 143, 145. Smith, D. A., Levine, A. M. , Morgan, E. H., Wood, A. 1997, IAU Circular, 6718, 1. Smith, D. A., Levine, A. M., Bradt, H. V., Remillard, R., Jerni- gan, J., et al. 1999, ApJ, 526, 693. Sreekumar, P., Bertsch, D. L., Hartman, R. C., Nolan, P. L., Thompson, D. J. 1999, Aph, 11, 221. Stienle, H., Bennett, K., Bloemen, H., Collmar, W., Diehl, R., Hermsen, W., Lichti, G. G., Morris, D., et al. 1998, A&A, 330, 97. Sudou, H., Taniguchi, Y. 2000, AJ, 120, 697. Thompson, D. J., Bertsch, D. L., Fichtel, C. E., Hartman, R. C., Hofstadter, R., Hughes, E. B., Hunter, S. D., Hughlock, B. W., et al. 1993, ApJS, 86, 629. Thompson, D. J., Bertsch, D. L., Dingus, B. L., Esposito, J. A., Etienne, A., Fichtel, C. E., Friedlander, D. P., Hartman, R. C., et al. 1995 ApJS, 101, 259. Totani, T. & Kitayama, T. 2000, ApJ, 545, 572. Tucker, W. H., Tananbaum, H., Remillard, R. A. 1995, ApJ, 444, 532. Turner, T. J., George, I. M., Nandra, K., Mushotzky, R. F. 1997, ApJS, 113, 23. Ueda, Y., Ishisaki, Y., Takahashi, T., Makishima, K., Ohashi, T. 2001, ApJS, 133, 1. Urry, C. M., Padovani, P. 1995, PASP, 107, 803. Voges, W., Aschenbach, B., Boller, Th., Bräuninger, H., Briel, U., et al. 2000, VizieR On-line Data Catalog: IX/29. Originally published in: Max-Planck-Institut fur extraterrestrische Physik, Garching (2000). Voges, W., Aschenbach, B., Boller, Th., Bräuninger, H., Briel, U., et al. 1999, A&A, 349, 389. Watanabe, K. & Hartmann, D. H. 2001, Proc. GAMMA 2001, Baltimore; astro-ph/0105180. Weekes, T. C., Bradbury, S. M., Bond, I. H., Breslin, A. C., Buckley, J. H., et al., 2000, The Fifth Compton Sympo- sium, Proceedings of the fifth Compton Symposium, held in Portsmouth, NH, USA, September 1999. Melville, NY: Amer- ican Institute of Physics (AIP), 2000. Edited by M. L. Mc- Connell and J. M. Ryan AIP Conference Proceedings, Vol. 510., p.637. Weferling, B., & Schlickeiser, R. 1999, A&A, 344, 744. Welty, A. D. & Ramsey, W. 1995, ApJ, 109, 2187. Worrall, M. & Birkinshaw, D. M. 1994, ApJ, 427, 134.
astro-ph/0311236	1	0311	2003-11-10T22:25:27	The Planetary Nebula System and Dynamics in the Outer Halo of NGC 5128	[ "astro-ph" ]	The halos of elliptical galaxies are faint and difficult to explore, but they contain vital clues to both structure and formation. We present the results of an imaging and spectroscopic survey for planetary nebulae (PNe) in the nearby elliptical NGC 5128. We extend the work of Hui et al.(1995) well into the halo of the galaxy--out to distances of 100 and 50 kpc along the major and minor axes. We now know of 1141 PNe in NGC 5128, 780 of which are confirmed. Of these 780 PNe, 349 are new from this survey, and 148 are at radii beyond 20 kpc. PNe exist at distances up to 80 kpc (~15 r_e), showing that the stellar halo extends to the limit of our data. This study represents by far the largest kinematic study of an elliptical galaxy to date, both in the number of velocity tracers and in radial extent. We confirm the large rotation of the PNe along the major axis, and show that it extends in a disk-like feature into the halo. The rotation curve of the stars flattens at ~100 km/s with V/sigma between 1 and 1.5, and with the velocity dispersion of the PNe falling gradually at larger radii. The two-dimensional velocity field exhibits a zero-velocity contour with a pronounced twist, showing that the galaxy potential is likely triaxial in shape, tending toward prolate. The total dynamical mass of the galaxy within 80 kpc is ~5 x 10^{11} M_sun, with M/L_B ~ 13. This mass-to-light ratio is much lower than what is typically expected for elliptical galaxies.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astrophysical Journal, v602, 2004 February 20 Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 10/10/03 THE PLANETARY NEBULA SYSTEM AND DYNAMICS IN THE OUTER HALO OF NGC 5128 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, 21218, USA Eric W. Peng1,2, Holland C. Ford1,3 and Kenneth C. Freeman RSAA, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, Australia Received 2003 August 14; accepted 2003 November 4 ABSTRACT The halos of elliptical galaxies are faint and difficult to explore, but they contain vital clues to both structure and formation. We present the results of an imaging and spectroscopic survey for planetary nebulae (PNe) in the nearby elliptical NGC 5128. We extend the work of Hui et al. (1995) well into the halo of the galaxy -- out to distances of 100 and 50 kpc along the major and minor axes. We now know of 1141 PNe in NGC 5128, 780 of which are confirmed. Of these 780 PNe, 349 are new from this survey, and 148 are at radii beyond 20 kpc. PNe exist at distances up to 80 kpc (∼ 15re), showing that the stellar halo extends to the limit of our data. This study represents by far the largest kinematic study of an elliptical galaxy to date, both in the number of velocity tracers and in radial extent. We confirm the large rotation of the PNe along the major axis, and show that it extends in a disk-like feature into the halo. The rotation curve of the stars flattens at ∼ 100 km s−1 with V /σ between 1 and 1.5, and with the velocity dispersion of the PNe falling gradually at larger radii. The two-dimensional velocity field exhibits a zero-velocity contour with a pronounced twist, showing that the galaxy potential is likely triaxial in shape, tending toward prolate. The total dynamical mass of the galaxy within 80 kpc is ∼ 5 × 1011M⊙, with M/LB ∼ 13. This mass-to-light ratio is much lower than what is typically expected for elliptical galaxies. Subject headings: dark matter -- galaxies: elliptical and lenticular, cD -- galaxies: halos -- galaxies: individual (NGC 5128) -- galaxies: kinematics and dynamics -- planetary nebulae: general 1. INTRODUCTION Extragalactic planetary nebulae (PNe) are powerful tools for studying the dynamical states of early-type galaxies. Using their bright [O III] emission lines, we can identify PNe and typically measure their radial velocities to an accuracy of ∼ 15 km s−1. Traditionally, the kine- matics of old stellar populations are derived from absorp- tion line profiles in integrated spectroscopy (e.g. Bender, Saglia, & Gerhard 1994; Kronawitter et al. 2000). This method, however, is limited to the relatively high surface brightness central regions of galaxies (r < 2re), where the mass density is dominated by baryons. Unlike in spi- rals where the rotation curves can be measured out to a large radii using H I observations, very few ellipticals have large scale H I disks or polar rings that can be used to probe the potential in the halo. So, while current theo- ries of structure formation predict that elliptical galaxies should reside in massive dark matter halos, the dynam- ical evidence for these halos is not nearly as complete or as conclusive as it is for spiral galaxies (e.g. Gerhard et al. 2001, Romanowsky et al. 2003). Electronic address: [email protected], [email protected] Electronic address: [email protected] 1 Visiting Astronomer, Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observa- tory, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Re- search in Astronomy, Inc. (AURA) under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation. 2 Current address: 136 Frelinghuysen Road, Physics and As- tronomy, Rutgers University, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA; er- [email protected] 3 Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Bal- timore, MD 21218, USA Using PNe, we can now obtain kinematical information in the halos of early-type galaxies at radii up to 80 kpc, allowing us to study the two-dimensional stellar kinemat- ics and the mass distribution in these galaxies. Because PNe are evolved asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars, their kinematics must trace that of the underlying stellar population, making them ideal test particles for dynam- ical studies. PNe have been used successfully as velocity test particles in many elliptical galaxies. As early as a decade ago, Ciardullo et al. (1993) measured velocities for 29 PNe within r ∼ 10 kpc for NGC 3379. Other ex- amples include Arnaboldi et al. (1998), who discovered 43 PNe within r ∼ 16 kpc for NGC 1316 (Fornax A), and M´endez et al. (2001), who measured velocities for 535 PNe within r ∼ 14 kpc for NGC 4697. More recently, Romanowsky et al. (2003) presented results from a PN spectrograph study in which ∼ 100 PNe were observed in each of three galaxies out to radii of 4 -- 6 re. The work most relevant to this paper is the study of Hui et al. (1995, hereafter H95), who first investigated the PN system of NGC 5128. At a distance of 3.5 Mpc (Hui et al. 1993a, hereafter H93a), NGC 5128 is the clos- est large elliptical galaxy to the Milky Way and is a prime candidate for PNe studies. At the distance of NGC 5128, 1′ = 1.02 kpc. Hui et al. 1993b (H93b) identified 785 PNe in NGC 5128, and H95 measured velocities for 431 PNe. This previous study probed the halo potential out to projected distances of ∼ 20 kpc along the major axis and ∼ 10 kpc along the minor axis, and produced strong evidence for: 1) A dark matter halo, 2) A significant quantity of angular momentum in the halo, and 3) In- 2 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Table 1. Observing Runs: Imaging Data Acquired AT/With Date [O III] on-/off-band, inner halo CTIO, Prime Focus CCD [O III] on-/off-band, outer halo CTIO, Prime Focus CCD [O III] and V imaging CTIO, Mosaic II CCD camera 1993 Jun 17 -- 19 1995 Mar 24 -- 28 2000 Jun 4 trinsic triaxiality in the true shape of the galaxy. In this study, we present the results of an extended survey in which we have identified and measured veloci- ties for PNe in NGC 5128 out to projected distances of 80 and 40 kpc along the major and minor axes, respec- tively. We identified 356 new PN candidates, many of which are beyond 20 kpc, bringing the total number of PNe in NGC 5128 to 1141. In total, we were able to measure 349 new PN radial velocities, which increases the kinematic sample to 780 PNe. Similar studies in other galaxies have typically used 2 -- 10 times fewer test particles (whether PNe or globular clusters), and have mostly been conducted in regions where r . 5re. The data set we present in this paper represents by far the largest kinematic survey of an elliptical galaxy to date, both in the number of velocity tracers, and the radial extent in the galaxy halo (r ∼ 15re). 2. THE SURVEY We can identify extragalactic PNe candidates by their bright [O III] emission lines. PNe, which have strong emission lines and very little continuum emission, are detected in images taken through an "on-band" [O III] filter, but are not detected in images taken through an "off-band" continuum filter. Optimally, the on-band fil- ter is designed such that its central wavelength matches the wavelength of λ5007 redshifted to the systemic ve- locity of the galaxy, and its width is large enough to en- compass the velocity dispersion of the observed galaxy's stars. For NGC 5128, its systemic velocity of 541 km s−1 (H95) translates into an on-band filter centered at 5016A. A typical galactic velocity dispersion of 200 km s−1 re- quires a filter width of greater than 20A in order to in- clude all PNe with velocities of less than 3-σ from the mean. Ideally, the off-band filter is an intermediate-band filter that is not far from the [O III] line, but does not include it. In some cases, a Johnson V-band filter is used as the off-band. The V filter can be used as an off-band despite the fact that it contains the [O III] line because of its large bandpass (∼ 900A). After identifying PNe candidates in the imaging, we obtain spectra of them with multi-fiber spectrographs. The detection of the [O III]λ5007 emission line allows us to measure their radial velocities. In bright PNe, we can also see the [O III]λ4959 emission line. For a small subset of our sample (22 PNe), we measured the velocity using the Hα emission line. 2.1. Imaging Observations We imaged the halo of NGC 5128 over the course of three observing runs using the Blanco 4-meter telescope at Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory (CTIO). Table 2. Imaged Fields Field f10 f12 f14 f16 f17 f18 f21 f8 f22 f15 f19 f20 f21 f23 f24 f30 f31 f40 f41 f42 f43 f5 f7 f4 RA(2000) Dec(2000) 13:23:21.26 −43:15:20.09 13:27:14.46 −43:01:18.30 13:24:36.65 −43:01:01.59 13:28:30.72 −42:46:55.61 13:26:46.06 −42:47:00.56 13:25:56.82 −42:46:56.58 13:28:03.09 −42:33:08.67 13:25:27.89 −43:15:41.55 13:26:44.92 −42:32:47.81 13:22:54.30 −43:00:41.51 13:24:07.66 −42:46:45.31 13:22:55.67 −42:46:51.95 13:27:58.66 −42:32:49.00 13:25:27.95 −42:33:00.94 13:24:11.27 −42:33:00.52 13:24:09.04 −43:42:59.67 13:22:48.88 −43:42:44.84 13:24:12.59 −42:18:58.32 13:25:28.32 −42:18:53.75 13:26:43.04 −42:18:48.18 13:27:59.18 −42:18:56.95 13:22:54.56 −43:28:48.03 13:26:44.96 −43:14:48.87 13:24:08.97 −43:28:55.40 mosNE 13:28:13.59 −42:04:24.82 mosSW 13:21:54.56 −44:06:50.84 Field-of-View (′) 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 15.1 × 14.9 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 14.7 × 14.7 38.1 × 43.8 37.1 × 37.6 These imaging runs are listed in Table 1. All imaged fields are listed in Table 2, and shown on a 2◦ × 2◦ image of NGC 5128 from the Digitized Sky Survey in Figure 1. During the first run, on 1993 Jun 17 -- 19, we used the Prime Focus CCD Imager (PFCCD) to image twelve halo fields. In 1993, the PFCCD 2048 × 2048 pixel detector covered a 15.′1 × 14.′9 field on the sky at a pixel scale of 0.′′445 pixel−1. Typical seeing was in the range 1.′′2 -- 1.′′7. There was thin cirrus on the first night, but conditions were photometric for the other two. The centering of the CCD frame was off by several arc minutes east for five of the observed fields (10,12,14,16,18). While this introduced a few gaps in our survey region, it did not have any impact on the presented science. During our second run, 1995 Mar 24 -- 28, we used the PFCCD to observe fifteen more halo fields. Three of the 1993 fields (4,5,21) were re-observed because the see- ing and weather were better. In 1995, the PFCCD cov- ered a 14.′7 × 14.′7 field on the sky at a pixel scale of 0.′′431 pixel−1. Seeing was in the range 1.′′1 -- 1.′′8, and weather conditions were non-photometric on the first night (thin cirrus), but photometric for the remainder of the run. For both PFCCD imaging runs, we used a narrowband filter with a central wavelength of 5016A and a transmis- sion FWHM of 35A in an f/2.7 beam. The off-band filter Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 3 Fig. 1. -- Fields imaged for NGC 5128 PNe Survey. The fields imaged for PNe detection are plotted over a 2◦ × 2◦ Digitized Sky Survey image of NGC 5128. The image is oriented with North up, East to the left. The calibration wedge and vignetting at the top are due to this region of sky being near the edge of the plate. At the distance of NGC 5128, 1′ = 1.02 kpc. The PFCCD fields are ∼ 15′ square. The larger Mosaic II fields are ∼ 38′ square. See Table 2 for central coordinates and exact sizes for each field. for these runs was a 200A wide filter centered at 5280A. For each field, the total exposure times were typically 2400 -- 3600 s through the on-band filter, and 500s through the off-band filter. The off-band images are deeper in the continuum to help avoid spurious PN detections. On a third observing run, we used the CTIO Mosaic II CCD camera to image two major axis fields on opposite sides of the galaxy centered at projected radii of 75 (NE) and 85 (SW) kpc. This imaging was done on 2000 June 4 under photometric, moonless conditions with a seeing of 1.′′1. For our Mosaic imaging, we used an on-band filter with a central wavelength of 5016A and a FWHM of 45A in an f/2.87 beam. In place of a true off-band filter, we substituted a Johnson V filter. Total exposure times were 3600s in [O III] and 300s in V. 4 Peng, Ford, & Freeman PNe Detection and Astrometry We used standard CCD reduction software in IRAF4 to bias subtract, flat field, and remove cosmic rays from our imaging data. PN identification can be done in a few different ways. The traditional method of "blinking" on- and off-band images was used for some of our survey. We also divided the on-band by the off-band to look for bright, stellar residuals. Another technique, used on f14, f15, and our Mosaic fields, is to employ an object de- tection algorithm such as SExtractor (Bertin 1996), and select objects that have large color. This is similar to the method described in Arnaboldi et al. (2002). Even when automated detection was employed, all PN candidates were visually inspected. Deriving accurate positions for PNe candidates is im- portant for fiber spectroscopy, where fibers are only 2 -- 3′′ in diameter. The fact that our data were taken over a period of many years during which astrometric refer- ence catalogs continually improved compels us to be very careful when creating an internally consistent astromet- ric catalog. All positions published in this paper are on the astrometric reference frame of the USNO-A2.0 cat- alog (Monet et al. 1998). The reference catalogs used for spectroscopic follow-up, however, also included the Guide Star Catalog v1.0 (GSC; Lasker et al. 1990), GSC v1.2, and USNO-A1.0. Compared to the GSC v1.0 and v1.2, the USNO-A2.0 catalog has both a higher stellar density and astrometry that is less plate-dependent. With NGC 5128's relatively low galactic latitude (+19◦), and the depth of the USNO- A2.0 catalog, there was no shortage of astrometric ref- erence stars with which to obtain a solution -- hundreds of stars with B magnitudes between 13.5 and 17.0 were used for each field. Typically, fourth-order polynomials were necessary to fit the data, obtaining positional ac- curacy with < 0.′′3 residuals. We used overlap between neighboring PFCCD fields to confirm that our astrome- try was consistent between fields. Astrometry for the H93b sample of PNe was based on the GSC v1.0, which possesses a small, but non-negligible zeropoint shift when compared to the USNO-A2.0 sys- tem. Although the internal relative astrometry for the previously published and the current work has RMS er- rors of only 0.′′10 -- 0.′′33, the zeropoint shifts between sys- tems could be as large as 2′′. Our goal was to create a consistent set of positions that future observers could ob- serve in the same fiber configuration, and also to match duplicate observations of the same object. Since the rel- ative astrometry used for each observing run was shown to be satisfactory by proof of successful spectroscopic observations, when making the merged, final catalog, we decided that simple zeropoint shifts would suffice to make the PN positions consistent. To calculate the appropriate shifts in the vicinity of NGC 5128, we found the USNO-A2.0 positions for the bright GSC reference stars listed in H93b (their Table 2). From these, we calculated shifts of +0.′′55 in right ascen- sion and +1.′′30 in declination (to be applied to the H93b positions). In all cases, we checked our new astrometry 4 IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Ob- servatories, which are operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation. Table 3. Astrometric Fiducial Stars from USNO-A2.0 Name RA(J2000) Dec(J2000) R mag F01 F02 F03 F04 F05 F06 F07 F08 F09 F10 F11 F12 F13 F14 F15 F16 F17 F18 F19 F20 F21 F22 F23 F24 F25 F26 F27 F28 F29 F30 F31 F32 F33 F34 F35 F36 F37 F38 F39 F40 F41 13:24:49.38 −43:05:07.7 13:25:56.18 −43:09:60.0 13:26:17.59 −42:55:36.9 13:26:05.46 −42:51:37.9 13:24:37.28 −42:47:05.0 13:23:55.81 −42:55:42.0 13:23:51.18 −43:03:53.8 13:25:07.04 −42:41:57.3 13:24:31.48 −43:18:29.7 13:26:24.10 −43:19:03.2 13:24:46.97 −43:20:29.8 13:24:05.15 −42:46:52.8 13:27:21.77 −42:51:50.5 13:24:08.86 −42:42:49.9 13:26:52.11 −43:19:40.9 13:27:39.21 −42:59:41.7 13:23:25.38 −42:51:50.0 13:23:38.87 −43:18:50.3 13:24:34.99 −43:27:46.6 13:24:03.98 −43:26:10.1 13:24:21.90 −43:28:31.7 13:27:59.96 −42:49:59.5 13:25:13.90 −43:34:22.8 13:23:56.25 −43:33:28.9 13:28:33.83 −43:20:29.8 13:28:19.55 −42:36:01.6 13:25:53.61 −43:42:28.6 13:28:42.28 −43:23:57.6 13:22:08.23 −43:22:50.7 13:29:11.28 −43:12:44.8 13:28:16.53 −43:30:24.1 13:22:52.84 −43:34:01.3 13:30:09.13 −42:47:32.2 13:30:13.34 −42:50:33.4 13:24:16.08 −43:53:26.6 13:29:15.79 −43:35:50.9 13:26:05.39 −42:04:21.7 13:26:02.57 −42:10:28.4 13:26:35.91 −42:07:51.1 13:24:46.80 −42:12:52.6 13:25:01.77 −42:15:39.7 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.0 14.1 14.1 14.1 14.1 14.1 Note. -- Positions and magnitudes are from the USNO-A2.0 catalog. All stars are within 1◦ of NGC 5128. against the PN positions in the actual images and found that they agreed. We include in Table 3 a list of bright, isolated, astrometric fiducial stars from the USNO-A2.0 catalog. These stars were used for guide fibers when tak- ing spectra of PNe. Not only can they be used in future observations, but they can also be used to translate the coordinates published in this paper to future astrometric reference frames. Although these data were taken under conditions of variable transparency and seeing, and we did not ap- ply photometric calibrations to them, the limiting mag- nitude of each image in this new survey is at least as faint or fainter than that of H93a, which was complete to m5007 = 24.8, or 1.5 magnitudes down the PN lumi- nosity function. In all cases where our fields overlapped area previously surveyed, we recovered all of the PNe listed in H93b. In addition, we were able to identify additional candidates in these regions that were not de- tected in the previous study. In total, we identified 356 new PN candidates which, in addition to the 785 PNe listed in H93b, brings the total number of [O III] imag- ing detections in NGC 5128 to 1141. Of these 1141, 431 Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 5 Table 4. Observing Runs: Spectroscopy Target(s) Instrument FOVa Fibersb Grating Resc (A) (′) Date AAO/2dF PN CTIO/ARGUS PN AAO/2dF PN/GC CTIO/Hydra PN/GC PN/GC AAO/2dF PN (Hα) AAO/2dF 120 50 120 40 120 120 200 24 400 130 400 400 1200V KPGL3 1200B KPGL3 1200V 1200V 2.2 3.4 2.2 4.9 2.2 2.2 1997 Mar 14,16 / Apr 3 -- 5 1997 May 13 -- 14 2001 Jan 20 2001 Feb 18 -- 20 2002 Apr 4 -- 6, 9 -- 10 2002 Jul 7 aField-of-View bNumber of fibers available for each configuration cSpectral Resolution PNe were previously confirmed spectroscopically by H95. In the following section, we describe our effort to obtain radial velocities for the remaining candidates. 2.2. Spectroscopy Observations Spectroscopy was done over the course of six separate observing runs: four with the Anglo-Australian Obser- vatory (AAO) 2-degree Field (2dF) fiber spectrograph, one with the CTIO Argus spectrograph, and one with the CTIO Hydra spectrograph. The 2dF spectrograph in particular is an ideal instrument for NGC 5128 stud- ies because its field-of-view encompasses a 60 kpc radius around the galaxy center. Central crowding of PNe is the primary limitation that prevents maximal fiber al- location. We targeted the 356 new candidates from the 1993 -- 2000 imaging data as well as 353 candidates from the sample of H93b that had no previous velocity mea- surement. On three of these runs, fiber configurations also included globular cluster candidates in NGC 5128 (Peng, Ford, & Freeman 2004b). For the first five runs, the spectral range was centered on the [O III]λ5007 line, and for the last run it was centered on Hα. The spectro- graph setups, fields of view, and resolutions are presented in Table 4. Our first AAO/2dF observing run occurred during parts of four nights in the spring of 1997. This period was designated as "shared-risk" for 2dF, and only one spec- trograph (with 200 fibers) was available. The weather was clear and seeing was 1.′′0 -- 1.′′5 for all three nights. Total exposure time for each configuration ranged from 1 -- 2.5 hours. In May 1997, we used the ARGUS multi-fiber spec- trograph on the CTIO 4-meter telescope to observe PNe candidates from the 1995 imaging data, as well as some from the 1993 data set. At the time of the observations, ARGUS contained 24 fiber pairs, each 1.′′8 in diameter. We observed seven fiber configurations over two nights, with each configuration receiving 2.25 hours of exposure time. Our second AAO/2dF observing run was taken in ser- vice mode in January, 2001. We received one 2.5 hour exposure for a single fiber configuration. This is the first of three runs where we also placed fibers on globular cluster candidates. In February, 2001, we observed with the Hydra multi- fiber spectrograph on the CTIO 4-meter. We obtained data for five fiber configurations over three nights of clear weather, and 1.′′2 -- 2.′′0 seeing. The spectral resolution of this data is lower than for other runs, but this did not seem to affect the velocity accuracy. Our third 2dF run was in April, 2002 during bright conditions. We used a total exposure time of 7.5 hours for one fiber configuration over the course of five nights. Our fourth 2dF data set was taken in service mode during July, 2002. This one differed from previous runs in that the grating was centered on the Hα emission line. Previously unobserved PNe that were targeted in this fiber setup were from fields 14 and 15. Data Reduction With the development of a number of dedicated soft- ware packages, the reduction of fiber spectroscopy is rel- atively routine. For our reductions we used either the 2dF data reduction package (2dfdr), or the IRAF pack- ages doargus and dofibers. At the time of our first 2dF observations, 2dfdr was still being developed, so we chose to reduce our data with dofibers in IRAF. In a typical reduction, images were bias subtracted and the spectra were extracted using a fiber flat field exposure. The extracted spectra were then flat-fielded and wavelength calibrated. Arc lamp exposures, taken through the night, showed that the wavelength solution did not change appreciably over time. Nevertheless, we used the nearest arc exposure (in time) to dispersion correct each exposure before combining. RMS residuals in the wavelength solution were typically ∼ 0.15A. The spectra were throughput corrected using either offset sky exposures (2dF), sky line fluxes (2dF/Hα), or projector flats (Hydra). A median sky was created using 20 -- 40 sky fibers, and then was subtracted from each spectrum. Finally, the multiple exposures from each fiber configu- ration were regridded to a common dispersion solution and averaged with a 3-σ rejection threshold for cosmic rays. There were some exceptions to this description of the reduction process. For the Argus data and first 2dF data, flat fielding, throughput corrections, and sky subtraction were not applied -- these calibrations do not affect the measurement of emission line radial velocities. Also, the fiber flats taken during our first 2dF run were not appro- priate for aperture extraction, so the arc exposures were used instead. 6 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Velocity Measurement We visually inspected each combined spectrum for the presence of the [O III]λ5007 emission line. For those spectra where there was discernible [O III] emission, we fit the line centers using the IRAF package rv, and ap- plied heliocentric corrections to the measured doppler ve- locities. We noted the detection of [O III]λ4959 in bright PNe, but did not include this line in the velocity mea- surement. We also verified that the lines were symmetric and un- resolved. Previous surveys for intracluster PNe in Virgo have accidentally detected Lyman α emitting galaxies at high redshift (Kudritzki et al. 2000). In these galax- ies, the λ1216 line is redshifted into the on-band fil- ter. For the filters we used to survey NGC 5128, a Ly- man α galaxy would need to be near z = 3.125 to be detected. The detection of both λλ4959, 5007 lines con- firms that the observed lines are from [O III]. For those spectra where only one line is detected, we can check for an overly broad or asymmetric line profile, a signa- ture of Lyman α . All one-line PN spectra were checked manually, and none were obvious Lyman α galaxies. This is not surprising because NGC 5128 is over three times closer than the Virgo cluster. Our images can be shallower than those for surveys in Virgo and still detect PNe that are 2.5 magnitudes down the PN lu- minosity function (similar to H93a). By re-observing PNe with published photometry (H93b), we find that the faintest objects for which we measure velocities have F5007 ∼ 2 × 10−16 erg s−1 cm−2, which is approximately two magnitudes down the PN luminosity function. By comparison, in a narrowband blank-field survey to mea- sure the surface density of background galaxy contami- nants, Ciardullo et al. (2002) found zero galaxies that had line fluxes this bright, albeit in a significantly smaller area of sky. This is consistent with early surveys for z > 3 emission line galaxies (summarized by Prichett 1994) which were unsuccessful and had depths similar to or deeper than our PN survey. As a result, high redshift Lyman α galaxy interlopers are not of a problem for this PN survey of NGC 5128. 3. THE PLANETARY NEBULA CATALOGS Ultimately, we wished to create a table of all the unique PNe in NGC 5128 with their positions and best radial velocities. This task was complicated by imaging overlap regions, two astrometric systems and multiple observing runs. Below, we outline the steps we took to produce the final catalogs. 3.1. Duplication and Velocity Accuracy Once our entire catalog was on a common astrometric system, we matched each PN against the entire catalog to check duplication. Mainly, duplication occurred in over- lap regions where PNe were identified in separate images and given different names. In cases where a "new" PN was actually previously observed in H95, we assigned a new composite name. When two PNe were both previ- ously unpublished, one name was chosen. In the process of checking for duplicates, we discovered that one PN in the H95 catalog, 5504, was observed twice and listed twice. Another pair of PNe, 5420 and 5423, were found to be the same object. In both cases, we averaged the Table 5. Velocity Consistency and Errors ObsRuna 2dF97 Argus97d 2dF01 Hydra01 2dF02 2dF02(Hα) ∆vb (km s−1) σ/√2 (km s−1) −21 −19 −17 −10 −20 −13 15.9 15.6 14.0 28.3 11.2 19.2 PNc 51 17 16 11 15 152 aRefers to observing runs listed in Table 4 bAdd ∆v to match H95 velocity frame cNumber of PNe in common with H95 dThe Argus97 sample had no PNe in common with H95. These values are based on 17 PNe in common with the 2dF97. two velocity measurements and removed one listing from our catalog. The correct number of unique PNe in H95 should be 431. Besides the unintentional duplication, we also pur- posely repeated spectroscopic observations of certain PNe over multiple observing runs. Together, these PNe allowed us to quantify systematic velocity offsets and ran- dom errors. For consistency, the "zeropoint" velocity ref- erence frame is considered to be the one defined by the PNe published in H95. All data from subsequent observ- ing runs were tied back to the H95 sample by using a sample of re-measured PNe. Systematic velocity shifts and empirical velocity errors derived from these duplicate and multiply observed PNe are presented in Table 5. The largest systematic shift be- tween any two of the newly presented spectroscopic runs is 11 km s−1, while the largest shift between one of the new spectroscopic runs and H95 is 21 km s−1. All of the velocity offsets between our newer data and H95 have the same sign, and may point to some systematic effect. However, given the small size of the offsets, we chose to bring our velocities onto the system established by H95 for the sake of consistency in the literature. Multiple ve- locity measurements of the same PN were averaged after applying this offset. Because some PNe from H95 were re-observed, we list them in our catalog with a composite name and their new velocity. These repeat observations also allow us to determine the internal velocity measurement errors. We estimate the RMS error as the standard deviation about the mean velocity difference, divided by √2 (making the approx- imation that the errors are roughly equal for each ob- serving run). RMS velocity errors were typically ∼ 20 km s−1, which is comparable to the best errors ob- tained by H95. This is consistent with the velocity error we derived from our first 2dF run, where 11 PNe were observed in multiple fiber configurations. This internal comparison yielded a velocity RMS error of 10 km s−1. One caveat to this method is that the PNe with dupli- cate observations tend to be ones with stronger λ5007, so these errors, while not atypical, should be considered lower limits. 3.2. The Catalogs After removing duplicate measurements and incorpo- rating systematic velocity shifts, we merged the samples Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 7 Table 6. NGC 5128 Planetary Nebula Position and Velocity Catalog ID (1) Ctr003 ctr007 ctr010 ctr013 ctr026 ctr107 ctr109 ctr115 ctr118a ctr118b V RA(J2000) (km s−1) (hh:mm:ss.ss) (2) 366 483 370 233 521 443 542 270 251 573 (3) 13:25:48.88 13:25:43.77 13:25:42.29 13:25:40.89 13:25:44.86 13:25:34.50 13:25:24.86 13:26:19.48 13:25:36.61 13:25:27.21 (4) Y (′) (6) Dec(J2000) (dd:mm:ss.s) X (′) (5) 5.650 −0.771 −42:56:54.5 1.052 6.626 −42:55:03.8 0.890 5.920 −42:55:44.1 −42:55:16.7 6.148 1.361 4.541 −0.649 −42:57:44.8 0.500 2.877 −42:58:27.1 −43:02:37.6 −1.554 −0.450 −42:56:53.9 8.861 −5.358 0.244 3.184 −42:58:20.8 −43:09:39.4 −7.066 −4.834 R (′) (7) 5.684 6.676 5.946 6.248 4.617 2.872 1.555 10.370 3.209 8.530 Note. -- There are 780 confirmed PNe. The complete version of this table is in the electronic edition of the Journal. The printed edition contains only a sample. to yield a catalog of 780 spectroscopically confirmed PNe. Of these, 431 are from H95, and 349 are new. Also, 148 PNe are at projected radii greater than 20 kpc. The names, positions, and velocities of all PNe are presented in Table 6. The columns are: (1) PN identification (field and PN number, H93b designation, or composite name), (2) radial velocity in km s−1, (3) RA (J2000), (4) Dec (J2000), (5) distance along photometric major axis (X) in arc minutes, positive to the northeast as in H95, (6) distance along photometric minor axis (Y ) in arc min- utes, positive to the northwest, and (7) projected radius from the galaxy center in arc minutes. The positional quantities X and Y follow the conven- tion of H95. The position angle of the major axis is 35◦, as measured in Dufour et al. (1979). Because our survey area is over 2◦ across, the small angle approx- imation for distances on a sphere can be incorrect by as much as ∼ 10′′. Instead, we transformed the equa- torial coordinates to a spherical system with the origin at the center of NGC 5128 and the axes defined by the photometric axes. We adopt the center of NGC 5128 to be the value given by Kunkel & Bradt (1971), which is (13h25m27.s72, −43◦01′05.′′8, J2000). This is the same value used in H95. The pole of this system is at (09h07m35.s9, +24d47m39.′′63, J2000), and the longitude of the north celestial pole in this system is 138.◦72103. The transformed values are given with enough precision to recover the original equatorial coordinates. We also present a catalog of PN candidates detected in our imaging for which we do not have a velocity because they have not been observed spectroscopically. There are 361 remaining PN candidates, and they are listed in Table 7. 3.3. X-ray matches We compared our PN catalog with the catalog of X- ray point sources in NGC 5128 presented by Kraft et al. (2001). Three X-ray sources are within 2′′ of a known PN, although one of these matches (K-053) is more likely to be with with a neighboring continuum object. These PN have IDs 525, 4225, and 5203, and they match with X-ray sources K-053, K-080, and K-241. Table 7. Unconfirmed PN Candidates in NGC 5128 ID RA(J2000) Dec(J2000) 13:25:36.95 −43:00:59.6 13:25:39.09 −43:01:01.9 13:25:35.18 −43:00:31.0 13:25:36.67 −43:00:11.5 13:25:41.42 −43:01:25.2 13:25:33.86 −43:00:57.4 13:25:35.00 −43:00:13.0 13:25:52.98 −43:00:55.8 13:25:49.47 −43:01:43.7 13:25:35.68 −43:00:41.2 212 215 227 228 229 231 232 235 238 239 Note. -- There are 361 unconfirmed PNe. The complete version of this table is in the electronic edition of the Journal. The printed edition contains only a sample. 4. RESULTS 4.1. The PN Spatial Distribution Our catalog of PN velocities is unique in its size and spatial coverage. We plot the positions of each confirmed PN on an image of NGC 5128 in Figure 2. The outline of our survey area is also drawn, and follows the outer boundaries of the fields shown in Figure 1. There are a few gaps in our coverage within this region, mainly due to the small CCDs used in the original H93 survey, but also due to a few errors in pointing. The gap between fields 8 and 10 is mostly covered by the H93 survey, but the 6′ gaps between fields 14/15, 16/17, and 18/19 are real. Besides these small regions, almost all of the area within this boundary has been observed to a uniform depth. Most of the PNe lie near the photometric major axis of the galaxy, which is at a position angle of 35◦. This is especially so in the halo, where the PNe mirror the disky structure seen in deep photographic images (Malin 1978, also shown in Israel 1998). While there are three PNe at projected radii of 80 kpc in our NE Mosaic field, there is a notable absence of PNe in our southwest Mosaic field. This is not surprising, however, as the low surface brightness halo light is known to be somewhat asymmet- ric, extending more toward the northeast. Qualitatively, the PNe do appear to follow the low surface brightness halo light seen in Malin's image and in our own obser- 8 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Fig. 2. -- Spectroscopically confirmed PNe in NGC 5128. As in Figure 1, this image is a 2◦ × 2◦ DSS image centered on NGC 5128. PNe are represented by circles, and the line marks the outer boundary of our survey region. There are a few gaps in our sky coverage of the inner regions due to the small CCDs used in the original H93 survey (see Figure 1). vations, and are able to probe regions even fainter than those accessible to broadband photometry. The detection along the NE major axis of three PNe at ∼ 80 kpc with normal velocities (i.e. they are bound to the galaxy) supports the idea that the stellar halo ex- tends to these distances and beyond. Even though these three PNe are spatially close in projection, possibly sug- gesting some form of halo substructure, we think it is unlikely that they are associated with either each other or the dwarf irregular galaxy ESO 324-G024, which is just under 20 kpc away. ESO 324-G024 has an optical radius of under 2 kpc, the individual PNe are over 15 kpc apart, and they collectively have a velocity dispersion of 172 km s−1. The large differences in their radial veloci- ties can be more easily explained by an extension of the velocity field seen in the inner halo. 4.2. The PN Velocity Field Both the density of PN velocities in the inner regions and the number of PNe velocities in the outer halo make our sample a valuable resource for dynamical studies. Unlike traditional major and minor axis long-slit spec- troscopy of ellipticals (e.g. Franx, Illingworth, & Heck- man 1989), discrete velocity tracers such as PNe and Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 9 Spatial Distribution and Velocity Field for 780 Cen A PNe 40 20 0 −20 −40 > +100 km/s > +100 km/s +50 km/s +50 km/s 0 km/s 0 km/s −50 km/s −50 km/s < −100 km/s < −100 km/s ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 3. -- Raw PN velocity field. The X-axis is along the photometric major axis (positive is NE), and the Y-axis is along the photometric minor axis (positive is NW). Dotted ellipses trace the rough isophotes for NGC 5128 from 1 -- 4 re. As in Figure 2, the solid line traces the outer boundary of our survey area. Each point represents the location and radial velocity of a single PN. PN with velocities larger than systemic (receding) are represented by crosses, and those with velocities smaller than systemic (approaching) are represented by open boxes. The color of each point shows the magnitude of the velocity with respect to systemic. Red points are rapidly receding, green points have velocities near zero, and blue points are rapidly approaching. globular clusters are more conducive to producing full, two-dimensional velocity fields at large radii. Ongoing kinematic surveys with the planetary nebula spectro- graph (Douglas et al. 2002), and integral field spectro- graphs like SAURON (Bacon et al. 2001), promise that two-dimensional velocity fields will be much more com- mon in the coming years. In Figure 3, we show our raw PN velocity field. We plot in coordinates centered on NGC 5128, where the X- axis is the photometric major axis (positive is northeast), and the Y-axis is the photometric minor axis (positive is northwest). Dotted ellipses trace the rough isophotes for NGC 5128 from 1 -- 4 re. These conventions are the same as those used in H95. As in Figure 2, the solid line traces the outer boundary of our survey area. Each point repre- sents the location and radial velocity of a single PN. PNe with velocities larger than systemic (receding) are repre- sented by crosses, and those with velocities smaller than systemic (approaching) are represented by open boxes. The color of each point shows the magnitude of the ve- locity with respect to systemic. Despite the large ve- locity dispersion, the bulk rotation along the major axis described by H95 clearly extends farther into the halo. Previous work with discrete velocity tracers, such as PNe or globular clusters, use a variety of techniques to extract bulk kinematics. The size of the sample usually dictate the methods used. For small samples, it is of- ten beneficial to assume a reasonable parametric model, such as solid-body rotation or a flat rotation curve. In cases where there are sufficient numbers of test parti- cles, some have used non-parametric methods to avoid a priori assumptions of the form of the mean velocity field. For example, Merritt, Meylan & Mayor (1997) used the method of thin plate smoothing splines in con- junction with generalized cross-validation and penalized likelihood techniques to recover the velocity distribution of stars in the Galactic globular cluster ω Centauri. In NGC 1316, Arnaboldi et al. (1998) used a similar tech- nique and compared their results from those derived from parametric estimates. As data sets continue to grow in size, non-parametric techniques are likely to become more common. We chose to represent NGC 5128's kinematics by es- timating line-of-sight velocity moments as a function of position with a non-parametric smoothing algorithm. At the position of each PN, we applied a local linear smoother using a bivariate Gaussian kernel function, Kh(x′, y′), with bandwidth h (which is σ for a Gaus- sian kernel). This estimator has the advantage of be- ing relatively simple and computationally fast. Like all smoothers, it requires that we make decisions regarding both the order of the approximation and the smoothing 10 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Spatial Distribution and Velocity Field for 780 Cen A PNe ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 40 20 0 −20 −40 > +100 km/s > +100 km/s +50 km/s +50 km/s 0 km/s 0 km/s −50 km/s −50 km/s < −100 km/s < −100 km/s 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 4. -- Kernel smoothed PN velocity field. Definition of axes and points are the same as in Figure 2. We estimated the mean streaming motion at the location of each PN using a non-parametric local linear smoother with a 3 kpc bandwidth Gaussian kernel function. Significant rotation is visible about both the major and minor axes. scale. In the general case of local polynomial smoothers, we need to choose the order of the polynomial. We used a linear smoother, as there was little reason to use higher order polynomial smoothers given the high intrinsic stellar velocity dispersion. Next, it is impor- tant that a smoothing scale is chosen that best matches the data. Small bandwidths for sparsely sampled data do not smooth over the dispersion in the velocity field, while large bandwidths in rapidly varying regions may wash out real features. Bandwidths can also be allowed to vary as a function of local density. Keeping these trade-offs in mind, we settled on a fixed bandwidth of h = 3 kpc for our kernel. This smoothing scale was the smallest one that did not preserve noisy features in densely sampled regions. We also found that fixing the bandwidth did not result in a loss of information in the outer halo, and has the benefit of making the velocity field easier for readers to interpret. The final results are not strongly sensitive to the bandwidth size. However, for h > 5 kpc, we lose resolution within 1 re, a region where the velocity field shows interesting structure. The resulting velocity field is shown in Figure 4, where each PN's velocity has been replaced with v(x, y), the estimate of the mean velocity field at that position. This smoothed velocity field shows much more clearly the bulk motion of the stars in NGC 5128. One can see the fast, disk-like rotation of stars along the major axis, as well as significant minor axis rotation. Figure 4 also shows point symmetry in the velocity field -- i.e. stars on opposite sides of the origin have op- posite velocities with respect to the galaxy, (x, y, v) → (−x,−y,−v). This symmetry is expected for triaxial potentials, and can be exploited to double the num- ber of data points. We tested the validity of assum- ing point symmetry by calculating the correlation be- tween the original and antisymmetric (reflected through the origin) velocity fields. We computed the Spearman rank-order correlation coefficient, which has a range of −1 for perfectly anti-correlated samples to +1 for per- fectly correlated samples. Restricting ourselves to a re- gion of NGC 5128 that is well-sampled, a 100 × 30 kpc box with 724 PNe, we compute a correlation coefficient of 0.84. This rejects by 23σ the null hypothesis -- that the reflected field is uncorrelated with the original. Because of this symmetry, we can create a velocity field with 1560 velocities. This field contains both the original PNe as well as their reflected counterparts. The smoothed, antisymmetrized velocity field is shown in Fig- ure 5. Two things are immediately apparent in this ve- locity field. First, the strong major axis rotation is rein- forced, extending to at least 50 kpc, and maybe as far out as 80 kpc. There is also weaker but still significant rota- tion along the minor axis that extends as far as the data goes. Second, the line of zero-velocity is both misaligned and twisted with respect to the photometric axes. Both of these effects are expected when observing a triaxial system from certain viewing angles (Statler 1991). The twisting of the zero velocity contour (ZVC) is more Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 11 Spatial Distribution and Velocity Field for 780x2 Cen A PNe 40 20 0 −20 −40 > +100 km/s > +100 km/s +50 km/s +50 km/s 0 km/s 0 km/s −50 km/s −50 km/s < −100 km/s < −100 km/s ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 5. -- Smoothed, antisymmetrized PN velocity field. This figure is similar to Figure 4 except that we have taken advantage of the point-symmetry in the velocity field, as expected for a triaxial potential. In addition to the original PNe shown in Figure 2, the position of each PN was reflected through the origin and the sign of its velocity was reversed. Together, these PN were kernel-smoothed as in Figure 4. evident in Figure 6, where we display only those positions that have velocities within ±12 km s−1 of zero. At the center of the galaxy, the ZVC is almost parallel to the minor axis. At a distance of 1 re, however, it turns and follows a straight line at an angle of 7◦ from the major axis. We parametrize the ZVC as y = x (0.125 x + 5) √x2 + 2.56 where x and y are in kpc. We then plot this curve on the full antisymmetrized velocity field in Figure 7. Notice how the velocity gradient is very sharp on the ZVC side of the major axis. The rapid major axis rotation only exists in a narrow region, within ±7◦ of the photometric major axis. The rest of the galaxy halo appears to be undergoing a slower minor axis rotation. This division even appears to be true in the outer halo at 80 kpc, where PNe are in close proximity to each other but straddle the ZVC and thus have markedly different velocities. 4.3. The PN Velocity Dispersion Field We can also calculate the two-dimensional spatial de- pendence of the velocity dispersion, the second moment of the velocity distribution. We use the same local lin- ear smoother described above except that the quantity in which we are interested is now p v2. Calculating variance is always dependent on either model assump- tions or smoothing scales and both parametric and non- parametric methods are prone to bias. Napolitano et al. Spatial Distribution and Smoothed Zero Velocity Field for 780x2 Cen A PNe 40 ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 20 0 −20 −40 > +100 km/s > +100 km/s +50 km/s +50 km/s 0 km/s 0 km/s −50 km/s −50 km/s < −100 km/s < −100 km/s 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 6. -- Zero Velocity points in the NGC 5128 velocity field. To better illustrate the line of zero velocity, this figure reproduces the mean velocity field of Figure 5, but only plots locations that have velocities that are within ±12 km s−1 of zero. Notice how the zero-velocity contour starts out aligned with the minor axis, but then has a sharp kink at about 1 re where it proceeds at at angle of ∼ 7◦ to the major axis. (2001) point out that bilinear fits to a discrete sample of radial velocities can introduce bias in estimates of the ve- locity dispersion. This can be a problem in the sparsely sampled outer regions where a small smoothing scale can underestimate the dispersion, and over-smoothing can 12 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Spatial Distribution and Velocity Field for 780x2 Cen A PNe ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 40 20 0 −20 −40 > +100 km/s > +100 km/s +50 km/s +50 km/s 0 km/s 0 km/s −50 km/s −50 km/s < −100 km/s < −100 km/s 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 7. -- Smoothed antisymmetrized velocity field with zero velocity contour (ZVC) plotted. Notice how the rapid major axis rotation is only present within ±7◦ of the major axis, while the rest of the galaxy halo undergoes a slower minor axis rotation. overestimate it. In Figure 8, we present our attempt at producing a ve- locity dispersion field for NGC 5128. This figure differs from previous ones in that we used a varying bandwidth kernel to partially compensate for the sparse sampling in the halo. We set the bandwidth to the larger of 3 kpc or the distance to the tenth nearest neighbor. While the es- timated dispersions beyond ∼ 5 re are likely to be biased, we can still see real and interesting structure in the in- ner halo. The colors in Figure 8 correspond to the degree of pressure support, with red points being "hotter". As one would expect for an elliptical galaxy, the center has a high velocity dispersion. The velocity dispersion stays high (σ ∼ 150 km s−1) then falls gradually along the ma- jor axis. Along the minor axis, the dispersion drops more rapidly. This agrees with the measurements of H95, who found that the velocity dispersion changed as a function of position angle with the highest dispersion being where the rotation was also highest. 4.4. Intrinsic Shape and Triaxiality Observationally, two-dimensional velocity data in the halos of early-type galaxies are still rare. When such data sets exist, they are useful for comparing with models and simulations. In particular, we focus on the predicted velocity fields for triaxial galaxies and merger remnants. Elliptical galaxies have long been suspected to be tri- axial in shape (Binney 1978; Illingworth 1977). How- ever, recovering their true axial ratios is difficult from imaging alone because we can only see their shapes pro- Spatial Distribution and Velocity Dispersion Field for 780x2 Cen A PNe 40 ) c p k ( s i x A r o n i M c i r t e m o t o h P 20 0 −20 −40 > 150 km/s 100 km/s < 50 km/s 50 0 Photometric Major Axis (kpc) −50 Fig. 8. -- NGC 5128 velocity dispersion field. The PN sample used was antisymmetrized. The dispersion was calculated using a variable bandwidth kernel with the bandwidth set to the larger of 3 kpc or the distance to the tenth nearest neighbor. Dispersion estimates beyond ∼ 5re are likely to be biased and should be ignored. The colors are determined by the magnitude of the dispersion, with red points representing the dynamically hottest regions. In the inner regions, there is a large degree of pressure support which declines gradually along the major axis, and more quickly along the minor axis. jected onto the sky. Many have shown that mapping the two-dimensional velocity field gives additional lever- age on this problem (e.g. Binney 1985; Wilkinson et al. 1986; Statler 1987). In an attempt to constrain the in- Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 13 prolate spheroid. The axial ratios can then be expressed as trinsic shapes of elliptical galaxies, Statler (1991, S91) studied the morphology of projected velocity fields as a function of axial ratios and viewing angles. In a triax- ial potential, stars can follow "tube" orbits about the long and short axes, or "box" orbits that have no net angular momentum (there are others, but we limit this discussion to these families). Intermediate (y ) axis tube orbits, however, are not stable. As a result, the distribu- tion of x-tube and z-tube orbits, in conjunction with the viewing angle, determine the shape of the velocity field. For certain viewing angles, both kinematic misalign- ment and kinks in the zero-velocity contour will re- sult. Examples of this are shown in S91's Figure 3. Some of these velocity fields are qualitatively similar to the NGC 5128 field in Figure 7. While this particu- lar model is not necessarily the best for comparing with NGC 5128 -- S91 used more extreme axial ratios to em- phasize the effect -- it is a nice illustration of how the ZVC can change with viewing angle in a triaxial galaxy. H95 combined PNe kinematics with the orientation of the dust lane to constrain the orientation and axial ratios of NGC 5128. By assuming that the inner portion of the central gas disk has settled and lies in the plane perpen- dicular to the long axis, they were able to determine that we are viewing NGC 5128 nearly along the intermediate axis. Conveniently, this means that the photometric ma- jor axis corresponds to the intrinsic long axis, and the photometric minor axis corresponds to the intrinsic short axis. The viewing angle that they derived was θ = 90◦ and φ = 107◦. Like in S91, θ is defined as the angle of the line of sight from the z-axis. Since we are supposedly looking down a line-of-sight (LOS) that is in the x − y plane, this value is 90◦. A possible point of confusion is that Hui and Statler define φ differently. Hui defines it as the angle in the x − y plane of the LOS from the long x-axis, while Statler defines it as the angle from the −y-axis. The result is that φH95 = 107◦ is equivalent to φStatler = 107◦ + 90◦ = 197◦. This same LOS can equivalently be described as θ = −90◦ and φStatler = 17◦. With fewer PNe, H95 measured a single kinematic axis in NGC 5128 that was misaligned by 39◦ from the pho- tometric minor axis. As a result, Mathieu, Dejonghe, & Hui (1996) classified the morphology of the velocity field as "Nn" -- a normal, single maximum/minimum veloc- ity field with a normal core whose outer ZVC deviates from the core ZVC by less than 30◦. With our larger catalog and denser sampling, we see that the ZVC does in fact deviate significantly in the core. Hence, we re- classify NGC 5128's velocity field as "Dd", i.e. one with two peaks in velocity (seen in this case along the major and minor axes) and a kinematically distinct core. This is consistent with S91's statement that D-type fields and d-type cores are most favored when the view is down the y-axis. The non-linearity of the ZVC also affects H95's deter- mination of NGC 5128's axial ratios. If a, b, and c corre- spond to the long, intermediate, and short axes, and the axial ratios are defined as ζ = b/a, ξ = c/a and 1 ≥ ζ ≥ ξ, then the triaxiality of a galaxy can be parameterized as T = 1 − ζ2 1 − ξ2 (1) (S91). T is equal to 0 for an oblate spheroid and 1 for a ζ2 = 1 − ξ2 = 1 − T (1 − e2) 1 − T e2cos2φ 1 − e2 1 − T e2cos2φ (2) (3) where e is the observed (projected) axial ratio, and which we take to be 0.8 (H95). The asymptotic position angle of the ZVC with respect to the intrinsic short axis, which in the case of NGC 5128 is the photometric minor axis, depends on the degree of triaxiality as sin−1√T (S91). Because H95 had a smaller sample of PNe in a smaller area, they determined that this angle was 39◦. However, as we have seen from Sec- tion 4.2, this angle is actually closer to 83◦. Using this new value, we obtain T = 0.985, a value that is signifi- cantly more prolate than the T = 0.40 derived by H95. Given the previous values for the viewing angles, we ob- tain axial ratios (b/a, c/a) = (0.791, 0.787). While the value of c/a is almost identical to H95's, our value for b/a is smaller than H95's value of 0.92. Whereas H95 found NGC 5128 to be slightly oblate and significantly triaxial, we find that the shape of NGC 5128 is very nearly prolate. Statler's velocity field classifica- tions (his Figure 6), however, show that a galaxy this prolate is unlikely to show a "Dd" velocity field from this viewing angle. This discrepancy could arise because of uncertainty in the angle of the ZVC. Nevertheless, this clearly shows the importance of measuring the velocity field well into the halo. Only the dense sampling and large spatial extent of our survey showed the more precise asymptotic angle of the ZVC. Of course, this treatment assumes a certain degree of symmetry and dynamical re- laxation. While we find that the velocity field is quite symmetric, the outer isophotes of NGC 5128 still show the effects of non-equilibrium motions that must have been caused by recent interactions. Merger simulations might help shed more light on the intrinsic shape of the potential, and whether figure rotation might be necessary to reproduce the observed kinematics. 4.5. Mass Estimates One of the major advantages of using discrete veloc- ity tracers such as PNe is that they are detectable at very large radii. Because we can only constrain the mass within our most distant test particle, getting kinematic information in the halos of galaxies is essential for de- termining their total mass. Total masses of elliptical galaxies have been estimated dynamically using spectral absorption-line profiles (e.g. Gerhard et al. 2001, Gra- ham et al. 1999), PNe (e.g. H95, Ciardullo et al. 1993), globular clusters (e.g. Cot´e et al. 2001, Romanowsky & Kochanek 2001, Cot´e et al. 2003), hot X-ray gas (For- man, Jones, & Tucker 1985), weak gravitational lens- ing (McKay et al. 2002), as well as combinations of these techniques. For the most part, these observations support the existence of substantial dark matter halos around ellipticals, with the exact nature of the outer re- gions a function of environment. Since gravity dominates most formation processes, we expect that many proper- ties of galaxies should scale with their total gravitational mass. Therefore, it is important to measure the total 14 Peng, Ford, & Freeman masses of nearby galaxies, where the data is obtainable. Using the smaller sample of PNe, H95 estimated the mass of NGC 5128 within 25 kpc to be 3.1 × 1011M⊙ with a mass-to-LB ratio of 10. We use the PNe in NGC 5128 to estimate its total dynamical mass within 80 kpc and compare this to previous work. Dynamical mass estimation in pressure-supported sys- tems such as elliptical galaxies is more complicated than for disk galaxies. With only two dimensions of spatial in- formation, and one dimension of velocity data, assump- tions about the symmetry of the galaxy and the isotropy of the velocity ellipsoid are necessary. One of the more convenient family of mass estimators uses the weighted mean of vlosi Ri/G where vlosi is the line of sight veloc- ity and Ri is the projected radius. The exact weighting factor depends on the assumptions the various estimators make. Variants on this theme include the virial mass esti- mator, the projected mass estimator (Heisler, Tremaine, & Bahcall 1985), and the tracer mass estimator (TME) by Evans et al. (2003). The latter is designed for the use of a "tracer" population, such as PNe or globular clusters, whose spatial distribution does not match the overall mass distribution. Simulations show that this es- timator does at least as well as the other estimators, and has significantly less bias. Given these well-suited prop- erties, we chose to use the tracer mass estimator. For this mass estimator, the mass enclosed within the outermost tracer particle is M = C GN Xi v2 losi .Ri where C = 4(α + γ) π 4 − α − γ 3 − γ 1 − (rin/rout)(3 − γ) 1 − (rin/rout)(4 − α − γ) , the form of gravitational force field is ψ(r) ∝ r−α, and the space density of tracer particles goes as r−γ. This mass estimate is only for pressure support, so the contri- bution from rotation must be added separately. We estimate γ using the surface density of PNe in cir- cular annular bins, shown in Figure 9. The inner 5 kpc shows the effects of incompleteness, and the drop off at large radii is likely due to the increased diskiness of the isophotes. However, the PNe between projected radii of 5 and 40 kpc nicely follow a power law with γ = 2.54. In addition, we assume an isothermal potential (α = 0) and an isotropic velocity distribution. These are both shown to be reasonable assumptions for halo velocity tracers in nearby galaxies, e.g. M 31 (Evans et al. 2003), M 87 (Cot´e et al. 2001), and M 49 (Cot´e et al. 2003). The TME only calculates the contribution of random motions to the mass. As we have shown, the stars in NGC 5128 have a large rotational component that must be included. This contribution is separable in the Jeans equation and is simply Mrot(r) = hvroti2r/G, where hvroti is the mean rotation speed. We take hvroti to be 100 km s−1 since this is where the PN rotation curve flattens. The rotation of the PNe will be discussed more extensively in the following section. The total dynamical mass of NGC 5128 within 80 kpc, as estimated by the tracer mass estimator, is 5.3±0.5 × 1011M⊙. The error in this estimate is purely statis- tical and was derived using the bootstrap with 1000 Radial Profile of Mass Tracers 1.0000 0.1000 0.0100 ) 2 c p k / N ( g o l 0.0010 0.0001 10 R (kpc) Fig. 9. -- Radial distribution of PNe. We fit a power-law to the radial surface density of PNe (Σ ∝ Rγ ) for the pur- pose of using the tracer mass estimator. PNe were binned in circular annuli. The inner regions show the effects of incom- pleteness, while the drop off in the outer regions is likely due to breakdown of our assumption of spherical symmetry. resamplings. Assuming that the stellar component of NGC 5128 has a B-band luminosity of LB = 3.98 × 1010L⊙ (H95), we get M/LB = 13 ± 1. For self-consistency, we compare masses from the TME with previously derived values. When we use only the PNe available to H95, we derive a mass within 25 kpc of 3.3 ± 0.6 × 1011M⊙, a value in close agreement with the mass of 3.1 × 1011M⊙ derived in H95 using the spheri- cal Jeans equation, and that of ∼ 4 × 1011M⊙ estimated in Mathieu, Dejonghe, & Hui (1996) using the QP tech- nique. 4.6. The Extended Stellar Disk The presence of an extended stellar disk along the ma- jor axis allows us to make some useful simplifications. As did H95, we treat this major axis sample as a thick, rotating disk in a spherical potential. Although we have evidence that NGC 5128's potential is likely triaxial in shape, the approximation of spherical symmetry in this case is not likely to introduce egregiously large biases because NGC 5128 is not very triaxial. In fact, when Mathieu et al. (1996) modeled NGC 5128 using triaxial Stackel potentials, their mass estimate was statistically indistinguishable from the value obtained from the spher- ical Jeans equation. ◦ In Figure 10, we show the rotation curve and line-of- sight velocity dispersion profile for PNe along the major axis. PNe were included in this sample if they had a per- pendicular distance from the major axis of ±2′ or were cone about the major axis with respect to within a ±10 the origin. The first criterion is the same as for H95, and the latter was added so that more PNe from the outer regions could be included. The PNe on one side were re- flected through the origin to create a single radial profile for 302 PNe. The points with error bars in Figure 10 are the binned values as a function of radius. These values are listed in Table 8. We also kernel smoothed the entire data set with a variable-width gaussian, with the width inversely proportional to the local density of PNe. The errors in Vrot and σ are equal to σ/√N and σ/√2N , respectively. 150 100 50 ) s / m k ( t o r V 0 0 Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 15 NGC 5128 Major Axis PNe 20 40 Projected Distance (kpc) 60 80 Fig. 10. -- Rotation curve and velocity dispersion for major axis PNe. We use the PNe along the extended stellar disk to show the rotation and dispersion in the stars. PNe included are either within a perpendicular distance of ±2′ from the major axis or ±10◦ cone centered on the major axis. In both plots, the points represent binned values along the major axis while the solid line is the local kernel-smoothed value where the kernel width is a function of the local density. (a) The top panel shows that the rotation curve rapidly rises and flattens at ∼ 100 km s−1. (b) The bottom panel shows the dispersion dropping from a central value of 140 km s−1to a minimum of ∼ 75 km s−1. Beyond 20 kpc, V /σ varies between 1 and 1.5. Table 8. Binned Major Axis PNe Rotation and Dispersion and 1.5. Rproj (kpc) 1.4 2.2 2.7 3.7 5.3 7.9 11.5 17.6 24.0 34.4 50.6 78.5 Vrot km s−1 19 ± 22 29 ± 23 34 ± 19 80 ± 24 93 ± 18 48 ± 21 95 ± 19 103 ± 23 100 ± 19 109 ± 22 80 ± 30 135 ± 97 σ km s−1 139 ± 16 143 ± 16 122 ± 14 153 ± 17 113 ± 13 133 ± 15 120 ± 13 109 ± 16 84 ± 13 74 ± 16 73 ± 21 137 ± 69 Figure 10a shows that the rotation velocity of major axis PNe rises until 10 kpc, at which point it stays flat at ∼ 100 km s−1. This behavior was seen out to 25 kpc in H95, and appears to be constant out to the limits of our data. The velocity dispersion has a central value of ∼ 140 km s−1, consistent with absorption line spec- troscopy (Wilkinson et al. 1986), and slowly declines to ∼ 75 km s−1 at 50 kpc. Outside of 20 kpc, the ratio be- tween rotational and pressure support, V /σ is between 1 4.7. Mass Estimation with the Jeans Equation Following the methods of H95, we apply the spherical Jeans equation to the major axis rotation and line-of- sight velocity dispersion profile to derive the dynamical mass distribution in NGC 5128. Briefly, the Jeans equa- tion for a spherical, isotropic stellar system is d(ρσ2) dr = − GM (r)ρ r2 + ρV 2 rot r (4) which, when solved for the velocity dispersion is σ2(r) = ρ−1Z ∞ r GM (x)ρ x2 dx − ρ−1Z ∞ r ρV 2 rot x dx (5) Another assumption we must make is the form of the mass model. We adopt a two-component mass model for the luminous and dark matter in the galaxy. Like H95, we choose the Hernquist (1990) mass model for the luminous component, which has the form ρ(r) = Mla 2π 1 r(r + a)2 , (6) where Ml is the total luminous mass, and a is the scale length and relates to the effective radius of the familiar de Vaucouleurs law as a = re/1.8153. 16 Peng, Ford, & Freeman ) s / m k ( t o r V 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0 Wilkinson et al. PNe 20 60 Distance along Photometric Major Axis (kpc) 40 80 Isothermal NFW Hernquist Fig. 11. -- (a) Major axis rotation curve. We fit a parametrized flat rotation curve to the rotation data shown in Figure 10a. (b) Jeans Equation fit to the major axis velocity dispersion profile. In the bottom panel is the best fit line-of-sight velocity dispersion profile for three different dark halo mass models. For the dark component, we assume three different mass models: the Hernquist mass profile, a pseudo- isothermal halo with a core, and the mass profile from Navarro, Frenk, & White (1996, 1997, NFW). The den- sity profile of the isothermal halo has the form ρ(r) = ρ0 1 + (r/D)2 , (7) where ρ0 is the central density, and D is the scale length. Correspondingly, the cumulative mass profile is M (r) = 4πρ0D2 [r − D arctan(r/D)]. (8) The NFW density and mass profiles take the forms ρ(x) = ρs x(x + 1)2 , M (x) = 4πρsr3 s [ln(1 + x) − x 1 + x ], (9) (10) where x = r/rs, rs is the scale radius at which the slope of the profile transitions to the r−3 regime, and ρs is the density at rs. Thus, the total mass model is M (r) = Mlr2 (r + a)2 + Mdark(r), (11) where Ml is the luminous mass of the galaxy which is allowed to vary, a is the scale length which is fixed from the galaxy surface photometry, and Mdark(r) is one of the three mass models described above. We also parametrize the intrinsic (three-dimensional) rotation curve as Vrot(r) = , (12) v0r p(r2 + r2 0) which asymptotically approaches the value of v0 as r → ∞. We numerically integrate these functions over the line-of-sight to obtain the projected rotation, surface mass profile, and line-of-sight velocity dispersion profile. In the fitting procedure, we first fit for v0 and r0 from the rotation curve data. Then, we solve for the best fit luminous and dark mass parameters given the projected velocity dispersion profile data. For the luminous com- ponent, we assume and fix re = 5.185 kpc (Dufour et al. 1979). The three free parameters in the mass model are then Ml, a dark matter scale length (d, D, rs), and a mass or density scale (Md, ρ0, ρs). Figure 11 shows the best-fit rotation curve and disper- sion profiles. The best-fit parameters for the rotation curve are v0 = 141 km s−1and r0 = 6.3 kpc. In these plots and fits, we also include binned long-slit spectro- scopic kinematic data from Wilkinson et al. (1986) at distances within 1.′5. These data fill a region in which there are few PNe due to the high background and large extinction toward the center of the galaxy. We show the results from our model fits in Table 9 and in the velocity dispersion plot of Figure 11. All three mass models give equally acceptable fits to the data. At small radii, the isothermal halo has a core while the other models have r−1 cusps. At large radii, the isothermal Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 17 Table 9. Mass Model Fits Model (1) Ml (2) Isothermal NFW Hernquist 1.5 × 1011 1.4 × 1011 1.4 × 1011 Scale Mass/Density (3) 0.0243 0.010 7.2 × 1011 Scale Radius Mtot(r < 80 kpc) Ml/LB Mtot/LB (6) (7) (4) (5) 4.5 14.4 31.7 5.9 × 1011 5.1 × 1011 5.0 × 1011 3.8 3.4 3.5 15 13 12 1Dark Matter halo model 2Total luminous mass (M⊙) 3ρ0 for isothermal (M⊙/pc3), ρs for NFW (M⊙/pc3), Md for Hernquist (M⊙) 4D, d, and rs, in kpc 5Total mass within 80 kpc 6Mass-to-light of luminous matter 7Total mass-to-light within 80 kpc halo falls off as r−2, the NFW as r−3, and the Hernquist profile as r−4. This behavior is reflected in the fitted parameters, where the isothermal halo requires a larger luminous mass, smaller scale length, and gives the largest total mass. The NFW and Hernquist profiles are similar, except that the Hernquist model requires a larger scale length because of its steeper falloff at large radii. For the NFW halo, we also calculate the concentration parame- ter, c = r200/rs, where r200 is the "virial radius", defined to be the radius inside of which the average density is 200 times the critical density. The halo concentration for our best-fit NFW halo model is c = 12, which is consistent with values obtained from simulations (NFW 1997). While comparisons between these three density profiles is an interesting exercise, we are not able to use our data to differentiate between them. It may in principle be possible to rule out one or more with much higher quality data at large radii, but the lack of kinematic tracers, and various degeneracies with orbital anisotropy and the assumed light distribution make the task difficult. All three models give total masses within 80 kpc of 5 -- 6×1011M⊙, with Mtot/LB ∼12 -- 15. The parameters determined for the Hernquist dark halo are not signifi- cantly different from those determined in H95 using only PNe within 25 kpc. Moreover, these values are in good agreement with those obtained with the tracer mass es- timator. An interesting check on these mass estimates is to see how many PNe, if any, would be unbound from the galaxy given the estimated mass profile. In Figure 12, we plot the radial velocity of each PN versus its projected radius. The overplotted solid lines mark the escape veloc- ity at that true radius given the best-fit two-component Hernquist mass model. The escape velocity takes the form vesc = r2G( Ml r + a + Md r + d ). (13) The dotted lines mark the escape velocity if there is no dark matter. Many PNe are not bound to the galaxy if there is no dark matter (however, this is only obvious if the PN sample extends beyond 10 kpc). This shows once again that a dark component is necessary to explain the stellar velocity distribution. All the PNe, even the outermost ones, are bound by our best-fit mass model. Although it is true that since we make the assumption of equilibrium, most of the PNe ) s / m k ( y t i c o l e V 400 200 0 −200 −400 0 20 40 Projected Radius (kpc) 60 80 Fig. 12. -- Escape velocity versus radius for PNe. Each point marks the projected radius and radial velocity of a PN. The solid lines are the local escape velocity for our best-fit two- component Hernquist mass model. The dotted lines are the same, except for a model with no dark matter. Without dark matter, many PNe are unbound. With dark matter, even the most distant PNe are consistent with being bound. should appear bound, this does not preclude any one PN from having V > vesc. It is of interest that the most dis- tant stars in NGC 5128 have velocities that are still con- sistent with being bound to the galaxy. This would not necessarily be the case for galaxies in a cluster environ- ment. Intracluster PNe have been identified in the Virgo and Fornax clusters, and have velocities that trace the cluster potential (Arnaboldi et al. 2002). An increase in σ could also be caused by a recent tidal interaction with a neighbor. The fact that NGC 5128 is in a loose group of galaxies with a lack of any nearby neighbors may help explain why these most distant PNe have very regular velocities. 5. DISCUSSION 5.1. Comparison to Merger Simulations N-body simulations of disk-disk mergers suggest that spheroidal stellar populations may be the result of one or more mergers. Moreover, Barnes (1992) showed that many simulated merger remnants have misaligned kine- matic axes. Recent simulations are producing two- dimensional velocity fields that are useful comparisons for our data. In particular, we refer to the work of Bendo & Barnes (2000) and Naab & Burkert (2001). 18 Peng, Ford, & Freeman Both of these groups simulated the mergers of two stel- lar disk/bulge systems with different mass ratios and an- gular momentum vectors at varying angles. It is impor- tant to note that these studies did not include gas dy- namics or star formation, so cannot reproduce a remnant such as NGC 5128 in detail. However, the general trends in stellar kinematics are useful baselines for comparison. They tested two families of mergers -- "equal-mass" (1:1) and "unequal-mass" (3:1). All merger remnants have masses of 3 -- 5×1011M⊙, values which are comparable to the total mass of NGC 5128. Equal-mass mergers tend to produce a wide variety of kinematic properties, often disrupting many of the initial characteristics of the pro- genitor galaxies. Unequal-mass mergers tend to preserve the disk of the larger galaxy, and hence will more consis- tently have rotational support. All kinds of mergers can produce the types of velocity field morphology we see in NGC 5128. These simula- tions show that the projected velocity contours can kink, much like those in Statler's triaxial galaxies, and in our observed velocity field. The remnant's final kinematics will be the result of the initial angular momentum (both rotational and orbital) of the progenitor galaxies, and the shape of the final potential. The properties of NGC 5128 are similar to some as- pects of both types of mergers. It is important to keep in mind that even if we were certain that NGC 5128 was the product of a disk-disk merger, it would be extremely difficult to uniquely constrain the exact parameters of the merger that occurred. Given the diskiness of the outer isophotes in NGC 5128, and the rapid rotation along the major axis, it is possible that NGC 5128 is the re- sult of an unequal-mass disk-disk merger. On the other hand, the severe misalignment of the kinematic axis in the halo is more typical of 1:1 mergers. Naab & Burk- ert (2001) use simulations to show that even these 1:1 remnants may contain a disk component, although these simulated disks are much smaller in size than the one ob- served in NGC 5128. An interesting note is that the 3:1 simulated merger remnants in Bendo & Barnes (2000) with kinematic properties most like the 1:1 merger rem- nants were also the most prolate. These prolate remnants also showed a relatively large population of X-tube or- bits, and these may be responsible for the twist in the ZVC. Thus, in the simplest comparison that we can make with these simulations, the morphology and kinematics of NGC 5128 are broadly consistent with the remnant of an unequal-mass merger. Two-dimensional velocity fields have the potential to tell us much more about the structure and formation of ellipticals if the corresponding models and simulations are available. Simulations that also include gas dissipa- tion and star formation would be especially useful. Ongo- ing surveys such as SAURON and the PN spectrograph promise to accumulate a wealth of data in the coming years. 5.2. Mass-to-Light By assuming isotropy, we derive a mass within 80 kpc of 5 × 1011M⊙, which gives a mass-to-light ratio of M/LB ∼ 13. We can also compare this mass to the total K-band luminosity, which should be a better mea- sure of the old stellar population of the galaxy. Re- cently, the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS) imaged and measured photometry for NGC 5128 in their Large Galaxy Atlas (Jarrett et al. 2003). They measured an apparent total magnitude of Ks = 3.942 ± 0.016, which translates to MKs = −23.778, a value slightly brighter than M ∗ K for the K -- band galaxy luminosity function (Kochanek et al. 2001). This gives a Ks-band luminos- ity of LKs = 6.97 × 1010L⊙ and a mass-to-light ratio of M/LKs ∼ 7. The reader must be warned that mass estimates are fraught with systematic uncertainties due to the many assumptions made. For instance, we have assumed that the surface radial distribution of stars continues as ei- ther a power law, de Vaucouleurs law, or Hernquist pro- file even at very large radii. Given the extremely low surface brightness of the integrated stellar light, and the small number of PNe at these distances (we detect 4 PNe beyond 60 kpc), it is currently extremely difficult to accurately constrain the density profile at these radii. However, the amount of light in these regions is negligible for the purposes of determining the total luminosity of the galaxy. Likewise, the abundance of two-dimensional velocity data behooves us to eventually model the mass distribution with non-spherical geometries. In this case, we are fortunate that the unique, nearly edge-on disk-like component in NGC 5128 works in our favor by simplify- ing the geometry of the tracer PNe in the halo. What we can see is that the stars in NGC 5128 do exist in detectable numbers at distances as great as 80 kpc (at least in one direction), and that their velocities are fairly well-behaved, extending the flat rotation profile seen in the inner halo. Although dark matter is required to explain the ob- served stellar kinematics in NGC 5128, our value for M/LB is noticeably low when compared to those de- termined for ellipticals using X-ray halos and satellite kinematics. This is interesting, especially in light of re- cent results from the PN spectrograph group that re- port low mass-to-light ratios for ellipticals within 5 re (Romanowsky et al. 2003). Bahcall, Lubin, & Dor- man (1995) compiled the values of M/LB for galax- ies in the literature and found that they are closer to 200±50 R/(100kpc) for ellipticals and 60±10 (R/100kpc) for spirals. If we assume H0 = 70 and calculate M/LB for R = 80 kpc, then these are lowered somewhat to val- ues of 112± 28 and 34 ± 6, but both are still larger than what we are measuring by over 3σ. H95 also remarked that the dynamical mass they measured within 25 kpc was systematically lower than that measure by Forman, Jones, & Tucker (1985) from ROSAT data. van Gorkom et al. (1990) reached a similar conclusion when compar- ing H I dynamical mass estimates with the X-ray esti- mates. However, Kraft et al. (2003) recently used Chan- dra and XMM data to measure the total gravitating mass with 15 kpc and determined a value of ∼ 2 × 1011M⊙, which is statistically indistinguishable from the values we obtain from our mass models within the same radius. This independent mass determination implies that our assumptions of orbital isotropy and a high inclination for the stellar disk are not likely to be grossly wrong, at least within 15 kpc. Could it be possible that NGC 5128 appears brighter than expected, either because of an error in measurement or because it is young? Using our value of the gravitating mass, NGC 5128 would have to be over two magnitudes Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 19 fainter than what Dufour et al. (1979) measured in order for M/LB to be at the level of 80 -- 100. One potential cul- prit is that the obscuring dust lane makes extrapolation toward the central regions essential for obtaining a mag- nitude that one can compare with other galaxies. Hence, there will always be a larger than normal uncertainty in the galaxy's measured luminosity, although this is less true for infrared wavelengths. However, we think it is un- likely that such a large error was made. Could NGC 5128 be intrinsically brighter than most ellipticals because it is young? Using the 2001 release of the Bruzual & Char- lot (1993) evolutionary synthesis models, we find that for solar metallicity, the mean age of the "old" component of NGC 5128 (excluding the dust lane region) would need to have an age of 2 Gyr in order to be two magnitudes brighter than a similarly enriched 12 Gyr old population. While there is growing evidence that some fraction of the stars in NGC 5128 formed in a secondary event (e.g. Rejkuba 2003), it is unlikely the entire galaxy could be this young, especially since some globular clusters in the galaxy that are at least 10 Gyr old (discussed in Peng, Ford, & Freeman 2004c). Additionally, color-magnitude diagram studies of the red giant population in the halo show no evidence for a dominant young component (Har- ris & Harris 2002). 5.3. Comparison with Other Ellipticals While some of the most massive ellipticals can have central velocity dispersions of σ ∼ 300 km s−1, NGC 5128 has a more intermediate value for its central velocity dispersion with σ ∼ 150 km s−1. Likewise, with ab- solute magnitudes of MB = −20.8 and MKs = −23.778, NGC 5128 has an typical luminosity for early-type galax- ies. The measured amount of total luminous mass is 1.4 × 1011M⊙, and its stellar mass-to-light ratio is Ml/LB ∼ 3.5. These properties of NGC 5128's stellar component all are what one would expect for a typi- cal elliptical galaxy, so there is little reason to suspect that its dark halo should be less massive than in other galaxies. While it is possible that our assumption of isotropy for the stellar orbits is incorrect, fully radial or- bits (which maximizes the discrepancy) might increase the total M/L by a factor of two, but not a factor of ten. Could the low value for M/L be explained by the lumi- nous component rather than the total mass (i.e. by the stellar population rather than the dark matter)? If so, then this should be evident in the colors of the galaxy. How do the mean integrated optical colors of NGC 5128 compare to those of other, perhaps less morphologically disturbed ellipticals? We compare the U -- V color of NGC 5128 to those of Virgo and Coma elliptical galax- ies using photometry from Bower, Lucey, & Ellis (1992). The colors of ellipticals are known to correlate with galaxy properties such as velocity dispersion, surface brightness, and luminosity so it is important to compare physically similar galaxies. We plot the color-velocity dispersion relation for these galaxies and for NGC 5128, because the velocity dispersion for NGC 5128 is well- measured with a value of 150 km s−1 (Wilkinson et al. 1986, H95). We have obtained our own measure of the colors of NGC 5128 using CCD photometry of the galaxy introduced in Peng et al. (2002), and further described in Peng, Ford, & Freeman (2004b). We deredden our measured colors assuming E(B − V ) = 0.115 (Schlegel, Color−Velocity Dispersion Relation Virgo and Coma Ellipticals (Bower, Lucey, & Ellis 1992) NGC 5128 (This study, 2' < r < 10') NGC 5128 (van den Bergh 1976, r < 2.5') 1.70 1.60 1.50 0 ) V − U ( 1.40 1.30 1.20 1.10 100 Velocity Dispersion (km/s) Fig. 13. -- (U -- V ) Color-Velocity Dispersion Relation for Elliptical Galaxies with NGC 5128. We compare our mea- surement of the mean (U -- V ) color and velocity dispersion of NGC 5128 with those measured for Virgo and Coma early- type galaxies from Bower, Lucey, & Ellis (1992). The value from van den Bergh (1976) is bluer than ours, probably be- cause that color is for a more central region. NGC 5128 appears significantly bluer than the cluster ellipticals for its velocity dispersion, although this may due to metallicity gra- dients. Finkbeiner, & Davis 1998) to obtain (U − V )0 = 1.28. These results are plotted in Figure 13. We also plot the significantly bluer measurement for NGC 5128 of van den Bergh (1976, vdB76). The difference between our measurement and the value from vdB76 underline the importance of aperture effects. vdB76 measured the color of the galaxy out to a radius of 2.′5, a region that is still affected by the young stars in the dust lane. vdB76 notes that the color of the galaxy becomes bluer as one measures regions closer to the nu- cleus. We chose to generously mask the dust lane to avoid any light from obviously recent star formation. Our mea- surement is for a region 2 -- 10 arc minutes along the ma- jor axis, and 5 -- 10 arc minutes along the minor axis. It is not surprising that our measured color is redder than that measured by vdB76. In Figure 13, we also see that NGC 5128 is fairly blue for its velocity dispersion compared to Virgo and Coma ellipticals. Even our redder measurement falls below the color-velocity dispersion relation. One could argue that this may also be an aperture effect. Elliptical galaxies are known to have metallicity (and hence, color) gradients. The aperture through which Bower et al. measured their photometry has a radius of 2.5h−1 kpc, which is 1.75 kpc for H0 = 70. Measurements through an aperture of this size for NGC 5128 would be dominated by the dust lane and its associated star formation. If we assume, however, that NGC 5128 does have an obscured, redder stellar population comparable to those in the cluster ellipticals, we can make some assumptions on the nature of the color gradient and estimate what its color would be. Franx & Illingworth (1990) measured the mean (U -- R) color gra- dient in ellipticals to be −0.23 mag per decade of radius. Since most of this is due to the change in (U −B), we assume this value as an upper limit on the gradient in (U -- V ). The mean radius at which we measure our color is ∼ 6 kpc. If we assume that the mean radius of the Bower et al. measurements are ∼ 1 kpc, then the maxi- 20 Peng, Ford, & Freeman mum expected color difference between our values would be 0.18 mag. Adding this value to our (U -- V )0 color, for a value of 1.46, does in fact bring NGC 5128 to the mean of the color-velocity dispersion relation. The major prob- lem with this extrapolation is that we do not see color gradients in NGC 5128 of this magnitude, although our measurements are still preliminary. So, while we mea- sure the color of the "old" stellar light in NGC 5128 to be significantly bluer than the central regions of local el- lipticals at the same velocity dispersion, we will need to do further work on color gradients to determine whether this is because these galaxies are intrinsically different, or because the apertures of the measurements are different. If the colors are intrinsically different, this could be another clue that there exists an intermediate-age com- ponent in the galaxy. A recent star-formation event of only 10% by mass can significantly change the optical colors of otherwise old stellar populations. However, a difference of only 0.12 mag between NGC 5128 and the mean Virgo-Coma relation cannot account for the dif- ference in age of 10 Gyr needed to make up the M/LB "deficit". We can compare this mass-to-light value with the work of Romanowsky et al. (2003), who recently reported that the three ellipticals in their study are not dominated by dark matter within 5 re. For NGC 3379, they find that the ratio of dark matter to total mass within 5 re (9 kpc) is less than 0.32. The situation in NGC 5128 is not very different. For NGC 5128, this ratio within 9 kpc is 0.26, within 5 re is 0.55, and within 80 kpc is 0.73. So, we find that the transition from luminous- to dark matter- dominated enclosed mass occurs at approximately 5 re. It is possible that much of the dark matter is beyond 80 kpc, and thus not detected by our kinematic trac- ers. NGC 5128 looks to be the product of an unusual merger -- systems with such extended disks are some- what unique. It may be that the merger parameters which led to such an extended disk also led to the dark halo being even more extended. If that is true, the mass measured by the PNe and GC, and also by the X-ray data, would not include much of the dark matter. How- ever, what is perhaps a bit puzzling is that the dark mat- ter models that we fit to the current data do not require a low concentration, which might be expected if the dark halo was very diffuse. 6. SUMMARY We extended the original PN survey of H95 by sur- veying three times farther into the halo. There are now 1141 known PNe in NGC 5128, of which 780 are con- firmed with radial velocities. Many of these new PNe are at projected distances beyond 20 kpc. Despite the disturbed appearance of NGC 5128 in op- tical images, the velocity field of the PNe is very regular. The point symmetry of the potential is evidenced in the velocity field. There is a high degree of rotation along the major axis that coincides with a faint stellar disk. Beyond 20 kpc, this disk has a flat rotation curve at a velocity of 100 km s−1. There also exists significant minor axis rotation, resulting in a well-defined twist in the line of zero velocity. This "S"-shaped zero velocity contour is characteristic of triaxial potentials and merger remnants. Using this larger sample of PNe, we re-derive the in- trinsic axial ratios of NGC 5128 and find that the galaxy may be nearly prolate, with axial ratios b/a ≈ c/a ≈ 0.79. This is in contrast to the more oblate shape derived by H95. However, this estimate is at odds with other model predictions which require a more triaxial shape, and merits further study. We also find that the kinemat- ics are consistent with simulated disk-disk merger rem- nants, and could perhaps be the result of one with a 3:1 mass ratio. The entire PN sample is used to estimate the dynam- ical mass of the galaxy using the tracer mass estimator. We also use the kinematics of the major axis stellar disk to derive a mass from the spherical Jeans equation. The rotation curve is flat out to the limit of our data while the velocity dispersion profile falls gradually. Taken to- gether, the TME and our best-fit Hernquist, isothermal halo, and NFW models give an average mass within 80 kpc of 5 × 1011M⊙, and M/LB ∼ 13. These mod- els produce masses that agree with determinations from the latest X-ray data. As H95 showed, dark matter is necessary to fit the velocity distribution of PNe beyond ∼ 10 kpc. The mass-to-light ratio of NGC 5128 is found to be abnormally low when compared to those determined for other ellipticals. It is unlikely that this M/LB difference is either due to an incorrect measurement of the galaxy light, or because the galaxy is extremely young. It may be that the dark matter halo is very extended, and that a large fraction is beyond 80 kpc. We defer further dis- cussion of the formation of NGC 5128 to a future paper (Peng, Ford, & Freeman 2004c), in which we will com- pare these field star kinematics with those of the globular clusters. E. W. P. acknowledges support from NSF grant AST 00-98566. H. C. F. acknowledges support from NASA contract NAS 5-32865 and NASA grant NAG 5-7697. We thank the staffs at CTIO and the AAO for their in- valuable help during our observing runs. We also thank David Malin for making available to us his deep photo- graphic prints of NGC 5128. E. W. P. acknowledges Tom Statler for useful discussions on the zero-velocity contour, Roger Peng for his insight on non-parametric smoothers, and Eric Barnes for discussions on mass models. We thank the anonymous referee for constructive comments. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extra- galactic Database (NED), which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technol- ogy, under contract with NASA. REFERENCES Arnaboldi, M., Freeman, K. C., Gerhard, O., Matthias, M., Kudritzki, R. P., M´endez, R. H., Capaccioli, M., & Ford, H. 1998, ApJ, 507, 759 Arnaboldi, M. et al. 2002, AJ, 123, 760 Bacon, R. et al. 2001, MNRAS, 326, 23 Bahcall, N. A., Lubin, L. M., & Dorman, V. 1995, ApJ, 447, L81 Barnes, J. E. 1992, ApJ, 393, 484 Bender, R., Saglia, R. P., & Gerhard, O. E. 1994, MNRAS, 269, 785 Bendo, G. J. & Barnes, J. E. 2000, MNRAS, 316, 315 Bertin, E. & Arnouts, S. 1996, A&AS, 117, 393 Planetary Nebulae in NGC 5128 21 Binney, J. 1978, Comments on Modern Physics, Part C - Comments on Astrophysics, vol. 8, no. 2, 1978, p. 27-36., 8, 27 Binney, J. 1985, MNRAS, 212, 767 Bower, R. G., Lucey, J. R., & Ellis, R. S. 1992, MNRAS, 254, 601 Bruzual A., G. & Charlot, S. 1993, ApJ, 405, 538 Ciardullo, R., Jacoby, G. H., & Dejonghe, H. B. 1993, ApJ, 414, 454 Ciardullo, R., Feldmeier, J. J., Krelove, K., Jacoby, G. H., & Gronwall, C. 2002, ApJ, 566, 784 Cot´e, P. et al. 2001, ApJ, 559, 828 Cot´e, P., McLaughlin, D. E., Cohen, J. G., & Blakeslee, J. P. 2003, ApJ, 591, 850 Douglas, N. G. et al. 2002, PASP, 114, 1234 Dufour, R. J., Harvel, C. A., Martins, D. M., Schiffer, F. H., Talent, D. L., Wells, D. C., van den Bergh, S., & Talbot, R. J. 1979, AJ, 84, 284 Evans, N. W., Wilkinson, M. I., Perrett, K. M., & Bridges, T. J. 2003, ApJ, 583, 752 Forman, W., Jones, C., & Tucker, W. 1985, ApJ, 293, 102 Franx, M., Illingworth, G., & Heckman, T. 1989, ApJ, 344, 613 Gerhard, O., Kronawitter, A., Saglia, R. P., & Bender, R. 2001, AJ, 121, 1936 G. 1998, A&AS, 133, 325 414, 463 [H93a] 88, 423 [H93b] 449, 592 [H95] Harris, W. E. & Harris, G. L. H. 2002, AJ, 123, 3108 Heisler, J., Tremaine, S., & Bahcall, J. N. 1985, ApJ, 298, 8 Hernquist, L. 1990, ApJ, 356, 359 Hui, X., Ford, H. C., Ciardullo, R., & Jacoby, G. H. 1993, ApJ, Hui, X., Ford, H. C., Ciardullo, R., & Jacoby, G. H. 1993, ApJS, Hui, X., Ford, H. C., Freeman, K. C., & Dopita, M. A. 1995, ApJ, Illingworth, G. 1977, ApJ, 218, L43 Israel, F. P. 1998, A&A Rev., 8, 237 Jarrett, T. H., Chester, T., Cutri, R., Schneider, S. E., & Huchra, J. P. 2003, AJ, 125, 525 Kochanek, C. S. et al. 2001, ApJ, 560, 566 Kraft, R. P., V´azquez, S. E., Forman, W. R., Jones, C., Murray, S. S., Hardcastle, M. J., Worrall, D. M., & Churazov, E. 2003, ApJ, 592, 129 Kronawitter, A., Saglia, R. P., Gerhard, O., & Bender, R. 2000, A&AS, 144, 53 Kudritzki, R.-P. et al. 2000, ApJ, 536, 19 Graham, A. W., Colless, M. M., Busarello, G., Zaggia, S., & Longo, Peng, E. W., Ford, H. C., & Freeman, K. C. 2004c, ApJ, 602, in Kunkel, W. E. & Bradt, H. V. 1971, ApJ, 170, L7 Lasker, B. M., Sturch, C. R., McLean, B. J., Russell, J. L., Jenkner, H., & Shara, M. M. 1990, AJ, 99, 2019 Malin, D. F. 1978, Nature, 276, 591 Mathieu, A., Dejonghe, H., & Hui, X. 1996, A&A, 309, 30 McKay, T. A. et al. 2002, ApJ, 571, L85 M´endez, R. H., Riffeser, A., Kudritzki, R.-P., Matthias, M., Freeman, K. C., Arnaboldi, M., Capaccioli, M., & Gerhard, O. E. 2001, ApJ, 563, 135 Merritt, D., Meylan, G., & Mayor, M. 1997, AJ, 114, 1074 Monet, D. B. A. et al. 1998, VizieR Online Data Catalog, I/252 Naab, T. & Burkert, A. 2001, ApJ, 555, L91 Napolitano, N. R., Arnaboldi, M., Freeman, K. C., & Capaccioli, M. 2001, A&A, 377, 784 Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S., & White, S. D. M. 1996, ApJ, 462, Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S., & White, S. D. M. 1997, ApJ, 490, Peng, E. W., Ford, H. C., Freeman, K. C., & White, R. L. 2002, AJ, 124, 3144 Peng, E. W., Ford, H. C., & Freeman, K. C. 2004b, ApJS, 150, in 563 493 press press Rejkuba, M., Minniti, D., Silva, D. R., Bedding, T. R. 2003, a, in press (astro-ph/0309358) Romanowsky, A. J. & Kochanek, C. S. 2001, ApJ, 553, 722 Romanowsky, A. J., Douglas, N. G., Kuijken, K., Merrifield, M. R., Gerssen, J., Arnaboldi, M., & Freeman, K. C. 2002, Galaxy evolution, theory and observations. Romanowsky, A. J., Douglas, N. G., Arnaboldi, M., Kuijken, K., Merrifield, M. R., Napolitano, N. R., Capaccioli, M., Freeman, K. C. 2003, Science, in press (astro-ph/0308518) Schlegel, D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525 Statler, T. S. 1987, ApJ, 321, 113 Statler, T. S. 1991, AJ, 102, 882 van den Bergh, S. 1976, ApJ, 208, 673 van Gorkom, J. H., van der Hulst, J. M., Haschick, A. D., & Tubbs, Wilkinson, A., Sharples, R. M., Fosbury, R. A. E., & Wallace, P. T. A. D. 1990, AJ, 99, 1781 1986, MNRAS, 218, 297
astro-ph/0703640	1	0703	2007-03-25T18:08:55	Infrared Brightness Temperature of Mars, 1983-2103	[ "astro-ph" ]	The predicted infrared brightness temperature of Mars using the 1976 model of Wright is tabulated here for the period 1983 to 2103. This model was developed for far-infrared calibration, and is still being used for JCMT calibration.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Preprint typeset using LATEX style emulateapj v. 08/22/09 INFRARED BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS, 1983-2103 EDWARD L. WRIGHT UCLA Dept. of Physics & Astronomy PO Box 951547, Los Angeles CA 90095-1547 ABSTRACT The predicted infrared brightness temperature of Mars using the 1976 model of Wright is tabulated here for the period 1983 to 2103. This model was developed for far-infrared calibration, and is still being used for JCMT calibration. Subject headings: Mars, infrared 1 AU is 1367 W/m2, and the albedo is A = 0.29. Replacing the step function temperature vs. time model used in Wright (1976) with the triangle function used in Wright (2007) led to an effective hour angle change of 0.28◦. With these mod- ifications the new code gave exactly the same brightness temperature for 82% of the entries in the Wright (1976) and Wright & Odenwald (1980) tables, when rounded to the nearest K. 18% of the entries differed by ±1 K. The positions of Mars and the Earth are computed using the low precision formulae of van Flandern & Pulkkinen (1979). The Mars pole is 21h14m, 55◦ 02.4′ (J2000) and the rotation period is 88775 sec. The modified Julian day MJD in the tables is JD−2440000. A blackbody with no limb darkening at the temperatures given in the tables will give the same flux as the Mars model at the tabulated wavelengths, given in µm: 10, 20, 34, 65, 100, 150, 250 & 350. 3. DISCUSSION This model is obsolete but these tables could be use- ful for understanding far infrared calibrations. Mars has well known albedo variations, thermal inertia variations, and craters. These could be included but then the model would depend on the local time, and the results would have to tab- ulated hourly instead of every 40 days. The treatment of the atmosphere and especially dust in the atmosphere is minimal in this model. During dust storms the coupling between the at- mosphere and the surface by infrared emission will get much larger than the 1% assumed here, and will lead to a larger ef- fective thermal inertia during dust storms. Certainly by the end of the time range in these tables there should be much more information available about thermal conditions on Mars. A comparison of this new data to the 1976 Mars model will allow one to determine appropriate calibration corrections for far-infrared and sub-millimeter data. The code used to calculate the Mars model and generate the tables presented here has been appended to the LaTex file after the \end{document}. This paper will be a Web-only manuscript, available at http://arXiv.org and its mirrors. 1. INTRODUCTION Wright (1976) improved the far infrared calibration us- ing a time variable brightness temperature of Mars to replace the constant Tb = 235 K that had been used earlier. Tb for Mars changes are due both to the eccentricity its orbit and the large phase angle reached by Mars, which produces a dramatic morning it vs. afternoon temperature change. Wright & Odenwald (1980) extended the tabulation of pre- dicted temperatures for Mars to 1983, and then further predic- tions running until 1995 were provided privately on request. In 1995 I received an E-mail from Henry Matthews at the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope requesting a further exten- sion of the tabulated predictions, and an extension was posted on the WWW1. This table was later extended to 2011 after a further request from the JCMT in 2001. As 2011 is approach- ing, I have extended this tabulation to 2103 and am posting the tables here. 2. CALCULATIONS In 1995 the old code from Wright (1976) had been lost, and a new version of the Mars program was created based on the rotating, cratered asteroid model described in Wright (2007). The modifications involved • setting the number of facets in the craters down to 1, so the model is not cratered, • setting the number of latitudes to 6, and using Gaussian quadrature weights and knots for sin(lat), • adding a constant 1% of the noon flux to allow for at- mospheric emission, • adding the angle dependent emissivity, ∝ µβ, that was used in Wright (1976). While adding the angle dependent emissivity it was noticed that Wright (1976) had assumed ǫ/(1 + β) for the hemi- spheric emissivity instead of the correct ǫ/(1 + β/2). Since the purpose of the calculation was to reproduce the old Mars model, a temperature fudge factor of +1.7% in the sub- solar temperature TSS was added to the code, along with a +4.3% increase in the thermal inertia parameter Θ = (κρCω)1/2TSS/[(1 − A)F⊙]. The thermal inertia √κρC = 0.006 cal/cm2/K/s1/2 = 251 J/m2/K/s1/2, the emissivity is ǫ = 0.9 and its angular variation is β = 0.1, the solar flux at Electronic address: [email protected] 1 http://www.astro.ucla.edu/∼wright/old mars.txt 2 Wright BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:1983-1989 TABLE 1 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:1989-1995 TABLE 2 MJD 5480 5520 5560 5600 5640 5680 5720 5760 5800 5840 5880 5920 5960 6000 6040 6080 6120 6160 6200 6240 6280 6320 6360 6400 6440 6480 6520 6560 6600 6640 6680 6720 6760 6800 6840 6880 6920 6960 7000 7040 7080 7120 7160 7200 7240 7280 7320 7360 7400 7440 7480 7520 7560 7600 7640 10 252 248 246 244 243 243 243 244 248 250 244 242 244 248 252 253 252 249 246 244 243 243 244 244 245 245 248 253 261 259 251 248 247 245 243 240 239 239 240 242 244 246 247 249 251 255 260 264 269 265 251 241 236 233 233 20 244 240 238 237 235 235 234 235 240 241 233 229 230 235 240 242 241 239 237 235 235 236 236 236 236 236 238 244 252 248 238 235 235 234 232 230 229 230 232 234 236 238 239 240 242 246 250 255 259 255 239 230 225 223 223 34 237 234 232 231 229 228 228 229 233 235 226 221 222 226 232 234 234 232 230 229 229 230 230 230 230 229 231 237 246 241 229 226 227 226 225 223 222 223 226 228 230 232 232 233 235 239 244 248 253 248 232 223 218 215 216 65 230 227 225 224 223 222 221 222 226 228 219 214 214 218 224 227 227 225 223 222 222 223 223 223 223 222 224 230 239 234 221 219 220 219 218 216 215 216 219 221 224 225 225 225 228 232 237 241 245 241 225 216 211 208 209 100 227 224 222 221 219 218 218 218 223 224 215 210 210 214 221 223 223 222 220 218 219 220 220 220 219 218 220 226 235 230 217 215 216 215 214 213 212 213 215 218 220 222 222 222 224 228 233 238 242 237 221 212 208 205 205 150 224 221 219 218 217 216 215 215 220 222 213 208 208 212 218 221 221 219 217 216 216 217 217 217 217 215 217 224 233 227 214 212 213 213 212 210 209 210 213 216 218 219 219 219 222 226 231 235 239 235 219 210 205 202 202 250 222 219 217 216 215 214 213 213 218 220 210 206 206 209 216 219 219 217 215 214 214 215 215 215 214 213 215 222 230 225 212 210 211 211 210 208 207 208 211 213 215 217 217 217 219 224 228 233 237 232 217 207 203 200 200 350 221 218 216 215 214 213 212 212 217 219 209 205 205 208 215 218 218 216 214 213 213 214 214 214 213 212 214 221 229 224 211 209 210 210 209 207 206 207 210 212 214 216 216 216 218 223 227 232 236 231 216 206 202 199 199 MJD 7680 7720 7760 7800 7840 7880 7920 7960 8000 8040 8080 8120 8160 8200 8240 8280 8320 8360 8400 8440 8480 8520 8560 8600 8640 8680 8720 8760 8800 8840 8880 8920 8960 9000 9040 9080 9120 9160 9200 9240 9280 9320 9360 9400 9440 9480 9520 9560 9600 9640 9680 9720 9760 9800 9840 10 235 238 241 245 248 250 253 257 261 264 264 261 259 258 248 235 230 229 232 236 240 244 249 253 258 263 267 268 265 260 254 249 248 243 232 228 230 234 238 244 249 255 261 267 270 269 264 258 251 247 244 244 242 234 231 20 225 229 233 236 240 242 245 248 252 254 254 251 248 249 239 224 218 218 221 226 231 236 241 245 249 254 258 259 256 249 243 240 240 234 222 217 219 224 229 234 240 246 252 258 261 260 255 248 242 238 236 236 234 223 220 34 218 222 226 230 233 236 238 242 245 247 247 243 241 242 232 217 211 211 214 219 224 229 234 238 243 248 251 252 248 242 236 233 234 228 214 210 212 217 222 228 234 239 245 251 254 253 248 241 235 231 230 230 227 216 213 65 211 215 219 223 227 229 231 235 239 240 240 236 233 235 225 210 204 203 207 212 217 222 227 231 236 241 244 245 241 234 228 226 227 221 207 202 205 210 215 221 227 232 238 244 247 246 241 234 228 225 223 224 221 209 206 100 208 212 216 220 223 225 227 231 235 237 236 232 229 231 221 207 201 200 203 209 214 219 224 228 232 237 241 241 238 230 225 223 223 218 204 199 201 206 211 217 223 229 235 241 243 243 238 230 224 221 220 220 217 206 202 150 205 209 214 217 221 223 225 229 232 234 233 229 226 229 219 204 198 197 201 206 211 216 221 225 230 235 238 238 235 227 222 220 221 215 201 196 199 204 209 215 221 226 232 238 241 240 235 228 222 219 217 218 215 203 200 250 203 207 211 215 219 220 222 226 230 232 231 227 224 226 217 202 196 195 198 204 209 214 219 223 227 233 236 236 233 225 220 218 219 213 199 194 196 202 207 212 219 224 230 236 239 238 233 225 220 216 215 215 213 201 198 350 202 206 210 214 218 219 221 225 229 231 230 226 223 225 216 201 195 194 197 203 208 213 218 222 226 232 235 235 232 224 219 217 218 212 198 193 195 201 206 211 218 223 229 235 238 237 232 224 219 215 214 214 212 200 197 IR Brightness of Mars 3 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:1995-2001 TABLE 3 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2001-2007 TABLE 4 MJD 9880 9920 9960 10000 10040 10080 10120 10160 10200 10240 10280 10320 10360 10400 10440 10480 10520 10560 10600 10640 10680 10720 10760 10800 10840 10880 10920 10960 11000 11040 11080 11120 11160 11200 11240 11280 11320 11360 11400 11440 11480 11520 11560 11600 11640 11680 11720 11760 11800 11840 11880 11920 11960 12000 12040 10 233 237 242 248 255 262 267 269 266 261 255 249 245 243 242 243 244 238 234 236 241 247 253 259 263 264 260 255 250 247 245 243 242 242 244 248 244 239 240 244 249 255 257 256 252 249 246 244 244 243 243 244 244 247 253 20 222 226 232 238 245 252 258 259 258 252 246 241 237 235 234 235 235 228 224 225 230 235 241 248 253 254 251 247 242 239 237 235 234 234 236 240 235 228 228 231 236 242 245 245 243 240 237 236 236 236 236 235 235 238 244 34 215 220 225 231 238 245 251 253 251 246 239 234 231 229 228 229 229 221 217 218 222 227 233 240 246 247 245 240 236 233 231 229 228 228 230 234 228 221 220 223 228 234 238 238 236 233 231 230 230 230 229 229 228 231 238 65 208 213 218 224 231 237 243 245 244 238 232 228 225 222 221 222 223 214 210 211 215 220 226 233 238 239 238 233 229 226 225 223 221 221 223 227 221 214 213 215 220 227 230 231 229 226 224 224 224 223 223 222 221 223 231 100 205 209 215 221 227 234 240 242 240 235 229 224 221 219 218 219 219 210 206 208 212 217 222 229 235 236 234 230 225 223 221 219 218 218 219 223 218 211 210 212 216 223 227 227 226 223 221 220 220 220 219 219 217 220 227 150 202 207 212 218 224 231 237 239 238 232 226 222 219 216 215 217 217 208 204 205 209 214 220 227 232 233 232 227 223 220 219 217 216 215 217 221 215 208 207 209 213 220 224 225 223 220 218 218 218 217 217 216 215 217 225 250 200 204 210 216 222 229 235 237 235 230 224 219 216 214 213 214 214 206 202 203 207 212 218 224 230 231 229 225 221 218 216 215 213 213 214 218 213 206 205 207 211 218 222 222 221 218 216 215 215 215 215 214 212 215 222 350 199 203 209 215 221 228 234 236 234 229 223 218 215 213 212 213 213 205 201 202 206 211 216 223 229 230 228 224 220 217 215 213 212 212 213 217 212 205 204 206 210 217 221 221 220 217 215 214 214 214 214 213 211 214 221 MJD 12080 12120 12160 12200 12240 12280 12320 12360 12400 12440 12480 12520 12560 12600 12640 12680 12720 12760 12800 12840 12880 12920 12960 13000 13040 13080 13120 13160 13200 13240 13280 13320 13360 13400 13440 13480 13520 13560 13600 13640 13680 13720 13760 13800 13840 13880 13920 13960 14000 14040 14080 14120 14160 14200 14240 10 256 249 246 247 249 248 246 244 242 241 241 242 244 245 246 247 249 253 259 266 268 257 248 242 238 236 235 236 239 241 244 247 249 251 255 258 262 263 263 263 260 245 235 231 230 232 236 240 244 248 252 256 261 265 266 20 247 237 232 233 236 237 236 234 232 232 233 235 236 237 238 238 240 244 250 258 259 245 236 231 227 225 225 227 230 233 236 239 241 242 245 249 252 253 253 253 251 235 224 219 219 222 227 231 236 240 244 247 252 256 257 34 241 229 223 225 228 229 228 227 225 225 227 229 230 231 231 231 232 237 243 251 252 237 228 223 220 218 218 220 223 227 230 233 234 236 239 242 245 246 246 246 244 228 217 212 212 215 220 225 229 234 237 241 245 249 250 65 234 222 215 217 221 222 221 220 218 218 220 222 223 225 224 224 225 230 236 244 244 230 221 216 213 211 211 213 217 220 223 226 227 229 232 235 238 239 238 239 237 221 210 205 205 208 213 218 222 227 230 234 238 242 243 100 230 218 212 213 217 218 218 216 215 215 217 219 220 221 221 220 222 226 233 240 241 226 217 213 210 208 207 209 213 217 220 223 224 225 228 232 235 236 235 235 234 217 207 202 201 204 210 214 219 223 227 230 235 239 240 150 227 215 209 210 215 216 215 214 212 212 214 216 217 219 218 217 219 224 230 238 238 224 215 210 207 205 205 207 211 214 217 220 221 222 225 229 232 233 232 232 231 215 204 199 199 202 207 212 217 221 224 228 232 236 237 250 225 213 207 208 212 213 213 212 210 210 212 214 215 216 216 215 217 221 228 236 236 222 212 208 205 203 203 205 208 212 215 218 219 220 223 227 230 231 230 230 229 213 202 197 197 200 205 210 214 219 222 225 230 234 235 350 224 212 206 206 211 212 212 211 209 209 211 213 214 215 215 214 216 220 227 234 235 220 211 207 204 202 202 204 207 211 214 217 218 219 222 226 229 230 229 229 228 212 201 196 196 199 204 209 213 218 221 224 229 233 234 4 Wright BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2007-2013 TABLE 5 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2013-2019 TABLE 6 MJD 14280 14320 14360 14400 14440 14480 14520 14560 14600 14640 14680 14720 14760 14800 14840 14880 14920 14960 15000 15040 15080 15120 15160 15200 15240 15280 15320 15360 15400 15440 15480 15520 15560 15600 15640 15680 15720 15760 15800 15840 15880 15920 15960 16000 16040 16080 16120 16160 16200 16240 16280 16320 16360 16400 16440 10 265 260 255 252 250 240 231 228 230 234 239 244 249 254 260 265 269 269 266 259 253 248 245 245 239 231 230 233 237 242 248 255 261 267 269 268 263 257 251 246 243 242 243 241 234 233 236 241 247 254 260 265 266 263 258 20 255 250 245 242 242 231 220 217 219 224 229 234 240 245 251 257 260 260 256 249 243 238 237 237 230 220 219 222 227 233 239 245 252 258 261 259 254 248 242 238 235 234 236 232 224 222 225 230 236 242 249 255 256 255 250 34 248 243 237 235 236 224 212 209 212 217 222 228 234 239 244 250 253 253 249 242 236 232 231 231 223 213 212 215 220 226 232 238 245 251 254 252 247 241 235 232 229 228 230 226 217 215 218 223 229 235 242 248 249 248 243 65 241 235 229 228 229 217 205 202 205 210 215 221 227 232 237 243 246 246 242 235 228 225 224 225 216 206 205 208 213 219 225 231 238 244 247 245 240 233 228 225 223 222 223 219 210 208 211 216 222 227 235 241 242 241 236 100 238 231 225 225 225 214 202 198 201 207 212 218 223 228 234 240 243 243 238 231 225 221 221 221 213 202 201 205 210 215 221 227 234 241 243 242 237 230 225 221 219 218 220 215 207 205 208 213 218 224 231 237 239 237 233 150 235 228 223 222 223 211 199 196 199 204 209 215 221 226 231 237 240 240 236 228 222 219 218 219 210 199 199 202 207 213 219 225 232 238 240 239 234 227 222 219 217 216 217 213 204 202 205 210 216 221 228 234 236 235 230 250 233 226 221 220 221 209 197 194 196 202 207 213 219 223 229 235 238 238 234 226 220 217 216 217 208 197 196 200 205 211 217 223 229 236 238 237 232 225 220 217 215 214 215 211 202 200 203 208 213 219 226 232 234 232 228 350 232 225 219 219 220 208 196 193 195 201 206 212 217 222 228 234 237 237 233 225 219 216 215 215 207 196 195 199 204 210 216 222 228 235 237 236 231 224 219 216 213 213 214 210 201 199 202 207 212 218 225 231 233 231 227 MJD 16480 16520 16560 16600 16640 16680 16720 16760 16800 16840 16880 16920 16960 17000 17040 17080 17120 17160 17200 17240 17280 17320 17360 17400 17440 17480 17520 17560 17600 17640 17680 17720 17760 17800 17840 17880 17920 17960 18000 18040 18080 18120 18160 18200 18240 18280 18320 18360 18400 18440 18480 18520 18560 18600 18640 10 253 248 245 243 242 242 245 245 239 237 240 245 251 256 260 259 256 252 248 245 244 243 243 243 244 247 252 249 243 244 247 251 252 250 247 245 243 242 243 244 244 245 246 248 252 259 265 258 250 247 244 241 239 238 238 20 244 240 237 235 234 234 237 237 229 226 228 232 238 244 248 249 247 243 239 238 237 236 235 235 235 238 244 238 231 230 233 238 240 239 238 235 234 234 235 236 237 237 236 238 243 251 256 246 237 235 233 230 229 228 229 34 238 234 231 229 228 228 230 230 222 219 221 224 229 236 241 242 240 236 233 231 231 230 229 228 228 231 238 231 223 221 225 230 232 232 231 228 227 228 229 230 230 230 229 231 236 244 249 237 229 227 225 223 222 221 222 65 231 227 225 223 221 221 224 224 215 212 214 217 222 229 233 234 233 229 226 225 224 223 222 221 221 224 231 224 216 214 217 222 225 225 224 222 221 221 223 223 224 223 222 223 229 237 242 230 221 220 218 216 215 214 215 100 227 224 221 219 218 218 220 220 212 209 210 213 218 225 230 231 230 226 223 221 221 220 219 218 217 221 227 221 212 210 212 219 221 221 220 218 217 218 219 220 220 220 218 220 225 234 239 226 218 216 214 213 211 210 211 150 225 221 219 217 215 215 218 218 209 206 208 211 215 222 227 228 227 223 220 219 218 217 216 215 215 218 225 218 210 207 210 216 219 219 218 216 215 216 217 217 218 217 216 217 222 231 236 223 215 213 212 210 209 208 209 250 222 219 217 215 213 213 215 216 207 204 205 208 213 220 225 226 225 221 218 217 216 215 214 213 212 216 222 216 207 205 207 214 217 217 216 213 212 213 215 215 216 215 214 215 220 229 234 221 213 211 210 208 206 205 207 350 221 218 216 214 212 212 214 215 206 203 204 207 212 219 224 225 224 220 217 216 215 214 213 212 211 215 221 215 206 204 206 213 216 216 215 212 211 212 214 214 215 214 212 214 219 228 233 220 211 210 209 207 205 204 206 IR Brightness of Mars 5 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2019-2025 TABLE 7 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2025-2031 TABLE 8 MJD 18680 18720 18760 18800 18840 18880 18920 18960 19000 19040 19080 19120 19160 19200 19240 19280 19320 19360 19400 19440 19480 19520 19560 19600 19640 19680 19720 19760 19800 19840 19880 19920 19960 20000 20040 20080 20120 20160 20200 20240 20280 20320 20360 20400 20440 20480 20520 20560 20600 20640 20680 20720 20760 20800 20840 10 240 242 244 246 248 249 252 256 260 263 266 267 256 243 236 233 232 234 237 240 244 247 251 254 258 262 264 264 261 257 256 251 238 230 228 231 234 239 244 248 253 258 263 267 268 266 260 254 249 247 245 236 229 229 233 20 231 234 236 238 239 241 243 246 250 253 256 258 246 232 225 221 221 224 227 232 236 239 242 245 249 253 255 255 251 247 246 243 228 219 217 220 224 230 235 240 244 249 255 259 259 257 250 244 239 239 237 226 218 218 222 34 224 227 230 232 233 234 236 240 244 247 249 251 239 225 218 214 214 217 221 225 229 233 236 239 242 247 248 248 243 239 239 236 221 212 210 213 218 223 228 233 238 243 248 252 253 250 243 236 233 232 231 219 211 211 215 65 218 221 223 225 226 226 229 233 237 240 242 244 232 218 211 207 207 209 214 218 223 226 229 232 236 240 241 240 236 231 232 229 214 204 203 205 211 216 221 227 231 236 241 245 246 242 235 229 226 226 224 212 203 204 208 100 214 217 220 222 222 223 225 229 233 236 238 241 228 214 207 204 204 206 210 215 219 223 225 228 232 236 238 237 232 227 228 226 210 201 199 202 207 213 218 223 228 232 238 241 242 239 231 225 222 222 221 208 200 201 205 150 212 215 217 219 220 220 222 226 230 233 236 238 226 212 205 201 201 203 208 213 217 220 223 225 229 234 235 234 230 225 226 223 208 198 196 199 205 210 215 221 225 230 235 239 239 236 228 223 219 220 218 206 197 198 203 250 210 213 215 217 218 218 220 224 228 231 234 236 223 210 203 199 199 201 206 210 214 218 221 223 227 231 233 232 227 222 223 221 206 196 194 197 203 208 213 218 223 227 233 237 237 234 226 220 217 217 216 203 195 196 200 350 209 212 214 216 217 217 219 223 227 230 233 235 222 209 202 198 198 200 205 209 213 217 220 222 226 230 232 231 226 221 222 220 205 195 193 196 201 207 212 217 222 226 232 236 236 233 225 219 216 216 215 202 194 195 199 MJD 20880 20920 20960 21000 21040 21080 21120 21160 21200 21240 21280 21320 21360 21400 21440 21480 21520 21560 21600 21640 21680 21720 21760 21800 21840 21880 21920 21960 22000 22040 22080 22120 22160 22200 22240 22280 22320 22360 22400 22440 22480 22520 22560 22600 22640 22680 22720 22760 22800 22840 22880 22920 22960 23000 23040 10 237 243 248 254 260 266 270 269 265 258 252 247 244 243 243 237 232 232 236 241 247 254 261 266 268 266 261 255 249 246 243 242 242 244 241 236 236 240 245 251 258 262 262 259 255 250 247 245 243 242 242 244 247 249 242 20 227 233 239 245 251 258 261 260 256 249 243 238 236 235 236 227 221 222 225 231 237 243 250 256 259 257 252 246 241 238 235 234 234 237 232 225 225 228 233 239 246 251 252 250 246 242 239 237 236 235 234 235 239 240 232 34 220 226 232 238 245 251 254 253 249 242 236 232 230 229 230 221 214 215 218 224 230 236 243 249 252 250 245 239 235 232 229 228 228 230 225 218 218 221 226 231 238 244 245 243 239 235 233 231 230 228 228 229 233 233 225 65 214 219 225 231 238 244 247 246 242 235 229 225 223 223 223 214 207 208 211 217 223 229 236 242 244 243 238 233 228 225 223 221 222 224 219 211 211 214 218 224 231 236 238 236 232 229 226 225 223 222 221 222 226 227 218 100 210 216 222 228 234 240 243 243 238 231 225 222 219 220 220 210 204 204 208 213 219 225 232 238 241 240 235 229 224 221 219 218 218 220 215 208 208 211 215 220 227 233 234 233 229 225 222 221 220 218 218 218 222 223 214 150 208 213 219 225 231 238 241 240 236 228 223 219 217 217 217 208 201 202 205 211 217 223 230 236 238 237 232 226 222 219 217 215 216 218 213 205 205 208 212 218 224 230 232 230 226 223 220 219 217 216 215 215 219 221 212 250 205 211 217 223 229 235 239 238 233 226 220 217 215 215 215 206 199 200 203 209 214 220 227 234 236 235 230 224 220 217 215 213 214 216 210 203 203 206 210 215 222 228 229 228 224 220 218 216 215 214 213 213 217 218 209 350 204 210 216 222 228 234 238 237 232 225 219 216 214 214 214 205 198 199 202 208 213 219 226 233 235 234 229 223 219 216 214 212 213 215 209 202 202 205 209 214 221 227 228 227 223 219 217 215 214 213 212 212 216 217 208 6 Wright BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2031-2037 TABLE 9 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2037-2043 TABLE 10 MJD 23080 23120 23160 23200 23240 23280 23320 23360 23400 23440 23480 23520 23560 23600 23640 23680 23720 23760 23800 23840 23880 23920 23960 24000 24040 24080 24120 24160 24200 24240 24280 24320 24360 24400 24440 24480 24520 24560 24600 24640 24680 24720 24760 24800 24840 24880 24920 24960 25000 25040 25080 25120 25160 25200 25240 10 241 243 248 253 255 254 251 248 245 244 243 243 244 244 245 247 252 259 256 249 247 248 247 245 242 240 240 241 242 244 245 247 248 250 253 258 264 269 264 251 243 238 235 234 235 238 241 244 247 249 252 255 259 262 264 20 228 230 234 240 243 243 241 238 236 236 236 236 236 236 236 237 243 250 245 235 234 235 235 234 232 231 231 232 234 236 238 238 239 240 244 249 255 260 254 240 231 227 224 223 225 229 232 236 239 241 243 246 250 253 254 34 221 222 226 232 236 236 235 232 230 229 230 230 230 229 229 230 236 244 238 227 225 227 228 227 225 224 224 226 228 230 231 232 232 233 237 242 248 254 247 232 224 219 217 216 218 222 226 229 233 235 236 239 243 246 247 65 214 214 218 224 228 229 228 225 223 223 223 223 223 223 221 222 229 237 230 219 217 220 220 220 218 217 217 219 221 223 225 225 224 226 230 235 241 247 240 225 217 213 210 209 211 215 219 223 226 228 229 232 237 239 240 100 210 210 214 220 225 225 224 221 220 219 220 220 220 219 218 219 225 233 227 215 213 216 217 216 215 213 214 216 218 220 221 221 221 222 226 232 238 243 236 221 213 209 207 206 208 212 216 219 222 224 226 229 233 236 236 150 208 208 211 218 222 223 222 219 217 217 218 217 217 217 215 216 223 231 224 212 210 213 214 214 212 211 211 213 215 217 219 219 218 220 224 229 235 240 233 219 211 207 204 203 205 209 213 217 220 222 223 226 230 233 233 250 205 206 209 215 220 220 219 217 215 215 215 215 215 214 213 214 220 229 222 210 208 211 212 211 210 209 209 211 213 215 216 217 216 218 222 227 233 238 231 216 209 204 202 201 203 207 211 215 218 219 221 224 228 231 231 350 204 205 208 214 219 219 218 216 214 214 214 214 214 213 211 213 219 227 221 209 207 210 211 210 209 208 208 210 212 214 215 216 215 217 221 226 232 237 230 215 208 203 201 200 202 206 210 214 217 218 220 223 227 230 230 MJD 25280 25320 25360 25400 25440 25480 25520 25560 25600 25640 25680 25720 25760 25800 25840 25880 25920 25960 26000 26040 26080 26120 26160 26200 26240 26280 26320 26360 26400 26440 26480 26520 26560 26600 26640 26680 26720 26760 26800 26840 26880 26920 26960 27000 27040 27080 27120 27160 27200 27240 27280 27320 27360 27400 27440 10 262 261 260 250 237 231 229 231 235 239 244 248 252 256 261 265 267 266 261 255 251 249 244 233 228 229 233 238 243 248 253 259 265 269 269 266 260 253 248 245 244 242 233 230 232 236 241 247 254 260 266 269 268 263 257 20 252 250 251 240 226 219 218 221 225 230 235 240 244 247 252 257 258 256 251 245 241 241 236 222 217 218 223 228 233 239 245 250 257 260 261 257 250 243 239 236 237 234 223 219 221 226 231 237 244 251 257 260 259 254 248 34 245 243 244 234 219 212 211 214 218 223 228 233 237 241 246 250 251 249 244 237 234 235 229 215 210 211 216 221 227 233 238 244 250 254 254 250 243 236 232 230 231 228 216 212 214 219 224 231 237 243 250 253 252 248 241 65 237 235 237 227 212 205 204 206 212 217 222 226 230 234 239 243 244 242 236 229 227 228 222 208 202 204 209 214 220 226 231 237 243 247 247 243 235 229 225 224 224 221 209 205 207 212 217 224 230 236 243 246 245 241 234 100 234 231 233 223 208 201 200 203 208 213 218 223 227 230 235 239 241 239 232 226 223 224 219 204 199 200 205 211 216 222 227 233 239 243 243 239 232 225 222 220 220 218 206 202 204 208 214 220 226 233 239 242 242 237 230 150 231 229 231 221 206 199 198 200 206 211 216 220 224 228 233 237 238 236 229 223 221 222 216 202 196 198 203 208 214 220 225 231 237 240 240 237 229 223 219 218 218 215 203 199 201 206 211 218 223 230 237 240 239 234 228 250 229 226 228 218 204 197 195 198 203 208 213 218 222 226 231 235 236 234 227 221 218 220 214 200 194 195 201 206 211 218 223 228 235 238 238 234 227 221 217 215 216 213 201 197 199 204 209 215 221 228 234 237 237 232 226 350 228 225 227 217 203 196 194 197 202 207 212 217 221 224 230 234 235 233 226 220 217 218 213 199 193 194 200 205 210 217 222 227 234 237 237 233 226 220 216 214 215 212 200 196 198 203 208 214 220 227 233 236 236 231 225 IR Brightness of Mars 7 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2043-2049 TABLE 11 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2049-2055 TABLE 12 MJD 27480 27520 27560 27600 27640 27680 27720 27760 27800 27840 27880 27920 27960 28000 28040 28080 28120 28160 28200 28240 28280 28320 28360 28400 28440 28480 28520 28560 28600 28640 28680 28720 28760 28800 28840 28880 28920 28960 29000 29040 29080 29120 29160 29200 29240 29280 29320 29360 29400 29440 29480 29520 29560 29600 29640 10 251 246 243 242 243 243 237 234 235 240 246 252 259 264 265 263 258 252 248 245 243 242 242 244 247 243 238 239 243 249 254 258 258 255 251 247 245 244 243 243 243 244 246 252 254 247 245 246 249 250 249 246 243 242 242 20 242 238 236 234 235 235 227 223 225 229 234 240 247 253 255 253 249 244 240 238 236 234 234 236 239 234 228 228 230 236 242 246 247 245 242 239 237 236 236 235 235 235 237 243 245 235 231 233 236 238 238 236 234 233 233 34 236 232 229 228 229 229 220 216 218 222 227 233 240 246 248 247 242 237 234 232 230 228 228 229 233 227 221 220 223 227 234 239 240 238 235 232 231 230 230 229 229 228 230 237 238 227 222 224 228 230 230 229 227 226 227 65 229 225 223 222 222 222 214 209 211 215 220 225 232 239 241 240 236 230 227 225 223 222 221 223 226 220 214 213 215 220 226 231 233 231 228 225 224 224 223 223 222 221 223 230 231 220 215 216 221 223 223 222 220 219 220 100 225 222 219 218 219 219 210 206 207 211 216 222 229 235 237 236 232 227 224 222 220 218 218 219 223 216 210 210 212 216 222 228 229 228 225 222 221 220 220 219 219 217 219 226 228 217 211 211 217 219 220 219 217 216 217 150 223 219 217 216 216 216 208 203 205 209 214 219 226 232 235 233 229 224 221 219 217 216 215 217 220 214 208 207 209 213 220 225 226 225 222 219 218 218 217 217 216 215 216 223 225 214 208 209 214 217 217 216 214 213 215 250 220 217 215 213 214 214 205 201 202 207 212 217 224 230 232 231 227 222 219 217 215 213 213 214 218 212 205 205 207 211 217 223 224 223 220 217 216 216 215 214 214 212 214 221 223 212 206 206 212 215 215 214 212 211 212 350 219 216 214 212 213 213 204 200 201 205 211 216 223 229 231 230 226 221 218 216 214 212 212 213 217 211 204 204 206 210 216 222 223 222 219 216 215 215 214 213 213 211 213 220 222 211 205 205 211 214 214 213 211 210 211 MJD 29680 29720 29760 29800 29840 29880 29920 29960 30000 30040 30080 30120 30160 30200 30240 30280 30320 30360 30400 30440 30480 30520 30560 30600 30640 30680 30720 30760 30800 30840 30880 30920 30960 31000 31040 31080 31120 31160 31200 31240 31280 31320 31360 31400 31440 31480 31520 31560 31600 31640 31680 31720 31760 31800 31840 10 242 244 245 245 246 248 252 258 265 266 255 248 244 240 238 236 237 239 241 244 246 248 250 253 256 260 263 264 265 261 246 236 232 231 232 236 240 243 247 251 254 259 263 265 265 262 257 254 252 242 231 228 230 233 238 20 235 236 237 237 237 238 242 249 257 256 243 236 232 229 227 226 227 230 233 236 238 240 241 243 247 251 253 254 256 252 236 225 221 220 222 226 231 235 239 242 246 250 254 256 256 251 246 244 244 232 220 217 219 223 228 34 229 230 231 231 230 231 235 242 250 248 235 228 225 222 220 219 220 223 226 229 232 234 234 237 240 244 246 247 249 246 229 218 214 213 215 219 224 228 233 236 239 243 247 249 249 244 238 237 237 226 213 209 212 216 222 65 222 223 224 224 223 224 228 235 243 241 227 221 217 215 213 212 213 216 220 223 225 227 227 230 233 237 239 240 241 239 222 211 207 206 208 213 217 222 226 229 232 236 241 242 242 237 231 229 230 219 206 202 204 209 215 100 219 220 221 220 219 220 224 231 240 237 224 217 214 212 210 209 210 213 216 219 222 223 224 226 230 233 235 236 238 235 218 208 203 202 204 209 214 218 223 226 229 233 237 239 238 233 227 226 227 215 202 199 201 206 211 150 216 217 218 218 217 218 222 229 237 235 221 215 211 209 207 206 207 210 214 217 219 221 221 223 227 231 233 233 235 232 216 206 201 200 202 207 211 216 220 223 226 230 234 236 235 230 224 223 224 213 200 196 198 203 209 250 214 215 216 216 214 215 220 227 235 233 219 213 209 207 205 204 205 208 212 215 217 218 219 221 225 229 231 231 233 230 214 203 198 197 200 204 209 213 218 221 224 228 232 234 233 228 222 221 222 210 198 194 196 201 206 350 213 214 215 215 213 214 219 226 234 231 218 211 208 206 204 203 204 207 211 214 216 217 218 220 224 228 230 230 231 229 213 202 197 196 199 203 208 212 217 220 223 227 231 233 232 227 221 220 221 209 197 193 195 200 205 8 Wright BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2055-2061 TABLE 13 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2061-2067 TABLE 14 MJD 31880 31920 31960 32000 32040 32080 32120 32160 32200 32240 32280 32320 32360 32400 32440 32480 32520 32560 32600 32640 32680 32720 32760 32800 32840 32880 32920 32960 33000 33040 33080 33120 33160 33200 33240 33280 33320 33360 33400 33440 33480 33520 33560 33600 33640 33680 33720 33760 33800 33840 33880 33920 33960 34000 34040 10 243 248 253 258 263 268 269 267 261 254 249 246 245 239 231 229 232 236 241 247 253 260 266 269 269 265 259 252 247 244 242 243 241 234 232 235 240 246 252 259 265 267 265 261 255 250 246 243 242 242 244 245 238 236 239 20 234 239 244 249 255 259 260 258 251 244 239 238 238 230 220 218 221 226 232 238 244 250 257 260 260 256 250 243 239 236 235 236 232 223 222 224 229 235 241 249 255 257 256 252 246 241 238 236 234 234 236 236 228 225 227 34 227 232 237 243 248 253 253 251 244 237 233 231 232 224 213 211 214 219 225 231 237 244 250 254 253 249 243 236 232 230 229 230 226 216 215 217 222 228 234 241 248 250 249 245 239 235 232 230 228 228 230 230 221 218 220 65 220 226 230 236 241 245 246 244 236 230 226 225 225 217 205 204 207 212 218 224 230 236 243 247 246 242 235 229 226 223 222 223 219 210 208 211 215 221 227 234 241 243 242 238 232 228 225 223 221 221 223 223 214 211 213 100 217 222 227 232 238 242 243 240 232 226 222 221 222 213 202 200 204 209 214 221 226 233 240 243 243 239 232 226 222 220 219 220 215 206 204 207 212 217 223 230 237 240 239 235 229 225 222 220 218 218 220 219 211 208 210 150 214 220 224 230 235 239 240 237 230 223 220 219 219 211 199 198 201 206 212 218 224 230 237 240 240 236 229 223 220 217 216 217 213 204 202 205 209 215 221 227 234 237 236 232 226 222 219 217 215 215 217 217 208 205 207 250 212 217 222 227 233 237 238 235 227 221 217 216 217 209 197 196 199 204 210 216 222 228 235 238 238 234 227 221 217 215 214 215 211 201 200 202 207 213 218 225 232 235 234 230 224 220 217 215 213 213 215 215 206 203 205 350 211 216 221 226 232 236 237 234 226 220 216 215 216 208 196 195 198 203 209 215 221 227 234 237 237 233 226 220 216 214 213 214 210 200 199 201 206 212 217 224 231 234 233 229 223 219 216 214 212 212 214 214 205 202 204 MJD 34080 34120 34160 34200 34240 34280 34320 34360 34400 34440 34480 34520 34560 34600 34640 34680 34720 34760 34800 34840 34880 34920 34960 35000 35040 35080 35120 35160 35200 35240 35280 35320 35360 35400 35440 35480 35520 35560 35600 35640 35680 35720 35760 35800 35840 35880 35920 35960 36000 36040 36080 36120 36160 36200 36240 10 244 250 256 260 261 258 254 250 246 245 243 243 243 243 246 251 247 242 243 247 251 253 252 250 246 244 243 243 243 244 245 245 247 251 258 262 255 249 248 246 243 241 239 239 240 242 243 245 247 248 250 254 258 262 267 20 232 237 244 249 250 249 245 241 238 237 236 235 234 235 238 243 237 230 229 233 238 241 241 240 237 235 235 235 236 236 236 236 237 241 249 253 242 236 235 234 232 230 229 229 231 233 236 238 239 239 241 244 249 253 257 34 224 229 236 242 243 242 239 235 232 231 230 229 228 228 231 236 230 222 221 224 230 233 234 233 230 229 229 229 230 230 230 229 230 234 243 246 234 227 227 226 225 223 222 222 225 227 229 231 232 233 234 237 242 246 251 65 217 222 228 234 236 235 232 228 226 224 223 222 221 221 224 229 223 215 214 216 222 226 227 226 223 222 222 223 223 223 223 222 222 227 236 239 226 219 219 219 218 216 215 216 218 221 223 225 226 225 227 230 235 239 243 100 213 218 224 231 232 231 228 224 222 221 220 219 218 217 220 226 220 212 210 212 218 222 223 222 220 218 218 219 220 220 220 218 219 223 232 236 222 215 216 216 214 213 212 212 214 217 219 221 222 222 223 227 232 236 240 150 211 215 222 228 230 229 226 222 220 218 217 216 216 215 217 223 217 209 207 210 216 220 221 220 217 216 216 217 217 218 217 215 216 221 230 233 220 213 213 213 212 210 209 210 212 215 217 219 220 219 221 224 229 233 237 250 208 213 219 226 227 227 223 220 217 216 215 214 213 213 215 221 215 207 205 207 213 218 218 218 215 214 214 215 215 215 215 213 214 219 227 231 217 210 211 211 210 208 207 207 210 212 215 217 217 217 218 222 227 231 235 350 207 212 218 225 226 226 222 218 216 215 214 213 212 212 214 220 214 206 204 206 212 217 217 217 214 213 213 214 214 214 214 212 213 218 226 230 216 209 210 210 209 207 206 206 209 211 214 216 216 216 217 221 226 230 234 IR Brightness of Mars 9 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2067-2073 TABLE 15 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2073-2079 TABLE 16 MJD 36280 36320 36360 36400 36440 36480 36520 36560 36600 36640 36680 36720 36760 36800 36840 36880 36920 36960 37000 37040 37080 37120 37160 37200 37240 37280 37320 37360 37400 37440 37480 37520 37560 37600 37640 37680 37720 37760 37800 37840 37880 37920 37960 38000 38040 38080 38120 38160 38200 38240 38280 38320 38360 38400 38440 10 268 257 244 237 234 233 234 237 240 243 247 249 252 256 260 263 264 262 259 258 253 239 231 229 230 234 238 243 247 252 256 261 266 268 267 262 256 251 248 246 236 229 229 232 237 242 247 253 259 265 269 270 267 260 254 20 259 246 233 226 223 222 224 227 231 235 238 241 244 247 251 254 254 252 249 248 245 229 220 218 220 224 229 234 239 243 248 253 257 259 257 252 245 241 240 238 226 218 218 222 226 232 238 244 250 256 260 261 258 251 244 34 253 239 226 219 216 215 217 220 225 229 232 235 237 240 245 247 248 245 241 241 238 222 212 210 212 217 222 227 232 237 241 246 251 252 250 245 238 233 233 232 219 211 211 215 220 225 231 237 243 249 254 254 251 244 237 65 245 231 219 212 209 208 210 214 218 222 225 228 230 233 238 240 240 237 233 234 231 215 205 203 205 210 215 220 226 230 234 239 244 245 243 237 230 226 226 225 212 203 203 208 213 218 224 230 236 242 247 247 244 236 230 100 242 228 215 209 205 204 206 210 215 218 222 225 227 230 234 237 237 234 229 230 228 212 202 199 202 207 212 217 222 226 230 236 240 241 240 233 226 223 223 222 209 200 200 204 209 215 221 226 232 239 243 243 240 233 226 150 239 225 213 206 203 202 204 208 212 216 220 222 224 227 232 234 234 231 226 227 225 209 199 197 199 204 209 214 220 224 228 233 238 239 237 231 224 220 220 219 206 197 197 202 207 212 218 224 230 236 240 241 237 230 224 250 237 223 210 204 201 200 201 205 210 214 217 220 222 225 229 232 232 229 224 225 223 207 197 195 197 202 207 212 217 222 226 231 235 237 235 228 221 218 218 217 204 195 195 200 205 210 216 222 228 234 238 238 235 228 222 350 236 222 209 203 200 199 200 204 209 213 216 219 221 224 228 231 231 228 223 224 222 206 196 194 196 201 206 211 216 221 225 230 234 236 234 227 220 217 217 216 203 194 194 198 203 209 215 221 227 233 237 237 234 227 221 MJD 38480 38520 38560 38600 38640 38680 38720 38760 38800 38840 38880 38920 38960 39000 39040 39080 39120 39160 39200 39240 39280 39320 39360 39400 39440 39480 39520 39560 39600 39640 39680 39720 39760 39800 39840 39880 39920 39960 40000 40040 40080 40120 40160 40200 40240 40280 40320 40360 40400 40440 40480 40520 40560 40600 40640 10 248 245 243 243 237 231 232 235 240 246 252 259 265 268 267 263 257 251 247 244 242 242 244 241 235 235 239 244 250 257 262 264 262 257 252 248 245 243 242 242 243 247 247 241 240 242 247 253 256 256 253 250 246 244 244 20 239 236 236 236 228 221 221 225 230 236 242 249 256 259 258 254 248 243 239 236 234 234 236 232 225 224 228 233 239 245 251 254 252 248 244 240 238 236 235 234 235 238 239 231 228 229 234 240 244 245 244 241 238 236 236 34 232 230 230 230 221 214 214 218 223 229 235 242 249 252 252 248 241 236 232 230 228 228 230 225 218 217 221 225 231 238 244 246 245 242 237 234 232 230 229 228 228 232 232 224 220 221 225 232 237 238 237 234 231 230 230 65 226 223 223 223 214 207 207 211 216 222 228 235 241 245 245 241 234 229 226 223 222 222 223 218 211 210 214 218 223 230 237 239 238 235 230 227 225 223 222 221 222 225 225 217 213 214 218 224 229 230 230 227 224 224 224 100 222 220 220 220 210 203 204 207 212 218 224 231 238 241 241 237 231 226 222 220 218 218 220 215 207 207 210 215 220 226 233 235 235 231 227 223 222 220 218 218 218 222 222 213 210 210 214 220 226 227 226 223 221 220 220 150 220 217 217 217 208 201 201 205 210 216 222 228 235 239 238 235 228 223 220 217 216 216 217 212 205 204 208 212 217 224 230 233 232 229 224 221 219 217 216 215 215 219 219 211 207 208 211 217 223 224 224 221 218 218 218 250 217 215 215 215 205 198 199 202 208 214 220 226 233 237 236 232 226 221 217 215 213 214 215 210 203 202 205 210 215 221 228 231 230 226 222 219 217 215 214 213 213 217 217 208 205 206 209 215 221 222 221 219 216 215 216 350 216 214 214 214 204 197 198 201 207 213 219 225 232 236 235 231 225 220 216 214 212 212 214 209 202 201 204 209 214 220 227 230 229 225 221 218 216 214 213 212 212 216 216 207 204 205 208 214 220 221 220 218 215 214 215 10 Wright BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2079-2085 TABLE 17 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2085-2091 TABLE 18 MJD 40680 40720 40760 40800 40840 40880 40920 40960 41000 41040 41080 41120 41160 41200 41240 41280 41320 41360 41400 41440 41480 41520 41560 41600 41640 41680 41720 41760 41800 41840 41880 41920 41960 42000 42040 42080 42120 42160 42200 42240 42280 42320 42360 42400 42440 42480 42520 42560 42600 42640 42680 42720 42760 42800 42840 10 243 244 244 244 246 251 257 253 247 246 248 249 247 244 242 241 241 242 243 245 246 247 248 252 257 263 269 263 251 244 239 237 235 236 238 240 243 246 248 251 253 257 261 263 263 263 262 251 238 232 230 231 235 239 243 20 236 236 236 235 236 241 248 242 234 233 235 236 236 234 232 231 232 234 236 237 238 238 239 242 248 254 260 252 239 232 228 226 224 226 228 232 235 238 240 242 244 248 252 253 253 252 253 242 227 220 219 221 225 229 234 34 230 230 229 228 229 235 242 235 225 224 227 229 228 227 225 225 226 228 230 231 231 231 232 235 241 248 253 244 232 225 221 219 217 219 222 225 229 232 234 235 237 241 245 246 246 245 246 235 220 213 212 213 218 223 227 65 223 223 223 221 222 227 235 228 217 216 219 221 221 220 219 218 219 221 223 224 225 224 224 228 234 241 246 237 224 218 214 212 210 212 215 219 222 225 227 228 230 234 238 239 239 238 239 228 213 206 204 206 211 216 221 100 220 220 219 218 218 224 231 224 214 211 216 218 218 217 215 214 216 218 220 221 221 220 221 224 230 237 243 233 221 214 211 208 207 208 211 215 219 222 223 225 227 231 234 236 235 234 235 224 210 203 201 203 207 212 217 150 217 217 217 215 215 221 229 221 211 209 213 215 215 214 213 212 213 216 217 218 219 218 218 222 228 235 240 231 218 212 208 206 204 206 209 213 216 219 221 222 224 228 232 233 232 231 233 222 207 200 198 200 205 210 215 250 215 215 214 213 213 219 227 219 209 206 211 213 213 212 210 210 211 213 215 216 216 215 216 220 225 232 238 228 216 209 206 204 202 203 207 211 214 217 219 220 222 226 229 231 230 229 231 220 205 198 196 198 203 208 213 350 214 214 213 212 212 218 226 218 208 205 210 212 212 211 209 209 210 212 214 215 215 214 215 219 224 231 237 227 215 208 205 203 201 202 206 210 213 216 218 219 221 225 228 230 229 228 230 219 204 197 195 197 202 207 211 MJD 42880 42920 42960 43000 43040 43080 43120 43160 43200 43240 43280 43320 43360 43400 43440 43480 43520 43560 43600 43640 43680 43720 43760 43800 43840 43880 43920 43960 44000 44040 44080 44120 44160 44200 44240 44280 44320 44360 44400 44440 44480 44520 44560 44600 44640 44680 44720 44760 44800 44840 44880 44920 44960 45000 45040 10 247 251 254 259 263 266 266 262 257 253 251 246 234 228 229 232 237 242 247 252 258 263 268 269 267 262 255 249 246 245 242 233 230 231 235 240 246 252 259 265 269 269 265 259 253 248 244 242 243 243 237 233 235 239 244 20 238 242 246 250 255 257 257 252 246 243 242 237 223 217 218 222 227 232 238 243 249 255 259 261 258 252 245 240 237 237 234 223 219 221 225 230 236 243 249 256 260 260 256 250 244 239 236 235 235 235 227 222 224 228 234 34 232 236 239 244 248 250 250 245 239 235 236 230 216 210 211 215 220 226 232 237 242 248 253 254 251 245 238 233 231 231 228 216 212 214 218 223 230 236 242 249 253 253 250 243 237 233 230 228 229 229 220 215 217 221 226 65 225 229 232 237 241 243 243 238 231 228 229 224 209 202 203 208 213 219 225 230 235 241 246 247 244 237 230 226 224 224 222 209 205 207 211 216 223 229 235 242 246 246 243 236 230 226 223 222 222 222 213 209 210 214 219 100 222 226 229 233 238 240 239 234 227 224 225 220 205 199 200 205 210 215 221 226 232 238 242 243 241 233 227 222 221 221 218 205 201 203 208 213 219 225 231 238 242 243 239 232 226 222 220 218 219 219 210 205 206 211 216 150 219 223 226 231 235 237 236 231 224 222 223 218 203 196 197 202 207 213 219 224 229 235 240 241 238 231 224 220 218 218 216 203 198 201 205 210 217 223 229 236 240 240 236 230 224 220 218 216 217 216 207 203 204 208 213 250 217 221 224 229 233 235 234 229 222 219 220 215 201 194 195 200 205 211 217 222 227 233 237 238 236 228 222 218 216 216 213 201 196 198 203 208 215 220 227 234 238 238 234 228 222 218 215 214 214 214 205 200 202 206 211 350 216 220 223 227 232 234 233 228 221 218 219 214 200 193 194 199 204 210 216 221 226 232 236 237 235 227 221 217 215 215 212 200 195 197 202 207 214 219 226 233 237 237 233 226 221 217 214 213 213 213 204 199 201 205 210 IR Brightness of Mars 11 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2091-2097 TABLE 19 BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURE OF MARS:2097-2103 TABLE 20 MJD 45080 45120 45160 45200 45240 45280 45320 45360 45400 45440 45480 45520 45560 45600 45640 45680 45720 45760 45800 45840 45880 45920 45960 46000 46040 46080 46120 46160 46200 46240 46280 46320 46360 46400 46440 46480 46520 46560 46600 46640 46680 46720 46760 46800 46840 46880 46920 46960 47000 47040 47080 47120 47160 47200 47240 10 251 258 263 266 264 260 254 250 246 244 242 242 243 246 242 238 238 242 248 254 259 259 257 253 249 246 244 243 243 243 243 245 251 252 245 243 246 249 251 251 248 245 243 242 243 243 244 245 245 247 250 256 264 263 253 20 240 247 253 256 255 251 246 241 238 236 234 234 235 238 233 227 227 230 235 242 247 249 247 244 240 238 237 236 235 235 235 236 242 243 234 230 232 236 239 239 238 236 234 234 235 236 237 237 237 237 240 247 256 252 240 34 232 239 246 249 248 245 239 235 232 230 228 228 229 232 226 220 220 222 227 233 239 241 240 237 234 232 231 230 229 229 228 229 236 236 226 222 223 228 231 232 231 229 227 228 229 230 230 230 230 230 233 241 249 245 232 65 225 232 238 242 241 238 232 228 226 223 222 221 222 225 219 213 213 215 219 226 232 234 233 230 227 225 224 223 223 222 221 222 229 229 219 214 215 220 224 225 224 222 220 221 222 223 224 224 223 223 226 234 242 237 224 100 221 228 235 238 238 234 229 225 222 220 218 218 219 222 216 209 209 212 216 222 228 230 230 227 223 222 221 220 219 219 217 218 225 226 215 210 211 216 220 221 221 218 217 217 219 220 220 220 219 219 223 230 238 233 221 150 219 225 232 236 235 232 226 222 220 218 216 215 216 219 213 207 207 209 213 219 226 228 227 224 221 219 218 218 217 216 215 216 222 223 213 208 208 214 218 219 218 216 214 215 216 217 218 218 216 216 220 227 236 231 218 250 217 223 230 233 233 229 224 220 217 215 214 213 214 217 211 205 204 207 211 217 223 226 225 222 219 217 216 215 214 214 213 213 220 221 211 206 206 211 216 216 216 214 212 213 214 215 216 216 214 214 218 225 234 229 215 350 215 222 229 232 232 228 223 219 216 214 213 212 213 216 210 204 203 206 210 216 222 225 224 221 218 216 215 214 213 213 211 212 219 220 210 205 205 210 215 215 215 213 211 212 213 214 215 214 213 213 217 224 233 228 214 MJD 47280 47320 47360 47400 47440 47480 47520 47560 47600 47640 47680 47720 47760 47800 47840 47880 47920 47960 48000 48040 48080 48120 48160 48200 48240 48280 48320 48360 48400 48440 48480 48520 48560 48600 48640 48680 48720 48760 48800 48840 48880 48920 48960 49000 49040 49080 49120 49160 49200 49240 49280 49320 49360 49400 49440 10 249 245 242 240 238 237 239 241 243 245 247 249 251 254 258 262 265 267 262 248 238 233 232 233 235 239 243 246 250 253 257 261 264 265 263 259 256 254 243 232 229 229 233 237 242 246 251 256 261 266 268 268 263 256 250 20 236 233 231 229 227 228 230 232 235 238 239 240 242 245 249 252 255 258 253 237 227 222 221 222 226 230 234 238 241 244 248 252 255 255 253 248 246 245 234 221 217 218 223 228 233 238 243 248 253 258 260 258 253 246 241 34 228 226 224 222 220 221 223 226 229 231 233 233 235 238 242 246 248 251 246 230 220 215 213 215 219 223 228 232 235 238 241 245 248 248 245 240 238 239 227 214 210 211 216 221 226 231 236 241 246 251 253 251 246 238 234 65 220 218 217 215 214 214 216 220 222 225 226 226 228 231 235 239 241 243 239 223 213 208 206 208 212 217 221 225 228 231 234 238 241 241 238 232 231 232 220 207 203 204 209 214 219 225 229 234 239 244 246 244 238 231 226 100 217 215 213 211 210 210 213 216 219 221 223 223 224 228 232 235 237 240 236 219 209 205 203 205 208 213 218 222 225 227 231 235 238 238 234 228 227 228 217 204 199 200 205 210 216 221 226 230 236 241 242 241 234 227 223 150 214 212 211 209 208 208 210 214 216 219 220 220 222 225 229 232 235 237 233 217 207 202 200 202 206 211 215 219 222 225 228 232 235 235 232 226 224 226 214 201 196 198 203 208 213 219 223 228 233 238 240 238 232 225 220 250 212 210 208 207 205 206 208 211 214 216 218 218 219 223 227 230 232 235 231 214 205 200 198 200 204 209 213 217 220 222 226 230 233 233 229 223 222 224 212 199 194 195 200 206 211 216 221 226 231 236 237 236 229 222 218 350 211 209 207 206 204 205 207 210 213 215 217 217 218 222 226 229 231 234 230 213 204 199 197 199 203 208 212 216 219 221 225 229 232 232 228 222 221 223 211 198 193 194 199 205 210 215 220 225 230 235 236 235 228 221 217 12 Wright REFERENCES van Flandern, T. C., Pulkkinen, K. F. 1979. Low-precision formulae for planetary positions. Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 41, 391-411. Wright, E. L. 1976. Recalibration of the far-infrared brightness temperatures of the planets. Astrophysical Journal 210, 250-253. Wright, E. L. 2007. Comparing the NEATM with a Rotating, Cratered Thermophysical Asteroid Model. ArXiv Astrophysics e-prints arXiv:astro-ph/0703085. Wright, E. L., Odenwald, S. 1980. Brightness Temperature of Mars: 1979-1983. Bulletin of the American Astronomical Society 12, 456.
astro-ph/0604140	1	0604	2006-04-06T16:43:33	HST/STIS Spectra of Nuclear Star Clusters in Spiral Galaxies: Dependence of Age and Mass On Hubble Type	[ "astro-ph" ]	(Abridged) We study the nuclear star clusters in spiral galaxies of various Hubble types using spectra obtained with STIS on-board HST. We observed the nuclear clusters in 40 galaxies, selected from two previous HST/WFPC2 imaging surveys. The spectra provide a better separation of cluster light from underlying galaxy light than is possible with ground-based spectra. To infer the star formation history, metallicity and dust extinction, we fit weighted superpositions of single-age stellar population templates to the spectra. The luminosity-weighted age ranges from 10 Myrs to 10 Gyrs. The stellar populations of NCs are generally best fit as a mixture of populations of different ages. This indicates that NCs did not form in a single event, but instead they had additional star formation long after the oldest stars formed. On average, the sample clusters in late-type spirals have a younger luminosity-weighted mean age than those in early-type spirals (log(age/yr) = 8.37+/-0.25 vs. 9.23+/-0.21). The average cluster masses are smaller in late-type spirals than in early-type spirals (log(M/Msun) = 6.25+/-0.21 vs. 7.63+/-0.24), and exceed the masses typical of globular clusters. The cluster mass correlates strongly with both the Hubble type of the host galaxy and the luminosity of its bulge. The latter correlation has the same slope as the well-known correlation between supermassive black hole mass and bulge luminosity. The properties of both nuclear clusters and black holes are therefore intimately connected to the properties of the host galaxy.	astro-ph	astro-ph	HST/STIS SPECTRA OF NUCLEAR STAR CLUSTERS IN SPIRAL GALAXIES: DEPENDENCE OF AGE AND MASS ON HUBBLE TYPE1 Jorn Rossa2, Roeland P. van der Marel2, Torsten Boker3, Joris Gerssen4, Luis C. Ho5, Hans-Walter Rix6, Joseph C. Shields7, and Carl-Jakob Walcher6 ABSTRACT We study the nuclear star clusters in spiral galaxies of various Hubble types using spectra obtained with STIS on-board HST. We observed the nuclear clus- ters in 40 galaxies, selected from two previous HST/WFPC2 imaging surveys. At a spatial resolution of ∼ 0.′′2 the spectra provide a better separation of cluster light from underlying galaxy light than is possible with ground-based spectra. Approximately half of the spectra have a sufficiently high signal-to-noise ratio for detailed stellar population analysis. For the other half we only measure the continuum slope, as quantified by the B − V color. To infer the star formation history, metallicity and dust extinction, we fit weighted superpositions of single- age stellar population templates to the high signal-to-noise spectra. We use the results to determine the luminosity-weighted age, mass-to-light ratio, and masses 1Based on observations made with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope, obtained [from the Data Archive] at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5-26555. These observations are associated with proposals #9070 and #9783. 2Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218; [email protected], [email protected] 3Astrophysics Division, RSSD, European Space Research and Technology Centre (ESTEC), NL-2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands; [email protected] 4Department of Physics, University of Durham, Rochester Building, Science Laboratories, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, United Kingdom; [email protected] 5The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, 813 Santa Barbara Street, Pasadena, CA 91101-1292; [email protected] 6Max-Planck-Institut fur Astronomie, Konigstuhl 17, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany; [email protected]; [email protected] 7Department of Physics and Astronomy, Clippinger Research Laboratories, Ohio University, 251B, Athens, OH 45701-2979; [email protected] -- 2 -- of the clusters. The models provide excellent fits to the data and generally re- quire a mixture of populations of different ages. Approximately half of the sample clusters contain a population younger than 1 Gyr. The luminosity-weighted age ranges from 10 Myrs to 10 Gyrs. The stellar populations of NCs are generally best fit as a mixture of populations of different ages. This indicates that NCs did not form in a single event, but instead they had additional star formation long after the oldest stars formed. On average, the sample clusters in late-type spirals have a younger luminosity-weighted mean age than those in early-type spirals (hlog τiL = 8.37 ± 0.25 vs. 9.23 ± 0.21). The average mass-weighted ages are older by ∼ 0.7 dex, indicating that there often is an underlying older population that does not contribute much light, but does contain most of the mass. The average cluster masses are smaller in late-type spirals than in early-type spirals (log M = 6.25 ± 0.21 vs. 7.63 ± 0.24), and exceed the masses typical of globular It clusters. The cluster mass correlates loosely with total galaxy luminosity. correlates more strongly with both the Hubble type of the host galaxy and the luminosity of its bulge. The latter correlation has the same slope as the well- known correlation between supermassive black hole mass and bulge luminosity. The properties of both nuclear clusters and black holes in the centers of spiral galaxies are therefore intimately connected to the properties of the host galaxy, and in particular its bulge component. Plausible formation scenarios will have to account for this. We discuss various possible selection biases in our results, but conclude that none of them can explain the differences seen between clus- ters in early- and late-type spirals. The inability to infer spectroscopically the populations of faint clusters does introduce a bias towards younger ages, but not necessarily towards higher masses. Subject headings: galaxies: evolution -- galaxies: nuclei -- galaxies: spiral -- galaxies: star clusters -- galaxies: stellar content 1. INTRODUCTION The centers of spiral galaxies have been studied for decades using ground-based obser- vations. However, with the advent of high-spatial resolution observations from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) it became clear that there was still much to be learned. A particularly exciting finding has been the fact that most spiral galaxies have a nuclear star cluster (NC) in their very center. The agreement between the positions of these NCs and the isophotal centers of the galaxies is generally better than one arcsecond and is consistent with zero -- 3 -- to within the error bars (Boker et al. 2002). These NCs have now been studied in detail for large samples using broad-band imaging with HST's Wide Field and Planetary Camera (WFPC; Phillips et al. 1996), Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2; Carollo et al. 1997, 1998; Matthews et al. 1999; Boker et al. 2002, 2004) and Near-Infrared Imaging Cam- era and Multi Object Spectrometer (NICMOS; Carollo et al. 2001, 2002). These projects have shown that at least 50% of early-type spirals and at least 75% of late-type spirals host a NC. These NCs could hold important clues to the formation and evolution of spiral galaxies in general. And, in particular, they may be closely associated with the secular evolution processes that form pseudo-bulges and destroy bars (e.g., Athanassoula 1992a,b; Norman et al. 1996; Carollo 1999; Kormendy & Kennicutt 2004). The imaging studies have shown that the NC luminosities typically range from 105 -- 108 L⊙ and that their effective radii typically range from 2 -- 10 pc. About 50% of the NCs has an effective radius in the range of 2.4 -- 5.0 pc (Boker et al. 2004). The dependence of these properties on Hubble type, galaxy luminosity, bulge type, bar class, nuclear environment, and other quantities has also been studied in some detail. The next logical step is to build a more detailed understanding of physical properties such as the NC mass, age, and stellar populations. These quantities are difficult to derive from multi-band imaging, due to various well-known degeneracies between age, metallicity, dust, and population mixtures. Spectroscopic observations are therefore called for to make further progress. Up to a few years ago only NCs in a few individual nearby galaxies had been studied spectroscopically in some detail, including M33 (Kormendy & McClure 1993; Long et al. 2002), IC 342 (Boker et al. 1999) and NGC 4449 (Boker et al. 2001). More recently data have become available for some larger samples. Walcher et al. (2005, 2006) observed a sample of nine NCs in late-type spiral galaxies using the Ultraviolet and Visual Echelle Spectrograph (UVES) on the Very Large Telescope (VLT). The data were used to determine the cluster masses from measurements of the velocity dispersion. In addition, the stellar populations were inferred from models for the spectral absorption line features. Advantages of these VLT data included both high signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) and high spectral resolution. On the other hand, the modest spatial resolution of these and other ground-based observations are a disadvantage, since it makes it difficult to disentangle the NC light from underlying bulge and disk light. This can still be done acceptably for late-type spirals, which do not have prominent bulges. However, for early-type spirals this issue quickly becomes prohibitive. This problem can be alleviated significantly by using the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) on HST, but at the expense of reduced S/N and spectral resolution. This approach was used by Sarzi et al. (2005), who studied the centers of 23 early-type spirals. Their sample was selected to contain only galaxies for which the central regions are dominated by emission lines. These galaxies comprise a mix of H ii galaxies, LINERs and Seyfert galaxies. Their -- 4 -- results therefore provide insight into the central regions of spiral galaxies and bulges in general, but not necessarily NCs in particular. Common findings that have emerged from the spectroscopic studies are that the NCs span a wide range of characteristic ages, from 10 Myrs to 10 Gyrs, and that NCs typically contain a mixture of populations of different ages. What has remained less clear is how and to what extent cluster ages and masses depend on the Hubble type of the galaxy. Such a dependence would not be surprising, given that many other characteristic properties of galaxy nuclei vary strongly as a function of Hubble type, including e.g.: bulge/disk ratio; bulge brightness profile shape (de Vaucouleurs R1/4 law or exponential; e.g., Courteau et al 1996; de Jong 1996); AGN fraction (e.g., Ho et al. 1997); and black hole mass (e.g., Tremaine et al. 2002; Marconi & Hunt 2003; Haring & Rix 2004). Any dependence of NC properties on Hubble type would provide new constraints on theories for both NC formation and spiral galaxy evolution. Motivated by the aforementioned considerations we present here the results of a com- prehensive study of the properties of NCs as a function of Hubble type. We selected galaxies with known NCs from previous HST imaging surveys. The galaxies range from Hubble type Sa to Sm. They were observed with HST/STIS to ensure sufficient spatial resolution to allow a meaningful separation of NC light from underlying bulge and disk light, even for the earli- est Hubble types. As in Sarzi et al. (2005) and Walcher et al. (2006) we fit the spectra with weighted superpositions of single-age stellar population templates from Bruzual & Charlot (2003). This yields for each NC the star formation history, metallicity, dust extinction, luminosity-weighted age, mass-to-light ratio, and mass. The paper is laid out as follows. Section 2 describes the selection and characteristics of the sample. Section 3 discusses the acquisition and reduction of the HST/STIS spectra. Section 4 discusses the spectral population fitting procedure used for analyzing the spectra, as well as the robustness of its results. Section 5 discusses the methodology used for inferring total NC luminosities and broad-band colors from the spectra. Section 6 presents all the results, while Section 7 discusses various systematic effects that could potentially influence the results, including contamination from AGN emission, uncertainties in the subtraction of underlying bulge and disk light, and sample biases. Section 8 analyzes how the NC properties correlate with the global properties of the host galaxy, and in particular its Hubble type. Section 9 presents a summary of the main conclusions. -- 5 -- 2. SAMPLE SELECTION For the current spectroscopic survey we selected galaxies from the two imaging studies of NCs in spiral galaxies with HST/WFPC2. We chose early-type spirals from the sample of Carollo et al. (1998) and late-type spirals from the sample of Boker et al. (2002, 2004). Carollo et al. (1998) imaged a sample of 40 spiral galaxies. The parent sample was selected from the UGC Catalog (Nilson 1973) and the ESO-LV catalog (Lauberts & Valen- tijn 1989) with the following primary selection criteria: (1) Hubble type between Sa and Scd (Hubble T-type between 1 and 6); (2) heliocentric velocity less than 2500 km s−1; (3) inclination angle, estimated from the apparent axial ratio, smaller than 75◦; and (4) angular diameter larger than 1′. The 40 galaxies presented in Carollo et al. (1998) form the ran- dom subset that were observed between 1996 March and 1997 February. NCs were detected in 23 of the 40 galaxies. For spectroscopic follow-up with HST/STIS we selected only the 16 galaxies in which a NC had been detected with a magnitude brighter than 21.0 in the WFPC2 F606W filter (similar to the V -band). Other NCs were considered too faint to ob- tain a spectrum with a reasonable S/N with STIS in the available exposure time. We did not include the galaxy ESO 205−G7, although it has a central source of magnitude 19.1 ± 0.2. Ground-based spectra that we obtained of this object with the UVES spectrograph on the ESO/VLT in 2001 (unpublished) reveal a broad Hα line with a FWZI of 200 A, indicating that it is an AGN. Boker et al. (2002) imaged a sample of 77 spiral galaxies. The parent sample was selected from the RC3 catalog of bright galaxies (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991) with the following primary selection criteria: (1) Hubble type between Scd and Sm (Hubble T-type between 6 and 9); (2) heliocentric velocity less than 2000 km s−1; and (3) inclination angle, estimated from the apparent axial ratio, smaller than 51◦. The 77 galaxies presented in Boker et al. (2002) form a subset that was randomly selected from a "snapshot" pool to fill gaps in the HST observing schedule. NCs were detected in 59 of the 77 galaxies. For spectroscopic follow-up with HST/STIS we selected only the 40 galaxies in which a NC had been detected with a magnitude brighter than I = 20.5. Other NCs were considered too faint to obtain a spectrum with a reasonable S/N with STIS in the available exposure time. Our spectroscopic program for the late-type spirals was also a snapshot program, so not all 40 galaxies were actually observed with STIS. In the end, data were successfully obtained for a randomly selected subset of 24 galaxies1. One additional galaxy from the 40 (namely 1The galaxy ESO 138−10 was also observed in the context of program GO#9070, but this galaxy is not included in the sample for the present paper. Due to a pointing error no spectrum was obtained of the nucleus. -- 6 -- NGC 4411B) was observed together with the early-type galaxies (to fill the observing time vacated by ESO 205−G7). Some important properties and quantities of the sample galaxies are listed in Tables 1 and 2. The 15 early-type spirals are listed in Table 1 and the 25 late-type spirals are listed in Table 2. The listed properties include position coordinates, galaxy type, heliocentric velocity, and the apparent and absolute magnitude of the NC. Our spectroscopic sample contains some bias in the sense that we are not including the faintest NCs detected in imaging studies. We discuss the impact of this bias on our scientific results in Section 7.3. 3. OBSERVATIONS AND DATA REDUCTION 3.1. Observational Strategy We obtained longslit spectra with STIS on-board the HST. All observations used the CCD of the instrument, which is a SITe, thinned, backside illuminated 1024×1024 pixel array, with a pixel size of 21 µm×21 µm. A detailed description is given in the STIS instrument handbook (Kim Quijano et al. 2003). The early-type spirals were observed in the context of HST GO program #9783 and the late-type spirals in the context of HST Snapshot program #9070 (PI on both programs: Boker). Except for the adopted exposure times, both programs used a similar observing strategy. The observation sequence for each target started with a standard STIS point-source acquisition, in which a 5× 5 arcsecond image is first obtained. For the acquisition image, the telescope was pointed at the location of the galaxy center as determined from the existing WFPC2 images, and the image exposure time was chosen to provide S/N sufficient for accurate centroiding using the brightest pixels. After adjusting the pointing based on the result, we used the grating G430L to obtain low resolution spectra, with the aim to study the stellar populations of the NCs. The resulting spectra cover the wavelength range from 2888.6 -- 5703.2 A with a pixel scale of 2.73 A in the dispersion direction. The pixel scale in the spatial direction is 0.′′05071 pix−1. We used the 52′′ × 0.′′2 slit. The FWHM of the resulting line-spread function is 1.4 pixels for a point source and 4.0 pixels for a constant surface brightness extended source (Kim Quijano et al. 2003). The NCs are generally barely resolved spatially with HST (Boker et al. 2004) and fall between these two extremes. For a 2.5 pixel FWHM at 4000 A the spectral resolution is R = 586. The spectroscopic exposure time was divided over two exposures, with a 5 pixel offset along the slit in order to correct for hot pixels and cosmic ray events during data reduction. For GO program #9783 each of the two exposures was itself composed of two individual sub-exposures. The journal -- 7 -- of observations, including the integration times and the S/N per pixel values, is listed in Table 3. The observations of the late-type spirals generally had shorter exposure times than those of the early-type spirals (by a factor ∼ 2.4). This is due to the fact that the former were obtained in the context of a snapshot program. 3.2. Data reduction To start the data reduction we downloaded the latest instrument calibration files from the HST Data Archive. For each target we then applied the basic pipeline process to each of the two exposures. This includes overscan subtraction and trimming, bias correction, dark correction, and flat-fielding. We then aligned the two exposures by shifting one of the two by 5 pixels in the spatial direction. Subsequently, the task ocrreject in the IRAF2 STSDAS package was used to combine the images with rejection of both cosmic rays and hot pixels. After this step there remained both some positive and negative outliers in the combined data (the former are due to improperly removed cosmic rays and hot pixels; the latter are due to pixels that are hotter in the dark frame than in the science data). To correct these outliers we applied the task cosmicrays, first on the image itself and then on a negative version of itself. Following this, we performed a two-dimensional rectification and a flux calibration. For the wavelength calibration we used arc-lamp spectra obtained in the same HST orbit. The spectra were resampled logarithmically to a scale of 138 km s−1 per pixel to facilitate the spectral fitting discussed below. For each galaxy we extracted and co-added the central four rows of the two-dimensional spectrum. This yields a one-dimensional spectrum for a region of 0.′′20 × 0.′′20 around the galaxy center. This translates to 17 pc×17 pc at the mean distance to our galaxies. The extracted spectra contain primarily light from the bright NC, but there is also some con- tribution from the underlying galaxy (bulge and disk). To estimate this contribution we also extracted and co-added the rows on the two-dimensional spectrum at distances between 0.′′15 and 0.′′30 from the center. We subtracted the result (after proper scaling to the same number of rows) from the nuclear spectra. This also subtracts a small non-zero background count-rate that we found on most of the reduced two-dimensional spectra. The resulting one- dimensional nuclear spectra are the ones that we have used for the analysis in the remainder of this paper. It should be noted that even before subtraction the galaxy light makes only a 2IRAF is distributed by the National Optical Astronomy Observatory, which is operated by the Associa- tion of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc. (AURA) under cooperative agreement with the National Science Foundation. -- 8 -- relatively modest contribution to the nuclear spectrum. For the late-type spirals the median galaxy light contribution to the nuclear spectrum is 12%, and for the early-type spirals it is 29%. After the subtraction any remaining galaxy light contamination is probably much smaller than these percentages, although not quite zero. This is discussed further in Sec- tion 7.2. Most of the NCs have effective radii below 0.′′1, but there are a few with larger sizes (Boker et al. 2004). So in some cases our approach also subtracts a small amount of NC light. This is discussed further in Section 5. 4. SPECTRAL POPULATION FITTING 4.1. Modeling Approach There are several possible approaches for using our spectra to constrain the age, metal- licity, and dust extinction for the NCs in our sample. We will use here the fact that a population with arbitrary star formation history can be written as a sum of single-age stellar populations. Due to continued advances in stellar population synthesis modeling, the spectra of single-age stellar populations are now reasonably well known at a spectral resolution of a few Angstroms (e.g., Bruzual & Charlot 2003). By fitting a weighted superposition of the spectra of single-age stellar populations to an observed spectrum one can infer the popula- tion characteristics and star formation history of the object. We will refer to this approach as "spectral population fitting". Sarzi et al. (2005) and Walcher et al. (2006) previously used this approach to study the centers of spiral galaxies and their NCs. An alternative approach would be to extract and model individual line strength indices. This is advantageous be- cause different absorption lines are sensitive to different properties of the stellar population. For example, some lines are mostly sensitive to age, while others are mostly sensitive to metallicity. However, we do not use absorption line indices here. Because of the limited S/N of our spectra we can measure individual absorption lines only with limited accuracy. By contrast, the technique of spectral population fitting has the advantage that all pixels in the spectrum are modeled at the same time, so that the effect of noise is mitigated considerably. It also allows for a more straightforward interpretation of spectra with mixed populations of different age and/or metallicity. Walcher et al. (2006) used both line strength indices and spectral population fitting to analyze their ground-based VLT data of NCs, which have higher S/N and spectral resolution than our data, but lower spatial resolution. Broadly speaking, it was found that the two methods gave consistent results. We developed new software that fits an observed galaxy spectrum as a linear sum of population templates. The fit also allows for differences in redshift and line width between the galaxy and template spectra. The code is based on the Gauss-Hermite Pixel Fitting -- 9 -- software for analyzing galaxy kinematics (van der Marel 1994). It is similar to the code used by Walcher et al. (2006), which is based on the code for analyzing galaxy kinematics developed by Rix & White (1992). The best-fit is defined as the one that minimizes the χ2 difference between the observed and model spectra. It is found as the matrix solution of a non-negative least squares (NNLS) problem. This enforces the fact that none of the templates can have negative weight in the solution. To find the solution we used the fast and efficient algorithm of Lawson & Hanson (1974). Mathematical proofs exist that this algorithm will always find a global minimum (instead of a spurious local minimum). We verified the accuracy of our code by analyzing a small sub-sample of our survey with both our own code and that of Walcher et al. (2006) and found excellent agreement between the results. As templates we used the models of single-age stellar populations prepared by Bruzual & Charlot (2003). From their collection we used the model spectra based on the Padua 1994 evolutionary tracks, utilizing a Chabrier (2003) initial mass function (IMF) with lower and upper mass cut-offs of mlow = 0.1 M⊙ and mup = 100 M⊙. We used model spectra for four different metallicities Z = 0.004, 0.008, 0.02 and 0.05 and 14 different ages log τ =6.00, 6.48, 6.78, 7.00, 7.48, 7.78, 8.00, 8.48, 8.78, 9.00, 9.48, 9.78, 10.00 and 10.30.3 The models have solar abundance ratios. To address the effect of dust we made versions of each template spectrum with different amounts of extinction AV , using the extinction law of Cardelli et al. (1989). The templates have a spectral resolution of 3A, which is better than the resolution of the STIS data. All templates were rebinned to the same logarithmic scale with 138 km s−1 per pixel used for the galaxy spectra. We performed all fits over the wavelength range from 3540A to 5680A, for which galaxy data as well as model predictions are available. This region covers the prominent Balmer lines Hβ, Hγ, and Hδ plus other prominent diagnostic absorption lines such as the Mg Ib, Ca and Fe lines. 4.2. Results We applied the method of spectral population fitting to all of the NC spectra. We found that roughly half of the spectra did not have sufficient S/N for a meaningful analysis of the absorption line properties. So we decided to retain for the spectral population fitting only those NCs for which the spectra had S/N & 5 per pixel (see Table 3). This criterion 3The age τ is expressed in years throughout this paper, unless noted otherwise. The metallicity value Z = 0.02 is traditionally referred to as the "solar metallicity" (Z⊙). For historical consistency we will use this terminology here. However, it should be noted that it has recently been argued that the metallicity of our Sun is actually lower, namely Z = 0.012 (Asplund et al. 2005). -- 10 -- was chosen because at lower S/N it proved impossible to even recover the known galaxy redshift (listed by NED, the NASA Extragalactic Database) from the absorption lines in the spectrum. Visual inspection of the low S/N spectra also confirmed that little could be learned about their absorption lines. In practice the adopted S/N limit corresponds to a magnitude limit of mB ≤ 20.35 mag for the NCs observed in program GO#9783 (see Section 2) and mB ≤ 19.55 mag for the NCs observed in program GO#9070. The cutoff is fainter for the early-type spirals observed in GO#9783 than for the late-type spirals observed in GO#9070 because the former were observed with longer exposure times. In total there are ten early- and nine late-type galaxies brighter than the adopted cutoffs. They are listed in Table 4. For the NCs that are fainter than the adopted magnitude cutoffs we use the STIS spectra only for a study of the continuum shape, and not of the absorption lines. This is discussed in Section 5 below. To model the spectra we performed fits of different fixed metallicity Z and extinction AV . We used a grid with the four available metallicity values and extinctions increasing from zero upwards in steps 0.1 mag. For each fixed (Z, AV ) combination we used our code to find the weighted mix of populations of different ages that fits the observed spectrum with the minimum χ2, which we denote χ2 min(Z, AV ). Subsequently, we identified the best-fitting extinction and metallicity by finding the combination for which χ2 min(Z, AV ) is lowest. This yields for each galaxy the best-fit model that we use in the remainder of the paper. In principle we could have fit each NC spectrum with a weighted sum of all the available templates, including templates of different age, metallicity and extinction. However, this would introduce considerable degeneracy amongst the templates, leading to a non-unique fit that would be hard to interpret. Since we did not do this, it should be kept in mind that the best-fitting metallicity Z and extinction AV should be interpreted as "average" quantities only. Our strategy provides no insight into possible variations in metallicity and extinction within each NC. One might argue though that such variations are not large. Either way, the adopted approach is sufficient for the purposes of the present paper, and is similar to that adopted by Walcher et al. (2006). The observed spectra are shown in black in Figure 1, with the best-fit models overplotted in red. The NCs are shown in order of increasing age. The fits are generally good, as confirmed by the values of the reduced χ2 listed in Table 4. A few galaxies show emission lines (e.g., NGC 3277). These were masked in the fit. The best-fit metallicity and extinction for each galaxy are listed in Table 4. We also list NC properties that can be derived from the age-mix that best fits the data, namely: the luminosity-weighted mean value of log τ , which we call hlog τiL; the mass-weighted mean value of log τ , hlog τiM ; and the B-band mass-to-light ratio in solar units, M/LB. We note also that the best-fit models successfully -- 11 -- recovered the known redshift for all galaxies, and that the inferred line broadening was found to be consistent with expectation based on the instrumental resolution of the STIS setup (see Section 3.1). 4.3. Robustness of Population Fits With our aforementioned method we find the best-fitting metallicity and extinction for each NC. The uncertainties on these quantities can be obtained in a straightforward manner using the ∆χ2 statistic. This yields 1σ uncertainties that are generally similar to or smaller than the spacing of our (Z, AV ) grid. The inferred metallicity and extinction should therefore be fairly accurate, as judged by these formal uncertainties. On the other hand, there could be additional systematic uncertainties that are more difficult to quantify (e.g., due to uncertainties in the modeling of stellar evolution). So to be conservative we adopt throughout this paper the spacing of our grids as estimates of the uncertainties in Z and AV , i.e., ∆ log Z = 0.4 and ∆AV = 0.1. In the present context we are mostly interested in constraining the ages of the NCs. As it turns out, the inferred ages are not very sensitive to either Z or AV . This is illustrated by Figures 2 and 3. Figure 2 shows for all NCs the best-fit value of the luminosity-weighted mean age hlog τiL as a function of extinction. For this plot we determined for each NC the metallicity and age mix that give the lowest χ2 for fixed values of AV in the range 0.0 to 0.6 (this range contains the best-fit extinction for most of the galaxies in the sample; see Table 4). In general, the implied hlog τiL decreases monotonically with increasing AV . This is because with increased extinction, the population must be intrinsically bluer, and therefore younger, to provide the same continuum slope. However, even a change of 0.6 mag in the assumed AV changes the best fit age only by 0.2 -- 0.5 dex. This is much smaller than the spread in ages amongst the different NCs. Similarly, Figure 3 shows hlog τiL as a function of metallicity, with AV and the age mix at each metallicity chosen to minimize χ2. For young populations with hlog τiL . 8.5, the inferred age is almost independent of Z. For older populations the age decreases when the metallicity increases. This is because higher-metallicity populations tend to be redder, so that a younger age (i.e., bluer continuum) is needed to provide the same continuum slope. However, even a change of 1.1 dex in log Z only changes the inferred age by ∼ 0.3 dex. This is also much smaller than the spread in ages amongst the different NCs. So the overall age distribution of the NC population is insensitive to possible systematic uncertainties in the inferred extinctions and metallicities. Note also in this context that Figures 2 and 3 conservatively assume that we have no knowledge of the actual Z and AV . In reality, the values of these quantities are actually well constrained by our data. -- 12 -- Our template library is based on models with solar abundance ratios. Of course, the NCs under study may not have exactly these same abundance ratios. This might introduce small systematic biases in our results. However, the influence on the inferred ages is probably small. Figure 3 shows that, for the purposes of the present study, the inferred ages are relatively insensitive to variations in overall metallicity. Abundance ratio variations are probably a second-order effect as compared to variations in Z. Our results are therefore not likely to be sensitive to them either. This argument is supported by the good agreement between the M/L ratios inferred from our stellar population study and those from dynamical studies, as discussed in Section 6.3. Another possible concern might be that by allowing an arbitrary mix of ages (i.e., an arbitrary star formation history) we might somehow have provided the fit too much freedom. This could in principle decrease the accuracy of the inferred ages. To address this issue we also performed single-age fits to all NC spectra. We determined the χ2 of the fit to the data for each individual template of fixed Z, AV and age, and then adopted the template with the lowest χ2 as the best fit. The ages log τ thus inferred agree very well with the luminosity-weighted ages inferred from the composite-age fits. For the sample as a whole we find that log τ − hlog τiL has an average of 0.11 ± 0.08, with an RMS scatter of 0.36. The scatter is similar to the spacing in age between the different templates in our library, which is ∼ 0.3 dex. Another approach for assessing the accuracy of the inferred ages is to perform Monte- Carlo simulations. We did this in Boker et al. (2003). In that paper we constructed artificial galaxy spectra as a superposition of randomly chosen templates from the library with ran- domly chosen weights. Artificial Poisson noise was then added to the spectra with S/N values representative of the range encountered in our observations. The artificial spectra were analyzed in similar fashion as our real data, using the same library of templates (i.e., same metallicity and extinction) used to build the artificial galaxy spectra. Statistics were performed on the relation between the luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL of the input spectra and the values for the same quantity inferred with the code. The 1σ spread in the residuals was typically found to be . 0.3 dex for values of log τ & 8.0, which is the age for most of the NCs in our sample. The spread decreases for older populations and is about a factor of two smaller at log τ ≈ 9.0. The spread is larger for younger populations, but a very young population is never mistaken for an old one (log τ & 9.0). Also, young NCs (such as the one identified in NGC 2139) tend to be bright and produce spectra of high S/N, which decreases the uncertainty. There are five late-type spirals in our sample that we also studied in Walcher et al. (2006). For four of these galaxies (NGCs 300, 428, 1493 and 2139) the STIS data had -- 13 -- sufficient S/N for spectral population fitting. A cross-comparison of our results for these galaxies with the results in Walcher et al. (2006) provides a useful consistency check. The latter paper used data from the VLT, which provides higher spectral resolution but lower spatial resolution and a smaller wavelength range. Despite these differences, the luminosity- weighted ages inferred from the VLT and STIS data agree with a mean difference of 0.03±0.12 dex and a RMS scatter of 0.24 dex. So the agreement is excellent, and provides no reason to mistrust the results from either study. There are no early-type spirals for which a direct comparison to our STIS results is possible. Sarzi et al. (2005) performed a study with HST/STIS of the centers of early-type spiral galaxies with emission lines, but there are no galaxies in common between our samples to make a direct comparison. 5. BROAD-BAND MAGNITUDES AND B − V COLOR Approximately half of our spectra have insufficient S/N for spectral population fitting. However, even for the faintest NCs the spectra have sufficient S/N for the calculation of integrated properties. In particular, we used the spectra to estimate the apparent magnitudes of the NCs in the Johnson B and V passbands. These bands cover the wavelength range of our spectra and are of particular interest because they are used most frequently in stellar population studies. The STIS pipeline calibrates spectra to absolute fluxes in erg s−1 cm−2 A−1 using refer- ence files that are based on observations of spectrophotometric standard stars. We used the synphot package in IRAF/STSDAS to calculate integrals over the spectra, weighted with the transmission curves of the B and V passbands, respectively. The results were converted to magnitudes by comparison to results obtained in a similar manner for the star Vega, which has magnitude zero in all Johnson bands to within ∼ 0.03 mag (Bessell et al. 1998; Bohlin & Gilliland 2004). The random uncertainties in the magnitudes follow from propagation of the flux uncertainties calculated by the STIS pipeline. Our spectra do not quite cover the entire wavelength range of the V -band. In order to calculate V -band magnitudes we extended the spectra to redder wavelengths using a linear extrapolation. Any potential systematic errors thus introduced are not expected to be large. A constant flux error of 10% over the extrapolated region would change the calculated V -band magnitudes by only 0.03. More generally, the relative accuracy of the inferred magnitudes (i.e. the systematic errors in the implied colors B − V ) is expected to be . 0.05 mag. The magnitudes obtained by integration over the spectra measure only the light in our STIS aperture of 0.′′20 × 0.′′20. To estimate the total magnitudes of the NCs we therefore need to apply a correction for NC light that falls outside the aperture. We did this in two -- 14 -- steps. First, we added a constant correction of 2.5 log(0.71) = −0.37 mag, to account for the fact that even for a point source only 71% of the light falls in an aperture of 0.′′20× 0.′′20 (Kim Quijano et al. 2003). And second, we added a correction that depends on the extent of the NC. This correction is 2.5 log(fe/fp), where fe and fp are the fractions of the light of an extended and a point source, respectively, that fall within a 0.′′20 × 0.′′20 aperture. The fractions were calculated using a simple Gaussian model for the light distribution, with the FWHM as the only free parameter, using eq. (A3) of van der Marel et al. (1997). For fe we used the FWHM measured from the intensity profile along the slit and for fp we used the actual FWHM of the STIS PSF. The use of a simple Gaussian model for the core of the light distribution is adequate, given that the correction of −0.37 mag has already accounted for the scattering of light into the extended wings of the PSF. The final NC magnitudes, including the aperture corrections, are listed in Table 5. The table also lists the implied B − V color. As a consistency check, we compared our V -band magnitudes mV with the instrumental magnitudes in the WFPC2/F606W filter system given by Carollo et al. (1998) for the NCs in early-type spirals. We find that on average mV −mF606W = 0.04, with an RMS scatter of 0.40 mag. For comparison, single-age solar-metallicity stellar populations of 108 and 1010 yrs have mV − mF606W = 0.12 and 0.32, respectively (given the V − I from Bruzual & Charlot (2003) and the transformations given by Holtzman et al. (1995)). We also combined our V -band magnitudes with the I-band magnitudes given by Boker et al. (2002) for the NCs in late-type spirals to estimate V − I colors. These colors can be used as a consistency check for those NCs for which an independent color estimate is available. This is the case for the nine NCs for which spectral population fitting was performed in Section 4. For these NCs we calculated the predicted V −I color based on the best-fitting stellar population mix and dust extinction, as given in Table 4. We find that on average (V − I) − (V − I)pred = 0.18, with an RMS scatter of 0.53 mag. These comparisons suggest that our magnitudes are probably accurate in an absolute sense to ∼ 0.2 mag, when averaged over the sample. However, for individual NCs the 1σ accuracy is probably no better than ∼ 0.5 mag. These absolute accuracies are reasonable, given the uncertainties associated with galaxy light subtraction and aperture corrections. Of course, photometry of images generally provides a more accurate method for estimating NC magnitudes. Nonetheless, our results are useful because they augment existing results in the literature with results in bluer passbands. -- 15 -- 6. DISCUSSION OF SPECTRAL POPULATION FITTING RESULTS 6.1. Metallicities and Extinctions The main focus of our investigation is the determination of the ages and masses of the NCs. A study of the NC metallicities and extinctions is not the primary interest of our paper. Accurate studies of metallicities would probably benefit from an analysis of individual line strength indices in spectra of higher S/N, and accurate studies of extinction would probably benefit from analysis of spectra that cover a larger wavelength range. Nonetheless, our results obtained from the spectral population fitting (see Table 4) do have fairly small formal random uncertainties. While there might be systematic uncertainties, there are no specific omissions in our analysis that would lead us to mistrust the results. So it is of some interest to examine our findings for the metallicities and extinctions listed in Table 4. Figure 4 shows histograms of the metallicity distributions. The bottom panel is for the complete sample of NCs for which we performed spectral population fitting. The top two panels show the results for the early- and late-type spirals separately. The average inferred metallicity is ¯Z = 0.030 ± 0.005 for the early-type spirals, ¯Z = 0.018 ± 0.004 for the late- types, and ¯Z = 0.024 ± 0.006 for the complete sample. The quoted errors are formal errors, calculated as the RMS scatter among the individual datapoints divided by √N. Given the crudeness of our sampling in metallicity, these errors are probably optimistic. So on the whole, the primary conclusions are that the metallicities are close to solar and that the metallicities tend to be somewhat higher in early- than in late-type spirals. These results are quite consistent with what is known about the metallicities of spiral galaxies, and the dependence on Hubble type, from studies of nebular gas (e.g., Zaritsky et al. 1994). Figure 5 is similar to Figure 4, and shows histograms of the dust extinction distributions. The average inferred extinction is ¯AV = 0.32 ± 0.13 for the early-type galaxies, ¯AV = 0.39 ± 0.09 for the late-types, and ¯AV = 0.35 ± 0.08 for the complete sample. The average for the early-types is influenced somewhat disproportionately by NGC 3455. Its inferred extinction of AV = 1.4 is considerably larger than the values found for all other NCs. Without this galaxy the early-types would have ¯AV = 0.20 ± 0.06. Either way, the average extinction is marginally higher for the NCs in late-type galaxies than for the NCs in early-type spirals. This is as expected, given that late-type spirals are more gas rich, show enhanced star formation and radiate more FIR emission than early-type spirals (e.g., Kennicutt 1983; Devereux et al. 1987). In general, the results from spectral population fitting become more uncertain as the amount of dust extinction increases. However, for the sample here we do not generally find the dust extinctions to be particularly high. So there is little reason to be concerned that the inferred ages are significantly impacted by any remaining uncertainties in -- 16 -- the exact amount of extinction, or the detailed shape of the extinction law. As a consistency check on our analysis, we also compared the inferred extinctions to the known Galactic foreground value for each galaxy. In all cases we found the inferred value to be larger than the Galactic foreground value (see Tables 1 and 2) to within the ∼ 0.1 accuracy dictated by our sampling of AV . This is what would be expected for a successful fit, given that the total extinction should never be smaller than the known foreground extinction. It is of interest to compare our results to those of Sarzi et al. (2005) and Walcher et al. (2006). The HST study of Sarzi et al. (2005) addressed the stellar populations in the centers of 23 galactic bulges in early-type spirals for which the central regions are dominated by emission lines. These galaxies comprise a mix of H ii galaxies, LINERs and Seyfert galaxies. Sarzi et al. (2005) found that good fits could be obtained with models of either Z = 0.02 or 0.05, consistent with the results for early-type spirals in our study. Their average extinction of ¯AV = 0.37 ± 0.05 also agrees well with our value of ¯AV = 0.32 ± 0.13. The VLT study of Walcher et al. (2006) addressed the NCs in a sample of nine late-type spirals. The average metallicity for the Walcher et al. (2006) sample is ¯Z = 0.015± 0.004. This is consistent with the value ¯Z = 0.018 ± 0.004 for the late-type galaxies in our sample. The average I-band extinction found by Walcher et al. (2006) corresponds to ¯AV = 0.56 ± 0.18, as compared to ¯AV = 0.39 ± 0.09 for the late-type spirals in our sample. Our conclusion that the dust extinctions are not particularly high is also consistent with the findings of Carollo et al. (2001), who studied the V − H and J − H colors of NCs in spiral galaxies using HST imaging. So overall, our results agree well with those of other authors. 6.2. Cluster Ages We have derived luminosity-weighted ages for the 19 NCs for which we performed spec- tral population fitting (Table 4). Figure 6 shows histograms of the derived ages for the early-type, late-type and total sample. The average luminosity-weighted ages are hlog τiL = 9.23 ± 0.21 (early-type), 8.37 ± 0.25 (late-type) and 8.82 ± 0.18 (combined sample). The inferred average luminosity-weighted ages are smaller than the typical ages of galac- tic disks, for which the start of star formation was typically at least 5 -- 10 Gyrs ago (e.g., Knox et al. 1999; Binney et al. 2000; Abadi et al. 2003). This indicates that star formation has continued in the centers of spiral galaxies after the initial formation of the galaxy. We find the ages of the NCs in late-type spirals to be smaller than those in early-type spirals. This is illustrated further by Figure 7, which shows a clear relation between hlog τiL and the Hubble T-type of the host galaxy (the parameters of the best linear fit and the Spear- man rank-order correlation coefficient are given in Table 6). This result is probably not -- 17 -- unexpected, given that late-type spirals are more gas-rich (e.g., Young & Scoville 1991). So there might have been more gas flows towards the center from which to form stars. Also, our finding for the nuclear clusters is consistent with the fact that the underlying disks of late-type spirals formed more of their stars recently than early-type spirals (e.g., Kennicutt 1998). The three youngest clusters in our sample are hosted in late-type spirals, and the four oldest clusters are hosted in early-type spirals. It is again of interest to compare our results to those of Sarzi et al. (2005) and Walcher et al. (2006). The average luminosity-weighted age for nuclear clusters in early-type spirals reported here, 9.23 ± 0.21, is similar to the value 9.50 ± 0.13 inferred from the results of Sarzi et al. (2005). The small (non-significant) difference could be due to the fact that the Sarzi et al. (2005) sample has relatively more galaxies of very early types (Sa or even S0) than our study does. Also, the galaxies in their sample do not necessarily host nuclear star clusters and are much more biased towards AGN activity. So in view of these differences, the agreement between our results is surprisingly good. In the same spirit, the average luminosity-weighted age for nuclear clusters in late-type spirals reported here, 8.37± 0.25, is similar to the value 8.15± 0.19 inferred from the results of Walcher et al. (2006). Their VLT sample overlaps in part with our late-type sample (there are four galaxies in common with the STIS subsample for which we performed spectral population fitting: NGCs 300, 428, 1493 and 2139). The range of Hubble types in both samples is very similar, as is the range of cluster luminosities (the average absolute magnitude of the clusters in the Walcher et al. (2006) sample is hMIi = −12.75, as compared to hMIi = −12.64 for the NCs in late-type spirals for which we performed spectral population fitting). So the agreement of the present results with those inferred from the Walcher et al. (2006) VLT spectra is more or less what was expected. The VLT spectra had much higher spectral resolution and S/N than our data. So the agreement does indicate that there is no reason for concern that the limited spectral resolution and S/N of our STIS spectra might have somehow biased our results. We note that to make a fair comparison of the results of Walcher et al. (2006) and Sarzi et al. (2005) to ours we had to convert their results to the same definitions that we have used here. Our quantity hlog τiL is the average logarithm of the age of the population, weighted by luminosity. By contrast, Walcher et al. (2006) and Sarzi et al. (2005) quote loghτiL, which is the logarithm of the average age of the population, weighted by luminosity. We prefer the former statistic, because it more clearly highlights the contributions and presence of young populations. For example, a cluster for which 50% of the light comes from a 106 yr old population and the other 50% comes from a 1010 yr old population has hlog τiL = 8.0 and loghτiL = 9.70. Note also that while we and Sarzi et al. (2005) weight by luminosity in the spectral range covered by the STIS spectra, Walcher et al. (2006) weight by luminosity in the I-band. We corrected for this as well in making the aforementioned comparisons. -- 18 -- In addition to the luminosity-weighted ages we also calculated mass-weighted ages hlog τiM for our own STIS spectral population fits (see Table 4). The sample averages are hlog τiM = 9.89 ± 0.14 (early-type), 9.07 ± 0.21 (late-type) and 9.50 ± 0.16 (combined sample). These mass-weighted averages are considerably older than the luminosity-weighted averages, typically by ∼ 0.7 dex. This is because young populations are much brighter than old populations. So while young populations contribute a significant fraction of the light, their contribution to the total NC mass is more limited. There often is an underlying older population that does not contribute much light, but does contain most of the mass. Although it is possible to calculate average ages in various ways, it should be kept in mind that no single number can capture the complexity of mixed populations that is present in the NCs. Like Sarzi et al. (2005) and Walcher et al. (2006) before us we find that mixed populations generally give significantly better fits to the observed spectra than single-age fits. The median difference in χ2 between the best mixed-age and single-age fits for the sample galaxies is ∆χ2 = 92. There are a total of 16 free parameters in the mixed-age fits (metallicity, extinction, and the 14 weights of single-age templates). The standard theory of confidence level estimation using ∆χ2 statistics (e.g., Press et al. 1992) dictates that the 1-σ confidence limit around the best mixed-age fit corresponds to a contour of ∆χ2 = 18 in the 16-dimensional parameter space. Conversely, a value ∆χ2 = 92 is statistically significant at more than the 99.999% level. The present results provide the first demonstratation that mixed-age populations are present also in the NCs of early-type spirals. Walcher et al. (2006) studied only late-type spirals. Sarzi et al. (2005) studied early-type spirals, but their galaxies did not generally or necessarily host NCs. With our new results it is now clear that all NCs, independent of host Hubble type, did not form in a single event. Instead they had additional star formation even long after the oldest stars formed. Table 7 lists the derived luminosity fractions for the 19 NCs for which we performed spectral population fitting. Instead of listing the contributions of each individual single-age template, we have binned the weights into three (somewhat arbitrarily chosen) age groups. The groups correspond respectively to "young populations" (log τ ≤ 7.8), "intermediate-age" populations (7.8 < log τ ≤ 9.2), and "old" populations (log τ ≥ 9.2). In four of the ten NCs in early-type spirals more than half of the light comes from an old population. By contrast, in the NCs in late-type spirals the light is always dominated by an intermediate-age or young population. 6.3. Cluster Masses The spectral population fits to the STIS spectra yield the mass-to-light ratio in the B-band, M/LB (Table 4). These values range from 0.02 to roughly 9.0. The average M/LB -- 19 -- values are 3.64 ± 1.03 (early-type sample) and 0.52 ± 0.19 (late-type sample). The smaller value for the NCs in late-type spirals is due to the fact that on average they have younger stellar populations, as discussed above. The NC mass M is obtained upon multiplication of the B-band luminosity LB and the M/LB value of the best composite spectral population fit (Table 4). The former can be calculated from the apparent magnitude mB (Table 5), the extinction AB (which follows from the V -band extinction AV listed in Table 4), and the distance D in Mpc. The distance can be calculated as vsys/H0, where vsys is the systemic velocity of the galaxy corrected for Virgocentric infall as listed in Tables 1 and 2. We use here a Hubble constant H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1. This yields for the NC mass that log M = log(M/LB) − 0.4 mB + 2 log vsys + 0.530 AV + 8.502. (1) Here M and M/LB are both given in solar units. The constant 0.530 is equal to 0.4AB/AV , where AB/AV = 1.324 is based on the extinction law of Rieke & Lebofsky (1985). The constant 8.502 is equal to 0.4(25−5 log H0 +MB,⊙), where MB,⊙ is the B-band solar absolute magnitude (Binney & Merrifield 1998). We used equation (1) to calculate the masses for the 19 NCs for which we did spectral population fits. The results are listed in Table 4. Figure 8 shows histograms of the derived masses for the early-type, late-type and total sample. The average masses are log M = 7.63 ± 0.24 (early-type), 6.25 ± 0.21 (late-type) and 6.98 ± 0.22 (combined sample). So on average the NCs in our sample are much more massive than globular clusters (GCs) in the Milky Way, which have a characteristic mass of log M = 5.18 (e.g., Harris 1991). On the other hand, some of the most massive GCs in the Local Group, such as ω Cen in the Milky Way (Meylan 2002) and G1 in M 31 (Meylan et al. 2001), and in other nearby galaxies such as Cen A (Martini & Ho 2004) have masses that overlap with the low-mass end of the NC mass distribution. Such massive globular clusters are also abundant in mergers and starburst galaxies. Dynamical masses for the most massive young star clusters in the Antennae (NGC 4038/39) range from 5.81 ≤ log M ≤ 6.67 (Mengel et al. 2002), with the mass distribution showing a power-law increase towards lower masses (ψ(M) ∝ M −2 over the range 4.0 ≤ log M ≤ 6.0 (Zhang & Fall 1999; Whitmore et al. 1999)). More recently, for the GC W3 in the merger remnant NGC 7252 an even higher dynamical mass of log M = 7.9 ± 0.1 was derived (Maraston et al. 2004). The most massive star clusters in M 82 have typical masses of 5.54 ≤ log M ≤ 6.18 (McCrady et al. 2003). Although all these objects span a range of masses, they do all obey a common relation in terms of their "Fundamental Plane" properties (Walcher et al. 2005). These similarities extend also to related objects such as the nuclei of dwarf elliptical galaxies (Geha et al. 2002) and the so-called "ultra-compact dwarf" galaxies (Ha¸segan et al. 2005). This indicates that the formation of all these objects could be governed by similar physical processes. -- 20 -- One striking aspect of Figure 8 is that the mass distribution of NCs in early-type spiral galaxies is centered around much higher masses than that in late-type spirals. This is illustrated further by Figure 9, which shows a clear relation between cluster mass M and the Hubble T-type of the host galaxy (the parameters of the best linear fit and the Spearman rank-order correlation coefficient are given in Table 6). As many as six out of ten NCs in early-type spirals for which we performed spectral population fits have masses log M & 8.0 (the apparent bimodality in the mass distribution for the early-type sample seen in the top panel of Figure 8 is most likely due to low number statistics and not worth attaching much significance to). For comparison, this exceeds the masses of many dwarf galaxies (e.g., Binggeli et al. 1988). This result for early-type spirals connects with an earlier finding of Carollo et al. (2002). They found that NCs in early-type spirals span a much larger range in luminosity than the NCs found in late-type spirals, with luminosities extending up to ∼ 108.4L⊙ in the H-band. Our work shows that the luminosity of these very bright NCs is not generally the result of a very young population with a very low M/L. Instead, most of these very bright NCs have predominantly old populations. Hence, they are not just luminous, but also very massive. Our mass estimates agree reasonably well with the few other published estimates for NCs in spiral galaxies. Walcher et al. (2005) determined the masses of NCs in nine late- type spiral galaxies from a combination of velocity dispersion measurements and dynamical modeling. Four of the galaxies (NGCs 300, 428, 1493 and 2139) are common to the STIS subsample for which we performed spectral population fitting. For these galaxies the average residual between our two studies (our values minus theirs) is ∆ log M = −0.21 ± 0.13 dex. This good agreement is consistent with the findings of Walcher et al. (2006), who also found that mass estimates from dynamical modeling and spectral population fitting are more or less consistent. This agreement implies, among other things, that any systematic errors due to the assumed solar abundance ratios in the spectral population fitting cannot be large. The average NC mass of all nine late-type spiral galaxies in the Walcher et al. (2005) sample is log M = 6.51 ± 0.18, as compared to log M = 6.25 ± 0.21 for the late-type spirals in our sample. Dynamical mass measurements also exist for the NCs in the nearby late-type spirals M33 (Kormendy & McClure 1993) and IC 342 (Boker et al. 1999). The inferred values of log M . 5.85 for M33 and log M ∼ 6.78 for IC 342 fit within the range of our NC mass determinations for late-type spirals. We have not attempted to infer formal uncertainties on the M/L values and masses implied by the spectral population fits. One reason for this is that the large number of free parameters and the possibility of correlations between the parameters make this a difficult problem. Also, it is likely that the true errors are dominated by systematics, rather than the S/N of the data. Either way, the average uncertainty can be estimated from the comparison -- 21 -- of our results to the dynamical measurements of Walcher et al. (2005). Based on this we estimate that the average error in both M/L and M does not exceed ∼ 0.3 dex. However, it should be noted that the errors need not be the same for the different galaxies in the sample. When the light of the NC is dominated primarily by a single population, either young or old, the inferred M/L and M should be fairly robust. But if instead the light is dominated by a young population while at the same time the mass is dominated by an old population, then the M/L and M are more uncertain. When these quantities are determined primarily by a population that forms only a small percentage of the total light then the result is obviously more susceptible to systematic uncertainties of various kinds. Similarly, the values of hlog τiM discussed in Section 6.2 are then also more uncertain. An additional uncertainty comes from our coarse sampling of the ages in our template library. For example, we include spectra of log τ = 10.00 and 10.30, but a population that is as old as the Universe (∼ 13.5 × 109 yr, so that log τ = 10.13) can only be approximated as a weighted mixture of the two. For the NCs in early-type spirals we find that one has a luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL that actually exceeds the canonical age of the Universe in a ΛCDM cosmology, and there are five NCs that have a mass-weighted age hlog τiM for which this is true. So it is possible that the M/L and M values for these NCs have been slightly overestimated. 7. ASSESSMENT OF SYSTEMATIC EFFECTS 7.1. AGN Contributions The galaxies that we selected for STIS spectroscopy were all chosen because they were found to have a compact nuclear source, as identified from HST imaging. In principle such a source could be either a star cluster or non-thermal emission from an AGN. However, one can discriminate between these possibilities using the size of the source. A star cluster is generally spatially resolved with HST in nearby galaxies, whereas AGN emission is unresolved.4 Boker et al. (2004) did a detailed study of the sizes of the nuclear sources in late-type spirals. They found that all sources in their sample were spatially resolved, indicating that they are star clusters. This is not unexpected, given that we know from emission line studies that AGN 4It is usually assumed that the detection of a resolved nuclear source implies that the source is not an AGN. While this is generally a valid argument, it must be applied with some care. Continuum emission from an AGN is indeed generally not spatially resolved. However, the emission-line region in many low-luminosity AGN can often be resolved in HST images (e.g., Pogge et al. 2000). While a filter such as F606W (as used by, e.g., Carollo et al. (1998)) transmits mostly continuum, it does have a small emission-line contribution from Hα+[N ii] as well. Therefore, even if the nuclear source is an AGN, it is not entirely ruled out that it could appear slightly extended in F606W. -- 22 -- are very rare in the latest Hubble types (Ho et al. 1997). Carollo et al. (1998) and Carollo et al. (2002) measured the sizes and optical vs. near-IR colors of nuclear sources in mostly early-type spirals. As in the late-type spirals, the sources were almost always found to be extended. The colors were found to be in the range V − H = −0.5 to 3.0. This is similar to the range covered by stellar population synthesis predictions for star clusters with different ages and metallicities (e.g., Bruzual & Charlot 2003). So in both late- and early-type spirals, the nuclear sources detected from HST imaging appear in large majority to be star clusters, and not AGNs. Carollo et al. (1998) did find some nuclear sources for which the spatial extent was not inconsistent with a point source. However, none of these made it into our spectroscopic STIS sample. The fact that the nuclear sources seen in HST imaging are generally star clusters does not by itself preclude the possibility that an AGN might contribute some emission as well. Based on information in NED, only three of the 40 galaxies in our sample were previously classified as an AGN (NGC 5377) or a LINER (NGCs 4540 and 6384). Only one of these galaxies, NGC 5377, is part of the high S/N STIS sample for which we have performed spectral population fits. Indeed, NGC 5377 shows emission lines in our STIS spectra. Only two other galaxies show emission lines as well, namely NGC 3177 and NGC 3277 (the latter has the strongest emission lines of the three galaxies, including [O II] and [O III]). And in these two galaxies the emission lines could be due to H ii regions, and need not be indicative of an AGN. Nonetheless, the true fraction of AGN in our sample could be larger, especially for early-type spirals. Based on ground-based emission line spectra 10% of Sb-Sbc galaxies are classified as Type I AGN and 34% as LINERs or transition objects (Ho et al. 1997). Of course, emission lines themselves are masked in our stellar population fitting. So an AGN would only affect our analysis through its non-thermal continuum. This would have two effects: it would change the overall continuum slope of the spectrum and it would decrease the equivalent width of the absorption lines. These effects are very similar to (and in our modeling are probably degenerate with) the effects of changes in extinction in metallicity. However, the sensitivity of the inferred population ages to uncertainties in extinction and metallicity is not particularly large for the purposes of our study. This is dicussed in detail in Section 4.3 and quantified in Figures 2 and 3. Therefore, the sensitivity of the inferred population ages to a possible non-thermal AGN contribution is probably not particularly large either. In principle it is possible that an unknown number of galaxies in our sample is affected by the presence of an AGN continuum. In those galaxies we would still expect our age and M/L determinations of the NC to be relatively unbiased. However, the total luminosity and mass estimates would be too high by an amount that depends on exactly what fraction of the light in the STIS spectrum is from an AGN. Since AGNs are more common in early- -- 23 -- type spirals than in late-type spirals, this would affect early-type spirals more than late-type spirals. NCs in early-type spirals are in fact found to have higher luminosities (Carollo et al. 2002) and masses (Section 6.3) than those in late-type galaxies. However, AGN continua can probably not explain this effect. An AGN continuum can be very difficult to distinguish from a young stellar population dominated by O stars. Therefore, the amount of AGN continuum in the STIS spectra is approximately constrained to be no more than the percentage of the light in our stellar population fits that is attributed to a very young stellar population. For the early-type spirals, where we are most concerned about potential AGN contributions, these percentages are generally zero or very low (cf. Table 7). Therefore, potential AGN contributions are not expected to affect our overall conclusions. 7.2. Bulge and Disk Light Subtraction Another source of uncertainty in our analysis is the accuracy with which the galaxy (bulge and disk) light underneath the NC can be subtracted. The high spatial resolution of HST allows us to do this subtraction much more accurately than what is possible in a ground-based study. Nonetheless, the subtraction is not perfect and it is important to address how this might have affected the results. As described in Section 3.2, we subtracted the galaxy light by subtracting the spectrum observed at ∼ 0.′′2 from the NC. This assumes implicitly that the bulge and disk have approximately constant surface brightness in the central 0.′′2. This is a simplification, because bulges tend to have cusped brightness profiles that increase all the way towards the center. This is not likely to affect the results for late- type spirals, which have faint or negligible bulges. So galaxy contamination to the nuclear spectrum is small, and exactly how it is modeled and corrected has little effect on the final results. However, early-type spirals have prominent bulges, and for them the galaxy light subtraction is more important. So it is important to address how potential inaccuracies in the galaxy light subtraction might have affected our results for early-type spirals. One important test of our galaxy light subtraction procedure is to compare the lumi- nosities derived from our spectra with those derived from HST/WFPC2 imaging by Carollo et al. (1998). Our spectra only provide a one-dimensional light profile that has been inte- grated over a 0.′′2 wide slit (which reduces the contrast between the cluster light and the underlying galaxy light), sampled at 0.′′05 resolution. By contrast, WFPC2 imaging provides a two-dimensional image that is sampled at 0.′′05 resolution in both orthogonal directions. Therefore, the WFPC2 images allow more accurate and sophisticated techniques for galaxy light subtraction than was possible with our STIS spectroscopy, including allowance for a possible central surface brightness cusp in the bulge light. Nonetheless, the luminosities in- -- 24 -- ferred from our spectra show little bias as compared to those inferred from the imaging, and appear accurate in an average sense to ∼ 0.2 mag (see Section 5). Therefore, the comparison with the WFPC2 imaging results by itself provides no reason to mistrust the accuracy of the galaxy light subtraction in our STIS spectra. What remains as a caveat is the possibility that both our study and the Carollo et al. (1998) study might have overestimated the NC cluster luminosity in early-type spirals, by underestimating the bulge contribution to the central few pixels. Our own STIS dataset does not really allow us to test this possibility in much quantitative detail. However, Carollo et al. (2002) in their appendix B described detailed and extensive tests of the accuracy of their decompositions of HST images into NC and bulge components. They found no evidence that their inferred NC luminosities would be systematically biased. Depending on the exact properties of the NC and the surrounding bulge, they did find that it is possible to infer NC luminosities that are too faint or too bright. However, for NCs with radii that are similar to those typically observed, the errors are generally no worse than ±1 mag. When averaged over a realistic range of NC and bulge properties, the average bias in NC magnitudes was found to be close to zero. We have found here that NCs in early-type spirals are more massive than those in late- type spirals. The difference in average mass is 1.4 dex (see Section 6.3). To explain these findings as a result of inaccuracies in the galaxy light subtraction, one would need to assume that NC luminosities in early-type spirals have been overestimated by an average of ∼ 3.5 mag. In view of the results of Carollo et al. (2002), this seems highly unlikely. Nonetheless, it should be acknowledged that the identification and characterization of a NC embedded in a bulge with a steep luminosity profile is a difficult and potentially non-unique prob- lem. Therefore, additional investigations into the accuracy of such decompositions remain desirable. Possible inaccuracies in the galaxy light subtraction would not only affect the determi- nation of the NC luminosity, as just discussed, but they might also affect our age and M/L determinations for the NC. If bulge light has inadvertently contributed to the spectra that we have analyzed, and if bulges have older ages and higher M/L than NCs, then we will have overestimated both the M/L values and masses of the NCs in early-type spirals. This would go in the same direction as the correlation observed in Figure 9, and we therefore need to address the possible importance of this effect. To proceed we need some understanding of the stellar population gradients in the central ∼ 20 pc of the early-type spirals in our sample (for the galaxy light subtraction we use the observed spectrum at ∼ 0.′′2 from the galaxy center, which corresponds to ∼ 20pc at the mean distance of our sample.) Unfortunately, little is known about this. The stellar population -- 25 -- properties of bulges have been well-studied (Wyse et al. 1997). However, most of this work refers to much larger (∼ kpc) scales, and to "classical" bulges with R1/4 light profiles. By contrast, NCs are preferentially found in "pseudo"-bulges with exponential light profiles (Carollo et al. 1998), the properties of which are not nearly as well understood (Kormendy & Kennicutt 2004). Our own STIS data cannot be used to address radial population gradients, because the S/N of the spectra drops too rapidly away from the center. Also, color gradients from HST imaging in different bands is not generally available for the galaxies in our sample. Despite the difficulties in constraining stellar population gradients on the relevant spatial scales in our sample galaxies, there do exist some indirect arguments and observations that can provide insight. First, Carollo et al. (2001) imaged a sample of (mostly early-type) spirals with HST in both optical and near-IR wavelengths. They showed that the V − H colors of the NCs in their sample were always similar to and consistent with the V − H color of the surrounding pseudo-bulge. This suggests that any stellar population gradients in the very central regions of spiral galaxies may not be large. Second, as a test, we analyzed our STIS spectra both with and without subtraction of the galaxy light observed at 0.′′2. The inferred ages were found to be very similar for the two sets of spectra: the age difference for the NCs has a mean of ∆ log τ = 0.22 ± 0.06 dex for early-type spirals and 0.07 ± 0.01 dex for late-type spirals. If there had been large population gradients between the light in the galaxy center and at 0.′′2, then one might have expected the inferred age to be more sensitive to the galaxy light subtraction. And third, for late-type spirals we find that our age determinations are in excellent agreement with those of Walcher et al. (2006), even though the latter were obtained with five times worse spatial resolution and mixed in much more disk and bulge light into the spectrum that was analyzed. None of the arguments that we have presented prove conclusively that the luminosities and M/L values of the NCs, particularly in early-type spirals, might not have been overes- timated. On the other hand, none of the available data and tests that we and others have done suggest that this has in fact been the case either. Given the available evidence, it seems unlikely that errors resulting from galaxy-light subtraction could by themselves explain the correlation of cluster mass with Hubble type shown in Figure 9. Carollo et al. (2002) found that NCs in early-type spirals tend to be brighter on average than those in late-type spirals. Therefore, NCs in early-type spirals must be more massive than those in late-type spirals unless either: (1) Carollo et al. (2002) systematically overestimated the NC luminosities in early-type spirals; or (2) NCs in early-type spirals are younger and have significantly lower M/L than those in late-type spirals. The first possibility is not something that we can verify independently with our own STIS data, but does seem to have been tested extensively (and ruled out) by Carollo et al. (2002). The second possibility is exactly the opposite of what we conclude from our STIS data, namely that NCs in early-type spirals are older than those -- 26 -- in late-type spirals (see Section 6.2). It seems unlikely that systematic errors in M/L due to inaccuracies in the galaxy-light subtraction could be large enough to explain this. So in summary, the difficulty of performing an accurate subtraction of underlying galaxy bulge and disk light certainly does cause some uncertainty in our results. However, estimates of the size of this uncertainty do not appear large enough to be able to explain the finding of Section 6.3 that early-type spirals are more massive than those in late-type spirals. 7.3. Sample Biases 7.3.1. Selection for Spectroscopy and Population Fitting The results for the ages and masses of NCs discussed in Sections 6.2 and 6.3 pertain to those galaxies for which our STIS spectra had sufficient S/N for spectral population fitting. This biases systematically against faint NCs. Also, an explicit brightness cutoff was also applied in the selection of the NC sample for the STIS observations themselves (see Section 2). The luminosity and M/L of a stellar population depend systematically on age, in the sense that young populations are more luminous and have lower M/L. It is therefore likely that the paucity of faint clusters in our sample has introduced biases in the inferred age and mass distributions of the NCs. It is important to correct for these biases to obtain results that are representative for NCs as a class. Figure 10 shows histograms of the distribution of absolute NC magnitudes MF606W for early-type spirals. The top panel shows the distribution for all NCs detected by Carollo et al. (1998). The middle panel shows the histogram for the NCs which we have observed with HST/STIS. The bottom panel shows the histogram for those NCs for which we performed spectral population fitting. The average values of the distributions are: MF606W = −12.12 (WFPC2 sample; Carollo et al. (1998)), −12.79 (STIS sample), and −13.19 (spectral pop- ulation fitting sample). Figure 11 is similar to Figure 10, but shows the distributions for late-type spirals studied by Boker et al. (2002) as a function of absolute NC magnitude MI. The average values of these distributions are: MI = −11.68 (WFPC2 sample; Boker et al. (2002)), −12.29 (STIS sample), and −12.64 (spectral population fitting sample). Overall, our sample spans an interesting range of Hubble types and luminosities. However, Figures 10 and 11 show that the NCs for which we have performed spectral population fits are on aver- age ∼ 1.0 mag brighter than the average NC in a spiral galaxy, and they also sample a more limited range of brightness than would be found in a random sample of NCs. To translate the luminosity bias in our sample into a mass bias we need to know the average extinction, age and M/L for the faint clusters. However, without high S/N spectra -- 27 -- and spectral population fits these quantities are unknown. If age, M/L and extinction do not correlate with NC luminosity, then a bias of −1.0 mag in brightness simply corresponds to a bias of +0.4 in log M. However, this assumption need not be correct. It is therefore of interest to try to constrain observationally whether age, M/L and extinction correlate with NC luminosity. We explored this issue explicitly for those NCs for which we performed spectral population fits, but found no obvious trends. However, this is not a very stringent test of possible correlations. The NCs for which spectral population fits were performed cover a more limited range of luminosities than all NCs in spiral galaxies (see Figures 10 and 11). Therefore, subtle correlations might easily have been masked by the intrinsic scatter in the quantities of interest. The fact that we have measured B − V colors for all galaxies in our STIS sample (see Table 5), and not just the brightest ones, allows us to study potential correlations over a larger range of NC magnitudes. Figure 12 shows histograms of B − V for the NCs in our STIS sample for both early- and late-type spirals. Separate histograms are shown for the NCs that were bright enough for spectral population fitting (the NCs listed in Table 4) and those that were too faint (the NCs that are listed in Table 5 but not in Table 4). For the bright sub-sample the sample averages are B − V = 0.77 ± 0.08 for early-type spirals and B − V = 0.45±0.09 for late-type spirals. The fact that NCs in early-type spirals tend to have redder colors than those in late-type spirals was already hinted at in the HST study of V −H colors by Carollo et al. (2002) (see their Figure 6). This result is revealed more clearly by our sample because it contains many more late-type spirals. Our spectral population fitting has shown that this color difference is due primarily to a difference in age: NCs in early-type spirals are generally older than those in late-type spirals, while the dust extinction is similar. An interesting aspect of Figure 12 is the difference between the bright and faint sub- samples. For both early- and late-type spirals the distribution for the faint sub-sample is shifted towards redder colors as compared to the bright sub-sample. The shape of the distributions for the faint sub-samples also differs somewhat between the early- and late- type spirals. The faint NCs in late-type galaxies peak at about B − V ∼ 0.6 -- 0.9, with a small tail towards bluer colors. By contrast, the faint NCs in early-type spirals show a broader distribution. However, this is driven primarily by the unusually red colors for the NCs in NGC 5188 and NGC 6384. This could be primarily a signature of dust. An inspection of the HST/WFPC2 image in Carollo et al. (1998) for NGC 5188 reveals a very complex nuclear morphology including several dust lanes close to the nucleus, indicative of heavy extinction. To some lesser extent this also applies to NGC 6384. For early-type spirals the sample average for the faint sub-sample (for which no spectral population fits were performed) is B − V = 1.21 ± 0.20, compared to B − V = 0.77 ± 0.08 -- 28 -- for the bright sub-sample. The difference in color can be explained in several ways. For example, one can attribute the entire color difference to the effects of dust. In that case the faint sub-sample must on average have ∆AV = 1.36 ± 0.68 mag more extinction. That would also explain why the NCs in the faint sub-sample appear on average 1.2 mag fainter than those in the bright sub-sample. In this scenario, there is no need to assume that our NC mass and age estimates in Sections 6.2 and 6.3 are biased in any way. Alternatively, one can attribute the differences in color between the sub-samples to differences in age, because older populations are redder. However, even a population as old as a Hubble time is not as red as B − V = 1.21; for Z = 0.02 one has B − V = 0.98 and for Z = 0.05 one has B − V = 1.11 (Bruzual & Charlot 2003). So at least part of the color differences must be due to dust (as already mentioned, this is certainly plausible for NGC 5188 and NGC 6384). Either way, in this scenario the average hlog τiL = 9.23 that we derived for NCs in early-type spirals from spectral population fits is probably a lower limit. The NCs that were too faint to study could be as old as a Hubble time. A population as old as a Hubble time is ∼ 2.0 mag less luminous in the V -band than a population of the same mass with log τ = 9.23. For comparison, the NCs in the sample of Carollo et al. (1998) are on average only 1.0 mag fainter than those for which we have performed spectral population fits. So the difference in brightness could be due entirely to a difference in age. There need not be a difference in average mass amongst the bright and faint samples. For late-type spirals the sample average color for the faint sub-sample is B − V = 0.69±0.05, compared to B − V = 0.45±0.09 for the bright sub-sample. Again, this difference in color can be attributed either to a difference in dust extinction (∆AV = 0.74 ± 0.31) or a difference in age (∆ log τ = 0.41±0.12; based on Bruzual-Charlot models of solar metallicity, assuming an age hlog τiL = 8.37 for the brighter sub-sample, cf. Section 6.2). The difference in age would correspond to a difference in brightness of 0.55 mag in the I-band, for a population of fixed mass. Both scenarios would explain why the NCs in our faint sub-sample are on average 0.6 mag fainter than those in our bright sub-sample, without any need to invoke a difference in NC mass between the sub-samples. The average I-band absolute magnitude for our faint sub-sample is still 0.4 mag brighter than the average for all NCs in the Boker et al. (2002) sample. This, too, could be due to differences in dust absorption (∆AV = 0.85), age (∆ log τ = 0.30), mass (∆ log M = 0.16), or any combination thereof. While some difference in mass cannot be ruled out, a difference of ∆ log M = 0.16 would be no larger than the random uncertainties in our spectral population fitting sample averages (which are ∆ log M ≈ 0.2). Figure 12 shows differences in B − V color between the bright and faint NCs in our sample, and as discussed, this could be due to differences in either dust extinction or age. While in general it is difficult to discriminate between these alternative explanations, dif- -- 29 -- ferences in age could be the more plausible explanation. For the NCs that we have been able to study in detail, the amount of dust extinction was generally found to be quite small (Section 6.1). Figure 13 shows the correlation between hlog τiL and B − V for the NCs for which we performed spectral population fits (Table 4). It is clear that at least for this sub- sample the B − V color is almost uniquely an indicator of age, with older NCs having redder colors. Variations in dust extinction between the NCs add only a small amount of scatter to an otherwise very tight relation (the parameters of the best linear fit and the Spearman rank-order correlation coefficient are given in Table 6). As a result of our analysis of the B − V colors of the NCs we conclude that the inferred average ages discussed in Section 6.2 are probably biased in the sense that they are younger than the true average for all NCs in spiral galaxies. Depending on whether or not there is a systematic difference in dust extinction between faint and bright NCs, the bias might be anywhere in the range ∆ log τ = 0.0 -- 0.6 dex. For many early-type spirals this implies that the NC population need not be any younger than the galaxy itself. This is not generally true for NCs in late-type spirals. Even when a possible age-bias is accounted for, it remains true that most NCs in late-type spirals have average population ages significantly younger than a Hubble time. More generally, while there are some biases in our spectral population fitting results, none of these can account for the differences that we have found between NCs in early-type and late-type spirals. NCs in early-type spirals are older and more massive than those in late-type spirals. By contrast to our results for the cluster ages, we have found no evidence that the average NC masses, discussed in Section 6.3, are systematically biased due to our inability to spectroscopically analyze the populations of faint clusters. 7.3.2. Completeness of Imaging Surveys Another potential selection effect inherent to our work is that the original HST imaging surveys of Carollo et al. (1998) and Boker et al. (2002) may have been biased against the detection of faint clusters. Boker et al. (2002) found NCs in ∼ 75% of the galaxies in their HST imaging study of late-type spiral galaxies. The absolute magnitude distribution for these clusters showed a cutoff at MI ≈ −9. It was argued that this cutoff is real, based on the fact that clusters as faint as MI ≈ −8 could easily have been detected in all galaxies. Late-type spirals do not have prominent bulges making the detection of NCs relatively straightforward. On the other hand, no firm upper limits were set on the luminosity of potential clusters in the centers -- 30 -- of those galaxies where no cluster was detected. So it remains possible that some of these galaxies do host a NC, but that it simply was too faint to be detected. Carollo et al. (1998) found NCs in ∼ 50% of the galaxies in their HST imaging study of mostly early- and intermediate-type spiral galaxies. This should definitely be regarded as a lower limit. Due to their brighter bulges, NCs are more difficult to detect in early-type spirals than in late-type spirals. In several galaxies it was only possible for Carollo et al. (1998) to set an upper limit to the magnitude of any potential NC. In those cases, where the bulge had a very steep R1/4 profile, these upper limits were not particularly stringent. So it is possible that some of these galaxies do host a NC, but that it simply was too faint to be detected. As a corollary of this, there is actually no firm statistical ground to conclude that the prevalence of NCs is lower in early-type spirals than in late-type spirals. The possibility that some NCs might have gone undetected in the original imaging surveys is of some concern. On the other hand, there are two arguments that mitigate the potential impact of this on the interpretation of our results. First, the detection rate of NCs has been quite high in both early- and late-type spirals. Therefore, our results are probably representative at least for the majority of the NCs. So while our sample average NC properties could be biased towards higher luminosities and masses, the bias is not expected to be very large. Second, for those galaxies in which a NC has gone undetected in the imaging surveys it is not necessarily true that the NC must be atypically faint. Those galaxies might simply have had atypically bright or concentrated bulges, or unusually complicated or dusty morphologies. Therefore, our results may well be typical also for the NCs that reside in galaxies in which they were not detected. One of the more interesting findings of our work is the correlation of NC mass with Hubble type. One potential selection effect in this correlation is that low-mass clusters may have preferentially gone undetected in early-type spirals, as compared to the late-type spirals. In other words, NCs could reside in the bottom-left of Figure 9 that were not represented in our spectroscopic survey. But even so, there remains a clear distinction between the NC masses in early and late Hubble types. Many NCs in early-type spirals are quite massive, log MNC [M⊙] & 7, whereas such massive clusters are almost non-existent in late-type spirals. This is not a selection effect. There is no reason why massive NCs would not be detected in late-type spirals; they should in fact be the easiest to detect. Therefore, the absence of points in the upper-right part of Figure 9 is real. -- 31 -- 8. RELATION BETWEEN CLUSTER MASS AND GLOBAL GALAXY PROPERTIES An important finding of the WFPC2 study of Carollo et al. (1998) was that the NC luminosity (i.e. absolute magnitude) correlates with the host galaxy luminosity for early- type spirals. Boker et al. (2004) subsequently found a similar correlation for NCs in late-type spirals. Both studies find that more luminous galaxies tend to have more luminous NCs. However, the relations between these quantities are not the same for NCs in early-type and late-type spiral galaxies. They are offset and have a somewhat different slope. At fixed galaxy luminosity, NCs in early-type spirals tend to be more luminous than those in late- type spirals. This dependence on Hubble type was seen also in the study of Carollo et al. (2002), who concluded that NCs in early-type spirals can be significantly more luminous than those in late-type spirals. One of the advantages allowed by the present spectral population fitting study is that it yields the mass of the NCs, and not just their luminosity. The mass of a cluster is at some level a more fundamental quantity than its luminosity, because the latter can be unduly influenced by variations in stellar population age and dust extinction amongst galaxies. We therefore use the inferred cluster masses to revisit the previously established correlations amongst NC properties and galaxy properties. Figure 14 shows the relation between NC mass M (from Table 4) and total blue galaxy luminosity LB for the 19 galaxies for which we performed spectral population fits. The quantity LB was calculated from the apparent magnitude BT,0 (extinction- and K-corrected) listed in the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991) and the distances given in Tables 1 and 2. There is a correlation in the expected sense, with more luminous galaxies typically hosting more massive clusters. However, the correlation is not very strong, and is significant only with 92% confidence (see Table 6). One reason why the relation may appear weaker than those presented by Carollo et al. (1998) and Boker et al. (2004) is that those authors considered samples that covered a smaller range of Hubble types. Since NCs masses correlate strongly with Hubble type (see Figure 9), any sample that mixes a large range of Hubble types will present more scatter. Since NC luminosities and masses appear to depend strongly on both galaxy luminosity and Hubble type, it is useful to ask whether there is not one single global galaxy property with which NC mass correlates more strongly. If so, then that might be the more fundamental quantity that drives these correlations. The situation is reminiscent of that for the masses of black holes in galaxy centers. Those tend to be larger in bright galaxies than faint galaxies (e.g., M87 vs. M32) and tend to be larger in galaxies with big bulges than in those with small bulges (e.g., the Sombrero galaxy NGC 4594 vs. the Milky Way). It was realized that these -- 32 -- facts indicate that while black hole mass correlates only weakly with global galaxy properties such as Hubble type or luminosity, it correlates much more strongly with quantities that describe the bulge. In particular, tight correlations exist with bulge velocity dispersion (e.g., Tremaine et al. 2002), mass (e.g., Haring & Rix 2004) and luminosity (e.g., Marconi & Hunt 2003). For most of the galaxies in our sample we do not have access to either bulge veloc- ity dispersions or detailed disk-bulge decompositions. However, a rough estimate of the bulge-to-total light ratio for each galaxy can be obtained from its Hubble T -type (which we rounded to the nearest integer) using the correlations presented by Simien & de Vaucouleurs (1986). Of course, it should be kept in mind that these correlations have significant scatter. Moreover, the correlations are based on the assumption that the bulge can be described by an R1/4 surface brightness profile, which is suspect for very late Hubble types (Kormendy & Kennicutt 2004). Nonetheless, the bulge-to-total light ratios suggested by the correlations of Simien & de Vaucouleurs (1986) provides an useful low-order estimate. Upon multiplication by the total galaxy luminosity, LB, this yields an estimate for the bulge luminosity Lbul,B. Figure 15 shows the NC mass for the spectral population fitting sample as a function of the inferred Lbul,B. There is a clear trend of increasing NC mass M as a function of increasing bulge luminos- ity. The correlation is statistically significant at 99.99% confidence (see Table 6). The RMS scatter in M around the best fit is 0.72 dex. This is larger than the observational errors of 0.3 dex in our mass estimates (see Section 6.3), so there does appear to be a certain amount of intrinsic scatter in the correlation. The scatter in the correlation of cluster mass with bulge luminosity is similar to that for the correlation with Hubble type (0.61 dex, cf. Figure 9 and Table 6). Both correlations are tighter than that with total galaxy luminosity (Figure 14). The correlation with bulge luminosity is a combination of the correlations with Hubble type and with total galaxy luminosity; it takes into account both the general fact that early-type spirals have higher bulge-to-total luminosity ratios than late-type spirals, and the specific fact the early-type spirals in our sample are slightly more luminous than the late-type spirals in our sample (Figure 14). Some care must be taken in the interpretation of the correlation between NC mass M and Lbul,B. First of all, there might have been a selection effect against NCs in the bottom right of Figure 15, for the reasons discussed in Section 7.3.2. Second, the correlation between NC mass M and Lbul,B is not truly a one-to-one correlation. Probably not all spiral galaxies host NCs. Boker et al. (2002) found NCs in ∼ 75% of the galaxies in their HST imaging study of late-type spiral galaxies and Carollo et al. (1998) found NCs in ∼ 50% of the galaxies in their HST imaging study of mostly early- and intermediate-type spiral galaxies. Therefore, -- 33 -- there exist galaxies that have bulges, but no NCs. Conversely, some of the late-type spiral galaxies that host NCs do not appear to have a bulge. Simien & de Vaucouleurs (1986) perform disk-bulge decompositions for galaxies with Hubble types as late as Sd (T = 7), and our estimates of Lbul,B use their results. However, detailed analysis of HST images of galaxies with such late Hubble types indicates that some of these galaxies simply do not host bulges at all (Boker, Stanek & van der Marel 2003). This is even more true for galaxies of Hubble type Sm. For the two galaxies in Table 4 with this Hubble-type we assigned a bulge- to-total light ratio based on extrapolation of the fitting function of Simien & de Vaucouleurs (1986). However, the resulting values of Lbul,B should probably be considered upper limits (as indicated by arrows in Figure 15), since these galaxies likely do not have a bulge at all. The correlation of NC mass with bulge luminosity suggests that the global properties of the host galaxy play an important role in the formation process of NCs. There is evidence that the properties of both NCs and bulges depend sensitively on secular evolution processes in galaxy disks (Kormendy & Kennicutt 2004). The stellar populations of NCs are generally best fit as a mixture of populations of different ages (see Section 6.2). This indicates that NCs did not form in a single event, but instead they had additional star formation long after the oldest stars formed. This adds to other accumulating evidence that secular evolution plays an important role in shaping the central regions of spiral galaxies. Nonetheless, the physical processes that form bulges and NCs are overall still understood relatively poorly. While the results presented here provide useful new additional constraints, it is not currently clear what causes the observed differences in NC properties as a function of Hubble type. The present day NC mass is a function of many variables, including: the mass of the NC at its initial formation; the average mass that was added during each subsequent burst of star formation; the amount of time between bursts; and the number of bursts experienced since formation (which may or may not depend on the age of the galaxy). All of these variables might plausibly depend on the Hubble type. Scenarios with different combinations of these variables may all be able to explain the available data equally well. On the other hand, it is useful to note that some simple scenarios do appear to be ruled out by our data. For example, one might have postulated that the histories of NCs across the Hubble sequence are more of less identical except for the fact that some NCs have more frequent or more massive bursts of star formation than others. This would explain why some NCs are more massive than others. But one would then expect that high-mass clusters have average population ages that are equal to or younger than those in low-mass clusters. However, this is not observed. Figure 16 shows the relation between log M and hlog τiL (from Table 4) implied by our spectral population fitting results. Since both quantities individually correlate with Hubble type they also correlate with one another, in the sense that the NCs with the highest masses tend to have the oldest populations. Therefore, the differences in NC masses as a -- 34 -- function of Hubble type must involve more parameters than just variations in the mass and frequency of star formation bursts. For example, it is possible that NCs in early-type spirals simply form with higher masses than those in late-type spirals to begin with. The relation between NCs and the overall globular cluster systems of spiral galaxies remains at present unclear, but there could be connections. One formation mechanism for NCs is through the inspiral of globular clusters into the galactic center through dynamical friction. This process typically takes anywhere between a Gyr and a Hubble time (Milosavl- jevi´c 2004), which is not inconsistent with the inferred population ages of many of the NCs in our sample. The GCs of the Milky Way are almost uniformly more metal poor than the NCs analyzed in our sample. So in our Milky Way it is unlikely that one could form a NC from GCs. However, the GC system of the Milky Way is not representative of all other galaxies. Several galaxies are known with populations of metal rich GCs such as the LMC (Westerlund 1997) and NGC 5128 (Yi et al. 2004). Metallicity considerations by themselves therefore seem insufficient to validate this scenario. Also, it has previously been found that individual (globular) clusters in galaxies such as M33 follow a correlation between cluster mass M and population age hlog τiL that is not dissimilar to the correlation for NCs in Figure 16 (Chandar et al. 1999). It is not obvious whether these results are related, because individual star clusters are generally less massive (103−5 M⊙) than NCs and reside in a less dense environment. Nonetheless, it could indicate a commonality in the physical process that governs the formation of both types of clusters. Such a commonality is further supported by the finding that both types of cluster fall on the same fundamental plane relations (Walcher et al. 2005). Another important quantity that correlates strongly with the bulge luminosity is the mass MBH of supermassive black holes (BHs) in galactic nuclei. Marconi & Hunt (2003) collected accurate black hole mass determinations from a variety of sources and determined the best-fit linear correlations of log MBH vs. Lbul in various bands. While the correlation has its lowest scatter in the near-IR K-band, there is a clear correlation in the B-band as well. This correlation is overplotted as a dashed line in Figure 15. Its scatter is quoted by Marconi & Hunt (2003) as 0.48 dex. The slope of the relation is identical to within the statistical uncertainties to the slope of the relation between log MNC and Lbul,B. The latter correlation has a somewhat larger scatter though (0.72 dex, cf. Table 6). As mentioned previously, it should be kept in mind that not all spiral galaxies have NCs, while some have NCs but not bulges. On the other hand, these same things could be true for BHs as well. With well- known exceptions such as the Milky Way and NGC 4258, accurate BH mass determinations for spiral galaxies remain rather scarce (see e.g., Marconi et al. 2003; Atkinson et al. 2005). So we do not really know whether there exist some galaxies with bulges that do not host BHs. And we do know that some supermassive BHs (as revealed by AGN activity) exist in -- 35 -- very late-type galaxies such as the Sd spiral NGC 4395 (Filippenko & Ho 2003; Peterson et al. 2005) and the dE galaxy Pox 52 (Barth et al. 2004) that probably do not have bulges. Also, the globular cluster G1 which could have an intermediate-mass BH (e.g., Gebhardt et al. 2002, 2005) has been suggested to have been the NC of a (now disrupted) dwarf galaxy. Either way, it is not clear if there is a causal connection between the NCs and BHs that both seem to be common in (spiral) galaxies. Such a connection is not unimaginable, since star clusters have often been suggested as the source of the seed BHs that subsequently grow supermassive through merging or accretion (e.g., Portegies Zwart & McMillan 2002; van der Marel 2003). Comparison of the lines in Figure 15 suggests that at fixed bulge luminosity MNC ≈ 3.3 × MBH. However, this does not imply that NCs and BHs necessarily exist in the same galaxies. At present there are no individual galaxies for which both a NC mass determination and a secure BH mass determination exist. There are some galaxies with NCs that have BH mass upper limits (e.g., Boker et al. 1999; Gebhardt et al. 2001; Merritt et al. 2001). The most interesting limit exists for M33, which has MBH/MNC ≤ 10−2. The safest conclusion from the data available at the present time is that both the properties of NCs and BHs in the centers of spiral galaxies seem intimately connected to the properties of the host galaxy, and in particular its bulge component. 9. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS We obtained longslit spectra with HST/STIS of a sample of 40 NCs in spiral galaxies of both early and late Hubble types. The sample was selected from the HST/WFPC2 imaging studies of Carollo et al. (1998) and Boker et al. (2002), respectively. At a spatial resolution of ∼ 0.′′2 the spectra provide a much better separation of the NC from underlying bulge and disk light than is possible with ground-based spectra. For the 19 NCs with highest S/N we performed spectral fitting to analyze their stellar populations. A weighted superposition of single-age stellar population models from the spectral library of Bruzual & Charlot (2003) was fitted in a χ2 sense to the observed STIS spectra over the wavelength range from 3540 A to 5680 A. The models provide excellent fits to the data. They yield the star formation history of each NC, the B-band mass-to-light ratio M/LB, and the luminosity-weighted and mass-weighted mean population ages, hlog τiL and hlog τiM . We find the average uncertainty in the inferred age to be ∆hlog τiL . 0.3 dex. We used the spectra for all 40 targets to determine the NC luminosity LB in the B band (taking into account corrections for aperture losses), as well as the B − V color. The inferred luminosities are broadly consistent with those obtained from the HST/WFPC2 imaging studies. For the galaxies with spectral population fits we combined LB with the -- 36 -- inferred values of M/LB to estimate the NC mass MNC. We find the average uncertainty in the inferred mass to be ∆MNC . 0.3 dex. The inferred masses agree with dynamical mass measurements for the few NCs in our sample for which such measurements are available. The metallicity Z and dust extinction AV were varied to optimize the spectral population fits. In general the NC metallicities are close to solar, but they tend to be somewhat higher in early- than in late-type spirals. The average extinction towards the NCs is relatively low, ¯AV = 0.3 -- 0.4, and does not differ much between early- and late-type spirals. Tests showed that uncertainties in the assumed values of Z and AV do not significantly affect the inferred population ages. The best spectral fits generally contain a mixture of populations of different ages. Ap- proximately 53% of the NCs contain a population younger than 1 Gyr. The NCs show a wide range of luminosity-weighted ages, ranging from 10 Myrs to 10 Gyrs. On average, NCs in late-type spirals are younger than in early-type spirals (hlog τiL = 8.37±0.25 vs. 9.23±0.21). For both galaxy types the NC age is less than the typical age of galactic disks. The stellar populations of NCs are generally best fit as a mixture of populations of different ages (see Section 6.2). This indicates that NCs did not form in a single event, but instead they had additional star formation long after the oldest stars formed. The average mass-weighted ages are considerably older than the luminosity-weighted ages, typically by ∼ 0.7 dex. So there often is an underlying older population that does not contribute much light, but does contain most of the mass. The average NC masses are smaller in late-type spirals than in early-type spirals (log M = 6.25 ± 0.21 vs. 7.63 ± 0.24). For both galaxy types the NCs are much more massive than typical globular clusters in the Milky Way. However, the lowest NC masses overlap with the high-mass end of the globular cluster mass distribution in some other galaxies. We presented a detailed discussion of various systematic effects that might have influ- enced our results, including contamination from AGN emission, uncertainties in the subtrac- tion of underlying bulge and disk light, and sample biases. Each of these probably play a role at some level. However, we argued that none of them can explain the differences that we find between NCs in early- and late-type spirals. The primary impact of sample biases is that the average NC ages for our sample might be lower than they would have been for an unbiased NC sample. This is because older NCs are fainter and are therefore less likely to yield sufficient S/N for spectral population fitting. However, based on a joint analysis of luminosities and B − V colors (available for all the NCs in our STIS sample, even those with low S/N spectra) we found no evidence that the inferred NC masses are necessarily biased. -- 37 -- Our findings are broadly consistent with those obtained in other recent spectroscopic studies of NCs, in particular those of Walcher et al. (2005, 2006) and Sarzi et al. (2005). The primary new contribution of the present work is the added insight about the variations in NC properties as a function of Hubble type. This particular issue was addressed previously by Carollo et al. (2002). They found that NCs in early-type spirals have a higher average luminosity than those in late-type spirals. Our work shows that this is not because NCs in early-type spirals are younger. To the contrary, we actually find them to be older. Therefore, NCs in early-type spirals are not just more luminous than those in late-type spirals, but also more massive. The NC mass MNC correlates loosely with total galaxy luminosity. It correlates more strongly with both the Hubble type of the galaxy and the luminosity of the host galaxy bulge. But it should be kept in mind that not all spiral galaxies necessarily have a bulge or a NC. Also, the correlations do have considerable scatter (0.6 -- 0.7 dex in log MNC at a fixed Hubble type or bulge luminosity). The correlation of log MNC with bulge luminosity is particularly intriguing because it has the same slope as the well-known correlation between supermassive black hole mass MBH and bulge luminosity. At fixed bulge luminosity the correlations predict MNC ≈ 3.3 × MBH. This does not imply that NCs and black holes necessarily exist in the same galaxies, so the implications of this relation remain unclear. However, it does appear that the properties of both NCs and black holes in the centers of spiral galaxies are intimately connected to the properties of the host galaxy, and in particular to its bulge component. Support for proposals #9070 and #9783 was provided by NASA through a grant from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5-26555. We thank the anonymous referee for suggestions that helped improving the presentation of the paper. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED) which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. We also made use of the Lyon Extragalactic Database (LEDA). -- 38 -- REFERENCES Abadi, M. G., Navarro, J. F., Steinmetz, M., & Eke, V. R. 2003, ApJ, 597, 21 Asplund, M., Grevesse, N., & Sauval, A. J. 2005, in: Cosmic abundances as records of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis in honor of David L. Lambert, ed. T. G. Barnes III & F. N. Bash, ASP Conference Series Vol. 336, p. 25 Athanassoula, E. 1992a, MNRAS, 259, 328 Athanassoula, E. 1992b, MNRAS, 259, 345 Atkinson, J. W., et al. 2005, MNRAS, 359, 504 Barth, A. J., Ho, L. C., Rutledge, R. E., & Sargent, W. L. W. 2004, ApJ, 607, 90 Binney, J., Dehnen, W., & Bertelli, G. 2000, MNRAS, 318, 658 Bessell, M. S., Castelli, F., & Plez, B. 1998, A&A, 333, 231 Binggeli, B., Sandage, A., & Tammann, G. A. 1988, ARA&A, 26, 509 Binney, J. J., & Merrifield, M. 1998, Galactic Astronomy (Princeton: Princeton University Press) Boker, T., van der Marel, R. P., & Vacca, W. D. 1999, AJ, 118, 831 Boker, T., van der Marel, R. P., Mazzuca, L., Rix, H.-W., Rudnick, G., Ho, L. C., & Shields, J. C. 2001, AJ, 121, 1473 Boker, T., Laine, S., van der Marel, R. P., Sarzi, M., Rix, H.-W., Ho, L. C., & Shields, J. C. 2002, AJ, 123, 1389 Boker, T., Stanek, R., & van der Marel, R. P. 2003, AJ, 125, 1073 Boker, T., van der Marel, R. P., Gerssen, J., Walcher, C. J., Rix, H.-W., Shields, J. C., & Ho, L. C. 2003, SPIE, 4834, 57 Boker, T., Sarzi, M., McLaughlin, D. E., van der Marel, R. P., Rix, H.-W., Ho, L. C., & Shields, J. C. 2004, AJ, 127, 105 Bohlin, R. C., & Gilliland, R. L. 2004, AJ, 127, 3508 Bruzual, G., & Charlot, S. 2003, MNRAS, 344, 1000 -- 39 -- Cardelli, J. A., Clayton, G. C., & Mathis, J. S. 1989, ApJ, 345, 245 Carollo, C. M., Stiavelli, M., de Zeeuw, P. T., & Mack, J. 1997, AJ, 114, 2366 Carollo, C. M., Stiavelli, M., & Mack, J. 1998, AJ, 116, 68 Carollo, C. M. 1999, ApJ, 523, 566 Carollo, C. M., Stiavelli, M., de Zeeuw, P. T., Seigar, M., & Dejonghe, H. 2001, ApJ, 546, 216 Carollo, C. M., Stiavelli, M., Seigar, M., de Zeeuw, P. T., & Dejonghe, H. 2002, AJ, 123, 159 Chabrier, G. 2003, PASP, 115, 763 Chandar, R., Bianchi, L., & Ford, H. C. 1999, ApJ, 517, 668 Courteau, S., de Jong, R. S., & Broeils, A. H. 1996, ApJ, 457, L73 de Jong, R. S. 1996, A&AS, 118, 557 de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H., Buta, R. J., Paturel, G., & Fouque, P. 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies, (New York: Springer-Verlag) Devereux, N. A., Becklin, E. E., & Scoville, N. 1987, ApJ, 312, 529 Filippenko, A. V., & Ho, L. C. 2003, ApJ, 588, L13 Freedman, W. L., Madore, B. F., Hawley, S. L., Horowitz, I. K., Mould, J., Navarrete, M., & Sallmen, S. 1992, ApJ, 396, 80 Gebhardt, K., et al. 2001, AJ, 122, 2469 Gebhardt, K., Rich, R. M., & Ho, L. C. 2002, ApJ, 578, L41 Gebhardt, K., Rich, R. M., & Ho, L. C. 2005, ApJ, 634, 1093 Geha, M., Guhathakurta, P., & van der Marel, R. P. 2002, AJ, 124, 3073 Haring, N. & Rix, H.-W. 2004, ApJ, 604, L89 Harris, W. E. 1991, ARA&A, 29, 543 Ha¸segan, M., et al. 2005, ApJ, 627, 203 Ho, L. C., Filippenko, A. V., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1997, ApJ, 487, 568 -- 40 -- Holtzman, J. A., Burrows, C. J., Casertano, S., Hester, J. J., Trauger, J. T., Watson, A. M., & Worthey, G. 1995, PASP, 107, 1065 Kennicutt, R. C., Jr. 1983, ApJ, 272, 54 Kennicutt, R. C., Jr. 1998, ARA&A, 36, 189 Kim Quijano, J., et al. 2003, STIS Instrument Handbook, Version 7.0, (Baltimore: STScI). Knox, R. A., Hawkins, M. R. S., & Hambly, N. C. 1999, MNRAS, 306, 736 Kormendy, J., & McClure, R. D. 1993, AJ, 105, 1793 Kormendy, J., & Kennicutt, R. C., Jr. 2004, ARA&A, 42, 603 Lauberts, A., & Valentijn, E. A. 1989, The surface photometry catalogue of the ESO-Uppsala galaxies, (Garching: European Southern Observatory) Lawson, C. L., & Hanson, R. J. 1974, Solving Least Squares Problems (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall) Long, K. S., Charles, P. A., & Dubus, G. 2002, ApJ, 569, 204 Maraston, C., Bastian, N., Saglia, R. P., Kissler-Patig, M., Schweizer, F., & Goudfrooij, P. 2004, A&A, 416, 467 Marconi, A., & Hunt, L. K. 2003, ApJ, 589, L21 Marconi, A., et al. 2003, ApJ, 586, 868 Martini, P., & Ho, L. C. 2004, ApJ, 610, 233 Matthews, L. D., et al. 1999, AJ, 118, 208 McCrady, N., Gilbert, A. M., & Graham, J. R. 2003, ApJ, 596, 240 Mengel, S., Lehnert, M. D., Thatte, N., & Genzel, R. 2002, A&A, 383, 137 Merritt, D., Ferrarese, L., & Joseph, C. L. 2001, Science, 293, 1116 Meylan, G. 2002, in: Extragalactic Star Clusters, IAU Symp. 207, ed. D. Geisler, E. K. Grebel, and D. Minniti. (San Francisco: ASP), p. 555 Meylan, G., Sarajedini, A., Jablonka, P., Djorgovski, S. G., Bridges, T., & Rich, R. M. 2001, AJ, 122, 830 -- 41 -- Milosavljevi´c, M. 2004, ApJ, 605, L13 Nilson, P. 1973, Uppsala General Catalogue of Galaxies, (Uppsala: Uppsala Astronomiska Observatorium) Norman, C. A., Sellwood, J. A., & Hasan, H. 1996, ApJ, 462, 114 Peterson, B. M., et al. 2005, ApJ, 632, 799 Phillips, A. C., Illingworth, G. D., MacKenty, J. W., & Franx, M. 1996, AJ, 111, 1566 Pogge, R. W., Maoz, D., Ho, L. C., & Eracleous, M. 2000, ApJ, 532, 323 Portegies Zwart, S. F., & McMillan, S. L. W. 2002, ApJ, 576, 899 Press, W. H., Teukolsky, S. A., Vetterling, W. T., & Flannery, B. P. 1992, Numerical Recipes (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Rieke, G. H., & Lebofsky, M. J. 1985, ApJ, 288, 618 Rix, H.-W., & White, S. D. M. 1992, MNRAS, 254, 389 Sandage, A., & Tammann, G. A. 1990, ApJ, 365, 1 Sarzi, M., Rix, H.-W., Shields, J. C., Ho, L. C., Barth, A. J., Rudnick, G., Filippenko, A. V., & Sargent, W. L. W. 2005, ApJ, 628, 169 Schlegel D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525 Simien, F., & de Vaucouleurs, G. 1986, ApJ, 302, 564 Tremaine, S., et al. 2002, ApJ, 574, 740 van der Marel, R. P. 1994, MNRAS, 270, 271 van der Marel, R. P., de Zeeuw, P. T., & Rix, H.-W. 1997, ApJ, 488, 119 van der Marel, R. P. 2003, in: The Astrophysics of Gravitational Wave Sources, ed. J. M. Centrella, AIP Conference Proceedings, Vol. 686, p. 115 Walcher, C. J., van der Marel, R. P., McLaughlin, D. E., Rix, H.-W., Boker, T., Haring, N., Ho, L. C., Sarzi, M., & Shields, J. C. 2005, ApJ, 618, 237 Walcher, C. J., Boker, T., Charlot, S., Ho, L. C., Rix, H.-W., Rossa, J., Shields, J. C., & van der Marel, R. P. 2006, ApJ, submitted -- 42 -- Westerlund, B. E. 1997, The Magellanic Clouds, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) Whitmore, B. C., Zhang, Q., Leitherer, C., Fall, S. M., Schweizer, F., & Miller, B. W. 1999, AJ, 118, 1551 Wyse, R. F. G., Gilmore, G., & Franx, M. 1997, ARA&A, 35, 637 Yi, S. K., Peng, E., Ford, H., Kaviraj, S., & Yoon, S.-J. 2004, MNRAS, 349, 1493 Young, J. S., & Scoville, N. Z. 1991, ARA&A, 29, 581 Zaritsky, D., Kennicutt, R. C., Jr., & Huchra, J. P. 1994, ApJ, 420, 87 Zhang, Q., & Fall, S. M. 1999, ApJ, 527, L81 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2. -- 43 -- Fig. 1. -- HST/STIS spectra of the NCs (black), overlaid with the best spectral population fits (red) obtained as described in the text. Characteristic properties of the fits are listed in Table 4. The spectra are sorted (from left to right and from top to bottom) in order of increasing luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL, with galaxy names indicated in the individual sub-panels. -- 44 -- Fig. 1. -- (continued) -- 45 -- Fig. 1. -- (continued) -- 46 -- Fig. 1. -- (continued) -- 47 -- Fig. 2. -- Dependence of the best-fit derived luminosity-weighted ages as a function of the extinction AV for all 19 NCs. Results for the same NC at different extinction are connected by a line. Age uncertainties due to uncertainties in extinction are relatively small and are much less than the variation in age from cluster to cluster. The extinction range shown is 0.0 to 0.6, which contains the best-fit extinction for most of the galaxies in the sample (see Table 4). -- 48 -- Fig. 3. -- Dependence of the best-fit derived luminosity-weighted ages as a function of the metallicity Z for all 19 NCs. Results for the same NC at different metallicity are connected by a line. -- 49 -- Fig. 4. -- Histogram of the distribution of the best-fitting nuclear cluster metallicities Z listed in Table 4. The metallicities were obtained from spectral population fits to the STIS spectra. The top panel shows the distribution for the ten early-type spirals, the middle panel shows the distribution for the nine late-type spirals, and the bottom panel shows the distribution for the combined sample of all 19 galaxies. The discrete sampling along the horizontal axis reflects the fact that Bruzual-Charlot models are available only for a fixed set of metallicities. -- 50 -- Fig. 5. -- Histogram of the distribution of the best-fitting extinction AV listed in Table 4. The extinction values were obtained from spectral population fits to the STIS spectra. The top panel shows the distribution for the ten early-type spirals, the middle panel shows the distribution for the nine late-type spirals, and the bottom panel shows the distribution for the combined sample of all 19 galaxies. -- 51 -- Fig. 6. -- Histogram of the distribution of the luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL listed in Table 4. The ages were obtained from spectral population fits to the STIS spectra. The top panel shows the distribution for the ten early-type spirals, the middle panel shows the distribution for the nine late-type spirals, and the bottom panel shows the distribution for the combined sample of all 19 galaxies. -- 52 -- Fig. 7. -- Relation between the luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL listed in Table 4 and the Hubble T-type of the host galaxy (Tables 1 and 2). The ages were obtained from spectral population fits to the STIS spectra and were assigned a measurement uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussion in Section 4.3. Hubble T-types were, somewhat arbitrarily, assigned an uncertainty of 1.0. Early-type spirals tend to have older NC populations. The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. -- 53 -- Fig. 8. -- Histogram of the distribution of log M, the logarithm of the NC mass in solar units, as listed in Table 4. The masses were obtained by taking the product of the mass-to- light ratios inferred from spectral population fits to the STIS spectra, and the luminosities directly measured from the STIS spectra (corrected for extinction and aperture losses). The top panel shows the distribution for the ten early-type spirals, the middle panel shows the distribution for the nine late-type spirals, and the bottom panel shows the distribution for the combined sample of all 19 galaxies. -- 54 -- Fig. 9. -- Relation between the NC mass M listed in Table 4 and the Hubble T-type of the host galaxy (Tables 1 and 2). Masses were assigned a measurement uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussion in Section 6.3. Hubble T-types were, somewhat arbitrarily, assigned an uncertainty of 1.0. Early-type spirals tend to have more massive NCs. The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. -- 55 -- Fig. 10. -- Histogram of the absolute NC magnitudes in early-type spirals. The magnitude MF606W is measured in the VEGAMAG system of the WFPC2/F606W filter (similar to the V -band). It was calculated from the published mF606W values listed in Table 1. The top panel shows the distribution for all NCs detected by Carollo et al. (1998). The middle panel shows the histogram for the NCs which we have observed with HST/STIS. The bottom panel shows the histogram for those NCs for which we performed spectral population fits. -- 56 -- Fig. 11. -- Histogram of the absolute I-band NC magnitudes MI in late-type spirals, calcu- lated from the published mI values listed in Table 2. The top panel shows the distribution for all NCs detected by Boker et al. (2002). The middle panel shows the histogram for the NCs which we have observed with HST/STIS. The bottom panel shows the histogram for those NCs for which we performed spectral population fits. -- 57 -- Fig. 12. -- Histograms of the B − V distribution for early- and late-type spirals. The left panels present the early-type sample above (top panel) and below (bottom panel) our selected magnitude cutoff. The right panels depict the late-type sample above (top panel) and below (bottom panel) our selected magnitude cutoff. -- 58 -- Fig. 13. -- Correlation between the luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL, as inferred from spec- tral population fits to our STIS spectra, and broadband color B − V . Age measurements were assigned an uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussion in Section 4.3. The B − V color increases with increasing age of the NC. Open symbols denote NCs in early-type spirals and solid symbols denote NCs in late-type spirals. The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. -- 59 -- Fig. 14. -- Relation between the NC mass M listed in Table 4 and the total B-band luminos- ity LB of the host galaxy. Masses were assigned a measurement uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussion in Section 6.3. The measurement uncertainties in LB are not well known, and were somewhat arbitrarily assigned a value of 0.1 dex. There is a weak correlation in the sense that more luminous galaxies have more massive NCs. Open symbols denote early-type spirals and solid symbols denote late-type spirals. The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. -- 60 -- Fig. 15. -- Relation between the NC mass M (listed in Table 4) and the B-band luminosity Lbul,B of the host galaxy bulge. Masses were assigned a measurement uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussion in Section 6.3. The measurement uncertainties in Lbul,B are dom- inated by variations in disk-to-bulge ratios among galaxies, and were somewhat arbitrarily assigned a value of 0.25 dex. There is a strong correlation in the sense that galaxies with more luminous bulges have more massive NCs. Open symbols denote early-type spirals and solid symbols denote late-type spirals. For the very late-type spirals NGC 428 and NGC 2552 we assigned a bulge-to-total light ratio based on the extrapolation of the fitting function of Simien & de Vaucouleurs (1986). Therefore, the resulting values of Lbul,B for these two cases should be considered as upper limits (indicated by arrows). The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. The dashed line indicates the relation between the BH mass MBH and B-band luminosity Lbul,B for all galaxies studied by Marconi & Hunt (2003). -- 61 -- Fig. 16. -- Correlation between the NC mass M and the luminosity-weighted age hlog τiL (listed in Table 4). Both quantities were assigned a measurement uncertainty of 0.3 dex, based on the discussions in Sections 4.3 and 6.3. More massive clusters tend to have older stellar populations (and tend to reside in earlier-type spirals) than less massive clusters. Open symbols denote NCs in early-type spirals and solid symbols denote NCs in late-type spirals. The solid line indicates the best linear fit, the parameters of which are listed in Table 6. -- 62 -- Table 1. Early-type Spiral Galaxy Sample Galaxy R.A. Dec. Classification T [hh mm ss.ss] [dd◦mm′ss.′′s] vsys [km s−1] (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) D [Mpc] (7) AV [mag] (8) mF606W MF606W [mag] (9) [mag] (10) NGC 1325 NGC 1385 NGC 2082 NGC 3177 NGC 3277 NGC 3455 NGC 4030 NGC 4806 NGC 4980 NGC 5188 NGC 5377 NGC 5806 NGC 6384 NGC 7421 NGC 7690 03 24 25.20 03 37 28.32 05 41 51.21 10 16 34.21 10 32 55.50 10 54 31.07 12 00 23.65 12 56 12.67 13 09 10.24 13 31 28.46 13 56 16.79 15 00 00.30 17 32 24.30 22 56 54.00 23 33 02.60 −21 32 32.8 −24 30 04.2 −64 18 04.0 +21 07 24.8 +28 30 42.0 +17 17 06.2 +01 06 03.3 −29 30 13.8 −28 38 30.8 −34 47 44.0 +47 14 17.2 +01 53 29.0 +07 03 38.0 −37 20 51.0 −51 41 52.0 SA(s)bc SB(s)cd SAB(rs+)c SA(rs)b SA(r)ab (R')SAB(rs)b SA(s)bc SB(s)c? SAB(rs)a pec? (R':)SAB(rs)b (R)SB(s)a SAB(s)b SAB(r)bc SB(r)bc Sb 4.2 5.7 3.2 3.0 1.9 3.2 4.1 4.9 1.0 3.1 1.1 3.3 3.8 4.0 2.9 1414 1305 942 1392 1539 1185 1476 2350 1329 2301 2036 1440 1780 1662 1281 20.2 18.6 13.5 19.9 22.0 16.9 21.1 33.6 19.0 32.9 29.1 20.6 25.4 23.7 18.3 0.072 0.067 0.192 0.074 0.088 0.110 0.087 0.285 0.237 0.173 0.054 0.169 0.409 0.049 0.035 20.0 19.0 20.9 17.1 17.2 20.1 19.3 20.8 20.2 19.2 16.5 18.6 19.6 19.0 18.0 −11.60 −12.41 −09.94 −14.47 −14.60 −11.15 −12.41 −12.12 −11.43 −13.56 −15.87 −13.14 −12.83 −12.92 −13.35 Note. -- Column (1) lists the galaxy name. Columns (2) and (3) list the right ascension and declination (J2000.0) from the NASA Extragalactic Database (NED). Column (4) lists the morphological classification given by NED and column (5) lists the Hubble T-type taken from the Lyon Extragalactic Database (LEDA). Much of the information in Columns (4)+(5) relies on the information given by the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991) as its primary source. Column (6) lists the systemic velocity corrected for Virgocentric infall using the model of Sandage & Tammann (1990), as taken from LEDA. Column (7) lists the corresponding distance for a Hubble constant H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1. Column (8) lists the Galactic foreground extinction (Schlegel et al. 1998) in the V -band for RV = 3.1 from NED. Column (9) lists observed apparent magnitude mF606W of the nuclear cluster in the WFPC2 F606W filter, as given by Carollo et al. (1998). Column (10) lists the corresponding absolute magnitude corrected for foreground extinction. -- 63 -- Table 2. Late-type Spiral Galaxy Sample Galaxy R.A. Dec. Classification T [hh mm ss.ss] [dd◦mm′ss.′′s] vsys [km s−1] (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) D [Mpc] (7) AI [mag] (8) mI [mag] (9) MI [mag] (10) NGC 300 NGC 428 NGC 450 ESO 358−5 NGC 1493 NGC 2139 UGC 3574 NGC 2552 NGC 2805 NGC 3346 NGC 3423 NGC 3445 A 1156+52 NGC 4411B NGC 4540 NGC 4618 NGC 4625 NGC 4701 NGC 4775 NGC 5068 NGC 5585 NGC 5668 NGC 5964 NGC 6509 UGC 12732 00 54 53.72 01 12 55.16 01 15 30.29 03 27 16.47 03 57 27.73 06 01 08.44 06 53 10.57 08 19 20.25 09 20 20.38 10 43 38.70 10 51 13.25 10 54 35.87 11 59 08.57 12 26 47.28 12 34 50.92 12 41 32.50 12 41 52.95 12 49 11.60 12 53 46.29 13 18 55.24 14 19 47.90 14 33 24.89 15 37 36.33 17 59 24.92 23 40 39.80 −37 40 56.9 +00 58 58.7 −00 51 40.9 −33 29 06.1 −46 12 38.1 −23 40 24.4 +57 10 44.6 +50 00 27.2 +64 06 12.2 +14 52 17.9 +05 50 31.3 +56 59 24.4 +52 42 26.1 +08 53 02.0 +15 33 09.6 +41 09 03.0 +41 16 26.8 +03 23 19.0 −06 37 27.1 −21 02 21.5 +56 43 46.0 +04 27 01.7 +05 58 28.2 +06 17 12.1 +26 14 10.0 SA(s)d SAB(s)m SBc SAB(s)m pec: SB(rs)cd SAB(rs)cd SA(s)cd SA(s)m? SAB(rs)d SB(rs)cd SA(s)cd SAB(s)m SB(rs)cd SAB(s)cd SAB(rs)cd SB(rs)m SAB(rs)m pec SA(s)cd SA(s)d SB(s)d SAB(s)d SA(s)d SB(rs)d SBcd Sm: 6.9 8.2 6.0 8.7 6.0 5.8 5.9 8.9 7.0 5.9 6.0 8.7 6.0 5.9 6.0 8.4 8.7 5.6 6.8 6.2 6.9 6.7 6.7 7.0 8.8 −54 1130 1720 1409 796 1649 1635 695 1968 1315 1025 2245 1307 1334 1383 748 816 768 1565 607 571 1665 1552 1926 870 2.2 16.1 24.6 20.1 11.4 23.6 23.4 9.9 28.1 18.8 14.6 32.1 18.7 19.1 19.8 10.7 11.7 11.0 22.4 8.7 8.2 23.8 22.2 27.5 12.4 0.025 0.055 0.077 0.022 0.020 0.065 0.103 0.090 0.100 0.054 0.058 0.015 0.053 0.058 0.065 0.041 0.035 0.057 0.067 0.197 0.030 0.071 0.113 0.375 0.172 15.29 −11.43 17.94 −13.15 20.07 −11.96 20.09 −11.45 17.17 −13.13 19.09 −12.83 19.97 −11.98 18.04 −12.04 19.02 −13.33 19.64 −11.78 19.03 −11.85 19.10 −13.45 20.43 −10.98 18.88 −12.58 19.25 −12.29 18.73 −11.46 19.74 −10.63 16.80 −13.46 18.04 −13.78 17.54 −12.34 18.24 −11.35 18.85 −13.10 19.21 −12.63 19.48 −13.09 19.35 −11.29 Note. -- Column (1) lists the galaxy name. The galaxy A 1156+52 is also known as UGC 6983. Columns (2) and (3) list the right ascension and declination (J2000.0) from NED. Column (4) lists the morphological classification given by NED, except for NGC 450 which was taken from LEDA. Column (5) lists the Hubble T-type taken from LEDA. Much of the information in Columns (4)+(5) relies on the information given by the RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991) as its primary source. Column (6) lists the systemic velocity corrected for Virgocentric infall using the model of Sandage & Tammann (1990), as taken from LEDA. Column (7) lists the corresponding distance for a Hubble constant H0 = 70 km s−1 Mpc−1. The value for NGC 300 has been taken from Freedman et al. (1992). Column (8) lists the Galactic foreground extinction (Schlegel et al. 1998) in the I-band using the Cardelli et al. (1989) extinction law and RV = 3.1, from NED. Column (9) lists observed apparent magnitude mI of the nuclear cluster in the I-band from Boker et al. (2004). Column (10) lists the corresponding absolute magnitude corrected for foreground extinction. -- 64 -- Table 3. Journal of HST/STIS G430L Observations Galaxy Data set identifier Observation Date Integration Time hS/N i (1) (2) [mm-dd-yyyy] (3) NGC 300 NGC 428 NGC 450 NGC 1325 ESO 358−5 NGC 1385 NGC 1493 NGC 2082 NGC 2139 UGC 3574 NGC 2552 NGC 2805 NGC 3177 NGC 3277 NGC 3346 NGC 3423 NGC 3455 NGC 3445 A 1156+52 NGC 4030 NGC 4411B NGC 4540 NGC 4618 NGC 4625 NGC 4701 NGC 4775 NGC 4806 NGC 4980 NGC 5068 NGC 5188 NGC 5377 NGC 5585 NGC 5668 NGC 5806 NGC 5964 NGC 6384 NGC 6509 NGC 7421 NGC 7690 UGC 12732 o6dz02 o6dz03 o6dz38 o8nb02 o6dz37 o8nb03 o6dz10 o8nb04 o6dz35 o6dz05 o6dz06 o6dz08 o8nb05 o8nb06 o6dz07 o6dz12 o8nb07 o6dz13 o6dz14 o8nb58 o8nb01 o6dz19 o6dz20 o6dz36 o6dz21 o6dz22 o8nb09 o8nb10 o6dz23 o8nb11 o8nb12 o6dz25 o6dz26 o8nb13 o6dz27 o8nb14 o6dz29 o8nb15 o8nb16 o6dz32 04-20-2002 08-23-2001 10-31-2001 06-27-2003 02-06-2002 08-02-2003 12-12-2001 07-30-2003 04-10-2002 04-15-2002 09-26-2001 02-28-2002 06-24-2003 06-23-2003 04-10-2002 02-28-2002 06-27-2003 11-02-2001 12-20-2001 04-15-2004 06-26-2003 05-03-2002 04-11-2002 11-26-2001 12-11-2001 04-19-2002 06-25-2003 07-30-2003 04-19-2002 07-31-2003 06-28-2003 08-29-2001 02-27-2002 06-27-2003 02-21-2002 07-13-2003 08-30-2001 06-26-2003 06-29-2003 08-30-2001 [s] (4) 900 900 900 2140 900 2180 900 2300 900 900 900 900 2200 2200 900 900 2140 900 900 2180 2180 900 900 900 900 900 2100 2140 900 2200 2300 900 900 2180 900 2140 900 2200 2340 900 (5) 24.5 7.7 1.3 4.9 1.2 28.3 31.4 2.4 15.5 1.2 9.6 4.1 51.0 30.8 1.9 3.7 5.1 2.9 1.6 21.0 7.5 1.7 1.2 1.8 26.7 8.3 2.0 4.1 4.4 3.7 57.2 8.9 4.3 11.9 2.8 5.2 2.9 12.1 36.6 1.8 Note. -- Col. (1) lists the host galaxy name. Col. (2) lists the data set identifier in the HST Data Archive. Col. (3) and (4) list the date of the observations and the total exposure time. Col. (5) lists the signal to noise (S/N ) per pixel in the logarithmically rebinned disk-subtracted spectrum. -- 65 -- Table 4. NC Properties from Spectral Population Fits and Derived Masses Galaxy (1) Z (2) AV [mag] (3) hlog τ iL hlog τ iM M/LB (4) (5) (6) [M⊙/LB,⊙] χ2 red (7) log M [M⊙] (8) NGC 1325 NGC 1385 NGC 3177 NGC 3277 NGC 3455 NGC 4030 NGC 5377 NGC 5806 NGC 7421 NGC 7690 NGC 300 NGC 428 NGC 1493 NGC 2139 NGC 2552 NGC 4411B NGC 4701 NGC 4775 NGC 5585 0.008 0.008 0.05 0.05 0.02 0.05 0.02 0.02 0.05 0.02 0.004 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.05 0.008 0.02 0.004 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.0 1.4 0.0 0.2 0.6 0.0 0.1 0.4 0.1 0.0 0.1 0.5 0.8 0.4 0.5 0.7 9.98 8.08 9.21 9.65 8.51 9.83 8.63 10.20 9.01 9.19 8.63 9.22 7.74 6.97 7.79 8.76 8.27 9.25 8.73 10.13 9.01 10.05 10.24 9.48 10.28 10.13 10.30 9.14 10.13 9.62 9.65 8.72 7.74 8.87 8.85 9.00 10.04 9.14 3.65 0.12 2.72 8.18 0.57 8.96 1.39 7.97 0.74 2.12 0.51 1.18 0.12 0.02 0.17 0.36 0.17 1.87 0.26 2.19 3.02 9.37 5.89 2.26 3.66 3.28 2.42 2.80 2.58 3.46 2.42 2.95 3.03 2.84 2.35 3.49 3.56 3.06 7.08 6.39 8.15 8.34 6.75 7.99 8.63 8.11 6.87 7.98 5.68 6.71 6.18 5.43 5.77 6.53 6.53 7.60 5.80 Note. -- Column (1) lists the galaxy name. Columns (2) and (3) list the metallicity and extinction that give the best fit to the observed spectrum. Columns (4) and (5) list the luminosity-weighted and mass-weighted average value of log τ for the best spectral population fit, where τ is the population age in years. Column (6) lists the B-band mass-to-light ratio for the NCs in solar units. Column (7) gives the χ2 per degree of freedom of the fit. Column (8) lists the NC masses, which were calculated from the M/L ratio, the B-magnitude, and from the best-fitted extinction. The horizontal line divides the NCs in early-type spirals (above the line) from those in late-type spirals (below the line). -- 66 -- Table 5. Photometric Properties of the NCs in Early- and Late-type Spirals Galaxy (1) mB [mag] (2) mV [mag] (3) B − V [mag] (4) NGC 1325 NGC 1385 NGC 2082 NGC 3177 NGC 3277 NGC 3455 NGC 4030 NGC 4806 NGC 4980 NGC 5188 NGC 5377 NGC 5806 NGC 6384 NGC 7421 NGC 7690 NGC 300 NGC 428 NGC 450 ESO 358-5 NGC 1493 NGC 2139 UGC 3574 NGC 2552 NGC 2805 NGC 3346 NGC 3423 NGC 3445 A 1156+52 NGC 4411B NGC 4540 NGC 4618 NGC 4625 NGC 4701 NGC 4775 NGC 5068 NGC 5585 NGC 5668 NGC 5964 NGC 6509 UGC 12732 21.11±0.01 18.99±0.01 21.94±0.01 18.08±0.01 18.63±0.01 21.01±0.01 19.51±0.01 22.12±0.02 21.20±0.01 21.26±0.01 16.84±0.01 19.85±0.01 21.64±0.02 19.86±0.01 17.79±0.01 17.79±0.01 20.05±0.01 20.61±0.04 22.01±0.02 18.03±0.01 19.47±0.01 21.85±0.02 19.75±0.01 20.61±0.01 21.83±0.02 20.97±0.01 21.34±0.01 21.96±0.02 20.52±0.01 21.84±0.02 20.24±0.03 20.32±0.02 17.98±0.01 19.57±0.03 20.76±0.01 20.01±0.01 20.74±0.01 21.31±0.01 21.35±0.01 21.45±0.02 0.92±0.01 20.19±0.01 0.23±0.01 18.76±0.01 0.95±0.02 20.99±0.01 0.88±0.01 17.20±0.01 0.96±0.01 17.67±0.01 0.77±0.01 20.24±0.01 1.00±0.01 18.51±0.01 0.99±0.02 21.13±0.01 0.76±0.01 20.44±0.01 2.00±0.01 19.26±0.01 0.49±0.01 16.35±0.01 1.13±0.01 18.72±0.01 1.33±0.02 20.31±0.01 0.67±0.01 19.19±0.01 0.65±0.01 17.14±0.01 0.45±0.01 17.34±0.01 0.70±0.01 19.35±0.01 0.53±0.05 20.08±0.03 0.60±0.03 21.41±0.02 17.87±0.01 0.16±0.01 19.50±0.01 −0.03±0.01 21.10±0.02 0.75±0.03 0.36±0.01 19.39±0.01 0.61±0.01 20.00±0.01 0.82±0.02 21.01±0.01 0.87±0.01 20.10±0.01 20.52±0.01 0.82±0.01 0.24±0.03 21.72±0.02 0.68±0.01 19.84±0.01 0.92±0.02 20.92±0.01 19.47±0.02 0.77±0.04 0.36±0.03 19.96±0.02 0.34±0.01 17.64±0.01 0.83±0.04 18.74±0.03 0.93±0.01 19.83±0.01 19.44±0.01 0.57±0.01 0.72±0.01 20.02±0.01 0.69±0.01 20.62±0.01 0.71±0.01 20.64±0.01 20.80±0.01 0.65±0.02 Note. -- Column (1) lists the Galaxy name. Column (2) and (3) list the total B- and V -band magnitudes of the NC, -- 67 -- including aperture corrections. Column (4) lists the color B − V of the NC. The listed quantities are not corrected for foreground extinction or extinction intrinsic to the galaxy. The horizontal line divides the NCs in early-type spirals (above the line) from those in late-type spirals (below the line). -- 68 -- Table 6. Fit Coefficients and Statistical Significance y (2) Figure (3) a (4) b (5) RMS(x) RMS(y) (6) (7) rs (8) 1 − P (9) hlog τ iL log M hlog τ iL log M log M 7 9 13 14 15 16 +11.54 ± 0.68 −0.55 ± 0.13 +8.81 ± 0.61 −0.37 ± 0.11 +7.26 ± 0.16 +2.53 ± 0.23 −19.50 ± 3.82 +2.68 ± 0.38 −4.10 ± 1.33 +1.27 ± 0.15 +3.50 ± 0.72 +0.76 ± 0.10 1.97 1.66 0.10 0.37 0.57 0.78 1.08 0.61 0.26 0.98 0.72 0.60 −0.3080 −0.7933 +0.9246 +0.4906 +0.7965 +0.6895 0.8005 0.9999 0.9999 0.9670 0.9999 0.9989 x (1) T T B − V log Ltot,B log Lbul,B log M hlog τ iL Note. -- Cols. (1) to (3) list the quantities to be correlated using the generic expression y = a + b × x, and the corresponding figure, in which they are plotted against each other. Cols. (4) and (5) are the coefficients a and b of the best linear regression fit, taking into account the errors in both x and y. Col. (6) and (7) list the RMS scatter around the best fit in both x and y. Cols.(8) and (9) list the Spearman rank-order correlation coefficient rs and its significance (1 − P ). -- 69 -- Table 7. Luminosity Fractions of NCs per Age Bin of Best Composite Population Fit Galaxy (1) f (log τ ) (τ < 7.8) (2) f (log τ ) (τ = 7.8 - 9.2) (3) f (log τ ) (τ > 9.2) (4) NGC 1325 NGC 1385 NGC 3177 NGC 3277 NGC 3455 NGC 4030 NGC 5377 NGC 5806 NGC 7421 NGC 7690 NGC 300 NGC 428 NGC 1493 NGC 2139 NGC 2552 NGC 4411B NGC 4701 NGC 4775 NGC 5585 ... ... 0.005 0.077 0.170 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 0.380 0.868 0.447 ... ... ... ... 0.088 0.974 0.822 0.133 0.668 0.331 0.842 0.062 0.880 0.765 0.698 0.629 0.620 0.132 0.553 1.000 0.889 0.811 0.805 0.912 0.026 0.174 0.791 0.163 0.669 0.158 0.938 0.120 0.235 0.302 0.371 ... ... ... ... 0.111 0.189 0.195 Note. -- The luminosity fractions in Columns (2) to (4) are shown in three, somewhat arbitrarily chosen, age-bins. The bins roughly reflect young, intermediate-age and old populations. The horizontal line divides the NCs in early- type spirals (above the line) from those in late-type spirals (below the line).
