Unnamed: 0
int64 0
372k
| title
stringlengths 33
257
| username
stringlengths 4
785
| timestamp
stringlengths 4
30
| decision
stringclasses 4
values | comment
stringlengths 2
14.5k
⌀ | topic
stringlengths 13
237
| policies
stringlengths 4
222
| policy_title
stringclasses 94
values | policy_index
int64 0
93
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
400 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aamer Sohail (cricketer, born 1973) | User:Eggishorn | 19:03, 9 February 2021 (UTC) | delete | Per : {{tq|what constitutes a match played at the highest international or domestic level ... is dependent on its inclusion in a substantial source}}. A simple database listing of match records is not a substantial source | Deletion of Aamer Sohail (cricketer, born 1973) | WP:NCRIC | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
401 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farris (mineral water) | User:Gidonb | 13:24, 21 June 2008 (UTC) | comment | I would like to suggest closing this AfD per . Other than the nominator, I do not see one person who proposes to delete the article on the largest mineral water brand in Norway. Also, if no one wants to delete this article through a regular AfD, why was it proposed for speedy deletion before the AfD | Deletion of Farris (mineral water) | WP:SNOWBALL | Wikipedia:Snowball clause | 87 |
402 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaniv Brik | User:IJA | 16:31, 18 January 2015 (UTC) | delete | Fails as he hasn't played in a |fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps | Deletion of Yaniv Brik | WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
403 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of war crimes against U.S. officials | User:Tarc | 15:22, 6 August 2007 (UTC) | delete | ensure that the individuals' articles cover the allegations if they are properly sourced. The info is notable, just not in an article of its own, as that strays into |synthesis problems of trying to tie disparate administrations into a whole for indictment | Deletion of Allegations of war crimes against U.S. officials | WP:SYNT | Wikipedia:No original research | 12 |
404 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Way Cousin | User:Dhartung | 05:17, 19 May 2008 (UTC) | delete | The term http://www.google.com/search?q=double.cousin double cousin is more often used for this sort of thing. Note that we have double first cousin already. I can find no evidence this is a term that is even in wide use, let alone one that would pass | Deletion of Two Way Cousin | WP:NEO | Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary | 10 |
405 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spaceships of Eve Online (2nd nomination) | User:Themfromspace | 19:47, 4 May 2009 (UTC) | delete | Wikipedia is not a game guide. Not only that, but the topic and content here have no |notability in the real world. Since all of the content is |in-universe it fails our guidelines for |writing about fiction. We need ''real-world'' notability to be able to cover it adequately. This article is too deep within the game to be able to cover on Wikipedia, this content is best reserved for a specialty encyclopedia that isn't concerned the way its topics are recieved outside of the game's universe | Deletion of Spaceships of Eve Online (2nd nomination) | WP:N||WP:INUNIVERSE||WP:WAF | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
406 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advertising campaign | user:Andrew | 09:51, 13 May 2020 (UTC) | keep | "The topic is notable as entire books are written about it with titles like ''Advertising Campaign Design''; ''Advertising Campaign Planning''; ''Advertising Campaign Strategy''. The rest is then a matter of ordinary editing per . Deletion has no part to play in this per which states that ""''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page" | Deletion of Advertising campaign | WP:IMPERFECT||WP:ATD | Wikipedia:Editing policy | 24 |
407 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus Freak Hideout (4th nomination) | User:The | 11:46, 1 February 2016 (UTC) | keep | This publication is used by other |reliable sources, such as ''Encyclopedia of Contemporary Christian Music'' right https://books.google.com/books?id=xwI5AQAAIAAJ&q=%22Jesus+Freak+Hideout%22+-jesusfreakhideout.com&dq=%22Jesus+Freak+Hideout%22+-jesusfreakhideout.com&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiN3oCavdbKAhWE4yYKHYlHByoQ6AEIOjAF in this search. It is also mentioned in ''Contemporary Musicians'' right https://books.google.com/books?id=xBk6AQAAIAAJ&q=%22Jesus+Freak+Hideout%22+-jesusfreakhideout.com&dq=%22Jesus+Freak+Hideout%22+-jesusfreakhideout.com&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiw8ICsvtbKAhWI0iYKHfk4AkEQ6AEINjAE in this search. These two instances are enough for me to consider this publication a |notable website, for inclusion as part of this ever growing encyclopedia | Deletion of Jesus Freak Hideout (4th nomination) | WP:RS||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
408 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabrejay | User:Bearian | 18:52, 9 April 2020 (UTC) | delete | it's consensus that club DJs are |run of the mill, and short of |significant coverage, they are not automatically notable |because of where they work or for whom they work. There's no evidence in the article that this one is an exception, but ping me if you become aware of good sources | Deletion of Fabrejay | WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTINHERITED | Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill | 32 |
409 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pimlico Plumbers | User:Sehmeet | 13:52, 19 July 2011 (UTC) | keep | Passes guidelines and should be categorised to stub class | Deletion of Pimlico Plumbers | WP:ORGIN | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
