discourse_id
stringlengths
12
12
essay_id
stringlengths
12
12
discourse_text
stringlengths
4
4.1k
discourse_type
stringclasses
7 values
discourse_effectiveness
stringclasses
3 values
85bf674fd4ea
1B4E66B0BE0A
The goal is to promote alternative transportation and reduce smog.
Claim
Adequate
84022eb94922
1B4E66B0BE0A
"It's a good opportunity to take away stress and lower air pollution," said businessman Carlos Arturo Plaza.
Evidence
Adequate
82d6ae6b094d
1B4E66B0BE0A
there are advantages to limited car usage because of Car Culture
Claim
Ineffective
8308f9cac2a6
1B4E66B0BE0A
. President Obama's ambitious goals to curb the United States greenhouse gas emissions is to shift in American behavior. Research studies suggest that Americans are buying fewer cars, driving less and getting fewer licenses as each year goes by. The United States has long been one of the world's prime car cultures. The number of miles driven in the United States peaked in 2005. "What most intrigues me is that rates of car ownership per household and per person started to come down two to three years before the downturn," says Michael Sivak, a research professor at the University of Michigan's Transportation Research Institute. The internet makes telecommuting possible and allows people to feel more connected without driving to meet friends. With all these changes, people who stopped car commuting as a result of the recession may find less reason to resume the habit.
Evidence
Adequate
1d1a09789980
1B4E66B0BE0A
there are many different advantages to limiting car usage because of pollution, many different acts of transportation, and because of Car Culture.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
8875771f4aa7
1B976DF43007
In the Challenge of the Exploring Venus, the auther suggests that studying venus is a worthy pursuit despite the dangers I think he I right, but i think that the dangers are to much to risk.
Position
Ineffective
a8b55cb03e5c
1B976DF43007
In the story the auther calls venus the ''Evening Star'' and said that it was one of the brightest points in the the sky,but it also said ''while venus is simple to see from a good distance, but safe vantage point from eath.''
Evidence
Ineffective
a9a90d0724e6
1B976DF43007
you can't get close to venus because it's too dangerus.
Claim
Adequate
c9d1549e884c
1B976DF43007
Some of the ways that venus is too dangerus to go to is because we know what will happy if we go.
Claim
Ineffective
8a8b66aaf35a
1B976DF43007
We sent things up befor and each previous mission was unmanned but for good reason, since not one spacecraft survied the landing for more then maybe a few hours. Thats when we saw the issue and stoped sending up sacescrafts. Not one spaceship has touched down on venus in more that three decades. A thick atmospehere of 97% carbon dioxide covers venus, also to add to that theres even more difficulit clouds of highly corrosive sulfric acid on venus. On the the planet the conditions arfe far more extreme then anything humans encoouter on earth or anywhere so far. The atmospheric pressure is 90 times greater than what we have on earth. besides high presurs and unbareable heats, the weather is bad too. Erupting volcanoes, powerful earthquackes, and very frequent lighting strikes.
Evidence
Ineffective
27c68d26970b
1B976DF43007
In the end, our travels on earth and farther should'nt be limitted but at the same time we are facesed with dangers and things we sould strive to do better in but we should do our best to look at the word without getting to close to danger.
Concluding Statement
Ineffective
084a3ca15ddc
1BB48664CC6A
The Leonardo da Vinci's painting was his bigges painting in thw world he made a 83 percent happy will 9 percent disgusted and 6 were percent fearful and only 2 were angry. The Mona Lisa demonstrantion bring a smile to your face when you see it whit your one eyes
Evidence
Adequate
920c5242576d
1BB48664CC6A
it show you how computer can do just imagine a computer that knows if you were happy all the time or if you were sad
Claim
Adequate
2fae8362c958
1BB48664CC6A
The painting Vinci did was only one of the thing he did he mad more thing in the pass but the whole world knowes him for this one pating he ,ad and everyone from king to people like me and you come and see it
Evidence
Ineffective
93aaee484295
1BB48664CC6A
Leonardo da Vinci will be the best man in the world for making this
Claim
Ineffective
c2bcc9771602
1BB48664CC6A
at his time the detels he put in to this and the paint he put in to was one of the best thing he could of done.
Evidence
Ineffective
2cd28db69a8b
1BC1E6EAB178
Studying Venus is worthy to pursuit the despite the dangers because the people is stuying the Venus.
Position
Adequate
6e1265ec4557
1BC1E6EAB178
They trying so hard but the Venus atmosphere is almost 97 precent carbon dioxide b;anket around the lant and the heat stays inside of the planet.