astro-ph/0702096	2	0702	2007-09-16T14:29:22	Probing the Cluster Mass Distribution using Subaru Weak Lensing Data	[ "astro-ph" ]	We present results from a weak lensing analysis of the galaxy cluster A1689 (z=0.183) based on deep wide-field imaging data taken with Suprime-Cam on Subaru telescope. A maximum entropy method has been used to reconstruct directly the projected mass distribution of A1689 from combined lensing distortion and magnification measurements of red background galaxies.The resulting mass distribution is clearly concentrated around the cD galaxy, and mass and light in the cluster are similarly distributed in terms of shape and orientation. The azimuthally-averaged mass profile from the two-dimensional reconstruction is in good agreement with the earlier results from the Subaru one-dimensional analysis of the weak lensing data, supporting the assumption of quasi-circular symmetry in the projected mass distribution of the cluster.	astro-ph	astro-ph	October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk 7 0 0 2 p e S 6 1 2 v 6 9 0 2 0 7 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a Modern Physics Letters A c(cid:13) World Scientific Publishing Company PROBING THE CLUSTER MASS DISTRIBUTION USING SUBARU WEAK LENSING DATA KEIICHI UMETSU1, MASAHIRO TAKADA2, TOM BROADHURST3 1. Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan 2. Astronomical Institute, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan 3. School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel [email protected] Received (Day Month Year) Revised (Day Month Year) We present results from a weak lensing analysis of the galaxy cluster A1689 (z = 0.183) based on deep wide-field imaging data taken with Suprime-Cam on Subaru telescope. A maximum entropy method has been used to reconstruct directly the projected mass dis- tribution of A1689 from combined lensing distortion and magnification measurements of red background galaxies. The resulting mass distribution is clearly concentrated around the cD galaxy, and mass and light in the cluster are similarly distributed in terms of shape and orientation. The azimuthally-averaged mass profile from the two-dimensional recon- struction is in good agreement with the earlier results from the Subaru one-dimensional analysis of the weak lensing data, supporting the assumption of quasi-circular symmetry in the projected mass distribution of the cluster. Keywords: cosmology: observations -- gravitational lensing -- galaxies: clusters: individ- ual(Abell 1689) PACS Nos.: include PACS Nos. 1. Introduction Weak gravitational lensing of background galaxies provides a unique, direct way to study the mass distribution of galaxy clusters.1,2 Recent improvements in the quality of observational data usable for lensing studies now allow an accurate de- termination of the mass distribution in clusters. A1689 is one of the best studied lensing clusters,3,4,5,6 located at a moderately low redshift of z = 0.183. Deep HST/ACS imaging of the central region of A1689 has revealed 106 multiply lensed images of 30 background galaxies, which allowed a detailed reconstruction of the mass distribution in the cluster core (10h−1kpc <∼ r <∼ 200h−1kpc).3 In Ref. 4, we developed a model-independent method for reconstructing the cluster mass pro- file using azimuthally-averaged weak-lensing distortion and magnification measure- ments, and derived a projected mass profile of A1689 out to the cluster virial radius (r <∼ 2h−1 Mpc) based on the wide-field, deep imaging data taken with Suprime- Cam on the 8.2m Subaru telescope. The combined strong and weak lensing mass 1 October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk 2 K. Umetsu, M. Takada, & T. Broadhurst profile is well fitted by an NFW7 profile with high concentration of cvir ∼ 13.7, which is significantly larger than theoretically expected (cvir ≃ 4) for the standard LCDM model.8 In this paper we present a weak lensing analysis of A1689 using wide-field Sub- aru imaging data, with special attention to the map-making process. Throughout this paper, we use the AB magnitude system, and adopt the concordance ΛCDM cosmology with (Ωm0 = 0.3, Ωλ0 = 0.7, h = 0.7). In this cosmology one arcminute corresponds to the physical scale 129kpc/h for this cluster. 2. Sample selection For our weak lensing analysis we used Subaru/Suprime-Cam imaging data of A1689 in V (1,920s) and SDSS i′ (2,640s) retrieved from the Subaru archive, SMOKA (see Ref. 4, 6 for more details). The FWHM in the final co-added image is 0′′.82 in V and 0′′.88 in i′ with 0′′.202 pix−1, covering a field of 30′ × 25′. The limiting magnitudes are V = 26.5 and i′ = 25.9 for a 3σ detection within a 2′′aperture. A careful background selection is critical for a weak lensing analysis.4,6 For the number counts to measure magnification, we define a sample of 8,907 galaxies (¯nµ = 12.0 arcmin−2) with V − i′ > 1.0. For distortion measurement, we define a sample of 5,729 galaxies (¯ng = 7.59 arcmin−2) with colors 0.22 mag redder than the color- magnitude sequence of cluster E/S0 galaxies, (V − i′) + 0.0209i′ − 1.255 > 0.22. The smaller sample is due to the fact that distortion analysis requires galaxies used are well resolved to make reliable shape measurement. We adopt a limit of i′ < 25.5 to avoid incompleteness effect. In what follows we will assume hzsi = 1 for the mean redshift of the red galaxies,3,4 but note that the low redshift of A1689 means that for lensing work, a precise knowledge of this redshift is not critical. 3. Lensing Distortions We use the IMCAT package developed by N. Kaiser a to perform object detection, photometry and shape measurements, following the formalism outlined in Ref. 9. We have modified the method somewhat following the procedures described in Ref. 10. To obtain an estimate of the reduced shear, gα = γα/(1 − κ), we measure the image ellipticity eα from the weighted quadrupole moments of the surface brightness of individual galaxies. Firstly the PSF anisotropy needs to be corrected using the star images as references: α = eα − P αβ e′ sm q∗ β (1) αβ eβ where Psm is the smear polarizability tensor being close to diagonal, and q∗ α = (P∗sm)−1 ∗ is the stellar anisotropy kernel. We select bright, unsaturated foreground stars identified in a branch of the half-light radius (rh) vs. magnitude (i′) diagram (20 < i′ < 22.5, hrhimedian = 2.38 pixels) to calculate q∗ α. ahttp://www.ifa.hawaii/kaiser/IMCAT October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk Probing the Cluster Mass Distribution using Subaru Weak Lensing Data 3 Fig. 1. Gravitational reduced-shear field in A1689 obtained from shape distortions of the red background galaxies, smoothed with a Gaussian with FWHM = 2′ for visualization purposes. The shaded circle indicates the FWHM of the Gaussian. The coordinate origin is at the optical center (see Figure 4). ∗smq∗ In order to obtain a smooth map of q∗ α which is used in equation (1), we divided the 9K × 7.4K image into 5 × 4 chunks each with 1.8K × 1.85K pixels, and then ∗ (~θ), fitted the q∗ in each chunk independently with second-order bi-polynomials, qα in conjunction with iterative σ-clipping rejection on each component of the residual β(~θ). The final stellar sample consists of 540 stars, or the mean surface α − P αβ e∗ number density of ¯n∗ = 0.72 arcmin−2. From the rest of the object catalog, we select objects with 2.4 . rh . 15 pixels as an i′-selected weak lensing galaxy sample, which contains 61, 115 galaxies or ¯ng ≃ 81 arcmin−2. It is worth noting ∗) ≃ (−0.013, −0.018) that the mean stellar ellipticity before correction is ( ¯e1 over the data field, while the residual e∗ = 2 = (0.54 ± 0.94) × 10−4. The mean offset from the null (0.47 ± 1.32) × 10−4, ¯e∗res expectation is ¯e∗res = (0.71 ± 1.12) × 10−4. On the other hand, the rms value of stellar ellipticities, σe∗ ≡ (cid:10)e∗2(cid:11), is reduced from 2.64% to 0.38% when applying the anisotropic PSF correction. Second, we need to correct the isotropic smearing effect on image ellipticities caused by seeing and the window function used for the shape measurements. The pre-seeing reduced shear gα can be estimated from α after correction is reduced to ¯e∗res ∗, ¯e2 1 gα = (P −1 g )αβe′ β (2) with the pre-seeing shear polarizability tensor P g αβ. We follow the procedure de- scribed in Ref. 10 to measure P g. We adopt the scalar correction scheme,10,11,12 namely, P g g measured for individual objects are still noisy especially for small and faint objects. We remove from the galaxy cat- 2 tr[P g]δαβ ≡ P g s δαβ. The P s αβ = 1 October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk 4 K. Umetsu, M. Takada, & T. Broadhurst g i of P s alog those objects that yield a negative value of P s g estimate to avoid noisy shear estimates. We then adopt a smoothing scheme in object parameter space.10,13,14 We first identify thirty neighbors for each object in rg-i′ parameter space. We then calculate over the local ensemble the median value hP s g and the variance σ2 g of g = g1 + ig2 using equation (2). The dispersion σg is used as an rms error of the shear estimate for individual galaxies. The mean variance ¯σ2 g over the red galaxy sample is obtained as ≃ 0.133, or q¯σ2 g ≈ 0.36. Finally, we use the following α/(cid:10)P s g(cid:11). estimator for the reduced shear: gα = e′ For map-making, we then pixelize the distortion data into a regular grid of Npix = 21 × 17 independent pixels, covering a field of ≈ 30′ × 24′. The pixel size is ∆pix = 1.′4, and the mean galaxy counts per pixel is ∼ 15. The bin-averaged reduced shear is given as ¯gα,i ≡ ¯gα(~θi) = Pk∈celli ukgα,k/Pk∈celli uk (a = 1, 2; i = 1, 2, ..., Npix), where gα,k is the estimate of the αth component of the reduced shear g,k+α2) is its inverse-variance weight softened with for the kth galaxy, and uk = 1/(σ2 a constant α. Here we choose α = 0.4.14 In Figure 1 we show the reduced-shear field obtained from the red galaxy sample, where for visualization purposes the ¯gα(~θ) is resampled on to a finer grid and smoothed with a Gaussian with FWHM = 2′. Fig. 2. Distribution of the lensing magnification bias n/n0 measured from a red-galaxy sample in the background of A1689, smoothed with a Gaussian with FWHM = 2′ for visualization purposes. The shaded circle indicates the FWHM of the Gaussian. 4. Magnification Bias Lensing magnification, µ(~θ), influences the observed surface density of background galaxies, expanding the area of sky, and enhancing the flux of galaxies. In the sub- October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk Probing the Cluster Mass Distribution using Subaru Weak Lensing Data 5 1 − γ2 critical regime,1,2 the magnification µ is given by µ = 1/(cid:2)(1 − κ)2 − γ2 2(cid:3). The count-in-cell statistics are measured from the flux-limited red galaxy sample (see §2) on the same grid as the distortion data: Ni ≡ N (< mcut; ~θi) = Pk∈celli 1 with mcut being the magnitude cutoff corresponding to the flux-limit. The normalization and slope of the unlensed number counts N0(< mcut) for our red galaxy sample are reliably estimated as nµ,0 = 12.6 ± 0.23 arcmin−2 and s ≡ d log N0(m)/dm = 0.22 ± 0.03 from the outer region ≥ 10′.4 The slope is less than the lensing invariant slope, s = 0.4, and hence a net deficit of background galaxies is expected: Ni/N0 = nµ,i/nµ,0 = µ2.5s−1 . The masking effect due to bright cluster galaxies is properly taken into account and corrected for.4 Figure 2 shows a clear depletion of the red galaxy counts in the central, high-density region of the cluster. Note we have ignored the intrinsic clustering of background galaxies, which seems a good approximation,4 though some variance is apparent in the spatial distribution of red galaxies. i 5. Two-Dimensional Mass Reconstruction The relation between distortion and convergence is non-local, and the convergence κ derived from distortion data alone suffers from a mass sheet degeneracy.1,2 How- ever, by combining the distortion and magnification measurements the convergence can be obtained unambiguously with the correct mass normalization. Here we com- bine pixelized distortion and magnification data of the red background galaxies, and reconstruct the two-dimensional (2D) distribution of κ using a maximum en- tropy method (MEM) extended to account for positive/negative distributions of the underlying field.16,17 We take into account the non-linear, but sub-critical, regime of the lensing properties, κ and γα. We take κi = κ(~θi) as the image to be reconstructed,16 and express a set of discretized κ-values as p = {κi} (i = 1, 2, ..., Npix). The total log-likelihood function, F (p) = − ln L(p), is expressed as a linear sum of the shear/magnification data log-likelihoods18 and the entropy term16: F (p) = lg(p) + lµ(p) − αS(p, m), lg ≡ − ln Lg ≈ lµ ≡ − ln Lµ ≈ Npix X i=1 2 X α=1 (¯gα,i − gα,i(p))2 σ2 g,i , 1 2 Npix X i=1 (Ni − Ni(p))2 Ni , (3) (4) (5) where gα,i(p) and Ni(p) are the theoretical expectations for ¯gα,i and Ni, respec- tively, σg,i ≡ σg(~θi) is the rms error for ¯gi = ¯g1(~θi) + i¯g2(~θi), and S(p, m) is the cross entropy function for the positive/negative field;16 the m is a set of the model parameters and α(> 0) is the regularization constant. The maximum likelihood so- lution, p, is obtained by minimizing the function F (p) with respect to p for given α and m. We take mi = const ≡ m, and determine by iteration the Bayesian value October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk 6 K. Umetsu, M. Takada, & T. Broadhurst of α for a given value of m. We found that the maximum-likelihood solution for the Bayesian α is insensitive to the choice of m. In the following we set m to be 0.2. We note that the adopted MEM prior16,17 ensures κi → 0 in the noise-dominated regime, F (p) ∼ −αS(p, m) (i.e., maximizing the entropy alone). In order to quan- tify the errors on the mass reconstruction we evaluate the Hessian matrix of the function F (p) at p = p, Hij (p) = ∂2F (p) p=p, from which the covariance matrix of the parameters p is given by Cij ≡ h∆κi∆κji = (H)−1 ij (p). Figure 3 displays the κ map reconstructed with the MEM method. In Figure 4 we compare the con- tours of the reconstructed κ (thick) and the i′-band luminosity density of the cluster sequence galaxies (thin) superposed on the i′-band image of the central region of A1689. ∂pi∂pj Fig. 3. The projected mass distribution κ of A1689 reconstructed by a maximum entropy method using weak-lensing distortion and magnification data of red background galaxies. For visualization purposes the κ-map is resampled on to a finer grid, and smoothed with a Gaussian with FWHM = 2′. The lowest contour is κ = 0.07, and the contour steps are ∆κ = 0.05. 6. Model-Independent Mass Profile of A1689 We show in Figure 5 the azimuthally-averaged profile of the reconstructed conver- gence, κ(θ), as a function of projected radius θ from the optical center of A1689 (circles). The vertical error bars represent the 1σ uncertainties based on the error covariance matrix Cij of the reconstruction. Note that the error bars are correlated. Also shown for comparison are the earlier results from the HST/ACS strong lensing analysis (triangles) and the Subaru weak lensing analysis (squares) with the one- dimensional (1D) reconstruction method, respectively, along with the best-fitting NFW7 model (solid) for the combined ACS+Subaru profile (see Ref. 4). October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk Probing the Cluster Mass Distribution using Subaru Weak Lensing Data 7 Fig. 4. Contours (thick) of the reconstructed lensing convergence κ superposed on the i′-band image of the central region of A1689. The field size is 15′ on a side. The lowest contour and the contour intervals are 0.05. Also superposed are the contours (thin) of the projected luminosity density of the cluster member galaxies defined by the color-magnitude sequence. North is to the top and East is to the left. 7. Discussion and Conclusions We presented results from our weak lensing analysis of A1689 based on deep wide- field imaging data taken with Subaru/Suprime-Cam. We used a MEM algorithm to reconstruct the projected mass map in A1689 from combined distortion and mag- nification data of our red background galaxy sample. The combination of distortion and magnification data breaks the mass sheet degeneracy inherent in all recon- struction methods based on distortion information alone. Our results show that mass and light in A1689 are similarly distributed in terms of shape and orientation, and clearly concentrated around the cD galaxy (see Figure 4). The resulting mass profile from the present full 2D reconstruction is in good agreement with the results from the earlier Subaru 1D analysis4 (see Figure 5), supporting the assumption of quasi-circular symmetry in the projected mass distribution. Acknowledgments Part of this work is based on data collected at the Subaru Telescope, which is oper- ated by the National Astronomical Society of Japan. The work is in part supported by the National Science Council of Taiwan under the grant NSC95-2112-M-001-074- MY2. October 22, 2018 14:54 WSPC/INSTRUCTION FILE umetsuk 8 K. Umetsu, M. Takada, & T. Broadhurst Fig. 5. Reconstructed mass profile of A1689. The filled circles with error bars represent the results based on the 2D κ map reconstructed with the MEM algorithm. The error bars are correlated. The triangle and square symbols with error bars show the results from the HST/ACS strong lensing analysis (Broadhurst et al. 2005, ApJ, 621, 53) and the Subaru weak lensing analysis with the 1D reconstruction method (Broadhurst, Takada, Umetsu et al. 2005, ApJ, 619, L143, hereafter BTU05) respectively. The solid curve shows the best-fitting NFW profile for the combined ACS+Subaru data by BTU05 (Mvir = 1.93 × 1015M⊙, cvir = 13.7). The best-fitting NFW profile for the ACS+Subaru profile has a high concentration, cvir = 13.7, and somewhat overestimates the inner slope and is a bit shallower than the 1D-based results at large radius. References 1. Bartelmann, M. & Schneider, P. 2001, Phys. Rep. 340, 291 2. Umetsu, K., Tada, M., & Futamase, T. 1999, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl., 133, 53 3. Broadhurst, T. et al. 2005, ApJ, 621, 53 4. Broadhurst, T., Takada, M., Umetsu, K. et al. 2005, ApJ, 619, L143 5. Oguri, M., Takada, M., Umetsu, K., & Broadhurst, T. 2005, ApJ, 632, 841 6. Medezinski, E., Broadhurst, T., Umetsu, K. et al. 2007, ApJ in press [astro-ph/0608499] 7. Navarro, J. F., Frenk, C. S., White, S. D. M., 1997, ApJ, 490, 493 8. Bullock, J. S. et al. 2001, MNRAS, 321, 559 9. Kaiser, N., Squires, G., & Broadhurst, T. 1995, ApJ, 449, 460 10. Erben, T. et al. 2001, Astron. Astrophys., 366, 717 11. Hoekstra, H., Franx, M., Kuijken, K., & Squires, G. 1998, ApJ, 504, 636 12. Hudson, M. J., Gwyn, S. D. J., Dahle, H., & Kaiser, N. 1998, ApJ, 503, 531 13. Van Waerbeke, L. et al. 2000, Astron. Astrophys., 358, 30 14. Hamana, T. et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, 98 15. Bertin, E., & Arnouts, S. 1996, Astron. Astrophys. Suppl., 117, 393 16. Maisinger, K., Hobson, M. P., & Lasenby A. N. 1997, MNRAS, 290, 313 17. Hobson, M. P. & Lasenby, A. N. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 3, 905 18. Schneider, P., King, L., & Erben, T. 2000, Astron. Astrophys., 353, 41
0810.1375	1	0810	2008-10-08T07:50:36	IRC-10443: a multi-periodic SRa variable and the nature of long secondary periods in AGB stars	[ "astro-ph" ]	We obtained BVIc photometry of IRC-10443 on 85 different nights distributed over two years, and in addition low resolution absolute spectro- photometry and high resolution Echelle spectroscopy. Our data show that IRC-10443, which was never studied before in any detail, is a SRa variable, characterized by Delta(B)=1.27, Delta(V)=1.14 and Delta(I)=0.70 mag amplitudes and mean values <B>=13.75, <V>=11.33 and <Ic>=6.18 mag. Two strong periodicities are simultaneously present: a principal one of 85.5 (+/-0.2) days, and a secondary one of 620 (+/-15) days, both sinusoidal in shape, and with semi-amplitudes Delta(V)=0.41 and 0.20 mag, respectively. IRC-10443 turns out to be a M7III star, with a mean heliocentric radial velocity -28 km/s and reddened by E(B-V)=0.87, a third of which of circumstellar origin. The same 0.5 kpc distance is derived from application of the appropriate period-luminosity relations to both the principal and the secondary periods. The long secondary period causes a sinusoidal variation in color of 0.13 mag semi-amplitude in V-Ic, with IRC-10443 being bluest at maximum and reddest at minimum, and with associated changes in effective temperature and radius of 85 K and 6%, respectively. This behavior of colors argues in favor of a pulsation nature for the still mysterious long secondary periods in AGB stars.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Baltic Astronomy, vol. 17, 223-234, 2008. IRC−10443: A MULTI-PERIODIC SRa VARIABLE AND THE NA- TURE OF LONG SECONDARY PERIODS IN AGB STARS U. Munari1 A. Siviero1 P. Ochner2 S. Dallaporta2 C. Simoncelli2 1 INAF Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, via dell'Osservatorio 8, 36012 Asi- ago (VI), Italy 4 ANS Collaboration, c/o Osservatorio Astronomico, via dell'Osservatorio 8, 36012 Asiago (VI), Italy Received 2008 August 30; revised September 3; accepted September 8 Abstract. We obtained BV IC photometry of IRC−10443 in 85 different nights dis- tributed over two years, and in addition low resolution absolute spectro- pho- tometry and high resolution Echelle spectroscopy. Our data show that IRC −10443, which was never studied before in any detail, is a SRa variable, charac- terized by ∆B=1.27, ∆V =1.14 and ∆I=0.70 mag amplitudes and mean values <B>=13.75, <V >=11.33 and <IC>=6.18 mag. Two strong periodicities are simultaneously present: a principal one of 85.5 (±0.2) days, and a secondary one of 620 (±15) days, both sinusoidal in shape, and with semi-amplitudes ∆V =0.41 and 0.20 mag, respectively. IRC−10443 turns out to be a M7III star, with a mean heliocentric radial velocity −28 km/s and reddened by EB−V =0.87, a third of which of circumstellar origin. The same 0.5 kpc distance is derived from application of the appropriate period-luminosity relations to both the prin- cipal and the secondary periods. The long secondary period causes a sinusoidal variation in color of 0.13 mag semi-amplitude in V − IC, with IRC−10443 being bluest at maximum and reddest at minimum, and with associated changes in effective temperature and radius of 85 K and 6%, respectively. This behav- ior of colors argues in favor of a pulsation nature for the still mysterious long secondary periods in AGB stars. Key words: stars: pulsations -- stars: variables -- stars: AGB 1. INTRODUCTION IRC−10443 (= RAFGL 2209 = NSV 11129 = BD−12◦5123) is a bright (K=1.8 mag) infrared source discovered during the Two Micron Sky Survey (Neugebauer and Leighton 1969), that lies in the general direction of the Scutum Star Cloud. IRC−10443 was detected by the AFGL survey (Price and Murdock 1983) at 4.2 µm, and by IRAS satellite at 12 and 25 µm. Its 2MASS magnitudes and colors are Ks=1.92, J − H=1.35, J − K=1.80. Its spectral type is reported to be M6 by Neckel (1958) and Hansen and Blanco (1975), and M6.5 by Nassau et al. (1956). IRC−10443 is present in the NSV catalog of suspected variables because I-band observations, obtained at five different epochs (from 21-08-1963 to 28-06-1965) which are reported in the IRC catalog, seem to trace a variation 8 0 0 2 t c O 8 ] h p - o r t s a [ 1 v 5 7 3 1 . 0 1 8 0 : v i X r a 2 from magnitude 6.4 to 6.9 (however, the uncertainty of the single measurement is similar to the dispersion of the five IRC measurements around their mean). Not much more is known about IRC−10443 and its nature. In this paper we report on our BV I photometric monitoring (85 nights distributed over two years) and optical spectroscopic observations (low and high resolution) of this object, and how they constrain its basic properties. 2. OBSERVATIONS 2.1. Photometry BV IC CCD photometry of IRC−10443 was independently obtained with two separate telescopes: (a) the 0.30-m Meade RCX-400 f/8 Schmidt-Cassegrain tele- scope owned by Associazione Astrofili Valle di Cembra (Trento, Italy). The CCD was a SBIG ST-9, 512×512 array, 20 µm pixels ≡1.72′′/pix, with a field of view of 13′×13′. The B filter was from Omega and the V IC filters from Custom Scientific; and (b) the 0.50-m f/8 Ritchey-Cretien telescope operated on top of Mt. Zugna by Museo Civico di Rovereto (Trento, Italy) and equipped with Optec BV IC filters. The CCD was an Apogee Alta U42 2048×2048 array, 13.5 µm pixels ≡ 0.70′′/pix, with a field of view of 24′×24′. The comparison star for B and V bands was TYC 5699-6341-1, for which we adopted B=11.016 and V =10.334 in the standard Johnson U BV system. They were obtained from Tycho BT ,VT data following Bessell (2000) transformations. The comparison star for IC band was TYC 5699-6348-1 for which we adopted IC=6.39, V − IC=0.55 from the Hipparcos catalog. We had no alternatives for the comparison stars. In fact, these two are the only stars within the CCD field of view of IRC−10443 that (i) have reference magnitudes available in literature, (ii) are bright enough to be well exposed on the single CCD image without risking to saturate IRC−10443, and (iii) are photometrically stable to better than 0.02 mag. The last point was verified by noting that on all frames in any band we obtained, the relative magnitude of the two comparison stars was stable at this level. All photometric measurements were corrected for instrumental color equations derived nightly by observations of Landolt (1992) standard fields. The good consis- tency of the data obtained independently with two different instruments reinforce our confidence in the accuracy of the results, in spite of the very red colors of IRC−10443, that are not reached by typical Landolt standard stars. Our photom- etry is presented in Table 1. It covers the period from 16-07-2006 to 11-07-2008, with observations collected in 85 different nights. The Poissonian component of the total error budget is less than 0.01 mag for all the data. The r.m.s. of the Landolt standard stars around the color equations they contributed to calibrate was on the average 0.019 mag for B, 0.022 for V and 0.031 for IC bands. 2.2. Spectroscopy A low resolution, absolutely fluxed spectrum of IRC−10443 was obtained on June 24.97, 2008 UT with the B&C spectrograph of INAF Astronomical Ob- servatory of Padova attached to the 1.22m telescope operated in Asiago by the Department of Astronomy of the University of Padova. The slit, aligned with the parallactic angle, projected onto 2 arcsec on the sky, and the total exposure time was 1860 sec. The detector was an ANDOR iDus 440A CCD camera, equipped 3 Tabe 1. CCD hey f RC10443. a ad b ideify he ee e de ibed i e . 2.1. D B V D B V C C 3935.366 13.78 11.39 6.05 a 4289.557 13.74 11.29 6.22 b 3955.386 13.73 11.31 6.19 b 4296.517 13.65 11.20 b 3966.387 13.75 11.42 6.24 a 4306.501 11.17 6.17 b 3970.385 13.85 11.41 6.27 b 4309.340 13.50 11.15 6.16 b 3975.370 13.90 11.49 6.30 a 4312.369 13.60 11.20 6.17 b 3988.311 13.96 11.58 6.33 a 4314.423 13.70 11.22 6.15 b 4007.263 14.03 11.57 6.32 b 4316.435 13.73 11.25 6.18 b 4014.273 13.89 11.46 6.24 b 4351.345 14.12 11.64 6.30 b 4015.245 13.81 11.42 6.31 a 4356.371 14.08 11.60 6.22 b 4017.256 13.89 11.40 6.19 b 4358.350 14.05 11.52 6.22 b 4019.287 13.73 11.36 6.26 a 4360.318 13.99 11.50 6.20 b 4019.296 13.70 11.37 6.18 b 4363.319 13.90 11.45 6.18 b 4024.299 13.59 11.20 6.16 b 4374.334 13.65 11.21 6.09 b 4035.233 13.28 10.95 6.00 a 4376.325 13.58 11.17 6.05 b 4035.295 13.32 10.94 5.94 b 4381.316 13.55 11.13 6.01 b 4042.238 13.23 10.88 5.95 a 4386.328 13.64 11.16 6.06 b 4042.286 13.25 10.82 5.83 b 4389.143 13.67 11.21 6.10 b 4043.247 13.24 10.84 5.85 b 4392.309 13.69 11.24 6.10 b 4062.203 13.70 11.22 6.08 b 4405.243 13.97 11.50 6.25 b 4067.185 13.75 11.32 6.08 b 4406.269 13.95 11.50 6.30 b 4071.190 13.84 11.42 6.09 b 4417.208 14.24 11.81 6.41 b 4080.191 11.50 6.16 b 4423.265 14.29 11.82 b 4081.193 11.51 6.22 b 4431.190 14.41 11.89 6.43 b 4151.717 13.71 11.43 6.18 b 4440.192 14.20 11.80 6.45 b 4158.690 14.04 11.62 6.45 b 4544.676 13.87 11.52 6.33 b 4168.660 14.05 11.63 6.39 b 4559.630 13.59 11.23 6.24 b 4174.657 14.00 11.59 6.36 b 4572.655 13.52 11.31 6.21 b 4181.629 13.96 11.50 6.28 b 4579.617 13.90 11.49 6.27 b 4193.576 13.70 11.24 6.13 b 4582.615 14.00 11.55 6.33 b 4196.595 13.61 11.17 6.13 b 4588.599 14.09 11.65 6.33 b 4196.644 13.59 11.16 6.08 a 4592.609 14.14 11.70 6.42 b 4201.585 13.40 10.96 6.01 b 4595.593 14.16 11.68 6.29 b 4201.652 11.00 6.01 a 4598.594 14.13 11.66 6.28 b 4204.614 13.29 10.89 5.95 a 4600.596 14.06 11.68 6.32 b 4207.638 13.23 10.80 5.92 a 4614.534 13.72 11.43 6.30 b 4210.633 10.80 5.96 b 4618.542 13.75 11.37 6.19 b 4211.635 13.14 10.75 5.88 a 4627.569 13.57 11.18 6.16 b 4218.634 13.21 10.83 5.92 a 4636.557 13.46 11.06 6.08 b 4229.609 13.65 11.14 6.09 a 4638.588 13.23 10.96 5.98 b 4231.588 13.74 11.23 6.08 b 4639.472 13.38 11.02 6.05 b 4239.586 13.92 11.43 6.25 b 4640.550 13.41 11.04 6.05 b 4239.590 14.03 11.42 6.22 a 4643.484 13.45 11.05 6.05 b 4260.579 14.18 11.82 6.45 a 4649.531 13.52 11.11 6.10 b 4275.512 14.16 11.70 6.35 b 4652.481 13.52 11.14 b 4287.503 13.80 11.35 6.23 b 4658.500 13.66 11.25 6.20 b 4288.549 13.82 11.34 6.26 b 4 Fig. 1. Light- and color-curves of of IRC 10443. Open circles: telescope a; filled dots: telescope b (see sect. 2.1). with a EEV 42-10BU back illuminated chip, 2048×512 pixels of 13.5 µm size. A 300 ln/mm grating blazed at 5000 A provided a dispersion of 2.26 A/pix and a covered range extending from 3250 to 7890 A. High resolution spectra of IRC−10443 were obtained on June 10.04 and July 22.95 2008 UT with the Echelle spectrograph mounted on the 1.82m telescope operated in Asiago by INAF Astronomical Observatory of Padova. The detector was a EEV CCD47-10 CCD, 1024×1024 array, 13 µm pixel, covering the interval 3600−7300 A in 31 orders. A slit width of 200 µm provided a resolving power RP =26 000. 3. RESULTS 3.1. Photometric variability The light-curve presented in Figure 1 clearly shows that IRC−10443 is indeed variable. The recorded variability amounts to ∆B=1.27 (from 14.41 to 13.14), ∆V =1.14 (from 11.89 to 10.75) and ∆IC=0.70 (from 6.45 to 5.75), around the mean values <B>=13.75, <V >=11.33 and <IC>=6.18 mag. The variability is obviously periodic (see next section) and Figure 1 shows that the stars gets hotter (bluest V − IC) at V maxima, and cooler (reddest V − IC) at V minima. This behavior of the color is a distinctive features of stellar pulsation. 5 In fact, Figure 2 plots the V − IC color against the V magnitude, showing the clear correlation between them. If we take a black-body, red- den it by EB−V =0.87, scale its flux so to match the average V band bright- ness of IRC−10443, and let it varies at constant luminosity, we obtain the line in Figure 2, which is a reason- ably good fit to the observed points. This indicates that the variability displayed by IRC−10443 occurs at constant luminosity, in the form of expansion + cooling and contraction + warming, as expected in radial pul- sations. The corresponding variation in spectral type goes from M6.6 III to M7.5 III as indicated on the right ordinate axis of Figure 2. These cor- responding spectral types have been obtained by integrating the V and IC bands on the Fluks et al. (1994) spectra of M III giants reddened by EB−V =0.87 (the amount affecting IRC−10443, see sect. 3.4) Fig. 2. Brightness-color diagram for the observations in Figure 1. The line is the path followed by a black-body, reddened by EB−V =0.87, varying in radius and temperature at constant luminosity. IRC−10443 appears as a bona fide SRa variable. SRa variables are semi- regular late-type (M, C, S or Me, Ce, Se) giants displaying persistent periodicity and usually small (∆V <2.5 mag) light amplitudes. Amplitudes and light-curve shapes generally vary and periods are in the range 35-1200 days. Many SRa differ from Miras only by showing smaller light amplitudes (Whitelock 1996). 3.2. Multi periodicities Two main periodicities are at the same time present in IRC−10443: a principal and larger amplitude variation modulated by a 85.5 day period, and a secondary and smaller one of 620 days. The following expression corresponds to the curve fitting the V -band data in Figure 3 (where t is in HJD − 2450000): V (t) = 11.38(±0.02) + 0.41(±0.02) sin t − 4042.0(±0.3) 85.5(±0.2) + + 0.22(±0.02) sin t − 4141(±10) 620(±15) (1) The combination of these two plain sinusoids provides a reasonably close fitting to the observed light-curve. Nevertheless, the residuals are larger than the obser- vational errors, and an additional weaker component (either periodic or irregular) is probably present. Our present data are insufficient to characterize such an ad- ditional component, and to resolve it a much longer photometric monitoring is required, which we plan to pursue. 3.3. Spectral classification and radial velocity The low resolution spectrum we obtained of IRC −10443 was compared with the digital spectral atlas of Fluks et al. (1994), that includes all spectral types from 6 Fig. 3. Fitting of the V and V − IC light-curves of IRC−10443 with two sinusoids of 85.5 and 620 days periods (see sects. 3.2, 3.6 and Eq. 1). M0 to M10 with spectra covering the whole optical range. They are of high flux accuracy and of a resolution similar to ours. Literature data suggest a M6/M6.5 spectral type for IRC−10443, but our spectrum is quite poorly fitted by the M6III reference spectrum from Fluks et al. (1994) library, while the match is perfect with a M7III spectrum, as shown in Figure 4. In view of the pulsation activity present in IRC−10443, the difference between our and other spectral classifications present in literature can be accounted for by the changes in surface temperature that characterize the pulsation activity (see right hand-side ordinates of Figure 2). Figure 5 displays a portion centered on Hα of our high resolution Echelle spectrum of IRC−10443 for July 22.95, and by comparison those of bracketing spectral types from the atlas of Bagnulo et al. (2003), degraded to the resolution of our Echelle spectrum via a Gaussian filter. The spectral progression in Figure 5 confirms the M7III classification for IRC−10443. Mira variables displays emission lines, mainly the higher lines in the Balmer series, peaking in intensity at maximum brightness for both O- and C-rich varieties (e.g. Panchuk 1978, Yamashita et al. 1977, Mikulasek and Graf 2005), with large excursion in intensity along the pulsation cycle. When the first Echelle spectrum was exposed on June 10, IRC−10443 was on the rise and close to maximum bright- ness (pulsation phase 0.86), while for the July 22 spectrum it was declining and close to minimum brightness (pulsation phase 0.37). Both spectra do not show emission in the Hα line, in agreement with the fact that the presence of emission lines is far less frequent in SR than in Mira variables. The radial velocity of the M7III star is −24.1(±0.8) and −31.4(±0.7) km/s on the June 10 and July 22 spectra, respectively. The difference is well accounted 7 for by the pulsation activity. The two observations are separated in time by exactly half of the main 85.5 day pulsation period, and their mean value −28 km/s can be taken as representative of the systemic velocity of IRC−10443. At its galactic coordinates (l=20◦, b=−3◦) and distance (0.5 kpc, see below), the radial velocity expected from galactic disk rotation is +7 km/s (cf also Brand and Blitz 1993). The 35 km/s difference with the observed radial velocity, suggests that IRC−10443 does not belong to the young disk galactic population onto which it is seen projected and instead it is related to an older population. This is confirmed by the high tangential velocity, 86 km/s, derived from the proper motion listed in the NOMAD catalog (Zacharias et al. 2004) and the distance estimated in sect. 3.5 below. 3.4. Reddening The fit with the Flucks et al. (1994) M7III reference spectrum presented in Fig- ure 4 constrains the reddening affecting IRC−10443. The best match is obtained with EB−V =0.87±0.02 for a standard RV =3.1 reddening law. The intrinsic B − V color of M giants does not depend from the spectral type and hence the effective temperature, as illustrated by Johnson (1966), Lee (1970) and Fitzgerald (1970). Their tabular compilations provide <(B − V )◦>=+1.544 as the mean intrinsic color of M5 to M8 class III giants. The mean B − V color of our observations is < (B − V ) >=+2.418, which corresponds to a reddening EB−V =0.87±0.04 affecting IRC 10443. These two independent methods converge to the same amount of reddening affecting IRC 10443, EB−V =0.87±0.03, which is adopted in this paper. A fraction of this total reddening is probably of circumstellar origin, as supported by the detection by Kwok et al. (1997) of emission from circumstellar dust in IRAS low resolution spectra. IRC−10443 lies in the general direction of the Scutum Star Cloud (SSC, centered at l=27◦, b=−3◦ galactic coordinates). SSC is one of the regions of the Milky Way with the highest stellar density, caused by unusually low extinction over its area. Reichen et al. (1990) presented the results of a detailed investigation of the extinction over the SSC based on ground-based and balloon- born UV survey data. Toward the direction to IRC−10443 they found that the interstellar reddening linearly increases with distance until EB−V ∼0.55 is reached at 0.5 kpc. Longward, the further rise of the reddening with distance is very slow, reaching EB−V ∼0.65 at 4 kpc. Only for distances d>6 kpc the reddening increases to EB−V ∼1 (Madsen and Reynolds 2005). Following the results of Reichen et al. (1990), we therefore conclude that ∼1/3 of the total EB−V =0.87 reddening affecting IRC−10443, is of probable circum- stellar origin. 3.5. Distance In a seminal paper, Wood et al. (1999) used MACHO observations of late-type giant variables in LMC to produce a period-luminosity diagram for them, where five separate period-luminosity sequences were identified. Comparing with the model prediction of Wood and Sebo (1996), three of these sequences were found to coincide with the fundamental and first overtones pulsation modes, while the other two seemed to trace the variability induced by ellipsoidal distortion of RGB and AGB giants harbored in binary systems. Since then, the availability of huge sets of data from large micro-lensing sur- 8 Fig. 4. Absolute spectro-photometry of IRC−10443 for 24.97 June 2008 UT (thick line) with superimposed the reference spectrum of a M7III star from the atlas of Fluks et al. (1994) reddened by EB−V =0.87 (thin line). veys (MACHO, OGLE, EROS, MOA) contributed to rapidly refine the picture, with now up to 14 different period-luminosity sequences identified (e.g. Kiss and Bedding 2003, Ita et al. 2004, Soszynski et al. 2005, Soszynski et al. 2007). The most recent calibration of the various period-luminosity relations for late- type giant variables has been presented by Soszynski et al. (2007). Their relation for O-rich semi-regular variables of LMC takes the form Ks = −4.35(log P − 2.0) + 11.25, where Ks band is that of the 2MASS survey. Whitelock et al. (2008) have shown that any chemical abundance effect on the K-band period-luminosity relation of Miras must be small. Working with the revised Hipparcos parallaxes of van Leeuwen (2007), Whitelock et al. (2008) have derived that period-luminosity relation of O-rich Miras in our Galaxy has the same slope and it is 0.1 mag brighter than the corresponding one for the LMC. We assume that a similar 0.1 mag shift would make the Soszynski et al. (2007) relations applicable to the O-rich SRa variables of our Galaxy. Adopting this 0.1 mag shift, a LMC distance modulus of (m - M)◦=18.39 (van Leeuwen et al. 2007), a LMC reddening of EB−V =0.06 (Mateo 1998), the extinction relation AKs = 0.442EB−V for an M-type spectral distribution and a standard RV =3.1 extinction law (Fiorucci and Munari 2003), the distance to IRC−10443 corresponding to the 85.5 day period is 0.5 kpc. Soszynski et al. (2007) relation for the long secondary periods of O-rich red giants in LMC takes the form Ks = −4.41(log P − 2.0) + 15.05, and when applied (with the same 0.1 mag shift as above) to the 620 day secondary periodicity displayed by IRC−10443, it provides the same distance, 0.5 kpc, as obtained for the 85.5 day main period. Such 0.5 kpc distance is adopted for IRC−10443 in this paper. 3.6. On the nature of the long secondary period In spite of large investigation efforts, both observational and theoretical, "the cause of the long secondary periods seen in cool giants remains a mystery at the present time" as recently remarked by Wood (2007). It has been known for a long time that some semi-regular variables shows the presence of a long secondary period (LSP) in their light-curves, typically ten 9 times longer than the primary pulsation period. This ratio for IRC−10443 is 7.25. Lists of local giants displaying LSPs have been published, among others, by Houk (1963), Mattei et al. (1997), Kiss et al. (1999). Wood et al. (1999) found that ∼25% of all variable AGB star in LMC show LSPs. A similar fraction, ≃30%, of local semi-regular variables has been found by Percy et al. (2004) to display LSPs. The semi-regular variables appear to pulsate in the first overtone (Lebzelter and Wood 2006), and thus it could be tempting to relate the LSPs with pulsation in the fundamental mode. How- ever, as found in theoreti- cal models by Fox and Wood (1982) and verified by ob- servations (e.g. Kiss et al. 1999, Mattei et al. 1997), the ratio of fundamental to fist overtone periods is close to two, ruling out that LSPs are due to pulsations in the fundamental mode. Estab- lished observational facts are that LSPs are accompanied by radial velocity variations (of a lower amplitude than observed for the primary pe- riod; Hinkle et al. 2002, Wood et al. 2004) and by variation in intensity of the Hα absorption (that could trace a variable filling by an emission component of chro- mospheric origin; Wood et al. 2004). In addition, cool variable giants showing LSPs rotate at similar velocity and show similar dust-free IRAS colors as cool variable giants not showing the LSPs (Olivier and Wood 2003). In RGB objects showing LSPs, the period of asso- ciated radial velocity variations is twice the period of photometric LSP variability (as expected in the case LSPs arise from ellipsoidally distorted giants in binary systems; Adams et al. 2006), while in AGB objects the period is the same (as expected in the case of pulsations; Wood et al. 2004). Various explanations of the LSP phenomenon have been proposed, but all have encountered some problems, as discussed by Wood (2007, and references therein). reference. All spectra are continuum normalized, offset in ordinates for better visibility, and shifted from Bagnulo et al. (2003) are plotted for Fig. 5. Portion, centered on Hα and CaI 6572.8, of the high resolution 22.95 July 2008 Echelle spectrum of IRC−10443. Spectra of cool giants to 0.0 radial velocity. A striking feature displayed by IRC−10443 is illustrated in the bottom panel of Figure 3, where the color variation is fitted with two sinusoids of the same periods of those fitting the V light-curve (cf Eq. 1 and the top-panel of Figure 3). Their semi-amplitudes are 0.23 mag for the sinusoid associated to the principal 85.5 day period, and 0.13 mag for the LSP, with a mean V − IC=5.19. From Figure 3, it is evident that IRC−10443 is bluest when it is at the maximum brightness along 10 the LSP cycle, and reddest when it is at the minimum brightness. This is the same pattern observed for the principal 85.5 day period and strongly argues in favor of a pulsation interpretation of LSP phenomenon, at least in IRC−10443. The simultaneous presence of two pulsations also accounts for the dispersion of the points in Figure 2 along the back-body curve. The dispersion would have been significantly reduced if only one pulsation would have been present, as confirmed by removing from observations one or the other of the sinusoidal variation of the color and re-plotting Figure 2. The variation in V − IC color can be transformed into variation in effective temperature of the underlying stellar photosphere using the reference continuum energy distribution given by Fluks et al. (1994) along the spectral sequence of M giants. The total amplitude of 0.46 mag observed in V − IC for the principal period, corresponds to a change in 0.73 spectral types around the M7III mean, and therefore to a variation from 3030 to 3175 K in effective temperature. The 0.26 mag total color amplitude of the LSP would correspond to a change of 0.41 spectral types around the M7III mean, meaning a variation from 3060 to 3145 K. If both pulsations are supposed to occur at constant luminosity, the corresponding total excursion in radius is ∼10% for the principal 85.5 day period, and ∼6% for the LSP. These excursions in radius are less than that inferred by Wood et al. (2004) from radial velocity observations at optical wavelengths of a sample of three hot- ter AGB stars characterized by longer LSP than IRC−10443. We estimated the change in effective temperature and radius of the underlying photosphere. If in- stead we had referred to a black-body fitting of the observed optical spectrum of the star (re-shaped by the extremely strong TiO molecular absorptions), the variation in color temperature and radius of IRC−10443 would have been almost twice larger, 150 K and 10 %, respectively. It is worth noticing that recent theoretical improvements in the treatment of pulsation, like inclusion of time dependent turbulent convection (Olivier and Wood 2006), are opening new modeling possibilities for pulsation modes in cool giants. Important applications to the long lasting problem of what is driving the LSPs could be obtained in the near future (cf. Wood 2006). To better characterize the object and increase its interest as a test target for current theories, we plan to continue a tight observational monitoring of IRC−10443 over the next years, long enough to cover at least the whole next LSP period. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. We would like to thank P.A. Whitelock for useful comments on the original version of the paper, the anonymous referee for helpful suggestions, and S. Ciroi, F. Di Mille, S. Tomasoni, F. Moschini and M. Nave for assistance during the observations. REFERENCES Adams E., Wood P. R., Cioni M. R. 2006, MSAIt 77, 537 Bagnulo S., Jehin E., Ledoux C. et al. 2003, Messenger 114, 1 11 Bessell M. S. 2000, PASP 112, 961 Brand J., Blitz L. 1993, A&A 275, 67 Fiorucci M., Munari U. 2003, A&A 401, 781 Fitzgerald M. P. 1970, A&A 4, 234 Fluks M. A., Plez B., The P. S. et al. 1994, A&AS 105, 311 Fox M. W., Wood P. R. 1982, ApJ 259, 198 Ita Y., Tanabe T., Matsunaga N. et al. 2004, MNRAS 353, 705 Johnson H. L. 1966, ARA&A 4, 193 Hansen O. L., Blanco V. M. 1975, AJ 80, 1011 Hinkle K. H., Lebzelter T., Joyce R. R., Fekel F. C. 2002, AJ 123, 1002 Houk N. 1963, AJ 68, 253 Kiss L. L., Szatmry K., Cadmus R. R., Mattei J. A. 1999, A&A 346, 542 Kiss L. L., Bedding, T. R. 2003, MNRAS 343, L79 Kwok S., Volk K., Bidelman W. P. 1997, ApJS 112, 557 Landolt A. U. 1992, AJ 104, 340 Lebzelter T., Wood P. R. 2006, MSAIt 77, 55 Lee T. A. 1970, ApJ 162, 217 Madsen G. J., Reynolds R. J. 2005, ApJ 630, 925 Mateo M. L. 1998, ARA&A 36, 435 Mattei J. A., Foster G., Hurwitz L. A. et al. 1997, in Hipparcos - Venice '97, ESA SP-402, 269 Mikulasek Z., Graf T. 2005, CoSka 35, 83 Nassau J. J., Blanco V. M., Cameron D. M. 1956, ApJ 124, 522 Neckel H. 1958, ApJ 128, 510 Neugebauer G., Leighton R. B. 1969, Two-Micron Sky Survey. A Preliminary Catalogue, NASA SP, Washington Olivier E. A, Wood P. R. 2003, ApJ 584, 1035 Olivier E. A, Wood P. R. 2006, MSAIt 77, 515 Panchuk V. E. 1978, SvAL 4, 201 Percy J. R., Bakos A. G., Besla G. et al. 2004, in Variable Stars in the Local Group, IAU Colloquium 193, D.W. Kurtz and K.R. Pollard eds., ASPC 310, 348 Price S. D., Murdock T. L. 1983, The Revised AFGL I.R. Sky Survey, Catalog and Supplement, Air Force Geophysics Lab. AFGL-IR-83-0161 Reichen M., Lanz T., Golay M., Huguenin D. 1990, Ap&SS 163, 275 Soszynski I., Udalski A., Kubiak M. et al. 2005, AcA 55, 331 Soszynski I., Dziembowski W. A., Udalski A. et al. 2007, AcA 57, 201 van Leeuwen F. 2007, Hipparcos: The New Reduction of the Raw Data, Springer- Verlag van Leeuwen F., Feast M. W., Whitelock P. A., Laney C. D. 2007, MNRAS 379, 12 723 Yamashita Y., Nariai K., Norimoto Y. 1977, An Atlas of Representative Stellar Spectra, Univ. of Tokio Press Whitelock P. A. 1996, in Light Curves of Variable Stars, C.Sterken and C.Jaschek eds., Cambridge Univ. Press Whitelock P. A., Feast M. W., van Leeuwen F. 2008, MNRAS 386, 313 Wood P. R., Sebo K. M. 1996, MNRAS 282, 958 Wood P. R., Alcock C., Allsman R. A. et al. 1999, in Asymptotic Giant Branch Stars, T. Le Bertre, A. Lebre and C. Waelkens eds., IAU Symp 191, 151 Wood P. R., Olivier E. A., Kawaler S. D. 2004, ApJ 604, 800 Wood P. R. 2006, MSAIt 77, 76 Wood P. R. 2007, in The 7th Pacific Rim Conference on Stellar Astrophysics, Y. W. Kang et al. eds., ASPC 362, 234 Zacharias N., Monet D. G., Levine S. E. et al. 2004, AAS 205, 4815
astro-ph/0304009	1	0304	2003-04-01T02:58:37	QSO Lifetimes	[ "astro-ph" ]	The QSO lifetime t_Q is one of the most fundamental quantities for understanding black hole and QSO evolution, yet it remains uncertain by several orders of magnitude. If t_Q is long, then only a small fraction of galaxies went through a luminous QSO phase. In contrast, a short lifetime would require most galaxies today to have undergone a QSO phase in their youth. The current best estimates or constraints on t_Q from black hole demographics and the radiative properties of QSOs vary from at least 10^6 to 10^8 years. This broad range still allows both possibilities: that QSOs were either a rare or a common stage of galaxy evolution. These constraints also do not rule out the possibility that QSO activity is episodic, with individual active periods much shorter than the total active lifetime. In the next few years a variety of additional observational constraints on the lifetimes of QSOs will become available, including clustering measurements and the proximity effect. These new constraints can potentially determine t_Q to within a factor of 3 and therefore answer one of the most fundamental questions in black hole evolution: Do they shine as they grow? This precision will also test the viability of our current model for accretion physics, specifically the radiative efficiency and need for super-Eddington luminosities to explain the black hole population.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies ed. L. C. Ho (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press) QSO Lifetimes PAUL MARTINI The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution of Washington Abstract The QSO lifetime tQ is one of the most fundamental quantities for understanding black hole and QSO evolution, yet it remains uncertain by several orders of magnitude. If tQ is long, then only a small fraction of galaxies went through a luminous QSO phase. In contrast, a short lifetime would require most galaxies today to have undergone a QSO phase in their youth. The current best estimates or constraints on tQ from black hole demographics and the radiative properties of QSOs vary from at least 106 to 108 years. This broad range still allows both possibilities: that QSOs were either a rare or a common stage of galaxy evolution. These constraints also do not rule out the possibility that QSO activity is episodic, with individual active periods much shorter than the total active lifetime. In the next few years a variety of additional observational constraints on the lifetimes of QSOs will become available, including clustering measurements and the proximity effect. These new constraints can potentially determine tQ to within a factor of 3 and therefore answer one of the most fundamental questions in black hole evolution: Do they shine as they grow? This precision will also test the viability of our current model for accretion physics, specifically the radiative efficiency and need for s uper-Eddington luminosities to explain the black hole population. 1.1 Introduction Shortly after the discovery of luminous QSOs, several authors suggested that they could be powered by accretion onto supermassive black holes (e.g., Salpeter 1964; Zel’dovich & Novikov 1964; Lynden-Bell 1969). The strong evidence that dormant, supermassive black holes exist at the centers of all galaxies with a spheroid component (e.g., Richstone et al. 1998) supports this hypothesis and suggests these galaxies go through an optically luminous accretion phase. More recent observations suggest that the masses of supermas- sive black holes are correlated with the sizes of their host galaxy spheroids, which implies some connection between the growth of the subparsec-scale supermassive black holes and the kiloparsec-scale spheroids. The critical parameter for understanding how quickly these present-day black holes grew to their present size is the lifetime of the QSO phase tQ . The QSO lifetime determines the net growth of supermassive black holes during an optically luminous phase. It may also have implications for the growth rate of galactic spheroids. For the purpose of the present review, the lifetime of a QSO is de fined to be the total 1 P. Martini (1.1) amount of time that accretion onto a supermassive black hole is sufficiently luminous to be classified as a QSO — that is, the net time the luminosity in som e wavelength range L > LQ,min , where LQ,min is the minimum luminosity of a QSO. This is an observational de finition, chosen because QSOs are categorized on the basis of luminosity in existing surveys. A more physically motivated de finition of a QSO would de fine the life time as the time a black hole is accreting above some minimum mass accretion rate, or emitting radiation above some minimum fraction of the Eddington luminosity (and this de fin ition would also require a minimum black hole mass), as these two parameters are more directly relevant to the details of the accretion physics. The measured QSO luminosity instead depends on the product of one of these quantities with the black hole mass. A valuable fiducial time scale for supermassive black hole gr owth is the Salpeter (1964) or e-folding time scale: 0.1 (cid:17) (cid:18) L LEdd (cid:19) yr, tS = M/ M = 4.5 × 107 (cid:16) ǫ where ǫ = L/ Mc2 is the radiative efficiency for a QSO radiating at a fraction L/LEdd of the Eddington luminosity. Commonly accepted values of these two key parameters for luminous QSOs are ǫ = 0.1 and L/LEdd = 1. The importance of an optically luminous or QSO mode of black hole growth relative to significantly less efficient , or less luminous modes is not well established, primarily due to uncertainties in these two parameters and the uncertainty in the QSO lifetime. If the QSO lifetime is long, then QSOs were exceptionally rare objects and only a small number of the present-day supermassive black holes went through a QSO phase. In this scenario, essentially all of the mass in these black holes can be accounted for by luminous accretion. The remaining supermassive black holes in other galaxies must instead have accreted their mass through less radiatively efficient or less luminous modes. If instead the QSO lifetime is short, most present-day black holes went through an optically luminous accretion phase, yet this phase made a relatively small contribution to the present masses of the black holes. One long-standing upper limit on the lifetime of QSOs is the lifetime of the entire QSO population. The evolution of the QSO space density is observed to rise and fall on approxi- mately a 109 year time scale (see, e.g., Osmer 2003). More re fined demogra phic arguments, described in detail in the next section, find values on order 1 06 - 107 years. Lower limits to the QSO lifetime are less direct, such as that provided by the proximity effect in the Lyα forest, and they argue for a lower limit of tQ > 104 years. Unlike demographic arguments, which constrain the net time a black hole accretes matter as a luminous QSO, the lower lim- its are based on radiative measures that do not take into account the possibility that a given black hole may go through multiple luminous accretion phases. These radiative methods, described in §1.3, constrain the episodic lifetime of QSOs and place a lower bound on the net lifetime. Observations of QSOs and the less-luminous Seyfert and LINER galaxies demonstrate that AGNs have a range of different accretion mechanisms and these mechanisms depend on AGN luminosity. In the present review I will only discuss the luminous QSOs, de fined to be objects with absolute B magnitude MB > -23 mag. These objects may form a relatively homogeneous subclass of AGNs that accrete at an approximately fixed fraction of the Ed- dington rate with constant radiative efficiency. This lumin osity limit corresponds to L ≈ LEdd for a 107 M⊙ black hole. 2 P. Martini 1.2 The Net Lifetime The main methods used to estimate the net lifetime of QSOs are demographic es- timates, which typically take one of two forms: integral or counting. Integral estimates are based on the integrated properties of QSOs over the age of the Universe, while counting ar- guments compare the numbers of objects at different epochs. The classic integral constraint on tQ is that the amount of matter accreted onto QSOs during their lifetime tQ , as represented by the luminosity density due to accretion, should be less than or equal to the space density of remnant black holes in the local Universe (So łtan 1982). T his type of estimate is most sensitive to the assumed value of the radiative efficiency ǫ. One example of a counting ar- gument is to ask what value of tQ is require if all bright galaxies go through a QSO phase in their youth (e.g., Rees 1984). Counting arguments are not sensitive to ǫ, but are affected by the assumed value of L/LEdd and galaxy (black hole) mergers. The predicted upper bound for ǫ is 0.3, attained in models of thin disk accretion onto a maximally rotating Kerr black hole (Thorne 1974). The value of ǫ is more commonly set to 0.1, based on expectations for thin-disk accretion onto a non-rotating black hole. Deter- mination of L/LEdd is more tractable observationally, at least once the mass of the central black hole is known. The most common assumption is that L/LEdd ∼ 1 for luminous QSOs. If they are substantially sub-Eddington, then this implies the presence of a population of massive (> 1010 M⊙ ) black holes not seen in the Universe today. In contrast, substantial super-Eddington luminosities (greater than a factor of a few) have historically been consid- ered unlikely due to the limitations of radiation pressure that de fine the Eddington limit. However, recent work has suggested that the Eddington luminosity could be exceeded by as much as a factor of 100 in some objects due to small-scale inhomogeneities in thin accretion disks (Begelman 2002). The demographic constraint set by the evolution of the entire QSO population, tQ ≤ 109 years, is essentially the only demographic constraint on tQ that does not depend on some assumptions about the parameters ǫ and L/LEdd and is neither a counting nor an integral constraint. If the conventional values for these parameters are assumed and tQ = 109 years, then the black holes in QSOs grow by ∼ 25 e-folds during this QSO phase. This rapid, pro- longed growth would produce a population of extremely massive black holes (> 1010 M⊙ ) that have not been observed in the local Universe (Cavaliere & Padovani 1988, 1989), as- suming the initial black hole seeds are stellar remnants with M > 1 M⊙ . A simple counting argument was considered by Richstone et al. (1998), who compared the space density of QSOs at z ≈ 3 to supermassive black holes in the local Universe. As the space density of QSOs at their peak is approximately 10-3 times that of present-day supermassive black holes, the implied lifetime is tQ ≈ 106 years. This lifetime is much shorter than the Salpeter time scale and therefore implies that only a small percentage of the present-day mass in black holes was accreted during the QSO epoch. 1.2.1 QSO Evolution and the Local Black Hole Population Many more detailed demographic models have been put forth, particularly in the last decade (Small & Blandford 1992; Haehnelt & Rees 1993; Haehnelt, Natarajan, & Rees 1998; Salucci et al. 1999; Yu & Tremaine 2002). These models are mostly based on counting arguments that simultaneously address the present-day black hole mass function and the space density evolution of QSOs with a recipe for the luminosity evolution and growth of 3 P. Martini Fig. 1.1. History of accretion onto supermassive black holes by optically luminous QSOs (from Yu & Tremaine, their Fig. 1). supermassive black holes in the QSO phase. Haiman & Loeb (1998) and Haehnelt et al. (1998) find that they can match the present-day black hole mas s function and the QSO luminosity function at z = 3 with tQ between 106 and 108 years, depending on the relationship between the mass of the central black hole and the host halo. They describe how a lifetime as short as 106 years requires that much of the present-day black hole mass is not accreted as an optically luminous QSO. Yu & Tremaine (2002; see also Yu 2003) develop a similar model that is a variation on So łtan’s (1982) integral approach using new data for the p resent-day black hole mass function, as well as the luminosity function and space density evolution of QSOs. They calculate the present-day black hole mass function with the M• - σ relation (Ferrarese & Merrit 2000; Gebhardt et al. 2000) and velocity dispersion measurements for a large number of elliptical galaxies and massive spheroids from the SDSS (Bernardi et al. 2003) and take the QSO luminosity function from the 2dF (Boyle et al. 2000) and the Large Bright QSO Survey (Hewett, Foltz, & Chaffee 1995). Their estimate of the current mass density in black 0.65 M⊙Mpc3 . This can be compared to the integrated holes is ρQSO (z = 0) = (2.5 ± 0.4) × 105h2 • mass accretion onto black holes due to luminous QSOs, which they calculate to be (1 - ǫ)Lbol d z Z ∞ •,acc (z) = Z ∞ ρQSO ǫc2 0 z where Φ(L, z) is the QSO luminosity function. The total mass density accreted by optically •,acc (z = 0) = 2.1 × 105(CB/11.8)[0.1(1 - ǫ)/ǫ] M⊙Mpc3 , where CB luminous QSOs is then ρQSO is the bolometric correction in the B band scaled by the value of 11.8 calculated by Elvis et al. (1994). The cumulative accretion history they derive is shown in Figure 1.1. Note that half of the total mass density accreted by QSOs occurred by z ≈ 1.9. The mean lifetime of QSOs above some black hole mass is then approximately equal to the integrated luminosity of accreted matter by these black holes, divided by their space density: Φ(L, z)dL, d t d z (1.2) 4 P. Martini Fig. 1.2. Mean QSO lifetime from Yu & Tremaine (2002; their Fig. 5). The two lines represent the calculated lifetime for two values for the radiative efficiency ǫ. The solid parts of the lines show the range of local black hole masses estimated from observations of early-type galaxies. The dotted lines represent regions where the local black hole mass function and QSO luminosity function were extrapolated. The two horizontal, dashed lines are the Salpeter time scale for ǫ = 0.3 and 0.1. . (1.3) L(M• ) dL R t0 τ (> M• ) ≃ R ∞ Φ(L, t )d t 0 nearly R ∞ • , t0 )dM ′ (M ′ M• M• • This method is therefore essentially an integral method, but by considering the lifetime above a range of black hole masses Yu & Tremaine (2002) capture some of the elements of a counting argument as well. Figure 1.2 shows the mean lifetime derived by Yu & Tremaine (2002) as a function of black hole mass for two values of the radiative efficiency. The solid lines mark the range of black hole mass constrained by the velocity dispersions of early- type galaxies. The dotted lines are based on extrapolations of the local black hole mass function and the luminosity function of QSOs. This calculation assumes that QSOs are radiating at the Eddington luminosity and that the spectral energy distributions of the entire QSO population are well represented by the Elvis et al. (1994) sample. For ǫ = 0.1 - 0.3 and 108 < M• < 109 M⊙ , Yu & Tremaine calculate that the mean QSO lifetime lies in the range tQ = 3 - 13 × 107 years. For the standard radiative efficiency of ǫ = 0.1 and a bolometric correction CB = 11.8, optically selected QSOs can account for ∼ 75% of the current matter density in black holes. The X-ray and infrared backgrounds offer a potentially better constraint on the total mass accretion onto black holes, as these wavelengths are less susceptible to obscured or highly beamed AGNs. Barger et al. (2001) combined these multiple backgrounds and estimated ρ•,acc ≈ 9 × 105 (0.1/ǫ) M⊙Mpc3 , higher than Yu & Tremaine’s estimate due to optically selected QSOs alone. The discrepancy may be due to a genuine population of obscured AGN, but then comparison of this higher accreted mass density with that estimated for local black holes implies ǫ ≥ 0.3, in con flict with the maximum efficiency estimated for accre tion onto a Kerr black hole. Other potential causes of this discrepancy include (1) uncertainties 5 P. Martini in the local black hole mass density, which has been extrapolated to M• < 108 M⊙ and M• > 109 M⊙ , (2) a different population responsible for these backgrounds, (3) the possibility of a free- floating supermassive black hole population that has been ejected from galaxies, and (4) the possibility that a significant amount of black hole ma ss has been lost as gravitational radiation in mergers. 1.2.2 Coevolution of QSOs, Black Holes, and Galaxies An alternative approach to modeling the coevolution of QSOs, black holes, and galaxies is to build detailed models with some adjustable parameters and ask what the life- time is in that context. This is the approach adopted by Kauffmann & Haehnelt (2000), who model the formation of QSOs during major mergers of gas-rich galaxies. Any merger between galaxies with a mass ratio greater than 0.3 results in some fraction Macc of gas accreted onto the black hole over a time scale tQ . The galaxy mergers and their cold gas con- tent are then obtained from their semi-analytic model of galaxy evolution, combined with the merging history of dark matter halos from extended Press-Schechter (1974) theory. Kauffmann & Haehnelt let the peak luminosity of each QSO scale as the mass of gas accreted onto the central black hole, which in turn scales as the mass of available cold gas in the merger and the lifetime of the accretion phase. The radiative efficiency is taken to be constant and chosen so that the most luminous QSOs do not exceed the Eddington luminosity. The luminosities of QSOs after the merger do not remain constant, but decline exponentially from their peak on a time scale tQ . While their high-redshift QSOs emit at close to the Eddington luminosity, the QSOs at low redshift have L/LEdd = 0.01 - 0.1. In addition to a QSO lifetime that is constant with redshift, these authors also parametrize the lifetime to scale as the dynamical time: tQ (z) = tQ (0) (1 + z)-1.5, where tQ (0) is the lifetime at z = 0. The lifetime that best fits the evolution of the QSO popula tion, the merger history of galaxies, and the evolution of their cold gas fraction is tQ (0) = 3 × 107 years (for a given merger event). 1.3 Limits on Episodic Activity 1.3.1 QSOs and Starbursts The presence of many QSOs in merging systems and the detection of luminous hard X-ray emission from the cores of some merging galaxies strongly suggest that at least some QSOs are triggered by interactions of giant, gas-rich galaxies. The merging process removes angular momentum from a significant fraction of the t wo galaxies’ ISM, leading it to flow inward toward the circumnuclear region and central black hole. This angular momentum loss is a natural mechanism to ignite QSO activity, as well as significant amounts of circumnuclear star formation. In extreme circumstances Norman & Scoville (1988) proposed that mass loss from a sufficiently large star cluster formed in such a merger may pr ovide a continuous fuel supply for a long tQ . These authors specifically explore the implications of a st ar cluster of mass 4 × 109M⊙ within the central 10 pc of the merger remnant. In ∼ 108 years, mass loss from this cluster can power accretion rates of up to 10M⊙ yr-1 , corresponding to QSO luminosities L > 1012L⊙ due to the black hole alone, and much higher than the stellar luminosity of the 6 P. Martini central star cluster. This model therefore predicts an episodic QSO lifetime of ∼ 108 years after a major merger between two massive, gas-rich galaxies. A number of examples of so-called transition QSOs, which show evidence for recent and substantial star formation, were studied in detail by Canalizo & Stockton (2001). They derived ages for the post-starburst population as high as 300 Myr in some objects, while Brotherton et al. (1999) derived an age of 400 Myr for the post-starburst population in UN J1025-0040. If the the QSO and starburst were triggered at the same time, the implied lifetimes for the QSOs are greater than a few ×108 years. Kawakatu, Umemura, & Mori (2003) recently considered a similar coevolution model for black holes and galaxies. They model the formation and growth of the central black hole via radiation drag on the host galaxy ISM. This process gradually increases the mass of the central black hole for ∼ 108 years, during which time the galaxy may appear as an ultraluminous infrared galaxy. Once the central region is no longer obscured, the galaxy appears as an optically identifiable QSO. This evolutionary scenario corresponds to a great deal of supermassive black hole growth, which these authors propose would lead to larger velocities in the broad-line region. 1.3.2 Size of Narrow-Line Regions The size of the narrow-line region (NLR) around AGNs potentially provides a straightforward, geometric estimate of their lifetime. Bennert et al. (2002) recently studied a sample of Seyferts and QSOs and found that the size of the NLR increases approximately as the square root of the [O III] luminosity and the square root of an estimate of the Hβ lu- minosity. For a constant ionization parameter, electron density, and covering factor, the size of the ionized region should scale as the square root of the luminosity. The NLR is therefore ionization bounded and the size of the ionized region sets a lower limit to the lifetime of the ionizing source. As the most luminous QSOs in their sample have NLRs approximately 10 kpc in radius, the episodic lifetime of the most luminous QSOs must be greater than 3 × 104 yr. 1.3.3 Lengths of Jets Jets are another macroscopic product of accretion onto a supermassive black hole. Their expansion time therefore sets a lower limit to the lifetime of the accretion. The main uncertainty in the use of jets to constrain the lifetime is the expansion speed, although the lengths of the jets themselves are also somewhat uncertain due to the unknown inclination angle. The expansion speed of jets as a population can be estimated by the mean ratio of the length of the jet to the counterjet (Longair & Riley 1979), although this requires that we assume that all jets have the same expansion speed. For an expansion speed υ = β c and inclination to the line of sight θ, the observed length ratio of the jet to counterjet (following Scheuer 1995) is Q = (1 + β cos θ)/(1 - β cos θ). (1.4) If we assume that the inclination angle of the population is uniformly distributed between zero and θmax degrees, the mean of log Q in the limit of small β is 7 (1.5) β 2 (1 + cos2 θmax )...]. P. Martini hln Qi = β (1 + cos θmax )[1 + 1 6 Combining studies of radio jets by a number of authors, Scheuer (1995) obtains β = 0.03 ± 0.02 and sets strong bounds on β such that 0 < β < 0.15. Blundell, Rawlings, & Willott (1999) compiled data from three separate, flux-limited ra- dio surveys and studied the evolution of the classical double population, using this large database to decouple redshift and luminosity degeneracies. With the expansion speed con- straints of Scheuer (1995), they find ages for classical doub le sources as large as a few ×108 years in the lowest redshift sample (such large sources are selected against at higher redshift due to the steepening of their spectra). The existence of these objects therefore appears to set a long lower limit to the lifetime of nuclear activity. The main caveat in the use of maximum jet lengths to place lower limits on the episodic lifetime of QSOs is that jets are commonly found in very low-luminosity AGNs, and not only in systems of QSO luminosities. While nearly all of the sources used in Scheuer’s study had QSO luminosities, this is not true of all of the sources studied by Blundell et al. (1999). The lifetime derived from the lengths of jets therefore do not exclude the possibility that a high-luminosity QSO phase is a relatively short-lived stage in the lifetime of an AGN. 1.3.4 Proximity Effect QSOs can create a sphere of ionized matter in their vicinity whose radius is set by the episodic lifetime or recombination time scale, whichever is shorter. This ionized region is observed as the proximity effect in the Lyα forest (Bajtlik, Duncan, & Ostriker 1988; Scott et al. 2000), which quantifies the decrease in the numbe r of neutral hydrogen clouds of a given column density per unit redshift in the vicinity of the QSO. In order to produce this zone of increased ionization and decreased number density of the high-column density Lyα forest clouds, the ionization field from the QSO must have bee n operating for at least the recombination time scale of these relatively high-column density clouds. Because the proximity effect is observed along the line of sight to the QSO, the physical extent of the region only depends on the observed luminosity of the QSO, and not the episodic lifetime. The equilibration time scale for Lyα clouds is: -1 τ ≡ nHI (cid:18) d nHI d t (cid:19) where nHI is the number density of neutral hydrogen atoms. The relevant time scale is τ = 1 × 104(1 + ω )-1J -1 21 where ω is the increase in ionizing flux due to the QSO relative to the b ackground and J21 the intensity of the background ionizing radiation at the Lyman-limit in units of 10-21 erg cm-2 Hz-1 sr-1 . The equilibration time scale is ∼ 104 years for typical values of ω and J21 . (1.6) (1.7) , yr, 1.4 Future Prospects 1.4.1 Luminous QSOs at z > 6 Observation of QSOs in the early Universe when the optical depth in neutral hydro- gen is large (z > 6) offers a more powerful constraint on the lifetime than the proximity effect 8 P. Martini because these QSOs exist in a neutral, predominantly lower-density IGM. Above z ≈ 6, the Gunn-Peterson trough in the IGM will erase all flux blueward o f Lyα in the absence of ion- ization of the surrounding medium by the QSO, i.e. an H II region. The size of this region is set by the lifetime of the QSO as the sole ionizing source, unlike the case for the proximity effect, where the lifetime is only constrained to be the recombination time because only high density regions remain to be (re)ionized. Haiman & Cen (2002; see also Haiman & Loeb 2001) applied this concept to the z = 6.28 QSO SDSS 1030+0524. They used the expected density distribution of the IGM with a hydrodynamic simulation (Cen & McDonald 2002) and found that a quasar lifetime of 2 × 107 years and an H II region ∼ 4.5 Mpc (proper) radius produced a good match to the observed flux in SDSS 1030+524 blueward of Ly α. The masses of the black holes powering QSOs such as this one and others with z > 6 provide some additional information on the early evolution of QSOs. For example, one of the key conclusions of Haiman & Cen (2002) was that the z = 6.28 QSO was not significantly lensed or beamed. Therefore if the QSO is shining at or below the Eddington rate, the mass of the central black hole is on order 2 × 109 M⊙ . The other z > 6 QSOs discovered by the SDSS have comparable luminosities, and therefore are presumably similarly massive. To form such a massive black hole at this early epoch requires that it has been accreting at the Eddington rate for nearly the lifetime of the Universe, less than 109 years at z = 6 assuming ǫ = 0.1, L ≈ LEdd , and a 100 M⊙ seed. Depending on the mass of the seed black hole population, either the QSO lifetime must be quite long or super-Eddington accretion must occur in the early Universe. 1.4.2 Transverse Proximity Effect The proximity effect can be used to set a stronger constraint on the episodic lifetime with a direct measure of its extent in the plane of the sky. This measurement could be made through observations of multiple QSOs that lie in close proximity on the sky. The proximity effect due to a lower-redshift QSO in the spectrum of higher-redshift QSO would provide a lower limit on the lifetime of the lower-redshift QSO equal to the time required to ionize the intervening neutral medium, where the ionization front expands at a speed υ ≃ c in the primarily low-density IGM. The angular diameter distance between the two QSOs is then a lower-limit to the lifetime. Such a measurement was first dis cussed by Bajtlik et al. (1988), although in practice the statistical significance of the pro ximity effect in neutral hydrogen of any given QSO at z < 6 is sufficiently weak that this measurement would require co mbining data from large numbers of QSOs to obtain a mean lower limit to the episodic lifetime. The proximity effect in neutral hydrogen is difficult to meas ure because its mean opacity of the intergalactic medium is so low (at least below z ≈ 6) and the recombination times for the remaining neutral, high-density clouds are quite short. Helium offers a better chance of success as the mean opacity of neutral helium is quite high above z ≈ 2.9. Individual helium ionizing sources, i.e. QSOs, above this redshift will therefore produce distinct opacity gaps. Unfortunately, relatively few He II opacity gaps are known as the He II Lyα λ304 Å line is still in the space UV regime at z ≈ 3. Current instrumentation therefore requires them to be observed in the spectra of very bright QSOs. These systems are also easily obscured by the much more common Lyman-limit systems. There are currently five known helium absorption systems in t he spectra of four QSOs. 9 P. Martini These systems offer potentially excellent lower limits on the episodic lifetime if the origins of these systems are identified with QSOs a significant distan ce from the He II system. Jakobsen et al. (2003) identified such a candidate QSO for the He II opacity gap at z ≈ 3.056 in the spectrum of the z = 3.256 QSO Q0302-003. They identified a z = 3.050 ± 0.003 QSO at the approximate redshift of the helium feature with an angular separation of 6.′5 from the line of sight to Q0302-003. If the new QSO is responsible for the helium opacity gap, then the light travel time sets a lower limit of tQ > 107 yr. The widths of all of the known He II opacity gaps are ∆z ≃ 0.01 - 0.02, which corresponds to a size of 2 - 5 Mpc (Jakobsen et al. 2003). These sizes set a strong lower limit of ∼ 106 years for the lifetime of the ionizing source. An alternative explanation of these opacity gaps is that they are due to low-density regions in the IGM. Heap et al. (2000) studied the opacity gap in Q0302-003 and argue against this interpretation, as their simulations cannot reproduce the distribution and amplitude of the gap with a low-density region. 1.4.3 Clustering The clustering of QSOs can provide a strong constraint on their net lifetime , under the assumption that QSOs reside in the most massive dark matter halos. If QSOs are long- lived, then they need only reside in the most massive, and therefore most strongly clustered, halos in order to match the observed space density of luminous QSOs. In contrast, if QSOs are short-lived phenomena, then a much larger population of host halos is required to match the observed QSO space density at the epoch of observation. As this large population of hosts will be dominated by less massive halos, due to the shape of the halo mass function, the QSO population will not be as strongly clustered. These simple arguments therefore predict that the larger the observed correlation length, the longer the lifetime of QSOs (Haehnelt et al. 1998). Martini & Weinberg (2001) calculated the expected relation between QSO clustering and lifetime in detail in anticipation of forthcoming measurements from the 2dF and SDSS col- laborations (see also Haiman & Hui 2001). The main assumptions of this model are that the luminosity of a QSO is a monotonic function of the mass of its host dark matter halo and that all sufficiently massive halos go through a QSO phase. Fo r some absolute magnitude- limited sample of QSOs at redshift z, the probability that a given halo currently hosts a QSO is simply tQ/tH , where tH is the lifetime of the host halo. The QSO therefore does not nec- essarily turn on when the halo forms, which differs slightly from the model developed by Haehnelt et al. (1998). Calculation of the clustering corresponding to some lifetime tQ requires knowledge of the minimum halo mass, which can be found by setting the integral of the mass function of dark matter halos, multiplied by the fraction that host QSOs, equal to the observed space density Φ(z): dM n(M , z). tQ tH (M , z) Φ(z) = Z ∞ Mmin The halo lifetime tH depends on both the halo mass and redshift and was calculated by solving for the median time a halo of mass M at redshift z will survive until it is incorporated into a new halo of mass 2M . The mass function of dark matter halos n(M , z) is calculated with the Press-Schechter formalism: (1.8) 10 (1.9) ρ0 M δc (z) σ2 (M ) dσ(M ) dM P. Martini exp (cid:20)- δ 2 n(M , z) dM = -r 2 c (z) 2σ2 (M ) (cid:21) dM . π The predicted clustering of QSOs depends directly on the minimum halo mass. The bias factor for halos of a given mass was calculated by Mo & White (1996) as δc,0 (cid:20) δ 2 b(M , z) = 1 + 1 c (z) - 1(cid:21) . σ2 (M ) The effective bias factor for the host halo population is then the integral of the bias factor for all masses greater than Mmin and weighted by the halo number density and lifetime: -1 n(M , z) b(M , z)n(M , z) tH (M , z) (cid:19) (cid:18)Z ∞ beff (Mmin , z) = (cid:18)Z ∞ tH (M , z) (cid:19) Mmin Mmin The clustering amplitude of QSOs can be parametrized as the radius of a top-hat sphere in which the rms fluctuations of QSO number counts σQ is unity: (1.10) dM dM . (1.11) σQ (r1 , z) = beff (Mmin , z) σ(r1 ) D(z) = 1, (1.12) where σ(r1 ) is the rms linear mass fluctuation in spheres of radius r1 at z = 0 and D(z) is the linear growth factor. The radius r1 is similar to the correlation length r0 , at which the correlation function ξ (r) is unity, but can be determined more robustly because it is an integrated quantity and does not require fitting ξ (r). For some specified cosmology and comoving QSO space density, r1 depends directly on tQ . Figure 1.3 shows the minimum mass, effective bias factor, and r1 as a function of tQ for a range of cosmologies at z = 2, 3, and 4. The bottom panels, which show the relationship between r1 and tQ , demonstrate that the clustering length increases as a function of QSO lifetime and that the clustering length can be used to obtain a good estimate of the lifetime if the cosmological parameters are relatively well known. The difference in the relationship between r1 and tQ as a function of redshift mostly re flects the evolution in the QSO space density (taken from Warren, Hewett, & Osmer 1994). QSOs are rarer at z = 4 than at z = 2 or 3 and therefore the observed space density can be matched with a larger Mmin at the same tQ . At all of these redshifts the most massive halos correspond to the masses of individual galaxy halos. At lower redshifts, the most massive halos could contain multiple galaxies and the assumption of one QSO per halo may break down. The relation between clustering and lifetime is much shallower for the ΩM = 1 models because of their smaller mass fluctuations. For these models the values of Mmin also lie out on the steep, high-mass tail of the halo mass function, where a smaller change in Mmin is required to compensate for the same change in tQ . The relationship between lifetime and clustering is sensitive to several model details, which can be used to either determine the precision of the estimated lifetime or observa- tionally test and further re fine the relation. One uncertain ty lies in the de finition of the halo lifetime, which was taken to be the median time before the halo was incorporated into a new halo of twice the original mass. If the de finition were increa sed to a factor of five increase in mass (a strong upper limit), then the QSO lifetimes corresponding to the same observed r1 would increase by a factor of 2 - 4. Another potential complication is that the correlation between halo mass and QSO luminosity is not perfect. Scatter in this relation will lead to the inclusion of a larger number of less massive halos in an absolute-magnitude limited sample 11 P. Martini Fig. 1.3. Minimum halo mass, effective bias, and clustering length as a function of tQ for a range of CDM models at z = 2, 3, and 4 (from Martini & Weinberg 2001; their Fig. 7). of QSOs. Because this scatter always serves to increase the number of lower-mass halos, it decreases the clustering signal from the ideal case of a strict relationship and effectively makes the clustering predictions in Figure 1.3 into lower limits for tQ for a measured r1 . The presence of scatter in this relation could be determined and measured observationally. In the absence of scatter, there should be a direct relationship between the clustering length and QSO luminosity at fixed redshift. The presence of scatter wil l flatten the predicted relation between clustering and luminosity and could be used to estimate and correct for the amount of scatter in the determination of tQ . This model also assumes that the luminosity evolution of QSOs is a step function, that is they are either on at some constant luminosity, or off. If QSOs are instead triggered by a mechanism that drives a great deal of fuel toward the center, such as a galaxy merger, this fuel supply will probably gradually diminishes over time and cause the fading of the QSO. An alternative parameterization of QSO luminosity evolution, employed by Haehnelt et al. (1998) is an exponential decay: L(t ) ∝ exp(-t /tQ ). Martini & Weinberg (2001) found that if this luminosity evolution is used instead of the “on-off ” mo del, and tQ rede fined to represent 12 P. Martini Fig. 1.4. Clustering length vs. tQ for the ΛCDM model for two luminosity evolu- tion models and three values of the space density (from Martini & Weinberg 2001; their Fig. 8). the e-folding time of the QSO, there is very little change in the relation between tQ and r1 (see Fig. 1.4). This figure also demonstrates the scalable nature of the model to QSO surveys with different absolute magnitude limits. A decrease in the absolute magnitude limit is equivalent to increasing the space density of QSOs and therefore the number of lower-mass halos. To first approximation, increasing the space density of the sam ple by a factor of 10 corresponds to a factor of 10 longer lifetime at fixed r1 . These results scale in a similar manner if QSOs are beamed. If QSOs are only visible through some beaming angle fB , then the space density needs to be corrected by a factor f -1 B before the QSO lifetime can be determined from the clustering. The 2dF and SDSS surveys will provide the best measurements of QSO clustering to date. Preliminary results from these surveys (Croom et al. 2001; Fan 2003) indicate that r0 ≈ 6h-1Mpc, or r1 ≈ 9h-1Mpc for ξ (r) = (r/r0 )-1.8 . This corresponds to a lifetime of tQ ≈ 106 years. A much larger correlation length r0 = 17.5 ± 7.5h-1Mpc (Stephens et al. 1997) was measured in the Palomar Transit Grism Survey (Schneider, Schmidt, & Gunn 1994). This high correlation length may be a statistical anomaly as it is only based on three QSO pairs, but could also be a consequence of the very high luminosity threshold of the survey. 13 P. Martini Table 1.1. Constraints on the QSO Lifetime Method Net/Episodic Lifetime [yr] Current: Evolution Local Black Holes Merger Scenario Mergers & Starbursts Proximity Effect Radio Jets Net Net Net Episodic Episodic Episodic < 109 107 - 108 few ×107 few ×108 > 104 few ×108 Future: QSOs at z > 6 Transverse Proximity Effect Clustering Episodic Episodic Net few ×107? 107 ?? 106 - 107 ?? 1.5 Summary Current estimates of the QSO lifetime lie in the range tQ = 106 - 108 years, still uncertain by several orders of magnitude. Estimates of the net lifetime are primarily de- mographic and rely on assumptions about the radiative effici ency of accretion ǫ and the luminosity of QSOs relative to the Eddington rate L/LEdd . The new models developed in the last few years (Kauffmann & Haehnelt 2000; Yu & Tremaine 2002) have started to relax the common assumptions about the values of ǫ and L/LEdd , but a complex relationship between ǫ, L/LEdd , and M• has by no means been ruled out. While the physics of the accretion process and the potential for significant obscured black hole growth may appear daunting obstacles, there are reasons for optimism. Demographic estimates of the net lifetime will be substantially improved as more supermassive black hole masses are measured and the validity of the M• - σ relation better established, including its application to active galaxies. Measurement of the black hole mass in more QSOs via reverberation mapping (e.g., Barth 2003), or estimates using the M• - σ method will lead to direct estimates of L/LEdd for many QSOs. These steps will help to eliminate some of the main uncertainties in the value or range of L/LEdd and the local mass density of supermassive black holes. Finally, measurement of a significant number of redshifts for the sources that comprise the hard X-ray and sub-mm background will greatly improve the integral constraint provided by the net luminosity from accretion. Many of these new observations could be realized in the next several years and reduce the need for sweeping assumptions about ǫ or L/LEdd . The current best estimates or limits for the episodic lifetime are consistent with a wider range of tQ than the net lifetime, but constraints from the proximity effect in the Lyα forest do point to tQ > 104 years. Observations of QSOs when the opacities of neutral helium and hydrogen was much higher suggest much longer episodic lifetimes, although to date are still only based on observations of two QSOs. Constraints such as these on the episodic lifetime provide a valuable complement to the primarily demographic estimates of the net 14 P. Martini lifetime, as they do not depend on assumptions of accretion physics, but instead on much more straightforward radiation physics. The next few years offer the hope of tremendous progress in measurement of the QSO lifetime via a variety of techniques. The discovery of additional QSOs associated with He II absorption systems (and hopefully more of these systems), as well as additional QSOs at high redshift z > 6, could provide quite strong lower limits to the episodic lifetime, while clustering measurements hold great promise to constrain the net lifetime. As the clustering method does not depend on assumptions about accretion physics, it will provide a valuable complement to the present demographic approaches. This potential progress suggests that tQ could be determined to within a factor of 3 in the next three years, which is sufficient precision to addres s some fundamental questions on the growth of black holes and the physics of the accretion process. One important advance will be to determine if the QSO lifetime determined via clustering is in agreement with that estimated via black hole demographics. As these models employ an independent set of assumptions, these measurements could provide strong evidence that ǫ ≈ 0.1 and L/LEdd ≈ 1 are valid choices. Measurement of tQ will also determine if a luminous QSO phase was the dominant growth mechanism for present-day supermassive black holes. If tQ > 4 × 107 yr, then a substan- tial fraction of the black hole mass in QSO hosts was accreted via this optically luminous mechanism. However, such a long lifetime would also imply that QSOs were quite rare phenomena and only a small fraction of present-day supermassive black holes were created as QSOs. The remainder may have been identifiable as AGN, or we re heavily obscured, but would not have been classified as optically luminous QSOs. If instead tQ is shorter than the Salpeter time scale, then hosting a short-lived QSO phase was a relatively common occurrence. However, only a small fraction of the present-day black hole mass was accreted during this time and the remainder must have occurred via a less luminous, or less radiatively efficient, mode of accret ion, either before or after the QSO epoch. This could then imply that advection-dominated accretion (e.g., Narayan, Mahade- van, & Quataert 1998) or in flow-outflow solutions (Blandford & Begelman 1999) played a significant role in black hole growth. I would like to thank Zoltán Haiman and David Weinberg for helpful comments on this manuscript. I am also grateful to Luis Ho for inviting and encouraging me to prepare this review. References Bajtlik, S., Duncan, R. C., & Ostriker, J. P. 1988, ApJ, 327, 570 Barger, A. J., Cowie, L. L., Bautz, M. W., Brandt, W. N., Garmire, G. P., Hornschemeier, A. E., Ivison, R. J., & Owen, F. N. 2001, AJ, 122, 2177 Barth, A. J. 2003, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Pasadena: Carnegie Observatories, http://www.ociw.edu/ociw/symposia/series/symposium1/proceedings.html) Begelman, M. C. 2002, ApJ, 568, L97 Bennert, N., Falcke, H., Schulz, H., Wilson, A. S., & Wills, B. J. 2002, ApJ, 574, L105 Bernardi, M., et al. 2003, AJ, 125, 1817 Blandford, R. D., & Begelman, M. C. 1999, MNRAS, 303, L1 Blundell, K. M., Rawlings, S., & Willott, C. J. 1999, AJ, 117, 677 15 P. Martini Boyle, B. J, Shanks, T., Croom, S. M., Smith, R. J., Miller, L., Loaring, N., & Heymans, C. 2000, MNRAS, 317, 1014 Brotherton, M. S., et al. 1999, ApJ, 520, L87 Canalizo, G., & Stockton, A. 2001, ApJ, 555, 719 Cavaliere, A., & Padovani, P. 1988, ApJ, 333, L33 —. 1989, ApJ, 340, L5 Cen, R., & McDonald, P. 2002, ApJ, 570, 457 Croom, S. M., Boyle, B. J., Loaring, N. S., Miller, L., Outram, P. J., Shanks, T., & Smith, R. J. 2002, MNRAS, 335, 459 Elvis, M., et al. 1994, ApJS, 95, 1 Fan, X. 2003, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Pasadena: Carnegie Observatories, http://www.ociw.edu/ociw/symposia/series/symposium1/proceedings.html) Ferrarese, L., & Merritt, D. 2000, ApJ, 539, L9 Gebhardt, K., et al. 2000, ApJ, 539, L13 Haehnelt, M.. & Natarajan, P., & Rees, M. J. 1998, MNRAS, 300, 817 Haehnelt, M., & Rees, M. J. 1993, MNRAS, 263, 168 Haiman, Z., & Cen, R. 2002, ApJ, 578, 702 Haiman, Z., & Hui, L. 2001, ApJ, 547, 27 Haiman, Z., & Loeb, A. 1998, ApJ, 503, 505 —. 2001, ApJ, 552, 459 Heap, S. R., Williger, G. M., Smette, A., Hubeny, I., Sahu, M., Jenkins, E. B., Tripp, T. M., & Winkler, J. N. 2000, ApJ, 534, 69 Hewett, P. C., Foltz, C. B. „ & Chaffee, F. H. 1995, AJ, 109, 149 8 Jakobsen, P., Jansen, R. A., Wagner, S., & Reimers, D. 2003, å , 397, 891 Kauffmann, G., & Haehnelt, M. 2000, MNRAS, 311, 576 Kawakatu, N., Umemura, M., & Mori, M. 2003, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Pasadena: Carnegie Observatories, http://www.ociw.edu/ociw/symposia/series/symposium1/proceedings.html) Longair, M. S., & Riley, J. M. 1979, MNRAS, 188, 625 Lynden-Bell, D. 1969, Nature, 223, 690 Martini, P., & Weinberg, D. H. 2001, ApJ, 547, 12 Mo, H. J., & White, S. D. M. 1996, MNRAS, 282, 347 Narayan, R., Mahadevan, R., & Quataert, E. 1998, in The Theory of Black Hole Accretion Discs, ed. M. A. Abramowicz, G. Björnsson, & J. E. Pringle (Cambridge: Cambr idge Univ. Press), 148 Norman, C. A., & Scoville, N. Z. 1988, ApJ, 332, 124 Osmer, P. S. 2003, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press) Press, W. H., & Schechter, P. 1974, ApJ, 187, 425 Rees, M. J. 1984, ARA&A, 22, 471 Richstone, D.O., et al. 1998, Nature, 395, A14 Salpeter, E. E. 1964, ApJ, 140, 796 Salucci, P., Szuszkiewicz, E., Monaco, P., & Danese, L. 1999, MNRAS, 307, 637 Scheuer, P. A. G. 1995, MNRAS, 277, 331 Schneider, D. P., Schmidt, M., & Gunn, J. E. 1994, AJ, 107, 1245 Scott, J., Bechtold, J., Dobrzycki, A., & Kulkarni, V. P. 2000, ApJS, 130, 67 Small, T. A., & Blandford, R. D. 1992, MNRAS, 259, 725 Sołtan, A. 1982, MNRAS, 200, 115 Stephens, A. W., Schneider, D. P., Schmidt, M., Gunn, J. E., & Weinberg, D. H. 1997, AJ, 114, 41 Thorne, K. S. 1974, ApJ, 191, 507 Warren, S. J., Hewett, P. C., & Osmer, P. S. 1994, ApJ, 421, 412 Yu, Q. 2003, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophysics Series, Vol. 1: Coevolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Pasadena: Carnegie Observatories, http://www.ociw.edu/ociw/symposia/series/symposium1/proceedings.html) Yu, Q., & Tremaine, S. 2002, MNRAS, 335, 965 Zel’dovich, Ya. B., & Novikov, I. D. 1964, Sov. Phys. Dokl., 158, 811 16 — —
astro-ph/0205101	1	0205	2002-05-07T16:09:56	Frontiers of the Universe: What do we know, what do we understand?	[ "astro-ph" ]	In this talk I summarize the topics addressed during the conference. We have discussed the most relevant cosmological observations of the last say 10 years and their implications for our understanding of the Universe. My finding throughout this meeting has been that it is amazing how our knowledge of cosmological parameters has improved during the last years. It comes as a surprise to many, that the simplest inflationary model of adiabatic perturbations agrees well with present data. But it is frustrating that we have not made any progress in identifying the dark matter, in contrary, we have supplemented it by what we call the 'dark energy', a gravitationally and esthetically repulsive component which is even more mysterious than the dark matter. We have no understanding about the origin of these two most abundant energy components of the present Universe.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Frontiers of the Universe: What do we know, what do we understand? Ruth Durrer Universit´e de Gen`eve D´epartment de Physique Th´eorique 24, Quai Ernest Anserment, 1211 Gen`eve 4, Suisse Abstract In this talk I summarize the topics addressed during the conference. We have discussed the most relevant cosmological observations of the last say 10 years and their implications for our understanding of the Universe. My finding throughout this meeting has been that it is amazing how our knowledge of cosmological parameters has improved during the last years. It comes as a surprise to many, that the simplest inflationary model of adiabatic perturbations agrees well with present data. But it is frustrating that we have not made any progress in identifying the dark matter, in contrary, we have supplemented it by what we call the 'dark energy', a gravitationally and esthetically repulsive component which is even more mysterious than the dark matter. We have no understanding about the origin of these two most abundant energy components of the present Universe. 2 0 0 2 y a M 7 1 v 1 0 1 5 0 2 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1 Introduction Most of us are convinced that below a certain (very high) temperature and density and above a certain (very small) length scale, general relativity is the relevant theory for the description of the interaction of matter and spacetime. The Friedmann universe is one of the simplest solutions of Einstein's equation and this is probably the main reason these solutions have been found and discussed originally by Friedmann. In contrast to Newto- nian gravity, Einstein's equations do allow for homogeneous and isotropic solutions, but they are generically non-static. Nevertheless, I consider it as a big surprise that the Friedmann universe is such a good approximation to the observable universe. As I will argue below, we have several independent pieces of evidence, that the metric deviations from the Friedmann solution are of the order of (1) ∼= 3000h−1Mpc. on all cosmological scales from about 0.1 Mpc up to the Hubble scale, H −1 The fact that this amplitude of the gravitational potential is scale independent is equiv- alent to the fact that the observed fluctuations obey a Harrison Zel'dovich spectrum. Ψ ≃ 10−5 ≪ 1 , 0 In the following sections I recollect some observational evidences and discuss the most important lessons we learn from them. At several occasions I shall also formulate some doubts, especially concerning the data analysis. I shall finish with a brief inventory about what we know and then turn to the more interesting even if less well defined question of what we understand. Clearly, 'under- standing' has many levels and probably means something different for all of us. In this sense I just present a personal point of view. I shall conclude with a few words about the direction the field might develop into. 2 Big bang nucleosynthesis and Type Ia Supernovae Big bang nucleosynthesis has been discussed by T. X. Thuan, S. Sarkar, and also A. Lubowich during this conference. The agreement of the observed light element abun- dances with calculations represents one of the fundamental pillars of big bang cosmology. There are two cosmological parameters which can be determined by comparing nucleosyn- thesis calculations with observations. The Helium abundance restricts any additional, non-standard, relativistic contribution to the energy density of the Universe. This can be cast in ∆Nν ≤ 0.2 or ΩXrel ≤ 1.16 × 10−6 . (2) Here, Xrel denotes any 'particle' species which is still relativistic at the time of nucle- osynthesis (T ∼ 0.1MeV) in addition to the three species of neutrinos and the photons. Examples are a component of stochastic gravity waves or some other unknown particles, e.g. sterile neutrinos, with mass mX < 0.1MeV. The deuterium and Lithium abundances determine the density of baryons in the universe [1], Ωbh2 = 0.02 ± 0.002 . (3) 2 Even though we do not understand type Ia supernovae in detail (see contributions by J. Niemeyer and C.R. Ghezzi), we have realized observationally, that they represent excellent 'modified standard candles'. The Supernovae type Ia measurements of the past years [2, 3] have led to the most surprising result that the present universe is accelerating, in other words the gravitationally active combination ρ + 3p is negative in the present universe. Casting this in terms of an equation of state, p = wρ, the data yield weff ∼ −0.6 ± 0.15. Or, if we assume the dark energy of the universe to be in the form of a cosmological constant with wΛ = −1, which is combined with dark matter which has wm = 0, this can be cast as Ωm − 0.75ΩΛ = −0.25 ± 0.125. These results have been discussed by K. Schahmaneche in this meeting. Clearly, it is still somewhat premature to exclude possibilities like 'grey dust' or 'oscillations of the photons' (see e.g. [4]). But also the large scale structure (LSS) data combined with cosmic microwave background anisotropies give strong evidence for a cosmological constant (or quintessence). The only form of energy which leads to a 'cosmological constant' is a constant po- tential energy (in classical physics) or vacuum energy (in quantum physics). But exactly this form of energy has no dynamical consequences in all known physical interactions except gravity. Only differences in the vacuum energy are dynamically meaningful in non-gravitational interactions. Once gravity is taken into account, this otherwise arbi- trary integration constant suddenly becomes dynamically important. Since in supersymmetric theories the vacuum energy from fermions and bosons ex- actly cancels, the typical value of the vacuum energy expected from modern particle physics is ρΛ = ≃ E4 SU SY > ∼ 1012GeV4 ≃ 1059ρc . (4) Λ 8πG Here ESU SY denotes the supersymmetry breaking scale which we know to be at least 1TeV or larger. The above mentioned observations find a non-vanishing value which is at least 59 orders of magnitude smaller than what one naively expects. This finding represents probably the most amazing puzzle in physics. Clearly, we are lacking a basic piece in our understanding and interpretation of the cosmological constant and/or of vacuum energy. Actually, we can also face this result in a positive way: nobody (except perhaps Prof. Burbidge) has expected it! This is the clearest evidence that cosmology, which for a long time lived from 'theoretical speculations' has become data dominated. I belive that the accelerating universe and the cosmological constant represents the biggest puzzle in present physics. There are divers attempts to address it, but none of them so far could convince a majority (see contributions from M. Turner and F. Piazza). More observational constraints on this mysterious dark energy are desperately needed. Various attempts in this direction have been addressed in the contributions by J. Newman, R. Bean and J. Weller. 3 3 The cosmic microwave background The Universe is permeated by an isotropic thermal radiation at T = (2.728 ± 0.01)K, the cosmic microwave background (CMB). Anisotropies in this background radiation (a part from a dipole of C1 ∼ 10−3 which is due to our motion with respect to the CMB rest frame) are of the order of ∆T T ≃ 10−5 ≃ Φ . (5) The last ≃ indicates that CMB anisotropies are of the same order of magnitude as the gravitational potential (Bardeen potential) Φ. This isotropy, together with the cosmo- logical principle (we are not sitting in a special place in the Universe), proves that the Universe is close to Friedmann on large scales. The accurate mapping of CMB anisotropies, especially by the three latest experiments Boomerang [5], MAXIMA [6] and DASI [7] teaches us much more that this: the simplest model of a Harrison Zel'dovich (scale invariant) spectrum of purely adiabatic scalar fluctuations with reasonable cosmological parameters fits the data very well (see Fig. 1). Figure 1: The CMB anisotropy power spectrum measurements from Boomerang (solid,red), MAXIMA (dashed, green) and DASI (dotted,blue) are shown. A typical inflationary model with scale invariant scalar perturbations is indicated to guide the eye (solid line). The CMB anisotropy spectrum for causal global defects (texture) is also shown (dashed line). This result is by no means trivial: the simplest worked out models with 'causal' initial perturbations, i.e. initial conditions where all correlations on super horizon scales vanish, do not fit the data (dashed line in Fig. 1). The reason for this is relatively subtle: these models, where fluctuations are induced by topological defects, actually 4 also produce a Harrison Zel'dovich spectrum of fluctuations. But the fluctuations are not 'in phase', i.e. at the moment of recombination not all fluctuations of a given wavelength are at a maximum/minimum /zero respectively. The peak structure which is so characteristic of fluctuations created at a very early initial time and which have a fixed amplitude at horizon crossing, is therefore not expected from topological defects. For topological defects the physical mechanism which creates the fluctuations shortly after horizon crossing is non-linear. The non-linearities imply a coupling of modes which smears out the acoustic peaks at least to some extend. Furthermore, tensor and especially vector perturbations contribute significantly (more than 50%) to the CMB anisotropies at large scales, leading to a suppression of the purely scalar acoustic peaks in a COBE normalized spectrum. This is the main lesson which we have learned so far from these beautiful experiments: the cosmological initial fluctuations stem most probably from an inflationary phase or some equivalent, which produced fluctuations on scales larger than the Hubble horizon. I consider this data as 'evidence for inflation' of a completely different quality than the homogeneity and isotropy of the Universe and the flatness problem. For the latter inflation justifies highly improbable initial conditions. In contrary, the acoustic peaks have been predicted from inflation. This actually even before the development of inflation by Doroshkevich, Zeldovich and Sunyaev (1978) [9]. These authors have used an initial spectrum of fluctuations with correlations on super Hubble scales which can only be generated during an inflation-like process. Here we use the term 'inflation' in its most generic sense as a period where the co-moving size of the Hubble scale is increasing. Since the details of the acoustic oscillations depend sensitively on cosmological pa- rameters like Ωm, ΩΛ, Ωbh2, h, r = T /S, ns, nT , τc, · · · , (6) many of us have used them to determine them. Progress in the determination of cos- mological parameters has been reported here by S. Sarkar, J. Silk, M. Tegmark and C. Pryke. A. Melchiorri has discussed to which extend present results will improve with new data from the MAP and PLANCK satellite experiments. Even though this parameter estimation is potentially a very powerful method, espe- cially when combined with other datasets, which are desperately needed since the CMB alone has important degeneracies, I think we must be careful not to over-interpret the data. Simply consider the number of papers written by us theoreticians (I, myself wrote one of them...) about the missing second peak after the first Boomerang-98 results [10] which have now turned out to be due to a systematic error in the data analysis (a miss-estimated beam size). The person who warned me most not to over-interpret this marginal feature in the Boomerang power spectrum was Paolo de Bernardis himself. As Zwicky [11] put it: "If only theorists would know what goes into an experimental data point and if only experimenters would know what goes into a theoretical calculation, they both would take each other much less serious". Therefore, I guess we may be confident that the cosmological parameters as deter- mined so far seem to lie in the right bulk part, but I do by no means take seriously the formal errors quoted in the published papers. 5 An additional point to be aware of is that these parameter estimations always assume that the correct model is in the family of models being parameterized. If one allows for more generic models (e.g. relaxing the requirement of adiabaticity) one can find very different cosmological parameters which also fit the present CMB data (see Fig. 2). Figure 2: The CMB anisotropy power spectrum measurements from Boomerang are compared with flat models with Ωbh2 = 0.042 with cosmological constant, ΩΛ = 0.7. The model with mixed isocurvature and adiabatic components is a good fit (solid line), while the adiabatic model does not fit the data with this parameter choice. Figure from Trotta et al. [12], where one can find more details. Much more remarkable than the precision of cosmological parameters obtained from CMB measurements so far is their concordance with independent determinations from other data like LSS, peculiar velocities, lensing etc., under the simplest possible model assumptions. Let us therefore summarize results from other datasets. 4 Peculiar velocities Apart from the CMB (and lensing), peculiar velocities represent one of the most straight- forward ways to measure the gravitational potential and hence the metric perturbations. Unfortunately, they are notoriously difficult to measure, since vpec r = cz − rH0 (7) is the small difference of two large numbers, of which the second one (r) is very difficult to measure. Therefore, one has to consider carefully how to use this noisy data at its best. A first order of magnitude result is that peculiar bulk velocities are of the order 6 of vpec(r) ∼ 300km/s on scales of r ∼ 50h−1Mpc. Using the scaling relation from linear perturbation theory, v(r) ∼ Φ × c2 rH0 , this implies Φ ∼ 10−5 , (8) where Φ is again the (dimensionless) gravitational potential. But also on smaller scales, 0.1Mpc < ∼ 1Mpc, where structures are virialized and we expect Φ ≃ (v/c)2, we obtain from the velocity dispersion in clusters, v ∼ 1000km/s again Φ ∼ 10−5. < ∼ r Together with the CMB anisotropies on large scales, this gives Φ ∼ 10−5 on all < ∼ cosmologically relevant scales, from the size of galaxies up to the Hubble scale, 0.1Mpc r < ∼ 6000Mpc. Clearly, to determine bulk velocity flows, a precise measurement of the Hubble pa- rameter is desperately needed (see contribution by J. Beckman). All the results discussed here are not very precise but they are nevertheless very interesting and might be telling us something which we have overlooked so far... Finally I want to mention that during the last couple of years, a new technique, namely the statistics of pairwise velocities of galaxies has been developed and it has been shown that it can lead to a relatively precise measurement of σ8 and Ωm as it does not suffer from many of the problems of bulk velocities [13]. 5 Large scale structure New galaxy redshift surveys are being completed or under way. The number of published galaxy redshifts is growing very fast. The galaxy redshift catalogs are mainly used to determine the galaxy power spectrum which we hope to be closely related to the matter power spectrum (see contribution of S. Zaroubi). Most recently, the 2dF power spectrum has been interpreted to show evidence for oscillations or at least structure, which indicate a relatively high ratio Ωb/Ωm ∼ 0.15 (see Ref. [14] and the contribution by C. Frenk). It is really amazing to which extent big bang nucleosynthesis, CMB, LSS, SNIa and also cluster data [15] come together and favor h2Ωb ∼ 0.02, Ωm ∼ 0.3 and ΩΛ ∼ 0.7. I admit, however, that I do have reservations to interpret the oscillations in the 2dF power spectrum as acoustic oscillations of baryons (this concern is partially shared with C. Frenk, see his contribution). First of all, according to my naive estimate they are not quite at the right position. Secondly, they could very well mimic some effect from a finite size filter, the Fourier transform of a top-hat filter simply gives a Bessel function. I am also a bit reluctant to take seriously the interpretation of the 'bend in the power spectrum'. Since the mean density of the universe is set equal to the mean density of galaxies in the catalog at hand, the power spectrum at the scale of the survey, L, vanishes by construction P (k = 2π/L) ≡ 0. It is therefore not surprising that all observed galaxy power spectra show a bend in the last few points, i.e. for the smallest values of k. Furthermore, a volume limited sample out to the largest scale k ∼ 0.02h/Mpc can be estimated to contain roughly 1% of all the galaxies in the 2dF catalog leading to 7 N ∼ 1000. But the Poisson noise due to this finite number is just of the order of the square of the fluctuation amplitude, ∆2(k = 0.02h/Mpc) = k3P (k) ∼ 10−3 ∼ 1/N. Therefore, and also due to a 'tradition of sloppiness' in the statistical treatment of galaxy redshift data, I am not completely convinced that these data is correctly interpreted in the present literature. 6 Weak lensing The deflection of light is fully determined by the gravitational potential, i.e. by the clustering properties of matter. The statistical distribution of the shear, the direction of elongation of galaxies, measures the gravitational field along the line of sight. We define the amplification matrix A, y (cid:19)image (cid:18) x = A(cid:18) x y (cid:19)object with A = (cid:18) µ + γ1 γ2 γ2 µ − γ1 (cid:19) . The expectation value of γ is related to the convergence power spectrum Pκ via hγ2i = 2 πθ2 c Z ∞ 0 dk k Pκ(k)J 2 1 (kθc) , (9) (10) where J1 is the Bessel function of order 1. More details can be found in the contribution by F. Bernardeau and in Ref. [17]. Observations of the shear of galaxies finally lead to constraints in the Ωm, σ8 plane. For present surveys, the best results are those of Ref. [17] shown in Fig. 3, but this method is just coming up and will hopefully lead to improved results, once the errors are better under control. Figure 3: The 1,2 and 3 σ contours for Ωm and σ8 from the weak lensing analysis of the VIRMOS deep imaging survey. Figure from Werbaeke et al. [17], where one can find more details. 8 7 Conclusion We have seen in this conference that cosmology is harvesting an enormous amount of data leading to ever better measurements of the cosmological parameters. At present it seems that the Universe is flat and Λ-dominated with purely adiabatic scalar pertur- bations which are responsible at the same time for the CMB anisotropies and for large scale structure. Astrophysical observations presently undergo amazing breakthroughs in almost all wavebands of the electromagnetic spectrum. This has been impressively demonstrated in the talks by A. Quirrenbach, A. Omont, A. Watson, H. Meyer, C. Cesarsky and A. Melchiorri. Also the hope that we may finally be able to detect gravi- tational radiation directly has become realistic (see contributions by T. Damour and M. Huber). Observational cosmology is clearly in its most exciting phase, new discoveries and challenges for theorists are to be expected every day. The main parameters of the cosmological model may very well be determined with sufficient accuracy within a couple of years. Then we will know the parameters of the Universe we are living in. But do we understand cosmology? I think there we are still very far from our goal: of the two main constituents of the present Universe, we have no information other than their cosmological activity. Despite intensive searches (see contributions from T. Sumner, L. Baudis and others), we have not observed the particle giving rise to Ωm yet. There are many dark matter candidates (see contribution from S. Scopel), but clearly not all of them can be realized in nature. Concerning the dominant term in the cosmic density, ΩΛ, the situation is even worse. There we have no convincing theory giving a result even in the right bulk park. Interesting ideas are being developed (see e.g. the contribution by T. Padmanabhan), but so far the problem remains unsolved. Also inflation, the 'explanation' of the flatness and homogeneity of the universe, and of the adiabatic initial fluctuations, is more on the level of a paradigm than of a theory of the early universe, motivated by high energy physics (see contribution by S. Dodelson). These are, as I see it, the main problems which concern the early universe. Most probably, they cannot be solved without simultaneous progress in the theory of high energy physics. They may actually provide our only clues to the physics at very high energies, like string theory, which are probably not accessible also in future accelerators (see the contributions from G. Veneziano and J. Magueijo). Cosmology may turn out as the ultimate tool to study the fundamental laws of physics. ∼ z At the redshifts 1010 > > ∼ 10, i.e. from about T ∼ 1MeV until cosmic structures become non-linear and the first objects form, we understand the cosmic evolution rather well. We can provide good, successful calculations of primordial nucleosynthesis and recombination, as well as integrate the linear perturbation equations to determine CMB anisotropies. These calculations are in good agreement with observations and, together with other measurements, they allow us to determine the cosmological parameters. At low redshift, z < 10, when structure develops, radiation processes and chemical evolution take place together with gravitational clustering. The physics becomes com- plex. Many different effects have to be taken into account simultaneously, if we want to obtain a consistent picture. Complex numerical simulations combining gravity with 9 hydrodynamics are presently being developed (see contribution from T. Abel). But also new observations focusing on small scales in different bands of the electromagnetic spec- trum are underway (see contributions from S. Bridle, I. Lehmann, A. Bunker, E. de Gouveia Dal Pino N. Gruel and others). I believe that, within a couple years when the important work of determining cosmo- logical parameters to good accuracy will have been solved, there will remain two major directions for cosmological research: • z ≫ 1010 Early universe, towards the fundamental laws of physics. • z < ∼ 10 The formation of galaxies and stars, complexity. Acknowledgment: I thank the participants of this 'Rencontre de Blois' and Filippo Vernizzi for interesting and stimulating discussions. My participation at the conference was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation. References [1] S. Burles, K. M. Nollet, M. S. Turner, Astrophys. J. 552, L1 (2001). [2] S. Perlmutter et al., Astrophys. J. 517, 565 (1999). [3] A. Riess et al. Astron. J. 116, 1009 (1998). [4] C. Csaki, N. Kaloper and J. Terning, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 161302 (2002). [5] Netterfield, C.B. et al., 2001, astro-ph/0104460 [6] Lee, A.T. et al., Astrophys. J. 561, L1 (2001). [7] Halverson, N.W. et al., Astropjys. J. 568, 38 (2002). [8] G.F. Smoot et al. Astrophys. J. 396, L1 (1992). [9] A.G. Doroshkevich, Ya.B. Zeldovich, & R.A. Sunyaev, Sov. Astron. 22, 523 (1978). [10] P. de Bernardis et al., Nature 404, 495 (2000). [11] F. Zwicky, Morphological Astronomy, Berlin (1957). [12] R. Trotta, A. Riazuelo and R. Durrer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 231301 (2001) [13] R. Juszkiewicz et al., Science 287, 109 (2000). [14] W.J. Percival et al., Mont. Not. Roy. Ast. Soc., submitted 10 [15] Z. Haiman, J.J. Mohr and G.P. Holder, Astrophys. J. Lett. 560, L111 (2001). [16] J.A. Peacock et al., Nature 410, 169 (2001). [17] L. Van Waerbeke et al., Astron. Astrophys 374, 757 (2001). 11
astro-ph/9903055	1	9903	1999-03-03T06:33:25	The R-Mode Oscillations in Relativistic Rotating Stars	[ "astro-ph", "gr-qc" ]	The axial mode oscillations are examined for relativistic rotating stars with uniform angular velocity. Using the slow rotation formalism and the Cowling approximation, we have derived the equations governing the r-mode oscillations up to the second order with respect to the rotation. In the lowest order, the allowed range of the frequencies is determined, but corresponding spatial function is arbitrary. The spatial function can be decomposed in non-barotropic region by a set of functions associated with the differential equation of the second-order corrections. The equation however becomes singular in barotropic region, and a single function can be selected to describe the spatial perturbation of the lowest order. The frame dragging effect among the relativistic effects may be significant, as it results in rather broad spectrum of the r-mode frequency unlike in the Newtonian first-order calculation.	astro-ph	astro-ph	The R-Mode Oscillations in Relativistic Rotating Stars Yasufumi Kojima and Masayasu Hosonuma Department of Physics, Hiroshima University, Higashi-Hiroshima 739-8526, Japan ABSTRACT The axial mode oscillations are examined for relativistic rotating stars with uniform angular velocity. Using the slow rotation formalism and the Cowling approximation, we have derived the equations governing the r-mode oscillations up to the second order with respect to the rotation. In the lowest order, the allowed range of the frequencies is determined, but corresponding spatial function is arbitrary. The spatial function can be decomposed in non-barotropic region by a set of functions associated with the differential equation of the second- order corrections. The equation however becomes singular in barotropic region, and a single function can be selected to describe the spatial perturbation of the lowest order. The frame dragging effect among the relativistic effects may be significant, as it results in rather broad spectrum of the r-mode frequency unlike in the Newtonian first-order calculation. 1. Introduction In recent years, the r-mode oscillations in rotating stars have been found to be signifi- cant implications. The axial oscillations are unstable by the gravitational radiation reaction (Andersson 1998, Friedman and Morsink 1998). The mechanism of the instability can be un- derstood by the generic argument for the gravitational radiation driven instability, so-called CFS-instability, which is originally examined for the polar perturbations, (Chandrasekhar 1970, Friedman and Schutz 1978, Friedman 1978). All rotating stars become unstable in the absence of internal fluid dissipation, irrespective of the parity modes. Viscosity however damps out the oscillations, and stabilizes them in general. The polar f-mode instability is believed to act only in rapidly rotating neutron stars (Lindblom 1995). The axial instability is however found to set in even in much more slowly rotating cases, and to play an important role on the evolution of hot newly-born neutron stars (Lindblom et al. 1998, Andersson et al., 1998). The instability carries away most of angular momentum and rotational energy of the stars by the gravitational radiation. The gravitational wave emitted during the spin- down process is expected to be one of the promising sources for the laser interferometer gravitational wave detectors (Owen et al. 1998). -- 2 -- Most of the estimates for the r-mode instability are based on the Newtonian calculations. That is, the oscillation frequencies are determined by inviscid hydrodynamics under the Newtonian gravity, and the gravitational radiation reaction is incorporated by evaluating the (current) multipole moments. Relativity has great influence on stellar structures, redshift in oscillation frequencies, frame dragging, radiations and so on. It is important to explore the relativistic effects, which may not change the general features of the oscillations, but shift the critical angular velocity. The relativistic calculation is not so easy task, even using the linear perturbation method concerning the oscillation amplitude. Both relativity and rotation complicate the problems considerably. As the first step toward a clear understanding of relativistic corrections, we have ex- amined the r-mode oscillations with two approximations, the slow rotation approximation (Hartle 1967) and the Cowling approximation (Cowling 1941). The rotation is assumed to be slow, and treated as small perturbation from the non-rotating case. We also assume that the perturbation of the gravity can be neglected in the oscillations. The accuracy of the Cowling approximation are tested in the rotating relativistic system (Finn 1988, Lindblom and Splinter 1990, Yoshida and Kojima 1997). The calculations give the same qualitative results and reasonable accuracy of the oscillation frequencies, as in the Newtonian stellar pulsation theory (e.g., Cox 1980). In Section 2, we summarize the basic equations for the inviscid fluid in slowly rotating relativistic stars and the perturbation scheme to solve them. The r-mode solution is given at the lowest order with respect to the rotational parameter in Section 3. The mode can not be specified by a single frequency unlike in the Newto- nian r-mode oscillation, although the frequency is bounded to a certain range. The spatial function of the mode is arbitrary at this order. In order to determine the radial structure, we need the rotational corrections up to the third order in the background. In Section 4, we include the rotational effects, and derive the equation governing the r-mode oscillations in non-barotropic region. The resultant equation becomes singular in the barotropic case, since the second-order differential term vanishes. In Section 5, we separately consider for the barotropic stars the mode function and the correction to the leading order. In Section 6, we discuss the implication of our results. We use the geometrical units of c = G = 1. 2. Pulsation equations of axial mode We consider a slowly rotating star with a uniform angular velocity Ω ∼ O(ε). The rotational effects can be treated as the corrections to the non-rotating spherical star. We will take account of the corrections up to the third order in ε. The metric tensor for describing the stationary axisymmetric star is given by (Hartle 1967,Chandrasekhar and Miller 1974, -- 3 -- Quintana 1976) ds2 = −eν [1 + 2(h0 + h2P2)] dt2 + eλ"1 + 2eλ r (m0 + m2P2)# dr2 + r2(1 + 2k2P2) dθ2 + sin2 θ"dφ − ω + W1 − W3  1 sin θ dP3 dθ ! dt#2  , (1) where Pl(cos θ) (l = 2, 3) denotes the Legendre's polynomial of degree l. The metric functions except gtφ should be expanded by an even power of ε, while gtφ by an odd power of ε due to the rotational symmetry, i.e., ω ∼ O(ε), (h0, h2, m0, m2, k2) ∼ O(ε2) and (W1, W3) ∼ O(ε3). These quantities are functions of the radial coordinate r. The equilibrium state is assumed to be described with perfect-fluid stress-energy tensor. The 4-velocity of the fluid element inside the star has the components, which are correct to O(ε3), U φ = ΩU t, U t = (−gtt − 2Ωgtφ − Ω2gφφ)−1/2. (2) The pressure and density distributions are subject to the centrifugal deformation, which is the effect of O(ε2). These distributions are expressed as p = p0(r) + {p20(r) + p22(r)P2(cos θ)}, ρ = ρ0(r) + {ρ20(r) + ρ22(r)P2(cos θ)}, (3) (4) where p0 and ρ0 are the values for the non-rotating star, and the quantities in the braces are the rotational corrections. The non-rotating spherical configuration and the rotational corrections in eqs.(1)-(4) are determined by successively solving the perturbed Einstein equa- tions with the same power of ε (Hartle 1967,Chandrasekhar and Miller 1974, Quintana 1976). We consider the linear perturbations of the equilibrium fluid state. We use the Eulerian change of the pressure, density and 4-velocity, which are represented by δp, δρ and δUν. The perturbations of the gravitational field are neglected in the Cowling approximation. It is convenient in the following calculation to expand these functions in terms of the spherical harmonics Ylm, δp = Xlm δρ = Xlm δplm(t, r)Ylm(θ, φ), δρlm(t, r)Ylm(θ, φ), Rlm(t, r)Ylm(θ, φ), (ρ + p)δUr = eν/2Xlm (ρ + p)δUθ = eν/2Xlm "Vlm(t, r)∂θYlm(θ, φ) − (5) (6) (7) (8) Ulm(t, r) sin θ ∂φYlm(θ, φ)# , -- 4 -- [Vlm(t, r)∂φYlm(θ, φ) + Ulm(t, r) sin θ∂θYlm(θ, φ)] , (ρ + p)δUφ = eν/2Xlm δUt = −ΩδUφ. (9) (10) With these definitions, the pulsation equations are derived from the conservation laws of the perturbed energy-momentum, where δT ν µ = (δρ + δp)UµU ν + [(ρ + p)δUµU ν + (ρ + p)δU νUµ] + δpδν µ. δT ν µ;ν = 0, (11) (12) Since we assume that the perturbation is adiabatic, the thermodynamic relation between the perturbed pressure and density can be written as δp + ξ · ∇p = Γp p + ρ (δρ + ξ · ∇ρ) , (13) where Γ is the adiabatic index and ξ is the Lagrange displacement. We will solve eqs.(11) and (13) by the expansion of ε. In a spherical star, the pertur- bations decouple into purely polar and purely axial modes for each l and m. A set of the functions Plm ≡ (δplm, δρlm, Rlm, Vlm) describes the polar mode, while the function Alm ≡ Ulm describes the axial mode. In the presence of the rotation, the mode will be mixed among the terms with different l, while the mode can still be specified by a single m (e.g., Kojima 1992, Kojima 1997). The coupled equations are schematically expressed as 0 = [Alm] + E × [Pl±1m] + E 2 × [Alm, Al±2m] + · · · , 0 = [Plm] + E × [Al±1m] + E 2 × [Plm, Pl±2m] + · · · , (14) (15) where the symbol E means some functions of order ε, and the square bracket formally represents the relation among the axial perturbation function Alm, or the polar perturbation function Plm appeared therein. We also assume that the time variation of the oscillation is slow and proportional to Ω, i.e., ∂t ∼ Ω ∼ O(ε). This is true in the r-mode oscillation, as will be confirmed soon. We look for the mode which is described by a single axial function with index (l, m) in the limit of ε → 0. That is, the polar part should vanish, while the axial part becomes finite. Hence, the perturbation functions are expanded as Alm = A(1) lm + ε2A(2) lm + · · · , Plm = ε(P (1) lm + ε2P (2) lm + · · ·). (16) Substituting these functions into eqs.(14) and (15), and comparing the coefficients of εn(n = 0, 1, 2), we have 0 = [A(1) lm], l±1m + E × A(1) 0 = [εP (1) lm], 0 = [ε2A(2) lm] + E × [εP (1) l±1m] + E 2 × [A(1) lm, A(1) l±2m] = [ε2A(2) lm + E 2 × A(1) lm], (17) (18) (19) -- 5 -- where we have used A(1) l±2m = 0 and the relation (18) in the last part of (19). Equation (17) represents the axial oscillation at the lowest order, which can be specified by U (1) lm . Equation (19) is the second-order form of it, and the term E 2 × A(1) lm can be regarded as the rotational corrections. We will show the explicit forms corresponding to eqs.(17)-(19) in subsequent sections. 3. First-order solution The leading term of eq.(11) is reduced to where U (1) lm − imχU (1) lm = 0, χ = 2 l(l + 1) = 2 l(l + 1) (Ω − ω), (20) (21) and a dot denotes time derivative in the co-rotating frame, i.e., evolution of the perturbation can be solved by the Laplace transformation, Ulm = (∂t + imΩ)Ulm. The u(s, r) = Z ∞ 0 U (1) lm (t, r)e−stdt. The Laplace transformation of eq.(20) is written as (s + im(Ω − χ)) u(s, r) − f (1) lm (r) = 0, (22) (23) where f (1) transformation, the solution in t-domain is easily constructed as lm describes the initial disturbance at t = 0. After solving u and using the inverse lm (t, r) = Z f (1) U (1) lm (r) est s + im(Ω − χ) ds = f (1) lm (r)e−im(Ω−χ)tH(t), (24) where H(t) is the Heaviside step function. We will consider t > 0 region only, so that the function H(t) may well be omitted from now on. For the Newtonian star, m(Ω − χ) becomes a constant (25) σN = 1 − 2 l(l + 1)! mΩ. This is the r-mode frequency measured in the non-rotating frame (Papaloizou and Pringle 1978, Provost et al. (1981), Saio 1982). In the relativistic stars, is monotonically increasing function of r, 0 ≤ ≤ R. The possible range of the r-mode frequency is spread out. If one regards eq.(24) as the sum of the Fourier component e−iσt, then the spectrum is continuous in the range 1 − 2 l(l + 1) R Ω ! mΩ ≤ σ ≤ 1 − 2 l(l + 1) 0 Ω ! mΩ. (26) -- 6 -- This result is the same1, even if metric perturbations are considered (Kojima 1998). The time-dependence is determined, whereas the radial dependence f (1) lm is arbitrary at this order. The function f (1) lm in eq.(24) is constrained by the equation of motions for the polar part, as will be shown in the subsequent sections. In this manner, the perturbation scheme (17)-(19) is degenerate perturbation. 4. Second-order equation The pressure and density perturbations are induced by the rotation, while the axial mode in the non-rotating stars is never coupled to them. We may assume that the perturbation can be specified by a single function U (1) lm at the leading order, since general case can be described by the linear combination. The axial part induces the polar parts with index (l ± 1, m) according to the perturbation scheme (18). It is straightforward to solve δpl±1m, and δρl±1m from two components of eq.(11) in terms of the first-order corrections and U (1) lm . The explicit results are δpl±1m = 2S±U (1) lm , e−ν/2 δρl±1m = −4S± ν ′ (eν/2U (1) lm )′ + 2T± eν r2ν ′ (r2e−ν)′U (1) lm , where l S+ = l + 1 T+ = lQ+, Q+, S− = l + 1 l Q−, T− = −(l + 1)Q−, l2 − m2 (2l − 1)(2l + 1) . (27) (28) (29) (30) (31) Q+ = vuut (l + 1)2 − m2 (2l + 1)(2l + 3) , Q− = vuut We here denote a derivative with respect to r by a prime. The lowest order form of eq.(13) is also decoupled into the equation of each l, m component, δ pl±1m − C 2δ ρl±1m = AC 2eν e−λRl±1m − lm! , 3imξ2 r2 Q±U (1) with C 2 = A = Γp0 p0 + ρ0 , ρ′ 0 p0 + ρ0 − p′ 0 Γp0 . (32) (33) (34) 1 Note that this conclusion is derived within the lowest-order approximation of the perturbation scheme. The consistency in the higher order will affect it for barotropic case as will be shown in the following sections. -- 7 -- In eq.(32), the displacement ξ2 represents the quadrupole deformation of the stationary star, and is related to the quantities of O(ε2) as ξ2 = − 2 ν ′ (cid:18)h2 + 1 3 2r2e−ν(cid:19) . (35) The region for A > 0 is convectively unstable, while that for A < 0 is stably stratified. We here assume A 6= 0 in the following calculations, but will separately consider the case A = 0 in Section 5. From eq.(32), the function Rl±1m is solved by U (1) lm for the region A 6= 0. The function Vl±1m describing the horizontal motion is calculated from the remaining component of eq.(11). The explicit form is given by [l′(l′ + 1)Vl′m]l′=l±1 = S±(v2 + l(l + 1)r2Ωe−ν U (1) lm ) + T±(v1 + 1 2 r2e−ν U (1) lm ) + l(l + 1)Q±v0, where v2 = 4e−(3ν+λ)/2" r2eλ/2 − 4r2e−3ν/2 Aν ′ (eν/2 U (1) ! (eν/2 U (1) lm )′, ν ′ lm )′ + ν ′ 2C 2 (eν/2 U (1) lm )!# ′ (36) (37) v1 = 2e−(3ν+λ)/2" e(3ν+λ)/2 lm −"r2e−ν v0 = U (1)′ ξ2 Aν ′ 3 2 2 ′ lm# (r2e−ν)′ U (1) −" 2e−ν/2 ν ′ (r2e−ν/2)′ + Ωr2e−ν# U (1) lm , (38) ( + 2Ω) − 3 2 eλm2 r − 3 2 e−(ν+λ)/2"e(ν+λ)/2 ξ2 #′# U (1) lm . (39) In eq.(36), we have used eq.(20) to simplify it. These corrections in the polar functions affect the axial parts with indices (l ± 2, m) and (l, m). We are interested in the term with index (l, m) as the corrections to the leading equation. In deriving the axial equation with these corrections, the terms up to O(ε3) in the background field also affect it. We include both corrections to the axial equation and have the following form, where L is the Sturm-Liouville differential operator defined by 0 = U (2) lm − imχU (2) lm + L[ U (1) lm ], (40) (41) L[ U (1) lm ] = 8c3e(−λ/2−ν)(ρ0 + p0)" r2e(λ−ν)/2 0 !′ F = −4c32e(−λ/2−ν) r2eλ/2ρ′ Aν ′(ρ0 + p0) Ap′ − 0 ′ lm )′# (eν/2 U (1) " e(λ+3ν)/2 Aν ′ ρ0 + p0 4c22e(−λ−3ν)/2 − (F + G) U (1) lm , (r2e−ν)′(ρ0 + p0)#′ +(cid:18) 2c1eν Aν ′r2(cid:19) [(r2e−ν)′]2, G = −8c32e(−λ/2−ν) r2eλ/2 ν ′ ! − 3c1 re−λ/2 eλ/2ξ2 r !  l(l + 1) "ξ2 l + 1 ln Q2 − + (−1)n−1 3m2 cn = − + r ξ2 + k2 − ′ 1 2 (l + 1)n Q2 +. l ′ + ′ − 3 2 -- 8 -- 4c2 ν ′r2 (2r4e−ν)′ eλ ′ r ξ2 − k2 + m2 + 5W3 # −(cid:18)W1 + 5W3   (cid:19) , 6W3 (42) (43) (44) In order to solve eq.(40), we introduce a complete set of functions as for the operator L, L[yκ] + κyκ = 0. (45) where −κ is the eigenvalue and the eigenfunction yκ(r) is characterized by κ, e.g., the number of the nodes. The eigenvalue is real number of O(ε2), since L is the Hermitian operator of O(ε2). The eigenvalue problem is solved with appropriate boundary conditions. For example, the function should satisfy the regularity condition at the center and the Lagrangian pressure should vanish at the stellar surface. Certain initial date f (1) lm in eq.(24) can be decomposed by the set. We may restrict our consideration to a single function labeled by κ, since the general case is described by discrete sum or integration over a certain range. By putting yκ = imχf (1) lm;κ, we have L[ U (1) lm ] = L[imχf (1) lm;κe−im(Ω−χ)t] = −imκχf (1) lm;κe−im(Ω−χ)t, (46) where (e−im(Ω−χ)t)′ gives the first order correction and is neglected here. Using f (1) integrate eq.(40) with respect to t, and have the function U (2) lm (t, r) of O(ε2) as lm;κ, we can U (2) lm = (imκχtf (1) lm;κ + f (2) lm )e−im(Ω−χ)t, (47) where the function f (2) order forms is approximated as lm of O(ε2) is unknown at this order. The sum of the first and second U (1) lm + U (2) lm = h(1 + imκχt)f (1) lm;κ + f (2) lmi e−im(Ω−χ)t lm;κ + f (2) = hf (1) lmi e−im(Ω−(1+κ)χ)t, (48) (49) where we have exploited the freedom of f (2) lm to eliminate the unphysical growing term in eq.(48). The value κ originated from the fixing of the initial data becomes evident for large -- 9 -- t, since the accumulation of small effects from the higher order terms is no longer neglected. As a result, the frequency should be adjusted with the second-order correction to be a good approximation even for slightly large t, as in eq.(49). This renormalization of the frequency is closely related to treating t as strained coordinate in the perturbation method. (See e.g. Hinch 1991.) In this way, the specification of the initial data at the leading order has influence on the second-order correction κ. 5. Oscillations in barotropic stars The structure of the neutron stars is almost approximated to be barotropic. The pul- sation equation is quite different from that of non-barotropic case, as in the Newtonian pulsation theory. The relation (32) for the case A = 0 is replaced by δpl±1m = C 2δρl±1m = p′ 0 ρ′ 0 δρl±1m = − ν ′(p0 + ρ0) 2ρ′ 0 δρlm. (50) In the last part of eq.(50), we have used hydrostatic equation of the non-rotating star. In this case, the function Rl±1m is never determined through eq.(32) unlike in A 6= 0 case, but rather we have two restrictions to a single function U (1) lm . These conditions are never satisfied simultaneously unless for m = ±l, in which one condition is trivial, δpl−1m = δρl−1m = 0 due to Q− = 0. The other condition for m = ±l becomes (eν/2U (1) lm )′ + ν ′ 2C 2 − l + 1 2 (r2e−ν)′ r2e−ν ! eν/2U (1) lm = 0. (51) Substituting the form (24) into this and neglecting the higher order term due to (e−im(Ω−χ)t)′, we have the same differential equation for f (1) lm . The integration with respect to r results in U (1) lm (t, r) = f (1) lm;∗e−im(Ω−χ)t = hN0(ρ0 + p0)rl+1e−ν(e−ν)(l−1)/2i e−im(Ω−χ)t, (52) where N0 is a normalization constant. determined. The corresponding the 3-velocity at t → +0 is given by In this way, the function of the lowest order is ξφ = δvφ = N0rl+1(e−ν)(l−1)/2. (53) As shown by Friedman and Morsink 1998, the canonical energy of the perturbation is neg- ative for the Lagrange displacement ξφ, and the solution therefore means unstable if the gravitational radiation reaction sets in. -- 10 -- We now specify Rl±1m of O(ε2) to proceed to the pulsation equation with the second order corrections. The function Xl±1m describing the radial motion is introduced as Rl±1m = Xl±1m + 3imeλξ2 r2 Q±U (1) lm . (54) The function Xl±1m is arbitrary at this order, but we have two special cases. One is Xl±1m = 0, which is the limiting case for eq.(32) in a sense. The other is chosen so as to vanish the Lagrangian change of the pressure within the entire star. The condition corresponds to Xl±1m = 4S±eλ−ν U (1) lm /ν ′. For the first choice, the Lagrangian change of the pressure never vanishes at the surface unless ρ0 vanishes there. The second one is the usual way treated in the Newtonian r-mode, as shown by Lindblom and Ipser (1998). With the second choice of Xl±1m and eq.(52), the pulsation equation for m = ±l leads to U (2) lm − imχU (2) lm − G U (1) lm = 0, (55) where G is defined in eq.(43). This equation is solved for U (2) up to O(ε2) is written as lm as in Section 4. The solution (56) U (1) lm + U (2) lmi e−im(Ω−(1+G)χ)t, lm = hf (1) lm;∗ + f (2) where the function f (2) lm of O(ε2) is unknown at this order. This expression (56) is formally the same as in eq.(49) for the non-barotropic case with κ = G. The second-order correction in the frequency however depends on the position owing to the particular choice of the function f (1) lm;∗. We show the second-order rotational correction G for l = m = 2 mode in Fig.1. We adopt the polytropic stellar model with index n = 1. For the Newtonian star, G is a positive function, which monotonically increases from the center to the surface. The value ranges from G = 0.55(Ω2R3/M) to G = 0.75(Ω2R3/M), where R and M are the radius and the mass for the non-rotating star. These values are rather smaller than that of incompressible case, G = 37/27(Ω2R3/M). (Only for the Newtonian incompressible case, the factor G is a constant. See Appendix.) The stellar deformation ξ2, which is the most important contribution to G, diminishes in the compressible fluid. As the star becomes relativistic, other relativistic factors become significant. As a result, the factor G is scaled down as a whole, and eventually becomes negative for some regions. In any cases, the frequencies satisfy the criterion of the radiation reaction instability, which implies 0 < (1 + G)χ/Ω < 1. That is, retrograde in the rotating frame and prograde in the inertial frame. Therefore, the second-order correction never changes qualitative picture of the instability. In Fig.2, we show the frequency range of the r-mode oscillations in the first-order ro- tational calculation. The upper and lower limits on the continuous spectrum in eq.(26) are -- 11 -- shown by two lines. The intermediate values between the two lines are allowed for a fixed model M/R. The frequency is a single value σN , given by eq.(25) in the Newtonian limit. The dragging effect relevant to the relativity broadens the allowed range as shown by eq.(26). In Fig. 3, the allowed range is shown including the second-order corrections for the extreme case Ω2 = M/R3. Even in the Newtonian case, the oscillation frequency is not a single value, since the factor G depends on r, as seen in Fig.1. The allowed range of the frequency further increases with the relativistic factor. From this result, we expect that the r-mode frequency ranges from 0.8σN to 1.2σN for a typical neutron star model with M/R ∼ 0.2. We examine the effect on the spectrum of the gravitational waves emitted by the r-mode oscillations. We for simplicity neglect all relativistic corrections expect in the frequency, and estimate the spectrum by the Newtonian radiation theory. The dimensionless gravitational amplitude h(t) at infinity is determined by evaluating the time variation of the current multipole moment, h(t) ∼ dlSlm/dtl (Thorne 1980). The current multipole moment Slm for l = m = 2 mode and the velocity (53) is given by S22 = N Z ρ0(e−ν)1/2e−2i(Ω−χ)tr6dr, (57) where the normalization N is also included the constant from the integration over angular parts. The Fourier component h(σ) can be expressed as h(σ) = Z h(t)e+iσtdt ∝ Z ρ0(e−ν)1/2(Ω − χ)2δ(σ − 2(Ω − χ))r6dr. (58) The spectrum has a finite line breadth as shown in Fig.4. The spectrum is non-zero only for σ = σN in the Newtonian treatment, but is broad in the relativistic one. The width at the half maximum is ∆σ/σN ∼ 0.1. 6. Discussion In this paper, we have calculated the r-mode oscillations in the relativistic rotating stars, neglecting the gravitational perturbations. The evolution can be described by oscillatory solutions which are neutral, i.e., never decay or grow in the absence of the dissipation. The oscillation is described not by a single frequency, but by the frequencies of a broad range, unlike in the Newtonian case. The reason is that the local rotation rate depends on the position due to the frame dragging effect even for uniform rotation. The r-mode oscillation frequency forms a continuous spectrum within a certain range. This property is distinguished from the well-known stellar oscillation modes such as the polar f-, p-modes, in which the spectrum of frequency is discrete. The r-mode frequencies lie in the unstable region for the gravitational radiation reaction instability, but it will be an important issue whether or not -- 12 -- the different spectrum of the unstable modes leads to different growth, e.g., in the non-linear regime. We would like to thank Prof. Y. Eriguchi for enlightening discussion about this topics. This was supported in part by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research Fund of the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of Japan (08640378). A. Newtonian limit In this appendix, we will consider the r-mode oscillations in the Newtonian limit, in which (eν, eλ, (ρ0 + p0)/ρ0, /Ω) → 1, (′, m2, k2, W1, W3) → 0. (A1) Equation (40) reduces to the equation derived by Provost et al. (1981), if the variables are matched. They solved the eigenvalue problem, assuming the form e−i(mΩ−σ0(1+σ1))t, where σ0 of O(ε) is given by 2mΩ/(l(l + 1)). The correction σ1 of O(ε2) was determined by solving the eigenvalue problem for the operator LN = DN − (FN + GN ) in the case of A 6= 0, with LN [y] + σ1y = 0, Agρ0 y′#′ DN [y] = 4c3Ω2ρ0" r2 0!′ FN = −4c3Ω2 r2ρ′ g !′ GN = −4c3Ω2 r2 0 Ap′ + , 4c2Ω2 − ρ0 8c2Ω2r Ag#′ "ρ0r + 4c1Ω2 Ag ! , + 2c1rα′ + 2m2 l(l + 1) α, g (A2) (A3) (A4) (A5) where we have used the gravitational acceleration g = ν ′/2 and ellipticity α = −3ξ2/(2r). The second-order correction σ1 exactly corresponds to κ in eq.(45). As shown previously (Provost et al. (1981), Saio 1982), the eigen-value problem becomes singular2 for the barotropic case A = 0, since the second-order differential term vanishes. The second-order solution (56) in the Newtonian limit reduces to U (1) lm + U (2) lm = hN0ρ0rl + f (2) lmi e−i(mΩ−σ0(1+σ1))t. (A6) 2 Recently, Lockitch and Friedman (1998) showed the resolution of the singularity in Newtonian isentropic stars. -- 13 -- This equation is valid only for l = ±m, since the Newtonian counterpart of eq.(50) is never satisfied otherwise. When the correction GN is not a constant, the eigenvalue problem is ill-posed. The function GN indeed depends on r for the compressible matter, so that Provost et al. (1981) concluded no solution in this case. The exceptional case is the incompressible fluid, in which GN is a constant since α = 5/4(Ω2R3/M), g = Mr/R3. The correction in the frequency for l = m is 4l Ω2R3 + 2l l + 1 α, (A7) GN = − (l + 1)3 M which should be the same value calculated by Provost et al. (1981) except a misprint in their expression. -- 14 -- REFERENCES Andersson, N. 1998, ApJ, 502, 708. Andersson, N., Kokkotas, K.D., & Schutz, B.F., 1998, astro-ph/9805225 Chandrasekhar S., 1970, Phys. Rev. Lett. 24, 611. Chandrasekhar S., Miller J.C., 1974, MNRAS, 167, 63. Cowling, T.G., 1941, MNRAS, 101, 367. Cox J.P., 1980, Theory of Stellar Pulsation, Princeton University Press Finn L.S., 1988, MNRAS, 232, 259. Friedman J.L., Schutz B.F., 1978, ApJ, 222, 281. Friedman J.L., 1978, Commum. Math., Phys., 62, 247. Friedman, J.L. and Morsink, S.M. 1998, ApJ, 502, 714. Hartle J.B., 1967, ApJ, 150, 1005. Hinch E.J., 1991, Perturbation Method, Cambridge University Press Lindblom L., Splinter R.J., 1990, ApJ, 348, 198. Lindblom L. 1995, ApJ, 438, 265. Lindblom, L., Owen, B.J. and Morsink, S.M.,1998, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 4843. Lindblom, L. and Ipser, J.R., 1998, gr-qc/9807049 Lockitch, K. H. and Friedman, J. L., 1998, gr-qc/9812019 Kojima, Y. 1992, Phys. Rev. D46, 4289. Kojima, Y. 1997, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 128, 251. Kojima, Y. 1998, MNRAS, 293, 49. Owen, B.J.,et al.1998, Phys. Rev. D58, 4020. Papaloizou J., and Pringle J.E., 1978, MNRAS, 182, 423. Provost J., Berthomieu G., Rocca A., 1981, A&A, 94, 126. -- 15 -- Quintana, H., 1976, ApJ, 207, 279. Saio H., 1982, ApJ, 256, 717. Thorne K.S., 1980, Rev. of Mod. Phys., 52, 299. Yoshida, S. and Kojima, Y. 1997, MNRAS, 289, 117. This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0. 2 3 Ω R M G / 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 −0.2 −0.4 0.0 -- 16 -- M/R=0.01 M/R=0.1 M/R=0.25 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 r/R Fig. 1. -- The second-order correction in the frequency as a function of radius. The factor G is normalized by using the mass M, radius R and angular velocity Ω. The solid line is for the Newtonian case M/R = 0.01. The dotted line represents the result for M/R = 0.1, and the dashed line for M/R = 0.25. N σ σ / 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.0 -- 17 -- 0.1 0.2 0.3 M/R Fig. 2. -- The frequency range with the relativistic factor M/R. Two lines denote the upper and lower limits of the frequency. The intermediate values between them are allowed for a fixed model M/R. The frequency is normalized by the Newtonian value σN . N σ σ / 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.0 -- 18 -- 0.1 0.2 0.3 M/R Fig. 3. -- The same as Fig.2, but the second-order correction with Ω2 = M/R3 is included. ) σ ( h 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 1.0 -- 19 -- 1.1 σ/σ N 1.2 1.3 Fig. 4. -- The Fourier transform of the gravitational wave amplitude of l = m = 2 mode for stellar model M/R = 0.2. The frequency is normalized by the Newtonian value σN , and the amplitude h(σ) is normalized by the maximum.
astro-ph/0406161	1	0406	2004-06-07T12:37:47	Colour changes in quasar light curves	[ "astro-ph" ]	The study of quasar variability has long been seen as a way to understanding the structure of the central engine of active galactic nuclei, and as a means of verifying the morphology of the standard model. Much work has already been done on the statistical properties of light curves monitored in one colour, and it is now possible to use these observations to test predictions of theoretical models. The addition of a second colour can add enormously to the power of such tests, and put tight constraints on the nature of the variations. In this paper a yearly monitoring programme of several hundred quasars in blue and red passbands covering 21 years is presented. The statistics of colour changes are examined for a 15 year period of homogeneous data with Fourier power spectrum analysis, in a form suitable for testing against theoretical predictions. The results of the Fourier analysis show that there is more power in blue light on all timescales than in the red. Examination of the light curves shows several different modes of colour change. However, if allowance is made for the effects of the underlying host galaxy, the variations become close to achromatie. There are however structural differences between red and blue light curves which cannot be accounted for in this way, and various modes of variability including disc instability and microlensing are examined to provide explanations for these features.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, 1 -- 1 (2002) Printed 14 July 2018 (MN LATEX style file v1.4) Colour changes in quasar light curves M. R. S. Hawkins University of Edinburgh, Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, Scotland, UK Accepted ??. Received ??; in original form ?? ABSTRACT The study of quasar variability has long been seen as a way to understanding the structure of the central engine of active galactic nuclei, and as a means of verifying the morphology of the standard model. Much work has already been done on the statistical properties of light curves monitored in one colour, and it is now possible to use these observations to test predictions of theoretical models. The addition of a second colour can add enormously to the power of such tests, and put tight constraints on the nature of the variations. In this paper a yearly monitoring programme of several hundred quasars in blue and red passbands covering 21 years is presented. The statistics of colour changes are examined for a 15 year period of homogeneous data with Fourier power spectrum analysis, in a form suitable for testing against theoretical predictions. The results of the Fourier analysis show that there is more power in blue light on all timescales than in the red. Examination of the light curves shows several different modes of colour change. However, if allowance is made for the effects of the underlying host galaxy, the variations become close to achromatie. There are however structural differences between red and blue light curves which cannot be accounted for in this way, and various modes of variability including disc instability and microlensing are examined to provide explanations for these features. Key words: quasars: general -- galaxies: active 1 INTRODUCTION It has long been recognised that the variability of active galactic nuclei (AGN) has the potential to probe the struc- ture and dynamics of the central engine and put tight con- straints on any unified model. For low luminosity AGN (Seyfert galaxies) extensive monitoring of short term pho- tometric and spectroscopic variations (Peterson et al. 1999) has made a major impact on the understanding of the struc- ture of the central regions. Much effort has also been put into the optical monitoring of luminous AGN (quasars) (Hook et al. 1994; Cristiani et al. 1996; Hawkins 1996), but with less concrete results. The main problems have been the long time scales over which quasars appear to vary making uni- formly sampled light curves for a large number of objects very hard to obtain, and the lack of theoretical predictions against which to test models of quasar variability. A first step towards rectifying this was made possible by the publi- cation of predicted structure functions for light curves in accretion disc and starburst models of quasar variability (Kawaguchi et al. 1998). The predictions were made for one colour passband, and were suitable for comparing with struc- ture functions for samples of quasar light curves. What was needed was a sample of several hundred quasars covering a wide range of redshifts and luminosities, regularly moni- c(cid:13) 2002 RAS tored over a period of decades. Such a sample has gradually been built up from plates taken with the UK 1.2m Schmidt telescope in the ESO/SERC field 287, details of which are given in the following section. Light curves from these data, together with theoretical predictions for the structure func- tion of variations, have been used in a recent paper (Hawkins 2002) to distinguish between various models of AGN vari- ability. An unexpectedly complicated picture emerged in which Seyfert galaxy variations were best explained by an accretion disk model, while quasar variability was closer to the predictions for microlensing. A new dimension can be added to the existing analy- sis by the addition of a second passband to the monitor- ing data. Different models of variability show very different behaviour in the way colour changes manifest themselves in the light curves. So far, quantitative predictions suitable for testing against observations have not been published for any models, but even so there are generic expectations for colour effects in the best studied models. For example, in the starburst model for AGN variability (Aretxaga & Terlevich 1994), the variations are attributed to successions of super- nova explosions. In this model one can confidently predict that AGN will become bluer as they get brighter, just as supernovae do. 2 M. R. S. Hawkins Figure 1. Light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles) for a selection of quasars which show no systematic colour change with brightness. Observational work on colour changes in AGN is rather sparse. The long term monitoring programme of the Seyfert galaxy NGC 5548 has shown strong colour changes in the ultraviolet from IUE observations (Clavel et al. 1991). This is illustrated in Fig. 3 of Hawkins & Taylor (1997) which shows the data uniformly sampled and converted to a mag- nitude scale. The situation with regard to quasars is less clear. Hawkins (1996) concluded that light variations in most quasars were close to being achromatic, on the basis of an analysis of correlations between yearly changes in BJ and R magnitudes, but Cristiani et al. (1997) claimed to find a difference in the amplitude of structure functions for B and R band light curves. A similar small effect is seen in Fourier power spectra (Hawkins 2001), but in these data the author concludes that the difference is not significant. In this paper the intention is to improve on these earlier results by carrying out a comprehensive analysis of colour changes in quasar light curves. This will provide a powerful discriminant between quasar models as they become suffi- ciently robust to make testable predictions. 2 THE QUASAR MONITORING PROGRAMME The light curves in this study are from a long term quasar monitoring programme based on photographic plates taken with the UK Schmidt Telescope of the ESO/SERC field 287. The field centre is at 21h 28m, -45◦ (1950), and some 350 sky limited plates and films have been taken over a variety of timescales from hours to 26 years, and in several opti- cal passbands. Of particular relevamce to the present pro- gramme is a yearly sequence of observations in BJ (IIIa-J emulsion with a GG395 filter) and R (IIIa-F or 4415 emul- sion with a RG630 filter) passbands covering 21 years from 1980 to 2001. This unbroken sequence normally included 4 sky limited exposures in both BJ and R each year, but in a few years it was only possible to obtain one plate in one or both of the passbands. Details of all the plates used in this paper are given in Table 1 of the Appendix. The early plates (up to 1992) were measured with the COSMOS measuring machine, and after that with SuperCOSMOS at the Royal Observatory, Edinburgh. The survey area was confined to c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 Colour changes in quasar light curves 3 Figure 2. Light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles) for a typical selection of quasars. The variation is largely achromatic. c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 4 M. R. S. Hawkins a square area of 19 deg2 in the centre of the field to avoid problems with vignetting and other off-axis effects. Approx- imately 180,000 objects were detected in this area to a limit of BJ ≈ 21.5. The R plates went to a limit of R ≈ 20.5. The plates were paired up to give around 100 photo- metric measures in each of BJ and R for every object on the plate where a detection was made. Because variability was the main interest for these data, the measures were first reduced to a common photometric zero point using local standards. These transformed measures were then calibrated with a CCD standards (Hawkins 1996), giving a typical rel- ative photometric error of 0.08 mag for each plate. For most years where 4 plates were available this error reduced to 0.04 mag. A more detailed discussion of these errors is given by Hawkins (1996) and references therein. The absolute pho- tometric errors across the field are somewhat larger than this, but are hard to pin down precisely without a grid of standards covering the whole field. They are however not sig- nificant for the present investigation where relative change in brightness is being analysed. The quasars for the sample were selected by a number of methods including ultra-violet excess, variability, objec- tive prism, and red drop-out. Of the estimated 1800 quasars in the field, some 1200 now have redshifts in the range 0.1 < z < 4.5. From this parent population a number of complete samples have been constructed according to well- defined selection criteria (Hawkins 2000). The light curves now span 26 years in the BJ passband, and 21 years in both BJ and R. Nearly all quasars discovered by colour tech- niques have varied by more than 0.35 mag, the threshold for detection by variability. The statistics of this are discussed in more detail by Hawkins (2000). The quasar light curves in this survey appear to be most useful on a timescale of 5 years or more. Short term variations were studied by taking 16 exposures over six months in 1984. Typical light curves are illustrated by Hawkins (1996), and analysis shows that very few of the quasars in the sample vary by more than 0.1 mag over this period, This is too close to the photometric errors on the measurements to be useful for statistical anal- ysis. In fact the median amplitude for quasar variation is about 0.6 mag, and most quasars in the sample take a few years to achieve this (Hawkins 2000). 3 COLOUR CHANGES IN QUASAR LIGHT CURVES 3.1 Qualitative aspects of the light curves It was stated by Hawkins (1996) that the variation of most quasars appears to be nearly achromatic, and indeed it is not difficult to find examples of quasar light curves which show no measurable colour change even with large changes in amplitude. Four such cases are shown in Fig. 1, and it will be seen that although there is some scatter between blue and red magnitudes in individual years, there is no sytem- atic change in colour with brightness. At the other extreme, there are quasars which show light curves of very different character in blue and red passbands (Hawkins 1998). The long term (several years) variation of most quasars is near to being achromatic, but close examination of the light curves shows small departures from this simple picture. Fig. 2 shows six typical quasar light curves which illustrate this. It will be seen that although there is no systematic colour change between maximum and minimum brightness, sharp features in the blue light curves tend to be slightly 'smeared out' in the red. Also, there are occasional small isolated fluctuations on a timescale of a year in either pass- band which are not mirrored in the other colour. One type of variation which is rarely seen in the quasar population is the strictly chromatic variability observed for NGC 5548 (Clavel et al. 1991). 3.2 Fourier power spectra of the light curves Most statistical analysis of AGN light curves until recently was carried out by calculating the structure function (Cris- tiani et al. 1996; Hook et al. 1994) or auto-correlation function (Hawkins 1996). The idea was to characterise the timescale or amplitude by reference to the shape of these functions, but the early results did not shed much light on these or any other parameters. There were several prob- lems to overcome. Perhaps the most important one concerns the timescale covered by the observations. Inspection of the light curves in Figs 1 and 2 strongly suggests power on a timescale of decades or more, and recent work has confirmed this (Hawkins 2001). To properly measure the timescale of variation it is clear that a run of data covering many tens of years is ideally needed. Although this ideal has yet to be achieved, the survey on which the present analysis is based goes a long way to addressing the problem. Another prob- lem with early datasets was the lack of homogeneous, regular monitoring. Without this, time series analysis becomes dif- ficult, with spurious features and aliassing dominating the results. It is also important to have a large sample of light curves covering a large span of AGN redshift and luminosity to enable subsamples to be analysed and compared. Again, this survey marks a major improvement on earlier work. Another area of difficulty concerns the procedures which have been used to analyse light curves. The irregular pattern of observations in the monitoring programmes has led to the choice of structure or auto-correlations functions as analyt- ical tools, which are relatively insensitive to aliassing prob- lems from unevenly spaced data. However, these functions have a number of drawbacks, including correlation between the points, difficulty in characterising the errors, and ambi- guity of interpretation. Fourier power spectra, although con- taining essentially the same information for an infinite run of data, provide a number of advantages for finite datasets. The frequency values are much less affected by neighbour- ing points, the errors are relatively easy to calculate, and the interpretation is much more straightforward than for other functions. The main reason that they have not been used in the past is that to be useful a long run of evenly sampled homogeneous data is essential to avoid insurnount- able aliassing problems. The data described in section 2 now meet these requirements, and so we shall use Fourier power spectrum analysis to investigate the chromatic properties of AGN light curves in this paper. We define the Fourier power spectrum P (j) for each light curve, in the observers frame, as c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 Colour changes in quasar light curves 5 Figure 3. Light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles) for two low luminosity AGN which show the effects of the underlying galaxy in their light curves. P (j) =(N −1 Xn=0 cos(cid:16) 2πjn N (cid:17) m(n))2 +(N −1 Xn=0 sin(cid:16) 2πjn N (cid:17) m(n))2 where N is the number of epochs, and the frequency j runs from 0 to N-1. The power spectrum of a sample of light curves is defined as the mean of the individual power spectra P(j). Fig. 5 shows the combined Fourier power spectrum for a sample of 302 blue and red passband light curves for the period 1983-1987. During this period there were four plates of similar quality in both colours taken within a few weeks of each other every year. COSMOS measures of the four yearly plates in each colour were averaged with equal weight to give a uniformly sampled and homogeneous run of data. The power spectrum was evaluated for each light curve, and these power spectra were then averaged as described above. The errors were calculated in two ways. Firstly, the sam- ple was split into various subsamples, and the dispersion in the resulting power spectra used to estimate the errors. Secondly, a sample of stars from the same set of measure- ments as the quasars was analysed in the same way, and the dispersion in the frequency measures used to estimate the error on each point. The errors obtained by these two meth- ods were not significantly different, and an average value was used. The left hand panel shows data for the observed light curves, and it will be seen that in both BJ and R passbands the shape of the power spectrum is close to a power law, and although the two slopes are similar there is significantly more power in BJ . This implies a larger ampltude of varia- tion in blue light, and hence that the AGN become bluer as they brighten. 3.3 Effect of an underlying host galaxy One obvious possible reason for a change in colour as AGN vary is the presence of an underlying galaxy of compara- ble brightness to the nucleus, but of a redder colour. When the nucleus is at its brightest, the additional light from the underlying galaxy will have little effect on either the blue c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 or red light curves. However, as the nucleus dims the light of the quasar will become progressively more dominated by the light of the underlying galaxy. For a red galaxy this will happen first in the red, and the red light curve may even bottom out at the R magnitude of the underlying galaxy. In blue light the quasar will continue to fade, as the nuclear light continues to dominate the faint B flux of the galaxy. Plausible examples of this process may be seen in Fig. 3 which shows the light curves for two low luminosity AGN (MB ∼ −22). This pattern of behaviour is never seen in more luminous AGN (quasars) such as in Fig. 1. The possibility that colour changes in light curves are caused by the effects of an underlying galaxy can be tested by attempting to correct for such an effect. The first step is to estimate the mean magnitude of the quasar host galaxies and its dispersion. This can be done for the quasars in the sample used here by looking for light curves similar to those in Fig. 3 which bottom out in the red, but continue falling in blue. A sample of 17 was chosen by eye from the available quasar light curves, on the basis that they showed clear signs of the variation in R reaching a minimum when the BJ light continued to fade. The mean luminosity of the underlying galaxies measured in this way was found to be MR = −22.6 with a standard deviation σ = 0.4. The small dispersion in the flux of host galaxies provides a plausible basis for attempting to correct for the colour dis- tortion of the light curves by subtracting the mean value from each point in the R band light curves. The effect of do- ing this is shown in Fig. 4. Light curves for two quasars show- ing evidence for colour changes with luminosity are shown in the two left hand panels. The colour change is such that the amplitude in BJ is larger than in R. The same light curves are shown in the two right hand panels, but with the estimated mean flux of the underlying galaxy subtracted. It will be seen that apart from one or two isolated short term fluctuations the variation is now close to being achromatic in both light curves. The two galaxies in Fig. 4 were chosen so that the effect is clear to the eye, but there is also a significant effect on the 6 M. R. S. Hawkins Figure 4. Light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles) for two AGN. The left hand panels show the light curves as measured, with evidence for chromatic variation. In the right hand panels the contribution from the underlying galaxy has been subtracted, and the variation is close to being achromatic. statistical properties of variation when the correction is ap- plied to a large sample of light curves. The right hand panel of Fig. 5 shows the power spectrum for the sample of 302 light curves in the left hand panel, but with the contribution of the underlying galaxy subtracted as described above. It is clear that in the right hand panel the two power spectra are indistinguishable within the errors, implying that the resid- ual variation is close to achromatic. We can examine this model in a bit more detail by splitting the sample into low and high luminosity objects to see whether a single luminos- ity for the underlying galaxy really is sufficient. In Fig. 6 we see power spectra as for Fig. 5, but in two luminosity bins containing 125 and 177 light curves for low and high lumi- nosity quasars respectively. In each case a galaxy luminosity of MR = −22.6 has been used, and it is clear that for the less luminous quasars this works well. For the more lumi- nous quasars a somewhat brighter underlying galaxy would be needed to produce achromatic variation. 3.4 Colour changes in accretion discs In most well studied systems which are believed to be pow- ered by accretion discs, variations in brightness are accom- panied by colour changes. These are usually such that the object becomes bluer with increasing luminosity. Well known examples of this come from dwarf novae (Horne et al. 1990) and Seyfert galaxies (Clavel et al. 1991; Peterson et al. 1999). The development of accretion disc models has not so far reached the point where quantitative predictions suitable for comparing with observations have been made as to the nature of colour changes, so in interpreting observed colour changes it is necessary to rely on more general conceptual considerations. The standard model of a geometrically thick, optically thick disc (Shakura & Sunyaev 1973) has a temperature gra- dient such that it becomes cooler and redder with increasing radius. It is not perhaps surprising that it can be shown that the non-linear oscillations of such a disc can lead to temper- ature and hence colour changes. Radial temperature changes c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 Colour changes in quasar light curves 7 Figure 5. Fourier power spectra for quasar light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles). The left hand panel shows results for the observed light curves, and the right hand panel for the same light curves after subtracting a contribution for the underlying galaxy of absolute magnitude MR = −22.6. in thermally unstable slim accretion discs have been exam- ined in some detail with the aid of numerical simulations by Honma et al. (1991). They show that a hot wave propagates outwards as instabilities occur in the inner disc, leading to a change in integrated colour, in the sense that as the disc becomes brighter it becomes bluer. This is consistent with the observations of Seyfert galaxies (Clavel et al. 1991; Pe- terson et al. 1999), and also for the type of quasar variation seen in Fig. 4. The achromatic variation seen in Fig. 1 would not be consistent with this model, and nor would the light curves shown in Fig. 2. Here, basically achromatic variation is modified by the smoothing out in the red of the sharper features in the blue light curves. An alternative approach to modelling optical variability in accretion discs (Mineshige et al. 1994) invokes a cellular automaton mechanism. The accretion disc achieves a self- organised critical state in which a 1/f spectrum of fluctu- ations is produced. This cellular automaton model appears to be the most promising approach to modelling disc insta- bilities at the moment. It has been developed by Kawaguchi et al. (1998) to investigate variability in AGN. They use it to produce simulated light curves with a power law spec- trum of variations which can be compared with observa- tions (Hawkins 2001). For Seyfert galaxies there is good agreement, although for more luminous quasars the observed spectrum of variations is flatter. Although no quantitative predictions have so far been made for colour changes, it is plausible that in a disc with a strong temperature and hence colour gradient these avalanches will produce chromatic ef- fects as the flux varies. The problem here is that any variabil- ity would be on a very short timescale, and inconsistent with c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 the observations of optical variations. Definitive answers to these points must await model predictions for colour changes in the different types of accretion disc. 3.5 Colour changes from microlensing An alternative explanation for the effects shown in Fig. 5 comes from microlensing. In this picture, the observed vari- ation is produced by the gravitational microlensing effect of a population of planetary or sub-stellar mass bodies along the line of sight to the quasar (Hawkins 1996). Although the microlensing of a point source produces a strictly achromatic light curve, for an accretion disc with a radial temperature gradient this is not necessarily so. For example, if the nu- cleus is a compact blue source unresolved by the character- istic mass of the microlenses, but in the red the source is less compact and partially resolved by the lensing objects, colour changes may be observed as the source is microlensed. The effect of this can be seen in the results of numerical simu- lation of microlensing of unresolved and partially resolved sources (Lewis et al., 1993; Schneider & Weiss 1987) where the smaller power for the resolved sources is well illustrated. The application of this model to the microlensing of an ac- cretion disc with a compact blue nucleus and a strong radial colour gradient would be to produce less power in the red than the blue fluctuations, providing that the emitting re- gion of the disc is comparable with the Einstein radius of the lenses. These ideas have been put on a firmer and more quan- titative footing in a recent paper by Yonehara et al. (1999). They carry out numerical simulations of the microlensing 8 M. R. S. Hawkins Figure 6. Fourier power spectra for quasar light curves in BJ (filled circles) and R (open circles). The left hand panels show results for the observed light curves, in two luminosity bins. The right hand panels show Fourier power spectra for the same light curves, after subtracting a contribution for the underlying galaxy of absolute magnitude MR = −22.6 in both luminosity bins. of accretion disks by a compact body, and show that for a standard optically thick accretion disc with a radial temper- ature gradient colour changes will be seen, whereas for an optically thin (advection dominated) disc where most of the emission takes place at the inner edge, the variation will be achromatic. Yonehara et al. (1999) base their modelling on the multiply lensed quasar system Q2237+0305. The indi- vidual images in this system have been shown to vary achro- matically when microlensed (Corrigan et al. 1991; Houde & Racine 1994) which would imply an optically thin disc. How- c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 ever, to account for the colour changes implied in Fig. 5 and illustrated in the light curves, an accretion disc of greater optical depth would be required. There is one other aspect of microlensing which has rele- vance to the quasar light curves, especially those in Fig. 2. In a situation where the accretion disc has a blue compact core embedded in redder outerparts, then lensing can produce cusp-like features from the unresolved central region which are smoothed out in the resolved red light source. The idea can be seen from the synthetic light curves for more and less resolved sources in Schneider & Weiss (1987). This pro- vides an explaination for the way sharp blue features become smoother in the red in Fig. 5. 4 DISCUSSION It is clear from examination of Figs. 1-4 that colour changes can occur in quasar light curves. This result is consistent with earlier work for Seyfert galaxies (Clavel et al. 1991) and quasars (Cristiani et al. 1997), but also shows that there are apparently different modes of colour change. We tentatively identify the following patterns: (i) Achromatic, no indication of any colour change. (ii) Light curves showing the same structure in red and blue, but with a scale change. (iii) The apparent bottoming out of red light curves as blue light continues to decline. (iv) Colour change mainly characterised by the smooth- ing in the red of sharp features in the blue. It is quite possible that no single model will be found that can account for such a diverse range of features in the light curves. On the other hand, theories of quasar variability should make predictions about colour changes, which may well be similar and require detailed comparison with good data to distinguish them. Fig. 5 implies that even with a very simple model for the underlying galaxy, the mean power spectra for red and blue light can be brought into coinci- dence. Although it is clear that the presence of an underlying red galaxy plays a significant role in AGN colour changes, it cannot account for all the features seen in the two-colour light curves. Examination of Fig. 2 shows that there are features in the light curves which cannot be reconciled in this way. To be more specific, certain cusp-like features in the blue light curves appear as if smoothed out in the red, although there is typically little overall change in colour be- tween maximum and minimum light. At present, theoretical understanding of accretion disc instabilities is not sufficiently well developed that such de- tailed features can be modelled. It is certainly possible that an event in the blue centre of a nucleus could propagate into the redder outerparts and become blurred in the process, but the apparent symmetry of the colour changes imposes constraints on such a mechanism. In disc instability models where the emission is localised to a particular region of the disc, there may well be colour changes associated with the outburst, but there is no reason to believe that the structure of the event will be different in red and blue passbands. Microlensing does provide a possible explanation both for overall changes in colour, and for the smearing out in the c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 Colour changes in quasar light curves 9 red of rapid brightness changes in the blue. This effect relies on an accretion disc of comparable size to the Einstein radii of the lenses, but given this it is a prediction of microlensing variations that if colour changes are observed at all they will be such that features in the blue will be smoothed out in the red. Furthermore, the larger the colour change, the more pronounced this smoothing will be. 5 CONCLUSIONS In this paper we have investigated colour changes in a large sample of quasars, monitored yearly in the BJ and R bands over a period of 21 years. Examination of the light curves suggests that the variations involve colour changes for many quasars, and Fourier power spectrum analysis for a 15 year homogeneous subset of the data confirms that there is more power on all timescales in the blue passband compared with red. This effect may at least in part be due to the contribu- tion of red light from the underlying host galaxy, and can be corrected for in such a way that the variation comes close to being achromatic for all quasars. Current theories of accretion disc instability can explain colour changes seen in observations of Seyfert galaxies. The standard optically thick accretion disk is characterised by a radial temperature gradient which when perturbed will tend to exhibit changes in integrated colour. However, they do not appear to be able to produce the smearing out in the red of blue features which is a characteristic of many quasar light curves. An alternative explanation for the observed variability of quasars is that it is caused by the microlensing effects of a population of planetary or sub-stellar mass bodies dis- tributed along the line of sight. In this case achromatic vari- ation can be accounted for by microlensing of an optically thin (advection dominated) disc. Chromatic variations are possible with a conventional optically thick disc with a radial colour gradient, which is large compared with the Einstein radius of the lenses. This can also explain the the observed smearing out in the red of cusp-like features in the blue. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I wish to thank Alan Heavens for suggestions with regard to the subtraction of the flux of the underlying host galaxy. REFERENCES Aretxaga I., Terlevich R., 1994, MNRAS, 269, 462 Clavel J. et al., 1991, ApJ, 366, 64 Corrigan R.T., et al., 1991, AJ, 102, 34 Cristiani S., Trentini S., La Franca F., Aretxaga I., Andreani P., Vio R., Gemmo, A., 1996, A&A, 306, 395 Cristiani S., Trentini S., La Franca F., Andreani P., 1997, A&A, 321, 123 Hawkins M.R.S., 1996, MNRAS, 278, 787 Hawkins M.R.S., 1998, A&A, 340, L23 Hawkins M.R.S., 2000, A&AS, 143, 465 Hawkins M.R.S., 2001, ApJ, 553, L97 Hawkins M.R.S., 2002, MNRAS, 329, 76 Hawkins M.R.S., Taylor A.N., 1997, ApJ, 482, L5 Honma F., Matsumoto R., Kato S., 1991, PASJ, 43, 147 10 M. R. S. Hawkins Horne K., la Dous C.A., Shafter A.W., 1990, in Mauche C.W. ed., Accretion-Powered Compact Binaries. p.109, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, p. 109 Hook I.M., McMahon R.G., Boyle B.J., Irwin M.J., 1994, MN- RAS, 268, 305 Houde M., Racine R., 1994, AJ, 107, 466 Kawaguchi T., Mineshige S., Umemura M., Turner E.L., 1998, ApJ, 504, 671 Lewis G.F., Miralda-Escud´e J., Richardson D.C., Wambsganss J., 1993, MNRAS, 281, 647 Mineshige S., Ouchi N.B., Nishimori H., 1994, PASJ, 46, 97 Peterson B.M. et al., 1999, ApJ, 510, 659 Schneider P., Weiss A., 1987, A&A, 171, 49 Shakura N.I., Sunyaev R.A., 1973, A&A, 24, 337 Yonehara A., Mineshige S., Fukue J., Umemura M., Turner E.L., A&A, 343, 41 APPENDIX Table 1. Details of photographic observations for the two-colour monitoring programme Plate Date Emulsion Filter Exposure R 6196 R 6200 R 6209 J 6229 R 6230 R 6238 J 7099 R 7259 R 8005 J 8008 R 8649 R 8671 R 8717 R 8723 J 8727 J 8728 J 8729 J 8730 J 9322 R 9323 J 9327 J 9335 R 9336 J 9338 R 9365 R 9374 J10260 J10264 J10271 J11344 R11345 R11351 R11359 R11360 J11387 R11919 J11949 J11971 J12012 J12023 R12084 R12136 J12602 R12626 J12648 J12656 J12657 R12669 R12740 R12771 R13207 R13251 J13252 J13269 R13270 J13315 J13316 R13338 J13760 80-08-04 80-08-05 80-08-06 80-08-09 80-08-09 80-08-10 81-08-01 81-10-06 82-08-14 82-08-16 83-07-09 83-07-14 83-08-03 83-08-04 83-08-05 83-08-05 83-08-05 83-08-05 84-05-26 84-05-26 84-05-27 84-05-28 84-05-28 84-05-29 84-06-03 84-06-04 85-06-14 85-06-15 85-06-16 86-09-04 86-09-05 86-09-06 86-09-07 86-09-07 86-09-25 87-05-25 87-06-04 87-06-22 87-07-18 87-07-22 87-08-21 87-09-14 88-06-12 88-06-19 88-07-12 88-07-14 88-07-14 88-07-18 88-09-04 88-10-07 89-07-27 89-08-26 89-08-26 89-09-03 89-09-03 89-09-24 89-09-24 89-09-28 90-06-23 IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 90.0 90.0 90.0 65.0 90.0 90.0 75.0 15.0 90.0 60.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 65.0 60.0 80.0 60.0 60.0 90.0 60.0 90.0 90.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 80.0 90.0 80.0 75.0 75.0 90.0 128.9 75.0 104.4 75.0 28.5 130.0 130.0 120.0 106.1 100.0 100.0 100.0 150.0 140.0 140.0 90.0 120.0 60.0 65.0 75.0 60.0 60.0 100.0 60.0 c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 Colour changes in quasar light curves 11 Plate Date Emulsion Filter Exposure Plate Date Emulsion Filter Exposure R10349 J11319 J11334 J17775 J17779 J17788 R18028 J18110 R18484 J18492 J18503 J18514 R18521 J18522 R18524 R18529 R18853 R18855 R18876 R18882 J18919 J18926 J18945 J18947 R19209 R19210 R19217 R19219 J19220 J19225 J19235 J19236 85-07-23 86-08-29 86-09-02 97-10-21 97-10-22 97-10-24 98-05-28 98-09-17 99-07-09 99-07-19 99-08-03 99-08-05 99-08-06 99-08-06 99-08-09 99-08-10 00-06-02 00-06-03 00-07-01 00-07-06 00-08-06 00-08-29 00-09-18 00-09-19 01-06-20 01-06-20 01-06-25 01-06-27 01-06-27 01-06-29 01-07-22 01-07-22 IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ 4415 IIIaJ 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ 4415 IIIaJ 4415 4415 4415 4415 4415 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ 4415 4415 4415 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 90.0 80.0 85.0 60.0 60.0 60.0 90.0 60.0 90.0 35.9 60.0 60.0 110.0 49.6 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 60.0 60.0 60.0 60.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 60.0 60.0 49.0 60.0 R13767 J13789 R13790 J13819 R13830 J13837 R13909 R14396 R14417 R14422 J14449 R14502 J14640 J14643 J14648 R15005 J15006 J15034 R15045 R15073 R15086 J15102 J15563 R15564 R15575 R15673 R15684 J15795 J15796 J15801 R16149 R16160 J16177 J16180 J16183 R16208 R16224 J16230 R16678 J16700 R16703 J16728 J16731 J16741 R16747 R16754 R17108 J17117 J17167 J17173 J17189 R17197 R17232 R17254 R17592 R17599 R17611 R17615 J17774 J10292 R10302 R10306 R10341 90-06-29 90-08-19 90-08-19 90-09-10 90-09-16 90-09-17 90-10-12 91-07-07 91-07-19 91-07-20 91-08-07 91-09-01 91-10-31 91-11-01 91-11-07 92-06-03 92-06-03 92-07-01 92-07-03 92-07-26 92-07-28 92-08-01 93-05-24 93-05-24 93-05-26 93-08-09 93-08-11 93-10-05 93-10-06 93-10-07 94-06-15 94-06-17 94-07-06 94-07-07 94-07-08 94-07-29 94-08-09 94-08-10 95-07-06 95-07-29 95-07-30 95-08-20 95-08-23 95-08-25 95-08-26 95-08-28 96-05-23 96-05-25 96-08-07 96-08-11 96-08-13 96-08-14 96-09-11 96-09-14 97-06-07 97-06-08 97-06-10 97-06-11 97-10-19 85-06-24 85-06-26 85-06-27 85-07-20 IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaJ 4415 IIIaJ 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ 4415 4415 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaJ 4415 4415 4415 4415 4415 4415 4415 IIIaJ IIIaJ IIIaF IIIaF IIIaF c(cid:13) 2002 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1 -- 1 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 GG 395 GG 395 RG 630 RG 630 RG 630 90.0 60.0 84.2 60.0 95.0 65.0 110.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 60.0 100.0 60.0 80.0 60.0 90.0 80.0 100.0 62.1 90.0 90.0 80.0 65.0 85.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 60.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 66.8 110.0 110.0 110.0 70.0 135.0 110.0 90.0 60.0 90.0 60.0 60.0 70.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 60.0 60.0 60.0 105.0 120.0 110.0 90.0 120.0 120.0 120.0 60.0 90.0 100.0 105.0 105.0
0807.3739	1	0807	2008-07-23T19:59:49	Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission V. CoRoT-Exo-4b: Stellar and planetary parameters	[ "astro-ph" ]	The CoRoT satellite has announced its fourth transiting planet (Aigrain et al. 2008) with space photometry. We describe and analyse complementary observations of this system performed to establish the planetary nature of the transiting body and to estimate the fundamental parameters of the planet and its parent star. We have analysed high precision radial-velocity data, ground-based photometry, and high signal-to-noise ratio spectroscopy. The parent star CoRoT-Exo-4 (2MASS 06484671-0040219) is a late F-type star of mass of 1.16 Msun and radius of 1.17 Rsun. The planet has a circular orbit with a period of 9.20205d. The planet radius is 1.19 Rjup and the mass is 0.72 Mjup. It is a gas-giant planet with a ''normal'' internal structure of mainly H and He. CoRoT-Exo-4b has the second longest period of the known transiting planets. It is an important discovery since it occupies an empty area in the mass-period diagram of transiting exoplanets.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Astronomy&Astrophysicsmanuscript no. 10273printer June 1, 2018 c(cid:13) ESO 2018 Letter to the Editor Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission V. CoRoT-Exo-4b: Stellar and planetary parameters ⋆ Moutou, C.1, Bruntt, H.2, Guillot, T.3, Shporer, A.4, Guenther, E.5, Aigrain, S.6, Almenara, J.M.7, Alonso, R.1, Auvergne, M.8, Baglin, A.8, Barbieri, M.1, Barge, P.1, Benz, W.9, Bord´e, P.10, Bouchy, F.11, Deeg, H.J.7, De la Reza, R.12, Deleuil, M.1, Dvorak, R.13, Erikson, A.14, Fridlund, M.15, Gillon, M.16, Gondoin, P.15, Hatzes, A.5, H´ebrard, G.11, Jorda, L.1, Kabath, P.14, Lammer, H.17, L´eger, A.10, Llebaria, A.1, Loeillet, B.1,11, Magain, P.18, Mayor, M.16, Mazeh, T.4, Ollivier, M.10, Patzold, M.19, Pepe, F.16, Pont, F.6, Queloz, D.16, Rabus, M.7, Rauer, H.14,21, Rouan, D.8, Schneider, J.20, Udry, S.16, and Wuchterl, G.5 (Affiliations can be found after the references) Received / Accepted ABSTRACT Aims. The CoRoT satellite has announced its fourth transiting planet (Aigrain et al. 2008) with space photometry. We describe and analyse complementary observations of this system performed to establish the planetary nature of the transiting body and to estimate the fundamental parameters of the planet and its parent star. Methods. We have analysed high precision radial-velocity data, ground-based photometry, and high signal-to-noise ratio spectroscopy. Results. The parent star CoRoT-Exo-4 (2MASS 06484671-0040219) is a late F-type star of mass of 1.16 M⊙ and radius of 1.17 R⊙. The planet has a circular orbit with a period of 9.20205d. The planet radius is 1.19 RJup and the mass is 0.72 MJup. It is a gas-giant planet with a "normal" internal structure of mainly H and He. CoRoT-Exo-4b has the second longest period of the known transiting planets. It is an important discovery since it occupies an empty area in the mass-period diagram of transiting exoplanets. Key words. planetary systems – techniques: photometry – techniques: radial velocity – stars: fundamental parameters 1. Introduction The masses and radii of extrasolar planets are fundamental pa- rameters for constraining the physics at play in their interiors. A combination of photometric and Doppler techniques is presently the only way to indirectly derive these parameters. However, this possibility is limited to planets that transit in front of their stars, hence a sample of objects that is highly biased towards close-in orbits. The planet search programme conducted from space by CoRoT (Baglin et al. 2006) is currently monitoring tens of thou- sands of stars and is regularly discovering new transiting plan- ets (Barge et al. 2008; Alonso et al. 2008; Deleuil et al. 2008a). CoRoT has the ability to discover planets with smaller radii and/or longer periods than what is routinely achieved by ground- based transit surveys. The evolution of fundamental parameters of extrasolar planets will thus be explored as a function of the distance to the star and as related characteristics like irradiation. This has important implications for our understanding of these planets. For example, it is a way to test whether tidal damp- ing (highly dependent on orbital distance), increased opacities, Send offprint requests to: e-mail: [email protected] ⋆ Based on observations obtained with CoRoT, a space project op- erated by the French Space Agency, CNES, with participation of the Science Programme of ESA, ESTEC/RSSD, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Germany and Spain; and on observations made with the SOPHIE spec- trograph at Observatoire de Haute Provence, France (PNP.07B.MOUT), and the HARPS spectrograph at ESO La Silla Observatory (079.C- 0127/F). or alternative theories are the explanation for the anomalously large sizes of some extrasolar planets (e.g. Guillot et al. 2006; Burrows et al. 2007; Chabrier & Baraffe 2007). With the current detection threshold of the first CoRoT run (45 day duration), 26 transiting events were detected. Two of them turned out to be planets (CoRoT-Exo-1b and 4b, Barge et al. (2008); Aigrain et al. (2008), 2 are grazing eclips- ing binaries, 7 are low-mass binaries, and 10 are background eclipsing binaries. Four events remain unsolved cases, either be- cause they are fast rotators (no possible radial velocity follow- up, the cross-correlation function is too wide or undetected with HARPS) or because they showed no radial-velocity variations. These cases are still in the list of systems to be observed at the next visibility season with higher accuracy. The statistics achieved on this run is compatible with expectations and the simulations on CoRoT detection, with its current threshold and follow-up performances. The present paper focuses on the fourth planet discovered by CoRoT. The detection and light curve analysis is described in a companion paper (Aigrain et al. 2008, hereafter Paper IV). With its 9.20205d period, the planet CoRoT-Exo-4b has the second longest period known so far in the family of transiting planets, after HD 17156b (Barbieri et al. 2007). We conducted a series of complementary observations from the ground to establish the planetary nature of CoRoT-Exo-4b and to derive the fundamen- tal parameters of both the star and the planet. 2 2. Observations 2.1. Photometricobservations C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b The photometric measurement was performed on-board CoRoT in an aperture that is adapted to each star and is trapeze shaped, with a solid angle close to that of a 14 arcsec diameter cir- cle. It means that a faint eclipsing binary in the vicinity of the main target can produce a transiting event diluted enough to mimic a planetary signal (Brown 2003). The contamination fac- tor of CoRoT-Exo-4 is estimated from the CoRoT entry cata- logue EXODAT (Deleuil et al. 2008b) to be extremely low, i.e. only 0.3% of the light comes from neighbouring stars. The first step in establishing the nature of the transiting body is to check the photometric behaviour of the stars in the vicinity of the tar- get, and especially those that fall inside the photometric aperture mask. This is easily done with ground-based telescopes. CoRoT-Exo-4 was first observed from the Wise Observatory 18-inch telescope (Brosch et al. 2008) on November 12, 2007. Only a partial transit was recorded, thus preventing a precise es- timate of the transit depth (of about 1.4%, which should be com- pared to the out-of-transit scatter of 0.16% in 5-min bins), but it is important that no significant variation was observed in nearby stars. Another transit event was observed with the Euler Camera (120-cm Swiss Telescope at La Silla Observatory) on November 30th, 2007. Two time series of about 40-min were collected in the star field, with a reference series taken at a similar elevation but one night prior to the transit. The transit depth was estimated to be 1.2 ± 0.15%, in agreement with the CoRoT measurements (1.1%). Finally, the ingress of another transit was observed at the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope with MegaCam on December 10, 2007. Again, only a partial transit was observed, and the tran- sit depth was not fully reliable. The three sets of photometric follow up confirm that 1) the transit observed by CoRoT occurs on the central target at the predicted epochs, 2) no star encompasses a deep eclipse, or even a short-term variation, in the vicinity of the target, 3) the transit depth is compatible with the depth measured by CoRoT (i.e. no strong dilution by background objects). A detailed analysis of these data will be given in Deeg et al. (in preparation). 2.2. Radialvelocityobservations Seven radial velocity measurements of CoRoT-Exo-4 were ob- tained with SOPHIE on the 1.93m telescope at Observatoire de Haute Provence (France), from October 31, 2007 to February 2, 2008. These first data points established the planetary nature of the companion, showing a detectable and low-amplitude, radial- velocity variation in phase with the CoRoT ephemeris. Thirteen additional measurements were also obtained with HARPS (3.6m telescope at La Silla, ESO, Chile), from November 19, 2007 to January 21, 2008. Both instruments are cross-dispersed, fiber-fed ´echelle spec- trographs on which precise radial-velocity measurements were performed with regular Th-Ar calibration observations and the reduction involves cross-correlation techniques (Baranne et al. 1996; Pepe et al. 2002). With SOPHIE, the high-efficiency mode was used with a resolving power of 40,000, and the sky back- ground was simultaneously recorded to correct for contamina- tion (Bouchy 2006). The radial velocities were obtained with a weighted cross correlation of the extracted spectra with a numer- ical mask corresponding to a G2 star. The data are listed in Table 2 (available in the on-line ver- sion) and shown in Fig. 1. The orbital solution was derived us- Fig. 1. Radial-velocity measurements of CoRoT-Exo-4 as a function of time, showing the best-fit solution and O − C residu- als. Black filled circles are HARPS data, and red open diamonds are SOPHIE data. ing the combined HARPS and SOPHIE datasets. In the fit we included a constant offset between the two sets of measure- ments. The ephemeris of the CoRoT light curve was used to constrain the solution. The data were best-fitted with a circular Keplerian orbit of semi-amplitude of 63 ±6 m/s. When using the 13 HARPS data points alone, the residual rms is 17.6 m/s. With the combined SOPHIE and HARPS datasets (20 measurements), the residual rms is 19.4 m/s. The offset between SOPHIE and HARPS data is only 5 m/s. Figures 1 and 2 show the data and the best fit as a function of time and orbital phase. The O − C time series does not show any variations that would indicate a second massive body in the system with a baseline of 100 days (Fig. 1). The bisector analysis is shown in Fig. 3. The errors on the span of the bisector slopes are twice as large as for the peak position of the cross-correlation function. The behaviour of the bisector span (BIS) with respect to the radial velocity shows a dispersed relation with little or no trend. Given that short-term variations are seen in the CoRoT light curve (see with Fig. 2 in Paper IV), we tentatively interpret these variations as possibly stemming from a residual of stellar activity. 2.3. Determinationofspectroscopicparameters From radial velocity observations we estimated the projected ve- locity of the parent star. The result is v sin i = 6.4 ± 1 km/s, based on the width of the cross-correlation functions from SOPHIE and HARPS. This agrees with a direct comparison of the observed spectrum with a rotationally broadened syn- thetic spectrum. With our determination of the stellar radius R⋆ = 1.15 R⊙(see below), this translates into a rotational pe- riod of the star ranging between Prot = 8.5 and 10.0 days. This value for the rotation period is compatible with the analysis in Paper IV, and is consistent with a synchronicity of the stellar rotation and the planet orbit. C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b 3 We analysed the normalized spectrum using the semi- automatic software package VWA (Bruntt et al. 2004, 2008). More than 600 mostly non-blended lines were selected for analy- sis in the wavelength range 3 980–6 830 Å. The VWA uses atmo- sphere models interpolated in the grid by Heiter et al. (2002) and atomic parameters from the VALD database (Kupka et al. 1999). Abundances were calculated relative to the solar spectrum from Hinkle et al. (2000) following the approach by Bruntt et al. (2008). The VWA automatically adjusts the parameters (Teff, log g, microturbulence) of the applied atmospheric model to get consistent results for all iron lines. The program iteratively min- imizes the correlation between the abundance and equivalent width found from weak Fe i lines (equivalent widths < 80 mÅ), the correlation of abundance and excitation potential of Fe i lines (equivalent widths < 140 mÅ), and the mean abundance of neu- tral and ionized Fe lines must yield the same result. To estimate the uncertainty on the derived parameters and abundances of individual elements, we measured the sensitivity of the results when changing the parameters of the atmospheric model (see Bruntt et al. 2008). The result is Teff = 6190±60 K, log g = 4.41±0.05, and a mi- croturbulence ξt = 0.94 ± 0.07 km s−1. The determined spectro- scopic parameters do not depend on the adopted value of v sin i. The overall metallicity is found as the mean abundance of the elements with at least 20 lines (Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Fe, Ni) yield- ing [M/H] = +0.05 ± 0.07. Details on individual abundances of CoRoT host stars will be given in a later paper. 3. Estimation of the stellar and planetary parameters 3.1. Stellarmass,radius,andage Using evolutionary tracks (Siess et al. 2000; Morel & Lebreton 2007), the spectroscopic determination of Teff and the ratio M1/3 s /Rs estimated from the CoRoT photometry (Paper IV), we derived the following estimates for the mass and radius of the star: Ms = 1.16+0.03 −0.03 R⊙. This corresponds to a surface gravity of log g = 4.37 ± 0.02, which agrees with the spectroscopic value of 4.41 ± 0.05. −0.02 M⊙ and Rs = 1.17+0.01 While the details of the process of how lithium is depleted in F-stars is not yet fully understood, it is now well-established that lithium is depleted for stars with a temperature below 6 200 K (Steinhauer & Deliyannis 2004). However, lithium depletion in F-stars is expected to be slow, and data taken for stars with the same age and spectral type show a huge scatter in the equiva- lent width. By comparing the equivalent width of the Li i line at λ6708 (35.2 ± 4.8 mÅ) of CoRoT-Exo-4b with the data for the Hyades (Boesgaard & Tripicco 1986; Thorburn et al. 1993), the UMa moving group (Soderblom et al. 1993), and NGC 3960 (Prisinzano & Randich 2007), an age of about 1+1.0 −0.3 Gyr is the most likely estimate for CoRoT-Exo-4b. 3.2. Planetarymassandradius Using the values obtained from the transit fit to the CoRoT light curve (Paper IV), the characteristics of the radial-velocity fit, and the stellar parameters from the previous section, we get a planetary mass of Mp = 0.72 ± 0.08 MJup and a planetary radius Rp = 1.19+0.06 −0.05 RJup. The semi-major axis of the orbit is a = 0.090 ± 0.001 AU. The mean density of the planet is 0.525 ±0.15 g cm−3. This new planet is found in the expected lo- cation of the mass-radius diagram (Fressin et al. 2007). In terms Fig. 2. Radial-velocity measurements of CoRoT-Exo-4 with respect to the orbital phase as estimated from the CoRoT ephemeris and the best-fit solution. Black filled circles are HARPS data, and red open diamonds are SOPHIE data. Fig. 3. Bisector variations (span of the bisector slope) as a func- tion of orbital phase (top panel) and radial velocity value (bot- tom panel). Black filled circles are HARPS data, and red open diamonds are SOPHIE data. We determined the fundamental parameters of the host star by analysing a HARPS spectrum. The signal-to-noise (S/N) level in the continuum is around 60 per pixel in the range 5 000- 6 000 Å and it decreases to 40 in the red and blue parts. The spectrum was carefully normalized by identifying continuum windows in a synthetic spectrum calculated with the parameters of the target star. A spline function was fitted to the continuum windows and divided into the observed spectrum to obtain the normalized spectrum. We made sure that the shapes and depths of lines in adjacent spectral orders were in good agreement. In the final spectrum, the orders were merged and the overlapping parts added using weights based on the measured S/N. 4 C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b no core 20Me core Table 1. The orbit parameters and the fundamental parameters of CoRoT-Exo-4b and its host star. opacities x30 1% K.E. standard opacities x30 1% K.E. standard V0 [ km/s] e P [d] Mp [MJup] ρp [g/cm3] Ms [M⊙] v sin i [km/s] log g 32.301 ± 0.005 0.0 ± 0.1 9.20205 ± 0.00037 0.72 ± 0.08 0.525 ± 0.15 1.16+0.03 −0.02 6.4 ± 1.0 4.41 ± 0.05 K [ m/s] a [AU] 63 ± 6 0.090 ± 0.001 Rp [RJup] Teq [K] Rs [R⊙] Teff [K] Age [Gy] 1.190+0.06 −0.05 1, 074 ± 19 1.17+0.01 −0.03 6190 ± 60 11.0 −0.3 Fig. 4. Theoretical models for the contraction of CoRoT-Exo- 4b with time compared to the observations. The models (Guillot et al. 2006) assume either solar composition (left panel) or the presence of a central dense core of 20 M⊕ (right panel). In each case, three possible evolution models are shown: (1) a standard model; (2) a model assuming that 1% of the incoming stellar luminosity is transformed into kinetic energy and dissi- pated in the deep interior by tides, (3) a model in which interior opacities have been arbitrarily increased by a factor 30. of composition, Fig. 4 shows that it contains a relatively small amount of heavy elements (0 to up to ∼ 30 M⊕, depending on the model chosen), as expected from the empirical correlation between stellar metallicity and mass of heavy elements in the planet (Guillot et al. 2006; Burrows et al. 2007; Guillot 2007). The agreement with different models of planetary evolution im- plies that we cannot rule out any specific scenario used to ex- plain anomalously large planets at this point. However, the dis- covery of other transiting planets on long-period orbits will be extremely valuable. 4. Discussion The planet CoRoT-Exo-4b has the second longest period of the transiting systems known today and is found in a region of the mass-period parameter space that was previously empty (see Fig. 5 available on-line). The mean density of 0.525 g cm−3 makes CoRoT-Exo-4b a gas-giant with a "normal" internal structure dominated by H and He. It is located in the bulk of Hot Jupiters in the mass-radius diagram. We estimate the age of the parent star to be about 1 Gyr; thus, the star is likely to be fairly active and its age and rotation rate (Paper IV) are compatible. New discoveries made with CoRoT will likely populate the mass-period diagram in the period range 5–50 days and allow further investigations of the importance of star-to-planet distance on the internal structure of giant planets. This will complement the output from current radial-velocity surveys, allow us to better understand the mechanisms that govern the contraction of these planets, and provide constraints for planet formation models. Acknowledgements. We thank the OHP and ESO staff for help provided dur- ing the SOPHIE/HARPS observations. The German CoRoT team acknowledges support through DLR grants 50OW0204, 50OW0603 and 50QP0701. HJD and JMA acknowledge support by grants ESP2004-03855-C03-03, and ESP2007- 65480-C02-02 of the Spanish Education & Science ministry. References Aigrain, S., Collier Cameron, A., Ollivier, M., et al. 2008, A&A, submitted Alonso, R., Auvergne, M., Baglin, A., et al. 2008, A&A, 482, L21 Baglin, A., Auvergne, M., Boisnard, L., et al. 2006, in COSPAR, Plenary Meeting, Vol. 36, 36th COSPAR Scientific Assembly, 3749 Baranne, A., Queloz, D., Mayor, M., et al. 1996, A&AS, 119, 373 Barbieri, M., Alonso, R., Laughlin, G., et al. 2007, A&A, 476, L13 Barge, P., Baglin, A., Auvergne, M., et al. 2008, A&A, 482, L17 Boesgaard, A. M. & Tripicco, M. J. 1986, ApJ, 303, 724 Bouchy, F. 2006, in Tenth Anniversary of 51 Peg-b: Status of and prospects for hot Jupiter studies, ed. L. Arnold, F. Bouchy, & C. Moutou, 319 Brosch, N., Polishook, D., Shporer, A., et al. 2008, Ap&SS, 314, 163 Brown, T. M. 2003, ApJ, 593, L125 Bruntt, H., Bikmaev, I. F., Catala, C., et al. 2004, A&A, 425, 683 Bruntt, H., De Cat, P., & Aerts, C. 2008, A&A, 478, 487 Burrows, A., Hubeny, I., Budaj, J., & Hubbard, W. B. 2007, ApJ, 661, 502 Chabrier, G. & Baraffe, I. 2007, ApJ, 661, L81 Deleuil, M., Deeg, H., Alonso, R., et al. 2008a, A&A, submitted Deleuil, M., Meunier, J.-C., Moutou, C., et al. 2008b, AJ, submitted Fressin, F., Guillot, T., Morello, V., & Pont, F. 2007, A&A, 475, 729 Guillot, T. 2007, ArXiv e-prints, 712 Guillot, T., Santos, N. C., Pont, F., et al. 2006, A&A, 453, L21 Heiter, U., Kupka, F., van't Veer-Menneret, C., et al. 2002, A&A, 392, 619 Hinkle, K., Wallace, L., Valenti, J., & Harmer, D. 2000, Visible and Near Infrared Atlas of the Arcturus Spectrum 3727–9300 Å (ISBN: 1-58381-037-4, 2000.) Kupka, F., Piskunov, N., Ryabchikova, T. A., Stempels, H. C., & Weiss, W. W. 1999, A&AS, 138, 119 Morel, P. & Lebreton, Y. 2007, Ap&SS, 460 Pepe, F., Mayor, M., Galland, F., et al. 2002, A&A, 388, 632 Prisinzano, L. & Randich, S. 2007, A&A, 475, 539 Siess, L., Dufour, E., & Forestini, M. 2000, A&A, 358, 593 Soderblom, D. R., Fedele, S. B., Jones, B. F., Stauffer, J. R., & Prosser, C. F. 1993, AJ, 106, 1080 Steinhauer, A. & Deliyannis, C. P. 2004, ApJ, 614, L65 Thorburn, J. A., Hobbs, L. M., Deliyannis, C. P., & Pinsonneault, M. H. 1993, ApJ, 415, 150 1 LAM, UMR 6110, CNRS/Univ. de Provence, 38, rue F. Joliot- Curie, 13388 Marseille, France 2 School of Physics A28, University of Sydney, Australia 3 OCA, CNRS UMR 6202, BP 4229, 06304 Nice Cedex 4, France 4 Wise Observatory, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel 5 Thuringer Landessternwarte, 07778 Tautenburg, Germany 6 School of Physics, Univ. of Exeter, Exeter EX4 4QL, UK 7 Instituto de Astrof´ısica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Spain 8 LESIA, CNRS UMR 8109, Obs. de Paris, 92195 Meudon, France 9 Physikalische Institut Univ. Bern, 3012 Bern, Switzerland 10 IAS, Universit´e Paris XI, 91405 Orsay, France 11 IAP, CNRS, Univ. Pierre & Marie Curie, Paris, France 12 Observat´orio Nacional, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil 13 IfA University of Vienna, 1180 Vienna, Austria 14 Institute of Planetary Research, DLR, 12489 Berlin, Germany 15 RSSD, ESA/ESTEC, 2200 Noordwijk, The Netherlands 16 Obs. de Gen`eve, Univ. de Gen`eve, 1290 Sauverny, Switzerland 17 IWF, Austrian Academy of Sciences, 8042 Graz, Austria 18 IAG, Universit´e de Li`ege, All´ee du 6 aout 17, Li`ege 1, Belgium 19 RIU, Universitat zu Koln, 50931 Koln, Germany 20 LUTH, Obs. de Paris, 5 place J. Janssen, 92195 Meudon, France 21 ZAA, Technical University Berlin, D-10623 Berlin, Germany C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b 5 C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b, Online Material p 1 Online Material C. Moutou et al.: CoRoT-Exo-4b, Online Material p 2 Fig. 5. Mass-period diagram of the 35 known transiting planets showing the location of CoRoT-Exo-4b (diamond). Table 2. Radial-velocity measurements of CoRoT-Exo-4 with SOPHIE (lines 1 to 7) and with HARPS (lines 8 to 20). "BIS" is the slope of the bisector span, measured in the cross-correlation function. BJD - 2400000 54405.6545 54408.6667 54410.6344 54413.6784 54416.6908 54494.3741 54507.3778 54423.8430 54424.8273 54428.8091 54442.7618 54443.7161 54445.7748 54447.7813 54448.7990 54449.7871 54450.7729 54481.6668 54482.6719 54486.6509 RV [km s−1] 32.370 32.278 32.258 32.343 32.294 32.259 32.320 32.352 32.344 32.234 32.381 32.361 32.270 32.239 32.268 32.272 32.373 32.287 32.287 32.290 Uncertainty [km s−1] 0.024 0.018 0.027 0.034 0.027 0.019 0.020 0.022 0.019 0.014 0.012 0.021 0.012 0.013 0.014 0.017 0.013 0.016 0.015 0.015 BIS [km s−1] −0.021 −0.004 −0.025 −0.113 −0.097 +0.020 +0.067 +0.020 +0.012 −0.017 +0.032 −0.050 −0.012 +0.015 −0.005 +0.002 −0.072 +0.040 +0.040 −0.002 err(BIS) [km s−1] 0.048 0.036 0.054 0.068 0.054 0.036 0.040 0.044 0.040 0.028 0.024 0.042 0.024 0.026 0.028 0.034 0.026 0.032 0.030 0.030
astro-ph/9812064	1	9812	1998-12-04T00:53:31	Transport and Acceleration of Energetic Charged Particles near an Oblique Shock	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have developed a numerical simulation code that treats the transport and acceleration of charged particles crossing an idealized oblique, non-relativistic shock within the framework of pitch angle transport using a finite-difference method. We consider two applications: 1) to study the steady-state acceleration of energetic particles at an oblique shock, and 2) to explain observed precursors of Forbush decreases of galactic cosmic rays before the arrival of an interplanetary shock induced by solar activity. For the former, we find that there is a jump in the particle intensity at the shock, which is stronger for more oblique shocks. Detailed pitch angle distributions are also presented. The simple model of a Forbush decrease explains the key features of observed precursors, an enhanced diurnal anisotropy extending several mean free paths upstream of the shock and a depletion of particles in a narrow loss cone at ~0.1 mean free path from the shock. Such precursors have practical applications for space weather prediction.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Transport and Acceleration of Energetic Charged Particles near an Oblique Shock Department of Physics, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330, Thailand D. Ruffolo ABSTRACT We have developed a numerical simulation code that treats the transport and accel- eration of charged particles crossing an idealized oblique, non-relativistic shock within the framework of pitch angle transport using a finite-difference method. We consider two applications: 1) to study the steady-state acceleration of energetic particles at an oblique shock, and 2) to explain observed precursors of Forbush decreases of galactic cosmic rays before the arrival of an interplanetary shock induced by solar activity. For the former, we find that there is a jump in the particle intensity at the shock, which is stronger for more oblique shocks. Detailed pitch angle distributions are also presented. The simple model of a Forbush decrease explains the key features of observed precur- sors, an enhanced diurnal anisotropy extending several mean free paths upstream of the shock and a depletion of particles in a narrow loss cone at ∼ 0.1 mean free path from the shock. Such precursors have practical applications for space weather prediction. Subject headings: acceleration of particles - shock waves - cosmic rays - solar- terrestrial relations 8 9 9 1 c e D 4 1 v 4 6 0 2 1 8 9 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1 1. Introduction An amazing variety of astrophysical phenomena can be attributed to magnetohydrodynamic shocks, and in particular to their ability to accelerate charged particles to high energies (Blandford & Eichler 1987). Shock acceleration is believed to account for the bulk of the galactic cosmic rays (Axford 1981) and solar cosmic rays (Lee & Ryan 1986) observed near the Earth. There is a variety of mechanisms by which shocks can accelerate particles, as indicated by di- rect observations within the solar system. Diffusive shock acceleration (Krymskii 1977, Axford, Leer, & Skadron 1977, Bell 1978), based on the first-order Fermi acceleration mechanism (Fermi 1954, Parker 1958), can accurately account for acceleration at the Earth's bow shock (Eichler 1981, Ellison, Mobius, & Paschmann 1990) and traveling interplanetary shocks (Lee 1983, Kennel et al. 1986), whereas stochastic ac- celeration, or second-order Fermi acceleration (Fermi 1949), is apparently the dominant mechanism in the vicinity of cometary bow shocks (Terasawa & Scholer 1989). Several lines of evidence indicate the distributed acceleration of energetic ions over a wide range of he- liolongitudes during gradual solar flare/coronal mass ejection (CME) events (Mason, Gloeckler, & Hoves- tadt 1984, Lee & Ryan 1986, Reames 1990, Ruffolo 1997), presumably due to CME-driven shocks, though it is not clear whether the first- or second-order Fermi mechanism is responsible for initial particle accelera- tion near the Sun. As CME shocks move outward from the Sun, they become traveling interplanetary shocks, and as such a shock passes a detector, in- tensity enhancements or anisotropy variations of en- ergetic particles are often recorded. Evidence that such intensity enhancements can represent true accel- eration, not mere pile-up, comes from major spectral changes (McKibben 1972, Reames et al. 1997). At en- ergies ∼< 1 MeV, there is clear evidence that particles can be accelerated out of the solar wind population (Gosling et al. 1981), presumably by diffusive shock acceleration. However, for energies > 10 MeV, all observations to date of ionic charge states near the times of interplanetary shock arrivals are inconsistent with a solar wind origin, indicating that the ions were originally accelerated out of coronal material (Boberg, Tylka, & Adams 1996). In addition, Tan et al. (1989) provided compositional evidence that ions of ∼ 1 MeV observed at the time of shock passage represent the same population as ambient solar energetic particles. The above evidence indicates that particles are in- jected into the interplanetary medium while the shock is still near the Sun, and later this particle popula- tion may be further affected by the shock as it propa- gates through the inner heliosphere. This leads one to the question of how an oblique shock (i.e., a shock in which the magnetic field is neither parallel nor per- pendicular to the shock normal) further accelerates existing populations of energetic charged particles. Note that close to an oblique shock, the diffusion approximation does not provide an accurate descrip- tion of the spatial or directional distribution of en- ergetic particles. The goal of the present work is to examine the spatial and pitch angle distribution that arises due to the transport and acceleration of an ex- isting particle population near an oblique shock. To the author's knowledge, this represents the first solu- tion of the pitch angle transport equation on both sides of an oblique, non-relativistic shock for non- ultrarelativistic particles. (For ultrarelativistic parti- cles at oblique shocks, for which one can set E ≈ pc, for parallel shocks and see Kirk & Heavens 1989; non-relativistic particles, see Kirk & Schneider 1989.) Therefore, we have started with the simplest case of an oblique shock with a constant magnetic field on either side in a medium with a spatially uniform scattering mean free path (Figure 1). It is hoped that this will lay the groundwork for further stud- ies of particle acceleration integrated into the frame- work of a pitch angle transport equation that will consider other effects for particular types of shocks; these could include a realistic magnetic field configu- ration, a spatially dependent scattering amplitude, a self-consistent treatment of wave generation and pitch angle scattering, or other effects. The basic process of charged particle acceleration by planar, parallel shocks has been worked out in the diffusion approximation (e.g., Krymskii 1977, Bland- ford & Ostriker 1978). Decker & Vlahos (1986) and Jokipii (1987) found that for oblique shocks the rate of particle acceleration increases with the shock an- gle, i.e., the angle between the magnetic field and the shock normal. In addition, there is a characteristic length over which the particle distribution increases upstream of the shock, given by D/u = vλk/(3u), where D is the coefficient of spatial diffusion (due to pitch angle scattering), u is the fluid speed rela- tive to the shock, v is the particle speed, and λk is the spatial mean free path along the magnetic field. 2 In the inner heliosphere, λk is typically 0.08 to 0.3 AU (Palmer 1982), and for u ∼ 0.002c and v = 0.1c (E = 94 MeV), this length scale is on the order of 17λk, or 1.4 to 5 AU. Thus a model with a constant diffusion coefficient does not explain the more local- ized increases observed as an interplanetary shock passes the Earth. One explanation is that the dif- fusion coefficient may decrease near a shock due to increased magnetic turbulence generated by acceler- ated particles (e.g., McKenzie & Westphal 1968, Lee 1983, Reames, Barbier, & Ng 1996). On the other hand, the large changes in particle anisotropies that are sometimes observed during shock passage (e.g., Evenson, Meyer, & Yanagita 1982, Heras et al. 1995) indicate a breakdown in the diffusion approximation, so a detailed treatment should also consider the pitch angle distribution. Recently, the EPAM instrument on the ACE spacecraft has been able to measure com- plex pitch angle distributions close to the time of shock passage (Armstrong & Holland 1998); mod- els of shock acceleration should attempt to reproduce such distributions. Furthermore, changes in the pitch angle distribution of relativistic ions (mainly galac- tic cosmic ray protons) as an interplanetary shock approaches, representing precursors to a Forbush de- crease accompanying the shock (Forbush 1938, Berry & Hess 1942, Forbush & Lange 1942) can be measured by ground-based neutron monitors and could provide advance warning of approaching shocks (Bieber & Evenson 1997), which can induce geomagnetic storms and affect satellites, communications, and power grids at Earth. Clearly the implementation of such a warn- ing system would rely on an accurate understanding of the pitch angle distribution of energetic ions up- stream of an interplanetary shock. Kirk & Schneider (1987a) presented an approx- imate analytic solution of a pitch angle transport equation for highly relativistic particles near a par- allel shock discontinuity (i.e., one in which the mag- netic field is parallel to the shock normal), giving insight into the variety of length scales correspond- ing to higher orders of anisotropy near the shock (the length scales also apply to non-relativistic par- ticles). This work was extended to oblique shocks by Kirk & Heavens (1989). Monte Carlo techniques have provided important information on the pitch angle distribution near the shock (Kirk & Schnei- der 1987b, Naito & Takahara 1995), the final spec- trum (Kirk & Schneider 1987b, Ballard & Heavens 1991, Lieu et al. 1994, Naito & Takahara 1995), 3 the rate of particle acceleration vs. the magnetic field-shock angle (Decker & Vlahos 1986, Lieu et al. 1994, Naito & Takahara 1995), the injection of parti- cles from a thermal population and its decreased effi- ciency for larger magnetic field-shock angles (Baring, Ellison, & Jones 1993), compositional selection effects (Ellison, Jones, & Eichler 1981), and the relative im- portance of first- and second-order Fermi acceleration at shocks (Krulls & Achterberg 1994). Here we adopt a different approach by incorpo- rating the treatment of an oblique shock disconti- nuity into a finite-difference numerical solution of a pitch angle transport equation. Previously, numeri- cal techniques have been developed to treat the pitch angle dependent transport of energetic particles in the inner heliosphere (Ng & Wong 1979, Schluter 1985, Earl 1987, Ruffolo 1991, Pauls & Burger 1994), recently including the effects of adiabatic decelera- tion and convection (Ruffolo 1995, Hatzky 1996, Lario 1997, Kocharov et al. 1998), and these have been used to analyze observations of solar energetic par- ticles (Bieber et al. 1980, Bieber, Evenson, & Pomer- antz 1986, Droge, Wibberenz, & Klecker 1990, Kallen- rode, Wibberenz, & Hucke 1992, Ruffolo, Khum- lumlert, & Youngdee 1998) and solar neutron decay particles (Ruffolo 1991, Droge, Ruffolo, & Klecker 1996). Including the injection of particles from other sources, such as a traveling interplanetary shock, has proven more difficult. Previous authors have set the simulation boundary at the shock and as- sumed an ad hoc particle injection function, say, Q, finding the function that best fits the observed data for a given event and energy range (Heras et al. 1995, Lario 1997, Kallenrode & Wibberenz 1997; Kallenrode 1997a, b). In principle this allows one to examine the dependence of Q on physical parameters of the shock, though there are a number of such inter- related parameters, which complicates the interpreta- tion of the association between Q and any individual parameter. Our approach is in a sense the reverse: we examine what parameter dependence should be ex- pected based on certain physical processes. Since dif- fusive shock acceleration is a manifestation of particle transport in the vicinity of the shock, we include both sides of the shock discontinuity in the calculation, with special treatment of particles crossing the shock based on the conservation of the magnetic moment, to examine both the transport and further accelera- tion of energetic charged particles near the shock. We are able to examine the effects of the shock-field an- gle and the form of the pitch angle scattering on the steady-state particle distribution in space and pitch angle for an idealized model of an oblique shock. As a further application of our method, we apply it to explain the observed precursors of Forbush decreases before the arrival of an interplanetary shock. 2. Methodology 2.1. Overview Before describing the methodology in detail, we present a brief overview of shock acceleration. The process of "diffusive shock acceleration" refers to the acceleration of charged particles as they are repeat- edly scattered back and forth across a shock front, which for the present purposes is a discontinuity in the fluid speed and magnetic field strength. This pro- cess does not require the diffusion approximation and can be examined by lower-level descriptions in terms of pitch angle scattering (Kirk & Schneider 1987a) or particle orbits in a disordered magnetic field (Decker & Vlahos 1985). Originally the literature discussed two mechanisms of acceleration at shocks: 1. In the first-order Fermi acceleration mechanism (Fermi 1954, Parker 1958), particles gain energy when scattering off of converging magnetic field irregulari- ties. At a shock, this occurs because the field irregu- larities are convected with the fluid flow (in the r´egime in which the Alfv´en speed is smaller than the fluid speed relative to the shock), and the upstream fluid flows toward the shock faster than the downstream fluid flows away. In this r´egime, scattering tends to isotropize the momentum while preserving its magni- tude in the local fluid frame. When a particle heads toward the shock (in the local fluid frame) in either direction, the frame transformation leads to a higher momentum in the new local fluid frame, which is con- served until the particle encounters the shock again. After two such crossings of the shock, the particle has a higher momentum in its original reference frame. 2. In the shock drift mechanism (Schatzman 1963), particles drift along an oblique shock front due to the sharp gradient in the magnetic field, and this drift is along the direction of the electric field so that parti- cles can gain a substantial amount of energy in one encounter with the shock. More recently, it has been shown that the distinc- tion between these two mechanisms vanishes in the de Hoffmann-Teller (shock) frame (de Hoffmann & Teller 1950) where the electric field is zero. The en- tire energy change due to mechanisms 1 and 2 is ac- counted for by transforming the particle momentum from the local fluid frame into the shock frame, con- sidering the energy-conserving shock encounter in the shock frame, and then transforming the momentum into the new local fluid frame (Decker 1983). [Note, however, that there is still a lateral drift along the shock, which is important, e.g., for the acceleration of anomalous cosmic rays at the solar wind termi- nation shock (Pesses, Eichler, & Jokipii 1981, Cum- mings, Stone, & Webber 1985).] For an oblique shock, the term diffusive shock acceleration is now generally used to refer to this unified description of particle ac- celeration that includes both mechanisms 1 and 2. The basic mechanism of particle acceleration at an oblique shock, as described above, includes two processes: a) frame transformations, as in first-order Fermi acceleration, and b) a change in pitch angle as the particle encounters the shock (which does not occur for a parallel shock). Processes a) and b) are related to parallel and perpendicular changes in the fluid velocity, respectively. Thus they are directly analogous to the two components of adiabatic de- celeration in the solar wind (e.g., Webb & Gleeson 1979, Ruffolo 1995), which are associated with the di- vergence of the wind parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field and have been termed "an in- verse Fermi effect" and "betatron deceleration," re- spectively. Just as betatron deceleration is an effect of adiabatic focusing (also known as magnetic mir- roring) when viewed in the local fluid frame (Ruffolo 1995), which in turn represents the conservation of the magnetic moment p2 ⊥/(2meB), for the case of shock acceleration the change in pitch angle as particles en- counter the shock approximately conserves the mag- netic moment as well (see §2.5). If we assume that the magnetic moment is actually conserved, then we do not need to concern ourselves with the details of the particle orbit near the shock; we treat the en- tire particle-shock interaction as a single event, and consider whether a particle ultimately crosses or is reflected by the shock, which is assumed to depend only on the initial pitch angle. Figure 2 provides a schematic illustration (for a non-relativistic particle) of acceleration at an oblique shock. [For an analogous illustration for adiabatic de- celeration, see Figure 1 of Ruffolo (1995).] The com- ponents of the particle velocity, vk and v⊥, refer to 4 motion parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field, respectively (the pitch angle is the angle with respect to the positive vk axis). Let us take the up- stream direction to be to the right; then the upstream and downstream flow speeds with respect to the shock frame are negative ("U" and "D," respectively, in Fig- ure 2). A particle with vk < 0 is moving from the up- stream side toward the downstream side. The veloc- ity relative to point "D" is greater than that relative to point "U," so if the particle crosses to the down- stream side, the magnitude of its velocity is greater in the new local fluid frame, and this velocity magni- tude is conserved by further scattering in that frame. Similarly, a particle with vk > 0 can cross from down- stream to upstream, and again the magnitude of the velocity increases in the new local fluid frame. A third type of shock encounter (for oblique shocks) is when a particle from upstream (vk < 0) reflects back up- stream with vk → −vk in the shock frame; again, we see that the magnitude of the velocity increases in the fluid frame. static, so the particle speed in this frame, qv2 In addition to the frame transformations described above, i.e., standard first-order Fermi acceleration for parallel shocks, at oblique shocks there is the addi- tional process of a change in pitch angle as a particle crosses the shock. At first glance it is not immedi- ately obvious why this process should lead to acceler- ation as opposed to deceleration. To see this, consider again a particle with vk < 0 crossing the shock from upstream to downstream (Figure 2). In the shock frame the large-scale magnetic field configuration is k + v2 ⊥, is conserved. If we assume approximate conservation of the magnetic moment, then v⊥ will increase, since the magnetic field is stronger on the downstream side. As can be seen in Figure 2, the speed relative to the downstream fluid ("D") increases; the dotted line in- dicates a curve of constant speed in the downstream fluid frame. Thus this process leads to an additional increase in energy in the new local fluid frame, be- yond that due to the frame transformation. Similarly, a particle with vk > 0 is moving from downstream to upstream, and approximate conservation of the mag- netic moment implies a decrease in v⊥. Then the speed relative to the upstream fluid ("U") increases; the dashed line indicates a curve of constant speed in the upstream fluid frame. The change in pitch angle can be quite large, so this can lead to a substantial in- crease in the energy gain at oblique shocks. There can also be a significant effect on the pitch angle distribu- tion, which makes particle transport and acceleration at oblique shocks more difficult to model than that at parallel shocks. 2.2. Transport Equation To our knowledge, this work represents the first treatment of oblique shock acceleration within a finite difference simulation of pitch angle transport, so as a first step this work considers only a simple, planar, oblique shock with straight magnetic field lines on either side (Figure 1). We consider only subluminal shocks so that we can work in the de Hoffmann-Teller reference frame (which we also refer to as the "shock frame") in which the shock is stationary, the fluid flow is parallel to the magnetic field, and the electric field is zero (de Hoffmann & Teller 1950). Ruffolo (1995) provided an equation of focused pitch angle transport (eq. [11] of that paper) that included solar wind effects, such as adiabatic decel- eration and convection, to first order in u/c in an Archimedean spiral magnetic field. When we consider a region of constant magnetic field on either side of the shock, that equation reduces to ∂F (t, µ, z, p) ∂t = − µvF (t, µ, z, p) ∂ ∂z ∂ − + ∂z (cid:18)1 − µ2 v2 c2(cid:19) uF (t, µ, z, p) ∂µ (cid:16)1 − µ ∂ ϕ(µ) ∂ ∂µ · F (t, µ, z, p), 2 uv c2 (cid:17) (1) where F ≡ d3N/(dzdµdp) is the density of particles in a given magnetic flux tube, is the time in the shock frame, t µ is the pitch angle cosine in the wind z p frame, is the distance from the shock along the magnetic field in the shock frame, is the particle momentum in the wind frame, is the particle velocity in the wind frame, is the solar wind speed along the magnetic field in the shock frame, and ϕ is the pitch angle scattering coefficient. v u In equation (1), the first term on the right hand side represents the effect of streaming, the second is for convection (including the relativistic correction 5 for transforming the streaming speed into the shock frame), and the third is for pitch angle scattering. The particle density in a flux tube, F , is related to the phase space density, f , by F = 2πap2f , where a(z) ∝ 1/B(z) is the cross-sectional area of the flux tube. We use F in the simulations, following Ng and Wong (1979), because we can easily design the nu- merical finite difference method to strictly conserve this quantity during streaming and convection, even when a(z) and B(z) are spatially varying. The pitch angle scattering coefficient, ϕ(µ), is expressed as ϕ(µ) = Aµq−1(1 − µ2) (2) where A is the scattering amplitude and q controls the form of the scattering coefficient. This expression, originally derived in the context of quasi-linear theory (Jokipii 1971), is adopted as a convenient and widely used parameterization. In this work we will consider q = 1, for isotropic scattering, and q = 1.5, which is in the range of 1.3 to 1.7 inferred by Bieber et al. (1986) for interplanetary scattering. Roughly speaking, q > 1 implies a deficit in scattering near a pitch angle of 90◦ (µ = 0); the effect of such a deficit on shock acceleration has also been examined by Kirk (1988). 2.3. Eigenfunction Expansion In addition to our numerical solution of equa- tion (1) (see §2.6), it is possible to find analytic solu- tions in the steady state if we restrict the z domain to one side of the shock. Setting ∂F/∂t = 0, we have ∂F ∂z = A 2[µv(1 − µuv/c2) + u] (1 − µ2)µq−1 ∂ ∂ · ∂µ ∂µ (cid:16)1 − µ uv c2 (cid:17) F. (3) Note that F is defined in a mixed frame, i.e., for µ and p defined in the solar wind frame and z and t in the shock frame. To first order in u/c, the analo- gous quantity defined in terms of variables in the solar wind frame is given by Fw = (1 − µuv/c2)F (Webb & Gleeson 1979), so we can simplify equation (3) to read ∂Fw ∂z = A 2[µv + u] ∂ ∂µ (1 − µ2)µq−1 ∂Fw ∂µ , (4) where α ≡ 2kv/A is an eigenvalue of the equation. To avoid divergence as z → ±∞, we must have k ≤ 0 (≥ 0) for z > 0 (< 0). Following Kirk & Schnei- der (1987a), who treated the case of q = 1, M (µ) can be expanded in terms of normalized Legendre polyno- mials. For q and u/v values of interest, we truncated the expansion to n terms and evaluated eigenvalues and eigenfunctions using the Mathematica software package (Wolfram Research, Inc.). For q = 1, n = 12 was sufficient to obtain eigenvalues with a relative ac- curacy of 10−5. For q = 1.5, obtaining an accuracy of about 2% for the first positive eigenvalue required n ≈ 80; for other eigenvalues fewer terms were re- quired. The eigenvalues α closest to zero (corresponding to long spatial scales) are shown in Figure 3 for q = 1 and 1.5 and a range of u/v values. For u/v = 0, the numerical values of α are 0, ±14.53, ±42.05, ±83.30, ±138.3, . . . for q = 1 and 0, ±11.3, ±33.0, ±65.6, ±109, . . . for q = 1.5. For a given q the relative mag- nitudes of these eigenvalues are similar, but not iden- tical, to those of the Legendre polynomials, ℓ(ℓ+1) for ℓ = 0, 1, 2, . . .. The eigenvalues shown in Figure 3 for q = 1.5 are about 20% lower in magnitude than those for q = 1, with the exception that α1 is lower by a fac- tor of about 2.4. Aside from α1, the eigenvalues shown here are approximately given by αi = α0 i (1 ± βu/v), where α0 is the value for u/v = 0, "±" follows the i sign of α0 i , and β is a constant between 2.2 and 2.4. Sample normalized eigenfunctions for these eigenval- ues are shown in Figure 4 for q = 1 and u/v = −0.075, with particles traveling away from the shock for µ < 0 downstream and µ > 0 upstream; each eigenfunction M (µ) is plotted with the sign for which hMi > 0. In cases considered in this paper, uv/c2 ≪ 1, so Fw ≈ F and M essentially gives the angular dependence of F . For u/v > 0, there is a zero eigenvalue, α0, with a corresponding constant eigenfunction, and a first pos- itive eigenvalue, α1, which tends to zero as u/v → 0. For q = 1, α1 ≈ 6u/v (with slight deviations for higher u/v), implying that k ≈ 3uA/v2. Note that in the diffusion approximation, the spatial diffusion co- efficient is given by the classic formula (Jokipii 1966, 1968, Hasselmann & Wibberenz 1968), again neglecting terms of order (u/c)2. For a given p, this can be solved by separation of variables, Fw(µ, z) = M (µ)Z(z), yielding Z ∝ ekz and v(cid:17) M = 0, (1 − µ2)µq−1 ∂M ∂µ − α(cid:16)µ + ∂ ∂µ u (5) D = v2 2 Z 1 0 (1 − µ2)2 ϕ(µ) dµ, (6) and for the form of ϕ(µ) specified in equation (2), we 6 have the well-known expression D = v2 A 1 (2 − q)(4 − q) . (7) For q = 1 we have D = v2/(3A), and the approx- imate z-dependence corresponding to the first pos- itive eigenvalue is Z ∝ euz/D; such a dependence is also found for the case of q = 1.5. Note that this solu- tion only applies to the region where uz < 0, i.e., the upstream region. In general, solutions correspond- ing to positive (negative) α are valid in the upstream (downstream) region, and the constant eigenfunction corresponding to α0 = 0 is valid in either region. The complete solution for F in the steady state on either side of the shock is a linear combination of the separable solutions. Therefore, the solution far upstream of the shock is a superposition of a constant and the above solution proportional to euz/D. Since α−1 ≫ α1, the only valid solution far downstream of the shock is a constant. Such spatial behavior of F at long distances from the shock is in accordance with standard results based on the diffusion approximation (e.g., Krymskii 1977; see also §2.5), though there are slight deviations at higher u/v (for q = 1, α1 > 6u/v by ≈2% at u/v = 0.1). At shorter distances there may be contributions from solutions corresponding to other eigenvalues. In terms of the particle mean free path, λ = 3D v = v A 3 (2 − q)(4 − q) such solutions decay over a distance scale of 1 k = 2 α v A = 2(2 − q)(4 − q) 3α λ. (9) (The symbol λ refers to the mean free path parallel to the magnetic field, λk, unless otherwise specified.) For q = 1 and u/v = 0.02, deviations from the solu- tion given by the standard diffusive approximation are expected upstream within 1/k = 0.13λ of the shock (corresponding to α2) and downstream within 0.14λ (corresponding to α−1); for q = 1.5 those distance scales become 0.07λ and 0.08λ, respectively. Note that this analysis alone cannot give the rel- ative amplitudes of different solutions; for that, one must consider how particles cross the shock. Kirk & Schneider (1987a) presented eigenvalues and eigen- functions of equation (5) for the case of q = 1, and for the case of ultrarelativistic particle energies (E ≈ pc) and a parallel shock, were also able to match 7 the upstream and downstream solutions and analyti- cally evaluate the steady-state distribution function, as well as the power-law index of the resulting spec- trum. The analogous calculation for oblique shocks was performed by Kirk & Heavens (1989). For par- allel shocks, Kirk & Schneider (1989) relaxed the as- sumption of ultrarelativistic particle velocities in cal- culating the steady-state particle distribution as a function of position, pitch angle, and momentum. In this work, we treat the crossing of moderately rela- tivistic particles across an oblique shock in numerical (finite difference) solutions of the pitch angle trans- port equation, and we also compare our steady-state numerical results with pitch angle distributions and spatial decay constants, k, that are expected based on the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues of equation (5), re- spectively. In summary, the results for steady-state shock ac- celeration can be expressed in terms of a superposi- tion of separable solutions of equation (3). A numer- ical solution of equation (1), in our case by a finite difference method, is required in order to determine the relative amplitudes of the separable solutions. We stress that the numerical method does not explicitly involve the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions, so we can test the numerical code by verifying that the results are consistent with a linear combination of separable solutions. Based on equations (133)-(135) and (124) of de Hoffmann & Teller (1950), the jump conditions of a non-relativistic shock in the de Hoffmann-Teller frame are (cid:20)un + 3 5 u2 s un (cid:20)(cid:18)un − (cid:20) 3 2 u2 s + 1 2 u2 An + u2 Ant2 u2 2un (cid:21) = 0 un (cid:19) t(cid:21) = 0 n(1 + t2)(cid:21) = 0 √un(cid:21) = 0, (cid:20) uAn (10) where a bracketed quantity refers to the difference be- tween that quantity on either side of the shock, us = p(5/3)(p/ρ) is the speed of sound, uAn ≡ Bn/√4πρ is the Alfv´en speed corresponding to Bn (hence the Alfv´en speed is uA = uAz sec θ), and t = tan θ, where θ is the angle between the magnetic field and the , (8) 2.4. Fluid and Magnetic Field Parameters shock normal. In the above, we used the conser- vation of mass flux and assumed an ideal gas with an adiabatic index of 5/3. Analogous conditions for relativistic shocks were derived by Heavens & Drury (1988). Equations (10) relate un, us, uA, and t upstream and downstream of the shock, so given any four of those variables the remaining four can be deter- mined. We use the subscript 1 (2) to refer to up- stream (downstream) variables. Solutions were ob- tained for us1 = uA1 = 50 km s−1, typical of near- Earth interplanetary space, and selected values of t1 and u1n − u2n. Note that in the high speed limit u1n/u2n → 4, i.e., (γ + 1)/(γ − 1) for an adiabatic index γ = 5/3. In this limit, the magnetic field ten- sion becomes negligible, and the tangential compo- nent of the velocity, unt, is nearly conserved, so we have t2/t1 → 4 as well. 1)/(1 + t2 The only fluid parameters that directly affect the particle transport are the fluid speed upstream and downstream and the magnetic compression ratio, B2/B1. Since the normal component of ~B is conserved, we have B2/B1 = sec θ2/ sec θ1. Figure 5 shows the shock compression ratio, u1n/u2n, and the magnetic compression ratio, B2/B1, as a function of ∆un = u1n − u2n for selected values of t1 = tan θ1. Since t2/t1 → 4 in the limit of high Mach numbers, the asymptotic value of the magnetic compression ratio is p(1 + 16t2 1), which is less than 4. To ex- amine the effect of B2/B1 on cosmic ray transport and acceleration near the shock, we perform simula- tions for u1n − u2n = 400 km s−1 and t1 = 0, 1, and 4, corresponding to upstream shock angles of 0◦, 45◦, and 76◦ and downstream shock angles of 0◦, 76◦, and 86◦, respectively. Complete fluid and magnetic field parameters for these configurations are given in Ta- ble 1. We do not consider t > 4 because we expect that our model would be inaccurate for nearly per- pendicular shocks in that it neglects particle diffusion perpendicular to the magnetic field, which is impor- tant for highly oblique shocks (e.g., Jones, Jokipii, & Baring 1998). 2.5. Boundary Conditions Next we consider changes in the momentum and pitch angle as a charged particle encounters the shock, i.e., a sudden change in the magnetic field and fluid speed. Following Decker (1983), we assume that in the shock frame both the particle momentum and the 8 first adiabatic invariant, i.e., the magnetic moment p2 ⊥/(2meB), are conserved. The above assumption is tantamount to considering the adiabatic limit, in which the shock is a region where the pitch angle changes gradually. The opposite limit would consider an infinitely thin shock front, and in this case the pitch angle distribution can only be determined by computing particle orbits. For highly oblique shocks (θ ∼> 80◦), there is essentially no difference between the resulting pitch angle distributions in the two lim- its (Terasawa 1979). Therefore, the approximation we are using should be reliable for highly oblique shocks, and at least represents a well-defined limit for less oblique shocks. The original simulation code of Ruffolo (1995) is capable of treating multiple values of the momen- tum in order to examine the particle distribution as a function of the momentum. However, for simplicity we have only treated one value of the momentum in this work, and have assumed that the dependence of F (t, µ, z, p) on p is given by a power law, F ∝ p−γ. When particles are accelerated during an encounter with the shock, we consider them to be advected from a lower value of the momentum to the momentum of interest. Therefore, we should evaluate the accuracy of the assumption that F has the same dependence on µ and z at the lower values of p from which parti- cles are advected. For non-relativistic particles with u < v, the largest fractional momentum change that can be achieved (that for reflection back upstream) is < 2u1/v (see Figure 2). In Figure 3 we see that the dependence of the eigenvalues α on u/v is linear or weaker for u/v values of interest. As will be described in §3.1, we do in fact see a systematic error in some results that increases with u1/v. For ultrarelativis- tic particle speeds (e.g., Kirk & Schneider 1987a) the assumption of a power-law dependence in the steady state is not a problem because v ≈ c so that u/v does not vary with momentum. Now we turn to the boundary conditions at the edges of the simulation region. At a reasonable distance from the shock front, we can employ the diffusion approximation, in which equation (1) can be expressed as a diffusion-convection equation. In the manner of Earl (1974), we set F (t, p, µ, z) ≈ F0(t, p, z) + F1(p, µ, z), where F0 ≡ hFiµ, F1 is an odd function of µ, and higher-order even functions are neglected. By separating the transport equation into odd and even parts, integrating each over µ, and neglecting the time dependence of F1 (i.e., assuming ∂F1/∂t ≪ v∂F0/∂z), we obtain ∂Sz ∂z ∂F0 ∂t = − , where Sz = uF0 − D ∂F0 ∂z (11) (12) is the z-flux and the spatial diffusion coefficient, D, is given by equation (6). Equation (11) should be obeyed on either side of the shock, with special jump conditions at the shock as described above. Note that either F or the phase space density, f , may be used in these equations and in the following discussion. We note further that in terms of F1(p, µ, z), we have Sz = u(cid:18)1 − 1 3 v2c2(cid:19) F0 + v 2 Z 1 −1 µF1dµ, (13) and if F1 = δµ, so that δ is the dipole anisotropy in the mixed frame, we obtain Sz = uF0 + v 3 (cid:16)δ − uv c2 (cid:17) F0, (14) where δ − uv/c2 represents the dipole anisotropy of Fw, the distribution function defined entirely in terms of independent variables in the solar wind frame. In the diffusion approximation solution of Krym- skii (1977), there are boundary conditions that F re- main finite as z → ±∞. In the steady state, equa- tion (11) requires that Sz be constant on either side of the shock, so we have F0 = A + B exp(cid:16) u D z(cid:17) (15) with different constants A and B upstream or down- stream. To avoid divergence far downstream, we must have B = 0, so F0 is constant, with Sz = uF0. Up- stream, we have Sz = uFu, where Fu is F0 far up- stream of the shock, representing the existing particle population that is accelerated by the shock. In the numerical solution of equation (1) in terms of z we can only treat a finite domain. However, the diffusion approximation is valid sufficiently far from the shock (see §2.3), with ∂Sz/∂z = 0, so setting Sz at the boundaries of the simulation region is approx- imately equivalent to fixing its value at ±∞. At the upstream boundary, we set Sz to a constant (for a given p) that is interpreted as uFu. At the down- stream boundary, Sz is set to uhFiµ at the boundary. 9 In the diffusion approximation (eq. [12]), this implies that ∂F0/∂z = 0, and also that the anisotropy is given by δ = uv/c2; the distribution function in the wind frame is Fw = (1 − µuv/c2)F and thus has a dipole anisotropy of zero. 2.6. Numerical Method The numerical simulations reported here employed the finite difference method of Ruffolo (1995) as sub- stantially modified by Nutaro, Riyavong, & Ruffolo (in preparation). The latter report will contain de- tails of the modifications and testing of the new code. Here, for completeness, we briefly outline the changes to the treatment of streaming and convection, and the treatment of particles crossing the shock. For a de- scription of other aspects of the numerical method which remain unchanged, the reader is referred to Ruffolo (1995). Changes to the treatment of streaming and con- vection were motivated by the work of Hatzky (1996), who used the total variation diminishing (TVD) tech- nique (Sweby 1984). While our previous numerical method (Ruffolo 1991, 1995) eliminated spatial dif- ferencing and hence numerical diffusion in the eval- uation of these terms, it required a small step size, ∆z = ∆µv∆t. On the other hand, the TVD algo- rithm permits only a very small amount of numerical diffusion for significantly larger ∆z. The result is that the new code runs 1 to 2 orders of magnitude faster. Another benefit is that convection is now treated in each step instead of by occasional jumps as in our pre- vious method, yielding much smoother profiles with- out spatial averaging. The previous method was ad- equate for the transport of solar energetic particles, where one could average over a moderate spatial in- terval, and the jumps merely yielded small-amplitude oscillations in the intensity as a function of time. However, for the present simulations of steady-state shock acceleration, with multiple reflections from the boundaries and a requirement of fine spatial resolu- tion, the new treatment of streaming and convection was essential in obtaining the smooth profiles shown here. The results for steady-state particle acceleration at a parallel shock provide a sensitive test confirming the accurate treatment of streaming and convection. In our implementation, we modified the standard TVD algorithm in order to permit a Courant number, γ = vz∆t/∆z, greater than one. This permits an ar- bitrary ∆z, and in particular, for ∆z = ∆µ v∆t we were able to reproduce results for solar energetic par- ticles that used our previous code (Ruffolo & Khum- lumlert 1995). The other modification of the code was to treat how particles cross the shock, which was also part of the streaming/convection step. For each µ-z grid point, we determine whether particles will stream/convect as far as the shock. If so, we perform a Lorentz transformation into the shock frame, allow particles to cross or reflect while conserving the magnetic mo- ment, and perform another Lorentz transformation back into the local wind frame (see §2.1). The TVD algorithm effectively splits a cell into fractions of par- ticles destined to move to two different spatial loca- tions; at the shock we generalize this approach to split cells into fractions destined to move to different µ-cells as well. The accuracy of this technique is verified by the numerical results for steady-state shock acceler- ation at oblique shocks, which are consistent with a sum of separable solutions of the transport equation (§2.3) on either side of the shock. 3. Results 3.1. Steady-State Shock Acceleration In a steady state, an equilibrium is reached in the evolution of the particle distribution function in terms of position, pitch angle, and momentum. In the present simulations, we assume that the momen- tum dependence is given by F ∝ p−γ, so we find the value of γ that yields a steady solution for F in terms of z and µ. Figure 6 indicates the flux balance that determines γ. Well away from the shock, we can use the diffusion approximation (see §2.5) to say that the net z-flux far downstream is due to convection: Sz = u2F0, where F0 = hFiµ. Far upstream, there is a balance between convection toward the shock and diffusion away, so that Sz = u1Fu, where Fu is the far upstream flux. Here we set Fu = 0, so there is a net outflow of particles from the shock in the downstream direction. This is balanced by the p-flux, Sp, rep- resenting acceleration at the shock of particles from lower momenta to the momentum of interest, as well as from the momentum of interest to higher momenta, for the appropriate steady-state power-law index, γ. Before considering oblique shocks, we tested our methodology for the case of a parallel shock (θ1 = θ2 = 0). Fluid and magnetic field parameters were as listed in Table 1. We considered protons with speeds v = 0.5 and 0.1c, corresponding to kinetic 10 energies of 145 and 4.7 MeV and momenta of 541.7 and 94.3 MeV c−1, respectively. We used grid spac- ings of ∆z/λ = 0.025 and 0.005, respectively, and ∆µ = 2/95. For convenience, we set v∆t = ∆z. Outer boundaries were placed at ±2.5λ and ±0.5λ for v = 0.5c and 0.1c, respectively. The numerical treat- ment of the boundary conditions assumed Fu = 0 and was sufficiently accurate that the proper behavior of F in the diffusion approximation was maintained out to within a few grid points from the boundaries, and the location of the boundaries did not influence F near the shock. A full simulation required about 2 hours of CPU time on a Sun Ultra-1 workstation. Figure 7 (top panel) shows the spatial dependence of the pitch angle averaged phase space distribution, hfiµ, near a parallel shock for v = 0.5c and q = 1 (z > 0 is the upstream region). As explained in §2.2, our simulations solve for F = d3N/(dzdµdp), the density of particles in a flux tube, which is related to f by F = 2πap2f , where a is the cross-sectional area of a flux tube; therefore, f ∝ BF . For a parallel shock, B is equal on the upstream and downstream side, so f ∝ F . Throughout this section, f is normalized to 1 far downstream. From Figure 7 we see that for a parallel shock, the spatial dependence of hfiµ is simply that expected in the diffusion approximation (§2.5), i.e., constant downstream and exponentially decaying to zero upstream with k = u/D. The pitch angle dependence was also the same as in the diffusion approximation. The same results were obtained for q = 1.5 and for v = 0.1c with q = 1 and 1.5. For a coarser µ-grid spacing, a spurious peak was obtained in hfiµ, which tends toward zero as ∆µ → 0 (a remnant of this is barely visible in the top panel of Figure 7). Even for a fine grid spacing, one anomaly is that a value of γ = 2.020 was needed for a steady state (i.e., to conserve the flux of particles in the sim- ulation region) for v/c = 0.5 or 0.1 and q = 1 or 1.5, whereas acceleration theory for parallel shocks (e.g., Krymskii 1977) yields γ = 3u2/(u1 − u2) + 1 or 2.034 for these fluid parameters. The assumptions of that theory should apply given that f (µ, z) is that ex- pected from the diffusion approximation. We believe that the systematic error in γ obtained from the sim- ulations arises from the assumption of a power-law dependence of F on p, which neglects the momen- tum dependence of F (µ, z) (see §2.5). The key prob- lem is that the upstream anisotropy of F depends on u1/v. As a test, the code was modified to artificially add an "extra" anisotropy for lower momenta, i.e., to multiply F upon acceleration by a µ-dependent fac- tor to account for the higher anisotropy of F at the lower momentum from which a particle was acceler- ated, yielding a similar F (µ, z) and γ = 2.041. We conclude that this explanation can in fact account for a systematic error in γ of the observed magnitude, and that γ is more sensitive to the assumption of a power-law dependence than is the distribution of par- ticles in space or pitch angle. Turning to oblique shocks, Figure 7 shows the spa- tial dependence of hfiµ for tan θ1 = 1 and 4 and for q = 1 and 1.5. In all cases, the distribution function farther from the shock is consistent with the diffusion approximation, with hFiµ constant downstream and exponentially decaying upstream with k = u/D. A conspicuous feature of Figure 7 is the jump (discon- tinuity) in hfiµ at an oblique shock (the finite slope is due to the finite grid spacing in z). This feature was also found in simulations by Ostrowski (1991), Gieseler et al. (1998), and T. Naito (private commu- nication, 1998). Gieseler et al. (1998) present a de- tailed theoretical and computational analysis of this feature, as well as possible observational signatures. We find that the jump is stronger for more oblique shocks, and weaker for q = 1.5 than for q = 1. The amplitude of the jump is on the order of a few percent for such fast particles (v = 0.5c), and our simulations indicate that the jump is stronger for slower particles (v = 0.1c), i.e., a higher u/v. Another difference from the case of a parallel shock is that for oblique shocks, additional eigenfunctions are excited in f (µ, z) near the shock. (If one is not suf- ficiently careful in treating the boundary conditions, as I was not during the initial stages of this work, additional eigenfunctions are also excited near the boundaries; discretization errors also yield spurious eigenfunctions near the shock, which become negligi- ble for 95 µ-grid points as used here.) For all steady- state simulations, f (µ, z) was consistent with a sum of separable solutions of equation (3). For tan θ1 = 4 (θ1 = 75◦), Figure 8 shows the dependence of f on µ and z within ±0.8λ of the shock, and Figure 9 shows f as a function of µ for z = ±0.05λ. (Recall that we use µ and p to refer to quantities in the local fluid frame; thus these plots are for a constant value of the local p. A Compton-Getting transformation to the shock frame would have no noticeable effect on our distribution plots.) For tan θ1 = 1, the results were qualitatively similar but with weaker anisotropies. In Figure 9, we see that upstream distributions 11 (thick lines) increase with µ up to µ ≈ 0.7 (with a slightly stronger anisotropy than in the far upstream region), and for greater µ values, f drops sharply. The reason for the sharp drop is that given our as- sumption of conservation of the magnetic moment, particles with µ > p1 − B1/B2, or 0.85 in this case, have come from downstream. A similar drop in f has been called a "deficit cone" (Nagashima et al. 1992) or "loss cone" effect (Bieber & Evenson 1997) for the case of galactic cosmic ray (GCR) depletion at high µ upstream of an interplanetary shock, which is due to the paucity of GCR coming from down- stream (see §3.2). The same effect occurs here be- cause the acceleration of particles coming from down- stream is weaker than for particles reflected from up- stream. The greatest acceleration occurs for parti- cles reflected with the greatest change in pitch angle (see Figure 2), i.e., for µ slightly below 0.85. Since stronger acceleration implies that f is advected from lower momenta, and the particle spectrum increases with decreasing momentum in this case, the strongest acceleration corresponds to the greatest increase in f . In the downstream region, particles are redistributed in pitch angle because of changes in pitch angle as particles cross the shock; the average flux also in- creases slightly due to acceleration. It is worth not- ing that for a highly oblique shock, most particles coming from upstream are in fact reflected, i.e., when µ < p1 − B1/B2, or in the case of a strong, highly oblique shock, for pitch angles more than 30◦ from the magnetic field direction. Another feature of Figures 8 and 9 is the sharp gradient in f at µ = 0 for the case of q = 1.5. For this form of the pitch angle diffu- sion coefficient, ϕ(µ) = Aµ0.5(1 − µ2) tends to zero as µ → 0. Since the µ-flux, Sµ = −(ϕ/2)(∂F/∂µ), is slowly varying in a near-equilibrium situation, the vanishing diffusion coefficient at µ = 0 is able to sus- tain an infinite gradient in F at that value. We believe that this behavior of f as a function of z and µ is not an artifact of the assumption of a power-law momentum dependence because when an extra anisotropy was artificially added, the µ and z dependence (including the jump at z = 0) was not significantly affected; this was also the case for paral- lel shocks. On the other hand, computed values of γ are strongly affected by the power-law assumption, so that this code in its present form is essentially unable to determine γ. The error in γ was much weaker for v/c = 0.5 than for v/c = 0.1 (because of the lower u1/v ratio). As an example, for q = 1 the γ values required for a steady state with v = 0.5c were 1.965 and 1.952 for tan θ1 = 1 and 4, respectively, while with v = 0.1c they were 1.985 and 1.787, respectively. Otherwise, the results regarding f (µ, z) for v/c = 0.1 were qualitatively similar to those shown in Figures 7 to 9 for v/c = 0.5, with much stronger anisotropies and jumps in hfiµ at the shock. 3.2. Precursors of Forbush Decreases To demonstrate the versatility of this method, we apply it to model Forbush decreases of galactic cos- mic rays (GCR) as an interplanetary shock passes the Earth (Forbush 1938, Berry & Hess 1942, Forbush & Lange 1942), which represent a transient phenomenon instead of a steady state. Ground-based neutron mon- itors measure secondary neutrons from the impact of relativistic, primary charged particles, mainly pro- tons, on the upper atmosphere. Due to selective de- flection by the Earth's magnetic field, neutron moni- tor observations are sensitive to primary cosmic rays from specific directions in space, and the worldwide network of neutron monitors provides detailed infor- mation on their pitch angle distribution, sensitive to variations on the order of 0.1%. Precursors to For- bush decreases are of practical interest as possible predictors of space weather effects on the Earth, such as satellite failures, radio fade-outs, power outages, etc., several hours or even days before the passage of a major interplanetary shock. Several analyses of neutron monitor observations have indicated two types of precursors to Forbush decreases: 1) an en- hanced diurnal anisotropy of GCR, with an excess of particles traveling toward the Sun along the inter- planetary magnetic field, and 2) a deficit of GCR in a "loss cone," i.e., along a narrow range of pitch an- gles directed nearly along the interplanetary magnetic field away from the Sun (Nagashima et al. 1992, Na- gashima, Fujimoto, & Morishita 1994, Sakakibara et al. 1995, Belov et al. 1995, Cane, Richardson, & von Rosenvinge 1996, Bieber & Evenson 1997). We model the Forbush decrease in a rather ide- alized manner, assuming the configuration of Fig- ure 1 and neglecting particle drifts (Nishida 1983, Kadokura & Nishida 1986), spatial dependence of the scattering mean free path, shock curvature, the finite spatial extent of the interplanetary shock, adiabatic focusing, and adiabatic deceleration. Nevertheless, we can explain the basic features of the observed pre- cursors, verifying their interpretation in terms of par- ticle transport in the vicinity of an oblique shock. 12 The simulation conditions were inspired by the dra- matic CME event of 1997 April 7, which arrived near Earth on April 10-11, and for which a possible loss cone feature is identified by Bieber & Evenson (1997). In this case, the travel time of 3 days indicates a shock speed of ≈ 600 km s−1 or only 200 km s−1 faster than the (typical) solar wind speed. Assuming that the shock normal is radial, we take the upstream shock-field angle to be the typical "garden-hose" an- gle of 45◦ (tan θ1 = 1), and as before we assume us1 = uA1 = 50 km s−1. Thus we find ∆un = 133 km s−1, tan θ2 = 3.20, and B2/B1 = 2.37, which in turn implies that particles crossing the shock from down- stream have pitch angles aligned with the magnetic field to within 40◦ (µ > 0.76). We used q = 1.5, which adequately describes interplanetary scattering (Bieber et al. 1986). For the upstream boundary con- dition, we specify a constant Fu (see §2.5), and the ini- tial condition sets F to that constant in the upstream region and to zero in the downstream region. We used ∆µ = 2/45 (45 µ-grid points) and ∆z/λ = 0.05, where λ = 0.3 AU. We considered v = 0.75c, corre- sponding to a kinetic energy of 480 MeV. For the mo- mentum spectrum, we assumed F ∝ p−1, according to the model proton spectrum of Reinecke, Moraal, & McDonald (1996) for the similar polarity solar cycle of 1977. However, the simulation results were very insensitive to the GCR spectral index. Figure 10 shows the omnidirectional GCR inten- sity as a function of position (normalized to 1 just upstream of the shock). As the shock moves past a fixed observer, one sees a gradual precursor decline and a slight recovery as the shock approaches. Such gradual declines in some observations were noted by Cane et al. (1996). In their one figure for such a For- bush decrease, that of 1972 Oct 31 (Figure 5 of that paper), it is seen that 2 out of 3 neutron monitor sta- tions observed a relative peak near the time of shock onset. It would be interesting if the omnidirectional flux could be estimated from the worldwide neutron monitor network for such events for direct comparison with the results of numerical simulations. At the shock itself, we see a jump reminiscent of that found in §3.1 for shock acceleration with Fu = 0 (Figure 7; see also Ostrowski 1991, Gieseler et al. 1998). Thus this model predicts a discontinuous drop at the shock followed by a more gradual decline which we identify as the declining slope of a Forbush de- crease. We note, however, that this model cannot hope to accurately reproduce the detailed features of the Forbush decrease itself, given its simplistic as- sumptions (see also §4). The phase space distribution, f , as a function of µ and z is shown in Figure 11, and pitch angle distri- butions in the near upstream (z = 0.05λ) and far up- stream (z = λ) regions are shown in Figure 12. We see that there is an overall enhanced sunward anisotropy both downstream and upstream, where it persists over several mean free paths from the shock. Close to the shock, we also find the second type of observed pre- cursor feature with a sharp decline in the loss cone region. Our numerical simulations indicate that f (µ, z) up- stream is approximately given by a sum of steady- state separable solutions. If a steady state has not been achieved, separable solutions of the full trans- port equation involve an eigenvalue equation similar to equation (5) with u/v → u/v − 1/(kvτ ), where τ is the decay time. Given the weak sensitivity of eigenvalues to u/v (except α1), the longest-lived solu- tions should be similar to the steady-state solutions of equation (5) with some modification to k. The time scale of evolution of a Forbush decrease, ∼1 day, is much longer than the travel time of particles across the distance scales of interest, ∼10 minutes, so it is reasonable that transient solutions have disappeared leaving only nearly stationary solutions of the trans- port equation. Both types of observed precursors of Forbush de- creases are readily understood in terms of the up- stream simulation results, as expressed as a super- position of separable solutions of equation (3). The constant solution in the far upstream region corre- sponds to the zero eigenvalue. The contribution of the first eigenfunction is opposite in sign to that seen in §3.1, corresponding to an anisotropy directed to- ward the Sun over a long spatial scale. Turning to the next eigenfunction, corresponding to α2, the spa- tial decay scale of the steady-state eigenfunction is 0.074λk, and in the time-dependent simulations this feature has a spatial scale length of ≈ 0.08λk along the magnetic field, or ≈ 0.11λr in the radial direction. This eigenfunction appears with the same sign as in Figure 4 for shock acceleration (Figure 9) and repre- sents a deficit of particles in the loss cone (µ ∼> 0.76) that came from the downstream region which is de- pleted in GCR, as well as an enhancement of particles with µ just below 0.76 which were accelerated during reflection from the shock. Several examples of loss- cone deficits were given by Nagashima et al. (1994) 13 and Sakakibara et al. (1995), and an enhancement for certain pitch angles corresponding to reflection and acceleration at the shock was reported by Belov et al. (1995). The predicted spatial decay length for these features depends only weakly on the shock speed or obliquity (i.e., the eigenvalues depend only weakly on u1/v, especially for relativistic velocities), but there is a significant dependence on q (see eq. [9]). The results shown here, with precursor features roughly of the magnitude reported by Cane et al. (1996), were for a simulated duration of 7.4 hours, which is substantially shorter than the actual time it takes a shock to propagate from the Sun to the Earth (typically 2 to 4 days). This is probably due to our neglect of enhanced spatial diffusion near the shock, which must be present in order to account for the sharp GCR gradient at the onset of a Forbush decrease. Stronger scattering would stem the tide of equilibration and lead to a longer duration of these features. 4. Discussion The numerical simulation procedure developed in this work is the first to solve a pitch angle transport equation on both sides of an oblique, non-relativistic shock without assuming an ultrarelativistic particle velocity. Here we have shown applications of the technique to study oblique shock acceleration in the steady state, and to consider the time-dependent problem of Forbush decreases and in particular their precursors. To explore the capabilities and limita- tions of this type of solution, we have started with the simplest case of a plane-parallel, oblique shock with straight magnetic field lines on either side (Fig- ure 1) and a spatially uniform scattering mean free path. Clearly this simple model is neglecting a va- riety of important processes, which will be discussed shortly. One limitation in this work was our assumption of a power-law dependence of the distribution function on the particle momentum. In further work this assump- tion should be relaxed, i.e., the simulations should treat different values of the momentum, as has been done by Kirk & Schneider (1989). This assumption has strongly affected calculated values of the parti- cle spectrum, but based on test runs that artificially compensate for the error, it seems not to have signif- icantly affected the spatial and pitch angle distribu- tions. This should be checked in future work. Monte Carlo (MC) techniques are undoubtedly more popular than the finite difference method used here, and MC simulations are very well-suited for exploring certain phenomena. Here we use a finite difference method for consistency with an existing code that includes a variety of effects known to be important for interplan- etary transport (Ruffolo 1995) so that the treatment of the shock can be readily incorporated into such sim- ulations. For transport simulations in general, finite difference or eigenfunction expansion techniques have some advantages, such as often requiring less com- puting time, the absence of statistical error, straight- forward extrapolation to reduce discretization error, easier treatment of a high dynamic range in particle density, and a straightforward and continuous imple- mentation of analytic expressions for scattering and other processes (for a comparison of different tech- niques, see Earl et al. 1995). The last of these is also a notable limitation in situations where analytic ex- pressions are not available, e.g., situations requiring the tracing of particle orbits. If the tracing of particle orbits is only necessary near the shock, that could be implemented in a finite difference code by a "transfer matrix" based on a one-time evaluation of the proba- bility of various outcomes at the shock for each µ-grid point. To the author's knowledge, calculated pitch an- gle distributions for steady-state acceleration of en- ergetic particles at a non-relativistic oblique shock have not reported previously. Such pitch angle dis- tributions should be directly comparable with recent and upcoming in situ observations near interplane- tary shocks. As observed distributions are reported in greater detail, they can be expected to challenge the theoretical models and help indicate which ad- ditional physical processes have important effects on particle transport and acceleration at interplanetary shocks. The pitch angle distributions for steady-state shock acceleration represent the superposition of pitch angle eigenfunctions with different amplitudes, as first de- scribed by Kirk & Schneider (1987a). The amplitudes of different eigenfunctions can only be determined by treating how particles cross the shock. The upstream pitch angle distributions obtained here for oblique, non-relativistic shocks and mildly relativisitic parti- cles (Figure 9) are qualitatively very different from those found for parallel, relativistic shocks and ultra- relativistic particles (Kirk & Schneider 1987a,b, Heav- ens & Drury 1988). In contrast to the non-relativistic case, those authors found that even for a parallel shock, eigenfunctions beyond those present in the dif- fusion approximation are excited. The upstream pitch angle distribution is highly collimated in the direction away from the shock. The downstream distribution for the parallel, mildly relativistic shock (u1 = 0.3c) is qualitatively similar to what we find for oblique, non- relativistic shocks. Our results can be more directly compared with the pitch angle scattering results of Naito & Takahara (1995), who treated oblique, mildly relativistic shocks with u1 = 0.1c·sec θ1. We find qual- itatively similar upstream pitch angle distributions but very different downstream distributions; for high obliquity (and high u1) those of Naito & Takahara (1995) are strongly collimated with particles moving away from the shock. The second application considered here, to pre- cursors of Forbush decreases of galactic cosmic rays (GCR), demonstrates the ability of this method to simulate time-dependent phenomena. The eigenfunc- tion analysis alone is sufficient to specify that in a steady state, one can have certain types of features in the pitch angle distribution over certain distance scales. For example, the observed increase in diurnal anisotropy well before the onset of some interplane- tary shocks (e.g., Cane et al. 1996, Bieber & Evenson 1997) is identified with the eigenvalue α1 and a long distance scale, and the superimposed excess for µ up to ≈ 0.5 and strong deficit thereafter (Nagashima et al. 1992, 1994, Sakakibara et al. 1995) is identified with the eigenvalue α2 and a distance scale of ∼ 0.1λ. The time-dependent simulations are necessary to ver- ify that these modes are in fact excited with the ap- propriate sign and a reasonable amplitude, and that the time-dependent, upstream distribution is approxi- mately represented by a superposition of steady-state eigenfunctions (which is not the case downstream). We note that simulations of a Forbush decrease with a parallel shock did not exhibit features corre- sponding to α2, which is an example of how not all eigenfunctions are excited in every situation. Since a localized deficit in a narrow loss cone is in fact not ex- pected for a parallel shock, this supports the physical explanation that the upstream deficit over a narrow range of pitch angles corresponds to particles cross- ing from the downstream region which is depleted in GCR (Nagashima et al. 1992). As stressed earlier, this model of a Forbush de- crease is idealized in many ways, though it seems to be adequate for describing the key features of upstream 14 precursors, which are of practical interest for short- term space weather forecasting (Bieber & Evenson 1997) by warning of the impending impact of a ma- jor interplanetary shock. We are much more hesitant to apply this idealized model to the Forbush decrease itself. However, according to Wibberenz, Cane, and Richardson (1997), the key features of a Forbush de- crease can be captured by assuming enhanced scatter- ing (a lower mean free path) in the region just down- stream of the shock. This could easily be included in a simulation technique such as ours and a compar- ison with particle distributions observed during the course of Forbush decreases could help identify what physical processes are crucial to the Forbush decrease phenomenon. A key motivation for this work is the potential to include more physical effects in the future. For a more realistic magnetic field configuration, trans- port effects such as adiabatic focusing and deceler- ation can readily be included, as they have already been included in numerical simulations of interplan- etary transport. Enhanced scattering near a shock almost certainly affects acceleration and transport in that region, yet the magnitude and extent of such scattering for high-energy particles is not well under- stood. Concrete models of the spatial dependence of the mean free path near a shock should be developed and tested for their success in explaining in situ ob- servations. The author is grateful to Paul Evenson, Wolfgang Droge, and Marty Lee for useful discussions and sug- gestions. In the formative stages of this work, I greatly benefited from lectures at the JSPS-ICRR In- ternational Spring School in Tokyo during February, 1995, and especially from those given by Toshio Tera- sawa. I particularly want to thank the Thailand Re- search Fund for their support of this research. I am also grateful for the kind hospitality of the Bartol Re- search Institute of the University of Delaware, where part of this research was performed under the support of NASA grant NAG 5-2606. 15 REFERENCES Armstrong, T. P., & Holland, G. G. 1998, Eos Trans. Am. Geophys. Union, 79, no. 17, Suppl., 2562 Axford, W. I. 1981, Proc. 17th Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Paris), 12, 155 Droge, W., Ruffolo, D., & Klecker, B. 1996, ApJ, 464, L87, astro-ph/9604019 Droge, W., Wibberenz, G., & Klecker, B. 1990, Proc. 21st Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Adelaide), 5, 187 Earl, J. A. 1974, ApJ, 193, 231 Axford, W. I., Leer, E., & Skadron, G. 1977, Proc. 15th Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Plovdiv), 11, 132 Earl, J. A. 1987, Proc. 20th Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Moscow), 3, 198 Ballard, K. R., & Heavens, A. F. 1991, MNRAS, 251, 438 Baring, M. G., Ellison, D. C., & Jones, F. C. 1993, ApJ, 409, 327 Bell, A. R. 1978, MNRAS, 182, 147 Belov, A. V., Dorman, L. I., Eroshenko, E. A., Iucci, N., Villoresi, G., & Yanke, V. G. 1995, Proc. 24th Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Rome), 4, 888 Berry, E. B., & Hess, V. F. 1942, Terr. Mag., 47, 251 Earl, J. A., Ruffolo, D., Pauls, H. L., & Bieber, J. W. 1995, ApJ, 454, 749 Eichler, D. 1981, ApJ, 244, 711 Ellison, D. C., Jones, F. C., & Eichler, D. 1981, J. Geophys., 50, 110 Ellison, D. C., Mobius, E., & Paschmann, G. 1990, ApJ, 352, 376 Evenson, P., Meyer, P., & Yanagita, S. 1982, J. Geo- phys. Res., 87, 625 Bieber, J. W., Earl, J. A., Green, G., Kunow, H., Muller-Mellin, R., & Wibberenz, G. 1980, J. Geo- phys. Res., 85, 2313 Fermi, E. 1949, Phys. Rev., 75, 1169 Fermi, E. 1954, ApJ, 119, 1 Bieber, J. W., & Evenson, P. A. 1997, Proc. 25th Forbush, S. E. 1938, Terr. Mag., 43, 203 Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Durban), 1, 341 Bieber, J. W., Evenson, P. A., & Pomerantz, M. A. 1986, J. Geophys. Res., 91, 8713 Blandford, R., & Eichler, D. 1987, Phys. Rep., 154, 1 Blandford, R. D., & Ostriker, J. P. 1978, ApJ, 221, L29 Forbush, S. E., & Lange, I. 1942, Terr. Mag., 47, 331 Gieseler, U. D. J., Kirk, J. G., Gallant, Y. A., & Achterberg, A. 1998, A&A, submitted Gosling, J. T., Asbridge, J. R., Bame, S. J., Feldman, W. C., Zwickl, R. D., Paschmann, G., Sckopke, N., & Hynds, R. J. 1981, J. Geophys. Res., 86, 547 Boberg, P. R., Tylka, J. A., & Adams, J. H., Jr. 1996, Hasselmann, K. & Wibberenz, G. 1968, Z. Geophys., ApJ, 471, L65 34, 353 Cane, H. V., Richardson, I. G., & von Rosenvinge, T. Hatzky, R. 1996, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Kiel T. 1996, J. Geophys. Res., 101, 21561 Heavens, A. F., & Drury, L. O'C. 1988, MNRAS, 235, Cummings, A. C., Stone, E. C., & Webber, W. R. 997 1986, J. Geophys. Res., 91, 2896 Decker, R. B. 1983, J. Geophys. Res., 88, 9959 Decker, R. B. & Vlahos, L. 1985, J. Geophys. Res., 90, 47 Decker, R. B. & Vlahos, L. 1986, ApJ, 306, 710 de Hoffmann, F., & Teller, E. 1950, Phys. Rev., 80, 692 Heras, A. M., Sanahuja, B., Lario, D., Smith, Z. K., Detman, T., & Dryer, M. 1995, ApJ, 445, 497 Jokipii, J. R. 1966, ApJ, 146, 480 Jokipii, J. R. 1968, ApJ, 152, 671 Jokipii, J. R. 1971, Rev. Geophys. Space Phys., 9, 27 Jokipii, J. R. 1987, ApJ, 313, 842 16 Jones, F. C., Jokipii, J. R., & Baring, M. G. 1998, ApJ, in press, astro-ph/9808103 Kadokura, A., & Nishida, A. 1986, J. Geophys. Res., 91, 13 Nagashima, K., Fujimoto, K., Sakakibara, S., Mor- ishita, I., & Tatsuoka, R. 1992, Planet. Space Sci., 40, 1109 Naito, T., & Takahara, F. 1995, MNRAS, 275, 1077 Kallenrode, M.-B. 1997a, J. Geophys. Res., 102, Ng, C. K., & Wong, K.-Y. 1979, Proc. 16th Internat. 22335 Cosmic Ray Conf. (Kyoto), 5, 252 Kallenrode, M.-B. 1997b, J. Geophys. Res., 102, Nishida, A. 1983, J. Geophys. Res., 88, 785 22347 Kallenrode, M.-B., & Wibberenz, G. 1997, J. Geo- phys. Res., 102, 22311 Kallenrode, M.-B., Wibberenz, G., & Hucke, S. 1992, ApJ, 394, 351 Kennel, C. F., Coroniti, F. V., Scarf, F. L., Livesey, W. A., Russell, C. T., Smith, E. J., Wenzel, K. P., & Scholer, M. 1986, J. Geophys. Res., 91, 11917 Kirk, J. G. 1988, ApJ, 324, 557 Kirk, J. G., & Heavens, A. F. 1989, MNRAS, 239, 995 Kirk, J. G., & Schneider, P. 1987a, ApJ, 315, 425 Kirk, J. G., & Schneider, P. 1987b, ApJ, 322, 256 Kirk, J. G., & Schneider, P. 1989, A&A, 225, 559 Kocharov, L., Vainio, R., Kovaltsov, G. A., & Torsti, J. 1998, Sol. Phys., 182, 195 Krulls, W. M., & Achterberg, A. 1994, A&A, 286, 314 Krymskii, G. F. 1977, Sov. Phys. Dokl., 22, 327 Lario, D. 1997, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Barcelona Lee, M. A. 1983, J. Geophys. Res., 88, 6109 Lee, M. A., & Ryan, J. M. 1986, ApJ, 303, 829 Lieu, R., Quenby, J. J., Drolias, B., & Naidu, K. 1994, ApJ, 421, 211 Ostrowski, M. 1991, MNRAS, 249, 551 Palmer, I. D. 1982, Rev. Geophys. Space Phys., 20, 335 Parker, E. N. 1958, Phys. Rev., 109, 1328 Pauls, H. L., & Burger, R. A. 1994, ApJ, 427, 927 Pesses, M. E., Eichler, D., & Jokipii, J. R. 1981, ApJ, 246, L85 Reames, D. V. 1990, ApJ, 358, L63 Reames, D. V., Barbier, L. M., & Ng, C. K. 1996, ApJ, 466, 473 Reames, D. V., Barbier, L. M., von Rosenvinge, T. T., Mason, G. M., Mazur, J. E., and Dwyer, J. R. 1997, ApJ, 483, 515 Reinecke, J. P. L., Moraal, H., & McDonald, F. B. 1996, J. Geophys. Res., 101, 21581 Ruffolo, D. 1991, ApJ, 382, 688 Ruffolo, D. 1995, ApJ, 442, 861, astro-ph/9408056 Ruffolo, D. 1997, ApJ, 481, L119, astro-ph/9702160 Ruffolo, D., & Khumlumlert T. 1995, Geophys. Res. Lett., 22, 2073, astro-ph/9506133 Ruffolo, D., Khumlumlert, T., & Youngdee, W. 1998, J. Geophys. Res., 103, 20591, astro-ph/9806097 Sakakibara, S., et al. 1995, Proc. 24th Internat. Cos- Mason, G. M., Gloeckler, G., & Hovestadt, D. 1984, mic Ray Conf. (Rome), 4, 896 ApJ, 280, 902 McKenzie, J. F., & Westphal, K. D. 1968, Phys. Flu- ids, 11, 2350 Schatzman, E. 1963, Ann. d'Astr., 26, 234 Schluter, W. 1985, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Kiel McKibben, R. B. 1972, J. Geophys. Res., 77, 3959 Sweby, P. K. 1984, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 21, 995 Nagashima, K., Fujimoto, K., & Morishita, I. 1994, Tan, L. C., Mason, G. M., Klecker, B., & Hovestadt, J. Geophys. Res., 99, 21419 D. 1989, ApJ, 345, 572 17 Terasawa, T. 1979, Planet. Space Sci., 27, 193 Terasawa, T., & Scholer, M. 1989, Science, 244, 1050 Webb, G. M, & Gleeson, L. J. 1979, Ap&SS, 60, 335 Wibberenz, G., Cane, H. V., & Richardson, I. G. 1997, Proc. 25th Internat. Cosmic Ray Conf. (Dur- ban), 1, 397 This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v4.0. 18 Fig. 1.- Model configuration in the de Hoffmann- Teller frame, in which the shock is stationary, the fluid flow ~u is parallel to the magnetic field ~B, and the electric field is zero. Fig. 2.- Illustration of changes in pitch angle when a particle crosses an oblique shock, a process which contributes to particle acceleration. Here vk and v⊥ are components of the particle velocity in the shock frame. See text for details. Fig. 3.- Eigenvalues closest to zero for equation (5) as a function of u/v for q = 1 (solid lines) and q = 1.5 (dashed lines). Fig. 4.- Eigenfunctions of equation (5) for eigenval- ues shown in Figure 3 for u/v = −0.075 and q = 1. For steady-state shock acceleration, the pitch angle distribution is a linear combination of such functions. Particle motion is directed away from the shock for µ < 0 downstream and µ > 0 upstream. Fig. 5.- Fluid compression ratio, u1n/u2n, and mag- netic compression ratio, B2/B1, as a function of the normal velocity jump in the shock frame, ∆un = u1n − u2n, for t1 = tan θ1 = 0, 0.5, 1, 2, and 4. Fig. 6.- Schematic illustration of the balance of spa- tial and momentum fluxes in diffusive shock acceler- ation. Fig. 7.- Spatial dependence of the pitch-angle av- eraged phase space distribution function, hfiµ, for steady-state particle acceleration near a shock (at z = 0) for various values of tan θ1, the tangent of the angle between the magnetic field and the shock nor- mal, for q = 1 (solid lines) and 1.5 (dotted lines), and for v = 0.5c. Farther from the shock, hfiµ is constant downstream and exponentially decays toward zero up- stream. The ordinate is normalized to the value far downstream. Fig. 8.- Phase space distribution of particles as a function of µ and z (in units of λ) near an oblique shock with tan θ1 = 4 for a) q = 1 and b) q = 1.5. Note the changes in the pitch angle distribution near the shock (at z = 0). Fig. 9.- Phase space distribution of particles as a function of µ near an oblique shock with tan θ1 = 4 for q = 1 (solid lines) and q = 1.5 (dashed lines) at z = 0.05λ (upstream; thick lines) and z = −0.05λ (downstream; thin lines). Fig. 10.- Spatial dependence of the pitch-angle aver- aged phase space distribution function, hfiµ, of galac- tic cosmic rays near an oblique interplanetary shock (tan θ1 = 1). As the shock moves (to the right) past a fixed observer, one sees a gradual precursor decline and a slight recovery, followed by a discontinuous de- crease at the onset of a Forbush decrease. Fig. 11.- Phase space distribution of particles as a function of µ and z (in units of λ) near an oblique interplanetary shock (tan θ1 = 1). The sharp drop downstream (z < 0) represents the Forbush decrease; upstream (z > 0) features represent precursors that may be useful for space weather prediction. Superim- posed on the enhanced sunward anisotropy, note the unusual pitch angle distribution just upstream of the shock. Fig. 12.- Phase space distribution of galactic cosmic rays as a function of µ near an oblique interplanetary shock (tan θ1 = 1) at z = 0.05λ (solid line) and z = λ (dashed line), representing near upstream and far upstream precursors of a Forbush decrease. 19 Selected Solutions of Shock Jump Conditionsa Table 1 tan θ1 tan θ2 u1n u2n B2/B1 0 1 4 0 3.88 15.11 538.0 541.5 544.3 138.0 141.5 144.3 1.00 2.83 3.67 aFor uA1 = us1 = 50 km s−1. A