410 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gardens (Pastoral Station) | User:Oakshade | 19:20, 16 October 2016 (UTC) | keep | as per the sources indicated above. Speedy tagging within 13 minutes of article creation is not helpful and only serves as | Deletion of The Gardens (Pastoral Station) | WP:BITE | Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers | 56 |
411 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/.ip | User:Someone | 21:23, 22 January 2014 (UTC) | delete | "Individual pseudo-TLDs can be notable just like everything else per , but there's no evidence that "".ip"" might be so" | Deletion of .ip | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
412 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miriam Rodón Naveira | User:David | 19:41, 26 December 2013 (UTC) | delete | for lack of evidence of passing or . Certainly, first member of ethnic minority to hold lesser leadership position at marginally notable research institute is not by itself grounds for notability | Deletion of Miriam Rodón Naveira | WP:PROF||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
413 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golden diamond | User:MarkH21 | 16:34, 7 March 2021 (UTC) | delete | "Fails due to the paucity of RS coverage. The only published academic literature that mentions this graph (under the name of ""Fibonacci Representation Graph"") appears to be {{Cite journal|last=Northshield|first=Sam|date=5 May 2015|title=Three Analogues of Stern's Diatomic Sequence|url=https://www.fq.math.ca/Papers1/52-5/Northshield.pdf|journal=The Fibonacci Quarterly|volume=52, 5|pages=168–186|arxiv=1503.03433}}, an article which itself does not appear to have been cited nor significantly covered in other published literature" | Deletion of Golden diamond | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
414 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/INDIACHATZ | User:GermanJoe | 22:35, 27 September 2015 (UTC) | delete | no claim of notability, no in-depth coverage via Google. Clear violation of (incl. non-commercial and free products) by one of the app developers | Deletion of INDIACHATZ | WP:PROMO | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
415 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armenia–Chile relations | User:Nick | 07:01, 9 April 2009 (UTC) | comment | That argument is basically | Deletion of Armenia–Chile relations | WP:ITSUSEFUL | Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions | 20 |
416 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female action heroes (2nd nomination) | NONE | NONE | keep | The topic clearly passes as there are dozens of books about it including | Deletion of List of female action heroes (2nd nomination) | WP:LISTN | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
417 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iyah may | User:Missvain | 15:12, 21 May 2021 (UTC) | delete | I cannot find how this subject meets , let alone . All mentions are passing, no charting. Appears to be for this subject | Deletion of Iyah may | WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC||WP:TOOSOON | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
418 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerst, Forrest J. | User:RGTraynor | 18:05, 13 March 2007 (UTC) | delete | no assertion of notability, fails by a country mile; this is just some high school kid. Perhaps Mr. Gerst could review and explain to us which elements of its criteria he thinks he meets | Deletion of Gerst, Forrest J. | WP:BIO||WP:BIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
419 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seaport (New York City Subway station) | User:Bearian | 17:35, 3 May 2010 (UTC) | merge | per and WP:CRYSTAL. That way its history stays visible to those who know | Deletion of Seaport (New York City Subway station) | WP:CHEAP | Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap | 74 |
420 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IFrogz | User:Gavin | 07:20, 22 June 2007 (UTC) | delete | as this stub is pure |product placement | Deletion of IFrogz | WP:SPAM | Wikipedia:Spam | 26 |
421 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suelong Sae Ma | User:Fenix | 14:36, 9 July 2014 (UTC) | delete | Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements | Deletion of Suelong Sae Ma | WP:NFOOTY | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
422 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maine in popular culture | User:Rorshacma | 23:56, 15 April 2021 (UTC) | delete | The article is essentially a list, and as it stands, it does not pass . There are not really any valid reliable sources currently being used, and I did a couple of searches, and was not really able to find anything that covers the concept of Maine in pop culture as a whole | Deletion of Maine in popular culture | WP:LISTN | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
423 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenn Sasscer | User:Asenine | 03:56, 13 May 2008 (UTC) | delete | Seems to fail and | Deletion of Glenn Sasscer | WP:BK||WP:BIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
424 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phone Car | User:Buckyboy28 | 20:07, 20 July 2007 (UTC) | keep | If the claimed exhibition and article in a major motor magazine were properly referenced in the article and verifiable, it would go a long way toward satisfying . I note that the creator of the article | Deletion of Phone Car | WP:N | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