Evidence
Adequate
ae1f5c851ac2
1BC1E6EAB178
the Nasa people been making stuff but they say, "while Venus is simple to see from the distant but safe vantege point of Earth, it has proved a very challenging place to examine more closely".
Claim
Adequate
9b3f6e833011
1BC1E6EAB178
The Nasa said that "These condistions are far more extreme than anything humans encounter on Earth, but such and environment would crush even a submarine accustomed to diving to the deepest parts of our Oceans and wuld liquefy many matals". so they mean that if they go there i die soo easly bc of the heat and the imposible because the planet is 97 persent blacket around of the planet. But they trying to send something on the venus but it died it was one of the oldest michanical they mad e for space planets so they can take a photo.
Evidence
Ineffective
aec2ddaefaeb
1BD82BE8C639
In "The Challenge of exploring venses " the author suggests that studying venus is a wrothy prsuit despite the dangers it presents
Position
Adequate
f6eb74994e12
1BD82BE8C639
The author thinks studyinfg venus is a worthy pursuit because venus is the most earth like planent in our soloar system.
Claim
Adequate
90b3ca9cc703
1BD82BE8C639
venus is the closest planet to earth in term of denstiy and size, and occasionaily the closest in distace too." the author belives one day that people cuold go there and vist and study on venouse more or maybey even live there, " imagine a blimp like vehicle hovering 30 or so miles above the roiling venusian landscape. just as our jet airplanes travel at a higher ataltitude to fly over many stroms,a vehicle hovery over hovering over venus wuold avoid the unfriendly ground conditions by staying up and out their way
Evidence
Adequate
350de1f1d632
1BD82BE8C639
But studying vesue is pretty challageing and dangeus
Claim
Adequate
24403676c7b1
1BD82BE8C639
being able to study tha planent you have to be on it and that diffcult because " a thick atmousephere of almost 97% carbon dixide blankets venus. even more challenging are the clouds of hihly corrosive sulfuric acid in venuis atmoahere." and "since no spacecraft suurvived the landing for more then a few hours. maybe this issue explans why not a single spaceship has tuoched down on venus in more than 3 decates."
Evidence
Adequate
56c76b2e1fcf
1BD82BE8C639
" noumerous facters contrirbute to venus's repuaton as a challenging planet for humans to study on."
Concluding Statement
Ineffective
77f2549b4f58
1BE3C3E7DE6C
Do you want to be a Seagoing Cowboy? You should
Position
Adequate
f61cbdf15572
1BE3C3E7DE6C
there are lots of cool places to see.
Claim
Effective
f06153761251
1BE3C3E7DE6C
Also you can have a fun time on board.
Claim
Effective
fe6c1a296818
1BE3C3E7DE6C
Third you get to help others in need.
Claim
Effective
127f0e60a2b9
1BE3C3E7DE6C
First you get to see a lot of unique places
Claim
Effective
95ccfd161545
1BE3C3E7DE6C
In the passage it states that Luke(or I) got to take a gondola ride in Venice, Italy. He also visited an excavated castle in Crete. I also marveled at the Panama Canal on my way to China. I loved it So I know you will. You should also go to help others that need help.
Evidence
Adequate
9944d8423717
1BE3C3E7DE6C
You will get to help others in need if you become a Seagoing Cowboy.
Claim
Effective
fc9d64b273f9
1BE3C3E7DE6C
First, in the passage it states that I had to feed and water the animals atleast two or three times a day. Second, if you are eighteen you could get drafted. That's another way to help. In the passage it stated that I could get drafted, so they told him to stay there and keep working with the Seagoing Cowboys. Third you also get to help work with the Seagpoing Cow boys. If you are a good worker and kind this would be a great job. If you like the Seagoing Cowboys you will like the fun.
Evidence
Effective
f6d3c39769a1
1BE3C3E7DE6C
In the passage it states that I had fun on board.
Claim
Effective
1940212fb5bf
1BE3C3E7DE6C
One reason is they would play volley ball, baseball,and table tennis. Also, the Seagoing Cowboys did fencing and boxing. Except if you are layed back and calm you can read! You have a lot of fun things you can do on board.
Evidence
Adequate
a6535c8ea5d4
1BE3C3E7DE6C
In conclusion, you get help. You get to have fun. Last but not least you ge to see a lot of amazing places! So, to sum it all up... you will have a blast if you become a Seagoing Cowboy.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
dcf57fb88091
1BE638E9C951
I agree, all students should do Extracurricular Activity in school and outside of school
Position
Adequate
6b35ad4a6165
1BE638E9C951
I feel like it will help them out with a lot of stuff like stress and can help them find out who they really are
Evidence
Adequate
9d784387180a
1BE638E9C951
It can give them time to be with friends and can also give them the chance to met new people.
