Unnamed: 0
int64 0
372k
| title
stringlengths 33
257
| username
stringlengths 4
785
| timestamp
stringlengths 4
30
| decision
stringclasses 4
values | comment
stringlengths 2
14.5k
⌀ | topic
stringlengths 13
237
| policies
stringlengths 4
222
| policy_title
stringclasses 94
values | policy_index
int64 0
93
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
600 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Rowsell
|
User:Tokyogirl79
|
06:44, 13 July 2016 (UTC)
|
delete
|
He seems to be quite knowledgeable on his chosen topics, but I just can't find anything to show that he's notable per Wikipedia's guidelines. He hasn't been the focus of any coverage that has been specifically about him or his works and he wouldn't qualify under since his work hasn't really been picked up anywhere, or at least not in the places Wikipedia would consider for that criteria. It's actually incredibly difficult to argue notability for scholars since they rarely get the amount of coverage or references necessary to pass GNG or ACADEMIC and Roswell is just another scholar who falls short of what is needed. This doesn't mean that he can't be good at what he does, just that it's really hard to pass guidelines. I think that the best I found was https://www.morningstaronline.co.uk/a-0e7b-Runes,-ruins-and-revelations this review by the Morning Star (British newspaper)|Morning Star, which is considered a tabloid on here
|
Deletion of Thomas Rowsell
|
WP:ACADEMIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
601 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinnerbone
|
user:czar
|
19:52, 3 May 2015 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) As for the argument that the subject is popular on Twitter, still no part of this bio meets |the notability guideline for creatives. Only hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search were in passing. The subject is not mentioned at either the Mojang or Minecraft articles, so those would not be worthwhile redirects. If there was something on Bukkit, perhaps, but there isn't a section for that (perhaps because it isn't notable). Please ping me you find more (non-English and offline) sources. czar 
|
Deletion of Dinnerbone
|
WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:CREATIVE||WP:VG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
602 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeshivat Shaare Torah
|
User:Cullen328
|
23:30, 10 March 2017 (UTC)
|
comment
|
In my opinion, this discussion has been badly contaminated by a series of falsehoods that {{u|Wiki-Coffee}} has been spreading about Yeshivat Shaare Torah, both here and at illage pump (policy). This editor has stated the school's enrollment is 60 half day students. That is false. The fact is that this organization operates a preschool program, a boys elementary school, a girls elementary school, a boys high school and a girls high school, with a combined enrollment of well over 1000 students. The editor claims that it is a profit making business. That is false. The organization is a registered tax exempt non-profit educational group. The editor claims that the only sources available about the organization are self published. That is false. I have added eleven independent references which verify the claims made in the article. Anyone who wants to cite Yeshivat Shaare Torah as an example of why we need to delete articles about secondary schools should rethink their position. Instead, it is an example of failure to properly research the topic before nominating an article for deletion, and a willingness to rely on falsehoods in an enthusiastic drive to delete
|
Deletion of Yeshivat Shaare Torah
|
WP:V
|
Wikipedia:Verifiability
| 2 |
603 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wireless (band)
|
[[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]]
|
15:13, 1 March 2006 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Found nothing in the article or on the group's website to indicate that the group meets
|
Deletion of Wireless (band)
|
WP:MUSIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
604 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Seaside Park, New Jersey fire
|
User:LGA
|
09:22, 13 September 2013 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Fails |WP is not a newspaper policy, no demonstrated lasting significance this is at best a local news story only - WikiNews is the place for this. In addressing directly the need time to see if it is notable, main space is not for that, we don't create articles on every high school football player because we need time to see if they make the professional grade
|
Deletion of 2013 Seaside Park, New Jersey fire
|
WP:NOTNEWS
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
605 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skateboading walrus style
|
User:NeoChaosX
|
06:28, 12 December 2007 (UTC)
|
delete
|
"Something being ""real"" or existing doesn't automatically make it |notable, though. No |sources about this style available"
|
Deletion of Skateboading walrus style
|
WP:N||WP:RS
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
606 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuelmyblog (2nd nomination)
|
User:Bearian
|
22:33, 3 January 2020 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per - extremely vague claims, poor sourcing, and inconsistent citation style - as well as concerns
|
Deletion of Fuelmyblog (2nd nomination)
|
WP:TNT||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over
| 4 |
607 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nungleppam Buddhimanta Singh
|
User:onel5969
|
16:20, 20 July 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
not nearly enough in-depth coverage to meet , nor
|
Deletion of Nungleppam Buddhimanta Singh
|
WP:GNG||WP:NBASIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
608 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Voice (Brooke Hogan album)
|
User:Gongshow
|
17:41, 22 March 2010 (UTC)
|
delete
|
I can't find any significant coverage in |reliable sources for this unreleased album; it appears to fail
|
Deletion of This Voice (Brooke Hogan album)
|
WP:RS||WP:NALBUMS
|
Wikipedia:Reliable sources
| 31 |
609 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahin Abbasian
|
User:Spiderone
|
22:11, 4 January 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