astro-ph/9310014	1	9310	1993-10-06T14:41:37	Subclustering and Luminous-Dark Matter Segregation in Galaxy Clusters	[ "astro-ph" ]	We have performed a series of N-body experiments on Connection Machine-5 in order to simulate the formation of galaxy clusters gravitationally dominated by a massive dark background. In accordance with previous authors we find an extremely inhomogeneous evolution where subcondensations are continually formed and merged. The final distribution of galaxies is more centrally condensed than that of dark matter particles. We have analyzed the origin of this galaxy-dark matter segregation and also the origin of subclustering leading to this effect. We have then analysed, analytically and numerically, the dependence of final segregation on the physical parameters characterizing the model of protocluster. We also find that such a segregation persists even when inelastic encounters of dark halos around galaxies are taken into account. We conclude that this effect cannot be in general avoided in any hierarchical clustering scenario.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Subclustering and Luminous-Dark Matter Segregation in Galaxy Clusters 3 9 9 1 t c O 6 0 4 1 0 0 1 3 9 / h p - o r t s a A. Serna, J.-M. Alimi Laboratoire d'Astrophysique Extragalactique et de Cosmologie. Observatoire de Paris-Meudon. Meudon, France and H. Scholl D(cid:19)epartement Cassini. Observatoire de la C^ote d'Azur. BP , Nice, France Abstract We have performed a series of high resolution N-body experiments on a Connection Machine CM- in order to simulate the formation of galaxy clusters gravitationally dominated by a massive dark background. In accordance with previous authors we (cid:12)nd an extremely inhomogeneous evolution where subcondensations are continually formed and merged. Final distributions do not present subclustering and galaxies are more centrally condensed than dark matter particles. We have found that such a luminous-dark matter segregation persists even when inelastic encounters of dark halos around galaxies are taken into account. We show rigorously that such a segregation is due to dynamical friction within the subclusters, while an interpretation of this e(cid:11)ect as a biasing process in initial conditions, is ruled out. We are then interested in the origin of subclustering. We (cid:12)nd that galaxy-dark matter segregation is mainly due to the substructures formed from local gravitational perturbations produced by the presence itself of massive bod- ies (galaxies), while the subclusters formed from initial Poisson density (cid:13)uctuations. Consequently, the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation depends only very slightly on the initial (cid:13)uctuation spectrum. Physical parameters characterizing the model of protocluster have, however, an important in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal result. This dependence has been qualitatively ex- plained by means of a simple dynamical model and has been numerically analyzed. We (cid:12)nd that (cid:12)nal distributions without segregation are only possible for extreme values of these physical parameters. We then conclude that such a segregation e(cid:11)ect cannot be in general avoided in any hierarchical clustering scenario. Consequently, all observational analyses assuming that galaxies in clusters trace mass are misleading and their conclusions have to be reconsidered. Sub ject headings: cosmology { dark matter { galaxies: cluster of { galaxies: clus- tering . Introduction. There exists a general agreement that self-gravitating systems go through two di(cid:11)erent stages in their evolution: (cid:12)rst, a fast phase of violent relaxation, where the dynamics is controlled by a collective potential, and then a slow two-body relaxation phase, where the dominant role corresponds to binary collisions. The (cid:12)nal distribution of energy per unit mass which results from violent relaxation is independent of particle masses (Lynden-Bell ), so one expects that no mass segregation will be produced during this phase. On the other hand, the estimates of M=L for rich galaxy clusters suggest that a large part of their mass may well be in some dark form. Current theories of galaxy formation admit a wide range of possible candidates for this dark matter. Within the context of hierarchical clustering theories, ob jects in the range of ev to (cid:0) M seem possible (Lacey & Ostriker ; Turner ; Gnedin & Ostriker ; (cid:12) Wambsganss & Pacynski ). N-body simulations show that formation of clusters containing both galaxies and dark matter can be however rather complicated. Numerical calculations by White ( ), Evrard ( ) and West & Richstone ( , hereafter WR) imply that clusters of galaxies have an extremely inhomogeneous evolution where subcondensations are continually formed and merged, giving rise to (cid:12)nal distributions with a considerable spatial segregation between the two mass components. This result can be also inferred from several other works (e.g., Roos & Aarseth ; Barnes ; Cavaliere et al. ). A signi(cid:12)cant luminous-dark matter segregation in galaxy clusters would imply that virial mass estimates based on galaxy coordinates have a great error (Limber ; Aarseth & Saslaw ; Smith et al. ; Smith , ; Bailey ; Ho(cid:11)man, Shaham & Shaviv ; Barnes , ; Valtonen et al. ; Navarro, Garcia-Lambas & S(cid:19)ersic ; Cowie, Henriksen & Mushotzky ; Evrard ; Merrit ; The & White , ). WR pointed out that the density parameter values (cid:10) ' .{. obtained from galaxy clusters could in that case be consistent with true values of (cid:10) = . A possible mechanism leading to that segregation could be the exchange of en- ergy from galaxies to dark matter particles produced by dynamical friction inside the subclusters. By using the standard formula (Chandrasekhar ) to estimate the dynamical friction time within a subcluster, West and Richstone (WR, West , Richstone ) found :N T g cr T = df () x( (cid:0) x)( + f ) ln (cid:3) where all variables refer to a subcluster, N being the number of galaxies in the sub- g cluster, x the galaxy mass fraction, f the ratio of dark to luminous particle mass, ln(cid:3) the usual Coulomb logarithm and T the crossing time, cr T = R=v () cr with R and v being the subcluster radius and galaxy velocity, respectively. For N = , g x = :, ln(cid:3) = and f ' , equation () implies T (cid:24) T . So, the friction time in df cr < substructures could be rather short and galaxies would go to the lump centers on a few crossing times. However, there are still some questions referring to this luminous-dark matter segregation which are su(cid:14)ciently important and controversial to be examined in detail. To this end, we have performed a series of N-body simulations where the simplest cosmological picture and assumptions are taken in order to establish a well-posed dynamical problem. Section discusses the initial conditions and the N-body code used for these simulations. First, although the above interpretation given by WR is reasonable, it has not been rigorously proved. In principle, other possible explanations, as some "biasing" e(cid:11)ects resulting from the initial distribution of galaxies in the deepest potential wells are also considered to explain that segregation (White ). Both possibilities will be tested (Section ) from a convenient series of numerical experiences. Another question which still holds without a fully satisfactory solution is that concerning the development of subclustering during the system expansion and collapse phases. The answer to this question has a fundamental importance because it could be related to some possibility of avoiding this e(cid:11)ect. WR claimed that subclusters leading to a (cid:12)nal segregation are formed from small-scale statistical (cid:13)uctuations on the initial particle distribution. Di(cid:11)erent initial density (cid:13)uctuation spectra would then imply some quantitative di(cid:11)erences in the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation. The extreme case where small-scale Poisson (cid:13)uctuations are initially suppressed could then imply similar resulting distributions for both mass components. A grid simulation performed by these authors seems to support that, but their conclusions are not clear because in the same numerical experiment they suppressed the cluster expansion phase, which could be a serious default in their analysis. A second type of subclusters, whose in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal results has not been analyzed, are those formed from the local gravitational perturbation produced by the presence itself of massive ob jects (galaxies) in a background of much lighter and more numerous particles (dark matter). If such a subclustering mechanism is important, lumps of dark matter would be always formed around galaxies (provided clusters form in a bottom up manner) and segregation would develop even from extreme initial conditions as those of a grid simulation. Section is devoted to analyze this sub ject. Finally, we must also analyze the in(cid:13)uence of the di(cid:11)erent physical parameters characterizing the model of protocluster on the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation. Equation () gives some information about the physical features which could modify the (cid:12)nal results. However, the parameters appearing in that equation are not known a priori because they refer to subclusters while calculations start by specifying the overall clus- ter characteristics. A simple infall model is developed in Section to estimate how the initial cluster parameters enter in equation (). This will allow us to interpret qualita- tively a sequence of simulations where the in(cid:13)uence of di(cid:11)erent physical parameters is analyzed. Infall models for the formation of condensed ob jects were (cid:12)rst constructed by Gunn & Gott ( ) and extended later by Gott ( ), Gunn ( ), Fillmore & Goldreich ( ), Bertschinger ( ) and White & Zaritsky ( ) for a wider variety of conditions. Inherent in all the above simulations is an assumption whose possible in(cid:13)uence must be tested: dark matter is initially distributed as a smooth background and galaxies interact elastically. However, it has been suggested (Eyles et al ) that segregation could be avoided by taking dark matter particles initially distributed as extended halos around galaxies. Inelastic encounters between these galaxy-halo systems could lead to loss of energy by the stripped dark material. In this case, non-luminous particles would progressively concentrate in the core as they are removed from galaxies. In order to analyze this possibility, we have simulated (Section ) the dynamical evolution of a cluster of galaxies containing massive dark halos. . Method. . Cluster Models. As in WR, we consider the simplest cosmological scenario where a cluster of galaxies is formed from the spherical collapse of a primordial density (cid:13)uctuation. This over- dense region initially expands with the Hubble (cid:13)ow, eventually reaches a maximum radius and then turns around and begins to contract. In order to simulate this simple model, we have considered a self-gravitating system containing both heavy (galaxies) and light (dark matter) softened particles of individ- ual masses m and m , respectively. Initial particle positions were typically assigned g dm at random within a uniform sphere of radius R . The initial velocity (cid:12)eld was a Hub- in ble (cid:13)ow, v = H r , where r is the position vector of each particle i and H is the i in i i in Hubble parameter at the starting time. For such an expanding uniform sphere, initial kinetic and potential energies are given by K = M H R and U = GM =R , in T in in in in T respectively, where M is the total mass. The Hubble parameter is then related to the T maximum radius, R , by m s (cid:18) (cid:19) GM R T in H = (cid:0) () in R R in m and the time required for expansion and subsequent collapse is s R m t = (cid:25) () coll GM T Throughout this paper we have used units in which G = M = and R = =. T in Previous works (White , Cavaliere et al. , WR) have chosen H in order in to obtain R =R ' . When comparing with clusters such as Coma, this expansion m in factor gives a collapse time of the order of yr and an initial redshift of about in an Einstein-de Sitter Universe. The expansion factor is also related to the initial values of the density parameter (cid:10) and the density contrast (cid:14) (Peebles ). Clusters i i di(cid:11)erent from Coma or models with a shorter or larger post-collapse evolution might be better described by using a somewhat di(cid:11)erent R =R value. In the present study, m in we have taken R =R ' as the standard expansion factor value, but we have also m in analyzed the e(cid:11)ects of considering smaller or larger values (see below section ). The numbers and masses of the two types of particles were chosen in such a way that while galaxies are individually much more massive, the total mass of the cluster is dominated by the non-luminous component. In most of our simulations, particles were considered, of which were taken as galaxies. The remaining bodies represented dark matter particles with a mass m ' m = in order to have a total non-luminous dm g mass fraction of (cid:17) = : . In real clusters, the ratio m =m must be many orders of g dm magnitude higher. Fortunately, tidal e(cid:11)ects due to individual dark matter particles seem to be unimportant and m enters as ( + m =m ) in Chandrasekhar's formula dm dm g for dynamical friction. One then expects that the e(cid:11)ects analyzed in this paper will be only very slightly modi(cid:12)ed by the technical limitations of the dark matter mass assignation. Most of our present simulations do not incorporate galactic collision e(cid:11)ects such as tidal stripping and merging. Despite the e(cid:11)orts of a number of workers (Richstone , ; Roos & Norman ; Dekel, Lecar & Shaham ; Merrit , ; Aguilar & White ), the relevant cross-sections for inelastic collisions are still not well known. By including these e(cid:11)ects, one may well commit a similar error as by neglecting them. However, these processes are clearly important and their possible in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal results must be tested. To this end, we have also performed simulations where the inelasticity of halo encounters is taken into account. The two- component approach used for that simulation is similar to that previously considered by Evrard ( ). Table presents a summary of our N-body calculations. . N-Body Code. Particles of mass m and m interact through the softened potential: i j (cid:30) = Gm m =(r + (cid:15) + (cid:15) ) () ij i j ij i j = where r is their separation. The softening parameter (cid:15) is essentially a particle radius. ij i We have adopted the usual convention (cid:15) = (cid:15) m where particles are taken as Plum- i i = mer spheres of identical central density (Farouki & Salpeter ; Farouki, Ho(cid:11)man & Salpeter ). In our simulations, (cid:15) was chosen in order to obtain (cid:15) = : for i the heaviest particles. The most obvious algorithm to integrate the equations () is direct summation (Aarseth , ). Unfortunately, the number of operations in this algorithm grows as N . On classical sequential computers it is at present not possible to consider a large number of particles (N (cid:20) ) and to perform many numerical simulations. On the other hand, the direct summation algorithm is specially adapted for massively parallel computers like a Connection Machine. In this paper, most of numerical simulations have been performed on a Connection Machine CM- by using a "Digital Orrery" algorithm, (cid:12)rst developed on a Connection Machine CM-, (Hillis & Barnes , Alimi & Scholl ). In this case, one physical or virtual processor is assigned to each particle. One can then imagine two rings of processors containing both the same set of N-body coordinates. One ring starts to turn around stepwise by the use of CM instructions. At each step, forces between all adjacent couples of bodies placed on the two di(cid:11)erent rings are calculated in parallel. A complete force calculation between all particles requires N (cid:0) such steps. To illustrate the computational requirements, for a simulation with particles, the main part, computing all interacting forces between all particles, took less than s per timestep. The accuracy of the integration can be illustrated by the variation of the total energy throughout a complete calculation (t ). The energy violation in a particle system was smaller than . per coll cent in a typical timestep, and . per cent for the overall simulation. . Origin of the Luminous-Dark Matter Segregation. The time evolution of a typical numerical simulation is shown in Figures . The small points represent dark matter particles and the large points represent galaxies. Like previous authors (White ; Roos & Aarseth ; Barnes ; Cavaliere et al. ; Evrard ; WR), we (cid:12)nd that during the expansion phase, several substructures appear in the system. These substructures merge during the phase of collapse giving rise to a (cid:12)nal con(cid:12)guration without considerable subclustering and where galaxies are more concentrated than dark matter particles. In order to analyze the time evolution of this galaxy-dark matter segregation we have plotted (Figure ) the harmonic mean separation (cid:0) N (N (cid:0) ) X X @ A R = hm () r i j<i ij for both mass components. A segregation between the galaxies and dark matter de- velops rapidly on a timescale much shorter than the cluster collapse time (spherical top-hat model). As we have quoted in the introduction, there are two possible mech- anisms which could explain such a segregation: dynamical friction in subclusters and biasing e(cid:11)ects in the initial conditions. In order to elucidate the viability of these two mechanisms, we have performed a series of simulations where the e(cid:11)ects of both processes have been separated. To this end, we repeat the previous simulation (A) but this time with only dark matter particles (Figure ). In a (cid:12)rst experience (B), those particles placed in the deepest Poisson potential wells are called "galaxies". Since the individual mass of these "galaxies" is equal to that of dark matter particles, we cancel in this way any possibility of dynamical friction. Figure a shows the time evolution of R for both hm species of particles with only a very small (cid:12)nal segregation. This is compatible with no (cid:12)nal segregation if we take into account the uncertainties. In a second experience (B), particles placed in the deepest potential wells of the previous simulation are again called "galaxies". However, we now change the mass of these "galaxies" and suppress a convenient number of surrounding dark matter parti- cles in order to get a ratio m =m similar to that of simulations A. The suppression g dm of surrounding light particles ensures that the mass distribution is not changed on scales larger than those of massive particles. We have in this way the same initial sta- tistical (cid:13)uctuations and the same biasing as in the previous experiment. Any di(cid:11)erence between the subsequent evolution and that observed in the (cid:12)rst experiment must be then attributed to dynamical friction. The evolution of the harmonic mean separation shows now an important galaxy-dark matter segregation (Figure b). We then con- clude that only dynamical friction in the subclusters seems a viable explanation for such a segregation. . The Origin of Subclustering. The interpretation of this kind of segregation as a consequence of dynamical friction within the substructures implies that it must depend strongly on the development of subclustering during the cluster evolution. WR consider that subclusters form from statistical (cid:13)uctuations on the initial particle distribution. Consequently, the amount of segregation which develops on di(cid:11)erent scales in a hierarchical clustering scenario must depend somewhat on the initial density (cid:13)uctuation spectrum. In order to test this, they simulated the collapse phase of a cluster where particles were placed at the points of a cubic grid in order to suppress initial small-scale Poisson (cid:13)uctuations. No signi(cid:12)cant segregation was then observed to occur between galaxies and dark matter, so they concluded that their result was due to the absence of initial (cid:13)uctuations. Some number of subclusters clearly appears from initial Poisson (cid:13)uctuations. The comparison between (cid:12)gures and , where the only di(cid:11)erence is the mass assignation for the particles taken as galaxies, shows however some di(cid:11)erences on the initial subcluster positions. The origin of the overdense regions in Figure is in fact purely statistical and several of them can also be identi(cid:12)ed in Figure at the earlier evo- lutionary stages. However, there also exist on Figure several subclusters which are always related to at least one galaxy. These last regions must be interpreted as the result of the local gravitational perturbation produced by the presence itself of very massive ob jects (galaxies). We must analyze what is the importance of each kind of subclusters on the (cid:12)nal segregation in order to test if this e(cid:11)ect is avoidable and to test its possible dependence on the initial density (cid:13)uctuation spectrum. To this end, we have performed a (cid:12)rst experience (C), where the expansion phase is also canceled but now the particle positions are assigned at random within a sphere of radius R = , so our system has initial statistical (cid:13)uctuations. The collapse phase in of this system for a time roughly equal to t leads to a (cid:12)nal result which is very coll similar to that obtained by WR in their grid simulation (Figure of WR), that is, no signi(cid:12)cant segregation is found (Figure ). This result indicates that the expan- sion phase plays a fundamental role in order to obtain (cid:12)nal segregated distributions. Dynamical friction is only e(cid:11)ective within small subclusters containing a low number of galaxies. The lifetime of this kind of substructures during the collapse phase is too short because they rapidly merge giving rise to a great central overdensity. If the cluster reaches its maximum radius without developing previously such subclusters, there is no segregation because dynamical friction has not enough time to play a role inside them. Consequently, the grid simulation performed by WR does not prove a statistical origin of subclusters leading to a (cid:12)nal galaxy-dark matter segregation. In two last numerical experiences (C and C), we have simulated both the expan- sion and collapse phases beginning from initial particle distributions where small-scale Poisson (cid:13)uctuations were suppressed. In simulation C, all particles were initially placed on the same grid while in C a di(cid:11)erent grid was used for each mass compo- nent. Figure shows the time evolution of this last experience. In both cases, we (cid:12)nd that subclusters are always associated to galaxies. Consequently, the origin of these substructures is essentially due to the local gravitational attraction of galaxies. We obtain (cid:12)nal segregations (Figures ) which are similar to that obtained in simulation A from initial random positions (see Figure ). This suggests that segregation is mainly related to such kind of subclusters, instead of those formed from initial sta- tistical density (cid:13)uctuations. It is interesting to note from Figures and b that the extreme symmetry of initial conditions in C leads to an evolution where all mergers are produced simultaneously at t ' :t . The R for the two mass components coll hm also shows that spatial segregation appears suddenly at this instant. The segregation is then latent in subclusters, but it is only communicated to the overall cluster after merging, when redistribution of particles according to their energies can take place. . Dependence on Physical Parameters. In the preceding sections we have proved that the (cid:12)nal luminous-dark matter seg- regation depends only very slightly on the initial (cid:13)uctuation spectrum. However, dynamical friction within subclusters can be more or less e(cid:11)ective for di(cid:11)erent choices of physical parameters characterizing the initial protocluster. Since the subclusters which mainly produce this e(cid:11)ect are those formed from the local gravitational attrac- tion of galaxies, we can estimate the way in which these parameters enter in equation (). To this end, we have developed a simple infall model of formation and evolution of subclusters and we have then performed a sequence of simulations which will be qualitatively interpreted in the framework of that model. We study the movement of a spherical shell of dark matter around a point galaxy of mass m . At the starting time, t , this shell has a radius r and expands with a g i i relative velocity v = H r . We consider that the initial total density within this shell, i in i (cid:22)(cid:26) , is somewhat greater than the critical density (cid:26) = H =((cid:25)G). Then, it will fall i ci in on the galaxy after reaching some maximum radius. The collapse time of this shell is given by (Gunn & Gott ): (cid:25) (cid:26) = ci t = c () H ( (cid:22)(cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) ) in i ci = In our case, the initial total density within r is, i R in (cid:22)(cid:26) = (cid:26) + (cid:26) () i DM g r i where (cid:26) = (cid:17)M =( (cid:25)R ) and (cid:26) = m =( (cid:25)R ) , M and R being the initial DM T g g T in in in values for mass and radius of the overall cluster. By substituting equation () into () and solving for r , we obtain the initial radius i of that shell reaching the galaxy at a given time t , c (cid:18) (cid:19) = r i (cid:26) (cid:28) g = ( ) R (cid:26) (cid:0) ((cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) )(cid:28) in ci DM ci = where (cid:28) (cid:17) H t =(cid:25) . in c The turn-around radius for a shell of initial radius r is (Gunn & Gott ): i (cid:22)(cid:26) i r = r () m i (cid:22)(cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) i ci In order to estimate the size of a subcluster at a given time t, we consider that it is roughly equal to the virial radius r =, where r is the maximum radius of that m m shell with a collapse time just equal to t. By combining equations (){(), the time dependence of the radius R and mass M of a subcluster is p p (cid:18) (cid:19) = = R (cid:26) (cid:28) ( + (cid:28) ) p g R (cid:26) (cid:0) ((cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) )(cid:28) in ci DM ci = = m (cid:26) ( + (cid:28) ) g ci = M = p (cid:26) (cid:0) ((cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) )(cid:28) ci DM ci = () where all parameters (except (cid:28) ) are referred to the starting time. Note that both R and M are proportional to the individual galaxy mass m . The p p g density in subclusters is then independent on m . g Using equation () to computate the galactic mass fraction, x (cid:17) m =M , and the g p crossing-time (eq. []) in a substructure, equation () for dynamical friction time gives T = p df () G(cid:26) (cid:28) ((cid:26) (cid:0) ((cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) )(cid:28) )( + f ) log (cid:3) DM ci DM ci = = :N (cid:26) ( + (cid:28) ) g ci = = with :N ( + (cid:28) ) g = (cid:3) = () ((cid:26) (cid:0) ((cid:26) (cid:0) (cid:26) )(cid:28) )( + f ) ci DM ci = where we have generalized for subclusters containing N galaxies. Note that (cid:26) is g DM related to the total non-luminous mass fraction (cid:17) and that the initial Hubble parameter H enters in equation () through (cid:28) and (cid:26) . The H value is related to the cluster in ci in expansion factor, R =R , through equation (). m in The Coulomb logarithm in a subcluster (eq. []) has been estimated by taking the standard values b ' G(m + m )=v and b ' R for the minimum and min g dm max p maximum impact parameters (Cohen, Spitzer & Routly , Farouki & Salpeter , Binney & Tremaine ), with v ' :GM =R being the mean square velocity of p p particles. Figures display the predicted (t =T ) values at di(cid:11)erent evolutionary stages coll df (t =, t = and t =) versus the overall mass fraction of dark matter (cid:17) , the coll coll coll expansion factor R =R and the number of galaxies in a subcluster N . As can m in g be seen from Figure a, higher mass fractions of dark matter do not always imply greater (cid:12)nal segregations. Within the gravitational picture leading to equations () and () we see that, for (cid:17) values not very di(cid:11)erent from . , higher values of this parameter imply a faster growth of the subcluster size and dynamical friction loses then e(cid:11)ectiveness. Figure shows the results of two simulations (D and D) where di(cid:11)erent (cid:17) values were taken. We see that (cid:12)nal segregation is in fact smaller when (cid:17) = : than for (cid:17) = :. Simulations with smaller (cid:17) values have been performed. However in that case, a ma jor part of mass is in galaxies, the initial system cannot be then considered as a uniform sphere. Consequently, equation () assignes a too large velocity to particles, and we do not observe a subsequent collapse of the system. With respect to the expansion factor dependence, equation () implies slightly longer dynamical friction timescales for higher R =R values. However, the col- m in lapse time is also longer and dynamical friction has then much more time to operate within the subclusters. Consequently, t =T increases with the expansion factor and col df a greater segregation is expected ((cid:12)gure b). N-body simulations (D and D) with R =R = and show in fact this behaviour (Figure ). m in Initial conditions in our numerical experiments specify the total number of galaxies instead of the number per subcluster entering in equation (). Simulations D and D show however that for higher total N values, merging of substructures begins g at earlier evolutionary times and the substructures then contain a higher number of galaxies. Consequently, the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation is smaller (Figure ) than in simulation A. These numerical results also suggest that the (cid:12)nal segregation depends on the richness of the cluster (Serna & Alimi ). . Tidal Stripping of Galaxies with Massive Dark Halos. As we have quoted in the introduction, inherent to all the above numerical experi- ments are the assumptions that galaxies interact elastically and dark matter is initially distributed as a smooth background. However, inelastic encounters of galaxies con- taining massive dark halos could lead to loss of energy by the stripped dark material (Eyles et al ). Non-luminous particles could then progressively concentrate in the core as they are removed from galaxies giving rise to (cid:12)nal distributions where dark matter particles are more centrally condensed than galaxies. In order to analyze this possibility, we have performed two simulations (E and E) where the inelasticity of halo encounters is taken into account. The approach used for these simulation is similar to that considered by Evrard ( ), but adapted to the present problem. We have generated positions and velocities for galaxies as in the previous sim- ulations. Around each galaxy, we have then assigned a halo where positions for dark matter particles are generated at random through the density pro(cid:12)le (cid:26)(r) = () M h (cid:25)Gr r t where r is the radial distance to the galaxy center, r is a truncation radius and M = t h m is the halo mass. The value of the truncation radius has been taken rather dm extended in E (r = d ) and rather small in E (r = d ), where d = R =N is t i t i i in g = the initial intergalactic spacing, in order to be compatible with the estimated size of dark halos from observations of galaxies in clusters (Mamon & Gerbal ). Peculiar velocities of dark matter particles in a given halo were assigned at random from a Gaussian distribution with one-dimensional velocity dispersion (cid:27) = v =() , where scl = v = GM =r is a scale velocity. scl h t Figure shows a very similar evolution of particle distribution for the simulations E and E. However it is very di(cid:11)erent from previous simulations, because it is modi(cid:12)ed by the introduction of tidal stripping. Dark halos are disrupted rapidly and subclusters resulting from merging of galaxy and dark matter remain isolated. Finally we do not observe as in the previous simulation a spherical central overdensity. The harmonic mean radius for dark matter (Figure ) appears essentially constant. However, (cid:12)nal segregation holds always. Galaxies are much more clustered than dark matter particles. Similar results were obtained in experience E. The segregation seems then rather persistent for any hierarchical clustering scenario, even when very di(cid:11)erent initial conditions are considered. . Conclusions. We have performed a series of N-body experiments in order to study the formation of galaxy clusters containing a dominant dark matter component. To this end, we have considered the simplest cosmological scenario where clusters are formed in a bottom-up manner from the spherical collapse of a primordial density (cid:13)uctuation. We con(cid:12)rm the numerical results of previous authors who found (cid:12)nal distributions with a considerable spatial segregation between the two mass components. We have shown that such segregation cannot be explained by some biasing e(cid:11)ect resulting from the initial distribution of galaxies in the deepest potential wells. The cluster evolution is characterized by the development of dark matter subcon- densations which grow and then merge giving rise to a (cid:12)nal con(cid:12)guration without subclusters. Our results strongly point out that dynamical friction inside such sub- structures is responsible for the luminous-dark matter segregation. The origin of sub- clustering is due to two kinds of local gravitational perturbations: those produced by statistical density (cid:13)uctuations in the initial particle distribution and those produced by the presence itself of very massive ob jects (galaxies). It has been shown that the (cid:12)rst type has only a small in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal segregation. Since galaxies are always present in a hierarchical scenario, the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation should be only very slightly modi(cid:12)ed by considering di(cid:11)erent initial (cid:13)uctuation spectra. On the contrary, there are physical parameters characterizing the model of pro- tocluster, which have an important in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal result. Our analytical and numerical results with values for (cid:17) not excessively di(cid:11)erent from . , imply a (cid:17) de- pendence on the (cid:12)nal amount of segregation which is contrary to that expected from prejudices a priori: for higher (cid:17) values, smaller segregation results. But, in any case, a considerable e(cid:11)ect is always obtained for this range of (cid:17) values. We have also found that the expansion factor has a strong in(cid:13)uence on the (cid:12)nal segregation, which is signi(cid:12)cantly reduced when small R =R values are considered. m in In the extreme case, where R =R is as small as unity (simulation C), no (cid:12)nal m in segregation is found. From equation () we can consider the expansion factor as a measure for the starting time, that is, for the redshift formation of the cluster. This then implies that, for a given present density parameter (cid:10) , the e(cid:11)ect will be smaller for the youngest clusters. The extreme but unrealistic case where cluster formation occurs at very recent epochs (R =R ' or z ' ), should give no (cid:12)nal segregation. m in i Finally, the spatial distribution of galaxies is similar to that of dark matter particles when the total number of galaxies is very high: The richer the cluster, the smaller is the luminous-dark matter segregation. Tidal stripping between massive dark halos of galaxies modi(cid:12)es somewhat the dynamical evolution of clusters. However, (cid:12)nal distributions for a large range of the halo radius show galaxies more clustered than dark matter particles. Consequently, even though some particular young and very rich clusters could have little segregation, we conclude that this e(cid:11)ect cannot be globally avoided in any hierarchical clustering scenario. Observational evidences for such a segregation are rather uncertain giving contra- dictory results for or against such an e(cid:11)ect. The dark matter density pro(cid:12)les obtained from X-ray observations show a tendency to be more centrally condensed than those of galaxies (Eyles et al. ; Buote & Canizares ; Gerbal et al. ; Watt et al. ), which is contrary to that predicted by the e(cid:11)ect analyzed in this paper. In the opposite, there is an observed tendency of increasing the mass-to-light ratio with system size (Ho(cid:11)man et al.) These last authors suggested that some segre- gation induced by dynamical friction could explain this observational tendency. Our numerical results agree in fact with those observations. In any case, all the above observational results have their own set of assumptions, di(cid:14)culties and uncertainties and none of them can be taken at present as a conclu- sive proof for or against such way of segregation, that is, for or against hierarchical clustering scenarios. However if such a segregation is present in real clusters, all ob- servational analyses assuming that galaxies in clusters trace mass are misleading and their conclusions have to be reconsidered (Serna & Alimi ). Acknowledgments. We thank D. Gerbal and M. J. West for useful discussions. We are specially in- debted to S. D. M. White for several suggestions on this paper. A.S. thanks the Ministere de l'Education Nationale, France, for a post-doctoral fellowship. The com- putations were carried out on the CM- of the Institute du Physique du Globe (IPG), Paris. References. { Aarseth, S. J., & and Saslaw, W. C. , ApJ , . Aguilar, L. A., & and White, S. D. M. , ApJ , . {{ Alimi, J. M., & Scholl, H. , Int. J. Mod. Phys. C. , . { Bailey, M. E. , MNRAS , . { Barnes, J. , MNRAS , . { Barnes, J. , MNRAS , . { Bertschinger, E. , ApJS , { Binney, J., & Tremaine, S. , Galactic Dynamics (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press). { Buote, D. A., & Canizares, C. R. , ApJ , . { Cavaliere, A., Santangelo, P., Tarquini, G., & Vittorio, N. , ApJ , . { Chandrasekhar, S. , ApJ , . { Cohen, R. S., Spitzer, L., & Routly, P. , Phys. Rev. , . { Cowie, L. L., Henriksen, M., & Mushotsky, R. , ApJ , . { Dekel, A., Lecar, M., & Shaham, J. , ApJ , . { Evrard, A. E. , ApJ , . { Evrard, A. E. , ApJ , . { Eyles, C. J., Watt, M. P., Bertram, D., Church, M. J., Ponman, T. J., Skinner, G. K., & Willmore, A. P. , ApJ , . { Farouki, R. T., Ho(cid:11)man, G. L., & Salpeter, E. E. , ApJ , . { Farouki, R. T., & Salpeter, E. E. , ApJ , . { Fillmore, J. A., & Golddreich, P. , ApJ , . { Gerbal, D., Durret, F., Lachieze-Rey, M., & Lima-Nieto, G. , A&A , . { Gnedin, N. Y., & Ostriker, J. P. , ApJ , . { Gott, J. R. , ApJ , . { Gunn, J. E. , ApJ , . { Gunn, J. E., & Gott, J. R. , ApJ , . { Hillis, W. D., & Barnes, J. , Nature , . { Ho(cid:11)man, Y., Shaham, J., & Shaviv, G. , ApJ , . { Lacey, C. G., & Ostriker, J. P. , ApJ , . { Limber, D. N. , ApJ , . { Lynden-Bell, D. , MNRAS , { Mamon, G. A. & Gerbal, D. , Proceedings of Second DAEC Meeting, The Distribution of Matter in the Universe (Observatoire de Paris). { Merrit, D. , ApJ , . { Merrit, D. , ApJ , . { Merrit, D. , ApJ , . { Navarro, J. F., Garc(cid:19)(cid:16)a-Lambas, D., & S(cid:19)ersic, J. L. , Ap&SS , . { Peebles, P. J. E. , The Large-Scale Structure of the Universe (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press). { Richstone, D. O. , ApJ , . { Richstone, D. O. , ApJ , . { Richstone, D. O. , in Clusters of Galaxies, ed. W. R. Oegerle, M. J. Fitchett & L. Danly (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press). { Roos, N., & Aarseth, S. J. , A&A , . { Roos, N., & Norman, G. A. , A&A , . { Serna, A., & Alimi, J.-M. in preparation. { Smith, H. , ApJ , . { Smith, H. , ApJ , . { Smith, H., Hintzen, P., Holman, G., Oegerle, W., Scott, J., & So(cid:12)a, S. , ApJ , L . { The, L. S., & White, S. D. M. , A. J., , . { The, L. S., & White, S. D. M. , A. J., , . { Turner, M. S. , in Dark Matter in the Universe, ed. S. M. Fall & D. Lynden- Bell (Dordrecht, Reidel). { Valtonen, M. J., Innanen, K. A., Huang, T. Y., & Saarinen, S. , Astr. Ap. , . { Wambsganss, J., & Paczynski, B. , ApJ , L. { Watt, M. P., Ponman, T. J., Bertram, D., Eyles, C. J., Skinner, G. K., & Willmore, A. P. , MNRAS , . { West, M. J. , in Clusters of Galaxies, ed. W. R. Oegerle, M. J. Fitchett & L. Danly (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press). { West, M. J., & Richstone, D. O. , ApJ , . { White, S. D. M. , MNRAS , . { White, S. D. M., & Zaritsky, D. , ApJ , . { White, S. D. M. , private communication. Figure Captions. Figure . Evolutionary stages for a typical particle system containing galaxies (big points) and a non-luminous component (small points) of total mass fraction (cid:17) = : . The isodensity contours represent the dark matter distribution at intervals of . times the mean non-luminous density. Figure . Time evolution of the harmonic mean separation of dark matter particles (solid curve) and galaxies (dashed curve) for simulation A. Figure . Evolutionary stages for a dark matter system. Figure . Time evolution of the harmonic mean separation for dark matter particles (solid curve) and for "galaxies" de(cid:12)ned as those particles placed at the deepest potential wells (dashed curve). a) Both particle species have equal individual masses, b) The m =m ratio is similar to that of simulation A.. g dm Figure . Time evolution of the harmonic mean separation of dark matter particles (solid curve) and galaxies (dashed curve) for a simulation where the expansion phase was canceled and particle positions were assigned at random. Figure . Evolutionary stages for a particle system containing galaxies (big points) placed on a grid and dark matter particles (small points) placed on a di(cid:11)erent grid. Figure . Time evolution of the harmonic mean separation of dark matter particles (solid curve) and galaxies (dashed curve) for two di(cid:11)erent grid simulations with a) all parti- cles placed on the same grid and b) each mass component on a di(cid:11)erent grid. Figure . Predicted (t =T ) at di(cid:11)erent times: t = (solid curve), t = (dashed curve) coll df coll coll and t = (dashed-dotted curve) as a function of a) the non-luminous mass fraction coll of the overall cluster, b) the expansion factor and c) the number of galaxies in a subcluster. Figure . Time evolution of R for both components in clusters with di(cid:11)erent mass fractions hm of dark matter: a) (cid:17) = :, b) (cid:17) = : . Figure . Time evolution of R for both components in clusters with di(cid:11)erent expansion hm factors: a) R =R ' and b) R =R ' . m in m in Figure . Time evolution of R for both components in clusters with di(cid:11)erent total numbers hm of galaxies: a) N = and b) N = . g g Figure . Evolutionary stages for a particle system containing galaxies with massive dark matter halos. The isodensity contours represent the dark matter distribution at intervals of times the mean non-luminous density. We represent in the left side, the simulation E (initial large halos), in the right side, the simulation E (initial smaller halos). Figure . Time evolution of R for both components in clusters with galaxies containing hm massive dark halos interacting inelastically (Simulation E). TABLE Summary of N-Body Experiments Run Positions N N R =R (cid:17) T g m in A Random . B Pot.Wells . B Pot.Wells . C Random . C Grid . C -Grids . D Random . D Random . D Random . D Random . D Random . D Random . E Large Halos . E Small Halos .
astro-ph/9506139	1	9506	1995-06-29T20:14:50	Multiwavelength Energy Distributions and Bolometric Luminosities of the 12--Micron Galaxy Sample	[ "astro-ph" ]	Aperture photometry from our own observations and the literature is presented for the 12\um\ Galaxies in the near infrared J, H and K bands and, in some cases, in the L band. These data are corrected to ``total'' near--infrared magnitudes, (with a typical uncertainty of 0.3 magnitudes) for a direct comparison with our IRAS fluxes which apply to the entire galaxy. The corrected data are used to derive integrated total NIR and FIR luminosities. We then combine these with blue photometry and an estimate of the flux contribution from cold dust at wavelengths longward of 100\um\ to derive the first {\it bolometric\/} luminosities for a large sample of galaxies. We use multiwavelength correlations to identify several combinations of infrared colors which discriminate between Seyfert~1 and~2 galaxies, LINERs, and ultraluminous starbursts. We find that bolometric luminosity is more closely proportional to 12-micron luminosity than to 60-micron, 25-micron or optical luminosity.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Multiwavelength Energy Distributions and Bolometric Luminosities of the 12 -- Micron Galaxy Sample1,2 Luigi Spinoglio Istituto di Fisica dello Spazio Interplanetario, CNR CP 27 00044 Frascati, Italy Electronic Mail: [email protected] Matthew A. Malkan, Brian Rush Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California at Los Angeles Electronic Mail: [email protected]; [email protected] Los Angeles, CA 90024 -- 1562 Luis Carrasco3, Elsa Recillas -- Cruz3 Instituto Nacional de Astrof´ısica, Optica y Electr´onica, Apartado Postal 51, Puebla, Pue., M´exico, CP 72000 Electronic Mail: [email protected]; [email protected] ABSTRACT Aperture photometry from our own observations and the literature is presented for the 12 µm Galaxies in the near infrared J, H and K bands and, in some cases, in the L band. These data are corrected to "total" near -- infrared magnitudes, (with a typical uncertainty of 0.3 magnitudes) for a direct comparison with our IRAS fluxes which apply to the entire galaxy. The corrected data are used to derive integrated total NIR and FIR luminosities. We then combine these with blue photometry and an estimate of the flux contribution from cold dust at wavelengths longward of 100 µm to derive the first bolometric luminosities for a large sample of galaxies. The presence of nonstellar radiation at 2 -- 3 µm correlates very well with nonstellar IRAS colors. This enables us to identify a universal Seyfert nuclear continuum from near -- to far -- infrared wavelengths. Thus there is a sequence of infrared colors which runs from a pure "normal galaxy" to a pure Seyfert/quasar nucleus. Seyfert 2 galaxies fall close to this same sequence, although only a few extreme narrow -- line Seyferts have quasar -- like colors, and these show strong evidence of harboring an obscured Broad Line Region. A corollary is that the host galaxies of Seyfert nuclei have normal near -- to 1This paper has been accepted for publication in the 1995 November 10 issue of ApJ. 2The three data tables mentioned in this paper (which do not appear in this preprint) can be accessed via anonymous ftp at eggneb.astro.ucla.edu in the /pub/rush directory. These ASCII files are named Spinoglio95-Table{1,2,3}.dat. These data tables will also be included in the AAS CD -- ROM Series "Astrophysics on Disc", Volume V, 1995. 3On sabbatical leave from UNAM, M´exico 1 far -- infrared spectra on average. Starburst galaxies lie significantly off the sequence, having a relative excess of 60 µm emission probably due to stochastically -- heated dust grains. We use these correlations to identify several combinations of infrared colors which discriminate between Seyfert 1 and 2 galaxies, LINERs, and ultraluminous starbursts. In the infrared, Seyfert 2 galaxies are much more like Seyfert 1's than they are like starbursts, presumably because both kinds of Seyferts are heated by a single central source, rather than a distributed region of star formation. Moreover, combining the [25 -- 2.2 µm] color the [60 -- 12 µm] color, it appears that Seyfert 1 galaxies are segregated from Seyfert 2s and starburst galaxies in a well-defined region characterized by the hottest colors, corresponding to the flattest spectral slopes. Virtually no Seyfert 2 galaxy is present in such a region. To reconcile this with the "Unified Scheme" for Seyfert 1s and 2s would therefore require that the higher frequency radiation from the nuclei of Seyfert 2s to be absorbed by intervening dust and re -- emitted at lower frequencies. We find that bolometric luminosity is most closely proportional to 12 µm luminosity. The 60 and 25 µm luminosities rise faster than linearly with bolometric luminosity, while the optical flux rises less than linearly with bolometric luminosity. This result is a confirmation of the observation that more luminous disk galaxies have relatively more dust -- enshrouded stars. Increases in the dust content shifts luminosity from the optical to 25 -- 60 µm, while leaving a "pivot point" in the mid -- IR essentially unchanged. Thus 12 µm selection is the closest available approximation to selection by a limiting bolometric -- flux, which is approximately 14 times νLν at 12 µm for non -- Seyfert galaxies. It follows that future deep surveys in the mid -- infrared, at wavelengths of 8 to 12 µm, will simultaneously provide complete samples to different bolometric flux levels of normal and active galaxies, which will not suffer the strong selection effects present both in the optical -- UV and far -- infrared. Subject headings: Galaxies: Nuclei -- Galaxies: Active -- Galaxies: Photometry -- Galaxies: Seyfert -- Galaxies: Starburst -- Infrared: Galaxies 2 1. INTRODUCTION In Spinoglio & Malkan (1989 -- SM hereafter), we showed that the 12 µm flux is approximately a con- stant fraction of the bolometric flux in active galactic nuclei (AGNs) of all types (e.g., Quasar/Seyfert 1, Seyfert 2, Blazar). We therefore used the IRAS sky survey to select an all -- sky (b ≥ 25◦) sample of galax- ies to a limiting 12 µm flux, thereby providing an un- biased sample of AGNs. Recently, we used the IRAS Faint Source Survey data (Moshir et al. 1991) to extend this work to a fainter 12 µm flux limit, of 0.22 Janskys. Our resulting extended sample includes 893 galaxies, 120 of which are known to have Seyfert 1 or 2 nuclei (Rush, Malkan, & Spinoglio 1993 -- RMS hereafter). Note that the constant ratio of 12 µm to bolometric flux was shown to apply to measurements dominated by the active nucleus. The IRAS 12 µm se- lection is highly effective at discovering Seyfert galax- ies because their hot nuclei usually dominate their total 12 µm fluxes. (This was verified by comparison with small -- beam 10.5 µm measurements in Edelson, Malkan, & Rieke 1987 -- EMR hereafter). Until the present paper, however, multiwavelength determina- tions of the bolometric flux for a significant sample of normal (non -- Seyfert) galaxies as a whole were not available. The mid -- to -- far -- infrared emission by which we se- lected these galaxies arises from dust grains which absorb short -- wavelength energy and thermally re -- radiate it. In a more intense radiation field, the grains will have higher equilibrium temperatures, and will tend to emit more at shorter infrared wavelengths. For many of the 12 µm selected galaxies, which are to some extent selected to have "hot" IRAS colors, much of the IRAS emission, especially at 12 and 25 µm is ul- timately powered by luminous young stars, which are still embedded in the dust clouds out of which they recently formed. And of course in the case of AGNs, there is an additional source of mid -- infrared flux pow- ered by the nonstellar nucleus. Thus the IRAS fluxes, especially at 12 and 25 µm provide a measure of what is unusual about these galaxies. To better understand these galaxies, we also need quantitative information about their more normal attributes. In particular, it is very helpful to have good measures of the un- derlying stellar population which are relatively inde- pendent of the presence of: a) recent bursts of star formation; and b) internal absorption by dust. It is well known that these requirements are best met by observations in the near -- infrared wavelengths. The light of normal galaxies in the standard photometric bands J[1.2 µm], H[1.6 µm], and usually K[2.2 µm] is dominated by red giants in the quiescent (old) stel- lar population, which is most closely tied to the total mass of the galaxy (Recillas -- Cruz et al. 1990, 1991). Thus the intrinsic JHK colors of most galaxies are confined to a relatively narrow range (Frogel et al. 1978). Since the extinction in the near -- infrared is much lower than that in the visual, only a small frac- tion of galaxies are dusty enough so that their near -- IR colors are detectably altered by reddening. In some galaxies with exceptionally strong starbursts, or an AGN, a measurable "excess" above this stellar pho- tospheric emission is detectable at 2.2 µm, and more easily at 3.5 µm. We detect both effects in the obser- vations presented below. This paper presents the results of an extended observing campaign in which we obtained accurate near -- infrared aperture photometry for the 12 µm Galaxies (§ 2.). We then use these to derive colors and total near -- infrared luminosities, for comparison with their IRAS and other properties (§ 3. and 4.). We compute the bolometric luminosities for a large sam- ple of normal and Seyfert galaxies (§ 5.) and present and discuss their normalized spectral energy distribu- tions (§ 6.). Finally, we give our conclusions (§ 7.). 2. OBSERVATIONS We have collected J, H, K, and in some cases L, photometry on 321 galaxies during eleven photomet- ric observing runs. Most of the data for northern galaxies were obtained with the 2.1 m reflector at the San Pedro Martir Observatory (hereinafter SPM; Baja California, M´exico), and for the southern galax- ies with the 1.0 m reflector at the European South- ern Observatory (ESO), both equipped with stan- dard InSb photometers. Some of the seyfert galax- ies observed at SPM, had been included in a sam- ple for variability studies of AGN's by Carrasco & Cruz -- Gonzalez (1995). Additional photometry for a few galaxies was also collected in May 1981 on the Mount Wilson 60 -- and 100 -- inch telescopes and dur- ing March -- April 1984. Eight to ten standard stars were observed on each night, with the scatter about the derived photometric zero points, after correction for airmass, being typically 0.01 to 0.02 magnitudes. The galaxies were observed with variable integra- tion times that yielded maximum internal errors of 3 0.008 magnitudes. Although, the uncertainties in our galaxy photometry are usually dominated by the ac- curacy with which the signal could be "peaked -- up" on the strip chart, this procedure was repeatable. Hence we feel confident that the typical errors obtained for the set of standard stars are representative of the ones expected for the galaxy sample. Standard stellar mag- nitudes, on the Caltech and ESO systems, were taken from Elias et al. (1982) and from Bouchet, Schmider, & Manfroid (1991), respectively. In Table 14,5 we present the results, in flux den- sities (mJy), using the absolute calibrations of the SPM (Carrasco et al. 1991) and the ESO (Bersanelli, Bouchet, & Falomo 1991) photometric systems. The first column gives the galaxy name; the second gives its equatorial coordinates from the IRAS Faint Source Catalog (B1950.0); the third through sixth columns give the J, H, K and L flux densities (where available); the seventh column lists the diameter of the aperture used; the eighth one the telescope and observing date and the ninth the object class. In our analysis below, we have included published J, H, K and L photometry from a large number of papers, all of which are summarized in the recently updated "Catalog of Infrared Observations" (Gezari et al. 1993). This adds 399 observations of 215 ob- jects, bringing our database to a total sample of 483 galaxies for which we have complete J, H and K pho- tometry. Fortunately, this includes virtually complete data for the Seyfert galaxies, which were the primary motivation for constructing the 12 µm Sample. Some of the galaxies were also measured with sim- ilar apertures by previous investigators (e.g. Rudy, Levan & Rodriguez -- Espinosa 1982; Balzano & Weed- man 1981). The typical agreement in magnitudes is 0.07 mag rms, and the agreement on infrared colors is even better (1σ=0.04 mag), since several systematic sources of error cancel out. 4The three tables referenced herein do not appear in print in this paper, but in the AAS CD -- ROM Series "Astrophysics on Disc", Volume V, 1995. 5During the infrared observing runs for this project, 14 galaxies were measured which were not included in the final 12 µm Sample (for various reasons; see discussion in RMS). The data for these objects are given in Table 2, which is constructed in the same manner as Table 1. 3. APERTURE CORRECTIONS: CALCU- LATION OF H−0.5 AND TOTAL MAG- NITUDES RMS made a special effort to estimate the total far -- infrared fluxes (representing the full spatial ex- tent) for each of the 12 µm galaxies. This extra work, not undertaken in most other studies, was required so that valid flux comparisons could be made between distant and nearby galaxies. Calculations of quan- tities such as luminosity functions require that our measurement of a given galaxy's flux should not de- pend on whether or not it happens to be resolved by the IRAS beams. Our reported IRAS fluxes thus give good measures of the far -- infrared light of the entire galaxy. In this paper we compare these with ground -- based photometry of the total light from the under- lying stellar population, as measured in the near -- infrared. Unfortunately there are virtually no direct measurements of the total near -- IR fluxes of nearby galaxies. Instrumental limitations and sky noise dic- tate that the J, H and K band measurements were made through circular apertures (6 -- 30 arcseconds) much smaller than the effective IRAS beams. To al- low a direct comparison of the near -- and far -- infrared fluxes we applied aperture corrections to transform the former into total magnitudes. The procedure was straightforward for each of the 274 galaxies which has a value of Aef f listed in the Third Reference Catalog of Galaxies (De Vaucouleurs et al. 1991 -- RC3 hereafter) This "effective" aper- ture, which includes one -- half the total flux from the galaxy -- is available for (∼53%) of our sample galax- ies with NIR photometry. We used the RC3 growth curves, (given in their Table 11), to extrapolate from the largest aperture used to the total flux. By com- paring the growth curves in RC3 with the observed fluxes in different apertures, we obtained the best re- sult when we adopted the growth curve for the NIR fluxes a curve corresponding to 3 morphological types earlier than the type listed in RC3. Evidently the near -- infrared continuum for a galaxy of given mor- phological type in our sample is slightly more concen- trated than the standard RC3 aperture growth curves would predict. For galaxies with Aef f but no RC3 morphological type, we assumed an early -- type spiral, and in fact the differences in the growth curves over the range considered are subtle. The total corrections ranged from 1 to 3 magnitudes. If they would have exceeded 4 magnitudes, we consider the uncertainty 4 too great to use this procedure, and we thus used the following method. For about 391 (∼81%) galaxies of our sample (in- cluding all of those for which the RC3 gives an Aef f ), the RC3 also gives a corrected isophotal diameter, D0, defined at an isophote of 25.0 blue magnitudes per square arcsec. For these galaxies, we correct the observed H magnitudes to a standard aperture, log(A/D0) = −0.5, as is often done to obtain a char- acteristic measure of most of a galaxy's luminosity. These are the galaxy magnitudes used, for example, in the near -- infrared Tully -- Fisher method (Aaron- son, Huchra, & Mould 1979 -- AHM hereafter). We have fitted a straight line to the average NIR mag- nitude growth -- curve of AHM for early -- type spirals: ∆m = mobs − m−0.5 = −1.02 − 2.03 × log(A/D0) for Sa's. For a typical value of log(A/D0) = −0.90 , the (negative) correction to the observed magnitude was on average 0.81 mag. To correct these to "total" val- ues, we examined the correlation between the −0.5 magnitudes and the total magnitudes derived for the 274 Aef f galaxies discussed above. We found that the total magnitudes were on average 0.9 mag. brighter, with an rms scatter of 0.35 mags. We therefore sub- tracted 0.9 mag from the −0.5 magnitudes. The re- sulting total magnitudes are not more accurate than 0.35 mag. (1 σ). Several dozen galaxies have multi -- aperture pho- tometry which allows us to intercompare our esti- mates of total infrared magnitudes6. The total mag- nitude estimated from the smaller aperture is not on average different from that estimated using the larger observed aperture, and the random scatter among 30 pairs of measurements is ± 0.25 magnitudes (1 σ). This scatter is partly a measure of the consis- tency of our various sets of multiaperture photom- etry, and partly a measure of the adequacy of our assumption that the RC3 growth curves apply to the near -- infrared fluxes of these galaxies. About the same scatter was found in comparisons of 60 −0.5 magni- tudes calculated with the AHM D(0) technique. For the Seyfert 2 galaxies, we derived total mag- nitudes by using the same extrapolation as for nor- mal galaxies, but only when measured fluxes were available in large enough apertures that the nuclear 6Each observing aperture for a given galaxy, when extrapolated with the RC3 or AHM growth curves, gives an independent estimate of its total magnitude which, in the absence of errors, should agree with each other. component of the galaxy were no longer affecting the shape of the growth curve as compared to a normal galaxy. We tested this method by comparing growth curves for several Seyfert 2s (for which data were available spanning a wide range of apertures) to the growth curves from RC3 and found that they were fit- ting well outside the nuclear region, which is typically 10 -- 20 arcseconds. We did not follow this procedure for the Seyfert 1 galaxies, since their near -- IR light is much more strongly centrally concentrated than any of the normal galaxy Instead we used the galaxy/nucleus growth curves. decompositions presented by Danese et al. (1992) and Kotilainen et al. (1992), and summed up the two components to measure the near -- IR luminosity. For the 13 Seyfert 1 galaxies in common with the study of Danese et al., we added their estimated "galaxy" and "nucleus" fluxes to obtain the total flux at 1.2, 1.6, and 2.2 µm. In particular, for Mkn 975, Mkn 9, Mkn 704, Mkn 509, Mkn 530 and MCG+1 -- 57 -- 16 (2237+07), we have taken the nuclear and galactic magnitudes as given by them, while for Mkn 335, I Zw 1, Mkn 618, Mkn 79, Mkn 766, NGC 5548 and Mkn 817, we have taken the nuclear magnitudes and the K galactic magnitude that they give and assumed their average (J − K)G = 1.13 and (H − K)G = 0.45 to derive galactic J and H magnitudes. We have 16 Seyfert 1 galaxies in common with the study of hard X -- ray selected galaxies of Kotilainen et al. (1992). Two of these are also in the list of Danese et al. (1992) (NGC 5548 and Mkn 509), and we adopted their estimates. For the 14 remaining galaxies we have used the J and K absolute magni- tudes of Kotilainen & Ward (1994) for both galaxy and nucleus, and converted into flux densities at earth using their quoted redshifts, H0 and calibration (Wil- son et al. 1972). For the H band fluxes, we adopted the values of non -- stellar fluxes given by Kotilainen et al. (1992) for the nuclear component, while for the galactic component, we used the colors in an annulus around the nucleus (from their Table 2) to scale the galactic colors7. The computed total fluxes in the J, H and K wavebands are listed in Table 3, together with the [J -- H], [H -- K] and [K -- L] colors in the smallest aper- ture available and the derived near -- infrared, far -- infrared and bolometric luminosities. We assumed 7Using (J − H)G = (J − K)G/(J − K)A × (J − H)A, where subscript G is for "galaxy" and subscript A for "annulus" 5 Ho = 75 km s−1M pc−1. The K correction (gener- ally very small) and the corrections of the observed redshift are described in RMS. The near -- infrared lu- minosity is derived from direct integration assuming power -- law interpolations between 1.2, 1.6, and 2.2 µm. Similarly, the far -- infrared luminosity is derived by trapezoid -- rule integrations of the IRAS fluxes. In most of these 12 µm galaxies the tabulated bolo- metric (0.4 -- 300 µm) luminosity has been computed by combining the total blue magnitude B0(T ), taken from the RC3, the corrected JHK photometry and the IRAS fluxes. To account for the mid -- infrared and submillimeter contributions, we used the L band flux8 and we extrapolated the 60 µm and 100 µm IRAS fluxes with grey body emission9, respectively. For most galaxies the calculated bolometric luminos- ity is 98% or more of the total luminosity we would have measured from complete multiwavelength cov- erage (since, the UV flux drops rapidly beyond the Ca II HK break, as shown, for example, in Malkan & Oke's (1983) "STDGAL" spectral energy distribu- tion). However for the Seyfert galaxies, both UV and X -- rays can significantly contribute to their bolomet- ric luminosities. Therefore we have included a crude power -- law interpolation between the B band (4400A), the 1330A band as measured by the IUE SWP (Edel- son et al. 1995) and the soft X -- ray band at 1 KeV as measured by the ROSAT All Sky Survey (Rush et al. 1996a; details of these data will be presented in Rush, Malkan, & Spinoglio 1996b). For most of the Seyfert 2s, UV and X -- ray detections were not available. Fortunately, we have verified that in those which the UV and X -- ray emission is detected, it adds only about 3% percent to the 0.4 -- 300 µm luminos- ity. This justifies our decision to ignore the UV and X -- ray wavebands in the calculation of all Seyfert 2, LINER and starburst bolometric luminosities. 4. ANALYSIS: CORRELATIONS OF COL- ORS 4.1. Near Infrared Colors Figure 1a shows the [J -- H] vs. [H -- K] two -- color diagram for all available measurements (483) of the 12 µm Sample of Galaxies. In all of the diagrams filled 8If the L band flux was not measured, we estimated it from the correlation of [K -- L] with [H -- K] color, as discussed in Ap- pendix A.. 9We refer to Appendix B. for the details of this computation. squares represent Seyfert 1 galaxies, open squares Seyfert 2 galaxies, asterisks high IR -- luminosity non -- Seyfert galaxies which we refer as to "starburst galax- ies" (see the discussion in RMS), open circles "LIN- ERs" (Low Ionization Nuclear Emission Region galax- ies; Heckman 1980) and diagonal crosses represent "normal" (i.e., all other) galaxies. In this and follow- ing diagrams, when a near -- IR color is plotted (i.e., and combination of J, H, K or L magnitudes), the data -- referred to simply as "nuclear" -- refer to the smallest aperture available, since this is usually the one with the best L magnitude coverage (due to the lower sky noise). The smaller aperture accentuates the difference between galaxies with and without ac- tive nuclei. In the near -- infrared color/color diagrams, vectors show the effects of 1 and 5 magnitudes of vi- sual extinction. This is for an external screen obeying a standard interstellar reddening law (Rieke & Lebof- sky 1985). In reality the dust and starlight are prob- ably intermixed, resulting in higher reddening being inferred at longer wavelengths. The region of "normal galaxy colors" is indicated in Figure 1a with a circle whose radius is equal to 2σ, centered on the average colors of <J -- H> = 0.77±0.008 and <H -- K> = 0.34±0.007 (uncertainties represent the standard deviation of the mean; the 1σ scatter in individual data points are 0.12 and 0.15, re- spectively; in fact an ellipse would be somewhat more appropriate due to the positive correlation between these two colors). These values are redder than the average colors of normal galaxies measured by Frogel et al. (1978) and Recillas -- Cruz et al. (1990, 1991), of <J -- H> = 0.72 and <H -- K> = 0.22. Although the effect is subtle and the scatter is large, the incon- sistency is that there is about 12% excess K flux in our sample compared to the others. These "2.2 µm excesses" may be attributable to thermal emission from extremely hot dust, presumably in actively star -- forming regions (since our galaxies have higher SFRs than other "normals" on average; as, for example, Joseph et al. (1984) found K -- excesses in starburst galaxies), as well as a possible contribution from red supergiants. Nonetheless, within our sample, most (90%) of the non -- Seyferts lie within the "normal" cir- cled region. A small number of the non -- Seyferts are substantially redder in [H -- K] and [J -- H], and appear to lie along the reddening vector shown in the lower right corner. Thus these galaxies could have intrinsi- cally "normal" colors, with the addition of large line -- of -- sight extinctions (of typically 3 -- 5 magnitudes in 6 AV ). Only about 10 of the non -- Seyferts fall signif- icantly to the right of the normal -- galaxy region, in- dicating that very few normal galaxies have strong 2.2 µm excesses (again, probably due to hot dust or red supergiants), and about half of these have high infrared luminosities. One galaxy only, NGC 3353 (= Mkn 35), has a [J -- H] color which is much bluer than the average (see Figure 1a) . This is one of the bluer members of the class of compact dwarf galaxies already known to have abnormally blue colors in the NIR (Thuan 1983). The Seyfert nuclei cannot be distinguished from the non -- Seyferts in [J -- H], but they tend to be much redder in [H -- K]. As is well known, this is because the red giant spectra in normal galaxies have rising flux densities from 1.2 to 1.6 µm, and then falling fluxes from 1.6 to 2.2 µm. The Seyfert nuclear con- tinuum has a flux density which rises monotonically from 1.2 to 1.6 to 2.2 to 3 µm, and therefore stands out better at longer wavelengths. Most (∼ 73%) of the Seyfert 1's and nearly half of both the Seyfert 2s (∼ 41%) and the starburst galaxies (∼ 44%) lie outside the 2σ circle defined by the normal galaxies and have significantly non -- stellar [J -- K] colors in small aper- tures. In agreement with Cruz -- Gonzalez (1984), the Seyfert 1s lie somewhere along the track which shows a mixture of normal starlight plus varying propor- tions of "quasar light". The redder Seyfert 1 nuclei in this and other color diagrams are very similar to the 9 brightest PG quasars (Edelson 1986), whose aver- age infrared colors (<J -- H> = 0.85 ± 0.14 <H -- K> = 0.98 ± 0.31 <K -- L> = 1.59 ± 0.18; Neugebauer et al. 1987) are indicated by the cross. These are in turn very similar to the average zero -- redshift quasar colors from Hyland & Allen (1982) of: <J -- H> = 0.95 <H -- K> = 1.15. As expected the published estimates of pure normal galaxy colors and pure quasar colors are very consistent with the two extremes of the IR color sequence in Figure 1a. The nuclear component we identified in Seyfert 1's -- pure "quasar light" has a flux at 60 µm only slightly higher than at 25 µm. We believe that the nuclei most if not all Seyfert 1s and quasars have a peak in their flux density at a wavelength of 30 -- 50 µm. In other words, pure quasar light has a peak energy output, in ν × fν, at wavelengths of 15 -- 20 µm. In the less luminous Seyfert 1s the observed flux at 60 µm has a substantial contribution from the host galaxy. Since the active nucleus produces very little 100 µm emis- sion, observations at that wavelength instead measure 7 the host galaxy. An even more sensitive measure of excess infrared flux over that expected from red giant photospheres is found in the [H -- K] vs [K -- L] diagram of Figure 1b, although fewer measurements are available (123), es- pecially for non -- Seyferts (only 36 normal galaxies). The average colors for normal galaxies (given with 1σ individual scatter) are: <H -- K> = 0.34 ± 0.12 (as mentioned above), and <K -- L> = 0.75±0.64, the lat- ter having the much larger scatter. Only one normal galaxy (NGC 5253) (see Figure 1b), lies close to the region defined by the PG quasars. The average colors of the 39 Seyfert 1's are <H -- K> = 0.84 ± 0.33 and <K -- L> = 1.31 ± 0.49; for the 24 Seyfert 2's they are <H -- K> = 0.61±0.37 and <K -- L> = 01.05±0.59; for the 8 starburst galaxies they are <H -- K> = 0.58±0.13 and <K -- L> = 1.09 ± 0.30; for the 17 LINERs they are <H -- K> = 0.32 ± 0.11 and <K -- L> = 0.38 ± 0.30. 4.2. Combined Near Infrared and IRAS Col- ors The IRAS and near -- infrared wavebands can be combined to separate the different galaxy classes. The ratio between the 25 µm flux and the K band flux (hereafter referred to as the [25 -- K] color) plotted against the [60 -- 25] color has already been shown to discriminate well between Seyfert 1s and Seyfert 2s (EM, EMR). We show this in Figure 2a for our sam- ple. The [25 -- K] color alone is evidently one of the best discriminators of Seyfert 1 and Seyfert 2 galax- ies. As noted by EM and EMR, the Seyfert 2 mid -- infrared slopes are systematically steeper by about 0.5 than the Seyfert 1s and quasars. Interestingly, the two luminous "Seyfert 1" galaxies with the most un- usual colors (steep 2 -- 25 µm slope but flat 25 -- 60 µm slope) are both powerful radiogalaxies: 3C 234 and 3C 445. It is also evident in Figure 2a that the star- burst galaxies tend to have steeper 2 -- 25 µm slopes than normal galaxies. Similar useful results are obtained with the [25 -- K] vs. [H -- K] two -- color diagram (Figure 2b). Here Seyfert galaxies are well separated from LINERs and that the high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts are also well separated from LINERs, although they overlap with the Seyferts having the smallest [H -- K] colors. Again the starburst galaxies are redder in H -- K than normal galaxies, and show some overlap with the Seyfert 2s but not the Seyfert 1s. One of the sharpest separations in all of these dia- grams is between the colors of "LINERs" and those of the ultraluminous IRAS galaxies (our "starbursts"). In virtually all cases, the LINERs lie within the range of colors defined by "normal" galaxies, concentrated to the weakest far -- IR fluxes. In contrast many of the starbursts have significant excesses in the mid -- infrared (in fact, from 2.2 up to 25 µm). This is strong prima facia evidence against the notion that LINERs harbor any unusual current star formation. If a recent burst of star formation were to explain the character- istic LINER emission line spectra, it would at have to be very different from those studied previously. The energy from this activity would at the least have to be hidden at mid -- IR wavelengths. There is no evidence for abnormal emission at any infrared wavelength in the LINERs in our sample. The extreme colors of the starbursts could be understood if the 3.5 µm, 25 µm, and 60 µm emission in those objects is affected by emission of small stochastically -- heated dust grains, as found in the Orion Complex by Bally, Langer, & Liu (1991) and Wall et al. (1995). The combination of IRAS and near -- infrared col- ors also defines a clear sequence from normal galaxies and active ones. The [60 -- 25] color versus the [H -- L] is shown in Figure 3. In the upper left of this dia- gram, normal galaxies and LINERs define a locus of low nuclear activity. A few Seyferts and the high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts also lie in this region. How- ever, the Seyfert galaxies (both types) also extend to the lower right part of the diagram, where no normal galaxy is located, defining a region of high nuclear ac- tivity. Thus the steep far -- IR slopes of normal galaxies and high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts correspond to the bluer near -- infrared spectra, while the flatter far -- IR active galaxies have redder near -- IR slopes. As we will discuss in a future paper (Rush et al. 1996b), this infrared trend to more dominant Seyfert activ- ity is mirrored in several optical observables which shift systematically as the galaxy is found closer to the lower right corner of the figure. The least squares line between all data points also fits the Seyfert galax- ies alone with similar regression coefficients (R= 0.67 for all galaxies, R= 0.64 for all Seyferts). This line, fitting all the data points, happens to connect the av- erage colors of normal galaxies (at the upper left cor- ner of the figure) exactly to the average color of the 9 brightest PG quasars selected by Edelson (1986). The high luminosity non -- Seyferts, as can be seen from their average colors, are significantly off the best fit- ting line, having an excess in the 60 µm emission. It follows that the infrared energy distributions of these ultraluminous IRAS galaxies, which do not harbour a "classical" Seyfert nucleus, cannot be explained by the combination of a quasar plus a galactic compo- nent which fits the Seyfert galaxies. It is not surprising that the only Seyferts classified as "Type 2" in the lower right portion of the diagram (near the realm of "pure quasar light") are the most extreme members of this class: Mkn 348 and 463, NGC 1068 and 5506, FSC 00521 -- 70 and Tololo 109. In fact spectropolarimetry, infrared and/or X -- ray spectroscopy has indicated that most of these AGNs harbor an obscured Seyfert 1 nucleus. This is consis- tent with our conclusion from Figure 3 that these are best described as reddened Seyfert 1 galaxies. The fact that most Seyfert 1s are located in the lower right part of the diagram while most Seyfert 2s are displaced in the upper left corner, where only a few Seyfert 1s are found (as well as most Messier galaxies classified as Seyfert 1s or 2s by V`eron -- Cetty & V`eron (1991) -- see RMS), shows that the energy distributions of the two Seyfert classes are different: the Seyfert 1s are steeper in the near -- infrared and flatter in the IRAS wavebands, while the Seyfert 2s behave in the opposite way. The mid -- infrared wave- lengths, from 3.6 to 12 µm, are depressed for the "Type 2" galaxies and enhanced for the "Type 1" galaxies. It can very well be that the hot nuclear continuum of Seyfert 1s is either non -- existent in Seyfert 2s (if the latter have physically different nu- clei compared to Seyfert 1s), or it is blocked by cir- cumnuclear material, as hypothesized in a popular version of the unified model. The mid -- infrared flux of the Seyfert 2s would therefore be due partly to the galactic component, plus -- in some cases such as NGC 1068 -- a starburst component which steepens both the [H -- L] and [60 -- 25] colors. These results are in agreement with those of Maiolino et al. (1995), who find that the nuclear 10 µm luminosity of Broad Line Seyfert galaxies, i.e. "Type 1" galaxies, is sys- tematically larger than that of those Seyferts without a BLR, i.e. "Type 2" galaxies; and that the host galaxies of Seyfert 2 nuclei tend to have a higher star formation rate than the host galaxies of Seyfert 1s (this is discussed in more depth in Appendix C.). The effect of adding a strong starburst component is to increase the H -- L color without much altering the 60/25 µm flux ratio (i.e., corresponding to a horizon- tal translation to the right in Figure 3). The classical Seyfert galaxies which show this effect most strongly 8 (Mkn 231, Mkn 273, NGC 1068, and NGC 7469) are already known to contain unusually powerful star- bursts. On the other hand, Arp 220 has too small (blue) an H -- L color to be consistent with a Seyfert 1 ("buried quasar") as the principal energy source. Figure 4a shows an even clearer separation between the Seyfert sequence and the starbursts. The former tend to have "hot" 12 -- 60 µm colors, while the lat- ter have steep 12 -- 60 µm slopes. This is because the starburst enhances both the 25 and 60 µm contin- uum, while the Seyfert nucleus enhances the 25, 12 and 3.5 µm emission. Also in this diagram the two objects Arp 220 and Mkn 273 have high 60 µm emis- sion relative to Seyfert galaxies and quasars. In principle, a good physical definition of a "star- burst" would be: a region where current rate of star formation substantially exceeds the rate averaged over its past history. However, translating this into di- rect quantitative observational terms has proven dif- ficult. We have therefore simplistically and arbitrar- ily designated all galaxies with infrared luminosities above 1.5 × 1011L⊙ as "starbursts". We find that these galaxies have colors which differ systematically from those of the "normal" galaxies. Nonetheless, the "starbursts" appear to be simply the extreme tail of the distribution of normal galaxies. The starbursts have the largest relative proportions of young stars and warm dust, but there is no clear dividing line and no qualitative distinction. Figure 4b shows the [H -- K] color plotted versus bolometric luminosity. At the highest bolometric lu- minosities, there is a clear separation between the Seyferts and the high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts. In this diagram, like the two previous ones, Arp 220 appears as an extreme starburst galaxy, while the high-luminosity objects with dominant nuclear activ- ity have much redder [H -- K], like the PG quasars, which have [H -- K] = 0.98 (see Figure 4a) . The basic hypothesis of the "Unified Scheme" for Seyfert 1 and 2 nuclei is that these are intrinsically the same physical objects, except that the former are seen face -- on, while the latter are viewed closer to edge -- on. On this hypothesis, therefore, a sample of Seyfert 1's should not differ from a sample of Seyfert 2's in any emission which is isotropic, such as low -- frequency radio or [OII] 3727 line emission. Figure 5 shows the [25 -- K] versus [60 -- 12] color -- color diagram which includes Seyfert galaxies and high luminosity non -- Seyferts. This diagram, as already shown in EMR for the CfA Seyfert galaxies, segregates Seyfert 1s in 9 the lower left part of the diagram. Only 5 out of 52 Seyfert 2s lie in this region, three of which are close to the edge, while 30 out of 48 Seyfert 1s are inside this region. One version of the Unified Scheme could ex- plain this, if those objects with an edge -- on torus, the Seyfert 2s, have steeper infrared energy distributions. This would make both [60 -- 12] and [25 -- K] redder, be- cause the high frequency radiation is absorbed by the optically thick torus and re -- emitted at lower frequen- cies (Pier & Krolik 1993). Their best -- fit model to the small -- aperture photometry for NGC 1068 is also shown in this diagram, as are the average colors for normal galaxies in our sample and the colors of var- ious mixtures of the two (see figure). According to this scheme, our whole -- galaxy colors for NGC 1068 appear to have roughly a 30 -- 40% contribution from the galaxy at 12 µm. 5. ESTIMATING BOLOMETRIC LUMINOSI- TIES 5.1. Multiwavelength Properties and Twelve -- Micron Selection As discussed above (and well known since the early days of IRAS), normal galaxies display an enormous range of properties when viewed over a wide spec- tral range (from optical to IRAS wavelengths). Clas- sical optically -- selected galaxies emit only a modest fraction of their bolometric luminosity in the ther- mal infrared (e.g., log(LF IR/LB ∼ -- 0.3 -- -- 0.4 for Shapley -- Ames galaxies -- De Jong et al. 1984). In contrast, IRAS discovered some galaxies which are very faint optically, and emit most of their large lu- minosities through re -- radiation by dust grains. Thus a rule similar to that noted by SM for Seyfert nuclei may well apply to disk galaxies: they define a se- quence of increasing dust content. As the proportion of dust increases (or intercepts an increasing fraction of the primary stellar radiation), the galaxy becomes fainter in the optical and brighter in the infrared. Or even for a fixed dust content, if a larger proportion of stars (probably younger ones) are embedded in warm dust, a growing fraction of the galaxy's bolometric output will be transferred particularly to the 25 µm and 60 µm bands. Since the old stellar population in the IR -- Luminous galaxies is not unusually lumi- nous, these galaxies are not extremely massive. In- stead their high luminosities are probably the result of a temporary increase in the current star formation rate which results in an unusually low mass/light ra- tio. This could well be a phase that many normal galaxies pass through, with a relatively low duty cy- cle. It has already been noted that this duty cycle could coincide with the fraction of the lifetime spent by a normal galaxy in close encounters with other galaxies. As SM found for Seyfert nuclei, it is also plausible that some intermediate waveband is relatively unaf- fected by these processes. In other words, for a wide range of normal galaxies of the same bolometric lumi- nosity, there could be a crossover wavelength in the energy distributions where a relatively constant pro- portion of the luminosity is emitted. Our new data suggest that this occurs and, as is the case for Seyfert nuclei, the crossover wavelength is in the mid -- IR near 12 µm, the wavelength at which our sample was de- fined. We note that 12 µm selection is biased in favor of objects which emit strongly at 12 µm, just as every flux -- limited sample is biased at the selection wavelength -- by definition. The particular strength of 12 µm selection is that it is biased in favor of a homo- geneous group of galaxies, for which the 12 µm flux is linearly proportional to the bolometric flux. In other words, our sample will preferentially include objects which are stronger at mid -- IR wavelengths, but these same objects also have higher bolometric luminosities and should be preferentially included in any sample complete to a given bolometric flux. The tight corre- lation between 12 µm flux and bolometric flux for our different classes of galaxies (SM; this work -- § 5.2.) is an empirical relationship that holds true regardless of the particular mechanisms (e.g., hot non-thermal nu- clear continuum, thermal emission from dust heated by starbursts) which elevate the 12 µm flux. Thus, al- though the spectral energy distributions of a wide va- riety of galaxies show a wide range of shapes (from the bluest objects which are strong in the optical/near -- IR and weak in the far -- IR, to objects which show the opposite characteristics), they converge best near 12 µm(see Figure 1 in SM). Thus, the mid -- IR is the "pivot" point where the fraction of the bolometric lu- minosity emitted is roughly constant. Within our sample, this is not only the case for Seyfert galaxies, late -- type spirals, and bolometri- cally luminous galaxies, but also for galaxies in gen- eral, including early -- type spirals and E/S0 galaxies. Even though the average fraction of the bolomet- ric flux emitted at 12 µm is lower for E/S0 galax- ies as a general class (one the order of a percent -- Knapp et al. 1989; Mazzei & De Zotti 1994; Mazzei, De Zotti, & Xu 1994) than for other galaxies, the unusual E/S0 galaxies in our sample have the same relation between L12µm and Lbol as the entire sam- ple (<L12µm/Lbol> ∼ 7% and L12µm ∝ L1.08 bol -- see § 5.2. and § 6.), so that those objects which do get into our sample still have their bolometric flux well represented by the flux at 12 µm. The more sub- tle difference between the E/S0s and other galaxies in our sample is exemplified in Figure 6, where we plot the [B -- H] vs. [K -- 12 µm] colors for our sample. The X's represent the average values for all galaxies and for the E/S0 galaxies (with dotted circles repre- senting 1σ individual scatter). The E/S0 galaxies are roughly evenly distributed over most of the range in which we see spirals, except for the lower right part of the graph. The average values of log(F12µm/F2.2µm) and [B -- H] are 0.75 and 3.85 for our E/S0 galaxies, as compared to 1.12 and 3.53 for our entire sample, reflecting the different dust content and, to a lesser extent, the stellar populations of these types of galax- ies. Thus, the fact that our E/S0s still obey the same relation between 12 µm and total luminosity as do the other galaxies in our sample, while being much stronger in the near -- IR and optical, simply points to the fact that the E/S0s represent the extreme end of far -- IR -- weak and optical/near -- IR -- bright galaxies mentioned above. 5.2. Individual Versus Bolometric Luminosi- ties Figures 7a -- d show the correlation of 12, 25, 60 and 100 µm luminosities with bolometric luminosity for the non -- Seyferts. Deviations from linearity are present for 25 µm, 60 µm and to a lesser extent for 100 µm, but not for 12 µm. Since the "warm excess" luminosity emerges at both 25 and 60 µm, the galaxies of higher luminosity do not appear to have unusual [25 -- 60] colors. This is not an artifact of the redshift since it is present for 60 and 25 but not 12 µm. For completeness, we also present the same correla- tions for Seyfert galaxies in Figures 8a -- d. However, we are fully aware that, since the bolometric lumi- nosities computed here refer to the whole galaxy, the correct fit for the Seyfert galaxies will have to await for total nuclear luminosities, from which starlight had been removed. This will be done in Rush et al. (1996b) by using optical photometric and spectro- scopic data, and it is beyond the scope of the present paper. As can be seen from Figures 8a, for all Seyferts 10 together the coefficient of the correlation of 12 µm lu- minosity versus bolometric luminosity is 1.09 (with regression R = 0.95, for 47 objects). For Seyfert 1s only, this is close to unity (1.03 with R = 0.97 for 19 objects), while for Seyfert 2s it is higher (1.16, with R = 0.93 for 28 objects). At higher wavelength lu- minosities increase slightly faster with the bolometric luminosity (see the figures for the slopes and regres- sion coefficients). The near infrared luminosity, obtained by integrat- ing the total J, H and K magnitudes, as described in § 3., is also a good measure of the bolometric luminos- ity for normal galaxies (see Figure 9a). However it is clear from the figure that it does not hold for the high luminosity non -- Seyferts, which show a relative lack of near infrared emission. For all Seyfert galaxies to- gether, the near infrared luminosity increases almost linearly with bolometric luminosity (see Figure 9b). While Seyfert 1s have a linear correlation, Seyfert 2s have a significantly flatter slope (0.84 with R = 0.94 for 29 objects), indicating that the low bolometric lu- minosity objects have a near infrared excess, due to a greater contribution from starlight. The blue luminosity, for normal galaxies, rises slower than linearly with the bolometric luminosity (see Figure 10a); again the high luminosity non -- Seyfert galaxies deviate the most from linearity. For Seyfert galaxies (Figure 10b) the blue luminosity -- bolometric luminosity relation is even flatter, indi- cating that a strong bias is always present in optical surveys. 6. NORMALIZED SPECTRAL ENERGY DIS- TRIBUTIONS For most of the galaxies of our sample, we have computed the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) normalized to the total fluxes in the frequency range 12.5 < log ν[Hz] < 15.0. Specifically, we have consid- ered all galaxies in the 12um sample for which were available fluxes (or magnitudes) in the following wave- bands: B, J, H, K, L, 12, 25, 60, 100. We integrated by connecting each waveband with a local power -- law slope, to derive a total 4000A -- 300 µm flux which is essentially the bolometric flux. In each non -- Seyfert 1 galaxy the fluxes in each waveband were then nor- malized by its total flux. Energy distributions of the Seyfert 1 galaxies were normalized by including the 1330A and soft X -- ray wavebands. The 1330A flux is the average of all archived IUE SWP spectra for each Seyfert 1, from Edelson et al. (1995) and the X -- ray flux is from the Rosat All Sky Survey results in Rush et al. (1996b). These soft X -- ray fluxes were extrap- olated out to 30 keV assuming a −1 energy index. For an additional comparison the average normalized SEDs (also including the UV and X -- ray wavebands) of the 6 brightest PG quasars, for which IUE spec- tra were available, has also been computed (Edelson 1986). We have used IUE observations from Edelson et al. (1995) to test our assumption that the shorter wave- length power can be safely neglected in all the galax- ies aside from the Seyfert 1s. In the 17 Seyfert 2s observed by both IUE and ROSAT, the UV+X -- ray spectrum contributes from 5 to less than 1% of the total (bolometric) flux. In two high -- luminosity IR starburst galaxies detected by IUE, their UV flux is 1 -- 2.5% of their bolometric flux. In the one 12 Mi- cron Sample LINER detected by IUE -- NGC 1052 -- the UV flux is 5% of the total. Neglecting these con- tributions therefore has added negligible error to our bolometric flux estimates. Figure 11 shows the average normalized energy dis- tributions of normal galaxies (mean of 288) Seyfert 1s (mean of 19), Seyfert 2s (mean of 29), high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts (mean of 19), and LINERs (mean of 15). In these plots the vertical (flux) scale is linear so that the integrals correspond to the usual total power. This is a useful way to visualize which wave- bands make the principal contributions to the bolo- metric luminosity. For comparison, the average en- ergy distribution of the 6 PG quasars is also given. The normalization for these quasars has been com- puted from optical through infrared data from the literature and by assuming a ratio of UV+X -- ray to total flux of 0.08, which is derived from the average of the 5 Seyfert 1s,10 for which we have a measure of the bolometric luminosity, and that were lying close to the PG quasars in the [60 -- 25] versus [H -- L] dia- gram (Figure 3). In Figure 12 we show the individual SEDs for all galaxies where we have calculated bolo- metric luminosities (except for the normal galaxies, which are too numerous to plot individually). In Figure 12a we show the median and first and third quartiles of the 288 normal galaxy spectra. The scatter in the SEDs of normal galaxies is smallest in the 8 -- 12 µm region. Stating this another way, all normal galaxies emit about 7±1% of their bolometric 10Namely: IZw1, Mkn9, Mkn704, Mkn1040 and N5548. 11 flux at 12 µm (as measured by λF λ). This means that a galaxy sample complete to a given 12 µm flux limit is also nearly complete to a given bolometric flux limit (of ∼14 times the 12 µm flux limit). In Figure 12b, we show the normalized SEDs of the 22 Seyfert 1 galaxies: all objects have simi- lar behavior, with flatter energy distributions than any other category. In the near -- to mid -- IR (13 < log ν[Hz] < 14) they are relatively brighter than any other galaxy type of our sample galaxies. Only the average spectrum of the bright PG quasar is similar to the Seyfert 1s, and even brighter at 13 < log ν[Hz] < 14. In Figure 12c, we show Seyfert 2s, the SEDs of which differ from those of Seyfert 1s in two main ways: (1) slightly more 60 -- 100 µm flux, as is expected from dustier objects which reprocess more of the lower -- wavelength radiation into the far -- IR; and (2) higher relative fluxes at J and H, i.e. the Seyfert 1s have a greater average 2.2 -- 3.5 µm excess from a strong AGN, as also indicated in the color -- color diagrams in Figure 1 above. In Figure 12d, the high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts are shown, the shape being similar for all objects. They carry the same fraction of flux at 25 µm com- pared to Seyfert 1s, however they drop down by al- most one magnitude at 12 µm having the same frac- tional flux as the normal galaxies; they show the weakest optical emission of any class. This is be- cause so much of their bolometric flux emerges in the far -- infrared, and their optical continua are heav- ily reddened. These are both caused by large quan- tities of dust intermixed with large numbers of lu- minous stars. Note that their SEDs intersect those of normal galaxies around 12 µm: both types emit about 7% of their bolometric luminosity in that wave- band. To consider an extreme example of such high -- luminosity galaxies, we compared these objects to the ultra -- luminous IRAS galaxy F10214+4724, which also has a spectrum that peaks in the infrared. This object's IRAS fluxes densities (Rowan -- Robinson et al. 1991) increase steeply at least up to 100 µm (log(Fν100µm/Fν60µm) ∼ 0.48), corresponding to a rest wavelength of ∼30 µm (with z ∼ 2.29 -- Brown & vanden Bout 1991), indicating that the emission is dominated by stellar processes similar to that from the much closer high -- luminosity galaxies in our sam- ple. In Figure 12e the LINERs are shown. Again, the SEDs are very similar, most of the energy coming 12 from the standard population of red giants charac- teristic of early -- type galaxies. Small to negligible en- ergy is produced by reradiation from cool dust grains. There is no evidence at any infrared wavelength of any flux that could be associated with a nonstellar nucleus. The LINERs have the lowest emission at in- frared frequencies and the highest in the visual. In other words, they have the most "normal" infrared properties of any galaxy subgroup. Their spectra also show a wavelength of minimum scatter -- around 6 to 8 µm. The energy they emit at 12 µm -- νLν -- is a constant 5% of their bolometric luminosity for all 12 of our LINERs. 7. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS ν We have calculated bolometric luminosities and normalized spectral energy distributions for galaxies in the the 12 µm Galaxy Sample, finding this sam- ple to be approximately complete in normal galax- ies down to a well -- defined bolometric flux limit of /0.07 = 1.1 · 10−10erg s−1 cm−2, given our νF lim 12 µm flux limit of 0.22 Jy. Future deeper surveys conducted at wavelengths of 8 to 12 µm will simulta- neously provide samples of normal and active galax- ies which will be complete to well -- defined bolomet- ric flux limits. The normal galaxy sample will be about 5 times larger, but will be about 2 times less deep. The depth of the Seyfert galaxy sample at low luminosities will be limited by how well the nu- cleus can be spatially separated from the host galaxy. We will use small -- beam mid -- infrared photometry to make this separation for the 12um Seyferts in an up- coming paper (Rush et al. 1996b). The future sur- veys at these mid -- infrared wavelengths will not be biased in favour or against particular types of galax- ies (e.g. blue quasars, starbursts, etc.) because the mid -- infrared emission for any class of objects is that most closely proportional to the bolometric luminos- ity (whereas the far -- infrared/optical luminosities rise faster/slower than linearly with bolometric luminos- ity). The near -- to far -- infrared energy distributions, as shown by the [H -- L] and the [60 -- 25] colors, define a clear sequence of increasing nuclear activity from normal galaxies, having blue [H -- L] color and cold [60 -- 25] color, to those Seyfert galaxies which have similar properties of quasars, with red [H -- L] color and hot [60 -- 25] color. Those Seyfert galaxies hav- ing a strong galactic component -- relative to the nu- clear component -- have intermediate colors. However, the high luminosity non -- Seyferts (we include Arp 220 in this class) lie significantly off the "nuclear activ- ity" sequence, indicating that their relative energy distribution cannot be explained by the mixture of galaxy plus quasar light, but -- most probably -- only by the occurrence of violent bursts of star formation which simultaneously flattens [60 -- 25] and steepens [H -- L]. Combining near -- and far -- infrared photometry is therefore a powerful diagnostic for identifying the emission mechanisms (quasars and/or star formation) which are ultimately responsible for the emitted light of galaxies. We also find that Seyfert 1s and Seyfert 2s are sep- arated on infrared color -- color diagrams. This can be reconciled with "Unified Schemes" in which Seyfert 1s are seen face -- on, Seyfert 2s are seen edge-on, and thus have much of their higher frequency radiation absorbed by an intervening torus, resulting in redder colors. We thank the IRAS (Infrared Astronomical Satel- lite) Team and the staff at IPAC (Infrared Process- ing and Analysis Center, Pasadena, CA), noting that without the success of the IRAS mission, this work could not even have been conceived. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED) which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Labo- ratory, California Institute of Technology, under con- tract with the National Aeronautics and Space Ad- ministration. We also thank the ESO (European Southern Observatory, Chile) and San Pedro Mar- tir Observatory (Baja California, Mexico) staff for assisting us during the various campaigns. We are grateful to K. Matthews and G. Neugebauer for sup- port of the infrared photometer at Mount Wilson, and C. Beichman and D. Dickinson for assistance with the observations. We are also grateful to Marion Schmitz who gave us the electronic version of the Catalog of Infrared Observations promptly upon its completion, thus saving us from making a thorough and endless literature search. We thank Jill Knapp for provid- ing us with electronic copies of the data tables from Knapp et al. (1989). This work was supported by NASA grants NAG 5 -- 1358 and NAG 5 -- 1719 and DGAPA/UNAM grant PAPIID:IN103992. A. ESTIMATED [3.5 µm] MAGNITUDES FOR COMPUTATION OF BOLOMET- RIC FLUXES The dramatic increase of sky noise with wavelength makes it extremely difficult to obtain large -- beam pho- tometry for λ > 3µm. Nonetheless, for many of the brightest 12 µm Galaxies, and for most of the Seyferts, we measured fluxes at L [3.5 µm] or L' [3.75 µm], which were presented in Table 1. For most non -- Seyfert galaxies, however, we lack L photometry. To obtain the bolometric luminosities in § 3. above, we assigned these galaxies an L magnitude based on the correlation between [H -- K] and [K -- L] shown in Fig- ure 2. The regression line we show for non-Seyferts is: [K − L] = ([H − K] − 0.13)/0.33 This relation shows a scatter of ±0.3 magnitudes, which is only a minor contributor to the final uncer- tainties of our bolometric luminosities. B. ESTIMATED SUB -- MILLIMETER FLUXES FOR COMPUTATION OF BOLOMET- RIC FLUXES Although our "LIRAS" integrations were stopped at 100 µm, it is known that substantial thermal flux emerges from cooler dust at longer wavelengths. Since the flux density often peaks at wavelengths longer than 100 µm, the IRAS 60 and 100 µm fluxes alone, if fitted with a single -- temperature component, tend to under -- estimated the total sub -- mm flux. Longer wavelength data are needed to determine the nec- essary correction. The relatively few measurements in the far -- infrared at λ > 100 µm are sufficient to demonstrate that not all galaxies show the same spec- tral shapes beyond 100 µm. To compare these results, we have reduced all of this long -- wavelength data to one measure of the far -- IR spectral turnover: the color temperature of a greybody, for an assumed dust emis- sivity ∝ λ−1, which would pass through the 100 µm flux measured by IRAS. As shown in Figure 13, the far -- IR/sub -- mm color temperature is correlated with the 60 -- 100 µm slope. The data are from Rickard & Harvey (1984), Telesco & Harper (1980), Thronson et al. (1990), Stark et al. (1989), Joy et al. (1986), Hunter et al. (1989), and Smith 1982. Not surprisingly, galaxies which ap- pear hotter in the IRAS bands also appear hotter in the far -- IR/sub -- mm, although the inferred dust tem- 13 peratures for the longer wavelengths are systemati- cally lower than the 60 -- 100 µm color temperature, because of the increasing contribution of colder dust at longer wavelengths. We have used the correlation shown in the figure, Tcolor = 11.4 · (α60−100 + 4.67)K to estimate color temperatures for each galaxy in our sample. We then added the integrated flux of a ǫ ∝ λ−1 greybody for λ > 100µm to our IRAS fluxes in deriving the Bolometric Luminosities of Table 3. The assumed emissivity law is probably conservative. If emissivity in fact drops like λ−2, even less than 20% of the Bolometric Luminosity typically emerges at λ > 100µm. C. COMPARISON WITH OTHER STUD- IES After submitting the original version of the present paper, we received preprints discussing the mid -- infrared emission from Seyfert nuclei (Maiolino et al. 1995; Giuricin, Mardirossian & Mezzetti 1995). In this sec- tion we show our results to be consistent with theirs, as we discuss further some differences between the ob- served properties of Seyfert 1s and 2s. As mentioned above in § 4.2., the main conclusions of Maiolino et al. are, first, that the nuclear 10 µm luminosity of Broad Line Seyfert galaxies is systematically larger than that of those Seyferts without a BLR; and, second, that the host galaxies of Seyfert 2s nuclei have higher star formation rates than the hosts of Seyfert 1s. From the average energy distributions, normalized to the total luminosities, that we computed in § 6. (see Figure 11), we find that the average ratio of 12 µm to total luminosity average is 0.075±.039 for the normal galaxies, 0.130±.052 for the Seyfert 1s, 0.097±.04 for the Seyfert 2s, 0.077±.027 for the Starbursts (and for comparison 0.039±.023 for the LINERs). Although the scatter around the mean is quite large, the trend is for a decreasing fraction of the total luminosity to emerge at 12 µm going from Seyfert 1s through Seyfert 2s to normal galaxies and starburst galaxies, and ending with LINERs. If we assume that the av- erage galactic component of the 12 µm emission in Seyfert galaxies is equal for both types to the total emission present in normal galaxies, it follows that the nuclear 12 µm component of the Seyfert 1s is brighter than that of the Seyfert 2s. This is essentially the first conclusion of Maiolino et al. We can check their second conclusion by using the normalized 60 µm luminosity to infer the star for- mation rate. For our sample, the average ratio of 60 µm to total luminosity is 0.38 for "starbursts", 0.20 for normal galaxies, 0.19 for Seyfert 2s, 0.15 for Seyfert 1s, and 0.11 for LINERs. Although the scatter is again large (the standard deviations of the above ratios range from 0.085 to 0.090) the trend in- dicates a decrease in the fractional 60 µm emission from starburst galaxies, through normal, Seyfert 2s, then Seyfert 1s and LINERs. This behavior can also be seen from the [60 -- 12] color for the whole 12 µm galaxy sample (i.e., the log(F60µm/F12µm), as plotted, for example, in Figure 4a). The more a galaxy is dominated by star formation processes the redder is its [60 -- 12] color. In fact, the [60 -- 12] color decreases from starburst galaxies (1.31±0.21 for 38 galaxies), through normal galaxies (1.05±0.22 for 705 objects), LINERs (1.00±0.25 for 30 objects), Seyfert 2s (0.98±0.37 for 65 objects), to Seyfert 1s (0.70±0.38 for 55 objects). We expect that much of the scatter in this relation will be explained with further observations, as is already the case for sev- eral exceptions to this trend among the Seyferts: sev- eral Seyfert 2s with the lowest [60 -- 12] values (<0.9; NGC 1068, MKN 348, and MKN 463, i.e. the best observed ones) are known to have an obscured BLR, while three Seyfert 1s with high values of [60 -- 12] (>1.2; NGC 1365, NGC 7469, and MKN 231) are already known to have significant starburst compo- nents. Giuricin et al. (1995) used a compilation of ground- based, small aperture photometric observations at 10 µm for 117 Seyfert galaxies. They find that the 10 µm luminosity distribution of Seyfert 1s extends to greater values than that of Seyfert 2s. This is not surprising. In fact, in the 12 µm galaxy sample (SM, RMS), the 12 µm and 60 µm luminosity func- tions of Seyfert 1s extend to higher luminosities than those of Seyfert 2s. This effect is also observed in Maiolino et al., who reported a 2σ difference between the 10 µm luminosities of broad-line and narrow- line Seyfert galaxies. Giuricin et al. also find that Seyfert 1s and Seyfert 2s differ significantly in their IRAS 12 -- 25 µm color, Seyfert 2s being redder than Seyfert 1s. We agree with Maiolino et al. that the above re- sults can be reconciled with the unified models for Seyfert galaxies if the 10 µm nuclear emission is mod- erately anisotropic. This might imply that the phys- ical size of the 10 µm source has to be no larger than the hypothesized obscuring torus and that this has 14 to be moderately optically thick in the mid-infrared. We also agree with their suggestion that some Seyfert host galaxies have enhanced levels of star forma- tion. In particular, this probably helped some of the Seyfert 2's get into the 12 µm sample. 15 REFERENCES Aaronson, M., Huchra, J., & Mould, J. 1979, ApJ 229, 1 (AHM) Bally, J., Langer, W.D., & Liu, W. 1991, ApJ 383, 645 Balzano, V.A. & Weedman, D.W. 1981, ApJ 243, 756 Bersanelli, M., Bouchet, P., & Falomo, R. 1991, A&A 252, 854 Bouchet, P., Schmider, F., & Manfroid, J. 1991, A&AS 91, 409 Brown, R.L. & vanden Bout, P.A. 1991, AJ 102, 1956 Carrasco, L. & Cruz -- Gonzalez, I. 1995, in preparation Carrasco, L., Recillas -- Cruz, E., Garcia -- Barreto, A., Cruz -- Gonzalez, I., Serrano, A.P.G. 1991, PASP 103, 987. Cruz -- Gonzalez, I. 1984, Ph.D. Thesis, Harvard Uni- versity Danese, L., Zitelli, V., Granato, G.L., Wade, R., De Zotti, G., & Mandolesi, N. 1992, ApJ 399, 38 De Jong, T., Clegg, P.E., Soifer, B.T., Rowan -- Robinson, M., Habing, H.J., Houck, J.R., Aumann, H.H., & Raimond, E. 1984, ApJL 278, L67 De Vaucouleurs, G., De Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H.G., Jr., Buta, R.J., Paturel, G., & Foque,P. 1991 Third Reference Catalog of Bright Galaxies (New York: Springer -- Verlag) (RC3) Edelson, R.A. 1986, ApJL 309, L69 Joseph, R.D., Meikle, W.P.S., Robertson, N.A., & Wright, G.S. 1984, MNRAS 209, 111 Joy, M., Lester, D.F., Harvey, P.M., & Frueh, M. 1986, ApJ 307, 110 Knapp, G.R., Guhathakurta, P., Kim, D.-W., & Jura, M. 1989, ApJS 70, 329 Kotilainen, J.K., Ward, M.J., Boisson, C., DePoy, D.L., & Smith, M.G. 1992, MNRAS 256, 149 Kotilainen, J.K., & Ward, M.J. 1994, MNRAS 266, 953 Malkan, M.A. & Oke, J.B. 1983, ApJ 265, 92 Maiolino, R., Ruiz, M., Rieke, G.H., & Keller, L.D. 1995, ApJ in press Mazzei, P. & De Zotti, G. 1994, ApJ 426, 97 Mazzei, P., De Zotti, G., & Xu, C. 1994, ApJ 422, 81 Moshir, M., et al. 1991, Explanatory Supplement to the IRAS Faint Source Survey, Version 2. (Pasadena: JPL) Neugebauer, G., Green, R.F., Matthews, K., Scmidt, M., Soifer, B.T., & Bennett, J. 1978, ApJS 63, 615 Pier, E.A. & Krolik, J.H. 1993, ApJ 418, 673 Recillas -- Cruz, E., Carrasco, L., Serrano, A., Cruz -- Gonzalez, I. 1990, A&A 229, 64 Recillas -- Cruz, E., Carrasco, L., Serrano, A., Cruz -- Gonzalez, I. 1991, A&A 249, 312 Rickard, L.J. & Harvey, P.M. 1984, AJ 89, 1520 Rieke, G.H. & Lebofsky M.J. 1985, ApJ 288, 618 Edelson, R.A., Malkan, M.A., & Rieke, G.H. 1987, Rowan -- Robinson, M. et al. 1991, Nature 351, 719 ApJ 321, 233 (EMR) Edelson, R.A. et al. 1995, preprint Rudy, R.J., Levan, P.D., & Rodriguez -- Espinosa, J.M. 1982, AJ 87, 598 Elias, J.H., Frogel, J.A., Matthews, K., & Neuge- Rush, B., Malkan, M.A. & Spinoglio, L. 1993, ApJS bauer, G. 1982, AJ 87, 1029 89, 1 (RMS) Frogel, J.A., Persson, S.E., Aaronson, M., & Matthews, Rush, B., Malkan, M.A., Fink, H.H., & Voges, W. K. 1978, ApJ 220, 75 1996a, in preparation. Gezari, D.Y., Schmitz, M., Pitts, P.S. & Mead, J.M. 1993, Catalog of Infrared Observations, NASA Ref- erence Publication 1294, June 1993. Giuricin, G., Mardirossian, F., & Mezzetti, M. 1995, ApJ in press. (preprint SISSA Ref. 5/95/A) Heckman, T.M. 1980, A&A 87, 152 Hunter, D.A., Thronson, H.A., Casey, S., & Harper, D.A. 1989, ApJ 341, 697 Rush, B., Malkan, M.A. & Spinoglio, L. 1996b, in preparation Smith, J. 1982, ApJ 261, 463 Spinoglio, L., & Malkan, M.A. 1989, ApJ 342, 83 (SM) Stark, A.A., Davidson, J.A., Harper, D.A., Pernic, R., Loewenstein, R., Platt, S., Engargiola, G., & Casey, S. 1989, ApJ 337, 650 Hyland, A.R. & Allen, D.A. 1982, MNRAS 199, 943 Telesco, C.M. & Harper, D.A. 1980, ApJ 235, 392 16 Thronson, H.A., Hunter, D.A., Casey, S., & Harper, D.A. 1990, ApJ 355, 94 Thuan, T.X. 1983, ApJ 268, 667 V`eron -- Cetty, M. P., & V`eron, P. 1991, A Catalogue of Quasars and Active Nuclei, 5th edition. ESO Scientific Report No. 10 -- October 1991 (Munich: European Southern Observatory) Wall, W.F., et al. 1995, submitted to ApJS Wilson, W.J., Schwartz, P.R., Neugebauer, G., Har- vey, P.M., & Becklin, E.E. 1972, ApJ 177, 523 This 2-column preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v3.0. 17 [H -- K] vs. [25 -- K] vs. FIGURE LEGENDS [J -- H] vs. [60 -- 12] vs. [H -- K] color -- color dia- [H -- K] color -- color dia- Figure 1 -- a: gram. The normal galaxy colors are indicated by the large circle whose radius is 2σ. Also indicated is the mean value of the 9 brightest PG quasars (see text). The extinction of 1 and 5 optical mag. is also given. b: [K -- L] color -- color diagram. In this and all following figures, the filled squares rep- resent Seyfert 1s, open squares Seyfert 2s, asterisks high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts, open circles LINERs and diagonal crosses normal galaxies. Figure 2 -- a: [60 -- 25] color -- color dia- gram. The [25 -- K] color gives a clear separation of Seyfert 1s from Seyfert 2s (see the text). b: [25 -- K] vs. [H -- K] color -- color diagram. Figure 3 -- [60 -- 25] vs. [H -- L] color -- color diagram. The line represent the least squares fit of all data points. Seyfert 1s and 2s are labelled with their names. The average colors with 1 σ errors are in- dicated for normal galaxies, high luminosity non -- Seyferts, LINERs and the brightest PG quasars (see text). Figure 4 -- a: gram. b: [H -- K] color vs. bolometric luminosity. Figure 5 -- [25 -- K] vs. [60 -- 12] color -- color diagram. The broken lines at [60 -- 12]=1. and [25 -- K]=1.35 de- fine a region where almost only Seyfert 1 galaxies are present. The cross represents the 1 σ scatter for the normal galaxies. The point in the upper left refers to the best fit model of an optically thick torus seen edge -- on for the nuclear colors of NGC1068 (Pier & Krolik 1993). The dotted line shows a mixture of those nuclear colors plus our average galactic colors (the numbers give the fraction of galactic to nuclear flux at 12 µm). For comparison we also show our large aperture data of the same galaxy. Figure 6 -- [B -- H] vs. [K -- 12 µm] color -- color dia- gram. Elipses representing the 1 -- σ scatter in each color are centered on the average value for the E/S0 galaxies and for all galaxies. Figure 7 -- Monochromatic luminosities vs. bolo- metric luminosity for normal galaxies and high lumi- nosity non -- Seyferts. Also shown are the points repre- senting LINERs. The lines represent the least squares fit to all but the LINERs points. a,b,c,d: 12, 25, 60, and 100 µm luminosity vs. bolometric luminosity. Figure 8 -- Monochromatic luminosities vs. bolo- metric luminosity for Seyferts. The lines represent the least squares fit to all data points, except the one relative to Arp 220 (which isn't likely a Seyfert -- see text), whose position is labeled. a,b,c,d: 12, 25, 60, and 100 µm luminosity vs. bolometric luminosity. Figure 9 -- Near -- infrared luminosity vs. bolometric luminosity for a) normals and high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts, and b) Seyferts. The solid lines represent the least squares fit to all data points. The dashed and dotted lines in b are the fits to the Seyfert 1s and 2s, respectively. Figure 10 -- Total blue luminosity vs. bolometric luminosity for a) normals and high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts and LINERs, and b) Seyferts. The lines rep- resent the least squares fit to all data points. Figure 11 -- Average spectral energy distribution normalized to bolometric flux of all classes of galaxies. Also included is the average PG quasar spectrum (see text). Figure 12 -- Spectral energy distribution, normal- ized to bolometric flux, of individual galaxies in the 12 µm Sample. a,b,c,d,e: normal galaxies, Seyfert 1s, Seyfert 2s, high -- luminosity non -- Seyferts, and LIN- ERs, respectively. For the normal galaxies, we plot only the logarithmic spectral energy distribution of the median and first and third quartiles points at each observed frequency. Figure 13 -- Least squares fit of the spectral index α60−100µm as a function of the color temperature, as- suming grey body emission with dust emissivity law ǫ ∝ λ−1. 18
astro-ph/0405068	2	0405	2004-05-06T19:16:48	Millisecond Pulsar Searches and Double Neutron Star Binaries	[ "astro-ph" ]	A unified strategy is developed that can be used to search for millisecond pulsars (MSPs) with ~solar mass companions (including neutron star companions in double neutron star binaries [DNSBs]) belonging to both very short period binaries, and those with periods so long that they could be appropriate targets for acceleration searches, and to bridge the gap between these two extremes. In all cases, the orbits are assumed to be circular. Applications to searches for binary pulsars similar to PSR J0737-3039 are discussed. The most likely candidates for more DNSBs consist of weakly magnetized neutron stars, spinning only moderately fast, like J0737-3039A, with periods generally longer than 15 ms, though this issue is not yet settled. Because of the similarity between the MSP components of DNSBs, and the longer period MSP population specific to massive condensed or core collapsed globular clusters, as well as the uncertainties about accretion-driven spinup, doubts linger about the standard models of DNSB formation.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Millisecond Pulsar Searches and Double Neutron Star Binaries J. Middleditch Modeling. Algorithms, and Informatics, MS B265, Computer & Computational Science Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545 [email protected] ABSTRACT A unified strategy is developed that can be used to search for millisecond pul- sars (MSPs) with ∼solar mass companions (including neutron star companions in double neutron star binaries [DNSBs]) belonging to both very short period binaries, and those with periods so long that they could be appropriate targets for acceleration searches, and to bridge the gap between these two extremes. In all cases, the orbits are assumed to be circular. Applications to searches for binary pulsars similar to PSR J0737-3039 are discussed. The most likely can- didates for more DNSBs consist of weakly magnetized neutron stars, spinning only moderately fast, like J0737-3039A, with periods generally longer than 15 ms, though this issue is not yet settled. Because of the similarity between the MSP components of DNSBs, and the longer period MSP population specific to massive condensed or core collapsed globular clusters, as well as the uncertain- ties about accretion-driven spinup, doubts linger about the standard models of DNSB formation. Subject headings: binaries: close -- pulsars: general -- pulsars: (J0737-3039) -- stars: neutron -- supernovae: general individual 4 0 0 2 y a M 6 2 v 8 6 0 5 0 4 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 1. Introduction The discovery of the double binary pulsar system PSR J0737-3039A,B (hereafter J0737 -- Burgay et al. 2003; Lyne et al. 2004) has rekindled interest in computation intensive searches for other similar systems, because their coalescence events will be detectable as sources to gravitational observatories (Kalogera et al. 2004), that will most likely be stronger than merger-induced core collapse supernovae (SNe) if very much less common (Middleditch 2004a, hereafter M04a). None of the other seven double neutron star binaries (DNSBs) have detected pulsar companions. Four of these (B1534+12, J1756-2251, B1913+16, and M15C) -- 2 -- have orbital periods of 10, and 3*8 hours respectively (Wolszczan 1991; Faulkner et al. 2004; Hulse & Taylor 1975; Prince et al. 1991) one has a period of 28 hours (J1829+2456, Cham- pion et al. 2004) and the remaining two (J1518+4904 and J1811-1736) have periods of 9 and 19 days (Nice, Sayer, and Taylor 1996; Lyne et al. 2000). In addition, three (J1811-1736, B1913+16, and M15C) have eccentricities of 0.83, 0.62, and 0.68, while four (J1518+4904, B1534+12, J1756-2251, and J1829+2456) have eccentricities of 0.25, 0.27, 0.18, and 0.14. By contrast, the eccentricity for J0737, with an orbital period of only 2.4 hours, is only 0.088. Should this trend continue as DNSBs evolve, then deeper, brute force searches using only circular orbits and quantum computers if necessary, may ultimately find more (how- ever, the lifetime of such close binary systems is very short). Other applications include millisecond pulsar (MSP) searches in low mass X-ray binaries (e.g., Dib et al. 2004), and very young supernova (SN) remnants (SNRs) in which a newly-born pulsar is spinning down rapidly and/or mimicking binary motion through precession (Nelson, Finn, & Wasserman 1990; Middleditch et al. 2000, hereafter M00). Even membership in a binary system with circular orbits, however, can drastically reduce the detectability of an MSP to conventional search techniques. In fact, if J0737A&B were moderately weaker at 1,400 MHz than 1.6 and 1.3 mJy, they would never have been detected even by acceleration searches. In addition, through the use of radio imaging techniques at sites such as the VLA, and others in Australia, point sources will be mapped that will be pulsar candidates, but will also be near the threshold of detection as pulsars even by conventional acceleration searches. Thus, many such mapped sources will also require brute force binary pulsar searches to uncover their pulsar parameters. The next section (§2) begins with a discussion of acceleration searches (§2.1), continues with a discussion of short period binary searches (§2.2), and derives how to transition between the two search extremes. Section 2.3 gives an example of a short period binary search, and §2.4 discusses ways to maintain the effectiveness of such searches with much less required computation. The following sections (§3 and §4) discuss how the DNSBs could affect MSP searches, and conclude. 2. Technique 2.1. Acceleration Searches The problem to be solved by future searches, then, is how to compensate, efficiently, but still completely, for the possibility that a target being searched may be a pulsar member of a short period binary system, and how to extend such searches into the range of longer -- 3 -- binary periods. By "short" we mean a binary period that is short enough so that the drift in pulse frequency due to the pulsar's acceleration in the binary system can be greater than one or two wavenumbers of frequency (cycles (observation time)−1). Expressed in terms of the physical parameters of the binary system, this constraint becomes: d (1) maxT 2 = 1.844 ∗ 10−5(f /650)T 2P −4/3 f ′ sin i(M/2.4M⊙)1/32.4Mc/M ≥ 1 , where f is the pulsar repetition frequency in Hz, f ′ max is the maximum absolute value of the time derivative of the pulse frequency caused by the orbital motion, T is the time duration of the observation of the pulsar, Pd is the orbital period in days, sini is the sin of the orbital inclination, i, and M is the total mass of the binary system, i.e., the mass of the pulsar, Mp, plus the mass of the companion star, Mc. Equation (1) shows that even an observation as short as one(five) minute(s) for a 0.1/1.0 day binary period, can be affected for a 650 Hz pulsar orbiting a solar mass companion. Thus we need to know how densely we must sample the parameters of the binary orbit in order that we lose, in the worst case situation, only 10%, 20%, or 40% of the power that a pulsar would produce in a Fourier transform of a given observation, relative to the power produced if the orbital parameters of our data-taking apparatus (or of our time series- stretching software) were perfectly matched to the orbital parameters of the pulsar. In order to solve this problem, it is first easier to investigate the problem in the limit of the "longer" short orbital periods, where we need only concern ourselves with matching the first two time derivatives of frequency, f ′ and f ′′. The errors that can be associated with the measurement of the rate of frequency drift in time, f ′, and the next time derivative, f ′′, are given by: δf ′ = √90/(πpPF T 2) , δf ′′ = 6√105/(πpPF T 3) , (2) (3) where PF is the Fourier power produced by the periodic pulsations in a power spectrum normalized so that the local mean power near (but not at) the pulsar frequency (or harmonic being discussed) is unity. These errors apply only when f ′ and f ′′ are to be measured while the remaining parameters, f and f ′′, or f and f ′ respectively are known a priori to the measurement. The derivation of the formulae for δf (which is given by δf = 3/(π√6PF T )) and δf ′ are outlined elsewhere (Ransom, Eikenberry, & Middleditch 2002, hereafter REM02); the formula for δf ′′ can be derived with similar arguments. (The formula for δf ′′′ can not be so derived, possibly because pure f ′′′ is almost indistinguishable from an ordinary periodic frequency modulation, which produces little effect at the central frequency. However the 2nd harmonic of the 2.14 ms pulsations from SN1987A during 31 Oct. '95 was so highly phase -- 4 -- modulated that the Fourier peak at the central frequency was starting to split -- M00.) Using a continuous Fourier interpolation and the first, second, and third derivatives of the Fourier amplitudes wrt the frequency (f ), f ′, and f ′′ can be estimated for a small range about 0, from the Fourier amplitudes close to f (Middleditch & Cordova 1982; Middleditch, Deich, & Kulkarni 1992, hereafter MDK). Since a power spectrum with unit mean has the statistical properties of one half of the χ2 for two degrees of freedom, we could have defined the errors given in equations (2) and (3) as the deviations of the parameters f ′ and f ′′ (taken one at a time) which reduced the power of a Fourier peak by 0.5 units below the maximum value. Thus we can rework equations (2) and (3) to solve for the deviations which reduce the peak power by 10% (i.e., reduced to 0.9 of the peak value): T 2δf ′ T 3δf ′′ 90% = 3√2/π , 90% = 6√21/π . (4) (5) By differentiation of the Doppler equation for f , we can relate f ′ and f ′′ to a function of the orbital phase, Ωt: f ′ = f ′′ = f Ω2ap sin i c f Ω3ap sin i c cos(Ωt) , sin(Ωt) , (6) (7) where t is time, c is the velocity of light, Ω = 2π/P , where P is the orbital period, and ap is the size of the orbit of the pulsar in the binary system: ap = 1.633 ∗ 1011P 2/3 d ( M 2.4M⊙ )1/3 ∗ 2.4Mc/M (cm) . (8) We can see from equations (6) and (7) that f ′ and f ′′ represent orthogonal coordinates of the orbital system (ignoring sin i for the moment), with f ′ measuring the depth into the binary system along the projected line of sight (conjunction axis -- Middleditch & Nelson 1976), and f ′′ measuring the extent of the binary system in the plane of the sky, perpendicular to the conjunction axis (i.e., along the line of quadratures). Thus, if we wanted to search our data for a pulsar in a not-too-short orbital period system, we would superpose a rectangular lattice of points over a circular orbit, where the lattice spacing is given by twice the tolerances of equations (4) and (5). At quadrature, with both binary members at maximum elongation (and thus in the plane of the sky, or Ωt = π 2 ), f ′ is near 0, but changing very rapidly, and hence f ′′ is near one of its two extremes, but changing only very slowly. Here also the differentials of f ′ and f ′′ resolve into 2 or 3π -- 5 -- relations that depend only upon the differentials of one of the two binary parameters, ap and orbital phase, Φ = Ωt: δf ′max = δΦf Ω2ap sin i 2c ; (Φ = π 2 , 3π 2 ), δf ′′max = δap sin if Ω3 2c ; " . (9) (10) Using equations (4) and (5) for the tolerances, we can derive an expression for the tolerances of the binary parameters, ap, and Φ: δΦ = 6√2c πf (ΩT )2ap sin i (radians) , δap = 12√21c πf (ΩT )3 sin i ; (Φ = π 2 , 3π 2 ) . (11) (12) The above equations give the mismatch of the orbital parameters that would produce a 10% loss of the power of a Fourier peak (per parameter). The simplicity of equations (11) and (12) has provided part of the motivation behind the quadrature search technique. This involves scanning through a data set large enough to contain at least one quadrature, plus at least half of the analysis size length, T /2, and tracking the data through the orbital motion, with increments in orbital parameters close to those given by equations (11) and (12), hoping to detect the pulsar. The other part of the motivation for the quadrature search has been due, in part, to computing limitations, either because of an upper limit to the size of the Fourier transforms that could be done, or an upper limit to the total amount of computing time available. Here, however, we wish to develop a search strategy that can make use of the entire set of data taken. Since the rectangular lattice of f ′ and f ′′ values has exactly the same density over the entire orbital plane, the experimenter could do just as well by searching the data for Doppler- shifted pulsar behavior at any a priori selected orbital phase domain, including conjunction. In this case, small steps must be taken in ap, but large steps are allowed in Φ. The only danger is that second order deviation of f ′ from the maximum value caused by the now cruder steps in Φ (set by the tolerance on f ′′), could exceed the tolerance set by the finer steps in ap. With a little calculation, one can show that the ratio of the step size in Φ required by f ′′ to that required by the 2nd order change in f ′ near maximum, can be given as: δΦf ′′ δΦf ′,2nd (Φ = 0, π) = 0.00223( 650 f )1/2( P T )2P −1/3 d ( 2.4M⊙ M )1/6( M 2.4Mc )1/2(sin i)−1/2 . (13) -- 6 -- Thus, paradoxically, the conjunction searches for millisecond pulsars are in trouble due to second order changes in f ′ until the orbital period, P , becomes shorter than ∼21 times the observation time, T , unless f is faster than 650 Hz, or the companion mass is large. The rationale behind this statement is that the longer orbital periods allow much larger values of δΦ at conjunction before f ′′ is a problem, i.e., the dependence of P on δf ′′ is stronger and dominates the two effects. Eventually, however, as P becomes much shorter, the approximation involved in equating f ′ and f ′′ to the orbital parameters has broken down due to the neglect of the higher derivatives. 2 , 3π 2 ) given by equation (11). In the limit of ΩT ≤ √42, or Before beginning our discussion of short period binaries, we want to find out how to transition between the two extremes of searches. We can do this by focusing our attention on the tolerance in δΦ∗ ap (Φ = π basically for all observations of duration less than one orbital period, this tolerance is always more stringent than that given for δap in equation (12). It is identical to the tolerance on δap dictated by the tolerance of f ′ at the conjunctions (Φ = 0, π), when f ′ has its extreme values that multiplication by δap/ap can lead to (potentially large) fractional variations. The point we wish to make here, then, is that no parameter spacing needs to be finer than this tolerance as the orbital period, P , gets long in comparison to the data stream length to be analyzed, T . 2.2. Searches in Short Period Binaries Now that the asymptotic value for the spacing of the orbital parameter space has been found, we can investigate the situation for the very short period binary systems, with ap- proximately one or more binary orbits occurring during the data interval, T , with the goal of smoothly connecting pulsar searches with short and longer orbital periods. In the situa- tion where one or more orbits occur during the run time, T , a binary orbit causes a phase modulation of amplitude: (14) (15) c so that the equation of the data becomes: (radians) , 2πf ap sin i Zφ = g(t) = a ∗ noise + b ∗ (1 + cos(2πf t + φ0 + Zφ ∗ cos(Ωt + Φ0))) . 2π , f ± 2 Ω 2π , · · ·, f ± n Ω The Fourier transform of this signal will produce peaks in the Fourier power spectrum at f , f ± Ω 2π , · · ·, each with complex Fourier amplitude proportional to (√−1)nJn(Zφ), where the Jn are Bessel functions of nth order, and a technique has been developed that exploits this pattern in the Fourier power spectrum (Ransom, Cordes, and Eikenberry 2003). In this brute force method, however, the time series is stretched to match -- 7 -- a particular set of orbital parameters and the mismatch of these to the true set generates a particular error vector, δZφ in the complex Zφ plane, constructed, as other complex planes, to track the modulus and phase of such vectors. A residual phase modulation then ensues because the error vector has a finite length, and can also migrate during the observation time due to orbital period mismatch. For the sake of simplicity, we will assume for now that the phase modulation has a constant amplitude and phase. Power is lost to this phase modulation from the main peak, whose height is proportional to: J 2 0 (δZφ) ≈ 1 − (δZφ)2/2 . (16) If we are completely ignorant of the orbital phase and projected orbital radius of a particular binary system, then we must search over the Zφ plane with tile sizes which can be determined from equation (16), i.e., (17) Thus for a worst case mismatch of orbital phase modulation of 1/√5 radians, the worst case loss of Fourier power will be only 10%. (radians) . δZφ,90% = 1/√5 To cover the Zφ plane efficiently, we choose a hexagonal tiling with a side dimension of 1/√5. The hexagonal tile has the same area (3√3/10) as a square tile of 0.721 radians on a side. For a tile on the plane with a radius vector of Zφ = 2πf ap sin i/c, the orbital phase subtended by this tile can be given by: δΦZφ ≈ δZφ Zφ = q2√3/5 c 2πf ap sin i ≈ 0.86c 2πf ap sin i (radians) , (18) where the 0.86 factor on the right hand side approximates the geometric mean (0.832) be- tween what are, in turn, approximations for the angle subtended by the hexagonal tile flat-flat and diagonal directions (to within 3.3% -- the actual mean phase angle subtended by the tiles to the origin of the Zφ plane is bigger than what the middle of equation (18) would predict). We can now compare half the fineness of this stepping in orbital phase to the worst case mismatch increments (10% loss in power) given by equation (11): α ≡ 2 , 3π δΦ(Φ = π 2 ) 0.5 × δΦZφ = ( P T )2 , (19) where the approximation in equation (18) has conveniently set the coefficient on the right hand side of equation (19) to unity. Equation (19) gives us the relaxation factor needed for the tile sizes to make the transition from MSP searches in short, to those in longer period binaries. We can now treat the entire search with the short period binary formalism, by letting the tiles expand by a factor of max(α, 1), as α increases with increasing orbital -- 8 -- period. It is no accident that 2π/√42 ≈ 1 ≈ (2√3/5)0.5, i.e., the larger tile size cuts on just when increasing orbital period, P , or decreasing observation time, T , causes the increments in equation (12), relative to ap, to exceed those of equation (11). The step sizes for the orbital period must be small enough so that the drift in orbital phase caused by the period mismatch is less than or equal to the phase subtended by a tile edge (drawn through the tile center) on the Zφ plane: δ( 1 P )T ≡ δF T ≈ 0.43c 4π2f ap sin i (cycles) ; or : δΩ ≈ 0.43c 2πT f ap sin i (radians s−1) . (20) A point which starts at an offset of x, of a tile edge unit, along the tile diagonal perpendicular to the (radial) direction to the origin of the Zφ plane, and then moves by y, of a tile edge unit, in the same direction due to orbital period mismatch (approximating the circumferential arc by a straight line) could easily share/duplicate its Fourier power among three different tiles. Assuming losses to Fourier power add directly (as in a quadrature sum) we can compute the total loss of power in the tile of the point's origin, in units of the 10% worst case mismatch, as: ∆(PF )I (PF )I = x2 + xy + y2 3 . (21) (22) (23) The loss of power to the two tiles whose common edge lies in the path of the point is: ∆(PF )II (PF )II = 3/4 + (x − 3/2)2 + (x − 3/2)y + y2 3 . These become equal on the line in the x-y plane given by: y = 2(1 − x) , with a 13/12 × 10% = 10.8% maximum loss of Fourier power occurring for the y = 1 (and x = 1/2) case posited by equation (17). For points in the Zφ plane which begin halfway (radially) between the tile center and edge, proceeding parallel (and thus ∼circumferentially) to those already discussed, the total loss of power in the tile of origin is: ∆(PF )III (PF )III = 3/16 + x2 + xy + y2 3 ; and the loss in the downstream neighboring tile is given by: ∆(PF )IV (PF )IV = 3/16 + (x − 3/2)2 + xy + y2 3 . These become equal on the line in the x-y plane given by: y = 3/2 − 2x , (24) (25) (26) -- 9 -- with a 5/6 × 10% = 8.3% maximum loss of Fourier power occurring when y = 1 (and x = 1/4). With these steps, we note that the total amount of computation needed by such a search is proportional to the fourth power of f and T , two powers to cover the Zφ plane, another power in the step sizes for the orbital period, and the last factor due to the size of each Fourier transform. Larger worst-case losses will be incurred, of course, by "inter-binning " the resulting Fourier transforms, as much as 19% (even as in MDK) unless more than two Fourier elements are used. At this point, a more sophisticated inter-binning is probably worth the extra computation to reduce the loss to 10% (four elements), or even 6% (six elements). However, the impact of cruder interbinning can be eliminated in two stage post- Fourier analyses, with candidates overselected in the first stage, prior to a second stage that accurately finds the frequencies of their true maximum power, and then uses these as the basis for a search for related harmonics. As the loss of Fourier power produced by the second harmonic (2f ) structure in the MSP's pulse profile is quadruple that for the fundamental, it is worth including subharmonics in the search algorithm (see §2.4). When the boundary between short and long periods is reached (P ≥ T ), it is understood that the tile size merely scales by (P/T )2. If the same number of cases are done, the area being covered on the Zφ plane increases. Thus, in almost all practical searches, the differential number of cases needed for (P ≥ T ) decreases by (P/T )2. 2.3. Example As a hypothetical test case, we assume that our target pulsar has a period of 5 ms, i.e., is 4.54 times as fast as the J0737A spin rate of 44.05 Hz. In order to calculate the work necessary to find such a pulsar in a circular orbit with the same period and (since the inclination of the J0737 system is nearly 90 degrees) semimajor axis, we must first calculate the area of the disk on the Zφ plane we need to search. The radius vector of this disk is given by: 2πf ap sin i ρm = = 1778 (radians), (27) c where we distinguish ρ as the radius of the disk on the Zφ plane, where Zφ itself is just the amplitude of the phase modulation as given in equation (14). The number of hexagonal tiles in each ring can be counted as two for every 3/√5 radians (when counting the number of rings later, we will count these as only one ring), with every other tile offset by 1/2 the flat- flat distance (p3/5 = √0.6 ≈ 0.775) in the radial direction, and are separated by 3/(2√5) -- 10 -- radians circumferentially: Nt(ρ) = 2πρ 3/(2√5) = 4√5 3 πρ = 16, 655 ( ρ ρm ) (tiles). Dividing ρ by the flat-flat distance, we can count the number of rings: Nr(ρ) = √15 3 ρ = 2, 296 ( ρ ρm ) (rings). (28) (29) The total number of tiles in the disk of radius, ρ, can then be estimated by the product of the two, times 1/2, due to the integral over the linear ramp of the number of tiles per ring: Ndisk(ρ) = 1 2 Nt(ρ) × Nr(ρ) = 1/2 4√5 3 √15 3 πρ ρ = √3πρ2 . 10 9 (30) It would have been easier to just take the disk area, πρ2, and divide by the area per tile, 0.3√3 radians2: Ndisk(ρ) = πρ2 0.3√3 = 10 9 √3πρ2 = 1.91 × 107( ρ ρm )2. (31) However, to compute the total amount of processing needed we need Nt(ρ) to weight by NP (ρ), the number of trial orbital periods, prior to integrating (see just below). Assuming our observation time, T , is 17,669 s, twice the J0737 orbital period of 8,834.5 s (P7), we will search over a range in orbital frequency, from: to: Ωn = 2π T = π P7 = 3.56 × 10−4 (radians s−1), Ωx = 2π P7 = 7.11 × 10−4 (radians s−1). (32) (33) For observation times longer than 2P7 = 17, 669 s, the relaxation factor from equation (19) applies and the amount of added computation, relative to that needed for 2P7 to P7, is down by a factor of 3. As in equations (20) and (27) the spacing of the orbital frequency search gets finer as ρ increases, so that the drift of the vector on the Zφ plane does not exceed 1/√5 radians: δΩ = . (34) 1 (√5T ρ) When we calculate diminishing trial periods from T to P7, the number of trial orbital periods needed in a given ring is: NP (ρ) = (Ωx − Ωn) δΩ = 2π( 1 P7 − 1 2P7 )√5T ρ = √5πρ = 2.5 × 104( ρ ρm ) (trial periods). (35) -- 11 -- Now we can multiply the number of trial periods per tile, by the number of tiles per ring, and finally by the number of rings to get the total work. This time we need a factor of 1/3 for the integration of the ρ2 term: NF F T (ρ) = 1 3 NP (ρ)Nt(ρ)Nr(ρ) = 40 27 √15π2 T Pmin ρ3 = 3.18 × 1011( ρ ρm )3. (36) Equation (36) shows why it is much easier to detect the slower component of double pulsar systems, such as the 0.36 Hz J0737B, thus gaining exact knowledge of the orbital period, phase (and eccentricity), and approximate knowledge of the companion's semi-major axis. 2.4. Mitigating Factors and Other Details In the example above the typical size for each FFT would be set by an ∼2 kHz sampling rate, times 8834 s, or about N = 224 samples. Processor speeds are such that each these can be done in under a second. The problem arises, however, in getting the 300 billion processor- seconds. There is usually enough memory local to modern processors to accommodate the relatively short FFT's, so that the computing can proceed in the "embarrassingly parallel" mode. The large number of trials also requires an extra 25.8 units of power to amortize, which is enough to be significant in just one trial. However, the coherent addition of higher and/or lower harmonics (e.g., as in M00, equation [1]) can make up for this quickly, particularly for the first three harmonics of spin periods of 15 ms or longer. Targeted searches which first find the 0.1% to 0.5% most significant "seed" events in the Fourier transform, can be used to coherently investigate trains of whole, half, and 1/3 harmonics. These can be evaluated in only one extra pass through the Fourier spectrum, with very little loss by using an interpolation involving at least six complex amplitudes. Such a technique can avoid missing significant periodic signals due to the statistical fluctuations in the seeds, generally with an expected mean power level between 10 (−3 +4.5) and 17 (−4.24 + 6) (i.e., with otherwise a much greater potential loss of power than just 10%) because down fluctuations in all three seeds are unlikely, and the coherent summing process, once started, is insensitive to them. In addition, the more extensive searches will, of necessity, have seeds with more power, and hence smaller frequency errors, making them more efficient in the harmonic summation process, particularly when including the whole integer higher harmonics (and thus whole integer multiples of the error in the fundamental frequency). Still, this amount of computation is prohibitive. It is possible that by convolving the original Fourier spectrum with perfectly matched filters for the phase modulation between one tile and its neighbors (a process that utilizes -- 12 -- short FFT's in memory also local to the processors [REM02]) that the majority of the longer FFT's do not have to be computed. Only six convolution templates need to be used, each representing a residual phase modulation for a vector, with a length of a tile flat-flat (√3 tile edges) on the ZΦ plane. This set of seven tiles forms one "7tile." Next, we can use six more templates, for vector offsets of √21 tile edges (e.g., [4.5,√3/2] etc.) to go from the original tile to the center tiles of the six neighboring 7tiles, and then we can flesh out these neighboring 7tiles by again using the six tile diagonal length convolutions, to form a "49tile." The steps in orbital period have to as fine as needed for the most radially distant tile in the 49tile. Since we are assuming that even the large FFT's fit entirely within memory local to each processor and FFT computation in such circumstances takes on the order of log2(N) this technique can only reduce the amount of computation required by a factor of four at best, and even then only with a much faster, and likely less effective, harmonic searching algorithm. 3. Discussion Fortunately, there may be reasons to believe that the MSPs found in DNSBs will, no matter how the MSPs entered into the pre-DNSB, have periods longer than 15 milliseconds, even though shorter period MSP members would not be easily detected. Although the predominant species of neutron stars (NSs) are the merger-spawned, weakly magnetized, MSPs with an initial spin period of ∼2 ms (M04a) at first glance it would seem to be very difficult to incorporate these into DNSBs as the MSP companion. There is not enough time for massive stars to capture them before they suffer their Fe catastrophe SNe, but if this does happen, then a 2 ms MSP in a DNSB becomes a real possibility. The less massive companions can not evolve into pre merger-target white dwarfs, again because the Fe catastrophe of the massive star happens too quickly. However, it is perfectly feasible for accretion to slow an NS rotation that is retrograde wrt the orbital angular momentum, a frequent outcome of NS capture as well as post-capture merger-induced core collapse, both of which would most likely result from binary-binary collisions. Thus, if an NS is captured, then accretion from the pre-Fe catastrophe massive star could slow its spin to 50 Hz, or below. Double merger, and/or single merger and a disruption accretion disk, both resulting from binary-binary collisions, could also deliver a weakly magnetized MSP and a post merger companion sufficiently massive to progress to an Fe catastrophe SN, thus "speeding up" its evolutionary clock. Whether these mechanisms are prevalent enough to produce the current distribution of DNSBs remains in question. However, condensed or collapsed core (CC) globular cluster (GC) stellar densities don't -- 13 -- seem to be required for the Galactic plane to make its share of fast (P ≤ 15 ms) i.e., merger- spawned MSPs, and the numbers of such MSPs in the two categories are about the same. However, given that the GCs are generally farther away (save for B1913+16 and J1811-1736 at 7 and 6 kpc, respectively, closer than 47 Tuc and M4, at 4 kpc and 2 kpc) and on account of their known dispersion measures, their MSPs have been discovered in longer time series observations. This selects against discovering GC, relative to Galactic plane (GP) DNSBs, thus the current GC/GP DNSB ratio of 1 to 7 is not unexpected for the same formation mechanism in both locations. Some even hold that accretion onto a directly rotating (prograde) NS can also slow its spin rate (Kundt 2002), and there may be some evidence for this in the MSP population of the GCs (see below). In this case, the DNSB can gain its MSP through, again most likely, binary-binary collisions in which the MSP companion is captured (but not likely, except in the case of double merger, formed by white dwarf-white dwarf merger and subsequent core collapse). An epoch of accretion ensues which then, relatively quickly, slows the NS spin. Later, the companion undergoes an Fe catastrophe SN and forms the highly magnetized NS. This opens up the possibility that DNSBs could have MSP components spinning faster than ∼50 Hz, and the reason none have been found so far would have to be due to the kinds of selection effects discussed here. It is also possible that, because the accretion onto the J0737As must always happen if the progenitors of the J0737Bs are to evolve into Fe catastrophe SNe, the 2 ms periods may never occur for the J0737As by the time of the Fe catastrophe SNe of the pre-J0737Bs. Before getting more specific about the details of the evolution of the J0737 binary system, we can still draw a few preliminary conclusions. Observations prohibit the MSP companions from being produced directly by their Fe catastrophe SNe, unless they are born so weakly magnetized as to persist as radio live pulsars beyond the epochs of their companions' impending Fe catastrophe SNe. Although some Fe catastrophe SNe have been born spinning faster than 100 Hz (Marshall et al. 1998), and some 3D calculations have indicated that a weakly magnetized NS could result from one (Fryer & Warren 2004) the very state of the remnants of the last SNe in DNSBs testifies otherwise. Out of eight DNSBs, seven have radio-dead companions, and the last (J0737B) has a 1.2 × 1012 G field and is spinning so slowly (2.8 s) as to have one foot already in the grave. In addition, the numbers of weakly magnetized Fe catastrophe SNe are limited because the gamma ray burst (GRB) rate sets a strict lower limit to the incidence of merger-induced SNe (Schmidt 1999, M04a). (In case there remain any lingering doubts that SN 1987A, merger-induced core collapse SNe, and GRBs are intimately related, we note, from M04a, that the product of the energy of the "mystery spot," 1049 ergs, and the beaming factor for GRBs, 105, yields 1054 ergs, a fair fraction of the maximum assumed isotropic fluence of GRBs.) Thus, unless we argue, that -- 14 -- in spite of the limited rate, some of the seven are similar to Cas A (Tananbaum 1999), with no evidence of a magnetic field it at all, Fe catastrophe SNe can only rarely produce NS remnants with the weak fields typical of MSPs, if ever. Field growth in pulsars due to magnetic/thermal interaction (Blandford, Applegate, & Hernquist 1983) even after hundreds of years, must also be considered unlikely, again because of Cas A. Thus the eight DNSBs constitute the best evidence so far that Fe catastrophe SNe usually produce remnants with magnetic fields well in excess of 1010 Gauss. In addition, PSR J0737A has a spin rate of 44 Hz, and, extrapolating backward, its initial rate, just prior to the pre-J0737B Fe catastrophe SN, was not much higher. This spin rate is more typical of those few MSPs with slower spins (Chen, Middleditch, & Ruderman 1993, hereafter CMR93) and distinctively sharp pulse profiles such as M15 A, B, C, and G (Anderson 1992; Chen & Ruderman 1993, hereafter CR93) and another handful in the other CC GC clusters and Galactic plane, that most agree have actually been recycled. Thus, J0737A must have been accreting from a star massive enough to undergo Fe catastrophe core collapse, and in spite of that was still spinning at only 50 Hz at that epoch some 50 Myr ago. Taken at face value, this supports the picture of predominant, fast (2 ms) merger-induced MSPs, versus the slower, recycled (and hence rare) MSPs. The "standard" model for DNSB formation starts with two massive, (but not equally so) stars, and requires two different types of accretion at two different epochs. The first involves the evolution of the more massive companion star A (the precursor to J0737A) and unstable mass transfer onto star B (the precursor of J0737B) as a way of avoiding a common envelope inspiral in short period binaries (Battacharya & van den Heuvel 1991; Dewi & van den Heuvel 2004; Willems & Kalogera 2004). Star A then undergoes an Fe catastrophe SN, leaving J0737A with the helium-rich companion, star B, which then evolves and overflows its Roche lobe, beginning the second epoch of mass transfer (this time sta- ble) onto J0737A as a high mass X-ray binary system (HMXB). This era of accretion spins up J0737A to an intermediate rotational frequency, while reducing its effective magnetic dipole moment. Star B evolves and undergoes an Fe catastrophe SN, leaving the highly magnetized NS, J0737B. Following this logic, if accretion were the only way to get a rapidly spinning NS, then the DNSBs would constitute the best evidence so far that the magnetic field configuration of an NS can be modified by accretion. But, of course, it isn't (M04a). The assumption implicit in the standard model, is that a longer interval of accretion in a binary (∼ 109 yrs) can typically spin up an NS to rotate as fast as 500 Hz, so that a shorter interval of accretion (∼ 5 × 107 yrs) while star B evolves toward its Fe catastrophe SN, is sufficient to spin it up from 0 to 50 Hz, and reduce its magnetic field to a value typical of MSPs. However, as already mentioned, GRBs require a certain number of merger-spawned -- 15 -- MSPs born with periods near 2 ms, leaving less and less room in the MSP population for those expected to be recycled into spinning as fast as 500 Hz. In addition, the details of the MSP population in the globulars do not support recycling as the origin of the fast MSPs (2-15 ms, M04a). So perhaps recycling may so ineffective that it could even have a hard time just spinning up J0737A from 0 to 50 Hz in only 5 × 107 yrs. The similarity of the distribution of MSP spin periods in the DNSBs (23 to 104 ms) to that of the "truly" recycled MSPs in the CC GCs (23 to 111 ms, with the 30.5 ms M15C in common) is uncanny, and, if not due to selection effects, could have physical meaning. It may only go so far, however, as J1811-1736 and B1913+16, with the longest periods of the eight DNSBs (104 and 59 ms) have the broadest (even relative) pulse profiles, W50(ms)/P0(s) = 225 and 207 (ATNF 2004 -- note that W50 is a function of the frequency band and time resolution of the observation, so caution must be used), with the rest scattering between 18 and 106. The same relation for the MSPs M15A-H, respectively, yields, in (W50/P0, P0) pairs: (18,111), (61,56), (43,31), (271,4.8), (172,4.65), (197,4.0), (21,38), and (104,6.7) (Anderson 1992) and thus shows the opposite trend. The relation in DNSBs may be due to varying amounts of accretion, while that in M15 may be due mostly to age. However, age may also have affected B1913+16, in that it has slowed significantly in just the last 108 years, leaving the putative varying spinup-caused direct relation between P0 and W50/P0 intact only for J1811-1736. If we ignore J1811-1736, then M15C and J0737, with periods of 30.5 and 22.7 ms, have W50/P0s of 43 and 106, consistent with the trend in the CC GCs, but the evidence is sparse, and M15C belongs to both distributions, so the issue of similarity in the trend of W50/P0 between the DNS, and the CC GC MSPs remains undecided. The W50/P0 versus P0 relationship for the entire pulsar population has a power law trend with an index near -0.8, indicating wider pulse profiles with decreasing period, until it reaches the (mostly recycled) MSPs at P0 = 0.1 s, at which point there are many pulsars with pulse profiles that are too narrow, such as M15A, C, and G. These start a new trend with roughly the same power law, that connects to the MSPs with periods shorter than 23 ms. There is a gap here, but this is due to not having W50s for the 28.8 ms pulsar, J0621+1002, and the 23.1 ms pulsar, J1804-0735 in the GC NGC 6539, and, of course, J0737A will also help fill it. The new trend is about a factor of ten below (toward narrower pulse profiles) any W50/P0 value of the extrapolation from the longest period pulsars, which is good because the continuation of the upper track exceeds 1000 near P0 = 10 ms, thus becoming unphysical (the ∼1.6 ms pulsars B1937+21 and B1957+20 fall below even the lower track). The dichotomy of the slow/narrow versus the fast/broad pulsars in M15 and the other CC GCs then, can also be viewed as consequence of this trend, and the near order of magnitude geometric mean difference factor between the sets of long and short spin periods. So instead of asking why some pulse profiles are wider than others, it may make -- 16 -- more sense to ask why the distribution of spin periods of the CC GCs is bimodal. All of this begs the question of if and how the recycling history of seven of eight DNSB MSPs differs from that of the CC GC MSPs, and how is the configuration of the NS magnetic field affected by each and why? The recycled GC MSPs, including those in M15, certainly had no several-solar mass helium star from which to accrete, so they must have managed with leaner pickings, or, again, the accretion itself slowed them. What is apparent from "normal" accretion is that, the more magnetized the NS, the slower the equilibrium spin frequency, from MSPs (though this evidence is sparse), through the HMXBs, and on down to AXPs/magnetars. Somehow, the field manages to get modified and we're still unsure if we have ever witnessed this process. Thus, if only non-braking accretion occurs, there obviously have to be a few different states, from "super-critical" on down, that have different effects on NS magnetic field configuration, and it is clear that particular extreme is not happening in HMXBs such as Cen X-3 and SMC X-1, or even Her X-1. Both the standout ∼1.6 ms pulsars, B1937+21 (Backer et al. 1982) and B1957+20 (Fruchter, Stinebring, & Taylor 1988), have very narrow (double) pulse profiles consistent with magnetic to (single) rotational pole migration due to accretion stresses during recy- cling, without their (now very close together) polar surface field strengths being significantly attenuated (CR93). As mentioned above, these are both located at the bottom extreme of the high frequency end of of the lower W50/P0 vs P0 track. If accretion can slow the spin of most NSs, then it is tempting to say that these two quite possibly form the entire class of (initially) strongly magnetized, and later, recycled MSPs, with all of the rest hav- ing weak magnetic fields at birth, through recycling (or not), and afterward. In any case, they are the rarest of rare pulsars, being first selected against, by as much as a factor of a hundred, because they were offspring of Fe catastrophe SNe (M04a) and then (perhaps) again by another factor of 10, because they somehow had to have very special accretion/field configuration-modifying circumstances. The number of "standard" MSPs exceeds that of the "non-standard" MSPs, B1937+21 and B1957+20, by about the same factor that the number of merger-induced SNe exceeds the number of Fe catastrophe-induced SNe, lending support to the possibility that accretion can act differently on the fewer strongly magnetized NSs than it does on their much more numerous, but less magnetized cousins. Still we do not yet know how accretion spins up a few strongly magnetized NSs, such as B1937+21 and B1957+20, to very high rotation rates, and why it is not all that effective at doing the same with the weakly magnetized (per Alpar et al. 1982), but pulsar recycling appears to work this way. Studies of this problem are still in their infancy (Cumming 2004). For now, however, we must conclude that there is a remote possibility that a 1.6 ms pulsar will be a member of a DNSB. -- 17 -- The last remaining holdout is J0034-0534, a pulsar in a 1.6 day binary with a low mass companion in a circular orbit of ∼10 lt-s (Bailes et al. 1994). This unique pulsar has a record low magnetic field and near record broad pulse profile, a 1.87 ms spin period, and a very steep radio spectrum (ATNF 2004), all of which make it a candidate for a merger of a white dwarf with a weakly magnetized NS (Middleditch 2004b). The spin period is shorter (just) than the 2.1 ms minimum period for merger-spawned pulsars (Camilo et al. 2000; M00) and longer than ∼1.6 ms (the "Chen Gap," after Kaiyou Chen). The pulse profile, however, is not dramatically wider in W50/P0 than the mean of the low P0 distribution extrapolated to this frequency1 but, at this point there is very little room for increase. Again, there is only a very remote possibility that such a pulsar will be a member of a DNSB. The more likely cousins to J0737, and certainly the easiest to find, short of detecting the younger, slower, strongly magnetized member, may be other similar systems, with a modestly fast MSP, like J0737A, and shorter or longer orbital periods, but at this point, we can not rule out selection effects favoring slower MSPs over faster. Nevertheless, we take, as an example, a pulsar with the same total mass of 2.58 solar, in a binary system with an orbital period of 1472 s, six times shorter than P7, the 8,834 s orbital period of J0737, and our assumed observation interval. To keep the argument simple, we relax the constraint on total mass for orbital periods longer than 1,472 s. Otherwise, ρm scales as (P/(1, 472s))2/3 and the work scales as (P/(1, 472s))2 as P gets larger. For this case, ap sin i = 0.43 lt-s and ρm = 119 radians. The amount of computation needed for orbital periods longer than P7, relative to that required for P7 to P7/6, is down by a factor of 15. The number of trial orbital periods needed at ρm for the range of 8,834 s to 1472 s is NP = 8, 332. The number of tiles/ring at ρm, Nt = 1, 111. And finally, the number of rings at ρm, Nr = 153. In this case the amount of computation needed at ρm (recall the factor of 1/3 in equation [36]) is only 4.73× 108, nearly a factor of a thousand less, and very accessible to modern computers. The reduction is due to two factors, the first being the decrease by a factor of 3.3 of the semimajor axis, which produces a factor of 36 when cubed. The second is the factor of 4.54 reduction in pulsar frequency, from 200 to 44 Hz, producing a factor of 94. Together these produce a factor of 3,375, or the cube root (15) in ρm (unrelated to the factor of 15 which applies to the long-to-infinite orbital period cases posited above). Against this, we used more trial orbital periods by a factor of 5 in the 1,472 s example, so our net reduction in calculation is about 675. The Fourier transforms are also shorter for this example, but the bad news is that the associated harmonic searches will work well only for 22 Hz and lower spin frequencies (for the 2nd harmonic), and 14 Hz and slower for the third harmonic. The good news is that 1Ignoring the erroneous values of 998 for J2051-0827 (the true value is about 60 -- Stappers et al. 1996) and the additionly unreferenced value of ∼3600 for J1807-2459! -- 18 -- the work required for fixed mass scales as P 2 as P gets smaller, while, at the same time, the pulsar orbit is more likely to be circular. Other alternatives include just reducing the observation time analyzed by a factor of 4, to 2,208 s, which would sacrifice a factor of 2 in signal-to-noise ratio, but which would also change the fully computationally intensive upper limit period from 8,834 s down to 2,208 s, reducing the amount of computation to 2,208 s by a nearly a factor near 2.3, in addition to the factor of 256 reduction everywhere, counting FFT lengths. Like the original example in §2.3 such a search would be effective up to the third harmonic of a 15 ms pulsar. Of course, if we want to search for MSPs with black hole companions, the total mass of the binary system will almost certainly exceed three solar, with the required amount of computation rising steeply with black hole mass. 4. Conclusion In this work we have derived the form of the transition between acceleration binary pulsar searches and truly short period binary pulsar searches. We have also shown here that although the amount of computation needed to search for MSPs in short period-high companion mass binary systems appears to be stupendous, rising as the fourth power of both the observation time and targeted upper limit pulse frequency, many such searches are now within our grasp, given intelligent choices of ranges for the unknown parameters. Recent advances in the understanding of the nature of supernovae and their compact remnants (e.g., M00, M04a, and this work, §3) can play a crucial role in narrowing otherwise prohibitively expensive computer searches for MSPs in binary systems. The easiest, and perhaps, most likely candidates for more DNSBs are similar to J0737 (though this is far from certain) with a weakly magnetized NS spinning only moderately fast. The possibility of finding any pulsar in a DNSB, with a ∼10 to 1.5 ms period, appears to be very remote, but many crucial details of DNSB formation and the pulsar recycling process remain mysteries. The astonishing similarity between the MSP periods in the DNSBs and the those of the longer period MSPs found only in the CC GCs, including the one MSP/DNSB in common, M15C, calls the standard model, which requires back accretion from a several solar mass, pre-Fe catastrophe SN helium star, into question, in spite of what Lorimer et al. (2004) would have us believe. Other options include MSP formation via binary-binary collisions and spindown via the reverse accretion. For the short period X-ray binary systems in particular, the range of parameters for such searches can be narrowed with exact knowledge of the orbital period and approximate -- 19 -- knowledge of the pulsar candidate's projected semi-major axis and orbital phase. Searches for MSPs in binary systems where one pulsar is already known, can be narrowed even further, as the orbital period, phase, and eccentricity are known exactly. However, slowly-rotating (non- MSP) pulsar companions in DNSBs do not require a very sophisticated search in order to set stringent upper limits, and eventually Relativity will likely provide all the orbital elements for the undetected companion NS, although these have much shorter radio lifetimes. Finally, even though this work does not discuss how to treat eccentricity, it can serve as a guide in the cases for which it is known exactly. We thank Scott Ransom for discussions. This work was performed under the auspices of the Department of Energy, and supported in part by the Institute for Nuclear and Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (INPAC). -- 20 -- REFERENCES Alpar, M. A., Cheng, A. F., Ruderman, M. A., & Shaham, J. 1982, Nature, 300,728 Anderson, S. B. 1992, PhD thesis, California Institute of Technology ATNF 2004, www.atnf.csiro.au/research/pulsar/psrcat Backer, D. C., Kulkarni, S. R., Heiles, C., Davis, M. M., & Goss, W. M. 1982, Nature, 300, 615 Bailes, M., et al. 1994, ApJ, 481, 386 Battacharya, D., & van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 1991, Phys. Rep., 481, 386 Blandford, R. D., Applegate, J. H., & Hernquist, L. 1983, MNRAS, 204, 1025 Burgay, M., et al. 2003, Nature, 426, 531 Camilo, F., Lorimer, D. R., Freire, P., Lyne, A. G., & Manchester, R. N. 2000, ApJ, 535, 975 Champion, D. J., Lorimer, D. R., McLaughlin, M. A., Cordes, J. M., Arzoumanian, Z., Weisberg, J. M., & Taylor, J. H. 2004, preprint (astro-ph/0403553) Chen, K., Middleditch, J., & Ruderman, M. A. 1993, ApJ, 195, L51 (CMR93) Chen, K., & Ruderman, M. A. 1993, ApJ, 408, 179 (CR93) Cumming, A. 2004, preprint (astro-ph/0404518) Dewi, J. D. M., & van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 2004, MNRAS, 349, 169 Dib, R., Ransom, S., Ray, P., & Kaspi, V. 2004, preprint (astro-ph/0401134) Faulkner, A. J., et al. 2004, in preparation Fruchter, A. S, Stinebring, D. R., & Taylor, J. H. 1975, ApJ, 195, L51 Fryer, C. L., & Warren, M. S. 2004, ApJ, 601, 391 Hulse, R., & Taylor, J. H. 1975, ApJ, 195, L71 Kalogera, V., et al. 2004, ApJ, 601, L179 -- 21 -- Kundt, W. 2002, in Proc of the 270. WE-Hearus Seminar, Neutron Stars, Pulsars and Supernova Remnants, ed. W. Becker, H. Lesch, & J. Trumper, MPE, 278, 206 Lorimer, D. R., et al. 2004, preprint (astro-ph/0404274) Lyne, A. G., et al. 2000, MNRAS, 312, 698 Lyne, A. G., et al. 2004, Science, 123, 456 Marshall, F. E., Gotthelf, E. V., Zhang, W., Middleditch, J., & Wang, Q. D. 1998, ApJ, 499, L79 Middleditch, J. 2004a, ApJ, 601, L167 (M04a) Middleditch, J. 2004b, abstract, LAUR 04-2113 (M04b) Middleditch J., & Cordova, F. A. 1982, ApJ, 255, 585 Middleditch, J., Deich, W. T. S. & Kulkarni, S. R. 1992, in Isolated Pulsars, ed K. A. Van Riper, R. Epstein, & C. Ho (Cambridge Univ. Press), 372 (MDK) Middleditch, J., et al. 2000, NewA, 5, 243 (M00) Middleditch, J., & Nelson, J. E. 1976, ApJ, 208, 567 Nelson, R. W., Finn, L. S., & Wasserman, I. 1990, ApJ, 346, 226 Nice, D. J., Sayer, R. W., & Taylor, J. H. 1996, ApJ, 466, L87 Prince, T. A., Anderson, S. B., Kulkarni, S. R., & Wolszczan, A. 1991, ApJ, 374, L41 Ransom, S. M., Cordes, J. M., & Eikenberry, S. S. 2003, ApJ, 589, 911 Ransom, S. M., Eikenberry, S. S., & Middleditch, J. 2002, AJ, 124, 1788 Schmidt, M. 1999, ApJ, 523, L117 Stappers, B. W., et al. 1996, ApJ, 465, L119 Tananbaum, H. 1999, IAU Circ. 7246 Willems, B., & Kalogera, V. 2004, ApJ, 603, L101 Wolszczan, A. 1991, Nature 350, 688 This preprint was prepared with the AAS LATEX macros v5.2.
astro-ph/0404529	1	0404	2004-04-27T13:28:20	Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02	[ "astro-ph" ]	The Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS) is a cosmic ray (CR) experiment that will operate on the International Space Station for three years, measuring the particle spectra in the rigidity range from 0.2 GV to 2 TV. The AMS-02 detector will provide measurements with unprecedented statistics of the hadronic and leptonic cosmic rays, allowing for a better study of the Earth magnetosphere through the secondaries produced by CR interactions in the atmosphere; of the solar system environment through the measurement of the solar modulation over a long period; of the solar system neighborhood through the measurement of the ratio between unstable isotopes and stable elements; of the interstellar medium of our Galaxy through the ratio between secondary and primary isotopes and the measurement of proton and helium spectra.	astro-ph	astro-ph	Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 Diego Casadei INFN, Sezione di Bologna Via Irnerio 46, 40126 Bologna, Italy April 27, 2004 The Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS) is a cosmic ray (CR) experiment that will operate on the International Space Station for three years, measuring the particle spectra in the rigidity range from 0.2 GV to 2 TV. The AMS-02 detector will provide measurements with unprecedented statistics of the hadronic and leptonic cosmic rays, allowing for a better study of the Earth magnetosphere through the secondaries produced by CR interactions in the atmosphere; of the solar system environment through the measurement of the solar modulation over a long period; of the solar system neighborhood through the measurement of the ratio between unstable isotopes and stable elements; of the interstellar medium of our Galaxy through the ratio between secondary and primary isotopes and the measurement of proton and helium spectra. 1 Introduction The Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS) is a cosmic ray (CR) experiment that will operate on the International Space Station (ISS) for three years, measuring the particle spectra in the rigidity range from 0.2 GV to 2 TV. The first version of the detector, called AMS-01, was flown on board of the space shuttle Discovery in 1998, from June 2 to 12. The second version of the detector, called AMS-02, will operate on the ISS starting from year 2007. AMS-01 collected more than hundred million events, and the results were published about the CR protons and antiprotons, helium, electrons and positrons, and the upper limit on the antimatter ratio (for a review, see Ref. [1]). The physics goals of the AMS experiment are: (1) the search for antinuclei among the CR, that would be a smoking gun in favor of the existence of cosmic antimatter in form of anti-stars (figure 1, left panel, shows the upper limits on the antihelium to helium ratio); (2) the search for signatures of the supersymmetric dark matter candidates, looking at the antiproton and positron spectra (figure 1, right panel, shows the expected distortion of the positron to electron ratio that would be 1 Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 2 . . )10 L C % 5 9 ( o 10 10 i t 10 a R x u F m u l i l / e H m u 10 10 i l e h i t 10 n A 10 −2 −3 −4 −5 −6 −7 −8 −9 (c) − ) e + + e ( / + e (a) Buffington et al. 1981 (b) Golden et al. 1997 (c) Badhwar et al. 1978 (d) AMS−01 (1998) (e) BESS (1993−2000) (b) (c) (a) (d) (e) BESS Polar (1 month) PAMELA, 3 years AMS−02, 3 years HEAT 94−95 −1 10 −2 10 Signal+bkg bkg Moskalenko−Strong DM signal AMS−02 1 year 1 10 2 10 Rigidity (GV) 3 10 1 10 2 10 E (GeV) Figure 1: Upper limits on the CR antihelium to helium ratio (left panel), and a possible signature of the neutralino annihilation in the ratio between CR positrons and electrons (right panel). TOF TRD Tracker t e n g a M ACC TOF RICH ECAL Figure 2: The AMS-02 detector. produced by the annihilation of 65 GeV/c2 neutralinos [2]); (3) the high-statistics study of the CR particle spectra up to 1 -- 2 TV rigidity. The AMS-02 detector (figure 2) is able to make multiple measurements of the energy lost by the particles traversing it, of their track and of their velocity [3]. The basic technique for particle recognition lays on the measurement of the energy loss, giving the particle charge absolute value, of the track curvature, giving the particle rigidity, and of the velocity value and direction, that gives the charge sign together with the curvature measurement. The anticoincidence system (ACC) vetoes tracks crossing the magnet, hence all Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 3 Figure 3: The trapped electrons and positrons measured by AMS-01. particles must traverse the transition radiation detector (TRD), the time of flight system (TOF), the silicon tracker and the proximity focusing Cerenkov detector (RICH). About half of them will also produce a shower in the electromagnetic calorimeter (ECAL), placed below the RICH. RICH and TOF are used to dis- tinguish electrons and positrons from antiprotons and protons down to 0.2 GeV, whereas TRD and ECAL allow for the e/p separation up to 300 GeV, that is the upper energy limit for the antiproton and positron measurements. Nuclei can be separated from antinuclei up to the maximum detectable rigidity, i.e. up to 2 TV. Finally, gamma rays can be detected in the largely unexplored energy range above few tens of GeV. This paper focuses on the "ordinary" CR astrophysics items that can be studied with the help of the AMS-02 detector. They are necessary steps before anyone will trust the possible exotic results of the measurement, but they are also important for the understanding of our Galactic environment. 2 Cosmic Ray Astrophysics 2.1 Earth Magnetosphere Figure 3 shows the trapped electrons and positrons measured by AMS-01, as func- tion of the geographic coordinates. The orbit inclination was 51.7◦ and the altitude ranged between 350 and 390 km. Field countours at 380 km are also shown. Back- tracing every event, all particles started from the Earth atmosphere were considered secondary [4]. Secondary electrons and positrons were detected after a time τ since Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 4 5.293 / 25 AMS−01: meas. protons AMS−01: proton LIS 1 − ) V e G ) 1 − V G 1 − s 1 − r s 2 − m ( F 4 10 3 10 2 10 10 1 φ = (0.632 ± 0.013) GV γ LIS = 2.84 ± 0.01 NLIS = (23700 ± 1100) m −2 sr −1 s −1 GV 1.84 −1 10 −2 10 −1 10 −2 10 −3 10 −4 10 −5 10 −6 10 AMS−02 AMS−01 BESS (95+97) BESS 93 IMAX CAPRICE MASS 91 1 − 1 − 2 − s r s m ( x u l f n o t o r p i t n A 1 10 2 10 R (GV) 10 −1 1 10 Kinetic energy (GeV) 10 2 Figure 4: The protons measured by AMS-01 can be used to measure the solar modulation parameter (left panel). The antiproton to proton ratio is also sensitive to the solar modulation (right panel). their creation, and it was found that they can be divided into two populations: "short-lived" e+/e− (τ < 0.1 s, left panel) originated uniformly (one can follow the AMS-01 orbits in the left panel), whereas "long-lived" e+/e− (τ > 1 s, right panel) were bouncing between two mirror points. This is due to the kinematics of charged particles in the asymmetric geomagnetic field, that was sampled by a detector mov- ing between geomagnetic latitudes from roughly 75◦ North to 75◦ South. Hence, an orbiting detector is a powerful instrument to study the trapped particles in the geomagnetic field. 2.2 Solar Modulation The solar activity, parametrized with the number of sun spots or with the value of the interplanetary magnetic field, is anticorrelated with the total CR flux on the top of the atmosphere, as measured for example with high mountain neutron detectors. The Sun affects the diffusion of charged particles below several GeV/nucl following its 22-years cycles (solar modulation). Figure 4, left panel, shows the solar modulation first-order effect on the proton spectrum measured by AMS-01 [5], that it is expected to be a single power-law in rigidity R = pc/(Ze) down to hundred MV. At the next order, the solar modulation has a charge-sign dependent effect that can be best seen in the antiparticle/particle ratio, as shown in the right panel with antiprotons. This plot shows also the expected statistics for AMS-02, that has the potential to discover high energy bumps that could be produced by exotic sources, like the annihilation of neutralinos, the supersymmetric candidates for the dark matter [2]. Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 5 ) 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 e B 0 1 / e B 9 AMS−02 (1 year) ACE Ulysses ISOMAX Voyager ISEE−3 2 V e G 1 - s 1 - r s 2 - m ( F 3 0.1 0.09 0.08 0.07 Strong & Moskalenko k E 10 10 10−1 10 Kinetic energy (GeV/n) 1 10 3 10 2 10 1 -1 -2 AMS-01 BETS97+98 Nishimura 2000 HEAT95 HEAT94 CAPRICE94 MASS91 MASS89 Tang 1984 Golden 1984 Prince 1979 Buffington 1975 Meegan 1975 Nishimura 1980 Fanselow 1969 -1 10 1 10 2 3 10 10 Ek (GeV) Figure 5: Beryllium (left) and electron (right) measurements. The expected AMS-02 statistics is shown in the left panel. Figure 6: CR proton (left) and helium (right) flux measurements are compared to AMS-02 expected statistics. 2.3 Local bubble and solar system neighborhood The solar system is inside the "local bubble", a low-density region with scale length of 100 pc with irregular shape, that is the result of the explosion of several supernovae in the neighborhood [6]. Recent simulations [7] show that the ratio between unstable and stable isotopes is very sensitive to the features of the local bubble. Figure 5, left panel, shows the expected AMS-02 statistics for the 10Be/9Be measurement. One can probe larger distances measuring the electron and positron spectra, Cosmic Ray Astrophysics with AMS-02 6 and the ratio between stable secondary species to primary nuclei, like the ratios of Li, Be and B to C. In particular, electrons (figure 5, right panel) can diffuse for relatively short time compared to CR nuclei, because of their large radiative losses. High energy electrons (with E ∼ 1 TeV) can reach distances of the order of 1 kpc, comparable with the galactic disk thicness, and lower energy electrons can propagate further beyond this limit: with electrons, the spherical propagation model becomes a rough approximation and a two-phases (disk and halo) cylindrical model is normally used. 2.4 Galactic Interstellar Medium A two-phases cylindrical model of the Galaxy is also used to simulate the propagation of protons and helium nuclei (figure 6) in the interstellar medium, where they diffuse for roughly 2 × 107 years. Protons and helium nuclei are the deepest charged probes of the Galaxy: they diffuse on the average through one third of the Galactic disk and in the halo, before being measured [7]. Other primary nuclei, like carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and iron, travel for long distances in the interstellar medium, where their interactions produce the secondary nuclei (Li, Be, B, and sub-Fe elements) that are not produced by the stellar nucleosynthesis, and whose fluxes are used to constrain the parameters of the galactic CR diffusion. AMS-02 will provide very accurate measurements of all elements up to Fe, thus allowing for a deeper knowledge of the characteristics of the CR sources (supernova explosions) and the interstellar medium. References [1] Aguilar, M. et al., Phys. Rep., vol. 366, no. 6 (2002) 331. [2] Lamanna, G., Proc. of the 28th ICRC (2003) 2001. [3] Alcaraz, J. et al., NIM A478 (2002) 119. [4] Alcaraz, J. et al., Phys. Lett. B 484 (2000) 10. [5] Casadei, D. & Bindi, V., Proc. of the 28th ICRC (2003) 2001. [6] Ma´ız-Apell´aniz, J., ApJ 560 (2001) L83. [7] Maurin, D. et al., A&A 394 (2002) 1039.
astro-ph/0506285	1	0506	2005-06-13T18:28:12	Metals in Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift	[ "astro-ph" ]	The chemical composition of high-redshift galaxies is an important property that gives clues to their past history and future evolution. Measuring abundances in distant galaxies with current techniques is often a challenge, and the canonical metallicity indicators can often not be applied. I discuss currently available metallicity indicators based on stellar and interstellar absorption and emission lines, and assess their limitations and systematic uncertainties. Recent studies suggest that star-forming galaxies at redshift around 3 have heavy-element abundances already close to solar, in agreement with predictions from cosmological models.	astro-ph	astro-ph	From Lithium to Uranium: Elemental Tracers of Early Cosmic Evo- lution Proceedings IAU Symposium No. 228, 2005 V. Hill, P. Fran¸cois & F. Primas, eds. c(cid:13) 2005 International Astronomical Union DOI: 00.0000/X000000000000000X Metals in Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift Claus Leitherer Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Dr., Baltimore, MD 21218, USA email: [email protected] Abstract. The chemical composition of high-redshift galaxies is an important property that gives clues to their past history and future evolution. Measuring abundances in distant galaxies with current techniques is often a challenge, and the canonical metallicity indicators can often not be applied. I discuss currently available metallicity indicators based on stellar and interstellar absorption and emission lines, and assess their limitations and systematic uncertainties. Recent studies suggest that star-forming galaxies at redshift around 3 have heavy-element abundances already close to solar, in agreement with predictions from cosmological models. Keywords. galaxies: abundances, galaxies: high-redshift, galaxies: starburst, ultraviolet: galax- ies 1. Introduction Until recently, abundance determinations at cosmological redshifts (z & 2) were limited to bright quasars and the material along their sightlines. Over the past 5 -- 10 years, the number and nature of accessible objects has expanded dramatically, and "normal" star- forming galaxies at high redshift have become targets of abundance studies (Pettini 2004). This progress was made possible by the use of efficient search techniques for finding large numbers of candidate galaxies (Steidel et al. 1999) and by the availability of 8 -- 10-m class telescopes for spectroscopic studies. I will discuss the general properties of these galaxies, introduce the techniques used for determining abundances, and provide an overview of their chemical composition. I will conclude with a cosmological perspective. 2. Sample The galaxies discussed in this paper are commonly referred to as Lyman-break galaxies (LBG; Giavalisco 2002) because of the search technique employed to detect them. They are color-selected via their strong Lyman discontinuity and/or their blue restframe ultra- violet (UV) colors. These galaxies are sufficiently bright for obtaining spectroscopic data (25m & R & 21m) -- a necessary prerequisite for abundance analyses. Owing to the selec- tion criterion, they are relatively dust-poor with typical visual attenuations of AV ≃ 1m and are fairly luminous, but not ultraluminous (L ≃ 1011 L⊙). LBGs are actively star- forming at rates of order 102 M⊙ yr−1 (Pettini et al. 2001) and have correspondingly short recycling times. Therefore the chemical composition of the newly formed stars and the interstellar gas are identical. Most LBGs are in the redshift range 2 . z . 3.5. The lower and upper limits are imposed by atmospheric cut-offs in ground-based observations and decreasing efficiencies of the search techniques. The corresponding lookback times in a standard universe are 11 Gyr . t . 12.5 Gyr, or about 15% of the age of the universe after its formation. 1 5 0 0 2 n u J 3 1 1 v 5 8 2 6 0 5 0 / h p - o r t s a : v i X r a 2 Claus Leitherer Figure 1. Comparison between the observed spectrum of MS1512 -- cB58 (solid) and two syn- thetic models with 1/4 Z⊙ (lower; dashed) and Z⊙ (upper; dotted). The models have continuous star formation, age 100 Myr, and Salpeter IMF between 1 and 100 M⊙. The stellar lines are weaker in the metal-poor model (from Leitherer et al. 2001). 3. Techniques -- Restframe Optical versus UV Abundance determinations typically fall into two categories, either relying on indica- tors in the restframe optical, or on those in the restframe UV. The restframe optical wavelength region has traditionally been used to determine galaxy abundances from nebular emission lines. At a redshift of z = 3, the restframe optical is observed in the near-infrared (IR) H and K bands. Spectroscopic observations of LBGs in the near-IR have become technically feasible (e.g., Pettini et al. 2001) but abundance analyses are still challenging. Only the strongest lines such as, e.g., Hα, Hβ, [N II] λ6584, or [O III] λ5007 are detectable at sufficient S/N. Even when good-quality spectra are available, the atmospheric windows usually restrict the wavelengths to a narrow range, which precludes commonly used techniques such as the classical R23 strong-line method (McGaugh 1991). The need for alternative variants of the classical strong-line method led Pettini & Pagel (2004) to readdress the usefulness of the N2 and O3N2 ratios. The former is defined as the ratio [N II] λ6584 over Hα and was recently discussed by Denicol´o et al. (2002); the latter includes the oxygen line for the ratio ([O III] λ5007/Hβ)/([N II] λ6584/Hα) and was originally introduced by Alloin et al. (1979). After calibrating the two abundance indicators with a local H II region sample, Pettini & Pagel find that O3N2 and N2 predict O/H to within 0.25 dex and 0.4 dex at the 2 σ confidence level, respectively. The observed frame optical wavelength region corresponds to the restframe UV of LBGs. The UV contains few nebular emission lines in star-forming galaxies (Leitherer 1997) and has rarely been used for chemical composition studies in local galaxies of this type. Fig. 1 compares the UV spectrum of the LBG MS1512 -- cB58 with theoretical spectra (Leitherer et al. 2001). Three groups of lines can be distinguished: (i) Interstellar absorption lines, most of which are strong and heavily saturated. Only in very few cases can unsaturated absorption lines in LBGs be used for an abundance analysis. (ii) Broad stellar-wind lines with emission and blueshifted absorption. These lines are the telltales of massive OB stars whose stellar winds are metallicity dependent. (iii) Weak photospheric absorption lines which can only be seen in high-quality spectra. Abundance studies from stellar lines in restframe UV spectra must rely either on suitable template stars or on extensive non-LTE radiation-hydrodynamic models which are only beginning to become available (Rix et al. 2004). Metals in High-z Galaxies 3 4. The Chemical Composition of LBGs An initial, rough estimate of the heavy-element abundances can be obtained from the equivalent widths of the strong UV absorption lines. Heckman et al. (1998) pointed out the close correlation of the Si IV λ1400 and C IV λ1550 equivalent widths with O/H in a sample of local star-forming galaxies. This correlation seems surprising, as these stellar-wind lines are deeply saturated. The reason for the metallicity dependence is the behavior of stellar winds in different chemical environments. At lower abundance, the winds are weaker and have lower velocity, and the lines become weaker and narrower. As a result, the equivalent widths are smaller at lower O/H. If the same correlation holds at high redshift, the observed equivalent widths in LBGs suggest [O/H] ≃ -- 0.5 (Leitherer 1999). A similar, somewhat weaker correlation exists between O/H and the equivalent widths of the strongest interstellar lines. This is even more unexpected because the equivalent widths of saturated lines have essentially no dependence on the column density Nion: W ∝ b[ln(Nion/b)]0.5. Therefore the correlation must be caused by the b factor, and therefore by velocity. More metal-rich galaxies are thought to host more powerful starbursts with correspondingly larger mechanical energy release by stellar winds and supernovae. The energy input leads to increased macroscopic turbulence and higher gas velocities at higher O/H (Heckman et al. 1998). If the same applies to star-forming galaxies in the high-redshift universe, their measured equivalent widths again indicate an oxygen abundance of about 1/3 the solar value. Pettini et al. (2001) determined oxygen abundances in five LBGs from emission lines in restframe optical spectra. The redshift range of the sample dictated the use of the R23 method. The galaxies turned out to be rather metal-rich, with O/H somewhat below the solar value. This is roughly in agreement with restframe UV results, and an order of magnitude above the metallicities found in damped Lyman-α absorbers (DLA) which are found at the same redshift. Because of the double-valued nature of the R23 method, the possibility exists but is deemed less likely that the sample has oxygen abundances of only 1/10 the solar value. The lensed LBG MS1512 -- cB58 and its bright restframe UV spectrum can be studied at sufficiently high S/N and resolution to detect and resolve faint, unsaturated interstellar absorption lines. Pettini et al. (2002) measured numerous transitions from H to Zn cov- ering several ionization stages. Abundances of several key elements could be derived. The α-elements O, Mg, Si, P, and S all have abundances of about 40% solar, indicating that the interstellar medium is highly enriched in the chemical elements produced by type II supernovae. In contrast, N and the Fe-peak elements Mn, Fe, and Ni are all less abundant than expected by factors of several. In standard chemical evolution models, most of the nitrogen is produced by intermediate-mass stars, whereas type Ia supernovae contribute most of the Fe-peak elements. Since the evolutionary time scales of intermediate- and low- mass stars are significantly longer than those of massive stars producing the α-elements, the release of N and the Fe-group elements into the interstellar medium is delayed by ∼109 yr. MS1512 -- cB58 may be an example of a star-forming galaxy in its early stage of chemical enrichment, consistent with its cosmological age of only about 15% of the age of the universe. Mehlert et al. (2002) provided similar arguments to explain variation of the C IV λ1550 line relative to Si IV λ1400 in a small sample of LBGs. C IV appears to decrease in strength relative to Si IV from lower to higher redshift, which may reflect the time delay of the carbon release by intermediate-mass stars. The interstellar lines in LBGs have blueshifts with velocities of up to several hun- dred km s−1 indicating large-scale outflows. The associated galactic mass-loss rates of ∼102 M⊙ yr−1 are comparable to the rates of star formation. The newly formed heavy 4 Claus Leitherer Figure 2. Left pair of panels: comparison of the observed spectrum of MS1512 -- cB58 (thick) with fully synthetic spectra (thin) for five different metallicities, from twice solar to 1/20 solar. First panel: region around 1425 A; second: region of the Fe III blend near 1978 A. Each pair of panels is labeled with the metallicity of the synthetic spectrum shown. Right pair of panels: same as left pair, but for Q1307 -- BM1163 (from Rix et al. 2004). elements are removed from their birth sites by stellar winds and supernovae and are trans- ported into the halo and possibly into the intergalactic medium (Pettini et al. 2002). Detailed studies of weak interstellar lines such as that done for MS1512 -- cB58 remain a technical challenge, even for high-throughput spectrographs at the largest telescopes. Furthermore, the results for Fe-peak elements carry some uncertainty because of the a priori unknown depletion corrections. Abundance analyses using stellar lines are not affected by depletion uncertainties. However, the existence of non-standard element ratios precludes the use of locally observed template spectra for spectral synthesis. Therefore our group (F. Bresolin, R. Kudritzki, C. Leitherer, M. Pettini, S. Rix) has embarked on a project to model the spectra of hot stars and link them with a spectral synthesis code to predict the emergent UV spectrum of a composite stellar population as a function of metallicity. We generated a grid of hydrodynamic non-LTE atmospheres with the WM- basic code (Pauldrach et al. 2001) and calculated the corresponding UV line spectra. The resulting library was incorporated into the Starburst99 code (Leitherer et al. 1999) which then allowed us to compute a suite of model spectra for appropriate stellar population parameters. As a first application, we used several faint stellar blends around 1425 A and 1978 A as a metallicity indicator (Rix et al. 2004). The 1425 A feature is a blend of Si III, C III, and Fe V, and the 1978 A absorption is mainly Fe III. The synthesized spectra for five metallicities are compared to the observed restframe UV spectra of MS1512 -- cB58 and Q1307 -- BM1163 in Fig. 2. The model having 40% solar metal abundance provides the best fit to the data, in agreement with the results from other methods. A variety of independent techniques lead to consistent results for the chemical com- position of LBGs. While each method by itself is subject to non-negligible uncertainties, Metals in High-z Galaxies 5 Figure 3. Metallicity-luminosity relationship. Data for local spiral and irregular galaxies are from Garnett (2002). The z = 2 objects are overluminous for their (O/H) abundances, derived using the N2 calibration of Pettini & Pagel (2004) but lie closer to the relationship for the local galaxies than z = 3 LBGs (from Shapley et al. 2004). the overall agreement of the results gives confidence in the derived abundances. LBGs at z ≃ 3 have heavy-element abundances of about 1/3 the solar value. 5. Cosmological Perspective Star-forming galaxies at z ≃ 3, at an epoch when the universe's age was only 15% the present value, display a high level of chemical enrichment. What does their chemical composition tell us about their relation to other galaxies at lower redshift and to other structures found at z = 3? Galaxies at somewhat lower redshift have only recently become accessible for detailed study due to the combined challenges of instrumentation and the galactic spectral prop- erties. Shapley et al. (2004) obtained K-band spectroscopy of seven UV-selected star- forming galaxies at redshifts between 2 and 2.5. The N2 method calibrated by Pettini & Pagel (2004) was used as an abundance diagnostic. When compared to the original higher-z LBGs, the z ≃ 2 sample is more metal-rich. This can be seen in Fig. 3, where O/H of the z = 2 galaxies is compared with that of LBGs at z ≃ 3 and of local star- forming galaxies over a range of blue luminosities. The latter were analyzed with the R23 method. The z = 2 sample has almost solar chemical composition but is still less metal-rich than local late-type galaxies with comparable luminosities. As a caveat, the comparison rests on the assumption that the N2 and R23 calibrations have no significant offset. The difference between the average redshift of the LBG sample and of the z = 2 galaxies translates into a mean age difference of about 1 Gyr. Both the chemical proper- ties and the masses of the z = 2 galaxies and LBGs are consistent with standard passive evolution models. Kewley & Kobulnicky (2005) followed the metallicity evolution of star-forming galaxies with comparable luminosities from z = 0 to 3.5. O/H was determined from restframe optical emission lines using the strong-line method in four homogeneous galaxy samples. The samples were taken from the CfA2 survey, from the GOODS field, from Shapley et al. (2004), and from the LBG sample, covering z ≈ 0, 0.7, 2.1 − 2.5, and 2.5 − 3.5, respectively. The average oxygen abundance in the local universe, as defined by the CfA2 sample is about solar. O/H decreases with redshift to approximately 1/3 solar at z = 3. 6 Claus Leitherer It is instructive to compare the heavy-element abundances of LBGs to those of DLAs and to the Lyman-forest at the same redshift (Pettini 2004). DLA systems have metallic- ities of about 1/15 Z⊙ and are thought to be the cross sections of the outer regions and halos of (proto)-galaxies seen along the sightlines of quasars. Although the properties of LBGs and DLAs do not immediately support a close relation between the two classes of objects, at least some link seems likely. If so, the observed outflows in LBGs may provide the metal enrichment of the halos. The Lyman-forest is predicted by cold dark matter models to result from structure formation in the presence of an ionizing background. The Lyman-forest had long been thought to be truly primordial, but metal enrichment of 1/100 -- 1/1000 Z⊙ has recently been detected (Aguirre et al. 2004). This relatively high metal abundance early in the evolution of the universe could have been produced by a first generation of Population III stars. Such stars can account for the amount of metals, and at the same time could have provided copious ionizing photons, as metal and photon production are closely correlated. Alternatively, star-forming galaxies at high redshift could be the production sites of the metals seen in the intergalactic medium if superwinds are capable of removing the newly formed metals from galactic disks. Acknowledgements I would like to thank Max Pettini for a careful reading of the manuscript and for providing invaluable comments. References Aguirre, A., Schaye, J., Kim, T., Theuns, T., Rauch, M., & Sargent, W. 2004, ApJ, 602, 38 Alloin, D., Collin-Souffrin, S., Joly, M., & Vigroux L. 1979, A&A, 78, 200 Denicol´o, G., Terlevich, R., & Terlevich, E. 2002, MNRAS, 330, 69 Garnett, D. R. 2002, ApJ, 581, 1019 Giavalisco, M. 2002, ARAA, 40, 579 Heckman, T. M., Robert, C., Leitherer, C., Garnett, D., & van de Rydt, F. 1998, ApJ, 503, 646 Kewley, L., & Kobulnicky, H. A. 2005, in R. de Grijs & R. M. Gonz´alez Delgado (eds.), Star- bursts: From 30 Doradus to Lyman Break Galaxies, (Dordrecht: Springer), p. 307 Kulkarni, V. P., Fall, S. M., Lauroesch, J. T., York, D. G., Welty, D. E., Khare, P., & Truran, J. W. 2005, ApJ, 618, 68 Leitherer, C. 1997, in: W. H. Waller, M. N. Fanelli, J. E. Hollis, & A. C. Danks (eds.), The Ultraviolet Universe at Low and High Redshift:, (Woodbury: AIP), p. 119 Leitherer, C. 1999, in: J. Walsh & M. Rosa (eds.), Chemical Evolution from Zero to High Redshift, (Berlin: Springer), p. 204 Leitherer, C., Leao, J. R. S., Heckman, T. M., Lennon, D. J., Pettini, M., & Robert, C. 2001, ApJ, 550, 724 Leitherer, C., et al. 1999, ApJS, 123, 3 McGaugh, S. 1991, ApJ, 380, 140 Mehlert, D., et al. 2002, A&A, 393, 809 Pauldrach, A. W. A., Hoffmann, T. L., & Lennon, M. 2001, A&A, 375, 161 Pettini, M. 2004, in: C. Esteban, R. J. Garc´ıa L´opez, A. Herrero, & F. S´anchez (eds.), Cosmo- chemistry, XIII Canary Islands Winter School, (Cambridge: CUP), p. 257 Pettini, M., Rix, S. A., Steidel, C. C., Adelberger, K. L., Hunt, M. P., & Shapley, A. E. 2002, ApJ, 569, 742 Pettini, M., Shapley, A. E., Steidel, C. C., Cuby, J., Dickinson, M., Moorwood, A. F. M., Adelberger, K. L., & Giavalisco, M. 2001, ApJ, 554, 981 Rix, S. A., Pettini, M., Leitherer, C., Bresolin, F., Kudritzki, R., & Steidel, C. C. 2004, ApJ, 615, 98 Shapley, A. E., Erb, D. K., Pettini, M., Steidel, C. C., & Adelberger, K. L. 2004, ApJ, 612, 108 Steidel, C. C., Adelberger, K. L., Giavalisco, M., Dickinson, M. & Pettini, M. 1999, ApJ, 519, 1
astro-ph/0111086	1	0111	2001-11-05T14:48:11	High-Mass Stars as Early Signpost of Cluster Formation	[ "astro-ph" ]	The connection between high-mass stars and young stellar clusters has been well established by near-IR observations showing young massive stars in HII regions surrounded by clusters of lower mass stars. Mm-wave observations show that these clusters form in approx. 1000 Msol dense cores. Interestingly, the mm-wave observations of very active cluster-forming regions also reveal the presence of seemingly quiescent dense massive cores, which contain few signs of ongoing star formation. In the W3 Main region we find an approx. 1000 Msol mass dense core which contains no mid-IR or cm-continuum sources. Near-IR imaging has failed to detect any embedded sources. Yet, we suggest that this region is at an early stage of cluster formation. This is given support by comparative observations of the NGC 6334 GMC. Here, we find another quiescent massive 1000 Msol core without mid-IR sources, HII regions, or a detectable near-IR cluster. Motivated by the presence of CH3OH and H2O masers in this IR-quiet core, we have searched for and detected a bipolar outflow driven by a young massive star deeply embedded in the core. The presence of an embedded high-mass star strengthens our arguments that IR-quiet cores are at an early stage of cluster formation. We propose that masers and outflows from very deeply embedded (and consequently IR-quiet) high-mass stars are among the first incipient signposts of cluster formation in massive cores. Accordingly, we have undertaken a SEST survey of 46 CH3OH maser clusters which are not coincident with IRAS sources or HII regions. From this sample, we detected outflows in transitions of SiO toward 15 of the maser clusters. These sources have now been observed at 1200 micron with SIMBA, the 37-multichannel bolometer at SEST. Each one is associated with a bright 1 mm point source.	astro-ph	astro-ph	TITLE ASP Conference Series, Vol. VOLUME, PUBLICATION YEAR EDITORS High-Mass Stars as Early Signpost of Cluster Formation Achim R. Tieftrunk & S. Thorwirth KOSMA, I. PI der Universitat zu Koln, Zulpicher Str. 77, 50937 Koln S. T. Megeath Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 Abstract. The connection between high-mass stars and young stellar clusters has been well established by near-IR observations showing young mas- sive stars in H ii regions surrounded by clusters of lower mass stars. Millimeter-wave observations show that these clusters form in ≈ 1000 M⊙ dense cores. Interestingly, the mm-wave observations of very active cluster- forming regions also reveal the presence of seemingly quiescent dense massive cores, which contain few signs of ongoing star formation. In the W3 Main region, next to the cluster-forming cores W3 SMS1 & 2, we find a ≈ 1000 M⊙ mass dense core which contains no mid-IR or cm- continuum sources. Near-IR imaging of this core has failed to detect any embedded sources. Yet, we suggest that this region is at an early stage of cluster formation. This is given support by comparative observations of a similar twin core system in the NGC 6334 GMC. Here, north of the highly active star-forming core NGC 6334 I, we find another quiescent massive ≈ 1000 M⊙ core without mid-IR sources, H ii regions, or a de- tectable near-IR cluster. Motivated by the presence of CH3OH and H2O masers in this IR-quiet core, we have searched for and detected a bipolar outflow driven by a young massive star deeply embedded in the core. The presence of an embedded high-mass star strengthens our arguments that IR-quiet cores are at an early stage of cluster formation. We propose that masers and outflows from very deeply embedded (and consequently IR-quiet) high-mass stars are among the first incipient signposts of clus- ter formation in massive cores. Accordingly, we have undertaken a SEST survey of 46 CH3OH maser clusters from the survey of Walsh et al. (1998) which are not coincident with IRAS sources or H ii regions. From this sample, we detected outflows in transitions of SiO toward 15 of the maser clusters. These sources will now be observed at 1200 µm with SIMBA, the 37-multichannel bolometer at SEST. 1 2 A. R. Tieftrunk 1. Introduction High-mass stars, although rare, are a major contributor of energy to the ambi- ent ISM, be it during their birth in the form of jets and outflows, during their UV-radiating lifetime, or during their spectacular death as supernovae. They are commonly detected in rich clusters of stars and to date an example of iso- lated high-mass star formation has not been observed. Thus, if one wants to understand the process of high-mass star formation, one must understand the physical processes which lead to the formation of entire clusters of stars. Fur- thermore, the dense clusters may influence the formation of massive stars, and may even be a required precursor for high-mass star formation. Is the formation of high-mass stars a natural implication of the stellar density and the possible interaction and coalescence of low-mass stars in large clusters? Do low-mass stars therefore need to form before a high-mass star can be fused? Or is it that high-mass stars simply form independently in the same dense environment as low-mass stars through the same processes of mass accretion? In this contribution, we present observations which show the presence of massive reservoirs of seemingly quiescent dense gas in close proximity to highly active cluster-forming cores. We argue that these reservoirs are at an early stage of star formation, where the usual signposts of massive stars and cluster formation -- strong mid-IR emission, bright radio continuum sources, and dense clusters of stars in 2 µm imaging -- are absent. Instead, the only signatures of star formation comes from deeply embedded high-mass stars, namely masers, powerful outflows, and luminous submm sources. We propose that some of the youngest regions of cluster formation may be found by using these early signposts of high-mass star formation, and describe an ongoing search for such regions. 2. High-mass Star Formation in Clusters From observations of 100 open clusters, Battinelli & Capuzzo-Dolcetta (1991) concluded that the star formation rate in clusters in our galaxy is 225 M⊙Myr−1 kpc−2, whereas the SFR near the sun is 3000 -- 5000 M⊙Myr−1kpc−2. From ob- servations of Perseus, L1641, 50% of L1630, and Mon R2 as part of the Two Micron All Sky Survey, Carpenter (2000) deduces that the largest fraction of stars must form in clusters. In fact, 70% of the young stars identified in Carpen- ter's analysis are in clusters with more than 100 members. This then leads one to the conclusion that the 10% still seen as open clusters are simply those that remain bound long after their parental molecular clouds are dissipated. The dispersal of the molecular gas in clusters is very much a function of their most massive members. High-mass stars (> 5 M⊙, corresponding to spectral type B6 or earlier) are always found to be associated with rich clusters with stellar densities of more than 1000 stars per pc3. These clusters are thus affected by the dispersive jets, the intense UV fields and, if the cluster remains bound after the dispersal of the molecular cloud, the ensuing supernovae of the massive stars. From observation of Herbig Ae/Be stars, Testi, Palla, & Natta (1999) con- clude that the lack of clusters around stars later than B7 -- B8 is an imprint of the stellar formation mode for high-mass stars. The process of high-mass star forma- tion within dense clusters through spherical accretion has been a long-standing High-Mass Stars as Early Signpost of Cluster Formation 3 problem. At around 8 -- 10 M⊙ the radiation pressure of the forming star begins to inhibit further infall of the material accreting (e.g. Yorke & Kruegel 1977, Kahn 1974, Larson & Starrfield 1971). Models including rotating protostellar grainy disks (e.g. Jijina & Adams 1996, Wolfire & Cassinelli 1987), magnetic fields (Balsara et al. 2001, Nakano 1998), and accretion rates growing with time (Behrend & Maeder 2001) can certainly push this limit very much higher, but the theories about the physical backgrounds for the accretion process are still open for much discussion. At stellar densities of around 107pc−3 accretion induced collision may begin to have a significant effect on the formation of high-mass stars up to the point where fusion of lower mass stars may actually form the more massive members (e.g. Bonnell et al. 1998, Stahler et al. 1998). These two scenarios for forming massive stars in clusters -- accretion and star coalescence -- are the focus of the current debate. 3. Early Signposts of High-Mass Stars High-mass stars are typically formed in warm (≈ 30 K), dense (n(H2) ≈ 105 cm−3), compact (≈ 50, 000 AU) and massive (≈ 1000 M⊙) dust cores, easily traced in CS, CH3CN, HC3N, or NH3 and the submm-continuum with typical FIR luminosities of 103 − 105 L⊙. These cores are usually associated with H2O, CH3OH, H2CO, NH3, and/or OH masers and often, at a later stage when the most massive members are emerging from their natal cocoons, hyper- or ultra- compact H ii regions. Often one can find shock-excited H2 emission knots at 2.1 µm and/or high-velocity bipolar outflows from broad wings in SiO or 13CO molecular emission lines. These molecular outflows typically have masses of around 150 (10 -- 5000) M⊙ and outflow rates of 3 × 10−5 − 3 × 10−2 M⊙yr−1 (Garay & Lizano 1999). Outflows and certain types of masers appear very early on in the formation process, long before luminous IR sources or H ii regions can be detected. Sheperd & Churchwell (1996) have shown that the outflow properties seem to be correlated with the luminosity of the embedded sources driving the outflows. Although new observation by Henning et al. (2000) are in support of this, a recent analysis of a number of massive outflows seems to indicate that this empirical relationship breaks down with increasingly higher mass (cf. contribution by Beuther et al., this issue). 3.1. W3 SMS3 W3 Main is a well-studied and very active region of high-mass star formation in the W3 GMC at a distance of 2.3 kpc. The W3 Main region is 10 pc north of the W3(OH) region and consists of two main molecular cores: W3 East & West. Towards W3 East we find a dense stellar cluster associated with the lumi- nous infrared source IRS 5 embedded in the compact molecular core W3 SMS1 (Tieftrunk et al. 1998). Towards this region Megeath et al. (1996) detected the highest density of stars: a cluster of ≈ 80 − 300 low-mass stars, corresponding to a stellar density of a few 103 pc−3. The bright source IRS 5 itself is associated with a massive bipolar outflow (Hasegawa et al. 1994) and a cluster of H2O masers where Claussen et al. (1994) have detected a number of hypercompact H ii regions with diameters less than 1000 AU. Towards IRS 4, embedded in the compact molecular core W3 SMS2, Tieftrunk et al. (1997) found another similar 4 A. R. Tieftrunk Figure 1. Contour plot of a 6 cm continuum VLA image superim- posed on the C18O emission from Tieftrunk et al. (1997). Contours are (2 − 20) × 2, 24, 30, 40, 60, 80, and 100 mJy/beam. Continuum compo- nents and 450 µm sources indicated by crosses are labeled. hypercompact H ii region. The presence of hypercompact sources indicates that the massive stars are just beginning to ionize their surrounding cores (Tieftrunk et al. 1997). Just to the south of IRS 4, is the molecular core W3 West/SMS3 (Ladd et al. 1993). This dense core is seemingly quiescent: it is devoid of mid-IR sources and radio continuum sources, and 2 µm imaging has failed to detect a cluster in SMS3 (Tieftrunk et al. 1998). Since SMS3 has a molecular mass and density higher than the surrounding cluster-forming cores, Tieftrunk, Gaume & Wilson (1998) argued that the SMS3 core may be at an early stage of cluster formation. 3.2. NGC 6334 I(N) Towards the north-eastern edge of the giant molecular cloud NGC 6334 (Fig. 2), at a distance of 1.7 kpc (Neckel 1978), another massive twin core system can be found: NGC 6334 I and I(N) (Fig. 3). As W3 SMS1 & 3, these two cores present 13CO 1-0 emission mapped with the SEST towards the Figure 2. giant molecular cloud NGC 6334. The twin cores NGC 6334 I & I(N) are found in the elongated structure towards the north-east. High-Mass Stars as Early Signpost of Cluster Formation 5 C18O (2-1) [left] and HC3N (15-14) [right] emission Figure 3. mapped with SEST toward the twin core system NGC 6334 I & I(N). a unique duet for studying the evolution of stellar clusters and the interstellar chemistry in young star-forming cores. NGC 6334 I, with a total mass of ≈ 1000 M⊙ and a dust temperature of ≈ 100 K, is a dense and compact molecular hot core associated with an ultracompact cometary H ii as well as a strong IR continuum region and a group of CH3OH, H2O, OH, and NH3 masers. It is considered to be the youngest of the star-forming regions in the NGC 6334 GMC, exhibiting the richest chemistry of all sources. In fact, our SEST data shows that this source is comparable to Orion-KL and Sgr B2 in the richness of its spectrum. However, in comparison to these sources where the preponderance of line blending is a principal problem for assigning emission lines or detecting new transitions, line widths in NGC 6334 I are 2 -- 4 times more narrow allowing for a significantly higher detection rate of weaker features (Fig. 4). In fact, we detected a plethora of line features down to a noise level of 0.01 K and expect that Sgr B2 and Orion-KL will be replaced by NGC 6334 I as the new standard source in searches for new interstellar molecules and transitions (Tieftrunk & Thorwirth, in prep.). Only 1.5′ north (1 pc at 1.7 kpc) of NGC 6334 I a second core of roughly equal size, comparable mass, and a molecular hydrogen density of ≈ 106 cm−3 (Kuiper et al. 1995) is apparent (Sandell 2000). Designated NGC 6334 I/(North) [hereafter I(N)] it is notable for the lack of mid-IR emission: to date, no thermal infrared emission has been detected from this region at wavelengths < 100µm (Gezari 1982). It does not contain an H ii region. However, H2O and CH3OH (class I and II) masers have been detected in the core. Very recently, Megeath & Tieftrunk (1999) presented evidence from SEST and ESO-2.2m data for multiple outflows originating in I(N) (Fig. 5). Using the SiO and 13CO emission in the line wings towards I(N), we deduced an outflow mass of 7 M⊙, transporting ≈ 10−3 M⊙ yr−1. From the well-known relationship of Shepherd & Churchwell (1996) we thus estimated a luminosity of 103 L⊙ and a mass of 10 M⊙ for the driving source. Thus, the I(N) core already contains at least one high-mass (proto)star and is possibly on the verge of cluster formation (cf. also Sandell 2000). From these observations we conclude that the first detectable evidence for 6 A. R. Tieftrunk Figure 4. Sample spectrum of 1 GHz bandwidth around 263 GHz towards SgR B2(N) [bottom] and NGC 6334 I [top] taken from our survey covering approximately 140 GHz between 78 GHz and 268 GHz. cluster formation are the signposts of outflows and masers of the associated high- mass stars long before a dense 2 µm cluster itself appears. Thus the formation of intermediate to high-mass stars can at least precede the appearance of the associated cluster of low-mass stars. This, however, does not imply that low- mass stars would actually form later as well; they may be too deeply embedded to become visible to the observer at an early stage of the cluster formation. 4. IRAS-quiet maser clusters Surveys of the earliest stages of massive star formation have concentrated on UC H ii regions (e.g. Brand et al. 1984, Wood & Churchwell 1989), some associated with IRAS sources (e.g. Bronfman et al. 1996, Osterloh et al. 1997), and more recently, on luminous IRAS sources which are not associated with H ii regions (e.g. Zhang et al. 2001, Molinari et al. 2000, Sridharan et al. 1999). However, as demonstrated by NGC 6334 I(N) and W3 SMS3, the earliest phases of massive star formation are probably both radio and infrared-quiet -- analogous to the Class 0 phase of low-mass star formation -- and searches using the IRAS database may miss some of the youngest, most interesting sources. Due to the lack of unbiased submillimeter surveys of the galaxy, only a few truly deeply embedded massive protostars or Class 0 objects are known. From the ATCA survey by Walsh et al. (1998) we had selected 46 maser clusters that were radio- and IR-quiet, i.e. not associated with UC H ii regions and more than 1 pc (1′ -- 14′) away from the nearest IRAS point source. With the SEST we detected broad SiO emission line wings towards 15 of these, indicative of outflows. It is clear that these CH3OH maser clusters with SiO outflows must have a driving source. These sources, however, are inconspicuous in the mid-IR and thus must be deeply embedded. NGC 6334 I(N), which has a comparable flux density to NGC 6334 I at 400 µm, is much brighter at 1 mm (Gezari 1982). Thus, these deeply embedded objects appear to be the prominent sources when observed at 1 mm in a system of star-forming cores. With SIMBA, the 37- High-Mass Stars as Early Signpost of Cluster Formation 7 left: K-band image with contours of HC3N(15-14) emis- Figure 5. sion towards NGC 6334 I & I(N); right: continuum subtracted H2(ν = 1 − 0)S(1) emission (marked with vertical lines) and CH3OH maser positions (dots) towards I(N) with contours of blue (dashed) and red (dotted) SiO(5-4) line wings and the lowest HC3N(15-14) contour. multichannel bolometer of SEST, we will now observe the 1200 µm flux of the maser sources. Since dust emission at (sub)mm wavelengths is generally optically thin, it provides a much better contrast between high and low density gas than most molecular lines. From this sample of regions, we expect to find not only the youngest examples of high-mass star formation, but some of the youngest regions of cluster formation. With such a sample we can better study the relationship between high- and low-mass stars, as well as construct a better picture of the physical and chemical environment of molecular clouds at the onset of cluster formation. References Balsara, D. S., Ward-Thompson, D., & Crutcher, R. M. 2001, MNRAS, 327, 715 Battinelli, P. & Capuzzo-Dolcetta, R. 1991, MNRAS, 249, 76 Behrend, R. & Maeder, A. 2001, A&A, 373, 190 Bonnell, I. A., Bate, M. R., & Zinnecker, H. 1998, MNRAS, 298, 93 Brand, J., van der Bij, M. D. P., de Vries, C. P., Leene, A., Habing, H. J., Israel, F. P., de Graauw, T., van de Stadt, H. & Wouterloot, J. G. A. 1984, A&A, 139, 181 Bronfman, L., Nyman, L.-A., & May, J. 1996, A&AS, 115, 81 Carpenter, J. M. 2000, AJ, 120, 3139 Claussen, M. J., Gaume, R. A., Johnston, K. J., & Wilson, T. L. 1994, ApJ, 424, L41 Garay, G. & Lizano, S. 1999, PASP, 111, 1049 Gezari, D. Y. 1982, ApJ, 259, L29 8 A. R. Tieftrunk Hasegawa, T. I., Mitchell, G. F., Matthews, H. E., & Tacconi, L. 1994, ApJ, 426, 215 Henning, Th., Schreyer, K., Launhardt, R., & Burkert, A. 2000, A&A, 353, 211 Jijina, J. & Adams, F. C. 1996, ApJ, 462, 874 Kahn, F. D. 1974, A&A, 37, 149 Kuiper, T. B. H., Peters, W. L., III, Foster, J. R., Gardner, F. F., & Whiteoak, J. B. 1995, ApJ, 446, 692 Ladd, E. F., Deane, J. R., Sanders, D. B., Wynn-Williams, C. G. 1993, ApJ, 419, L186 Larson, R. B. & Starrfield, S. 1971, A&A, 13, L190 Megeath, S. T. & Tieftrunk, A. R. 1999, ApJ, 526, L113 Megeath, S. T., Herter, T., Beichman, C., Gautier, N., Hester, J. J., Rayner, J., & Shupe, D. 1996, A&A, 307, 775 Molinari, S., Brand, J., Cesaroni, R., & Palla, F. 2000, A&A, 355, 617 Nakano, T. 1998, ApJ, 494, 587 Neckel, T. 1978, A&A, 69, 51 Osterloh, M., Henning, Th., & Launhardt, R. 1997, ApJS, 110, 71 Sandell, G. 2000, A&A, 358, 242 Shepherd, D. S. & Churchwell, E. 1996, ApJ, 472, 225 Stahler, S. W., Palla, F., & Ho, P. T. 1998, in: Protstars and Planets IV, eds. Mannings, V. et al. Univ. of Arizona Press, Tucson, 397 Sridharan, T. K., Menten, K. M., Wyrowski, F., & Schilke, P. 1999, in: Pro- ceedings of Star Formation 1999, eds. Nakamoto, T., Nobeyama Radio Observatory, 183 Testi, L., Palla, F., & Natta, A. 1999, A&A, 342, 515 Tieftrunk, A. R., Gaume, R. A., Claussen, M. J., Wilson, T. L., & Johnston, K. J. 1997, A&A, 318, 931 Tieftrunk, A. R., Gaume, R. A., & Wilson, T. L. 1998, A&A, 340, 232 Tieftrunk, A. R., Megeath, S. T., Wilson, T. L., & Rayner, J. T. 1998, A&A, 336, 991 Walsh, A. J., Burton, M. G., Hyland, A. R., & Robinson, G. 1998, MNRAS, 301, 640 Wolfire, M. G. & Cassinelli, J. P. 1987, ApJ, 319, 85 Wood, D. O. S. & Churchwell, E. 1989, ApJS, 69, 831 Yorke, H. W. & Kruegel, E. 1977, A&A, 54, 183 Zhang, Q., Hunter, T. R., Brand, J., Sridharan, T. K., Molinari, S., Kramer, M. A., & Cesaroni, R. 2001, ApJ, 552, 167
1808.08412	1	1808	2018-08-25T11:32:22	Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	Pattern classification architectures leveraging the physics of coupled nano-oscillators have been demonstrated as promising alternative computing approaches, but lack effective learning algorithms. In this work, we propose a nano-oscillator based classification architecture where the natural frequencies of the oscillators are learned linear combinations of the inputs, and define an offline learning algorithm based on gradient back-propagation. Our results show significant classification improvements over a related approach with online learning. We also compare our architecture with a standard neural network on a simple machine learning case, which suggests that our approach is economical in terms of numbers of adjustable parameters. The introduced architecture is also compatible with existing nano-technologies: the architecture does not require changes in the coupling between nano-oscillators, and it is tolerant to oscillator phase noise.	physics.app-ph	physics	Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture D. Vodenicarevic,1 N. Locatelli,1 J. Grollier,2 and D. Querlioz1 1)Centre for Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, CNRS, Univ Paris-Sud, Universit´e Paris-Saclay, rue Andr´e Amp`ere, 91405 Orsay, France 2)UMP CNRS/Thales, Univ Paris-Sud, Universit´e Paris-Saclay, 1 Avenue Augustin Fresnel, 91767 Palaiseau, France (Dated: 31 May 2021) Pattern classification architectures leveraging the physics of coupled nano-oscillators have been demonstrated as promising alternative computing approaches, but lack effective learning algorithms. In this work, we propose a nano-oscillator based classification architecture where the natural frequencies of the oscillators are learned linear combinations of the inputs, and define an offline learning algorithm based on gradient back-propagation. Our results show significant classification improvements over a related approach with online learning. We also compare our architecture with a standard neural network on a simple machine learning case, which suggests that our approach is economical in terms of numbers of adjustable parameters. The introduced architecture is also compatible with existing nano-technologies: the architecture does not require changes in the coupling between nano-oscillators, and it is tolerant to oscillator phase noise. I. INTRODUCTION Heavy demand for cognitive processing of large amounts of data using machine learning software is in- creasing the strain on data center energy consumption and hand-held device battery autonomy 1. Many alter- native computing architectures are therefore being devel- oped to match the specificities of such tasks by trading precision and sequential computation speed for increased parallelism and improved energy efficiency2. Most of these approaches rely on digital operations to approxi- mate the non-linearities at the heart of cognitive algo- rithms. On the contrary, the human brain successfully performs cognitive tasks in an energy-efficient fashion using slow, noisy, variable, unreliable but naturally non- linear neurons 3. It is therefore highly attractive to mimic this approach of the brain, and to leverage non-linear de- vice physics to perform cognitive tasks more efficiently4,5. This idea takes special sense with the recent advances in nanotechnology, which provide fast, compact and inte- grable nano-oscillators, with coupling and synchroniza- tion capabilities: nano-oscillators based on mechanical vibrations6, oxide phase changes7, Josephson junctions8, or spintronics9,10. Multiple recent works draw inspira- tion from the oscillatory activity observed in the brain at different scales11 to naturally perform pattern classi- fication by leveraging the rich dynamics of networks of coupled oscillators 12 -- 21. However, this approach has to overcome a difficult challenge. The natural frequencies of nano-oscillators can usually be tuned, by applying current or voltage biases, but dynamically adjusting inter-oscillator cou- pling strengths requires heavy circuitry14. As a conse- quence, traditional learning methods used for training neural networks, which usually consist in adjusting the couplings between non-linear units, are not very adapted to oscillator-based classifiers. An attractive alternative approach is the oscillator- based classifier initially proposed in a mathematical con- text by Vassilieva et al.12, and adapted to nano-oscillator technologies in18. The online learning procedure of this network involves reading the synchronization state of var- ious pairs of oscillators, and adjusting their natural fre- quencies in order to reinforce expected synchronizations, and weaken unexpected ones for each known input exam- ple presented to the oscillator network. This approach was recently validated experimentally by Romera et al., who achieved spoken vowel recognition using a network of four coupled spin-torque nano-oscillators17. In this work, we propose an "extended" nano- oscillator-based classifier architecture that retains the nanotechnology-compatibility of the reference approach of12, but is trained using gradient descent, the standard algorithm of machine learning. This allows our archi- tecture to capitalize on developments realized for more conventional forms of neural networks. We show that our extended classifier achieves better classification re- sults than the reference classifier on a simple task. We then run a standard classification benchmark of the ex- tended classifier against a classical neural network and investigate the robustness to phase noise and the scal- ability of the extended architecture. This allows us to discuss the advantages and drawbacks of our approach. II. DEFINITION OF THE OSCILLATOR-BASED CLASSIFICATION ARCHITECTURES Fig. 1(a) shows a pattern classification architecture, subsequently called reference classifier, similar to the one originally proposed by Vassilieva et al.12. This classifier consists of a set of N oscillators coupled all-to-all through constant uniform weak couplings. Among the N oscil- lators, NI act as input oscillators (oscillators 1 and 2 in Fig. 1(a)), and the NT others act as tuning nano- oscillators (oscillators 3, 4, 5 and 6 in Fig. 1(a)). The input vector x to be classified is presented by setting the natural frequencies of the input oscillators (F1, F2 in Fig. 1(a)) accordingly. The input oscillators induce Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 2 synchronizations in the oscillator network, which can be deduced from the average observed frequencies ¯f of the oscillators17,22. The resulting list of synchronized pairs of oscillators then yields a binary output vector y which represents the class that the system has associated to the presented pattern. The response of the classifier can be trained to perform a given classification task by ad- justing the natural frequencies of the tuning oscillators (F3, F4, F5, F6 in Fig. 1(a)). FIG. 1. (a) Schematic of the reference classifier with 2 input oscillators (1 and 2) and 4 tuning oscillators (3,4,5 and 6). (b) Schematic of the extended classifier with 6 oscillators. This reference architecture provides many benefits for implementation with nanotechnology: resilience to de- vice variability, to noise, to device non-linearity, and it has good scaling properties18. Moreover, high frequency signals are present only within the oscillator network, while natural frequency control inputs, and synchroniza- tion detection outputs are low frequency signals, which eases implementation. The limitation of the architecture, by contrast, is that it only provides NT tunable parameters, which limits its classification capabilities for low numbers of oscillators. Moreover, the classifier response is restricted by strong symmetries arising from the fact that all oscillators are identical and only defined by their natural frequencies. Overcoming such limitations requires rethinking the classification architecture. In Fig. 1(b), we introduce an extended version of the classifier that uses a weight ma- trix formalism, compatible with existing neural network frameworks. The natural frequencies of all oscillators are now trainable linear combinations of the inputs x and a constant bias according to: F = W , where W (cid:21) (cid:20)x 1 is the trainable weights matrix. This extended classifier therefore erases the difference between input and tuning oscillators as all the N oscillators in the network play a similar role. As each natural frequency is a potentially different linear combination of the inputs, the symme- tries present in the reference approach of12 are broken and (dim (x) + 1)× N tuning parameters are made avail- able. As the high-frequency couplings between oscillators are kept uniform and constant, the extended classifier remains compatible with the constraints of nanotechnol- ogy, only adding a low-frequency linear combination step to the inputs, which has already been implemented in CMOS23,24 or with programmable resistive devices25. III. PRESENTATION OF THE LEARNING ALGORITHMS The iterative online learning algorithm defined by Vas- silieva et al.12 and later adapted to experiments by Romera et al.17 consists in presenting a set of training input examples {x(m)}m=1..M with known expected clas- sification binary vectors {y(m)}m=1..M , and adjusting the natural frequencies according to the measured synchro- nizations. For each presented example (m), the resulting list of synchronized pairs of oscillators is compared to the expected one. The learning algorithm then aims at weak- ening the synchronizations of pairs of oscillators that are not expected for the example (m), by slightly pushing their natural frequencies apart, and at promoting desyn- chronized pairs that are expected to be synchronized, by slightly pulling their natural frequencies closer together. This behavior is achieved by applying linear updates that adjust the natural frequencies of the output oscillators according to the sum of observed frequency differences, weighted by a factor depending if the oscillators are to or not to synchronize12. However, this algorithm only acts on the natural frequencies of oscillator pairs used as outputs and compared to the expected example outputs, which does not allow having extra non-output oscillators to increase the computational power of the system at the same output dimensionality. More precisely, the online learning algorithm restricts the number of trained oscil- lators to a maximum of 2× dim(y). Moreover, the online learning algorithm is "greedy" as it acts on each pair of oscillators assuming they are isolated and do not influ- ence the other oscillators of the network. As all oscilla- tors interact together through complex network dynam- ics, this assumption can lead the algorithm to suboptimal results. In this work, we introduce an offline learning algorithm inspired by standard machine learning techniques that overcomes the limitations of the online learning algorithm by iteratively minimizing, through gradient descent, the total error function: E(m) i,j (1) Etot = 1 M M(cid:88) (cid:88) m=1 output pairs (i,j) where E(m) is the error on the output pair (i, j) for the i,j training example (m). Fig. 2 illustrates the value of E(m) i,j , which depends on the expected synchronization state of the pair (i, j) for the example (m) and a measure of the actual desynchronization D(m) i,j of the pair (i, j) after the example (m) is presented, defined by: ¯f (m) i − ¯f (m) j D(m) i,j = , k/2 (2) Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 3 where k is the uniform coupling strength between the i,j ≤ 1 oscillators. (i, j) are considered synchronized if D(m) and desynchronized otherwise. If the oscillators (i, j) are expected to be synchronized for the presented example (m), we define: (cid:16) 1 2 (cid:17)2 (cid:16) D(m) i,j if D(m) i,j ≤ 1   E(m) i,j = 1 i,j −1 D(m) −4 1 + e (cid:17) if D(m) i,j > 1 , (3) or if the synchronization (i, j) is not expected for the presented example (m): D(m) i,j if D(m) i,j ≤ 1 (cid:16) 1 − 1 2 1 − (cid:17)2 (cid:16) 1 i,j −1 D(m) −4 1 + e (cid:17) if D(m) i,j > 1 . (4) E(m) i,j = Computing the total error gradient with respect to the natural frequencies ∂Etot for the reference classifier or ∂F with respect to the weight matrix elements ∂Etot ∂W for the extended classifier requires in both cases the derivatives ∂E(m) i,j ∂F , which can be expanded using the chain rule: ∂E(m) i,j ∂Fa = ∂E(m) i,j ∂ ¯f (m) i i ∂ ¯f (m) ∂Fa + ∂E(m) i,j ∂ ¯f (m) j j ∂ ¯f (m) ∂Fa , (5) where the derivatives ing equations (3,4). ∂E(m) i,j ∂ ¯f (m) are obtained by differentiat- FIG. 2. Schematic of the differentiable error function depend- ing on the expected synchronization states for a given input example in the case of a binary classification task with output pair (4,5). Continuing the gradient computation requires the derivative of the average frequencies with respect to the natural frequencies of the oscillators: ∂ ¯f ∂F . The partial derivatives ∂ ¯f ∂F correspond to the Jacobian matrix of the oscillator network operator depicted as a blue rounded square in Figs. 1 and 2, and translate the rich dynamics of all the oscillators interacting together. Throughout the paper, we model the oscillator network using the Kuramoto model, with which many nanooscil- lators can be described18. In order to compute the Ja- cobian offline, we apply a simple Euler numerical inte- gration scheme following the update equations for the oscillator instantaneous frequencies f (t) and phases θ(t) with a time step dt = 10−11s, and total simulation time T = 1µs:fi(t) = Fi + k θi(t + dt) = θi(t) + 2πdtfi(t) N(cid:88) i=1 sin (θj(t) − θi(t)) . (6) As the state of the system at time t + dt is a contin- uously differentiable function of the state at time t, we translate the numerical update equations (6) into a con- tinuously differentiable operator as shown in Fig. 3(a). This update operator is then stacked in time as shown in Fig. 3(b) and the instantaneous frequencies f (t) are av- eraged on the last τ = 0.5µs to represent a continuously differentiable expression of the oscillator network opera- tor taking F as input and outputting ¯f . The derivatives are updated at each simulation step following:  has a complexity in O(cid:0)N 3(cid:1) but is highly parallelizable. (7) ∂F = 0. The are then averaged on the last τ /dt ∂F . This algorithm where δ is the Kronecker delta, and ∂θ(t=0) derivatives ∂f (t) ∂F timesteps to obtain the Jacobian ∂ ¯f (cid:88) (cid:18) ∂θj(t) ∂fi(t) ∂Fa ∂θi(t + dt) − ∂θi(t) ∂Fa j ∂θi(t) ∂Fa ∂fi(t) ∂Fa = + 2πdt = δi,a + k (cid:19) ∂Fa ∂Fa , cos (θj(t) − θi(t)) Following standard practices in gradient propagation through time, we implement gradient clipping26 by ap- plying the tanh squashing function to the Jacobian. Sim- ilarly, the natural frequencies F are min-max clipped to stay within [500; 680]MHz, which represents the typical tuning range of spin-torque nano-oscillators18. Unwanted sensitivity to initial conditions is prevented by setting the initial oscillator phases θ0 to uniformly random values in [0; 2π) for each simulation run. The differentiable os- cillator network operator can be implemented as a neu- ral layer within popular machine learning libraries for use with automatic differentiation. In this work, we use a Graphics Processing Unit (GPU)-accelerated custom C++ differentiable oscillator network operator for the machine learning library TensorFlow27. The Adam op- timizer is used with default parameters and a learning rate of 0.03 in order to minimize the total error Etot on a set of training examples. It should be noted that we assumed a basic Euler numerical integration scheme, but that our approach can be adapted to other explicit inte- gration methods as well. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE OFFLINE LEARNING IV. STRATEGY We first compare the online learning algorithm to the offline learning algorithm, on the NI = 2, NT = 4, k = 10MHz reference classifier, by solving a basic bi- nary classification task consisting in synchronizing tun- ing oscillators (4, 5) for a set of positive examples, and desynchronizing them for a set of negative examples. The Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 4 FIG. 3. (a) Schematic representation of the differentiable re- current cell reinterpretation of an Euler integration step of the Kuramoto model. (b) A fully differentiable oscillator network operator taking a vector of natural frequencies F as input, and outputting a vector of mean frequencies ¯f . total number of examples is M = 1156, of which 86% are negative. Fig. 4(a) shows the response map of the reference clas- sifier after 20 online learning iterations as a function of the input natural frequencies F1 and F2, where oscillators (4, 5) are synchronized in the green area, and the red and blue dots represent the positive and negative examples, i.e. the target regions for synchronization and desynchro- nization. Fig. 4(b) shows the natural frequencies of the tuning oscillators as functions of the learning iteration. After 20 iterations, the natural frequencies stabilize, and a classification rate of 91.7% is reached. The results show that classification task is not fully solved due to the fact that the only degree of freedom of the online learning algorithm is to push F4 and F5 apart or closer together, thereby adjusting the size of the synchronization region without being able to shift it towards the target region. In Fig. 4(c) we show the response map of the same clas- sifier after 20 offline learning iterations, and Fig. 4(d) shows the natural frequencies of the tuning oscillators as functions of the learning iteration. The results show that the offline learning algorithm is able to successfully adjust all four tunable natural frequencies, shift the syn- chronization region along the first diagonal of the map, and reach an improved classification rate of 99.7%. We then compare the reference classifier (NI = 2, NT = 4) to the extended classifier (N = 6), with k = 10MHz on more advanced binary classification tasks using the offline learning algorithm. Figs. 5(a,b) show the response maps of the reference classifier after 100 offline learning iterations for an off-diagonal circular tar- get region (M = 1156, 87.5% negatives), and a concave target region (M = 1156, 59.9% negatives) respectively. Figs. 5(c,d) show the results obtained in the same condi- tions with the extended classifier. Figs. 6(a,b) show the evolution of the error rates of both classifiers on the two datasets. Our results show that the reference classifier is unable to classify non diagonally-symmetric patterns FIG. 4. Comparing the online and offline learning algorithms on a basic classification task using the reference classification architecture with NI = 2 and NT = 4. (a) Response map after 20 iterations of online learning. (b) Tunable natural frequencies as functions of the online learning iteration. (c) Response map after 20 iterations of offline learning. (d) Tun- able natural frequencies as functions of the offline learning iteration. (87.7% on the off-diagonal circle) due to symmetries, and its low number of tunable parameters limits its capability to classify complex shaped regions (77.6% on the concave region). The extended classifier, however, successfully learns to represent both the off-diagonal circular (99.4%) and the concave (99.8%) target regions. These results show that the extended classifier, to- gether with the offline learning algorithm offers superior classification capabilities compared to the reference clas- sifier with online learning. V. BENCHMARKING THE EXTENDED CLASSIFIER WITH OFFLINE LEARNING We now benchmark the extended classifier (N = 6) against the reference classifier (NI = 4, NT = 2, the two tuning oscillators are used as outputs) using the offline learning algorithm, and a perceptron linear classifier on the standard Iris dataset28. The binary classification task consists in identifying whether or not a flower belongs to a specific species given four features. We set k = 10MHz and use 30 examples from each of the three species as a 90-item training set, and the 20 remaining examples per species as a 60-item test set. Table I shows the test set classification rates on iden- tifying each of the three species after 100 learning itera- tions for the reference classifier, the extended classifier, and the perceptron. The results show that the perceptron successfully classifies the linearly separable classes Setosa Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 5 Architecture Iris setosa Iris versicolor Iris virginica Reference Extended Perceptron 67 % 100 % 100 % 87 % 98 % 73 % 67 % 100 % 97 % TABLE I. Iris test set classification rates on the flower species identification task for the three Iris species, using the NI = 4, NT = 2 reference classifier, the N = 6 extended classifier, and a perceptron. to classical neural networks. Those differences are due to the highly non-monotonic nature of the oscillator net- work operator and its rich inter-unit interactions, both of which are unusual properties in classical neural network layers. Finally, the extended classifier successfully clas- sifies all three species (100%, 98%, 100%), which shows that its rich and tunable physics provide extra computing power compared to classical single-layer neural networks. We then evaluate how well the extended classifier with offline learning scales on the non linearly separable Iris versicolor identification task when the number of oscil- lator increases, and compare it to a two-layer tanh feed- forward neural network. Fig. 7 shows the test set clas- sification rates after 100 learning iterations as functions of the number of learned parameters for the extended classifier and the two-layer neural network. The results show that the extended classifier, using a single weight matrix, outperforms the two-layer neural network, which uses two weight matrices, at equivalent number of learned parameters for 15 learned parameters and above. FIG. 5. Response maps on two different target regions after 100 offline learning iterations for (a,b) the NI = 2, NT = 4 reference classifier, and (c,d) the N = 6 extended classifier. x1 and x2 are the components of the bi-dimensional input vector x. FIG. 6. Error rates (percentage of misclassified examples) as functions of the offline learning iteration, obtained with the NI = 2, NT = 4 reference classifier and the N = 6 extended classifier on (a) the off-diagonal circular target region dataset and (b) the convex target region dataset. (100%) and Virginica (97%) but fails on the non linearly separable Versicolor class (73%). On the contrary, the reference classifier fails to classify Setosa (67%) and Vir- ginica (67%) but performs better on Versicolor (87%). This observation highlights the different, and comple- mentary nature of oscillator-based classifiers compared FIG. 7. Iris versicolor identification test set classification rate as a function of the number of learned parameters, for the extended classifier trained offline, and for a two-layer tanh neural network. Real nano-oscillator systems are subject to phase noise, which is not included during offline learning in order to keep meaningful gradients. It is therefore important to evaluate the effects of phase noise when using a weight matrix trained offline in a noisy physical system. We choose to train the N = 6 extended classifier on the Iris versicolor identification task with the offline learn- ing algorithm for 100 learning iterations. The obtained weight matrix is then transferred into a simulated noisy Kuramoto model of the network, and the test set classi- fication rates are evaluated for different noise levels ex- pressed as the linewidth of an isolated oscillator. The Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 6 noisy version of the phase update equations (6) is: fi(t) = Fi + k N(cid:88) i=1 θi(t + dt) = θi(t) + 2πdtfi(t) + sin (θj(t) − θi(t)) √ , (8) 2πdt∆ N where ∆ is the linewidth of an isolated oscillator, and N is a pseudo-random Gaussian distribution with mean 0 and variance 1. For each noise level, the system is simu- lated 100 times with different random initial phases and different noise random seeds. Fig. 8 shows the average test set classification rate obtained with the noisy system on 100 trials, as a function of the oscillator linewidth. The blue-filled area represents the span between the worst and best test set classification rates encountered during the trials. The results show that noise decreases the classification rates. However, for noise levels typical of spin-torque nano-oscillators (∆ ≈ 1MHz18), the aver- age classification rate is 94.6% with a worst case at 90%, showing that the offline learning approach is robust to realistic levels of phase noise. FIG. 8. Average Iris versicolor identification test set classifi- cation rates obtained on 100 trials of a noisy extended classi- fier trained using the offline learning algorithm, as a function of the oscillator linewidth. The span between the worst and best cases encountered during the trials is blue-filled. VI. DISCUSSION This work defines the first full-featured supervised of- fline learning algorithm for oscillator-based classifiers, as well as an improved classification architecture compatible with current nanotechnologies. Comparison with the ref- erence approach of12 showed the power of the approach in terms of classification accuracy, while comparisons with standard neural networks showed that our approach was economical in terms of adjustable parameters. The main benefit of our approach is its compatibility with both the constrains of nanotechnology (no tuning of the coupling between the oscillators) and with the stan- dard techniques of machine learning. The neural net- work can be trained offline, using the powerful frame- works of software neural networks, such as 27 used here. By contrast, the main limitation of our approach also comes from the offline nature of learning. There can be mismatch between the model used for training, and the reality of the physical system in which the trained pa- rameters are transferred. The first mismatch mitigation approach is of course to choose a realistic device model. This work relies on the Kuramoto model which is used to describe a wide range of oscillators29, but any other smooth model30 can be used instead to produce trained weight matrices that are better fit to the target oscillator system. Mismatch effects can also be mitigated by adding random variability on the model properties at each learn- ing step in order to avoid over-fitting and produce robust solutions that transfer to variable physical devices. The impact of mismatch could also be further reduced by per- forming extra online learning steps to perfect the general solution provided by the offline learning algorithm. It should also be noted that the training process is rel- atively heavy, and slower than for more conventional neu- ral networks, due to the added complexity of modeling the dynamics of the nanooscillators. In terms of applica- tion, our approach therefore targets inference hardware, where the model is trained on a server and then pro- grammed on highly efficient specialized circuits provided to users. Furthermore, this study focuses on binary classifica- tion tasks, but multi-class classification can be readily achieved either by training one binary classifier per class, or by using multiple pairs of oscillators as outputs. Oscil- lator networks can also be stacked into multi-layer archi- tectures and trained transparently with the offline learn- ing algorithm thanks to automatic differentiation. Finally, even though we only used the average stable state of the oscillator network, the offline learning al- gorithm can be applied to temporal signals as well, by inputting a different F at every time-step, and reading a sliding time window average of f (t). A promising re- search direction would be to exploit the temporal and transient behaviors of the oscillator network to classify or generate sequences and signals in time. In conclusion, we showed that neural networks based on nano-oscillators, despite their nature that differs strongly from standard neural networks, can be trained using similar frameworks and methodology, to achieve good classification performance. This work suggests the value of bringer closer works performed in physics and in machine learning for the implementation of compact and energy efficient classification systems. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS the This work is supported by a public grant over- seen by the French National Research Agency (ANR) as part of Investissements d'Avenir program (Labex NanoSaclay, reference: ANR-10-LABX-0035), by the ANR MEMOS grant (reference: ANR-14- CE26-0021) and by the French Minist`ere de l'´ecologie, du d´eveloppement durable et de l'´energie. The au- thors thank P. Talatchian, M. Romera, F. A. Araujo, A. Mizrahi, A. F. Vincent, T. Hirtzlin, M. Ernoult, and C. H. Bennett for fruitful discussions. Nano-oscillator-based classification with a machine learning-compatible architecture 7 1M. P. Mills, Digital Power Group (2013). 2D. Schneider, IEEE Spectrum 54, 42 (2017). 3J. Hasler, IEEE Spectrum 54, 46 (2017). 4C. D. Schuman, T. E. Potok, R. M. Patton, J. D. Birdwell, M. E. Dean, G. S. Rose, and J. S. Plank, CoRR abs/1705.06963 (2017). 5J. Torrejon, M. Riou, F. A. Araujo, S. Tsunegi, G. Khalsa, D. Querlioz, P. Bortolotti, V. Cros, K. Yakushiji, A. Fukushima, H. Kubota, S. Yuasa, M. D. Stiles, and J. Grollier, Nature 547, 428 (2017). 6F. C. Hoppensteadt and E. M. Izhikevich, IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Fundamental Theory and Applications 48, 133 (2001). 7A. Sharma, J. Bain, and J. Weldon, IEEE Journal on Ex- ploratory Solid-State Computational Devices and Circuits PP, 1 (2015). 8Y. N. Ovchinnikov and V. Z. Kresin, Physical Review B 88, 214504 (2013). 9G. Csaba and W. Porod, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics 49, 4447 (2013). 10N. Locatelli, A. F. Vincent, A. Mizrahi, J. S. Friedman, D. Vo- denicarevic, J. V. Kim, J. O. Klein, W. Zhao, J. Grollier, and D. Querlioz, in 2015 Design, Automation Test in Europe Con- ference Exhibition (DATE) (2015) pp. 994 -- 999. 11X.-J. Wang, Physiological Reviews 90, 1195 (2010). 12E. Vassilieva, G. Pinto, J. Acacio de Barros, and P. Suppes, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks 22, 84 (2011). 13S. P. Levitan, Y. Fang, J. A. Carpenter, C. N. Gnegy, N. S. Janosik, S. Awosika-Olumo, D. M. Chiarulli, G. Csaba, and W. Porod, in Proceedings of the 2013 International Symposium on Low Power Electronics and Design, ISLPED '13 (IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 2013) pp. 235 -- 235, 00001. 14D. Nikonov, G. Csaba, W. Porod, T. Shibata, D. Voils, D. Ham- merstrom, I. Young, and G. Bourianoff, IEEE Journal on Ex- ploratory Solid-State Computational Devices and Circuits 1, 85 (2015). 15M. Cotter, Y. Fang, S. Levitan, D. Chiarulli, and V. Narayanan, in 2014 IEEE Computer Society Annual Symposium on VLSI (ISVLSI) (2014) pp. 130 -- 135. 16A. Parihar, N. Shukla, S. Datta, and A. Raychowdhury, in 2016 IEEE Photonics Society Summer Topical Meeting Series (SUM) (2016) pp. 110 -- 111. 17M. Romera, P. Talatchian, S. Tsunegi, F. A. Araujo, V. Cros, P. Bortolotti, K. Yakushiji, A. Fukushima, H. Kubota, S. Yuasa, D. Vodenicarevic, N. Locatelli, D. Querlioz, and J. Grollier, arXiv:1711.02704 [cond-mat, q-bio] (2017), arXiv: 1711.02704. 18D. Vodenicarevic, N. Locatelli, Flavio Abreu Araujo, J. Grollier, and D. Querlioz, Scientific Reports (2017). 19M. Ignatov, M. Ziegler, M. Hansen, and H. Kohlstedt, Science Advances 3 (2017), 10.1126/sciadv.1700849. 20Y. Fang, V. V. Yashin, S. P. Levitan, and A. C. Balazs, Science Advances 2 (2016), 10.1126/sciadv.1601114. 21G. Csaba and W. Porod, arXiv preprint arXiv:1805.09056 (2018). 22D. Vodenicarevic, N. Locatelli, J. Grollier, and D. Querlioz, in Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Neural Networks (Vancouver, 2016) pp. 2015 -- 2022. 23S. B. Furber, D. R. Lester, L. A. Plana, J. D. Garside, E. Painkras, S. Temple, and A. D. Brown, IEEE Transactions on Computers 62, 2454 (2013). 24P. A. Merolla, J. V. Arthur, R. Alvarez-Icaza, A. S. Cassidy, J. Sawada, et al., Science 345, 668 (2014). 25Y.-P. Lin, C. H. Bennett, T. Cabaret, D. Vodenicarevic, D. Chabi, D. Querlioz, B. Jousselme, V. Derycke, and J.-O. Klein, Scientific Reports 6, 31932 (2016). 26R. Pascanu, T. Mikolov, and Y. Bengio, in Proceedings of the 30th International Conference on International Conference on Machine Learning - Volume 28 , ICML'13 (JMLR.org, Atlanta, GA, USA, 2013) pp. III -- 1310 -- III -- 1318. 27M. Abadi, A. Agarwal, P. Barham, E. Brevdo, Z. Chen, et al., "TensorFlow: Large-scale machine learning on heterogeneous systems," (2015), software available from tensorflow.org. 28R. A. Fisher, Annals of Eugenics 7, 179 (1936). 29J. A. Acebr´on, L. L. Bonilla, C. J. P´erez Vicente, F. Ritort, and R. Spigler, Reviews of Modern Physics 77, 137 (2005). 30N. Locatelli, D. Vodenicarevic, W. Zhao, J. O. Klein, J. Grol- lier, and D. Querlioz, in 2015 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS) (2015) pp. 589 -- 592.