Claim
Adequate
eb404b315ef5
1BE638E9C951
it can bring the teachers and students closer to each other. This would give them the chance to get to know each other and try new things out.
Claim
Effective
69593bd3ae41
1BE638E9C951
This program can also help kids not be on their phones as much. it would help kids come all together and work as a team. I feel like now in days kids dont really care about there Schools Extracurricular Activity's. I feel like a lot of kids\teens depend on this phones for answers, ideas, and etc. these ideas will show them that there are better stuff then just being on your Phone, iPad, and Computer.
Evidence
Adequate
2dd0c99ccf6b
1BE638E9C951
Student's most of the time dont like school so these Activity's can show them that school can be fun. These activity's will give kids a chance to see the bright side of school and also the true meaning. It will also teach kids that trying new things out with new people can be fun. These programs can really make a kids or teens life a huge impact.
Evidence
Ineffective
1bc2fffeb2e2
1BE638E9C951
Extracurricular Activity's can show kids how to be more outgoing and bring the shy kids out of the shy zone.
Claim
Adequate
cfcfccea3554
1BE638E9C951
These Activity's can teach kids so many life lessons. It help kids and teens who think they are lazy turn into great students. These Activity's can inspire students to do better in school and lift there grades up. It can help kids/teens find out what they truly love and what they truly dislike.
Evidence
Ineffective
dab5f83f10d8
1BE638E9C951
I hope my words help out community's who are thinking about putting Extracurricular Activity's in there School system. I truly agree with these activity's and think it will help a lot with kids/teens. I hope one day all schools have fun activities for there students. I think can help many students come out into the real life and show them the true meaning of life. I love this idea so much and wish the best of luck for community with these activities.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
a27ac1eed5fd
1C3440A3FFD6
I disagree, I feel that the Mona Lisa wasnt really expressing 83 percent happy, 9 percent disgusted, 6 percent fearful, and 2 percent angry,
Position
Ineffective
b46f2f4602d6
1C3440A3FFD6
she looked like she was just posing for a picture or to be drawn, you cannot just look at somebody and tell what kind of emotions their expiriencing even if you do studies, it could just be thats how she is as a person all the time. The author uses facial feedback theory of emotion, saying not only does moving your facial muscles just express emotions , it may also even help produce them. They say that faces dont lie but anyone can fake emotions she was just taking a photo or was posing to be drawn they could have just made a conclusion stating she was 100 percent happy, I mean she was being drawn which means she must have been one of the best looking women around or something was good about her and only her, and her face drawing is now one of the most known pieces of art ever created. In the drawing it looks like shes outside so it could be the lighting or something around her that is causing her face to look like that. Its also hard to tell what kind of emotions shes having because she doesnt have eyebrows, the reason I say that is because most people raise or lower their eyebrows when they are trying to make their emotions noticable, so the main thing people can see about her emotions are her lips they look happy but its like a half smile, but the writer claims she is 83 percent happy, it seems much less than that. Her eyes look like she is staring at someone, not dissapointed.
Evidence
Ineffective
192b13bb266a
1C41622B0A7A
The author supports the idea that studying venus is a worthy pursuit despite the dangers it presents realy good
Position
Adequate
f17302923aa7
1C41622B0A7A
He gives facts and good reasons why people should study and visit venus
Evidence
Adequate
8ac00bda9621
1C41622B0A7A
In the first 3 paragraphs he gives interesting facts about venus. He says things that we dont have to know but is nice to know.
Claim
Adequate
404eeecca7c7
1C41622B0A7A
like in paragraph 2 he says venus is referred as the earth twin and is the closest planet to earth in term of density and size.
Evidence
Adequate
39f847633ebb
1C41622B0A7A
In paragraphs 4-6 he starts to explain why people should study venus and explain how venus is worthy to pursuit.
Claim
Adequate
1a9e6885bb0f
1C41622B0A7A
In paragraph 4 he says that "astronomers are fascinated by venus because it may well once have been the most Earth like planet in our solar sytem." Thats him explaining why venus is worthy of studing and has earth like features.
Evidence
Ineffective
d31bd18fcab0
1C41622B0A7A
In paragraph 5 he beins to talk about NASA and them sending humans to study venus.
Claim
Ineffective
56ae9d781f7b
1C41622B0A7A
The author says that "NASA's possible solution to the hostile condition on the surface of venus would allow scientist to float above the fray." He is now explaining how they can make it suitable for people to go study venus.