sources do not establish notability; http://bazideraz1404.ir/news/203864/%D8%B4%D8%A7%D9%87%DB%8C%D9%86-%D8%B9%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%B3%DB%8C%D8%A7%D9%86-%D8%AF%D8%B1-%D9%85%DB%8C%D8%A7%D9%86-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84-%DA%AF%D8%B1%D9%85-%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%A6%D9%88%D9%84%DB%8C%D9%86-%D9%88%D9%85%D8%B1%D8%AF%D9%85-%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%AF-%D8%B4%D9%87%D8%B1%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86-%D8%B4%D8%AF this is the only one with anything even close to in-depth coverage. Some of them, such as https://www.soccerpunter.com/player/1548454/Shahin-Abbasian Soccerpunter actually prove that he is ''not'' notable. Fails . We should wait until he passes before creating an article on him again
|
Deletion of Shahin Abbasian
|
WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
610 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/263.net
|
User:Gene93k
|
10:16, 25 June 2008 (UTC)
|
keep
|
and expand. 263.net has plenty of 3rd-party coverage to satisfy and . They are one of the biggest Internet companies in China. Some coverage: http://www.atimes.com/bizasia/AL23Aa01.html Asia Times, http://english.people.com.cn/english/200009/23/eng20000923_51135.html People's Daily, http://www.infoworld.com/articles/hn/xml/00/07/28/000728hnchina.html InfoWorld, http://www.chinatechnews.com/2008/04/16/6624-263netcns-dream-of-ipo-all-wet/ ChinaTechNews
|
Deletion of 263.net
|
WP:RS||WP:CORP||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Reliable sources
| 31 |
611 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JC Gonzalez
|
User:CactusWriter
|
18:11, 12 January 2016 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Fails and . No significant coverage by independent reliable sources
|
Deletion of JC Gonzalez
|
WP:BIO||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
612 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simeon Ekpe
|
User:Pburka
|
01:35, 20 May 2011 (UTC)
|
keep
|
It's not a . The article states that the subject died in 2010. I've removed it from :Category:Living people. The subject was a judge in a national court of appeal. I believe that this constitutes notability, as long as it is verifiable
|
Deletion of Simeon Ekpe
|
WP:BLP
|
Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons
| 15 |
613 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of historically male names now used for females
|
[[User talk:PeaceNT|''P''ea]][[Special:Contributions/PeaceNT|ceNT]]
|
15:36, 18 February 2007 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per obvious violation
|
Deletion of List of historically male names now used for females
|
WP:OR
|
Wikipedia:No original research
| 12 |
614 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godwin Maduka
|
User:SportingFlyer
|
23:28, 14 June 2021 (UTC)
|
keep
|
The article is clearly biased and needs a lot of work but this does not seem to fail . Maduka has had plenty of coverage as a gubernatorial candidate, some promotional interviews but mostly standard election coverage that prove notability. Like
|
Deletion of Godwin Maduka
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
615 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speaking Dictionary
|
User:Hyperbole
|
23:53, 8 February 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
no assertion of notability. Suggest someone apply at this point
|
Deletion of Speaking Dictionary
|
WP:SNOW
|
Wikipedia:Snowball clause
| 87 |
616 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nazism in Arab Palestine
|
User:Gatoclass
|
19:06, 21 September 2010 (UTC)
|
delete
|
"very little about the purported topic, ""Nazism in Arab Palestine"", but basically a of every connection to fascism in the Arab world that someone could dredge up, in addition to more COATRACK sections and BLP violations pertaining to alleged Holocaust revisionism/denial and so on. The small amount of legitimate information here is either already in more appropriate articles (such as the Mohammad Amin al-Husseini|al-Husseini article) or is presented completely without context. Also concur with the nominator's comments"
|
Deletion of Nazism in Arab Palestine
|
WP:COATRACK
|
Wikipedia:Coatrack articles
| 47 |
617 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Names of Hillary Clinton
|
User:Parsley
|
00:57, 15 February 2016 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per . I am not seeing anything that would qualify this as a biography topic. I mean, everyone has alternate names, but I don't see any notable articles for those
|
Deletion of Names of Hillary Clinton
|
WP:BLP
|
Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons
| 15 |
618 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heimat ist das, was gesprochen wird
|
User:Roscelese
|
15:18, 25 April 2011 (UTC)
|
keep
|
Passes criterion #5 of as the author has won a Nobel in literature
|
Deletion of Heimat ist das, was gesprochen wird
|
WP:NBOOK
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
619 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Early bird dinner
|
User:Bearian
|
19:34, 30 December 2008 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"This is a perfectly good . From personal experience, the use of a""early bird"" specials or ""buppers"" occur throughout the eastern USA and Canada. Surely this can be resuced"
|
Deletion of Early bird dinner
|
WP:STUB
|
Wikipedia:Stub
| 39 |
620 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabioacademy.com
|
NONE
|
NONE
|
delete
|
Fails and the only http://www.google.com/search?num=100&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&rls=CYBA%2CCYBA%3A2006-12%2CCYBA%3Aen&q=%22Sabioacademy%22+-wikipedia+-answers.com ghits are for its own site or directory pages David<span
|
Deletion of Sabioacademy.com
|
WP:WEB
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
621 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Lehar
|
User:David
|
05:39, 11 September 2014 (UTC)
|
delete
|
"As I wrote when seconding a prod on this article a year ago by {{user|Rschwieb}}, ""Per , fringe subjects need reliable mainstream sources allowing us to describe their ideas from a |neutral point of view. No such sources are evident in this case"
|
Deletion of Steven Lehar
|
WP:FRINGE||WP:NPOV
|
Wikipedia:Fringe theories
| 44 |
622 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alissa White-Gluz
|
User:Bearcat
|
16:52, 18 November 2008 (UTC)
|
merge
|