425 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mauritian of British origin | User:Metropolitan90 | 23:11, 12 April 2020 (UTC) | delete | "This article harkens back to a certain style of article we used to see more of at -- the ""Foobar|Fooian Barian"" ethnicity article. These articles would explain that Fooian Barians are people living in the country of Bar whose ancestry is from the country of Foo, that they speak the primary languages of Bar and Foo, they are found in the major cities of Bar, and practice the most common religions of Foo and Bar, but didn't provide any information the reader couldn't have guessed from the article title. The only nonobvious statement in this article is that 1% of the Mauritian population is of British descent -- but that statement isn't supported by either of its cited sources. It might seem to make sense to redirect this to White Mauritians, but that article is currently up for speedy deletion itself" | Deletion of Mauritian of British origin | WP:AFD | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion | 67 |
426 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE: Undertaker - From the Vault | User:The | 17:39, 1 May 2019 (UTC) | delete | "since subject fails . A lot of space is being wasted arguing on the basis of |""other similar stuff already exists in Wikipedia"". Which never helps" | Deletion of WWE: Undertaker - From the Vault | WP:GNG||WP:OSE | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
427 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Charlie Walker | User:Narky | 21:47, 9 February 2020 (UTC) | delete | All I could find was the IMDb entry cited in the article. IMDb is one of the classic examples of what is not a ; see Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources. Fails and | Deletion of I'm Charlie Walker | WP:RS||WP:NFILM||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
428 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashley Fernee | User:Whpq | 19:19, 31 October 2007 (UTC) | keep | meets for athletes having played at the top level of his sport | Deletion of Ashley Fernee | WP:BIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
429 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanders Bros., Inc. | User:Jeffrey | 01:29, 17 October 2009 (UTC) | delete | Article appears to show ''no'' evidence of notability and the subject appears to lack ''significant'' coverage. Voting in favour of delete as the subject fails to meet the |general notability guideline | Deletion of Sanders Bros., Inc. | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
430 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uathesis | User:David | 17:20, 10 February 2008 (UTC) | delete | per #A7. So tagged | Deletion of Uathesis | WP:CSD | Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion | 76 |
431 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hooker (Kent cricketer) | User:BlackJack | 05:01, 10 December 2009 (UTC) | keep | The subject was a first-class cricketer and as such meets the criteria laid down by and thereby | Deletion of Hooker (Kent cricketer) | WP:CRIN||WP:ATHLETE | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
432 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McMahon–Helmsley Faction | User:Dilbaggg | 19:12, 12 April 2021 (UTC) | comment | i am inclined to support keep but fact that the article has existed without any for a decade is baffling | Deletion of McMahon–Helmsley Faction | WP:RS | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
433 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JS Kabylie in Africa | User:Jacknstock | 14:14, 1 April 2018 (UTC) | keep | Wow, this is could become a particularly egregious case of (yes, I know it's not policy, but it is a real issue). Maybe if we included the 200 articles on clubs in European football... But that is a discussion better for WT:FOOTY. Is this one of the April Fools Day AfDs | Deletion of JS Kabylie in Africa | WP:BIAS | Wikipedia:Systemic bias | 83 |
434 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Maximilian de Gaynesford | User:Necrothesp | 10:21, 24 July 2019 (UTC) | comment | Note that if his chair is an established one instead of a personal one then he qualifies under #5. However, I can't determine whether it is or not. If kept, the article should be renamed Maximilian de Gaynesford, which appears to be his common name | Deletion of Robert Maximilian de Gaynesford | WP:NACADEMIC | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
435 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Multicultural education | User:Colonel | 18:18, 5 July 2011 (UTC) | keep | See ''http://books.google.com/books?id=d6r3r6x6E2kC&pg=PA296 Encyclopedia of education and human development'' for its article on ''Multicultural Education and Its Typologies''. Assembling such material into an NPOV whole will not be easy but seems feasible given time. Our |editing policy is to proceed by ordinary editing rather than deletion | Deletion of Multicultural education | WP:IMPERFECT | Wikipedia:Editing policy | 24 |
436 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael O'Connor (author, born 1944) | User:The | 06:30, 6 December 2017 (UTC) | delete | This is one more |promotional text masquerading as an encyclopaedia article | Deletion of Michael O'Connor (author, born 1944) | WP:PROMOTION | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
437 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Malov | User:Ejgreen77 | 01:44, 19 October 2017 (UTC) | keep | Easily meets #1 | Deletion of Roman Malov | WP:NHOCKEY | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