1903.01507	4	1903	2019-10-08T11:37:22	Free-Space Wide-Aperture Sheet-Isolator Based on a Multilayered Resonant Cavity	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics" ]	We introduce the first conceptual design of a free-space thin-sheet isolator with unlimited aperture and the possibility of a broadband omnidirectional rejection of the backward propagating light. The proposed design involves a multilayered resonant cavity incorporating subwavelength magnetic layers, dichroic nanolayers, and an optional metallic nanolayer. The cavity resonance enhances the Faraday rotation produced by the subwavelength magnetic layers, while providing nearly total absorption of the backward-propagating light by the dichroic nanolayers. The latter is a necessary and the most challenging condition for a thin-sheet isolator with unlimited aperture to function. The (optional) metallic nanolayer provides rejection of the obliquely incident light, which otherwise would be partially transmitted in either direction. Our numerical simulations and quasi-optical measurements at millimeter-wave frequencies illustrate how the key elements of the layered-sheet isolator work. Our approach can be scaled down to long- and mid-infrared wavelengths.	physics.app-ph	physics	Wide-aperture layered-sheet Faraday isolator R. Kononchuk,1 C. Pfeiffer,2 I. Anisimov,2 N.I. Limberopoulos,2 I. Vitebskiy,2 and A. A. Chabanov1 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, TX 78249, USA 2Air Force Research Laboratory, Sensors Directorate, Wright-Patterson AFB, OH 45433, USA (Dated: October 9, 2019) We introduce the first conceptual design of a free-space thin-sheet isolator with unlimited aperture and the possibility of a broadband omnidirectional rejection of the backward propagating light. The proposed design involves a multilayered resonant cavity incorporating subwavelength magnetic layers, dichroic nanolayers, and an optional metallic nanolayer. The cavity resonance enhances the Faraday rotation produced by the subwavelength magnetic layers, while providing nearly total absorption of the backward-propagating light by the dichroic nanolayers. The latter is a necessary and the most challenging condition for a thin-sheet isolator with unlimited aperture to function. The (optional) metallic nanolayer provides rejection of the obliquely incident light, which otherwise would be partially transmitted in either direction. Our numerical simulations and quasi-optical measurements at millimeter-wave frequencies illustrate how the key elements of the layered-sheet isolator work. Our approach can be scaled down to long- and mid-infrared wavelengths. I. INTRODUCTION Optical isolators are nonreciprocal devices transmit- ting light in only one direction [1]. They are indispens- able for eliminating adverse effects of back reflection in optical systems. A typical free-space isolator consists of a 45-degree Faraday rotator placed between two polarizers making a 45-degree angle with each other, as schemati- cally shown in Fig. 1. A properly polarized input light propagating in the forward direction, passes through the front polarizer P1, the Faraday rotator 45FR, and then the back polarizer P2, as shown in Fig. 1a. By con- trast, the backward-propagating light, after passing the back polarizer P2 and the Faraday rotator 45FR, will be blocked by the front polarizer P1, as shown in Fig. 1b. This simple isolation scheme essentially requires that the backward-propagating light is either totally absorbed by the polarizer P1 or diverted away from the system. In- deed, if the backward-propagating light in Fig. 1b were even partially reflected from the polarizer P1 towards the Faraday rotator, it would bounce back and force between the two polarizers, each time passing through the Fara- day rotator and acquiring an additional 45-degree rota- tion. After one round trip, the light would acquire an ad- ditional 90-degree polarization rotation and thus would not be blocked by the polarizer P1, resulting in isolation failure. This presents a major challenge in realizing a thin-sheet isolator, because all existing sheet polarizers (such as absorptive film polarizers, metal nanoparticles- embedded glass plates, wire grids, etc.) are at least par- tially reflective. In the existing free-space isolators, the problem of polarizer reflectivity is dealt with by either using beam-splitting polarizers or by tilting the sheet po- larizers at an angle to the light beam [2, 3]. Neither of these approaches, however, is applicable to a thin-sheet isolator. Indeed, if the free-space isolator is a thin mul- tilayer (as is the case here), one can only tilt the entire multilayered structure, not just the polarizer layers. Tilt- ing the entire multilayer, however, would not prevent the backward-propagating light from bouncing between the FIG. 1. Schematics and operating principle of the opti- cal isolator composed of a 45-degree Faraday rotator (45FR) positioned between two polarizers (P1 and P2) making a 45- degree angle with each other. (a) forward-propagating wave (red arrow) passes through; (b) backward-propagating wave (green arrow) is blocked by the isolator. sheet polarizers, causing the isolation failure. It thus ap- pears that after entering the sheet isolator, the backward- propagating light must be completely absorbed by the isolator. This strict requirement is unique to the case of a sheet isolator with unlimited aperture, and its fulfill- ment is the main focus of our study. In the next two Sections, we describe the design and experimental realization of layered-sheet (LS) polarizers providing nearly perfect resonant absorption of the light with unwanted linear polarization, while not affecting the light with the desired linear polarization. According to Fig. 1, a pair of such LS polarizers in combination with a thin-sheet Faraday rotator will act as a sheet isola- tor with unlimited aperture. Away from the cavity res- onance, the proposed resonant LS polarizers, as well as the entire sheet isolator, are highly reflective regardless of the input light polarization. The latter implies that away from the cavity resonance, the isolator reflects both the forward- and the backward-propagating input light. In Section 2 we present two qualitatively different de- signs of resonant LS polarizers compatible with the sheet isolator. The first design is symmetric -- it provides the total absorption of the unwanted polarization regardless of the direction of incidence. The second (preferable) 9 1 0 2 t c O 8 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 4 v 7 0 5 1 0 . 3 0 9 1 : v i X r a design is highly asymmetric -- it provides the total ab- sorption of the unwanted polarization for one direction of incidence, while providing a nearly perfect reflection of the unwanted polarization for the opposite direction of in- cidence. In the case of sheet isolator, the absorptive sides of the polarizers must face the Faraday rotator, while the opposite (outer) sides of the polarizers can be reflective. Our designs involve high-Q resonant cavity with embed- ded dichroic nanolayers (metal-grid polarizers). Taken out of the cavity, the dichroic nanolayers are mostly re- flective for the unwanted light polarization and, there- fore, could not be used as components of the sheet isola- tor. Both, symmetric and asymmetric designs are based on the same high-Q resonant cavity; the only difference is in the number and the location of the dichroic nanolayers inside the cavity. We have also fabricated and success- fully tested such polarizers at millimeter-wave (MMW) frequencies. The results of the quasi-optical MMW mea- surements are described in Section 3. The above solution for the sheet isolator with unlim- ited aperture involves at least two resonant cavities (one for each of the two polarizers in Fig. 1) with perfectly matched resonant frequencies. In Section 4, we put for- ward a qualitatively different design of the LS isolator. The idea is to incorporate the magnetic and dichroic lay- ers in a single resonant cavity, to avoid any impedance mismatch between the three constitutive components of the isolator in Fig. 1. The role of the high-Q dielectric cavity in this case is two-fold. Firstly, it provides a nearly total resonant absorption of the backward-propagating light by the dichroic nanolayers, while not affecting the forward-propagating light. Secondly, the cavity enhances the nonreciprocal circular birefringence associated with the subwavelength magnetic layers, thereby drastically reducing the total thickness of the multilayered struc- ture. Furthermore, a metallic nanolayer can be added to multilayered cavity to achieve omnidirectional rejec- tion of the light incident on the back surface of the sheet isolator, following the scheme of [4, 5]. The location of metallic nanolayer should coincide with an asymmetric nodal plane of the resonant field distribution. According to [5], at normal propagation, such a metallic nanolayer is "invisible for the resonant mode inside the cavity. How- ever, at oblique incidence, the nodal plane of the electric field distribution shifts away from the metallic nanolayer and the entire multilayered structure becomes highly re- flective [5]. In this paper, though, we focus on the case of normal incidence. The numerical simulations of the scattering parameters for the LS polarizers and the integrated LS isolator, as well as the quasi-optical proof-of-concept measurements, have been carried out in the W-band (75-110 GHz). The presented approach, though, is highly scalable and can be replicated for any frequency range from microwave to mid-infrared. 2 II. LAYERED-SHEET POLARIZERS The design of the LS polarizers involves dichroic nanolayers incorporated into a resonant multilayer di- electric cavity. In our numerical simulations using 4×4 Transfer-Matrix formalism, the dichroic nanolayers have a highly anisotropic sheet resistance: Rx = ∞ and Ry = 2.54 Ω/sq. At MMW frequencies, the dichroic nanolayers fully transmit the x-polarization (hereinafter, the TM polarization) component of the incident wave in the z-direction while mostly reflecting the y-polarization (hereinafter, the TE polarization) component. The cor- responding transmittance and reflectance values at a fre- quency of 95 GHz are Tx = 1, Rx = 0 and Ty = 1.79 × 10−4, Ry = 0.973. Thus, the high value of Ry would not allow the use of the stand-alone dichroic nanolayers as polarizers in the isolator in Fig. 1. The multilayer cavity is shown in Fig. 2a, and it is de- signed to operate at 95 GHz. It consists of quarter-wave layers of sapphire (H, dark blue) and quartz (L, light blue), with the corresponding refractive indices nH = 9.5 and nL = 3.8 and negligible absorption in the W-band. The transmittance and reflectance spectra of the multi- layer cavity are shown in Fig. 2b. The half-wave de- fect layer in the middle of the periodic layered structure provides a quasi-localized mode associated with the res- onant transmittance at the mid-gap frequency f0 = 95 GHz. The spatial intensity distribution of the electric field component within the multilayer at the resonance frequency f0 is shown in Fig. 2c. Since the half-wave defect layer has the lower refractive index, the resonant field distribution has an antinodal plane in the middle of the defect layer, where the amplitude of the quasi- localized resonant mode reaches its maximum value. In the absence of the dichroic layers, the results presented in Figs. 2b and 2c are polarization independent. These results will still apply to the TM polarization, after the dichroic layers have been incorporated into the multi- layer. The inclusion of the dichroic nanolayers in the multilayer cavity provides a broadband, omnidirectional and strongly enhanced transmittance suppression for the TE polarization. What happens to the TE polarization strongly depends on the number and the location of the dichroic nanolayers in the cavity. We start with the symmetric LS configuration in Fig. 3a, where the only dichroic nanolayer coincides with the symmetry plane of the cavity. Our simulations show that the resonant transmittance of the TE polarization is ∼ 10−7 (as seen in Fig. 3c), which is three orders of mag- nitude lower than for the stand-alone dichroic layer. The reflectance approaches unity (as seen in Fig. 3b), while the absorptance, A = 1 − T − R, drops an order of mag- nitude lower than that of the stand-alone dichroic layer. The physical reason for the reduced absorption is that the TE polarization is mostly reflected from the Bragg- reflector part of the LS polarizer and that the electric field intensity at the dichroic layer is only ∼ 10−3 of the incident wave intensity, as seen in Fig. 3c. The decreased 3 FIG. 2. (a) Schematics of the resonant multilayer cavity of quarter-wave sapphire (deep blue) and quartz (light blue) layers, utilized as a host structure for the LS polarizers in Figs. 3 -- 5; (b) simulated spectral transmittance (dashed line) and reflectance (solid line), and (c) spatial intensity distribu- tion, E(z)2, at the cavity resonance frequency 95 GHz. The plots (b) and (c) are polarization independent. In the case of LS polarizers, they still apply to the TM polarization. FIG. 4. (a) Schematics of the absorptive LS polarizer in- volving three dichroic nanolayers (black) incorporated in the host multilayer structure of Fig. 2a; (b) simulated spectral reflectance (solid line) and absorptance (dotted line), and (c) spatial intensity distribution, E(z)2, at the cavity resonance frequency 95 GHz, for the TE polarization in the forward propagation direction. FIG. 3. (a) Schematics of the reflective LS polarizer involving a dichroic nanolayer (black) incorporated in the host multi- layer structure of Fig. 2a; (b) simulated spectral reflectance (solid line) and absorptance (dotted line), and (c) spatial intensity distribution, E(z)2, at the cavity resonance fre- quency 95 GHz, for the TE polarization in the forward prop- agation direction. absorption can drastically reduce the absorption-related heating and, thereby, significantly increase the power- handling capability of the LS polarizer. However, its high reflectance for the TE polarization makes it impossible to use it as a component of the LS isolator. If, on the other hand, the dichroic layer is positioned at the nodal plane of the resonant electric field distri- bution, resonant absorption of the TE polarization can be significantly enhanced. Although the absorptance of an ultrathin homogeneous layer is known not to exceed 0.5 (see, for example, [6]), this absorptance limit can be overcome in a thin film with an intrinsic resonance [7], such as a plasmonic resonance, in a metasurface [8], or by using the Salisbury screen [9, 10], which is a highly reflective surface positioned a quarter-wave distance be- hind an absorbing layer. Perfect absorption can also be achieved by critical coupling of a lossy thin layer to a resonator [11 -- 13] or ideal impedance matching between a lossy slab and the free space [14, 15]. In the LS configuration in Fig. 4a, we utilize, as a re- flecting screen, the second dichroic nanolayer positioned a quarter-wave distance from the first one, resulting in nearly perfect absorption of the TE polarization at the resonance frequency. The third dichroic nanolayer is added for symmetric operation, so that the LS polarizer equally absorbs the TE-polarization component of the incident wave in either direction. The resonant trans- mittance for the TE polarization is ∼ 10−8 (as seen in Fig. 4c), implying a huge enhancement of the polariza- tion extinction ratio. The reflectance and absorptance spectra are shown in Fig. 4b. The nearly perfect absorp- tance is narrowband, due to its resonant nature. Away from the resonance frequency, the LS polarizer is highly reflective, regardless of the incident polarization. Thus in the vicinity of the cavity resonance, the LS polarizer of Fig. 4a can be used as a component of the LS isolator. Furthermore, if the left dichroic nanolayer of the LS polarizer in Fig. 4a is removed, the layered structure becomes asymmetric, as shown in Fig. 5a. Despite the structural asymmetry, the transmittance of the LS polar- izer remains identical for the opposite incident directions, due to the reciprocity principle. In particular, the reso- nant transmittance for the TE polarization is less than 10−7 (as seen in Fig. 5c), still implying an enormous enhancement of the polarization extinction ratio. By contrast, the reflectance and absorptance are extremely asymmetric about the direction of incidence, as seen in Fig. 5b. At the frequency of the cavity resonance, the wave with the TE polarization traveling from left to right is almost totally reflected by the asymmetric LS polar- izer, while the wave with the TE polarization traveling in the opposite direction is almost totally absorbed, pri- marily by the right dichroic nanolayer. Note that the Salisbury screen, which is inherently asymmetric, can also produce, at the resonance frequency, strongly asym- metric absorption/reflection of the incident wave [9]. It will, however, have the polarization extinction ratio and power limitation of a common dichroic-sheet polarizer. By comparison, in the case of the asymmetric LS po- larizer of Fig. 5a, the polarization extinction ratio and power-handling capability are greatly enhanced.  9095100Frequency (GHz)-30-20-100T,R (dB)TRyzx 012345Spatial location (mm)-30-20-1001020I/I0 (dB)01234Spatial location (mm)-30-20-1001020I/Iin (dB)01234Spatial location (mm)-30-20-1001020I/Iin (dB)bca9095100Frequency (GHz)-30-20-100T,R (dB)4 (a) Schematics of FIG. 5. the asymmetric absorp- tive/reflective LS polarizer involving two dichroic nanolay- ers (black) incorporated in the host multilayer structure of Fig. 2a; (b) simulated spectral reflectance (solid line) and ab- sorptance (dotted line), and (c) spatial intensity distribution, E(z)2, at the cavity resonance frequency 95 GHz, for the TE polarization in the forward (red) and backward (green) propagation directions. III. QUASI-OPTICAL MEASUREMENTS OF THE LAYERED-SHEET POLARIZER The proof-of-concept measurements of the LS polariz- ers introduced in Section 2 have been carried out in the W-band. The asymmetric LS polarizer was fabricated using 5-cm-diameter C-cut sapphire and quartz wafers and aluminum (Al) wire grids to produce the layer stack (H1L1)2(H1L2)(GH2)2(L2H1)(L1H1)2, where L1 and L2 are 404-µm and 442-µm thick quartz, respectively, H1 is a 256-µm thick sapphire, and (GH2) is a 40-nm thick Al wire grid with a duty cycle of 0.3 and period of 20 µm, deposited on a 246-µm thick sapphire wafer. The layer structure was mainly determined by the wafers on hand, and the wire grid was designed to fit to the fabricated multilayer. First, quasi-optical measurements of the wire grid on a double-thick sapphire (GH 2 2 ) were carried out with the use of Gaussian beams (beam waist diameter of ∼ 0.5 cm) normally incident to the grid. The S-parameters of (GH 2 2 ) were measured as a function of frequency with the use of a vector network analyzer. No significant differ- ence was noticed, within experimental error, between the measurements for the two (opposite) incident directions. The transmittance and reflectance spectra of (GH 2 2 ) for the TM and TE polarizations are shown in Figs. 6a and 6b, respectively. The sharp dip in the reflectance for the TM polarization at 94.1 GHz indicates the position of the Fabry-P´erot resonance of the substrate. At the resonance frequency, the polarization extinction ratio of (GH 2 2 ) is 33 dB. For the TE polarization, the reflectance is 0.86, implying that (GH 2 2 ) has a significant absorp- tance of 0.14. The S-parameter measurements were then performed on the layer stack. For the TM polarization, the dif- ference between the measurements for the two incident directions was negligible, similarly to the case of (GH 2 2 ). The transmittance and reflectance spectra for the TM polarization are shown in Fig. 7a. The layer stack has a nearly perfect resonant transmittance (with a resonance FIG. 6. Quasi-optical spectral measurements of the aluminum wire grid on sapphire: transmittance (dashed line) and re- flectance (solid line) of the (a) TM- and (b) TE-polarized Gaussian beam. Q-factor of 92) at 94.4 GHz and high reflectance away from the cavity resonance, indicating that the TM polar- ization does not interact with the wire grids. For the TE polarization, the transmittance is suppressed down to -50 dB within the entire band gap, being identical for the two incident directions (Figs. 7b and 7c). By comparison, the absorptance and reflectance are highly asymmetric about the direction of incidence. For the Gaussian beam inci- dent from the left (Fig. 7b), the reflectance is 0.99 in the vicinity of the resonance frequency, implying that the ab- sorptance is less than 0.01. By contrast, for the Gaussian beam incident from the right (Fig. 7c), the reflectance has a sharp dip of -38 dB at 94.03 GHz, indicating that the TE polarization is almost totally absorbed at the cavity resonance. The red-shift of the resonance frequency for the TE polarization is attributed to parasitic reactances of the wire grids, which effectively increase the cavity thickness. According to our simulations, this effect can be reduced by decreasing the period of the wire grid. Notwithstanding the different frequencies of the cavity resonance for the TM and TE polarizations (in Figs. 7a and 7c), our experimental results check well with those presented in Fig. 5b. The polarization extinction ratio as high as 50 dB and strong asymmetry of the absorp- tance/reflectance about the direction of incidence, in the vicinity of the resonance frequency, have both been ex- perimentally demonstrated. In addition, the extinction ratio of the LS polarizer was not adversely affected when it was tilted at an angle as large as 40 degrees to the incoming beam. The oblique incidence, though, resulted in a blue-shift of the resonant frequency. IV. INTEGRATED LAYERED-SHEET ISOLATOR A direct way to assemble a LS isolator is by placing a thin-sheet 45-degree Faraday rotator between a pair of the absorbing LS polarizers (such as in Figs. 4a or 5a), following the scheme of Fig. 1. A thin-sheet 45-degree Faraday rotator in the form of a resonant multilayer cav-  9095100Frequency (GHz)-40-30-20-100T,R (dB)TR9095100Frequency (GHz)-40-30-20-100T,R (dB)TR9095100Frequency (GHz)-40-30-20-100T,R (dB)TRTMTETM9095100Frequency (GHz)-40-30-20-100T,R (dB)TRTE9095100Frequency (GHz)-30-20-100T,R (dB)9095100Frequency (GHz)-30-20-100T,R (dB)ba5 FIG. 7. Quasi-optical spectral measurements of the asymmet- ric LS polarizer: transmittance (dashed line) and reflectance (solid line) of (a) the TM-polarized Gaussian beam, (b) the TE-polarized Gaussian beam incident to the right and (c) to the left. ity incorporating subwavelength magnetic layers was dis- cussed for the X-band in Ref. [4]. Thus the isolator as- sembly can include three resonant components operating at the same resonance frequency. Here we present a design of LS isolator based on a sin- gle multilayer cavity, which we coin 'integrated LS iso- lator'. The integrated LS isolator, designed for the W- band, is shown in Fig. 8. It still involves magnetic and dichroic layers incorporated in a sapphire/quartz mul- tilayer, but the polarizers cannot be identified as sepa- rate parts of the isolator. The multilayer includes two symmetric half-wave defect layers, providing a pair of resonant cavity-localized modes which enable a low-loss Faraday rotator [16]. The magnetic layers are a 11.65- µm thick strontium ferrite (SrFe12O19) with the permit- tivity ε = 36 + i0.1 [17, 18], diagonal elements of the permeability tensor µii = 1 and specific Faraday rota- tion α = 700 deg/cm [18], and the dichroic nanolay- ers are characterized by the sheet resistances Rx = ∞ and Ry = 15.6 Ω/sq. The position of the magnetic lay- ers is determined by the following. Note that at MMW frequencies, the nonreciprocal response is usually asso- ciated with the magnetic permeability tensor, whereas absorption is often caused by electrical conductivity of the magnetic material [19]. This implies that the mag- netic component of the electromagnetic wave is respon- sible for the nonreciprocal effects (such as Faraday rota- tion), while the electric component for the losses. Also note that at the cavity resonance, the nodal planes of the electric field component coincide with the antinodal planes of the magnetic field component, and vice versa. Therefore, when a subwavelength magnetic layer (such as strontium ferrite) is positioned at the antinodal plane of the magnetic field (also the nodal plane of the electric field), the Faraday rotation is enhanced and the losses are suppressed at the same time [4]. This approach can be utilized for any lossy magnetic material of consider- able magnetic gyrotropy, provided that the gyrotropy is predominantly associated with the permeability tensor while the losses are caused by the electric conductivity. Such magnetic materials are available from microwave to long- and mid-infrared frequencies [19, 20]. The two pairs of the (aligned) dichroic nanolayers, making a 45-degree angle with each other, each act as FIG. 8. (a) Schematics of the integrated LS isolator composed of the resonant sapphire/quartz (dark/light blue) multilayer incorporating two magnetic layers (red) and two pairs of the (aligned) dichroic nanolayers (black) making a 45-degree an- gle with each other; (b) simulated spectral transmittance in the forward (red) and backward (green) propagation direc- tions in the vicinity of the cavity resonance; (c,d) the corre- sponding spatial intensity distributions, E(z)2, at the reso- nance frequency 94.20 GHz. the asymmetric polarizer. They reflect the TE-polarized component of the incoming wave and resonantly absorb the TE-polarized component of the wave passed the mag- netic layers, in either direction (Figs. 8c and 8d). Note that the dichroic nanolayers can adversely affect the Fara- day rotation when positioned very close to the magnetic layer. On the other hand, placing them at the edges of the multilayer degrades their polarization contrast and power-handling capability. The integrated LS isolator, at normal incidence, achieves insertion loss of 0.04 dB and return loss of 33 dB at the resonance frequency 94.20 GHz (Fig. 8b). The return loss can be further increased by increasing the number of sapphire/quartz bi-layeres. Away from the resonance, the LS isolator is highly reflective in either di- rection. At oblique incidence, the degree of isolation pro- gressively deteriorates with increasing angle of incidence, in the same way as for conventional free-space isolators. One way to address this problem is by adding a metal- lic nanolayer to the LS isolator [5]. The position of the metallic nanolayer should coincide with a nodal plane of the electric component of the resonant field distribu- tion at normal incidence, to avoid a significant increase in the insertion loss [21]. At oblique incidence, though, the nodal plane of the electric field distribution can shift away from the metallic nanolayer thus making the LS isolator highly reflective at any frequency. For this to  9095100Frequency GHz-60-40-200T,R (dB)TR9095100Frequency GHz-60-40-200T,R (dB)TR9095100Frequency GHz-60-40-200T,R (dB)TR9095100Frequency GHz-60-40-200T,R (dB)TRTMTETEbca6 happen, the nodal plane location must not coincide with the symmetry plane (if any) of the multilayered struc- ture. This approach is discussed in greater detail in Ref. [22]. V. CONCLUSION We have developed the wide-aperture LS isolators for use in optical and quasi-optical systems. Our design is based on a resonant multilayer dielectric cavity host- ing subwavelength magnetic layers and dichroic nanolay- ers. The role of the cavity resonance is essential and multifold. Firstly, the resonance enhances the magnetic Faraday rotation produced by the subwavelength mag- netic layers thus allowing to make the LS isolator rather thin -- its total thickness does not exceed a few wave- lengths. Secondly, the resonant conditions allow the use of dichroic nanolayers by enhancing/modifying their dichroic properties. In particular, the resonant condi- tions provide a nearly total (resonant) absorption of the backward-propagating light by the dichroic nanolayers. The dichroic nanolayers taken out from the resonant multilayer cavity would be partially absorptive/reflective and, thus, could not be used in a sheet isolator. Finally, the resonant conditions are necessary for the formation of quasi-nodal planes in the oscillating electric field dis- tribution. Placing a metallic nanolayer at the location of an asymmetric nodal plane results in the rejection of the obliquely incident light and rendering the LS isolator omnidirectional [5]. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This research was supported by AFOSR via grants FA9550-16-1-0058, FA8650-17-C-1026, FA9550-15-F- 0001, and LRIR 18RYCOR013. [1] Handbook of Optical Components and Engineering, edited by K. Chang (Wiley-Interscience, New York, 2003). [2] D. H. Martin and R. J. Wylde, IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech. 57, 99 (2009). [12] J. R. Piper and S. Fan, ACS Photonics, 1, 347 (2014). [13] Y. Liu, A. Chadha, D. Zhao, J. R. Piper, Y. Jia, Y. Shuai, L. Menon, H. Yang, Z. Ma, S. Fan, F. Xia, and W. Zhou, Appl. Phys. Lett. 105, 181105 (2014). [14] I. S. Nefedov, C. A. Valagiannopoulos, S. M. Hashemi, [3] R. I. Hunter and D. A. Robertson, IEEE Trans. Microw. and E. I. Nefedov, Sci. Rep. 3, 2662 (2013). Theory Tech. 55, 890 (2007). [4] K. Smith, T. Carroll, J. D. Bodyfelt, I. Vitebskiy, and A. A. Chabanov, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 46, 165002 (2013). [5] A. A. Chabanov, K. Smith, T. Carroll, and I. Vitebskiy, in 2014 8th International Congress on Advanced Elec- tromagnetic Materials in Microwaves and Optics (IEEE, New York, 2014), p. 79. [15] D. G. Baranov, J. H. Edgar, T. Hoffman, N. Bassim, and J. D. Caldwell, Phys. Rev. B 92, 201405(R) (2015). [16] H. Kato, T. Matsushita, A. Takayama, M. Egawa, K. Nishimura, and M. Inoue, IEEE Trans. Magn. 38, 3246 (2002). [17] H. Liu, Z. Lou, H. Wang, and J. Miao, J. Infrared Millim. Terahertz Waves 30, 401 (2009). [6] C. Hagglund, S. P. Apell, and B. Kasemo, Nano Lett. [18] M. Shalaby, M. Peccianti, Y. Ozturk, and R. Morandotti, 10, 3135 (2010). Nat. Commun. 4, 1558 (2013). [7] J. Zhang, K. F MacDonald, and N. I. Zheludev, Light [19] A. G. Gurevich and G. A. Melkov, Magnetization Oscil- Sci. Appl. 1, e18 (2012). [8] S. Huang, Z. Xie, W. Chen, J. Lei, F. Wang, K. Liu, and L. Li, Opt. Express 26, 7066 (2018). [9] W. Salisbury, U.S. Patent No. 2,599,944, 1952. lations and Waves (CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996). [20] A. K. Zvezdin, and V. A. Kotov, Modern Magnetooptics and Magnetooptical Materials (Taylor & Francis, New York, 1997). [10] R. L. Fante and M. T. McCormack, IEEE Trans. Anten- [21] P. H. Berning and A. F. Turner, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 47, nas Propag. 36, 1443 (1988). 230 (1957). [11] J. R. Tischler, M. S. Bradley, and V. Bulovi´c, Opt. Lett. [22] E. Makri, K. Smith, A. A. Chabanov, I. Vitebskiy, and 31, 2045 (2006). T. Kottos, Sci. Rep. 6, 22169 (2016).
1708.09179	1	1708	2017-08-30T09:05:17	Micrometer thick soft magnetic films with magnetic moments restricted strictly in plane by negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	Stripe domains or any other type domain structures with part of their magnetic moments deviating from the film plane, which usually occur above a certain film thickness, are known problems that limit their potential applications for soft magnetic thin films (SMTFs). In this work, we report the growth of micrometer thick c-axis oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 SMTFs with their magnetic moments restricted strictly in plane by negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy. Extensive characterizations have been performed on these films, which show that they exhibit very good soft magnetic properties even for our micrometer thick films. Moreover, the anisotropy properties and high-frequency properties were thoroughly investigated and our results show very promising properties of these SMTFs for future applications.	physics.app-ph	physics	Micrometer thick soft magnetic films with magnetic moments restricted strictly in plane by negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy Tianyong Ma, Juanying Jiao, Zhiwei Li, Liang Qiao, Tao Wang, Fashen Li Key Laboratory for Magnetism and Magnetic Materials of the Ministry of Education, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China Corresponding author: [email protected] and [email protected] Abstract Stripe domains or any other type domain structures with part of their magnetic moments deviating from the film plane, which usually occur above a certain film thickness, are known problems that limit their potential applications for soft magnetic thin films (SMTFs). In this work, we report the growth of micrometer thick c-axis oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 SMTFs with their magnetic moments restricted strictly in plane by negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy. Extensive characterizations have been performed on these films, which show that they exhibit very good soft magnetic properties even for our micrometer thick films. Moreover, the anisotropy properties and high-frequency properties were thoroughly investigated and our results show very promising properties of these SMTFs for future applications. Keywords: negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy, magnetic moments, perpendicular anisotropy, high-frequency properties 1. Introduction In recent years, study of soft magnetic thin films (SMTFs) has become one of the hot topics in the field of magnetism because of their potential applications in high-frequency fields, such as miniature inductors, micro-transformers and noise suppressors [1-3]. In high-frequency applications, there are two basic demands for the SMTFs, which include small switching field and high permeability before the cut-off frequency. In order to reach these requirements, the magnetic materials must have both high saturation magnetization sM and low coercivity cH . Extensive studies have been devoted to Fe- and Co-based amorphous and nanocrystalline SMTFs with negligible magnetocrystalline anisotropy [4,5] and these SMTFs exhibit excellent static and high-frequency magnetic properties. However, in practical uses of magnetic devices, the SMTFs must have sufficient thickness (usually above micrometer) to obtain enough magnetic flux signal [6]. For the well-studied Fe- and Co-based amorphous and nanocrystalline SMTFs, a considerable perpendicular anisotropy will always occur due to defects and/or internal stress coming from the growth procedure of these SMTFs [7-9]. This perpendicular anisotropy will result in the appearance of a stripe-type domain structure when the thickness of these SMTFs exceeds a few hundred nanometers. Such a stripe domain structure will lead to two unfavorable consequences that hinders practical applications [10,11]: (1) a significant increase in coercivity, which leads to a deterioration of the soft magnetic properties; (2) the magnetic moments exhibit a large vertical component rather than strictly lie within the film plane. In practical uses, for example, the inductance and the quality factor of the miniature inductors will be significantly reduced and the loss will be extremely large when SMTFs with stripe domain structure were used. Therefore, preparation of thick enough SMTFs with its magnetic moments strictly lying parallel to the film plane is essential for them to have excellent soft magnetic properties and thus is crucial for practical applications of these SMTFs. In our previous work, we have studied CoIr-based SMTFs with a strong negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy grain uK , which shows that the c-plane of the CoIr crystal is an easy magnetization plane and the c-axis is the corresponding hard axis. In other words, rotation of the magnetic moments from the c-plane to the c-axis direction must overcome an effective magnetic field H grain u 2 K grain u M s of the order of ~8 kOe [12,13] in addition to the demagnetization field 4πMs. Therefore, we anticipate that the critical thickness for stripe type domain structure to appear shall be greatly enhanced if the CoIr SMTFs were grown with their c-plane parallel to the film plane. In this work, to verify our idea, we report the growth of oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 SMTFs up to micrometer thick. Our results show that these films with film thickness ranging from 100 nm to 1.12 μm all have excellent soft magnetic properties with small coercivity and, more importantly, with the magnetic moments of these films lie parallel to the film plane. The intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy and total effective out-of-plane anisotropy have been investigated, and our high-frequency permeability measurements show very promising properties of these SMTFs for future practical applications. 2. Experiment All our samples were prepared by DC perpendicular magnetron sputtering method with a layered structure of substrate/Ti/Au/Co84Ir16 (see inset of Fig. 1 (a)). Si wafer with (100) surface orientation was used as substrate, and the seed layer of Ti(8 nm) / Au(25 nm) was deposited first in order to induce the c-axis orientation of the Co84Ir16 soft magnetic layer. A variety of oriented Co84Ir16 films with different layer thicknesses ranging from 100 nm to 1120 nm were deposited using the same seed layer. In this work, for clarity, the samples were denoted as CoIr100, CoIr300, CoIr500, CoIr950, and CoIr1120 corresponding to samples with Co84Ir16 layer thicknesses of 100, 300, 500, 950, and 1120 nanometer. The seed layer was deposited using Ar as working gas with a pressure of 0.25 Pa. The Co84Ir16 soft magnetic layer was grown with an Ar pressure of 0.3 Pa by using Co target with five Ir chips symmetrically placed on the erosion race-track. To induce an in-plane uniaxial anisotropy, the substrate was inclined by 5o with a wedge during the sputtering process. The crystalline structure and cross section morphology were investigated by X-ray diffraction technique (XRD) and scanning electron microscope (SEM). The out-of-plane magnetization component in zero-field was detected through magnetic force microscopy (MFM). The static magnetic properties were measured with a vibrating sample magnetometer (VSM) and the dynamic magnetic properties were measured with an electron spin resonance spectrometer (ESR). The microwave permeability measurements were performed by a vector network analyzer (VNA) using the shorted microstrip method. 3. Results and discussion The XRD patterns of the samples with indicated Co84Ir16 layer thicknesses measured with  2 scan are shown in Fig. 1 (a). Only two diffraction peaks corresponding to Au (111) plane and Co84Ir16 (002) plane can be seen for all the samples. The schematic layer structure of the samples is shown in the inset of Fig. 1 (a). Similar to our previous work [13], the 8 nm Ti layer provides an amorphous surface that assists the oriented growth of the Au layer with (111) plane parallel to the thin film which was expected to induce the oriented growth of Co84Ir16 soft magnetic layer with its c-axis normal to the film surface. This was proved working very well by the only diffraction peak of the Co84Ir16 (002) plane for all our samples. To further verify the goodness of the c-axis alignment of the Co84Ir16 layer, rocking scans on the (002) peak were made for the CoIr100 and CoIr1120 samples as shown in Fig.1 (b). The full width at half maximum (FWHM) determined from Lorentz fits to the experimental data amount to 1.9o and 1.7o for the CoIr100 and CoIr1120 samples, respectively. The small values of FWHM reveal the good alignment of the Co84Ir16 layer [14]. Interestingly, the even smaller value for the CoIr1120 sample demonstrates that the misalignment which might come from defects or lattice mismatch can be further reduced for thicker samples. In Fig. 2 we present a typical cross-section image from SEM measurements for the 950 nm sample. The good alignment of the c-axis of the Co84Ir16 layer can be directly seen from the columnar-like crystalline structure. The in-plane magnetic hysteresis loops of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 SMTFs are shown in Fig. 3 (a)-(e). These loops were measured with the applied magnetic field parallel or perpendicular to the easy axis within the film plane. For all samples, the hysteresis loops are totally different when measured in the two directions, which suggests that all films possess an in-plane uniaxial magnetic anisotropy. The uniaxial anisotropy induced by the oblique deposition technique can be explained with the framework of the so-called self-shadowing model [15]. According to this model, the region behind a growing crystallite is in the "shadow" of the crystallite and thus is prevented from continuous receiving metal vapor, so the crystallites will form a two-dimensional array of chains which leads to the uniaxial anisotropy of the SMTFs. The almost rectangular loops are observed along the easy axis and the remanence ratios are all above 0.92. The large remanence ratio suggests that nearly all the magnetic moments lie parallel to the film plane even for our micrometer thick sample. This is in sharp contrast to the Fe- and Co-based amorphous and nanocrystalline SMTFs in which strip domain structure will appear when the film thickness exceeds only a few hundred nanometers [7-9]. As shown in Fig.3 (f), the saturation magnetization 4πMs of all the films are close to 14 KOe which agrees well with reported values in literature [16]. The coercivity cH determined from the easy axis loop decrease gradually from 35 Oe to 16 Oe with increasing film thickness. This decreasing tendency, which commonly exists in many magnetic thin films, can be well explained by the random anisotropy model for polycrystalline ferromagnetic films [17]. When the grain size is larger than the natural exchange length, the coercivity is inversely proportional to the grain size and can be described with nearly constant 4πMs and nearly invariable in-plane uniaxial anisotropy field induced by the same as H c  D 1 condition. The zero-field MFM images that were acquired in the as-deposited state at the film surface of sample CoIr950 and CoIr1120 are shown in Fig. 4. No obvious magnetic contrast can be seen in these zero-field MFM images, indicating the absence of stripe type domains and/or any other type of domain structures that involve with partial magnetic moments deviating from the others that lie parallel to the film plane. This matches well with the analysis from the hysteresis loops and is another evidence that most of the magnetic moments are restricted within the film plane. This is exactly the situation that we anticipated for the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 SMTFs with a strong intrinsic negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy of the order of ~ -106 J/m3. Together with the demagnetization field, this will provide an effective out-of-plane anisotropy of the order of ~ 20 kOe. On the other hand, the perpendicular anisotropy that leads to the stripe type domain structure is much smaller, ~ 104_105 J/m3. For example, the reported perpendicular anisotropy is about 9.5 kJ/m3 for NiFe films [18], and 11.3 kJ/m3 for FeCoNbB amorphous film [19], where stripe domain structure appears above several hundred nanometers. Therefore, the magnetic moments in our SMTFs are completely compelled to lie within the film plane by the strong effective out-of-plane anisotropy field. To quantify this effect and to get the value of the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy grain uK and the total effective out-of-plane anisotropy field H for our samples, we performed ESR measurements on all the films with a 9 applied parallel to the film plane and forming an angle of GHz microwave magnetic field applied in-plane but perpendicular to the easy axis direction. The DC magnetic field is rH rH is smallest when the applied magnetic field is parallel to the easy axis and the largest when perpendicular. From published works [13,20], H with the easy axis. The measured resonance fields H together with theoretical fits. It is well known that are shown in Fig. 5 (a)-(e) as a function of the relationship between the resonance field and the angle H can be expressed as: 2          H  H u 2 cos  0  H r cos    H  0    H u cos  2  0   H r cos    0 H  , (1) where  is the angular frequency,  is the gyromagnetic ratio, 0 is the equilibrium positions of the magnetization. The solid lines in Fig. 5 (a)-(e) are numerical fits to the experimental data using equation (1). The apparent twofold symmetry indicates a well defined in-plane uniaxial anisotropy in agreement with our VSM measurements [21]. The obtained total out-of-plane anisotropy field H are shown in Fig. 5 (f) as a function of film thickness. As can be seen, H decrease gradually from 27 kOe to 23 kOe with increasing film thickness. To get a clear understanding of this trend, we express the total out-of-plane anisotropy field as H 4 M  s  H grain u  H p , where 4  s H M grain u can be treated as constant. Then the decrease of H is coming from pH , the so called perpendicular anisotropy field in the favor of stripe domain structure. The corresponding perpendicular anisotropy constant can be determined as K  p MH p 2s which we believe is originating from the columnar structure and any defects or stress of the as-grown film [22, 23]. Following the above definition, 4  s H M grain u is determined to be 27.5 kOe and the intrinsic magnetocrystalline anisotropy grain uK was calculated to be -753 kJ/m3 which agrees well with reported values [12,13]. Then the thickness dependence of the perpendicular anisotropy pK was calculated and shown in Fig. 5 (f). Although pK is much larger than that for the NiFe film and the FeCoNbB amorphous film where pK is in the order of 10 kJ/m3, they are still much smaller than grain uK . Then, the net energy density gain grain K u  K P is still smaller when the magnetic moments lie parallel to the film plane even for the micrometer thick film. In other words, one can expect, the magnetic moments will be restricted within the film plane by the negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy provided K  P K grain u . To verify the potential applicability, we measured the microwave permeability spectra of our SMTFs by VNA. The frequency dependence of the permeability can be described by the following formula deduced from the Landau– Lifshitz–Gilbert (LLG) equation [24,25]:  M41   s  2   1 2 1 i  (  i  1 2 . (3) ) in which ω 1  ( M4γ   H grain u s  H )  (H   )H u u , uH 2 , where  is the angular frequency,  is the damping constant and uH is the in-plane uniaxial anisotropy field. Considering the values of sM and H have been obtained already, we fitted the experimental curves by equation (3) using uH and  as free fitting parameters as shown in Fig. 6 (a)-(e). The extracted values for uH are 115, 115, 120, 114, 110 Oe for our films in the order of increasing film thickness. Obviously, these values are approximately a constant which is consistent with the fact that they were induced by the same growth condition, namely the same incline angle ~ 5o during the sputtering process [15]. One can see that all these films exhibit a similar behavior with a nearly constant real part before the gradually decreasing resonance frequency with increasing film thickness. The initial permeability matches well with the calculated values by equation  i 1  4 HM s u , which is approximately 120 using the measured saturation magnetization sM4 and the extracted in-plane uniaxial anisotropy field uH . The natural resonance frequency exp rf corresponding to the maximum value in the imaginary part, as shown in Fig. 6 (f), follows the same trend of the calculated values by the extended Kittel's equation f r   2  HH u  which can be understood by the decrease of H with increasing film thickness. The weak discrepancy of the experimental and calculated data may result from the revised Kittel's equation derived from the LLG equation by neglecting the damping effect [26]. The damping constant  derived from the fitting, which increase with film thickness, were plotted in Fig. 6 (f). It is well known that , which is an important parameter for high frequency applications [27], consists of two parts, namely, the intrinsic and extrinsic contributions. The intrinsic part is largely depends on fundamental properties such as Ms and spin-orbit coupling effect [28], and the extrinsic part is generally explained by the defect-induced two-magnon model and/or the local resonance model [29,30], both of which is associated with magnetic inhomogeneities within the material (e.g. due to anisotropy dispersion and surface or interface roughness). Here, the intrinsic part may not influence the damping constant since sM is almost a constant. Therefore, the extrinsic part must play an important role in increasing the damping constant. Apart from this, it was reported that eddy currents also affect the permeability spectrum and cause a broadening of the resonance peak for thicker films [31,32]. From the above considerations, we believe that both magnetic inhomogeneities and eddy currents are involved in the increase of the damping constant, especially for the micrometer thick films. 4. Conclusions In summary, c-axis oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 magnetic films with strong negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy were fabricated in the range of 100 nm to 1.12 m. All these films were shown to have high saturation magnetization and high rectangular ratio with low coercivity in the easy direction. More importantly, all these films have a high degree of c-axis orientation even up to micrometer thick. As a result, the stripe type domain structure that usually appears above a few hundred nanometers has been effectively suppressed so that the magnetic moments lie strictly within the film plane. Additional, the intrinsic negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy constant was determined to be grain uK = -753 kJ/m3 and the permeability measurements indicate that all these films have very good high frequency properties. Therefore, our work provides an effective method to grow thick enough magnetic films with excellent soft magnetic characteristics for future practical applications. Acknowledgments This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundations of China (Nos. 11574122 and11204115) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (lzujbky-2017-k20). References [1] X. Yang, J.Q. Wei, X. H. Li, L.Q. Gong, T. Wang, F.S. Li 2012 Thickness dependence of microwave magnetic properties in electrodeposited Fe–Co soft magnetic films with in-plane anisotropy Physica B. 407 555 [2] V. Korenivski 2000 GHz magnetic film inductors J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 215 800 [3] M. Yamaguchi, Y. Miyazawa, K. Kaminishi, H. Kikuchi, S. Yabukami, K.I. Arai, T. Suzuki 2004 Soft magnetic applications in the RF range J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 268 170 [4] L. T. Hung, Nguyen N. Phuoc and C. K. Ong 2009 Angular dependence of dynamic magnetic properties and magnetization orientation distribution of thin films J. Appl. Phys. 106 063907 [5] T. J. Klemmer, K.A. Ellis, L.H. Chen, B. van Dover and S. Jin 2000 Ultrahigh frequency permeability of sputtered Fe–Co–B thin films J. Appl. Phys. 87 830 [6] V. Korenivski, R. B. van Dover 1997 Magnetic film inductors for radio frequency applications J. Appl. Phys. 82 10 [7] Nissim Amos, Robert Fernandez, Rabee Ikkawi, Beomseop Lee, Andrey Lavrenov, Alexander Krichevsky, Dmitri Litvinov and Sakhrat Khizroev 2008 Magnetic force microscopy study of magnetic stripe domains in sputter deposited Permalloy thin films J. Appl. Phys. 103 07E732 [8] A. B. Kashuba, V. L. Pokrovsky 1993 Stripe domain structures in a thin ferromagnetic film Phys. Rev. B. 48 14 [9] Marco Coïsson, Federica Celegato, Elena Olivetti, Paola Tiberto, Franco Vinai and Marcello Baricco 2008 Stripe domains and spin reorientation transition in Fe78B13Si9 thin films producedby rf sputtering J. Appl. Phys. 104 033902 [10] Yuanfu Lou, Ge Yin, Fu Zheng, Feilong Luo, Jianmin Bai, Dongping Wu, Jiangwei Cao and Fulin Wei 2012 Analysis of magnetic anisotropy of FeCoAlON thin films by the domain structures Materials Letters 79 45 [11] Nguyen N. Phuoc and C. K. Ong 2013 Thermal stability of high frequency properties of gradient-composition-sputtered FeCoHf films with and without stripe domains J. Appl. Phys. 114 023901 [12] Atsushi Hashimotoa and Shin Saito, Migaku Takahashi 2006 A soft magnetic underlayer with negative uniaxial magnetocrystalline anisotropy for suppression of spike noise and wide adjacent track erasure in perpendicular recording media J. Appl. Phys. 99 08Q907 [13] T. Wang, Y. Wang, G.G. Tan, F.S. Li, S. Ishio 2013 Microwave magnetic properties of the oriented CoIr soft magnetic film with negative magnetocrystalline anisotropy Physica B. 417 24 [14] R. A. Morris, Y. Inaba, J.W. Harrell and G.B. Thompson 2010 Influence of underlayers on the c-axis distribution in Co80Pt20 thin films Thin Solid Films 518 4970 [15] D. O. Smith, M.S. Cohen and G.P. Weiss 1960 Oblique-Incidence Anisotropy in Evaporated Permalloy Films J. App. Phys. 31 1755 [16] D. Hasegawa, S. Nakasaka, M. Sato, T. Ogawa and M. Takahashi 2006 Magnetization Process of h.c.p.-CoIr Nanoparticles With Negative Uniaxial Magnetocrystalline Anisotropy IEEE Trans. Magn. 42 2805 [17] G. Herzer 1990 GRAIN SIZE DEPENDENCE OF COERCIVITY AND PERMEABILITY IN NANOCRYSTALLINE FERROMAGNETS IEEE Trans. Magn. 26 1397 [18] Jeffrey McCord, Burak Erkartal, Thomas von Hofe, Lorenz Kienle, Eckhard Quandt, Olga Roshchupkina and Jörg Grenzer 2013 Revisiting magnetic stripe domains-anisotropy gradient and stripe asymmetry J. Appl. Phys. 113 073903 [19] Youxing Yu, Youran Yang, Yijiao Shan, Xiaofang Bi 2012 Abnormal substrate temperature dependent out-of-plane anisotropy in FeCoNbB amorphous films Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 232408 [20] Shujuan Yuan, Baojuan Kang, Liming Yu, Shixun Cao, Xinluo Zhao 2009 Increased ferromagnetic resonance linewidth and exchange anisotropy in NiFe/FeMn Bilayers J. Appl. Phys. 105 063902 [21] S. M. Rezende, J. A. S. Moura, and F. M. de Aguiar 1994 Ferromagnetic resonance of Fe(111)thin films and Fe(111)/Cu(111) multilayers Phys. Rev. B. 49 21 [22] Shan X. Wang,and Jongill Hong 1999 Magnetic and Microstructural Characterization of FeTaN High Saturation Materials for Recording Heads IEEE Trans. Magn. 35 2 [23] R.A. Morris, Y. Inaba, J.W. Harrell and G.B. Thompson 2010 Influence of underlayers on the c-axis distribution in Co80Pt20 thin films Thin Solid Films. 518 4970 [24] N.N. Phuoc, F. Xu, C.K. Ong 2009 Tuning magnetization dynamic properties of Fe–SiO2 multilayers by oblique deposition J. Appl. Phys. 105 113926 [25] S. Ge, S. Yao, M. Yamaguchi, X. Yang, H. Zuo, T. Ishii, D. Zhou, and F.Li 2007 Microstructure and magnetism of FeCo–SiO2 nano-granular films for high frequency application J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 40 3660 [26] Shujuan Yuan, Baojuan Kang, Liming Yu, Shixun Cao, Xinluo Zhao 2009 Increased ferromagnetic resonance linewidth and exchange anisotropy in NiFe/FeMn bilayers J. Appl. Phys. 105 063902 [27] N. Fujita, N. Inaba, F. Kirino, S. Igarashi, K. Koike, H. Kato 2008 Damping constant of Co/Pt multilayer thin-film media J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 320 3019 [28] V. Kambersky 1970 On the Landau-Lifshitz relaxation in ferromagnetic metals Can. J. Phys. B. 48 2906 [29] R. Arias and D. L. Mills 1999 Extrinsic contributions to the ferromagnetic resonance response of ultrathin films Phys. Rev. B. 60 7395 [30] C. Chappert, K. L. Dang, P. Beauvillain, H. Hurdequint, and D. Renard 1986 Ferromagnetic resonance studies of very thin cobalt films on a gold substrate Phys. Rev. B. 34 3192 [31] J. Ben Youssef, N. Vukadinovic, D. Billet and M. Labrune 2004 Thickness-dependent magnetic excitations in Permalloy films with nonuniform magnetization Phys. Rev. B. 69 174402 [32] N. Fujita, N. Inaba, F. Kirino, S. Igarashi, K. Koike and H. Kato 2008 Damping constant of Co/Pt multilayer thin-film media J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 320 3019 Fig. 1 (a) XRD patterns of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films with indicated layer thicknesses. The inset shows the schematic layer structure of the sample. (b) XRD rocking curves at the (002) peak of the 100 nm and 1120 nm films. Fig. 2 Typical SEM cross-section image of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 film of 950 nm thick. Fig. 3 (a-e) In-plane magnetic hysteresis loops of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films with the applied field parallel or perpendicular to the easy axis. (f) The thickness dependence of Hc determined from the easy axis loops and 4πMs for the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films. Fig. 4 Zero-field MFM images of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films with 950 nm and 1120 nm thicknesses. The image size are both 20 μm × 20 μm. Fig. 5 (a)-(e) Angle dependence of the resonance field (Hr) for the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films. The dots are experimental data and the curves are the fitted results. (f) The thickness dependence of Hθ and Kp. The red line is the fitting curve. Fig. 6 (a)-(e) Permeability spectra of the oriented hcp-Co84Ir16 films with indicated film thicknesses and the fitted damping constant α. (f) Thickness dependencies of the resonance frequency and the damping constant for the oriented Co84Ir16 films. fr is the calculated resonance frequency and frexp is that determined from the measured imaginary part of the permeability.
1705.05622	1	1705	2017-05-16T09:59:20	Implementation of the KDamper concept using disc springs	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	The KDamper is a novel passive vibration isolation and damping concept, based essentially on the optimal combination of appropriate stiffness elements, which include a negative stiffness el-ement. Among others, KDamper can provide comparative advantages in the very low fre-quency range. It should be mentioned, that the KDamping concept does not simply refer to a discrete vibration absorption device, but it consists a general vibration ab-sorption concept, applicable also for the design of advanced materials or complex structures. Such a concept thus presents the potential for numerous implementations in a large variety of technological applications, while further potential may emerge in a multi- physics environment. The paper proceeds to a review of the optimal design and selection of the parameters of the KDamper, which follows exactly the classical approach used for the design of the TMD. The negative stiffness elements have been replaced with a set of Belleville (disc) springs. It should be mentioned that two different cases for an initial displacement and an initial velocity have been considered. It is thus theoretically proven that the KDamper can inherently offer far better isolation and damping properties than the TMD. Finally, an application concerning the implementation of the KDamper for the design of a low frequency vertical vibration isolator is presented.	physics.app-ph	physics	1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 Im plem entation of the K D am per concept using disc springs Ioannis E Sapountzakis1, Pavlos G Tranakidis2 and Ioannis A Antoniadis3 1,2,3Mechanical Design and Control Systems Section, Mechanical Engineering Department National Technical University of Athens, Heroon Polytechniou 9, 15780 Zografou, Greece ABSTRACT The KDamper is a novel passive vibration isolation and damping concept, based essentially on the optimal combination of appropriate stiffness elements, which include a negative stiffness el- ement. The KDamper concept does not require any reduction in the overall structural stiffness, thus overcoming the corresponding inherent disadvantage of the "Quazi Zero Stiffness" (QZS) or "Negative Stiffness" (NS) isolators, which require a drastic reduction of the structure load bearing capacity. Compared to the traditional Tuned Mass damper (TMD), the KDamper can achieve better isolation characteristics, without the need of additional heavy masses, as in the case of the TMD. Contrary to the TMD and its variants, such as the inerter, the KDamper substi- tutes the necessary high inertial forces of the added mass by the stiffness force of the negative stiffness element. Among others, this can provide comparative advantages in the very low fre- quency range. It should be mentioned, that the KDamping concept does not simply refer to a discrete vibration absorption device, but it consists a general vibration ab-sorption concept, applicable also for the design of advanced materials or complex structures. Such a concept thus presents the potential for numerous implementations in a large variety of technological applications, while further potential may emerge in a multi- physics environment. The paper proceeds to a review of the optimal design and selection of the parameters of the KDamper, which follows exactly the classical approach used for the design of the TMD. The negative stiffness elements have been replaced with a set of Belleville (disc) springs. It should be mentioned that two different cases for an initial displacement and an initial velocity have been considered. It is thus theoretically proven that the KDamper can inherently offer far better isolation and damping properties than the TMD. Finally, an application concerning the implementation of the KDamper for the design of a low frequency vertical vibration isolator is presented. Corresponding author: Ioannis E Sapountzakis, PhD Candidate, Mechanical Design and Control Corresponding author: Ioannis E Sapountzakis, PhD Candidate, Mechanical Design and Control System Section, Department of Mechanical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Heroon Polytechniou 9, 15780, Zografou, Greece. Email: [email protected] 1. Introduction 2 The Tuned Mass Damper (TMD) has a long history, already more than 100 years. The TMD concept was first applied by [20]. A theory for the TMD was presented later in the paper by [34] . A detailed discussion of optimal tuning and damping parameters appears in [16]. Since then, numerous applications of various forms of TMDs have been reported. Some recent examples include vibration absorption in seismic or other forms of excitation of structures [15], wind and wave excitation in wind turbines by [8] and torsional vibrations in rotating and reciprocating machines by [31]. TMDs are available in various physical forms, including solids, liquids [8], or even active implementations [50]. The essential limitation of the TMD is that a large oscillating mass is required in order to achieve significant vibration reduction. Among others, this has prohibited the usage of TMDs in the automotive or aerospace sector. In an attempt to reduce the requirements for heavy oscillating masses, the inerter concept has been introduced in early 2000s by [32]. The inerter is a two terminal element which has the property that the force generated at its ends is proportional to the relative acceleration of its terminals. This constant of proportionality is called "inertance" and is measured in kilograms. The main advantage of the inerter is that the inerter need not have large mass in order to achieve the same inertia effect as the additional mass of the TMD. However, according to [10] since inerters, dampers and springs can be connected in multiple configurations, the comparison of the structure of the Frequency Response functions of the inerter and of the TMD becomes very complicated. In 2005 the inerter was profitably used as a part of suspension in Formula 1 racing car under the name of "J-damper" [9]. Since then, other applications emerged, such as in suspensions of railway vehicles [47] or in seismic protection of structures [42]. Although the initial inerter configuration is for linear accelerations, rotary versions [28], or even active configurations [46] have been proposed. Still, to work efficiently, all considered devices have to be precisely tuned which can be hard to achieve or even impossible in some cases. Moreover, proposed TMDs with inerters suffer from susceptibility to detuning. Although variable inertance mechanical configurations have been proposed for this purpose [5], the essential limitation of the inerter is the complex and elaborate mechanical design configurations needed for its implementation. A parallel direction to the various TMD approaches is the concept of introducing negative stiffness elements (or 'anti-springs') for vibration isolation. This concept has also a long history, being first introduced in the pioneering publication of [33], as well as in the milestone developments of [35]. The central concept of these approaches is to significantly reduce the stiffness of the isolator and consequently to reduce the natural frequency of the system even at almost zero levels [6], being thus called "Quazi Zero Stiffness" (QZS) oscillators. In this way, the transmissibility of the system for all operating frequencies above the natural frequency is reduced, resulting to enhanced vibration isolation. An initial comprehensive review of such designs can be 3 found in [21]. The negative stiffness behavior is primarily achieved by special mechanical designs involving conventional positive stiffness pre-stressed elastic mechanical elements, such as post-buckled beams, plates, shells and pre-compressed springs, arranged in appropriate geometrical configurations. Some interesting designs are described in [48], [44]. However, alternatively to elastic forces, other forms of physical forces can be used to produce an equivalent negative stiffness effect, such as gravitational [19], magnetic [36] or electromagnetic [52]. Quazi Zero Stiffness (QZS) oscillators are finding numerous applications in seismic isolation [17], [22], [37], [3] in all types of automotive suspensions [26], [27], [28] or in torsional vibrations [51]. Quite recently, periodic cellular structures with advanced dynamic behavior have been also proposed [45], [4], [32], [14], combining high positive and negative stiffness. Although the physical mechanisms that generate increased damping in cellular structures are not well understood, micro-buckling or slip- stick phenomena [25], [40], [11] could be among the possible explanations. Parallel, quite interesting possibilities towards achieving significant damping have been demonstrated to exist also in materials comprising a negative stiffness phase [24], not only at a material level [41], but also at macroscopic devices [18]. Moreover, such a behaviour c a n b e combined with high stiffness properties. A theoretical approach has been performed for the analysis of the static and dynamic stability of composite materials, incorporating negative stiffness elements [49]. However, Quazi Zero Stiffness (QZS) oscillators suffer from their fundamental requirement for a drastic reduction of the stiffness of the structure almost to negligible levels, which limits the static load capacity of such structures. For the completeness of the review, it should be mentioned that a rich variety of nonlinear dynamic phenomena [43], [43], [27], [7], [23], [38], either inherently present, or designed to be present in all types of the above vibration absorbers, greatly contribute to the complexity of their dynamic behavior, as well as to the increase of their dynamic performance. However, their treatment is far beyond the scope of this paper. In any case, they can be used to act complimentary to the above vibration absorption concept. Quite recently, a novel type of oscillator has been proposed [1], incorporating a negative stiffness element, which can exhibit extraordinary damping properties, without presenting the drawbacks of the traditional linear oscillator, or of the 'zero-stiffness' designs. This oscillator is designed to present the same overall (static) stiffness as a traditional reference original oscillator. However, it differs both from the original SDoF oscillator, as well as from the known negative stiffness oscillators, by appropriately redistributing the individual stiffness elements and by reallocating the damping. Although the proposed oscillator incorporates a negative stiffness element, it is designed 4 to be both statically and dynamically stable. Once such a system is designed according to the approach proposed in [1], it is shown to exhibit an extraordinary damping behaviour. Moreover, a drastic increase of several orders of magnitude has been observed for the damping ratio of the flexural waves propagating within layered periodic structures incorporating such negative stiffness oscillators [12]. In this paper, the concept of [1] is treated in a systematic way, within the context of the design of a general class of tuned mass dampers. In this way, a direct comparison of the KDamper with the TMD is performed in section 2, which reveals its basic properties. The KDamper always indicates better isolation properties than a TMD damper with the same additional mass. Instead of increasing the additional mass, the vibration isolation capability of the KDamper can be increased by increasing the value of the negative stiffness element. Consequently, significant vibration isolation properties can be achieved, even for very low values (practically insignificant) of the additional mass. However, the increase of the negative stiffness element is upper bounded by the static stability limit of the structure. Section 3 presents an application of the KDamper concept. The linear negative stiffness element is realized by a non-linear bistable element, which operates around an unstable equilibrium point. This bistable element takes the form of one Belleville spring, which transfer a negative force to a vertical spring through an appropriate mechanism. The system is designed so that it presents an adequate static load bearing capacity, while the transfer function of the system is below unity in the entire frequency range. x f(t) x f(t) m kN kP/2 kP/2 cD m k/2 kD y k/2 cD mD (a) (b) x f(t) x m m 5 f(t) kS/2 k3 y k4 kS/2 cD b ks/2 kP y ks/2 cD mD kN (c) (d) Figure 1: Schematic presentation of the considered vibration absorption concepts (a) Quasi-Zero Stiffness (QZS) oscillator, (b) Tunned Mass Damper(TMD), (c) Inerter (JDamper), (d) KDamper. Further insight to the physical behavior of the system is provided, by analyzing the balance of forces in the entire frequency range. It is observed that the magnitude of the damping force and of the inertia force of the additional mass is minimal throughout the entire frequency range, including the natural frequencies of the system. Thus, the external force is almost entirely balanced by the positive and negative stiffness forces, as well as by the inertia of the main mass. This fact ensures that an adequate level of elastic forces exists throughout the entire frequency range, able to counteract the inertial and the external excitation forces and justifies the concept of stiffness based vibration isolation. As it has been mentioned the non-linear bistable element takes the form of one disc spring. Disc springs are conical ring washers whose shape changes under axial loads, based on the approximated rotation of the generally uniform rectangular cross-section of the disc around a circle of inversion. Compared to other types of springs, the disc spring can be categorized as having a "small spring deflection coupled with high spring force". However, this restriction is circumvented by the ability to form stacks of multiple disc springs. Arranging the discs in parallel or nested formation multiplies the spring force, alternating or series arrangement multiplies the spring deflection. Both these stacking methods can be used in combination. One of the outstanding characteristics of the disc spring is doubtless its capacity for variation of the characteristic force-deflection curve over a wide range. Alongside practically linear characteristics, degressive force-deflection characteristics can also be implemented, even those in which spring force diminishes in certain ranges with increasing spring deflection. Many disc springs feature contact surfaces. These are predominantly large parts which in any case involve a high degree of production 6 complexity. In this case, modified calculation methods are used. Contact surfaces improve the guidance properties of disc springs. In some applications, the guiding element of the disc spring stack can have a disturbing influence. Slotted disc springs assume a special role. The slotting process changes the force-deflection range of the individual disc springs, resulting in greater spring deflections coupled with lower spring force. 2. Basic properties of the KDamper As it is stated in [2] KDamper uses the negative stiffness element and the basic concept as well as the steps of the optimal design are described. Now the three basic properties of the KDamper are going to be stated. The first one is the following. PROPERTY 1: The amplitude of the transfer function TXKI of the KDamper at the points qL and qR is less than the maximum amplitude of the transfer function TXMmax of a TMD with equal µ: T XKI T = XKL T = XKR T ≤ XM max (1) The obvious consequence of PROPERTY 1 is that the addition of a negative stiffness spring reduces the magnitude of the transfer function of the TMD. Figure 4 presents the Transfer function of the KDamper for two values of κ. K X T 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 μ=0.10 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 K X T 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 q=f/f0 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 μ=0.10 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 0.8 1 1.2 q=f/f0 (a) (b) Figure 4: Effect of the mass ratio µ on the Transfer function TXΚ of the KDamper for (a)κ=0.5, (b)κ=1.0. It should be noted that PROPERTY 1 does not hold for a spring kN with positive stiffness (i.e. with a negative value of κ). Next, the property 2 is the following 7 PROPERTY 2: The amplitude of the transfer function TXKI of the KDamper at the points qL and qR tends to zero when κ reaches the limit value of κMAX T XKI T = XKL T = XKR 0→ for ΜΑΧ→κκ (2) The most important consequence of eq(2) is that quite small values of the transfer function TXK can be reached. 3.5 3 2.5 ρ 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 I K X T 2 4 6 κ (a) 8 10 12 15 10 5 0 0 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 2 4 6 κ 8 10 12 (b) Figure 5: Variation of the KDamper parameters a) Effect of κ and µ the value of ρ=ωD/ω0. Β) Effect of κ and µ on the value TXKI of the transfer function TXK at the invariant points qL, qR. μ=0.01, κ=0.90κmax μ=0.01, κ=0.95κmax μ=0.01, κ=0.98κmax μ=100, κ=0 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 K X T 0 0 1 2 4 5 6 3 q=f/f0 Figure 6: Transfer functions TXK of the KDamper for values of κ , µ close to the limits. Figure 5 presents the variation of ρ and TXKI =TXKL=TXKR with the increase of the parameter κ. Figure 6 presents Transfer functions for values of κ or µ close to the limits. Values of low µ/high κ characterize the Kdamper, while values high µ/low κ can be indicative of an inerter. As it can be observed, very low values of the transfer function of the KDamper, can be reached, quite below unity. Moreover, these values can be achieved by an almost marginal value of µ=0.01. This fact implies that 8 the KDamper essentially does not require an additional mass mD. Moreover, the Kdamper indicates a superior behavior at the very low frequency range. A first implication of eq (42) is that there exists a range of values of κ for which: T XKL )( κ XKL T = 1)( κ < for κ ΜΑΧ ≥ UNκκ ≥ (3) Eq. (43) implies that in this case, the values TXKI=TXKL=TXKR do no longer present the maximum values of TXK since TXK(q=0)=1. Among others, this fact complicates the procedures for the selection of ζD based on averaging the slopes of TXK at the frequencies qL, qR , as it is the classical approach, proposed in [16]. Furthermore, although the fact that by increasing κ the transfer function TXKI=TXKL=TXKR can be reduced almost to zero, increasing κ has a number of implications in the design of the KDamper. First, high stiffness values result. Figure 7 reflects this fact to the increase of the stiffness values kN, kP and especially kS. N κ 0 -0.5 -1 -1.5 -2 -2.5 0 2 4 6 κ (a) P κ 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 S κ 0 0 2 4 6 κ 8 10 12 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 8 10 12 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 2 4 6 κ 8 10 12 (b) (c) Figure 7: Increase of the values of the stiffness elements of the KDamper by the increase of κ. (a) κN, (b) κP, (c)κS. Moreover, increasing the stiffness and especially kN may endanger the static stability of the structure. Although theoretically the value of kN is selected to ensure the static stability, variations of kN result in practice due to various reasons, such as temperature variations, manufacturing tolerances, or non-linear behavior, since almost all negative stiffness designs result from unstable non-linear systems. Consequently, an increase of the absolute value of kN by a factor ε may lead to a new value of kNL where the structure becomes unstable: k S + kk P + P k NL k NL 0 k −=⇔= NL kk PS k + S k P ) ε+= 1( k N And so the static stability margin ε can be exressed as ε = 1 2µρκ 2 ) 1(1[( ++ κ ] (4) (5) As it can be shown, the following PROPERTY 3 holds for ε. 9 PROPERTY 3: The increase of the negative stiffness of the system is upper bounded by the static stability limit of the structure: 0→ε for ΜΑΧ→κκ (6) Figure 8 presents the variation of κMAX over µ and of ε over κ and µ. X Α Μ K 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.25 μ (a) ε 2 10 1 10 0 10 -1 10 -2 10 10 -3 0 μ=0.01 μ=0.02 μ=0.05 2 4 6 κ (b) 8 10 12 Figure 8: Variation of KDamper parameters a) Effect of the mass ratio µ on the maximum value κMAX of κ. b) Effect of κ and µ over the static stability margin ε. Finally, high values of κ result to increased amplitudes of the response y, which may encounter further technological constraints. For example, for q=0 T YXK ( q )0 = = qY ( qX ( )0 )0 = = = qY ( X )0 = ST 1 κ+= 3. An implementation example 3.1 Indicative realization of a negative stiffness spring (7) An example for an implementation of the KDamper is now considered. It consists from a mass m which is supported by two parallel linear springs with stiffness kS and kP respectively and by a damper with constant cD . The damper cD and the spring kP are also connected to a mass mD . The negative stiffness spring kN is realized by one Belleville spring the properties of which will be found. t De Di Figure 9: Belleville spring 10 s u h0 m f(t) kP kS/2 CD kS/2 mD m kP mD kS/2 CD kS/2 x y u0 u (a) (a) (b) (b) Figure 10: Schematic presentation of the realization of the KDdamping concept using a Belleville spring (a) Configuration at the static equilibrium point, (b) Notation concerning the perturbed configuration. The static equilibrium position of the system is depicted in Fig 10(a), under the action of the gravity force. The perturbed position after an external dynamic excitation f(t) is depicted in Fig 10(b), along with the necessary notation concerning the various displacements of the system. The equations of motion of the proposed oscillator are: xm !! + c D ( x ! − y ! ) + k S l ( S l − SI ) + k l ( PP l − PI ) = f mg + ym !! D − c D ( x ! − y ! ) − k l ( PP l − PI ) + f u )( N = gm D (8.a) (8.b) 11 where lS(t) is the length of the spring kS, lSI is the initial length of the un-deformed spring kS, lP(t) is the length of the spring kP, lPI is the initial length of the un-deformed spring kP and fN(u) is the non-linear force exerted by the Belleville spring. The equations of the system at the static equilibrium point are derived by the equations (8): k S l ( S 0 l − SI ) + k l ( PP 0 l − PI ) = mg − k l ( PP 0 l − PI ) + f u ( N 0 ) = gm D (9.a) (9.b) where the index ( )0 is used to denote the static equilibrium point, lS0 is the length of the (normally deformed) spring kS at the static equilibrium point, lP0 is the length of the (normally deformed) spring kP at the static equilibrium point and fN(u0) is the non-linear force exerted by the Belleville spring at the static equilibrium point. Denoting by: v S l = 0 S l − SI v P l = 0 P l − PI f N = 0 f u ( 0 N ) the following equations result: v S [( = gmm ) + D − f /] k S N 0 v E ( −= gm D + f N 0 /) k P (10.a) (10.b) (10.c) (11.a) (11.b) Further elaboration of the sets of Eqs (49),(50),(51) and substitution in the set of eqs (48) leads to the final set of equations of motion: xm !! + c ( x ! − y ! ) + xk S + k P ( x − y ) D = f ym !! D − c D ( x ! − y ! ) − k P ( x − y ) f + u )( ND 0 = where: f ND u )( = f N u )( − f N 0 uu = 0 + y l S l = 0 S x + l P l = 0 P x −+ y (12.a) (12.b) (13.a) (13.b) (13.c) (13.d) The following expressions can be derived for the non-linear force fN and the equivalent non-liner stiffness kN of the Belleville spring (Lingshuai et al., 2014) F= #$%&'( +,-./( K#1 2 (K#1 45−2 45− 21 +1) (14) k;=<=<2= #$%&'( >,-./( K#1 (K#1 45 1−3 45* 2+@1 2 1 3.2 Selection of the system parameters 12 (15) The vibrations of a mass of m=100Kg are to be isolated, which is supported in the vertical direction by a system of springs of with a total static stiffness of k=49050N/m. The corresponding vertical static deflection of the system under its own weight is XVSD=2cm and the natural frequency of the system is f0=3.5Hz. The main parameters of a KDamper system are selected as µ=0.01 and κ=7.8. The resulting static stability margin is ε=0.05. The full set of the KDamper parameters is presented in Tables 1 and 2. Table 1. Non-dimensional KDamper parameters µ κ Ε ρ ζD qL qR κΝ κP κS 0.01 7.8 0.05 1.4279 0.69 0.97 1.87 -0.159 0.1784 2.400 Table 2. Dimensional KDamper parameters kS kP kN mD cD 1.17x105 N/m 8.8004x104 N/m -7.8003x103N/m 1.0 Kg 43.64 Nsec/m It should be noted that if the damping element CD was used to connect directly the mass m to the support (ground), the equivalent damping effect on the system would have been essentially negligible: = ζ 0 c D 2/ km = = ρµζ D 01.0 (16) (a) (b) Figure 11: Response Functions of the linear system to an initial displacement of 0.01 m a) 13 Displacements, b) Velocities. the mass mD is equal to yBCD=0.04m. Figure 11 presents the waveforms of the displacements and the velocities of the linear system to an initial displacement of 0.01m. As it can be observed at the figure above the maximum displacement of The next step is the design of the Belleville springs to be used for the non-linear problem. First, the equation above for the nonlinear stiffness K is considered. By setting the derivative of this equation equal to zero it can be found that when k; is maximum (kBCD) s=h0. The following equations must be true kBCD=1.02k;(linear)=−7946.7 N/m k(yBCD)=0.9kBCD=−7107.3 N/m values of k; in the accepted limits. Therefore, from eq. (17),(18) the full set of the Belleville springs The two equations must be true in order to have an adequate level of damping and also to keep the (17) (18) parameters can be defined. The full set of the Belleville springs parameters can be found in Table 3. Table 3. Belleville springs parameters No 56 E ν De Di 206 0.3 360 288 th 3 h0/th d 1.9 1.22 3.3 Response analysis for initial displacement Figure 12 presents the waveforms of the displacements and velocities of the response of the non- linear oscillator to an initial displacement of 0.01m. (a) (b) 14 Figure 12: Response of the KDamper configuration to an initial displacement of 0.01m (a) Displacements, (b) Velocities. Figure 13 presents the variation of the force FN as a function of the displacement u of the Belleville springs. The red color represents the theoretical curve and the blue the real one. Figure 13: Variation of the force FN as a function of the displacement u (a) (b) Figure 14: Variation of the non-linear stiffness kN to an initial displacement 0.01m. a) Variation in the time domain, b) Range of oscillation. Figure 14a presents the variation of kN over time and Fig 14.b as a function of the displacement u of the Belleville springs. A significant variation of kN is observed, verifying the strong no-linear nature 15 of the response. However, the negative stiffness kN remains within the specified acceptable limits, which guarantee both static stability and damping behaviour. (a) (b) Figure 15: Waveforms of the various force types of the KDamper to an initial displacement 0.01m (a) Forces at the mass m (b) Forces at the mass mD Figure 15 presents the waveforms of the forces. This fact ensures that an adequate level of elastic forces exists throughout the entire frequency range, able to counteract the inertial and the external excitation forces and provides further insight on the background of stiffness based vibration isolation. The next step is to check the stresses for the proposed structure. The equations for the stresses in the Belleville springs are σVW=− #$%&'( σY=− #$%&'( σYY=− #$%&'( σYYY=− #$%&'( σY\=− #$%&'( (,-./( K#1 2 @X (,-./( K#1 2 (Κ#Κ1 45− 21 + Κ@) (,-./( K#1 2 Κ#Κ1 45− 21 − Κ@ (,-./( K#1 2 %[ Κ#(Κ1−2Κ@ (,-./( K#1 2 %[ Κ#(Κ1−2Κ@ 45− 21 − Κ@) 45− 21 + Κ@) (19.a) (19.b) (19.c) (19.d) (19.e) Figure 16: Stresses in the Belleville spring for an initial displacement 0.01m As it can be seen in Fig.16 all stresses are in the allowed limits as the yield strength for the material 16 proposed (steel) is 1100 MPa. 3.4 Response analysis for initial velocity Figure 12 presents the waveforms of the displacements and velocities of the response of the non- linear oscillator to an initial velocity of 2.5m/s. (a) (b) Figure 12: Response of the KDamper configuration to an initial velocity of 2.5m/s (a) Displacements, (b) Velocities. Figure 13 presents the variation of the force FN as a function of the displacement u of the Belleville springs. The red color represents the theoretical curve and the blue the real one. Figure 13: Variation of the force FN as a function of the displacement u (a) 17 (b) Figure 14: Variation of the non-linear stiffness kN to an initial velocity of 2.5m/s. a) Variation in the time domain, b) Range of oscillation. Figure 14a presents the variation of kN over time and Fig 14.b as a function of the displacement u of the Belleville springs. A significant variation of kN is observed, verifying the strong no-linear nature of the response. However, the negative stiffness kN remains within the specified acceptable limits, which guarantee both static stability and damping behaviour. (a) (b) Figure 15: Waveforms of the various force types of the KDamper to an initial velocity of 2.5m/s (a) Forces at the mass m (b) Forces at the mass mD Figure 15 presents the waveforms of the forces. This fact ensures that an adequate level of elastic forces exists throughout the entire frequency range, able to counteract the inertial and the external excitation forces and provides further insight on the background of stiffness based vibration isolation. Figure 16: Stresses in the Belleville spring for an initial displacement 0.01m As it can be seen in Fig.16 all stresses are in the allowed limits as the yield strength for the material proposed (steel) is 1100 MPa. 4. Conclusions The systematic design procedure of section 3 leads to a KDamper performance that can inherently 18 offer far better isolation and damping properties than the TMD. Moreover, since the isolation and damping properties of the KD essentially result from the stiffness elements of the system, further technological advantages can emerge over other variants of TMD like the inerter, in terms of weight, complexity and reliability, without any need for compromises in the overall stiffness of the structure as it is the case of QZS. The background of the performance of this stiffness based vibration absorption concept is the fact that an adequate level of elastic forces exists throughout the entire frequency range, able to counteract the inertial and the external excitation forces, while the damping forces and the inertia forces of the additional mass remain minimal in the entire frequency range, including the natural frequencies. Moreover, the inherent non-linear nature of the negative stiffness force can be exploited to offer further potential advantages of the KDamper concept, such as robustness, broadband response and energy sinks. It should be mentioned that the approach presented does not simply refer to discrete vibration absorption device, but it consists a general vibration absorption concept, applicable also for the design of advanced materials or complex structures. Such a concept thus presents the potential for numerous implementations in a large variety of technological applications, while further potential may emerge in a multi- physics environment. Aknowledgements The first author would like to express his sincere thanks to the "The Foundation for Education and European Culture" for the financial support he was granted for his PhD studies during of which this work was implemented References [1] Antoniadis I, Chronopoulos D, Spitas V and Koulocheris D (2015) "Hyper-damping properties of a stable linear oscillator with a negative stiffness element", Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2015, 346, 37-52. [2] Antoniadis I, Kanarachos S, Gryllias K and Sapountzakis I (2016) "KDamping: A stiffness based passive damping concept", Journal of Vibration and Control, 2016, DOI: 10.1177/1077546316646514. [3] Attary N, Symans M and Nagarajaiah S (2015) Development of a rotation-based negative stiffness device for seismic protection of structures, Journal of Vibration and Control, DOI: 10.1177/1077546315585435. [4] Baravelli E, Ruzzene M (2013) Internally resonating lattices for bandgap generation and low- 19 frequency vibration control, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 332, 6562–6579. [5] Brzeski P, Kapitaniak T and Perlikowski P (2015) Novel type of tuned mass damper with inerter which enables changes of inertance, Novel type of tuned mass damper with inerter which enables changes of inertance, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 349 (4), 56-66. [6] Carrella A, Brennan M, and Waters T (2007) Static analysis of a passive vibration isolator with quasi-zero-stiffness characteristic, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 301, 678–689. [7] Carrella A, Brennan M, Waters T and Lopes Jr V (2012) Force and displacement transmissibility of a nonlinear isolator with high-static-low- dynamic-stiffness, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 55, 22–29. [8] Chen JL and Georgakis CT (2015), Spherical tuned liquid damper for vibration control in wind turbines, Journal of Vibration and Control, 21(10), 1875–1885 [9] Chen MZQ, Papageorgiou C, Scheibe F, Wang Fu Cheng, and Smith MC (2009) The missing mechanical circuit element. Circuits and Systems Magazine, IEEE, 9(1), 10-26. [10] Chen MZQ and Smith MC (2009) Restricted complexity network realizations for passive mechanical control. IEEE Trans. on Automatic Control, 54(10), 2290–2301. [11] Chortis DI, Varelis DS and Saravanos DA (2013) "Linearized Frequencies and Damping in Composite Laminated Beams Subject to buckling, Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, Transactions of the ASME, 135, 021006-1-10. [12] Chronopoulos D, Antoniadis I, Collet M and Ichchou M (2015) "Enhancement of wave damping within metamaterials having embedded negative stiffness inclusions", Wave Motion, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wavemoti.2015.05.005. [13] Chuan L, Liang ML, Wang YL and Dong YL (2012) Vibration suppression using two-terminal flywheel. Part I: Modeling and characterization, Journal of Vibration and Control 18(8), 1096–1105. [14] Correa DM, Klatt T, Cortes S, Haberman M, Kovar D and Seepersad C (2015) Negative stiffness honeycombs for recoverable shock isolation, Rapid Prototyping Journal 21/2, 193–200. [15] Debnath N, Deb SK and Dutta A (2015) Multi-modal vibration control of truss bridges with tuned mass dampers under general loading, Journal of Vibration and Control, DOI: 10.1177/1077546315571172 [16] Den Hartog JP (1956) Mechanical Vibrations (4th edition), McGraw-Hill, New York. [17] DeSalvo R, Passive, nonlinear, mechanical structures for seismic attenuation, Journal of 20 Computational and Nonlinear Dynamics 2, 290–298. [18] Dong L, Lakes R (2013) Advanced damper with high stiffness and high hysteresis damping based on negative structural stiffness, International Journal of Solids and Structures 50, 2416– 2423. [19] Dyskin AV, Pasternak E (2012) Mechanical effect of rotating non-spherical particles on failure in compression, Philosophical Magazine 92, 3451–3473. [20] Frahm H (1909) Device for Damping Vibrations of Bodies, US patent #989958, [21] Ibrahim R (2008) Recent advances in nonlinear passive vibration isolators, Journal of Sound and Vibration 314, 371–452. [22] Iemura H, Pradono MH (2009) Advances in the development of pseudo- negative-stiffness dampers for seismic response control, Structural Control and Health Monitoring 16, 784–799. [23] Kovacic I, Brennan MJ and Waters TP (2008) A study of a nonlinear vibration isolator with a quasi-zero stiffness characteristic, Journal of Sound and Vibration 315, 700–711. [24] Lakes R (2001) Extreme damping in composite materials with a negative stiffness phase, Physical Review Letters 86, 2897–8. [25] Lakes R, Rosakis P, Ruina A (1993) Microbuckling instability in elastomeric cellular solids, Journal of Materials Science 28, 4667–72. [26] Le TD, Ahn KK (2011) A vibration isolation system in low frequency excitation region using negative stiffness structure for vehicle seat, Journal of Sound and Vibration 330, 6311–35. [27] Lee CM, Goverdovskiy V and Samoilenko S (2004) Prediction of non-chaotic motion of the elastic system with small stiffness, Journal of Sound and Vibration 272, 643–55. [28] Lee CM, Goverdovskiy V (2012) A multi-stage high-speed railroad vibration isolation system with negative stiffness, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 331, 914–21. [29] Lee CM, Goverdovskiy V and Temnikov A (2007) Design of springs with negative stiffness to improve vehicle driver vibration isolation, J ournal of Sound and Vibration 302, 865–74. [30] Maor F and Gendelman OV (2015) Tuned pendulum as nonlinear energy sink for broad energy range, Journal of Vibration and Control, DOI: 10.1177/1077546315578561. [31] Mayet J, Ulbrich H (2015) First-order optimal linear and nonlinear detuning of centrifugal pendulum vibration absorbers, Journal of Sound and Vibration 335, 34–54 [32] Michelis P, Spitas V (2010) Numerical and experimental analysis of a tri-angular auxetic core 21 made of cfr-peek using the directionally reinforced integrated single-yarn (DIRIS) architecture, Composites Science and Technology 70, 1064–1071. [33] Molyneaux W (1957) Supports for vibration isolation, ARC/CP-322, Aeronautical Research Council, Great Britain. [34] Ormondroyd J and Den Hartog, J P (1928) The Theory of Dynamic Vibration Absorber, Trans. ASME, APM-50-7, 9-22. [35] Platus DL (1999) Negative-stiffness-mechanism vibration isolation systems, In: SPIE's International Symposium on Optical Science, Engineering, and Instrumentation, 98–105. [36] Robertson S, Kidner MRF, Cazzolato BS, Zander AC (2009) Theoretical design parameters for a quasi-zero stiffness magnetic spring for vibration isolation, Journal of Sound and Vibration 326, 88– 103. [37] Sarlis AA, Pasala DTR, Constantinou M, Reinhorn A, Nagarajaiah S, Taylor D (2012) Negative stiffness device for seismic protection of structures, Journal of Structural Engineering 139, 1124–33. [38] Shaw A, Neild S, Wagg D (2013) Dynamic analysis of high static low dynamic stiffness vibration isolation mounts, Journal of Sound Vibration, 332, 1437–55. [39] Smith MC (2002) Synthesis of mechanical networks: The Inerter, IEEE, Trans. on Automatic Control, 47, 1648-1662. [40] Spitas V, Spitas C and Michelis P (2013) Modeling of the elastic damping response of a carbon nanotube–polymer nano-composite in the stress-strain domain using an elastic energy release approach based on stick-slip, Mechanics of Advanced Materials and Structures 20, 791–800. [41] Taglinski T, Kochmann D, Stone D, Lakes R (2007) Composite materials with viscoelastic stiffness greater than diamond, Science 315, 620–622. [42] Takewaki I, Murakami S, Yoshitomi S, and Tsuji M. (2012) Fundamental mechanism of earthquake response reduction in building structures with inertial dampers. Structural Control and Health Monitoring, 19(6):590-608. [43] Vakakis AF, Gendelman OV, Bergman LA, McFarland DM, Kerschen G and Lee YS (2008) Nonlinear Targeted Energy Transfer in Mechanical and Structural Systems I. Berlin: Springer. [44] Virgin L, Santillan S, Plaut R (2008) Vibration isolation using extreme geometric nonlinearity, Journal of Sound and Vibration 315, 721–731. [45] Virk K, Monti A, Trehard T, Marsh M, Hazra K, Boba K, Remillat C, Scarpa F, Farrow I, 22 (2013) SILICOMB PEEK Kirigami cellular structures : mechanical response and energy dissipation through zero and negative stiffness, Smart Materials and Structures 22. [46] Wang FC and Wu SY (2015) Vibration control of an optical table employing mechatronic inerter networks, Journal of Vibration and Control, DOI: 10.1177/1077546314528365 [47] Wang FC, Hsieh MR, Chen HJ (2012) Stability and performance analysis of a full-train system with inerters. Vehicle System Dynamics, 50(4):545-571. [48] Winterflood J, Blair D, Slagmolen B (2002) High performance vibration isolation using springs in Euler column buckling mode, Physics Letters A 300, 122–130. [49] Wojnar CS, Kochmann DM (2014) A negative-stiffness phase in elastic composites can produce stable extreme effective dynamic but not static stiffness, Philosophical Magazine 94, 532–555. [50] Younespour A and Ghaffarzadeh H (2015) Structural active vibration control using active mass damper by block pulse functions, Journal of Vibration and Control, 21(14), 2787–2795. [51] Zhou J, Xu D, Bishop S (2015) A torsion quasi-zero stiffness vibration isolator, Journal of Sound and Vibration 338, 121–133. [52] Zhou N, Liu K (2010) A tunable high-static–low-dynamic stiffness vibration isolator, Journal of Sound and Vibration 329, 1254–1273. [53] Lingshuai M, Jinggong S and Wenjuan W (2014) Theoretical Design and Characteristics Analysis of a Quasi-Zero Stiffness Isolator Using a Disk Spring as Negative Stiffness Element, Shock and Vibration, DOI: 10.1155/2015/813763.
1805.05474	1	1805	2018-04-24T02:00:16	A Radio Frequency Channelizer based on Cascaded Integrated Micro-ring Resonator Optical Comb Sources and Filters	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics" ]	We report a broadband RF channelizer based on an integrated optical frequency Kerr micro-comb source, with an RF channelizing bandwidth of 90 GHz, a high RF spectral slice resolution of 1.04 GHz, and experimentally verify the RF performance up to 19 GHz. This approach to realizing RF channelizers offers reduced complexity, size, and potential cost for a wide range of applications to microwave signal detection.	physics.app-ph	physics	1 A Radio Frequency Channelizer based on Cascaded Integrated Micro-ring Resonator Optical Comb Sources and Filters Xingyuan Xu1, Jiayang Wu1, Thach G. Nguyen2, Sai T. Chu3, Brent E. Little4, Roberto Morandotti5,6,7, Arnan Mitchell2, and David J. Moss1 1Centre for Micro-Photonics, Swinburne University of Technology, Hawthorn, VIC 3122, Australia. 2School of Engineering, RMIT University, Melbourne, VIC 3001, Australia. 3Department of Physics and Material Science, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Hong Kong, China. 4State Key Laboratory of Transient Optics and Photonics, Xi'an Institute of Optics and Precision Mechanics, Chinese 5INSR-Énergie, Matériaux et Télécommunications, 1650 Boulevard Lionel-Boulet, Varennes, Québec, J3X 1S2, Canada 6National Research University of Information Technologies, Mechanics and Optics, St. Petersburg, Russia 7Institute of Fundamental and Frontier Sciences, University of Electronic Science and Technology of China, Chengdu 610054, Academy of Science, Xi'an, China. China. Abstract We report a broadband RF channelizer based on an integrated optical frequency Kerr micro-comb source, with an RF channelizing bandwidth of 90 GHz, a high RF spectral slice resolution of 1.04 GHz, and experimentally verify the RF performance up to 19 GHz. This approach to realizing RF channelizers offers reduced complexity, size, and potential cost for a wide range of applications to microwave signal detection. I. INTRODUCTION Detecting and analyzing microwave signals with large instantaneous bandwidth is essential for a wide range of applications in satellite communications, electronic warfare, and radar systems [1-10]. RF channelizers, which can slice the RF spectrum into frequency channels with digital-compatible bandwidths [11], serve as one of the most attractive approaches for RF signal detection and analysis. Conventional RF channelizers typically employ a bank of RF filters, thus are subjected to limitations of the electrical bandwidth bottleneck. Photonic techniques are promising solutions for RF channelizers, offering large bandwidths and strong immunity to electromagnetic interference. Early approaches to photonic RF channelizers, where RF signals were transmitted over single optical wavelengths and then physically split for spectral channelizing, were achieved via diffraction gratings [12], acousto-optic crystals [13], fiber gratings [14], and integrated devices [15]. However, those approaches required a large set of narrow, spectrally dense and precisely centered filter banks, hence suffering from limitations in spectral slice resolution, available number of channels and footprint. Recent approaches have been demonstrated based on multicasting RF signals onto multiple optical wavelengths via stimulated Brillouin scattering [16-18], parametric processes in nonlinear fiber [19, 20], spectrally sliced incoherent sources [21], discrete laser arrays [22], or electro-optic modulator-based frequency combs [11, 23, 24]. Other approaches relying on wavelength scanning structures [25] or dispersive Fourier transformations [26] have also been proposed, but all of these face limitations including channel number and spectral slice resolution, as well as increased complexity and potential cost because of the need for many discrete components, such as external RF sources and mode-locked lasers. Integrated micro-comb sources [27-31], particularly those based on CMOS-compatible platforms [32-40], offer many advantages for broadband RF channelizers compared with conventional multi-wavelength sources, such as a much higher number of wavelengths [41-50] and greatly reduced footprint and complexity. Here, we report a broadband RF channelizer based on an integrated optical frequency comb source. By using an on- chip Kerr comb source consisting of an active nonlinear micro-ring resonator (MRR) that yields a broadband 200 GHz- spaced comb, in combination with a passive on-chip MRR with a free spectral range (FSR) of 49 GHz and Q factor of 1 2 1.55×106, we realize an RF channelizer with a large number of channels (20 over the C-band and > 60 over the C/L- bands) and an RF bandwidth approaching 100 GHz. We verify the RF performance experimentally at frequencies up to 19 GHz, achieving a high spectral slice resolution of 1.04 GHz. In addition to high RF performance, this approach offers a reduced lower complexity, and potentially lower cost. footprint, II. PRINCIPLE Figure 1 shows a diagram of the broadband RF channelizer. Kerr combs were generated in an integrated active MRR pumped by a tunable CW laser and amplified by an erbium- doped fibre amplifier. A tunable optical bandpass filter was used to suppress the amplified spontaneous emission noise from the amplifier, while a fibre polarization controller was Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of the broadband RF channelizer based on an integrated optical comb source. Amp: erbium-doped fibre amplifier. OBPF: used to optimize the power in the waveguide. When the optical bandpass filter. PC: polarization controller. MRR: micro-ring wavelength of the pump light was tuned to one of the active resonator. OC: optical coupler. PM: phase modulator. Temp. Con.: MRR resonances with the pump power high enough to temperature controller. DEMUX: de-multiplexer. Rx: Receiver. OSA: Optical spectrum analyzer. provide sufficient parametric gain, optical parametric oscillation occurred, ultimately generating Kerr optical combs with equal spacing δOFC (~ 200 GHz). In the wavelength range of the channelizer, the frequency of the kth (k=2, 3, 4, …) comb line is fOFC (k)=fOFC (1)+(k-1)δOFC (1) where fOFC(1) is the frequency of the first comb line used on the red side. The Kerr combs were then shaped (flattened) by a Waveshaper and directed to a phase modulator (PM), where the input broadband RF signal was multicast onto each wavelength. Finally, the 200 GHz comb lines, each imprinted with the RF spectrum to be measured, were spectrally sampled, or sliced, by a separate passive high-Q MRR with an FSR of 49 GHz, where we used every 4th resonance for spectral slicing, corresponding to an equivalent spacing δMRR of ~196 GHz, and so the RF spectrum on the different 200 GHz-spacing comb lines are sampled sequentially with approximately a 4 GHz shift between adjacent comb lines. The output channelized RF frequencies can be given by: fRF (k)=fMRR (k)-f (k) OFC = [fMRR (1)-fOFC (1)]+(k-1)(δMRR-δOFC) (2) where fRF(k) is the kth channelized RF frequency, fMRR(k) is the kth centre frequency of the filtering MRR. Here, [fMRR(1)– fOFC(1)] is the relative spacing between the first comb line and adjacent filtering resonance, corresponding to the offset of the channelized RF frequencies, and (δOFC – δMRR) corresponds to the channelized RF frequency step between adjacent wavelength channels. In principle, the RF channels can readily be separated by an optical demultiplexer such as an arrayed waveguide grating with a channel spacing matching the FSR (or a multiple) of the 49 Fig. 2. Schematic illustration of the (a) 200 GHz-FSR MRR and (b) 49 GHz-FSR MRR. (c) SEM image of the cross-section of the 200 GHz MRR before depositing the silica upper cladding. 2 3 GHz MRR. Then RF signals can be detected via homodyne detection, where the flattened comb lines are first separated out before phase modulation and serve as the local oscillators (LO), then coupled together with the channelized RF optical sidebands and coherently detected for post processing. In this work, however, we measured the broadband optical spectrum to verify the feasibility of our approach, deferring channel demultiplexing and RF detection to a future work. We note that owing to the large number of wavelengths provided by the on-chip micro-comb, the RF channelizer featured a large number of wavelength channels, thus enabling broadband RF channelizing with digital-compatible channel bandwidths. III. EXPERIMENT The MRRs (Fig. 2(a, b)) were fabricated in a high-index doped silica glass platform using CMOS compatible fabrication processes. First, high-index (n = ~1.70 at 1550 nm) doped silica glass films were deposited using standard plasma enhanced chemical vapour deposition (PECVD), then patterned photo-lithographically and etched via reactive ion etching to form waveguides with exceptionally low surface roughness. Finally, silica glass (n = ~1.44 at 1550 nm) was deposited via PECVD as an upper cladding. The advantages of our platform for nonlinear OPOs include ultra-low linear loss (~0.06 dB‧ cm−1), a moderate nonlinearity parameter (~233 W−1‧ km−1), and in particular a negligible nonlinear loss up to extremely high intensities (~25 GW‧ cm−2) [28]. The low linear loss enabled the ring resonators to achieve Q factors > 1×106. A scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of the cross-section of the 200 GHz MRR before depositing the SiO2 upper cladding is shown in Fig. 2(c). The radii of the active MRR (for comb generation) and the passive MRR (for spectral slicing) were ~135 μm and ~ 592 μm, corresponding to FSRs of ~1.6 nm (~200 GHz) and ~0.4 nm (~49 GHz), respectively. After packaging the device with fibre pigtails, the through-port insertion loss was ~3.5 dB for the 200 GHz MRR and ~1.5 dB for the 49 GHz MRR. To generate Kerr combs, the pump power was boosted to ~500 mW and the wavelength was swept from blue to red. When the pump wavelength was tuned close to the resonance of the active MRR, primary combs were generated (Fig. 3(a)). Signal and idler lines were generated in the S-band and L-bands respectively, and the spacing between the signal and pump was 19 FSR, or 3.8 THz, determined by the parametric gain curve. When the detuning between the pump wavelength and the adjacent resonance was further changed, the parametric gain lobes broadened and secondary comb lines with a spacing equal to the FSR appeared via cascaded four wave mixing. Finally, flat Kerr combs were generated with the pump wavelength set to 1548.58 nm. As shown in Fig. 3(b–c), the resulting Kerr comb was over 200-nm wide, covering four bands (S, C, L, U) and was relatively flat over the full C and L bands, thus enabling a record large number 3 4 Fig. 3. Optical spectrum of (a) the primary comb, (b) the secondary comb, (c) the Kerr comb with 300 nm span, (d) the shaped optical comb for the channelizer with less than 0.5 dB unflatness, (e) 20 and (f) selected 4 comb lines modulated by RF signals. of wavelengths (20 over the C-band and > 60 over the C/L-bands). The large Kerr comb spacing also yielded an increased Nyquist zone, corresponding to an RF bandwidth of >100 GHz. This bandwidth is extremely challenging for mode-locked lasers and externally-modulated comb sources to achieve [41–44]. While the spectral profile of our comb was not indicative of operation in the single cavity soliton regime, we do not Fig. 4. Drop-port transmission spectrum of the on-chip 49 GHz MRR (a) with a span of 5 nm, (b) showing an FSR of 49 GHz, and (c) a resonance at 193.294 THz with full width at half maximum (FWHM) of 124.94 MHz, corresponding to a Q factor of 1.549×106. 4 5 Fig. 5. (a) The measured optical spectrum of the 200GHz micro-comb and transmission of 49GHz MRR. Zoom-in views of the channels with different channelized RF frequencies. (b) Extracted channelized RF frequencies, inset shows corresponding optical frequencies of the comb lines and spectral slicin g resonances. foresee any potential limitations related to that, given the range of Q factors and nonlinear figure of merit that we can achieve. In addition, from theoretical analysis of what we have observed, it is evident that the Kerr comb was working under "partially coherent" conditions that features stable phase and amplitude. In fact, the spatial patterns of what we observed appear to be similar to the so called "soliton molecules" [50, 51], which feature reasonably low intensity noise comparable with that of cavity solitons. We note that since the comb source serves as both the optical carrier for RF sideband generation as well as the LO for RF receiving, the channelized RF optical sidebands and LOs are inherently coherent, and thus strictly phase-locked comb lines are not necessary―which, in fact, is an advantage when comparing with RF coherent receivers [52]. Neither is the coherence between adjacent WDM channels required since they are not beating with each other. The 20 channels of the Kerr comb over the C-band were then shaped by a Waveshaper (Finisar 4000S) to get uniform channel weights. A feedback control path was introduced to read and shape the comb lines' power accurately, which were first detected by an optical spectrum analyser and then compared with the ideal weights (uniform in our case). This allowed us to generate an error signal to feed back into the waveshaper in order to calibrate the system and achieve accurate comb shaping and flatness of the comb envelope to within ± 0.3 dB (Fig. 3(d)). The phase modulator was then used to multicast the input RF signal onto each comb line. Figures. 3(e–f) show the optical spectra of the flat comb lines modulated by the RF signal. The number of equalized channels (20) was limited to the C-band by the bandwidth of the waveshaper. In principle the number of wavelengths could easily be increased up to 60 by using a combined C+L band waveshaper. Next, the multicast RF signal on each wavelength channel was spectrally sliced by the passive 49 GHz MRR. Figures. 4(a–b) show the drop-port transmission of the MRR over a 5nm range, showing an FSR of ~49 GHz (~0.4nm) over 152 modes (labelling the mode at 193.294 THz as 0). The transmission of a single resonance (Fig. 4(c)) shows a full width at half maximum (FWHM) of 124.94 MHz, corresponding to a Q factor of 1.549×106, and a 20dB bandwidth of 1.04 GHz, which determines the RF resolution. This RF resolution is compatible with state-of-the- art analog-to-digital converters [3], thus leading to digital-compatible broadband RF channelization. To illustrate the principle of operation of our RF channelizer, we plot the measured 200 GHz comb spectrum and transmission of the 49 GHz passive MRR (highlighting every 4th resonance that closely aligns with the 200 GHz comb) in the same figure (Fig. 5(a)). Zoom-in views in Fig. 5(a) show that over the 20 comb channels that are generated across the C-band, the relative shift between the 200 GHz comb lines and every 4th resonance of the 49 GHz MRR, which corresponds to the RF spectral sliced frequencies, ranges from 3.89 to 88.65 GHz. The frequencies and relative spacing of the 200 GHz comb and 49 GHz MRR are linearly fit and shown in Fig. 5(b), where we see that the fit comb spacing is δOFC = 200.44 GHz and the fit FSR of the spectrally sliced resonances (i. e., δMRR is the frequency spacing between every 4th resonance of the 49 GHz MRR) is δMRR = 196.01 GHz, thus resulting in a channelized RF frequency step between adjacent channels (δOFC – δMRR) of 4.43 GHz. We measured the RF performance of the channelizer up to 20 GHz – the limit of our equipment. This only required 4 wavelengths or channels of the 20 channels shown in Figure 5, corresponding to four RF frequencies ranging from 5 6 1.7 to 19.0 GHz. We measured the output of the 49 GHz passive MRR with an optical spectrum analyzer (Fig. 6), showing that optical RF sidebands with different RF frequencies had been channelized at different optical wavelengths. As Fig. 6(a) shows, optical-carrier RF tones at frequencies of 1.7 GHz, 6.3 GHz, 11.2 GHz, and 15.8 GHz were output at four different wavelength channels, corresponding to an RF frequency step between adjacent wavelength channels of ~ 4.8 GHz, in agreement with Fig. 5. The power leakage of channel 4 was mainly due to spurious optical carrier tones, which could be reduced by adopting an optimized modulation format such as carrier-suppressed single-sideband Fig. 6. RF response. Measured optical spectrum of 49 GHz MRR's output with different input RF frequencies, with the temperature of the 49 GHz MRR set to (a) 24.0°C, (b) 24.5°C, (c) 25.0°C, and (d) 25.5°C. (e) Channelized RF frequencies at different wavelength channels with different temperatures. modulation. In order to make full use of the RF resolution of our system (1 GHz) and bridge the gap formed by the ~ 4.8 GHz RF step size, we used temperature tuning [31, 53] of the passive MRR to continuously control the relative spacing between the source and filtering MRRs' resonances (fMRR(1)– fOFC(1)), where a millisecond time-scale thermal response time is expected. Figures. 6(a–d) show the output optical spectra with temperatures ranging from 24.0°C to 25.5°C. As reflected in Fig. 6(e), the offset of the channelized RF frequencies increased with a slope of ~1GHz/°C. By combining the fine resolution temperature tuning with the 4.8 GHz RF Fig. 7. Channelized RF frequencies at different channels. Fig. 8. Extracted extinction ratio of channelized RF signals. 6 7 increment across 60 channels over the C/L-bands, this device is capable of achieving an ultrawide RF bandwidth of over 100 GHz. Figure 7 shows the experimental channelized RF frequencies of the different optical channels extracted from Fig. 6, covering an RF bandwidth from 1.7 to 19.0 GHz, limited by the bandwidth of our RF modulator, verifying the effectiveness of thermal tuning to generate the broad operation bandwidth of our approach. Figure 8 shows the extinction ratio (ER) of the wavelength channels (i.e., the optical power ratio of the signal channel to the maximum of other channels) extracted from Figs. 6(a–d), showing up to 20 dB ER. The non-uniformity in optical power of the different channels mainly arose from the amplifier spectral gain profile, and this can be mitigated by using gain flattening filters. The extinction ratio was also limited by excess noise of the second EDFA when adapting the optimized RF modulation format to increase the OSNR. In this case, using lower noise EDFAs would enhance the performance. Moreover, the employed thermal controllers of the active and passive MRRs featured an accuracy of 0.01°C, corresponding to an error of ~50 MHz for the channelized RF frequencies, which can be eliminated via precise thermal control or a feedback loop to achieve high performance in practical applications. Although employing thermal tuning brought challenges for simultaneous full RF spectrum channelizing, it nonetheless allowed us to demonstrate the potential and novelty of our approach. In addition, we note that thermal tuning is not necessary, provided the RF frequency step between adjacent wavelength channels (i.e., the FSR difference between the active MRR and the passive MRR) is equal to the spectral slicing resolution (i.e, the 20dB bandwidth of the passive MRR), which can be achieved via precise lithographic control of the FSRs of the MRRs. For example, given δOFC=200 GHz, then designing the passive MRR such that δMRR=199 GHz, still with a 1 GHz 20dB-bandwidth, would result in a channelized RF frequency step of 1 GHz and a spectral slicing resolution of 1 GHz at the same time. Thus, the full RF spectra could be simultaneously channelized with 1GHz resolution without the need for temperature tuning. While the RF operation bandwidth, given by the product of channel number and resolution, would be slightly less than the device reported here, at 60 GHz for 60 wavelengths (channels) across the C/L bands, this could be increased by using a smaller FSR comb (eg., 100 GHz vs. 200 GHz). Finally, we note that our scheme generates RF output based on homodyne detection, whereas down-conversion of the channelized RF signal would require heterodyne detection where a second optical frequency comb with specially designed FSR and offset is required. Recent advances in dual-comb spectroscopy provide new possibilities for that [23, 54-56]. By employing integrated dual micro-combs with specially designed FSRs and offsets for heterodyne detection [57-59], broadband RF signals can be channelized and down-converted into digital bandwidths for direct analog-to-digital conversion and post processing, thus offering a highly competitive approach for integrated photonic RF receivers. IV. CONCLUSION We demonstrate a broadband RF channelizer based on a CMOS-compatible integrated optical frequency comb source. Broadband 200 GHz-spacing Kerr combs with a large number of comb lines were generated by an active on- chip micro-ring resonator, providing a record large number of wavelength channels as well as an RF operation bandwidth of about 100 GHz. We demonstrate the broadband channelization of RF frequencies from 1.7 GHz to 19 GHz with a high spectral slice resolution of 1 GHz via thermal tuning of a passive on-chip MRR with a Q factor of 1.549×106. This micro-comb based RF channelizer is highly attractive for achieving broadband RF channelization with large channel numbers, high resolution, small footprint, and potentially low cost. REFERENCES [1] J. Capmany and D. Novak, "Microwave photonics combines two worlds," Nat. Photonics, vol. 1, no. 6, pp. 319-330, Jun. 2007. [2] J. P. Yao, "Microwave Photonics," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 27, no. 1-4, pp. 314-335, Jan. 2009. [3] S. L. Pan and J. P. Yao, "Photonics-Based Broadband Microwave Measurement," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 35, no. 16, pp. 3498-3513, Aug. 2017. [4] J. Azana, C. Madsen, K. Takiguchi, and G. Cincotti, "Guest editorial - Optical signal processing," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 24, no. 7, pp. 2484-2486, Jul. 2006. [5] D. Marpaung, M. Pagani, B. Morrison, and B. J. Eggleton, "Nonlinear Integrated Microwave Photonics," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 32, no. 20, pp. 3421-3427, Oct. 2014. [6] R. A. Minasian, "Ultra-Wideband and Adaptive Photonic Signal Processing of Microwave Signals," IEEE J. Quantum Elect., vol. 52, no. 1, Jan. 2016. 7 8 [7] X. H. Zou, B. Lu, W. Pan, L. S. Yan, A. Stohr, and J. P. Yao, "Photonics for microwave measurements," Laser Photonics Rev., vol. 10, no. 5, pp. 711-734, Sep. 2016. [8] K. Xu, R. X. Wang, Y. T. Dai, F. F. Yin, J. Q. Li, Y. F. Ji, and J. T. Lin, "Microwave photonics: radio-over-fiber links, systems, and applications," Photonics Res., vol. 2, no. 4, pp. B54-B63, Aug. 2014. [9] S. L. Pan, D. Zhu, S. F. Liu, K. Xu, Y. T. Dai, T. L. Wang, J. G. Liu, N. H. Zhu, Y. Xue, and N. J. Liu, "Satellite Payloads Pay Off," IEEE Microw. Mag., vol. 16, no. 8, pp. 61-73, Sep. 2015. [10] H. W. Chen, R. Y. Li, C. Lei, Y. Yu, M. H. Chen, S. G. Yang, and S. Z. Xie, "Photonics-Assisted Serial Channelized Radio- Frequency Measurement System With Nyquist-Bandwidth Detection," IEEE Photonics J., vol. 6, no. 6, Dec. 2014. [11] X. J. Xie, Y. T. Dai, Y. Ji, K. Xu, Y. Li, J. Wu, and J. T. Lin, "Broadband Photonic Radio-Frequency Channelization Based on a 39-GHz Optical Frequency Comb," IEEE Photonic Tech. L., vol. 24, no. 8, pp. 661-663, Apr. 2012. [12] W. S. Wang, R. L. Davis, T. J. Jung, R. Lodenkamper, L. J. Lembo, J. C. Brock, and M. C. Wu, "Characterization of a coherent optical RF channelizer based on a diffraction grating," IEEE T. Microw. Theory, vol. 49, no. 10, pp. 1996-2001, Oct. 2001. [13] W. T. Rhodes, "Acousto-optic signal processing: Convolution and correlation," Proc. IEEE, vol. 69, no. 1, pp. 65–79, Jan. 1981. [14] D. B. Hunter, L. G. Edvell, and M. A. Englund, "Wideband microwave photonic channelised receiver," Int. Topical Meeting on Microw. Photon., pp. 249–251, 2005-Oct. [15] S. T. Winnall, A. C. Lindsay, M. W. Austin, J. Canning, and A. Mitchell, "A microwave channelizer and spectroscope based on an integrated optical Bragg-grating Fabry-Perot and integrated hybrid fresnel lens system," IEEE T. Microw. Theory, vol. 54, no. 2, pp. 868-872, Feb. 2006. [16] W. Y. Xu, D. Zhu, and S. L. Pan, "Coherent photonic radio frequency channelization based on dual coherent optical frequency combs and stimulated Brillouin scattering," Opt. Eng., vol. 55, no. 4, Apr. 2016. [17] X. H. Zou, W. Z. Li, W. Pan, L. S. Yan, and J. P. Yao, "Photonic-Assisted Microwave Channelizer With Improved Channel Characteristics Based on Spectrum-Controlled Stimulated Brillouin Scattering," IEEE T. Microw. Theory, vol. 61, no. 9, pp. 3470-3478, Sep. 2013. [18] Choudhary, B. Morrison, I. Aryanfar, S. Shahnia, M. Pagani, Y. Liu, K. Vu, S. Madden, D. Marpaung, and B. J. Eggleton, "Advanced Integrated Microwave Signal Processing With Giant On-Chip Brillouin Gain," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 846-854, Feb. 2017. [19] S. Bres, S. Zlatanovic, A. O. J. Wiberg, J. R. Adleman, C. K. Huynh, E. W. Jacobs, J. M. Kvavle, and S. Radic, "Parametric Photonic Channelized RF Receiver," IEEE Photonic Tech. L., vol. 23, no. 6, pp. 344-346, Mar. 2011. [20] O. J. Wiberg, D. J. Esman, L. Liu, J. R. Adleman, S. Zlatanovic, V. Ataie, E. Myslivets, B. P. P. Kuo, N. Alic, E. W. Jacobs, and S. Radic, "Coherent Filterless Wideband Microwave/Millimeter-Wave Channelizer Based on Broadband Parametric Mixers," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 32, no. 20, pp. 3609-3617, Oct. 2014. [21] X. H. Zou, W. Pan, B. Luo, and L. S. Yan, "Photonic approach for multiple-frequency-component measurement using spectrally sliced incoherent source," Opt. Lett., vol. 35, no. 3, pp. 438-440, Feb. 2010. [22] F. A. Volkening, "Photonic channelized RF receiver employing dense wavelength division multiplexing," U.S. Patent 724 583 3B1, 2007. [23] X. J. Xie, Y. T. Dai, K. Xu, J. Niu, R. X. Wang, L. Yan, and J. T. Lin, "Broadband Photonic RF Channelization Based on Coherent Optical Frequency Combs and I/Q Demodulators," IEEE Photonics J., vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 1196-1202, Aug. 2012. [24] Z. Li, X. M. Zhang, H. Chi, S. L. Zheng, X. F. Jin, and J. P. Yao, "A Reconfigurable Microwave Photonic Channelized Receiver Based on Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing Using an Optical Comb," Opt. Commun., vol. 285, no. 9, pp. 2311-2315, May. 2012. [25] R. Y. Li, H. W. Chen, Y. Yu, M. H. Chen, S. G. Yang, and S. Z. Xie, "Multiple-frequency measurement based on serial photonic channelization using optical wavelength scanning," Opt. Lett., vol. 38, no. 22, pp. 4781-4784, Nov. 2013. [26] W. H. Hao, Y. T. Dai, F. F. Yin, Y. Zhou, J. Q. Li, J. Dai, W. Z. Li, and K. Xu, "Chirped-pulse-based broadband RF channelization implemented by a mode-locked laser and dispersion," Opt. Lett., vol. 42, no. 24, pp. 5234-5237, Dec. 2017. [27] L. Razzari, D. Duchesne, M. Ferrera, R. Morandotti, S. Chu, B. E. Little, and D. J. Moss, "CMOS-compatible integrated optical hyper-parametric oscillator," Nat. Photonics, vol. 4, no. 1, 41-45 (2010). [28] D.J. Moss, R. Morandotti, A. L. Gaeta, and M. Lipson, "New CMOS-compatible platforms based on silicon nitride and Hydex for nonlinear optics," Nat. Photonics, vol. 7, no. 8, 597-607 (2013). [29] T. Herr, K. Hartinger, J. Riemensberger, C. Y. Wang, E. Gavartin, R. Holzwarth, M. L. Gorodetsky, and T. J. Kippenberg, "Universal formation dynamics and noise of Kerr-frequency combs in microresonators," Nat. Photonics, vol. 6, no. 7, pp. 480- 487, Jul. 2012. [30] J. S. Levy, A. Gondarenko, M. A. Foster, A. C. Turner-Foster, A. L. Gaeta, and M. Lipson, "CMOS-compatible multiple- wavelength oscillator for on-chip optical interconnects," Nat. Photonics, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 37-40, Jan. 2010. [31] A. Pasquazi, M. Peccianti, L. Razzari, D. J. Moss, S. Coen, M. Erkintalo, Y. K. Chembo, T. Hansson, S. Wabnitz, P. Del Haye, X. X. Xue, A. M. Weiner, and R. Morandotti, "Micro-Combs: A Novel Generation of Optical Sources", Physics Reports, vol. 729, 1-81 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2017.08.004 [32] M. Ferrera, L. Razzari, D. Duchesne, R. Morandotti, Z. Yang, M. Liscidini, J. E. Sipe, S. Chu, B. E. Little, and D. J. Moss, "Low-power continuous-wave nonlinear optics in doped silica glass integrated waveguide structures," Nat. Photonics, vol. 2, no. 12, 737-740 (2008). 8 9 [33] M. Kues, C. Reimer, P. Roztocki, L. R. Cortes, S. Sciara, B. Wetzel, Y. B. Zhang, A. Cino, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, D. J. Moss, L. Caspani, J. Azana, and R. Morandotti, "On-chip generation of high-dimensional entangled quantum states and their coherent control," Nature, vol. 546, no. 7660, 622-626 (2017). [34] L. Caspani, C. Xiong, B. Eggleton, D. Bajoni, M. Liscidini, M. Galli, R. Morandotti, David J. Moss, "On-chip sources of quantum correlated and entangled photons", Nature: Light Science and Applications, vol. 6, e17100 (2017); doi: 10.1038/lsa.2017.100. [35] M. Kues, C. Reimer, B. Wetzel, P. Roztocki, B. E. Little, S. T. Chu, T. Hansson, E. A. Viktorov, D. J. Moss, and R. Morandotti, "Passively mode-locked laser with an ultra-narrow spectral width," Nat. Photonics, vol. 11, no. 9, 159–162 (2017). [36] C. Reimer, M. Kues, P. Roztocki, B. Wetzel, F. Grazioso, B. E. Little, S. T. Chu, T. Johnston, Y. Bromberg, L. Caspani, D. J. Moss, and R. Morandotti, "Generation of multiphoton entangled quantum states by means of integrated frequency combs," Science, vol. 351, no. 6278, pp. 1176-1180 (2016). [37] M. Ferrera, Y. Park, L. Razzari, B. E. Little, S. T. Chu, R. Morandotti, D. J. Moss, and J. Azana, "On-chip CMOS-compatible all-optical integrator," Nat. Commun., vol. 1, 29 (2010). [38] F. Da Ros, E. P. da Silva, D. Zibar, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, R. Morandotti, M. Galili, D. J. Moss, and L. K. Oxenlowe, "Wavelength conversion of QAM signals in a low loss CMOS compatible spiral waveguide," APL Photonics, vol. 2, no. 4, 046105 (2017). [39] A. Pasquazi, L. Caspani, M. Peccianti, M. Clerici, M. Ferrera, L. Razzari, D. Duchesne, B. E. Little, S. T. Chu, D. J. Moss, and R. Morandotti, "Self-locked optical parametric oscillation in a CMOS compatible microring resonator: a route to robust optical frequency comb generation on a chip," Opt. Express, vol. 21, no. 11, pp. 13333-13341 (2013). [40] C. Reimer, M. Kues, L. Caspani, B. Wetzel, P. Roztocki, M. Clerici, Y. Jestin, M. Ferrera, M. Peccianti, A. Pasquazi, B. E. Little, S. T. Chu, D. J. Moss, and R. Morandotti, "Cross-polarized photon-pair generation and bi-chromatically pumped optical parametric oscillation on a chip," Nat. Commun., vol. 6, 8236 (2015). [41] X. X. Xue, Y. Xuan, H. J. Kim, J. Wang, D. E. Leaird, M. H. Qi, and A. M. Weiner, "Programmable Single-Bandpass Photonic RF Filter Based on Kerr Comb from a Microring," J. Lightwave Technol., vol. 32, no. 20, pp. 3557-3565, Oct. 2014. [42] X. X. Xue and A. M. Weiner, "Microwave photonics connected with microresonator frequency combs," Front. Optoelectron., vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 238-248, Jun. 2016. [43] T. G. Nguyen, M. Shoeiby, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, R. Morandotti, A. Mitchell, and D. J. Moss, "Integrated frequency comb source based Hilbert transformer for wideband microwave photonic phase analysis," Opt. Express, vol. 23, no. 17, pp. 22087- 22097 (2015). [44] X. Y. Xu, J. Y. Wu, M. Shoeiby, T. G. Nguyen, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, R. Morandotti, A. Mitchell, and D. J. Moss, "Reconfigurable broadband microwave photonic intensity differentiator based on an integrated optical frequency comb source," APL Photonics, vol. 2, no. 9, 096104 (2017). [45] X. Y. Xu, J. Y. Wu, T. G. Nguyen, M. Shoeiby, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, R. Morandotti, A. Mitchell, and D. J. Moss, "Advanced RF and microwave functions based on an integrated optical frequency comb source," Opt. Express, vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 2569- 2583, Jan. 2018. [46] X. Y. Xu, J. Y. Wu, T. G. Nguyen, T. Moein, S. T. Chu, B. E. Little, R. Morandotti, A. Mitchell, and D. J. Moss, "Photonic microwave true time delays for phased array antennas using a 49GHz FSR integrated optical micro-comb source," Photonics Research vol. 6, no. 5, B30-B36 (2018). [47] J Wu, X Xu, TG Nguyen, ST Chu, BE Little, R Morandotti, A Mitchell, David J. Moss, "RF Photonics: An Optical Microcombs' Perspective", IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 24 (4), 1-20 (2018). [48] A Pasquazi, M Peccianti, BE Little, ST Chu, DJ Moss, R Morandotti, "Stable, dual mode, high repetition rate mode-locked laser based on a microring resonator", Optics express 20 (24), 27355-27363 (2012). [49] M Peccianti, M Ferrera, L Razzari, R Morandotti, BE Little, ST Chu, David J. Moss, "Subpicosecond optical pulse compression via an integrated nonlinear chirper", Optics Express 18 (8), 7625-7633 (2010). [50] S. Coen, H. G. Randle, T. Sylvestre, and M. Erkintalo, "Modeling of octave-spanning Kerr frequency combs using a generalized mean-field Lugiato-Lefever model," Opt. Lett., vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 37-39, Jan. 2013. [51] Y. K. Chembo and C. R. Menyuk, "Spatiotemporal Lugiato-Lefever formalism for Kerr-comb generation in whispering- gallery-mode resonators," Phys. Rev. A., vol. 87, no. 5, May. 2013. [52] H. Guo, M. Karpov, E. Lucas, A. Kordts, M. H. P. Pfeiffer, V. Brasch, G. Lihachev, V. E. Lobanov, M. L. Gorodetsky, and T. J. Kippenberg, "Universal dynamics and deterministic switching of dissipative Kerr solitons in optical microresonators," Nat. Phys., vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 94-102, Jan. 2017. [53] X. Xue, Y. Xuan, C. Wang, P.-H. Wang, Y. Liu, B. Niu, D. E. Leaird, M. Qi, and A. M. Weiner, "Thermal tuning of Kerr frequency combs in silicon nitride microring resonators", Opt. Express, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 687-698, Jan. 2016. [54] B. Bernhardt, A. Ozawa, P. Jacquet, M. Jacquey, Y. Kobayashi, T. Udem, R. Holzwarth, G. Guelachvili, T. W. Hansch, and N. Picque, "Cavity-enhanced dual-comb spectroscopy," Nat. Photonics, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 55-57, Jan. 2010. [55] T. Ideguchi, A. Poisson, G. Guelachvili, N. Picqué, T. W. Hänsch, "Adaptive real-time dual-comb spectroscopy", Nat. Commun., vol. 5, pp. 3375, Feb. 2014. [56] G. Millot, S. Pitois, M. Yan, T. Hovhannisyan, A. Bendahmane, T. W. Hansch, and N. Picque, "Frequency-agile dual-comb spectroscopy," Nat. Photonics, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 27-37, Jan. 2016. 9 10 [57] M. G. Suh, Q. F. Yang, K. Y. Yang, X. Yi, and K. J. Vahala, "Micro-resonator soliton dual-comb spectroscopy," Science, vol. 354, no. 6312, pp. 600-603, Nov. 2016. [58] N. G. Pavlov, G. Lihachev, S. Koptyaev, E. Lucas, M. Karpov, N. M. Kondratiev, I. A. Bilenko, T. J. Kippenberg, and M. L. Gorodetsky, "Soliton dual frequency combs in crystalline microresonators," Opt. Lett., vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 514-517, Feb. 2017. [59] T. C. Briles, T. Drake, D. Spencer, J. R. Stone, C. Fredrick, Q. Li, D. Westly, B. R. Ilic, X. Yi, K. Y. Yang, K. Vahala, K. Srinivasan, S. Diddams, and S. Papp, "Optical Frequency Synthesis Using a Dual-Kerr-Microresonator Frequency Comb," in Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics, OSA Technical Digest (online) (Optical Society of America, 2017), paper SW4N.3. 10
1904.04208	1	1904	2019-03-19T08:03:02	Analysis and design of a Germanium multi-quantum well metal strip nanocavity plasmon laser	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics" ]	In order to achieve electrically pumped plasmon nano lasers, several structures, materials and methods, have been proposed recently. However, there is still a long way to find out a reliable appropriate on-chip plasmon source for commercial plasmonic integrated circuits. In this paper, a new waveguide integrated nanocavity plasmon laser is proposed for 1550 nm free-space wavelength. Due to its significant field confinement resulted by the metal strip structure and strong interaction of plasmonic modes with the germanium quantum wells and as a result a considerable Purcell factor about 291, this structure has a remarkable output performance. Using semi-classical rate equations in combination with finite difference time domain (FDTD) cavity mode analysis, the output performance measures are estimated and confirmed with respect to various physical models and simulation tools. Simulation results for this tiny structure (0.073 um2 area) show a 2.8uW output power with 10uA injection current and about 4.16mW output power with the threshold pump current of 27mA while maintaining its performance in a wide modulation bandwidth of 178GHz.	physics.app-ph	physics	Analysis and design of a Germanium multi- quantum well metal strip nanocavity plasmon laser HAMED GHODSI, 1 HASSAN KAATUZIAN, 1, * AND ELAHE RASTEGAR PASHAKI 1 1Photonics Research Laboratory (PRL), Electrical Engineering Department, Amirkabir University of Technology [email protected] Abstract: In order to achieve electrically pumped plasmon nano lasers, several structures, materials and methods, have been proposed recently. However, there is still a long way to find out a reliable appropriate on-chip plasmon source for commercial plasmonic integrated circuits. In this paper, a new waveguide integrated nanocavity plasmon laser is proposed for 1550 nm free-space wavelength. Due to its significant field confinement resulted by the metal strip structure and strong interaction of plasmonic modes with the germanium quantum wells and as a result a considerable Purcell factor about 291, this structure has a remarkable output performance. Using semi-classical rate equations in combination with finite difference time domain (FDTD) cavity mode analysis, the output performance measures are estimated and confirmed with respect to various physical models and simulation tools. Simulation results for this tiny structure (0.073 µm2 area) show a 2.8µW output power with 10µA injection current and about 4.16mW output power with the threshold pump current of 27mA while maintaining its performance in a wide modulation bandwidth of 178GHz. © 2018 Optical Society of America under the terms of the OSA Open Access Publishing Agreement 1. Introduction A room temperature electrically pumped integrated plasmon source that generates output power in the mW range is the key component for the realization of future integrated plasmonic chips. Providing a practical solution can revolutionize photonics and optoelectronics into all plasmonic integrated circuits, which have significant developments for various plasmonic counterparts of photonics and optoelectronic devices in recent years. [1-5] To do so, several numbers of researches on design and fabrication of plasmon sources i.e. plasmon nanolasers or SPASERs were done. These plasmon sources can be categorized in metallic nanoshells [6], nanocavities [7], nanowires [8] and waveguide-based nanolasers [9]. As mentioned, there are many laboratory fabrications and theoretically proposed devices, which in many cases have optical pumping or cryogenic operating conditions or complicated fabrication process [6,8]. Therefore, these devices are not ready for this purpose yet and there is still demand for practical plasmonic nanolasers. In this paper, an electrically pumped Germanium/Silicon-Germanium (Ge/Si0.11Ge) multiple quantum well plasmonic nanolaser is introduced, analyzed and simulated. The proposed nanolaser has a thin Gold metal strip structure, sandwiched between Ge quantum wells in order to maximize both field confinement and exciton-plasmon interaction possibility, which means higher Purcell and better gain medium/resonator mode overlap factors. This design is covered by two Aluminum electrical contacts for applying the pump current. In addition, it can be coupled into both MIM and IMI silicon-based plasmonic waveguides with considerable coupling efficiency or used in far-field configuration in which plasmon modes will be converted into photons through the cavity interface. This device benefits from a Metal-Semiconductor-Metal-Semiconductor-Metal (MSMSM) structure, which can perform well in 1550nm regime by means of incorporating highly doped strained Ge quantum wells as the direct bandgap gain medium. [10] In the next section, physical structure and fabrication considerations are explained. Then in section 3, governing physical principles are explained and numerically calculated. Following this, in section 4, the results of output characteristics analysis can be seen for different output couplings and this paper is concluded in the fifth section. 2. Physical structure and Fabrication As can be seen from Fig.1 the 3D structure of our proposed nanolaser consists of four different materials including Al top and bottom contacts, Germanium, and Si0.11Ge Buffer layers, strained Ge quantum wells and thin Gold strip in the middle forming the MSMSM nanocavity structure. Furthermore, different coupling scenarios are proposed and can be witnessed from Fig.2.A, Fig.2.B, and Fig.2.C respectively. The proposed nanolaser would be fabricated on a Silicon substrate as follows. It should be mentioned that we are not going to describe the fabrication process in detail; instead, in each fabrication step, an empirically fabricated similar structure will be referenced. A more detailed lateral structure and the design specifications are provided in Fig.3 and Table.1 respectively. Fig.1 3D schematics of proposed nanolaser The fabrication process can be started on a silicon substrate by deposition of the Aluminum bottom contact as stated in [11], followed by deposition of the Germanium and Si0.1Ge0.9 bottom buffer layers and then two Germanium quantum wells. [12,13] This process will be continued by deposition of the Gold metal strip, which can be taken from [13] and again a similar process to the bottom Ge/SiGe layers [12,13] and finally deposition of top Aluminum contact. [11] The fabricated structure can then be connected to a metal/insulator/metal (MIM) or insulator/metal/insulator (IMI) waveguide or even be used in far field lasing mode. (Fig.2) Our proposed nanolaser performs magnificently due to its strong mode confinement and tiny modal volume. In addition, significant overlap of plasmonic mode with the quantum wells results in higher output power and finally, two-sided mode profile doubles up the output. This great performance is a tradeoff for the complicated fabrication process and increased plasmon loss. (A) (B) Fig. 2 Proposed output coupling configurations. A. Far-field configuration. B. Coupling to MIM waveguide. C. Coupling to IMI waveguide. (C) Fig. 3 detailed lateral structure of the Cavity Table 1. Design parameters of the proposed nanolaser Description Resonator size Resonator height Bottom metal thickness Top metal thickness Bottom buffer thickness Bottom buffer thickness Number of QWs QW thickness Barrier wall thickness Thickness of p doped Ge buffer Ge Alloy percent Value 270 130 10 40 15 15 4 7 10 16 89 Doping concentration of the QWs and Barriers Doping concentration of the Ge Buffer 7.6×1019 1×1019 Unit nm nm nm nm nm nm - nm nm nm % cm-3 cm-3 Symbol WR HR XStrip XContact XBottom XTop NQW XQW XBarrier XBuffer x ND NA 3. Governing Theories Following the approach same as a traditional laser, in a plasmonic one, we also should have gain medium and a resonator. First, we will discuss resonator and mirrors and then we will explain the gain medium equations. Finally, we will be able to write the rate equations for simulation of the output power, pumping threshold, plasmonic gain and modulation bandwidth in the next section. 3.1. Cavity characterization and output coupling The proposed metal strip plasmonic nanocavity can be characterized by its resonance wavelength, quality factor, equivalent modal volume, Purcell factor, and confinement and coupling factors. The resonance wavelength can be found by calculating propagation modes decay rate versus frequency in the resonator which can be witnessed in Fig.4 for different cavity sizes while other parameters were taken from Table.1. It is worth mentioning that the complex dielectric constants are taken from CRC model of [14] for Gold, Aluminum, and Germanium and for SiGe a linear interpolation is done between dispersion models of [14]. From this analysis for cavity size of 270nm, the resonance frequency is calculated to be 194.31THz which is equivalent to 1542.86 nm free-space wavelength. Quality factor can be expressed by (1) for the plasmonic nanowire resonator: (1) Using design values of Table.1 and FDTD method, cavity and mirror loss values have been calculated while the first propagation mode of the cavity was applied as the source. (See Figure.5) The "Q" factor is then calculated and its value for 1550nm wavelength and the fundamental mode is about 26.37. Fig.4 Resonance frequency versus cavity width while other parameters are set from Table.1 Energy stored in cavity2Energy lost per cycle to wallsQ=(a) (b) Fig.5 Transverse (a) and longitudinal (b) cross sections of the cavity fundamental mode electric field distributions respectively. In plasmonic metal nanocavities, considering their large amount of loss, the quality factor is far less than their insulator optical counterparts. Therefore, the quality factor of our proposed nanocavity despite having considerable mode confinement and tiny modal volume is very low. In order to increase the quality factor, cavity loss that originates from both scattering and mirror losses should be compensated. Propagation mode loss of the plasmons in the metal strip even by using gold is still high and about 1.07×105 dB/cm in room temperature (300K). This can be significantly lowered by decreasing the working temperature that can lower the loss by a factor of 0.01 for each Kelvin. [15] For instance, in 100K, scattering loss will be halved. In addition, for decreasing the mirror loss a plasmonic Insulator/Metal/Insulator (IMI) Bragg reflectors as shown in Fig.6 can be utilized. The Bragg condition for calculation of the grating period can be written as (2). [16] (2) Where "λ0" is free-space wavelength, "LPeriod" is Bragg period, "neff1" and "neff2" are the effective refractive indexes for the thin and thick parts of the waveguide respectively and m is an integer. For the structure shown in Fig.6, the Bragg period is calculated to be 90nm. According to FDTD simulations for two periods on each side of the resonator, the quality factor is increased approximately by a factor of 2. However, it is a tradeoff between decreasing the mirror loss which results in increased "Q" factor and thus output power and increasing device dimension and lowering output coupling ratio. Fig.6 IMI Bragg reflectors for decreasing mirror loss ()1202212PeriodeffeffLnnm+=+Effective mode volume "Veff" has great importance in nanolaser operation, which can be calculated by (3). [14] (3) Where "ε" is dielectric constant, "E" is the electric field and "V" is the resonator volume. From the FDTD analysis using lumerical package for the optimal values of Table.1 equivalent mode volume for 193.54 THz, which is equal to 1550nm free space wavelength is about 3.2797×10-16cm3 on each side of the metal strip which is much less than a metal/semiconductor nanocavity of the same size. [7] This significantly high mode confinement and two-sided power propagation can guarantee a considerable output performance. The Purcell factor [17] "Fp", is a key parameter in cavity quantum electrodynamics (CQED) that defines the coupling ratio between a dipolar emitter (QWs in our case) and a cavity mode. Purcell factor as can be expressed in (4) specifies the possible strategies to enhance and control light-matter interaction. [18] Efficient light-matter interaction is achieved by means of either high quality factor "Q" or low modal volume "V", which is the basis of plasmonic cavity quantum electrodynamics (PCQED). [19] (4) Where "λ" is free-space wavelength, "n" is the refractive index of gain medium and Q is the quality factor for the plasmonic resonator. There is also an alternative way of finding the Purcell factor. To do so, we have to use two dipole sources on each side of the gold strip for applying the same electric and magnetic fields as the propagation mode. Then the Purcell factor can be calculated by averaging the ratio of the power emitted by a dipole source in the environment to the power emitted by the dipole in a homogeneous environment (bulk material) for the two dipole sources. However, the results were pretty much the same for the two methods in our FDTD simulations and we have used this fact for double checking. Since the emission rate is proportional to the local density of optical states (LDOS), and the LDOS is proportional to the power emitted by the source. [14] Among all of the propagation modes, fundamental mode, as can be witnessed in Fig.5, has a considerable overlap with the quantum wells and the least loss value according to Fig.7. Thus, the fundamental mode is more likely to be excited. The Purcell factor for 193.54THz and for the fundamental mode is equivalent to 291. β which is known as the coupling factor is defined by the ratio of the spontaneous emission rate into the lasing mode (Fundamental mode) and the spontaneous emission rate into all other modes and can be expressed by (5). [7] (5) (k) is the Purcell factor of the k'th mode. k = 1 corresponds to the lasing mode Where Fcav and the summation is on all cavity modes. For calculating β factor, a method based on several randomly positioned dipole sources is used where the lasing mode is determined by the dipole source with maximum Purcell factor. By means of (5) and calculation of Purcell factors for all of these dipole sources (As shown in Fig.8), the β factor can be determined and it is equal to 0.0685 for the proposed square cavity structure. 232()()max()()VeffrErdrVrEr=3234peffQFnV=(1)()cavkcavkFF= Fig.7 Propagation loss in dB/cm for different modes. Mode "1" is the fundamental mode It should be noticed that for a mode to be considered as the lasing mode, there are two main measures. Firstly, the mode overlap with the gain medium which is also known as "Γ" factor, should be maximum. "Γ" has been calculated by the dividing the volume in quantum wells in which the electrical field is more than the half of the maximum electrical field onto the volume of the gain medium, i.e. The four quantum wells. The fundamental mode as shown in Fig.5 has the highest overlap factor which is calculated to be about 44.4% while for the other modes as can be seen from the inlet of Fig.8 "Γ" is significantly lower than the fundamental mode. Secondly, the longitudinal mode profile should provide power on the ends to be transmitted outside and locally confined modes even with higher Purcell factors cannot be considered as the lasing mode. Fig.8 Normalized Purcell factor for some of the resonator modes. The values are Normalized to the Purcell factor of the fundamental mode. (Inlet: Transverse cross section for 4 of the calculated modes) Coupling factor for the far field scenario of Fig.2.A can be easily calculated by the transmission ratio of the mirrors from Fresnel's equation [20] and in our case, it is about 61.45%. For MIM scenario of Fig.2.B as can be seen in Fig.9 and FDTD analysis, the coupling efficiency is about ~30%. Eventually for IMI case as can be seen from Fig.10 for three different metal thicknesses of the IMI waveguide, the coupling factor to the host waveguide is provided where the maximum coupling factor is about 71.44% for the metal thickness of 10nm. (a) (b) Fig.9 MIM coupling transverse field profile cross-sections. a. At the cavity edge b. 35nm away from the cavity edge) a. 10nm, Coupling ratio = 71.44% Fig.10 IMI coupling ratio for different metal thicknesses at the edge and 35nm away (a. 10nm b.15nm c. 20nm) b. 15nm, Coupling ratio = 67.51% c. 20nm, Coupling ratio = 34.29% Fig.10 IMI coupling ratio for different metal thicknesses at the edge and 35nm away (a. 10nm b.15nm c. 20nm) 3.2 Rate equations and energy transfer In the proposed structure as can be seen in Fig.11, the energy of generated excitons in quantum wells due to electrical current will be transferred to Surface Plasmon Polariton (SPP) modes in both sides of the gold strip. In order to analyze the performance of a plasmonic nanolaser, we need a model for its rate equations. For this purpose, we will start with a set of semi-classical rate equations similar to the microcavity semiconductor lasers which can be witnessed in (6). [21] In these set of equations, the first one is expressing the rate of carrier changes and the second one is expressing the temporal changes in the plasmon generation which is affected by spontaneous plasmons coupled in the lasing mode (the first term), stimulated emission (the second term) and plasmon loss (the last term). [21] (a) (b) Fig.11 Energy transfer diagram. a. Energy band diagram of nanolaser in equilibrium, b. Energy transfer concept (6) In these equations "n" is the excited state population of the carriers, "s" is the number of plasmons in the lasing mode and "P" is the carrier generation rate in "s-1". Total carrier generation rate (P) is determined by several parameters like, pump current (rate of injected carriers by electrical pumping), thermionic emission over and tunneling rates through Schottky barrier (in this case is neglected due to the very high doping level), contact to QWs transit time (drift/diffusion theory [22]), transition probability from each well, carrier recombination lifetime in quantum wells (indicates the average time before an exciton 00()()saanvSdnPAnAsnndtVdsAnAsnnsdt=−−−−=+−−transfers its energy to the SPP lasing mode or lose energy due to other processes) which can be expressed by radiative recombination rate and non-radiative recombination rates [10] (Auger and SRH processes) and tunneling and thermionic emission probability between two neighbor quantum wells. All of the mentioned phenomena should be considered to achieve a precise model for finding pump rate (P) as a function of pump current (a carrier dynamics model). In this paper, we have proposed a simplified model, which is based only on direct and indirect recombination coefficients. In this model, internal quantum efficiency (η) can be calculated from (7). (7) Where "Rradiative" is radiative recombination coefficient, which is equal to "1.3×10-10 cm3/s" for Ge quantum wells and "Rnonradiative" is non-radiative recombination coefficient respectively. [10] For "Cnnp" and "Cppn" which are equal to "3×10-32 cm6/s" and "7×10-32 cm6/s" respectively and SRH recombination rate which is equal to "5.1×10-15 cm3/s", non- radiative recombination rate in our device is equivalent to "2.285×10-12 cm3/s". [10] As a result internal quantum efficiency is "98.24%" which means radiative recombination is totally dominant. Due to the symmetric structure, calculations were done for each side of the metal waveguide individually and then the output power has been calculated by superposition of top and bottom plasmon generations. Therefore, the carrier generation rates for the top "P1" and bottom sides "P2" can be expressed as a function of injection current as can be seen in (8). (8) Where, "Ipump" is injection current in "A", "n" is majority electron concentration in "cm-3", "p" is minority hole concentration in "cm-3", "ni" is intrinsic carrier concentration, "q" is electron charge in "C" and "Δp" is the steady-state population of excess holes in the gain medium. In addition, "τc" is the effective recombination lifetime, which can be estimated by (9) in which phonon-assisted carrier capture and escape times [23] are neglected. In our case P in "s-1" is related to the injected current in "A" by a coefficient of 2.75×1016A-1.s-1. (9) Where "τAl-QW1" is the transit time of the carriers from the contact to the first quantum well which is determined by saturation velocity of the electrons due to the compact size of the AugernnpppnnonradiativeAugerSRHtotalradiativenonradiativeradiativetotalRCnCpRRRRRRRR=+=+=+=2121212()222iQWQWQWQWradiativeradiativeDpumppumpcradiativeDcQWQWNVNVPPRnpnPPRNpIIRNpPPqNVq=−→=→123311213141111112cQWQWQWQWQWAlQWrecQWAlQWwwrecQWAlQWwwAurecQWAlQWwwAurec−−−−−−−−−−−−=+++=+=++=+++=+++nanolaser and for 31nm buffer layer (16nm p-doped Ge and 15nm n-doped SiGe) of our structure "τAl-QW1" is about 0.33ps. "τrec" is the recombination lifetime in one of the Germanium quantum wells which can be calculated by the total recombination coefficient "Rtotal" and assuming one excess carrier in the quantum well region and it is about 0.73ps. - Inter-quantum well transition mechanism as expressed by "τw-w" is determined by "(τtunnel 1 -1)-1" where "τtunnel" and "τtherm" are related transit times of tunneling through and + τtherm thermionic emission over the barrier mechanisms respectively. [24] In our device according to (10) the inter-quantum well transit time is dominated by the tunneling process and it is about 13ps. [24] (10) Where "mb" and "mqw" are effective mass of the electrons in the barrier region and quantum wells respectively, "Wqw" is the quantum well thickness, "h" is the Plank's constant, "lb" is the barrier thickness "k" is Boltzmann constant, T is temperature in Kelvin, "EG,SiGe" and "EG,Ge" are Barrier and quantum well bandgaps and eventually "G" is the energy-independent wave number which is 6451.61cm-1 for 1550nm. In addition, "τAu" is drift time of the electrons in the 10nm Gold strip which is in femtosecond scale and neglected in comparison to other mentioned time constants. Accordingly, "τc" can be calculated and it is about 891.6fs. "A" is the spontaneous emission rate, which can be modified by the Purcell effect via "A = FpA0", where "A0" is the natural spontaneous emission rate of the material equals to 1/τsp0 and τsp0 is the spontaneous emission lifetime of the gain medium which is equal to "τc/η" that results in 907.6fs spontaneous emission lifetime. "Γ" which equals to the ratio of carriers generated in the spatial distribution of plasmonic modes to the whole number of generated carriers, is also called mode overlap with the gain medium coefficient and as calculated before, it is 0.444. "n0" is the excited state population of carriers in transparency and it is about 3.5×1018cm-3, [10] "vs" is surface recombination velocity at the sidewalls of the resonator which equals to 2160 cm/s [25]. "Sa" and "Va" are the area of sidewalls of the nanolaser and volume of gain medium, which are equivalent to 1.188×10-10 cm2 and 1.0206×10-15 cm3 respectively. Eventually, "γ" is the total loss rate of plasmons in the cavity (loss coefficient per unit length × modal speed), which is calculated by "γm +γg" where "γm" and "γg" are resonator mirror loss and loss due to the gain medium per unit length respectively. Loss due to gain medium will be calculated by integrating the imaginary part of metal permittivity in the desired frequency along the path of SPPs and loss due to mirrors will be calculated by Fresnel's law [19]. Accordingly, "γ" is 4.151 fs-1. In order to compare the output performance of plasmon lasers, various figures of merit can be considered. Among these, we have used output power, threshold pump current, plasmonic gain, and operational bandwidth. Output power as can be witnessed in (11) is a function of the number of generated plasmons in a plasmon lifetime in the cavity and can be derived from the rate equations of (6). [7] (11) (),,2*122bGSiGeGGeGlbqwqwtunnelEEkTthermQWqwmXGXeheXmkT−+==moutcmgpShcP=+Where "ηc" is the coupling efficiency "S" is the number of generated plasmons in a plasmon lifetime, "τp" is plasmon lifetime in the cavity and equals to "Q×(2πfres)-1" in which "Q" is the quality factor and "fres" is the resonance frequency of the cavity, "h" is Planck's constant, "c" is light speed and "λ" is the output wavelength. Plasmonic gain as expressed by (12) can be defined by the increase in the number of plasmons per unit length of the cavity. [20] (12) Where "Gspp" is the plasmonic gain in "cm-1" and "vg" is the group velocity of the SPPs in "cm/s" which is expressed in (13) and in our device is about "4.44×109cm/s". (13) Where "ω" is the SPP frequency in "rad/s", "c" is the speed of light in vacuum in "m/s" and "εGe" and "εAu" are the dielectric constants of Germanium and Gold respectively. Threshold pump current as can be calculated by (14) is the point in which plasmonic gain of the nanolaser is equal to the total loss per unit volume of the cavity consisting both mirror loss "γm" and loss due to the gain medium "γg". Accordingly, the threshold pump rate is 7.69×1014s-1 and threshold current is about 29mA. (14) The bandwidth of the proposed nanolaser is characterized by three main time constants as can be seen in (15). (15) The first time constant is the effective recombination lifetime and as mentioned before it can be estimated by (9) to be 891.6fs. Parasitic RC time constant of the nanolaser, "τcap" can be calculated for "Rs" a standard "50Ω" resistance of the modulation source by (16). (16) Where "εc" is the average dielectric constant of both Germanium QWs and SiGe barriers and "τcap" is equal to "0.37fs" for our device. The third parameter, "τspp" which contributes for SPP dynamics that can be calculated from 3dB bandwidth of spectral response transfer function of (17) in the threshold pumping condition is equal to "3.33fs". [7] ()0ppsppgAsnndtGvs−=,GeAugsppsppGeAudvdc==+162.7510sppmgthththGPPPI=+=→=()12ccapsppBW=++()22RscRstripcapWRHX−= (17) Where "ωr" and "ωp" are derived from (18) and (19) respectively and "S0" is the steady- state plasmon number in the cavity. [7] (18) Where "N0" is the steady-state population inversion number of carriers. [7] (19) As a result, by putting these time constants in (15) effective modulation bandwidth can be achieved and thus the proposed device can perform up to 178GHz. 4. Results and output characteristics One of the most important characteristics of a laser is the output power profile vs normalized pump rate (P/Pth) which is shown in Fig.12. The behavior of this profile demonstrates the proper laser operation of the introduced structure. Fig.12 Output power (µW) vs normalized pump rate ()3302222211:@()(0)2(1)()plasmondBdBrpHHASH==+=−+()0011rpSAAN+=−−()0011ppANS=+−+Fig.13 Output power (µW) vs injected current (µA) In Fig.13 a better input-output characteristic that relates the output SPP power (µW) to the input injection current (µA) is shown. Relatively large output power levels while maintaining the input pump current in microampere levels and in the room temperature, results in a practically appropriate device for chip-level integration processes. As mentioned before, the threshold current is about 29mA. Due to the tiny area of this device for the threshold current the related current density is about 40000 kA/cm2 which is far greater than the traditional III-V diode lasers. [10] However, this enormous current density can be thermally managed by appropriate cooling solutions in order to achieve mW range output power. It should be mentioned that this device even in 10μA pump current which results in 13.7kA/cm2 provides about 2.8μW output power which makes it useful even in very low pump currents without thermal breakdown. Furthermore, in a plasmonic nanolaser due to the strong coupling of the spontaneous emission into the lasing mode even before the threshold current lasing can be achieved. In addition, laser gain per unit length of the cavity can also be witnessed in Fig.14. Fig.14 Laser gain (cm-1) vs injected current (µA) Finally, in Table.2 the key parameters of the proposed nanolaser are concluded. Although analysis done in this paper were based on theoretical models, this cannot guarantee if implemented it should work up to the derived performance. Nevertheless, a notable performance can be predicted. Table.2 Key parameters of the nanolaser Parameter This work Liu, et al [7] Output wavelength (nm) Area (µm2) Threshold current (mA) Output power in mW @ threshold Output power in µW @ 10μA Gain in cm-1 @ threshold Bandwidth in GHz @ threshold Purcell factor (Lasing mode) Coupling factor (β) 1550 0.073 29 4.16 2.8 26680 178 291 0.0685 850 0.06 0.0019 0.08 0.25 - > 80 15 0.55 5. Conclusion In this paper a Ge/SiGe multi-quantum well metal strip plasmon source is introduced, theoretically analyzed, and numerically simulated. We have confirmed our calculations by means of various physical models and simulation tools. The key advantages of the proposed structure are its tiny footprint (0.073µm2), Silicon friendly process, room temperature operation, electrically pumping and high-efficiency coupling with plasmonic waveguides, which makes it a proper choice for the plasmon source in the development of plasmonic integrated circuits. The new structure generates 2.8µW output power with 10µA injection current in 1550nm-free space wavelength, has a wide modulation bandwidth of 178GHz, large Purcell factor about 291 which is resulted by considerable mode confinement. References [1] S. Enoch and N. Bonod, Plasmonics. Heidelberg: Springer, 2012. [2] Abdolber Mallah Livani, Hassan Kaatuzian, "Design and Simulation of an Electrically Pumped Schottky -- Junction -- Based Plasmonic Amplifier," Applied Optics, Vol. 54, No. 9, PP. 2164 - 2173, 11 March 2015. [3] Mostafa Keshavarz Moazzam, Hassan Kaatuzian, "Design and Investigation of a N-type Metal/Insulator/Semiconductor/Metal structure2port Electro-Plasmonic addressed Routing Switch," Applied Optics, Vol. 54, No. 20, PP. 6199 - 6207, 03 July 2015. [4] Ahmad Naseri Taheri, Hassan Kaatuzian, "Design and simulation of a nanoscale electro-plasmonic 1 × 2 switch based on asymmetric metal -- insulator -- metal stub filters," Applied Optics, Vol. 53, No. 28, PP. 6546 - 6553, 01 October 2014. [5] E. Rastegar Pashaki, H. Kaatuzian, A. Mallah Livani, and H. Ghodsi, "Design and investigation of a balanced silicon-based plasmonic internal-photoemission detector," Applied Physics B, vol. 125, no. 1, Dec. 2018. [6] M. Stockman, "The spaser as a nanoscale quantum generator and ultrafast amplifier", Journal of Optics, vol. 12, no. 2, p. 024004, 2010. [7] K. Liu, N. Li, D. Sadana and V. Sorger, "Integrated Nanocavity Plasmon Light Sources for On-Chip Optical Interconnects", ACS Photonics, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 233-242, 2016. [8] J. Ho, J. Tatebayashi, S. Sergent, C. Fong, Y. Ota, S. Iwamoto, and Y. Arakawa, "A Nanowire-Based Plasmonic Quantum Dot Laser", Nano Letters, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 2845-2850, 2016. [9] Ding, K. and Ning, C. (2012). Metallic subwavelength-cavity semiconductor nanolasers. Light: Science & Applications, 1(7), pp. e20-e20. [10] J. Liu et al., "Tensile-strained, n-type Ge as a gain medium for monolithic laser integration on Si", Optics Express, vol. 15, no. 18, p. 11272, 2007. Available: 10.1364/oe.15.011272. [11] H. Lee, S. Choi and A. Jung, "Direct Deposition of Highly Conductive Aluminum Thin Film on Substrate by Solution-Dipping Process", ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, vol. 5, no. 11, pp. 4581-4585, 2013. Available: 10.1021/am400812e [Accessed 10 March 2019]. [12] I. Massiot et al., "Metal Nanogrid for Broadband Multiresonance Light-Harvesting in Ultrathin GaAs Layers", ACS Photonics, vol. 1, no. 9, pp. 878-884, 2014. Available: 10.1021/ph500168b. [13] Guo-En Chang, Shao-Wei Chen, and H. H. Cheng, "Tensile-strained Ge/SiGe quantum-well photodetectors on silicon substrates with extended infrared response," Opt. Express 24, 17562-17571 (2016) [14] Nanophotonic FDTD Simulation Software - Lumerical FDTD Solutions", Lumerical, 2019. [Online]. Available: http://www.lumerical.com/tcad-products/fdtd/. [Accessed: 10- Mar- 2019]. [15] J. Rumble, D. Lide and T. Bruno, CRC handbook of chemistry and physics, 75th ed. New York: CRC Press, 1997. [16] Z. Han, E. Forsberg and S. He, "Surface Plasmon Bragg Gratings Formed in Metal-Insulator-Metal Waveguides", IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 91-93, 2007. Available: 10.1109/lpt.2006.889036. [17] 11. E. M. Purcell "Spontaneous emission probabilities at radio frequencies" Phys. Rev. 69, 681 (1946) [18] G. Francs et al., "Plasmonic Purcell factor and coupling efficiency to surface plasmons. Implications for addressing and controlling optical nanosources", Journal of Optics, vol. 18, no. 9, p. 094005, 2016. Available: 10.1088/2040-8978/18/9/094005. [19] P. Ginzburg, "Cavity quantum electrodynamics in application to plasmonics and metamaterials", Reviews in Physics, vol. 1, pp. 120-139, 2016. [20] Kaatuzian H., PHOTONICS vol.1, 5'th printing, Amirkabir University Press (in Persian), 2017. [21] R. Ma, R. Oulton, V. Sorger and X. Zhang, "Plasmon lasers: coherent light source at molecular scales", Laser & Photonics Reviews, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 1-21, 2012. Available: 10.1002/lpor.201100040 [Accessed 10 March 2019]. [22] Lundstrom M., and R. Shuelke, "Numerical Analysis of Heterostructure Semiconductor Devices", IEEE Trans. Electron Devices Vol. 30 (1983): 1151-1159. [23] B. Romero, J. Arias, I. Esquivias and M. Cada, "Simple model for calculating the ratio of the carrier capture and escape times in quantum-well lasers", Applied Physics Letters, vol. 76, no. 12, pp. 1504-1506, 2000. Available: 10.1063/1.126077. [24] I. Taghavi, H. Kaatuzian and J. Leburton, "Performance Optimization of Multiple Quantum Well Transistor Laser", IEEE Journal of Quantum Electronics, vol. 49, no. 4, pp. 426-435, 2013. Available: 10.1109/jqe.2013.2250488. [25] Buck, T. and Brattain, W. (1955). Investigations of Surface Recombination Velocities on Germanium by the Photoelectromagnetic Method. Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 102(11), p.636.