and '''redirect'''. I think it's which clarifies that individual musicians within a band should generally be redirects to the band unless they're independently notable for something ''other'' than the band — had she '''won''' ''Canadian Idol'', she'd probably merit her own article, but I don't see why simply being a ''contestant'' couldn't be adequately addressed by discussing it in the band's article instead of a standalone
|
Deletion of Alissa White-Gluz
|
WP:MUSIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
623 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indian National Congress (Amarinder)
|
User:Hako9
|
22:31, 21 July 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Assuming this is about rumours on CM Amarinder Singh and Navjot Singh Sidhu (not that it matters), likely qualifies for
|
Deletion of Indian National Congress (Amarinder)
|
WP:A11
|
Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion
| 76 |
624 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Johnn
|
User:JJL
|
03:38, 6 December 2007 (UTC)
|
delete
|
would change this given for the claims of and a less hagiographic tone to the article
|
Deletion of Kevin Johnn
|
WP:RS||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Reliable sources
| 31 |
625 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3 CD Collector's Set (Rihanna album)
|
User:Status
|
02:43, 16 May 2012 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"I'm not understanding the argument. The ""background"" section, in which you are referring to, consists of information about the release and what is contained within it. I know this is probably against , but for example, ''My Worlds: The Collection'' basically consists of the same thing; the only difference being it was more commercially successful. Also, thought it might be a good mention, the article isn't even complete yet. I guess now me and Tomica are pressed for time to complete it... — "
|
Deletion of 3 CD Collector's Set (Rihanna album)
|
WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS
|
Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions
| 20 |
626 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wimbledon Estates
|
User:Eddie
|
02:10, 29 July 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
for failure to establish notability and potential breach of
|
Deletion of Wimbledon Estates
|
WP:NOT
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
627 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uma stone
|
User:Niteshift36
|
18:53, 31 December 2009 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Fails
|
Deletion of Uma stone
|
WP:PORNBIO
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
628 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ace Andres
|
User:Gwalla
|
21:23, 3 July 2008 (UTC)
|
comment
|
I see two links to The Wave (seems like a local magazine?), one profile promoting an upcoming show in the Oakland Tribune, and one to a page of videos of Terri Schiavo. Those media mentions aren't enough to demonstrate notability per , and the Schiavo one doesn't mention Ace Andres at all. &mdash
|
Deletion of Ace Andres
|
WP:BAND
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
629 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Mercedez (2nd nomination)
|
User:The
|
05:42, 14 August 2019 (UTC)
|
delete
|
since, irrespective of possibly subject's own request to eliminate the text, the subject fails the |now more stringent criteria for porn player notability
|
Deletion of Nina Mercedez (2nd nomination)
|
WP:NPORN
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
630 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flumen solum
|
User:JohnCD
|
20:28, 28 March 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fictional items from an unpublished book cannot possibly be |notable
|
Deletion of Flumen solum
|
WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
631 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlsbad Gap
|
User:Subdolous
|
19:25, 30 October 2007 (UTC)
|
delete
|
No reliable sources given. Not notable. See and
|
Deletion of Carlsbad Gap
|
WP:V||WP:NOTE
|
Wikipedia:Verifiability
| 2 |
632 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transdimensional mathematics
|
User:PianoDan
|
00:05, 30 January 2015 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per . Also because it's gibberish
|
Deletion of Transdimensional mathematics
|
WP:OR
|
Wikipedia:No original research
| 12 |
633 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catherine S. Snodgrass
|
User:power
|
21:05, 17 September 2018 (UTC)
|
delete
|
I don't see sufficient coverage for GNG or awards that would meet ANYBIO; the two children's books (of no particular prominence) aren't enough to meet either
|
Deletion of Catherine S. Snodgrass
|
WP:NAUTHOR
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
634 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haleh Ghoreishi
|
User:Crusio
|
10:16, 30 October 2011 (UTC)
|
keep
|
I'm not sure she meets WP:PROF: neither GS, nor WoS give high levels of citations (but WoS is not very strong in this area). However, I think this is a clear pass of per the reerences dug up by Drmies: interview in ''Intermediair'' (a rather prestigious publication), interviews in respectable newspapers, TV appearances
|
Deletion of Haleh Ghoreishi
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
635 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Elmore
|
User:aktsu
|
00:08, 12 May 2009 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Without any |significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject to show notability it's hard to vote anything else
|
Deletion of Phil Elmore
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
636 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richa (Actress)
|
User:Rms125a
|
00:31, 28 May 2015 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fails
|
Deletion of Richa (Actress)
|
WP:NACTOR
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
637 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Ward (2nd nomination)
|
User:Tchaliburton
|
15:12, 19 October 2014 (UTC)
|
keep
|