438 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. S. Daya Sagar | [[User talk:203.106.67.32|talk]]) | 03:02, 11 November 2014 (UTC) | keep | "His page needs to be kept live not only due to the fact that this page satisfies #C2, #C4, and to a very significant extent #C1. The two awards, this person recieved, that satisfy #C2 are Georges Matheron Lectureship and Krishnan Medal. A couple of examples evident from his homepagehttp://www.isibang.ac.in/~bsdsagar that satisfy #C4 include short reviews on his book titled ""Mathematical Morphology in Geomorphology and GISci"" http://www.isibang.ac.in/~bsdsagar/Quotes-from-Renowned-Experts.pdf, and Journal Reviewshttp://www.computingreviews.com/review/review_review.cfm?review_id=141739, http://pubs.cig-acsg.ca/doi/abs/10.5623/cig2013-056?journalCode=cig,http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11004-014-9569-3/fulltext.html to name a few on his book. This book is available in libraries wide across http://www.isibang.ac.in/~bsdsagar/MMGG-in-Libraries.txt. With all this, this page is a 'Strong Keep'. Wikipedia has pages on the names of the 'awards' that this person received, but why the page created on this person (a recipient of these awards) is nominated for deletion. Please keep this page live. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/203.106.67.32|203.106.67.32" | Deletion of B. S. Daya Sagar | WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
439 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jen Knox | User:Valereee | 14:18, 12 May 2015 (UTC) | delete | Not notable. Many references are affiliated -- from professional orgs, etc. She's won a couple of awards, so it's possible she'll eventually be notable, but | Deletion of Jen Knox | WP:TOOSOON | Wikipedia:Too soon | 1 |
440 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LaVerne Ray Fromberg | User:Montco | 04:06, 7 August 2007 (UTC) | delete | fails without sources. There is always monster.com for his resume | Deletion of LaVerne Ray Fromberg | WP:BIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
441 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy Eastwood | User:Instaurare | 23:45, 25 November 2016 (UTC) | delete | Fails | Deletion of Randy Eastwood | WP:POLITICIAN | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
442 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Manning (actor) | User:MichaelQSchmidt | 08:00, 26 August 2011 (UTC) | keep | He's done a bit more than ''just'' 16 episodes of ''The Real World: Washington D.C.''. Among his growing body of work we now have him as lead actor in ''Gingerdead Man 3: Saturday Night Cleaver''. And with his growing film and television career, the fellow pushes nicely at . The ''The Real World'' show's focusing on his sexual orientation, simply ensured that he would get the coverage to meet . As his career is moving forward, we can expect to hear more | Deletion of Mike Manning (actor) | WP:ENT||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
443 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Gruen | User:Tom29739 | 18:55, 2 May 2016 (UTC) | delete | Not enough sources to satisfy | Deletion of Walter Gruen | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
444 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Higgins | User:The | 14:39, 31 January 2007 (UTC) | delete | agreed, no notability asserted, and definitely | Deletion of Steve Higgins | WP:COI | Wikipedia:Conflict of interest | 59 |
445 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Overstone Combined School | User:Gateman1997 | 19:17, 10 November 2005 (UTC) | delete | with Wing, Buckinghamshire. Per developing consensus at | Deletion of Overstone Combined School | WP:SCH | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
446 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) | User:Spellcast | 00:27, 21 November 2009 (UTC) | delete | Wikipedia by its nature unfortunately suffers from which in the long-term places weight on specific events | Deletion of Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) | WP:RECENTISM||WP:UNDUE | Wikipedia:Recentism | 38 |
447 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bridgeheads | User:NawlinWiki | 04:32, 25 December 2007 (UTC) | delete | fails , no indep. reliable sources | Deletion of The Bridgeheads | WP:BAND | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
448 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacie Laughton | User:Presidentman | 21:36, 3 December 2012 (UTC) | keep | May pass #1 as a former(?) member of a state legislature, and clearly passes #2 | Deletion of Stacie Laughton | WP:POLITICIAN | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
449 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eleazar: | User:danntm | 15:02, 26 September 2006 (UTC) | delete | under |Wikipedia is not a free webhost or advertising service, |Wikipedia is not for advertising, and | Deletion of Eleazar: | WP:NOT||WP:SPAM||WP:VAIN | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
450 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leda Dionissia Alexopoulou | User:SpK | 22:06, 14 October 2009 (UTC) | delete | per and per Modernist's comment | Deletion of Leda Dionissia Alexopoulou | WP:RS | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
451 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clips4Sale | User:Ammarpad | 17:40, 5 December 2017 (UTC) | keep | rated just above 1500 in Alexa rank and more sources given above by Storm, this is clearly not vanity website. And websites are not bound by that's for companies not websites. It does meet guideline because of this coverage https://thefpl.us/episode/209, in magazine, https://wearyourvoicemag.com/news/social-media-sites-soft-banning-sex-workers-matters, in HW reporter https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/fetish-group-nancy-grace-dancing-stars-fart-245592. These sources and the one I added below (with many from others here), they definitely established , as it is widely recognized by independent sources | Deletion of Clips4Sale | WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NWEB||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
452 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecil (lion) (2nd nomination) | User:EvergreenFir | 20:54, 5 August 2015 (UTC) | keep | or rename, don't care. I argued in the last AfD for the old name, but sources keep asserting the notability of the lion so the current title seems apt enough. But this AfD is |pointy and has about a |snowball's chance in hell. Nominator appears to misunderstand what AfD is... it's not a vote and it's not a place to air grievances. Her insistence of keeping it open for 7 days demonstrates this well | Deletion of Cecil (lion) (2nd nomination) | WP:POINT||WP:SNOW | Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point | 28 |