1911.12764	1	1911	2019-11-28T16:00:10	Accessing MHz Operation at 2 V with Field-Effect Transistors Based on Printed Polymers on Plastic	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	Organic printed electronics is proving its suitability for the development of wearable, lightweight, distributed applications in combination with cost-effective production processes. Nonetheless, some necessary features for several envisioned disruptive mass-produced products are still lacking: among these radio-frequency (RF) communication capability, which requires high operational speed combined with low supply voltage in electronic devices processed on cheap plastic foils. Here, we demonstrate that high-frequency, low-voltage, polymer field-effect transistors can be fabricated on plastic with the sole use of a combination of scalable printing and digital laser-based techniques. These devices reach an operational frequency in excess of 1 MHz at the challengingly low bias voltage of 2 V, and exceed 14 MHz operation at 7 V. In addition, when integrated into a rectifying circuit, they can provide a DC voltage at an input frequency of 13.56 MHz, opening the way for the implementation of RF devices and tags with cost-effective production processes.	physics.app-ph	physics	Accessing MHz Operation at 2 V with Field-Effect Transistors Based on Printed Polymers on Plastic Andrea Perinot and Mario Caironi* Dr. A. Perinot, Dr. M. Caironi Center for Nano Science and Technology@PoliMi, Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, via Giovanni Pascoli 70/3, Milan, Italy E-mail: [email protected] Keywords: printed electronics, flexible organic transistor, laser sintering, radio-frequency, rectifier Organic printed electronics is proving its suitability for the development of wearable, lightweight, distributed applications in combination with cost-effective production processes. Nonetheless, some necessary features for several envisioned disruptive mass-produced products are still lacking: among these radio-frequency (RF) communication capability, which requires high operational speed combined with low supply voltage in electronic devices processed on cheap plastic foils. Here, we demonstrate that high-frequency, low-voltage, polymer field-effect transistors can be fabricated on plastic with the sole use of a combination of scalable printing and digital laser-based techniques. These devices reach an operational frequency in excess of 1 MHz at the challengingly low bias voltage of 2 V, and exceed 14 MHz operation at 7 V. In addition, when integrated into a rectifying circuit, they can provide a DC voltage at an input frequency of 13.56 MHz, opening the way for the implementation of RF devices and tags with cost-effective production processes. 1. Introduction Printed and solution-processed polymer Field-Effect Transistors (FETs) are considered among key enablers of flexible, wearable and portable electronics, and they hold the promise of low- cost access to many novel mass applications. This promise stemmed from the prospect of utilizing printing tools derived from well-established graphical arts technologies to deposit a variety of functional materials, which exhibit a suitable combination of mechanical and 1 electronic properties.[1-5] Such vision has begun to show concrete potential through a variety of proof-of-concept demonstrations, among which programmable logic circuitry for flexible displays,[6] transferrable electronics for pharmaceutics,[7] healthcare sensors for brainwave detection[8] or pulse oximetry,[9] fully-printed washable electronics on fabrics[10] and imperceptible logic circuitry on ultra-thin substrates for intelligent electronic skin.[11] Nonetheless, several among the most desirable applications, such as Radio-Frequency (RF) tags and smart labels, driving circuitry for large-area high-resolution flexible displays and real-time sensor arrays, along with wireless sensors and sensors networks, require high-speed and low-voltage operation of the basic components of the circuits, in particular the transistor.[12, 13] Given the limited carrier mobility and the coarse resolution of printing tools, printed organic electronics has struggled to deliver the challenging performances required to enable wireless capabilities.[14-19] Alternative flexible electronics technologies with higher carrier mobilities are being developed to achieve high-frequency circuits, such as metal-oxide semiconductors, carbon nanotubes and 2-D materials, reaching in some cases very high transition frequency ft ,[20] the highest operative frequency of a transistor, in the order of the GHz or tens of GHz.[21, 22] However such high performances are either achieved by resorting to conventional micro- and nano-fabrication techniques (i.e. e-beam lithography, CVD, sputtering, thermal evaporation), or pose scaling and processing issues (placing of high quality monolayers of 2D materials,[23] alignment of CNTs,[24-27] process temperatures compatible with cheap plastic substrates for high-quality metal-oxide layers[28, 29]). It is therefore highly desirable to further develop printed and flexible organic electronics in order to achieve high-frequency operation. While the possibility to obtain GHz organic transistors has only recently become argument of discussion,[30] progresses are being made in the range of near-field wireless communication. Several research groups in fact have proven the feasibility of operating organic transistors at frequencies in excess of 10 MHz,[31-36] but only a few works have achieved such frequencies by adopting printing techniques,[37] which 2 are more easily upscalable and compatible with large-area processing. The maximum frequency drastically decreases for organic transistors on flexible substrates.[15, 17, 18] Moreover, since ft is proportional to the bias voltage, the requirement of low-voltage operation, at least below 10 V as necessary for portable, self-powered wireless electronics, further complicates the achievement of high operational frequency. Examples of ft beyond the MHz threshold have been shown through the adoption of conventional thermally-grown silicon dioxide dielectrics (20 MHz at a bias of 10 V[19]), ALD-deposited alumina (19 MHz at 10 V[33]) or hybrid metal-oxide/self-assembled ultrathin dielectrics (3.7 MHz at a bias of 3 V[38] and 1.5 MHz at 4 V[39]). There are instead scarce examples of fast devices where low- voltage is achieved through solution-processing. In this respect, ionic gating schemes through electrolyte dielectrics,[40, 41] which allow to achieve 1 V, or even lower, operational voltages, are not suitable because of their slow switching speed, in the tens of kHz range for the best reported cases,[42, 43] because of the slow movement of ions. Polymer dielectrics, in particular if based on low-k materials, are a suitable choice to attain ideal high-frequency operation of FETs, but the achievement of the high capacitance necessary for low-voltage operation is challenging. Demonstrations of MHz operation in FETs integrating low-k polymers are rare,[16] and high ft values at a voltage below 10 V of transistors of this kind on flexible substrate are yet to be shown. In this work, we demonstrate that fully solution-processed, low-voltage polymer FETs, operating at MHz range, can be realized on flexible substrates with a combination of printing and direct-writing techniques. In particular, ft in excess of 1 MHz can be reached at an extremely low bias voltage of 2 V, a voltage comparable to electrolyte-gated devices. 14 MHz operation can be attained already at 7 V, therefore enabling near-field wireless communication, which we exemplify here with a voltage rectifier, one of the most relevant building blocks for 13.56 MHz RF tags. The combination of these performances, obtained 3 through scalable processes on cheap flexible substrates, represents a step forward in the realization of mass-produced, distributed electronics with RF communication functionalities. 2. Results To realize low-voltage, high-frequency polymer FETs we adopted a combination of femtosecond-laser sintering of high-resolution metal electrodes on plastic, a fast coating of uniaxially-aligned polymer semiconductor and a solution-processed high capacitance dielectric stack. We have previously adopted fs-laser sintering for the realization of high resolution electrodes and high-frequency polymer transistors on glass.[37] The same technique was also previously demonstrated to be compatible with plastic substrates for the fabrication of electrodes,[44, 45] semi-transparent grids[46] and transistors,[47-49] while it has not yet been adopted yet for high-frequency, printed electronics on plastic. Here we show that fs-laser sintering, thanks to highly controlled deposition of energy, allows the conversion of silver inks on plastic and the high spatial resolution patterning of electrodes suitable for high- performance fully solution-processed polymer transistors. Our simple two-steps fabrication process is sketched in Figure 1a: we first deposit via spin-coating a uniform thin film of an ink of silver nanoparticles, then a near-infrared fs-pulsed laser beam (λ = 1030 nm, 67 MHz repetition rate) induces the local sintering of the nanoparticles, directly writing conductive patterns. Finally, the unprocessed areas are washed out with an organic solvent. In future implementations aiming at reducing the amount of waste materials, spin-coating may be replaced with a suitable printing technique (e.g. bar-coating or ink-jet) and the washed material can be recollected and recycled. This approach allows to reach a maximum resolution of 1.5 µm for the patterning of conductive features at a scanning speed of 1 mm/s (current limit of our setup), with an impinging laser beam intensity of 1.9 mW µm-2. With this method, we patterned silver source and drain electrodes with a width Lov of 1.7 µm on PEN to be used in FETs with a bottom- 4 contact, top-gate architecture (Figure 1b). We realized an interdigitated structure in which the central finger is used as the source electrode, while the two external fingers are used as the drain. A photograph of the realized devices on a flexible PEN substrate is shown in Figure 1c. To proceed with the fabrication of OFETs, we followed the process illustrated in Figure 2a. We first modified the sintered Ag electrodes with a self-assembled monolayer of dimethylamino(benzenethiol) (DABT), which has been shown to improve charge injection for n-type organic semiconductors.[50] Then, we adopted the widely-studied semiconducting n- type co-polymer poly[N,N'-bis(2-octyldodecyl)-naphthalene-1,4,5,8-bis(dicarboximide)-2,6- diyl]-alt-5,5'-(2,2'-bithiophene), P(NDI2OD-T2) and deposited a thin layer of such material via bar-coating, which is a simple and fast method to induce the directional alignment of the polymer chains along the coating direction,[51] yielding a film with optimized charge mobility over large area.[14] We then deposited via spin-coating a 150-nm-thick multi-layered polymer dielectric stack, composed of an ultra-thin crossed-linked low-k polymer and a top high-k polymer, achieving an areal capacitance Cdiel of 39 nF cm-2. We finally inkjet-printed PEDOT:PSS gate electrodes on top of the dielectric. We fabricated FETs (Figure 2b) with a varying channel length L, ranging from 1 to 17.5 µm, with constant channel width W of 800 µm. The transfer curve for a FET with the shortest channel length of 1 µm (Figure 2c) highlights the correct operation and turn-on of the device at a gate voltage as low as 5 V, both in the linear (Vd = 1 V) and in the saturation (Vd = 5 V) regime, with no appreciable hysteresis. In addition, we highlight the extremely low gate leakage current that is more than 4 orders of magnitude lower than the device ON current in both operation regimes. Similarly, analogous electrical performance and low gate leakage current are achieved in the devices with longer channel length (Figure S1a-c). The drain current scales correctly with the channel length (Figure 2e, S2a-c), while the output curve, although not achieving clear saturation differently from the longer channel devices (Figure S3 a-c) and likely owing to the onset of short-channel 5 effects,[52] both confirms the correct operation of our downscaled device and suggests that a good charge injection performance is achieved in our architecture (Figure 2d). We calculated the apparent electron mobility (µapp) for our devices as a function of gate voltage form the derivative of the transfer curves according to the gradual channel approximation model. In the device with L = 1 µm (Figure 2f), µapp peaks at a low Vg of 1.8 V (2.2 V) in the linear (saturation) regime, then slightly rolls off with Vg, an effect related to the influence of charge injection limitations. For our case, we simply report in Table 1 the calculated value for the mobility in the saturation regime at maximum Vg, being one of the relevant bias point for the FET and for the rectifier circuit presented later in the text. At this bias point, µapp ranges in the interval from 0.15 to 0.3 cm2 V-1 s-1 when L is shortened from 17.5 to 1 µm. Such an increasing trend as the channel length is reduced is an effect stemming from the increase of the lateral electric field across the channel region, which affects charge injection and/or charge transport in organic FETs.[53-55] In Table 1, alongside with the calculated mobility, we report the measurement reliability factor r as suggested in Choi et al.,[56] which in our cases is always above 100 %, highlighting the presence of a very mild "kink effect". We extracted the contact resistance of the shortest-channel device (L = 1 µm) with the differential method,[57] which yielded a width-normalized contact resistance RCW = 1015 Ωcm at Vg = 5 V in the linear regime. The latter is a very small value in the context of printed polymer FETs, has rarely been achieved with the sole use of solution-based approaches and with low-voltage operation[58, 59] and has a paramount role in the achievement of good electrical behavior of our downscaled FETs. In particular, RCW is below the value of the width-normalized channel resistance RchW = VdW/Id -- RcW = 1369 Ωcm at the highest gate bias of Vg = 5 V (and Vd = 1 V). Despite RCW below 1000 Ωcm have been demonstrated for organic transistors,[60-66] these examples either adopted evaporation of dopants/electrodes, or 6 device biasing in excess of 10 V or the use of electrolyte-gating schemes, which are not desirable for high-frequency, low-voltage, all-solution-processed devices. We show in Figure S4a-b the superimposed transfer curves of 5 different devices each for L = 1 µm and L = 1.5 µm cases, and in Figure S5 we plot the superimposed trends of the extracted mobility versus gate voltage for the devices with the shortest channel (L = 1 µm), highlighting that our results are reproducible even at these challengingly short, micron-sized, channel lengths. In Table S1 we also report the mean and standard deviation of some selected figures of merit (i.e. the mobility at maximum bias and the parameters µ0, γ and VT as defined in Natali et al. [57]) for the set of 5 devices with L = 1 µm. Once again, the reproducibility of our devices is highlighted especially in terms of intrinsic mobility µ0 and in terms of the threshold voltage VT, for which the standard deviation is respectively 1.4 % and 5 % of the mean value. We also measured the transfer curve of a device (L = 1 µm) after 7 months from fabrication and storage in nitrogen atmosphere, highlighting how only a small loss in performance is detected (Figure S6a). We then kept such transistor in the ON state for 150 minutes by applying Vg = Vd = 5 V and measured its transfer curves every 30 minutes (Figure S6b), detecting a good stability of the device upon operational stress. In order to evidence the benefit of downscaled features on the frequency response of the fabricated FETs, we characterized the AC performance of our devices in terms of transition frequency ft, which depends on the electrical parameters of the transistor according to:[20] 𝑓𝑡 = 𝑔𝑚 2𝜋 (𝐶𝑔𝑠 + 𝐶𝑔𝑑) where gm is the device transconductance and Cgs, Cgd are the gate/source and gate/drain capacitances respectively. Additional details on the measurement method can be found in [37]. In Figure 3a we show the measured Cgs and Cgd versus bias voltage in the saturation regime (Vgs = Vds), and compared them to the theoretically expected values for our layout, according to:[67] 7 𝐶𝑔𝑠 = 𝐶𝑑𝑖𝑒𝑙 (𝑊 2 3 𝐿 + 𝑊𝑜𝑣𝐿𝑜𝑣) (1 + 𝛼𝑓,𝑔𝑠) 𝐶𝑔𝑑 = 2𝐶𝑑𝑖𝑒𝑙𝑊𝑜𝑣𝐿𝑜𝑣 (1 + 𝛼𝑓,𝑔𝑑) where Wov = 500 µm is the total width of the overlap between gate and bottom electrodes, which exceeds the actual channel width W (see the scheme reported in Figure S7), while the correction factors αf,gs and αf,gd are introduced to account for the fringing capacitance between the source/drain electrodes and the wide top gate. We calculated such factors using a formula proposed by Elmasry,[68] yielding αf,gs = 12.41 % and αf,gd = 21.05 %, which is in perfect agreement with our measured data. In the case of Cgd, the measured values are correctly constant at ~0.8 pF up to a bias voltage of 5 V, while Cgs exhibits a slightly increasing trend with the bias voltage, which we attribute to parasitic accumulation of additional charge outside the channel active area. This effect has already been explained for structures of this kind,[69] and originates from the fact that the semiconductor layer is not patterned, covering the whole substrate. At bias voltages > 5 V, the higher electric fields are producing a further increase in capacitance and a relatively small deviation from the predicted values. The measured gm per unit width versus bias voltage is shown in Figure 3b. We correctly identify a linear increase of gm from Vgs = 1 V to Vgs = 5 V, where the transconductance varies from 0.081 to 0.58 mS cm-1. The latter value is very close to the theoretical one extracted from the slope of the transfer curves, which yields 𝑔𝑚 𝑊 = 𝜇𝐶𝑑𝑖𝑒𝑙 𝐿 (𝑉𝑔𝑠 − 𝑉𝑡) = 0.53 mA Vcm . For bias voltages in excess of 5 V, gm exhibits a superlinear increase with Vgs, an effect that we attribute to the high lateral electric field insisting across the channel region. The measurements for gm, Cgs and Cgd can be combined to identify ft as in Figure 3c, where we show such measurement for a device with L = 1 µm and a bias voltage of 7 V (top panel) and 2 V (bottom panel). The measurement is limited at a frequency of 2 MHz due to setup constraints. Remarkably, we can measure an ft = 1.6 MHz for a bias voltage of only 2 V. In Figure 3d we show the trend of the measured ft for the same device versus bias voltage, 8 highlighting how this figure of merit essentially follows the behavior of gm. In the case of a bias voltage of 7 V, we can extrapolate a high transition frequency of 10.4 MHz. To assess the relevance of the performance achieved by our devices and also to favor the identification of effective strategies to improve even further ft, we have calculated the maximum achievable transition frequency with respect to the variation of our FET parameters, using the modeling recently proposed by H. Klauk.[30] With an RCW of a value equal to the one we measured, neither a further reduction of L nor an increase of µ0 would yield a very significant increase in ft (Figure S8a). At such fixed contact resistance, an increase in ft would only be obtainable with the reduction of Lov. However, even in the extreme and unrealistic case of Lov = 0, ft would be limited to a value below 100 MHz at best (Figure S8b). These calculations underline that we have already obtained, with the physical parameters characterizing our devices, an AC performance that is close to the highest possible. The reduction of the contact resistance thus constitutes the main route for accessing higher ft in the future, as it is the key point in order to achieve a regime where the modification of the other parameters is effective (Figure S8c). We have also measured the reproducibility of our devices in terms of transition frequency after 7 months from fabrication. In Figure S9 we show the measured curves for 4 devices with L = 1 µm at a bias voltage of 5 V, which highlight good reproducibility for ft with a mean value of 6.65 MHz and a standard deviation of 2.12 MHz. Overall, our best ft in the measurement set yielded a value of 14.4 MHz at a bias voltage of 7 V (Figure S10). We have also compared our achieved performance to the previous literature for organic high- frequency transistors on plastic, for which the transition frequency was explicitly measured and reported. Since ft is directly proportional to the applied bias voltage, in our comparison we decouple such effect by defining the voltage-normalized transition frequency ft/Vbias, where Vbias is the maximum voltage applied to the transistor electrodes during ft measurement. 9 In this way the voltage-normalized transition frequency encompasses the achieved performance exclusively in terms of effective charge transport properties and geometrical resolution. We report in Table 2 the calculated ft/Vbias of our FETs in comparison with other representative examples of high-frequency (ft > 1 MHz) organic devices on flexible substrate. Our FETs achieve the best performance in terms of ft/Vbias in the field of organic transistors on plastic, with a tenfold improvement compared to previous demonstrations. While ft is the relevant figure of merit for the assessment of the FET maximum operational speed for integration in analog circuitry (e.g. amplifiers), we additionally assessed the performance of our FETs upon large-signal operation, which is relevant for the implementation of RF applications such as wireless data communication. To this goal, we realized a simple rectifier circuit (Figure 4b, inset) and operated it up to 15 MHz, above the frequencies of interest for NFC. In Figure 4a we show the rectified output (red line) on an oscilloscope corresponding to an oscillating input signal with an amplitude of 8 V (black line). We measure a -3 dB frequency of 8.7 MHz, with respect to the amplitude recorded at 100 kHz (Figure S11). For a reduced signal amplitude of 5 V, the -3 dB frequency is as high as 6.4 MHz already (Figure 4b), and 1 V can still be read in DC at 15 MHz (Figure S12) proving the applicability of our approach for the implementation of RF tags. We also verified the stability of the output of our rectifier upon constant operation for 150 minutes at an input voltage amplitude of 5 V and at an input frequency of 15 MHz (Figure S13). The device was measured after 7 months from fabrication. Our rectifier shows stable performance over 2.5 hours of continuous operation even at the high operational frequency of 15 MHz. To better understand the measured performance of our rectifier we developed a simple model, based on the charge balance of the smoothing capacitor (see Figure 4b, inset), for the behavior of the output voltage versus input voltage frequency (see Supplementary Information). We are able to predict with good approximation the frequency behavior of the output voltage (Figure 10 4b, solid line), correctly identifying the frequency cutoff. Moreover, the model allows us to identify the main factors determining the output/input voltage ratio without affecting the rectifier cutoff frequency: in order to achieve a high ratio, it is critical to limit the OFF current in the transistor and to adopt a channel width large enough to feed the load resistance. The cutoff frequency is instead determined by the same parameters as the ft (i.e. L, µ, Vbias) and can be set independently. 3. Conclusions We have demonstrated the realization of high-frequency, low-voltage, polymer FETs on flexible substrates using only printing techniques and digital laser patterning. The proposed FETs feature a transition frequency in excess of 1 MHz at a bias voltage as low as 2 V, and can operate at a frequency in excess of 10 MHz at a bias voltage of 7 V, which is, to the best of our knowledge, the highest for the case of printed polymers integrating direct-written electrodes, on flexible substrates. Such performance allows the reported devices to operate at supply voltages comparable to electrolyte gated organic transistors, while they can be modulated at 2-3 orders of magnitude higher frequencies. Moreover, such operational bias voltage enables the implementation of stand-alone electronic devices, being fully compatible with thin film batteries or energy harvesters, such as plastic photovoltaic modules.[70] In addition, these devices achieve the best figure to date, by an order of magnitude, in terms of voltage-normalized transition frequency (2.06 MHz V-1). Finally, we have integrated these devices into a rectifying circuit that can provide voltage rectification up to 15 MHz, thus being compatible with NFC wireless communication at 13.56 MHz. The demonstration of such performance and its achievement with the sole use of solution-based processing, printing techniques and laser patterning, identifies a feasible route towards low-cost, mass-scale production of organic devices for RF applications. 11 4. Experimental Section General: The Ag-nanoparticles ink (NPS-JL) was purchased from Harima Chemicals, 4- (Dimethylamino)benzenethiol (DABT) was purchased from TCI Chemicals, P(NDI2OD-T2) was purchased from Polyera (Mn = 35.3 kDa; PDI = 1.8 (GPC); Elemental analysis: C: 75.21, H: 8.73, N: 2.87 (Theoretical: C:75.26, H:8.96, N: 2.83)), PEDOT:PSS (Clevios PJ700) was purchased from Haereus. The substrates consist of 125-µm-thick polyethylene naphthalate foils (Teonex Q65FA) purchased from DuPont TeijinFilms. Femtosecond laser sintering setup: The laser setup consists of a commercial laser source ( LightConversion PHAROS, based on Yb:KGW as active medium) which generates ~80 fs-long laser pulses with a repetition rate of 67 MHz, λ = 1030 nm and maximum output power of 2 W. Before reaching the sample, the beam is conditioned through an optical path which includes a software-controlled attenuator and a focalizing objective (Mitutoyo) lens whose magnifying power can be selected between 20X, 50X or 100X. The sample is positioned on a software- controlled moving stage (Aerotech ABL1000) capable of a maximum resolution of 0.5 nm and a maximum speed of 300 mm s-1. Contacts fabrication: The PEN substrates are used as-is on the pristine side (without adhesion- promoting treatment) and a 4-nm-thick AlOx layer is deposited via thermal evaporation of Al and exposure to atmosphere. The Ag-nanoparticles ink is spun at 7000 rpm for 5 min, yielding a 70-nm-thick layer. The laser-sintering step is then performed using 1.9 mW µm-2 beam power, 50X optics, 0.1 mm s-1 scanning speed. After laser processing, the samples are thoroughly washed with o-Xylene and isopropanol and finally dried with a nitrogen flux. Organic FETs fabrication: The samples with the desired laser-sintered patterns for the FET bottom electrodes are Ar-plasma etched with a power of 100 W for 4 min. A solution of 17 µl of DABT in 12 ml of isopropanol is prepared, the samples are immersed in it for 15 minutes and the rinsed with abundant isopropanol. A solution of P(NDI2OD-T2) in toluene (5 g l-1) is then deposited via bar-coating on the samples as described in [14], using a bar designed to yield 12 a 8-µm-thick wet layer. The samples are then annealed in a nitrogen atmosphere for 20 min at 120 °C. The dielectric is a double layer stack[71] composed of a very thin layer of a low-k polymer, in contact with the semiconductor, and a top high-k polymer, for a total thickness of about 200 nm and an areal capacitance of 39 nF/cm2. Finally, PEDOT:PSS is inkjet-printed with a Fujifilm Dimatix DMP-2831 to pattern the gate electrodes and the samples are annealed for 8 h in nitrogen atmosphere before measurement. Rectifier fabrication: The rectifier circuit is realized by connecting one of the realized transistor, biased in a transdiode configuration, to a discrete capacitor of 0.15 µF and to an oscilloscope with an input resistance of 1 MΩ using external point-contact probes. Electrical characterization: The devices are measured in nitrogen atmosphere. Static characterization is performed via a Keysight B1500A Semiconductor Parameter Analyzer. Frequency performance was measured using a custom setup which includes a Keysight ENA E5061B Vector Network Analyzer and an Agilent B2912A Source Meter. The apparent mobility µapp is extracted from the transfer characteristic according to 𝜇𝑎𝑝𝑝 = 2𝐿 𝑊𝐶𝑑𝑖𝑒𝑙 𝜕√𝐼𝑑 ( 𝜕𝑉𝑔 2 ) for the saturation regime and to 𝜇𝑎𝑝𝑝 = 𝐿 𝑉𝑑𝑊𝐶𝑑𝑖𝑒𝑙 𝜕𝐼𝑑 𝜕𝑉𝑔 for the linear regime. Supporting Information Supporting Information is available from the Wiley Online Library or from the author. Acknowledgements The authors are thankful to L. Criante and his team for the support with the femtosecond laser machining setup. This work has been financially supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme 'HEROIC', grant agreement 638059. 13 Received: ((will be filled in by the editorial staff)) Revised: ((will be filled in by the editorial staff)) Published online: ((will be filled in by the editorial staff)) References G. E. Bonacchini, C. Bossio, F. Greco, V. Mattoli, Y. H. Kim, G. Lanzani, M. Caironi, S. Yoshimoto, T. Araki, T. Uemura, T. Nezu, M. Kondo, K. Sasai, M. Iwase, H. C. M. Lochner, Y. Khan, A. Pierre, A. C. Arias, Nat. Commun. 2014, 5, 5745. G. Mattana, A. Loi, M. Woytasik, M. Barbaro, V. Noël, B. Piro, Advanced Materials J. S. Chang, A. F. Facchetti, R. Reuss, IEEE Journal on Emerging and Selected Topics X. Guo, Y. Xu, S. Ogier, T. N. Ng, M. Caironi, A. Perinot, L. Li, J. Zhao, W. Tang, R. L. Shunpu, C. Daping, Flexible and Printed Electronics 2017, 2, 013002. K. Fukuda, T. Someya, Adv. Mater. 2017, 29, 1602736. A. Sou, S. Jung, E. Gili, V. Pecunia, J. Joimel, G. Fichet, H. Sirringhaus, Org. [1] A. Sporea, A. Nejim, J. Carrabina, P. Cain, F. Yan, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 2017, 64, 1906. [2] Technologies 2017, 2, 1700063. [3] in Circuits and Systems 2017, 7, 7. [4] [5] [6] Electron. 2014, 15, 3111. [7] Adv Mater 2018, 30, e1706091. [8] Satake, A. Yoshida, M. Kikuchi, T. Sekitani, presented at 2016 38th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC), 16-20 Aug. 2016, 2016. [9] [10] T. Carey, S. Cacovich, G. Divitini, J. Ren, A. Mansouri, J. M. Kim, C. Wang, C. Ducati, R. Sordan, F. Torrisi, Nat. Commun. 2017, 8, 1202. [11] Y. Takeda, K. Hayasaka, R. Shiwaku, K. Yokosawa, T. Shiba, M. Mamada, D. Kumaki, K. Fukuda, S. Tokito, Sci. Rep. 2016, 6, 25714. [12] V. Subramanian, J. M. J. Frechet, P. C. Chang, D. C. Huang, J. B. Lee, S. E. Molesa, A. R. Murphy, D. R. Redinger, S. K. Volkman, Proc. IEEE 2005, 93, 1330. [13] Semicond. Sci. Technol. 2017, 32, 123002. [14] S. G. Bucella, A. Luzio, E. Gann, L. Thomsen, C. R. McNeill, G. Pace, A. Perinot, Z. Chen, A. Facchetti, M. Caironi, Nat Commun 2015, 6. [15] R. Kitsomboonloha, H. Kang, G. Grau, W. Scheideler, V. Subramanian, Adv Electron Mater 2015, 1, 1500155. [16] Y.-Y. Noh, N. Zhao, M. Caironi, H. Sirringhaus, Nat. Nanotechnol. 2007, 2, 784. [17] S. G. Higgins, B. V. O. Muir, G. Dell'Erba, A. Perinot, M. Caironi, A. J. Campbell, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2016, 108, 023302. [18] S. G. Bucella, A. Perinot, M. Caironi, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 2017, PP, 1. [19] A. Yamamura, S. Watanabe, M. Uno, M. Mitani, C. Mitsui, J. Tsurumi, N. Isahaya, Y. Kanaoka, T. Okamoto, J. Takeya, Science Advances 2018, 4. [20] M. Caironi, Y. Y. Noh, H. Sirringhaus, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 2011, 26, 034006. [21] N. Chimot, V. Derycke, M. F. Goffman, J. P. Bourgoin, H. Happy, G. Dambrine, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2007, 91, 153111. [22] R. Cheng, S. Jiang, Y. Chen, Y. Liu, N. Weiss, H.-C. Cheng, H. Wu, Y. Huang, X. Duan, Nat. Commun. 2014, 5, 5143. J. Semple, D. G. Georgiadou, G. Wyatt-Moon, G. Gelinck, T. D. Anthopoulos, 14 J. Zhang, J. Cui, X. Wang, W. Wang, X. Mei, P. Yi, X. Yang, X. He, physica status [23] B. J. Carey, J. Z. Ou, R. M. Clark, K. J. Berean, A. Zavabeti, A. S. R. Chesman, S. P. Russo, D. W. M. Lau, Z.-Q. Xu, Q. Bao, O. Kavehei, B. C. Gibson, M. D. Dickey, R. B. Kaner, T. Daeneke, K. Kalantar-Zadeh, Nat. Commun. 2017, 8, 14482. [24] S. Park, M. Vosguerichian, Z. Bao, Nanoscale 2013, 5, 1727. [25] N. Rouhi, D. Jain, P. J. Burke, ACS Nano 2011, 5, 8471. [26] solidi (a) 2018, 215, 1700719. [27] V. Derenskyi, W. Gomulya, W. Talsma, J. M. Salazar-Rios, M. Fritsch, P. Nirmalraj, H. Riel, S. Allard, U. Scherf, M. A. Loi, Adv. Mater. 2017, 29, 1606757. [28] S. R. Thomas, P. Pattanasattayavong, T. D. Anthopoulos, Chem. Soc. Rev. 2013, 42, 6910. [29] L. Petti, N. Münzenrieder, C. Vogt, H. Faber, L. Büthe, G. Cantarella, F. Bottacchi, T. D. Anthopoulos, G. Tröster, Applied Physics Reviews 2016, 3, 021303. [30] H. Klauk, Adv Electron Mater 2018, 0, 1700474. [31] M. Kitamura, Y. Arakawa, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 2011, 50, 01BC01. [32] M. Uno, T. Uemura, Y. Kanaoka, Z. Chen, A. Facchetti, J. Takeya, Org. Electron. 2013, 14, 1656. [33] K. Nakayama, M. Uno, T. Uemura, N. Namba, Y. Kanaoka, T. Kato, M. Katayama, C. Mitsui, T. Okamoto, J. Takeya, Adv Mater Interfaces 2014, 1, 1300124. [34] M. Uno, B.-S. Cha, Y. Kanaoka, J. Takeya, Org. Electron. 2015, 20, 119. [35] T. Uemura, T. Matsumoto, K. Miyake, M. Uno, S. Ohnishi, T. Kato, M. Katayama, S. Shinamura, M. Hamada, M.-J. Kang, K. Takimiya, C. Mitsui, T. Okamoto, J. Takeya, Adv. Mater. 2014, 26, 2983. [36] B. Kheradmand-Boroujeni, M. P. Klinger, A. Fischer, H. Kleemann, K. Leo, F. Ellinger, Sci. Rep. 2018, 8, 7643. [37] A. Perinot, P. Kshirsagar, M. A. Malvindi, P. P. Pompa, R. Fiammengo, M. Caironi, Sci. Rep. 2016, 6, 38941. [38] T. Zaki, R. Rodel, F. Letzkus, H. Richter, U. Zschieschang, H. Klauk, J. N. Burghartz, IEEE Electron Device Lett. 2013, 34, 520. [39] S. P. Senanayak, V. K. Sangwan, J. J. McMorrow, K. Everaerts, Z. H. Chen, A. Facchetti, M. C. Hersam, T. J. Marks, K. S. Narayan, Adv Electron Mater 2015, 1, 1500226. [40] E. Zeglio, O. Inganas, Adv Mater 2018, 0, e1800941. [41] B. Nketia-Yawson, S.-J. Kang, G. D. Tabi, A. Perinot, M. Caironi, A. Facchetti, Y.-Y. Noh, Adv. Mater. 2017, 29, 1605685. [42] B. Wang, W. Huang, L. Chi, M. Al-Hashimi, T. J. Marks, A. Facchetti, Chem. Rev. 2018, 118, 5690. [43] S. H. Kim, K. Hong, W. Xie, K. H. Lee, S. Zhang, T. P. Lodge, C. D. Frisbie, Adv. Mater. 2013, 25, 1822. [44] Y. Son, J. Yeo, C. W. Ha, S. Hong, S. H. Ko, D.-Y. Yang, Int. J. Nanomanuf. 2013, 9, 468. [45] H. Lee, J. Kwon, W. S. Shin, H. R. Kim, J. Shin, H. Cho, S. Han, J. Yeo, S. Hong, Micromachines 2017, 8, 153. [46] S. Hong, J. Yeo, G. Kim, D. Kim, H. Lee, J. Kwon, H. Lee, P. Lee, S. H. Ko, ACS Nano 2013, 7, 5024. [47] S. H. Ko, H. Pan, C. P. Grigoropoulos, C. K. Luscombe, J. M. J. Fréchet, D. Poulikakos, Nanotechnology 2007, 18, 345202. [48] One 2012, 7, e42315. [49] Y. Son, J. Yeo, H. Moon, T. W. Lim, S. Hong, K. H. Nam, S. Yoo, C. P. Grigoropoulos, D. Y. Yang, S. H. Ko, Adv. Mater. 2011, 23, 3176. J. Yeo, S. Hong, D. Lee, N. Hotz, M.-T. Lee, C. P. Grigoropoulos, S. H. Ko, PLoS 15 [50] M. Kitamura, Y. Kuzumoto, S. Aomori, M. Kamura, J. H. Na, Y. Arakawa, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2009, 94, 083310. [51] D. Khim, A. Luzio, G. E. Bonacchini, G. Pace, M. J. Lee, Y. Y. Noh, M. Caironi, Adv Mater 2018, 30, e1705463. [52] Y. Taur, T. H. Ning, Fundamentals of Modern VLSI Devices, Cambridge University Press, 2009. [53] A. Luzio, L. Criante, V. D'Innocenzo, M. Caironi, Sci. Rep. 2013, 3, 3425. [54] H. Sirringhaus, Adv. Mater. 2014, 26, 1319. [55] D. Fazzi, M. Caironi, PCCP 2015, 17, 8573. [56] H. H. Choi, K. Cho, C. D. Frisbie, H. Sirringhaus, V. Podzorov, Nat. Mater. 2017, 17, 2. [57] D. Natali, L. Fumagalli, M. Sampietro, J. Appl. Phys. 2007, 101, 014501. [58] D. Natali, M. Caironi, Adv. Mater. 2012, 24, 1357. [59] C. Liu, Y. Xu, Y.-Y. Noh, Mater. Today 2015, 18, 79. [60] T. Minari, C. Liu, presented at 2013 IEEE International Interconnect Technology Conference - IITC, 13-15 June 2013, 2013. [61] Q. Wang, S. Jiang, J. Qian, L. Song, L. Zhang, Y. Zhang, Y. Zhang, Y. Wang, X. Wang, Y. Shi, Y. Zheng, Y. Li, Sci. Rep. 2017, 7, 7830. [62] D. He, J. Qiao, L. Zhang, J. Wang, T. Lan, J. Qian, Y. Li, Y. Shi, Y. Chai, W. Lan, L. K. Ono, Y. Qi, J.-B. Xu, W. Ji, X. Wang, Science Advances 2017, 3. [63] T. Uemura, C. Rolin, T.-H. Ke, P. Fesenko, J. Genoe, P. Heremans, J. Takeya, Adv. Mater. 2015, n/a. [64] P. Darmawan, T. Minari, Y. Xu, S.-L. Li, H. Song, M. Chan, K. Tsukagoshi, Adv. Funct. Mater. 2012, 22, 4577. [65] B. Stadlober, U. Haas, H. Gold, A. Haase, G. Jakopic, G. Leising, N. Koch, S. Rentenberger, E. Zojer, Adv. Funct. Mater. 2007, 17, 2687. [66] D. Braga, M. Ha, W. Xie, C. D. Frisbie, Appl. Phys. Lett. 2010, 97, 193311. [67] T. Ytterdal, Y. Cheng, T. A. Fjeldly, Device modeling for analog and RF CMOS circuit design, John Wiley & Sons, 2003. [68] M. I. Elmasry, IEEE Electron Device Lett. 1982, 3, 6. [69] A. Valletta, M. Rapisarda, S. Calvi, G. Fortunato, S. Jacob, V. Fischer, M. Benwadih, J. Bablet, I. Chartier, R. Coppard, L. Mariucci, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 2014, 61, 4120. [70] S. Berny, N. Blouin, A. Distler, H. J. Egelhaaf, M. Krompiec, A. Lohr, O. R. Lozman, G. E. Morse, L. Nanson, A. Pron, T. Sauermann, N. Seidler, S. Tierney, P. Tiwana, M. Wagner, H. Wilson, Adv Sci (Weinh) 2016, 3, 1500342. [71] W. Tang, J. Li, J. Zhao, W. Zhang, F. Yan, X. Guo, IEEE Electron Device Lett. 2015, 36, 950. 16 Figure 1. a) Laser sintering processing steps for the fabrication of conductive electrodes on plastic, b) optical micrograph of a single device comprising active area and contact pads (magnification: layout of the source and drain electrodes), c) picture of the final realized devices on plastic PEN substrate. 17 Figure 2. a) Process flow for the fabrication of polymer FETs on plastic with solution-based techniques, b) 3D view of the final device stack, c) transfer curve and d) output curve for a realized FET with L = 1 µm, e) drain current at Vg = 5 V for the FETs and for the realized channel lengths, f) calculated apparent charge mobility for the device with L = 1 µm. 18 Figure 3. a) Measured and calculated data for the gate-source and gate-drain capacitances of a FET with L = 1 µm versus gate-source bias voltage, b) measured transconductance of the same device versus Vgs (the linear fit is a guide to the eye), c) combined measurement of the transconductance and gate capacitance of the same FET for ft extraction (top panel: 7 V bias, bottom panel: 2 V bias), d) extracted transition frequency for the same FET versus gate-source bias voltage. 19 Figure 4. a) Input and output voltage waveforms for a rectifier based on a realized FET with L = 1 µm at an input voltage frequency of 100 kHz (top panel) and of 10 MHz (bottom panel). b) Measured and simulated output voltage of the same rectifier versus frequency at an input voltage amplitude of 5 V (inset: rectifier circuit). 20 Table 1. Measured effective charge mobility and corresponding reliability factor for the realized FETs for the different channel lengths Channel Length [µm] 1 1.5 5.5 17.5 Apparent Mobility Reliability factor at Vg = 5 V [cm2 V-1 s-1] 0.30 0.29 0.16 0.14 r 107% 109% 128% 134% Table 2. Achieved voltage-normalized transition frequency ft/Vbias for relevant works on organic, high-frequency FETs on flexible substrate. ft [MHz] Vbias [V] ft/Vbias [MHz V-1] Fabrication techniques Ref. 14.4 1.6 1.6 4.9 1.92 3.3 7 2 8 30 15 30 a) NIL: Nano-Imprint Lithography 2.06 0.80 0.20 0.16 0.13 0.11 Laser sintering, bar-coating, spin-coating, inkjet. Laser sintering, bar-coating, spin-coating, inkjet Inkjet, spin-coating Laser ablation, spin-coating, inkjet Gravure, inkjet NILa), evaporation, inkjet, gravure This work This work [16] [18] [15] [17] 21 22
1912.09749	1	1912	2019-12-20T10:46:31	CVD diamond single crystals with NV centres: a review of material synthesis and technology for quantum sensing applications	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci" ]	Diamond is a host for a wide variety of colour centres that have demonstrated outstanding optical and spin properties. Among them, the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centre is by far the most investigated owing to its superior characteristics, which promise the development of highly sophisticated quantum devices, in particular for sensing applications. Nevertheless, harnessing the potential of these centres mainly relies on the availability of high quality and purity diamond single crystals that need to be specially designed and engineered for this purpose. The plasma assisted Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) has become a key enabling technology in this field of research. Nitrogen can indeed be directly in-situ doped into a high crystalline quality diamond matrix in a controlled way allowing the production of single isolated centres or ensembles that can potentially be integrated into a device. In this paper we will provide an overview on the requirements for synthesizing quantum-grade diamond films by CVD. These include the reduction of impurities and surrounding spins that limit coherence times, the control of NV density in a wide range of concentrations as well as their spatial localization within the diamond. Enhancing the charge state and preferential orientation of the colour centres is also discussed. These improvements in material fabrication have contributed to position diamond as one of the most promising solid-state quantum system and the first industrial applications in sensing are just starting to emerge.	physics.app-ph	physics	CVD diamond single crystals with NV centres: a review of material synthesis and technology for quantum sensing applications J. Achard1, V. Jacques2 and A. Tallaire1,3 1 LSPM, Université Paris 13, Sorbonne Paris Cité, CNRS, 99, avenue JB Clément, 93430 Villetaneuse, France 2 L2C, Laboratoire Charles Coulomb, Université de Montpellier and CNRS, 34095 Montpellier, France 3 IRCP, Ecole Nationale Supérieure de Chimie de Paris, 11, rue Pierre et Marie Curie, 75005 Paris, France Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract: Diamond is a host for a wide variety of colour centres that have demonstrated outstanding optical and spin properties. Among them, the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centre is by far the most investigated owing to its superior characteristics, which promise the development of highly sophisticated quantum devices, in particular for sensing applications. Nevertheless, harnessing the potential of these centres mainly relies on the availability of high quality and purity diamond single crystals that need to be specially designed and engineered for this purpose. The plasma assisted Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) has become a key enabling technology in this field of research. Nitrogen can indeed be directly in-situ doped into a high crystalline quality diamond matrix in a controlled way allowing the production of single isolated centres or ensembles that can potentially be integrated into a device. In this paper we will provide an overview on the requirements for synthesizing "quantum-grade" diamond films by CVD. These include the reduction of impurities and surrounding spins that limit coherence times, the control of NV density in a wide range of concentrations as well as their spatial localization within the diamond. Enhancing the charge state and preferential orientation of the colour centres is also discussed. These improvements in material fabrication have contributed to position diamond as one of the most promising solid-state quantum system and the first industrial applications in sensing are just starting to emerge. 1. Introduction Solid-state quantum systems that possess long-lived spin and/or optical coherence are likely to play key roles in the development of a broad range of applications in quantum technologies (QT), from quantum networks, to information processing and quantum sensing [1]. In this context, various candidates are being considered such as superconducting circuits [2], donors in silicon [3, 4], rare-earth ions in oxide crystals [5], quantum dots [6] or defects in semiconductors [7]. Among them, colour centres in diamond are arguably one of the most promising and studied systems [8]. The growing interest that surrounds this material essentially stems from the outstanding optical and spin properties of the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) colour centre [9], which have opened up a plethora of potential breakthrough applications in QTs, including the first demonstration of kilometer-scale entanglement between solid-state spin qubits for quantum networks [10], the realization of quantum error correction protocols [11], and the development of highly sensitive quantum sensors [12- 14], which are already close to commercial products [15]. In addition, the progresses achieved in harnessing NV centres' potential for QTs has fostered the emergence of other colour centres in diamond, particularly those of group IV, that exhibit complementary properties such as SiV, GeV, SnV, or PbV [16-20]. At the heart of the success of diamond as a platform for QTs, are the fundamental science and the technologies that have allowed the fabrication of specially designed and engineered "quantum grade" synthetic crystals. Indeed, most practical demonstrations and advances in diamond-based QT leverage on material development. Both the High-Pressure High-Temperature (HPHT) and Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) techniques are currently used to fabricate diamonds with optimized properties for industrial and high-tech applications. These synthetic diamond growth technologies have witnessed tremendous improvements over the past decades leading to ever thicker, larger and higher purity crystals [21]. Gem-quality material with fancy colours or colourless and up to several carats in size have been obtained, which may be seen by some, as a threat to the stability of the natural diamond market established for jewellery [22]. One of the driving forces for innovation however, has been the field of electronics in which diamond detectors as well as power devices are regarded as technologically disrupting with outstanding figures of merit [23]. Schottky diodes and field effect transistors are foreseen to allow the operation of smaller components that can drive exceptionally high currents and sustain high voltages in harsh environments [24-26]. While these devices are still in their infancy, their development has required improvements in the synthesis of fairly thick diamond films (several hundreds of µm) with a purity down to the ppb (parts per billion) level and a surface area as large as possible to facilitate processing and integration [27]. To this end, electrical doping using boron for p-type [28] and phosphorous for n-type [29] has been explored. Nitrogen which is a deep passivating donor with an activation energy of about 1.7 eV [30] generally needs to be avoided. However, like most wide band gap semiconductors, diamond suffers from a high activation energy of its dopants and asymmetric doping with n-type being extremely difficult to achieve on a standard (100) orientation and requiring non-conventional growth conditions and substrates [31-33]. The enormous progresses made in this area during the last decades have played a crucial role in unleashing the potential of this material for QTs and have contributed to make diamond material available to this broad research community. In fact, an accurate control over the amount of residual impurities (such as nitrogen and boron), isotopic content as well as crystalline defects that have a deleterious effect on spin coherence times are key to material adoption in QTs. While HPHT can produce bulk crystals with high crystalline perfection, purity remains limited and the technique is usually not flexible enough to allow for a precise engineering of "quantum grade" layers of material. The route that is thus most widely followed is to homoepitaxially grow a thin diamond film with optimized properties by CVD on a HPHT diamond substrate possessing appropriate crystalline quality and orientation. Although the CVD growth method is relatively mature, crystalline films that can deliver optimized performance in QTs are yet not routinely produced. In this review we discuss some of the achievements and the remaining challenges that are crucial to the highly demanding field of diamond-based QTs, with a focus on quantum sensing and imaging applications with NV colour centres. In particular we give special emphasis to the material fabrication through the now well-established CVD technique and focus on in-situ doped material with NV centres for sensing devices. Issues with other colour centres (SiV, GeV etc.) might be raised but will not be discussed in great details. 2. Material requirements for NV-based quantum sensing applications In this section, we fist identify some key challenges in diamond growth to optimize the performance of quantum sensing applications based on NV colour centres, starting with a brief reminder of their main optical and spin properties. The NV colour centre consists of a substitutional nitrogen atom (N) combined with a vacancy (V) in a neighboring lattice site of the diamond crystal (figure 1(a)). This point-like defect gives rise to localized electronic states with energy levels deeply buried inside the bandgap of diamond. As a result, the NV centre can be considered as an artificial atom, mostly decoupled from the valence and conduction bands of the host material. Like many point defects in semiconductors, the NV colour centre can be found in various charge states having very different optical and spin properties [9]. Applications in QTs mostly rely on the negatively- charged state (NV-), for which an additional electron is provided by a nearby donor impurity, thus leading to a quantum system with two unpaired electrons. The NV- colour centre exhibits a perfectly photostable photoluminescence (PL) emission with a zero-phonon line at 1.945 eV (ZPL = 637 nm), and provides a spin triplet ground level, which can be initialized by optical pumping, coherently manipulated with long coherence time through microwave excitation, and readout by pure optical means (figure 1(b)) [9]. As explained below, these properties are at the heart of NV- based quantum sensing. However, the NV defect can also be stabilized in a positively-charged configuration (NV+), which is optically inactive [34, 35], and more often in a neutral form (NV0), which is characterized by a shift of the zero-phonon line to 2.15 eV (ZPL = 575 nm), and does not feature the appealing spin properties of its negatively charged counterpart [36-38]. As a result, a first requirement on diamond crystals for QT applications is to provide an environment promoting the stabilization of the NV- charge state. In the following, we focus on the spin properties of the NV- configuration, which will be simply referred to as NV for clarity purpose. A key feature of the NV colour centre is that its ground level is a spin triplet state, S = 1, whose degeneracy is lifted by spin-spin interaction into a singlet state of spin projection ms=0 and a doublet ms=±1, separated by 2.87 GHz in the absence of magnetic field (figure 1(b)). Here ms denotes the spin projection along the NV defect quantization axis, corresponding to a [111] crystal axis joining the nitrogen and the vacancy. Radiative transition selection rules associated with the spin state quantum number lead to an efficient polarization of the NV defect in the ground state spin level ms=0 by optical pumping. Furthermore, the NV defect PL intensity is significantly higher when the ms=0 state is populated. Such a spin-dependent PL response enables the detection of electron spin resonance (ESR) on a single defect by optical means. Indeed, when a single NV defect, initially prepared in the ms=0 state through optical pumping, is driven to the ms=±1 spin state by applying a resonant microwave field, a drop of the PL signal is observed, as depicted in figure 1(c). Figure 1. (a) Left panel: Optical image of a high-purity diamond crystal grown by CVD. Right panel: Atomic structure of the NV defect. (b) Simplified energy level scheme. The NV defect is polarized into the spin sublevel ms=0 by optical pumping, and exhibits a spin- dependent photoluminescence (PL) intensity. (c) Optically-detected ESR spectra recorded by monitoring the NV defect PL intensity while sweeping the frequency of the microwave (MW) field. When a magnetic field is applied (lower panel), the ESR transitions are shifted owing to Zeeman effect thus providing a quantitative measurement of the magnetic field projection BNV along the NV defect quantization axis. The first demonstration of optically-detected ESR on a single NV defect was reported in 1997, using a natural diamond sample and a confocal optical microscope operating under ambient conditions [39]. About ten years later, it was shown that these properties can be exploited for the design of a new generation of magnetometers [40-43], providing an unprecedented combination of spatial resolution and magnetic field sensitivity, even at room temperature. Here the magnetic field is evaluated within an atomic-sized detection volume by recording the Zeeman shift of the NV defect's electron spin sublevels (figure 1(c)), which is given by  = 2gB IBNVI, where gB ≈ 28 GHz/T and BNV is the magnetic field projection along the NV defect quantization axis. The sensing functionalities of NV defects were then extended to a large number of external perturbations including strain [44], electric fields [45], pressure [46] and temperature [47-49], that all have a direct impact on the ESR frequency. For all these physical quantities, the shot-noise limited sensitivity 𝜂𝑠 of a single NV spin sensor scales as [13, 50] 𝜂𝑠 ∝ 1 ∗ 𝐶𝑠√𝑅𝑇2 (1) ∗ denotes the inhomogeneous spin where 𝐶𝑠 is the contrast of the optically-detected ESR spectrum, 𝑇2 dephasing time of the NV defect which limits the ESR linewidth, and R is the number of detected photons. For a single NV defect, the ESR contrast is of the order of 𝐶𝑠 ≈ 20 %, a value fixed by the intrinsic photophysical properties of the NV defect, which can hardly be modified. The sensitivity can thus be improved either by increasing the collection efficiency of the PL signal [50] or by introducing alternative methods to improve the spin readout fidelity, such as photoelectric detection [51], spin-to-charge conversion [52] or infrared absorption readout [53]. From a material science point of view, the only parameter allowing ∗ of the NV sensor, which is mainly limited by to optimize the sensitivity is here the spin dephasing time 𝑇2 magnetic interactions with a bath of paramagnetic impurities both inside the diamond matrix and on its surface [54]. A key requirement is therefore to engineer diamond samples with an extremely low content of impurities, as close as possible to a perfectly spin-free lattice, in order to reach long spin coherence times. We note that the sensitivity can also be enhanced for the measurement of time-varying signals. Such AC sensing protocols rely on dynamical decoupling sequences of the NV spin sensor, which results in a prolongation of its coherence time to a value commonly referred to as T2, which can be orders of magnitude longer than 𝑇2 ∗ [50]. While a single NV defect provides an ultimate spatial resolution for imaging applications, the sensitivity can be simply improved by increasing the number N of sensing spins. For an ensemble of NV defects, the shot-noise limited sensitivity 𝜂𝑒then scales as 𝜂𝑒 ∝ 1 ∗ 𝐶𝑒√𝑁𝑅𝑇2 (2) A challenge in material science is thus to increase the density of NV defects while maintaining good spin coherence properties. However, the gain in sensitivity is partially compensated by a reduced contrast of spin readout. Indeed, NV defects are oriented with equal probability along the four equivalent <111> crystal directions, leading to a decreased sensitivity because only a quarter of NV spins are efficiently contributing to the detected signal, the others producing solely a background photoluminescence. In addition, luminescence from other impurities, such as the neutral NV0 defects, further impairs the signal to background ratio. The spin readout contrast then falls typically to 𝐶𝑒 ≈ 1 % for large ensembles of NV defects [50]. Mitigating this effect requires (i) to achieve preferential orientation of the NV defects during the diamond growth and (ii) to improve the conversion of NV defects in the negatively-charged state configuration. Besides providing the highest sensitivity to date [55], ensembles of NV defects can also be used for imaging applications [56, 57]. To this end, a sample of interest is commonly deposited directly on top of a diamond crystal, which contains a thin layer of NV centres near the diamond surface. The spin-dependent PL signal from the NV layer is imaged onto a CCD camera in a wide-field detection scheme, with a spatial resolution limited by diffraction (∼500 nm). In the last years, this method has found numerous groundbreaking applications in very different fields of research [12], including NMR spectroscopy [58, 59], biomagnetism [60], geoscience [61], and condensed matter physics [62-65]. Further performance improvements of this technique require to engineer thin diamond layers with a high NV density featuring long spin coherence time and preferential orientation. To summarize, current challenges in diamond growth to optimize the performance of NV-based quantum sensing include (i) (ii) (iii) Tailoring the diamond matrix so that decoherence is as limited as possible. Although important progresses have been obtained through defect engineering or isotopic purification, coherence times are still far from the theoretical T1 limit. This is particularly true when the spins of interest are located near the surface or in a diamond crystal with a high nitrogen content. Controlling NV density and charge state. Since many sensing applications rely on dense NV ensembles to improve sensitivity, controlling the ratio between NVs and other N-containing defects is crucial. In addition, the close environment of the defect has to favour the occurrence of the negative charge state with respect to the neutral one. Spatially localizing NV centres. The precise positioning of single or ensemble of NV centres both in-depth and in-plane is of importance for incorporating them into cavities or nanostructures, or for improving the performances of wide-field imaging with NV ensembles. (iv) Controlling NV orientation. Promoting preferential orientation is desirable to limit background noise level, increase sensitivity and simplify device operation. These different aspects about the material fabrication will be discussed hereafter. 3. The synthesis of "quantum grade" diamond films and crystals 3.1. HPHT grown diamonds HPHT is well established to produce bulk single crystals with up to a few millimetre thick and millimetre square size that are available commercially in particular for cutting tools applications. This technique typically uses a bath of melted transition metals (such as Co, Fe, Ni, Cr, Mn etc.) in which carbon (in general diamond powder or graphite) is dissolved and re-precipitated on the facet of a small seed in a region of slightly lower temperature (20 to 50 °C less) [66]. This temperature gradient approach involves pressures and temperatures above 5 GPa and 1300 °C respectively. Different heavy set-ups exist that differ from the way the pressure is applied to the cell, such as uniaxial compression with belt and toroid systems, or multi-anvil systems (so- called bars and cubic presses) [67]. This equipment is mostly operated by industrial players (Element Six, General Electrics, Sumitomo, New Diamond Technology etc.) and are essentially destined to mechanical applications for which requirements on purity and quality are moderate. Under adapted and stable conditions though, large crystals can be produced with potentially extremely low extended defect content. For instance inclusion-free single sector diamonds with stacking faults and dislocation content below a few hundred per cm² have been demonstrated [68, 69]. However the precise recipes developed to reach this degree of perfection are usually a well-kept industrial secret, while the associated costs can be tremendously high (up to several k€ for a 500 µm thin slab). In contrast, standard HPHT crystals typically contain dislocation densities of the order of 104-105 cm-2 and visible growth sectoring [70], but their cost is limited to a few hundreds of euros depending on size, orientation and polishing. Although bulk crystals with low dislocation density can be grown by HPHT, the technique is not well adapted to produce films with a high purity or a controlled doping as required by quantum applications. Indeed, the starting powdered materials and the high pressures needed promote incorporation of impurities that may come from surface contaminations or are trapped in porosity. Standard HPHT diamonds are usually labelled as type Ib due to the presence of a large amount of non-intentionally doped nitrogen in them (typically 10-300 ppm) that lead to a yellowish colouration and obvious growth sectoring (see figure 2(a)) [71]. Nitrogen uptake depends on the solvent-catalyst used and its solubility in them. While quantum sensing requires incorporation of NV centres, it should be emphasized that nitrogen content in HPHT crystals is not necessarily in the form needed for an optimized sensor. A significant fraction of N is for example present as substitutional (Ns), known as P1 centre. Aggregated forms also exist due to nitrogen mobility being activated under high pressures and temperatures. The N-V-N or H3 centre is for example frequently created and leads to emission at 503 nm in PL. Other aggregated forms are less prevalent but commonly found like A-centres (2 neighbouring Ns) or B-centres (N4V) [71]. Their concentration can be of the order of several ppm depending on the growth conditions or treatment that they have underwent. The addition of getters (Ti, Zr, Al etc.) can reduce the amount of incorporated nitrogen by preferentially associating and precipitating it as a nitride allowing fabrication of type IIa colourless diamond crystals by HPHT (see figure 2(b)) [72]. This material leads to lower background PL and narrower diamond Raman peaks as illustrated in figure 2(c). However in general, N content cannot be suppressed completely and remains of the order of 0.1 ppm. Growth rates under such low nitrogen conditions are also strongly reduced which increases the overall cost of the HPHT diamonds [69]. Figure 2. (a) Optical and PL images of a type Ib HPHT substrate. (b) Optical and PL images of a type IIa HPHT substrate. (c) Raman/PL spectra of type Ib and IIa HPHT substrates obtained with an excitation line at 473 nm. The inset shows the linewidth of the diamond Raman peak. The type IIa diamond was provided by New Diamond Technology (NDT). Other impurities may also be incorporated in significant amounts including solvents from the melted baths (Ni and Co) or element contaminations (B, Si, Ge) which can lead to the appearance of specific defects or colouring [73]. Around 50 ppm of boron have been measured in some of the purest type IIa diamonds [74]. Boron is known to stabilize the neutral charge state of NV centres and is usually not desirable (see part 4.4). Impurity incorporation dependence on crystal orientation is also an important issue that is associated with variations in colouring and/or luminescence under UV light (figure 2(a)). Incorporation efficiency in (111) growth sectors is usually 2-3 times higher than in (100) and (110) sectors [75]. Isotopic purification of HPHT diamonds to change the 12C/13C ratio has been achieved using pyrolytic carbon powder [76] but it remains relatively difficult and uncommon due to the high cost of the precursors and low flexibility of the technique. While residual impurities are difficult to avoid with this synthesis process, intentional additions of certain metals to the bath/catalyst mixture can be explored to create specific colour centres. For example, SiV, GeV or SnV centres which are also interesting systems for QTs have been obtained [77, 78]. This is an important advantage of the HPHT approach because such elements cannot always be easily brought in through the vapour phase or incorporated using the CVD production technique due to limited solubility. The ability to control crystal morphologies through tuning of the growth temperature and the solvent has been highlighted and opens the way to obtaining various crystal habits from cubic to octahedral. Control of the morphology opens the way to the fabrication of larger plates with specific orientations that can be extracted from such stones [79]. In particular [111]-oriented diamonds can be cleaved from octahedral shape crystals and are particularly suited as substrates for CVD overgrowth with oriented NV centres (as will be discussed in part 6) [80]. Bulk crystals can thus be obtained through the HPHT technique with a high crystalline perfection but limited purity. Nevertheless NV ensembles in type Ib HPHT diamonds have been studied and exploited for QT demonstrations. Some examples include magnetometry [55], MW photon storage [81], coupling to superconducting resonators [82], quantum memories [83], hyperpolarisation of 13C [84] or data storage [85]. Although one can benefit from a bulk material that is easily available, the nitrogen density in the form of substitutional defects is usually a limiting factor and reduces the coherence times (T2) to typically 1-2 µs only at room temperature [86]. Nevertheless, by reducing the spin bath surrounding NV centres through isotopic purification and limited nitrogen doping, as well as irradiating the crystal to convert Ns into NV, T2 can be extended to several tens of µs [81]. In general electron irradiation followed by annealing has become a rather standard treatment to improve the performance of such HPHT crystals (see part 4.1). Although some attempts have been made to explore bulk HPHT diamonds crystals in the field of quantum sensing, this material in general fails to provide the purity and the flexibility of fabrication that is required for highly efficient devices. The most common approach thus relies on using HPHT crystals as the starting substrates onto which films with the desired properties are overgrown by CVD. 3.2. CVD grown diamonds Microwave plasma assisted CVD has become a key technology showing great potential to produce engineered films with the desired doping, isotopic purity and dimensions. The use of CVD-grown diamond films and crystals is relatively wide-spread in QTs although their availability remains scarce. Unlike HPHT, the CVD technique mostly involves academic research groups while commercial availability of high purity plates is limited to a few industrial companies only (Element Six, Diamond Materials, IIa Technologies etc.). A large market for CVD diamond plates is yet to be found. The fabrication of high-quality thick crystals is also technologically challenging with difficult scaling-up which contributes to increase the fabrication costs. Nowadays, HPHT still remains dominant when it comes to producing bulk synthetic diamonds while CVD is mostly focused on producing thinner layers. Although the size and thickness of the produced crystals is not such a limiting factor for QTs, diamonds may need to be thick enough to be processed and properly oriented or separated from their substrate. The CVD technique operates at low pressures (10-300 mbar), under conditions at which graphite should be the thermodynamically stable phase [87-89]. It involves kinetically stabilizing diamond through the production of atomic hydrogen within a high temperature plasma media that preferentially etches away weak sp2 bounds, allowing the addition of carbon to the diamond lattice of the substrate. H2 and CH4 are used in a typical proportion of 95-99 % to 5-1 % respectively. Addition of O2 in a small amount (< 2%) is sometimes used in order to increase the etching effect and limit impurities incorporation or non-epitaxial defects formation [90, 91]. In general, activation of the gas is performed through applying a 2.45 GHz MW field to a resonant cavity reactor (figure 3(a)) [92, 93]. Operation under higher pressures (> 100 mbar) and microwave powers (> 2 kW) leads to the formation of a localized plasma region in the core of which temperatures may reach up to 3000 K which is favourable to produce precursors for growth [94]. Indeed, thermal dissociation of the molecules into a variety of atomic and radical species is highly pronounced and may be of up to several tens of percent [95]. Growth is carried out at a temperature in the range 700-1100°C on a diamond seed through either cooling or heating the substrate holder depending on the power density applied. Several providers commercialize MW plasma assisted systems with varying characteristics (Cornes Technologies (Seki systems), Plassys, iplas, optosystems etc.) but a large number of research groups have developed their own equipment. The main differences in those systems are essentially in the way the MW radiation is coupled to the resonant cavity (electromagnetic modes), the location of dielectric windows as well as the design of the holder (translatable, rotatable, cooled or heated). High-power operating reactors are preferred for achieving high growth rates and low defect bulk diamond crystals. However the low-power regime may be advantageous for ensuring nm-scale control over the thickness of the layers and a precise positioning of dopants or colour centres (see part 5.1). With a hetero-substrate (like a silicon wafer) a polycrystalline film in which grain size directly depends on thickness through a columnar growth mode is generally obtained. Under certain growth conditions, films may exhibit a particular texture or preferential orientation [96]. The presence of grain boundaries is however deleterious to obtaining long coherence times and low background luminescence. Polycrystalline diamonds are usually not preferred for sensing applications. Interesting properties for single NVs have however locally been found within the larger grains of polycrystalline films [44, 97]. They also offer the advantage of providing a large and flexible platform for processing them into photonic crystals and resonators that would be highly desirable for QTs [98]. Figure 3. (a) Microwave Plasma Assisted CVD system allowing the growth of diamond. The inset shows a zoom into the plasma region in which a diamond is positioned for growth. (b) High purity thick CVD diamond layer grown on a yellow HPHT diamond substrate and (c) freestanding CVD diamond film obtained after removing the HPHT substrate by laser cutting and polishing. (d) PL image of a high purity thick freestanding CVD diamond film showing only very weak blue luminescence in the corners corresponding to the presence of stress. (e) PL image of a N2 doped thick freestanding CVD diamond film showing orange luminescence corresponding to the presence of both NV0 and NV- colour centres. Heteroepitaxial growth on specially developed templates that include a thin monocrystalline iridium layer deposited on an oxide thin film on silicon or a bulk crystal (Yttria stabilized Zr02, a-plane Al2O3 or SrTiO3) is another possible approach that promises wafer-scale deposition area [99-101]. In recent years, some important efforts in material development have been devoted to obtaining higher quality and larger films with new venture companies starting to commercialize them (Audiatech, Namiki etc.). The complex steps that lead to oriented diamond growth include deposition of the epitaxial Ir films on an appropriate substrate, the biased enhanced nucleation of diamond domains on them, thickening of the film and limitation of dislocation density through patterning of the surface [102]. In general dislocation densities still remain high even in thick films (> 107 cm-²) [103] and impurities such as silicon are hard to avoid. Nevertheless a recent assessment of state-of-the-art films produced through this approach have demonstrated coherence times of 5 µs supporting the idea that they may provide a useful larger platform for future applications in QTs providing material quality and availability are improved [104]. Homoepitaxial growth onto a diamond seed (generally a type Ib HPHT substrate) is the preferred fabrication route for obtaining high quality and purity diamond films that are suitable for QTs (figure 3(b) and 3(c)). Although CVD is relatively simple in its operating principle, obtaining layers with a given defect concentration and the desired thickness has animated a large number of research activities through the past decades, in particular within the earlier and demanding context of power electronics. Substrate selection and preparation plays an important role in the epitaxial overgrowth and adapted polishing or etching of the surface prior to growth helps limiting the propagation of defects from the interface [105]. Maintaining constant growth conditions, especially temperature, during long periods of time is also a limiting factor when thicker layers are desired. The development of specific substrate holders that include cooling with gas mixtures or vertical translation may be needed [106-108]. The presence of uncontrolled amounts of N2 or O2 from reactor leaks or impure feed gases have important consequences and can induce the formation of polycrystalline defects that would quickly ruin the entire growth run [87, 94, 109, 110]. To this end, care must be taken to frequently check for potential leakage sources and to use dedicated purifying systems especially for hydrogen. When a good control of gas environment is successfully achieved, single crystal diamond plates with good purity or intentionally doped with a controlled nitrogen amount can be prepared (see figure 3(d) and 3(e)). Other potential contamination sources may be released by the constitutive materials of the reactor themselves (metal walls, quartz windows, molybdenum holders etc.) such as boron, silicon or nitrogen. Besides choosing adapted materials for the reactor furniture, the design should ensure that internal parts are appropriately cooled down or positioned far away from the high temperature plasma media. The appearance of SiV emission in CVD diamonds is nevertheless very common and is even used as a criteria for establishing diamond's synthetic origin in gemmology [111]. Finally it should be noted that hydrogen, one of the main elements involved in the growth process is usually overlooked although it is one of the main impurities in CVD-grown crystals. Hydrogen-vacancy defects known as H1 centres are paramagnetic and show-up in EPR together with the nitrogen-vacancy-hydrogen (NVH) for example [112, 113]. The ability to prepare isotopically enriched layers is also a particularly useful asset of CVD grown diamond films. Indeed growth from methane using natural isotopic carbon ratio leads to the presence of 1.1 % of 13C in the films which is a non-zero nuclear spin element. Coupling of the NV spins to nearby 13C atoms is the main source of decoherence for films with a low NV amount (< 0.1 ppm) [54, 114]. Reducing the amount of 13C is relatively straightforward by substituting the conventional methane source with an enriched 12C methane cylinder. By doing so, T2 times have been successfully extended from a typical value of 0.5 ms up to a record of 2.4 ms [115]. Nevertheless the cost of such sources is several orders of magnitude higher than a standard methane cylinder. Moreover the specifications in terms of N2 or CO2 background content are usually much higher than high-purity grade methane and may require additional purification steps with dedicated purifier cartridges. On the other hand, intentional addition of 13C in CVD-grown films can be achieved to deviate from the natural isotopic ratio. Particular schemes have been proposed that explore coupling of a NV spin to a nearby long-lived nuclear spin to further extend quantum storage times [116]. Dynamic nuclear polarization may also be useful to magnetic resonance spectroscopy and imaging applications [117]. In general, one of the main advantages of the CVD growth approach for making "quantum grade" diamonds is the ability to engineer stacked layers of different doping and composition in a dynamic and very flexible way. Indeed the gas phase environment can be controlled to an extremely high level while changing from one composition to another can be done with abrupt interfaces providing residence time of gas species are taken into account (see part 5.1). CVD diamond fabrication of specially designed bulk crystals or thin films has thus become a cornerstone of the developments that the quantum technologies based on this material system have witnessed. 4. Creating colour centres with good coherence properties 4.1. Implanting colour centres in high purity CVD diamonds While the CVD technique allows the fabrication of isotopically enriched diamond films with extreme purity, a varying amount of colour centres need to be incorporated within this matrix to provide the sensing functionality. A widely followed approach consists of locally implanting nitrogen ions (N+) or a molecule +, CN+ etc.) in "electronic grade" (i.e. high-purity and non-luminescent) CVD diamonds. containing nitrogen (N2 In general 3 steps are required: (i) introducing impurities, (ii) creating vacancies (that may be co-implanted together with the impurity or afterwards), (iii) annealing to heal defects and diffuse vacancies so that the complex defect can be formed. The present paper does not intend to give a detailed review of the optimization of implanted colour centres in diamond and readers are advised to refer to the following articles [118, 119], however some of the main trends are presented below. Regarding the first step, the ions to be implanted can be accelerated in a wide range of energies from typically 2 keV to 20 MeV leading to implantation depths of 3 nm to about 5 µm respectively. This obviously requires rather different implantation set-ups from small table-top sources for low energies to large tandem accelerators to reach the MeV regime. It allows creating specific luminescent patterns within the diamond substrate as illustrated in figure 4(a). It should be noted that the ion energy not only influences the penetration depth of the ions but also the creation yield of NV centres with respect to each N atom entering the diamond lattice [120]. In fact, the higher the energy, the higher the number of vacancies that are co- created leading to higher yields. Typically, values range from 0.1 % at 2 keV up to about 45 % at 18 MeV. However at high acceleration energies, spatially positioning the implanted ions with accuracy becomes difficult due to the statistic distribution of collisions with atoms in the lattice that leads to a lateral and depth spread called straggling. Getting a spatial accuracy of less than 5 nm for example requires that ions are accelerated to an energy below 10 keV which limits penetration to 10 nm only (i.e. to near-surface NV centres). This shows that a trade-off exists between high-yield high-depth NVs and low-yield low-depth but highly localized NVs, depending on the energy of the incoming ions [121]. To go beyond those limits, strategies have been developed to increase the positioning accuracy by implantation through a pierced AFM tip [122], mica channels or opened PMMA masks [123]. An additional advantage of the implantation technique relies on its ability to generate defects from elements that cannot be easily grown-in directly by CVD due to too high steric hindrance, low stability or difficulty in bringing them through the gas phase. Besides, co-implantation with other elements brings additional flexibility in the generation of complex defects. Lühmann et al. have for example studied a wide variety of colour centres that can be created through implantation of elements as varied as Mg, Ca, F, O etc. in a matrix that already contains other implanted impurities of phosphorous or boron [124]. This obviously leads to an exhaustive variety of combinations and adds additional complexity to this approach in determining the most relevant colour centre for a given application. Control of the charge state of created vacancies has been accomplished by implanting nitrogen into n-type doped diamond rather than in a standard intrinsic crystal. In this way, the negative charge state of the vacancies is promoted which reduces their clustering and thus increases the probability that they associate to a single nitrogen atom to form a NV centre. Record creation yields of about 75 % have been reported in sulphur doped diamonds [125]. Introducing additional vacancies into the diamond crystal can also be explored in order to boost the NV/Ns ratio (creation yield). Such irradiations are accompanied by the creation of the GR1 luminescent defect (neutral vacancies) which intensity depends on the dose, the energy and the type of ions that are used (figure 4(b)). Helium ions accelerated to a few keV provide for example a way to locally create vacancies at a controlled depth of a few tens of nm and thus the ability to generate so called delta-profiles [126]. He+ ion beams can also be focused down to a small size to create patterns [127]. However, evidence exist of the creation of specific colour centres related to the implantation of helium atoms within the lattice. The optical properties of such Helium-Vacancy (He-V) centres have recently been studied [128]. Other irradiations using protons or electrons present the advantage of having a lower mass as compared to helium. Their stopping range is much longer which allows for a more uniform creation of vacancies through the volume of the sample. Electron irradiation at several MeV and doses of the order to 1017-1019 cm-2 has become a standard treatment to Ib HPHT diamonds in order to increase NV density [129]. Local irradiation at lower energies (around 200 keV) has also proved successful using the electron beam of a Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM) [130]. At this energy the penetration depth can be estimated to about 140 µm. Vacancy creation efficiency is also more limited with a minimum energy for vacancies creation of about 145 keV. Nevertheless this technique provides a way to generate local NV patterns [131, 132]. An alternative approach is the creation of vacancies through ultrafast (fs) laser irradiation pulses. Single NV centres can thus be written locally into arrays with a positioning accuracy of about 200 nm and coherence times of several hundreds of µs equivalent to naturally occurring NVs [133, 134]. Figure 4. PL image of a high purity freestanding CVD diamond film after localized nitrogen ion implantation which leads to the appearance of orange/red spots corresponding to NV0 and NV- colour centres (Collaboration University of Leipzig). (b) Evolution of vacancies/ion number and GR1 fluorescence as a function of implanted ion mass. (c) Evolution of the fluorescence of defects created by implantation as a function of annealing temperature. (b) and (c) are adapted from Lühmann et al [124]. Annealing ion implanted diamonds is a key ingredient to increase NV density and improve their coherence properties. This step allows vacancies to diffuse and defects to heal so that highly coherent NV centres are formed successfully following irradiation. Since vacancies in diamond are mobile above 700 °C, typical annealing temperatures after irradiation are in the range 800-1000 °C with the treatment carried out for a few hours (1-10 h). This is illustrated in figure 4(c) where the number of NVs is seen to increase with temperature together with a decrease of GR1. Annealing simultaneously when doing the ion implantation provides a way to reduce collateral damage and preferentially associate the vacancies with a nearby N rather than forming clusters [135]. Annealing at too high a temperature (> 1200°C) is likely to lead to the formation of vacancy clusters or to the thermal dissociation of NVs which should be avoided. Nitrogen atoms can also become mobile at temperatures of the order of 1600 °C possibly forming complex clusters like H3 (N-V-N) as shown in figure 4(c). In general T2 times of implanted and annealed NVs remain below those of naturally created ones by 1-2 orders of magnitude (typically 1-10 µs) due to the presence of other defects and residual damage that cannot be completely annealed out. Optimized annealing treatments at higher temperatures [136, 137] or composed of successive steps with various annealing temperatures and durations have been proposed to obtain NV coherence times close to those of native NVs [138]. Nevertheless there probably does not exist a universal efficient annealing step, the optimized procedure strongly depending on the initial quality of the diamond as well as the starting NV density. 4.2. In situ doping of colour centres While ex-situ creation of colour centres is a flexible approach with accurate positioning ability, it generally does not allow obtaining defects with as good coherent properties as naturally occurring ones from in-situ doping. Intentional doping during CVD growth can indeed be achieved by injecting into the plasma a precursor gas containing the element to be doped. N2 is the most widely used dopant for NV doping. This molecule has a very strong bond energy (9.8 eV) which requires high plasma power densities to efficiently dissociate it. Nitrogen doping into the tight diamond lattice is also not energetically favourable. Both those issues lead to low doping efficiencies of about 10-5 to 10-3 [139, 140]. When low plasma power densities are used (< 1 kW MW power), several % of N2 are usually required to reach Ns concentrations of the order of 0.1 ppm [141, 142]. An additional limitation is that only a small fraction of the total nitrogen will be incorporated as a complex associated to a vacancy, with the main part being substitutional to a single carbon atom (Ns). A typical yield (NV/Ntotal) for untreated as-grown CVD diamonds is of the order 1/300 or below [143]. Therefore it should be highlighted that the creation yield for in situ doping is similar to that obtained for nitrogen implanted at medium energies. This is a particularly limiting factor since not only the amount of NV centres to be used for sensing will be limited but the large proportion of nitrogen, a paramagnetic impurity, will induce decoherence especially for the highest doping levels [114]. In addition a small part of the total nitrogen in the CVD-grown diamond, more or less the same proportion as that of NVs may occur in the form of NVH complex [144]. These defects are fairly common in CVD diamonds grown under high nitrogen additions since hydrogen is one of the main ingredients for CVD growth. They can be detected in their negative form as a line in EPR and are also visible as a sharp absorption at 3123 cm-1 in FTIR in their neutral charge state [145, 146] (figure 6(c)). While hydrogen impurities are likely to passivate part of the NV centres and produce additional magnetic noise, these complexes cannot be easily annealed out even at very high temperatures. It would be desirable to improve the NV yield by changing the growth conditions such as substrate orientation, pressure and MW power, gas phase composition (methane, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen). However no systematic study exists so far on the influence of growth conditions on the NV creation yield most likely due to the difficulty in accurately measuring the concentration of those defects in thin diamond films. While N2 is the most frequently used dopant, other molecules have been shown to lead to improved NV doping efficiency and photostability. For instance, N2O which has a much lower dissociation energy is also available as a high-purity gas. While high-density NV ensembles (around 10 ppb) created through addition of N2 are subject to blinking and charge state instability especially under high laser pumping power (figure 5(a- c)), those formed from N2O are much more stable (figure 5(d-f)) [147]. This is possibly related to the presence of a low amount of oxygen near the growing surface due to N2O dissociation in the plasma that etches away any defects that act as traps for charge carriers [148]. However the use of other dopant sources is not very widespread and would require more dedicated studies Figure 5. (a) and (b) PL images of a CVD diamond film grown with 100 ppm of N2 in the gas phase obtained with a confocal scanning microscope (laser, 532 nm), allowing estimating the NV- density to 10 ppb and showing the poor photostability under high laser power. (c) ODMR spectra obtained under a magnetic field of 3 mT and where the characteristic hyperfine splitting is observed with a FWHM of 0.58 MHz. (d) and (e) PL images on a CVD diamond sample grown with 500 ppm of N2O in the gas phase allowing estimating the NV- density to 15 ppb and showing improved photostability even under high laser power. (f) ODMR spectra obtained under a magnetic field of 3 mT showing a similar hyperfine splitting of 0.9 MHz. Besides NV, other colour centres can be introduced in-situ in CVD-grown diamonds. However as compared to the HPHT process or to ex-situ implantation, the introduction of a wide variety of impurities is relatively limited. SiV and GeV centres have been obtained through addition of a varying amount of silane or germane gases (SiH4 and GeH4) [149, 150]. For those elements though, doping using a solid-state source (like a small piece of Si or SiC placed near the growing diamond) is usually the preferred approach due to its simplicity and non-toxicity [151, 152]. Dopants that modify the Fermi level of the semi-conducting diamond crystal such as phosphorous (n-type) or boron (p-type) can also be advantageously used to tune the charge state of the colour centres (see part 4.4). This is generally achieved through additions of TBP (tri-butyl phosphine), TMB (tri-methyl boron) or B2H6 (diborane) [153]. Although it is not directly involved in the creation of specific colour centres, the addition of O2 during growth is also sometimes explored to improve the crystalline quality of the films thereby potentially improving the coherent properties of in situ doped NV centres [154]. Controlling colour centres density 4.3. By in-situ doping, NVs can be created in a wide range of doping levels from isolated single centres to ensembles of several 10's of ppb without any post-treatment simply by tuning the added gas concentration during growth. For some nanoscale sensing applications, or for quantum memories [155] the manipulation of single NVs with long coherence times is required. Extremely low amounts of NVs (or even more, no NV at all) are however particularly difficult to achieve and require carefully purified gas sources and leak-tight reactor chambers. While high-purity "electronic grade" commercial diamonds (specified as Ns < 5 ppb) do not normally display luminescence originating from NVs, it has been shown that after annealing at high temperature (1600 °C for 4 h), vacancies diffuse and are able to associate to nitrogen [124]. This leads to up to 1 NV/µm² and indicates that even carefully prepared CVD diamond films may still contain a low but non- negligible residual background of nitrogen. The creation of isolated NVs (0.1-1 ppb) relies on low additions of N2 during growth in general diluted in hydrogen (around 0.1-10 ppm) and thus requires a precise control of the gas phase composition to achieve the desired concentration [139]. Doping efficiency also strongly depends on growth parameters such as power density, temperature and substrate orientation and can thus vary on different set-ups. On the other hand, high density NV ensembles are desirable for many quantum sensing schemes [156] since the sensitivity of a given sensor will depend on the square root of the number of sensing spins [13] (see part 2, eq. 2). However obtaining very high NV concentrations (> 100 ppb) is problematical by direct CVD growth since large additions of N2, above typically 250 ppm under high power density conditions, is accompanied by a degradation of the surface morphology [157] particularly at the edges of the crystal [158], even leading to a total loss of epitaxy for the highest levels. Nitrogen solubility is also limited in CVD and cannot allow reaching as high levels as those typically reached in type Ib HPHT diamonds (a few tens or hundreds of ppm). Under moderate nitrogen doping levels though, CVD diamonds often exhibit a brown colour indicative of the presence of vacancy clusters or dislocations as shown in figure 6(a) [159]. This is due to large absorption features at 510, 360 and 270 nm, the latter being directly correlated with Ns (figure 6(d)). Very high brightness diamond films can be obtained by such doping (figure 6(b)). For thick crystals, Ns concentration can be directly evaluated from the intensity of the 1344 cm-1 feature in FTIR as shown in figure 6(c) [160]. It has been proposed that addition of a low amount of oxygen during growth together with nitrogen helps limiting the formation of such defects and the appearance of the brown colour [91]. Highly N- doped CVD diamonds nevertheless contain a large amount of residual defects that strongly reduce their optical properties. HPHT or LPHT post-treatments (> 1500 °C) are often required to improve their colour due to a partial rearrangement or annihilation of point defects [161]. Figure 6. (a) Optical images of thick freestanding CVD diamond samples grown with 20 ppm, 40 ppm and 100 ppm of N2 in the gas phase from left to right, ranging from colourless to dark brown. (b) Corresponding Raman and PL spectra performed on these samples showing high emission from NV0 and NV- luminescence at 575 nm and 637 nm respectively. (c) FTIR spectrum carried out on a thick + and freestanding CVD diamond sample grown with 500 ppm of N2O in the gas phase allowing to clearly identify and quantify NS NVH0 defects. (d) UV-Visible absorption spectrum of a high purity CVD diamond plate and a CVD diamond plate grown with 500 ppm of N2O in the gas phase. Absorption at 270 nm is due to Ns while other broad absorption bands are related to vacancy clusters. 0, NS Besides the difficulty in growing CVD crystals in the presence of a high concentration of nitrogen in the gas phase, an additional issue comes from the fact that NVs represent only a small fraction of the total incorporated N content (see part 4.2). The contribution of 14N nuclear spin bath on NV spin's dephasing starts to overcome that of natural isotopic 13C for concentrations above 0.1 ppm. At 10 ppm total nitrogen, T2 times drop to about 10 µs [50]. Therefore this leads to a trade-off between high NV density and long coherence times. In order to circumvent this, partial conversion of Ns into NVs can be obtained through an appropriate irradiation using high energy electrons [55] or He+ ions (see part 4.1). Using the later, Kleinsasser et al. [162] achieved NV- densities of the order of 1 ppm which is only 10 fold lower than the highest densities reported in irradiated Ib HPHT diamonds [163] while ESR linewidths remained narrow (200 kHz). N to NV conversion rates of the order of 10-20 % are possible through an appropriate irradiation [164]. In this case dipolar interactions between proximal NV centres might dominate the dephasing rather than NV to N coupling. Controlling NVs charge state 4.4. The NV centre possesses neutral and negative charge states with zero phonon line emissions at 575 and 637 nm respectively (see part 2). Both are usually present in nitrogen-doped single crystal diamonds. Quantum sensors exploit the optical properties of the negatively charged NV centres (spin S = 1) and therefore the neutrally charged centres with spin S = ½ are undesirable. They may lead to overlapping of the PL emission due to broad phonon side bands as well as magnetic noise that degrades spin coherence times. It is generally admitted that NV centres acquire their negative charge from nearby electron donors. One obvious candidate for this charge transfer is the substitutional nitrogen that represents a large fraction of the total nitrogen content in non-irradiated nitrogen-doped HPHT and CVD diamonds [145]. For this reason, under a low power excitation in the range 450-610 nm to limit photo-ionization, the steady-state NV- centre population is typically about 75 % of the total NV amount [165]. However, this value can vary depending on the nitrogen doping level in the diamond crystal. Type Ib HPHT diamonds with high nitrogen content (several tens of ppm) may have a higher proportion of NV- [166, 167]. For example, in the PL spectra of figure 7(a) with an excitation at 532 nm, NV0 emission is almost undetectable as compared to that from NV- due to the large amount of nitrogen (circa 100 ppm) in this electron irradiated type Ib crystal. To the contrary, when too high a proportion of Ns are converted to NVs by irradiation, there may not be a sufficient amount of donors close enough to NVs to provide the necessary electron. In this case, emission from NV- tends to saturate while that from NV0 increases, which occurs above a certain irradiation dose [168]. Promoting NV's negative charge state can also be achieved with shallower electron donors than nitrogen such as phosphorous or sulphur [125, 169]. Boron which is an acceptor impurity produces an opposite effect by favouring the neutral charge state. Groot-Berning et al. have clearly shown the effect of co-doping in implanted diamond films [170] as illustrated in figure 7(b). Fermi level tuning can also be achieved with in- situ doped CVD diamond films [171] allowing a fine control over NV's charge state. Intentional doping of diamond by phosphorous during CVD growth is however particularly challenging due to the low doping efficiency of this element into the diamond while n-type conductivity is limited by compensating defects and high activation energy (0.6 eV) [172]. Nevertheless, electrical control over NV's charge state (and emission) has been shown with p-i-n junctions and switching from NV- to NV0 has been obtained by applying a strong bias [173]. Regarding shallow NVs, their charge state also strongly depends on the chemical species present at the diamond's surface (typically hydrogen or oxygen termination, see figure 7(b) and 7(c)). Since hydrogen termination of diamond films induces a 2D hole gas by a surface transfer doping mechanism [174], this termination is not favourable to negatively charged NVs. On the contrary, oxidative etching of the diamond by heating at temperatures around 450 °C in an O2 atmosphere leaves the surface oxygen-terminated and promotes NV- [175]. Active tuning of the band bending and thus of NV's charge state, through an electrolytic gate electrode [36] or using a Schottky metal contact [176] have been demonstrated leading to on-demand switching of the PL emission. In general, it should be noted that O-terminated diamond surfaces are preferred since they provide a more chemically stable environment for NV- centres. This termination is easily obtained through either acidic treatment (typically by dipping in boiling H2SO4/HNO3 mixtures), by exposure to a soft microwave oxygen plasma or UV-ozone lamp. Besides those effects intrinsic to the diamond environment and doping, the magnitude of NV0 and NV- emission in PL also depends on the excitation wavelength of the laser due to different absorption cross- sections [167]. Figure 7(a) shows that the NV0/NV- ratio is strongly affected by changing the laser from 532 nm to 473 nm for a diamond irradiated with an electron dose of 1.5x1019 cm-2. It has indeed been shown that excitation in the blue is more favourable to NV0. There is near equal excitation at 514 nm and in this case, the strengths of the zero-phonon lines is a good indicator of the relative concentrations of the two NV charge states [167]. In order to more precisely measure the charge state ratio, decomposing the PL spectrum obtained with a 532 nm excitation has also been proposed as a more straightforward approach [177]. NV- ionization into NV0 may occur depending on the laser power used and the excitation wavelength. This process leads to blinking issues and limits the maximum spin polarization accessible. Photon energies higher than 2.6 eV are required for direct ionization [165]. However, ionization may proceed through a 2- photon absorption process using a green laser [178]. The first photon induces a transition to the excited state of the defect while the second photon excites the electron to the conduction band of the diamond. This is accompanied by the creation of a photocurrent which can be usefully exploited to electrically detect the spin- state of the NV centre in the so-called PDMR scheme (Photocurrent Detection of Magnetic Resonance) [51, 179]. In a similar way, electron induced ionization of NV centres explains that only emission from the neutral charge state of the defect is detectable in cathodoluminescence [180]. In general the reverse process (recombination) that turns NV- back into NV0 takes place with a typical time of 500 µs [165] and is promoted by red excitation. Multicolour illumination with a near-Infrared laser increases the NV- steady-state population with respect to NV0 and strongly improves the spin read-out fidelity [181]. In some cases though, long term ionization can occur with the recombination being inhibited due to the presence of charge traps in the crystal that prevent an efficient diffusion of carriers [182]. Based on a multicolour excitation, optical patterning of the PL on the diamond's surface is then possible allowing foreseeing storage applications [85]. PL extinction for a long period of time is for example illustrated in figure 5(b) under high power green laser [147]. Figure 7. (a) PL emission of a type Ib HPHT diamond that has been irradiated by a 1 MeV electron beam at various doses as indicated in the legend (Collaboration ICR, Marseille). Excitation with a 473 or 532 nm laser was carried out. (b) and (c) PL showing the effect of co-doping with boron or phosphorous on the charge state of NV centres for both H-terminated or O-terminated (100) diamond surfaces. (Adapted from ref [170]) 5. Controlling the spatial localisation of NV centres Beyond the production of NV-doped diamond layers with good coherence time and stability, for most applications, spatial localization of NV- defects in the diamond host material is necessary. For instance, in wide-field imaging magnetometry, nanometre-thin layers highly doped with NV- defects should be located at or slightly below the surface [60, 183] in order to precisely control the distance between the interacting spins and the sample to be measured. Such thin layers are usually called "delta-doped" in analogy with works carried out on electronic doping of semiconductors that achieves high mobility channels with high dopant concentration through such a spatial confinement [184, 185]. The main approach to introduce localized nitrogen atoms into diamond in order to generate NV- defects is ex-situ ion-beam nitrogen implantation followed by annealing which allows for a spatial control of the nitrogen atom's position ultimately limited by ion channelling and straggling effects [121] (see part 4.1.). For nitrogen atoms implanted near the diamond surface with a few keV energy, the depth resolution is typically in the range of few nanometres [183, 186]. However, unwanted paramagnetic defects presumably created during the implantation process reduce the spin coherence time of implanted NV- defects [183], even if significant improvements can be achieved with optimized irradiation and annealing procedures [187, 188]. For these reasons, directly grown-in NV centres obtained by intentionally adding a nitrogen precursor to the gas phase during diamond growth by CVD [139, 189] is advantageous especially if spatial positioning is achieved. This approach is discussed here. 500550600650700NV-4x1018.cm-27x1018.cm-21x1019.cm-21.5x1019.cm-2 Ib @532nm Ib @532nm Ib @532nm Ib @532nm Ib @473nm Ib @473nm not irradiated Intensity (a.u.)Wavelength (nm)1.5x1019.cm-2NV0H3R(a)(b)(c)Positioning NVs in a thin layer ("delta-doping") 5.1. Several growth strategies have been developed to localize NV centres in-depth during CVD growth. The simplest way is to turn on and off the N2 input flow which allows growing nitrogen-doped stacked layers as illustrated in figure 8(a). However, in this case, changing the gas phase composition is hampered by long residence times tr of gas species in the plasma chamber. Indeed, for a typical incoming gas flow of 0.5 litre per minute and a volume for the plasma chamber of a few litres [93], several minutes are required to completely renew the gaseous environment which complicates the growth of stacked layers with sharp transitions [140]. This is all the more difficult since, as previously described, under high microwave powers which are required to efficiently dissociate N2, relatively high growth rates are reached (a few µm/h). Consequently, there is a trade-off between high doping efficiency and high thickness control which involves very low growth rates. Growth techniques with nanometre-scale resolution have already shown promising results in magnetometry [190-192] but they require very low power densities (typically 750 W for a pressure of about 30 mbar) and low methane additions (< 0.5 %) to reduce growth rates down to a few nm/h. This in turn limits achievable NV concentrations to typically 108 to 1012 cm-3. Moreover, at low-power densities, it is difficult to obtain a high crystalline quality especially if one wants to grow the thick buffer layer (> 10 µm) [94, 193] that is required to limit influence of the substrate on the overall luminescence. Nevertheless, delta- doped layers with highly confined NVs located in a 12C layer have been produced (see figure 8(b-d)) [141] and have exhibited long coherence times of several hundreds of µs when the surface is sufficiently far away and/or free of defects [194]. This technique has also been coupled to local 12C implantation in order to generate 3D profiles of NVs within the diamond sample [195]. Figure 8. (a) Cross section PL image of a 500 µm thick film showing 5 nitrogen-doped layers (in the inset). (b) Schematics showing a delta-doped layer containing NVs (with 15N) and sandwiched between 2 intrinsic layers grown with 12C. (c) and (d) Hahn echo measurements showing coherence times at different distances from the surface for NV centres located in this delta-doped layer. Adapted from Ohno et al. [141]. An alternative way to localize NV centres in-depth without changing the incoming gas flow is to modify the substrate temperature during growth. Indeed it has been clearly shown that nitrogen doping efficiency strongly depends on temperature [157, 196]. The main advantage of this approach is that a small change of pressure and/or microwave power allows decreasing or increasing temperature by more than one hundred degrees in a matter of seconds especially for high microwave power operating systems. Fast temperature variations can thus be harnessed to create abrupt interfaces that couldn't be easily obtained through gas phase tuning. It is then possible, as illustrated in figure 9, to fabricate nitrogen-doped stacked layers with thicknesses as low as a few hundreds of nanometres at high microwave power densities leading to high N2 dissociation efficiencies and thus high-quality diamond films as well as thick buffer layers. Figure 9. (a) Sketch of the cross-section of a CVD multilayer obtained by varying the growth temperature between 760 °C (orange layers) and 840 °C (blue layers) with increasingly short times for the low-temperature step. 2 ppm of N2 were constantly added to the gas phase. (b) PL raster scan of the cross-section of the sample revealing the presence of the 5 low-temperature layers were NV concentration is higher. (c) PL intensity line-cut along the white dashed line shown in (b). The inset shows data fitting with a Gaussian function of the thinnest nitrogen doped layer, leading to a full-width at half maximum of 850 nm. Another approach to couple the use of high microwave power densities and the possibility of growing delta nitrogen-doped layers is to quickly move the substrate holder in and out of the plasma region, where growth takes place, which seems very easy from a conceptual point of view. Nevertheless, the main difficulty lies in the fact that diamond growth reactors are based on resonant cavities and the substrate holder is part of this cavity. Thus, most of the time the plasma discharge is affected by a displacement of the holder [197]. In addition, to avoid too much a variation of substrate temperature, additional heating systems are sometimes required to compensate for the heating loss from the plasma source [198]. In order to circumvent those issues, substrate holders can be designed so that only a small central part that supports the sample is translated. Reactor designs also exist in which the cavity is relatively unaffected by movement of the holder (such as "egg-style" Aixtron reactors) [199]. This approach thus requires some engineering development and is relatively complicated. Controlling NV's distance from the surface 5.2. As previously detailed, the positioning of NV centres in a thin layer within the diamond crystal is particularly desirable for many sensing applications. In addition, the distance at which NVs are located from the surface also plays a critical role since it will directly affect their ability to sense a magnetic field for instance. In general to maximize the interaction, this distance should be short (i.e. shallow NVs). However the presence of defects or impurities at the surface also strongly affects both the charge state and the coherence time of NV centres due to the induced surface electronic spin bath or magnetic noise induced by surface spins [200]. Shallow NVs have been produced both by direct delta-doping [201] and by low energy ion implantation [186]. Near-surface NVs can also be created by converting incorporated nitrogen through low energy electron irradiation [202]. Precisely measuring NV's distance from the surface is not trivial and requires the development of specific procedures. One possible way is to detect the nuclear magnetic resonance signal from protons in adsorbed species at the surface (such as immersion oil) [203], by coating the surface with an element inducing strong magnetic noise [204] or by approaching a magnetized AFM tip [205]. While deep NVs (depth > 50 nm) in a low concentration nitrogen environment exhibit typical T2 times of 300-500 µs, this figure drops by 1 or 2 orders of magnitude (i.e. 1-10 µs) when the NV to surface distance is reduced to below 5 nm [206]. An overgrowth step in order to keep NV centres away from the surface allows improving Hahn echo T2 time as illustrated on figure 10(a). Removing defects at the surface is a way to extend coherence times of shallow NVs. An order of magnitude extension has been demonstrated by Sangtawesin et al. [207] through a series of well-controlled surface treatments that aim at recovering a surface state as perfect as possible. This includes polishing down to a roughness below 0.1 nm, removing surface damage by Ar/Cl2/O2 plasma etching, triacid cleaning (perchloric, nitric and sulfuric acid) followed by oxygen annealing at 450°C to fully oxygen-terminate the surface. Surface termination of the diamond indeed strongly affects shallow NV's properties [208]. Improvements as compared to an as-grown or as-implanted surface have been demonstrated through fluorine termination with an SF6 plasma treatment [209] (see figure 10(b)), nitrogen termination using a high power plasma [210] and oxygen termination as well depending on the initial orientation of the surface, (113) for example as suggested by Li et al. [211]. In addition a soft RIE (Reactive Ion Etching) oxygen plasma etching of the implanted surface, with nanometre-scale precision, has allowed bringing NVs closer to the surface (circa 4 nm) while preserving good coherence properties (T2 up to 30 µs) [212]. Finally, overgrowing a diamond film implanted with a shallow NV pattern provides a way to push further away the surface and can be exploited to improve coherence properties and stabilize NV's negative charge state while still benefiting from the placement accuracy of low energy implantation (i.e. circa 10 nm) [213]. However this approach also comes with additional issues. Impurities such as SiV and defects (dislocations for example) can be preferentially incorporated at the growth interface [214]. Slight etching of the surface as well as passivation of implanted NVs by hydrogen diffusion may also lead to the partial disappearance of the pattern [215, 216]. Figure 10. (a) Increase in the Hahn echo coherence time T2 for single NV centres before and after an overgrowth process. The inset shows the relative increase of the mean coherence times exceeding one order of magnitude for the 2.5 keV implanted NV centres corresponding to the shallowest NV centres. Adapted from Staudacher et al [213]. (b) Evolution of T2 time versus depth showing that an appropriate surface treatment can allow favourably extending coherence time near the surface. Adapted from Favaro de Oliveira et al [212]. Positioning NVs in-plane 5.3. It is very challenging to deterministically localize defects in the growing plane (i.e. in the X-Y direction) by CVD. This has been achieved on specific nanostructures either by top-down or bottom-up techniques. In the first case, the pattern created in a hard mask by optical or electron lithography is transferred to a diamond layer containing NV centres (either by growth or implantation) through Reactive Ion Etching (RIE) resulting in colour centres located in pillars as illustrated in figure 11(a). This process has been initially developed in order to obtain high aspect ratio pillared and conical structures that lead to a local field enhancement effect of the emitting surface[217-219]. It has also been successfully applied to nitrogen-doped diamond films in order to create arrays of nanopillars exhibiting NV fluorescence as shown in figure 11(b) [220]. Such pillars can even be usefully exploited to locally perform magnetic sensing when attached to an AFM tip for instance [221] or to be used for sensing at the nanoscale [12]. Beyond the localized NV emission, an additional positive effect of developing such structures is the improved wave-guiding of the NV emission particularly in the case of growth in the [111] direction as shown by Neu et al [222]. In this configuration, the preferential orientation of the NV axis in the direction of the pillar (i.e. dipole perpendicular to the pillar axis) leads to an enhanced coupling efficiency and thus extraction of light (see figure 11(c)). Figure 11. (a) Sketch of the fabrication process to create NV centres localized in pillars. (b) Nanopillars obtained by ICP etching with a chromium mask on top of a [100]-oriented CVD diamond single crystal and corresponding micro-PL mapping of an array of such pillars. Adapted from Widmann et al [220]. (c) Nanopillars obtained by ICP etching of a [111]-oriented CVD diamond single crystal and simulations showing wave-guiding of the emission from a single dipole oriented perpendicularly to (left) or parallel to (right) the nanopillar axis. The coupling efficiency is enhanced in the first case [222]. There have been only a few reports on the fabrication of diamond nanostructures based on a bottom- up approach. The formation of nanopillars by plasma etching, described previously, can be followed by an overgrowth step in order to form a thin layer in which impurities (nitrogen or silicon) can be intentionally introduced [223, 224]. Depending on the growth conditions, the shape of those pyramidal features can be varied according to the relative growth rates of different crystalline planes. This additional step can thus increase the concentration and localization of active colour centres [225-227] which can be useful to create quantum sensors or single photon sources based on this material [228]. In a similar way, fabrication of p-n electronic devices has been achieved by locally growing phosphorous doped layers on patterned diamond single crystals [229]. An uncommon way to fabricate arrays of NV centres in CVD diamond is based on a 2-step approach illustrated in figure 12(a). First, a pattern of micro-holes is created on a (100)-oriented high purity diamond substrate by optical lithography followed by RIE etching. The lateral orientation of the holes is chosen along the (110) directions. In a second step, overgrowth is performed by CVD so that the created holes were "re- filled" with nitrogen-doped diamond with limited growth on the top surface. This implies choosing growth conditions leading to a high (111) to (100) growth rate ratio, i.e. low methane concentrations and high substrate temperatures [230, 231]. The hole array totally disappears leading to a smooth surface (figure 12(b)). NV centre distribution can be assessed by observing the patterned region by CL. Figure 12(c) shows the CL image acquired at a wavelength of 575 nm, which corresponds to emission from NV0 centres in diamond. The pattern of holes is revealed by the presence of localized NV centres. Figure 12. (a) Sketch of the fabrication process allowing obtaining arrays of NV centres localized at the surface of CVD diamond. (b) Optical picture of the top CVD layer after ICP etching where square holes are visible. (c) Secondary electron image of the patterned area after CVD growth which shows a smooth surface with no visible holes remaining. (d) CL image at 575 nm of the same region where bright luminescence from NV centres is visible in the "re-filled" holes. 6. Controlling NV orientation NV centres' quantization axis is oriented along the <111> crystallographic directions and can thus have 4 equivalent directions in the crystal. In order to improve either the sensitivity or the easiness of use of a magnetic sensor working with an ensemble of NV centres, promoting a specific orientation among those 4 is a great advantage. CVD growth on substrates with alternative orientations provides a way to do that [232]. In general the most out-of-plane crystallographic directions of NV centres are more likely to show-up following CVD growth. When growth is performed on standard (100)-oriented substrates, all 4 directions having an equivalent angle with respect to the surface, there is an equiprobable formation of the four possible NV orientations (see figure 13(a)). Thus a maximum of 25 % of the total number of NV centres will be oriented with the desired angle. This has motivated research to grow on other non-classical growth orientations. 6.1. Growth on [110]-oriented substrates The first report of preferential alignment for grown-in NV centres was done using CVD-grown [110]- oriented films [143]. On this orientation, [111] and [111] directions are in the (110) plane while [111] and [111] are out-of-plane making a similar angle of 35.2° (see figure 13(b)). This particular configuration thus leads to 2 main populations among the 4 possible directions (50 % preferential orientation). Moreover, the specific configuration of the atomic structure on the plane suggests that defects are incorporated as a unit of a nitrogen and a vacancy rather than formed later by diffusion of a nearby vacancy [143]. Despite this preferential alignment, the (110)-orientation has not been the subject of many studies or applications [233- 235]. In fact (110)-oriented substrates are commercially available but with a limited size (typically 3x3 mm² or below). Due to cuboctahedral growth, when [110]-oriented diamond plates are extracted from the HPHT- grown crystal, multiple sectors are usually obtained [232] which constitutes an important drawback since sector boundaries lead to stress and defect formation [94, 236]. In addition, since homoepitaxial layers on (110)-oriented diamond substrates have one of the highest growth rates under standard CVD conditions [230], the top surface tend to rapidly disappear during growth limiting the final surface area when thick films are required. This point is illustrated in figure 14(a) and 14(b) in which the surface area decreases by a factor of 2 after a 30 h of growth even if 300 µm-thick films with high-quality can be grown at 10 µm/h. Figure 13. Schematic drawing of the four possible NV defect orientations (in green) for a (a) [100]-oriented diamond sample, (b) [110]-oriented diamond sample, (c) [111]-oriented diamond sample and (d) [113]-oriented diamond sample. The most out-of-plane directions (lowest angles) have the highest probability for preferential orientation during CVD growth. (Black: carbon, blue: nitrogen, red: vacancy). In order to avoid the use of (110)-oriented substrates, it has been reported that growth on a (100) surface onto which step bunching occurs can also lead to specific alignment of NVs [143]. This is due to the fact that step edges mainly consist of (110) planes [237] (figure 14(c)). Therefore preferential alignment of NVs on the risers of those steps is observed. Unfortunately, in this case, the NVs uniformity is very poor since they are mainly localized in stripes corresponding to the displacement of step edges during growth [238] (figure 14(d)). For all these reasons, (110) has been supplanted by other orientations that are more advantageous in terms of preferential orientation and/or easiness of growth. Figure 14. Surface morphology of a (110)-oriented CVD layer after a growth of (a) 6 hours (60 µm) and (b) 30 hours (300 µm). The top surface area has eventually decreased by a factor of 2. (c) Scheme of macro-steps formed at the surface of a [100]-oriented diamond film during growth where risers and terraces are identified. This image is adapted from Martineau et al. [237]. (d) Preferential incorporation of NVs at the risers of the steps with (110) orientation. This image is adapted from Pham et al. [238]. 6.2. Growth on [111]-oriented substrates If we consider a [111]-oriented sample, one NV direction will be perpendicular to the top surface (0° angle) while the three others will make a similar angle of 60° with respect to this direction (See figure 13(c)). Therefore, preferential alignment of NVs along this perpendicular direction will occur during growth [239- 241]. Using an atomistic layer-by-layer growth model, Miyazaki et al. have shown that incorporation of nitrogen at kinks during the displacement of [112] step edges is likely to lead to such preferential orientation [242]. In addition, it has been shown that, among this family, alignment of NVs along [111] rather [111] (i.e. N-V rather than V-N) has a higher probability to occur [241]. [111]-oriented HPHT diamond crystals can be purchased although their availability and size (typically 2×2 mm²) are quite limited. (111) plates can be extracted by slicing large cuboctahedral HPHT crystals (or CVD stones) with a 54.7° angle from the top (100) sector. Alternatively under certain HPHT conditions, octahedral growth is possible leading to pyramidal diamonds with <111>-oriented side facets [79] from which the fabrication of triangular (111) plates with minimal material loss and larger growth sector is possible. This crystalline orientation being particularly hard mechanically, it is extremely difficult to polish along an exact [111] direction using a standard scaife technique [243, 244]. A slight misorientation angle (1 to 2 °) is usually needed to obtain low roughness and reasonable polishing rates. As a consequence most as-received (111) substrates are not exactly oriented. Alternative polishing techniques have been proposed that make use of chemical agents or UV light assistance [245, 246] to obtain a better surface finish. The growth of CVD diamond on this specific orientation is known to be very difficult due to twinning, defects formation or impurity incorporation [247-249] which usually leads to lower carrier mobilities as compared to a conventional [100]-orientation [250]. Nevertheless, with the use of (111) substrates having a controlled misorientation of 2° along the [112] direction, atomically-flat thin films compatible with high- quality electronic devices have already been produced [251-253]. For thicker films, the probability for defect formation is higher due to the low energy difference between normal and twinned configurations as described by Butler et al. [254]. However specific growth conditions can be chosen so that a formed penetration twin is quickly overgrown by its parent face and cannot develop further [231]. This corresponds to an  value below 1.5; with 𝛼 = √3 𝑉(100) 𝑉(111) and where v(100) and v(111) are the growth rates of the (100) and (111) planes respectively. This is illustrated in figure 15(a) and 15(b) for 100 µm-thick intrinsic diamond films for which the use of high temperatures (> 1000°C) and low methane concentrations (< 1 %) allows minimizing  and keeping smooth morphologies. A relatively high crystalline quality as judged by Raman/PL has been demonstrated with growth rates as high as 6 μm/h which makes this process viable for the growth of thicker material. More information can be found in reference[80]. When a small amount of nitrogen is added to the gas phase (a few ppm), NV centres aligned along the [111] direction, i.e. perpendicularly to the surface, are preferentially formed [239-241] with a probability from 94 to 100 % (see figure 15(c) and 15(e)). This orientation further facilitates their integration into devices by optimizing the alignment with respect to an applied magnetic field and maximizing their emission when embedded in nanostructures [222]. Furthermore, if growth is performed using a 13C-depleted carbon source the coherence time can be enhanced to the ms range as illustrated in figure 15(f) for single isolated centres (see figure 15(d) and part 4.2). Obtaining high density NV ensembles is however rather difficult and may lead to a partial loss of orientation. Indeed, the optimal growth conditions window allowing keeping an α parameter lower than 1.5 strongly reduces when nitrogen concentration is increased in the feed gas. Nevertheless by using specific growth conditions in a low plasma density CVD, several tens of ppb of NV centres have recently been obtained with good alignment and moderate T2 times of the order of a few µs [194, 255]. In particular it has been shown that lower growth temperatures (circa 800 °C rather than 1000 °C) are preferable to promote preferential alignment of those ensembles. This is consistent with the fact that at high annealing temperatures above 1000 °C, a partial dissociation of NVs accompanied by vacancy migration might be the reason for re-orientation [256]. The films' thicknesses remained very limited though due the induced stress and low growth rates involved which currently limits the use of such CVD layers. For those reasons the use of alternative orientations to (111) have been considered in order to benefit from preferential orientation as well as higher tunability of NV density in thicker layers. Figure 15. (a) Optical and PL images of a [111]-oriented HPHT substrate obtained from a cuboctahedral diamond (Collaboration with the Sobolev Institute of Geology and Mineralogy). (b) Laser microscope images of a 100 µm-thick CVD layer grown on this substrate under optimized conditions. (c) ODMR signal of the 4 NV orientations with magnetic field aligned along [111]. (d) Confocal optical microscopy image of isolated NV centres oriented along [111] in red colour. (e) 97% preferential orientation has been estimated from analysis of more than 200 centres. (f) Spin echo signal measured for NV centres in a 13C depleted (111) diamond leading to almost 1 ms coherence time. (Collaboration University of Basel). 6.3. Growth on [113]-oriented substrates The choice of this alternative orientation has been guided by the fact that in this configuration, the [111] direction is almost in the (113) plane (80° angle with respect to the [113] direction) while the [111] direction is the most out-of-plane with an upward angle of 29.5°. The [111] and [111] directions make a similar downward angle of 58.5° with the [113] direction and are thus closer to the plane (See figure 13(d)). One of the limitations to the use of [113]-oriented single crystal diamond substrates is that they are not currently commercially available and need to be specifically fabricated on demand. Starting from relatively thick HPHT or CVD crystals with six {100} faces, (113) planes can be prepared by laser cutting and polishing the top face with an angle of 25.2° (± 0.5°) towards the [110] direction. For example in Ref. [257], cylindrical diamond substrates with a 2 mm-diameter have been produced using this procedure. (113) crystallographic faces are stable under certain CVD growth conditions [258, 259] and this orientation is suitable for thick layer growth. This stability is likely related to the fact that the (113) plane undergoes a surface reconstruction in the presence of a hydrogen plasma in a similar fashion to what has been reported for silicon, thus decreasing the surface energy on this orientation[260, 261]. Under high plasma density conditions 460 µm-thick CVD diamond films with smooth morphologies and free of non-epitaxial features have been grown (figure 16(a)). The corresponding growth rate of 15 μm/h was higher by a factor of 2 than that obtained on (100) under the same conditions. A decrease of the available surface area with thickness is noticeable although it remains limited and compatible with the synthesis of mm-thick films. It is essential to note that growth temperature range (700 to 1000 °C) as well as N2 addition of up to a few tens of ppm in the gas phase can be used which is not as restrictive as for (111) growth, as illustrated in figure 16(b-c). PL images (2nd row of figure 16(a-c)) shows only limited blue fluorescence related to the presence of dislocations (band A) [262] and indicates a limited stress in contrast with growth on (111). Green emission originates from the HPHT seed. A weak orange luminescence related to NVs centres begins to appear for the highest doping level which was confirmed by CL performed at 110 K (figure 16(d)). NV defect orientation was then experimentally measured by recording ESR spectra while applying a static magnetic field along the [113] direction. Only three of the 4 possible orientations were detected with 2 of them making a similar angle with the field, leading to 2 different ESR spectra presented in figure 16(e). The probability of occurrence of each NV defect orientations was estimated by recording ESR spectra over a set of about 200 single NV defects. The resulting statistical distribution is shown in figure 16(f) and a preferential orientation of 73% was clearly evidenced. This is again consistent with the fact that "in-plane" directions are very unfavourable for NVs creation [143, 238-241] and out-of- plane ones are promoted. Figure 16. (a) -- (c) CVD diamond layers grown on [113]-oriented HPHT substrates. (a) non-intentional N2 addition, (b) 0.5 ppm N2, (c) 10 ppm N2, in the gas phase. First row: SEM images where the different crystalline faces can be identified; Second row: PL images recorded with the DiamondView™ equipment under UV light excitation. Green luminescence comes from the HPHT substrate and blue and red layer. (d) Cathodoluminescence spectrum recorded at 110 K on CVD layers grown with 0 and 10 ppm of N2 in the gas phase. (e) Orientation- dependent ESR spectra recorded from single NV centres while applying a static magnetic field B=18 G perpendicular to (113) diamond surface plane. The most-in plane [111] direction is not detected. (f) Statistical distribution of NV defect orientations extracted from ESR measurements for a set of about 200 single NV defects. The black dashed lines indicate the expected distribution for randomly oriented NV defects. luminescence from dislocations/stress and nitrogen related centres respectively in the CVD As a large range of temperatures is accessible for (113) growth, the influence of this parameter has been assessed [263]. A stacked multilayer alternating high (1000°C) and low (800°C) temperatures has been produced following the scheme illustrated in figure 17(a), leading to a modulation of the nitrogen doping efficiency (see also part 5.1). It has however been found that preferential orientation changes from 50 % at high temperature to a maximum 80 % at low temperature (figure 17(b-c)). This approach thus allows combining both higher doping efficiency with preferential orientation. The spin coherence time (T2) of the NV ensemble has also been measured by applying a Hahn echo sequence. As shown in figure 17(d), the spin echo signal exhibits characteristic collapses and revivals induced by the interaction with a bath of 13C nuclear spin[264]. The decay of the envelope leads to a coherence time T2 of 232 ± 6 µs, which is similar to the one commonly obtained with conventional (100) crystals of identical isotopic purity [265]. Therefore the (113) orientation allows having a high degree of engineering of NV defects orientation and density. Although, as compared to (111), NVs are inclined with respect to the surface and only partially oriented, this orientation offers a good compromise particularly for thick CVD diamond layers. Figure 17. (a) Left -- Sketch of a sample grown at different temperatures and deposition times on a [113]-oriented diamond substrate. Right -- Confocal PL raster scan of a cross-section of the sample obtained by laser cutting. (b) Probability distribution of the NV defect orientation sorted by polar angle θ in samples grown at 1000°C and 800°C. The black dotted bars indicate the expected distribution for a diamond sample without preferential alignment. (c) ESR spectrum of a NV-doped layer grown on a [113]-oriented substrate while applying a static magnetic field which separates all NV defect orientations. (d) Spin-echo signal recorded for the subset of [111]- oriented NV defects with a static magnetic field of ∼50 G applied along the [111] axis. The inset shows the spin-echo sequence consisting of resonant microwave (π/2) and (π) pulses separated by a variable free precession time τ. 7. Conclusions The development of single crystal diamond synthesis by microwave-assisted plasma CVD has witnessed considerable progresses over the past 15 years to become nowadays a mature technology. Extensive efforts have been dedicated to the development of high purity diamond films for power electronics through the reduction of residual background impurities down to levels as low as 0.1 ppb for nitrogen and boron. To this end, high quality single crystals have been reliably fabricated with thickness of a few hundreds of µm on various orientations and doping concentrations. Quantum technologies that make use of colour centres in diamond have leveraged on those achievements to unleash the potential of this material system. While HPHT synthesis produces bulk crystals with high crystalline perfection, purity usually remains limited and the technique does not allow for a precise engineering of stacked "quantum grade" layers. On the other hand, CVD has become a key enabling technology for quantum sensing due to its unrivalled control on impurity content and isotopic ratio. The route that is most widely followed is thus to grow a thin active film by CVD with optimised properties for sensing onto a HPHT diamond substrate possessing appropriate quality and orientation. In particular precisely controlling NVs density in the crystal as well as their close environment is crucial to achieving optimal spin properties for quantum sensing applications. Many studies have thus been dedicated to optimizing the performance of CVD diamonds through a proper engineering of the material. Reducing nearby trapping centres created during growth by choosing alternative doping sources or growth conditions for example, may help stabilizing the charge state of NVs and avoid photobleaching issues. Isotopic control of the 13C/12C ratio associated to modification of the Fermi level has also allowed reaching record spin coherence times over 2 ms at room temperature. Beyond that, the coupling of a NV spin to a nearby long- lived nuclear spin has been proposed to further extend quantum storage times or create arrays of entangled systems. It is clear that many sensing applications (such as magnetic resonance imaging) will strongly rely on the future development of such complex coupling schemes and much efforts will need to be dedicated to this research area. To this end, nanometre-scale localisation of NV centres (and other nuclear spins) within the diamond lattice definitely remains an important challenge. So called delta-doped diamond layers have been produced with confinement of the colour centres in very narrow regions at or slightly below the surface. However ex-situ ion implantation or laser irradiation provides much better positioning accuracy than in-situ doped NVs despite slightly worse coherent properties. These approaches will need to be further developed. The synthesis of thick synthetic diamonds possessing an extremely high amount of NV centres and reasonably good coherence properties is another short-term target that will help pushing further the accuracy and performance of quantum sensors. Producing such crystals is not trivial and requires that adapted growth conditions are found to allow for high doping efficiency while preserving crystalline quality. In many cases, NV/Ns ratio needs to be improved through appropriate irradiation and annealing procedures. One specific asset the CVD technique can build on, is the ability to grow on different substrate orientations leading to partial or even full orientation of NV centres along a specific crystalline direction. The combination of different advantageous properties such as a high NV yield with specific orientation and possibly localisation in the diamond are likely to play a key role in the adoption of this material system. Nevertheless, efforts need to be pursued to improve the availability of this specially designed material to a broader community. Indeed, only few companies or academic laboratories currently have the know-how to engineer such quantum-grade material. Moreover, the size of the synthetic crystals remains limited to few mm² and it is important to push forward the HPHT and CVD techniques in order to increase the available area. This point is particularly important when micro-fabrication steps are required as it is the case for diamond tips fabrication. The last point that could be highlighted is the importance of defining standards in the production of quantum grade samples in terms of coherence time, NVs concentration, orientation which could allow opening the way of a more reproducible industrial production. Acknowledgment: This project has received funding from the European Union's research and innovation program through the Project ASTERIQS under grant agreement No 820394 and through the QUANTERA project MICROSENS n° ANR-18-QUAN-0008-02. It has been also supported by Region Ile-de-France in the framework of DIM SIRTEQ. ANR (Agence Nationale de la Recherche) and CGI (Commissariat à l'Investissement d'Avenir) are also gratefully acknowledged for their financial support through Labex SEAM (Science and Engineering for Advanced Materials and devices), ANR-10-LABX-096 and ANR-18-IDEX-0001, the Diamond-NMR project n° ANR-19-CE29-0017-04 and the SADAHPT project n° ANR-19-CE30-0027-02. References: [1] [2] Acín A, Bloch I, Buhrman H, Calarco T, Eichler C, Eisert J, Esteve D, Gisin N, Glaser S J, Jelezko F, Kuhr S, Lewenstein M, Riedel M F, Schmidt P O, Thew R, Wallraff A, Walmsley I and Wilhelm F K 2018 The quantum technologies roadmap: a European community view New Journal of Physics 20 080201 Arute F, Arya K, Babbush R, Bacon D, Bardin J C, Barends R, Biswas R, Boixo S, Brandao F G S L, Buell D A, Burkett B, Chen Y, Chen Z, Chiaro B, Collins R, Courtney W, Dunsworth A, Farhi E, Foxen B, Fowler A, Gidney C, Giustina M, Graff R, Guerin K, Habegger S, Harrigan M P, Hartmann M J, Ho A, Hoffmann M, Huang T, Humble T S, Isakov S V, Jeffrey E, Jiang Z, Kafri D, Kechedzhi K, Kelly J, Klimov P V, Knysh S, Korotkov A, Kostritsa F, Landhuis D, Lindmark M, Lucero E, Lyakh D, Mandrà S, McClean J R, McEwen M, Megrant A, Mi X, Michielsen K, Mohseni M, Mutus J, Naaman O, Neeley M, Neill C, Niu M Y, Ostby E, Petukhov A, Platt J C, Quintana C, Rieffel E G, Roushan P, Rubin N C, Sank D, Satzinger K J, Smelyanskiy V, Sung K J, Trevithick M D, Vainsencher A, Villalonga B, White T, [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] Yao Z J, Yeh P, Zalcman A, Neven H and Martinis J M 2019 Quantum supremacy using a programmable superconducting processor Nature 574 505-10 Freer S, Simmons S, Laucht A, Muhonen J T, Dehollain J P, Kalra R, Mohiyaddin F A, Hudson F E, Itoh K M, McCallum J C, Jamieson D N, Dzurak A S and Morello A 2017 A single-atom quantum memory in silicon Quantum Science and Technology 2 015009 He Y, Gorman S K, Keith D, Kranz L, Keizer J G and Simmons M Y 2019 A two-qubit gate between phosphorus donor electrons in silicon Nature 571 371-5 Goldner P, Ferrier A and Guillot-Noël O 2015 Handbook on the Physics and Chemistry of Rare Earths, ed J-C G Bünzli and V K Pecharsky (North-Holland: Elsevier) pp 1-78 Michler P 2019 Quantum Dots for Quantum Information Technologies, (Switzerland: Springer) Awschalom D D, Hanson R, Wrachtrup J and Zhou B B 2018 Quantum technologies with optically interfaced solid-state spins Nature Photonics 12 516-27 Acosta V and Hemmer P 2013 Nitrogen-vacancy centers: Physics and applications Mrs Bulletin 38 127-30 Doherty M W, Manson N B, Delaney P, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J and Hollenberg L C L 2013 The nitrogen-vacancy colour centre in diamond Physics Reports 528 1-45 Hensen B, Bernien H, Dréau A E, Reiserer A, Kalb N, Blok M S, Ruitenberg J, Vermeulen R F L, Schouten R N, Abellán C, Amaya W, Pruneri V, Mitchell M W, Markham M, Twitchen D J, Elkouss D, Wehner S, Taminiau T H and Hanson R 2015 Loophole-free Bell inequality violation using electron spins separated by 1.3 kilometres Nature 526 682-6 [12] [13] [16] [17] [14] [15] [11] Waldherr G, Wang Y, Zaiser S, Jamali M, Schulte-Herbrüggen T, Abe H, Ohshima T, Isoya J, Du J F, Neumann P and Wrachtrup J 2014 Quantum error correction in a solid-state hybrid spin register Nature 506 204-7 Levine Edlyn V, Turner Matthew J, Kehayias P, Hart Connor A, Langellier N, Trubko R, Glenn David R, Fu Roger R and Walsworth Ronald L 2019 Principles and techniques of the quantum diamond microscope Nanophotonics 8 1945-73 Rondin L, Tetienne J P, Hingant T, Roch J F, Maletinsky P and Jacques V 2014 Magnetometry with nitrogen-vacancy defects in diamond Reports on Progress in Physics 77 056503 Schirhagl R, Chang K, Loretz M and Degen C 2014 Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Diamond: Nanoscale Sensors for Physics and Biology Annual Review of Physical Chemistry 65 83-105 Stürner F M, Brenneis A, Kassel J, Wostradowski U, Rölver R, Fuchs T, Nakamura K, Sumiya H, Onoda S, Isoya J and Jelezko F 2019 Compact integrated magnetometer based on nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 93 59-65 Becker J N, Görlitz J, Arend C, Markham M and Becher C 2016 Ultrafast all-optical coherent control of single silicon vacancy colour centres in diamond Nature Communications 7 13512 Iwasaki T, Ishibashi F, Miyamoto Y, Doi Y, Kobayashi S, Miyazaki T, Tahara K, Jahnke K D, Rogers L J, Naydenov B, Jelezko F, Yamasaki S, Nagamachi S, Inubushi T, Mizuochi N and Hatano M 2015 Germanium-Vacancy Single Color Centers in Diamond Scientific Reports 5 12882 Iwasaki T, Miyamoto Y, Taniguchi T, Siyushev P, Metsch M H, Jelezko F and Hatano M 2017 Tin- Vacancy Quantum Emitters in Diamond Physical Review Letters 119 253601 Trusheim M E, Wan N H, Chen K C, Ciccarino C J, Flick J, Sundararaman R, Malladi G, Bersin E, Walsh M, Lienhard B, Bakhru H, Narang P and Englund D 2019 Lead-related quantum emitters in diamond Phys.Rev. B 99 075430 Sipahigil A, Evans R E, Sukachev D D, Burek M J, Borregaard J, Bhaskar M K, Nguyen C T, Pacheco J L, Atikian H A, Meuwly C, Camacho R M, Jelezko F, Bielejec E, Park H, Lončar M and Lukin M D 2016 An integrated diamond nanophotonics platform for quantum optical networks Science Tallaire A, Achard J, Silva F, Brinza O and Gicquel A 2013 Growth of large size diamond single crystals by plasma assisted chemical vapour deposition: Recent achievements and remaining challenges Comptes Rendus Physique 14 169-84 Eaton-Magaña S and Shigley J E 2016 Observations on CVD-Grown Synthetic Diamonds: A Review gems & Gemology, Fall 2016 52 222-45 Nazareno D, Nicolas R, Julien P, Giorgia L and Florin U 2019 Diamond power devices: State of the art, modelling and figures of merit J. Phys. D [23] [22] [18] [19] [20] [21] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] Tarelkin S, Bormashov V, Buga S, Volkov A, Teteruk D, Kornilov N, Kuznetsov M, Terentiev S, Golovanov A and Blank V 2015 Power diamond vertical Schottky barrier diode with 10 A forward current Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 212 2621 -- 7 Umezawa H 2018 Recent advances in diamond power semiconductor devices Materials Science in Semiconductor Processing 78 147-56 Traoré A, Muret P, Fiori A, Eon D, Gheeraert E and Pernot J 2014 Zr/oxidized diamond interface for high power Schottky diodes Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 052105 Shikata S 2016 Single crystal diamond wafers for high power electronics Diam. Relat. Mat. 65 168- 75 Achard J, Silva F, Issaoui R, Brinza O, Tallaire A, Schneider H, Isoird K, Ding H, Kone S, Pinault M A, Jomard F and Gicquel A 2011 Thick boron doped diamond single crystals for high power electronics Diam. Relat. Mater. 20 145-52 Koizumi S and Suzuki M 2006 n-Type doping of diamond Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 203 3358-66 Jones R, Goss L P and briddon P R 2009 Acceptor level of nitrogen in diamond and the 270-nm absorption band Phys.Rev. B 80 Pinault-Thaury M A, Tillocher T, Habka N, Kobor D, Jomard F, Chevallier J and Barjon J 2011 n-Type CVD diamond: Epitaxy and doping Materials Science and Engineering: B 176 1401-8 Pinault-Thaury M-A, Temgoua S, Gillet R, Bensalah H, Stenger I, Jomard F, Issaoui R and Barjon J 2019 Phosphorus-doped (113) CVD diamond: A breakthrough towards bipolar diamond devices Appl. Phys. Lett. 114 112106 Kato H, Makino T, Ogura M, Tokuda N, Okushi H and Yamasaki S 2009 Selective Growth of Buried n+Diamond on (001) Phosphorus-Doped n-Type Diamond Film Applied Physics Express 2 055502 Pfender M, Aslam N, Simon P, Antonov D, Thiering G, Burk S, Fávaro de Oliveira F, Denisenko A, Fedder H, Meijer J, Garrido J A, Gali A, Teraji T, Isoya J, Doherty M W, Alkauskas A, Gallo A, Grüneis A, Neumann P and Wrachtrup J 2017 Protecting a Diamond Quantum Memory by Charge State Control Nano Letters 17 5931-7 Schreyvogel C, Polyakov V, Wunderlich R, Meijer J and Nebel C E 2015 Active charge state control of single NV centres in diamond by in-plane Al-Schottky junctions Sci. Rep. 5 Grotz B, Hauf M V, Dankerl M, Naydenov B, Pezzagna S, Meijer J, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J, Stutzmann M, Reinhard F and Garrido J A 2012 Charge state manipulation of qubits in diamond Nature Communications 3 729 Hauf M V, Grotz B, Naydenov B, Dankerl M, Pezzagna S, Meijer J, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J, Stutzmann M, Reinhard F and Garrido J A 2011 Chemical control of the charge state of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Phys.Rev. B 83 081304 Rondin L, Dantelle G, Slablab A, Grosshans F, Treussart F, Bergonzo P, Perruchas S, Gacoin T, Chaigneau M, Chang H C, Jacques V and Roch J F 2010 Surface-induced charge state conversion of nitrogen-vacancy defects in nanodiamonds Phys.Rev. B 82 115449 Gruber A, Dräbenstedt A, Tietz C, Fleury L, Wrachtrup J and Borczyskowski C v 1997 Scanning Confocal Optical Microscopy and Magnetic Resonance on Single Defect Centers Science 276 2012-4 Balasubramanian G, Chan I Y, Kolesov R, Al-Hmoud M, Tisler J, Shin C, Kim C, Wojcik A, Hemmer P R, Krueger A, Hanke T, Leitenstorfer A, Bratschitsch R, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2008 Nanoscale imaging magnetometry with diamond spins under ambient conditions Nature 455 648-51 Degen C L 2008 Scanning magnetic field microscope with a diamond single-spin sensor Appl. Phys. Lett. 92 243111 [42] Maze J R, Stanwix P L, Hodges J S, Hong S, Taylor J M, Cappellaro P, Jiang L, Dutt M V G, Togan E, Zibrov A S, Yacoby A, Walsworth R L and Lukin M D 2008 Nanoscale magnetic sensing with an individual electronic spin in diamond Nature 455 644-7 Taylor J M, Cappellaro P, Childress L, Jiang L, Budker D, Hemmer P R, Yacoby A, Walsworth R and Lukin M D 2008 High-sensitivity diamond magnetometer with nanoscale resolution Nature Physics 4 810-6 Trusheim M E and Englund D 2016 Wide-field strain imaging with preferentially aligned nitrogen- vacancy centers in polycrystalline diamond New Journal of Physics 18 123023 [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] Dolde F, Fedder H, Doherty M W, Nöbauer T, Rempp F, Balasubramanian G, Wolf T, Reinhard F, Hollenberg L C L, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2011 Electric-field sensing using single diamond spins Nature Physics 7 459-63 Doherty M W, Struzhkin V V, Simpson D A, McGuinness L P, Meng Y, Stacey A, Karle T J, Hemley R J, Manson N B, Hollenberg L C L and Prawer S 2014 Electronic Properties and Metrology Applications of the Diamond ${\mathrm{NV}}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ Center under Pressure Physical Review Letters 112 047601 Kucsko G, Maurer P C, Yao N Y, Kubo M, Noh H J, Lo P K, Park H and Lukin M D 2013 Nanometre- scale thermometry in a living cell Nature 500 54-8 Neumann P, Jakobi I, Dolde F, Burk C, Reuter R, Waldherr G, Honert J, Wolf T, Brunner A, Shim J H, Suter D, Sumiya H, Isoya J and Wrachtrup J 2013 High-Precision Nanoscale Temperature Sensing Using Single Defects in Diamond Nano Letters 13 2738-42 Toyli D M, de las Casas C F, Christle D J, Dobrovitski V V and Awschalom D D 2013 Fluorescence thermometry enhanced by the quantum coherence of single spins in diamond Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110 8417-21 Barry J F, Schloss J M, Bauch E, Turner M J, Hart C A, Pham L M and Walsworth R L 2019 Sensitivity optimization for NV- diamond magnetometry arXiv 1903.08176 Bourgeois E, Jarmola A, Siyushev P, Gulka M, Hruby J, Jelezko F, Budker D and Nesladek M 2015 Photoelectric detection of electron spin resonance of nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond Nature Communications 6 8577 Shields B J, Unterreithmeier Q P, de Leon N P, Park H and Lukin M D 2015 Efficient Readout of a Single Spin State in Diamond via Spin-to-Charge Conversion Physical Review Letters 114 136402 Dumeige Y, Chipaux M, Jacques V, Treussart F, Roch J F, Debuisschert T, Acosta V M, Jarmola A, Jensen K, Kehayias P and Budker D 2013 Magnetometry with nitrogen-vacancy ensembles in diamond based on infrared absorption in a doubly resonant optical cavity Phys.Rev. B 87 155202 Balasubramanian G, Neumann P, Twitchen D, Markham M, Kolesov R, Mizuochi N, Isoya J, Achard J, Beck J, Tissler J, Jacques V, Hemmer P R, Jelezko F and Wratchtrup J 2009 Ultralong spin coherence time in isotopically engineered diamond Nature Materials 8 383-7 [55] Wolf T, Neumann P, Nakamura K, Sumiya H, Ohshima T, Isoya J and Wrachtrup J 2015 Subpicotesla [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] Diamond Magnetometry Phys. Rev. X 5 041001 Pham L M, Le Sage D, Stanwix P L, Yeung T K, Glenn D, Trifonov A, Cappellaro P, Hemmer P R, Lukin M D, Park H, Yacoby A and Walsworth R L 2011 Magnetic field imaging with nitrogen-vacancy ensembles New Journal of Physics 13 045021 Steinert S, Dolde F, Neumann P, Aird A, Naydenov B, Balasubramanian G, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2010 High sensitivity magnetic imaging using an array of spins in diamond Review of Scientific Instruments 81 043705 Glenn D R, Bucher D B, Lee J, Lukin M D, Park H and Walsworth R L 2018 High-resolution magnetic resonance spectroscopy using a solid-state spin sensor Nature 555 351-4 Smits J, Damron J T, Kehayias P, McDowell A F, Mosavian N, Fescenko I, Ristoff N, Laraoui A, Jarmola A and Acosta V M 2019 Two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy with a microfluidic diamond quantum sensor Science Advances 5 eaaw7895 Le Sage D, Arai K, Glenn D R, DeVience S J, Pham L M, Rahn-Lee L, Lukin M D, Yacoby A, Komeili A and Walsworth R L 2013 Optical magnetic imaging of living cells Nature 496 486 Fu R R, Weiss B P, Lima E A, Harrison R J, Bai X-N, Desch S J, Ebel D S, Suavet C, Wang H, Glenn D, Le Sage D, Kasama T, Walsworth R L and Kuan A T 2014 Solar nebula magnetic fields recorded in the Semarkona meteorite Science 346 1089-92 Broadway D A, Dontschuk N, Tsai A, Lillie S E, Lew C T K, McCallum J C, Johnson B C, Doherty M W, Stacey A, Hollenberg L C L and Tetienne J P 2018 Spatial mapping of band bending in semiconductor devices using in situ quantum sensors Nature Electronics 1 502-7 Hsieh S, Bhattacharyya P, Zu C, Mittiga T, Smart T J, Machado F, Kobrin B, Höhn T O, Rui N Z, Kamrani M, Chatterjee S, Choi S, Zaletel M, Struzhkin V V, Moore J E, Levitas V I, Jeanloz R and Yao N Y 2019 Imaging stress and magnetism at high pressures using a nanoscale quantum sensor Science 366 1349-54 [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83] Lesik M, Plisson T, Toraille L, Renaud J, Occelli F, Schmidt M, Salord O, Delobbe A, Debuisschert T, Rondin L, Loubeyre P and Roch J-F 2019 Magnetic measurements on micrometer-sized samples under high pressure using designed NV centers Science 366 1359-62 Tetienne J-P, Dontschuk N, Broadway D A, Stacey A, Simpson D A and Hollenberg L C L 2017 Quantum imaging of current flow in graphene Science Advances 3 e1602429 Kanda H 2010 Bulk Crystal Growth of Electronic, Optical & Optoelectronic Materials, ed P. Capper, S. Kasap and A Willoughby (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons) pp 407-32 Palyanov Y N, Kupriyanov I N, Khokhryakov A F and Ralchenko V G 2015 Handbook of Crystal Growth (Second Edition), ed P Rudolph (Boston: Elsevier) pp 671-713 Lin B, Wang X, Zhang Y, Zhu J and Zhang H 2015 Interface characterization of a Cu -- Ti-coated diamond system Surface and Coatings Technology 278 163-70 Burns R C, Chumakov A I, Connell S H, Dube D, Godfried H P, Hansen J O, Hartwig J, Hoszowska J, Masiello F, Mkhonza L, Rebak M, Rommevaux A, Setshedi R and Vaerenbergh P V 2009 HPHT growth and x-ray characterization of high-quality type IIa diamond Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 21 364224 Naamoun M, Tallaire A, Silva F, Achard J, Doppelt P and Gicquel A 2012 Etch-pit formation mechanism induced on HPHT and CVD diamond single crystals by H2/O2 plasma etching treatment Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 209 1715-20 Zaitsev A M 2001 Optical Properties of Diamond: A Data Handbook (Berlin: Springer) Palyanov Y N, Borzdov Y M, Khokhryakov A F, Kupriyanov I N and Sokol A G 2010 Effect of Nitrogen Impurity on Diamond Crystal Growth Processes Crystal Growth & Design 10 3169-75 Kanda H and Watanabe K 1999 Distribution of nickel related luminescence centers in HPHT diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 8 1463-9 Tallaire A, Mille V, Brinza O, Tran Thi T N, Brom J M, Loguinov Y, Katrusha A, Koliadin A and Achard J 2017 Thick CVD diamond films grown on high-quality type IIa HPHT diamond substrates from New Diamond Technology Diam. Relat. Mat. 77 146-52 Burns R C, Cvetkovic V, Dodge C N, Evans D J F, Rooney M-L T, Spear P M and Welbourn C M 1990 Growth-sector dependence of optical features in large synthetic diamonds J. Cryst. Growth 104 257-79 Nakamura K, Yamashita S, Tojo T, Mitsuishi M, Kataoka K and Yoshimoto M 2007 Single-crystal synthesis of highly thermal conductive 12C-enriched diamond from pyrolytic carbon powder by the high-pressure, high-temperature method Diam. Relat. Mat. 16 1765-9 Ekimov E A, Kondrin M V, Krivobok V S, Khomich A A, Vlasov I I, Khmelnitskiy R A, Iwasaki T and Hatano M 2019 Effect of Si, Ge and Sn dopant elements on structure and photoluminescence of nano- and microdiamonds synthesized from organic compounds Diam. Relat. Mat. 93 75-83 Palyanov Y N, Kupriyanov I N, Borzdov Y M and Surovtsev N V 2015 Germanium: a new catalyst for diamond synthesis and a new optically active impurity in diamond Scientific Reports 5 14789 Khokhryakov A F, Palyanov Y N, Kupriyanov I N, Borzdov Y M, Sokol A G, Hartwig J and Masiello F 2011 Crystal growth and perfection of large octahedral synthetic diamonds J. Cryst. Growth 317 32- 8 Tallaire A, Achard J, Boussadi A, Brinza O, Gicquel A, Kupriyanov I N, Palyanov Y N, Sakr G and Barjon J 2014 High quality thick CVD diamond films homoepitaxially grown on (111)-oriented substrates Diam. Relat. Mat. 41 34-40 Grezes C, Julsgaard B, Kubo Y, Ma W L, Stern M, Bienfait A, Nakamura J, Isoya J, Onoda S, Ohshima T, Jacques V, Vion D, Esteve D, Liu R B, Molmer K and Bertet P 2015 Storage and retrieval of microwave fields at the single-photon level in a spin ensemble Physical Review A 92 020301(R) Kubo Y, Ong F R, Bertet P, Vion D, Jacques V, Zheng D, Dreau A, Roch J F, Auffeves A, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J, Barthe M F, Bergonzo P and Esteve D 2010 Strong Coupling of a Spin Ensemble to a Superconducting Resonator Physical Review Letters 105 140502 Saito S, Zhu X D, Amsuss R, Matsuzaki Y, Kakuyanagi K, Shimo-Oka T, Mizuochi N, Nemoto K, Munro W J and Semba K 2013 Towards Realizing a Quantum Memory for a Superconducting Qubit: Storage and Retrieval of Quantum States Physical Review Letters 111 107008 [84] [85] [86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] King J P, Jeong K, Vassiliou C C, Shin C S, Page R H, Avalos C E, Wang H-J and Pines A 2015 Room- temperature in situ nuclear spin hyperpolarization from optically pumped nitrogen vacancy centres in diamond Nature Communications 6 8965 Dhomkar S, Henshaw J, Jayakumar H and Meriles C A 2016 Long-term data storage in diamond Science Advances 2 e1600911 Takahashi S, Hanson R, Tol J v, Sherwin M S and Awschalom D D 2008 Quenching Spin Decoherence in Diamond through Spin Bath Polarization Physical Review Letters 101 047601 Teraji T 2008 Physics and Applications of CVD Diamond, ed S Koizumi, C Nebel and M Nesladek (Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.) pp 29-75 Yang N 2018 Novel Aspects of Diamond: From Growth to Applications, (Switzerland: Springer) Achard J, Tallaire A, Teraji T, Mokuno Y, Yamada C, Chayahara A, Schreck M, Arnault J C, Yaita J, Iwasaki T and Hatano M 2018 Power Electronics Device Applications of Diamond Semiconductors, ed S Koizumi, H Umezawa, J Pernot and M Suzuki (Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing) pp 1-97 Teraji T, Yamamoto T, Watanabe K, Koide Y, Isoya J, Onoda S, Ohshima T, Rogers L J, Jelezko F, Neumann P, Wrachtrup J and Koizumi S 2015 Homoepitaxial diamond film growth: High purity, high crystalline quality, isotopic enrichment, and single color center formation Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 212 2365 -- 84 Dhillon H K, Twitchen D and Khan R 2014 Single crystal CVD Synthetic Diamond Material Patent n° US 2014/0335339 Schwander M and Partes K 2011 A review of diamond synthesis by CVD processes Diam. Relat. Mat. 20 1287-301 Silva F, Hassouni K, Bonnin X and Gicquel A 2009 Microwave engineering of plasma-assisted CVD reactors for diamond deposition Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 21 364202 Achard J, Silva F, Tallaire A, Bonnin X, Lombardi G, Hassouni K and Gicquel A 2007 High quality MPACVD diamond single crystal growth: high microwave power density regime J. Phys. D 40 6175- 88 Hassouni K, Silva F and Gicquel A 2010 Modelling of diamond deposition microwave cavity generated plasmas Journal of Physics D-Applied Physics 43 153001 Silva F, Gicquel A, Tardieu A, Cledat P and Chauveau T 1996 Control of an MPACVD reactor for polycrystalline textured diamond films synthesis: role of microwave power density Diam. Relat. Mat. 5 338-44 Jahnke K D, Naydenov B, Teraji T, Koizumi S, Umeda T, Isoya J and Jelezko F 2012 Long coherence time of spin qubits in 12C enriched polycrystalline chemical vapor deposition diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 012405 Aharonovich I and Neu E 2014 Diamond Nanophotonics Advanced Optical Materials 2 911-28 Aida H, Kim S-W, Ikejiri K, Kawamata Y, Koyama K, Kodama H and Sawabe A 2016 Fabrication of freestanding heteroepitaxial diamond substrate via micropatterns and microneedles Applied Physics Express 9 035504 [100] Schreck M, Gsell S, Brescia R and Fischer M 2017 Ion bombardment induced buried lateral growth: [101] [102] the key mechanism for the synthesis of single crystal diamond wafers Scientific Reports 7 44462 Lee K H, Saada S, Arnault J-C, Moalla R, Saint-Girons G, Bachelet R, Bensalah H, Stenger I, Barjon J, Tallaire A and Achard J 2016 Epitaxy of iridium on SrTiO3/Si (001): A promising scalable substrate for diamond heteroepitaxy Diam. Relat. Mat. 66 67-76 Ichikawa K, Kurone K, Kodama H, Suzuki K and Sawabe A 2019 High crystalline quality heteroepitaxial diamond using grid-patterned nucleation and growth on Ir Diam. Relat. Mat. 94 92- 100 [103] Schreck M, Mayr M, Klein O, Fischer M, Gsell S, Sartori A F and Gallheber B-C 2016 Multiple role of dislocations in the heteroepitaxial growth of diamond: A brief review Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 213 2028- 35 [104] Nelz R, Görlitz J, Herrmann D, Slablab A, Challier M, Radtke M, Fischer M, Gsell S, Schreck M, Becher C and Neu E 2019 Toward wafer-scale diamond nano- and quantum technologies APL Materials 7 011108 [105] Achard J, Tallaire A, Mille V, Naamoun M, Brinza O, Boussadi A, William L and Gicquel A 2014 Improvement of dislocation density in thick CVD single crystal diamond films by coupling H2/O2 plasma etching and chemo-mechanical or ICP treatment of HPHT substrates Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 211 2264 -- 7 [106] Charris A, Nad S and Asmussen J 2017 Exploring constant substrate temperature and constant high [107] pressure SCD growth using variable pocket holder depths Diam. Relat. Mat. 76 58-67 Liang Q, Yan C-s, Lai J, Meng Y-f, Krasnicki S, Shu H, Mao H-k and Hemley R J 2014 Large Area Single- Crystal Diamond Synthesis by 915 MHz Microwave Plasma-Assisted Chemical Vapor Deposition Crystal Growth & Design 14 3234-8 [108] Yamada H, Chayahara A, Mokuno Y, Horino Y and Shikata S 2006 Simulation of microwave plasmas concentrated on the top surface of a diamond substrate with finite thickness Diam. Relat. Mat. 15 1383-8 [109] Mokuno Y, Chayahara A and Yamada H 2008 Synthesis of large single crystal diamond plates by high rate homoepitaxial growth using microwave plasma CVD and lift-off process Diam. Relat. Mat. 17 415-8 [110] Asmussen J, Grotjohn T A, Schuelke T, Becker M F, Yaran M K, King D J, Wicklein S and Reinhard D K 2008 Multiple substrate microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition single crystal diamond synthesis Appl. Phys. Lett. 93 031502-3 [111] Willems B, Tallaire A and Achard J 2014 Optical study of defects in thick undoped CVD synthetic diamond layers Diam. Relat. Mat. 41 25-33 [112] Mizuochi N, Watanabe H, Okushi H, Yamasaki S, Niitsuma J and Sekiguchi T 2006 Hydrogen-vacancy related defect in chemical vapor deposition homoepitaxial diamond films studied by electron paramagnetic resonance and cathodoluminescence Appl. Phys. Lett. 88 091912 [113] Glover C, Newton M E, Martineau P, Twitchen D and Baker J M 2003 Hydrogen incorporation in diamond: the nitrogen vacancy hydrogen complex Physical Review Letters 90 185507 [114] Bar-Gill N, Pham L M, Belthangady C, Le Sage D, Cappellaro P, Maze J R, Lukin M D, Yacoby A and Walsworth R 2012 Suppression of spin-bath dynamics for improved coherence of multi-spin-qubit systems Nature Communications 3 858 [115] Herbschleb E D, Kato H, Maruyama Y, Danjo T, Makino T, Yamasaki S, Ohki I, Hayashi K, Morishita H, Fujiwara M and Mizuochi N 2019 Ultra-long coherence times amongst room-temperature solid- state spins Nature Communications 10 3766 [116] Dréau A, Maze J-R, Lesik M, Roch J-F and Jacques V 2012 High-resolution spectroscopy of single NV defects coupled with nearby 13C nuclear spins in diamond Physical Review Letters 85 134107 [117] Álvarez G A, Bretschneider C O, Fischer R, London P, Kanda H, Onoda S, Isoya J, Gershoni D and Frydman L 2015 Local and bulk 13C hyperpolarization in nitrogen-vacancy-centred diamonds at variable fields and orientations Nature Communications 6 8456 [118] Smith Jason M, Meynell Simon A, Bleszynski Jayich Ania C and Meijer J 2019 Colour centre generation in diamond for quantum technologies Nanophotonics 8 1889 [119] Pezzagna S and meijer J 2012 Ion implantation, ed M Goorsky (InTech) pp 1-24 [120] Pezzagna S, Naydenov B, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J and Meijer J 2010 Creation efficiency of nitrogen- vacancy centres in diamond New Journal of Physics 12 065017 [121] Pezzagna S, Rogalla D, Wildanger D, Meijer J and Zaitsev A 2011 Creation and nature of optical centres in diamond for single-photon emission -- overview and critical remarks New Journal of Physics 13 035024 [122] Pezzagna S, Wildanger D, Mazarov P, Wieck A D, Sarov Y, Rangelow I, Naydenov B, Jelezko F, Hell S W and Meijer J 2010 Nanoscale Engineering and Optical Addressing of Single Spins in Diamond Small 6 2117-21 [123] Spinicelli P, Dreau A, Rondin L, Silva F, Achard J, Xavier S, Bansropun S, Debuisschert T, Pezzagna S, Meijer J, Jacques V and Roch J F 2011 Engineered arrays of nitrogen-vacancy color centers in diamond based on implantation of CN- molecules through nanoapertures New Journal of Physics 13 025014 Lühmann T, Raatz N, John R, Lesik M, Rödiger J, Portail M, Wildanger D, Kleissler F, Nordlund K, Zaitsev A, Roch J-F, Tallaire A, Meijer J and Pezzagna S 2018 Screening and engineering of colour centres in diamond J. Phys. D 51 483002 Lühmann T, John R, Wunderlich R, Meijer J and Pezzagna S 2019 Coulomb-driven single defect engineering for scalable qubits and spin sensors in diamond Nature Communications 10 4956 [124] [125] [126] Fávaro de Oliveira F, Momenzadeh S A, Antonov D, Scharpf J, Osterkamp C, Naydenov B, Jelezko F, Denisenko A and Wrachtrup J 2016 Toward Optimized Surface δ-Profiles of Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers Activated by Helium Irradiation in Diamond Nano Letters 16 2228-33 [127] Huang Z, Li W-D, Santori C, Acosta V M, Faraon A, Ishikawa T, Wu W, Winston D, Williams R S and Beausoleil R G 2013 Diamond nitrogen-vacancy centers created by scanning focused helium ion beam and annealing Appl. Phys. Lett. 103 081906 [128] Prestopino G, Marinelli M, Milani E, Verona C, Verona-Rinati G, Traina P, Moreva E, Degiovanni I P, Genovese M, Tchernij S D, Picollo F, Olivero P and Forneris J 2017 Photo-physical properties of He- related color centers in diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 111 111105 [129] Acosta V M, Bauch E, Ledbetter M P, Santori C, Fu K-M C, Barclay P E, Beausoleil R G, Linget H, Roch J F, Treussart F, Chemerisov S, Gawlik W and Budker D 2009 Diamonds with a high density of nitrogen-vacancy centers for magnetometry applications Phys.Rev. B 80 115202 [130] McLellan C A, Myers B A, Kraemer S, Ohno K, Awschalom D D and Bleszynski Jayich A C 2016 Patterned Formation of Highly Coherent Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers Using a Focused Electron Irradiation Technique Nano Letters 16 2450-4 Jarmola A, Berzins A, Smits J, Smits K, Prikulis J, Gahbauer F, Ferber R, Erts D, Auzinsh M and Budker D 2015 Longitudinal spin-relaxation in nitrogen-vacancy centers in electron irradiated diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 107 242403 [131] [132] Eichhorn T R, McLellan C A and Jayich A C B 2019 Optimizing the formation of depth-confined nitrogen vacancy center spin ensembles in diamond for quantum sensing Phys. rev. Materials 3 113802 [133] Chen Y-C, Salter P S, Knauer S, Weng L, Frangeskou A C, Stephen C J, Ishmael S N, Dolan P R, Johnson S, Green B L, Morley G W, Newton M E, Rarity J G, Booth M J and Smith J M 2016 Laser writing of coherent colour centres in diamond Nature Photonics 11 77 [134] Stephen C J, Green B L, Lekhai Y N D, Weng L, Hill P, Johnson S, Frangeskou A C, Diggle P L, Chen Y C, Strain M J, Gu E, Newton M E, Smith J M, Salter P S and Morley G W 2019 Deep Three-Dimensional Solid-State Qubit Arrays with Long-Lived Spin Coherence Physical Review Applied 12 064005 [135] Choi J, Choi S, Kucsko G, Maurer P C, Shields B J, Sumiya H, Onoda S, Isoya J, Demler E, Jelezko F, Yao N Y and Lukin M D 2017 Depolarization Dynamics in a Strongly Interacting Solid-State Spin Ensemble Physical Review Letters 118 093601 [136] Naydenov B, Reinhard F, Lämmle A, Richter V, Kalish R, D'Haenens-Johansson U F S, Newton M, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2010 Increasing the coherence time of single electron spins in diamond by high temperature annealing Appl. Phys. Lett. 97 242511 [137] Yamamoto T, Umeda T, Watanabe K, Onoda S, Markham M L, Twitchen D J, Naydenov B, McGuinness L P, Teraji T, Koizumi S, Dolde F, Fedder H, Honert J, Wrachtrup J, Ohshima T, Jelezko F and Isoya J 2013 Extending spin coherence times of diamond qubits by high-temperature annealing Phys.Rev. B 88 075206 [138] Markham M, Stacey A, Deleon N, Chu Y, Shields B J C, MA, US), Hausmann B J M C, MA, US), Maletinsky P, Evans R E, Yacoby A, Park H, Loncar M and Lukin M D 2015 Synthetic diamond materials for quantum and optical applications and methods of making the same Patent n° US 2015/0299894 [139] Tallaire A, Collins A T, Charles D, Achard J, Sussmann R, Gicquel A, Newton M E, Edmonds A M and Cruddace R J 2006 Characterisation of high-quality thick single-crystal diamond grown by CVD with a low nitrogen addition Diam. Relat. Mat. 15 1700-7 Lobaev M A, Gorbachev A M, Bogdanov S A, Vikharev A L, Radishev D B, Isaev V A, Chernov V V and Drozdov M N 2017 Influence of CVD diamond growth conditions on nitrogen incorporation Diam. Relat. Mat. 72 1-6 [140] [141] Ohno K, Heremans F J, Bassett L C, Myers B A, Toyli D M, Jayich A C B, Palmstrøm C J and Awschalom D D 2012 Engineering shallow spins in diamond with nitrogen delta-doping Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 082413 [142] Samlenski R, Haug C, Brenn R, Wild C, Locher R and Koidl P 1995 Incorporation of nitrogen in chemical vapor deposition diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 67 2798-800 [143] Edmonds A M, D'Haenens-Johansson U F S, Cruddace R J, Newton M E, Fu K M C, Santori C, Beausoleil R G, Twitchen D J and Markham M L 2012 Production of oriented nitrogen-vacancy color centers in synthetic diamond Phys.Rev. B 86 035201 [144] Khan R U A, Cann B L, Martineau P M, Samartseva J, Freeth J J P, Sibley S J, Hartland C B, Newton M E, Dhillon H K and Twitchen D J 2013 Colour-causing defects and their related optoelectronic transitions in single crystal CVD diamond Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 25 275801 [145] Khan R U A, Martineau P M, Cann B L, Newton M E and Twitchen D J 2009 Charge transfer effects, thermo and photochromism in single crystal CVD synthetic diamond Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 21 364214 [146] Goss J P, Briddon P R, Hill V, Jones R and Rayson M J 2014 Identification of the structure of the 3107 cm−1H-related defect in diamond Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 26 145801 [147] Tallaire A, Mayer L, Brinza O, Pinault-Thaury M A, Debuisschert T and Achard J 2017 Highly photostable NV centre ensembles in CVD diamond produced by using N2O as the doping gas Appl. Phys. Lett. 111 143101 [148] Dhomkar S, Jayakumar H, Zangara P R and Meriles C A 2018 Charge Dynamics in near-Surface, Variable-Density Ensembles of Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Diamond Nano Letters 18 4046-52 [149] Bolshakov A, Ralchenko V, Sedov V, Khomich A, Vlasov I, Khomich A, Trofimov N, Krivobok V, Nikolaev S, Khmelnitskii R and Saraykin V 2015 Photoluminescence of SiV centers in single crystal CVD diamond in situ doped with Si from silane Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 212 2525 -- 32 [150] Sedov V, Martyanov A, Savin S, Bolshakov A, Bushuev E, Khomich A, Kudryavtsev O, Krivobok V, Nikolaev S and Ralchenko V 2018 Growth of polycrystalline and single-crystal CVD diamonds with bright photoluminescence of Ge-V color centers using germane GeH4 as the dopant source Diam. Relat. Mat. 90 47-53 [151] Häussler S, Thiering G, Dietrich A, Waasem N, Teraji T, Isoya J, Iwasaki T, Hatano M, Jelezko F, Gali A and Kubanek A 2017 Photoluminescence excitation spectroscopy of SiV−and GeV−color center in diamond New Journal of Physics 19 063036 [152] Mehmel L, Issaoui R, Tallaire A, Mille V, Brinza O, Nicolas L, Hétet G and Achard J 2018 Self- Assembled Silica Nanoparticles for Diamond Nano-Structuration Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 215 1800391 [153] Ohmagari S, Koizumi H, tsubouchi N, Barjon J, Haenen K and Pernot J 2018 Power Electronics Device Applications of Diamond Semiconductors, ed S Koizumi, H Umezawa, J Pernot and M Suzuki (Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing) pp 99-189 [154] Teraji T 2015 High-quality and high-purity homoepitaxial diamond (100) film growth under high oxygen concentration condition J. Appl. Phys. 118 115304 [155] Fuchs G D, Burkard G, Klimov P V and Awschalom D D 2011 A quantum memory intrinsic to single nitrogen -- vacancy centres in diamond Nature Physics 7 789-93 [156] Eisenach E R, Barry J F, Pham L M, Rojas R G, Englund D R and Braje D A 2018 Broadband loop gap resonator for nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond Review of Scientific Instruments 89 094705 [157] Achard J, Silva F, Brinza O, Tallaire A and Gicquel A 2007 Coupled effect of nitrogen addition and surface temperature on the morphology and the kinetics of thick CVD diamond single crystals Diam. Relat. Mat. 16 685-9 [158] Meng Y-f, Yan C-s, Krasnicki S, Liang Q, Lai J, Shu H, Yu T, Steele A, Mao H-k and Hemley R J 2012 High optical quality multicarat single crystal diamond produced by chemical vapor deposition Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 209 101-4 Jones R 2009 Dislocations, vacancies and the brown colour of CVD and natural diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 18 820-6 Lawson S C, Fisher D, Hunt D C and Newton M E 1998 On the existence of positively charged single- substitutional nitrogen in diamond Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 10 6171-80 [159] [160] [161] Meng Y-f, Yan C-s, Lai J, Krasnicki S, Shu H, Yu T, Liang Q, Mao H-k and Hemley R J 2008 Enhanced optical properties of chemical vapor deposited single crystal diamond by low-pressure/high- temperature annealing PNAS 105 17620-5 [162] Kleinsasser E E, Stanfield M M, Banks J K Q, Zhu Z, Li W-D, Acosta V M, Watanabe H, Itoh K M and Fu K-M C 2016 High density nitrogen-vacancy sensing surface created via He+ ion implantation of 12C diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 108 202401 [163] Botsoa J, Sauvage T, Adam M-P, Desgardin P, Leoni E, Courtois B, Treussart F and Barthe M-F 2011 Optimal conditions for NV− center formation in type-1b diamond studied using photoluminescence and positron annihilation spectroscopies Phys.Rev. B 84 125209 [164] Barry J F, Turner M J, Schloss J M, Glenn D R, Song Y, Lukin M D, Park H and Walsworth R L 2016 Optical magnetic detection of single-neuron action potentials using quantum defects in diamond Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 113 14133 [165] Aslam N, Waldherr G, Neumann P, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2013 Photo-induced ionization dynamics of the nitrogen vacancy defect in diamond investigated by single-shot charge state detection New Journal of Physics 15 013064 [166] Manson N B and Harrison J P 2005 Photo-ionization of the nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 14 1705-10 [167] Manson N B, Hedges M, Barson M S J, Ahlefeldt R, Doherty M W, Abe H, Ohshima T and Sellars M J 2018 NV− -- N+ pair centre in 1b diamond New Journal of Physics 20 113037 [168] Mita Y 1996 Change of absorption spectra in type-Ib diamond with heavy neutron irradiation Phys.Rev. B 53 11360-4 [169] Doi Y, Fukui T, Kato H, Makino T, Yamasaki S, Tashima T, Morishita H, Miwa S, Jelezko F, Suzuki Y and Mizuochi N 2016 Pure negatively charged state of the NV center in $n$-type diamond Phys.Rev. B 93 081203 [170] Groot-Berning K, Raatz N, Dobrinets I, Lesik M, Spinicelli P, Tallaire A, Achard J, Jacques V, Roch J-F, Zaitsev A M, Meijer J and Pezzagna S 2014 Passive charge state control of nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond using phosphorous and boron doping Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 211 2268-73 [171] Murai T, Makino T, Kato H, Shimizu M, Murooka T, Herbschleb E D, Doi Y, Morishita H, Fujiwara M, Hatano M, Yamasaki S and Mizuochi N 2018 Engineering of Fermi level by nin diamond junction for control of charge states of NV centers Appl. Phys. Lett. 112 111903 [172] Pinault-Thaury M-A, Stenger I, Jomard F, Chevallier J, Barjon J, Traore A, Eon D and Pernot J 2015 Electrical activity of (100) n-type diamond with full donor site incorporation of phosphorus Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 212 2454 -- 9 [173] Kato H, Wolfer M, Schreyvogel C, Kunzer M, Müller-Sebert W, Obloh H, Yamasaki S and Nebel C 2013 Tunable light emission from nitrogen-vacancy centers in single crystal diamond PIN diodes Appl. Phys. Lett. 102 151101 [174] Maier F, Riedel M, Mantel B, Ristein J and Ley L 2000 Origin of Surface Conductivity in Diamond Physical Review Letters 85 3472 [175] Fu K M C, Santori C, Barclay P E and Beausoleil R G 2010 Conversion of neutral nitrogen-vacancy centers to negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy centers through selective oxidation Appl. Phys. Lett. 96 121907 [176] Schreyvogel C, Wolfer M, Kato H, Schreck M and Nebel C E 2014 Tuned NV emission by in-plane Al- Schottky junctions on hydrogen terminated diamond Scientific Reports 4 3634 [177] Alsid S T, Barry J F, Pham L M, Schloss J M, O'Keeffe M F, Cappellaro P and Braje D A 2019 Photoluminescence Decomposition Analysis: A Technique to Characterize N-V Creation in Diamond Physical Review Applied 12 044003 [178] Siyushev P, Pinto H, Vörös M, Gali A, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2013 Optically Controlled Switching of the Charge State of a Single Nitrogen-Vacancy Center in Diamond at Cryogenic Temperatures Physical Review Letters 110 167402 [179] Bourgeois E, Londero E, Buczak K, Hruby J, Gulka M, Balasubramaniam Y, Wachter G, Stursa J, Dobes K, Aumayr F, Trupke M, Gali A and Nesladek M 2017 Enhanced photoelectric detection of NV magnetic resonances in diamond under dual-beam excitation Phys.Rev. B 95 041402 [180] Solà-Garcia M, Meuret S, Coenen T and Polman A 2019 Electron-induced state conversion in diamond NV centers measured with pump-probe cathodoluminescence spectroscopy arXiv 1910.04524 [181] Hopper D A, Grote R R, Exarhos A L and Bassett L C 2016 Near-infrared-assisted charge control and spin readout of the nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond Phys.Rev. B 94 241201 [182] Dhomkar S, Zangara P R, Henshaw J and Meriles C A 2018 On-Demand Generation of Neutral and Negatively Charged Silicon-Vacancy Centers in Diamond Physical Review Letters 120 117401 [183] Steinert S, Ziem F, Hall L T, Zappe A, Schweikert M, Götz N, Aird A, Balasubramanian G, Hollenberg L and Wrachtrup J 2013 Magnetic spin imaging under ambient conditions with sub-cellular resolution Nature Communications 4 1607 [184] El-Hajj H, Denisenko A, Bergmaier A, Dollinger G, Kubovic M and Kohn E 2008 Characteristics of boron -doped diamond for electronic applications Diam. Relat. Mat. 17 409-14 [185] Chicot G, Tran Thi T N, Fiori A, Jomard F, Gheeraert E, Bustarret E and Pernot J 2012 Hole transport in boron delta-doped diamond structures Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 162101 [186] Ofori-Okai B K, Pezzagna S, Chang K, Loretz M, Schirhagl R, Tao Y, Moores B A, Groot-Berning K, Meijer J and Degen C L 2012 Spin properties of very shallow nitrogen vacancy defects in diamond Phys.Rev. B 86 081406 [187] Naydenov B, Richter V, Beck J, Steiner M, Neumann P, Balasubramanian G, Achard J, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J and Kalish R 2010 Enhanced generation of single optically active spins in diamond by ion implantation Appl. Phys. Lett. 96 163108 [188] Yamamoto T, Müller C, McGuinness L P, Teraji T, Naydenov B, Onoda S, Ohshima T, Wrachtrup J, Jelezko F and Isoya J 2013 Strongly coupled diamond spin qubits by molecular nitrogen implantation Phys.Rev. B 88 201201 [189] Markham M L, Dodson J M, Scarsbrook G A, Twitchen D J, Balasubramanian G, Jelezko F and [190] Wrachtrup J 2011 CVD diamond for spintronics Diam. Relat. Mat. 20 134-9 Ishikawa T, Fu K-M C, Santori C, Acosta V M, Beausoleil R G, Watanabe H, Shikata S and Itoh K M 2012 Optical and Spin Coherence Properties of Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers Placed in a 100 nm Thick Isotopically Purified Diamond Layer Nano Letters 12 2083-7 [191] Ohashi K, Rosskopf T, Watanabe H, Loretz M, Tao Y, Hauert R, Tomizawa S, Ishikawa T, Ishi-Hayase J, Shikata S, Degen C L and Itoh K M 2013 Negatively Charged Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in a 5 nm Thin 12C Diamond Film Nano Letters 13 4733-8 [192] Ohno K, Joseph Heremans F, Bassett L C, Myers B A, Toyli D M, Bleszynski Jayich A C, Palmstrøm C J and Awschalom D D 2012 Engineering shallow spins in diamond with nitrogen delta-doping Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 082413 [193] Teraji T and Ito T 2004 Homoepitaxial diamond growth by high-power microwave-plasma chemical vapor deposition J. Cryst. Growth 271 409-19 [194] Osterkamp C, Mangold M, Lang J, Balasubramanian P, Teraji T, Naydenov B and Jelezko F 2019 Engineering preferentially-aligned nitrogen-vacancy centre ensembles in CVD grown diamond Scientific Reports 9 5786 [195] Ohno K, Joseph Heremans F, de las Casas C F, Myers B A, Alemán B J, Bleszynski Jayich A C and Awschalom D D 2014 Three-dimensional localization of spins in diamond using 12C implantation Appl. Phys. Lett. 105 052406 [196] Tallaire A, Achard J, Secroun A, De Gryse O, De Weerdt F, Barjon J, Silva F and Gicquel A 2006 Multiple growth and characterization of thick diamond single crystals using chemical vapour deposition working in pulsed mode J. Cryst. Growth 291 533-9 [197] Wu G, Chen M H and Liao J 2016 The influence of recess depth and crystallographic orientation of seed sides on homoepitaxial growth of CVD single crystal diamonds Diam. Relat. Mat. 65 144-51 [198] Nebel C and Muller-Sebert W 2017 Coating system and coating method Patent n° WO 2017/036543 [199] Widmann C J, Müller-Sebert W, Lang N and Nebel C E 2016 Homoepitaxial growth of single crystalline CVD-diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 64 1-7 [200] Romach Y, Müller C, Unden T, Rogers L J, Isoda T, Itoh K M, Markham M, Stacey A, Meijer J, Pezzagna S, Naydenov B, McGuinness L P, Bar-Gill N and Jelezko F 2015 Spectroscopy of Surface- Induced Noise Using Shallow Spins in Diamond Physical Review Letters 114 017601 [201] Myers B A, Das A, Dartiailh M C, Ohno K, Awschalom D D and Bleszynski Jayich A C 2014 Probing Surface Noise with Depth-Calibrated Spins in Diamond Physical Review Letters 113 027602 [202] Eichhorn T R, McLellan C A and Bleszynski Jayich A C 2019 Optimizing the formation of depth- confined nitrogen vacancy center spin ensembles in diamond for quantum sensing Phys. rev. Materials 3 113802 [203] Pham L M, DeVience S J, Casola F, Lovchinsky I, Sushkov A O, Bersin E, Lee J, Urbach E, Cappellaro P, Park H, Yacoby A, Lukin M and Walsworth R L 2016 NMR technique for determining the depth of shallow nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Phys.Rev. B 93 045425 [204] Tetienne J P, Hingant T, Rondin L, Cavaillès A, Mayer L, Dantelle G, Gacoin T, Wrachtrup J, Roch J F and Jacques V 2013 Spin relaxometry of single nitrogen-vacancy defects in diamond nanocrystals for magnetic noise sensing Phys.Rev. B 87 235436 [205] Pelliccione M, Myers B A, Pascal L M A, Das A and Bleszynski Jayich A C 2014 Two-Dimensional Nanoscale Imaging of Gadolinium Spins via Scanning Probe Relaxometry with a Single Spin in Diamond Physical Review Applied 2 054014 [206] Rosskopf T, Dussaux A, Ohashi K, Loretz M, Schirhagl R, Watanabe H, Shikata S, Itoh K M and Degen C L 2014 Investigation of Surface Magnetic Noise by Shallow Spins in Diamond Physical Review Letters 112 147602 [207] Sangtawesin S, Dwyer B L, Srinivasan S, Allred J J, Rodgers L V H, De Greve K, Stacey A, Dontschuk N, O'Donnell K M, Hu D, Evans D A, Jaye C, Fischer D A, Markham M L, Twitchen D J, Park H, Lukin M D and de Leon N P 2019 Origins of Diamond Surface Noise Probed by Correlating Single-Spin Measurements with Surface Spectroscopy Phys. Rev. X 9 031052 [208] Kaviani M, Deák P, Aradi B, Frauenheim T, Chou J-P and Gali A 2014 Proper Surface Termination for Luminescent Near-Surface NV Centers in Diamond Nano Letters 14 4772-7 [209] Osterkamp C, Lang J, Scharpf J, Müller C, McGuinness L P, Diemant T, Behm R J, Naydenov B and Jelezko F 2015 Stabilizing shallow color centers in diamond created by nitrogen delta-doping using SF6 plasma treatment Appl. Phys. Lett. 106 113109 [210] Stacey A, O'Donnell K M, Chou J-P, Schenk A, Tadich A, Dontschuk N, Cervenka J, Pakes C, Gali A, [211] Hoffman A and Prawer S 2015 Nitrogen Terminated Diamond Advanced Materials Interfaces 2 1500079 Li S, Chou J-P, Wei J, Sun M, Hu A and Gali A 2019 Oxygenated (113) diamond surface for nitrogen- vacancy quantum sensors with preferential alignment and long coherence time from first principles Carbon 145 273-80 [212] Favaro De Oliveira F, Momenzadeh S A, Wang Y, Konuma M, Markham M, Edmonds A M, Denisenko A and Wrachtrup J 2015 Effect of low-damage inductively coupled plasma on shallow nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 107 073107 [213] Staudacher T, Ziem F, Häussler L, Stöhr R, Steinert S, Reinhard F, Scharpf J, Denisenko A and Wrachtrup J 2012 Enhancing the spin properties of shallow implanted nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond by epitaxial overgrowth Appl. Phys. Lett. 101 212401 [214] Tallaire A, Barjon J, Brinza O, Achard J, Silva F, Mille V, Issaoui R, Tardieu A and Gicquel A 2011 [215] Dislocations and impurities introduced from etch-pits at the epitaxial growth resumption of diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 20 875-81 Lesik M, Raatz N, Tallaire A, Spinicelli P, John R, Achard J, Gicquel A, Jacques V, Roch J-F, Meijer J and Pezzagna S 2016 Production of bulk NV centre arrays by shallow implantation and diamond CVD overgrowth Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 213 2594 -- 600 [216] Stacey A, Karle T J, McGuinness L P, Gibson B C, Ganesan K, Tomljenovic‐Hanic S, Greentree A D, Hoffman A, Beausoleil R G and Prawer S 2012 Depletion of nitrogen‐vacancy color centers in diamond via hydrogen passivation Appl. Phys. Lett. 100 071902 [217] Geis M W, Efremow N N, Krohn K E, Twichell J C, Lyszczarz T M, Kalish R, Greer J A and Tabat M D 1998 A new surface electron-emission mechanism in diamond cathodes Nature 393 431-5 [218] Wang Q, Li J J, Jin A Z, Wang Z L, Xu P and Gu C Z 2006 The growth and characterization of diamond cone arrays formed by plasma etching Diam. Relat. Mat. 15 866-9 [219] Sun P, Tang C, Xia X, Yao Z, Quan B, Yuan G, Gu C and Li J 2016 Controlled fabrication of periodically high-aspect ratio CVD-diamond nanopillar arrays by pure oxygen etching process Microelectronic Engineering 155 61-6 [220] Widmann C J, Giese C, Wolfer M, Brink D, Heidrich N and Nebel C E 2015 Fabrication and characterization of single crystalline diamond nanopillars with NV-centers Diam. Relat. Mat. 54 2-8 [221] Maletinsky P, Hong S, Grinolds M S, Hausmann B, Lukin M D, Walsworth R L, Loncar M and Yacoby A 2012 A robust scanning diamond sensor for nanoscale imaging with single nitrogen-vacancy centres Nature Nanotechnology 7 320-4 [222] Neu E, Appel P, Ganzhorn M, Miguel-Sanchez J, Lesik M, Mille V, Jacques V, Tallaire A, Achard J and Maletinsky P 2014 Photonic nano-structures on (111) oriented diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 153108 [223] Felgen N, Naydenov B, Turner S, Jelezko F, Reithmaier J P and Popov C 2016 Incorporation and study of SiV centers in diamond nanopillars Diam. Relat. Mat. 64 64 -- 9 [224] Felgen N, Naydenov B, Jelezko F, Reithmaier J P and Popov C 2018 Homoepitaxial Diamond [225] Structures with Incorporated SiV Centers Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 215 1800371 Jaffe T, Felgen N, Gal L, Kornblum L, Reithmaier J P, Popov C and Orenstein M 2019 Deterministic Arrays of Epitaxially Grown Diamond Nanopyramids with Embedded Silicon-Vacancy Centers Advanced Optical Materials 7 1800715 [226] Dai B, Shu G, Ralchenko V, Bolshakov A, Sovyk D, Khomich A, Shershulin V, Liu K, Zhao J, Gao G, Yang L, Lei P, Zhu J and Han J 2017 2D inverse periodic opal structures in single crystal diamond with incorporated silicon-vacancy color centers Diam. Relat. Mat. 73 204-9 [227] Sovyk D N, Ralchenko V G, Tukmakov K N, Shershulin V A, Khomich A A, Vorobyov V V, Vlasov I I and Akimov A V 2016 Growth of CVD diamond nanopillars with imbedded silicon-vacancy color centers Optical Materials 61 25-9 [228] Neu E and Becher C 2014 Quantum Information Processing with Diamond, ed S Prawer and I Aharonovich (Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing) pp 127-59 [229] Kato H, Makino T, Ogura M, Takeuchi D and Yamasaki S 2013 Fabrication of bipolar junction transistor on (001)-oriented diamond by utilizing phosphorus-doped n-type diamond base Diam. Relat. Mat. 34 41-4 [230] Brinza O, Achard J, Silva F, Bonnin X, Barroy P, De Corte K and Gicquel A 2008 Dependence of CVD diamond growth rate on substrate orientation as a function of process parameters in the high microwave power density regime Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 205 2114-20 [231] Wild C, Kohl R, Herres N, Muller-Sebert W and Koidl P 1994 Oriented CVD diamond films: twin formation, structure and morphology Diam. Relat. Mat. 3 373-81 [232] Achard J and Tallaire A 2018 Power Electronics Device Applications of Diamond Semiconductors, ed S Koizumi, H Umezawa, J Pernot and M Suzuki (Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing) pp 1-27 [233] Chu C J, D'Evelyn M P, Hauge R H and Margrave J L 1991 Mechanism of diamond growth by chemical vapor deposition on diamond (100), (111), and (110) surfaces: Carbon-13 studies J. Appl. Phys. 70 1695-705 [234] Kamo M, Yurimato H and Sato Y 1988 Epitaxial growth of diamond on diamond substrate by plasma assited CVD Appl. Surf. Sci. 33-34 553-60 [235] Sternberg M, Kaukonen M, Nieminen R M and Frauenheim T 2001 Growth of (110) diamond using pure dicarbon Phys.Rev. B 63 165414 [236] Silva F, Achard J, Brinza O, Bonnin X, Hassouni K, Anthonis A, De Corte K and Barjon J 2009 High quality, large surface area, homoepitaxial MPACVD diamond growth Diam. Relat. Mat. 18 682-97 [237] Martineau P M, Gaukroger M P, Khan R and Evans D A 2009 Effect of steps on dislocations in CVD diamond grown on {001} substrates. Phys. Stat. Sol. (c) 6 1953-6 [238] Pham L M, Bar-Gill N, Le Sage D, Belthangady C, Stacey A, Markham M, Twitchen D J, Lukin M D and Walsworth R L 2012 Enhanced metrology using preferential orientation of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Phys.Rev. B 86 121202 [239] Fukui T, Doi Y, Miyazak T, Miyamoto Y, Kato H, Matsumoto T, Makimoto T, Yamasaki S, Morimoto R, Tokuda N, Hatano M, Sakagawa Y, Morishita H, Tashima T, Miwa S, Suzuki Y and Mizuochi N 2014 Perfect selective alignment of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Applied Physics Express 7 055201 Lesik M, Tetienne J-P, Tallaire A, Achard J, Mille V, Gicquel A, Roch J-F and Jacques V 2014 Perfect preferential orientation of nitrogen-vacancy defects in a synthetic diamond sample Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 113107 [240] [241] Michl J, Teraji T, Zaiser S, Jakobi I, Waldherr G, Dolde F, Neumann P, Doherty M W, Manson N B, Isoya J and Wrachtrup J 2014 Perfect alignment and preferential orientation of nitrogen-vacancy centers during chemical vapor deposition diamond growth on (111) surfaces Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 102407 [242] Tahara K, Ozawa H, Iwasaki T, Mizuochi N and Hatano M 2015 Quantifying selective alignment of ensemble nitrogen-vacancy centers in (111) diamond Appl. Phys. Lett. 107 193110 [243] Grillo S E and Field J E 1997 The polishing of diamond J. Phys. D 30 202-9 [244] Schuelke T and Grotjohn T A 2013 Diamond polishing Diam. Relat. Mat. 32 17-26 [245] Evan L H T, Soumen M, Emmanuel B B and Oliver A W 2014 Silica based polishing of {100} and {111} single crystal diamond Science and Technology of Advanced Materials 15 035013 [246] Watanabe J, Touge M and Sakamoto T 2013 Ultraviolet-irradiated precision polishing of diamond and its related materials Diam. Relat. Mat. 39 14-9 [247] Yan C S and Vohra Y K 1999 Multiple twinning and nitrogen defect center in chemical vapor deposited homoepitaxial diamond Diam. Relat. Mat. 8 2022-31 [248] Sakaguchi I, Nishitani-Gamo M, Loh K P, Haneda H and Ando T 1999 Hydrogen incorporation control in high quality homoepitaxial diamond (111) growth Diam. Relat. Mat. 8 1291-5 [249] Kasu M, Makimoto T, Ebert W and Kohn E 2003 Formation of stacking faults containing microtwins in (111) chemical-vapor-deposited diamond homoepitaxial layers Appl. Phys. Lett. 83 3465-7 [250] Mortet V, Daenen M, Teraji T, Lazea A, Vorlicek V, D'Haen J, Haenen K and D'Olieslaeger M 2008 Characterization of boron doped diamond epilayers grown in a NIRIM type reactor Diam. Relat. Mat. 17 1330-4 [251] Tokuda N, Ogura M, Matsumoto T, Yamasaki S and Inokuma T 2016 Influence of substrate misorientation on the surface morphology of homoepitaxial diamond (111) films Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 213 2051 -- 5 [252] Norio T, Masahiko O, Satoshi Y and Takao I 2014 Anisotropic lateral growth of homoepitaxial diamond (111) films by plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition J. J. Appl. Phys. 53 04EH [253] Norio T, Toshiharu M, Takao I and Satoshi Y 2012 Formation of Step-Free Surfaces on Diamond (111) Mesas by Homoepitaxial Lateral Growth J. J. Appl. Phys. 51 090107 [254] Butler J E and Oleynik I 2008 A mechanism for crystal twinning in the growth of diamond by chemical vapour deposition Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 366 295-311 [255] Ozawa H, Tahara K, Ishiwata H, Hatano M and Iwasaki T 2017 Formation of perfectly aligned nitrogen-vacancy-center ensembles in chemical-vapor-deposition-grown diamond (111) Applied Physics Express 10 045501 [256] Ozawa H, Ishiwata H, Hatano M and Iwasaki T 2018 Thermal Stability of Perfectly Aligned Nitrogen- [257] Vacancy Centers for High Sensitive Magnetometers Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 215 1800342 Lesik M, Plays T, Tallaire A, Achard J, Brinza O, William L, Chipaux M, Toraille L, Debuisschert T, Gicquel A, Roch J F and Jacques V 2015 Preferential orientation of NV defects in CVD diamond films grown on (113)-oriented substrates Diam. Relat. Mat. 56 47-53 [258] Snail K A, Lu Z P, Weimer R, Heberlein J, Pfender E and Hanssen L M 1994 Confirmation of {113} [259] facets on diamond grown by chemical vapor deposition J. Cryst. Growth 137 676-9 Janssen G, Schermer J J, van-Enckevort W J P and Giling L J 1992 On the occurrence of {113} facets on CVD-grown diamond J. Cryst. Growth 125 42-50 [260] Bird D M, Clarke L J, King-Smith R D, Payne M C, Stich I and Sutton A P 1992 First principles calculation of the structure and energy of Si(113) Physical Review Letters 69 3785 [261] Dabrowski J, Müssig H J and Wolff G 1994 Atomic Structure of Clean Si(113) Surfaces: Theory and Experiment Physical Review Letters 73 1660 [262] Teraji T, Mitani S and Ito T 2003 High rate growth and luminescence properties of high-quality homoepitaxial diamond (100) films Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 198 395-406 [263] Chouaieb S, Martínez L J, Akhtar W, Robert-Philip I, Dréau A, Brinza O, Achard J, Tallaire A and Jacques V 2019 Optimizing synthetic diamond samples for quantum sensing technologies by tuning the growth temperature Diam. Relat. Mat. 96 85-9 [264] Childress L, Gurudev Dutt M V, Taylor J M, Zibrov A S, Jelezko F, Wrachtrup J, Hemmer P R and Lukin M D 2006 Coherent Dynamics of Coupled Electron and Nuclear Spin Qubits in Diamond Science 314 281-5 [265] Mizuochi N, Neumann P, Rempp F, Beck J, Jacques V, Siyushev P, Nakamura K, Twitchen D J, Watanabe H, Yamasaki S, Jelezko F and Wrachtrup J 2009 Coherence of single spins coupled to a nuclear spin bath of varying density Phys.Rev. B 80 041201
1802.02057	2	1802	2018-05-07T08:10:51	Adaptive operation strategy for voltage stability enhancement in active DMFCs	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	An adaptive operation strategy for on-demand control of active direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) is proposed as an alternative method to enhance the voltage stability. A simplified semi-empirical model is firstly developed to describe I-V relationships based on uniform-designed experiments. It is then embedded into multi-objective optimizations to construct the adaptive operation strategy. Experimental studies are implemented on different DMFC systems to validate the proposed semi-empirical model, control strategy and system response to operational adjustments. Numerical simulations are also performed to investigate the underlying mechanisms of the proposed adaptive operation strategy. The results show that the adaptive operation strategy provides possibilities for voltage stability enhancement without the sacrifice of energy conversion efficiency. The adaptive operations are also found to be able to extend the range of operating current density or to decrease the voltage deviation according to one's requirements. Moreover, the response of DMFCs to operational adjustments is quick, which further validates the effectiveness and feasibility of the adaptive operation strategy in practical applications. The proposed strategy contributes to a guideline for the better control of output voltage from operating DMFC systems.	physics.app-ph	physics	Adaptive operation strategy for voltage stability enhancement in active DMFCs Qin-Wen YANGa, Xu-Qu HUa,∗, Xiu-Cheng LEIa, Ying ZHUa, Xing-Yi WANGa, Sheng-Cheng JIb aState Key Laboratory of Advanced Design and Manufacturing for Vehicle Body, College of Mechanical and Vehicle Engineering, Hunan University, Changsha, 410082, China bBeijing Aeronautical Science & Technology Research Institute of COMAC, Beijing, 102211, China Abstract An adaptive operation strategy for on-demand control of active direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) is proposed as an alternative method to enhance the volt- age stability. A simplified semi-empirical model is firstly developed to describe I-V relationships based on uniform-designed experiments. It is then embedded into multi-objective optimizations to construct the adaptive operation strategy. Experimental studies are implemented on different DMFC systems to validate the proposed semi-empirical model, control strategy and system response to op- erational adjustments. Numerical simulations are also performed to investigate the underlying mechanisms of the proposed adaptive operation strategy. The results show that the adaptive operation strategy provides possibilities for volt- age stability enhancement without the sacrifice of energy conversion efficiency. The adaptive operations are also found to be able to extend the range of op- erating current density or to decrease the voltage deviation according to ones ∗Corresponding author Email address: [email protected] (Xu-Qu HU) Preprint submitted to Energy Conversion and Management May 8, 2018 requirements. Moreover, the response of DMFCs to operational adjustments is quick, which further validates the effectiveness and feasibility of the adaptive operation strategy in practical applications. The proposed strategy contributes to a guideline for the better control of output voltage from operating DMFC systems. Keywords: Direct Methanol Fuel Cell, Operation strategy, Multi-objective optimization 1. Introduction Direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) has emerged in recent years as a promising power source for various kinds of electronic devices [1, 2]. It can provide high energy density and almost instant recharging with simple system configurations [3, 4]. But to move towards real-time operations of DMFCs that meet a com- mercially acceptable standard, further improvements are still needed especially in the fields of systematic stability [5, 6, 7, 8]. During the past decades, lots of research efforts have been dedicated to enhance the system stability of fuel cells by improving the catalyst loading [9, 10], the fuel cell structure [11, 12, 13, 14], the fuel delivery system [3, 15] and the water management [16, 17], etc. One problem that received relatively less attention is the voltage instabil- ity. Because of the over-potential effects, the output voltage from DMFCs is inevitably unsteady as the current density is often required to change in a wide range during practical applications. An obvious voltage deviation is, therefore, frequently encountered even if the DMFC was assumed to be operated in the theoretical ohmic loss range [15, 18]. Many published experimental results have 2 shown that the output voltage could be very sensitive to a small variation of current density [10, 13, 19]. Although the voltage stabilizers can be helpful to a certain extent, an operation strategy is also in great need to avoid additional energy loss caused by voltage stabilizations. Moreover, it can be necessary while the voltage deviation is beyond the input limit of voltage stabilizers. Several control strategies have been applied to analyze and enhance the system stability of DMFCs [20, 21], such as PID control algorithms [22], neural network methods [23], model predictive control schemes [24, 25], fuzzy logic [26] and extremum seeking controls [27]. However, most of them were designed to work under the assumption of small disturbance (or little noise). Since the operating conditions in commercial electric equipments would change sharply, the influence of large disturbance on the voltage stability needs to be taken into account. An adaptive operation strategy that is suitable for considering large disturbance in complex operating conditions becomes the initial motivation of the present study. However, it is full of challenges, as it involves accurate modeling of DMFC systems to study the underlying mechanisms of multiple operating parameters. During the past decades, several mechanical models were proposed to study the energy conversion process of DMFCs, from one-dimensional [28, 29], two- dimensional [7, 30, 31, 32] to three-dimensional [33, 34] point of view. Consid- ering about large variations of operating parameters, we have proposed an ef- fective semi-empirical model to describe I-V relationship and developed a three- dimensional Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) model to study the DMFC 3 performance [35]. More recently, it has been successfully applied to determine the optimal operating conditions in DMFC systems [36]. Although the effects of operating conditions (such as temperature, methanol concentration and so- lution/air flow rates) on the DMFC performance can be well estimated using those existing models [37, 38, 39], an effective operation strategy can still be necessary for determine appropriate operational adjustments to enhance voltage stability in practical applications. In the present study, an adaptive operation strategy is developed. Its perfor- mance and underlying mechanisms have also been systematically studied using analytical, numerical and experimental techniques. The strategy establishment is presented in details in Section 2. The theoretical, experimental and numerical studies about the necessity, feasibility and superiority of the proposed strategy are organized in Section 3. Experimental validations about the semi-empirical model, control strategy and system response are provided in Section 4. Conclu- sions and perspectives were summarized in Section 5. 2. Methods and models The adaptive operation strategy is developed based on the integration of experimental, analytical and numerical techniques. Uniform-designed experi- ments are firstly performed to study the I-V relationships under various groups of operating parameters. A simplified semi-empirical model is then developed to quantitatively describe DMFC performances in experiments. Based on the semi-empirical model, the adaptive operation strategy is developed using multi- 4 objective optimizations. The underlying mechanism of adaptive DMFC opera- tions are also studied using numerical simulations. 2.1. Experimental setup and design Figure 1: Experimental platform of a single-cell DMFC system. Fig. 1 shows the experimental platform applied in the present study. A single-cell DMFC stack (TeskStak, Parker Hannifin Energy Systems) consists of a five-layer Membrane Electrode Assembly (MEA) sandwiched by two graphite end plates (for anode and cathode). Serpentine flow channel of 12 U-turns is integrated inside the end plates, which takes a rectangular cross-section (30.94 × 30.65 mm2) and a total length of 415.06 mm. At the anode side, the methanol solution composed by deionized water and pure methanol is flowed into the chan- nel by a peristaltic pump (BT300LC). At the cathode side, an air compressor (OUTSTANDING OTS-550) regulated by a rotameter (OMEGA FMA-2605A) is used to pump the air into the fuel cell. The working temperature of the DMFC stack is maintained by a supplementary heating apparatus that is controlled by a temperature controller (Omega CSC32). An electronic load device (ITECH 5 it8211) is used to change the current density to different levels and to measure the corresponding values of the voltage. The DMFC performance is monitored by an electrochemical workstation (CHI660E), while the production of CO2 is measured by a CO2 concentration detector (JA500-CO2-IR1). Table 1: Value ranges of main operating parameters. Name Temperature (K) Air flow rate (ccm) Value range [298, 343] [81.2, 186] Name Value range Methanol concentration (M) Feed solution flow rate (ccm) [0.25, 2] [3.5, 5.5] Four main operating parameters are considered in experimental study, in- cluding the working temperature (T ), the methanol concentration (CM ), the in- put flow rates of feed methanol solution (FM ) and air (FA). The value ranges of operating parameters are determined according to literature review and practi- cal experience, as summarized in Table 1. Based on the uniform design principal, a systematic experimental work is designed to study the influence of operating parameters [40]. As five levels are selected for each operating parameters, 65 ex- perimental tests are designed and performed. Among them, 45 cases are decided by uniform design, and the other 20 ones are supplementary for the analysis of DMFC performance degradation. Details about the operating parameters for these uniform-designed experimental cases are summarized in Appendix, Table A.4. 2.2. Semi-empirical model Since the degradation of DMFC performance was observed in experiments, a linear regression method is applied in the collection process of experimental 6 data [35, 41]. Careful investigation is implemented to analyze the compensated experimental data, and a semi-empirical model can be deduced to describe the relationship between the operating parameters and the output voltage. A semi-empirical model was successfully developed to quantify the influence of main operating parameters on the DMFC output in our previous studies [33, 35]. However, it contains a large number of undetermined coefficients which requires considerable computation cost for identification. A simplified semi- empirical model with less coefficients is then proposed in the present study, which can be expressed as, Vcell = Vth + k1T + k2T ln(CM ) + k3T ln(FA) + k4 − k5e(k6/T +k7)j − (k8j2 + k9T + k10C2 M + k11CM + k12) ×"ln(j) + k13 + k14ln CM − 1 k15e(−k16 /T )CM !# j (1) − (k17j + k18T + k19C2 M + k20CM + k21) × [ln(j) + k22ln(FA) + k23] + k24j2ln(FM ), where Vcell and j are the output voltage and the current density, respectively. Vth denotes the reversible 'no-loss' voltage which theoretically equals to 1.21 V. T , CM , FM and FA denote the operating parameters as mentioned above, and ki (i = 1, 2, ..., 24) denotes different undetermined coefficient. Generally speaking, this model is based on electrochemical theory and constructed through 7 integration of three sub-models, i.e., the open circuit sub-model (k1-k4), the resistance sub-model (k5-k7) and the closed circuit one (k8-k24). For coefficient identifications, the reference data can be collected from more than 65 experimental tests based on the principal of uniform design (as men- tioned in Section 2.1). Firstly, the coefficients in resistance sub-model are ob- tained through regression of experimental data of area-specific resistance varying with temperatures. The coefficients in open circuit sub-model can be then de- termined by regression of experimental results of open circuit voltage changing with operating parameters. Finally, the rest coefficients in closed circuit sub- model are identified through nonlinear regression of experimental I-V curves. The determined coefficients are listed as follows, k1 = −3.7534 × 10−5, k2 = −3.1534 × 10−4, k3 = 6.6200 × 10−5, k4 = −0.7499, k5 = 6.9897, k6 = 916.91, k7 = −4.6392, k8 = −0.8801, k9 = −0.5791, k10 = −4.8053, k11 = 4.8053, k12 = −1.2135, k13 = −36.4865, k14 = 2.8580 × 10−4, k15 = 5.34657 × 107, k16 = 5182.4, k17 = −0.1160, k18 = 0.5793, k19 = 4.8062, k20 = −4.8062, k21 = 1.2016, k22 = −8.2586 × 10−4, k23 = −36.4679 and k24 = 29.8714. A parameter sensitivity analysis about the quantitative effects of the main operating parameters on the output voltage is performed based on the statistics package Minitab (Fig. 2). It shows that the output voltage is sensitive to all the four main operating parameters, even if the change of methanol flow rate seems to take relatively small effect compared with the other three parameters. A systematic trend is observed for all the four parameters, with the voltage deviations from its mean trending largest at the extreme ranges of those pa- 8 Figure 2: Contributions of main operating parameters to output voltage. rameters. Moreover, the increase of methanol concentration is observed to be accompanied by a decrease of output voltage, but the situation for the other three parameters reverses. This quantitative analysis could provide a parame- ter control guideline for engineers, which could also be highly beneficial for the design of our operation strategy. 2.3. Adaptive operation strategy A commercial power source is usually required to provide a steady voltage output Vset, while its operating current density varies in a range of [jmin, jmax]. However, the problem of large voltage deviation is frequently encountered in unoptimized DMFC operations (Fig. 3 (A)). It would worsen the performance of control systems and increase the difficulty for practical uses of DMFC systems. The enhancement of voltage stability around Vset with current density varying in [jmin, jmax] is thus one of the critical issues for the commercialization of DMFC 9 Control System DMFC Stack Electronic Load B4/C5 Determined operating parameters ( , T C F F , , m m air B3/C4 Optimization method C3 ) B2 Required operating voltage and current density range ( setV , j min , j max ) Objective function for multi objective optimization Unoptimized operation Regular optimization Adaptive optimization A V Large voltage deviation jmin jmax j Decreased voltage deviation B V Vset C V Vset jinterval,1 ... jinterval,n ... a% -a% jmin jmax j Adaptive curve section number n Adaptive operating parameters m , , T C F F ( , air (cid:712) (cid:712) n 1 2, ... i m , ) j i B1/C1 Simplified semi-empirical jmin jmax j V cell model f T C F F ( , , , m m air , j ) C2 Voltage deviation constraints , j min j max , , %) a V j V set j int erval i , , - ° ® °¯ , j j min > 1, 2, 3,...., max @ n , j i V j V set subject to V set d a % ( setV Figure 3: Schematic of operation strategies for DMFC systems. systems. Optimized operation strategies are then proposed for such purpose in this section. It is of importance to notice that the following optimizations are all based on our simplified semi-empirical model (see Section 2.2), as it provides a fast and reliable way to determine the output voltage from a specific current density j and the corresponding operating parameters. A regular optimization strategy (Fig. 3 (B)) can be deduced by direct uti- lizations of classical optimization methods, such as genetic algorithm (GA) or particle swarm optimization (PSO). More specifically, the classical optimization method is used to minimize the voltage deviation Vcell −Vset in the full range of required current density [jmin, jmax] and determine the specific group of operat- ing parameters [T, CM , FM , FA], as shown in Fig. 3 (B1-B4). Compared with unoptimized cases, the regular optimization could decrease the voltage devia- 10 tion to a certain degree. However, it can only provide one single I-V curve, for which the voltage stability could still not guarantee the relatively small voltage deviation ±a% permitted in practical use. As the I-V curves can be switched by adjusting operating parameters, an appropriate operational adjustment can be highly beneficial for the enhancement of voltage stability in DMFC systems. Inspired by the logical deductions as mentioned above, an adaptive operation strategy is further proposed as demonstrated in Fig. 3 (C). Its main idea lies in the determinations of appropriate adjustments of operating parameters, to fulfill the required small voltage deviation ±a% and the large range of working current density [jmin, jmax] (Fig. 3 (C1-C2)). Such a real-time adjustment brings out a switch of I-V curves, the modified DMFC performance is then described by an integration of serval sections from different I-V curves. The determinations of each I-V curve section involve two objectives, which are the minimization of voltage deviation Vcell − Vset and the maximization of each current density interval jinterval. A multi-objective optimization model is then proposed (Fig. 3 (C3)), which can be expressed as min f (x, jinterval) = min{w1[V (j0, x) − V (j0 + jinteral, x)] + w2 s.t.   f or V (j0, x) − Vset Vset ≤ a%, V (j0 + jinterval, x) − Vset Vset ≤ a%, j ∈ [jmin, jmax], 1 jinterval }, (2) 11 where j0 is the starting current density for each section, and x denotes a ran- dom series of operating parameters (i.e., [T, CM , FM , FA]). The main multi- objective function f is designed to be composed by two parts, one 'voltage- deviation' subfunction Vj0 − Vj0+jinterval measures the voltage variation for a specific I-V curve section, and the other 'interval' subfunction 1 jinterval accounts for the effect of operating range of current density of each I-V curve sections. The weighting factors for each subfunctions, w1 and w2, can be adapted to one's specific requirements. During program implementations, the constraint of permitted voltage devi- ation ±a% is guaranteed inside the 'interval' subfunction. Specifically speaking, once the voltage deviation of certain I-V curve section exceeds the constraint, a switch of operating parameters x is designed to execute automatically, un- til the constraint is fully satisfied in the whole range of working current den- sity [jmin, jmax]. Several classical optimization algorithms, such as GA, PSO and simulated annealing (SA), have been successfully applied for solving multi- objective optimization problems in civil engineering [42, 43], solar energy and hydraulic energy systems [44, 45], etc. With the help of classical optimization methods, our multi-objective optimization model can be solved to determine the series of operating parameters x and the current density intervals jinterval (Fig. 3 (C4-C5)). The adaptive operation strategy with appropriate operational adjustments is thus developed. 12 2.4. Numerical model A three-dimensional numerical model was developed and validated to exper- imental results in our previous studies [35, 36]. It was designed by integrating the governing equations of continuity, momentum conservation, species trans- port and electrochemical phenomena. It has been successfully applied to inves- tigate the energy conversion process in a DMFC system [36], which is the same one as that we used in the present study. Therefore, this well-developed numer- ical model can be adopted in the present study to investigate the underlying mechanisms of the adaptive operation strategy. For simplicity and concision, more details about the numerical model were not contained here, which can be available in Ref. [35, 36]. 3. Results and discussions 3.1. Large voltage variation in unoptimized operations Table 2: Operating parameters for testing cases with large voltage variations. Case T (K) CM (M) FM (ccm) FA (ccm) 1 2 323 323 0.25 0.50 4 5 81.2 140.8 Large voltage variation, that was revealed in many pioneering works [4, 15, 32], has also been frequently encountered in our experiments. Two typical cases are presented in Fig. 4 (top). They were observed in unoptimized experimental process, for which the operating parameters are summarized in Table 2. As the current density varies in a fixed range (from 0.02 to 0.06 A/cm2), the output voltage is found to decrease from 0.3556 V to 0.0768 V for Case 1, and from 13 ) V ( e g a t l o V ) V ( e g a t l o V 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 Operation range Case 1 Case 2 Voltage decrease >75% Voltage decrease >50% 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 Current density (A/cm2) Regular Adaptive (GA) Adaptive (PSO) Operation range Voltage dviation >40% Adjustment Required Vset Voltage deviation <20% 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 Current density (A/cm2) PSfrag replacements Regular Adaptive (GA) Adaptive (PSO) PSfrag replacements Case 1 Case 2 Figure 4: Large voltage variation in a fixed range of current density (top) and the voltage stability enhancement using regular or adaptive operation strategy (bottom). 0.4638 V to 0.2092 V for Case 2. It implies that the overpotential effect can- not be negligible for the operational performances of DMFC systems, as the increase in current density is accompanied by a significant decrease of output voltage (which can be larger than 50%). Such a huge voltage variation is also normally beyond the input limit of voltage stabilizers, and the operation strat- egy is therefore in great need to minimize the voltage variation to a desired degree. 14 3.2. Optimized operations Principal aim of the proposed operation strategy is to minimize the voltage deviation as the current density changes in a required range. Assuming that the permitted output voltage Vset equals to 0.3 V and the current density varies between 0.02 and 0.06 A/cm2, the adaptive operations proposed by both regular and adaptive methods have been carefully examined. The operating condition that ensures the smallest voltage deviation can be determined through a regular optimization using genetic algorithm, which is T = 322.8 K, CM = 0.6 M, FM = 5.5 ccm and FA = 140.8 ccm. As shown in Fig. 4 (bottom), the voltage deviation can be deduced to about ±40% (-41.8% to 40.93%) by regular optimizations. Although it is much better than those unoptimized cases (Fig. 4 (top)), it is still far from the input requirements of regular voltage stabilizers. How to effectively reduce the voltage deviation is still significant for practical applications of fuel cell systems. As shown in Fig. 4 (bottom), the voltage deviation can be effectively de- creased to less than 20% using the adaptive operation strategies either by genetic algorithm (GA) or by particle swarm optimization (PSO). Compared with reg- ular optimization that only provides one set of fixed operating parameters, the adaptive optimization proposes a real-time control of operating conditions. For instance, an operational adjustment is imposed at around the current density of 0.04 A/cm2, and the adaptive I-V curve using GA is therefore composed by the gentle-slope regions of two different I-V curves. The left I-V curve is im- plemented at T = 325.3 K, CM = 1.2 M, FM = 5.4 ccm and FA = 140.6 ccm, 15 and the right one is at T = 342.3 K, CM = 0.3 M, FM = 5.5 ccm and FA = 140.7 ccm. As the connected I-V curves are shown to be able to signifi- cantly subside the voltage variation, this type of real-time control of operating parameters can be regarded as 'optimized flexible operations'. The real-time analysis and control of fuel cell systems have been widely studied [8, 32], which have provided sufficient evidence for the realizability and feasibility of the pro- posed 'optimized flexible operations'. It can be also important to notice that the operation strategies optimized by GA or PSO almost coincide with each other. It preliminarily shows that the proposed strategy has not been restricted to a specific optimization method. However, as the present study principally aims at the formulation of adaptive control strategy, the effects of different optimization methods on the strategy performance will not be fully discussed. The classical optimization method of GA is then adopted in the following results. 3.3. Numerical analysis Numerical analysis is performed to answer the question "How does the adap- tive operation strategy work on the voltage stability enhancement in DMFCs?". Simulations are carried out using the constructed 3D numerical model [36]. The operating conditions are chosen to be the same as that for Fig. 4 (bottom) in Section 3.2. Fig. 5 shows the numerical results of methanol concentration distributing on the interface plane between the diffusion and catalyst layers, in which the top figures (a-c) represent regular operations and the bottom ones (d-g) represent adaptive operations. A remarkable characteristics is the stripped distribution of 16 Figure 5: Distribution of methanol concentration on the interface plane of diffusion and catalyst layers. Top figures (a-c) represent regular operations, and the bottom ones (d-g) correspond to adaptive operations. methanol concentrations, which is mainly caused by the parallel serpentine ar- rangement of flow channel in DMFC systems [33, 36]. It coincides very well with previous revealing, and more discussions about the effects of channel geometric patterns can be available in [32, 41]. For the regular case, the overall color temperature becomes increasingly low as the current density increases from 0.02 to 0.04 and to 0.06 A/cm2 (Fig. 5 (a- c)). It indicates that the methanol concentration decreases with the increase of current density, as the flux of methanol solution should be constant for a given operating condition. This result agrees with the physical fact that a larger power generation is normally based on a higher fuel consumption [7, 33, 36]. A similar result can also be found in adaptive operations. However, as the adap- tive operation strategy imposes an adjustment of operating parameters, there are two figures (e, f) at the current density 0.04 A/cm2 indicating the change of methanol concentration distributions before and after the adjustment. The 17 (a) 0.7 ) L / l o m ( M C f o e g a r e v a t e c a F 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 PSfrag replacements Case 1 Case 2 Regular Adaptive (b) 0.7 Adjustement ) L / l o m ( M C f o n o i t i a v e d d r a d n a S t PSfrag replacements 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 Case 1 Case 2 Current density (A/cm2) 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 Regular Adaptive Adjustement 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 Current density (A/cm2) Figure 6: Facet average (a) and standard deviation (b) of methanol concentration on the interface plane between the diffusion and catalyst layers. adaptive adjustment has caused a significant decrease of methanol concentra- tion, which can be the reason for the sharp voltage increase in adaptive opera- tions (as shown in Fig. 4 (bottom)). At a low current density 0.02 A/cm2, the methanol concentration for the adaptive case (Fig. 5 (d)) is much higher than that with regular optimization (Fig. 5 (a)), but the situation reverses when a high current density 0.06 A/cm2 is reached. Quantitative analysis on the methanol concentration distributing on the in- terface plane between diffusion and catalyst layers is summarized in Fig. 6. As the current density varies from 0.02 to 0.06 A/cm2, the facet average of methanol concentration gradually decreases from 0.3 to 0.17 mol/L for regular case, while it declines sharply from 0.63 to 0.08 mol/L for the adaptive one (Fig. 6 (a)). A slump occurring at 0.04 A/cm2 for adaptive case is caused by the operational adjustment that has also been demonstrated in Fig. 4 (bottom) and Fig. 5. It is of importance to notice that, the slope of facet average of methanol concentration is significantly modified by the adjustment. Compared 18 with regular optimization, it decreases faster for adaptive one before the opera- tional adjustment. However, a slower decrease is achieved after the operational adjustment. It suggests that the adaptive operation strategy can effectively modulate the methanol consumption rate inside DMFCs to improve the energy conversion process. The regulation effect of adaptive operation strategy can also be found in results of standard deviation of methanol concentration. As shown in Fig. 6 (b), the uniformity of methanol concentration distributions can be markedly regulated by the operational adjustment. The above results have shown, in both qualitative and quantitative ways, that the operational adjust- ment proposed by adaptive operation strategy is an effective way to regulate the methanol consumption. It can be highly beneficial for the maintenance of voltage stability in DMFCs that are required to be operated in a wide range of current density. 3.4. On-demand adaptive operations Flexible operations are usually demanded in practical use, for example, de- creasing the voltage deviation or extending the range of operating current den- sity. Such a flexible requirement can also be satisfied using on-demand control of operating parameters based on the adaptive operation strategy. Compared with the constant requirements realized by optimized operations in Section 3.2 (Fig. 4 (bottom), voltage deviation ≈ 20% and current density varying in [0.02, 0.06]), the flexible operations with a smaller voltage deviation or a larger range of operating current density are considered in this section. Fig. 7 shows the optimized adaptive operations according to user's require- 19 ) V ( e g a t l o V ) V ( e g a t l o V 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 Operation range Controlled small voltage deviation (≈15%) Required Vset Twice adjustments 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 Current density (A/cm2) Operation range Controlled voltage deviation (≈20%) Required Vset Twice adjustments 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 Current density (A/cm2) Figure 7: On-demand control of voltage stability using adaptive operation strategy. ments. For a required output voltage 0.3 V, the voltage deviation is successfully decreased to about ±15% in the first plot, while the operating current den- sity is extended to [0.015, 0.065] A/cm2 in the second one. The cost for those high requirements is the increase of adjusting times. As shown in Fig. 7, one needs to implement twice adjustments to achieve a more stable voltage output in a larger working current density. Taking the first plot as example, the left I-V curve section in [0.02, 0.035] A/cm2 corresponds to the operation condi- 20 tions of T = 314.7 K, CM = 1.1 M, FM = 5.5 ccm and FA = 136.3 ccm, the middle one in [0.035, 0.052] A/cm2 corresponds to the operating conditions of T = 339.9 K, CM = 0.3 M, FM = 5.5 ccm and FA = 126.8 ccm, and the right one in [0.05, 0.06] A/cm2 corresponds to the operating conditions of T = 342.8 K, CM = 0.3 M, FM = 5.5 ccm and FA = 140.6 ccm. All of them are determined by the adaptive operation strategy which ensures the smallest slope of each curve section in the corresponding interval of current density. It is known to all that the DMFC system can provide a relatively stable voltage when it is operated in the gentle-slope range in I-V curves [15, 18, 36]. The adaptive operation strategy provides us a method to search and to integrate gentle-slope sections in different I-V curves (which takes a low rate of voltage decrease as current density increases), to ensure the required voltage stability and to meet various requirements from DMFC users. 4. Experimental validations 4.1. Semi-empirical validation A simplified semi-empirical model has been constructed for predicating I-V relationships of DMFC system in the present study (as described in Section 2.2). Experimental tests, based on the experimental platform described in Section 2.1, are performed for model validations. The operating parameters are summarized in Table 3. Comparisons of experimental I-V data and semi-empirical predica- tions are shown in Fig. 8. The experimental results can be well estimated by the proposed semi-empirical model, even if the deviation from model predica- 21 Table 3: Operating parameters of testing cases for semi-empirical model validations. Case T (K) CM (M) FM (ccm) FA (ccm) 1 2 3 298 323 343 1.00 0.25 0.50 4.5 4 5 125.2 81.2 140.8 tions to experimental data would slightly increase as the operating voltage is approaching 0 V. As the DMFC performance normally decays at a very high rate while its current density is approaching to its maximum values (i.e., output voltage approaches 0 V), the preferable operations normally happen at the in- termediary regions of I-V curves. As those 'extreme' DMFC operations are out of the scope of the present study, the good agreement of model predications to experimental results in Fig. 8 has validated the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed semi-empirical model. ) V ( e g a t l o V 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 Case 1 Case 2 Case 3 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 Current density (A/cm2) PSfrag replacements Figure 8: Comparisons of experimental I-V data and corresponding predications using semi- empirical model (Line: Model; Dot: Experiment.) 22 0.6 0.5 0.4 Unoptimized Adaptive OPT Operation range Adjustment Voltage deviation ≈13.7% Required Vset=0.38 V 0.3 Voltage deviation ≈18.4% 0.2 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 Current density (A/cm2) 25 20 15 10 5 0 Unoptimized Adaptive OPT Adjustment 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 Current density (A/cm2) ) V ( e g a t l o V ) % ( y c n e c i f f i E PSfrag replacements Single parameter Double parameters PSfrag replacements Single parameter Double parameters Figure 9: Experimental validation of adaptive optimized operations of a customized DMFC system (top) and the corresponding efficiency analysis (bottom). 4.2. Controller validation Experimental work has also been carried out to validate the effects of adap- tive operation strategy on voltage stability enhancement. It is based on a cus- tomized DMFC stack that integrates a 5 × 5 cm2 MEA with Nafion 115 mem- brane, in which Pt-Ru black (4 mg/cm2) and Pt-C (0.3 mg/cm2) are used as anode and cathode catalysts. The DMFC stack is required to work at an output voltage 0.38 V, and the current density lies in the range of [0.5, 2.5] A/cm2. 23 Fig. 9 (top) shows the comparisons of experimental I-V curves obtained with or without adaptive operation strategy. The voltage deviation is significantly decreased from 18.4% to 13.7% as the adaptive operation is implemented. It implies that the voltage stability can be effectively enhanced by the adaptive operation strategy. Compared with the unoptimized operation with a specific series of operation parameters of T = 338.0 K, CM = 0.5 M, FM = 2.0 ccm and FA = 1000.0 ccm, a manual adjustment of operating parameters should be imposed at 1.4 A/cm2 for adaptive operation. The efficiency analysis has also been performed to further investigate the effects of adaptive operation strategy on DMFC systems. Several pioneering methods were successfully proposed for cost evaluations in various energy con- version systems [5, 46, 47, 48]. We apply one of the classical evaluation criteria that has been widely used in DMFC systems. It takes a form as follows, η = VcellI LHV (Ncons + Ncross) , (3) where η denotes the energy conversion efficiency, Vcell and I are the output voltage and current density, respectively. LHV is the lower heating value of methanol, Ncons and Ncross denote the molar flow rates of methanol for effective current generation and the methanol crossover, respectively. It measures the energy conversion efficiency by the ratio of effective fuel cost, i.e., the percentage of effectively consumed fuel in the total amount of fuel 'investment'. Fig. 9 (bottom) shows the energy conversion efficiency obtained in DMFC 24 ) V ( e g a t l o V 0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 PSfrag replacements Unoptimized Adaptive OPT Adjustment Single parameter Double parameters Adjustment 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 Time (s) Figure 10: System response to the adjustment of operating parameters. systems with or without adaptive operation strategy, which correspond to the cases in Fig. 9 (top). For low current density ≤ 0.5 A/cm2, the efficiencies of different operations are almost the same. However, the difference becomes in- creasingly obvious as the operating current density increases. An obvious jump can be found in adaptive operation, which is caused by the operational adjust- ment proposed by adaptive operation strategy. Actually, the mean efficiency of adaptive operation (12.2%) is slightly higher than that of unadjusted one (11.4%). It implies that the adaptive operation strategy can provide possibili- ties for voltage stability enhancement without the sacrifice of energy conversion efficiency. 4.3. System response to adjustments Although the operational adjustments in adaptive operation strategy is help- ful for voltage stability enhancement, it can be also regarded as system distur- bances that would bring out negative effects to system stability. The response 25 of DMFC system to operational adjustments, therefore, needs to be taken into account in one's evaluations of the effectiveness of the adaptive operation strat- egy. Preliminary study has been carried out based on the customized DMFC stack (as described in Section 4.2). Fig. 10 shows the time evolution of output voltage in a DMFC system, which is modulated by the adjustments of one or two operation parameters. For single-parameter adjustment, the input air flow rate FA is increased from 200 to 800 ccm, while the other operating parameters are kept at T = 328.0 K, CM = 0.5 M, FM = 3.0 ccm. It can be found that the output voltage is relatively steady at about 0.34 V before the operational adjustment is imposed. After the single-parameter adjustment, a quick response takes place in the DMFC system, which results in an obvious voltage increase from 0.34 to 0.38 V in 5 seconds. The same phenomenon has also been revealed for double-parameter adjustment, in which the input air flow rate FA is decreased from 500 to 100 ccm, the methanol solution flow rate FM is decreased from 3.0 to 1.0 ccm, and the other two operating parameters are kept at T = 328.0 K, CM = 0.5 M. It shows that the response time of DMFC system to operational adjustments can be as short as less than 5 seconds. Such a rapid response ensures, to some extent, the realizability of the proposed adaptive operation strategy. However, it is well-known that, the flow rates of the air and the feed solution are relatively easy to be modulated by manual operations. In order to realize an automatic adaptive operation, an automatic operating system embedded with adaptive operation strategy can be highly beneficial for the adjustment implementations. 26 It will be considered in our future work. 5. Conclusions Concentrating on the problem of voltage instability, an adaptive operation strategy was successfully developed for on-demand control of DMFC systems to enhance the voltage stability in operating DMFC systems. The procedure of strategy developing has been discussed in details in the present study, and the feasibility and superiority of the proposed operation strategy have been systematically studied using both experimental and numerical techniques. The main findings in the present study can be summarized as follows, 1) Large voltage variation was frequently observed in the experiments using a typical DMFC stack. Although it can be decreased by a regular optimiza- tion method to a certain degree, it still needs improvements to avoid additional energy loss caused by the process of voltage stabilization. The adaptive oper- ation strategy can be a potential solution, as it could effectively decrease the voltage variation from more than 40% to less than 20% by introducing certain operational adjustments. 2) On-demand DMFC operations, such as providing a smaller voltage de- viation or a larger operating current density, was shown to be fulfilled by the adaptive operation strategy. The adaptive operation strategy provides a method to search and to integrate gentle-slope sections in different I-V curves to ensure the demanded voltage stability in flexible operations. 3) Numerical results were provided to study the underlying mechanisms of 27 the adaptive operation strategy, as the adjustment of operating parameters pro- posed by adaptive operation strategy can be an effective way to regulate the methanol consumption inside the DMFC system. Experimental work was also carried out to validate the effects of adaptive operation strategy on the voltage stability in an operating DMFC system. A rapid response of DMFC system (less than 5 seconds) to the change of operating parameters was experimen- tally observed. It ensures the applicability of the proposed adaptive operation strategy. Acknowledgments Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51505136 & 11402084), the Natural Science Foundation of Hunan Province (No. 2015JJ3051 & 2017JJ3018), the self-determined project of State Key Labo- ratory of Advanced Design and Manufacturing for Vehicle Body (No. 51475002), the open fund of State Key Laboratory of Fluid Power & Mechatronics Systems (No. GZKF-201615) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (Hunan University). References References [1] K. Chau, Y. Wong, C. Chan, An overview of energy sources for electric vehicles, Energy Conversion and Management 40 (10) (1999) 1021–1039. 28 [2] F. Ji, L. Yang, H. Sun, S. Wang, H. Li, L. Jiang, G. Sun, A novel method for analysis and prediction of methanol mass transfer in direct methanol fuel cell, Energy Conversion and Management 154 (2017) 482–490. [3] M. Kamaruddin, S. Kamarudin, W. Daud, M. Masdar, An overview of fuel management in direct methanol fuel cells, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 24 (2013) 557–565. [4] T. Taner, Energy and exergy analyze of pem fuel cell: A case study of modeling and simulations, Energy 143 (2018) 284–294. [5] T. Taner, Optimisation processes of energy efficiency for a drying plant: A case of study for turkey, Applied Thermal Engineering 80 (2015) 247–260. [6] D. Zhou, E. Breaz, A. Ravey, F. Gao, A. Miraoui, K. Zhang, Dynamic variable coupling analysis and modeling of proton exchange membrane fuel cells for water and thermal management, in: Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition (APEC), 2016 IEEE, IEEE, 2016, pp. 3476– 3480. [7] D. Zhou, F. Gao, E. Breaz, A. Ravey, A. Miraoui, Tridiagonal ma- trix algorithm for real-timetime simulation of a 2-d pem fuel cell model, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics PP (99) (2017) 1–1. doi:10.1109/TIE.2017.2787598. [8] C. Wu, J. Chen, C. Xu, Z. Liu, Real-time adaptive control of a fuel cell/battery hybrid power system with guaranteed stability, IEEE Trans- actions on Control Systems Technology 25 (4) (2017) 1394–1405. 29 [9] N. Karim, S. Kamarudin, An overview on non-platinum cathode catalysts for direct methanol fuel cell, Applied Energy 103 (2013) 212–220. [10] P. Patel, M. Datta, P. Jampani, D. Hong, J. Poston, A. Manivannan, P. Kumta, High performance and durable nanostructured TiN supported Pt50–Ru50 anode catalyst for direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC), Journal of Power Sources 293 (2015) 437–446. [11] L. Fukuhara, N. Kado, K. Kosugi, P. Suksawad, Y. Yamamoto, H. Ishii, S. Kawahara, Preparation of polymer electrolyte membrane with nanoma- trix channel through sulfonation of natural rubber grafted with polystyrene, Solid State Ionics 268 (2014) 191–197. [12] M. Wang, G. Liu, Z. Tian, Y. Shao, L. Wang, F. Ye, M. Tran, Y. Yun, J. Lee, Microstructure-modified proton exchange membranes for high- performance direct methanol fuel cells, Energy Conversion and Manage- ment 148 (2017) 753–758. [13] A. Ozden, M. Ercelik, D. Ouellette, C. Colpan, H. Ganjehsarabi, F. Ham- dullahpur, Designing, modeling and performance investigation of bio- inspired flow field based DMFCs, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy (2017) 1–13. [14] T. Wilberforce, Z. El-Hassan, F. Khatib, A. Al Makky, J. Mooney, A. Barouaji, J. Carton, A.-G. Olabi, Development of Bi-polar plate design of PEM fuel cell using CFD techniques, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 42 (40) (2017) 25663–25685. 30 [15] A. Mehmood, M. Scibioh, J. Prabhuram, M. An, H. Ha, A review on dura- bility issues and restoration techniques in long-term operations of direct methanol fuel cells, Journal of Power Sources 297 (2015) 224–241. [16] T. Taner, Alternative energy of the future: a technical note of PEM fuel cell water management, Journal of Fundamentals of Renewable Energy and Applications 5 (3) (2015) 1–4. [17] T. Taner, The micro-scale modeling by experimental study in PEM fuel cell, Journal of Thermal Engineering 3 (6) (2017) 1515–1526. [18] F. Barbir, PEM fuel cells: theory and practice, Academic Press, 2012. [19] Y. Wang, K. Chen, J. Mishler, S. Cho, X. Adroher, A review of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells: technology, applications, and needs on fundamental research, Applied Energy 88 (4) (2011) 981–1007. [20] N. Bizon, Load-following mode control of a standalone renewable/fuel cell hybrid power source, Energy Conversion and Management 77 (2014) 763– 772. [21] N. Bizon, M. Oproescu, M. Raceanu, Efficient energy control strategies for a standalone renewable/fuel cell hybrid power source, Energy Conversion and Management 90 (2015) 93–110. [22] F. Zenith, U. Krewer, Modelling, dynamics and control of a portable DMFC system, Journal of Process Control 20 (5) (2010) 630–642. 31 [23] C.-Y. Chang, C.-H. Hsu, W.-J. Wang, C.-Y. Chen, The active control de- sign for DMFC/Battery hybrid system using PIDNN, International Journal of Innovative Computing Information and Control 8 (3 B) (2012) 2101– 2112. [24] L. Fan, J. Zhang, C. Li, Model predictive control on constant voltage output of a proton exchange membrane fuel cell, Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 6 (2) (2013) 115–119. [25] R. Keller, S. Ding, M. Muller, D. Stolten, Fault-tolerant model predictive control of a direct methanol-fuel cell system with actuator faults, Control Engineering Practice 66 (2017) 99–115. [26] D. Zhou, A. Al-Durra, F. Gao, A. Ravey, I. Matraji, M. Simoes, Online energy management strategy of fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles based on data fusion approach, Journal of Power Sources 366 (2017) 278–291. [27] D. Zhou, A. Ravey, A. Al-Durra, F. Gao, A comparative study of extremum seeking methods applied to online energy management strategy of fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles, Energy Conversion and Management 151 (2017) 778–790. [28] V. Oliveira, D. Falcao, C. Rangel, A. Pinto, Heat and mass transfer ef- fects in a direct methanol fuel cell: A 1D model, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 33 (14) (2008) 3818–3828. [29] J. Ko, P. Chippar, H. Ju, A one-dimensional, two-phase model for direct 32 methanol fuel cells–Part I: Model development and parametric study, En- ergy 35 (5) (2010) 2149–2159. [30] E. Birgersson, J. Nordlund, H. Ekstrom, M. Vynnycky, G. Lindbergh, Re- duced two-dimensional one-phase model for analysis of the anode of a DMFC, Journal of the Electrochemical Society 150 (10) (2003) A1368– A1376. [31] T. Yan, T.-C. Jen, Two-phase flow modeling of liquid-feed direct methanol fuel cell, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 51 (5) (2008) 1192–1204. [32] D. Zhou, T. Nguyen, E. Breaz, D. Zhao, S. Cl´enet, F. Gao, Global pa- rameters sensitivity analysis and development of a two-dimensional real- time model of proton-exchange-membrane fuel cells, Energy Conversion and Management 162 (2018) 276–292. [33] B. Yu, Q. Yang, A. Kianimanesh, T. Freiheit, S. Park, H. Zhao, D. Xue, A CFD model with semi-empirical electrochemical relationships to study the influence of geometric and operating parameters on DMFC performance, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38 (23) (2013) 9873–9885. [34] H. Heidary, M. Kermani, B. Dabir, Influences of bipolar plate channel blockages on PEM fuel cell performances, Energy Conversion and Manage- ment 124 (2016) 51–60. [35] Q. Yang, A. Kianimanesh, T. Freiheit, S. Park, D. Xue, A semi-empirical model considering the influence of operating parameters on performance 33 for a direct methanol fuel cell, Journal of Power Sources 196 (24) (2011) 10640–10651. [36] X. Hu, X. Wang, J. Chen, Q. Yang, D. Jin, X. Qiu, Numerical investigations of the combined effects of flow rate and methanol concentration on DMFC performance, Energies 10 (8) (2017) 1094. [37] D. Chu, R. Jiang, Effect of operating conditions on energy efficiency for a small passive direct methanol fuel cell, Electrochimica Acta 51 (26) (2006) 5829–5835. [38] V. Silva, A. Rouboa, Optimizing the DMFC operating conditions using a response surface method, Applied Mathematics and Computation 218 (12) (2012) 6733–6743. [39] D. Zhou, F. Gao, E. Breaz, A. Ravey, A. Miraoui, K. Zhang, Dynamic phenomena coupling analysis and modeling of proton exchange membrane fuel cells, IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion 31 (4) (2016) 1399– 1412. [40] K.-T. Fang, D. Lin, P. Winker, Y. Zhang, Uniform design: theory and application, Technometrics 42 (3) (2000) 237–248. [41] A. Kianimanesh, Q. Yang, S. Park, D. Xue, T. Freiheit, Model for the degradation performance of a single-cell direct methanol fuel cell under varying operational conditions, Fuel Cells 13 (6) (2013) 1005–1017. [42] E. Asadi, M. da Silva, C. Antunes, L. Dias, L. Glicksman, Multi-objective 34 optimization for building retrofit: A model using genetic algorithm and artificial neural network and an application, Energy and Buildings 81 (2014) 444–456. [43] N. Delgarm, B. Sajadi, F. Kowsary, S. Delgarm, Multi-objective optimiza- tion of the building energy performance: A simulation-based approach by means of particle swarm optimization (PSO), Applied Energy 170 (2016) 293–303. [44] M. Wang, J. Wang, P. Zhao, Y. Dai, Multi-objective optimization of a combined cooling, heating and power system driven by solar energy, Energy Conversion and Management 89 (2015) 289–297. [45] J. Marques, M. Cunha, D. Savi´c, Multi-objective optimization of water dis- tribution systems based on a real options approach, Environmental Mod- elling & Software 63 (2015) 1–13. [46] V. Silva, S. Weisshaar, R. Reissner, B. Ruffmann, S. Vetter, A. Mendes, L. Madeira, S. Nunes, Performance and efficiency of a DMFC using non- fluorinated composite membranes operating at low/medium temperatures, Journal of Power Sources 145 (2) (2005) 485–494. [47] A. Casalegno, C. Santoro, F. Rinaldi, R. Marchesi, Low methanol crossover and high efficiency direct methanol fuel cell: the influence of diffusion layers, Journal of Power Sources 196 (5) (2011) 2669–2675. [48] T. Taner, M. Sivrioglu, A techno-economic & cost analysis of a turbine 35 power plant: A case study for sugar plant, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 78 (2017) 722–730. Appendix A. Additional Data Table A.4: Operating parameters for uniform-designed experiments. 1 0.25 1.5 0.5 1 1.5 1.5 0.25 1.5 1.5 0.5 1.5 0.25 0.5 1 2 T (K) CM (M) 333 333 298 323 313 343 313 323 333 323 298 298 313 313 333 333 333 298 333 343 313 323 0.25 0.25 1 0.5 0.25 2 FM (ccm) FA (ccm) 4.5 3.5 4 4.5 4 4.5 4.5 5.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 5.5 5.5 4.5 5.5 4 4.5 5 4.5 4 5 5 125.5 81.2 81.2 125.2 108.7 81.2 108.7 93.6 108.7 140.8 93.6 140.8 125.2 93.6 140.8 140.8 93.6 81.2 93.6 108.7 140.8 108.7 N o. 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 1 2 1.5 0.5 2 0.5 0.5 1.5 2 1 2 T (K) CM (M) 298 323 323 323 343 298 333 323 313 313 313 313 298 333 343 343 343 343 323 298 343 298 343 2 1 0.5 0.25 0.5 1.5 1 2 2 1 0.25 0.25 FM (ccm) FA (ccm) N o. 5.5 4 5 4 3.5 4.5 5.5 5 4.5 3.5 5.5 3.5 3.5 5 5.5 5 3.5 5 4 4 5.5 5 4 93.6 81.2 93.6 125.2 93.6 125.2 108.7 125.2 140.8 81.2 81.2 108.7 125.2 81.2 81.2 140.8 140.8 108.7 93.6 140.8 125.2 108.7 125.2 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 36
1911.00377	1	1911	2019-11-01T13:47:37	Generalized Scharfetter-Gummel schemes for electro-thermal transport in degenerate semiconductors using the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.other", "math.NA", "math.NA", "physics.comp-ph" ]	Many challenges faced in today's semiconductor devices are related to self-heating phenomena. The optimization of device designs can be assisted by numerical simulations using the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, where the magnitude of the thermoelectric cross effects is controlled by the Seebeck coefficient. We show that the model equations take a remarkably simple form when assuming the so-called Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient. The corresponding heat generation rate involves exactly the three classically known self-heating effects, namely Joule, recombination and Thomson-Peltier heating, without any further (transient) contributions. Moreover, the thermal driving force in the electrical current density expressions can be entirely absorbed in the diffusion coefficient via a generalized Einstein relation. The efficient numerical simulation relies on an accurate and robust discretization technique for the fluxes (finite volume Scharfetter-Gummel method), which allows to cope with the typically stiff solutions of the semiconductor device equations. We derive two non-isothermal generalizations of the Scharfetter-Gummel scheme for degenerate semiconductors (Fermi-Dirac statistics) obeying the Kelvin formula. The approaches differ in the treatment of degeneration effects: The first is based on an approximation of the discrete generalized Einstein relation implying a specifically modified thermal voltage, whereas the second scheme follows the conventionally used approach employing a modified electric field. We present a detailed analysis and comparison of both schemes, indicating a superior performance of the modified thermal voltage scheme.	physics.app-ph	physics	Generalized Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes for electro-thermal transport in degenerate semiconductors using the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient Markus Kantner Weierstrass Institute for Applied Analysis and Stochastics (WIAS), Mohrenstr. 39, 10117 Berlin, Germany 9 1 0 2 v o N 1 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 7 7 3 0 0 . 1 1 9 1 : v i X r a Abstract Many challenges faced in today's semiconductor devices are related to self-heating phenomena. The optimization of device designs can be assisted by numerical simulations using the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, where the magnitude of the thermoelectric cross effects is controlled by the Seebeck coefficient. We show that the model equa- tions take a remarkably simple form when assuming the so-called Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient. The corresponding heat generation rate involves exactly the three classically known self-heating effects, namely Joule, recombination and Thomson -- Peltier heating, without any further (transient) contributions. Moreover, the thermal driving force in the electrical current density expressions can be entirely absorbed in the diffusion coefficient via a generalized Einstein relation. The efficient numerical simulation relies on an accurate and robust discretization technique for the fluxes (finite volume Scharfetter -- Gummel method), which allows to cope with the typically stiff solutions of the semiconductor device equations. We derive two non-isothermal generalizations of the Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme for degenerate semiconductors (Fermi -- Dirac statistics) obeying the Kelvin formula. The approaches differ in the treatment of degeneration effects: The first is based on an approximation of the discrete generalized Ein- stein relation implying a specifically modified thermal voltage, whereas the second scheme follows the conventionally used approach employing a modified electric field. We present a detailed analysis and comparison of both schemes, indicating a superior performance of the modified thermal voltage scheme. Keywords: finite volume Scharfetter -- Gummel method, semiconductor device simulation, electro-thermal transport, non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, degenerate semiconductors (Fermi -- Dirac statistics), Seebeck coefficient 1. Introduction Thermal effects cause many challenges in a broad variety of semiconductor devices. Thermal instabilities limit the safe-operating area of high power devices and modules in electrical energy technology [1, 2], electro-thermal feedback loops lead to catastrophic snapback phenomena in organic light-emitting diodes [3, 4] and self-heating effects deci- sively limit the achievable output power of semiconductor lasers [5 -- 8]. The numerical simulation of semiconductor devices showing strong self-heating and thermoelectric effects requires a thermodynamically consistent modeling ap- proach, that describes the coupled charge carrier and heat transport processes. In the context of semiconductor device simulation, the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system [9 -- 14] has become the standard model for the self-consistent description of electro-thermal transport phenomena. This is a system of four partial differential equations, which couples the semiconductor device equations [15, 16] to a (lattice) heat flow equation for the temperature distribution in the device. On the step from the isothermal to the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, additional thermoelectric transport coefficients must be included in the theory. The magnitude of the thermoelectric cross-effects is governed by the Seebeck coefficient (also thermopower), which quantifies the thermoelectric voltage induced by a temperature gra- dient (Seebeck effect) [17, 18]. The reciprocal phenomenon of the Seebeck effect is the Peltier effect, which describes the current-induced heating or cooling at material junctions. As a consequence of Onsager's reciprocal relations, the Email address: [email protected] (Markus Kantner) Preprint submitted to Journal of Computational Physics © 2019. Licensed under the Creative Commons CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0. November 4, 2019 Seebeck and Peltier coefficients are not independent such that only the Seebeck coefficient must be specified [19]. Over the decades, several definitions have been proposed for the Seebeck coefficient [20 -- 23]; recent publications list at least five coexisting different (approximate) formulas [24, 25]. In the context of semiconductor device simulation, the Seebeck coefficients are typically derived from the Boltzmann transport equation in relaxation time approxima- tion [26 -- 28] or defined according to the adage of the Seebeck coefficient being the "(specific) entropy per carrier" [13, 14, 18, 29]. These approaches are often focused on non-degenerate semiconductors, where the carriers follow the classical Maxwell -- Boltzmann statistics. This approximation breaks down in heavily doped semiconductors, where the electron-hole plasma becomes degenerate and Fermi -- Dirac statistics must be considered to properly take into account the Pauli exclusion principle. Degeneration effects are important in many semiconductor devices such as semiconductor lasers, light emitting diodes or transistors. Moreover, heavily doped semiconductors are considered as "good" thermoelectric materials, i. e., materials with high thermoelectric figure of merit [17, 18], for thermoelectric generators, which can generate electricity from waste heat [30, 31]. In this paper, we will consider an alternative model for the Seebeck coefficient, which is the so-called Kelvin formula for the thermopower [32]. The Kelvin formula recently gained interest in theoretical condensed matter physics and has been shown to yield a good approximation of the Seebeck coefficient for many materials (including semiconductors, metals and high temperature superconductors) at reasonably high temperatures [32 -- 42]. The Kelvin formula relates the Seebeck coefficient to the derivative of the entropy density with respect to the carrier density and therefore involves only equilibrium properties of the electron-hole plasma, where degeneration effects are easily included. To our knowledge, the Kelvin formula has not been considered in the context of semiconductor device simulation so far. In Sec. 2, we show that the Kelvin formula yields a remarkably simple form of the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, which shows two exceptional features: 1. The heat generation rate involves exactly the three classically known self-heating effects (Joule, Thomson -- 2. The thermal driving force in the current density expressions can be entirely absorbed in a (nonlinear) diffusion Peltier and recombination heating) without any further (transient) contributions. coefficient via a generalized Einstein relation. Hence, the ∇T term is eliminated in the drift-diffusion form. The second part of this paper (Sec. 3) deals with the discretization of the electrical current density expressions, which are required in (non-isothermal) semiconductor device simulation tools. The robust and accurate discretization of the drift-diffusion fluxes in semiconductors with exponentially varying carrier densities is a non-trivial problem, that requires a special purpose discretization technique. The problem has been solved by Scharfetter and Gummel for the case of non-degenerate semiconductors under isothermal conditions [43]. Since then, several adaptations of the method have been developed to account for more general situations (non-isothermal conditions [44 -- 51], degeneration effects [52 -- 57]). The Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficients allows for a straightforward generalization of the Scharfetter -- Gummel approach to the non-isothermal case. We take up two different approaches to incorporate degen- eration effects into the non-isothermal Scharfetter -- Gummel formula and give an extensive numerical and analytical comparison of both methods. This includes an investigation of limiting cases and structure preserving properties of the discrete formulas (Sec. 3.3), a comparison with the numerically exact solution of the underlying two-point boundary value problem (Sec. 3.4) and a comparison of analytical error bounds (Sec. 3.5). Finally, in Sec. 3.6, we present a numerical convergence analysis of both schemes based on numerical simulations of a one-dimensional p-n-diode. 2. The non-isothermal drift-diffusion system using the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient In this section we briefly review the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system, which provides a self-consistent de- scription of the coupled electro-thermal transport processes in semiconductor devices. The model has been extensively studied by several authors from the perspective of physical kinetics or phenomenological non-equilibrium thermody- 2 Fig. 1. (a) Fermi -- Dirac integrals (7) of order ν = 1/2, 0 and −1/2 as functions of the reduced Fermi energy η. For η (cid:28) −1 the Fermi -- Dirac integrals approach the Maxwell -- Boltzmann distribution F (η) = exp (η) (non-degenerate limit). (b) Plot of the degeneracy factor (17b) (or diffusion enhancement factor) for the Fermi -- Dirac integrals in (a). For η (cid:28) −1 the degeneracy factor approaches 1 (linear diffusion). (c) Correction factor (32) that quantifies the deviation of the Fermi -- Dirac integrals from the exponential function. The non-degenerate limit corresponds to γ (η) ≡ 1. namics [9 -- 14]. The model equations read: −∇ · ε∇φ = q (C + p − n) , ∂tn − 1 q 1 q ∇ · jn = −R, ∇ · jp = −R, cV ∂tT − ∇ · κ∇T = H. ∂t p + (1) (2) (3) (4) Poisson's equation (1) describes the electrostatic field generated by the electrical charge density ρ = q (C + p − n). Here, φ is the electrostatic potential, n and p are the densities of electrons and holes, respectively, C is the built-in doping profile, q is the elementary charge and ε is the (absolute) dielectric constant of the material. The transport and recombination dynamics of the electron-hole plasma are modeled by the continuity equations (2) -- (3), where jn/p are the electrical current densities and R is the (net-)recombination rate. The latter includes several radiative and non- radiative recombination processes (Shockley -- Read -- Hall recombination, Auger recombination, spontaneous emission etc.) [15]. The carrier densities n, p are connected with the electrostatic potential φ via the state equations (cid:32) µc + qφ − Ec (T) kBT (cid:33) (cid:32) Ev (T) − qφ − µv (cid:33) kBT n = Nc (T) F , p = Nv (T) F , (5) where kB is Boltzmann's constant, T is the absolute temperature, Nc/v is the effective density of states and Ec/v is the reference energy level (typically the band edge energy) of the conduction band or valence band, respectively. The function F describes the occupation of the electronic states under quasi-equilibrium conditions, which is controlled by the quasi-Fermi energies µc/v of the respective bands. The quasi-Fermi energies are connected with the quasi-Fermi potentials ϕn/p via µc = −qϕn, µv = −qϕp. (6) In non-degenerate semiconductors (Maxwell -- Boltzmann statistics), F is the exponential function F (η) = exp (η). Taking the degeneration of the electron-hole plasma due to Pauli-blocking into account (Fermi -- Dirac statistics), F is typically given by the Fermi -- Dirac integral ∞ F (η) = Fν (η) = 1 Γ (ν + 1) 0 dξ ξν exp (ξ − η) + 1 , (7) where the index ν depends on the dimensionality of the structure. Isotropic, bulk materials with parabolic energy bands are described by ν = 1/2; for two-dimensional materials (quantum wells) the index ν = 0 applies. See Fig. 1 (a) 3 (a)(b)(c)Maxwell -- Boltzmann012357946810-10-8-6-4-20246810-10-8-6-4-2024681000.20.40.60.81.010110210010-410-310-110-2-10-8-6-4-20246810for a plot of the Fermi -- Dirac integrals for different ν as a function of the reduced Fermi energy. The function F may also include non-parabolicity effects, see Appendix A. In the case of organic semiconductors, F is often taken as the Gauss -- Fermi integral [58, 59] or a hypergeometric function [60, 61]. The heat transport equation (4) describes the spatio-temporal dynamics of the temperature distribution in the device. Here, cV is the (volumetric) heat capacity, κ is the thermal conductivity and H is the heat generation rate. The non-isothermal drift-diffusion model assumes a local thermal equilibrium between the lattice and the carriers, i. e., T = TL = Tn = T p. The system (1) -- (4) must be supplemented with initial conditions and boundary conditions (i.e., for electrical contacts, semiconductor-insulator interfaces, heat sinks etc). We refer to Refs. [15, 62] for a survey on commonly used boundary condition models. The electrical current densities are driven by the gradients of the quasi-Fermi potentials and the temperature where σn = qMnn and σp = qMp p are the electrical conductivities (with carrier mobilities Mn/p) and Pn/p are the Seebeck coefficients. Finally, we consider a (net-)recombination rate of the form [63] jn = −σn (∇ϕn + Pn∇T) , (cid:17) (cid:16) R = R φ, ϕn, ϕp, T (cid:32) (cid:32) 1 − exp = − µc − µv kBT (cid:17) (cid:16)∇ϕp + Pp∇T (cid:17) rα φ, ϕn, ϕp, T , jp = −σp (cid:16) (cid:33)(cid:33)(cid:88) α , (8) (cid:16) (9) (cid:17) ≥ 0 are which combines several radiative and non-radiative recombination processes labeled by α (e.g., Shockley -- Read -- Hall recombination, spontaneous emission, Auger recombination etc.). The functions rα = rα inherently non-negative and specific for the respective processes. We refer to Refs. [15, 62] for commonly considered recombination rate models. φ, ϕn, ϕp, T 2.1. Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient In this paper, we consider the so-called Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient [32] Pn = −1 q ∂s (n, p, T) ∂n , Pp = + 1 q ∂s (n, p, T) ∂p , (10) which relates the thermoelectric powers to the derivatives of the entropy density s = s(n, p, T) with respect to the carrier densities. The expression for the entropy density is easily derived from the free energy density f (n, p, T) of the system, which is a proper thermodynamic potential if the set of unknowns is chosen as (n, p, T) ("natural variables") . The expressions for the quasi-Fermi energies and the entropy density then follow as ∂ f (n, p, T) ∂n = +µc (n, p, T) , ∂ f (n, p, T) ∂p = −µv (n, p, T) , ∂ f (n, p, T) ∂T = −s (n, p, T) . (11) Taking the second derivatives, this yields the Maxwell relations ∂µc (n, p, T) ∂T = − ∂s (n, p, T) ∂n , ∂µv (n, p, T) ∂T = + ∂s (n, p, T) ∂p , (12) which allow for an alternative representation of Eq. (10). The free energy density includes contributions from the quasi-free electron-hole plasma (ideal Fermi gas), the lattice vibrations (ideal Bose gas) and the electrostatic (Coulomb) interaction energy. Throughout this paper, we assume a free energy density of the form [13] f (n, p, T) = fe -- h (n, p, T) + fL (T) + fCoul (p − n) . The free energy density of the (non-interacting) electron-hole plasma reads [13, 63] fe -- h (n, p, T) = kBT F −1 + kBT F −1 F −1 (cid:33) n − kBT Nc (T) G p − kBT Nv (T) G (cid:32) F −1 n (cid:32) Nc (T) p Nv (T) + Ec (T) n − Ev (T) p, (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:33)(cid:33) (cid:33)(cid:33) (cid:32) (cid:33) n (cid:32) Nc (T) p Nv (T) 4 (13) (14) (cid:17) (cid:16) χ − 1 Fig. 2. (a) Seebeck coefficient according to the Kelvin formula (16) as a function of the reduced Fermi energy η for power law type effective density of states Nc/v ∝ T 3/2 and F (η) = F1/2 (η) in units of kB/q. The formula (16) takes degeneration effects (Fermi -- Dirac statistics, solid lines) of the electron-hole plasma into account, which causes a deviation from the non-degenerate result (Maxwell -- Boltzmann statistics, dashed lines) at η (cid:38) −1. The temperature dependency of the band gap energy yields an offset of E(cid:48) E(cid:48) g (T) for electrons (red lines) and g (T) = −5. (b) Seebeck coefficient for n-type GaAs. Solid lines are E(cid:48) v = (cid:16) computed according to the Kelvin formula (16a) using Fermi -- Dirac statistics, dashed lines indicate the corresponding non-degenerate limit. The D are given in the plot in units of cm−3. The temperature-dependency of the band gap energy Eg (T) is respective ionized donor densities C = N+ 0.067 − 1.2 × 10−5 K−1 T modeled by the Varshni model (18) with data from Ref. [62] and the effective mass is m∗ m0 [62], where m0 is the free electron mass. The fitting parameter is set to χ = −0.2. Experimental data: (cid:79) Carlson et al. [65], (cid:35) Amith et al. [66], ♦ Edmond et al. [67] (data from Ref. [68]), (cid:3) Homm et al. [69] and • Emel'yanenko et al. [70] (data from Ref. [68]). g (T) for holes (blue lines). The plot is for χ = −0.2 and k−1 E(cid:48) B E(cid:48) c (T) = c (T) = χ + 1 2 (cid:17) (cid:16) (cid:17) 2 where F −1 is the inverse of the function F in the state equations (5) and G denotes its antiderivative: G (cid:48) (η) = F (η). Note that Eq. (14) implies ∂ fe -- h ∂n = kBT F −1 n Nc (T) + Ec (T) , ∂ fe -- h ∂p = kBT F −1 p Nv (T) − Ev (T) . (15a) (cid:32) (cid:33) (cid:32) (cid:33) The lattice contribution fL (T) yields the dominant contribution to the heat capacity cV. It can be derived from, e. g., the Debye model for the free phonon gas [64]. The Coulomb interaction energy fCoul must be modeled such that the state equations (5) follow consistently from solving the defining relations for the quasi-Fermi energies (11) for the carrier densities. In order to supplement the "missing" electrostatic contributions in Eq. (15a), we specify the derivatives of fCoul with respect to the carrier densities: ∂ fCoul ∂n = −qφ, ∂ fCoul ∂p = +qφ. (15b) We refer to Albinus et al. [13] for a rigorous mathematical treatment of the Coulomb interaction energy. The Seebeck coefficients (10) are evaluated using Eqs. (11) -- (15). Since fCoul is independent of the temperature and fL does not depend on the carrier densities, the evaluation of Eq. (10) requires only the Maxwell relations (12) and the derivatives of Eqs. (15a) with respect to the temperature. One obtains Pn (n, T) = − kB q kB q where the prime denotes the derivatives N(cid:48) ture dependency Nc/v (T) ∝ T θ (e. g., θ = 3/2), the factor in the first term reduces to a constant T N(cid:48) c (T) Nc (T) v (T) Nv (T) c/v (T) = ∂T Nc/v (T) and E(cid:48) E(cid:48) c (T) E(cid:48) v (T) − 1 kB 1 kB Pp (p, T) = + − F −1 − F −1 Nv (T) Nv (T) Nc (T) Nc (T) g , , n p n p g + c/v (T) = ∂T Ec/v (T). For power law type tempera- c/v (T) /Nc/v (T) = θ. (16a) (16b) (cid:32) T N(cid:48) (cid:32) T N(cid:48) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:33) (cid:33) (cid:33) (cid:33) (cid:33) (cid:33) 5 -50510reduced Fermi energy -8-6-4-20246810Seebeck coefficient150200250300350400450500550600650700temperature [K]-0.7-0.6-0.5-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.10Seebeck coefficient [mV/K](a)(b)Fermi -- DiracMaxwell -- Boltzmannholeselectrons5.5×10151.5×10173.5×10179.0×10172.5×10187.7×1018For temperature-dependent effective masses, the term is more complicated. The function g (x) = x dF −1 (x) dx (17a) quantifies the degeneration of the Fermi gas. For non-degenerate carrier statistics (Maxwell -- Boltzmann statistics), Eq. (17a) reduces to exactly g ≡ 1. For degenerate carrier statistics one obtains g > 1, which implies a nonlinear enhancement of the diffusion current (see Sec. 2.4). For later use, we also introduce the function gη (η) ≡ g (F (η)) = F (η) F (cid:48) (η) , (17b) c (T) − E(cid:48) which is plotted in Fig. 1 (b). The last terms in Eq. (16) describe the contributions of the temperature dependency of the band edge energies to the Seebeck coefficients. The two terms are not independent, as they are required to satisfy E(cid:48) g (T) = E(cid:48) v (T), where Eg (T) is the energy band gap. A plot of the Seebeck coefficients (16) as functions of the reduced Fermi energy η is shown in Fig. 2 (a) for F (η) = F1/2 (η) and Nc,v ∝ T 3/2. The plot illustrates schematically the impact of the temperature derivatives of the band edge energies and the role of degeneration effects. In the following, several consequences of the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficients are described, which are very appealing for numerical semiconductor device simulation as they greatly simplify the model equations. Before going into details, we emphasize that the Kelvin formula is of course merely a convenient approximation and by no means exact. More accurate and microscopically better justified approaches to calculate the Seebeck coefficient are based on advanced kinetic models such as the semi-classical Boltzmann transport equation beyond the relaxation time approximation (retaining the full form of the collision operator [71, 72]) or fully quantum mechanical methods [36, 37, 39, 42]. 2.2. Comparison with experimental data Several empirical models for the temperature dependency of the band gap energy have been proposed in the literature [73], including the commonly accepted Varshni model (18) Eg (T) = Eg,0 − αT 2 β + T , (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:16) (cid:17) χ + 1 2 v (T) = c (T) = E(cid:48) g (T) and E(cid:48) It shall be noted that the terms involving E(cid:48) where Eg,0, α and β are material specific constants [74]. In order to specify E(cid:48) c/v (T) from Eq. (18), we introduce χ − 1 a parameter χ such that E(cid:48) E(cid:48) g (T). In applications, χ can be used as c/v (T) in Eq. (16) are non-negligible and yield a a fitting parameter. significant contribution to the Seebeck coefficients at elevated temperatures. Indeed, some room temperature values g (300 K) for important semiconductors are −2.95 (Si), −4.47 (Ge), −5.32 (GaAs) [62], which are on the same of k−1 B E(cid:48) order of magnitude as the first term T N(cid:48) In Fig. 2 (b), the Kelvin formula is plotted along with experimental data for n-GaAs. We observe a good quan- titative agreement of the formula (16a) with the experimental data in both the weak and the heavy doping regime D ≥ 9 × 1017 cm−3) the conduction band electrons become for temperatures above 150 K. At high carrier densities (N+ degenerate (see the deviation of the solid from the dashed lines), where the experimental values nicely follow the degenerate formula (16a). See the caption for details. At low temperatures (T < 150 K, not shown), the Seebeck coefficient is increasingly dominated by the phonon drag effect [69], which is not considered in the present model. c/v (T) /Nc/v (T) ≈ 1.5 in Eq. (16). 2 A commonly accepted form of the self-consistent heat generation rate H was derived by Wachutka [9]: 2.3. Heat generation rate (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)jp (cid:32) ∂ϕp (n, p, T) (cid:107)jn(cid:107)2 + 1 σp (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)2 − T jn · ∇Pn − T jp · ∇Pp + q (cid:33) (cid:32) ∂ϕn (n, p, T) + Pp ∇ · jp − T (cid:32) (cid:33) T ∂ϕn (n, p, T) ∂T ∇ · jn. + Pn H = 1 σn − T ∂T (cid:33) − ϕn − T ∂ϕp (n, p, T) ∂T + ϕp R (19) ∂T 6 Here we omit the radiation power density contribution from the original work. The notation (cid:107)x(cid:107) = (x · x)1/2 is the standard vector norm. The derivation of Eq. (19) is based on the conservation of internal energy and does not involve any explicit assumptions on the Seebeck coefficient. Using the Maxwell relations (12) and the transport Eqs. (2) -- (3), we rewrite Eq. (19) as H = 1 σn + qT (cid:32) 1 (cid:107)jn(cid:107)2 + σp Pp − 1 q (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)jp (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)2 − T jn · ∇Pn − T jp · ∇Pp + q (cid:16) (cid:33) (cid:32) ∂s (n, p, T) ∂p ∂t p − qT Pn + 1 q ∂s (n, p, T) ∂n ∂tn, (cid:17) (cid:33) ϕp − ϕn + Πp − Πn R (20) The first two terms HJ,λ = σ−1 where we introduced the Peltier coefficients Πn = T Pn and Πp = T Pp ("second Kelvin relation"). Before we highlight the consequences of the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficients on H, we give a brief interpretation of the individual terms in Eq. (20). λ (cid:107)jλ(cid:107)2 (for λ ∈ {n, p}) describe Joule heating, which is always non-negative and therefore never leads to cooling of the device. The next two terms HT -- P,λ = −T jλ · ∇Pλ (for λ ∈ {n, p}) describe the Thomson -- Peltier effect, which can either heat or cool the device depending on the direction of the current flow. At constant temperature, this reduces to the Peltier effect HT -- P,λT =const. = −jλ·∇Πλ, which is important at heterointerfaces and p-n junctions. At constant carrier densities, one obtains the Thomson heat term HT -- P,λn,p=const. = −Kλ jλ · ∇T ∂T − Pλ (for λ ∈ {n, p}). The Thomson -- Peltier effect combines both with the Thomson coefficient Kλ = T ∂Pλ contributions. The recombination heat term HR = q(ϕp − ϕn + Πp − Πn)R models the self-heating of the device due to recombination of electron-hole pairs. The difference of the Peltier coefficients describes the average excess energy of the carriers above the Fermi voltage. The last line in Eq. (20) is a purely transient contribution, that has been discussed by several authors [9 -- 12, 25]. In simulation practice, this term is often neglected, since estimations show that it is negligible in comparison with the other self-heating sources, see Refs. [75, 76]. = ∂Πλ ∂T We observe that the transient term vanishes exactly if we choose the Kelvin formula (10) for the Seebeck coef- ficients. As a result, solely the classically known self-heating terms are contained in the model and all additional, transient heating mechanisms are excluded: Finally, we rewrite the recombination heating term using the Seebeck coefficients (16) and Eq. (5). One obtains (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)jp (cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:13)2 − T jn · ∇Pn − T jp · ∇Pp + q (cid:34) T N(cid:48) (cid:33) (cid:32) p v (T) Nv (T) g Nv (T) g (T) + (cid:16) (cid:17) ϕp − ϕn + Πp − Πn (cid:33) (cid:33)(cid:35) (cid:32) T N(cid:48) c (T) Nc (T) g + n Nc (T) kBT R. R. (21) H = 1 σn (cid:107)jn(cid:107)2 + 1 σp (cid:32) HR = Eg (T) − T E(cid:48) (cid:17) g (T) + 3kBT (cid:16) The last term describes the (differential) average thermal energy per recombining electron-hole pair. For an effective density of states function Nc/v ∝ T 3/2 and non-degenerate carrier statistics, we recover the classical result HR ≈ Eg (T) − T E(cid:48) R. This yields a clear interpretation of the degeneracy factor g (see Eq. (17)): It describes the increased average thermal energy of the Fermi gas due to Pauli blocking in comparison to the non-degenerate case at the same carrier density. We emphasize that the Kelvin formula immediately yields the correct average kinetic energy 2 × 3 2 kBT of the three-dimensional electron-hole plasma just from the temperature dependency of the effective density of states function Nc/v ∝ T 3/2. This does in general not hold for Seebeck coefficients derived from the Boltzmann transport equation in relaxation time approximation, where the average thermal energy of the electron- hole plasma in the recombination heat term depends on a scattering parameter, see e. g. Ref. [29]. The dissipated heat is closely related with the electrical power injected through the contacts. The global power balance equation for the present model is derived in Appendix D. 2.4. Electrical current densities in drift-diffusion form In this section we recast the electrical current density expressions from the thermodynamic form (8) to the drift- diffusion form. As we will see below, the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient allows to entirely absorb the thermally driven part of the electrical current density in the diffusion coefficient via a generalized Einstein relation. Thus, the ∇T term can be eliminated in the drift-diffusion form, which significantly simplifies the current density 7 expression. Our derivation is based on rewriting the gradient of the quasi-Fermi potential using the free energy density (13) and further thermodynamic relations stated above. In the following, we sketch the essential steps for the electron current density, the corresponding expression for the holes follows analogously. We obtain (cid:32) (cid:33) −q∇ϕn Eq. (11) = ∇ ∂ f ∂n Eq. (13) = ∇ ∂ fCoul ∂n + ∂ fe -- h ∂n Eq. (15b) = −q∇φ + ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 ∇n + ∂2 fe -- h ∂n ∂p ∇p + ∂2 fe -- h ∂n ∂T ∇T, where we have separated the contributions from the Coulomb interaction energy fCoul (leading to drift in the electric field) and the quasi-free electron-hole plasma (yielding Hessian matrix elements of the ideal Fermi gas' free energy density fe -- h). The electrons and holes are decoupled in the non-interacting Fermi-gas such that ∂2 fe -- h ∂n ∂p = 0. Moreover, since (i) the Coulomb interaction energy is independent of the temperature and therefore does not contribute to the system's entropy and (ii) the lattice contribution fL is independent of the carrier densities, it holds where s is the entropy density of the full system (see the last formula in Eq. (11)). Thus, we arrive at ∂2 fe -- h ∂n ∂T = − ∂s ∂n , which must be substituted in Eq. (8) to obtain ∇ϕn = ∇φ − 1 q 1 q ∇T, ∂s ∂n ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 ∇n + (cid:35) (cid:33) + Pn ∇T (cid:34)1 q (cid:32) ∇φ − 1 q jn = −σn ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 ∇n + ∂s ∂n = −σn∇φ + σn 1 q ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 ∇n. In the last step, we have used the Kelvin formula (10) for the Seebeck coefficient. The temperature gradient term vanishes exactly, since reversing the order of the derivatives in the Hessian of the free energy density immediately yields the definition (10) and cancels with the Seebeck term in Eq. (8). The same result can be obtained by simply inverting the carrier density state equation (5) and using the explicit expression (16). With the electrical conductivities σn = qMnn, σp = qMp p and (cid:32) (cid:33) (cid:32) (cid:33) ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 = kBT n g n Nc (T) , ∂2 fe -- h ∂p2 = kBT p g p Nv (T) , (from Eq. (15a)), we finally arrive at the drift-diffusion form: The diffusion coefficients are given by the generalized Einstein relation [26, 77] jn = −qMnn∇φ + qDn (n, T)∇n, (cid:33) (cid:32) kBT Mn g q n , Nc (T) Dn (n, T) = jp = −qMp p∇φ − qDp (p, T)∇p. (cid:33) (cid:32) kBT Mp Dp (p, T) = g p . Nv (T) q (22) (23) Here the degeneracy factor g describes an effective enhancement of the diffusion current that depends nonlinearly on the carrier densities, which results from the increased average thermal energy of the carriers in the case of Fermi -- Dirac statistics (see above). The diffusion enhancement due to carrier degeneracy has been found to be important in, e. g., semiconductor laser diodes [78], quantum-photonic devices operated at cryogenic temperatures [79, 80] as well as or- ganic field-effect transistors [81] and light emitting diodes [58]. We emphasize that the drift-diffusion form (22) of the current densities is fully equivalent to the thermodynamic form (8). Thus, even though the ∇T term is eliminated, the thermoelectric cross-coupling via the Seebeck effect is fully taken into account via the temperature dependency of the diffusion coefficient. A generalization to the case of hot carrier transport (with multiple temperatures) is described in Appendix B. For Seebeck coefficients that deviate from the Kelvin formula, additional thermodiffusion terms emerge. 8 3. Non-isothermal generalization of the Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme for degenerate semiconductors The typically exponentially varying carrier densities in semiconductor devices lead to numerical instabilities when using a standard finite difference discretization. In particular, the naive discretization approach results in spurious oscillations and may cause unphysical results such as negative carrier densities [82, 83]. A robust discretization scheme for the drift-diffusion current density was introduced by Scharfetter and Gummel [43], who explicitly solved the current density expressions as a separate differential equation along the edge between two adjacent nodes of the mesh. The resulting discretized current density expressions feature exponential terms that reflect the characteristics of the doping profile and allow for numerically stable calculations. Over the last decades, several generalizations of the Scharfetter -- Gummel method have been proposed for either degenerate semiconductors [52 -- 57] or non-isothermal carrier transport with included thermoelectric cross effects [44 -- 51]. In this section, we derive two different generalizations of the Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme for degenerate semicon- ductors obeying the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient. Both schemes differ in the treatment of degeneration effects and are obtained by extending the approaches previously developed in Refs. [54, 56] and [52]. First, we outline the finite volume method in Sec. 3.1 and then introduce the non-isothermal Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes in Sec. 3.2. We study important limiting cases and structure preserving properties of the discretizations (Sec. 3.3), give a detailed comparison with the numerically exact solution of the underlying two-point boundary value problem (Sec. 3.4) and derive analytical error bounds (Sec. 3.5). Finally, we present a numerical convergence analysis by means of numerical simulations of a one-dimensional p-n-diode in Sec. 3.6. 3.1. Finite volume discretization We assume a boundary conforming Delaunay triangulation [84] of the point set R = {rK}K=1...Nnodes, rK ∈ Ω, where Ω ⊂ Rd is the computational domain with dimensionality d = {1, 2, 3}. The dual mesh is given by the Voronoï cells which provides a non-overlapping tessellation Ω =(cid:83) ΩK = {r ∈ Ω : (cid:107)r − rK(cid:107) ≤ (cid:107)r − rL(cid:107) for all rL ∈ R with rL (cid:44) rK} , K ΩK of the domain. This represents an admissible mesh in the sense of Ref. [85]. The finite volume discretization of the system (1) -- (4) is obtained by integration over the cell ΩK and usage of the divergence theorem [83, 85]. The discrete (stationary) non-isothermal drift-diffusion system reads − (cid:88) L∈N(K) + − (cid:88) L∈N(K) L∈N(K) sK,Lε (φL − φK) = qΩK (CK + pK − nK) − (cid:88) (cid:88) sK,LJn,K,L = −qΩKRK, sK,LJp,K,L = −qΩKRK, (cid:88) L∈N(K) sK,Lκ (TL − TK) = sK,L (cid:0)HJ,K,L + HT -- P,K,L (24a) (24b) (24c) (24d) (cid:1) + ΩKHR,K 1 2 L∈N(K) with the flux projections Jn,K,L = (rL − rK) · jn, (25) on the edge KL := {x rL + (1 − x) rK x ∈ R, 0 ≤ x ≤ 1}. The geometric factors in Eq. (24) are the volume ΩK of the K-th Voronoï cell and the edge factor Jp,K,L = (rL − rK) · jp sK,L = (26) The symbol N (K) denotes the set of nodes adjacent to K. For the sake of simplicity we restrict ourselves to the case of a homogeneous material. This limitation is not important for the flux discretization, as the discrete fluxes appear only along possible heterointerfaces (edges of the primary simplex grid, see Fig. (3)) but never across. In the case of heterostructures, the currents along material interfaces are weighted by the respective edge factors. Moreover, boundary terms on ∂Ω ∩ ΩK (cid:44) ∅ are omitted in Eq. (24), which are treated in the standard way as ∂ΩK ∩ ∂ΩL (cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107) . 9 Fig. 3. Delaunay triangulation and construction of Voronoï cells. The red arrow indicates the discrete current Jn,K,L between two neighboring control volumes ΩK and ΩL. The green area is the bi-hyperpyramid (or "diamond cell") DK,L with height (cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107) and internal face ∂ΩL ∩ ∂ΩK. Adapted, with permission, from Ref. [89]. © 2019 IEEE. described in Ref. [85] and references therein. The discrete electron density reads nK = Nc (TK) F(cid:0)ηn,K ηn,K = −(cid:0)Ec (TK) − qφK + qϕn,K (cid:1) with (cid:1) / (kBTK) (holes analogously). The discrete recombination rate RK is obtained by (cid:0)ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pn,K,L (TL − TK)(cid:1) − Jp,K,L (cid:0)Pn,L − Pn,K (cid:16) (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:17) ϕp,L − ϕp,K + Pp,K,L (TL − TK) Pp,L − Pp,K (cid:1) − TK,LJp,K,L (cid:17)(cid:17) locally evaluating Eq. (9) as RK = R(φK, ϕn,K, ϕp,K, TK). Similarly, the discrete doping density on ΩK is taken as CK = C(rK). The discrete self-heating terms are HJ,K,L = −Jn,K,L (cid:16) HT -- P,K,L = −TK,LJn,K,L (cid:16) , , HR,K = q ϕp,K − ϕn,K + TK Pp,K − Pn,K RK. (27a) (27b) (27c) The finite volume discretization of the Joule and Thomson -- Peltier heating terms is not straightforward [86 -- 88]. De- tails on the derivation of Eqs. (27a) -- (27b) are provided in Appendix C. The discretization of the edge current densities Jn/p,K,L, the edge-averaged temperature TK,L and the Seebeck coefficients Pn/p,K,L along the edge KL are subject to the following sections. 3.2. Discretization of the current density expression The discretization of Jn/p,K,L is obtained by integrating the current density expressions (22) along the edge KL between two adjacent nodes of the mesh. Since the Kelvin formula implies a remarkably simple form of the electrical current densities in drift-diffusion form, where the thermal driving force is eliminated exactly (see Sec. 2.4), this allows for a straightforward adaptation of the Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes developed for the isothermal case. We assume the electrostatic field E = −∇φ and the temperature gradient ∇T to be constant along the edge KL, such that φ (x) = x φL + (1 − x) φK, T (x) = x TL + (1 − x) TK, where x ∈ [0, 1] parametrizes the coordinate on the edge r (x) = x rL + (1 − x) rK. Tacitly, these assumptions have already been used above in Eqs. (24a) and (24d). Moreover, also the mobilities Mn/p and the fluxes Jn/p,K,L are assumed to be constant on the edge. For the electron current density, this yields the two-point boundary value problem (BVP) (cid:32) kBT (x) g (cid:33) dn n (x) Nc (T (x)) dx = q (φL − φK) n (x) + Jn,K,L Mn , n (0) = nK, n (1) = nL, (28) on x = [0, 1]. The problem for the holes current density is analogous. In the non-degenerate case (Maxwell -- Boltzmann statistics) the degeneracy factor is exactly g ≡ 1, such that the problem can be solved exactly by separation of variables. One obtains q (φL − φK) nL dn Jn,K,L qMn(φL−φK) = + n nK kB 0 1 dx T (x) , 10 where the integral on the right hand side yields the (inverse) logarithmic mean temperature = 1 Λ (TL, TK) ≡ 1 TK,L , Λ (x, y) = x − y log (x/y) , (29) 1 dx T (x) = 0 1 0 dx x TL + (1 − x) TK (cid:16) (cid:16) (cid:17) − nK B (cid:16)−Xndeg (cid:17)(cid:17) where Λ (x, y) is the logarithmic mean. Solving for the flux yields the non-isothermal Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme Jndeg n,K,L = MnkBTK,L where B (x) = x/(cid:0)exp (x) − 1(cid:1) is the Bernoulli function. The Bernoulli function is closely related to the logarithmic mean: B (x) = 1/Λ(cid:0)exp (x), 1(cid:1). At isothermal conditions TK ≡ TL, Eq. (30) reduces to the original Scharfetter -- Xndeg n,K,L Xndeg n,K,L nLB (30) n,K,L = , , Gummel scheme [43]. In the case of Fermi -- Dirac statistics (g (cid:44) 1), no closed-form solution exists such that approximate solutions of the BVP (28) are required. As the degeneracy factor g depends on both the carrier density and temperature, the problem is not even separable q (φL − φK) kBTK,L 3.2.1. Modified thermal voltage scheme Following Refs. [54, 56], we solve the BVP (28) by freezing the degeneracy factor g (n/Nc (T)) → gn,K,L to a carefully chosen average. The resulting problem has the same structure as in the non-degenerate case (see above), but with a modified thermal voltage kBTK,L/q → kBTK,Lgn,K,L/q along the edge, which takes the temperature variation and the degeneration of the electron gas into account. This yields the modified thermal voltage scheme q (φL − φK) kBTK,Lgn,K,L (cid:17) − nK B (cid:16)−Xg = MnkBTK,Lgn,K,L Xg n,K,L Xg n,K,L Jg n,K,L (cid:17)(cid:17) (31a) nLB n,K,L (cid:16) (cid:16) = , , where TK,L is the logarithmic mean temperature (29). In order to ensure the consistency with the thermodynamic equilibrium and boundedness gn,K ≤ gn,K,L ≤ gn,L (for ηn,K ≤ ηn,L or with K ↔ L else), the edge-averaged degeneracy factor is taken as [54, 56] log(cid:0)F(cid:0)ηn,L (cid:1) /F(cid:0)ηn,K ηn,L − ηn,K (cid:1)(cid:1) = gn,K,L = F −1 (nL/Nc (TL)) − F −1 (nK/Nc (TK)) log (nL/Nc (TL)) − log (nK/Nc (TK)) . (31b) In the limit of ηn,L = ηn,K, it approaches the common nodal value lim ηn,L→ηn,K≡¯ηn gn,K,L = F (¯ηn) F (cid:48) (¯ηn) = g (F (¯ηn)) ≡ gη (¯ηn) . For constant temperature TL = TK = T, the scheme reduces to the modified Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme discussed in Refs. [54, 56]. It can thus be regarded as a non-isothermal generalization of this approach. In the non-degenerate limit g = 1, it reduces to the non-isothermal, non-degenerate Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme (30). 3.2.2. Modified drift scheme The traditional approach for the inclusion of degeneration effects in the Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme, that is widely used in commercial software packages, is based on introducing the correction factors [52, 90, 91] γ (η) = F (η) exp (η) , (32) and rearranging the current density expression with nonlinear diffusion (22) (involving the generalized Einstein rela- tion (23)) into a form with linear diffusion and a modified drift term: (cid:32) φ + kBT q (cid:33) log (γ (ηn)) . (33) jn = σnEn + MnkBT∇n + kB q σn ρn (T, ηn)∇T, En = −∇ 11 Here, the degeneration of the electron gas induces a thermodiffusion term with the coefficient ρn (T, ηn) = log (γ (ηn)) − T N(cid:48) c (T) Nc (T) γ(cid:48) (ηn) /γ (ηn) 1 + γ(cid:48) (ηn) /γ (ηn) = log (γ (ηn)) + (34) that vanishes exactly in the non-degenerate limit γ (η) ≡ 1 ≡ gη (η). Hence, the function ρn (T, ηn) quantifies the differ- ence between the degenerate and the non-degenerate Seebeck-coefficient, see Fig. 2 (a). On the step from Eq. (22) to (33), we have used the relation gη (η) = (1 + γ(cid:48) (η) /γ (η))−1. A plot of the correction factor (32) is given in Fig. 1 (c). The current density expression (33) is discretized by projecting the current on the edge KL, assuming the effective electric field En to be a constant along the edge, and freezing ρn (T, ηn) → ρn,K,L to a constant average value. Here, different averages can be taken for ρn,K,L, see Fig. 4 (c). The influence of this choice will be discussed below in Sec. 3.4. Along the same lines as above, one arrives at the modified drift scheme , T N(cid:48) c (T) Nc (T) (cid:16) (cid:17) gη (ηn) − 1 Jγ n,K,L = MnkBTK,L (cid:16) TL log(cid:0)γ(cid:0)ηn,L nLB (cid:16) (cid:17) − nK B (cid:16)−Xγ (cid:1)(cid:1) (cid:1)(cid:1) − TK log(cid:0)γ(cid:0)ηn,K Xγ n,K,L (cid:17)(cid:17) n,K,L , TK,L (cid:33) . (cid:32) TL TK (35a) (35b) − ρn,K,L log Again, TK,L is the logarithmic mean temperature (29). The corresponding non-degenerate limit (30) is easily recovered with Xγ n,K,L = by γ(cid:0)ηn,L/K (cid:1) → 1 and ρn,K,L → 0. q (φL − φK) kBTK,L + 3.3. Limiting cases and structure preserving properties In the following, we investigate some important limiting cases and structure preserving properties of the gen- eralized Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes (31) and (35). This includes an analysis of the consistency of the discrete expressions with fundamental thermodynamical principles (thermodynamic equilibrium, second law of thermody- namics). To this end, it is convenient to rewrite both expressions using the identity B (−x) = exp (x) B (x) and the logarithmic mean Λ (see Eq. (29)) as (cid:16) ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pg (cid:16) ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pγ (cid:17) n,K,L (TL − TK) (cid:17) n,K,L (TL − TK) Jg n,K,L = −σ g n,K,L and Jγ n,K,L = −σγ n,K,L (cid:16) g with σ n,K,L =qMn Λ nL exp (cid:16) Λ nL exp with σγ n,K,L =qMn (cid:17) (cid:17) (cid:16)− 1 (cid:16)− 1 (cid:16) 1 n,K,L 2 Xg sinhc , nK exp 2 Xg n,K,L (cid:16) 1 n,K,L 2 Xγ sinhc , nK exp 2 Xγ n,K,L (cid:17) (cid:17) (cid:17)(cid:17) (cid:16) 1 2 Xg n,K,L (cid:16) 1 2 Xγ n,K,L , (36) (cid:17)(cid:17) , (37) log (cid:32) Nc (TL) (cid:33) (cid:32) Nc (TL) Nc (TK) 1 Nc (TK) log (TL/TK) log (TL/TK) Pg n,K,L = − kB q and Pγ n,K,L = − kB q (cid:34) log where sinhc (x) = sinh (x)/x. This representation directly corresponds to the continuous current density expression g/γ in the thermodynamic form (8), where the conductivity along the edge σ n,K,L is determined by a "tilted" logarithmic average of the nodal carrier densities. Both expressions (36) -- (37) have a common structure, but differ in the discrete conductivity σ n,K,L along the edge, which are implicitly prescribed by the Scharfetter -- Gummel discretization procedure. The latter read Ec (TL) − Ec (TK) (cid:1) ηn,L −(cid:0)TK − TK,L n,K,L) and the discrete Seebeck coefficients Pg n,K,L (due to Xg (cid:44) σγ (cid:44) Xγ (cid:44) Pγ gn,K,L g n,K,L (cid:33) (cid:34) n,K,L − n,K,L TL − TK (cid:0)TL − TK,L + ρn,K,L − TL log(cid:0)γ(cid:0)ηn,L (cid:0)TL − TK,L (cid:1) ηn,K (cid:1)(cid:1) − TK log(cid:0)γ(cid:0)ηn,K (cid:1)(cid:1) − TK,L log(cid:0)γ(cid:0)ηn,L (cid:1) ηn,K (cid:1) ηn,L −(cid:0)TK − TK,L TL − TK TL − TK − 1 kB (cid:35) (cid:1) /γ(cid:0)ηn,K (cid:35) (38a) (cid:1)(cid:1) (38b) − 1 kB Ec (TL) − Ec (TK) TL − TK . TL − TK − 12 = −(cid:0)ϕn,L − ϕn,K (cid:1) / (TL − TK) equals the (negative) ratio of both discrete driving forces such that the discrete The discrete Seebeck coefficients (38) enter the discrete Joule heat term (27a) and thus the discrete entropy production rate (see Sec. 3.3.5 below). Out of the thermodynamic equilibrium, the discrete Seebeck coefficients (38) determine the point of compensating (discrete) chemical and thermal current flow such that Jn,K,Lϕn,K(cid:44)ϕn,L,TK(cid:44)TL = 0. In other words, there is a non-equilibrium configuration with TK (cid:44) TL and ϕn,K (cid:44) ϕn,L, where the discrete Seebeck coefficient Pg/γ n,K,L current density is zero. This compensation point is in general slightly different between both schemes (see inset of Fig. 4 (c)). In the limit of a small temperature gradient and a small difference in the reduced Fermi energy along the edge, both discrete Seebeck coefficients approach in leading order the continuous expression (16a) n) + O(δηn δΘ) + O(δΘ2), E(cid:48) c( ¯T) (cid:34) ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) + O(δη2 Nc( ¯T) 2 (TL + TK), δηn = ηn,L − ηn,K and ¯ηn = 1 gη (¯ηn) − ¯ηn − 1 kB (cid:35) 2 = − kB q where δΘ = (TL − TK) / ¯T, ¯T = 1 Pg/γ n,K,L (cid:0)ηn,L + ηn,K (cid:1). 3.3.1. Thermodynamic equilibrium In the thermodynamic equilibrium (thermal equilibrium TK = TL and chemical equilibrium ϕn,K = ϕn,L), both the discrete current densities (31) and (35) are exactly zero. This is easily seen from Eqs. (36) -- (37), where the discrete driving force vanishes under thermodynamic equilibrium conditions. (cid:16) ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pg/γ (cid:17) n,K,L (TL − TK) 3.3.2. Strong electric field (drift-dominated limit) Due to the asymptotics of the Bernoulli function B (x → ∞) = 0 and B (x → −∞) ∼ −x, the modified thermal voltage scheme (31) approaches the first-order upwind scheme (cid:0)δφK,L → ±∞(cid:1) ∼ −qMn (cid:18) nL + nK sign(cid:0)δφK,L (cid:1)(cid:19) nK − nL + Jg n,K,L δφK,L = Jupw n,K,L 2 2 (39) in the limit of a strong electrostatic potential gradient δφK,L = φL − φK → ±∞. The upwind scheme is a stable, first- order accurate discretization for advection-dominated problems, where the coefficient is evaluated in the "donor cell" of the flow [92]. Hence, this asymptotic feature of the original Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme, which is important for the robustness of the discretization as it avoid spurious oscillations, is preserved in the degenerate and non-isothermal case. The modified drift scheme (35) approaches the upwind scheme as well  − (TL − TK) ρn,K,L  , (cid:1) and temperatures TL (cid:44) TK are very different. This is shown in Fig. 4 (c), where the modified however, in the case of strong degeneration the convergence is significantly slowed down if the nodal correction drift scheme shows a constant offset from the numerically exact solution of the BVP (28) for δφK,L → −∞. (cid:0)δφK,L → ±∞(cid:1) ∼ −qMn factors γ(cid:0)ηn,K (cid:1)(cid:19)δφK,L + (cid:2)γ(cid:0)ηn,L (cid:2)γ(cid:0)ηn,K sign(cid:0)δφK,L (cid:1) (cid:44) γ(cid:0)ηn,K (cid:18) nL + nK log (cid:1)(cid:3)TL (cid:1)(cid:3)TK nK − nL Jγ n,K,L kB q 2 2 + 3.3.3. No electric field (diffusive limit) In the case of a vanishing electrostatic potential gradient δφK,L = φL − φK = 0 the schemes take the form lim δφK,L→0 Jg n,K,L lim δφK,L→0 Jγ n,K,L = MnkBTK,Lgn,K,L (nL − nK) , 1 = MnkBTK,L (cid:18) Λ T ρn,K,L L [γ(ηn,L)]TL /TK,L , T ρn,K,L K [γ(ηn,K)]TK /TK,L (cid:19) (cid:2)γ(cid:0)ηn,L T ρn,K,L L (cid:1)(cid:3)TL/TK,L nL − (cid:2)γ(cid:0)ηn,K T ρn,K,L K (cid:1)(cid:3)TK /TK,L (40)  . nK The modified thermal voltage scheme (31) approaches the central finite difference discretization (40), which is a stable discretization for diffusion-dominated transport problems [92]. With the edge-averaged degeneracy factor gn,K,L, Eq. (40) nicely reflects the structure of the diffusive part of the continuous current density expression (22) involving the generalized Einstein relation (23). For the modified drift scheme (35), the limiting expression is a weighted finite difference discretization. Due to the different treatment of the degeneracy of the electron gas via the correction factors (32), it does not yield a discrete analogue of the generalized Einstein relation. 13 3.3.4. Purely thermally driven currents In the chemical equilibrium (ϕn,L = ϕn,K), the current is driven only by the temperature gradient. The correspond- ing expressions are easily obtained from Eqs. (36) -- (37), which include the discrete Seebeck coefficients (38). 3.3.5. Non-negativity of the discrete dissipation rate The continuous entropy production rate (dissipation rate) per volume (see Eq. (D.4)) has contributions from carrier recombination, heat flux and Joule heating HJ = − (∇ϕn + Pn∇T)·jn−(cid:16)∇ϕp + Pp∇T stot = HJ, T 2 (cid:107)∇T(cid:107)2 + (µc − µv) R + 1 T 1 T κ (cid:17)·jp. With the current density expressions (8) and a recombination rate of the form (9), all terms in stot (including HJ) are evidently non-negative (i. e., zero in the thermodynamic equilibrium and positive else). Therefore, the model obeys the second law of thermodynamics. In order to rule out unphysical phenomena such as steady state dissipation [54, 93], it is highly desirable to preserve this important structural property of the continuous system in its discrete counter- part. Given the finite volume discretization described above, this is straightforwardly achieved for the contributions from the carrier recombination and the heat flux, however, it is less obvious for the Joule heating term. In fact, the non-negativity of the discrete Joule heating term is non-trivial and can be violated in general when using a naive discretization approach as in Ref. [94]. We show that the discrete dissipation rate is evidently non-negative for both generalized Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes (31) and (35). This follows immediately from their consistency with the thermodynamic equilibrium (see Sec. 3.3.1) in conjunction with the discrete form (27a) of the heating term. Substituting Eq. (36) in (27a), one obtains = −(cid:16) Hg J,n (cid:17) n,K,L (TL − TK) ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pg (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)ϕn,L − ϕn,K + Pg n,K,L (TL − TK) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 ≥ 0, Jg n,K,L = σ g n,K,L g which is zero only in the (discrete) thermodynamic equilibrium and positive else. The discrete conductivity σ n,K,L is positive by construction, see Eq. (36). Analogous expressions are obtained for the holes' current contribution and the modified drift scheme (35). In conclusion, the consistency of the discrete system (24) with the second law of thermodynamics relies on using the respective Seebeck coefficients Pn/p,K,L implied by the current discretization (see Eq. (38)) consistently in the discretized Joule heating term (27a). Only then this structural property of the discrete system holds without any smallness assumption. 3.4. Comparison with numerically exact solution We investigate the accuracy of the schemes (31) and (35) by comparing them with the numerically exact solution of the BVP (28). In the isothermal case, this has been carried out before in a similar way by Farrell et al. [95] (for different Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes), which inspired the investigation of highly accurate Scharfetter -- Gummel type discretizations based on the direct numerical integration of the arising integral equation using quadrature rules in Ref. [96]. In the present non-isothermal case, the problem is more complicated because of the spatially varying temperature distribution along the edge. It is convenient to recast the problem (28) into the form dy (x) = ¯T T (x) dx y (0) = ¯ηn − 1 (cid:104) (cid:105) δΦ + Nc( ¯T) Nc(T(x)) J F (y) T(x)N(cid:48) c(T(x)) Nc(T(x)) F (y) F (cid:48) (y) − δΘ 1 2 δηn, y (1) = ¯ηn + 2 (TL + TK), δT = TL − TK, ¯ηn = 1 2 with the notations T (x) ≡(cid:16) x − 1 and the non-dimensionalized quantities 1 + 2 2 δηn, (cid:17) ¯T, ¯T = 1 δΘ , (41) (cid:0)ηn,L + ηn,K (cid:1), δηn = ηn,L − ηn,K (cid:32) (cid:33) J = Jn,K,L MnkB ¯T Nc( ¯T) , δΦ = q (φL − φK) kB ¯T , δΘ = δT ¯T . 14 Fig. 4. Comparison of the non-isothermal Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes for δηn = 5. (a) In the non-degenerate regime (¯ηn = −5) all schemes coincide, even in the presence of a temperature gradient. (b) At ¯ηn = 2 degeneration effects become significant. While Jg follows Jexact with an acceptable error over the whole range of δΦ, the modified drift scheme Jγ has a significant offset at strong electric fields (δΦ → −∞). The grey shaded area indicates the analytic bounds of the modified thermal voltage scheme determined using the nodal values gn,K and gn,L instead of gn,K,L. (c) An additional temperature gradient increases the error in the degenerate regime. The insets show the effect of different averages ρn,K,L of the nodal values ρn,K and ρn,L in the modified drift scheme and the different behavior of the schemes in the region of vanishing discrete currents. The exact current Jexact = Jexact(δΦ, δηn, δΘ, ¯ηn, ¯T) is a function of five parameters that satisfies the BVP (41). We solve the BVP (41) numerically using the shooting method [97], where we combine a 4th order Runge -- Kutta method with Brent's root finding algorithm [98] . The problem is invariant under the simultaneous transformation J → −J δΦ → −δΦ, δΘ → −δΘ, x → 1 − x, δηn → −δηn, (i. e., the sign of the current changes when changing the nodes K ↔ L), such that we can restrict our analysis to δΘ ≥ 0, when exploring the accuracy of the discrete current in the (δΦ, δηn)-plane. The comparison is carried out for F (η) = F1/2 (η) and Nc = 2 MacLeod's algorithm [99]. (cid:17)3/2. The Fermi -- Dirac integrals F1/2 (η) and F−1/2 (η) are evaluated using m∗ ckBT/(2π2) (cid:16) Figure 4 shows the numerically exact current Jexact along with the approximations Jg (modified thermal voltage scheme (31)) and Jγ (modified drift scheme (35)) as a function of the normalized electric field δΦ along the edge. For weak degeneracy, both schemes agree with the numerically exact solution -- even in the case of non-isothermal conditions. This is shown in Fig. 4 (a) for ¯ηn = −5 and δΘ = 0.1. At strong electric fields δΦ → ±∞, all schemes approach the upwind scheme Jupw (grey dashed line, cf. Eq. (39)). The schemes (31) and (35) differ in the treatment of degeneration effects, which becomes apparent for increased ¯ηn. Figure 4 (b) shows the results for ¯ηn = 2 at isothermal conditions δΘ = 0. The modified thermal voltage scheme Jg (red line) yields an acceptable deviation from the exact result Jexact (black line) over the whole range of δΦ. The error vanishes at strong electric fields where both Jg and Jexact converge to the upwind scheme Jupw. The modified drift scheme (purple line), however, shows a significant error at large (negative) δΦ, where it overestimates the current density significantly (about 33 % relative error at δΦ = −3). This behavior results from the different treatment of the degeneration effects, that degrades the convergence of the modified drift scheme in the case of strong degeneration (see Sec. 3.3.2). The plot highlights two other important exceptional points (pure diffusion and zero current), where both schemes show a similar accuracy. In the presence of an additional temperature gradient along the edge, see Fig. 4 (c), the approximation error of both schemes increases. The upper inset shows that the choice of the average of ρn,K,L (see Eq. (34)) has only a minor impact on the modified drift scheme. The lower inset zooms on the region where the currents become zero. Here, all schemes provide a satisfying accuracy, but none of them is exact, i. e., they yield a small spurious discrete current and intersect with the exact solution only in the vicinity of the exact zero current point. We observe that the modified drift schemes show a slightly better performance in this case, i. e., the Seebeck coefficient (38b) appears to be slightly better than (38a). The normalized absolute errors (J − Jexact)/ J (with J = MnkB ¯T Nc( ¯T)) of the two schemes (31) and (35) are shown in the (δΦ, δηn)-plane in Fig. 5 under isothermal (δΘ = 0, top row (a) -- (d)) and non-isothermal (δΘ = 1/6, bottom row (e) -- (h)) conditions and for different levels of degeneration (weak ¯ηn = 0 and strong ¯ηn = 5). In the limit of very fine meshes (δΦ, δηn, δΘ) → (0, 0, 0), both schemes coincide and the deviation from the exact current approaches 15 -4-20246800.050.100.150.200.250.300.35-10-8-6-4-20246810-1001020304050607080-10-8-6-4-20246810020406080100120zerocurrentpurediffusionarith.log.geom.harm.(a)(b)(c)normalized edge current0671-1Fig. 5. Comparison of the two non-isothermal Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes (31) and (35) (with arithmetic average ρn,K,L =(cid:0)ρn,K + ρn,L (cid:1) /2) in the (δΦ, δηn)-plane at isothermal (δΘ = 0, top row (a) -- (d)) and non-isothermal (δΘ = 1/6, bottom row (e) -- (h)) conditions and different levels of degeneration (weak ¯ηn = 0 or strong ¯ηn = 5). The normalized absolute error (J − Jexact)/ J is color-coded for the range [−1, 1] (dark colored regions correspond to larger errors, see the level lines). See the text for a discussion. zero. One observes that the size of the white regions with a normalized absolute error below 0.01 (in the following denoted as "low error domain") are generally larger for the modified thermal voltage scheme than for the modified drift scheme. Thus, the modified thermal voltage scheme is expected to yield a higher accuracy on sufficiently fine meshes. This will be evidenced by the numerical simulation of a p-n-diode in Sec. 3.6. The plots in Fig. 5 feature two additional lines, that refer to special limiting cases where both schemes yield a very high accuracy. The case of a pure drift current (i. e., no diffusion nL = nK) is indicated by a red line; the zero current line (blue) refers to the curve in the (δΦ, δηn)-plane where the exact current vanishes (Jexact = 0 in the BVP (41)). In the isothermal case (δΘ = 0), the latter corresponds to the thermodynamic equilibrium, in the non-isothermal case (δΘ (cid:44) 0) it refers to the situation of compensating chemical and thermal driving forces. Both schemes are exact in the case of a pure drift current, i. e., they asymptotically approach the upwind scheme (39), which is important for the robustness of the discretization in order to avoid spurious oscillations. The modified thermal voltage scheme shows a high accuracy also for slight deviations from the pure drift line, even in the case of strong degeneration, see Fig. 5 (b, f). In contrast, the modified drift scheme yields significant errors (much higher than 0.01) already for tiny deviations from the pure drift line in the strongly degenerate case, see Fig. 5 (d, h). This behavior has already been observed above in Fig. 4 (b, c) and was predicted analytically in Sec. 3.3.2. Note that in the non-isothermal case, the temperature gradient shifts the pure drift line from pure drift c( ¯T)/Nc( ¯T) (see Fig. 5 (e -- h)). A prominent feature of δη n the modified drift scheme is the additional intersection with the exact solution (see also Fig. 4 (c) at δΦ ≈ 3.5), which leads to additional "fingers" of the low error domain, see Fig. 5 (c, d, g, h), that are not associated with any special limiting case. The same feature has been observed for the so-called inverse activity scheme described in Ref. [95]. Finally, we study the consistency of the discretization schemes with the zero current line. In the isothermal case, both schemes are exact and therefore consistent with the thermodynamic equilibrium, see Fig. 5 (a -- d). In the strongly degenerate case, however, the zero current line is only partially located within the low error domain, since the schemes intersect with the exact solution only in the vicinity of the zero current line and not exactly on it (see also the inset of Fig. 4 (c)). Nevertheless, the zero current lines of the discrete schemes, which are plotted as dashed orange lines in Fig. 5 (e -- h), nicely overlap with the exact zero current line (blue). Thus, the spurious non-zero currents are very low and the little discrepancy in this limiting case is only of minor importance. δΘ=0 = 0 (in Fig. 5 (a -- d)) to δη ≈ −δΘgη(¯ηn) ¯T N(cid:48) pure drift n 16 modified thermal voltage schememodified drift scheme-2-1012-2-1012-4-3-2-101234-4-3-2-101234-4-3-2-101234-4-3-2-101234-1.01.0pure drift(a)zero current(b)(c)(d)0.010.10.010.10.010.10.010.1110.010.10.010.10.010.10.010.111(e)(f)(g)(h)10we obtain the series expansion of the discrete currents (31) and (35) at (δΦ, δηn, δΘ) = (0, 0, 0) up to second order as 3.5. Analytical error estimate We compare both schemes (31) and (35) by deriving an upper error bound. We follow the approach developed by Farrell et al. [95] and extend it to the non-isothermal case. Using the identities B (x) − B (−x) = −x, Jg = −F (¯ηn) δΦ + F (¯ηn) Jγ = −F (¯ηn) Xγ + F (cid:48) (¯ηn) where (cid:18) x (cid:19) , 2 B (x) + B (−x) = x coth (cid:33) (cid:32) Xg (cid:33) (cid:32) Xγ coth 2 2 gη (¯ηn) δΘ gη (¯ηn) δΘ coth 2 + O(δ3), + O(δ3), (cid:32) (cid:32) δη + δη + ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) (cid:33) Xg (cid:33) Xγ (cid:32) 2 (cid:33) 1 Xγ = δΦ − gη (¯ηn) − 1 ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) gη (¯ηn) δΦ, Xg = gη (¯ηn) n δΘ)+O(δΘ2 δηn)+O(δΘ3)+O(δΦ δη2 n)+O(δΦ δηn δΘ)+O(δΦ δΘ2) denotes the third-order n)+O(δη2 and O(δ3) ≡ O(δη3 corrections. The second-order expansion of the modified drift scheme is independent of the kind of average used for ρn,K,L ≈ ρn(¯ηn, ¯T) + O(δη2 n) + O(δηn δΘ) + O(δΘ2), as only its zeroth-order contribution (where all means coincide) is relevant here. Using the inequality [95] gη (¯ηn) δΘ δη + , 1 ≤ x coth (x) ≤ 1 + x , we arrive at the error estimates for the modified thermal voltage scheme (neglecting third-order terms) F (cid:48) (¯ηn) δΦ δηn + ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) gη (¯ηn)δΦ δΘ (cid:33) ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) gη (¯ηn)δΦ δΘ + gη (¯ηn) − 1 gη (¯ηn) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)Jg − J1 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) ≤ 1 δΦ δηn + 2 (cid:32) (cid:19) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)δηn + (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 , ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) gη (¯ηn) δΘ (42) (43) and the modified drift scheme (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)Jγ − J1 F (cid:48) (¯ηn) (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) ≤ 1 (cid:18) 2 δηn − δΦ + ¯T N(cid:48) c( ¯T) Nc( ¯T) gη (¯ηn) δΘ where J1 = F (¯ηn) is the first-order exact solution of the BVP (41). Both schemes converge to the exact result as their first-order terms agree with J1. The first two terms of Eq. (43) coincide with Eq. (42). The error bound for the modified drift scheme has an additional second-order contribution that becomes significant in the case of strong degeneration ¯η (cid:29) 1 where (gη (¯ηn)− 1)/gη (¯ηn) → 1. Therefore, the maximum error of the modified thermal voltage scheme is guaranteed to be smaller than that of the modified drift scheme in the case of degenerate carrier statistics. This analytical result is consistent with the numerical results shown in Figs. 4 and 5 and holds in both the isothermal and the non-isothermal case. For non-degenerate carrier statistics, both error estimates (42) and (43) coincide, since both schemes reduce to the non-degenerate scheme (30). 3.6. Numerical simulation of a p-n-diode = 2 × 1018 cm−3 followed by a 1 µm long p-doped section with C = −N− We consider a one-dimensional GaAs-based p-n-diode and compare the convergence of the total current density (jtot = jn + jp) under mesh refinement using both discretization schemes. The device consists of a 1 µm n-doped = −2 × 1018 cm−3. section with C = N+ D We use Fermi -- Dirac statistics F (η) = F1/2 (η) and take Shockley -- Read -- Hall recombination, spontaneous emission and Auger recombination into account [15, 62]. The material parameters, mobility models (depending on temperature and doping density) and the temperature-dependent heat conductivity model are taken from Ref. [62]. The mobilities and thermal conductivity along the edges are taken as the harmonic average of the respective nodal values. We use Dirichlet boundary conditions on both ends of the diode, modeling ideal Ohmic contacts (charge neutrality at the A 17 Fig. 6. Convergence of total current density in the p-n diode problem without self-heating effects (H = 0, isothermal case). (a) Current-voltage curves obtained by the two schemes (31) and (35) on an equidistant grid with 13 nodes. The reference solution (black line) was obtained on a fine grid (65535 nodes). (b) Convergence of the relative error with respect to the reference solution under mesh refinement at 2 V. The modified drift scheme (blue squares) shows a monotonous, quadratic convergence for decreasing h. The modified thermal voltage scheme (red circles) converges non-monotonously as it intersects with the reference solution at h ≈ 4.5 nm. (c) Convergence of the absolute error of both schemes. boundary) and ideal heat sinks with Tcontact = 300 K. The simulations are carried out on equidistant grids with varying number of mesh points Nnodes and mesh size h = 2 µm/(Nnodes − 1). The nonlinear systems are solved using a Newton iteration method with a fully analytical Jacobian matrix [83]. Figure 6 (a) shows the current-voltage curves obtained by both discretization schemes on a coarse grid (13 nodes, h ≈ 1.7× 10−7 m) under isothermal conditions, i. e., without self-heating and Seebeck effect. For the evaluation of the error, we use a reference solution that was computed on a fine grid with 65535 nodes (h ≈ 3.1 × 10−11 m), where the relative error between both schemes is about 9.6 × 10−9. At 2 V the computed currents differ significantly from the reference result: The relative error is about 13 % for the modified thermal voltage scheme and 15 % for the modified drift scheme. The convergence of the computed current densities to the reference result under mesh refinement is shown in Fig. 6 (b). The modified drift scheme (Eq. (35), blue squares) shows a monotonous, quadratic convergence for decreasing h. The modified thermal voltage scheme (Eq. (31), red circles), however, shows a non-monotonous convergence behavior as it intersects with the reference solution at h ≈ 4.5 × 10−9 m. On sufficiently fine meshes (h < 10−8 m), the error of the modified thermal voltage scheme is almost one order of magnitude smaller than that of the modified drift scheme. Conversely, the modified thermal voltage scheme reaches the same accuracy as the modified drift scheme already on a coarse grid with less than half of the number of nodes. Thus, the modified thermal voltage scheme saves about one refinement step. The convergence of the absolute error is plotted in Fig. 6 (c), where the inset highlights the origin of the non-monotonous convergence behavior of the modified thermal voltage scheme. The numerical results for the non-isothermal case, where self-heating and the Seebeck effect are taken into account, are shown in Fig. 7. The results are qualitatively very similar to the isothermal case shown in Fig. 6; quantitatively the advantage of the modified thermal voltage scheme over the modified drift scheme is even greater. On a coarse grid, the total current is underestimated by both schemes with a relative error of about 8 %, see Fig. 7 (a). For sufficiently fine meshes (h < 0.5 × 10−8m), the error of the modified thermal voltage scheme is always more than one order of magnitude smaller than that of the modified drift scheme, see Fig. 7 (b). In other words, the modified thermal voltage scheme reaches the same accuracy already on an about four times coarser mesh (two refinement steps), which is a substantial advantage for large problems involving complex multi-dimensional geometries. Again, we observe a non-monotonous convergence behavior of the modified thermal voltage scheme, see Fig. 7 (b, c). 4. Summary and conclusion We discussed the non-isothermal drift-diffusion system for the simulation of electro-thermal transport processes in semiconductor devices. It was shown that the model equations take a remarkably simple form when assuming the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient. First, the heat generation rate involves exactly the three classically known self-heating effects (Joule heating, recombination heating, Thomson -- Peltier effect) without any further transient con- tributions. Moreover, our modeling approach immediately yields the correct average kinetic energy of the carriers 18 1.01.21.41.61.82.0bias [V]012345678×106(a)current density [A cm-2]10-1010-910-810-7h [m]10-1010-910-810-7h [m]relative error error10-110-210-410-310-510-610-810-7-12-8-6-4-20absolute error [A cm-2] ×10580-100010-1010-8-10(c)(b)2.0×1012 h29.7×1012 h2referencemodified thermal voltagemodified drift≈ 1 refinementstepFig. 7. Convergence of total current density in the p-n diode problem with self-heating effects. (a) Current-voltage curves obtained by the two schemes (31) and (35) on an equidistant grid with 13 nodes. As in Fig. 6, the reference solution (black line) was obtained on a grid with 65535 nodes. Self-heating lowers the mobilities such that the total current density is smaller than in the isothermal case, cf. Fig. 6 (a). (b) Convergence of the relative error with respect to the reference solution under mesh refinement at 2 V. As in the isothermal case, the modified thermal voltage scheme (red circles) shows a non-monotonous convergence behavior that is faster than the quadratic convergence of the modified drift scheme (blue squares). (c) Convergence of the absolute error of both schemes. The modified thermal voltage scheme intersects twice with the reference solution. in the recombination heating term, independently of any scattering parameter. Second, the Kelvin formula enables a simple representation of the electrical current densities in the drift-diffusion form, where the thermal driving force can be entirely absorbed in the (nonlinear) diffusion coefficient via the generalized Einstein relation. The Kelvin formula accounts for the degeneration of the electron-hole plasma (Fermi -- Dirac statistics) and was shown to be in a good quantitative agreement with experimental data reported for n-GaAs. We have derived two non-isothermal generalizations of the finite volume Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme for the dis- cretization of the current densities, which differ in their treatment of degeneration effects. The first approach is based on an approximation of the discrete generalized Einstein relation and implies a specific modification of the thermal voltage. The second scheme is based on including the degeneration effects into a modification of the electric field, which is similar to the conventional method that is widely used in commercial device simulation software packages [90, 91]. We presented a detailed analysis of both schemes by assessing their accuracy in comparison to the nu- merically exact solution of the underlying two-point boundary value problem. Moreover, we derived analytical error bounds and investigated important structure preserving properties of the discretizations, including the consistency with the thermodynamic equilibrium, the non-negativity of the discrete dissipation rate (second law of thermodynamics on the discrete level) and their asymptotic behavior in the drift- and diffusion-dominated limits. Finally, we performed a numerical convergence study for a simple example case. Our results indicate a significantly higher accuracy and faster convergence of the modified thermal voltage scheme in comparison to the modified drift scheme. This result holds under both isothermal and non-isothermal conditions. The higher accuracy -- about one order of magnitude for sufficiently fine grids in the present case study -- of the modified thermal voltage scheme makes it a favorable discretization method for problems exhibiting stiff solutions (internal layers at p-n junctions, boundary layers at elec- trical contacts) or devices with a complicated multi-dimensional geometry, where the number of nodes required to reach the asymptotic accuracy regime is extremely large and routinely exceeds the available computational power. In more general situations, where the Seebeck coefficient deviates from the Kelvin formula (e. g., due to the phonon drag effect), we suggest to combine the two discretization techniques by decomposing the Seebeck coefficient into a Kelvin formula part and an excess contribution: Pn = PKelvin n . The first part can be absorbed in the generalized Einstein relation, which allows for the treatment described in Sec. 3.2.1 and inherits the improved accuracy of the modified thermal voltage scheme. The excess part Pexc n must be averaged along the edge and plays a similar role as the ρn,K,L term in Sec. 3.2.2 (leading to an additive correction in the argument of the Bernoulli function). + Pexc n Acknowledgements This work was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) under Germany's Excellence Strategy -- EXC2046: Math+ (project AA2-3). The author is grateful to Thomas Koprucki for carefully reading the manuscript and giving valuable comments. 19 1.01.21.41.61.82.0bias [V]00.20.40.60.81.01.21.41.6current density [A cm-2]10-1010-910-810-7h [m]relative error error-10-8-6-4-20absolute error [A cm-2] ×106(a)10-110-210-410-310-510-610-810-910-7×10410-1010-910-810-7h [m]1.50-1.510-105×10-9(b)(c)2.3×1011 h24.0×1012 h2referencemodified thermal voltagemodified drift≈ 2 refinement stepsAppendix A. Non-parabolic energy bands The results presented in this paper hold for Fermi -- Dirac statistics with arbitrary density of states, provided that the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient is applicable. In particular, this includes also the case of non-parabolic energy bands. For example, we assume the scalar Kane-type model [28] for the conduction band energy dispersion E = Ec + εk, (1 + αεk) εk = 2k2 2m∗ c with the non-parabolicity parameter α ≥ 0. This corresponds to the density of states (in 3D) (cid:88) k,σ (cid:33)3/2 (cid:112) (cid:32)2m∗ c 2 Dc (E) = 1 V δ (E − E (k)) = 1 2π2 (E − Ec) (1 + α (E − Ec)) (1 + 2α (E − Ec)) Θ (E − Ec) , which recovers with the parabolic case for α = 0. Here, Θ is the Heaviside step function. For weak non-parabolicity 0 ≤ α/β (cid:28) 1, the corresponding electron density can be expanded in a series of Fermi -- Dirac integrals (7) (cid:33)n n = dE Dc (E) R = Nc (T) F (ηn) , F (ηn) = Fn+ 1 2 (ηn) , with ηn = β (µc + qφ − Ec) and β = (kBT)−1, which is clearly of the type (5). The desired asymptotic behavior in the non-degenerate limit F (η (cid:28) −1) ∼ exp (η) is restored by rescaling ∞(cid:88) n=0 2 α β (cid:17) (cid:16) 5 (cid:17)(cid:32) (cid:16) 5 + n 2 − n (cid:19)−1 (cid:18) β K2 2α 1 n! Γ Γ (cid:18) β (cid:19) 2α (cid:114) β πα exp (cid:3)(cid:1) + 1 1 exp(cid:0)β(cid:2)E − qφ − µc (cid:114) (cid:18) β (cid:18) β (cid:19) β πα exp K2 2α 2α (cid:19) Nc (T) → Nc (T) , F (η) → F (η), where Kν is the modified Bessel function of second kind. Appendix B. Generalization to the case of multiple temperatures The results for the Kelvin formula can be generalized to the multi-temperature case, i.e., to systems describing hot carrier transport where the carrier ensembles have temperatures different from the lattice temperature Tn (cid:44) TL (cid:44) T p. We postulate the free energy density of the electron-hole plasma (cid:16) fe -- h n, p, Tn, T p, TL = kBTn (cid:17) (cid:34) nF −1 (cid:32) pF −1  n (cid:16) Nc (TL, Tn) p T p, TL Nv − Nc (Tn, TL) G (cid:33) (cid:17) − Nv (cid:16) (cid:32) (cid:17) G F −1 (cid:32) F −1  + kBT p T p, TL (cid:33)(cid:33)(cid:35)  (cid:17)  − pEv (TL) , + nEc (TL) Nc (Tn, TL) p T p, TL n (cid:16) Nv (cid:16) (B.1) (cid:17)3/2, where where the effective density of states Nc/v = Nc/v(Tn/p, TL) is now a function of the carrier temperature and the lattice temperature. In the case of 3D bulk materials, this might be for example Nc/v = 2 the effective masses are allowed to depend on the lattice temperature TL. Moreover, the band gap energy and the band (cid:17) edge energies Ec/v depend solely on TL. The free energy density of the phonon gas fL = fL (TL) and the electrostatic interaction energy fCoul = fCoul (p − n) are the same as in Sec. 2.1. + fCoul (p − n) + fL (TL) is a n, p, Tn, T p, TL The multi-temperature free energy density f m∗ e/h (TL) kBTn/p/(2π2) n, p, Tn, T p, TL = fe -- h (cid:16) (cid:17) thermodynamic potential, that yields expressions for the chemical potentials (cid:16) (cid:33) (cid:17) − Ev (TL) + qφ + Ec (TL) − qφ (cid:32)  Nc (Tn, TL) n (cid:16) p T p, TL Nv 20 +µc = −µv = ∂ f ∂n ∂ f ∂p = kBTnF −1 = kBT pF −1 (B.2a) (B.2b) and the entropy densities The state equations for the carrier densities follow from Eq. (B.2) as sn = − ∂ f ∂Tn , (cid:32) µc + qφ − Ec (TL) kBTn (cid:0)∇ϕn + Pn,n∇Tn + PL,n∇TL jn = −σn (cid:33) (cid:1) , sp = − ∂ f ∂T p , sL = − ∂ f ∂TL . (cid:16) (cid:32) Ev (TL) − qφ − µv (cid:33) (cid:17) F (cid:17) (cid:16)∇ϕp + Pp,p∇T p + PL,p∇TL kBT p , . jp = −σp n = Nc (Tn, TL) F , p = Nv T p, TL In analogy to Eq. (8), we postulate the generalized electrical current density expressions with the thermopowers given by the Kelvin formula Pn,n = −1 q ∂sn ∂n , PL,n = −1 q ∂sL ∂n , Pp,p = + 1 q ∂sp ∂p , PL,p = + 1 q ∂sL ∂p . Here, we do not describe the corresponding hot carrier transport system in full detail, but rather focus on the cen- tral property of the electrical current densities, which is the simple representation in the drift-diffusion form (without thermodiffusion). If the thermal driving forces can be absorbed in a generalized Einstein relation for the diffusion coef- ficient, this enables a generalized Scharfetter -- Gummel discretization of type (31) (modified thermal voltage scheme). With the definitions given above, the drift-diffusion form of Eq. (B.3) reads (along the lines in Sec. 2.4) (cid:33) (cid:32) (B.3) (B.4) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:32) (cid:33) −1 q = −σn −1 jn = −σn ∇µc + Pn,n∇Tn + PL,n∇TL q ∇ ∂ fCoul ∇ ∂ fe -- h − 1 −1 = −σn q ∂n q ∂n (cid:34) ∂2 fe -- h ∂n2 ∇n − 1 ∇φ − 1 = −σn q (cid:32) ∂2 fe -- h ∇φ − 1 = −σn ∂n2 ∇n + q = −qMnn∇φ + MnkBTng ∇ ∂ f ∂n + Pn,n∇Tn + PL,n∇TL (cid:34) ∂2 fe -- h ∂2 fe -- h ∂n ∂Tn ∂n ∂TL 1 q (cid:35) ∇Tn − 1 q (cid:33) ∂sn ∇Tn + ∂n ∇n Pn,n + q n Nc (Tn, TL) + Pn,n∇Tn + PL,n∇TL ∇TL + Pn,n∇Tn + PL,n∇TL (cid:35) (cid:33) PL,n + 1 q ∂sL ∂n ∇TL (cid:33) (cid:33) (holes analogously). As a result, the generalized Einstein relation -- which now yields a nonlinear diffusion coefficient that depends on both the lattice and the carrier temperature -- allows to absorb the thermal driving forces also in the multi-temperature case, if the respective Kelvin formulae (B.4) for the Seebeck coefficients are assumed. Appendix C. Discretization of the heat source term This section explains the finite volume discretization of the heat source term (27) entering the discrete heat equa- tion (24d) in more detail. First, the discrete recombination heating term is obtained by integration over the K-th Voronoï cell as (cid:16) ϕp − ϕn + Πp − Πn (cid:17) (cid:16) R ≈ q ϕp,K − ϕn,K + TK (cid:16) (cid:17)(cid:17) RK, using the local values of the quasi-Fermi potentials, temperature, Seebeck coefficients and RK = R(φK, ϕn,K, ϕp,K, TK). The discretization of the Joule and Thomson -- Peltier heating terms is more involved. The continuous expressions HR,K = dV q ΩK 1 ΩK (cid:88) 1 σλ λ∈{n,p} HJ = (cid:107)jλ(cid:107)2 = − (cid:88) λ∈{n,p} Pp,K − Pn,K (cid:88) λ∈{n,p} HT -- P = −T jλ · ∇Pλ jλ · (∇ϕλ + Pλ∇T) , 21 are all of the type H = κ (jλ · ∇ψ), where jλ is an electrical current density vector and ∇ψ is the gradient of a particular scalar field with ψ ∈ {ϕλ, T, Pλ} and κ ∈ {1, Pλ, T} for λ ∈ {n, p}. The essential problem in the discretization of H is that the full vector field jλ and the full gradient ∇ψ are required on the cell ΩK, whereas naturally only approximations of the normal components are available. There are several methods to tackle this problem, see Ref. [86] for a discussion. Here, we follow the approch suggested by Eymard & Gallouët [88], who introduced a weakly converging gradient. The discrete expressions (27a) and (27b) are obtained along the following lines: We seek for a finite volume discretization of the term H = κ (jλ · ∇ψ) by integration over the K-th cell (cid:88) dV H = 1 2 ΩK L∈N(K) DK,L dV H ≈ 1 2 DK,L κK,L (jλ · ∇ψ)K,L, (cid:88) L∈N(K) where the integral was recast in an integral over the adjacent bi-hyperpyramids DK,L (see Fig. 3) with volumes DK,L = 1 d (cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107)∂ΩK ∩ ∂ΩL = (cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107)2 sK,L. 1 d (C.1) Here, d is the dimensionality of the computational domain and sK,L is the edge factor (26). Moreover, κK,L is a suitably chosen average of κ on the domain DK,L (see below). Following Eymard & Gallouët [88, Definition 2], we approximate ∇ψ by the weakly converging discrete gradient ∇ψK,L ≈ d ψL − ψK (C.2) where nK,L = (rL − rK) /(cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107) is the (outward-oriented) normal vector and d ∈ {1, 2, 3} is the dimensionality of the domain. The technique has been adopted for the discretization of Joule heating in similar models [86, 100, 101] and for the computation of contact currents [83]. Finally, we combine Eqs. (C.1), (C.2) and the normal projection of the current Jλ,K,L = (rL − rK) · jλ (see Eq. (25), where Jλ,K,L is given by a Scharfetter -- Gummel type discretization scheme) and obtain (cid:107)rL − rK(cid:107) nK,L (cid:88) L∈N(K) dV H ≈ 1 2 ΩK sK,L κK,L Jλ,K,L (ψL − ψK) , cf. Eqs. (27a) -- (27b). In order to ensure the non-negativity of the discrete Joule heating and dissipation rate (see Sec. 3.3.5), κK,L is taken as the logarithmic mean temperature (29) or the edge-averaged Seebeck coefficient (38), respectively. Appendix D. Power balance The balance equation for the total power is derived by integrating the heat transport Eq. (4) over the domain Ω: dV cV ∂tT − Ω Ω dV ∇ · κ∇T = (cid:17) (cid:17) (cid:16) dV H. Ω (cid:16) (cid:17) (ϕn + Πn) jn + ϕp + Πp jp + q (ϕn + Πn) ∂tn − q ϕp + Πp ∂t p. H = −∇ ·(cid:16) Using Eqs. (2) -- (3) and partial integration, the expression for the heat generation rate (21) is rearranged as The internal energy density of the system reads u (n, p, T) = f (n, p, T) + T s (n, p, T), where the free energy density is given in Eq. (13). Using the defining relations for the quasi-Fermi potentials and the entropy density (11) as well as the Kelvin formula (10), the differential internal energy per carrier is obtained as as + T ∂s ∂p = −q (ϕn + Πn) , = +q (ϕn + Πn) , ∂u ∂p ∂ f ∂n + T ∂s ∂n ∂ f ∂p ∂u ∂n = = where the Peltier coefficients Πn/p are defined via the Kelvin relation Πn/p = T Pn/p. Using the definition of the heat capacity cV = ∂T u, the (integrated) heat transport equation is rearranged as a balance equation for the internal energy: (cid:32) (cid:33) dV Ω ∂u ∂T ∂T ∂t + ∂u ∂n ∂n ∂t + ∂u ∂p ∂p ∂t = d dt dV u = − Ω ∂Ω 22 dA n ·(cid:16)−κ∇T + (ϕn + Πn) jn + (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:17) ϕp + Πp jp . (D.1) In the following, we will recast the surface integral on the right hand side into an expression for the injected electrical power and the dissipated heat. The local continuity equation for the internal energy (first law of thermodynamics, cf. Eq. (D.1)) reads ∂tu + ∇ · ju = 0, ju = −κ∇T + (ϕn + Πn) jn + ϕp + Πp jp, (D.2) (cid:17) where ju is the internal energy flux density. The corresponding continuity equation for the entropy density is obtained from Gibb's fundamental thermodynamic relation du = Tds + µcdn − µvdp. By substituting Eqs. (2) -- (3) and (D.2), one arrives at ∂ts = 1 T ∂tu − µc T ∂tn + µv T ∂t p = −∇ · js + stot, js = 1 T ju − ϕnjn − ϕpjp where js is the the entropy flux density. The entropy production rate reads (cf. Sec. 3.3.5) (cid:16) (cid:16) (cid:17) , (D.3) (D.4) κ T 2 (cid:107)∇T(cid:107)2 + 1 T HJ. We return to the power balance equation (D.1) and rewrite the surface integral on the right hand side as is the Joule heat term. The entropy flux density is closely connected jQ = Tjs = ju − ϕnjn − ϕpjp = −κ∇T + Πnjn + Πpjp. = ∂Ω dA n ·(cid:16) ∂Ω dA n · jQ + ϕnjn + ϕpjp (D.5) . (cid:17) The first term is the heat flux density leaving the device. The second term is evaluated for a device with mixed bound- i ΓD,i are the electrical contacts with (ideal) Ohmic boundary conditions ϕn = ϕp = ϕD,i = const. on ΓD,i (Dirichlet conditions). The remaining facets ΓN are semiconductor- insulator interfaces or artificial boundaries with "no-flux" boundary conditions n · jn/p = 0. One obtains 1 T (µc − µv) R + (cid:17) stot = with the heat flux density Here, HJ = jn·(∇ϕn + Pn∇T) +jp·(cid:16)∇ϕp + Pp∇T dA n ·(cid:16)−κ∇T + (ϕn + Πn) jn + (cid:16) (cid:17) ary conditions ∂Ω = ΓD∪ΓN, where the segments ΓD =(cid:83) (cid:88) ϕp + Πp ∂Ω jp (cid:17) (cid:17) ϕnjn + ϕpjp = ϕD,i dA n ·(cid:16) (cid:17) ∂Ω ´ dA n·(cid:16) dA n ·(cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:88) i jn + jp = ϕD,iIi, i ΓD,i where Ii = with total current I = I2 = −I1 (Kirchhoff's current law) and applied voltage U = ϕD,1 − ϕD,2, this is (cf. Ref. [12]) is the electrical current flux across the i-th electrical contact. For a two-terminal device ΓD,i jn + jp Thus, at stationary conditions, we finally obtain the power balance equation as of the heat flux density ∇ · jQ = H + ∇ ·(cid:16) In conclusion, the injected electrical power UI is equal to the heat flux density leaving the device. With the divergence (D.6a) dA n ·(cid:16) ∂Ω (cid:17) ϕnjn + ϕpjp = I1ϕD,1 + I2ϕD,2 = −UI. UI = dA n · jQ. ∂Ω (cid:17) , this can also be written as dA n ·(cid:16) (cid:17) Πnjn + Πpjp UI = dVH + Ω ΓD Πnjn + Πpjp , (D.6b) where the first term is the total heat generated on the full domain and the second term describes the "Peltier power", that can be either positive or negative, depending on the direction of the current flow. In the case of optoelectronic devices (with open optical cavities), the power balance must be supplemented by additional terms describing the emitted radiation power [29]. The power balance equation (D.6) is consistent with the results previously reported in the literature, i.e., the result persists when assuming the Kelvin formula for the Seebeck coefficient. 23 References [1] J. Lutz, H. Schlangenotto, U. Scheuermann, R. D. Donker, Semiconductor Power Devices -- Physics, Characteristics, Reliability, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2011. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-11125-9. [2] H.-J. Schulze, F.-J. Niedernostheide, F. Pfirsch, R. Baburske, Limiting factors of the safe operating area for power devices, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 60 (2012) 551 -- 562. doi:10.1109/ted.2012.2225148. [3] A. Fischer, T. Koprucki, K. Gärtner, M. L. Tietze, J. Brückner, B. Lüssem, K. Leo, A. Glitzky, R. Scholz, Feel the heat: Nonlinear electrothermal feedback in organic LEDs, Adv. Funct. Mater. 24 (2014) 3367 -- 3374. doi:10.1002/adfm.201303066. [4] A. Fischer, M. Pfalz, K. Vandewal, S. Lenk, M. Liero, A. Glitzky, S. Reineke, Full electrothermal OLED model including nonlinear self-heating effects, Phys. Rev. Appl 10 (2018) 014023. doi:10.1103/physrevapplied.10.014023. [5] M. Osi´nski, W. Nakwaski, Thermal effects in vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers, Int. J. High Speed Electron. Syst. 5 (1994) 667 -- 730. doi:10.1142/s0129156494000267. [6] J. Piprek, J. K. White, A. J. SpringThorpe, What limits the maximum output power of long-wavelength AlGaInAs/InP laser diodes?, IEEE J. Quantum Elect. 38 (2002) 1253 -- 1259. doi:10.1109/jqe.2002.802441. [7] M. Streiff, W. Fichtner, A. Witzig, Vertical-Cavity Surface-Emitting Lasers: Single-Mode Control and Self-Heating Effects, Springer, New York, 2005, pp. 217 -- 247. doi:10.1007/0-387-27256-9_8. [8] H. Wenzel, P. Crump, A. Pietrzak, X. Wang, G. Erbert, G. Tränkle, Theoretical and experimental investigations of the limits to the maximum output power of laser diodes, New J. Phys. 12 (2010) 085007. doi:10.1088/1367-2630/12/8/085007. [9] G. K. Wachutka, Rigorous thermodynamic treatment of heat generation and conduction in semiconductor device modeling, IEEE Trans. Comput.-Aided Design Integr. Circuits Syst. 9 (1990) 1141 -- 1149. doi:10.1109/43.62751. [10] U. Lindefelt, Heat generation in semiconductor devices, J. Appl. Phys. 75 (1994) 942 -- 957. doi:10.1063/1.356450. [11] H. Brand, S. Selberherr, Two-dimensional simulation of thermal runaway in a nonplanar GTO-thyristor, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 42 [12] J. E. Parrott, Thermodynamic theory of transport processes in semiconductors, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 43 (1996) 809 -- 826. doi:10. [13] G. Albinus, H. Gajewski, R. Hünlich, Thermodynamic design of energy models of semiconductor devices, Nonlinearity 15 (2002) 367 -- 383. (1995) 2137 -- 2146. doi:10.1109/16.477772. 1109/16.491259. doi:10.1088/0951-7715/15/2/307. doi:10.1007/0-387-27256-9_3. [14] U. Bandelow, H. Gajewski, R. Hünlich, Fabry -- Perot lasers: Thermodynamics-based modeling, Springer, New York, 2005, pp. 63 -- 85. [15] S. Selberherr, Analysis and Simulation of Semiconductor Devices, Springer, Vienna, 1984. doi:10.1007/978-3-7091-8752-4. [16] P. A. Markowich, The stationary Semiconductor device equations, Springer, Vienna, 1986. doi:10.1007/978-3-7091-3678-2. [17] H. J. Goldsmid, Introduction to Thermoelectricity, volume 121 of Springer Series in Materials Science, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2010. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-00716-3. 1 -- 73. doi:10.1002/9783527338405.ch1. [18] C. Goupil, Ouerdane, K. Zabrocki, W. Seifert, N. Hinsche, E. Müller, Thermodynamics and Thermoelectricity, Wiley, Weinheim, 2011, pp. [19] L. Onsager, Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. I., Phys. Rev. 37 (1931) 405. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.37.405. [20] R. Kubo, M. Yokota, S. Nakajima, Statistical-mechanical theory of irreversible processes. II. Response to thermal disturbance, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 12 (1957) 1203 -- 1211. doi:10.1143/jpsj.12.1203. [21] M. Cutler, N. F. Mott, Observation of Anderson localization in an electron gas, Phys. Rev. 181 (1969) 1336 -- 1340. doi:10.1103/physrev. [22] H. Fritzsche, A general expression for the thermoelectric power, Solid State Commun. 9 (1971) 1813 -- 1815. doi:10.1016/0038-1098(71) [23] P. M. Chaikin, G. Beni, Thermopower in the correlated hopping regime, Phys. Rev. B 13 (1976) 647 -- 651. doi:10.1103/physrevb.13.647. [24] B. S. Shastry, Thermopower in correlated systems, in: V. Zlatc, A. Hewson (Eds.), New Materials for Thermoelectric Applications: Theory and Experiment, NATO Science for Peace and Security Series B: Physics and Biophysics, Springer, Dordrecht, 2013, pp. 25 -- 29. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-4984-9_2. [25] J. C. Freeman, Self-heating in semiconductors: A comparative study, Solid State Electron. 95 (2014) 8 -- 14. doi:10.1016/j.sse.2014. 181.1336. 90096-2. 02.005. [26] K. M. Van Vliet, A. H. Marshak, Conduction current and generalized Einstein relations for degenerate semiconductors and metals, Phys. Status Solidi B 78 (1976) 501 -- 517. doi:10.1002/pssb.2220780209. [27] A. H. Marshak, C. Van Vliet, Electrical current and carrier density in degenerate materials with nonuniform band structure, Proc. IEEE 72 (1984) 148 -- 164. doi:10.1109/proc.1984.12836. [28] M. Lundstrom, Fundamentals of carrier transport, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000. doi:10.1017/CBO9780511618611. [29] H. Wenzel, A. Zeghuzi, High-power lasers, in: J. Piprek (Ed.), Handbook of Optoelectronic Device Modeling and Simulation: Lasers, Modulators, Photodetectors, Solar Cells, and Numerical Methods, volume 2, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Raton, 2017, pp. 733 -- 771. doi:10.4324/9781315152318-2. [30] G. J. Snyder, E. S. Toberer, Complex thermoelectric materials, Nat. Mater. 7 (2008) 105 -- 114. doi:10.1142/9789814287005_0006. [31] N. S. Bennett, Thermoelectric performance in n-type bulk silicon: The influence of dopant concentration and dopant species, Phys. Status Solidi A 214 (2017) 1700307. doi:10.1002/pssa.201700307. [32] M. R. Peterson, B. S. Shastry, Kelvin formula for thermopower, Phys. Rev. B 82 (2010) 195105. doi:10.1103/physrevb.82.195105. [33] B. S. Shastry, Electrothermal transport coefficients at finite frequencies, Rep. Prog. Phys. 72 (2008) 016501. doi:10.1088/0034-4885/ 72/1/016501. [34] T. Silk, I. Terasaki, T. Fujii, A. Schofield, Out-of-plane thermopower of strongly correlated layered systems: An application to Bi2(Sr, La)2CaCu2O8+δ, Phys. Rev. B 79 (2009) 134527. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.79.134527. 24 [35] A. Garg, B. S. Shastry, K. B. Dave, P. Phillips, Thermopower and quantum criticality in a strongly interacting system: Parallels with the cuprates, New J. Phys. 13 (2011) 083032. doi:10.1088/1367-2630/13/8/083032. [36] L.-F. Arsenault, B. S. Shastry, P. Sémon, A.-M. Tremblay, Entropy, frustration, and large thermopower of doped Mott insulators on the fcc lattice, Phys. Rev. B 87 (2013) 035126. doi:10.1103/physrevb.87.035126. [37] X. Deng, J. Mravlje, R. Žitko, M. Ferrero, G. Kotliar, A. Georges, How bad metals turn good: Spectroscopic signatures of resilient quasiparticles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 086401. doi:10.1103/physrevlett.110.086401. [38] V. Zlati´c, G. R. Boyd, J. K. Freericks, Universal thermopower of bad metals, Phys. Rev. B 89 (2014) 155101. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB. 89.155101. [39] J. Kokalj, R. H. McKenzie, Enhancement of the thermoelectric power by electronic correlations in bad metals: A study of the Kelvin formula, Phys. Rev. B 91 (2015) 125143. doi:10.1103/physrevb.91.125143. [40] J. Hejtmánek, Z. Jirák, J. Šebek, Spin-entropy contribution to thermopower in the [Ca2CoO3−t]0.62(CoO2) misfits, Phys. Rev. B 92 (2015) 125106. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.92.125106. [41] I. Terasaki, Research update: Oxide thermoelectrics: Beyond the conventional design rules, APL Mater. 4 (2016) 104501. doi:10.1063/ [42] J. Mravlje, A. Georges, Thermopower and entropy: Lessons from Sr2RuO4, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117 (2016) 036401. doi:10.1103/ [43] D. L. Scharfetter, H. K. Gummel, Large-signal analysis of a silicon Read diode oscillator, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 16 (1969) 64 -- 77. 1.4954227. physrevlett.117.036401. doi:10.1109/t-ed.1969.16566. [44] T.-W. Tang, Extension of the Scharfetter -- Gummel algorithm to the energy balance equation, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 31 (1984) 1912 -- 1914. doi:10.1109/t-ed.1984.21813. [45] C. C. McAndrew, K. Singhal, E. L. Heasell, A consistent nonisothermal extension of the Scharfetter -- Gummel stable difference approxima- tion, IEEE Electr. Device L. 6 (1985) 446 -- 447. doi:10.1109/edl.1985.26187. [46] M. Rudan, F. Odeh, Multi-dimensional discretization scheme for the hydrodynamic model of semiconductor devices, Compel. 5 (1986) 149 -- 183. doi:10.1108/eb010024. [47] A. Forghieri, R. Guerrieri, P. Ciampolini, A. Gnudi, M. Rudan, G. Baccarani, A new discretization strategy of the semiconductor equations comprising momentum and energy balance, IEEE T. Comput. Aid. D. 7 (1988) 231 -- 242. doi:10.1109/43.3153. [48] D. Chen, E. C. Kan, U. Ravaioli, Z. Yu, R. W. Dutton, A self-consistent discretization scheme for current and energy transport equations, in: IV Int. Conf. on Simulation of Semiconductor Devices and Processes (SISDEP), Zurich, 1991, pp. 235 -- 240. [49] K. Souissi, F. Odeh, A. Gnudi, A note on current discretization in the hydromodel, Compel. 10 (1991) 475 -- 485. doi:10.1108/eb051722. [50] J. H. M. Ten Thije Boonkkamp, W. H. A. Schilders, An exponential fitting scheme for the electrothermal device equations specifically for the simulation of avalanche generation, Compel. 12 (1993) 95 -- 111. doi:10.1108/eb010116. [51] A. W. Smith, A. Rohatgi, Non-isothermal extension of the Scharfetter -- Gummel technique for hot carrier transport in heterostructure simulations, IEEE T. Comput. Aid. D. 12 (1993) 1515 -- 1523. doi:10.1109/43.256926. [52] Z. Yu, R. W. Dutton, SEDAN-III -- A generalized electronic material device analysis program, Technical Report, Stanford Univ., 1985. [53] H. Gajewski, Analysis und Numerik von Ladungstransport in Halbleitern, Mitt. Ges. Angew. Math. Mech. 16 (1993) 35 -- 57. [54] M. Bessemoulin-Chatard, A finite volume scheme for convection-diffusion equations with nonlinear diffusion derived from the Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme, Numer. Math. 121 (2012) 637 -- 670. doi:10.1007/s00211-012-0448-x. [55] T. Koprucki, K. Gärtner, Discretization scheme for drift-diffusion equations with strong diffusion enhancement, Opt. Quantum. Electron. 45 (2013) 791 -- 796. doi:10.1007/s11082-013-9673-5. [56] T. Koprucki, N. Rotundo, P. Farrell, D. H. Doan, J. Fuhrmann, On thermodynamic consistency of a Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme based on a modified thermal voltage for drift-diffusion equations with diffusion enhancement, Opt. Quantum. Electron. 47 (2015) 1327 -- 1332. doi:10.1007/s11082-014-0050-9. [57] J. Fuhrmann, Comparison and numerical treatment of generalised Nernst -- Planck models, Comput. Phys. Commun. 196 (2015) 166 -- 178. doi:10.1016/j.cpc.2015.06.004. [58] S. L. M. van Mensfoort, R. Coehoorn, Effect of Gaussian disorder on the voltage dependence of the current density in sandwich-type devices based on organic semiconductors, Phys. Rev. B 78 (2008) 085207. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.78.085207. [59] G. Paasch, S. Scheinert, Charge carrier density of organics with Gaussian density of states: Analytical approximation for the Gauss -- Fermi integral, J. Appl. Phys. 107 (2010) 104501. doi:10.1063/1.3374475. [60] M. C. J. M. Vissenberg, M. Matters, Theory of the field-effect mobility in amorphous organic transistors, Phys. Rev. B 57 (1998) 12964 -- 12967. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.57.12964. [61] K. Seki, K. Marumoto, M. Tachiya, Bulk recombination in organic bulk heterojunction solar cells under continuous and pulsed light irradiation, Appl. Phys. Express 6 (2013) 051603. doi:10.7567/APEX.6.051603. [62] V. Palankovski, R. Quay, Analysis and Simulation of Heterostructure Devices, Springer, Vienna, 2004. doi:10.1007/ 978-3-7091-0560-3. [63] M. Kantner, Modeling and simulation of electrically driven quantum dot based single-photon sources: From classical device physics to open quantum systems, PhD thesis, Technical University Berlin, Berlin, 2018. doi:10.14279/depositonce-7516. [64] G. Czycholl, Theoretical solid-state physics., Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2008. doi:10.1007/978-3-540-74790-1. [65] R. Carlson, S. J. Silverman, H. Ehrenreich, Nernst effect in n-type GaAs, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 23 (1962) 422 -- 424. doi:10.1016/ [66] A. Amith, I. Kudman, E. F. Steigmeier, Electron and phonon scattering in GaAs at high temperatures, Phys. Rev. 138 (1965) 1270 -- 1276. 0022-3697(62)90112-9. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.138.A1270. 0022-3719/12/9/011. [67] J. T. Edmond, R. F. Broom, F. A. Cunnel, Report on meeting on semiconductors at Rugby, Physical Society, London, 1956, p. 109. [68] S. K. Sutadhar, D. Chattopadhyay, Thermoelectric power of n-GaAs, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 12 (1979) 1693 -- 1697. doi:10.1088/ [69] G. Homm, P. J. Klar, J. Teubert, W. Heimbrodt, Seebeck coefficients of n-type (Ga, In)(N, As),(B, Ga, In) As, and GaAs, Appl. Phys. Lett. 25 93 (2008) 042107. doi:10.1063/1.2959079. Semicond. 7 (1973) 667 -- 674. [70] O. V. Emel'yanenko, V. A. Skripkin, U. A. Popova, Thermoelectric power and phonon drag in heavily doped III -- V crystals, Sov. Phys.- [71] A. T. Ramu, L. E. Cassels, N. H. Hackman, H. Lu, J. M. O. Zide, J. E. Bowers, Rigorous calculation of the Seebeck coefficient and mobility of thermoelectric materials, J. Appl. Phys. 107 (2010) 083707. doi:10.1063/1.3366712. [72] G. Mascali, V. Romano, Exploitation of the maximum entropy principle in mathematical modeling of charge transport in semiconductors, [73] K. P. O'Donnell, X. Chen, Temperature dependence of semiconductor band gaps, Appl. Phys. Lett. 58 (1991) 2924 -- 2926. doi:10.1063/ [74] I. Vurgaftman, J. R. Meyer, L. R. Ram-Mohan, Band parameters for III -- V compound semiconductors and their alloys, J. Appl. Phys. 89 Entropy 19 (2017) 36. doi:10.3390/e19010036. 1.104723. (2001) 5815 -- 5875. doi:10.1063/1.1368156. [75] K. Kells, S. Müller, G. Wachutka, W. Fichtner, Simulation of self-heating effects in a power pin diode, in: S. Selberherr, H. Stippel, E. Strasser (Eds.), Simulation of Semiconductor Devices and Processes, volume 5, Springer, Vienna, 1993, pp. 41 -- 44. doi:10.1007/ 978-3-7091-6657-4_9. [76] P. B. M. Wolbert, G. K. M. Wachutka, B. H. Krabbenborg, T. J. Mouthaan, Nonisothermal device simulation using the 2D numerical IEEE T. Comput. Aid. D. 13 (1994) 293 -- 302. doi:10.1109/43. process/device simulator TRENDY and application to SOI-devices, 265671. [77] P. T. Landsberg, On the diffusion theory of rectification, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 213 (1952) 226 -- 237. doi:10.1098/rspa.1952.0122. [78] K. Shore, M. Adams, The effects of carrier degeneracy on transport properties of the double heterostructure injection laser, Appl. Phys. 9 (1976) 161 -- 164. doi:10.1007/bf00903953. [79] M. Kantner, U. Bandelow, T. Koprucki, J.-H. Schulze, A. Strittmatter, H.-J. Wünsche, Efficient current injection into single quantum dots through oxide-confined p-n-diodes, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 63 (2016) 2036 -- 2042. doi:10.1109/ted.2016.2538561. [80] M. Kantner, T. Koprucki, Numerical simulation of carrier transport in semiconductor devices at cryogenic temperatures, Opt. Quantum. Electron. 48 (2016) 543. doi:10.1007/s11082-016-0817-2. [81] Y. Roichman, N. Tessler, Generalized Einstein relation for disordered semiconductors -- Implications for device performance, Appl. Phys. [82] F. Brezzi, L. D. Marini, P. Pietra, Numerical simulation of semiconductor devices, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 75 (1989) 493 -- 514. Lett. 80 (2002) 1948 -- 1950. doi:10.1063/1.1461419. doi:10.1016/0045-7825(89)90044-3. [83] P. Farrell, N. Rotundo, D. H. Doan, M. Kantner, J. Fuhrmann, T. Koprucki, Drift-diffusion models, in: J. Piprek (Ed.), Handbook of Optoelectronic Device Modeling and Simulation: Lasers, Modulators, Photodetectors, Solar Cells, and Numerical Methods, volume 2, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Raton, 2017, pp. 15 -- 58. doi:10.4324/9781315152318-25. [84] H. Si, K. Gärtner, J. Fuhrmann, Boundary conforming Delaunay mesh generation, Comput. Math. Math. Phys. 50 (2010) 38 -- 53. doi:10. 1134/S0965542510010069. [85] R. Eymard, T. Gallouët, R. Herbin, Finite volume methods, in: P. Ciarlet, J. Lions (Eds.), Handbook of Numerical Analysis, volume 7 of Handbook of Numerical Analysis, Elsevier, 2000, pp. 713 -- 1018. doi:10.1016/S1570-8659(00)07005-8. [86] A. Bradji, R. Herbin, Discretization of coupled heat and electrical diffusion problems by finite-element and finite-volume methods, IMA J. [87] C. Chainais-Hillairet, Discrete duality finite volume schemes for two-dimensional drift-diffusion and energy-transport models, Int. J. Numer. Numer. Anal. 28 (2008) 469 -- 495. doi:10.1093/imanum/drm030. Meth. Fl. 59 (2009) 239 -- 257. doi:10.1002/fld.1393. [88] R. Eymard, T. Gallouët, H-convergence and numerical schemes for elliptic problems, SIAM J. Numer. Anal. 41 (2003) 539 -- 562. doi:10. 1137/s0036142901397083. [89] M. Kantner, A generalized Scharfetter -- Gummel scheme for degenerate and non-isothermal semiconductors, in: J. Piprek, K. Hinzer (Eds.), Proc. Int. Conf. Numerical Simulation of Optoelectronic Devices (NUSOD), Ottawa, 2019, pp. 7 -- 8. doi:10.1109/nusod.2019.8806839. [90] Synopsys, Inc., Sentaurus Device UserGuide, Mountain View, CA, 2010. [91] Silvaco International, Atlas User's Manual, Santa Clara, CA, 2016. [92] H. K. Versteeg, W. Malalasekera, An Introduction to Computational Fluid Dynamics: The Finite Volume Method, Prentice Hall, Harlow, 2007. [93] M. Bessemoulin-Chatard, C. Chainais-Hillairet, Exponential decay of a finite volume scheme to the thermal equilibrium for drift -- diffusion systems, J. Numer. Math. 25 (2017) 147 -- 168. doi:10.1515/jnma-2016-0007. [94] A. Kato, M. Katada, T. Kamiya, T. Ito, T. Hattori, A rapid, stable decoupled algorithm for solving semiconductor hydrodynamic equations, IEEE T. Comput. Aid. D. 13 (1994) 1425 -- 1428. doi:10.1109/43.329272. [95] P. Farrell, T. Koprucki, J. Fuhrmann, Computational and analytical comparison of flux discretizations for the semiconductor device equations beyond Boltzmann statistics, J. Comput. Phys. 346 (2017) 497 -- 513. doi:10.1016/j.jcp.2017.06.023. [96] M. Patriarca, P. Farrell, J. Fuhrmann, T. Koprucki, Highly accurate quadrature-based Scharfetter -- Gummel schemes for charge transport in degenerate semiconductors, Comput. Phys. Commun. 235 (2019) 40 -- 49. doi:10.1016/j.cpc.2018.10.004. [97] H. B. Keller, Numerical Solution of Two Point Boundary Value Problems, SIAM, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 1976. [98] R. P. Brent, An algorithm with guaranteed convergence for finding a zero of a function, Comput. J. 14 (1971) 422 -- 425. doi:10.1093/ [99] A. J. MacLeod, Algorithm 779: Fermi -- Dirac functions of order -1/2, 1/2, 3/2, 5/2, ACM T. Math. Software 24 (1998) 1 -- 12. doi:10.1145/ comjnl/14.4.422. 285861.285862. [100] M. Liero, T. Koprucki, A. Fischer, R. Scholz, A. Glitzky, p-Laplace thermistor modeling of electrothermal feedback in organic semicon- ductor devices, Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 66 (2015) 2957 -- 2977. doi:10.1007/s00033-015-0560-8. [101] J. Fuhrmann, A. Glitzky, M. Liero, Hybrid finite-volume/finite-element schemes for p(x)-Laplace thermistor models, in: C. Cancès, P. Omnes (Eds.), Finite Volumes for Complex Applications VIII -- Hyperbolic, Elliptic and Parabolic Problems, Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2017, pp. 397 -- 405. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-57394-6_42. 26
1803.04468	1	1803	2018-03-12T19:14:11	Independent indistinguishable quantum light sources on a reconfigurable photonic integrated circuit	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics", "quant-ph" ]	We report a compact, scalable, quantum photonic integrated circuit realised by combining multiple, independent InGaAs/GaAs quantum-light-emitting-diodes (QLEDs) with a silicon oxynitride waveguide circuit. Each waveguide joining the circuit can then be excited by a separate, independently electrically contacted QLED. We show that the emission from neighbouring QLEDs can be independently tuned to degeneracy using the Stark Effect and that the resulting photon streams are indistinguishable. This enables on-chip Hong-Ou-Mandel-type interference, as required for many photonic quantum information processing schemes.	physics.app-ph	physics	Independent indistinguishable quantum light sources on a reconfigurable photonic integrated circuit D.J.P. Ellis1*, A.J. Bennett1a, C. Dangel1,b, J.P. Lee1,c, J.P. Griffiths1, T.A. Mitchell2, T.-K. Paraiso1, P. Spencer2, D.A. Ritchie2 and A.J. Shields1. 1 Toshiba Research Europe Limited, 208 Science Park, Milton Road, Cambridge, CB40GZ, UK. 2 Cavendish Laboratory, Cambridge University, J. J. Thomson Avenue, Cambridge, CB3 0HE, UK a now at School of Engineering, Cardiff University, Queen's Buildings, 14-17 The Parade, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK. b also at Physik Department, Technische Universitat Munchen, 85748 Garching, Germany. c also at Department of Engineering, Cambridge University, 9 J.J. Thomson Avenue, Cambridge, CB3 0FA, UK. Abstract We report a compact, scalable, quantum photonic integrated circuit realised by combining multiple, independent InGaAs/GaAs quantum-light-emitting-diodes (QLEDs) with a silicon oxynitride waveguide circuit. Each waveguide joining the circuit can then be excited by a separate, independently electrically contacted QLED. We show that the emission from neighbouring QLEDs can be independently tuned to degeneracy using the Stark Effect and that the resulting photon streams are indistinguishable. This enables on-chip Hong-Ou- Mandel-type interference, as required for many photonic quantum information processing schemes. 1 Photonic Integrated Circuits (PICs) are rapidly becoming the default platform for photonic quantum applications due to their robustness, interferometric stability, reconfigurability and scalability1,2,3, Furthermore, they allow complex optical systems, which until recently would occupy a whole laboratory to be reduced to the size of a single chip. PICs have been employed in many quantum applications including logic gates2,4, higher order path entanglement5, quantum walks6,7, tests of Boson Sampling8,9,10,11 on-chip quantum teleportation12. These PICs can support optical qubits encoded in path, time bin, polarisation or mode and can be interconverted13,14. All of these experiments have relied upon photons generated externally and delivered to the PICs through fibre. One route to achieve on-chip photon generation is to use silicon waveguides to directly produce photons15,16, but the Poissonian statistics of pair generation makes this inherently unscalable. An alternative scheme is to use quantum emitters with naturally sub- Poissonian photon statistics within a waveguide circuit made of the emitter's host material17,18,19,20. It is also possible to evanescently couple the emitter to a low-loss PIC21,22,23 and these schemes have verified the emission of single photons. However, for realising large scale and compact circuits it will be necessary to integrate multiple sources of indistinguishable photons on the chip, as we demonstrate here. The device we report utilises a "plug, bond and play" hybrid integration approach to passively align and join multiple, independent quantum light sources to a multi-channel PIC in an inherently scalable fashion. The Quantum Photonic Integrated Circuit, or QPIC, consists of three parts: (1) the array of Quantum Dot-containing light emitting diodes (QD LEDs), which are butt coupled to (2) a reconfigurable silicon oxynitride (SiOxNy) PIC on a silicon substrate and (3) an array of optical fibres for optical access to the device (see Figure 1). We show the 2 essential elements of a quantum-PIC including the generation of coherent, indistinguishable quantum light on-chip; the reconfigurability of the PIC; and the inclusion of an integrated excitation source. The linear array of independently controllable QD LEDs can naturally emit single photons, photon pairs24,25 and using electric field tuning, transitions in separate emitters can be made degenerate. The LEDs are designed to emit photons along the growth direction of the crystal and hence must be rotated through 90 degrees in order to butt-couple to the PIC. The challenge is then to obtain electrical contact from the LED array, as conventional bonding systems (such as wire bonders) are not designed to access out-of-plane contact pads. We achieve electrical connection using gold tracks on the surface, and a series of etched recesses at the left-hand end of the PIC. Raised metal contacts on the LEDs mate with these etched recesses to form a "plug and socket" arrangement, simultaneously aligning the LEDs and waveguides. The whole device can then then be mounted on a simple "dip stick" and lowered directly into helium vapour, cooling the device to 8k. Under these conditions all of the LEDs and phase modulators can be operated simultaneously with minimal consumption of Helium. The LED heterostructure was grown by molecular beam epitaxy and comprises a weak planar cavity with 4 (10) pairs of GaAs/AlGaAs distributed Bragg reflectors above (below) a λ- cavity spacer. Self-assembled InAs quantum dots are placed at the centre of the cavity with an AlGaAs tunnel barrier on both sides to increase the range over which the quantum dot emission can be tuned. Mesas were wet etched and ohmic contacts produced by thermal evaporation and subsequent lift-off. The upper surface of the LED (p-doped) is partially covered with a gold contact, upon which a gold ball bump is placed. This bump forms the male part of the "plug and socket" assembly scheme. To enable electrical contact to be made 3 to the lower (n-doped) contact region, additional dummy mesas were added to the LED array and metal tracks defined running from the top of the dummy mesa down to the lower ohmic contact. The photonic integrated circuit comprises a 1.6 µm thick core layer of n=1.55 SiOxNy, surrounded by n=1.51 SiOxNy cladding layers such that the waveguide supports a single mode at our operation wavelength of around 900 nm. All of the SiOxNy layers are deposited by Plasma Enhanced Chemical Vapour Deposition (PECVD) onto a silicon substrate. Waveguides are defined lithographically and dry etched prior to the deposition of the overcladding layer. Further etching of the SiOxNy and underlying silicon is then used to form thermal isolation trenches for the phase modulators and the "sockets" for the interconnection of the LEDs. Finally metal layers are deposited and patterned by lift-off to form the resistive heaters for the MZIs and the various contact tracks. The fibre array is a commercially available component comprising an array of polarisation- maintaining (PM) optical fibres mounted in a v-groove array. The fibres are used both to route in laser light (when off-chip excitation is employed) and to send quantum dot emission to detectors. The fibre array and LED devices are bonded to the PIC using an index-matched UV- curable adhesive applied directly to the PIC's end facets. The LED array is aligned with the PIC by ensuring each gold ball bump is mated with the corresponding etched socket (as shown in Figure 1b). This simultaneously aligns the electrical contacts and optical elements for each channel. No active alignment is necessary. The presence of the plug and socket also prevents the bonding adhesive from electrically insulating the LED and PIC chips as any excess adhesive will fill from the bottom of the trench rather than flow over the raised contacts. Finally, the 4 remaining void between the gold bump and the etched trench is infilled with a silver-doped conductive epoxy allowing electrical contact from the surface of the PIC chip to the LEDs. The waveguides, LEDs and fibres are all arranged on a 250 µm pitch. One section of the QPIC is as shown in Figure 2a, with two LEDs addressing a directional coupler. Figure 2b shows a typical IV curve. Photo-luminescence from each LED in the pair can be separately measured by biasing the unwanted LED at -5V to quench its emission (Figure 2c and d). Here the external 850 nm excitation laser is routed in through the waveguide circuit and pumps both LEDs simultaneously. Figure 2e shows a FEM calculation of the emitted field from an on-axis QD being guided into the waveguide. Only QDs aligned with the waveguide mode can contribute to the spectra. Also, the efficiency of light collection from the device is determined by the numerical aperture of the waveguide, giving a similar efficiency to what would be expected from a free-space lens of similar numerical aperture26. In the case shown in Figure 2e, we calculate a collection efficiency of 18%. The second active element on the chip is the reconfigurable Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI), which contains a lithographically defined resistive heater (Figure 2f). Networks of phase shifters and MZIs can be used to realise any arbitrary circuit3 and are used to prepare arbitrary qubit superposition states in rail-encoded QPIC schemes. In Figure 2g,h we drive one LED to emit electroluminescence into the MZI and use this to calibrate the device. Scanning the power applied to the phase shifter produces a clear switching between the output ports. At a wavelength of 890nm the couplers are closest to being balanced and we observe ideal switching operation (Figure 2i) with a visibility greater than 98% and a 2 phase shift requiring 520mW. Such high fidelity single qubit manipulation is an essential element of any versatile and reconfigurable QPIC. 5 The LEDs used here are designed to allow a giant Stark shift of >20nm24 in reverse bias. In this regime no current flows, no electroluminescence is observed and optical excitation is required. All LEDs on the QPIC exhibit similar behaviour, as shown in the group of ten tuning spectra (Figure 3a). We select two adjacent LEDs, 5 and 6, to demonstrate that photons from separated QDs can be rendered indistinguishable. Both devices were simultaneously optically excited through the waveguide circuit, and the QD photons collected through a single channel, as shown in Figure 3b. Figure 3c shows tuning of LED6 as the bias on LED5 is held constant at 0.92V and in Figure 3d the bias on LED5 is varied whilst LED6 is fixed at 0.89V. In both cases we are able to tune negatively charged transitions to degeneracy at 936.1nm when VLED5 = 0.92 V and VLED6 = 0.89 V. We then separately characterise the transitions, suppressing emission from the other LED by applying -5V. The transitions display a slightly different power dependence, so can be made to have the same intensity on the output channel when exciting with 126W. At this point the linewidths of the transitions were measured and coherence times were determined to be 220 ps and 100 ps respectively (Figure 3f). Using a Hanbury Brown and Twiss setup and a pair of superconducting single photon detectors, the measured anti-bunching times of the two transitions in LED5 (LED6) were 913ps (927ps) and g(2)(0) was 0.230 (0.269) (Figure 3g,h). The measured non-zero g(2)(0) may be attributed to background emission in the LED arising from other QDs in the device. We then perform a Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment to study on-chip two photon interference. With both devices tuned to degeneracy, if indistinguishable, the photons from the two QDs will undergo two-photon interference at the directional coupler and both leave from the same output port. Therefore, measuring coincidences between the two detectors in 6 Figure 4a shows a "peak" in the autocorrelation function. This is precisely what we measure (Figure 4b). Using the independently measured characteristics for the two LEDs we calculate the expected autocorrelation function, shown as red lines in Figure 4. The model agrees well with the experimental data. For comparison, the blue curve shows the results of a similar calculation in which no interference takes place. When we introduced a small energy difference between the transitions, the visibility of interference falls sharply as predicted (green curve in Figure 4c,d). At zero detuning, and with infinitely fast detectors, we predict a maximum two photon interference visibility of 80% limited by the non-zero g(2)(0) of the sources. Taking into account the measured detector response, we predict a reduced visibility of 54%. Finally, we demonstrate a route to make our QPIC's source completely self-contained and scalable. In Figure 5 we show how the LED array itself can also be used to simultaneously excite and tune the energy of dots, without an external laser27. The lower (Master, M) LED in Figure 5a is driven at 10mA generating ~880nm wetting layer emission that was guided laterally by the cavity spacer. This excited QDs in the adjacent devices (Slave LEDs S1, S2), which can be tuned. Figure 5b shows experimental data recorded with this on-chip pumping scheme. Light collected from the upper LED (S2, held at fixed bias) occurs at constant wavelength, but light from the lower LED (S1, biased with VDC) displays the giant stark shift. With the current LED array design, some of the light from the pump LED is also collected by the waveguide. The resulting background can be eliminated through future modifications to the device design. This all electrical, tunable excitation scheme therefore offers a route to a truly independent and scalable all electrical QPIC. 7 The integration of a tuneable single photon LED array with a reconfigurable photonic integrated circuit is a step forward in the direction of chip-scale quantum information processing with on-demand, high fidelity quantum sources. Future implementations of the current prototypes on low QD density wafers will eliminate the finite background in g(2)(τ) measurements. We evaluate that a 10dB reduction of the background would lead to a 2- photon interference visibility of 98%, sufficient to allow high fidelity on-chip quantum logic gates such as the C-NOT gate to be realised. Further optimisation of the waveguide profile at the LED/PIC interface, and in the longer term, deterministic QD positioning28 will provide additional filtering, reducing the contribution of off-axis QDs and improve the collection efficiency. We also expect greater indistinguishability from resonance fluorescence with the exciting light guided through the LED cavity29. Together, these improvements will allow this scalable platform to be deployed in a wide range of new applications. In conclusion, we have demonstrated a compact, packaged device that integrates a reconfigurable loss-loss photonic circuit with an array of independently controlled single quantum dot light sources. Choosing a QLED design that allows substantial changes to the energy of transitions in the single quantum dots, we are able to show that photons from separate quantum dots can be made indistinguishable. This is a key requirement of linear optical quantum computing schemes. 8 Figure 1. Assembly of the Quantum Photonic Integrated Circuit. The main figure shows an exploded diagram of the LED array, SiOxNy waveguide circuit and PM fibre array. a. Optical photograph of the LED array (scale bar is 2mm). b. Schematic of the bonding interface between the LED array and waveguide circuit. c. Optical photograph of the assembled device (scale bar is 5mm). 9 Figure 2. Activating and redirecting light on the Quantum Photonic Integrated Circuit. a. Schematic of the operation of the device under external optical excitation. b. Typical IV curve. c. Photoluminescence spectra recorded from two LEDs at 1.0V. c,d. Schematic showing operation of the on-chip phase shifters. e. FEM simulation showing coupling between an on-axis quantum dot in a low-quality planar cavity and a butt-coupled straight waveguide. f. Electroluminescence from one LED measured through channels 1 and 2 respectively as the power applied to the phase shifter is varied. A clear switching behaviour is observed. g. Single wavelength (890nm) data from e. replotted in more detail. We observe ~ideal MZI behaviour. 10 Figure 3. Making the transitions in separated emitters degenerate. a. Photoluminescence vs bias scans of all 10 LEDs on the device. Also show similar tuning behaviour. b. Schematic of the device with LEDs 5 and 6 studied in more detail. c. PL tuning curve. LED 5 held at 0.92 V. Bias applied to LED 6 scanned. d. PL tuning curve. As for c. except LED 5 is now scanned and LED 6 is held constant. e. Photoluminescence power dependence data for the transitions at degeneracy. f. Etalon linewidth measurements at degeneracy. g, h. Autocorrelation histograms for LEDs 5, 6 respectively. 11 Figure 4. On-chip two photon interference of light from separate LEDs. a. The experimental setup for testing the indistinguishability of light from LED5 and LED6. b-d. Experimental Hong- Ou-Mandel histograms for detunings of 0, 15 and 109 eV between the two quantum dot transitions, which are enlarged in e-g. The red (blue) line is a calculation based on experimental parameters when maximum (minimum) indistinguishability is present. The green line plots the predicted visibility. 12 Figure 5. Integrating the excitation source onto the QPIC. a. Schematic of the section of the device used to demonstrate simultaneous on-chip pumping and tuning of a quantum emitter. A bias of Vpump is applied to the Master LED (M), and strong emission at 880nm is guided to two adjacent Slave LEDs (S1, S2). One of these is tuned by bias VDC to produce the plot in b. 13 Acknowledgements We thank E. Murray and T. Meany for assistance at an early stage of this project, R. M. Stevenson for assistance with the superconducting detectors and Kevin and Trevor for hardware support. We acknowledge funding from the EPSRC for MBE the system used for the growth of the LED. C.D. acknowledges support from the Marie Curie Actions within the Seventh Framework Programme for Research of the European Commission, under Network PICQUE (Grant No. 608062). P.S. acknowledges support from the EPSRC Quantum Communications Hub (Grant No EP/M013472/1). References 1Lifante, G. Integrated Photonics. Wiley (2003). 2Politi, A., Cryan, M. G., Rarity, J. G., Yu, S. and O'Brien, J. L. Science 320 5876, 646-649 (2007). 3Carolan, J., Harrold, C., Sparrow, C., Martin-Lopez, E., Russell, N.J., Silverstone, J.W, Shadbolt, P.J., Matsuda, N., Oguma, M., Itoh, M., Marshall, G.D., Thompson, M.G., Matthews, J.C.F., Hashimoto, T., O'Brien, J.L., Laing, A. Science 349 (6249), 711-716 (2015). 4Crespi, A., Ramponi, R., Osellame, R., Sansoni, L., Bogioanni, I., Sciarrino, F., Vallone, G., Mataloni, P. Nat. Comms 2, 566 (2011) 5Matthews J.C.F., Politi A. Stefanov A. and O'Brien, J.L. Nat Photonics, 3 346-350 (2009). 6Sansoni, L., Sciarrino, F., Vallone, G., Mataloni, P., Crespi, A., Ramponi, R., Osellame, R. Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 (1), 010502 (2012). 7Peruzzo, A., Lobino, M., Matthews, J.C.F., Matsuda, N., Politi, A., Poulius, K., Zhou, X-Q., Lahini, Y., Ismail, N., Wörhodd, K., Brombery, Y., Silberberg, Y., Thompson, M.G., O'Brien, J.L. Science 329 (5998) pp1500 (2010). 8Spring, J.B., Metcalf, BJ, Humphreys PC, Kolthammer WS, Jin XM, Barbieri M, Datta A, Thomas-Peter N, Langford NK, Kundys D, Gates JC, Smith BJ, Smith PG, Walmsley IA. Science 339 6121 798-801 (2013). 9Broome MA, Fedrixzzi A, Rahimi-Keshari S, Dove J, Aaronson S, Ralph TC, White AG. Science 339 (6121), 794-798 (2013). 10Crespi A, Osellame R, Ramponi R, Brod DJ, Galvao EF, Spagnolo N, Viteli C, Maiorino E, Mataloni P, Sciarrion F. Nature Photonics 7, 545-549 (2013). 11Wang H, He Y, Li Y-H, Su Z-E, Li B, Huang H-L, Ding X, Chen M-C, Liu C, Qin J, Li J-P, He Y-M, Schneider C, Kamp M, Peng C-Z, Höfling S, Lu C-Y, Pan J-W. Nature Photonics 11, 361-365 (2017). 14 12Metcalfe BJ, Spring JB, Humphreys PC, Thomas-Peter N, Barbieri M, Kolthammer WS, Jin X- M, Langford NK, Kundys D, Gates JC, Smith BJ, Smith PGR, Walmsley IA. Nature Photonics 8 771 (2014). 13Feng L-T, Zhang M, Zhou Z-Y, Li M, Xiong X, Yu L, Shi B-S, Guo G-P, Dai D-X, Ren X-F, Guo G- C. Nature comms 7, 11985 (2016). 14Mohanty A., Zhang, M., Dutt, A., Ramelow, S., Nussenzveig, P., Lipson, M. Nature Comms 8 14010 (2017). 15Silverstone JW, Bonneau D, Ohira K, Suzuki N, Yoshida H, Lizuka N, Ezaki M, Natarajan CM, Tanner MG, Hadfield RH, Zwiller V, Marshall GD, Rarity JG, O'Brien JL, Thompson MG. Nature Photonics 8 104-108 (2014). 16Kues M, Reimer C, Roztocki P, Cortes LR, Sciara S, Wetzel B, Zhang Y, Cino A, Chu ST, Brent EL, Moss DJ, Caspani L, Azana J, Morandotti R. Nature 546 622 (2017). 17Coles RJ, Price DM, Dixon JE, Royall B, Clarke E, Kok P, Skolnick MS, Fox AM, Makhonin MN. Nature Communications 7 (2016). 18Jöns KD, Rengstl U, Oster M, Hagart F, Heldmaier M, Bounouar S, Ulrich SM, Jetter M, Michler P. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 48 085101 (2015). 19Prtljaga N, Coles RJ, O'Hara J, Royall B, Clarke E, Fox AM, Skolnick MS. Appl. Phys. Lett. 104 23 231107 (2014). 20Kiršanskė G, Thyrrestrup H, Daveau RS, Dreessen CL, Pregnolato T, Midolo L, Tighineanu P, Javadi A, Stobbe S, Schott R, Ludwig A, Wieck AD, Park SI, Song JD, Kuhlmann AV, Söllner I, Löbl MC, Warburton RJ, Lodahl P. Phys. Rev. B 96 156306 (2017). 21Zadeh IE, Elshaari AW, Jöns KD, Fognini A, Dalacu D, Poole PJ, Reimer ME, Vwiller V. Nano letters 16 289-2294 (2016). 22Davanco, M., Liu, J., Sapienza, L., Zhang, C-Z., Vinicius De Miranda Cardoso, J., Verma, V., Mirin, R., Nam, S-W., Liu, L. and Srinivasan, K. Nature Comms. 8 889 (2017) 23Kim, J.-H., Aghaeimeibodi, S., Richardson, C.J.K., Leavitt, R.P., Englund, D., Waks, E. Nano letters 17 12 (2017). 24Patel, R. B., Bennett, A. J., Farrer, I., Nicoll, C. A. ,Ritchie, D. A. and Shields, A. J. Nature photonics 4 (9), 632-635 (2010). 25Flagg, E.B., Muller, A., Polyakov, S.V., Ling, A., Migdall, A., Solomon, G.S. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 137401 (2010). 26 Murray E, Ellis DJP, Meany T, Floether FF, Lee JP, Griffiths JP, Jones GAC, Farrer I, Ritchie DA, Bennett AJ, Shields AJ. Appl. Phys. Lett. 107 171108 (2015). 27Lee JP, Murray E, Bennett AJ, Ellis DJP, Dangel C, Farrer I, Spencer P, Ritchie DA, Shields AJ. Appl. Phys. Lett. 110 (7), 071102 (2017). 28 Skiba-Szymanska J, Jamil A, Farrer I, Ward MB, Nicoll CA, Ellis DJP, Griffiths JP, Anderson D, Jones GAC, Ritchie DA, Shields AJ. Nanotechnology 22 065302 (2011). 29Muller A, Flagg EB, Bianucci P, Wang XY, Deppe DG, Ma W, Zhang J, Salamo GJ, Xiao M, Shih CK. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 18 187402 (2007). 15
1712.05562	1	1712	2017-12-15T07:14:19	Chip-Level Electromigration Reliability Evaluation with Multiple On-Die Variation Effects	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	In this paper, we briefly introduce physical foundations of electromigration (EM) and present a few classical EMrelated theories. We discuss physical parameters affecting EM wire lifetime and we introduce some background related to the existing EM physical simulators. In our work, for EM physical simulation we adopt the atomic concentration balance-based model. We discuss the simulation setup and results. We present a variation-aware electromigration (EM) analysis tool for power grid wires. The tool considers process variations caused by the chemical-mechanical polishing (CMP) and edge placement error (EPE). It uses a compact model that features critical region extraction and variation coefficient calculation.	physics.app-ph	physics	Chip-Level Electromigration Reliability Evaluation with Multiple On-Die Variation Effects Department of Silicon Engineering, Micron Technology Karthik Airani, Rohit Guttal 8000 South Federal Way, Boise, Idaho Abstract In this paper, we briefly introduce physical foundations of electromigration (EM) and present a few classical EM- related theories. We discuss physical parameters affecting EM wire lifetime and we introduce some background related to the existing EM physical simulators. In our work, for EM physical simulation we adopt the atomic concentration balance-based model. We discuss the simulation setup and results. We present a variation-aware electromigration (EM) analysis tool for power grid wires. The tool considers process variations caused by the chemical-mechanical polishing (CMP) and edge placement error (EPE). It uses a compact model that features critical region extraction and variation coefficient calculation. 1. Introduction Electromigration (EM) is a phenomenon of material transport caused by a gradual movement of ions in a conductor due to momentum transfer between conducting electrons and diffusing metal atoms [1]. A void or an extrusion may be formed if a wire undergoes EM stress for a sufficiently long period of time. Such defects may eventually damage the wire. For wires manufactured in Dual Damascene process, void formation occurs much faster than extrusion growth. Thus wire damage caused by voids is much more probable than by extrusions and is considered to be the main EM failure mechanism as shown in Figure 1. Fig. 1 EM failures In reality, void formation occurs much faster than extrusion growth, which is very unlikely to occur [2]. Therefore voids are considered the major EM-caused failures. In this paper, we only focus on the EM-induced void damage of interconnects. The ion movement is caused by several forces, the two main ones are: 1) The direct electrostatic force Fe caused by the electric field, and 2) The force from the momentum transfer with moving electrons Fp, which is in the opposite direction to the electric field [5]. The resulting force Fres acting on an ion is given by (1). ! (1) In (1), q is the electron charge, Ze is the nominal valence of the metal, Zp accounts for the magnitude and direction of the momentum exchange between the conducting electrons and the metal ions, Z* is the effective valence, E is the electrical field, j is current density and ! is the metal resistivity. ρ 2. Physics Behind EM 2.1 Black's Equation EM effects have been widely studied. In 1969, J. R. Black developed the equation (referred to as Black's Equation [3]), which captures the EM failure rate dependence on temperature, electrical stress, and material properties. (2) In (2), MTTF is the mean-time-to-failure, A is an experimental constant, j is the current density, n is the current density exponent (1≤n≤2), Ea is the activation energy, k is Boltzmann constant, T is the absolute temperature in K. Black's equation indicates that larger current density results in shorter EM lifetime. The current exponent n determines whether the shape of a current waveform affects EM lifetime [4]. For n=1, the time-average current density can be used in (1) and the current waveform shape does not affect EM lifetime; else if n>1, transient current density should be considered and the shape of a current waveform matters. There is some controversy across EM literature regarding the exact value of n. A common agreement is that the value of n is close to 1 when the current density is small, and it gradually increases to 2 as the current density increases. For example, in [4], the authors report n=1 for j≤0.1MA/cm2, n=1.5 for 0.1MA/cm2<j<1MA/cm2 and n=2 for j≥1MA/cm2; in [5], the authors report n=1.1±0.2 for j≤2.5MA/cm2 and n=1.8 for j>2.5MA/cm2. In our experiments, we use the time-average current density on low j wires and triangular waveforms on high j wires. With increasing current densities and decreasing wire dimensions, it is possible that more wires will have current density in the range corresponding to n>1. In such cases, more detailed information about current waveforms will be required for EM analysis and discussion on this topic is beyond the scope of this paper. The model is abstract, not based on a specific physical model, but it flexibly describes the failure rate dependence on the temperature, the electrical stress, and the specific technology and materials. The value of Black's equation is that it maps experimental data taken at elevated temperature and stress levels in short periods of time to the expected component failure rates under actual operating conditions. 2.1 Blech Length Effect For electromigration to occur, there is also a lower limit on the interconnect length [6]. It is known as "Blech length" [7], and any wire that has a length below this limit (typically on the order of 10-100 µm) will not fail by electromigration. Here, the mechanical stress buildup causes a reversed migration process which reduces or even compensates the effective material flow towards the anode (Figure 2). Fig. 2 Back stress buildup. ! Although known as "Blech length" effect, the actual criterion to determine if a wire is EM-immortal or not, is the product of its current density j and length L. Specifically, a conductor line is not susceptible to electromigration if the product of the wire's current density j and length L is smaller than a process technology-dependent threshold value jLthreshold. Below, we briefly explain the phenomena behind the Blech length effect. The electromigration induced drift velocity is determined by (3). ! (3) I.A. Blech observed that the metal ions stopped moving, when the wire length was reduced to a certain length. Also, he observed that no ion drift could be detected below a threshold current density. These observations can be explained by considering the flux due to electromigration and the gradient of the chemical potential via a gradient of mechanical stress [7-10] according to (4) where Ω is the atomic volume, and σ is the hydrostatic stress. This equation shows that a gradient of mechanical stress acts as driving force against electromigration. Thus, electromigration stops, when the opposing stress gradient, commonly referred to as "back stress" [11], equals the electromigration driving force, so that Jv=0. This steady-state condition is the so-called "Blech Condition", given by (5) (4) Integrating (5) over the interconnect line length yields (6) ! (5) where σ0 is the stress at x=0. This equation shows that the stress varies linearly along the line, when the backflow flux equals the electromigration flux. Given that the maximum stress a conductor line can withstand is σth, the critical product for electromigration failure can be stated as (7) (6) This is the so-called "Blech Product". The critical product provides a measure of the interconnect resistance against electromigration failure and several experimental works have reported that the critical product for modern copper interconnects is in the range from 2000 to 10000 A/cm [12-15]. (7) 2.3 Diffusion Paths In a homogeneous crystalline structure, because of the uniform lattice structure of the metal ions, there is hardly any momentum transfer between the conducting electrons and the metal ions. However, this symmetry does not exist at the grain boundaries and material interfaces, so here the momentum is transferred much more vigorously [16]. Since in these regions, the metal ions are bonded more weakly than in a regular crystal lattice, once the electron wind has reached certain strength, atoms become separated from the grain boundaries/interfaces and are transported ! ! ! in the direction of the current. Figure 3 shows the EM diffusion paths in a dual-damascene copper interconnect structure, which is the main metallization process in modern semiconductor fabrication [17]. Fig. 3. Dual-damascene copper EM diffusion paths In a dual-damascene structure, only a single metal deposition step is used to simultaneously form the main metal line and the via beneath it. After the via and trench recesses are etched, the via is filled in the same metal-deposition step that fills the trench. Therefore, vias are always in the same copper (Cu) body as the upper level metal, but are separated from the lower level metal by a barrier layer which prevents copper diffusion into the dielectric as shown in Figure 3. Typical barrier layer materials are Ta, TaN, TiN and TiW. The diffusion processes caused by electromigration can be divided into grain boundary diffusion, bulk diffusion and surface diffusion. In general, surface diffusion is dominant in copper interconnects. 3. Variation-Aware Compact MTTF Model 3.1 Variation Sources 3.1.1 CMP dishing Chemical Mechanical Polishing/Planarization (CMP) is a process of smoothing surfaces with the combination of chemical and mechanical forces [18]. Copper and the adjacent dielectric are removed from the wafer at different rates during CMP, creating surface anomalies and a varying topography [19]. Many factors, including pattern geometry (e.g., line density), affect the material removal rates. The CMP process strives to achieve flat topography to improve yield. Dishing is a copper surface anomaly caused by CMP. Dishing occurs when copper recedes below the level of the adjacent dielectric. Although dummy metal fills are added in order to achieve a flat topography, dishing still occurs (Figure 4). dishing Fig. 4 CMP dished copper wires. 3.1.2 Edge Placement Error As technology continues to scale down, lithography no longer produces ideal geometric shapes. The most typical error is the Edge Placement Error (EPE) [20]. EPEs outside the feature are considered positive errors (bumping) and EPEs inside the feature are negative errors (necking) as shown in Figure 5. Although techniques such optical proximity correction (OPC) are applied to reduce EPE, these variations still exist. ! necking bridging bumping Fig. 5. EPE affected wires 3.2 Compact Model 3.2.1 Observations Figure 6 shows an example of AFD simulation result by ANSYS of a CMP dished wire. A maximum AFD occurs at the cathode and a minimum AFD at the anode end of the wire. Fig. 6 EM physical simulation of a CMP dished wire. We make several observations based on the simulations with CMP/EPE variations: 1) A bumping on a wire does not relax the overall EM stress, whereas necking reduces the EM lifetime; 2) On a wire, there exists a critical region where maximum AFD occurs. Necking in this region affects EM significantly; necking elsewhere affects EM much less. The position of a critical region depends on the wire length, current density, and current direction; 3) When CMP dishing affects the critical region, the resulting EM lifetime is proportional to the square of the 4) When necking affects the critical region, the resulting EM lifetime is a function of the necking size and wire height; location. These observations inspire us to develop a compact model that captures dependencies between wire geometry imperfections and EM lifetime. We run simulations with various configurations, and develop a reasonably accurate model within a practical range of geometric variations. ! 3.2.2 Critical Region We define the critical region of a wire as a region where the AFD is greater than 10% of AFDmax (the maximum value of AFD along the entire wire). The critical region boundary position is found to be a piecewise function of wire length and current density as shown in (8), where k1=0.85, k2=1.65e-12, CR=0.85e6, CL=1.02e16 and CC=0.0915 are constants, l is the wire length and j is the current density. B L B R 0 ⎧ ⎪ ⎪ = ⎨ ⎪ ⎪⎩ ⎧ ⎪ ⎪ = ⎨ ⎪ ⎪⎩ k l 1 − C L j k 2 ( j C + C ) l ⋅ k l 1 − C j R 2 0 Cl L ≤ < k j 1 l ≥ C L k j 1 0 l ≤ < C R k j 2 1 l ≥ C R k j 2 1 (8) A sample curve for current density 40mA/mm2 is shown in Figure 7. In this Figure, the square- and circle-marked lines represent distances from the cathode via to the right and left boundaries of the critical region. The double arrowed lines mark the lengths of critical regions. It can be observed that for a fixed current density, the length of critical region does not change. Fig. 7 Critical region boundaries. To quantify the effects of process variation we introduce the variation coefficient. Definition 1: Variation coefficient Cvar is the ratio of an ideal wire EM lifetime tlife0 and EM lifetime tlife of the corresponding wire with geometric variations. C var = 0 t life t life (9) Unlike for process variation induced global effects on EM lifetime, when considering local effects, we assume that the amount of charge passing through a wire does not change. ! ! 3.2.3 Compact Model There are many factors that affect the EM lifetime of a wire with CMP/EPE variations. However, instead of investigating those detailed physical effects, we try to extract the major components that are most important to EM lifetime with variations and develop a simplified model that can be easily applied to full-chip interconnect EM analysis. Fig. 8. Compact model curve for Cvar due to CMP. The ratio between an imperfect and ideal wire height (h'/h0) is the dominant factor for Cvar of CMP dishing. This dependency is given by (10), and shown in Figure 3.5, for kCMP = 1 and m = 2. (10) To determine Cvar of EPE necking, we first consider the case where a single circular dent is present on a wire. The dent can be completely described by its depth d, length l and location x, and Cvar is a function of these three parameters captured by (11), where b and w are the length of the critical region and the width of a wire; kEPE is a fitted parameter equal to 7.2e18. Figure 3.6 shows a sample plot for Cvar of EPE necking with d=0.03µm and l=1µm. (11) Fig. 9. Compact model curve for Cvar due EPE When multiple dents are present on a wire, their cumulative effect is found to be the product of Cvar caused by each dent, given by (12). C var C var,i = ∏ i (12) This variation-aware EM lifetime model provides a mapping methodology from an assumed variation to the resulting EM lifetime. A more useful way to apply this model is to estimate the variation tolerance of EM-sensitive wires. For example, we may want to know how much CMP dishing or how much EPE is allowed for a given wire. These are later referred to as variation criticalities, and will be given to designers. 6. Conclusions As technology scales down, EM is becoming progressively a more serious problem. It posts huge challenge on analysis tools and limits the application of conventional EM theories such as Black's equation and Blech length effect. Moreover, the process variation brings in more uncertainty to EM analysis. ! In this paper, we introduced the basic background knowledge of EM, and described the modeling of variation effects. The variation effects mainly refer to the changes of wire geometry caused by CMP and EPE that affect the EM lifetime of individual wires. A compact variation-aware EM lifetime model is developed. Using this model, variation tolerance of each EM-sensitive wire can be fed back to designers. As technology is scaling down, process variation on wires becomes increasingly more significant. Our work shows that its effect on EM reliability is non- negligible, and a variation-aware EM analysis tool may provide a more realistic assessment of the EM reliability of power grids. 2006, pp. 39-46. Physics, 104, 023529 (2008). 338-347, April 1969. 387-389, 1977. Reliability Physics Symposium (IRPS), Anaheim, CA, 2012, pp. 6A.4.1-6A.4.9. Failures," in IEEE Transactions on Very Large Scale Integration (VLSI) Systems, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 118-130, Jan. 2015. Reference [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromigration. [2] J. Lienig, "Invited Talk: Introduction to Electromigration-Aware Physical Design," International Symposium on Physical Design, [4] F. Wei, C. L. Gan, T. L. Tan, et.al, "Electromigration-induced extrusion failures in Cu/low-k interconnects," Journal of Applied [5] R. S. Sorbello, "Theory of the Direct Force in Electromigration," Phys. Rev. B, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 798-804, 1985. [6] R. Reis. Circuit Design for Reliability, Springer, New York, 2015. [7] J. R. Black, "Electromigration - A Brief Survey and Some Recent Results," IEEE Trans. on Electron Devices, Vol. ED-16 (No. 4), pp. [8] I. A. Blech, "Electromigration in thin aluminum films on titanium nitride," J. Appl. Phys., vol. 47 (1976), pp. 1203–1208. [9] F. Chen et al., "Investigation of emerging middle-of-line poly gate-to-diffusion contact reliability issues," 2012 IEEE International [10] I. A. Blech and C. Herring, "Stress Generation by Electromigration," Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 29, no. 3, pp. 131-133, 1976. [11] I. A. Blech and K. L. Tai, "Measurement of Stress Gradients Generated by Electromigration," Appl. Phys. Lett, vol. 30, no. 8, pp. [12] C. Herring, "Diffusional Viscosity of a Polycrystalline Solid," J. Appl. Phys., vol. 21, pp. 437-445, 1950. [13] D. A. Li, M. Marek-Sadowska and S. R. Nassif, "A Method for Improving Power Grid Resilience to Electromigration-Caused via [14] http://www.iue.tuwien.ac.at/phd/orio/node26.html. [15] E. T. Ogawa, A. J. Bierwag, K.-D. Lee, H. Matsuhashi, P. R. Justinson, and et al., "Direct Observation of a Critical Length Effect in [16] D. Li, et al. Variation-aware electromigration analysis of power/ground networks. Proceedings of the International Conference on [17] D. Ney, X. Federspiel, V. Girault, O. Thomas, and P. Gergaud, "Stress-Induced Electromigration Backflow Effect in Copper [18] L. Doyen, E. Petitprez, P. Waltz, X. Federspiel, L. Arnaud, and Y. Wouters, "Extensive Analysis of Resistance Evolution due to [19] D. A. Li, M. Marek-Sadowska and S. R. Nassif, "T-VEMA: A Temperature- and Variation-Aware Electromigration Power Grid [20] A. S. Oates and M. H. Lin, "Void Nucleation and Growth Contributions to the Critical Current Density for Failure in Cu Vias," Proc. [21] J. W. McPherson and P. B. Ghate, "A methodology for the calculation of continuous dc electromigration equivalents from transient [22] D. Li and M. Marek-Sadowska, "Estimating true worst currents for power grid electromigration analysis," Fifteenth International [23] C. K. Hu, R. Rosenberg, H. S. Rathore, et.al, "Scaling Effect on Electromigration in On-Chip Cu Wiring," International [24] N. Srivastava, K. Banerjee, K. E. Goodson, "Scaling Analysis of Multilevel Interconnect Temperatures for High-Performance ICs," [25] Q. Wang, et al. Research on phase locked loop based on DSP and CPLD. Mechanical & Electrical Engineering Magazine, 2007. [26] D. Li, et al. On-chip em-sensitive interconnect structures. Proceedings of the international workshop on system level interconnect [27] B. Li, C. Christiansen, C. Burke and et al., "Short Line Electromigration Characteristics and their Applications for Circuit Design," [28] D. Li, et al. "Layout Aware Electromigration Analysis of Power/Ground Networks". Circuit Design for Reliability, 2015. [29] M. Lin, N. Jou, W. Liang and K. C. Su, "Effect of Multiple Via Layout on Electromigration Performance and Current Density Dual-Damascene Cu/Oxide Interconnects," Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 78, no. 18, pp. 2652-2645, 2001. Computer-Aided Design, 2011. Interconnects," Trans. Dev. Mater. Reliab., vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 175-180, 2006. Electromigration Induced Degradation," J. Appl. Phys., vol. 104, p. 123521, 2008. Analysis Tool," in IEEE Transactions on Very Large Scale Integration (VLSI) Systems, vol. 23, no. 10, pp. 2327-2331, Oct. 2015. Intl. Reliability Physics Symp., pp. 452-456, 2009. current waveforms," in Proc. Symp. on Electromigration of Metals, New Orleans, LA, pp. 64-74, Oct. 7-12, 1984. Symposium on Quality Electronic Design, Santa Clara, CA, 2014, pp. 708-714. Conference on Interconnect Technology, 1999, pp. 267-269. IEEE Trans. on Electron Devices, volume 52, issue 12, 2005, pp. 2710-2719. prediction, 2010. International Reliability Physics Symposium, 2013, pp 3.F.2.1-3.F.2.5. Distribution in Copper Interconnect," International Reliability Physics Symposium, pp. 844-847, 2009.