I think that CTV can be trusted as a reliable source. But in any case, http://articles.philly.com/1999-09-20/news/25489506_1_outstanding-news-steve-schwaid-news-director here is another reference that mentions her Emmy win. I believe this is sufficient for reative. It does need to be cleaned up, but AFD is not cleanup. Here are some references that may help: http://articles.philly.com/1997-10-08/entertainment/25536739_1_kyw-newscast-ken-matz 1, http://articles.philly.com/1997-12-03/entertainment/25554403_1_anchor-team-newscast-weekend-sports-anchor 2, http://articles.philly.com/1993-03-24/news/25952267_1_farrow-single-mother-judge-elliot-wilk 3
|
Deletion of Jennifer Ward (2nd nomination)
|
WP:C
|
Wikipedia:Copyrights
| 60 |
638 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levi Sanders
|
User:SportingFlyer
|
22:31, 28 February 2018 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as it stands now; right now, the article is basically just a blurb. Not prejudiced to its recreation
|
Deletion of Levi Sanders
|
WP:INHERITED
|
Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions
| 20 |
639 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worcestershire Record Office
|
User:Huon
|
22:57, 30 October 2008 (UTC)
|
comment
|
"please do not ""vote"" twice. The problem is not one of reliability, but of |notability. A Wikipedia article should be based on secondary sources. If those sources don't exist or offer only trivial information (such as the directory you mention), the topic is deemed non-notable and thus unsuitable for Wikipedia"
|
Deletion of Worcestershire Record Office
|
WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
640 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Selden
|
User:Isotope23
|
20:14, 18 September 2006 (UTC)
|
comment
|
right now I'm leaning delete per as this is completely unverfied. If it were sourced though, I'd be willing to extend sports coverage to this guy. If Golf|walking around hitting a little ball is a sport, then cards are too
|
Deletion of Brian Selden
|
WP:V||WP:BIO
|
Wikipedia:Verifiability
| 2 |
641 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Lee Young
|
User:K
|
20:58, 12 August 2017 (UTC)
|
delete
|
"a directory listing on an unremarkable subject. Insufficient independent sourcing & does not meet . The ""Keep"" votes are from SPAs apparently affiliated with the subject"
|
Deletion of Joshua Lee Young
|
WP:ENT
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
642 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papa (song)
|
User:SBKSPP
|
05:52, 3 July 2021 (UTC)
|
merge
|
to Gideon's Daughter. Fails per nom
|
Deletion of Papa (song)
|
WP:NSONG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
643 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You're Gonna Go Far, Kid
|
User:Blackmetalbaz
|
17:26, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per and
|
Deletion of You're Gonna Go Far, Kid
|
WP:CRYSTAL||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
644 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Girls (band)
|
User:Doc
|
18:05, 1 October 2009 (UTC)
|
comment
|
"It should be noted that this group now meets criterion #2 (""Has had a charted single or album on any national music chart"") as their debut album ''Album'' has http://www.billboard.com/artist/girls/1071413#/artist/girls/chart-history/1071413 debuted at #136 on the Billboard 200 album chart in the United States"
|
Deletion of Girls (band)
|
WP:MUSIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
645 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tara C. Smith
|
User:Agricola44
|
13:54, 30 August 2010 (UTC)
|
delete
|
"Adding to the above observations that her publication record seems very typical of a junior prof (WoS citations 18, 4, 3, 1, ... h-index = 3), it would seem this is a pretty clear case of . Easy to hit lots of false-positives here for the much-more-cited researcher ""Tyler C Smith"", who may have been at the same institution at one time. Respectfully"
|
Deletion of Tara C. Smith
|
WP:CRYSTAL
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
646 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hubert Paul Chatelain
|
User:TimothyBlue
|
07:09, 25 January 2021 (UTC)
|
merge
|
"to USS Chatelain (DE-149) per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but the content will improve the target article, be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""'' // "
|
Deletion of Hubert Paul Chatelain
|
WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
647 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessie Castillo (2nd nomination)
|
User:Phil
|
11:01, 3 June 2011 (UTC)
|
keep
|
Passes criterion 2 as mayor of a municipality with a population of nearly half a million with plenty of press coverage as found by the news search linked above
|
Deletion of Jessie Castillo (2nd nomination)
|
WP:POLITICIAN
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
648 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ida Daussy
|
User:Gene93k
|
17:52, 10 May 2014 (UTC)
|
keep
|
With some further searching, I found enough RS coverage in English and French to satisfy . She's apparently famous in South Korea
|
Deletion of Ida Daussy
|
WP:BASIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
649 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Seinfeld minor characters
|
User:Presidentman
|
13:19, 7 January 2013 (UTC)
|
keep
|
Meets as that it is a valuable information source
|
Deletion of List of Seinfeld minor characters
|
WP:LISTPURP
|
Wikipedia:Manual of Style
| 89 |
650 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four-Pack Music Sky Broadcasting
|
User:JediLofty
|
16:25, 19 August 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Fails and a cursory Googling returned no results for the exact phrase. -- JediLofty
|
Deletion of Four-Pack Music Sky Broadcasting
|
WP:RS
|
Wikipedia:Reliable sources
| 31 |
651 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PagerDuty
|
User:power
|
19:20, 3 October 2017 (UTC)
|
comment
|
"I've used their product before, so no !vote. I'm not sure I'd consider https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/08/08/pagerduty_ceo_appointment_plans/ to be , and $40 million in funding is close to the point of presumed notability for ""tech startups"
|
Deletion of PagerDuty
|
WP:MILL
|
Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill
| 32 |
652 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Music is Live Andy Hui X Denise Ho Music is Live (Live Album)
|
User:CaliforniaAliBaba
|