453 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Egyptian Pong | User:Reyk | 19:48, 10 December 2008 (UTC) | delete | Sourceless and, I strongly suspect, unsourceable article about a game that someone |made up one day | Deletion of Egyptian Pong | WP:NFT | Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day | 88 |
454 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nancy LaMott | User:Hrafn | 04:12, 29 May 2009 (UTC) | delete | fails to meet any of the specific criteria of . Cited coverage (three New York obituaries) fails to provide sufficient coverage to meet . Article is almost entirely unsourced | Deletion of Nancy LaMott | WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
455 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Chasan | User:Jkudlick | 07:13, 18 January 2015 (UTC) | delete | While becoming an Eagle Scout (Boy Scouts of America)|Eagle Scout is a great personal achievment, it is not inherently notable because literally millions of American boys have earned the rank. Becoming an Oracle Certification Program#Oracle Certified Professional Java SE Programmer (formerly the Sun Certified Java Programmer)|Oracle Certified Java Programmer is not notable, as that is the lowest level of certification in that particular language. Nothing else mentioned in the article rises to meeting , and none of the coverage provided rises beyond , thus is also failed. I don't recommend SALTing unless the article is recreated | Deletion of Jake Chasan | WP:BIO||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
456 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archaeoporn | User:Zahakiel | 15:10, 5 March 2007 (UTC) | delete | "As neo as a ~logism can be. Regarding the comment above, it is true that this does not appear to meet any specific articles for speedy deletion, but an administrator can (and should, in my view) speedily close this debate because, as stated in , ""If an issue doesn't have a snowball's chance in hell of getting an unexpected outcome from a certain process, then there is no need to run it through that process."" I think that any editor other than maybe the author voting to ""keep"" this despite it's undeniable status as a recently created term for any policy-based reason is a remote possibility beyond any reasonable expectation" | Deletion of Archaeoporn | WP:SNOW | Wikipedia:Snowball clause | 87 |
457 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 College Football Championship Game | User:Paulmcdonald | 17:32, 14 January 2014 (UTC) | keep | I do not believe this is too soon at all. Information on the 2014 season has already begun, including coaching changes, recruiting, etc. Bowl schedules are being assembled and locations are being named. ESPN and other sportswriters have even made predictions on who will win this game. And since this game is the culmination of the 2014 season (played in January 2015) I believe that removing it would be bad. Further, more than enough has been written in the media about this game already that it clearly passes , the general notability guideline. So much has gone in to the preparation of this game in the media that it could have been created a year ago and would still have passed even then | Deletion of 2015 College Football Championship Game | WP:GNG||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
458 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roberta Weiss | User:Michig | 07:36, 24 August 2018 (UTC) | keep | The significant role in ''Santa Barbara'' (161 episodes) is easily verified, and as well as a smallish role in ''The Dead Zone'', she had a lead role in ''How to Make Love to a Negro Without Getting Tired'' (https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=pK8DAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA60&dq=roberta+bizeau&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj57rfllIXdAhWrDsAKHVWnCgIQ6AEIMzAC#v=onepage&q=roberta%20bizeau&f=false, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=kVgEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA7&dq=roberta+bizeau&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj57rfllIXdAhWrDsAKHVWnCgIQ6AEINzAD#v=onepage&q=roberta%20bizeau&f=false), as well as significant roles in ''Mangeuses d'Hommes'', ''High Stakes'', and ''Abducted''. Easily satisifes | Deletion of Roberta Weiss | WP:NACTOR | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
459 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BAE AUDIO | User:Agtx | 17:18, 12 July 2015 (UTC) | delete | "Looking at ""BAE Audio"" and ""British Audio Engineering"" (their new name per the article), turns up a couple more things but they're all press releases. No independent secondary source coverage of the type that would meet " | Deletion of BAE AUDIO | WP:ORGIND | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
460 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Women's League of Chinland | User:GeoffreyT2000 | 05:25, 18 February 2017 (UTC) | delete | The Google search link does not find any reliable sources. The organization thus fails | Deletion of Women's League of Chinland | WP:ORG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
461 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Ondessonk | User:Ivanvector | 17:06, 30 May 2014 (UTC) | keep | this seems to be a fairly well known summer camp, based on web presence and Google Books hits, enough to pass GNG I think. The page needs to be seriously trimmed though, it seriously fails and nearly every source given is 'd | Deletion of Camp Ondessonk | WP:NOTGUIDE||WP:SELFPUB | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