Evidence
Ineffective
0f01a154764a
1C41622B0A7A
The author wraps up the story talking about human curiosity and earth should not be limited by dangers and doubts. The author supports the idea that studing venus is a worthy pursuit despite the dangers it presents really good he gave facts and backed up his idea about studying venus.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
a1d2f0d4d923
1C592378CBD1
After going to school for ten months, students need a bit of a break before starting up again. Not only are their bodies tired, but so are their minds. Their minds are basically at capacity! So when summer break rolls around, students tend to leave everything they learned behind. While understandable to want to stop putting more information in their brain, students should never leave what they know behind. Students work so hard for a long time, to gain new information and more knowledge. In order to assure continued learning, teachers assign summer projects. Unfortunately, students decide to not do the assigned summer projects because it tends to get in the way of their summer. So, what if the switch was flipped and students could create their own summer projects?
Lead
Effective
faa2ac2d2870
1C592378CBD1
Students should have the freedom to complete their own summer assignments
Position
Adequate
7339a8ea9a58
1C592378CBD1
they're more likely to do the project when it's their own
Claim
Effective
5abb421074bf
1C592378CBD1
students can express their own creativity,
Claim
Effective
9d40d950d81c
1C592378CBD1
they will actually enjoy doing their project.
Claim
Effective
27a45d281b62
1C592378CBD1
If students could create their own assignments, they would actually do the work to get it done.
Claim
Effective
31c29494a619
1C592378CBD1
They have all summer to come up with a fun project idea, so why not make it the greatest one possible? Fast-forwarding to when school starts up again, students will have a completed project to present to their teachers and peers. They won't only be happy for the grade, but they'll be proud of themselves for completing their project.
Evidence
Adequate
d982d40e8fb6
1C592378CBD1
Adding to the positive, teachers will have a better impression of what their students do. Meaning that teachers will know how to operate their classes, based on their students and how they learn.
Claim
Effective
c14d8be070f4
1C592378CBD1
Students will also be able to express their creativity freely.
Claim
Effective
12f34e2d9879
1C592378CBD1
For example, one student may not be able to color, paint, or draw, while another student is really good at coloring, painting, and drawing. The student who isn't as good at doing those things, may be better at using computers to create things. So that student should be able to complete his/her summer assignment, on his/her terms. Some teachers assume that all students are capable of doing only one thing, which is very untrue and unrealistic. Students should not be limited to doing one thing, in one way. It's unfair that some teachers grade based on how artistic the assignment is, or how technological it is. Everyone has their own strengths and weaknesses. Teachers should look towards all their students specific strengths, instead of aiming at their weaknesses. Plus, teachers should be very fond of students' creativity in their assignments, and grade them based on the student's hard work, the assignment criteria, and their creativity.
Evidence
Effective
0cbdb43a4c9d
1C592378CBD1
Lastly, students will actually enjoy working on their summer projects!
Claim
Effective
e07bd486eb4b
1C592378CBD1
Since they have their own freedom to create whatever the please, they can make it any way they want. On top of that, they'll have the whole summer to make their very own masterpiece. So, when working on the assignment, it won't seem like such a drag to have to complete. Students can also work at their own pace. Since students do have a solid three months to complete and revise their projects, there should be nothing less than perfection.
Evidence
Adequate
29233d9c7cb9
1C592378CBD1
All in all, students should never stop learning new things. The new way of learning is expressed through creativity. Scott Fitzgerald once said, "For what it's worth... it's never too late, or too early, to be whoever you want to be. There's no limit ". Students should not be limited to creativity, creativity should be unlimited to students. Students should create their own summer assignments, to assure the continuation of learning, and to show them there will never be a limit to their own creativity. 
Concluding Statement
Adequate
4f7414d81fc9
1C8340F2AEE0
Have you ever wondered what other planets are like? Have you ever gotten the questioned yourself about these other planets like... Have scientists found other lifeforms? Have scientists found resorces on other planets like they have on Earth? well then if thats the case let me explain you why
Lead
Adequate
f69fb7ddde14
1C8340F2AEE0
"Venus is a worthy pursuit despite the dangers it presents."
Position
Adequate
0047ec8f5596
1C8340F2AEE0
There could possibily be other life forms on other planets and even Venus
Claim
Adequate
8b7ba7dfb688
1C8340F2AEE0
how there's life forms on Earth, typicaily Humans, Animals and even Bacteria like Algy and Fungi, In the article "The Challenge of Exploring Venus" In paragraph 4 it says "Venus could have supported various forms of life, just like Earth
Evidence
Ineffective
19b2f92a092e
1C8340F2AEE0
Another reason why Venus is worth studying is, like the Sun its the hottest thing in our solar system
Claim
Ineffective
c67c1af1ec6e
1C8340F2AEE0
what if Venus is not as hot as the Sun but what if Venus is hot for anything to be on there, in the article " The Challenge of Exploring Venus" In paragraph 3 it says "Venus tempreture average is over 800 degrees Fahrenheit."