00:05, 9 May 2007 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"per : ""the general consensus on notability of albums is that if the musician or ensemble that made them is considered notable, then their albums have sufficient notability to have individual articles on Wikipedia"". Also the opening paragraph is in English; the part that is not in English consists of the song titles"
|
Deletion of Music is Live Andy Hui X Denise Ho Music is Live (Live Album)
|
WP:MUSIC
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
653 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modular Combat (video game)
|
User:APerson241
|
19:51, 25 June 2013 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as it currently stands - reads like an advertisement and has no sources; fails
|
Deletion of Modular Combat (video game)
|
WP:NOTABILITY
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
654 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1/72 Scale Plastic Napoleonic Figures
|
User:Atyndall
|
04:13, 27 July 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
This list seems to be full of |original research and does not suggest why such 1:72 scale plastic toys are notable. Google turns up some results but none are reliable and google news turns up nothing. I think that this article fails |general notability criteria. —Atyndall [
|
Deletion of 1/72 Scale Plastic Napoleonic Figures
|
WP:OR||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:No original research
| 12 |
655 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modulating stress responses by the UPRosome: A matter of life and death
|
User:JohnCD
|
11:19, 22 November 2012 (UTC)
|
comment
|
it shares a title with http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21482118 this paper and may be copied from it. I have asked the (new) author whether it is, and also asked for comment from ikiProject Molecular and Cellular Biology
|
Deletion of Modulating stress responses by the UPRosome: A matter of life and death
|
WP:W
|
Help:Watchlist
| 57 |
656 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denis Rancourt
|
User:Espresso
|
00:13, 20 December 2008 (UTC)
|
keep
|
The news sources listed above appear sufficient, taken together, to satisfy . He also appears to be considered an expert on environmental issues, per: http://epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Minority.Blogs&ContentRecord_id=de6a54bf-802a-23ad-45ed-60ae6f3febe2 Additionally, I believe his physics work might well meet . A Google Scholar searchhttp://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?num=50&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&q=%22DG+Rancourt%22&btnG=Search finds one paper on which he is first author with 164 citations, & many others with respectable citations. His physics research could do with being mentioned in the article
|
Deletion of Denis Rancourt
|
WP:BIO||WP:PROF
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
657 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cloudcade
|
User:Sergecross73
|
15:16, 28 October 2014 (UTC)
|
comment
|
The fact that this had to be re-listed at AFD is probably a sign that it's not quite as clear-cut as you think, and wouldn't have been a good speedy deletion candidate. Even now, we've only got the input of a handful of editors. This is usually the type of article that I totally rewrite and re-source to show that there's clearly enough coverage and content here to meet the . I'm just not that motivated to do that since I'm not all that big on mobile gaming, and don't especially feel inclined to help out a company that clearly went out of their way to use Wikipedia as a means of personal |promotion
|
Deletion of Cloudcade
|
WP:GNG||WP:PROMOTION
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
658 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skye Rider
|
User:CommanderWaterford
|
18:30, 10 February 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Lacks more than clearly , even
|
Deletion of Skye Rider
|
WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
659 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZigZag (2015 video game)
|
[[user talk:czar|czar]]
|
17:36, 1 August 2015 (UTC)
|
merge
|
to Ketchapp and speedy close. {{ping|Anarchyte|p=}}, why didn't you just redirect to the developer's page |before coming to AfD? – 
|
Deletion of ZigZag (2015 video game)
|
WP:BEFORE
|
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion
| 67 |
660 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladimir Mikhaylovich Petrov (TRIZ Master)
|
User:Walton_monarchist89
|
20:26, 4 March 2007 (UTC)
|
delete
|
unsourced, hence no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to establish notability per . Delete unless sources can be added
|
Deletion of Vladimir Mikhaylovich Petrov (TRIZ Master)
|
WP:BIO
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
661 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kjetil Lundebakken
|
User:Spiderone
|
13:33, 2 March 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
I could not find any significant coverage of Lundebakken, meaning that a fail is likely
|
Deletion of Kjetil Lundebakken
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
662 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OpenLiteSpeed
|
User:timtempleton
|
22:03, 12 September 2017 (UTC)
|
delete
|
I did a Google search and can only find how to articles about configuring the tool - but no significant coverage on the tool itself, or why it's notable. Fails
|
Deletion of OpenLiteSpeed
|
WP:RS
|
Wikipedia:Reliable sources
| 31 |
663 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dog poop girl (4th nomination)
|
User:Colonel
|
12:34, 4 March 2009 (UTC)
|
keep
|
The nomination obviously fails as there are obvious places one might merge this rather than delete it such as Internet vigilantism and the attempt to PROD the article shows a lack of attention to the numerous previous discussions
|
Deletion of Dog poop girl (4th nomination)
|
WP:BEFORE
|
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion
| 67 |
664 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Communitychannel
|
User:Bearian
|
20:15, 11 March 2009 (UTC)
|
keep
|
per Reyesking1. While ''most'' such YouTube bloggers are not notable, she appears to be so, and meets and . I would integrate the refs into the text, and move to the person's name
|
Deletion of Communitychannel
|
WP:N||WP:WEB
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
665 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional beauty queens
|
User:Ajf773
|
05:20, 21 February 2017 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as