462 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Ashlee | User:Lar | 12:19, 12 April 2010 (UTC) | delete | per lack of notability as ably argued by Bali U et al. is fatally flawed, and every article that is deleted despite citing it, is one more argument for fixing it (eventually | Deletion of Christopher Ashlee | WP:PORNBIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
463 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. N. Samarasekera | User:Dan | 04:58, 2 August 2021 (UTC) | delete | should have been a procedural delete in that the article's creator is proposing the article be deleted. Clearly fails to satisfy the requirements of / | Deletion of D. N. Samarasekera | WP:NSCHOLAR||WP:ANYBIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
464 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Facility 9461 | User:Quarl | NONE | delete | as |non-notable and |unverifiable (8 unrelated Ghits). &mdash | Deletion of Facility 9461 | WP:N||WP:V | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
465 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Change Is Gonna Come (The West Wing) | User:Sgeureka | 14:00, 16 July 2012 (UTC) | merge | which also silences the ''keep because you can't delete merged content'' votes. So, this article fails #PLOT and doesn't establish otability. Plus per , this means there is no basis for a stand-alone episode article. &ndash | Deletion of A Change Is Gonna Come (The West Wing) | WP:NOT||WP:N||WP:AVOIDSPLIT | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
466 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Branch Insurance | User:Theroadislong | 21:08, 18 January 2021 (UTC) | delete | I declined this as a draft back in December as not meeting our notability guidelines, despite much editing in the meantime it still seems to fail | Deletion of Branch Insurance | WP:NCORP | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
467 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimo Nadeem | User:Rinfoli | 12:03, 22 April 2014 (UTC) | delete | WP:NFOOTBALL fail | Deletion of Dimo Nadeem | WP:BIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
468 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Morris (activist) | User:86 | 13:25, 12 February 2007 (UTC) | comment | May I also note ? The assumption should be that | Deletion of Chris Morris (activist) | WP:AGF | Wikipedia:Assume good faith | 53 |
469 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/General Pissedness Factor (GPF) | User:Black | 02:27, 16 February 2007 (UTC) | delete | this article seems to have been created in an environment characterized by a GPF of 8.6 and thus is in violation of . But seriously, delete per | Deletion of General Pissedness Factor (GPF) | WP:CIVIL||WP:HOAX | Wikipedia:Civility | 90 |
470 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Be Anounced Nine Inch Nails Album | User:Mrschimpf | 12:34, 10 February 2010 (UTC) | delete | WP:HAMMER and What's next? Kim Kardashian's proposed first musical compilation project? These spec titles just keep getting crazier | Deletion of To Be Anounced Nine Inch Nails Album | WP:CRYSTAL | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
471 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Digimon locations | User:Undead | 16:49, 23 August 2015 (UTC) | delete | This one appears to be pure |List cruft. It is terribly written and comes off as a fan site. Having it doesn't help out the Digimon article | Deletion of List of Digimon locations | WP:LISTCRUFT | Wikipedia:Listcruft | 66 |
472 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randall Bell (3rd nomination) | User:Magnolia677 | 22:43, 6 June 2020 (UTC) | keep | "No doubt a promo, but the guy passes and . I Googled ""Randall Bell""""appraiser"" and found one reliable source after another. And not just passing mention, these are full articles about Bell, see https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/manson-oj-simpson-heavens-gate-murder-real-estate-appraiser-randall-bell-804463/,https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/13/nyregion/in-newtown-conn-a-question-of-what-to-do-with-adam-lanzas-home.html,https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1997-11-21-9711210183-story.html" | Deletion of Randall Bell (3rd nomination) | WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
473 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheyi Ojo | User:GiantSnowman | 20:58, 5 January 2015 (UTC) | delete | "certainly fails , and seems to fail . Not convinced by the coverage, it's all too ""OMG a young prospect!!!"" for my liking" | Deletion of Sheyi Ojo | WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
474 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Group Facilitation: A Research and Applications Journal | User:Phoenixred | 14:22, 19 December 2012 (UTC) | keep | I believe that the journal meets and ournals. This is a well established journal that is indexed in major databases that focus on the scholarly study of business (https://ulrichsweb.serialssolutions.com/title/1355926195765/488502 EBSCO's Business Source series, ABI/INFORM, and several ProQuest databases). Additionally, a quick web search shows that articles in the journal have been cited repeatedly across both books on facilitation and scholarly articles on facilitation that appear in other journals. However, the article definitely needs to be fleshed out to help illustrate that fact (which I'm happy to help in accomplishing). Thanks | Deletion of Group Facilitation: A Research and Applications Journal | WP:GNG||WP:NJ | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
475 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Port Prophecy | User:Quarl | NONE | delete | as |non-notable website. Alexa rank 56,055 . &mdash | Deletion of Port Prophecy | WP:WEB | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
476 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marie-Laure Sauty de Chalon | User:Bearian | 20:49, 9 February 2011 (UTC) | keep | over 40,000 Ghits; |two reliable sources in English already are in the stub; some indication of notability. Rescue | Deletion of Marie-Laure Sauty de Chalon | WP:RS | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