1907.09710	1	1907	2019-07-23T06:19:37	Complete inclusion of bioactive molecules and particles in polydime-thylsiloxane: a straightforward process under mild conditions	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.bio-ph" ]	By applying a slow curing process, we show that biomolecules can be incorporated via a simple process as liquid stable phases inside a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) matrix. The process is carried out under mild conditions with regards to temperature, pH and relative humidity, and is thus suitable for application to biological entities. Fluorescence and enzymatic activity measurements, show that the biochemical properties of the proteins and enzyme tested are preserved, without loss due to adsorption at the liquid-polymer interface. Protected from external stimuli by the PDMS matrix, these soft liquid composite materials are new tools of interest for robotics, microfluidics, diagnostics and chemical microreactors.	physics.app-ph	physics	Complete inclusion of bioactive molecules and particles in polydimethylsilox- ane: a straightforward process under mild conditions Greta Faccioa, Alice Contb, Erik Mailanda, Elaheh Zare-Eelanjegha, Riccardo Innocenti Ma- linib, Katharina Maniura-Webera, René Michel Rossib and Fabrizio Spanob a Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Laboratory for Bi- ointerfaces, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland. b Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Laboratory for Bi- omimetic Membranes and Textiles, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland. E-mail: [email protected] [email protected] Abstract By applying a slow curing process, we show that biomolecules can be incorporated via a simple process as liquid stable phases inside a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) matrix. The process is carried out under mild conditions with regards to temperature, pH and relative humidity, and is thus suitable for application to biological entities. Fluorescence and enzymatic activity meas- urements, show that the biochemical properties of the proteins and enzyme tested are preserved, without loss due to adsorption at the liquid-polymer interface. Protected from external stimuli by the PDMS matrix, these soft liquid composite materials are new tools of interest for robotics, microfluidics, diagnostics and chemical microreactors. Liquids and elastomeric materials are key components in microfluidic and diagnostic devices. Conveyed in open structures such as microchannels[1], deposited as refillable reservoirs[2], or conductive metallic lines[3], liquids can add novel functionalities to materials. For instance, in closed structures such as droplets, liquids reinforce the mechanical properties of elastomeric composite material[4]. Our work reports a novel inclusion process and addresses how it affects the molecules contained in the droplets, in particular bioactive molecules or particles embedded in a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) matrix. The introduction of compartments, channels and cages in materials is a challenging, yet desired step towards the manufacture of complex lab-on-a-chip architectures, metamaterials[5], flexible sensors[6], stretchable electronics[3], soft composites[7], mobile structures[8], and soft ro- bots[9]. Compartmentalization of biomolecules and/or reactions benefit from the confinement in an isolated and thus contamination-free environment. When coupled to a high-throughput manufacturing strategy, this allows access to a large number of samples, each with different reaction conditions[10]. For instance, this has been used for screening and for crystallization studies, where nanoliter-scale droplets have been superficially deposited on a PDMS chip to imprint nanowells[11]. A similar approach has been applied to single protein counting[12] and single-cell analyses[13,14]. Droplets are complex systems characterized by a high internal mobility of the component mol- ecules[15] and 'active' droplets able to self-divide, self-replicate, or migrate along chemical gradients can be assembled by tailoring their composition and surface tension[15]. Single size- controlled droplets provide microreactors for chemical reactions in a partially isolated environ- ment, which is of high interest for microfluidic devices[16 -- 18], or the analysis of reactions in confined spaces[19]. The inclusion of a liquid or gel phase in a polymeric material allows mod- ification of the mechanical properties of the material and the generation of soft liquid compo- sites (SLC) with novel properties and functionalities, e.g. for diagnostics[20 -- 22], production of plasmonic devices[23], stretchable electronics[3], soft conductive three-dimensional sponges[24], and polymer-encapsulated liquid droplets[25]. Regardless of its high hydrophobicity (water contact angle of 110[26]), PDMS is a versatile elastomeric polymer, easy to manipulate, with a very good contour accuracy (<10 nm), chemi- cal inertness, thermal stability, and homogeneity even after the generation of microstruc- tures[27,28]. Applications range from electronics to biomedical devices, mechanobiology and microfluidics. PDMS has been applied to the development of patches for the release of thera- peutic molecules triggered by a mechanical stress[29], e.g. stretching, pressure. PDMS is often used in the prototyping of microfluidic devices but the small dimensions of the channels and the high hydrophobicity of the material makes it prone to biofouling, thus requiring passivation methods[30 -- 36]. Current approaches to the production of microcompartments for liquids in elastomeric materials require laborious two-to-many step processes involving the deposition of multiple layers, the design of masks or moulds, lithography or replica molding[37]. In addition to increasing time and cost, multiple steps increase the risk of fabrication errors and possible contamination. Here, we report a straightforward method for the inclusion of biomolecules as liquid droplets in PDMS films to generate SLC materials. In comparison to previously reported approaches, droplets are fully included in the PDMS matrix, and the formation and storage of biomolecules in aqueous droplets is achieved without surfactants or detergents that might compromise their bioactivity. Ensuring the stability of fluorophores and of catalytic entities is a requirement when testing how synthetic devices affect biological entities. Therefore, we firstly optimized the in- clusion method by using dyes and then demonstrated its functionality by investigating three fluorescent proteins and the biotechnologically-relevant catalyst laccase. Additionally, we show that functional materials such as magnetic nanoparticles in liquid droplets can also be included in PDMS films and their spatial distribution can be controlled via external stimuli. Figure 1. Schematic representation of the process leading to the inclusion of an aqueous solu- tion containing a biomolecule in its active form in PDMS. After pouring a thin basal layer of liquid PDMS that is then cured, a subsequent thicker layer is added on top. Then the biomole- cule-rich solution is deposited in µl-sized droplets and the PDMS is let to cure under mild con- dition, to be characterized subsequently by in situ spectrophotometry or ex situ using biochem- ical methods. The initial hypothesis was that PDMS in its viscous state would be suitable for the inclusion of liquid droplets, which could introduce additional functionalities to the material. Two main is- sues had however to be faced. First, the high viscosity of unpolymerized PDMS prevents the spontaneous complete penetration of water-only liquid droplets, as their density is too low. Secondly, droplets with higher density dispensed at the surface of the unpolymerized PDMS slowly migrated towards the bottom and adhered to the mould used for casting, leading to a loss of integrity. To solve the first technical issue, the density of the liquid droplet was tuned to promote its complete incorporation in the PDMS matrix. Preliminary screening experiments identified glycerol as the optimal compound. Characterized by a higher density than PDMS (dglycerol = 1.26 g/cm³ and dPDMS = 0.97 g/cm3 at 20C), glycerol is able to stabilize the tertiary structure of biomolecules, it is used as cryoprotectant, inhibitor of aggregation, and is an inert component in enzymatic, biological, and chemical reactions[38]. Moreover, PDMS and glycerol were selected for their incompressibility and immiscibility. Therefore, glycerol was added at a concentration of 50% to all aqueous samples prior to deposition in PDMS. These droplets were then introduced within the PDMS matrix as shown in Figure 1. To ensure the integrity of the droplet within the material, first a basal layer of PDMS (0.5-1 mm thick) was poured into the mould and cured under mild conditions (Figure 1, step 1), e.g. room temperature (22°C) for 48 h. Once cured, a second unpolymerized PDMS layer was dispensed to reach an approximate 5:1 vol/vol ratio with the basal layer (Figure 1, step 2). As an alternative to degas- sing, air inclusions were let to spontaneously migrate to the surface and, when no longer visible (after approximately 30 min), droplets of the chosen biomolecule-containing solutions were dispensed on the surface of the viscous PDMS using a micropipette and let to settle (Figure 1, step 3). The deposition of the droplets was realized before the polymerization of the PDMS was complete, e.g. during an experimentally defined window of time of a few hours where the PDMS was still in a liquid viscous state, even if the polymerization process already started. As an illustration of the final composite, Figure 2 shows the generation of aqueous dye-loaded inclusions into the PDMS matrix. The aqueous solution containing the blue-violet dye in dis- tilled water was mixed with glycerol (50% volume of the droplet solution) to generate the drop- lets included into the PDMS matrix. Figure 2a and 2b illustrate the top view of the PDMS film with blue-violet droplets having a unique size. The droplets' volume was 10 µl and the droplets were deposited on a hexagonal lattice, demonstrating control over the localization of each drop- let. Figures 2c and 2d indicate that the droplets were not on the surface of the PDMS matrix but were included inside the PDMS matrix as illustrated in Figure 2d where a side view of the PDMS matrix is shown. In the next example (Figure 2e, 2f, 2g, and Figure SI1), droplets of different volumes were included in the PDMS to demonstrate control over their size. The volumes used were 5, 10, 15 and 20 µl. Figures 2e, 2f and 2g clearly indicate the possibility to control the volume and thus the size of the generated inclusions into the PDMS matrix allowing to tune both the material and the droplets/microreactors. Figure 2. Soft liquid composite samples made with inclusions of various dye-loaded droplets: a) Top view of the blue-violet dye-loaded droplet inclusions forming a hexagonal network; b) Zoomed view of the hexagonal network; c) 60° and d) 90° side views of the sample illustrating the complete inclusion of the blue-violet liquid droplets into the PDMS matrix; e) Top view of inclusions made using droplets of 5, 10, 15 and 20 µl ; f) Zoomed view of the soft liquid com- posite sample illustrating the different droplets; g) 90° side view of the sample illustrating the penetration of the blue-violet liquid droplets into the PDMS matrix. h) Top view of the sample made with different dye-loaded droplets forming a cubic network; i) Zoomed view of the cubic network; j) 90° side view of the sample illustrating the penetration of the different dye-loaded droplets into the PDMS matrix. As a last illustration of the developed method, in Figure 2h, 2i, and 2j, the introduction of aque- ous droplets using different dyes was investigated. A cubic network was used to deposit the droplets. The droplets contained the same volume (10 µl) but were made of mixtures of different dyes in distilled water and 50 v/v % glycerol. Figure 2h and 2i display the top views of the sample. In particular, Figure 2i shows a zoomed view of the cubic network. In Figure 2j, we show the 90° side view illustrating the droplets into the PDMS matrix. In Figure SI2, additional illustrations indicate the change of colour in function of the view angles due to the superposition of the different dye-loaded droplets demonstrating that the material could be used to manipulate incoming light and potentially as a signal transducer. Figure 3. Inclusion of biomolecules containing droplets in a controlled spatial arrangement. (a) Zoomed view of inclusions of GFP in PDMS as droplets in liquid form. Deposited as 6 droplets of 10 µl volume, aqueous solutions containing GFP can be stored in PDMS as well-defined spherical droplets. (b) Droplets can be freely arranged in patterns and arrays without leading to fusion while preserving their fluorescent properties (FL). After demonstrating control over the droplet distribution and size (Figure 2 and 3) fluorescent proteins were used to investigate the effect of the inclusion process on biomolecules (Figure 3a). Fluorescent proteins CPC, GFP, and mCherry were selected because of their different struc- tural and fluorescent properties. Since the fluorescence of a protein is dependent on the inter- action of the chromophore with its molecular environment, including the protein matrix[39], it can be perturbed by the interaction with a material surface[40,41]. It is thus interesting to in- vestigate if the inclusion of fluorescent proteins solutions in a PDMS matrix affects their prop- erties[42]. All fluorescent proteins used are characterized by good solubility levels and their molecular surface show well distributed hydrophobic regions that, however, could lead to in- teractions with the PDMS surface (Figure SI3). Although the adsorption of proteins to surfaces is a spontaneous process hard to prevent, and their interaction with PDMS surfaces in aqueous solutions was reported to lead to extensive adsorption forming layers of up to 4 nm in thickness with a density of ~3 mg/m2 in less than one hour, droplets containing the fluorescent proteins were homogeneous. The colour was not concentrated at the PDMS interface nor at the bottom of the droplets, which could happen in case of aggregation. Therefore, this suggests that the addition of the glycerol inhibits the adsorption of the proteins to the surface and minimizes their interactions with one another (Figure 3a). Upon inclusion and by controlling the direction of the white-light illumination, the characteristic fluorescence of the proteins became visible (Fig- ure 4a, Figure SI4). Under lateral illumination, the included droplets of GFP and CPC appeared green and red to the eye, respectively, as these conditions reduced the amount of reflected white light observed under top illumination. CPC, GFP and mCherry proteins within droplets retained their characteristic light absorption and fluorescence properties (Figure 4b) once included, i.e. with absorbance/fluorescence maxima at 620/640 nm, 395/509 nm, and 587/610 nm, respec- tively. In addition to being measured in situ with a fluorimeter, fluorescence intensity was quan- tified using a microarray scanner (Figure 4c) and the linear correlation between concentration and emitted fluorescence of GFP was not affected by the inclusion process (Figure 4c) in a 0-2 mg/ml range. These results show that PDMS could be used as an optical waveguide[43] (Figure 4a), due to the intrinsic smoothness of the polymerized PDMS-liquid interface that minimizes light scattering and reflection. This might be of interest for static optofluidic applications, e.g. liquid lenses and mirrors. Figure 4. Characterization of fluorescent proteins, enzymes, and nanoparticles included as drop- lets in PDMS. (a) Fluorescence of the included biomolecules was visible upon lateral illumina- tion. (b) In situ measurements of the absorbance (continuous line) and fluorescence (dashed line) emission spectra of GFP (green), mCherry (blue), CPC (red) and included as droplets in PDMS. (c) Concentration-dependent fluorescence emission of GFP as droplets in PDMS. In the inset, a photographic image and a false colouring based on fluorescence of the material. (d) Concentration-dependent activity of laccase included in PDMS (empty dots) and of the control solution (filled dots). (e) Migration of nanoparticle aggregates in aqueous solution as droplets when exposed to an external magnetic field (magnet on the left) and visualized by optical mi- croscopy over time (droplet volume: 10 µl, = 2.7 mm, total time = 30s). The enzyme laccase has proven to be particularly valuable in biocatalysis, food engineering, and sensing devices[44], it would therefore be interesting to be able to screen its properties in the presence of different solutes in a controlled environment. Like the fluorescent proteins used above, laccase is also a highly soluble protein that, additionally, is glycosylated at multiple sites, which contribute to its stabilization[45]. The interaction of proteins, applied in dry powder form, through hydrophobic and moulding interactions with unpolymerized PDMS has been shown not to compromise the functionality of the protein[46]. To test this observation with the newly developed inclusion method, solutions of laccase with concentrations ranging from 0 to 3.2 mg/ml were included as droplets in PDMS. Enzymatic activity was measured after two days and compared to an identical untreated control enzyme solution. To reliably perform a one-to- one comparison of residual activity between the control solution and the one stored as inclu- sions, we simply extracted the inclusion solution using a micropipette. The laccase solution included in PDMS retained its activity and was not influenced by the inclusion process, i.e. the residual activity measured from the included enzymatic solution was comparable to the un- treated solutions (Figure 4d). The highest level of protein adsorption is usually registered at conditions of pH values close to the isoelectric point (pI) of the protein[47]. Since the laccase solution was prepared in 50% glycerol with the addition of 100 mM of potassium phosphate giving a pH of 7.5, a condition far from the pI of the protein, it is not surprising that the inclusion of laccase (pI = 3.535) within PDMS did not lead to a loss of enzymatic activity (Figure 4d). In addition, the high concentration of amphiphilic glycerol present in the droplet will also favour the retention of the biomolecules in the liquid phase, as glycerol can shield the interaction be- tween the hydrophobic PDMS surface and the hydrophobic regions of the proteins. The possibility of completely embedding liquid droplets in a material paves the way for the development of microreactors and sensing droplets, e.g. containing traceable elements whose behavior can be influenced by external triggers. By including solutions containing superpara- magnetic nanoparticles, the localization and orientation of these particles could reveal the pres- ence of externally applied magnetic fields, e.g. a magnet influenced their movement. Similarly, nanoparticle movement could be actively induced to swirl the solution within the droplet (Fig- ure 4e) and clearly indicates that a liquid phase is maintained in the inclusions introduced in the PDMS matrix. These observations suggest applications of included nanoparticles as stirrers for microliter volumes and/or as drivers of the motion of droplets on surfaces[48 -- 50]. Conclusions We report a method for the complete inclusion of aqueous droplets containing dyes, biomole- cules or nanoparticles in PDMS under mild conditions that do not alter their biochemical prop- erties or mobility, respectively. This new tool allows to create liquid phases into a polymeric matrix, a process that will be useful for the development of functional materials from photonic crystals, batteries, biosensors, storage devices, microreactors to transdermal drug delivery sys- tems which are under investigation in forthcoming works[51]. Conflicts of interest Parts of this work were implemented in a European Patent Application (EP17197227.6;50617EP). References 1. Song, H.; Tice, J. D.; Ismagilov, R. F. A Microfluidic System for Controlling Reaction Net- works in Time. Angewandte Chemie 2003, 115, 792-796. 2. Bongsoo, K.; SangHyuk, Y.; Kim Yong‐Jin; Jaeyoon, P.; Byunghoon, K.; Seungjoo, H.; Kang Sun‐Woong; Keonwook, K.; Unyong, J. A Strain‐Regulated, Refillable Elastic Patch for Controlled Release. Adv. Mater. Interfaces 2016, 3, 1500803. 3. Larmagnac, A.; Eggenberger, S.; Janossy, H.; Vörös, J. Stretchable electronics based on Ag- PDMS composites. Sci. Rep. 2014, 4, 7254. 4. Style, R. W.; Boltyanskiy, R.; Allen, B.; Jensen, K. E.; Foote, H. P.; Wettlaufer, J. S.; Du- fresne, E. R. Stiffening solids with liquid inclusions. Nat Phys 2015, 11, 82-87. 5. Kim, H. K.; Lee, D.; Lim, S. Wideband-Switchable Metamaterial Absorber Using Injected Liquid Metal. Scientific Reports 2016, 6, 31823. 6. S. Khan; S. Tinku; L. Lorenzelli; R. S. Dahiya Flexible Tactile Sensors Using Screen-Printed P(VDF-TrFE) and MWCNT/PDMS Composites. IEEE Sensors Journal 2015, 15, 3146-3155. 7. Sadasivuni, K. K.; Mohiuddin, M.; Gao, X.; Akther, A.; Mun, S.; Kim, J., In Cellulose/PDMS hybrid material for actuating lens; 2015; Vol. 9434, pp 94340K-94340K-6. 8. Wang, W.; Rodrigue, H.; Ahn, S. Deployable Soft Composite Structures. Scientific Reports 2016, 6, 20869. 9. Martinez, R. V.; Branch, J. L.; Fish, C. R.; Lihua, J.; Shepherd, R. F.; Nunes, R. M.; Zhigang, S.; Whitesides, G. M. Robotic Tentacles with Three‐Dimensional Mobility Based on Flexible Elastomers. Adv Mater 2012, 25, 205-212. 10. Iino, R.; Matsumoto, Y.; Nishino, K.; Yamaguchi, A.; Noji, H. Design of a large-scale femtoliter droplet array for single-cell analysis of drug-tolerant and drug-resistant bacteria. Frontiers in Microbiology 2013, 4. 11. Zhu, Y.; Zhu, L.; Guo, R.; Cui, H.; Ye, S.; Fang, Q. Nanoliter-Scale Protein Crystallization and Screening with a Microfluidic Droplet Robot. Scientific Reports 2014, 4, 5046. 12. Walt, D. R. Protein measurements in microwells. Lab Chip 2014, 14, 3195-3200. 13. Bose, S.; Wan, Z.; Carr, A.; Rizvi, A. H.; Vieira, G.; Pe'er, D. Scalable microfluidics for single cell RNA printing and sequencing. Genome Biol. 2015, 16, 120. 14. Klein, A. M.; Mazutis, L.; Akartuna, I.; Tallapragada, N.; Veres, A.; Li, V. Droplet barcod- ing for single-cell transcriptomics applied to embryonic stem cells. Cell 2015, 161, 1187-1201. 15. Lach, S.; Yoon, S. M.; Grzybowski, B. A. Tactic, reactive, and functional droplets outside of equilibrium. Chem. Soc. Rev. 2016, 45, 4766-4796. 16. Boukellal, H.; Selimovic, S.; Jia, Y.; Cristobal, G.; Fraden, S. Simple, robust storage of drops and fluids in a microfluidic device. Lab Chip 2009, 9, 331-338. 17. Stone, H. A.; Stroock, A. D.; Ajdari, A. ENGINEERING FLOWS IN SMALL DEVICES. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 2004, 36, 381-411. 18. Song, H.; Chen, D. L.; Ismagilov, R. F. Reactions in Droplets in Microfluidic Channels. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2006, 45, 7336-7356. 19. Loste E., Park R. J., Warren J., Meldrum F.C., Precipitation of Calcium Carbonate in Con- finement. Advanced Functional Materials 14(12):1211-1220. 20. Kobayashi, T., Konishi, S.; Microfluidic chip with serially connected filters for improve- ment of collection efficiency in blood plasma separation. Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical 2012161(1), 1176-1183. 21. Jin, B.; Esteva-Font, C.; Verkman, A. S. Droplet-based microfluidic platform for measure- ment of rapid erythrocyte water transport. Lab Chip 2015, 15, 3380-3390. 22. Taylor, N.; Elbaum-Garfinkle, S.; Vaidya, N.; Zhang, H.; Stone, H. A.; Brangwynne, C. P. Biophysical characterization of organelle-based RNA/protein liquid phases using microfluid- ics. Soft Matter 2016, 12, 9142-9150. 23. Wang, J.; Liu, S.; Nahata, A. Reconfigurable plasmonic devices using liquid metals. Opt. Express 2012, 20, 12119-12126. 24. Liang, S.; Li, Y.; Chen, Y.; Yang, J.; Zhu, T.; Zhu, D.; He, C.; Liu, Y.; Handschuh-Wang, S.; Zhou, X. Liquid metal sponges for mechanically durable, all-soft, electrical conductors. J. Mater. Chem. C 2017, 5, 1586-1590. 25. Chipara, A. C.; Owuor, P. S.; Sanjit, B.; Gustavo, B.; Asif, S. A. S.; Mircea, C.; Robert, V.; Jun, L.; Galvao, D. S.; Tiwary, C. S.; Ajayan, P. M. Structural Reinforcement through Liquid Encapsulation. Adv. Mater. Interfaces 2017, 4, 1600781. 26. Lawton, R. A.; Price, C. R.; Runge, A. F.; Doherty III, W. J.; Saavedra, S. S. Air plasma treatment of submicron thick PDMS polymer films: effect of oxidation time and storage condi- tions. Colloids Surf. Physicochem. Eng. Aspects 2005, 253, 213-215. 27. Schneider, F.; Draheim, J.; Kamberger, R.; Wallrabe, U. Process and material properties of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) for Optical MEMS. Sensors and Actuators A: Physical 2009, 151, 95-99. 28. Mata, A.; Fleischman, A. J.; Roy, S. Characterization of Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) Properties for Biomedical Micro/Nanosystems. Biomed. Microdevices 2005, 7, 281-293. 29. Morteza, A.; Sahar, S.; Nelson, B. J.; Metin, S. Recent Advances in Wearable Transdermal Delivery Systems. Adv Mater 2018, 30, 1704530. 30. Wu, D.; Zhao, B.; Dai, Z.; Qin, J.; Lin, B. Grafting epoxy-modified hydrophilic polymers onto poly(dimethylsiloxane) microfluidic chip to resist nonspecific protein adsorption. Lab Chip 2006, 6, 942-947. 31. Roach, L. S.; Song, H.; Ismagilov, R. F. Controlling Nonspecific Protein Adsorption in a Plug-Based Microfluidic System by Controlling Interfacial Chemistry Using Fluorous-Phase Surfactants. Anal. Chem. 2005, 77, 785-796. 32. Faccio, G. From Protein Features to Sensing Surfaces. Sensors 2018, 18. 33. Liu, Y.; Zhang, L.; Wu, W.; Zhao, M.; Wang, W. Restraining non-specific adsorption of protein using Parylene C-caulked polydimethylsiloxane. Biomicrofluidics 2016, 10, 024126. 34. Chandradoss, S. D.; Haagsma, A. C.; Lee, Y. K.; Hwang, J.; Nam, J.; Joo, C. Surface Pas- sivation for Single-molecule Protein Studies. Journal of Visualized Experiments: JoVE 2014, 50549. 35. Keir, B.; Wu Min‐Hsien; Zheng, C.; Zhangfeng, C.; Watts, J. F.; Baker, M. A. Simple sur- face treatments to modify protein adsorption and cell attachment properties within a poly(di- methylsiloxane) micro‐bioreactor. Surf. Interface Anal. 2006, 38, 198-201. 36. Herrmann, M.; Roy, E.; Veres, T.; Tabrizian, M. Microfluidic ELISA on non-passivated PDMS chip using magnetic bead transfer inside dual networks of channels. Lab Chip 2007, 7, 1546-1552. 37. McDonald, J. C.; Whitesides, G. M. Poly(dimethylsiloxane) as a Material for Fabricating Microfluidic Devices. Acc. Chem. Res. 2002, 35, 491-499. 38. Vagenende, V.; Yap, M. G. S.; Trout, B. L. Mechanisms of Protein Stabilization and Pre- vention of Protein Aggregation by Glycerol. Biochemistry (N. Y.) 2009, 48, 11084-11096. 39. Stepanenko, O. V.; Stepanenko, O. V.; Kuznetsova, I. M.; Verkhusha, V. V.; Turoverov, K. K. Beta-Barrel Scaffold of Fluorescent Proteins: Folding, Stability and Role in Chromophore Formation. International review of cell and molecular biology 2013, 302, 221-278. 40. Quiquampoix H., A stepwise approach to the understanding of extracellular enzyme activity in soil. I. Effect of electrostatic interactions on the conformation of a beta-D-glucosidase ad- sorbed on different mineral surfaces. Biochimie, 1987, Jun-Jul; 69(6-7):753-63 41. Baugh L., Vogel V., Structural changes of fibronectin adsorbed to model surfaces probed by fluorescence resonance energy transfer, J. Biomed. Mater. Res. A, 2004, Jun 1; 69(3):525- 34 42. Chumbimuni-Torres, K.; Coronado, R. E.; Mfuh, A. M.; Castro-Guerrero, C.; Silva, M. F.; Negrete, G. R.; Bizios, R.; Garcia, C. D. Adsorption of proteins to thin-films of PDMS and its effect on the adhesion of human endothelial cells. RSC Adv. 2011, 1, 706-714. 43. Cai, Z.; Qiu, W.; Shao, G., Wang, W.; A new fabrication method for all-PDMS waveguides, Sensors and Actuators A: Physical 2013 204 44-47. 44. Rodríguez Couto, S.; Toca Herrera, J. L. Industrial and biotechnological applications of laccases: A review. Biotechnol. Adv. 2006, 24, 500-513. 45. Norde, W. My voyage of discovery to proteins in flatland …and beyond. Colloids and Sur- faces B: Biointerfaces 2008, 61, 1-9. 46. Piscitelli, A.; Pezzella, C.; Giardina, P.; Faraco, V.; Sannia, G. Heterologous laccase pro- duction and its role in industrial applications. Bioengineered Bugs 2010, 1, 252-262. 47. Baldrian, P. Fungal laccases - occurrence and properties. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 2006, 30, 215-242. 48. Heyries, K. A.; Marquette, C. A.; Blum, L. J. Straightforward Protein Immobilization on Sylgard 184 PDMS Microarray Surface. Langmuir 2007, 23, 4523-4527. 49. van Reenen, A.; de Jong, A. M.; den Toonder, Jaap M. J.; Prins, M. W. J. Integrated lab- on-chip biosensing systems based on magnetic particle actuation - a comprehensive review. Lab Chip 2014, 14, 1966-1986. 50. Chong, W. H.; Chin, L. K.; Tan, R. L. S.; Wang, H.; Liu, A. Q.; Chen, H. Stirring in Sus- pension: Nanometer-Sized Magnetic Stir Bars. Angewandte Chemie International Edition 2013, 52, 8570-8573. 51. Long, Z.; Shetty, A. M.; Solomon, M. J.; Larson, R. G. Fundamentals of magnet-actuated droplet manipulation on an open hydrophobic surface. Lab Chip 2009, 9, 1567-1575. 52. Innocenti Malini R., Lesage J., Toncelli C., Fortunato G., Rossi R. M., Spano F., Crosslink- ing dextran electrospun nanofibers via borate chemistry: Proof of concept for wound patches, European Polymer Journal, 110 (2019), 276-282. Supporting Information Complete inclusion of bioactive molecules and particles in polydi- methylsiloxane: a straightforward process for the under mild conditions Greta Faccioa, Alice Contb, Erik Mailanda, Elaheh Zare-Eelanjegha, Riccardo Innocenti Malinib, Katharina Maniura-Webera, René Michel Rossib, Fabrizio Spanob* a Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Laboratory for Bi- ointerfaces, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland. b Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Laboratory for Bi- omimetic Membranes and Textiles, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland *E-mail: [email protected] [email protected] Figure SI1. Soft liquid composites sample made with inclusions of red dye loaded droplets: a) Top view of the sample; b) Zoomed view of the soft liquid composite sample illustrating the different droplet volumes; c) 90° side view of the sample illustrating the penetration of the red liquid droplets into the PDMS matrix. d) Zoomed top view illustrating the droplet vol- umes with 20, 15, 10, 5 and 2 µl, respectively. Figure SI2. Soft liquid composites sample made with inclusions using different dye-loaded droplets: a) Top view of the sample; b), c) and d) 90° side views of dye-loaded inclusions into the PDMS matrix changing colors due the superposition of the droplets in function of the se- lected lateral view angle. Figure SI3. Surface hydrophobicity of the proteins used in the study: CPC (with the bilin co- factor as blue spheres, PDB:4F0T), GFP (PDB:1EME), mCherry (PDB:2H5Q), and laccase (PDB:1KYA) visualized according to the normalized Eisenberg hydrophobicity scale showing hydrophilic regions as white and hydrophobic ones in red. Figure SI4. Photographic imaging of fluorescent proteins GFP and CPC as liquid droplets in PDMS upon top and lateral illumination.
1904.07779	1	1904	2019-04-16T15:59:33	Coherent Magneto-Optomechanical Signal Transduction and Long-Distance Phase-Shift Keying	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mes-hall", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci", "quant-ph" ]	A transducer capable of converting quantum information stored as microwaves into telecom-wavelength signals is a critical piece of future quantum technology as it promises to enable the networking of quantum processors. Cavity optomechanical devices that are simultaneously coupled to microwave fields and optical resonances are being pursued in this regard. Yet even in the classical regime, developing optical modulators based on cavity optomechanics could provide lower power or higher bandwidth alternatives to current technology. Here we demonstrate a magnetically-mediated wavelength conversion technique, based on mixing high frequency tones with an optomechanical torsional resonator. This process can act either as an optical phase or amplitude modulator depending on the experimental configuration, and the carrier modulation is always coherent with the input tone. Such coherence allows classical information transduction and transmission via the technique of phase-shift keying. We demonstrate that we can encode up to eight bins of information, corresponding to three bits, simultaneously and demonstrate the transmission of an 52,500 pixel image over 6 km of optical fiber with just 0.67% error. Furthermore, we show that magneto-optomechanical transduction can be described in a fully quantum manner, implying that this is a viable approach to signal transduction at the single quantum level.	physics.app-ph	physics	Coherent Magneto-Optomechanical Signal Transduction and Long-Distance Phase-Shift Keying M.J. Rudd, P.H. Kim, C.A. Potts, C. Doolin, H. Ramp, B.D. Hauer, and J.P. Davis∗ Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2E9 A transducer capable of converting quantum information stored as microwaves into telecom-wavelength sig- nals is a critical piece of future quantum technology as it promises to enable the networking of quantum proces- sors. Cavity optomechanical devices that are simultaneously coupled to microwave fields and optical resonances are being pursued in this regard. Yet even in the classical regime, developing optical modulators based on cav- ity optomechanics could provide lower power or higher bandwidth alternatives to current technology. Here we demonstrate a magnetically-mediated wavelength conversion technique, based on mixing high frequency tones with an optomechanical torsional resonator. This process can act either as an optical phase or amplitude modulator depending on the experimental configuration, and the carrier modulation is always coherent with the input tone. Such coherence allows classical information transduction and transmission via the technique of phase-shift keying. We demonstrate that we can encode up to eight bins of information, corresponding to three bits, simultaneously and demonstrate the transmission of an 52,500 pixel image over 6 km of optical fiber with just 0.67% error. Furthermore, we show that magneto-optomechanical transduction can be described in a fully quantum manner, implying that this is a viable approach to signal transduction at the single quantum level. I. INTRODUCTION The ability to reliably convert microwave photons to telecom-wavelength photons promises to enable long-distance entanglement of superconducting qubits over telecom fiber networks, a major advance towards developing a quantum in- ternet [1]. Cavity optomechanics, in which mechanical and optical (or microwave) degrees of freedom are highly cou- pled, is a leading contender for such wavelength conversion, in part because mechanical motion can be coupled to a wide range of cavities along the electromagnetic spectrum [2, 3]. Despite such promise, there are many obstacles to efficient and low-noise optomechanical wavelength conversion, such as parasitic thermal noise [4, 5] and the difficulty of simultane- ously coupling two widely separated cavity resonances, such as microwave and telecom. The later stems primarily from the natural mismatch between the size and materials of me- chanical resonators that couple to microwaves versus optical wavelengths. Nonetheless, a number of clever approaches are being pursued to circumvent this mismatch, such as dielectric membranes that are simultaneously coupled to a high-finesse Fabry-P´erot cavity and patterned with a superconducting elec- trode for integration into a microwave cavity [6], and piezo- electric optomechanical resonators in which microwaves can be coupled to the mechanics either directly through an electric field [7, 8] or indirectly via surface acoustic waves [9, 10]. We have recently developed another option, using a mag- netic component affixed to a telecom-wavelength optome- chanical resonator [11], to convert 300 MHz to 1.1 GHz (UHF) tones to a telecom carrier. This takes advantage of a spin-mode intermediary [12], not unlike the surface acoustic wave intermediary in piezoelectric conversion, but with in- creased utility -- as described below. Here, we show both the- oretically and experimentally that this conversion results in a telecom modulation that is coherent with the phase of the microwave drive tone. We therefore use phase-shift keying ∗ [email protected] (PSK) [13] to encode information in the microwave tone -- in up to 8 bins, and therefore, three bits simultaneously -- and read it out through the telecom-wavelength carrier. Further- more, we are able to use PSK to send an image originating in UHF tones, along a telecom fiber over a distance of 6 km with low (≤ 1%) error rate, demonstrating the potential for this wavelength conversion scheme to be integrated with long- distance fiber networks. II. EXPERIMENT At the heart of our conversion technique is the realization that magnetic materials can be harnessed to interface with mi- crowaves as they couple to magnetic fields [14], just as piezo- electric materials couple to electric fields [7, 9]. Therefore, a hard magnetic material (high magnetic coercivity) deposited onto a mechanical resonator allows magnetic control over its motion, as we have previously demonstrated by driving and damping an optomechanical torsional resonator [11]. In order to take advantage of the quality-factor enhancement of a me- chanical resonator, such control is typically limited to a nar- row band of frequencies around the mechanical resonance. To extend the range of frequencies over which one can control the mechanical motion, and hence use for signal transduction, we instead use a soft magnetic material (low magnetic coerciv- ity) with low-damping collective spin excitations. In essence this allows one to oscillate the magnetic moment of the sys- tem, and then use the mixing inherent to magnetic torque to frequency-mix to the mechanical resonance [15]. Here we use a Ni80Fe20 (permalloy) disk, which is pat- terned onto the mechanical resonator during nanofabrication. In such a magnetic material the spin excitations have reso- nances at fres with susceptibility [16], χ(fx) = χ0f 2 res res − fx (fx − i∆f )] [f 2 , (1) which can be driven by an alternating magnetic field in the plane of the device (x) with strength Hx and frequency fx. 9 1 0 2 r p A 6 1 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 9 7 7 7 0 . 4 0 9 1 : v i X r a 2 9,400 in vacuum at room temperature. The mechanical dis- placement is read-out by monitoring the optical cavity trans- mission via a dimpled-tapered fiber [21, 22]. This sensitive detection scheme results in a thermomechanically calibrated [23] mechanical noise floor of 1.1 fm/ Hz, and a torque sen- sitivity of 0.4 zNm/ Hz. A 910 nm diameter permalloy disk was deposited in ultra-high vacuum onto the "sample pad" of the torsional resonator, Fig. 1, in a second e-beam lithography step, enabling the torque-mixing described above. √ √ High-frequency magnetic fields are applied by driving single-loop coils patterned on a printed circuit board (PCB) [11, 15]. Two orthogonal field directions are achieved by hav- ing the loop for the out-of-plane field printed on the top of the PCB, with the in-plane field generated by vias through the thickness of the PCB [11, 15]. These are driven using two signal generators, each referenced to a 10 MHz Rb stan- dard. In the current experiment, each is driven at 16 dBm. A static magnetic field is also applied in the plane of the mag- netic disk, to shift the vortex location and hence optimize the spin-resonance signal [12, 15]. III. THEORY To investigate the signal transduction in our magneto- optomechanical architecture, we begin by considering the canonical optomechanical Hamiltonian describing coherent evolution of the system [24], H0 = ωca†a + p2 2m + mx2 mΩ2 2 + gxa†a. (3) Here, a† (a) is the creation (annihilation) operator for the op- tical cavity mode, ωc is the resonance frequency of the opti- cal cavity, x and p are the mechanical resonator position and momentum operators, Ωm = 2πfm is the mechanical reso- nance frequency, m is the effective mass of the mechanical el- ement, and g is the optomechanical coupling constant defined as g = dωc/dx. From the Hamiltonian we can derive the quantum Langevin equations [25]. We include terms describing the coupling be- tween the system, the magnetic drive, and the external envi- ronment: x = p m , p = −mΩ2 mx − ga†a − Γmp + δFth + δFtor, and a = −iωca − igxa − κ 2 a + √ κeain. (4) (5) (6) Specifically, δFtor = τy/leff is the force applied via the torque mixing process, leff is the effective length of the lever arm [11], δFth is the random thermal forces driving the mechanical element, Γm is the mechanical damping rate, κ is the optical cavity damping rate, and κe is the coupling rate to the external cavity drive. a) Scanning electron micrograph of FIG. 1. the magneto- optomechanical device. Electron-beam lithography was used to pat- tern the device in 250-nm-thick single-crystal-silicon on silicon diox- ide. A second electron-beam-lithography step was used to deposit a 910 nm diameter, 60 nm thick, Ni80Fe20 disk onto the sample pad of the torsional resonator. Scale bar is 200 nm. (b) Spin resonances in the Ni80Fe20 disk can be driven by modulating a magnetic field along the x-axis. This results in an alternating in-plane magnetic moment in the disk, which -- in the presence of a second magnetic field along the z-axis -- produces a torque along the torsion axis of the device (y- axis) as described in the text. The frequencies of the spin resonance and torsional resonance set the frequencies that can be used for the phase modulation presented below. The origin of the doublet in the spin resonance is not currently understood and beyond the scope of the current work. Here ∆f is the spin-resonance linewidth and χ0 is the off- resonant susceptibility [16]. The spin resonance used in the present experiment is shown in Fig. 1, and corresponds to the gyrotropic motion of a vortex state [17, 18] at ∼385 MHz. A second orthogonal magnetic field, with strength Hz and fre- quency fz, can then be applied to down-mix the induced mag- netic moment to a torque along the torsion rod (y), at the dif- ference between the two magnetic drive frequencies [12, 15]: τy(fx − fz) = V HxHzµ0 2 χ(fres), (2) where V is the volume of magnetic material and we con- sider the magnetic susceptibility to be driven on resonance. To take advantage of the quality-factor enhancement of the resonator, the two alternating magnetic fields should be sep- arated in frequency by the mechanical resonance frequency, i.e. fm = fx − fz [15]. In this scenario, the out-of-plane field can be considered the tone one wishes to coherently con- vert to telecom wavelengths, with the in-plane field as a fixed pump. As the frequency of the collective spin modes can be controlled by the geometry [12, 18] and are rather broadband (∆f ∼ 30 MHz in Fig. 1), this torque-mixing provides a tun- able and broadband route for signal transduction. The optomechanical device used here is similar to those in Ref. 12, specifically designed to be highly sensitive to torque [19, 20]. It consists of a disk-shaped optical resonator that is partially encircled by a concentric mechanical resonator (Fig. 1b), which is separated from the microdisk by a 100 nm gap. The mechanical motion has a torsional resonance with a center frequency of fm = 16.7 MHz and a quality factor of 360Frequency (MHz)Demodulated Signal (mVRMS)370380390400410420yxz(a)01234(b)Linearizing the equations of motion around the steady state optical amplitude ¯a, and solving them in the Fourier domain (see Appendix A), the final equations of motion are given by x[ω] ≈ χm[ω] δFth + δFtor (7) (cid:16) (cid:17) (cid:16) − ig¯ax[ω] + √ (cid:17) and . κeδain[ω] δa[ω] = χc[ω] (8) m − ω2 − iΓmω))−1 is the In these equations χm[ω] = (m(Ω2 mechanical susceptibility, χc[ω] = (κ/2−i(ω−∆l))−1 is the optical cavity susceptibility, ∆l is the laser detuning from the optical cavity resonance, and we have ignored effects from dynamical backaction [25]. For a sufficiently strong torque, i.e. greater than the thermal force, the mechanical motion fol- lows the applied torque directly (in-phase). Next, we consider the effect this driving force has on the de- tected optical quadrature operators (see Appendix B for defi- nition). Let us first consider optical homodyne detection of the phase quadrature. In this situation the laser is tuned directly on cavity resonance (i.e., ∆l = 0) to maximize the optical signal. Solving for the output phase-quadrature we find, δXQ,out[ω] = (1 − κeχc[ω])δXQ,in[ω] √ +2 κeχc[ω]χm[ω]g¯a(δFth + δFtor). (9) In contrast, for direct detection the laser is tuned to the highest slope of the optical resonance (i.e., ∆l = κ/2). Direct detec- tion is analogous to a measurement of the output amplitude- quadrature; therefore, solving for the amplitude operator we find, δXI,out[ω] = (1 − κe(cid:60)(χc[ω]))δXI,in[ω] +κe(cid:61)(χc[ω])δXQ,in[ω] −2 κe(cid:61)(χc[ω])χm[ω]g¯a(δFth + δFtor). √ (10) Comparing Eqns. (9) and (10) one can see that in both sit- uations the measured output operator is proportional to the input quadrature operators and the sum of thermal force and the force applied via the magnetic torque mixing procedure described above. The above analysis leads to the conclusion that when the magneto- operated in a homodyne optical circuit, optomechanical transducer operates as a resonant optical phase modulator [26] (e.g., electro-optic modulator (EOM)), whereas in direct detection it operates as an amplitude mod- ulator. In both situations the process is completely coherent such that the phase of the applied torque is directly trans- duced into the output optical signal. Yet, as we experimentally demonstrate below, both of these optical signals are measured by the receiver as modulations to the mechanical phase, as expected from Eqn. (7). This theoretical framework can be interpreted in the quan- tum regime by considering the driving magnetic field Hz(fz) to consist of single photons. In this limit, the transduced field would be dominated by thermal fluctuations at room tempera- ture; however, by performing these experiments in a cryogenic environment the thermal force term can be eliminated [4], al- lowing the transduction of quantum signals. 3 FIG. 2. Demonstration of the coherence of the demodulated 1570- nm-wavelength signal (black) with respect to the phase of the 401.7 MHz drive tone (green dashed). IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION To test the coherent response of the wavelength conversion, we first use a homodyne optical detection system sensitive to shifts in the phase of the optical field within the silicon mi- crodisk. The microdisk lies in one arm of the homodyne sys- tem [35], such that as the mechanical resonator moves in the evanescent field of the microdisk it shifts the optical phase in the cavity and hence the phase of the detected optical sig- nal. This optical signal is demodulated using a digital lock- in amplifier -- referenced to the same 10 MHz Rb source as the signal generators -- at the mechanical resonance frequency to attain the amplitude and, more importantly, phase of the signal modulated at fm. One can consider the photodetector and lock-in amplifier as the receiver in this carrier modulation scheme [13]. The result, shown in Fig. 2, indicates that the phase of the demodulated optical signal at 1570 nm reliably follows the input phase of the UHF tone (here at 401.7 MHz). For the purposes of transmitting information from a mi- crowave source via a telecom carrier, one is naturally con- FIG. 3. Binary phase-shift keying encoded as "non-return to zero" [13] in the UHF tone (green dashed) is coherently observed in the phase of the telecom homodyne detection system. Telecom phase data is averaged over 80% of the time bin (of 6.7 ms), and assigned an average value (black circles) with error bars from the standard error of the mean. This optomechanical wavelength conversion and data transmission rate corresponds to 150 baud. π/2-π/2000.020.040.060.080.10Time (s)Phase (rad)cerned with the speed at which the system can respond to changes in the phase. To test this, we begin with binary phase- shift keying (BPSK), in which two phase bins -- correspond- ing to one bit -- are converted via torque mixing and read-out in the telecom fiber. The signal is averaged over the middle 80% of the time bin, resulting in an average phase with error bars associated with the standard error of the mean, shown in Fig. 3. At a rate of 150 baud (symbols per second), we can associate each time bin with a particular phase bin. This rate could be improved by increasing the signal-to-noise ratio of the converted signal, as discussed below. Interestingly, it is also possible to encode more than two phase bins in a single time bin, which has the potential to in- crease data transmission rates. We show in Fig. 4 the phase of the microwave tones divided into 8 bins, or "symbols," corre- sponding to 3 bits of data per time bin -- referred to as 8PSK [13]. Unfortunately, this required slowing the transmission rate to 64 baud (3 bits in 8 symbols per 125 ms), due to the increased signal averaging needed to resolve all eight phase bins. Therefore, in our current system higher-order PSK does not result in an improved data transmission rate, though with improvements in our signal-to-noise (so that individual phase bins are more easily resolved with less averaging) high-order FIG. 4. a) Eight-bin phase-shift keying (8PSK), corresponding to 3 bits of information per time bin. The phase of the 1570 nm telecom signal is averaged over 80% of the time bin (black circles) and error bars correspond to the standard error of the mean. The phase of the 401.7 MHz tone is shown as the green dashed line. (b) 8PSK data represented on a constellation diagram for a larger data set. Here, we demonstrate that 8PSK is the limit for high-order PSK with current levels of signal-to-noise in the demodulated phase. 4 FIG. 5. a) Image consisting of 150 × 350 points (52,500 pixels). Each pixel can be transmitted as a time bin, with the symbol (black or white) corresponding to the transmitted phase. (b) Reconstructed image after being encoded in the UHF phase and demodulated after homodyne optical detection. Here, the error rate is 0.38%. (c) The image was encoded identically to panel b, but was transmitted via di- rect detection, as described in the text, allowing reconstruction after being transmitted down a 6 km long optical fiber. Here, the error rate is 0.67%. PSK is likely to be advantageous because of the coherent re- sponse of the optical modulation to the phase of the input tone. Finally, after showing that our magneto-optomechanical wavelength conversion is coherent, we turn to demonstrating image transmission via BPSK. As a proof of principle, we have constructed an image containing 52,500 pixels, chosen to be only black or white so that we have an equivalent num- ber of bits of information to encode, as shown in Fig. 5a. The phase of the microwave tone was then modulated to encode the bits, which were sent at a transmission rate of 150 baud to the out-of-plane drive coil. The resulting telecom optical sig- nal was demodulated as above, now with each time bin cor- responding to one pixel, allowing reconstruction of the image as shown in Fig. 5b. It is clear that this generates a faithful representation of the original image, with the introduction of just 0.38% error in the transmitted pixels. For networking applications it is impractical to imagine running two fiber optics for each information channel so that homodyne detection can be performed on a balanced photode- tector. Instead, we turn to the direct detection method de- scribed in Section III. In this approach the amplitude of the optical signal is modulated coherently, but the phase of the mechanics is demodulated using the digital lock-in amplifier exactly as in the homodyne case. In this configuration we can transmit the information encoded in the phase of the mi- 01.02.03.0Time (s)0.51.52.5(a)(b)000001010011100101110111-π/2π/2π/4-π/43π/4-3π/4π0Symbol050100150050100150050100150010020030050150250350(a)(b)(c)crowave tone over long distances in a single fiber optic cable, as shown for 6 km of fiber in Fig. 5c. Here, the error rate in- creases to 0.67%, which could be reduced by the introduction of a fiber-amplifier, although such amplification is not appli- cable to quantum information transmission. V. CONCLUSION We have demonstrated that magneto-optomechanics en- ables coherent signal transduction from UHF tones to tele- com wavelengths. We have used this coherence to demon- strate (classical) optomechanical information transduction via phase-shift keying, using both binary and eight-bin phase- shift keying. Future improvements in signal-to-noise, for ex- ample by using lower spin-damping materials such as yttrium- iron-garnet [28 -- 31], could allow high-order phase-shift key- ing to be used in classical networking applications. Signif- icant improvements could also be made by improving the overlap between the magnetic field from the drive tone and the nanoscale magnetic component on the torsional resonator, for example, by using low-impedance microwave resonators [32 -- 34]. Such low-mode volume superconducting resonators may also be vital for extending this technique to wavelength transduction in the quantum regime. For quantum-level trans- duction, one would also need to eliminate thermomechanical noise, which is difficult in MHz-frequency devices [20, 35]. To facilitate this, it may be possible to construct optome- chanical crystal torque sensors [36] with higher mechanical frequencies that would more easily allow for ground-state preparation [4, 5], or to use carefully timed dynamical back- action cooling as has been performed for microwave drum res- onators [37]. With such avenues for improvement, magneto- optomechanical signal transduction has the potential to be useful for quantum, as well as classical, information trans- mission. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank L.J. LeBlanc for loaning her 6 km fiber spool. This work was supported by the University of Alberta, Faculty of Science; the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council, Canada (Grants Nos. RGPIN-04523-16, DAS-492947-16, STPGP 494024-16, and CREATE-495446- 17); and the Canada Foundation for Innovation. Appendix A: Equations of motion In our experimental setup the optical resonator is driven by a coherent state, evanescently coupled via a dimpled ta- pered optical fiber [21, 22]. The input coherent state is de- scribed by ain = (¯ain + δain(t))eiωlt, where ¯ain is the co- herent state amplitude, δain are small fluctuations about the coherent state amplitude, and ωl is the frequency of the driv- ing laser. Furthermore, we can define the cavity field as κe¯ain/(κ/2 − i∆l) is a = (¯a + δa(t))eiωlt, where ¯a = √ 5 the intra-cavity coherent state amplitude, δa(t) are small fluc- tuations about this steady state amplitude, and ∆l = ωl − ωc is the laser detuning, where we have included any constant shift of the optical resonance due to radiation pressure. Using this definition, and assuming ¯a is real, the value ¯a2 = ¯N is the average number of intra-cavity photons. We can linearize the equations of motion about this defined steady state, ignor- ing terms non-linear in the small fluctuation parameters and arriving at the equations, (cid:16) x[ω] = χm[ω] 1 − ig2¯a2χm[ω](χc[ω] − χ∗ δFth + δFtor − g¯a(cid:0)χc[ω]δain[ω] + χ∗ c [−ω]) (A1) in[ω](cid:1)(cid:17) , (cid:16) − ig¯ax[ω] + √ c [−ω]δa∗ (cid:17) . κeδain[ω] δa[ω] = χc[ω] (A2) c [−ω]) modifies the mechan- The term ig2¯a2χm[ω](χc[ω]−χ∗ ical susceptibility through the optical spring and optical damp- ing effects for non-zero laser detuning. However, in the exper- ZPF/κΓm (cid:28) 1, imentally relevant regime when C = 4 ¯N g2x2 where xzpf =(cid:112)/2mωm is the mechanical zero-point fluc- Furthermore, the additional forcing term g¯a(cid:0)χc[ω]δain[ω] + in[ω](cid:1) is the optical backaction resulting from the tuation amplitude, these terms are small and may be ignored. c [−ω]δa∗ χ∗ random radiation-pressure shot noise. This term is much smaller than the other forces in this experiment and may also be ignored. However, if the force resulting from the torque mixing process is quantum in nature, this term would limit the quantum efficiency of the transduction to the standard quan- tum limit. Ignoring these terms we are left with the simplified equation given in the main text. Appendix B: Optical noise quadratures The input optical amplitude and phase quadrature operators are given by [38], (B1) δXI,in = δain + δa∗ in, δXQ,in = −i(δain − δa∗ in). (B2) Using the input-output formalism that states aout = ain − √ κea, where the output field may be written as aout = (¯aout + δaout(t))eiωlt, one can solve for the output optical quadrature operators. Here, ¯aout is the coherent output state amplitude, δaout are small fluctuations about the coherent output state amplitude. If we consider the noise spectrum of the output field we can define the output amplitude and phase quadrature operators as, δXI,out = δaout + δa∗ out, δXQ,out = −i(δaout − δa∗ out). (B3) (B4) These may be solved for directly using Eqn. (8), and the re- lationship between the input and output field defined above to obtain Eqn. (9) and (10) in the main text. 6 [1] H.J. Kimble, Nature 453, 1023 (2008). [2] J.T. Hill, A.H. Safavi-Naeini, J. Chan and O. Painter, Nature Comm. 3, 1196 (2012). [3] F. Lecocq, J.B. Clark, R.W. Simmonds, J. Aumentado and J.D. Teufel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 043601 (2016). [19] P.H. Kim, C. Doolin, B.D. Hauer, A.J.R. MacDonald, M.R. Freeman, P.E. Barclay and J.P. Davis, Appl. Phys. Lett. 102, 053102 (2013). [20] P.H. Kim, B.D. Hauer, C. Doolin, F, Souris and J.P. Davis, Na- ture Comm. 7, 13165 (2016). [4] H. Ramp, B.D. Hauer, K.C. Balram, T.J. Clark, K. Srinivasan [21] C.P. Michael, M. Borselli, T.J. Johnson, C. Chrystal and O. and J.P. Davis, arXiv:1812.09417. [5] M. Forsch, R. Stockill, A. Wallucks, I. Marinkovic, C. Gartner, R.A. Norte, F. van Otten, A. Fiore, K. Srinivasan and S. Groblacher, arXiv:1812.07588. [6] R.W. Andrews, R.W. Peterson, T.P. Purdy, K. Cicak, R.W. Sim- monds, C.A. Regal and K.W. Lehnert, Nature Comm. 10, 321 (2014). [7] J. Bochmann, A. Vainsencher, D.D. Awschalom and A.N. Cle- land, Nature Phys. 9, 712 (2013). [8] J.D. Witmer, J.A.Valery, P. Arrangoiz-Arriola, C.J. Sarabalis, J.T. Hill and A.H. Safavi-Naeini, Scientific Reports 7, 46313 (2017). [9] K.C. Balram, M.I. Davanco, J.D. Song and K. Srinivasan, Nat. Photonics 10, 346 (2016). Painter, Opt. Express, 15, 4745 (2007). [22] B.D. Hauer, P.H. Kim, C. Doolin, A.J.R. MacDonald, H. Ramp and J.P. Davis, EPJ Tech. Instrum. 1:4 (2014). [23] B.D. Hauer, C. Doolin, K.S.D. Beach and J.P. Davis, Annals of [24] T.P. Purdy, K.E. Grutter, K. Srinivasan and J.M. Taylor, Science [25] M. Aspelmeyer, T. J. Kippenberg and F. Marquardt, Rev. Mod. Physics 339, 181 (2013). 356, 1391 (2017). Phys. 86, 1391 (2014). [26] V.S. Ilchenko, A.A. Savchenkov, A.B. Matsko and L. Maleki, Journal of the Optical Society of America B 20, 333 (2003). [27] S.O. Kasap, "Optoelectronics and Photonics: Principles and Practices" (Prentice Hall, New Jersey), (2001). [28] X. Zhang, C.-L. Zou, L. Jiang and H. X. Tang, Phys. Rev. Lett. [10] A. Vainsencher, K.J. Satzinger, G.A. Peairs and A.N. Cleland, 113, 156401 (2014). Appl. Phys. Lett. 109, 033107 (2016). [11] P.H. Kim, B.D. Hauer, T.J. Clark, F. Fani Sani, M.R. Freeman and J.P. Davis, Nature Comm. 8, 1355 (2017). [12] P.H. Kim, F. Fani Sani, M.R. Freeman and J.P. Davis, Appl. [29] A. Osada, R. Hisatomi, A. Noguchi, Y. Tabuchi, R. Yamazaki, K. Usami, M. Sadgrove, R. Yalla, M. Nomura and Y. Naka- mura, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 223601 (2016). [30] M. Harder, L. Bai, P. Hyde and C.-M. Hu, Phys. Rev. B 95, [13] J.B. Anderson, "Digital Transmission Engineering" (IEEE [31] J. Graf, H. Pfeifer, F. Marquardt and S. Viola Kusminskiy, Phys. Phys. Lett. 113, 083104 (2018). Press, New York), (1999). [14] L. Bai, M. Harder, P. Hyde, Z. Zhang, C.-M. Hu, Y.P. Chen and J. Q. Xiao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 217201 (2017). [15] J.E. Losby, et al., Science 350, 798 (2015). [16] S.S. Kalarickal, P. Krivosik, M. Wu, C.E. Patton, M.L. Schnei- der, P. Kabos, T.J. Silva and J.P. Nibarger, J. Appl. Phys. 99, 093909 (2006). [17] J.P. Park, P. Eames, D.M. Engebretson, J. Berezovsky and P.A. Crowell, Phys. Rev. B 67, 020403(R) (2003). [18] V. Novosad, F.Y. Fradin, P.E. Roy, K.S. Buchanan, K.Yu. Gus- lienko and S.D. Bader, Phys. Rev. B 72, 024455 (2005). 214411 (2017). Rev. B 98, 241406(R) (2018). [32] A. Bienfait, et al. Nature Nanotechnology 11, 253 (2016). [33] C. Eichler, A.J. Sigillito, S.A. Lyon and J. R. Petta, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 037701 (2017). [34] L. McKenzie-Sell, J. Xie, C.-M. Lee, J.W.A. Robinson, C. Cic- carelli and J.A. Haigh, arXiv:1901.10395. [35] B.D. Hauer, P.H. Kim, C. Doolin, F. Souris and J.P. Davis, Phys. Rev. B 98, 214303 (2018). [36] M. Wu, N.L.-Y. Wu, T. Firdous, F. Fani Sani, J. E. Losby, M. R. Freeman and P. E. Barclay, Nat. Nano 12, 127 (2017). [37] T.A. Palomaki, J.D. Teufel, R.W. Simmonds and K.W. Lehnert, Science 342, 710 (2013). [38] R. Loudon, "The Quantum Theory of Light" (OUP Oxford), (2000).
1908.02363	1	1908	2019-07-13T10:55:23	A Tunable Electrorheological Fluid Microfluidic Rectifier: Irreversibility of Viscous Flow due to Spatial Asymmetry Induced Memory Effects	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.soft", "physics.flu-dyn" ]	Due to the reversibility of viscous flow it is not expected to obtain a fluidic rectifier simply from geometrical asymmetry without any moving mechanical parts. Here, we found a counter example by using spatial asymmetry combined with electric field to inject memory effects that render the flow irreversible. This stems from the strong dependency of the electrorheological (ER) fluid particle chaining on the flow direction. A funnel-shaped microfluidic rectifier with ER fluid has been shown to be easily and rapidly tuned via the applied electric field to achieve more than an order of magnitude rectification along with pressure oscillations. These findings are of importance for realization of fluidic diodes, rectifiers and ratchets.	physics.app-ph	physics	A Tunable Electrorheological Fluid Microfluidic Rectifier: Irreversibility of Viscous Flow due to Spatial Asymmetry Induced Memory Effects X. Huo1 and G. Yossifon1* 1Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Micro- and Nanofluidics Laboratory, Technion -- Israel Institute of Technology, Technion City 32000, Israel * Corresponding author: [email protected] PACS numbers: 47.65.Gx, 83.80.Gv 47.61.-k Due to the reversibility of viscous flow it is not expected to obtain a fluidic rectifier simply from geometrical asymmetry without any moving mechanical parts. Here, we found a counter example by using spatial asymmetry combined with electric field to inject memory effects that render the flow irreversible. This stems from the strong dependency of the electrorheological (ER) fluid particle chaining on the flow direction. A funnel-shaped microfluidic rectifier with ER fluid has been shown to be easily and rapidly tuned via the applied electric field to achieve more than an order of magnitude rectification along with pressure oscillations. These findings are of importance for realization of fluidic diodes, rectifiers and ratchets. 1 Electrorheological (ER) fluids consist of solid particles dispersed in an insulating carrier fluid, mostly dielectric oils or organic liquids. Under applied electric fields, the particles become electrically polarized and align themselves to form chains and columns along the field direction, which cause a dramatic increase in apparent viscosity of the ER fluid, resulting in a phase transition from a liquid to a solid-like state. The phase transformation is achieved very quickly, usually on the order of 1-10 ms, and is reversible. This unique feature renders ER fluids promising agents in electric-mechanical interfaces such as shock absorbers, breaks, clutches, valves and actuators [1]. Microfluidics has emerged and prospered for over one decade as a low-cost technique for precise spatial and temporal control of analytes and rapid biological or chemical diagnosis [2]. It is applied in an enormous number of applications in point-of-care (POC) and lab-on-a-chip (LOC) systems. ER fluids have gained increasing interest in microfluidics, due to their diverse microfluidic applications, e.g., microvalves [3,4], micropumps for driving flow in a programmable manner [5] and even logic control of microfluidics [6]. Inspired by the effects of symmetry-breaking geometries of ionic-permselective pores (e.g. funnel-shaped nanochannels [7] or conical-shaped pores [8]) on ionic current rectification, reminiscent of electron rectification in diodes, we set out to examine the effect of similar symmetry breaking on ER fluid behavior. However, due to the reversibility of viscous flow at low Reynolds numbers [9] it is not expected to obtain a fluidic diode, rectifier or ratchet [10], wherein the resistance depends on the direction of flow, simply from geometrical asymmetry of the channel. Here we found a counter example by using spatial asymmetry to inject memory effects, stemming from flow direction dependency of electrorheological fluid particle chaining, that render flow irreversible. Electrorheological fluid behaves Newtonian in the absence of an electric field and Bingham in the presence of an electric field [11-13]. Flow irreversibility in the low Reynolds regime was previously reported for non- Newtonian viscoelastic fluids with triangular [14, 15] and hyperbolic [15] nozzle/diffuser shapes as well as contraction with an obstacle design [16] in order to achieve high 2 anisotropic flow resistance between the two flow directions. However, the fluidic diodicity or rectification factor is quite low, in the range of 1.5-6, and is an inherent fixed parameter of the system for a given flow rate. Previously reported microfluidic rectifiers with Newtonian fluid involved complex channel design that included moving mechanical parts, e.g. valve [17] or flap [18]. To the best of our knowledge the current study is the first realization of a fluidic rectifier without moving mechanical parts which can be dynamically and rapidly tuned via the applied electric field to achieve more than an order of magnitude rectification. Furthermore , all previous studies on ER fluids examined straight and parallel actuating electrodes. Here, we broke the parallel electrode setup commonly used in ER studies via a funnel-shaped microchannel obtained by simply tilting the electrodes side walls (Fig.1a, b). It is obvious that in such a geometry, where the gap between the opposing electrodes varies from tip to base, and in turn, the electric field intensity, the strength and density of the ER chains also vary along the channel. In such a symmetry-broken channel, it is expected that the ER effect will depend upon the flow direction, hence, leading to a rectification effect, manifested via effective viscosity instead of current. Fabrication of the chip followed the technique used by Helal et al. [19], wherein the channel geometry was obtained using direct laser micromachining (Mob laser 50, with L Designer) of a copper foil (3M, 1182, 90 µm in thickness) and Kapton tapes arranged on a glass slide, where the middle section of copper foil served as the electrodes (Fig.1a). The channel was sealed with another glass slide, with an intermediate layer of 50µm thick adhesive tape (3M, 467MP). The copper foils were connected to a function generator (TTi, TGA12104) in series with a high-voltage amplifier (Trek, 2220). The ER fluid examined was RheOil4, with an average diameter of 3.5µm polyurethane particles in silicone oil at a volumetric concentration of =3% Vol, which was obtained upon dilution with 50 cSt silicone oil (Sigma-Aldrich). The funnel-shaped microfluidic chip was mounted on an inverted epi-fluorescent microscope (Nikon, Eclipse Ti-U) for visualization. The ER fluid was then loaded into a syringe and introduced into the microchannel via a tubing (Qosina, Tygon), with flow rate, Q, controlled by a syringe pump (KDS Legato 210). The pressure 3 drop across the microchannel inlets was measured (using Honeywell SSCDANT030PG2A3 pressure sensors) for varying volumetric flows and electric field intensities. In the current study, we chose to apply an electric field of a square-wave form at a frequency of 10Hz, where electrophoresis effects become negligible, resulting in the symmetric accumulation of the particles at the two opposite electrodes (See Fig. S1). In contrast, under DC conditions, the particles, having a native charge, accumulated on one of the electrodes, thus, leading to non-symmetric flow and to degradation of the microfluidic device due to non-reversible absorption of the particles at the electrodes edge. Interestingly, we obtained a maximum in the ER response (Fig.S1) at ~100Hz, followed by high frequency dispersion. Previous studies either reported an almost constant apparent viscosity up to ~100Hz [20] or also noted the existence of such a maximum [21]. Although interesting, the detailed study of the effect of frequency on the ER response is left for future studies and here, we fixed the frequency to 10Hz. Owing to the design of the microchannel device, high-quality visualization of the temporal behavior of the particles was feasible and was synchronized with the pressure sensors and function generator signals. The flow direction from base to tip was defined as positive, while from tip to base was defined as negative. For a positive flow direction, particle feeding from the funnel base to tip further intensified particle blockage at the funnel tip, leading to a rapid buildup of pressure (Fig.1c) and vice-versa for the negative flow direction, wherein tip blockage was delayed to higher voltages due to the counteracting shearing effect of the flow (Fig.1d). This was also manifested by a transient response of the pressure drop for the positive (Fig.2a) and negative (Fig.2b) flow directions. At sufficiently low voltages, where there was no particle blockage of the tip, the pressure drop saturated at a low value. Interestingly, we noted that oscillations of the pressure response occurred beyond the critical voltage for particle blockage of the funnel tip, Vc, which was associated with a rapid buildup of pressure and particle accumulation. At a certain peak pressure, defined as the yield pressure [19], the particle blockage destabilized and broke, as indicated by the sharp pressure drop which was again restored and broke in a periodic manner. Plotting the maximum pressure drop response (average of the maximum pressure 4 values in an oscillatory response, as indicated in Fig. 2b) for both directions (Fig. 2c) clearly showed delayed critical voltage for the particle blockage for the negative flow direction. This dependency on the flow direction can be described via a hydrodynamic rectification factor defined as the ratio between the pressure drops in the positive versus negative direction for the same applied voltage and flow rate. The difference between the critical voltage for the positive and negative flow directions (marked respectively as Vc,p and Vc,n in Fig.2c), resulted in a more than one order of magnitude ER rectification (Fig.2d), with a distinct maximum corresponding to the delayed critical voltage of the negative direction. The maximum was due to the fact that at voltages sufficiently below the critical voltage, the differences between the positive and negative flow directions becomes negligible and hence, the rectification factor becomes unity. The same applies to sufficiently large voltages, where the ER effect overwhelms the hydrodynamic shearing effect and becomes independent of the flow direction, hence, the maximum appears only at intermediate voltages at which the these two effects are comparable (see Fig.S2 and S3). For simple scaling analysis, we used the dimensionless Mason number [22], Mn, that characterizes the relation between hydrodynamic shear and electric polarization forces , (1) where ηc is the viscosity of the continuous phase, is the shear rate, ε0 and εc are the permittivity of the vacuum and the dielectric constant of the continuous phase, respectively, E is the electric field strength, and is the relative polarizability of the particles [22]. The critical electric field beyond which the tip region is blocked, is taken as . Since at voltages around the critical voltage the hydrodynamic and electric polarization forces acting on the chains are comparable, we can use the criteria of Mn ~ 1 to approximate the critical electric field. In a channel with a rectangular cross-section, the shear rate can be described as [23] , (2) 5 20 2ccMnE/ccEVh261Qwfhwhwhere f is a decreasing function of w/h. Combining Eqs. (1) and (2) and Mn~1 yields , (3) where K is the scale factor. For a fixed Q, this scaling seems to qualitatively predict the experimental results (Fig. 2d as well as Fig.S4, depicting similar behavior, for a microchannel with a tip opening of 400µm) in terms of the dependency of the voltage at which the rectification maximum occurs, Vmax ( ), on the tip opening, h, while the fitted prefactor . We then further examined the effect of the flow rate on ER rectification by measuring the pressure drop versus voltage for both positive and negative flow directions with varying flow rates (Fig.3a). As clearly seen, the critical voltages for funnel tip blockage for both the positive and negative directions, shifted to higher voltages with increasing flow rates (Fig.3a). The voltage at which the rectification factor maximum ( ) occurred exhibited a similar trend (Fig.3b). From Eq.(3), for fixed channel dimensions, h and w, the critical voltage ( ) scales with Q0.5 is indicated by the dashed line in the inset of Fig.3b, with a fitted prefactor . The time period, T, of the pressure oscillations (indicated in Fig. 2b) is expected to linearly scale with the electric field squared, regardless of the direction of the flow, in accordance with the scaling of the particle-particle force as seen in Fig. 3c. Since the pressure oscillations correspond to the periodic buildup and destruction of the accumulated particle chains within the funnel, the funnel can be treated as a container that destabilizes once reaching its finite filling capacity. Accordingly, the filling time should scale inversely with the flow rate, Q. Expressing these relations with respect to the threshold values of the electric field, Eth, and its associated periodic time, Tth, for the occurrence of the oscillations yields the following universal scaling , (4) as depicted in the inset of Fig. 3c. It is seen that the periodic time for the positive flow is higher than the negative flow direction in accordance with the higher yield pressure for the 6 0.5 cVKQhwf,cnV920.53.910KVmsmax,cnVVmax,cnVV920.54.110KVms22 ththTTEEQformer. The mechanism underlying the rectification effect is described in Fig.4. The asymmetry in the ER effect cannot simply arise from the hydrodynamics, since the solution to the Stokes flow (Reynolds number ; where the density is kg/l, the dynamic viscosity is Pa∙s, the width of the opening is h=150µm, and the velocity is m/s for Q=10µL/min) is symmetric upon change of the flow direction. The same applies for the electric field, which is the solution of the Laplace equation. However, the duration of time the particles have to form chains in the vicinity of the funnel tip, performing as a positive DEP (p-DEP) trap, is very different for the opposite flow directions. When the flow is in the positive direction, the chains have sufficient time to form along the funnel length. However, when the flow is in the negative direction, the particles begin to interact with each other, and begin to form chains already at the inlet to the tip of the funnel. If the distance at which the chains are formed, s (Fig.4a), is larger than a critical value, sc, then the chains escape the p-DEP trap (Fig.4b) and there is no jamming of the funnel, which, in turn, results in an intensified ER effect. It is expected that the distance at which chain formation initiates, depends on the inverse of the strength of the particle-particle force, i.e. (Fig.4c). To summarize, a significant rectification, of more than one order of magnitude, of the apparent viscosity was obtained due to an ER effect upon symmetry-breaking of the electric field using non-parallel electrodes with a funnel-shaped microchannel. A distinct maximum rectification was observed, with a corresponding voltage (approximately the critical voltage for the blockage of the tip region in the negative flow direction) that monotonically increased with increasing h and/or Q, according to the simple scaling expression of Eq.(3). It was demonstrated that spatial asymmetry injected memory effects, via strong flow direction dependency of the particle chaining, that render flow irreversible. Such a diode-like ER device is of both fundamental and applicative importance and may stimulate further studies of the effect of symmetry breaking as well as introduce new functionalities to ER-based microfluidic and micro-electro-mechanical devices. For 7 Re~0.05uh1.030.0350.012u2sEexample, symmetry breaking geometries could be useful for realization of ER fluidic equivalents of electrical circuit elements. The latter has been the focus of intensive research efforts in recent years using nanofluidics, e.g., diode [8], transistors [24] and recently also using ER-based droplet microfluidics [6,25]. This may ultimately lead to large-scale integration of microfluidic processors with more complexity for on-chip processing for chemical and biological reactions and testing, drug screening, and others. We wish to acknowledge MAFAT for their financial support and the Technion Russel- Berrie Nanotechnology Institute (RBNI) and the Technion Micro-Nano Fabrication Unit (MNFU) for their technical support. We also thank Prof. Touvia Miloh, Prof. Steve Frankel, Dr. Nipun Arora and Dr. Sinwook Park for helpful discussions. [1] P. Sheng, and W. Wen, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 44, 143 (2012). [2] A. Manz, N. Graber, and H. M. Widmer, Sensor. Actuat. B-Chem. 1, 244 (1990). [3] J, Kim, K. Yoshida, K. Kouda, and S. Yokota, Sensor. Actuat. A-Phys. 156, 366 (2009). [4] T. Miyoshi, K. Yoshida, J. Kim, S. I. Eom, and S. Yokota, Sensor. Actuat. A-Phys. 245, 68 (2016). [5] L. Liu, X. Chen, X. Niu, W. Wen, and P. Sheng, Appl. Phys. Lett. 89, 083505 (2006). [6] L. Wang, M. Zhang, J. Li, X. Gong, and W. Wen, Lab Chip 10, 2869 (2010). [7] L. Rosentsvit, W. Wang, J. Schiffbauer, H.-C. Chang, and G. Yossifon, J. Chem. Phys. 143, 224706 (2015). [8] Z. S. Siwy, Adv. Funct. Mater. 16, 735 (2006). [9] L. D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics (Pergamon Press, New York, 1987). [10] N. Tesla, Valvular Conduit, U.S. Patent No. 1 329 559. [11] N. Kuramoto, M. Yamazaki, K. Nagai, and K. Koyama, Thin Solid Films 239, 169 (1994). [12] M. Whittle, R. J. Atkin, and W. A. Bullough, J. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech. 57, 61 (1995). [13] T. C. Halsey, J. E. Martin, and D. Adolf, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1519 (1992). 8 [14] A. Groisman, and S. R. Quake, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 094501 (2004). [15] P.C. Sousa, F.T. Pinho, M.S.N. Oliveira, and M.A. Alves, J. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech. 165, 652 (2010). [16]K. E. Jensen, P. Szabo, F. Okkels, and M. A. Alves, Biomicrofluidics 6, 044112 (2012). [17] J. Liu, Y. Chen, C. R. Taylor, A. Scherer, and E. P. Kartalov, J. Appl. Phys. 106, 114311 (2009). [18] M. L. Adams, M. L. Johnston, A. Scherer, and S. R. Quake, J. Micromech. Microeng. 15, 1517 (2005). [19] A. Helal, B. Qian, G. H. McKinley, and A. E. Hosoi, Phys. Rev. Appl. 5, 064011 (2016) [20] H. Ma, W. Wen, W. Y. Tam, and P. Sheng, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2499 (1996). [21] X. Tang, and H. Conrad, J. Appl. Phys. 80, 5240 (1996). [22] J. E. Martin, and R. A. Anderson, J. Chem. Phys. 104, 4814 (1996). [23] Y. Son, Polymer 48, 632 (2007). [24] R. Fan, M. Yue, R. Karnik, A. Majumdar and P. D. Yang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95 086607 (2005). [25] M. Zhang, L. Wang, X. Wang, J. Wu, J. Li, X. Gong, J. Qin, W. Li and W. Wen, Soft Matter, 7, 7493 (2011). 9 FIG. 1. Chip design and definition of the positive versus negative flow directions. (a) Scheme of the funnel-shaped electrode within the microfluidic channel, where the tilt angle of the electrode sides is defined as θ, while the width of the funnel tip opening is defined as h. Chips of varying h and θ were used while keeping the same average cross-section area of the funnel. (b) Image of the chip. (c) Microscopy image of the tip region under a flow of Q=10μL/min in the positive direction and an AC voltage of 650V and 10Hz square wave form. Particle blockage of the funnel tip is clearly seen. (d) Microscopy image of the tip region under the same conditions as in (c) with flow in the negative direction, where the hydrodynamic shearing of the particle chains leaves an open path for the ER fluid. 10 FIG. 2. The effect of the funnel geometry on ER rectification. Transient pressure drop response for (a) positive and (b) negative flow direction at different voltages (400V, 650V and 800V (10Hz frequency)). The width of the tip opening was h=150μm and the flow rate was Q=10 μL/min. Beyond the critical voltage for particle blockage of the funnel tip, the response became oscillatory. (c) The yield pressure vs. voltage for both the positive and negative directions as obtained from parts (a) and (b), respectively. (d) The rectification factor vs. voltage for different widths (150, 300, 400, 600 and 2470μm (straight channel)) of the funnel tip. With decreasing tip width, the voltage corresponding to the maximum rectification factor, Vmax, decreased (see also inset; symbols represent experiments while dashed line represents theoretical scaling Eq.(3)), while the rectification factor increased. 11 FIG. 3. The effect of the flow rate on ER rectification and pressure drop oscillations. (a) The yield pressures for both positive (dashed lines) and negative (continuous lines) flow directions vs. voltage, for flow rates of 5, 10 and 15μL/min. (b) The rectification factor vs. voltage for different flow rates of 5, 10 and 15μL/min. With increasing flow rates, the voltage corresponding to the maximum rectification factor, Vmax, increased (see also inset; symbols represent experiments while dashed line represents theoretical scaling Eq.(3)), as well as the maximum rectification factor. (c) The time period of the pressure oscillations vs. the electric field squared for both positive and negative flow direction and varying flow rates. The inset depicts the universal scaling Eq. (4) of the measured data taken relative to the threshold value of the electric field (Eth) for inducing oscillations (each case has its own threshold value) and the corresponding threshold periodic time (Tth). 12 FIG. 4. The underlying physical mechanism of asymmetric ER response upon change of flow direction. (a) Microscopic image of a funnel with tip opening of 400μm defining the distance, s, where the chain is first formed under negative flow direction. (b) The electric field (norm), as calculated using numerical simulations indicating its intensification at the electrode corners. (c) The distance, s, is inversely proportional to E2. The critical voltages for the negative flow direction, Vc,n, and their corresponding critical distance of chain formation, sc. For s>sc, the formed chains were able to escape the DEP trap, and thus, do not jam the entrance to the funnel. 13
1801.04166	1	1801	2018-01-12T13:52:34	A finite element analysis of rolling of bilayer films to cylindrical and conical tubes	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	With recent developments in nanotechnology, self-assembled structures are providing convenient, cheaper and more precise ways of manufacturing various patterns and shapes with less complexity. Of these self-assembled structures, rolled-up nano-tubes play a vital role in various aspects. The notion is, the utilization of strain energy developed during epitaxial growth of a bilayer thin film over a substrate, mediated by a sacrificial layer. While the sacrificial layer is etched, the bilayer film is subjected to release its own in-built strain energy in the out-of-plane direction (3D structure) due to a bending stress induced by biaxial strain through the thickness, in the bilayer. This paper proposes a new method of fabricating conical self-rolled assembly by thickness and strain variations along the width of the bilayer and, cylindrical structure of variable radius due to thickness and strain variations along the length.	physics.app-ph	physics	A finite element analysis of rolling of bilayer films to cylindrical and conical tubes Nihit Vyas and Ratna Kumar Annabattula∗ Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai-600036, India October 21, 2018 Abstract With recent developments in nanotechnology, self-assembled structures are providing conve- nient, cheaper and more precise ways of manufacturing various patterns and shapes with less complexity. Of these self-assembled structures, rolled-up nano-tubes play a vital role in various aspects. The notion is, the utilization of strain energy developed during epitaxial growth of a bilayer thin film over a substrate, mediated by a sacrificial layer. While the sacrificial layer is etched, the bilayer film is subjected to release its own in-built strain energy in the out-of-plane direction (3D structure) due to a bending stress induced by biaxial strain through the thickness, in the bilayer. This paper proposes a new method of fabricating conical self-rolled assembly by thickness and strain variations along the width of the bilayer and, cylindrical structure of variable radius due to thickness and strain variations along the length. Keywords: thin Film; bilayer; cone; finte element analysis 1 Introduction Neoteric advances on self-assembly of various thin film structures[1 -- 8] have prompted for prolif- erated research at nano-scale. Some of the prominent contributions in the field of self-assembled bilayer thin film systems (a double layered film) are nano-tubes[1 -- 3], nano-scrolls[5, 6, 9], nano- rings[3, 4], etc.. It is a result of out-of-plane deformation of the bilayer due to a through thickness gradient of eigenstrain developed during the epitaxial growth of the film over the substrate. How- ever, initially, the bilayer being strongly bonded to the substrate, the bilayer remains strained. The implication thus, is to overcome this bond energy, achieved by etching, and releasing the eigenstrains (due to lattice mismatch of film and substrate) in specific direction, in the form of ∗Corresponding author: [email protected] 1 rolling-up and/or wrinkling[8] of the bilayer[10]. These structures contribute significantly to a wide variety of interest in fields of drug delivery[7], nano-tools[11], photonics[12 -- 14], nano-jets and engines[15 -- 18], and thus, it makes a significant topic for exploration of different patterns caused by the interplay between geometry and strain, specially due to its precise assembly[19]. Previously, simulation works have been explored along with experimental backings for radius estimates[20], moving boundary analysis [21] to simulate progressive etching, bending and wrin- kling mode preference[10], side of roll preference[22, 23], twisting[6], etc.. In some of the recent works, cone shaped nanostructures have also been made[14, 24, 25] for the nano-jets and nano-motors. One of the methods is, by taking thickness gradient and/or strain gradient along the width, as observed in [24]. Although not explicitly mentioned or worked upon previously, these gradients contribute to a lot of variations for the precise self-assembly of coni- cal or coiled structures. In this paper, a new method for fabricating conical bilayer structures is presented and, we further investigate the effect of geometric parameters (thickness, length and width) of the initial bilayer and strain variation (decoupled), on the final geometry, separately. Similarly, investigation of thickness and strain variations along the length of the bilayer, is also presented. 2 Model setup The formulation of a bilayer model is based on a multilayered plate system of Reissner-Mindlin plates[26, 27] combined with Foppl-von K´arm´an[28] equations for non-linear deformation, as the rolled-up assembly of the bilayer is subjected to small strains with large rotations. The roll-up process is simulated using Finite Element Method with the aid of commercial package ABAQUS[29]. The material properties (Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio) for the bilayer consisting of linear elastic isotropic Silicon (top layer) and SixGe1−x (bottom layer) are taken as E1 = 170 GPa, ν1 = 0.22[30] and E2 = 166.15 GPa, ν2 = 0.2775 (x 0.9), respectively. In this section, thickness of a free-hanging bilayer is varied linearly, without any cohesive layer or substrate as shown in Fig. 1. Also, strain in the SixGe1−x layer is varied separately for a uniformly thick (both the layers of same non-varying thickness) free-hanging bilayer as shown in Fig. 2. The model consists of a bilayer, fixed at left end of the longer edge along the width and free at the other, with length l = 20 µm and a linearly tapered, symmetric thickness cross-section, for thickness gradient along the width (w) (Fig. 1a) and along the length (l) (Fig. 1b). Eigenstrain is fixed at 2% for all thickness variation analysis. For the thickness variation along the width, we first keep the taper ratio (to/ti) constant, varying only the width, to simulate the effects of taper angle (the angle formed by the thickness gradient) by varying aspect ratio (w/l). Here, ti and to are the total thickness of bilayer at small thickness and large thickness edge, respectively. The effect of the variation of taper angle is further studied, by keeping ti and w/l constant and varying to. Taper angle, thus, is varied in terms of taper ratio. Finally, the effect of average thickness ((to+ti)/2) for same taper angle/taper ratio was studied by keeping initial taper ratio as 5 and then adding 10 to 40 nanometers to the whole bilayer, terming this as average thickness increment, uniformly by maintaining proportionality in thickness of 2 the layers as (1:1) in the bilayer. Width is also varied for each average thickness case, for the complete study. Fixed end Fixed end to ti Free end (a) Free end (b) Figure 1: (a) Tapered thickness along the width and (b) Tapered thickness along the length in a bilayer system Similarly, for strain gradient (0.75% to 3%) along the length and along the width (0.5% to 3%), bilayer with uniform cross section (with 30 nm thickness of a layer) is used with equal thick- ness for both layers. Minimum strain along the length was chosen as 0.75% so as to observe higher deformation/rotation (also, to overcome the effects of fixed boundary). Likewise, mini- mum strain of 0.5% is chosen for gradient along the width so as to avoid strain free condition and provide some bending moment at the respective edge. (a) (b) Figure 2: a) Strain gradient along the width and b) Along the length in a bilayer system Rolled-up cylindrical nano-tubes have certain radius (R), which depends on the ratio of thick- ness (t1/t2) of the individual layers in a bilayer, and on strain difference in upper (subscript 1) and lower layer (subscript 2), δ = 1 − 2 ( represents strain), and material modulus ratio χ = Y1/Y2, according to [31] Y 2 1 t4 1 + Y 2 2 t4 R = 2 + 2Y1Y2t1t2(2t2 1 + 2t2 6Y1Y2t1t2(t1 + t2)(η11 − η22) 2 + 3t1t2) (1) 3 where, Y1 = E1/(1−ν2 1 ), Y2 = E2/(1−ν2 1 ) and ηi = 1, for plane strain condition. The projection Figure 3: Projection of trace of a longitudinal edge of a sample rolled up uniform bilayer of certain uniform strain in lower layer (SixGe1−x layer) and no strain in upper layer (Si layer) on to xy-plane. of trace of a longitudinal edge of rolled-up bilayer, initially in xy-plane before rolling-up, on to the xy - plane is observed to be a straight line, as in Fig. 3. However, this deviates for the thickness variation of bilayer along the width and strain gradient along the width, as discussed below. 2.1 Effects of thickness variations along the width of a free standing bi- layer film In this section, we study the effect of geometry, i.e., taper angle (by taper ratio (to/ti)), aspect ratio (w/l) variation (by varying width) and average thickness ((to + ti)/2) variation (same taper ratio, adding overall thickness), on the cone angle, pitch and radius of the rolled-up tube. Due to the asymmetry introduced through tapered cross section, the film also bends in y-direction, as shown in Fig. 4. This leads to formation of a helical roll with increasing pitch, as a direct consequence of varying bending stiffness along the width. Conical shapes due to thickness gra- dient along the width, have been previously observed experimentally[24]. However, there was no systematic study on such conical system in literature to the best of our knowledge. We study the change in pitch, for different aspect ratio (w/l), taper ratio (to/ti) and average thick- ness, between same extrema number, starting from fixed end to free end as depicted in Fig. 4c. All the variations were studied by tracing and projecting the deformed state of small thickness edge and large thickness edge on the xy-plane as shown in Fig. 4c and 4d, respectively. 4 (a) (b) (c) (d) Figure 4: a) Conical structure formed by thickness gradient along the width, b) Tracing the de- formed small thickness edge, c) Projection of small thickness edge on xy-plane and d) Projection of large thickness edge on xy-plane. 5 2.1.1 Effects of width variation (a) (b) Figure 5: Aspect ratio effect: a) Pitch variation plot for small thickness edge and b) For large thickness edge (a) (b) Figure 6: Aspect ratio effect: a) Location of an extrema along median wave-line path d for differ- ent aspect ratios (w/l) from fixed end to free end of an edge's projection plot and b) Normalised radius (r/l) (non-solid lines) and normalised cone angle It can be observed from Figs. 5 and 6a, as the aspect ratio w/l increases, number of turns in- 6 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxcrease for both small thickness edge and large thickness edge, resulting in formation of a compact conical roll. Fig. 5 suggests, more the aspect ratio (w/l), lesser the pitch (p) becomes, between two extrema number (read as a curve in Fig. 5), i.e., for a given turn number, for both small thickness edge and large thickness edge. It may further be noted that the increase in the number of turns with increase in the aspect ratio (w/l) is quantitatively larger for the small thickness edge than the large thickness edge. This is due to lower bending stiffness of the small thickness edge compared to the large thickness edge. While the radius of any given section along the length of the bilayer remains same, it linearly increases from small thickness edge (smallest radius) to large thickness edge (largest radius), forming a constant cone angle, as shown in Fig. 6b, which decreases as the aspect ratio (w/l) increases. Thus, supporting the previous statement of com- pactness, as indicated by Fig. 5. Fig. 6b also indicates that the radius of any longitudinal section of the bilayer is independent of the aspect ratio (w/l). Note that the thickness of the film changes at a longitudinal section with width variation for a given to and ti. Hence, it may be concluded that for a given thickness the radius remains independent of the aspect ratio (w/l). However, this radius can't be obtained from equation (1) due to the effects of thickness variation along width. 2.1.2 Effects of taper ratio (to/ti) Fig. 7a and 7b show the effect of varying taper ratio (to/ti) for a given width of the bilayer, on the geometry of conical roll. The value of ti is taken as 10 nm while the value of to is varied. As the taper ratio increases (See Fig. 7a and 7b), the number of turns decreases, and hence, the pitch between two particular extrema increases. As observed and stated previously, the radius for the same thickness remains the same and increases with increasing thickness at the large thickness edge (as thickness of outer edge is varied) as observed in Fig. 7c. The overlapping of curves for different widths for small thickness edge reiterates the prediction. The cone angle increases with increasing the taper ratio (to/ti) as shown in Fig. 7d, and decreases with increase in aspect ratio, for a fixed taper ratio, as observed previously in Fig. 6b. 2.1.3 Effects of average thickness variation In this section, we study the effect of increasing the film thickness at both the large thickness edge and small thickness by the same amount thus keeping the taper angle constant for a particular width. In other words, the average thickness ((to + ti)/2) is increased keeping the thickness of each layer proportional (1:1). Note that, for any given average thickness in the case of different widths, the thickness of either of the longitudinal edge is fixed and constant for different widths. With the increase in average thickness (measure of thickness in xz-plane), the number of turns decrease and pitch increases linearly as shown in Figs. 8a and 8b, for the small thickness edge and the large thickness edge, respectively. Radius increases linearly and equally for both small thickness and large thickness edge, with increasing average thickness, due to increasing bending stiffness and as indicated by the parallel lines of both edges (see Fig. 8c). The cone angle remains constant as the taper angle is maintained same (Fig. 8d), independent of average thickness. Variation of the cone angle with aspect ratio, 7 (a) (c) (b) (d) Figure 7: Taper ratio effect: a) Pitch variation plot for small thickness edge, b) For large thickness edge, c) Normalised radius (r/l) and d) Normalised cone angle 8 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxis in accordance with previous observations, which is, the cone angle decreases with increasing aspect ratio as taper angle is also changing with the aspect ratio (Fig. 6b). (a) (c) (b) (d) Figure 8: Average thickness effect (taper angle fixed): a) Pitch variation plot for small thickness edge, b) For large thickness edge, c) Normalised radius (r/l) (non-solid lines) and d) Normalised cone angle Thus, it can be inferred that, for the thickness variation along the width, the deformation in y- direction is due to bending moment arising from the stiffness variation along that direction. Thus, the pitch so obtained increases continuously as the bending stiffness variation is also continuous. Radius for a particular average thickness remains the same as the same bending stiffness at that longitudinal section and the same strain is acting in that plane (initially xz-plane). The structure 9 so obtained is a variation of surface of a helicoid with varying pitch and straight line generatrix with a cylindrical directrix whose parametric equation is given by [32]. 2.2 Thickness tapering along the length The effects of variation of thickness along the length are studied in this section. The initial configuration of the bilayer is depicted in Fig. 1b. The shape obtained after straining to the bilayer, is that of a tube with increasing radius (free end to fixed end) (See Fig. 9a). The radius thus obtained, is a function of thickness. The FE model predicts variable radius, and is in very good agreement with the analytical solution (equation (1)) for a given thickness at a given position along the length, as shown in Fig. 9b. The radius of curvature for a given thickness of a uniform thickness bilayer, was calculated using equation (1), obtaining different radius for different thickness of the uniform bilayer and plotted in Fig. 9b along withthe radius of curvature for a linearly tapered thickness along the length of the bilayer system. The FE analysis plot depicts the radius at a particular point of the tapered bilayer along the length. Fixed end Front view (a) (b) Figure 9: a) Effect of tapered thickness and strain gradient along the length in a bilayer system and b) Evolution of radius with thickness variation (50 to 10 nm) and strain variation (0.75% to 3%) (left to right, linearly) 2.3 Effects of strain gradient along the width In this section, we present the results concerning the second methodology, i.e., simulations by strain engineering to fabricate conical films. First, we discuss the system with strain gradient along the width of the film and then along the length of the film (discussed in the next section). 10 The values of strains at small strain edge and large strain edge for both the cases are shown in Figs. 2a and 2b. Note that in this section, the thickness of the bilayer film is taken as 30 nm (each layer) and is uniform in all simulations for the mentioned strain gradient. (a) (c) (b) (d) Figure 10: Strain gradient effect: a) Pitch variation for large strain edge, b) For small strain edge, c) Normalised radius (r/l) (referred by edge) and d) Normalised cone angle and normalise spiral angle Figs. 10a and 10b show the variation of normalized pitch as a function of aspect ratio (w/l) of the film for large strain edge and small strain edge, respectively (0.5% strain at an edge is termed small strain edge and 3% at the other edge is termed as large strain edge). It can be observed that 11 the number of extrema increases and the pitch decreases with increase in the aspect ratio (w/l). However, the edges are switched, i.e., the edge with higher strain curls in smaller radius. The effects of strain gradient along the width for different aspect ratios (w/l) as shown in Fig. 10 are similar to the effects due to thickness variation along the width as shown in Figs. 5 and 6. (a) (c) (b) (d) Figure 11: Average thickness effect (on strain variation model): a) Pitch variation for large strain edge, b) For small strain edge, c) Normalised radius (r/l) (referred by edge) and d) Normalised cone angle and normalised spiral angle Effect of average thickness on the normalized pitch for width 32 µm, is shown in Figs. 11a and 11b. Here, the average thickness is the average of the thickness of top and bottom layers of the 12 bilayer. Note that the number of turns and the pitch variation in this case are less compared to the case of film with uniform strain and thickness gradient along the width (see Figs. 8a and 8b). Fig. 11c shows the radius variation as a function of average thickness and Fig. 11d shows the cone angle and spiral angle (spiral angle is the term used for angle formed by a linear increase in radius of a longitudinal section of the bilayer film from fixed end to free end) as a function of average thickness. The radius of the roll increases (see Fig. 11a) with increase in average thickness due to increased bending stiffness for both the small strain and large strain edges. However, it is worth noting that the rate of change of radius with thickness is not the same for both the edges unlike the case of the thickness variation along the width (Fig. 8c). This different rates of radius variation with the average thickness for both the edges (Fig. 11a) may be attributed to the existence of spiral angle. Thus, comparative observations can be made with the thickness variation along the width, with an additional angle of spiral as depicted in Fig. 12a. The spiral angle remains constant for three or more maxima as observed in Fig. 10d, and thus, is independent of the strain gradient. Also, as seen in Fig. 11d, the cone angle remains same since there is no change in the strain gradient, but the spiral angle increases with the increase in overall stiffness which in turn is due to the increase in the average thickness. Due to the spiral angle effect, only the initial radius (starting radius of helical spiral) (first turn on the conical tube), of various edges, is relevant for defining the rolled-up assembly. Note that below three maxima of large strain edge, it is not possible to get a proper spiral angle, due to the effect of fixed boundary condition on the first maxima and minima. Also, beyond a total thickness of 80 nm of the bilayer, the edge with small strain does not roll in a complete turn, thus, some measurements are not possible for those cases (cone angle, radius of the small strain edge). The spiral angle comes in effect due to the strain being bi-directional, hence, it can relax in the plane of the bilayer. It was not so in the case of thickness variation along the width as bending stiffness was limited to one direction, and is a fixed entity for the entire bilayer. In conclusion, It was observed that the thickness variation along the width has a larger effect (with direct proportionality) on the radius, cone angle and pitch variation, as compared to the strain variation (with inverse proportionality). 2.4 Effects of strain gradient along the length In this section, we present the results corresponding to the case of a bilayer film subjected to variation of strain along the length of the film. The values of strain at the fixed and the free lateral edges are shown in Fig. 2b. Note that the strain at the free edge is 3% and at the fixed edge is 0.75% with a linear variation. The simulation predicts variable radius as shown in Fig. 9 showing a very good agreement with the analytical solution (equation (1)) (same procedure was followed in calculations as for thickness taper along the length). Here, it can be concluded that the thickness variation along the length has lower effects on the bilayer radius (with direct proportionality) compared with the strain variation along the length (with inverse proportionality). 13 (a) (b) Figure 12: a) Depiction of spiral angle and, b) Location of an extrema along median wave-line path d for different aspect ratios (w/l) from fixed end to free end of an edge's projection plot 3 Conclusions We propose a novel method to fabricate conical tubes based on the same principle of out-of-plane deformation of bilayer thin films. It has been shown that by varying the thickness or strain along the width of the bilayer film, it is possible to obtain conical tubes of different geometrical proper- ties. Detailed analysis on the effects of thickness variation and strain variation along the width is conducted to quantify the geometry of the thus formed cones. It was observed that the cone angle is directly influenced by the taper angle and the strain gradient. The radius of the cone at a given section is influenced by thickness (direct proportionality) and strain (inverse proportionality) at that section. The radius remains constant for a given longitudinal section of uniform thickness in the case of thickness gradient along the width. But in the case of strain gradient along the width, the radius of a given longitudinal section shows an increase in radius from fixed end to free end, which is counter intuitive. The radius change along the width of the film results in the cone angle and the radius change along the length (discussed in the previous sentence) results in spiral angle. The spiral angle appears in the rolled-up geometry of the conical bilayer for the strain variation case alone, due to the non-equi-biaxial nature of the eigenstrains. In the case of thickness variation along the width, we do not observe a spiral angle formation due to the equi-biaxial state of strain. The geometry of the cone is described by helices of constant radius and variable pitch for the thickness variation. In the case of a uniform thickness bilayer film with strain gradient along the width, the helices will be of increasing radius with variable pitch. It has been observed that the strain (or thickness) variation along the length of the film results in the formation of spiral geometry. The work presented here can be helpful in predicting the dimensions of the resultant geomet- 14 rical features of the rolled-up tubes and cones for a given initial geometry of the film and the eigenstrain. Thus, the methodologies int his work may help designers to come up with novel fabrication strategies of micro and nano-scale three dimensional objects from two-dimensional geometries through strain and geometry engineering. References [1] O. G. Schmidt, K. Eberl, Nanotechnology: Thin solid films roll up into nanotubes, Nature 410 (6825) (2001) 168 -- 168. [2] V. Y. Prinz, V. Seleznev, A. Gutakovsky, A. Chehovskiy, V. Preobrazhenskii, M. Putyato, T. Gavrilova, Free-standing and overgrown InGaAs/GaAs nanotubes, nanohelices and their arrays, Physica E: Low-dimensional Systems and Nanostructures 6 (1) (2000) 828 -- 831. [3] L. Zhang, S. Golod, E. Deckardt, V. Prinz, D. Grutzmacher, Free-standing Si/SiGe micro- and nano-objects, Physica E: Low-dimensional Systems and Nanostructures 23 (3) (2004) 280 -- 284. [4] O. Schmidt, C. Deneke, Y. Manz, C. Muller, Semiconductor tubes, rods and rings of nanometer and micrometer dimension, Physica E: Low-dimensional Systems and Nanos- tructures 13 (2) (2002) 969 -- 973. [5] L. Zhang, E. Ruh, D. Grutzmacher, L. Dong, D. J. Bell, B. J. Nelson, C. Schonenberger, Anomalous coiling of SiGe/Si and SiGe/Si/Cr helical nanobelts, Nano Letters 6 (7) (2006) 1311 -- 1317. [6] Z. Chen, Shape transition and multi-stability of helical ribbons: A finite element method study, Archive of Applied Mechanics 85 (3) (2015) 331 -- 338. [7] I. W. Hamley, A. Dehsorkhi, V. Castelletto, S. Furzeland, D. Atkins, J. Seitsonen, J. Ruoko- lainen, Reversible helical unwinding transition of a self-assembling peptide amphiphile, Soft Matter 9 (39) (2013) 9290 -- 9293. [8] A. I. Fedorchenko, A.-B. Wang, V. I. Mashanov, W.-P. Huang, H. H. Cheng, Strain-induced wrinkling on SiGe free standing film, Applied Physics Letters 89 (4) (2006) 043119. [9] D. J. Bell, L. Dong, B. J. Nelson, M. Golling, L. Zhang, D. Grutzmacher, Fabrication and characterization of three-dimensional InGaAs/GaAs nanosprings, Nano Letters 6 (4) (2006) 725 -- 729. [10] P. Cendula, S. Kiravittaya, Y. Mei, C. Deneke, O. Schmidt, Bending and wrinkling as com- peting relaxation pathways for strained free-hanging films, Physical Review B 79 (8) (2009) 085429. [11] A. A. Solovev, W. Xi, D. H. Gracias, S. M. Harazim, C. Deneke, S. Sanchez, O. G. Schmidt, Self-propelled nanotools, ACS Nano 6 (2) (2012) 1751 -- 1756. 15 [12] T. Kipp, H. Welsch, C. Strelow, C. Heyn, D. Heitmann, Optical modes in semiconductor microtube ring resonators, Physical Review Letters 96 (7) (2006) 077403. [13] F. Li, Z. Mi, S. Vicknesh, Coherent emission from ultrathin-walled spiral InGaAs/GaAs quantum dot microtubes, Optics Letters 34 (19) (2009) 2915 -- 2917. [14] V. A. B. Quinones, L. Ma, S. Li, M. Jorgensen, S. Kiravittaya, O. G. Schmidt, Enhanced optical axial confinement in asymmetric microtube cavities rolled up from circular-shaped nanomembranes, Optics Letters 37 (20) (2012) 4284 -- 4286. [15] L. Baraban, M. Tasinkevych, M. Popescu, S. Sanchez, S. Dietrich, O. Schmidt, Transport of cargo by catalytic Janus micro-motors, Soft Matter 8 (1) (2012) 48 -- 52. [16] A. Fennimore, T. Yuzvinsky, W.-Q. Han, M. Fuhrer, J. Cumings, A. Zettl, Rotational actu- ators based on carbon nanotubes, Nature 424 (6947) (2003) 408 -- 410. [17] Y. Mei, A. A. Solovev, S. Sanchez, O. G. Schmidt, Rolled-up nanotech on polymers: From basic perception to self-propelled catalytic microengines, Chemical Society Reviews 40 (5) (2011) 2109 -- 2119. [18] A. A. Solovev, Y. Mei, E. Berm´udez Urena, G. Huang, O. G. Schmidt, Catalytic microtubu- lar jet engines self-propelled by accumulated gas bubbles, Small 5 (14) (2009) 1688 -- 1692. [19] Z. Chen, G. Huang, I. Trase, X. Han, Y. Mei, Mechanical self-assembly of a strain- engineered flexible layer: wrinkling, rolling, and twisting, Physical Review Applied 5 (1) (2016) 017001. [20] G. Nikishkov, I. Khmyrova, V. Ryzhii, Finite element analysis of self-positioning mi- crostructures and nanostructures, Nanotechnology 14 (7) (2003) 820. [21] W. Huang, S. Koric, X. Yu, K. J. Hsia, X. Li, Precision structural engineering of self- rolled-up 3D nanomembranes guided by transient quasi-static FEM modeling, Nano Letters 14 (11) (2014) 6293 -- 6297. [22] I. S. Chun, A. Challa, B. Derickson, K. J. Hsia, X. Li, Geometry effect on the strain-induced self-rolling of semiconductor membranes, Nano Letters 10 (10) (2010) 3927 -- 3932. [23] S. Alben, B. Balakrisnan, E. Smela, Edge effects determine the direction of bilayer bending, Nano Letters 11 (6) (2011) 2280 -- 2285. [24] V. M. Fomin, M. Hippler, V. Magdanz, L. Soler, S. Sanchez, O. G. Schmidt, Propulsion mechanism of catalytic microjet engines, IEEE Transactions on Robotics 30 (1) (2014) 40 -- 48. [25] W. Gao, S. Sattayasamitsathit, J. Orozco, J. Wang, Highly efficient catalytic microengines: template electrosynthesis of polyaniline/platinum microtubes, Journal of the American Chemical Society 133 (31) (2011) 11862 -- 11864. 16 [26] E. Reissner, The effect of transverse shear deformation on the bending of elastic plates, J. Appl. Mech. (AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS: ASME) 12 (1945) 69 -- 77. [27] R. Mindlin, Influence of rotatory inertia and shear on flexural motions of isotropic, elastic plates, J. Appl. Mech. 18 (1951) 31. [28] L. D. Landau, E. Lifshitz, Theory of Elasticity, vol. 3, Oxford : Butterworth-Heinemann, 3rd English edn., 978-0750626330, 1986. [29] D. S. Simulia, Abaqus 6.12 documentation, Providence, Rhode Island, US . [30] W. N. Sharpe, B. Yuan, R. Vaidyanathan, R. L. Edwards, Measurements of Young's mod- ulus, Poisson's ratio, and tensile strength of polysilicon, in: Micro Electro Mechanical Systems, 1997. MEMS'97, Proceedings, IEEE., Tenth Annual International Workshop on, IEEE, 424 -- 429, 1997. [31] G. P. Nikishkov, Curvature estimation for multilayer hinged structures with initial strains, Journal of Applied Physics 94 (8) (2003) 5333 -- 5336. [32] S. Krivoshapko, V. Ivanov, Encyclopedia of analytical surfaces, Springer, 2015. 17
1808.05507	1	1808	2018-08-16T14:23:41	Design-oriented Modeling of 28 nm FDSOI CMOS Technology down to 4.2 K for Quantum Computing	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mes-hall", "quant-ph" ]	In this paper a commercial 28-nm FDSOI CMOS technology is characterized and modeled from room temperature down to 4.2 K. Here we explain the influence of incomplete ionization and interface traps on this technology starting from the fundamental device physics. We then illustrate how these phenomena can be accounted for in circuit device-models. We find that the design-oriented simplified EKV model can accurately predict the impact of the temperature reduction on the transfer characteristics, back-gate sensitivity, and transconductance efficiency. The presented results aim at extending industry-standard compact models to cryogenic temperatures for the design of cryo- CMOS circuits implemented in a 28 nm FDSOI technology.	physics.app-ph	physics	Design-oriented Modeling of 28 nm FDSOI CMOS Technology down to 4.2 K for Quantum Computing Arnout Beckers†, Farzan Jazaeri†, Heorhii Bohuslavskyi‡, Louis Hutin‡, Silvano De Franceschi‡, and Christian Enz† †Integrated Circuits Laboratory (ICLAB), Ecole Polytechnique F´ed´erale de Lausanne (EPFL), Switzerland, ‡CEA-L´eti, Grenoble, France [email protected] 8 1 0 2 g u A 6 1 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 7 0 5 5 0 . 8 0 8 1 : v i X r a Abstract -- In this paper a commercial 28-nm FDSOI CMOS technology is characterized and modeled from room temperature down to 4.2 K. Here we explain the influence of incomplete ionization and interface traps on this technology starting from the fundamental device physics. We then illustrate how these phenomena can be accounted for in circuit device-models. We find that the design-oriented simplified EKV model can accurately predict the impact of the temperature reduction on the transfer characteristics, back-gate sensitivity, and transconductance effi- ciency. The presented results aim at extending industry-standard compact models to cryogenic temperatures for the design of cryo- CMOS circuits implemented in a 28 nm FDSOI technology. I. INTRODUCTION Quantum computing can reshape many fields by providing the computing power to solve exponentially-growing prob- lems. To reach this computing power, an important challenge today is the scale-up to larger qubit numbers [1], [2]. Each ad- ditional qubit adds to the complexity of the room-temperature control-equipment, introducing more interconnections, wiring capacitance and thermal-noise pickup. Implementing the con- trol equipment in miniaturized cryo-CMOS represents an interesting solution for scalability and fast qubit-information processing. Digital, analog and RF circuits are then required to operate down to deep-cryogenic temperatures. In this context, silicon-on-insulator technology provides an excellent platform to create a complete, scalable quantum computing system [3], [4]. CMOS-compatible spin qubits have been developed in a FDSOI nanowire technology [5], [6], and can be co-integrated with the required qubit-control circuits designed in a FDSOI CMOS process. Increased digital/analog performances down to 4.2 K have been reported for advanced FDSOI CMOS technologies [7], [8]. The suitability of the 28 nm node for qubit-control electronics has been reported in [7]. Furthermore, the FDSOI back-gate offers a versatile tool to control the power consumption close to the qubits [7], which may become essential to keep decoherence at bay in co-integrated quantum- classical circuits. Due to a strong reduction of the cooling power at millikelvin temperatures, the control circuits are envisioned to operate at 4.2 K or higher -- and eventually the qubits as well [2]. However, designing the cryo-CMOS qubit- control circuits -- while meeting a stringent speed-power trade- This project has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 Research & Innovation Programme under grant agreement No. 688539 MOS- Quito. INVESTIGATED DEVICES (28-NM FDSOI CMOS PROCESS) TABLE I Symbol G L M I N Type nMOS pMOS nMOS nMOS nMOS W/L 1 µm / 1 µm 1 µm / 1 µm 1 µm / 28 nm 210 nm / 28 nm 80 nm / 28 nm off -- is not an easy task, since cryo-CMOS device models are currently lacking in circuit-simulators. In order to keep pace with the rapid qubit-developments, device models remaining physically accurate down to 4.2 K are urgently required. To this purpose, important physical phenomena at deep-cryogenic temperatures, i.e. interface trapping and incomplete ionization, need to be included. Here, after a brief discussion of the measurement results down to 4.2 K, the temperature-trends of the main technological parameters are investigated (Sec. II). To explain some of these trends, we examine the temperature dependencies of interface trapping and incomplete ionization in the device physics of this technology (Sec. III). It will be evidenced that these phenomena can respectively alter the slope factor and the threshold voltage. As we will demonstrate, adjusting the corresponding model parameters in the design- oriented simplified EKV model, allows to model the DC cryogenic device-performance down to 4.2 K, including the effect of the back-gate (Sec. IV). These results pave the way towards the extension of industry-standard compact models down to the deep-cryogenic temperature regime [9], [10]. This will allow to explore optimal cryo-CMOS circuit designs for multiple applications, in particular qubit-control systems. II. MEASUREMENTS AND CHARACTERIZATION The set of devices under investigation, fabricated in a commercial 28 nm FDSOI CMOS process, is listed in Table I. Details on the fabrication procedure can be found in [7]. A schematic cross-section of the FDSOI nMOS transistor is drawn in Fig. 1a. The transfer characteristics were measured in the linear (VDS = 50 mV) and saturation operational regimes (VDS = 0.9 V) at different temperatures [7]. The back-gate voltage (Vback) is swept from −0.9 V to 0.9 V. Figs. 1b-f show the transfer characteristics in saturation at Vback= 0 V. The strong improvement of the SS with decreasing tem- perature is clear for all devices in Fig. 1. However, note Fig. 1. a) Schematic cross-section of a nMOS device fabricated in a 28 nm FDSOI CMOS process [7], b)-f) Transfer characteristics measured in saturation (VDS = 0.9 V) with Vback= 0 V, at 300, 210, 160, 110, 77. 36, 10, and 4.2 K for b) nMOS W/L = 1 µm / 1 µm, c) nMOS W/L = 1 µm / 28 nm, d) pMOS W/L = 1 µm / 1 µm, e) nMOS W/L = 210 nm / 28 nm, and f) nMOS W/L = 80 nm / 28 nm. The EOT for nMOS is 1.55 nm, and for pMOS 1.7 nm. The gate-source voltage is increased with a step size of VGS = 5 mV. Colors indicate the temperature, and markers the device according to Table I. that the improvement from 36 K down to 4.2 K is marginal, especially for the short devices. Based on the measurements in Fig. 1, the following technological parameters have been extracted (Fig. 2): the subthreshold swing (SS), slope factor (n), threshold voltage (Vth), transconductance in linear and saturation (Gm,lin, Gm,sat), and the on-state current (Ion). As illustrated in Fig. 2a, for temperatures below ≈ 160 K, the extracted average SS-values show an increasing offset, ∆SS, from the thermal limit, UT ln 10, with UT (cid:44) kT /q the thermal voltage. ∆SS reaches around 10 mV/dec at 4.2 K for long nMOS, since UT ln 10 predicts ≈ 0.8 mV/dec. The necessary slope factors to reach such high SS are extracted in Fig. 2b using n = SS/(UT ln 10). From this figure, a hyperbolic temperature-dependency of n is evident, which is not strongly dependent on geometry at cryogenic temperatures. The data points below 77 K in Fig. 2a cannot be explained by n0UT ln 10 with a slope-factor n0 limited by 2, according to n0 = 1 + Cdep/Cox, where Cdep is the depletion capaci- tance and Cox the oxide capacitance. Moreover, including the interface-trap capacitance, Cit = qNit, i.e. n0 = 1 + (Cdep + Cit)/Cox with Nit the density-of-interface-traps per unit area, would lead to very high extracted values for Nit in the order of 1013 cm−2 at 4.2 K [11] -- [13]. However, it should be emphasized that in this n0-formula the temperature-dependent occupation of interface-traps is not taken into account. This will be further investigated in Sec. III. The shift in threshold voltage at 4.2 K with respect to room temperature increases in the order of 0.1−0.3 V (Fig. 2c). Note that the largest Vth- increase is observed for pMOS, similarly to a 28-nm bulk process [14]. Furthermore, the maximum Gm,sat and Gm,lin (Figs.2d-e) improve down to 4.2 K, e.g. respectively × 3.4 (linear) and × 1.8 (saturation) for nMOS W/L = 1 µm / 1 µm. In Fig.2f, Ion is extracted at VGS = 1 V. Note that the actual trend of Ion with temperature is strongly dependent on the bias and the device-type. At a standard supply-voltage of 1 V, the on-state current increases with decreasing temperature for long nMOS (Fig. 1b), while it decreases for pMOS (Fig. 1d). The drain-induced barrier-lowering (DIBL) is approximately zero for the long devices. For the short devices, small im- provements have been extracted down to 4.2 K, but the short- channel effect remains largely temperature-independent, e.g. decreasing from 0.07 V/V (300 K) to 0.068 V/V (4.2 K) for nMOS W/L =80 nm / 28 nm, and from 0.065 V/V (300 K) to 0.059 V/V (4.2 K) for nMOS W/L =210 nm / 28 nm (ex- tracted at ID = 10−8 A). III. DEVICE PHYSICS The improvements of (SS, Gm,sat, Gm,lin) and the increase in Vth follow directly from the temperature-scaling of the Fermi-Dirac distribution function, f (E). As illustrated in Fig. 3a, at 4.2 K f (E) is almost a step function. Therefore, the conduction band needs to be bent further downward to create sufficient overlap with the conduction-band density-of-states to reach inversion, increasing Vth. Note that the subthreshold region happens only when EF lies within ≈ 3UT of Ec. However, as indicated by ∆SS in the previous section, the turn-on rate predicted in this way is too steep. In what follows, we investigate the impact of incomplete ionization/freeze- out and interface trapping to explain this observation. Both phenomena are modeled by the Fermi-Dirac distribution as a)c)b)T (K)3004.2d)f)e)T (K)3004.2T (K)3004.2T (K)3004.2T (K)3004.2n+Buried oxiden+p+pVGVDVSVbackSiyFig. 2. Technological parameter extraction at 300, 210, 160, 110, 77. 36, 10, and 4.2 K, a) Subthreshold swing, modeled for long-channel devices by SS = n0UT ln 10 + ∆SS, with ∆SS ∝ Nit [15], [16], b) Slope factor in log-log scale highlighting its hyperbolic temperature dependency, c) Threshold- voltage shift with respect to 300 K, d)-e) Maximum transconductances in saturation and linear regions of operation, normalized to 300 K, f) On-state current normalized to 300 K. Colors indicate the temperature, and markers the device according to Table I. well, i.e. respectively f (EA) (for p-type doping) and f (Et), where EA and Et are the acceptor and trap energy levels. This is qualitatively shown in Fig.3a. In case the Si-channel (Fig. 1a) is truly undoped, incomplete ionization should not be considered. However, if there is a certain background doping, e.g. p-type NA = 1015 cm−3, these impurities can be frozen out in the flatband condition at 4.2 K. As shown in Fig.3a, the calculated EF -position for low-doped channel at 4.2 K lies under EA, leading to freeze-out (f (EA) (cid:28) 1). these impurities will become quickly ionized Nonetheless, due to field-assisted ionization [17], when EA bends under EF near the surface of the front-gate. In the subthreshold region, when EF ≈ Ec − 3UT , complete ionization can be assumed. Therefore, incomplete ionization cannot lead to the subthreshold-swing degradation observed in the previous sec- tion. Note, however, that for non-zero doping concentrations incomplete ionization can yield a small change in the threshold voltage, due to a modification of the charge-neutrality and the resulting EF -position [16]. Fig. 3a highlights that the temperature-dependency of interface-trap occupation, f (Et), may influence the turn-on rate of the device down to 4.2 K. Similarly to the derivation for bulk MOSFET presented in [16], by including f (Et) the temperature dependency of n ∝ 1/UT can be derived for the front-gate in FDSOI as well. This gives SS = n(T )UT ln 10 = n0UT ln 10 + ∆SS, where n0 is the slope factor without interface traps, and ∆SS the subthreshold-swing offset as observed in the previous section. ∆SS is given by (qNit/Cox) ln 10(cid:2)gt/(1 + gt)2(cid:3) with Nit the density-of-interface-traps and gt the trap degeneracy factor. in this model, Nit does not become multiplied Note that with UT , resulting in reasonable extracted values for Nit at 4.2 K (≈ 1011-1012 cm−2) lower than [12], [13]. The ∆SS- offset starts to increase below ≈ 160 K since the subthreshold region happens when EF lies closer to Ec, where Nit is observed to be higher already at 300 K (Fig. 3a). From this section, we conclude that interface trapping strongly degrades the SS through the hyperbolic temperature-dependency of n, and incomplete ionization slightly alters the Vth-increase for non-zero doping concentrations. These two parameters, n and Vth, can be modified accordingly in design-oriented models to predict deep-cryogenic operation. In the next section we demonstrate this relying on the simplified EKV model. IV. DESIGN-ORIENTED MODELING The design-oriented simplified EKV model is described in detail in [18]. The suitability of this model for FDSOI processes has been assessed at room temperature [19]. Using this model, the effects of the temperature reduction down to 4.2 K on the transfer characteristics, the back-gate sensitivity, and the transconductance efficiency are modeled. The model accurately predicts the transfer characteristics down to 4.2 K for long (Figs. 3b-c) and short devices (Fig.3d). The strong increase in the n model parameter at 4.2 K accounts for the interface-trapping phenomenon. The VT 0 model parameter captures the change in the threshold voltage due to Fermi- Dirac scaling and incomplete ionization. Note that the used values for n and VT 0 correspond to the extracted values in Fig. 2b and 2c. Furthermore, as illustrated in Fig. 3e, changing the VT 0 model parameter allows to capture the effect of the a)b)c)d)e)f)UTln10ΔSS∝1TFig. 3. Band diagram along the y-direction in Fig. 1a. The position of the Fermi-level, EF , is calculated at 4.2 K in the case of undoped and low-doped channel, including incomplete ionization and bandgap widening at 4.2 K. The simulated Fermi-Dirac distribution at 4.2 K is plotted for both cases. The temperature-dependent occupation of the interface traps, f (Et), can degrade the subthreshold swing. Due to band bending of EA under EF at the front-gate, frozen-out impurities under the surface become completely ionized (f (EA) = 1), long before subthreshold is reached (EF ≈ Ec − 3UT ) due to field-assisted ionization. b)-e) Simplified EKV (solid lines) for b) nMOS W/L = 1 µm / 1 µm, c) pMOS W/L = 1 µm / 1 µm, and d) nMOS W/L = 1 µm / 28 nm at 300, 77, and 4.2 K (markers) for Vback=0 V. The model parameters, n, VT 0 (threshold voltage), Ispec(cid:3) (specific-current-per-square), and Lsat (saturation length), are shown. e) Back-gate sensitivity at 4.2 K modeled with simplified EKV. The model is shown for Vback=−0.9 V and 0.9 V with solid lines. Markers and dashed lines indicate measurements at 4.2 K, f) Normalized transconductance efficiency versus the inversion coefficient, IC, at 300 and 4.2 K. back-gate also at 4.2 K [19]. A small adjustment of the slope factor is necessary as well, to account for the change in SS in- duced by the back-gate. Fig.3f verifies that the Gm/ID design- methodology remains valid for a 28 nm FDSOI technology down to 4.2 K. The normalized transconductance efficiency, GmnUT /ID, is plotted versus the inversion coefficient IC (cid:44) T . ID,sat/Ispec, with Ispec = Ispec(cid:3)W/L = 2(W/L)nµCoxU 2 The specific-current-per-square, Ispec(cid:3), decreases over one order of magnitude from room temperature down to 4.2 K. For the short-channel device, the additional Lsat-parameter, which denotes the length of the channel in full velocity saturation, decreases down to 4.2 K due to a reduced phonon scattering. V. CONCLUSION In this work, the DC operation of a 28 nm FDSOI tech- nology is modeled down to 4.2 K by means of the simplified EKV model. A study of the device physics is first performed including the temperature dependencies of interface trapping and incomplete ionization. We find that the Fermi-Dirac temperature dependency of interface-trap occupation explains the large degradation of the subthreshold swing at 4.2 K. In case impurities are present, freeze-out is of minor importance for device operation thanks to field-assisted ionization. These results bring us one step closer to the realization of large-scale silicon-based quantum computing systems. REFERENCES [1] C. G. Almudever, L. Lao et al., "The engineering challenges in quantum computing," in Design, Automation Test in Europe Conference Exhibi- tion (DATE), 2017, March 2017, pp. 836 -- 845. [2] L. M. K. Vandersypen, H. Bluhm et al., "Interfacing spin qubits in quantum dots and donors: hot, dense, and coherent," npj Quantum Information, vol. 3, no. 1, p. 34, Sep. 2017. [3] S. R. Ekanayake, T. Lehmann et al., "Characterization of SOS-CMOS FETs at Low Temperatures for the Design of Integrated Circuits for Quantum Bit Control and Readout," IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 539 -- 547, Feb. 2010. [4] S. D. Franceschi, L. Hutin et al., "SOI technology for quantum informa- tion processing," in 2016 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), Dec. 2016, pp. 13.4.1 -- 13.4.4. [5] R. Maurand, X. Jehl et al., "A CMOS silicon spin qubit," Nature Communications, vol. 7, p. 13575, Nov. 2016. [6] L. Hutin, R. Maurand et al., "Si CMOS platform for quantum informa- tion processing," in 2016 IEEE Symposium on VLSI Technology, June 2016, pp. 1 -- 2. [7] H. Bohuslavskyi, S. Barraud et al., "28nm Fully-depleted SOI technol- ogy: Cryogenic control electronics for quantum computing," in 2017 Silicon Nanoelectronics Workshop (SNW), 2017, pp. 143 -- 144. [8] F. Balestra and G. Ghibaudo, "Physics and performance of nanoscale semiconductor devices at cryogenic temperatures," Semiconductor Sci- ence and Technology, vol. 32, no. 2, p. 023002, 2017. [9] T. Poiroux, O. Rozeau et al., "Leti-UTSOI2.1: A Compact Model for UTBB-FDSOI Technologies Part II: DC and AC Model Description," IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, Sep. 2015. [10] S. Khandelwal, Y. S. Chauhan et al., "BSIM-IMG: A Compact Model for Ultrathin-Body SOI MOSFETs With Back-Gate Control," IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, vol. 59, pp. 2019 -- 2026, 2012. [11] T. Elewa, F. Balestra et al., "Performance and physical mechanisms in SIMOX MOS transistors operated at very low temperature," IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, vol. 37, pp. 1007 -- 1019, April 1990. 4.2 K300 KLsat3004.2300774.2300774.2e)f)a)c)b)d)EcEDEAEvf(EA)EiEtBuried oxidef(E)4.2 KyEF (undoped)EF (NA=1015 cm−3)0Et1[12] R. Trevisoli, M. de Souza et al., "Junctionless nanowire transistors operation at temperatures down to 4.2 K," Semiconductor Science and Technology, 2016. [13] I. M. Hafez, G. Ghibaudo, and F. Balestra, "Assessment of interface state density in silicon MOS transistors at room, liquid nitrogen, and liquid helium temperatures," Journal of Applied Physics, no. 4, 1990. [14] A. Beckers, F. Jazaeri et al., "Cryogenic characterization of 28 nm bulk CMOS technology for quantum computing," in 47th European Solid- State Device Research Conference (ESSDERC), Sept 2017, pp. 62 -- 65. [15] A. Beckers, F. Jazaeri, and C. Enz, "Characterization and Modeling of 28 nm Bulk CMOS Technology down to 4.2 K," IEEE Journal of the Electron Devices Society, pp. 1 -- 1, 2018. [16] A. Beckers, F. Jazaeri, and C. Enz, "Cryogenic MOS Transistor Model," IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, pp. 1 -- 9, 2018. [17] D. P. Foty, "Impurity ionization in MOSFETs at very low temperatures," Cryogenics, vol. 30, no. 12, pp. 1056 -- 1063, 1990. [18] C. Enz, F. Chicco, and A. Pezzotta, "Nanoscale MOSFET Modeling: Part 1: The Simplified EKV Model for the Design of Low-Power Analog Circuits," IEEE Solid-State Circuits Magazine, vol. 9, no. 3, 2017. [19] A. Pezzotta, F. Jazaeri et al., "A design-oriented charge-based simplified model for FDSOI MOSFETs," in 2018 Joint International EUROSOI Workshop and International Conference on Ultimate Integration on Silicon (EUROSOI-ULIS), March 2018, pp. 1 -- 4.