|
Deletion of List of fictional beauty queens
|
WP:LISTCRUFT
|
Wikipedia:Listcruft
| 66 |
666 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Namibia African People's Democratic Organisation
|
User:Happyme22
|
03:22, 26 June 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per and . How/why is this organization notable? No reliable sources to verify the information either
|
Deletion of Namibia African People's Democratic Organisation
|
WP:N||WP:V
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
667 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Charles & Tati Controversy
|
User:Grapefruit17
|
15:12, 12 May 2019 (UTC)
|
comment
|
I would agree that this violates per above. PewDiePie vs T-Series and other such articles may also have trouble passing but they're not taking all of the other baggage that this entry has i.e failing , , and
|
Deletion of James Charles & Tati Controversy
|
WP:10YT||WP:10YT||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NEUTRAL||WP:N||WP:GOSSIP
|
Wikipedia:Recentism
| 38 |
668 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brittany Teei
|
User:Marc
|
20:52, 4 June 2011 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"per #Generally acceptable standards #1 based on her qualification for and participating in Cook Islands at the 2010 Commonwealth Games. does not discount someone for representing a small country. Given the number and size of the participating countries for Tennis at the 2010 Commonwealth Games#Participating nations this easily qualifies as a ""major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level"
|
Deletion of Brittany Teei
|
WP:NSPORT||WP:NSPORT
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
669 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memorial Mario Cecchi Gori
|
User:Spiderone
|
18:49, 28 April 2021 (UTC)
|
keep
|
the sources on the Italian Wikipedia look fairly good and SF's sources show some decent coverage. If it's covered in this detail in major publications in more than one country, it's enough for . There's a lack of English-language coverage but that's no reason to delete. If anything, one of the strengths of Wikipedia is accurately covering topics that are not well covered in the English media
|
Deletion of Memorial Mario Cecchi Gori
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
670 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladan Slijepčević
|
User:Synchronism
|
08:42, 4 June 2009 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per #A2 as there is no hope for translation in the foreseeable future. I ed it to the Serbian Wikipediahttp://sr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transwiki:Владан_Слијепчевић (hopefully I got it right), as Jac16888 suggested at . There already is an article on Vladan therehttp://sr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Владан_Слијепчевић, but it is a stub, perhaps they will find this more useful
|
Deletion of Vladan Slijepčević
|
WP:CSD||WP:PNT||WP:transwiki
|
Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion
| 76 |
671 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PureVPN (2nd nomination)
|
User:Jovanmilic97
|
14:26, 8 July 2019 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"Reviewed by tech magazines which is their job afterall"" is a very claim here. The fact the product was covered in such means it was notable enough to be noticed by those. Such as TechRadar https://www.techradar.com/reviews/pc-mac/software/utilities/purevpn-1325640/review, PC World https://www.pcworld.com/article/3219730/purevpn-vpn-review.html, Business.com https://www.business.com/reviews/purevpn/, Tom's Guide https://www.tomsguide.com/us/purevpn,review-4497.html, IGN https://www.ign.com/articles/2017/05/18/purevpn-review, PCMag https://www.pcmag.com/commentary/356727/did-purevpn-cross-the-line, Mashable https://mashable.com/review/pure-review-vpn/ (almost all of these bring cited in the article), and others I could possibly find if I looked more indepth. There is also coverage of it doing something for someone like on Forbes https://www.forbes.com/sites/joeescobedo/2017/09/18/how-purevpn-boosted-its-yoy-traffic-by-289-via-user-generated-content/#1bfd2e2b7a91 and International Business Times https://www.ibtimes.com/purevpn-provided-users-data-fbi-stalking-case-2599677. Passes clearly"
|
Deletion of PureVPN (2nd nomination)
|
WP:POINT||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point
| 28 |
672 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sachini Widanalage
|
User:Smartyllama
|
20:04, 16 December 2019 (UTC)
|
delete
|
There were only eight athletes in her Commonwealth Games competition, and in any case only applies to track and field athletes and should not be confused with the broader
|
Deletion of Sachini Widanalage
|
WP:NATH||WP:NSPORT
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
673 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nico Yennaris
|
User:Zanoni
|
23:26, 18 August 2010 (UTC)
|
delete
|
None of them passes either or
|
Deletion of Nico Yennaris
|
WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
674 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qiqqa
|
User:Avram
|
19:06, 11 August 2016 (UTC)
|
comment
|
Which reasons of -REASON? Not-notable? Advertising? Would like to see a concrete basis
|
Deletion of Qiqqa
|
WP:DEL
|
Wikipedia:Deletion policy
| 19 |
675 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of images in Gray's Anatomy: I. Embryology
|
User:MarcoTolo
|
22:14, 11 May 2007 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"As noted in , ""''Lists can be used as a table of contents, or if the user is browsing without a specific research goal in mind...''"". Unless I misunderstand how Commons works, this hierarchical browsing function would be lost"
|
Deletion of List of images in Gray's Anatomy: I. Embryology
|
WP:LISTS
|
Wikipedia:Lists
| 36 |
676 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hidden Valley High School (Grants Pass, Oregon)
|
User:TerriersFan
|
NONE
|
keep
|
"nominated for deletion 3 minutes after creation which is utterly unacceptable and against the spirit of fD which says ''Before nominating a recently created article ... Unless it is obviously a hopeless case, consider sharing your reservations with the article creator, mentioning your concerns on the article's discussion page, and/or adding a ""cleanup"" template, instead of bringing the article to AfD.''. This is a high school that is significant in its community and the article has the sources needed to meet "