477 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerard Duveen | User:Anthony | 14:51, 9 March 2007 (UTC) | delete | Does not apear to satisfy | Deletion of Gerard Duveen | WP:PROF | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
478 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alice City | User:Gab4gab | 16:54, 2 February 2017 (UTC) | keep | "The article 2nd ext link exists at WayBackMachine. It was helpful to search books using (""Alice City"" underground) which found: https://books.google.com/books?id=CLYbUQlpb-kC&pg=PA31&dq=%22Alice+City%22+underground&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjyhLC66vHRAhVByVQKHSegCeUQ6AEIGjAA#v=onepage&q=%22Alice%20City%22%20underground&f=false New Scientist article, https://books.google.com/books?id=m4sky8hXunsC&pg=PA61&dq=%22Alice+City%22+underground&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjyhLC66vHRAhVByVQKHSegCeUQ6AEIHjAB#v=onepage&q=%22Alice%20City%22%20underground&f=false Underground Infrastructures (book), https://books.google.com/books?id=Ih8Hz5Xsvj4C&pg=PR18&dq=%22Alice+City%22+underground&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjyhLC66vHRAhVByVQKHSegCeUQ6AEIJjAC#v=onepage&q=%22Alice%20City%22%20underground&f=false Megacities, Labour, Communications (book), https://books.google.com/books?id=UORSzFBv1tAC&pg=PA49&dq=%22Alice+City%22+underground&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjyhLC66vHRAhVByVQKHSegCeUQ6AEINzAG#v=onepage&q=%22Alice%20City%22%20underground&f=false Seizing the Future (book) and many others. The number of books indicates a degree of interest in the subject to be an exception of imo" | Deletion of Alice City | WP:CRYSTAL | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
479 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Net channels | User:Stuartyeates | 04:58, 4 November 2012 (UTC) | delete | as falling foul of and completely unsourced | Deletion of List of Net channels | WP:NOTDIR | Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not | 69 |
480 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little pieces | User:Ducknish | 22:24, 4 May 2012 (UTC) | delete | seeing as the virus did no real damage and no news reports seem to exist, it fails | Deletion of Little pieces | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
481 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forever Red (movie) | User:Ryulong | 21:15, 24 October 2006 (UTC) | delete | but I'm sure that there's got to be a CSD for this article, if not | Deletion of Forever Red (movie) | WP:IAR | Wikipedia:Ignore all rules | 63 |
482 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. Bap Reddy (2nd nomination) | User:onel5969 | 12:34, 29 December 2020 (UTC) | delete | not enough in-depth coverage to show that they pass | Deletion of D. Bap Reddy (2nd nomination) | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
483 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NoHomers.net (2nd nomination) | [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] | 16:00, 21 November 2013 (UTC) | delete | "Lacks any in-depth, independent coverage in reliable sources. A mention on a commercial DVD by the Matt Groening does not impart notability. |""Notable"" is not synonymous with ""fame"" or ""importance,"". Fails CRIT" | Deletion of NoHomers.net (2nd nomination) | WP:WEB||WP:WEBCRIT | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
484 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arun Dev Yadav | User:Princepratap1234 | 11:45, 3 July 2021 (UTC) | delete | fails | Deletion of Arun Dev Yadav | WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
485 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global smoking habit | User:Celarnor | 01:20, 1 May 2008 (UTC) | delete | Mostly |original research and |synthesis | Deletion of Global smoking habit | WP:OR||WP:SYNTH | Wikipedia:No original research | 12 |
486 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendy Lou | User:Thsmi002 | 23:55, 17 March 2019 (UTC) | keep | per #3. Lou is a Fellow of the American Statistical Association | Deletion of Wendy Lou | WP:PROF | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
487 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Sinjin (2nd nomination) | User:MCB | 22:58, 22 January 2006 (UTC) | keep | bad faith nom, . After a dozen or more of these it is time to block nominator for disruption of Wikipedia | Deletion of Sean Sinjin (2nd nomination) | WP:POINT | Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point | 28 |
488 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry the Green Engine | User:Archrogue | 00:24, 30 November 2020 (UTC) | merge | if possible. There is some information here to preserve. Some of it is about the story that Henry appears in and not on topic. But the Washington Post article does cover some interesting facts about Henry. I agree this isn't enough to establish |notability but it is worth | Deletion of Henry the Green Engine | WP:N||WP:PRESERVING | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
489 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Sign Language grammar | User:Jayron32 | 05:48, 30 October 2007 (UTC) | delete | I was about to say keep per Summary Style, however, this article is entirely redundant with the main ASL article, so I would say that delete and redirect is in order here. However, no prejudice to recreating the article as a Summary Fork since the main ASL article is quite long and it may be appropriate to split it up per | Deletion of American Sign Language grammar | WP:SUMMARY | Wikipedia:Summary style | 23 |