Evidence
Adequate
6e38cc5ef13f
1C8340F2AEE0
what if it relates to Earth in many ways?
Claim
Ineffective
4e8db7f23218
1C8340F2AEE0
In the article in paragraph 4 it says "Long ago, Venus was probably covered largely with oceans"
Evidence
Ineffective
e67df760f1b4
1C8340F2AEE0
This is all the evidence on why Venus is worth discovering dispite the dangers while, Scientists may have discovered a bit of Venus and a bit of Mars unfortionatly for now some of those planets remain a mystery while some are on the very peak of changing from the unknown to the discoverable.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
92adc55a313b
1C9693E27251
That "Facial Action Coding System" is a Joke
Position
Adequate
193cdf5002c5
1C9693E27251
We all know that there are different emotions going are the school. The different types of emotions that are commonly at a school are happy, mad, sad, bored, or even nuetral.
Evidence
Adequate
99c55d9f708c
1C9693E27251
My question is, why do you care how the student is feeling?
Claim
Adequate
93ce4ec2f756
1C9693E27251
I know that the teacher himself or herself does not want to be here so, what makes them think that us students wants to be here.
Evidence
Adequate
62501e1891ec
1C9693E27251
A student comes in the school the teacher says, "Goodmorning!" The student just walks past without saying anything. Let me take a guess, the student is not feeling school, sleepy, or even that student might not like the teacher.
Evidence
Adequate
7158f412f737
1C9693E27251
We do not need a "Facial Action Coding System" pulled out to just find out the students feeling.
Claim
Adequate
cf3e96cc64e0
1C9693E27251
In paragraph eight, it states, "To an expert, faces don't lie; these muscle clues are sometimes used to spot when a "smiling" politician or celebrity isn't being truthful."
Evidence
Adequate
4c0ea044be09
1C9693E27251
A person lied, why can the investigator not do the job how it is suppose to be done taking everything step by step intead of getting a machine to do all of the job.
Claim
Adequate
9d6aecb114a6
1C9693E27251
By the way, how are you feeling now that I am stating my opinion? I hope you are feeling great because I know I am.
Concluding Statement
Ineffective
94d7b0867c54
1CE967B8E5C9
Lukes particapation to the Seagoing Cowboys progam allowed him to experience adventures.
Claim
Adequate
921d42973dfa
1CE967B8E5C9
The one thing it didn't mention in the artical was his family where were they the whole time Luke was on board. The artical never mentioned a mom or dad. Was Luke alone with no communication skills.
Evidence
Ineffective
c398565137e2
1CE967B8E5C9
I think you shouldn't join the Seagoing Cowboys
Position
Ineffective
607d11d29e81
1CE967B8E5C9
you wouldn't get to see your family for as long as your with the Cowboys.
Evidence
Adequate
3bda22becd52
1CE967B8E5C9
Yes, it's an adventure
Counterclaim
Adequate
7d4b387bb37c
1CE967B8E5C9
but you could get sea sick or worse home sick. If you get home sick you may not know what to do.
Rebuttal
Adequate
cc2990401c19
1CE967B8E5C9
You wouldn't want to go out in the sea, unboard animals then go back to main land.
Claim
Adequate
ad4d8e9bdc56
1CE967B8E5C9
No one wants to do that. To many people would get sick and not want to go back on board and that would just put more pressure on you to do more work. You won't know if you have a certain amount of time to do certain things on the boat, who knows.
Evidence
Adequate
1232c48fdcac
1CE967B8E5C9
Luke may have loved all the adventures and great times, but that's only one person's point of view of the whole idea.
Claim
Adequate
a4da96e5d693
1CE967B8E5C9
You would need more oppinions in order to see if it is a good service to work for. Everybody may say joining the Cowboys is an amazing idea but others may say it's a terrible idea. How much money does it cost to join the Cowboys, They never mentioned that either.
Evidence
Adequate
d09a38f0653a
1CE967B8E5C9
Luke's particapation the seagoing Cowboys was amazing in his mind but thats his mind not yours. Choose wisly on whether you want to join the seagoing Cowboys. It's your desicion not Luke's or anyone elses.
Concluding Statement
Adequate
6a229ba930b4
1CF149052D11
Some teachers feel that students should complete a summer project during their break to have them continue their studies even during the summer.
Lead
Adequate