|
Deletion of Hidden Valley High School (Grants Pass, Oregon)
|
WP:A||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Attribution
| 34 |
677 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Coryton
|
User:Smartse
|
16:47, 9 December 2016 (UTC)
|
merge
|
to Tampon Tax. Despite what the BBC report, there are insufficient sources providing substantial, in-depth coverage of ''her'' to meet . She is only notable in regards to the Tampon Tax, so mention her importance there
|
Deletion of Laura Coryton
|
WP:BIO
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
678 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Carnahan
|
User:Pharaoh
|
13:01, 9 May 2015 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Has not actually played in NFL and fails lacks significant coverage
|
Deletion of Andrew Carnahan
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
679 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandy Hampton
|
User:Hnsampat
|
20:29, 4 December 2010 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"As Mattbuck said, although the existence of articles for ''all'' of these characters is a little ridiculous, some of these articles have shown enough real-world notability to merit being kept. I will agree with Lucy-marie that most of these articles ''currently'' contain little more than in-universe plot summary, but that does not mean that they ''inherently'' lack notability or verifiability and so, like Shooterwalker, I question the wisdom of nominating them all for deletion en masse. Just because they are not good articles right now does not mean they don't have room for improvement. (Josiah Bartlet and Sam Seaborn come to mind as two articles that have undergone dramatic improvement in terms of including out-of-universe information over the past few years.) I also completely disagree with Lucy-marie's claim that the notability has been ""lost"" because the show stopped airing in 2006. |Notability is not temporary. I concur with Mattbuck's recommendation that we retain the articles for the Josiah Bartlet, Ziegler, Seaborn, Lyman, Cregg, McGarry, Santos, Moss, Young, and Bailey, and possibly also Abbey Bartlet, Vinick, Schott, Hampton, and Gardner (since they were all considered part of the main cast at one point or another, although they didn't appear in the main credits every single episode"
|
Deletion of Mandy Hampton
|
WP:NTEMP
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
680 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Mayweather Jones
|
User:Papaursa
|
17:33, 2 August 2014 (UTC)
|
delete
|
He doesn't meet or . His claim to notability is having a famous father, but notability is not inherited at WP
|
Deletion of Justin Mayweather Jones
|
WP:NBOX||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
681 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Reyes
|
User:Ukexpat
|
16:52, 20 June 2012 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fails
|
Deletion of Sean Reyes
|
WP:POLITICIAN
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
682 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew John Caldwell
|
User:Richard3120
|
15:43, 15 July 2019 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fails and . Likely autobiography (as you would expect from a PR guy), and leaving aside the fact that the majority of the sources fail WP:RS, the twelve sources currently in the article are four articles written by Mr. Caldwell himself, four sources talking about how he has authored a chapter about publicity in a non-notable book, an interview with him (primary source) on a website which charges to market your music, one radio show on which his song was played (probably not on rotation, but it's impossible to verify), and two articles about how he organised a street party in his home town. No in-depth reliable sources that demonstrate notability
|
Deletion of Matthew John Caldwell
|
WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
683 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shivani Rajasekhar
|
User:Atlantic306
|
19:32, 15 June 2019 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as with only one upcoming film as a major credit and the coverage so far seems otability is not inherited|inherited from the father at this stage, thanks
|
Deletion of Shivani Rajasekhar
|
WP:TOOSOON||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Too soon
| 1 |
684 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaius Chibueze
|
User:Timtempleton
|
02:08, 1 February 2020 (UTC)
|
delete
|
a Google search uncovers almost nothing about his background. Fails
|
Deletion of Gaius Chibueze
|
WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
685 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wineries in Quebec
|
User:Amatulic
|
14:59, 12 August 2014 (UTC)
|
delete
|
I am not convinced by SweetNightmares' argument. There might be an argument for creating a list article that mirrors the category of Candadian wineries, provided it provides useful information beyond a mere a regurgitation of the category contents. But that isn't what we're discussing. Rather, we should be discussing how this particular article complies with and . There is no purpose in listing non-notable companies, other than to attract spamlinks
|
Deletion of List of wineries in Quebec
|
WP:OTHERSTUFF||WP:NOTDIR||WP:INDISCRIMINATE
|
Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions
| 20 |
686 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whispy Woods
|
User:Balladofwindfishes
|
19:15, 28 October 2007 (UTC)
|
keep
|
Easily one of the most recignized villains of Kirby. Makes cameos in other series, and is outright a staple of the series. Unlike Kracko, Whispy actually has a relevant and important role in his games, and also in the anime. The fact you mentioned that ridley doesn't have an article, see
|
Deletion of Whispy Woods
|
WP:OTHERSTUFF
|
Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions
| 20 |
687 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SchilliX (2nd nomination)
|
user:intgr
|
12:04, 17 January 2017 (UTC)
|
comment
|
"It's obsolete"" is not a valid reason for deletion. Historical articles are not only accepted, but encouraged on Wikipedia; |notability is not temporary. Build your deletion nominations on the |notability guideline instead"