1910.13760	1	1910	2019-10-30T10:36:07	Stereocomplexation of Poly(Lactic Acid)s on Graphite Nanoplatelets: from Functionalized Nanoparticles to Self-Assembled Nanostructures	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci" ]	The control of nanostructuration of graphene and graphene related materials (GRM) into self-assembled structures is strictly related to the nanoflakes chemical functionalization, which may be obtained via covalent grafting of non-covalent interactions, mostly exploiting {\pi}-stacking. As the non-covalent functionalization does not affect the sp2 carbon structure, this is often exploited to preserve the thermal and electrical properties of the GRM and it is a well-known route to tailor the interaction between GRM and organic media. In this work, non-covalent functionalization of graphite nanoplatelets (GnP) was carried out with ad-hoc synthesized pyrene-terminated oligomers of polylactic acid (PLA), aiming at the modification of GnP nanopapers thermal properties. PLA was selected based on the possibility to self-assemble in crystalline domains via stereocomplexation of complementary poly(L-lactide) (PLLA) and poly(D-lactide) (PDLA) enantiomers. Pyrene-initiated PLLA and PDLA were indeed demonstrated to anchor to the GnP surface. Calorimetric and X-ray diffraction investigations highlighted the enantiomeric PLAs adsorbed on the surface of the nanoplatelets self-organize to produce highly crystalline stereocomplex domains. Most importantly, PLLA/PDLA stereocomplexation delivered a significantly higher efficiency in nanopapers heat transfer, in particular through the thickness of the nanopaper. This is explained by a thermal bridging effect of crystalline domains between overlapped GnP, promoting heat transfer across the nanoparticles contacts. This work demonstrates the possibility to enhance the physical properties of contacts within a percolating network of GRM via the self-assembly of macromolecules and opens a new way for the engineering of GRM-based nanostructures.	physics.app-ph	physics	Stereocomplexation of Poly(Lactic Acid)s on Graphite Nanoplatelets: from Functionalized Nanoparticles to Self-Assembled Nanostructures. Matteo Eleuteri a, Mar Bernal a, Marco Milanesiob, Orietta Monticelli c,Alberto Fina a, a- Dipartimento di Scienza Applicata e Tecnologia, Politecnico di Torino, Sede di Alessandria, Viale T. b- Dipartimento di Scienze e Innovazione Tecnologica, Università degli Studi del Piemonte Orientale, c- Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale, Università di Genova, Via Dodecaneso, 31, 16146 Viale T. Michel 11, Alessandria, Italy Michel 5, Alessandria, Italy Genova, Italy *corresponding authors: [email protected]; [email protected] Abstract The control of nanostructuration of graphene and graphene related materials (GRM) into self- assembled structures is strictly related to the nanoflakes chemical functionalization, which may be obtained via covalent grafting of non-covalent interactions, mostly exploiting π-stacking. As the non- covalent functionalization does not affect the sp2 carbon structure, this is often exploited to preserve the thermal and electrical properties of the GRM and it is a well-known route to tailor the interaction between GRM and organic media. In this work, non-covalent functionalization of graphite nanoplatelets (GnP) was carried out with ad-hoc synthesized pyrene-terminated oligomers of polylactic acid (PLA), aiming at the modification of GnP nanopapers thermal properties. PLA was selected based on the possibility to self-assemble in crystalline domains via stereocomplexation of complementary poly(L-lactide) (PLLA) and poly(D-lactide) (PDLA) enantiomers. Pyrene-initiated PLLA and PDLA were indeed demonstrated to anchor to the GnP surface. Calorimetric and X-ray diffraction investigations highlighted the enantiomeric PLAs adsorbed on the surface of the nanoplatelets self-organize to produce highly crystalline stereocomplex domains. Most importantly, PLLA/PDLA stereocomplexation delivered a significantly higher efficiency in nanopapers heat transfer, in particular through the thickness of the nanopaper. This is explained by a thermal bridging effect of crystalline domains between overlapped GnP, promoting heat transfer across the nanoparticles contacts. This work demonstrates the possibility to enhance the physical properties of contacts within a percolating network of GRM via the self-assembly of macromolecules and opens a new way for the engineering of GRM-based nanostructures. Keywords: PLA Stereocomplex, Graphite Nanoplatelets, Interfacial Thermal Resistance, Thermal Bridging, Non-covalent Functionalization. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Introduction Graphene and graphene-related materials (GRM) are one of the most intensively explored nanoparticles family in materials science owing to their superior properties.(Geim and Novoselov, 2007; Gómez-Navarro et al., 2007; Lee et al., 2008; Stoller et al., 2008; Balandin and Nika, 2012) In particular, graphene oxide (GO), reduced graphene oxide (RGO), multilayer graphene (MLG) and graphite nanoplatelets (GnP) attracted a wide research attention in the last decade.(Ferrari et al., 2015) Their peculiar mechanical, electrical and thermal properties make GRM ideal platforms for the construction of sophisticated nanostructured systems, which fabrication requires precise control of graphene chemistry, including chemical modifications with specific functional groups.(Rodriguez- Perez et al., 2013) In this field, the organic functionalization of GRM has led to the manufacturing of high-performance multifunctional graphene-based materials where covalent and non-covalent bonding provides bridges between adjacent layers.(Meng et al., 2013; Wan et al., 2018) However, the covalent attachment of any functional group affects the thermal and electronic properties of GRM because of the perturbation of their aromatic character. Therefore, the supramolecular functionalization is often preferable as it may preserve the structure and properties of non-oxidized GRM, while it simultaneously enables the attachment of specific organic moieties, through π-stacking or hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions.(Zhang et al., 2007; Choi et al., 2010; Liu et al., 2010; Cheng et al., 2012; Hsiao et al., 2013; Ji et al., 2015; Georgakilas et al., 2016) In particular, π-π stacking interactions between GRM and polyaromatic hydrocarbons, such as pyrene, perylene, hexabenzocoronene, have been widely investigated and validated for the preparation of GRM-based materials. (Björk et al., 2010; Georgakilas et al., 2012; Parviz et al., 2012; Hirsch et al., 2013; Wang et al., 2014) Non-covalent functionalization of GRM may indeed be exploited to tailor interfaces between nanoplatelets and the surrounding organic media or to control interfaces within GRM networks. Compatibilization between GRM nanoplatelets and organic polymers have been widely studied to promote dispersion in the preparation of nanocomposites as well as to tailor their physical properties. (Kuilla et al., 2010; Potts et al., 2011; Mittal, 2014; Papageorgiou et al., 2017) Polyaromatic derivatives, mostly based on pyrene or perylene substituted with a dangling chain able to compatibilize towards the organic polymer have been largely studied, including the functionalization of GRM with polymers bearing pyrene groups.(Jingquan et al., 2010; Liang et al., 2012; Tong et al., 2013; Wang et al., 2015; Fina et al., 2018) ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ On the other hand, the modification of interfaces between GRM nanoplatelets within their percolating network is currently of high interest to enhance mechanical, electrical and thermal performance in GRM aerogels, foams and nanopapers. In particular, thermal properties of GRM nanopapers have attracted a significant research interest for the application as flexible heat spreaders. (Shen et al., 2014; Song et al., 2014; Xin et al., 2014; Renteria et al., 2015; Bernal et al., 2017; Bernal et al., 2018) However, the application of GRM based nanopapers is typically limited by their low mechanical resistance and brittleness. The incorporation of a limited amount of polymers into GRM nanopapers may enhance their toughness and deformability, while decreasing the heat transfer efficiency of the nanopaper, as polymers are well known for their typically low thermal conductivity. However, as the thermal conductivity of polymers is strongly dependent on chain orientation (Singh et al., 2014; Chen et al., 2016) and crystallinity (Choy et al., 1993; Ronca et al., 2017), the possibility to control local orientation and crystallization of macromolecules at the surface of GRM currently appears as a fascinating route to produce mechanically strong and high thermal conductivity nanostructures. Several polymers have been shown to effectively nucleate on GRM(Ferreira et al., 2013; Manafi et al., 2014; Bidsorkhi et al., 2017; Colonna et al., 2017b), despite the self-organization of highly ordered crystalline domains onto the surface of GRM remains challenging. An interesting option to self-assemble crystalline domains is via stereocomplexation of complementary polymer enantiomers. For instance, polylactic acid (PLA) has two optically active enantiomers because of the chiral nature of the monomer: poly(L-lactide) (PLLA) and poly(D-lactide) (PDLA). PLLA and PDLA are able to co-crystallize into racemic stereocomplexes (SC), which have been studied mostly for their higher thermal stability and superior physical properties than the homocrystals of the homopolymers.(Tsuji et al., 1992; Tsuji, 2005; Hirata and Kimura, 2008) The incorporation of small amounts of GRM and functionalized GRM in PLLA/PDLA blends was also shown to promote the intermolecular coupling between the enantiomers, thus acting as nucleating agents for the stereocomplex.(Sun and He, 2012; Wu et al., 2013; Gardella et al., 2015; Xu et al., 2015; Xu et al., 2016; Yang et al., 2016; Zhang et al., 2017) In this work, we report a facile approach to promote PLA SC formation onto the surface of GnP, exploiting the denser chain packing in the SC structure(Anderson and Hillmyer, 2006; Xu et al., 2006) to modify the physical properties of the contact between graphite nanoplatelets. Pyrene-end functionalized enantiomeric PLAs with low molecular weight were synthesized and used to supramolecularly modify GnP. Then, stereocomplexation of the PLLA and PDLA anchored to the GnP surface was carried out, to produce highly crystalline domains acting as junctions between ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ nanoplatelets. Results obtained demonstrated the promotion of the intermolecular coupling between the enantiomeric PLAs adsorbed on the surface of the nanoplatelets, leading to the efficient stereocomplexation of the systems. More importantly, the presence of highly crystalline domains from PLLA/PDLA stereocomplexation delivered nanopapers with a higher through-plane efficiency in heat transfer, acting as efficient thermal bridges between overlapped GnP. Experimental Section Materials L-lactide and D-lactide (purity ≥ 98 %) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Before polymerization, both monomers, L-lactide and D-lactide, were purified by three successive re-crystallizations from 100% (w/v) solution in anhydrous toluene and dried under vacuum at room temperature. 1- Pyrenemethanol (Pyr-OH) (purity 98 %) and stannous octanoate, tin(II) 2-ethylhexanoate (Sn(Oct)2, purity ~ 95%) were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich and used as received. All solvents, toluene (anhydrous, purity 99.8 %), chloroform (purity ≥ 99.5 %), methanol (purity ≥ 99.8 %), N-N- dimethylformamide (DMF) (anhydrous, purity 99.8 %) and dimethyl ether (DME) (purity ≥ 99.0 %) were purchased from Sigma Aldrich and used without further purifications. Graphite nanoplatelets (GnP) were synthesized by Avanzare (Navarrete, La Rioja, Spain) according to a previously reported procedure.(Colonna et al., 2017a) In brief, overoxidized-intercalated graphite was prepared starting from natural graphite, followed by rapid thermal expansion of at 1000°C, to produce a worm-like solid, and then mechanically milled to obtain GnP. Synthesis of pyrene-end functionalized PLLA and PDLA (Figure 1a) Pyrene-end functionalized poly(L-lactic acid) (Pyr-L) and pyrene-end functionalized poly(D-lactic acid) (Pyr-D) were synthesized by the ring-opening polymerization (ROP) of monomers, L-lactide and D-lactide, initiated with Pyr-OH and catalyzed by Sn(Oct)2 in bulk at 140°C, as previously reported.(Eleuteri et al., 2018) In detail, L-lactide or D-lactide (5.5 g, 38 mmol) were charged under argon flow into the reactor (i.e., a 50-ml two-neck round-bottomed flask equipped with a magnetic stirrer). Pyr-OH (220 mg, 0.94 mmol) was introduced under argon flow and the flask was evacuated for 15 min and purged with argon; these vacuum/argon cycles were repeated three times in order to thoroughly dry the reactants. The monomer-to-Pyr-OH molar ratio was calculated to obtain an average theoretical molecular weight (Mnth) for Pyr- L or Pyr- D of 7000 g/mol. Then, the reactor ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ vessel was immersed in an oil bath at 140 °C under stirring. Once the reactants were completely melted and homogenized, a freshly prepared solution of Sn(Oct)2 in toluene (271 μL, [lactide]/[ Sn(Oct)2] = 103) was added under argon and the reaction was allowed to proceed under inert atmosphere for 24h. After cooling to room temperature, the reaction was quenched in an ice bath and the crude products were dissolved in chloroform and poured into an excess of cold methanol (2°C). The solid residue was filtered and dried in vacuum at 40 °C. Then, Pyr-L was dissolved in DMF (15 mg mL-1) at 65 °C for 15 min. The solvent was allowed to evaporate at 25°C for 48 hours and the residual solvent was removed by drying at 60 °C for 3 hours. Preparation of Pyr-L/Pyr-D stereocomplex (Figure 1b) Equivalent amounts of Pyr-L and Pyr-D were separately dissolved in DMF (15 mg mL-1) at 65 °C. The solutions were then mixed and stirred at 65 °C for 15 min. The mixed solution was casted on a Petri dish. The solvent was allowed to evaporate at 25°C for 48 hours and the residual solvent was removed by drying at 60 °C for 3 hours. The above-described blends were denoted as Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. It is worth mentioning that both parallel and antiparallel stereocomplex structures may be obtained from the blend of Pyr-L and Pyr-D, as previously reported for similar pyrene-terminated PLA oligomers.(Danko et al., 2018) However, the two structures have very limited differences in cell dimensions(Brizzolara et al., 1996) and interaction energies, so that the two cannot be distinguished by XRD data and thermal analyses and, most importantly, are expected to deliver very similar material properties. Figure 1. (a) Synthesis of Pyr-L and Pyr-D. (b) Schematic illustration of stereocomplex formation from equivalent amounts of Pyr-L and Pyr-D. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Preparation of functionalized GnP Pyr-L (Figure 2a) 100 mg GnP were added to a 100 mL solution of Pyr-L in DMF (0.5 mg·mL-1) and sonicated in pulsed mode (30 s ON and 30 s OFF) for 15 min with power set at 30 % of the full output power (750 W) by using an ultrasonication probe (Sonics Vibracell VCX-750, Sonics & Materials Inc.) with a 13 mm diameter Ti-alloy tip. After that, the suspension was left to stand for 24 hours to ensure the adsorption of the stereoisomer on the basal plane of GnP. Then, the suspension was filtered through a Nylon Supported membrane (0.45 μm nominal pore size, diameter 47 mm, Whatman) and the filtrate analysed by UV-Vis. The filtered cake was re-dispersed in DMF (50 mL), sonicated in an ultrasonication bath for 10 min, filtered and the filtrate analyzed by UV-Vis. The dispersion-filtration cycle was repeated a second time to ensure the completely disappearance of the Pyr-L on the filtrate. Finally, the functionalized GnP were washed with methanol (50 mL) and diethyl ether (50 mL) and dried at 60 °C for 24 hours. Preparation of functionalized GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC (Figure 2b and c) Functionalized GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC were prepared following two different methods. In the first method (Figure 2b), 100 mg GnP was added to a 100 mL DMF solution containing equivalent masses of Pyr-L (25 mg) and Pyr-D (25 mg). The procedure previously described for sonication, filtration and purification of the functionalized GnP Pyr-L was followed and the modified GnP obtained by this method are coded as GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A. In the second method (Figure 2c), two suspensions of GnP Pyr-L and GnP Pyr-D (25 mg of enantiomer and 50 mg GnP in 50 mL DMF) prepared as described previously for GnP Pyr-L were mixed together to obtain a final solution with the same concentrations of enantiomers and GnP as in GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A. The procedure previously described for sonication, filtration and purification was followed and the modified GnP obtained by this method are coded as GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure 2. Preparation of functionalized GnP: a) GnP Pyr-L, b) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A and c) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr- D SC_B. Preparation of GnP and functionalizedGnP nanopapers GnP nanopapers were prepared by suspension of GnP in DMF at a concentration of 0.2 mg mL-1 and the solutions were sonicated as described previously for the preparation of functionalized GnP. Then, GnP nanopapers were prepared by vacuum filtration, dried and mechanically pressed, following the procedure previously reported.(Bernal et al.; Bernal et al., 2017) GnP nanopapers containing the stereocomplexes were prepared following the method described previously for GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A. The total concentrations of Pyr-L and Pyr-D in DMF were 0.1 mg mL-1, while the final concentration of GnP in the solutions was 0.2 mg mL-1. For comparison ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ purposes, two additional nanopapers were prepared for the formation of the stereocomplex, increasing the concentrations of the stereoisomers to 0.2 and 0.4 mg mL-1, denoted as GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ, respectively. Characterization methods All 1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectra were recorded on a NMR Varian Mercury Plus 300 MHz. Samples were dissolved in deuterated chloroform (CDCl3) with TMS as internal reference (chemical shifts δ in ppm). Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) measurements were performed on a DSC Q20 (TA Instruments , USA). Approximately 5 mg of sample were placed in the aluminum pans. The samples were heated from 25 °C to 250 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C min-1 and kept for 1 min to erase the thermal history. Afterwards, the specimens were cooled down to 25 °C, and finally reheated to 250 °C at 10 °C min-1 to evaluate the crystallization and melting behaviour of the samples. For functionalized GnP, the reference aluminum pan was filled with pristine GnP to facilitate the observation of the thermal transitions arising from the Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. Powder X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements for the stereoisomers, the SC crystallites and functionalized GnP were carried out using an X-ray diffractometer (PANalytical X'Pert Pro MPD, Philips PW3040/60) with a Cu Kα radiation source with a wavelength of 1.542 Å. The measurements were operated at 40 kV and 40 mA with scan angles from 5° to 25° at a scan step of 0.026°. XRD measurements on nanopapers were carried out also with a 2D detector, exploiting a a Gemini R Ultra diffractometer. All data were collected using Cu Kα radiation. Data collection and reduction was carried out with CrysAlisPro software, version 1.171.35.11. (Agilent Technologies UK Ltd. Oxford, UK). 2D images were collected with a time from 10 to 30 seconds depending on the 2. The 2D data were then reduced to intensity vs. 2 profiles by the same software, to investigate preferential orientations in the nanopapers and well as to obtain averaged XRD profiles over the whole possible orientations. Thermal gravimetrical analysis (TGA) were performed using a TGA Discovery (TA Instruments, USA) under nitrogen atmosphere from 50 °C to 800 °C at 10 °C min-1. The thermal degradation temperatures were defined as the temperatures corresponding to the maximum DTG peaks, obtained from the first derivative curve of the TGA thermogram. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectra were recorded on a Perkin Elmer Perkin Elmer Frontier spectrometer (Waltham, MA, USA) in the range of 400 -- 4000 cm-1 with 16 scans at a resolution of 4 cm-1. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) were performed on a VersaProbe5000 Physical Electronics X-ray photoelectron spectrometer with a monochromatic Al source and a hemispherical analyzer. Survey scans and high-resolution spectra were recorded with a spot size of 100 μm. The samples were prepared by depositing the GnP powders onto adhesive tape and keeping the samples under vacuum for 15 h prior to the measurement. A Shirley background function was employed to remove the background of the spectra. The morphology of the graphene papers was characterized by a high resolution Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscope (FESEM, ZEISS MERLIN 4248). The density (ρ) of the nanopapers was calculated according to the formula ρ = m/V, where m is the mass of the nanopaper, weighed at room temperature using the TGA microbalance (Sensitivity: < 0.1 µg) and V is calculated from a well-defined disk film using the average thicknesses measured by FESEM. The in-plane thermal diffusivity (α∥) and cross-plane diffusivity (α⊥) were measured using the xenon light flash technique (LFT) (Netzsch LFA 467 Hyperflash). The samples were cut in disks of 23 mm and the measurement of the α∥ was carried out in a special in-plane sample holder while the α⊥ was measured in the standard cross-plane configuration. Each sample was measured five times at 25 °C. Results and Discussion Synthesis of Pyr-L and Pyr-D by ROP and formation of Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC The Pyr-L and Pyr-D synthesized by the ring-opening polymerization of L-lactide and D-lactide using Pyr-OH as initiator have been first characterized for their molar masses. The number average molecular weight (MnNMR) of Pyr-L and Pyr-D was estimated based on the 1H-NMR spectra (Figure S1), using the integral area of the methine protons signals in the PLA chain and next to the terminal hydroxyl group, at δ = 5.16 ppm and δ = 4.35 ppm, respectively. The MnNMR is ca. 7000 g mol-1, which is in accordance to the theoretical number average molecular weight (Mnth) calculated from the monomer-to-Pyr-OH molar ratio, thus confirming the controlled polymerization reaction. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Furthermore, the characteristic absorption bands of pyrene (Figure S2) confirm the presence of the cromophore group in the enantiomers. Crystallization of as-synthesized Pyr-L or Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC was obtained after dissolving the product in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) and left to crystallize. DMF was chosen in this study, allowing for the formation of stereocomplex crystallites and providing sufficient affinity for the subsequent dispersion of graphene nanoplatelets, as the surface tension of DMF (37.1 mJ m-2) is similar to that of graphene.(Hernandez et al., 2008; Coleman et al., 2011) Given the influence of the solvent on the polymorphic crystalline structure of poly(L-lactide)(Marubayashi et al., 2012; 2013) and stereocomplex crystallization of PLA(Tsuji and Yamamoto, 2011; Yang et al., 2017) have been previously reported, for comparison purposes, Pyr-L or Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC crystallizations were also performed in chloroform, being the most common solvent for PLA (result comparison in Supporting Information). The structures of the Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC after crystallization from DMF were corroborated by FTIR spectroscopy (Figure 3). The ν(C=O) band, which is sensitive to the morphology and the conformation of PLA,(Kister et al., 1998) changed after the stereocomplexation, showing a downshift of the signal which is related to the weak hydrogen bond formation between the CH3 groups and the C=O group in the Pyr-L/ Pyr-D SC.(Kister et al., 1998; Zhang et al., 2005; Gonçalves et al., 2010) Furthermore, the CH3 and CH bending region, between 1250 and 1400 cm-1, showed asymmetric and broad bands for Pyr-L compared to Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, being the δ(CH) band high-frequency shift for the stereocomplex (~ 10 cm-1), as previously observed by Kister et al.(Kister et al., 1998) The band at 920 cm−1, observed in Pyr-L and assigned to the α-helix of an enantiomeric PLA, disappeared in and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC and a new band appeared at 909 cm−1 , corresponding to β-helix, characteristic of the stereocomplex, accordingly to previous report by Michalski et al.(Michalski et al., 2018) Finally, after stereocomplexation the ν(C-COO) stretching mode at 872 cm-1 is shifted at higher frequency and appears less asymmetric compared to the corresponding band in Pyr-L spectrum, thus further confirming the successful formation of the stereocomplex crystallites. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure 3. FTIR spectra (500 -- 2250 cm-1 region) of Pyr-L (black) and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC (red) after crystallization in DMF. The stereocomplexation of pyrene-based PLA systems were analyzed by DSC (Figure 4a) and XRD (Figure 4b). The stereoisomers, Pyr-L and Pyr-D, were confirmed to crystallize in the stereocomplex form as demonstrated by the increase of the melting temperature (Tm), from 152.2 °C for Pyr-L to 207.5 °C for Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. Moreover, the formation of the Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC leads to both higher enthalpy of melt crystallization (ΔHm) and high Tm in DMF compared to the stereocomplex formed in chloroform (see Figure S3 and Table S1), evidencing for the crucial role of the solvent in promoting stereocomplexation. Interestingly, no crystallization peak (Tcc) at around 100 °C was observed during the formation of Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC in DMF, which is ascribed to the crystallization during the previous cooling scan.(Bao et al., 2016) Hence, the π-π interactions between pyrene groups in low molecular weight Pyr-L and Pyr-D did not hinder the stereocomplex crystallization,(de Arenaza et al., 2013) as exclusive stereocomplex crystallites are formed in DMF.(Yang et al., 2017) The effect of DMF on the crystallization of Pyr-L and the formation of SC crystallites in Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC were also ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ 2100180015001200900600920 cm-1873 cm-1872 cm-11752 cm-11760 cm-1Pyr-L/ Pyr-D SCPyr-LTransmittance (a.u.)Wavenumber (cm-1)CH and CH3 bending region909 cm-1confirmed by XRD (Figure 4b). In fact, Pyr-L shows the typical diffraction peaks of the stereoisomer at 2θ 14.8°, 16.7°, 19.1° and 22.4°, corresponding to the (010), (110)/(200), (203) and (210) planes. Additionally, the crystalline complex ε-form, induced by the formation of complexes in specific solvents with five-membered ring structure such as DMF,(Marubayashi et al., 2012; 2013) is evidenced by the peak observed at 2θ ≈ 12.4°. Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC formed in DMF exhibits only the diffraction peaks of SC crystallites at 12.1°, 21.1° and 24.0°, thus indicating the exclusive formation of SC crystallites, due to the low vapor pressure of DMF and the dissimilar solubility parameter between solvent and polymer.(Tsuji and Yamamoto, 2011; Yang et al., 2017) Figure 4. a) DSC thermograms of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC recorded during the second heating (10 °C min- 1). b) Powder XRD patterns of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. Supramolecular functionalization of GnP with pyrene-end functionalized PLAs The formation of the stereocomplex in the presence of GnP was investigated using two different approaches: i) sonicating the nanoplatelets in a solution containing both Pyr-L and Pyr-D (Figure 2b) and ii) sonicating separately the GnP with each of the stereoisomers, Pyr-L or Pyr-D, before mixing them to form the stereocomplex (Figure 2c). After that, the products were washed thoroughly to remove any DMF-soluble oligomers unbound to GnP (See Figure S4 in the Supporting Information). The modification of GnP was investigated by XPS (Figure S5), which provides information about the elemental composition and chemical binding states of the samples. Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC were firt analysed, showing signals at ~ 284.9 eV attributed to aliphatic carbons (-CH2, -CH3), at 285.5 eV ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ a)b)10152025(200)(010)(110)/(200)Pyr-L/Pyr-D SCIntensity (a.u.)2 (°)Pyr-L crystal(203)(210)(110)(300)/(030)(220)4080120160200240Pyr-L/Pyr-D SCHeat flow (W/g)Temperature (°C)Pyr-LExo(C-OH), the C-O-C peak at 286.8 eV and the 288.9 eV binding energy of the -C=O. The deconvolution of the C1s spectra of the functionalized GnP are dominated by the peak at 284.4 eV, related to the sp2 C-C bonds and thus the differentiation of the additional aliphatic carbons of the polymer backbone was difficult, suggesting for a limited fraction of PyrL or PyrD onto GnP. However, the O1s spectra (Figure S5b) showed the three bands typical of the composition of PLA (O- C=O at 531.5 eV, C-O-C at 533.0 eV and C-OH at 534.2 eV) reflected in GnP Pyr-L and GnP Pyr- L/Pyr-D SC, evidencing significant differences compared to pristine GnP and directly evidencing for grafted PLA chains. The fitting of XPS spectra, with additional comments and atomic ratios for each oxygen functional group are reported in Supporting Info, Figure S5 and Table S2. The functionalization of GnP by the stereoisomers and the formation of the stereocomplex on the basal plane of GnP was also corroborated by thermal analysis (Figure 5). Pristine GnP showed a 3.0 % weight loss until 600°C under N2 atmosphere, because of the decomposition of organic impurities and or elimination of the few oxidized groups obtained during the synthesis process of such nanoplatelets.(Colonna et al., 2017a) On the other hand, the major weight loss for PLA-functionalized GnP is observed between 200 - 400°C, corresponding to the decomposition of the polymer chains. In this temperature range, GNP Pyr-L showed a small weight loss ~ 3 wt.% (after subtraction of the weight loss corresponding to the pristine GnP), which corresponds to an adsorption concentration of 0.0535 mmol g-1 or adsorption density of approx. 1400 chains μm-2. The adsorption of the stereoisomers in the surface of GnP can be explained by i) the π-π interactions between pyrene moieties and GnP and ii) the intermolecular CH-π interactions between the -- CH groups of PLLA and GnP,(Hu et al., 2009; Arenaza et al., 2015) the former assumed to be more significant. Therefore, the limited adsorption of Pyr-L is mainly ascribed to the low content of pyrene anchoring units, as each oligomeric PLA chain is end capped with a single pyrene group. This observation is consistent with previous studies on the non-covalent functionalization of carbon nanoparticles with pyrene containing polymers, where lower pyrene/polymer ratios showed a weakening of the polymer-carbon nanoparticle interactions.(Meuer et al., 2008; 2009) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SCs, prepared with the two different methodologies, were also investigated for their thermal decomposition. GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SCs exhibited a higher thermal stability, as observable from the onset temperature of 353.0 °C, compared to 322.3 °C for GnP Pyr-L to. Most interestingly, the ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ amount of polymer chains adsorbed on the nanoplatelets is in both cases ca. 10 wt.%, (20 wt.% of the total initial amount of polymer) that corresponds to an adsorption concentration and density of 0.190 mmol g-1 and approx. 12000 chains μm-2, respectively. These values are one order of magnitude higher than those calculated for the GnP functionalized with only Pyr-L. The strong ability of carbon- based nanoparticles to induce the stereocomplex crystallization of PLA(Hu et al., 2009; Xu et al., 2010; Yang et al., 2016) together with the formation of SC precursors in the presence of DMF adsorbed on the GnP during the sonication process, favours the supramolecular functionalization of GnP with the SC. Figure 5. TGA curves of GnP and functionalized GnP. DSC heating curves and XRD patterns of functionalized GnP (Figure 6) were further performed to discern the phenomena related to the adsorption of the stereoisomers on the GnP and the formation of the SC crystallites. The DSC thermogram of GnP Pyr-L did not show any clear melting peak of the homocrystals (Figure 6a) and no diffraction peaks of Pyr-L could be observed on the XRD pattern (Figure 6b). These results confirm the low amount of stereoisomer adsorbed on the basal plane of GnP, as already evidenced from TGA. On the other hand, GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC exhibited clear evidences of PLA stereocomplexation, with significant differences as a function of the preparation method (Figure 6a inset). GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, prepared sonicating GnP in a mixed solution of ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ the stereoisomers in DMF, showed a single Tm at 222.8 °C, which is 15.3 °C higher than the Tm of the SC in the absence of GnP, while showing the typical diffraction peaks (Figure 6b) of the SC crystallites at 2θ = 12.0, 20.8 and 24.1 °, assigned to the (110), (330)/(030) and (220) planes.(Tsuji, 2005; Bao et al., 2016) On the other hand, GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B, where GnP was separately sonicated in the presence of one of the stereoisomers before mixing them to form the SC, exhibited two partially overlapped melting peaks at about 193 and 211°C (Figure 6a, inset), while displaying a XRD signal at the same position but with lower intensities, when compared to GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A. The double melting peak has been previously observed in the precipitates of PDLA + PLLA mixtures of the stereoisomers in solution and explained by melting of less perfect crystallites and recrystallization into more stable crystallites.(Tsuji et al., 1992) It is worth noting that the main melting point of SCs in GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B was found at a temperature (211.2 °C) that is significantly lower than the Tm of GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A. These differences highlight the role of both GnP and interactions of pyrene-terminated PLA oligomers to its surface. Indeed, in GnP Pyr- L/Pyr-D SC_B, the stereoisomers anchored onto the basal plane of GnP through pyrene terminals clearly affects the nucleation and growth of the SC crystallites. Hence, the probability of the intermolecular contact between the stereoisomers in solution and those on GnP increases, enhancing the stereocomplex crystallization from the surface of the nanoparticles.(Hu et al., 2009; Yang et al., 2016) However, the mobility of Pyr-L and Pyr-D chains adsorbed on the GnP is limited, organizing the SC crystallites in a poorly stable state, as observed by the DSC results. In GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, two competing effects are occurring simultaneously: the anchoring of the polymer chains to the nanoplatelets and the formation of the SC crystallites from enantiomers in solution. Here, the mobility of the polymer chains is promoted by sonication in solution together with the GnP, enhancing the stereocomplexation process, while the pyrene groups favour their adsorption on the basal planes of the GnP. As a direct consequence, more organized and stable crystallites are obtained in GnP Pyr- L/Pyr-D SC_A. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure 6. a) DSC thermograms of GnP Pyr-L and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC recorded during the second heating (10 °C min-1). Inset shows the melting region of GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B. b) Powder XRD patterns of GnP Pyr-L and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. Functionalized GnPs were used to prepare nanopapers, to assess the effect of the modification with Pyr-D/Pyr-L on the thermal transfer properties. In particular, the nanopapers have been prepared following the method described for GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, that has been previously confirmed that this strategy forms better SC crystallites. Furthermore, two nanopapers with increasing concentration of the stereoisomers were prepared to investigate the effect of the SC content on the properties of the nanopapers. Nanopapers density was significantly decreased by the presence of Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, in the range of 0.3÷0.4 g cm-3, compared to 1.0 g cm-3 for the pristine GNP nanopaper (Table 1). Despite the density is slightly decreasing with increasing the enantiomer concentration, the strong reduction in density is not consistent with the simple presence of the SC phase, based on the organic content, as determined by residue at 600°C in thermogravimetric analyses (Table 1 and Figure S6). Therefore, the nanopaper density appears to be mainly dependent on a different organization of the flakes, driven by the organic functionalization with Pyr-L/Pyr-D. Table 1. Density (ρ) and in-plane (αn∥) and cross-plane (αn⊥) thermal diffusivities of nanopapers. Nanopaper GnP ρ (g cm-3) SC content α∥ (mm2s-1) α⊥ (mm2s-1) 1.03 ± 0.02 - 221.6 ± 4.2 0.96 ± 0.02 ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ a)b)1012141618202224(220)(330)/(030)(110)Intensity (a.u.)2 (°) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B GnP Pyr-LGnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ 0.40 ± 0.06 0.35 ± 0.06 GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ 0.32 ± 0.07 7.0 9.1 16.3 163.9 ± 3.6 0.53 ± 0.01 148.0 ± 2.3 2.85 ± 0.05 116.0 ± 15.8 4.50 ± 0.01 To investigate the microstructure of the nanopapers, FESEM analyses were carried out; top-view and cross-sectional images of the nanopapers are shown in Figure 7. The presence of the organic phase, corresponding to the Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC (Figures 7b, c and d), can be observed on the top-view images as thin coating onto the GnP flakes. The cross-sectional images of the nanopapers (Figure 7 insets) suggest the presence of the polymer chains, indeed modifies the structural organization of the GnP flakes. To further investigate the self-assembly of GnP flakes in the nanopaper, 2D-XRD measurements were carried out to qualitatively evaluate the degree of in-plane orientation. In Figure 8, 2D XRD patterns for the nanopapers of pristine GnP and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC are reported. As expected for nanopapers prepared by vacuum filtration from suspensions of 2D nanoparticles, a very high degree of in-plane preferential orientation was observed for pristine GnP. This is evidenced by the strongly variable intensity distribution of the 002 basal plane for graphite vs. the azimuthal angle, with the characteristic two maxima is opposite positions, confirming a very large fraction of the GnP flakes is oriented parallel to the plane of the nanopaper. In the presence of Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, a slightly lower degree of orientation is generally observed, as suggested by a weaker orientation of the diffraction signal for 002 graphitic planes. This limited loss of orientation is particularly clear with in the cases of GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ, suggesting that higher concentrations of SC have a role in the self-assembly of GnP nanoflakes during filtration. Furthermore, for GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D inner diffraction circles are visible, corresponding to the XRD diffraction signals from the SC (Figure S7), with no significant preferential orientation (Figure 8c,d) and intensity proportional to the SC concentration determined by TGA. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure 7. Top view FESEM images of GnP nanopapers: a) GnP, b) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, c) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr- D SC_Aʹ and d) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ. Insets are the corresponding cross-sectional FESEM images of the nanopapers. Figure 8. 2D XRD patterns measured via transmission geometry on nanopapers of pristine GnP (a) GnP Pyr- L/Pyr-D SC_A (b), GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ (c) and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ (d). A schematic of pattern collection is also reported. The thermal conductivities of the nanopapers were analyzed in both cross-plane and in-plane directions. Results reported in Table 1 and Figure 9 show a clear reduction of in-plane diffusivity in ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ a)b)c)d)adcbthe presence of SC, which is expected, based on the low thermal conductivity of polymers. Furthermore, this reduction is a direct function of the fraction of SC in the nanopaper. Conversely, the cross plane diffusivity showed only a slight reduction at the lowest SC content, whereas at higher SC content the diffusivity is increased by a factor of 3 in GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ and 4.5 in GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ, despite the increasing fraction of the polymeric phase. . Figure 9. In-plane (α∥) and cross-plane (α⊥) thermal diffusivities for pristine and functionalized GnP nanopapers, with different contents of Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. The increase in cross-plane diffusivity may partially be related to a loss in nanoflakes orientation. As the fractions of flakes lying on direction tilted with respect to the nanopaper plane are expected to contribute more to the heat transfer across the nanopaper, owing to the well-known anisotropy of graphitic materials. However, in this case, the above commented differences in preferential orientation are not sufficient to explain the change in cross-plane diffusivity. Indeed, the lower degree of orientation was observed for GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, compared to pristine GnP, does not correspond to a better cross plane diffusivity. Furthermore, the significant differences between diffusivities for GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ are not reflected in terms of preferential orientations, proven to be comparable. Therefore, the enhanced efficiency on cross-plane heat transfer appears to be related to the organization of the SC phase, acting as thermal bridge between GnP flakes. In fact, crystallinity and orientation of the macromolecules are well-known to ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ 100150200250GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A''GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A'GnP  __ (mm2s-1)GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A012345__(mm2s-1)dramatically affect the thermal conductivity of the polymeric materials (Choy et al., 1980; Choy et al., 1993; Singh et al., 2014) and the organization of a thermally stable and highly crystalline SC phase, strongly interacting to the surface of GnP via the pyrene terminal groups, appears to have an effective role in promoting heat transfer between overlapped GnP flakes. Conclusions Non-covalent functionalization of graphite nanoplatelets (GnP) was obtained with ad hoc synthesized pyrene chain-ended oligomers of stereoregular polylactic acid (Pyr-L and Pyr-D), exploiting the π- π stacking interactions with GnP surface. Stereocomplexation of Pyr-L and Pyr-D onto GnP was obtained both via one-pot preparation from a mixture of GnP/Pyr-L/Pyr-D, as well as by mixing of GnP/Pyr-L and GnP/Pyr-D suspensions, with the former procedure allowing the preparation of better organized SC domains. Nanopapers were prepared at different SC fraction, evidencing the dominant role of the polymeric functionalization in the self-assembly of the GnP flakes. In particular, lower densities and reduced orientations of the nanopapers were induced by the presence of SC, acting as a polymeric cross-linkers between different GnP moieies. Most interestingly, the presence of PLA SC between GnP flakes was found to enhance cross-plane heat transfer in GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC nanopapers, explained in terms of the contribution of local crystallinity to the reduction of thermal resistance at the interface between GnP flakes. Therefore, the possibility to control the thermal conductivity anisotropy of GnP nanostructures, by the self-assembly of organic polymeric functionalization, was demontrated. The proposed approach can be generally applied to the physical properties modification of engineered nanostructures based on graphene and graphene related materials. Acknowledgements This work has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme grant agreement 639495 -- INTHERM -- ERC-2014- The authors gratefully acknowledge dr. Julio Gomez (Avanzare Innovación Tecnólogica, E) for providing GnP, dr. Mauro Raimondo (Politecnico di Torino, I) for FESEM analyses, dr. Salvatore ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Guastella (Politecnico di Torino, I) for XPS measurements and dr. Domenica Marabello (University of Turin and CRISDI, Italy) for 2D XRD measurements. Authors's contribution A.F. and O.M conceived this research work and the experiments within, interpreted the experimental results and led the research activities. M.E. carried out the synthesis of Pyr-L/Pyr-D, nanopapers and characterization. M.B. contributed to the synthesis, data analysis and interpretation of results. M.M. carried out 2D XRD measurement, data treatment and interpretation. Manuscript was mainly written by M.B. and A.F. The authors declare no conflict of interest. References Anderson, K.S., and Hillmyer, M.A. (2006). Melt preparation and nucleation efficiency of polylactide stereocomplex crystallites. Polymer 47(6), 2030-2035. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2006.01.062. Arenaza, I.M.d., Obarzanek-Fojt, M., Sarasua, J.R., Meaurio, E., Meyer, F., Raquez, J.M., et al. (2015). Pyrene-end-functionalized poly(L-lactide) as an efficient carbon nanotube dispersing agent in poly(L- lactide): mechanical performance and biocompatibility study. Biomedical Materials 10(4), 045003. Balandin, A.A., and Nika, D.L. (2012). Phononics in low-dimensional materials. Materials Today 15(6), 266- 275. doi: http://doi.org/10.1016/S1369-7021(12)70117-7. Bao, J., Chang, X., Shan, G., Bao, Y., and Pan, P. (2016). Synthesis of end-functionalized hydrogen-bonding poly(lactic acid)s and preferential stereocomplex crystallization of their enantiomeric blends. Polymer Chemistry 7(30), 4891-4900. doi: 10.1039/C6PY00976J. Bernal, M.M., Di Pierro, A., Novara, C., Giorgis, F., Mortazavi, B., Saracco, G., et al. Edge-Grafted Molecular Junctions between Graphene Nanoplatelets: Applied Chemistry to Enhance Heat Transfer in Nanomaterials. Advanced Functional Materials, 1706954-n/a. doi: 10.1002/adfm.201706954. Bernal, M.M., Di Pierro, A., Novara, C., Giorgis, F., Mortazavi, B., Saracco, G., et al. (2018). Edge-Grafted Molecular Junctions between Graphene Nanoplatelets: Applied Chemistry to Enhance Heat Transfer in Nanomaterials. Advanced Functional Materials 28(18), 1706954. doi: 10.1002/adfm.201706954. Bernal, M.M., Tortello, M., Colonna, S., Saracco, G., and Fina, A. (2017). Thermally and Electrically Conductive Nanopapers from Reduced Graphene Oxide: Effect of Nanoflakes Thermal Annealing on the Film Structure and Properties. Nanomaterials 7(12), 428. Bidsorkhi, H.C., D'Aloia, A.G., De Bellis, G., Proietti, A., Rinaldi, A., Fortunato, M., et al. (2017). Nucleation effect of unmodified graphene nanoplatelets on PVDF/GNP film composites. Materials Today Communications 11, 163-173. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mtcomm.2017.04.001. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Björk, J., Hanke, F., Palma, C.-A., Samori, P., Cecchini, M., and Persson, M. (2010). Adsorption of Aromatic and Anti-Aromatic Systems on Graphene through π−π Stacking. The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 1(23), 3407-3412. doi: 10.1021/jz101360k. Brizzolara, D., Cantow, H.J., Diederichs, K., Keller, E., and Domb, A.J. (1996). Mechanism of the stereocomplex formation between enantiomeric poly(lactide)s. Macromolecules 29(1), 191-197. doi: DOI 10.1021/ma951144e. Chen, H., Ginzburg, V.V., Yang, J., Yang, Y., Liu, W., Huang, Y., et al. (2016). Thermal conductivity of polymer-based composites: Fundamentals and applications. Progress in Polymer Science 59, 41-85. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progpolymsci.2016.03.001. Cheng, Q.-Y., Zhou, D., Gao, Y., Chen, Q., Zhang, Z., and Han, B.-H. (2012). Supramolecular Self-Assembly Induced Graphene Oxide Based Hydrogels and Organogels. Langmuir 28(5), 3005-3010. doi: 10.1021/la204558f. Choi, E.-Y., Han, T.H., Hong, J., Kim, J.E., Lee, S.H., Kim, H.W., et al. (2010). Noncovalent functionalization of graphene with end-functional polymers. Journal of Materials Chemistry 20(10), 1907-1912. doi: 10.1039/B919074K. Choy, C.L., Chen, F.C., and Luk, W.H. (1980). Thermal conductivity of oriented crystalline polymers. Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics Edition 18(6), 1187-1207. doi: doi:10.1002/pol.1980.180180603. Choy, C.L., Fei, Y., and Xi, T.G. (1993). Thermal conductivity of gel-spun polyethylene fibers. Journal of Polymer Science Part B: Polymer Physics 31(3), 365-370. doi: doi:10.1002/polb.1993.090310315. Coleman, J.N., Lotya, M., O'Neill, A., Bergin, S.D., King, P.J., Khan, U., et al. (2011). Two-Dimensional Nanosheets Produced by Liquid Exfoliation of Layered Materials. Science 331(6017), 568-571. doi: 10.1126/science.1194975. Colonna, S., Bernal, M.M., Gavoci, G., Gomez, J., Novara, C., Saracco, G., et al. (2017a). Effect of processing conditions on the thermal and electrical conductivity of poly (butylene terephthalate) nanocomposites prepared via ring-opening polymerization. Materials & Design 119(Supplement C), 124-132. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2017.01.067. Colonna, S., Pérez-Camargo, R.A., Chen, H., Liu, G., Wang, D., Müller, A.J., et al. (2017b). Supernucleation and Orientation of Poly(butylene terephthalate) Crystals in Nanocomposites Containing Highly Reduced Graphene Oxide. Macromolecules 50(23), 9380-9393. doi: 10.1021/acs.macromol.7b01865. Danko, M., Hrdlovic, P., Brzezinski, M., Duda, A., and Biela, T. (2018). Real-time monitoring of stereocomplex formation of poly(L-lactide) and poly (D-lactide) decorated with a pyrene derivative as a fluorescence probe. Polymer 156, 76-84. doi: 10.1016/j.polymer.2018.09.041. de Arenaza, I.M., Sarasua, J.R., Amestoy, H., Lopez-Rodriguez, N., Zuza, E., Meaurio, E., et al. (2013). Polylactide stereocomplex crystallization prompted by multiwall carbon nanotubes. Journal of Applied Polymer Science 130(6), 4327-4337. doi: 10.1002/app.39721. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Eleuteri, M., Pastorino, L., and Monticelli, O. (2018). On the degradation properties of electrospun fibers based on PLLA: The effect of a drug model modification. Polymer Degradation and Stability 153, 109-117. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymdegradstab.2018.04.013. Ferrari, A.C., Bonaccorso, F., Fal'ko, V., Novoselov, K.S., Roche, S., Boggild, P., et al. (2015). Science and technology roadmap for graphene, related two-dimensional crystals, and hybrid systems. Nanoscale 7(11), 4598-4810. doi: 10.1039/c4nr01600a. Ferreira, C.I., Dal Castel, C., Oviedo, M.A.S., and Mauler, R.S. (2013). Isothermal and non-isothermal crystallization kinetics of polypropylene/exfoliated graphite nanocomposites. Thermochimica Acta 553, 40-48. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tca.2012.11.025. Fina, A., Colonna, S., Maddalena, L., Tortello, M., and Monticelli, O. (2018). Facile and Low Environmental Impact Approach to Prepare Thermally Conductive Nanocomposites Based on Polylactide and Graphite Nanoplatelets. ACS Sustain Chem Eng 6(11), 14340-14347. doi: 10.1021/acssuschemeng.8b03013. Gardella, L., Furfaro, D., Galimberti, M., and Monticelli, O. (2015). On the development of a facile approach based on the use of ionic liquids: preparation of PLLA (sc-PLA)/high surface area nano-graphite systems. Green Chemistry 17(7), 4082-4088. doi: 10.1039/C5GC00964B. Geim, A.K., and Novoselov, K.S. (2007). The rise of graphene. Nat Mater 6(3), 183-191. Georgakilas, V., Otyepka, M., Bourlinos, A.B., Chandra, V., Kim, N., Kemp, K.C., et al. (2012). Functionalization of Graphene: Covalent and Non-Covalent Approaches, Derivatives and Applications. Chemical Reviews 112(11), 6156-6214. doi: 10.1021/cr3000412. Georgakilas, V., Tiwari, J.N., Kemp, K.C., Perman, J.A., Bourlinos, A.B., Kim, K.S., et al. (2016). Noncovalent Functionalization of Graphene and Graphene Oxide for Energy Materials, Biosensing, Catalytic, and Biomedical Applications. Chemical Reviews 116(9), 5464-5519. doi: 10.1021/acs.chemrev.5b00620. Gómez-Navarro, C., Weitz, R.T., Bittner, A.M., Scolari, M., Mews, A., Burghard, M., et al. (2007). Electronic Transport Properties of Individual Chemically Reduced Graphene Oxide Sheets. Nano Letters 7(11), 3499-3503. doi: 10.1021/nl072090c. Gonçalves, C.M.B., Coutinho, J.o.A.P., and Marrucho, I.M. (2010). "Optical Properties," in Poly(Lactic Acid). John Wiley & Sons, Inc.), 97-112. Hernandez, Y., Nicolosi, V., Lotya, M., Blighe, F.M., Sun, Z., De, S., et al. (2008). High-yield production of graphene by liquid-phase exfoliation of graphite. Nature Nanotechnology 3, 563. doi: 10.1038/nnano.2008.215 https://www.nature.com/articles/nnano.2008.215#supplementary-information. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Hirata, M., and Kimura, Y. (2008). Thermomechanical properties of stereoblock poly(lactic acid)s with different PLLA/PDLA block compositions. Polymer 49(11), 2656-2661. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2008.04.014. Hirsch, A., Englert, J.M., and Hauke, F. (2013). Wet Chemical Functionalization of Graphene. Accounts of Chemical Research 46(1), 87-96. doi: 10.1021/ar300116q. Hsiao, S.-T., Ma, C.-C.M., Tien, H.-W., Liao, W.-H., Wang, Y.-S., Li, S.-M., et al. (2013). Using a non- covalent modification to prepare a high electromagnetic interference shielding performance graphene nanosheet/water-borne polyurethane composite. Carbon 60, 57-66. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2013.03.056. Hu, X., An, H., Li, Z.-M., Geng, Y., Li, L., and Yang, C. (2009). Origin of Carbon Nanotubes Induced Poly(l- Lactide) Crystallization: Surface Induced Conformational Order. Macromolecules 42(8), 3215-3218. doi: 10.1021/ma802758k. Ji, L., Wu, Y., Ma, L., and Yang, X. (2015). Noncovalent functionalization of graphene with pyrene-terminated liquid crystalline polymer. Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing 72, 32-39. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesa.2015.01.009. Jingquan, L., Wenrong, Y., Lei, T., Dan, L., Cyrille, B., and P., D.T. (2010). Thermosensitive graphene nanocomposites formed using pyrene‐terminal polymers made by RAFT polymerization. Journal of Polymer Science Part A: Polymer Chemistry 48(2), 425-433. doi: doi:10.1002/pola.23802. Kister, G., Cassanas, G., and Vert, M. (1998). Effects of morphology, conformation and configuration on the IR and Raman spectra of various poly(lactic acid)s. Polymer 39(2), 267-273. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0032-3861(97)00229-2. Kuilla, T., Bhadra, S., Yao, D., Kim, N.H., Bose, S., and Lee, J.H. (2010). Recent advances in graphene based polymer composites. Progress in Polymer Science 35(11), 1350-1375. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progpolymsci.2010.07.005. Lee, C., Wei, X., Kysar, J.W., and Hone, J. (2008). Measurement of the Elastic Properties and Intrinsic Strength of Monolayer Graphene. Science 321(5887), 385-388. doi: 10.1126/science.1157996. Liang, C., Jingquan, L., Rui, W., Zhen, L., and Wenrong, Y. (2012). A facile "graft from" method to prepare molecular‐level dispersed graphene -- polymer composites. Journal of Polymer Science Part A: Polymer Chemistry 50(21), 4423-4432. doi: doi:10.1002/pola.26264. Liu, J., Yang, W., Tao, L., Li, D., Boyer, C., and Davis, T.P. (2010). Thermosensitive graphene nanocomposites formed using pyrene‐terminal polymers made by RAFT polymerization. Journal of Polymer Science Part A: Polymer Chemistry 48(2), 425-433. doi: doi:10.1002/pola.23802. Manafi, P., Ghasemi, I., Karrabi, M., Azizi, H., and Ehsaninamin, P. (2014). Effect of Graphene Nanoplatelets on Crystallization Kinetics of Poly (lactic acid). Soft Materials 12(4), 433-444. doi: 10.1080/1539445X.2014.959598. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Marubayashi, H., Asai, S., and Sumita, M. (2012). Complex Crystal Formation of Poly(l-lactide) with Solvent Molecules. Macromolecules 45(3), 1384-1397. doi: 10.1021/ma202324g. Marubayashi, H., Asai, S., and Sumita, M. (2013). Guest-Induced Crystal-to-Crystal Transitions of Poly(l- lactide) Complexes. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 117(1), 385-397. doi: 10.1021/jp308999t. Meng, Y., Wang, K., Zhang, Y., and Wei, Z. (2013). Hierarchical Porous Graphene/Polyaniline Composite Film with Superior Rate Performance for Flexible Supercapacitors. Advanced Materials 25(48), 6985- 6990. doi: doi:10.1002/adma.201303529. Meuer, S., Braun, L., and Zentel, R. (2008). Solubilisation of multi walled carbon nanotubes by [small alpha]- pyrene functionalised PMMA and their liquid crystalline self-organisation. Chemical Communications (27), 3166-3168. doi: 10.1039/B803099E. Meuer, S., Braun, L., and Zentel, R. (2009). Pyrene Containing Polymers for the Non‐Covalent Functionalization of Carbon Nanotubes. Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics 210(18), 1528-1535. doi: doi:10.1002/macp.200900125. Michalski, A., Socka, M., Brzezinski, M., and Biela, T. (2018). Reversible Supramolecular Polylactides Gels Obtained via Stereocomplexation. Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics 219(9). doi: ARTN 1700607 10.1002/macp.201700607. Mittal, V. (2014). Functional Polymer Nanocomposites with Graphene: A Review. Macromolecular Materials and Engineering 299(8), 906-931. doi: doi:10.1002/mame.201300394. Papageorgiou, D.G., Kinloch, I.A., and Young, R.J. (2017). Mechanical properties of graphene and graphene- based nanocomposites. Progress in Materials Science 90, 75-127. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmatsci.2017.07.004. Parviz, D., Das, S., Ahmed, H.S.T., Irin, F., Bhattacharia, S., and Green, M.J. (2012). Dispersions of Non- Covalently Functionalized Graphene with Minimal Stabilizer. ACS Nano 6(10), 8857-8867. doi: 10.1021/nn302784m. Potts, J.R., Dreyer, D.R., Bielawski, C.W., and Ruoff, R.S. (2011). Graphene-based polymer nanocomposites. Polymer 52(1), 5-25. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2010.11.042. Renteria, J.D., Ramirez, S., Malekpour, H., Alonso, B., Centeno, A., Zurutuza, A., et al. (2015). Strongly Anisotropic Thermal Conductivity of Free-Standing Reduced Graphene Oxide Films Annealed at High Temperature. Advanced Functional Materials 25(29), 4664-4672. doi: doi:10.1002/adfm.201501429. Rodriguez-Perez, L., Herranz, M.a.A., and Martin, N. (2013). The chemistry of pristine graphene. Chemical Communications 49(36), 3721-3735. doi: 10.1039/C3CC38950B. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Ronca, S., Igarashi, T., Forte, G., and Rastogi, S. (2017). Metallic-like thermal conductivity in a lightweight insulator: Solid-state processed Ultra High Molecular Weight Polyethylene tapes and films. Polymer 123, 203-210. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2017.07.027. Shen, B., Zhai, W., and Zheng, W. (2014). Ultrathin Flexible Graphene Film: An Excellent Thermal Conducting Material with Efficient EMI Shielding. Advanced Functional Materials 24(28), 4542- 4548. doi: doi:10.1002/adfm.201400079. Singh, V., Bougher, T.L., Weathers, A., Cai, Y., Bi, K., Pettes, M.T., et al. (2014). High thermal conductivity of chain-oriented amorphous polythiophene. Nature Nanotechnology 9, 384. doi: 10.1038/nnano.2014.44 https://www.nature.com/articles/nnano.2014.44#supplementary-information. Song, N.-J., Chen, C.-M., Lu, C., Liu, Z., Kong, Q.-Q., and Cai, R. (2014). Thermally reduced graphene oxide films as flexible lateral heat spreaders. Journal of Materials Chemistry A 2(39), 16563-16568. doi: 10.1039/C4TA02693D. Stoller, M.D., Park, S., Zhu, Y., An, J., and Ruoff, R.S. (2008). Graphene-Based Ultracapacitors. Nano Letters 8(10), 3498-3502. doi: 10.1021/nl802558y. Sun, Y., and He, C. (2012). Synthesis and Stereocomplex Crystallization of Poly(lactide) -- Graphene Oxide Nanocomposites. ACS Macro Letters 1(6), 709-713. doi: 10.1021/mz300131u. Tong, X.-Z., Song, F., Li, M.-Q., Wang, X.-L., Chin, I.-J., and Wang, Y.-Z. (2013). Fabrication of graphene/polylactide nanocomposites with improved properties. Composites Science and Technology 88, 33-38. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2013.08.028. Tsuji, H. (2005). Poly(lactide) Stereocomplexes: Formation, Structure, Properties, Degradation, and Applications. Macromolecular Bioscience 5(7), 569-597. doi: 10.1002/mabi.200500062. Tsuji, H., Hyon, S.H., and Ikada, Y. (1992). Stereocomplex formation between enantiomeric poly(lactic acids). 5. Calorimetric and morphological studies on the stereocomplex formed in acetonitrile solution. Macromolecules 25(11), 2940-2946. doi: 10.1021/ma00037a024. Tsuji, H., and Yamamoto, S. (2011). Enhanced Stereocomplex Crystallization of Biodegradable Enantiomeric Poly(lactic acid)s by Repeated Casting. Macromolecular Materials and Engineering 296(7), 583-589. doi: 10.1002/mame.201000397. Wan, S., Li, Y., Mu, J., Aliev, A.E., Fang, S., Kotov, N.A., et al. (2018). Sequentially bridged graphene sheets with high strength, toughness, and electrical conductivity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1719111115. Wang, H., Bi, S.-G., Ye, Y.-S., Xue, Y., Xie, X.-L., and Mai, Y.-W. (2015). An effective non-covalent grafting approach to functionalize individually dispersed reduced graphene oxide sheets with high grafting density, solubility and electrical conductivity. Nanoscale 7(8), 3548-3557. doi: 10.1039/C4NR06710J. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Wang, J., Chen, Z., and Chen, B. (2014). Adsorption of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons by Graphene and Graphene Oxide Nanosheets. Environmental Science & Technology 48(9), 4817-4825. doi: 10.1021/es405227u. Wu, D., Cheng, Y., Feng, S., Yao, Z., and Zhang, M. (2013). Crystallization Behavior of Polylactide/Graphene Composites. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 52(20), 6731-6739. doi: 10.1021/ie4004199. Xin, G., Sun, H., Hu, T., Fard, H.R., Sun, X., Koratkar, N., et al. (2014). Large-Area Freestanding Graphene Paper for Superior Thermal Management. Advanced Materials 26(26), 4521-4526. doi: doi:10.1002/adma.201400951. Xu, H., Feng, Z.-X., Xie, L., and Hakkarainen, M. (2016). Graphene Oxide-Driven Design of Strong and Flexible Biopolymer Barrier Films: From Smart Crystallization Control to Affordable Engineering. ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering 4(1), 334-349. doi: 10.1021/acssuschemeng.5b01273. Xu, H., Teng, C., and Yu, M. (2006). Improvements of thermal property and crystallization behavior of PLLA based multiblock copolymer by forming stereocomplex with PDLA oligomer. Polymer 47(11), 3922- 3928. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2006.03.090. Xu, H., Wu, D., Yang, X., Xie, L., and Hakkarainen, M. (2015). Thermostable and Impermeable "Nano-Barrier Walls" Constructed by Poly(lactic acid) Stereocomplex Crystal Decorated Graphene Oxide Nanosheets. Macromolecules 48(7), 2127-2137. doi: 10.1021/ma502603j. Xu, J.-Z., Chen, T., Yang, C.-L., Li, Z.-M., Mao, Y.-M., Zeng, B.-Q., et al. (2010). Isothermal Crystallization of Poly(l-lactide) Induced by Graphene Nanosheets and Carbon Nanotubes: A Comparative Study. Macromolecules 43(11), 5000-5008. doi: 10.1021/ma100304n. Yang, S., Xu, J.-Z., Li, Y., Lei, J., Zhong, G.-J., Wang, R., et al. (2017). Effects of Solvents on Stereocomplex Crystallization of High-Molecular-Weight Polylactic Acid Racemic Blends in the Presence of Carbon Nanotubes. Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics 218(21), 1700292-n/a. doi: 10.1002/macp.201700292. Yang, S., Zhong, G.-J., Xu, J.-Z., and Li, Z.-M. (2016). Preferential formation of stereocomplex in high- molecular-weight polylactic acid racemic blend induced by carbon nanotubes. Polymer 105, 167-171. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymer.2016.10.034. Zhang, D., Lin, Y., and Wu, G. (2017). Polylactide-based nanocomposites with stereocomplex networks enhanced by GO-g-PDLA. Composites Science and Technology 138, 57-67. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2016.11.016. Zhang, J., Sato, H., Tsuji, H., Noda, I., and Ozaki, Y. (2005). Infrared Spectroscopic Study of CH3···OC Interaction during Poly(l-lactide)/Poly(d-lactide) Stereocomplex Formation. Macromolecules 38(5), 1822-1828. doi: 10.1021/ma047872w. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Zhang, Y., Liu, C., Shi, W., Wang, Z., Dai, L., and Zhang, X. (2007). Direct Measurements of the Interaction between Pyrene and Graphite in Aqueous Media by Single Molecule Force Spectroscopy: Understanding the π−π Interactions. Langmuir 23(15), 7911-7915. doi: 10.1021/la700876d. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ SUPPORTING INFORMATION Stereocomplexation of Poly(Lactic Acid)s on Graphite Nanoplatelets: from Functionalized Nanoparticles to Self-Assembled Nanostructures. Matteo Eleuteri, Mar Bernal, Marco Milanesio, Orietta Monticelli, Alberto Fina 1.1 Characterization of Pyr-L Figure S1. 1H NMR spectrum in CDCl3 of Pyr-L. The UV-Vis spectra of Pyr-L in DMF at a concentration of 0.5 mg mL-1 is shown in Figure S2. The typical absorbance bands of pyrene in the region of 270 -- 350 nm can be clearly observed. Figure S2. UV-Vis absorption spectra of Pyr-L in DMF at a concentration of 0.5 mg mL-1. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ 1.2 Effect of the Solvent on the Pyr-L/Pyr-D Stereocomplexation Pyr-L/Pyr-D sterecomplexes were prepared from solutions in different solvents, namely chloroform and N,N- dimethylformamide. The first is a conventional solvent for polylactic acid, whereas the second was selected for its well-known affinity to GnP. While sterecomplexation is observed to occur in both solvents, results from thermal analysed as well as spectroscopy evidence for dramatic differences in organization of SC crystallites, as a function of the PLA oligomers with the solvent. Figure S3. DSC thermograms of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, recrystallized from DMF and CHCl3, recorded during the second heating (10 °C min-1). Table S1. Thermal parameters of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC obtained after crystallization in DMF and CHCl3: cold crystallization temperature (Tcc) and enthalpy (ΔHcc), melting temperature (Tm) and enthalpy (ΔHm) and temperature corresponding to the maximum DTG peaks (Tmax) obtained from the first derivative curve of the TGA thermograph of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. Tcc a (°C) ΔHcc a (J g-1) Tm a (°C) ΔHm a (J g-1) Tmax b (°C) 7.3 11.0 - 5.6 138.5, 152.2 140.6, 152.5, 165.1 207.5 198.7 39.3 38.8 45.1 43.5 264.2 274.0 296.6 293.4 Sample Pyr-L (DMF) Pyr-L (CHCl3) Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC (DMF) 87.1 92.2 - Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC (CHCl3) 79.3 a Determined by DSC analysis, second heating (10 °C min-1). b Determined by TGA analysis. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure S4. UV-Vis spectra obtained after dispersion-filtration cycles during the preparation of a) GnP Pyr-L, b) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A and c) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B. 1.3 XPS analysis Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC were first measured as reference samples in order to facilitate the interpretation of the XPS spectra of supramolecularly functionalized GnP (Figure S5). In the case of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, the C1s spectra show the components related to the polymers structure:(Shakesheff et al., 1997; Jordá-Vilaplana et al., 2014) the peak at ~ 284.9 eV attributed to aliphatic carbons (-CH2, -CH3), the band at 285.5 eV (C-OH), the C-O-C peak at 286.8 eV and the 288.9 eV binding energy of the -C=O. The deconvolution of the C1s spectra of the functionalized GnP are dominated by the peak at 284.4 eV, related to the sp2 C-C bonds and thus the differentiation of the aliphatic carbons of the polymer backbone remains difficult, suggesting for a limited fraction of PyrL or PyrD onto GnP. The O1s spectra (Figure 5b) of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC were deconvoluted into the three bands typical of the composition of PLA: the O-C=O at 531.5 eV, the C-O-C at 533 eV and the C-OH at 534.2 eV. On the other hand, the O1s spectrum of GnP showed only two components due to the C=O at 530.5 eV and a broad band related to the C-O-C group. The successful functionalization of the GnP with the polymer chains is confirmed by the presence on the O1s spectra of the corresponding oxygen bands observed in the O1s spectra of Pyr-L and Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC. The values of the at.% of each oxygen functional group are summarized in Table S2. Atomic ratios (at.%) were calculated from experimental intensity ratios and normalized by atomic sensitivity factors. The C1s and O1s peaks were fitted as following the previously described procedure.(Bernal et al.) ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure S5. C1s and O1s XPS spectra of GnP, Pyr-L, Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A, Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B, GnP Pyr-L, GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_B. Table S2. XPS peak assignment and atomic percentage (at.%) for Pyr-L, Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC, GnP, GnP Pyr-L, GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC _A and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC _B. Sample Pyr-L Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC GnP GnP Pyr-L GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC _A Total C1s Total O1s at.% at.% Contributions from O to C1s spectra at.% C-OH C-O-C C=O 59.2 59.2 96.5 96.4 95.5 40.8 40.8 3.5 3.6 4.5 6.1 4.5 0.9 0.9 0.6 26.1 22.7 0.8 1.1 3.3 20.7 17.0 1.8 1.5 1.2 ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC _B 96.0 4.0 0.8 1.5 1.8 1.4 Adsorption concentration and adsorption density The adsorption concentration and density of the stereoisomers and the SCs were determined from the TGA data of the fuctionalized GnP. The adsorption concentration (mmol g-1) was calculated from the mmol of polymer chains adsorbed per gram of framework graphene carbon according to the literature:(Hu et al., 2017) 𝑀𝑝 ⁄ ( (𝑀𝑝 + 𝑀𝐺) ⁄ ) 𝑀𝑤𝑝 𝐺𝐶 ( 𝑚𝑚𝑜𝑙 𝑔 ) = (1 − 𝑀𝑝 ⁄ (𝑀𝑝 + 𝑀𝐺) × 1000 ) where Mp is the total mass of adsorbed polymer, MG is the total mass of GnP and Mwp is the molecular weight of the polymer in g mol-1. The adsorption density, defined by the number of polymers per area of GnP surface, N/A, was calculated as:(Chadwick et al., 2013) 𝑁 𝐴 = 𝑀 𝐴 𝑀𝑝 𝑀𝐺 1 𝑀𝑤𝑝 where M/A is the mass per unit area of graphene estimated as 7.48 x 10-7 kg m-2 (assuming an average area of GnP of 100 μm2 and a density of 2200 kg m-3) and Mwp is converted to kg molecule-1. 1.5 Additional characterization of GNP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC nanopapers Thermogravimetry was used to assess the content of organic fraction, namely the Pyr-l/Pyr-D SC in the nanopapers prepared form different enantiomers concentrations. Results are reported in Figure S6. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Figure S6. Thermogravimetric plots for nanopapers of GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC prepared with different enantiomers concentrations 2D XRD were reduced to intensity vs. 2θ profiles, to investigate preferential orientations in the nanopapers and well as to obtain averaged XRD profiles over the whole possible orientations. Results are reported in Figure S7. Figure S7. XRD spectra from 0-360° intergration of 2D Patterns obtained on nanopapers of pristine GnP (a) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A (b), GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹ (c) and GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_Aʹʹ (d). Peaks are identified with their crystalline plane s assignment graphene (g) or stereocomplex (SC) ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ 10020030040050060080859095100Weight (%)Temperature (°C) GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A' GnP Pyr-L/Pyr-D SC_A''0,000,050,100,150,200,25Deriv (%/°C)g.(002)g.(004)g.(101)SC.(110)SC.(330)/(030)SC.(220)g.(002)g.(004)g.(101)SC.(110)SC.(330)/(030)SC.(220)g.(002)g.(004)g.(101)SC.(110)SC.(330)/(030)g.(002)g.(004)g.(101)adcb References Bernal, M.M., Di Pierro, A., Novara, C., Giorgis, F., Mortazavi, B., Saracco, G., et al. Edge-Grafted Molecular Junctions between Graphene Nanoplatelets: Applied Chemistry to Enhance Heat Transfer in Nanomaterials. Advanced Functional Materials, 1706954-n/a. doi: 10.1002/adfm.201706954. Chadwick, R.C., Khan, U., Coleman, J.N., and Adronov, A. (2013). Polymer Grafting to Single‐Walled Carbon Nanotubes: Effect of Chain Length on Solubility, Graft Density and Mechanical Properties of Macroscopic Structures. Small 9(4), 552-560. doi: doi:10.1002/smll.201201683. Hu, S., Laker, Z.P.L., Leese, H.S., Rubio, N., De Marco, M., Au, H., et al. (2017). Thermochemical functionalisation of graphenes with minimal framework damage. Chemical Science 8(9), 6149-6154. doi: 10.1039/C6SC05603B. Jordá-Vilaplana, A., Fombuena, V., García-García, D., Samper, M.D., and Sánchez-Nácher, L. (2014). Surface modification of polylactic acid (PLA) by air atmospheric plasma treatment. European Polymer Journal 58, 23-33. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eurpolymj.2014.06.002. Shakesheff, K.M., Evora, C., Soriano, I., and Langer, R. (1997). The Adsorption of Poly(vinyl alcohol) to Biodegradable Microparticles Studied by X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS). Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 185(2), 538-547. doi: https://doi.org/10.1006/jcis.1996.4637. ©2019. This manuscript version is made available under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
1907.02651	1	1907	2019-06-19T22:14:45	Origin of current-controlled negative differential resistance modes and the emergence of composite characteristics with high complexity	[ "physics.app-ph", "cs.ET" ]	Current-controlled negative differential resistance has significant potential as a fundamental building block in brain-inspired neuromorphic computing. However, achieving desired negative differential resistance characteristics, which is crucial for practical implementation, remains challenging due to little consensus on the underlying mechanism and unclear design criteria. Here, we report a material-independent model of current-controlled negative differential resistance to explain a broad range of characteristics, including the origin of the discontinuous snap-back response observed in many transition metal oxides. This is achieved by explicitly accounting for a non-uniform current distribution in the oxide film and its impact on the effective circuit of the device, rather than a material-specific phase transition. The predictions of the model are then compared with experimental observations to show that the continuous S-type and discontinuous snap-back characteristics serve as fundamental building blocks for composite behaviour with higher complexity. Finally, we demonstrate the potential of our approach for predicting and engineering unconventional compound behaviour with novel functionality for emerging electronic and neuromorphic computing applications.	physics.app-ph	physics	Origin of current-controlled negative differential resistance modes and the emergence of composite characteristics with high complexity Shuai Li1, Xinjun Liu2, Sanjoy Kumar Nandi1, Shimul Kanti Nath1, Robert G. Elliman1 1Department of Electronic Materials Engineering, Research School of Physics and Engineering, The Australian National University, Canberra ACT 2601, Australia 2Tianjin Key Laboratory of Low Dimensional Materials Physics and Preparation Technology, Faculty of Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300354, China *Address correspondence to [email protected] and [email protected] Abstract Current-controlled negative differential resistance has significant potential as a fundamental building block in brain-inspired neuromorphic computing. However, achieving desired negative differential resistance characteristics, which is crucial for practical implementation, remains challenging due to little consensus on the underlying mechanism and unclear design criteria. Here, we report a material-independent model of current-controlled negative differential resistance to explain a broad range of characteristics, including the origin of the discontinuous snap-back response observed in many transition metal oxides. This is achieved by explicitly accounting for a non-uniform current distribution in the oxide film and its impact on the effective circuit of the device, rather than a material-specific phase transition. The predictions of the model are then compared with experimental observations to show that the continuous S-type and discontinuous snap-back characteristics serve as fundamental building blocks for composite behaviour with higher complexity. Finally, we demonstrate the potential of our approach for predicting and engineering unconventional compound behaviour with novel functionality for emerging electronic and neuromorphic computing applications. Introduction Current-controlled negative differential resistance (NDR) is of increasing interest for brain- inspired computing based on a number of promising applications, including trigger comparators1, self-sustained and chaotic oscillators2-7, threshold logic devices8,9 and the emulation of biological neuronal dynamics10,11. Since the functionality of such devices is determined by the specific form of their current-voltage characteristics, it is important to understand the physical basis of switching and how it is affected by device structure and operating conditions. This is complicated by the fact that conductivity changes responsible for NDR can involve electronic, thermal or a combination of electronic and thermal processes, and is further complicated by the possibility of material-specific phase transitions and non-uniform current distributions due to electroforming or current constriction/bifurcation12-18. Despite these complexities, several studies have demonstrated that continuous S-type NDR in amorphous binary metal oxides can be well modelled by a temperature-dependent transport 1 model, such as Poole-Frenkel conduction, and local Joule heating19-23. Indeed, Gibson recently generalized this understanding to show that S-type NDR can arise from any conduction mechanisms that depends superlinearly on temperature24. His study also provided a basis for correlating particular NDR characteristics with material properties, thereby providing a basis for engineering devices with specific characteristics. 25, TaOx While the above studies provide a foundation for understanding S-type NDR characteristics, they do not explain the diverse range of other NDR characteristics exhibited by thin film oxides, 26, such as the discontinuous snap-back response observed in oxides such as NbOx 27. This is analogous to a similar response observed in chalcogenide glasses28 and is SiOx characterised by abrupt, hysteretic voltage changes during bidirectional current sweeps. Devices exhibiting more complex combinations of continuous and snap-back characteristics have also been reported and have the potential to offer new functionality for neuromorphic computing3. In an attempt to understand the origin of such characteristics, Kumar et. al.25 employed in-situ temperature mapping of amorphous NbOx devices that exhibited both S-type and snap-back characteristics. The onset of the continuous S-type NDR was found to occur at ~400 K, consistent with Poole-Frenkel conduction, while the snap-back characteristic was found to occur at ~1000 K and was attributed to the known insulator-metal-transition (IMT) in 29-31. However, the latter mechanism fails to account for similar snap-back behaviour in NbO2 oxides such as TaOx and has been questioned by Goodwill et. al.26 based on finite-element modelling of TaOx and VOx devices that reproduces the snap-back response without recourse to a material specific phase transition. In this Article, we introduce a material independent model of current-controlled NDR that addresses the about controversy and explains a diverse range of discrete and compound NDR characteristics measured in NbOx-based devices. This is achieved by explicitly accounting for a non-uniform current distribution in the device and its impact on the effective circuit of the device under current-controlled testing. Our results clearly define criteria for achieving continuous S-type and snap-back characteristics and further show that these serve as the fundamental building blocks for other compound NDR characteristics with higher complexity. Device structure and switching characteristics The device characteristics presented herein are derived from a range of studies by our group and are selected to demonstrate specific characteristics and functionality (see Supplementary Information Table S1). The devices are based on NbOx/Pt cross point structures with Pt/Ti or Pt/Nb top electrodes (Fig. 1a) and were fabricated using standard photolithographic processes described elsewhere32. Switching characteristics were simulated using a lumped element model of an archetype threshold switch (memristor). For simplicity, the electrical conductivity was assumed to have a power law dependence on temperature such that the device resistance is given by: 𝑅𝑚 = 𝑅0( 𝑇𝑚 𝑇𝑎𝑚𝑏 )−𝛾 where Tm and Tamb denote the temperature of the electrically active region and the ambient environment, R0 is the resistance of the active region at T=Tamb and  is an exponent that 2 determines the temperature dependence. Gibson24 has shown that a superlinear temperature dependence is required to produce current controlled NDR so that  > 1. The dynamic behaviour of the memristor is then described by Newton's law of cooling: 𝑑𝑇𝑚 𝑑𝑡 = 𝐼𝑚 2𝑅𝑚 𝐶𝑡ℎ − ∆𝑇 𝑅𝑡ℎ𝐶𝑡ℎ where Rth and Cth are the thermal resistance and the thermal capacitance of the device, and ∆T is the temperature difference between the Tm and Tamb. This model was implemented as a circuit model using LT-Spice and details of the model and associated parameters are given in the Supplementary Information (see Section 2). Selected simulations of individual and compound NDR characteristics were also performed using the Poole-Frenkel conduction mechanism (see Section 2 of the Supplementary information). Figs. 1b and 1c show representative switching characteristics that highlight the threshold switching and NDR responses observed under voltage and current-controlled testing, respectively. Such characteristics are the result of an increase in device conductance induced by local Joule heating and are accurately reproduced by lumped element models such as the one described above22,28. In contrast, Fig. 1d shows the current-voltage characteristics of a device that exhibits discontinuous I-V characteristics under current-controlled testing, referred to as a "snap-back" response. This behaviour is a generic response observed in many oxides but is not predicted by the archetype lumped element model and clearly involves physical processes not included in the model. Fig. 1 Device structure and current-voltage characteristics. a, Schematic of metal-oxide-metal cross-point device structures used in this study. b, Measured current-voltage characteristic under voltage-controlled operation. c,d, Measured current-voltage characteristics of devices under current-controlled operation showing continuous S-type and discontinuous ("snap-back") behaviour, respectively. 3 Underlying physical mechanism Here we introduce a new model that addresses the above shortcoming and provides a comprehensive understanding of discrete and compound NDR characteristics. This is achieved by explicitly accounting for a non-uniform current (temperature) distribution in the oxide film and its impact on the effective circuit of the device. The response of the oxide film is then heterogeneous, with the hottest region being the first to undergo current-controlled NDR and the cooler regions acting as a parallel resistance. For a strongly peaked temperature distribution, as is the case for filamentary conduction, the distribution can be represented by a core-shell structure comprising the filamentary conduction path (core) and a parallel resistance due to the surrounding film (shell) 26, as shown in Fig. 2 (top). The total device current is then distributed between these two regions, with the magnitude of the parallel resistance depending on the conductivity of the film and the temperature distribution in the device. Although the total device current remains constrained under current controlled operation, the current ratio in the core and shell regions is free to respond to local conductivity changes and can facilitate a sudden reduction in core resistance if the resistance of the shell is sufficiently low. As discussed below, this simple two-zone, core-shell model is sufficient to explain the diverse range of switching phenomena observed in oxide devices, including the snap-back response shown in Fig. 1d. As the core and shell regions represent different areas of the same oxide film, their electrical conductivity is expected to be governed by the same physical mechanism. As a consequence the structure can be represented by two parallel archetype memristors (as defined above), one representing the high-conductivity filament, with resistance Rm1(Ic), and the other the parallel conduction through the surrounding film, with resistance Rm2(Is), as shown in Fig. 2 (top). The total device resistance is then 𝑅𝑑𝑒𝑣 = where both Rm1(Ic) and Rm2(Is) can be negative 𝑅𝑚1𝑅𝑚2 𝑅𝑚1+𝑅𝑚2 within specific current ranges. For a strongly localised current distribution (e.g. filamentary conduction) the core region can be represented by an archetype memristor and the surrounding shell by a fixed (i.e. temperature independent) resistor of resistance 𝑅𝑆 = 𝑅𝑚2(𝐼 = 0). In this case the switching characteristics are determined by the relative magnitudes of the shell resistance 𝑅𝑆 and the maximum negative .When the parallel resistance 𝑅𝑆 differential resistance of the core region 𝑅𝑁𝐷𝑅 = 𝑚𝑎𝑥 𝑑𝑉 𝑁𝐷𝑅 𝑑𝐼 is much larger than 𝑅𝑁𝐷𝑅 the source current, 𝐼𝑠, flows predominantly through the core and gives rise to a continuous S-type NDR characteristics similar to that of the archetype memristor (Fig. 2a). In contrast, when 𝑅𝑆 is less than 𝑅𝑁𝐷𝑅 the current flows mainly through the shell region and can have a lower current density than the core due to their relative areas. In this case the shell resistance effectively acts a current divider that enables the core to respond to the positive feedback created by local Joule heating while maintaining constant total device current. The resulting increase in core conductivity is then analogous to the threshold switching response shown in Fig. 1b and produces the sudden reduction in voltage that characterizes the snap-back response in Fig. 2b. In essence, the current source and parallel shell resistance act as a voltage source for the core memristor and it undergoes voltage-controlled threshold switching when the device voltage exceeds it threshold value, VTh. More generally, it is necessary to consider that both the core and shell regions have temperature dependent conductivities that can be represented by archetype memristors, as shown in Fig. 2c. In this case the resulting NDR characteristics reflect the relative magnitudes and temperature dependencies of the two regions 4 and include a wide range of compound characteristics, an example of which is illustrated in Fig. 2c. Fig. 2 Lumped element models of devices with different core-shell resistance ratios and the calculated switching response. a, The shell resistance is constant and greater than the negative differential resistance of the core. b, The shell resistance is constant and lower than the negative differential resistance of the core. The orange coloured solid line shows the current-voltage curve of Rm1 without the parallel Rs. c, The shell resistance changes with current and is treated as a second memristor. The red and orange coloured solid lines represent the individual current-voltage characteristics of Rm1 and Rm2. Fig. 3 shows more quantitative analysis of these dependencies, including calculated device temperatures (see Section 2 of the Supplementary Information for details of the model). Here the core region of the devices is represented by the same archetype memristor while the shell region is variously represented by a fixed resistor or a second memristor. Fig. 3a shows the differential resistance, dV/dI, derived from the current-voltage characteristics of the core memristor, showing that the absolute maximum of the NDR is ~ 380 Ω at a current of ~315 μA. Based on the above discussion this resistance sets the criterion for the S-type and snap- back responses, with the S-type NDR observed for shell-resistances greater than this value and snap-back NDR observed for shell-resistances less than this value. In this context, the current- voltage characteristic of the isolated core memristor corresponds to the former case with RS >> RNDR (i.e. RS = ∞) and exhibits the expected continuous S-type NDR characteristics, as shown in Fig. 3b. The onset temperature in this case is predicted to be ~450 K, consistent with simulations based on Poole-Frenkel conduction22 and experimental observations25. The counter example is shown if Fig. 3c which depicts the characteristics of the same device but with a parallel shell resistance of 150 Ω, i.e. RS < RNDR. In this case the device exhibits a hysteretic 5 snap-back response similar to that observed experimentally (e.g. Fig. 1d). Significantly, the onset temperature for the snap-back response is similar to that for the S-type response, as expected from their common origin. Indeed, this clearly demonstrates that the snap-back response results from current redistribution between the core and shell regions of the device rather than a material-specific phase transition. Finally, Fig. 3d shows corresponding calculations for a device in which the temperature dependencies of both the core and shell regions are considered. In this case, the shell region is also represented by an archetype memristor albeit with slightly different resistance and temperature dependence than the core. The resulting compound characteristics reflect the relative resistances and temperature dependencies of the core and shell regions and represent only one of many compound responses, as discussed below. Fig. 3 Dynamic resistance and simulated temperature profile. a, The dynamic resistance, dV dI , plotted as a function of Im. The inset shows an expanded area of the region where RNDR is the maximum value of negative differential resistance dV dI . b, Simulated device temperature of continuous S-type NDR with corresponding current-voltage curve with RS >> RNDR. The device temperature profile shows a gradual and continuous increase with increasing current. c, Plot of device temperature and the quasi-static current-voltage curve as a function of current for snap-back NDR with RS < RNDR. The onset temperature remains relatively low at ~450 K and is followed by an abrupt increase in temperature. d, Simulated temperature profile of two active regions for the compound NDR behaviour which consists of one continuous S-type and one snap-back NDRs. Engineering devices with compound characteristics Despite the apparent simplicity of the lumped element core/shell model it has proven sufficient to reproduce a broad range of experimentally observed compound NDR characteristics in our NbOx-based devices. This is highlighted in Fig. 4 which compares a range of predicted and experimentally observed characteristics. For example, Fig. 4a illustrates a case where current 6 flow is initially concentrated in the core region to produce a continuous S-type NDR response at low currents. As the current continues to increase, the temperature of the shell also increases to the point where it exhibits S-type NDR but in this case the core resistance is too high to meet the requirements for a snap-back response. The device therefore exhibits two continuous S- type NDRs. In contrast, Fig. 4b shows a case where the core resistance is sufficient low at high currents to meet the requirements for a snap-back response in the shell region. This produces one continuous S-type NDR and a snap-back NDR, similar to the reported behaviour25. The final example, Fig. 4c, corresponds to a case where the conditions for a snap-back response are met by both the core and shell regions, thereby resulting in a double snap-back response. Significantly, each of these characteristics has been observed experimentally in discrete devices, as shown in Figs. 4d-f. Experimentally, the characteristics are determined by the film stoichiometry, device structure and operating conditions (i.e. current compliance during electroforming or maximum operating current). Fig. 4 Compound NDR characteristics in individual and coupled devices. Simulation predicted compound NDR characteristics for two parallel memristors that exhibit continuous S-type NDR, including: a, the co- existence of two continuous NDR regions. b, one continuous S-type NDR with one snap-back NDR c, two snap- back NDR regions. d-f, Experimentally measured compound NDR characteristics for individual NbOx devices. g-i, Experimentally measured compound NDR characteristics for coupled NbOx devices formed by combining two discrete devices in parallel; The response of the individual devices is included for reference. Note: all the compound behaviours have also been simulated and predicted with the Poole-Frenkel conduction (Fig. S4 in the Supplementary Information). 7 It is interesting to note that the above discussion does not explicitly require that the shell resistance Rm2(Is) be a component of the active device. It could instead be a separate circuit element such as an external resistor or a second memristor. Indeed, when an external parallel resistor is added to a device exhibiting continuous S-type NDR the characteristics transition from continuous to snap-back NDR behaviour as the resistor is varied to satisfy the criteria discussed above (see Section 1 of the Supplementary Information). More generally, the full complexity of the predicted characteristics (Figs. 4a-c) was reproduced by combining two discrete S-type devices in parallel, as shown in Figs. 4g-i. This is particularly significant because the realization and reproducibility of specific composite NDR characteristics in individual devices can be challenging due to limited control of the core-shell structure, particularly for nanoscale devices where the formation of a distinct core-shell structure is less likely. The ability to control the switching characteristics by combining discrete S-type NDR devices addresses these issues and provides additional flexibility for designing devices with specific functionality. Designing composite behaviour with higher complexity Fig. 5 Simulations of complex NDR characteristics and associated dynamical behaviour. a, Schematic of the oscillator circuit configuration used in the simulation. b, Two memristors that exhibit continuous S-type NDR, an unconventional complex compound NDR behaviour is predicted in simulation which includes a continuous S- type NDR followed by a snap-back response in the forward current sweep and two continuous S-type NDRs regions in the reverse sweep. c-d, Current oscillations in time domain and the corresponding recurrence plot (∆t = 0.6 μs) at an applied DC voltage pulse of 7.5 V. e-f, Current oscillations in time domain and the corresponding recurrence plot (∆t = 0.6 μs) with a DC voltage pulse input of 8.7V. 8 From the above understanding it is also possible to understand and engineer devices with unique I-V characteristics and functionality. As an example, Fig. 5 shows the equivalent circuit and predicted characteristics of a novel compound device with higher complexity. The I-V characteristics show combined S-type and snap-back responses during a forward current- sweep and two continuous S-type responses during a reverse current sweep. The dynamic behaviour of this compound NDR response was studied using a Pearson-Anson oscillator circuit (Fig. 5a) with a load resistor of 2 kΩ, a 50 Ω monitoring resistor, an external parallel 100 nF capacitor and an intrinsic capacitance of 1 nF (see Section 3 of the Supplementary Information for details of the model). The results show two types of oscillation dynamics. For an input voltage pulse of 7.5 V the device exhibits periodic oscillations with high peak-to-peak amplitude, as shown in Fig. 5c and validated in the recurrence plot of Fig. 5d. In contrast, when the input voltage is increased to ~8.7 V the system exhibits irregular or chaotic-like characteristics with lower peak-to-peak amplitude (Fig. 5e). The irregularity of the oscillation is confirmed by the recurrent plot (Fig. 5f). Complex and compound NDR behaviours with even higher order of complexity were also predicted with triple memristors in parallel (see Section 4 of the Supplementary Information). We note that characteristics similar to those depicted in Fig. 4a have been realized experimentally and are the subject of further study. However, this example serves to illustrate the potential of the simple core-shell model for exploring devices with novel functionality. Conclusions A material-independent model of current-controlled negative differential resistance was introduced and shown to explain a broad range of reported switching characteristics, including the so-called "snap-back" response observed in transition metal-oxides. The model assumed a non-uniform current distribution in the film and took account of its effect on the equivalent circuit of the device. For highly localized current distributions this amounted to approximating the film by a core-shell structure in which the core was treated as an archetype memristor and the shell was approximated as a parallel resistor. In this case the continuous and snap-back switching modes were shown to depend on the relative resistances of the core and shell regions. The model was then extended to include the case where both the core and shell have memristive behaviour. This demonstrated that the continuous S-type and snap-back responses serve as fundamental building blocks for NDR characteristics with higher complexity and novel functionality for future electronics and emerging computing paradigm. 9 References 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Yu, S. Neuro-inspired computing with emerging nonvolatile memorys. Proc. IEEE 106, 260-285 (2018). Liu, X., Li, S., Nandi, S. K., Venkatachalam, D. K. & Elliman, R. G. Threshold switching and electrical self-oscillation in niobium oxide films. J. Appl. Phys. 120, 124102 (2016). Kumar, S., Strachan, J. P. & Williams, R. S. Chaotic dynamics in nanoscale NbO2 Mott memristors for analogue computing. Nature 548, 318 (2017). Sharma, A. A., Li, Y., Skowronski, M., Bain, J. A. & Weldon, J. A. High-Frequency TaOx-Based Compact Oscillators. IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev. 62, 3857-3862 (2015). Mian, M. S., Okimura, K. & Sakai, J. Self-oscillation up to 9 MHz based on voltage triggered switching in VO2/TiN point contact junctions. J. Appl. Phys. 117, 215305 (2015). Parihar, A., Shukla, N., Jerry, M., Datta, S. & Raychowdhury, A. Vertex coloring of graphs via phase dynamics of coupled oscillatory networks. Sci. Rep. 7, 911 (2017). Zhao, B. & Ravichandran. Low-Power Microwave Relaxation Oscillators Based on Phase-Change Oxides for Neuromorphic Computing. Phys. Rev. Appl 11, 014020 (2019). Lappalainen, J., Mizsei, J. & Huotari, M. Neuromorphic thermal-electric circuits based on phase-change VO2 thin-film memristor elements. J. Appl. Phys. 125, 044501 (2019). Pickett, M. D. & Williams, R. S. Phase transitions enable computational universality in neuristor-based cellular automata. Nanotechnology 24, 384002 (2013). Yi, W. et al. Biological plausibility and stochasticity in scalable VO2 active memristor neurons. Nat. Commun. 9, 4661 (2018). Pickett, M. D., Medeiros-Ribeiro, G. & Williams, R. S. A scalable neuristor built with Mott memristors. Nat. Mater. 12, 114 (2013). Kumar, S. & Williams, R. S. Separation of current density and electric field domains caused by nonlinear electronic instabilities. Nat. Commun. (2018). Ridley, B. Specific negative resistance in solids. Proc. Phys. Soc. Lond. 82, 954 (1963). 14 Wang, M. et al. S-Type Negative Differential Resistance in Semiconducting Transition-Metal Dichalcogenides. Adv. Elec. Mater., 1800853 (2019). Ovshinsky, S. R. Reversible electrical switching phenomena in disordered structures. Phys. Rev. Lett. 21, 1450 (1968). Czubatyj, W. & Hudgens, S. J. Thin-film Ovonic threshold switch: Its operation and application in modern integrated circuits. Electron. Mater. Lett. 8, 157-167 (2012). Park, J. H. et al. Measurement of a solid-state triple point at the metal -- insulator transition in VO2. Nature 500, 431 (2013). Imada, M., Fujimori, A. & Tokura, Y. Metal-insulator transitions. Rev. Mod. Phys. 70, 1039 (1998). Li, S., Liu, X., Nandi, S. K. & Elliman, R. G. Anatomy of filamentary threshold switching in amorphous niobium oxide. Nanotechnology 29, 375705 (2018). Funck, C. et al. Multidimensional simulation of threshold switching in NbO2 based on an electric field triggered thermal runaway model. Adv. Elec. Mater. 2, 1600169 (2016). Goodwill, J. M., Sharma, A. A., Li, D., Bain, J. A. & Skowronski, M. Electro-thermal model of threshold switching in TaOx-based devices. ACS Appl. Mater. Interf. 9, 11704-11710 (2017). 10 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Slesazeck, S. et al. Physical model of threshold switching in NbO2 based memristors. RSC Adv. 5, 102318-102322 (2015). Gibson, G. A. et al. An accurate locally active memristor model for S-type negative differential resistance in NbOx. Appl. Phys. Lett. 108, 023505 (2016). Gibson, G. A. Designing Negative Differential Resistance Devices Based on Self- Heating. Adv. Funct. Mater. 28, 1704175 (2018). Kumar, S. et al. Physical origins of current and temperature controlled negative differential resistances in NbO2. Nat. Commun. 8, 658 (2017). Goodwill, J. M. et al. Spontaneous current constriction in threshold switching devices. Nat. Commun. 10, 1628 (2019). Chen, T., Tse, M., Sun, C., Fung, S. & Lo, K. Snapback behaviour and its similarity to the switching behaviour in ultra-thin silicon dioxide films after hard breakdown. J. Phys. D. Appl. Phys. 34, L95 (2001). Suntola, T. On the mechanism of switching effects in chalcogenide thin films. Solid State Electron. 14, 933-938 (1971). Janninck, R. & Whitmore, D. Electrical conductivity and thermoelectric power of niobium dioxide. J. Phys. Chem. Solids 27, 1183-1187 (1966). Adler, D. Mechanisms for metal-nonmental transitions in transition-metal oxides and sulfides. Rev. Mod. Phys. 40, 714 (1968). Eyert, V. The metal-insulator transition of NbO2: An embedded Peierls instability. EPL 58, 851 (2002). Nath, S. K., Nandi, S. K., Li, S. & Elliman, R. G. Detection and spatial mapping of conductive filaments in metal/oxide/metal cross-point devices using a thin photoresist layer. Appl. Phys. Lett. 114, 062901 (2019). 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Acknowledgements This work was partly funded by the Australian Research Council (ARC) and Varian Semiconductor Equipment/ Applied Materials through an ARC Linkage Project Grant: LP150100693. We would like to acknowledge access to NCRIS facilities at the ACT node of the Australian Nanotechnology Fabrication Facility (ANFF) and the Australian Facility for Advanced ion-implantation Research (AFAiiR), and thank Dr Tom Ratcliff for comments and feedback on the manuscript. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Author contributions S.L., X. L. and R.G. E. conceived the concept. S.L. and X.L. performed the simulations of the models. S.L., S.K.N and S.K.N. fabricated the devices and performed experimental measurements. S.L. and R.G.E. wrote the manuscript. All authors discussed the results and implications and commented on the manuscript at all stages. 11 Supplementary Information 1. Device Controllability of NDR Figure S1. Current-voltage plots of NDR tunability via an external resistor in parallel with a crossbar NbOx memristor. The external resistance was applied in the range from 600 Ω to 170 Ω with transitions from continuous S-type NDR to snap-back NDR. Table S1. Measured device structures. Data Fig. 1e, Fig. 4e Fig. 1d Fig 4d, 4g-i Fig 4f Top electrode thickness (nm) NbOx (nm) NbOx composition, x Bottom electrode and thickness (nm) Device dimension Pt(25)/Nb(10) Pt(25)/Nb(10) Pt(25)/Ti(5) Pt(50) 50 50 50 50 2.15±0.05 2.60±0.05 2.60±0.05 Pt (25) Pt (25) Pt (25) 2.60±0.05 TiN(50) 10 μm x 10 μm 10 μm x 10 μm 10 μm x 10 μm 50 μm diameter CV pad 1 2. SPICE Models for archetype threshold switching memristor Figure S2. a, SPICE model for threshold switching memristor based on Joule heating and an electrical conductivity with a power-law dependence (equation 1 and 2). b, SPICE model for threshold switching memristor based on Joule heating and standard Poole-Frenkel conduction. Figure S3. a, SPICE equivalent circuit of a core-shell structure for one active memristor and a passive parallel resistor in parallel. b, SPICE equivalent circuit of a core-shell structure for two active memristors in parallel. 2 Table S2. Memristor parameters used in simulation for the generic conductivity model. Model Parameters (Unit) Thermal capacitance (J⋅K- 1) Resistance prefactor (kΩ) Thermal resistance (K⋅W−1) Ambient temperature (K) Superlinear coefficient Shell resistance (Ω) Metallic state resistance (Ω) Symbol Cth Rm1 Value 1×10-15 Rm2 Value 1×10-15 R0 α Tamb γ Rs Rv 15 to 30 15 to 30 1.6×106 to 1.8 ×106 1.1×106 to 1.6 ×106 296.15 2 to 3 150 50 to 200 296.15 2 to 3.5 N/A 70 to 100 Table S3. Memristor parameters used in simulation for the Poole-Frenkel conduction model. Model Parameters (Unit) Symbo Rm1 Value Rm2 Value Thermal capacitance (J⋅K-1) Resistance prefactor (Ω) Thermal resistance (K⋅W−1) Ambient temperature (K) Shell resistance (Ω) Metallic state resistance (Ω) Activation Energy (eV) Boltzmann constant (J⋅K-1) Elementary charge (C) Vacuum permittivity (F⋅m-1) Relative permittivity of the threshold switching volume Thickness of the threshold switching volume (nm) l Cth R0 α Tamb Rs Rv Ea kB e ε0 εr tv 1×10-15 25 to 75 1×10-15 25 1.3×105 to 1×106 2.2×105 to 1×106 296.15 100 0 0.215 1.38×10-23 1.6×10-19 8.85×10-12 45 296.15 N/A 0 0.215 to 0.225 1.38×10-23 1.6×10-19 8.85×10-12 45 20 to 30 50 to 125 3 Figure S4. a, simulated S-type NDR response. b, Simulated discontinuous snap-back characteristics. the co-existence of two continuous NDR regions. c, Co-existence of one continuous S-type NDR with one snap-back NDR d, Predicted compound characteristics with two snap-back NDR regions. e, Composite behaviour with two snap-back NDR regions. f, Composite behaviour with higher complexity. 3. SPICE Model for dynamical behaviour Table S4. Memristor parameters used in dynamical simulation based on the Poole-Frenkel conduction model. Model Parameters (Unit) Symbo Rm1 Value Rm2 Value Thermal capacitance (J⋅K-1) Resistance prefactor (Ω) Thermal resistance (K⋅W−1) Ambient temperature (K) Metallic state resistance (Ω) Activation Energy (eV) Boltzmann constant (J⋅K-1) Elementary charge (C) Vacuum permittivity (F⋅m-1) Relative permittivity of the threshold switching volume Thickness of the threshold switching volume (nm) l Cth R0 α Tamb Rv Ea kB e ε0 εr tv 2.5×10-14 47 1.5×105 296.15 0 0.204 1.38×10-23 1.6×10-19 8.85×10-12 45 19 4 2.5×10-14 110 4.2×105 296.15 0 0.202 1.38×10-23 1.6×10-19 8.85×10-12 45 24 4. Predicted compound NDR behaviour with triple memristors in parallel Figure S5. a-b, Examples of simulated compound NDR characteristics with three memristors in parallel. 5
1810.00572	1	1810	2018-10-01T08:24:05	Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	We investigated the influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe radiation detectors by comparing experimental data with numerical simulations based on simultaneous solution of drift-diffusion and Posisson equations, including the Shockley-Read-Hall model of the carrier trapping. We determined the Schottky barrier height and the Fermi level position from I-V measurements. We measured the time evolution of the electric field and the electrical current after application of a voltage bias. We observed that the electrical properties of CZTS are fundamentally governed by two deep levels close to the mid-bandgap - one recombination and one hole trap. We show that the hole trap indirectly increases the mobility-lifetime product of electrons. We conclude that the structure of deep levels in CZTS are favorable for high electrical charge transport.	physics.app-ph	physics	Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors M Rejhon1, J Franc1, V Dedic1, J Pek´arek1, U N Roy2, R Grill1 and R B James3 E-mail: [email protected] 1 Charles University, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Institute of Physics, Ke Karlovu 5, Cz-121 16 Prague 2, Czech Republic 2 Nonproliferation and National Security Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York, USA 3 Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, South Carolina 29808, USA Abstract. We investigated the influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe radiation detectors by comparing experimental data with numerical simulations based on simultaneous solution of drift-diffusion and Posisson equations, including the Shockley-Read-Hall model of the carrier trapping. We determined the Schottky barrier height and the Fermi level position from I-V measurements. We measured the time evolution of the electric field and the electrical current after application of a voltage bias. We observed that the electrical properties of CZTS are fundamentally governed by two deep levels close to the mid-bandgap - one recombination and one hole trap. We show that the hole trap indirectly increases the mobility-lifetime product of electrons. We conclude that the structure of deep levels in CZTS are favorable for high electrical charge transport. Keywords: CdZnTeSe, I-V measurement, electric field, deep level, radiation detector Submitted to: J. Appl. Phys. 1. Introduction CdZnTeSe (CZTS) has been a focus of research interest as a material for hard X- ray and gamma-ray room temperature semiconductor detectors [1, 2, 3]. So far, Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 2 the semiconductor material of choice is CdZnTe (CZT) with 10-15% of Zn content [4, 5, 6, 7]. It was demonstrated that the addition of Se to the CZT matrix results in effective lattice hardening and a reduction of Te inclusions and dislocations, which did not form a cellular structure like CZT [8, 9]. Apparently, it is a consequence of a decrease in the lattice constant by 0.41 A/mol [8]. It was also observed that CZTS crystals exhibit better crystallinity than CZT, which can lead to a larger yield of high-quality material with comparable electrical and spectroscopic properties as CdTe and CZT materials [9]. The electrical charge transport in semiconductor detectors is affected by the material properties, such as deep levels and metal-semiconductor interfaces. The deep levels can act as trapping centers or recombination centers [10, 11]. These are formed by the presence of defects, such as sub-grain boundaries, Te inclusions/precipitates, impurities and compositional inhomogeneity [12, 13]. In the current study we investigated the deep levels that influence the time and temperature dependence of the electrical current, carrier trapping and recombination of photo-generated charge. We applied measurements of I-V characteristics and electro-optic Pockels effect in this work. We also simulated the results using drift- diffusion and Poisson equations, including the influence of the Shockley-Read-Hall model. 2. Experimental We investigated a CZTS sample with 4% Se and 10% Zn fabricated by the travelling heat method (THM). We chose a sample with a moderate µτ product for electrons (≈ 1 × 10−3 cm2/Vs) in order to understand how deep levels influence its electron- transport properties and may limit the detector performance. The sample dimensions were 6.50 × 5.30 × 2.68 mm3. The sample surfaces were mechanically polished with Al2O3 abrasive (surface RMS of 2 nm) without any further chemical treatment. To measure the I-V characteristics and electric field profile, we deposited gold and indium contacts on the larger opposite sides by evaporation. The motivation to use different metals for the opposite contacts was derived from our experience with CZT, where band bending upwards occurs at the Au/CZT interface and downwards at the In/CZT interface. The Au cathode then blocks electrons while the In anode blocks holes. In Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 3 this way a decrease of the dark current can be achieved independent of the position of the Fermi level, which is located close to mid-bandgap for this high-resistivity material. The gold contact was equipped with a guard ring to separate the bulk and surface leakage currents during the electrical measurements. The I-V characteristics were measured at 300 K. A Keithley 2410 sourcemeter was used to bias the sample, and a Keithley 6514 electrometer was used to measure the bulk current on a serial 1 MΩ resistor. The sample resistivity was evaluated from the I-V curve around zero voltage, and the Schottky barrier height was determined from the I-V characteristics at high applied voltages. We evaluated the time evolution of the electric field and the electrical current after application of a voltage bias at temperatures of 290 K, 300 K and 310 K. The electro- optic Pockels effect was used to measure the electric field in the CZTS sample. A standard setup consisted of a testing light, two polarizers and an InGaAs camera. The sample was placed between two crossed polarizers, and testing light at a wavelength of 1550 nm passed through the sample. The transmitted light distribution T (x, y) was collected by an InGaAs camera (figure 1). The electric field distribution E(x, y) depends on the transmittance as E(x, y) ∼ arcsin(cid:112)T (x, y). More details about the measurement setup and evaluation of the electric field profiles can be found in our previous articles [14, 15]. The time and temperature evolutions of the electric field and the current after the application of a voltage bias were compared with a numerical simulation based on the solution of the drift-diffusion and Poisson equations, including the Shockley-Read-Hall model [16]. Figure 1. Scheme of the experimental setup used for measurement of the electric field in CZTS. LED1550nmCollimatorCZTSInGaAscameraPolarizerAnalyzer1550nm bandpass filterAInfluence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 4 3. Results and Discussion 3.1. I-V measurements The I-V measurement of bulk current in the range from −800 V up to +800 V at 300 K is shown in figure 2(a). We evaluated the sample resistivity = 1.1× 1010 Ωcm from the I-V curve between −1 and +1 V using Ohm's law (figure 2(b)). The Fermi level EF is connected to resistivity by the equation: (cid:104) µeNc exp(cid:0) EF kT (cid:1) + µhNv exp 1 = (cid:16) (−EF −EG) (cid:17)(cid:105) , kT (1) where µe and µh are the electron and hole mobility, respectively. Nc,v is the effective density of states for electrons (holes) in the conduction (valence) band, k is the Boltzmann constant, T is the absolute temperature and EG is the bandgap energy (EG = 1.52 eV [17]). The general carrier mobilities for electrons µe ≈ 1100 cm2V−1s−1 and for holes µh ≈ 80 cm2V−1s−1 were used [18, 19]. We observed from thermoelectric power measurements a slight n-type conductivity for sample. Therefore, we assume that the calculated Fermi EF = Ec − 0.727 eV. level is related to the conduction band minimum at Figure 2. The I-V characteristics of In/CZTS/Au sample measured at 300 K (black squares) and simulated I-V curve (red circles) are plotted in graph (a). The graph (b) shows the I-V curve around zero voltage with a linear fit (Ohm's law). A sample resistivity = 1.10 × 1010 Ωcm was determined. The Schottky barrier heights were computed using Eq. (2) from the experimental data (graph (c)). The I-V curve at high voltage due to the Schottky barrier height φB and Schottky barrier lowering ∆φB is given by the equation [20] (cid:18) − φB − ∆φB kT (cid:19) , (cid:113) 2eNt j = A(cid:63)T 2 exp (cid:113) eE where A(cid:63) is the Richardson constant. The Schottky barrier lowering in the simplest form is ∆φB = e 4πε and the electric field is E = ε U . Here, e is the elementary (2) 8006004002000200400600800Voltage on In contact (V)8642024j(A·cm−2)1e8(a)Temperature 300KExperimental dataModel1.00.50.00.51.0Voltage on In contact (V)101234567j(A·cm−2)1e10(b)Sample resistivity=1.1±0.1×1010 ΩcmDataLinear fit3.84.04.24.44.64.85.05.25.4Voltage1/4 (V1/4)5.95.85.75.65.55.45.35.25.15.0ln(j)(A·cm−2)1e8(c)Schottky barrier height: φAuB = 0.96± 0.02 eVφInB = 0.90± 0.02 eVData from 220V to 800VData from - 220V to - 800VLinear fitInfluence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 5 charge, ε is the absolute permittivity, Nt is the deep level concentration, and U is the applied bias. If the current dependence ln(j) versus U 1/4 is linear, this model based on Schottky barrier height and barrier lowering due to the applied high voltage is valid. The relation between ln(j) and U 1/4 for voltages in the range of 220 − 800 V for both polarities is presented in figure 2(c). The current flow at high voltage is limited by the Schottky barrier height at both polarities. It means that the bands bend at both interfaces (Au/CZTS and In/CZTS) upwards. We evaluated the Schottky barrier height at the Au/CZTS interface as B = 0.96 ± 0.02 eV and at the In/CZTS interface as φIn φAu B = 0.90 ± 0.02 eV. 3.2. Dynamics of the electric field and current plus simulations We also measured the time evolution of the electrical current after application of a bias, together with measurements of the internal electric field at 290 K, 300 K and 310 K using the electro-optic Pockels effect. The measured data of the bulk electrical current and electric field under the cathode are shown in figure 3 (solid lines). The electrical current strongly decreases within approximately the first two seconds. Then, it starts to increase over time. The electric field under the cathode has an opposite course (it inceases within the first two seconds, and then it starts to decrease). We simulated the temporal evolution of the electric field and the electrical current using the solution of the drift-diffusion and Poisson equations including the Shockley- Read-Hall model [21, 22]. The simulated data are depicted in figure 3 (dashed lines). The parameters used for the simulation are listed in Table 1. We were able to fix a number of parameters from experimental data, and in this way we increased the reliability of the simulations. The Schottky barrier heights at the In/CZTS and Au/CZTS interfaces were set from the evaluation of the I-V characteristics (figure 2). The band-gap energy was set from the results of ellipsometry measurements [17]. The Fermi level position was calculated according to Eq. (1). The energies of the deep levels were set based on results of the evaluation of temperature and time evolution of the electrical field by Pockels effect studied in detail in our article [17]. The capture cross-sections of deep levels were used as fitting parameters. We applied the experimentally determined values of electron capture cross-section of level E1 and hole capture cross-section of level E2 as initial values for fitting. The resulting Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 6 Table 1. Parameters of the deep levels using in the simulations Deep levels: Energy (eV) Concentration (cm−3) σn (cm2) σp (cm2) 2.68 1.52 800 General condition: Bias on In electrode (V) Sample properties: Thickness (mm) Bandgap energy (eV) Fermi level energy (eV) Schottky barrier height (eV) EF = Ec − 0.727 φAu = 0.96/φIn = 0.90 E1 Ec − 0.836 2.8 × 1011 5.0 × 10−13 7.5 × 10−16 E2 Ec − 0.697 5.4 × 1011 1.1 × 10−25 7.0 × 10−15 optimal values (Table 1) are 1 − 2 orders of magnitude smaller. These set of fitting parameters presented in Table 1 lead to a very good agreement between experiment and simulated data (figure 3). According to simulation results the level E1 is acting as a recombination center with a higher capture cross-section for electrons than for holes. The deep level E2 is in the model a pure hole trap. The results of the simulation show that the electrical current is predominantly formed by the flow of injected free holes due to the band bending upwards at the interfaces. The Au/CZTS interface blocks electrons in the regime of application of a positive voltage on the In contact. The In/CZTS interface injects the holes into the volume of the sample. The damped oscillatory character with undershoots of both the electric current and of the electric field under the cathode is caused by the change of occupancy of deep levels over time. The computed deep level's occupancies by electrons are depicted in figure 4. The presented profiles and their evolution in time can be described by the following series of processes. At first holes are injected from the In anode within 0.1 sec after application of the bias and are captured on both deep levels. This effect causes a strong decrease in the occupation of both deep levels, especially for those close to the anode (see the dashed lines showing the occupancy profiles after 0.13 sec in figures 4(a,b)). The simplified scheme describing these processes is plotted in figure 5(a). This leads to an increase of the positive space charge in the sample. Due to the formed positive space charge, the electric field under the cathode increases. After that, the higher electric field depletes the holes from the volume near the cathode, which leads to a higher emission of captured holes from the deep level E2 accompanied by an increase of its occupancy (see profiles after 1.9 sec and 4 sec in figure 4(b) and schemes in figure 5(b)). This process causes the subsequent decrease of the positive space charge, which induces a Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 7 Figure 3. Time evolution of the electric field under the cathode (black solid line) and the electric current (red solid line) after switching on the bias at different temperatures. The numerical simulation of the electric field evolution under the cathode is represented by a black dashed line and the current is represented by red dashed line. decrease of the electric field below the cathode. The electrical current increases due to the higher amount of free holes. The graph 4(c) shows that the deep level E1 is monotonously discharged (electron transfer from the level) over time (black squares with dashed line). On the other hand, the integrated occupancy of the deep level E2 exhibits an undershoot, which induces the undershoot in the electric field. The profiles of the free holes in the valence band are depicted in figure 4(d). The I-V curve was simulated by using the solution of the drift-diffusion with respect to a Schottky barrier lowering and Poisson equations including the Shockley- 0102030405060Time (s)300035004000450050005500Ecathode(V/cm)290KEexpEsim051015202530Time (s)300035004000450050005500Ecathode(V/cm)300KEexpEsim02468101214Time (s)300035004000450050005500Ecathode(V/cm)310KEexpEsim0.00.20.40.60.81.0j(A·cm−2)1e7jexpjsim0.20.30.40.50.60.70.80.91.0j(A·cm−2)1e7jexpjsim0.60.81.01.21.4j(A·cm−2)1e7jexpjsimInfluence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 8 Figure 4. The graph (a) shows the deep level E1 occupancy. The deep level E2 occupancy is depicted on graph (b). The graph (c) exhibits the integrated deep level occupancy for deep level E1 as black squares and for deep level E2 as blue circles. The distribution of free holes in the valence band is plotted on graph (d). Figure 5. Simplified scheme of trapping and de-trapping of carriers. Scheme (a) is plotted for time 0.01 s after bias application. The carriers are injected from the contact into the bulk, where they are trapped at the deep levels. Scheme (b) shows the steady- state at 20 s after switching on the bias. 0.00.51.01.52.02.5Distance from anode (mm)707580859095Deep level E1 occupancy (%)(a)0.01s0.13s1.9s4s20s0.00.51.01.52.02.5Distance from anode (mm)05101520Deep level E2 occupancy (%)(b)0.01s0.13s1.9s4s20s05101520Time (sec)808284868890929496Integrated deep level E1 occupancy (%)(c)0.00.51.01.52.02.5Distance from anode (mm)106107108109p (cm−3)(d)0.01s0.13s1.9s4s20s8101214161820Integrated deep level E2 occupancy (%)+++++--++In+Au-Time: 0.01 sTime: 20 s-+++---+++++--+++++-+-+---+-++-++-++-+---++++-+-+-+---+--+-+-EcEcEvEvE2E2E1E1++++(a)(b)+++Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors 9 Read-Hall model. The result of the simulated I-V curve is depicted in figure 2(a). There is a good agreement in the regime with a positive voltage on the In contact. The opposite regime (negative voltage on the In contact) shows a mismatch between experiment and simulation. It can be caused by a more complex character of the defect structure of the material extending beyond the simplified two-level model. However, we assume that these two deep levels are the main ones responsible for the undershoot in the electric field and of the current evolution. Figure 6 shows the results of simulations for the electron µτ product for the case of only one level E1 and the case with both levels E1 + E2. The mean of the electron µτ E1 product is 0.59× 10−3 cm2V−1. The electron µτ E1+E2 product for the case with both levels is 1.16 × 10−3 cm2V−1, which agrees with the experimentally determined e = 1.10 × 10−3 cm2V−1. The electron µτ product is higher for the case value µτ exp with both levels due to the presence of the hole deep level E2. This level communicates dominantly with the valence band and acts as a hole trap. It reduces the concentration of free holes and in this way also transitions electrons from the recombination trap E1 to the valence band. The occupancy of the level E1 with electrons is increased, transitions of electrons from the conduction band to the level E1 decreased and the mobility-lifetime product of electrons increased. Figure 6. The profiles of the electron µτ product based on simulations with and without the deep level E2. 4. Conclusions We investigated the deep levels that influence the carrier transport and performance of detector-grade CZST using the I-V characteristics, Pockels effect and numerical simulations based on the Shockley-Read-Hall model. We determined the Schottky barrier height and the Fermi level position in the CZTS sample. These parameters 0.00.51.01.52.02.5Distance from anode (mm)0.20.40.60.81.01.21.4µτ×10−3 (cm2V−1)µτE1+E2mean = 1.16×10−3 cm2V−1µτE1mean = 0.59×10−3 cm2V−1only E1E1 and E2Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors10 describing the sample, supplemented with our previous results about deep levels in the material, were used in the simulation of the electric field and electrical current evolution over time. We achieved a very good agreement between the experimental and simulated data using a model with one deep recombination and one deep hole trap. The hole trap increases the mobility-lifetime product of electrons by decreasing the concentration of free holes and in this way increasing the electron occupancy of the deep recombination trap. We conclude that the deep levels in CZTS have a favourable structure for high electric-charge transport, which is critical for producing high-performance X-ray and gamma-ray detectors. Acknowledgments This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Defense Nuclear Nonproliferation Research and Development, DNN R&D. This paper was also financially supported by the Grant Agency of Czech Republic (GA CR), project 102-18-06818S and student project SVV -- 2018 -- 260445. References [1] Bezsmolnyy Y 2001 Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 458 461 -- 463 ISSN 0168- 9002 proc. of the 11th Internat. Workshop on Room Temperature Semiconductor X- and Gamma-Ray Detectors and Associated Electronics [2] Roy U N, Bolotnikov A E, Camarda G, Cui Y, Hossain A, Lee K, Lee W, Tappero R, Yang G, Cui Y, Burger A and James R B 2015 Journal of Crystal Growth 411 34 -- 37 ISSN 00220248 [3] Roy U N, Bolotnikov A E, Camarda G S, Cui Y, Hossain A, Lee K, Lee W, Tappero R, Yang G, Gul R and James R B 2015 APL Materials 3 026102 (Preprint https://doi.org/10.1063/ 1.4907250) [4] Schlesinger T E, Toney J E, Yoon H, Lee E, Brunett B, Franks L and James R B 2001 Materials Science and Engineering: R: Reports 32 103 -- 189 ISSN 0927-796X [5] Iniewski K 2016 Journal of Instrumentation 11 C12034 [6] Wahl C G, Kaye W, Wang W, Zhang F, Jaworski J, Boucher Y A, King A and He Z 2014 Polaris-h measurements and performance 2014 IEEE NUCLEAR SCIENCE SYMPOSIUM AND MEDICAL IMAGING CONFERENCE (NSS/MIC) IEEE (345 E 47TH ST, NEW YORK, NY 10017 USA: IEEE) ISBN 978-1-4799-6097-2 iEEE Nuclear Science Symposium / Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC), Seattle, WA, NOV 08-15, 2014 [7] Krawczynski H S, Stern D, Harrison F A, Kislat F F, Zajczyk A, Beilicke M, Hoormann J, Guo Q, Endsley R, Ingram A R, Miyasaka H, Madsen K K, Aaron K M, Amini R, Baring Influence of deep levels on the electrical transport properties of CdZnTeSe detectors11 M G, Beheshtipour B, Bodaghee A, Booth J, Borden C, Bottcher M, Christensen F E, Coppi P S, Cowsik R, Davis S, Dexter J, Done C, Dominguez L A, Ellison D, English R J, Fabian A C, Falcone A, Favretto J A, Fern´andez R, Giommi P, Grefenstette B W, Kara E, Lee C H, Lyutikov M, Maccarone T, Matsumoto H, McKinney J, Mihara T, Miller J M, Narayan R, Natalucci L, Ozel F, Pivovaroff M J, Pravdo S, Psaltis D, Okajima T, Toma K and Zhang W W 2016 Astroparticle Physics 75 8 -- 28 ISSN 09276505 [8] Tanaka A, Masa Y, Seto S and Kawasaki T 1989 Journal of Crystal Growth 94 166 -- 170 ISSN 0022-0248 [9] Gul R, Roy U N, Camarda G S, Hossain A, Yang G, Vanier P, Lordi V, Varley J and James R B 2017 Journal of Applied Physics 121 125705 (Preprint https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4979012) [10] Buis C, Aillon E G, Lohstroh A, Marrakchi G, Jeynes C and Verger L 2014 Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 735 188 -- 192 ISSN 0168-9002 [11] Bolotnikov A, Camarda G, Cui Y, Yang G, Hossain A, Kim K and James R 2013 Journal of Crystal Growth 379 46 -- 56 ISSN 0022-0248 compound Semiconductors and Scintillators for Radiation Detection Applications: A Special Tribute to the Research of Michael Schieber [12] MacKenzie J, Kumar F J and Chen H 2013 Journal of Electronic Materials 42 3129 -- 3132 ISSN 1543-186X [13] Burger A, Chattopadhyay K, Chen H, Ma X, Ndap J O, Schieber M, Schlesinger T, Yao H, Erickson J and James R 2000 Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 448 586 -- 590 ISSN 0168-9002 [14] Rejhon M, Franc J, Dedic V, Kunc J and Grill R 2016 Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 49 375101 [15] Franc J, Dedic V, Rejhon M, Z´azvorka J, Praus P, Tous J and Sellin P J 2015 Journal of Applied Physics 117 165702 [16] Grill R, Franc J, Elhadidy H, Belas E, S Uxa, Bugar M, Moravec P and Hoschl P 2012 IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 59 2383 -- 2391 ISSN 0018-9499 [17] Rejhon M, Dedic V, Beran L, Roy U N, Franc J and James R B 2018 Investigation of deep levels in cdzntese crystal and their effect on the internal electric field of cdzntese gamma-ray detector (Preprint arXiv:1809.10353) [18] Pousset J, Farella I, Gambino S and Cola A 2016 Journal of Applied Physics 119 105701 [19] Pavesi M, Santi A, Bettelli M, Zappettini A and Zanichelli M 2017 IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 64 2706 -- 2712 ISSN 0018-9499 [20] Sze S and Ng K K c2007 Physics of semiconductor devices 3rd ed (Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley- Interscience) ISBN 978-0-471-14323-9 [21] Hall R N 1952 Phys. Rev. 87(2) 387 -- 387 [22] Shockley W and Read W T 1952 Phys. Rev. 87(5) 835 -- 842
1803.02589	1	1803	2018-03-07T10:52:05	Performing Mathematical Operations using High-Index Acoustic Metamaterials	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	The recent breakthrough in metamaterial-based optical computing devices [Science 343, 160 (2014)] has inspired a quest for similar systems in acoustics, performing mathematical operations on sound waves. So far, acoustic analog computing has been demonstrated using thin planar metamaterials, carrying out the operator of choice in Fourier domain. These so-called filtering metasurfaces, however, are always accompanied with additional Fourier transform sub-blocks, enlarging the computing system and preventing its applicability in miniaturized architectures. Here, employing a simple high-index acoustic slab waveguide, we demonstrate a highly compact and potentially integrable acoustic computing system. The system directly performs mathematical operation in spatial domain and is therefore free of any Fourier bulk lens. Such compact computing system is highly promising for various applications including high throughput image processing, ultrafast equation solving, and real time signal processing.	physics.app-ph	physics	Performing Mathematical Operations using High-Index Acoustic Metamaterials Farzad Zangeneh-Nejad and Romain Fleury* Laboratory of Wave Engineering, EPFL, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland *To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: [email protected] Keywords: Analog computing, Acoustics, Metamaterials, Edge detection, Slab waveguides. The recent breakthrough in metamaterial-based optical computing devices [Science 343, 160 (2014)] has inspired a quest for similar systems in acoustics, performing mathematical operations on sound waves. So far, acoustic analog computing has been demonstrated using thin planar metamaterials, carrying out the operator of choice in Fourier domain. These so-called filtering metasurfaces, however, are always accompanied with additional Fourier transform sub-blocks, enlarging the computing system and preventing its applicability in miniaturized architectures. Here, employing a simple high-index acoustic slab waveguide, we demonstrate a highly compact and potentially integrable acoustic computing system. The system directly performs mathematical operation in spatial domain and is therefore free of any Fourier bulk lens. Such compact computing system is highly promising for various applications including high throughput image processing, ultrafast equation solving, and real time signal processing. 1. Introduction The idea of analog computation dates back to the early 19th century, when a number of mechanical and electronic computing machines intended for simple mathematical operations such as differentiation or integration were developed [1,2]. Such analog computing devices were then totally overshadowed by the emergence of their digital counterparts in the second half of 20th century, as they could not compete with the speed and reliability of digital data processors [3]. The recent breakthrough in the seemingly unrelated field of metamaterials [4- 20], however, is bringing them back into the competition as an important alternative computational approach at the hardware level, with highly promising applications in ultrafast equation solving [21,22], real-time and continuous signal processing [23], and imaging [24]. In their inspiring proposal, Silva, et.al [25] proposed the first realization of computational metamaterials, performing various mathematical operations including differentiation, integration and convolution on electromagnetic waves. Such wave-based computational scheme then formed the basis for chains of ultrafast and highly efficient optical computing devices [26-39], all allowing one to go beyond the limitations of conventional analog computers. In a general classification, all of the proposed metamaterial-based computing devices can be divided into two different categories according to the approach that is taken for the computation. In the first approach, the operator of choice is carried out by a thin planar metamaterial in Fourier domain. This approach, usually known as metasurface (MS) approach in the literature [25,26], involves the use of two additional graded index (GRIN) bulk lenses applying Fourier transform (FT) on the input and output signals of the filtering metasurface. The inevitable use of GRIN lenses drastically increases the overall size of these types of computing systems, in turn hindering their applicability in compact architectures. The second approach, usually regarded as Green's function (GF) method, however, overcomes this limitation by not doing the computation in Fourier domain. In fact, as its name suggests, the approach relies on engineering the metamaterial block itself so that its Green's function follows that of the operator of choice. Although the available bandwidth when using this approach is often substantially reduced, the resulting computing device is highly compact and potentially integrable as it avoids the usage of FT sub-blocks [25,31]. Motivated by the renewed interest in optical analog computing, there has been a quest for similar acoustic systems carrying out mathematical operations on sound waves. As a matter of fact, some acoustic computational devices have already been demonstrated utilizing transmissive [40] or reflective metasurfaces [41], offering platforms for efficient acoustic wave manipulation [42,43]. The underlying computing principle in such systems, however, relies on MS method. Consequently, the filtering metasurface is always accompanied with additional focusing metasurfaces taking the role of FT blocks, a fact which enlarges the resulting acoustic device as mentioned and, in turn, prevents its practical and flexible usage in miniaturized systems. Here, we propose and demonstrate an acoustic computing system whose underling working principle is based on GF method, meaning that the metamaterial block carries out the computation directly in spatial domain, without any need for additional Fourier lenses. We show how the proposed system is capable of performing different mathematical operations such as first or second order differentiation, and integration. We further demonstrate the possible usage of our computing device for edge detection of an image. Compared with the reported MS-based devices having overall lengths of about 𝐿=10𝜆 or more, our computing acoustic system is comparable in its length with the wavelength of operation, allowing its practical and flexible usage for the synthesis of highly efficient and compact architectures. Altogether, our results constitute a framework for various innovative acoustic applications comprising medical imaging, ultrafast equation solving, and real time signal processing. 2. Methods To start, consider the geometry of Fig. 1a, depicting a metamaterial built from intercrossing air-filled acoustic pipes with the radius R= 1.5 cm, arranged in a square lattice with the lattice constant a=5 cm. Such kind of metamaterial coils up the space and provides an internal geometrical detour for sound, reducing its effective travelling velocity [44-47]. Consequently, from a macroscopic point of view, the structure effectively acts as a high-index acoustic medium, a result which was already explored in [47]. For further assertion, however, we have calculated the band structure of the crystal using finite-element simulations and represented it in Fig. 1b. Inspecting the obtained band structure reveals that the metamaterial under investigation indeed imitates a medium with the refractive index of neff>1, as its dispersion curve falls below the sound cone and varies linearly within the frequency range of 0 and 1 KHz. Now, consider a finite piece of the crystal with length L placed in air (Fig. 1c). In this scenario, the high-index medium acts as an acoustic slab waveguide, guiding sound by total internal refraction as described in [47]. We first aim to perform differentiation, the most fundamental mathematical operation in science and engineering, making use of such simple slab. Assume an incident pressure field with the spatial distribution of 𝑃'(𝑥) is obliquely impinging on the slab as indicated in Fig. 1c. Our goal is to engineer the slab in a way that it carries out differentiation in spatial domain, and provides the derivative of the incoming beam either by reflection or transmission. Considering the transfer function of an ideal differentiator (𝐺(𝑘-)=𝑖𝑘-), one can argue that, in order to be able to differentiate the input field, the reflection or transmission coefficient of the slab is required to vanish at (at least) one incident angle. Similar to its optical counterpart, the transmission coefficient of this type of acoustic waveguide is non-zero for all incident angles. Nonetheless, its reflectance can, in principle, reduce to zero under certain circumstances. In fact, as outlined in [39], if the length L satisfies the following condition at some incident angle Bq , the reflection coefficient will attain a zero value: k n 0 eff cos(sin ( 1 - q B ) )) L = up (1) sin( n eff where k0 is the wavenumber at the operation frequency and u is an integer. This is nothing but the usual Fabry-Pérot resonance condition, also known as longitudinal transmission resonance in acoustics. What actually happens at this incident angle is that the high-index slab mimics a half-wavelength transmission line, transferring all of the power by matching the characteristic impedances loaded to the input and output of the line. In the following section, we will describe how such a zero in the reflection coefficient of the waveguide can be leveraged for the realization of a spatial differentiation. Intuitively, one may ask whether such simple waveguide is also able to perform other operators like integration, for example. To answer this question, we should refer to the Green's function of an ideal integrator in the Fourier domain, which is of the form G(k ) x = 1 ik x . Depending on whether we choose the transmitted or reflected field as the output, such form of transfer function necessitates the transmission or reflection coefficient of the slab to have a pole at one incident angle. In essence, the reflection coefficient of a slab waveguide cannot have a pole, neither in electromagnetism, nor here in acoustics. Nevertheless, its transmission coefficient can possess poles at certain angles. More specifically, at the incident angles for which the wave-vector and frequency of the incoming beam match those of one of the guided modes of the waveguide, the incident wave strongly excites that mode, creating a pole in the transmission coefficient. This pole in the transmission coefficient of the waveguide can indeed be utilized to carry out spatial integration as we demonstrate in the Results section. 3.1. Spatial differentiation 3. Results Consider again the slab waveguide shown in Fig. 1c, and suppose its length is chosen to be L=9a. The reflection coefficient of the waveguide is then calculated via full-wave numerical simulation, and is reported in Fig. 2a. As obvious, the reflectance has reduced to zero at 𝜃0≈ 30° for which the condition of Eq.1 is fulfilled. We now focus our attention on how the obtained reflection coefficient, calculated for various incident angles, can be mapped onto a transfer function in spatial Fourier domain. As described in [31], one can write the relation between the wave-vector kx and incident angle θ as k x =- k sin(sin ( sin( 0 1 - ) ) q q B ) (2) Employing the above equation, one may conveniently map the reflection coefficient onto its corresponding transfer function in wave-vector space. Shown in Fig. 2b is the real part of the transfer function. It is now obvious that the transfer function of the slab is indeed zero at kx=0, which is key for the realization of spatial differentiation. We note that while the transfer function G(kx) does not exactly match that of an ideal differentiator, it still can be well- estimated with a linear function near the origin as shown in the figure (the red dashed line). As a result, for the incoming fields Pi(x) having sufficiently wide spatial distribution (or equivalently having a small bandwidth in Fourier domain), the reflected field Pr(x) will be very close to the first order derivative of Pi(x). This anticipation can be easily confirmed by considering a spatially wide incident beam having, for example, the Gaussian distribution of in Fig. 2c, and calculating its corresponding reflected field (Fig. 2d). As observed, the reflected field is in perfect agreement with the exact derivative of the incoming field. The profiles of the incident and reflected wave fronts are further analytically calculated and sketched in the inset of Fig. 2e, acknowledging again the proper performance of the differentiator. It should be noted that the amplitude of the reflected field is much lower than that of the incident field. This is actually normal and expected since the transfer functions of differentiators, even in their ideal case, have very low values near the origin. At this point, it is highly instructive to underline that while the proposed differentiator offers less bandwidth than its MS-based analogues, it is highly compact, a much-sought property allowing its practical usage in integrated architectures. To be specific, the overall length of the slab ( L /l= 2 ) is about one twenties of that of MS-based differentiators in [40,41]. Furthermore, while the MS-based structures are always accompanied with fabrication complexities due to the coupling responses between metasurfaces, our high-index slab waveguide is quite easy to be implemented in practice [47]. 3.2. Spatial integration We next move onto designing an acoustic analog integrator. To this end, all we need is to excite one of the guided modes of the waveguide as explained before in the Methods section. Unfortunately, however, there exists one problem towards achieving such functionality: in principle, it is not possible to excite the guided modes of the slab from air. This is a direct consequence of the phase matching criteria [48], and the fact that the effective refractive index of the slab is higher than its surroundings. In order to get rid of this problem, we use a well-known technique regarded as prism coupling [48,49]. Consider the geometry represented in Fig. 3a, where two additional high-index slabs, acting as the prism couplers, have been put before and after the primary waveguide. Suppose then an obliquely incident wave is travelling inside one of the prisms as schematically shown in the inset of the figure. It is worth noting that the fact that the sound trajectory does not follow the directions of the pipes should not cause any concern as our metamaterial derives its properties from its structure rather than its subwavelength composites. We assume L1=4a, and L2=9a, and calculate the transmission coefficient of the configuration via finite-element numerical simulations (Fig. 3b). The figure reveals the existence of two guided modes whose excitations at the incident angles of 57q » 1 ! and 68q » ! 2 has led to the peaks observed in the transmission. Here, without loss of generality, we focus on the second pole and assume the incident angle of the incoming beam to be Bq q= 2 . Similar to the case of the acoustic differentiator, the obtained transmission coefficient can be readily converted to a transfer function in the wave-vector space employing the mapping of Eq. 2. This is actually done in Fig. 3c, indicating the fact that the transfer function of the system can be well-estimated with that of an ideal integrator. We notice, however, that the transfer function is limited to one at the origin, rather than being infinite as it should be for an ideal differentiator. This detrimental property, which stems from the leakage of the excited mode to the prisms, prevents the integrator from retrieving the zero harmonic (or the DC component) of the input field. However, our design still allows the efficient integration of spatially wide AC signals. For instance, suppose a pressure field having the Gaussian-derivative distribution depicted in Fig. 3d as the input of the system. Remarkably, not only is Pi(x) quite wide in the spatial domain but also it contains no DC component. The resulting transmitted field Pt(x) is plotted in Fig. 3e. Comparing Pt(x) with the exact integration of Pi(x) evidences the great functionality of the designed integrator. 3.3. Higher order operators Now that we have successfully performed differentiation and integration, we study the possibility of performing more complex operators. Consider, for example, realization of second order differentiation, an operator which is diversely found in important partial differential equations like wave equation, Schrodinger equation and Euler equation. Our approach to realize this operator is quite straight forward: we cascade two half-wavelength acoustic slab waveguides, each differentiates individually the incoming pressure field one time. The cascading process has been conceptually represented in Fig. 4a: an incident pressure field with the spatial distribution Pi(x) coming in from air strikes the boundary of a half-wavelength slab waveguide. Then, the resulting reflected field Pr1 (x), which is in fact the spatial derivate of Pi (x), impinges another similar slab waveguide. The final pressure field Pr2 (x), reflecting back from the second slab will therefore be the second-order derivative of Pi(x), provided that the input signal is sufficiently wide in spatial domain. To examine whether the designed system works well in performing second-order differentiation, let us assume again the input field has the Gaussian distribution of Fig. 2c. The corresponding output field Pr2 (x) together with the exact second order derivative of the input field are reported in Fig. 4b, confirming the proper functioning of the system. Further insight into the computation process can be obtained by exploring the calculated field profile illustrated in the inset of Fig. 4c. 3.4. Edge detection Finally, we examine the relevance of such acoustic computing devices for detecting the edges of an image. One common and established technique for edge detection, known as zero crossing technique [50], relies on calculating spatial derivative of the image in the direction(s) whose edges are intended to be detected. This can easily be carried out exploiting the acoustic computing setup schematically pictured in Fig. 5a. The setup consists of a loudspeaker, a mask plane with locally engineered transparencies according to the shape of the desire image (shown in Fig. 5b), a half-wavelength acoustic slab waveguide, and a microphone. The underlying working principle of the setup is as follows. The sound generated by the loudspeaker is spatially modulated by the mask plane, creating the appropriate spatial field distribution corresponding to the image. The resulting pressure field then impinges on the high-index acoustic slab and is spatially differentiated when it reflects. The reflected field is then detected by the microphone so as to create the edge-detected image. Fig. 5c reports the output edge-detected image. Notably, since differentiation is carried out along x direction, only the vertical edges have been resolved. The horizontal edges can also be detected employing a similar setup, but with a slab waveguide carrying out differentiation along y. The resulting edge-detected image for the latter case is provided in Fig. 5d. One may also consider two-dimensional edge detection by cascading two different differentiators; one differentiates the image along x whereas the other does that along y. This way, both vertical and horizontal edges of the images can be appropriately detected in one measurement, as observed in the result of Fig. 5e. 4. Discussion and Conclusion In summary, in this article, we proposed to achieve acoustic analog computing making use of high-index slab waveguides. These proposed devices are highly compact and potentially usable in miniaturized (subwavelength) signal processing systems. In particular, our computing devices are superior to their MS-based analogues in that their overall lengths were comparable with the operational wavelength. This is because they directly performed the desired operation in spatial domain, and were needless of bulky Fourier lenses. We demonstrated how a simple, easy-to-fabricate acoustic slab enables realization of spatial differentiators and integrators. We further proved the relevance of such computing devices for detecting the edges of an image. Notice that the edge detection resolution level provided by our wave-based computing systems is inherently restricted by diffraction limit [51-54], while it is not the case when using standard digital image processors. However, our scheme allows one to instantaneously process the entire image at once, which is not achievable with digital data processors. This property can dramatically enhance the throughput of our analog image processor, eventually reducing the cost and energy required for the edge detection process. Furthermore, one may think of improving the design by considering metamaterial slabs supporting spoof acoustic plasmons, which would lead to devices not limited by diffraction and capable of subwavelength edge detection. These computing devices have the potential to be employed as the building block for fast equation solving as well. For example, consider a very simple first-order differential equation as 55-𝑔(𝑥)=𝑓(𝑥). To find the unknown function g(x), one should only employ the acoustic 𝑓(𝑥), and detect the transmitted field. More complex differential or integro-differential setup of Fig. 3a, modulate the incident pressure field in accordance with the known function equations can also be solved exploiting the cascading method proposed in section 3.3. Such analog equation solvers are not only faster than their digital versions, but also offer low- power consumption operation. Our computing systems can also be envisioned to be utilized in other promising applications including real-time signal processing, wave manipulation and acoustic neural networks. This work was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) under Grant No. Acknowledgement 172487. Fig. 1: Design of an acoustic computing system performing spatial differentiation. a, Geometry of a periodic acoustic lattice built from air-filled intercrossing pipes. The lattice constant and radii of the pipes are assumed to be a=5 cm and R=1.5 cm, respectively. b, Band structure of the crystal numerically calculated by FEM. The frequency dispersion of the crystal imitates that of a high-index acoustic medium within the frequency range of 0 to 1 KHz. c, An incident pressure field with the arbitrary spatial distribution of Pi(x) impinges a finite piece of the crystal. If the length L is chosen to be half of the wavelength of the guiding wave inside the slab, the reflected field will be first-order derivative of the incoming beam. Fig. 2: Demonstration of proper functioning of the differentiator, a, Variation of reflection coefficient of the waveguide versus the incident angle. The reflection coefficient vanishes at Bq » ! 30 , forming the underlying working principle of the differentiator. b, Transfer function of the differentiator in the wave-vector space obtained using the mapping relation of Eq. 2. c, A spatially wide Gaussian-like pressure field is considered as the input signal of the differentiator. d, Corresponding reflected field profile: the reflected field follows well the exact derivative of the input signal, affirming the proper functioning of the differentiator. e, Field profile of the incident and reflected beams. Fig. 3: Design and demonstration of an acoustic computing system performing integration, a, Proposed configuration: guided modes of the slab are excited by a pressure field travelling inside another high-index medium acting as a prism coupler. b, Variation of transmission coefficient of the system versus the incident angle: the excitation of the guided modes creates some poles in the transmission coefficient, constituting the key underlying working principle of our integrator. c, Transfer function of the system. d, A spatially wide derivative-Gaussian pressure field is considered as the input signal. e, Corresponding transmitted field profile together with the exact integration of the input. Fig. 4: Design and Demonstration of an acoustic computing system carrying out second order differentiation, a, Two half-wavelength slab waveguides are cascaded so as to realize an acoustic second order differentiator. Each waveguide individually differentiates the input field one time. b, Output signal of the computing system when the incoming field has the Gaussian-like distribution shown in Fig. 2c. The output field is in perfect agreement with the second order derivative of incident beam. c, Field profile of the incident and reflected fields. Fig. 5: Edge Detection of an image utilizing the proposed acoustic computing system, a, Acoustic computing setup designed for detecting the edges of an image: the setup consists of a loudspeaker as the source, a mask plane with locally engineered transparencies according to the shape of the image whose edges are intended to be detected, a half-wavelength acoustic slab waveguide differentiating the image, and a microphone to resolve edge-detected image, b, Photograph of the image whose edges are aimed to be detected, c, Output edge-detected image when the slab waveguide differentiates the image in x direction: the vertical edges of the image have been detected. d, Same as panel c except that the slab differentiates the image in y direction, detecting its vertical edges. e, Resulting image when two cascaded differentiators differentiates the image in both x and y directions, revealing its horizontal and vertical edges simultaneously. References 1. Clymer A Ben 1993 The Mechanical Analog Computers of Hannibal Ford and William Newell IEEE Ann. Hist. Comput. 15 19–34 2. Maclennan B J 2007 A Review of Analog Computing Complex. Syst. Sci. (Springer, 2008) 1–45C Explorations 3. Goodman C 1990 The Digital Revolution: Art in the Computer Age Art J. 49 248–52 4. Smith D R, Pendry J B and Wiltshire M C K 2004 Metamaterials and negative refractive index. Science 305 788–92 5. Alu A and Engheta N 2005 Achieving transparency with plasmonic and metamaterial coatings Phys. Rev. E - Stat. Nonlinear, Soft Matter Phys. 72. 6. Engheta N and Ziolkowski R W 2006 Metamaterials: Physics and Engineering 7. Salandrino A and Engheta N 2006 Far-field subdiffraction optical microscopy using metamaterial crystals: Theory and simulations Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 74 8. Chen H and Chan C T 2007 Acoustic cloaking in three dimensions using acoustic metamaterials Appl. Phys. Lett. 91 183518 9. Torrent D and Sánchez-Dehesa J 2007 Acoustic metamaterials for new two- dimensional sonic devices New J. Phys. 9 10. Guenneau S, Movchan A, Patursson G and Ramakrishna S A 2007 Acoustic metamaterials for sound focusing and confinement New J. Phys. 9 11. Fleury R and Alù A 2014 Manipulation of electron flow using near-zero index semiconductor metamaterials Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 90 12. Pfeiffer C, Zhang C, Ray V, Guo L J and Grbic A 2014 High performance bianisotropic metasurfaces: Asymmetric transmission of light Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 13. Fleury R, Sounas D L and Alu A 2014 Negative refraction and planar focusing based on parity-time symmetric metasurfaces Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 14. Ross M B, Blaber M G and Schatz G C 2014 Using nanoscale and mesoscale three-dimensional plasmonic the optical response of anisotropy metamaterials Nat. Commun. 5 to engineer 15. Sounas D L, Fleury R and Alù A 2015 Unidirectional cloaking based on metasurfaces with balanced loss and gain Phys. Rev. Appl. 4 16. Alù A, Silveirinha M G, Salandrino A and Engheta N 2007 Epsilon-near-zero metamaterials and electromagnetic sources: Tailoring the radiation phase pattern Phys. Rev. B - Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 75 17. Koutserimpas T T and Fleury R 2018 Zero refractive index in time-Floquet acoustic 18. Hwang Y and Davis T J 2016 Optical metasurfaces for subwavelength difference 19. Cummer S A, Christensen J and Alù A 2016 Controlling sound with acoustic metamaterials J. Appl. Phys. 123 operations Appl. Phys. Lett. 109 metamaterials Nat. Rev. Mater. 1 20. Yves S, Fleury R, Berthelot T, Fink M, Lemoult F and Lerosey G 2017 Crystalline metamaterials for topological properties at subwavelength scales Nat. Commun. 8 21. Estakhri, N. M., Edwards, B. E., & Engheta, N. (2017, May). Solving integral In CLEO: equations with QELS_Fundamental Science (pp. FTh1G-2). Optical Society of America. optical metamaterial-waveguide networks. 22. Abdollahramezani S, Chizari A, Dorche A E, Jamali M V and Salehi J A 2017 Dielectric metasurfaces solve differential and integro-differential equations Opt. Lett. 42 1197 23. Caloz C, Gupta S, Zhang Q and Nikfal B 2013 Analog Signal Processing: A Possible Alternative or Complement to Dominantly Digital Radio Schemes IEEE Microw. Mag. 14 87–103 24. Khorasaninejad M, Chen W T, Devlin R C, Oh J, Zhu A Y and Capasso F 2016 Metalenses at visible wavelengths: Diffraction-limited focusing and subwavelength resolution imaging Science. 352 1190–4 25. Silva A, Monticone F, Castaldi G, Galdi V, Alù A and Engheta N 2014 Performing mathematical operations with metamaterials Science. 343 160–3 26. AbdollahRamezani S, Arik K, Khavasi A and Kavehvash Z 2015 Analog computing using graphene-based metalines Opt. Lett. 40 5239 27. Pors A, Nielsen M G and Bozhevolnyi S I 2015 Analog computing using reflective plasmonic metasurfaces Nano Lett. 15 791–7 28. Solli D R and Jalali B 2015 Analog optical computing Nat. Photonics 9 704–6 29. Golovastikov N V., Bykov D A, Doskolovich L L and Bezus E A 2015 Spatial optical integrator based on phase-shifted Bragg gratings Opt. Commun. 338 457–60 30. Doskolovich L L, Bezus E A, Bykov D A and Soifer V A 2016 Spatial differentiation of Bloch surface wave beams using an on-chip phase-shifted Bragg grating J. Opt. (United Kingdom) 18 31. Youssefi A, Zangeneh-Nejad F, Abdollahramezani S., Khavasi A. 2016. Analog computing by Brewster effect. Optics letters 41 3467-3470 32. Zhu T, Zhou Y, Lou Y, Ye H, Qiu M, Ruan Z and Fan S 2017 Plasmonic computing of spatial differentiation Nat. Commun. 8 33. Doskolovich L L, Bezus E A, Golovastikov N V., Bykov D A and Soifer V A 2017 Planar two-groove optical differentiator in a slab waveguide Opt. Express 25 22328 34. Wu W, Jiang W, Yang J, Gong S, Ma Y 2017 Multilayered analog optical differentiating device: performance analysis on structural parameters Opt. letters, 42, 5270-5273. 35. Fang Y, Lou Y, Ruan Z 2017. On-grating graphene surface plasmons enabling spatial differentiation in the terahertz region. Opt. letters, 42, 3840-3843. 36. Zhang W, Cheng K, Wu C, Wang Y, Li H and Zhang X 2018 Implementing Quantum Search Algorithm with Metamaterials Adv. Mater. 30 37. Guo C., Xiao M., Minkov M., Shi Y., Fan S. 2018 Photonic crystal slab Laplace operator for image differentiation Optica 5 251-256 38. CHEN H, AN D, LI Z and ZHAO X 2017 Performing differential operation with a silver dendritic metasurface at visible wavelengths Opt. Express 25 26417–26 39. Zangeneh-Nejad F, Khavasi A and Rejaei B 2018 Analog optical computing by half- wavelength slabs Opt. Commun. 407 338–43 40. Zuo S Y, Wei Q, Cheng Y and Liu X J 2017 Mathematical operations for acoustic signals based on layered labyrinthine metasurfaces Appl. Phys. Lett. 110 41. Zuo S Y, Tian Y, Wei Q, Cheng Y, Liu X J 2018 Acoustic analog computing based on a reflective metasurface with decoupled modulation of phase and amplitude. Journal of Applied Physics 123, 091704 42. Xie Y, Shen C, Wang W, Li J, Suo D, Popa B I, Jing Y and Cummer S A 2016 Acoustic Holographic Rendering with Two-dimensional Metamaterial-based Passive Phased Array Sci. Rep. 6 43. Tian Y, Wei Q, Cheng Y and Liu X 2017 Acoustic holography based on composite metasurface with decoupled modulation of phase and amplitude Appl. Phys. Lett. 110 44. Liang Z and Li J 2012 Extreme acoustic metamaterial by coiling up space Phys. Rev. 45. Xie Y, Konneker A, Popa B I and Cummer S A 2013 Tapered labyrinthine acoustic metamaterials for broadband impedance matching Appl. Phys. Lett. 103 46. Frenzel T, David Brehm J, Bückmann T, Schittny R, Kadic M and Wegener M 2013 Three-dimensional labyrinthine acoustic metamaterials Appl. Phys. Lett. 103 47. Zangeneh-Nejad F., Fleury R 2018 Acoustic Analogues of High-Index Optical Waveguide Devices arXiv preprint arXiv:1802.02784. 48. Maier S A 2007 Plasmonics: Fundamentals and applications 49. Zangeneh-Nejad F and Khavasi A 2017 Spatial integration by a dielectric slab and its planar graphene-based counterpart Opt. Lett. 42 1954 50. Haralick R M 1984 Digital Step Edges from Zero Crossing of Second Directional Derivatives IEEE Trans. Pattern Anal. Mach. Intell. PAMI-6 58–68 51. Zhu J Christensen J, Jung J, Martin-Moreno L, Yin X, Fok L, Zhang X and Garcia- Vidal F J 2011 A holey-structured metamaterial for acoustic deep-subwavelength imaging Nat. Phys. 7 52–5 52. Slaney M, Kak A C and Larsen L E 1984 Limitations of Imaging with First-Order Diffraction Tomography IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech. 32 860–74 53. Zhang S, Yin L and Fang N 2009 Focusing ultrasound with an acoustic metamaterial Lett. 108 network Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 54. Lerosey G, De Rosny J, Tourin A and Fink M 2007 Focusing beyond the diffraction limit with far-field time reversal Science. 315 1120–2
1709.01496	1	1709	2017-09-05T17:25:08	Mode-shape perturbation induced by analyte adsorption in nanomechanical sensors	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	Nanomechanical resonators offer important benefits for the sensing of physical stimuli such as the mass of an added molecule. To map out the local shape properties of the physical stimuli, such as the distribution of the mass density of a molecule, sensory information should be collected through multiple modes of a mechanical sensor. By utilizing the specific mode shapes, the spatial distribution of a physical stimulus can be reverse calculated. However, the mode shapes of a sensor may deviate from their ideal forms once analytes start to accumulate on the sensor. As a result, algorithms based on the ideal form of the mode shapes no longer work accurately. Here, we developed a theoretical framework to calculate the change in the mode shapes of a nanomechanical beam after analyte adsorption. We verified the theoretical model by performing finite element simulations and comparing the change in the mode shapes obtained from each approach. Monte Carlo simulations were performed to relate the maximum deviation in the mode shapes to the surface roughness of the sensor after analyte accumulation. By predicting the change in the mode shapes and using the corrected forms, the accuracy of the nanomechanical sensing can be improved significantly.	physics.app-ph	physics	Mode-shape perturbation induced by analyte adsorption in nanomechanical sensors Mert Yüksel1 and M. Selim Hanay1,2,* 1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Bilkent University, Ankara 06800, Turkey 2National Nanotechnology Research Center (UNAM), Bilkent University, Ankara 06800, Turkey E-mail: [email protected] Nanomechanical resonators offer important benefits for the sensing of physical stimuli such as the mass of an added molecule. To map out the local shape properties of the physical stimuli, such as the distribution of the mass density of a molecule, sensory information should be collected through multiple modes of a mechanical sensor. By utilizing the specific mode shapes, the spatial distribution of a physical stimulus can be reverse calculated. However, the mode shapes of a sensor may deviate from their ideal forms once analytes start to accumulate on the sensor. As a result, algorithms based on the ideal form of the mode shapes no longer work accurately. Here, we developed a theoretical framework to calculate the change in the mode shapes of a nanomechanical beam after analyte adsorption. We verified the theoretical model by performing finite element simulations and comparing the change in the mode shapes obtained from each approach. Monte Carlo simulations were performed to relate the maximum deviation in the mode shapes to the surface roughness of the sensor after analyte accumulation. By predicting the change in the mode shapes and using the corrected forms, the accuracy of the nanomechanical sensing can be improved significantly. 1 I. INTRODUCTION Nanoelectromechanical system (NEMS) resonators can be used as exquisite sensors of physical stimuli. As the size of a mechanical sensor shrinks, its responsivity increases. Combining this advantage with low-noise readout schemes has enabled extreme sensitivity levels to be achieved, such as the detection of electronic spins [1], single-atoms [2], single- proteins [3,4], nanoparticles [5,6], single-cells in liquid [7-9] and volatile chemicals at low concentration [10,11]. A novel sensing modality of NEMS technology for single-molecule analysis has been discovered recently. It was shown that the spatial properties of analyte particles, such as their size and skewness, can be extracted by using multiple mechanical modes of a sensor [12]. Such multimodal measurements provide both size and shape features, as well as the mass of the analyte. Furthermore, by merging different spatial features, an image of the analyte can be reconstructed. The new technique, inertial imaging [12], transforms the capabilities of nanomechanical sensors to a new level: the combined data of molecular mass, size and shape of the analyte can provide previously unattainable insights in biomolecular analytics. The technique can be used for any resonator system with well-defined mode shapes: for instance, the electromagnetic analog of inertial imaging was also demonstrated in a microfluidic environment using microwave sensors [13]. Inertial imaging and similar multimode techniques [14-23] work on the principle that the mode shapes of the sensor are well known. However, the mode shapes in a real device deviate from the ideal mode shapes since there are many factors (surface effects, clamping conditions, fabrication errors) that can affect the physical composition of sensors. To apply inertial imaging algorithms, such deviations from ideality should be taken into account. Here, we take the first step in doing so by quantifying the change in the mode shape of a NEMS resonator after analyte adsorption. We model an analyte by considering its inertial effect on the resonator: the contribution to the elastic energy is ignored because Young's moduli of biological material are usually orders of magnitude smaller than those of crystalline material used for NEMS. However, the approach provided here can be generalized for such cases in which the contribution of the analytes to the stiffness is important. First, we used first-order perturbation theory to obtain the change in resonance frequency and mode shapes. Then, we performed simulations to verify that these theoretical predictions were correct. We demonstrated the utility of our approach by placing two particles on the NEMS sensor sequentially: the parameters of the second particle (mass and position) were obtained much more accurately once the effect of the first particle on mode shape was taken into account. We then used this theory to study the effect of surface roughness on mode shapes. 2 II. THEORY 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-(/)𝑥 =𝜌𝐴 𝛺-/ 𝜙-(/)𝑥 Consider a doubly-clamped beam extending along the 𝑥 direction. It has a Young's modulus 𝐸, cross sectional area 𝐴, mass density 𝜌 and moment of inertia 𝐼. The equation of motion for the 𝑛'( flexural mode of this structure is [24]: Here, 𝜙-(/) is the unperturbed mode shape and 𝛺-/ =𝜔-,/5 , in which 𝜔-,/ is the unperturbed resonance frequency of the 𝑛'( mode. its density profile along the beam axis 𝑥. The 1D density profile of this analyte is shown by 𝜖 × 𝜇(𝑥), in which 𝜖≪1 is introduced as the smallness parameter for this perturbation. The in which 𝜙-𝑥 and 𝛺- are the updated values for the mode shape and the square of the In a sensing application, an analyte gets adsorbed by this doubly clamped beam and changes the composition of Eq. (1). To account for the finite size and shape of an analyte, we consider equation of motion after the perturbation of analyte becomes: (1) (2) resonance frequency, respectively. These parameters can be expressed as a perturbation series [25]: 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-𝑥 =𝜌𝐴 𝛺- 𝜙-𝑥 +𝜖 𝜇𝑥𝐴𝛺- 𝜙-(𝑥) 𝜙-𝑥 =𝜙-(/)𝑥 + 𝜖 𝜙-(=)𝑥 +𝒪(𝜖5) 𝛺-=𝛺-/ +𝜖 𝛺-= +𝒪(𝜖5) 𝛺-= =2 𝜔-/𝜔-= (3) (4) in which 𝜖 𝜙-(=) and 𝜖 𝛺-= are the first order corrections to the mode shape and the square of the resonance frequency, respectively. Noting that 𝜔-=𝜔-/ +𝜖 𝜔-= +𝒪(𝜖5), the relationship between the first-order shift in resonance frequency, 𝜔-= , and the 𝛺-= can be determined: the terms at the same order in 𝜖, performed integration by parts, and invoked the boundary To proceed further, we substituted these expressions into the equation of motion, collected (5) conditions to cancel out several terms, as explained in the Annex. In this way, we obtained the first-order correction to the frequency: 𝜔-(=)𝜔-(/)=−12𝜌 𝑑𝑥𝜇𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 5 (6) which is exactly the equation obtained by other methods in the literature [12]. We then turned our attention to the first-order correction to the mode shape, which had not been calculated before. We wrote the correction function as a superposition of the original mode shapes: 3 (7) Here, the right-hand side does not include the term 𝑚=𝑛, because any such term (i.e., 𝑐-- 𝜙-(/)) would not constitute a deviation from the original mode shape (𝜙-(/)) and can always both sides with 𝜙C(/) and integrating, we obtained the sought-after weights, 𝑐C- : in which 𝑇-C quantifies the triple-overlap between the two modes and the analyte: be normalized out. Substituting in the formula shown in Eq. (7) into Eq. (2) and multiplying (8) 𝜙-(=)= 𝑐C- 𝜙C(/) DCE- 𝑐C-=1𝜌 𝛺-/ 𝛺C/ −𝛺-(/)𝑇-C 𝑇-C≡ 𝑑𝑥 𝜇𝑥 𝜙-𝑥𝜙C𝑥 𝜙-(=)=1𝜌 𝛺-/ 𝛺C/ −𝛺-(/)𝑇-C 𝜙C(/) CE- Therefore, the first order correction to the mode shape is: (9) (10) III. SIMULATIONS To verify that the correction to the mode shapes calculated in Eq. (10) is accurate, we performed finite element simulations. We used COMSOL Multiphysics to simulate the dynamics of analyte adsorption on a doubly-clamped beam. Eigenfrequency analysis is performed with and without analyte adsorption to observe perturbed and unperturbed out-of- plane mode shapes and the corresponding resonance frequencies. Care was taken to normalize the mode shapes properly so that the orthonormality condition was satisfied for each mode. To model the analyte, a uniform density profile, 𝜇𝑥 , was defined between specified x-positions on the beam model, as shown in Fig. 1. Simulations were repeated with finer meshes until a convergence limit well beyond the effect of the analyte was reached. Exactly the same mesh specifications were defined for the beam, in both cases with and without the adsorbed mass, to get an accurate comparison. For the particular simulation that is shown in Fig. 1, the density profile, 𝜇𝑥 , was chosen to be less than the beam's material density to be able to observe small The first order correction to the mode shape was calculated for the first (𝜙=(=)) and second (𝜙5(=)) perturbations. It is centered on 1/4th of the beam, and extends along the 5% of the beam's length. out-of-plane mode shapes from the simulations by simply taking the difference between the perturbed and unperturbed mode shapes. To compare this deviation with the theoretical prediction, Eq. (10) was evaluated up to the first 10 modes. A comparison between the numerical and theoretical results is shown in Fig. 1, which indicated that our analytical prediction matches well with the results from finite element analysis (FEA). Specifically, 4 the second mode. In this particular case, the largest weight in Eq. (7) was 𝑐5=, which means that Fig. 1(b) shows the first-order deviation of the first mode, which resembles the ideal shape of the correction to the mode shape of the first mode should resemble the ideal mode shape of the second mode. A similar situation holds true for the correction to the second-mode, as shown in Fig. 1(d), in which the largest contribution comes from the ideal shape of mode 1 followed by mode 3. FIG. 1. Performance of calculating the corrected mode shapes. (a) The mode shape of the first resonance of the doubly clamped beam used in finite element simulations with the adsorbed particle (black) located in position x. (b) The first-order correction to the mode shape for the first mode is calculated (red) and compared to the result obtained by FEM simulations (black). (c) The mode shape of the second resonance of the beam with the adsorbed particle. (d) The first-order correction to the mode shape for the second mode is calculated (red) and compared to the result obtained by FEM simulations (black). Once the deviation from the ideal mode shapes are calculated, the perturbed mode shapes can be reconstructed by: 𝜙-𝑥 =𝑐--𝜙-(/)+𝜖 𝑐C- 𝜙C(/) CE- (11) The error between the estimated and FEA-perturbed mode shape is calculated in the following way: 5 %𝐸𝑟𝑟𝑜𝑟= 𝜙-LMN−𝜙-MOPQRNPMS 𝜙-LMN 𝑥100 (12) The error is calculated for the different number of modes used in Eq. (12) [Fig. 2(a)]. For the first three modes, it is observed that the error decays with increasing number of modes used, and it saturates after 10 terms. To test the reliability of the estimation, the error was also calculated as a variation of the position of the adsorbed density profile. Figure 2(b) shows that the analytical technique works for a range of positions of the adsorbed particle. FIG. 2. (a) Error vs. the number of modes used. As more modes are used in the model, much better agreement between the theoretical and FEM simulations is obtained. For the first three modes, the errors drop quickly, then saturate to a residual value. (b) Error vs. position of the adsorbed particle. The performance of the prediction is evaluated for a particle adsorbed at different locations on the beam. The error does not change significantly if the particle is located at different positions. 6 So far, we have only considered the case in which a single particle has been adsorbed. Now, we locate a second particle identical to the first one in a way that they do not overlap. We studied how the perturbation of the first particle on the mode shapes changes the performance for detecting the properties of the second particle. We kept the position of the first particle (𝑥=) constant, and swept the position of the second particle (𝑥5) along the beam [Fig. 3(a)]. Then, we calculated 𝑥5 by using both the normal (unperturbed) mode shapes and the corrected 𝑥= locations, and the mean error for the estimated 𝑥5 were calculated, as shown in Fig. 3(b). (perturbed) mode shapes after the first particle. The same procedure was applied for different When we compared the calculated values with the actual center-of-mass position of the second particle, we observed that using corrected mode shapes for detection provided better accuracy for the center-of-mass estimation. The error using the original mode shapes may seem to be small already. However, the errors propagate when the higher order moments of a distribution are calculated; therefore, it is crucial to decrease the error in determining the position as much as possible. The procedure can be repeated by updating the corrected mode shape whenever a new particle is adsorbed, which enables more precise particle position tracking. FIG. 3. Position prediction accuracy. (a) The center-of-mass position of the first particle (𝑥=) is fixed at 𝑥==0.25 and the center-of-mass position of the second particle (𝑥5) is moved along the beam. For each 𝑥5 values, the position prediction algorithm is used both with the normal mode shapes (black line), of 𝑥5 is calculated from (a) for different positions of the first particle (𝑥=) to test the reliability of our and the corrected mode shapes (blue line), which are the perturbed mode shapes after the adsorption of the first particle. The error between the calculated and actual positions is plotted. (b) The mean error method. We can use this technique to work on more general problems, such as the effect of surface roughness on mode shapes. The effect of the surface roughness on the mode shapes of a nanomechanical beam is generally disregarded in NEMS applications. However, surface roughness can have a negative effect on the sensitivity of the application. Here, we applied our 7 approach to determine the variation in the mode shapes of the nanomechanical beam due to surface roughness. For simplicity, we considered a case in which surface roughness is caused by soft adsorbates so that the elasticity contribution of the adsorbates can be ignored. In our simulations, we implemented roughness profile as particles attached to the surface of the beam. We created random surface roughness profiles, z(x), by controlling the number of adsorbed particles and their height and length along the surface [Fig. 4(a)]. For each randomly generated surface profile, the roughness rms value was calculated in the following way: (13) ^ / 𝑅𝑜𝑢𝑔ℎ𝑛𝑒𝑠𝑠 𝑟𝑚𝑠= 1𝐿 𝑧𝑥 5𝑑𝑥 %𝐷𝑒𝑣𝑖𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛,𝑀𝑜𝑑𝑒 𝑆ℎ𝑎𝑝𝑒 1= 𝜙=(/)−𝜙= 𝜙=(/) 𝑥100 in which L is the length of the beam, which is normalized to 1 unit. Then the deviation from the normal mode shape was calculated: in which 𝜙= represents the calculated mode shape with the surface roughness. Figure 4(b) shows (14) the deviation in the first mode shape depending on the surface roughness. Although for some cases, the mode shape does not change even for a large surface roughness, there is a clear trend that, on average, a larger surface roughness implies a larger deviation in the mode shape. FIG. 4. (a) Surface roughness profile of the beam in one of the Monte Carlo simulations. The inset show a close-up view of the surface after adsorption of analytes. (b) Surface roughness vs. the deviation in the first mode shape. The orange line shows the trend line obtained by fitting a 12th degree polynomial curve to the data. 8 IV. SUMMARY / CONCLUSION In conclusion, we derived and verified a mathematical procedure to estimate the perturbed mode shapes of a nanomechanical beam after the adsorption of a species. We used our mathematical procedure for a doubly clamped nanomechanical beam resonator and showed that it agrees with the results from finite element analysis. Then, we showed that using perturbed mode shapes increases the sensitivity for mass position sensing. NEMS sensing applications highly depend on the change in the resonance frequencies and the mode shapes. Although it is straightforward to detect the change in the resonance frequencies, there is no easy way to sense the change in the mode shapes. Therefore, this change is neglected in many NEMS applications. However, new techniques such as inertial imaging depends on the mode shapes. Here, we show that perturbed mode shapes of a nanomechanical beam can be easily calculated. When these changes are taken into account, the sensitivity of the NEMS application is improved. The approach provided here can be used to record a history of particles adsorbed on a structure and update the mode shapes accordingly so that spatial sensing can be performed accurately. MS Hanay acknowledges financial support from the European Commission, FP7 Marie ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Curie Program in the form of a Career Integration Grant number 631728. 9 APPENDIX Continuing from Eq. (5) in main text, the expression after plugging in the perturbation expansion reads: 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-(=)𝑥 −𝜇𝑥𝐴𝛺-/ 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-= 𝑥 – =𝜌𝐴 𝛺-/ 𝜙-= 𝑥 +𝜌𝐴 𝛺-= 𝜙-/ 𝑥 To proceed further, we multiply both sides of the with 𝜙-/ 𝑥 and integrate: 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝜇𝑥𝐴𝛺-/ 𝜙-/ 𝑥 = 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝜌𝐴 𝛺-(/) 𝜙-(=)𝑥 + 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝜌𝐴 𝛺-(=) 𝜙-(/)𝑥 lm/,==0, we obtain: lm/,== hijnhl 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-= 𝑥 = 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-= 𝑥 𝐸𝐼𝜕𝜕𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 = 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-= 𝑥 𝜌𝐴𝛺-/ 𝜙-/ 𝑥 conditions on each end (𝑥=0 and 𝑥=1) of the doubly-clamped beam: 𝜙-/(0,1)= 𝜙-=(0,1)= hijkhl (A1) (A2) (A3) Applying integration by parts to the first term on the left hand side and using the boundary which cancels out the first term on the right hand side of Eq. (7). The second term on the right hands side simply integrates to 𝜌𝐴 𝛺-(=). Therefore, Eq. (7) now reads: frequency: 𝑑𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 𝜇𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 =𝜌 𝛺-(=) –𝛺-/ 𝜔-(=)𝜔-(/)=−12𝜌 𝑑𝑥𝜇𝑥 𝜙-/ 𝑥 5 Converting back to frequency shifts, we obtain the first order correction to resonance (A4) (A5) 10 D. Rugar, J. Sidles, and A. Hero, Single-spin magnetic resonance force microscopy, M. S. Hanay, S. Kelber, A. K. Naik, D. Chi, S. Hentz, E. C. Bullard, E. Colinet, L. I. Bargatin et al., Nano Lett. 12, 1269 (2012). J. Chaste, A. Eichler, J. Moser, G. Ceballos, R. Rurali, and A. Bachtold, Nature A. K. Naik, M. S. Hanay, W. K. Hiebert, X. L. Feng, and M. L. Roukes, Nature J. Lee, W. Shen, K. Payer, T. P. Burg, and S. R. Manalis, Nano Lett. 10, 2537 (2010). S. Olcum et al., Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States S. Schmid, M. Kurek, J. Q. Adolphsen, and A. Boisen, Sci. Rep. 3, 1288 (2013). E. Sage et al., Nature communications 6 (2015). T. P. Burg, M. Godin, S. M. Knudsen, W. Shen, G. Carlson, J. S. Foster, K. Babcock, References: [1] 2005. [2] Nanotech. 7, 301 (2012). [3] Nanotech. 4, 445 (2009). [4] Duraffourg, and M. L. Roukes, Nature Nanotech. 7, 602 (2012). [5] [6] [7] and S. R. Manalis, Nature 446, 1066 (2007). [8] [9] of America 111, 1310 (2014). [10] M. Li, H. X. Tang, and M. L. Roukes, Nature nanotechnology 2, 114 (2007). [11] [12] M. S. Hanay, S. I. Kelber, C. D. O'Connell, P. Mulvaney, J. E. Sader, and M. L. Roukes, Nature Nanotech. 10, 339 (2015). [13] M. Kelleci, H. Aydogmus, L. Aslanbas, S. O. Erbil, and M. S. Hanay, arXiv preprint arXiv:1702.06056 (2017). [14] 103303 (2007). [15] M. Calleja, and J. Tamayo, Nature Nanotech. 5, 641 (2010). [16] (2010). [17] [18] Review Applied 3, 064002 (2015). [19] (2015). [20] [21] [22] M. S. Barson et al., Nano Lett. 17, 1496 (2017). [23] 2016 IEEE 11th Annual International Conference on (IEEE, 2016), pp. 217. [24] applications (Springer Science & Business Media, 2013). [25] engineers I: Asymptotic methods and perturbation theory (Springer Science & Business Media, 2013). S. Schmid, S. Dohn, and A. Boisen, Sensors 10, 8092 (2010). T. Biswas, J. Xu, N. Miriyala, C. Doolin, T. Thundat, J. Davis, and K. Beach, Physical S. Contera, Nanotechnology 27, 132501 (2016). S. M. Heinrich and I. Dufour, Sensors 15, 29209 (2015). G. Tao and B. Choubey, in Nano/Micro Engineered and Molecular Systems (NEMS), A. N. Cleland, Foundations of nanomechanics: from solid-state theory to device C. M. Bender and S. A. Orszag, Advanced mathematical methods for scientists and S. Olcum, N. Cermak, S. C. Wasserman, and S. R. Manalis, Nature communications 6 S. Dohn, W. Svendsen, A. Boisen, and O. Hansen, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 78, 103303, E. Gil-Santos, D. Ramos, J. Martinez, M. Fernandez-Regulez, R. Garcia, A. San Paulo, S. Dohn, S. Schmid, F. Amiot, and A. Boisen, Appl. Phys. Lett. 97, 044103, 044103 11
1907.03905	1	1907	2019-07-08T23:19:56	Temperature Dependence of a Width of $\Delta$H = $\Delta$B Region in 5 wt.\% (Fe, Ti) Paticle-Doped MgB$_2$ Superconductor	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	A temperature dependence of a width of $\Delta$H = $\Delta$B region has been studied for 5 wt.\% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB$_2$ superconductor. The result revealed that widths of the region are linear along temperature. Here we show the meaning of the result and details of the calculation. In previous report, we represented a theory that a width of $\Delta$H = $\Delta$B region is related with upper critical field of the superconductor, which is that pinned fluxes at volume defect are picked out and move in $\Delta$H = $\Delta$B region when a distance between them is the same as that of upper critical field. Thus, we inspected the relationship between a width of the region and upper critical field along temperature. The theory would gain another justification if temperature dependence of a width of the region is proportional to that of upper critical field. We discussed several topics for $\Delta$H = $\Delta$B region of 5 wt.\% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB$_2$ superconductor, which are Fe of (Fe, Ti) particle, Bean model, volume dependence of the region, etc..	physics.app-ph	physics	Temperature Dependence of a Width of ∆H = ∆B Region in 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) Paticle-Doped MgB2 Superconductor H. B. Lee, G. C. Kim, and Y. C. Kim∗ Department of Physics, Pusan National University, Busan 46241, Korea Abstract A temperature dependence of a width of ∆H = ∆B region has been studied for 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 superconductor. The result revealed that widths of the region are linear along temperature. Here we show the meaning of the result and details of the calculation. In previous report, we represented a theory that a width of ∆H = ∆B region is related with upper critical field of the superconductor, which is that pinned fluxes at volume defect are picked out and move in ∆H = ∆B region when a distance between them is the same as that of upper critical field. Thus, we inspected the relationship between a width of the region and upper critical field along temperature. The theory would gain another justification if temperature dependence of a width of the region is proportional to that of upper critical field. We discussed several topics for ∆H = ∆B region of 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 superconductor, which are Fe of (Fe, Ti) particle, Bean model, volume dependence of the region, etc.. 9 1 0 2 l u J 8 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 5 0 9 3 0 . 7 0 9 1 : v i X r a ∗Electronic address: [email protected]; Fax: +82-51-513-7664 1 I. INTRODUCTION ∆H = ∆B region in a field dependence of magnetization curve (M-H curve) is the re- gion that appears in the volume defect-dominating superconductors. If volume defects are many enough in the superconductor, ∆H = ∆B region appears, which is the region that the increased applied field is the same as the increased magnetic induction after the super- conductor reached the maximum diamagnetic property. The region appears because volume defects pin magnetic quantum fluxes preferentially over the entire specimen [1]. A volume defect pins much more quantum fluxes than planar or line defect does because its free energy density is low, which depends on its volume. If pinned fluxes at a volume defect are many, they bend like bow because of their repulsive force between them. Thus, fluxes have been not pinned at volume defects are pushed forward, and they would be pinned at other volume defect. Therefore, there are almost no unpinned fluxes in the superconductor if volume defects are many enough. Magnetic quantum fluxes are pinned at volume defects step by step from the surface to center of the superconductor as applied magnetic field increases. In this way, magnetic quantum fluxes in a superconductor are preferentially pinned at volume defects over entire specimen. On the other hand, when pinned fluxes are picked out from the volume defect by increase of magnetic quantum fluxes caused by applied magnetic field, the entire pinned fluxes at a volume defect are picked out all at once instead of being leaked out from the volume defects one by one [2, 3]. We would use the term (cid:48)pick out(cid:48) instead of depinning because they are picked out at once when pinned fluxes at a volume defect are depinned. It is considered that they are picked out at once by the tension of them. We have represented the two conditions that pinned fluxes are picked out from a volume defect [1]. One is when ∆Fpickout is more than ∆Fpinning and the other is when a distance between of pinned fluxes at a volume defect is the same as that of upper critical field (Hc2). The former is applicable before H(cid:48) c1 which is defined as the applied magnetic field showing maximum diamagnetic property (the first field in ∆H = ∆B region), and the latter is applicable in ∆H = ∆B region. The justification of the latter is due to the fact that the neighborhood of the volume defect would lose superconductivity if the distance between pinned fluxes is narrower than that of Hc2, thus the concept of flux pinning will not be established in the state. 2 A width of ∆H = ∆B region decreases as temperature increases. The behavior seems to be caused by the fact that the coherence length (ξ) of a superconductor increases as temperature increases, thus the number of fluxes pinned at a volume defect decreases as temperature increases. Therefore, a width of ∆H = ∆B region decreases as temperature increases. Thus, it is needed to check the relationship between Hc2 and a width of ∆H = ∆B region as the temperature increases because Hc2 is Φ0/2πξ2, where Φ0 is magnetic quantum flux [4]. Many reviews do not believe the reality of ∆H = ∆B region and related theories. We think that the denial is mainly caused by the fact that ∆H = ∆B region is different from the general theory of superconductivity. If we had showed the relation between a width of ∆H = ∆B region and temperature, the theory and our assertion would be understood more clearly. Because a width of ∆H = ∆B region is related to Hc2 of the superconductor in the theory, we believe that the reality of ∆H = ∆B region and the theory would be proved more clearly if a width of the region depends on temperature as Hc2 does. II. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION A. Decisions of the width of ∆H = ∆B region Widths of ∆H = ∆B region were obtained by taking average for the region of the first quadrant and that of the second quadrant in M-H curve. When the exact width is difficult to take due to flux jump, the value was reasonably taken. Figure 1 (a) shows M-H curve of 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 at 5 K. Inspecting the first and the second quadrants, it is certain that widths of ∆H = ∆B region were expanded to 1.5 T. Thus the width is decided to be 1.3 T, which is 1.5 T- 0.2 T (H(cid:48) c1 is 0.2 T). M-H curve of the specimen at 10 K is shown in Fig. 1 (b). The diamagnetic property at 1.5 T of 10 K is somewhat smaller than that of 5 K in first quadrant, and diamagnetic property of second quadrant at 1.5 T is slightly lower from the horizontal line. Thus, it is hard to think the region to be expanded to 1.5 T. Taking the median value, the width of the region is 1.05 T, which is 1.25 T - 0.2 T. Figure 2 (a) shows M-H curve of the specimen at 15 K. It is difficult to decide the exact value of the width in the first quadrant because of the flux jump. However, it is certain that 3 the region would be up to 1 T when considered in the second quadrant. Thus, the width at 15 K is 0.8 T, which is 1.0 T - 0.2 T. M-H curve of the specimen at 20 K is shown in Fig. 2 (b). It is clear that the width of the region is up to 0.9 T in first quadrant. However, there is a little confusion that ∆H = ∆B region is up to 0.8 T or 0.9 T in second quadrant, thus the end of the region is conservatively decided to be 0.8 T. Therefore, the width of the region is 0.6 T, which is 0.8 T - 0.2 T. The M-H curve at 25 K of the specimen is shown in Fig. 3 (a). The curve was made a mistake in measuring the magnetization without removing the pinned magnetic fluxes in the specimen. Estimating H(cid:48) c1 at 25 K, it is certain that it is higher field than that of 20 K and lower field than that of 30 K. Thus, it will be reasonable that H(cid:48) c1 at 25 K is 0.2 T because H(cid:48) c1 at 30 K is not far from 0.2 T. The region has been formed before the flux jump appears if compared widths of the first quadrant with that of the second quadrant. Thus, the width of region at 25 K is determined to be 0.4 T, which is 0.6 T - 0.2 T. M-H curve of the specimen at 30 K is shown is Fig. 3 (c). ∆H = ∆B region completely disappears. The noting thing is the maximum diamagnetic property of the specimen also decreases a little. The thickness of the specimen used for the measurement was 0.25 cm. Thus, the width of the region as unit thickness have to be 4×t (t is the thickness of the specimen). In addition, since applied magnetic field penetrates both sides of the specimen, volume defects in the superconductor have pinned the fluxes for both side until applied magnetic field reach H(cid:48) c1. Therefore, a width of the region as unit thickness is W∆H=∆B = ndw + (nd − 1)H(cid:48) c1 (1) where W∆H=∆B is a width of the region as unit thickness, w is experimentally obtained width of the region, nd is the number of specimen when the specimen of unit thickness was divided (ndt=1). Results for the width of ∆H = ∆B region along temperature are shown in Fig. 4 (a). As temperature increases, it is certain that a width of ∆H = ∆B region would decrease linearly. B. Relation between the width of ∆H = ∆B region and Hc2 A width of ∆H = ∆B region was suggested as follows [1]. W∆H=∆B = Hf − H(cid:48) c1 = n2mcpsmΦ0 − 4πM − H(cid:48) c1 (2) 4 where H(cid:48) c1 is the first field of ∆H = ∆B region and Hf is the final field of ∆H = ∆B region. n2, mcps, m, and Φ0 are the number of quantum fluxes pinned at a defect, the number of defects which are in the vertically closed packed state, the number of defects having pinned fluxes from the surface to the center of the superconductor in an axis, and flux quantum, respectively. mcps is the minimum number of defects when the penetrated fluxes into the superconductor are completely pinned. Thus, 2r×mcps is unit if r is radius of spherical defect and n2mcpsmΦ0 is magnetic induction in ∆H = ∆B region [1]. The number of flux quanta that are pinned at a spherical defect of radius r in a static state is n2 = πr2 π( d 2 )2 × P = ( )2 × P 2r d (3) where r, d and P is a radius of defect, a distance between quantum fluxes pinned at the defect and filling rate which is π/4 when they have square structure, respectively [5]. If d2 is 2πξ2, which is Hc2 state, a volume defect pin the maximum flux quanta. In addition, Hc2 is Inserting to Eq. (3) Thus, Hc2 = Φ0/2πξ2 = Φ0/d2 n2 = πr2 Φ0 Hc2 W∆H=∆B = mHc2 − 4πM − H(cid:48) c1 = aHc2 − b πr 2 (4) (5) (6) Thus, W∆H=∆B is proportional to Hc2 if r and m are fixed. Therefore, it is determined that the theory would have another justification if the behavior of the width along temperature is proportional to that of Hc2. C. Discussion It is clear that 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 has ∆H = ∆B region in M-H curve. However, it is another problem that ∆H = ∆B region can be generalized in the super- conductor. We insisted that the region can be generalized in the volume defect-dominating 5 superconductor. However, many peer reviews thought that the region cannot be generalized. We suggest two papers in literature, which concerned melt-textured growth superconductor that is one of volume defect-dominating superconductor. ∆H = ∆B region in M-H curve was clearly shown in the papers [6, 7]. The typical equation of Hc2 along temperature is as follows. ξ(T )2 ∝ 1 1 − t ⇒ Hc2 = Φo 2πξ2 ∝ 1 − t (7) where t = Tm/Tc, ξ is coherence length [8]. Tm is the measuring temperature and Tc is critical temperature. The equation shows that Hc2 is linear along temperature. Fig. 4 (b) is temperature dependence of Hc2 for 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 specimen, which was air-cooled. It shows that Hc2 is also linear along temperature. Most of literatures for MgB2 were that Hc2 is linear along temperature [9, 10]. Thus, it is clear that Hc2 is linear along temperature. Therefore, it is certain that the pick-out of pinned fluxes at a volume defect is influenced by Hc2 because the temperature dependence of a width of ∆H = ∆B region is proportional to that of Hc2. On the other hand, we could understand the way that pinned fluxes are picked out from a defect in ∆H = ∆B region if calculating ∆Fpinning and ∆Fpickout. As the result of calculating ∆Fpinning and ∆Fpickout in ∆H = ∆B region for 163 nm volume defects, ∆Fpinning/∆Fpickout was more than 4 [11]. Even though ∆Fpinning is more than four times larger than ∆Fpickout, pinned fluxes at the volume defect have been picked out and moved in ∆H = ∆B region. This is completely different from the concept that pinned fluxes are picked out and move when ∆Fpickout is more than ∆Fpinning. A noting thing is that a width of ∆H = ∆B region is dependent on a volume of the specimen, whereas Hc2 is not. As applied magnetic field (H) increases, fluxes are quantized and penetrate into the inside of the superconductor. If H approaches Hc2, fluxes difference between inside and outside of superconductor is infinitesimal. Thus, Hc2 is not dependent of volume of the specimen. However, a width of the region decreases as much as a volume of a specimen decreases because the number of volume defects decreases as many as a volume of a specimen decreases. Concerning Fe of (Fe, Ti) particle, ∆H = ∆B region was suspected to be that M-H curve is distorted because of the ferromagnetic nature of Fe. This means that it was a mistake to assert that ∆H = ∆B region appears in M-H curve of the specimen. We already 6 have known the problem of Fe, which is shown in Fig. 5. It is certain that M-H curves were distorted if crystal Fe was doped on MgB2. Especially, the specimen was broken after synthesizing MgB2 because MgB2 does not match crystal Fe. The figure was measuring a broken specimen. However, there was no problem with amorphous metal. (Fe, Ti) particle is amorphous, which shows different magnetic behavior from crystal Fe. We did not find any distortion in M-H curves of specimens [12]. Therefore, ∆H = ∆B region is real in the specimen as shown in Fig. 1 - 3. Concerning Bean model, the flux penetration method represented in the previous paper violates Bean model which is one of critical state model [1, 13]. We think that Bean model does not describe the nature of superconductor properly although it is honored. Researchers having studied the difference between the critical current density (Jc) of transport and that of Bean model would notice that the former is always larger than the latter. If Bean model was to describe the nature of superconductivity properly, the transport Jc must have been less than that of Bean model because there are contact resistance, etc. Bean model seems to be a theory that suggests a minimum Jc of the superconductor. In literature, it is observed that Flukiger et al. reported transport Jc and Bean model(cid:48)s Jc concurrently in Fe/MgB2 tapes [14]. III. CONCLUSION We studied temperature dependence of a width of ∆H = ∆B region in 5 wt. % (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 superconductor. A width of the region decreases linearly as tempera- ture increases. In previous report, we asserted the theory that a width of ∆H = ∆B region relates with Hc2 and pinned fluxes are picked out from the volume defects when the distance between pinned fluxes is the same as that of Hc2. Hc2 of MgB2 also decreases linearly as temperature increases. Therefore it is clear that a width of ∆H = ∆B region have relation with Hc2 of MgB2. It is considered that the theory has another justification. IV. METHOD 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2 and 5 wt.% nano-Fe particle-doped MgB2 were synthesized using the nonspecial atmosphere synthesis (NAS) method [15]. Briefing NAS 7 method, Mg (99.9% powder), B (96.6% amorphous powder), (Fe, Ti) particles, and crystal nano-Fe particles were prepared for the specimen. After mixing Mg and B stoichiometry, (Fe, Ti) particles and crystal nano-Fe particles were added by weight, respectively. They were finely ground and pressed into 10 mm diameter pellets. (Fe, Ti) particles were ball-milled for several days, and average radius of the (Fe, Ti) particles was approximately 0.163 µm. On the other hand, an 8 m-long stainless-steel (304) tube was cut into 10 cm pieces. One side of the 10 cm-long tube was forged and welded. The pellets and excess Mg were placed in the stainless-steel tube. The pellets were annealed at 300oC for 1 hour to make them hard before inserting them into the stainless-steel tube. The other side of the stainless-steel tube was also forged. High-purity Ar gas was put into the stainless-steel tube, and which was then welded. The specimens was synthesized at 920oC for 1 hour and cooled in air. The field dependences of magnetization were measured using a MPMS-7 (Quantum Design). [1] H. B. Lee, G. C. Kim, H. J. Park, D. Ahmad, and Y. C. Kim, ∆H = ∆B region in volume defect-dominating superconductors. https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.04683 (2018). [2] D. J. Van Ooljkn and G. J. Van Gurp, Measurement of noise in the resistive state of type II superconductor. Phys. Lett. 17 230 (1965). [3] J. E. Bonevich et al. Electron Holography Observation of Vortex Lattices in a Superconductor. Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 2952 (1993). [4] Charles P. Poole, Jr., Horacio A. Farach, Richard J. Creswick, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY 1st 270, Academic Press (1995). [5] H. B. Lee, G. C. Kim, Y. C. Kim, R. K. Ko, and D. Y. Jeong, Equation of motion for pinned fluxes at volume defects and increases of a diamagnetic property by flux pinning in superconductors, https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.06434 (2019). [6] S. W. Hsu, K. Chen and W. H. Lee, Temperature and Field-Sweeping Rate Dependence of Flux Jumps in A Melt-Textured YBa2Cu3O7−x Superconductor. Solid State Communications 75 799 (1990). 8 [7] K. H. Muller and C. Andrikidis, Flux jumps in melt-textured Y-Ba-Cu-O, Phys. Rev. B 49, 1294-1307 (2003). [8] Michael Tinkham, INTRODUCTION TO SUPERCONDUCTIVITY second edition, Dover Publication, New York 118 (2004). [9] Cristina Buzea and Tsutomu Yamashita, Review of the superconducting properties of MgB2 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 14 R115 (2001) [10] M Eisterer, Magnetic properties and critical currents of MgB2. Supercond. Sci. Technol. 20 R47R73 (2007). [11] H. B. Lee, G. C. Kim, B. J. Kim, and Y. C. Kim, Upper Critical Field Based on the Width of ∆H = ∆B region in a Superconductor. https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.08559 (2019). [12] H. B. Lee, G. C. Kim, Y. C. Kim and D. Ahmad, Flux jump behaviors and mechanism of FeTi doped MgB2 at 5 K, Physica C 515 31 (2015). [13] Charles P. Bean, Magnetization of High-Field Superconductors. Rev. of Mor. Phy. Jan. 31 (1964) [14] R Flukiger, P Lezza, C Beneduce, N Musolino and H L Suo, Improved transport critical current and irreversibility fields in mono- and multifilamentary Fe/MgB2 tapes and wires using fine powders, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 16 264-270 (2003). [15] H. B. Lee, Y. C. Kim and D. Y. Jeong, Non-special atmosphere synthesis for MgB2. J. Kor. Phys. Soc. 48 279-282 (2006). 9 FIG. 1: Field dependence of magnetizations (M-H curves) of 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2, which was air-cooled. (a): M-H curve at 5 K. (b): M-H curve at 10 K. 10 FIG. 2: Field dependence of magnetizations (M-H curves) of 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2, which was air-cooled. (a): M-H curve at 15 K. (b): M-H curve at 20 K. 11 FIG. 3: Field dependence of magnetizations (M-H curves) of 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle-doped MgB2, which was air-cooled. (a): M-H curve at 25 K. (b) M-H curve at 30 K 12 FIG. 4: (a): Temperature dependence of a width of ∆H =∆B region for 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle- doped MgB2 (b): Temperature dependence of upper critical field (Hc2) for 5 wt.% (Fe, Ti) particle- doped MgB2 13 FIG. 5: Distorted M-H curves of Fe-doped MgB2 for various temperatures, Fe is nano-crystal particle. 14
1901.11288	1	1901	2019-01-31T09:45:52	Highly sensitive piezotronic pressure sensors based on undoped GaAs nanowire ensembles	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	Semiconducting piezoelectric materials have attracted considerable interest due to their central role in the emerging field of piezotronics, where the development of a piezo-potential in response to stress or strain can be used to tune the band structure of the semiconductor, and hence its electronic properties. This coupling between piezoelectricity and semiconducting properties can be readily exploited for force or pressure sensing using nanowires, where the geometry and unclamped nature of nanowires render them particularly sensitive to small forces. At the same time, piezoelectricity is known to manifest more strongly in nanowires of certain semiconductors. Here, we report the design and fabrication of highly sensitive piezotronic pressure sensors based on GaAs nanowire ensemble sandwiched between two electrodes in a back-to-back diode configuration. We analyse the current-voltage characteristics of these nanowire-based devices in response to mechanical loading in light of the corresponding changes to the device band structure. We observe a high piezotronic sensitivity to pressure, of ~7800 meV/MPa. We attribute this high sensitivity to the nanowires being fully depleted due to the lack of doping, as well as due to geometrical pressure focusing and current funneling through polar interfaces.	physics.app-ph	physics	Highly sensitive piezotronic pressure sensors based on undoped GaAs nanowire ensembles Yonatan Calahorra1†, Anke Husmann1†, Alice Bourdelain2, Wonjong Kim3, Jelena Vukajlovic-Plestina3, Chess Boughey1, Qingshen Jing1, Anna Fontcuberta i Morral3,4, Sohini Kar-Narayan1* 1 Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge, 27 Charles Babbage Cambridge CB3 0FS, UK 2 Institut des Nanotechnologies de Lyon - Université de Lyon, UMR 5270 - CNRS, Ecole Centrale de Lyon, France 3 Laboratory of Semiconductor Materials, Institute of Materials, School of Engineering, Ecole polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland 4 Institute of Physics, School of Basic Sciences, Ecole polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland † These authors contributed equally to this work *Email:[email protected] Abstract Semiconducting piezoelectric materials have attracted considerable interest due to their central role in the emerging field of piezotronics, where the development of a piezo-potential in response to stress or strain can be used to tune the band structure of the semiconductor, and hence its electronic properties. This coupling between piezoelectricity and semiconducting properties can be readily exploited for force or pressure sensing using nanowires, where the geometry and unclamped nature of nanowires render them particularly sensitive to small forces. At the same time, piezoelectricity is known to manifest more strongly in nanowires of certain semiconductors. Here, we report the design and fabrication of highly sensitive piezotronic pressure sensors based on GaAs nanowire ensemble sandwiched between two electrodes in a back-to-back diode configuration. We analyse the current-voltage characteristics of these nanowire-based devices in response to mechanical loading in light of the corresponding changes to the device band structure. We observe a high piezotronic sensitivity to pressure, of ~7800 meV/MPa. We attribute this high sensitivity to the nanowires being fully depleted due to the lack of doping, as well as due to geometrical pressure focusing and current funnelling through polar interfaces. Introduction Nanoscale piezoelectric semiconductors have attracted considerable attention in the past decade for applications in sensing, optics and energy harvesting [1-3]. This stems from the unique set of properties offered by the combination of piezoelectricity and semiconductor physics. For example, the piezoelectric effect, where mechanically induced changes to atomic structure induce electrical polarisation (and vice-versa) [4], is transient by nature. In other words, applying pressure to a piezoelectric crystal will yield a voltage (or current) peak, but not act as a DC source. In that sense, a piezoelectric pressure sensor is actually a pressure-change sensor. The underlying reason is the retention of charge neutrality. Conversely, in semiconductors, potentially there are regions of high and low conductivity in close proximity, such as junction-related depletion regions [5]. Consider a semiconductor which is also piezoelectric, e.g. III-V, III-N or II-VI materials, that forms a p-n or metal- semiconductor junction. If the depletion region become strained, then the corresponding change in polarisation will result in a change in surface charge and hence surface potential, effectively resulting in a change in junction barrier height. This effect is not time-dependent since the polarisation charges would not be neutralised. This effect has been coined as the piezotronic effect [3], and it bears potential in mechanical sensing [1], mechanically controlled logic [6] and optics [7]. It also affects the operation of III-N based high electron mobility transistors[8], and is closely related to ferroelectric-metal contacts [9]. The current-voltage (I-V) characteristics of a single Schottky junction is given by [5] 𝐼~𝑒𝑥𝑝 ( 𝑞Φ𝐵 𝑘𝐵𝑇 ) 𝑒𝑥𝑝 ( 𝑞𝑉 𝑛𝑘𝐵𝑇 ) 𝑥 (1 − 𝑒𝑥𝑝 (− 𝑞𝑉 𝑘𝐵𝑇 )) (1) where Φ𝐵 is Schottky barrier height, 𝑉 is the applied voltage, 𝑛 is the ideality factor, 𝑘𝐵 is the Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature and 𝑞 is the electronic charge. Following Eq. (1), a simple expression for the change in current due to change in barrier height is given by 𝑙𝑛(𝐼𝑆𝑡𝑟𝑒𝑠𝑠/𝐼0) ∼ −∆Φ𝐵 ( 𝑞 𝑘𝐵𝑇 ) (2) The current through back-to-back Schottky diodes (as found in a semiconductor sandwiched between two metallic electrodes) is more complex, since the applied voltage is dropped across both junctions, as well as the semiconductor, taking continuity into consideration. The I-V characteristics in this case are governed by the semiconductor depletion, and flat-band conditions [10]. Most work on nanowire (NW) piezoelectricity and piezotronics has been devoted to III-Ns and ZnO, which are the most commonly known piezoelectric semiconductors [6, 11-16]. This is intriguing, considering that the initial observations of mechanical effects on Schottky barrier height were obtained on III-V materials [17-20]. The piezotronic effect in (non-nitride) III-V materials is important due to their applications in high-speed electronics and optoelectronics [21], and in NWs due to potential integration with silicon [22, 23]. However, there are not many reports on piezoelectricity and piezotronic effects in III-V NWs [24-28], although Ref. [29] provides a comprehensive review on the subject. In previous work from our group, we have used non-destructive piezoresponse force microscopy (PFM) [30] to examine the converse piezoelectric effect in GaAs and InP NWs [28]. Others have also focused on GaAs NWs, studying piezoelectric generation of NW ensembles [26], as well as single NW current generation and piezotronics using an atomic force microscopy (AFM) apparatus [27]. In this context, it is useful to examine the electro-mechanical effects in a practical device configuration. Here, we demonstrate and analyse the piezotronic effect in Schottky diodes based on GaAs NW ensembles. We consider the complex nature of device contacts, and qualitatively determine the stress distribution in the NWs through analysis of current response to mechanical loading in a back- to-back diode configuration. Materials and Methods Piezotronic pressure-sensitive devices were fabricated by sandwiching GaAs nanowire ensembles between two electrodes. GaAs nanowires have been grown through molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) by Ga-assisted self-catalysed method on Si substrates covered with a thin oxide layer. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Hitachi TM3030 was used to characterise NW morphology and monitor device processing. Bottom left SEM in Figure 1 shows the growth results, comprising a mix of zinc-blende (ZB) NWs, wurtzite (WZ) NWs, and a parasitic growth (see Supporting Information S1, for full details). Figure 1. Schematic of device fabrication process, and corresponding SEM images: the silicon substrate bearing grown GaAs NWs is spin coated with polyimide, etched and sputtered with gold. Left scale bar is 1.5 µm, all other scale bars are 5 µm. Piezotronic devices were fabricated using these nanowire ensembles as follows (see Figure 1): polyimide was spin coated as a spacer layer, then etched back to expose the NW tips, followed by the devices being sputtered with gold as the top electrode(see Supporting Information S1 for full details). The p-Si substrate served as the bottom electrode and was connected to a conductive substrate via silver paint for electrical access. Figure 1 shows a schematic of the device fabrication and corresponding SEM images of the different fabrication stages. The area of a single device was roughly 0.1 cm2, see also Figure 2a inset. Considering the back etching step of the spacer layer, we assume the contacts are mostly formed to the longest NWs, usually associated with ZB growth. We did not consider the mechanical or electrical effects of uncontacted material. I-V Measurements were performed under different loading scenarios using LabView®️ to control a Keithley 2400 SourceMeter. Applied voltages were swept from 0V -> 1V -> -1V -> 0V with a sweep rate of 0.1 V/s while the current was measured in a two-point configuration. Devices were loaded with a set of calibration weights. The load was sequentially increased, and a comparative voltage sweep was done at the end of each run to ensure that the devices recover their original unloaded I-V characteristics. Results and Discussion Figure 2a shows the I-V measurements of a typical GaAs NW ensemble device, before, during and after mechanical loading. The curves changed and current was found to diminish (in absolute value) with the application of compressive stress, i.e. when a weight was placed on top of the device. Noticeably, this happened for both voltage polarities, unlike some piezotronic devices reported in the literature, where current on one side increases while it decreases on the other side [31]. There was, however, a difference in the observed current response for the two voltage polarities: the change was significantly larger when negative voltage was applied, compared to when a positive voltage was applied. The negative polarity voltage sweep also gave rise to a higher current. This trend was observed in an additional device (See SI Figure S2). Figure 2: (a) I-V curve for Device B under load. Inset: device mounted for measurements (b) 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ √𝑉𝐹𝐵 − 𝑉 for two devices for the negative polarity of the I-V curves. Inset: Values for VFB. We start by discussing these findings qualitatively: the GaAs NWs are sandwiched between a gold electrode at the top and highly conducting p-type silicon at the bottom, and the shape of the I-V curve obtained agrees with back-to-back (BtB) diode characteristics. Generally, in a BtB configuration, for any given applied voltage, one diode is forward biased while the other is reverse biased, thereby the latter accounts for most of the voltage drop - and is the limiting element for the electronic current. In our device, voltage was applied to the top gold electrode while the p-Si substrate was grounded. A positive voltage corresponds to the substrate/NW junction being reversed biased, while the metal/NW junction current determined by the actual potential drop on the junction. The smaller current response to mechanical loading in this voltage polarity indicates that while the current is dictated by the substrate/NW junction, it remains unaffected by the stress, therefore indicating that this junction and the NW segments closest to it undergo little or no deformation. This result is further discussed in detail below. In negative polarity, the substrate/NW junction is forward biased.. It is useful to examine the device in better detail. In BtB Schottky diodes, a large enough reverse bias may also correspond to injection of minority carriers [10] (electrons in our case -- considering the p-Si as determining the majority carriers). Our device is composed of a semiconducting junction and a Schottky junction, and therefore, in the negative polarity, it is possible that the substrate/NW junction injects majority carriers (holes), and the metal/NW junction injects electrons. We apply the results obtained by Sze [10] to examine the operation of our device in negative polarity. In our case, due to the nominally intrinsic nature of the NWs, and their inherent size dependent properties favouring depletion[32, 33], it is reasonable to expect -80-60-40-20020-1-0.500.51no loadload of 50gload of 100gno load recoveredCurrent (mA)Voltage (V)(a)-16-14-12-1000.20.40.60.81A no loadB no loadA load of 50gB load of 50gA load of 100gB load of 100gln (I/I0) (I0 = 1A)(VFB-V)0.5(V0.5)(b)-0.2-0.15-0.1012ABVFB (V)P (kPa) the NW to be depleted at all voltages, and the current to obey the corresponding relations, i.e. 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ (𝑉 − 𝑉𝐹𝐵)2 or 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ √𝑉 − 𝑉𝐹𝐵 [10], depending on whether the device is beyond application of the flat-band voltage, 𝑉𝐹𝐵. Figure 2b shows the graphs for the measured current for 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ √𝑉 − 𝑉𝐹𝐵 , which provided a better fit than 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ (𝑉 − 𝑉𝐹𝐵)2 (see the second fit in Supporting Information Figure S3). This suggests that for most of the applied voltages the device is beyond flat-band conditions. This fitting also allows the extraction of 𝑉𝐹𝐵 as a function of applied compression (Figure 2b inset), showing that 𝑉𝐹𝐵 is reduced (in absolute value) almost linearly with compression. Next we analyse the band diagram of the device to examine our understanding of its operation and result. Figure 3. Schematic band diagrams of the NW device (shown in the upper inset. a) Unbiased, uncompressed axial band diagram - gallium contact; b) Unbiased, uncompressed band diagram corresponding to the sidewall contact; c) axial band diagram under negative bias; d) axial band diagram under negative bias and compression (shown schematically in the middle inset). Figures 3a-d show the band diagrams corresponding to equilibrium, negative polarity, and the addition of compressive stress. This is a schematic analysis based on the conditions in the GaAs boundaries. Specifically, considering the depleted nature of the device as mentioned above, we examine two possible contact configurations for the metal/NW junction, due to contact potentially forming between the NW growth front and the gallium catalyst, or the NW sidewalls and the deposited gold electrode. Figures 3a and b are plotted considering these two effects: for the growth interface, the Si/GaAs pn junction, we consider ideal band continuity, thus determined by the similar electron affinities of silicon and GaAs (~ 4.05 eV) [5]; next, the conduction and valence bands of the GaAs NW are mostly linear due to depletion (Poisson equation becomes Laplace equation following the lack of ionised dopants); finally we consider a "nearly ideal" interface between the gallium droplet (work function of ~ 4.2 eV) and the (111)B facet of the NW, formed in-situ (Figure 3a), and a post-processing interface between the {1-10} or {11-2} facets of the NW sidewalls and the gold, dominated by charge traps, with Fermi level pinning to ⅓ of the band gap [10]. Let us now consider the two voltage polarities and the two contact configurations. Clearly, the gold contact favours hole injection (in positive applied voltage polarity), while the gallium contact favours electron injection (in negative applied bias polarity). It is therefore possible that during polarity change, the active contact also changes. Interestingly, the gold contact is formed on non-polar GaAs surfaces, which agrees with the lower electromechanical response corresponding to the positive polarity. Another factor which probably contributes to this finding is the mechanical encapsulation of the NWs, effectively protecting the substrate/NW junction, thereby further reducing the electromechanical response. Notably, plotting 𝑙𝑛(𝐼) ∼ √𝑉 − 𝑉𝐹𝐵 for the forward bias yields a very small value (~ 𝑘𝐵𝑇, Supporting Information Figure S4) for 𝑉𝐹𝐵. This aligns very well with the gold-contact band diagram (Figure 3b) and further validates our understanding of the device operation. We continue analysing the device assuming that the gallium contact, formed on the polar (111)B face of the NW, is active in the negative polarity. Figure 3c depicts the gallium contact under negative voltage, injecting minority carrier electrons, while the substrate/NW Pn junction is forward biased (injecting holes), resulting in quasi Fermi levels for holes and electrons, that are plotted schematically. Figure 3d depicts the device upon application of compression. The axial piezoelectric coefficient (𝑑33 or 𝑒33) of (111) oriented GaAs NWs is negative and therefore upon application of compressive stress, a negative polarisation charge develops at the arsenic face, and positive charge at the gallium face [28, 34]. Overall, the polarisation is oriented along (111)A, resulting in upward bending of the bands at the arsenic face, thus effectively increasing the barrier for electrons, and reducing the current. Another outcome of the mechanically induced band shift is that the bands are pushed towards flat-band conditions, meaning that a smaller bias is required in order to reach flat-band conditions. This is in perfect agreement with the fitting results of the devices shown in the inset of Figure 2b, where 𝑉𝐹𝐵 decreases (in absolute value) with compression. We now discuss the results in better detail in light of our understanding of the device structure and corresponding band diagrams. Figure 4 shows the calculated gauge factor, GF, defined as the relative change in resistivity normalised by strain. This calculation is an estimate, considering we did not measure the actual compression in the NWs, rather we only have values of the applied pressure. In order to assess strain, we consider the interaction to be elastic, and neglect any plastic deformation of the contacts. This is justified based on the successful retention of the unloaded I-V characteristics. We use the following values for Young's modulus: YGaAs,111 = 130 GPa [35], and Ypolyimide = 2.5 GPa (from Dupont technical sheets), and we consider a simplified polyimide-GaAs NW composite, comprising ~1% GaAs, giving an overall effective elastic modulus of 3.75 GPa. Using this value to estimate strain for a given load, our GaAs NW piezotronic devices were found to be highly sensitive to pressure with a peak GF of ~105. This is considerably higher than piezoresistive devices with GF of ~ 200, and also compared to piezotronic devices based on ZnO [11, 31] or InAs NWs (~1000)[36]. For a quantitative comparison, we examine the known quantities used, i.e. weight and associated pressure, and examine the piezotronic pressure sensitivity, ∆Φ𝐵/∆𝑃, where P is the applied pressure. We compare our results to Ref. [11],[15],[20] and [37]. For our device, we plot the barrier height change for the weights examined (Supporting Information Table S5) and find a slope of about 7790 meV/MPa for our higher performing device (B). This suggests that our devices exhibit excellent sensitivity for pressure, the highest reported to date to the best of our knowledge. In Ref. [11] a single ZnO microwire was strained (and compressed) in ratios up to ±1%, with a corresponding change in barrier height of ±5 meV. To convert this strain to stress, we take YZnO,wire = 80 GPa, which is a value somewhat smaller than accepted for bulk [38]. Therefore, Zhou et al. observed a pressure sensitivity of 5/800 = 0.0063 meV/MPa in their study. Kiel et al. [15] measured 9/65 = 0.14 meV/MPa sensitivity for a single crystal ZnO Schottky barrier. More recently, Wang et al. [37] reported a record high piezotronic pressure sensitivity of 1400 meV/MPa, by combining two mirrored ZnO platelets, thus taking advantage of the surface polarisation effect on both device contacts, the sensitivity of this configuration was further studied by Kiel et al. [39]. If so, our result of 7790 meV/GPa is remarkable considering that ZnO is about an order of magnitude more piezoelectric than GaAs [28]. It is also striking when compared to the only study we know of piezotronic sensitivity in bulk GaAs, where Chung et al. measured 0.0067 meV/MPa for the (111) direction [20], indicating a 6 orders of magnitude increase in sensitivity of the NW device compared to bulk diodes. Figure 4: (a) Gauge factors for two devices under two different loading conditions. (b) extracted ∆Φ𝐵 as a function of pressure at -0.5 V, with and in inset showing the variation of ∆Φ𝐵 as a function of voltage. There are three possible reasons for the observed high sensitivity, the first being mechanical stress focusing, as reported for GaAs NW piezoelectric sensors [26]. In Ref. [26], the authors have shown that electrically contacting NW ensembles may result in a significant increase in effective strain in the NWs, leading to an enhancement of the apparent piezoelectric coefficients by up to 2 orders of magnitude. It is very likely that this effect significantly affects the response of our pressure-sensitive piezotronic device. Secondly, the fact that the device is completely depleted contributes to the reduction of any screening effect, thus maximising the piezotronic response. As mentioned above in the initial discussion of the piezotronic effect, the existence of the depletion region allows the existence of the non-decaying piezotronic effect to begin with. In the case where the entire length of the NW is depleted, the effect is obviously expected to be enhanced. This explanation is supported by our finding that devices with higher initial currents exhibited lower sensitivities (see the comparison between devices A and B in Figure 4). Interestingly, in a recent theoretical work, a piezotronic bipolar transistor was examined [40], where it was shown that as the transistor was strained, the dominant piezo-potential developed at the base of the transistor, i.e. the area with lowest doping that was essentially depleted. The theoretically derived GF was reported to be ~ 104, which is an order of magnitude higher than obtained by a single ZnO NW contact studied in [11]. If so, there is an established connection between depletion and enhancement of the piezotronic effect. This is of course not surprising since the piezotronic effect is defined in depletion regions. Therefore, the question of significance for a device is how much strain is transferred to areas which are depleted. Finally, another factor that might contribute to the sensitivity -1 106-5 1050-1-0.500.51A load of 50gA load of 100gB load of 50gB load of 100gGauge factor (Dr / (r e) )Voltage (V)99% PI + 1% GaAs (111)(a)00.010.0200.511.522.5A B D F (V) at 0.5VP (kPa)(b)00.010.02-101A 1.93kPaA 2.58kPaB 1.93kPaB 2.58kPaD F (V)V (V) of our devices is the contact configuration. In our discussion we concluded that the dominant contact under negative bias is the gallium droplet, which interfaces the polar (111)B facet. Therefore, arguably, all the electrons injected into the device in negative bias "feel" the pressure. In many other studies involving single ZnO NWs, contacts are made in a wrapping configuration, where significant contact is made to non-polar facets, effectively lowering the responsivity. This aligns well with our observation of the lower response in the positive bias where contact is made through the wrapping gold. In fact if we examine 𝑉𝐹𝐵 for the positive bias, we find that it does not change with pressure (Supporting Information Figure S4), indicating the lowered piezotronic response. Conclusions To summarise, we have fabricated highly sensitive piezotronic sensors using MBE-grown GaAs nanowire ensembles in a back-to-back diode geometry. We studied the current-voltage characteristics of these devices with and without mechanical loading, and found that the current response was dependent on the polarity of the applied voltage. This asymmetry in the response arose due to the inherently different nature of the Schottky diodes formed at the respective electrode/nanowire interfaces. The doped p-Si substrate on which the nanowire ensemble was grown, served as the bottom electrode was, while the top electrode comprised of sputtered gold / gallium droplet. The effect of loading on the current-voltage characteristics could be explained by considering the band diagram of the device, whereby the applied mechanical pressure resulted in polarisation changes at the surface, thus leading to a change in the band conditions and barrier height. Our best-performing device exhibited a piezotronic pressure sensitivity of 7790 meV/MPa, which is higher than that reported in the literature for other nanowire-ensemble, single nanowire and single/bicrystal configurations piezotronic pressure sensors. The high piezotronic sensitivity of the device could be attributed to increased device depletion, funnelling of the current through polar interface, as well as mechanical stress focusing as a result of our nanowire-based device geometry. We expect that these finding will serve to guide further work into the design of highly sensitive pressure sensors. Acknowledgements This work was financially supported by a grant from the European Research Council through an ERC Starting Grant (Grant no. ERC -- 2014 -- STG -- 639526, NANOGEN). C.B. acknowledges funding from the EPSRC Cambridge NanoDTC, EP/G037221/1, Cambridge Philosophical Society bursary, Sir Colin Corness Bursary from Magdalene College Cambridge, and EPSRC post-Ph.D. prize. A.H acknowledges funding from the Isaac Newton Trust. WK, JVP and AFiM thank funding from H2020 through the projects INDEED and Nanoembrace. References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] (2013) (9) 752. [8] X.D. Wang, J. Zhou, J.H. Song, J. Liu, N.S. Xu, Z.L. Wang, Nano Letters 6 (2006) (12) 2768. Z.L. Wang, J.H. Song, Science 312 (2006) (5771) 242. Z.L. Wang, Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 1 (2010) (9) 1388. J. Curie, P. Curie, Bulletin de minéralogie 3 (1880) 4. S.M. Sze, K.N. Kwok, Physics of semiconductor devices, John wiley & sons (2006). Z.L. Wang, Nano Today 5 (2010) (6) 540. C.F. Pan, L. Dong, G. Zhu, S.M. Niu, R.M. Yu, Q. Yang, Y. Liu, Z.L. Wang, Nature Photonics 7 C. Wood, D. Jena, SpringerLink (Online service), Polarization Effects in Semiconductors N. Jamond, P. Chretien, L. Gatilova, E. Galopin, L. Travers, J.C. Harmand, F. Glas, F. Houze, N. J. Lagowski, I. Baltov, H.C. Gatos, Surface Science 40 (1973) (2) 216. K.W. Chung, Z. Wang, J.C. Costa, F. Williamson, P.P. Ruden, M.I. Nathan, Applied Physics J. Singh, Electronic and optoelectronic properties of semiconductor structures, Cambridge P. Keil, T. Fromling, A. Klein, J. Rodel, N. Novak, Journal of Applied Physics 121 (2017) (15). Y. Calahorra, C.L. Ou, C. Boughey, S. Kar-Narayan, Nanowires for Energy Applications 98 (2018) N. Gogneau, P. Chretien, E. Galopin, S. Guilet, L. Travers, J.C. Harmand, F. Houze, Physica N. Jamond, P. Chretien, F. Houze, L. Lu, L. Largeau, O. Maugain, L. Travers, J.C. Harmand, F. L. Pintilie, M. Alexe, Journal of Applied Physics 98 (2005) (12). S.M. Sze, D.J. Coleman, A. Loya, Solid-State Electronics 14 (1971) (12) 1209. J. Zhou, Y.D. Gu, P. Fei, W.J. Mai, Y.F. Gao, R.S. Yang, G. Bao, Z.L. Wang, Nano Letters 8 (2008) From Ab InitioTheory to Device Applications, Springer Science+Business Media, LLC,, Boston, MA (2008). [9] [10] [11] (9) 3035. [12] Status Solidi-Rapid Research Letters 8 (2014) (5) 414. [13] Glas, E. Lefeuvre, M. Tchernycheva, N. Gogneau, Nanotechnology 27 (2016) (32). [14] Gogneau, Nanoscale 9 (2017) (13) 4610. [15] [16] 445. [17] [18] M. Kusaka, Surface Science 78 (1978) (1) 209. [19] M. Kusaka, N. Hiraoka, M. Hirai, S. Okazaki, Surface Science 91 (1980) (1) 264. [20] Letters 59 (1991) (10) 1191. [21] University Press, New York (2003). [22] Morral, Nature Photonics 7 (2013) (4) 306. [23] A.F.I. Morral, Nano Letters 17 (2017) (7) 4101. [24] Khrebtov, E.M. Tanklevskaya, I.A. Seleznev, Semiconductors 45 (2011) (8) 1082. [25] [26] 10 (2016) (2) 172. [27] Khrebtov, I.P. Soshnikov, E. Lahderanta, Physica Status Solidi-Rapid Research Letters 12 (2018) (1). [28] Semiconductor Science and Technology 32 (2017) (7) 074006. [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] Y. Calahorra, S. Kar-Narayan, Journal of Materials Research 33 (2018) (6) 611. Y. Calahorra, M. Smith, A. Datta, H. Benisty, S. Kar-Narayan, Nanoscale 9 (2017) 8. X.N. Wen, W.Z. Wu, C.F. Pan, Y.F. Hu, Q. Yang, Z.L. Wang, Nano Energy 14 (2015) 276. Y. Calahorra, D. Ritter, Journal of Applied Physics 114 (2013) (12). Y. Calahorra, E. Yalon, D. Ritter, Journal of Applied Physics 117 (2015) (3). H.Y.S. Al-Zahrani, J. Pal, M.A. Migliorato, G. Tse, D.P. Yu, Nano Energy 14 (2015) 382. V. Lysak, I.P. Soshnikov, E. Lahderanta, G.E. Cirlin, Physica Status Solidi-Rapid Research Letters P. Krogstrup, H.I. Jorgensen, M. Heiss, O. Demichel, J.V. Holm, M. Aagesen, J. Nygard, A.F.I. J. Vukajlovic-Plestina, W. Kim, V.G. Dubrovski, G. Tutuncuoglu, M. Lagier, H. Potts, M. Friedl, I.P. Soshnikov, D.E. Afanas'ev, V.A. Petrov, G.E. Cirlin, A.D. Bouravlev, Y.B. Samsonenko, A. P.A. Alekseev, V.A. Sharov, P. Geydt, M.S. Dunaevskiy, V.V. Lysak, G.E. Cirlin, R.R. Reznik, A.I. Y. Calahorra, X. Guan, N.N. Halder, M. Smith, S. Cohen, D. Ritter, J. Penuelas, S. Kar-Narayan, [34] [35] World Scientific (1994). [36] [37] (2017) (5) 4859. [38] (2014) (2) 166. [39] (10). [40] P. Keil, M. Trapp, N. Novak, T. Fromling, H.J. Kleebe, J. Rodel, Advanced Materials 30 (2018) P. Zhu, Z.M. Zhao, J.H. Nie, G.W. Hu, L.J. Li, Y. Zhang, Nano Energy 50 (2018) 744. G. Arlt, P. Quadflieg, Physica Status Solidi 25 (1968) (1) 323. S. Adachi, GaAs and Related Materials: Bulk Semiconducting and Superlattice Properties, X. Li, X.L. Wei, T.T. Xu, D. Pan, J.H. Zhao, Q. Chen, Advanced Materials 27 (2015) (18) 2852. L.F. Wang, S.H. Liu, X.L. Feng, Q. Xu, S. Bai, L.P. Zhu, L.B. Chen, Y. Qin, Z.L. Wang, Acs Nano 11 H. Kim, U.S. Jung, S.I. Kim, D. Yoon, H. Cheong, C.W. Lee, S.W. Lee, Current Applied Physics 14
1810.08018	1	1810	2018-10-18T12:44:40	Coating of Aluminum Alloys by Micro Arc Oxidation in Nitrate Salt	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci" ]	Plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) is a process for obtaining oxide coatings on valve metals. Mostly PEO is done in an aqueous solution electrolyte which limits the size of treated parts due to the system heating up. In presented work an alternative method of PEO processing applied in aluminum 1050 alloy in nitrate molten salt was investigated. The morphology, phase and chemical compositions, micro-hardness, and corrosion resistance were examined using. The obtained results showed that formed coating contains from two sub-layers, outer soft layer with the thickness of 4 micrometer and inner, denser layer with the thickness of 5 micrometer. The formed coating consists of corundum, {\gamma} - Al2O3, {\theta} - Al2O3 and is free of any contaminants originated from the electrolyte.	physics.app-ph	physics	COATING OF ALUMINUM ALLOYS BY MICRO ARC OXIDATION IN NITRATE SALT Alexander Sobolev, Alexey Kossenko, Michael Zinigrad, Konstantin Borodianskiy Zimin Advanced Materials Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Biotechnology and Materials, Ariel University, Ariel 40700, Israel [email protected] Plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) is a process for obtaining oxide coatings on valve metals. Mostly PEO is done in an aqueous solution electrolyte which limits the size of treated parts due to the system heating up. In presented work an alternative method of PEO processing applied in aluminum 1050 alloy in nitrate molten salt was investigated. The morphology, phase and chemical compositions, micro-hardness, and corrosion resistance were examined using. The obtained results showed that formed coating contains from two sub-layers, outer soft layer with the thickness of 4 µm and inner, denser layer with the thickness of 5µm. The formed coating consists of corundum, γ-Al2O3, θ- Al2O3and is free of any contaminants originated from the electrolyte. Introduction Aluminum alloys show a variety of advanced physical and mechanical properties such as low density and high thermal and electrical conductivity [1]. Al alloys are widely applied in various industries such as electronics, marine, aerospace and machining [2]. However, its relatively low chemical resistance and negative potential limit its use, especially when good corrosion and wear resistance properties are required [3]. This issue could be solved by the formation of the protective coating formed by plasma electrolytic oxidation (PEO) process [4-6]. PEO process also named as micro arc oxidation (MAO) or anode spark deposition (ASD) is a type of high voltage anodizing process. The process causes to the formation of oxide crystal based coatings on valve metals and alloys (Al, Ti, Mg, Zr) [7-8].This process involves the reactions of anodizing and the formation of dielectric breakdowns (micro- arc discharges). While the voltage furthers increases, the micro-arc discharges stabilize and a crystalline high-temperature coating is forms. Usually the process conducted in aqueous electrolyte, but our previous 190 works showed that molten salt electrolyte is preferable in applications for large surfaces [9-10] and in work of composition prediction [11]. In the presented work the process of coating formation on Al 1050 alloy by PEO process in nitrate salt of the KNO3 -- NaNO3 composition was investigated. Electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction were applied to evaluate morphology, chemical and phase composition changes during the process. Microhardness and corrosion tests were performed to evaluate the technological properties of the formed coating. Experimental Aluminum wrought alloy 1050 specimens (chemical composition shown in Table 1) with a surface area of 0.16-0.17 dm2 were grounded using by abrasive papers grits #600-1000, and then subjected to ultrasonically cleaning in acetone. Si 0.25 Chemical composition of the Al alloy 1050 Chemical Element [%wt.] Table 1 Mg 0.05 Fe 0.44 Cu 0.05 Mn 0.05 Zn 0.07 Ti 0.05 Al Base PEO treatment conducted at 280С in the electrolyte with the eutectic composition of NaNO3 -- KNO3 with the mass % of 45.7:54.3 respectively. The electrolyte was held in a nickel crucible (99.95% Ni) which served as a counter electrode as well. The surface ratio of anode:cathode was 1:30, the anodic current density was 70 mA/cm2, voltage was limited by the galvanostatic mode. The applied power supply has the following parameters: Imax = 5A, Umax =900V, current and voltage were pulsed with a square-wave sweep at a frequency of 50Hz (ta = tk = 0.01 s). Duration of PEO treatment was 10min with the coating rate of 1μm/min. The current and the voltage wave profiles and trend plots, as well as the power consumed during the process, were measured using Fluke Scope Meter 199C, which was located into the electrical circuit between the power supply and the working container. 191 A standard method for metallographic preparation was used for cross-sections preparation. Surface and cross-section morphologies of the obtained PEO coatings were examined by TESCAN MAIA3 scanning electron microscopy (SEM) equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) system. The phase composition of the coatings were determined by a PANalytical Empyrean diffractometer (in Cu Kα radiation) in grazing incidence mode using a scan with a grazing angle of 3°, a step size of 0.03°, and at a 2θ range from 10° to 90°. A Buehler Micromet 2100 microhardness tester was used to evaluate microhardness of the obtained oxide layer on a cross section area. The microhardness was determined according to ASTM E384, C1327, and B578 as the mean of eight measurements for each sublayer under a load equal to 10g. The corrosion behavior of samples was examined by potentiodynamic polarization tests in a 3.5 wt.% NaCl solution by Autolab PGSTAT12 potentiostat/galvanostat with the General Purpose Electrochemical System (GPES), version 4.9 software. A three-electrode cell with a stainless steel counter electrode and a saturated Ag/AgCl reference electrode was used. The polarization resistance of a sample was determined at the range of ± 250mV with respect to the recorded corrosion potential at a scan rate of 0.1 mV/s (OCP). Prior to the potentiodynamic polarization test, the samples were kept in the 3.5 wt.% NaCl solution for 60 min in order to reach the steady state of a working electrode (OCP). Results and Discussion Fig. 1 presents the surface morphology of the treated by PEO alloy and the chemical composition obtained by EDS. The obtained surface has a typical structure for the surfaces obtained by PEO approach. This coating has a pan-like structure with a nonuniformly distributed porous structure. The pores are of the sphere- like geometry with the average size of 0.2-2.5 µm.EDS results show that the results fit the composition of the formed aluminum oxide with no any additional impurities originated from the electrolyte composition. That is totally different from the results usually obtained in the aqueous electrolyte where the formed coating usually contains additional elements originated from the electrolyte composition. 192 Fig. 1. The surface morphology of Al 1050 alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approachshown in (a) ×1500, (b) ×5000, and (c) the chemical composition of the Al 1050 alloy after PEO treatment by EDS. The line scan of the obtained coating is shown on Fig. 2. The line scan of the obtained coating evaluated the presence of two layers: the outer and the inner. Based on the elemental distribution across the coating thickness it is seen that the inner layer is more homogeneous and has no pores while the outer has softer structure and contains pores. The thickness of the outer and the inner layers are about 4 and 5 µm, respectively. The surface phase composition evaluation has been done by XRD investigation which patterns shown in Fig. 3. 193 Fig. 2. Cross section morphology of Al 1050 alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approachand its EDS line scan: 1 -- aluminum base (Al alloy 1050); 2 -- inner layer; 3 -- outer layer; 4 -- resin. XRD patterns detected the presence of three aluminum oxide phases namely, corundum, γ-Al2O3, θ-Al2O3. Detected phases are phases of aluminum oxide which were formed as a result of high temperature dielectric plasma breakdowns with further melting and crystallization of newly formed coating. Micro-hardness measurements were performed on the obtained oxide coating and compared with the base Al alloy. Those results are presented in Table 2. Based on the results, we assume that the outer layer mostly contains corundum phase while inner layer contains softer compounds as γ-Al2O3 and θ-Al2O3. 194 Fig. 3. X-ray surface diffraction pattern of Al 1050 alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approach. Table 2 Micro-hardness measurementsthe alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approach Base Al alloy [HV] Inner layer[HV] Outer layer[HV] 44 748 1112 The corrosion resistance of the coated alloy was determined by the potentiodynamic polarization method. The obtained curve compared to that of unmodified ally and both are presented in Fig. 4. Before the potenetiodynamic measurements, samples were immersed into 3.5% NaCl for reaching OCP. During the measurements the corrosion potential (Ecorr) and the current (icorr) were recorded. The coefficients βa and βc were calculated from the slops on the Figure 4 and the polarization resistance (Rp) was calculated according to the following equation: (1) 195 )(3.2cacorrcapiRFig. 4. Potentiodynamic polarization curves of Al 1050 alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approach (a) and base Al 1050 alloy (b), both in 3.5% NaCl solution. Table 3 summarizes the obtained results on the corrosion parameters. Corrosion test characteristics of based Al 1050 alloy compared to the alloy with oxide coating obtained by PEO approach. Samples Base Al 1050 Coated Al 1050 Table 3 Ecorr [mV] icorr×10-6 [A] Anodic Tafel slope (βa) [mV/decade] CathodicTafel slope (βc) [mV/decade] Rp,×105 [Ω/cm2] -980 13 185 208 0.032 -480 0.5 280 220 1.07 The results in Table 3 show that PEO process is a promising method for improvement of metal corrosion resistance [12-13].The calculated polarization resistance of the coated alloy is 1.07105 Ω/cm2, while uncoated is 0.032105 Ω/cm2.Thepolarization resistance in coated alloy is one and a half orders of magnitude higher than that of the uncoated alloy. 196 Conclusions The presented work showed the process and characterization of oxide coating formation on Al 1050 alloy in the eutectic composition nitrate salts. X-ray diffraction investigation results showed that the coating consists of the following phases: corundum, γ-Al2O3, θ-Al2O3. The SEM images showed that the formed oxide coating contains two sublayers, outer soft layer with the thickness of 4µm and inner, denser layer with the thickness of 5µm. Those results were confirmed by micro- hardness measurements which detected the differences of the hardness of both oxide layers. Moreover, the corrosion resistance test showed that the corrosion rate of the coated alloy is in one order of magnitude lower compared to the uncoated alloy. Acknowledgements This work was carried out with the support of the Ministry of Aliyah and Integration, the State of Israel. Additionally, the authors would like to thank Ms. Natalia Litvak from the Engineering and Technology Unit at the Ariel University for her help with electron microscopy investigations. References A.L. Yerokhin, X. Nie, A. Leyland, A. Matthews, S.J. Dowey. Plasma electrolysis for surface engineering. Surf. Coat. Technol. 1999, 122, 73 -- 93. X. Nie, E.I. Meletis, J.C. Jiang, A. Leyland, A.L. Yerokhin. A. Matthews, Abrasive wear/corrosion properties and TEM analysis of Al2O3 coatings fabricated using plasma electrolysis. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2002, 149, 245 -- 251. L. Rama Krishna, K.R.C. Somaraju, G. Sundararajan. The tribological performance of ultra-hard ceramic composite coatings obtained through microarc oxidation. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2003, 163 -- 164, 484 -- 490. A.L. Yerokhin, A. Leyland, A. Matthews. Kinetic aspects of aluminiumtitanate layer formation on titanium alloys by plasma electrolytic oxidation. Appl. Surf. Sci.2002, 200, 172 - 184. A.L. Yerokhin, A. Shatrov, V. Samsonov, P. Shashkov, A. Pilkington, A. Leyland, A. Matthews. Oxide ceramic coatings on aluminium 197 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. alloys produced by a pulsed bipolar plasma electrolytic oxidation process. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2005, 199, 150 -- 157. L. Rama Krishna, A. Sudha Purnima, G. Sundararajan. A comparative study of tribological behavior of microarc oxidation and hard - anodized coatings. Wear 2006, 261, 1095 -- 1101. 8. 7. H.X. Li, V.S. Rudnev, X.H. Zheng, T.P. Yarovaya, R.G. Song. Characterization of Al2O3 ceramic coatings on 6063 aluminum alloy prepared in borate electrolytes by micro-arc oxidation. J. Alloys Compd. 2008, 462, 99 -- 102. A. Kossenko, M. Zinigrad. A universal electrolyte for the plasma electrolytic oxidation of aluminum and magnesium alloys. Mater. Des. 2015, 88, 302-309. A. Sobolev, A. Kossenko, M. Zinigrad, K. Borodianskiy. Comparison of Plasma Electrolytic Oxidation Coatings on Al Alloy Created in Aqueous Solution and Molten Salt Electrolytes. Surf. Coat. Technol. 2018, 344, 590-595. 9. 10. A. Sobolev, A. Kossenko, M. Zinigrad, K. Borodianskiy. An Investigation of Oxide Coating Synthesized on an Aluminum Alloy by Plasma Electrolytic Oxidation in Molten Salt. Applied Sciences. 2017, 7 (9), 889-898. 11. M. Zinigrad, V. Mazurovsky, K. Borodianskiy. Physico-Chemical and Mathematical Modeling of Phase Interaction taking place during Fusion Welding Processes. Materialwissenschaft und Werkstofftechnik (Mater SciEngTechnol). 2005, 36 (10), 489-496. 12. N. Movahedi, A. Habibolahzadeh. Effect of plasma electrolytic oxidation treatment on corrosion behavior of closed-cell Al-A356 alloy foam. Mater. Lett. 2016, 164, 558-561. 13. A. Venugopal, J. Srinath, L. Rama Krishna, P. Ramesh Narayanan, S.C. and nanomechanical behaviors of plasma electrolytic oxidation coated AA7020-T6 aluminum alloy. Mater. Sci. Eng. A2016, 660, 39 -- 46. Venkitakrishnan. Corrosion Sharma, P.V. 198
1801.09772	1	1801	2018-01-26T03:11:51	Obstacle evasion in free-space optical communications utilizing Airy beams	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics" ]	A high speed free-space optical communication system capable of self-bending signal transmission around line-of-sight obstacles is proposed and demonstrated. Airy beams are generated and controlled to achieve different propagating trajectories, and the signal transmission characteristics of these beams around the obstacle are investigated. Our results confirm that, by optimising their ballistic trajectories, Airy beams are able to bypass obstacles with more signal energy and thus improve the communication performance compared with normal Gaussian beams.	physics.app-ph	physics	Obstacle evasion in free‐space optical communications utilizing Airy beams Guoxuan Zhu1,†, Yuanhui Wen1,†, Xiong Wu1,†, Yujie Chen1,, Jie Liu1, and Siyuan Yu1,2 1State Key Laboratory of Optoelectronic Materials and Technologies, School of Electronics and Information Technology, Sun Yat‐sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China 2Photonics Group, Merchant Venturers School of Engineering, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1UB, UK †These authors contributed equally to this work Corresponding author: [email protected] A high speed free‐space optical communication system capable of self‐bending signal transmission around line‐of‐sight obstacles is proposed and demonstrated. Airy beams are generated and controlled to achieve different propagating trajectories, and the signal transmission characteristics of these beams around the obstacle are investigated. Our results confirm that, by optimising their ballistic trajectories, Airy beams are able to bypass obstacles with more signal energy and thus improve the communication performance compared with normal Gaussian beams. Free space light fields propagating along curved trajectories, also known as accelerating beams, have been intensively investigated in recent years since the first demonstration of an Airy beam within the context of optics in 2007 [1]. More and more kinds of accelerating beams are subsequently proposed and generated moving along various trajectories including convex [2] and nonconvex ones [3] in both two‐dimensional and three‐dimensional space [4‐6]. Nonetheless, Airy beams, as the simplest kind of accelerating beams with peculiar properties including not only self‐bending but also self‐healing and non‐diffracting [7,8], are attractive for a variety of potential applications, such as micromanipulation [9,10], filamentation [11], vacuum electron acceleration [12], light bullets [13,14], micromachining [15], plasmonics [16,17], optical routing [18] and imaging [19,20]. In addition, Airy beams as a new type of structured light beams in addition to Gaussian beams, Bessel beams, vortex beams, etc. are also introduced to the field of free‐space optical communication, mainly due to their self‐healing property, which could help the main lobe of these beams resist small obstacles or atmosphere turbulences [21,22]. Transmission of spatial image signal encoded in the Fourier plane has been presented through a 4f telescope system [23]. However, truly high speed free‐space communication based on Airy beams is not yet demonstrated and whether the peculiar ballistic dynamics of Airy beams is beneficial for evading obstacle and thus improving the communication performance still needs to be assessed. In this Letter, we proposed and demonstrated an Airy‐based high speed optical communication system as well as evaluating its communication performance around obstacles. One‐dimensional truncated Airy beams are employed in this case for evading transverse obstacles in both simulation and experiment. A comparison of Airy beams and normal Gaussian beams in terms of their obstacle evading performance has been carried out, which shows that Airy beams with optimized ballistic trajectories can avoid obstacles almost the size of the initial beam waist radius while the normal Gaussian beam is mostly blocked under the same condition. High speed optical communication is further implemented and the communication 1 performance is also evaluated to confirm the improvement afforded by Airy beams over Gaussian beams. Our finding suggests that Airy beams as a new type of structured light beams might be useful in high speed free‐space communication, especially where the beams need to overcome small line‐of‐sight obstacles within the communication link. The established communication system based on Airy beams is shown in Fig. 1. A 28‐Gbaud QPSK signal is modulated onto the 1550nm wavelength light beam by an arbitrary waveform generator (AWG) and amplified by an Er‐doped fiber amplifier (EDFA). This light beam is then collimated to a beam waist radius (denoted as ω0) about 2mm in free space and subsequently modulated by a phase‐only spatial light modulator (SLM1) for Airy beam generation. The one‐dimensional Airy beam can be generated by loading a cubic phase pattern, α∙(x‐x0)3, on the SLM1, where α is the cubic parameter, x is the transverse coordinate and x0 is the transverse shifting parameter. The total insertion loss of this reflective SLM (PLUTO‐2‐TELCO‐013, HOLOEYE) is around 0.6dB including the diffraction and response loss. After performing Fourier transformation with a lens, the Airy beam is generated near the back focal plane of the lens with a focal length of 20cm. Apart from generating Airy beams, the SLM1 is also capable of adjusting the ballistic trajectory of Airy beams so as to get over a preset obstacle with more bypassing energy. Two approaches are employed here, including (a) changing the cubic parameter α and (b) shifting the phase pattern by adjusting x0. Approach (a) can optimize the degree of bending of the Airy beam and approach (b) can optimize the emission angle of the ballistic trajectory. Both approaches can be realized by simply loading patterns on SLM without manually adjusting other optical devices. An opaque thin plate near the focal plane of the lens is used as the obstacle to transversely block the signal beam. The propagation trajectory of the signal beam is monitored by a camera placed on a slider after a 4f imaging system. The focal length of the lenses in this imaging 4f system is 25cm. Since the performance of an optical receiver in capturing optical power is related to their receiving aperture, a pinhole is put right after the receiving lens to mimic a finite receiving aperture in practice. The pinhole has the same aperture as the transmitter (ω0) and has been aligned with a Gaussian beam. The received energy is detected by a power meter. At the same time, the Airy mode is demodulated by the SLM2 and the signals are collected by a collimator and a single‐mode‐fiber pigtail. For directly evaluating the obstacle evasion ability, the PD is put parallel to the SLM2 to avoid the influences caused by SLM2 mode conversion and misalignment issues. The signals then go through a QPSK receiving system and are processed offline. An amplified spontaneous emission source and a variable optical attenuator are applied to act as noise with around 0.1nm bandwidth and ‐40dBm power at 1550nm, while the received signal light power without obstacle is around ‐5dBm. The signal processing results reflect the performance of the entire communication scheme. In order to intuitively illustrate the impacts of the two adjusting parameters of the cubic phase mentioned before on the beam trajectory, the propagation of a series of Airy beams with different combination of the two parameters has been simulated by the beam propagation method (BPM). The optical field of an objective plane at z=z0 can be calculated based on the given initial optical field and the corresponding propagating distance z0. After sweeping the propagating distance z0 and record the field distribution on each objective plane, the two‐dimensional (2D) trajectory profile can be acquired. 2 Figure 2 sub‐pane the foca propagat based on the regio modulate 2(a4) ind about th about th x0 can be side, the (a) presents el respectivel l plane. The ting trajector n paraxial app on between z ed by the sa dicate that th he focal poin e plane x=0. e selected acc signs of α an the 2D sim y, where x is idea of the ries to overco proximation, z=‐10cm and me α and th he trajectorie t. As a resul Considering t cording to the nd x0 should b mulated traje the transver Airy beam ome irregular the simulated z=10cm, Fig. e opposite x s modulated t, the traject these symme e location of be minus as s ctories of th rse direction, communicat r‐shaped obs d trajectories 2(a1) and 2( x0 are symme by the oppo tories modul etric properti the obstacle shown in Fig. he Airy beam z is the beam tion scheme stacles. Since s range is from (a3) indicate etric about th osite α and th lated by the es of Airy be [e.g. when o 2(a6)]. m with α an m propagatio is utilizing t e the beam p m z=‐10cm to that the traje he focal plane he same x0 ar opposite α ams' trajecto obstacle is loc nd x0 shown on direction, a these highly‐ propagation m o z=20cm. Fo ectories of Ai e while Fig. 2 re centrally s and x0 are s ories, the sign cated on the n in each and z=0 is tailorable method is cusing on iry beams 2(a1) and ymmetric ymmetric n of α and lower‐left xperiment set rbitrary wave r; PC: polariza plitter; PH: eous emissio r; OSC: oscillo tup of the co eform genera ation controll pinhole; MR on; VOA: var oscope. Fig. 1. Ex AWG: ar amplifier beam sp spontane oscillator mmunication ator; QPSK: ler; Col.: colli R: mirror; P riable optica n system over quadrature imator; LP: lin M: power m l attenuator; rcomes obsta phase‐shift k near polarize meter; BPF: ; ICR: integr cles with Airy keying; EDFA r; SLM: spatia band‐pass f ated coheren y and Gaussi A: Erbium‐do al light modu filter; ASE: nt receiver; an beams. ped fiber ulator; BS: amplified LO: local 3 ) Simulation results of the α is mm‐3. (b b) Experimen ers α and x0 w while an obst and (b3) x=ω0 0. e ballistic dyn ntal results o tacle on the f namics of Airy of the bypas focal plane bl y beams with ssing power ocks the light different par of the Airy t beam from rameters α a beams with x=‐ω0 to (b1) nd x0, the different ) x=0, (b2) Fig. 2. (a) unit of α paramete x=ω0/2 a As show overcom these tw receiving (normaliz obstacle respectiv the diffra the cubic shown in power w n in Fig. 2(a) e the obstac wo modulatio g aperture lo zed by the in is settled o vely. It should action loss of c phase for A n Fig. 2(b1), t with large α an , adjusting α cle. However, on parameter cated at the ncident powe on the focal d be noted th f SLM1 becau iry beam gen he low receiv nd absolute x and x0 are b restricted by rs should be plane z=20c r) related to plane and hat the maxim use the diffra neration, whic ving power w x0 is caused b beneficial for y the finite a e carefully se cm. The expe the two mod blocks the mum normali action efficie ch changes sh with minus α by the pinhol dispersing th aperture (pinh elected to av erimental res dulation para beam from zed power is ncy of SLM i harply in orde is caused by e. As the obs he beam pow hole) at the r oid dispersin ults of the re meters are s x=‐ω0 to x= around 0.92 s related to t er to overcom the obstacle stacle increas wer to specif receiver, the ng power ou eceived optic shown in Fig. =0, x=ω0/2 a 2. This is main the phase va me a large ob and the low singly blocks t ic area to values of tside this cal power 2(b). The and x=ω0, nly due to ariation of bstacle. As receiving the beam 4 along the plane, it is necessary to apply larger α and x0 to evade the obstacle, and finally the power within the received aperture inevitably gets lower. Fig. 2(b3) indicates that the ultimate obstacle size that Airy beams can get around is close to the original beam waist radius and the receiving aperture. To illustrate the benefit of utilizing the ballistic trajectories of Airy beams for getting around obstacles, we compare the obstacle‐evading ability of the Airy beams with normal Gaussian beams, as shown in Fig. 3. The Gaussian beam is generated simply by replacing the previous cubic phase with a quadratic lens phase so that the beam size is adjustable. It should be noted that the normal Gaussian beam here is symmetric about the beam axis as usual without beam steering. Fig. 3(a) shows three typical trajectories of the original Gaussian beam, deformed Gaussian beam by adjusting the lens phase and deformed Airy beam. Each trajectory is processed and obtained from eleven images of beam patterns recorded by the camera on the slider as shown in Fig. 1, and the beam patterns on the focal plane are presented in Fig. 3(b) particularly. The longitudinal interval length between the adjacent recorded images is 10 mm, so these eleven images exhibit the beam trajectory propagating from z=‐50 mm to z=50 mm. With an obstacle put on the focal plane as indicated by the dashed rectangle, the original Gaussian beam in Fig. 3(a1) is mostly blocked. By adding a lens mask to the original Gaussian beam to adjust its beam size, the deformed Gaussian beam can partially get over the obstacle. While for Airy beams with optimized ballistic trajectories, they can shift most of their energy to the upper side of the propagation region and thus mostly circumvent the obstacle. By altering the position of the obstacles, it is found that the Airy beam can overcome larger obstacle with more bypassing energy than the normal Gaussian beams. The relationship between optimal receiving power and the location of obstacle is shown in Fig. 3(c). The obstacle location is marked by the position of the top end of the obstacle while the lower part of the plane is totally blocked. When the transversely blocked region is less than half the plane, both deformed Gaussian and Airy beam can overcome the obstacle. However, when the blocked region is more than half the plane, the power of deformed common Gaussian beam decreases sharply while the Airy beam can still transmit until the obstacle blocks the whole beam waist. The gain in received power by using the Airy beam compared with the normal Gaussian beam is up to 9 dB. Both Airy and Gaussian beams are examined in a free space communication system with an obstacle put on the focal plane z = 0 and the plane z = 50 mm after the focal plane respectively. The communication performance is evaluated by the error vector magnitude (EVM) between the received signals after DSP and the respective ideal signals [24]. The value of EVM characterizes the dispersion of the signal points on the constellation diagram and a larger value means worse performance. The EVM result is related to the signal to noise ratio (SNR) in principle. Here, we had added ‐40dBm noise to mimic the practical situation and the SNR without obstacle is around ‐35dB. 5 he compariso ) deformed A ship between n beam and (c on between tr Airy beam. ( optimal rece c2) deformed rajectories of b1) to (b3) T eiving power d Airy beam. Fig. 3. Th and (a3) relations Gaussian f (a1) original The correspo and the locat l Gaussian be onding beam tion of the ob eam, (a2) defo m profiles on bstacle top en ormed Gauss the focal p nd with (c1) d sian beam lane. The deformed 6 plane, the ob munications ue to achieve reshold [25]. k size is more acle blocks m n beams. Fo is not on the ne. At the FE m is able to e is further aw bstacle is swe performance e bit‐error‐rat The EVM per e than half o more of the t or each kind e focal plane, C threshold l evade obstac way from the f ept in nine eq qually spaced e are shown i n Fig. 4. The te (BER) of 0 0.0038, which rformances o of Gaussian a For both obs f the plane. transverse pl lane, the Air of beam, the e Airy beams while the Ga aussian beam imit, the Gau ussian beam c cle size of ~ ω ω0. The differ focal plane. In each p the comm EVR valu (FEC) thr the block the obst Gaussian obstacle focal plan Airy beam obstacle d locations ra dashed red h h is the soft nd Airy beam stacle positio y beam achi s can also ov ms are able to can overcom rence in perfo ange from ‐ω horizontal lin decision forw ms have no ob ns (on or aft eves better p ercome large o overcome la e obstacle siz ormance beco ω0 to ω0. The e marks the rward error c bvious differe ter the focal performance er obstacles w arger obstacl ze of ~ ω0/2, omes larger results of reference correction ence until plane), as over the when the es on the while the when the he EVM of t the communi ication system m against lo cation of the e obstacle w ith Gaussian and Airy ork, we have ries to overco ng the Airy b thin plate. B m is close to t proposed an ome obstacle beam traject Both numeric the initial be nd demonstra es in free sp ory are impl al and exper am waist rad ated a schem pace optical lemented to rimental com ius and much me of utilizing communicat evade the p mparisons sho h larger than Airy beams w tion systems. preset obstac ow the obsta normal Gaus with tailorabl . Two appro cle represent acle‐evading ssian beams. le ballistic aches for ted by an ability of . National N 31); National ogy Program ties of China Natural Scien Basic Resea of Guangzho (SYSU: 17lgzd nce Foundat arch Program ou (2018‐100 d06). tion of Chin m of China 02‐SF‐0094); na (NSFC) (1 (973 Progra Fundamenta 11774437, U m) (2014CB3 al Research F U1701661, 6 340000) Scie Funds for th 61490715, ence and e Central Fig. 4. T beams. In this wo trajector optimizin opaque t Airy beam Funding. 1169003 Technolo Universit 7 References 1. Siviloglou, G. A., Broky, J., Dogariu, A., & Christodoulides, D. N., "Observation of accelerating Airy beams," Phys. Rev. Letters 99, 213901 (2007). 2. E. Greenfield, M. Segev, W. Walasik, and O. Raz, "Accelerating light beams along arbitrary convex trajectories", Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 213902 (2011). 3. Y. Wen, Y. Chen, Y. Zhang, H. Chen, and S. Yu, "Winding light beams along elliptical helical trajectories," Phys. Rev. A 94, 013829 (2016). 4. L. Froehly, F. Courvoisier, A. Mathis,M. Jacquot, L. Furfaro, R. Giust, P. A. Lacourt, and J. M. Dudley, "Arbitrary accelerating micron‐scale caustic beams in two and three dimensions", Opt. Express 19, 16455 (2011). 5. Y. Wen, Y. Chen, Y. Zhang, H. Chen, and S. Yu, "Tailoring accelerating beams in phase space," Phys. Rev. A 95, 023825 (2017). 6. Y. Wen, Y. Chen, Y. Zhang, and S. Yu, "A highly adjustable helical beam: design and propagation characteristic," Chin. Opt. Lett. 15, 030011 (2017). 7. J. Broky, G. A. Siviloglou, A. Dogariu, and D. N. Christodoulides, "Self‐healing properties of optical Airy beams," Opt. Express 16, 12880 (2008). 8. X. Chu, G. Zhou, and R. Chen, "Analytical study of the self‐healing property of Airy beams," Phys. Rev. A, 85, 013815 (2012). 9. J. Baumgartl, M. Mazilu, and K. Dholakia, "Optically mediated particle clearing using Airy wavepackets," Nat. Photon. 2, 675 (2008). 10. J. Zhao, I. D. Chremmos, D. Song, D. N. Christodoulides, N. K. Efremidis, and Z. Chen, "Curved singular beams for three‐dimensional particle manipulation," Sci. Rep. 5, 12086 (2015). 11. P. Polynkin, M. Kolesik, J. V. Moloney, G. A. Siviloglou, and D. N. Christodoulides, "Curved plasma channel generation using ultraintense Airy beams," Science 324, 229 (2009). 12. J. Li, W. Zang, and J. Tian, "Vacuum laser‐driven acceleration by Airy beams," Opt. Express 18, 7300 (2010). 13. A. Chong, W. H. Renninger, D. N. Christodoulides, and F. W. Wise, "Airy–Bessel wave packets as versatile linear light bullets," Nat. Photon. 4, 103 (2010). 14. D. Abdollahpour, S. Suntsov, D. G. Papazoglou, and S. Tzortzakis, "Spatiotemporal Airy light bullets in the linear and nonlinear regimes," Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 253901 (2010). 15. A. Mathis, F. Courvoisier, L. Froehly, L. Furfaro, M. Jacquot, P. A. Lacourt, J. M. Dudley, "Micromachining along a curve: Femtosecond laser micromachining of curved profiles in diamond and silicon using accelerating beams," Appl. Phys. Lett. 101, 071110 (2012). 16. L. Li, T. Li, S. M. Wang, C. Zhang, and S. N. Zhu, "Plasmonic Airy beam generated by in‐plane diffraction," Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 126804 (2011). 17. J. Lin, J. Dellinger, P. Genevet, B. Cluzel, F. de Fornel, and F. Capasso, "Cosine‐Gaussian plasmon beam: a localized long‐range nondiffracting surface wave," Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 093904 (2012). 18. P. Rose, F. Diebel, M. Boguslawski, and C. Denz, "Airy beam induced optical routing," Appl. Phys. Lett. 102, 101101 (2013). 19. S. Jia, J. C. Vaughan, and X. Zhuang, "Isotropic three‐dimensional super‐resolution imaging with a self‐bending point spread function," Nat. Photon. 8, 302 (2014). 20. T. Vettenburg, H. I. C. Dalgarno, J. Nylk, C. Coll‐Lladó, D. E. K. Ferrier, T. Čiž már, F. J. Gunn‐Moore, and K. Dholakia, "Light‐sheet microscopy using an Airy beam," Nat. Method 11, 541 (2014). 21. Y. Gu, and G. Gbur, "Scintillation of Airy beam arrays in atmospheric turbulence," Opt. Letters 35, 3456 (2010). 22. X. Ji, H. T. Eyyuboğlu, G. Ji, and X. Jia, "Propagation of an Airy beam through the atmosphere," Opt. Express 21, 2154 (2013). 23. Y. Liang, Y. Hu, D. Song, C. Lou, X. Zhang, Z. Chen, and J. Xu, "Image signal transmission with Airy beams," Opt. Lett. 40, 5686 (2015). 24. A. Georgiadis, "Gain, phase imbalance, and phase noise effects on error vector magnitude," IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, 53, 443 (2004). 25. A. Tanaka, N. Cvijetic, and T. Wang, "First optical Nyquist filtering of 10 G OOK for OFDMA λ‐overlays on 40km and 1: 128 split PON," In OptoElectronics and Communications Conference held jointly with 2013 International Conference on Photonics in Switching (OECC/PS), 2013 18th (pp. 1‐2), IEEE, (2013). 8
1902.07534	1	1902	2019-02-20T12:31:41	Active beam steering and afocal zooming by nematic liquid crystal infiltrated graded index photonic structures	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.optics" ]	This study presents active beam steering and afocal zooming of light by incorporating liquid crystals (LCs) with graded index photonic crystal (GRIN PC). The GRIN PC structures are composed of low refractive index polymer annular rods having gradually varied radii of holes. To actively manipulate incident light, the annular rods are infiltrated with nematic LCs. By applying an external voltage to the infiltrated LCs, the effective index profile of the low-index GRIN PC structure is modulated without introducing any mechanical movement. The incident beam deflection and corresponding focal distance modulation are tuned only by controlling the applied bias voltage. In the present work, hyperbolic secant refractive index profile is chosen to design GRIN PC structures. To design GRIN PC structure with annular PCs, Maxwell-Garnett effective medium approximation is employed. Moreover, we analytically express the relation between infiltrated LCs and gradient parameter to show the physical background of the tuning ability of the proposed devices. Also, beam steering and afocal zooming devices are analytically investigated via geometrical optics and numerically realized with the help of the finite-difference time-domain method. A beam deflection with an angle change of {\Delta}{\theta}out= 44{\deg} and a light magnification with maximum x2.15 are obtained. LCs are inexpensive materials and work under low voltage/power condition. This feature can be used for designing an electro-optic GRIN PC device that can be useful in various optical applications.	physics.app-ph	physics	Active beam steering and afocal zooming by nematic liquid crystal infiltrated graded index photonic structures Ceren Babayigit1,, Hamza Kurt1 and Mirbek Turduev2 1Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, TOBB University of Economics and Technology, Ankara 2Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, TED University, Ankara 06420, Turkey. e-mail: [email protected] 06560, Turkey. Abstract -- This study presents active beam steering and afocal zooming of light by incorporating liquid crystals (LCs) with graded index photonic crystal (GRIN PC). The GRIN PC structures are composed of low refractive index polymer annular rods having gradually varied radii of holes. To actively manipulate incident light, the annular rods are infiltrated with nematic LCs. By applying an external voltage to the infiltrated LCs, the effective index profile of the low-index GRIN PC structure is modulated without introducing any mechanical movement. The incident beam deflection and corresponding focal distance modulation are tuned only by controlling the applied bias voltage. In the present work, hyperbolic secant refractive index profile is chosen to design GRIN PC structures. To design GRIN PC structure with annular PCs, Maxwell-Garnett effective medium approximation is employed. Moreover, we analytically express the relation between infiltrated LCs and gradient parameter to show the physical background of the tuning ability of the proposed devices. Also, beam steering and afocal zooming devices are analytically investigated via geometrical optics and numerically realized with the help of the finite-difference time-domain method. A beam deflection with an angle change of Δθout= 44° and a light magnification with maximum x2.15 are obtained. LCs are inexpensive materials and work under low voltage/power condition. This feature can be used for designing an electro -- optic GRIN PC device that can be useful in various optical applications. 1. Introduction Recent developments in the area of photonic crystals (PCs) have revealed the ability of controlling, manipulating, transmitting and detecting the light by paving the way for the broad range of PC applications, such as waveguides [1], optical switches [2], filters [3], defect-mode micro cavities [4], self-collimation [5] and routing [6] to name a few. On the other hand, although many PC devices have been developed with enhanced and additional optical characteristics, most of them perform only certain functionalities that are predicted by their photonic band gaps or dispersion characteristic within the allowed bands. It means that once they were fabricated, the optical properties of such structures cannot be tuned easily, i.e., these structures can be considered as passive photonic devices. In this regard, not only to enhance the functionality, efficiency, flexibility and compactness but also to reduce the cost of optoelectronic devices; attaining the ability to dynamic control of the optical properties by external parameters 1 becomes crucial. In the last decade, there have been several efforts to achieve optical tunability by using various means such as microfluidics [7], ferroelectric materials [8], graphene [9], dielectric elastomers [10], liquid crystals (LCs) [11], thermal control [12] and mechanical control [13]. Among these techniques, LCs can be considered as a good candidate for optical tunability owing to their low power consumption/dissipation, fabrication cost efficiency and structural compactness [14]. For instance, LCs have been used to tune the band gaps [15]-[18], negative refraction effect [19] in PCs and to design tunable optical waveguides [20, 21]. Moreover, the utilizing of LCs in the designs of diffractive lens, switchable grating, and beam deflector have been proposed in Refs. 22-24. Light focusing and guiding elements occupy an important role in photonic applications. In order to implement the focusing effect, various notable approaches based on negative refraction [25], Fabry -- Perot resonances [26], super-lenses [27], aperiodic metallic waveguide arrays [28], metamaterials [29], photonic nano-jets [30] have been proposed. On the other hand, the light guiding is achieved by using photonic-bandgap systems [31], slot-waveguides [32], plasmonic waveguides [33], coupled resonators [34] and dispersion-based optical routing [35,36] methods. Apart from these techniques, manipulation of light propagation behavior is further enhanced by introducing the concept of gradient-index (GRIN) materials. This powerful tool has been contributed to numerous nano-photonic and optical applications including optical mode coupling [37], focusing [38], light bending [39], wavelength de-multiplexing [40] and mode order converting [41]. Nevertheless, despite the significant progress that has been made in these studies, nearly all of the designed light focusing and light guiding structures operates without tunability characteristic. In other words, the optical properties of these structures are fixed and active control is not possible. In this study, the computational results are obtained for beam steering and afocal zooming applications. GRIN PC structures are composed by aligned polymer annular rods on air medium and filling them with nematic liquid crystals (LCs). By incorporating LC materials with the GRIN media, the active beam steering and afocal zooming of the incident light are achieved. First, the ray transfer analysis of proposed structures is analytically derived via geometrical optics. Then, the simulations are performed with the 2D finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) method with appropriate boundary conditions. Good agreement between the analytical and numerical methods is observed. 2. The problem definition and nematic LCs as a tool for active controlling Photonic interconnectors are used for efficient light transmission between different optical elements. Here, the main challenging issue is the misalignment between input and output light guiding components. If one considers fiber-optic communication system, misalignment between transmitting and receiving components leads to increase of transmission losses that decrease the maximum data rate relatively. In this case, mechanical alignment of the elements can be quite complicated and inconvenient for durability of the system. For this reason, controlling of the alignment without any displacement of elements by mechanical intervention is crucial. In this 2 case, by using beam steering mechanism this problem can be solved and via this approach, photonic interconnectors can be integrated easily to a system [42]. Optical beam steering is also plays an important role in light detection [43], laser micromachining [44], and microscopically imaging [45-47] applications. Another active light controlling concept that studied in this work is afocal zooming. The afocal zooming is the important optical effect for microscopy and imaging systems [48]. Optical lens system can focus, diverge and collimate the incoming light. Here, for focusing and diverging behaviour of light, imaging properties of the lens system can be modelled via the focal length characteristic. On the other hand, if the focal length of collimated light is infinite, then paraxial characteristic of the lens system cannot be modelled. Such systems are referred as afocal lens systems [49]. Afocal lens systems are mostly used in optical zooming applications. Optical zooming can be obtained by using mechanically compensated or optically compensated zoom lenses that are used for beam expansion and compression purposes [50]. Here, optically compensated lens systems depend on the single motion of a lens or lens system while mechanical compensated zoom lenses operate with multiple motions in multiple directions. Both zooming approaches require complicated and simultaneous adjustment of multiple lens pairs. For this reason, employing these systems in micro/nano photonic applications can be considered as a challenging task. Nevertheless, in order to solve this issue, the monolithic system with a cascaded construction is proposed [51]. However, for different magnification cases, distinct monolithic systems are required, which makes this approach unfeasible. Fig. 1. (a) Corresponding refractive index alteration with respect to θLC and the relationship between the rotation angle and applied voltage VRMS. (b) Schematic views of the 2D LC-infiltrated annular PC structure and (c) its envisioned voltage excitation mechanism (3D cross-sectional side view). In this study, we propose beam steering and afocal zooming concepts using nematic LCs infiltrated PC structures. Here, active controlling of the beam deflection and spot size tuning is achieved by applying external voltages. Nematic LCs are birefringent materials which provides different refractive indices along different optical axes [52, 53]. When the ray of light is incident upon a birefringent medium, it splits into two mutually perpendicular components which are called the ordinary rays (o-rays) and extraordinary rays (e-rays). The o-ray always lies perpendicular to the optical axis while e-ray lies in a plane of the optical axis [53]. This phenomenon brings out ordinary (no) and extraordinary (ne) refractive indices for nematic LCs. 3 Hence, orientation of the nematic LCs can be tuned by applying external voltage and consequently the effective refractive index of the nematic LCs can be altered [54]. For the transverse magnetic (TM) polarized light where the concerned non-zero electric and magnetic field components are Ez, Hx, and Hy, respectively, the effective permittivity of nematic LCs can be expressed as [55]: (1) where θLC is the rotation angle of nematic LCs (the nematic LC molecules' orientation along xz- plane is given as an inset in Fig. 1(a)). Since the rotation angle θLC defines the variation of effective refractive index of nematic LCs, it can be expressed as a function of applied external voltage as follows: (2) Here, the nematic LC molecules can be oriented by an electric field (or a magnetic field) when the field strength exceeds the Freedericksz transition threshold [56]. In Eq. 2, Vc is the critical voltage at which the tilting angle starts to change and V0 is a constant value. Also, the term (V- Vc/V0) can be defined as root-mean-square (RMS) voltage, VRMS. As a result, corresponding relationships of nematic LCs' the rotation angle with respect to refractive index alteration and VRMS are represented in Fig. 1(a). In Fig. 1(b) the schematic representation of square lattice PC structure infiltrated by nematic LCs is presented. In order to excite nematic LCs by an external voltage a pair of indium tin oxide (ITO) conducting glass substrates are generally used in the way that given in Fig. 1(c). As it is seen in Fig. 1(c), in addition to ITO layers, the "alignment layers" are also used to provide the specific initial angle of nematic LCs' orientation. This initial angle is crucial to obtain a defect-free alignment and to improve the performance of nematic LCs (response time and viewing angle). Another important parameter that influences the performance of the nematic LCs is the temperature. According to Clausius-Mossotti and Lorentz-Lorenz equations the temperature dependency of the nematic LCs' birefringence is expressed as follows [57]: (3) where, T is the operating temperature, Tc is the clearing temperature of the nematic LC material, β is an exponent and ∆n0 stands for the nematic LCs temperature dependent birefringence at T=0 K. Since high birefringence is needed to obtain broad range tunability, throughout this manuscript operating temperature is assumed equal to room temperature. It is important to note that in the case of temperature increase, depending upon the birefringence change, the tuning value will decrease. 4 2222222cos()sin()eoLCLCeLCoLCnnnnn==+100 VV2tanexp, V > V2CLCCCVVV−=−−−01,CTnnT=−3. Active beam steering and afocal zooming design approach As it is well known, the light within the GRIN medium follows curved trajectories because of gradual change in refractive index. Hence, for optical phenomena such as focusing, diverging and collimating the GRIN medium can be used without introducing the curved front and back interfaces for the optical components. In this regard, the main concept of the study lies on merging GRIN optics with nematic LCs to achieve active control of propagation of light. Here, the gradient of the refractive index distribution of GRIN medium can be actively changed to obtain the desired steering and zooming effects. In order to form GRIN medium, two-dimensional (2D) annular PCs are employed. The substantial design parameters for the annular PCs are the radii of the dielectric rods (rrod) and the holes (rhole) that drilled into the dielectric rods. By gradually changing air holes' radii one can change dielectric filling ratio of the elementary PC cell, so that GRIN PC medium with desired refractive index profile can be obtained. In this study, hyperbolic secant (HS) refractive index profile is chosen to design GRIN PC lens. HS refractive index distribution is mathematically expressed as follows: (4) where n0 is the refractive index value at the optical axis and α is the gradient parameter that represents the depth of the index distribution. The shape of the HS function closely resembles parabola and by tuning gradient parameter α one can control the sign of the parabola [58]. Here, α parameter can take real and complex values that result in negative (opens downward) and positive (opens upward) parabolas, respectively. Fig. 2. (a) Schematic of 2D annular GRIN PC structure with varying gradually changing air holes' radii and its corresponding refractive index profile. (b) Schematic of 2D GRIN LC-infiltrated annular PC structures and its corresponding refractive index profile. 5 ()()0sec,nynhy=In order to design GRIN PC structure with annular PCs, Maxwell-Garnett EM approximation is employed. Here, EM approximation determines the radii of the air holes according to the defined HS refractive index profile. The formulation of the effective permittivity for the transverse magnetic (TM) polarized wave is expressed as follows: where (5) is the filling dielectric filling ratio of annular PC rods. Also, εrod and εair are correspond to the permittivity of annular PC rod and air medium. Then, after some algebra, the variation formula of air holes' radii rhole for TM polarization can be expressed as follows: (6) where "a" is the lattice constant and neff (y) stands for HS refractive index function. It should be noted that the gradual variation of the air holes is achieved only along the transverse y-direction and the positions of the annular PCs cell are kept constant as unit distance a along the y- and x- directions. Herewith, by using Eqs. 5 and 6, one can design the square lattice GRIN PC structure for the desired refractive index distribution. For the design of GRIN PC structure, annular rods are assumed to be made of polymer with refractive index of np=1.80 [59] and the outer radii are fixed to rrod=0.48a. The detailed schematic of the designed annular GRIN PC and its effective index profile are depicted in Fig. 2(a). Here, the gradient parameter is calculated as α=0.0887a-1. In order to design the tunable GRIN PC structure, the air holes of annular PCs are assumed to be infiltrated by nematic LC molecules with no=1.59 and ne=2.22. Here, refractive indices correspond to phenylacetylene type LC material [60]. Infiltration by nematic LC leads to change in effective refractive index distribution of the annular GRIN PC structure according to the following formula: (7) where εLC is the permittivity of the nematic LCs, and are the filling factors of the holes area that drilled into the dielectric rods and annular PC rods, respectively. The schematic representation of the LC infiltrated structure with its corresponding refractive index profile is given in Fig. 2(b). In this case, the gradient parameter α is recalculated as 0.0477a-1. As can be seen from the index profiles in Figs. 2(a) and 2(b), one can observe that infiltration of LCs to the annular GRIN PC structure affects gradient parameter. In order to analytically express the relation between infiltrated LC and α parameter, the following formula can be obtained by incorporating Eqs. 4 and 7: 6 ()()1,effrodairff=+−()222rodholefrra=−()()222()(),aireffholerodrodairnyaryr−=+−()()()221121,effeffrodLCairnffffffff==−++−221holeffra=222rodffra= (8) In Eq. 8 all parameters except εLC are defined by constant values so that α depends on only εLC which varies with the rotation angle of nematic LCs, θLC. The refractive index profile variation of annular GRIN PC with respect to the rotation angle θLC of the infiltrated nematic LCs is presented in the Fig. 3(a). Here, one can see the transition between positive and negative paraboloid index profiles. This transition is related to the values of α parameter, which takes real and imaginary values (this can be proved also by the Eq. 8). As can be seen in Fig. 3(b), for the variation in θLC from 0° (εLC=1.59) to 43° (εLC=1.80), the gradient parameter gets real values and it decays to the zero with the increase of the rotation angle. On the other hand, α takes imaginary values for the rotation angles θLC greater than 43° as shown in Fig. 3(c). Here, the important point is that for θLC = 43° the refractive index profile close to the straight line (constant along y- axis) and the α parameter approximately equals to zero. Fig. 3. (a) The effective refractive index change through the y-axis with respect to the LCs' rotation angle. Change of the gradient parameter α depending on the rotation angle in the range of (b) θLC=[0°,43°] and (c) θLC=[43°, 90°]. In light of given gradient parameter tuning concept, we propose beam steering and afocal zooming applications with nematic LCs infiltrated annular GRIN PC structures. In Fig. 4(a), a perspective view of the proposed beam steering device is presented. As can be seen in Fig. 4(a), we show operating principle of the beam steering device schematically where applied the external voltage tunes the directivity of the incident beam. Indeed, applied voltage changes gradient parameter α by the help of the nematic LCs and consequently paraboloid refractive index profile changes its sign as shown in Fig. 4(b). For the afocal zooming application, the device that designed for beam steering is mirror symmetrized with respect to propagation x- direction. This mirror-symmetry reveals the converging lens characteristics of the design. The proposed afocal-zoom design is represented in Fig. 4(c) where one can see that the device consist of three regions. As can be seen in Fig. 4(c), only the middle section of PC structure is infiltrated with LCs and left as well as right sections are made of non-infiltrated annular GRIN PC structures. Here, the side annular GRIN PCs operate as converging lenses and middle section infiltrated with LCs (shaded in yellow in Fig. 4(c)) serves as the lens with tunable focal point 7 ()()221220()11sec.holerodLCrodrodairairryrhynaa−=−+−+(applied external voltage manipulates focusing characteristic). The principle of beam diameter manipulation can be deduced from variation of effective refractive index profile in Fig. 4(d). Here, when the LCs' orientation is in the range of 0°≤ θLC<43°, the middle section operates as a converging lens. On the other hand, when the LCs' orientation varies as 43°<θLC≤90°, the middle section operates as a diverging lens. Consequently, adaptation of the beam diameter to the particular task can be achieved without introducing any mechanical motion of lens such as in Ref. [50]. Fig. 4. Perspective view of 2D GRIN LC-infiltrated annular PC structures for (a) beam steering application with the size of dx=11.96a and dy=9.96a and (c) afocal lens structure with the sizes of dx=32.96a and dy=20.96a. (b) and (d) show the effective index change through the y-axis with respect to the rotation angle for each configuration. 4. Analytical and numerical results In this section, the operating principle of the proposed beam steering and afocal zooming devices is analytically investigated via ray theory. For this reason, the GRIN media having effective refractive index profiles same as in Figs. 4(c) and 4(d) are examined for beam steering and afocal zooming applications, respectively. After, the time-domain analyses of the proposed structures are provided in detail. Conceptual modelling of light propagation through a non-homogeneous medium can be explained by the ray equation also known as Eikonal equation: (9) where n is the refractive index of medium, is the gradient of the n, is ray path and is the arc length along the ray path. By solving the ray equation for given refractive index distribution, ray trajectories can be obtained. In this regard, the ray trajectory function in a continuous HS GRIN medium with refractive index profile given in Eq. 4 is expressed as follows (see Ref. 58 for detailed derivation of the ray trajectory): 8 (),ddrsnndsds=n()[(),()]rsxsys=22dsdxdy=+ (10) where y(x) is the ray trajectory function with respect to initial position u0 and incident angle . Here, for the gradient parameter α, the data calculated in Figs. 3(b) and 3(c) are used. It should also be noted that the Eq. 10 is derived in hyperbolic coordinate system by using transformation. By taking the position derivative of Eq. 10, the slope information of the ray can be expressed as follows: (11) By using Eqs. 10 and 11 the ray trajectories through the HS GRIN medium are calculated and the corresponding ray propagations for beam steering application are plotted in Fig. 5. In order to visualize beam steering effect, in Figs. 5(a), 5(b), and 5(c) we depicted three distinct ray to α=0.0477a-1, α=i0.0098a-1, and deflection cases where gradient parameter equals α=i0.0691a-1, respectively. Here, gradient parameters are taken from the data in Figs. 3(b) and 3(c). Here, if α is set to be 0.0477a-1≥ α > 0.036a-1 (0°≤ θLC <42°), the incident beam steers downward (see Fig. 5(a)) and for the interval 0.0144ia-1≤ α ≤ 0.0691ia-1 (44°< θLC ≤ 90°) the incident beam steers upwards (see Fig. 5(c)) by the HS GRIN medium. On the other hand, when the gradient parameter α is set to 0.0098ia-1 (θLC=43°), the overall medium becomes uniform and thus, incident rays exit the medium without any deflection as shown in Fig. 5(b). The ray deflection angle θout variation at the back-surface of the GRIN media with respect to α gradient parameter (LCs rotation angel θLC) is shown in Fig. 5(d). Fig. 5. Expected beam bending based on ray theory in the cases of (a) α=0.0477a-1 (b) α=i0.0098a-1 and (c) α=i0.0691a-1. (d) Beam deflection angle profile in compliance with the rotation angle of the LC molecules. Field intensities for a/λ=0.15 in the cases of (e) θLC = 0°, (f) θLC = 43°and (g) θLC = 90°. (h) Analytical beam deflection angle profile with respect to the rotation angle of the LC molecules for a/λ=0.100, a/λ=0.125 and a/λ=0.150. 9 1001sin()()sinhcos(),xyxuux−=+0usinh()uy=()00100sin()cos()().coshsinhcos()(sin()/)uxuxyxuxux−−+=+Table I. Beam steering angle variation with respect to LCs rotation angle θLC. θLC θout at a/λ=0.100 θout at a/λ=0.125 θout at a/λ=0.150 0° 43° 90° -10° 0° 34° -12° 0° 21° -14° 0° 30° After the conceptual explanation of the beam steering application via ray theory, numerical analyses of the proposed LCs infiltrated annular GRIN PC structure are conducted by employing FDTD method. The beam steering structure shown in Fig. 4(a) is exited with TM polarized continuous wave source having a Gaussian profile. Figures 5(e)-5(g) represent the steady state intensity profiles for cases of θLC = {0°, 43°, 90°} under incident light wave operating at normalized frequency of a/λ=0.150. Beam deflection characteristics of the proposed structure can be clearly observed from the figure plots. Also, ray theory observations in Figs. 5(a)-5(c) are verified by the FDTD results (see Figs. 5(e)-5(g)). In order to analyse operating frequency bandwidth of the beam steering PC structure, its steering ability is examined under excitation of light waves with normalized frequencies of a/λ=0.100, a/λ=0.125 and a/λ=0.150 (corresponding to the first TM band). As a result, beam deflection angle variation with respect to LCs rotation angle is presented in Fig. 5(h). The beam deflection results are summarized in Table I where the variation of the steering angle under the effect of the LC orientation angle is presented. As seen from Table I, for the normalized frequencies of a/λ= {0.100, 0.125, 0.150}, the total deflection angle obtained as Δθout={44º, 43º, 44º} under the rotation angle variation from 0° to 90°. Fig. 6. Expected beam diameter tuning based on ray theory in the cases of (a) α=0.0477a-1 (b) α=i0.0098a-1 and (c) α=i0.0691a-1. (d) Corresponding beam diameter variation of output beams with respect to θLC. Field intensities for a/λ=0.20 in the cases of (e) θLC = 0°, (f) θLC = 43°and (g) θLC = 90°. (h) Analytical beam diameter variation of output beams with respect to θLC for a/λ=0.15, a/λ=0.20 and a/λ=0.25. Same procedure is also followed for the proposed afocal zooming application. Similarly, in order to explain the behaviour of light rays within the stacked GRIN media, the ray trajectories are calculated and schematically represented in Figs. 6(a)-6(c). In Fig. 6(a), the exiting positions of propagating rays are accumulated near-by optical axis for the gradient parameter of 10 α=0.0477a-1. It means that if one considers a light beam instead of rays, the output beam diameter considered to be squeezed down. On the other hand, if α changes from α=i0.0098a-1 (see Fig. 6(b)) to α=i0.0691a-1 (see Fig. 6(c)), the locations of exiting rays become distant from each other, i.e., beam diameter expansion characteristics shows up. In order to give an insight to a-focal zooming effect, Fig. 6(d) is prepared. In Fig. 6(d), the dr distance between upper and lower exiting rays positions with respect to α gradient parameter is represented. Table II. Beam diemeter variation with respect to LCs rotation angle θLC. θLC Dout at a/λ=0.15 Dout at a/λ=0.20 Dout at a/λ=0.25 0° 90° 1.37λ 1.64λ 1.85λ (Din x 0.73 ) (Din x 0.87 ) (Din x 0.98 ) 2.79λ 3.54λ 4.04λ (Din x1.49 ) (Din x 1.88 ) (Din x 2.15 ) Thereafter, under same simulation conditions given for beam steering device, the numerical analyses of the afocal annular GRIN PC structure is examined via FDTD. Steady state field intensities of the designed zoom lens are determined for θLC= {0°, 43°, 90°} and the results are shown in Figs. 6(e), 6(f), and 6(g), respectively. As expected, same characteristics which are obtained by the ray theory are corroborated with the numerical results. For the normalized frequencies of a/λ=0.15, a/λ=0.20 and a/λ=0.25, the beam diameter manipulation capacity of the proposed structure is examined in Fig. 6(h). Here, beam diameter calculations are conducted by extracting cross-sectional profiles of the exiting beam at the output of the structure and measuring beam width between the two points where the intensity is 1/e2= 0.135 times of the peak value. As a result, beam diameter varies for a/λ=0.15 from 1.37λ to 2.79λ, for a/λ=0.20 from 1.64λ to 3.54λ and for a/λ=0.25 from 1.85λ to 4.04λ in the interval of θLC= {0°, 90°}, respectively. The beam diameter tuning results are collected and presented in Table II. Here, the output and input beam diameters are defined as Dout and Din, respectively. 5. Conclusion In this study, we presented compact structures for tunable beam steering and afocal beam zooming applications by combining LCs and annular PCs. Since there is no moving mechanical part, the proposed structures are more compact and practical when they are compared with their conventional counterparts. The presented calculations show that for different frequency ranges, proposed beam steering and afocal zooming mechanisms supply broad tuning capability. For beam steering application, the deflection angle can be tuned linearly in the range of -12° to 30° by tuning the rotation angle of LCs under the normalized frequency a/λ=0.15. Similarly, adapting the beam diameter of the output beam from 1.64λ to 3.54λ is possible with the proposed afocal zooming structure under the normalized frequency a/λ=0.20. These beam diameters corresponds to x0.87 minimization and x1.88 magnification of the incidence ligth at a/λ=0.20. As a result, we investigated both analytically and numerically the beam steering and afocal zooming concepts. The designed LCs infiltrated PC structures can be implemented to various optical applications 11 such as near-field scanning, vision correction, object tracking, optical communication, medical diagnostic, x-ray optics, space and atmospheric research, holography and imaging systems. References [1] Debnath K, Bucio T D, Al-Attili A, Khokhar A Z, Saito S and Gardes F Y 2017 Opt. Express 25 3214-3221. [2] Beggs D M, White T P, O'Faolain L and Krauss T F 2008 Opt. Lett. 33 147-149. [3] Mirjalili S M, Mirjalili S Z 2017 Neural Computing Appl. 28 1 -- 7. [4] Zhou W D, Sabarinathan J, Bhattacharya P, Kochman B, Berg E, Yu P C and Pang S 2001 IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 37 1153 -- 1160. [5] Kosaka H and Kawashima T 1999 Appl. Phys. Lett, 74 1212-1214. [6] Prather D W, Shi S Y, Pustai D M, Chen C H, Venkataraman S, Sharkawy A, Schneider G J and Murakowski J 2004 Opt. Lett. 29 50-52. [7] Domachuk P, Nguyen H C, Eggleton B J, Straub M and Gu M 2004 Appl. Phys. Lett. 84 1838 [8] Tagantsev A K, Sherman V O, Astafiev K F, Venkatesh J and Setter N 2003 J. Electroceramics 11 5 -- 66. [9] Yan H, Li X, Chandra B, Tulevski G, Wu Y, Freitag M, Zhu W, Avouris P and Xia F 2012 Nature Nanotechnology 7 330. [10] Wen H, Chang I L, Chen L W 2012 Opt. Commun. 24 5524-5530. [11] Rezaei B, Giden I H and Kurt H 2017 Opt. Commun. 382 28-35. [12] Cunningham J E et al. 2010 Opt. Express 18 19055. [13] Park W and Lee J 2004 Appl. Phys. Lett. 85 4845. [14] Gourlay J, Love G D, Birch P M, Sharples R M and Purvis A 1997 Opt. Commun. 137 17 -- 21. [15] Busch K, John S 1999 Phys. Rev. Lett, 83 967-970. [16] Alagappan G, Sun X W, Shum P, Yu M B and Doan M T 2006 J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 23 159-167. [17] Liu C Y, Chen L W 2005 Phys. Rev. B 72 045133. [18] Khalkhali T F, Rezaei B and Ramezani A H 2012 Opt. Commun, 285 5254-5258. [19] Wang Y Yu, Chen L W 2006 Opt. Express 14 10580-10587. [20] Zografopoulos D C, Asquini R, Kriezis E E, d'Alessandro A and Beccherelli R 2012 Lab. Chip 12 3598-3610. [21] Kurt H, Citrin D S 2008 Opt. Express 16 11995-12001. [22] Li G et al. 2006 PNAS USA 103 6100 -- 6104. [23] Shang X, Trinidad A M, Joshi P, Smet J D, Cuypers D and Smet H D 2016 IEEE Photonics J. 8 1. [24] Liu Y J, Zheng Y B, Shi J, Huang H, Walker T R and Huang T J 2009 Opt. Lett. 34 2351-2353. [25] Matsumoto T, Eom Kun-Sun and Baba T 2006 Opt. Lett. 31 2786-2788. [26] Li X, He S and Jin Y 2007 Phys. Rev. 75 045103. [27] Cubukcu E, Aydin K, Ozbay E, Foteinopoulou S and Soukouli C M 2003 Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 207401. [28] Verslegers L, Catrysse P B, Yu Z and Fan S 2009 Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 033902. [29] Ren G, Lai Z, Wang C, Feng Q, Liu L, Liu K, and Luo X 2010 Opt. Express 18 18151-18157. [30] Mahariq I, Kuzuoglu M, Tarman I H and Kurt H 2014 IEEE Photon. J. 6 1-14. [31] Joannopoulos J D, Villeneuve P R and Fan S H 1997 Nature 386 143 -- 149. [32] Almeida VR, Xu Q, Barrios C A and Lipson M 2004 Opt. Lett. 29 1209 -- 1211. [33] Weeber J C, Lacroute Y and Dereux A 2003 Phys. Rev. B 68 115401. [34] Yariv A, Xu Y, Lee R K and Scherer A 1999 Opt. Lett. 24 711 -- 713. [35] Prather D W, Shi S, Pustai D M, Chen C, Venkataraman S, Sharkawy A, Schneider G J and Murakowski J 2004 Opt. Lett. 29 50-52. [36] Kurt H, Turduev M and Giden I H 2012 Opt. Express 20 7184-7194. [37] Kurt H, Oner B B, Turduev M and Giden I H 2012 Opt. Express 20 22018-22033. [38] Gaufillet F and Akmansoy E 2012 Opt. Commun, 285 2638-2641. [39] Oner B B, Turduev M and Kurt H 2013 Opt. Lett. 38 1688-1690. [40] Yilmaz D, Giden I H, Turduev M and Kurt H 2013, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 49 477-484. [41] Oner B B, Turduev M, Giden I H and Kurt H 2013 Opt. Lett. 38 220-222. [42] Refai H H, Sluss J J and Tull M P 2007 Opt. Eng. 46 085401. 12 [43] Bachman C G 1979 Laser Radar Systems and Techniques (Dedham: Artech House). [44] Gattass R R and Mazur E 2008 Nat. Photon. 2 219 -- 225. [45] Betzig E and Trautman J K 1992 Science 257 189 -- 195. [46] Delaney P M, Harris M R and King R G 1994 Appl. Opt. 33 573 -- 577. [47] Lechleiter J D, Lin D T and Sieneart I 2002 Biophys. J. 83 2292 -- 2299. [48] Smith W J 1996 Modern Lens Design: A Resource Manual ( New York: McGraw-Hill). [49] Bass M, Van Stryland E W and Williams D R 1995 Handbook of Optics (New York: McGraw-Hill). [50] Fuchs U and Wickenhagen S 2015 Proc. SPIE 9580 958007. [51] Fuchs U and Matthias S 2014 Proc. SPIE 9194 91940U. [52] Bahadur B 1995 Liquid Crystals: Applications and Uses (Singapore: World Scientific). [53] Kelly S M and O'Neill M 2000 Liquid Crystals for Electro-Optic Applications (Academic Press). [54] Scharf T 2007 Polarized Light in Liquid Crystals and Polymers (Hoboken, NJ, USA: Wiley). [55] Bahari B and Rashed-Mohassel J 2014 IET Optoelectron. 8 11-17. [56] Li J 2005 Electronic Theses and Dissertations.Paper 4460. [57] Li J, Gauzia S, Wu S T 2004 Opt. Express 12 2002 -- 2010. [58] Turduev M, Giden I H and Kurt H 2015 Opt. Commun. 339 22-33. [59] Higashihara T and Ueda M 2015 Macromolecules 48 1915-1929. [60] Takeda H and Yoshino K 2004 Phys. Rev. E 70 026601-1-026601-7 13