490 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bells (band) (2nd nomination) | User:RadioFan | 02:04, 13 July 2013 (UTC) | comment | Please dont imply that you are clarifying Wikipedia policy or even practice. What you note here just doesn't match up with how Wikipedia works. Please review particularly the section which reads ''The burden of evidence lies with the editor who adds or restores material | Deletion of Bells (band) (2nd nomination) | WP:PROVEIT | Wikipedia:Verifiability | 2 |
491 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HEWI London | User:K | 00:52, 6 December 2017 (UTC) | delete | fails & ; an advertorial piece on an unremarkable company | Deletion of HEWI London | WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NCORP | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
492 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PropertyGuru (company) | User:Black | 10:23, 15 June 2021 (UTC) | keep | "There's a protocol for dealing with articles which if followed would have lead the nominator to consider . The claim that the article ""majorly having refs from just one source The Straits Times"" is not justified. The subject has wp:sigcov meeting the wp:3REFS minimum in wp:RS one of which, {{Cite news|title=TPG-Backed PropertyGuru Eyes $2 Billion Thiel SPAC Deal|url=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-08/li-s-bridgetown-2-spac-said-in-talks-to-merge-with-propertyguru|last=Li|first=Fiona|date=2021-06-08|access-date=2021-06-15|work=Bloomberg News}} is listed green at (Bloomberg News). In regards to The Straits Times, it's WP entry says, ""daily average circulation of 364,134 and 364,849 respectively in 2017"" and while there is some criticism further down the page alluding to its unreliability for politically charged matters there is no consensus at stating that The Straits Times is unreliable for purposes of establishing . Additionally, the WP for Business Times (Singapore) reads ""'''The ''Business Times''''' is Singapore's only financial daily"" and although it shares the same parent company as The Straits Times it hasn't been part of the paper for almost half a century. There's also significant coverage in CNA (TV network) {{Cite news|title=Singapore's PropertyGuru raises S$200m funding from KKR|url=https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/business/singapore-s-propertyguru-raises-s-200m-funding-from-kkr-10883868|date=2018-10-31|access-date=2021-06-08|work=CNA (TV network)}} one of Singapore's national news channels, all of which adds up to " | Deletion of PropertyGuru (company) | WP:MILL||WP:ATD||WP:RSP||WP:RSN||WP:NCORP||WP:NCORP | Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill | 32 |
493 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhoom 3 (film) | User:MichaelQSchmidt | 18:49, 21 February 2009 (UTC) | delete | as failing | Deletion of Dhoom 3 (film) | WP:NFF | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
494 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XStoryPlayer | User:Sergecross73 | 12:46, 13 March 2012 (UTC) | delete | Lack of coverage in |third party, reliable sources. Doesn't meet the | Deletion of XStoryPlayer | WP:RS||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Reliable sources | 31 |
495 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shinmeiryuu | User:JJL | 00:26, 12 January 2009 (UTC) | delete | "it's but I see no evidence that it's notable or a fork of something like the ""Akamatsu-verse"" referred to there; plus, it seems to be misspelled (an extra ''u'' at the end). Also seems to have elements of at least . Perhaps correct the spelling and rd to the author's page; if it covers a few series, it's likely worth a rd" | Deletion of Shinmeiryuu | WP:INTERESTING||WP:SYNTH | Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions | 20 |
496 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chocolate Crunchies | User:Bakazaka | 06:36, 10 February 2019 (UTC) | comment | If you already merged the content (step 1 of ), then continue the merge by creating a redirect (step 2 of ), both for attribution and in case anyone objects and wants to revert. There's no obvious reason here to stop after step 1, and the only other editor who has touched that article or talk page since 2015 has ''supported'' your merge. I encourage you to continue being by withdrawing this nomination and finishing the merge with a redirect per | Deletion of Chocolate Crunchies | WP:MERGETEXT||WP:MERGETEXT||WP:BOLD||WP:MERGETEXT | Wikipedia:Merging | 58 |
497 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nintendo's Castle | User:GIen | 15:20, 17 August 2006 (UTC) | delete | nn {{tl|db-bio}} does not even qualify for an Alexa Internet rank or meet | Deletion of Nintendo's Castle | WP:WEB | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
498 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harbhajan Singh (military officer) | User:Mztourist | 05:12, 26 June 2020 (UTC) | delete | fails and | Deletion of Harbhajan Singh (military officer) | WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG | Wikipedia:Notability | 71 |
499 | Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Razgar Rahimi | User:Bearcat | 16:48, 20 January 2021 (UTC) | delete | Establishing that a person is notable enough for a Wikipedia article is not a question of verifying facts via his own |self-published content about himself — it's a question of how much |reliable source coverage has or hasn't been ''paid'' to him and his work by ''media'' outlets. So a person isn't notable just because he has a staff profile on the website of his own former employer, or a press release from his own former employer, or directory entries in academic directories — to be notable, ''external'' sources he is ''not'' affiliated with have to have deemed his work ''significant'', such as by doing journalism about him and/or giving him a noteworthy ''award'' for his work. But the only genuine media source here is a short blurb about his death in a listicle that blurbs ''everybody'' who died in the same plane crash, which is not in and of itself enough | Deletion of Razgar Rahimi | WP:SELFPUB||WP:RS | Wikipedia:Verifiability | 2 |
Subsets and Splits