topic
stringlengths
3
73
argument
stringlengths
24
222
label
stringclasses
2 values
Polygamy
Polygamy leaves some men with no women to marry; socially destabilizing
CON
Polygamy
Polygamy is traumatizing and depressing for wives
CON
Polygamy
Recognizing polygamy would cause a host of legal problems.
CON
Polygamy
Polygamy reduces the impulse to adultery and resulting divorces
PRO
Polygamy
Polygamous families are more dynamic and nurturing of diverse interests
PRO
Polygamy
Polygamy provides wives with a sisterhood of life-long friends
PRO
Tibet independence
The right to self-determination must be offered sparingly to avoid international instability.
CON
Withdrawing from Iraq
An early US exit might cause Iraqi troops to defect to the insurgency
CON
Withdrawing from Iraq
An early withdrawal from Iraq would embolden terrorists
CON
Withdrawing from Iraq
Prolonging the Iraq War will permanently damaged the US military
PRO
Withdrawing from Iraq
Torturous and brutal tactics in Iraq have only worsened US moral credibility.
PRO
Withdrawing from Iraq
Mending relations with countries that opposed the war would make it easier to fight the war on terror.
PRO
Kangaroo culling in Australia
Culling Kangaroo tarnishes the image of Australia around the world.
CON
Kangaroo culling in Australia
Kangaroo destruction of habitats is causing soil erosion that damages crops.
PRO
Kangaroo culling in Australia
Kangaroos are the cause of costly car accidents
PRO
Veal
Loose housing for calves often subjects them to bullying and apprehension.
CON
Veal
Calves are fed inhumane milk diets to keep them anemic and their meat pale
CON
Veal
Veal farming is a good alternative to the slaughtering of unwanted calves
PRO
DC handgun ban
A handgun ban deprives citizens of the most commonly used weapon for self defense
CON
DC handgun ban
Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
PRO
Muhammad cartoons controversy
The Jylands-Posten cartoons created an international impression of Denmark as Xenophobic.
CON
Muhammad cartoons controversy
Images of Muhammad are forbidden because they lead to idolatry.
CON
Muhammad cartoons controversy
Publishing images of Muhammad helps combat self-censorship.
PRO
Osama Bin Laden Sea Burial
Giving Bin Laden religious respects degrades Islam.
CON
Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 US elections
Allotting Florida and Michigan delegates according to national will promotes a tyranny of the majority.
CON
Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 US elections
Seating Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 gives a voice to voters there
PRO
Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 US elections
Splitting the delegates would give some voice to Michigan and Florida voters.
PRO
Dollarization
Dollarization limits monetary policy flexibility
CON
Dollarization
Dollarization undermines the sovereign symbolism of a national currency
CON
Dollarization
Dollarization helps encourage foreign investment
PRO
Dollarization
Dollarization can reduce the risk of inflation:
PRO
Ending US sanctions on Cuba
Changing legally etched Cuban human rights violations requires sanctions
CON
Ending US sanctions on Cuba
Lifting sanctions against Cuba will hardly benefit US businesses.
CON
Ending US sanctions on Cuba
Sanctions hurt Cuban-Americans with relatives in Cuba.
PRO
Ending US sanctions on Cuba
Sanctions against Cuba violated laws on the freedom of navigation.
PRO
Free trade
Free trade and markets harm the environment
CON
Free trade
Trade liberalization damages the growth of poor countries
CON
Free trade
The current regional FTAs undermine poor countries' bargaining power
CON
Free trade
Free trade sacrifices national unity to economics
CON
Free trade
Free trade and investment risks rapid capital flight from developing countries.
CON
Free trade
Free trade promotes peace and stability internationally
PRO
Free trade
Free markets and trade benefit the environment
PRO
Free trade
Free trade improves the economic growth of developing nations
PRO
Superdelegates
Superdelegates often vote out of self-interest for likely winner
CON
Superdelegates
Candidate solicitations of superdelegates damage the political process
CON
Superdelegates
Superdelegates provide greater mainstream party representation
PRO
Superdelegates
Superdelegates provide unifying margin of victory in tight race
PRO
Superdelegates
Superdelegates help increase the likelihood of a Democratic presidency
PRO
Legalization of Marijuana
Marijuana use can lead to cancer
CON
Legalization of Marijuana
Marijuana use impairs hormone production.