1809.08278	2	1809	2018-12-04T19:25:50	Characterization of vertically aligned carbon nanotube forests grown on stainless steel surfaces	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mtrl-sci" ]	Vertically aligned carbon nanotube (CNT) forests are a particularly interesting class of nanomaterials, because they combine multifunctional properties, such as high energy absorption, compressive strength, recoverability and super-hydrophobicity with light weight. These characteristics make them suitable for application as coating, protective layers and antifouling substrates for metallic pipelines and blades. Direct growth of CNT forests on metals offers the possibility to transfer the tunable CNT functionalities directly onto the desired substrates. Here, we focus on characterizing the structure and mechanical properties, as well as wettability and adhesion of CNT forests grown on different types of stainless steel. We investigate the correlations between composition and morphology of the steel substrates with the micro-structure of the CNTs, and reveal how the latter ultimately controls the mechanical and wetting properties of the CNT forest. Additionally, we study the influence of substrate morphology on the adhesion of CNTs to their substrate. We highlight that the same structure-property relationships govern the mechanical performance of CNT forests grown on steels and on Si.	physics.app-ph	physics	Characterization of vertically aligned carbon nanotube forests grown on stainless steel surfaces Eleftheria Roumeli1,2, Marianna Diamantopoulou1, Marc Serra-Garcia1,3, Paul Johanns4, Giulio Parcianello5, Chiara Daraio2* 1 Department of Mechanical and Process Engineering, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH Zurich), 8092, Zurich, Switzerland. 2 Division of Engineering and Applied Science, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA. 3 Department of Physics, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH Zurich), 8092, Zurich, Switzerland. 4 Institute of Mechanical Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland. 5 General Electric Switzerland, CH-5401 Baden, Switzerland Keywords: characterization; stress/strain measurements; electron microscopy; carbon nanotube; steel; coatings Vertically aligned carbon nanotube (CNT) forests are a particularly interesting class of nanomaterials, because they combine multifunctional properties, such as high energy absorption, compressive strength, recoverability and super-hydrophobicity with light weight. These characteristics make them suitable for application as coating, protective layers and antifouling substrates for metallic pipelines and blades. Direct growth of CNT forests on metals offers the possibility to transfer the tunable CNT functionalities directly onto the desired substrates. Here, we focus on characterizing the structure and mechanical properties, as well as wettability and adhesion of CNT forests grown on different types of stainless steel. We investigate the correlations between composition and morphology of the steel substrates with the micro-structure of the CNTs, and reveal how the latter ultimately controls the mechanical and wetting properties of the CNT forest. Additionally, we study the influence of substrate morphology on the adhesion of CNTs to their substrate. We highlight that the same structure-property relationships govern the mechanical performance of CNT forests grown on steels and on Si. 1. Introduction The unique properties of carbon nanotube (CNT) forests have been documented extensively in the past decade 1 -- 4. Modifying the synthesis conditions allows tuning of the geometry, alignment, density and structure of CNTs, which offers control over their mechanical performance 5 -- 10. CNT forests grown directly on metal substrates, and specifically on steels, are particularly interesting because they offer a conformal coating solution, which is independent from the substrate's geometry 11 -- 36. Direct growth avoids the need for intermediate adhesive layers, thus enabling a robust contact interface between the CNTs and the metal 12. 1 Floating catalyst chemical vapor deposition combines high CNT yield, vertical alignment and conformal substrate coverage. This method is commonly used for CNT forest growth on metal substrates 12,28,29,31. Most literature on CNTs grown on metallic substrates, either in the form of aligned forests or non-aligned CNTs, focuses on the synthesis methods 11,15,18,20,26,29,31,34 -- 37. Few reports characterize the CNTs super-hydrophobicity 21,27,28, corrosion resistance 27,38, field- emission properties 14,25 and electrochemical performance as capacitors 12,13,16. The mechanical response of CNT forests grown on metallic substrates, like their behavior under compression or impact, as well as their adhesion to the substrate, have not yet been thoroughly investigated. The remarkable compressive behavior of CNT forests grown on silicon has been documented in literature and it includes energy dissipation in the order of MJ/m36,39,40, compressive strengths ranging between 0.1-500 MPa 9,39 and almost full-length strain recovery (>80%) for hundreds of compression cycles 1,41. The mechanical performance of the silicon-grown CNT forests has been correlated to the forests' structure and alignment 6,8,9,41. The forest's structural properties, in turn, depend on the catalyst distribution and interfacial effects between the CNTs and the silicon substrates 9,42,43. However, the behavior of catalysts at the interfaces with the steel substrates is different, due to the native composition of these substrates. Steels, for example, are rich of multiple metals and oxides. In the floating catalyst method, the interactions of the supplied metal catalyst particles with the native metals and oxides of the growth substrate determine the rate and yield of CNT formation 31. We expect the differences in surface composition between silicon and steel substrates, to affect the morphology and ultimate mechanical behavior of the CNT forests grown in the different types of substrates. The focus of this work is to study the mechanical properties, adhesion and wettability of CNT forests grown on steel substrates and reveal the structure-property relationships that govern the CNT performance. Our results demonstrate the mechanical performance of CNT forests grown on steel is governed by the CNT micro-structure on the same way as it does on Si-grown CNTs. Considering the fact that the CNT forests combine light-weight, super-hydrophobicity, high energy absorption, similar to that of rigid polymer foams, with reusability, due to the large strain recoverability, a wide area of steel coating applications can be reached. 2. Experimental 2.1. Materials 2.1.1. Steel substrates The compositions of the used steels are summarized in Table 1. Prior to growth, all the substrates were placed in a Cr-etching bath for 15 min and then ultra-sonicated in acetone for 5 min to remove any organic residues or dust. In addition, the substrates were air-annealed for 30 min at 827oC before the start of the growth process (section 2.1.2). The surface roughness of all substrates was measured with a Dektak XT Stylus profilometer and the values are summarized in Table 1. The steels' surface energy was determined through contact angle measurements using a Drop Shape Analyzer from Krüss Optronic GmbH, model DSA2544. Young's theory relates the measured contact angle (θ) to the specific free energy of the tested solid (𝛾𝑆), the used liquid (𝛾𝐿) and the interfacial free energy between the solid and the liquid (𝛾𝑆𝐿) as follows44: 𝛾𝐿𝑐𝑜𝑠𝜃 = 𝛾𝑆 − 𝛾𝑆𝐿 Eq. (1) Fowkes' theory predicts the surface energy of a solid, assuming it is a summation of individual and independent components (polar, dispersive, acidic etc.): 2 𝛾𝑆 = 𝛾𝑠 𝑎𝑏 + ⋯ Eq. (2) 𝑝 + 𝛾𝑠 𝑑 + 𝛾𝑠 where the superscripts "d", "p" and "ab" correspond to the dispersive, polar and acid-base interactions respectively. We used water and diiodomethane to probe the polar and dispersive forces of the substrates and a harmonic-mean approach to sum their contribution following Wu's equation44: (1 + 𝑐𝑜𝑠𝜃)𝛾𝐿 = 4 ( 𝑑 𝑑𝛾𝑆 𝛾𝐿 𝑑 + 𝑑+𝛾𝑆 𝛾𝐿 𝑝 𝑝) 𝑝𝛾𝑆 𝛾𝐿 𝑝+𝛾𝑆 𝛾𝐿 Eq. (3) where the subscript "L" is for each liquid used in the measurement Table 1. Stainless steel substrates nominal compositions and surface characteristics Steel sample Cr (wt%) Ni (wt%) Mo (wt%) Cu (wt%) C (wt%) Surface roughness (µm) S1 S2 S3 S4 1.9-2.6 8-9.5 <0.4 11-12.5 2.2-3 1.3-1.9 <0.3 0.05-0.15 0.08-0.12 0.1-0.14 13.5-16 4-6 1.2-2 1-2 0.07 0.2 0.13 0.36 0.85 Surface energy, 𝛾𝑆 (mJ/m2) 35.4 30.7 53.7 44.8 2.1.2. CNT forest synthesis CNT forests were synthesized on thermally oxidized silicon (Si) wafers and/or on the different stainless steel substrates, using vapor phase or "floating catalyst" thermal CVD. The furnace tube had an external diameter of 5 cm and a 15 cm heating zone 10. The synthesis reactions were performed in Ar flow of 800 sccm at 827 °C in atmospheric pressure. The precursor solution was ferrocene in toluene, at a concentration of 0.02 g/ml and the injection rate was 1 ml/min. 2.2. Characterization methods To characterize the CNT structure and purity we used scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and Raman spectroscopy. SEM images were obtained using a HITACHI, SU8200 SEM, operating at 2-5 kV and 11nA (Fig. 1). High resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) images were obtained using a FEI TF30ST operating at 300 kV. Raman spectroscopy measurements were performed on a NTEGRA Spectra, NT-MDT. The hydrophobicity response of the CNT forest was determined through the water contact angle measurements described in the previous section. The micromechanical testing of the samples was performed using a FT-MTA02 module from FEMTO TOOLS. The obtained data of this experiment include also contributions from the sensor and system configuration as well as from the supporting steel material underneath the CNT forest. In order to remove these contributions and allow further calculations on the response of the CNT forests, we tested also a polished uncoated SS substrate45. At least four experiments for every 3 sample type were performed, and the average values for dissipated energy, unloading modulus (E) and peak stress are extracted from the obtained stress-strain curves The samples' recovery, R, is defined as the displacement recovered at the end of each compression cycle, divided by the maximum displacement, according to the following formula10: 𝑅 = 𝜀𝑚𝑎𝑥−𝜀𝑢𝑛𝑙𝑜𝑎𝑑 𝜀𝑚𝑎𝑥 . Eq. (4) Here, 𝜀𝑚𝑎𝑥 is the maximum displacement at the end of compression cycle, and 𝜀𝑢𝑛𝑙𝑜𝑎𝑑 is the displacement after unloading to 10% of the maximum load in each cycle. The loss coefficient, η, measures energy dissipation and is calculated as follows46: 𝜂 = 𝛥𝑈𝑖 2𝜋𝑈1 , Eq. (5) where U1 is the elastic energy stored in the material when it is loaded elastically to a stress σmax during the first cycle and ΔUi is the energy dissipated in the ith cycle. Several methods have been reported to study the CNT adhesion to metal substrates including peel tests, scotch tape tests, scratch tests, indentation and combinations of those 47,48. Amongst those, the scratch test is the most widely accepted method to quantitatively assess well-adherent coatings on metals47,49,50. To study specifically the adhesion of CNTs to their growth substrates, the literature reported methods include: the scotch tape removal method 27,28, the pull-off method, which involves taping over the CNTs and measuring the pulling force12,30, and the ultrasonication method, in which the time required to remove the CNTs from the substrate is recorded27,33. However, these methods are often user-sensitive, uncalibrated and do not guarantee that the CNTs will be removed from the substrate as opposed to breaking at weak points51. More accurate methods proposed for adhesion testing employ a nano-indenter or an atomic force microscope (AFM)51,52, which scratches through the substrates and measures the coating adhesion strength. Nevertheless, this approach is bound by a low force detection threshold and the dimensions of the coating may impose additional restrictions. Thus, in order to study the adhesion of CNT forests to their growth substrates, we develop a custom-built scratch setup. The custom setup consists of a 3-axis linear stage holding a razor blade (VWR International, No. 9) adjusted at a 45o angle above the substrate. The substrate is stabilized with four screws. A strain gauge is placed in the x-direction (scratching direction), to detect the force on the substrate while the razor blade scratches off the CNTs forest. After positioning the sample on the stage using the adjustment screws, the razor blade is moved manually, to get in contact with the edge of CNT forests. The samples are scratched with five different scratching speeds, namely 0.2, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 5.0 mm/s. The output voltage of the strain gauge is recorded as a function of time with an oscilloscope (Tektronix, DP0314, Digital Phosphor Oscilloscope). After calibration (Kc=0.045 V/N), the scratching force can be obtained. From the force, the energy release per unit area (E/A, in J/m2) can be calculated as follows: 𝐸 𝐴 = 𝐸 𝑤∙𝐿 = 𝐸 𝑤∙𝑢∙𝑡 = 𝑃 𝑤∙𝑢 = 𝐹∙𝑢 𝑤∙𝑢 = 𝐹 𝑤 . Eq. (6) Here, w is the width of the CNT forest, P is the power in J/s, L is the length of the forest and u is the velocity in m/s. 4 3. Results and Discussion 3.1. Structural Investigation In Fig. 1, we present typical SEM and HRTEM images of CNTs forests grown on the S1 and S4 substrates. We observe a conformal coating of about 60-80 µm in every case on the top of the steel surface. The average growth rate is the same across all samples grown on steels, 1.4±0.2 µm/min. The average outer nanotube diameter, as calculated from SEM images, is 93 ± 20 nm for CNTs grown on S1-S2 and 65 ± 20 nm for CNTs grown on S3-S4. HRTEM images reveal that CNTs grown on S1-S2 have on average 107 walls, while those on S3-S4 have on average 68 walls. The small height of the grown CNT forests does not allow accurate direct mass measurement. To calculate their mass, we employ the method suggested by Laurent et al 53. In it, the mass and volume of a single multi-walled CNT, mMWCNT and volume VMWCNT, can be calculated as follows: 𝑚MWCNT = 1 𝐴 𝜋𝐿[𝑛𝑑𝑜𝑢𝑡 − 2𝑑𝑠−𝑠 ∑ 𝑖𝑛 𝑖=0 ] (Eq.7) 𝑉𝑀𝑊𝐶𝑁𝑇 = 2 𝜋𝐿𝑑𝑜𝑢𝑡 4 (Eq. 8) Here, A is the specific surface area of a single nanotube sheet (equivalent to the one side of a rolled graphene sheet regardless of its diameter, A=1315 m2/g), L is the CNT length, n is the number of walls of the CNT, dout is the outer diameter, ds-s is the inter-tube distance (ds -- s = 0.34 nm). Then from the SEM-observed areal density (7.9x108 CNTs/cm2 for S1-S2 and 1.4x109 CNTs/cm2 for S3-S4) and the overall forest volume (area of steel substrate x forest height), we calculate the sample density. Based on HRTEM and SEM observations, this method results on a density of 0.1 g/cm3 for samples S1-S2, and 0.06 g/cm3 for S3-S4, which are within the literature- reported values for CNT forests 6,10,54. Differences on surface properties and composition of the steel substrates can explain the differences in CNT diameters and density for the various substrates. As can be seen from Table 1, steels S3-S4 are richer in iron alloys like Fe-Ni and Fe-Cr, compared to S1-S2. In literature, excess of Cr and Ni over Fe, has been associated with the formation of CNTs with smaller diameter and narrower distribution which is in agreement with our observations of CNTs with smaller diameters in samples S3-S4 55,56. Additionally, samples S3 and S4 have a higher surface roughness and a higher surface energy compared to S1 and S2. The higher surface roughness combined with better wettability can inhibit catalyst particle mobility and thus, hinter particle coalescence 57,58. Therefore, on S3-S4 the available catalyst size would be smaller thus leading to smaller CNT diameters, which is the result of our experimental observation 58,59. The larger CNT diameter and broader distribution found on samples S1-S2 can be justified by the significantly lower Cr and Ni content, as well as the smoother surface and lower surface energy of these steels. Lower surface roughness and energy lead to catalyst particles with higher mobility, which would allow larger clustering and thus, the SEM-observed CNTs with larger diameters can be justified. 5 Figure 1. (a-b) Representative SEM images of sample S1; (c) HRTEM image of individual CNT from sample S1; dash lines mark the inner tube wall and dotted lines mark the outer CNT wall; (d) outer diameter size distribution for sample S1; (e-f) SEM images of sample S4; (g) HRTEM image of individual CNT from sample S4; (h) measured outer diameter size distribution for sample S4. Scale bars correspond to: (a, e) 500 μm, (b, f) 40 μm, (c, g) 10 nm. To evaluate the possible differences between CNT forests grown on Si wafers versus steel substrates, we perform control experiments. From SEM images of CNTs grown on silicon, presented in Supplementary Material (Fig. S.1a-b), the measured forest height is 1.0 ± 0.05 mm while the CNT diameter is 70 ± 10 nm. The average density is 0.21 ± 0.08 g/cm3 and growth rate is 20 µm/min. These features are in agreement with previous reports on CNT forests grown via the floating-catalyst or fixed catalyst processes 40,60,61. The observed average diameter of Si-grown CNTs is between the diameters of CNTs grown on steels. The higher growth rate and density of the forests grown on Si, can be justified by the substrate composition. In the case of Si wafer substrate, ferrocene feedstock is the only source of catalyst particles, whereas on the steel substrates, since the surface is rich in metals such as Fe, Cr, Ni, Mo and Cu, the corresponding metal oxides are formed during annealing at elevated temperatures in air flow, serving as additional catalyst sites11,17,30. In Si substrates the dissociated carbon atoms are diffusing over Fe catalyst particles, while on steel substrates there are additional sites available composed primarily of Cr and Ni. Carbon solubility in Cr and Ni is lower compared to Fe 55,62. As such, the lower growth rate, and subsequently the lower density, in steel substrates can be justified by the presence of Cr and Ni, in agreement with previous reports from Chen et al 55. To analyze the quality of the produced CNTs, we perform Raman spectroscopy measurements (Fig. 2). The Raman peak at around 1600 cm-1 (G band) is associated to the graphitic carbon, while the one around 1340 cm-1 (D band) is related to a hybridized vibrational mode arising from defects on the graphene structure. The ratio between G and D peaks (IG/D) can be used as an indication of the CNTs' quality51. CNT forests grown on Si wafers result in a high IG/D ratio of 1.9 indicating their high quality, while the CNTs grown on the steel substrates range from 0.7-1.0. The better alignment and purity of the CNTs grown on Si versus steels as suggested by Raman, is in agreement with the previous SEM observations. The small variation between samples grown on 6 S1-S2 and S3-S4, with the former presenting higher values (0.9-1.0) compared to the latter (0.71- 0.79), suggest a lower defect density and higher degree of alignment for forests grown on S1-S2 in comparison to those grown on S3-S4 steels 51,63. Figure 2. Raman spectra obtained from the CNT forests grown on the different substrates. The IG/D ratio is indicated for every substrate type. 3.2. Quasi-static characterization We study the mechanical performance of the CNT forests subjected to quasi-static compressions for five consecutive cycles at a stain rate of 0.02 s-1. Results indicate that after the third compression cycle, the forests reach a steady-state response (data for the first five compression cycles for S4 presented in the inset of Fig. 3a). Representative stress-strain curves for the first compression cycle for the different types of steel substrates, as well as for the CNT forest grown on Si wafer are presented in Fig. 3a. From the obtained curves, we extract the dissipated energy (Fig. 3b), unloading modulus (Fig. 3c), peak stress (Fig. 3d), loss coefficient (Fig. 3e) and recovery (Fig. 3f), for each of the five consecutive compression cycles. At the first compression cycle, samples S1, S2 and S3 have similar dissipated energy values, which range between 1.7-1.9 MJ/m3. The CNT forest on S4 dissipates distinctly less energy, with an average value of 1.3 MJ/m3. CNTs grown on Si dissipate 1.9 MJ/m3, confirming that the energy dissipation is at the same order of magnitude for all CNT forests grown on Si and on steel. For the subsequent cycles, we note a decrease in the amount of dissipated energy, which levels off at about 7 at 20-30% of the original value on all substrates. Same behavior is observed for the CNTs grown on Si wafer. The peak stress remains almost constant through all the consecutive compressions on all samples, with variations less than ±10%. Specifically, the CNTs on the S1 steel present the highest strength value, peaking at 24.4 MPa, while for S2 the maximum reached stress is 21.2 MPa. For S4 and S3 steels, lower stress levels are observed for the first compression cycle reaching 15.7 and 12.3 MPa, respectively. The peak stress values for the CNTs grown on Si are also constant, with an average at 10 MPa. The unloading moduli obtained for all samples range between 75 MPa and 100 MPa, with S4 presenting the highest stiffness, followed by S2, S1 and S3. In all steel samples, the unloading modulus is almost constant, with deviations within ±10% for all the successive compression cycles. For CNTs grown on Si, the modulus is found to be higher and constant throughout cyclic loading, averaging at 170 MPa for all cycles. The higher stiffness found on CNTs grown on Si compared to steels, can be correlated to the higher quality and significantly more height of the CNT forests grown on Si. The loss coefficient, which reflects the degree to which a material dissipates energy, is slightly decreasing for each consecutive cycle for all steel types. We obtain similar values for all samples grown on steels and on Si, which lie between 2x10-2 and 7x10-2. We also investigate the deformation recovery of the CNTs after compression. We find that CNTs grown on the steels S1 and S2 show the largest recovery, averaging at 45% for all compressive cycles. The CNTs on S3 and S4 have also an almost constant recovery throughout all cycles, at 23% and 26%, respectively. CNT forests grown on Si recover significantly more, with an average at 78% throughout all compression cycles. This difference for recovery of CNTs grown on steels compared to Si, can be justified by the much higher thickness of the CNT forest on Si, as reported in previous studies 10. Our results show that the denser, thicker and more aligned CNT forests grown on S1-S2, exhibit the highest energy dissipation, peak stress, loss coefficient and recovery, while the less dense, smaller diameter and more tortuous CNTs grown on sample S4, result in higher stiffness. This is in agreement with previous observations of CNTs grown on Si 10. 8 Figure 3. (a) Stress-strain curves for CNT forests grown on all substrates; five consecutive compression cycle stress-strain data for S4 (inset); (b) dissipated energy, (c) unloading modulus, (d) peak stress, (e) loss coefficient and (f) recovery percentage for CNT forests grown on all substrates; (b-f) account for five consecutive compression cycles on each sample. 9 The mechanical performance of the CNT forests suggests that they may be suitable for vibration mitigation and protective applications because they combine high energy dissipation, strength and recoverability. We compare the performance of our materials with other CNT foams or polymeric foams of similar density, which are used in those applications, in an Ashby plot 46 (Fig. 4). The compressive strength of CNT forests grown on metal substrates is superior to the performance of rigid polymer foams and comparable to synthetic materials like high density polyurethanes, polyvinyl chloride and polymethaclylamide (with densities about 1, 0.5 and 0.2 g/cm3 respectively) 46. However, the rigid polymer foam materials fail catastrophically upon compression, while CNT forests offer the same performance coupled with recoverability. Flexible polymer foams on the other hand, which lie on the bottom left part of the property plot presented in Fig. 4, offer the advantage of recoverability but have considerably lower strength (10-2-100 MPa) and energy dissipation (10-3-10-1 MJ/m3) compared to CNTs. Therefore, the mechanical performance of CNT forests combines advantages otherwise not found in one group of foams. The Ashby plot of Fig. 4 also offers a comparison with literature-reported mechanical performance of CNT forests. Forests grown on Si fabricated with the floating catalyst method and tested under similar conditions are depicted as grey triangles pointing up and CNT forests fabricated with a different method and/or tested under different conditions are represented by yellow triangles pointing down 1,5,8,9,39,41,64 -- 69. The comparison confirms our observation that CNT forests grown on steels have similar mechanical properties as CNTs grown on Si. Figure 4. Compressive strength versus elastic modulus for foam materials. Green circles represent polymer foams and red circles non-polymer (ceramic and wood) foams. The performance of CNT forests on steel is marked by square, blue markers and CNT forests grown on Si are represented by triangles (pointing up, grey triangles for CNTs fabricated with the same method and tested under similar conditions and pointing down yellow triangles for CNTs fabricated through different methods and/or measured with different conditions). Data from our work and literature-reported values 1,5,8,9,39,41,64 -- 69. 10 3.3. Wetting properties Corrosion protection on steel surfaces can be obtained using superhydrophobic coatings which prevent water diffusion to the surfaces, thereby extending their service life 21,28,70. CNTs have been suggested as alternatives because they combine superhydrophobicity with thermal and electrical conductivity, which their organic counterparts lack 21,28,71. To characterize the hydrophobicity of our coatings, we perform water contact angle measurements. The results are summarized in Table 2. All the fabricated CNT forests are hydrophobic, and in some cases superhydrophobic. The best performance is obtained for the CNT forest on S2, which has a water contact angle of 161.5o, followed by S3, S1 and S4, for which the contact angles vary from 153.6 to 144.8o. The measured contact angle of the control CNT sample grown on a Si wafer is 133.2 ± 5.8o, which is the lowest measured value. This can be explained by the enhanced surface roughness of the steel surfaces, compared to that of a Si wafer. The higher surface roughness of steels yields a less uniform CNT height, therefore a rougher top surface of the forest. It is known that a higher surface roughness leads to higher contact angles72,73 and therefore this can count for the higher contact angle of CNT forests on steel versus Si. The morphological differences of CNTs on the steel substrates can justify the lower hydrophobicity of S4 compared to S1, S2 and S3. As shown by the IG/D index, calculated from the Raman spectra of the samples, S4 presents the highest defect density and tortuosity, and therefore has more non-aligned CNT tips exposed on the surface which justifies the lowest hydrophobicity compared to the rest of the samples. The CNTs on S2 have the highest CNT quality, as indicated by the Raman IG/D index, suggesting more aligned CNT tips on the surface and thus a higher hydrophobicity is expected. Table 2. Contact angle between a water droplet and the CNT forests grown on different substrates. Substrate used Average water contact angle (degrees) S1 S2 S3 S4 Si 150.6 ± 10.8 161.5 ± 4.4 153.6 ± 5.8 144.8 ± 0.3 133.2 ± 5.8o 3.4. Adhesion tests To evaluate the adhesion between the CNT forests and the steel substrates, we use a custom- made scratching setup (Fig. 5a). As described previously, the force during the razor blade movement along the length of the substrate is continuously monitored. At the time point in which the razor blade scratches the VACNT forest a distinct force increase is recorded, as shown Fig. 5b, in a representative example of an obtained force-time curve, corresponding to sample S3. Using Eq. (6) we calculate the average energy released during scratching for each substrate. The results 11 for all samples, considered at five different scratching speeds, show that the CNTs adhere more efficiently on the surface of S3-S4, compared to S1-S2 at every tested scratch speed (Fig. 5c). Specifically, for S3 the average energy release values range between 530-620 J/m2, while for S4 they are within 250-450 J/m2. For CNTs on S1-S2 the adhesion is almost the same with energy release values around 100-200 J/m2. As previously discussed and shown in Table 1, the surface energy of steel substrates is highest for S3, and then in descending order for S4, S1 and S2, respectively. Additionally, S3-S4 have larger surface roughness compared to S1-S2. The combination of higher surface energy and roughness, found in S4 and S3, can explain the better adhesion that CNTs have on these surfaces, compared to S1-S2. Due to the use of different techniques to measure the adhesion-related strength or energy release, a comparison with all literature reported values is not always possible12,30,51,52. The results which could be compared with our measurements are those reported by Cao et. al30, Ageev et. al52 and Lahiri et. al.51. Cao et. grew CNT forests on the end of a silicon carbide (SiC) micron-thick fiber in a form of a brush. They determined the adhesion of the CNTs on SiC by taping over the CNT area and pulling them away from their substrate with a tension machine. The calculated energy based on their results, assuming a pulling length equal to the total length of the bristle in their brush, is 84 J/m2 for CNTs grown on SiC fibers without post-growth treatment30. Ageev et. al used the AFM to measure the adhesion of CNT forests grown through PECVD on a Si wafer on a Ti/Ni layer (buffer and catalyst respectively) and reported an adhesion strength of 0.55-1.9 mJ/m2 52. Finally, Lahiri et. al, using a nanoindentor scratched through un-oriented CNTs grown on Si and Cu wafers, determined an adhesion of ~80-400 J/m2 for Si and 600-1070 J/m2 for Cu wafers51. The results from Lahiri et al. for Si wafer-grown CNTs are comparable to the energy release values found in our work, while those for Cu-grown CNTs indicate a higher adhesion than the one found in our samples. However, it should be noted that in the case of randomly oriented CNTs the contact area between the individual tube and the substrate can be much higher than in the case of vertically- aligned CNTs where mostly only the base of each tube is in contact with the substrate. Therefore, the calculated energy release per unit area can be an overestimation in the case of un-oriented CNTs. The results of Cao et. al, are lower than the values measured in the present work which can be attributed to the different type and geometry of the substrates use in that work. Finally, the results from Ageev et. are significantly lower than the rest of reported values, possibly due to the fundamentally different measurement method employed in that case. 12 Figure 5. (a) Experimental setup for testing the adhesion between the CNTs and their steel substrates. (b) Obtained force-time curve for sample S3. (c) Calculated energy release as a function of the scratching speed, for the different types of samples. 4. Conclusions In this work, we report the synthesis, structural and mechanical characterization of CNT forests grown on commercial steel substrates. The CNT forests are grown using the floating catalyst method, directly on top of the steel substrates without the use of intermediate adhesive layers, to allow a robust direct contact. We study the mechanical properties, wettability and adhesion of the synthesized CNTs and investigate the structure-property relationships that govern the CNTs' performance. We find that the steel substrate composition and morphology determine the CNT diameter and density. CNTs with larger diameter and density exhibit higher degree of alignment and have the highest energy dissipation, peak stress, loss coefficient and recovery, as well as higher hydrophobicity. CNTs with smaller diameter, density and higher tortuosity result in higher stiffness and lower hydrophobicity. The results reveal that CNT forests grown on steel combine high energy dissipation, high compressive strength and stiffness with recoverability. Their mechanical performance, lightweight and superhydrophobicity, combined with their adhesion to steel, highlight the possibility to use carbon nanotubes forests as a protective multifunctional layer material for metal surfaces. ASSOCIATED CONTENT Supporting Information. SEM images of CNTs grown on silicon are presented in Figure S.1 AUTHOR INFORMATION Corresponding Author * Tel: +1 626 395 8515. E-mail: [email protected] (Chiara Daraio) ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was part of the "Advanced cnt structures for functional surfaces applications" project co-funded by ALSTOM/GE and Hightech Zentrum Aargau AG. Contact angle and surface roughness measurements were performed at the Molecular Materials Research Center of the Beckman Institute of the California Institute of Technology. The authors would like to thank Dr. Matthew S. Hunt, for the HRTEM imaging. REFERENCES (1) Cao, A.; Dickrell, P. L.; Sawyer, W. G.; Ghasemi-Nejhad, M. N.; Ajayan, P. M. Super- 13 Compressible Foamlike Carbon Nanotube Films. Science (80-. ). 2005, 310 (5752), 1307 -- 1310. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1118957. (2) Qu, L.; Dai, L.; Stone, M.; Xia, Z.; Wang, Z. L. Carbon Nanotube Arrays with Strong Shear Binding-On and Easy Normal Lifting-Off. Science (80-. ). 2008, 322 (5899), 238 -- 242. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1159503. (3) De Volder, M. F. L. F. L.; Tawfick, S. H. H.; Baughman, R. H.; Hart, A. J. J.; Volder, M. F. L. De; De Volder, M. F. L. F. L.; Tawfick, S. H. H.; Baughman, R. H.; Hart, A. J. J.; Baughmann, R. H. H.; et al. Carbon Nanotubes : Present and Future Commercial Applications. 535 -- 540. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1222453. Science (2013), 2014, (80-. 535 ). (4) Schnorr, J. M.; Swager, T. M. Emerging Applications of Carbon Nanotubes. Chem. Mater. 2011, 23 (3), 646 -- 657. https://doi.org/10.1021/cm102406h. (5) Thevamaran, R.; Meshot, E. R.; Daraio, C. Shock Formation and Rate Effects in Impacted 390 -- 398. Foams. Carbon N. 2015, (1), 84 Y. Carbon Nanotube https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2014.12.006. (6) Raney, J. R.; Misra, A.; Daraio, C. Tailoring the Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Arrays of Aligned Multiwall Carbon Nanotubes by Utilizing Different Hydrogen Concentrations during Synthesis. Carbon N. Y. 2011, 49 (11), 3631 -- 3638. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2011.04.066. (7) Thevamaran, R.; Karakaya, M.; Meshot, E. R.; Fischer, A.; Podila, R.; Rao, A. M.; Daraio, C. Anomalous Impact and Strain Responses in Helical Carbon Nanotube Foams. RSC Adv. 2015, 5 (37), 29306 -- 29311. https://doi.org/10.1039/C5RA03561A. (8) Pour Shahid Saeed Abadi, P.; Hutchens, S. B.; Greer, J. R.; Cola, B. A.; Graham, S. Effects of Morphology on the Micro-Compression Response of Carbon Nanotube Forests. Nanoscale 2012, 4 (11), 3373. https://doi.org/10.1039/c2nr30474k. (9) Yaglioglu, O.; Cao, A.; Hart, A. J.; Martens, R.; Slocum, A. H. Wide Range Control of Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Carbon Nanotube Forests: A Comparison between Fixed and Floating Catalyst CVD Techniques. Adv. Funct. Mater. 2012, 22 (23), 5028 -- 5037. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.201200852. (10) Pathak, S.; Raney, J. R.; Daraio, C. Effect of Morphology on the Strain Recovery of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotube Arrays: An in Situ Study. Carbon N. Y. 2013, 63 (505), 303 -- 316. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2013.06.083. (11) Vander Wal, R. L.; Hall, L. J. Carbon Nanotube Synthesis upon Stainless Steel Meshes. Carbon N. Y. 2003, 41 (4), 659 -- 672. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0008-6223(02)00369-X. (12) Talapatra, S.; Kar, S.; Pal, S. K.; Vajtai, R.; Ci, L.; Victor, P.; Shaijumon, M. M.; Kaur, S.; Nalamasu, O.; Ajayan, P. M. Direct Growth of Aligned Carbon Nanotubes on Bulk Metals. Nat Nano 2006, 1 (2), 112 -- 116. https://doi.org/10.1038/nnano.2006.56. (13) Raja Noor Amalina Raja, S.; Mohd Asyadi, A.; Mohd Ambri, M.; Seman, R. N. A. R.; Azam, M. A.; Mohamed, M. A. Highly Efficient Growth of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotubes on Fe -- Ni Based Metal Alloy Foils for Supercapacitors. Adv. Nat. Sci. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 2016, 7 (4), 45016. https://doi.org/10.1088/2043-6262/7/4/045016. 14 (14) Li, D.; Cheng, Y.; Wang, Y.; Zhang, H.; Dong, C.; Li, D. Improved Field Emission Properties of Carbon Nanotubes Grown on Stainless Steel Substrate and Its Application in Surf. Ionization 10 -- 18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2016.01.011. Gauge. 2016, Appl. 365, Sci. (15) Reinhardt, H.; Hellmann, C.; Nürnberger, P.; Kachel, S.; Hampp, N. Free Form Growth of Carbon Nanotube Microarchitectures on Stainless Steel Controlled via Laser-Stimulated Catalyst (16). https://doi.org/10.1002/admi.201700508. Formation. Interfaces Mater. 2017, Adv. 4 (16) Park, D.; Kim, Y. H.; Lee, J. K. Synthesis of Carbon Nanotubes on Metallic Substrates by a Sequential Combination of PECVD and Thermal CVD. Carbon N. Y. 2003, 41 (5), 1025 -- 1029. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0008-6223(02)00432-3. (17) Park, S. J.; Lee, D. G. Development of CNT-Metal-Filters by Direct Growth of Carbon 182 -- 186. (SUPPL. 2006, Phys. Appl. 1), 6 Nanotubes. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cap.2006.01.035. Curr. (18) Camilli, L.; Scarselli, M.; Del Gobbo, S.; Castrucci, P.; Nanni, F.; Gautron, E.; Lefrant, S.; De Crescenzi, M. The Synthesis and Characterization of Carbon Nanotubes Grown by Chemical Vapor Deposition Using a Stainless Steel Catalyst. Carbon N. Y. 2011, 49 (10), 3307 -- 3315. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2011.04.014. (19) Camilli, L.; Scarselli, M.; Del Gobbo, S.; Castrucci, P.; Lamastra, F. R.; Nanni, F.; Gautron, E.; Lefrant, S.; D'Orazio, F.; Lucari, F.; et al. High Coercivity of Iron-Filled Carbon Nanotubes Synthesized on Austenitic Stainless Steel. Carbon N. Y. 2012, 50 (2), 718 -- 721. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2011.09.034. (20) Hashempour, M.; Vicenzo, A.; Zhao, F.; Bestetti, M. Direct Growth of MWCNTs on 316 Stainless Steel by Chemical Vapor Deposition: Effect of Surface Nano-Features on CNT Growth 330 -- 347. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2013.06.087. Structure. Carbon 2013, and 63, N. Y. (21) Francesco De, N.; Paola, C.; Manuela, S.; Francesca, N.; Ilaria, C.; Maurizio De, C.; De Nicola, F.; Castrucci, P.; Scarselli, M.; Nanni, F.; et al. Super-Hydrophobic Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotube Coatings for Stainless Steel. Nanotechnology 2015, 26 (14), 145701. https://doi.org/10.1088/0957-4484/26/14/145701. (22) Suárez-Martínez, R.; Ocampo-Macias, T.; Lara-Romero, J.; Lemus-Ruiz, J.; Jiménez- Alemán, O.; Chiñas-Castillo, F.; Sagaro-Zamora, R.; Jiménez-Sandoval, S.; Paraguay- Delgado, F. Synthesis and Tribological Performance of Carbon Nanostructures Formed on AISI (3), 36. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11249-016-0769-5. 316 Stainless Steel Substrates. Tribol. Lett. 2016, 64 (23) Karwa, M.; Iqbal, Z.; Mitra, S. Scaled-up Self-Assembly of Carbon Nanotubes inside Long 1235 -- 1242. Tubing. Carbon N. 2006, (7), 44 Y. Stainless https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2005.10.046. Steel (24) Kruehong, S.; Kruehong, C.; Artnaseaw, A. Branched Carbon Fibres and Other Carbon Nanomaterials Grown Directly from 304 Stainless Steel Using a Chemical Vapour Deposition 143 -- 152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.diamond.2016.02.011. Process. Mater. Diam. Relat. 2016, 64, 15 (25) Weiwei, Z.; Yu, Z.; Ningsheng, X.; Yuanming, T.; Runze, Z.; Yan, S.; Zhi, X.; Xuedong, B.; Jun, C.; Juncong, S.; et al. Epitaxial Growth of Multiwall Carbon Nanotube from Stainless Steel Substrate and Effect on Electrical Conduction and Field Emission. Nanotechnology 2017, 28 (30), 305704. (26) Pattinson, S. W.; Viswanath, B.; Zakharov, D. N.; Li, J.; Stach, E. A.; Hart, A. J. Mechanism and Enhanced Yield of Carbon Nanotube Growth on Stainless Steel by Oxygen-Induced Surface 932 -- 937. https://doi.org/10.1021/cm504209u. Chem. Mater. Reconstruction. 2015, (3), 27 (27) Ashraf, A.; Salih, H.; Nam, S.; Dastgheib, S. A. Robust Carbon Nanotube Membranes Directly Grown on Hastelloy Substrates and Their Potential Application for Membrane Distillation. 243 -- 251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2016.05.016. Carbon 2016, 106, N. Y. (28) Sethi, S.; Dhinojwala, A. Superhydrophobic Conductive Carbon Nanotube Coatings for Steel. Langmuir 2009, 25 (8), 4311 -- 4313. https://doi.org/10.1021/la9001187. (29) Pakdee, U.; Chiangga, S.; Suwannatus, S.; Limsuwan, P. Growth of MWCNTs on Flexible J. Nanomater. 2017, 2017. Stainless Steels without Additional Catalysts. https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/5672728. (30) Cao, A.; Veedu, V. P.; Xuesong, L. I.; Yao, Z.; Ghasemi-Nejhad, M. N.; Ajayan, P. M. Multifunctional Brushes Made from Carbon Nanotubes. Nat. Mater. 2005, 4 (7), 540 -- 545. https://doi.org/10.1038/nmat1415. (31) Masarapu, C.; Wei, B. Direct Growth of Aligned Multiwalled Carbon Nanotubes on Treated 9046 -- 9049. Langmuir 2007, (17), 23 Stainless Substrates. https://doi.org/10.1021/la7012232. Steel (32) Sano, N.; Hori, Y.; Yamamoto, S.; Tamon, H. A Simple Oxidation-Reduction Process for the Activation of a Stainless Steel Surface to Synthesize Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes and Its Application to Phenol Degradation in Water. Carbon N. Y. 2012, 50 (1), 115 -- 122. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2011.07.059. (33) Hordy, N.; Mendoza-Gonzalez, N. Y.; Coulombe, S.; Meunier, J. L. The Effect of Carbon Input on the Morphology and Attachment of Carbon Nanotubes Grown Directly from Stainless 348 -- 357. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2013.06.089. Carbon 2013, Steel. 63, N. Y. (34) Sano, N.; Yamamoto, S.; Tamon, H. Cr as a Key Factor for Direct Synthesis of Multi- Walled Carbon Nanotubes on Industrial Alloys. Chem. Eng. J. 2014, 242, 278 -- 284. https://doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cej.2013.12.073. (35) Zhuo, C.; Wang, X.; Nowak, W.; Levendis, Y. A. Oxidative Heat Treatment of 316L Stainless Steel for Effective Catalytic Growth of Carbon Nanotubes. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2014, 313, 227 -- 236. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsusc.2014.05.189. (36) Romero, P.; Oro, R.; Campos, M.; Torralba, J. M.; De Villoria, R. G. Simultaneous Synthesis of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotubes and Amorphous Carbon Thin Films on Stainless 31 -- 38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2014.10.020. Carbon 2015, Steel. (C), 82 N. Y. 16 (37) Baddour, C. E.; Fadlallah, F.; Nasuhoglu, D.; Mitra, R.; Vandsburger, L.; Meunier, J. L. A Simple Thermal CVD Method for Carbon Nanotube Synthesis on Stainless Steel 304 without the Addition of an External Catalyst. Carbon N. Y. 2009, 47 (1), 313 -- 318. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2008.10.038. (38) Abdulrahaman, M. A.; Abubakre, O. K.; Abdulkareem, S. A.; Tijani, J. O.; Aliyu, A.; Afolabi, A. S. Effect of Coating Mild Steel with CNTs on Its Mechanical Properties and Corrosion Behaviour in Acidic Medium. Adv. Nat. Sci. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 2017, 8 (1), 15016. (39) Pathak, S.; Lim, E. J.; Pour Shahid Saeed Abadi, P.; Graham, S.; Cola, B. A.; Greer, J. R. Higher Recovery and Better Energy Dissipation at Faster Strain Rates in Carbon Nanotube Bundles: An 2189 -- 2197. https://doi.org/10.1021/nn300376j. ACS Nano in-Situ Study. 2012, (3), 6 (40) Misra, A.; Raney, J. R.; De Nardo, L.; Craig, a E.; Daraio, C. Synthesis and Characterization of Carbon Nanotube-Polymer Multilayer Structures. ACS Nano 2011, 5 (10), 7713 -- 7721. https://doi.org/10.1021/nn202262j. (41) Bradford, P. D.; Wang, X.; Zhao, H.; Zhu, Y. T. Tuning the Compressive Mechanical Properties of Carbon Nanotube Foam. Carbon N. Y. 2011, 49 (8), 2834 -- 2841. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2011.03.012. (42) Xu, M.; Futaba, D. N.; Yumura, M.; Hata, K. Alignment Control of Carbon Nanotube Forest from Random to Nearly Perfectly Aligned by Utilizing the Crowding Effect. ACS Nano 2012, 6 (7), 5837 -- 5844. https://doi.org/10.1021/nn300142j. (43) Bedewy, M.; Meshot, E. R.; Reinker, M. J.; Hart, A. J. Population Growth Dynamics of 8974 -- 8989. 2011, Nano (11), 5 ACS Carbon https://doi.org/10.1021/nn203144f. Nanotubes. (44) Roumeli, E.; Pavlidou, E.; Avgeropoulos, A.; Vourlias, G.; Bikiaris, D. N. D.; Chrissafis, K. Factors Controlling the Enhanced Mechanical and Thermal Properties of Nanodiamond- Reinforced Cross-Linked High Density Polyethylene. J. Phys. Chem. B 2014, 118 (38), 11341 -- 11352. https://doi.org/10.1021/jp504531f. (45) Felekis, D.; Vogler, H.; Mecja, G.; Muntwyler, S.; Nestorova, A.; Huang, T.; Sakar, M. S.; Grossniklaus, U.; Nelson, B. J. Real-Time Automated Characterization of 3D Morphology and Mechanics of Developing Plant Cells. Int. J. Rob. Res. 2015, 34 (8), 1136 -- 1146. https://doi.org/10.1177/0278364914564231. (46) Ashby, M. F. Chapter 4 - Material Property Charts. In Materials Selection in Mechanical (Fourth Edition); Butterworth-Heinemann: Oxford, 2011; pp 57 -- 96. Design https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-1-85617-663-7.00004-7. (47) Chapman, B. N. Thin-Film Adhesion. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 1974, 11 (1), 106 -- 113. https://doi.org/10.1116/1.1318537. (48) Kleinbichler, A.; Pfeifenberger, M. J.; Zechner, J.; Moody, N. R.; Bahr, D. F.; Cordill, M. J. New Insights into Nanoindentation-Based Adhesion Testing. JOM 2017, 69 (11), 2237 -- 2245. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11837-017-2496-2. (49) Steinmann, P. A.; Hintermann, H. E. Adhesion of TiC and Ti(C,N) Coatings on Steel. J. 17 Vac. Sci. Technol. A Vacuum, Surfaces, Film. 1985, 3 https://doi.org/10.1116/1.572845. (6), 2394 -- 2400. (50) Akono, A. T.; Reis, P. M.; Ulm, F. J. Scratching as a Fracture Process: From Butter to Steel. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2011, 106 (20), 2 -- 5. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.204302. (51) Lahiri, I.; Lahiri, D.; Jin, S.; Agarwal, A.; Choi, W. Carbon Nanotubes: How Strong Is Their 780 -- 787. 2011, Nano ACS (2), 5 Bond with Substrate? https://doi.org/10.1021/nn102900z. the (52) Ageev, O. A.; Blinov, Y. F.; Il'ina, M. V.; Il'in, O. I.; Smirnov, V. A.; Tsukanova, O. G. Study of Adhesion of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotubes to a Substrate by Atomic-Force State Microscopy. 309 -- 314. https://doi.org/10.1134/s1063783416020037. 2016, Phys. Solid (2), 58 (53) Laurent, C.; Flahaut, E.; Peigney, A. The Weight and Density of Carbon Nanotubes versus the Number of Walls and Diameter. Carbon N. Y. 2010, 48 (10), 2994 -- 2996. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2010.04.010. (54) Yu, M.; Funke, H. H.; Falconer, J. L.; Noble, R. D. High Density, Vertically-Aligned 225 -- 229. 2009, Nano Lett. (1), 9 Carbon Nanotube Membranes. https://doi.org/10.1021/nl802816h. (55) Chen, G.; Seki, Y.; Kimura, H.; Sakurai, S.; Yumura, M.; Hata, K.; Futaba, D. N. Diameter Control of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotube Forests from 1.3-3.0 Nm by Arc Plasma Deposition. Sci. Rep. 2014, 4. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep03804. (56) Kim, N. S.; Lee, Y. T.; Park, J.; Ryu, H.; Lee, H. J.; Choi, S. Y.; Choo, J. Dependence of the Vertically Aligned Growth of Carbon Nanotubes on the Catalysts. J. Phys. Chem. B 2002, 106 (36), 9286 -- 9290. https://doi.org/10.1021/jp021018u. (57) De Los Arcos, T.; Garnier, M. G.; Seo, J. W.; Oelhafen, P.; Thommen, V.; Mathys, D. The Influence of Catalyst Chemical State and Morphology on Carbon Nanotube Growth. J. Phys. Chem. B 2004, 108 (23), 7728 -- 7734. https://doi.org/10.1021/jp049495v. (58) Jourdain, V.; Bichara, C. Current Understanding of the Growth of Carbon Nanotubes in Catalytic Chemical Vapour Deposition. Carbon N. Y. 2013, 58, 2 -- 39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2013.02.046. (59) Gohier, A.; Ewels, C. P.; Minea, T. M.; Djouadi, M. A. Carbon Nanotube Growth Mechanism Switches from Tip- to Base-Growth with Decreasing Catalyst Particle Size. Carbon N. Y. 2008, 46 (10), 1331 -- 1338. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.carbon.2008.05.016. (60) Nessim, G. D.; Hart, A. J.; Kim, J. S.; Acquaviva, D.; Oh, J.; Morgan, C. D.; Seita, M.; Leib, J. S.; Thompson, C. V. Tuning of Vertically-Aligned Carbon Nanotube Diameter and Areal Density through Catalyst Pre-Treatment. Nano Lett. 2008, 8 (11), 3587 -- 3593. https://doi.org/10.1021/nl801437c. (61) Raney, J. R.; Fraternali, F.; Daraio, C. Rate-Independent Dissipation and Loading Direction Effects in Compressed Carbon Nanotube Arrays. Nanotechnology 2013, 24 (25). https://doi.org/10.1088/0957-4484/24/25/255707. (62) Moisala, A.; Nasibulin, A. G.; Kauppinen, E. I. The Role of Metal Nanoparticles in the Catalytic Production of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes -- a Review. J. Phys. Condens. 18 Matter 2003, 15 (42), S3011 -- S3035. https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-8984/15/42/003. (63) Meshot, E. R.; Zwissler, D. W.; Bui, N.; Kuykendall, T. R.; Wang, C.; Hexemer, A.; Wu, K. J. J.; Fornasiero, F. Quantifying the Hierarchical Order in Self-Aligned Carbon Nanotubes from Atomic to Micrometer Scale. ACS Nano 2017, 11 (6), 5405 -- 5416. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsnano.6b08042. (64) Wittmaack, B. K.; Volkov, A. N.; Zhigilei, L. V. Mesoscopic Modeling of the Uniaxial Compression and Recovery of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotube Forests. Compos. Sci. Technol. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2018.03.014. (65) Gibson, L. J.; Ashby, M. F. Cellular Solids; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 1997. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139878326. (66) Worsley, M. A.; Kucheyev, S. O.; Satcher, J. H.; Hamza, A. V.; Baumann, T. F. Mechanically Robust and Electrically Conductive Carbon Nanotube Foams. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2009, 94 (7), 1 -- 4. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3086293. (67) Deck, C. P.; Flowers, J.; McKee, G. S. B.; Vecchio, K. Mechanical Behavior of Ultralong (2). J. Appl. Phys. 2007, 101 Multiwalled Carbon Nanotube Mats. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.2426940. (68) Won, Y.; Gao, Y.; Panzer, M. a; Xiang, R.; Maruyama, S.; Kenny, T. W.; Cai, W.; Goodson, K. E. Zipping, Entanglement, and the Elastic Modulus of Aligned Single-Walled Carbon Nanotube Films. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 2013, 110 (51), 20426 -- 20430. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1312253110/- /DCSupplemental.www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1312253110. (69) Olofsson, N.; Ek-Weis, J.; Eriksson, A.; Idda, T.; Campbell, E. E. B. Determination of the Effective Young's Modulus of Vertically Aligned Carbon Nanotube Arrays: A Simple Nanotube-Based 385710. https://doi.org/10.1088/0957-4484/20/38/385710. Nanotechnology Varactor. 2009, (38), 20 (70) Fihri, A.; Bovero, E.; Al-Shahrani, A.; Al-Ghamdi, A.; Alabedi, G. Recent Progress in Superhydrophobic Coatings Used for Steel Protection: A Review. Colloids Surfaces A Physicochem. 378 -- 390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.colsurfa.2016.12.057. 2017, Eng. Asp. 520, (71) Lau, K. K. S.; Bico, J.; Teo, K. B. K.; Chhowalla, M.; Amaratunga, G. A. J.; Milne, W. I.; McKinley, G. H.; Gleason, K. K. Superhydrophobic Carbon Nanotube Forests. Nano Lett. 2003, 3 (12), 1701 -- 1705. https://doi.org/10.1021/nl034704t. (72) Wenzel, R. N. Surface Roughness and Contact Angle. J. Phys. Colloid Chem. 1949, 53 (9), 1466 -- 1467. https://doi.org/10.1021/j150474a015. (73) Miwa, M.; Nakajima, A.; Fujishima, A.; Hashimoto, K.; Watanabe, T. Effects of the Surface Roughness on Sliding Angles of Water Droplets on Superhydrophobic Surfaces. Langmuir 2000, 16 (13), 5754 -- 5760. https://doi.org/10.1021/la991660o. 19
1902.07566	2	1902	2019-03-28T10:02:44	Interplay of magnetization dynamics with microwave waveguide at cryogenic temperatures	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.supr-con" ]	In this work, magnetization dynamics is studied at low temperatures in a hybrid system that consists of thin epitaxial magnetic film coupled with superconducting planar microwave waveguide. The resonance spectrum was observed in a wide magnetic field range, including low fields below the saturation magnetization and both polarities. Analysis of the spectrum via a developed fitting routine allowed to derive all magnetic parameters of the film at cryogenic temperatures, to detect waveguide-induced uniaxial magnetic anisotropies of the first and the second order, and to uncover a minor misalignment of magnetic field. A substantial influence of the superconducting critical state on resonance spectrum is observed and discussed.	physics.app-ph	physics	Interplay of magnetization dynamics with a microwave waveguide at cryogenic temperatures I. A. Golovchanskiy1,2, N. N. Abramov2, M. Pfirrmann3, T. Piskor3, J. N. Voss3, D. S. Baranov1,4,5, R. A. Hovhannisyan1, V. S. Stolyarov1,4,6, C. Dubs7, A. A. Golubov1,8, V. V. Ryazanov2,4,6, A. V. Ustinov2,3, M. Weides3,9 1 Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, State University, 9 Institutskiy per., Dolgoprudny, Moscow Region, 141700, Russia 2 National University of Science and Technology MISIS, 4 Leninsky prosp., Moscow, 119049, Russia 3 Physikalisches Institut, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany 4 Institute of Solid State Physics (ISSP RAS), Chernogolovka, Moscow Region 142432, Russia ´Ecole sup´erieure de physique et de chimie industrielles de la Ville de Paris, Paris Sciences et Lettres Research University, 5 Laboratoire de Physique et dEtude des Materiaux, UMR8213, Institut des NanoSciences de Paris-Sorbonne Universite, 10 rue Vauquelin, 75005 Paris, France 6 Solid State Physics Department, Kazan Federal University, Kazan 420008, Russia 7 INNOVENT e.V. Technologieentwicklung, Pruessingstrasse 27B, 07745 Jena, Germany 8 Faculty of Science and Technology and MESA+ Institute for Nanotechnology, University of Twente, Enschede 7500 AE, The Netherlands 9 School of Engineering, University of Glasgow, Rankine Building, Oakfield Avenue, Glasgow G12 8LT, United Kingdom In this work, magnetization dynamics is studied at low temperatures in a hybrid system that con- sists of a thin epitaxial magnetic film coupled with a superconducting planar microwave waveguide. The resonance spectrum was observed over a wide magnetic field range, including low fields below the saturation magnetization and both polarities. Analysis of the spectrum via a developed fitting routine allowed for the derivation of all magnetic parameters of the film at cryogenic temperatures, the detection of waveguide-induced uniaxial magnetic anisotropies of the first and the second or- der, and the uncovering of a minor misalignment of magnetic field. A substantial influence of the superconducting critical state on resonance spectrum is observed and discussed. I. INTRODUCTION The field of magnonics studies the application of magnetization oscillations and waves in ferromagnetic structures1 -- 6. The following benefits make magnonics promising for application in processing of microwave sig- nals: tunability of the magnon dispersion with applied magnetic field and the geometry of the medium, low dis- sipation and power consumption, high operational fre- quencies, convenient micron and sub-micron scales of spin wavelength at microwave frequencies, and, finally, absence of parasitic coupling of spin waves with non- magnetic environments. Conventionally, magnonics is a room-temperature research discipline. Currently a sub-discipline is emerging that deals with magnetization dynamics at cryogenic temperatures and can be referred to as "cryogenic magnonics". Indeed, quantum magnonics is of high current interest7 -- 11. Mi- crowave experiments in quantum magnonics are typi- cally performed at milli-kelvin temperatures, often us- ing setups equipped with superconducting quantum cir- cuits. On the other hand, a development of various hybrid devices is taking place based on superconduct- ing resonators7,12 and Josephson junctions13 -- 15. Also, it was shown that hybridization of a magnon medium with superconducting structures results in substantial modi- fication of dispersion properties16 -- 19, as well as in the formation of magnonic band structures20. Lastly, meta- material properties have been reported for superconduc- tor/ferromagnet superlattices21. More generally and be- yond superconductor-induced phenomena, the magnetic properties at low temperatures are probed in absence or only with minor thermal excitations. Typical thermal effects for standard magnonics, such as reduced satura- tion magnetization or thermally activated domain wall motion, are lessened for cryo-magnonics, leading to new phenomena in ferromagnetic resonance (FMR). In this regard, investigation of magnetic properties of ferromagnetic films at low temperature as well as of their interaction with superconducting circuits is imper- ative. This report addresses both problems. We focus on the ferromagnetic resonance in a thin Yttrium Iron Gar- net (YIG) film coupled to a superconducting Nb planar waveguide in out-of-plane magnetic field. We obtain the FMR spectrum at low temperature in a wide field range. The spectrum shows linear magnetic resonance versus field dependence for high fields and a range of nonlin- ear dependence of FMR frequency at low magnetic fields where the Kittel formulas are inapplicable. Developing a fitting routine, we derive all magnetic parameters of the YIG film. Our analysis shows that the waveguide itself induces substantial uniaxial magnetic anisotropy. Next, we study the FMR spectrum at temperatures below the superconducting critical temperature of the waveguide and observe an influence of the superconducting critical state of Nb on the resonance spectrum. We note that while YIG is probably the most popular magnetic material for magnonic applications, owing to its low damping, the damping in YIG and its tempera- ture dependence are not addressed in this paper and can be found elsewhere22 -- 24. In this report, YIG is selected as a model magnetic single-crystalline thin film with dis- tinct magnetocrystalline anisotropy and sufficiently low saturation magnetization, which is convenient for out-of- plane measurements. connectors. A thermometer and a heater were attached directly to the holder for precise temperature control. The holder was placed in a superconducting solenoid in- side a closed-cycle cryostat (Oxford Instruments Triton, base temperature 1.2 K). The response of the system was studied by analyzing the transmitted microwave signal S21 with the VNA Rohde & Schwarz ZVB20. 2 II. EXPERIMENTAL DETAILS III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Figures 2a,b show transmission spectra of the studied sample at T = 10 K> Tc of Nb and at 2 K< Tc. Spec- tra have been normalized with S21(f ) at µ0H = 0.5 T. Figures 2c,d show a set of normalized absorption curves S21(f ) of the sample at the same temperatures and sev- eral magnetic fields. Field dependent spectral lines in Figs. 2a,b with the minimum transmission correspond to FMR curves fr(µ0H). Both spectra show linear FMR response at µ0H > 0.2 T, which is typical for the Kittel-FMR mode of a thin film in out-of-plane mag- netic field. The resonance frequency with out-of-plane field is fr ∝ (µ0H − 4πMeff ), which indicates the value of the effective saturation magnetization 4πMeff ∼ 2000 Oe at fr → 0. Upon decreasing µ0H, the linear reso- nance line is terminated with a kink at µ0H ∼ 4πMeff and transforms into two FMR branches with nonlin- ear dependence of resonance frequency versus field for µ0H < 4πMeff . We refer to the higher-frequency FMR branch with stronger absorption as C-line and to the lower-frequency FMR branch with weaker absorption as G-line. Note that in general, observation of FMR in thin films with out-of-plane geometry at µ0H < 4πMeff might be challenging due to formation of nonuniform magnetization configurations. With out-of-plane field µ0H < 4πMeff , ferromagnetic films are not magnetized to saturation, and Kittel formulas for FMR are not appli- cable. Splitting of the FMR response into several spectral lines at µ0H < 4πMeff can be caused by various factors, including standing spin wave resonances18,30 -- 32, FMR re- sponse of magnetic domain structure33 -- 35, or magnetic phase separation. After transition of the Nb CPW into the superconduct- ing state, the transmission spectrum changes (compare Figs. 2a and b, Figs. 2c and d). While the spectrum at T < Tc consists of the same resonance lines as at T > Tc, superconductivity manifests itself in hysteresis of FMR peak absorption at µ0H < 0.2 T, which is best visi- ble for the C-line (compare S21(f ) at µ0H = 0.1 T and µ0H = −0.1 T in Fig. 2d): FMR absorption at nega- tively swept magnetic field (positive H in Figs. 2b,d) is substantially stronger than at positively swept magnetic field (negative H in Figs. 2b,d). In addition, at T < Tc a suppression of FMR response is observed at the low field region µ0H < 0.02 T. Below we will discuss the FMR response of YIG in absence of superconductivity, estab- lish causes for the split of FMR at µ0H < 4πMeff , and define the contribution of superconductivity to the FMR FIG. 1. Schematic illustration of the investigated system. YIG epitaxial film is grown on [111]-oriented single-crystal GGG substrate by means of LPE. A Nb CPW is fabricated directly on top of YIG film. The main direction of the CPW is indicated with the axis. Magnetic field H is applied out- of-plane, along [111] orientation of YIG/GGG (i.e., along z- direction). The FMR absorption measurements were performed using the so-called VNA-FMR approach25 -- 27 (VNA stands for the vector network analyzer). A schematic illustration of the investigated system is shown in Fig. 1. The single-crystalline epitaxial YIG film of thickness d = 51 nm was deposited on single-crystal [111]-oriented Gadolinium Gallium Garnet (GGG) substrate using the liquid phase epitaxy (LPE) technique. Details of LPE as well as room-temperature characteristics of LPE-grown ultra-thin YIG films can be found elsewhere23,28. Mea- surement of the FMR response in YIG was enabled by fabrication of a co-planar waveguide (CPW) directly on top of YIG film. The CPW was patterned out of 150 nm thick magnetron-sputtered niobium (Nb) thin film with superconducting critical temperature Tc (cid:39) 8.5 K using photo-lithography and plasma-chemical etching. Deposi- tion of Nb at room temperature was obstructed by poor adhesion of the metal film to the YIG surface, and there- fore, was performed at 300◦C. The 50 Ω impedance of the superconducting CPW was provided by its 27-40- 27 µm gap-center-gap dimensions. Direct placement of the CPW on the probed magnetic film and its elonga- tion via meandering enhance sensitivity to weak FMR absorptions29. The experimental chip was installed in a copper sample holder and wire bonded to a PCB with RF 3 FIG. 2. a) and b) Gray-scale-coded transmission spectra S21(µ0H, f )/S21(µ0H = 0.5 T, f ) measured at T = 10 K above Tc (a) and T = 2 K below Tc (b). c) and d) Corresponding frequency dependencies of the normalized transmission S21(f ) at several magnetic fields at T = 10 K (c) and T = 2 K (d). For curves in (c) and (d) the background was subtracted. At T < Tc the spectrum shows hysteresis of absorption. Magnetic field was swept negatively from +0.5 to -0.5 T (indicated with arrows), and, therefore, the part of spectra in (b) at positive fields provides the "down-field-sweep" data while the part of the spectrum at negative fields provides the "up-field-sweep" data. Labels C and G indicate higher- and lower-frequency spectral lines, respectively. spectrum. A. FMR at T > Tc. Magnetic properties of YIG film at cryogenic temperatures. Having analysed possible origins for the split of the FMR into the C-line and G-line in Fig. 2 we can state that neither domain structure nor spin waves can con- tribute to the FMR spectrum for our particular study. For instance, nucleation of magnetic domains upon de- magnetization at µ0H < 4πMeff occurs for thin films with strong perpendicular anisotropy in comparison with the demagnetizing energy36,37, i.e. when the magnetic quality parameter Q = Ku/2πM 2 s > 1, where Ku is the out-of-plane uniaxial anisotropy, and Ms is the satura- tion magnetization. However, a typical field of uniaxial anisotropy µ0HKu = 2Ku/Ms in LPE-grown YIG thin films ranges up to ∼ 200 Oe23,28,32,38 ensuring Q (cid:28) 1. The highest values of uniaxial anisotropy in YIG films µ0HKu ∼ 103 Oe that can be obtained in pulsed-laser- deposited films39 still ensure Q < 1. As an additional test, we have performed a magnetic force microscopy study of magnetic flux structure at the surface of the YIG film at 4 K using attocube attoDRY 1000 closed-cycle cryogenic microscope, supplied with a superconducting solenoid, and found no traces of domains or any field- dependent magnetic structure. Therefore, we confirm that formation of the domain structure does not occur. The magnetic state of the YIG film is single-domain, and variation of the out-of-plane component of magnetization at µ0H < 4πMeff occurs via rotation of the magnetiza- tion vector from out-of-plane orientation to in-plane. The absence of contribution of standing spin-wave res- onances to the FMR spectrum can be illustrated in the following way. At H = 0 the magnetization vector of 123456T = 10 K (a)Frequency f (GHz)0.910.930.950.970.991.011.031.05CGH sweep-0.4-0.3-0.2-0.10.00.10.20.30.4123456T = 2 K (b)Frequency f (GHz)Magnetic field H (T)0.910.930.950.970.991.011.031.05CGH sweep0.900.951.00GT = 10 K (c)Transmission S21 (abs) H=0.35 T H=0.326 T H=0.3 T H=0.1 TC1234560.940.960.981.00T = 2 K (d) H=0.35 T H=0.326 T H=0.1 T H=-0.1 TTransmission S21 (abs)Frequency f (GHz)GCa single-domain film is aligned in-plane. Therefore, the Kittel formula for FMR and dispersion relations for any spin-wave mode at H = 0 become applicable. When sev- eral resonances are observed, a contributing spin-wave mode can be identified by estimating a resonance fre- quency difference ∆fr between the Kittel mode and any standing spin-wave resonance mode. The latter appears due to quantization of the wavelength with geometrical parameters of a sample. The difference ∆fr is then com- pared with the experimentally observed one ∼ 1.3 GHz at H = 0 (Fig. 2). If an in-plane magnetostatic standing spin-wave mode40,41 is assumed, e.g., the backward vol- ume mode or the magnetostatic surface mode, its wave- length λ/2 for the standing mode should be quantized with dimensions of the CPW, i.e., λ/2 ∼ 20 − 40 µm. Such a standing spin-wave mode provides only marginal difference ∆fr (cid:46) 10 MHz due to a small ratio d/λ ∼ 10−3. Alternatively, if exchange-dominated perpendicu- lar standing spin-wave resonance42,43 is assumed the typ- ical exchange constant in YIG films32 ∼ 4 × 10−12 J/m provides ∆fr ∼ 2.5 GHz for d = λ/4 and ∆fr ∼ 7.5 GHz for d = λ/2. Thus, none of the possible standing spin- wave modes can provide ∆fr ∼ 1.3 GHz. Overall, when a standing spin-wave resonance is excited multiple con- sequential spectral lines are expected. FMR absorption for each line should decrease progressively with the mode number (see, for instance Ref.44). Such a picture is not observed in our experiment. Therefore, we confirm that several spectral lines in Fig. 2 at µ0H < 4πMs are not caused by standing spin-wave resonances. The remaining explanation for two FMR lines re- quires the existence of two resonating areas with differ- ent magnetic properties in the vicinity of the CPW. The magnetic structure is essentially single-domain in each area. The resonating areas can be identified by the cou- pling strength of microwaves to precessing magnetization that is proportional to the FMR amplitude and corre- lates directly with the amplitude of excitation AC mag- netic fields. In CPW geometry, AC magnetic fields are mainly focused in the vicinity of the central transmission line12,25. Therefore, geometry of the experiment (Fig. 1) suggests that the lower-frequency, weaker G-line origi- nates from YIG at gap areas of CPW where the coupling is weaker, while higher-frequency, stronger C-line appears due to FMR response of YIG area under the central con- ducting line of the CPW. The accuracy of that explana- tion is strengthened by additional features, as discussed below. the analytical For the case of the single-domain single-crystalline resonance curve fr(µ0H) YIG film, can be obtained in the entire H-range following Refs.38,45 -- 47 (we keep the notations given in Ref.38). The orientation of magnetization of a single-domain film at arbitrarily oriented magnetic field is defined by the minimum of free magnetostatic energy g = g(Ms, h, k1, k2, ku, θ, ψ, φh, φm), where k1, k2 and ku are unitless parameters of cubic magnetocrystalline anisotropy and out-of-plane uniaxial anisotropy, respec- 4 FIG. 3. Spherical coordinate system for the studied YIG film sample. Adopted from Ref.38. Direction of the CPW transmission line (see Fig. 1) is indicated with the red axis, which specifies additional in-plane uniaxial anisotropy due to CPW directionality . tively, h = µ0H/4πMs is the normalized external mag- netic field, and θ, ψ, φh, φm define the orientations of H and Ms with respect to principle crystallographic axes of YIG in spherical coordinates (see Fig. 3). In addition, the system in Fig. 1 has a distinct directionality along the ori- entation of the CPW. This directionality may contribute to the orientation of magnetization. We account for its possible contribution by an additional energy term ga added to the free magnetostatic energy g that provides a phenomenological in-plane uniaxial anisotropy of the first order. The term of the in-plane uniaxial anisotropy of the first order in the coordinates of Fig. 3 is ga = −ka1 sin(ψ)2 cos(φh − α)2. (1) FMR frequency is defined by derivatives at position of minimum of free energy45 -- 47 as fr ∼ γ(gψψgφmφm − g2 )1/2/ sin(ψ), ψφm (2) where γ is the gyromagnetic ratio. See Refs.38,45 -- 47 for details. Dotted data in Fig. 4a show the experimental fr(µ0H) resonance curves extracted from Fig. 2a. First, we focus on the G-line of the FMR spectrum. In order to fit the data, we have developed the following routine, which al- lowed us to obtain all magnetic parameters of g and fr, despite a large number of parameters and their partial interdependency. First, we note that when misalignment θ of orientation of magnetic field with the z-axis is small, and in-plane CPW uniaxial anisotropy ka1 is negligible, the linear part at µ0H (cid:29) 4πMeff can be fitted with the simplified expression38 fr = 2γMs(h − (1 − ku + 2k1/3 + 2k2/9)). (3) Fitting the data in the field range from 0.3 T to 0.4 T with Eq. 3, we obtain the gyromagnetic ratio γ/2π = [21 1 ] [111] [011 ] 𝐻 𝑀 𝜙h 𝜙m 𝛼 CPW 𝜃 𝜓 YIG GGG 5 the following parameters: 4πMs = 1876 Oe, k1 = −0.16, k2 = 0.18, ku = −0.12, θ = 1.4, φh = 126, ka1 = 0.025, and α = 177. Importantly, parameters of the cubic mag- netocrystalline anisotropy k1 and k2 are by a factor of 2-3 higher than typical values at room temperature23,38. This trend correlates well with the temperature depen- dence of the cubic magnetocrystalline anisotropy in YIG bulk single crystals48. After fitting the G-line, which corresponds to the FMR response of YIG areas at the CPW gaps, the only option to fit the C-line, which corresponds to the FMR response of YIG areas under the central CPW line, is to introduce an additional term into the energy g that represents the second order uniaxial anisotropy induced by the CPW. The term of the in-plane uniaxial anisotropy of the sec- ond order in the coordinates of Fig. 3 is ga = −(ka1 + 2ka2) sin(ψ)2 cos(φh − α)2 + +ka2 sin(ψ)4 cos(φh − α)4 (4) Using magnetic parameters obtained for the G-line, the fitting procedure for the C-line with the anisotropy given by Eq. 4 provides ka1 = 0.121 and ka2 = −0.048. This fit is shown in Fig. 4a with the blue curve. Possible origins of the CPW-induced anisotropy in- clude a distinct directionality of microwave currents. Also, directionality of the surface stress can be consid- ered that appears from differences in thermal expansion of narrow central transmission line of metal CPW and YIG/GGG oxides. The surface stress may appear either due to deposition of Nb film at elevated temperature or due to performance of experiments at cryogenic tempera- tures. For instance, the difference in thermal expansions between Nb and garnets can enable a strain in YIG at 2 K of up to ≈ +6× 10−4 along the CPW in case of absence of mechanical relaxation in Nb. In contrast, if a com- plete relaxation of tensions occurs in Nb at room tem- perature, the difference in thermal expansions enables the opposite-sign strain in YIG of ≈ −4 × 10−4. Both values of the strain are well comparable with the growth induced tensions provided by the lattice misfit between the GGG substrate and YIG film that induces the uniax- ial anisotropy in LPE-grown28 and PLD-grown films49,50. See the Appendix section for details. Importantly, pres- ence of both first- and second-order anisotropies suggests different mechanisms for their induction. Figure 4b shows dependencies of orientations of mag- netization ψ(µ0H) and φm(µ0H) for C- and G-FMR lines on magnetic field. A marginal difference between C- and G-curves in the entire field range indicates co-alignment of magnetization orientations at both gap and center areas of the CPW, implying that the entire volume of YIG that is subjected to the FMR remains in the single- domain state throughout the experiment. Our experimental setup does not allow us to study mi- crowave transmission at higher temperatures T (cid:38) 15 K. Therefore, temperature dependence of magnetic param- eters of YIG is not addressed in this report and can be found elsewhere22,23,51. FIG. 4. Fitting experimental fr(µ0H). (a) The dependence of the FMR frequencies on magnetic field. The CPW induces the uniaxial anisotropy of the 1st (G-line) and the 2nd order (C-line). Pictograms in (a) illustrate orientation of magne- tization relative to orientations of magnetic field and CPW axis at different magnetic fields. (b) The dependence of free- energy-minimum orientations of magnetization on magnetic field. The black dotted line indicates position of the kink in FMR curves. 2.985 GHz/kOe, which is close to the ratio for a free electron 2.803 GHz/kOe, and also the value of satura- tion magnetization in relation with anisotropy parame- ters 4πMeff = 4πMs×(1−ku +2k1/3+2k2/9) = 1975 Oe. Next we note that (i) the position of the kink at µ0H (cid:39) 0.22 T in the (fr, µ0H) plot is mostly determined by mis- alignment of the magnetic field with z-axis, i.e., by θ and φh; (ii) the position of the maximum of FMR frequency at µ0H (cid:39) 0.12 T in the (fr, µ0H) plot is mostly deter- mined by the magnetocrystalline anisotropy parameters k1 and k2; (iii) the slope of the resonance curve fr(µ0H) at H → 0 and the value fr(H = 0) are defined by the CPW-induced uniaxial anisotropy, i.e., by ka1 and α in Eq. 1. Using the least-squares method for optimization through steps (i) to (iii) and back, after several runs, (iv) the fit is further optimized by adjusting parameter ku. Following routines (i)-(iv) we have obtained an opti- mum fit of the G-line (see the red curve in Fig. 4a) with 012345CPW(a) Experimental data Fit for G-line. Fit for C-line.Resonance frequency fr (GHz)MCPWCPWHH>MeffMCPWCPWH0<H<MeffH=0HM0.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.35020406080(b) G-line C-lineSpherical coordinate (deg)Magnetic field H (T)140160180 mG-line mC-lineSpherical coordinate m (deg)B. FMR at T < Tc. Impact of the superconducting critical state. At T < Tc of Nb, in presence of superconductivity, the FMR absorption spectrum changes (see Fig. 2b). Since the Nb CPW is placed directly on top of the YIG film, all changes in absorptions in the C-branch can be at- tributed to the magnetization state under the Nb line. Therefore, the effect of superconductivity on the FMR can be tracked by analyzing the superconducting critical state of Nb film and its variation with applied magnetic field. Figure 5a shows the zero-field-cooled (ZFC) transmis- sion spectra that is acquired when the sample is cooled down to 2 K at zero magnetic field, and afterward S21 measurements were performed while sweeping magnetic field from 0 to 0.11 T. Figure 5b shows the field-cooled (FC) transmission spectra that is acquired when the sam- ple was cooled down to 2 K at µ0H = 0.25 T, and after- ward S21 measurements were performed while sweeping magnetic field back from 0.11 T down to 0. The hystere- sis in peak absorption can be tracked by fitting S21(f ) curves at each value of H and plotting dependencies of FMR amplitude I on magnetic field H (Fig. 5c). I(µ0H) dependency is caused by variation of the CPW-FMR cou- pling strength with magnetic field, i.e., by variation of magnetization and magnetic flux inhomogeneity in the YIG induced by the Nb superconducting critical state. Note that no hysteresis in peak absorption is observed at T > Tc (Figs. 2a and 5c), where the transmission spectra is fully reversible and independent of the ZFC/FC initial state. First we discuss the ZFC curve in Fig. 5c, where three intervals in I(µ0H) can be distinguished. At low fields, the strongest FMR absorption is observed with I ∼ 0.1 at µ0H up to 2× 10−3 T (highlighted with the red circle in Fig. 5a). This corresponds to the Meissner state of the Nb line when the Meissner screening currents circulate at the edges of the Nb film and exclude magnetic flux from its cross-section. In the Meissner state, DC magnetic flux remains homogeneous across the Nb line and en- sures a strong coupling of the CPW to the YIG at FMR. At intermediate fields 2 × 10−3 < µ0H < 10−2 T, the FMR absorption drops rapidly from I ∼ 0.1 to the min- imum I ∼ 0.02, caused by the partially penetrated su- perconducting critical state where superconducting vor- tices start to penetrate Nb film. The magnetic flux pro- file in partially penetrated superconducting films is the most inhomogeneous52 -- 54, which causes a weak coupling of the FMR to the CPW and low absorption intensity. The partially penetrated state commences at the flux- focus enhanced first critical field of the superconducting film µ0Hc1 ∼ 2 × 10−3 T, where the first Abrikosov vor- tices start to penetrate into the film, and terminates at the magnetic field of full penetration 10−2 T. At high fields µ0H > 0.01 T, after full penetration is reached, magnetic flux in the superconducting film forms a con- stant gradient that can be depicted by the Bean critical 6 5. transmission Gray-scale-coded FIG. spectra S21(µ0H, f )/S21(µ0H = 0.5 T, f ) measured at 2 K starting from ZFC state (a) and FC state (b). C and G spectral lines are indicated. Red circle in (a) highlights FMR absorption in the Meissner state of the CPW. c) Dependen- cies of resonance peak absorption for C-lines on magnetic field I(µ0H) obtained at 2 K and 10 K. Direction of magnetic field sweep is indicated with arrows. The µ0H axis is given on a log scale. Field regions for three superconducting states of Nb at ZFC curve in (c) are separated with blue dashed lines. state model55 -- 58. The gradient is formed due to pin- ning of vortices and induces a homogeneous circulating 1234ZFC (a)Frequency f (GHz)0.900.920.940.960.981.00H sweepCG1234FC (b)Frequency f (GHz)H sweep0.900.920.940.960.981.00CG10-310-210-10246810Fully penetratedBean statePartially penetratedstate ZFC, 2K FC, 2K ZFC, 10K FC, 10K(c)FMR absorption intensity I (10-2 abs)Magnetic field H (T)ZFCZFCFCFCMeissnerstatecritical currents. Upon increasing magnetic field, both the pinning of vortices and the slope of magnetic flux reduce57,58 making magnetic flux in YIG more homoge- nous. A smaller gradient of the magnetic flux in the superconductor increases the coupling that we observe in gradual increase of the FMR peak absorption upon increasing magnetic field from 0.01 T to higher fields. Note that such nonmonotonic behavior of I(µ0H) is not observed for the G-line (Fig. 5a), which indicates addi- tionally that the absorption at G-line is caused by the FMR at the gap areas of the CPW, where the influence of the superconducting state of Nb is marginal. Increasing magnetic field further beyond the field range in Fig. 5, the ZFC curve should coincide with the FC curve at the so-called irreversibility field58 -- 60, where pin- ning of vortices becomes negligible. The FC curve in Fig. 5 consists of two parts. For µ0H > 0.03 T the coupling remains by a factor of ∼ 2 higher than one for the ZFC curve. This difference is attributed to the fact that upon decreasing magnetic field, the Bean crit- ical currents counter-act the Meissner currents, diamag- netic response of the superconducting film is reduced as compared to the ZFC measurement60, and the influence on YIG at the FMR decreases. Below 0.03 T, I drops rapidly, which can be explained by a gradual formation of a complex remanent critical state at H = 0 with highly nonuniformly distributed frozen magnetic flux. Also at low magnetic fields, magnetization of individual Abrikosov vortices may contribute to YIG inhomogene- ity by inducing substantial local magnetic fields of up to µ0Hv ∼ Φ0/πλ2 L ∼ 0.06 T, where Φ0 is the magnetic flux quantum and λL ∼ 10−7 m is the typical London penetration depth in Nb films. Overall, the influence of the superconducting critical state in our geometry on the FMR appears to be destruc- tive. The FMR intensity for both ZFC and FC curves remains below values of I at T > Tc (Fig. 5c). However, magnetic hysteresis often is employed in magnetic logic devices. Also, in vicinity to H = 0, FMR is substan- tially stronger when superconductor is in the Meissner state than for normal metal CPW. This effect may be a result of interaction of magnetic moments in YIG with Meissner screening currents in the ideal diamagnet. IV. CONCLUSION In conclusion, ferromagnetic resonance of YIG film is studied in out-of-plane magnetic fields and cryogenic temperatures using a superconducting coplanar waveg- uide that is fabricated directly on top of the magnetic film (see Fig. 1). FMR absorption spectra are obtained in a wide field range. Nonlinear dependence of the FMR frequency on magnetic field at low field values, below the field of saturation magnetization, showed a split of res- onance into two spectral lines, which were identified as the FMR response of YIG at gap areas of the CPW and of YIG located directly under the central conducting line 7 of the CPW. A routine was developed for fitting the FMR lines. This routine allowed us to obtain all magnetic param- eters of YIG, i.e., the saturation magnetization, the gy- romagnetic ratio, and parameters of magnetocrystalline and out-of-plane uniaxial anisotropies. In addition, the fitting routine has issued the misalignment angle of 1.4◦ between magnetic field and the out-of-plane orientation, as well as parameters of in-plane magnetic anisotropy of the first and the second order, which are induced by the CPW. The FMR spectrum at temperatures below the super- conducting critical temperature of the waveguide showed a hysteresis in FMR peak absorption. The hysteresis is explained by influence of magnetization of the Nb trans- mission line in the superconducting critical state. Track- ing the dependence of the intensity of the FMR on mag- netic field allowed us to identify all fundamental states of a superconducting film in out-of-plane magnetic field, i.e., the Meissner state, the partially penetrated state, and the fully penetrated Bean critical state. Also, it al- lowed explanation the hysteresis in the FMR absorption by the pinning of magnetic vortices, which induces the gradient of magnetic flux in superconducting films. The gradient is controlled by direction of the magnetic field sweep. In general, this report suggests that development of magnonics at cryogenic temperatures may be beneficial due to: (i) substantially different properties of magnetic materials, including magneto-crystalline anisotropy, (ii) the possibility to engineer additional anisotropies with metal structures, and (iii) the potential to affect the spec- tra by hybridization of a magnonic media with supercon- ductors. As a final remark we would like to point out a related work by Jeon et al. on the effect of the supercon- ducting critical state on magnetization dynamics in thick superconductor/ferromagnet/superconductor trilayers61. V. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors acknowledge Lucas Radtke and Yannick Schoen for assistance with sample preparation and ini- tial measurements and Paul Baity for critical reading of the manuscript. This work was supported by the Euro- pean Research Council (ERC) under the Grant Agree- ment 648011, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) within Project INST 121384/138-1 FUGG. C.D. thanks the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft for financial sup- port under contract number DFG DU 1427/2-1. I.A.G. acknowledges support by the German Academic Ex- change Service (DAAD) via the program "Research Stays for University Academics and Scientists 2017". I.A.G., N.N.A., V.V.R., and A.V.U. acknowledge the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation (Re- search Project K2-2018-015 in the framework of the In- crease Competitiveness Program of NUST MISiS) for support in microwave measurements. V.S.S., I.A.G., and D.S.B. acknowledge the Russian Science Foundation (RSF) (Project No. 18-72-10118) for support in numer- ical analysis and MFM investigations. V.V.R. acknowl- edges a partial support by the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (RFBR) (Project No. 19-02-00316). VI. APPENDIX: STRESS INDUCED IN YIG BY NB CPW FIG. 6. Dependencies of the thermal expansion coefficient on temperature α(T ) for Nb, YIG and GGG. One possible cause of the CPW induced anisotropy that is derived in Sec. IIIA is the stress in YIG that is forced by differences in thermal expansion of the narrow extended central transmission line of the metal CPW and YIG/GGG oxides. Assuming that an unstressed continu- ous interface is formed between Nb and YIG during depo- sition of Nb at the deposition temperature Td ≈ 600 K, the stress at the interface at the measurement temper- ature Tm = 2 K can be estimated with the following expression (cid:90) Tm Td σ ≈ E 1 − ν = E 1 − ν [αG(T ) − αNb(T )]dT, (5) where σ is the stress in YIG, E = 2 × 1012 dyne/cm2 is the Young's modulus of YIG at the temperature range from 0 to 300 K62, ν = 0.29 is the Poisson's ratio, is 8 the strain at the interface at Tm due to the difference in thermal expansion, αG(T ) and αNb(T ) are temperature dependencies of the linear thermal expansion of the gar- net and Nb, respectively. Importantly, the stress in Eq. 5 implies absence of mechanical relaxation. However, estimation of the stress at the Nb/YIG inter- face using Eq. 5 is impeded. While thermo-mechanical properties of Nb are well studied in a wide tempera- ture range63 from ≈ 0 K up to about the melting point, a consistent study of thermo-mechanical properties of YIG is not available for the required temperature range. The coefficient αG(T ) for YIG is available piecewise and can be obtained by interpolation of αG(T ) at temper- atures above64,65 and below66 the room temperature. On the other side, the coefficient αG(T ) for YIG can be substituted with one for GGG since their thermo- mechanical properties are almost identical64,65. The co- efficient αG(T ) for GGG is reported for several temper- ature ranges separately: room temperature and higher temperature data is available in Refs.64,65, αG(T ) at low temperatures is reported in Ref.67 for the range from 6 K to 300 K and in Ref.68 for the range from 80 K to 330 K. Figure 6 shows dependencies of the thermal expansion on temperature α(T ). The red curve shows αNb(T ) for Nb that is calculated using Ref.63. The blue curve shows αG(T ) for YIG that is calculated using Refs.64,66. Black dashed and dotted curves show αG(T ) for GGG that are calculated using Ref.64 and Ref.68, respectively. Solid black curve shows linear interpolation between lower- temperature and higher-temperature curves αG(T ) for GGG at the range from 180 K up to 330 K. The inter- polated dependence for αG(T ) is used for calculations. Calculations with Eq. 5 and coefficients α(T ) in Fig. 6 provide the strain at YIG/Nb interface ≈ +6.4 × 10−4 that produces a compressive stress σ ∼ 109 dyne/cm2. Note however, that if the room-temperature deposition of Nb takes place, or the strain in Nb relaxes at room tem- perature, according to Eq. 5 and Fig. 6 an opposite-sign strain ≈ −4 × 10−5 emerges at cryogenic temperature Tm. If the data for GGG is used instead of YIG, the integral in Eq. 5 provides approximately the same strain ≈ +5.6×10−4 at the interface with unrelaxed Nb, and a larger opposite-sign strain ≈ −4× 10−4 at the interface with the room-T deposited or relaxed Nb. These values are well comparable with the growth induced tensions provided by the lattice misfit between the GGG substrate and the YIG film that induces the uniaxial anisotropy in LPE-grown28 and PLD-grown49,50 films. 1 B. Lenk, H. Ulrichs, F. Garbs, and M. Munzenberg, "The building blocks of magnonics," Phys. Rep. 507, 107 (2011). 2 A. V. Chumak, V. I. Vasyuchka, A. A. Serga, and B. Hille- brands, "Magnon spintronics," Nat. Phys. 11, 453 (2015). 3 Y. Kajiwara, K. Harii, S. Takahashi, J. Ohe, K. Uchida, M. Mizuguchi, H. Umezawa, H. Kawai, K. Ando, K. Takanashi, S. Maekawa, and E. Saitoh, "Transmis- sion of electrical signals by spin-wave interconversion in a magnetic insulator," Nature 464, 262 (2010). 4 Special Issue on Magnonics, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 50 (2017). 5 S. O. Demokritov and A. N. Slavin, eds., Magnonics: From Fundamentals to Applications (Springer-Verlag Berlin Hei- delberg, 2013). 010020030040050060002x10-64x10-66x10-68x10-61x10-5Coefficinet of linear thermal expansion Temperature T (K) Nb, Ref. 62 YIG, Ref. 63, 65 GGG, Ref. 63 GGG, Ref. 67 GGG, interpolation6 M. Evelt, L. Soumah, A.B. Rinkevich, S.O. Demokritov, A. Anane, V. Cros, Jamal Ben Youssef, G. de Loubens, O. Klein, P. Bortolotti, and V.E. Demidov, "Emission of coherent propagating magnons by insulator-based spin- orbit-torque oscillators," Phys. Rev. Appl. 10, 041002 (2018). 7 H. Huebl, C. W. Zollitsch, J. Lotze, F. Hocke, M. Greifen- and S. T. B. Goennenwein, stein, A. Marx, R. Gross, "High cooperativity in coupled microwave resonator ferri- magnetic insulator hybrids," Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 127003 (2013). 8 Y. Tabuchi, S. Ishino, T. Ishikawa, R. Yamazaki, K. Usami, and Y. Nakamura, "Hybridizing ferromagnetic magnons and microwave photons in the quantum limit," Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 083603 (2014). 9 X. Zhang, C.-L. Zou, L. Jiang, and H. X. Tang, "Strongly coupled magnons and cavity microwave photons," Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 156401 (2014). 10 R. G. E. Morris, A. F. van Loo, S. Kosen, and A. D. Karenowska, "Strong coupling of magnons in a YIG sphere to photons in a planar superconducting resonator in the quantum limit," Sci. Rep. 7, 11511 (2017). 11 Marco Pfirrmann, Isabella Boventer, Andre Schneider, Tim Wolzand Mathias Klaui, Alexey V. Ustinov, and Martin Weides, "Magnons at low excitations: Observa- tion of incoherent coupling to a bath of two-level-systems," (2019), arXiv:1903.03981. 12 I. A. Golovchanskiy, N. N. Abramov, V. S. Stolyarov, I. V. Shchetinin, P. S. Dzhumaev, A. S. Averkin, S. N. Kozlov, A. A. Golubov, V. V. Ryazanov, and A. V. Ustinov, "Probing dynamics of micro-magnets with multi- mode superconducting resonator," J. Appl. Phys. 123, 173904 (2018). 13 S. E. Barnes, M. Aprili, I. Petkovic, and S. Maekawa, "Ferromagnetic resonance with a magnetic josephson junc- tion," Supercond. Sci. Technol. 24, 024020 (2011). 14 S. Mai, E. Kandelaki, A. F. Volkov, and K. B. Efetov, "In- teraction of josephson and magnetic oscillations in joseph- son tunnel junctions with a ferromagnetic layer," Phys. Rev. B 84, 144519 (2011). 15 I. A. Golovchanskiy, N. N. Abramov, V. S. Stolyarov, O. V. Emelyanova, A. A. Golubov, A. V. Ustinov, and V. V. Ryazanov, "Ferromagnetic resonance with long josephson junction," Supercond. Sci. Technol. 30, 054005 (2017). 16 B.M. Lebed and S.V. Yzkovlev, "Dispersion of surface spin waves in a layered superconductor-ferrite structure," Pis'ma v ZhTF (in Russian) 15(14), 27 (1989). 17 V. B. Anfinogenov, Y. V. Gulyaev, P. E. Zilberman, I. M. Kotelyanskiy, N. I. Polzikova, and A. A. Suhanov, "Obser- vation of the electronic absorption of magnetostatic waves in a ferrite - high temperature superconductor structure," Pis'ma v ZhTF (in Russian) 15(19), 24 (1989). 18 I. A. Golovchanskiy, N. N. Abramov, V. S. Stolyarov, V. V. Bolginov, V. V. Ryazanov, A. A. Golubov, and A. V. Ustinov, "Ferromagnet/superconductor hybridization for magnonic applications," Adv. Func. Mater. 28, 1802375 (2018). 19 I. A. Golovchanskiy, N. N. Abramov, V. S. Stolyarov, V. V. Ryazanov, A. A. Golubov, and A. V. Ustinov, "Modified dispersion law for spin waves coupled to a superconduc- tor," J. Appl. Phys. 124, 233903 (2018). 20 O. V. Dobrovolskiy, R. Sachser, T. Bracher, T. Bottcher, V. V. Kruglyak, R. V. Vovk, V. A. Shklovskij, M. Huth, B. Hillebrands, and A. V. Chumak, "Magnon-fluxon in- 9 teraction in a ferromagnet/superconductor heterostruc- ture," Nature Physics , doi.org/10.1038/s41567 -- 019 -- 0428 -- 5 (2019). 21 A. Pimenov, A. Loidl, P. Przyslupski, and B. Dabrowski, "Negative refraction in ferromagnet-superconductor super- lattices," Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 247009 (2005). 22 M. Haidar, M. Ranjbar, M. Balinsky, R. K. Du- and J. Akerman, "Thickness- and mas, S. Khartsev, temperature-dependent magnetodynamic properties of yt- trium iron garnet thin films," J. Appl. Phys. 117, 17D119 (2015). 23 N. Beaulieu, N. Kervarec, N. Thiery, O. Klein, V. Nale- tov, H. Hurdequint, G. de Loubens, J. B. Youssef, and N. Vukadinovic, "Temperature dependence of magnetic properties of a ultrathin yttrium-iron garnet film grown by liquid phase epitaxy: Effect of a Pt overlayer," IEEE Magnetics Letters 9, 3706005 (2018). 24 I. Boventer, M. Pfirrmann, J. Krause, Y. Schon, M. Klaui, and M. Weides, "Complex temperature dependence of cou- pling and dissipation of cavity magnon polaritons from mil- likelvin to room temperature," Phys. Rev. B 97, 184420 (2018). 25 I. Neudecker, G. Woltersdorf, B. Heinrich, T. Okuno, G. Gubbiotti, and C.H. Back, "Comparison of frequency, field, and time domain ferromagnetic resonance methods," J. Magn. Magn. Mat. 307, 148 (2006). 26 S. S. Kalarickal, P. Krivosik, M. Wu, C. E. Patton, M. L. Schneider, P. Kabos, T. J. Silva, and J. P. Nibarger, "Ferromagnetic resonance linewidth in metallic thin films: Comparison of measurement methods," J. Appl. Phys. 99, 093909 (2006). 27 Y.-C. Chen, D.-S. Hung, Y.-D. Yao, S.-F. Lee, H.-P. Ji, and C. Yu, "Ferromagnetic resonance study of thickness- dependent magnetization precession in Ni80Fe20 films," J. Appl. Phys. 101, 09C104 (2007). 28 C. Dubs, O. Surzhenko, R. Linke, A. Danilewsky, U. Bruckner, and Jan Dellith, "Sub-micrometer yttrium iron garnet LPE films with low ferromagnetic resonance losses," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 50, 204005 (2017). 29 I. A. Golovchanskiy, V. V. Bolginov, N. N. Abramov, V. S. Stolyarov, A. Ben Hamida, V. I. Chichkov, D. Roditchev, and V. V. Ryazanov, "Magnetization dynamics in dilute Pd1−xFex thin films and patterned microstructures con- sidered for superconducting electronics," J. Appl. Phys. 120, 163902 (2016). 30 C. Kittel, "On the theory of ferromagnetic resonance ab- sorption," Phys. Rev 73, 155 (1948). 31 Y. V. Khivintsev, L. Reisman, J. Lovejoy, R. Adam, C. M. Schneider, R. E. Camley, and Z. J. Celinski, "Spin wave resonance excitation in ferromagnetic films using planar waveguide structures," J. Appl. Phys. 108, 023907 (2010). 32 S. Klingler, A. V. Chumak, T. Mewes, B. Khodadadi, C. Mewes, C. Dubs, O. Surzhenko, B. Hillebrands, and A. Conca, "Measurements of the exchange stiffness of YIG films using broadband ferromagnetic resonance tech- niques," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 48, 015001 (2015). 33 J. O. Artman and S. H. Charap, "Ferromagnetic resonance in periodic domain structures," J. Appl. Phys. 49, 1587 (1978). 34 M. Ramesh and P. E. Wigen, "Ferromagnetodynamics of parallel stripe domains - domain walls system," J. Mag. Mag. Mater. 74, 123 (1988). 35 I. S. Camara, S. Tacchi, L-. C. Garnier, M. Eddrief, F. For- tuna, G. Carlotti, and M. Marangolo, "Magnetization dy- namics of weak stripe domains in Fe-N thin films: a multi- technique complementary approach," J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 29, 465803 (2017). 36 T. G. W. Blake, C.-C. Shir, Y.-0 Tu, and E. D. Torre, "Effects of finite anisotropy parameter Q in the deter- mination of magnetic bubble material parameters," IEEE Trans. Magn. 18, 985 (1982). 37 F. Virot, L. Favre, R. Hayn, and M. D. Kuz'min, "Theory of magnetic domains in uniaxial thin films," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 45, 405003 (2012). 38 S. Lee, S. Grudichak, J. Sklenar, C. C. Tsai, M. Jang, Q. Yang, H. Zhang, and J. B. Ketterson, "Ferromagnetic resonance of a YIG film in the low frequency regime," J. Appl. Phys. 120, 033905 (2016). 39 S. A. Manuilov, S. I. Khartsev, and A. M. Grishin, "Pulsed laser deposited Y3Fe5O12 films: Nature of mag- netic anisotropy I," J. Appl. Phys. 106, 123917 (2009). 40 D. Stancil, Theory of Magnetostatic Waves (Springer- Verlag New York, Inc., 1993). 41 A. A. Serga, A. V. Chumak, and B. Hillebrands, "YIG magnonics," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 43, 264002 (2010). 42 C. Kittel, "Excitation of spin waves in a ferromagnet by a uniform rf field," Phys. Rev. 100, 1295 (1958). 43 M. H. Seavey and P. E. Tannenwald, "Direct observation of spin wave resonance," J. Appl. Phys. 30, S227 (1959). 44 S. A. Bunyaev, V. O. Golub, O. Yu. Salyuk, E. V. Tartakovskaya, N. M. Santos, A. A. Timopheev, N. A. Sobolev, A. A. Serga, A. V. Chumak, B. Hillebrands, and G. N. Kakazei, "Splitting of standing spin-wave modes in circular submicron ferromagnetic dot under axial symme- try violation," Sci. Rep. 5, 18480 (2015). 45 J. Smit and H. G. Beljers, "Ferromagnetic resonance ab- sorption in BaFe12O19 highly anisotropic crystal," Philips Res. Rep. 10, 113 (1955). 46 H. Suhl, "Ferromagnetic resonance in nickel ferrite between one and two kilomegacycles," Phys. Rev. 97, 555 (1955). 47 S. M. Rezende, J. A. S. Moura, F. M. de Aguiar, and W. H. Schreiner, "Ferromagnetic resonance of Fe(111) thin films and Fe(111)/Cu(111) multilayers," Phys. Rev. B 49, 15105 (1994). 48 P. Hansen, "Anisotropy and magnetostriction of gallium- substituted yttrium iron garnet," J. Appl. Phys. 45, 3638 (1974). 49 Brandon M. Howe, Satoru Emori, Hyung-Min Jeon, Trevor M. Oxholm, John G. Jones, Krishnamurthy Ma- halingam, Yan Zhuang, Nian X. Sun, and Gail J. Brown, "Pseudomorphic yttrium iron garnet thin films with low damping and inhomogeneous linewidth broadening," IEEE Magnetics Letters 6, 3500504 (2015). 50 Biswanath Bhoi, Bosung Kim, Yongsub Kim, Min-Kwan and Sang-Koog Kim, "Stress- Kim, Jae-Hyeok Lee, induced magnetic properties of PLD-grown high-quality ultrathin YIG films," J. Appl. Phys. 123, 203902 (2018). 51 H. Maier-Flaig, S. Klingler, C. Dubs, O. Surzhenko, R. Gross, M. Weiler, H. Huebl, and S. T. B. Goen- nenwein, "Temperature-dependent magnetic damping of yttrium iron garnet spheres," Phys. Rev. B 95, 214423 (2017). 52 Ch. Jooss, J. Albrecht, H. Kuhn, S. Leonhardt, and H. Kronmuller, "Magneto-optical studies of current dis- tributions in high-Tc superconductors," Rep. Prog. Phys. 10 65, 651 (2001). 53 F. S. Wells, A. V. Pan, S. Wilson, I. A. Golovchanskiy, S. A. Fedoseev, and A. Rozenfeld, "Dynamic magneto- optical imaging of superconducting thin films," Supercond. Sci. Technol. 29, 035014 (2016). 54 F. S. Wells, A. V. Pan, I. A. Golovchanskiy, S. A. Fedoseev, and A. Rozenfeld, "Observation of transient overcritical currents in YBCO thin films using high-speed magneto- optical imaging and dynamic current mapping," Sci. Rep. 7, 40235 (2017). 55 C. P. Bean, "Magnetization of high-field superconductors," Rev. Mod. Phys. 36, 31 (1964). 56 W. T. Norris, "Calculation of hysteresis losses in hard su- perconductors carrying ac: isolated conductors and edges of thin sheets," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 3, 489 (1969). 57 D.-X. Chen and R. B. Goldfarb, "Kim model for magne- tization of type-II superconductors," J. Appl. Phys. 66, 2489 (1989). 58 I. A. Golovchanskiy, A. V. Pan, O. V. Shcherbakova, and S. A. Fedoseev, "Rectifying differences in transport, dy- namic, and quasi-equilibrium measurements of critical cur- rent density," J. Appl. Phys. 114, 163910 (2013). 59 M. Tinkham, "Resistive transition of high-temperature su- perconductors," Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 1658 (1988). 60 I. A. Golovchanskiy, A. V. Pan, J. George, F. S. Wells, S. A. Fedoseev, and A. Rozenfeld, "Vibration effect on magnetization and critical current density of superconduc- tors," Supercond. Sci. Technol. 29, 075002 (2016). 61 K. Jeon, C. Ciccarelli, H. Kurebayashi, L. F. Cohen, X. Montiel, M. Eschrig, T. Wagner, S. Komori, A. Sri- vastava, J. W. A. Robinson, and M. G. Blamire, "Effect of meissner screening and trapped magnetic flux on mag- netization dynamics in thick Nb/Ni80Fe20/Nb trilayers," Phys. Rev. Appl. 11, 014061 (2019). 62 D. F. Gibbons and V. G. Chirba, "Acoustical loss and young's modulus of yttrium iron garnet," Phys. Rev. 110, 770 (1958). 63 Kai Wang and Robert R. Reeber, "The role of defects on thermophysical properties: Thermal expansion of V, Nb, Ta, Mo and W," Materials Science and Engineering R23, 101 (1998). 64 S. Geller, G. P. Espinosa, and P. B. Crandall, "Thermal expansion of yttrium and gadolinium iron, gallium and alu- minum garnets," Jr. Appl. Cryst. 2, 86 (1969). 65 Rui sheng Liang and Feng chao Liu, "Measurement of ther- mal expansion coeffiecient of substrate GGG and its epi- taxial layer YIG," Powder Diffraction 14, 2 (1999). 66 H. J. Levinstein, E. M. Gyorgy, and R. C. LeCraw, "Ther- mal expansion of YIG and YIG with Mn and Si additions," J. Appl. Phys. 37, 2197 (1966). 67 A. M. Antyukhov, A. A. Sidorov, I. A. Ivanov, and A. V. Antonov, "Thermal expansion coefficients of crystals of certain garnets over the range 6-310 K," Inorg. Mater. (Translated from Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Neorg. Mater.) 23, 702 (1987). 68 Tso Yee Fan, Daniel J. Ripin, Roshan L. Aggar- wal, Juan R. Ochoa, Bien Chann, Michael Tilleman, and Joshua Spitzberg, "Cryogenic Yb3+-doped solid-state lasers," IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Elec- tronics 13, 448 (2007).
1810.05978	1	1810	2018-10-14T05:40:31	Analytical, numerical and experimental investigation of a tunable, nonlinear multi-degree-of-freedom parametrically excited amplifier	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	A tunable, multi-degree-of-freedom, parametrically excited amplifier is introduced as an apparatus capable of shifting slow, weak signals to higher frequencies, by exploiting the amplifier natural resonances via controlled parametric excitation and nonlinear feedback. This device can find use as a signal amplifier and as a spectrum control device. A tuned dual-frequency signal is created to parametrically excite (pump) the system and produce the desired energy shift. The pump signal is applied by a controlled electromechanical actuator, and is modified in-situ according to the slow frequency signal and the desired response. A three DOF model is introduced, and the governing nonlinear EOM are derived and solved analytically via asymptotic methods and verified with numerical simulations. A parametric design of an experimental rig was carried out, and the importance of experimental calibration and system identification is emphasized. Some preliminary experimental results are provided with favorable agreement with the theory.	physics.app-ph	physics	Analytical, numerical and experimental investigation of a tunable, nonlinear multi-degree-of-freedom parametrically excited amplifier A. Dolev1, I. Bucher1 1 Dynamics Laboratory, Mechanical Engineering, Technion Technion City, Haifa 3200003, Israel e-mail: [email protected] Abstract A tunable, multi-degree-of-freedom, parametrically excited amplifier is introduced as an apparatus capable of shifting slow, weak signals to higher frequencies, by exploiting the amplifier natural resonances via controlled parametric excitation and nonlinear feedback. This device can find use as a signal amplifier and as a spectrum control device. A tuned dual-frequency signal is created to parametrically excite (pump) the system and produce the desired energy shift. The pump signal is applied by a controlled electromechanical actuator, and is modified in-situ according to the slow frequency signal and the desired response. A three DOF model is introduced, and the governing nonlinear EOM are derived and solved analytically via asymptotic methods and verified with numerical simulations. A parametric design of an experimental rig was carried out, and the importance of experimental calibration and system identification is emphasized. Some preliminary experimental results are provided with favorable agreement with the theory. 1 Introduction The phenomenon of parametric resonance [1,2] in mechanical systems has been studied extensively in the past [3 -- 5], and in recent times has gained renewed interest by researchers, due to technological advances especially in the field of nano- and micro-electro mechanical systems. Parametric resonance is utilized in mechanical system to create parametric resonators, which are used in sensing [6,7], actuation [8] and filtering [9] applications. These resonators are superior to linear ones in terms of amplification and sensitivity. While the parametric amplifier response is bounded by nonlinearities [10], the time-invariant realizations are bounded by nonlinear stiffness and damping [11]. Although the parametric resonance has found use in some mechanical applications, it may also have devastating effects in some cases, such in the case of ship instability [12] or sheet metal coating [13], therefore should be avoided in many instances. Parametric resonators can be roughly divided according to their operating mode. Degenerate resonators are parametrically excited (pumped), by a frequency that equals to twice the response frequency, usually close to twice the natural frequency. On the other hand, non-degenerate resonators are not bound to be pumped according to the previously mentioned ratio [14], and some exploit a combination of frequencies, making them more versatile and potentially tunable. The present work extends a previous work [15] in the field of tunable, nonlinear parametrically excited amplifiers, from a single-degree-of-freedom (SDOF) to multi-degree-of-freedom (MDOF) amplifiers. In the previous work, two operating modes, degenerate and non-degenerate, were utilized simultaneously to drive an electromechanical actuator forming a new operating mode. In this mode, the amplifier is pumped with a dual-frequency signal, thus creating a dual-frequency parametric amplifier (DFPA). The DFPA exploits the advantages of both operating modes, large response amplitude and tunability, making it suitable for a wide band of input signals whose frequency is much lower than the DFPA natural frequency. Exploiting the amplifier resonance, energy is transferred from a slow and weak input to a signal with a larger amplitude and a higher frequency, close to the natural frequency of the amplifier. Extension of the work to a MDOF DFPA allows more flexibility and tunability, at the expanse of increased complexity. Energy can be transferred to each of the DFPA natural frequencies, and the projection of the external force on the natural mode being excited can be evaluated. Figure 1: A lightly damped MDOF system with a tunable, nonlinear and time varying stiffness s(t). In the first section of this paper, analytical model of nonlinear MDOF parametric amplifiers and their response is formulated alongside a brief mathematical explanation. Then, numerical simulations are used to verify the proposed analytical model. Next, the experimental set-up is introduced, flowed by a brief explanation of the system calibration and identification procedure. Afterwards, preliminary experimental results are provided and compared to the analytical solution and numerical simulations. Finally, insights and some small discrepancies between the results are discussed. 2 Mathematical derivation and solutions of the EOM In this section, the model of a MDOF DFPA is introduced alongside the governing equations of motion (EOM). First, the dimensional nonlinear EOM are derived using Hamilton's principle. Then, using several transformations and definition of new parameters, the scaled EOM in modal coordinates are derived, in a form suitable for solution using asymptotic methods. The analytical solution is derived with the method of multiple scales [16]. 2.1 Derivation of the scaled, nonlinear, modal EOM In this section, a tunable, nonlinear parametrically excited amplifier having three DOF is investigated as a representative case of a MDOF parametric amplifier. The system's model is depicted in Figure 1, and it is . characterized be particle mases , and time varying stiffness , linear dashpots , linear stiffness Additionally the system is subjected to two external harmonic forces and . It proves convenient to define two new coordinates (see Figure 1): . (1) Using Hamilton's principle, the EOM of the system in Figure 1 are derived: . (2) Where is a cubic stiffness parameter and is defined as follows: mckst1ft2ft,uyxvxz312331113122222000000000000000f00000000fipmmmxcxkxxmmucuktusummvcvkvv3spkt . (3) Here two distinct, though algebraically related, pumping frequencies are used and , and the appropriate pumping magnitudes and phases are and , . It proves convenient to use the undumped linear system normal modes to transform the coordinates, hence the normal modes of the following system were computed: The modal matrix, containing the normal modes of the system is defined as follows: Next, the following transformation is used: . Here is some measure of the modal damping and is assumed small: , (4) (5) (6) (7) and is to be determined later, when the problem's various magnitudes' scaling is analyzed. Substituting Eq.(6) to Eq.(4) and multiplying it by modal coordinates: from the left, leads to the following EOM in (8) Here are the modal damping coefficients and are the natural frequencies. Dimensionless time is now introduce in the following form: , where is the characteristic frequency of the response, and , such that: . Substituting Eq.(9) and Eq.(10) to Eq.(8) and dividing by leads to the following EOM: (9) (10) , (11) 11coscospaaabbbktkttab,ab12311122200000,000immmkxmmkummkvqq0q123Φ~OqΦη01TΦ322112233312000000000,00,00,0000000000cos00,cos000TTTnnnaaabbbtsttktIηζΩηΩηΦKΦηΦSΦηΦQζΩSK,1,2,3iit~O,~1O2232222222212311120000,00TTTIηζχηχηΦKΦηΦSΦηΦQχwhere . Equation (11) is rewritten in the following form: . (12) Where light damping, weak pumping and weak nonlinearity are assumed: , (13) the coefficients matrix provided in Appendix A. and the vector consisting of nonlinear modal coordinates combinations, are 2.2 Solution of the scaled, nonlinear, modal EOM To derive the analytical solution of the governing EOM, an asymptotic method was used, the method of multiple scales, where the following solution form was assumed: (14) The latter has two spatial scales and and two time scales . Substituting Eq.(14) into Eq.(12) and collecting terms in the same order of leads to the following ODEs. (15) (16) Here the notation was adopted. The solution in complex notation of the zeroth order ODEs, Eq.(15), when only the force exist is: , (17) where CC stands for the complex conjugate of the preceding terms. To fully compute the zeroth order need to be found, therefore Eq.(17) is substituted into Eq.(16). The solution, the amplitude terms, right hand side of Eq.(16) can be computed once The solution greatly depends on the pumping and excitation frequencies. has been substituted and is provided in Appendix A. In the following subsection, the response is derived for the case when the system is excited by a slow force in a manner that most of the , while being pumped by a dual frequency signal response energy is close to the second natural frequency. The same procedure can be carried out for the remaining natural frequencies, and is omitted here for brevity. /22γIηχηPζχηKηκη12222312223222111TTTsγχχζζΦKΦKΦSΦηκηPΦQκη001101,,,ηηη0η1η,0,1iii0:20020DχηηP1:20110100020022nDDDDγηηχζχΩηηKκηη/D22fcosrrF22ii3201222eeCC2rriiirFA1iA0η1randab2.2.1 Response near the second natural frequency -- dual frequency pumping In order to transfer energy from a frequency well below any natural frequency to the second natural frequency, , the following frequency relationships are assumed (based on [15]): . To derive the analytical response the pumping frequencies are defined as: , (18) (19) where and are two algebraically dependent detuning parameters as will be shown. Substituting Eq.(19) to Eq.(16), the secular terms which need to be set to zero in order to derive are: here, , (20) . Transforming to polar form: , (21) and separating to real and imaginary equations, leads to: . (22) In order to transform Eq.(22) to an autonomous system, the following functions are defined: and their derivatives are: , . One is interested in the solutions at steady-state, thus sets , and from Eq.(24): . (23) (24) (25) 2f122,,2,01rbra221222bra12iA1121221111112122222212111222222333222222222221112332322122222222ii22333322222332333:i2i23232ee0:023i2i2:i2i2brabaAAAAHHAAAHAAAAAAAAAAAAkAAAA233211122222220AAAHAA2122122223223HA1111e2iAa2211111222222222222221112112222233111222222222222112333122212224222222222122:8::48co3243224cos2s:bbraaaaaHaaaaaaaakaHaaaH31212222233233333241222222222333233211222324ssin:48in32:2bbraakaaaaaaHaHa11221122,2221221,2120a2122,12Therefore, one defines:: (26) Implementation of Eq.(26) leads to the algebraic relation between the pumping frequencies, which was mentioned previously: (27) The solution at steady state is of interest (i.e., and ), hence are set once Eq.(26) has been substituted into Eq.(22). From the imaginary equations of and one has . Therefore, the real equations of and are fulfilled, and the only equations remained to be solved are: (28) From the imaginary part of the equation, the second mode amplitude can be computed: (29) In order to produce large amplitudes (i.e., amplification), the denominator should approach zero, and it is possible only if the pumping magnitude is set according to the following condition: . (30) The term on the left hand side of Eq.(30) is the linear stability threshold, , which is an important system parameter that depends on the modal damping, natural frequency, modal shape and modulated stiffness. Substituting Eq.(29) to the real equation leads to the following nonlinear transcendental equation: , (31) from which the phase can be computed, hence the amplitude via Eq.(29). Equation (31) can be transformed using trigonometric identities to a 10th order polynomial [15] and solved with better computational speed and accuracy than iterative zeros search. A closed form solution is not possible, but once are computed, the response of the zeroth order is given by: and . (32) The contribution of the next order terms, especially close to the natural frequency and at the external force frequency , can be derived, but is omitted for brevity. The solution with terms of the first order in is: 121211,2222arbarb00,a00a1310300aa1322202220222222202222210222002210222022020222:88c32cos:sinos242sin24bbraabbraaaakakaaHHaH102022212222220sin42si2nbbraakHak22221224akLTH32222262222021220322222221220222122022220122022222122043sin6sin4sin24sin24cossin04sin2rbbrbaaaarbarabaaHHkkkkk020a01122200223322coscos/22cos2cosrrrrrraa2/2ar . (33) From Eq.(31), ten conjugate solutions are possible; implementation of the reverse transformation leads to five possible real solutions, which are either stable or unstable. The stability analysis is carried out in a standard procedure [16], therefore omitted from the paper, but is shown in the presented results. 3 Numerical verification of the DFPA response In order to verify the analytical results, the DFPA parameters should be chosen according to the assumptions made during the solution. Assumptions regarding the relations between the frequencies were made, to ensure that only certain terms stemming from the nonlinearity are indeed secular. Additionally, assumption were made, which should be larger than the linear stability regarding the magnitude of the pumping threshold and smaller than unity. Values larger than one are unpractical as their meaning is that negative stiffness is produced. Moreover, to avoid negative stiffness when dual pumping is utilized, the sum of the pumping magnitudes should obey . Therefore the following parameters were chosen: , (34) leading to the following natural frequencies, modal matrix and linear stability thresholds: (35) Additionally the external force was set as: (36) Figure 2: Analytically computed response amplitudes of the second modal coordinate when the system is tuned to shift energy to the second mode. (a) response amplitudes close to the second natural frequency, . Continuous lines , (b) the corresponding response amplitudes at the external force frequency mark stable and dashed lines mark unstable solutions. 2111111122021102133131213131cos/2coscos/2coscos/2cosarararrrrrrraaaaaaaLTHLTH1ab1233341231230.5kg0.25kg5.9kg2.5310N/m1.2010N/m3.6510N/m1%2%3%mmmkkk9.940.21290.02540.351512.07111.15Hz,0.71470.84040.9759,22.00%kg14.1560.8871.60330.904139.38nLTHΦαf21f1cos0.1t/2afrfFigure 3: Analytically and numerically computed response amplitudes displayed in modal coordinates, when the system is tuned to shift energy to a specific mode. In the subfigures, only the largest solution branch of the response near the relevant natural frequency is displayed. (a) response amplitudes for , (b) corresponding amplitudes at , (c) response amplitudes for , (d) corresponding amplitudes at , (e) response amplitudes for , (f) corresponding amplitudes at . Analytical solutions are displayed by continuous lines and numerical solutions by data markers (dots, squares and diamonds). The nonlinearity was set to bring certain amplitudes according to the mode to which energy was transferred. From the problem's various magnitudes' scaling analysis the parameters appearing in Eq.(6), (10) and (13) were set to: and 1/2affrf2/2affrf3/2affrf, (37) The analytical solutions of the second modal coordinate , when the energy is shifted to the second mode are displayed in Figure 2. One can notice that multiple solutions may exist for a given pumping frequency, , is stable (blue continuous line in Figure 2(a)). and the largest amplitude close to the natural frequency, For this solution it is noticeable that energy is transferred from the external force frequency, , (blue continuous line in Figure 2(b)) to the natural frequency (i.e., as the solution in Figure 2(a) increases the corresponding one in Figure 2(b) decreases). It is clear that this solution is the most significant, as the apparatus is designed to amplify signals and shift energy. Next, the analytical solutions were verified via comparison to numerical simulations. Notice that only the largest stable amplitudes are displayed in order to avoid confusion. Figure 3 depicts the analytical and numerical responses, when dual-frequency pumping was employed to shift, each time, energy from the external force to a different natural frequency and mode. For each case, the modal amplitudes near the natural frequency and at the external force frequency are shown vs. the pumping frequency. It is noticeable that for all three cases the analytical and numerical solution resemble up to a certain pumping frequency for which the solution is no longer stable, and the numerical solutions drops to zero. Interestingly, for all three cases, as the pumping frequency is increased, more energy is transferred from the second mode to the relevant mode. The comparison verifies the theory according which energy can be transferred to any desired mode by correctly tuned pumping frequencies. 4 Experimental set-up, identification, some results and analysis The experimental system shown in Figure 4 was designed and built to validate the theoretical results and refine the theory as needed. The system consist of an aluminum plate which is suspended by four leaf springs enforcing motion in a single direction as depicted. Two modular masses are attached to the aluminum plate via leaf springs enforcing parallel motion as well. The displacement of the various masses are measured using lased displacement sensors which are attached to the aluminum plate. The forces applied to the masses are via linear voice coil actuators which are also attached to the aluminum plate. In this and configuration the measured coordinates are , and . The actuators were driven via a real-time digital signal processor (dSPACE 1104) to allow for easy tuning of the parametric excitation and nonlinear stiffness. In addition, the latter also served as a data question device. Figure 4: Experimental rig, showing the mechanical parts, the sensors and voice-coil actuators 210,2,1/222~frf1m2mxtutvt4.1 System calibration and identification Prior to conducting experiments, the sensors and voice coil actuators must be calibrated, and the system parameters need to be identified. At the beginning, the displacement sensors were calibrated using a manual micrometer. Next, the voice coil actuators were experimentally modeled and their mild static nonlinearity was pre-compensated by adjusting the supplied input signals. This action eliminates the inherent nonlinearity of the applied force created by magnetic imperfection in the voice coils. Once the system sensors and actuators were calibrated, its parameters were set to be identified. Two frequency responses were produced and measured, where the input forces were and . The natural frequencies, normal modes and damping coefficient were estimated with the aid of Structural Dynamics Toolbox [17] which contains a MIMO identification algorithm. Knowing the system topology, the method of model updating [18] was used to reevaluate the masses and stiffness. The results are provided below: , (38) and the normalized modes are shown in Figure 5Error! Reference source not found.. Figure 5: Mode shapes 4.2 Principal parametric resonance -- verification of linear stability threshold As explained in Section 2.2.1, the linear stability threshold is an important system parameter and it is proportional to the modal damping. To produce large amplitudes and amplification one needs to know these parameters values (i.e., each mode has a different threshold). Having identified the linear system parameters and successfully eliminated the inherent actuator static nonlinearities, the model was ready to the stage where it is digitally modified. Next, the parametric excitation and system nonlinearity were added through the actuators as computed in the digital signal processor. The appropriate expressions for pumping and nonlinearity, which appear in the Eq.(2), were realized through a digital feedback, as formulated below. , (39) 12f,f1,112f,f1,11231231231233.031Hz6.980Hz8.794Hz0.5%1.89%2.66%0.3501kg0.3535kg6.4966kg637.4N/m1009.4N/m2663N/mfffmmmkkkTDEPDETT3T2P13cos00f,,coscos0000rbbbraaaxtutkuvtttusuFMqFqqKFFCqhere the matrices and provided in Eq.(38). On the right hand side, the forces contain the linear system parameters which were estimated in Section 4.1 are applied by the actuators fed by and , and the fast digital system, when the direct excitation force applied on and is realized via , and the pumping and nonlinearity are realized via . While the former term, , is only time dependent, the latter, , is time and position dependent. The zeroth order solution in of the governing equations for the case of principal parametric resonance [16], when the system is pumped with a single frequency close to twice the natural frequency and without external excitation, is: . (40) The solution procedure is omitted for brevity as it is similar to the one carried out in Section 2. It is noticeable, that the pumping magnitude must be larger than the linear stability threshold, , for the asymptotic solutions to exist. The pumping magnitude and nonlinearity were set according to Eq.(40) to bring certain amplitudes when the system is tuned to be excited near the second natural frequency. In order to estimate the for , for which a parametric resonance was produced. system was pumped with a magnitude larger than Then the pumping magnitude was slowly decreased until no measurable amplitude sustained at steady-state. The pumping magnitude for which no amplitude sustained is denoted . The measured amplitudes in modal coordinate vs. the deviation between the analytical value of and the applied pumping magnitude, , are shown in Figure 6. Figure 6(a) depicts the measured amplitude vs. the deviation, when the was computed according to the estimated in Eq.(38). Using these measurements, the actual was estimated, and the damping was updated accordingly, assuming that , and are accurate. A similar experiment was conducted using the updated damping and actual from the two experiments, the deviation was reduced from about 1.8 to 0.005. , and the results are shown in Figure 6(b). Comparing the results Figure 6: Response amplitude in modal coordinates vs. the deviation of the pumping magnitude from theory before was updated (a), and after it and were updated (b). MCKDEFPF2m3mDEFPFDEFPF02200124212224212212222244arc1614sin,arc21,3sinaaaaaaakkakka2LTH2214/kLTH2fLTHLTHLTHLTH2LTH21k222LTH2LTH4.3 Dual-frequency parametric excitation -- preliminary experimental results and verification After the system was calibrated, its parameters identified and a method to derive the relevant linear stability threshold was verified, utilization of the DFPA mode was ready to be use. Based on the analytical solution, Eq.(33), the pumping magnitudes and nonlinearity were chosen to bring certain amplitudes. The measured frequency response, analytical solution and numerical simulation for the parameters provided in Eq.(41) appear in Figure 7 and Figure 8. . (41) The amplifier response, when operated in DFPA mode close to a natural frequency, consists of two main harmonics with a relatively large amplitude in comparison to the other ones. The largest amplitude is at a frequency close to the chosen natural frequency, in this case , and an additional amplitude at the external force frequency, . Observing Figure 7, in which the response amplitudes close to are shown, a good resemblance between the numerical simulation and analytical solution can be seen, as seen previously in Figure 3. The . It is experimental results greatly resemble the numerical simulation, although shifted by about important to mention that unlike the simulation, for which the solution dropped to zero at about , the measured amplitude did not. In fact, the measured amplitude reached a value of about which is the allowable value, therefore the experiment did not proceed beyond this frequency. It seems that higher values may have been achieved as the theory predicts. The amplifier response amplitudes at the external force frequency, , are shown in Figure 8, and provide similar insights as Figure 7. The analytical, numerical and experimental results resemble, although the measured response is shifted by about . Figure 7: Amplitudes in modal coordinates near the second natural frequency vs. the pumping frequency. Analytical results are shown by continuous lines, numerical results by circular data markers and experimental results by hollow diamond shaped data markers. 73324.4410N/m,0.24,0.24,f0.1N6.98Hz6.677Hz0.303Hzababrsfff2frf2f0.3Hz7.25Hz1.35mmrf0.3Hz2fFigure 8: Amplitudes in modal coordinates at the external force frequency vs. the pumping frequency. Analytical results are shown by continuous lines, numerical results by circular data markers and experimental results by hollow diamond shaped data markers. 5 Conclusions A tunable, nonlinear parametrically excited amplifier with three DOF model was introduced. Its governing EOM were derived and solved using the method of multiple scales for the case of combined dual-frequency pumping signal and external excitation. It has been shown that the amplifier can be tuned to shift energy to any of its natural frequencies by a properly tuned pumping signal. These results were verified by numerical simulations shown in Figure 3 and experimental results shown in Section 4. During the analytical solution an important system parameters were introduced, the linear stability thresholds. In contrast to SDOF systems, for MDOF system these parameters does not solely depend on the damping coefficient, but also on the natural frequencies, modal shapes and modulated stiffness via, , and . Unsurprisingly, it turns out that the topology has a great impact on the ability to parametrically excite a system. Therefore, when designing one care should be taken for the resulting values of the thresholds. Large values of exceeding unity result with negative stiffness in practice, which is usually undesired or requires large forces making it energetically inefficient. An experimental system was built in order to validate the results and refine the theory as needed. Prior to conducting experiments, the system was calibrated and its parameters were estimated. Preliminary results are shown in Section 4 and resemblance between the various solutions was noticed once the linear stability threshold was estimated. According to the estimated , and assuming no error in the natural frequencies, modal shapes and modulated stiffness, the damping coefficient was reevaluated. In the nonlinear frequency response shown in Section 4.3, a mild frequency shift was noticed between the measured response and analytical and numerical solutions. Although shift is small by engineering standards, it means that as expected, there are errors in the estimated system parameters, which are the masses, stiffness and damping. It is relatively easy to notice the error in the estimated natural frequencies, but hard to notice the error in the mode shapes. Nevertheless, the results are satisfactory and validate the model. Acknowledgements This research was supported by the Technion funds for Security research. rf21kLTHLTH0.3HzReferences [1] W. Lacarbonara, S. Antman, What is Parametric Excitation in Structural Dynamics?, In ENOC- 2008. ENOC, Saint Petersburg, Russia (2008). [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] K. Y. Billah, On the definition of parametric excitation for vibration problems, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 270, No.1-2, (2004), pp. 450 -- 454. N. HaQuang, D. T. Mook, R. H. Plaut, Non-linear structural vibrations under combined parametric and external excitations, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 118, No. 2, (1987), pp. 291 -- 306. L. D. Zavodney, A. H. Nayfeh, The response of a single-degree-of-freedom system with quadratic and cubic non-linearities to a fundamental parametric resonance, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 120, No. 1, (1988) pp. 63 -- 93. R. H. Plaut, J. J. Gentry, D. T. Mook, Non-linear structural vibrations under combined multi- frequency parametric and external excitations, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 140, No. 3, (1990), pp. 381 -- 390. L. A. Oropeza-Ramos, C. B.Burgner, K. L. Turner, Robust micro-rate sensor actuated by parametric resonance, Sensors Actuators A Phys., Vol. 152, No. 1, (2009) pp. 80 -- 87. [7] W. Zhang, K. Turner, A mass sensor based on parametric resonance, In Proceedings of the Solid State Sensor, Actuator and Microsystem Workshop, Hilton Head Island, SC, (2004), pp. 49 -- 52. [8] [9] K. Turner, S. Miller, P. Hartwell, Five parametric resonances in a microelectromechanical system, Nature, Vol. 396, No. 6707, (1998), pp. 149 -- 152. J. Rhoads, Tunable microelectromechanical filters that exploit parametric resonance, J. Vib. Acoust., Vol. 127, No. 5, (2005), pp. 423 -- 430. [10] J. F. Rhoads, S. W. Shaw, The impact of nonlinearity on degenerate parametric amplifiers Rhoads, Appl. Phys. Lett., Vol. 96, No. 23, (2010), p. 234101. [11] M. Géradin, D. J. Rixen, Mechanical Vibrations: Theory and Application to Structural Dynamics, Wiley, (2014). [12] T. Fossen, H. Nijmeijer, Parametric resonance in dynamical systems, Springer Science & Business Media, (2011). [13] C. H. Kim, N. C. Perkins, C. W. Lee, Parametric resonance of plates in a sheet metal coating process, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 268, No. 4, (2003), pp. 679 -- 697. [14] A. Olkhovets, D. W. Carr, J. M. Parpia, H. G. Craighead, Non-degenerate nanomechanical parametric amplifier, In Technical Digest. MEMS 2001. 14th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems, IEEE, Interlaken, Switzerland, (2001), pp. 298 -- 300. [15] A. Dolev, I. Bucher, Tuneable, non-degenerated, nonlinear, parametrically-excited amplifier, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 361, (2016), pp. 176 -- 189. [16] A. H. Nayfeh, D. T. Mook, Nonlinear Oscillations, John Wiley & Sons, (2008). [17] E. Balmes, Structural Dynamics Toolbox, User manual. (2016). [18] Y. Halevi, I. Bucher, Model updating via weighted reference basis with connectivity constraints, J. Sound Vib., Vol. 265, No. 3, (2003), pp. 561 -- 581. Appendix A The nonlinear matrix and modal vector are: (A.1) The right hand side of the Eq.(16) term by term is as follows: (A.2) (A.3) , (A.5) and are (A.4) where . And the last term of eq.(16) on the right hand side, the nonlinear term, is: , is comprised of many terms with different frequencies, up to 90 if both forces where considered to have two distinct frequencies. These terms are omitted for brevity. 433212122212332222122212221222322322122212221222334321222222233222T212321222321232222212223212223212223232221222322232223222123233333333366633333κ31212212322T1312322323212223212313222322122232223222323334321232223233,3333ηi0102i2eCCDDAi0i022e2ieiCCrrrDA1112223ii2iiiii211iii21222i2033eeeeeeeeee2eaararabbrbbraabbbbaabbbrrrrbaabbabbabbaHAktAAγηK33123iiiii211222233CCeeeeeaabbbbaaaaaabbaaaAAA2122122223223H20CCκΘηΘ1f2f
1808.09883	2	1808	2019-02-12T23:29:17	Realizing $Q$ > 300,000 in diamond microdisks for optomechanics via etch optimization	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.mes-hall", "physics.optics" ]	Nanophotonic structures in single--crystal diamond (SCD) that simultaneously confine and co-localize photons and phonons are highly desirable for applications in quantum information science and optomechanics. Here we describe an optimized process for etching SCD microdisk structures designed for optomechanics applications. This process allows the optical quality factor, $Q$, of these devices to be enhanced by a factor of 4 over previous demonstrations to $Q \sim 335,000$, which is sufficient to enable sideband resolved coherent cavity optomechanical experiments. Through analysis of optical loss and backscattering rates we find that $Q$ remains limited by surface imperfections. We also describe a technique for altering microdisk pedestal geometry which could enable reductions in mechanical dissipation.	physics.app-ph	physics	Realizing Q > 300, 000 in diamond microdisks for optomechanics via etch optimization Matthew Mitchell,1, 2 David P. Lake,1, 2 and Paul E. Barclay1, 2 1)Department of Physics and Astronomy and Institute for Quantum Science and Technology, University of Calgary, Calgary, AB, T2N 1N4, Canada 2)Nanotechnology Research Centre, National Research Council of Canada, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2M9, Canada (Dated: 14 February 2019) Nanophotonic structures in single -- crystal diamond (SCD) that simultaneously confine and co-localize photons and phonons are highly desirable for applications in quantum information science and optomechanics. Here we describe an optimized process for etching SCD microdisk structures designed for optomechanics applications. This process allows the optical quality factor, Q, of these devices to be enhanced by a factor of 4 over previous demonstrations to Q ∼ 335, 000, which is sufficient to enable sideband resolved coherent cavity optomechanical experiments. Through analysis of optical loss and backscattering rates we find that Q remains limited by surface imperfections. We also describe a technique for altering microdisk pedestal geometry which could enable reductions in mechanical dissipation. I. INTRODUCTION Over the past decade, advances in fabrication tech- niques have enabled rapid progress in the development of nanophotonic devices. This maturation is in large part thanks to researchers' ability to borrow techniques and materials from the semiconductor electronics in- dustry. For example, silicon-on-insulator technology, which is designed to reduce stray capacitance of elec- tronic microchips, has provided a ready-made platform for nanophotonic optical waveguides and cavities capable of confining light to small volumes1. In a similar spirit, nanophotonic devices have been realized in a wide vari- ety of dielectric and semiconductor thin films, where the large refractive index contrast between a top thin film waveguide layer and the underlying substrate or remov- able sacrificial layer provides vertical optical confinement, while patterning of the top layer provides lateral optical confinement. The combination of large per-photon field intensities and low optical loss that can be realized in these devices have enabled studies of strong light -- matter interactions that reveal new physical phenomena and can be harnessed for a wide range of applications ranging from sensing2 -- 4, to nonlinear5 -- 7 and quantum optics8. These innovations in nanophotonics have played a particularly critical role in the field of cavity optomechanics9, in which nanofabricated devices are en- gineered to couple optical and mechanical resonances via optical forces. State-of-the-art cavity optomechanical systems have been fabricated from dielectric and semi- conductor thin films, such as Si10,11, SiN12 -- 14, SiO2 15 -- 18 and III-V semiconductors such as GaAs19, InGaP20, AlGaAs20, GaP21, and AlN22. Owing to the tight optical confinement possible in these thin film based structures, they can posses large optomechanical coupling g0, which quantifies the per-photon optical force in the cavity. In addition, by undercutting and releasing the waveguid- ing layer from the substrate via selective chemical etch- ing, they can be mechanically isolated, enabling creation of suspended mechanical resonators with low mechan- ical dissipation. Together with low optical loss, these properties allow light to be coherently coupled to me- chanical resonances of these devices, and operated in the sideband resolved regime commonly used for optome- chanical cooling9. However, many desirable materials for nanophotonics and optomechanics applications are only available in bulk form, requiring new approaches for fabricating structures with the tight vertical optical confinement and mechanical isolation required by cavity optomechanics. Single -- crystal diamond (SCD) is one such material. Its large electronic bandgap (∼ 5.45 eV) and associated wide transparency window results in low multiphoton absorp- tion at telecommunication wavelengths, allowing opera- tion at high optical power levels not supported by smaller bandgap materials such as Si. Among large bandgap ma- terials, diamond has a moderately high refractive index (n ∼ 2.45), allowing for strong optical confinement, as well as excellent mechanical and thermal properties, e.g. a Young's modulus and thermal conductivity that are the highest among known materials. Together, these at- tributes make diamond attractive for nanophotonics and optomechanics applications. Furthermore, diamond is host to quantum emitters such as the nitrogen vacancy (NV) and silicon vacancy (SiV) colour centres23,24 that can be can be coupled to mechanical25 -- 29 and optical30 -- 33 resonators, and used to generate single photons for quan- tum networking applications34 -- 36 and store quantum information37 -- 39. SCD is not currently commercially available in hetero- epitaxially grown thin film form, and although efforts to grow high quality diamond films on substrates such as Ir/MgO40, Ir/YSZ/Si41,42, and SiC/Si43 are underway, this material is not yet readily available. Integrated opti- cal and optomechanical devices have been demonstrated in polycrystalline diamond (PCD)44 -- 46, which is com- mercially available in thin film form but is not an ideal host for highly coherent quantum emitters. Most state- 9 1 0 2 b e F 2 1 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 2 v 3 8 8 9 0 . 8 0 8 1 : v i X r a 2 FIG. 1: Single -- crystal diamond fabrication process, where the steps optimized in this work are highlighted in green. (i) 300 nm thick PECVD Si3N4 layer, ∼ 5 nm of Ti as an anti -- charging layer, and EBL resist (ZEP 520A) is deposited. (ii) EBL is performed and chip is developed in ZED N50 followed by IPA at −15◦C. (iii) Patterns are transferred to the Si3N4 hard mask using the optimized ICPRIE etch discussed in the text. (iv) ZEP is removed using a deep-UV exposure followed by Remover PG, and the pattern is transferred to the diamond using an anisotropic O2 plasma ICPRIE etch. (v) Sidewall protection layer via a conformal coating of PECVD Si3N4. (vi) A short ICPRIE etch removes Si3N4 from the bottom of the etch windows. (vii) An initial zero bias O2 ICPRIE plasma partially undercuts the microdisks. (viii) A ∼ 100 nm layer of SiO2 is deposited via electron -- beam physical vapor deposition (EBPVD). (ix) A second zero bias O2 plasma etch is performed, finishing the plasma undercutting process. (x) The sample is soaked in HF to remove the remaining Si3N4 layer, followed by a piranha clean. of-the-state studies of highly coherent SiV and NV colour centres37,47,48 are performed using "bulk" SCD chips grown using chemical vapour deposition. As such, several alternative approaches to fabrication of SCD nanopho- tonic devices from this material have been investigated. Efforts to create nanophotonic devices from SCD in- clude wafer bonding and polishing7,32,49 -- 51, liftoff49,52, and use of hybrid materials31,53. An arguably simpler ap- proach is to fabricate devices directly from bulk diamond chips. This offers the possibility of creating devices from the highest quality material without requiring any man- ual processing steps such as bonding or polishing. To this end, ion -- beam milling54 -- 56, angled plasma etching57 -- 59, and plasma undercutting60 approaches have been suc- cessful in fabricating nanophotonic structures from SCD. Of these, the quasi-isotropic plasma undercutting tech- nique developed by Khanaliloo et al.60 for fabricating microdisk structures from bulk diamond is unique in its ability to harness etching along diamond crystal planes in both vertical and lateral directions. It has been used to realize diamond devices with a desirable combination of high optical Q and small mode volume60 and for the first demonstrations of optomechanics in SCD61,62. Recently, a modified version of the undercut pro- cess used for early demonstrations of SCD cavity op- tomechanical microdisks62 was used to create devices whose increase in Q, together with improvements in their thermal properties, enabled coherent coupling be- tween light and mechanical motion, ie. optomechani- cally induced transparency and cooling63. In the work presented in this article, we provide a detailed de- scription of this modified fabrication process, and de- scribe additional optimization of the etching parame- ters that further increases Q by ∼ 4× compared to results reported in Ref.63. This places the devices in the resolved sideband regime which is a requirement for observing efficient radiation-pressure dynamical back- action effects9,64, such as ground state cooling11, and ef- ficient optomechanical wavelength conversion14,65, which we have recently demonstrated66. In addition, by an- alyzing the influence of the microdisk's diameter on the loss and internal scattering rates of the microdisk modes, we reveal that Q is likely limited by surface roughness, indicating that further improvements may be possible. II. PROCESS OVERVIEW The approach reported here for fabricating undercut devices from bulk SCD is inspired by the SCREAM process developed for bulk single -- crystal silicon MEMS microfabrication67, and has been used by our group to fabricate nanophotonic devices such as nanobeams61 and microdisk whispering gallery mode resonators60. This process has seen adoption by researchers fabricating a variety of nanoscale structures from SCD68 -- 70, and the properties of the quasi-isotropic etch and its interaction with the diamond crystal planes have been investigated in detail in Ref.71. The modified process used in Ref.63 for fabricating im- proved microdisk optomechanical cavities is shown in Fig. 1, where the optimized steps that are the focus of this article have been highlighted in green. We start with 3 mm × 3 mm optical grade, CVD grown, SCD chips pur- DiamondZEP 520ASi3N4SiO2EBLICPRIEO2PECVDSi3N4ICPRIEC4F8/SF6EBPVDICPRIEO2HFWetEtch(i)(ii)(iii)(iv)(v)(vi)(vii)(viii)(ix)(x)ICPRIEC4F8/SF6ICPRIEO2chased from Element Six72,73. These are mechanically polished further by Delaware Diamond Knives to surface roughness < 5 nm RMS, and are cleaned in boiling pi- ranha (150 mL H2SO4:50 mL H2O2) followed by a 3 × 30s rinse in H2O, and drying with N2. As an O2 in- ductively coupled reactive ion etch (ICPRIE) is used for all of the diamond etching steps it is necessary to use a hard mask for patterning. We have chosen Si3N4 in order to take advantage of highly optimized Si etching recipes during later steps. A 300 nm thick Si3N4 layer is de- posited via plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD). The Si3N4 is then coated with a thin Ti layer (5 - 10 nm), deposited via electron -- beam physical vapor deposition (EBPVD), which reduces charging that can be problematic during subsequent electron beam lithogra- phy (EBL) steps due to diamond's insulating properties. Finally, a 400 nm layer of ZEP 520A is spin coated on the surface of the chip (4000 RPM, 60 s, 180oC bake for 5 min while semi -- covered by reflective lid). Patterning of the ZEP was performed using a Raith 150-TWO system, with beam energy of 30 keV, aperture of 10 µm, and dose factor of 4 × 80 µC/cm2, followed by development for 20 s in a bath of ZED -- N50, followed by IPA, both cooled to −15◦C. The ZEP pattern is then transferred to the Si3N4 hard mask layer via ICPRIE with C4F8/SF6 chemistry using an Oxford PlasmaPro 100 Estrelas Deep Silicon Etching system. This step is vital for ensuring smooth sidewalls of the diamond structures and is discussed in Sec. III. The pattern is then transferred to the diamond layer via a nearly vertical anisotropic O2 ICPRIE etch, the optimization of which is discussed in Sec. IV. Before the undercut step, a sidewall protection layer is required to prevent unwanted etching of the patterned device. In this work a 150 nm thick conformal layer of PECVD Si3N4 was used, however, atomic layer deposited Al2O3 has also been successfully employed by Moura- dian et al.68. This layer is then removed only from the top surface and bottom of the etch wells using the same hard mask etch chemistry and conditions as in the pat- terning step, which preferentially etches horizontal sur- faces. The devices are then undercut via a zero bias O2 quasi-isotropic etch performed at an elevated tem- perature (250◦C) to reduce the etching time required for sufficient undercutting62. In recent work an additional SiO2 electron beam evaporation step was added to al- ter microdisk pedestal profiles, as depicted in Fig. 1(viii- ix) which led to improved thermal handling, and is dis- cussed in Sec. IV. Finally after sufficient undercutting the hard mask is stripped in 49% HF solution (20 mL), and cleaned in boiling piranha, where each acid step is followed by a 3 × 30 second rinse in H2O and drying with N2. Further post -- processing surface treatments are discussed in Sec. V. III. HARD MASK & SIDEWALL PROTECTION LAYER ETCH OPTIMIZATION 3 offers resolution ultra -- high nano -- While EBL lithography, it is vital to make the initial hard mask etch as smooth as possible to reap these benefits. Major limiting factors for Q of previously studied diamond microdisk structures were sidewall roughness and a "ledge" on the top edge of the microdisk62,63. Both of these imperfections were caused by a non-ideal hard mask etch that impacted the quality of the subsequent vertical diamond etched surfaces. 2(d). Fig. 2(a-c) illustrates the importance of the hard mask etch on the diamond sidewall roughness. The ledge seen in Fig. 2(c) was a result of breakthrough of the Si3N4 hard mask's angled sidewalls during the anisotropic di- amond etch, as seen in Fig. It was also found that this ledge caused breakthrough of the sidewall pro- tection layer during the quasi -- isotropic plasma under- cutting step (Fig. 1(vii)). Prior to the etch optimization described below, this breakthrough severely limited the yield of the process. In extreme cases it resulted in com- plete delamination of the sidewall protection layer, and subsequent unwanted etching of the device surfaces, as shown in Fig. 2(e,f). The hard mask etch was optimized following a pro- cedure similar to Hill74, by performing the identical EBL process described above on ∼ 300 nm thick Si3N4 deposited on Si substrates. This was stopped when the Si3N4 sidewalls were smooth and close to vertical, ensuring that there was no breakthrough during the anisotropic diamond etch as shown in Fig. 3(a-c). The optimized ICPRIE etch parameters are given in Table I. Here the ICP column refers to the power applied to the coil responsible for generating the plasma, hence control- ling the ion density, while the RF column refers to the power applied to the coil responsible for accelerating the ions towards the substrate, controlling ion energy. In optimizing this etch the temperature (15◦C) and pres- sure (10 mTorr) were held constant. Initially tests were performed to find a bounding region for the bias voltage, which is a measure of the potential difference between the plasma and substrate electrode, achieved by varying the ICP and RF power and C4F8:SF6 gas ratio. Several iter- ations were performed holding either the gas ratio or RF and ICP powers constant, while varying the other. The etch quality was analyzed for varying bias voltage and gas ratio until an acceptable etch was achieved, where etch quality was determined by analyzing SEM images post -- etching. Overall ratios of C4F8:SF6 from 3.75 to 0.56, ICP powers from 650 -- 1800 W, and RF powers from 10 -- 25 W were explored. IV. ANISOTROPIC DIAMOND ETCH OPTIMIZATION A smooth vertical diamond etch is also critical for realiz- ing devices with low optical loss. To this end, following 4 FIG. 2: Consequences of poor hard mask etch where the Si3N4 layer has been colorized; non-colorized surfaces are SCD. (a,b) The highly angled sidewalls of the Si3N4 hard mask is a consequence of over -- passivation during the etch. (c) This leads to breakthrough of the hard mask layer during the anisotropic diamond etch resulting in "ledge" in the diamond layer. (d) More severe breakthrough, resulting in holes in the hard mask, can also result in complete etching of the device. Result of partial (e) and complete (f) breakthrough of the hardmask layer. FIG. 3: Result of optimized hard mask etch where the Si3N4 layer has been colorized; non-colorized surfaces are SCD. (a,b) The optimized hard mask etch resulted in less angled, smooth sidewalls that do not exhibit breakthrough during the anisotropic diamond etch. (c,d) Smooth diamond sidewalls resulting from optimized hard mask etch, with no holes in the hardmask layer. (e) Example microdisk structure after subsequent processing described in Sec. II. T [◦C] 15 Pressure RF [W] [mTorr] 20 10 Bias [V] 50 ICP [W] 1200 C4F8 [sccm] SF6 [sccm] 14 14 TABLE I: Nominal etch parameters used for patterning the Si3N4 hard mask. This results in an etch rate of ∼ 3.0 nm/s for PECVD Si3N4. the Si3N4 hard mask etch optimization, the anisotropic diamond etching process was optimized to reduce micro- masking effects that can lead to rough device sidewalls75. This optimization is also important for future devices such as photonic crystals, whose sensitivity to roughness is enhanced owing to their large surface area to volume ratio, and whose optical design is simplified if vertical sidewalls are achievable. The anisotropic SCD etches were performed using an Oxford PlasmaPro 100 Cobra ICP system (step (iv) in Fig. 1), where the goal of this optimization was to cre- ate as smooth of diamond sidewalls as possible to reduce optical loss due to surface roughness76. During this opti- mization the temperature (15◦C), chamber pressure (10 mTorr), and O2 flow rate (30 sccm) of the etches were held constant. Initially a sweep of the etcher RF power from 20 -- 100 W was performed, with the ICP power held constant at 850 W. These etch conditions are la- beled RF -- α in Table II, and SEM images of the resulting etched devices are shown in Fig. 4. From this sweep it is apparent that low RF power results in highly angled (a)(e)(f)(g)(h)(b)(c)(d)5 µm5 µm1 µm1 µm500 nm4 µm3 µm500 nm(e)(f)5 µm5 µm"Ledge"(a)(b)(c)(d)5 µm1 µm3 µm3 µm3 µm500 nm3 µm5 FIG. 5: Scanning electron micrographs of microdisk structures after the anisotropic etch step for varying ICP power. Etch setting at each point in the parameter sweep are detailed in Table II. Scale bars are 5 µm. FIG. 4: Scanning electron micrographs of microdisk structures after the anisotropic etch step for varying RF power. Etch setting at each point in the parameter sweeps RF -- α (top two rows of images) and RF -- β (bottom row of images) are detailed in Table II. Scale bars are 5 µm. sidewalls and slower etch rates, while the high forward RF power induces some roughness at the bases of the sidewalls. The sidewall angle as a function of DC -- bias is shown in Fig. 6(a), where a maximum angle of ∼16◦ was observed. The etch rate was found to vary less dramati- cally throughout this sweep, as shown in Fig. 6(b). Note that roughness in the surrounding etch window walls present in some of these etches is a result of non -- ideal EBL and is not a consequence of the individual diamond etch conditions. The smoothest etch, identified to be the OG36 con- ditions as determined by scanning electron microscope (SEM) images, was then used as a starting point for an ICP power sweep. During this sweep the DC -- bias was kept roughly constant by adjusting the RF power to com- pensate for variations caused by the changing ICP power. This sweep is labeled "ICP" in Table II, and SEM images of its results are shown in Fig. 5. Based on this sweep, an ICP power of 1000 W was determined to provide the best combination of sidewall smoothness and verticality. This ICP value was used for a final RF sweep, labeled "RF -- β(cid:48)(cid:48) in Table II. Its results are shown in Fig. 4, from which the parameters used for sample OG56 were identi- fied as the optimized combination of etch verticality and sidewall smoothness, and were used in the fabrication of the sample whose optical properties are characterized in the following Sec. V. FIG. 6: Etch rates and sidewall angles for RF sweep points (RF-α) with constant 850 W ICP power. (a) Sidewall etch angle as a function of DC bias, measured from the horizontal. (b) Etch rate as a function of DC bias. V. OPTICAL CHARACTERIZATION AND SURFACE TREATMENTS Although the evaluation of the various etch conditions presented above is somewhat qualitative, a more quan- titative evaluation is possible by measuring the optical properties of a fully fabricated microdisk. This requires further processing steps (vii) -- (x) in Fig. 1 in order to undercut the device, as described in Sec. II. Step (vii) has already been characterized in Ref.60 and provides a smooth bottom surface for the undercut microdisk struc- ture, vital to observe high-Q optical resonances. The pedestal shaping steps (viii) and (ix) are optional, and are described in Sec. VI below. In step (x), after strip- ping the mask layers the sample was cleaned in heated pi- ranha. During this step the sample was placed in H2SO4 (6 mL), heated to 70◦C before adding H2O2 (2 mL), which raised the temperature of the resulting piranha so- lution to ∼ 100◦C. After 1 hour the sample was removed and rinsed in H2O (3 × 30 s) and dried with N2. The optimized devices were evaluated by measuring OG37OG38OG46OG47OG55OG56OG54OG53OG48OG49Sidewall angle [°]016DC Bias [V]120180240300DC Bias [V]120180240300Etch Rate [nm/s]1.42.0(a)(b)ICP [W] RF [W] Bias [V] Etch Rate [nm/s] Sidewall Angle [◦] Parameter Sweep 6 850 850 850 850 850 850 1000 1150 1300 1000 1000 20 40 60 80 100 80 90 100 110 100 110 130 190 230 279 311 281 286 291 293 304 319 1.534 1.636 1.911 1.620 1.759 2.206 2.454 3.225 4.062 2.685 2.378 15.55 6.509 2.976 1.107 0.636 13.27 4.063 6.952 8.994 3.242 2.634 RF -- α ICP RF -- β Sample OG47 OG46 OG38 OG36 OG37 OG54 OG53 OG48 OG49 OG55 OG56 TABLE II: Parameters used in the anisotropic SCD etch optimization. Q of their optical modes and comparing with Q of un- optimized devices. Measurements were carried out by coupling a tunable diode laser (Newport TLB-6700B) to the device via a dimpled optical fiber taper, as out- lined in60,62,63. All measurements were performed in a N2 purged environment. Fig. 7 compares the fiber taper transmission spectrum for the highest-Q optical mode observed in a optimized fabrication process microdisk (Fig. 7(a)), with that of the highest-Q device from ear- lier work63 (Fig. 7(b)), demonstrating a ∼ 4× improve- ment in "intrinsic" quality factor, Qi, to Qi ∼ 335, 000. The confidence interval obtained when fitting the opti- cal lineshape to extract Q is typically (cid:28) 1% of Q and is omitted in the following analysis and figures as it would not be resolved. In this work 67 of 154 pre -- and 88 of 161 post-optimization devices were initially studied as only a subset of the patterned devices are had a suffi- ciently small pedestal after the undercut to support high -- Q modes, as described in Ref.60. From this set only de- vices possessing a doublet structure, as shown in Fig. 7, were used in our analysis, which corresponds to 62 pre -- and 68 post -- optimization devices. This corresponded to the highest -- Q modes (Q > 1.4 × 104) of each device, the measurements of which are presented in Figs. 8-9. Note that the vast majority of singlet modes observed did not exceed this doublet -- Q cutoff. A small handful of singlet modes with Q's up to 5 × 104 were observed, but are omitted from this study. The doublet nature of these modes is created by backscattering that couples the microdisk's nominally degenerate clockwise and counter- clockwise traveling wave whispering gallery modes to cre- ate standing waves76,77. Each standing wave mode is a symmetric or anti-symmetric superposition of the trav- eling wave modes, and they can have different Qs i and Qa i respectively, as their intensity profiles sense different volumes of the microdisk. In general, multiple mechanisms contribute to the total optical loss rate of the microdisks, which scales as 1/Q. Since loss rates are additive, we can write 1/Q = 1/Qi + 1/Qex. The intrinsic Qi can be decomposed as 1/Qi = 1/Qrad + 1/Qb + 1/Qss + 1/Qsa, where Qrad, Qb, Qss, and Qsa relate to radiation loss via leakage into unbound modes, bulk absorption, surface scattering, and surface FIG. 7: (a,b) Normalized fiber transmission as a function of laser wavelength for an optical mode fabricated using the described optimized process (a) compared to previous work (b), for fixed span in λ. The intrinsic quality factor Qi for the symmetric and antisymmetric modes is extracted by fitting (purple) the transmission profile (blue). absorption, respectively. Etch smoothness impacts Qss, while etch chemistry and other processing that influences the diamond surface can impact Qsa. Qb is determined by the bulk optical properties of the material, and Qrad is defined by solutions to Maxwell's equations for modes of a device fabricated without any imperfections. Loss related to coupling with the fiber taper is accounted for the "external" Qex. The dominant source of loss can be identified through theoretical calculations or experimental measurements. For typical fiber taper coupling in these devices, Qex > 106 is extracted from the fit to the optical resonance. Note that "parasitic" loss introduced by the fiber into modes not involved in input or output coupling can also be accounted for as in Spillane et al.78, and was found to be small compared to 1/Q. Bulk loss for a weakly 1540.61540.71540.8λ [nm]λ [nm]T0.80.91.0TQi~ 75,000Qi~ 335,000sQi~ 87,000saQi~ 284,000a(a)(b)1551.251551.351551.450.40.60.81.0absorbing media can be approximated by 1/Qb = α/k, where the wavenumber k = 2πnr/λ = nrωo/vp where ωo and vp are the frequency and phase velocity of the light, respectively. Here α = 4πni/λ is the absorption coefficient of the bulk, where nr and ni are the real and imaginary parts of the refractive index79 -- 81. Using α ∼ 1×10−3 cm−1 for the absorption coefficient of CVD -- SCD at IR wavelengths82, results in an estimated Qb > 107. The radiation loss limited contribution was estimated via finite -- difference time -- domain simulations83 and found to be Qrad > 106 for the disk geometry (thickness, radius and pedestal size) studied here. i and Qa To investigate loss due to surface absorption, the pre- optimized devices were subjected to tri -- acid cleaning. This 1:1:1 sulfuric, perchloric, nitric acid bath is typ- ically used to remove graphitic surfaces detrimental to spin coherence properties of diamond nitrogen vacancy (NV) and silicon vacancy (SiV) centers47,48. It was per- formed using 10 mL of the acid mixture at 250◦C for 1 hr using a reflux system to capture the acid vapor, followed by rinsing in H2O (3 × 30 s) and drying with N2. To assess the impact of this cleaning, microdisk modes of the devices were measured before and after cleaning. These results are summarized in Fig. 8, which shows the change in measured doublet Qav, defined as the average of Qs i , for a range devices with vary- ing diameter. This is quantified as "Q% difference", de- fined as (Qafter − Qbefore)/Qbefore for both Qav and Qbs, for before and after cleaning. No change in Qav con- sistent across many devices or with a clear trend as a function of microdisk diameter is observed. This holds for both TE and TM like mode, whose fields are most strongly concentrated near the vertical and horizontal microdisk surfaces, respectively76. Additionally, no sig- nificant change in the thermal capacity of the devices was observed, as determined by measuring the shift in doublet center wavelength, λo, as a function of dropped optical power, Pd. This suggests that loss due to surface absorp- tion is not limiting Qi, provided the surface is not con- taminated by material impervious to the tri-acid clean, or to the hydrofluoric acid and piranha cleaning carried out post-fabrication (see Fig. 1). Also shown in Fig. 8 is a measure of the backscattering rate, Qbs ∼ λo/∆λ, where ∆λ is the doublet splitting76. This was also found to be unaffected by the tri-acid, suggesting that any sur- face roughness responsible for the mode coupling is likely related to etched diamond surface morphology, which is expected to be unaffected by the cleaning steps used here. To gain additional insight into the mechanism limit- ing Q, the dependence of Qav and Qbs on diameter for the optimized devices is plotted in Figs. 9(a) and 9(b). Although variations in Qav and Qbs of an order of mag- nitude are observed, no clear dependence on diameter is noted, and we attribute the variability to imperfections unique to each microdisk, and to differences in modal ra- dial and vertical quantum number of the modes used in the data set. However, as shown qualitatively in Figs. 9(a) and 9(b), we observe that Qbs tracks changes in Qav 7 FIG. 8: Comparison of Qav, and Qbs before and after cleaning in tri -- acid as described in the text for TM -- like (a) and TE -- like (b) modes. as a function of diameter. This is shown more quantita- tively in Figs. 9(c) and 9(d), which show scatter plots of 1/Qav as a function 1/Qbs for the TE and TM modes, respectively. We find that 1/Qav and 1/Qbs have a corre- lation coefficient, r = 0.83 and r = 0.75 for the TM -- and TE -- like modes, respectively. This correlation suggests that surface roughness is limiting Q. Additionally, as shown by the 1/Q histogram in Figs. 9(e,f), the density (ρ) of high-Qav TE -- like modes (Fig. 9(e)) in these mi- crodisks is larger than that of the TM -- like modes (9(f)). This suggests that there is a greater degree of surface roughness and scattering for the TM -- like modes. The probability densities of 1/Q for the TE -- and TM -- like modes in Fig. 9(e) and 9(f) were well fit to a half -- normal or folded normal distribution expected for Q limited by surface roughness that varies randomly along the perime- ter of the microdisk, with different random distribution for each disk. Finally, no large asymmetry between Qs i and Qa i of the standing wave modes was observed for any of the devices measured in this study, further supporting the conclusion that the dominant form of surface rough- ness limiting Q is distributed along the perimeter of the microdisk. This is in contrast to the effect of large dis- crete local perturbations along the microdisk perimeter, which can couple differently to the phase shifted spatial intensity profiles of the standing wave modes76. Based on the evaluation of each loss mechanism de- scribed above we conclude that Qss is limiting Qi, most likely due to remaining etch roughness in the anisotropic diamond etch and roughness on the top or bottom sur- faces. This suggests that further improvements to Q could be achieved by developing a smoother anisotropic diamond etch. -0.50.501-0.50.501-1Q % di(cid:31)erenceQ % di(cid:31)erenceDiameter [µm]Diameter [µm]5.45.86.26.65.45.86.2QavQbsQavQbs(a)(b)TM - likeTE - like8 FIG. 9: (a,b) 1/Qav and 1/Qbs vs. disk diameter for the TE -- and TM -- like modes, where an average value of Qa and Qs is taken. Solid lines are a boxcar average of the data, potted as a guide to the eye. (c,d) 1/Qav vs. 1/Qbs for the TE -- and TM -- like modes with calculated correlation coefficient, r, suggesting positive correlation between 1/Qav and 1/Qbs. (e,f) Probability distribution of measured values for (c) 1/QTE and (d) 1/QTM for microdisks of varying diameter where each histogram has been fit to a half -- normal distribution. VI. THERMAL ENGINEERING VIA PEDESTAL SHAPE When confining light to a small mode volume in a solid state structure both linear and nonlinear absorption of light can cause significant heating of the cavity84,85. This heating can cause instability in the cavity resonance fre- quency due to the thermo -- optic effect and make it prac- tically difficult to maintain a constant -- cavity detuning, which is vital in many optomechanical processes. In previous work it was found that the ∼ 100 nm diame- ter pedestal size of the microdisk structure pictured in Fig. 10(a) was limiting the thermal time constant of the device due to the reduced thermal conductivity in the pedestal62. To attempt to alleviate this issue a method for altering the pedestal shape was investigated. Namely by deposit- ing an additional masking layer it is possible to tailor the pedestal shape of the microdisk during the under- cut stage. It is important to use a non-conformal layer such that the undercutting process may continue hori- zontally as shown in Fig. 1(viii). Here EBPVD was used to deposit a 100 nm layer of SiO2, in a line of sight fash- ion, allowing undercutting to continue immediately af- ter. Here a Johnson Ultravac load-locked electron beam evaporation system was used with a deposition pressure of ∼ 1 × 10−6 Torr, and a deposition rate of 0.5 A/s. By varying the point at which this deposition occurs during the undercut the pedestal shape can be altered differently as shown in Figs. 10(a -- c). Here the SiO2 was deposited after 4 hours of undercutting for the structures in Figs. 10(b,c), where an additional 4 and 5 hours were required to undercut each device respectively. This corresponds to 45% and 40% of the total undercut time, where the discrepancy in time is due to different etch depths dur- ing the anisotropic etch60. This process can be repeated to customize the pedestal shape and could potentially be used to engineer the phononic properties of the structure, similar to the work of Nguyen et al.86. By altering the pedestal geometry, the device in Fig. 10(b) demonstrated an order of magnitude decrease in the thermal time con- (e)(c)(a)(d)(b)(f)1/QTE [×10-5]1/Qav1/Qav1/Qav1/Qav1/Qbs 1/Qbs 1/Qbs 1/Qbs 1/QTM [×10-5]ρρ01234567800.10.20.30.40.501234567800.10.20.310-510-510-510-410-410-610-610-310-610-310-410-610-410-410-510-4TE - likeTE - likeTM - likeTM - liker = 0.75r = 0.83Diameter [µm]Diameter [µm]4.65.05.45.86.24.65.05.45.86.29 FIG. 10: Effect of additional masking step during the quasi -- isotropic undercut on microdisk pedestal geometry. (a) Hourglass pedestal shape resulting from no additional masking step. (b) Flared shape resulting from masking after undercutting by ∼ 45%. The circular holes observed in the microdisk were part of a separate study, and did not affect the flared pedestal shape. (c) Pedestal shape resulting from masking after undercutting by ∼ 40%. stant of the microdisk structures, measured by fitting the response of the optical transmission for an input optical step function. This alteration resulted in the ability to support roughly an order of magnitude larger intracavity photon number before the onset of thermal instability63. The ability to operate at large N while avoiding thermal instability is practically important in cavity optomechan- ics applications due to the linear dependance of the op- tomechanical cooperativity C = 4g0N/κΓm on N , where g0 is the single -- photon coupling rate, κ = ωo/Qo, and 9. This enabled the observation of op- Γm = ωm/Qm tomechanically induced transparency and optomechan- ically mediated wavelength conversion with C > 1 in previously reported work63,66. VII. DISCUSSION The detailed description of the fabrication process pro- vided here will enable researchers to create a wide range of diamond photonic devices for applications including quantum photonics, nonlinear optics, and optomechan- ics. The optimization presented here, resulting in a ∼ 4× increase in average Qi for TE -- like modes compared to our previous cavity optomechanical devices, was carried out over a timescale of ∼3 months on equipment shared with other researchers for a wide variety of processes and ma- terials. As etch parameters vary from tool to tool, we hope that the optimization results presented here could be utilized by others to identify similar issues or devices characteristics and use our procedure to improve over- all etch quality. For reference, Table III compares this result with the current state of the art for SCD cavities at telecommunications wavelengths. While SCD optome- chanical crystals, demonstrated by Burek et al.59 provide superior g0, microdisks have an advantage in that they naturally support optical modes across the entire trans- parency window of the material, enabling multimode op- tomechanical experiments such as optomechanical wave- length conversion14,65,66, and for larger microdisk diam- eter can have much greater radiation loss limited opti- cal Q. The improvement demonstrated here is particu- TABLE III: Comparison of SCD cavities supporting modes at telecommunications wavelengths. Indicates which works have also demonstrated optomechanical coupling in the structure. Author/Reference Structure Qi(×105) Optomechanics Microdisk This work Lake et al.63 Microdisk Mitchell et al.62 Microdisk Khanaliloo et al.60 Microdisk Burek et al.58 Racetrack Burek et al.59 OMC Teodoro et al.90 Microdisk 3.35 0.87 0.68 1.02 2.70 3.02 0.057 Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No larly meaningful for applications in cavity optomechan- ics, as it places the optimized devices in the resolved side- band regime where the mechanical resonance frequency, ωm/2π ∼ 2 − 3 GHz for the microdisks studied here, ex- ceeds the cavity optical energy decay rate, κ/2π ∼ 0.6 GHz for the high -- Q device9. This regime is a require- ment for observing efficient radiation-pressure dynamical back-action effects9,64, such as ground state cooling11, and low -- noise amplification87. Further enhancement in optical Q could be achieved by improving the etch qual- ity, and reducing surface roughness that is still present, as we conclude from the analysis above that the optical Q remains limited by surface imperfections. For example, incorporation of Cl2 based etching may enable smoother diamond surfaces88. Additional cleaning steps such as post -- fabrication oxygen annealing, as utilized by Burek et al.59, or investigating appropriate surface termination techniques such as those devoped for silicon89 could also be investigated for improving optical Q. Finally, while current SCD microdisks mechanical quality factors, Qm, are limited by clamping loss62,63, the pedestal shaping step described in Sec. VI could be utilized to reduce me- chanical dissipation and increase C (cid:29) 1, by incorporat- ing a phononic shield into the pedestal as demonstrated by Nguyen et al. in GaAs microdisks86. (c)(b)5 m(a)4 m3 mVIII. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 21M. Mitchell, A. C. Hryciw, and P. E. Barclay, Appl. Phys. Lett. 10 The authors would like to thank Blaine McLaughlin for his assistance in the lab, and Ghazal Hajisalem, Aaron Hryciw, Scott Munro and Les Schowalter for all their help and support in and out of the NRC Nanotechnology Research Centre and nanoFAB. IX. FUNDING This work was supported by National Research Coun- cil Canada (NRC), Alberta Innovates, National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), and Canada Foundation for Innovation (CFI). 1D. Thomson, A. Zilkie, J. E. Bowers, T. Komljenovic, G. T. Reed, L. Vivien, D. Marris-Morini, E. Cassan, L. Virot, J.-M. F´ed´eli, J.-M. Hartmann, J. H. Schmid, D.-X. Xu, F. Boeuf, P. O'Brien, G. Z. Mashanovich, and M. Nedeljkovic, Journal of Optics 18, 073003 (2016). 2A. G. Krause, M. Winger, T. D. Blasius, W. Lin, and O. Painter, Nature Photon. 6, 768 (2012). 3M. Wu, A. C. Hryciw, C. Healey, D. P. Lake, H. Jayakumar, M. R. Freeman, J. P. Davis, and P. E. Barclay, Phys. Rev. X 4, 021052 (2014). 4M. Wu, N. L. Y. Wu, T. Firdous, F. Fani Sani, J. E. Losby, M. R. Freeman, and P. E. Barclay, Nature Nanotechnology 12, 127 EP (2016). 5C. C. Evans and E. Mazur, in Nano-Optics for Enhancing Light- Matter Interactions on a Molecular Scale, edited by B. Di Bar- tolo and J. Collins (Springer Netherlands, Dordrecht, 2013) pp. 119 -- 176. 6D. P. Lake, M. Mitchell, H. Jayakumar, L. F. dos Santos, D. Curic, and P. E. Barclay, Appl. Phys. Lett. 108, 031109 (2016). 7B. J. Hausmann, I. Bulu, V. Venkataraman, P. Deotare, and M. Loncar, Nature Photon. 8, 369 (2014). 8C. Fabre, V. Sandoghdar, N. Treps, and L. F. Cugilandolo, eds., Quantum Optics and Nanophotonics, Lecture Notes of the Les Houches Summer School, Vol. 101 (Oxford University Press, 2017). 9M. Aspelmeyer, T. J. Kippenberg, and F. Marquardt, Rev. Mod. Phys. 86, 1391 (2014). 10M. Eichenfield, J. Chan, R. Camacho, K. Vahala, and O. Painter, Nature 462, 78 (2009). 11J. Chan, T. P. M. Alegre, A. H. Safavi-Naeini, J. T. Hill, A. Krause, S. Groblacher, M. Aspelmeyer, and O. Painter, Na- ture 478, 89 (2011). 12M. Eichenfield, R. Camacho, J. Chan, K. J. Vahala, and O. Painter, Nature 459, 550 (2009). 13C. Baker, S. Stapfner, D. Parrain, S. Ducci, G. Leo, E. M. Weig, and I. Favero, Opt. Express 20, 29076 (2012). 14Y. Liu, M. Davan¸co, V. Aksyuk, and K. Srinivasan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 223603 (2013). 15A. Schliesser, O. Arcizet, R. Rivi`ere, G. Anetsberger, and T. Kippenberg, Nature Phys. 5, 509 (2009). 16S. Weis, R. Rivi`ere, S. Del´eglise, E. Gavartin, O. Arcizet, A. Schliesser, and T. J. Kippenberg, Science 330, 1520 (2010). 17Y.-S. Park and H. Wang, Nature Phys. 5, 489 (2009). 18C. Dong, V. Fiore, M. C. Kuzyk, and H. Wang, Science 338, 1609 (2012). 19L. Ding, C. Baker, P. Senellart, A. Lemaitre, S. Ducci, G. Leo, and I. Favero, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 263903 (2010). 20B. Guha, S. Mariani, A. Lemaıtre, S. Combri´e, G. Leo, and I. Favero, Opt. Express 25, 24639 (2017). 104, 141104 (2014). 22C. Xiong, X. Sun, K. Y. Fong, and H. X. Tang, Appl. Phys. Lett. 100, 171111 (2012). 23I. Aharonovich, A. D. Greentree, and S. Prawer, Nature Photon. 5, 397 (2011). 24T. Schroder, S. L. Mouradian, J. Zheng, M. E. Trusheim, M. Walsh, E. H. Chen, L. Li, I. Bayn, and D. Englund, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 33, B65 (2016). 25J. Teissier, A. Barfuss, P. Appel, E. Neu, and P. Maletinsky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 020503 (2014). 26P. Ovartchaiyapong, K. W. Lee, B. A. Myers, and A. C. B. Jayich, Nat. Commun. 5, 4429 (2014). 27K. W. Lee, D. Lee, P. Ovartchaiyapong, J. Minguzzi, J. R. Maze, and A. C. Bleszynski Jayich, Phys. Rev. Applied 6, 034005 (2016). 28S. Meesala, Y.-I. Sohn, H. A. Atikian, S. Kim, M. J. Burek, J. T. Choy, and M. Loncar, Phys. Rev. Applied 5, 034010 (2016). 29S. Meesala, Y.-I. Sohn, B. Pingault, L. Shao, H. A. Atikian, J. Holzgrafe, M. Gundogan, C. Stavrakas, A. Sipahigil, C. Chia, R. Evans, M. J. Burek, M. Zhang, L. Wu, J. L. Pacheco, J. Abra- ham, E. Bielejec, M. D. Lukin, M. Atature, and M. Loncar, Phys. Rev. B 97, 205444 (2018). 30D. Englund, B. Shields, K. Rivoire, F. Hatami, J. Vuckovic, H. Park, and M. D. Lukin, Nano Lett. 10, 3922 (2010). 31P. E. Barclay, K. M. C. Fu, C. Santori, A. Faraon, and R. G. Beausoleil, Phys. Rev. X 1, 011007 (2011). 32A. Faraon, P. E. Barclay, C. Santori, K.-M. C. Fu, and R. G. Beausoleil, Nature Photon. 5, 301 (2011). 33J. Riedrich-Moller, C. Arend, C. Pauly, F. Mucklich, M. Fischer, S. Gsell, M. Schreck, and C. Becher, Nano Letters 14, 5281 (2014). 34A. Sipahigil, K. Jahnke, L. Rogers, T. Teraji, J. Isoya, A. Zibrov, F. Jelezko, and M. Lukin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 113602 (2014). 35B. Hensen, H. Bernien, A. E. Dr´eau, A. Reiserer, N. Kalb, M. S. Blok, J. Ruitenberg, R. F. L. Vermeulen, R. N. Schouten, C. Abell´an, W. Amaya, V. Pruneri, M. W. Mitchell, M. Markham, D. J. Twitchen, D. Elkouss, S. Wehner, T. H. Taminiau, and R. Hanson, Nature 526, 682 EP (2015). 36A. Sipahigil, R. E. Evans, D. D. Sukachev, M. J. Burek, J. Bor- regaard, M. K. Bhaskar, C. T. Nguyen, J. L. Pacheco, H. A. Atikian, C. Meuwly, R. M. Camacho, F. Jelezko, E. Bielejec, H. Park, M. Loncar, and M. D. Lukin, Science (2016). 37G. Balasubramanian, P. Neumann, D. Twitchen, M. Markham, R. Kolesov, N. Mizuochi, J. Isoya, J. Achard, J. Beck, J. Tissler, V. Jacques, P. Hemmer, F. Jelezko, and F. Wrachtrup, Nature Mater. 8, 383 (2009). 38N. Bar-Gill, L. Pham, A. Jarmola, D. Budker, and R. Walsworth, Nat. Commun. 4, 1743 (2013). 39D. D. Sukachev, A. Sipahigil, C. T. Nguyen, M. K. Bhaskar, R. E. Evans, F. Jelezko, and M. D. Lukin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 223602 (2017). 40S. Washiyama, S. Mita, K. Suzuki, and A. Sawabe, Applied Physics Express 4, 095502 (2011). 41S. Gsell, T. Bauer, J. Goldfuss, M. Schreck, and B. Stritzker, Appl. Phys. Lett. 84, 4541 (2004). 42M. Fischer, S. Gsell, M. Schreck, R. Brescia, and B. Stritzker, Diamond and Related Materials 17, 1035 (2008), proceedings of Diamond 2007, the 18th European Conference on Diamond, Diamond-Like Materials, Carbon Nanotubes, Nitrides and Sili- con Carbide. 43J. Yaita, T. Iwasaki, M. Natal, S. E. Saddow, and M. Hatano, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics 54, 04DH13 (2015). 44C. F. Wang, R. Hanson, D. D. Awschalom, E. L. Hu, T. Feygel- son, J. Yang, and J. E. Butler, Appl. Phys. Lett. 91, 201112 (2007). 45P. Rath, N. Gruhler, S. Khasminskaya, C. Nebel, C. Wild, and W. H. P. Pernice, Opt. Express 21, 11031 (2013). 46P. Rath, S. Khasminskaya, C. Nebel, C. Wild, and W. H. Per- nice, Nat. Commun. 4, 1690 (2013). 47Y. Chu, N. de Leon, B. Shields, B. Hausmann, R. Evans, E. To- gan, M. J. Burek, M. Markham, A. Stacey, A. Zibrov, A. Yacoby, D. Twitchen, M. Loncar, H. Park, P. Maletinsky, and M. Lukin, Nano Lett. 14, 1982 (2014). 48R. E. Evans, A. Sipahigil, D. D. Sukachev, A. S. Zibrov, and M. D. Lukin, Phys. Rev. Applied 5, 044010 (2016). 49J. C. Lee, I. Aharonovich, A. P. Magyar, F. Rol, and E. L. Hu, 20, 8891 (2012). 50Y. Tao, J. M. Boss, B. A. Moores, and C. L. Degen, Nat. Com- mun. 5, 3638 (2013). 51I. Bayn, S. Mouradian, L. Li, J. A. Goldstein, T. Schroder, J. Zheng, E. H. Chen, O. Gaathon, M. Lu, A. Stein, C. A. Rug- giero, J. Salzman, R. Kalish, and D. Englund, Appl. Phys. Lett. 105, 211101 (2014). 52A. H. Piracha, P. Rath, K. Ganesan, S. Kuhn, W. H. P. Pernice, and S. Prawer, Nano Letters 16, 3341 (2016), pMID: 27111636. 53J. Riedrich-Moller, L. Kipfstuhl, C. Hepp, E. Neu, C. Pauly, F. Mucklich, A. Baur, M. Wandt, S. Wolff, M. Fischer, S. Gsell, M. Schreck, and C. Becher, Nature Nanotech. 7, 69 (2012). 54T. M. Babinec, J. T. Choy, K. J. M. Smith, M. Khan, and M. Loncar, Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B 29, 010601 (2011). 55M. Hiscocks, K. Ganesan, B. Gibson, S. Huntington, F. Ladouceur, and S. Prawer, Opt. Express 16, 19512 (2008). 56H. A. Atikian, P. Latawiec, M. J. Burek, Y.-I. Sohn, S. Meesala, and M. Loncar, APL Photonics 2, N. Gravel, A. B. Kouki, 051301 (2017). 57M. J. Burek, N. P. de Leon, B. J. Shields, B. J. Hausmann, Y. Chu, Q. Quan, A. S. Zibrov, H. Park, M. D. Lukin, and M. Loncar, Nano Lett. 12, 6084 (2012). 58M. J. Burek, Y. Chu, M. S. Z. Liddy, P. Patel, J. Rochman, S. Meesala, W. Hong, Q. Quan, M. D. Lukin, and M. Loncar, Nat. Commun. 5, 5718 (2014). 59M. J. Burek, J. D. Cohen, S. M. Meenehan, N. El-Sawah, C. Chia, T. Ruelle, S. Meesala, J. Rochman, H. A. Atikian, M. Markham, D. J. Twitchen, M. D. Lukin, O. Painter, and M. Loncar, Optica 3, 1404 (2016). 60B. Khanaliloo, M. Mitchell, A. C. Hryciw, and P. E. Barclay, Nano Lett. 15, 5131 (2015). 61B. Khanaliloo, H. Jayakumar, A. C. Hryciw, D. P. Lake, H. Ka- viani, and P. E. Barclay, Phys. Rev. X 5, 041051 (2015). 62M. Mitchell, B. Khanaliloo, D. P. Lake, T. Masuda, J. P. Hadden, and P. E. Barclay, Optica 3, 963 (2016). 63D. P. Lake, M. Mitchell, Y. Kamaliddin, and P. E. Barclay, ACS Photonics 5, 782 (2018). 64T. Kippenberg and K. Vahala, Science 321, 1172 (2008). 65J. T. Hill, A. H. Safavi-Naeini, J. Chan, and O. Painter, Nat. Commun. 3, 1196 (2012). 66M. Mitchell, D. P. Lake, and P. E. Barclay, in Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (Optical Society of America, 2018) p. SF2J.1. 67K. A. Shaw, Z. Zhang, and N. C. MacDonald, Sensors and Ac- tuators A: Physical 40, 63 (1994). 68S. Mouradian, N. H. Wan, T. Schroder, and D. Englund, Appl. Phys. Lett. 111, 021103 (2017). 11 69N. H. Wan, S. Mouradian, and D. Englund, Applied Physics Letters 112, 141102 (2018). 70M. Kiss, T. Graziosi, and N. Quack, in Proc. SPIE, Vol. 10513 (2018). 71X. Ling, Z. T. X., S. R. J., and Y. Amir, Advanced Materials 30, 1705501 (2018). 72J. Isberg, J. Hammersberg, E. Johansson, T. Wikstrom, D. J. Twitchen, A. J. Whitehead, S. E. Coe, and G. A. Scarsbrook, Science 297, 1670 (2002). 73R. S. Balmer, J. R. Brandon, S. L. Clewes, H. K. Dhillon, J. M. Dodson, I. Friel, P. N. Inglis, T. D. Madgwick, M. L. Markham, T. P. Mollart, N. Perkins, G. A. Scarsbrook, D. J. Twitchen, A. J. Whitehead, J. J. Wilman, and S. M. Woollard, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 21, 364221 (2009). 74J. T. Hill, Nonlinear Optics and Wavelength Translation Via Cavity-Optomechanics, Ph.D. thesis, Caltech (2013). 75M. J. Madou, Fundamentals of Microfabrication and Nanotech- nology, 3rd ed., Vol. 2 (CRC Press, 2011). 76M. Borselli, T. J. Johnson, and O. Painter, Opt. Express 13, 1515 (2005). 77T. J. Kippenberg, S. M. Spillane, and K. J. Vahala, Opt. Lett. 27, 1669 (2002). 78S. M. Spillane, T. J. Kippenberg, O. J. Painter, and K. J. Vahala, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 043902 (2003). 79T. Asano, B.-S. Song, and S. Noda, Opt. Express 14, 1996 (2006). 80T. Xu, S. Yang, S. V. Nair, and H. E. Ruda, Phys. Rev. B 75, 125104 (2007). 81C. Kreuzer, J. Riedrich-Moller, E. Neu, and C. Becher, Opt. Express 16, 1632 (2008). 82R. P. Mildren and J. R. Rabeau, eds., Optical Engineering of Diamond (Wiley-VCH Verlag & Co. KGaA, 2013). 83A. F. Oskooi, D. Roundy, M. Ibanescu, P. Bermel, J. Joannopou- los, and S. G. Johnson, Comp. Phys. Comm. 181, 687 (2010). 84T. Carmon, L. Yang, and K. J. Vahala, Opt. Express 12, 4742 (2004). 85P. E. Barclay, K. Srinivasan, and O. Painter, Opt. Express 13, 801 (2005). 86D. T. Nguyen, W. Hease, C. Baker, E. Gil-Santos, P. Senellart, A. Lemaıtre, S. Ducci, G. Leo, and I. Favero, New J. Phys. 17, 023016 (2015). 87C. F. Ockeloen-Korppi, E. Damskagg, J.-M. Pirkkalainen, T. T. Heikkila, F. Massel, and M. A. Sillanpaa, Phys. Rev. X 6, 041024 (2016). 88C. Lee, E. Gu, M. Dawson, I. Friel, and G. Scarsbrook, Diamond and Related Materials 17, 1292 (2008), proceedings of Diamond 2007, the 18th European Conference on Diamond, Diamond-Like Materials, Carbon Nanotubes, Nitrides and Silicon Carbide. 89M. Borselli, T. J. Johnson, and O. Painter, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 131114 (2006). 90T. Graziosi, S. Mi, M. Kiss, and N. Quack, APL Photonics 3, 126101 (2018).
1711.05670	2	1711	2017-12-22T21:24:52	Anti-reflection coating design for metallic terahertz meta-materials	[ "physics.app-ph", "cond-mat.other" ]	We demonstrate a silicon-based, single-layer anti-reflection coating that suppresses the reflectivity of metals at near-infrared frequencies, enabling optical probing of nano-scale structures embedded in highly reflective surroundings. Our design does not affect the interaction of terahertz radiation with metallic structures that can be used to achieve terahertz near-field enhancement. We have verified the functionality of the design by calculating and measuring the reflectivity of both infrared and terahertz radiation from a silicon/gold double layer as a function of the silicon thickness. We have also fabricated the unit cell of a terahertz meta-material, a dipole antenna comprising two 20-nm thick extended gold plates separated by a 2 $\mu$m gap, where the terahertz field is locally enhanced. We used the time-domain finite element method to demonstrate that such near-field enhancement is preserved in the presence of the anti-reflection coating. Finally, we performed magneto-optical Kerr effect measurements on a single 3-nm thick, 1-$\mu$m wide magnetic wire placed in the gap of such a dipole antenna. The wire only occupies 2\% of the area probed by the laser beam, but its magneto-optical response can be clearly detected. Our design paves the way for ultrafast time-resolved studies, using table-top femtosecond near-infrared lasers, of dynamics in nano-structures driven by strong terahertz radiation.	physics.app-ph	physics	Anti-reflection coating design for metallic terahertz meta-materials MATTEO PANCALDI1,2, RYAN FREEMAN3, MATTHIAS HUDL1, MATTHIAS C. HOFFMANN4, SERGEI URAZHDIN3, PAOLO VAVASSORI2,5 AND STEFANO BONETTI1,* 1Department of Physics, Stockholm University, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden 2CIC nanoGUNE, E-20018 Donostia-San Sebastian, Spain 3Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA 4SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA 5IKERBASQUE, Basque Foundation for Science, E-48013 Bilbao, Spain *[email protected] Abstract: We demonstrate a silicon-based, single-layer anti-reflection coating that suppresses the reflectivity of metals at near-infrared frequencies, enabling optical probing of nano-scale structures embedded in highly reflective surroundings. Our design does not affect the interaction of terahertz radiation with metallic structures that can be used to achieve terahertz near-field enhancement. We have verified the functionality of the design by calculating and measuring the reflectivity of both infrared and terahertz radiation from a silicon/gold double layer as a function of the silicon thickness. We have also fabricated the unit cell of a terahertz meta-material, a dipole antenna comprising two 20-nm thick extended gold plates separated by a 2 µm gap, where the terahertz field is locally enhanced. We used the time-domain finite element method to demonstrate that such near-field enhancement is preserved in the presence of the anti-reflection coating. Finally, we performed magneto-optical Kerr effect measurements on a single 3-nm thick, 1-µm wide magnetic wire placed in the gap of such a dipole antenna. The wire only occupies 2% of the area probed by the laser beam, but its magneto-optical response can be clearly detected. Our design paves the way for ultrafast time-resolved studies, using table-top femtosecond near-infrared lasers, of dynamics in nano-structures driven by strong terahertz radiation. © 2017 Optical Society of America under the terms of the OSA Open Access Publishing Agreement OCIS codes: (300.6495) Spectroscopy, terahertz; (320.2250) Femtosecond phenomena; (160.3918) Metamaterials; (160.3820) Magneto-optical materials. References and links 1. M. C. Hoffmann and J. A. Fülöp, "Intense ultrashort terahertz pulses: generation and applications ," J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 44(8), 083001 (2011). 2. M. Trigo, Y. M. Sheu, D. A. Arms, J. Chen, S. Ghimire, R. S. Goldman, E. Landahl, R. Merlin, E. Peterson, M. Reason, and D. A. Reis, "Probing Unfolded Acoustic Phonons with X Rays," Phys. Rev. Lett. 101(2), 025505 (2008). 3. M. Liu, H. Y. Hwang, H. Tao, A. C. Strikwerda, K. Fan, G. R. Keiser, A. J. Sternbach, K. G. West, S. Kittiwatanakul, J. Lu, S. A. Wolf, F. G. Omenetto, X. Zhang, K. A. Nelson, and R. D. Averitt, "Terahertz-field-induced insulator-to-metal transition in vanadium dioxide metamaterial," Nature 487(7407), 345–348 (2012). 4. D. Daranciang, M. J. Highland, H. Wen, S. M. Young, N. C. Brandt, H. Y. Hwang, M. Vattilana, M. Nicoul, F. Quirin, J. Goodfellow, T. Qi, I. Grinberg, D. M. Fritz, M. Cammarata, D. Zhu, H. T. Lemke, D. A. Walko, E. M. Dufresne, Y. Li, J. Larsson, D. A. Reis, K. Sokolowski-Tinten, K. A. Nelson, A. M. Rappe, P. H. Fuoss, G. B. Stephenson, and A. M. Lindenberg, "Ultrafast Photovoltaic Response in Ferroelectric Nanolayers," Phys. Rev. Lett. 108(8), 087601 (2012). 5. R. Mankowsky, A. Subedi, M. Först, S. O. Mariager, M. Chollet, H. T. Lemke, J. S. Robinson, J. M. Glownia, M. P. Minitti, A. Frano, M. Fechner, N. A. Spaldin, T. Loew, B. Keimer, A. Georges, and A. Cavalleri, "Nonlinear lattice dynamics as a basis for enhanced superconductivity in YBa2Cu3O6.5," Nature 516(7529), 71–73 (2014). 6. U. Staub, R. A. de Souza, P. Beaud, E. Möhr-Vorobeva, G. Ingold, A. Caviezel, V. Scagnoli, B. Delley, W. F. Schlotter, J. J. Turner, O. Krupin, W.-S. Lee, Y.-D. Chuang, L. Patthey, R. G. Moore, D. Lu, M. Yi, P. S. Kirchmann, M. Trigo, P. Denes, D. Doering, Z. Hussain, Z. X. Shen, D. Prabhakaran, A. T. Boothroyd, and S. L. Johnson, "Persistence of magnetic order in a highly excited Cu2+ state in CuO," Phys. Rev. B 89(22), 220401(R) (2014). 7. P. Beaud, A. Caviezel, S. O. Mariager, L. Rettig, G. Ingold, C. Dornes, S.-W. Huang, J. A. Johnson, M. Radovic, T. Huber, T. Kubacka, A. Ferrer, H. T. Lemke, M. Chollet, D. Zhu, J. M. Glownia, M. Sikorski, A. Robert, H. Wadati, M. Nakamura, M. Kawasaki, Y. Tokura, S. L. Johnson, and U. Staub, "A time-dependent order parameter for ultrafast photoinduced phase transitions," Nat. Mater. 13(10), 923–927 (2014). 8. T. Kubacka, J. A. Johnson, M. C. Hoffmann, C. Vicario, S. de Jong, P. Beaud, S. Grübel, S.-W. Huang, L. Huber, L. Patthey, Y.-D. Chuang, J. J. Turner, G. L. Dakovski, W.-S. Lee, M. P. Minitti, W. Schlotter, R. G. Moore, C. P. Hauri, S. M. Koohpayeh, V. Scagnoli, G. Ingold, S. L. Johnson, and U. Staub, "Large-Amplitude Spin Dynamics Driven by a THz Pulse in Resonance with an Electromagnon," Science 343(6177), 1333–1336 (2014). 9. G. L. Dakovski, W.-S. Lee, D. G. Hawthorn, N. Garner, D. Bonn, W. Hardy, R. Liang, M. C. Hoffmann, and J. J. Turner, "Enhanced coherent oscillations in the superconducting state of underdoped YBa2Cu3O6+x induced via ultrafast terahertz excitation," Phys. Rev. B 91(22), 220506(R) (2015). 10. S. Bonetti, M. C. Hoffmann, M.-J. Sher, Z. Chen, S.-H. Yang, M. G. Samant, S. S. P. Parkin, and H. A. Dürr, "THz-Driven Ultrafast Spin-Lattice Scattering in Amorphous Metallic Ferromagnets," Phys. Rev. Lett. 117(8), 087205 (2016). 11. M. P. M. Dean, Y. Cao, X. Liu, S. Wall, D. Zhu, R. Mankowsky, V. Thampy, X. M. Chen, J. G. Vale, D. Casa, J. Kim, A. H. Said, P. Juhas, R. Alonso-Mori, J. M. Glownia, A. Robert, J. Robinson, M. Sikorski, S. Song, M. Kozina, H. Lemke, L. Patthey, S. Owada, T. Katayama, M. Yabashi, Y. Tanaka, T. Togashi, J. Liu, C. Rayan Serrao, B. J. Kim, L. Huber, C.-L. Chang, D. F. McMorrow, M. Först, and J. P. Hill, "Ultrafast energy- and momentum-resolved dynamics of magnetic correlations in the photo-doped Mott insulator Sr2IrO4," Nat. Mater. 15(6), 601–605 (2016). 12. T. Henighan, M. Trigo, M. Chollet, J. N. Clark, S. Fahy, J. M. Glownia, M. P. Jiang, M. Kozina, H. Liu, S. Song, D. Zhu, and D. A. Reis, "Control of two-phonon correlations and the mechanism of high-wavevector phonon generation by ultrafast light pulses," Phys. Rev. B 94(2), 020302(R) (2016). 13. S. Grübel, J. A. Johnson, P. Beaud, C. Dornes, A. Ferrer, V. Haborets, L. Huber, T. Huber, A. Kohutych, T. Kubacka, M. Kubli, S. O. Mariager, J. Rittmann, J. I. Saari, Y. Vysochanskii, G. Ingold, and S. L. Johnson, "Ultrafast x-ray diffraction of a ferroelectric soft mode driven by broadband terahertz pulses," arXiv:1602.05435v1 (2016). 14. F. Chen, Y. Zhu, S. Liu, Y. Qi, H. Y. Hwang, N. C. Brandt, J. Lu, F. Quirin, H. Enquist, P. Zalden, T. Hu, J. Goodfellow, M.-J. Sher, M. C. Hoffmann, D. Zhu, H. Lemke, J. Glownia, M. Chollet, A. R. Damodaran, J. Park, Z. Cai, I. W. Jung, M. J. Highland, D. A. Walko, J. W. Freeland, P. G. Evans, A. Vailionis, J. Larsson, K. A. Nelson, A. M. Rappe, K. Sokolowski-Tinten, L. W. Martin, H. Wen, and A. M. Lindenberg, "Ultrafast terahertz-field-driven ionic response in ferroelectric BaTiO3," Phys. Rev. B 94(18), 180104(R) (2016). devices," Nature 444(7119), 597–600 (2006). 15. H.-T. Chen, W. J. Padilla, J. M. O. Zide, A. C. Gossard, A. J. Taylor, and R. D. Averitt, "Active terahertz metamaterial 16. L. Razzari, A. Toma, M. Shalaby, M. Clerici, R. Proietti Zaccaria, C. Liberale, S. Marras, I. A. I. Al-Naib, G. Das, F. De Angelis, M. Peccianti, A. Falqui, T. Ozaki, R. Morandotti, and E. Di Fabrizio, "Extremely large extinction efficiency and field enhancement in terahertz resonant dipole nanoantennas," Opt. Express 19(27), 26088–26094 (2011). 17. C. A. Werley, K. Fan, A. C. Strikwerda, S. M. Teo, X. Zhang, R. D. Averitt, and K. A. Nelson, "Time-resolved imaging of near-fields in THz antennas and direct quantitative measurement of field enhancements," Opt. Express 20(8), 8551–8567 (2012). 18. J. Zhang, X. Zhao, K. Fan, X. Wang, G.-F. Zhang, K. Geng, X. Zhang, and R. D. Averitt, "Terahertz radiation-induced sub-cycle field electron emission across a split-gap dipole antenna," Appl. Phys. Lett. 107(23), 231101 (2015). 19. M. Savoini, S. Grübel, S. Bagiante, H. Sigg, T. Feurer, P. Beaud, and S. L. Johnson, "THz near-field enhancement by means of isolated dipolar antennas: the effect of finite sample size," Opt. Express 24(5), 4552–4562 (2016). 20. M. Kozina, M. Pancaldi, C. Bernhard, T. van Driel, J.M. Glownia, P. Marsik, M. Radovic, C. A. F. Vaz, D. Zhu, S. Bonetti, U. Staub, and M.C. Hoffmann, "Local Terahertz Field Enhancement for Time-Resolved X-ray Diffraction," Appl. Phys. Lett. 110(8), 081106 (2017). 21. K. Balasubramanian, A. S. Marathay, and H. A. Macleod, "Modeling magneto-optical thin film media for optical data storage," Thin Solid Films 164, 391–403 (1988). 22. R. Atkinson, I. W. Salter, and J. Xu, "Quadrilayer magneto-optic enhancement with zero Kerr ellipticity," J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 102(3), 357–364 (1991). 23. N. Qureshi, H. Schmidt, and A. R. Hawkins, "Cavity enhancement of the magneto-optic Kerr effect for optical studies of magnetic nanostructures," Appl. Phys. Lett. 85(3), 431 (2004). 24. N. Qureshi, S. Wang, M. A. Lowther, A. R. Hawkins, S. Kwon, A. Liddle, J. Bokor, and H. Schmidt, "Cavity-Enhanced Magnetooptical Observation of Magnetization Reversal in Individual Single-Domain Nanomagnets," Nano Lett. 5(7), 1413–1417 (2005). 25. A. Barman, S. Wang, J. D. Maas, A. R. Hawkins, S. Kwon, A. Liddle, J. Bokor, and H. Schmidt, "Magneto-Optical Observation of Picosecond Dynamics of Single Nanomagnets," Nano Lett. 6(12), 2939–2944 (2006). 26. S. Wang, A. Barman, H. Schmidt, J. D. Maas, A. R. Hawkins, S. Kwon, B. Harteneck, S. Cabrini, and J. Bokor, "Optimization of nano-magneto-optic sensitivity using dual dielectric layer enhancement," Appl. Phys. Lett. 90(25), 252504 (2007). 27. P. Biagioni, J.-S. Huang, and B. Hecht, "Nanoantennas for visible and infrared radiation," Rep. Prog. Phys. 75(2), 024402 (2012). 28. G. Hass, H. H. Schroeder, and A. F. Turner, "Mirror Coatings for Low Visible and High Infrared Reflectance," J. Opt. Soc. Am. 46(1), 31–35 (1956). 29. S. Yoshida, "Antireflection coatings on metals for selective solar absorbers," Thin Solid Films 56(3), 321–329 (1979). 30. K. C. Park, "The Extreme Values of Reflectivity and the Conditions for Zero Reflection from Thin Dielectric Films on Metal," Appl. Opt. 3(7), 877–881 (1964). 31. S. Adachi and H. Mori, "Optical properties of fully amorphous silicon," Phys. Rev. B 62(15), 10158 (2000). 32. M. Born and E. Wolf, Principles of Optics (Cambridge University, 1999). 33. M. N. Polyanskiy, "Refractive index database," https://refractiveindex.info. 34. F. D. J. Brunner, O-P. Kwon, S.-J. Kwon, M. Jazbinšek, A. Schneider, and P. Günter, "A hydrogen-bonded organic nonlinear optical crystal for high-efficiency terahertz generation and detection," Opt. Express 16(21), 16496–16508 (2008). 35. COMSOL Multiphysics® v. 5.3. https://www.comsol.com. COMSOL, AB, Stockholm, Sweden. 36. Since we are impinging on the air/silicon interface at normal incidence with a wavelength of ≈ 300 µm, the amplitude of the electric field at z = 10 nm above the silicon substrate is almost equal to the amplitude of the transmitted electric field, because of the n ×(cid:16) (cid:174)ES i − (cid:174)E Air (cid:17) = 0 boundary condition. 37. The discrepancy between the two values has to do with the fact that the single-cycle field is broadband, and different frequencies are amplified differently by a fixed-geometry design. 38. Z. Q. Qiu and S. D. Bader, "Surface magneto-optic Kerr effect," Rev. Sci. Instrum. 71(3), 1243 (2000). 39. P. Vavassori, "Polarization modulation technique for magneto-optical quantitative vector magnetometry," Appl. Phys. Lett. 77(11), 1605 (2000). Introduction 1. Following the development of intense, coherent laser-based sources of terahertz radiation [1], the past decade has witnessed an increased interest in the use of this type of radiation to coherently control the properties of materials on the sub-picosecond time scale. Terahertz photons, with energies in the meV range, can drive nonlinear dynamics without significantly increasing the entropy of the system [2–14]. In the field of condensed matter physics, the investigations of ultrafast dynamics driven by strong terahertz fields are frequently performed using terahertz-pump (usually in the 1 - 10 THz range, 300 to 30 µm in wavelength) and visible or near-infrared probing light (typically a sub-100 fs pulse). To study the effects in the strong-field limit, the strength of the terahertz field can be locally enhanced exploiting near-field effects in meta-materials [3,15–20], which typically consist of micrometer-sized metallic structures deposited on the sample surface. However, since the area of the sample is often significantly smaller than the area of metallic structures in meta-materials, the reflectivity in the visible or near-infrared frequency range of the probe is dominated by the latter. As a consequence, it is extremely challenging to isolate the sample response, despite the enhancement provided by the meta-material. This problem can be mitigated by using dielectric and absorbing coatings, for instance to enhance the magneto-optical activity in magnetic thin films, and to reduce the background reflections [21–26]. This solution greatly boosts the signal up to a point where single nano-structures can be measured. The drawback of this approach is that it imposes constraints on the choice of layers underneath the target structure. This limitation can become crucial if these underlayers are utilized to tune the important properties of the studied thin films. In this case, a more suitable solution is to deposit an anti-reflection (AR) coating only on the metal structures forming the meta-material, to minimize the reflection from those areas, which is the main factor affecting the strength of the measured signal. At the same time, the AR layer should not perturb the terahertz radiation that still needs to be enhanced by the metal layers. In this work, we propose a simple, but until now unexplored, single-layer anti-reflection coating design that can be implemented on arbitrary meta-material structures comprising highly conducting and reflective metallic layers. The coating suppresses the near-infrared reflection typically utilized to probe the response of the sample, without noticeably affecting the terahertz radiation at much larger wavelengths. We have performed transfer matrix method calculations, as well as measurements of the reflectivity both in the near-infrared and terahertz range, to demonstrate the functionality of our design. We have also investigated, using time-domain finite element simulations, the near-field enhancement properties of a dipole antenna - a template for Fig. 1. Design of the dipole antenna for terahertz near-field enhancement in the gap between two metallic electrodes, covered with an anti-reflection coating for near-infrared and visible radiation. A single-cycle of the terahertz field, with the suitable polarization for the optimal coupling to the antenna, is sketched. The pink arrows schematically show the working principle of the anti-reflection coating for a metal, where destructive interference (zig-zag arrows within the top layer) is combined with the dielectric losses to compensate for the forbidden transmission through the metallic electrodes (crossed-out arrows in the metal layer), as described in detail in the text. the terahertz meta-materials - covered with the anti-reflection coating. Finally, we experimentally measured the magneto-optical Kerr effect from a magnetic wire placed in the gap of the antenna. 2. Anti-reflection coating design Terahertz meta-materials can be formed by depositing metallic (typically gold) layers that can locally enhance the electromagnetic field of incident radiation. One of the simplest realization of such structure consists of two metallic strips separated by a small gap, i.e. a dipole antenna [27]. For a suitable geometry of the antenna and polarization of the incident radiation, opposite charges can be induced by the electromagnetic field at the opposite edges of the gap, producing a strong local enhancement of electric field within the gap. Intuitively, but incorrectly, this charge motion is often attributed to the current driven by the electric field. However, the correct explanation is that the local electric field enhancement in the gap is caused by the screening of the magnetic field, which induces a current flow in the metal, in the direction orthogonal to it (parallel to the electric field). This current flow, known as the eddy current, can penetrate within the skin depth of the material (75 nm at 1 THz for gold). In contrast, the electric field component of the radiation is screened virtually instantaneously at the surface of the conductor by the charge redistribution, and at terahertz frequencies provides a negligible contribution to the net current flow in the bulk of the material, even in non-ideal metals. In the standard AR coatings, designed to minimize the reflection from dielectric materials, one exploits the phenomenon of destructive interference of the waves reflected at the two interfaces, to cancel the total electric field that propagates in the backward direction. Since the energy of α-SiMetalETHzHTHzNIR/VIS laserTHz E-field enhancement region Single-cycle THz pulsethe electromagnetic wave is conserved, the transmission through the dielectric is maximized. However, this mechanism cannot be implemented for coatings on metals, since the wave cannot propagate through the metal, and hence the reflection cannot be eliminated. For an AR coating to work for a metal, it is necessary to create destructive interference (to suppress Fresnel reflections), and to simultaneously absorb the radiation, as shown schematically in Fig. 1. In other words, the dielectric layer needs to be sufficiently lossy in the visible/near- infrared region, so that the wave decays after multiple reflections at the interfaces. This idea was proposed decades ago by Hass et al. [28], who demonstrated that lossy double dielectric layers can suppress the reflectivity of aluminum and copper in the visible range, while maintaining high-reflectivity in the mid-infrared range, up to the wavelength of 10 µm. Moreover, they also highlighted the fact that absorption in single-layer AR coatings is necessary to reduce the high reflectance of metals in the visible range. In a later related work by Yoshida [29], a single-layer AR coating for metals was described mathematically. He first considered a non-absorbing dielectric layer with real refractive index n1 > 1 and thickness d1, deposited on top of a metallic substrate characterized by n2 = n2 + ik2. The reflectance R for the monochromatic light with wavelength λ, impinging at normal incidence on the three-layers stack composed of the air (n0 = 1), the non-absorbing dielectric coating, and the metal substrate, is given by [29] R = (1) where r01 = (1 − n1)/(1 + n1) is the Fresnel reflection coefficient for the air-dielectric interface, r12 = (n1 − n2)/(n1 + n2) is the Fresnel reflection coefficient for the dielectric-metal interface, and δ1 = 2πn1d1/λ. The reflectance reaches a minimum when [30], 1 + r01r12 exp(2iδ1) , where m is an integer value, and Rmin = (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)2 (cid:105) , (cid:35) 1 2 (cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12)(cid:12) r01 + r12 exp(2iδ1) (cid:104)(m + 1) − α12 (cid:19)2 (cid:34)(n1 − n2)2 + k2 (cid:18) (n1 + n2)2 + k2 2π λ 2 2 , n1d1 = (cid:18) r01 + ρ12 1 + r01 ρ12 ρ12 = r12 = α12 = Arg(r12) = arctan , 2 −2n1k2 n12 − n22 − k2 (cid:19) 1 2 . (cid:18) n1 = n2 + 2 k2 n2 − 1 (cid:19) . 2 (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) The minimum reflectance Rmin is zero when ρ12 = r01, giving If k2 = 0, which corresponds to a dielectric coating on top of a dielectric substrate, Eq. (6) gives 1/2. Since n2 > n1, the solution for α12 = arctan(0) in Eq. (5) should be α12 = π, because n1 = n2 of the π phase shift introduced by the dielectric coating-dielectric substrate interface in this case. Thus, Eq. (2) gives n1d1 = λ/4 for m = 0, defining a quarter-wave coating, in which the reflectance is minimized by the destructive interference in the coating layer. Moreover, Eq. (6) imposes a constraint on the values of n2 and k2, since n1 > 1. The effect of this constraint is that, according to Yoshida [29], "zero reflection cannot be achieved with a single dielectric film coating for metals" with large extinction coefficient k (cid:39) 3, such as silver and gold. However, Fig. 2. (Solid curves: Calculated reflectance at the wavelength of 800 nm for the Air/α- Si/Au/Si(substrate)/Air multilayer, as a function of the α-Si thickness, for two different Au thicknesses at normal incidence. Dashed curve: Calculated reflectance at a wavelength of 800 nm for an ideal dielectric on top of a 100 nm Au layer, characterized by n = 3.9 and zero imaginary part of the refractive index. in this case, zero reflection can be obtained by allowing the dielectric coating to be slightly absorbing. In the following, we experimentally confirm that the reflection from gold, and hence from any good metal, can be suppressed by using a single layer of sputtered amorphous silicon (α-Si). In the visible/near-infrared range, a thin α-Si film acts as a dielectric with a relatively large imaginary part of the refractive index, since the electronic states are not characterized by well-defined momentum, enhancing the radiation absorption in α-Si as compared to its crystalline form [31]. On the other hand, low absorption in the terahertz range (λ ∼ 100 µm), and the small thickness compared to the radiation wavelength, make these layers practically invisible, thus maintaining the high-reflectivity characteristics of gold in this range. We first used the transfer matrix method (TMM) [32] to simulate the feasibility of this approach. We simulated the Air/α-Si/Au/Si(substrate)/Air multilayer, where the outermost Air layers were semi-infinite, and the substrate was 500 µm thick. The radiation was assumed to be monochromatic with a wavelength of 800 nm, the typical center-wavelength of a Ti:sapphire laser, at a normal incidence to the multilayer stack. We used the refractive indices nAir = 1, nα−Si ≈ 3.90 + 0.11j, nAu ≈ 0.15 + 4.91j, and nSi ≈ 3.681 + 0.005j [33]. In Fig. 2 we plot the reflectance of the stack as a function of the α-Si thickness, for two gold layers with different thickness. For thin gold (20 nm), part of the radiation can be transmitted into the substrate, and ≈ 30 nm of amorphous silicon on top of it can efficiently suppress the reflectivity. For thick gold (100 nm), enough to prevent any transmission, a thicker amorphous silicon layer (≈ 230 nm) is needed to achieve the same suppression. In the same figure, we also plot the reflectivity (dashed lines) of a fictitious dielectric layer with zero imaginary part of the refractive index, and its magnitude equal to that of the the amorphous silicon, representing a conventional dielectric with negligible losses. It is evident that such a layer on top of a 100-nm thick gold layer cannot efficiently suppress the reflectivity, demonstrating that the cumulative losses after multiple reflections are necessary to realize the anti-reflection configuration. We note that a single α-Si anti-reflection coating remains efficient over a broad range of incidence angles. We used TMM to check that, when varying the incidence angle from 0 to 050100150200250300amorphousSiThickness(nm)0.00.20.40.60.81.0Reflectance20nmAu100nmAu100nmAu,nSirealFig. 3. Experimental (symbols) and calculated (line) reflectance for a α-Si/Au/Si(substrate) sample based on a 20 nm-thick Au layer, at wavelengths of 800 nm (magenta) and 300 µm (black), the latter corresponding to the radiation frequency of 1 THz. 37.5 degrees, the optimal thickness for the α-Si layer varies by less than 2%. Furthermore, at the optimal thickness, the 800 nm reflectance remains below 0.05 (an acceptable value for the coating to properly work), at angles of incidence as high as 50 degrees. This can be understood as a consequence of the large refractive index of silicon, which causes the electromagnetic wave to strongly refract when entering the AR layer. As a result, the optical path in the silicon layer noticeably increases only at very large angles of incidence. 3. Experimental and numerical verification In Fig. 3, we plot the calculated and the measured reflectance for several Air/α-Si(t)/Au(20 nm)/Si(substrate)/Air multilayers, as a function of t, both for 800 nm and for the terahertz radiation impinging on the sample at 10 degrees incidence. The 800 nm radiation was produced by the Ti:sapphire-based regenerative amplifier (Coherent Legend) in 40 fs pulses, with the 30 nm FWHM bandwidth around the center 800 nm wavelength, as measured by a grating spectrometer. The reflectance at 800 nm was measured directly using a photodiode. The signal was scaled using the known reflectance value of a commercial gold mirror. The reflectance R of the terahertz radiation, generated by optical rectification in a OH1 organic crystal [34], was determine from the measured transmittance T, using R = 1− A− T, where the absorption A was calculated based on the TMM. The transmittance was taken to be proportional to the square of the normalized amplitude of the maximum electro-optical sampling signal in a 100 µm thick, 110-cut GaP crystal. The excellent agreement between the data and the calculations directly demonstrates the functionality of our design in suppressing the near-infrared reflectivity, with the appropriate thickness of α-Si, 27 nm and 127 nm in the studied case of 800 nm radiation. We emphasize that our experiment demonstrates efficient suppression of the broadband 40 fs pulses of 800 nm radiation. This is not surprising, considering that the bandwidth to carrier ratio is less than 4%. This result confirms the suitability of our design for the conventional ultrafast experiments. On the other hand, the terahertz reflectivity is unchanged by the α-Si layer, suggesting that the terahertz near-field enhancement is also likely unaffected the silicon layer. However, since the measured reflectivity is a far-field property, and near-field properties are in general very sensitive to interface effects, one needs to perform a more detailed investigation of the possible effects of the anti-reflection coating on the terahertz radiation in the near-field regime. 0255075100125150amorphousSiThickness(nm)0.00.20.40.60.81.0ReflectanceTMM800nmExp.800nmTMM1THzExp.THzFig. 4. (a) Frequency-domain, finite element analysis of the enhancement map for a monochromatic electromagnetic field with frequency f = 1 THz incident on two gold plates separated by a gap. (b) Time-domain finite element simulations of the x-component of the electric field for a single-cycle (broadband) terahertz field at the center of the gap, without Au plates (solid black curve), with Au plates (solid gray curve) and with α-Si/Au plates (filled gray dots). In all the calculations, the electric field of the incident radiation is polarized along the x−axis, and the propagation direction is along the z−axis, normal to the sample plane. To analyze the near-field effects of the coating, we have performed finite-element numerical calculations using COMSOL Multiphysics®software [35]. In Fig. 4(a), we plot the electric field enhancement at a frequency of 1 THz, for a set of two infinitely long, 65 µm wide, 20 nm thick gold plates separated by a gap of 2 µm. The terahertz electric field is applied along the x−axis in this Figure. The field enhancement is computed by dividing the electric field value in the gap region by the electric field value at the air/silicon interface, in the absence of the gold plates. In Fig. 4(b), we plot time-dependence of the x-component of the terahertz electric field in the middle of the gap (x = 0), and at z = 10 nm above the silicon substrate. The simulation used the experimental time profile of the impinging terahertz field, measured by electro-optical sampling, with the peak value of ≈ 300 kV/cm. For the bare silicon-air interface, the terahertz field is reduced to approximately half of its free-space magnitude, consistent with the relative amplitude of the transmitted wave at an air/silicon interface computed as t = 2/(n + 1), with n ≈ 3.4 [36]. The presence of the gold plates introduces a slight temporal shift, and enhances the amplitude of the terahertz field to more than 500 kV/cm, consistent with the ≈ 4 times enhancement observed in the frequency domain simulations of Fig. 4(a) [37]. Most importantly, the addition of the α-Si layer on top of the gold plates does not noticeably affect the field, confirming our intuitive conclusions based on the negligible effect of the α-Si layer on the terahertz reflectivity. To test the functionality of the AR coating in a practical configuration, we measured the polar magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) [38] from the 3 nm-thick CoNi film patterned into a 1 µm- wide, 100 µm-long wire. The CoNi stack is formed by a Ta(2)Cu(2)[Co(0.2)Ni(1)]3Ni(0.5)Ta(3) multilayer (thicknesses in nm) with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy. The wire is located in the 2 µm-wide gap between two 100 µm long and 65 µm wide gold plates, coated with 27 nm of α-Si. By analyzing the magneto-optic response, we can unambiguously identify the signal coming from the embedded CoNi wire, with no contribution from the non-magnetic electrodes. As the MOKE signal typically results in a tiny intensity variation on top of a large background, this specific system implementation also demonstrates the general suitability of our design for −2−1012x(µm)05101520z(nm)atf=1THzAuAuAir(a)567E-fieldenhancement01Time(ps)−400−2000200400Electricfieldingap(kV/cm)(b)NoAuAuSi/AuFig. 5. Polar Kerr ellipticity as a function of the magnetic field applied orthogonal to the sample plane, for the 800 nm and 550 nm wavelengths of the probing light. Symbols: average of 25 hysteresis loops for a 1 µm-wide, 100 µm-long CoNi wire. Solid curves: average of 4 hysteresis loops hysteresis loops for a 100 µm × 100 µm CoNi square, at the same wavelengths. Inset: Zoom in on the 550 nm wavelength hysteresis loop for the CoNi wire. the detection of small effects other than magneto-optical ones. The polar MOKE loops from the embedded wire are plotted in the main panel of Fig. 5 for two different wavelengths of the probing radiation, 550 nm and 800 nm. At 800 nm, the AR coating optimized for this wavelength is expected to completely suppress the reflectivity of the gold electrodes, while at 550 nm, a substantial reflection from the metallic pads is expected. Using radiation of different wavelengths is geometrically equivalent to studying samples with different AR coating thickness, with the advantage that the very same sample can be used and the wavelength can be tuned very accurately. The plotted MOKE signals reflect the change in the polarization ellipticity of the probing light, determined with a suitable polarization analyzing system. In these measurements, we utilized a polarization modulation technique [39] to provide the sensitivity necessary for testing the effectiveness of the proposed AR coating. In this setup, the polarization of the incident light was modulated at the frequency ω, while both the total measured intensity I0 and its variation Iω at the modulation frequency were simultaneously recorded. The polarization ellipticity was determined from Iω normalized by the total intensity I0 reflected from the sample. While the variations of Iω were affected only by the magnetic structure, the magnitude of I0 is determined by the whole probed area, including the gold plates. The data plotted with symbols in Fig. 5 clearly show that the AR coating significantly enhances the signal-to-background ratio, resulting in a more than a ten-fold increase of the realtive amplitude of the loop at the design wavelength. We have checked that the increase in the relative signal is not caused by the difference between the magneto-optical constants of CoNi between 800 and 550 nm wavelengths, by measuring the MOKE signal from a 100 µm × 100 µm CoNi square of 3 nm thickness, with no gold electrodes surrounding the structure. The resulting hysteresis loops are shown with solid curves in the the same Fig. 5. To quantitatively analyze our observations, we note that if the areas and the reflectivity of different reflecting regions are known, one can predict the difference in the total measured Kerr ellipticity K between the CoNi square larger than the probing spot, and the wire-shaped sample, −50050µ0H(mT)−0.75−0.50−0.250.000.250.500.75KerrEllipticity(mrad)800nm550nm−50050µ0H(mT)−0.010.000.01Table 1. Summary of the ellipticity ratio between a CoNi wire and a CoNi square calculated according to Eq. (7). 550 nm (theor.) 550 nm (exp.) 800 nm (theor.) 800 nm (exp.) RCoNi 0.49 0.46 0.47 0.49 RSi 0.40 0.40 0.36 0.34 RCoatedAu 0.50 0.50 0.020 0.031 K,wire/K,square 0.017 0.016 0.24 0.19 according to [24] K,wire K,square = Awire + ASi RSi RCoNi Awire + ACoatedAu RCoatedAu , RCoNi (7) where Am is the total area occupied by a certain material m illuminated by the laser beam, and Rm the corresponding reflectivity that can be measured experimentally or calculated using Fresnel equations. Table 1 summarizes the relationship between the ellipticity of the wire and the ellipticity of the square, assuming that the probing light is focused in to a uniform circular spot with diameter φ = 75 µm, and the various probed areas are Awire = ASi ≈ φh (h = 1 µm), ACoatedAu ≈ π(φ/2)2 − 2φh. The area occupied by the wire is therefore about 2% of the total area. Indeed, for the wavelength of 550 nm, at which the Au reflectivity is not suppressed by the AR coating, the ellipticity signal for the wire is about 1.6% of that for the large square, both theoretically and experimentally. In contrast, for the 800 nm wavelength, we expect and observe an increase of this ratio by an order of magnitude. The deviation between the theoretically expected value (24%) and the experimental value (19%) can be explained by a combination of a few-nm uncertainty in the deposited material thickness, deviations of the optical properties of different layers from their nominal values, and by the effects of the nanowire and gold electrode edges, whose scattering properties were not taken into account in the calculations reported in Table 1. 4. Conclusion In summary, we have designed and experimentally demonstrated an anti-reflection coating for highly reflective metals, which are typically utilized in the fabrication of terahertz meta-materials. The anti-reflection coating can efficiently suppress the reflection of light in the visible and infrared ranges, typically used in the studies of ultrafast phenomena by pump-probe techniques. At the same time, the coating does not perturb the propagation of terahertz radiation, and does not affect the near-field enhancement in the meta-materials. Our results are expected to open a path for time-resolved experiments aimed at probing the ultrafast dynamics driven in nano-scale structures by strong terahertz fields, by using table-top femtosecond near-infrared laser sources. Funding Swedish Research Council (Grant E0635001); Marie Skłodowska Curie Actions, Cofund (Project INCA 600398s); European Research Council (ERC) (Starting Grant 715452 "MAGNETIC- SPEED-LIMIT"); H2020 European Union Programme, FETOPEN-2016-2017 (Project 737093 "FEMTOTERABYTE"); Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness under the Maria de Maeztu Units of Excellence Programme - MDM-2016-0618; US National Science Foundation (NSF) (Grant ECCS-1503878, Grant DMR-1504449); U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Award No. 2015-SLAC-100238-Funding.
1906.05041	1	1906	2019-06-12T10:00:43	Energy harvesting below the onset of flutter	[ "physics.app-ph" ]	This work demonstrates preliminary results on energy harvesting from a linearly stable flutter-type system with circulatory friction forces. Harmonic external forcing is applied to study the energy flow in the steady sliding configuration. In certain parameter ranges negative excitation work is observed where the external forcing allows to pull part of the friction energy out of the system and thus makes energy harvesting possible. Studies reveal that this behavior is largely independent of the flutter point and thus that it is primarily controlled by the excitation. Contrary to existing energy harvesting approaches for such systems, this approach uses external forcing in the linearly stable regime of the oscillator which allows to control vibrations and harvest energy on demand.	physics.app-ph	physics	Energy harvesting below the onset of flutter Merten Stendera,∗, Merten Tiedemannb, Norbert Hoffmanna,c aHamburg University of Technology, Hamburg, Germany bAUDI AG, Ingolstadt, Germany cImperial College London, London, United Kingdom 9 1 0 2 n u J 2 1 ] h p - p p a . s c i s y h p [ 1 v 1 4 0 5 0 . 6 0 9 1 : v i X r a Abstract This work demonstrates preliminary results on energy harvesting from a linearly stable flutter- type system with circulatory friction forces. Harmonic external forcing is applied to study the energy flow in the steady sliding configuration. In certain parameter ranges negative excitation work is observed where the external forcing allows to pull part of the friction energy out of the system and thus makes energy harvesting possible. Studies reveal that this behavior is largely independent of the flutter point and thus that it is primarily controlled by the excitation. Contrary to existing energy harvesting approaches for such systems, this approach uses external forcing in the linearly stable regime of the oscillator which allows to control vibrations and harvest energy on demand. Keywords: energy harvesting, friction, friction-induced vibrations, mode-coupling, left eigenvectors 1. Introduction Energy harvesting from vibrations [1, 2] has recently become an important research field driven by the development of micro-electromechanical systems. When harvesting energy from ambient vibrations, the central limitation of the energy conversion is the frequency range of the resonator compared to the spectrum of the vibrations to be harvested. The energy efficiency decreases rapidly when the frequency spectrum of the vibrations shifts out of the resonator's optimal point of operation. Energy harvesting from high-amplitude friction-induced vibrations (FIV) was proposed recently [3]. Even though friction-excited systems are well known to exhibit rich periodic and chaotic dynamic behavior [4], most systems show high vibration energy shares in narrow frequency ranges. Hence, energy harvesting resonators can be tuned accordingly and help to overcome the limitations of suboptimal frequency range coverage. However, those har- vesting approaches rely on the existence of high-amplitude vibrations - which in most cases is an unwanted dynamic state. Loosely speaking, energy harvesting from FIV 'makes the best out of an undesirable situation'. Furthermore, considering real-world FIV, the energy generation remains mostly uncontrollable and unpredictable due to their inherently fugitive and irregular nature. ∗Corresponding author URL: [email protected] (Merten Stender) Preprint submitted to Journal of Sound and Vibration June 13, 2019 External forcing of self-excited friction systems has been mostly studied as active damp- ing measure [5]. Additionally, forcing has been applied in various ways to predict the stability behavior of friction systems with flutter-type, i.e. mode-coupling, instabilities. Schlagner and von Wagner [6] examine various friction oscillator models under external forcing of the nor- mal contact force. The authors find that the phase shift between the in-plane vibration and the friction force controls the friction work put into or pulled out of the system, and thus stability. Experimentally, the modal properties and friction forces of a full brake system are analyzed in [7] to assess the system robustness. Higher friction energy inputs indicated configurations that were prone to show FIV. A recent study [8] investigates the behavior of a minimal nonlinear self-excited system under harmonic forcing. The amplitudes of the frequency response func- tion (FRF) and the work done by circulatory forces are investigated as potential predictors for instability. Locally, high values of those metrics are observed before the point of instability. In the following, we illustrate how external forcing of a linear friction oscillator can be used to harvest energy. For this purpose we study the work done by damping, circulatory and external forces in the linearly stable regime of the system. 2. Linear flutter-type system Figure 1: (a) linear friction oscillator [9] and (b) portrait of the eigenvalues λ exhibiting flutter-type instability for a variation of the friction coefficient µ with m = 1 kg, kx = 11 N/m, ky = 20 N/m, k = 5 N/m, cx = 0.3 Ns/m, cy = 0.3 Ns/m, v > x (t) We are considering the dynamic system [9] in Figure 1 (a) Mx + Dx + (K + N) x = fexc (t) M, D, K, N ∈ R2,2 (see Appendix A) (1) with energy input from the friction interface and external forcing fexc. Motions in horizontal and vertical directions are viscously damped and coupled through the inclined stiffness k. The speed of the conveyor belt is assumed to always be larger than the horizontal velocity of the slider such that the system is not undergoing any stick-slip type dynamics and can be taken as linear. This assumption for high relative sliding velocities is supported by a recent experimental study [4]. A Coulomb-type friction force creates the asymmetrical circulatory terms N = −N(cid:62) that allow the system to flutter [9]. This mode-coupling behavior is depicted in Figure 1 (b). At the coupling point µc = 0.453, the first mode is uni-directionally forcing the second mode at resonance frequency. Once this mode experiences negative damping at µ(cid:63) = 0.47, the system 2 xyµmkvcycxkxky(a)π4fxfy0.20.40.645µIm(λ)0.20.40.6−0.400.4µRe(λ)µc=0.453µ?=0.47(b)becomes linearly unstable. For damped systems the points of coupling and instability are usually not identical. 3. Negative excitation work We study the system in the strictly stable configuration, i.e. µ < µ(cid:63) = 0.47. The balance of work W done in the forced system (cid:90) 2π (cid:124)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:125) x(cid:62)fexc dt 0 Ω Wexc − (cid:90) 2π (cid:124)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:125) x(cid:62)Cx dt 0 Ω Wdamp − (cid:90) 2π (cid:124)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:123)(cid:122)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:32)(cid:125) x(cid:62)Nx dt 0 Ω Wcirc = 0 (2) is obtained by integrating the respective power over one period of vibration. The terms of inertia and stiffness vanish due to their conservative character and the viscous dampers represent energy sinks. In the following, we consider a horizontal forcing. Figure 2: Work done in the forced system for fexc = [1, 0](cid:62) · cos (Ωt) in the stable regime. Negative excitation work is found in (b) around the second mode 4.62 ≤ Ω ≤ 5.34 rad/s for higher friction values The work at µ = 0.2 is displayed in Figure 2 (a) for an excitation frequency sweep. The first and second mode are clearly visible at Ω = 3.9 rad/s and Ω = 5.0 rad/s. The energy put into the system by the friction and the excitation is dissipated in the dampers to maintain the energy balance of the system. When the friction value is increased to µ = 0.4, an interesting observation can be made, see Figure 2 (b): While the balance of work does not qualitatively change for the first mode, the excitation work changes sign close to the second mode. For this configuration the system exhibits negative excitation work when forced in the frequency range of 4.62 ≤ Ω ≤ 5.34 rad/s. Here, the external forcing in fact pulls energy out of the system. As a result, the overall energy flow changes from one sink, i.e. the dampers, to two sinks, i.e. the dampers and the excitation. At the second mode 82% of the total friction energy input are dissipated in the dampers and 18% are pulled out of the system by the forcing, resulting in the net efficiency of ξ = Win/Wout = 0.18. This means that the forcing channels energy stemming from the friction interface out of the system, and thus allows for energy harvesting. The system seems to develop its own dynamics counteracting the forcing. Most importantly, the harvesting is op- erated in the stable regime of the linear oscillator. Thus, if the forcing is turned off, the system will return to its equilibrium sliding state. This behavior is fundamentally different to existing 3 3456−202Ω[rad/s]W[Nm]excitationdampingfriction3.54.55.5−606Ω[rad/s]W[Nm]0(a)(b)µ=0.2µ=0.4approaches, where high-amplitude vibrations, i.e. in the linearly unstable regime of the system, are utilized for energy harvesting. To actually design such an energy harvester, one will have to take into consideration the required power electronics, resulting electro-mechanical interactions and the resulting decrease in the effective conversion rate ξ. The work done at resonance frequency excitation is studied along the friction coefficient in Figure 3 for horizontal forcing. The friction work remains positive and the damper work remains negative for both modes throughout the complete parameter range. However, the excitation work changes sign for the second mode at 0.261 ≤ µ ≤ 0.452. As a result, energy harvesting is possible in this friction value range. line), i.e. Ω1,2 = Im(cid:0)λ1,2 (cid:1), fexc = [1, 0](cid:62) · cos(cid:0)Ω1,2t(cid:1). Negative excitation work is observed at the second mode for Figure 3: Work along the friction coefficient for excitation frequencies at the first (solid line) and second mode (dashed 0.261 ≤ µ ≤ 0.452, i.e. before the points of coupling µc (gray region) and instability (red region) µ(cid:63). The maximum conversion efficiency is ξ = 20.2% at µ = 0.39 4. Conditions for energy harvesting from flutter-type systems To better understand the phenomenon of negative excitation work, the relationship between the excitation direction and the eigenvectors of the system is studied in Figure 4. The dot product is analyzed to indicate points of orthogonality and co-linearity. For the real parts of the eigenvec- tors, we observe a relation between the dot product and negative excitation work: There are two parameter configurations at which the forcing acts orthogonal to an eigenvector: at µ = 0.261 the forcing is perpendicular to the right eigenvector, whereas at µ = 0.452 the forcing is per- pendicular to the left eigenvector [10] of the second mode. In between those points, there exists no negative dot product between eigenvectors and forcing. This indicator for energy harvesting was also found in different forcing scenarios. Particularly, negative work is observed for that mode which a) exhibits the change of sign in the dot product and b) later becomes unstable, see Figure 1. This behavior needs to be investigated further in future research. Hence, for the time being, we conclude that energy can be harvested from a specific system mode once the dot product of the forcing and all real eigenvectors of this mode share the same sign. 4 0.10.30.5−2000200µW[Nm]0.20.40150.10.30.5µ0.20.4−2500.10.30.5µ0.20.3020.440.4608µ>µ?µc≤µ≤µ?Wexc<0frictiondampingexcitationFigure 4: Dot product (cid:104)· , ·(cid:105) of the excitation vector and real parts of (a) right and (b) left eigenvectors vright,left. Negative excitation work is observed for the parameter range in between points of orthogonality between forcing and eigenvectors of the second mode fx, fy (cid:104) (cid:105)(cid:62) 5. Conclusion We present preliminary results on a non-conservative flutter-type friction oscillator with forc- ing. In specific configurations, the harmonic forcing allows to pull energy out of the system and thus harvest energy. While the action of the dampers remains unchanged, the selection of the excitation direction changes the qualitative effect of the forcing on the system's energy balance: The flow of energy can be changed from two sources - one sink, i.e. positive friction and ex- citation contributions, to one source - two sinks, i.e. positive friction and negative excitation contributions, for energy production. First results indicate that the forcing direction and the set of left and right eigenvectors have to share a dot product of the same sign for energy harvesting. Particularly, the system is considered in the linearly stable regime, which creates the energy- on-demand nature of this approach with two major advantages. First, the energy harvesting is controlled completely by the forcing and therefore does not depend on the existence of ambient or friction-excited vibrations. Once energy is required, the forcing is enabled. Second, also the amplitude and frequency of vibration is controlled by the forcing and can thus be adapted to operational conditions or structural requirements of the system. Once the forcing is turned off, the oscillator returns to its equilibrium. This operation principle may be useful for decentralized sensor energy supply at remote locations within complex machines, such as turbo-machinery, by making use of rotating parts. Acknowledgment M.S. was supported by the German Research Foundation (DFG) within the Priority Program "'calm, smooth, smart"' under the reference Ho 3851/12-1. Author contributions MS, MT and NH designed the research, MS performed the research and created the artwork, MS and MT wrote the manuscript and NH revised the manuscript. 5 0.10.20.30.4−101µhfexc,Re(vright)i0.10.20.30.400.1µhfexc,Re(vleft)i0.420.450.48−101·10−2mode2mode1Wexc<0(a)(b)Appendix A. Equations of motion K = References (cid:35) M = (cid:34)m 0 (cid:34) kx + 1 0 m 2 k − 1 2 k + 1 2 µky (cid:34)cx (cid:35) 0 cy (cid:35) , C = 0 − 1 2 k + 1 2 µky ky + 1 2 k , N = , fexc = (cid:35) (cid:34) (cid:34) fx · cos (Ωt + φx) (cid:17)(cid:35) 0 − 1 2 µky fy · cos 1 2 µky 0 Ωt + φy (cid:16) , (A.1) [1] T. J. Ka´zmierski, S. Beeby, Energy Harvesting Systems, Springer New York, New York, NY, 2011 (2011). doi:10.1007/978-1-4419-7566-9. [2] C. Wei, X. Jing, A comprehensive review on vibration energy harvesting: Modelling and realization, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 74 (2017) 1 -- 18 (2017). doi:10.1016/j.rser.2017.01.073. [3] D. W. Wang, J. L. Mo, X. F. Wang, H. Ouyang, Z. R. Zhou, Experimental and numerical investigations of the piezoelectric energy harvesting via friction-induced vibration, Energy Conversion and Management 171 (2018) 1134 -- 1149 (2018). doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2018.06.052. [4] M. Stender, M. Di Bartolomeo, F. Massi, N. Hoffmann, Revealing transitions in friction-excited vibrations by non- linear time-series analysis, Nonlinear Dynamics 47 (7) (2019) 209 (2019). doi:10.1007/s11071-019-04987-7. [5] N. Hoffmann, U. von Wagner, L. Gaul, Quenching mode-coupling friction-induced instability using high-frequency dither, Journal of Sound and Vibration 279 (1-2) (2005) 471 -- 480 (2005). doi:10.1016/j.jsv.2003.12.056. [6] S. Schlagner, U. von Wagner, Evaluation of automotive disk brake noise behavior using piezoceramic actuators and sensors, PAMM 7 (1) (2007) 4050031 -- 4050032 (2007). doi:10.1002/pamm.200700854. [7] P. Stegmann, S. Kruse, K. Augsburg, Robustness of Disc Brake Systems Regarding Squeal, in: M. Mains (Ed.), Topics in Modal Analysis, Volume 10, Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series, Springer International Publishing, Cham, 2015, pp. 79 -- 86 (2015). doi:10.1007/978-3-319-15251-6 9. [8] M. Tiedemann, M. Stender, N. Hoffmann, On vibrations in non-linear, forced, friction-excited systems, PAMM 15 (1) (2015) 267 -- 268 (2015). doi:10.1002/pamm.201510124. [9] N. Hoffmann, L. Gaul, Effects of damping on mode-coupling instability in friction induced oscillations, ZAMM- Journal of Applied Mathematics and Mechanics/Zeitschrift fur Angewandte Mathematik und Mechanik 83 (8) (2003) 524 -- 534 (2003). doi:10.1002/zamm.200310022. [10] I. Bucher, S. G. Braun, Left Eigenvectors: Extraction From Measurements and Physical Interpretation, Journal of Applied Mechanics 64 (1) (1997) 97 (1997). doi:10.1115/1.2787300. 6
1802.01934	1	1802	2018-02-06T13:23:35	Synthesis of Membrane-Electrode Assembly for Fuel Cells by Means of (Sub)-Atmospheric Plasma Processes	[ "physics.app-ph", "physics.plasm-ph" ]	An easy procedure to build up membrane-electrode assemblies for applications dedicated to miniaturized PEMFC using H2 or CH3OH by a two-steps atmospheric plasma process is reported. Firstly, catalyst nanoparticles are grafted on carbon substrates by spraying a Pt colloidal solution in the post-discharge of an RF atmospheric plasma torch. In the second step, the resulting decorated electrodes are covered by plasma synthesized polymeric membranes in the discharge of a DBD. The sulfonated polystyrene membranes are synthesized by injecting simultaneously styrene and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid monomers, in the presence of a carrier gas (Ar or He). The membranes are chemically characterized by XPS, ToF-SIMS, and FTIR (IRRAS) and their deposition rate is investigated by SEM.	physics.app-ph	physics	NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE Title Authors Affiliations Ref. DOI Abstract Synthesis of Membrane-Electrode Assembly for Fuel Cells by Means of (Sub)-Atmospheric Plasma Processes Delphine Merche, Thierry Dufour, Julie Hubert, Claude Poleunis, Sami Yunus, Arnaud Delcorte, Patrick Bertrand, François Reniers* Service de Chimie Analytique et Chimie des Interfaces (CHANI), CP255, Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB), Bv du Triomphe, 2, B-1050, Brussels, Belgium Institut de la Matie`re Condense´e et des Nanosciences (IMCN), Bio and Soft Matter (BSMA), Universite´ Catholique de Louvain (UCL), Croix du Sud 1, box L07.04.01, B-1348 Louvain la-Neuve, Belgium Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 An easy procedure to build up membrane-electrode assemblies for applications dedicated to miniaturized PEMFC using H2 or CH3OH by a two-steps atmospheric plasma process is reported. Firstly, catalyst nanoparticles are grafted on carbon substrates by spraying a Pt colloidal solution in the post-discharge of an RF atmospheric plasma torch. In the second step, the resulting decorated electrodes are covered by plasma synthesized polymeric membranes in the discharge of a DBD. The sulfonated polystyrene membranes are synthesized by injecting simultaneously styrene and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid monomers, in the presence of a carrier gas (Ar or He). The membranes are chemically characterized by XPS, ToF-SIMS, and FTIR (IRRAS) and their deposition rate is investigated by SEM. 1. Introduction Fuel cells are subject to a widespread enthusiasm as they constitute an alternative to conventional batteries and accumulators, and allow us to bring complementary solutions to fossil energies.[1] Many studies have been conducted for several years in order to optimize the triple contact of the fuel cells (arrival of the gases/ionomer/catalyst) by improving the different interfaces and to reduce the price of the different elements constituting the cell. Plasma processes for the synthesis of the membranes and electrodes are a major asset because the microstructural and chemical properties of the plasma-membranes (chemical composition, structure, morphology, thickness, etc.) and the plasma-electrodes are closely linked to the deposition conditions. Moreover, these environmental-friendly processes could reduce the amount of noble metal for the electrodes, while preserving the same electrical performances. Also, they allow the synthesis of thin ion-exchange membranes in one single step, contrary to liquid phase-based methods [2–4] which require multiple steps, organic solvents, reactants, and long reaction times. This synthesis is especially adapted to microfuel cells supplied in methanol or hydrogen dedicated to the electronic market (notebooks, cameras, mobile phones, small robots, etc.). Moreover, the strong adherence of the plasma-membranes onto electrodes constitutes an advantage for the intimate contact between the catalyst/membrane/arrival of the reactants where the redox reactions take place in the cell. The studies relative to the synthesis by ''Plasma Enhanced Chemical Vapor Deposition'' (PECVD) of thin ionic membranes from a polymerizable monomer (fluorocarbon or hydrocarbon backbone monomer) mixed with sulfonation agents (trifluoromethanesulfonic acid, chlorosulfonic acid, sulfur dioxide, etc.) are generally carried out at low pressure in order to stabilize the species and the plasma discharge. [5–13] In our work, plasma-polymerized sulfonated polystyrene (pp-sulfonated PS) was synthesized in one single step from a mixture of styrene and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (CF3-SO3H) in the discharge of a dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) under sub-atmospheric pressure. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 1 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE In addition to the PECVD of the membranes on usual substrates (as silicon) for chemical characterization, membrane-electrode assemblies were performed by a two-steps plasma process. Firstly, catalyst nanoparticles were grafted on carbon substrates by spraying a Pt colloidal solution in the post-discharge of an RF atmospheric plasma torch (according to previous papers and patent from our team).[14–18] This fast and easy method allows the surface activation and the surface decoration in only one step. The activation of carbon substrates due to plasma exposure is usually based on the grafting of oxidized species but also on the formation of structural surface defects due to ion and electron bombardment, which can, in turn, be functionalized.[17] This step is often carried out by means of wet chemistry techniques.[19] In other cases, the activation of the surface and the grafting of metal particles are combined with techniques requiring a high vacuum system (ion gun, low pressure plasma, and/or thermal evaporation).[20] Secondly, plasma-polymer membranes were deposited onto the Pt-plasma- decorated electrodes directly in the DBD, operating at sub-atmospheric pressure, as described previously. As the two-steps process could be easily combined in one continuous procedure and as it leads to a strong contact between the membrane and the catalytic phase, the perspective to constitute a financially viable alternative compared to the industrial synthesis of the Nafion is appealing. Moreover, the Nafion presents disadvantages as permeability of the fuel, low temperature limit and a relatively high thickness (a hundred of mm) which are locks for the use of the commercial membrane in miniature devices.[1,21,22] Working under (sub)-atmospheric pressure presents lots of advantages: it avoids the constraints linked to a costly high-vacuum system, and therefore enables an easy implementation of the process in a continuous production line. However, a major drawback due to the high pressure is the very small mean free path of the reactive species, making the reaction mechanisms much more difficult to understand, and therefore to control. The pp-sulfonated PS obtained by plasma copolymerization were chemically characterized by X- ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS), and by dynamic and static time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS). The deposition rate was studied by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The thermal stability and the ability to exchange ions (after soaking in an electrolyte solution) were investigated by XPS. The carbon substrates decorated by Pt nanoparticles were characterized by XPS, static ToF-SIMS, and SEM. Dynamic ToF-SIMS and SEM were used to observe the different interfaces of the pp-sulfonated PS deposited onto glassy carbon decorated by Pt nanoparticles. 2. Experimental Section 2.1. Materials The liquid styrene (Fluka, purity: 99.5%) and the liquid trifluoromethane sulfonic acid precursors (Sigma–Aldrich, purity >98%) were used as received for the plasma polymerization, without any further purification. This acid being very hygroscopic, it requires a closed system with a controlled atmosphere. The Pt nanoparticles were provided by Plasmachem. They were sterically stabilized by polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) and showed a size distribution of 3–4nm in diameter. Once diluted in methanol, the resulting solution was used for the first step of the process. Silicon wafers (100) from Compart Technology Ltd. were selected as flat substrates for surface characterizations and for the deposition rates study of the pp-sulfonated PS. Glassy carbon (non-porous) and Carbon Toray Paper (porous) were used for the grafting of Pt Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 2 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE catalyst and then for the membrane synthesis (membrane-electrode assembly). Glassy carbon (Sigradur K platen) was chosen to this end as a model for the depth profiling by dynamic SIMS. The substrates were cleaned with methanol and isooctane. The atmospheric plasma torch used for the grafting of the metallic nanoparticles was sustained by Ar (''Air liquide'', purity: 99.999%), mixed with oxygen (''Air liquide'', purity: 99.995%). The DBD for the plasma-polymer synthesis was sustained either by He (''Air liquide'', purity: 99.999%) or by Ar (''Air liquide'', purity: 99.999%). 2.2. Nanoparticles Grafting The catalyst nanoparticles were deposited on carbon gas diffusion layers (Carbon Toray Paper) and on glassy carbon by spraying the Pt colloidal solution in the post-discharge of an RF atmospheric plasma torch. The plasma torch (Atomflo250DSurfX Technologies) consists of two closely spaced circular aluminum electrodes perforated to flush the process gas (Ar) at a flow rate of 30 L.min-1. To improve the grafting process on the carbon substrates, a tiny flow rate of oxygen (20mL.min-1) was mixed with the carrier gas, as already highlighted for the grafting of Au, Rh, and Pt nanoparticles in the Nano2hybrids project. [15] Fig. 1 Figure 1. Experimental setup dedicated to the grafting of catalytic nanoparticles, by using an RF plasma torch. Figure 2. Experimental setup dedicated to the pp- sulfonated PS on Si wafers or on carbon substrates decorated with Pt nanoparticles (NPT) by using a home-built DBD. The inset shows a schematic representation of pp-sulfonated PS synthesized on glassy carbon decorated with Pt nanoparticles. Fig. 2 We have carried out several configurations (variation of the angle between the substrate and the gas flow direction, injection of the colloidal solution out of the post-discharge, etc.). The best configuration resulted from the best compromise between a high amount of nanoparticles grafted and a low oxidation of the Pt nanoparticles, as illustrated in Figure 1. The substrate, parallel to the gases flow direction, is fixed on a rotative cylindrical stick of 10mm in diameter and placed at 2mm from the plasma torch exit. The substrates were activated during 2min (30 L.min–1 Ar, 20mL.min–1 O2 at 80W). Then the Pt colloidal solution was nebulized in the afterglow of the plasma torch during 3min (20 sprays of 0.17mL). After the 3min of Pt grafting, a termination step is operated under the same conditions without any spraying of platinum (during 2min). Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 3 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE 2.3. Plasma Polymerization The pp-sulfonated PS thin films were deposited in one single step, in a home-built DBD. The cylindrical glass chamber has already been detailed in previous papers. [23,24] The schematic diagram of the reactor is presented in Figure 2. Although the system also runs under atmospheric pressure, the results presented in this paper were obtained at a slightly reduced pressure (2.104 Pa) but still in the same order of magnitude as atmospheric pressure, in order to be able to increase the inter-electrode distance and to minimize the breakdown voltage (according to the Paschen Law). The chamber was pumped continuously during the plasma polymerization process (dynamic regime) to minimize the air contamination of the growing film. The liquid styrene monomer was kept at 313K and the temperature of the trifluoromethane sulfonic acid was ranging from 313 to 333 K. Both monomers vapors were simultaneously introduced into the discharge with identical flow rates of Ar or He (1.5 L.min–1 flowing through each liquid vessel). The frequency was fixed at 15 kHz and the voltage was varied from 1 to 2 kV. The silicon substrates (or the decorated carbon substrates) were placed between the electrodes, close to the arrival of the precursors (on the right end side of the 21cm long bottom electrode, at 9cm from its center, as shown in Figure 2). Deposition times ranged from 5 to 10 min. After the plasma polymer deposition on Si wafers or on carbon electrodes loaded with Pt catalyst, the chamber was purged in order to evacuate the reactive gas, then backfilled to atmospheric pressure using Ar or He. Finally, the samples were transferred to the analytical tools. 2.4. Characterization of the Samples The pp-films were characterized by FTIR, XPS, and ToF-SIMS. The deposition rates were calculated by measuring the thickness (by cross- section) of the pp-sulfonated PS films by means of a Field Emission Gun Scanning Electron Microscope (FEG-SEM) Zeiss Leo 982. SEM was also used to investigate the morphology of the plasma-polymerized films (with the addition of a gold coating of about 5nm in thickness to make them conductive) and the deposited Pt. To evaluate the quality of the grafting, XPS analyses were performed on the carbon substrate decorated with the catalyst nanoparticles before and after ultrasonification in a methanol bath. XPS analyses were carried out in a Physical Electronics PHI-5600 system equipped with a concentric spherical analyser and a 16 channeltron plate. Spectra were acquired with the Mg anode (1 253.6 eV) operating at 300 W. The typical area of analysis is around 800mm. The average surface concentrations (excluding hydrogen, which is not detected in XPS) on two identical samples at three different regions were computed on the Casa XPS software, after removal of a Shirley background line. The sensitivity coefficients used are: S=0.35, C=0.205, N=0.38,O=0.63, F=1,andPt=3.50, instead of 1.75 (corresponding to the singlet Pt 4f7/2) as referred in the literature.[25] Indeed, in order to take into account all the platinum components and not to neglect the Pt (+4) and Pt (+2) components, we have considered the whole spectral envelope on the survey spectrum, corresponding to the spin-orbit doublet (Pt 4f7/2 and Pt 4f5/2). Therefore the compositions of the Pt decorated carbon substrates must be taken as indicative and are used only for comparison between the different plasma treatments (with/without oxygen, nature of the substrate, etc.). Wide survey spectra were acquired at a 93.9 eV pass-energy, with a 5 scan accumulation (time/step: 50ms, eV/step: 0.8). The high resolution scans were acquired at a 23.5 eV pass-energy with an accumulation of 10 scans (time/step: 50ms, eV/step: 0.025). The high resolution scans of C1s, S2p, and Pt4f were decomposed into several peaks components, with the same FWHM for each, through 4 Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE convoluting Gaussian and Lorentzian profiles with respect to a 30:70 ratio. The components assignments and binding energies were based on the literature. [9,26,27] Static positive and negative ToF-SIMS measurements were performed with an ''IONTOF V'' spectrometer (IONTOF GmbH, Münster, Germany) equipped with a reflectron analyser and controlled by the SURFACELAB 6.1 software. The sample was bombarded in static regime at two different regions by pulsed Bi3 2+ (acceleration voltage=60 keV, primary ion current=0.01pA, total ion fluence=2.1013 Bi3 2+ cm–2, beam diameter 0.3µm). The acquisition time was fixed to 1min and the scan was confined to a square of 500500µm2. Cs+ (acceleration voltage=1 keV, primary ion current=100nA, total ion fluence=1,7.10–18 Cs+.cm–2, beam diameter = 0.3mm) was employed as primary source for the dynamic ToF-SIMS measurements (erosion of 100100µm2) on pp-sulfonated deposited on glassy carbon decorated with Pt nanoparticles. 3. Results and Discussion 3.1. pp-Sulfonated PS on Si Wafers Chemical Structure XPS is a very powerful technique to characterize thin polymer coatings.[28] Figure 3 presents the survey of pp sulfonated PS/DBD He and high resolution scans of S2p, C1s, O1s, and F1s. We have already shown that the synthesis of pp sulfonated PS revealed a relatively preserved structure of the acid precursor in the discharge near atmospheric pressure in our plasma conditions.[23] All the sulfur is present in the sulfonic form (S2p1/2 and S2p3/2 at 169 and 170 eV, respectively) and no sulfur at lower oxidation state (such as RSO2R' at 166 eV and RSOR' at 164.5 eV) is incorporated into the films. These results differ from most of the deposits operated at low pressure, where the peak is often splitted.[5,8,9,22,29,30] Figure 3. XPS survey with insets showing narrow scans corresponding to S2p, C1s, O1s, F1s of pp- sulfonated PS (He, 313 K for the both monomers, 1 kV). The significant retention of the sulfonic acids groups suggests milder plasma conditions at sub-atmospheric pressure in our synthesis conditions. This better retention could be explained by lower mean free paths of the radicals, excited species (such as metastables), and charged species. Their collisions frequency is therefore higher but their energy could be too low to fragment the sulfonic groups. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 5 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE In this previous paper, the XPS results showed that the content in sulfonated groups was tunable by varying the temperature of the acid monomer (so the acid-to-styrene ratio) or by increasing the voltage.[23] Therefore, it was possible to produce plasma-membranes, thermally stable, with a higher content in sulfonic acids groups (up to 4% at 1 kV and up to 6.6% at 2 kV) than in the Nafion 117 (for which sulfonated groups of around 1% is reported). The presence of sulfonic acid groups was also confirmed by FTIR and static SIMS.[23] The thermal stability was investigated by XPS from the point of view of the chemical composition and of the core level peak shape for the different elements of the membranes heated at 393 K in dry medium (stove) and at 353 K in aqueous medium (water bath). Owing to the similar elemental composition and the similar shape of the high resolution peaks before and after the heating (except for the oxygen peak after soaking in hot water, for which the OH/H2O component slightly increased), we can conclude that the thermal stability (from the point of view of the chemical composition) is correct. In an attempt to bring out the presence of easily accessible ionic sites, preliminary tests were operated by means of XPS on the pp-sulfonated PS immerged in an aqueous solution. They were soaked in NaOH 0.1 M during 30 min to replace the H+ of the acid form by Na+ in order to check if our films have a similar behavior to ionic exchange membranes. Afterwards, those ones were rinsed by milli-Q water, dried, and analyzed by XPS. The emergence of the Na1s peak at 1 075 eV and the Auger peak at 264 eV for the pp-sulfonated PS are clearly noticeable in Figure 4. The same treatment was applied to the non-sulfonated pp-PS in order to compare and confirm the ion exchange effect of the sulfonated polymer. The elemental composition of the reference (pp-PS) and pp-sulfonated PS after immersion in NaOH is given in Table 1. Analogous tests were performed by Ogumi on pp-membranes synthesized at low pressure from trifluorochloroethylene and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid after soaking in CsOH during 30 min. The presence of Cs was attested by Electron Probe Micro-Analysis (EPMA) afterwards.[6] Figure 4. Survey spectra after immersion in NaOH of pp-sulfonated PS with insets showing the narrows scans of S2p, C1s, O1s, F1s, Na1s. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 6 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE Deposition Rates Table 1. XPS elemental composition of pp-PS and pp-sulfonated PS after immersion in NaOH. Figure 5 shows a typical SEM cross-section image of pp-sulfonated PS synthesized onto silicon wafers. The films (few mm in thickness) are uniform and present a strong adhesion to the substrate whatever its nature. The deposition rates are given in Table 2. An increase in the deposition rate with the voltage is highlighted (360–580nm/min at 1 kV, against 825–1425nm/min at 1.5 kV) owing to an increase of the fragmentation and the amount of activated precursors. Therefore, the polymerization by random radical recombination is increased. Moreover, the films synthesized in the presence of Ar instead of He show a slightly higher deposition rate due to the more filamentary behavior of the Ar discharge. Table 2. Deposition rates of the pp-sulfonated PS deposited onto Si wafers in the presence of Ar or He (313 K for the both monomers). Figure 5. SEM cross-section image of a pp-sulfonated PS on Si wafer. 3.2. Nanoparticles Grafting on Carbon Substrates Chemical Structure The configuration illustrated in Figure 1 displays a good compromise between a high amount of Pt grafted and a low oxidation of the Pt nanoparticles. After any plasma treatment (with or without O2), Pt nanoparticles were detected by XPS on the carbon surface; the fitted Pt and C high resolution peaks are presented in Figure 6 and 7, respectively. Table 3 exhibits the elemental compositions of the metallic grafting on glassy carbon after ultrasonication and also on Carbon Toray Paper before and after ultrasonication. For comparison, the table indicates the composition of Carbon Toray Paper used as a substrate for the decoration of Pt nanoparticles in a pure argon discharge. Due to its significant porosity (78%), the amount of Pt detected on Carbon Toray Paper is lower than on glassy carbon. As the Carbon Toray Paper is a non-flat surface, the Pt nanoparticles are grafted over an indeterminate thickness, supposed to be higher than the depth probed by XPS analysis (10 nm). Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 7 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE Table 3. XPS elemental composition before and after ultrasonication of the surface of glassy carbon (GC) and Carbon Toray Paper (CT) after grafting of Pt nanoparticles by means of the atmospheric plasma torch. The incorporated oxygen is mostly due to the addition of oxygen gas (20mL.min–1) into the Ar post-discharge (30 L.min–1), to the opened environment in which the RF torch is working and to the colloidal solution. The silicon contamination (evidenced by XPS) may be due to the sprayer system. The small amount of nitrogen could be due to the capping agent of the Pt nanoparticles (PVP) and to the ambient air. The benefit of adding oxygen in the plasma was pointed out in previous publications.[15,16] As can be seen in Table 3, the amount of nanoparticles grafted is lower when no oxygen was added (less active sites) and the bonds become weaker (the quantity of Pt decreased after ultrasonication by a factor close to 2). As the amount of platinum (when oxygen is added) was similar before and after ultrasonication, a strong adhesion of the nanoparticles to the carbon substrates is suggested. The activation of carbon substrates was argued in the Nano2hybrids project (especially by the way of simulation of grafting Au on carbon nanotubes).[17,31] The nucleation takes place preferentially on ''defects'' or on active sites (such as oxygenated vacancies) generated by plasma preactivation. Those ones trap metallic atoms and play the role of nucleation centers. Therefore, the density of defects influences the dispersion and the concentration of metal nanoparticles grafted and allows to adapt the interfacial properties. Therefore, thanks to the plasma activation, the distribution of the oxygenated vacancies is more homogeneous and leads to the grafting of a tunable concentration of nanoparticles. Figure 6. XPS survey of Pt grafted on glassy carbon after ultrasonication with insets showing narrow scans of the elements. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 8 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE In Figure 7a, the fitting of the Pt 4f core level (Pt4f5/2–Pt4f7/2 spin-orbit doublets with 3.3 eV energy separation) was based on a method suggested by Croy.[32] The fitting for our deposits showed that the Pt was mostly present under metallic state for this configuration: about 70% of Pt (0), about 20% of Pt (+2), and less than 10% of Pt (+4). We should mention also that we have tested other plasma-spray- substrate configurations. Other configurations allow us to obtain more oxidized Pt. Depending on the geometry, the oxidation state of the platinum is tunable, which could play a role on the methanol oxidation reaction catalysis in the cell.[32] The fitting of the C1s peak is based on a method proposed by Swaraj.[33] The C1s high resolution scans evidenced the presence of carbon-oxygen species. As we can see in Figure 7b, the C spectrum was fitted in four components. C-O species are detected since during the plasma treatment, the sample was exposed to a strong oxidizing atmosphere including the ambient air, the injection of methanol droplets, and the addition of oxygen to the Ar gas. Figure 7. Decomposition of the Pt4f (a) and C1s (b) XPS peaks for a grafting of Pt nanoparticles on glassy carbon after ultrasonication. The topmost surface of glassy carbon and Carbon Toray Paper decorated by nanoparticles was characterized by static SIMS. Figure 8 displays the positive and the negative Static SIMS spectra of glassy carbon decorated with Pt nanoparticles (in the presence of oxygen added in the postdischarge). The positive spectrum shows the existence of the following peaks: Pt+, PtO+, PtO2 +, PtCl2 +,, PtCl4 +, Pt2 +, Pt2Ox +, Pt3 +, Pt3Ox +, CH3NH3 +, NH4 + (after grafting of the metallic particles), in addition to other peaks present on the surface of the native sample like aliphatics,CxHyO+,H2O+,Na+,Al+, Si+, CO+, NO+, K+, Ar+, and Ca+, as confirmed in the literature.[34] The chlorine (non-visible in XPS spectra) could originate from the synthesis method of the nanoparticles. The nitrogen compounds come from the PVP used as a capping agent and from the ambient air. In the negative spectrum, peaks of C–, CH–, OH–, C2H–, CN–, Cl–, CNO–, CO2H–, C4H–, SO2 – , SO3 –, HSO4 – (already present in the native sample) but also peaks of PO3 – , PtO–, PtO2 – , PtCl–, PtCl2 –, Pt2Ox –, Pt3Ox – , etc. are noticeable. The most abundant isotopes of platinum are 195Pt (relative abundance: 0.338), 194Pt (0.330), 196Pt (0.252), and 198Pt (0.072). Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 9 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE Figure 8. Positive (left) and negative (right) static ToF-SIMS spectra of glassy carbon decorated with Pt nanoparticles. Morphology (SEM) The SEM pictures shown in Figure 9 correspond to the glassy carbon substrate (a) as received and (b) decorated by Pt nanoclusters by the means of the RF plasma torch. In Figure 9b, an increase in the roughness is observed due to the grafting of the nanoclusters, which appear as white dots uniformly distributed. As a high loading leads to a more important coalescence process, the structure of the deposit is strongly related to the loading in Pt nanoparticles at the glassy carbon surface. Figure 9. SEM images of (a) glassy carbon untreated, (b) glassy carbon after grafting of catalyst. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 10 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE 3.3. pp-Sulfonated PS on Electrodes Chemical Structure The pp-sulfonated PS synthesized on Pt nanoparticles deposited on carbon substrates were chemically characterized by XPS and by static ToF-SIMS. As those surface characterization results were similar to the previous ones operated on silicon wafers, they have not been repeated here. In order to determine the bulk homogeneity of the membranes and to have access to the membrane–catalyst and catalyst–carbon interfaces, dynamic ToF-SIMS depth profiling has been performed. The evolution of the dynamic ToF-SIMS negative fragments as a function of the erosion time for the pp-sulfonated membranes on glassy carbon loaded with Pt clusters is shown in Figure 10. Figure 10. (a) Evolution of the negative dynamic ToF-SIMS fragments from pp-sulfonated PS (DBD Ar, 313 K for the two monomers, 1 kV, 3 min) deposited on glassy carbon decorated with Pt nanoparticles versus the time of erosion; (b) zoom of (a) for the low intensity fragments. Figure 10 shows that the sulfonic acid groups were homogeneously grafted inside the whole membrane (fragments at m/z=157 and 183 corresponding to C6H5SO3 – and C8H7SO3 –, respectively). The non-fragmented trifluoromethanesulfonic acid monomer (m/z=149) is mostly adsorbed at the ''plasma-membrane''/''Pt nanoparticles'' interface due to the two monomers injected before the breakdown of the plasma in the DBD chamber and the polymerization process. The fluorine coming from the fragmentation of the trifluoromethanesulfonic acid follows the same trend. The polymeric film/Pt and Pt/glassy carbon interfaces are particularly visible; the carbon components without nitrogen decrease during the erosion of the nanoparticles and increase when the Pt nanoparticles have totally disappeared. The CNO– peak at m/z=42 (from the capping agent of the colloidal solution) and oxygen (after the achievement of a plateau in the plasma-film) increase similarly to the Pt. The oxygen bond to the Pt comes from the tiny flow of oxygen added to the Ar plasma, from the solution and from the open environment. Morphology (SEM) Figure 11a shows the SEM pictures of the top view of scratched pp-sulfonated PS synthesized on glassy carbon loaded in metallic catalyst. The plasma-polymer is flat and homogeneous. Figure 11b shows the cross-section of the same deposit. Pt clusters, homogenously distributed and clearly visible at the interface (as confirmed by the dynamic ToF-SIMS results), appear bright (effect of the atomic number). Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 11 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE Figure 11. SEM images of pp-sulfonated PS synthesized on glassy carbon loaded with Pt nanoparticles. 4. Conclusion We tried to show, in this paper, that atmospheric pressure plasma is a potential useful tool for building membrane-catalyst-electrode assemblies for fuel cell applications. It presents the advantage of being an easy-to-set-up process that does not require complicated technology or involve complex chemical reaction schemes. Thermally stable pp-sulfonated PS coatings have been successfully synthesized by means of a home-built DBD, in one single step, by ''copolymerization'' of two precursors (styrene and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid) injected simultaneously into the discharge. These coatings could play the role of ion-exchange membranes in miniaturized PEMFC, using hydrogen or methanol for portable applications. The complementarity of the spectroscopic techniques (XPS, FTIR, static and dynamic SIMS) showed that the sulfonic acid groups were well preserved in the discharge near atmospheric pressure and also grafted inside the whole polystyrene membrane. The influence of the parameters (temperature of the acid, voltage applied between the electrodes, nature of the carrier gas, etc.) on the amount of the grafted ionizable groups was monitored by XPS, which showed a higher content than in the Nafion 117 (up to4% at 1 kV and up to 6.6% at 2 kV versus about 1% for the Nafion). The presence of ionic sites was also pointed out by means of the Na signal followed by XPS after soaking the membranes in a solution of NaOH to change its form. In order to develop membrane-electrode assembly by atmospheric plasma, these films were also deposited directly onto carbon substrates decorated with platinum. We have grafted the catalyst from a platinum colloidal solution sprayed into the post-discharge of an RF atmospheric plasma torch on gas diffusion layers and on glassy carbon (used as a model for the depth profiling by dynamic SIMS) in several configurations and for different parameters. The amount of Pt grafted on carbon substrates and the oxidation states of the Pt can be tuned depending on the configurations. This one-step process is a promising technique to deposit nanocatalysts for fuel cells applications due to its easy transferability to industrial process. The aim of this process was to constitute electrodes that will be used afterwards as substrates for the adhesion of plasma-membranes as part of membrane-electrode assemblies for fuel cells. Thedifferent interfaces of themembraneelectrode assembly are clearly visible, detected, and characterized by depth profiling (dynamic ToF-SIMS) and SEM. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 12 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE 5. Acknowledgements This work was supported by the Belgian Federal Government IAP (Belgian Interuniversity Attraction Pole ''Physical Chemistry of Plasma- Surface Interactions – project P6/08) and by the FNRS (FRFC grant n 2.4543.04). D. Merche thanks the F. R. I. A. (Belgium) and the ''Fondation Jaumotte – Demoulin-Van Buuren'' for a PhD grant. 6. References [1] S. Roualdes, M. Schieda, L. Durivault, I. Guesmi, E. Ge´rardin, J. Durand, Chem. Vap. Deposition 2007, 13, 361. [2] C. R. Martins, G. Ruggeri, M. De Paoli, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2003, 14, 797. [3] J. C. Yang, M. J. Jablonsky, J. W. Mays, Polymer 2002, 43, 5125. [4] F. Kucera, J. Jancar, Polym. Eng. Sci. 1998, 38, 783. [5] N. Inagaki, S. Tasaka, T. Kurita, Polym. Bull. 1989, 22, 15. [6] Z. Ogumi, Y. Uchimoto, Z. Takehara, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1990, 137, 3319. [7] K. Yasuda, Y. Uchimoto, Z. Ogumi, Z. Takehara, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1994, 141, 2350. [8] Y. Uchimoto, K. Yasuda, Z. Ogumi, Z. Takehara, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1991, 138, 3190. [9] H. Mahdjoub, S. Roualdes, P. Sistat, N. Pradeilles, J. Durand, G. Pourcelly, Fuel Cells 2005, 5, 277. [10] S. Roualdes, I. Topala, H. Mahdjoub, V. Rouessac, P. Sistat, J. Durand, J. Power Sources 2006, 158, 1270. [11] A. Ennajdaoui, J. Larrieu, S. Roualdes, J. Durand, Eur. Phys. 2008, 42, 9. [12] A. Ennajdaoui, S. Roualdes, P. Brault, J. Durand, J. Power Sources 2010, 195, 232. [13] Z. Jiang, Z. Jiang, X. Yu, Y. Meng, Plasma Process. Polym. 2010, 7, 382. [14] F. Demoisson, M. Raes, H. Terryn, J. Guillot, H.-N. Migeon, F. Reniers, Surf. Interface Anal. 2008, 40, 566. [15] N. Claessens, F. Demoisson, T. Dufour, A. Mansour, A. Felten, J. Guillot, J.-J. Pireaux, Reniers, Nanotechnology 2010, 21, 385603. [16] R. Leghrib, A. Felten, F. Demoisson, F. Reniers, J.-J. Pireaux, E. Llobet, Carbon 2010, 48, 3477. [17] J.-C. Charlier, L. Arnaud, I. V. Avilov, M. Delgado, F. Demoisson, E. H. Espinosa, C. P. Ewels, A. Felten, J. Guillot, R. Ionescu, R. Leghrib, E. Llobet, A. Mansour, H.-N. Migeon, J.-J. Pireaux, F. Reniers, I. Suarez-Martinez, G. E. Watson, Z. Zanolli, Nanotechnology 2009, 20, 375501. [18] Belgium WO/2009/021988 (2009) invs.: F. Reniers, F. Demoisson, J.-J. Pireaux, Method for Depositing Nanoparticles on a Support. [19] R. Yu, L. Chen, Q. Liu, J. Lin, K.-L. Tan, Ng. S. Choon, H. S. O. Chan, G.-Q. Xu, T. S. Andy Hor, Chem. Mater. 1998, 10, 718. [20] G. Ren, Y. Xing, Nanotechnology 2006, 17, 5596. [21] V. Neburchilov, J. Martin, H. Wang, J. Zhang, J. Power Sources 2007, 169, 221. [22] B. Bae, H. Y. Hab, D. Kim, J. Membr. Sci. 2006, 276, 51. [23] D. Merche, J. Hubert, C. Poleunis, S. Yunus, P. Bertrand, P. De Keyzer, F. Reniers, Plasma Process. Polym. 2010, 7, 836. [24] D. Merche, C. Poleunis, P. Bertrand, M. Sferrazza, F. Reniers, IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 2009, 37, 951. [25] C. D. Wagner, W. M. Riggs, L. E. Davis, J. F. Moulder, G. E. Muilenberg, Handbook of X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, Parkin Elmer Corporation, Physical Electronics Division, USA 1979. [26] M. M. Nasef, H. Saidi, Appl. Surf. Sci. 2006, 252, 3073. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 13 NOTE: THIS DOCUMENT IS A PRE-PRINT VERSION. YOU MAY USE IT AT YOUR OWN CONVENIENCE BUT ITS CONTENT MAY DEVIATE IN PLACES FROM THE FINAL PUBLISHED ARTICLE. FOR CITATION, REFER TO THE INFORMATION REPORTED IN THE INTRODUCTIVE TABLE [27] J. R. Croy, S. Mostafa, H. Heinrich, B. Roldan Cuenya, Catal. Lett. 2009, 131, 21. [28] N. Vandencasteele, F. Reniers, J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat. Phenom. 2010, 177–178, 394. [29] C. Brumlik, A. Parthasarathy, W.-J. Chen, C. Martin, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1994, 141, 2273. [30] F. Finsterwalder, G. Hambitzer, J. Membr. Sci. 2001, 185, 105. [31] C. Bittencourt, A. Felten, B. Douhard, J.-F. Colomer, G. Van Tendeloo, W. Drube, J. Ghijsen, J.-J. Pireaux, Surf. Sci. 2007, 601, 2800. [32] J. R. Croy, S. Mostafa, J. Liu, Y. Sohn, H. Heinrich, B. R. Cuenya, Catal. Lett. 2007, 119, 209. [33] S. Swaraj, U. Oran, A. Lippitz, R.-D. Schulze, J. Friedrich, W. Unger, Plasma Process. Polym. 2004, 1, 134. [34] G. N. Kamau, Anal. Chim. Acta 1988, 207, 1. Plasma Processes & Polymers, 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 11-12, 1144-1153, http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ppap.201100208 14

Subsets and Splits

No community queries yet

The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.