|
Deletion of SchilliX (2nd nomination)
|
WP:NTEMP||WP:N
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
688 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley Holt
|
User:Barkeep49
|
19:59, 1 May 2018 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as non-notable who failes Best
|
Deletion of Bradley Holt
|
WP:NBASEBALL
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
689 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Datasheet Archive
|
User:HighKing
|
13:14, 17 September 2018 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Agree with all of the above, borderline A7. Utterly fails GNG and
|
Deletion of Datasheet Archive
|
WP:NCORP
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
690 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luca Lazar
|
User:David
|
23:29, 21 May 2014 (UTC)
|
keep
|
"As well as the National Museum exhibit mentioned above, he has been shown at the Cobra Museum in the Netherlands in ""the first major survey show of Georgian contemporary art to take place outside the country's borders"" http://www.undo.net/it/mostra/81644. I think this meets the ""substantial part of a significant exhibition"" clause of "
|
Deletion of Luca Lazar
|
WP:CREATIVE
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
691 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Furtling
|
User:Ilmari
|
19:57, 7 May 2006 (UTC)
|
keep
|
I'm the one who wikified the stub after it was added last year, and the one who remove the |prod tag added by Brian. That said, I have no particular objection to having it nominated on AfD and, should the consensus be such, deleted. I do maintain that this seems to be an encyclopedic subject — as in, covered, however briefly, by at least one print encyclopedia — and that it ''could'' be expanded. I haven't personally seen either of the books cited (save for the online version), and have no idea where I might be able to find them if I were to go looking for them. Nonetheless, someone could do that, and presumably someone might be able to locate other references to the subject. In the mean time, the article in its present form is doing no harm to Wikipedia. Deleting it, though insignificant in the grand scheme if things, would nonetheless be a net loss for the encyclopedia
|
Deletion of Furtling
|
WP:PROD
|
Wikipedia:Proposed deletion
| 92 |
692 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Lynch (American football)
|
User:Shadowjams
|
14:08, 31 January 2014 (UTC)
|
delete
|
Basic failure of . Obvious delete. Absent substantial coverage, college athletes aren't notable. In contrast, see Tim Tebow's page, which existed prior to his NFL career. Canadalovesnd's exaggerated concern is nothing to worry about. We have notability guidelines for a reason
|
Deletion of Aaron Lynch (American football)
|
WP:NSPORTS
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
693 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Lim
|
User:PRehse
|
17:20, 20 June 2016 (UTC)
|
comment
|
As it stands the subject does not meet either or . I also don't think he meets but perhaps there is more out there. I'll hold off voting for a bit - the AfD was started a bit too quick
|
Deletion of Terry Lim
|
WP:NACTOR||WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
694 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deby Medrez Pier
|
User:Ashleyyoursmile
|
12:02, 21 April 2021 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fails , , and . Google search turned up no reliable independent sources that discuss the subject in depth. Sources used in the article do not fully support statements mentioned in the article, http://nyc.thedelimagazine.com/22520/brooklyn-singersongwriter-deby-medrez-pier-plays-mercury-lounge-tonight-91 this source used in the article is a blog while http://www.debymedrezpier.com/tour.html this is and http://www.mercuryeastpresents.com/mercurylounge this lists tour dates
|
Deletion of Deby Medrez Pier
|
WP:MUSICBIO||WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG||WP:SELFPUB
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
695 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Impact of Slavery on Modern African American Lives
|
User:onel5969
|
15:34, 9 December 2017 (UTC)
|
delete
|
as per . And excellent find regarding it being a school project by {{u|MShabazz
|
Deletion of Impact of Slavery on Modern African American Lives
|
WP:NOTESSAY
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
696 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campaigns of Pharaoh and Cleopatra
|
User:Sephiroth
|
00:51, 23 June 2008 (UTC)
|
delete
|
fails #INFO, , #GUIDE
|
Deletion of Campaigns of Pharaoh and Cleopatra
|
WP:NOT||WP:GAMECRUFT||WP:NOT
|
Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not
| 69 |
697 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daisy Ridley
|
User:Blaylockjam10
|
22:11, 30 April 2014 (UTC)
|
keep
|
She's going to be a lead actress in a major movie. I agree that the article falls under
|
Deletion of Daisy Ridley
|
WP:POTENTIAL
|
Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state
| 6 |
698 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tere Liye Bro
|
[[User talk:usernamekiran|(talk)]]
|
13:06, 23 February 2020 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per discussion above. states {{tq|Failure to meet these criteria is not conclusive proof that a topic should not be included; conversely, meeting one or more does not guarantee that a topic should be included.}} Only because this TV series was nationally braodcast, doesnt make it automatically notable. Coverage in one reliable source is not wp:sigcov|significant coverage. We also have to consider current persistent attempts of production companies from India to create wikipedia articles of their TV shows, and actors; during the publicity/marketing campaigns. As per , PR, paid news/reviews, coverage is bound to take place. At least 2-3 reviews (not capsule reviews), and/or significant coverage is required for establishing notability. —usernamekiran
|
Deletion of Tere Liye Bro
|
WP:TVSERIES||WP:COMMONSENSE||WP:ROUTINE
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
699 |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Phua
|
NONE
|
12:20, 10 April 2016 (UTC)
|
delete
|
per nom. Completely fails to assert . scope_creep
|
Deletion of Dennis Phua
|
WP:BIO
|
Wikipedia:Notability
| 71 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.