CON
Legalization of Marijuana
Some train and plane tragedies were connected with marijuana use.
CON
Legalization of Marijuana
Increased legal marijuana consumption will decrease economic productivity
CON
Legalization of Marijuana
If marijuana is harmful, isn't this sufficient punishment for users
PRO
Legalization of Marijuana
Children have been brainwashed on high costs of marijuana.
PRO
Legalization of Marijuana
Legalizing marijuana will reduce profits of traffickers and gangs
PRO
Prostitution
Individuals must cede some rights for safety, including right to prostitute.
CON
Prostitution
Legalizing prostitution won't substantially reduce HIV/AIDS risks
CON
Prostitution
By worsening HIV/AIDS, prostitution will devastate societies
CON
Prostitution
Legalization will increase prostitution and subsequently worsen public health.
CON
Abolition of nuclear weapons
Nuclear weapons may protect humans from threats from space.
CON
Abolition of nuclear weapons
Nuclear abolition could not prevent covert nuclear programs
CON
Abolition of nuclear weapons
Nuclear weapons tests are a global hazard
PRO
Abolition of nuclear weapons
Nuclear weapons are a drain on resources
PRO
Return of Israel to pre-1967 borders
Pre-1967 borders would be too insecure and dangerous
CON
Return of Israel to pre-1967 borders
Pre-1967 borders will not satisfy Islamic terrorists
CON
Return of Israel to pre-1967 borders
Arabs seek pre-1967 borders to weaken and dissolve Israel.
CON
Return of Israel to pre-1967 borders
Coordinated Arab attack unlikely; pre-1967 borders fine.
PRO
Return of Israel to pre-1967 borders
With pre-1967 borders, PLO would recognize Israel, end conflict
PRO
Three Gorges Dam
The hydroelectric TGD should not be considered renewable due to social, environmental costs.
CON
Three Gorges Dam
Floating garbage is piling up behind the TGD
CON
Three Gorges Dam
Three Gorges Dam damages water quality
CON
Three Gorges Dam
The Three Gorges Dam has submerged mines, resulting in pollution
CON
Three Gorges Dam
The Three Gorges Dam is a cause of corruption.
CON
Three Gorges Dam
The TGD helps limit the risk of floods in the region.
PRO
Three Gorges Dam
Three Gorges Dam gives China added respect in the world.
PRO
Three Gorges Dam
The TGD helps to alleviate drought.
PRO
Primaries in US elections
Superdelegates are not bound to represent the electorate
CON
Primaries in US elections
Early emphasis on Iowa and New Hampshire disenfranchises minority voters
CON
Primaries in US elections
Primaries help reveal candidates to the public
PRO
Hate crime laws
Hate crime laws violate religious free speech
CON
Hate crime laws
Hate crime laws are likely to be abused by accusers
CON
Hate crime laws
Hate crime laws tie the hands of judges
CON
Hate crime laws
Hate crime laws force false categorizations of minority groups
CON
Hate crime laws
Hate crime laws violate religious free speech
CON
Hate crime laws
Hate crimes terrorize communities and so deserve greater punishment
PRO
Hate crime laws
Hate crime enhancements will not overwhelm reporting systems
PRO
Assault weapons ban in the United States
The 1994 assault weapons ban did not decrease crime
CON
Assault weapons ban in the United States
Banning semi-automatic weapons would harm small businesses.
CON
Assault weapons ban in the United States
The 1994 US assault weapons ban significantly decreased use
PRO
Assault weapons ban in the United States
Assault weapons are used by drug cartels, kill thousands
PRO
Kosovo independence
An independent Kosovo would have to pay impossible debts to Serbia
CON
Kosovo independence
Many EU foreign ministers fear violence following Kosovo independence
CON
Kosovo independence
Kosovo independence would encourage other separatist movements
CON
Kosovo independence
Kosovo independence will not inspire other separatist movements
PRO
Ecotourism
Ecotourism can damage habitats
CON
Ecotourism
Ecotourism does not preserve but damages local cultures
CON
Ecotourism
Third world governments often seize local control to expand ecotourism
CON
Ecotourism
Ecotourism favors corporate interests over democratic processes
CON
Ecotourism
Ecotourism cultivates a conservation ethic
PRO
Ecotourism
Ecotourism generates funds for conservation
PRO